Metal Clusters in Chemistry
Edited by P. Braunstein L. A. Oro P. R. Raithby
Further Titles of Interest
A. Togni, R. L. Halterman (Eds.) Metallocenes Synthesis, Reactivity, Applications (2 Volumes) 1998.3-527-29539-9 Industrial Inorganic Products An Ullmann’s Encyclopedia (6 Volumes) 1998, 3-527-29567-4 M. Beller, C. Bolm (Eds.) Transition Metals for Organic Synthesis Building Blocks and Fine Chemicals (2 Volumes) 1998.3-527-29501-1 E. C. Constable Metals and Ligand Reactivity 1996, 3-527-29277-2
Metal Clusters in Chemistrv J
Edited by
P. Braunstein L. A. Oro P. R. Raithby
Weinheim New York Chichester Brisbane Singapore Toronto
Prof. Dr. P. Braunstein Lab. de Chimie de Coordination UniversitC Louis Pasteur 4, rue Blaise Pascal F-67070 Strasbourg CCdex
Prof. L. A. Oro Dept. of Inorganic Chemistry I. C. M. A. - Faculty of Science University of Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza
Dr. P. R. Raithby Dept. of Chemistry University of Cambridge Lensfield Road GB-Cambridge CB2 1EW
This book was carefully produced. Nevertheless, editors, authors and publisher do not warrant the information contained therein to be free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate.
Cover picture: Prof. Dr. A. Miiller, University of Bielefeld, Germany Library of Congress Card No.: applied for
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Deutsche Bibliothek Cataloguing-in-Publication Data: Metal clusters in chemistry / ed. by P. Braunstein ... - Weinheim ; New York ; Chichester ; Brisbane ; Singapore ; Toronto : Wiley-VCH 1999 ISBN 3-527-29549-6
0WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999 Printed on acid-free and chlorine-free paper. All rights reserved (including those of translation in other languages). No part of this book may be reproduced in any form - by photoprinting, microfilm, or any other means - nor transmitted or translated into machine language without written permission from the publishers. Registered names, trademarks, etc. used in this book, even when not specifically marked as such, are not to be considered unprotected by law. Composition: Asco Typesetters, Hong Kong. Printing: betz-druck gmbh, D6429 1 Darmstadt. Bookbinding: Wilhelm Osswald & Co., D-67433 Neustadt. Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany.
Preface
Metal clusters occupy a central role in chemistry. Aspects of cluster chemistry impinge on branches of the subject ranging from organometallic chemistry, through coordination chemistry, homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis to solid-state chemistry and catalysis. Research in metal clusters is an interdisciplinary enterprise that has exploded rapidly in importance over the past twenty years because metal clusters exhibit increasingly interesting bonding as well as electronic, structural and physical, and chemical and catalytic properties. Several reviews and books have appeared in the past emphasising the key role that metal clusters play in chemistry, materials science, nanotechnology and catalysis, but no up to date single source dealing with the recent developments in metal cluster chemistry is currently available. The purpose of this book is to provide a general source of references for workers including experimental and theoretical chemists and physicists in this interdisciplinary field, and covering both fundamental and applied science. It is, however. also directed at graduate students and scientists who have not previously been involved in research into metal clusters. The vast majority of the metal clusters considered in this book follow the definition offered by Cotton and others, namely, complexes containing three or more metal atoms held together, at least in part, by metal-metal bonds, although sometimes for the sake of convenience dinuclear complexes with metal-metal bonds are included. Thus, the existence of metalmetal bonds distinguishes cluster complexes from polynuclear cage complexes. This book originates from the Scientific Network of the European Science Foundation (ESF), which was initiated in 1992, with the aim of promoting the interactions between European laboratories working in the field, as well as stimulating multidisciplinary efforts and identifying frontier areas. Several workshops and Euroconferences associated with this Network were held during the period 19921998. The three volumes present a coordinated set of contributions written by leading European scientists who have been involved in the ESF Network activities. We are aware that research into metal clusters has also been very active in non-European countries. Therefore, in order to pay tribute to these contributions, leading scientists
vi
Preface
from outside Europe have been invited to add their personal views to the different sections covered by this book on Metal Clusters in Chemistry. The first volume of this book covers the topics of molecular metal clusters, the second volume contains sections on metal clusters in catalysis and dynamic and physical properties of metal clusters. Volume 3 covers the chemistry of nanomaterials and of solid-state clusters. It also contains an update of the reviews published on metal clusters in the last ten years, and finally presents a view on further developments in cluster chemistry leading into the next millennium. In general, the sections within the book contain a blend of experimental results together with an analysis of theoretical aspects of the work. In some instances, closely related areas have been discussed by several authors and here a complementary diversity of views is offered. The editors wish to thank the authors for their contributions to this book and the numerous scientists who have been involved in Network activities, they have all greatly assisted in the project by their vitality and enthusiasm for this developing area. We hope that this book will offer a source of ideas for future research developments. Cluster chemistry is still a young science that continues to grow rapidly. The diversity within the subject area is so large that it is now possible, with time and effort, to identify emerging patterns, such as structure-reactivity relationships, and to analyse them. Clearly, the apparent cooperative phenomena between two or more metal centres depend on the ability of the metal to “talk” to each other, either by direct metal-metal interactions or through ligand bridges. We firmly believe that the search for applications in quite different fields including the construction of metal clusters with desired electronic and catalytic properties will be of fundamental importance in the coming years. In this book it is our aim to show that metal cluster chemistry is an active, multidisciplinary and international research area with a rich past and a bright future, and to stimulate further interest in and enthusiasm for the subject .
May, 1999
P.B. L.A.O. P.R.R.
Contents
Preface ...............................................................
v
Volume I:
Molecular Metal Clusters
1
Molecular Clusters. ..................................................
1
General Introduction ................................................. F A . Cotton
3
1.1
Molecular Clusters - An Overview .................................. M. H. Chisholm
8
1.2
Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexametal Boride ... Clusters .............................................. C.E. Housecvoft Introduction .... ... ................................... Expansion. .......................... .................. Expansion beyond Mh during syntheses and ligand substitution reactions of Mg borides. ............................... Expansion from Mg cages using group 11 metal frag Degradation ........................................................ Rearrangements ............................... ................ Conversion of trigonal prismatic to octahedra Interconversion between cis- and trans-isomers of octahedral R u ~ M ~( M B = Ir or Rh) borides .......................
1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.2.1 1.2.2.2 1.2.3 1.2.4 1.2.4.1 1.2.4.2 1.3 1.3.1
10
10 12
18 20
Steric Effects in Metallacarboranes................................. 26 A.J. Welch Introduction ..................... .................. 26
viii
Contents
1.3.2 1.3.3 1.3.3.1 1.3.3.2 1.3.4
Minor consequences ................................................ Major consequences ................................................ Polyhedral deformation ............................................ Low-temperature isomerization .................................... Conclusions and outlook ...........................................
1.4
Heteronuclear Clusters Having Transition Metals and Metals of Group 1 4 . , ............................................... D .J . Cardin Introduction ........................................................ The coordination of diorganogroup-14 element compounds ...... Synthetic approaches ............................................... Compounds in which the group 14 ligand is bonded terminally to a cluster .......................................................... Compounds in which the group 14 ligand doubly bridges metals in a cluster without further reaction ........................ Clusters in which the Group 14 ligand or the heterometallic cluster has undergone further reaction .............................
1.4.1 1.4.2 1.4.3 1.4.4 1.4.5 1.4.6 1.5 1.5.1 1.5.2 1.5.3 1.6
1.6.1 1.6.2 1.6.2.1 1.6.2.2 1.6.3 1.6.4 1.7
1.7.1 1.7.2
Hetero-Metal Clusters by Assembling Amino Substituted Subvalent Main Group Metals and their Ligand Reactions ........ M . Veith Introduction ........................................................ Syntheses of clusters by using MezSi(NtBu)zM ( M = Ge( 11), Sn(I1))............................................................... Conclusion ..........................................................
32 34 34 39 44 48 48 49 50 51 54 65
73 73 74 89
Synthetic Pathways to a Neglected Class of Compounds: 91 Organobimetallics of Aluminium and cobalt ........................ J .J . Schneidev Introduction ........................................................ 91 Synthesis of mixed group 13/transition metal complexes .......... 92 Transition metal bonds to Ga, In and T1 .......................... 92 Transition metal (tm) bonds to B and A1 .......................... 95 Synthetic routes to organobimetallic compounds of Co and A1. . 100 Outlook and trends ................................................ 106 Group 5 and 6 Bimetallic Complexes with Phosphido Bridges: Syntheses and some Structural Features ........................... G. Boni, M . M . Kiibicki and C. Moibe Introduction ....................................................... Synthesis of metallophosphines ...................................
110 110 110
Contents
ix
1.7.3 1.7.3.1 1.7.3.2 1.7.4 1.7.5
Bimetallic complexes from metallophosphines. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Monobridged complexes .......................................... Dibridged complexes .............................................. Bimetallic complexes from metallodiphosphines ................. Molecular structures of phosphido bridged complexes . . . . . . . . . . .
1.8
Polythiometalates and Polyoxothiometalates Based on AcidoBasic Condensation Processes ..................................... 124 F. Skheresse, E. Cudot and C. Sinwnnrt-Jeyat Introduction .......................... .................. 124 Thiometalates and catalysis ........................ Academic research induced by catalysis ........... Sulfido-ligands ................ .......................... 127 Disulfido-ligands . . . . . . . . . . . Vanadium systems.. ...................................... The [MzS2X2I2+X-0, S fr CS2 activation ............. Reactions of thiometalates Selective sulfuration of fully oxygenated polyoxoanions ......... 136 Addition of a thiometallic fragment on a lacunary polyanion Self-condensation of the [Mo2S202I2' fragment. ................ 139
1.8.1 1.8.2 1.8.3 1.8.3.1 1.8.3.2 1.8.3.3 1.8.3.4 1.8.3.5 1.8.4 1.8.4.1 1.8.4.2 1.8.4.3
1.9 1.9.1 1.9.2 1.9.2.1 1.9.2.2 1.9.2.3 1.9.2.4 1.9.2.5 1.9.3 1.9.4 1.10 1.10.1 1.10.2
1 14
1 15 116 1 19 120
Electronic Effects on the Shape of M2X2 Frameworks ( X = Naked Chalcogenide Atom, M = Late Transition Metal). . 143 C. Mealli and A . Ovlirndini ...................... 143 Introduction .......................... .............................. ........ 146 n less electron rich M2X2 pl etons . . 146 Puckering of the MlX2 skeletons ............................. 150 Coupling/ uncoupling of dichalcogenide within puckered ...................... ........................ 152 Coupling of chalcogenide atoms in electron rich M2X2 ............................ planar frameworks. plexes of the type L2MX2 Uncharged and dic Conclusions ........................... .................. 160 ................................... Appendix Towards Transition Metal Clusters by Reaction of Simple Metal Carbonyls with Chalcogenides and Chalcogenolates G. Henkel and S. WriJgruber Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...................... Synthetic aspects.. .................................................
164
X
Contents
1.10.3 1.10.4 1.10.5 1.10.6 1.10.7 1.10.8 1.10.9
Topological aspects ................................................ Complexes containing up to two metal atoms .................... Complexes containing three metal atoms ......................... Complexes containing four metal ions ............................ Complexes containing five metal ions ............................. Complexes containing six metal ions .............................. Complexes of higher nuclearities ..................................
1.11
Low-Nuclearity Iron and Ruthenium Selenido-Carbonyl Clusters Derived from Phosphine and Diphosphine Selenides ..... 193 D . Cauzzi. C. Graifi G. Predievi and A. Tiripicchio Introduction ....................................................... 193 Clusters derived from Ph3PSe ..................................... 194 Ph3P-substituted selenido iron clusters ............................ 194 196 Ph3P-substituted selenido ruthenium clusters ..................... 197 Cluster derived from (Ph2PSe)2X ................................. (PhlP)2X-substituted selenido iron clusters ....................... 199 ( PhzP)2X-substituted selenido ruthenium clusters ................200 Structural features ................................................. 201 M3E2 nido clusters ................................................. 201 Ru~E closo ~ clusters ............................................... 202 Cluster growth reactions ........................................... 204 207 Concluding remarks ...............................................
1.11.1 1.11.2 1.11.2.1 1.11.2.2 1.11.3 1.11.3.1 1.11.3.2 1.11.4 1.11.4.1 1.1 1.4.2 1.11.5 1.11.6 1.12
1.12.1 1.12.2 1.12.3 1.13
1.13.1 1.13.2 1.13.3 1.13.4 1.13.5
A New Supporting Ligand for p 0 x o Metal Derivatives: N.N.dialky1carbamato. 02CNR2 .................................. D . Belli Dell’ Amico. F. Culderazzo. F. Mavchetti and G. Pampaloni Hydrolytic processes ............................................... Non-hydrolytic processes .......................................... Conclusions ........................................................
Alkyne Scission on Metal Cluster Frameworks.................... M.J. Morris Introduction ....................................................... Molybdenum-ruthenium clusters .................................. Molybdenum-cobalt clusters ...................................... Alkyne scission in dinuclear metallacyclopentadiene complexes .......................................................... Conclusions ........................................................
165 167 170 177 180 181 187
209 210 215 218 221 221 225 227 229 233
Contents 1.14
1.14.1 1.14.2 1.14.3 1.14.4 1.14.4.1 I . 14.4.2 1.14.4.3 1.14.4.4 1.14.4.5 1.14.5 1.14.5.1 1.14.5.2 1.14.5.3 1.14.5.4 1.14.5.5 1.14.6 1.15
1.15.1 1.15.2 1.15.3 1.15.4 1.15.5
1.16 1.16.1 1.16.2 1.16.3 1.16.4 1.16.5
xi
Multiple Interactions Between Arenes and Metal Atoms. ......... 236 A .J. Deeming Introduction ....................................................... 236 Arenes bridging two metal atoms employing only n interactions .237 Arenes brid n interactions ...................................................... 239 Aryls in metal clusters.. . . . . Terminal aryls in metal clus Bridging aryls without n-co Bridging aryls with n-coordination through a single carbon ............................................................ 246 aryls with n-coordination through two carbon atoms.. 247 Bridging aryls with n-coordination through a11 six carbon atoms. .............................................................. 248 Arynes in metal clusters ........................................... 250 Terminal q'-arynes ................................. 252 Arynes bridging tw Arynes bridging three metal atoms ............................... 254 255 Arynes bridging four metal atoms ................................ ................261 Arynes bridging five metal atoms Some recent developments with nap From C-H-Activation to Arene Clusters and Back Organometallic Cluster Chemistry with Cyclopentadienyl ....... .... 269 Cobalt Fragments and Olefins ... H. Wudepohl and A . Metz Introduction ....................................................... 269 Ethylene: cluster complexes with pu,-ethylidyneligands .......... 271 Substituted styrenes: cluster complexes with face-capping arene ligands.. ..................................................... 278 Cycloalkenes: cluster complexes with bridging cycloalkyne ................................... 285 ligands ........ 287 Conch Cyclopentadienylnickel Clusters ................................... S. Pasynkiewicz and A . Pietrzykowski Introduction ....................................................... (Cyclopentadieny1)trinickel clusters ............................... (Cyclopentadieny1)tetranickel clusters. ............................ (Cyclopentadieny1)pentanickelclusters. ........................... (Cyclopentadienyl)hexanickel clusters. ............................
290 290 290 302 305 306
xii 1.17
1.17.1 1.17.2 1.17.3 1.17.4 1.17.5
1.18 1.18.1 1.18.1.1 1.18.1.2 1.18.2 1.18.2.1 1.18.2.2 1.18.2.3 1.18.2.4 1.18.3 1.18.4 1.19
1.19.1 1.19.2 1.19.3 1.19.4 1.19.5 1.19.5.1 1.19.5.2 1.19.5.3 1.19.5.4 1.19.5.5 1.19.6
Contents
Ligand Orientation Effects on Metal-Metal Bonding ............. 308 S . Alvarez and G. Aulldn Introduction ....................................................... 308 Pyramidality and metal-metal bond strength in binuclear complexes ............................................... 309 Ligand orientation effects in unsupported [Fe2(CO)8]*- and derivatives .......................................................... 311 Ligand orientation effects in bridged Fe-Fe bonds, including 314 triangular Fe2M clusters .......................................... Clusters with a Fe4C skeleton ..................................... 318 Synthesis and Properties of Metal Carbonyl Clusters Containing Nitrido Ligands ........................................ A. Furnagalli and R.D . Pergola Introduction ....................................................... Generalities on interstitial nitrido clusters ........................ Synthesis of the nitrido ligand in clusters ......................... Synthesis of nitrido clusters ....................................... Iron clusters ........................................................ Ruthenium clusters ................................................ Cobalt and rhodium clusters; some clues to the pyrolytic cluster growing mechanism ........................................ Mixed-metal clusters ............................................ Structural features .............................................. Spectroscopic data associated with the interstitial nitrides ....
323 323 323 324 327 327 328 329 335 338 342
High Nuclearity Osmium . Gold Clusters ...................... 348 J. Lewis and P.R. Raithby Introduction .................................................... ... 348 Electron counting schemes and the rationalization of cluster geometries ....................................................... 349 Synthetic routes to higher nuclearity clusters .................. 352 Characterization of the new clusters ........................... 353 Reactions of high nuclearity osmium cluster carbonyl anions towards monodentate and bidentate gold phosphine cations . 355 Additions to hexanuclear osmium cluster anions .............. 355 Additions to heptanuclear osmium cluster anions ................359 Additions to octanuclear osmium cluster anions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 362 Additions to nonanuclear cluster anions .......................... 364 365 Additions to decanuclear cluster anions .......................... Synthesis of poly-aurated high nuclearity osmium carbonyl cluster .............................................................. 368
Contents
...
Xlll
1.19.6.1 1.19.6.2 1.19.6.3 1.19.6.4 1.19.6.5 1.19.7
Hexaosmium cluster systems ...................................... Heptaosmium cluster systems ..................................... Octaosmium cluster systems. ...................................... Nonaosmium cluster systems.. .................................... Decaosmium cluster systems ...................................... Conclusion.. .......................................................
1.20
Novel Imido Rhodium Clusters: Synthesis and Perspectives. . . . . . . 38 1 L,A . Oro, M. A . Ciriuno, C. Tejel, Y.-M.Shi and J . Modrego Introduction .................. .............................. 381 The challenge of synthesizing m imido complexes.. ....... 382 A synthetic strategy for rhodium triangular cores ................ 382 Butterfly rhodium imido clusters ...................... A “Rh3( p-N-p-tolyl)z” core with tuneable donicity . . Exploiting the ambivalent donor character of the “Rhi( p-N-p-tolyl)z” core: heterometallic clusters ................ 389 Trinuclear anionic rhodium imido clusters . . The bonding in imido-rhodium clusters.. .... Fluxional behavior .......... .................................. 395 Conclusions and outlook ............ ...................... 396
1.20.1 1.20.2 1.20.3 1.20.4 .20.5 .20.6 .20.7 .20.8 .20.9 1.20.10
1.21.1 1.21.2 1.21.2.1 1.21.2.2 I .21.2.3 1.21.2.4 1.21.3 1.21.5 1.21.5.1 1.21.5.2 1.21S . 3 1.21S.4 1.22
1.22.1
368 370 370 372 373 377
Synthesis and Reactivity of Tripalladium Clusters ................ 399 D.Kovalu-Demertzi Introduction ......................... .......................... 399 ................. ................ 400
Synthesis of neutral mixed-v Synthesis of tripalladium Pd(0)clusters. ........................... 403 Synthesis of tripalladium clusters in the formal oxidation state of Pd( 11) ........................ ....................... Bonding and structure in tripalladium clusters ............ ................. ..................... 406 ............ 407 eactions ................. Oxidative addition reactions and electron-transfer reactions.. . . . 410 Ligand addition reactions . . . . . . Host-guest chemistry ........... ..................... 412 Platinate (11) Complexes as Building Blocks for Complexes with Pt +M (Donor- Acceptor) bonds. ............................ J. Forniis and A . Martin Introduction .......................................................
4 17 4 17
xiv
Contents
1.22.2 1.22.3 1.22.4 1.22.5 1.22.6 1.22.7
Ag complexes .................................. 418 Synthesis of Pt Attempts to prepare Pd + Ag complexes......................... 428 Structural types of Pt + Ag complexes ........................... 431 0-X. . .Ag secondary interactions .................................. 434 Other Pt-M complexes ............................................ 436 Attempts to prepare complexes containing Pt + Pt bonds ....... 438
1.23
Complexes of Keggin-Type Monolacunary Heteropolytungstates: Synthesis and Characterization .................................... 444 A.M. V. Cavaleiro. J.D.Pedrosa de Jesus and H .I. S. Nogueira Introduction ........ ............................. 444 lated species................ 445 Keggin type heterop Polyoxotungstates with formula [XWllM(L)039In- ...... The 1 : 1 complexes ................................................ 446 Synthesis and stability in solution ................................. 447 Structural characterisation ........................................ 448 Electronic and vibrational spectra ................................ 448 NMR and EPR spectra ........................................... 449 Powder and single crystal X-ray diffraction studies .............. 451 451 Electrochemical properties ........................................ Thermal stability ................................................... 452 Polyoxotungstates with the formu M(XW11039)2In- ..........453 ............................. 453 The 1 : 2 complexes ............... .......... 453 Synthesis and stability in solution .................. 453 Structural characterisation ........................................ 453 Vibrational spectra ................................................ 454 NMR spectra ...................................................... Single crystal X-ray diffraction studies ...................... Electrochemical properties ........................................ 455 The 1 : 2 complexes as oxidation catalysts ........................ 455 ................................ 456 Concluding remarks ...........
1.23.1 1.23.2 1.23.3 1.23.3.1 1.23.3.2 1.23.3.3 1.23.3.3.1 1.23.3.3.2 1.23.3.3.3 1.23.3.3.4 1.23.3.3.5 1.23.4 1.23.4.1 1.23.4.2 1.23.4.3 1.23.4.3.I 1.23.4.3.2 1.23.4.3.3 1.23.4.3.4 1.23.4.4 1.23.5 1.24
1.24.1 1.24.2 1.24.2.1 1.24.2.2
--f
.
Reactivity of Diauracycles A Way to Prepare Chains of Gold Atoms ........................................................ M . Laguna and E. Cerrada Introduction ....................................................... Reactivity of [ A u ~ ( C H ~ P P ~ ~............................... CH~)~] Reactions of [ A u ~ ( C H ~ P P ~ ~with C H gold( ~ ) ~ ]111) or silver(I) complexes .......................................................... Reactions of [ A u ~C( H Z P P ~ ~ C H with ~ )mono ~ ] and binuclear gold( I) complexes .................................................
459 459 461 463 466
Contents
xv
1.24.2.3 1.24.3
Reactions of [ A u ~ ( C H ~ P P ~ ~with C Hprotic ~ ) ~ ]acids ............ 470 Mixed-valence linear chains of gold atoms ...................... ,471
1.25
Aurophilicity at Chalcogenide Centers. Synthesis of Polynuclear Chalcogenido-centeredComplexes with Gold-Gold Interactions. .............. ............... 477 0. Crespo, M.C. Gimeno Introduction .............................................. Oxygen-centered complexes ....................................... 478 ............................ 481 Sulfur-centered complexes Double bridging sulfido li ................. 482 ......................... 482 Triply bridging sulfido lig Quadruply bridging sulfido ligands .................. Quintuply and sextuply bridging sulfido ligands. .................487 Selenium-centered complexes. ..................................... 488 ............................. 488 Double bridging selenido ligands Triply bridging selenido ligands ............................... Quadruply bridging selenido ligands .............................. 490 ....................... 490 Tellurium-centered complexes
1.25.1 1.25.2 1.25.3 1.25.3.1 1.25.3.2 1.25.3.3 1.25.3.4 1.25.4 1.25.4.1 1.25.4.2 1.25.4.3 1.25.5 1.26
.26.1 .26.2 .26.3 .26.4 .26.5 .26.6 1.27 1.27.1 1.27.2 1.27.2.1
Au(1). . .Au(I) and Au(1). . .Ag(I) Loose Clusters.. ............... 493 J. Vicente, M-T. Chicote, I. Saura-Llamas, M-C. Lagunas, M. C. Ramirez de Arellano, P. Gonzblez-Herrero, M-D. Abrisqueta and R. Guerrero. Introduction ........................... ................... 493 Assisted loose clusters .......................... ...... 494 ............................ 499 Unassisted loose clusters . . . Mixed loose clusters .............. ............................ 502 Aurophilic coordination ................. ...............504 ....... 504 Conclusions ........................................ The Heteronuclear Cluster Chemistry of the Group 11 Metals Some Recent Advances ............................................ 509 I. D.Salter Introduction ....................................................... 509 Investigations into the fluxional behaviour exhibited by group 51 1 11 metal heteronuclear clusters in solution ....................... Dynamic behavior involving a rearrangement of the metal cores of clusters containing square-based pyramidal A u ~ R u ~ 51 1 units.. ..............................................................
xvi
Con tents
1.27.2.1.1 1.27.2.1.2 1.27.2.1.3 1.27.2.1.4 1.27.2.2 1.27.2.2.1 1.27.2.2.2
1.27.3 1.27.3.1 1.27.3.2 1.27.3.3
1.28 1.28.1 1.28.2 1.28.2.1 1.28.2.2 1.28.3 1.28.3.1
I .28.3.2 1.28.3.3 1.28.3.4 1.28.3.5 1.28.4
Introduction ..................... .............................. 511 Dynamic behavior of the clusters [ A u ~ R u ~ ( ~ ,u,-COMe)( -H)( p-L2)(CO)9]........................... 51 1 Dynamic behavior of the cluster [ A u ~ R u ~ ( ~ ~ - H )p-1,2-Ph2PC6H4PPh2)(CO)12] (~-H)( . . . . . . . . . . . . . 515 Dynamic behavior of other clusters with metal frameworks containing square-based pyramidal A u ~ R units. u~ Dynamic behavior involving the bidentate diphos 1,1 '-bis(dipheny1phosphino)ferrocene (dppf) attached to the group 11 metals in heteronuclear clusters.. ....................... 518 Introduction ....................... ............................. 518 The dynamic behavior of the clust [AU2RU3(p-H )(pI,-COMe)(P-dPPf)(CO)y1> [ M ~ R u ~ H ~ ( ~ - ~ P P ~[M ) (= C CU, O ) ~Ag Z ]or Au], [ A U ~ R ~ ~ ( ~ ~ - S ) ( ~ - ~and PP~)(CO)~] [ A U C U R U ~ ( ~ ~ - H ) ~ ( ~ - ~............................... P P ~ ) ( C O ) ~ ~ ] . 519 The use of sterically demanding bidentate diphosphine ligands to control the metal core geometries adopted by clusters containing Au~Ru3units ...................... Introduction ................................... ............. 528 Structures of clusters of general formula [AUZ (p-H)(p-L2)(CO)12]..... ....................................... 529 Structures of clusters of general formula [Au2Ru3(p3 (p-L*)(CO)g].......................................... Homonuclear and Heteronuclear Cluster Compounds of Gold .... 535 J. Strahle Introduction ....................................................... 535 Synthesis of homonuclear gold cluster compounds. .............. 536 Photolysis of R3PAuN3 ........................................... 536 Synthesis of [Au(AuCl)(AuPPh3)8]+.............................. 537 Synthesis of heteronuclear gold cluster compounds .............. 539 Photolysis of Ph3PAuN3 in the presence of a metal carbonyl ................................................. 539 s of [Re(CO)5Au(AuPPh3)6]2+ ................ 543 Photolytic synthesis of [ ( C ~ H ~ ) M O ( C ~ ) ~ ( A U........... P P ~ ~ ) ~543 ]+. Co-photolysis of Pd or Pt azido complexes with metal carbonyl complexes .......................................................... 544 Co-photolysis of Ph3PAuN3 and L2M( N3)2 ( M = Pd, Pt; L2 = dppe, ( PPh3)2)............................................... 546 Properties and reactions of heteronuclear gold cluster ..................................................... 547
Contents
xvii
1.28.5 1.28.6
Structures of the heteronuclear gold cluster compounds ......... 549 Bonding in the homonuclear and heteronuclear gold cluster 551 compounds.........................................................
1.29 1.29.1 1.29.2 1.29.2.1 1.29.2.2 1.29.2.3 1.29.3 1.29.3.1 1.29.3.2 1.29.3.3 1.29.3.4 1.29.3.5 1.29.4 1.29.4.1 1.29.4.2 1.29.4.3 1.29.4.4 1.29.4.5 1.29.4.6 1.29.4.7 I .29.5
Naked Clusters of the Post-Transition Elements ...... 561 S. Ulvtdund and L. Bcnytsson-Kloo Introduction and scope of review ................................. 561 Synthesis and stabilization of cationic clusters .................... 562 Historic overview and fundamen Molten salts and related routes . Superacids and other low-temper ................... 567 Synthesis and stabilization of anionic clusters .................... 571 Liquid ammonia and amine solutions ............................ 571 ..... 572 Cluster stabilization by sequestering agents Electrochemical methods .......................................... 573 574 Recent synthetic developments .................................... A note on Zintl phases .................................. 574 Structure and bonding .. . . . . . . . . . 575 Electron-precise polyhedra . 5n-electron clusters .................. 576 Electron-rich clusters with electron counts < 6n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 577 Electron-rich clusters with electron counts >6n .................. 581 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 582 Electron-poor clusters. electron counts < 5n The bonding of cluster species in group 12 .......... Em-cluster bonding . Are the naked clusters really n Cluster condensation and extended structures .................... 589 Reactions and extensions ........ ...................... 591
Volume 11:
Catalysis and Dynamics and Physical Properties
2
Metal Clusters in Catalysis ........................................
2.1
Metal Clusters in Catalysis . An Overview........................ 605 R.J . Puddephatt Introduction ....................................................... 605 Clusters as models for heterogeneous catalysis ................... 606 Stabilization of metal clusters for catalysis ....................... 608 Homogeneous catalysis with cluster complexes ................... 610 Homometallic clusters for homogeneous catalysis ................ 610 Heterometallic clusters for homogeneous catalysis ............... 611 Heterogeneous catalysis involving cluster complexes ............. 612 Conclusion ......................................................... 613
2.1.1 2.1.2 2.1.3 2.1.4 2.1.4.1 2.1.4.2 2.1.5 2.1.6
603
xviii
2.2 2.2.1 2.2.2 2.2.3
2.3 2.3.1 2.3.2 2.3.3 2.3.4 2.3.5 2.3.6 2.3.7 2.4
2.4.1 2.4.2 2.4.2.1 2.4.2.2 2.4.3 2.4.4 2.5
2.5.1 2.5.2 2.5.2.1 2.5.2.2 2.5.2.3 2.5.2.4 2.5.2.5 2.5.2.6 2.5.2.7 2.5.3
Contents
Heterometallic Clusters in Catalysis ............................... P. Braunstein and J. Rosd Introduction ....................................................... Catalytic properties of heterometallic metal-metal bonded cluster compounds of transition metals ........................... Conclusion .........................................................
616 616 622 665
.
ortho-Metalated Dinuclear Rhodium(11) Compounds Synthesis. Structure and Catalytic Applications .............................. 678 P . Lahuerta and I? Estevan Introduction ....................................................... 678 The chemical reaction ............................................. 680 Selectivity of the metalation reaction ............................. 687 Chiral ortho-metalated compounds ............................... 689 NMR spectroscopy ................................................ 690 Crystal data ........................................................ 691 ortho-Metalated dinuclear compounds in catalysis ............... 692 The Role of Co-catalysts in the Reductive Carbonylation of Aromatic Nitro Derivatives Catalyzed by Transition Metal Carbonyl Clusters .................................................. S. Cenini and F. Ragaini Introduction ....................................................... Synthesis of carbamates and ureas ................................ Neutral ligands as co-catalysts .................................... Halide anions as co-catalysts ...................................... Synthesis of heterocycles .......................................... Conclusions ........................................................
697 697 699 699 700 706 713
Homogeneous Catalysis with Ruthenium Carbonyl Cluster Complexes: Hydrogenation of Alkynes ............................ 715 J.A. Cabeza Introduction ....................................................... 715 Survey of catalyst precursors ...................................... 716 Clusters containing only hydride and carbon monoxide ligands . 720 Clusters containing P-donor ligands .............................. 721 Clusters containing cyclopentadienyl ligands ..................... 724 Clusters containing edge-bridging N-donor ligands .............. 724 Clusters containing face-bridging N-donor ligands ............... 725 Clusters containing face-bridging N-donor ligands and phosphine ligands .................................................. 732 Heteronuclear clusters containing ruthenium ..................... 736 Concluding comments ............................................. 737
Contents 2.6
2.6.1 2.6.2 2.6.3 2.6.4 2.6.5 2.6.5.1 2.6.5.2 2.6.6 2.6.7
2.7
2.7.1 2.7.2 2.7.3 2.7.3.1 2.7.3.2 2.7.3.3 2.7.4 2.8
2.8.1 2.8.1.1 2.8.2 2.8.2.1 2.8.2.2 2.8.3 2.8.3.1 2.8.3.2
xix
Metal Clusters as Models for Hydrodesulfurization Catalysts .... 741 M. Brorson, J. D. King, K. Kiriukidou, F. Prestopino and E. Nordlander Introduction ....................................................... 741 Industrial hydrodesulfurization ................................... 742 The active phases in heterogeneous The mechanism(s) of HDS catalysis 746 Model clusters and model reactions.. ............................. 747 Low-valent transition metal clusters .............................. ..................... Transition metal sulfido clusters ... Chevrel phases: heterogeneous HDS catalysts containing molecular clusters. ................................................. 776 Summary. ...... ..................................... 777 Synthesis with Supported Metal Particles by Use of Surface Organometallic Chemistry: Characterization and some ..................................... 782 Applications in Catalysis F. Lefehvre. J.-P. Cundy and J.-M. Basset Introduction ......................................... Synthesis and characterization of bimetallic catalys orted metal particles ...... 783 reaction of organometallics with ..................788 Applications in catalysis. ........ Ligand effect: Hydrogenation of aldehydes[' '1 ............................................ ....... 788 ........................ 789 Adatom effects.. .... ........................... 791 The site isolation e Conclusion ........ ........................ 793 Activation of Carbon Monoxide, Water, and Alcohols on Metal Carbonyl Clusters. Homogeneous and Surface-mediated ... 796 Reactions. .............................................. S. Deahute, P. J. King and E. Suppa Introduction ..................... ............... 796 ............... 798 The aim of this work ............ The role of surfaces in CO and water activation ....... Activation of cluster-bound carbonyls .................. Nucleophilic-electrophilic attack at coordinated carbonyls.. .... 804 Reactions leading to clusters containing water or water ................................... 805 components ............... fragments of water.. ........... 805 Clusters containing water Surface-mediated splitting of water into its components ... 810 (hydration and dehydration reactions) .............
xx 2.8.3.3 2.8.4 2.8.4.1 2.8.4.2 2.8.4.3 2.8.5 2.9
2.9.1 2.9.2 2.9.3 2.9.3.1 2.9.3.2 2.9.4 2.9.5 2.10
2.10.1 2.10.2 2.10.2.1 2.10.2.2 2.10.2.3 2.10.3 2.10.3.1 2.10.3.2 2.10.3.3 2.10.4 2.10.4.1 2.10.4.2 2.10.5
Contents Clusters with ligands which could come from water ............. 812 Hydration and dehydration reactions of cluster-bound propargyl alcohols ................................................. 816 Mononuclear complexes........................................... 819 Bimetallic complexes .............................................. 821 Reactions of propargyl alcohols with metal carbonyl clusters of the iron triad .................................................... 822 Concluding remarks ............................................... 832 Solid-gas Reactions Involving Metal Carbonyl Clusters .......... 844 S. Aime, W. Dastru, R. Gobetto and A. Vide Introduction ....................................................... 844 Solid-gas reaction pathways ....................... ....... 845 Solid-gas reactions involving unsaturated transition metal 846 clusters ............................................................. Reactions of (,u-H)20s3(CO)l~ with CO, NH3. H2S and HCl ..................................................... Selective incorporation of l3C0 in ( p-H)Os3(C0)9(p3-q2-4-Me-CgHgN)............................. 851 Solid-gas reactions involving lightly stabilized transition metal clusters ................................................... Conclusions ........................................................ 855 The Surface of Inorganic Oxides: an Unusual Reaction Medium for the High-yield and Selective Synthesis of Various Osmium Carbonyl Clusters .................................................. 860 E. Cariati, E. Lucenti. D . Roberto and R. Ugo Introduction ....................................................... 860 Synthesis of neutral osmium carbonyl clusters.................... 861 Synthesis of [ H ~ O S ~ ( C O........................................ ),~] 861 Synthesis of lOs3(CO)12]from [Os(CO)3C12]2or OsC13 .......... 863 Syntheses of [ H O S ~ ( C O ) ~( ~ YY =]OH, OR. C1. Br. 02CR) from [Os3(CO)l2................................................ Synthesis of anionic osmium carbonyl clusters ................... 865 Surface-mediated syntheses of [H30s4(C0)12]- and [H20s4(C0)12I2-................................................... 866 Surface-mediated syntheses of [ O S ~ & ( C O ) ~.................. ~]~869 Surface-mediated syntheses of [Os5C(CO)14]*- ...................869 The understanding of the process of nucleation of surface osmium(11) carbonyl species to osmium carbonyl clusters ....... 870 On the surface of magnesia........................................ 870 On the surface of silica added with alkali metal carbonates ..... 871 Conclusion ......................................................... 874
Contents
xx1
2.1 1
The Role of Interstitial Atoms in Transition Metal Carbonyl
2.11.1 2.1 1.2 2.11.2.1 2.11.2.2 2.1 1.2.3 2.1 1.2.4 2.1 1.2.5 2.1 1.2.6 2.1 1.2.7 2.11.3 2.11.3.1 2.1 1.3.2 2.11.3.3 2.11.3.4 2.1 1.3.5 2.11.3.6 2.11.3.7 2.11.4 2.1 1.4.1 2.1 1.4.2 2.1 1.4.3 2.11.5
........................................ . . . . . 877 and C.M. Martin Introduction ................... ......................... 877 ............... 880 Types of interstitial atom.. ................ Three-coordinate interstitial sites. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Four-coordinate interstitial site ......................... 884 Five-coordinate interstitial sites . Six-coordinate interstitial sites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 886 Eight-coordinate interstitial sites ................. Ten-coordinate interstitial sites. ................................... 892 892 Twelve-coordinate interstitial sites ................................ Mechanistic insights into interstitial atom formation. ............ 893 Interstitial hydrogen atoms. ................... Interstitial boron atoms ........................... Interstitial carbon atoms ........ Interstitial nitrogen atoms. ........ ........................ 901 Interstitial oxygen atoms ................. ............... 904 Interstitial phosphorus (arsenic a ..................................... 905 Interstitial sulfur atoms. ........................ 907 Why the interest? ................ ............... 907 Binary phases ............................. The surface-cluster analogy ........................... Enhanced cluster stability .................................. 909 Concluding remarks ............. ........................ 909
2.12
2.12.1 2.12.2 2.12.2.1 2.12.2.2 2.12.3
Potential Applications of Nanostructured Metal Colloids H. B6nnemann and W. Bvijoux Introduction ....................... .................... ............... 914 .................... .............................. 924 Fuel cells.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
Dynamics and Physical Properties. ................................
3.1
Dynamic and Physical Properties - An Overview ................. 935 J.R. Shupley
3.2
The Ligand Stereochemistry of Transition Metal Carbonyl Clusters ............................................................ A . Sironi Introduction .......................................................
3.2.1
933
937 937
xxii 3.2.2 3.2.2.1 3.2.2.2 3.2.3 3.2.4 3.2.4.1 3.2.4.2 3.2.4.3 3.2.4.4 3.2.5 3.2.5.1 3.2.5.2 3.2.6 3.2.6.1 3.2.6.2 3.2.7 3.3
3.3.1 3.3.2 3.3.3 3.3.3.1 3.3.3.2 3.3.3.3 3.3.4 3.3.5 3.3.6 3.3.7 3.3.8 3.3.9 3.3.10 3.3.11 3.3.12 3.3.13
Contents
Favorable ligand packing ................. .................... .............. The ligand polyhedral model The equal potential surface ( Stereochemical regularities in BMCCs ............................ Charge equalization . The formal local char
938 941
................................................. 946 ................... .............. 946 yl clusters ...................... . . 949 .................................. 949 [( Ind)3Ir3(P ~ - C O )........... ~] [MM'(CO)4Cp2] .............. .................................. 950 951 Intermolecular interactions ........................................ Solid-state structure of [Cr2(CO)lo][2,2,2.Crypt-M]2 ( M = Na, K) ..................... ............................ Solid-state dynamics of Fe3(CO)12................................ Conclusions ........................................................
952 953 955
Multinuclear NMR Studies on Homo- and Heterometallic Rhodium Clusters Containing 6 or More Metal Atoms ........... 960 B. T. Heaton. J .A . Iggo. I .S. Podkorytou, D .J . Smawfield, and S.P. Tunik Introduction ....................................................... 960 NMR measurements ............................................... 960 Hexanuclear homo- and heterometallic clusters containing Rh .................................................................. 963 [Rhs(CO)16] and related homo- and heterometallic derivatives .......................................................... 963 Substituted derivatives of [Rh6(CO)16]............................ 967 Hexanuclear, homo- and heterometallic rhodium-containing clusters with an interstitial atom (B, C, N ) ....................... 972 Heptanuclear Rh-containing clusters ............................. 979 Octanuclear Rh-containing clusters ..................... Nonanuclear Rh-containing clusters .................... Decanuclear Rh-containing clusters ............................... 986 987 Undecanuclear Rh-containing clusters ............................ Dodecanuclear Rh-containing clusters ............................ 988 Tridecanuclear Rh-containing clusters ............................ 990 Tetradecanuclear Rh-containing clusters ......................... 992 Higher nuclearity Rh-containing clusters ( 2 15 metals) ....... Concluding remarks ............................................... 995
Contents 3.4
3.4.1 3.4.2 3.4.3 3.4.4 3.4.5 3.4.5.1 3.4.5.2 3.5
3.5.1 3.5.2 3.5.3 3.5.4 3.5.5 3.5.6 3.5.7 3.5.8 3.5.9 3.5.10
3.6 3.6.1 3.6.2 3.6.3 3.6.4 3.6.5 3.6.6 3.6.7
3.7 3.7. I
Structure and Dynamics in Metal Carbonyl Clusters: NMR. EXAFS and Crystallographic Studies ............................ L.J . Farrugia and A . G. Orpen Introduction ...................................................... Dynamic NMR spectroscopy of clusters......................... General mechanisms of ligand exchange......................... Fluxionality in the archetypal clusters M3(C0)12 M = Fe, Ru. 0 s ................................................................. X-ray absorption spectroscopy studies of metal carbonyl clusters ............................................................ Cluster structures in solid and solution .......................... Cluster reaction studies ...........................................
xxiii
1001 1001 1003 1007 1008 1018 1020 1021
Reversible Skeletal Rearrangements in Transition Metal Clusters ........................................................... 1028 P.J . Dyson Introduction ...................................................... 1028 Stereochemical non-rigid behavior of metal cluster polyhedra . . 1029 Polyhedral rearrangements in trinuclear clusters ................ 1030 Polyhedral rearrangements in tetranuclear clusters .............. 1032 Square pyramidal-bridged butterfly interconversions ............1035 Octahedral-trigonal prism interconversions ..................... 1040 Octahedral-capped polyhedral interconversions ................ 1042 Polyhedral rearrangements of high-nuclearity osmium clusters . I045 Polyhedral rearrangements of heteronuclear group 8-platinum clusters ............................................................ 1048 Concluding remarks .............................................. 1049 Skeletal Isomerism in Transition Metal Clusters .................1053 0. Rossell. M. Seco and G. Segalks Introduction ...................................................... 1053 1054 Trinuclear clusters ................................................ Tetranuclear clusters .............................................. 1056 1059 Pentanuclear clusters ............................................. Hexanuclear clusters .............................................. 1061 Hepta- and higher nuclearity clusters ............................ 1065 1069 Conclusions ....................................................... Bond Length-Bond Enthalpy Patterns in Metal Carbonyl Cluster Chemistry ................................................. A .K. Hughes and K. Wade Introduction ......................................................
1073 1073
xxiv 3.7.2 3.7.2.1 3.7.2.2 3.7.3 3.7.4 3.7.5 3.7.6 3.7.7 3.7.8 3.7.9
3.8 3.8.1 3.8.2 3.8.2.1 3.8.3 3.8.3.1 3.8.3.2 3.8.3.3 3.8.3.4 3.8.4 3.8.4.1 3.8.4.2 3.8.5 3.8.5.1 3.8.5.2 3.8.6 3.8.6.1 3.8.7
3.9
Contents
The method ....................................................... 1074 1074 Basic assumptions ................................................ Bulk metals: rates at which metal-metal bonds change in 075 strength with length .............................................. Applications to metal carbonyls with known heats of 077 formation ......................................................... Applications to neutral osmium carbonyl clusters. 080 0S~.-(co)y .......................................................... Applications to osmium carbonyl anions [Os.v( CO),.]2- and neutral and anionic osmium carbonyl . hydrides . [Os,( CO),.H,] '-................................................... 1088 Applications to rhenium carbonyl clusters ....................... 1093 1095 Applications to rhodium carbonyl clusters ...................... Core carbon atoms: the relevance of metal carbides ............1097 101 Concluding remarks ....................................... Bimetallic Effects on the Redox Activity of Transition-metal 104 Carbonyl Clusters ................................................. P . Zanello and F. Fubrizi de Biuni 104 Introduction ...................................................... 104 Trinuclear clusters ................................................ Triangular complexes [M3(C0)12]( M = Fe. Ru) ................ 1104 1112 Tetranuclear clusters .............................................. Tetrahedral complexes ............................................ 1112 1117 Butterfly complexes ............................................... [ M ~ ( C O ) I ~ CECR)].'~ +~(R ( M = Fe. Ru. Co) ................... 1118 Planar complexes ................................................. 1122 Pentanuclear clusters ............................................. 1122 Bow-tie complexes [Fe&l(CO)16]"- ( M = Pt. Au) .............. 1123 Spiked triangulated rhomboidal complexes [M3(Co)lo+.(,U.X)(,U.HgCMo(~~)3(C5H5)~ )I- ( M = Mn. n = 2. X = H; M = Fe. n = 0. X = CO) ........................ 1123 1127 Hexanuclear clusters .............................................. Octahedral complexes ............................................ 1127 1131 Raft-like complexes ............................................... Octanuclear clusters .............................................. 1133 Bicapped octahedral complexes [R~~(C~)~~(C){,U~.R~(CO)~}{~~.M(CO)~}] ( M = Re. Rh) ... 1133 Conclusions ....................................................... 1134
'-
Electron-sink Features of Homoleptic Transition-metal Carbonyl Clusters ................................................. G. Longoni. C. Femoni. M . C. Iupulucci and P . Zanello
1137
Contents
3.9.1 3.9.2 3.9.3 3.9.4 3.9.5
3.10 3.10.1 3.10.2 3.10.3 3.10.4 3.10.5
3.11 3.11.1 3.11.2 3.11.3 3.1 1.3.1 3.11.3.2 3.11.4
3.12 3.12.1 3.12.2 3.12.3 3.12.3.1 3.12.3.2 3.12.3.3 3.12.4 3.12.4.1 3.12.4.2 3.12.4.3 3.12.5
Introduction ...................................................... Metal carbonyl clusters featuring only two chemically and electrochemically reversible oxidation states ..................... HTMCC featuring.three chemically and electrochemically reversible oxidation states ........................................ HTMCC displaying electron-sponge features .................... Conclusions .......................................................
xxv 137 139 1141 1150 1154
Modeling of Electrode Interactions with Metal Clusters ......... 1159 A . Ignaczak and J .A .N.F. Gomes Introduction ...................................................... 1159 Historical background ............................................ 1159 The B3LYP method applied to the cluster-model calculations .. 1162 Electrostatic effects ............................................... 1170 Conclusions ....................................................... 1175 The Transition from Low- to High-nuclearity Molecular Metal Clusters Followed by X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy .........1179 R. Zanoni Introduction ...................................................... 1179 A brief introduction to applications of photoemission spectroscopy to clusters........................................... 1180 Case studies ....................................................... 1182 Experimental resolution of surface and bulk atoms in ligated 1182 metal clusters ..................................................... From molecular clusters to semiconducting particles - high nuclearity Cu-Se clusters ......................................... 1186 Perspectives ....................................................... 1192 Structure. Morphology. and Interface Structure of Supported Metal and Alloy Particles . HRTEM Studies ................... S. Giorgio. H . Graoui. C. Chapon and C.R. Henry Introduction ...................................................... Sample preparation ............................................... Shape and structure............................................... Pd-MgO (001).................................................... Pd-ZnO (100) .................................................... Pd-ZnO (001) .................................................... Characterization of the interface ................................. Pd-MgO (001) .................................................... Pd-ZnO (100) .................................................... Pd-ZnO (001) .................................................... Alloying effect ....................................................
1194 1194 1196 1196 1196 1198 1198 1202 1202 1204 1204 1205
xxvi
Contents
3.12.6 3.12.7
Annealing in gas atmospheres .................................... Discussion ........................................................
3.13
Radiation-induced Metal Clusters. Nucleation Mechanism and Chemistry ......................................................... 1213 J . Belloni and M . Mostufuvi Introduction ...................................................... 1213 Pulse radiolysis principle ......................................... 1214 Nucleation and growth mechanisms ............................. 1215 Principle of radiolytic formation of atoms and clusters .........1215 Atom and charged dimer formation ............................. 1217 Coalescence processes ............................................ 1221 1222 Hydrated clusters ................................................. Ligand effect on cluster growth .................................. 1223 Effect of dose rate on cluster growth ............................. 1224 1225 Cluster formation from multivalent ions ......................... Coalescence of bimetallic clusters ................................ 1225 Principle of redox potential determination of transient species ............................................................. 1228 Reactivity of metal atoms ........................................ 1228 1228 Redox potential of metal atoms .................................. Comparison between ionization potential and optical absorption of atoms .............................................. 1231 Reactivity of metal clusters ....................................... 1232 Monometallic clusters ............................................ 1232 Reactivity of bimetallic clusters .................................. 1239 Mechanism of electron transfer catalyzed by clusters ........... 1241 The thermodynamics of catalysis ................................ 1241 Autocatalytic growth ............................................. 1243 1243 Kinetics of electron-transfer catalysis ............................ Conclusion ........................................................ 1244
3.13.1 3.13.2 3.13.3 3.13.3.1 3.13.3.2 3.13.4 3.13.4.1 3.13.4.2 3.13.4.3 3.13.4.4 3.13.4.5 3.13.5 3.13.6 3.13.6.1 3.13.6.2 3.13.7 3.13.7.1 3.13.7.2 3.13.8 3.13.8.1 3.13.8.2 3.13.8.3 3.13.9 3.14 3.14.1 3.14.2 3.14.3 3.14.4 3.14.5 3.14.6
1207 1209
The Investigation of Heavy Metal Cluster Structures in Powder Samples by the Radial Distribution Function Method ............ 1248 V.Z. Korsunsky Introduction ...................................................... 1284 Simple manifestation of nearest metal-metal distances ......... 1251 More detailed structure manifestation in RDFs ................. 1254 Polynuclear chains with direct interactions between heavy atoms .............................................................. 1257 . ligands . Heavy atoms in ........................................... 1259 1261 Conclusion ........................................................
Contents
xxvii
3.15.1 3.15.2 3.15.3 3.15.4
The Spectrum of an Exciton in Nan0 crystal Semiconductor Structures . Theory ............................................... S.I . Pokutnyi and V.V. Kooukhuk Introduction ................................................. The Hamiltonian of an exciton in a nano crystal ........... The spectrum of an exciton in a nano crystal ............... Bulk exciton in a nano crystal ...............................
Volume 111:
Nanomaterials and Solid State Chemistry
4
Nanomaterials.....................................................
4.1
Metal Clusters and Nanomaterials: an Overview ................. 1273 M. Ichikawa Introduction ...................................................... 1273 Ship-in-a-bottle synthesis of metal clusters in micropores ....... 1274 Robust metal clusters in mesopores .............................. 1284 Bimetallic clusters in zeolites ..................................... 1285 Cluster tranformation to nanoparticles in mesopores ........... 1287 Nanowires in mesoporous channels and their unique properties ......................................................... 1289 Metal Catalysts derived from zerolite-entrapped metal clusters . 1292 Water-gas shift reaction ( WGSR) ................................ 1293 NO + CO reaction ................................................ 1296 CO hydrogenation ................................................ 1296 Methane homologation reaction ................................. 1297 1298 Future prospect ...................................................
3.15
4.1.1 4.1.2 4.1.3 4.1.4 4.1.5 4.1.6 4.1.7 4.1.7.1 4.1.7.2 4.1.7.3 4.1.7.4 4.1.8 4.2
4.2.1 4.2.2 4.3
4.3.1 4.3.2 4.3.3
1263 26 3 264 265 266
1271
Silver-Tellurium Clusters from Silylated Tellurolate Reagents . . 1302 D . Fenske and J.F. Corrigan Introduction ...................................................... 1302 Silver-tellurium clusters .......................................... 1303 Nanosized Clusters on and in Supports . Perspectives for Future Catalysis .......................................................... 1325 G. Schmid Introduction ...................................................... 325 Between molecule and bulk . the position of nanosized 326 clusters ............................................................ The effect of the ligand shell in immobilized clusters on activity and selectivity ............................................ 329
xxviii
Contents
4.3.4 4.3.5 4.3.6
Bimetallic shell-structured particles .............................. Clusters in nanotubes ............................................. Conclusions and perspectives .....................................
4.4
On the Possibility of Single Electronics Based on LigandStabilized Metal Clusters ......................................... 1342 U. Simon Introduction ...................................................... 1342 1343 What is single-electron tunneling? ................................ Single-electron tunneling in nanoparticles ....................... 1347 Evidence of SET in ligand-stabilized metal clusters ............. 1349 1349 Single cluster properties .......................................... One-dimensional arrangements .................................. 1351 Two-dimensional arrangements .................................. 1353 1354 Three-dimensional cluster networks .............................. Clusters as building blocks for SET devices ..................... 1356 Doubts and chances .............................................. 1356 First devices....................................................... 1356 Summary and outlook ............................................ 1359
4.4.1 4.4.2 4.4.2.1 4.4.3 4.4.3.1 4.4.3.2 4.4.3.3 4.4.3.4 4.4.4 4.4.4.1 4.4.4.2 4.4.5 4.5
4.5.1 4.5.2 4.5.2.1 4.5.2.2 4.5.2.3 4.5.3
4.6
4.6.1 4.6.2 4.6.3 4.6.4 4.6.4.1 4.6.4.2 4.6.4.3 4.6.4.4 4.6.4.5
1332 1336 1339
Strategies for Assembling Pd and Pt Atoms ...................... 1364 M .N . Vargafik, N . Yu. Kozitsyna, N . V. Cherkashina. R.I . Rudy. D .I . Kochubey and I. I. Moiseev Introduction ...................................................... 1364 1367 Giant clusters ..................................................... Polymeric precursors of giant clusters ........................... 1367 Giant Pd clusters ................................................. 1372 Platinum clusters and colloids .................................... 1379 Conclusions ....................................................... 1388 Electronic Structure of Naked. Ligated and Supported Transition Metal Clusters from ‘First Principles’ Density Functional Calculations ........................................... 1392 G. Pacchioni. S. Kruger and N . Rosch Introduction ...................................................... 1392 Density functional theory ........................................ 1393 Naked clusters .................................................... 1395 Clusters in ligand shells ........................................... 1402 Low-nuclearity gold compounds - complexes or clusters? ...... 1402 Metal-ligand interaction ......................................... 1404 Magnetic quenching in carbonylated Ni clusters ................1407 Bimetallic clusters ................................................ 1411 Interstitial atoms in clusters ...................................... 1417
xxix
Contents
4.6.5 4.6.5.1 4.6.5.2 4.6.6 4.7
4.7.1 4.7.2 4.7.3 4.7.4 4.7.5
Supported metal clusters ......................................... Ni4. Cu4. and Pd4 clusters on MgO(001) ........................ Ni clusters deposited on A1203 ................................... Concluding remarks ..............................................
1422 1424 1427 1429
Physical Properties of Metal Cluster Compounds. Model Systems for Nanosized Metal Particles ........................... 1434 L.J . de Jongh Introduction: Why are metal nanoparticles of interest? ......... 1434 Giant magic-number metal clusters .............................. 1437 Evolution to magnetic metallic properties . Some examples . . . . . 1440 Odd-even electron numbers and energy level statistics in cluster assemblies ................................................. 1445 Energy-level statistics in assemblies of small metal particles: summary of theoretical background ............................. 1449
4.8.4 4.8.4.1 4.8.4.2 4.8.5
On the Size-Induced Metal-Insulator Transition in Clusters and Small Particles ............................................... P.P . Edwards, R .L. Johnston and C.N .R. Rao Introduction - divided metals .................................... The electronic structure of divided metals ....................... The metal-insulator transition in mesoscopic and macroscopic systems ............................................................ Experimental studies.............................................. Single particles .................................................... Arrays of particles ................................................ Concluding remarks ..............................................
5
Solid-state Cluster Chemistry ....................................
1483
5.1
Solid-state Cluster Chemistry . An Overview .................... T. Saito
1485
5.2
Transition Metal Clusters - The Relationship between Molecular and Crystal Structure ................................. M .J . Calhorda, D . Braga and F. Grepioni Introduction ...................................................... Experimental and theoretical methods ........................... Molecular and crystal structures of transition metal carbonyls Conclusions .......................................................
4.8
4.8.1 4.8.2 4.8.3
5.2.1 5.2.2 5.2.3 5.2.4 5.3 5.3.1
1454 1454 1457 1463 1467 1468 1476 1478
1491 1491 1492 . 1494 1503
Discrete and condensed clusters in low Valent Niobium Oxides . . I509 G. Svensson. J . Kohler and A . Simon Introduction ...................................................... 1509
xxx
Contents
5.3.2 5.3.3 5.3.3.1 5.3.3.2 5.3.3.3 5.3.3.4 5.3.3.5 5.3.3.6 5.3.3 5.3.4 5.3.6
Oxoniobates containing discrete Nb6012 clusters ................ 1509 Reduced oxoniobates with condensed Nb6012 clusters.......... 1519 Intergrowths between perovskite and NbO ...................... 1521 The formation of intergrowth compounds ....................... 1526 Structural considerations ......................................... 1529 Two pairs of compounds ......................................... 1534 Attempts to change the properties by doping .................... 1538 What is the valence of the niobium atoms? ...................... 1539 Oxotantalates containing discrete Ta60 1 2 clusters ............... 1542 Reduced oxoniobates containing Nb208 clusters ................1543 Superconductivity in low-valent oxoniobates .................... 1545
5.4
Cluster Compounds Containing Mixed-Charge Cluster Units: [M6X12]2+ and [Msx.. 14+ or [ M ~ X I ~ and ]~+ [ M o ~ C I ~ (M=Nb. ]~+ Ta; X=CI. Br) ............................ 1551 N . BrniteviC Introduction ...................................................... 1551 Hexanuclear [M,jX12].+ ( M = Nb. Ta; X = Cl. Br; n = 2. 3. 4) cluster units and reactions in non-aqueous solvents .............1552 Behavior of [M6X12I2+in methanol .............................. 1552 The [(M6X12)X2].6ROH( R = Me. Et) clusters as precursors . . 1553 Clusters with mixed-charge cluster units ......................... 1555 [Ta6C112(PrCN)6][(Ta6C112)C16].2PrCN, a compound with homonuclear mixed-charge cluster units - [Ta6C112]2+ in 1555 the cation and [Ta6C112I4+in the anion .......................... [M6X12(EtOH j6][( Mo6Cls)C14X2].nEtOH.mEtzO,compounds with heteronuclear mixed-charge cluster units [MgX12l2+and [M06C18]~+( M = Nb. Ta; X = C1. Br) .......................... 556 Conclusion ........................................................ 561
5.4.1 5.4.2 5.4.2.1 5.4.2.2 5.4.3 5.4.3.1 5.4.3.2 5.4.4 5.5
5.5.1 5.5.2 5.5.3 5.5.3.1 5.5.3.2 5.5.4 5.5.4.1 5.5.4.2 5.5.5
M&14 and M6L18 Units in Early Transition Element Cluster 563 Compounds........................................................ C. Perrin Introduction ...................................................... 1563 1564 Preparation and characterization ................................ The M6L18 based compounds . M ~ M ~ M................... ~ L I ~ 1565 Electronic properties of the M6L18 unit .......................... 1565 Dependence of M6L18 packing on the size, charge, and stoichiometry of the countercations .............................. 1566 M6L14 based compounds - MlM6L14 ........................... 1573 1573 Electronic properties of the M6L14 unit .......................... M6L14 stacking in the various structures ......................... 1574 Evolution of the intra-unit distances with electronic or steric factors - comparison of M6L14 and M6L18 units ................ 1577
Contents 5.5.5.1 5.5.5.2 5.5.5.3 5.5.5.4 5.5.6 5.5.7
5.5.8 5.6
5.6.1 5.6.2 5.6.2.1 5.6.2.2 5.6.2.3 5.6.3 5.6.3.1 5.6.3.2 5.6.4
5.7
5.7.1 5.7.1.1 5.7.1.2 5.7.2 5.7.2.1 5.7.2.2 5.7.2.3 5.7.2.4
xxxi
Evolution of the metal-metal intracluster bond depending 1579 on the cluster oxidation state ..................................... Relativistic effects on M-M intracluster distances .............. 1581 Matrix effects of ligand size ...................................... 1581 Effects of charge on intra-unit distances ......................... 1583 1584 The oxyhalides in Mg cluster chemistry .......................... Physical properties of discrete M6L18- and M6Ll4-based compounds ........................................................ 1585 Concluding remarks .............................................. 1588
Ternary Rhenium and Technetium Chalcogenides Containing Re6 or T c ~Clusters ............................................... 1591 W Bronger Introduction ...................................................... 1591 The structural systems of the ternary chalcogenides of rhenium and technetium ................................................... 1591 Ternary chalcogenides of rhenium and technetium containing isolated clusters ................................................... 1594 a ternary rhenium chalcogenide with Cs6Re& . two-dimensionally linked clusters ................................ 1595 Ternary chalcogenides of rhenium and technetium with three1599 dimensionally-linked clusters ..................................... Experiments and calculations for the characterization of the binding in clusters of the ternary chalcogenides of rhenium and technetium ................................................... 1604 Magnetochemical and vibrational spectroscopic investigations . 1604 Molecular orbital calculations for the determination of the relative stabilities of Mg clusters ................................. 1605 The 24 valence electron configuration of the Re6 cluster and the explanation of contradictory experiments ................... 1607 Discrete and Linked Homoatomic Clusters of the Elements Ge. Sn. and Pb .................................................... 1612 T.F. Fassler Introduction ...................................................... 1612 Scope .............................................................. 1616 Historical background - Zintl ions and Zintl phases ............ 1616 Molecular clusters ................................................ 1617 Wade’s Rules ..................................................... 1617 Structurally characterized polyhedral clusters of group 13-1 5 elements ........................................................... 1618 Soluble polyhedral Zintl ions of group- 14 elements ............. 1618 Structures of homoatomic nine-atom clusters ................... 1623
xxxii
Contents
5.7.2.5 5.7.3 5.7.3.1 5.7.3.2 5.7.3.3 5.7.3.4 5.7.4
Crystal packing in compounds with nine-atom clusters .... 628 Cluster units in Ge.. Sn.. and Pb-rich intermetallic phases . 630 630 lntermetallic phases containing discrete polyhedra . . . . . . . . . lntermetallic phases containing linked polyhedra . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1630 Superconductivity................................................. 1633 Theoretical investigations of the electronic structures ...........1633 Conclusion ........................................................ 1637
5.8
Hexacapped Cubic Transition Metal Clusters and Derivatives . a Theoretical Approach ........................................... 1643 R. Guutier, J.-F. Hulet and J.-Y. Suillard Introduction ...................................................... 1643 Empty hexacapped cubic species ................................. 1645 Species containing interstitial transition-metal atoms ........... 1650 Distorted metal-centered cubic Mg architectures ................ 1653 Interstitial main group atoms .............................. 655 Cubic cluster condensation ................................. 656 659 Conclusions and comments ................................
5.8.1 5.8.2 5.8.3 5.8.4 5.8.5 5.8.6 5.8.7 5.9
5.9.1 5.9.2 5.9.2.1 5.9.2.2 5.9.2.3 5.9.3 5.9.3.1 5.9.3.2 5.9.3.3 5.9.3.4 5.9.4 5.9.4.1 5.9.4.2 5.9.4.3 5.9.4.4 5.9.4.5
Metallocarbohedrenes MgC12 (M =Ti. Zr. Hf. V. Nb. Cr. Mo. Fe) and Ti.M’. C12 (M’=Y. Zr. Hf. Nb. Ta. Mo. W. Si. x + y = 8) - from Mass Spectrometry to 664 Computational Chemistry ................................... M ..M . Rohmer. A4. Binard and J ..A4. Poblet 664 Metallocarbohedrenes - organometallic fullerenes? ....... Formation. growth and dissociation of met-cars ................ 666 Methods of preparation .......................................... 1666 1671 Crystal growth .................................................... Dissociation pathways ............................................ 1674 Physical properties of met-cars and related clusters .............1676 1676 Ionization potentials .............................................. Electron affinity ................................................... 1677 Collective electronic properties: delayed ionization and 1678 delayed atomic ion emission...................................... Ion chromatography studies ...................................... 1679 Chemical reactivity of met-cars and related M,C, clusters . . . . . 1681 Methods of investigation ......................................... 1681 1681 Association reactions of Ti8C$ .................................. Reactions of niobium-contamlng met-cars and titanium carbide clusters with acetone ..................................... 1683 Reaction of TixCl2+and other met-cars with methyl iodide .... 1683 Oxidation-induced reactions of TiXC12 and other metal-carbide clusters ............................................................ 1685
Contents
5.9.4.6 5.9.4.1 5.9.5 5.9.5.1 5.9.5.2 5.9.5.3 5.9.6 5.9.6.1 5.9.6.2 5.9.6.3 5.9.7 6
6.1 6.2 6.2.1 6.2.2 6.2.3 6.3 6.4 6.5
xxxiii
Reactivity ofVgC12’ and NbgC12+. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1685 Reactivity of vanadium-carbon nanocrystals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1686 Theoretical models of the pentagonal dodecahedron.. . The earliest theoretical studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1686 The quest for Jahn-Teller distortion.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1689 The electronic ground state of dodecahedra1 met-cars . . . . . . . . . . 1690 A conformer proposed by theory - the tetracapped tetrahedron of metal atoms.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1693 Looking for different cage structures.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1693 The tetracapped tetrahedron of metal atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1693 Pentagonal dodecahedron or capped tetrahedron the controversy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1704 Conclusion - more than a peak in a mass spectrum?. . .. ... . . ... 1707 -
Metal Clusters in Chemistry - Bibliography of Reviews 1988-1997 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M.I. Bruce Introduction . . . . . . . . ... . . . ..... ...... ........ ... .. . . . 1711 Books . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................... 1711 Books on metal clusters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1712 ................................... Conferences . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1716 .............. 1718
7
Retrospective and Prospective Considerations in Cluster . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1755 Chemistry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8
Introduction .
..................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1756
Structure of carbonyl clusters . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1760
. . . . . .. . ... . . . . . . . .
Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1779
..............1781
Index. ... . . ...... . . . ..... .. ... .... ..... ... . . . . . . _ . .... ..... ........ 1783
List of Contributors
Maria-Dolores Abrisqueta Grupo de Quimica Organometilica Departamento de Quimica lnorginica Facultad de Quimica Universidad de Murcia Aptdo. 4021 E-3007 1 Murcia Spain Silvio Aime Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica, Chimica Fisica e Chimica dei Materiali Universita di Torino Via Pietro Giuria 7 1-10 125 Torino Italy Santiago Alvarez Departament de Quimica Inorganica Universitat de Barcelona Av. Diagonal, 647 E-08028 Barcelona Spain Gabriel Aullon Departament de Quimica Inorganica Universitat de Barcelona Av. Diagonal, 647 E-08028 Barcelona Spain
Jean-Marie Basset Laboratoire de Chimie Organometallique de Surface UMR CNRS-CPE 9986 43 Bd du 11 Novembre 1918 F-696 16 Villeurbanne Cedex France Daniela Belli Dell‘ Amico Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale Universita di Pisa Via Risorgimento 35 1-56126 Pisa ltaly Jacqueline Belloni Laboratoire de Physico-Chimie des Rayonnements UMR 8610 Universite Paris-Sud - B2t. 350 Centre d’Orsay F-9 1405 Orsay Cedex France ~
Marc Benard Laboratoire de Chimie Quantique UMR 7551 CNRS Universite Louis Pasteur 4 rue Blaise Pascal F-67070 Strasbourg France
xxxvi
List of Contributors
Lars Bengtsson-Kloo Inorganic Chemistry Royal Institute of Technology S-10044 Stockholm Sweden Gilles Boni Laboratoire de Synthese et d’Electrosynthese Organometalliques Universite de Bourgogne 6, Boulevard Gabriel F-21000 Dijon France Helmut Bonnemann Max-Planck-Institut fur Kohlenforschung Kaiser-Wilhelm-Platz 1 D-45470 Mulheim a.d. Ruhr Germany Dario Braga Dipartimento di Chimica G. Ciamician V. Selmi, 2 40126 Bologna Italy Pierre Braunstein Laboratoire de Chimie de Coordination (UMR 7513 CNRS) Institut Le Be1 Universite Louis Pasteur 4 rue Blaise Pascal 67070 Strasbourg France Werner Brijoux Max-Planck-Institut fur Kohlenforschung Kaiser-Wilhelm-Platz 1 D-45470 Mulheim a.d. Ruhr Germany Nevenka BrniEevit Ruder BoSkovib Institute
BijeniEka 54 HR-10001 Zagreb Croatia Welf Bronger Institut fur Anorganische Chemie Technische Hochschule Aachen Professor-Pirlet-Stral3e 1 D-52056 Aachen Germany Michael Brorson Haldor Topwe Research Laboratories Nym~llevej55 DK-2800 Lyngby Denmark Michael I. Bruce Department of Chemistry University of Adelaide Adelaide South Australia 5005 Australia Javier A. Cabeza Departamento de Quimica Organica e Inorganica Instituto de Quimica Organometalica ‘Enrique Moles’ Universidad de Oviedo-CSIC E-3307 I Oviedo Spain Emmanuel Cadot Institut Lavoisier Universite de Versailles-St-Quentin 45, Avenue des Etats-Unis F-78035 Versailles France Fausto Calderazzo Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale Universitii di Pisa Via Risorgimento 35
List of Contributors
1-56126 Pisa Italy Maria Jose Calhorda ITQB - Instituto de Tecnologia Quimica e Biologica R. da Quinta Grande, 6 Apartado 127 P-2780 Oeiras Portugal Jean-Pierre Candy Laboratoire de Chimie Organometallique de Surface UMR CNRS-CPE 9986 43 Bd du 1 1 Novembre 1918 F-696 16 Villeurbanne Cedex France David J. Cardin Department of Chemistry University of Reading Whiteknights Reading Berkshire RG6 6AD UK
xxxvii
Ana M. V. Cavaleiro Department of Chemistry University of Aveiro P-38 10 Aveiro Portugal Sergio Cenini Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica Metallorganica e Analitica and CNR Center Via G. Venezian 21 1-20133 Milano Italy Elena Cerrada Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain Claude Chapon CRMC2-CNRS Campus de Luminy, Case 9 13 F-13288 Marseille Cedex 9 France
Elena Cariati Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica, Metallorganica e Analitica and Centro CNR Universita di Milano via G. Venezian 21 1-20133 Milano Italy
Natalia V. Cherkashina N. S. Kurnakov lnstitute of General and Inorganic Chemistry Russian Academy of Sciences 3 1 Leninski Prospect 117907 MOSCOW, GSP-1 Russia
Daniele Cauzzi Dipartimento di Chimica Generale ed Inorganica, Chimica Analytica, Chimica Fisica Universita di Parma Viale delle Scienze 1-43100 Parma Italy
Maria-Teresa Chicote Grupo de Quimica Organometalica Departamento de Quimica Inorghnica Facultad de Quimica Universidad de Murcia Aptdo. 4021 E-3007 1 Murcia Spain
xxxviii List o j Contributors Malcolm H. Chisholm Department of Chemistry Indiana University Bloomington, IN 47405 USA Miguel A. Ciriano Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain John F. Corrigan Department of Chemistry The University of Western Ontario London Ontario N6A 5B7 Canada F. Albert Cotton Chemistry Department Texas A&M University P.O. Box 300012 College Station, TX 77842 USA Olga Crespo Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain W. Dastrh Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica, Chimica Fisica e Chimica dei Materiali Universita di Torino Via P. Giuria 7 I- 10125 Torino Italy Stefano Deabate Dipartimento di Chimica IFM
Universita di Torino Via P.Giuria 7 I- 10125 Torino Italy Antony J. Deeming Department of Chemistry University College London 20 Gordon Street London WCI H OAJ UK L. Jos de Jongh Kamerlingh Onnes Laboratory Leiden University P.O. Box 9506 N L 2300 RA Leiden The Netherlands Roberto Della Pergola Dipartamente di Scienze dell’ Ambiente e del Territorio Universita di Milano Bicocca Via G. Emanueli 15 1-20126 Milano Italy Paul J. Dyson Department of Chemistry The University of York Heslington, YOIO5DD UK Peter P. Edwards School of Chemistry The University of Birmingham Edgbaston Birmingham B15 2TT UK Francisco Estevan Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Universitat de Valencia Dr. Moliner 50 E-46100 Burjasot-Valencia Spain
List of Contributors
Fabrizia Fabrizi de Biani Dipartimento di Chimica dell’Universita di Siena Pian dei Mantellini 44 1-53100 Siena Italy
xxxix
Universita degli Studi dell’ Insubria Via J. H. Dunant 3 1-21100 Varese Italy
Louis J. Farrugia Department of Chemistry University of Glasgow Glasgow G12 8QQ UK
Regis Gautier Laboratoire de Chimie du Solide et Inorganique Moleculaire UMR CNRS 651 1 Universite de Rennes I F-35042 Rennes Cedex France
Thomas F. Fassler ETH Zurich Laboratorium fur Anorganische Chemie Universitatsstr. 6 CH-8092 Zurich Switzerland
M. Concepcion Gimeno Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain
Dieter Fenske Institut fur Anorganische Chemie der U niversi tat D-76128 Karlsruhe Germany
Suzanne Giorgio CRMC2-CNRS Campus de Luminy, Case 913 F-13288 Marseille Cedex 9 France
Cristina Femoni Dipartimento di Chimica Fisica ed Inorganica Universita degli Studi di Bologna viale del Risorgimento 4 1-40136 Bologna Italy
Roberto Gobetto Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica, Chimica Fisica e Chimica dei Materiali Universitii di Torino Via P. Giuria 7 1-10125 Torino Italy
Juan Fornies Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain
Jose A.N.F. Gomes CEQUP/Faculdade de CiCncias Universidade do Porto Rua do Campo Alegre 687 P-4 150 Porto Portugal
Alessandro Fumagalli Dipartimento di Biologia Strutturale e Funzionale
Pablo Gonzalez-Herrero Grupo de Quimica Organometalica Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Facultad de Quimica
XI
List of Contributors
Universidad de Murcia Aptdo. 4021 E-3007 1 Murcia Spain
University of Liverpool P.O. Box 147 Liverpool L69 7ZD UK
Claudia Graiff Dipartimento di Chimica Generale ed Inorganica, Chimica Analytica, Chimica Fisica Universita di Parma Vide delle Scienze 1-43100 Parma Italy
Gerald Henkel lnstitut fur Synthesechemie Gerhard-Mercator-Universitiit Lotharstrasse 1 D-47048 Duisburg Germany
Houda Graoui CRMC2+-CNRS Campus de Luminy Case 9 13 F-13288 Marseille Cedex 9 France Fabrizia Grepioni Dipartimento di Chimica G. Ciamician V. Selmi, 2 1-40126 Bologna Italy Rita Guerrero Grupo de Quimica Organometalica Departamento de Quimica lnorganica Facultad de Quimica Universidad de Murcia Aptdo. 4021 E-3007 1 Murcia Spain Jean-Franqois Halet Laboratoire de Chimie du Solide et Inorganique Moleculaire UMR CNRS 651 I Universite de Rennes I F-35042 Rennes Cedex France Brian T. Heaton Department of Chemistry
Claude R. Henry CRMC2-CNRS Campus de Luminy, Case 913 F-13288 Marseille Cedex 9 France Catherine E. Housecroft lnstitut fur Anorganische Chemie Universitat Basel Spitalstrasse 51 CH-4056 Basel Switzerland Andrew K. Hughes Department of Chemistry University of Durham Science Laboratories South Road Durham DHI 3LE UK Maria Carmela Iapalucci Dipartimento di Chimica Fisica ed lnorganica Universita degli Studi di Bologna viale del Risorgimento 4 1-40136 Bologna Italy Masaru Ichikawa Catalysis Research Center Hokkaido University Kita-ku, N-11. W-10
List of Contributors
Sapporo 060 Japan Jonathan A. Iggo Department of Chemistry University of Liverpool P.O. Box 147 Liverpool L69 7ZD UK Anna Ignaczak Department of Theoretical Chemistry University of t o d i ul. Narutowicza 68 90-136 Lodz Poland Brian F. G. Johnson Dept. of Chemistry University of Cambridge Lensfield Road Cambridge CB2 1EW UK Roy L. Johnston School of Chemistry The University of Birmingham Edgbaston Birmingham B 15 2TT UK Jason D. King Inorganic Chemistry 1 Chemical Center Lund University Box 124 S-22100 Lund Sweden Philip J. King School of Chemistry University of Bristol Cantock’s Close Bristol BS8 1TS UK
xli
Keranio Kiriakidou Inorganic Chemistry 1 Chemical Center Lund University Box 124 S-22100 Lund Sweden Dmitry I. Kochubey G. K. Boreskov Institute of Catalysis Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences 5 Prospect Akademika Lavrent’eva 630090 Novosibirsk Russian Federation Jiirgen Kohler Max-Planck-Institut fur Festkorperforschung HeisenbergstraIje 1 D-70569 Stuttgart Germany Vladimir I. Korsunsky Institute of Chemical Kinetics and Combustion Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences Novosibirsk 630090 Russia Dimitrd Kovala-Demertzi Inorganic Chemistry Department of Chemistry University of Ioannina G-45 110 Ioannina Greece Volodymyr V. Kovalchuk 270045 Odessa 90, Velyka Arnautska apt. 16 Ukraine Natalia Yu. Kozitsyna N. S. Kurnakov Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry
xlii
List of’ Contributors
Russian Academy of Sciences 3 1 Leninski Prospect 117907 MOSCOW, GSP-1 Russia
Universitat de Valencia Dr. Moliner 50 E-46100 Burjasot-Valencia Spain
Sven Kruger Lehrstuhl fur Theoretische Chemie Technische Universitiit Munchen D-85747 Garching Germany
Frederic Lefebvre Laboratoire de Chimie Organometallique de Surface UMR CNRS-CPE 9986 43 Bd du 1 1 Novembre 1918 F-696 16 Villeurbanne Cedex France
Marek M. Kubicki Laboratoire de Synthese et d’Electrosynthese Organomttalliques Universite de Bourgogne 6, Boulevard Gabriel F-21000 Dijon France
Jack Lewis Robinson College Grange Road Cambridge CB3 9AN UK
Antonio Laguna Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain
Giuliano Longoni Dipartimento di Chimica Fisica ed Inorganica Universita degli Studi di Bologna viale del Risorgimento 4 1-40136 Bologna Italy
Mariano Laguna Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain
Elena Lucenti Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica, Metallorganica e Analitica and Centro CNR Universita di Milano via G. Venezian 21 1-20133 Milano Italy
Maria-Cristina Lagunas Grupo de Quimica Organometalica Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Facultad de Quimica Universidad de Murcia Aptdo. 4021 E-30071 Murcia Spain Pascual Lahuerta Departamento de Quimica Inorganica
Fabio Marchetti Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale Universita di Pisa Via Risorgimento 35 1-56126 Pisa Italy Antonio Martin Departamento de Quimica Inorganica
List of Contributors
Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Arag6n Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain Caroline M. Martin Dept. of Chemistry University of Cambridge Lensfield Road Cambridge CB2 IEW UK
Ilya I. Moiseev N. S. Kurnakov Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry Russian Academy of Sciences 3 1 Leninski Prospect GSP-1 117907 MOSCOW, Russia Michael J. Morris Department of Chemistry University of Sheffield Sheffield S3 7HF UK
Carlo Mealli Instituto per lo Studio della Stereochimica ed Energetica dei Composti di Coordinazione Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche Via J. Nardi 39 1-50132 Firenze Italy
Mehran Mostafavi Laboratoire de Physico-Chimie des Rayonnements - UMR 8610 Universite Paris-Sud-Bgt. 350 Universitk Paris-Sud Centre d’Orsay F-91405 Orsay Cedex France
Alexander Metz Anorganisch-Chemisches Institut Ruprecht-Karls-Universitat Im Neuenheimer Feld 270 D-69 120 Heidelberg Germany
Helena I. S. Nogueira Department of Chemistry University of Aveiro P-3810 Aveiro Portugal
Javier Modrego Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain Claude Morse Laboratoire de Synthese et d’Electrosynthese Organometalliques Universite de Bourgogne 6, Boulevard Gabriel F-2 1000 Dijon France
xliii
Ebbe Nordlander Inorganic Chemistry 1 Chemical Center Lund University Box 124 S-22100 Lund Sweden Annabella Orlandini Instituto per lo Studio della Stereochimica ed Energetica dei Composti di Coordinazione Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche Via J. Nardi 39 1-50132 Firenze Italy
xliv
List o j Contributors
Luis A. Oro Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain
Christiane Perrin Laboratoire de Chimie du Solide et Inorganique Moleculaire UMR CNRS 65 11 Universite de Rennes I Avenue du General Leclerc F-35042 Rennes Cedex France
A. Guy Orpen School of Chemistry University of Bristol Bristol BS8 ITS UK
Antoni Pietrzykowski Faculty of Chemistry Warsaw University of Technology Koszykowa 75 00-662 Warsaw Poland
Gianfranco Pacchioni Dipartimento di Scienza dei Materiali Istituto Nazionale di Fisica della Materia Universita di Milano Via Emanueli 15 1-20126 Milano Italy Guido Pampaloni Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale Universita di Pisa Via Risorgimento 35 1-56126 Pisa ltaly Stanislaw Pasynkiewicz Faculty of Chemistry Warsaw University of Technology Koszykowa 75 00-662 Warsaw Poland Julio D. Pedrosa de Jesus Department of Chemistry University of Aveiro P-38 10 Aveiro Portugal
Josep-M. Poblet Departament de Quimica Universitat Rovira i Virgili Pc Imperial Tarraco 1 E-43005 Tarragona Spain lvan S. Podkorytov S. V. Lebedev Central Synthetic Rubber Research Institute Gapalskaya 1 St. Petersburg, 198035 Russia Sergey I. Pokutnyi State Maritime University Nikolaev 327025 Ukraine Giovanni Predieri Dipartimento di Chimica Generale ed Inorganica, Chimica Analytica, Chimica Fisica Universita di Parma Viale delle Scienze 1-43100 Parma ltaly Fabio Prestopino lnorganic Chemistry 1
List of Contributors
Chemical Center Lund University Box 124 S-22100 Lund Sweden Richard J. Puddephatt Department of Chemistry University of Western Ontario London, Ontario N6A 5B7 Canada Fabio Ragaini Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica Metallorganica e Analitica and CNR Center Via G. Venezian 21 1-20I33 Milano Italy Paul R. Raithby Department of Chemistry University of Cambridge Lensfield Road Cambridge CB2 1EW UK M. Carmen Ramirez de Arellano Grupo de Quimica Organometalica Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Facultad de Quimica Universidad de Murcia Aptdo. 4021 E-30071 Murcia Spain C.N.R. Rao CSIR Centre of Excellence in Chemistry Indian lnstitute of Science Bangalore 560012 India Dominique Roberto Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica, Metallorganica e Analitica and Centro CNR
xlv
Universita di Milano via G. Venezian 21 1-20133 Milano Italy Marie-Madeleine Rohmer Laboratoire de Chimie Quantique UMR 7551 CNRS Universite Louis Pasteur 4 rue Blaise Pascal F-67070 Strasbourg France Notker Rosch Lehrstuhl fiir Theoretische Chemie Technische Universitat Munchen D-85747 Garching Germany Jacky Rose Laboratoire de Chimie de Coordination (UMR 7513 CNRS) Institut Le Be1 Universite Louis Pasteur 4 rue Blaise Pascal F-67070 Strasbourg France Oriol Rossell Departament de Quimica Inorganica Universitat de Barcelona Marti i Franques 1 1 1 E-08028 Barcelona Spain ~
Rimma I. Rudy N . S. Kurnakov Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry Russian Academy of Sciences 3 1 Leninski Prospect 117907 MOSCOW, GSP-I Russian Federation Jean-Yves Saillard Laboratoire de Chimie du Solide el Inorganique Moleculaire
xlvi
List o j Contributors
UMR CNRS 651 1 Universitk de Rennes I F-35042 Rennes Cedex France Taro Saito Department of Chemistry Faculty of Science Kanagawa Univeristy Hiratsuka, Kanagawa 259-1293 Japan Ian D. Salter Department of Chemistry University of Exeter Stocker Road Exeter EX4 4QD UK Enrico Sappa Dipartimento di Chimica IFM Universiti di Torino Via P. Giuria 7 1-10125 Torino Italy Isabel Saura-Llamas Grupo de Quimica Organometalica Departamento de Quimica Inorginica Facultad de Quimica Universidad de Murcia Aptdo. 4021 E-30071 Murcia Spain Gunter Schmid Institut fur Anorganische Chemie FB 8 Universitat-GH Essen Universitatsstr. 5-7 D-45 1 17 Essen Germany Jorg J. Schneider Institut fur Anorganische Chemie Universitat GH-Essen UniversitatsstraBe 5-7
D-45 117 Essen Germany Francis Secheresse Institut Lavoisier Universite de Versailles-St-Quentin 45, Avenue des Etats-Unis F-78035 Versailles France Miquel Seco Departament de Quimica Inorganica Universitat de Barcelona Marti i Franques 1-1 1 E-08028 Barcelona Spain Gloria Segales Departament de Quimica Inorginica Universitat de Barcelona Marti i Franques 1-1 1 E-08028 Barcelona Spain John R . Shapley School of Chemical Sciences University of Illinois 505 South Mathews Avenue Urbana, IL 6 1801 USA You-Mao Shi Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragon Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC E-50009 Zaragoza Spain Arndt Simon Max-Planck-Institut fur Festkorperforschung HeisenbergstraBe 1 D-70569 Stuttgart Germany
List of Contributors
Ulrich Simon Universitat G H Essen Institut fur Anorganische Chemie Schutzenbahn 70 D-45141 Essen Germany Corine Simonnet-Jegat Institut Lavoisier Universite de Versailles-St-Quentin 45, Avenue des Etats-Unis F-78035 Versailles France Angelo Sironi Dipartimento di Chimica Strutturale e Stereochimica Inorganica Via Venezian 21 1-20133 Milano Italy Daniel J. Smawfield Department of Chemistry University of Liverpool P.O. Box 147 Liverpool L69 7ZD UK Joachim Strahle Institut fur Anorganische Chemie Eberhard-Karls-Universitat Auf der Morgenstelle 18 D-72076 Tubingen Germany Gunnar Svensson Arrhenius Laboratory Stockholm University S- 1069I Stockholm Sweden Cristina Tejel Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Arag6n Universidad de Zaragoza-CSIC
xlvii
E-50009 Zaragoza Spain Antonio Tiripicchio Dipartimento di Chimica Generale ed Inorganica, Chimica Analytica, Chimica Fisica Universita di Parma Viale delle Scienze 1-43100 Parma Italy Sergey P. Tunik St. Petersburg University Department of Chemistry Universitetskii pr. 2 St. Petersburg, 198904 Russia Renato Ugo Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica, Metallorganica e Analitica and Centro CNR Universita di Milano via G. Venezian 21 1-20133 Milano Italy Stefan Ulvenlund Department of Explorative Pharmaceutics Astra Draco AB P.O. Box 34 S-221 00 Lund Sweden Michael N. Vargaftik N. S. Kurnakov Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry Russian Academy of Sciences 3 1 Leninski Prospect 1 17907 MOSCOW, GSP-1 Russia Michael Veith Anorganische Chemie
xlviii
List of Contributors
Universitat des Saarlandes D-66123 Saarbrucken Germany
Ruprecht-Karls-Universitat Im Neuenheimer Feld 270 D-69 120 Heidelberg Germany
Alessandra Viale Dipartimento di Chimica Inorganica, Chimica Fisica e Chimica dei Materiali Universita di Torino Via P. Giuria 7 I- I0 125 Torino Italy
Stefan WeiBgraber Institut fur Synthesechemie Gerhard-Mercator-Universitat LotharstraRe 1 D-47048 Duisburg Germany
Jose Vicente Grupo de Quimica Organometalica Departamento de Quimica Inorganica Facultad de Quimica Universidad de Murcia Aptdo. 4021 E-3007 1 Murcia Spain
Ken Wade Department of Chemistry University of Durham Science Laboratories South Road Durham D H l 3LE UK Hubert Wadepohl Anorganisch-Chemisches Institut
Alan J . Welch Department of Chemistry Heriot-Watt University Edinburgh EH14 4AS UK Piero Zanello Dipartimento di Chimica Universita di Siena Pian dei Mantellini 44 1-53100 Siena Italy Roberto Zanoni Dipartimento di Chimica Universita degli Studi di Roma ‘La Sapienza’ piazzale Aldo Moro 5 1-00185 Rome Italy
1 Molecular Clusters
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
General Introduction F. Albert Cotton
When I was asked to write a general introduction to this book, at first I was hesitant. It was not my natural modesty, but a sense of the vastness of the subject that made me pause. When I introduced the term “metal atom cluster” in 1964”’ to designate “a finite group of metal atoms that are held together mainly, or at least to a significant extent, by bonds directly between the metal atoms, even though some nonmetal atoms may also be intimately associated with the clusterLz1,” the number of compounds that were known to satisfy this definition was small. I would estimate that there were no more than a dozen well-characterized examples of such compounds and perhaps fewer. Today I would hesitate to guess how many thousand cluster compounds there are, for fear of underestimating, and the range of types is now great. Over the past thirty years, growth in the field has been exponential. Perhaps even more than in other areas of inorganic chemistry, little if any of this growth could have occurred were it not for the enabling technique of X-ray crystallography. Unlike Werner complexes or certain other areas of chemistry (much of organic chemistry, for example), there are no simple structural prototypes to which the majority of clusters could be a priori assigned. For much of the field, structural knowledge, which of course is indispensable in understanding the chemistry, has to be obtained on a case-by-case basis by X-ray crystallography. As an historically interesting illustration of the impossibility of making progress in metal atom cluster chemistry without X-ray crystallographic structural data, I would draw attention to the case of the now largely forgotten chemist Kurt Lindner. In the 1920s Lindner and his students at Berlin University carried out many studies on the chemistry of the compounds of Mo”, W”, and Ta”, and in 1927 Lindnerl3I published a summary account of all their work in which he attempted to assign structures that he concocted by fusing together tetrahedra and/or octahedra via p 2 - and p,-halide ligands. These structures, of course, bear no resemblance to reality. A few more words about the definition of a cluster are appropriate. At the time the term was proposed, there had been occasional use of the word “cage”. This
4
I Molecular Clusters
1
2
3
term has to be (and has been) rejected for several good reasons. The word cage suggests the ideas of containment and encapsulating of something, but this is not characteristic, nor even possible, for many clusters. Clearly a triangle of metal atoms, being two dimensional, or even some three-dimensional clusters, such as butterflies, cannot surround anything and small closo-clusters such as tetrahedra do not have sufficient space inside to do so. If one wishes to consider a pair of bonded metal atoms to be a logical part of the cluster family, the term cage would clearly be inappropriate. Of course, there are some metal atom clusters that really do encapsulate non-metal atoms ( H , C, N usually), but this is a special characteristic of some rather than a general characteristic of all clusters. Another important point concerning the definition of a metal atom cluster compound is the requirement that there is significant direct bonding between the metal atoms. In the absence of this there is no justification for using a special word (cluster) since the molecule or ion would be simply the kind of polynuclear Werner complex already well known at the turn of the 19thCentury. Such a species is little more than the sum of its parts, apart from some weak, chemically insignificant, magnetic interactions. To illustrate, a molecule such as 1 is not a metal atom cluster compound, whereas 2, with its direct M-M bond, is. There are, of course, some ambiguous cases, such as the iron-sulfur clusters, 3. Whether there is significant “bonding directly between the metal atoms” of such clusters, at the Fe-Fe distances concerned, 2.6-2.7 A, is a moot point. Indeed, the word “cluster” is often used more broadly to designate aggregates in which any direct metal-to-metal bonding is unlikely. As so often happens in chemical nomenclature, and indeed in linguistic questions more generally, borderline areas arise, grow, and require elasticity in terminology. I cannot help saying that I do not think a compound with only metal to ligand contacts is appropriately called a “metal cluster”. But it happens. Despite its spectacular present, it should be remembered that metal atom cluster chemistry also has a very early origin. The earliest point to which I have been able to trace it is the period 1857-1861 when a Swedish chemist, Christian Bloomstrand, discovered the dichloride and dibromide of molybdenum. 14] Based on the significant observation that these contained two kinds of halogen, one precipitable by silver ion and the other not, in a 1 : 2 ratio, he concluded that the minimum acceptable molecular formula for these compounds was M03X6, and that this consisted of a
General Introduction
5
4
5
non-dissociating M O ~ X core ~ ~ and + two dissociable X- ions. It was not until many years later that suggestions were made by Werner”’ and WeinlandL6]as to the structures of these “dihalides.” Their suggestions are shown as 4 and 5. Both were based on the assumption that metal atoms could be joined together only by bridging ligands, direct metal-metal bonding being a non-existent concept in that period. The later suggestions of Lindner, which have already been mentioned, also assumed that the compounds are trinuclear, which we now know to be untrue. Other early discoveries in the field were reported in the period 1907-1913.”~s~91 There were the [ M ~ X I ~ J X ~compounds, . ~ H ~ O where M = Nb, Ta and X = C1, or Br. Even at this early time Chapin was able to show that “Ta6C114.7H20” in solution dissociated into a TagC112~+core and two C1- ions. Much later, X-ray work supplied structural details. One of the most impressive contributions to the early development of metal atom cluster chemistry was the work of C. Brosset,’12’a Swedish crystallographer who determined the structures of several compounds derived from “MoC12” and showed that they were based on a M06Clg4+ core, consisting of an octahedron of directly bonded Mo atoms (each to four others) with a p3-C1atom lying above each triangular face. It is remarkable that these complex structures were resolved as long ago as the early 1940s. For a number of years these octahedral Mg clusters remained the largest ones known. The advent of the first metal carbonyl cluster, Fe?(C0)12, was also long ago.“” Here again there was long uncertainty about its structure, resolved only by the work of Dahl in 1966,[141who was also responsible for clarifying the nature of the analogous Ru.,(C0)12 and O S ~ ( C O ) ~During ~ . [ ~ ~the ] same period of time Chini and coworkers[’”] prepared the first four-atom metal carbonyl cluster, Coq(C0)12, whose Rh and Ir analogues were soon to follow, and in 1963 Dahl showed the true formula and structure of the first six-atom cluster compounds of the carbonyl type, 1 6. Rh6 (co) Also in the 1960s the [Re3C112I3- cluster was discovered, and the name cluster was generally adopted. Thus, by about 1970, the stage had been set for the explosive development that has occurred over the past quarter of a century. The field is now so broad that an all-inclusive catalogue may no longer be feasible. We can, ‘‘‘9’
6
1 Molecular Clusters
however, mention a number of the major classes, as they are represented in the present contribution to the secondary literature. The two “classical” types of metal atom cluster chemistry that already existed (embryonically) some thirty years ago have both prospered and grown enormously. One of these encompasses clusters with the metal atoms in low to medium oxidation states together with halide, oxygen or chalcogenide ions. In addition to MogX8, Nb6X12, Re3X9 and their derivatives, there are now M03 and W3 based clusters, Chevrel phases, Re6 based clusters, Nb3 and Nb4 based clusters, and others. The other classical type embraces those containing metal atoms in very low (ca. 0) oxidation states, in which the ligands are most commonly CO. For this class some useful if not rigorous relationships between structures (closo, nido, arachno) and electron counts have been developed, beginning with “Wade’s rules”. To this second class a new subdivision has been added, namely, those into which main group elements have been incorporated. Sometimes they are encapsulated (C, N ) or they may be part of the polyhedron, for example in RCCo3(C0)9, where the C and Co atoms together define a tetrahedral cluster. Hydrido clusters and the corresponding anionic clusters have also become very numerous. Of course, metal atom clusters have become an important part of transition metal organometallic chemistry. Thus, isolobal species such as v6-C6H6Mo and Mo(CO)3 can be substituted for one another. Mixed metal clusters have also become very numerous and well known. These range from simple cases, where obvious isoelectronic replacements are made, as exemplified by C04(CO)12 and RhCo3 (CO)12, to very large and complex species such as [Ni9Pt3(C0)21HI3-. There is no end in sight to the possibilities for more mixed metal clusters. A recent innovation is the creation of very large clusters that have solid cores of close-packed metal atoms. An example is one containing a Pd33Ni9 core, covered with CO and PR3 molecules. The Pd atoms form a trigonal stack of hexagonally close packed atoms, with the Ni atoms at exterior corners. Another unusually interesting example[’71is a compound containing the anion [A177 {N(SiMe3)2)20l2-. This is not only a very large cluster but is an opening into the realm of main group metals. Another more recent development is the occurrence of clusters that are integral components of extended solid state structures. The Chevrel phases, already mentioned, are one example but there are numerous others, of which in some the clusters have a hetero atom in the center of the octahedron, e.g., ZrgNC115. Recently, it has been shown that the individual clusters can often be extracted and dissolved in suitable solvents. A major new sub-field of cluster chemistry is that of nanoparticles of metals in which there are no intentionally appended ligands. These are not molecular and thus neither homodisperse nor crystalline. Interest in all these newer types of clusters is often driven by their potential in terms of heterogeneous catalysis, and the unusual electrical, magnetic and spectro-
General Introduction
7
scopic properties they may possess. Therefore, the chemistry of metal clusters is a subject of practical as well as scientific interest. It is thus timely that this wideranging survey of the field should appear. The editors are to be congratulated for having assembled a group of authoritative reviewers, able to write as experts on the many areas of the subject. These 77 contributions constitute a remarkable encyclopedia on a fascinating, active and important subject.
References [I] F. A. Cotton, Inorg. Chem. 1964, 3, 1217. [2] This definition was later slightly modified to read “. . . . held together entively, mainly or at least ’ F. A. Cotton, Quurt. Reu. 1966, 20, 389; F. A. Cotton, to a significant extent ....” C McGruw-Hill Yeurbook of Science and Technology,1966. 131 K. Lindner, Zeits. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1927, 162, 203. 141 C. W. Bloomstrand, J. Prukt. Chem 1857, 71, 449; 1859, 77, 88; 1861, 82, 433. [ 5 ] A. Werner, “Neuere Anschuuungen uuf dem Gebiete der anorganischen Chemie,” Braunschweig, 1905. [6] R. Weinland, “Einjuhrung in der Chemie der Komplexuerbindungen,” 2”d Ed., 1924. [7] M. C. Chabrie, Comptes Rend. 1907, 144, 804. [8] W. A. Chapin, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1910, 32, 323. [9] H. S. Harned, J. Am. Chem. SOC.1913, 35, 1078. [lo] H. S. Harned, L. Pauling and R. B. Corey, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1950, 72, 5477. [ l l ] P. A. Vaughn, J. H. Sturtivant and L. Pauling, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1950, 72, 5477. [ 121 C. Brosset, Arkiu f o r Kemi, Miner. Geol. Band 20A, No. 7 (145); Band 22A, No. 11 (1946); Akriu, Band No. 1 (1949). [ 131 J. Dewar and H. 0. Jones, Proc. Roy. Soc. (London), 1905, A76, 558; 1907, A79, 66. 1141 C. H. Wei and L. F. Dahl, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1966,88, 1821; 1969, 91, 1351. [15] E. R. Corey and L. F. Dahl, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1961, 83, 2203. [16] P. Chini, V. Albano and S. Martinengo, J. Organomet. Chem. 1969, 16, 471. [I71 E. Ecker, E. Weckert and H. Schnockel, Nature 1997,387, 379.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.1 Molecular Clusters - An Overview Malcolm H. Chisholm
The term cluster takes on many meanings in chemistry. However, for the inorganic chemist the definition provided by F. A. Cotton‘’] some 30+ years ago still forms the basis for origins of this field. “A group of three or more metal atoms linked together at least in part by metal-metal bonding.” Today inorganic chemists have expanded the field of “clusters” to include complexes that contain a group of metal atoms that are electronically or magnetically interacting. In this way the term finds common usage in bioinorganic chemistry. Metal clusters abound in organometallic chemistry and one of the earliest fields of endeavor was in the area of metal carbony1 chemistry where clusters such as Fe3(C0)12 and C04(C0)12 have been known for 50 years or more. Interestingly these seemingly simple homoleptic species still find themselves topics of current debate in terms of their dynamic solution and solid-state behavior. 12,31 The subtle changes in their coordination properties within a series such as M3(C0)12, where M = Fe, Ru and Os, and mixed metal complexes there of, M2M’(C0)12, are not fully understood. The formation of unsaturated metal carbonyl fragments under thermolysis or photolysis led to the formation of higher nuclearity clusters often incorporating interstitial atoms such as carbide, nitride, hydride or oxide. Also it soon became apparent that the high reactivity of metal carbonyl cluster fragments could activate a wide variety of small organic molecules, particularly unsaturated species such as alkenes and alkynes. Indeed, carbon-carbon, carbon-hydrogen, and carbon-heteroatom bond cleavage reactions at metal carbonyl clusters became a field of study in itself. With access to increasingly higher nuclearity clusters the cluster-surface bonding analogy emerged. [41This is well exemplified by the bonding modes of ethene and benzene to two and three metal atoms, respectively. As the field of metal carbonyl cluster chemistry was expanding rapidly many other new classes of clusters joined the fold, in particular, gold phosphine clusters, metal-alkoxide, -thiolate, and -halide clusters of the early transition elements. The theories of bonding in metal clusters rapidly advanced aided by both computational procedures and conceptual ideas. Without a doubt the most significant in the latter
1.1 Molecular Clusters - An Overview
9
area was the isolobal principle, advanced by Hoffman and his coworkers.151Two species are isolobal when their frontier molecular orbitals have the same symmetry and the same number of electrons. So H+ and Au(PPh3)+ are isolobal, as are ( l ) , H, CH3, Mn(C0)5, CpW(CO)3; (2), :CH2, Fe(C0)4, PtL2, and Mo(OR)4 and (3) CH, CpM(CO)?,where M = Mo, W, CO(CO)I,P, W(OR)3. This view of bonding in clusters, one based on a fragment molecular orbital approach wherein fragments combine, leads not only to retrosynthetic analysis but also to new synthesis. This synthetic strategy was recognized early on by Stone and his coworkersL6]and is widely in use today in the synthesis of mixed main-group-transition-metal clusters and all types of hybrid clusters built from organometallic and non-organometallic fragments. As the classes of cluster compounds became more and more diverse, the forms of their chemistry expanded rapidly. Heteronuclear clusters could be tethered to supports and used as precursors to heterogeneous catalysts. Large clusters could be used in the synthesis of nanoparticles or linked together in an orderly manner to make new materials. As clusters grew in size and complexity and their characterization techniques became more routine then questions of their electronic structure took on new significance - how many metal atoms does it take to mimic the properties of a bulk metal? Meanwhile there are even more interesting properties quantum effects not recognized previously. The area of metal cluster chemistry starts to merge with that of colloids and indeed with solid-state chemistry as well as surface chemistry. For these and other reasons it is no wonder that metal cluster chemistry has attracted the attention of some of the brightest minds in science over the past several decades and continues to flourish in so many ways. In this volume some of the leading cluster chemists provide up-to-date reviews of their fields of research. The topics covered include virtually every aspect of cluster chemistry with the notable exception of early transition metal clusters with x-donor ligands, which was the subject of a recent book.”]
References [ I ] F. A. Cotton, Acc. Chem. Res. 1969, 2, 240. 121 L. J. Farrugia. Dalton Trans. 1997, 1783. [3] (a) B. F. G. Johnson, Dalton Tram. 1997, 1473; (b) B. E. Mann, Dalton Trans. 1997, 1457. [4] (a) J. T. Yates, Jr. and M. R. Albert, “The Surface Scientist’s Guide to Organometallic Chemistry”, ACS, Washington, D.C.; 1987; (c) E. L. Muetterties, Chem. Soc. Rev. 1982, If, 283. (51 R. Hoffmann, Angeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1982, 21, 711. [6] F. G. A. Stone, Angeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1984,23, 89. [7] Early Transition Metal Clusters with n-Donor Ligands, M. H. Chisholm, Ed., VCH Publishers, Inc., New York, NY; Weinheim, Germany and Cambridge, England.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.27 The Heteronuclear Cluster Chemistry of the Group 11 Metals - Some Recent Advances Iun D.Sulter
1.27.1 Introduction The first examples of compounds containing a bond between copper, silver or gold and another, different transition metal were a series of dimers reported by Nyholm and c o - w ~ r k c r s [in' ~1964. ~ ~ Although Nyholm rt ul['] also described the first mixedmetal gold cluster, [Au?Fe(C0)4(PPh?)?]," in the same year, the heteronuclear cluster chemistry of the Group 11 metals was very poorly developed before 1981, despite the great interest shown in the field of transition metal cluster compounds as a whole during that time period.[51However, since 1981, the chemistry of mixedmetal clusters containing copper, silver or gold has attracted considerable interest and a very large number of Group 1 1 metal heteronuclear clusters have now been synthesized and studied.[6p1 Most examples that are currently known contain one or more M(ER3) ( M = Cu, Ag or Au; E = As or P; R = alkyl or aryl) units and, in the vast majority of cases, the Group 11 atom(s) are ligated by organophosphine(s).["15' The M( ER3) fragments in this class of cluster compound can adopt either edge-bridging or face-capping bonding modes on subunits of transition metals (M') other than Group 11 metals (Fig. 1). These subunits normally either consist of a discrete trigonal planar Mi unit or an M i face of a larger polyhedron of M' atoms.[6-101 When two or more M( ER3) units are present in a mixed-metal cluster, the situation is complicated by the tendency for the coinage metals to adopt adjacent sites in the metal framework of the cluster. This tendency has been attributed to bonding interactions between the M atoms.[6 91 However, a reasonable number of examples
*The existence of a bonding interaction between the gold atoms [Au-Au 3.028(1) A] was not recognized until later.'"]
5 10
I Moleculur Clusters
(a)
PR3
(b)
M*-
M'
PR3
/"\ M'
M' M'
Figure 1. The (a) edge-bridging and (b) face-capping bonding modes adopted by M(PR3)
( M = Cu, Ag or Au; R = alkyl or aryl) units in heteronuclear clusters. M' is a transition metal other than a Group 11 metal.
of heteronuclear clusters which do not have the Group 11 metals in close contact have also been The combination of the fact that the M(ER3) units can adopt two different bonding modes and the fact that close contact between the Group 11 metals may or may not occur in species in which there is more than one coinage metal means that heteronuclear clusters containing M( ER3) moieties can adopt a wide variety of different skeletal geometries. Much of the interest shown in heteronuclear Group 11 metal clusters arises from the unusual bonding properties of the M( ER3) units, which are in marked contrast to those of almost all other transition metal fragments that are found in cluster compounds. Theoretical studies['7p191of the bonding capabilities of the M( ER3) units suggest that the differences in energy between the various structural types can be very small for mixed-metal clusters that contain these fragments. This theoretical prediction that the metal skeletons of Group 11 metal heteronuclear clusters should often show an unusual degree of flexibility is supported by experimental evidence obtained both from the solid state and from solution For example, heteronuclear Group 11 metal clusters with very similar stoichiometries can often exhibit markedly different metal core structures, skeletal isomerism can occur, both in the solid state and in solution, and the metal frameworks of this class of cluster compound are frequently stereochemically non-rigid in solution. This article describes some recent results in the field of Group 11 metal heteronuclear cluster chemistry from my group and co-workers. We have been particularly interested in the following topics: (i) Attempts to discover new types of stereochemical non-rigidity exhibited by the metal cores of heteronuclear Group 11 metal clusters in solution. (ii) Studies of the fluxional behavior of the bidentate diphosphine ligand 1,l '-his(dipheny1phosphino)ferrocenewhen it is attached to Group 11 metals in mixedmetal clusters. (iii) Investigations into how the nature of bidentate diphosphine ligands attached to gold atoms in heteronuclear clusters affect the skeletal geometry adopted by these cluster compounds.
1.27 The Heteronuclear Cluster Chernistrj? of the Group I 1 Metals
51 1
1.27.2 Investigations into the fluxional behaviour exhibited by group 11 metal heteronuclear clusters in solution 1.27.2.1 Dynamic behaviour involving a rearrangement of the metal cores of clusters containing square-based pyramidal A u ~ R uunits ~ 1.27.2.1.1 Introduction As stated in the previous section, dynamic behaviour involving intramolecular rearrangements of the metal skeletons of Group 11 metal heteronuclear clusters is relatively common, in marked contrast to the situation observed for almost all other transition metal clusters. which have metal frameworks that are stereochemically rigid in The mechanisms of these metal core rearrangements are, therefore, of considerable interest. A recent re-examination of some low-temperature H N M R spectroscopic datac2'] p3-H)(p-H)(p-Ph2ECH2E' Ph?)(CO)121 previously obtained for the clusters [Au~Ruq( ( E = E' = As or P; E = As, E' = P),[21,221 which all adopt a capped square-based pyramidal metal core geometry, suggested that these clusters all exhibit dynamic behavior, which involves an intramolecular rearrangement of the metal frameAlthough dynamic behaviour involving intramolecular metal core rearrangements is commonly observed for heteronuclear clusters containing two Au( ER3) units,[6.8.''I skeletal non-rigidity of a metal framework containing a square-based pyramidal AuzRui unit had not been previously reported. We were interested in studying this novel fluxional process further, but unfortunately no NMR spectra consistent with the ground state structures of any of the above hexanuclear clusters could be obtained, even at low temperatures. Therefore, we decided to attempt to synthesize other clusters with metal frameworks containing square-based pyramidal A u ~ R ufragments. ~
'
1.27.2.1.2 Dynamic behaviour of the clusters [AU2RU3(1UU-H)(1U~-COMe)(1U-L2)(C0)91 [Lz = Ph2P(CHz),PPh2 {n = 1 (1) or 5 (2)) or dppf (3) (dppf = 1,l '-bis(dipheny1phosphino)ferrocene)l The clusters [Au2Ru3(p-H)(p3-C0Me)(p-L2)(CO)9] [L? = PhzP(CH?),PPh2 {n = 1 (1) or 5 (2)}[231or dppf (3)[241] can be synthesized in ca. 30-55'%1 yield by treating a diethyl ether solution of [Ru3(p-H)3(,u3-COMe)(C0)9] with the complex [Au?(p-L~)Mez].They all adopt square-based pyramidal metal core structures, with the
5 12
I Moleculur Clusters
Figure 2. The molecular structure of [A~~Ru~(p-H)(p&OMe)(p-dppf)(C0)9] (3).L'41The C2, C' and C4 carbons on each of the phenyl rings have been omitted for clarity. The clusters [AuzRu3(p-H)(pu,-COMe){p-Ph2P(CH2),PPh2}(C0)9] [n = I (1) or 2 (2)] adopt similar square-based pyramidal skeletal geometries.[231
basal plane defined by the two Au atoms and two of the Ru atoms and the third Ru atom forming the apex of the pyramid (e.g. Fig. 2). In the ground state structure of [AuZRu~(p-H)(pu,-COMe)(p-Ph2PCHZPPh2)(CO),] ( l ) the , two methylene hydrogens are inequivalent and the two phenyl rings attached to each phosphorus atom are inequivalent, since there is no plane of symmetry through the two Au atoms in the square-based pyramidal A U Z R Umetal ~ NMR framework of the cluster (Fig. 3).[231At low temperatures, 'Hand I3C-{'H} spectra consistent with the ground state structure can be obtained. However, as the temperature is raised, the two separate methylene hydrogen signals in the 'HNMR spectrum broaden and then coalesce until, at the high-temperature limit, a single methylene proton resonance is observed. The two sets of signals in the I3C-{ 'H} NMR spectrum for each different type of phenyl carbon atom also broaden and then coalesce as the temperature increases and a single resonance is observed for each different type of phenyl carbon atom at the high temperature limit. Clearly, a fluxional process renders the two methylene hydrogens and the two phenyl rings attached to each phosphorus atom equivalent at high temperatures. This fluxional coupling is observed on the hydrido process must be intramolecular; since 31P-1H ligand signal in the ' H NMR spectrum at the high-temperature limit. The fluxional
1.27 Tlw Hetrronucliw C'luster Clieniistrj),of' tlze Group I I Met&
Figure 3. The metal core of the cluster [ A u 2 R u ~(p-H )( ,ul-COMe i(~(-Ph2PCH2PPh2(COlq] I l), showing the two inequivalent methylene proton environments and the inequivalence of the two phenyl rings attached to each phosphorus atom in the groundstate structure of the cluster. The carbonyl. hydrido and methoxycarbyne ligands have been omitted for clarity (reprinted by permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry from ref. 23).
5 13
U
Ru3
process occurring is thought" to involve an actual rearrangement of the squarebascd pyramidal AuzRui metal core of the cluster, together with a concomitant migration of the hydrido ligand around the Ru-Ru edges of the trigonal planar R u ~ fragment. The proposed mechanism for the rearrangement of the metal skeleton of [Au2Ru3(,u-H)(p3-COMe)(p-Ph2PCH2PPh2)(C0)9] involves a series of separate "windscreen-wiper'' movements of the diphosphine-digold unit, each of which must use one of the two gold atoms as a stationary pivot, while the other gold atom moves between the two remaining adjacent edge-bridging Ru-Ru sites (i.e. the second gold atom and the hydrido ligand exchange their edge-bridging sites). Successive movements of this type, with each gold atom acting as a pivot in turn results in a migration of the diphosphine-digold unit (and also the hydrido ligand) around ~ (Fig. 4). The the three edge-bridging Ru-Ru sites of the trigonal planar R u moiety proposed dynamic behaviour of the metal core of the cluster creates an effective mirror plane through the Ph2PCHZPPhz ligand, which is attached to the two gold atoms, and hence renders the two methylene hydrogens and the two phenyl rings attached to each of the phosphorus atoms equivalent on the NMR timescale. It is interesting that the edge-bridging Au( PPhl) unit in the cluster [AuRu3 {pi(Me2P)3CH}(CO)9( PPh3)J-[O?SCF3)is known to undergo migration around the *The observed variable-tempcrature ' H and " C - - { ' H ] N M R spectra can also bc explained by a fluxional process involving the two phosphorus atoms of the bidentatc diphosphine ligand Ph2PCH2PPh2 undergoing intramolecular site-exchange between the two gold atoms in the metal skeleton of the cluster. IIowever. this type of fluxional process is thought to be extremely unlikely.'231
514
1 Moleculur Clusters
Au fragment
0
RU
fragment
Figure 4. The mechanism proposed for the intramolecular metal core rearrangement of the squarebased pyramidal metal skelctons of the clusters [Au2Ru3(p-H)(p3-COMe)(p-Ll)(CO)9] [L? = Ph?P(CH2),PPhl (n = I or 5 ) or dppf]. This mechanism involves a series of separate “windscreenwiper” movements of the diphosphine-digold unit, each of which must use one of the two gold atoms (labeled with * on the figure) as a stationary pivot, while the other gold atom moves between the two remaining adjacent edge-bridging Ru-Ru sites (ie.the second gold atom and the hydrido ligand exchange their edge-bridging sites). Successive movements of this type, with each gold atom acting as a pivot in turn, result in a migration of the diphosphine-digold fragment (and also the hydrido ligand) around the three edge-bridging Ru-Ru sites in the trigonal planar R u j unit. The fluxional process creates an effective mirror plane through the bidentate diphosphine ligand, which is attached to the two gold atoms (reprinted by permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry from ref. 23).
three edges of the trigonal planar R u unit ~ in solution.[251This fluxional process is fast on the NMR timescale at ambient temperatures, but a 31P-{1H}N MR spectrum consistent with the ground state structure of the cluster was obtained at low temperatures. The variable-temperature NMR spectra of the clusters [Au2Ru3(pU-H)[Lz = PhzP(CH2)5PPh2 (2) or dppf (3)]are consistent with (p3-COMe)(p-L2)(CO)g] the A u ~ R umetal ~ frameworks of both compounds undergoing similar dynamic behaviour to that proposed for It is of interest to determine and compare the thermodynamic parameters for the ( l ) . [ 2 3 3 2 4 1
1.27 The Heteronuclecir Cluster C l ~ e ~ ~ i softlze t r j ~ Group I I Metals
5 15
intramolecular metal core rearrangements of the clusters ( l ) , (2) and (3). Bandshape analysis of variable-temperature "C-{ ' H ) NMR spectra for (1)-(3) and also of ' H NMR spectra for (1)* affords the thermodynamic parameters presented in Table 1. It is well established that energies quoted in terms of AGI values are less prone to systematic errors than the other parameters calculated by band-shape analysis and, therefore, AGT values are normally used for comparison purposes.[261 Table 1 shows that the magnitude of AGt for the metal core rearrangement of (1) determined from H NMR spectroscopy is identical within experimental error to that obtained from I3C-{ ' H ) NMR spectroscopy. Interestingly, the values of AGt for the skeletal rearrangements of (2) (58.6 ? 0.2 kJmol-') and (3) (58.9 ? 0.1 kJ mo1-I) are identical within experimental error, whereas the magnitude of AGt for the same fluxional process in (1) (67.1 & 0.2 kJmol-') is ca. 8 kJ mol-' greater. It is possible that the greater stereochemical demands of the Ph2PCH2PPh2 ligand compared with those of dppf and Ph?P(CH2)5PPh2hinder the migration of the two Au atoms around the trigonal planar Ru-i unit and so cause the magnitude of AG+ for this fluxional process to be considerably greater for (1) than the AG' values observed for (2) and (3). If this is the case and the relative stereochemical demands of the bidentate diphosphines are important, then it is perhaps rather surprising[271that the ferrocenyl backbone of dppf would seem to be exhibiting a very similar degree of flexibility to that of the aliphatic pentamethylene backbone of the Ph?P(CHZ)TPPh2 ligand. The magnitudes of AS: for intramolecular fluxional processes in organometallic complexes are frequently found to be between +20 and -20 J K-' mo1-'[281and all of the ASt values calculated for 11)-(3) (Table 1) lie in this range. This observation is consistent with the proposed intramolecular nature of the fluxional processes which (1)-(3) undergo in solution. The skeletal rearrangement mechanism proposed for (1)-(3) (Fig. 4) would also explain the single methylene proton environments observed in the low-temperature ' H N M R spectra of each of the clusters [Au2Ru4(p3-H)(p-H)(p-Ph2ECH2E'Ph2)(CO)l?]( E = E' = As or P; E = As, E' = P) (see Sec. 1.27.2.1.1). It is interesting that the proposed metal core rearrangement in each of the above clusters must have a very much smaller value of AG* than those observed for (1)-(3), since a ' H NMR spectrum consistent with the ground-state structure could not be obtained for any of the hexanuclear clusters. even at -90 0C.[201
'
1.27.2.1.3 Dynamic behaviour of the cluster [ A u z R u ~ ( ~ u ~ - H ) ( ~ - H ) ( ~ ~ ( - ~ , ~ - P ~ z P C ~(4) H~PP~~)(CO)IZI The metal core of the recently synthesized hexanuclear cluster [Au2Ru4(p3-H)(p-H)(, L L - ~ , ~ - P ~ ? P C CO) ~ H I~21P(4) P~ contains ~ ) ( a square-based pyramidal Au2Ru3
* It was not possible to derive the thermodynamic parameters for the skeletal rearrangements of (2)
and (3) from variable-temperature ' H NMR spectra.""241
ASt(JK-' mol-I)
7.5 10.5b 14.8 & 15.2 -19.9 & 11.1 20.2 i 8.0
AGt(kJ mol-')
67.1 f 0.2b 61.0 & 0.2 58.9 f 0.1 58.6 & 0.2
69.3 f 3.3b 71.4 f 4.1 52.9 f 3.2 64.1 i 2.2
AHt(kJmo1-I)
"Calculated at 298.15 K by band-shape analysis of selected phenyl carbon signals in variable-temperature I3C-{'H} NMR spectra, unless otherwise stated. bCalculated at 298.15 K by band-shape analysis of the methylene hydrogen signals in variable-temperature ' H NMR spectra.
(2) [ A u z R u(p-H)(p3 ~ -COMel { P - P ~ ~ P ( C H Z ) , P1(COhI P~Z (3) [AuzRu3(p-H)(p3-COMe)(~-dppf)(CO)91
(1) IAurRu3(p-H)(p3-COMe)(pu-Ph2PCH2PPh2)(C0)9I
Cluster
Table 1. Energy parameters" for the intramolecular metal core rearrangement observed in solution for the clusters [Au2Ru3(pH)(p3-COMe)(pL-L2)(C0)p] [L2 = Ph*P(CH*),PPhZ ( n = 1 or 5)[231 or dppf {dppf = I . l'-bis(diphenylphosphino)ferr~cene}~~~~] (Fig. 4).
2:
n,
5
Q 2
E
n
55
m
2
1.27 The Hetrronucleur C1u.ster Chemistrjy of the Group I I Metuls
5 17
Figure 5. The molecular structure of IA u2 Ruq ( p3-H ) (p-W ) ( p- 112-Ph?PCs Hq PPh2)(CO)I 21 (4).'2 'I There is no planc of symmctry through the two gold atoms in the capped square-based pyramidal AuzRuq metal core of the cluster, so the two phenyl rings on each phosphorus atom of the bidentate diphosphine ligand are not equivalent in the ground-state structure. The two hydrido ligands have been omitted for clarity. One of these hydrido ligands is thought to occupy an edge-bridging site across the Ru(2)-Ru(3) vector and the other is thought to cap the Ru(l)Ru(2)Ru(4)face of the cluster's metal skeleton.'2y1
unit and the two sets of phenyl rings on each phosphorus atom are inequivalent (Fig. 5).[291However, at ambient temperatures, the I3C-{ 'H} NMR spectrum of (4) shows a single resonance for each different type of phenyl carbon atom, which is consistent with the metal core of the cluster undergoing a similar rearrangement in solution to that proposed for (1)-(3) (Fig. 4). The intramolecular metal core rearrangement of (4) must be accompanied by a concomitant fluxional process involving site-exchange of the two hydrido l i g a n d ~ .Although ~ ~ ~ ] some broadening* is observed for the phenyl carbon atom signals in the I3C- { ' H } NMR spectra at low temperatures, no spectrum consistent with the ground-state structure of (4) could be obtained. Thus, the magnitude of AGI for the metal core rearrangement in (4) must
*The broadening observed in the low-temperature 13C-{ 'H} N M R spectra may be associated with the slowing down of the rotation of the phenyl rings around the P-C bonds rather than the slowing down of the intramolecular metal core rearrar~gement.'~~]
518
I Molecular Clusters
be considerably lower than those observed for (1)-(3), which is consistent with the {E = observations for the clusters [Au2Ru4(p3-H)(p-H)(p-Ph2ECH2E'Ph2)(C0)12] E' = As or P; E = As, E' = P) (Sec. 1.27.2.1.2),[231which are closely related to (4).
1.27.2.1.4 Dynamic behaviour of other clusters with metal frameworks containing square-based pyramidal A u ~ R uunits ~ Although to the best of our knowledge, the paper describing the clusters [Au2Ru3(p-H)(p3-COMe){p-Ph2P(CH2),PPh2}(C0)~] (n = 1 or 5)[231was the first specific report of the stereochemical non-rigidity of a cluster containing a squarebased pyramidal A u ~ R uunit, ~ it is interesting to look back at the NMR data described in the literature for other clusters with metal skeletons containing similar A u ~ R uunits ~ to see if there is any evidence for the novel fluxional process that (1)(4) undergo. 161 has a metal core structure conThe cluster [Au2RugC(pu-Ph2PCH2PPh2)(Co) sisting of a square-based pyramidal A u ~ R uunit ~ and an Rug octahedron, containing an interstitial carbido ligand, fused together by sharing a common R u face.[301 ~ Although the two methylene hydrogens and the two phosphorus atoms in the Ph2PCH2PPh2 ligand, which is attached to the two gold atoms, are both inequivalent in the ground-state structure, a triplet is reported for the methylene hydrogen signal in the ' H NMR spectrum of the cluster and a singlet is reported for the 3'P-{1H} NMR spectrum. The authors[301do not comment on their NMR spectroscopic data, but an intramolecular rearrangement of the square-based pyramidal A u ~ R umoiety ~ in the octanuclear cluster similar to that observed for (1)-(4) (Fig. 4) (Sec.s 2.1.2 and 2.1.3) would explain the apparent equivalence of the two methylene hydrogens and the two phosphorus atoms on the NMR timescale in solution. The variable-temperature I3C-{ 'H} NMR spectra observed for the cluster [Au2Ru3(p-H)(p3-COMe)(C0)9( PPh3)2] are also consistent with the square-based pyramidal A U Z R Umetal ~ skeleton undergoing an intramolecular rearrangement in However, the spectra can equally well be explained by carbonyl ligand site-exchange, which is a well established fluxional process for transition metal organometallic
1.27.2.2 Dynamic behaviour involving the bidentate diphosphine ligand 1,l '-bis(dipheny1phosphino)ferrocene (dppf ) attached to the group 11 metals in heteronuclear clusters 1.27.2.2.1 Introduction Our interest in studying the fluxional behaviour of the dppf ligand attached to coinage metals in Group 11 metal heteronuclear clusters was prompted by a report of a
1.27 The Heteronuclcw Cluster Chemistrj?of the Group 11 Metals
519
variable-temperature NMR spectroscopic study on the cluster (Au?Ruq(p-dppf)(C0)12BH].[341The dppf ligand attached to the gold atoms in the hexanuclear cluster undergoes dynamic behaviour involving inversion at the two phosphorus atoms and concomitant twisting of the two cyclopentadienyl rings. This dppf ligand fluxionality was observed to be in concert with a “rocking” motion of the two Au atoms with respect to the Ru4B core of the cluster and the two processes were found to be mutually dependent. Therefore, we wished to investigate the dynamic behaviour of the dppf ligand when it bridges two Group 11 metals in a heteronuclear cluster further. As well as the compound [AuzRu3(p-H)(p3-COMe)(p-dppf)(C0)9] (3):which is discussed in Sec. 1.27.2.I .2, we were interested in studying systems with metal frameworks containing trigonal bipyramidal or distorted trigonal bipyramidal M2Rul ( M = Cu, Ag or Au) units, since these species are also known to have stereochemically non-rigid metal cores in solution.[3 5 , 3 6 1 However, the intramolecular core rearrangements of the latter type of cluster involve a very different mechanism to that previously discussed for (3).The two coinage metals in the trigonal bipyramidal or distorted trigonal bipyramidal MzRu3 units in the ( M = Cu; Ag or Au)[”] and metal cores of the clusters [M2Ru4H2(pu-dppf)(C0)12] ~~’ between the two distinct sites ( i e . axial [Au2Ru3(p3-S)(p-dppf) ( C O ) S ] [exchange and equatorial in the ground-state metal framework structures) via a mechanism which is thought to involve a restricted Berry pseudo-rotation (Fig. 6).[35p371
1.27.2.2.2 The dynamic behaviour of the clusters IAU2RU3(iu-H)(iu3-COMe)(iu-dPPf)(C0)91 (31, [ M ~ R ~ ~ H ~ ( ~ ~ - ~ PIM P= ~ )cu ( C(51, O Ag ) ~ (6) ~ Ior A U (711, [AU2RU3(iu3-S)(iu-dPPf)(C0)91(8) and IAuCuRu4(iu3-H)2(iu-dPPf)(C0)121 (9) The clusters [M2RuqH+dppf)(C0)12] [ M = Cu (S), Ag (6) or Au (7)][27,381 and [A~?Ru3(p~-S)(p-dppf)(C0)9][~~’ (8) all have metal frameworks which contain trigonal bipyramidal or distorted trigonal bipyramidal M z R u ~groups (Figs. 7, 8 and 9). Variable-temperature ‘ H and 3’P-( ‘ H f N M R spectroscopic studies show that the two coinage metals in each cluster still undergo intramolecular site-exchange, even though they are linked together by the dppf ligand.[24*27,381 For clusters 15)-(7), this metal core rearrangement must be accompanied by a concomitant process involving the site-exchange of the two hydrido ligands. The spectra also show that, in each case, the dppf ligand is undergoing a second fluxional process, involving inversion at the phosphorus atoms and a concomitant twisting of the cyclopentadienyl rings. Figure 10 illustrates how the two fluxional processes exchange the hydrogen atoms of the cyclopentadienyl rings between different environments and a typical series of variable-temperature spectra are illustrated for (6) in Fig. 1 1 .[381 The 2D EXSY ‘ H N M R spectrum of (5) iFig. 12) also clearly shows how the cyclopentadienyl hydrogen atoms in the copper-containing cluster are exchanged by a combination of the metal core rearrangement and dppf ligand
520
1 Molrculur Clusters
Figure 6. The restricted Berry pseudo-rotation mechanism proposed for the intramolecular metal core rearrangements observed in solution for the clusters [ M ~ R U ~ H ~ ( C O ) ~=~Cu, L ~Ag ] or Au; (M L = a variety of monodentate phosphine ligands or L2 = a variety of bidentate diphosphine ligands). The mechanism exchanges the two coinage metals in sites M( 1) and M(2) of the trigonal bipyramidal M2Rul unit in the metal skeletons of the clusters oio a square-based pyramid a1 inter' mediate (reprinted by permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry from ref. 36).
fluxional process.[271The dppf fluxion is also occurring in addition to the intramolecular metal core rearrangement (Sec. 1.27.2.1. l ) for (3). The thermodynamic parameters for the two distinct fluxional processes in (3) and (5)-(8) have been calculated by band-shape analysis of variable-temperature NMR spectra where possible (Table 2).[243271 All of the values of AS$ in Table 2 are between -20 and +20 J K-' mol-', which supports the proposed intramolecular nature of the dppf ligand fluxionality and the metal core Table 2 shows that the values of AGi obtained for the intramolecular metal core rearrangements of (5)-(7) decrease in the order of descending Group 11 metal congeners, as has been previously observed for a number of analogous clusters. The value of AGI obtained for ( 5 ) is significantly larger than the ranges of ca. 40-43 kJ mol-'
Figure 7. The molecular structure of [ C U ~ R U ~ [ ~ - H ) ~ ( p d p pf )(CO),r](5).showing the capped trigonal bipyramidal skeletal geometry. Thc structure of the analogous silver-containing cluster [A~~RUJ(~I,-HI~(//-~~~~)(CO)I~~ (6) is thought to be very similar and that of the closely related trimetallic species [AuCuRul (/ci-H)li/i-dppf)(<’0)121 (9) is also very similar, except that there is a gold atom in the site of Cu(2). rather than a copper atom (reprinted by permission of‘ Elsevier Science Ltd. from ref. 38).
Figure 8. The molecular structure of [ A u ~ R u ~ ( / / I -/ H ~ -)HI ) ( / L dppfhC0)121 ( 7 ) .One of the equatorial Au-Ru [Au(1 )-Rur2)] distances is too long (Au. .Ru 3.558 A! for any significant bonding interaction, so the A u ~ R u ~ fragment in the metal core of the cluster is distorted towards a square-based pyramidal geometry Therefore, the A u z R u ~skeletal geometry of the cluster is intermediate between capped trigonal bipyramidal and capped squarebased pyramidal (i.c,. intermediate between gold atom arrangements A and B in Fig. 13) 1 reprinted by permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry from ref. 27).
d
522
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 9. The molecular structure of [ A U ~ R U ~ ( ~ ~ - S ) ( / L(S),‘”’ -~P~ show~)(CO)~] ing the trigonal bipyramidal Au2Ru3 skeletal geometry.
Figure 10. Schematic representations of the two dynamic processes which the clusters [ M ~ R u ~p-H z ( dppf)(CO),z][M = Cu ( 5 ) ,Ag (6) or Au (7)]undergo in solution. In each case, the iron atom and the phenyl rings of the dppf ligand have been omitted for clarity. (a) The intramolecular metal core rearrangement, which exchanges the two coinage metals ( M and M’) in each of (5)--(7)between the two distinct sites [eg Cu(1) and Cu(2) in Fig. 71 in the capped trigonal bipyramidal or distorted capped trigonal bipyramidal metal skeletons of the clusters, shown when the dppf ligand is stereochemically rigid, (b) the effect of the intramolecular metal core rearrangement on the cyclo-
1.27 The Heteronudear Cluster Chemistry of the Group 11 Metals
523
HA
Figure 10 (continurtl) pentadienyl (Cp) hydrogens when the dppf ligand is stereochcmically rigid, (c) the inversion at the phosphorus atoms and twisting of the cyclopentadienyl rings observed for the dppf ligand. At the low-temperature limit. Cp hydrogens HA--HHare all inequivalent, so eight signals are observed in the ' H NMR spectra of (5)and (6) iey. Fig. 11). However. at intermediate temperatures, the skeletal rearrangements of (6! and (7) are fast on the NMR timescale, but the dppf ligand fluxional process cannot be observed. Thus, the site-exchange of Group 1 1 metals M and M'causes exchange also to occur between the following pairs of Cp hydrogens, HA HH, Hg ++ HG, Hc HF and Ho 4 HE and four Cp hydrogen peaks are observed in the ' H NMR spectra of (6) (Fig. 1 1 ) and (7) at -60 or -50 "C. At the high-temperature limit, both the metal core rearrangement and the dppf ligand fluxion are fast on the NMR timescale. The latter dynamic process produces effective mirror planes through both of the two C S H ~ units P of the dppf ligand and exchanges the pairs of protons HA HD, HB tf Hc. HE Hf13HI. HG. Therefore, the combination of the two fluxional processes renders the set of four hydrogens H A , HI), Hb and HH all equivalent and the set of four hydrogens He. Hc. HI. and HG all equivalent on the NMR timescale and so two signals due to Cp hydrogens are visible in the ' H NMR spectra of(5)-(7) at ambient temperatures and above (q. Fig. 1 I ) (reprinted by permission of Elsevier Scicnce Ltd. from ref. 38).
-
-
-
-
524
I Moleculur Clusters
Ii
(c)
50
,
v--
45
40
35
,
3 0
Figure 11. The signals due to the Cp hydrogens in the ' H N M R spectra of IAgZRLi4(p3-H)( p d p p f )(CO)12]($4 recorded at various temperatures. (a) The high-temperature limiting spectrum at +40 " C , with both the dppf ligand fluxion and the skeletal rearrangement fast on the N M R timescale, (b) at -50 "C, with the skeletal rearrangement still fast on the N M R timescale. but the dppf ligand fluxion not observed, (c) the low-temperature limiting spectrum at -100 " C , when both the skeletal rearrangement and the dppf ligand fluxion are not observable on the N M R timescale (reprinted by permission of Elsevier Science Ltd. from ref. 38).
1.27 The Heteronuclear Cluster Chemistry of the Group 11 Met&
525
3.5
1.0
1.5 6
i.0
i.5
5.5
5.0
4.5
4.0
3.5
s
Figure 12. The signals due to the cyclopentadienyl hydrogens in the 2D EXSY ' H NMR spectrum of the cluster [Cu2Ru4(p3-H)2(p-dppf)(C0)12] ( 5 ) in CD2Clz solution, recorded at -70 "C. The spectrum clearly shows which cyclopentadienyl hydrogens are exchanged by a combination o f the intramolecular metal core rearrangement process and dppf ligand fluxion. All of the hydrogen atoms (group I ) which produce signals A, B. F and H are being exchanged by a combination o f the two fluxional processes and so are all of the hydrogen atoms (group 2) which give rise to peaks C , D. E and G. However, there is clearly no exchange between any of the hydrogen atoms belonging to group 1 and any of those in group 2. The signals marked with * are due to the solvent. and the other very small peaks which are visible are either spinning sidebands of the solvent signals or they are due to trace impurities (reprinted by permission o f the Royal Society of Chemistry from ref. 27).
and ca. 40-45 kJmol-', which have been previously reported for skeletal rearrangements in the analogous clusters [Cu2Ru4(p3-H)2(CO)12L2]( L = a variety of monodentate phosphine and phosphite l i g a n d ~ ) ' ~and ~ ] [Cu2Ru4(p3-H)2(p-L2)(C0)12][L2 = PhzE(CH2),,PPhl ( E = P, n = 1, 5 and 6; E = As, n = 1 or 2) or c ~ s - P ~ ~ P C H = C H P Prespectively. ~ ~ ] , [ ~ ~ ] However, the size of AGI measured for ( 5 ) is comparable to that of 48.1 0.2 kJ mol-' calculated by band-shape analysis at 298 K for the similar fluxional process in [Cu2Ru4(p3-H)2{p-Ph2P(CH2)2PPh2}-
AGt(kJ mol-')
AS7 (J mo1-l K-I )
ASi(Jmol-lK-l)
AHt(kJ mol-')
AH~(kJmol-')
"Calculated at 298.15 K by band-shape analysis of the cyclopentadienyl hydrogen signals in variable-temperature 'HN M R spectra, unless otherwise stated. bThe dppf ligand undergoes a fluxional process, which involves inversion at the phosphorus atoms together with a twisting of the cyclopentadienyl rings (Fig. 10). 'Calculated at 298.15 K by band-shape analysis of variable temperature 31P-{IH} N M R spectra. "The free energy of activation for this process in [Au2R&(p3-H)(p-H)(p-dppf)(C0)l~] (7) is too low for either the low-temperature limiting ' H NMR spectrum or a low-temperature limiting "P-{'H} N M R spectrum with narrow linewidths to be observed, even at 173K. Therefore. band-shape analysis of the variable-temperature ' H or 31P--{' H } N M R spectra to obtain parameters for the metal core rearrangement was not possible for (7).However, the value of AGi for the metal core rearrangement in (7) has been estimated from the coalescence temperature in the variable temperature ilP-{ 'H}N M R spectra as ca. 33 kJ mol-' at the coalescence temperature of ca. 193 K.L3*1 'Thc metal skeleton of [AuCuRuq(~3-H)z(p-dppf)(C0)12] ( 9 )is stereochemically rigid in solution at ambient temperatures. 'No NMR spectra consistent with the ground-state structure of [Au2Ru3(p3-S)(p-dppf)(CO)q](8, could be obtained, even at low temperatures. Therefore, no value of AGI for the intramolecular metal core rearrangement of (81could be obtained.["1 'Calculated at 298.15 K by band-shape analysis of variable-temperature "C-{ IH} NMR spectra.
Cluster
f
AGi (kJ mol-' )
(b) Intramolecular rearrangement of the cluster's metal core.''
Cluster
(a) I , 1'-Bis(dipheny1phosphino)ferrocene(dppf) ligand fluxion.b
Table 2. Energy parameters" for the fluxional processes observed in solution for the clusters [MMrRuH2(p-dppf)(C0)12]( M = M ' = Cu, Ag or Au; M= Cu, M' = Au)~"], [Au2Ru3(p-H)(p3-COMe)(p-dppf)(C0)9] i24i and [Au2R~~(p~-S)(dppf)(CO)s].~~~j
'r
cr\
1.27 The Hetesonuckecir Cluster Chernistsj?of the Group I I Metals
527
(CO)12].[351 The only previously reported values of AGi for metal core rearrangements in copper-containing clusters, which are larger than that observed for (5) are 52.8 f 0.1 kJmol-I (for n = 3) and 52.1 k 0.1 kJmol-' (for n = 4) for I C U ~ R U ~ The magnitude of AGI for the skeletal (p3-H)2(~-P~~P(CH~),,PP~~}(CO)I~].[~~] rearrangements in the silver-containing cluster (6) is comparable to those of 40 k 1 kJmol-' and 40.4 k 0.1 kJmol-I measured for (Ag2Ru4(pc,-H)2(CO)12( PPh3)2]'361and [Ag2Ru4(/i3-H)2(,u-Ph2P(CH2)3PPh2}(C0)12],[351 respectively. It is significantly larger than the range of AGi values of ca. 32-36 kJ mol-' observed for [Ag2Ru4(p3-H)2(p-L~)(C0)12] [Lz= Ph?P(CHz),PPh2 (n = 1 or 2) or cis-PhzPCH= C H P P ~ Z ]51. [The ~ only previously reported values of AGt for skeletal rearrangements in silver-containing clusters that are larger than that observed for (2) are 41.5 f 0.1 kJmol-' (for n = 4) and 42.2 f 0.1 kJmol-' (for n = 6) for [AgzRuq( p u , - H ) 2 ( ~ i - P h ~ P ( C H ~ ) n P P h ~ } j C 0and ) 1 ~45 ] ' 3ks 11 kJ mol-' for [Ag2Ru4(p3-H)2(CO)l2(PR3)2] ( R = Pr' or Cy).[""' Accurate quantitative comparisons of the magnitudes of A@ for metal core rearrangements in gold-containing clusters are very difficult, since the free energies of activation are normally too small for wellresolved low-temperature NMR spectra to be ~ b t a i n e d . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ] The AGi values calculated for the dppf ligand fluxion (Table 2) clearly show that this process and the metal core rearrangement are independent for each of the clusters, (3) and (5)-(8), which is in marked contrast to the two mutually dependent processes reported[341for [Au2Ru4ipu-dppf)(C0)12BH]. The values of AGi for the dppf ligand fluxionality in clusters (5)-(8) all lie in the range 47.0 _+ 0.2 to 51.5 f 0.1 kJ mol-', so it would appear that the nature of the coinage metals that the dppf ligand is attached to and the exact nature of the structure of the metal framework of a cluster do not have a great influence on the dynamic behaviour of the dppf ligand. However, the magnitude of AGt for the dppf fluxion in (3) (45.2 0.1 kJmol-I) is ca. 2 kJ mol-' lower than the bottom end of the above range. This may reflect the fact that the dppf ligand is attached to a square-based pyramidal A u ~ R uunit ~ (Fig. 2) rather than to a trigonal bipyramidal or distorted trigonal bipyramidal M2Ru3 ( M = Cu, Ag or Au) moiety (Figs. 7-9). We also wished to establish whether or not the dppf ligand fluxion would occur in a cluster with a stereochemically rigid metal core, so we synthesized the trimetallic 121 (9) ( Fig. 7).[271 The variable-temperature species [AuC~Ru~(p~-H)~(p-dppf)(CO) IH NMR spectra of (9) demonstrate that the dppf ligand undergoes the same fluxional process as that observed for (3) and ( 5 ) - ( 8 ) . Band-shape analysis of these NMR spectra afforded a value of A($ of 49.2 0.2 kJmol-' for the dppf ligand fluxion (Table 2). This ACi value lies in the range observed for the same fluxion in (5)-(8) (Table 2), so it would appear that whether or not the dppf ligand is bonded to a cluster metal framework that is stereochemically non-rigid in solution does not have a large effect on the magnitude of ACT for the inversion and twisting process.
528
1 Moleculur Clusters
1.27.3 The use of sterically demanding bidentate diphosphine ligands to control the metal core geometries adopted by clusters containing A u ~ R u ~ units 1.27.3.1 Introduction As discussed in Sec. 1.27.1, the energy differences between different metal core structures can be very small for some Group 11 metal heteronuclear clusters. Species containing two Au( ER3) ( E = As or P; R = alkyl or aryl) units bonded to other transition metals exhibit a wide range of skeletal geometries,[6-s1 but four main structural types can be identified. These structural types depend on whether the two Au(ER3) groups are edge-bridging or face-capping and whether or not there is close contact between the gold atoms. The most commonly observed metal core structure has two face-capping Au( ER3) fragments in close contact (Gold atom arrangement A in Fig. 13).[6-81Digold heteronuclear clusters containing two Au(ER3) units bridging different metal-metal edges with the gold atoms in close contact (Gold atom arrangement B in Fig. 13) are much rarer and most known examples have the Au atoms linked together by bidentate ligands.[6-81We wished to investigate how digold clusters could be forced to adopt skeletal geometries containing gold atom arrangement B (Fig. 13) by synthesizing two series of analogous clusters ligated by bidentate diphosphines of varying stereochemical demands.
Au fragment
0 Other transition metals fragment M' Figure 13. Two possible arrangements for the two Au atoms in a digold heteronuclear cluster. The trigonal planar M; fragment can either be a discrete three-metal unit or one face of a larger polyhedron of transition metals M' other than Group 11 metals. (a) Au arrangement A. (b) Au arrangement B (reprinted by permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry from ref. 23).
1.27 The Hcteroriuclear Cluster Chemistrj~q f t h e Group I I Metals
529
1.27.3.2 Structures of clusters of general formula [Au2Ru4(p3-H)(p-H)(,u-L2)(C0)12] [L2 = Ph2P(CH2),PPh2 (n = 1 or 2), cis.-Ph2PCH=CHPPh2, 1,2-Ph2PC~H4PPh2or 1,l '-bis(dipheny1phosphino)ferrocene (dppf )] Table 3 lists the metal core structures adopted by the clusters [Au2Ru4(p3-H)(p-H)(CO)I ? ( PPh3)2]'"' and [Au2Ru4(p3-H)(p-H)jp-L2)(CO) 121 [L2 = Ph2P(CHZ),PPh2 (n = 1 or 2),[2'1C ~ S - P ~ ~ P C H = C H P 1,2-Ph2PC6H4PPh2[291 P ~ ~ , ' ~ ~ , ~ ~ ]or dppflZ7]].It can be seen that the formal replacement of the two PPhi groups bonded to the gold PPh3)zj by any of the bidentate diphosphine atoms in [Au2Ru4(p3-H)(p-H)(COlj2( ligands L2 results in a change in the metal framework structure of the cluster. The ligands Ph2PCHlPPh2, cis-Ph?PCH=CHPPhl and 1, ~ - P ~ ~ P C ~ all H ~force PP~I ~ observed in the metal skeleton of the PPh3the trigonal bipyramidal A u ~ R uunit containing species (Fig. 14) to change to gold arrangement B (e.g. Fig. 5 ) . However, the ligands Ph2P(CH2)2PPh2 and dppf seem to be less stereochemically demanding in this context and they both distort the trigonal bipyramidal AuzRui unit in [Au2Ru4(p3-H)(p-H)(C0)12( PPh3)2]towards a square-based pyramid, so that one of the equatorial Au-Ru (Au(1). . .Ru(2) in Fig. 8) distances is too long for any
Table 3. The different gold atom arrangements adopted by the Au2Rui units in the A u ~ R umetal ~ f r a m e w o r k s o f t h e c l u s t e r s [ A ~ ~ R ~ ~ ( ~ ~ , - H ) ~ ~ ~[Lz - H=~ Ph>P(CH2J,PPhl ( ~ ~ - L ~ ) ~ C O ~( ~ n= ~ ]1 or 2),I2I1 dppf,["] tu-PhzPCH=CHPPh? Ii5 41' and 1,2-Ph2PC6H4PPh2["1] dnd IAu2Ru4(p7-H)(pU-H)(CO)12(PPhi),] 1 5 Cluster
Gold atom arrangement for the AuzRu3 unit (Fig. 13)
IAU~R~?(/~,-H)(~-H)(CO)I~~PP~~)~~ [Au2Ru4(pu,-H)(pu-H) (pu-PhzP(CH?)zPPhz) (CO)12 I [AU~RU~(~~-H)(~U-H,(~-~P~~)(CO),~~
A (trigonal bipyramidal) intermediate between A and B" intermediate between A and Bb IAU~RQ(/~~-H)(~-HJ(/~-P~~PCH>PP~~)(CO)I~]' B (square-based pyramidal) [A~?R~J(~~-H)(~-H)(/C-C~S-P~~~CH=CH=CHPP~~)(CO)~~] B (square-based pyramidal) [ A U ~ R U ~ ( / ~ , - H ) ( ~ - H ) ( ~ ~ - ~ . ~ - P ~ ? P C ~ H ~ P P ~ B~ (square-based ) ( C O ) I ~ ~ pyramidal) "One of the equatorial Au-Ru distances is too long (Au. .Ru 3.446A) for any significant bonding interaction, so the AuzRu? unit in the Au2Ru4 metal core of the cluster is distorted towards a square-based pyramidal geometry.'"] of the equatorial Au-Ru [Au(1). . .Ru(2) in Fig. 81 distances is too long (Au.. .Ru 3.558 A) for any significant bonding interaction, so the AuzRu3 unit in the AuzRu4 metal core of the cluster is distorted towards a square-based pyramidal g e ~ m e t r y . i ~ ~ ] "The closely related clusters [Au~Ru4(/c,-H)(p-H)(p-Ph~AsCH~EPh~)(CO)~~] (E = As or P) also adopt very similar skeletal geometries. with the Au2Ru3 fragment exhibiting gold atom arrangement B.1221
530
1 Moleculuv Clusters
Ppl Figure 14. The molecular structure of [Au~Ru~(IIu,-H)(II-H)(CO) 12( PPh3 121. The gold atoms in the capped trigonal bipyramidal A u ~ R metal u ~ framework adopt gold atom arrangement B (Fig. 13). The phenyl groups have been omitted for clarity (reprinted by permission of the Royal Society of Chemistry from ref. 36).
significant bonding interaction (Au-Ru 3.446 A for Ph2P(CH2)2PPh2[21 and 3.558 A for dppfIZ7]).Therefore, the metal core structures adopted by [Au2Ru4(p3H)(p-H)(p-L2)(CO)12][L2 = PhzP(CH2)2PPh2 or dppf] can be best described as intermediate between capped trigonal bipyramidal and capped square-based pyramidal (i.e. intermediate between gold atom arrangements A and B in Fig. 13).
1.27.3.3 Structures of clusters of general formula [Au~Ru~(u~-S)(,U-L~)(CO)~] [L2 = Ph2P(CH2),PPh2 (n = 1 or 2), &-Ph2PCH=CHPPh2, 1,2-Ph2PC6H4PPh2 or 1,l'bis(dipheny1phosphino)ferrocene (dppf )] Table 4 lists the metal core structures adopted by the clusters [Au2Ru3(p3-S)(C0)9( PPh3)2lL4']and [Au2Ru~(p3-S)(,u-L2)(CO)9] [L2 = Ph2P(CHz),PPh2 (n = 1[431 or 2[291),C ~ S - P ~ ~ P C H = C H 1,2-Ph2PCsH4PPh2[291 P~~,[~~I or dppf1241].It can be seen that the bidentate diphosphine ligands generally have a much smaller effect on the metal core structures of the pentanuclear Au2Ru3 clusters compared with that observed for the hexanuclear A u ~ R usystem ~ (Sec. 3.2). In fact, none of the bidentate diphosphine ligands studied are capable of distorting the trigonal bipyramidal AuzRu3 unit to a square-based pyramidal geometry ( c j Table 3). The formal replacement of the two PPh3 groups attached to the gold atoms in
1.27 The Heteronuclrar Cluster Chemistry o f t h e Group I 1 Metals
531
Table 4. The different gold atom arrangements adopted by the AuzRu3 metal frameworks of the clusters I A ~ ? R ~ ~ ( ~ I , - S ) ( ~ - L ?[L? ) ( C=OPhlP(CH?),,PPhz )Y] (n = 1 ~ 4 i ]or 2120'), dppf, cu-Ph?PCH= "'l] and [AuzRu3(pi-S)(CO)y(PPhj )>]I3' 42' CHPPh?1441and 1,2-PhzPC6H~PPh2 Cluster
Gold atom arrangement for the AuzRu3 metal framework (Fig. 13)
[AU2RuI(pLJ-S!(CO)Y(PPh3 h1 [Auz R u (pj-S){ ~ /L-Ph2P(CH?)2PPh?}(CO10 1 [AuzRu?(p,-S)(pc-d~~f)(CO!~l [Au?Ruj ( p j-S)(p-cb-Ph?PCH=CHPPh:)(CO)9] [A uR ~ U? ( ~-S) 3 (p-Ph2PCH zPPh2)iCO)S1
A (trigonal bipyramidal) A (trigonal bipyramidal) A (trigonal bipyramidal) A (trigonal bipyramidal) Intermediate between A and Ba [ A u ? R u ~ ( ~ ~ - S ) ( / L - I , ~ - P ~I~ P C ~ H ~ P PIntermediate ~ ~ ) ( C O )between ~ A and Bb "One of the equatorial Au-Ru distances is too long ( A u . ..Ru 3.335 A) for any significant bonding interaction, so the Au2Ru3 metal core of the cluster is distorted towards a square-based pyramidal geometry.14" bThere are two independent molecules in the asymmetric unit of this cluster. In each of these molecules, one of the equatorial Au-Ru [ry. Au(2j.. .Ru(3) in Fig. 151 distances is too long (Au. ' .Ru 3.487 and 3.515A) for any significant bonding interaction, so the AulRuj metal core of the cluster is distorted towards a square-based pyramidal ge~metry.:'~]
[Au2Ru3(p3-S)(C0)9( PPh3)2] by the bidentate diphosphine ligands PhZP(CH2)zPPh2, cis-PhzPCH=CHPPh2 and dppf does not significantly alter the trigonal bipyramidal skeletal geometry observed for the PPh3-containing species (e.g. Fig. 9). Only two of all of the bidentate diphosphines used cause any significant change to the skeletal geometry observed for the PPh3-containing species, which is in marked contrast to the results obtained for the hexanuclear A u ~ R usystem ~ (Sec. 3.2). The 1,2-Ph?PChHqPPhz and PhzPCH2PPh2 ligands both cause a change from the trigonal bipyramidal gold atom arrangement A (Fig. 13) in [Au2Ru3(p3-S)(C0)y(PPh3)2] by causing the elongation of one of the equatorial Au-Ru [eg. Au(2).. .Au(3) in Fig. 151 distances, so that it is too long for any significant bonding interaction. This elongation is 3.335 A for [Au2Ru3(p3-S)(p-Ph2PCH2PPh2)( C O ) Y ] [and ~ ~ ]3.487 and 3.515 A for the two independent molecules, which are observed in the asymmetric unit of [ A u ~ R u ~ ( ~ ~ - S ) ( ~ - ~ , ~ - P ~ ~ P C ~ H ~ P (Fig. 15). Therefore, the Au2Ru3 metal frameworks of [Au2Ru3(p3-S)(p-L~)(C0)9] ( Lz=PhzPCHzPPh2 or 1 , ~ - P ~ Z P C ~ Hboth ~ P adopt P ~ ~ geometries ) which are intermediate between trigonal bipyramidal and square-based pyramidal (i.e. gold atom arrangements A and B in Fig. 13). It is interesting that the sterically demanding bidentate diphosphine ligands that are capable of forcing the A u ~ R uunit ~ in the metal cores of the A u ~ R uclusters, ~ which are described in Sec. 1.27.3.2 (Table 3), to adopt the square-based pyramidal gold arrangement B (Fig. 13) are not able to cause the same distortion in the metal skeletons of the sulfur-containing Au2Ru3 clusters (Table 4). This observation is
532
1 Molecular Clusters
E4.3 \Lj
Lb
Figure 15. The molecular structure of one of the two molecules in the asymmetric unit of the cluster [Au*Ru? (,u?-S)(p-l,2-Ph2PC6H4PPh2)(CO)91.[29] In each of these molecules, one of the equatorial Au-Ru [eg. Au(2). . .Au(3)] distances is too long (Au.. .Ru 3.487 and 3.515 A) for any significant bonding interaction, so the AuzRu3 metal core of the cluster is distorted towards a square-based pyramidal geometry. Therefore, the gold atoms in the metal framework of the cluster adopt a structure, which is intermediate between gold arrangements A and B (Fig. 13).
especially surprising in view of the fact that gold arrangement B is actually the preferred skeletal geometry for the series of similar pentanuclear clusters [Au2Ru3(p-H)(p3-COMe)(pu-L2)(CO)9] [L2 = Ph2P(CHz),PPh2 (n = 1 or 5)[231 and dppfIz4]](Sec. 1.27.2.1.2.) (e.g. Fig. 2) and also for [Au2Ru3(p-H)(p3-COMe)(C0)9(PPh3)2],L311 in which the gold atoms are not even bridged by a bidentate diphosphine ligand.
Acknowledgements I would like to acknowledge the following co-workers for their invaluable help in the recent investigations of the chemistry of Group 1 I metal heteronuclear clusters: Dr. Steven Williams (synthesis and NMR spectroscopy), Drs. Vladimir Sik and Keith Orrell ( N M R spectroscopy), Ms Catriona Collins (NMR spectroscopy) and Drs. Trushar Adatia and Jon Steed (X-ray crystallography). My thanks are also due to Drs. Steven Williams and Kevin Young for the helpful advice that they offered concerning this article. In addition, I am very grateful to John Matthey plc for supporting my work with generous loans of gold, silver and ruthenium salts.
1.27 The Heteronuclear Cluster Cliernistry of the Group 1 I Metuls
533
References [ I I C.E. Coffey, J. Lewis, R.S. Nyholm; J. Cliern. Soc.. 1964, 1741. [2] A.S. Kasenally, R.S. Nyholm, R.J. O’Brien, M.H.B. Stiddard, Nuture, 1964, 204. B71. [3] AS. Kasenally, R.S. Nyholm, M.H.B. Stiddard, J. Am. Chenz. Soc.. 1964, 86; 1984. 141 J.W. Lauher. unpublished results. See ref. 9 for details. [ 5 ] For example, D.A. Roberts. G.L. Geoffroy in Cornprehensiae Oryunometallic Chemistry. eds. G. Wilkinson. F.G.A. Stone, E.W. Abel, Pergamon. Oxford, 1982, vol. 6, p. 763. [6] I.D. Salter in Coniprehensir~e Orquriornetallic Chemistry II. eds. G. Wilkinson, F.G.A. Stone and E.W. Abel, Pergamon, Oxford, 1995. vol. 10, p. 255. 171 D.M.P. Mingos. M.J. Watson. Adc. h o r y . Chern.. 1992, 39. 237. [8] I.D. Salter. Adti. Orgunornet. C l i m . . 1989, 29. 249. 191 K.P. Hall. D.M.P. Mingos, Proy. Inory. Chiwi., 1984, 32, 327. I 101 P. Braunstein. J. Rose, Gold Bull. 1985. 18, 17. I 11 I I.D. Salter, Adc. Dynumic Stereocheni., 1988, 2. 57. [I21 M. Melnik, R.V. Parish, Coortl, Chern. Reaie\r.s. 1986, 70, 157. [ 131 J.J. Steggerda, J.J. Bour, J.W.A. van der Velden. Reel. Truc. Chim. Pu~s-Bus.1982. 101, 164. (141 P.G. Jones, Gold Bull., 1986, 19, 46. [ 151 P.G. Jones, Gold Bull., 1983, 16. 114. (161 P.G. Jones, Gold Bull.. 1981, 14. 102. 1171 D.J. Wales. D.M.P. Mingos, L. Zhenyang, Inorg. Chem., 1989. 28, 2754. 1181 D.M.P. Mingos, Polj~liehon.1984, 3. 1289. 1191 D.G. Evans, D.M.P. Mingos. J. Orgcrnorne~.Chern.. 1982, 232. 171. [20] S.S.D. Brown, I.D. Salter. unpublished results. [21] S.S.D. Brown. I.D. Salter. A.J. Dent. G.F.M. Kitchen, A.G. Orpen, P.A. Bates, M.B. Hursthouse, J. Cliern. Soc.. Dulton Truns. 1989, 1227. 1221 S.S.D. Brown. I.D. Salter. D.B. Dyson, R.V. Parish. P A . Bates. M.B. Hursthouse, J. Chevn. Sot, Dulton Truns., 1988. 1795. (231 C.A. Collins, I.D. Salter, V. Sik, S.A. Williams, T. Adatia. J. Cheni. Soc,., Dultun Trcmx., 1998. 1107. 1241 C.A. Collins, I.D. Salter. V. Sik. S.A. Williams, J.C. Jeffery J. Chetn. Soc.. Dulton Trans., submitted for publication. [25) J.T. Mague. C.L. Lloyd, 0rgunoiiietcillic.s. 1992, I I . 26. [26] E.W. Abel, S.K. Bhargava. K.G. Orrell. Prog. Inorg. Clieni., 1984, 32, I . [27] I.D. Salter, V. Sik, S.A. Williams, T. Adatia, J. Cheni. Soc., Dulton Trans.. 1996, 643. 1281 B.E. Mann in Comprc~hen.c.ice Or~junometrrllic~ Chrmi.stry, eds. G. Wilkinson, F.G.A. Stone and E.W. Abel, Pergamon. Oxferd, 1982. vol. 3. p. 89. [29] I.D. Salter, J.W. Steed. V. Sik. S.A. Williams. unpublished results. 1301 P.J. Bailey. M.A. Beswick. J. Lewis, P.R. Raithby. M. Carmen Ramizez de Arellano, J. Oryrrnoriiet. Clietn.. 1993. 459. 293. [31] L.J. Farrugia. M.J. Freeman, M. Green, A.G. Orpen, F.G.A. Stone. I.D. Salter, J. Orgcmomet. Cliein., 1983. 249. 273. [32] L.W. Bateman. M. Green. K.A. Mead, R.M. Mills. I.D. Salter. F.G.A. Stone. P. Woodward, J. Chivn. Soc.. Dulton Trcrns., 1983. 2599. 1331 For example. B.F.G. Johnson. R.E. Benfield in Trunsition Metul Clusters, ed. B.F.G. Johnson, John Wiley and Sons Ltd.. 1980. ch. 7; B.F.G. Johnson. A t h ~ .D y n ~ n i i cStweochen?., 1988. 2, 207: L.J. Farrugia in Coriiprrl7en.r.i1~~, Or~iunornetullicClzeniistry II. eds. G. Wilkinson, F.G.A. Stone and E.W. Abel, Pergamon. Oxford. 1995, vol. 10. p. 187. [34] S.M. Draper. C.E. Housecroft. A.L. Rheingold. J . Orgcmoriwr. Chmi., 1992, 435, 9.
534
I Molecular Clusters
[35] C.P. Blaxill, S.S.D. Brown, J.C. Frankland, I.D. Salter and V. Sik, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1989, 2039. [36] M.J. Freeman, A.G. Orpen, I.D. Salter, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1987, 379. [37] A.G. Orpen, I.D. Salter, Orgunometallics, 1991, 10, 111. [38] I.D. Salter, S.A. Williams, T. qdatia, Polyhedron, 1995, 14, 2803. [39] P.J. McCarthy, I.D. Salter, V. Sik, J. Organomet. Chem., 1988, 344, 41 1 . 1401 C.J. Brown, P.J. McCarthy, I.D. Salter, J. Chem. Soc., Dulton Trans., 1990, 3583. [41] T. Adatia, Acta Crystallogr., Sect. C, 1993, 49, 1926. [42] M.I. Bruce, 0. bin Shawkataly, B.K. Nicholson, J. Organomet. Chem., 1985, 286, 427. [43] S.S.D. Brown, S. Hudson, I.D. Salter, M. McPartlin, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1987, 1967. [44] I.D. Salter, S.A. Williams, T. Adatia, unpublished results.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.28 Homonuclear and Heteronuclear Cluster Compounds of Gold Joaclzim Strahle
1.28.1 Introduction Since the pioneering work of Malatesta and his coworkers,['-31many new homonuclear gold clusters have been synthesized. These clusters can be divided into two groups. A smaller group of non-centered clusters consists of four to seven gold atoms, while a larger group of cluster compounds is characterized by one central and seven to twelve peripheral gold atoms. M i n g o ~ [ ~ classified ,~' the centred clusters with respect to their structure into toroidal and spherical types. Even a high nuclearity gold cluster compound, Au55( PPh3)12C16, consisting of 55 gold atoms is known.[61The results have been reviewed in several article^.[^.^^*] Most of the gold cluster compounds are synthesized from mononuclear gold( I ) complexes like RjPAuX ( X = halide, NO,, SCN-, etc.) by reduction with NaBH4, Ti(q-tol)*,CO, or other reducing agents. We have recently found that the photolytic decomposition of the azido complexes R3PAuN1 in T H F is another convenient method.['] Furthermore, the photolysis of azido complexes can be used for the synthesis of heteronuclear gold cluster compounds, if a source for the heteroatom is present during the photolysis in form of a carbonyl or azido complex.['1 A great variety of heteronuclear gold cluster compounds are known. In many of these clusters the AuPR3 moiety behaves like an isolobal proton"'.' 'I and bridges an edge of a transition metal cluster. While another type of heteronuclear clusters is built up by one central transition metal atom and up to twelve gold atoms, as described in several reviews.[*,' 14]
536
I Molecular Clusters
1.28.2 Synthesis of homonuclear gold cluster compounds 1.28.2.1 Photolysis of R3PAuN3 The controlled thermal decomposition of azido complexes[151has been used for the synthesis of metal nitrogen compounds such as nitride," 61 N-halogenoimido'' 'I or phosphorane iminato complexes.[' *I This type of decomposition, which presumably proceeds with a cleavage of the N,-Nb bond of the coordinated azido ligand, could not be observed for the gold(I ) azido complexes R3PAuN3. Thermal treatment resulted in the formation of gold metal. The photolytic decomposition of R3PAuN3 by irradiation with UV light at low temperature, however, afforded homonuclear gold cluster compounds. In this case a reductive elimination of the complete azido ligand in the form of molecular nitrogen occurs. The type of homonuclear gold cluster compound formed by the photolysis of R3PAuN3 is influenced by the steric demand of the ligand bound to the gold atom. If Ph3PAuN3 is used for the photolytic reaction in THF then smaller clusters like [(Ph3PAu)812+are obtained (Eq. 1). 6Ph3PAuN3
+ 2 Ph3PAu'
hc
+
+[(Ph3PAu),12+ 9N2
(1)
This cluster has already been synthesized by the reaction of [A~(AuPPh3)81"~ with PPh3, and has been structurally c h a r a c t e r i ~ e d . [ ~ The , ~ ~metal ] core has a structure which can be described as a capped centred chair (Fig. 1). In the presence of smaller ligands like Cl-, which can be abstracted from a chlorinated solvent like CH2C12 or can be added as Ph3PAuCl to the reaction mixture, the larger, and presumably more stable cluster [Aull (PPh3)8C12]+is usually observed as a result of the photolysis (Eq. 2, Fig. 2).Iz1]
6"
Figure 1. Structure of the inner core of the homonuclear gold cluster cation [(AuPPh3)8l2+. Only the P atoms (open circles) of the phosphine ligands are shown.
Figure 2. Structure of the inner core of thc homonuclear gold cluster cation [Au(AuPPh7)8(A~Cl)~l+ C1 atoms hatched circles, P dtonx open circles
8 Ph3PAuN3
+ 2 Ph3PAuClf
Ph3PAu'
h-t,
(PPhj),C12]+
+ 3 PPh3 + 12 N2
(2)
The same Aull cluster was obtained by Vollenbroek et ~ 1 by an . aggregation ~ ~ ~ reaction of [AuiAuPPh3)xl3+ with C1-. Other Aul I clusters showing an identical skeleton of metal atoms, however, with the composition Au(AuPAr3)7(AuX)3 ( X = I, SCN or C N ) have been isolated previously by Malatesta and coworkers, and were the first examples of homonuclear gold c l ~ s t e r s . [ ~ , ~ ~ . ~ ~ ~ A reduction of the bulkiness of the phosphine ligand by using MezPhPAuN3 as the starting material for the photolysis results in the formation of the Au13 cluster It [Au13(PMe2Ph)loC12]3+,[251 which has been already obtained by Mingos et exhibits a centred icosahedron (Fig. 3) structure. These homonuclear clusters are usually also obtained as by-products of the photolytic synthesis of the heteronuclear cluster compounds (see Sec. 1.28.3).
1.28.2.2 Synthesis of [Au(AuCl)(AuPPh3)$ While the homonuclear clusters obtained from the photolysis had already been synthesized using other methods,[',*' as described above, an unknown cluster cation was obtained by an unexpected reaction.[''] In the course of our attempts to synthesize heteronuclear vanadium gold clusters c.W a photolysis of a mixture of Ph3PAuN3/PhiPAuC1 ( 3 : 1 ) and N ~ ~ [ ( C S H S ) V ( C O in) ITHF/toluene ] (2: 11, the homonuclear cluster cation [Au(AuCl)(AuPPh3)p,]+was discovered. As this new cluster cation cannot be detected if the photolysis is performed without the vanadium complex, and the known cluster [Au(AuCl)2(AuPPh3)8lf is obtained instead, the vanadium complex probably directs the reaction to yield the new cluster cation.
~
538
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 3. Structure of the inner core of the homonuclear gold cluster cation [Au(AuPMe2Ph)lo(AuC1)212f Cl atoms: hatched circles; P atoms: open circles.
The structure of the spherical cluster [Au(AuCl)(AuPPhs)x]+(Fig. 4)consists of a centered eight membered crown of gold atoms with an additional AuCl molecule bound to the central gold atom. The cluster is isoelectronic and isostructural with [ P ~ ( C O ) ( A U P P ~ ~and ) ~ []P~~+( [ C~ O~) (~A~U ~ P] P ~ ~ with )~]~ the+ [CO ~ ~ligand ] occupying the position of the AuCl molecule. They result from the reaction of toroidal clusters [ M ( A U P P ~ ~ ) *(M ] ~= + Pt[149291,PdfZE1) with carbon monoxide. Interestingly, the corresponding homonuclear cluster [ A U { A U P ( C ~ H ~ O M ~ )' ] ~ } ~ ] ~ + , with a toroidal structure of a centred crown, is also known. Its transformation to a spherical cluster by a reaction with a molecule of AuCl would, however, require a
Figure 4. Structure of the inner core of the homonuclear gold cluster cation [Au(AuCl)(AuPPh?) 8 ] CI atom: hatched circle; P atoms: open circles.
+
1.28 Homonuclear and Heteronuclear Cluster Compounds of Gold
539
simultaneous reduction by two electrons, as AuCl, unlike CO, is not an electron donor.
1.28.3 Synthesis of heteronuclear gold cluster compounds 1.28.3.1 Photolysis of Ph3PAuN3 in the presence of a metal carbonyl complex If the photolysis of Ph3PAuN1 is carried out in the presence of a metal carbonyl complex, the Ph3PAu(0) moieties can substitute CO ligands affording heteronuclear cluster compounds of the composition [M(CO),(AuPPh3),]'+. To maintain the electron count of the transition metal M requiring a stable 18 electron configuration, each CO ligand must by substituted by two PhlPAu(0) fragments. Therefore an electron balance of n + 2x + y z = 18 is necessary, where n is the number of valence electrons of the transition metal M. Usually a series of cluster compounds with a different degree of substitution of the CO ligands results from the photolysis. The photolytically induced substitution stops, however, when the stable M(CO)3 step is reached. In addition to the substitution reaction, one or two Ph3PAu+ cations can be added to form a cluster cation. The photolysis of Mo(C0)6 and Ph3PAuN3 in THF, for example, yields the series of cluster compounds [Mo(CO)5(AuPPh3)1]+,[Mo(C0)4(AuPPh3)5]+,and [ Mo( CO)3( A U P P ~ ~ ) ~ ](Eq. + [ ~3).~ - ~ ~ ' ~
Mo(CO),
+ 2n Ph3PAuN3 + Ph3PAu'
The structures of [ M O ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~and ) ~ ] +[ M [ ~O~ (I C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~are )~]+[~~I shown in Fig. 5. The structure of [Mo(CO)5(AuPPh3)3]+was not determined. It can, however, be assumed that it has the same structure as the isoelectronic cluster V(C0)5(A~PPh3)3.[351 Homonuclear gold cluster compounds are always formed as by-products, but the amount can be reduced by using an excess of the metal carbonyl complex. The yield of the different heteronuclear cluster compounds can be influenced by the time of irradiation. Longer reaction times favour the formation of the larger clusters. The wavelength of the UV radiation also has a strong influence. It has, however, not been studied in detail. The various products formed from the photolysis can be separated chromatographically on an A1203 column. For this, the cluster cations are transformed in their readily soluble PF; salts.
540
I Molecular Clusters n
Figure 5. Structures of the inner core of thc heteronuclear gold molybdenum cluster cations a) [Mo(CO)d(AuPPh3)5]+,and b) [Mo(C0)3(AuPPh3)7]+.
The analogous tungsten gold clusters [W(C0)4(AuPPh3)5]+ and [W(CO)3(AuPPh3)7]- as well as [W(c0)4(A~PPh3)6]~+ have been synthesized by Steggerda et al. from the homonuclear gold cluster [(AuPPh3)g12+and W(C0)3(NCEt)3or w(c0)~.[361
The photolysis of a mixture of Ph3PAuN3 and the iron carbonyl complex Fe(C0)5 in THF yields [Fe(C0)3(A~PPh3)5]+.[~~] The structure of its FeAuj skeleton is the same as that of [Mo(C0)4(AuPPh3)5]+(Fig. 5a). The known cluster Fe(C0)4(A~PPh3)2,[~~] which can be obtained from [Fe(C0)4l2- and Ph3PAu+, was not detected as a product of the photolysis reactions. When Fe2(C0)9 or Fe3(CO)l2 are used in place of Fe(CO)5 analogous results are observed. On the contrary R u ~ ( C O12,) behaves differently. Presumably because of the stronger metal-metal bonds photolysis with Ph3PAuN3 does not result in a cleavage of the Ru3 cluster. Oxidative addition of Ph3PAuN3 at one Ru-Ru bond takes place instead, and simultaneously the azido group reacts with one CO ligand to form a cyanato ligand, so that Ru3(CO)1O(p-AuPPh3)(pu-NCO) is formed.[371 Co2(CO)g proved to be the most reactive carbonyl complex. It is the only one that reacts without irradiation to afford the known[391heterobinuclear complex Ph3PAuCo(C0)4 (Eq. 4):[401 Co2(CO),
+ 2 Ph3PAuN3 + 2Ph3PAuCo(CO), + 3 N2
(4)
The photolysis of Ph3PAuCo(C0)4 with Ph3PAuN3 yields the cluster cation [ C ~ ~ ( C O ) ~ A U ( A ~ P Pwhose ~ ~ )inner ~ ] +skeleton ,[~~' consists of two CoAu4 trigonal bipyramids sharing one axial Au atom (Fig. 6). It can be assumed that this cluster is a condensation product of [Co(C0)3(AuPPh3)4]+ and Co(C0)3(AuPPh3)3, which are presumably present as intermediate products in the reaction mixture.
1.28 Hornonuclear and Heteronuclear Cluster Compounds of Gold
Figure 6. Structure of the inner core of the condensed cluster ICo?(CO)hAu(AuPPhj)fi]+.
V
541
U
[Co(CO)3(AuPPh3)4]+can be obtained in good yield, if [ C O Z ( C O ) ~ A U ( A U P P ~ ~ ) ~ ] + or Ph3PAuCo(C0)4 is reacted with [Ph3PAu]PFs in refluxing CHzClz without irrad i a t i ~ n . [ ~ ~It' ~will ' ] be shown in Sec. 1.28.3 that the neutral cluster Co(CO)3(AuPPh3)3 (Fig. 7a) is obtained from the reaction of [Co(CO)?(AuPPh3)4]+with
c1-,[341
The photolysis of a mixture of Mn2(CO)lo and Ph3PAuN3, in THF, yields [Mn(C0)4(AuPPh3)4]+ (Fig. 8), together with small amounts of [Mn(C0)3(AuPPh3)6]+ (Fig. 9a).r4'1Better yields of [Mn(C0)3(AuPPh3)6]+are obtained starting from P ~ ~ P A U M ~ ( C OPh3PAuN3, ) ~ , [ ~ ~ Iand Ph3PAuNCO in the photolysis (Eq. 5j.[421In this case, the neutral cluster M ~ ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P(Fig. ~ ~ )7bj ~ [is~ the ~] main by-product. Ph3PAuMn(CO),
+ [Ph3PAuIf + 4 Ph3PAuN3
hf
+
[Mn(C0)3(AuPPh3)s]+ 2CO
+ 6N2
(5)
Figure 7. Structures of the inner core of the neutral clusters a) [Co(CO)j(AuPPhi)-i], and b) IMn(C0)4(AuPPh3)31.
542
I Molecular Clusters
e
Figure 8. Structure of the inner core of the heteronuclear gold manganese cluster cation [Mn(C0)4(AuPPh3)4I1.
The neutral cluster Mn(C0)4(AuPPh3)3had been synthesized previously by Ellis[441 from [Mn(C0)4l3- and [Ph3PAu]+. Surprisingly, the photolysis of P ~ ~ P A U V ( C Oand ) ~ [Ph3PAuN3 ~~] did not give the expected heteronuclear vanadium gold cluster. Only homonuclear gold cluster cations with [V(co)6]- as the counterion could be obtained.[461Chromatographic separation of the reaction mixture dissolved in CHZC12 afforded [( Ph3PAu)g(AuCI)~AU][V(CO)~] as the main product. The photolysis was therefore carried out substituting some of the Ph3PAuN3 by Ph3PAuNCO to avoid an excess of the azide, which probably favours the formation of homonuclear gold clusters. The best results were obtained with a 3 :2 molar mixture of Ph3PAuNCO/Ph3PAuN3 together with Ph3PAuV(C0)6, giving approximately 35% yield of [V(CO)4(AuPPh3)6]+ (Fig. 9b),[461 in addition to 30% of V ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~and ~ ) ~30Y0 [ ~ ~of’ the homonuclear gold clusters.
Figure 9. Structures of the inner core of the cluster cations a) IMn(C0)3(AuPPh3)6]’~,and b) IV(C0)4(AuPPhi)6]+.
1.28 Honlonucleur and Hrteronucleur Cluster Compounds of Gold
543
Figure 10. Structure of the cluster [Re(CO)sAu(AuPPh3)6]z+. Only the P atoms of the phosphine ligands are shown.
1.28.3.2 Photolytic synthesis of [Re(C0)~Au(AuPPh3)6]~$ The photolysis of a mixture of Re2(CO)lo and Ph3PAuN3 parallels the results obtained with M n l ( C 0 )10. The clusters Re(C0)4(AuPPh3)3,[Re(C0)4(AuPPh3)4If, and [Re(C0)3(AuPPh3)6]+have been obtained and identified by mass spectrometry.[471However, no single crystal for structure determinations could be obtained. Therefore, in addition, the photolysis of Rez(C0)10 with Ph3PAuNCO was studied. Crystallisation of the product of the photolysis from methanol yields the new cluster cation [Re(CO)sAu(AuPPh3)6]'+ (Fig. lo), which crystallizes with [Re3(C0)9(pu-OMe)3(p,-OMe)]and C1- as counter ion^.[^^^ The structure of this new cluster cation contrasts the results described in Sec. 1.28.3.1, where the heteronuclear gold clusters are characterized by a transition metal atom M located in the center of a hemispherical fragment of gold atoms, where all the Au-M bond lengths are similar. The new cluster cation, however, is more closely related to the homonuclear gold clusters. As the Re(C0)S moiety is isolobal to a Ph3PAu fragment['O,'ll it occupies the position of a peripheral gold atom, and, in fact, the cluster has a structure comparable with that of '
ALI(AUPC~~)~(AUSCN)~.'~"]
1.28.3.3 Photolytic synthesis of [(CsHs)Mo(C0)2(AuPPh3)4]+ In addition to the heterobinuclear complexes Ph3PAuM(CO), ( M = Co, Mn, V ) , heteroleptic cyclopentadienyl carbonyl complexes Ph?PAuM(Cp)(CO),can be used
544
1 Moleculuv Clusters
6
[ C ~ M O ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~Only ~ ) ~the ] + .P atoms of the phosphine ligands are shown.
as materials for the photolysis with Ph3PAuN3. As a first result we obtained [CpMo(CO)*(AuPPh3)4]+ from the photolysis of CpMo(C0)3(AuPPh3) and Ph3PAuN3 (Eq. 6).'501
+
+ [P~~PAu]' [ C P M O ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~+~3N2 )~]+ + CO
C P M O ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~2~Ph3PAuN3 ) +
(6)
As with [Mn(CO)4(AuPPh3)4]+(Fig. 8), the five metal atoms of the cluster cation [CpMo(CO)2(AuPPh3)4]+form a trigonal bipyramid with the Mo atom in equatorial position (Fig. 11). By analogy with the heterometallic gold clusters discussed in Sec. 1.28.3.1, the composition of the cluster cation is also determined by the electronic requirements of the transition metal Mo. With the electrons from the bonds to the cyclopentadienyl and CO ligands and the three electrons from the I(Ph3PAu)4]+ fragment the Mo atom reaches a stable configuration of 18 electrons.
1.28.3.4 Co-photolysis of Pd or Pt azido complexes with metal carbonyl complexes The palladium and platinum azido complexes L2M(N3)2 ( M = Pd, Pt; L2 = dppe, (PPh3)2), like Ph3PAuN3, undergo a reductive elimination of the azido ligands upon UV irradiation forming palladium( 0) and platinum( 0) complex fragments L2M. Unlike gold atoms, however, Pd and Pt atoms do not show the same tendency to cluster together. Therefore, the photolysis of palladium( 11) and platinum( 11) azido complexes in the presence of metal carbonyl complexes does not give the comparable heteronuclear clusters. Most of the metal carbonyl complexes do not react at all with the Pd or Pt azido complexes. Only with Co2(CO)8 is a reaction observed. With (dppe)Pt(N3)2 the photolysis affords the trinuclear cluster (dppe)PtCoz(C0)7(Eq. 7),[51a1 which was previously synthesized by Dehand and
1.28 Homotiucl~wrlitid Heteronucleur Cluster Compound.\ of Gold
545
Figure 12. Structure of the heteronucledi du\tei (dppe)PtCo,(CO), Only the C atoms of the CH2 groups and P atoms are shown of the bis(dipheny1phosphine) ligniid
Nennig.[j2]in 1974, from (dppe)PtCI?and [Co(CO),]-, and also by Hidai et a/.[s31 using (dppe)Pt(C=CPh)?and C O ~ ( C O ) ~ .
If
+
(dppe)Pt(Ni)? C O ? ( C O ) ~
I
(dppe)PtCo:!(CO),
+ 3 N ? + CO
(7)
The structure determination["'"] shows, that one of the bridging CO ligands in Co?(CO)x is substituted by a (dppe)Pt(O) fragment forming a triangular CozPt cluster (Fig. 12).This is similar to the situation found in [(PhiP)(OC)PtCo2(CO)7].[51 h1 When [ (dppe)PtCo?(CO),] is used in the photolysis reaction with PhiPAuNi, the triangular ColPt cluster is cleaved and the heteronuclear cluster cations [Pt(dppe)(AuPPhi)4I2+(Fig. 13) and [ C O ~ ( C O ) ~ A U ( A U P P(Fig. ~ ? ) 6) ~ ]are + formed (Eq. 8).[s1"1
+
[(dppe)PtCo?(CO),] 8 Ph?PAuN3+ 3 PhiPAu+ hI + [Pt(dppe)( AuPPhi),] 2+
+ P P h i + C O + 12N2
Figure 13. Structure of the heteronuclenr cluster cation [(dppelPt(AuPPh&
+ [ C O ? ( C O ) , A U ( A U P P '~ ~ ) ~ ]
546
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 14. Structure of the inner core of the heteronuclear gold platinum cluster [Pt(CO)(AuPP&)61if. C1 atoms: hatched circles; P atoms: larger open circles.
1.28.3.5 Co-photolysis of Ph3PAuN3 and L2M(N3)2 (M = Pd, Pt; L2 = dppe, (PPh3)2) The photolysis of (Ph3P)zPt(N3)2,Ph3PAuN3, and Ph3PAuC1 in THF affords a mixture of products, which, after chromatographic separation, yields the neutral clusters Pt( PPh3)(AuPPh3)6(AuC1)3 and Pt (CO)(AuPPh3)6(AuC1)3.[5 The former has already been synthesized and structurally characterized by Steggerda et al. [ j 4 ] Our structure determination of the CO derivative shows that the skeleton of both clusters is identical, consisting of an icosahedral fragment of nine Au atoms with the Pt atom in its center (Fig. 14). The origin of the CO ligand is not obvious, since no carbon monoxide or carbonyl complex was used during the synthesis. In accordance with the one can assume that it originates from coordinated ethanol, which was used as an eluant during the chromatographic separation. Additional gold platinum clusters obtained by other methods have been reviewed by Steggerda.[l4] The photolysis with the palladium( 11) azido complexes (Ph3P)*Pd(N3)2 and (dppe)Pd(N3)zin the presence of Ph3PAuN3 and Ph3PAuCl yields different products than those formed from the analogous Pt complexes. In this case the PdAu12 clusters Pd(AuPPh3)8(AuC1)4(Fig. 15)[j6] and Pd(AuPPh3)6(Au2dppe)(A~C1)4[~’~ are obtained (Eq. 9).They are analogous to the homonuclear Au13 cluster [ A ~ ( A U P M ~ ~ P ~ ) ~ O ( A Uand C ~ represent ) ~ ] ~ +the , [ first ~ ~ ,examples ~ ~ ~ of heteronuclear clusters involving a complete icosahedron of twelve Au atoms with the heteroatom in its center.
+
-
(dppe)Pd(N3), 8 Ph3PAuN3 l1.U
+ 4 Ph3PAuCl
Pd(AuPPh3),(Auzdppe)(AuCl), + 15 N2 + 6 PPh3
(9)
1.28 Homonuclear und Heteronucleuu Cluster Compounds of Gold
547
Figure 15. Structure of the inner core of the icosahedral gold palladium cluster IPd(AuPPh3)s(AuC1)AJ. C1 atoms: hatched circles; P atoms: open circles
1.28.4 Properties and reactions of heteronuclear gold cluster compounds In the crystalline form the heteronuclear gold cluster compounds are air-stable at ambient temperature and not sensitive to light. Solutions, however, decompose slowly under action of light to form gold metal. A comparison of the wavenumbers of the CO stretching vibrations of the substituted carbonyl complexes shows that the (AuPPh?),,fragments have a good donor ability. This ability increases with the number of AuPPh3 groups bound to the transition metal M. The CO stretching vibration for Mo(C0)6 is 2112 cm-1,[583 and for while for [Mo(C0)4(AuPPh3)5]+values of 1890, 1915, and 1975 c111-',[~~] [Mo(CO)3(AuPPh3)7]+values of 1835 and 1895 are found. Analogously, the stretching vibrations of the terminal CO ligands of C o z ( C 0 ) are ~ in the region between 2001 and 21 12 cm-' .[581 In [Co(CO)3(AuPPh3)4]+the corresponding lower values are 1915, 1925, and 1980 ~ m - ' , [ ~ 'and ] in [Co(CO)z(AuPPh3)6]+they are 1873 and 1904 An even stronger donor ability is observed in the neutral clusters, as can be seen from the frequencies shown by Co(CO)3(AuPPh3)3,at 1891, 1905 and 1963 ~ r n - ' . [ ~ ~ ] As discussed above, the stepwise photolytic substitution of CO ligands by R3PAu fragments stops once the M(C0)3 stage is reached. We, therefore, used the long known nucleophilic attack of OH- on the CO group, which was first discovered by Hieber and Leutert in 1932,[601when they reacted Fe(CO)5 with OH- to obtain the metallate [Fe(CO)4]*-.Correspondingly, [Co(CO)3(AuPPh3)4]+reacts with ethanolic
548
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 16. Structures of the inner core of the heteronuclear gold cobalt cluster cations d) [Co(C0)2(AuPPh3)slt, and b) [Co(C0)2(AuPPh3)7I2+
NaOH in the presence of Ph3PAuCl to afford the larger cluster [Co(CO)2(AuPPh3)6]+(Fig. 16a) in approximately 83% yield, in addition to small quantities of the dication [Co(CO)2(AuPPh3)7l2+(Fig. 16b).[591In accordance with the findings of Hieber and Leutert it can be assumed that the metallate [Co(CO)2(AuPPh3)4]- is formed as an intermediate product, which subsequently adds two or three cations [PhsPAu]+ (Eqs. 10, 11).
+
[ C O ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~4) OH ~]+ +
[Co(CO),(AuPPh3),]-
+ C0:- + 2 H20
(10)
[CO(CO)2(AuPPh3)6]+
(11)
[Co(CO),(AuPPh3),]-
+ 2 Ph3PAu'
+
The analogous rhodium clusters [Rh(C0)2(AuPPh3)6]+and [Rh(CO)2(AuPPh3)7l2+ with the same composition and structure had already been obtained by Mingos et a1.[611from [Ph3PAu]+ and [BH4]- in the presence of [Rh(CO)*(MeCN)2]+. The observation that the dication [Co(C0)2(AuPPh3)7I2+is obtained in addition to [Co(C0)2(AuPPh3)6]+shows that an equilibrium mediated by [Ph3PAuIf exists and can be used to build up and to degrade the clusters. This equilibrium can furthermore be influenced by C1- or PPh3, which are able to remove a [Ph3PAu]+ cation from the cluster in the form of the very stable products Ph3PAuCl and [Au(PPh3)2]+. We found that the cluster cations [Co(C0)3(A~PPh3)4]-~ and [Mn(C0)4(AuPPh3)4If react with PkPCl in CH2C12 to yield the neutral clusters Co(C0)3(AuPPh3)3 (Eq. 12)1341 and Mn(C0)4(AuPPh3)3[431 containing one less [AuPPh3]+ group. While Mingos et a1.[611used the reaction of PPh3 with [Rh(CO)2(AuPPh3)7l2+to obtain the monocation [Rh(CO)z(AuPPh3)6]+. The re-
1.28 Honzonuchr rind Heteronurleur Clustcr Coinpouncl..t of Gold
549
verse reactions with [Ph3PAu]+ to yield the clusters with one additional Au atom have also been shown to occur.
[Co(CO),(AuPPh3),]+ fC1-
+
k Co (C O),(AuPPhi), PhqPAuCl
( 12)
Another interesting reaction is the condensation of [Co(CO)i(AuPPh3)4]+and Co(C0)3(AuPPhl)? to form [Co2(CO)sAu(AuPPhi)6]+(Fig. 6) in high yield (Eq. 13).[341
This reaction has, however, so far only been observed in the case of the cobalt-gold clusters. The condensed cluster [Coz(CO)hAu(AuPPh3)6]+. on the other hand, can be transformed with PhiPAu+ and PPh3 to two cluster cations [Co(CO)3(AuPPh3)4]+(Eq. 14).[34'
1.28.5 Structures of the heteronuclear gold cluster compounds With the exception of [Re(C O ) S A U ( A U P P ~ ~ ) ~all] ' +the [ ~ heteronuclear ~~ gold transition metal clusters described above are characterized by a core structure consisting of one central heteroatom M and three to twelve gold atoms at approximately equal distances from the heteroatom. The peripheral gold atoms tend to from close contacts with each other and, therefore, build a close-packed surface composed of triangular faces. For the larger clusters these surfaces can best be described as fragments of an icosahedron (Fig. 17), which is complete in the case of the PdAuIZ clusters Pd(AuPPh~)~(Au~dppe)(A~Cl)4[~~~ and Pd(AuPPh3)s(A~C1)4[~~] (Fig. 15). This results in a close-packing of MAu3 tetrahedra sharing MAu2 faces and having the central heteroatom M as a common corner. The smaller cluster C O ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~has ~ )a~ skeleton [ ~ ~ I of a single tetrahedron (Fig. 7a), while the skeletons of the MAu4 clusters exhibit a trigonal bipyramidal structure, which can be regarded as a double tetrahedron (Figs. 8, 13). An exception to the rules given above is the MnAu3 cluster Mn(C0)4(AuPPh3)3. Its skeleton has a structure of a planar MnAu3 rhombus with the Mn atom in an equatorial position (Fig. 7b).[43,621
550
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 17. Representation of the idealized metal atom skeletons of the heteronuclear gold clusters as fragments of centred icosahedra.
1.28 Homonuclear and Heteronuclear Cluster Compounds of' Gold
55 1
Despite of the fact that M ~ ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~and ~ ) C~ O [ ~( C~ O . ~) ~ (] A U P P ~ ~ ) ~ [ ~ ~ ] have the same number of cluster valence electrons, isomeric structures of a rhombus and a tetrahedron are found. The analogous observation of isomeric structures formed for clusters with the same total number of cluster valence electrons was made for the Au6M clusters. The metal skeleton of [ M ~ ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~ ) ~ ] + [ ~ ~ I (Fig. 9a) takes the spherical form of a pentagonal bipyramid with the Mn atom in axial position. The clusters [ V ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~ (Fig. ) ~ ] +9b) [ ~ ~and ] [Co(CO)2( A U P P ~ ~ ) ~ ](Fig. + [ ~ ' ]16a), on the other hand, exhibit an ellipsoidal skeleton in form of a double-capped trigonal bipyramid with the heteroatom in an equatorial position (Fig. 17). The occurence of two different structures in the case of both A u ~ Mand Au6M clusters may be explained in terms of the stereochemistry and bonding.[421Model studies show that the ellipsoidal structure of Au6V results in a lower repulsion between the four CO ligands and the (AuPPh3)6 fragment. While for the smaller Mn(CO)3 group in [Mn(C0)3(AuPPh3)6]+also with a spherical framework only a minor repulsion results. The spherical framework, however, allows for more effective gold-gold interactions. On the other hand, the different structures for [Mn(C0)3(AuPPh3)6]+ and [V(C0)4(AuPPh3)6]+as well as [Co(C0)2(AuPPh3)6]+obviously lead to a better orbital overlap in each case (see Sec. 1.28.6). This probably also accounts for the presence of isomeric A u M ~ clusters: although the stereochemical repulsion is less effective. Other examples for Au3M clusters with a tetrahedral skeleton are [( PhMe2P)3Re( H ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~ ) ~ [Rh( ] + , H)(CO)( [ ~ ~ ] P P ~ ~ ) ~ ( A L I P P ~ ~[()triphos)Rh( ~ ] + , [ ~ ~H)2] ( A u P P ~ ~ ) ~ ] ~ and + , [ ~V' I( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ Whereas ~ ) ~ . [ ~ ~the ] clusters (PhMe2P)3P P a~ planar ~ ) ~ ]skeleton +[~~I Re( H)2(A~PPh3)3,[631 and [( P ~ ~ P ) ~ I ~ ( N O ~ ) ~ ( A Uhave Au3M in form of a rhombus (Table 1). Examples for clusters with a trigonal bipyramidal MAu4 core are summerized in Table 2. Table 3 contains selected cluster compounds with a MAus skeleton. Heteronuclear clusters with a AusPt core show a variety of structures. Of the cluster cations [Pt(PPh3)(AuPPh3)6j2f,[671 [Pt(PP~~)(CC-~-BU)(AUPP~~)~]+,[~*~ and only the last one has an inner skeleton comparable [Pt(PPh3)(CO)(AuPPh3)6]2+,[671 to the one of [V(C0)4(AuPPh3)6]+ or [Co(C0)2(AuPPh3)6]+,while for clusters with a pentagonal pyramidal AU6 fragment [Mn(CO)3(AuPPh3)6lf is the only example (Table 4). Selected higher nuclearity cluster compounds with seven to twelve gold atoms are given in Tables 5 and 6.
1.28.6 Bonding in the homonuclear and heteronuclear gold cluster compounds The structure and bonding of the homonuclear and heteronuclear cluster compounds has been discussed by M i n g ~ s . [ ~ . ~W . ~e , have ' ~ ] also described, from a
M-Au distances [pm]
258.4(4)-262.0(4) Mn(CO)d(AuPPh3)3 ( P ~ M c z P ) ~ R ~ ( H ) z ( A u P P ~ ~ ) ~ 268.8(2)-273.0(2) [(Ph3P)ZIr(N@)(AuPPh3)31+ 259.3( 1)-267.5( 1)
Co(CO)i(AuPPhi13 [(PhMezP)iRe(H)i(AuPPh3)3]+
250.4( 1)-254.0(2) 272.3(2) 264.0f3)-272.2(3) [(P~~P)~R~(H)(CO)(AUPP~~)~]’ [(triphos)Rh(H)*(AuPPhj)j]’+ 269.5(2) V(CO)5(AuPPh3)j 270.9(1)-275.6( 1 )
Cluster compound
[341 1631 1641 1651 1351 1431 I631 [661
tetrahedron tetrahedron tetrahedron tetrahedron tetrahedron rhombus rhombus rhombus
279.5( 1)-285.1(1) 293.1(2) 281.412)-291.4(2) 288.7( I ) 276.8( 1)-285.5( 1) 276.6(2)-28 1.3(2) 278.7( 2 ) ,28 1.2(2) 272.7( l), 280.6(1 )
Ref.
Structure
Au-Au distances [pm]
Table 1. Metal-metal bond lengths for MAu3 heteronuclear cluster compounds with structures of a tetrahedron or a rhombus.
2
Bi;
9
r;
5
n
$2
‘r
h,
v1
cn
Table 2. Metal-metal bond lengths for heteronuclear cluster compounds with a trigonal bipyrdmidal MAu4 core. Cluster compound [Co(CO)q(AuPPhi)i]' [ Ml1(C0)4IAuPPh: '41
'+
[Pt(dppe)(AuPPh?J] [CpMor CO).( AuPPh? 141 Ilr(PPh: ~ 2 ( H ~ ~ ( A i i P P l i : ) ~ ] [Rh(P(O-r-Pr~~)~iHI~ AuPPli? A ] +
M-Au distances [pml
Au-Au distances [pm]
Ref
258 Of2) 264 7( 1 ) 261 3(3)-273 ?(?' 266 1(1)-2689(11 275 5i2) 280 8\21 261 7\21-275 3f21 265 I i 1 1 272 5 1I )
278 41 1)-293 4( 1 I 277 3( I ,-292 2' 1, 276 O( 1) 283 912) 281 2(1)-285 6(21 279 4(2\-314 2(21 281 if 1)-308 4(1 J
[401 [411 [5161 I 501 [741 1751
qualitative basis. some aspects of the bonding in heteronuclear gold transition metal cIusters.['] Mingos[" distinguished the centered higher nuclearity gold cluster compounds with regard to their topology. The spherical clusters have the peripheral gold atoms lying approximately on the surface of a sphere. They are characterized by four bonding cluster orbitals. Whereas the toroidal clusters with only three bonding cluster orbitals have the peripheral gold atoms lying approximately on a ring or torus. The homonuclear gold clusters [ ( A U P P ~ ~ ) ~ ] ' + , [[Au(AuPPh3)x~.~~I ) ~ ][AU(AUCI)(AUPP~~)~]+[")~ ~+.[~~.~~~ ( A u C I ) ~ ] + , [ ~[ (~A. ~U ~PIM ~ I P ~ ) I O ( A U C ~and described in Secs. 1.28.2.1 and 1.28.2.2 belong to the spherical type. Of the spherical type are also the heteronuclear clusters centred by a Pt or Pd atom, Pt(PPh3)(AUPP~~)~(AUCI)~,'~'".~~I Pt(CO)(AuPPh?)h(AuCI)j,[' la' Pd(AuPPh3)x( A u C I ) ~ , " ~ ] which are described in Sec. 1.28.3.4. The and Pd(AuPPh3)6(A~2dppe)(AuCl)4,~'~~ eight electrons for the four bonding orbitals are provided by the Ph3PAu(O) fragments, and in the case of the PtAuq clusters in addition by the ligands bound to the Pt atom. As discussed in Sec. 1.28.3.2, the heteronuclear cluster cation [Re(C0)5A u ( A u P P ~ ~ ) ~ ] ' is+ [ comparable ~~] to a homonuclear gold cluster. Since the Re(C0)5 group is isolobal to a Ph;PAu moiety, it occupies the position of a peripheral gold atom. The resulting cluster l, Fig. 10) forms a toroidal topology, and therefore, has three occupied bonding cluster orbitals. The centred homonuclear gold clusters are characterized by strong radial bonds between the central and the peripheral atoms. The bonds between h e peripheral gold atoms are noticeably weaker and have longer Au A U distances. These findings are also reflected by the structure of j Re(CO)jAiiuAuPPli~ jhl'-. where the radial Re-Au bond length is 287.0 pin, while the distance to the neighboring peripheral gold atoms is 297.0 pm. For the heteronuclear gold clusters j M ( C 0 ),iAuPPh;),.]'+ with a central heteroatom M and three to seven peripheral gold atoms. as described in the previous
277.6( 1)-308.8( 1) 272.2(4)-301.3(4) 276.3(5)-293.2(3) 279.5(3)-300.5(3) 281.1 (5)-317.6(3)
Au-Au distances [pm] 1371 [341 ~361 [611 1761
Ref.
279.2(1)-295.1(1) 280.4( 1)-288.4( 1) 275.3(5)-296.2(4) 281.0(2)-297.6(2)
261.8( 1)-272.3(2) 254.9(1)-257.1(2) 273( 1 j-284( 1j 265.9(2)-271.4(2)
[Mn(CO)3(AuPPh3161' [Co(CO)2(AuPPh3)6]+ [V(C0)4(AuPPh3)6]+
[Pt(PPh3)(CO)(AuPPh3)6I2+
Au-Au distances [pm]
M-Au distances [pm]
Cluster compound
Pb btb btb btb
Structure
[421 [591 [461 ~ 7 1
Ref.
Table 4. Metal-metal bond lengths for MAu6 heteronuclear cluster compounds with the structures of a pentagonal bipyramid (pb) or a bicapped trigonal bipyramid (btbj.
259.0(1)-265.1(1) 279.9(5j-284.6(7) 275.2(3)-284.9(3) 266.9(4)-273.1(4) 259.0(3)-267.6(3)
[Fe(C0)3(AuPPh3)s]+ [Mo(CO)&4uPPh3)sIf [W(C0)4(AuPPh3) s ] + [Rh(CNCsHs)3(AuPPh3I s ] 2+ [Pt (PPh3) ( CO)(AuPPhjIs]
+
M-Au distances [pm]
Cluster compound
Table 3. Metal-metal bond lengths for MAus heteronuclear cluster compounds with the structure of a capped trigonal bipyramid.
0 P
%
$:
0
52
k
P
wl
wl
279 6(2)-300 4(2) 280(3)-300(3) 286 O(2)-306 O(2) 285 4(2)-293 S(2) 277.1(2)-298 3(2)
267 5(2)-273 812) 268(2)-278 9(4) 269 O(2) 273 4(2) 272 2(2)-276 7( I ) 271 0(3)-278 2(4)
[Pt(CO)\AuPPhi)b(AuCl\?] I Pt(PPh?)(AuPPh?)h( AUCI)i] [P~(CN)(AUCN)(AUPP~~)~]*
[ Pd(AuPPhi)b(Au?dppe)(AuCI 141 [Pd(AuPPhi) ~ ( A L I C I ) ~ ]
Au-Au distances [pm]
M-Au distances [pml
Cluster compound
Table 6. Metal-metal bond lengths for MAu9 and MAUL?heteronuclear cluster compounds.
151al [541 1771 ~ 7 1 1561
Ref.
1271
2 8 3 . 3 l)-307.9( I )
[Pt(C0i(AuPPhi)~]'+
[Co(C0)z(AuPPh3)jI2+ [Rh(C0)z(A~PPhi)j]~' [Mo!CO\~(AUPP~?)~]+ [W(CO)?!AuPPh3)7If
265.1(1)-270.3( I )
Ref.
[591 1611 [32, 331 [361 [611 1281 1291
Au-Au distances (pm]
274.813)-332.6(3) 278.8(4)-311.8(5) 283.8(1)-3O3.1( 1 ) 28S.7(3)-303.5(4) 278.1(2)-300.9(2) 276.5(2)-280.5(2) 280.0(4)-286.4(4)
M-Au distances [pm]
2.56.8(6)-264.7(5) 264( 1 )-276.5(8) 277.1( I )-286.0( 1 ) 276.0(4)-285.6( 3) [ R ~ ( C N C ~ H ~ ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~ ) ~ ( A U C265.4(3)-281.9(3) I)~]+ [Pd(AuPPh3)*l2' 261.1(2)-262.4!2) [Pt(AuPPh?)x]'+ 263.1(31-264.0(3)
Cluster compound
Table 5. Metal-metal bond lengths for MAuj and MAu8 heteronuclear cluster compounds.
wl wl wl
e. 9 c
3
x
2E:
B
2 >
2 E
Y
5
2
2
7.
Q 3 Q
3
c
3
5
tu 00
'I.
556
I Moleculur Clusters
sections, a different bonding scheme must be considered. The number of bonding cluster orbitals depends on the number and type of frontier orbitals of the M(CO), or M(C5H5)(CO),group. The gold atoms of the Ph3PAu groups on the other hand can be assumed to be sp; hybridized. One of the hybrid orbitals is binding the phosphine ligand, while the other one is available for metal-metal bonding. Within the cluster it points radially to the center. The remaining pair of degenerate ps and pjJ orbitals are empty and energetically high-lying, and therefore can be neglected for the bonding. An M(CO), group has three frontier orbitals; they can be classified according to Wade[691and Owen[701into one radial orbital pointing at the center of the cluster, and one set of two degenerate tangential orbitals. They combine with the radial orbitals of the Ph3PAu groups to form three bonding MOs. One of them, where all of the group orbitals involved contribute with the same sign, can be characterized as being of 0 type, while the other two contain one nodal plane each, and therefore, are of the n type (Fig. 18). An M(CO)4 or Mo(CgH5)(C0)2group on the other hand, has only two frontier orbitals, one radial, like a M(CO)3 group, but only one tangential orbital. Therefore, only two cluster MOs are formed, one of 0 and one of n type (Fig. 18). The existence of only two bonding cluster MOs also means that for the relatively large clusters like [ V ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~only ) ~ ] the + [ ~astonishingly ~] small number of four electrons is available for the metal-metal bonds in the cluster. An additional stabilization by gold-gold interactions must, however, be considered, and the high stability of these clusters is another indication for the importance of this unprecedented affinity between gold atoms, that was termed aurophilicity by S ~ h r n i d b a u r1,721 .~~ The isomeric structures of the MAu6 and MAu3 clusters (see Sec. 1.28.5) are presumably influenced by the different number of n MOs in these clusters. Since the two tangential orbitals of the M(CO)3 groups are arranged perpendicular to one another, a hemispherical (AuPPh3)6 or (AuPPh3)3 is preferred. It is interesting to note that the bonding in [ M ~ ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~ is ) ~similar J + [ ~ ’to] that in the cyclopentadienyl complex CpMn(CO)3, since the hemispherical, pentagonal pyramidal (AuPPh3)6 unit behaves like a cyclopentadienyl ring. When there is only one tangential orbital as in the M(C0)4 group of [ V ( C O ) ~ ( A U P P ~ ~ or )~M ] + ~[ ~( ~ C ]O ) ~ ( A U P Pthe ~ ~elliptical ) ~ [ ~ ~ VAu6 I or planar, rhombic MnAu3 structure obviously leads to a more effective overlap. Three of the frontier orbitals of the C o ( C 0 ) t group,[731as present in [Co(CO)2( A u P P ~ ~ ) ~ ]are + ,unoccupied [~~] and suitable for a combination with the orbitals of the (AuPPh3)6 fragment, to form three bonding cluster MOs. In this case the two tangential orbitals of the Co(C0): group are not degenerate, and are of different form (b2 and 2b1, Fig. 18). -The orbital 2bl would not achieve an effective overlap with a hemispherical (AuPPh3)h fragment, while with the elliptical form present in [Co(COj?(AuPPh3)6]+a better overlap is possible. In the cyclopentadienyl complex c p C o ( c O ) ~where , the cyclopentadienyl ligand is comparable to a
1.28 Homonuclear
uiid
Heterorzuclear Cluster Conipoundc o j Gold Mn(C0);
Mn(C0)j
it3
6
557
co (CO):
co ( C O ) ;
2b'
dL
C O (C 0 )11 ( C ) [ (P11jP.411)fi
Figure 18. Representation of the orbital interactions in the cluster skeletons of a) [V(CO)J(AUPP~&,]'.b'i [Mn((:O~;,AuPPh;)(,l+and c) [Co(CO)r(AuPPhi)hl+.The radial sp hybrid orbitals of the PhlPAu groups are represented as filled and open circles.
558
I Moleculur Clusters
hemispherical (AuPPh3)6fragment, this 2bl orbital is also assumed to only overlap weakly with the cyclopentadienyl ring.[731 As discussed in Sec. 1.28.3.1, the number of Ph3PAu(O) groups in the heteronuclear clusters of the type [ M ( C O ) , ( A U P P ~ ~ )is~ ,determined ]~+ by the electronic demand of the transition metal M, that requires a stable 18 electron configuration. The cluster cation [Pt(dppe)(A~PPh~)~]~+[~'] is an exception to this rule, since the central Pt atom only achieves 16 electrons by adding to the 10 d electrons of the Pt(0) atom the four electrons of the two Pt-P bonds, and the two electrons of the (AuPPh3)if fragment. For platinum it is, however, not unusual to have a 16 electron configuration.
Acknowledgements The generous support of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft and the Verband der Chemischen Industrie is gratefully acknowledged. Thanks are also due to my co-workers for their dedicated and enthusiastic cooperation. I also thank Mrs. E. Niquet for preparing the SCHAKAL diagrams.
References [I] L. Malatesta, L. Naldini, G. Simonetta, F. Cariati, J. Chem. Soc., Cliem. Commun. 1965, 212213. [2] M. McPartlin, R. Mason, L. Malatesta, J. Chem. Soc., Clzem. Commun. 1969, 334. [3] M. Manassero, L. Naldini, M. Sansoni, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. 1979, 385-386. [4] D. M. P. Mingos, Polyhedron 1984,3; 1289-1297. [5] D. M. P. Mingos, D. J. Wales, Introduction to Cluster Chemistry, Prentice-Hall, London, 1990. [6] G. Schmid, R. Pfeil, R. Boese, F. Bandermann, S. Meyer, G. H. M. Calis, J. W. A. Van der Velden, Chem. Ber. 1981, 114, 3634-3642. [7] D. M. P. Mingos, Gold Bull. 1984, 17, 5-12. [8] K. P. Hall, D. M. P. Mingos, Progr. lnorg. Chem. 1984, 32, 237-325. 191 J. Strahle, J. Orgunomet. Chem. 1995, 488, 15-24. [lo] R. Hoffmann, Anyew. Chem. Znt. Ed. Engl. 1982,21, 71 1-725. [ 111 D. G. Evans, D. M. P. Mingos, J. Orpnon7et. Chen7. 1982, 232, I7 1 - 191. [12] D. M. P. Mingos, M. J. Watson, A h . Inory. Chem. 1992, 3Y, 327-399. [13] P. Braunstein, J . RosC, Gold Bull. 1985, 18, 17-30. [14] J. J. Steggerda, Comments Inorg. Chem. 1990, 11, 113-129. [15] J. Strahle, Comments Inory. Chem. 1985, 4 , 295-321. [16] a) K. Dehnicke, J. Strahle, Angew. Chem. lnt. Ed. Enyl. 1981, 20, 413-426; b) K. Dehnicke, J. Strahle, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1992, 31, 955-978. 1171 K. Dehnicke, J . Strahle, Chem. Rev. 1993, 93, 981-994.
1.28 Honionucleav und Heteronucleav Cluster Compounds of Gold
559
[ 181 K. Dehnicke. J. Strihle, Polyhedron 1989, 8. 707-726. [I91 J. Pethe, C. Maichle-Mossmer, J . Striihle, Z. Anarg. Allg. Chem. 1998, 624, 1207-1210. [20] F. A . Vollenbroek, W. P. Bosman, J. J. Bour. J. H. Noordik, P. T. Beurskens. J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. 1979. 387-388. [21] J. Mielcke, Diploma Thesis, University of Tubingen. 1989. [22] F. A . Vollenbroek, J. J. Bour, J. W. A. van der Velden, Red. Truc. Chim. Puy.s-Bus 1980, 99, 137- 141. (231 F. Cariati, L. Naldini, Inorg. C h h . A d a 1971, 5, 172- 174. [24] P. Bellon, M. Manassero. M. Sansoni, J. Chew. Sor..,Dulton Truns. 1972, 1481L1487. (251 G. Beuter, Thesis, University of Tubingen, 1990. [26] C. E. Briant, B. R. C. Theobald, J. W. White, L. K. Bell, D. M. P. Mingos: A. J. Welch, J. Chiw. Soc., Chcrn. Conitnun. 1981, 201-202. [27] R. P. F. Kanters, P. P. J. Schlebos. J. J. Bour, W. P. Bosman, H. J. Behm. J. J. Steggerda, Inorg, Chem. 1988. 27. 4034-4037. [28] L. N. Ito, B. J. Johnson, A. M. Mueting, L. H. Pignolet, Inorg, Chem. 1989, 28, 2026-2028. 129) J. J. Bour, R. P. F. Kanters, P. P. J . Schlebos, W. P. Bosman, H. Behm, P. T. Beurskens, J. J. Steggerda, Recl. Trai>.Chim. Ptrys-Bus 1987. 106; 157-1 58. [30] K. P. Hall. B. R. C. Theobald, D. 1. Gilmour, D . M. P. Mingos. A. J. Welch, J. Chem. Soc., Cheni. Cornmiin. 1982. 528 -530. 1311 C. E. Briant, K. P. Hall. D. M. P. Mingos, J. Chem. Soc., Cheni. Cotnmun. 1984. 290-291. [32] G. Beuter, J. Striihle. A m p i . . C h t w , In/. Ed. Et7
560
I Molecular Clusters
[56] M. Laupp, J. Strahle, Z. Naturforsch. B 1995, 50, 1369-1372. [57] M. Laupp, J. Strahle, Angew. Chem. Inf. Ed. Engl. 1994, 33, 207-209. [58] D. M. Adams, Metal-Ligand and Related Vibrations, E. Arnold, London, 1967. 1591 M. Holzer, J. Strahle, G. Baum, D. Fenske, Z. Anorg. AEIg. Chern. 1994, 620, 192-198. [60] W. Hieber, € 7 . Leutert, Z. Anovg. Allg. Clwm. 1932, 204, 145- 164. [6l] S. G. Bott, H. Fleischer, M. Leach, D. M. P. Mingos, H. Powell, D. J. Watkin, M. J. Watson, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans. 1991, 2569%2578. (621 J. E. Ellis, Adti. Organoinent. Chem. 1990, 31, 1-51. 1631 B. R. Sutherland, K. Folting, W. E. Streib, D. M. Ho, J. C. Huffman, K. G. Caulton, J. Amer. Clienz. Soc. 1987, 109, 3489-3490. 1641 P. D. Boyle, B. J. Johnson, A. Buehler, L. H. Pignolet, Inorg. Chern. 1986, 25, 5-7. 165) A. Albinati, F. Demartin, P. Janser, L. F. Rhodes, L. M. Venanzi, J. Amer. Chem. SOL..1989, 111, 2115-2125. 1661 A . L. Casalnuovo, L. II. Pignolet, J. W. A. van der Velden, J. J. Bour, J. J. Steggerda, J. Amer. Clicwz. SOL..1983, 105, 5957-5958. (671 L. N. Ito, J. D. Sweet, A. M. Mueting, L. H. Pignolet, M. F. J. Schoondergang, J. .J. Steggerda, Inory. Chem. 1989,223, 3696-3701. 1681 D. E. Smith, A. J. Welch, I. Treurnicht, R. J. Puddephatt, Inorg. Cliern. 1986, 25, 4616-4617. 1691 K. Wade, Adu. Inovg. Chem. Radiochem. 1976, 18, 1-66. 1701 S. M. Owen, Poljhedron 1988, 7, 253.~283. (711 F. Scherbaum, A. Grohmann, B. Huber, C. Kruger, H. Schmidbaur, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1988, 27, 1544-1546. 1721 H. Schmidbaur, Gold Bull. 1990, 23, 11-21. 1731 T. A. Albright, J. K. Burdett, M. H. Whangbo, Orbital Interaction in Chemi,sfry,John Wiley, New York, 1985. 1741 A . L. Casalnuovo, J. A. Casalnuovo, P. V. Nilsson, L. H. Pignolet, Inorg. Chem. 1985, 24, 2554--2559. 1751 B. D. Alexander, A. M. Mueting, L. H. Pignolet, Inorg. Chem. 1990, 29, 1313-1319. 1761 L. N. Ito, A. M. P. Felicissimo, L. H. Pignolet, Inorg. Chem. 1991, 30, 387-396. 1771 J. J. Bour, P. P. J. Schlebos, R. P. F. Kanters, W. P. Bosman, J. M. M. Smits, P. T. Beurskens, J. J. Steggerda, Inorg. Chim. Acfa 1990, 171, 177-181.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.29 Naked Clusters of the Post-Transition Elements Stcfun Ulvenlund and Lars Bengtsson-Kloo
1.29.1 Introduction Compared with the transition-metal cluster chemistry, the post-transition element counterpart may appear as a bewildering jungle inhabited by bizarre molecular objects. In Figure 1 a typical transition-metal cluster“’ is compared with two examples from the cluster chemistry of mercury’21and sulfur.[31The selection of clusters for Fig. 1 is somewhat biased in order to clearly demonstrate the following points: 1. Whereas the transition-metal clusters are ligand-supported (in the typical case by
carbonyls), the post-transition element clusters are most often unsupported and/ or destabilized by the interaction with ligands; hence the use of the term “nuked cluster”. 2. The transition-metal clusters often display highly symmetrical metal frameworks, normally with symmetries derived from the platonic or archimedian solids or variations thereof. The post-transition element clusters, on the other hand, are not necessarily affected by such confinements. However, as will be explained in Sec. 1.29.4, relationships between the structure and the electron count do exist for the naked clusters. and regular, closed geometries are found for a rather large group of these species. For instance, the trigonal prismatic symmetry of the Rhh framework in Fig. I A is also found in the naked tellurium cluster Te64+ 141 From the structures shown in Fig. I , the need for a broad definition of the term “cluster” is obvious. Throughout this review, a “cluster” will therefore be defined as an aggregate oj t1i-o or more like atonzs connected by direct and substuntiul elementelwmwt bonds. This sweeping definition allows for an unscrupulous inclusion of molecular and ionic rings, cages and chains under the common heading “cluster”.
562
A
I Moleculav Clusters
W
f
B
C
Figure 1. A biased comparison between transition and posttransition element clusters. The figure shows the cluster frameworks and surrounding atoms at bonding distances in (A) the carbon-centered carbonyl cluster RhsC(CO)is, (c)S I ~ A S F and ~)~, ( B ) the infinite and crystallographically incommensurate mercury chains in Hg3-,y(AsFg).
With reference to Fig. 1 it should be obvious that such broad-mindedness is desirable when main-group clusters are concerned. However broad and sweeping, the definition does not account for the large number of hetrvoatomic aggregates which do, intuitively, belong to the class of “clusters”. Since the bulk of this text concerns homoatomic species, this problem is a bearable one. Another term which will frequently be used is “sub-valence”. This term will hereafter be defined as it normally (but implicitly) is, namely as a n unusually low, positive oxidation state, which generally will not be stable in aqueous solution. The two terms “sub-valence” and “cluster” are intimately connected in the sense that all naked, cationic post-transition element clusters are sub-valent species.
1.29.2 Synthesis & and stabilization of cationic clusters 1.29.2.1 Historic overview and fundamental concepts The first synthesis of a naked cluster was probably performed around 1798, when Klaproth reported that the newly discovered element tellurium slowly dissolves in
1.29 Nuked Clusters of the Post-Transition Eletwents
563
sulfuric acid to give a red solution.[" It took more than 150 years until the true nature of the species responsible for this coloration was revealed. Finally, in 1968 Gillespie and co-workers unambiguously showed that the species is the sub-valent cluster Te4'+, 1.[61 By that time, however, such cationic clusters had already been isolated and structurally characterized in the solid state. In 1961 Corbett and coworkers reported the unprecedented Big5+ cluster, 2, which was found to be present in the sub-chloride Bi6C17, isolated from molten Bi-BiClj mixtures.['] The structural characterization of this compound ended a long discussion about the subchlorides of the Bi-BiCIj system that had started with Heintz' studies on the system in 1844.[81Historically, the chemistry of the cationic, naked clusters of the posttransition elements may thus be said to be an off-spring of molten-metal salt chemistry['] and of the chemistry of very strong mineral acids (later to be supplemented by the "superacids").
,-
1
2
The observation that the media used in these pioneering syntheses of cationic clusters ( o h m and BiC13) are both very strong acids is important. Indeed, the concepts of Lewis acidity and aci~-.srahili=ation['o,' are central to the understanding of the formation of subvalent species in general and naked cationic clusters in particular. In order to understand why, consider the simple reaction ( I ) , in which a subvalent species M,,"+ disproportionates to the normal-valent compound MXh and the parent metal M in the presence of the Lewis base X-.
The heart of the acid-stabilization concept is a consequence of the thermodynamics of reaction (1): if X forms strong bonds with M h + ( i e . if X- acts as a strong Lewis base), then disproportionation of M,,"' will be strongly driven by the favorable change in enthalpy. Weak Lewis bases ('non-coordinating' anions)" would therefore be expected to be beneficial for the stability of sub-valent species. In other words, the thermodynamic stability of M,7"t in a given system would be expected to increase upon the addition of a Lewis acid, which is stronger than the
564
1 Molecular Cliislevs
normal-valent oxidation state of the element M in reaction (1). These expectations are nicely borne out by numerous experimental observations, and the reactions in the Sb-SbC13 and Sb-SbC13-AIC13 systems serve as excellent examples. Antimony metal has a very low solubility in liquid SbC13 (0.018 mole-%) and the sub-valent species formed upon dissolution disproportionates to metallic antimony and SbCl3 upon solidification of the solution."31 The nature of the sub-valent species and the stoichiometry of the choroantimonate( 111) ions formed when SbC13 acts as a chloride acceptor are both unknown. However, the general symproportionation reaction taking place can be written as in (2).
( n - ~ / 3 ) S b+ (WZ+ a/3)SbC13 4 Sb,"'
+ Sb,,C13,n+uUp
(2)
The addition of an excess of the strong Lewis acid AlC13 results in a 200-fold increase of the solubility of the metal and blocks the disproportionation of the subvalent species observed in neat SbC13.[l4]In the Sb-SbCl3-AICl3 system, the favorable enthalpy of formation of Al,,C13,+lp ions might be considered as facilitating the dissolution of the metal and stabilizing the sub-valent compound [reaction (3)].""] The formation of chloroantimonate( 111) ions in the Sb-SbC13 system [reaction (2)]; on the other hand, is not sufficiently favorable to allow the dissolution to proceed to an appreciable degree or to stabilize the sub-halide. (U
-
n/3)Sb
+ (a/3)SbCI3 + (a . m)AlC13
+
Sb,"'
+ ~ A l ~ C 1 3 ~ , +(3) ,~
Born-Haber cycles have been used by Passmore et al. to rationalize the thermodynamic stability of a large number of AsF6- salts of cluster cations.[15' The calculations correctly predict the stability of most characterized compounds and also give indications that some compounds, which never have been synthesized in spite of great efforts (ey. AsF6- salts of monoatomic halogen cations), are unstable. This success confirms the argument that the formation of sub-valent cations is mainly enthalpy driven and that a Coulombic treatment of their solid compounds often is a reasonable approximation. To summarize, the naked post-transition element clusters normally present themselves in strongly Lewis-acidic solutions and in solid compounds, which are ionic in the sense that their structures contain large, weakly coordinating anions separated from the cluster cations at van der Waals or weakly bonding distances. The latter fact has given rise to the expression "anti-coordination chemistry" in connection with such cluster compounds.[' 'I
1.29.2.2 Molten salts and related routes The synthesis of cluster compounds and sub-valent species in molten salt solution was mainly developed by Corbett and his co-workers.["] In this section and
1.29 Nnkcd Clusters of the Post-Trunsition Elements
565
throughout the review. the term “molten salt” is used liberally to denote molten halides whose melting points are above room temperature. Many of these (e.q. SbClI, AlCll, GaClI) are low-melting and not appreciably dissociated in the liquid state; they are, strictly speaking, molecular solvents. Historically, however, the solution studies of halides with elevated melting points have been considered a part of molten salt chemistry,‘”’ irrespective of the microscopic constitution of the melts. The most obvious and frequently used route to sub-valent species in molten halide solution is the reduction of a normal-valent halide with its parent metal, i.e. symproportionation reactions such as (2). This methodology is natural, since it disfavors disproportionation of the sub-valent compound to the zero-valent state according to ( 1 ) . In addition, the methodology minimizes the number of components in the system. Post-transition metal-molten salt systems from which solid, subvalent compounds have been isolated through symproportionation reactions are summarized in Table 1. Table 1. Metal-molten salt systems in which solid, sub-valent compounds with metal-metal bonds
have been synthesized by symproportionation or similar reactions. The many sub-halides of gallium and indium have been omitted. These compounds contain either sub-valent monoatomic cations [ c . ~ .(Ga-)!GaCl;)l””* and (In+)(C1-:]1172~ and/or ligand-stabilized metal-metal bonded nnioizs [c,.y. (Ga+)2(Ga2Xh2-).X = B r , For a review of the sub-valent chemistry of the group 13 metals, see refs. 155, 174, 175, and 1761.
*”
Metal-molten salt system Cd -CdC12-AICI: Hg-Hg2Clz -AlCl: Gd SbCIq GaCI: BI-BIX~,X = C1. Br BI-BIXJ, X = Br, I Bl-CaCl: BI BICII-AICI: Bi-BiCIq-GaCI: Bi-In BiCli BI-BICI:-HfC14 BI- BiCIq-ZrCI4 Bi-BiBr:-ZrBra Se-SeCIJ- AICI: Se SeCIJ NbCls Se SeBr4 TaBr, Te TeCIq- AICI: I2
ICI AICIq
Isolated solid phases
Ref. 1211, 212,300-3021 [213. 215, 2161 [291 [ 16, 68, 259. 3031 1259, 260. 3041 [281 [200, 2481 1200, 201 I [291 [3051 [247I [ 306)
PO51 1234, 3071 1308I ~ 9 1 1191 1307, 3091 1307, 3091 12351
W1
566
1 Molecular Clusters
Table 2. Gaseous heats of formation, dH,b[AX-], for a number of Lewis acid-base AXcomplexes of relevance for the synthesis of cationic clusters.
Lewis acid-base reaction
AH,b[AX- ]/kJ mol-'
Ref.
AIC13 + C1- + AlC1, GaC13 + C1- + GaC1; PF5 + F- 4PF, A s F ~+ F- 4AsF; SbFs + F- + SbF,
-348 -335 -423 -465 -465
[310, 3111 [310, 3111
[3121 13121 [3 131
Many molten halides are insufficiently Lewis-acidic to allow for the formation of appreciable amounts of sub-halides through symproportionation reactions with the parent metal. As described above, the addition of an excess of a more acidic halide is the obvious way to increase the yield. The most commonly used acids of this type are GaC13 and AlC13, which are both very potent halide acceptors (Table 2). The use of inert halides as solvents for symproportionation reactions seems not to have been investigated extensively. However, such solvents may provide effective, alternative routes to sub-valent compounds. This is illustrated by the improved synthesis of Bi6C17 from Bi and BiC13 in liquid antimony( 111) chloride.[l6] A major drawback connected with the symproportionation reaction is that the number of redox reactions that can take place is limited. A more recent development, which shows obvious similarities to the traditional molten salt route, but which avoids the limitations of symproportionations, is the solid-state technique developed by Beck in which a volatile, high-valent transition-metal chloride acts both as halide acceptor and as oxidizing agent.[17]The synthesis of Tes2' by oxidation of tellurium with WC16 according to (4) is representative."']
The fact that Tes2+ has never been synthesized by symproportionation nicely proves that new, unprecedented cluster species may be synthesized if some imagination is used in the choice of oxidizing agent and Lewis acid. Other chalcogenide clusters, low-dimensional bismuth iodides and mixed clusters such as Te& 2+ have recently been synthesized by similar vapor transport r n e t h o d ~ . [ ~ ~ - ~ ' ] Similarly, liquid GaC13 can be used as an oxidizing agent for post-transition elements and affords a new synthetic route to cationic clusters.[271Thus, (Bi53+)(GaC14-)3can be synthesized from Bi-GaCls melts, 3.[2'1Investigations of the solution chemistry of the Bi-GaC13 system show that GaC13 is reduced to Ga+ by bismuth metal, while concommitantly acting as a chloride acceptor. The forma-
1.29 Nuked Clusters of the Post-Trunsition Elements
567
3
tion of Bi5(GaC14)3can be summarized according to reaction ( 5 ) 10Bi
+ (9 + 3m)GaC13
-
2Bis(GaCl4)3+ 3Ga’
+ 3Ga,,,C13,n+1-
(5)
Another way to vary the metal-molten salt theme is to change the reducing agent. This variation does not seem to have been exploited, although it implies an increase in the number of possibilities in cluster synthesis; a stronger reducing agent might be expected to be required in systems where the symproportionations fail. The attempts to synthesize antimony clusters by varying the reducing agent is a promising example.[291Thus, the Sb- SbC13, Sb-SbClI-AlCl3, and SbbSbC13-GaCl3 systems do not yield any isolable cluster species, whereas the Ga-SbC11-GaC13 one does.r291Preliminary data on the black solid phase isolated from this system are consistent with Sbs(GaC14)1, the bismuth analogue of which has been synthesized and characterized.[2*,z91
1.29.2.3 Superacids and other low-temperature systems A superacid can most conveniently be defined as a protic acid of a strength comparable with or more acidic than unhydrous sulfuric acid.[301Examples of such acids are fluorosulfuric acid (HSO3F), oleum and, more notably, mixtures of strong protic acids with strong Lewis acids such as HS03F SbFS (the “magic acid”) and HF + SbF5. On the Hammett acidity scale ( these two mixtures are the strongest acids known. A book by 0’ Donne11 gives an excellent review on solute speciation, acid-base equilibria, and the inorganic chemistry related to superHowever, most of the work performed in superacidic media to date concerns organic chemistry; such media are very suitable for the synthesis of otherwise highly unstable organic radicals and carbocations as reviewed by Olah et ul. in A~ summary l of superacids connection with the general aspects of ~ u p e r a c i d s . [ ~ which have been used in the synthesis of post-transition element clusters is given in Table 3.
+
568
I Molecular Clusters
Table 3. Superacids which have been used in the synthesis of post-transition element clusters. Superacid
Comments
bS04
High viscosity makes crystallization difficult; insufficient acidity for most cluster synthesis. High viscosity; higher acidity than anhydrous H2SO4.
H2S207
Representative reaction
HS03F
The most acidic simple mineral acid.
Oleum
Variable composition; high vapour pressure of SO3. Difficult to handle; high viscosity of reaction mixtures. Easier to handle and better crystallization medium than neat S206F2. The “magic acids”; extremely acidic.
S206F2 HS03FPS206F2 HS03F-AsFS/SbFS HF-AsF~/S~F~ HS03FPS03-SbF5
Acidity comparable to the magic acids. Used to enhance the stability of bromine cations.
+ 3AsF5 + Ss2+ + 2AsF6See magic acids. See HSO3F.
Sg
+ AsF3r3’]
The superacid route to naked clusters was pioneered and developed by Gillespie, Passmore and co-workers and has mainly contributed to the synthesis and understanding of the chalcogen and halogen cluster corn pound^.[^^-^^^ Originally, the syntheses were perfomed in accordance with Klaproth’s original but accidental synthesis of Te42+ in concentrated sulfuric acid (Sec. 1.29.2.1); i.e. one-component superacids were used both as the oxidizing agent and as the source of the necessary weak Lewis base. The synthesis of Se42+by oxidation of selenium in disulfuric acid according to (6) is typical.r371 4 Se
+ 6 H2S207
+
Se42+
+ 2 H S 3 0 K + 5 H2S04+ SO2
(6)
An inherent aspect of reaction (6), which is worth pondering on at this point, is the extreme stability of cluster compounds towards oxidation in suficiently acidic media. The stability of Se42+ towards oxidation to the Se(1V) and Se(V1) species known from aqueous solution chemistry is truly amazing considering the presence of the potent oxidizing agent H2S207. This illustration of the concept of acid-
1.29 Nuked C1uster.s of the Post- Trrmsitioti E1mctit.v
569
stabilization is perhaps more striking than those from molten salt chemistry. The stability of course disappears if the acidity of the solvent is decreased; sulfur clusters, for instance, are stable in HSO1F-SbF5 mixtures but are slowly oxidized further to give SO? in the weaker fluorosulfuric The formation of stable solutions and compounds of the halide cluster cations generally demands stronger oxidation agents and stronger acids than the chalcogens. A versatile oxidizing agent in this respect is peroxydisulphuryl difluoride, S206F2, which readily oxidizes halogens and chalcogens to cationic clusters in HSO3F or other superacidic solvents.[3y1 The oxidizing superacids are versatile and effective for the generation of clusters in solution but severe difficulties are associated with crystallization and recovery of solid cluster phases. These difficulties were to a great extent overcome by the observation that the pentafluorides of antimony and. even better, arsenic in superacidic or inert solvents quantitatively oxidize post-transition elements to cationic clusters. The method was presented in 1969 and was first used in the synthesis of the (AsF6)- salt of (Sg)’+ 4 in HF solution, according to reaction (7).i401 Sg
+ 3 ASFS
+
S ~ ( A S F+~A) s~F ~
(7)
4
The use of AsF5 as the oxidizing agent for the elements in cluster synthesis has several advantages over the molten salt route and the syntheses in “neat” superacids: the reactions may be performed in inert solvents (most often liquid S02) and the syntheses may be performed at ambient or low temperature rather than at elevated temperatures. In addition, the reaction by-products and the solvents are volatile and easily separated from the reaction mixture. Furthermore, the AsF6- ion is thermodynamically more stable than the AlCL- and GaC14- ions (Table 2), which are the protagonists of the molten salt scene. A considerable number of cluster compounds of mercury, bismuth, the halogens [ ~and, ~ to a and the chalcogens have now been prepared by the use of A s F ~ 361 lesser degree, SbF5 and other oxidizing fluorides such as NbF5 and TaF5.[41*421 More recently, the use of catalysts to promote reactions in SO2 solutions has also been developed as an additional synthetic tool.i431
570
I Molecular Clusters
In contrast to the traditional molten salt route, the superacid route has also produced numerous examples of hetevoatomic clusters, most notably mixed polychalcogen cluster cations and such aggregates containing both halogen and chalcogen atoms. For instance, mixed chalcogen A,Mn2+ clusters ( a n = 6 or 10) can be synthesized either by direct reactions of A/M alloys with AsF5 in liquid SO2 or by reaction of (Mq2+)(AsFgP)2or (Mg2+)(AsF6-)2with another chalcogen A in SO2 s o l ~ t i o n . Similarly, ~ ~ - ~ ~ reactions between sulfur, halogens and AsFs or SbFS in SO2 produce species such as S71+and S7Br+.49 5 1 An attractive extension to the possibilities of producing heteroatomic clusters in SO2 solutions of strong Lewis acids is the synthesis of new, unusual coordination compounds in the same media. and The synthesis and characterization of the triazidotellurium( IV), Te(N3)3}f,[521 pentabromodiselenium, Se2Br5+,[531 cations are but two examples. The use of Lewis-acidic metal halides dissolved in organic solvents as synthetic media is a novel approach to post-transition element cluster chemistry, and the only two solvent systems which have been studied so far are the GaCl3-benzene and, to a lesser extent, GaBr3-benzene ~ y ~ t e m . [ The ~ ~ use , ~ of~ benzene , ~ ~ - as~ solvent ~ ~ in the synthesis of clusters is convenient since the solvent is cheap, easy to handle and can be used at ambient temperatures without specially designed glassware or other dedicated laboratory equipment. Furthermore, the recovery of solid, sub-valent compounds from the benzene solutions is conveniently performed by extraction with an alkane. The sub-valent chemistry of gallium, indium, antimony, bismuth and mercury has been investigated in GaXs-benzene systems. Both gallium and indium metal dissolve in GaX3-benzene solutions to form colorless solutions of the corresponding sub-valent ions M+.[55,56,591 In contrast, bismuth metal dissolves to yield highly colored or opaque solutions in which Bi5,+, Bi+, Gat and Ga3ClloP have been identified as the reaction p r o d ~ c t s . [ ~From * , ~ ~such ] solutions, Bi~(GaC14)3may be recovered. The overall reaction is the same as that between bismuth and molten GaC13, i.e. ( 5 ) . Similarly, reaction between Bi and GaBr3 in benzene produces Bis(GaBr4), or Bis(GaBr4)z depending on reaction conditions.[591 Symproportionation reactions between Bi and BiC13 dissolved in GaC13-benzene solutions are also possible and ultimately yield Bis3+ in both chloride and bromide media.[54,591 However, strongly emerald green solutions of Bi+ can be identified as intermediates.[591Similarly, the synthesis of the alleged SbS(GaC14)3 in molten Ga-SbC13-GaC13 mixtures (vide supra) seems to be paralleled in benzene soluti~n.['~] Hg, 2+ can be synthesized in GaC13-benzene solution either by a symproportionation of Hg22+and mercury metal or by direct oxidation of mercury metal by GaC13.[581The latter route has interesting implications, since mercury metal is only very sparingly soluble in neat, molten GaC13. It therefore seems plausible that interactions with benzene stabilizes Hg, 2f in such solutions and therefore renders mercury metal more susceptible to oxidation. Cluster-arene interactions are discussed in more detail in Sec. 1.29.4.6.
+
1.29 Nuked Clusters of the Post-Transition Elements
57 1
1.29.3 Synthesis and stabilization of anionic clusters As we have seen, syntheses of cationic clusters are to a large extent a matter of keeping ligands (Lewis bases) out of the picture; similarly, syntheses of anionic. clusters are a matter of keeping electrons on a short leash. The why and how of this
struggle is the object of the following sections.
1.29.3.1 Liquid ammonia and amine solutions Joannis used solutions of alkali metals in liquid ammonia to reduce post-transition elements for the first time in 1891,[h01and subsequent contributions by Kraud6'] and Zint1[621clarified the chemistry involved. By carrying out careful electrochemical studies Zintl unambiguously showed that the post-transition elements dissolve in these media to form solutions of reduced "polyanionige Saltze" or, to use a more modern terminology, naked anionic clusters. From potentiometric titration data he also managed to give the correct stoichiometry of a rather large number of such clusters. r y . Pbg" and Sng4-, 5 . To acknowledge Zintl's contributions, such clusters were named "Zintl ions" by Corbett in 1976.[631 Zintl also found that the most convenient way to produce the solutions of the anionic clusters in liquid ammonia is to extract alkali metal/post-transition element alloys in the solvent. However, detailed solid-state characterization of the clusters is very difficult using this technique, since poorly crystalline and often pyrophoric solids are obtained once the solvent is evaporated. These troublesome solids are alkali-metal ammoniates of cluster ions,[641of which only [Li(NH1)4]3[Li2(NH1)2Sbj] ' 2 NHI seem to have been completely structurally characterized, 6.[651 Furthermore, the ammoniates most often slowly revert back to the alloy upon further loss of ammonia. The last step involves transfer of electrons from the strongly reducing cluster anion back to the alkali-metal ion and thus represents a major synthetic obstacle.
5
6
572
I Molecular Clusters
The problems of properly characterizing the compounds from ammonia solutions caused a major hiatus in the exploration of the cluster anions. However, in 1970 Kummer and Diehl reported that liquid ammonia may be replaced by more easily handled and considerably more stable polyamines, most conveniently by tetraethylenediamine (en).[66%671 Extraction of sodium-tin alloys in en and subsequent precipitation with T H F or monoglyme yields the reasonably stable compound ( Na+)4(Sng4-). 6-8en.[661 Kummer and Diehl pointed out the analogy between Sng4- and the previously characterized[681cluster cation Big5+, and a partial structural characterization was reported for ( Na+)4(Sng4-)‘ 7en.[691However, in terms of the synthesis of well-defined, stable cluster compounds, the route pioneered by Kummer and Diehl left a lot to be desired. Nevertheless, supercritical amines have recently been found to be good reaction media for the synthesis of extended chalcogenide structures.[701 Remarkably little effort has been made to identify the predominant cluster ions in ammonia and amine solution, apart from the early work of Zintl and the theses by Wilson and Lambert.[71,721 In the latter work, Sng4- and Pbg4- were characterized by spectroscopic methods although their conformations could only be inferred.
1.29.3.2 Cluster stabilization by sequestering agents A way to block the problematic back-donation of electrons from the cluster anion to the cation and thereby a way to prevent the reformation of an alloy, is to sequester the latter ion in a more effective way than is possible with neat ammonia or en. In the 1970s these sequestering agents became available in the form of macrocyclic ligands (cryptands). The formidable ability of cryptands to selectively bind and stabilize alkali metal ions is perhaps most strikingly displayed in the amazing A number of cryptands have been used in “natride” salt (cryptand-Na+)( the syntheses of Zintl ions, but the most successful is 4,7,13,16,21,24-hexaoxa-1,10diazabicyclo-[8.8.8]hexa-cosane,( N ( C I H ~ O C ~ H ~ O C ~ Hwhich ~)~N is ) hereafter, , for obvious reasons, abbreviated “crypt”, 7.
The addition of crypt to en during the dissolution of alloys of sodium and post-
1.29 Nuked Clusters of the Pnst-Trunsition Elements
573
transition elements not only greatly enhances the dissolution rate of the alloy, but also allows isolation of crystalline, well-defined compounds (salts) containing Zintl ions and sequestered sodium ions.[641The thermodynamic significance of the sequestering agent is, of course, the extremely strong complex formation between crypt and Na+, which pushes the cluster-forming reaction (8) to the right.
Most, if not all, solids containing Zintl ions and sequestered alkali metal ions are infinitely stable in the absence of moisture and oxygen. Since the original report of the solid state structures of (crypt-Na+)2(Pb5'-) and (crypt-Na+)4(Sng4-) in 1975,[741the synthetic use of crypt has now produced compounds containing Zintl ions of germanium, tin, lead, arsenic, antimony, bismuth and t e l l ~ r i u m . [ ~ ~ , ~ ~ ~ ~ and T1Sng3-[S21have In addition, a number of mixed clusters such as been synthesized by extraction of ternary alloys. This type of synthesis has the additional potential of producing unusual coordination compounds as was first shown by Rudolph and Wilson in the synthesis of the tetratellurostannate(1V) ion, SnTed4-, by extraction of Na/Te/Sn alloys.L831Numerous group 15/16[s41and 14/16 185-871 mixed clusters (q. [Sb2Se42-])have been obtained in similar ways and the Sng4- cluster has been used as a starting material for the synthesis of the trigonal bipyramidal Sn2Tei'- anion.["] Also the nickel( 11)-phosphine adduct of Ge94-, was made by the extraction of a K4Ge9 alloy with crypt in the presence of Ni(C0)2(P P h 3 ) ~ . [ ~ ~ l
1.29.3.3 Electrochemical methods Electrochemical syntheses of Zintl ions were proposed and preliminarily investigated by E. Zintl himself as early as 1933,[901but was not revitalized until the 1980s.[83.91.921 This synthetic route, as currently applied by Haushalter et (11.,[93-9s1 involves the application of a cathodic current to an electrode made from the alloy under study in a supporting electrolyte of large cations (typically. solutions of quarternary ammonium or phosphonium salts). The cathodic production of polyanions is rapid and normally allows for the isolation of crystalline compounds in a few days. An obvious advantage of the method is that the alloy used does not necessarily have to involve a reactive alkali or alkaline-earth metal; for instance, a number of Sb,,Tei,"- species are produced in the cathodic dissolution of an SbzTe3 a l l ~ y . [ ~ ~ * ~ ~ I The Pbg4- ion has also been identified in ammonia solutions of KI by the cathodic electrolysis of lead electrodes.[961
574
I Molecular Clusters
1.29.3.4 Recent synthetic developments Recent developments have enabled stable compounds containing Zintl ions to be isolated from media, which do not comprise expensive sequestering agents such as crypt. This seems to open up wide possibilities for the synthesis of new, unprecedented cluster species. In 1983, Haushalter et al. reported that some binary alkalimetal/post-transition alloys were (quite surprisingly!) extractable in aqueous solution in the presence of (Bu4N)Br and to yield highly colored solutions.[971This observation lead to the isolation and subsequent structural characterization of the polychalcogenide salts ( Bu4N+)2(Mn2-)(M = S, Se, Te; IZ = 5-6)[971and has been of immense importance in the development of polyanionic coordination chemistry of the heavier chalc~genides.[~~l Compounds containing the Sng4- ion, previously were also isolated in the same pioneering characterized as (~rypt-K+)4(Sng~-),~~,~~ study, but they were not structurally characterized. Common solvents other than water can also be used in the extraction of alloys to produce polychalcogenide ions. For instance, the extraction of K4SnTe4 in methanol solutions of (Ph4P)Br yields . 2 CH30H.['001Extraction of the same alloy in aqueous solutions (Ph4P+)~(Te4~-) of (Me4N)Br yields (Me4N+)4(Sn2Te64-),['011which clearly demonstrates that the formation of polyanions is highly dependent on solvent and counterion and that a large arsenal of various synthetic routes is essential for the full exploitation of polychalcogenide chemistry. This area of cluster chemistry is now under rapid development." 02-1041 Extraction of alloys in non-amine solution has so far been concentrated on the production of novel metal-telluride p o l y a n i o n ~ . [Metalates ~~] of group 15 and 16 elements have been produced by solventothermal methods and superheated solvents with great success.~46~105~1061
1.29.3.5 A note on Zintl phases There is a close relationship between the solution-based syntheses of the naked clusters, as described above, and pure solid state chemistry. This relationship stems from the fact that homonuclear bonding and discrete clusters in many cases also exist within alloys of the type used in the synthesis of Zintl ions in solution. Indeed, such alloys are often to be regarded as well-defined intermetallic compounds."071 A class of intermetallics of special relevance here is the "Zintl phases" (not to be confused with non-intermetallic solids containing Zintl ions)." 08] The cluster structures in Zintl phases often have direct counterparts among the naked clusters discussed in this review and they generally follow the same structure-bonding relationships (Sec. 1.29.4.4). For instance, the classical, discrete Zintl clusters Mg4-, 5 , have been structurally characterized in Cs4Geg and K12Snl7, isolated from melts of alkali metals and the group 14 element^,^'"^*^'^^ as well as in compounds synthe-
1.29 Naked Clusters qf the Post-Transition Elements
575
sized by the use of sequestering agents as described in Sec. 1.29.3.2. However, the description of the clusters in Zintl phases as 'naked' can certainly be challenged. The very special conditions for bonding and stability, which exist within these phases (and intermetallics in general), often enable stabilization of cluster species that clearly would be unstable in most other chemical environments.[291Clusters with extremely high charge or extreme bond strain are but two examples.* Nevertheless. several molten alloys between the alkali metals and the post-transition metals display short-range ordering, i. e. Zintl clustering, analogous to those found in the corresponding solids. This provides some support to the notion that the clusters in solid Zintl phases are to be regarded as isolated or 'naked' in some sense." 12-118] However, since the Zintl anion has been acclaimed to be heavily involved in the physical properties (e.y. the "paddle-wheel" mechanism of conductivity) of the molten alloys, the interaction with cations is most likely substantial and possibly not exclusively electrostatic in character." 6,1 "I When appropriate, Zintl phases will be alluded to in the following section, but the sheer quantity of structural and other data collected in this field of chemistry['081 prohibits an extensive review within the boundaries of this work. In the following, the emphasis will continue to be on clusters which are stable in both solution and the solid state.
'
1.29.4 Structure and bonding One of the most fascinating topics in cluster chemistry is the relationship between the structure of a cluster and the number of electrons involved in the clusterskeleton bonding. In this respect, cluster chemistry is in general indebted to borane chemistry, since it was in this field that the first glimpses of such a relationship were caught. In this section, the way the electron count (hereafter abbreviated ec) of posttransition element clusters is related to their structure is described. Qualitative or semi-quantitative aspects will be put forward rather than intricate molecular orbital (MO) considerations, in order to make the arguments more general. The section is subdivided into areas dealing with electron-precise, electron-rich, and electron-poor clusters, respectively. The definitions of the words precise, rich and poor in this context follow the original ones by Mingos" 91 and are clarified along the way. The determination of the ec of naked post-transition element clusters is generally very easy (as compared to the transition-metal case) because of the lack of occupied valence d orbitals, interfering ligands and interstitial atom^.^^^^-^^^^ The ec of
'
* It should be mentioned that unusual curionic clusters may be stabilized in certain host-guest structures in the solid state. For instance, the extremely electron-poor clusters In3 and Ins have been claimed to form in zeolite A (see ref. 11 I ) .
'+
'+
516
I Molecular Clusters
a post-transition element cluster will hereafter be defined as the total number of valence s- and p-electrons of its atomic constituents minus its charge.
1.29.4.1 Electron-precise polyhedra. 5n-electron clusters The most convenient starting-point for a description of the relationship between the ec and the cluster structure is the electron-precise polyhedral clusters. The notion of these clusters as "electron-precise'' stems from the fact that the number of electrons is just correct to form traditional, localized two-center, two-electron (2c,2e) bonds along all edges of the relevant polyhedron, with one lone pair situated at each apex." 91 The electron-precise polyhedra are always three-connected; i. e. each atom in the cluster framework (corresponding to an apex in the polyhedron) is bonded to three other framework atoms. Furthermore, these polyhedra are possible only for an even number of vertices (cluster atoms), and the number of vertices must be larger than or equal to four. Balaban has given the matter a thorough treatment and has compiled a listing of possible geometries.['261It is clear that the ec in electron-precise M, polyhedra is 5n (see Fig. 2).
ec = Srz
ec = S / l
ec = 511
+2
+2
ec = S r i
+ 4 = 6n
ec = 5n + 6 = 611
Figure 2. The expected bond breakings occuring upon successive two-electron reductions of electron-precise tetrahedral and trigonal prismatic clusters. The lone-pairs of the prismatic cluster and its reduced derivatives are not shown.
1.29 Nuked Clustcw of the Post-Trunsitior.1 E1cwent.s
577
Chemical examples of electron-precise clusters include the many polyhedral C,,H, 20 (the so-called p o l y l ~ e d r ~ ? ~2 7s1)and [ ' their silicon, germanium molecules with tz I and tin analogues.['28 I 3 O 1 Also related are the organostibine clusters.[' 3 1 - 1 3 2 1 H 0moatomic examples from the chemistry of the naked post-transition element clusters are considerably more scarce. Except for the well-known P4 and As4 molecules and the Md4- ions of group 14 (which are exclusively found in Zintl none seems to have been structurally characterized. By taking hc.feroatomic Zintl ions into consideration only two more examples are added: Pb~Sbz'-['"~ and and is best described in Sn2Bi2'- .[*'I T12Tez2- has a butterfly terms of two telluride ions coordinated to two T1(I ) ions.['391
1.29.4.2 Electron-rich clusters with electron counts
< 6n
The elements of group 16 in the Periodic Table have a comparatively large number of valence electrons to be distributed over the cluster framework in which they are incorporated. Their homoatomic clusters are therefore often electron-rich in the sense that they have an electron count higher than 5n. The more electron-poor character of the elements of group 15 results in a borderline situation where cationic clusters are found to be electron-poor (Sec. 1.29.4.4), whereas the anionic ones are electron-rich. The structurally characterized, electron-rich naked clusters of the post-transition elements are listed in Table 4. The structure and bonding of naked, electron-rich clusters have been thoroughly described and discussed by Gillespie,["] Pa~smore,["~as well as by Lynes and Mingos,[' 1 9 . 1 2 1 . 1 4 0 ] R elated bonding models are the 8-N rule generalized by Grimm and Sommerfeld['"'] and the Zintl-Klemm concept normally applied to Zintl phase^.['^)*.'^^ 1441 The topology (connectivity) of M,, clusters having an electron count >517 can often be derived from the electron-precise polyhedra using a simple valence-bond In a two-electron reduction of an electron-precise polyhedral cluster, the extra two electrons must be localized as a lone pair if the overall pattern of localized 2c,2e M-M bonds and the octet configurations are to be preserved. In this valence-bond model, a two-electron reduction thus induces a cleavage of one M-M bond and consequently opens the polyhedral cluster skeleton as schematically shown in Fig. 2 for the case of the tetrahedron and the trigonal prism. In MO terms this process can be seen as the filling of an anti-bonding orbital and a subsequent rupture of an M-M bond. For each additional two-electron reduction, one M-M bond is broken; the cluster framework successively becomes more open and ut tlie limit o f a n electron count oJ'hn UIZ open ring results (Fig. 2 ) . According to this model, a further reduction, beyond an electron count of 612, produces chains (Sec. 1.29.4.3) or causes a complete disintegration of the M, moiety. Additional features must be included in the model in order to accommodate clusters with odd numbers of atoms.[361 At this point, it should be emphasized that the simple model outlined here serves
518
1 Molecular Clusters
Table 4. Characterized, homoatomic post-transition element clusters with electron counts (ec) > Sn (excluding polychalcogenides). Cluster
ec
Structure
5n + 3
Ass ring with two 3connected As atoms Two linked As11 units Square planar Trigonal prism with one capping Sb atom See As1 I 3Square planar Rather obvious . . . Square planar
5n + 4 5n + 2 Sn + 3 5n + 3 5n + 2 Sn+ 1 5n + 2
+
5n 6 5n+ 17 5n 2
Ricyclic S8 ring See Fig. 1 Square planar
5n + 6
See sS2+
+
+8
5n+ 15
Six-membered boat bridged by four Se Analogous to S1g2+
5n + 2
Square planar
5n+4
Boat
5n + 2
Trigonal prism
5n + 6 5n + 6 6n + 2
Bicyclic Tex ring Biconnected squares V-shape
5n
Characterized compounds
1.29 Nuked Clusters
of
the
Post-Transition Elements
579
Table 4 (continued) Cluster
Is
+
7+
Xe:+
ec
Structure
6n + 1 6n + 2 6n + 4 612 + I 6n + 2 6n + 2
Rather obvious . . . V-shape Planar Z-shape Rather obvious . . . V-shape See Sec. 1.29.4.3
6n + 4 6 n t 12
Z-shape Weakly bound Z-shaped Is* moieties forming zigzag chains Rather obvious
611 + 3
Characterized compounds
as a rationalization of cluster structures, not as an a priori prediction. The model deals only with the expected number of bond-breakages or bond-formations and the resulting connectivity (topology) of the clusters, not with the expected "real" structures of the reduced or transformed species (i.e. the cluster conformation). The real structure of a cluster (its conformation) is a consequence of many factors, including the obvious electron-electron and core-core repulsion, core-electron attraction, and (in the solid state) packing effects. Also, and more interestingly, the possibilities of weak intra-cluster bond formation must be taken into account. Such bonds may stem from the possibility of delocalizing electron density from anti-bonding MOs to empty AOs (i.e. unoccupied d orbitals in the case of post-transition elements)[361or from the formation of n*-n* bonds. The theory of the latter type of bonds were first developed by Bannister[1451 and later refined by G i l l e ~ p i e [ 'and ~ ~ ]Gleitner.[I4'] For instance, it is possible to explain the weak cross-ring interactions of Ss2+ and Ses" (Fig. 3) in a satisfactory way using the concept of n*-n* bonds, 4.[15] This argument that a two-electron reduction of a given cluster results in a more open cluster framework has been experimentally verified numerous times. However, some electron-rich cluster species refuse to conform to the simple models and instead adopt structures which are blatantly rule-breaking. Thus, the Tef,4f cluster is found to adopt the trigonal prismatic structure of an electron-precise 5n-electron c l ~ s t e r , [ ~ *in' ~spite ~ , ' of ~ ~the ~ fact that its ec is 5n + 2. An ec of 5n + 2 suggests that one of the bonds should be broken and that a Czr boat conformation would be more stable (Fig. 2). The anomalous structure of Te,j4+ has been explained by arguments of varying sophistication. The bonds within the triangular faces of the Te64t prism (2.68 A)are found to be considerably shorter than those between these faces (3.13 A), which led Gillespie to describe the anomalous structure of Te,j4+ as
580
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 3. The incommensurate crystal structure of Hgi-,F(AsF6).
a resonance hybrid of resonance structures which all conform to the expected structure of a 5n 2 cluster (for instance 8 and 9).[4,361 Passmore et al. has elaborated on the Te64f theme using MO theory.['51 They pointed out that the cluster may be described as a Te32+ dimer in which the two monomeric units are bound by a 6c,4e TC* - TC' bond, thus giving support to the general idea that electron delocalization plays an important r61e in the structure of Finally, semi-empirical and ab initio calculations have also been used in 511 Density functional attempts to understand the structure of Te64+ . studies suggest that the relatively high charge on the cluster is the main reason for its anomalous structure, since the charge is more evenly distributed when it is delocalized in the prismatic conformation than when localized in the boat conformation.[I5 Obviously, subtle electronic factors are sometimes of great importance in the structure of naked clusters.
+
[140915031
8
9
The four-membered 22-electron clusters of the post-transition elements seem to further emphasize this trivial observation. According to the simple valence-bond model, the conformation of these 5n + 2 clusters is expected to be the butterfly
1.29 Ncikcd Clusters
of'the Post-Transition
Elements
58 1
shape (CI", Fig. 2). On the other hand, detailed ah initio and EHMO calcul a t i o n ~ ' show ~ ~ . that ~ ~ two ~ stable conformations are possible for both 20- and 22electron M4 clusters: Td and C,, for the 20-electron case and Czv and D4h for the 22-electron case. In reality. the only characterized 4n 2 electron M4 cluster that conforms with the valence bond predictions is Si46p.['j 3 ] However, the iso-electronic M4 clusters of sulfur, selenium, tellurium, antimony and bismuth are squares (D4h) and their bonding is best described in terms of delocalized p7c-p7c bonds, ~0,[15.140,154-1~6]
+
10
As pointed out by Passmore ef d.''51 these species are both validating and violating the "double-bond rule". This rule states that elements of the second row form thermodynamically stable double bonds, whereas elements of lower rows do not."571 The M41t cations ( M = S, Se. Te) and M41p anions (M = Sb, Bi) obviously contain thermodynamically stable 7c-bonds (albeit delocalized) and therefore violate the rule. At the same time, however, the dimerization of [M=M]' units to M4*+ results in a lowering of the number of double bonds per M, which is in agreement with the rule. On the other hand, the stubborn reluctance of 0 2 ' to dimerize to O 4 I t is probably a reflection of the strength of the 0=0double bond relative the corresponding single bond.[151
1.29.4.3 Electron-rich clusters with electron counts >6n The cationic clusters formed by chlorine, bromine and iodine are invariably Xnf ( n = 2, 3 or 5 ) chain fragments, which occasionally interact to form more elaborate structural motifs (Table 4). Chains are also a dominant topology for the polyphosphides and polyphosphanes,"581 as well as of the polyhalidesr'591 and poly~ h a l c o g e n i d e s . [ ~ ~ ~I' ~ ~The ~ ' " ~propensity ~' for chain formation rather than rings or closed structures forming can be ascribed as a direct consequence of the ec of these catenated species. All known cationic halogen clusters as well as the polychalcogenides and polyhalides have electron counts larger than 6n and would therefore. as discussed above, be expected to be open chains, in accordance with what is observed.
582
I Molecular Clusters
+
The Br2+ and 12’ ions are paramagnetic (ec = 13 = 6n 1) species, which have been isolated as their fluoroantimonate(V) salts (Table 4). In terms of MO theory, the unpaired electron resides in a singly occupied n* orbital (a n* SOMO:, and these ions may therefore be termed n*-radicals.[’’I Whereas Iz(Sb2FI1) is paramagnetic,[’611the salts I*(AsF6) and I*(SbF6)(Sb3F14)are found to be diamagnetic and to contain ( I 2 + ) 2 d i m e r ~ . [ ’ ~This ~ ” ~dimerization ~] is hardly surprising; 12’ has a bond order of 1.5 and is thus violating “the double-bond rule”. However, due to the electron count of 142f a bonding situation analogous to the chalcogen M42f rings is out of question; in 142+there are too many electrons to allow for the formation of a delocalized 5pz-5pn system. Furthermore, the 1-1 distances of 142+ vary greatly, Passmore et al. have described the bonding in the 142’ dimer in terms of a z*-n* bond formed by a positive overlap of the n*-SOMO’s of the 12’ units, ll.“sl Or
1 0
I 0 0 1
11
1.29.4.4 Electron-poor clusters. Electron counts <5n Polyhedral clusters in which the electron count is less than 5n are “electron-poor’’ in the sense that the number of skeleton electrons is insufficient to form localized, 2c,2e bonds. Instead, models involving 3c,2e bonds or full global electron delocalization (’three-dimensional a r o r n a t i ~ i t y ) [ ’ ~ ~must - ’ ~ ~be ] invoked to describe the bonding c~nditions.[’’~~ Electron-poor naked clusters are, as would be expected, formed by the early post-transition elements in groups 13 and 14. In addition, the cationic clusters of group 15 are electron-poor. Examples, derived from the compilation in Table 5, include the iso-electronic Pbg4- and Big” clusters and the 22-electron M5 species of thallium, tin, lead, antimony, and bismuth. A notable feature of the formally naked, electron-poor clusters of group 13 is their absence in solution and in solids synthesized by solution techniques; they seem to present themselves exclusively in intermetallics (Zintl phase^).['^*^'^^' For instance, the TIs7- cluster is found together with T177- in the ternary Zintl-phase Na2K21T11g,[1681but the necessarily high charge of such group 13 clusters presumably makes them unstable in solution, as alluded to in Sec. 1.29.3.5.[291 In solution and non-intermetallic solids, the only stable sub-valent species of the group 13 elements are the atomic ions Ga+ and In+ and ligand-supported c l ~ s t e r s . [ ” ~ ’ ~ ~ ~ ’ ~ ~ ~ Most of the understanding of the bonding and structural relationships in electronpoor clusters has its origin in the chemistry of the boranes. L i b s ~ o r n b ’ s ~and ’~~~’~~~ William’s[’951 original systematization of the structures and bonding in these com-
1.29 Nuked Clusters of the Post-Transition Elements
583
Table 5. Characterized naked, homoatomic post-transition element clusters with electron counts (ec) < 5n. Cluster
ec
Structure
Characterized compounds
4n + 2 4n + 2 4n + 3
Trigonal bipyramid Tricapped trigonal prism See See. 1.29.4.4
4n+4
Monocapped square antiprism
411 + 2
Tetrahedron
4n + 2 4t1 + 2 4tz + 3 4n + 4
Trigonal bipyramid Tricapped trigonal prism See See. 1.29.4.4 Monocapped square antiprism
4n + 4 4n + 2 4FI + 2 4n + 3 4n + 4
Tricapped trigonal prism Trigonal bipyramid Tricapped trigonal prism See Sec. 1.29.4.4 See Sec. 1.29.4.4
4n 4n 4n 4n
+4 +5 +2 +2
Tricapped trigonal prism Puckered ring Trigonal bipyramid? Trigonal bipyramid
4n 4n
+6 +4
Square antiprism Tricapped trigonal prism
pounds has been developed and generalized to account for the bonding patterns found in both main-group and transition-metal clusters, mainly by Rudolph ("paradigm for the electron requirements of cluster^"),[^ 241 Wade ("Wade's rules")" 2 3 1 and Mingos." The structural relationship between closo-, nido-, arachno- and hypho-boranes (with ccs of 4n 2. 4n 4, 4n + 6, and 4n 8, respectively) as well as its bearings on general cluster structures are well-known and need not be described here. Sufficient to say is that these relationships are directly applicable to naked clusters if the electrons of the B-H exobonds of the boranes are supposed to correspond to lone-pairs in the clusters. The great energy separation between the valence np- and ns-electrons in heavier post-transition elements means that the
+
+
+
584
1 Moleculiir Clusters
ns-electrons generally can be assumed to fill the r61e as l ~ n e - p a i r s . " ~However, ~] the exact energy difference between these electrons can have substantial impact on the bonding conditions and degree of delocalization within the cluster framework, as has recently been shown by calculations on the closo-M5 clusters of T1, Sn, Pb, Sb, and BiLz9] The relationship between the structure and bonding of boranes and that of naked post-transtion element clusters was noticed and discussed for the first such species ever to be characterized, uiz. the Big5+ ion.[681Ironically, this cluster is an anomaly in the sense that its ec is 4n + 4, rather than 4n 2 as would be expected from its structure (vide infra). Naked, post-transition clusters with ec = 4n 2 that are adhering to the rules are exemplified by the recently synthesized, octahedral Sn62cluster core in {crypt-K+},{ (Snz-)[Cr(C0)5]3},[1971 and by the previously mentioned 22-electron MS species of thallium, tin, lead, and bismuth. The latter species all adopt the expected trigonal pyramidal structure, 3. Recent developments in the field include the isolation of the group 14 analogue Ges2- with the aid of sesquestering agents[751and a confirmation of trigonal bipyramidal structure of Bii3+ in solutions and Fluxional behavior of the closo-M5 clusters in solution has been shown to be unlikely, since the square pyramidal (C4") structure is not energetically available.[291 Nice examples of nido-clusters from the world of naked clusters are provided by the (4n 4)-electron clusters Geg4- and Sn94-,[9931993b 0th of which are monocapped square antiprisms obtained by removing one of the capping vertices of the MI" closo-structure, the bicapped square antiprism. The squareantiprismatic (4n+6)-electron cluster Big 2+ provides an example of an arachnocluster, 12.['6,200,2011
+
+
+
f k
A few electron-poor naked clusters containing an odd number of electrons are known, namely the 39-electron clusters Geg3-, Sng3-, and Pbg3- (ec = 4n 3).[76-791 These M9 clusters present a challenge for the closo/nido structural relationship since they are electronic intermediates between the two types. However, the closolnido concept also seems to be valid also for the 39-electron clusters; the structure of all three clusters are found to be intermediate between the "pure" closo-
+
1.29 Naked Clusters of the Post-Transition Elements
Figure 4. Two different views of the tlo\o-Ms [tricapped trigond prism) dnd m d o - M ~(monocnpped square antiprism) clusters showing the striking geometrical similarities between the two cases.
Moiioc,ippwl \(I.
aiilipri\ni,
C4,,
585
Tricapped triganal pi-ism, qh
(tricapped trigonal prism) and nido-structures (monocapped square antiprism), albeit somewhat closer to the &.so-structure. The family of naked 40-electron (4n 4) Mg clusters display two puzzling features: firstly, the structural chw/nido anomaly of B & - alluded to above and, secondly, the fluxionality on the NMR-timescale of the Mg4- clusters of group 14.17' These features suggest the existence of energetically accessible isomers in addition to the expected C4, nido-structure observed in the solid state for Geg4and Sn94-.[2023 The two different anomalies are closely related and boil down to the relation between the C4, and D 3 h symmetries. Geometrically, the C4v and D3h geometries are very alike and can be converted into one another by simple atomic displacements ( Fig. 4).['04] Calculations employing EHM0,['501relativistic EHM0,'2051 and CND0[",i991 methods suggest the expected C4v symmetry to be the more stable, but they also show that the energy barrier of a C4v + &h rearrangement is low. Furthermore, the rearrangement energy was shown to decrease in the order Ge > Sn > Pb > Bi.[2051Big" may thus be expected to be particularly prone to a distortion from the ideal C4, towards the D3h doso-structure. Simple packing effects may therefore be the cause of the deviation from the expected structure of Big5' in the solid state.['991Similarly, the energy separation between the C4,, and D 3 h forms is expected to be low enough to explain the fluxionality in solution,[2021 although recent ab initio calculations have shown that the Dih closo structure is only a transition state in the rearrangement of the C4, structure.[2061 A dependence of the cluster geometry on the polarity of the solvent is also to be expected since species with C4v symmetry have an appreciable dipole moment, whereas clusters with Dih symmetry do not.[641Ultimately, the sterical non-rigidity of the Mg clusters can be traced back to the electron configuration of these species.[2071An analysis of the HOMOS and LUMOs of Ms and Mg closo-clusters show that a two-electron
+
20232031
586
I Molecular Clusters
+
reduction or a two-electron oxidation ( i e . the transformation to [4n 41- and 4nelectron clusters, respectively) in both cases result in clusters with stable electron configurations, albeit with a slightly lower overall bond order than the original c l o s o - c l ~ s t e r . This [ ~ ~ is~ ~not ~ ~true ~ ~ for other M, cfoso-clusters (n < 1 l), where such changes in the ec produce clusters which are susceptible to Jahn-Teller distortion. Thus, 4n- and (4n 4)-electron h& and M9 species are also electronically stable in the closo-conformation, whereas other M, clusters with such ecs are not. A nice confirmation of this is the stability of the BsC18 and BgC19 molecules, both with ec = 4n.L2081 Certain types of heteroatoms are readily incorporated in the nine-membered, electron-poor clusters of group 14 as shown by multinuclear NMR spectroscoSn9-xGex 4- ,[71,83,2031 T1Sns5-,[831 and pic studies of Sng-xPbx4-,[71*91,202,2031 Sn8-xPbxT15-[2031 (x = 0-9) in en solution. All these species are found to be fluxional on the NMR timescale and a definite elucidation of their structure in solution is therefore not possible. However, the clusters T1Sng3- and T 1 s b ~ ~have been structurally characterized by crystallography and investigated by theoretical method^.[*^,^^^' The clusters adopt the cfoso-structures expected form their ec (4n + 2): bicapped square antiprismatic for T1Sng3- and tricapped trigonal prisThe stability of heteroatomic, electron-poor cluster frameworks matic for TlSns may seem surprising considering the delocalized nature of the bonding; superficially, a heteroatom can be expected to disturb the delocalization and thereby lower the stability. However, as pointed out by Corbett, many deltahedra and deltahedral fragments have non-equivalent positions “whereby heteroatoms presumably can be better accommodated”.[641
+
’-.
1.29.4.5 The bonding of cluster species in group 12 The principles of the bonding in the linear cations of group 12 are quite different from what has been discussed so far. The electron configuration of the group 12 metals zinc, cadmium, and mercury is (n - l)d”ns2, which means that these elements to a large extent have to rely only on s electrons for their bonding and that they consequently, as far as cluster chemistry is concerned, behave as being extremely electron-poor. The number of valence electrons is not sufficient for the formation of closed structures and the option is to form linear chains and chain fragments, as observed. The bonding in the dimers Mz2+ (M = Zn,[209,2101 Cd,[211,2L21 Hg) as well as in the more reduced species Hg32+r41,214-2161 and Hg42+,[41,217,2181 is easily accounted for by a simple valence-bond model and does not seem to call for further comment. However, the inter-chain Hg-Hg distances found for Hg42+ suggest an appreciable bonding and there is a tendency to form infinite zigzag chains. This tendency is fully developed in the fascinating, infinite mercury chains found in the non-stoichiometric, crystallographically incommensurate phases Sb,r2211 Nb,r2221 Ta (Fig. 1).[2221 The chains behave Hg3-s(MF6), M = As,[2,21932203
1.29 Nuked Clusters qf the Post-Trunsition Elements
587
as one-dimensional metal fragments and the bonding (however unique and interesting) is more akin to metallic bonding than to cluster bonding.[2232271 Possibly, a similar view also applies to the little studied compound Hg,(MF6) ( M = Nb, Ta), into which Hg3-n( MFc,) can be transformed.[421In Hg3(MF6) the one-dimensional structural motif of Hgip0(MFh) is replaced by two-dimensional Hg-nets. Recently, low-dimensional mercury clusters have also been characterized by means of X-ray diffraction and electron microscopy in Hgx(Ti&) compounds with close relations to the fluoroniobate and - t a n t a k e corn pound^.^^^^^^^^^ The triangular HgJ4+ and Hg2Agi+ clusters have been isolated with the aid of ~ ~ ~Hg-Hg ~] distances are typically diphosphines,[230-2321 and as a r s e n a t e ~ . The 0.15-0.20 A longer than in the linear Hg,,’+ clusters, which is logical considering the formally smaller number of 6s electrons available for Hg-Hg bonding.
1.29.4.6 Em-cluster bonding. Are the naked clusters really naked? Specific cluster-counterion and/or inter-cluster interactions are evident in many solid structures containing formally naked clusters. With the exception of the mercury clusters, these interactions are generally weak enough to validate the notion of the cluster as “naked”. However, they are nevertheless interesting since in some cases they influence the cluster structures. In addition, the cation-Zintl ion and inter-cluster interactions are of interest since they represent bridges to the structures found in Zintl phases and other inter metallic^.[^^] The charge-transfer interaction between fluoroantimonate( V ) anions and M4’’ cluster cations (M = Se, Te) has been thoroughly discussed[2341and 35Cl NQR studies have been undertaken in order to elucidate the interaction between chloroaluminate( 111) ions and cluster cations in salts of I3+, 15’: Te42f, Hg3’’ and Bi5 .12 3 . 2 3 s 1 The results imply that the anion-cluster interaction is predominantly ionic in 13(AlC14),IS(AIC14),Te4(AlC14)2,and Bi5(AlC14)3,whereas an appreciable covalent nature is evident in Te4(A12C17)2 and, especially, in Hg?(AIC14)2.In general, the covalent nature of the cluster-counterion interaction is very pronounced in cluster compounds of mercury. Thus, the nearest-neighbor Hg-Cl and Hg-F disand tances in tetrachlorometallate and hexafluorometallate compounds of Hg, Hg4’+ are short and do not lend support to the idea that these compounds can be 0n the contrary, the structures are better described described as ionic.[41.s8.214~2181 in terms of molecular entities and an essentially linear Hg-Hg-X coordination. Indeed, it is well known that the group 12 element dimers M2’+ in general and Hg2’+ in particular are only metastable in the absence of ligands along the M-M vector direction. The necessity of a reasonably electronegative ligand to stabilize Hg2‘+ was explored by Schwerdtfeger and c o - w o r k e r ~ . [ ~However, ~~’ Hg2?+ forms complexes with arenes in SO2 solution,[2371and recent experimental data for the Hg-GaC13-benzene systems (Sec. 2.3) are best rationalized in n = 2 or 3, moieties in a quasi-trihapto coordination mode, terms of Hg,,(C6H6)2~’,
’
’+
588
I Molecular Clusters
13.[581 Such moieties are closely akin to the Hg22+-mesitylene structure in [Hg(CgH12)A1C14]2[23x1 and presumably also to the (Hg22+)(CsH6)2 complexes in the structurally uncharacterized [Hg(C6H6)AlC14]2.[2"1 Thus, it seems that weak Hg-C bonds may help to stabilize the mercury chain clusters, an idea that is lent further support by the spectroscopic data of [ H ~ ~ ( C O ) ~ ]1)2.[2401 (S~~FI
Cluster-benzene interactions have also been proposed to be of importance in solutions of Bi53+.[2x1Bearing the configuration of the HOMO of Bis" in mind,[29.1981 the trigonal bipyramidal structure of As2(AICp*)3(Cp*=C5Me5)with the Cp*s coordinated to the equatorially located A1 atoms, is in good agreements with these However unsupported by solid-state structural data, the proposed cluster-arene interactions are also in good agreement with the extensive literature on complexes between arenes and sub-valent ions,[2421 recently highlighted by the spectacular C s ~ ( c p ) ~entity[2431 and buckyball complex T l ( C 6 0 P h ~ ) . [ ~ ~ ~ ] Specific interactions between Zintl ions and cations in salts of cryptated cations are very limited because of the effective sequestering of the cation. Without the presence of effective sequestering agents the situation changes considerably. In Rb3As7.3en (en = ethylenediamine),[2"51N a 4 P 1 4 . 6 e n , [ ~and ~ ~ ]Na&19.7en,[~~] the cations are found to bridge between the cluster anions. In the case of Na4Sn~.7en, the bridging results in severe distortion of the approximately tricapped trigonal prismatic Sng4- clusters. A bridging function for the cations is even more pronounced in the compound (crypt-K+)3(KSng3-), which was synthesized from a solution where the amount of crypt (accidentally) was insufficient to ensure a stoichiometric sequestering of the cations.[24h1The structure contains nominal Sng4ions linked into infinite chains by K+ ions. The nature of the counterion in solid cluster compounds can have a major impact on cluster stability, even in compounds where the cluster-counterion contacts are found at van der Waals distances and the cluster-counterion interaction thus can be regarded as non-specific. For instance, Bile( HfC16)3[2471 and Bi5(MC14)3(M = Al, Ga)[293200324x1 all contain bismuth in the formal oxidation state +0.6, but the former compound is made up of the sub-valent species Bi+ and Big5+,whereas the two
1.29 Nuked Clusters oj the Post-Tvcmsition Eletnents
589
latter contain only Bis". The species are related to one another by the disproportionation reaction 19). 2 Bi5'+
i
+ Bi'
Big''
(9)
The formal disproportionation of Bi53 ' , which occurs in the presence of HfC16'-, is obviously caused by the higher charge and larger size of the anion as compared to MCL-. Dikarev rt al. have treated this problem with a model based on a hypothetical close-packing of anions around the clusters.[24y1A situation reminiscent (but even more intricate) of the formal solid-state disproportionation of Bi53+ is found in the three compounds (crypt-K)3Geg,2,5en,['9y1 (crypt-K)?Geg,PPh3 ," " and (crypt-K)3Geg.0.5en,[781which have already been mentioned (Sec. 1.29.4.4). Although the K : Ge ratio is identical in these compounds, the former compound is a mixed-valence compound containing two types of diamagnetic clusters (Geg4and Geg'-), whereas the two latter only contain the paramagnetic Ge9'- ion. This series of compounds seem to illustrate that rather subtle changes of the composition of a solid phase indeed heavily affect the stability of a given cluster, further emphasized by the analogous mixed-valence Sn94-/2p and Pbg4-12- compounds.r801
1.29.4.7 Cluster condensation and extended structures Inter-cluster bonding between the post-transition element clusters is rather common. Both Hg4" and 12 chain fragments inter-connect, as already discussed in the Secs. 1.29.4.3 and 1.29.4.5, and the cationic cluster chemistry of tellurium has been shown to contain examples of similar, but more elaborate inter-cluster bonding.i17.2501 In (Teg'-)(WC16-)2 the inter-cluster Te-Te distance is found to be short (3.4 A) and indicative of substantial bonding.["] This intercluster bonding pattern may be said to be fully developed in Te7(WOBr4),[2s and T ~ ~ ( A S F ~where )?[~~~' polymeric (Te7'+ ) cations are found, 14.
'
14
Such low-dimensional chalcogenide compounds are discussed in a recent review by Beck.'2s01Also, a large number of chalcogenide and a smaller number of pnic-
590
I Molecular Clusters
tide metallates display low-dimensional b e h a v i ~ r . [ ' 3~- 2.5~6 1~ S'imilarly, the As214cluster consists of two linked As11 and the compound BaSn? formally contains chains of face-sharing s1-16~~ octahedra.[' Weak inter-cluster bonding is also evident in structures such as (Bi~2+)(A1C14-)2.['6,2011 Some sub-halides contain extended structural motifs, which are derived from the extended structures of the cluster-forming element itself. The one- and two-dimensional structures of the bismuth sub-bromides and sub-iodides BiX,[259,2601 Bi 1414, 15,[251 and Bi1814[2611 (reviewed and discussed by Dikarev et a1.)[2491 comprise Bi-Bi chains and nets, which are clearly related to the structure of metallic bismuth. Similarly, the lower halides of tellurium (Te3C12 and Te2X; X = C1, Br, 1)[262-2641 show structural similarities with elemental tellurium. Inclusion of heteroatoms into such sub-halides gives rise to very intriguing structural chemistry, as shown by the recently reported mixed bismuth sub-halides BiS gNi51,[26s1 B ~ ~ ~ R U ? B and I - ~the ~ . highly [ ~ ~ ~exciting I Bi7RhBrg, containing a molecular, pentagonal bipyramidal (RhBi7)Brs cluster with an interstitial Rh atom.[26x1 Thus, the bonding features in sub-valent compounds not only provide a link to the structures of Zintl phases, but also to the structures of the elements. This latter aspect is also emphasized by the note on the structure of amorphous red phosphorous.[2691
15
1.29 Nuked Clusters qf the Post-Transition Elements
591
1.29.5 Reactions and extensions The reaction chemistry of the naked post-transition element clusters is still a rather white spot on the map of cluster chemistry. To a large extent this is a consequence of experimental difficulties and the often extreme redox conditions. Thus, the reactions of anionic clusters are often trivial results of their strong reducing capacity[681and their cationic counterparts are often exceedingly strong oxidizers. An extreme example is of course (Oz+)(BF4-),which oxidizes xenon to its unipositive oxidation state.[2701 However, the reactivity of other chalcogenide and halide cluster cations can be harnessed. Thus, ME’+, M = S, Se, react with tetrafluoroethylene to ‘-2721 and Ifl+, n = 2,3, yield his( perfluoroethy1)-polychalcogenides,(C2F5)2Mn[27 reacts quantitatively with his( perfluoroethyl)diselenide, (C2F5)2Se2,to give the corresponding salts of the [Se(C*H5)I# cation.[273113’ also reacts with various nitrogen-containing organic molecules to form novel organic cations such as CH3NI+ and cationic derivatives of pyridine, C ~ H S N I + . ‘ ~ ~ ~ ] Perhaps of more general interest are reactions involving transition-element species. The high solubility of many transition metal complexes in SO2 make reaction between such compounds and cationic clusters possible. Thus, Se4” reacts with The ] *cluster .[~~~] W(C0)g in SO2 solution to yield the cluster ion [ W ~ ( S ~ ~ ) ( C O ) I O was isolated as its SbFb- salt in 1985 and shown to contain [WSe2(C0)5+]2dimers weakly interacting through Se-Se bonds. At the same time, the molybdenum analogue was independently synthesized and structurally characterized by another research Although synthesized by a different route, the [M(C0)3($The cations in these Te3)](SbF6)2 (M = Mo, W ) compounds are compounds comprise the first ever characterized three-membered chalcogen rings and have a “piano-stool” geometry with the M(CO)3 moiety sitting below the center of the Te32t ring plane, 16. Other examples include the As6 and As4 structures stabilized by Cp*Co and Cp*Fe.r27y.2801 Sub-valent post-transition species have been isolated also with the aid of transition-metal clusters. The groups of Venanzi, with the spectacular Hg2 unit in Hgl[Pt?(CO)i(PPh-i-Pr2)3]2,[2811 and Puddephatt seem to be the most successful in this game.[2822841
592
1 Molecular Clusters
Many interesting transition metal complexes are also soluble in en, which enables reactions between such species and Zintl ion to occcur. This field of reaction chemistry was pioneered by Teixidor et al. who reacted Pt( PPh3)4 and Pd( PPh3)4 with Sng4- and Pb94- in en to yield PtMg4- and PdMg4- cluster cores.[285-2861 Using a similar route, the Ni( PPh3)2+ adduct of Geg4-, containing an additional interstitial Ge atom, has recently been isolated and structurally characterized, 17.[891 However, the first structurally characterized cluster formed by direct reaction between a Zintl ion and a metal complex was [CrSng(CO)3I4-,isolated as its cryptK+ salt in 1988.[2871 The CrSbg4- cluster core was found to have the closo-structure expected from its ec. Similar incorporation of transition-metal complexes into previously known Zintl anions has been accomplished for Sn94-,287and M73- ( M = P, As, Sb).[2881 However, metal-carbonyl fragments can be used also to stabilize enigmatically elusive post-transition cluster species. A nice example is the Pbg4- ion, which was unambiguously detected in solution as early as the 1930s (Sec. 1.29.2.1),but eluded isolation in the solid state for almost 60 years. In 1990, the Pbg4- core was finally isolated as the stable closo-cluster [CrPbg(C0)3]4-,[2891 iso-structural with the previously described [CrSng( CO)3]4- tetraanion. Stabilization by metal carbonyls has also produced the octahedral Sn62- closo-cluster core found in [Sns{ Cr(CO),}6I2-, the first ever synthesized and characterized six-membered, electron-deficient naked cluster,
17
18
The incorporation of transition-metal atoms into post-transition clusters may be a relatively new area of research, but the opposite process ( i e . the incorporation of
I 29 Nuked Cliwter\ of tlir Post-Trunsitiori Elements
593
post-transition atoms into transition-metal clusters) is not. This type of chemistry has been separately reviewed by Whitmire and and the bonding in transition-metal compounds containing E2 units, E = group 15 or 16 element, has been rather extensively i n ~ e s t i g a t e d . [ ~ ” ’ ~In~ “the ~ majority of cases the posttransition fragment can be regarded as a simple electron donor, a ligand. However, as pointed out by Whitmire, this simple description is not applicable to species such as [ Bi4Fe4(CO)131’- , [ 2 y 5’2y61 which can just as well be described as a tetrahedral Bi4 unit coordinating Fe(CO),,groups. It thus seems as if the cross-fertilization between transition and post-transition chemistry represented by the Zintl-metal carbonylates and their cationic counterparts can rightfully be regarded as one step on the way to a continuous cluster chemistry, which starts with the naked post-transition element clusters and ends with the well-known transition-metal counterparts. Finally, it should be mentioned that Zintl ions have found a (still) limited application in the production of surface-modified materials. Certain organic polymers can be metallated efficiently in a non-electrochemical route employing Zintl ions of tin In en Similarly, many anisotropic inorganic materials, for instance metal single-crystals and graphite, can be surface-metallated by use of Zintl ions.[2ys1 The surface reaction between Sng4- and gold crystals has been studied by electron m i c r ~ s c o p y . ’ ~ ” ~
Acknowledgements The Swedish Natural Science Research Council ( N F R ) and Human Capital & Mobility (contract no. CHRX CT93 0277) are gratefully acknowledged for their financial support.
References [l] V.G. Albano, M. Sansoni, P. Chini, S. Martinengo, J. Clzern. Soc. Dulton 1973, 651. 121 I.D. Brown, B.D. Cutforth. C.G. Davies, R.J. Gillespie, P.R. Ireland, J.E. Vekris, Can. J. Cliem. 1974, 52, 791. [3] R.C. Burns, R.J. Gillespie, J.F. Sawyer, Inorg. Clzern. 1980, 19, 1423. [4] R.C. Burns, R.J. Gillespie, W.-C. Luk, D.R. Slim, Inorg. Clienz. 1979, 18, 3086. 151 M.H. Klaproth, Phil. Mug. 1798, I , 78. (61 J. Barr, R.J. Gillespie. R. Kapoor, G.P. Pez, J. Am. Clietn. Soc. 1968, 90, 6855. 171 A. Hershaft, J.D. Corbett, J. Chem Phys. 1961, 36, 551. [S] A. Heintz, Ann. Phys. 1844, 63. 59.
594
I Molecular Cluster5
[9] M.A. Bredig, in Molten Salt Chemistry, ed. M. Blander, Interscience, New York, 1964, ch. 5 , pp. 367-425; J.D. Corbett, in Fused Salts, Ed. B.R. Sundheim, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1964, ch. 6, pp. 341-407; H. Bloom, The Chemistry of’Molten Salts, W. A. Benjamin Tnc., New York, 1967, ch. 8, pp. 142-153; N.H. Nachtrieb, Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 1980,31, 131; W.W. Warren, in Anvances in Molten Salt Chemistry, eds. G. Mamantov and J. Braunstein, Plenum, New York, 1981, vol. 4, ch. I , 1-69; W.W. Warren, in Molten Salt Chemistry, eds. G. Mamantov and R. Marassi, Riedel, Dordrccht, 1987, pp. 237-257. [lo] J.D. Corbett, R.K. McMullan, J. Am. Chem. SOC.1956, 78, 2906. [I I] J.D. Corbett, Prog. Inorg. Chem. 1976, 21, 129. [ 121 The general aspects of “coordination chemistry of non-coordinating anions” have been discussed and reviewed by M.R. Rosenthal, J. Chem. Educ. 1973, 50,331; W. Beck, K. Sunkel, Chem. Rev. 1988,88, 1405; C.D. Garner, B. Hughes, Adv. Inorg. Chem. Radiochem. 1975,17, 1; N.M. Gowda, S.B. Naikar, G.K.N. Reddy, A h . Inorg. Chem. Radiochem. 1986, 28, 255; G.A. Lawrence, Chem. Rev. 1986, 86, 17. [I31 J.D. Corbett, S. Winbush, F.C. Albers, J. Am. Chem. Sue. 1957, 79, 3020. 1141 M. Serrlie, G.P. Smith, J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem. 1981, 41, 931. [15] N. Burford, J. Passmore, J.C.P. Sanders, Mol. Struct. Energ. 1989, 11, 53. [I61 J. Beck, C.J. Brendel, L. Bengtsson-Kloo, B. Krebs, M. Mummert, A. Stankowski, S. Ulvenlund, Chem. Ber. 1996, 129, 1219. 1171 J. Beck, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1994, 33, 163. 1181 J. Beck, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1990, 29, 293. 1191 J. Beck, A. Fischer, Z. Anorg. Allgem. Chem. 1997, 623, 780. 1201 J. Beck, G. Bock, Z. Naturjorsch. 1996, 51B, 119. 1211 J. Beck, M. Kasper, A. Stankowski, Chem. Ber. 1997, 130, 1189. [22] J. Bcck, G. Bock, Z. Anorg. Allgem. Chem. 1996, 622, 823. 1231 J. Beck, K. Miiller-Buschbaum, Z. Anorg. Allgem. Chem. 1997, 623, 409. 1241 E.V. Dikarev, B.A. Popovkin, Dokl. Akad. Nuuk SSSR 1990, 310, 117. 1251 E.V. Dikarev, B.A. Popovkin, A.V. Shevelkov, Z. Anorg. Allgem. Chem. 1992, 612, 118. [26] J. Beck, Chem. Ber. 1995, 128, 23. [27] S. Ulvenlund, Thesis, Lund Univ., 1995. 1281 S. Ulvenlund, L. Bengtsson-Kloo, K. Stihl, J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. 1995, 91, 4223. [29] S. Ulvenlund, K. Stihl, L. Bengtsson-Kloo, Inorg. Chem. 1996, 35: 223. 1301 R.J. Gillespie, T.E. Peel, Adu. Phys Org. Chern. 1972, 9, 1. [31] L.A. Hammett, A.J. Deyrup, J. Am. Chern. Soc. 1932, 54, 2721. [32] T.A. 0 Donnell, Super-acids and Acidic Melts, VCH, New York, 1993. 1331 G.A. Olah, G.K.S. Prakash, J. Sommer, Superacids, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1985. [34] R.J. Gillespie, J. Passmore, Ace. Chem. Res. 1971, 4, 413; R.J. Gillespie, J. Passmore, J. Chem. Brit. 1972, 8, 475. [35] R.J. Gillespie, J. Passmore, Adu. Inorg. Chem. Radiochem. 1975, 17, 49. [36] R.J. Gillespie, Chem. Soc. Rev. 1979, 8, 315. [37] J. Barr, R.J. Gillespie, R. Kapoor, K.C. Malhotra, Can. J. Chem. 1968, 46, 149. [38] R.J. Gillespie, J. Passmore, P.K. Ummat, O.C. Vaidya, Inorg. Chem. 1971, 10, 1327. 1391 R.J. Gillespie, Inorg. Chem. 1972, 11, 586. [40] R.J. Gillespie, J. Passmore, J. Chem. Soc., Chrm. Comm. 1969, 1333. [41] I.D. Brown, R.J. Gillespie, K.R. Morgan, J.F. Sawyer, K.J. Schmidt, Z. Tun, P.K. Ummat, J.E. Vekris, Inorg. Chem. 1987,26, 689. [42] W.R. Datars, P.K. Ummat, R.J. Gillespie, Mat. Res. Bull. 1985, 20, 865. [43] M.P. Murchie, J. Passmore, G.W. Sutherland, R. Kapoor, R. J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans. 1992, 503. 1441 R.J. Gillespie, W. Luk, E. Maharajh, D.R. Slim, Inorg. Chem. 1977, 16, 892. 1451 P. Boldrini, I.D. Brown, R.J. Gillespie, P.R. Ircland, W. Luk, D. Slim, Inorg. Chem. 1976, 15, 765.
1.29 Nuked Clusters ojthe Post-Transition Elements [46] [47] 1481 1491
595
G.W. Drake. J.W. Kolis, C1)ortl. C/iem. Rcr. 1994. 137. 131. W.S. Sheldrik. M. Wachhold, Anyeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Eizgl. 1997, 36, 207. M.G. Kanatzidis, A.C. Sutorik, Proy. InOU(j. Cliem. 1995, 43, 151. J. Passmore. G. Sutherland, P.S. White. Inorg. Cliem. 1982, 21, 2717. [50J J. Passmore. G. Sutherland. P. Taylor, T.K. Whidden, P.S. White, Inorg. Chem. 1981. 20, 3839. [51] J. Passmore. G. Sutherland. T.K. Whidden. P.S. White, C.-M. Wong. Can. J. Chem. 1985. 63, 1209. 1521 J.P. Johnson, G.K. MacLean, J. Passmore, P.S. White. Ciin. J. Chem. 1989, 67, 1687. 1531 M.P. Murchie, J. Passmore, P.S. White, Cun. J. Chtw?. 1987, 65, 1584. [54j S. Ulvenlund, A. Wheatley, L. Bengtsson, J. Chem. Soc., Chrm Comm. 1995. 59. [55J S. Ulvenlund, A. Wheatley. L. Bengtsson, J. Clzcm. Soc., Du//o17Trans. 1995, 245. [56] S. Ulvenlund. A. Wheatley. L. Bengtsson, J. C/iem. Soc., Da//on Truns. 1995, 255. [57] S. Ulvenlund. L. Bengtsson, J. Mid. Struct. 1994, 255. 181. [ S S ] S. Ulvenlund, J. Rosdahl. A. Fischer. P. Schwerdtfeger, L. Kloo, Eur. J. Inorg. C/zem. 1999, 633. [59] A.N. Kouznetsov, L. Bengtsson-Kloo. B.A. Popovkin, to be published. (601 A. Joannis, C. R. Hehtl. Seances Acad Sci. 1891. 113, 795. 1611 C.A. Kraus, J. Am. Cliern. So(,. 1922, 44, 1220. [62] E. Zintl, A. Harder, Z. Phys. Cliem.1931, 154A. 47; E. Zintl. J. Goubeau, W. Dullenkopf, Z. Phys. Clirm. 1931, 154A, I ; E. Zintl, A. Harder, Brr. 1933, 66B, 760; E. Zintl, H. Kaiser, 2. Anorg. Allg. Cliem. 1933, 211- 113. [63] D.G. Adolphson, J.D. Corbett. D.J. Merryman, J. A m . Chem. SOC. 1976. 98. 7234. [641 J.D. Corbett, Cliem. Rev. 1985. 85, 383. [65] N. Korber. F. Richter, Anyew. Chem. fnt. Ed Eny. 1997, 36, 1512. [66] D. Kummer. L. Diehl. Anyen,. Chem. 1970. 82, 881. [67] L. Diehl, K. Khodadadeh, D. Kummer, J. Strahle, Z. Ntiturforscli. 1976, 3/B, 522. 1681 A. Hershaft, J.D. Corbett. Inorg. Chem. 1963, 2 , 979. 1691 L. Diehl, K. Khodadadeh, D. Kummer, J. Stdhle, Clim. Ber. 1976, 109, 3404. [70] S.E. Lehman. Jr.. G.L. Schimek, J.M. Cusick, J.W. Kolis, Inorg. Chini. Actu 1997, 260, 173. [71] W.L. Wilson, Thesis. The University of Michigan, 1982. [72] L. Lambert, Diplomrr Thesis, The University of Lund, 1998. [73] F.J. Tehan, B.L. Barnett, J.L. Dye. J. Am. Chem. Soc.. 1974, 96, 7203. [74] J.D. Corbett, P.A. Edwards, J. Clzrvn. Soc., Cliem. Comm. 1975, 982. 1751 J. Campbell, G.J. Schrobilgen, fnorcj. Chem. 1997, 36. 4078. [76] S.C. Critchlow, J.D. Corbett, J. A I M .Clzem. Soc. 1983, 105, 5715. [77] V. Angilella. C. Belin, J. Cliern. Soc,.. Furaday Trans. 1991, 87. 203. [78] T.F. Fassler. M. Hunziker. h o r y . Cliem. 1994. 33, 5380. 1791 J. Campbell. D.A. Dixon. H.P.A. Mercier, G.J. Schrobilgen, fnorg. Cliem. 1995, 34. 5798. [SO] T.F. Fassler. M . Hunziker. Z. Anory. Allyem. Clzenz. 1996. 622, 837. [ S l ] S.C. Critchlow, J.D. Corbett. I m r y . Cliem. 1982, 21. 3286. 1821 R.C. Burns, J.D. Corbett. J. Am. Cliem. Soc. 1982. 104. 2804. 1831 R.W. Rudolph, W.L. Wilson, R.C. Taylor, J. Am. Clieni. Soc. 1981, 103, 2480. [84] D.M. Smith, C.-W. Park. J.A. Ibers, Inory. C/ienz. 1996; 35, 6682. [85] M. Bjorgvinsson, J.F. Sawyer, G.J. Schrobilgen, Inory. Chenz. 1991, 30, 2231. [86] M. Bjorgvinsson. G.J. Schrobilgen, fnorg. C%em.1991, 30, 2540. [87] M. Bjorgvinsson, H.P.A. Mercier. K.M. Mitchell. G.J. Schrobilgen, G. Strohe, Inory. Chrm. 1993.32, 6046. [SS] T.F. Fassler. U. Schiitz, J. Oryunomet. Chtvn. 1997. 541, 269. Int. ~ . Ed. Eng. 1996, 35, 2852. 1891 D.R. Gardner, J.C. Fettinger, B.W. Eichhorn, Amqriv. C / ~ C W [901 E. Zintl, H. Kaiser, Z. Anorg. All<].Clzein. 1933. 211, I 1 3. [911 B.S. Pons, D.J. Santure, R.C. Taylor, R.W. Rudolph. Electrocliim. Ac/u 1981, 26, 365.
596
I Molrculur Clusters
1921 B. Eisenmann, Angeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1993, 32, 1693. 1931 C.J. Warren, D.M. Ho, R.C. Haushalter, A.B. Bocarsly, Angeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Eng. 1993, 32, 1646. 1941 C.J. Warren, S.S. Dhingra, D.M. Ho, R.C. Haushalter, A.B. Bocarsly, Inory. Chew!. 1994, 33, 2709. [95] J.L. Shreeve-Keyer, R.C. Haushalter, Polyhedron 1996, 15, 1213. [96j J.B. Chlistunoff, J.J. Lagowski, J. Phys. Chem. 1997, BIOI, 2867. 1971 R.G. Teller, L.J. Krause, R.C. Haushalter, Inorg. Chem. 1983, 22, 1809. [98] L.C. Roof, J.W. Kolis, Chem. Rev. 1993, 93, 1037. [99] J.D. Corbett, P.A. Edwards, J. A m . Chem. Soc. 1977, 99, 3313. [loo] J.C. Huffman. R.C. Haushalter, Z. Anory. Ally. Chem. 1984, 518, 203. [loll J.C. Huffman, J.P. Haushalter, A.M. Umarji, G.K. Shenoy, R.C. Haushalter, Inorg. Chem. 1984,23, 2312. [lo21 M.A. Ansari, J.C. Bollinger, J.A. Ibers, Inory. Chem. 1993, 32, 231. [I031 T.M. Martin, P.T. Wood, J.W. Kolis, Inorg. C h m . 1994, 33, 1587. [lo41 S.S. Dhingra, R.C. Haushalter, Inorg. Chem. 1994, 33, 2735. [lo51 W.S. Sheldrick, M. Wachold, Angeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Eng. 1997, 36, 206. [ 1061 C. Wang, R.C. Haushalter, Inary. Clzem. 1997, 36, 3806. [lo71 R. Nesper, Anyriv. Chem. Int. E d Enyl. 1991, 30, 789. I 1081 H.G. von Schnering, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1981, 20, 33; H. Schafer, B. Eisenmann, Reo. Inor<]. Chem. 1981, 3, 29; H.G. von Schnering, Nova Actu Leopold 1985, 59, 165; H. Schafer, Ann. Rev. Muter. Sci. 1985, 15, I; H.G. von Schnering, Bol. Soc. Chil. Quim. 1988, 33, 41; S.M. Kauzlarich, Comments Inorg. Chem. 1990, 10, 75; R. Nesper, Prog. Solid State Cliem. 1990, 20, I ; J.D. Corbett, Pure & Appl. Chem. 1990, 62, 103 J.D. Corbett, Sfruct. & Bondincg 1997, 87, 157; Chemistry, Structure and Bonding of Zintl Phuses und Ions, Ed. S.M. Kauzlarich, VCH, Weinheim 1996. [lo91 V. Queneau, S.C. Sevov, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Eny. 1997, 36, 1754. [110] H.G. von Schnering, M. Baitinger, U. Bolle, W. Carrillo-Cabrera, J. Curda, Y . Cirin, F. Heinemann, J. Llanos, K. Peters, A. Schmeding, M. Somer, Z. Anorg. Allgem. Cheni. 1997, 623, 1037. 11111 N.H. Heo, H.C. Choi, S.W. Jung, M.Park, K. Seff,J. Phys. Chem. 1997, 101B, 5531. [I121 H.T.J. Reijers, W. van der Lugt, M.-L. Saboungi, D.L. Price, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 1990, 117/ 118, 56. [ 1131 H.T.J. Reijers, M.-L. Saboungi, D.L. Pricc, W. van der Lugt, Phys. Rev. 1990, 41B, 5661. [I141 H.T.J. Reijers, W. van der Lugt, M.-L. Saboungi, Phys. Rev. 1990, 42B, 3395. [115] W. van der Lugt, Phys. Scr. 1991, T39, 372. [116] M.-L. Saboungi, J. Fortner, W.S. Howells, D.L. Price, Nature 1993, 365, 237. [ 1171 R. Winter, 0. Leichtweiss, M.-L. Saboungi, R.L. McGreevy, W.S. Howells, J. Non-Cryst. Solids 1996, 205-207, 66. [118] R.D. Stoddard, M.S. Conradi, A.F. McDowell, M.-L. Saboungi. D.L. Price, J. Non-Crysf. Solids 1996, 205-207, 203. [119] D.M.P. Mingos, Nuture (Phys. Sci.) 1972, 236, 99. [120] A. Simon, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1988, 27, 159. [121] D.M.P. Mingos, Acc. Chem. Rex. 1984, 17, 1984. [122] B.K. Ted Znorg. Chem. 1984,23, 1251. 11231 K. Wade, Adz.. Inory. Chem. Radiocheni. 1976, 18, 1 . 1124) R.W. Rudolph, Acc. Chem. Res. 1976, Y, 447. [125] K. Wade, Chem. Brit. 1975, 11, 177. [126] A.T. Balaban, Rev. Roum. Chim. 1966, 11, 1097. [127] H. Prinzbach, K. Weber, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1994, 33, 2239. [128] M. Weidenbruch, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1993, 32, 545. [129] A. Sekiguchi, C. Kabuto, H. Sakurai, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1989, 28, 55.
1.29 N ~ l k r dCluste~sof the Post- Transition Elements
597
[ 1301 L.R. Sita. I. Kinoshita, Orgunoriir~ttillie~ 1990. Y, 2865. [I311 H.J. Breunig, M . Denker. E. Lork. Aiiyrii.. Chem. Int. Ed. Eng. 1996, 35. 1005. [I321 H.J. Breunig, R . Rosler, E. Lork, A n g m Clieni. Int. Ed. Eny. 1997, 36, 2237. [I331 H. Schafer, K.H. Janzon. A. Weiss. Anyeit.. Clicw. Inr. Ed Enyl. 1963, 2, 393. [ 1341 E. Busmann. Z. Anory. Ally. Clieni. 1961. 313, 90. 11351 I.F. Hewiady. E. Busmann. W. Klemm. Z. Anorg. Allg. Clzern. 1964, 328. 283. 11 361 R.E. Marsch. D.P. Shoemaker. Actu. Cryst. 1953. 6 , 197. [ 1371 S.C. Critchlow. J.D. Corbett, Znorg. Chtvn. 1985, 24, 979. 11381 R.C. Burns, J.D. Corbett. J. An7. Cliem. Soc. 1981, 103. 2627. [139] F.U. Axe, D.S. Marynick, Inory. Clieni. 1988, 27, 1426. [ 1401 P.D. Lyne, D.M.P. Mingos. in An Econiuni to L i m s Puiiliny Mol~~cules in Nufitrul SCitY71Y rind Medicine. eds. Z.B. Maksic, M. Eckert-Maksic, Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1992. 11411 H.O. Grimm, A. Sommerfeld. %. P/IJX 1926. 36, 36. [ 1421 E. Zintl. Anycii,. Chem. 1939, 52. 1. [ 1431 H. Schiifer, B. Eiseiimann, W. Miiller, Angew. Clic~7.Itit. Ed. Enyl. 1973, 12, 694. [1441 W. Klemm, Proc. Clleni. Soc~.London 1958. 329. [ 1451 A.J. Banister, H.Y. Clarke. 1. Rayment, H.M.M. Shearer. Inor.
598
I Molecular Clusters
[168] Z. Dong, J.D. Corbett, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1994, 116, 3429. [I691 Y. Dumas, Bull. Soc. Clzirn. France 1969, 2634. [I701 H. Schmidbaur, R. Nowak, W. Bublak, P. Burkert, B. Huber, G. Muller, Z. Natuvfbrsch. 1987, 42B, 553. [I711 D. Mascherpa-Corral, Thesis, Montpellier U. S. T. L., 1975. [ 1721 J.M. van den Berg, Acta Cryst. 1966, 20, 905. [I731 C.P. van der Vorst, G.C. Verschoor, W.J.A. Maaskant, Acta Cryst. 1978, 34B, 3333. [I741 A.J. Carty, D.G. Tuck, Prog. Inorg. Chem. 1975, 19, 243. [175] P. Paetzold, Angeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1991, 30, 544. [176] D.G. Tuck, Polyhedron 1990, 9, 377. [I771 M.J. Taylor, P.J. Brothers, in Chemistry of Aluminium, Gallium, Indium and Thallium, Ed. A.J. Downs, Blackie Academic & Professional, 1993, ch. 3, p. 1 1 I . [I781 C. Dohmeier, D. Loos, H. Schnockel, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1996,35, 129. [I791 D. Loos, H. Schnockel, D. Fenske, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1993, 32, 1059. [I801 D. Loos, E. Baum, A. Ecker, H. Schnockel, A.J. Downs, Angew. Chrm. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 860. [I811 C.D. Doriat, M. Friesen, D. Loos, E. Baum, A. Ecker, H. Schnockel, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 1969. [182] W. Kostler, G. Linti, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Eng. 1997, 36, 2644. [ 1831 P.J. Brothers, K. Hubler, U. Hubler, B.C. Noll, M.M. Olmstead, P.P. Power, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1996, 35, 2355. [ 1841 K.W. Hellmann, L.H. Gade, A. Steiner, D. Stalke, F. Moller, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 161. [ 1851 L. Bengtsson-Kloo, S. Ulvenlund, Spectrochim. Actu 1997, ,453, 2129. 11861 G. Gerlach, W. Honle, A. Simon, Z . Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1982, 486, 7. (1871 W. Honle, G. Gerlach, W. Weppner, A. Simon, J. Solid State Chem. 1986, 61, 171. [l88] W. Uhl, M. Layh, T. Hildebrand, J. Organornet. Chem. 1989, 364, 289. [I891 M. Tacke, H. Kreinkdmp, L. Plaggenborg, H. Schnockel, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1991, 604, 35. [I901 D. Loos, H. Schnockel, J. G d U S S , U. Schneider, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1992, 31, 1362. 11911 W. Uhl, W. Hiller, M. Ldyh, W. Schwartz, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1992, 31, 1364. [I921 W. Uhl, Angew. Chem. Ilzt. Ed. Engl. 1993, 32, 1386. [I931 W.N. Lipscomb, Boron Hydrides, Benjamin, New York, 1963; W.N. Lipscomb, in Boron Hydride Chemistry, Ed. E.L. Muctterties, Academic Press, New York, 1975, ch. 2, pp. 30-78. [I941 W.N. Lipscomb, Angew. Chem. 1977,89, 865. [I951 R.E.W. Williams, Inorg. Chem. 1971, 10, 210. [I961 F. Klanberg, D.R. Eaton, L.J. Guggenberger, E.L. Muetterties, Inorg. Chem. 1967, 6: 1271. [I971 B. Schiementz, G. Huttner, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1993, 32, 297. [I981 K. Ichikawa, T. Yamanaka, A. Takamuku, R. Glaser, Inorg. Chem. 1997, 36, 5284. 11991 C.H. Belin, J.D. Corbett, A. Cisar, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1977, 99, 7163. 12001 J.D. Corbett, Inorg. Chem. 1968, 7, 198. [201] B. Krebs, M. Hucke, C. Brendel, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1982, 21, 445. 12021 R.W. Rudolph, W.L. Wilson, F. Parker, R.C. Taylor, D.C. Young, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1978, 100, 4629. [203] W.L. Wilson, R.W. Rudolph, L.L. Lohr, R.C. Taylor, P. Pyykko, Inorg. Chem. 1986, 25, 1535. 2041 L.J. Guggenberger, E.L. Muetterties, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1976, 98, 7221. 2051 L.L. Lohr, Inorg. Chem. 1981,20, 4229. 2061 L. Bengtsson-Kloo, A.N. Kouznetsov, B.A. Popovkin, J. Rosdahl, to be published. 2071 M.E. O’Neill, K. Wade, J. Mol. Struct. 1983, 103, 259. 2081 J.A. Morrison, Chem. Reo. 1991, 91, 35. 2091 B. Gaiek, F. Proshek, Russ. J. Inorg. Chem. 1964, 9, 256.
1.29 Nuked Clusters of the Post-Transition Elements
599
12101 D.H. Kerridge, S.A. Tariq, J . Chetn. Soc. A 1967, 1122. 12111 R. Faggiani. R.J. Gillespie. J.A. Vekris, J. Chem. Soc., C/iem. Cornrn. 1986, 517. 12121 T. StafTel, G. Meyer, Z . Anory. Ally. Chem. 1987, 548, 45. [213] D.J. Merryman. P.A. Edwards. J.D. Corbett. R.E. McCarley. Znorg. Chem, 1974, 13, 1471. [214] B.D. Cutforth, C.G. Davies, P.A.W. Dean; P.R. Ireland. P.K. Ummat, Inory. Chem. 1973, 12, 1343. [215] R.D. Ellison, H.A. Levy. K.W. Fung, Inorg. Cheni. 1972, 11, 833. [216] G. Torsi, K.W. Fung, G.M. Begun, G. Mamantov, Inorg. Clzem. 1971. 10, 2285. 12171 B.D. Cutforth. R.J. Gillespie, P.R. Ireland, J. Chem. Soc.. Chern. Comm. 1973, 723. 12181 B.D. Cutforth, R.J. Gillespie, P. Ireland. J.F. Sawyer, P.K. Ummat, Inory. Chern. 1983, 22, 1344. [219] A.J. Schulz, J.M. Williams. N.D. Miro, A.G. MacDiarmir, A.J. Heeger, Znorg. Chem. 1978, 17, 646. 12201 N.D. Miro, A.G. MacDiarmir. A.J. Heeger, A.F. Garito, C.K.; Chiang, A.J. Schulz, J.M. Williams, J. Inor(]. N l d . Chem. 1978, 40. 1351. [221] Z. Tun, 1.D. Brown, Actci Cryst. 1982, 3NB. 2321. [2223 Z. Tun, I.D. Brown. P.K. Ummat, Acfu Cryst. 1984, 40C. 1301. 12231 W.R. Datars. A. van Schnydel, J.S. Lass, D. Chartier, R.J. Gillespie, Phjs. Rec. Lett. 1978, 40, 1184. [224] D. Chartier, W.R. Datars, R.J. Gillespie, Can. J . Phys. 1983. 61, 71. [225] F.S. Razavi, W.R. Datars, D. Chartier, R.J. Gillespie, Phys. Rev. Lett. 1979, 42, 1182. [226] E. Batalla, W.R. Datars, D. Chartier, R.J. Gillespie, Solid Stute Comm. 1981. 40, 71 1. [2271 E. Batalla, W.R. Datars. D. Chartier, R.J. Gillespie, Solid State Comm. 1981, 40, 1203. (2281 P. Canal, P. Moreau. G. Ouvrard, M. Sidorov, M. McKelvy, W. Glaunsinger, Chem. Muter. 1995, 7, 1132. [229] M. Sidorov, M. McKelvy, P. Sharma, W. Glaunsinger, P. Canal, P. Moreau. G. Ouvrard, Cheni. Muter. 1995, 7 , 1140. [230] A. Knoepfler, K. Wurst, P. Peringer. J. Chern. Soc., Cliem. Comrn. 1995, 131. [231] W.R. Mason, Znorcg. Chem. 1997. 36, 1164. [232] A. Muhlecker-Knoepfler. E. Ellmerer-Muller, R. Konrat, K.-H. Ongania, K. Wurst; P. Peringer; J . Chem. Soe., Dalton Trms. 1997, 1607. 12331 A.L. Wessels. W. Jeitschko. M.H. Moller, Z. Nnturjorscli. 1997, 52B, 469. 12341 G. Cardinal, J. Gillespie. J.F. Sawyer, J.E. Vekris, J. Chem. Soc.. Dulton Truns. 1982, 795. 12351 D.J. Merryman, P.A. Edwards, J.D. Corbett. J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Cornm. 1972, 779. [236] P. Schwerdtfeger, P.D.W. Boyd, S. Brienne. J.S. McFeaters, M. Dolg, M . 3 . Liao, W.H.E. Schwarz, Inorg. Chim. Acta 1993, 213. 233. [237] P.A. Dean, D.G. Ibbott, J.B. Stothers, Cun. J. Chem. 1976, 54, 166. [238] W. Frank. B. Dincher. Z. Nuturforsch. 1987. 42B. 828. [239] R.W. Turner, E.L. Amma, J. Inorg. Nucl. Cheni. 1966. 28, 241 I . [2401 M. Bodenbinder, G. Balzer-Jollenbeck, H. Willner, R.J. Batchelor, F.W.B. Einstein, C. Wang, F. Aubke, Inorg. Chenz. 1996, 35. 82. [241] C.K.F. von HBnisch, C. Uffing. M.A. Junker, A. Ecker, B.O. Kneisel, H. Schniickel, Anyeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. En~gl.1996. 35, 2875. [242] M.A. Paver, C.A. Russell, D.S. Wright. Anyew. Chern. Itit. Ed. Engl. 1995. 34. 1545. [243] S. Harder, M.H. Prosenc. Anyeit,. Chem. Znt. Ed. Enyl. 1996. 35, 97. [244] M. Sawamura, H. Ikura. E. Nakamura. J. A m . Chem. Soc. 1996, 118, 12850. [245] H.G. von Schnering, ACS Symp. Ser. 1983. 232, 99. [246] R.C. Burns, J.D. Corbett, Inory. Chem. 1985, 24, 1489. [247] R.M. Friedman, J.D. Corbett, Inory. Chcm 1973, 12, 1134. 12481 B. Krebs. M. Mummert, C. Brendel, J. Less-Common M e t 1986, 116, 159. 12491 E.V. Dikarev. A.V. Shevelkov. B.A. Popovkin. Mendeleeu Chem. J . 1991, 36, 28. [250] J. Beck, Coorrl. Cheni. Rev. 1997. 163, 55.
600
I Molecular Clusters
12511 J. Beck, Angeie. Chern. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1991, 30, 1128. 1252) G.W. Drake, G.L. Schimek, J.W. Kolis, Inory. Chem. 1996, 35, 1740. [253] J. Li, Z. Chen, T.J. Emge, D.M. Proserpio, Inorg. Chern. 1997, 36, 1437. 12541 S.S. Dhingra, D.-K. Seo, G.R. Kowach, R.K. Kremer, J.L. Shreeve-Keyer, R.C. Haushalter, M.-H. Whangbo, Angeie. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 1087. [255] M. Asbrand, B. Eisenmann, Z. Anorg. Allgem. Chem. 1997, 623. 561. [256] M.J. Ferguson, R.W. Hushagen, A. Mar; Inorg. C%em.1996,35, 4505. (2571 R.C. Haushalter, B.W. Eichhorn, J. Chenz. Soc., Chem. Cornrn. 1988, 1027. 12581 T.F. Fassler, C. Kronseder, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 2683. 12591 H. von Benda, A. Simon, W. Bauhofer, Z. Anorg. Allcg. Chem 1978, 438, 53. 12601 H.G. von Schnering, H. von Benda, C. Kalveram, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1978, 438, 37. 12611 E.V. Dikarev, B.A. Popovkin, Dokl. Acad. Nauk SSSR, 1990, 31, 90. 12621 R. Kneip, D. Mootz, A. Rabenau, Angeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1973, 12, 499. [263] M. Takeda, N.N. Greenwood, J. Cliem. Soc., Dalton Trans. 1976, 631. [2641 R. Kneip, D. Mootz, A. Rabenau, Angel;. Chenz. Int. Ed Engl. 1973, 13, 403. 12651 M. Ruck, Z. Anory. Allyrm. Chem. 1995, 621, 2034. 12661 M. Ruck, Z. Anory. Allgcm. Clzem. 1997, 623, 243. 12671 M. Ruck, Z. Anory. Allgem. Chern. 1997, 623, 1591. 12681 M. Ruck, Angav. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1997, 36, 1971. (2691 H. Hartl, Angeiv. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34, 2637. 12701 C.T. Goetschel, K.R. Loos, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1972, 94, 3018. 12711 C.D. Desjardins, J. Passmore, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans. 1973, 2314. 12721 H.L. Paige. J. Passmore, Inorg. Chem. 1973, 12, 593. 12731 J. Passmore, P. Taylor, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans. 1976, 804. 12741 I. Tornieporth-Oetting, T. Klapotke, J. Passmore, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chern. 1990, 586, 93. 12751 C. Belin, T. Makani, J. Roziere, J. C/zem.Soc., Chern. Comrn. 1985, 118. 12761 M.J. Collins, R.J: Gillespie, J.W. Kolis, J.F. Sawyer, Inorg. Chem. 1986, 25, 2057. 12771 R. Faggiani, R.J. Gillespie, C. Campana, J.W. Kolis, J. Clzem. Soc., Chem. Comm. 1987, 485. 12781 A. Seigneurin, T. Makani, D. Jones, J. Roziere, J. Clzern. Soc., Dalton Trans. 1987, 2111. 12791 C. von Hiinisch, D. Fenske, F. Weigend; R. Ahlrichs, Chem. Eur. J. 1997, 3. 1495. 12801 G . Friedrich, O.J. Schercr, G. Wolmcrshauser, Z. rmory. ally. Chem. 1996. 622, 1478. [281] A. Albinati, A. Moor, P.S. Pregosin, L.M. Venanzi, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1982, 104, 7672. 12821 K.-H. Dahmen, D. Imhof, L.M. Venanzi, T. Gcrfin, V. Gramlich, J. Organornet. Chenz. 1995, 486, 37. [283] L. Hao, J.J. Vittal, R.J. Puddephatt, Orycznomet. 1996, 15, 3115. [284] A. Albinati, K.-H. Dahmen, F. Demartin, J.M. Forward, C.L. Longley, D.M.P. Mingos, L.M. Venanzi, Inorg. Chetn. 1992, 31, 2223. [285] F. Teixidor, M.L. Luetkens, R.W. Rudolph, J. Am. Clirm. Soc. 1983, 105, 149. 12861 M.L. Luetkens, F. Teixidor, R.W. Rudolph, Inorg. Chim. A m 1984, 83. L13. 12871 B.W. Eichhorn. R.C. Haushalter, W.T. Pennington, J. Am. Clzem. Soc. 1988, 110, 8704. 12881 S. Charles, B.W. Eichhorn, A.L. Rheingold, S.G. Bott, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1994, 116, 8077. 12891 B.W. Eichhorn, R.C. Haushalter, J. Chem. Soc., Chenz. Conzm. 1990, 937. (2901 K.H. Whitmire. J. Coord. Chern. 1988, 1 7, 95. 12911 J.R. Eveland, J.-Y. Saillard, K.H. Whitmire, Znorg. Chem. 1997, 36, 330. [292] S. Kahlal, J.-F. Halet. J.-Y. Saillard, K.H. Whitmire; J. Organornet. Chenz. 1994, 478, I . 12931 P.D. Mlynek, L.F. Dahl, Or(janomer. 1997, 16, 1655. 12941 K.H. Whitmire, J.R. Eveland, J. Chem. Soc., Chrm. Comm. 1997, 1335. 12951 K.H. Whitmire, M.R. Churchill, J.C. Fettinger, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1985, 107, 1056. 12961 K.H. Whitmire, T.A. Albright, S.-K. Kang, M.R. Churchill, J.C. Fettinger, Inorg. Chem. 1986,25, 2799. [297] L. Krause, R.C. Haushalter, Thin Solid Films 1983, 102, 161. 12981 R.C. Haushalter, Angeiv. Chern. Int. Ed, Engl. 1983, 22, 558.
I 2 9 Naked Clusters of the PoJt-Tvrinsition Element5
601
[2991 M.M.J. Treacy, R.C. Haushalter, S.B. Rice, L'/troriiicro.sL.op~1987, 23, 135. [3001 J.D. Corbett. hiorg. C ' h i i . 1962. I , 700. [301I R.A. Potts. R.D. Barnes. J.D. Corbett. fnorg. C'/ietir. 1968. 7. 2558. [3021 J.D. Corbett. W.J. Burkhard, L.F. Drudig. J. A m . C/iem. Soc. 1961. 83, 76. [3031 R.M. Friedman. J.D. Corbett, Inorg. Chini. Actu 1973, 7, 525. [3041 B. Predel, D. Rothacker. T/ier-rnoc/iir?i.Act[/ 1970, I . 477. [3051 A.N. Kouznetsov. A.V. Shevelkov. S.I. Troyanov. B.A. Popovkin. submitted for publication. [306] A.N. Kouznetsov, A.V. Shevelkov. S.I. Troyanov. B.A. Popovkin. Zliur. Nrorg. Khim 1996. 4 / , 958. 13071 J.D. Corbett. D.J. Prince. B. Garbisch. Itiorg. Clietn. 1970, 9. 2731. [3081 R.K. McMullan. D.J. Prince. J.D. Corhett, h o r y . C%eni. 1971, 10, 1749. [309] T.W. Couch. D.A. Lokken. J.D. Corbett, /norg. C/ieni. 1972. I f , 357. [310] J.D. Beck, R.H. Wood, N.N. Greenwood, Inorgi. Chei~i.1970. 9, 86. [31 I ] R.G. Pearson. R.J. Mawby. in "Huloyerz Chetni.s/rj,".ed. V. Gutmann. Academic Press. New York, 1967, vol. 3. p.67. [312] T.E. Mallouk. G.L. Rosenthal, G. Miiller. R. Brusasco. N. Bartlett. I/ior
602
1 Molecular Clusters
[343] H. Hartl, J. Nowicki, R. Minkwitz, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1991, 30, 328. [344] T. Birchall, R.D. Myers, J . Passmore, W.A.S. Nandana, G. Sutherland, Can. J. Chem. 1982, 60, 1264. [345] J. Passmore, G. Sutherland, P.S. White, Inorg. Chem. 1981, 20, 2169. [346] A. Aplett, F. Grein, J.P. Johnson, J. Passmore, P.S. White, Inorg. Chem. 1986, 25, 422. [347] J. Passmore, P. Taylor, T. Whidden, P.S. White, Cun. J. Chem. 1979, 57, 968. [348] T. Drews, K. Seppelt, Anyew. Chem. Int. Ed. Eng. 1997, 36, 273. [349] T. Birchall, R.C. Burns, L.A. Devereux, C.J. Schrobilgen, Inorg. Chem. 1985, 24, 890. [350] R.C. Burns, R.J. Cillespie, W.C. Luk, Inory. Chem. 1978, 17, 3596. (3.511 R. Fehrmann, N.J. Bjerrum, H.A. Andreasen, Inorg. Clzem. 1976, 15, 2187. [352] I.D. Brown, D.B. Crump, R.J. Gillespie, Inory. Chem. 1971, 10, 2319.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.2 Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexametal Boride Clusters Catherine E. Housecroft
1.2.1 Introduction Our work over the last decade on boron-containing clusters has detailed a number of strategies for assembling metal cages while at the same time denuding the boron atom of hydrogen atoms.“] While metal clusters containing fully interstitial carbon or nitrogen atoms (particularly the former) have been well documented in the literature for a good number of years,12-61those containing fully interstitial boron atoms are more limited in number. The first example to be reported was [Co6(CO)18B]‘71but was not structurally characterized. Since that report, the application of electron counting schemes[8-111has become a useful method either of predicting or rationalizing metal-cluster structures possessing either single or condensed metal skeletons. The count of 93 valence electrons for “[Cog(C0)18B]”is not in keeping with a closed hexacobalt cage, suggesting that this formulation must be viewed with some skepticism. Fourteen years passed between the report of the boride from Schmid and coworkers,17]and that of the next fully encapsulated boron atom in a discrete molecular environment; Shore’s group described [HRu,j(CO)17B], the octahedral structure (Fig. 1) being confirmed by the results of an X-ray diffraction study.[12]The metalbound H atom is readily removed, and Shore also reported the isolation of [( P ~ ~ P ) ~ N ] [ R u ~ ( CI1 O21) Independently, ~~B]. we reported the synthesis and spectroscopic characterization of the salt [Me3NH][Ru6(CO) I ~ B []l.31 These studies opened the door to the development of the chemistry of interstitial borido clusters. At this stage, we should stop to clearly define what is meant in this review by the term “interstitial”. Figure 2 shows the environment of a boron atom in M4butterfly, Ms-square-based pyramidal, and M6-octahedral and trigonal prismatic frameworks, i.e. the most common M4 to M6 cavities in discrete clusters. The exposure of the boron atom in the M4B-species means that the reactivity of this site is ~ignificant,”~~,‘~,’ 51 whereas in the M6B-systems, the boron atom is protected
1.2 Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexametal Boride Clusters
11
Figure 1. The structure of [HRuh(C0)17B] (X-ray diffraction study). The H atom was not located.
from attack. A pc,-boron atom within a square-pyramidal metal core is also partially exposed, and for these reasons we have chosen to define “interstitial” or, more correctly, “fully interstitial”, as describing an atom “fully encapsulated within a metal cage”. For the examples presently available, this essentially restricts it to a p 6 n
Figure 2. Semi- and fully-interstitial boron environments in Mq, MS and Mg cages having butterfly, square-based pyramidal, octahedral, and trigonal prismatic structures respectively.
Butterfly M4 P4-B semi-interstitial
Square-base pyramid M5 P5-B semi-interstitial
Octahedron M6
Trigonal prism Mg
P6-B
interstitial t
P6-B
interstitial
12
1 Molecular Cluster3
Figure 3. The core structures of (a) [HOss(C0)16Bland (b) [ C O ~ ( C O ) BH)], ~ ~ B (determined by X-ray diffraction mcthods.
mode. There are some ambiguities, notably in Shore's [ H O S ~ ( C ~ ) ~(Fig. ~ B ]3a) "~~ and Fehlner's [ C O ~ ( C O ) ~ BH)]'17' ~ B ( (Fig. 3b), but such geometries will not concern us in this review. Further ambiguity arises for capped metal-cages where the distance of the boron atom to the capping atom is usually longer than a normal bonding interaction; such examples will be discussed later in this article.
1.2.2 Expansion 1.2.2.1 Expansion beyond M6 during syntheses and ligand substitution reactions of M6 borides In most of our studies of ruthenium boride clusters, the strategy has been to build up the cage starting from R u ~ Bor Ru4B p r e c u r s ~ r s . ' ' ~ ' ~High ~ ' ~ ~nuclearity, homometallic products have consisted predominantly of RUG-cages;for example, photolysis of [ R U ~ ( C O ) ~ Bgives H ~ ]the butterfly (Fig. 2) cluster [HRuq(C0)12BH2] and the octahedral boride [ H R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ['~ B ] However, . limited examples of aggregation beyond six ruthenium atoms have been observed, and, perhaps significantly, photolytic reaction conditions were common to these occurrences. In characterizing the products of the photolysis of [ R u (C0)9BH5], ~ mass spectrometric B ~ ]a, 124-valence evidence pointed towards the formation of [ R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~with electron count, which is consistent with the structure shown in Fig. 4a.['*] When PPh3-for-CO substitution in [Rug(C0)17B]- was carried out using photolysis, a range of products was obtained including [HRu7(C0)19B] and [HRu7(C0)18( PPh3)BI. Capped-octahedral structures, consistent with the 98 valence-electron counts, have been proposed for both these products (Fig. 4b).[l9] The formation of iron borides with metal nuclearity > 6 has been achieved by the Fehlner group,1201 but, as in the Ru7 and Rug clusters cited above,[18,'91the actual cavity containing the boron atom is a hexametal one. The results of a crystallo-
1.2 Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexameta1 Boride Clusters
Figure 4. Proposed core structures of' (a) [ R u ~ ( C O ) ~(faced-sharing ~B~] octahedra), and (b) [HRu7(C0)19B]and [HRu7(CO)18 ( PPhl)B] (capped octahedron).
13
(b)
graphic study have confirmed that [HFe7( C0)20BI2- contains a capped-trigonal prismatic metal core (Fig. 5) with the boron atom essentially in contact with only six metal atoms, the seventh Fe-B separation being significantly longer than the other six.
Figure 5. The core structure of [HFe7(C0)2oBI2-, determined by single crystal X-ray diffraction methods.
W
14
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 6. The core structure of [ R ~ ~ R u ~ ( C O ) ~determined ~ B Z ] - , by single crystal X-ray diffraction methods.
Heterometallic borides of core-composition RmM2B ( M = Ir or Rh) may be prepared by the reaction of [HRu4(C0)12BH]- with suitable group 9 reagents, for example [Rh2(C0)4C12],12'] [Rh2(nbd)2C12](nbd = norbornadiene), [221or [Ir2L4C12] In each case, no expansion of ( L = cyclooctene or L2 = cycloocta-l,5-diene).~2'1 the cluster cage beyond six metal atoms has been observed; these reactions are further discussed in Sec. 1.2.4. However, the reaction between [ R u ~ ( C O ) ~ B Hand ~][Rh2(C0)4C12] led to the formation of [ H R ~ ~ R u ~ ( C O )[~R~~B~]R, L I ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B ] and [ R ~ ~ R L I ~ ( C O ) ~Characterization ~B~]-. by X-ray diffraction methods of the [( Ph3P)2N]+ salt of [ R ~ ~ R u ~ ( C O )has ~ ~ shown B ~ I - that this possesses the capped, This anion belongs to double trigonal prismatic structure shown in Fig. 6.[231 a family that includes [ H ~ R U ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B[HFe7(C0)20BI2-, ] - , ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ] [201 and the (CO)~ s C ] ~1271 - , [C06Ni2(CO)16c2]~-, '281 carbides [Ni7(CO)&I2-, [261 [Ni40~3 [Ni,o(CO)1gC2I2-,[291 [Nil I (C0)15C2l2-,[261 and [Ni12(CO)1 6C2I2-.'261 The pathway by which [Rh3Rug(C0)23B$ arises from the combination of [ R U ~ ( C O ) ~ B Hand ~]{Rh(C0)2}+has not been established, but it is noteworthy that the tetrahedral Ru3B unit that is present in the starting ruthenaborane is retained (twice over) in the product as illustrated by Fig. 6. There is no evidence to indicate that the pathway involves cage expansion beginning from a hexametal cage, and we have not been able to isolate single trigonal prismatic borides from this reaction mixture.
1.2.2.2 Expansion from M6 cages using group 11 metal fragments The expanded-cage products, (i.e. more than six metal atoms), described in the previous section arose serendipitously. A designed method of expanding the Mg cage involves reactions between hexametal boride anions and group 11 metal fragments, provided in the form of, for example, LAuCl or ClAu(L-L)AuC1 in which L = monodentate phosphine and L-L = bisphosphine. Such general reactions are well established in cluster chemistry, '301 and an extension to boride chemistry is an
1.2 Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexametal Boride Clusters
15
obvious route to higher nuclearity, boron-containing clusters. Generally, cluster anions undergo simple addition of LAu+ fragments. However, a comparative study starting from the RugB anions [Rug(C0)17B]- and [H2Rug(C0)18B]- (Fig. 7) has produced the following, interesting results. The reactions of [Rug(CO)17B]- with [LAuCl] ( L = PPh3 or P(CsHdMe-2)3) gave, as expected, [Rug(CO)I ~ B ( A u L )in ] good yield. Structural characterization confirmed the attachment of the gold(1) phosphine unit in an edgebridging position,"51 the same site occupied by the cluster-hydrogen atom in [HRU~(CO)~~B and ] ~a' ~result " ~ ~upholding the isolobal relationship between H+ and LAu+.[~']In principle, the trigonal prismatic boride [H2Rug(CO) should also react with LAuCl with the addition of an LAu+ unit. However, we found that this reaction was accompanied by elimination of Hz and CO to give a mix] , [Rug(CO)1gB(AuL)3] ture of [Rug(CO)17B(AuL)], [HRug( CO)I ~ B ( A u L ) ~and when L = PPh3, and [Ru6(C0)17B(AuL)] and [HRug(C0)1gB(AuL)2] when L = P(CsH4Me-2)3. This result exemplified a novel trigonal prismatic + octahedral cage-rearrangement; the role of the boron atom in maintaining core-integrity during the transformation is clearly important. A similar situation has been observed in nitride chemistry, but under quite different reaction conditions: trigonal prismatic [Cog(CO)lsN]- loses carbon monoxide when heated in THF to give octahedral [Cog(CO)I ~ N ] ~ Figure . ' ~ 7 illustrates the cluster structures of [Rug(C0)17B(AuL)], [HRug(C0)1gB(AuL)2], and [Rug(C0)1gB(AuL)?],each being confirmed by the results of single crystal X-ray diffraction determinations (for different L). While the Rus-cage is essentially octahedral (and this geometry is consistent with the 86-valence electron count), distortion in the digold and trigold derivatives is particularly severe. In [ H R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B ( A U the P P ~Ru-Ru ~ ) ~ ] ,edge most intimately associated with the two gold centers is lengthened to 338.9(2) pm (compared to 281.0 lengthened to 299.2(3) pm for the remaining Ru-Ru distances), and in [Rug(C0)1gB(AuPPh3)3], the two opposing Ru-Ru edges. which are bridged respectively by one or two gold centers are similarly elongated (327.6(1) and 313.0(3) pm). The distortion in the core of [HRu6(C0)1gB(AuPPh3)2]is illustrated are in Fig. 8a. In the solid state, the three AuPPh? units in [Rug(C0)1gB(AuPPh~)3] non-equivalent, but the 31P NMR spectrum (for a CD2C12 solution) at 180 K reveals only two signals in a 1 : 2 ratio. This is rationalized in terms of a dynamic process involving the "rocking motion" shown in Fig. 8b.'251Of course, this assumes that the 31PNMR spectroscopic handle is valid as a probe for the movement of the entire gold( I ) phosphine fragment. Although this assumption has commonly been invoked in solution studies of clusters with peripheral AuPR3 units, some caution is needed since Au-P bond cleavage is not unknown.1321 The best route theP ~reaction for forming [ R ~ ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B ( A is UP ~ ) ~ ] between [Rug(C0)17B]- and [(Ph3PAu)30][BF4],and this strategy proved to be the only method of preparing [ R u ~ ( C ~ ) ~ ~ B { A U P ( C ~lower H ~ Myields ~ - ~of)these ~ } ~trigold ] ; clusters were obtained when the precursor was [H2Rug(C0)18BIp.'251 The reactions of [Rug(C0)17B]- with derivatives in the family [ClAu(L-L)AuCl] (L-L = bisphosphine) have led to three types of products: [{Rug(C0)17B}2(p-
16
I Molecular Clusters
1 PRODUCTS
Figure 7. Schematic representation of the formation of mono-, di- and trigold(1) phosphine derivatives formed from [Rug(C0)17B]- or [ H ~ R u c , ( C O ) ~ ~Product B ] - . distributions are discussed in the text.
1.2 Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexametul B o d e Clusters
17
Figure 8. (a) The core structure of [HRub(CO)lsB(AuPPh?)2],determined by single crystal X-ray diffraction methods, illustrating the elongation of the gold-associated Ru-Ru edge. ib! Proposed solution fluxional process for [Rug(CO),gB(AuPPh7)3].
Au( L-L)Au)], [fRug(COjl7B](Au(L-L)AuCI)], and [ { R U ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B } ~ A In U]-.[~~] [ { R U ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B } ~L-L)Au)], ( ~ - A U ( two RugB-cages are linked by the Au( L-L)Au fragment, while in [ { Rug(C0)17B}(Au(L-L)AuCl)], the boride cluster interacts with one gold center from which a pendant (L-L)AuCl chain extends. The third type of cluster consists of two octahedral boride cages, which are fused by a common gold(1) center (Fig. 9). The exact geometry about the gold atom
Figure 9. The proposed structure of [(Rub(C0)17B}ZAu]-; the geometry at the gold( I ) center is not necessarily pseudo-square planar, but may possess a spiro-twist as has been observed in related, structurally characterized species.
18
1 Molecular Clusters
has not been crystallographically confirmed, but such fusion is not unprecedented; the anions [ { R U ~ ( C O ) I & ) ~ Tand ~ ] - [ ( R U ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ C }are ~ Hboth ~ ] ~ -related to [ { R u ~ ( C ~ ) ~ ~ B } and ~AU have ] - been structurally characterized. In addition, we have reported the preparation and structures of the anions [ { H F ~ ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B H } ~and A U[]{-H R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B H } ~ Aboth U ] - , of which show a spiro-twist about the gold(1) center.[32b1The relative yields of the three types of product depended upon the nature of L-L, with yields of [ ( R u ~ ( C ~ ) ~ ~ B } ~ A U ] being high for conformationally restricted ligands, for example (2)-bis(dipheny1phosphin0)ethene. [331 [3433s1
1.2.3 Degradation Pentametal boride clusters feature far less frequently in the literature['6'17,36,371 than do tetrametal or hexametal species, and systematic expansion of an M4B to M5B or M4M'B cage is difficult; reaction pathways tend to continue through to the species in which the boron atom is fully encapsulated.[22s361 During the formation of [Fe4Rh2(CO)16Blp,Fehlner had observed the formation of an intermediate species proposed as an Fe4RhB cluster, but it eluded isolation.[381 Relatively early work in our studies of [ H R U ~ ( C O ) I ~and B ] [Rug(C0)17B]- set out to mimic what was already known for the isoelectronic carbide and nitride clusters: under 1 atm of CO at 25 "C, [Rug(C0)16N]~ is converted quantitatively to [ R U ~ ( C O ) I ~ N ] -while , [ ~ ~ ]the quantitative conversion of [Rug(C0)17C] to [ R u ~ ( C O ) ~ occurs ~ C ] under 80 atm of CO at 70 0C.[401Our attempts to achieve a similar conversion from an octahedral Ru6B to square-pyramidal Ru5B skeleton were unsuccessful. However, the reaction between CO (55 atm) and [Ru~(CO)~~B(AUP (see P ~Sec. ~ ) ] 1.2.2.2) for 14.5 h resulted in the formation in good yield of the blue compound [Ru5(CO)l5B(AuPPh3)];the remaining material was unreacted [ R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B ( A U PThe P~~ reaction )]. can be represented by Eq. ( I ) , and Fig. 10 illustrates the structural changes in the cluster core that accompany the reaction. Of significant interest is the way in which the AuPPh3 unit swings down to interact directly with the boron, and thus, might be considered as a protecting group since the Rug + Rus degradation does not occur in its absence. Attempts to isolate [Ru~(C0)15B]-by removal of the {AuPPh3}+ fragment (ie. by treatment with [( Ph3P)2N]Cl) have not been successful.
+
[ R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B ( A U P P3~CO ~)] +
+
[ R u ~ ( C O ) I $ ( A U P P ~ ~Ru(C0)5 )]
(1)
The application of "B NMR spectroscopy has been a routine and important part of our studies of metal boride clusters.['51The degradation of the Ru6-cage results
1.2 Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexametal Boride Clusters
19
CO, 55 atrn
Figure 10. The formation of [Rus(CO)lsB(AuPPh3)]by degradation of [Rus(CO)17B(AuPPh3)]; each structure has been crystallographically confirmed.
in the boron atom becoming more exposed (fully to semi-interstitial as is shown in Fig. 2), and the IlB NMR spectroscopic resonance shifts upfield from 6 + 194.4 P ~ ~signal ) ] . also in [Rus(C0)17B(AuPPh3)]to 6 172.5 in [ R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B ( A U PThe becomes significantly broader (wi= 25 Hz compared to 175 Hz). A similar structural motif as that observed for the core of [Ru~(C0)15B(AuPPh3)] has also been confirmed by single crystal X-ray crystallography for [HRhRu4(nbd)(CO)12B(AuPPh3)] (nbd = norbornadiene).'361However, this boride was prepared by the controlled cluster-expansion reaction shown in Eq. (2); the point during the reaction at which the [Ph3PAuCl] is added is critical; if it is too late the major product is [ R ~ ~ R U ~ ( ~ ~ ~ ) ~ ( C O ) I ~ B ( A U P P ~ ~ ) ] . [ ~ ~ , ~
+
The cluster skeletons of the many octahedral borides that we have now reported are particularly stable with respect to degradation; the isomerizations that are discussed in Sec. 1.2.4 support this point and emphasize the fact that the ,u,-boron atom acts as "atomic glue" in stabilizing each cluster core. However, the reaction of [Rh2Ru4(CO)16B]- with [ClAu(dppm)AuCl] (dppm = bis(diphenylphosphin0)methane) has provided an unusual example of cluster degradati~n.'~'] We[32c,33,421 and other^[^^-^'' have made use of a number of compounds in the family
20
I Molecular Clusters
(a)
(b)
Figure 11. (a) Proposed structure of IRh~Ry(CO)~sBAu(dppm)l. (b) The structure of [RhRu4(CO)14B{Auz(dppm)11, determined by single crystal X-ray diffraction methods; Ph and CO groups, and H atoms are omitted for clarity.
[ClAu(L-L)AuCl] (L-L = bisphosphine ligand) to link metal centers and clusters. The reaction between [ R ~ ~ R U ~ ( C O ) and I ~ B[ClAu(dppm)AuCl] ]has been found but in addition to lead to the formation of [{Rh2Ru4(CO)16B}2(pU-Au(dppm)Au] two novel species were formed: [Rh2R~(CO)lsBAu(dppm)](Fig. 1 la) and [RhRu4(CO)14BAu2(dppm)](Fig. 1 lb). Although we have not investigated the the fact that we mechanism of the formation of [RhRu4(C0)14BAu2(dppm)], have also been able to isolate [Rh2Ru4(CO)1sBAu(dppm)]from this reaction may indicate that phosphorus-to-rhodium coordination plays a role in the abstraction of the rhodium atom from the Rh2Ru4 cage and thus, in cage degradation. As in the structures of [Rus (CO)l~B(AuPPh3)land [HRhRu4(nbd)(CQ)12B(AuPPh3)] described above, the crystallographically confirmed structure of [RhRu4(CO)14BAuz(dppm)] shows a square-based pyramidal group 8/9 metal core containing a semi-interstitial boron atom with the gold( I ) phosphine moiety attached asymmetrically to the base of the square pyramid.
1.2.4 Rearrangements 1.2.4.1 Conversion of trigonal prismatic to octahedral Ru6B clusters The trigonal prism and octahedron may be described in terms of two eclipsed or two staggered equilateral triangles, respectively. The conversion of one to
1.2 Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexarnetal Boride Clusters
21
Figure 12. A transformation from a trigonal prismatic Ru6B to octahedral Ru6B cage formally involves rotation of one Rui triangle with respect to the other.
the other involves mutual rotation of these triangles. Figure 12 shows this cluster core rearrangement as it applies to the transformation of [H2Ru6(C0)18Blp ( LL=) ~ ] into [ R u ~ ( C ~ ) ~ ~ B ( A[UHLR)u]~, ( C O ) ~ ~ B ( A Uand L ) ~[] R , u~(CO)~~B(AU phosphine), details of which were described in Sec. 1.2.2.2 and Fig. 7. A similar metal-cage rearrangement has been observed during attempts to prepare phosphine-substitution products of [ H * R U ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ B ]In- . ' fact, ~ * ~ we have been unsuccessful in obtaining any derivatives of this trigonal prismatic boride which retain the latter framework, cage-rearrangement (accompanied by the loss of H2 and CO) apparently being facile.
1.2.4.2 Interconversion between cis- and trans-isomers of octahedral R u ~ M ~(M B = Ir or Rh) borides The reaction of [HRu4(C0)12BH]- with [Rh*(C0)4C12] has proved a successful route to the formation of [ R ~ ~ R u ~ ( C O ) I and ~ B ]converts -, a semi-interstitial p4-B atom into a fully interstitial one. The anion [Rh2Ru4(C0)16BIp has also been isolated as one product in the reaction of [Ru3(C0)9BH4Ip and [Rh2(C0)4C12] (see ( Cbeen O ) de~~B] Sec. 1.2.2.1), and the crystal structure of [( P ~ ~ P ) ~ N ] [ R ~ ~ R u ~has t e ~ m i n e d . ' The ~ ~ ] metal cage in [Rh2Ru4(C0)16BIp is octahedral (as expected from the 86 valence-electron count) with the rhodium atoms mutually trans. However, in solution, we have shown1211 that the product of the reaction of [HRu4(C0)12BHlp with [Rh2(C0)4C12] consists of a mixture of cis- and trans-isomers of [Rh2Ru4(C0)16BIp ; the "B NMR spectrum (in ['HgJTHF) exhibits two triplets at 6+194.2 (cis) and 6+197.3 (trans) ( J ~ h = p 26 Hz). Similar differences in "B NMR chemical shift have also been observed for the cis and trans-isomers of [Fe4Rh:(C0)16B]-, although in this case the cis-isomer was not observed as a persistent species in solution but rather as an intermediate in the formation of tran.s-[Fe4Rh~(CO)16B]- from [HFe4(CO)12BHIp with [Rh2(C0)4Cl*].[381 For comparison. we have also studied the formation of [IrlRu4(CO)16B]-; this octahedral boride has been prepared by reacting [HRu4(C0)12BHIp with [Ir2L4C12] ( L = cyclooctene or L2 = cycloocta-1,5-diene) followed by treatment with CO at
22
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 13. The formal addition of {Ir(C0)2} fragments to the butterfly framework of [ H R ~ ( C O ) I ~ B H(with ]concomitant loss of two hydrogen atoms) is proposed to give cis[Ir2R~4( C0)16B]- prior to rearrangement to the truns-isomer. When rhodium carbonyl fragments are added, both cis- and truns-products have been observed in solutions of the final product.
atmospheric pressure.” Here, the isolated crystalline product was the [ (Ph3P)2N]+ salt of trans-[Ir2Ru4(CO)lsB]-, and in solution, “B NMR spectroscopic data showed only one species, assumed to be the trans-isomer. It seems likely, however, that the cis-isomer does form first (Fig. 13) and then undergoes rapid cage isomerization. The preference between cis- and trans-isomers of the octahedral Rh2Ru4B and Ir2Ru4B borides can be altered by derivatizing the clusters. We first noted such changes in the products of the reactions of [ R u ~ M ~ ( C O ) ~ (~M B= ] - Ir or Rh) with gold( I ) phosphines.’’’] The reaction of trans-[Ir2Ru4(CO)16B]- with [R~PAuCI] ( R = Ph or C6Hll) led exclusively to ~ ~ S - [ I ~ ~ R U ~ ( C O )AI ~ single B A ~crystal PR~]. structure determination of C~S-[I~~RU~(CO)~~BAUP(C~H~ 1)3] confirmed the relative positions of the iridium atoms, and also showed that the gold(1) phosphine unit occupied an edge-bridging site, interacting with the iridium rather than ruthenium atoms (Fig. 14a). The octahedral cage suffers from severe distortion; although the Ir-Ir edge is significantly lengthened (327.3(2) pm) as Fig. 14a1illustrates, the range of other edge lengths is quite large (280.3(4) to 306.2(5) pm). Any reactions of [Rh2R~(C0)16B]-may be presumed to begin with a mixture of trans- and cis-isomers. Treatment with [R~PAuCI]( R = Ph or C6H11) has been found to give green (major) and brown products, and on standing, the brown product converted to the green material. When an analogous reaction was carried out with [(2MeC6H4)3PAuCl], only a green product was obtained. Each green material was shown to be ~ ~ U ~ ~ - [ R ~ ~ R U ~ ( C Owhile ) ~ ~spectroscopic B A U P R ~data ] , for the brown compounds were consistent with their formulation as c ~ ~ - [ R ~ ~ R u ~ ( C O ) I ~ B A U P R ~ An X-ray diffraction study of trans-[Rh2Ru4(C0),6BAuP(c6H11)3] confirmed the structure shown in Fig. 14b, with the gold(1) phosphine unit capping an RhRu2face; of course, all faces in the trans-RhzRu4 cage consist of RhRuz triangles. In the light of the skeletal isomerism exhibited by [ R ~ ~ R u ~ ( C O ) ~and ~B][ R ~ ~ R ~ ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ Bwe A were UPR interested ~], to investigate the effects of introducing ligands other than carbonyls. The first study undertaken looked at the reaction of [HRQ(CO)~~BH]with [Rhl(nbd)2C12] (nbd = norbornadiene).[”] In this case,
I .2 Expanding, Degrading, and Rearranging Hexametal Boride Clusters
23
P Figure 14. The core structures (confirmed by single crystal X-ray diffraction of (a) cis[ I ~ ~ R ~ ( C O ) I ~ B A ~131, P (and C ~ (b) HII trans-[RhzRu4(CO)I~BAUP( C6H1I )3].
the product was ciL~-[HRh2Ru4(nbd)2(C0)12B], deprotonation of which yielded the conjugate base that retained the cis-Rh2Ru4 skeleton. Both clusters have been characterized by X-ray crystallography. We saw no evidence for these cis-species to convert to their respective trans-isomers. Similarly, the gold( I ) phosphine derivatives [ R ~ ~ R u ~ ( ~ ~ ~ ) ~ ( C (OR)=IPh, ~ BC6Hll A U P or R ~2-MeCsH4) ] each possessed cis-arrangements of the Rh~Ru4-framework,with no tendency being shown for cis + trans skeletal isomerism. In a more recent report,[491we have described the effects of introducing triphenylphosphine and trimethylphosphite ligands. Reactions between [RhzRuq(CO)l6B]- and PPh3 demonstrated that PPh3 substitutes for CO at rhodium rather than ruthenium centers, and that in the derivative, [RhzRu4(CO)14( PPh3)ZB(AuPPh3)], the rhodium atoms (each bearing a PPh3 ligand) were mutually cis in the octahedral cage. Up to three P(OMe)3 ligands may be introduced into [RhzRu4(C0)16B]- and we have shown that cis + trans Rh~Ru4-cageisomerization for becomes less facile across the series [Rh2Ru~(CO)~~-,{P(OMe)~},B(AuPPh~)] x = 1 to 3 . Further, migration of P(OMe)3 from Rh to Ru accompanies cis + trans x = 2 or 3. cage rearrangement in [R~~R~~(CO)I~_,{P(OM~)~},B(A~PP~~)],
Acknowledgements Coordinates for some structures determined from X-ray diffraction studies were obtained using the Cambridge Crystallographic Database,1501implemented through
24
1 Molecular Clusters
the ETH in Zurich. The results reported here from my own group could not have been carried out without the dedication of the students and postdoctoral associates who have worked on the project; their names are cited in relevant references. Funding for this section of our research has come from the Petroleum Research Fund (administered by the ACS) and the SERC/EPSRC (for studentships).
References [ I ] C.E. Housecroft, Chem. Soc. Rev., 1995, 24, 215. 121 J.S. Bradley, Adv. Organomet. Chem., 1983, 22, 1. 131 M.I. Bruce in Comprehensive Organornetallic Chemistry I , Eds. E.W. Abel, F.G.A. Stone, and G. Wilkinson, Pergamon, Oxford, 1982, Vol. 4, Ch. 32.6, p. 889; M.P. Cifuentes and M.G. Humphrey in ComprehensiveOryanometallic Chemistry 11, Eds. E.W. Abel, F.G.A. Stone, and G. Wilkinson, Pergamon, Oxford, 1995, Vol. 7, Ch. 16, p. 907. [4] W.L. Gladfelter, Ado. Organomet. Chem., 1985, 24, 41. [5] M.D. Vargas and J.N. Nicholls, Adv. Znory. Radiochem., 1986, 30, 123. [6] C.E. Housecroft in Inorganometallic Chemislry, Ed. T.P. Fehlner, Plenum Press, New York, 1992, Ch. 3, p. 73. [7] G. Schmid, V. Batzel, G. Etzrodt, and R. Pfeil, J. Organomet. Chem., 1975, 86, 257. [8] D.M.P. Mingos and D.J. Wales, Introduction to Cluster Chemistry, Prentic Hall, Englewood Cliffs, 1990. [9] D.M.P. Mingos and A.S. May in The Chemistry of Metal Cluster Complexes, Eds. D.F. Shriver, H.D. Kaesz, and R.D. Adams, VCH; 1990, p. 11. [ 101 C.E. Housecroft, Metal-metal Bonded Carbonyl Dimers and Clusters, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1996, Ch. 3. [ 111 C.E. Housecroft, Structure and Bonding, 1997, 87, 137. [I21 F-E. Hong, T.J. Coffy, D.A. McCarthy, and S.G. Shore, Inorg. Chern., 1989, 28, 3284. [ 131 A.K. Chipperfield, C.E. Housecroft, and P.R. Raithby, Oryanometullics, 1990, 9, 479. [14] C.E. Housecroft, Ado. Organomet. Chem., 1991, 33, 1. [15] C.E. Housecroft, Coord.Chem. Rev., 1995, 143, 297. [16] C.S. Jun, T.P.Fehlner, and A.L.Rheingold, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1993, 115, 4393. [17] J-H. Chung, D. Knoeppel, D. McCarthy, A. Columbie, and S.G. Shore, Inorg. Chenz., 1993, 32, 3391. [18] S.M. Draper, C.E. Housecroft, A.K. Keep, D.M. Matthews, X. Song, and A.L. Rheingold, J. Organomet. Chem., 1992, 423, 241. 1191 C.E. Housecroft, A.L. Rheingold, A. Waller, and G.P.A. Yap, Polyhedron, 1998, 17, 2921. [20] A. Bandyopadhyay, M. Shang, C.S. Jun, and T.P. Fehlner, Inorg.Chem., 1994, 33, 3677. [21] J.R. Galsworthy, A.D. Hattersley, C.E. Housecroft, A.L. Rheingold, and A. Waller, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1995, 549. [22] A.D. Hattersley, C.E. Housecroft, and A.L. Rheingold, J. Cluster Sci., 1997. 8, 329. [23] J.R. Galsworthy, C.E. Housecroft, and A.L. Rheingold, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1994, 2359. 1241 C.E. Housecroft, D.M. Matthews, A.L. Rheingold, and X. Song, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., 1992, 842. [25] C.E. Housecroft, D.M. Matthews, A. Waller, A.J. Edwards, and A.L. Rheingold, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1993, 3059.
1.2 Expunding. Degrading, und Rearranging Hexumetul Boride Clusters
25
[26] A. Ceriotti, G. Piro, G. Longoni, M. Manassero, N. Masciocchi, and M. Sansoni, New J. Chem., 1988, 12, 501. 1271 G.B. Karet, R.L. Espe, C.L. Stern, and D.F. Shriver, Inorg. Cliem., 1992, 31, 2658. 1281 A. Arrigoni, A. Ceriotti. R.D. Pergola, G. Longoni, M. Manassero? N. Masciocchi, and M. Sansoni, Angew. Cliem., Int. Ed. Engl., 1984, 23, 322. [29] A. Ceriotti. G. Longoni, M. Manassero, N. Masciocchi, L. Resconi, and M. Sansoni, J. Cllem. Soc,.,Chem. Commun., 1985, 181, 1301 See for example: K.P. Hall and D.M.P. Mingos, Puog. Inorg. C/zern., 1984, 32, 237; I.D. Salter, A r k Organomet. Chem.. 1989, 32, 237 and references therein. [31] G. Ciani and S. Martinengo, J. OrGqunomet. Chem., 1986, 306, C49. 1321 Within our own metallaborane and boride cluster systems, see for example: (a) K. S. Harpp and C. E. Housecroft, J. Urgunoniet. Chem., 1988, 340, 389; (b) S.M. Draper, C.E. Housecroft, J.E. Rees, M.S. Shongwe, B.S. Haggerty, and A.L. Rheingold, Organometallics, 1992, 11, 2356; (c) J.R. Galsworthy, C.E. Housecroft. and A.L. Rheingold, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Truns., 1995; 2639. [331 C.E. Housecroft. A.L.Rheingold, A. Waller, and G.P.A. Yap, J. Organomet. Chem., 1998, 565, 105. [34] C.B. Ansell, M.A. Modrick, and J.S. Bradley, Acta Crystallogr., Sect. C, 1984, 40, 1315. 1351 R.F.G. Johnson, W.-L. Kwik, J. Lewis, P.R. Raithby. and V.P. Saharan. J. Chem. Soc., Dulton Trans. 1991, 1037. [36] A.D. Hattersley, C.E. Housecroft, and A.L. Rheingold, .I. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1996, 603. [37] C.E. Housecroft, D.M. Matthews, and A.L. Rheingold, Organometallics, 1992, 11, 2959. (381 R. Khattar, J. Puga, T.P. Fehlner, and A.L. Rheingold, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1989, 111, 1877;
A.K. Bandyopadhyay, R. Khattar, J. Puga, T.P. Fehlner, and A.L. Rheingold, Inorg. Cliem., 1992. 31, 465. 1391 M.L. Blohm and W.L. Gladfelter, Orgunometallics, 1985, 4, 45. 1401 B.F.G. Johnson, J. Lewis, W.J.H. Nelson, J.N. Nicholls, J. Puga, P.R. Raithby, M.J. Rosales, M. McPartlin, and W. Clegg, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Truns., 1983, 277. 1411 A.D. Hattersley, C.E. Housecroft, and A.L. Rheingold, Inorg. Chim. Acta, 1999, in press. [42] S.M. Draper, C.E. Housecroft, and A.L.Rheingold, J. Organomet. Cliem., 1992, 435, 9. 1431 C.E. Briant, K.P. Hall, and D.M.P. Mingos, J. C h m . Soc., C h i . Comniun., 1983, 843. 1441 M. Ferrer, R. Reina, 0. Rossell, M. Seco, S. Alvarez, E. Ruiz, M.A. Pellinghelli, and A. Tiripicchio, Orgunometallics, 1992, 11, 3753. [45J J.E. Goldberg, D.F. Mullica, E.L. Sappenfield, and F.G.A. Stone, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Truns.. 1992, 2495. 1461 R. Reina, 0. Rossell, M. Seco, J. Ros, R. Yaiiez, and A. Perales, Znorg. Chem., 1991, 30, 3973. 1471 R.I. Brice, S.C. Pearse, I.D. Salter, and K. Hendrick, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Truns., 1986, 2 18 1. 1481 C.E. Housecroft and A. Waller, unpublished results. [49] A.D. Hattersley, C.E. Housecroft, L.M. Liable-Sands. A.L. Rheingold, and A. Waller, pol^)hedron, 1998, 17, 2957. [ S O ] F.H. Allen, J.E. Davies, J.J. Galloy, 0. Johnson, 0. Kennard, C.F. Macrae, E.M. Mitchell, G.F. Mitchell. J.M. Smith, and D.G. Watson, J. Chem. Znj: Cornp. Sci., 1991, 31, 187.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.3 Steric Effects in Metallacarboranes Alan J. Welch
1.3.1 Introduction Metallacarboranes are cluster compounds in which the cluster vertices comprise one or more metal atoms (main group metal, transition metal or rare earth [lanthanide or actinide] metal), one or more (most often two) carbon atoms, and boron atoms, the last usually in the majority. The total number of cluster vertices may vary but the vast majority of metallacarboranes have between 6 and 14 vertices; moreover, the cluster may be either open or closed. However, the single largest group of metallacarboranes has 12 vertices and is structurally based on the closed icosahedron, 1. Boranes and heteroboranes, of which metallacarboranes are a constituent group, have fascinating, non-classical structures involving multicenter bonding. In the simplest terms this propensity for multicenter bonding arises directly from the fact that their component { BH} fragments are electron dejicient, having 3 available valence orbitals but only 2 valence electrons. By multicenter bonding the relatively few valence electrons available are efficiently shared by many vertices. Whilst molecular orbital ( MO) studies of (hetero)boranes adequately describe the bonding within individual molecules, the significant breakthrough in the area came in 1971 with the development of the polyhedral skeletal electron pair (PSEP) theory, or “Wade’s rules”.‘’] These simple rules rationalized the structural patterns in (hetero)boranes that had been recognized by Rudolph”] and by W , i l l i a m ~by [ ~re~ lating the cluster structure to two factors; the number ( n )of cluster vertices and the number of skeletal electron pairs (seps). Briefly, if there are ( n 1) seps then the cluster adopts the structure of a Platonic solid (icosahedron if n = 12, octadecahedron if n = 11, and bicapped square antiprism if n = 10, etc.) and is termed closo. If there are ( n + 2) seps then the cluster adopts a structure based on one of these closed structures but with a high connected vertex missing, and is termed nido, and if there are ( n + 3) seps then the structure, termed arachno, is that of a closed form with two (adjacent) missing vertices. Still more open forms, hypho, klado, . . . are
+
27
1.3 Steric EfJits in Metallacarboranes
1
+
+
found with (n 4), (n 5 ) , etc. seps, but are less numerous. At the other extreme a few heteroboranes, including metallacarboranes, have only n seps, and display structures derived from the corresponding closo geometry that has undergone a single diamond-square-diamond (dsd) transformation (see later). Such species are termed pileo, or more commonly hypercloso. Figure 1 shows part of what has been termed the Wade-Williams structural matrix, illustrating the geometrical relationship between closo n vertex, nido (n - 1) vertex, and arachno (n - 2) vertex polyhedra that arises because all have (n 1)
+
Figure 1. Part of the WadeWilliams structural matrix.
hypercloso
closo
nido
arachno
28
1 Molecular Clusters
seps. Counting seps is a straightforward procedure in most cases; if v is the number of valence electrons of the vertex element and x is the number of electrons formally provided by exo-polyhedral atoms or groups, the skeletal electron contribution is (v + x - 2) for a main group element vertex, (v x - 12) for an 18-e transition metal vertex, and (v + x - 10) for a 16-e transition metal vertex. The vast majority (but not all) of the metallacarboranes discussed in this review are considered as 18-e species. The study of steric effects in metallacarboranes is essentially a study in structural chemistry. In the early 1990s we recognized that, for a systematic study of the effects of steric crowding on a family of molecules, metallacarboranes were ideal candidates. Within the cluster structure a metallacarborane clearly has isomeric possibilities; rearrangements between different heteroborane isomers do take place (usually at high temperatures), but the mechanisms by which they occur are poorly understood. The possibilities for variation in substituents at the carbon and metal vertices are obvious, since metallacarboranes are most easily synthesized by metallation of carboranes, themselves usually prepared by reaction between a preformed borane cluster and an alkyne; thus judicious choice of alkyne and metal fragment affords the desired C and M substitution, respectively. In addition, however, substitution reactions at boron vertices, themselves known for many years, are growing in popularity and complexity, as became evident by the recent synthesis of Finally, metallacarboranes 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1l-(CHC12)lo-I,12-clos0-C2BloH2.[~] are, for the most part, thermally and chemically stable compounds attainable by well-established and straightforward synthetic routes. For all these reasons they are eminently suitable for a systematic study of the effects of steric congestion on molecular structure and reactivity. The triangulated surface of (hetero)borane clusters presents the perfect template on which to study steric crowding. We reasoned that, if bulky substituents X, Y and Z could be bound to mutually adjacent cluster atoms, then local steric crowding would be efficiently established, as shown in 2. In practical terms, the family of icosahedral metallacarboranes designated 3,1,2-closo-MC2B9 are suited to such a study. This is the heteroatom pattern readily afforded by metallation of a 7,8nido-CzB9 carborane ligand, itself the product of straightforward deboronation of a 1,2-closo-CzBlo carborane parent, Scheme 1. If the cage carbon atoms carry bulky groups R' and R2, and L, is a sterically demanding ligand set bonded to the metal atom, the local crowding desired would be set up. How might such a crowded metallacarborane behave?
+
2
1.3 Steric Efects in Metallacarboranes
29
Scheme 1. Deboronation of 1,2-closo-C~B~0 carborane to 7,8-nidoo-C2B9carborane, and metallation giving 3,1,2-c/oso-MC2B9 metallacarborane.
The vast majority of our work in this area has involved 3,1,2-MC2Bg metallacarboranes in which both cage carbon atoms carry phenyl substituents. We wanted to use the steric bulk of these phenyl substituents to produce crowded metallacarboranes that might accordingly have unusual or interesting properties, but it was first necessary to try to get some feel for the electronic consequences of C-phenyl substitution on the cage. This is conveniently achieved by comparing the IIB{'H} NMR spectra of 1,2Fig. 2. closo-C2BloHlz, l-Ph-l,2-closo-C2BloH~1and 1,2-Ph2-1,2-closo-C2BloHlo, The IlB resonances of all three compounds occur between 0 and -15 ppm, but progressive phenyl substitution does cause a slight overall movement of the reso-
I 0
-5
PhCZBloHII
I
I -5
0
-10
-15 ppm
Ill I -10
0
-5
-10
<S"B>
-8.5
<6"B>
-7.6
-15 ppm
I
PhzCzBIoHlo
<6I1B> -10.7
-15 ppm
Figure 2. Stick representations of the "B{ 'H} NMR spectra of 1,2-c/oso-C2BloHlz,I-Ph-1,2-c/osoC2B loH II and 1,2-Phz-1,2-c/oso-CzBloH10.
30
1 Molecular Cluster3
*
L
6.4 A
+ *
3.7A
Figure 3. The effective width (6.5 A) and effective thickness (3.7A) of a phenyl group.
nances to high frequency. The weighted average "B chemical shift, (611B), conveniently quantifies this movement. For the three carboranes considered, (dl' B) is -10.7, -8.5 and -7.6ppm, respectively. The effect is measurable but small; replacement of C H by CPh has relatively little electronic effect on the carborane, at least in as much as it is reflected in (dI1B). On the other hand, replacement of H by Ph is a significant steric change and moreover, it is one that is highly dependent on the conformation. Figure 3 shows "face-on" and "edge-on" space filling diagrams of a C6H5 group. The effective width is ca. 6.4A (based on van der Waals radii) but the effective thickness is ca. 3.7A (based on n MOs). Clearly, the steric demands of a phenyl group, which is a substituent to a heteroborane cluster, depend markedly on its conformation. For a molecule with Ph attached to one of two adjacent cage C atoms, this conformation is conveniently described by the angle 0, defined as the modulus of the average Ccage-Ccage-Cphenyl-Cpheny] torsion angle. 1' Thus, for the simplest phenyl carborane, 1-Ph-1, ~ - c I o s o - C ~ B ~ there O H ~are ~ , two limiting conformations defined by 0 = 0" and 0 = 90°, Fig. 4. In collaboration with
6 = oo
Figure 4. The limiting conformations of 6 = 90'
I-Ph-1,2-closo-CzB,oH, I.
1.3 Steric Efsects in Metullucarboranes
31
Table 1. The Structure of l-Ph-1,2-closo-C2Bl,-,H11.
SCXRD cc-modification at 200 K P-modification at 150 K Electron Diffraction HF/6-31G*
67.7(4) 71.7(2) 54 65
1.640(5) 1.649(2) 1.628(5) 1.626
[61 [71 [61 [61
colleagues at the Universities of Edinburgh and Erlangen, we have determined the structure of this molecule by low-temperature single-crystal X-ray diffraction on two crystalline modification^,["'^ by electron diffraction in the gas phaseL6]and by ab initio MO calculation^.'^^ The essential results are summarized in Table 1. The optimum value of 19is in the range ca. 55-70", but the theoretical study reveals a very shallow potential well with the conformation at 8 = 90" only 0.3 kJ mol-' less stable, and even that at I9 = 0" only 2.1 kJmol-' less stable, than the optimum conformation. Clearly, with two CPh fragments at adjacent positions in a heteroborane, such high 0 values could not be sustained without significant Ph . . . Ph congestion. Accordingly, a structural studyis1 shows that the phenyl rings in 1,2-Ph2-1,2-cZosoC2B10H10 (Fig. 5a) have conformations defined by low 8 values (average 0 = 5.5"). Moreover, when this species is deboronated to afford the anion [7,8-Ph2-7,8-nidoC2BgH101- the same basic conformation is found'9J(Fig. 5b). Deprotonation of this monoanion by removal of the endo-H atom attached to B( 10) affords the dianionic 3, in which the phenyl rings are carborane ligand [7,8-Ph~-7,8-nido-C2BsHg1~-, ideally oriented to sterically crowd an incoming metal fragment. We have found that such crowding can have either relatively minor or relatively major consequences.
a
b
Figure 5. The structures of (a) 1,2-Phz-l,2-closo-C2BloHlo and (b) [7,8-Phz-7,8-nido-C2BsH 101showing low 0 values for the phenyl rings
32
I Molecular Clusters
@ c-c
Ph
2-
Ph
3
1.3.2 Minor consequences In this section we discuss species derived from metallation of the ligand 3 that have somewhat distorted cluster structures as the result of steric crowding. However, the extent of the crowding is not sufficient to cause either a major polyhedral deformation (e.g. the breaking of a cage connectivity) or an internal polytopal rearrangement (either to an isomer of the molecule expected or to a different structural form). Examples of such major changes do exist, and are described in the following section. When a transition metal fragment {ML,} bonds to the C2B3 face of a 7,8nidu-CzBg ligand, an important feature of the structure of the resulting metallacarborane is A, the slipping parameter, describing the lateral displacement of the metal atom from a position above the center of the carborane ligand face, 4.To a first approximation, A is inversely related to the quality of the match between the frontier MOs of the metal fragment with those of the ligand, with the result that A{lmear ML} (poor match) > A{angular ML,} (intermediate match) > A{conical ML,} (good match; A = O).ilO1 Reaction of 3 with [Ph3PHgC12]2 affords 7,8-Ph2-1O-endu-Ph3PHg-7,8-niduC2B9H9, 5.'"' The {HgPPh3}2+fragment is isolobal with H+. Thus, this fragment is expected to simply endo-o bond to B( 10) of the anion 3, affording a direct structural analogue of [7,s-Ph2-7,X-nido-Cz Bs H 101- (large, electronically -driven, A), which is precisely what is observed. However, A for compound 5 is l.lOA, M-
A
4
5
1.3 Strvic. Effkcts in Metullucurboranes
33
significantly greater than that measured (0.92 A) in the non-Cpheny1analogue 10endo-Ph3PHg-7,8-nido-C2B9H1 I ,I121 suggesting some degree of steric repulsion between the Ph cage substituents and the PPh3 group. Consistent with this, the average 0 value for the phenyl rings in 5 is 29.1", which is much greater than in [7,8-Ph2-7,8-nido-C2BgH101- . Evidence for rather more steric congestion exists in the metallacarborane 1,2-Ph2-3-cod-3,1,2-c/oso-PdC~B~H9, 6, (cod = cyclo-octa-l,5-diene). In this compound, formed by reaction between 3 and PdC12(cod), the orbital match between metal fragment (now formally {MLz}) and cage is better, whereby the resulting smaller A ensures a more crowded molecule. The manifestation of this crowding is molecular distortioni131; principally, the Pd atom is slipped by 0.52 A away from the cage C atoms (c.f: 0.24A in the analogous compound without Ph subs t i t ~ e n t s " ~the ~ ) , C( 1)-B(4) and C(2)--B(7)distances are abnormally long, and the Ph groups are twisted to an average H value of 48.8", towards the upper limit calculated for an adjacent diphenyl heteroborane before massive destabilization. Is'It is of considerable interest to note that reaction between 3 and PtClz(cod) under the same conditions yields only an isomerized platinacarborane, uide infra. Although a linear {ML} fragment such as {HgPPh3}2+or {AuPPh3}+ suffers a large slipping distortion when bonded to a carborane ligand, a tetrahedral analogue such as {CuPPh3}+ does not, having essentially three frontier orbitals with which to bond to the cage. Thus, in [3-PPh3-3,1, ~ - c / ~ ~ ~ - C U C ~ the B ~Cu(3) H ~ ~atom ] ~ is ,~"~ more-or-less central over the C2B3 pentagon (A = 0.27 A), and this situation barely alters (A = 0.25 A) in the dicopper species 3,4,8-exo-Ph~PCu-3-PPh~-3,1,2-c/osoC U C ~ B ~1,H7,I in which a second {CuPPh3}+ fragment is exopolyhedrally bonded to the Cu(3)B(4)B(8) and supports a Cu-Cu bond. Compound 8 is the di-CPh analogue of 7. To avoid undue crowding between the cage Ph groups and the endo-{Cu(3)PPh3} fragment the latter is pushed back to A = 0.62A. Presumably this distortion precludes 3,4,8 face capping by a second {CuPPh3}+ fragment, which instead is located over the B(2)B(8)B(9)face, there being no direct CU-CU interaction. Thus, steric crowding is responsible for exo-skeletal isomerism in this (and related) di-cupracarboranes. ' l 71
6
7
8
34
1 Molecular Clusters
R' R~small
R~P'
closo catalytically inactive
Y
exo-nido catalytically active
Scheme 2. Closo and exo-nido rhodacarboranes.
1.3.3 Major consequences More serious steric overcrowding in metallacarboranes can have a dramatic effect on molecular structure. Broadly three such major consequences have been recognized; polyhedral deformation including connectivity breaking, low-temperature isomerization (both of the 1,2 + 1,7 and 1,2 + 1,2 variety) and vertex extrusion yielding exo-nido species. Most of our work in the area has focused on the first two aspects and these are described below. However, vertex extrusion is important in that it can produce metallacarborane structures which are important in understanding their homogeneous catalytic activity. [' *] A typical rhodacarborane system is shown in Scheme 2. If the substituents R ' and R 2 on cage-C are small then the molecule exists primarily as the closo 12-vertex Rh"' species shown on the left. However, an equilibrium between this and the exo-nido Rh' tautomer shown on the right must exist, with this latter form responsible for catalytic behaviour. Increasing the bulk of R' and R 2 progressively increases the proportion of the exo-nido form as steric crowding is avoided. When R' = Me and R 2 = Ph the compound exists solely in the exo-nido form and can be crystallized as such.
1.3.3.1 Polyhedral deformation If the carborane ligand 3 is capped by an {M(y-L)} fragment (y-L is an y-bonded polyene) a major polyhedral deformation occurs. The first system we studied, 1,2Ph2-3-Cp*-3,1,2-RhC2BgHg 9 [Cp* = (y-C5Me5)]is typical."'] The steric demands of the capping metal fragment force both cage bound phenyl rings to adopt high values (ca. 82.5") causing them to move apart to avoid unacceptable P h . . . P h
1.3 Steric Effects in Metallacarboranes
35
9
crowding so prizing open the C(1)-C(2) connectivity. The C(1)-C(2) distance is stretched to ca. 2.5A (cJ ca. 1.7A in a non-deformed, e.g. mono-Ph, analogue) and, at the same time, the M(3) . . . B(6) distance is contracted to ca. 3 A (cJ: ca. 3.5A in a non-deformed analogue), producing an essentially square M(3)C(1)B(6)C(2)face. This polyhedral deformation appears to be quite general for a variety of 1,2-Ph2-3-(q-L)-3,1,2-MC2B9H9 metallacarboranes studied, Table 2. Moreover, analysis of the MC2B9 skeletons of deformed and non-deformed anal o g u e ~ by ‘ ~ the ~ ~ “Root Mean Square (RMS) Misfit” methodf241shows that the deformation is essentially localized to the M(3)C(1)C(2)B(6)face. We have termed MC2B9 metallacarboranes with square M(3)C(1)C(2)B(6)faces as “pseudocloso”. Although they are not represented on the Wade-Williams matrix (Fig. I), structurully they appear to lie intermediate between closo and hypercloso 12-vertex shapes (Fig. 6); since these have, respectively, ( n 1) and n seps, the electronic description of pseudocloso metallacarboranes is clearly of interest, and MO studies designed to investigate this are currently in hand.[251 Spectroscopically, pseudocloso metallacarboranes are characterized by (6”B) values shifted ca. 15 ppm to high frequency relative to analogous, non-deformed (6”B) is analogues, e.g. for 1,2-Ph2-3-Cp*-3,1,2-pseud0closo-RhC~B~H~”~~
+
Table 2. Structural Parameters (A) and (d” B) (ppm) for Pseudocloso Metallacarboranes 1,2-Ph23-(?-L)-3,1,2-MC2BgHg.
w-I
C(1).. C(2)
M(3).. .B(6)
2.92 2.95 2.99 2.96 3.01
(dl1B)
Ref.
36
I Moleculuv Clusters
Figure 6. Closo._useudo. closo and hypereloso 12-vertex polyhedra. Y
closo (n+l) seps
pseudocloso
hypercloso (n) SePS
+6.0 ppm whereas for 3-Cp*-3,1,2-~loso-RhC2B9H11~'~~ it is -8.6 ppm. Moreover, following assignment of the B NMR spectra of pseudocloso metallacarboranes, first by individual gauge for localized orbital (IGLO) calculations'201and subsequently by B-" B correlated spectroscopy (COSY) experiments, [''] we have been able to show that all boron resonances are shifted to high frequency, albeit by differing amounts, in moving from a closo to an analogous pseudocloso species (Fig. 7). Recent work has extended the family of pseudocloso metallacarboranes: Reaction of 3 with a source of the {Rh[9]aneS3}2+ fragment yields 1,2-Ph2-3,3,3-[9]ane S3-3,1,2-pseudocloso-RuC2B9H9, 10, the first pseudocloso metallacarborane with a o-bonded { ML3} fragment; [''I metallation of the tetra-anionic carborane 11 with { Ru(q-cymene)}2+ affords the unique closo-pseudocloso species 12 in which one 12vertex metallacarborane has a normal closo geometry and the other a pseudocloso geometry (although in solution at room temperature both clusters become equivalent on the NMR time-scale and (611B) is 1.1 ppm, intermediate between that ex-
4,7
.1
40
30
20
10
0
5.
-10 -20
-30
-40ppm
1,2-Ph2-3-Cp*-3,1,2-pseudocloso-RhC2B9H9
Figure 7. Stick representations of the 'lB{ 'H} NMR spectra of 3-Cp*-3,1,2-closo-RhC~B9H11 and B9H9. 1,2-Ph2-3-Cp*-3,1,2-pseudocloso-RhC~
1.3 Steric. Ejfects in Mrtullucarbovunes
37
11
10
12
13
eSMe
Ph
CIAu,
c-c
14
15
16
pected for closo and pseudocloso forms):['*' metallation of the zwitterionic nido carborane 13 with {Ru(r-cymene)}2+ (cymene = C6H4MeiPr-1,4) or {RhCp*)*+ gives rise to pseudocloso 14 or its RhCp* equivalent, the first examples of carbaborylphosphine ligands r5-bonded to transition metals:[291finally, reaction of the triply substituted monoanionic carborane ligand 15 with a source of the {RuCp*}+ fragment yields the pseudocloso species 16.[30i
38
I Molecular Clusters
18
17
Although pseudodoso metallacarboranes are afforded by {M(v-L)} capping of nido diphenylcarborane, use of a carborane with slightly less sterically demanding substituents yields partially deformed “semipseudodoso” species such as 17 ( Ph and C-CPh cage s u b s t i t u e n t ~ [ ~ and ~ ~ )18 (SPh substituents; steric crowding between S lone pairs of ele~trons[~’’). In 17 and 18 the C ( l ) . . . C(2) connectivity is 2.18 and 2.10A respectively, with Ru(3) . . .B(6) 3.17 and 3.20A respectively, and the (611B) values, 2.4 and -2.3 ppm respectively, are indicative of a limited shift to high frequency relative to closo analogues. Figure 8 reveals essentially an inverse linear relationship between C( 1) . . . C(2) and M(3) . . . B(6) for closo, semi-
4.0
I
closo
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
C(1).,,C(2)
Figure 8. Plot of M ( 3 ) . - . B ( 6 )and cp, ’ ‘ ’ C(2) distances (A) in metallacarboranes.
1.3 Steric Efects in Metallacarboranes
1
semipseudocloso
39
~
pseudocloso
hypercloso
closo
nido
Figure 9. Structural continuum between closo and hypercloso 12 vertex shapes.
pseudocloso, pseudocloso, and hypercloso metallacarboranes, implying a continuum of structure type on the Wade-Williams matrix (Fig. 9) with full steric control of intermediate structures. The change from closo to hypercloso involves a single dsd transformation (of the 3,1,6,2 face). A complementary view of the deformed metallacarborane structures we have produced via steric crowding is that they constitute frozen “snapshots” of this dsd transformation.
1.3.3.2 Low-temperature isomerization The isomerization of closo carboranes at elevated temperatures has been known for B ~ ~ H ~ cleanly ~ to the 1,7 isomer more than 30 years. Thus, ~ , ~ - c I o s o - C ~rearranges at ca. 450 0C[321whilst at ca. 700 “C the 1,7 form converts to the 1,12 isomer, although accompanied by substantial decompo~ition‘~ 31 (Scheme 3). Metallacarboranes undergo analogous isomerizations at similar temperatures (e.g. Scheme 4),1341although it has previously been recognized that arranging for the starting metallacarborane to be sterically crowded can reduce the isomerization temperature (e.g. Scheme 5).[351Work in our group has shown that low-temperature isomerizations are common in metallacarboranes with C-phenyl substituents; starting
40
1 Molecular Clusters
@ -@ 4-@ 7OO0C
45OoC
Scheme 3. Isomer-
from 3,1,2-MCzBg precursors two quite different isomerizations have been noted, the 1,2 i 1,7C atom isomerization of Schemes 4 and 5 , and the so-called 1,2 i 1,2C atom isomerization (videin&). Typical of the former is the isomerization of I-Ph-3,3-( PMe2Ph)2-3,1,2-cfosoPtC2BgH10, 19, to an approximately equimolar mixture of 1-Ph-2,2-(PMe2Ph)zin warm 1,2,8-closo-PtC2BgH1o and 8-Ph-2,2-(PMe2Ph)2-1,2,S-closo-PtC2BgHlo (55 "C) CDC13 (Scheme 6), the identities of both products being established by diffraction studies.1361 Even more dramatic is the result of the reaction between {Pt(PMe2Ph),}2+ and the diphenylcarborane ligand 3. On warming a frozen (-196 "C) mixture of Pt(PMe2Ph)zCl2 and 3 to room temperature the only isolatable product is the C-separated species 20.[361Thus, the (transient) product 1,221, must undergo a net 1,2 + 1,7 Ccage Ph2-3,3-(PMe2Ph)2-3,1,2-closo-PtC2BgHg, atom isomerization at < 18 "C.
-
Ph'
20
19
21
PR, = PMezPh
I
I
500°C,
@ C
Scheme 4. Isomerization of 3-(q-CsH5)-3.1,2closo-CoC2BgHI1,
I.3 Steric Eflects in Metallucurboranes
41
65'C
Scheme 5. Low-temperature isomerization of I-'Bu-3,3,3-( PPh?)l(H)3.1 ,2-closo-IrC2BgHlo.
$Bu fc,
4-
It is tempting to suggest that such low-temperature isomerization is driven by the relief of steric crowding in the pre-isomerized molecule, but whilst overcrowding is likely to be an important contributory factor there are several clues that it is not solely responsible: metallacarborane 19 does not appear to be particularly overcrowded, yet it isomerizes easily; reaction of 3 with {Pt(cod)}2+affords a direct analogue of isomerized 20, yet use of {Pd(cod)}'+ yields only the distorted, non-isomerized, 6, suggesting that the nature of the metal atom is important in determining the course of the isomerization;" 31 moreover, this idea is further supported by the observation that the reaction of 3 with {Ni(PMe'Ph),}*+ reNevertheless, whateverthe true sults in a "1,2 + 1,2" Ccdgeatom i~omerization.'~'~ nature of the reason or reasons for low-temperature isomerizations of metalla( phenyl)carboranes, the simple fact that such changes can reliably be produced under mild conditions offers the important possibility of an experimental study of the isomerization mechanism(s). The precise mechanism(s) by which carboranes and heterocarboranes isomerize has been the subject of considerable speculation over many years. Notable suggestions have included the hextuple-concerted dsd mechanism uia a cubeoctahedral intermediate (Scheme 7),I3'l the triangle rotation1391and extended triangle rotationl4'1 mechanisms, the pentagonal twist p r o c e ~ s ,involvement ~ ~ ~ , ~ ~ of ~ a nido interrr~ediate[~'Iand the involvement of an anticubeoctahedral intermediate.'421 Equally, there have been a number of theoretical investigations of the phenomeIn a significant recent study144JWales concluded that the 1,2 + 1,7 and
Ph' 17, PR,
= PMe,Ph
Scheme 6. Low-temperature isomerization of l-Ph-3,3-(PMe2Ph)2-3,1.2-clo.ro-PtC~B~Hlo, 17
42
I Molecular Clusters
Scheme 7. Proposed hextuple-concerted dsd rearrangement of ~ , ~ - C I O S O - C ~ B ~ O H ~ ~ to 1,7-closo-C2B I o H ~ ~ .
1,7 + 1,12 rearrangements of C2B10H12 occur via high energy intermediates linked to precursor, product, and each other by a series of sequential dsd steps. For the 1,2 + 1,7 process, one intermediate, 22, of C, symmetry, was however found to be relatively stable. Two fundamental problems have restricted the impact of experimental study of the isomerization mechanism(s). Firstly, until very recently, it has not proved possible to isolate an intermediate in a heteroborane isomerization, which would have provided an important signpost for the rearrangement mechanism. Secondly, the fact that such isomerizations tend to require high temperatures has meant that vertex labeling studies ( i e . substitution of B H by BX) have been of limited use because of the possibility of B-X bond cleavage and positional scrambling. Recent studies at Heriot-Watt University have had some success in overcoming both these essential problems and thus have been shedding direct light on the true 1,2 + 1,7 isomerization mechanism, but in addition we have also recently been able to show that, at least in one particular system, the hextuple-concerted dsd mechanism is not operating. As previously noted, transient 21 isomerizes to 20 at < 18 "C, a net 1,2 + 1,7 Ccageisomerization. The operation of the hextuple-concerted dsd process on 21 affords 23, but since this species is not observed it, too, must be transient, undergoing further rearrangement to yield 20. We have synthesized 23 by a different route; reaction of the C-separated carborane ligand 24 with the {Pt(PMe2Ph)2}2f fragment.[451Compound 23 does not isomerize in refluxing toluene, therefore it is not an intermediate in the low-temperature rearrangement of transient 21 to observed 20, and the hextuple-concerted dsd mechanism is inappropriate.
22
23, PR3 = PMeZPh
24
1.3 Steric Effects in Metullucurborunes
43
26
27
Scheme 8. (Proposed) Transformation of the transient species 27 into non-icosahedral 25, followed by (established) transformation of 25 into 26.
Whilst evidence against one mechanism is of some value, evidence for another is clearly better. Recently we have been fortunate in isolating, for the first time, an intermediate in the isomerization of one icosahedral metallacarborane into another. Thus, reaction of 3 with a source of the {Mo(v,K~H~)(CO),}' fragment affords the anion 25, which is closed but not icosahedral.[461Gentle warming of 25 ( T H F reflux) rapidly yields C-separated 26. We propose that 27 is the transient first product of the metallation of 3 but is overcrowded, rearranging spontaneously to 25. The relationship between 27 and 26 is the same as that between 1,2- and I , ~ - C ~ B I O H ~ ~ , thus identifying 25 as an isomerization intermediate (Scheme 8). Interestingly 25 has the same structure as Wales' predicted C, symmetric intermediate 22. [441 Very recently we have begun to develop analogous chemistry with vertex labeled analogues of 3. Following treatment of carborane 15 with the Mo fragment cation the neutral compound 28, a second structural analogue of 22, has been isolated. 14'' Subsequent gentle thermolysis affords a mixture of the C-separated icosahedra 29 and 30 (Scheme 9). Whilst the relationship between 28 and 29 is clear (and consistent with theory'441)that between 28 and 30 is not, and we believe that 28 is formed along with a second intermediate, 31, which gives rise to 30. The predicted structure of 31 is shown.
28
29
44
1 Molecular Clusters
Ph
Scheme 9. Metal dependency of the metallation of cdrborane ligand 3 ( R = variety of phosphine ligands).
1.3.4 Conclusions and outlook Pre-organizing for metallacarboranes to be deliberately overcrowded can have significant structural effects. Work in our group has focused on polyhedral deformution and on low-temperature isomerization. Polyhedral deformation can result in unusual, open (pseudocloso) structures, which, although not represented on the Wade-Williams matrix, appear structurally to lie between closo and hypercloso forms. The further discovery of partially deformed (semipseudocloso)species supports the idea of a continuum of structure type, which can, at least in part, be controlled by judicious use of substituents with differing steric demands. Low-temperature isomerization of 3,1,2-MC2Bg icosahedra into 1,2,8-MC~Bg
1.3 Steric' Efects in Metallacarhoranes
45
icosahedra (net 1,2 41,7 Ccdgeatom isomerization) can routinely be achieved. We have shown, at least in one system, that the hextuple-concerted dsd mechanism is inappropriate and have demonstrated in another the first isolation of an intermediate species. Current studies with vertex labeled carborane precursors should afford additional mechanistic information and may lead to a complete experimental mapping of all vertices in the net 1,2 41,7 isomerization of metallacarboranes. In the future we would expect to be able to extend this study to embrace the net 1,7 41,12 isomerization. Whilst it is very encouraging that our recent work with metallacarborane isomerization has provided experimental support for the conclusions of previous theoretical studies on carborane isomerization, the inclusion of metal vertices can clearly have a moderating effect. This is dramatically demonstrated by examples of metal-dependency. Thus, reaction of 3 with { Pt( PR3)2]2i instantaneously produces a 1.2 i 1,7 Ccageisomerization, whereas reaction with {Ni(PR3)2}*+ results in one Ccageatom moving from upper to lower pentagons of the icosahedron, away from the metal atom, whilst remaining directly connected to the other Ccageatom1371 (Scheme 9). Such a process is known as a 1,2 1.2 Ccageisomerization. Considerable further work is necessary to fully understand the nature of the metal dependency of the isomerization processes and to track the movement of every vertex through labeling. In these future studies our ability to drive these isomerizations routinely at low temperatures through steric crowding is likely to continue to be important. ---f
Acknowledgements The chemistry described above which has originated from our laboratories, originally at the University of Edinburgh and latterly at Heriot-Watt University, would not have been possible without the dedication and skill of a number of postdoctoral and postgraduate co-workers, in rough chronological order Zoe Lewin, Natalia Douek, Gwenda Kyd, Tom McGrath, Jill Cowie, David Donohoe, Kerry Adams, Rhodri Thomas, Andrew Weller, Anna McWhannell, Georgina Rosair, Shirley Dunn, Rhona Garrioch, Kristen Low, and Catherine McAvoy. Recent collaboration with Francesc Teixidor, and Clara Viiias and their group at the ICMAB-CSIC, Bellaterra, Spain, has been stimulating and fruitful, and financial support from the EPSRC, NATO, the Royal Society, the University of Edinburgh, and Heriot-Watt University is also gratefully acknowledged. Last, but by no means least, continued support for our work by the Callery Chemical Company, PA, has been invaluable and is considerably appreciated.
46
1 Molecular Clusters
References [I] Wade K. (1971) J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. 792; (1976) Adv. Inorg. Chem. Rudiochem. 18 1 [2] Rudolph R.W. (1976) Acc. Chem. Res. 9 446 [3] Williams R.E. (1971) Inorg. Chem. 10, 21 I; (1976) Adv. Inory. Chem. Radiochem. 18 67 [4] Jiang W., Knobler C.B., Hawthorne M.F. (1996) Angew. Chemie Int. Ed. Engl. 35 2536 [5] Cowie J., Reid B.D., Watmough J.M.S., Welch A.J. (1994) J. Organometal. Chem. 481 283 [6] Brain P.T., Cowie J., Donohoe D.J., Hnyk D., Rankin D.W.H., Reed D., Reid B.D., Robertson H.E., Welch A.J., Hofmann M., von Rag& Schleyer P. (1996) Inorg. Chem. 35 1701 [7] Thomas Rh.LI., Rosair G.M., Welch A.J. (1996) Acta Crystallogr. C52 1024 [8] Lewis Z.G., Welch A.J. (1993) Acta Crystullogr. C49 705 [9] Cowie J., Donohoe D.J., Douek N.L., Welch A.J. (1993) Actu Crystallogr. C49 710 [lo] Mingos D.M.P., Forsyth M.I., Welch A.J. (1978) J. Chem. Sac. Dalton Trans. 1363 [I I] Lewis Z.G., Welch A.J. (1993) Acta Crystallogr. C49 715 [I21 Colquhoun H.M., Greenhough T.J., Wallbridge M.G. (1979) J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 619 [I31 Kyd G.O., Yellowlees L.J., Welch A.J. (1994) J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 3129 [I41 Smith D.E., Welch A.J. (1986) Acta Crystallogr. C42 1717 [I51 Do Y., Kang H.C., Knobler C.B., Hawthorne M.F. (1987) Inorg. Chem. 26 2348 [I61 Kang H.C., Do Y., Knobler C.B., Hawthorne M.F. (1988) Inorg. Chem. 27 1716 [I71 Adams K.J., Cowie J., Henderson S.G.D., McCormick G.J., Welch A.J. (1994) J. Organometal. Chem. 481 C9 [I81 Hawthorne M.F. et a1 (1984), J. Am. Chem. Soc. 106 2979; 2990; 3004 [I91 Lewis Z.G., Welch A.J. (1992) J. Organometal. Chem. 430 C45 [201 Brain P.T., Buhl M., Cowie J., Lewis Z.G., Welch A.J. (1996) J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 231 [21] Gradler U., Weller A.S., Welch A.J., Reed D. (1996) J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 335 [22] Donohoe D.J. (1996) PhD Thesis, University of Edinburgh 1231 Thomas Rh.Ll., Welch A.J. (1997) J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 631 [241 Macgregor S.A., Wynd A.J., Moulden N., Gould R.O., Taylor P., Yellowlees L.J., Welch A.J. (1991) J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 3317 [25] Macgregor S.A., Welch A.J. (l998),work in progress [26] Bown M., Plesek J., Base K., Stibr B., Fontaine X.L.R., Greenwood N.N.; Kennedy J.D. (1989) Mugn. Reson. Chem. 27 947 [27] Welch A.J., Weller A.S. (1996) Inorg. Chem. 35 4548 [28] Thomas Rh.Ll., Rosair G.M., Welch A.J. (1996) J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1327 [29] McWhannell M.A., Rosair G.M., Welch A.J., Teixidor F., Vifias C. (1999) J. Organometul. Chem., 573 165 [30] Rosair G.M., Welch A.J., Weller A S . (1998) Organometullics, 17 3227 [31] Teixidor F., Vifias C., Flores M.A., Rosair G.M., Welch A.J., Weller A.S. (1998) Inorg. Chem., 37 5394 [32] Grafstein D., Dvorak J. (1963) Inorg. Chem. 2 1128 [33] Papetti S., Heying T.L. (1964) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 86 2295 [34] Kaloustian M.K., Wiersema R.J., Hawthorne M.F. (1972) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 94 6679 1351 Baker R.T., Delaney M.S., King R.E., Knobler C.B., Long J.A., Marder T.B., Paxon T.E., Teller R.G., Hawthorne M.F. (1984) J. Am. Chem. Soc 106 2965 [36] Baghurst D.R., Copley R.C.B., Fleischer H., Mingos D.M.P., Kyd G.O., Yellowlees L.J., Welch A.J., Spalding T.R., O’Connell D. (1993) J. Organometal. Chem. 447 C14 [37] Garrioch R.M., Kuballa P.J., Low K.S., Rosair G.M., Welch A.J. (1999) J. Organomet. Chem., 575 57 [38] Lipscomb W.N. (1966) Science 153 373 1391 Zakharkin L.I., Kalinin V.N. (1966) Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 169 590
1.3 Steric Effects in Metallucarborunes
47
[40] Wu S., Jones M. (1989) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 111 5373 [41] Edvenson G.M., Gaines D.F. (1990) Inorg. Chem. 29 1210 [42] Roberts Y.V., Johnson B.F.G. (1994) J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 759 [43] Gimarc B.M., Ott J.J. (1986) Inorg. Chem. 25 83, 2708; Wales D.J. Stone A.J. (1987) h o r g . Chem. 26 3845; Gimarc B.M., Warren D.S., Ott J.J., Brown C. (1991) Inorg. Chem. 30 1598 [44] Wales D.J. (1993) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115 1557 [45] Welch A.J., Weller A.S. (1997) J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 1205 1461 Dunn S., Rosair G.M., Thomas Rh.Ll., Weller A S . , Welch A.J. (1997) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 36 645 1471 Dunn S., Rosair G.M., Weller A.S., Welch A.J. (1998) J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1065
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.4 Heteronuclear Clusters Having Transition Metals and Metals of Group 14 David J. Curdin
1.4.1 Introduction The chemistry of heterometallic clusters has given us many beautiful molecules, and continues to provide us with surprises. The majority of work has concentrated on homonuclear clusters, though heteronuclear derivatives are receiving increasing attention. In the heteronuclear field, most work has concentrated on compounds having two or more transition metals, though work with main group metals has been a continuing if small area. It was authoritatively reviewed by Whitmire"] but there has not been a comprehensive survey since. Transition metal clusters having a group 14 element have been studied by a number of workers; for recent references see Mackay,(21Lewis,13Jand Braunstein.141There are, in addition, many pure group 14 element clusters, (5, and references therein.) but these will only be mentioned in passing in this article. Heterometallic clusters have been the subject of synthetic studies, attempts to account for the structure and bonding in such systems; and with a view to catalytic activity. Despite the many claims of clusters acting as catalysts, there is still much dispute concerning the precise nature of the active sites in such systems. Clusters incorporating group 14 elements have been part of this activity, not least because the main-group elements often enhance cluster stability considerably. In particular carbido clusters have received much attention, stemming from the view that carbido-metal intermediates are important in the initiation of Fischer-Tropsch catalyses.I6]In this short article we shall concentrate on the use of low-valent derivatives of germanium, tin, and lead in the build-up of heterometallic clusters from small homonuclear transition metal ones, and focus mainly on the work carried out in our laboratories in recent years.
1.4 Heteronuclear Clusters Having Transition Metals and Metals of Group 14
49
1.4.2 The coordination of diorganogroup-14 element compounds The coordination chemistry of the now large variety of species of the type R2M, where R is an organic group, (or an amido ligand) and M a group 14 element has been reviewedF7'and been the subject of several subsequent publications.ls-lO1The coordination arises through the nucleophilic lone pair of electrons and vacant orbital on M.'11-141illustrated below: '
1
in which the shading indicates double occupancy of the orbital. In valence bond language, M can be described as sp2 hybridised, and the vacant orbital as having mainly p-character. In keeping with this, gas-phase electron diffraction data for the species where R = (Me3Si)ZCH and M = Ge or Sn, for example show the molecules to be m o n o r n e r i ~ . "It~ ~is the considerable bulk of the ligands in these species which prevents oligomerisation. The first ionization potential for these species is generally low, for example 7.42 eV in {(Me3Si)2CH},Sn,F'51and 7.32 eV in the lead Accordingly the stannylene behaves as- a good nucleophile, and perhaps surprisingly for a sixelectron species, has only low electrophilic character. Coupled with this nucleophilicity, is the strong tendency of tin(I1) to become tin(IV), so these compounds in addition to Lewis base behaviour also insert [oxidatively as far as the tin is concerned] into other bonds; behaviour which is not the main concern here. Since the stannylene is diamagnetic, and behaves as a singlet carbene analogue,F161it can donate to a metal atom as a terminal ligand (2), [M, M', C, and C (of R) coplanar]
L 2
in which the metal M' is assumed to have octahedral coordination by M and five
50
1 Moleculur Clusters
ligands L. A further possibility is that the R2M entity becomes bonded as a bridging, rather than terminal ligand, as in 3,
L" 3
in which it is assumed that the M' metals form a triangle, and are coordinated by n ligands L, which would typically be carbonyls. Indeed, concerning coordination to clusters, this is by far the preferred mode of attachment, only a single example each of the terminal mode being known for germylenes or stannylenes. In the bridging mode, when coordinated to a planar metallic array, the R groups are generally orientated well out of the metal plane, though the ligating carbons are frequently not perpendicular to this plane, and characteristic angles are observed (see below). Nevertheless, coordination around M is not very far removed from a regular tetrahedral. Many of these compounds, (except derivatives of amido group 14 species) in contrast to the group 14 element precursors, are air and moisture stable, and resist attack by quite strong aqueous acids. The presence of silyl or other lipophilic substituents confers substantial solubility in organic solvents on most of these species, and makes a variety of NMR and other spectroscopic measurements in solution possible.
1.4.3 Synthetic approaches The precise method of synthesis of these compounds depends on the group 14 reagent, and the transition metal cluster. Here we will concentrate on clusters formed by addition to tri- or tetra-nuclear clusters of iron, ruthenium, osmium, or iridium. For these metals, activation may be required for osmium or iridium species, whereas ruthenium carbonyl reacts readily. Triiron dodecacarbonyl reacts very readily, but is generally accompanied by cluster breakdown; even retaining a dimetallic fragment requires prior activation, and low temperatures. These patterns are related to the strength of the MI-CO bond, and of the M'-M' bond, both of which increase on descending the group. When activation is required, the well-known amine oxide method generally works well. Trimethylamine N-oxide reacts with many coordinated carbonyl groups
1.4 Hrteronucltw Clusterx Having Transition Metals and Metals of Group 14
51
affording amine and carbon dioxide."" If the reaction is carried out in acetonitrile, the vacant coordination site is occupied by the nitrile, a ligand which is much more readily displaced by nucleophiles than is carbon monoxide. L,M'-CO
+ MeiNO + MeCN
L,M'-NCMe
4
+ C02 + Me3N
Not all CO ligands can be so removed, but an estimate can be made in individual cases from t(C-0): when this falls below a critical value, the M-CO interaction is too strong, and it is unlikely that the reaction will take place. A factor with low-valent group 14 reagents is their extremely ready oxidation. After formation of the nitrile adduct, excess Me3NO must be removed; and this can usually be achieved by filtration through a small pad [ca. 2 cm] of dry, oxygen-free silica gel. The literature contains some interesting reports concerning reactions with the much less sensitive triorganophosphines, where this precaution was not taken, and it is clear that oxidation of the phosphine has been the main problem. Acetonitrile is by no means the only nitrile that can be used, but it is convenient and easily removed. It is interesting in this connection, that while no group 14 adduct of the Fe3 triangle has been reported, the complex [Fe3(CO)1 1 (NC-C6H4-Me-4)] was obtained (as were several group 15 adducts) in good yield, and structurally characterized"81 from addition of the nitrile following treatment of [Fe3(CO)121 with Me3NO at low temperature. The group 14 reagents vary considerably in their reactivity. Compounds [{Me3Si)2CH},M},] - ( M = Ge or Sn) are the most reactive: displacing carbon monoxide from triruthenium dodecacarbonyl at only slightly above ambient temperatures. The trimeric aryl reagent [{C6H2Pr\-2,4,6)2Sn},]' I 9 ' requires moderate heating, usually in toluene, and the amido species frequently have lower reactivity. Apart from hydrido species (see below) the products can normally be isolated either following chromatography on silica, or by crystallization from a hydrocarbon solvent. The hydrido species (especially where there is bridging to the group 14 metal) may be air and water sensitive, and may not survive chromatography, at least using protic columns.
1.4.4 Compounds in which the group 14 ligand is bonded terminally to a cluster Addition of [{S ~ I { C H ( M ~ ~ S to ~ )a~toluene } ~ } ~solution ] of [Osj(C0)11 (NCMe)] at room temperature or below, gave the adduct [Os3(CO)1 I (SnRz)] in excellent yield, after recrystallization from toluene at -20°C. The product, which is stable in air for short periods, undergoes slight decomposition over a few days, and forms mono-
52
I Molecular Clusters
clinic, orange crystals. The crystal structure shows that the tin group occupies an equatorial position on the osmium triangle, as expected for a bulky substituent. The structure is shown in Fig. 1 .C2O] A further reason for the equatorial position of the tin, may be that in this site, there is no competition for overlap with 71-electrons of the metal from a transcarbonyl group (backbonding electrons). Although the n-acceptor character of SnR2 is less than that of a carbonyl group,L211 there is evidence that it is still appreciable. In the present case for example, the measured Sn-0s distance 2.573(3)A, is significantly less than the sum of the single-bond radii [2.648~%]. The osmium triangle is very close to equilateral, though the measured Os-0s vector trans to the tin [2.891(1)A]is higher than the distance in [Os3(CO)12] or the remote Os-0s vector here [2.877(3)A]. Examples of terminal coordination of osmium, and particularly osmium clusters are rare, but one intriguing example is provided by the group 14 adduct [(OC)sOs+ Os(C0)3(GeC13)Cl], though in this case the donating species is the formally eighteen electron Os(C0)s fragment, and not the germanium group. The Os-0s distances (from 2.916(2) to 2.913( 1) A, for the three independent molecules of the unit cell) are slightly longer than those of [Os~(C0)12], 2.877(13)& (mean), though this is difficult to interpret because of the presence of the presumably high trans-influence group 14 ligand. Our only other similar example of terminal coordination with an osmium cluster is with the germanium analogue { (Me3Si)zCH),Ge, which forms the di-adduct shown below. ' 2 2 1 In this case the structural data are not of particularly high quality, though the heavy atom framework is not in doubt. There are two hydrogen atoms associated with the molecule, but the data do not allow us to locate these directly. However, based on the related [Os3(C0)lo(pu-H)2SnR2],(see below) these can be tentatively placed as shown in Fig. 2, from the positions adopted by the carbonyl and germanium ligands. The supporting bond-length and angle data for these placements are shown in Fig. 3. It can be seen that one of the Os-0s vectors and one of the Os-Sn vectors is
1.4 Heteronuclear Clirsters Hwiny Transition Metals and Metals OJ' Group 14
53
0
Figure 2. The structure of [Osj(ilc-GeR2)(GeRz)(CO),(/c-H)2]
0
significantly longer than the other, resulting in, we suggest, a form accommodating a bridging atom. In both cases, the in-plane carbonyl ligands are placed much closer to the non-bridged framework bonds (angles 114", 118", and 118") than to the bridged, supporting the proposed hydrogen locations. The more normal mode for the R I M fragments coordinated to clusters is bridging two metal centers. However, we may visualise the formation of the bridged structure from the reactants. the stable terminal species mentioned above do not appear to be convertible into the bridged. Neither the terminal GeR2 nor SnR2 compounds gave rise to detectable quantities of bridged isomers on heating, though other forms of decomposition occurred at high temperatures.
Figure 3. The structure of [[Os?(,pGeR2)(GeR2)(CO)~~( p H ) 2 ] . K = CH(SiMe3):; giving sclected bond lengths. and the hydrogen locations suggested.
.Ge
54
I Molecular Clusters
1.4.5 Compounds in which the group 14 ligand doubly bridges metals in a cluster without further reaction This bonding mode is by far the commonest for simple addition of MR2 species to reactive metal clusters. For example in the group 8 dodecacarbonyl series, the lighter two metals react with a variety of MR2 species readily, while the osmium carbonyl requires activation. In the ruthenium case, the first isolated product is generally the pentametallic species [ R u(CO)s( ~ p-CO)(MR2)2],though it is possible to obtain the hexametallic clusters. These reactions can be conducted in high yields in aprotic aliphatic or aromatic solvents, heptane and toluene being convenient. Typical product structures are shown in Figs. 4-7. In the ruthenium reactions it is interesting that no hydrido species could be obtained when reactions were conducted under hydrogen. The isolation, by Bonnet and coworkers,1231of the species [ R U ~ N ~ ( ~ H ) ~ ( C O ) ~ (from V - Cthe ~ Hreaction ~)] of ruthenium dodecacarbonyl with [{Ni(q-C5H5)(CO)2}2] under hydrogen, suggested the intermediacy of the unstable [ R u ~ ( C OI )o H ~in ] , these reactions, however, the presence of a dry dihydrogen atmosphere made no difference to the products
Figure 4. The structure of [ O S(~-snR2)2(CO)s(~-CO)]; ~ R = CH(SiMe3)2.
1.4 Heteronucleur Clusters Huviny Trunsition Metuls and Metuls of Group 14
55
Figure 5. The structure of [Ru?(~-SnR2)1(C0)91; R = C6HzPr;-2.4.6.
when adding MR2 species to ruthenium clusters, and no hydrido species were isolated. )]; (Fig.4) are Structurally related to [ O s ~ ( p U - S n R 2 ) ~ ( C 0 ) ~ ( pR- C=0CH(SiMe3)2, both the ruthenium analogue, and the ruthenium and osmium compounds prepared with the amide Sn{N(SiMe3)2},, which is isoelectronic with Sn(CH(SiMe3)2},.
Figure 6. The structure of [Rui(pSnR2 ) 2 ( /r-SnRi)(C0)9;; R = ChHlPr\-2.4.6. R’ = CH(SiMe3)r
56
1 Moleculuv Clustcrs
The use of this and the related germanium amide as ligands for both clusters and single transition metal atoms has been described. [ 9 1 The compound [OS~{~-S~{N(S~M~~)~}~(CO)~(~-CO)] has the same metal framework as the alkyltin analogue, and similar parameters, though the preparation requires more forcing conditions, because of the lower nucleophilicity of the his(amido)- compared with the bis(alky1)-tin species. As expected the product is moisture sensitive [ Sn-N bonds] and appears to decompose readily in solution, even on standing in an inert atmosphere. A noteworthy feature of the structure is that the Sn-0s bonds are significantly longer in the amido-compound, but the decomposition is complex. since osmium dodecacarbonyl is a significant product. Structurally, the addition of a group 14 bridge leads to the lengthening of the M-M vector, (significantly more than by a bridging carbonyl) and a coplanar array of metal atoms, with the bulky alkyl or aryl substituents oriented in a plane close to, but not precisely perpendicular to the metal plane. The Sn-Ru distances are significantly shorter than the appropriate sum of covalent The turning away from the perpendicular direction becomes much more pronounced in triangular clusters of the type [Fe2(CO)h(p-MR2)](see below). Nevertheless, it is responsible for a unique stacking feature in certain clusters. For example the cluster [ R u(C0)9 ~ ( ~ - S ~ { C H ( S ~ M(p-Sn{ ~ ~ ) ZC~H2Pr\-2,4,6}~)2], }~) generated as follows:
+
[Ru3(C0)12] 2Sn{C6H2P~\-2,4,6}~ +
[ R u(c0) ~ lo(p-Sn{C6H2Pr;-2,4,6),)2]
[RU~(CO)IO(,LL-S~(C~H~P~;-~,~.~}~)~] + sn(CH(SiMe3)~)~ +
[ R u(C0)s(p-Sn{CH(SiMe3)2}2)(p-Sn{C6H2Pr;-2,4.6}2)2] ~
crystallises in space group P61 or P65 for individual crystals. The chirality results
I . 4 Hetc~ronuclcur Cltr~ter,Huriny Trunsition Metii1.T [mu' Metals o f Group I4
57
Figure 8. The structure of [Fe,(CO)*(p-SnR?)]; R = ChHiEt2-2,6.
from the helical packing of molecules within the crystal, forced by the different ligands surrounding the metal framework. and their twist. The product overall, is of course, a racemic mixture of the two forms. Whereas. as described under synthesis, the ruthenium carbonyl reacts without activation, and osmium requires the introduction of a labile ligand, but triiron dodecacarbonyl, with its weaker M-M and M-C bonds, generally undergoes some cluster breakdown on reaction with M R ? reagents, though not (see above) with a variety of group 15 donors.'"' The tin reagents, Sn(C6H2Prl,-2,4,6j2, Sn{CH(SiMe3)2}2, and Sn{C6H2Ph3-2.4,6jz all afforded the trinuclear clusters [Fez(C0)g(p-SnR2)], whose structures are shown in Figs. 8- 10.
Figure 9. The structure of [Fe2(C0)8(,u-SnR2)]; R = CsH?Pr;-2.4.6.
58
I Moleculur Clusters
Figure 10. The structure of [Fe2(C0)s(p-SnRz)], R = CsH*Ph3-2,4,6.
These molecules have the expected tin group bridging the Fe-Fe vector, but the disposition of the R groups is unexpected in that in each case the C-Sn-C plane is tilted significantly away from the perpendicular to the metal plane. This deviation can be quantified in terms of a “twist” angle, the dihedral angle between the metal and the C-Sn-C planes.‘251While this is difficult to explain in electronic terms, it is remarkably constant (73.8-77.3’ for a range of clusters) for the aryl substituted ligands, but rather more variable for the (less bulky) Sn{CH(SiMe3)2}, derivatives. Although it has not yet proved possible to add group 14 metals to a triangular iron framework, careful, low-temperature activation of [Fes(CO)121, using Me3NO and MeCN, followed by Sn{CH(SiMe3)2},, has allowed the isolation and characterization of an FezSnz cluster (Fig. 1 1).[261 This molecule is related to [Fe2(,~-SnMe2)2(CO)s],[~’] but both the stoichiometry and geometry are different in [Fe2(,~-sn{CH(SiMe3)2>,)2(CO)~]. In the dimethyl compound the Sn atoms can approach each other closely, so that the Fe atoms are forced apart and they acquire an 18-electron configuration from the 4 carbonyls and the bridging tin groups. This close approach of the tins is precluded with the bulky alkyl substituents, and the Fe atoms are now forced close, eliminating two carbonyls, so that they acquire an 18-electron configuration through a formal Fe=Fe bond, 3 carbonyls and the bridging groups. Carbonyls of the group 9 elements have been explored mainly with iridium, since rhodium analogues proved difficult to obtain, at least employing Rh4(C0)12 as a starting material. Iridium carbonyl is notoriously insoluble, and consequently difficult to substitute. We have employed two methods; activation with Me3NO/MeCN. or conversion to the anion [Ir4(CO)11Br]-, which is very convenient as Br- is
I,4 Neteronuclear Clusters Huving Trunsition Metals and Metuls of Group 14
59
Figure 11. The molecular structure of [Fe2(1c-SnR1)2(C0)6];R = CH(SiMe3)I
readily lost on treatment with a variety of nucleophiles, and which was used for the majority of the clusters described here. Although the amine oxide method works well, it requires low temperatures and we have not been able to characterize the acetonitrile adduct. Even with the most reactive of the MR2 species, e.g. Sn{CH(SiMe3)2},, Ir4(CO)12 failed to react, even at elevated temperatures in toluene. Perhaps more surprisingly, the nitrile adduct [Ir4(CO)IINCBU']also failed to give a tin cluster, though in this case decomposition occurred at higher temperatures. Activation with Me 3 N 0 followed by MeCN gave only an unstable brown solid, which was heat and light-sensitive. Treatment of this with Sn{CH(SiMe3)2}, in toluene afforded two iridium clusters of formulae [ I ~ ~ ( C O ) C I { S ~ { C H ( S ~ and M~~)~}~}~] [Ir3(CO)lo{Sn{CH(SiMe,),}2}2]. The first has a planar hexametallic metal framework, determined by a single crystal X-ray study, in which the Ir-Ir distances are significantly elongated over the parent carbonyl and other substituted derivatives. However, the crystals show disorder, and a full refinement was not possible. The other compound was also isolated using the bromide derivative, and is described below. Activation of the parent carbonyl using the bromo derivative has enabled us to isolate a much wider range of heterometallic clusters, the composition of which now depends on the group 14 species employed. In the case of Sn{CH(SiMe3)2},,
60
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 12. The molecular structure of [h(CO)9(p-C0)2( S n h ) ] ; R = CH(SiMe3)Z.
several clusters can be obtained depending both on the conditions and the stoichiometry.r281 When a single equivalent of the tin reagent is used in diethyl ether at low temperature, yellow-orange crystals of the expected [IT4(C0)g(p-C0)2(SnR2)] are obtained. This compound shows two distinct IR bands at 1872 and 1836 cm-', characteristic of bridging carbonyls, and implying the bridging mode for the tin addend. This structure was confirmed by an X-ray structure (Fig. 12). Curiously, when the reaction employs two equivalents of tin reagent, a similar orange-yellow crystalline material was the major product. Elemental analysis was identical to the earlier product, as was the ' H NMR, and the IR spectrum in solution. However, the crystals had a quite distinct solid-state IR spectrum: exhibiting four well-resolved bridging carbonyl bands at 1871, 1864, 1841, and 1832 cm-l. A possible structure for this isomer, has an axial, terminal SnR2, (the same orientation as the bromo-substituent in the starting anion), and four bridging carbonyls disposed as shown in the Fig. 13. Addition of a substantial excess of Sn(CH(SiMe3)2}, to the bromo anion in either ether or toluene gives a mixture of products as well as some unreacted [Ir4(CO)121. These products can be separated by careful chromatography, giving five new clusters of which two, formed in moderate quantities are described here. A yellow crystalline cluster having a single v(C0) in the bridging region (1800 cm-I) was paramagnetic and the elemental analysis showed an Ir : Sn ratio of 3 : 2. The structure is shown in Fig. 14.
1.4 Ht~teronuclcwC1ustrr.i Hacitig Tramition Metals and Metals of Group 14
Figure 13. Proposed structure for the second isomer of composition [Irq(c'O)I I (SnRz)].
61
CO R = CH(SiMe3)2
Once again the pentametallic structure is planar, with significantly lengthened lr-lr distances. The carbonyl bridged distance is 2.873(2)A, and the tin-bridged separations are 2.957(2) and 2.967(2)A. Not only are the tin bridging distances significantly longer than the carbonyl-bridged, as is normally found, but these distances are significantly greater than other bridged Ir-Ir lengths in planar clusters, (see for example below). The average value for those in Irq(CO)12 is 2.693& but comparisons are complicated with the tetrahedral structure in comparison to the planar array of the tin-iridium compound. The increases can be traced to the fact does not have the expected 48that the present cluster, [Ir~(C0),(p-CO)(pu-SnR2)2] electron-precise count, but is a 5 1 -electron cluster, with corresponding occupancy of orbitals having M-M antibonding character.
LJ
Figure 14. The molecular structure of [Iri(C0)9(~r-CO)(~-SnRz)z]; R = CH(SiMe?)>.
62
I Molecular Clusters
Q Figure 15. A molecule of [ h ( C O ) h(~-SnR2)2 ( ~ ~ - 0Sn-RSn03)I; 3 {R = CH(SiMe3)2}, with the methyl groups omitted for clarity.
The other main products of this reaction is the Ir3Sn3 compound referred to above, and a blue-green cluster with a complex IR carbonyl spectrum, (but no bridging carbonyls) both suggesting an unusual type of product. The structure of this material is shown in the Fig. 15. In this compound the Ir4 nucleus has been retained, but an Ir-Ir bond has been opened up to give the butterfly, two sides of which are tin-bridged. The third tin entity has lost an alkyl group, and bonds to the Ir4Snz raft by one direct Sn-Ir bond, and three oxygen bridges. The oxygen atoms must have been acquired during silica chromatography as the reaction conditions require the strictest exclusion of air and moisture because of the sensitivity of the SnR2 species, however the mechanistic details are not k n o ~ n . ' ' ~ ] When the same tin/iridium stiochiometry is employed, but a small amount of T H F is added to the solvent, the major product is now an air-sensitive purple cluster, again with an Ir$3n2 framework. This material has no bridging carbonyl stretches, is diamagnetic, and shows a ' H NMR peak in solution at 6 - 9.61; a region typical of late transition metal hydrides. The structure of this species, [Ir3(pU-SnR2)2(CO)*H], is shown in Fig. 16.[301 Hydrogen abstraction, which must occur from the added THF, allows the cluster to acquire the expected, (diamagnetic) electron precise 48-electron count. In agreement with this, the Ir-Ir bonds are now significantly shorter than in the electronrich cluster, (2.842(2), 2.834(2), and 2.838(2)A). It is noteworthy, however, that the iridium triangle is now considerably closer to equilateral than in the electron rich cluster, despite the presence of the high trans-influence hydride ligand, and the absence of the group bridging the third Ir-Ir vector.
1.4 Hrtrronucleur Clusters Having Transition Metals and Metals of Group 14
63
Figure 16. Molecular structure of [Ir3(/i-SnR~)2(CO)~H].
Use of the bulky aryltin( 11) monomer/dimer mixed species [SnArz/ArzSnSnArz], with Ar = C6H*Pri-2,4,6,in reactions with [Ir4(CO)11BrIpsalts, results in a different series of clusters. Again a mixture of products was obtained with the main components being a blue-green species believed to be an analogue of the raft described above, together with four other crystalline clusters, and trace materials. All of these clusters have been characterized by elemental analysis, and molecular weight measurements, and can be formulated as [Ir?(SnAr2)2(CO)6], [Ir3(SnArz)z(CO)s], [Ir4(p-SnAr2)4(CO)x],and [Ir4(,~~-SnAr2)5(CO)j]. The first, a red crystalline species, is air-sensitive, diamagnetic, and lacks carbonyl bridges; and almost cercontaining an Ir- Ir bond, tainly has the structure [(OC)3Ir(p-SnArz)zIr(C0)3], which confers an eighteen-electron configuration on the iridium atoms. The spectroscopic data for [Ir3(SnArz)~(CO)~] indicate that the structure is analogous to the electron-rich Sn{CH (SiMe3)2}, derivative, but lacking the bridging carbonyl. Spectroscopic data (IR and NMR) for the remaining compounds together with the analytical, molecular weight, and mass spectrometric data indicate the structures shown in Fig. 17, and, as implied, the species are both diamagnetic. X-ray structures are currently not completed for these clusters. While tin clusters form the widest range of heterometallic species reported here, it has proved possible to isolate and characterize some mixed lead compounds. These are both light- and air-sensitive, frequently precluding chromatographic separation, but in favorable cases, crystallisation using Schlenk techniques has given pure products. Few lead-transition metal clusters were known at the start of this work, and only for combinations with including a single structurally characterized species, [Pb{Fez(CO)s},].1341 We first introduced the lead( 11) species Pb(CsHzPh3-2,4,6)2 as a reagent having '
64
1 Moleculur Clusters
Figure 17. Proposed structures for the species [Ir4(pSnAr2)4(CO)g],and [Ir4(p-SnAr2)5(CO)j].
extremely bulky ligands, in order to protect the M-Pb bonds from chemical attack. The lead species is an extremely air- and light-sensitive purple solid, which can be stored with rigorous exclusion of air in the dark. Using this ligand, the sensitive species [Ru3(p-PbR2)2(CO)~(pu-CO)], [Ru~(~-P~R~)(CO)~(~-CO)~], and [Ir4(p-PbR2)(C0)s(p-C0)2]were prepared, and characterized spectroscopically but were not sufficiently stable for structural work to be carried out.[351However, using the reagent Pb{CH(SiMe3)2},, with [Ru3(C0)12]the clusters [Ru3(pU-PbR2)2(CO)9(p-CO)]and [ R u(p-PbR2) ~ (C0)g(p-CO)] were obtained, again as light- and airsensitive species.[361Reaction occurs on reflux in hexane, and the compounds must be separated by fractional crystallization, since chromatography leads to decomposition. The structure of [Ru3(p-PbR2)2(C0)9(pU-CO)] is shown in Fig. 18.
Figure 18. The molecular structure of [Rus(~-PbR2)2(C0)9 (P-CO)].
1.4 Heteronuclear Cliistei.s Huring Trunsition Metuls und Metuls of Group 14
65
In this molecule, the Ru-Ru vectors are significantly lengthened in comparison to the dodecacarbonyl as expected, and there is a single bridging carbonyl. The Ru-Pb distances (the first reported) range from 2.765(2)A to 2.790(2)A. In each case the lead bridges are asymmetrical, with the longer Pb-Ru separation being adjacent to the bridging carbonyl, and is possibly caused by a pseudo tvuns-influence of this ligand at the ruthenium center.
1.4.6 Clusters in which the Group 14 ligand or the heterometallic cluster has undergone further reaction The reaction of SnRz ( R = (Me3Si)lCH) with the reactive osmium hydride [ O S ~ ( P - H ) ~ ( C O )affords I O ] an Os3Sn cluster retaining both hydrogen at0ms:1~~1 [SnR21 + [ O S ~ ( P - H ) ~ ( C O ) I[~O] S ~ ( C O ) I O ( ~ ~ - H ) ~ S ~ R ~ ] +
The X-ray data, coupled with N M R data reveal that the hydrogen atoms are both in bridging positions, but one of them is between tin and osmium, a unique feature. The hydrogens were not directly located in the X-ray data, but the disposition of the other atoms around the bridged tin and osmium, the appropriate bond lengths, and intermediate 'J( '"Sn-'H) coupling all confirm this location (Fig. 19). As with many other compounds having main-group atoms bridged by hydrogen, [Os3(CO)lo(,u-H)2SnR2] is highly reactive, and certainly compared with any of the other clusters described here. Indeed on warming in solution, or even on standing in the solid state for prolonged periods brings about a rearrangement reaction.1381 An alkyl group of the tin moiety migrates to the carbon of a coordinated carbonyl producing an acyl group, and a hydrogen migration occurs so that both adopt the more usual position bridging two osmium atoms. The rearranged product has the structure shown in Fig. 20, in which methyl groups have been omitted for clarity. The tin atom now has trigonal planar coordination involving the remaining alkyl group and two of the osmium atoms. If we regard this as sp2 in character, the oxygen of the acyl group donates into the vacant, orthogonal p-orbital of the tin. This geometry of the cluster is seen to be in accord with this picture. A further reaction of the starting cluster is the coordination of his(dimethy1)acetylene dicarboxylate, which again involves the unique bridging hydride. In this case, both of the cluster hydrides are transferred to the same acetylenic carbon of the alkyne, so that the coordination of the resulting dihydro-derivative is through a single carbon, giving the carbene-complex with the structure shown in Fig. 21.
Figure 19. The structure of [Ow(CO)~o(~-H)zSnRzl (R = CH(SiMe3)2), showing the hydride positions.
1.4 Hetevonucleur C1uster.r Hcrcing Transition Metuls und Metal., of Group 14
67
Figure21. Thc structure of [Os;(~~-SnR~){pC(COOMe)CH~COOMe}(CO)l~]. [R = CH(SiMei)l]. Hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity.
The compound can then be represented as [0s3(p-SnR2){ p-C( CO0Me)CH2COOMe}(CO)lo]. [R = CH(SiMc3)2]. This mode of coordination of an alkyne to a cluster has no precedent. An unexpected feature of the structure is the close approach of one of the oxygen atoms of a COOMe group to one of the osmium atoms of the cluster (see Fig. 21).[381 The tin reagent [ S I I { ~ - C ( S ~ M ~ ~ ) ~ Cand ~ Hrelated ~N>~ species, ], although potentially good donors and moderately electron-rich at the metal centre, have four coordinate tin atoms, and therefore have a highly reduced tendency to add to clusters. However, with the reactive [Os3(pU-H)2(CO)lo], one of the tin ligands can be lost as the substituted picoline:
This elimination of the picoline, generates the Sn{2-C( SiMe3)2C5H4N} fragment, which coordinates to the cluster as a p-stannyne complex, as shown in Fig. 22. The remaining hydride remains coordinated to the cluster, bridging two of the framework osmium atoms. In terms of the electron count, this electron-precise cluster has 45 cluster valence electrons from the Os3(CO)loH fragment, and thus three are contributed, as required, by the stannyne group. Notable features of the structure are (i) the appreciable lengthening of the 0 s - 0 s distance bridged by the
68
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 22. The structure of [Osj(,u-H)(CO)lo{Sn{2-C(SiMej)zCsH4N)], omitting hydrogen atoms for clarity.
stannyne (3.001(4)A) compared to other tin-bridged osmium atoms, (ii) the correspondingly short distances of the Sn-0s bonds (2.641(2) and 2.642(2)A) compared to related separations, and (iii) the short Sn-N bond in the stannyne [2.235(14)A] compared to the starting reagent [Sn-N 2.449(7)A]1391.The first of these is perhaps surprising for an electron precise cluster, but the tin-ligand distances are easily understood in terms of the loss of a picolyl ligand, and donation of three electrons to the cluster framework. The stannyne complex is unstable in solution, losing a further picoline molecule, and affording a highly insoluble cluster, for which we have no structural data at present. The M(I1) reagents [ M ( C H ( P P ~ Z ) ~ }(M ~ ]= , Sn or Pb), introduced by Karsch,[401have three coordinate metal atoms, and again are expected to retain their composition when bonded to clusters. In this case though, reactions afford no isolable heterometallic clusters, but after work-up, give cluster adducts of the parent bis(phosphine), PhzPCH2PPh2. The hydrogen in the product must be an artifact of the experimental procedures emp10yed.l~'~ For example, in reaction with [ R u ~ ( C O121, ) the adduct [ R u ~ ( C Olo(dppm)] ) was obtained rapidly and quantita-
1.4 Hcteronucltw Clustrrc Hur inq TrunJition Metals ond Metuls of Group 14
69
Figure 23. The structure of [Ru?(CO)h(pSnK2)(pPh2PCH2PPh2)1, prepared by ligand transfer from [ Sn { CH (PPh2 ) 2 }?I.
tively using the tin reagent (lower yields were obtained from the lead analogue), whereas the free bis( phosphine) requires prolonged heating with chemical activation. This disappointing result can, however, be turned to good account. in preparing phosphine derivatives of existing clusters. The examples below illustrate this point:
Structures of these compounds are shown in Fig. 23 and 24.
70
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 24. The structure of the paramagnetic, electron-precise cluster [Os, (pSnR2):,(C0)g(,u-P~~PCH~PP~~)].
Acknowledgements The author wishes to acknowledge the outstanding contribution to this work of Dr. Christine Cardin, who has provided all the structural data on which this paper relies so heavily. He would also like to thank the coworkers cited in the references for their hard work and many helpful discussions, Dr. Paul R. Raithby for the provision of diffractometer time in the early years and for helpful discussions, the EPSRC, the Krieble fund, and the Reading University Research Endowment Fund for support.
References [l] K. H. Whitmire, J. Coord. Chem., 17, 95 (1988). [2] S. G. Anema, K. M. Mackay, and B. K. Nicholson, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Truns., 3853 (1996). [3] J. Lewis and J. R. Moss, Can. J. Chem., Rev. Can. Chimie, 73, 1236 (1995). [4] P. Braunstein, C. Charles, G. Kickelbick, and U. Schubert, Chem. Cornrnun., 2093 (1997).
1.4 Heteronuclmr Clusters Hiwing Transition Metals and Metals of Group 14
71
[5] L. R. Sita, R. M. Xi, G. P. A. Yap, L. M. LiableSands, and A . L. Rheingold. J. Am. Chetn. Soc., 119, 756 (1997). 161 C. J. Su, P. C. Su. Y. Chi, S. M. Peng, and G. J. Lee, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 118, 3289 (1996). [7] M. F. Lappert and R. S. Rowe, Coord. C'henz. R ~ L I100, . , 267 (1990). [8] R. Bohra, P. B. Hitchcock, M. F. Lappert, S. C. F. Auyeung, and W. P. Leung. J. Chem. Soc.; Dalton Trans., 2999 (1995). [9] S. L. Ellis. P. B. Hitchcock, S. A. Holmes, M. F. Lappert, and M. J. Slade, J. Oryanomet. Chem., 444. 95 (1993). [lo] M. Veith, S. Weidner. K. Kunze. D. Kafer, J. Hans, and V. Huch. Coord. Chem. Rec., 137, 297 [ 1994). [ 1 I ] T. Fjeldberg, A. Haaland, B. E. R. Schilling, H. V. Volden, M. F. Lappert, and A. J. Thorne, J. Oryanornet. Chem., 276, C 1 (1984). [I21 T. Fjeldberg, A . Haaland. B. E. R. Schilling. H. V. Volden, M. F. Lappert, and A. J. Thorne. J. Orgunomet. Chem., 280, C 43 (1985). [13] T. Fjcldberg, A. Haaland. B. E. R. Schilling, M. F. Lappert, and A. J. Thorne, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans.. I 5 5 1 ( 1 986). [14] D. E. Goldberg, P. B. Hitchcock, M. F. Lappert, K. M. Thomas, A. J. Thorne, T. Fjeldberg, A . Haaland, and B. E. R. Schilling, J. Chem. Soc.. Dalton Trans., 2387 (1986). I 151 P. J. Davidson and M. F. Lappert, J. Chem. Soc., Chenz. Commun., 317 (1973). [ 161 M. F. Lappert, J. Oryanornet. Chrm.. 100, 139 (1975). [I71 H. Alper and J. T. Edward, Cun. J. Chem., 48, 1543 (1970). [18] C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin, N. B. Kelly. G. A. Lawless, and M. B. Power, J. Oryunomet. Chcni., 341. 447 (1988). [I91 F. J. Brady, C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin. M. A. Convery, M. M. Devereux, and G. A. Lawless, J. Oryanomet. Chem., 241. 199 (1991), and references therein. 1201 C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin, M. B. Hursthouse, and G. A. Lawless, unpublished work. [ Z l l J . D. Cotton, P. J. Davidson, and M. F. Lappert. J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 2275 (1976). [22] C . J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin; J. M. Power, P. P. Power. and M. M. Olmstead, Unpublished ohsrruations (1985). (231 G. Lavigne, F. Papageorgiou. C. Bergounhou. and J. J. Bonnet, Inory. Chem., 22, 2485 (1983). 1241 C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin, G. A. Lawless. J. M. Power, M. B. Power, and M. B. Hursthouse, J. Oryanoniet. Chenz.,325, 203 ( 1987). 1251 C . J. Cardin. D. J. Cardin, M. A. Convery, M. M. Devereux, B. Twamley, and J. Silver, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Truns., 1145 ( 1996). [26] C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin, G. A . Lawless, and M. B. Powcr, Proc~edinysy f t h e Royul Irish Acudemy Section B Biological Geological and Chemicul Science, 89, 399 (1989). 1271 C . J. Gilmore and P. Woodward, J. Chmm.Soc., Dalton Trans., 1387 (1972). 1281 C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin, and M. B. Power, unpuhlishrd ohsertations (1990). 1291 C . J. Cardin, M. B. Power, and D. J. Cardin. J. Oryanomet. Chem.,462, C 27 (1993). [30] C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin. H. Henke, and M. B. Power. unpuhlished ohservations (1990). [31] T. J. Marks, and A. R . Newmann, J. A m . Chem. Soc.. 0.5; 769 (1973). [32] J. D. Cotton, S. A. R. Knox, I. Paul. and F. G. A. Stone, Journal of the Chemical Society, A , 264 (1967). 1331 J. Dalton. I Paul, and F. G. A. Stone, Journul oj'tlzr Chemical Society> A , 1215 (1968). [34] K. H. Whitmire, C. B. Lagrone. M. R. Churchill, J . C. Fettinger, and B. H. Robinson, Inory. Chcm., 26, 3491 (1987). 1351 D. J . Cardin and B. Twamley, unpublished observations (1994). [36] N. C. Burton, C . J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin, B. Twamley, and Y. Zubavichus, Organornetallic~.s, 14. 5708 (19951. ~
12
1 Molecular Clusters
1371 C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin, H. E. Parge, and J. M. Power, J. Cllrm. Soc., Chem. Commun., 609 (1984). 1381 C. J. Cardin, D. J. Cardin, J . M. Power, and M. B. Hursthouse, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 107, 505 (1985). [39] L. M. Engelhardt, B. S. Jolly, M. F. Lappert, C. L. Raston, and A. H. White, J. C'hern. Soc., Chem. Commun. 336 (1988). [40] H. H. Karsch, and G. Mueller, Orgunomrtnllics, 5 , 1664 (1986). [41] D. J. Cardin and M. M. Devereux, unpuhlishedohsevautions (1991). ~
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.5 Hetero-Metal Clusters by Assembling Amino Substituted Subvalent Main Group Metals and their Ligand Reactions
1.5.1 Introduction Over the last fifteen years we have been interested in assembling several metallic elements around a central transition metal to create a metal cluster by this strategy. Our approach has been very simple, and we have used his(amino)carbene analogues (related to molecules containing ns’-elements) such as Me?%(NtBu)zM ( M = Ge, Sn, Pb) to replace standard nonmetallic ligands in a transition metal complex M’L,, ( L = CO, PR3, organic ligands). A brief review of the molecular clusters synthesized in our laboratory is given here. Because in the final clusters the metallic elements like Ge or Sn are only three coordinates (for tetra-coordinate G e or Sn see reviewsl’.’I or recent literaturei3’)we were curious to know if we could use this specific property for further reactions. Within this general theme there were two main questions: ( 1 ) Would the inner metallic skeleton survive in oxidation reactions‘? (2) Could we use the amino ligands bonded to the main group metals for nucleophilic substitution without destroying the inner metallic arrangement? As some of the structural results have not been published so far, we have added some brief experimental details in footnotes. It is not within the scope of this article to cover the whole literature on this topic; we would nevertheless like to point out that clusters similar to those dealt with in this article have also been prepared by M.F. Lappert’s g r ~ u p . ~Recently, ~ , ’ ~ one of my former coworkers. L. Stahl, has extended the amino stabilization concept to new transition metal comp1exes.I” A general review concerning the synthesis of hetero-metal clusters with ns’-main group metals and covering some of the general literature appeared in 1992.’”
74
1 Molecular Clusters
1.5.2 Syntheses of clusters by using MezSi( NtBu)2M (M = Ge(II), Sn(I1)) Syntheses of metal clusters with CO as coligand In 1981‘’’ we reported for the first time that the bis(amino)stannylene 2 can replace CO ligands in hexacarbonyl complexes of chromium or molybdenum. It has since been found that this type of reaction can be expanded to either the bis(amino)germylene 1 or to W(CO)6 as summarized in Eq. (1).
M
= G e(l), Sn
(2)
M
= Ge, Sn; M’ = Cr, Mo, W
(1)
The substitution of CO by the his(amino)germylene or -stannylene is carried out thermally in refluxing toluene or, alternatively, by displacement of tetrahydrofuran ( T H F ) by germylene or stannylene from the intermediate complex (CO)SM’(THF)’~ in] ,a photochemical reaction. The lead analogue of 1 and 2, Me2Si(NtBu)2Pb[’01,does not seem to react similarly as we have been unable to isolate well characterized products. When an excess of M’(CO)6 is used mostly the mono-substituted derivatives with n = 1 and the general formula Me*%(NtBu)2M-M’(C0)5 are generally formed. Using an excess of 1 or 2, besides the mono complexes, complexes with a higher substitution number (n = 2 or 3) are also formed. This is not only observed when W(CO)6 is used as the starting material but also with the metal carbonyls of chromium or molybdenum. Until now, we have not carried out a systematic study, but we have isolated one of the triply substituted complexes of chromium, [MeZSi(NtBu)2Sn]3Cr(CO)3 (3), in the crystalline form. The result of the single crystal X-ray determination of this compound“ is depicted in Fig. 1. In the crystal, two different molecules with the same composition and metal arrangement are found in the asymmetric unit, but they differ in their point symmetry (one is C2, the other C l ) and by the mutual orientation of the planar SiNzSn four membered rings to one another (only one molecule is shown in the figure). The four metal atoms are in a plane forming a T-shape with Cr occupying the central position; this mer configuration is common to the two symmetrically independent molecules. Even in solution we have found no evidence (13C, 29Si NMR), for the presnce of a f u c isomer. The Cr-Sn distances fall into two categories: there are short distances for the Sn-Cr bonds that are trans to one another (2.504-2.515 A) and longer Sn-Cr bonds for all those that are in a cis position to two other Sn-Cr bonds and trans to a CO group (2.542-2.543 A). The shorter trans Sn-Cr bonds are consistent with longer Sn-N bonds in the SnN2Si rings (mean
I . 5 Hetero-Metal Clusters
75
Figure 1. One of the two independent molecules in the crystal structure of 3 is shown." ' I Hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity: carbon and oxygen atoms are not labeled.
value: 2.06(1)A) compared to the longer cis Sn-Cr bonds, which are associated with shorter Sn-N bonds (mean: 2.03( 1) A). The Cr-C bonds show no special effect and the atoms in the cis and trans positions have similar bond lengths (1.84(3)A). Another metal cluster, which also contains four metal atoms is formed when the carbene analogues 1 or 2 are reacted with either Mn2(CO)lo or FeZ(C0)g (Eqs. 2a and 2b).1'23'31
+
2 Me?Si(NtBu)zM Mn?(CO)lo 1.2 +
2 CO
+ [Me2Si(NtBu),M]2[Mn(C0)4]2 M
= Ge
(2a)
(4), Sn ( 5 )
+
Me?Si(NtBu)?M FeZ(C0)o 132 +
Fe(C0)5 + I/n [Me2Si(NtBu)2M-Fe(C0)4In n = 1 M = Ge (6). Sn (7) n = 2 M = Ge (S), Sn (9)
(2b)
As in Eq. (1). in the reactions of 1 or 2 with dimanganesedecacarbonyl, the carbony1 groups are displaced by an equal number of the 1 or 2 groups. The crystal structure determinations of 4 and 5 reveal that the germanium and tin atoms do not simply replace the carbon atoms of the carbonyl groups, but also lead to a rearrangement of the structure: in each case a four-membered planar MzMn? ring is formed. In Fig. 2 the result of the X-ray structure determination of 4 is shown, the structure of 5 is quite similar but nevertheless different in some details.
76
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 2. The centrosymmetric molecule [Me?%(NtBu)zGe]*[Mn(CO)412 14) from an X-ray structure determination."3' See also caption to Fig. 1. The Mn -Mn bond is represented as a dashed line.
The most striking difference between the two compounds 4 and 5 both of which have the same point symmetry C , and are isomorphous,[l3]are the unsymmetrical Ge-Mn bonds in 4 (2.460(2)A and 2.600(2)A) while in 5 the corresponding Sn-Mn bonds are quite similar (2.61 13(4)A and 2.693(1)A). Compared to Mn?(CO)s(pC O ) ( / L - G ~ M ~ ~ )which , " ~ I has Mn-Ge distances in the range of 2.432-2.4437(2) A, one of the two bonding distances in 4 is clearly elongated. We think this phenomenon could be most easily explained by steric requirements and not by electronic effects. On this line Mn-C distances tr-uns to the Mn-Ge bonds show no significant differences (1.798(5)and 1.808(5)A). the Mn-Mn distances In comparison to MnZ(C0)lo ( M n . . .Mn 2.923(3) in 4 and 5 are systematically elongated (4: Mn-Mn = 3.025(2)& 5 : Mn-Mn = 3.184A). Whereas the expansion of the bond in the germanium derivative 4 is quite small, in the tin derivative 5 it is more important. From N M R measurements we deduce that 4 and 5 are diamagnetic. We therefore propose an intramolecular Mn-Mn bond in these derivatives or a stable singlet state of a diradical. It is interesting that despite the different Mn-Ge/Mn-Sn bond lengths. the equivalent angles within the M2Mn2 rings at Ge or Sn (4:73.4( l)', 5 : 73.7( 1)") or at Mn (4: 106.6(l)", 5 : 106.3(1)") are almost equal. As may be deduced from Eq. (2b) similar M2M2' rings are obtained by the reaction of 1 and 2 with Fe2(C0)9. Nevertheless, the situation is complicated by an equilibrium between the monomeric entities [MezSi(NtBu)2M-Fe(C0)4], 6 and 7, and the dimers 8 and 9 (Eq. 3), respectively. 2Me2Si(NtBu)2M-Fe(C0)4 M = G e (6),Sn (7)
+ [ M ~ ~ S ~ ( N ~ B U ) ~ M - F ~ ( C O( 3) )~ ] ~ M
= Ge
(8),Sn (9)
While the equilibrium for 7/9 is relatively quickly attained at room temperature with a 1 : 1 ratio of 7 to 9, the corresponding 6/8 equilibrium is very slow. As a matter of fact, in a freshly prepared solution of 6 only NMR spectral data due to the monomer is present. When a toluene solution of 6 is allowed to stand for several
1.5 Hetero-Metul Clusters
77
Figure 3. The centrosymmetric molecule [Me: Si(N tBu)z Sn]?[Fe(CO:d]2 (9j from an X-ray structure determination.[' 31 For further details see caption to Fig. 1.
days, the signals of 8 become prominent attaining a 3 : 1 ratio at room temperature. Both the equilibria 6/8 and 7/9 are temperature dependent, as shown by NMR, shifting in both cases to the monomer at higher temperatures. The structure of 9 has been determined by X-ray analysis and the arrangement of atoms is depicted in Fig. 3.[l3IThe molecule again has C, point symmetry (compare 4, 5 ) which means that the central four membered metal cluster is strictly planar and crystallizes isotypically in a centro-symmetric lattice. As in 4 and 5 the two SiNzSn rings are almost perpendicular to the central Sn?Fe:! ring; the two tin atoms can thus be considered as spiro-centers. The most remarkable properties of the compound are the following: 1) Although there is a monomer/dimer equilibrium in solution, the two Fe-Sn distances are closer to one another (Sn-Fe: 2.712(2)A; Sn-Fe': 2.685(2)A)than the corresponding Ge-Mn or Sn-Mn distances in 4 and 5 . [(Cp)?SnFe(C014]2has a structure similar to that of 9, the FezSn:! ring displaying shorter Fe-Sn bonds (2.651 and 2.670!~)"". 2) The Fe-Fe distance (4.116(1)A) within the Fe:!Snz ring is much larger than a typical Fe-Fe bond length and the Sn-Sn separation (3.492(1)A) is smaller than in compound 5 . As expected, no metal-metal interactions across the ring diagonals need to be considered. As in other transition metal complexes of Me?%(NtBu)zSn, 2 , the coordination of the tin atom to the transition metal leads to a shortening in Sn-N bond length (9: Sn-N (mean): 2.06819)A) compared with the uncoordinated compound ( 2 :2.091(5)AJ.'17' Another type of reaction of 1 and 2 with simple metal carbonyls has been observed with Co:!(COis (Eq.(4)). Me:! Si (N t Bu)?M t Coz (CO), M = Ge ( I ) . Sn ( 2 )
+
Me:! Si(N rBu):!M [Co(CO),]z M = Ge (10),Sn (11)
(4)
In these reactions the carbene analogues 1 and 2 insert into the Co-Co bond of the dicobaltoctacarbonyl forming a triatomic MCo2 metal cluster. I' 81 The reactions
78
I Moleculur Clusters
Figure 4. The molecular structure of [MezSi(NtBu)&1][Co(C0)4]2 (11) as determined by X-ray diffraction techniques'"] (see also caption to Fig. I ) .
are almost quantitative. The compounds obtained from these reactions are diamagnetic and all spectroscopic data are in accord with an insertion product of the carbene analogue into the transition metal-metal bond. The result of the X-ray structure analysis on 11 is shown in Fig. 4. In the crystal structure of 11 the asymmetric unit contains two independent molecules that are nevertheless quite similar in their structures. The two Sn-Co distances [2.632(2)A and 2.638(1) A] are almost equal. They are longer than in the comparable compound ClzSn[Co(CO)& in which the Co-Sn distances are in the range of 2.533-2.535A,L191but are shorter than the Fe-Sn distances in 9 (see above). Even in the compounds C lS n [ C 0 ( C 0 ) 4 ] 3 [ ~ ~ ~ and S ~ S ~ ~ [ C O ( Cthe O Sn-Co ) ~ ] ~ distances ~ ~ ~ ~ (2.606& 2.59 A) are shorter than in 11. The Sn-N distances in 11 (2.059A) are again shortened with respect to the free bis(amin0)stannylene 2 (see above). The Co-Sn-Co bond angles in 11 are 115.4(1)" and 116.6(1)",respectively, and confirm that there is no Co-Co bonding interaction.
Reactions of 1 and 2 with cyclopentadienyl-carbonylmetal complexes The insertion ability of carbene analogues 1 and 2 into metal-metal bonds (see above) can be expanded to include many molecules with metal-metal or metalcarbon bonds. As some of these results have been published previously, we just briefly mention the products obtained in these reactions.i221 Cp(CO)lFe-Fe(CO)zCp
+ MezSi(NtBu)zGe 1 i
Me2Si(NtBu)zGe[Fe(CO)2Cp]2 ( 5 ) 12
1.5 Hetwo-Mrtul Clusters
Cp(C0)2Fe-Fe(CO)2Cp
79
+ 2Me*Si(NtBu)zSn [Cp(CO)2Fe]2[Me*%(NtBu),Sn]z 13
4
(6)
Cp(C0)2Fe-Me + MelSi( N tBu)?M M = Ge ( l ) , S n (2) +
Me2 Si ( NtBu) 2 M (Me)[ Fe(C0)2 CP] 14 ( M = Ge). 15 ( M = Sn)
(7)
As may be seen from inspection of Eqs. ( 5 ) and (6) the two his(amino)carbene analogues react differently with [ Cp(C0)2Fe]2. While only one germylene inserts into the iron-iron bond forming 12, two stannylene units are inserted to form 13. In the first case a triatomic heterometal cluster is obtained with an electron count similar to that in compounds 10 and 11 and in the second case (Eq. 6) a tetraatomic Fe-Sn-Sn-Fe zigzag chain with point symmetry C, is obtained with Sn-Fe distances of2.605(2) A and a Sn-Sn bond length of 2.991(2) A; the Fe-Sn-Sn angle is 117.9(1)". In contrast to compound 9, the Sn-N distances are not shortened in 13 and are found to be almost equal to that in the free stannylene (13: Sn-N 2.099(2) A). In Eq. ( 7 ) the results of the insertion of the low valent elements in 1 and 2 into an iron-carbon bond are summarized. The two products 14 and 15 are obtained in almost quantitative yield and are similar in structure.'221 Another reactivity pattern of the carbene analogues 1 and 2 with cyclopentadienyl metal carbonyls was established with C O ( C ~ ) ( C O ) ~As. "can ~ ~ be concluded from Eq. (8), carbon monoxide is smoothly eliminated and the cobalt atom in Co(Cp)(CO)bonds to a germanium or tin atom.
+
2Me*Si(NtBu)zM 2Co(Cp)(CO)2 M = Ge (1),Sn (2) +
[Me2Si(NtBu),M-Co(Cp)CO], M = Ge (16),Sn (17)
+2 C 0
(8)
In both cases the simple M-Co compound is not obtained but a dimeric species with a MICo2 ring. This can unambiguously be established by an X-ray structure analysis, which has been performed on single crystals of 17. The molecule is centrosymmetric (Fig. 5 ) and has the point symmetry C Z h , the two fold axis running through the silicon and tin atoms and the mirror plane intersecting the cyclopentadienyl ligands and running through the cobalt atoms and the carbonyl group. The Sn-Co bonds are thus equal (2.567(1)A) and the angles at Sn (98.2') and Co(8l.X)'' add up to 180". It is interesting to compare this compound 17 with compound 5 in which a
80
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 5. The molecular structure of the trans isomer (mutual orientations of the Cp ligands with respect to the ring) of [MezSi! NtBu)2Sn]*[Co(Cp)CO]z (17) as determined by X-raydiffraction techniques['" (see also caption to Fig. 1). The molecule has Czi, symmetry in the crystal.
Mn-Mn bond seems to be present, and with 9 where the Co(Cp)CO unit is replaced by the isoelectronic Fe(C0)4 unit. A superposition of 17 and 9 shows, that the two molecules are quite similar, the bonds within 17 being about 95% shorter than in 9 (this holds for M'-M', Sn-M' and Sn-Sn distances in the two molecules). As a consequence the Cp(C0)Co group is more tightly bonded to the main group metals than is the Fe(C0)4 unit. The central four membered ring in 5 is, on the other hand, very different from the M'2Sn2 rings in 9 and 17. Here the Mn-Mn distance is obviously much smaller than the corresponding M' -M' distances in 9 and 17. The probable Mn-Mn bonding interaction is nicely reflected by this comparison (see also Fig. 6). Besides the formation of the dimers 16 and 17, there is an equilibrium between two forms in solution. The two cyclopentadienyl groups of the dimer can be either trans oriented to one another (as in the crystal) or cis oriented (Eq. 9). The cis compound is easily recognized by its 'H- and "C-NMR spectra that show two different tert-butyl groups, whereas the trans compound has only one symmetrically independent tert-butyl group. The equilibrium is temperature dependent, the cis: trans ratio for 16 and 17 at room temperature is approximately 1 : 2 and at 330 K it approaches 1 : 1, the cis isomer growing at the expense of the trans isomer. I*'1
Figure 6. Comparison between MrM; rings of equal size: 17 with 9 (SnzFcz) and 17 with 5 (SnzMnz).
1.5 Hetevo-Metal Clu.sters
cis
81
trans
Syntheses of metal clusters with phosphine, cyclopentadienyl ligands and homoleptic complexes The Wilkinson catalyst Rh( PPh3)3C1 has been allowed to react with the germylene Me2Si(NtBu)zGe (1) and the stannylene MezSi(NtBu)zSn (2).The products of these reactions are quite different and are strongly dependent on the carbene analogue (Eqs. 10, 1 l a and 1 l b ) . 1 2 3 1 4 MezSi(NtBu)lGe 1
+ Rh(PPh3)3Cl +
3 PPh3
+ [MezSi(NtBu)2Ge]4RhCl
(10)
18 2 MelSi(NtBu)zSn 2
+ Rh(PPh3)3Cl
4
PPh3 + ci,r-[Me2Si(NfBu)zSn]2Rh(PPh3)2Cl 19
(1 la)
5 MezSi(NtBu)zSn + Rh(PPh3)3Cl 2 +
3 PPh3 + [Me~Si(NtBu)zSn]5RhCl 20
(1 l b )
The reaction of 1 with Rh( PPhl)3C1 proceeds directly to the homoleptic complex 18, which has been fully characterized, and we have not been able to detect any intermediate in this reaction.1241 The analogous reaction of 2 with Rh( PPh3)3C1can be separated into two steps: first a trinuclear metal entity 19 is formed, and at higher molar ratios of 2 the homoleptic tin substituted rhodium(1) complex 20 is formed. which contains six metal atoms clustered at the center of the m o 1 e c ~ l e . l ~ ~ ~ The compounds 18, 19 and 20 have been characterized by X-ray structure determination techniques. In 18, the central unit is an almost square planar germanium arrangement in the middle of which the rhodium atom is situated. One of the edges
82
I Molecular Clusters
of this central Ge4-square is bridged by a chlorine ligand. Compound 20 is different from 18 as all five tin atoms are coordinated around the rhodium atom in a trigonal bipyramidal fashion, the chlorine ligand again bridging two of the tin centers. The difference in structures may be attributed to the lower steric demands of ligand 2. Finally the tin atoms in compound 19 are in a cis arrangement with the rhodium atom occupying the center of a distorted square planar coordination polyhedron, which is made up of two tin and two phosphorus atoms. Again two tin atoms are bridged by the chlorine ligand. The Ge-Rh and Sn-Rh distances in 18, 19 and 20 are in the expected range (Ge-Rh: 2.337-2.376; Sn-Rh: 2.526-2.571 A) and reflect the coordination numbers of the elements under consideration. The reaction of Pd(PPh3)4 with MezSi(NtBu)zSn is somewhat reminiscent of that with Rh( PPh3)3Cl as again the stannylene replaces the phosphine l i g a n d ~ . ' The ~~] product 21, which can be isolated from this reaction (Eq. 12), still contains one triphenyl-phosphine ligand bonded to each palladium center. Pd(PPh3)4
+ 3/2 Sn(NtBu)zSiMez +
1/2(PPh3)Pd[Sn(NtBu)2SiMez]$d(PPh), + 3 PPh3
(12)
21
The PdzSn3 trigonal bipyramidal metal cluster formed in this reaction (X-ray structure evidence) is new for Pd,Sn, systems but has previously been found for platinum-tin systems in (Ph3P)Pt(Snacac)3Pt(PPh3).'251 An interesting feature of the structure is that the SiNzSn rings in 21 are oriented in a paddle wheel fashion and thus create chirality along a three-fold axis (two different molecules crystallize in the asymmetric unit of the lattice). The Pd-Sn bond lengths are found between 2.688 and 2.725A. The Pd-Pd separation in 21 is only 2.590A, which suggests that Pd-Pd bonding may be present. In accord with this model the Pd-Sn-Pd angles are extremely acute (56.94-57.54'). A very elegant way of forming a NiSn4 cluster saturated by amide ligands involves the displacement of cyclooctadiene (cod) from the Ni(cod)z complex by the bis(amin0)stannnylene 2 (Eq. 13).lz6' Ni(cod)z
+ 4Sn(NtBu)2SiMe2 2
+
2cod
+ Ni[Sn(NtBu)2SiMe2]4
(13)
22
The blood-red compound 22 contains five metal atoms of which the four tin atoms tetrahedrally coordinate the central nickel atom, as has been confirmed by X-ray structure analysis. The tin-nickel distances range from 2.388(2)-2.399(2) A. Because of the steric crowding of the tert-butyl groups of the amino ligands, the Sn-Ni-Sn angle deviates considerably (up to 12") from the ideal value of 109.5". The same coordination number at nickel, but in a different geometry, is found when NiBrz is reacted with 2. A similar reactivity and similar structures are found
1.5 Hetero-Metal Clusters
83
for PdC12 and PtC12 while other transition metal halides (CrC12, FeC12, CoC12, ZnClz) form Lewis acid/base adducts with 2 without any direct transition metal-tin bonding (Eq. 14).‘241
+
4 Me.ISi(NtBu)*Sn M’X2 2
i
M’[Sn(NtBu)2SiMe2]4X, M’ = Ni,X = Br (23) M’ = Pd, Pt; X = C1 (24,25)
(14)
The molecules 23, 24 and 25 have an almost planar M’Sn4 cross in common with the transition element occupying the central site in all cases. The two halogen ligands are in between two tin atoms forming almost symmetrical Sn-X-Sn bridges with acute angles (74-81”) at the halogen atoms. The change in the coordination geometry of Ni in going from molecule 22 to 23 can be understood by a change in the oxidation state from formal 0 (d”) to +2 (d’). The Sn-Ni distances are elongated in 23 when compared to 22: they are found between 2.459(4) and 2.466(4)A and reflect the higher coordination number at tin in 23. A quite spectacular ‘insertion reaction’ of the carbene analogues 1 and 2 into transition metal ligand bonds is found with nickelocene [NiCpz] (Eq. 15).’”’ NiCp,
+ 2 MezSi(NtBu)zM 1 (Ge).2 (Sn)
+
[CpNi(M(NtBu)zSiMe2},(lu-Cp)] M = Ge (26).Sn (27)
(15 )
The crystal structures of 26 and 27 reveal a novel type of cluster. As a matter of fact, the three metallic atoms are connected to one another to form an open triangle whereby the nickel atom occupies the central position. This triangular unit is intermediate between two parallel cyclopentadienyl ligands (Ni is penta-hapto coordinated to one of the cyclopentadienyl units, while the two main group metals coordinate to the second cyclopentadienyl) and the structure can thus be regarded as a Cp, ‘sandwich’ centered by a triatomic cluster. The germanium compound differs from the tin compound by the asymmetric cyclopentadienyl bridge, which becomes symmetrical in the tin derivative. The Ge-Ni distances thus differ considerably (2.085(3) and 2.258(3)A) while the Sn-Ni distances are almost equal (2.326(2) and 2.369(2)A). The metal-metal distances are very short as may be seen from the comparison of the bond lengths in 22 and 23 (see above).
Trimetallic clusters with bis(amin0)germylenes and stannylenes As a consequence of our versatile assemblage routes, which had so far led only to clusters with two different metallic elements, we thought it to be useful to apply this strategy to obtain clusters with three different metallic elements. In collaboration with P. Braunstein and M. Knorr we have explored the reaction of heterodinuclear complexes, stabilized by the ‘diphos’ ligand and with a Si(OMe)3group attached to iron, with 1 and 2, the results being illustrated in Eqs. (16), (17) and (18).[2x1
84
1 Molecular Clusters
P h 3 e Pt
Fe(C0)3
~
+ MqSi(NtSu),M
-----)
Ph3-F-'
I
H
Si(OMe)3
phcx'.'"
Fe(C0)3 + {H-Si(OMe)3}
(16)
'd
M = Gem, Sn (2) Si Me2 M = Ge (23,Sn (29) X = CH2, NH
ph2ri"'ph[Ar Fe(C0)3 + Me2Si(NtBu)2Ge--t Me$i(Nm~)~Ge-p
Ph3+Pt-
Fe(C0)3 + PPh,
\/
\/
A tSu-N\r-tBu
71
mu-r TrnU Si
Si Me2
Me2 29
30
phrr
Me-M
*\
/ Me
,e(CO)3+ Me2Si(NtBu)2M
0-
(17)
Si(OMe)2
-----)
' " ' I *"' Me-T-r (18)
Me2siwBu)2\
/si(OMe),
0 M
= Ge
(I), Sn (2)
Me
M = Ge, M' = Pd (30) M = Sn, M' = Pd (31) M = S n , M'=F't(32)
In Eq. (16) a ligand on Pt and on Fe ( H and Si(OMe)3)is completely displaced by a bridging main group metaldi(amide): the compounds 28 and 29 have been fully characterized by several methods, multinuclear NMR being the most diagnostic. So
85
1.5 Hetero-Metul Clustrcs
far we have not analysed the products which result from the formally displaced trimethoxysilane. Nevertheless. in the two cases a trimetallic cyclic cluster is obtained with three different metal atoms. Unfortunately we were not able to add a further stannylene ligand to 28 by displacing the triphenylphosphine group. As illustrated in Eq. (17) this reaction also occurs with the bis(amino)germylene (1) leading to the tetra-metallic compound 30 which contains three different metallic elements. Another synthetic route to trimetallic clusters is shown in Eq. (1 8): here a formal insertion of the germylene 1 and stannylene 2 into the 0-Pd( Pt) bond takes place and the metal clusters 31, 32 and 33 are obtained. An X-ray crystal structure determination of 31 reveals a rather short Ge-Pd bond (2.36(5)A)and a remarkably long Fe-Pd bond (2.74(6)A). Variable temperature NMR spectroscopy on 31, 32 and 33 is consistent with a rapid exchange of the methoxy groups on germanium and tin, respectively. In summary, we have synthesized various heterobimetallic and heterotrimetallic clusters. The different structural motifs of these clusters are shown in Fig. 7 for general comparison (the ligand on the main group metals M is exclusively
M/ M \ M
RhSn, (19) NiGe, (26) NiSn, (27)
&CO, (10) SnCo, (11) GeFe, (12)
FeSn,Fe
GePdFe (31) SnPdFe (32) SnPtFe (33)
PtFeGe (28) FVFeSn (29)
CrSn,
(13)
(3)
\M PtFeGe, (30)
MnzGe, (4) Mn,Sn, (5)
M M
M
.M, M
NiSn,
I
\M
M’ ’ M
M
(22)
RhGe,
‘M (18)
NiSn, (23)
PdSn, (24) PtSn, (25)
Pd,Sn,
(21)
I
M
M
RhSn,
(20)
NiSn, (35)
Figure 7. General structural motifs of metal atoms in clusters using M( NtBuiZSiMel [M = G e ( I ) , Sn (2)jas “ligands” to transition metals (M’). The numbers in parcntheses refer to the molecules specified in the text.
86
1 Molecular Clusters
Ligand reactions of amino substituted heterometal clusters With the syntheses of metal complexes of the bis(amino)germylene, 1, and -stannylene, 2, we have made available a huge number of different metal clusters (see above). We have also begun to study the properties of these metal centered molecules in view of addition and substitution reactions that occur without destroying the central metal part of these molecules. Our first results in this area are outlined in this chapter. All the reactions have the homoleptic compound Ni[Sn(NtBu)2SiMe2]4,22, as the starting material. The first attempt was to oxidize 22 using simple oxidation reagents such as Br2 or PhMe3NBr3. Compound 22 is very sensitive to oxidation and reacts immediately with elemental halogens. As the reactions proceed very quickly we were not able to isolate pure products, and a mixture of different oxidized species as shown in Eq. (19) was obtained.'241
+
[Me2Si(NtB~)~Sn]4NiX2 22
+ NiBr2
+ SnBr2 +
x Me2 Si(N tBu)zSn(NtBu)2SiMe2 t
+
y [Me2Si(NtBu)2Sn]4NiBr2 z Me2Si(NtBu),SnBr2 23
(19)
X2 = Br2, PhMe3NBr3
The formation of the compounds NiBrz and Me&( NtBu)2SnBr2 indicates that oxidation has proceeded too far and has led to an irreversible destruction of the cluster. MezSi(NtBu)zSn(NtBu)2SiMe2 and SnBr2 are known to originate from the reaction of Me2Si(NtBu)zSnBrz with the bis(amino)stannylene 2. The only product, which still has the NiSn4 cluster unit in the molecular skeleton, is [MezSi(NtBu)2Sn]4NiBr2 which by comparison of its spectral data with those of 23, which is obtained by an alternative route (see above), can be easily characterized. Thus, it has been shown that an oxidation of 22 to a small extent is possible without destroying the cluster. It is important to note that this oxidation is accompanied by a structural change of the cluster and the tetrahedral Sn4Ni core of the molecule 22 changes to an almost planar Sn4Ni arrangement, which is typical of a formal Ni2+ with ds electron configuration. We believed that replacement of the amino ligands on the nickel complex 22 by alkoxo or siloxo ligands is feasible. Nevertheless, the treatment of 22 with alcohols poses in itself problems and the steric bulk of the groups attached to the hydroxyl moiety plays an important role. The type of products which can be obtained are shown in Eqs. (20)-(22).'291
1.5 Hetero-Metul Clusters
H
+
I
[MezSi(NtBu)zSn]4Ni 4 CH3OH 22
+
[MezSi(NtBu)2Sn]4Ni niPrOH 22
+
87
OCH3 I
[Me2Si(NtBu)(NtBu)Sn]4Ni (20) 34
x Mez[NtBu(H)]z
4
H I
0-iPr I
+ y [MezSi(NtBu)2Sn]2[Me2Si(NtBu)(NtBu)Sn] [(iPrO)zSn]2Ni
(21)
35 [Me2Si(NtBu)2Sn]4Ni+ 8 Ph3SiOH +4
[(Ph3SiO)zSn]2+ 4 Me$3[NtBu(H)]2
+ Ni
(22)
The reaction in Eq. (22) is an example of the complete destruction of the original cluster; the amine ligands on tin were replaced by tri( pheny1)siloxy groups with quantitative formation of the amine MezSi[NtBu(H)]2, but the nickel-tin bonds are lost and bond fission was observed. Besides the formation of elemental tin, the dinuclear complex [( Ph3SikO)zSnlz was obtained as a white crystalline product and characterized unambiguously by an X-ray structure determination. [291 While tert-butanol does not react with 22 (presumably due to the steric bulk of the tert-butyl group), methanol reacts smoothly to form the tetra-alcohol adduct 34 in quantitative yield (Eq. (20)).The molecule 34 crystallizes in a tetragonal space group and its molecular structure is depicted in Fig. 8. The molecule has S4 crystal
Figure 8. The molecular structure (S4 symmetry) of Ni[Sn(OMe)(NtBu){N(H)tBu}SiMe& (34) from an X-ray structure determination.12y1 Hydrogen atoms are omitted and carbon atoms are not labeled. There are hydrogen bridges (0. .N = 2.89( 1) A) between the oxygen atoms and the nitrogen atoms N( 1 ) which in contrast to N(2) are pyramidally coordinated.
88
1 Moleculur Cluster3
b
Figure 9. The molecular structure of [MezSi(NtBu)2Sn]2[Me2Si(NtBu)(NtBu{H})Sn][(iPrO)2Sn]zNi (35) as determined by X-ray diffraction techniques. 1291 For further details see caption to Fig. 1 and text.
point symmetry. On each of the four Sn(NtBu)2SiMe2 ligands of 22 one methanol molecule has been added in such a way that the methanolate ligand is coordinated to the tin center increasing the coordination number of the tin atoms to four, and the proton has been trapped by one of the two nitrogen atoms in the ring. As can be deduced from inspection of the Fig. 8 an oxygen...nitrogen hydrogen bond is clearly distinguishable (0.. .N = 2.89( 1) A) between an alcoholate group and a nitrogen atom of neighboring bis(amino)stannylene ligand. Compared to 22 the Ni-Sn distances in 34 are elongated by 0.02 A (Sn-Ni in 23: 2.463(2)A). This is in accord with an increase in the coordination number at the tin atom from 3 to 4. A complex structure is obtained from the reaction of the nickel stannylene cluster 22 with iso-propanol. In this case, the compound 35 can be isolated in reasonable yields and the structure of the molecule as found by an X-ray diffraction analysis is shown in Fig. 9. The central nickel atom is coordinated by five tin atoms in a very distorted trigonal bipyramidal arrangement. Two of the tin atoms still have an unchanged MezSi(NtBu)z ligand and one further ligand has a proton coordinated to one of the ring nitrogen atoms resulting in a MezSi(NtBu)[NtBu(H)] unit. The latter tin (Snl) and Sn3 are connected by an iso-propyloxy group. Finally, there are two tin atoms (Sn4 and Sn5) which have exclusively iso-propoxy ligands coordinated to them. The amino ligand on Sn4 and Sn5 have been completely substituted by alkoxo ligands. The question arises as to why Ni(0) should have five stannylene ligands? By examining the tin-nickel bond distances in more detail a very surprising answer can be given to this question. Whereas the Ni-Sn distances from Ni to Snl, Sn2, Sn3 and Sn5 range from 2.456(2)-2.465(2)A (all tin atoms being tetra-coordinate) the distance to Sn(4), which is the only tin atom with three bonds to either nickel or oxygen, is found to be 2.623(2)A. Furthermore, the coordination polyhe-
1.5 Hetero-Metal Clusters
89
dron around Sn4 is trigonal pyramidal with acute Ni-Sn(4)-0 angles of about 86" and an 0-Sn-0 angle of 94.2'. We therefore propose the following description of N( H)tBu)Sn][(iPr0)2Sn]Ni the cluster 35: to [Me?Si(NtBu)lSn]2[Me2Si(NtBu)( a Sn(0iPr)z molecule is added in such a way that two oxygen atoms ( 0 2 and 0 3 ) coordinate to two different tin centers (Sn2 and Sn5) while Ni, through a filled dz2 orbital, coordinates to Sn4, which uses its empty pz-orbital as acceptor (dn - pn bonding). This description would explain the geometry of the cluster as well as the trigonal pyramidal geometry around the tin atom Sn(4).
1.5.3 Conclusion We have been able to demonstrate that the simple concept of assembling clusters by facile addition reactions of carbene analogues to transition metals is working well. It leads to a variety of different clusters (see Fig. 7). Because of the reactive properties of the amido substituted carbene analogues, addition and substitution reactions may easily be performed. We are currently exploring this field in more detail. The results might also be of significance for catalysis of 0x0 derivatives of metal clusters because of their reduced chemical reactivity, which would be of general interest. Another aspect could be to use clusters terminated by 0x0 ligands as precursors for novel metal oxides.
References / I ] M. Veith, Chmi. Rec. 1990, YO, 3. 121 M. Veith, S. Weidner, K . Kunze. D. Kiifer, J. Hans, V. Huch, Coord, Chem. Rev. 1994, 137, 297. 131 M. Veith, C. Mathur. V. Huch, J. Cheni. Soc.. Dulton Trun.~.1997. 995. 141 M. F. Lappert, R. S. Rowe. Coord. Chern. Rev. 1990. IOO, 267. [5] T. B. Hitchcock, M. F. Lappert. M. J. McGeary. Organomefu//ics 1990, 9, 884. [6] L. Grocholl, V. Huch. L. Stahl, R. J. Samples, P. Steinhart. A. Johnson, Inorg. Cheni. 1997, 36, 4451. [7] M. Veith, Muyrczin Forschung, Universitiit des Saarlandes, 1992, I . 33. [S] M. Veith, H. Lange. K. Brauer. R. Bachmann. J. Oryunornef. Chcni. 1981. 216, 377. [9] W. Stohmeier. D. Von Hobe, Chem. Bcv. 1961, 94. 2031. [lo] M. Veith, M. Grosser, Z. Nufu$rsch. 1982, 37h, 1375. [l 11 M. Veith, L. Stahl, V. Huch. unpublished data. [ M e ~ S i ( N t B u ) ~ S i i ] ~ C r ( C3. O)~, CixH72CrNh03Si3S113, 1093.3 g/mol; monoclinic, space group C2/c, ~1 = 34.403(7), h = 18.260(4). c = 26.147(5)[A], /l = 113.68(3); V = 15043(5) A', Z = 12, Siemens AED 4-circle ~ parameters, R I = 0.042 diffractometer. 7858 reflections (5206 with F > 2 1 7 ~ )665 (wR? = O . l I l j , CCDC 118887.'"'
90
1 Molecular Clusters
[I 21 Crystallographic data for the structures reported in this paper have been deposited with the Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre as supplementary publication no CCDC118887-1 18892. Copies of the data can be obtained free of charge on application to CCDC, 12 Union Road, Cambridge CB2 1EZ UK [Fax: int. Code +44(1223)336-033; E.mail
[email protected]]. 1131 M. Veith, M. Olbrich, M. Notzel, C. Klein, L. Stahl, V. Huch, unpublished results. [Me$( NtBu)&e]2Mn2(C0)8, 4, C28H48GezMn2N408Si2, 879.9 g/mol; monochic, space group P21/n, u = 8.876(5), b = 11.703(6), c = 18.858(1])[A], 8, = 91.91(2)"; V = 1958(2)A, Z = 2, Siemens AED 4-circle diffractometer, 2833 reflections (2528 with F > 2 a ~ . ) ,233 parameters, R = 0.0349 (R, = 0.0332) CCDC 118888.L'21[Me2Si(NtBu)2Sn]2Mn2(co)8, 5 , C28H48Mn2N4OsSi2Sn2, 972.14 g/mol; monoclinic, space group P21/n, a = 8.899(8), b = 11.940(9), c = 19.188(10)[A], p = 92.75(3)"; V = 2037(3)A3, Z = 2, Siemens AED 4, parameters, R1 = 0.030 circle diffractometer, 3570 reflections (3282 with I > 2 0 ( ~ ) ) 209 (wR2 = 0.086), CCDC 118889.['21[MezSi(NtBu)2Sn]z [Fe(C0)4]2,9, C28H48Fe2N408Si2Sn2, 973.96g/mol; monoclinic, space group P2l/n, a = 8.959(2), b = 12.033(2), c = 19.042(4)[A], p = 91.80(3)"; V = 2051.8(7) A3, Z = 2, Siemens AED 4 circle diffractometer, 1570 reflections 206 parameters, R1 = 0.056 (wR2 = 0.1518) CCDC 1 18890.L'21 (1436 with F > ~CJF), [I41 K. Triplett, M. D. Curtis, J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 1975, 97, 5747. [I51 L. F. Dahl, R. E. Rundle, Acta Crystullogr. 1963, 16, 419. [16] P. G. Harrison, T. J. King, J. A. Richards, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Truns. 1975, 16, 419. [I71 M. Veith, Z. Naturforsch. 1978, 33b, 7. [IS] M. Veith, M. Olbrich, C. Klein, unpublished data. MezSi(NtBu)lSn[Co(C0)4]2, 11, C I8H24Co2N208SiSn, 661.03 g/mol; triclinic, space group = 97.89(3), P-I, u = 8.971(2), b = 17.872(4), c = lS.688(4)[A], CI = 110.82(3), y = 97.57(3)["],V = 2720(1) A', Z = 4, Image Plate System (STOE-IPDS), 8146 reflections , parameters, R1 = 0.057 (wR2 = 0.167), CCDC 1 18891."21 (7570 with F > 2 a ~ . )577 [MezSi(NtBu)2Sn]2[Co(CO)cp]2,17, C ~ ~ H ~ ~ C O ~ N ~ O (crystallies ~ S ~ ~ Sas~a ~toluene .C,H ad-~ duct), 1034,44g/mol; monoclinic, space group C2/m, u = 14.704(11), b = 17.857(11), c = 9.181(7)[A], ,8 = 101.98(6)", V = 2358(3)A3, Z = 2, Siemens AED diffractometer, 1600 . ) ,1 parameters, R I = 0.024 ( w R ~ = 0.073) CCDC 1 18892.r'21 reflections (1572 with F > 2 ~ 7 ~11 [I91 K. M. Mackay, B. K. Nicholson, M. Service, Actu Crystallogr. 1990, C46, 1759. [20] P. Klufers, Z. Naturforsch. 1991, 46b, 187. [21] K. Merzweiler, H. Kraus, L. Weisse, Z. Nutuvfbrsch. 1993, 48B, 287. [22] M. Veith, L. Stahl, V. Huch, Orgunometallics 1993, 12, 1914. [23] M. Veith, L. Stahl, V. Huch, Inorg. Chem. 1989, 28, 3278. [24] M. Veith, A. Muller, L. Stahl, M. Notzel, M. Jarczyk, V. Huch, Inorg. Chem. 1996, 35, 3848. [25] G. W. Bushnell, D. T. Eadie, A. Pidcock, A. R. Sam, R. D. Holmes-Smith, S. R. Stobard, J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 1982, 104, 5837. 1261 M. Veith. L. Stahl, V. Huch, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Comm. 1990, 359. [27] M. Veith, L. Stahi, Angew. Chem. 1993, 105, 123; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1993, 32, 106. [28] M. Knorr, E. Hallauer, V. Huch, M. Veith, P. Braunstein, Orgunometullics 1996, 15, 3868. [29] M. Veith, M. Jarczyk, V. Huch, M. Opsolder, to be published.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.6 Synthetic Pathways to a Neglected Class of Compounds: Organobimetallics of Aluminum and Cobalt Jovy J. Schneider
1.6.1. Introduction Preparative organometallic chemistry of mixed main group metal (mgm)-transition metal (tm) compounds has recently grown significantly and spans nearly the whole range of possible element combinations of tms and mgms. Although there are many examples of these bimetallic complexes, and some have been obtained via unexpected synthetic routes, certain combinations of mixed tm/mgm complexes are still rare due to the lack of synthetic pathways to these compounds. Hence, some tm/ mgm combinations have not yet been explored in detail, or more importantly, have not even been synthesized and characterized. One of these tm/mgm combinations is Co/AI, which is the main topic of this article. To unravel new and yet unexplored synthetic pathways for these types of complexes, is a vital task for the experimentalist working in the field. From a qualitative theoretical point of view a description of chemical bonding in mixed tm/mgm complexes, in which the mgm acts just as a simple donor ligand within a bimetallic complex, is often appropriate. However, when the nuclearity of the compounds increases the mgms become more and more incorporated in the overall description of chemical bonding of bimetallic tm/mgm systems. The description of the mgm as a simple donor atom then no longer holds. Intriguing synthetic examples that lend support to this more extended view of the mgm/tm bonding in bimetallic complexes have been reported."] Within this article we will focus on new synthetic pathways, which have, for the first time, provided routes to the synthesis and structural characterization of organobimetallic Co/Al-complexes exhibiting unusual and even, from a theoretical point of view, interesting bonding arrangements between A1 and Co. First of all, to put the experimental results presented in this account in a broader context, a brief insight into synthetic routes, which allow for the selective formation of tm bonds to heavier group 13 elements (Ga, In, T1) in bimetallic complexes, will be given. This
92
1 Molecular Clusters
will be followed by a brief discussion of synthetic methodologies leading to the preparation of the first and second row group 13 congeners, B and Al. However, within the limited space of a multitopic cluster book a review of previous work is not necessarily intended to be comprehensive but rather should make the reader aware of developments and trends, so that he is able to arrange and classify results presented within the subject area. Our own synthetic work in the field of Co/Al organobimetallic complexes is presented within this context. In a concluding section possible applications of organobimetallic complexes containing tm/group 13 element combinations and trends for future work in this area will be discussed.
1.6.2 Synthesis of mixed group 13/transition metal complexes 1.6.2.1 Transition metal bonds to Ga, In and T1 A huge number of different synthetic approaches to generate mgm/tm bonds in organometallic complexes exist. The most widely applicable can be categorized as follows: I. Elimination reactions: i) with extrusion of an alkali metal salt ii) with extrusion of gaseous by-products iii) with extrusion of neutral non-gaseous molecules iv) bimolecular elimination reactions 11. Direct reaction of mgm with tm compounds or bare tm Alternative methods, which are not explicitly mentioned above, exist and lead to other mgm/tm combinations. These have been the subject of several excellent reviews.L21 I. Elimination reactions i) with extrusion of an alkali metal saltL3]
+
Na[Co(C0)4] EX3 + [E{Co(C0)4}3] (E = In, T1, X
+ NaX
= Br, C1)
The salt elimination route is widely applicable to a huge variety of tm/mgm complexes.
1.6 Synthetic P a t h a y s to a Neglected Cluss of Conzpounds
93
ii) with extrusion of gaseous by-product^[^'
+
+
3 [HMoCp(C0)3] 3 [Me3Ga] + [Ga{M o C ~ ( C O ) ~ } 3~CH4 ]
(2)
I
iii) with extrusion of neutral, non gaseous molecules[51
Thermodynamically stable by-products are released in these two reactions and allow for the high yield formation of mixed tm/mgm complexes. iv) bimolecular elimination reactions This synthetically promising type of reaction can be described by the general reaction sequence shown in Eq. (4). R MR+L,M'
R
= alkyl,
M
I
--f
L,MM'
= mgm
compound, L,M'
(4) = tm
compound
94
1 Molecular Clusters
A number of examples of the addition of alkyltin,[61or --leadF7]compounds to give organoplatinum complexes have been reported. However, examples of this type of reaction leading to the formation of tm/group 13 elements are rare and its general utility has not been established so far (see Eq. 5 and 6).[81
-PMe3
[IrMe(PMed4]
+
[BrlnMed
Me I ,.$Me3 Me- lr -1nMeBr
benzene
orether
Me3P
'I
or
Me I .,,\Me Me3P- Ir -1nMeBr Me3P'I
(benzene)
-PMe3
[IrMe(PMe3)4] + [InMe3]
PMe3
PMe3
(ether)
Me
I *,\\\Me Me3P- li-lnMe2 4 Me3P I PMe3
Me
1 %\,\& pMe3
+
Me-
4
Me3P
Ir'-lnMe2
I
PMe3
11. Direct reaction of mgm with tm compounds or bare tm. In contrast to group 14, 15, and 16 elements, which have been introduced in a number of cases as naked mgms or elements,['] usage of bare group 13 metals for the preparation of mixed group 13/tm complexes is not widespread. Nevertheless, as early as in 1942, Hieber showed that bulk group 13 metals and a finely divided tm can be combined directly together in the presence of CO to form mixed mgm/Co clusters (mgm = Ga, In, Tl).[91These compounds represent the first examples of this reaction type.
M = Ga, In , TI
3
Homonuclear unbridged tm bonds exhibit a high reactivity towards insertion or addition reactions when the ligand periphery is sterically crowded. This results in a
1.6 Synthetic Puthwuys to u Neglected Class of Compounds
95
substantial weakening of the tm (M-M) bond, an increase in reactivity, and consequently a homolytic scission of the particular tm (M-M) bond and an insertion of metallic Ga (Eq. 8)."01
4
1.6.2.2 Transition metal (tm) bonds to B and A1 tm-B bonds Although known since 1963," the first crystallographic characterization of tm to boron o-bonds was not reported until 1990."21 Synthetic pathways to compounds containing o-bonds between tms and boron have been reviewed and categorized according to the elements which are bonded to boron.[131 i) compounds containing halogen substituted B to tm-o-bonds:
BC13
+ Na[MCp(C0)3]
M
Mo,W
=
+
[C12BpMCp(C0)3] NaCl
4
(9)
Similar salt elimination between various other anionic tm organometallics ( Ni, Fe, Co) and BC13 can lead to crystalline complexes containing direct tm-B bonds." 31 ii) compounds containing carbon-substituted B to tm-o-bonds: Schmid and Noth have synthesized a variety of compounds containing B-tm bonds (tm = Mn, Mo) by another general reaction sequence (Eq.
+
+
R2BC1 Na[M(CO)3R*]4 R2BpM(CO)3R* NaCl R
= various
alkyl substituents
R* = Cp (M = Mo), CO(PPh3) (M = Mn)
(10)
96
I Molecular Clusters
However, this early work lacked a crystallographic characterization of tm-B bonds in such borylene metal complexes, which might be responsible for the fact that this work had fallen into oblivion until recently." Synthesis and X-ray crystallographic characterization of the first bridged borylene tm complexes in which BR fragments bridge two metal centers were reported more then 30 years after this early ground laying work in tm/borane chemistry (Eq. 1 l).[lG1 r
2K
R
x
dR I
X = NMe2, f-Bu
R = H, Me, Me
tm-A1 bonds Compared to boron, complexes with aluminum/tm bonds are scarce. Nevertheless, several reaction pathways leading to the synthesis of these compounds exist. i) via reaction of tm carbonyl anions with neutral organo aluminium compounds:[171
5
This reaction has led to the formation of the first structurally characterized Fe-A1 bond. Because of the basic character of the carbonyl fragment, which is reflected in the v(C0) IR stretching frequency, and the soft basic characteristics, attributed to the low oxidation state of the tm atom, tm-mgm bonding is most attractive towards
1.6 Synthetic Patlzwciys to u Neylectetl Clu.vs oJ Compounds
97
the relatively soft group 13 Lewis acid [(C6Hs)iAl]and is responsible for the formation of direct Fe-A1 bonding in this complex.['*] [ClAl{(CH2)3NMe?}(i-Bu)] +
+ [CpFe(CO)?]-
[Cp(CO)?Fe-Al((CH*)3NMe*(i-Bu)}]
(13)
6
Taking this knowledge into account, the same principle coupled with a kinetically hindered situation around the A1 center (Eq. 13, 6) has afforded the synthesis of a number of transition metal substituted alanes with direct tm-mgm bonding thus, opening a new synthetic route into the field of tm/Al bimetallic compounds." 9h1 The general trends, exemplified by Eq. (12) and Eq. (13), can be rationalized through the principle of hard and soft acids and bases."9c1 Tuning the electronic situation at the acidic and basic sites is the key to tm-mgm bonding in these type of complexes. ii) with extrusion of neutral gaseous by-products As early as 1971, Grcen and coworkers reported that reaction of tm hydride complexes with trimethylaluminium results in the formation of the first structurally characterized organobimetallics with direct tm-A1 bonds ( Eq. 14).['01 [(q5-Cp)2MoH2]+ AIMe3
70' C
toluene
98
1 Molecular Clusters
iii) via salt
7
The complex [Al{Co(C0)3)3]was reported more then 25 years ago by Schwarzhans and Keller and described as an a intriguing tetrahedral bimetallic Co/Al cluster complex with direct Co-A1 bonding bearing an unusual naked ligand free A1 atom (7). Independent work to reproduce these results had been, so far, unsuccessful. We, like others working in this field, were not able to reproduce their work.[',221Repeated attempts to follow Schwarzhans' procedure gave predominantly [Co4(CO)12].However, in addition a minor product was found, which indeed turned out to be a Co/Al cluster 8, but one in which the A1 is coordinated via the carbonyl oxygen rather than via a direct bond to the transition metal center (Fig. 1). For this type of complexation two characteristic vco stretching frequencies Analogous ~J M-O=C-M isocarbonyl at 1555 and 1405 cm are o b ~ e r v e d . [ ~
-'
Figure 1. Molecular structure of [C04(CO)i 3 N T H F h CO?(CO)101 8 in the solid state determined by X-ray crystallography.[231 The Co3(CO)9cluster fragment of 8 attached to CSOhas been omitted for clarity owing to crystallographic disorder of this part of the
1.6 Synthetic Patliwclys to a Neglected Class of Compounds
99
bridges are found for early/late transition metal complexes (Co-C=O-Ti at 1268, 1233 cm-1,1241Co-C=O-Zr at 1373 cm-1[24J)and in Al/W complexes with Al-O=C-W bridges ( 1 540 cm-’).[25J A similar coordination environment to that found for A1 as in 8 is found in 9, which is formed as the product of a metal exchange r e a ~ t i o n : ” ~ ] 3 [Hg{WCP(C0)3)21
+ 2A1
+
2 [Al{WCP(C0)3l(THF)31
(16)
/\
The reason for isocarbonyl bridging rather than for Al-tm bonding in these complexes can be found in the interaction of the small and therefore hard group 13 metal A1 with the CO group. The A1 is better suited to the harder basic site in the tm compound, and this is the carbonyl oxygen rather than the metal center. iv) via reaction of {RAl} alanediyl fragments with tm-organometallics:r26J
+
3 [(Me5Cs)AI] 2 [CpzNi] +
[{CpNiAl(MesCs))2]
+ “ [ ( M ~ ~ C S ) C ~ , A I ] ”(17)
This interesting reaction uses a high temperature technique employing free A1 atoms to generate low valent {Al(Me5Cg)) fragments, which are metastable in etheral solution at -78 “C. Reactive alanediyl fragments may attack the Lewis acidic Ni atom of [CpzNi] via insertion into the Cp-Ni bond and formation of mixed Al/Ni-organobimetallic
10
100
1 Molecular Cluster5
1.6.3 Synthetic routes to organobimetallic compounds of Co and A1 As has been shown in the preceding section, so far only a few heteronuclear organometallic compounds with transition metal-aluminium bonds have been synthesized and characterized unequivocally. Before we started our work in the area of Co/A1 organometallics, apart from the solid state intermetallic phases like Co2Alj and CoZA19, no transition metal complexes with discrete Co-A1 bonds were known. Our entry into this chemistry originally stemmed from an interest in the synthesis of homonuclear hydridocobalt clusters.[271In the course of these studies we have learned that diethylaluminum hydride reacts with the bis ethylene complex 11 to form a series of homonuclear paramagnetic clusters 12, 13, and 14 when the initial reaction mixture is quenched with ethanol at -78 "C (Scheme 1).[281 However, an aprotic workup of such a reaction mixture yields the first Co/Al cluster complexes (Scheme 1, Fig. 2 and 3).["] Since gaseous by-products are formed, this reaction route can be classified into category I.ii. Reaction of diethylaluminiumhydride with 11 can be considered as an addition reaction of a Lewis acid complex to a coordinately unsaturated alkene. This type of addition is usually found either for mgm[291or tm complexes[301alone, and represents a synthetically useful route to the formation of dimetallacycloalkanes of mgms or t m ~ . [ ~To ' ] the best of our knowledge, the formation of 15 (CjMe5) and 17 (CjMe4Et) in Scheme 1 shows, for the first time, that mgms and tms can both coordinate to alkenes simultaneously. The length of the olefinic C=C bond in 17 is comparable with that of other dimetalated olefins and is only slightly different from that in free ethene (1.363(5) us. 1.34 A). This indicates a stronger contribution of the alkene-o-donor portion than that of the metal-a-n-acceptor portion to the bond of the Co-dimetallioalkene molecular fragment in 17. An almost ideal planar ordering of all four atoms C1, C1*, A1 and Al* is achieved by the dialuminioolefin unit in 17. This indicates that no significant rehybridization of the sp2 carbon atoms CI and C1" towards sp3 hybridization occurs in the formation of the dialuminioethene unit.["] At that point we turned our attention to the use of the EXAFS technique (Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure) which can provide valuable structural information on matter regardless of whether it is in the solid- or solution state. Already widely employed as analytical tool in solid state and material sciences,[321the method has only been employed in a few cases to analyze crystalline organometallic compounds. Our EXAFS measurements on 15 and its Me4EtC5 derivative 17 were carried out at the Co-K edge under an argon atmosphere at the ROMO I1 station at the Hamburger Synchrothronstrahlungslabor HASYLAB at DESY.[''] The Fourier transforms of the k3-weighted X(k) functions reveal two coordination shells for the
1.6 Syntlirtic Path\iq>.s to a NrcqltJcted CIas.s of Compounds
6
P
+
5 9
5 t
v
I
+
I
I
10 1
102
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 2. Molecular structure of 17 in the solid state determined by X-ray crystallography.[281Selected bond lengths [A] and angles ["I: Co-A1 2.569, CO-C1 1.992(4),CO-CI* 1.986(4), Al-Cl 2.088(4), Co-C6 2.030(4) and ref. [281.
Figure 3. Molecular structure of 16 as determined in the solid state as determined by X-ray crystallography.[281 Selected bond lengths [A] and angles ["I: AI-Al* 2.663(3), Co-Al 2.336(l ) , Co-Al* 2.333(I ) , Co-Al*-Co 110.4(I ) , AI*-Co-Al 69.6(1 ) and ref. [28].
1.6 Synthetic Pathwuys to a Neglected Class of Cornpowids
103
10 50 10 00 9 50
9 00 8 50 800
7 50 700
6 30
600
-
..
550
500 4 50
400
3 30
300 2 50 200 1 50
100
0 so
000 OM)
100
200
300
400
500
600
spectrum
of
r[Al
Figure 4. Fourier transform of the Co K-EXAFS d(Co,C)= 2 03 A, d(Co, Al) = 2 56 A. Fit index 0 024 12’]
15
Fit
parameter
Co atoms in 15 and 17. The first coordination shell is formed by C atoms at a distance of 2.06(1) A to Co, and the second coordination shell by A1 atoms at a distance of 2.56(3) A (15) and 2.59(3) A to Co (17). However, an interpretation of the remaining small intensity peaks in the Fourier transformed g(r) functions is not possible at the moment (Fig. 4 and 5). Considering the dominant main peaks at 2.061( 1 ) A due to carbon backscatterers and the interatomic distances, which can be retrieved from them, they are typical for Co-C5 ring contacts in which the metal atom is r5 coordinated. Therefore, these are assigned to the C O -C ~ R( R = Me5, EtMe4) distances in 15 and 17. Bonding distances obtained from single crystal X-ray analysis in compounds containing tm-A1 bonds are in the range of 2.456(1) A (Fe[”I)-2.974 A ( M O [ ~ ~The ] ) . second set of distances determined for 15 and 17 by EXAFS nicely fits into the lower part of that region, indicating direct Co-A1
104
I Molecular Clusters
I
000
100
200
300
400
500
600
rIAi
Figure 5. Fourier transform of the Co-K-EXAFS spectrum d jCo,C) = 2.03 A, d (Co, Alj 2.57 A, Fit index 0.021.[281
of 17. Fit
parameter:
bonding in 15 and 17. Therefore, EXAFS studies indicate that direct Co-A1 bonding must be present in 15 and 17. This shows the analytical value of such measurements in characterizing prototypes of organometallic compounds such as 15 and 17. As can be seen from Scheme 1, a second mixed tetranuclear organocobalt/ aluminum cluster 16, albeit in low yield, could be isolated as red-orange crystals from the product mixture of the reaction between 11 and [EtzAIH]. An essential feature of its molecular structure is a Co2Al~rectangle with a short Co-Aldistance (2.334 A),indicating direct Co-A1 bonding. With reference to the bimetallic phase [A17Telo] (Al-A1 2.660 and the organometallic complexes ([{CH(SiMe3)2}4A12](Al-A1 2.660( l)'""]), [Kz{Al(i-Bu))1 4 (AI-A1 2.685 A[351), and [{(r5-C,Me5)A1)4](Al-A1 2.773(4) A[361)the assumption of A1-A1 bonding in 16 would appear to be justified. This then should result in the formulation of 16 as
bicyclo[ 1.1.0]-1,3-dicobalta-2.,4-dialuminacyclobutanecontaining a tetracoordinated Al. However "counting" electrons using the EAN rule would leave the complex without any Al-Al bond. This exemplifies that care should be taken in using bond distances as absolute criteria for such compounds. Interannular bonding distances in planar four membered rings, as they are present in 16, are usually Reaction of the his ethylene precursor complex [(q5-Cp)Co(ethene),]with [(C?H5)2AIH]leads to formation of two other structurally different Co-A1 cluster compounds under similar reaction conditions, which have already favored formation of the CpR-substituted Co/AI clusters 15, 16 and 17.
18 Co-Co 2.55A p3-AI - CO 2.356 A Al - A l 2.686 A
19 Co-Co 2.44A p3-Al - Co 2.337 A pz-AI - Co 2.435A
Besides small amounts of the well known tetracobalt hydrido cluster [ { C ~ C O H ) ~ ] which , ' ~ ~ ]is the only product when the initial reaction mixture is quenched with ethanol, formation of two mixed bimetallic Co/AI clusters with different tm/mgm polyhedra are isolated when strictly aprotic conditions are maintained in this reaction. In 18 an octahedral cluster framework in which four {CpCo) fragments are bonded to two (AI(C2Hs)) units is formed. The closo structure of the cluster is completed by two hydrido ligands, which show up in the 'H-NMR spectrum but could not be detected by X-ray crystallography. N o information so far has been obtained as to whether the hydrido ligands are doubly or triply bridging the Co atoms, or both Co and A1 atoms. However, a purely Al bridging situation can be excluded judging from the observed chemical shift
106
I Molecular Clusters
(- 14.17 ppm) of the hydrido ligands, which is typical for hydride ligands bridging only tm’s. In 19 a Co3 triangle is doubly and triply bridged by a CAl(CzH5))and a {A1(C2H5)2}fragment. The “lost” C2H5 unit of the former Al(C2H5)2 fragment, which is now complexed as a ,uu,-ethylidyneunit on the opposite site of the Co3A12 cluster polyhedron of 19. In both complexes, 18 and 19, alkyl transfer reactions from the organoaluminum source are observed. This has already been observed in earlier work in organoaluminum chemistry. We have found that formation of all mixed Co/Al cluster compounds by the [(CpR)Co(C2H4)2]( R = H5, Me5, MeeEt) route depends critically on the organoaluminum source used in the reactions with this type of organocobalt compound. If diisobutylaluminumhydride (dibah) instead of [Et2AlH] is used, no formation of mixed Co/Al clusters is observed. In contrast to Scheme 1 and Eq. (18) the mixed hydrido ethylidyne Co3 cluster 20 is the only isolable product under analogous conditions (Eq. 19).
/”\#
/ /
+
-
80’ C [(i~o-butyl)~AIH] toluene
20
Obviously dibah serves as a source of hydrogen and allows for the decrease in formation temperature of 20 since formation of 20 is observed when 11 alone is thermolyzed in n-octane (l10°C).r391Hence, the source of hydrogen is the precoordinated ethylene in 11, whereas in reaction 19 it is obviously the more easily available hydrogen ligand of the organoaluminum source dibah, which drastically reduces the reaction temperature necessary to form 20.
1.6.4 Outlook and trends Without doubt, work remains to be carried out in order to gain a better understanding of the processes leading to the formation of unusual Co/Al complexes such as 15-19. However, the identification of new reaction pathways may make other
1.6 Syiitlietic P u t h w y s to a Neglected Class of Compounds
107
Co/Al bimetallics accessible, which will take this interesting class of compounds further out of oblivion. As a general result of the work presented here the Co/Al bond in organometallic complexes is accessible by conventional synthesis routes and is sufficiently stable to be studied in more detail in the future. Besides a fundamental interest in characterizing and understanding the reaction pathways, which leads to complexes with still unknown tm/mgm element combinations like Co/Al, there is a growing impetus for experimental work in the organometallic chemistry of bimetallic compounds, which is directed towards possible applications in material science. For specific tm/mgm combinations, one attractive potential application of such compounds is their usage as single source precursors in MOCVD processes. A number of different tm/mgm Combinations do in fact have intrinsic semiconducting properties[401and show promise in possible applications as bimetallic conducting films for semiconductors, which are important in microelectronic applications.[411 Binary mixed organometallic single source precursors have already shown that they can offer a route to pure bimetallic contacts (Al/Co, Al/Fe, Ga/Fe)[421.By taking this bimetallic single source concept further to other tm/mgm combinations and by tailoring the ligand environment to the special application demands. the field for new tm/mgm combinations, which is attractive in materials applications, holds promise for the future. Besides the potential of such complexes in material science, there is always the search for catalytic activity in mixed bimetallic complexes containing tm's and mgms. One promising example of this is the combination tm/group 13 metals, where bimetallics containing Ni and A1 are highly active in ethene dimerization reactions. These were studied for the first time 45 years ago by Ziegler and Holzand later their reactivity was mechanistically clarified by Wilke and coworker~.["~] Inspired by this work, the search for the catalytic active intermediates bearing direct Ni-A1 bonds in ethene dimerization reactions has been very active over the last few years.[451Nevertheless, only recently the first organobimetallic Ni-A1 complex 10, with a completely different ligand environment, was synthesized and structurally characterized, but so far its catalytic activity has not been investigated.12']
Acknowledgement The author would like to thank Prof. Dr. C. Kriiger and his coworkers at the MaxPlanck-Institut fur Kohlenforschung, Miilheim a.d. Ruhr for X-ray crystallographic investigations, the group of Prof. H. Bertagnolli, University of Stuttgart for making the EXAFS measurements possible, the DFG for a Heisenberg Fellowship, and the
108
1 Molecular Clusters
Fonds der Chemischen Industrie and ESF for additional financial support for the research presented here.
References [ 11 K.H. Whitmire, J. Coord, Chem. 1988, 17, 95. [2] see e.y. a) N.A. Compton, R.J. Errington, N.C. Norman, Adv. Orgunomet. Chem. 1990, 31, 91; b) D.G. Tuck, Comprehensive Orgunometallic Chemistry, Vol. 1 (G. Wilkinson, F.G.A. Stone, F. Abel, Eds.) Pergamon, Oxford, 1982, 954. [3] a) D.J. Patmore, W.A. Graham, Inorg. Chem. 1973, 5, 1536; b) W.R. Robinsonj D.P. Schussler, Inorg. Chem. 1973, 12, 848; ( c ) P. Braunstein, M. Knorr, M . Shampfer, A. DeCian, J. Fischer, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans. 1994, 117. [4] a) J.N. Denis, W. Butler, M.D. Click, J.P. Oliver, J. Organornet. Clzem. 1977, 129, 1; b) A.J. Conway, P.B. Hitchcock, J.D. Smith, J. Clicm. Soc. Dalton Truns. 1975, 1945. [S] W. Uhl, M. Pohlmann, Organometallic.s, 1997, 16, 2478. [6] a) C. Eaborn, A. Pidcock. B.R. Steele, J. Cliem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 1976, 767; b) C. Eaborn, K. Kundu, A. Pidcock, ibid, 1981, 1223; c j T.A.K. AIAllaf, C. Edborn, K. Kundu, A. Pidcock, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Cornmun. 1981, 55, T.A.K. All-Allaf, C. Butler, C. Eaborn, A. Pidcock, J. Organoniet. Chem. 1980, 188, 7. [7] J.K. Jawad, R.J. Puddephatt, Inorg. Chim. Acta; 1978, 31, L391. [8] D.C. Thorn, R.L. Harlow, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1989, 11, 2575. [9] a) W. Hieber, U. Teller, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1942, 249, 43; b) H.J. Haupt, F. Neumann, H. Preut, J. Organomet. Chem. 1975, 99, 439. [lo] J.J. Schneider, U. Denninger, J. Hagen, C. Kriiger, D. Blaser, R. Boese, Chenz. Ber. 1997, 130, 1433. 1111 H. Noth, G. Schmid, Angeiu. Chem. 1963, 75, 861; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1963, 2, 623. 1121 a) R.T. Baker, D.W. Ovenall, J.C. Calabrese, S.A. Westcott, N.J. Taylor, I.D. Williams, T.B. Marder, J. Am. Cliem. Soc. 1990, 112, 9399; b) J.R. Knorr, J.S. Merola, Organonietallics, 1990, 9, 3008. I131 G. Schmid, in Gmelin Handbuch der Anorganischen Chemie 19, Teil 3, 159, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1975. [I41 a) G. Schmid, H. Noth, J. Orgunomet. Chem. 1967, 7, 129; b) H. Noth, G. Schmid, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 1966, 345, 69. 1151 H. Wadepohl, Anyew. Cliem. 1997, 109, 2547; Angew. Clieni. Int. Ed Engl. 1997, 109, 2441. [I61 H. Braunschweig, T. Wagner, Angew. Chef??.1995, 107. 904; An(jeit.. Chem. Int. Ed Engl. 1995, 34. 825. H. Braunschweig, Angew. Chem. 1998, 110, 1882, Anyen.. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1998, 37, 1786. [ 171 J.M. Burlitch, M.E. Leonowicz, R.B. Peterson, R.E. Hughes, Inorq. Chem. 1979, 18; 1097. [IS] R.A. Fischer, T. Priermeier, Orgunometallics 1994, 13, 4306. [I91 a) R.A. Fischer, J. Behm, T. Priermeier, W. Scherer, A n g c w . Chem. 1993, 105, 776; Anyew. C h ? . Int. Ed. Engl. 1993, 32, 746; b) J. WeiB, D. Stetzkamp. B. Nuber, R.A. Fischer, C. Boehme, G. Frenking, Anyew. Chem. 1997, 109, 95; Anyeit,. Clieni. Int. Ed. Enql. 1997, 36, 70; c ) R.G. Pearson, J. Chen?. Educ. 1968,45, 581, 643. [20] a) R.A. Forder, M.L.H. Green, R.E. Mac Kenzie, J.S. Poland, K. Prout, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Conimun. 1973, 426; b) R.A. Forder, K. Prout, Acta Cry.rt. 1974, B30, 2312.
1.6 Syntlietic Putliwuys to a Neglected Cluss of Conipounds
109
1211 K.E. Schwarzhans, H. Steiger, Angcn~.Chenz. 1972, 84, 587, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1972, 11. 535. 1221 G. Schmid, Anyew. Chmi. 1978, 90, 417; Angot,. Climi. Int. Ed. Engl. 1978, 17. 392. (231 J.J. Schneider, U. Denninger, C . Kriiger, Z. Nutu~fi)rsch.1994, 496, 1549. [24] B. Stutte. V. Biitzel, R . Boese: G. Schmid, Chenz. Ber. 1978, 11, 1603. 1251 R.B. Peterson. J.J. Stezowski. Che'ng Wan, J.M. Burlitch, R.E. Hughes, J. Am. Cheni. Soc. 1971. 93, 3532. 1261 C. Dohmeier, H. Krautscheid. H. Schnockel. Anyrw,. C h m . 1994, 106, 2570; Anyaw. Chern. Int. Ed. Engl. 1994, 33, 2482. 1271 a) J.J. Schneider, C. Kriiger, R. Goddard. S. Werner. B. Metz, Chem. Ber. 1991, 124, 301; b) J.J. Schneider, U . Specht. R . Goddard, C. Kriiger, Cliem. Ber. 1997, 130, 161: c) J.J. Schneider. Z. Nutzryforsch. 1994, 49h, 691. 1281 J.J. Schneider, C. Kriiger. M. Nolte. I. Abraham, T.S. Ertel, H. Bertagnoli. Anyew. Chem. 1994, 106, 2537; Angew Chem. Iiit. E d Engl. 1994, 33, 2435. 1291 a ) H. Schnockel. M. Leimkiihler, R. Lotz. R. Mattes. Angew. Cheni. 1986, 98, 929; Angeiv. Chiwi. b i t . Ed Enql. 1993. 32. 973; b) D.L. Thorn. R. Harlow, J. A m Clicm. Soc. 1989. 111, 2575. 1301 a ) F.A. Cotton, P.A. Kibala, Pol.vher/rori, 1987, 6, 645; b) F.A. Cotton, P.A. Kibala. Inory. Cheni. 1990, 29, 3192: c) W. Kaminski, J. Hopf. H . Sinn, H.J. Vollmcr, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1976, IS, 629; di W.J. Evans, T.A. Ullibari; J.W. Ziller, J. A m . Chm. Sue. 1990, 112, 219. 1311 a) W. Beck, B. Niemer, M. Wieser. Anyeiv. Chem. 1993, 105, 969; Anyen.. Chem. Int. Ed. Emql. 1993, 32, 923; b) D.L. Thorn. R.L. Harlow. J. Am. Chem. Soc.. 1989, 11, 2575. [321 see e g . J.W. Niemantsverdriet, Spectroscopy in Catalysis. VCH Verlagsgesellschaft Weinheim. Ch.6, 1993. 1331 R. Ncsper, J. Curda, Z. Nutivjhrsclz. 1987, 42h. 557. 134) W. Uhl, Z. Nrrturfi,rsch. 1989. 43h, I 113. [35] W. Hiller, K.W. Klinkhammer, W. Uhl. J. Wagner, Arzgew. Chern. 1991, 103, 182; Angeiv. Chivn. Int. Ed EngI. 1991. 30. 119. [36] C . Dohmeier, C. Robl. M. Tacke, H.G. Schnockel. Anyen. Chein. 1991. 103, 594; Anyen. C/ieni. Int. EN! Engl. 1991. 30, 179. [37] a ) E.A. Zarate. W.J. Youngs, C.A. Tessier-Youngs. J . Am. Chrm. Soc. 1988. 1 1 0 , 4068; b) J.W. Moore. D.A. Sanders. P.A. Scheer. M.D. Click. J.P. Oliver, J. Am. Chern. Soc. 1971, 93, 1035. 1381 J. Miiller. H. Dorner, A n p i t , . Clieni. 1973, 85, 867; Angeii,. C'lieni. Int. Ed. Engl. 1973, 12, 843. [39] a ) C.P. Casey, R.A. Widenhoefer, S.L. Hallenbeck, R.K. Hayashi, D.R. Powell, G.W. Smith, Or~~cinomettillit..(.. 1994. 13. 1521: b) R.B.A. Pardy. G.W. Smith, M.E. Vickers, J. Oryunomet. Cliiwi. 1983. 2.72. 341 . [401 aj C.M. Lukehart. S.B. Milne, S.R. Storck, R.D. Shull. J.E. Wittig in Nanotechnology (G.M. Chow, K.E. Gonsalves. Eds.), ACS Spposium Series, 1996, 622. 1411 b) R.A. Fischer, W. Scheer, M. Kleine. Anyew. C'hcm. 1993, 32. 778. Anqric,. Cheni. h t . Ed Encql. 1993, 32, 748 and references cited therein. 1421 R.A. Fischer, Chem. C'nserer Zeit 1995, 29. 141. 1431 K . Ziegler, Brcnn.c.tofflChe/iii. 1959. 40, 209. 1441 a) G. Wilke. Anyen,. Cheni. 1988. 100, 189, Anyeit,. C h ~ m Int. . Ed En(//. 1988, 27, 185; b) G . Wilke, N o w Actu Leopoldinu N F 65. 1991. 277. 105. [45] K.R. Porschke. W. Klcimann. Y.-H. Tsay. C. Kriiger, G. Wilke, Cheni. Ber.. 1990, 123, 12.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.7 Group 5 and 6 Bimetallic Complexes with Phosphido Bridges: Syntheses and some Structura1 Features Gilles Boni, Mavek M. Kubicki, and Claude Morse
1.7.1 Introduction The concept that the catalytic properties of a late transition metal are significantly altered by the presence of an early transition metal is responsible for the considerable interest in the synthesis of early/late heterobimetallic complexes. Much work has been directed towards the synthesis of this class of compounds and it has been found that the stability of the bimetallic framework is enhanced by the presence of a bridging ligand linking the two disparate metal sites. Our group is interested in a class of p-phosphido heterobinuclear complexes incorporating a group 5 or 6 metallocene derivative and a group 6 or 8 transition metal carbonyl moiety. Terminal phosphido transition metal complexes have been shown to be good precursors for their preparation. The aim of this article is to summarize some synthetic approaches and some structural features of such binuclear compounds.
1.7.2 Synthesis of metallophosphines Metathetical reactions are the common synthetic routes to phosphido derivatives of early transition metals: nucleophilic substitution of halide on the metal by anionic phosphido species has been widely used in group 4 chemistry."] M-C1
+
P-
___)
M-P
+
CI
Scheme 1
An alternative approach, based on a substitution of a halide in a halophosphine by a nucleophilic organometallic fragment, has been developed for d 2 mono-
I . 7 Croup 5 and 6 Bimetallic Complexes with Phosphido Bridges
1 11
hydrides of group 5 CpzM( H ) (L) ( M = Nb, Ta; L = two-electron donor)12' and d2 dihydrides of group 6 Cp2MH2 ( M = Mo, W).[31In a first step, metallophosphonium salts are formed: deprotonation of these salts is achieved by using the hydroxide anion and leads to the corresponding neutral phosphido derivatives. The regeneration of the salts is quantitative in reaction with HCl.
+
c p 2hl.
PRlCl
L
.-*
OH
H+
-
-. /
C-Or 7- l t l .
PR,
L
R = Me, Ph h1 = Nb, Ta ; L = CO, P h l 2 ~H. Phk2Ph M=Mo, W ; L = H Scheme 2
These reactions may be attributed to the basic properties of d2 mono- or dihydrido complexes, already exemplified in other reactions: i) with Bronsted acids
M = Nb, Ta ; L = CO, PMc2Ph h.1 = .110. w : L = H [5]
[4]
Scheme 3
In the cases of niobium and tantalum, two cationic structural isomers are detected depending both on the nature of the ligand L and the reaction conditions. ii) with Lewis acids The following addition compounds containing dative metal-metal bonds have been isolated and characterized.
Scheme 4
112
1 Moleculav Clusters
iii) with acyl chlorides Nucleophilic attack of the lone pair in d2 complexes has also been suggested to account for the formation of aldehydes when acyl chlorides are reacted with carbonyl complexes.[l01
0
CPN.
H
co
+
> RKC' 0 Co
M = Nb. Ta
1
Scheme 5
The reaction products are altered when the transformations outlined in Scheme 2 are carried out starting from phosphito derivatives [L = P(OMe)3 or PPh(0Me)zl. Phosphonato complexes are isolated either as the sole products ( M = Nb, R = Me; M = Ta, R = Ph) or together with the expected metallophosphines in variable yields ( M = Nb, R = Ph). A complete transformation from metallophosphine to the corresponding phosphonato complex occurs over 24 h.
and/or
Cp:bI,
PR'R"(0hIe)
PR'R" II
'
,
PR,
PRlhle
/
Cp$I,
hl=Nb,?'a
Scheme 6
Clearly an intramolecular Arbuzov-like rearrangement explains the formation of metallophosphonates. The phosphorus lone pair attacks the methyl group giving the dealkylation reaction and the conversion of phosphorus ( 111) to phosphorus (V).
Cp?hl,.
/P a
r/
,O-h!e
P
'R'
4
-
Cplbf,
/
PR2hle
PR'R" I1
h l = h b Ta
0
Scheme 7
Steric and electronic effects strongly influence the reaction rate. A fast rearrangement is observed with the more basic and less hindered PMe2 phosphido group." '1
1.7 Group 5 and 6 Bitnrtallic Complexes with Pliosphido Bridges
1 13
With the objective of making other kinds of metallophosphanes, the reaction outlined in Scheme 2 has been extended to dichlorophosphines. Depending on the nature of the basic reagent involved in deprotonation (OH- or OMe-), phosphonyl or phosphinite derivatives are recovered."
?il = Nb, Ta Scheme 8
The do trihydrides Cp2MH3 ( M = Nb, Ta) also give fast reactions with chlorophosphines leading to symmetrical ionic compounds. The central position of the PR2H group has been unambiguously established by ' H NMR spectroscopy." 14'
Scheme 9
Due to the lack of both a metal centred lone pair and an available coordination site, a nucleophilic substitution reaction is obviously inoperative here. Therefore, a direct insertion into the central M-H bond is responsible for the formation of the phosphonium salt. Such a reactivity has been explained recently, by Nikonov et al, in terms of a new and interesting concept, which considers the carbenoid nature of halophosphines." 5 1 Deprotonation of phosphonium salts can give rise either to phosphino or to phosphido derivatives." 31
Cp+4
/
\
/
H
bl = Nb ;R = Me, Ph M = Ta ; R = M e
Scheme 10
H Cp JICI - PR, \ H
PRiH
2(Nbl 2(Ta)
k l = Ta
R = Ph ; Cp = C j H j
R = Me : Cp = C+le-i
3CTa'
114
I Molecular Clusters
Thus, the initial phosphonium salts contain two competing acidic sites located at the metal and at the phosphorus atom, respectively. The strength of these acidic centers depends on the nature of the metal, on the Cp ligands, and on the electron donor capability of the phosphorus substituents. In the case of niobium, only phosphino derivatives are formcd. When M = Ta, R = Me, Cp = C5H5, a phosphino complex is also formed, whereas when R = Ph, Cp = CsHs or R = Me, Cp = C5Me5, phosphido compounds 3(Ta) are obtained. A similar competition occurs during the deprotonation of the molybdenum salts [ CpzMo( H)(PR2H)lf leading to either a Mo( 11) phosphino ( R = Me) or a Mo(IV) phosphido ( R = Ph) Metallodiphosphines may be obtained by using the same procedure as described earlier. These difunctionalized ligands contain a metal r~ bonded phosphido moiety associated with either a dangling phosphorus of a monocoordinated diph~sphine"~] or a phosphine group directly linked to a Cp ligand."'] Thus, these bidentate metalloligands combine the coordination abilities of metallophosphines with the additional properties of organic phosphines. The following examples illustrate these two kinds of phosphorus ligands:
4(Nb) Scheme 11
1.7.3 Bimetallic complexes from metallophosphines Three types of monophosphido derivatives are involved in the synthesis of binuclear systems. PR-
CpzM
CpzTa-/H PPh-
0
\
L' hl=Nb
IZ.I=Ta Scheme 12
1(Nb) l(Ta)
bVI = Mo
iL1 = W
l(kf0) IrWj
H
3(Ta)
I . 7 Gvoup 5 und 6 Binietullic ConiplexeJ with Phosphido Bridges
1 15
1.7.3.1 Monobridged complexes Open chain bimetallic complexes containing a phosphido bridged ligand are easily synthesized by reacting metallophosphines 1(Nb, Ta, Mo, W) with [M'Ln] species (Fig. 1 ) . [ 2 a . 1 9 . 3 a l
M
=
N b Td , M'Ln = Cr(COj5 Mo'CO h,COi, Fe(COI4, MnlCO12Cp 7 (Nb, Ta)
,
Scheme 13
Interestingly, bimetallic complexes including the [ Fe(CO)4] moiety are also recovered after treatment of [ Cp?M(PPhHCl)(CO)]+Cl- salts with Collman's reagent Na?Fei CO)4[201
hl = Nb, Ta
7'(Nb, Ta)
Scheme 14
In contrast to the OH- and MeO- reagents. which are able to achieve both a substitution and a deprotonation reaction (or cice w rs u, see Scheme 8), Collman's reagent, because of its lower basic character, affords only the chloride displacement.
Figure 1. Molecular structure of CpCp*Ta(CO)(pPPh2)Mn(COhCp
116
I Moleculur Clusters
1.7.3.2 Dibridged complexes p-phosphido p-carbonyl structures
A photochemical process is used to convert the monobridged bimetallic systems 7(Nb,Ta) or 7'(Nb, Ta) to p-CO, p-PR2 dibridged complexes. The same structures are also generated directly starting from metallophosphines 1(Nb, Ta) and the carbonyl reagents [M'(C0)4L2] (M' = Cr, L2 = NBD; M' = Mo, W, L = piperidine) or [Fe(CO)3] (Fig. 2). [ 2 PR2
Cp,hI,
'
co
hv -hlyco)" I
PR? 0
c p+ I ,
1 [M'(CO)"-1
co
1
8(Sb, Ta)
h.1 = Nb, Ta ;bl'= Cr, Mo, W, Fc Scheme 15
All these complexes exhibit two characteristic spectroscopic features: an IR vco bridging absorption located near 1700 cm-' , and a dramatically deshielded phosphorus resonance (Ad ~150-200ppm) in the 31PNMR spectrum.
Figure 2. Molecular structure of CpzNb(p-PPh2, p-CO)Fe(CO)3.
p-phosphido p-hydrido structures When metallophosphines l(Mo, W) are reacted with M'(C0)5(THF) (M' = Cr, Mo, W ) , a mixture of mono- and dibridged p-phosphido complexes is obtained.
I . 7 Group 5 and 6 Bimetallic Complexes with Phosphido Bridye.s
%>lo, FV)
h1 = hlo, w M' = Cr, Mo, W
1 17
lO(hl0, FV)
Scheme 16
After chromatographic separation, monobridged complexes ~ ( M o ,W ) easily transformed to the dibridged compounds 10(Mo, W) by photochemical elimination of co.[221 In turn, the tantalum phosphine complex 3(Ta) gives dibridged structures 1 l(Ta), which are accompanied, in some cases, by small amounts of monobridged complexes." 3 3 2 3 1
H / PPh-
Cp ?TL-
- M'(C O ),
11(Ta)
hi' = Cr, \ = 4 hl' = Xlo, \ = 4 hi' = LV, \ = 4 h.1' = Fc, z = 3
Scheme 17
Although a terminal phosphido group is not available in phosphino derivatives 2(Nb, Ta), they behave as metalloligands towards unsaturated organometallic fragments also giving rise to dibridged complexes ll(Ta, Nb) (Fig. 3).[13*231
Figure 3. Molecular structure of Cp2Td(H)ip-PPh? ,u-H,Fel C 0 ) i
118
1 Molecular Clusters H
11(Nb. Ta)
Scheme 18
Because no dihydrido-phosphido species is detected by ‘H and 31 P variable temperature NMR analyses of the starting material 2(Nb, Ta), an electrophilic substitution at the phosphorus atom might account for the formation of the bimetallic complexes. High field resonances of the bridging hydrides and low field 31Presonances are the typical structural features of this kind of dibridged complex.
Reactivity of dibridged complexes Both p-CO and p-H dibridged complexes readily react with L donor ligands including phosphines, phosphites, isonitriles, etc. Open chain structures are restored by a completely regioselective addition of L at the M’ site. Whether the L ligand is cis or trans to the PR2 bridge depends on both the size of the metal M’ arid the bulkiness of the incoming ligand. Thus, for the bulky triphenylphosphine ligand, the trans isomer is formed as the sole product when M’ = Cr, whereas a cisltrans mixture (95/5) is when M’ is the larger tungsten atom.[21C’241
CIS
8(hb. Ta)
trans XI = Nh, TJ
Scheme 19
This possibility of breaking the second bridge allowed us to draw up a strategy for the resolution of a chiral tantalocene as outlined in Scheme 20.[251
1.7 Group 5 and 6 Bimetallic Conzplexes with Phosphido Bridges
119
Two diixstereoisomers Cp" =
x)+ 0
L* = (R)-(+)-PMePh(o-An)
Scheme 20
Each diastereoisomer can be isolated in a pure optically active form. They display quasi mirror image circular dichroism curves which illustrates the enantiomeric relationship between the tantalum asymmetric centers.
1.7.4 Bimetallic complexes from metallodiphosphines Metallodiphosphine 4(Nb) binds a [M'(C0)4] (MI = Cr, Mo, W ) fragment leading to a six membered cyclic structure: which adopts a chair like conformation as revealed by X-ray analysis (Fig. 4). Contrary to the other dibridged systems, 31P NMR resonances correspond well to those of the open chain (monobridged) structures with a large M-P-M' angle.['71
h.1' = Cr, blo, W
4Wb)
lJ(Nb)
Scheme 21
In a similar way, diphosphines 5(Ta) and 6(Ta) act as chelating ligands towards [M'(C0)4] moieties affording two types of Ta(V) or Ta( 111) heterobimetallic systems.[' '1 PPh:
13(Ta) Scheme 22
c
11(Ta)
120
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 4. Molecular structure of Cp*Nb(p-PPh:!, p-dmpm)Mo(CO)4.
1.7.5 Molecular structures of phosphido bridged complexes Nineteen X-ray analyses have been performed, in our group (Table I ) , on Inonoand di-bridged bimetallic systems with one bent metallocene unit and with one phosphido bridge. A rhodium-niobocene structure with two phosphido bridges has been reported by Nikonov et a1.r261 Their structural parameters are listed in Table 1. The molecules are listed in an order which reflects the number of bridges and the nature of the metallocene (group 5 metals: Nb( 111), Ta( 111),d2; Nb( V), Ta(V), do; group 6 metals: Mo( IV), W( IV), d2). In all dinuclear complexes the metallocene fragments exhibit their usual mononuclear geometries: the pseudo-tetrahedral geometry for d' metals, and the very distorted trigonal bipyramidal (or edge-capped tetrahedral) geometry for five coordinate d o metals. The main question that needs to be answered when considering a dinuclear system, is whether or not a metal (metallocene) -metal (M') bond is present. Two parameters from Table 1, the M-M' separation and the M-P-M' angle, give quite direct answer to this question: i) for monobridged compounds the M-M' distances are in the range of 4.3914.784 A and the M-P-M' angles in the range 122.0 to 129.1". ii) for dibridged compounds the M-M' distance range is 2.869-3.400 A with M-P-M' angles comprised between 73.0 and 84.9". Thus, there should be no direct metal-metal interaction in monobridged complexes. Note that the values of M-P-M' angles in monobridged compounds are the largest observed for sp3 hybridized phosphorus atoms. This is certainly due to the steric
Tabelle 1. Geometrical parameters for phosphido bridged biscyclopentadienyl complexes. Compound
M-M'
M-P
M'-P
M-P-M' M-X-M'
P-M-X P-M'-X
P-M-X/ M-P-M'
M-CP
CP-M-CP Ref. ~
~
Monobridgrd Cuinplexes oJGroiip V Metol.5 (Nb"'. T
Cp?Nb(COJ(p-PMe,)W(CO),PMe,Ph
3.679(2)
2.668(4) 2.610(4) 2.06(2)
124.9(2)
87.3(5J
2 5( IJ
2.06 2.07
139.4
Cp"CpTa(COJ(p-PMeJW(CO),.(PAMP) SS "'
4.7723(7 1 2.685(3) 2.628(3) 2.04( IJ
127.8(1)
83.4(4)
l2.7(1)
2.08 2.08
136.0
Cp"CpTa(COJ(p-PMe2JW(COJ,.(PAMP) RS ' I '
4.7598(9) 2.675(5) 1.99i2)
127.1(2)
82.4(7)
7.2(2)
1.99 2.06
136.4
68.4(1)
2.06
137.5
2.641i.5)
125.94(8) X9.0(2)
2.06
Cp~Nh(P(OMeJ,)(p-PPh2)Cr(CO)~,C,H~~!C2,5,0,0,0,~.7S7S~9J 2.687( 1 ) ,0 2.485( 1 J
2.582( I J
129.11(5) 91.01(5) 71.16(6)
2.06 2.06
135.8
Cp"-CpTa(COJ(p-PPh,JMn(COJ~Cp.1.5C7HI "' 4.541(1)
2.708(2) 2.03( I)
2.397(3)
125 X I )
88.1(2)
69.3(1)
2.05 2.10
136.0
Cp'CpTa(COJ(p-P(OMeJPh)Cr(COJ,' I '
2.647(2) 2.542(2) 2.028(6)
127.1(1)
89.6(2)
69.9(1 J
2.05 2.10
137.1
12S.S0(9J 92.61(7) 92.88(7)
40.4(1)
2.06 2.05
135.0
12447(7J 82(3J
68(3)
1.96
139.8
4.646( 1 J
4.7831(9) 2.715(2) 2.555(2)
2.667(2) 2.5 I7(2)
I96
4.547(1)
123. I(IJ
1.96 I95
141.4
2.584(3) 2.616(3) 12?.0(I)
I.96 1.95
139.9
1.94 I.96
125.5
O(planarJ 2.07
132.2
123.95(9) 82.17(7)
2.884(2) 2.493(2) ?.20X(2) 2.172(7)
2.03 I J
75.42( IJ X5.8(2)
93.2(2)
77.1(4) 88.5(7J
91(1) 103(IJ
O(planar) 2 10
96.3(2j 98 2(2J
O(planar) 2.07 2.07
131.2
94.7(2) I17.9(2)
7.6 7.6
2.1 1 2.09
132.5
90
2.08 2.08
134.4
planar
2.06 2.08
134.8
planar
2.07 2.07
134.9
planar
I.97 1.97
137. I
1.94
125.4 ( I 17.7)
Cp Nb(p-PPh R,p CO)Cr(COJ,
3.07% IJ
2 S46( I) 2.328( I) 78.23(4) 2.148(7) 2.3 I2(6) 87.2(2)
Cp' Nb(p-PPh J,RhEt
2.869(23
2.55.5(6) 2.602(6)
Cp.Ta(HJ(p-PMe,.p-HJCr(COj,
Cp:Ta(H)(p-PPh ,,p-H)Fe(CO)
3.293(1J
2.209(5) 73.7(2) Z.ZIX(6)
41.6(1J
72.5(2)
2.08
105.5(3)
2.284(3) 84.85(8) 64(3) l.X3(8Jbr 1.71(9) 137(5J 7X3J I.60(9),
2.587(2)
3.1 13(2J 2.547(4)
2.I(lJbr
2.168(4) 1.3(1)
82.2(1)
61(3)
134(6J
83(4J
?.464(3J
81 6 ( l )
--
80.73(6) 109(1j
87(2)
134.9
2.08
I.X6(9),
Dihridgrd Ciiinplexe~i f Groyi VI Mrtul\ (Mo, WJ, d2 metrilr
Cp.W(p-PPhl,p-H)W(COJ,
3.2708(8) 2 540(5) -.
[~nsu-CMe:Cp~W(p-PPh.,p~HJW(COJ, ~~
3.2320(5) 2.536(2) 2.02(6)
-.
2.4532) I.95(6)
832)
( I J Cp" = I-'Bu-3.4-Me,-CiH,). . . PAMP = (RJ-(+)-PMePh(o-An):(2) Cp* =C5Me,; (3) Cp' = C5Me,Et.
planar ~
1.98
~~~
122
I Molecular Clusters
.... Figure 5. Shapes of HOMO-1 orbitals for Cp2Nb(pPPh2)(pL-CO)Fc(CO)3 and CpzTa( H)(p-PPh>)(p-H)Fe(C%.
requirements of the bulky organometallic fragments. It is also worth noting that in the monobridged complexes the methyl substituents on the phosphido bridge are in endo positions with respect to the LMP unit, while the bulkier phenyl substituents are exo, pushing the second metal into the endo position. There are two types of dibridged complexes. The M-M' distances and M-P-M' angles are 2.884-3.079 A and 75.4-78.2" in (p-PR2, p-CO) species, whereas the corresponding values for (p-PR2, p-H) rings are 3.113-3.400 A and 80.7-84.9", respectively. This suggests the presence of a direct metal-metal bond for (p-PR2, p-CO) complexes, but the situation is not clear for p-hydrido ones. Extended Huckel calculations confirm the presence of a metal-metal bond in p-CO compounds and show it not to be present in p-H systems. This is illustrated by the shapes and CpzTa( H)(p-PPhz)of HOMO-1 orbitals for Cp2Nb(p-PPh2)(pu-C0)Fe(C0)3 (pu-H)Fe(C0)3 (Fig. 5). The metal (metal1ocene)-phosphorusbonds are shorter and consequently stronger (2.493-2.635 A) in dibridged compounds than in the monobridged ones (2.5842.715 A)suggesting some electron density delocalisation through the second bridge and its lowering on the metallocene unit. This is roughly confirmed by the values of Cp-M-Cp (Cp are the geometrical centers of the C5 rings) angles which are larger (stronger repulsions) in monobridged species than in the dibridged ones (e.y. for group 5 metallocenes: 135.0-139.4" us. 131.2-134.9").
References [I] (a) D. G. Dick, D. W. Stephan, Organometallics 1990, 9, 1911-1916; (b) D. G. Dick, D. W. Stephan, Organornrtallics 1991, 10, 2811-2816; (c) D. G. Dick, D. W. Stephan, Can. J. Chem.
1.7 Group 5 and 6 Bit.rlc.tallic. Complexes with Phospliido Bridges
123
1991, 6 9 , 1146-1 152; (di R. T. Baker. J. F. Whitney, S. S. Wreford, Or
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.8 Polythiometalates and Polyoxothiometalates Based on Acido-Basic Condensation Processes Francis Sicheresse, Emmanuel Caclot, Corine Simonnet-Jegat
1.8.1 Introduction The preparation and characterization of sulfur-containing molecules is of major importance because of their applications in modern problems of chemistry in relation to hydrodesulfurization catalysis, inorganic, and bioinorganic chemistry. In order to define new synthetic routes of S-based coordination compounds, considerable attention has been given to the chalcogenometalates due to their unique ability to function as versatile ligands. Indeed, this field has been extensively reviewed.[' -l5] Our contribution in this field is summarized in Scheme 1, but only results corresponding to part 1 of the diagram will be discussed here. Acidobasic Condensation
Mixed-valence Complexes - Bioinorganic Chemistry - Catalysis
Internal Redox Process
Material with Adjustable Shape Addition of Small Molecules - CuCI, CuNCS - Fragments of Complexes
and Dimensionality - Open Structures - Cubanes - Polymers ID, 2D, 3D
@\ Nucleophilic Reagent with Acceptor Properties
-
Behave as Pseudohalides with Empty d-Orbitals
Scheme 1. Diagrammatic representation illustrating the reactivity of [MS4I2-, M = Mo, W.
1.8 Polytlziometulutes and Polyoxothiometulutes
125
The first preparations of the tetrathiometallates [WS4I2- and [MoSq]*- were reported by Berzelius" 61 and their true composition established by Kriiss" and C o r l e i ~ . ~In " ~ 1883 ~ crystals were obtained"" but their complete structures were not solved until 1963."9q201 In those [MSqI2- anions, the metal ion has a high formal oxidation state (VI), is located at the center of a tetrahedron of sulfides, with M-S distances of about 2.17 A,and has low-lying d-orbitals, as represented in Scheme 2.
-10
-15
-20
Scheme 2. The energy level diagram for [WS,]'-.
The lowest levels located at -21.4 eV and -20.2 eV respectively correspond to the splitting of the four s orbitals of the sulfur atoms; in those levels the contribution of the 6s orbital of the tungsten is very weak. The singlet at -14.3 eV is made up of the total symmetric combination of the 3p orbitals of sulfur, which interact weakly with the 6p tungsten orbitals. The doublet at -14 eV represent the n combination of the d,z and d,zPy' metallic orbitals with the sulfur p-orbitals. The triplet at -13.8 eV is an internal admixture of the p orbitals of the sulfur atoms with small amounts of those of tungsten. The t2 level at -13.7 eV represents the lowest bonding W-S level containing the tungsten d,, and d,, orbitals and forming the 0bonding system with p-orbitals of sulfur atoms. In this level, a weak n-overlap is observed involving p orbitals of sulfur and the tungsten d,z orbital. The HOMO is located at -13 eV and contains only non-bonding sulfur orbitals without any contribution from tungsten. The doublet at -9.1 eV represents the LUMO (the antibonding level corresponding to the bonding level located at -14 eV): in this
126
I Molecular Clusters
level the contribution of the d orbitals of tungsten is very important, higher than in the corresponding bonding level. The level at -8.3 eV represents the antibonding part of the 0-bonding orbital observed at -13.8 eV. These two e and t2 higher energy levels form the acceptor levels of the thiometalate being separated by 0.8 eV (6400 cm-'), which roughly corresponds to the ligand field value of the S2- anion in T d symmetry. The reactivity of the thiometalates and their applications in coordination chemistry, related to their unique ligand properties, were pioneered by A. Muller in about 1970.[211 The first trimetallic complex reported was [Ni(WS4)2]2-[221 in which the thiometalate acts as a bidentate ligand through two sulfur atoms forming an edge of the WS4 tetrahedron. The structure of this compound was confirmed later by a full X-ray diffraction The same type of coordination was observed with oxothiometalates in the isostructural anions [Ni(W0S3)2l2-- and [Ni(W02S2)2]2-[241.Other heterobimetallic compounds having the same or similar architecture were isolated with various transition metal ions, Fe,[203251 C O , ['I~ Ni, Pd, and Pt,[26,271 Zn,[283Cd, and HgC3] The high stability of these complexes was attributed to the delocalizatiori of d electrons of the additional transition metal towards the empty d orbitals (LIJMO) of the central molybdenum or tungsten atom (see above). This delocalization was postulated on the basis of electrochemical experiments,[291these compounds being easily and reversibly reduced through a one or two-electron process. After 1975, thiometalate chemistry was focused in two new directions of research, differing in their purpose as well as in the structural types of the complexes involved. These two new areas of research are related to two fields of chemistry which had apparently not been connected before; heterogenous catalysisr301and bioinorganic ~ h e m i s t r y'I . ~ ~
1.8.2 Thiometalates and catalysis The catalyst generally used in the hydrosulfurization (HDS) process is MoS2, promoted by cobalt or and supported on alumina or activated carbon. The his-thiometalo complex [Ni(WS4]2]2- cited in the introduction was tested as a precursor for an unsupported mixed nickel tungsten sulfide catalyst. Catalytic activity measurements of the thermally-decomposed Ni-complex were found to be better than for catalysts prepared by conventional methods.[331 Metal sulfides are also known to catalyze the hydrogenation of arenes and the hydrogenolysis of thiophene~.[~"' Recent work shows that thiometalates are not necessarily good models for des~lfurization,[~~] their activity being closely dependent on the M : S stoichiometry and on the oxidation state of the metal. A review based on the coniparison of reactions of desulfurization of thiophene in organometallic compounds or on single-crystal metal surfaces has appeared, giving an excellent overview of the state of the art.[361
1.8 Polythiornetalutes and Polyoxothiometulutes
127
Moss and WS5 fragments were shown to be active in hydrogenation reactions, hydrodesulfurization and hydrodenitrogenation;[3j1 so complexes built from fragments of thiometallates were tentatively used as models for the study of processes occurring in heterogenous catalysis[371or even as potential catalysts for HDS or hydrogenation reactions.[”]
1.8.3 Academic research induced by catalysis 1.8.3.1 Sulfido-ligands Referring to catalysis studies, academic research focused on the synthesis of thiocompounds involving MS4 or MS5 “active” cores. Discrete clusters or complexes
Figure 1. a ) Structure of [WS4Pt(dppm)],(adapted from ref. 39). b) Orbital interactions in the {WS4Cu}core. (adapted from ref. 40b).
128
pIos41*-
I Molecular Clusters
PhSSPh
DMF, 90°C
S
S
Figure 2. Reaction scheme showing the formation of [ M o ~ ( S ~ ) ~ ( S ) ~ I : ‘ - , (adapted from ref. 41).
were synthesized and characterized, containing the MS4 fragment, and further complexes containing an additional precious metal, such as [WS4Pt(dppm)j,1391 [M’(bpy)3][(MS4)2M”]( M = Mo, W and M’ = Co, Ni, Mn and M ” = Pt, Pd), [ W S 4 ( R ~ ( b p y ) 2 ) 2 ] ~ and + , [ ~[~A] U ~ ( W S ~ ) ~ ] ~ - . [ ~ ~ ~ ] In these compounds, the MS2M’ central core is highly stabilized by the acceptor properties of the MS4 ligand, which allows these compounds to become involved in ligand substitution reactions and facile redox processes. In contrast the [M’(bpy)2C12] (M’ = Ni, Co) parent complex is irreversibly reduced uia a twoelectron process, [MS4M’(bpy)z]resulting from the substitution of two chlorides by MS4’-, which is reversibly reduced at two clearly separated one-electron steps. These results show that the MS4 ligand can be considered as a good acceptor due to its empty d-orbitals. With M’ = Cu a molecular orbital resulting from the bonding combination of d-orbitals of the thiometalate with d-orbitals of Cu was postulated (see Fig. 1b) based on extended Hiickel calculations.[40b1 The pyramidal MS5 fragment present in homopolynuclear complexes has been obtained by condensation of thiometalates under reducing conditions. For example, the reaction between PhEEPh ( E = S or Se) and [MoS4I2- led to the formation of dinuclear [Mo2S812- complex containing the [Mo2S4l2’ core (Fig. 2).14’] We have also explored the possibility of obtaining homopolynuclear complexes via the electrophilic attack on thiometalates by protons. We have studied these reactions extensively because of the opportunity they offer to observe, and eventually, to trap transient species between the starting thiometalate and the final insoluble and amorphous MS3 compound. Figure 3 shows the general scheme summarizing the acidification of [WS4I2- and detailing the different steps.r531 These condensations represent examples of intricate reactions since the protonation is systematically accompanied by redox phenomena making the metal and/or the sulfido ligand interesting. Moreover, these redox properties are also systematically coupled with the geometrical change of the reduced metal center. A large set of complexes, most of them characterized by X-ray diffraction, were reported. In [W30S8)2-,[443451 and [ W I S ~ ] * - , [the ~ ~sulfido ] ligands [ M 0 3 S s j ~ - , [ [W3Sg]2-,r431 ~~] appear unchanged whereas a metal center is reduced, generally by 2e-. The geometry at the reduced metal center changes from tetrahedral to pyramidal as represented in Fig. 4a. A second MS5 pyramid can be incorporated in the former molecular structure accompanied by a second electronic transfer to give [W4S12]2-,[47d1 which contains two central MSS pyramids sharing a common S-S edge as represented in Fig. 4b. In
129
weakly acid medium
H+ H20
/H+
strongly acid medium
Figure 3. General scheme illustrating the acidification of [WS,]'-, (from ref. 53a)
11
Figure 4. Structures of [WISSX]'- X
=
0, S. and [W4Sl2I2-, (adapted from ref. 43 and ref. 47)
130
1 Molecular Clusters
the [W2S4I2+dicationic fragment the two tungsten atoms are both reduced by one electron (V, d’) and are linked through a metal-metal bond (the complex is diamagnetic, W-W = 2.9 A)) and this ensures its high stability. The molecular structure of [W4S12I2-- can be formulated as [(WS4)(WzS4)(WS4)I2-, the two WS4 groups acting as terminal bidentate ligands towards the {W2S4}*+ central core. This formulation suggests the { W Z S ~ } fragment ~+ exists in acidified solutions as WS42-, probably stabilized by molecules of solvent. Starting from this hypothesis we succeeded in “extracting” the dithio-fragment from acidified mixtures of WS4=- by addition of the 2,2‘-bipyridine, a strongly chelating ligand, in the presence of halides.[47b1In this reaction bipyridine competes with WS42- to stabilize the {W2s4j2+core as summarized below:
By combining acido-basic titration results and UV-vis spectroscopic data a general scheme for the acidification of WS42- can be proposed for a weak acidic medium ( H + : W < 3) showing the reduction of tungsten is accompanied by the formation of the oxidized S2 2- disufido group according to the following equation:
[W3SgI2- is obtained quantitatively for p = 3 and q = 4 ( H + : W = 4 : 3) while [W4S12I2- corresponds to p = 4 and q = 6 (H+ : W = 6 : 5). Note that the expected [W2S6I2- dianion (p = 2, q = 2, H+ : W = 2 : 2) does not exist since it would contain two reduced tetrahedral tungstens, which is forbidden; the reduction of the metal center is always accompanied by the change from tetrahedral to pyramidal geometry. As kinetic studies recently revealed[47c1that the first step of the condensation is the protonation of WS42- according to the following reaction: WS42-
+ H+ + WS4H-
This hydrogeno-anion was recently trapped and isolated in the solid state as a PPh4+ salt (tetragonal, space group Z 4 , a = 13.0130 A, c = 7.1260 A).The structure was determined by X-ray diffraction showing the monoprotonated species has retained the tetrahedral geometry of the W S 2 - precursor.[47C1This new result illustrates that the reduction, and of course the associated geometrical change, take place after the evolution of H2S between two protonated units: the electron transfer occurs in a condensed species, probably a dinuclear intermediate, which remains uncharacterized.
s4
s4
jl Figure 5. a ) Structure of [ W ~ S I I ] ' -(adapted . from ref. 50). b) [W2S11I2- : [ W ~ S I I H relationship. ]
1.8.3.2 Disulfido-ligands Conversely, the selective oxidation of the sulfido ligand of WS4'-, without change in the formal oxidation state of the metal ( V I ) led to quite different structural types, [W2S902]2-,[501 or [ M o ~ S ~ O ~ ] ~ - . [ ~ ~ ] as reported for [W'SIlH] ,[481 [W2S11]2-,[491 In a more acidic medium (H- : W > 3). the oxidation of sulfides into disulfido ligands is accompanied by a complete change in geometry at the metal, as represented in Fig. 5a. The coordination geometry of the metal centers can be described as that of two pseudo pentagonal pyramids sharing an S-corner. The [W2S11]2anion has a twofold axis passing through the apex of the pyramid, which relates the two pyramidal sub-units in a syn-geometry. [ W ~ SI HII can be derived from [ W ~ S I by ~ ] protonation ~ of the S-bridge, which provokes the rotation of a WS5 pyramid around its main axis and changes a p-S bridge into a p-v3-S2 bridge as represented in Fig. 5b.
132
I Moleculur Clusters
In the WS2 terminal three-centered core the n* antibonding orbital of the S2*group splits into two c o m p o n e n t ~ [ ~ .a~ n; * ] :orbital mainly located in the WS; plane and strongly interacting with the metal, and a ni orbital, which is perpendicular to the WS2 plane and interacting weakly with the metal. The absorption observed near 475 nm in the electronic spectrum of [W2S11H]- has been attributed to the n: + d(W) transition.[481A second band related to the n{ + d transition is expected. Because of the strong stabilization of the bonding orbital due to the high oxidation state of the metal, this transition is shifted to higher energies. In less oxidized compounds such as [Mo3S(S2]6I2-,this transition is observed near 365 nm.I4] The formation of disulfido-groups from sulfido-ligands was also achieved by using externul elemental sulfur as the oxidizing agent.[”] The [M(S2)2E] ( E - = 0 ,S, M = W, V ) fragment present in all these complexes was recently trapped from acidic solutions and stabilized by a chelating ligand (2-2’-bipyridine) in the molecular shown in Fig. 6.
1.8.3.3 Vanadium systems The presence of the pyramidal [M(S2)2E](E-0, S) intermediate seems to be a general feature in the acidification of MS4, since this fragment was also trapped and characterized with [V04l3- in a polysulfide-containing medium.I53b1 This intermediate readily reacts with chelating ligands and is stabilized as a mononuclear spe-
s2
Figure 6. Structure of [wO(SZhbpyl, (adapted from ref. 53a).
1.8 Polythiomrtulutrs und Poll’o.uotliiometcilutr~s
1 33
01
s1
Figure 7. Structures of
[(VOfS2)2)2-p2-S4-( VO(S2)2)2]‘
, (adapted from ref. 53c).
cies. With (S,)2- ligands the unexpected templating effect of 4,4‘-bipyridine in the ~ - [ ~ ~ ‘ ] in Fig. 7. solid state gives the tetranuclear anion [ V ~ O ~ S ~ O ]represented
1.8.3.4 The [M2S2X2I2+X = 0, S fragment Between these two extreme redox behaviors (reduction of the metal or oxidation of sulfides), the use of molybdenum led to compounds containing reduced metal, generally Mo(V), and oxidized sulfur ligands, such as (S,7)2-,n = 2,3,4. In a few complexes these polysulfide ligands are present in a single configuration as in [Mo202S2(S2)2],[541( Mo-r2-S2 groups). These polysulfide anions represent good precursors, which, by abstraction of (S,)?- groups through redox processes, lead to cationic fragments, which have been successfully condensed on lacunary anionic species (see below). In other cases the disulfido ligands are present in the complex in various terminal configurations, such as in [Mo2S1ol2- r 5 5 a 1 (Mo-v2-S2 and Mo-v2-S4 groups) as shown in Fig. 8. Disulfido-groups can also be present in a complex as bridging ligands between two metal centers e.y. in [Mo2S& [5 6 1 and [Mo3S13]’- [57a1, which are represented in Fig. 9.
r
Figure 8. Structure of [Mo?Slo]’-, (adapted from ref. %a).
1 2-
134
I Molecular Clusters
s-s 2-
2-
\/
Figure 9. Representations of the structure of [Mol2S,2l2-, (adapted from rcf. 56) and [MoiSl,]*-, (adapted from ref. 57).
These anionic complexes are important for giving, by oxidation of terminal disulfido groups, very reactive, trinuclear cationic species.” h1 In molybdothiocompounds involving M o - ~ ~ -orS4)( ~ moieties, various specific “functional groups”” were clearly identified and engaged in nucleophilic attack on dicarbomethoxyacetylene, leading to the conversion of (S,) 2- sulfido ligands into dithi~lene.[~~~~~
’
1.8.3.5 CS2 activation [(S4)2Mo=S]readily reacts with CS2 to give both cis and trans [(CS4)2Mo=S]complexes, these compounds having the ability to reversibly release CS2 to revert to Mo-q2-S2. This elegant work is obviously closely connected to the activation of the C-S bond in HDS Very recently we have shown that CS2 could be added via reduction to [MoS4I2to give [Mo(CS3)4I3-,the only mononuclear reduced Mo-compound involving CS2 characterized so far[58b1(Fig. 10). This addition of CS2 under reducing conditions represents a facile, in situ synthesis of [CS3I2- thiocarbonate ligands that are difficult to prepare by conventional methods.
1.8.4 Reactions of thiometalates with polyoxometalates The early transition metals such as V, Mo, W, in their highest oxidation state form metal-oxygen macrostructures referred to as polyoxometalates. They represent a rich class of soluble clusters which have been studied for their chemical reactivity,
1.8 Polythiornetulutes and Pol~oxothioinetulutrs
s11
c4
~
135
s12
Figure 10. Structure of [Mo(CS?)4]’-.
physical properties, and also for their use in a large field of applications, including catalysis, medicine and material^.[^^-^^] The macrostructures of these compounds were generally obtained through acido-basic condensation processes[6o1and as a consequence of their reactivity, polyoxometalates can be easily functionalized and their functionalization, for example by organic ligands, not only affects the electronic structure of the parent polyanion but can also stabilize new structural types.[‘ The introduction of sulfur into the polyanionic frameworks is expected to modify the chemical and electronic properties of the 0x0-parents, and owing to the softness of sulfur new architectures are expected to be derived from the various precursors. Three different ways have been developed in our group to prepare the first polyoxothiometalates: J
i) selective sulfuration of a polyoxoanion based on O/S exchange, ii) stereospecific addition of a thiometallic fragment on a geometrically adapted polyvacant polyoxoanion, iii) direct synthesis by condensation of a thiometallic precursor. An example of each type of preparation is given here to illustrate the possibility of adapting the synthetic methology to the geometry of the expected final product.
136
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 11. Reaction scheme for the formation of a-[PWllNbSO39I4-, (from ref. 66).
1.8.4.1 Selective sulfuration of fully oxygenated polyoxoanions Direct reaction of hydrogen sulfide or sulfido ions with a polyoxoanion generally results in the reduction of the metal centers ( M = Mo, W ) and the breaking of the M-0-M bonding scheme of the framework. Therefore, only structures first stabilized aiu redox processes by substitution of tungsten by a less reducible atom can be isolated using this route. The precursor c(-[PW11Nb040]~was obtained by addition of a N b 0 3 + group, resulting from the controlled hydrolysis of NbClS, on the monovacant Keggin heteropolyanion a-[PWll O39I7-. The resulting compound was reacted with variable amounts of paramethoxyphenylthionophosphine sulfide (R2P2S4) to give the first Keggin compound ~-[PW11NbS039]~with sulfide replacing oxide[661(Fig. 11). The O/S substitution in the Keggin structure was clearly proven by IR and Raman studies, together with 31PNMR and voltammetric data.
1.8.4.2 Addition of a thiometallic fragment on a lacunary polyanion Another original method of synthesis is the stereospecific addition of a preformed thiometallic core in a polyvacant polyoxoanion. The [M2S20212+( M = Mo, W ) thioprecursor and y-[SiWlo036]'- represent an excellent example of obtaining the product by matching reactivity and geometry. The thiocation [M2S2O2l2+( M = Mo, W) was obtained aiu selective oxidation of (S,)2- ligands (where y1 = 2 or 4) in [(S4)MoOS2MoO(&)I2- using iodine in aqueous solution or D M F medium[671according to the equation:
+
+
8 [(S,)MOOS~MOO(S,)]*- 2 12 + [M02S202]~+ 2 ~ / Ss
+ 4 I-
This redox reaction is remarkable for changing a nucleophile, namely [(S4)MoOS2MoO(&)I2 ~,into the [Mo2S202I2+,which is a very strong electrophile. The tungsten homologue [W2S202]2Lwas prepared in a similar way in non-aqueous medium. The dithiocation reacts as a Lewis acid with the divacant y-[SiWl0036]'-
1.8 Polythiometulutes und Po1~~osotliion~rtakitc.s 137
Figure 12. Polyhedral view ofthe structure o f I)-[SiW I0 Mo?S?O?s1'- .
anion and fills the polyanion vacancy to yield the metal-saturated y[SiW1oM2S2038]~-( M = MoV, W v ) anion, represented in Fig. 12.[681 W NMR spectroscopy is a powerful tool for characterization of these species in aqueous solution. The number of peaks and the chemical shifts observed in the -110 to -190 ppm range are assigned to W(V1) tungsten atoms with C21.symmetry, while the low frequency (h' = 1041.2 ppm) signal is characteristic of the two equivalent reduced W( V ) atoms (see Fig. 13). The electronic properties of the y-isomer are completely modified by the substitution of only two oxygens by two sulfur atoms. The reduction by two electrons of the [SiW~203o]~parent anion results in the deiocalization of the two electrons over the [SiW 1204,,16- macrostructure, while in the S-substituted [SiW12038S2l6- anion the two additional electrons are localized on two specific metal centers,[68c1which adopt, as expected, a pyramidal geometry. Another possibility exists for incorporating sulfur in a Keggin anion. When the size of the [M202S2I2-' thio-fragment ( M = Mo, W ) and that of the cavity of the lacunary 0x0-precursor are not compatible, the direct stereospecific addition is no longer possible. In that case the acido-basic reaction gives sandwich-type compounds. This is typically the case of the reaction between the trivacant
1060
1040
(PPm)
1020
m -110
-190
(PPm)
Figure 13. I8'W N M R spectra of ; ~ - [ S i W ( V I ) ~ , , W ( V ) ~ (from S ~ o ~ref. ~ ] "68' ~.
138
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 14. a) Polyhedral view of the trivacant ~-[PW9034]~-. b) Polyhedral representation of [P?W24S6074(H20)61'2-.c) View of the (Mot, Mo2, Mo3) equatorial plane: 0 3 4 and 0 3 5 are oxygens of water.
M-(PW~O~ represented ~]~in Fig. 14a and [M202S2I2+( M = Mo, W ) . Two (PWg} Keggin sub-units are doubly bridged by three [M202S2I2+fragments in a sandwich type arrangement, as illustrated in Fig. 14b. The two Keggin units are equivalent, being related by the equatorial plane containing the six sulfur atoms. Seven
1.8 Pol~t1iionietalate.r and Pol~oxothionietulates
139
lines of relative intensities 2 :2 : 2 : 1 :2 : 2 : 1 are observed in I X 3 W NMR spectra. Chemical shifts in the range - 1 10 ppm to - 160 ppm are assigned to tungsten ( V I ) atoms in octahedral 0x0-environment, as reported above. Lines at 1197 ppm and 1376.4 ppm are assigned to the reduced tungsten ( V ) atoms of the three (W2S202) thiometallic fragments. The two resonances suggest the three { W2S202} bridges are not equivalent. The lowering of the symmetry is related to the presence of water molecules, in different environments, linked to the reduced molybdenum (or tungsten): two water molecules and an 0x0 group are directed toward the inner cage between the two {PWg) units, as represented in Fig. 14c.
1.8.4.3 Self-Condensation of the
[Mo2S202I2+fragment
The former strategy of synthesis is really convenient for the preparation of polyoxothioanions derived from well-established structural types, but is inadequate for the design of sulfur-rich frameworks. Therefore we developed another original approach based on the self-condensution under acido-basic conditions of the [Mo202S2I2+ fragment described above.[691The geometry of the molecular compound obtained by addition of potassium hydroxide to an aqueous solution of the dithio-fragment is represented in Fig. 15. Various titrations of solutions of [Mo2S202(H20)6I2+ by standard solutions of KOH allowed the “wheel” to be obtained qualitatively according to the following equation:
A remarkable feature of this structure is the cyclic arrangement of the neutral Mo12cluster with a central cavity of 11 A. Six [Mo2S202] building blocks are connected by hydroxo double-bridges and the coordination at the Mo centers is achieved by a terminal oxygen and a shared molecule of water. These water molecules are very labile, which promises to be a feature of the reactivity of this wheel with anions such as phosphates, acetates. and carboxylates. The self-condensation is reversible since the acidification of [Mo12S12012(OH)12(H20)6]by standard inorganic acids gave the original dithio-precursor. This protocol represents a convenient and productive way of obtaining new types of condensed species from simple and well defined precursors. We have illustrated that sulfur-based macrostructures could be obtained either by reduction of the charge of the cutionic precursor by a base, or by reaction between anionic precursors with acids (the first polynuclear compounds we described at the very beginning of this work have been obtained cia this procedure). The considerable interest of acido-basic condensation processes based on the lowering of the charge of adapted precursors lies in the possibility of designing tridimensional solids having predictable geometries and properties.
140
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 15. Structure of [ M o ~ ~ S , ~ O , ~ ( O H ) I ~a)( ball H~O and )~]: stick view showing the atom bonding scheme. b) Polyhedral representation, (from ref. 69).
References [l] [2] [3] 141
Holm, R.H. Chem. SOC.Reu. 1981, 10, 55. Coucouvanis, D. Acc. Chem. Reu. 1981, 14, 201. Miiller, A,, Diemann. E., Jostes, R., Bogge, H. Anyew. C'hern., Znt. Ed Engl. 1981, 20 934. Miiller, A., Jaegermann, W., Enemark, J.H. Coord. Clzern. Rev. 1982, 46, 245.
1.8 Pol~~thiometulutes and Polyoxothiometalutes
141
[5] a) Averill, B. Struct. Bonding (Berlin) 1983, 53, 59. b) Sarkar, S., Mishra, S.B.S. Cuord. Chem. Rev. 1984, 59, 239. [6] Draganjac, M.. Rauchfuss, T.B. Anyeir. Chern., Int. Ed. Engl. 1985, 24. 742. [7] Muller, A,. Jaegermann. W., Hellmann, W. J. Mol. Struct. 1983, 100, 559. [8] Muller, A. Po/yhedron 1986, 5 , 323. [9] Coucouvanis, D., Hadjikyriacou. A., Draganjac, M.. Kanatzidis, M.G., Ileperuma, 0. P d y hedron 1986. 5. 349. [lo] Muller, A,, Diemann. E. Adv. /nor
142
1 Moleculuv Clusters
Pan, W.H., Harmer, M.A.. Halbert, T.R., Stiefel, E.I. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1984, 106, 459. Pan, W.H., Leonowicz, M.E., Stiefel, E.I. Inory. Chem. 1983, 22, 672. Miiller, A,, Bhattacharyya, R.G., Koniger-Ahlborn, E., Sharma, R.C., Rittner, W., Neumann, A,, Henkel, G., Krebs, B. Inorg. Chim. Acta 1979, 37, 493. Secheresse, F., Lavigne, G.; Jeannin, Y., Lefebvre, J. J. Coord. Chern. 1980, 11, 1 I . Hanewald, V.K., Kid, G., Gattow, G. Z. Anorg. Allq Chenz. 1981, 478, 215 Bhaduri, S., Ibers, J.A. Inorg. Chem. 1986, 25,4. a) Secheresse, F., Lefebvre, J., Daran, J.C., Jeannin, Y. h o r y . Chem. 1982, 21, 1331. b) Simonnet-Jegat. C.. Toscano, R. A,, Robert, F., Daran, J. C.: Secheresse, F. J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 1994, 1311. c) Secheresse, F., Miiller, A. 1998, unpublished results. Secheresse, F., Manoli, J.M., Potvin, C. Inorg. Chem. 1986, 25, 3967. Manoli, J.M., Potvin, C., Secheresse, F. Inory. Cliem. 1987, 26, 340. Manoli, J.M., Potvin, C., Secheresse, F. Inorg. Chim.Actu 1987, 133, 27. a) Coucouvanis, D., Hadjikyriacou, A.I. Inory. Chem. 1987, 26, I . b) Hadjikyriacou, A.I., Coucouvanis, D. h o r g . Chem. 1989, 28,2169. Chandrasekaran, J., Ansari, A,, Sarkar, S. Inorg. Chem. 1988, 27, 3663. a) Simonnet-Jegat, C., Jourdan, N.. Robert, F., Bois, C., Secheresse, F. Inorg. Chim. Actu 1994, 216, 201. b) Simonnet-Jegat, C., Robert, F., Skcheresse, F. Truns. Met. Chem. 1994, 19, 379. c) Simonnet-Jegat, C., Delalande, S., Marg, B., Halut, S., Secheresse, F. J. Chrwz. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1996, 423. Rittner, W., Miiller, A,, Neuman, A,, Bather, W.. Sharma, R.C. Angerv. Chem., Int. Eil. Engl. 1979: 18, 530. a) Clegg, W., Christou, G.. Garner, C.D., Sheldrick, G.M. Inory. Chenz. 1981, 20, 1562. b) Xinquan Xin, Guoxin Jin, Boyi Wang, Pope, M. Inory. Chem. 1990, 29, 554. Miiller, A,, Nolte, W.O., Krebs, B. Angeiv. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 1978, 17, 279. a) Miiller, A,, Sarkar, S., Bhattacharyya, R.G., Pohl, S.; Dartmann, M. Anyew. C h m . , Int. Ed. Enyl. 1978, 17, 535. b) Miiller, A,, Wittneben, V., Krickemeyer, E., Bogge, H., Lemke. M. Z. Anory. Ally. Chem. 1991, 605, 175. a) Coucouvanis, D., Draganjac, M.E., Koo, S.M., Toupdakis, A,, Hadjikyriacou, A,[. Inorg. Chem. 1992, 31, 1186. b) C. Simonnet-Jegat, C., Cadusseau, E., Dessapt, R. Secheresse, F., submitted for publication. a) Coucouvanis, D., Hadjikyriacou, A.I., Toupadaki, A,. Lane, J.D., Koo, S.M., Ileperuma, O., Draganjac, M.E., Saligoglou, A. Inorg. Chem. 1991, 30, 754. b) Coucouvanis, D., Toupdakis, A,, Lane, J.D., Koo. S.M., Kim, C.G., Hadjikyriacou, A.I. J. Am. Chcm. Soc. 1991, 113. 5271. Pope, M. T. in “Hetero and Isopoly Oxometalates”; Springer-Verlag: New-York, 1983. “Polyoxometallutes: From Platonic Solid~sto Antiretovirul Actiaity” Pope, M. T., Miiller, A. Eds, Kluwer Acad. Pub.: Dordrecht; The Netherlands, 1994. Bussereau, F., Picard, M., Malik, C., TezC, A,, Blancou, J. Ann. Inst. PusteurlVirol. 1998,32,33. Ono, K., Nakane, H., Barre-Sinoussi, F., Chermann C. Nucleic Acids Res. Symp. Sor. 1984, 15. 169. [64] (a) Misono, M. Cutal. Rev.-Sci. Eng., 1987, 29, 269 (b) Haeberle. T., Emig, G. Chem. Eng. Techno/. 1988, 392 (c) Watzenberger, A,, Emig, G., Lynch, D. T. J. Cutul. 1990, 124, 247 (c) Cadot, E., Marchal, C., Fournier, M., TezC, A,, Herve, G. “Polyoxometullate,s: From Plutonic So1id.s to Antiretovirul Activity” Pope, M. T., Miiller, A. Eds, Kluwer Acad. Pub.: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1994, p 315. [65] Proust, A,, Thouvenot, R., Yoo, J. K., Gouzerh, P. Inorg. Chem. 1995, 34, 4106. 1661 Cadot, E.; BCreau, V., SCcheresse; F. Inory. Chim. Actu 1995, 132, 1029. [ 671 Coucouvanis, D., Toupadakis, A,, Hadjikyriacou, A.I. Znory. Chem. 1988, 27, 3273. 1681 a) Cadot, E., Bereau, V., Marg, B.. Halut, S., Secheresse, F. Inory. Chem. 1996, 9.5, 3099. b) Cadot, E., Bereau, V., Secheresse, F. Inory. Chim. Actu 1996, 252, 101. c) Bereau, V . These, 1997, Universitc de Versailles. 1691 Cadot, E., Salignac, B., Halut, S., Secheresse, F. Anye,v. Chem.. Int. Ed. En~ql.1998, 37, 612.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.9 Electronic Effects on the Shape of M2X2 Frameworks (X = Naked Chalcogenide Atom, M = Late Transition Metal) Curlo M t d i and Annmhrllu Orlmdini
1.9.1 Introduction Transition metal dimers containing the M2Xz framework ( M = transition metal, X = naked S, Se or Te bridging atom) are numerous. A search in the Cambridge Structural Database”] (no additional bridging ligand is allowed) yields close to 200 hits and structural information is also available from techniques other than X-rays. Some complexes are biologically relevant, in particular the species L ~ F ~ ( , U - S ) ~ F ~ L ~ [ ~ ] whose rhomboidal Fe2S2 core mimics that of important iron proteins. Amongst the transition metal complexes having the general formula [L,M(pX)2MLl,,]” ( m = 3 and n = +2 + -2 or 112 = 2 and n = 0, +2), we have experi- ~ ] present mentally studied those with L3 = CH3C(CHZPPh2)3 = t r i p h o ~ . [ ~The qualitative MO analysis is devoted to some aspects of interpretation of the latter, which are then extended to the whole series of related compounds listed in Table 1. Thus, we will concentrate first on dimers with terminal ML3 fragments and d ” metals ( n 2 6). In these cases, three filled metal orbitals are considered as Zone pairs and the bonding within the skeleton M z X originates ~ from the interactions of the d, and o metal hybridsL6]with the pure AOs of the bridging chalcogenides. Major roles are played by the steric demands of the terminal ligands and by the highly variable electron population. Almost like sponges, the complexes [ L ~ M X Z M Lcan ~ J ”attain up to five different valence elcctron counts. For example, by considering only metals of the first transition row ( F e through Cu) and the different total charges, the species 1-4[7-101and 913] in Table 1 are the least electron rich. Complex IlI3] contains one additional electron, 5-8[”.’21 and lZC3]two, 1314] three and finally 14[13’and 15[14]contain four additional electrons. Structurally, the core MzX2 can be either planar, Scheme la, or hinged at the vector X . . . X, Scheme 1 b.[’ While the puckering favors M-M bond formation, coupling of the two chalcogenide atoms is occasionally observed both in planar (13-15) and puckered (1-4) structures.
x-x M-Xh
2.552(2) 2.007(5) 2.228(2) 2.293(2) 2.364(2) 2.575(2) 2.645(2)b 2.709(9) 2.543(9) 2.498(9) 1.98(2) 2.185( 10) puckered structure, with M-M but not X-X bond (EXAFS) 3.475(2) 2.751(6)b 2.216(2) 3.688(1)b 2.88(2) 2.339(8) 4.093(2) 3.062(2) 2.56(3) undetermined structure, most probably planar undetermined structure. most probably planar 3.434(8) 2.58(2) 2.15(1) 3.598(2) 2.6 13(8) 2.23( I ) 3.865(1) 2.208 (4) 2.225(8) 4.348(2) 2.802( I ) 2.586( 10) 4.028(3) 2.073(4) 2.265(8) 3.02(1) 2.372(3) 3.658(1) 3.568(1) 2.94( I ) 2.37( I). 2.27( I ) " 4.231( I ) 3.066(2) 2.6 12(2j 4.364(1) 2.919(1) 2.62(1 ) 3.555( 1) 3.005(2) 2.333( 1) 3.763(1) 3.136(1) 2.449(2) 3.263( I ) 2.619(2) 4.100(1) 4.104( I ) 3.258(1) 2.620(8) 3.965(1) 3.465(1) 2.632(2) + not available + 121 2.695( 1) 2.636(2) 3.648( 1)
M-M
107
180 180 180
180
180
180 180 180
180 180 180 180 180 180
180 180 180
79.8( 1) 77.1(1) 75.6( 1) 79.7(1)
MXXM
~
aCp* - [C;Mes]-, triphos = CH:(CH2PPh2):, HE2 = H B ( 3 , 5 - P r j p ~ ) ~ ;np: = N(CH2CH2PPh2)3; dppy = PPh2Py: PhrPCHzCHzPPh2. bAveraged values with standard deviations calculated according to the expression: o(d) = [E(dal, - d,)'/n(n I)]'/' 'The two values refer to the average Ir-S distances involving the fragments (Cp*)(MejP)Irand (Cp*)Ir, respectively.
Compound"
Table 1. List of the complexes studied with their salient structural features.
dppe
=
[71
Ref
P P
-
1.9 Electvaizic Effc3ct.v on the Shape qf M z X , Frameivorks
145
u a
h
Scheme I
A key-assumption is that the puckering of LjMX2ML3 is inhibited by short contacts between the substituents of the terminal ligands, even when electronic effects would be favorable. The point is suggested by the pairs of isoelectronic complexes that exhibit either the structure a or b in Scheme 1. For example, in comparing 1 with 9 or 5 with 12, it is evident that the carbonyl ligands permit the formation of the M-M bond through the molecular bending. The latter overcomes 91 1-3, the metal electron deficiency in the d7-d7dimers [(C0)~Fe(,uu-X2)Fe(C0)~],[' as well as in their reduced derivatives, 5.["' The question remains why the two additional electrons in 5 preferentially cleave the X- X bond, which is presumably stronger than the Fe-Fe bond. Simple molecular modeling confirms that the hinge at the X-X vector, observed in structures 1-5. is highly hindered even in presence of the simplest phosphine, PH1. Thus, the imposed planarity in the complexes 6-8 and 12 (apparently with 34 valence electrons as 5) alters the nature of the chemical bonding within the M2X2 skeleton. If one or two electrons are subtracted from some of the latter systems as, for example in 9-11, instability or metastability of the singlet ground state ensues. This is probably the origin of the unique reactivity of the species [(triphos)Rh(pS)2Rh(triphos)3]-', 10, towards the activation of small molecules (e.y. H2 and O Z ) . [ If ~ ' the M2X2 skeletons, that are forced to stay planar, contain one or two additional electrons ( e . q : the (triphos)2NizX:! complexes 13,[4114'' 31), in-situ coupling of the chalcogenide atoms (Scheme 2) is observed.
Scheme 2
Steric constraints similar to those of triphos are apparently also exerted by the tris( pyrazoly1)borate ligands with 3,5 diisopropyl substituents and indeed the dicopper( 11) complex [ ( HBz)Cu(p-S2)Cu(HBz)], 15, is another known example of a S5- bridge in electron rich L6M2 unpuckered framework^."^' The latter species
146
I Molecular Clusters
is particularly interesting for its close relationship with dicopper peroxo analogs, which are important models of dioxygen carrier proteins.[171The peroxo is in equilibrium with a bis(p-0x0) isomer and the X-ray characterizations have indicated that the 0-0 scission is governed by weakening of one terminal Cu-N bond. At the same time, the other two Cu-N bonds reorient towards an overall L2Cu(p-O:2CuL2 planar arrangement. This prompts us to verify whether a similar dichotomy may be expected also for the dichalcogenides. Moreover, the progressive removal of two terminal ligands provides the link to extend the theoretical analysis to the bonding in known L2M(pU-X)2ML2 species ( 18-25[18p251), which are overall planar with no trans-annular linkage. The chemical oxidation of the complex [( Et3P)2Pt(p-Te)2Pt( PEt3)2] 22 induces puckering and Te2 coupling as shown by the structure of the dication 26.["] The electronic underpinnings, which highlight the latter structural trends, can also explain the peculiar behavior of the redox process as observed by cyclovoltammetry . Although several theoretical studies (ab-initio and DFT ) have appeared for specific cases,[21-26p291 th'is chapter exploits qualitative MO theory and, in particular, the undeniable power of the correlation diagrams, to draw the links between molecules different but similar. The arguments are developed with the help of the EHMO method[301and of the graphic capabilities of the package
1.9.2 Discussion 1.9.2.1 Chemical bonding in less electron rich M2X2 planar skeletons It is convenient to start the MO analysis from the model [(PH3)3Co(pu-X)2Co(PH3)3], Scheme la, which has a planar M2X2 skeleton. Many pieces of chemical information are obtainable by applying distortional perturbations to the basic MO picture of the latter. In particular, it may be inferred how the formation of M-M and/or X-X trans-annular bonds in either model a or b in Scheme 1 depends on the electron count. Moreover, some hints can be gained about the potential reactivity of these species. In contrast to the CzVsymmetry of a in Scheme 1, the experimental structures of the isoelectronic complexes 6-8" 21 and l2I3] have quasi-c~hsymmetry (staggered L3M fragments[321).The choice of model a in Scheme 1 allows thc monitoring of the inter-conversion to b in Scheme 1 under the particular symmetry without biasing the theoretical analysis significantly. In fact, the torsional barrier for the ML3 reorientation is small, consistent with both NMR and calculations (the EHMO value for X=S and M=Co is only ca. 2 kcal/mol). Along the pathway, the molecule bends at the X . . . X vector thus forming the M-M bond, while each ML3 group rotates about the axis passing through the metal and parallel to :Y . . . X
1.9 Electronic Effects OM the Sliuppe of M2X2 Fruuneworks
147
(max. rotation up to ca. 15"). Finally, the X-X bond is formed by the hinge of the two MXM planes about the M-M vector. It is worth mentioning that, due to the steric problems arising on reorienting ML3 groups, CO or hydride ligands are more conveniently used than PH3. This can be achieved with confidence as the trends in the macroscopic M O arrangements are fairly constant in all cases. Fig. 1 presents the basic orbital interactions in the planar model a in Scheme 1 . The L6M2 grouping (on the left side) is assembled from two pyramidal L3M fragments, which, for the electronic configurations > d 6 , have six filled non bonding d orbitals (ir. two tZg sets, as each fragment L3M descends ideally from an octahedral For the d7-d7complexes 6-8 and 12, the electron pair in excess is assigned to one of the in-phase and out-of-phase combinations of the metal d, hybrids, which are all sketched on the left hand side of Fig. 1 together with those of the higher CJ hybrids. All of the combinations of chalcogenide atomic orbitals are depicted on the right - hand side. The n-combinations of both the L6M2 or X2 groupings are distinguished as nli or n1 although M2X2 is not an actual mirror plane in the point-
\
/
{with X2 2a}
1a1 *----X
X'
Figure 1. Diagram for the interaction between the frontier MOs for the LhM2 and Xr groupings.
148
1 Molecular Clusters
group C2". The overall ring a-bonding stems from four delocalized interactions of ~ ~ * ) , and (~1110*).[~~' These correspond to the largest the types (alo), ( n ~ ~ * 1 n(a*lnli) Overlap Populations between FMOs and, although the 20*( XZ)combination is already slightly above its metal dn11 partner (bl), X2 is considered as a tetraanion able to donate at least eight a electrons. Figure 1 highlights a fifth donation of the type 711 (see the filled-bonding/emptyantibonding MOs 3al and 4al), which is almost as strong as any of the a interactions. The other two MOs of n ~ type, * 3b2 and 2b1, are localized on MZ and X2, respectively, and are described as non-bonding electron pairs. Thanks to the Z_L donation, the metals reach formal electron saturation, i.e. the electrons count for the dimers 6-8 and 12 is 36, with one resonant M=X double bond, as shown schematically in Scheme 3. The one-electron oxidation of [(triphos)Co(p-S)2Co(triphos)], 12, yields the monocation 11 whose structural features are not dramatically changed.[31 The framework M2S2 remains planar and the M-M distance is still non-bonding although shortened (3.43 us. 3.60 A); only the orientation of the terminal (triphos)Co groups is no more staggered. This is consistent with the localized metal character of the MO, which looses one electron ( i e . M~-zL*,3b2). More intriguing are the possible consequences in the doubly oxidized dication 9 whose structure could not be determined.[31By referring to Fig. 1, the new HOMO-LUMO gap (2bl-3b2) is small (<0.5 eV). Since a triplet ground state cannot be excluded, a reinvestigation of the magnetic properties of 9 would be necessary. In contrast, the Rhz dication 10 is certainly diamagnetic.['] Specific EHMO calculations confirm that 2bl and 3b2 are still the two frontier levels but their gap is large enough (ca.1 eV) due to the intrinsically higher energy of rhodium d orbitals. Complete depopulation of 3b2 magnifies the unsaturation at the rhodium dnL orbitals, which is in part compensated by the delocalized M=S double bond (Scheme 3). In spite of the latter, the Rh2S2 nl framework can be ideally reconciled to the quadrupole, shown in Scheme 4, determined by the pair of empty Rh dnL orbitals that coexist adjacent to the two filled S pnl orbitals.
Scheme 4
Scheme 5
The separation of the nl charges with nucleophilic sulfur and electrophilic rhodium atoms, confers unique reactivity to 10. For example, the reversible activation of two H2 molecules and the formation of the structurally characterized complex [(triphos)HRh(,~-SH)2RhH(triphos)]+~ has been reported.['' As shown in Scheme 5, polarization and heterolytic splitting of two H:, molecules could be induced by the highly polarized Rh"+/S"- linkages, perhaps asynchronously as a ter-molecular reaction is thermodynamically improbable. A comparable M O interpretation of the 0 2 heterolytic splitting over the dipole Ir"'/C"has been previously presented.[351 The ni donor capabilities of the chalcogenide bridges towards the electron deficient metals need not be invoked if a tvcms-annular M-M cr bond could be formed in M2X2 cores similar to some planar M4 systems with the expected electron count. but not in For example, the fifth M-M 0 bond is observed in [Req(C0)16]2-[3h1 Os4(CO)I & ~ ' ] . which has two additional electrons. An MO analysis could highlight the electronic underpinnings of such a remarkable structural difference.r341Here, we simply mention that by applying similar criteria to M:,X? planar frameworks, the proper electronic conditions for the formation of the trans-annular M-M bond cannot be met.["1 Otherwise the latter can be formed on bending the molecule X vector (ride infiva). Before analyzing molecular puckering in detail, we mention other planar cases in which the metal electrophilicity of the skeleton with the same electron count as 10 is relieved by the addition of one terminal ligand. For complexes containing triphos, such a possibility is perhaps limited to the small hydride ligands found in the hydrogenated derivative of Conversely, if the terminal L3M fragment is of the type CpM, there is room also for more sterically demanding donors including phosphines. This is the case of the complexes (Cp*)2L,nIr:,(,u-S)2[L = PMe3, CO, CN-t-Bu, m = l,2].'401Schematics of the latter species, 16 and 17 in Table I , are shown in Scheme 6a and 6b, respectively. Since the fragments [Cp*Ir]'+ and [(triphos)Rh]'+ are i.~olohal,[~'~ it is obvious that in 16 the reoriented dnl orbitals ( F M O s la1 and lb:, in Fig. 1) are used to coordinate the L ligands. Conversely, the removal of only one ligand in 17 (Scheme 6b) liberates one dnl orbital and restores Ir=S double bond at the corresponding metal atom as experimentally confirmed by the two 0.1 A shorter I r 4 distances. If also the second L ligand could be removed (not proven experimentally), molecu-
150
I Molecular Clusters
2.37
L
a
b
Scheme 6
lar puckering could be sterically feasible, especially if Cp* were substituted by less demanding Cp precursors. As will be illustrated next, electronic factors do not allow direct access to the puckering route, which leads to the formation of the M-M linkage.
1.9.2.2 Puckering of the M2X2 skeletons Terminal CO ligands are sterically consistent with the observed puckered struc( X = S, Se, Te).r7p99111 The ture of the iron complexes [(CO),Fe(p-X)2Fe(CO)3]o,p2 analysis of the latter can be conveniently carried out with the help of Walsh diagrams, which start at the well understood MO picture of the planar skeleton (Fig. 1). This strategy has been proven to be very informative for other comparable [(CO)3M(pU-Y2)M(CO),] species [Y = CO, SH, PH2].[421 While the formation of the M-M linkage is induced in all cases by the bending of the molecule at the X . . . X vector, the pathway (Fig. 2a) features the simultaneous formation of the X-X linkage on variation with Fig. 2b. It will be evident that the two final MO pictures require the difference of two units in the total electron count. Both Fig. 2a and 2b have the common feature the crossing between the levels 4al and 3b2, which are LUMO and HOMO of d7-d7 planar complexes (6-8, 12) that have previously been considered to be saturated via the partial M-X nl bonding. Since the metal d, components of 4al are in-phase (see Fig. I ) , this overall M2X2 n ~ antibonding * level converts ultimately into the Mz-a bonding orbital in Fig. 3. The residual X2 contribution in the latter suggests that the classic M-M bent bond[261maintains a reminiscence of the unperturbed d, pz interaction. Analogously, 3b2 (the original HOMO with M2-711* character) converts into the bent M2cr* partner of Fig. 3 in both Fig. 2a and 2b. The basic difference between Fig. 2a and 2b concerns 2bl level, which destabilizes sharply in the former. The reason is as follows; molecular puckering itself mixes the characters of the initially low and filled lbl and 2bl MOs, which avoid the crossing in any case. Recall that in the planar model (Fig. 1) the latter levels, although belonging to the same symmetry, are quasi-orthogonal to in-plane cr annular-bonding ((qla*)) and X2-n1* characters, respectively. Since M2X2 is not a real mirror -
1.9 Electronic Efects on the Shupp of M2X2 Frurne1zwk.Y
a
151
b
Figure 2. Compariwn of the Walsh d i d p m s for the puckering of the MIX? skeleton with (a) or without [b) X-X coupling
plane, even the incipient molecular bending rehybridizes together the pnl and the in-plane p radial orbitals of thc bridging atoms. This also holds for their al combi~ nations so that the results can be schematically represented as follows: the p n orbitals get more and more involved into CT donations to the metals (Fig. 4a and 4b), while the originally out-pointing p orbitals ( 2 1 ~ and 2rr* in Fig. 1) become perpendicular to the planes MXM (Fig. 4c, 4d). At the large X-X separations (as in the dianion 5, which has been shown by EXAFS techniques[""] to contain M-M but not X-X bonds) the 3a1 and 2bl MOs are lone puivs that are somewhat repulsive to each other. Moreover, together with the M-M 1~ bonding orbital 4al (Fig. 3), they represent the three highest occupied MOs, all having X2 contributions. The well known nucleophilicity of the chalcogenide atoms in 5[""] is fully consistent with such an MO picture. When the X- X distance shortens as in Fig. 2a, the pristine 2b1 MO (Fig. 4d) converts into a high lying Xl-cr* MO while the final 2bl orbital is the M-X antibonding counterpart of Fig. 4b. Accordingly. in the complexes with four M-X single bonds plus the X-X and M-M ones, the levels 2b1, 3bl and 3b2 (Mz-a*) must be empty.[431In contrast, the original LUMO 4a1, which has converted into
152
I Molecular Clusters
the M2-a bonding MO, must be populated. If the route (Fig. 2a) is taken starting from planar and stable 36e systems (e.g. 6-8, 12), then one of the two electron pairs in 2bl and 3b2 should be discharged from the system while the other one would be transferred in 4al. In any case, the process is symmetryforbidden[441with the Surther complication that there would be two forbidden electron jumps in a row, as suggested by the Fig. 2a. Interestingly, also molecular puckering, which is not accompanied by X-X bond formation (pathway in Fig. 2b) and does not require variation of the total electron number, is a symmetry forbidden process (crossing of filled 3b2 and empty 4al levels). By disregarding the steric problems and irrespective of lhe coupling of the chulcogenide atoms, the puckering of planur skeletons or its inverse process ( M-M bond cleavage) is not electronicully allowed.
<$ "
M
M
a
b
C
d
Figure 4. Representation of the molecular orbitals of (a) 2a1, (b) lbl, (c) 3a1, and (d) 2bl.
1.9.2.3 Coupling/ uncoupling of dichalcogenide within puckered frameworks Detailed mechanistic studies have demonstrated that the reduction process for [(C0)3Fe(p-Se)2Fe(C0)3],2, ultimately leading to the corresponding dianion 5, is stepwise and not unimolecular.[""] The added electrons are unpaired at the bridging atoms and the radical species combine in a tetrameric intermediate whose scission finally yields the dianonic dimer 5 with Fe-Fe but no Se-Se linkage. Apparently, inconsistent with the latter pathway, the electrochemical oxidation of the bis-sulfido dianion 5 has been quoted[221to lead directly to the uncharged species 1
I . 9 Electronic Effects on the Shape of’ M2X2 Frcrnzeworks
153
. ‘b,
/ 3a,
Figure 5. Evolution of the MOs for elongating the X ~ - Xdistance within MzX2 puckered skeletons.
and to be reversible. While the theoretical analysis of the stepwise reaction seems a rather difficult task, it is interesting to evaluate the problems related to concerted coupling/uncoupling of the two chalcogenides via redox chemistry. The Walsh Scheme ( Fig. 5 ) , which correlates the MO pictures on the right hand sides of Figs. 221 and 2b. respectively, clearly shows the 2bl/4al inter-level crossing. On the left hand side, the model of the uncharged complex 1 has M-M and X-X bonds, hence the corresponding g * levels 3b2 and 3bl are empty and so 2bl exhibits overall M2X?-o* character. The question is, which MO could initially host the additional electrons. Obviously, the ideal candidate to attain the conformer such as 5 upon X-X cleavage would be the X2-cr* M O 3bl. which is too high in energy. The other two LUMO candidates, 2bl and 3b2 are rather close in energy in a region where there are even more closely-packed levels (not shown). In any event, a reduced system maintaining the original structure appears inconsistent with the singlet ground state. Other authors, on the basis of HFS calculations (substantially consistent with the present EHMO results), suggested that 2bl was the acceptor of the new electrons on account of its X?-o* character.[281However, x2-0~ is only one component of 2b1, which is more accurately described as an overall MzX2-o* level. Accordingly, the addition of electrons is expected to weaken the skeletal M-X bonds. The MO 3b2 with its M2-o* character is perhaps a better candidate, not only because it is already slightly lower than 2bl but because it is significantly stabilized by even a small elongation of the M-M bond (the weaker one). The trend is already evident in
154
I Molecular Clusters
Fig. 2a (from right to left) as 3b2 goes down in energy more quickly than 2bl. Moreover, if M-M but not X-X increases (the corresponding diagram is not shown for the sake of brevity), 2bl remains almost constant while 3b2 stabilizes and crosses the ascending 4al level at some point. This suggests that M-M uncoupling is favored over that of X-X. Consistent with the experimental data[""] the MO arguments remove the possibility that the reduction of 1 may lead directly to the dianion 5. It is more likely that the M-M bond elongates while the M2X2 skeleton remains puckered at the X-X linkage. The distortional trend could be inverted if the electrons were removed before 3b2 crosses 4al (fast cyclovoltammetry). On the other hand, the oxidation of 5 by subtracting two electrons from 4al (the M-M bonding MO, at the right hand side of Fig. 6) would soon contrast withfovbidden 2bl/4al inter-level crossing. Only if 2bl was already higher than 4al would the oxidation lead directly to 1. In any case. based on the previous MO arguments, it is hard to see how the process in question can be electrochemically reversible. As a final consideration, the coupling of two naked chalcogenides to generate a formal Xz2- unit in-situ is a rather difficult process for the complexes of the triads of iron and cobalt. A puckered dimer forms only from reactants containing the X2 unit. The X-X linkage cannot be broken directly. Conversely, direct X-X coupling seems possible within L6M2X2 assemblies containing the more electron rich metals such as Ni and Cu.
1.9.2.4 Coupling of chalcogenide atoms in electron rich M2X2 planar frameworks Remarkably, the complexes [(triphos)MX2M(triphos)lnexist with five different electron counts (from M = Co, n = t 2 to M = Ni, n = 0). The electron rich [NizX2]" frameworks (13, n = +1, and 14, n = 0) feature the planar skeleton in Scheme 2 with a somewhat elongated trans-annular X-X linkage (see Table 1). The evolution of the MOs on squeezing the rhombus is presented in Fig. 6. For the sake of continuity, the working symmetry is still C2" but also the C2h labels of real molecules with staggered ML3 fragments are reported on the right-hand side. The MO levels in Fig. 6 correspond to those on the left hand sides of Figs. 2a and 2b. In the uncharged complex 14, the scheme is fully populated up to 4al. Because the latter has overall M2X2 nl* character, not only the previously important X2 + M2 n~ donation is cancelled but significant n l repulsions intuitively disfavor X-X coupling. In contrast, the structure with the latter trans-annular bond is computationally more stable (by ca. 0.5 eV) than the starting structure. Moreover, barriers of a few tenths of an eV separate the two minima so that isoelectronic, but still unreported bis(pcha1cogenide) isomers are not unrealistic. Quantitative EHMO results are questionable especially when bond making/breaking is implied, nonetheless the switch of the HOMOS (4al and 2bl) along the pathway is consistent
1.9 Electronic EfIL’ctson the Shupe of M2Xz Frameworks
155
Figure 6. Evolution of the MOs for squeezing the MzX2 planar skeleton at the X-X vector.
with the two minima and with a symmetrj~cillon*eu’inter-conversion, hence with the dichotomy of the species. Surprisingly, the small total energy variations result from a complex balance of major stabilizing/destabilizing effects on the various populated levels (those evident in Fig. 6 and others at lower energies). In particular, 2bl with M?XZ (nl,la*) bonding character exhibits the greatest destabilization on reducing the X-X distance because of its X?-o* component. Moving towards the right, 2bl crosses 4al but remains at an accessible energy to be the HOMO. The evolving character of 2bl is most critical for the relation between the annular and trans-annular bonds of the M2X2 skeleton. Figure 7 proposes the ring bonding interaction (rill 12n*) already depicted in Fig. 1 and highlights the destabilizing effects on 2bl of the low lc/* combination of chalcogen s orbitals.
\
Scheme 7
I
156
I Molecular Clusters
In the cobalt dimers 6-8 and 12, the Mz-n,,FMO (bl) accepted the electrons from the S2-20* FMO, which, for non-bonding X-X distances, is low and filled. The donor-acceptor roles are now inverted. In fact the d9-d9 metal configuration of 14 implies “back-donation” from bl into the X2-20* FMO, which is forced to be high lying and empty by the short X-X distance. The energy of the resulting MO 2bl (still M2X2-(njl120*) bonding) depends on the weight of its X2-20* component. Ultimately, when the latter FMO is too high, the bonding interaction with the metals vanishes as well as the residual electron density back-donated into X2-20*. Under these circumstances, there remain only three out of four M-X linkages while the X-X bond order becomes practically one. As is often the case in chemistry, the actual system can be described as being between the two limiting situations, i.e.: traizs-annular and annular bonding are in competition and form at the expenses of each other. Recall that the dichalcogenide grouping was the formal 10 electron donor in planar dimers such as [(triphos)2Co2S~](12, as well as 6-8), which were formulated as 36 electron species. The apparently incongruent 38 electron count of [(triph0~)2Ni2Te2],14,[l3]and of 15[l4] as well, is rationalized by the MO arguments. The XZ grouping becomes only a 6 electron donor by virtue of the inactivate nl donor capability and of the inverted electron flow for one of the four annular M-X bonds (from X2 + M2 to M2 + X2). Ultimately, 14 and 15 may be also counted as having 36 electrons (12 from the terminal ligands, 18 from the two d9 metals and 6 from the unit X22-). In a similar way to metals, the chalcogenide atoms tune up the number of electrons made available to the cluster and, accordingly, they are occasionally regarded as integral components of transition metal clusters. Regardless of the substitution of Te with S atoms, 13 has one electron less than 14. The rather long S-S bond of 2.21 A in 13 (approximatly one step before the right hand side of Fig. 6) raises the question whether one electron is missing from 4al or 2bl. The preparation of 13 involves H2S as a reactant and may give, as an alternative product, a complex where a single sulfur atom is linearly bridging the nickel metals.[451Accordingly, 13 is probably formed from an in-situ coupling of two naked S atoms. In this case, 4al is the best candidate over a long range, to have one missing electron. Given the M2X2-n1* character of the latter, the stabilizing n bonding within the ring is partially restored. In contrast, one electron missing in 2bl would weaken the M2 + X2 back-donation, hence the ring 0-bonding. Moreover, the inversion between the SOMO (4al) and second HOMO (2bl) is symmetryfirbidden along the pathway so that the shortening of the S-S linkage must be interrupted before the crossing point. Since such an electronic constraint does not apply to closed shells where both 4al and 2bl are populated, the in-situ S-S coupling may proceed to give the shorter S-S distance of 2.07 A in the Cu2 dimer 15.[’41 Although only dichalcogenide dimers are the topic of this article, we cannot help but point out the peroxo analog of 15, namely ( HBz)Cu(pu-02)Cu( H B z ) , [ ~and ~ ] the very exciting L6Cu202 complexes of Tolman, which exhibit the dichotomy of per-
1.9 Electronic EfSrctJ on the Shappr of MzX? Framettwks
157
Scheme 8
0x0 and bis(p-0x0) forms." 71 Experimental and theoretical a h - i n i t i ~ [ ~studies '] have shown that the latter can be in equilibrium. Moreover, the X-ray structure of the his(p-0x0) derivative [L'pr'Cu(p-oxo)~Cu LIPr3IS 71 indicates that the ( 3 2 0 2 planar skeleton with no trans-annular bond is permitted being accompanied by some rearrangement of the terminal L1M units. As shown in Scheme 8, the latter loose threefold symmetry due to the lengthening of one Cu-L linkage and by the movement of the other two into the Cu202 plane. The connectivity of the tripodal ligand prevents the L3M fragments from transforming into L2M ones. As mentioned, no bis(p-chalcogenide) isoelectronic analog of the ditellurido/disulfido complexes 14 and 15 has been reported. However, a rearrangement of such as shown in Scheme 8 drastically shifts the equilibrium towards the broken X-X linkage and, ultimately, the departure of one terminal donor stabilizes the d8-dX L2Ni(,u-S)2NiL2species by > 3 eV. In fact, recall that in these electron rich species each LIM dnL hybrid (xz + p_)is populated. In going from L3M to L2M fragments, the d, and p, components separate as shown in Scheme 9 with p- becoming the empty uninvolved orbital typical of the square-planar coordination. Conversely, not only is significant energy gained by the electrons in the pure z2 orbital with respect to the d, hybrids but also the overall repulsion of the four 711 electron pairs is strongly mitigated within the M2X2 ring. Another subtle effect arises from the reorientation of the in-plune dnl/ metal hybrids, in particular those contributing to the bl interactions with the bridging atoms. By referring to Scheme 7, the tilted dn,, hybrids of L3M fragmentsc6]lie slightly out of the M2Xz plane whereas the corresponding L2M hybrids are optimally oriented to interact with the 20' combination of the chalcogenides. The
Scheme 9
158
I Molecular Clusters
greater the back-donation into the latter X-X antibonding orbital, the more susceptible is the bond to being broken. This situation recalls the dichotomy of metal olefin complexes.[481In the case of Zeise’s salt, minimum back-donation occurs from a pure d orbital of the fragment L3Pt(II) into the n*c-c level. Conversely, L2Pt(O)fragments have a filled and well hybridized dn orbital that is responsible for a large back-donation, which ultimately favors the cleavage of the C=C 71 bond (metallo-cyclopropane
1.9.2.5 Uncharged and dicationic complexes of the type L2MX2ML2 The electronic features of the complexes [L4M2X2I0,+*( M = Pt, Pd) can be easily derived from the previous MO arguments. The uncharged species 18-24 in Table 1 are planar, whereby the local square coordination is typical of Pd( 11) and Pt( 11) ds atoms. Only one isoelectronic complex 25 is reported to be puckered.r251Recent DFT and ab-initio calculations point out either the energetic preference for the overall planar geometry[”] or a flat potential energy surface on puckering.[291 Conversely, the removal of two electrons as in 26 favors, both experimentally[221 and computationally,[211molecular bending with the formation of the trans-annular X-X bond. The Pd, Pt ds metals have low acidic character at the p; orbital and the axial ligand is eliminated. In turn, the absence of the latter causes the largest stabilization of the z2 orbital (Scheme 9) hence of the whole dimer (additionally, no major dnl/pnl repulsions are active). In a model of 18-24, the interaction (dn111X::-2o*) is more effective than in corresponding L6M2 complexes. In fact, the L2M hybrids are well oriented and, since the metals belong to the second or third transition row, are quite diffuse. At the left-hand side of Fig. 7, the M2X2 o-bonding MO 2bl (donation 2o* i nil) lies below the grouping of 4 4 non bonding d orbitals typical of metals in square planar coordination.r61Similar to the L6M2X2 case in Fig. 2a, 2bi destabilizes on shrinking the X-X distance while the M2X2 skeleton bends. The puckering mixes together the in-plane pa and p n l orbitals of the bridging atoms and produces MOs quite similar to those in Fig. 4a-4d. As shown by the CACAO drawing on the right-hand side of Fig. 7, 2bl is ultimately the M2X2 g * MO. Evidently, the filled Xz-nL* combination has become the major donor towards the reoriented metal dnl1 hybrids. Similar to Fig. 2a but not shown in Fig. 7, a third bl level inherits most of the X2-o* component of the original 2bl and is ultimately found at high energy. In any case, 2bl also looses much energy along the pathway and the final geometry can be attained upon discharge of the electron pair, which populates the level.[501The structure of complex 26, which is the oxidized derivative of 22, is consistent with the latter MO picture, although it remains questionable whether the redox process follows the path shown in Fig. 7. The dashed line in Fig. 7 (from the right to the left hand side) represents 2bl
+
1.9 Electronic Ef(>rtson the Shtrpe of M2X2 Framewwks
159
Figure 7. Evolution of the MOs for the puckering of a L4M2X2 model with simultaneous X-X coupling.
when the M2X2 skeleton unpuckers while maintaining the X-X linkage. The CACAO drawing on the extreme left confirms that 2bl originates now from the backdonation of diqI into the high lying FMO X2-20* as it occurred for the L6M2X2 species (refer to the Fig. 6 at the right-hand side and to Scheme 7). Importantly, 2bl has inverted the character relative to the M2X2 ring bonding (from o* to a) and has obviously gained energy. In no case, however, can it descend below the block of d orbitals on account of the high lying X2-20' component. If populated, the total energy difference with respect to the planar isomer with no trans-annular linkage is large (>2 eV) and the dichotomy invoked for L6M2 skeletons is now less probable. Even so, it is possible that the planar L2M(p-X2)ML2 isomer with trans-annular X-X bond may have a finite lifetime. In fact, according to the experimental data'221 PEt3)2]" ( n = 0, +2), the dication 26, reported for the species [( Et?P)?Pt(p-Te2)Pt( obtained viu the chemical oxidation of 22, exhibits quasi-reversible oxidation waves in cyclic voltammetry. The MO picture outlined suggests that fast addition/removal of electrons to and from 2bl (dashed line in Fig. 7) may be possible as the level remains fairly isolated in the frontier MO region. On the other hand, the reported irreversible electrochemical oxidation of 22 confirms that 2bl is not the best candidate for the removal of the electrons as it lies below the non-bonding d-centered MOs. With a lack of additional pieces of experimental information, it is quite hard to define the MO which actually becomes depopulated and the structural rearrangements, which accompany the irreversible oxidation wave in this case.
160
I Molecular Clusters
1.9.3 Conclusions In the article, a link between the electronic structures of a large class of metal dimers containing two naked chalcogenides as bridges has been established. For the reported L6M2X2 species, the interconversion between planar and puckered M2X2 skeletons (hinged at X . . . X) is electronically prevented even if sterically allowed. Neither can the addition/removal of one or two electrons from the system change the situation. Within the planar or bent frameworks, specific electronic factors govern the in situ formation of the X-X linkage and such a coupling may occur only with electron rich metals, which need not have a M-M bond. The dichotomy of species with or without the trans-annular linkage is in principle possible but a certain energy barrier separates the two isomers. No major steric factors work against the puckering of L4M2X2 complexes because no direct M-M linkage is required. The observed planar/bent rearrangement, which occurs upon chemical oxidation of selected L ~ M z X species, ~ contributes to the X-X coupling as well. However, when carefully evaluated, the underlying electronic effects indicate that the interconversion route is not even in this case the most direct one.
1.9.4 Appendix In performing the extended Huckel calculationsr301care was taken that the geometries were as close as possible to those of the experimental data. The various input files for the CACAO programt3’] are available from the authors on request (e-mail:
[email protected]). The STO parameters used were those standard in a latter package and referenced in its documentation.
1.9.5 Note Added in Proof Since the manuscript was sent to the Editors a few papers have appeared related to species of the type LzM(p-S)zML2. A puckered structure, comparable with that of 25-26, has been determined for a Pt derivative by means of X-ray diffraction,[”] while a Pd analogue has been characterized by computational methods.[521A theoretical analysis of the same framework has emphasized the role of the direct M-M interaction for skeletal puckering.[’ 31 Finally a review article highlights the chemical reactivity promoted by the Pt2S2 core.[s41
References [ 11 Cambridge Crystallographic Data Center, University Chemical LdbOratOry, Lensfield Road, Cambridge CB2 IEW, UK.
121 (a) J. J. Mayerle. S. E. Denmark, B. V. DePamphilis, J. A. Ibers, R . H. Holm, J . A m . Chem. Soc. 1975. Y7, 1032-1045: ib; M. A. Bobrik, K. 0. Hodgson, R. H. Holm. Inory. Chem. 1977. 16, 1851-1858: ( c ) A. Salifoglou. M. G . Kanatzidis, D. Coiicouvanis, Inorg. Chrm. 1988. 27. 3394-3406: (d) N . Ueyama. S. Ueno, T. Sugawara, K. Tatsumi. A. Nakamura, N. Yasuoka. J. Chrni. Soc. Dulton Trcm. 1991. 2723-2727; (el I. Bertini. S. Ciurli, C. Luchinat. Structure rind Bonding. 1995. 83, 1-54. 131 C. A. Ghilardi, C . Mealli, S. Midollini, V. I. Nefedov. A. Orlandini, L. Sacconi, Inor~g.Chem. 1980. 10. 2454 2462. 141 C . Mealli. S. Midollini. Inorg. Chem. 1983. 22, 2785-2786. 151 C. Bianchini. C. Mealli, A. Meli, M. Sabat, Inorg. Cheni. 1986, 25, 4617-4618. [6] T. A. Albright, J. K. Burdett and M. H. Whangbo, Orbital Interuction.s in Cherni.stry, 1985,
John Wiley, New York. [ 7 ] ( a ) C . H. Wei, L. F. Dahl. Inorg. Chem. 1965. 4 , 1-11: 1. L. Eremenko. H. Berke. A. A. H. van der Zeijden, B. I. Kolobkov. V. M. Novotortsev, J. Orguriomet. Chem. 1994, 471. 123-132. [Sl C . F. Campana. F. Y. K. Lo: L. F. Dahl. Inorq. Chem. 1979, 18, 3060- 3064. [9] R . E. Bachman. K. H. Whitmire. J. Organomer. Chem. 1994, 47Y. 31-35. [ l o ] R . Minkwitz, H. Borrmann, J. Nowicki. Z. Ncituif?orsch. 1992, 47b. 915 918. [ I I ] (a) T. D. Weatherill, T. B. Rauchfuss, R. A. Scott. Inorg. Chem. 1986, 25. 1466-1472: (b) D. Seyferth, R. S. Henderson. L. C. Song, Oryu/?ori?et(i//ic,(.1982, I , 1255133. 1121 H. F. Klein, M. GaM. U. Koch. B. Eisenmann, H. Schafer, Z. Nuturfiirsch. 1988, 4 3 , 830838. [ 131 M. DiVaira, M . Peruzzini; P. Stoppioni, J. Chrm, Soc. Clwn. Conimun. 1986, 374-375. [ 141 K . Fujisawa, Y. Moro-oka, N. Kitajima. J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Conzmun. 1994, 623-624. [ I S ] The LhM2 unit in Scheme Ib i s a .suivhorse typical of systems completed by a n-conjugated chelate in the riding bridging mode (e.g. diamidoleiie or dithiolate) and recently investigated by
one of the authors (C. Mealli)"61. Many of the previous MO concepts can be easily extended to the present complexes where the ric1c.r is a pair of naked chalcogenide atoms. [ 161 C . Mealli. A. lenco, A. Anillo, S. Garcia-Granda. R . Obeso Rosete. Inorg. C h f w 1997, 36, 3724- 3729. [ I71 W. B. Tolman, Ace. Choi?. Rex 1997. 30, 227-237 and references therein. [IS] J. G. Brennan, T. Siegrist. S. M. Stuczynski. M. L. Steigcrwald, J. Am. Chetn. Soc. 1990. 112, 9233-9236; K. Matsumoto. C. Nishitani. M. Tadokoro, S. Okeya. J. Chcni. So(,. Drilfori Trrms. 1996, 3 3 3 5-3 3 36. [ 191 C.A. Ghilardi. S. Midollini. A. Orlandini, submitted to Inorg. Chern. Conimzin. 120) V. W. W. Yam, P. K. Y. Yeung. K. K. Cheung. J . Chem. Soc. Cheni. Commuri. 1995. 267269. 1211 A. Bencini, M. DiVaira. R. Morassi, P. Stoppioni, F. Mele. Polyhedron 1996, 15, 2079-2086. 1221 A. L. Ma. J. B. Thoden, L. F. Dahl. J. C/iem. Soc. Chrm.Conzmun. 1992. 1516-1518. 1231 (a) R . D. Adams, T. A. Wolfe. B. W. Eichorn. R . C. Haushalter, Po/y/iedron 1989. 8, 701; (b) D. Fenske. H. Fleischer. H. Krautsheid. J. Magull. C. Oliver, S. Weisberger, Z. Nuturf i w s c h . 1991, 46b, 1384. 1241 .H. Wolkers, K. Dehnicke. D. Fenske, A. Khassanov, S. S. Hafner, Actci CrystuNugr., See. C 1991, 47, 1627. [25] R. Mason. B. Law, D. M. P. Mingos. unpub/i.slzed ivork referenced in C. E. Briant, C. J. Gardner, T. S. A. Hor, N. D. Howells. D. M. P. Mingos. J. Chem Soc. Dalton. Tran.~.1984, 2645-2651. 1261 K. Teo, M. B. Hall. R. F. Fenske. L. F. Dahl, Inorg. Chrni. 1975: 14, 3103 3117. [27] L. DeKock, E. J. Baerends. A. Oskam, Inorg. (%em. 1983. 22; 4158 -4159. [28] L. DeKock, E. J. Baerends. R. Hengelmolen, Orguno/nctallics, 1984, 3, 289-292. (291 M. Capdevila, W. Clegg, P. Gonzalez-Duarte, A. Jarid, A. Lledos, Inorg. Cheni 1996,35,490-497. 1301 (a) R. Hoffmann. J. Chew. Phys. 1963. 3Y, 1397; (b) R. Hoffmann and W. N. Lipscomb, J. Clieni. Phys. 1962.36,2179; [c)R. Hoffmann and W. N. Lipscomb, J. C'hcw. Phys. 1962,37,3489. [31] C. Mealli. D. M . Proserpio. J. Cheni. E(h/c. 1990, 67. 399-402.
162
1 Moleculuv Clusters
[32] In the series [ ( M ~ ~ P ) ~ C O ( , ~ - X ) ~ C O ( Mthe ~ ~Se/Te P ) ~ ]derivatives ,[’*’ differ from those of the S derivatives having one Co-P bond within the plane MzX2 rather than perpendicular to it. Short contacts between the bulky terminal ligands and the more diffuse chalcogenide atoms can cause such a difference. [33] C. Bianchini, C . Mealli, A. Meli, M. Sabat, P. Zanello, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1987, 109, 185-198. [34] C . Mealli, D. M. Proserpio, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1990, 112, 5484-5496. [35] P. Barbaro, C. Bianchini, K. Linn, C. Mealli, A. Meli, F. Vizza, Inorg. Chim. Actu. 1990, 112, 5484-5496. [36] (a) M. R. Churchill, R. Bau, Znorg. Clzem. 1968, 7,2606; (b) G. Ciani, G. D. Alfonso, M. Freni, P. Romiti, A. Sironi, J. Organomet. Chem. 1978, 157, 199. [37] V. J. Johnston, F. W. B. Einstein, M. R. K. J. Pomeroy,J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1987,109,8111-8112. [38] By summarizing the arguments of reference 1341, one M-M annular bond stems from the interaction (2a*j.rrll)where, as in Fig. 1, 2a* is a combination of high lying metal hybrids. On squeezing the square along one diagonal, the lower la* (from the filled “tzg” sets) becomes the favored partner of the rill combination at the distal atoms. If the antibonding combination between the two latter FMOs rises enough in energy to be depopulated (here is the difference between 0 s and Re derivatives), then ring bonding stems from the donation of la’ into 7111.By focusing on the FMOs of the shortly separated metals, while la’ and 20 carticipate in ringbonding, the low-filled l a and the high-empty 2a*combinations are only apparently inert. In fact, together they are responsible for the new M-M truns-annular linkage. A similar description was proposed for the Fe-Fe linkage in Fe2(C0)9.[391 In contrast, no M-M bond seems possible in planar M2Xz skeletons with the electron counts of 6-12. In no case does the squeezing of the M-M diagonal (irrespective of the possible steric problems), push the bz antibonding combination between a * ( z 2 )and Xz-nll (refer again to Fig. 1) above the LUMO 4al so that the electrons can be poured from one level to the other. 1391 (a) C. Mealli, D. M. Proserpio, J. Organomet. Chem. 1990, 386, 203-208; (b) C. Mealli, J. Reinhold, E. Hunstock, New J. Chem. 1994, 18, 465-471. [40] D. A. Dobbs, R. G. Bergman, Inorg. Chem. 1994,33, 5329-5336. 1411 R. Hoffmann, Angew. Chenz. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1982,21, 71 1-724. [42] A. R. Pinhas, R. Hoffmann, Inorg. Chem. 1979, 18, 654-658. 1431 The participation of both the p7zI electrons pairs of X2-2 in a donations enables the consideration of the unit as an eight electron donor. Thus, in contrast with previous suggestions,[’*] 1 can be counted a 34 rather than a 32 electron complex. [44] R. B. Woodward, R. Hoffmann, Angew. Chern. Int. Ed. Engl. 1969, 8, 781. 1451 (a) C. Mealli, S. Midollini, L. Sacconi. Chem. Commun., 1975, 765-766; (b) C. Mealli, L. Sacconi, Inorg. Chem., 1982, 21, 2870-2874. [46] N. Kitajima, K. Fujisawa, C. Fujimoto, Y. Moro-oka, S. Hashimoto, T. Kitagawa, K. Toriumi, K. Tatsumi, A. Nakamura, J. A m . Chem. Soc. 1992, 114, 1277-1291. [47] C. J. Kramer, B. A. Smith, W. B. Tolman, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1996, 118, 11283-1 1287. [48] T. A. Albright, R. Hoffmann, J. C. Thibeault, D. L. Thorn, J. Am. Chem. Sor. 1979, If)!, 3801-3812. [49] J. Chatt, L. A. Duncanson, J. Chem. Soc. 1953, 2039. [50] When puckering is not accompanied by the shortening of the X-X distance (Scheme not shown), the level 2bl is not greatly affected energetically. Also in this case, there is a progressive involvement of X 2 - p q orbitals in a-bonding to the metals, but 2bl remains quite deep in energy as its Xz-a’ character is not magnified. The potential energy surface is consistently low mainly for this reason.[291 [51] M. Capdevila, Y. Carrasco, W. Clegg, R. A. Coxall, P. Gonziles-Duarte, A. Lledos, J. Sola, G. Ujaque, J. Chern. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1998, 597-598. [52] M. Capdevila, W. Clegg, R. A. Coxall, P. Gonziles-Duarte, M. Hamidi, A. Lledos. G. Ujaque, Inory. Chem. Commun. 1998,1,466-468. [53] G. Aullon, G. Ujaque, A. Lledos, S. Alvarez, P. Alemany, Inorg. Chem. 1998, 37, 804-813. 1541 S.-W. A. Fong, T. A. A. Hor, J. Chem. Soc. Dulton Trans., 1999, 639-651.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.10 Towards Transition Metal Clusters by Reaction of Simple Metal Carbonyls with Chalcogenides and Chalcogenolates Gerald Henkel and Sttlfirri Wei&riihrr
1.10.1 Introduction After the exciting development of the coordination chemistry of polynuclear transition metal complexes with sulfur, selenium and tellurium ligands over the past three decades driven, primarily, by their relevance as models for biologically active metal sites, special attention has been devoted to derivatives which contain CO groups as co-ligands in recent years. Besides their importance as a fundamental class of new complexes with unprecedented chemical and structural properties in general, the increasing interest in these compounds can also be traced back to potential applications such as catalysis, the use as precursors for semiconductors with low band-gaps as well as in photovoltaic or in IR detection applications.[’] The general subject has frequently been reviewed from different points of view,[21and the latest accounts, which focus primarily on selenium and tellurium complexes are precedented by reviews dealing more with sulfur-containing species. Within this context. the present article concentrates on transition metal cluster complexes of cobalt, iron and manganese with mixed chalcogen/carbonyl ligand spheres obtained by reaction of simple binary metal carbonyls with alkali-metal sulfides, alkali-metal thiolates or transition-metal thiolate complexes and their selenium or tellurium counterparts. With respect to the large body of complexes with mixed carbonyl/chalcogenide ligand spheres known today, the number of complexes containing chalcogenolate as well as carbonyl ligands is comparatively small. Examples for the latter type of compounds include [Fe2(SC2Hj)2(C0)g],L31 [Fe?(TeR)2(C0)6],[41 [Mn2(ER)?(C0)8] ( E = S, Se, Te),”] [Mn2(ER)3(CO),]- ( E = S, Se, Te),[5361[MnFe(SePh)3(CO)6],[6a’ [MnlCo( ) ~ ] , [ ~TePh)j] [Mn(EPh)2(C0)4]- (E = Te, Se)[s”.6a1[ C O ~ ( S C ~ H ~ ) ~ ( C O ( C0)8],[sa1 [MnzCo(SePh)5( CO)81,[6a1 [ Co5 (SCzH5)j(CO) [Cogs(SC2H5)4(CO)11],[91[Fe?(SC4H,)(EPh)(CO),]-( E = S, Se),“’] whereas the former type of
164
I Molecular Clusters
complexes are represented by species of general formula [M,Ey(CO)Z]"( M = Mn, Fe, Co; E = S, Se, Te; n = -2, -l,O, +1, +2, + 3 ) . In the following sections, we will discuss the results of our recent work in the field of manganese-, iron- and cobalt cluster complexes with mixed chalcogen/carbonyl ligand spheres, taking relevant complexes from the literature into account.
1.10.2 Synthetic aspects The reactions performed in our laboratory were carried out in sealed ampoules at temperatures above the normal-pressure boiling points of the solvents used. These conditions are often referred to as solvothermal conditions, a subject which has been discussed very recently by Sheldrick and Wachhold." This method was developed from the hydrothermal synthesis in water near critical conditions (T, = 374.1 "C, p,. = 221.2 bar), which has been the domain of geochemists and mineralogists with the aim to mimic the formation processes of minerals. In recent years, a pronounced trend to other solvents and substantially less drastic reaction conditions] with temperatures in the range of or slightly above the normal-pressure boiling points, under equilibrium conditions, in sealed reaction vessels has occurred. With these conditions, the reactions can be carried out in thick-walled glass ampoules, and the progress of the reactions can be controlled easily (see [I I]). Generally] the reactants are placed in glass tubes together with small amounts of an appropriate solvent (e.g. methanol or acetonitrile) under strictly anaerobic conditions. After mixing the slurries by shaking, the mixtures are frozen with liquid nitrogen followed by sealing the glass tubes in vucuo with a flame of appropriate temperature. Another important difference to more classical synthetic procedures is the use of very small amounts of solvent. In typical cases, only a maximum of 5 ml of solvent is added to 5-10 mmol of solid reactants. As a result, saturated solutions are obtained in equilibrium with solid material, which dissolves continuously depending on the progress of the reaction and the crystallization of the reaction products. The scope of our work extends to soluble molecular complexes without polymeric character. In this case, it is necessary to work in saturated solutions. If anionic species are formed, high concentrations of appropriate counter-cations (e.g. quaternary ammonium cations) favor crystallization. In most cases, the starting materials used for solvothermal synthesis (as well as for 'normal' reactions) are of simple composition (e.g. binary metal halides, metal chalcogenides or polychalcogenides and simple metal carbonyls). In a specific approach to synthesize mixed chalcogen/carbonyl cluster complexes with unprecedented chemical and structural properties] we start from polynuclear
1.10 Toiiarcl.v Transition Metal C‘1ustei.s
165
transition metal-chalcogenolate complexes in order to make use of the pre-defined metal framework as a building block for clusters of higher nuclearities. In many of our reactions, 2-propane-substituted chalcogenide ions are used as ligands because they can also act as a source for ‘naked’ chalcogenide ions. This is important if ligands are needed which are able to form a larger number of bridging functions than chalcogenolate ligands can do. Sometimes, it is desirable to reproduce the compounds obtained by solvothermal procedures under atmospheric pressure in open reaction vessels. However, the composition of the products formed under solvothermal conditions often differs significantly from the molar ratios of the reactants. In these cases, the reaction conditions have to be optimized in order to improve the yields, and this can more easily be performed by using conventional synthetic procedures. Sometimes, however, it is not possible to ‘translate’ the hydrothermal reaction path into conventional solution chemistry, because the products or some intermediates are not stable under these conditions. Similar difficulties often occur if a reaction leading to a specific complex is optimized by adjusting the reactant ratios according to the product composition. In these cases, reaction pathways involving more complicated intermediates have to be assumed.
1.10.3 Topological aspects The metal ions in mixed chalcogen/carbonyl complexes of manganese, iron and cobalt are often surrounded by five ligand donor functions (normally a { E ~ ( C O ) I } donor set) in a square-pyramidal fashion. A typical example is the binuclear complex [FeZS2(CO),]. which contains a disulfide ligand shown in Fig. 1.[‘*dl In several instances, a trigonal-bipyramidal coordination, as observed in [Fe(C0)5], is preferred instead[l3”-“](Fig. 2). In some cases, however, the coordi-
Figure 1. The butterfly-shaped complex [Fe*&(CO)h]with squarepyramidal coordination sites.
166
1 Molecular Clusters
nation number is expanded to six. The additional ligand then defines the second apex of a pseudo-octahedral ligand environment. This situation is illustrated in Fig. 3 showing the molecular structure of [Mnz(TePh)2(C0)8].[5"1 In polynuclear complexes, the square-pyramidal { ME*(C0)3] sub-units can be linked via common corners or edges. If two of these building blocks are connected via a common E...Eedge with conservation of the coordination number 5 , the
Figure 3. Molecular structure of [Mn:,(TePh)z(CO)s].
I . I0 Towardo Transition Metal Clusters
167
typical 'butterfly'-shaped structure represented by [Fez(CO)&] is formed (see Fig. 1 ) . This fundamental structural motif is the dominant feature in a large number of polynuclear complexes. From another point of view, the butterfly-type structure is an incomplete bioctahedral system with a common face and a vacant bridge. This vacancy has been discussed in terms of a bent bond defined by two orbitals centered on both metals, respectively, and extending in the direction of the vacant In very special cases, the square-pyramidal ligand arrangements in these butterfly-type sub-units are distorted towards trigonal-bipyramidal coordination sites. Within the picture of the bent bond, this transition would disrupt the metal-metal bond and should be directly attributable to electronic variations within the ligand spheres of the metal atoms. In the next sections, we will discuss these topological aspects in more detail taking recent results from our laboratory into account.
1.10.4 Complexes containing up to two metal atoms These compounds do not belong to the family of cluster complexes in a classical sense, but they are mentioned here for systematic reasons. For the synthetic chemist, they are very useful precursors for building up complexes of higher nuclearities. The first mononuclear carbonyl compound of cobalt, iron or manganese known was the pentacarbonyl complex [Fe(CO)51" 3d-e1 with a trigonal-bipyramidal ligand field (see Fig. 2). Though related electroneutral species of cobalt and manganese are not known due to a strict observance of the 18-electron-rule in these cases, the monoanionic manganese derivative [Mn(C0)5]- has also been described as a trigonalbipyramidal species." 3F,g1 Recently, however, it has been shown that [Mn(C0)5]- is able to adopt the square-pyramidal geometry in its [PPh4JS salt as well (Fig. 4). Within the whole series of complex species [M(CO)(]"-, this remarkable pentacarbonyl complex is the only example with a square-pyramidal ligand field known so far. It is formed by a disproportionation reaction of [Mn2(CO)lo] with Na2Se2 together with [Mn3Sel(C0)9I2- in methanolic solution (see below).['41 The coordination polyhedron of [Mn(C0)5]- is a regular square pyramid of nearly perfect symmetry (point group C4\) and as such possesses a spatial distribution of the CO ligands similar to that of the protonated hexacoordinated compound [HMn(CO)5][l'I. Anionic hexacoordinated complex anions of formula [Mn(EPh)2(CO)4)- ( E = Te, Se)[5"36"1 do also exist. 4 large fraction of the binuclear mixed chalcogen/carbonyl transition metal complexes of iron and manganese contain the {M2E,I(C0)6}core with the butterflytype structure (n = 2) or substructure (n == 3, see Section 1.10.3). As an example of a complex with thiolate ligands, the structure of [Fel(SC~H7)2(C0)6]"61 is shown in
168
I Moleculur Clusters
Figure 4. The square-pyramidal complex anion [Mn(C0)5]- in crystals of [Ph4P][Mn(C0)s1.
Figure 5. This complex was obtained by solvothermal reaction of [Fe2(CO)9]with NaSC3H7 in methanol. In contrast to [Fe2S2(C0)6],an S-S bonding interaction is lacking leading to S...S distances as long as 2.919(1) A.The Fe-Fe distance is 2.513(1) A in length indicating a metal-metal bond. The organic residues of the bridging ligands are orientated in an equidirectional sense with respect to the Fe...Fe axis. The {Fe2S2(C0)6} core of [Fe2(SC3H7)2(C0)6] finds its counterpart in the structurally related compound [Fez( SC2H5)2(CO)6].r31 Within the group of binuclear chalcogen/carbonyl complexes, another type of general formula [Mn2(ER)2(CO)8]( E = S[5d1,Ser5h.c1,Te15”]) is established by manganese (see Fig. 3). Besides these chalcogenolate-containing species, corre-
Figure 5. The binuclear complex [Fe2(SGH7MCO)d
1.10 Toilwrd Trmnsition Metcil Clusters
169
Figure 6. Structure of [Mn2Te2(C01s]'-in crystds of (Ph~Pjz[ MnlTe>(COix]
sponding chalcogenide compounds are also known. The complex anions IMnlTe?(CO)g and (Mn,Te( Te2)(CO)s]'- were obtained by solvothermal reaction of [Mnz(CO)lo]with Na2Te2 or [Ph4P]:Te4, respectively, and crystallized as tetraphenylphosphonium Their structures are shown in Figs. 6 and 7. Both species contain manganese as 18-electron-systems in octahedral { Mn(CO)4Tez} ligand fields with telluride (I MnlTe2(CO)s]'-) or mixed telluride/ditelluride ([MnzTe(Te2)(C0)8I2-) ligands in bridging positions. Due to the larger spatial demand of the ditelluride ligand, the Mn. . .Mn distance rises from 4.024( 1) in the former to 4.560( 1 ) A in the latter compound, indicating no metal-metal bonds. About 5% of the [Mn2Te(Te2)(CO)s12- anions in the comhowever. show a different coordination pound [Ph4P]21Mn?Te(Te?)(CO)g].MeOH, pattern of the Te?'- ligand. In this case: only one Te atom is involved in the bridge without any coordination function of the other one. A similar bridging situation has been observed in [Fe,Te( Te2)(CO),j12-['''. A related manganese complex with two diselenide bridges has been identified in crystals of [Ph4P]21Mn2(Se~)2(CO)~].C4H1~~0, and a derivative containing Se4'- is also known.["] In contrast to the butterfly-type structure with its characteristic nonplanar central M2E2 heterocycle, the Mn2Tez core of [Mn2Te2(CO)gl2- is nearly perfectly planar.
Figure 7. Structurc of [Mn2(Te,lTeiCOixl'- i n ciystnls of [Ph3P]2[Mn2Te(Tei.,C0 MeOH
170
1 Moleculur Clusters
0161
A third type of binuclear chalcogen/carbonyl complex is defined by three chalcogen atoms in bridging positions and six carbonyl ligands bonded terminally to the metal atoms. The general formula of these complexes is [Mnz(ER)3(CO),]- ( E = S,[6b,20,211, Se[6”,221, Te[5a1).A mixed-metal derivative of formula [MnFe(SePh)3(CO),][“l is also known. They also contain the metal atoms in octahedral ligand environments. Both coordination octahedra share a common face, which is defined by the three chalcogen atoms. Figure 8 shows the structure of [Mn2(SeC3H7)3(CO)6lpas a typical example for this complex type. The complex anion was obtained by reaction of [Mn2(SeC3H7)6l2- with [Mn2(CO)101 and crystallized as tetraphenylphosphonium salt under solvothermal conditions.[221 The overall structure is an extension of the butterfly-type structure with a third chalcogen atom occupying the vacant bridging site. In this respect, there are striking structural similarities between [Fe2(SC3H7)2(C0)6](Fig. 5 ) lacking this bridge and [Mn2(SeC2H5)3(C0)6Ip.Both complexes are electron-precise with respect to the 18electron-rule, but in the latter case, no metal-metal bond is required in accordance with the long Mn...Mn distance of 3.294(1) A. All three organic residues of the bridging ligands are orientated in an equidirectional sense with respect to the Mn. . .Mn axis.
1.10.5 Complexes containing three metal atoms Within this class of complexes, the metal atoms define triangular frames. With the exception of [ MnzCo( TePh)5(C0)8][5“1 and [ M ~ ~ C O ( S ~ P ~ ) ~ ( Clinear O)~][~”],
1.10 Towards Transition Metal Clusters
171
Figure 9. The complex anion [ F e ~ T e j C O ) ~In] ' crystals ~ of [EtdN]l[Fe;Te(COh]
complexes are not known so far. In the case of cobalt and iron, only species with chalcogenide or chalcogenolate ligands are known, whereas in the case of manganese - besides purely inorganic complexes mixed chalcogenide/chalcogenolate species do also exist. Of particularly widespread occurrence are the triangular complexes of general ( E = S, Se),'"] [Co*FeE(C0)9] ( E = S, Se, Te),[231 formula [CO~E(CO)~)] [CoFe2E(C0)9]'/'- ( E = S, Se, Te)[231,[Fe3E(CO)9]Z- ( E = S, Se, Te),[24.471 [Fe3EZ(CO),] ( E = S, Se: Te)[251and [Mn3E2(C0)9l2- ( E = S, Se),r26,'41 [FeZMnTel(CO)10 and [FelMnSe:,( C0)9]-,[23d1 respectively. As examples, the structures of the iron-containing species [Fe3Te(CO)912 and [Fe,Se,(CO),] are shown in Figs. 9 and 10. In both cases, the 18-electron-rule is obeyed resulting in three ([Fe3Te(CO)9]'-) and two ([ Fe3Sel(CO)g]) metal-metal bonds, respectively. ~
Figure 10. The complex (FelSe2(CO)9].
172
1 Moleculur Clusters
Figure 11. The complex anion [FelSeH(CO)g]-in crystals of [Ph4P I [ F ~ ~ S ~ H ( C1. O ) Y
As a consequence, the metal framework of [Fe3Te(C0)9l2- is a regular triangle, whereas that of [Fe$ez(CO)g] derives from a metal square with one corner being unoccupied. The triangular complexes of the type [Fe3E(CO)912- ( E = S, Se) can be protonated to form [Fe3E(CO)gHI-- species. They contain a hydrido ligand bridging one edge of the Fe triangle.[271As an example, Fig. 11 shows the structure of Complexes of this type are [Fe3Se(CO)gH]- in crystals of [Ph4P][Fe3Se(CO)gH].[27b1 accessible by reaction of mixed chalcogenide/carbonyl complexes with trifluoromethanesulfonic acid in methylene or by solvothermal reaction of binary transition metal carbonyls with simple chalcogenides (Na2S2, Na2Se and NazTe2 respectively) in alkaline s ~ l u t i o n . [ ~ ~ ~ ~ " ~ The hydrido bridge reduces the overall symmetry of the cluster complex by widening the corresponding Fe-Fe distance from the unbridged value of ca. 2.63 A up to the bridged one of 2.72 A. The corresponding {FezSe(C0)6H}framework consists of two trigonal-bipyramidal {FeSe(CO)3H} sub-units with H and Se defining the common edge being in axial and equatorial positions, respectively. Consequently, the substructure does not possess the butterfly-type geometry, which allows for a bent metal-metal bond. It is also possible to synthesize trinuclear complexes with two hydrogen bridges by reaction of mixed chalcogenide/carbonyl complexes with trifluoromethanesulfonic acid under specific In this case, one metal atom is surrounded by a set of six and the other two by a set of five ligands. Compared with the electron-precise compound [Fe3Sez(CO)g],the related complex anion [Mn3Se2(CO)g12-has only 49 valence electrons and thus falls short of the value requested by the 18-electron-rule (PSEP theory[281)by one. The manga-
1.10 Towards Transition Metal Clusters
Figure 12. Structure of [Mn3Se2(CO)OI'- in crystals of [Ph4P]2[Mn?Se2(CO)q].thf
113
M
nese species has been obtained as the oxidized component of the disproportionation reaction of [Mnl(CO)lo]with NazSel (see Section 1.10.4) and characterized as its dark-red tetraphenylphosphonium salt."41 The molecular structure is depicted in Fig. 12. The odd number of valence electrons is manifested by the paramagnetic behavior (pefr= 1.8 p, for LPh4P]2[Mn3Se2(CO)9]at 100 K). The heavy atom framework is a slightly distorted square pyramid with alternating Mn and Se atoms occupying the base and a third Mn atom defining the top. While the heavy atom framework of the 50-electron-species [ Fe?Se2(CO)g](see Fig. 10) is of comparable geometry, the carbonyl ligands around the metal atoms on top of the (M.iSe?} pyramids have different spatial orientations. Based on these observations and a number of other indicators such as Mn-Se bond lengths and formal oxidation states, the unusual contact C(7).. .Mn( 1 ) has been interpreted in terms of a novel unsymmetric carbonyl bridge connecting Mn( 1) and Mn(3), which is lacking in [Fe3Sez(C0)9]. The manganese atoms are surrounded by three carbonyl and two selenide ligands each in a square-pyramidal fashion if the weak interaction of the asymmetric C O bridge (Mn(l)-C(7): 2.726(7) A) is neglected. On the other hand, Mn( 1 j has a distorted octahedral ligand sphere if this bridge is considered as a bond. The binuclear { Mn2Sez(CO)(,) sub-unit containing Mn(2) and Mn(3) adopts the butterfly-type structure. In contrast to [Fe3E?(CO)g]( E = S, Se: Te) with trigonal-bipyramidal coordination of Fe(3) (see Fig. lo), the [Fe3Sz(CO)g] component of the 1 : 1 adduct of composition [Fe2S2(C0)6][Fe3S2(CO)9] has a structure similar to that of [ Mn3Se?(CO)9]z-[291 and thus adopts an alternative conformation. After re-evaluation of the packing situation, it was concluded that both components form charge-transfer adducts such that trinuclear [Fe3S?(C0)9]and binuclear [Fe2(S?)(CO)G]molecules are associated alternatively uici intermolecular S . . . S bridges, which are 3.157 A in
174
1 Molecuhr Clusters
Figure 13. Structure of the adduct [Fe2(S2)(CO)h][FejS2(C0)9].
lengths, to form one-dimensional endless strands (Fig. 13). The structure of the trinuclear [Fe3S2(C0)9] component has been re-interpreted in terms of the novel asymmetric carbonyl bridge recognized for the first time in [Mn3Se2(C0)9I2-, and its occurrence here has been traced back to a transfer of electron density from the trinuclear component to the disulfide group of the binuclear complex. The different electronic situation may also explain why the Mossbauer spectrum of [Fe3S2(C0)9][Fe~( s2)(co)6] differs significantly from that of the individual complexes [Fe&(C0)9] and [Fez(S2)(CO)6].[30i Based on a large body of experimental data, it has been concluded that an asymmetric carbonyl bridge of the type observed in [Mn3Se2(C0)9I2- might be established in complexes of general formula [ M ~ E z ( C O )(~E]=~ S, Se, Te; z = -2, - l , O , + l ) if the two metal atoms in the base of the M3E2 pyramid are electronically non-equivalent. In this case, the metal atom in the higher oxidation state is probably stabilized by a ( pn),-o-dM interaction. The change from the non-bridged ([FelE2(CO)9],Fig. 10) to the bridged state ([Mn3Se2(C0)9I2-, Fig. 12) is accompanied by a 30" rotation of the apical {M(CO)3}fragment around its local symmetry axis followed by a subsequent bend of this axis by about 15" in the direction of M( 1). At the same time, the coordination polyhedron changes from the trigonal bipyramid to the square pyramid. By consequent use of these arguments, it was also possible to solve the problem of the metal distribution in [MnFe2Se2(CO)g]-,[23d1 a related Mn/Fe mixed-metal complex anion possessing the characteristic asymmetric carbonyl bridge identified for the first time in [Mn~Se2(C0)9]2-.['41 The metal positions in the base of the M3Se2 pyramid are most probably filled in an ordered fashion with manganese (position M( 1)) and iron (position M(2)). An interesting extension of the [Mn3Se2(C0)9I2- complex anion has been obtained in the reaction system [MnZ(CO)1o]/Na~Se2/[Ph4P]Clunder solvothermal conditions in methanol. The trinuclear compound [Mn3Se2(SeMe)(C0)9j2-derives from [Mn3Se2(C0)9I2- by addition of a methaneselenolate ligand and removal of one electron from the manganese frame.['41 The electron-precise complex is shown
1.I0 Towards Trunsition Metul Clusters
175
Figure 14. The complex anion [MnJSe?(SeMe)(COjg]’- i n crystals of jPhJP]2[MniSe2iSeMei(C~~y]
in Fig. 14. The additional methaneselenolate ligand (Se(3))bridges the non-bonding Mn(2). .Mn(3) edge of the manganese triangle. Due to a total of 52 valence electrons, only one Mn-Mn bond (Mn(I)-Mn(3)) is needed to achieve the noble gas configuration. This bond is now stabilized by a semi-bridging CO ligand. Each manganese atom is surrounded by six ligands in a pstwboctahedrdl fashion. Both sub-units are extenbinuclear { Mn2(,n-Se)i(CO)hJand { Mn2(pu-Se)1(p-CO)Se(C0)5$ sions of the butterfly-type structure with a third ligand atom occupying the vacant bridging site. From a structural point of view, the {Mn?(p-Se)3(CO)h}sub-unit (see (CO)~]~[~ is closely related to the binuclear complex anion [ M I I ~ ( S ~ C ~ H ~ ) ~ Fig. 8). ln this context, it should also be mentioned that the mixed sulfur/carbonyl complex [MnlS2(SH)(C0)9]’ with coordination properties very similar to those observed in 1 MniSe?(SeMe)(CO)s]’-has recently been prepared.[311It is also possible to cleave the CO bridge as well as the corresponding Mn-Mn bond in this trinuclear complex by replacing the bridging sulfide ligands by disulfide groups. The corresponding complex ion [Mn3(S2)2(SH)(C0)9I2-shown in Fig. 15 was obtained by solvothermal reaction of NaIS? with [MnZ(CO)l o ] in ethanol.[211 The hydrogen atom of the sulfhydryl group, however, could not be located by Xray methods. Another route to [ Mni(S2)2(SH)(CO)9]2p was occasionally found by reaction of [Mn?(SH),(CO)6]-with [NiCI 1 H24NZSZJ under solvothermal conditions S H ) (revealed CO)~] in methanol. The crystal structure of [ P ~ ~ P ] ~ [ M ~ I ~ ( S ~ ) ~ (clearly the position of hydrogen within the SH (see Fig. 15). Each isolated Mn center has a psrudo-octahedral { S3(CO)3) ligand environment with a total valence electron count of 18. The two disulfide ligands are coordinated in different modes. One of them is bonded as a ,u3-q’,q ’ , q ’ , the other one as a p3-q’. q l , i12 bridging ligand.
176
1 Moleculur Clusters
In contrast to iron and manganese, the number of trinuclear cobalt complexes with 2-propane thiolate or with is comparatively small. The reaction of [CO~(CO)S] C3H7SSC3H7 in methanol under solvothermal conditions afforded the electroneutral complex [ C O ~ ( S C ~ H ~ ) ~ (which CO)~ contains ], a triangle of cobalt Its structure is shown in Fig. 16. A similar complex with ethanthiolate ligands has been obtained by conventional synthetic strategies."] The overall structural principles of this complex type can be described as follows. The metal-ligand framework is a trigonal prism with corners defined by the five sulfur donor functions of the isopropanethiolate ligands and one carbon atom of a CO ligand. The metal atoms are shifted from the centers of the
Figure 16. Structure of crystalline
[C~~(SC~H~)S(CO)~I.
1.10 Towards Transition Metal Clusters
177
Figure 17. Structure of crystalline IColTe2 f C 0 )I 1 1.
quadratic faces of the prism slightly towards the axially bonded three remaining CO ligands. One of the three cobalt atoms has a pseudo-square-pyramidal {S,(CO)) ligand set, whereas the other ones are in pseudo-square-pyramidal {S3(C 0 )z ) ligand environments.
1.10.6 Complexes containing four metal ions The reaction of [Co2(CO)8],Na2Te2 and [Ph4P]Cl in methanolic solution under solvothermal conditions afforded black-violet needles of the tetranuclear cluster complex [Co4Te2(CO)11].which is shown in Fig. 17.[341This compound has been discussed as a possible intermediate during the formation of the undecanuclear complex anion [Co~~Te-i(CO)lol’(see Section 1.10.9, Fig. 32). Its trapezoidal metal arrangement is in accordance with the 1 8-electron-rule, which predicts three Co-Co single bonds for the total of 66 valence electrons observed here. Similar metal frameworks have also been observed in structurally related Sb and Bi complexes.[351The four Co atoms are bridged by two p4-Te ligands and additionally bonded to a total of ten terminal and one bridging C O groups resulting in square-pyramidal {Te?(CO)T1 ligand spheres. The cluster complex contains two butterfly-type sub-units, which share a common carbonyl and the two telluride ligands. Other tetranuclear complexes of formula [M2M12E’(CO)11 1 ( e $1 M, M’ = Fe, E = S;[361M. M’ = Ru, E = Te;[371M, M’ = Ru, E = Se;[381 M = Ru. M‘ = Fe, E = Te;[39”1M = Co, M’ = Fe, E = S [39b1) have four metalmetal bonds due to a total of 62 iM = Fe or Ru) or 64 ( M = Co) valence electrons,
178
I Moleculur Clusters
Figure 18. Structure of crystalline [F~&(CO)I11.
respectively. As an example, the structure of [ F ~ ~ S ~ ( C is O )shown ~ I ] in Fig. 18. Square-planar cluster complexes of general formula [ C O ~ E ~ ( C O ( E) = ~ ~S,] Se, Te) that possess only ten carbonyl ligands are also known.[401The structure of [Co4Se2(CO)lo]is shown in Fig. 19. The complex [Mn4(S2)2(C0)15]contains two disulfide ligands and has been obtained by oxidation of [Mn2(SSnMe3)2(CO)S]["' Similar to [Mn3(S2)2(CO)g(SH)I2 (see Chapter 1 . 1 0 3 , the disulfide groups are coordinated in different coordination modes. Each manganese atom is coordinated pseudo-octahedrally by six ligands, but the coordination spheres of the individual atoms differ with respect to the total number of sulfur ligands. Two of them are coordinated to three sulfur atoms, the other ones to two and one, respectively. The family of tetranuclear complexes ~
Figure 19. Structure of crystalline ICo4Se2(CO)1ol.
1.10 Toivuru's Trunsition Metal Clusters
179
Y
Figure 20. The complex anion [Fe4Te2(C0),4]' In crystals of [ P hPI2 [FejTezi C 0 )I 4 1.
[Fe4E4(C0)12] ( E = S. Se, Te) also contain pseudo-octahedrally coordinated metal atoms in { Fe(CO)3Ej} site^.[^^"'^] They can be obtained by thermally or photochemically induced dimerization of [Fe2(E2)(CO)6].[42'1 Another interesting complex was obtained by solvothermal reaction of [Mnz(CO)lo] and Na2Te2 in ethanolic solutionC2 and isolated as [Ph4P]z[Mn4(Te2)3(CO)131. The complex anion [Mn4(T ~ ~ ) ~ ( C O I Iconsists ~ ] ' - of one {Mn(C0)4} and three {Mn(C0)3}fragments, which are bridged by three ditelluride groups acting as bridging ligands in different coordination modes. A variety of other tetranuclear cluster complexes contain two binuclear fM2E?(CO)h}fragments ( M = Mn, Fe, Co), which possess the more or less regular tC4H9[43h1), butterfly-type structure. Examples are [Fe4(SR)2S(COj12]( R = [Fe4(C2S4)(C0)12],[441 and [Fe4Se2(Sez)(CO)1212-.[4s1 In contrast to these species, 1 FeJTel(C0),412- '27c.461 contains only one binuclear { M2Ez(C0)6}fragment which deviates significantly from the regular butterfly-type structure. The structure of [Fe4Te2(C0)14l2- is shown in Fig. 20. The central (FezTe2(CO)h} fragment does not have the ideal butterfly-type structure due to a shift from the square-pyramidal towards a predominantly trigonal-bipyramidal coordination of iron. Each telluride ligand is bonded not only to both iron atoms within the distorted butterfly-type sub-unit but also to an iron atom of a trigonal-pyramidal { Fe(CO)4} fragment completing its ligand environment by forming a nearly perfect FeTe(C0)d trigonal bipyramid. The coordination of two { M(CO),} fragments by the telluride ligands of a {Fe?Tez(CO)h}sub-unit in a direction which coincides with the Te. . .Te axis is a unique feature in complex chemistry. The specific bonding situation of the telluride ligands might be the reason for the unusual coordination geometry observed within the butterfly-type sub-unit. Furthermore, this ligand arrangement might be the result of metal-metal interactions, which differ from those present in but terfly-type units of conventional design. An interesting singularity in polynuclear chalcogen/carbonyl complexes is the tetranuclear iron compound [Fe4Te(CO)1 6 1 ~ ,[471 which has no metal-metal bonds.
180
I Molecular Clusters
The four {Fe(C0)4}fragments of [Fe4Te(C0)16]~are bonded to a central telluride ion in a tetrahedral fashion. The resulting coordination of iron is trigonalbipyramidal with tellurium defining a common axial position for each {FeTe(C0)4} fragment.
1.10.7 Complexes containing five metal ions Within this group, the number of complexes known so far is comparatively small. Recently, the complex anion [FesTe4(CO)1 4 1 ~ - has been described that consists of two { Fe2Te2(C0)6}fragments adopting the butterfly-type structure. Both fragments are bonded to a central {Fe(C0)2}unit via all four tellurium atoms defining apseudooctahedral { FeTe4(C0)2} coordination site with the carbonyl groups in adjacent positions.[481The central {FeTe4(CO)2}unit can also be replaced by a square-planar {NiS4) coordination site leading to the complex anion [Fe4NiS4(CO)12]2-.124h3 Another very interesting complex anion can formally be derived from [ FesTe4(CO)1,l2- by removal of one telluride ion from each of the two butterfly sub-units and replacing those remaining by sulfide ions resulting in the formation of [FeSS2(C0)14]2-.[24h,491 Due to the loss of two telluride ligands, the total number of 86 valence electrons observed in [FesTe4(C0)14I2- is reduced to a value of 76. This drastic decrease is compensated for by the formation of four additional Fe-Fe bonds in [FesS2(CO)14I2- such that an electron-precise complex anion is formed again. This sulfur-containing species is shown in Fig. 21. The novel cluster contains two trinuclear { Fe3S(CO)gS}sub-units which can be structurally derived from the class of [Fe3E(C0),l2- complexes (see Fig. 9) by replacing one CO ligand by a
Figure 21. The complex anion [ F e ~ S z ( C 0 ) ~ 4in] ~crystals of [Ph4Pl2[FesS2(CO)141.
1.10 Tou~urclsTrunsition Metul Clusters
181
Fiqure 22. Structure of [Coj(SEt)i(CO)lo]
chalcogenide ion. Both sub-units are linked viu a common metal atom and thus share a common fFe(C0)zEz)fragment. A pentanuclear mixed chalcogen/carbonyl cluster complex with ethanethiolate ligpnds is the cobalt-containing species [Coj(SEt)j ( C 0 )101, which was structurally characterized by X-ray methods[8J(Fig. 22). The complex contains a trinuclear (Co,(SEt),(CO)j} sub-unit, which is very from a strucclosely related to the trinuclear complex anion [CO~(SC,H,)S(CO),] tural point of view (see Fig. 16, Section 1.10.5). Here again, the metal-ligand frame is a distorted trigonal prism, but now the six corners are defined by four sulfur atoms and two CO ligands defining triangular (S3 f and {S(CO)z}faces, respectively. The main difference on going from [ C O J ( S C J H ~ ) ~ ( CtoO{Co,(SEt)4(CO)j) )~] is the exchange of one thiolate ligand by CO. The trinuclear sub-unit is linked to a binuclear {Coz(SEt)(C0)5 } fragment vitr those three thiolate ligands which define the triangular sulfur face of the prism.
1.10.8 Complexes containing six metal ions With the sole exception of [Fe$3eh(C0)12]2-.hexanuclear mixed chalcogen/ carbonyl cluster complexes of iron and manganese are not known. The structure of is shown in Fig. 23. [Fec,Sec,(CO)lz]'- in crystals of [PPN]2[FehSe6(C0)12][501 This compound has recently been obtained by solvothermal reaction of [Fe(C0)5] with NalSez in methanolic solution and characterized with X-ray crystallographic methods. The complex anion contains two butterfly-type (FezSez(C0)h) sub-units which are bonded to a central planar {FezSe?) fragment. The iron atoms within
182
1 Molecular Clusters
these fragments achieve a tetrahedral ligand environment completely defined by inorganic selenide ions. Prior to our work, the same cluster complex has been isolated as [Ph4P]2[FegSeg(CO)12],r24b3 and the sulfur-containing derivative [FegSg(C0)12I2is also known.[511 In the last paragraph of the previous section, the pentanuclear complex [Cog(SEt)5(C0)10]( Fig. 22) was described as a species containing the trinuclear {Co,(SEt)4(C0)5) sub-unit. Based on the same sub-unit and extending the binuclear {Co,(SEt)(C0)5)fragment towards the trinuclear unit {Co,S(CO)g), the hexanuclear mixed sulfide/thiolate/carbonyl complex [Cogs(SEt)4(CO)111 could also be obtained.[’] Its structure is shown in Fig. 24. In contrast to its CO-rich congener, the hexanuclear mixed sulfide/thiolate/ carbonyl complex [ C O & ( S C ~ H ~ ) ~ O (1- CisOcharacterized )~ by its higher sulfur and drastically smaller CO content. The novel cluster anion was obtained by solvosolution and thermal reaction of [Co2(Co)S] with [ C O ~ ( S C ~ Hin~ )methanolic ~]
Figure 24. Structure of [CO ~S(SE~)~(CO)IO].
I . 10 Towards Trunsition Mctul Clusters
183
Figure 25. The complex anion [CogS?(S'Pr),o(CO)2]-in crystals of [ Ph4P][Co6S?(S'Pr)10 (CO)?1.
characterized as tetraphenylphosphomium salt.[521The structure containing several unprecedented features is shown in Fig. 25. The six cobalt atoms define a common plane. They are grouped in pairs of regular triangles and arranged such that a central metal square is formed. This metal square is capped from both sides by two quadruply bridging sulfide ions, which form a square-bipyramidal {CoqSl) cage. Both edges of the metal square, which connect the triangles, are bridged by 2propanethiolate ligands. In addition, the edges of the triangles, which do not belong to the metal square, are bridged by two 2-propanethiolate ligands each. As a result, the four central Co atoms are surrounded exclusively by five sulfur donor functions in a square-pyramidal fashion. The outer Co atoms have four thiolate ligands. They expand their ligand spheres towards square-pyramidal { CoS4(CO)} coordination sites by binding an additional axial CO ligand each. Within the whole class of complexes described in this article, this is the first example for a cluster complex that contains a butterfly-type substructure completely defined by sulfur donor atoms. They derive from the typical {MzE2(C0)6} fragments by replacement of all six CO ligands by -SC3H7 groups such that the { C O ~ S ~ ( S C ~unit H ~is) formed. ~} Both butterfly-type { C O ~ S ~ ( S C ~units H ~ pres)~) ~ ( C the O)~ sulfur ] - atoms of their cyclic Co2S2 frameent in [ C O ~ S ~ ( S C ~ H ~ ) ~share works as well as the axially bonded thiolate groups. As has been the case with the penta- and hexanuclear complexes [Coj(SEt)5(CO)lo] (see Fig. 22, Section 1.10.7)[s1and [ C ~ ~ S ( S E ~ ) ~ ( C (see O )Fig. I I ] 24, this Section),['] respectively, the two identical trinuclear { C O ~ S ~ ( S C ~ H ~sub-units )~CO} are very closely related to the trinuclear complex of [cO6s2(sC3H~)~o(Co)2]~ [ C O ~ ( S C ~ H ~ ) ~from ( C Oa) ~structural ] point of view (see Fig. 16, Section 1.10.5). The metal-ligand framework of each sub-unit is a distorted trigonal prism, but now all six corners of the prism are occupied by sulfur donor functions. These trigonal prisms share a common edge defined by the sulfide ions. The axial ligands are thio-
184
I Moleculur Clusters Sei6i
Figure 26. The complex anion [Fe&Seg(SMe)2]'- 111 crystals of (PhCH2NEtiI4[Fe+3ey(SMe)2].
late groups for the Co atoms belonging to the central metal square or CO groups for the other cobalt atoms. Although the overall structure of this complex is unprecedented in coordination chemistry, a nearly identical metal arrangement has been observed in hexanuclear iron complex anions of formula [Fe6Es(SR)2I3--( E = S; R = 'Bu, Et,IS3]CH2Ph, Me,[54iE = Se, R = Me, CH2Ph[551).The structure of [Fe6Ses(SMe)2I4- is shown C O ) ~ ] - the , coordination of the in Fig. 26. In contrast to [ C O ~ S ~ ( S C ~ H ~ ) , O (however, metal atoms is tetrahedral resulting in a different ligand distribution, and the higher oxidation state of iron (average value +2.67), as compared to Co (average value +2.17), requires a higher sulfide content. A hexanuclear chalcogen/carbonyl compound of cobalt containing no thiolate S,] Se), is shown in Fig. 27 for E = S[561.The ligands, [ C O ~ E ~ ( E ~ ) ( C(O E )=I ~ S~) cluster complex is assembled from two identical trinuclear { C O ~ S ( C O ) ~sub-units which share the S atoms of the disulfide ligand. They possess principle features already known from the [Fe3E(C0)sl2- ( E = S, Se, Te) series of complexes (see Fig. 9, Section 1.10.5).
Figure 27. Structure of crystalline ~ ~ ~ 6 ~ 2 ( ~ 2 ) 2 ( ~ ~ ) 1 4 ~ ~
The last part of this section is devoted to complexes, which comprise an octahedron of cobalt atoms inscribed into a cube of chalcogenide ions. The octahedral Co faices thus are capped by chalcogen atoms, and the cobalt atoms form additional bonds to exogenous CO ligands resulting in square-pyramidal { CoE4(CO)1 coordination sites. The first complex within this series, the electroneutral species [CogS8(CO)6],was described by Stanghellini et al. in 1984,[s71shortly after the discluster core, namely [Co6&covery of the first complex containing the {Co~,Sxj (€'Etj)6]+ as its [BPh4]While the series of complexes containing tertiary phosphane ligands comprises electroneutral as well as monocationic species>[s9]all CO containing derivatives known so far are uncharged molecules. Besides sulfurcontaining species, uncharged derivatives containing selenium[56h1and tellurium[601 are also known. Within the class of iron complexes, the closely related hexanuclear have also been structurally species of general formula [Fe6E8(PR3)s]o.'+.'t.3+ characterizedr611. It is interesting to note that a complex species of formula [FesEx(CO)b]" is not known. Very recently, the complex anion [CocSeg(CO)(,]- was obtained by solvothermal with NalSe, in methanol/thf solution. The structure of the reaction of [CO?(CO),YJ cluster complex in crystals of [Co6Sep(CO)s][Na(thf) h ] is shown in Fig. 28.[621 The monoanionic species [Co6Sex(CO)s]- is isostructural with [CosSes(CO)6].[s6h1but due to a valence electron count of 90 for the former complex compared to 89 for the latter one. all intramolecular distances are shifted to longer values for the 90-electron species. The most pronounced effect of the oneelectron-reduction is the elongation of the mean Co-Co distance. which increases from 2.910 A up to 2.968 A. It most probably originates from the occupation of a cluster orbital, which is antibonding in origin with respect to the metal framework. Slightly less changes are observed for the Co-Se and Co-(CO) distances. Upon one-electron-reduction, they are as long as 2.35 1 and 1.752 A compared to values of
Figure 28. The complex anion [CobSe~(CO)hl-in crystals of "a( thf ib][Co&g (CO)6].
i
186
1 Moleculur Clusters
2.342 and 1.712 8, in the oxidized case. Similar redox-dependent effects have been observed in the series of phosphane-containing complexes of iron and ~ o b a l t . ~ ~ ~ , ~ ~ ] Solvothermal reaction of [ C O(CO)g], ~ Na2Se2 and [Ph4P]Cl in methanolic solution afforded the formation of hexanuclear cluster complexes, which differ not only in their CO contents but also in their redox states. According to a crystal structure is composed of analysis, the complex salt [P~~P]~[CO~S~~(CO)~][CO$~~(CO)~]CI monoanionic complexes [Co&3es(CO)6]- as described above (Fig. 28), dianionic complexes [Co&es(C0)4j2-, isolated chloride ions and [Ph4P]+ cations in the ratio 1 : 1 : 1 :4. The structure of [Co&es(C0)4I2- is shown in Fig. 29.[631 The novel cluster complex has unprecedented coordination properties, which can be derived from those of [Co&e8(C0)6]- by loss of two opposite CO ligands combined with the introduction of an additional electron. Both cobalt atoms, with their CO ligands removed, move towards the center of the cluster and approach each other inside the Seg cube at a distance of 2.677 A. The Co6 framework has now been transformed from a regular octahedron into a flat square-planar bipyramid with Co-Co distances of 3.045 A within the basal plane and of 2.535 A within the bonds from the axially orientated atoms, respectively, to the atoms in the basal plane. The transformation from [Co6Ses(C0)6]- to [Co,jSes(C0)4~~is also accompanied by a significant shortening of the Co-Se bonds (2.317 us. 2.363 A) within the square-planar coordination sites. In the course of systematic investigations, the sulfur-containing complex salt [P~~P]~[CO~S~(CO)~][CO~S~(C~)~]CI could also be synthesized under solvothermal
1.10 Toit~urdsTrunsition Metul Clusters
187
Fiigure 30. The complex anion [Fe8Te6(CO)z?]’-in crystals of
conditions.[641Here again, more conventional, highly reduced hexanuclear cluster complexes of formula [ Co6sX(Co)6]- coexist with completely unconventional COdeficient species [CohSg(C0)4l2- in even more highly reduced states.
1.10.9 Complexes of higher nuclearities Compared with cluster complexes of lower nuclearities, the number of mixed chalcogen/carbonyl complexes having more than six metal atoms is small. Besides some complexes containing iron and cobalt, no manganese compound within this class of complexes is known. ~ ’ ~ ~ ’ in Fig. 30. The structure of the cluster anion [ F e ~ T e s ( C 0 ) 2 4 ] ~ -IS[ ~depicted This compound is an extension of the tetranuclear complex anion [Fe4Tez(C0)14]2-(see Fig. 20, Section 1.10.6), which can be obtained from [Fe4Te2(C0)14I2by replacement of the axial CO ligand of each of the terminal {Fe(C0)4}fragments by butterfly-type {Fe?Tez(CO)s}units. Here again, the central {FelTe2(CO)h}fragment does not have the ideal butterfly-type structure due to a shift from the squarepyramidal towards a predominantly trigonal-bipyramidal coordination of iron. The coordination of the iron atoms within the two {FeTe3(CO)3}fragments is pseudooctahedral. The second octanuclear mixed chalcogen/carbonyl compound so far known is the complex anion [FegTeg(Te2)(C0)20]2-.’45.481 Th’is novel cage system (Fig. 3 1) contains two cuboidal { Fe4Te4(CO)loTe21 fragments, which share the atoms of the ditelluride group. With a total of 144 valence electrons, the complex anion is electron-precise without any iron-iron bonds. The cluster complex of highest nuclearity containing chalcogen/carbonyl ligands known so far is [CollTe,(CO)lo]’-. The novel cage compound has been obtained by reaction of [Co2(CO)g],Na2Te2 and [Ph4P]CI in methanolic solution under solvothermal conditions[341and isolated as [Ph4P]2[Col,Te,(CO) lo]. The complex anion ‘
188
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 31. The complex anion [FegTes(Te2)(C0)2012-In crystals of [ P ~ ~ P I ~ I F ~ X T ~ X ( T ~ ) Z ( C O ) ~
[C011Te7(CO)lo]~~, shown in Fig. 32, contains the novel { C O ~ O cluster } cage which is a slightly elongated pentagonal-prismatic array of cobalt atoms. The cobalt prism is centered by a single cobalt atom. The only other metal cluster with a related pentagonal-prismatic geometry is the {Pt19} core of [Pt19(CO)2,]4-.r661 The encapsulated Co atom is 2.558 8, away from its Co neighbors. As a result, the average Co-Co distance within the pentagonal-planar faces (2.583 A)is ca. 0.04 A shorter than the corresponding distance between atoms of adjacent metal pentagons (2.622 A). These distances are in the range of normal Co-Co bonds observed e.g. in the tetranuclear complex [Co4Te2(CO)l0](2.58 A).[40c1 Each of the five {Co,} squares is capped by a p4-Te ligand with a mean Co-Te bond distance of 2.510 A.In addition, two ,u,-Te ligands are situated above the centers of the pentagonal Co faces forming Co-Te bonds of 2.569 A in length. These ligands are also bound to the encapsulated Co atom at distances of 2.642(2) and 2.647(2) A,respectively. According to our knowledge, this unusual bridging mode of a chalcogenide ion has been observed for the first time resulting in a linear
Figure 32. The complex anion [Co,lTe7(CO)lo12-in crystals of lPh4Pl2[COI1Te-i(CO)101.
1.10 Towards Transition Metul Clusters
189
TeeCo-Te coordination. The other Co atoms are in a tetrahedral ligand environment due to ten terminally bonded CO groups. They are surrounded by three Te ligands and one CO ligand each. The encapsulated Co atom is the common vertex of a total of five nearly regular octahedral CoCo4Te units, which are connected via common faces to form the complete ColoCo(,u,-Te)z(p4-Te)5 framework. The mean oxidation state of Co is calculated to be +1.09. This value is in agreement with a mixed-valent state in which the encapsulated metal atom is formally divalent and the remaining ones are monovalent. Very recently, a related undecanuclear cluster complex containing selenide ligands has also been obtained by solvothermal reaction of (Coz(CO)8] with [C'o2(SeC?H7)5lp and [Ph4P]Cl in methanolic solution and isolated as [Ph4P]2[c'ol I S ~ ~ ( C O ) ~ ~The ].[~ complex 'I anion [Col 1Se7(CO)loJ2pis isostructural with [c'ol I Te7(CO)I " ] ~and - thus exhibits the same principal structural features including the novel pentagonal cobalt prism as well as the encapsulated cobalt atom. A perspective view, which outlines the body-centered pentagonal-prismatic cobalt (open stncks) and pentagonal-bipyramidal selenium (solid sticks) framework, is given in Fig. 33.
Acknowledgment The authors wish to acknowledge the invaluable collaboration of the diploma and Ph.D. students whose names are cited in the reference list. Special thanks are due to those who gave their assistance in the preparation of this article.
190
1 Moleculur Clusters
Our work has been generously supported by grants from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft ( DFG) and the German Federal Minister for Education, Science, Research and Technology (BMBF). We also thank the Fonds der Chemischen Industrie for financial support.
References [ I ] a) J.G. Brennan, T. Siegrist, S.M. Stuczynski, M.L. Steigerwald, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1989, 1 I I , 9240; b) R.C. Haushalter, C.M. O’Connor, J.P. Haushalter, A.M. Umarij, G.K. Shenoy, Ang e l ~ Chem. , 1984,96, 147; AngeiV. Chem. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1984, 23, 169; c) M. Rakowski DuBois, Chem. Rev. 1988, 89, I; d) R.R. Chianelli, Cutal. Rev. Sci. Eng. 1984, 26, 361; e) H. Topsoe, B.S. Clausen, Cutul. Rev. Sci. Eng. 1984, 26, 395; f ) D. Coucouvanis, Ace. Chcm. Res. 1991, 24, 1; g) M.A. Ansari, J. A. Ibers, Coord. Chem. Reo. 1990, 100, 223. [2] a) J.A. McCleverty, Prog. Inorg. Cliem. 1969, 10, 49; b) D. Coucouvanis, Prog. Inorg. Chem. 1970, 11, 233; D. Coucouvanis, Prog. Inorg. Chem. 1979, 26, 301; c) R. Eisenberg, Prog. Inory. Chem. 1970, 12, 295; d) J. Willemse, J.A. Cras, J.J. Steggerda, C.P. Keijzers, Struct. Bonding 1976, 28, 83; e) R.P. Burns, C.A. McAuliffe, Ado. Inorg. Chem. Rudiochem. 1979, 22, 303; f ) R.P. Burns, F.P. McCullough, C.A. McAuliffe, Adv. Inorg. Chem. Rudiochem. 1980, 23, 21 I; g) D. Coucouvanis, Ace. Chem. Re.c 1981, 14, 201; h) M. Draganjac and T.B. Rauchfuss, Anyew. Clzem. 1985, 97, 745; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1985, 24, 742; j) I.G. Dance, Polyhedron 1986, 5 , 1037; k) A. Miiller and E. Diemann, Ado. Inory. Chem. Radiochem. 1987, 31, 89; 1) P.J. Blower, J.R. Dilworth, Coord. Chem. Rev. 1987, 76, 121; m) A. Miiller, Polyhedron 1986, 5 , 323; n) D. Coucouvanis, A. Hadjikyriacou, M. Draganjac, M.G. Kanatzidis, and 0. Ileperuma, Polyhedron 1986, 5 , 349; o) I.G. Dance, K . Fisher, Prog. Inor(/. Cliem. 1994, 41, 637; p) L.C. Roof, J.W. Kolis, Chem. Rev. 1993, 93, 1037; q) B. Krebs, G. Henkel, Anyeizr. Chen?. 1991, 103: 785: Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1991, 30, 769; r) D. Fenske. J. Ohmer, J. Hachgenei, K. Merzweiler, Angew. Chem. 1988, 100, 1300; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1988, 27, 1300; s) M.G. Kanatzidis, S.-P. Huang, Coord. Chem. Rev. 1994, 130, 509; t) J.W. Kolis, Coord. Chem. Rev. 1990, 105, 195. [3] C.H. Wei, L.F. Dahl, Inorg. Chem. 1963, 2, 328. [4] a) R.E. Bachman, K.H. Whitmire, Oryunometullics 1993, 12, 1988; b) M. Shieh, M.-H. Shieh, Orgunometullics, 1994, 13, 920; c) S. Shieh, P.-F. Chen, Y.-C. Tsai, S. Shieh, S.-M. Peng, G.-H. Lee, Inorg. Chem. 1995, 34, 2251. [S] a) W.-F. Liaw, D.-S. Ou, Y.-S. Li, W.-Z. Lee, C.-Y. Chuang, Y.-P. Lee, G.-H. Lee, S.-M. Peng, Inory. Clzem. 1995, 34, 3747; b) C.J. Marsden, G.M. Sheldrick, J. Oryanomet. Chenz. 1972,40, 175; c) W. Eickens, S. Jager, P.G. Jones, C. Thone, J. Oryunomrt. Chem. 1996, 51 I , 67; d) J. Chen, V.G. Young, Jr., R.J. Angelici. Orgunometullics 1996, 15, 325. [6] a) W.-F. Liaw, C.-Y. Chuang, W.-Z. Lee, C.-K. Lee, G.-H. Lee, S.-M. Peng, Inorg. Chenz. 1996, 35, 2530; b) D. Fenske, J. Meyer, K. Merzweiler, Z. Nuturforsch. 1987, 42b, 1207. [7] C.H. Wei, L.F. Dahl, J. Am. Chem. Soe. 1968, 90, 3960. [8] C.H. Wei, L.F. Dahl, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1968, 90, 3969. 191 C.H. Wei, L.F. Dahl, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1968, 90, 3977. [lo] A. Winter, L. Zsolnai, G. Huttner, J. Orgunornet. Chenz. 1983, 250, 409 [ I l l W.S. Sheldrick, M. Wachhold, Angew. Chem. 1997, 109, 214; Angew. Clzem. Int. Ed. Enyl. 1997, 36, 206. [12] a) C.H. Wei, L.F. Dahl, Inorg. Chem. 1965, 4, I; b) C.F. Campana, F.Y-K. Lo, arid L.F. Dahl, Inorg. Chem. 1979, 18, 3060; c) D.A. Lesch, T.B. Rauchfuss, Inorg. Chem. 1981,20, 3583.
1.10 Towards Trunsition Metal Clusters
191
[I31 a) B. Beagley, D.W.J. Cruickshank, P.M. Pinder. A.G. Robiette, G.M. Sheldrick, Actu C~JTtullogr. Sect. B 1969, 25, 737; b) J. Donohue; A. Caron, Actu Crystullogr. Sect. B 1964, 17, 663; c ) J. Donohue. A . Caron, Actu Crystullogr. Sect. B 1962. 15, 930; dj R. Boese, D. Blaser, Z. Kristallogr. 1990. 193, 289; e ) D. Braga, F. Grepioni, A.G. Orpen, Organometu1lic.s 1993. 12, 148; f ) B.A. Frenz, J.A. Ibers. Inorg. Chetn. 1972. 11, 1109; g) G. Kong: G.N. Harakas, B.R. Whittlesey, J. ilm. Chem. Sue. 1995, 1 17, 3502. [I41 R. Seidel, B. Schnautz, G. Henkel, Angeiv. Chem. 1996. 108. 1836; Anyew. Chem. Int. EN'. Engl. 1996, 35, 1710. [I51 a ) S.J. La Placa, W.C. Hamilton, J.A. Ibers, A. Davison, Inorg. Chem. 1969, 8. 1928; b) S.J. La Placa, W.C. Hamilton. J.A. Ibers, Inorg. Chem. 1964. 3, 1491. [ 161 B. Schnautz. G. Henkel. in preparation. [ I 71 B. Schnautz. G . Henkel, in preparation. [I81 B.W. Eichhorn, R.C. Haushalter, J.S. Merola, Inorcq. Chem. 1990. 29, 728. [1'3] S.C. O'Neal. W.T. Pennington, and J.W. Kolis, /nor
192
I Molecular Clusters
1411 V. Kiillmer, E. Rottinger, H. Vahrenkamp, J. Chem. Soc. Clzem. Conimun. 1977, 782. 1421 a) L.L. Nelson, F.Y-K. Lo, A.D. Rae, L.F. Dahl, J. Orgunomet. Chem. 1982, 225, 309: b) E. Rottinger, H. Vahrenkamp, J. Oryanomet. Chem. 1981, 213, I; c) L. Bogan, Jr., D.A. Lesch, T.B. Rauchfuss, J. Organornet. Chem. 1983, 250, 429. [43] a) J.M. Coleman, A. Wojcicki, P.J. Pollick, L.F. Dahl, Inorg. Ciiem. 1967, 6, 1236; b) J.A. de Beer, R.J. Haines, J. Orgunometal. Chen?. 1970, 24, 757. [44] P.V. Broadhurst, B.F.G. Johnson, J. Lewis, P.R. Raithby, J. Chem. Soc. Clzem. Commun. 1982, 140. [45] S.-P. Huang, M.G. Kanatzidis, Inory. Clzenz. 1993, 32, 821. [461 R. Seidel, G. Henkel, in preparation. [47\ L.C. Roof, D.M. Smith, G.W. Drake, W.T. Pennington, J.W. Kolis, Inorg. Chem. 1995, 34, 337. (481 L.C. Roof, W.T. Pennington, J.W. Kolis, Angew. Chem. 1992, 104, 924; Angew. Cheni. Int. Ed. Engl. 1992, 31, 913. 1491 R. Seidel, G. Henkel, in preparation. [50] R. Seidel, G. Henkel, in preparation. [51] G.L. Lilley, E. Sinn, B.A. Averill, Inory. Chem. 1986, 25, 1073. [52] S. Weipgriiber, G. Henkel, in preparation. [53] a) G. Christou, R.H. Holm, M. Sabat, J.A. Ibers, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1981, 103, 6269; b) K.S. Hagen, A.D. Watson, R.H. Holm, J. Am. Chenz. Soc. 1983, 105, 3905. [54] a) G. Henkel, H. Strasdeit, B. Krebs, Angew. Chem. 1982, 94, 204; Angeiv. Chem. Ozt. Ed. Engl. 1982, 21, 201; Angew. Cheni. Suppl. 1982, 489; b) H. Strasdeit, B. Krebs, G. Henkel, Inory. Chem. 1984, 23, 1816. [55] H. Strasdeit, B. Krebs, G. Henkel, Z. Natucfbrsch. 1987, 42b, 565. 1561 a) D.L. Stevenson, V.R. Magnuson, L.F. Dahl, J. Am. Chem. Sue. 1967, 89, 3727; b) G. Gervasio, S.F.A. Kettle, F. Musso, R. Rossetti, P.L. Stanghellini, Inovg. Chem. 1995, 34, 298. 1571 a) G. Gervasio, R. Rossetti, P.L. Stanghellini, G. Bor, Inory. Chim. Actu 1984, 83, L9; b) E. Diana, G. Gervasio, R. Rossetti, F. Valdemarin, G. Bor, P.L. Stanghellini, Inory. Chein. 1991, 30, 294. [58] F. Cecconi, C.A. Ghilardi, S. Midollini, Inorg. Chim. Actu 1981, 64, L47. [59] a) M. Hong, Z. Huang, X. Lei, G. Wei, B. Kang, H. Liu, Polyhedron 1991, 10, 927; b) F. Cecconi, C.A. Ghilardi, S. Midollini, A. Orlandini, P. Zanello, Polyhedron 1986, 5, 2021; c) D. Fenske, J. Ohmer, K. Merzweiler, Z. Nututfbrsch. 1987, 42b, 803; d) D. Fenske, J. Hachgenei, J. Ohmer. Angerv. Ciiem. 1985, 97, 684; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1985, 24, 706; e) F. Cecconi, C.A. Ghilardi, S. Midollini, A. Orlandini. Inory. Chin?. Acta 1983; 76, L183; f ) D. Fenske, J. Ohmer, J. Hachgenei, Angew. Chem. 1985, 97, 993. Angew. Chenz. Int. Ed. Engl. 1985, 24, 993. [601 M.L. Steigerwald, T. Siegrist, S.M. Stuczynski, h r g . Chem. 1991, 30, 2256. [61] a) A. Bencini, C.A. Ghilardi, S.Midollini, A. Orlandini, U. Russo, M.G. Uytterhoeven, G. Zanchini, J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. 1995, 963; b) F. Cecconi, C.A. Ghilardi, S. Midollini, A. Orlandini, P. Zanello, J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans 1987, 831; c) A. Agresti, M. Bacci, F. Cecconi, C. A. Ghilardi, S. Midollini, Inory. Chem. 1985, 24, 689; d) M.L. Steigerwald, T. Siegrist, E.M. Gyorgy, B. €lessen; Y.-U. Kwon, S.M. Tanzler, Inory. Chem 1994, 33, 3389; e) C.A. Goddard, J.R. Long, R.H. Holm, Inorg. Cheni. 1996, 35, 4347. [62] R. Seidel, G. Henkel, in preparation. 1631 R. Seidel, G. Henkel, in preparation. [64] a) S. Weifigraber, G. Henkel, in preparation; b) B. Schnautz, G . Henkel, in preparation. [65] M. Shieh, P.-F. Chen, S.-M. Peng, G.-H. Lee, Inorg. Chern. 1993, 32, 3389. 1661 D.M. Washecheck, E.J. Wucherer, L.F. Dahl, A. Ceriotti, G. Longoni, M. Manassero, M. Sansoni, P. Chini, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1979, 101, 6110.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.11 Low-Nuclearity Iron and Ruthenium Selenido-Carbonyl Clusters Derived from Phosphine and Diphosphine Selenides D1iniele Cmrri, Cluutlirt Gr-uifl,Giocmni Prdieri,
N
M Antonio ~
Tiripiccliio
1, 11.1 Introduction The chemistry of transition-metal chalcogenido polynuclear clusters has undergone rapid development in the last few years as pointed out in recent reviews.['] The reasons for this increasing interest derive (i) from the usefulness of chalcogenido ligands in cluster growth reactions, (iij from the pursuit of structural models and precursors for the synthesis of new materials and (iii) from the search of new coordinations and geometries.['.'] In this regard, spectacular results have been achieved in the field of nickel tellurides[31and selenides["] and copper s e l e n i d e ~ ,where ~ ~ ' giant molecular clusters have been synthesized and structurally characterized. In order to prepare transition-metal selenido clusters, different synthetic routes are presently available. such as those involving, as starting materials, diphenyl diselenide,[61 phenylselenyl chloride,['] selenofene.[81 trialkylsilyl ~elenides,["*'~ polyselenide anions,'"] and phosphine selenides.[lO1Furthermore, small selenido clusters, such as [Fez(p-Se?)(C0)6]and [Fe3(,u3-Se)z(C0),],can be conveniently used to prepare larger mono- and bimetallic species," ' I as described in Sec. 1.1 1.5. [n particular. the reaction of tertiary phosphine selenides with metal carbonyl co~mplexes[~~' provided a simple. one-step synthetic procedure for the formation of sel'enido clusters through oxidative transfer of selenium atoms to low-valent metal centers, taking advantage of the reactivity of the P=Se bond. Moreover, this method appears suitable for the synthesis of phosphine-substituted molecular clusters of different nuclearity, depending on which phosphine is used. The availability of these clusters offers the opportunity to exert a stoichiometric control in those processes that lead from molecular metal chalcogenides such as [M,E,( PR3),1 to extended inorganic solids like M,E,. The stoichiometric control. combined with the kinetic control, which derives from low activation energies of these processes, often allows the preparation of otherwise inaccessible solid phases or microinhomogeneous materials such as nanocomposites." 'I
194
I Molecular Clustevs
Despite the synthetic potential of the phosphine selenides, their reactions with metal carbonyls have been explored only to a limited extent until the last three years, and most of the previously described chalcogenido-carbonyl clusters containing Group 15 donor ligands had been obtained by substitution reactions.['.' l a , ' 31 For this reason, we started to study the reactions of phosphine and diphosphine selenides with [M3(C0)12]( M = Fe or Ru)[14]with the aim of obtaining new phosphine substituted selenido carbonyl clusters, whose structural characterization and reactivity are the central issue of this article.
1.11.2 Clusters derived from Ph3PSe The carbonyl clusters [M3(C0)12] ( M = Fe or Ru) react with Ph3PSe through oxidative transfer of selenium atoms to the metal cluster (Fig. l), giving a variety of phosphine-substituted selenido carbonyl cluster^,[^^^' whose structural frameworks are shown in Fig. 2. The open-triangular, variously substituted, do-clusters with the M3Se2 core are the major products for both metals, but significant amounts of clusters with dinuclear Fe2Se2, trinuclear Fe3Se and tetranuclear Ru4Se2 cores are also obtained. The product distribution is strongly dependent on the reaction conditions, particularly on the cluster-phosphine molar ratio. In the case of iron the reaction takes place rapidly, upon gentle warming, whereas in the case of ruthenium the presence of Me3N0, as decarbonylation reagent, is required to increase the reaction rate.
1.11.2.1 Ph3P-substituted selenido iron clusters The reaction of [Fe3(C0)12]with Ph3PSe is non-selective. Whatever starting molar ratio is used, the reaction affords six products (1-6, Fig. 2) belonging to the three families of clusters cores Fe2Se2, Fe3Se2 and Fe3Se.['41 The starting Fe3(C0)12/ Ph3PSe molar ratio slightly affects the yields of the individual products, the disubstituted products being abundant only when the ratio is 1 : 8. All these compounds follow the 18-electron rule when pu,-Seand p-Se2 are considered as four- and
1 M = Fe, L, = L, = L, = CO M = Fe, L, = PPh, L, = L3 = CO 3 M = Fe, L, = L, =PPh, L, = CO 2
7 M =Ru,L i z PPh,
b =L3 = CO
8 M = Ru, L , = = PPh, L3 = CO 9 M = Ru, L, = L, = L3 = PPh3
[M3(p3-Se),(CO),S] (50 electrons, d o , 7 s.e.p.s)
6
se
5 L=PPh,
Ph3P
Fe
PPh,
10 L = C O 11 L = P P h 3
[RU4(~~-~),(~~0)2(co)~(L)(Pph3)1
(62 electrons, closo, 7 s.e.p.s) Figure 2. Structural diagrams of the Phi€'-substituted selenido-carbonyl iron and ruthenium clusters (carbonyls omitted) along with the appropriate electron counts according to the I &electron rule and the PSEP theory.'"]
six-electron donors, respectively. The first five products possess the well-known cluster cores Fe2Se2 and Fe3Se2, typical of iron and ruthenium chalcogenido clusPPhl)2] 6 is unprecedented in the neutral ters,"' whereas [Fe~(,uu3-Se)(p-CO)(CO)~( form, only the dianion [Fei(pu,-Se)(CO)g]'-and the corresponding dihydride having been synthesized." 61 The possible sequential steps of these reactions are illustrated in Fig. 3. The first two reactions ( u .h ) , involve oxidative transfer of selenido ligands from the phosphine to the trinuclear clusters and are the key steps in the entire process. The dinuclear compounds are probably produced by decomposition of the FeiSe? cores through an internal redox process (step c), which results in the detachment of metal(0) species. In fact, on heating the pure trinuclear cluster 3 (FejSezP2) under reflux, significant amounts of the dinuclear complexes 4 ( FeZSezP) and 5 (FeZSe2P2)
196
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 3. Possible sequential steps in the reaction between Ph3PSe and [Fe3(C0)12].
are obtained. The released metal(0) fragment could react with trinuclear clusters producing higher-nuclearity species, such as the tetranuclear clusters 10 and 11 found in the case of ruthenium (see 2.2). It is reasonable to think that similar clusters are also formed in the case of iron, but they are probably not sufficiently stable. The variety of Ph3P-substituted products can arise from direct CO substitution by free Ph3P ligands or from disproportionation processes. In this regard, we have found (reaction d ) that the monosubstituted cluster 2 (Fe3SeZP),when dissolved in chloroform at room temperature, is in equilibrium with the corresponding unsubstituted 1 (Fe3Se2) and the disubstituted 3 (Fe3Se2P2) products. The separation of the complex mixtures of selenido-carbonyl iron clusters, derived from the synthetic routes described above, can also be accomplished by high-performance liquid chromatography ( HPLC)." 'I This technique (eventually coupled with mass-spectrometric detection" 71) is particularly convenient for the separation of organometallic species, owing to its superior speed and efficiency when compared with traditional column and thin layer chromatography." *I The order of elution of the iron clusters on silica is strongly dependent on the degree of phosphine substitution and on the cluster framework, which, in the first place, determines the polarity of the molecule.[''1
1.1 1.2.2 Ph3P-substituted selenido ruthenium clusters In the case of ruthenium, with a 1 : 2 Ru3(CO)I*/Ph3PSemolar ratio, the reaction is quite selective giving, in very high yield, the disubstituted trinuclear, 50-electron cluster (nido, seven skeletal electron pairs, s.e.p.s) [Ru3(p3-Se)2(C0)7(PPh3)2] 8, which is just the primary product of the oxidative attack of two Ph3PSe molecules on the metal triangle.[14]The production of large amounts of this compound is probably due to its high thermal stability; in fact, it does not decompose in toluene under reflux, to give dinuclear species, as the isostructural iron cluster 3 does. Minor products are the analogous mono- and trisubstituted derivatives 7 (Ru3Se2P) and 9 (Ru3Se2P3) and the 62-electron (closo, seven s.e.p.s) tetraruthenium clusters
[Ru4(p4-Se)2(p-C0)2(CO)x(PPh3)] 10 and [Ru4(p4-Se),(,u-CO)z(COj7( PPh;)?] 11. The last two species belong to the large family of the bicapped, square-planar clusters of general formula M4Ez L,,, which have attracted considerable interest recently from both the synthetic as well as the structural point of view"91 (see paragraph 1.1 1.4.2). When the starting molar ratio Ru3(CO)Iz/Ph3PSe is 1 :4, the trisubstituted derivative 9 is the main product, but the yield is not as high as that of the disubstituted species 8 in the 1 : 2 reaction. 'The mass spectra, in chemical ionization mode, of the ruthenium clusters"'' show the molecular ions together with several groups of peaks at 28-,LLintervals, arising from the progressive loss of the carbonyl ligands (e.g. [Ru;Sez( PPh3)2(C0)6li, m/z 1153, 100% for 8 and 739'0 for 9). The considerable abundance of the molecular ions, particularly for compound 8 (ca. 50%), testify to the higher stability of the ruthenium clusters compared to the iron homologues, whose mass spectra are generally dominated by mononuclear fragments.
1.11.3 Cluster derived from (Ph2PSe)2X The clusters [M1(CO)12]( M = Fe or Ru) have been successfully reacted with the three diphosphine diselenides (Ph,PSe),X shown in Fig. 4 (along with their parent
Figure 4. Structural diagrams of the diphosphine diselenides along with those of their parent diphosphines.
198
I Molecular Clusters
diphosphines), affording again the substituted open-triangular, 50-electron, nidoclusters [M3(p3-Se)2(CO)7{p-( Ph2P)zX)I as the main products.r20p221 The set of the other products parallels the previous set of Ph3P-derivatives, including the dinuclear species, in the case of iron, and the closo tetranuclear clusters, in the case of ruthenium. The most important aspect of this reaction sequence is the characterization of the new compound [Ruq(,u3-Se)4(CO) lo(p-dppm)] 20, which is the first 72-electrons Ru-Se cubane-like cage complex to be reported. The structural diagrams of the resulting clusters are shown in Fig, 5.
Ph,P
+
‘PPh,
Figure 5. Structural diagrams of the diphosphine-substituted selenido-carbonyl iron and ruthenium clusters (carbonyls omitted).
1.I I Lou-Nuclenrity Iron und Rutheniunz Selenido-Curhonyl Clusters
199
1.1 1.3.1 (PhzP)zX-substituted selenido iron clusters The reactions of [Fe3(CO)12 ] with the diphosphine diselenides dppmSe2 dppeSe2, and dppfcSe2 ( Fig. 4) produce12 various diphosphine-substituted selenido iron complexes, among which the nin'o-clusters [Fei(p,-Se);!(CO)-,Ip-LL)](LL = dppm, 12; dppe, 13; dppfc, 14) should be regarded as the primary products of the oxidative atlack. In particular, the reactions with dppeSe2 and dppfcSe2 afford 13 and 14 respectively, along with other complexes that contain the same Fe3Se2 cluster core, such as the unsubstituted cluster 1 and the derivatives 15 and 16, where dppe and dppfc bridge two cluster units. On the other hand, the reaction with dppmSe2 also gives rise to lower-nuclearity products, particularly to the dinuclear derivative (Fez(p-Se,)(C0)4(p-dppm)l17. Compounds 12 ( Fe3Se2dppm) exhibits an unexpected "P NMR spectrum, at room temperature, consisting of a singlet (6 77.7) and two doublets at higher fields (6 53.0 and 42.6, J(P,P) 58 Hz). Correspondingly, the ' H spectrum shows two methylene triplets (6 4.08 and 3.22, J ( H , P ) 10.5 Hz), which coalesce in toluene at 364 K. Fig. 6 shows the ' H two-dimensional exchange (EXSY) spectrum, which indicates that the two methylene signals are correlated by chemical exchange. These data suggest _ _ the fluxional behaviour depicted in Fig. 7, which consists of the migration of an iron-iron bond to link the two iron atoms bridged by the bidentate
0.0 1.0
2.0 3.0
7 (1 h0 ppni
'
Figure 6. H two-dimensional exchange (EXSY 1 spectrum (303 K , CHCII) of [ Fei i,uI-Se)2iCO)7(pdppm)].
200
I Moleculm Clusters
Figure 7. Proposed dynamic behaviour of [ Fe~(p3-Se)~(C0)7(p-dppm)] in solution.
ligand. In this way the two phosphorus atoms become non-equivalent and give the observed doublets in the 3'P NMR spectrum. The singlet at lower field is attributed to the symmetrical isomer, the only product that could be isolated in the solid state. This isomerism is probably induced by the dppm ligand whose steric demands cause the basal iron atoms to approach each other (see Section 1.11.4.1), promoting linking between them.
1.11.3.2 (Ph~P)2X-substitutedselenido ruthenium clusters The diphosphine diselenide dppmSe2 and [ R u ~ ( C O ) I(1~ :] 1) react in toluene giving I Ru3 (~u,-se)2(c0)7 (p-dppm)] 18, [RU4(L(4-Se)2(p-CO)(CO)s (p-dppm)I 19 and [Rq(p3-Se)4(CO)lo(p-dppm)] 20.[201Cluster 18 has a bicapped, open-triangular, 50electrons nido-core and is the expected primary product of the oxidative attack of dppmSe2 to the starting carbonyl cluster. Cluster 18 exhibits the same NMR spectral patterns as the corresponding iron derivative 12, hence the same fluxional behaviour can be proposed. Also 19 has a known architecture, being formally a substitution derivative of the 62-electron, bicapped square-planar, closo-cluster [RU~(~~-S~)~(,U-CO)~(CO)~].[~"~ Cluster 19 can be regarded as a secondary product, probably deriving from the addition of a mononuclear metal fragment to cluster 18, under the adopted pyrolytic conditions used. The structure of complex 20, outlined in Fig. 5 , consists of a cubane-like, 72electrons M4E4 cage core, which is unprecedented for ruthenium and selenium.'201 Also this complex should be regarded as a secondary product, probably formed by the self-assembly of two dinuclear RuzSez groups, derived from 18 (Ru3Sel) by loss of a mononuclear metal fragment. In the case of dppeSe2 and dppfcSe2 the sole characterized products, obtained by reactions with [ R u ~ ( C O ) ~are ~ ] the , corresponding nido-derivatives [Ru3(p3-Se)2(C0)7(p-dppe)](21) and [Ru3(p3-Se)2(C0)7(dppfc)](22).["] Compound 22 is the
1.I I Loii~-Nucleuritj~ Iron und Rutheniuni S~.l.izi~~-CurhonylClusters
201
only nido-cluster of this family where the diphosphine does not behave as a bridging ligand (Fig. 5 ) . From the reaction of (Ph2PSe)lNH with [Rul(C0)12].Woollins et LII. isolated the cho-cluster [ R u(,u4-Se)2 ~ (u-CO)( C 0 ) s( p - (Ph?PSe)?NH1 ].I2 31
1.11.4 Structural features Most products of the reactions of iron and ruthenium carbonyls with phosphine and diphosphine selenides. described in the preceding sections, display the iiiclo MlSe2 open-triangular and (only for ruthenium) the closo Ru4Se2 square bipyramidal cores. Both these two structural types are characteristic of the chalcogen elements ( S , Se, Te), in combination with transition metals. and compare with a variety of examples in the literature, particularly for iron and ruthenium. The availability of a wide number of data allows an adequate comparison of the relevant structural parameters to be made in order to detect the influence of chalcogen elements and of substituents ( particularly phosphines) on the chalcogenido-carbonyl cluster geomet ry .
1.11.4.1 M ~ E nido z clusters T h e chalcogenido clusters of general formula [M?E?Lg]( M = Fe or Ru, E = S , Se or Te, L = two-electron ligand) exhibit a bicapped, open-triangular array of metal atoms, which can be described as a square pyramidal structure with two metal and
' U p to now, cighteen structures of iiitlo clusters of formula JF;cxip?-E)2L9]( E = S. Se or Te, L = two-electron ligand) are known; thirteen are recorded on the Cambridge Structural Database (CSD, October 1997 release I and five arc reported in recent There are 10 structurcs of the type I R u ; ( j r , - E ~ ~ Lseven ~ ] ; on the CSD, one i n a recent paperL231 and two to be published.'221 L ,= , I PR. S. Se or Te. n = 11; E = Bi. n == 12), 20 With regards to the c / o s o clusters [ R L I J ~ ~ , - E ) ~1,E structures have been considered; 16 of these are found in the CSD, four reported in recent papers. [ I 5 . 2 2.231 The average bond length values, given in Angstrom to two decimal places, have been calculated from distance values with estimated standard deviations lying in the range 0.001~ 0.005 A. CSD reference codes for [ F e ~ ( p , - E ) ~ L BENPIT. ~]: DUJZUD. JIZYUM. KOKGIA, LATRUT. PEDNOB, PEDNUH. PEDPAP, PODCAM, TAQMAZ. VOYWAH. YEDLOI, ZEHQIM. CSD reference codes for J R U J I ~ ~ ~ - EGEJMIR. ] ~ L ~ I : JUVWAY 10, KIHFAI, KUWBAF. KUWBIN. ZEHQUY. ZUVTUF. CSD reference codes for [Ru,l/r4-Ej:L,,1: BIFFIF. FASTEY. FUHYEM. JEYPEI. JUVVURIO. KIHDUA, KIHFEM. KIHFOW. KONFAU. KONFEY. KUWBEJ. PARPIH. TAWKOR. VOTZAF. VOTZEJ. ZEHROT.
202
1 Molecular Clusters
two chalcogen atoms alternating in the basal plane and the third metal atom (Ma,) at the apex of the pyramid (see for example compound 12 in Fig. 5 ) . For the same metal (Fe or Ru) the overall size of these clusters is dependent on the size of the chalcogen element, which affects not only the M-E distances, but also the M-Ma, ones. In the case of Fe, the mean values of the Fe-E bond lengths are 2.24 ( E = S), 2.37 (Se),and 2.55 (Te) A and those of Fe-Fe,, linkages are 2.59, 2.67, and 2.75 A respectively. Correspondingly, the non-bonding E. . .E and Fe. . .Fe diagonal interactions in the basal plane range from the minimum values of 2.84 and 3.37 A, respectively, for the disulfido clusters to the maximum values of 3.31 and 3.85 A of the ditellurido species. The same trend exists in the case of ruthenium, the Ru-E distances being 2.39 ( E = S), 2.52 (Se) and 2.69 &Te) and the Ru-Ru,~ ones 2.78 to 2.83, to 2.96 A,respectively. As regards CO substitution with tertiary phosphines, it is interesting to note that it is regioselective for the basal metal atoms. However, with stronger acceptor ligands, such as PhNC, the apical site is preferred,[241suggesting that Ma, is more electron-rich. Basal substitution with phosphines on a single metal atom M( P) produces a significant lengthening of the M( P)-M,, distance, which differs from the other M-M,, distance by 0.11 A in [FelSe2(CO)sPPh3] 2 and by 0.15 A in [Ru3Sez(CO)-i(dppfc)I22. The case of diphosphines deserves specific comments. Generally (with the exception of compound 22["] and another ruthenium compound[251),diphosphines act as bridging ligands between the basal metal atoms, in such a way that they exert a significant influence on the M. . .M non-bonding distance, producing appreciable modifications of the overall cluster shape. In the case of iron diselenides Fe3Se2(p-LL)["] the Fe.. .Fe separation is 3.489(2) in 12 (dppm), 3.560(4) in 13 (dppe) and 3.626(2) A in 14 (dppfc). The progressive cluster shape modification, by passing from dppm (smallest bite) to dppfc (largest bite), is also apparent from the increase of the Fe-Fe,,-Fe angle, from 81.1(1) to 86.5(1)", and by the corresponding decrease of the Se--Fed,-Se angle, from 89.9( 1) to 79.9( 1)'. The dependence between the angles Se-Ma,-Se and M-Ma,-M, for iron and ruthenium (exhibiting the same trend of iron) are shown in Fig. 8.
1.11.4.2 Ru4E2 closo clusters The structure of closo, square bipyramidal M4E2 clusters (see for example compound 19 in Fig. 5 ) has attracted particular attention from the theoretical point of view, owing to the possibility of different electron counts and of the possiblity of bonding character in the E . . . E interaction. In fact, when E is an aryl- or alkylphosphido ligand ( E = PR), the P. . .P distances are unusually and MO calculations for model iron and rhodium compounds[271indicate that the P. . .P
1.11 Low-Nucharity Iron and Ruthenium Srlenido-Curhonyl Clusters
203
I
Figure 8. Diagram showing the dependence between the angles Se--M,,,-Se and M-Ma,-M in the diphosphine-substituted nick) clusters [M\Se?Lgl( M = Fe or Ru); the two iron and ruthenium subsets give rise to distinct least-squares straight lines, the upper one referring to the first group; points 12 14. 21 correspond to clusters reported in Figure 5,'' 1.221 points [a]-[c] refer respectively to [Rui(p3-Se)2(CO)cj 13[ 6 b1 [ Rui?(,u,-Se)?KO), { p - (Ph2 Pj2C2 }1[6h1
-
84-
v
?!.4(
82-
2
& 80 78 -
76,
I
.
I
.
I
.
I
.
interaction is attractive. With regard to the structures of RuqE2 clusters ( E = S , Se, Te, PR or Bi) the averaged values of the E . . .E separations are 2.78 for PR, 3.08 for S , 3.30 for Se, 3.64 for Te and 3.92 A for Bi. Taking into account that the covalent radii for P and S are 1.10 and 1.04 A respectively,'"] in this family of clusters the P. . .P separation also appears particularly short. The increasing size of the capping element causes significant lengthening of the Ru--Ru bond distances, whether the two metal atoms are CO bridged (the mean Ru--Ru values are 2.75 for S, 2.77 for Se and 2.81 A for Te) or not (2.81, 2.85, and 2.93 A).In the case of PR groups as capping ligands, the mean Ru-Ru distances are 2.71 A in the presence of a CO bridge (lower than the values observed for the chalcogenido clusters) and 2.87 A in the absence of CO bridge (lying in the middle of the range observed for the chalcogenido clusters), resulting in the largest difference between the two types of distances (0.26 A). With regard to phosphine substituted derivatives, the series [Ru4SezLI J offers the widest number (six) of structural examples. In these diselenido ruthenium clusters, substitution with Group 15 donor ligands influences the number and the location of bridging carbonyls, as shown in Fig. 9. Moreover. the presence of a bridging diphosphine (with a small bite like dppm) results in a shortening of the bridged the same mean distance Ru--Ru edge from a mean value of 2.85 to 2.77 A.[22.231 observed in the case of bridging CO. Finally, it is interesting to note that the average value of the Ru-Se distances (2.58 A) observed in the doso clusters Ru4Sez (four Ru-Ru bonds) is significantly higher than the corresponding one (2.52 A) found in the structurally related nido RuJSe2 (two Ru-Ru bonds) species.
204
1 Molecular Clusters
P-Ru-
1 X \
P-Ru-
Ru
Figure 9. Structural types (non-bridging carbonyls omitted) resulting from Group 15 donor ligand substitution (mostly P) on the closo cluster [ R u 4 ( p 4 - S e ) ~ ( p - C O ) ~ ( C O ) ~ ] .
1.11.5 Cluster growth reactions Recent work by other research groups[281showed that small chalcogenido clusters, such as dinuclear and trinuclear Group 8 metal derivatives are useful precursors for cluster growth processes viu reaction with suitable transition metal species especially those belonging to Group 6. For example, [FesSe2(C0)9] reacts with [ C P ~ M O ~ F ~ ~ S ~ ~ ( and C O )[Fez(SeTe)(CO)g] ~][’~~’ inter[ C P ~ M O ~ ( C Oto) ~give ] acts at room temperature with [W(CO)s(thf)] (thf = tetrahydrofuran) yielding [ Fe4Mo(p3-Se)z(pj-Te)z(CO)141. [ 28i1 With regard to phosphine-substituted derivatives, the availability of workable amounts of the trinuclear selenido ruthenium clusters [Ru~(,u3-Se)2(C0)7(pu-dppm)] (18) and [Ru3(p3-Se)2(C0)7( PPh3)2] (8) stimulated us to assess their tendency to give cluster growth reactions. As stated previously, both compounds are nido clusters with 50 electrons and 7 skeletal electron pairs (s.e.p.s), and hence they could be prone to add zero-s.e.p.s metal fragments, such as M(CO)3 ( M = Mo or W ) , to give the hypothetical doso clusters [MRu3(p4-Se)2(CO)lo(PPh3)2], in the case of 8 (species I in Fig. 10). This would have been expected also considering the existence of the analogous monophosphine sulfur derivative [ WRu3(p4-S)2(CO)~ 1 ( PMe2Ph)].[2”1
I.I I Lo\t,-Niic.leurityIron und Rutheniuni Selenido-Ccrrhonyl Clusters
,.
.I
5
205
23 M = M o 24 M = W
Figure 10. Diagrammatic representation jcarbonyls omittcd) of the reactions of cluster 8 and 18 with MjCO); groups derived from [M(CO)3(MeCN)?] ( M = Mo or W); I and I1 are hypothetical intermediates.
The results of the reactions of the two clusters with [M(C0)3(MeCN)3]are summarized in Fig. 10. Cluster 18 does not react, probably owing to steric hindrance of the bridging diphosphine, whereas cluster 8 unexpectedly affords the bicapped, square-planar clusters [M2Ru2(~C14-Se!2(~1-CO)C14(CO)~( PPh3)2] ( M = Mo 23, W 24) as unique products, formally derived from the addition of two M(CO)3groups with removal of a Ru(C0)3 fragment,[301cia the possible intermediates I and 11. Both these bimetallic clusters exhibit electron-deficient (60 electrons), planar, centrosymmei:rical arrays of two Group-6 metals and two ruthenium atoms, bicapped above and below by two quadruply bridging selenium atoms. As a result, the six atoms of the M2Ru2Se2 core form distorted octahedrons, in which four carbonyls asymmetrically bridge the M-Ru edges (Fig. 11, M = W ) . Apart the unusual mixed metal core, cluster 23 and 24 are unique, as they contain only six s.e.p.s instead of
206
1 Molecular ClusterJ
Figure 11. View of the molecular structure of [Ru2W2Se2(,u-C0)4(CO)6(PPh3)2]. Selected bond distances (A) with e.s.d.s in parentheses: W( 1 j-Se( 1 ) 2.595(2), Ru(1)-Se(1j 2.579(2); W( 1)-Ru(1) 2.803(2).
seven, as observed in the clusters of the Ru4El-derived family'6a,23,28c~e,29,3 and as required by the PSEP theory.[321 On the other hand, cluster 18, which appears inert in the previous process, exhibits a particular reactivity, under pyrolytic conditions. In fact, when heated in the presence of the decarbonylation reagent Me3N0, it produces the new cluster [RuhSe4(CO)12(,~-dpprn)z]. This hexanuclear species, shown in Fig. 12, clearly derives from the self-assembling of two cluster units with release of two carbonyl molecules in a sort of condensation process, whose final result is the formation of three new metal-metal bonds.[221The molecular structure of this cluster, solved by X-ray diffraction techniques, has only one precedent, namely that of [OsgS4(CO)161, which was obtained by the photolysis of [ O S ~ S ~ ( C O ) ~ ] . [ ~ ~ ]
Figure 12. Structural diagram (carbonyls omitted) of the hexanuclear cluster [ Ruh SeA(C0)I2 (p-dppm)*]; metal-metal distances (A) with e.s.d.s in parentheses: u 2.826(2j, h 3.015(2).c 2.982(2), d 2.858(2), e 3.002(2),/3.023(3), y 2.81 l(2).
1.11 Lou.-Nuclearitjj Iron und Ruthenium Schido-Ccirhonyl Clusters
207
1.l1.6 Concluding remarks Systematic investigations on the reactions of tertiary phosphine and diphosphine selenides towards iron and ruthenium carbonyl clusters have achieved the following results: ( i )these reactions provide a simple, one-step (sometimes selective) synthetic route to phosphine-substituted, low-nuclearity selenido-carbonyl clusters, through oxidative transfer of selenium atoms; (iij they lead, in some cases, to the formation of new species, such as the monoselenido cluster [Fe~(p3-Se)(~l-CO)(CO)7( PPh?)z] and the cubane-like cage complex [Ru4(p3-Se)4(CO) l&-dppm)]; (iii) some of these cornpounds display particular physico-chemical characteristics, such as the fluxional ( M = Fe behaviour in solution of the dppm derivatives [M3(p3-Se)2(C0)7(p-dppm)] or Ru); (ic) certain compounds of this family exhibit specific activity in cluster growth reactions, such as [Ru3(p3-Se)2(C0)7( PPh3)2] which reacts with M'(CO)3 fragments ( M ' = Mo or W ) , leading to the electron-deficient, closo-octahedral species [M~Ru2(p4-Se)~[p-CO)4(CO)6( PPhj)?]. These findings, along with the results achieved by other research groups, encourage the pursuit of these investigations, particularly by extending the described synthetic strategy to other phosphines, eventually containing other ligand functionalities. An important goal, which directly derives from the results described in Section 1.1 1.5, is to generate a series of phosphine-substituted selenido-carbonyl clusters. with different cluster cores, different ligands and different degrees of substitution, to be tested in cluster growth reactions. In fact, increasing evidence is being acquired that the presence of phosphine ligands can exert a decisive influence on the cluster growth processes.
References / I ] L. C . Roof, J. W. Kolis, C / i m Rrr., 1993. Y3%1037: G. Schmid ( E d . ) , Cluster cind Colloids, VCH, Weinheim, 1994. Ch. 3. (21 M . L. Steigerwald, Pol~~/iedr.on. 1994 13. 1245: M. L. Steigerwald. T. Sicgrist, E . M . Gyorgy; B. Hessen. Y.-U. Kwon, S. M. Tanzler. Inorcq. C%eni.. 1994. 33. 3389. [3] J. G. Brennan. T. Siegrist. S. M . Stuczynski. M.L. Steigerwald, J. h i . Cllerii. S i c . , 1989, I l l . 9240; Z. Nomikou. B. Schubert, R. Hoffniann, M. L. Steigerwald. Inory. Chem., 1992. 31, 2201. 141 D. Fenske, J. Ohmer. J. Hachgenei. Angcw. C/KW..Int. Ed E/iq/.. 1985, 24, 993; D. Fenske. H. Krautscheid, M . Muller. Amqeii.. C/icvi7.,lnr. Ed. En(//..1992. 31, 321. (51 H. Krautscheid. D. Fenske. G. Baurn. M . Semmelmann, A/iqc,it'. Chwn.. I / / / , Ed. Encql.. 1993. 32, 1303. 161 [a)B. F. G. Johnson. T. M. Layer. J. Lewis. A . Martin. P. R . Raithby, J. Orgcinomcf. C'hiwi., 1992. 429. C41; (bl T. M . Layer, J. Lewis. A. Martin, P. R . Raithby. W.-T. Wong, J. Cliern. S i c , . Dcilton Trtr/zs. 1992. 34 1 I . 171 T. Chihara, H. Yamaraki, .I. Oryrrnorm,t. C % e r r i . . 1992. 428, 169. 181 A. J . Arcc. R . Machado. C. Rivas. Y . De Sanctis. A. J . Deeming, J. Orcqcirzonwt. C/7cwi.,1991, 419. 63.
208
I Molecular C1usterLs
[91 J. Hsiou Liao, M. G. Kanatzidis, Inorg. Chem., 1992, 31, 431; J. Hsiou Liao, M. G. Kanatzidis, J. Am. Chem. Soc.; 1990, 112. 7400. [lo] C. Hogdrth, N. J. Taylor, A. J. Carty, A. Meyer, J. Chern. Soc. Chem. Commun., 1988, 834; F. Van Gastel, L. Agnes, A. A. Cherkas, J. F. Corrigan, S. Doherty, R. Ramachandran. N. J. Taylor and A. J. Carty, J. Cluster Sci., 1991, 2, 131; S. M. Stuczynski, Y.-U. Kwon and M. L. Steigerwald, J. Oryanonzet. Chem., 1993, 449, 167; W. Imhof, G. Huttner, J. Oryanomet. Chem., 1993, 448, 247. [ l l ] (a) P. Mathur, Md. M. Hossain, R. S. Rashid, J. Oryanomet. Clzem., 1993, 460, 83; (b) P. Mathur, Md. M. Hossain, R. S. Rashid, J. Oryanomet. C h m . , 1994, 467, 245. [12] M. L. Steigerwald, T. Siegrist, E. M. Gyorgy, B. Hessen, Y.-U. Kwon, S. M. Tanzler, Inorg. Chem., 1994, 33, 3389. [ 131 P. Mathur, B. H. S. Thimmappa, A. L. Rheingold, Znorg. Chem., 1990, 29, 4658; P. Mathur, Md. M. Hossain, R. S. Rashid; P. Mathur, Md. M. Hossain, R. S. Rashid, J. Organomet. Chem., 1993, 448, 2 11. [I41 P. Baistrocchi, D. Cauzzi, M. Lanfranchi, G. Predieri, A. Tiripicchio, M. Tiripicchio Camellini, Inorg. Chim. Acta, 1995, 235, 173. 1151 P. Baistrocchi, M. Careri, D. Cauzzi, C. Graiff, M. Lanfranchi, P. Manini, G. I’redieri, A. Tiripicchio, Inorg. Chim. Actn, 1996, 252, 367. [16] R. E. Bachman, K. H. Whitmire, Inorg. Chem., 1994, 33, 2527; S. N. Konchenko, A. V. Virovets, S. V. Tkachev, V. I. Alekseev, N. V. Podberezskaya, Polyhedron, 1996, 15, 1221. [17] M. Careri, A. Mangia, P. Manini, G. Predieri, V. Raverdino, G. Tsoupras, E. Sappa, J. Chromatogr., 1993, 647, 79; M. Careri, C. Graiff, A. Mangia, P. Manini, G. Predieri, Rapid Commun. Muss Spectrom., 1998, 12, 225. 1181 A. Casoli, A. Mangia, G. Predieri, E. Sappa, M. Volante, Chem. Rev., 1989, 89, 407. 1191 B. H. S. Thimmappa, J. Cluster Sci., 1996, 7, I . [201 D. Cauzzi. C. Graiff, M. Lanfranchi, G. Predieri, A. Tiripicchio, J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans.. 1995, 2321. 1211 D. Cauzzi, C. Graiff, M. Lanfranchi, G. Predieri, A. Tiripicchio, J. Organonzer. Chem., 1997, 536-537,497. 1221 D. Cauzzi, C. Graiff, G. Predieri, A. Tiripicchio, J. Chclm. Soc. Dulton Truns., 1999, 237 and results to be published 1231 A. M. Z . Slawin, M. B. Smith, J. D. Woollins, J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans., 1997, 1877. [24] H. G. Raubenheimer, L. Linford, G. Kruger, A. Lombard, J. Chem. Soc. D ~ l t o nTrans., 1991, 2195. 1251 H. Shen, S. G. Bott, M. G. Richmond, Inorg. Chim. Acta, 1996, 241, 71. 1261 R. C. Ryan, L. F. Dahl, J. Amer. Clzem. Soc., 1975, 97, 6904. 1271 J.-F. Halet, R. Hoffmann, J.-Y. Saillard, Inorg. Chem., 1985, 24, 1695. 1281 (a) V. Day, D. A. Lesch and T. B. Rauchfuss, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1982, 104, 1290; (b) R. D. Adams, J. E. Babin, J.-G. Wang and W. Wu, Inorg. Chem., 1989,28, 703; ic) P. Mathur, B. H. S. Thimmappa and A. L. Rheingold, Inorg. Chr~m.,1990, 29, 4658; (d) P. Mathur, I. J. Mavunkal, V. Rugmini and M. F. Mahon, Inorg. Chern., 1990, 29, 4838; (e) P. Mathur, D. Chakrabarty and Md. Munkir Hossain, J. Orgunomet. Chem., 1991, 418, 415; ( f ) P. Mathur, D. Chakrabarty, Md. Munkir Hossain and R. S. Rashid, J. Organomet. Chem., 1991, 420, 79; (g) P. Mathur, Md. Munkir Hossain and A. L. Rheingold, Organornetullics, 1994, 13, 3909; (h) M. Shieh, T.-F. Tang, S.-M. Peng and G.-H. Lee, Inorg. Chem., 1995, 34, 2797; ( i ) P. Mathur and P. Sekar, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., 1996, 727; (1) S. N. Konchenko, A. V. Virovets and N . V. Podberezskaya, Polyhedron, 1997, 16, 1689. [29] R. D. Adams, T. A. Wolfe and W. Wu, Polyhedron, 1991, 10, 447. 1301 D. Cauzzi, C. Graiff, C. Massera, G. Mori, G. Predieri, A. Tiripicchio, J. Chem. So(.. Dalton Trans., 1998, 32 1. [31] P. A. Eldredge, K. S. Bose, D. E. Barber, R. F. Bryan, E. Sinn, A. Rheingold and B. A. Averill, Inorg. Chem., 1991, 30, 2365. 1321 D. M. P. Mingos, Accounts Chem. Res., 1984, 17, 311. [33] R. D. Adams, I. T. Horvath, J. Am. Chem. SOL..,1984, 106, 1869.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.12 A New Supporting Ligand for p o x 0 Metal Derivatives: N,N-dialkylcarbamato, 02CNR2 Daniela Bdli Dell' Amico. Fausto Caldercrzzo, Fahio Marchetti, Guido Panipaloni
0 x 0 (and sulfido) ligands are ubiquitous in coordination chemistry, more frequently acting as bridging ligands between two ( p z - ) ,three (,LL~-) or four (p4-) metal atoms. They are mainly responsible for the formation of polynuclear systems from compounds of lower nuclearity. In this connection, it is interesting to note that t e m i n a l oxd'] (and sulfido)[21ligands are rare in coordination chemistry. Terminal 0x0 ligands arc mainly found among 0x0 derivatives of metals in their relatively high oxidation states [vanadium(IV) and vanadium( V ) , rhenium( VII), uranium( V I ) , and so on]; when usual or relatively lower oxidation states are considered, normally 0x10 ligands occupy a bridging position. The derivatives of iron( III), the p-0x0 ligand being responsible for the nucleation of these compounds,[31are especially important in coordination chemistry.[31 Terminal hydroxo ligands are even less common.[41Normally, ,LL-OXOderivatives of transition (or main-group elements) are accompanied by supporting ligands, such as carboxylato, alkoxo and so on, which usually reduce the nuclearity of the system. This article mainly concerns the formation of p-oxo metal complexes containing the N, N-dialkylcarbamato group as the supporting ligand. Compounds of moderate nuclearity are therefore produced, whose molecular structures have been solved by X-ray diffraction methods. It will be shown that the p-0x0 ligand more commonly originates from a hydrolytic process, presumably through the intermediacy of a terminal hydroxo-species. However, other p-0x0 derivatives have been identified, the bridging ligand arising from mechanisms different from hydrolysis. The content of this article originates from work carried out in these laboratories on the synthesis and structural characterization of homoleptic N , N-dialkylcarbamates, initiated about twenty years ago. and then expanded to the use of these derivatives as starting material for: a) the preparation of p-0x0 complexes; b) implanting metal cations on inorganic matrices, mainly silica; c) identification of other reaction pathways leading to the genesis of the p-0x0 ligand and, normally, to the corresponding increase of nuclearity. For simplicity. this article is divided into two parts depending on whether the p -
210
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 1. The molecular of the uranium( IV) compound U 4 ( ~ 3 - 0 )(02CNEt2 2 ) I 2 (ethyl groups not shown).
0x0 ligand has derived from: a) a hydrolytic process; or b) a deoxygenation process involving carbon dioxide.
1.12.1 Hydrolytic processes An earlier review article[5a1has pointed out the general aspects of the hydrolytic processes leading to p-0x0 derivatives of metal-carbamates. The first p-0x0 N,N dialkylcarbamato complex to be reported in the literature was the uranium( IV) derivative containing the Uq(p~3-0)2core and twelve supporting N,N-diethylcarbamato as shown in Fig. 1. Moderate to good yields of the p-0x0 derivative could be obtained by careful hydrolysis of the homoleptic precursor.[61 The general equation pertaining to the hydrolytic process of a given N,N-dialkylcarbamato metal complex can be summarized as shown in Eq. (1). mM(02CNR2),
+ pH20
+
M,~(p-O),(02CNR2),,,-2,
+ 2pC02 + 2pNHR2
(1)
The driving force of the reaction is the evolution of carbon dioxide; thus, in most cases, the synthetic procedure leading to the p-0x0 derivative consists of treating the N , N-dialkylcarbamato precursor with a stoichiometric amount of water in an organic solvent. A p-0x0 derivative of titanium( IV), with the formula T i 2 ( ~ - 0 ) ~ (OzCNEt2)2Cp*,, apparently produced by a hydrolytic process, has also been reported.[7a1
1.12 A N e w Supporting Liyandjor p - 0 ~Metal 0 Deriiutiues
N
Figure 2. The molecular ~ t r u c t u r e " ~of' the chromium( 111) compound Cr2(,m-0)(02CNEt2r6C1(NHEt2) (ethyl groupa not shown)
21 1
x Cr (p3-0)(0,CNEt,).CI(NHEt,), Cr:(p3-O)( O,CNEt;),CI(NHEt,),
In addition to the uranium( I V ) derivative, other products, obtained in these Laboratories by hydrolytic processes, have been structurally characterized, namely:
The chromium( 111) compound contains a central tridentate oxide ligand (Fig. 2), an arrangement which is typical of other 0x0-centred derivatives of chromium(111), such as the carboxylato['" and sulfato" 31 complexes. In the diethylcarbamato derivative, the central oxide ligand deviates by only 0.07 A from the plane of the three chromium atoms. It should be noted that the chromium derivative still retains a chloride ligand in its coordination; as the starting material is anhydrous CrCh, this corresponds to incomplete removal of chloride from the kinetically inert 3d' chromium( 111) cation. The aluminum derivative originates from a hydrolytic process of the iso-propyl precursor, shown earlier["] to be dinuclear with bridging carbamato groups, see Eq. (2).
The compound was obtained in good yields by controlled hydrolysis of the homoleptic precursor. The molecular structure of the pu3-0~0derivative is schematically
212
1 Molecular Clusters
Figure 3. The molecular structure'*' of the aluminum compound A14 (p3- 0 ) 2 (OlCNPr 2 ) (alkyl ~ groups not shown).
shown in Fig. 3 and consists of a tetranuclear assembly of aluminum atoms joined by bridging oxide and carbamato groups. The molecule contains five- [Al(l) and Al(3)] and six-coordinate [Al(2) and A1(4)]aluminum atoms with distorted tngonalbipyramidal and octahedral geometries, respectively. This compound thus belongs to the category of alumoxanes, whose probably better known derivatives at present are the alkylal~moxanes,['~~ produced by hydrolytic processes on alkyl-aluminum derivatives. Of the octanuclear derivatives, we first described the heterobimetallic nickel-zinc complex. It was obtained['] in low yields by what appears to be a hydrolytic process involving the homoleptic compounds of zinc( 11) and nickel( II), when the starting material [Ni(NCMe)6]ZnCl4 was made to react with the NHPr12/C02 system in a hydrocarbon as medium over long reaction times. The presence of zinc in the bimetallic derivative was established analytically and on the basis of the diffraction experiment, the latter showing that two of the eight metal atoms are four coordinate, typical of zinc in an oxygen-containing ligand environment (uide injra, data concerning the tetranuclear p4-O derivative of zinc( 11),Zn4(p4-0)(02CNEt2)6). Nickel is five-coordinate in this compound, see Fig. 4. Concerning the formation of the bimetallic compound, it is believed that this originates from a hydrolytic process on the zinc(I1) derivative [the rate ( S K I )of water exchange"61 in the hexa-aquo metal cations is 2 x lo7 for zinc, about three orders of magnitude larger than for nickel( II)], as indicated in Eq. ( 3 ) . The intermediate, presumably unstable hydroxo derivative of zinc, Zn(02CNPr12)0H,thus formed should attack the nickel( 11) carbamate giving the final product. It is interesting to note that the compound crystallizes in the rhombohedra1 space group R3.
+
Zn(02CNPri2)2 H2O + (Zn(OzCNPr'2)OH)
+ NHPr'2 + CO2
(3)
The octanuclear copper( 11 ) compound was obtained by controlled hydrolysis of the
Figure 4. The molecular structure"' of the heterobimetallic nickel-zinc compound Ni6Zn2(pJ-0),(02CNPr12) 12 ialkyl groups not Ehown).
homoleptic precursor Cu(02CNPr;)2, of unknown molecular structure, in good yields. Its molecular structure is schematically shown in Fig. 5. The asymmetric unit contains four copper atoms and six crystallographically independent di-iso-propylcarbamato groups. The primed atoms of Fig. 5 are centrosymmetrically related to those of the other half of the octanuclear unit. An important feature of the molecular structure is the presence of the p4-0x0 ligand, which is separated by 1.906(5)-1.950(6) A from the four copper atoms. The
Figure 5. The molecular 5t1 ucture[")] of the octanuclear copperi 11) compound Cup / I ~ - O I ~ ~ ~ C N (alkyl PI-~),~ groups not shown I
Cu,i~i,-O),iO CNPr
A
214
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 6. The molecular structure" of the octanuclear iron(11) compound Feg(p4-0)2(02CNPr;),, (alkyl groups not shown).
Fe,(~,-O),(O,CNPr',),,
octanuclear units have no significant interactions with the adjacent clusters. It is to be noted that in spite of its high molecular weight of 2370.9, the compound still presents a moderate solubility in hydrocarbons (it can in fact be recrystallized from heptane). The octanuclear 0x0-carbamato derivative crystallizes in the triclinic space group with Z = 1; thus, the molecule, which contains 321 atoms (hydrogens included), has an approximately spherical shape with dimensions of the order of 2 nm. The p4-0~0derivative of iron( 11), of formula Feg(p4-0)2(02CNPr12)12 deserves special attention as it is a very unusual case of a p-0x0 derivative of iron(II), see Fig. 6. Very few examples of authenticated p-0x0 derivatives of iron( 11) have been reported in the literature," 'I although mixed-valence iron( 11)-iron(111) p-0x0 derivatives are known.['81It was obtained in good yields by the hydrolytic process shown in Eq. (4). 8 F e ( 0 2 c N P ~+~ 2~H) 2~ 0 +
+
Fes(pq-0)2(02CNPrk),2 4NHPri2 + 4 C 0 2
(4)
The octanuclear compound of Fig. 6, which is structurally similar to the Zn( 11)-Ni( 11) heterobimetallic derivative, contains four- and five-coordinated iron( 11) centers, while the coordination geometry is approximately tetrahedral for Fe(4) and approximately trigonal bipyramid for the remaining iron atoms. The lattice symmetry is triclinic and is similar to the uranium( IV) derivative discussed above; it has an essentially spherical shape with dimensions of the order of 2 nm.
1.12 A New Supporting Ligundjor p-0x0 Metal Derivatives
215
1.12.2 Non-hydrolytic processes The p-0x0 derivatives obtained by processes which do not involve the intervention of water are (in increasing order of nuclearity): Zr3(~f.I-O)(p-O)Cp2(OzCNEt2)6;'191 Znq (p4-0)(02CNEt2)6;[201
Tax(p-O)12(02CNEt2)16.[2'1 In all three cases, the presence of a metal system in a low oxidation state is required for the formation of the p-0x0 function, namely, ZrCpz(CO)?, zinc metal, and Ta(OzCNEt2)3, respectively. Historically, the first dialkylcarbamato derivative with a p-0x0 functionality not deriving from a hydrolytic process was discovered during attempts to prepare the homoleptic derivative of zinc, Zn(OZCNR2)2, which is still unknown. After some unsuccessful attempts with anhydrous zinc halide^,'^^.^^] the reaction (150 "C, 180 atm of carbon dioxide) of zinc metal with Et2NH/C02 gave the 0x0-derivative of formula Zn4(pq-O)(02CNEt2)6,instead of the expected homoleptic derivative. Our attempts to produce the homoleptic derivative by this method were justified by some precedents in the literature concerning the preparation of the alkali metal and aluminum derivatives starting from the corresponding metals.[243251 The molecular structure of the tetranuclear p-0x0 derivative is shown in Fig. 7. The formation of the tetranuclear Linc derivative is believed to be best described by the stoichiometry shown in Eq. ( 5 ) . 4Zn
+ 7 NHEt2 + 7C02
+
Zn4(p4-0)(0~CNEt2)6 Et2NC(O)H
4
Figure 7. The molecular structurerzo1 of the tetranuclear zinc( I1 compound Z n ~ ( p ~ - O ) ( O ~ C N E (alkyl t 2 ) h groups not shown)
-
+ 3 H?
(5)
2 16
1 Moleculur Clusters
Zr,(ll,-O)(~-CCo)Cp,(O,CNPr,),
Zr,(~3-O)(r.l-O)CP,(O,CNPr ' 2 6
(a)
(b)
Figure 8. The molecular structures["] of the trinuclear zirconium( IV) compounds: (a) the ketenylidene precursor Zr.3(p3-O)(p-CCO)Cp2(02CNPr12)6of: (b) Zr3 (p3-0)(p - 0 ) C p(02CNPr'2)6 ~ (ethyl groups not shown).
The deoxygenation of carbon dioxide is supported by the finding that Et2NI3C(O)H was detected among the products when the reaction was carried out in the presence of labeled carbon dioxide. The molecular structure is highly symmetrical and the diethylcarbamato groups are of one type only, namely bridging bidentate. The zinc atoms form the vertices of a tetrahedron, whose edges are occupied by the bridging carbamato groups, the bridging oxide occupying the center of the tetrahedron. Concerted deoxygenation/reductive coupling of zirconium- (or hafnium)-bonded carbon monoxide in MCp?(C0)2 leads to the trinuclear derivative M3(p3-O) ( , u - C C O ) C ~ ~ ( O ~ C N91R the ~ ) ~molecular ;[~ structure of the zirconium derivative (R = Prl) is shown in Fig. 8a. The reactions leading to the ketenylidene trinuclear species Mi(p3-O)(pu-CCO)Cpz(02CNR2)~and their reaction products with carbon dioxide are shown in Eq. (6) and (7).
Reaction (7) proceeds at room temperature and at one atmosphere pressure of carbon dioxide, thus converting the bridging ketenylidene ligand into the bridging oxide.[19b1The ketenylidene complex reacts with carbon dioxide even in the solid state; the gas produced from the zirconium derivative. promptly evacuated into a mass-spectrometer, was shown to be carbon suboxide C302.[19c1The inorganic reaction product appears to catalyze the polymerization of carbon suboxide to red solid The structure of the product resulting from reaction ( 7 ) , R = Pr’, is shown in Fig. 8b. The tantalum octanuclear derivative Tag(p-O)12(O?CNEt2)16[’11 was serendipitously obtained during unsuccessful attempts to simplify the synthesis of Ta(O?CNEt2)?, by using sodium metal in tetrahydrofuran ( T H F ) , instead of CoCp*, in T H F or toluene, see Eq. (8). The former reducing system actually leads to the octanuclear derivative of tantalum(V ) . the oxidation from tantalum( 111) to tantalum(V ) being realized through the deoxygenation of the corresponding equivalents of carbon dioxide to give CO and HCONEt2, the latter being detected as one of the products. The remaining four oxides of the Tas cage presumably originate from THF.
The molecular structure of the octanuclear tantalum(V ) compound is shown in Fig. 9. The point symmetry is C, and the internal cage has approximately D 4 h symmetry. The eight tantalum atoms are situated at the vertices of a cube whose edges contain the twelve bridging oxides. Once again. the dimensions of this octanuclear species approximately correspond to those of the unit cell, with a diameter of about 2 nm.
Figure 9. The molecular structure‘”] of the octanuclear tantalum( V j compound Tax (p-0) I2jOZCNEtZ)16 (ethyl groups not shown). The compound is triclinic, space group Pi (No. 2)- Z = 1, and cell dimensions u = 15.440(3); h = 15.710(1);c = 16.090(2)A; U = 2971.4 A3.
218
I Molecular Clusters
1.12.3 Conclusions The research on p-0x0 derivatives supported by the N, N-dialkylcarbamato ligands has identified a new class of compounds characterized by a moderate to good solubility in organic solvents. The maximum nuclearity identified so far is eight, but it is quite possible that this can be increased in the future with an appropriate choice of the alkyl groups. The p-0x0 derivatives with the highest nuclearity are characterized by a molecular size around 2 nm, the periphery of the core being constituted by the alkyl groups. In a sense, the latter protect the inner oxygen-containing groups from further attack by water or by the oxidizing agent. It is to be expected that further research will discover new molecular assemblies of this type for several other transition- and non-transition metal cations. Also the formation of clusters of clusters is possible, provided the junction among, for example, the octanuclear clusters will be generated through a hydrolytic process involving some of the peripheral dialkylcarbamato groups. A further development of this chemistry comes from the possibility, already established for some mononuclear N, N-dialkylcarbamato derivatives, of using the carbamato function as a reactive point towards hydroxylated inorganic matrices; this method of chemically implanting metal cations has been successfully of used with tin( IV),[261 platinum( 11),[271 and zirconium( IV),[281 and is now under active investigation for other metal cations. The extension of this technique to polynuclear N,N-dialkylcarbamato derivatives will provide new possibilities, the most evident one being that of chemically implanting small oxide clusters on inorganic matrices.
Acknowledgments Generous support from the Minister0 dell’ Universita e della Ricerca Scientifica e Tecnologica (MURST) and by the Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR, Roma) is gratefully acknowledged.
References [I] For some recent examples of crystallographically established coordination compounds containing terminal 0x0 ligands, see: P. J. Stewart, A . J. Blake, P. Mountford Inorg. Chem., 36, 1982 (1997); F. A. Cotton, G. Schmid, Znory. Chem., 36, 2267 (1997); B. Noll, S. Noll, P. Leibnitz, H. Spies, P. E. Schulze, W. Semmler, B. Johanssen, Znory. Chirn. Actu, 255, 399
1.12 A New Supporting Ligand for p - 0 ~ 0Metal Derivatives
21 9
(1997); K. Kanamori. K. Ino, K.-I. Okamoto. A c f u Crj.sfu/logr., S k t . C, 53, 672 (1997); J. Mizutani, H. Imoto, T. Saito, Actu Crysttillogr., Sect. C, 53, 47 (1997); P. Y. Zavalij, T. Chirayil. M. S. Whittingham. V. K. Pecharsky, R . A. Jacobson, Acta Crysfullogr.. Sect. C, 53. 170 (1997); W. T. A. Harrison, L. L. Dussack, A. J. Jacobson, Acta Crystallogr.., SLW. C, 53. 200 (1997); T. I. A . Gerber, J. Perils. J. G . H. Du Preez, G . Bandoli, Acta Crystullogr.. Scc,t. C. 53. 217 (1997): A. A. Eagle, G . N . George. E. R. T. Tiekink, C. Ci. Young, Inorg. Cliem.. 36, 472 (1997); C. Limberg, M. Biichner, K. Heinze, 0. Walter, Inorg. C/zem.,36, 872 (1997); W. A. Herrmann. W. A. Wojtczak, G. R. J. Artus, F. E. Kuhn. M. R. Mattner, Inorg. Chern.,36, 465 (1997). [2] For some recent examples of coordination compounds containing terminal sulfido ligands, see: H. Pan, M. A. Harmer, L. Wei, M. E. Leonowicz. C. 0. B. Dim, K. F. Miller, A. E. Bruce, S. McKenna. J. L. Corbin. S. Wherland. E. I. Stiefel. 1nor~q.Clzim. Acta. 243, 147 (1997); P. K. Chakraborty, I. Ghosh, R. Bhattacharyya, A. K . Mukherjee, M. Mukherjee, M. Helliwell, Polyhedron, 15, 1443 [ 1996); A. K. Mukherjee, P. K. Das, M. Mukherjee, P. K. Chakraborty, R . Bhattacharya, Acta Crystullogr. , S . C, 53, 209 (1997); Y. Mizobe. M. Hosomizu, Y. Kubota, M. Hidai. J. Or~~unometul. c w . , 507, 179 (1996); J. T. Goodman, S. Inomata, T. B. Rauchfuss. J. A m . Cheni. Soc., 118. 11674 (1996); F. A. Cotton, G. Schmid, Inorg. C/icv7i.,36, 2267 (1997); D. Rabinovich. G. Parkin, Inorg. C/ieni., 34. 6341 11995): S. Thomas, E. R. T. Tieking, C. G . Young. 0rgunori~etuNic.c.15. 2428 (1996); D.-L. Long, S. Shi. X.-Q. Xin. B.-S. Luo, L.-R. Chen. X.-Y. Huang, B.-S. Kang. J. Cliem. Soc.. Dalton Trans., 2617 (1996); C. G . Young. L. J. Laughlin, S. Colmanet. S. D. B. Scrofani, hiorg. Chrm., 35, 5368 (1996); P. J. Lundmark, G. J. Kubas, B. L. Scott. Organon?rrallic.r, 15, 3632 (1996); S. Ogo, T. Suzuki. Y. Ozawa. K. Isobe. Inory. C / i m . , 35. 6093 (1996); W. J. Evans, M. A. Ansari, J . W. Ziller. S. 1. Khan. OrH"tzoriie/ullic,.c.14. 3 (1995 I; S.-P. Huang, M. G. Kanatzidis. Inorq. C/iim, Acro, 230. 9 (1995); H. Kawaguchi. K . Tatsumi. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 117, 3885 (1995); V. J. Murphy, G. Parkin, J. A m . C/7em. Soc., 117, 3522 (1995). 131 S. J. Lippard. Angen.. C/wni., In/. Ed. Emql., 27, 344 (3988); D. M. Kurtz, Chem. Riw, YO, 585 (1990); J. B. Vincent. G . L. Olivier-Lilley. B. A. Averill. Chem. R m . , YO, 1447 (1990); L. Que, A. E. True, Progr. Inorcq. Cliem., 38. 98 (1990; R . G. Wilkins, Chern. Soc. Rev.. 171 (1992). 141 For a recent case of terminally bonded hydroxo ligands in organometallic derivatives of molybdenum(I1) and molybdenum(llI), see: J. C. Fettinger, H.-B. Kraatz. R . Poli, E. A. Quadrelli. Cl7mi. Cornmun., 889 ( 1997). Other coordination compounds of molybdenum containing terminal -OH ligands have been studied crystallographically: P. R. Robinson, E. 0. Schlemper, R. K. Murmann, Inorg. C/iet7i.,14, 2035 (1976); M. R . Churchill. F. J. Rotella, Inorg. Chmi., 17, 668 ( 1978): T. Yamasc, J . C/wm. Soc.. Dalton Trans., 283 (1978); C. T. Kan, P. B. Hitchcock, R. L. Richards. J. Cher77. Soc.. Dalton Truns.. 79 (1982); Inovg. Clzem..22, 2723 (1983);J. Bohmer, G. Haselhorst, K. Wieghardt. B. Nuber, Angew. Clzem., Int. Ed. Engl., 33, 1473 (1994); T. Adachi, D . L. Hughes, S. K. Ibrahim, S. Okamoto, C. J. Pickett, N. Yabanouchi, T. Yoshida, C h i . Commun., 1081 (19953. razzo. F. Marchetti, G. Pampaloni, Sfoichiometric and E.ud.wnate.s, in, 1. T. Horvath, F. JoO. Eds., Aqueous OrgaNATO AS1 series, Paper presented at the NATO Workshop on Aqueous Organometallic Chemistry and Catalysis, Debrecen, Hungary, Aug. 28-Sept. 2nd, 1994; (b) F. Calderazzo, G. Dell' Amico, M . Pasquali, G . Perego, Inorg. Cllen7.. 17, 474 (1978). 161 F. Calderazzo, G . Dell' Amico. R. Netti, M. Pasquali, Inory. Chern.; 17, 471 11978). 1-71 (a) P. Gomez-Sal, A. M. Irigoyen, A . Martin, M. Mena, M. Monge, C. Yelamos, J. Orgunomeial. Cliem.. 4Y4, C19 (1995): (b) D. Belli Dell' Amico, F. Calderazzo. F. Gingl, L. Labella, J . Strahle. Gnzr. C/7ir>i.Ittrl.. 118, 729 (1988). 181 U. Abraham, D. Belli Dell' Amico, F. Calderazzo. S. Kaskel, L. Labella; F. Marchetti, R. Rovai, J. Strahle. Clieni. Commun., 1941 (1997). 1,
220
I Molecular Clusters
191 A. Bacchi, D. Belli Dell’ Amico, F. Calderazzo, U. Giurlani, G . Pelizzi, L. Rocchi, Guzz. Chin?. Itul., 122, 429 (1992). [lo] E. Agostinelli, D. Belli Dell’ Amico, D. Fiorani, G. Pelizzi, Guzz. Chim. Ital.. 118, 729 111988). [l I] D. Belli Dell’ Amico, F. Calderazzo, L. Labella, C. Maichle-Mossmer, J. Strahle, Chem. Commun., 1555 (1994). [ 121 (a) B. N. Figgis, G. B. Robertson, Nuture (London),205, 694 (1965); (b) S. C. Chang, G. A. Jeffrey, Actu Crystallogr., Sect B. 26, 673 (1970); (c) R . C. Paul, P. Kapoor, 0. B. Baidya, R. Kapoor. Z. Naturforsch., B 34, 160 (1979): F. A. Cotton, W. Wang, Inorg. Chenz., 21, 2675 (1982); E. Gonzales-Vergara, J. Hegenauer, P. Saltman, M. Sabat, J. A. Ibers, Inorg. Chim. Actu, 66, 115 (1982). [13] (a) K. Mereiter, H. Vollenkle, Acta Crystallogr., Sect. B, 36, 1278 (1980); (b) K. Mereiter, Acta Crystallogr., Sect. B, 36, 1283 (1980). (141 D. Belli Dell’ Amico, F. Calderdzzo, M. Dell’ Innocanti, B. Guldenpfennig, S. lanelli, G. Pelizzi, P. Robino, Gazz. Chini. Itab, 123, 283 (1993). 1151 (a) J. L. Atwood, M. J. Zaworotko, Chem. Commun., 302 (1983); (b) M. R. Mason, J. M. Smith, S. G. Bott, A. R. Barron, J. Am. Cliem. Soc., 115, 4971 (1993); (c) C. J. Harlan, M. R. Mason, A. R . Barron, Orgunometallics, 13, 2957 (1994). [ 161 M. L. Tobe, Inorgunic Reaction Mechanisms, Nelson, London, 1972. 1171 H. P. Muller, R. Hoppe, Z. Anorg. ANg. Chem., 569: 16 (1989); ibidem, 619, 193 (1993). The preparation of a more recent case [C. M. Che, C. W. Chan, S. M. Yang, C. X. Guo, C . Y. Lee, S. M. Peng, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans, 2961 (1995)l of a p-0x0 derivative of iron( 11) could not be repeated [F. Calderazzo, L. Labella, F. Marchetti, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1485 (1998)l. [I81 For mixed-valence iron( 11)-iron(111) p-0x0 derivatives, see: K. L .Taft, A. Caneschi, L. E. Pence, C. D. Delfs, G. C. Papaefthymiou, S. J. Lippard, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 115, 11753 (1993): K. L. Taft, C. D. Delfs, G. C. Papaefthymiou, S. Foner, D. Gatteschi, S. J. Lippard, J . Am. Chem. Soc., 116, 823 (1994); K. L. Taft, G . C. Papaefthymiou, S. J. Lippard, Inorg. Chern., 33, 1510 (1994); W. Micklitz, V. McKee, R. L. Rardin, L. E. Pence, G. C. Papaefthymiou, S. G. Bott, S. J. Lippard, J. Am. Chem. Soc.. 116, 861 (1994), and refs. therein. [19] (a) F. Calderazzo, U. Englert, A. Guarini, F. Marchetti, G. Pampaloni, A. Segre, Angew. Chem.,Int. Ed. Engl., 33, 1188 (1994); (b) F. Calderazzo, U. Englert, A. Guarini, F. Marchetti, G . Pampaloni, A. Segre, G. Tripepi, Chem. Eur. J., 2, 412 (1996); (c) G . Pampaloni, L. Pandolfo, G. Tripepi, unpublished results; (d) G. Paiaro, L. Pandolfo, CommentsInorg. Chen?.,12, 213 (1991). [20] A. Belforte, F. Calderazzo, U. Englert, J. Strahle, Inorg. Chem., 30, 3778 (1991). [21] P. B. Arimondo. F. Calderazzo, R. Hiemeyer, C. Maichle-Mossmer, F. Marchetti, G. Pampaloni, J. Strahle, Inorg. Chem., 37, 5507 ( I 998). [22] Several unsuccessful attempts have been made to prepare homoleptic N,N-dialkylcarbamato derivatives of zinc: anhydrous ZnX2 (X=Cl, Br) were treated with the R2NH/C02 system leading to dialkylcarbamato derivatives still retaining chloride in their composition 1231, of unknown structure. [23] (a) A. Belforte, PhD thesis, Scuola Normale Superiore, May 1989; (b) R. Alessio, PhD Thesis, Dipartimento di Chimica e Chimica Industriale, Universita di Pisa, February 1997. [24] A. Belforte, F. Calderdzzo, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1007 (1989). [25] T. W. Martinek, US Patent 3,056,820, October 2nd 1962 (to Pure Oil Co.), Chem. Abstr., 58, 6700 g (1963). [26] L. Abis, D. Belli Dell’ Amico, F. Calderazzo, R. Caminiti, F. Garbassi, S. Ianelli, G. Pelizzi, P. Robino, A. Tomei, J . Mol. Catal., 108, L113 (1996). [27] L. Abis, D. Belli Dell’ Amico, C . Busetto, F. Calderazzo, R. Caminiti, C. Ciofi, F. Garbassi, G. Masciarelli, J. Muter. Chem., 751 (1998). [28] L. Abis, F. Calderdzzo. C. Maichle-Mossmer, G. Pampaloni, J. Strahle, G. Tripepi, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 841 (1998).
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.13 Alkyne Scission on Metal Cluster Frameworks Michael J. Morris
1.13.1 Introduction The interaction of alkynes with metal carbonyl clusters has been investigated since the earliest days of organometallic chemistry. The 1960s and 70s saw much activity in this area, with the emerging technique of X-ray crystallography used to define the bonding modes of the organic ligands in the products. A review written by Hubel some 30 years ago on the reactions of alkynes with cobalt and iron carbonyls served only to emphasize the bewildering variety of structural types resulting from such reactions."] This diversity arises through the propensity of alkynes to undergo coupling reactions with carbonyl ligands and/or additional alkyne molecules to give ligands such as cyclobutadienes, cyclopentadienones, quinones, and cyclohexadienones. However, sometimes the incorporation of a single alkyne ligand in a well-defined bonding mode can be observed.[21For trinuclear clusters this often 7 ' 1 coordination modes I and 11, and for takes the form of the p3, $-\I and p y , 1 tetranuclear butterfly clusters the alkyne usually bridges all four metals in a p4, 1;1* mode 111. In the case of terminal alkynes, RC-CH, rearrangement of the alkyne ligand is often observed on coordination, for example by oxidative addition to form an alkynyl hydride IV or by 1,2-H migration to form a vinylidene (=C=CHR) V. A much rarer mode of reactivity involves the scission of the alkyne C-C bond and the formation of two alkylidyne ligands VI. Approximately 20 examples of alkyne scission have now been observed over the past 20 years or so and are detailed in Tables 1-3 below, classified according to the type of reaction involved. The reactions have been divided, rather arbitrarily in some cases, into three categories: 1 ) Reaction of an alkyne with a mononuclear metal complex or preformed cluster; 2) Thermolysis of a metal cluster which already contains one or more alkyne ligands; 3 ) Reaction of a metal alkyne complex or cluster with additional metal fragments.
222
1 Molecular Clusters
M
R,
p=
M-
\
M
a
R
II
I
111
R
U
1
M+
I
R IV
V
VI
Scheme 1. Typical bonding modes of alkyne ligands.
Table 1. Alkyne scission in reactions of alkynes with complexes. Precursor
Alkyne
Product
Reference
RI
C-CR~ ( R 1 ,R’ = SiMe3, Ph, Bu, C02Me and others)
3
Me3SiC-CNEt2 or Et2NCzCNEt2
A
MeCKNEt2
5
F~CCGCCF~
6
PhCECPh
I
PhC-CPh
8
PhC-CH
9
PhCECPh
10
223
1.13 AIkjwe Scission on Metal Cluster Frameworks Table 2. Alkyne scission by thermolysis of metal-alkyne complexes A1kyne complex
Product
Reference
C o ( R I C CR')(PPhi)Cp R ' = Ph. R' = Ph. COzMe, CN, R' = Me, R 2 = C02Me
Col(/(;-CR'j(~;-CR')Cpl
11
M?(CO)(v-R'C-CR ' ) C p M = Co, Rh. Ir, R ' , R' = Ph, tol, SiMe3, CF7, C02Me
M; ( p - C R ' ) I p;-CR')Cpj
12
As well as these examples, there are also several recent studies, especially by Chi and co-workers, which involve the related scission of coordinated acetylide ligands to carbide and alkylidyne ligands."yl Reactions are also known which do not give alkylidyne complexes but which imply alkyne scission, e.g. treatment of WFe2(p3Ctol)(CO)gCpwith CIPh2 gave two dimetalla-ally1 complexes, one of which was WFe(pu-CPhCtolCPh)(C0)5Cp with a rearranged chain.[201It should be mentioned that alkyne scission and metathesis can be observed in mono- and dinuclear systems such as Schrock's tungsten alkoxides, but this lies outside the scope of the current article. Historically speaking, the most studied reactions are those involving the forma~ C P ~ ]where M = Co, Rh, Ir. This can be achieved tion of [ M ~ ( ~ u I - C R )clusters from mononuclear units such as CpM(C 0 )l or from preformed alkyne clusters M3(CO)(p3-C2R2)Cpl; in each case the scission step occurs at a trinuclear metal
Table 3. Alkyne scission by reaction of alkyne complexes with cluster-building reagents. Alkyne complex
Other reagent
Product
Reference
224
I Moleculur Clustcw
center. A theoretical analysis of the mechanism (for M = Co, R = H ) by Hoifmann showed that the most likely pathway involved movement of the alkyne to one edge of the metal triangle followed by scission of the C-C bond. In this instance at least, it appears that loss of the CO ligand occurs after alkyne scission; pathways in which the CO was lost first were calculated to be of much higher energy."'] Certain common factors can be gleaned from the Tables. Firstly, virtually all of the reactions take place under thermal conditions or in the presence of decarbonylating agents such as Me3N0, or sometimes both. This strongly suggests that loss of a carbonyl ligand is an important step in many cases, with the resulting electronic deficit being made up by the conversion of a 4-electron donor alkyne into two 3-electron donor alkylidynes. This is borne out by the fact that in some cases the reaction can be reversed simply by placing the product under an atmosphere of CO. The coupling of two alkylidynes to form an alkyne is also a well-known process in systems where the corresponding alkyne scission is not observed. Secondly, it should be noted that virtually all of the reactions involve disubstituted alkynes; only one example of the cleavage of a terminal alkyne, that of Me3SiC-CH at a tricobalt center, had been reported by Vollhardt before our work detailed below. This is clearly because in most cases other more favorable processes, such as oxidative addition or vinylidene formation, intervene. A third notable point involves the disposition of the resulting alkylidyne ligands in heterometallic clusters. In compounds where CpMo, CpW or CpFe fragments are involved, the alkylidyne ligands in the product are always bonded to these vertices, either as p2-bridges or as p3 face-capping fragments. This also means that the alkylidyne ligand will cap a face consisting of two CpM groups and one metal carbonyl unit, in preference to a face involving one CpM group and two metal carbonyl units. In terms of the synthesis of mixed-metal clusters the third approach, addition of metal fragments to alkyne complexes, is one of the most versatile as the use of different metal-ligand combinations and different reaction conditions can greatly affect the outcome. As an illustration, the rhenium acetylide complex Rez(p-H)(p-C-CPh)(CO)p reacted with Mo2(C0)4Cp2 to give the alkyne butterfly cluster M O ~ R ~ ~ ( , U ~ - H C C P ~ )whereas ( C O ) ~with C ~ Fe3(C0)12 ~, rearrangement to a vinylidene ligand occurred to give spiked triangular Fe2Re2(p3-C=CHPh) (CO)15, and with Co2(CO)s, cluster fragmentation gave initially (OC)5Re(C=CPh){Co2(CO)6}, which on exposure to air gave ReCo2(pul-CPh)(CO)loby C r C ~leavage."~] Our own contributions to this area started in late 1994 as a continuation of our studies of the reactivity of the dimolybdenum alkyne complexes MO~(,UR'C-CR2)(C0)4Cp2 (I), which are readily prepared in high yield (>750/(1) by a one-pot reaction from Mo2(C0)6Cp2 (2) via the reactive triply-bonded dimer Moz(C0)4Cp2 (3). We had previously demonstrated that the reactions of these alkyne complexes with phosphines and thiols were very different to those of their precursors; for example, introduction of the alkyne ligand promoted C-S bond cleavage in thiols to give products with sulfido ligands.[211Given that large numbers of novel dimolybdenum species have been derived from 3 through its reactions with
organic molecules, its use in cluster building has been somewhat limited, and the We therefore decided to examine the possible use of 1 results difficult to in cluster building reactions in the hope that the alkyne ligand would be retained in the product.
Scheme 2. Formulae of the dimolybdenum alkyne complexes.
l a 1b IC Id
Rl=R*=H R1=H,R2=Me R1=H,R2=Ph R1 = H, R2 = C02Me
le If 1g
dh
R1=R2=Me Rl=R2=Et R1= R2 = C 0 2 M e R’=RZ=Ph
1.13.2 Molybdenum-ruthenium clusters Reaction of the disubstituted compound le with ruthenium carbonyl in toluene under reflux gave the blue hexanuclear cluster Mo?Ru4(p3-CMe)2(CO)l 2 C p ~4e in moderate yield (28’%1),along with the known carbido cluster Ru6C(C0)14(q-ChHSMe). Changing the solvent to heptane eliminated this product and left the yield of 4e unchanged. The occurrence of alkyne scission in the product was indicated by its spectroscopic properties, particularly the I3C N M R chemical shift of the alkylidyne carbons at b 353.9, and established conclusively by X-ray analysis; the two alkylidyne ligands symmetrically cap the two Mo2Ru faces (Fig. Unlike most octahedral clusters, which have 86 cluster valence electrons in accordance with the rationalization of the Wade-Mingos rules, the product has only 84 electrons. The seat of this unsaturation appears to be the Mo-Mo bond, which is quite short [2.5792(8) A]. Complexes with bulkier disubstituted alkynes (If, lg) failed to give any products. but when the reaction was extended to complexes la-d containing terminal alkynes two compounds could be isolated: the blue alkyne cleavage products Mo~Ru~(,LQ-CH)(~~-CR’)(CO)~~C~~ 4a-d and the orange trinuclear clusters M ~ ~ R u ( ~ ~ - C - C H R ’ ) (5a-d CO) in,which C ~ ~ the alkyne ligand had rearranged to form a vinylidene. The yields of the former were distinctly low (4-16‘%,) whereas those of the latter were quite reasonable (around 40%). As stated before. the cleavage of any terminal alkyne is a rare event; the formation of the hexanuclear clusters 4a-d is unusual in that it is clearly a general process for a number of simple terminal
226
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 1. X-Ray crystal structure of the product 4e. 1
A, toluene or
1
11'
'R* 4a-e
Scheme 3. Clusters formed by reaction of 1 with ruthenium carbonyl
I 5a-d
I H
I 13 Alkjnc Sciuion on Metal Clirrter Fninictrwks
227
alkynes, and the reaction involving l a is particularly noteworthy as it is the first recorded example of the cleavage of acetylene itself into two methylidyne units on a cluster. Predictably, however, it was also the reaction that gave the lowest yield. Since none of the other reactions of 1 involve alkyne scission, we assume that the C=C cleavage step takes place on a mixed-metal cluster and is evidently intramolecular since unsymmetrical alkyne complexes such as l b give rise only to the corresponding unsymmetrical bis(a1kylidyne) clusters (4b) uncontaminated by the symmetrical clusters (4a, 4e), which would be formed by alkyne scrambling. We have not been able to isolate any intermediate species, and it is interesting that we detected no products analogous to the alkyne clusters W ~ R U ( , L Q - C ~ R ~ ) ( C O ) ~ C ~ ~ previously prepared by Stone and coworkers." 31 It is possible that species like this are intermediates in the alkyne scission reaction and possibly also precursors to the vinylidene clusters 5 , but as yet we have no evidence to confirm or deny this. We did attempt to prepare new MoRu clusters of intermediate nuclearity, which could then be treated with alkynes. In the event, however, heating Mo2(C0)4Cp2 with R u (CO) ~ 12 gave another hexaiiuclear cluster, Mo2 R u ~pug-C)( ( ,u-O)(CO)1zCp2, as the only isolable product in a reaction which appears to involve cleavage of a CO ligand into an interstitial carbide and a bridging 0x0
1.13.3 Molybdenum-cobalt clusters Initially we explored the reaction of alkyne complexes 1 with cobalt carbonyl. This proved an excellent route to high yields of the tetranuclear clusters C02M02(p4-R'C2R2)(CO)sCp2( 6 ) ,which contain the alkyne ligand p4-bonded to a butterfly of metal atoms, with the cobalt atoms situated in the hinge of the butterfly and the molybdenum atoms on the wingtips. N o alkyne scission or rearrangement of the alkyne ligand to a vinylidene was observed.[2s1The reaction of l h with C O ~ ( C O ) ~ failed to give an analogous product. the importance of which only became evident later.
A, toluene
30 min
Scheme 4. Reaction of
la-g with CO?(CO)S giving 6a-g.
I
I
co
co 6a-g
228
I Molecular Clusters
cml
Figure 2. X-Ray crystal structure of the product 7.
We then decided to examine the reactions of alkyne complexes 1 with the dicobalt alkyne complexes Co2(R3C2R4)(C0)6.Most of these were rather unproductive: the usual course seemed to be decomposition of the cobalt complex under the reaction conditions (refluxing toluene) or formation of 6. However, we did succeed l h with in isolating a new complex from the reaction of Mo2(pU-C2Ph2)(CO)4Cp2 C02(,u-C2Ph2)(C0)6in 22% yield. This product showed a peak at 6 363.9 in its 13C NMR spectrum, indicating that alkyne scission had occurred to give an alkylidyne group. Full characterization by X-ray crystallography (Fig. 2) revealed it to be another butterfly cluster, C O ~ M O ~ ( ~ ~ - C P ~ ) ~ ( , U ~(7), -C in~which P ~ ~both )(CO)~C~ alkyne ligands of the reagents have been retained: one cleaved into two benzylidyne groups which cap the external Mo2Co faces of the butterfly, and the other as the intact alkyne bridging the internal faces in the same way as in 6.[261One interesting point is that the metal atom distribution in the butterfly is reversed compared to 6: in 7 the molybdenum atoms form the hinge and the cobalt atoms the wingtips. This may be a result of the preference of the alkylidyne ligands to bond to Mo2Co faces rather than MoCo2 ones due to the strong Mo-C bonds: if the metal atom arrangement in 7 was the same as in 6, the available outer faces would both be MoCo2. Another interesting feature concerns the electron counting: complex 7 has only 58 valence electrons, whereas 6 has the 60 electrons expected for a butterfly cluster of this type.[271As noted above for 4, this unsaturation appears to result in a short Mo-Mo bond, 2.5507( 11) A.
1.13 Alkyne Scission on Metal Cluster- Franieworks
229
The mechanism of formation of 7 was rather intriguing since none of the other combinations of alkyne complexes gave a similar product. By preparing Mo2 and Co2 complexes of di-p-tolyl acetylene and combining them with the corresponding complex of CzPhZ, we attempted to discover which of the alkyne ligands was cleaved and which remained intact. However, this would be virtually impossible to ascertain spectroscopically and in any case, the reactions seemed to give mixtures of isomers. We also noticed that in some of the original reactions, small amounts of a purple compound were formed, which we identified as tetraphenylcyclopentadienone (tetracyclone). This raised the interesting possibility that the two alkyne ligands might link up before the cleavage reaction took place. This led us onto the next phase of our work, involving dinuclear molybdenum metallacyclopentadiene complexes.
Ph
8
Scheme 5. Two routes to complex 7.
1.13.4 Alkyne scission in dinuclear metallacyclopentadiene complexes In their well-known paper on alkyne oligomerization at dinuclear metal centers. Knox, Stone, and co-workers showed that complexes of type 1 reacted with further alkynes under rather forcing conditions (refluxing xylene or octane) to give compounds in which up to four alkynes were linked, with the exact species isolated depending on the alkyne substituents.[281In the case of diphenylacetylene it was shown that reaction of l h with more CzPhz gave a green complex Mo*(,u-C4Ph4)-
230
1 Molecular Clusters
(C0)Cpz (8) containing two alkynes joined in a metallacyclopentadiene unit, and possessing a metal-metal triple bond rather like that in Mo2(C0)4Cp2. The compound could be more conveniently prepared in good yield simply by treatment of Mo2(C0)6Cp2 with an excess of C2Ph2 in refluxing octane. Only bulky alkynes such as diphenylacetylene gave this type of product; presumably the steric bulk is required to achieve the right degree of decarbonylation since an analogous compound, Mo2(C0)(pI-C4Et4)Cp2,reported by Muetterties, could be carbonylated to Mo2(C0)3(p-C4Et4)Cp2 whereas the triple bond in 8 is unreactive towards C0.[291 The compound is however, rather air-sensitive, and on stirring in CH2C12 in air is converted within minutes into a brown complex, which they formulated as Mo20(p-O)(pU-C4P~)Cp2 (9), containing the same metallacyclopentadiene unit.
I
Ph 8
9
Scheme 6. Reaction of 8 with atmospheric oxygen.
We prepared 8 and studied its reaction with cobalt carbonyl. Gratifyingly a rapid reaction (2 h) occurred in boiling toluene to give a 49% yield of the alkyne bis(a1kylidyne) butterfly cluster 7. We therefore believe that the reaction of l h with Co2 (p-C2Ph2)(CO)6 probably proceeds by decomposition of the dicobalt complex and reaction of the liberated alkyne with the dimolybdenum species to give 8, which in turn reacts with a dicobalt fragment. This would also explain the failure of the reactions when the alkyne substituents are changed: if either alkyne is not bulky enough, a complex of this type cannot be formed. If the alkyne attached to the molybdenum center is less bulky, the alkyne complex can however react instead with the liberated dicobalt fragment to give a cluster of type 6; if it is C2Ph2 this will not happen and slow decomposition will be observed instead. Formation of 7 from 8 involves cleaving the four carbon chain into fragments of 2 1 1 carbons. We were hopeful that the reaction of 8 with ruthenium carbonyl might give a complex similar to 4 but containing an alkyne ligand as well as two alkylidynes, but in fact it gave a multitude of products, all in low yield. However we also examined the reaction of the 0x0 complex 9 with the two metal carbonyls. In the case of cobalt carbonyl the only isolable product was the known niixedmetal metallacyclopentadiene complex C O M O ( ~ - C ~ P ~ ~ ) ( C In O the ) ~ case C ~ ~of. [ ~ ~ ]
+ +
1.13 Alkyne Scission on Metal Cluster Frameworks
23 1
ruthenium carbonyl the major product was an unusual bow-tie cluster, Mo2Ru3(p3-O)l(p3-CPh)(pu-C3Ph3)(CO)8Cp2 There were several notable features about this compound. Firstly the four-carbon chain has again been cleaved, but in a different way: this time 3 + 1 carbon fragments have been formed in the shape of a p-CIPh3 dimetalla-ally1 ligand that bridges the two molybdenum atoms, and a p3-CPh group, which as expected caps the MozRu face. The other interesting points and MozRu are the highly distorted nature of the bow-tie shape, in which the R u ~ triangles are virtually perpendicular to each other, due to the presence of the two triply-bridging 0x0 ligands, and the unusual loose coordination of one of the phenyl groups of the CIPh3 ligand to ruthenium.
10
Scheme 7. Reaction of 9 with ruthenium carbonyl
In search of an explanation for the different modes of cleavage of the C4Ph4 ligand in the clusters 7 and 10. we were prompted to examine the 0x0 complex 9 rather more closely. Although at first sight we saw no reason to doubt the formulation proposed by Stone, closer inspection revealed one puzzling inconsistency in the spectroscopic data. The I3C NMR spectrum of 8 contains peaks at 200.0 and 106.7 ppm assigned to the p-CPh and CPh carbons respectively, with the former occurring at lower field due to their bridging carbene character. In 9, the corresponding peaks are at 242.8, 197.9, 90.9 and 84.7 ppm, i.e. there is an unexplained shift of approximately 50 ppm in one of the signals assigned to the bridging CPh carbons. Attempts to grow crystals of 9 or its analogues incorporating q-CsH4Me ligands, p-tolyl substituents on the alkyne, or both were all unsuccessful. We therefore examined some reaction chemistry of 9 in an attempt to resolve this question. A common reaction of molybdenum 0x0 complexes is that with organic isocyanates, which effects the replacement of the 0x0 group by the isoelectronic imido ligand. Complex 9 reacted with PhNCO in refluxing toluene to give a 64% yield of
232
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 3. X-Ray crystal structure showing the structural formula of 1 1 .
11 in which only one of the 0x0 ligands has been replaced by an imido group (replacement of both 0x0 ligands did not prove possible under any conditions). This time we were successful in obtaining crystals of the analogue Mo2(0)(p-CqPh4)(p-NPh)(q-CSH4Me)*.Surprisingly, the crystal structure (Fig. 3 ) showed that the pU-C4Ph4ligand adopts an unprecedented coordination mode in which it is bonded to one molybdenum through an interaction similar to a terminal alkylidene. In fact, this requires only the breaking of one Mo-C bond and effectively involves migration of one bridging carbene-like carbon of the metallacyclopentadiene unit to a
9
I
Ph 11
Scheme 8. Reaction of 9 with PhNCO yielding 11.
terminal position. Since the " C NMR spectrum of the imido complex is very similar to that of the 0x0 complex 9, we propose that this coordination mode is also present in the latter. and that the ligand rearrangement occurs during the oxidation process. probably for steric reasons.[321Consequently the structural formula of 9 is not as shown above, but instead, as shown in Scheme 8, analogous to that of 11.
1.13.5 Conclusions The dimolybdenum alkyne complexes 1 are useful starting materials for the synthesis of heterometallic clusters containing hydrocarbon fragments. In the case of the MORUclusters, we have shown that scission of simple terminal alkynes to produce methylidyne groups is possible, albeit in low yield. In the cobalt system we have isolated high yields of alkyne clusters but alkyne scission only occurs in very specific cases, apparently ciu a nietallacyclopentadiene intermediate. Starting from preformed metallacyclopentadiene complexes, we have shown that the scission of four-carbon chains can be achieved in two ways depending on the metal-ligand fragments employed, and in the process have discovered a novel coordination mode for the nietallacyclopentadiene ring. It is interesting to speculate that some of the reactions in Tables 1-3 which involve more than one alkyne, for example of the type 2 C?Ph2 p3-CPh + j(-C3Ph3. might also proceed cia metallacyclopentadiene intermediates which fragment, rather than by alkyne scission followed by alkynealkylidyne coupling. --f
Acknowledgements Virtually all the work described in this article was performed by an excellent postgraduate student, Miss (now Dr.) Louise J. Gill, whose commitment and enthusiasm remained undimmed throughout three years of hard work. All of the crystal structures were solved by Harry Adams (sometimes assisted by groups of undergraduate students) without whom we would still be completely in the dark about many of our products. We would also like to thank the EPSRC for a studentship and Johnson Matthey plc for a generous loan of ruthenium chloride.
234
I Molecular Clusters
References [I] W. Hubel, in Organic Synthesis via Metal Carhonyls, Ed. I. Wender and P. Pino, Wiley, New York, 1968, p. 273. [2] E. Sappa. A. Tiripicchio and P. Braunstein, Chem. Rev., 1983, 83, 203; Coord. Chem. Rev., 1985, 65, 219; P.R. Raithby and M.J. Rosales, Adv. Inorg. Chem. Radiochem., 1985, 29, 169. [3] J.R. Fritch, K.P.C. Vollhardt, M.R. Thomson and V.W. Day, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 19’79, 101, 2768; J.R. Fritch and K.P.C. Vollhardt, Angew. Chem.; Int. Ed. Engl., 1980, 19, 559; B. Eaton, K.P.C. Vollhardt and J.M. O’Connor, Organometallics, 1986, 5, 394. 141 R.B. King, R.M. Murray, R.E. Davis and P.K. Ross, J. Organomet. Chem., 1987, 330, 115; R.B. King and C.A. Harmon, Inorg. Chenz., 1976, 15, 879. [5] E. Cabrera, J.C. Daran and Y. Jeannin, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., 1988, 607. /6] S.A.R. Knox, K.J. Adams, J.J. Barker and A.G. Orpen, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1996, 975. 171 J.R. Shapley, C.H. McAteer, M.R. Churchill and L.V. Biondi, Oryanometallics, 1984, 3, 1595. [8] J.R. Shapley, M.G. Humphrey and C.H. McAteer, in ‘Selectivity in Catalysis’, Ed. M.E. Davis and S.L. Suib, ACS Symp. Ser., 1993, 517, 127; see also M.C. Comstock and J.R. Shapley, Coord. Chem. Rev., 1995, 143, 501. [9] J.L. Haggitt, B.F.G. Johnson, A.J. Blake and S. Parsons, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., 1995, 1263. [lo] B.F.G. Johnson. J. Lewis, J.A. Lunniss, D. Braga and F. Grepioni, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Conzmun., 1988, 972; D. Bragd, F. Grepioni, B.F.G. Johnson, J. Lewis and J.A. Lunniss, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1991, 2223; 1992, 1101. [Ill H. Yamazaki, Y. Wakatsuki and K. Aoki, Chem. Lett., 1979, 1041. 1121 A.D. Clauss, J.R. Shapley, C.N. Wilker and R. Hoffman, Organometallics, 1984, 3, 619; P. Quenec’h, R. Rumin and F.Y. Petillon, J. Organornet. Chem., 1994, 479, 93. (131 Y. Chi and J.R. Shapley, Organometallics, 1985, 4, 1900; F.G.A. Stone and M.L. Williams, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1988, 2467. [14] J.T. Park, J.R. Shapley, M.R. Churchill and C. Bueno, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1983, 105, 6182; J.T. Park, J.R. Shapley, C. Bueno, J.W. Ziller and M.R. Churchill, Orgunometallics, 1988, 7, 2307. [I51 J.T. Park, B.W. Woo, J.-H. Chung, S.C. Shim, J.-H. Lee, S.-S. Lim and I.H. Suh, Organometallics, 1994, 13, 3384. 1161 M.P. Gomez-Sal, B.F.G. Johnson, R.A. Kamarudin, J. Lewis and P.R. Raithby, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Conzmun., 1985, 1622; J.M. Fernandez, B.F.G. Johnson, J. Lewis and P.R. Raithby, Acta Crystullogr., Sect. B, 1978, 34B, 3086; C.R. Eady, J.M. Fernandez, B.F.G. Johnson, J. Lewis, P.R. Raithby and G.M. Sheldrick, J. Chem. SOC.,Chem. Commun., 1978, 421. [I71 A.D. Shaposhnikova, M.V. Drab, G.L. Kamalov, A.A. Pasynskii, I.L. Eremenko, S.E. Nefedov, Y.T. Struchkov and A.I. Yanovsky, J. Organomet. Clem., 1992, 429, 109; A.A. Pasynskii, I.L. Eremenko, S.E. Nefedov, B.I. Kolobkov, A.D. Shaposhnikova, R.A. Stadnitchenko, M.V. Drab, Y.T. Struchkov and A.1. Yanovsky, New J. Chem., 1994, IS, 69. [IS] R. Rumin, F. Robin, F.Y. Petillon, K.W. Muir and I. Stevenson, Organometallics, 1991. 10, 2274. 1994, 116, 11181; 1191 S.-J. Chiang, Y. Chi, P.-C. Su, S.-M. Peng, G.-H. Lee, J. Am. Chem. SIC., Y. Chi; P.-C. Su, S.-M. Peng and G.-H. Lee, Organometallics, 1995, 14, 5483; Y. Chi, C. Chung, Y.-C. Chou, P.-C. Su, S.-J. Chiang, S.-M. Peng and G.-H. Lee, Organometallics, 1997, 16, 1702. 1201 F.G.A. Stone, J.C. Jeffery, K.A. Mead, H. Razay, M.J. Went and P. Woodward, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 1984, 1383.
I . I3 Allcyie Scission on Mc.tcrl Cluster Frurneicorks
235
1211 G . Conole, K.A. Hill, M. McPartlin. M.J. Mays and M.J. Morris, J. Chern. So(,.,Chern. C(inirnuii., 1989. 688; G. Conole. M. McPdrtlin, M.J. Mays and M.J. Morris, J. Cheni. Soc.. Dalton Tran.?.,1990, 2359; H. Adams. N.A. Bailey, S.R. Gay, T. Hamilton and M.J. Morris, J. Orycinoniet. Chcwi., 1995, 493. C25; H. Adams, N.A. Bailey. S.R. Gay, L.J. Gill, T. Hamilton and M.J. Morris, J. Chmi. Soc., Dalton Trcins., 1996. 2403. 3341. [22] M.D. Curtis, Polj~liedron.1987. 6, 759. 1231 H. Adams, L.J. Gill and M.J. Morris, J. Chrni.Soc., Chnn. Cornmun., 1995. 899 and 1309; Orycinonietnllic,s, 1996. 15. 41 82. [24] H. Adams. L.J. Gill and M.J. Morris. Organorne/aNic~s,1996, 15, 464. [25] H. Adams, N.A. Bailey, L.J. Gill, M.J. Morris and F.A. Wildgoose, J. Chenz. So(,.,Dcilton Truns., 1996, 1437. (261 H. Adams, L.J. Gill and M.J. Morris. J. Client Soc.. D d t o n Truns, 1996, 3909. 1271 E. Sappa, A . Tiripicchio, A.J. Carty and G.E. Toogood, Prog. Inory. Cheni.. 1987, 35, 437. 1281 S.A.R. Knox, R.F.D. Stansfield. F.G.A. Stone, M.J. Winter and P. Woodward. J. Cheni. Soc,.. Dalton Trnns.. 1982, 173. [29] S. Slater and E.L. Muetterties. Inorg. Cheni.. 1980, 19, 3337; E.L. Muetterties and S. Slater, Inorg. Chern.. 1981, 20. 946. 1301 R. Yanez, N. Lugan and R . Mathieu, OrganoriiefaNic.r, 1990. 9) 2998. 131) H. Adams, L.J. Gill and M.J. Morris. J. Orycmoniet. Client, 1997, 533, 117. [32] H. Adams, L.J. Gill and M.J. Morris. J. C'liern. Soc.; Dalton Trcms.. 1998, 2451; L.J. Gill. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Sheffield, November 1997.
Metal Clusters in Chemistry Volume 1: Molecular Metal Clusters Edited by P. Braunstein, L. A. Or0 & P. R. Raithby Copyright OWILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, D-69469 Weinheim (Federal Republic of Germany), 1999
1.14 Multiple Interactions Between Arenes and Metal Atoms Antony J. Deeming
1.14.1 Introduction Arenes have played a special role in the development and applications of organometallic chemistry. In their q6 mode of coordination, they were among the first known polyhapto ligands and form one of the basic building materials of transition metal chemistry since the first rational synthesis of Cr(ChH6)Z by the FischerHafner method."] The phenyl ligand is another fundamental unit in organometallic chemistry. It is coordinated to metal atoms by particularly resilient 0-bonding, and is particularly resistant to p-elimination to give benzyne. Therefore, aryl complexes are among the more stable compounds containing M-C 0 bonds. However, most arene work has been on mononuclear complexes, and the chemistry of phenyl, benzene, and related ligands as bridges is less developed. Using arenes as bridges, there is scope to make full use of both 0 and 71 interactions and to produce a wide variety of structural and bonding motifs. This review will focus on the coordination of benzene in dinuclear and polynuclear metal compounds where coordination is through M-C 0 bonds in conjunction with n-complexation. There is considerable scope for multiple interaction of arenes with metals and the number of known types of benzene incorporation into clusters is steadily increasing. The number of variations in the modes of interaction is potentially enormous as the number of metal atoms coming into play increases. Even with two or three metal atoms the structural possibilities are extensive. Indeed in this article we can do no more than highlight the main features but by doing so we hope to show how the area might develop. Certainly the study of arenes multiply bonded to several metal atoms will lead to greater understanding of how the arene is chemically modified by such interactions (we know little about this at present) and should provide clear models of chemisorbed arenes at metal surfaces or other polymetallic environments. Indeed, we may eventually be able to switch from the
1.14 Multiple Interactions Betliven Arenes nnd Metal Atoms
(co)30s-
237
-0s
Scheme 1. Photo-isomerization of p 3 - $ , ? I 2 , q' benzene to p3-q'. q ' , q z benzyne by a double oxidative addition.
idea of coordinating arenes to metal atoms to the concept of using an arene as a stable electron-rich core or armature about which to construct a metal shell. Initially we will look briefly at bridging arenes, where only n-interactions are involved, but this introduction will be followed by a consideration of systems where both n and o-interactions operate. The p i - g 2 ,g2, q2-CsHs system, first reported by q'. q2-C6H6),[2.31 has proved to be Johnson and Lewis in 1985 for Osi(CO)~(p3-q', an important organometallic type and a sound model for n-benzene absorption parallel to a ( 1 , I , 1) or other triangulated metal surface. The interesting photochemical isomerization of this cluster leads cia an intramolecular rearrangement to the di-o-bonded benzyne cluster Osl(p-H)z(pi-ql,q ' , g'-CsH4)(C0)9,r41which we first observed as a product of the direct thermal reaction of Os3(CO)12with benzene (Scheme l)."' This is a nice simple example of the involvement of both o and n interactions in arene-cluster partnerships and demonstrates the possibility of isoinerization. Firstly let us look at clusters containing just n interactions between the arene and the metal atom array. We will leave o-bonding until later.
1.14.2 Arenes bridging two metal atoms employing only z interactions Benzene can potentially form bridges between metal atoms using either four or six TC electrons. The simplest situation is where a benzene bridge is formed by q 2 coordination to two metal atoms, as found in the dinuclear compound (('Bu2PCH2CH2P'Bu')Ni}2(~LZ-q2,g2-CsH6), type A (Fig. 1).[61 There is no direct contact between the Ni atoms which lie most favorably over opposite faces of the aromatic ring. A similar form of benzene bridging occurs in the com-
238
I Molecular Clusters M
M
A
6
C
M
D M
M -
M E
F G
H
Figure 1. Modes of benzene bridging between two metal atoms (non-planarity of the rings is exaggerated).
pounds r(CsMes)Re(C0)2)2(,u2-r2,q2-CsHd,7(Pd(AlC14)}2(p2-v2, T2-C6H6),'s'and [{OS(NH3)5)2(p2-q2, q2-C,jHs)]4 .[91 Thermal treatment of the diosmium complex leads to loss of ammonia and the formation of what is believed to be a p2-q2, q6-CsH6 complex, type B, although there has been no crystal structure to confirm this.['] Whereas p2-q2,q2-CsH6 coordination is normally through four adjacent carbon atoms as in type A, it has also been found to occur through opposite C-C ~-q~, type C.['O]Benzene can also bridge two bonds in { ( ' B ~ 3 S i 0 ) 3 T a } ~ ( pq2-CsH6), metal-metal bonded metal atoms as in type D (Fig. 1). An example of this is the 34-electron cluster Ru2(CsMe5)2(p-H)(p-PPhz)(p2-q2, q2-CsH,j), which supports a metal-metal bond and therefore the Ru atoms must be on the same face of the arene." '1 In the 1,4-xylene complex Co2(Cy2PCH2CH2PCy2)2(p2-q3, q3-C&Me2-1,4), all six carbon atoms are coordinated as in type E, which produces a 16-electron configuration for each of the cobalt atoms.['23131 Again there is no metal-metal bond. The metal moieties are on opposite faces of the arene ring, which is distorted into a chair form as shown for E in Fig. 1. On the other hand, a boat form F is adopted if the metal atoms are constrained by metal-metal bonding to be on the same side of the arene as in (CsHs)Ir(p2-q3,q3-CsHs)M(CsHs),where M = Co or Rh.[14] This mode of arene coordination is also found in the bridged paracyclophane system Ru2(CO)6(p2-q3,q3-ClhH16).[151 Another mode of benzene bridging G (p2-q4,q4-C6H6 coordination) is found in {(C5H5)Fe)2(p2-q4, q4-CsMes), formed
I . 14 Multiplp I~~tercrctions Between Arenes and Metal Atoms
239
by cyclotrimerization of but-2-yne.[l 31 Finally benzene is found in triple-decker complexes sandwiched between two metal centers in a p2-v6,q6 fashion H. A recently reported example is found in Hf'I4( PMe2Ph)4(p2-V6.T / ~ - C ~ H ~ ) . [ ' ~ ~ Figure 1 shows that there is now a range of different types of p-benzene available to us. There is no reason to believe that this set is exhaustive but it might be difficult to synthesize other types by design. Little work has been done on the organic chemistry of these benzene rings, although the lack of planarity in several of them ( E to C ) , which is rather exaggerated in Fig. 1, would suggest there is a loss of aromaticity. At present there is no evidence for advantages in producing bridging systems to modify the chemistry of the arene.
1.14.3 Arenes bridging more than two metal atoms employing only 7r interactions Benzene lying parallel to a triangle of metal atoms in a trinuclear or higher nuclearity cluster has been shown to be distorted towards a Kekule cyclohexatriene structure such that the shorter C-C bonds are coordinated.r31 There is some evidence that this relates to the geometry found for the attachment of ben~ ~mpounds ~~'~ with p3-q2, q 2 ,g2-C6H6 zene on Pt or Rh ( l . l > l ) s u r f a c e ~ . [ I Co have now been characterized for Os3(CO)9(,u3-q2, q', 17'-Cr,H6),[~.~~] Ru3(C0)9( p 3 - q 2q', , ?72-FhH6),[Z3 2 5 1 Ru3(p-H)3(q-C5Me5)3(p3-q2, q', q2-C6H6),[z61and Co3(C5H5)3(p3-q-, ri', q'-arene).[27~z81 and at triangular faces of various higher nuclearity clusters.rz91These compounds all adopt the C3v structure in which the centers of three shorter C-C bonds lie directly above the metal atoms (structural type A, Fig. 2). A 30" rotation of the benzene ring on the metal triangle would give an alternative C3v structure in which three carbon atoms now lie directly above the metal atoms. There is no evidence that this orientation can provide a ground stage arrangement, although the facile rotation of the benzene on the top of the metal triangle indicates that both conformations must be close in energy. However, geometries close to this alternative C3" arrangement, but distorted from it, have recently been observed. The complex Ru3(p-H)3(C5Me5)3(1(3-v12, $, $-ChHh) adopts the standard structure A and a one-electron oxidation leads to the corresponding monocation, which has the same basic structure.r261However, a two-electron oxidation leads to the dication with the alternative structure B. As well as benzene rotation by 30°, there has been a sideways slippage of the benzene ring towards one ruthenium atom so that the coordination is best described as q' at one ruthenium atom with an q3 bridge across the other pair of metal atoms. The ligand is ,u3-v3, q', $-benzene. The electronic factors (presumably the control is electronic and not steric), which lead to this change in structure on going from the 48-electron cluster to the corresponding
240
I Moleculuv Clusters
M
M
A
Figure 2. Two orientations of benzene coordinated at a triangle of metal atoms shown from above and in perspective.
B
46-electron cluster, still need to defined properly. By going from A to B there is an increase in the number of M-C contacts and this may be favorable for an 'electrondeficient' system. The A-to-B change is reminiscent of the 30" rotation of p3-alkyne from a conformation with the C-C axis parallel to a metal-metal edge to a perpendicular orientation on going from a 48-electron cluster such as O S ~ ( C O ) I O (p3-JI-alkyne)to a 46-electron system such as Fe3(C0)9(p3-l-alkyne).[301 Clearly both A and B provide models for benzene binding at ( 1, I , 1) metal surfaces, which may prove to be compelling analogues of chemisorbed arene states. The only structural precedent for B is the distantly related system in which one benzene of a Ti(l;16-C6H6)2unit bonds to a triangle of Ti atoms in the B-type manner in Ti4(q6-C6H6)2(p-I)3( IAlR2)3.[3 13321
1.14.4 Aryls in metal clusters Metal clusters incorporate aryl ligands in a variety of ways (A to F, Fig. 3). Some forms only differ by small geometric and energetic changes and are not easily distinguishable other than by diffraction methods. Broadly the aryl binds in such ways as to generate electron precise molecules. In going from A through to F, greater electron donation occurs. The phenyl group in A and B donates one electron, in C and D three electrons while in E and F seven electrons are donated. Often it is therefore possible to account: in part, for the observed mode of bonding in terms of the stoichiometry of the molecule. We believe that, although types B to D may be
1.14 Minltiplr Ititrractions BetLceen Arenes und Metul Atonis
241
Q M A
Figure 3. Modes of aryl coordination that are known for metal clusters.
M
B
C
E
F
M D
distinct in the solid state, they may well be in dynamic equilibrium in solution so that solution geometries may not be so easy to define. One might either argue that a phenyl coordinates in a certain way to satisfy the electronic requirements of the metal atoms or alternatively that a phenyl with a particular bonding type controls the structure adopted by the rest of the molecule. Such discussions are usually unhelpful. Why a particular system chooses between A and B is unclear, or between C and D, or between E and F. It is likely that sterics largely determine the structure adopted out of these pairs. The availability of different modes close in energy in many cases allows ligand migrations and structural variability. At present there is little evidence to substantiate these ideas.
1.14.4.1 Terminal aryls in metal clusters Terminal aryl ligands, common in main group organometallics, are infrequently encountered in cluster compounds of the transition metals. Oddly there are no systematic methods of synthesis from common reagents such as aryllithium. Aryl ligands are generally derived by their cleavage from heteroatoms of the reagents used. For example, phenyl transfer from PPh? can lead initially to clusters containing yIi -Ph and p-PPhl, the latter reinforcing the cluster. For example, thermolysis of Pt( PPh3)4 or Pt(C?H4)(PPh?)2leads to isomers of Pt3(gi-Ph)(PPh2)1(PPh3)2 (Fig. 4).[33,341 Different crystalline modifications contain either two short Pt-Pt interactions [2.758(3) A] and one non-bonding Pt. . .Pt interaction [3.586(2)A1 or, alternatively. there are three bonding interactions of intermediate length [two at 2.956(3) A and one at 3.074(4) A].It is perhaps odd that this molec-
242
1 Molecular Clusters
A
8
Figure 4. Crystalline modifications of Pt3(V'-Ph)(,uu-PPh2)3( PPhl)*. Pt-Pt distances: A, 3.586(2), 2.758(3), 2.758(3) A and B, 3.074(4), 2.95613), 2.956(3) A.
ular upheaval appears to have little effect on the phenyl group other than to change its conformation about the Pt-Ph bond. Another example of q'-Ph derived from PPh3 is the formation of R u (q' ~ -Ph)(p-PPh2)(p3-ampy)(p-PhC=CHPh)(C0)5(PPh3) PPh3)2 with diphenyla~etylene.~~~] In addion treating Ru3(pU-H)(p3-ampy)(CO)7( tion to the expected alkyne insertion into a Ru-H bond, a PPh3 ligand has cleaved into Ph and PPh2 fragments. Phenyl cleavage from dppm (PhzPCHzPPh2) also occurs to form the clusterstabilizing fragment p3-PhPCH2PPh2. This process leads to the phenyl clusters Ru3 (ql -Ph)(p3-PhPCH2PPh2)(CsHs)(C0)5[361and Ru3 ( q -Ph)(p3-PhPCH2PPh2)( , L L ~ - C ~ N C ) ( C ~ N C )'I ( CbyO )reacting ~[~ Ru3 (CO)lo(dppm) with appropriate ligands. The dppm ligand also fragments to give a 11'-Ph cluster Ru3(q1-Ph)( ~ ~ - P ~ P C H ~ P P ~ ~ ) ( , U ~ - C - C P P ~ on ~ )thermolysis ( ~ - P P ~ ~of)the ( C bridged O)~[~~] dicluster system {Ru3(dppm)(CO)~}2(pu-Ph2PC=CPPh2). In a related way the tribut phosphine (Ph2P)3CH cleaves to produce Ir3(ql-Ph)(p3-PPh)(p-dppm)(CO)6,[391 with Ru3(C0)12 this ligand gives several products including Ru2(p-q1-Ph)(C0)5{(Ph2P)2CHPPh}.[401 We have shown that a phenyl migration from the 2-pyridyl phosphine Ph2P(2-CsH4N) can occur to give the terminal phenyl ligand and the robust clusterstabilizing p3-PhP(2-C5H4N ) ligand in the cluster O S ~ ( ~ ' - P ~ ) ( ~ ~ - P ~ P C ~ H ~ N ) (Fig. 5).[411 With ruthenium the phenyl migration to Ru occurs, but there is subsequent migration to CO to give the p-benzoyl cluster Ru3(q1-PhCO)(p3-PhPCjH4N)(C0)9.[42'431 One example of q' -aryl formation not involving tertiary phosphines is the formation of Co3(q'-C6Fj)(p3-S)(CO)gfrom C6F5SSC6F5 and Co2(CO)s by both C-S and S-S bond cleavage.[441 The bridging p-q'-phenyl ligand B and the terminal q'-phenyl ligand A (Fig. 3 ) are both one-electron donor ligands, so it is not easy to predict which would be
'
1.14 Multiple Interactions Between A r e n a and Metal Atoms
243
L 1431
'
Figure 5. Molecular structure of Osq(q -Ph)(p?-PhPCTH4N)(CO)y.
formed in a particular case. Presumably the choice is controlled by steric effects but one might suppose that, if there are no overriding reasons against it, the ligand will adopt mode B to maximize the metal-to-ligand interactions. The phenyl clusters described in this section are all electron precise considering the phenyl as a oneelectron donor. Since both A and B (Fig. 3) are one-electron donors, one might envisage rapid Ph migration between terminal and bridging positions and hence between metal centers. N o experimental evidence for this can be cited. However, the ability of the ligand to be terminal or bridging suggests a potential for phenyl mobility within clusters or at surfaces. The occurrence of terminal rather than bridging Ph depends upon small steric or electronic factors and explanations cannot be given with confidence.
1.14.4.2 Bridging aryls without Ic-coordination These occur more commonly than terminal phenyl ligands, presumably because of the increased M-C contact as indicated (Fig. 3, type B). CopperiI), silver( I ) and gold( I ) compounds with these bridges are particularly well studied.[4s1A number of binary aryl transition metal complexes of the type M,Ary have been synthesized. Those with bulky aryls such as mesityl (mes) or perfluorophenyl are the most tractable, the bulk preventing further oligomerization or polymerization. Some
244
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 6. Representations of the structures of r;e2(p-rl'-rnes)2jrl1-mes)4and Mn3(p-v' -mesh( q -mes)z.
'
'
'
examples are Fez(p-q -mes), ( qI - m e ~ ) * , [ ~and ~ ] Mn3 (p-q' -mes)4(y - m e ~ ) 2 , [ ~ " ~ ) ~ (M~ 'and - C M' ~ F ~are ) ~any ), (Fig. 6) and [ N B U ~ ] ~ [ M M ' ( ~ - ~ ' - C ~ F where combinations of Pd and Pt.[48,49]Related p-y I-phenyl bridges are probably the standard motif in many phenyl species but these are usually polymeric and ill-defined. While the structure of PhCu is unknown, derivatives such as [Li(THF)4] [CugPhs] (Fig. 7) contain such bridges,r50]as does [Cu3(p-q'-Ph)2 ( M ~ ~ N C H ~ C H ~ N M ~ C H ~ C H ~ NinMboth ~ ~ the ) ]cation [ C Uand ~P the~anion.[511 ~] No more than an indication of our knowledge of this type of bridging aryl is presented here. In the transition metal cluster arena, this type of phenyl bridge is also well established, the first example (Fig. 8) being characterized more than 25 years ago by Nyholm et d.[52,531 They obtained product Os?(p-y'-Ph)(p~-PhPC6H4)(p-PPhz)(CO)g as one of many from the direct thermal reaction of Os3(CO)12 with PPh3. I still remember the surprise when this and other triosmium derivatives
Figure 7. Structure of the anion in [Li(THF)4]+[CusI'hs]
I . 14 Multiple Inteructions Between Avenes and Metal Atoms
245
Figure 8. Structure of Os?(p-q -Ph)(p~-PPh~)(p;-PhPC6Hl)jCO)~, the first example of d symmetrical p q ' -phenyl bridge in transition metal clusters
such as benzyne clusters were obtained from this very simple, commonplace reaction. Other examples of compounds containing /r-yl-Ph ligands are Ru3( p-v'-Ph)(p3-ampy)(~l-PPh2)2(C0!6;[35'54' OS~(/L -Ph)( - ~ ,' u - C ~ H ~ N ) ( C1 O 0 , )' ~ ~ ' R u ~ ( ~I -Ph)-v (p3-ampy)(p-PPh2)(C0)7( PPh3)[561(which reacts with CO to give a terminal vl-Ph intermediate prior to Ph migration back to PPhz to reform PPh3), and Ru3-
(p-qI-Ph)(p3-Me~NCONH)(,~r-PPh2)2(C0)6.'~'~ Aryl coordination of this type may be further supported/stabilized by additional interactions. For example, aryl halides are known to act as donors through the halogen atom and in [Pt2Ag(SC4H8)(p-ChF5)2(C6F5)4] the two bridging pentafluorophenyl groups bridge two platinum atoms as p-v'-bridges but there is an additional bonding between ortho-fluorine atoms and the silver atoms. Therefore, these ligands could be considered to be p j coordinated. Figure 9 shows the core of this anionic complex.[581
F
Figure 9. The central core of j Pt?Ap(SC4Hx)(/(I-C~Fj)2(1~ '-C<,Fj)?]-.
F
246
I Molecular Clusters
A
8
orthogonal to the plane of the phenyl, which is the normal situation.
In most p-ql -Ph ligand systems the aryl bridge is approximately symmetrical and the M-M vector is orthogonal to the plane of the arene. This perpendicular arrangement seems to require 3-centered bonding A (Fig. lo), but the observed perpendicular orientation has been used to invoke the contribution of the component B. The alternative in-plane coordination would require a four coordinate planar carbon and this has been observed in the case of the complex V2{2,6-(Me0)2C6H3}4 in which two of the four aryl ligands are constrained to adopt this geometry by the presence of additional coordination through ortho-Me0 groups (Fig. 1 l).[591
1.14.4.3 Bridging aryls with z-coordination through a single carbon atom The bridge C shown in Fig. 3 has been described a semi-bridging and is found in Zn2Ph4,which adopts a different type of bridge from that in A12Ph6, which contains symmetrical p-q'-Ph ligands of type B. The ZnPh2 subunits, distorted from linear, are linked through type C Ph-bridges. The p-q'-Ph bridges could be considered to
j 2
Figure 11. Representation of the structure of V(2,6-(MeO)&$I3}4.
1.14 Multiple Inteructions Between Arcnes and Metal Atoms
241
Scheme 2. Double oxidative addition of PhSeSePh to give bridging Ph and PhCO ligands.
be a-bonded to one Zn atom and, with longer orthogonal interaction to the other Similar situations are Zn atom, could be considered rr-complexed to that atom.*601 encountered in transition metal clusters. The C6F5 bridge in Pt3(p-q1-CgF5)(qIC6F5)3(PPh2)2contains a short a-Pt-C bond length of 2.108(10) A and a long orthogonal Pt-C distance of 2.621(10) A.i611Counting the p -q '- C s F ~ as a 3electron donor, the cluster attains a 44-electron count by an additional q2-interaction to a phenyl of the diphenylphosphido bridge. Another example of this quite derived rare mode of coordination is found in Os3(,uU-ql-Ph)(p-PhC0)(,u~-Se);!(CO)s by a triple oxidative addition of PhSeSePh to [Os,(CO)lo(MeCN)2] (Scheme 2).i621 This compound is saturated if the p-11'-Ph behaves as a 3-electron donor. As in the Pt case above, there is a short a-0s-C bond length of 2.24(2) A and a long orthogonal 0s-C distance of 2.51(2) A. Another example of this type of bridge, but doubled, is present in the 2,2'-biphenyldiyl nickel compound, Ni3(,u3-C12Hs)(,u3C6H4)(P'Prj)3, in which biphenyl is chelated through a-Ni-C bonds at one nickel with secondary interactions of the nickel-bonded carbon atoms at the other two nickel atoms.i631
1.14.4.4 Bridging aryls with n-coordination through two carbon atoms The p - q l , q2-type of coordination, first observed for ligands such as bridging alkenyl or alkynyl, has only recently been shown for aryl ligands (type D, Fig. 3 ) . Treatment of the pentamethylcyclopentadienyl compound Ir2Cpf2(C0)2with the diazonium salt [ 4-MeOCbH4N2][BF4] leads to the addition compound [Ir2Cp*2(puq ' . q2-CsH40Me)(C0)2][BF4]in which the aryl is bridging as shown in Scheme 3.[641Its NMR spectra down to -90 "C are consistent with a symmetrical aryl bridge and not the p - q ' , q'-bonding mode established in the crystal. Of course, there could have been a structural change to the symmetrical form in solution but more likely there is a rapid oscillation of the ligand between the two Ir atoms. The only other case of the p - q ' , q2-bonding mode for phenyl is that in Ru3(p-q', q2-Ph)(p3-S)(p-PPh?)(CO)s[ PPh3) formed by fragmentation of PPh3.[651
248
1 Molrculur Clusters
Rf- J!i Me0
OMe
-
\ -
Cp'lr A c C
A
-I k p *
-
--
,.
Cp'lr
,
. Ir Cp* C 0
0 0
Scheme 3. Rapid p q ' , q2-phenyl oscillation.
1J4.4.5 Bridging aryls with Ic-coordination through all six carbon atoms Bridging phenyl in the compound MnCr(p-y', q6-Ph)(CO)7(PPh3) is a-bonded to the Mn atom and y6-coordinated to a Cr(C0)3 group.[661In effect the complex Mn(y1-Ph)(C0)4(PPh3) is behaving as a six-electron donating y6 arene ligand at the Cr(C0)3 group. There is no significant bonding between the metal atoms. In several osmium and ruthenium clusters of the general type Ms(p-y', y6-Ph)(pU-X)(CO)8 where X is a 3-electron donor (I, SR, C4H3N), the phenyl bridges across the termini of a M3 chain of atoms (Fig. 12). These compounds have been derived in various ways. Oxidative addition of PhSR ( R = Ph or Fc) to R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ leads by S-C cleavage to the phenyl products Ru3(pU-q', y6-Ph)(p-SR)(CO)g.[671 Similarly, oxidative addition of iodoarenes (ArI) to Ru3(CO)12 leads directly to the stable products Ru3(p-y1,q6-Ar)(p-I)(CO)g, a reaction successful for a range of different aryl iodides.[681The ' H NMR spectrum of the Ph compound shows five different signals since the p-I atom is out of the R u plane. ~ The cluster is rigid. The iodo group stays on one side of the R u ~plane and the phenyl group is likewise immobile. This rigidity results in non-interconvertible isomers from the addition of 3,4-dimethyliodobenzene as shown in Scheme 4. Although this appears to be a
l z ) o C('O ( Mh, - , M X
Figure 12. Structural formula for clusters of the type M ~ ( P - vqh-Ph)(p-X)!Co)8. ',
I . 14 Mciltijd~Interrrctions Betwwn A~rncIsund Metal Atoms
' Me
+
249
+
Scheme 4. Oxidatiw addition of aryl iodides to R L I ~ ( C O J ~ ~
simple reaction, studies on substituted aryl iodides shows that rearrangements are possible. For example, Scheme 4 shows that 2-methyliodobenzene gives the 3methylphenyl product (as a pair of orientational isomers) and 4-methoxyiodobenzene gives the 3-methoxyphenyl product (also as orientational isomers) in addiWe believe tion to the methoxybenzyne cluster, Ru4(p4-V'-C4H30Me)(CO),~.1~81 that these reactions may occur i-ia dehydroiodination to give benzyne intermediates since this provides a pathway for rearrangement. Loss of two CO ligands from Os3(,uu-V'-Ph)(p-C4H6N)(CO)lo results in a re. '] arrangement of the phenyl bridge to the seven-electron donating p - ~ 'V6-mode.IS To form an electron-precise product a 0 s - 0 s bond is cleaved in the process. Given that phenyl ligands can have the various modes of coordination A to C (Fig. 3) using just the one carbon atom, one can imagine that seven-electron donation could be achieved by v6 in conjunction with different types of q' coordina-
250
I Molecular Clusters
Figure 13. Structure of p j - q ' , q6-Ph in OsdRu ( p j - q ' , q6-Ph)(p-H)3{P(OMe)3}(CO)12.
tion and this has been demonstrated by the formation of O S ~ R U ( P - H ) ~ ( P ~ - P ~ ) (CO)12{P(OMe)3] .[691 This compound is synthesized by cation-anion coupling of [Os4H2(C0)12I2- with [Ru(CgHg)(MeCN)3I2+. Subsequent treatment of the benzene-containing product with trimethylphosphite results in an internal oxidative addition of benzene to give phenyl plus hydride ligands. The spiked tetrahedral structure is shown in Fig. 13. The scope for phenyl coordination is large and we should look forward to the discovery of various new modes of coordination but these discoveries will be largely fortuitous since the very flexibility of the aryl system works against any designed synthesis. An aspect of aryl coordination not covered in this account is where an aryl-to-metal bonding occurs as part of a more complex ligand system, usually including coordinated heteroatoms. For example, we have shown in Scheme 5 a cluster that contains, as a component, a substituted form of the Ph ligand E in Fig. 3.[70*7'1 The cluster Ru3(p3-CgH4CHCH)(CO)sformed by loss of sulfur from benzothiophene contains the same type of p-q',v6-coordinated aryl as in Fig. 12. We will not attempt to describe this more complex chemistry further but an examination of multicomponent ligands of this type could lead to ideas about new motifs that could be applied to 'pure' aryl complexes.
Scheme 5. Sulfur extrusion from benzothiophene at RW(CO)IZ.
1.14.5 Arynes in metal clusters Most studies have been on the parent ligand C6H4, which in the free state is ben~ y n e . [ ~ However, '] the two carbon atoms that are not bonded to hydrogen are
1.14 Multiple Interactions Between Arenes and Metal Atoms
251
normally o-bonded to metal atoms in clusters and therefore there is little chemical resemblance between free and coordinated benzyne. Some authors have preferred therefore to call the ligand ovtho-phenylene to avoid this comparison but in organometallic nomenclature it is usually most convenient to use the name the ligand would have if metal-free. We talk of coordinated alkynes for convenience even though they might be better described as metallacyclopropenes. Describing the bonding of coordinated ChH4 can create problems in some cases and this is apparent in the more complex examples in Fig. 14. Benzyne ligands are known to coordinate to between one and five metal atoms in molecular species. Almost certainly chemists in the course of time will discover additions to the twelve known types A to L we have given in Fig. 14.
8
9 M-
M
M-
M
B
A
M
\
M--M
M E
D
C
-M
F
M
M-
G
J
-M
K
Figure 14. Modes of benzyne interaction with one to five metal atoms.
H
L
252
I Moleculur Clusters
1.14.5.1 Terminal y2-arynes Benzyne formally corresponds to an alkyne and it is not surprising that there are many benzyne and alkyne compounds that correspond directly, in stoichiometry, structure and bonding. However, with benzyne having potentially up to eight electrons for metal binding and alkyne only four, one can account for the greater variety of geometric and bonding types found for benzyne as a ligand. Coordination of benzyne to a single metal atom in a complex is now quite common, especially with early transition metals such as zirconium, but there are examples right across the d-block metals (y2-coordination of type A, Fig. 14). Zr(y2-C6H4)(PMe3)Cp2,[741 Some examples are Ta(y2-C6H4)(y-C5Me5)Me2,[731 Ke(q2-CsH3Me) (q1-C6H4Me)( PMe3)2,r751Ru(y2-C6H4)(PMe3)4,[761Ni(y2-C6H4) (CY~PCH~CH~PCY More ~ ) . ~examples ~'] are provided in reference 72. Alkynes coordinated to transition metals are not linear because the substituents are bent away from the metal. This accounts, to some extent, for the metal-stabilization of arynes since the ligand intrinsically has this geometry. Known mononuclear benzyne complexes are fewer than those of alkyne, not because they are less stable, but mainly because the benzyne ligand must be generated within the coordination sphere by an elimination process, whereas no such problems apply to the synthesis of alkyne complexes. There is a strong driving force favoring bridging modes of benzyne over terminal ones and this has prevented the isolation of stable clusters containing benzyne bonded to just one metal center. This effect is the consequence of the thermodynamic stabilization resulting from forming multiple interactions with metal centers. The same applies to other unsaturated ligands such as alkynes, alkylidenes etc. which occur only very rarely terminally in metal clusters and then usually as reaction intermediates.
1.14.5.2 Arynes bridging two metal atoms One way a bridge can be formed between two metal centers is to generate the dibenzyne ligand C6H2, which links the two nickel atoms in the compound { N ~ ( C ~ ~ P C H ~ C H ~ P,2,4,5-C6H2), C ~ ~ } ~ ( ,although L L - ~this might be properly thought of as two separate metal-to-benzyne entities of the type discussed in Sec. 1.14.5.1.[''I Intuitively one would expect a benzyne ligand to bridge two metal atoms by two 0-bonds as in type B (Fig. 14) and that this would be a more stable than the terminal bonding mode A. The four membered M2C2 ring is essentially unstrained, the longer M-M distance allowing the most favorable angles at the carbon atoms to be accommodated. There are examples in main group chemistry, such as Hg3(C6H4)3which forms a 9-membered ring.[781This compound, the magnesium analogue, and the dilithio compound Liz(C6H4) have be used to transfer the C6H4 ligand by metathesis with metal halides. This method has been used in the
1.14 Multiple Interactions Between Arenrs und Mt.tal Atoms
253
reaction of Mg4(THF)4(C6H4)4 (which contains ,LQ- rather than p2-CsH4 ligands, see below) with InC12 {2,6-(Me2NCH2)C6H3) to give the dinuclear compound
In2(p-C6H4):,-{2,6-(Me2NCH2)2C6H3}.[791 In general, this has not been used as a method in transition metal chemistry where the CsH4 ligand has been derived from phenyl phosphines or from benzene itself by double oxidative addition reactions. For example, the complex Ir:,(q-CgMe5)2(p-O)(PPh3) undergoes an interesting isomerization in benzene at 85 "C to give ~ ( p-C6H4)jp1-OH)(p-PPhl).Triphenylphosphine and not benzene is the Irz ( v - C Me5)2 source of the benzyne.[801This is also the case in the formation of the corresponding formed by treating Ir?(Y-C5Me5)2hydride I~~(~-C~M~~)~(~-C,~H~)(,LL-H)(,LI-PP~:,) HzCI:, with PPh3 and hydroxide ion using phase-transfer methods.["] On the other hand, solvent is the source of benzyne in the formation of I ~ : , C P ~ ( ~ - C ~ H ~by) ( C O ) ~ UV-photolysis of IrCp(CO):, in benzene.[s21Likewise in the treatment of palladium acetate with S'Pr2 in refluxing benzene to give Pd4(p-C,jH4):,(p-S1Pr2)2(p-MeC0:,)4, the bridging benzyne is formed from the ~ o l v e n t . ' Thermal ~ ~ . ~ ~ decomposition ~ of this compounds generates triphenylene. Fig. 15 shows some of these p-CbH4 complexes. The benzyne ligand can bridge across a very wide range of distances between the metal atoms. For example, there is a considerable difference in the Ir-Ir distances in the above diiridium compounds with p-CcH4 bridges: 3.369(1) for Ir2(C5H5)2(p-OH )( p-PPh2)(p-CgH4),['O12.7 17 A for Ir2(C5H5):,(CO):,( , u - C ~ H ~ ) , [ ' ~ ] The hydroxy-bridged and 2.8901(4) A for Ir2(C5Me5)2(p-H)(p(-PPh2)(p-C6H4).['l1 species is a 36-electron species and there is formally a non-bonding Ir-Ir contact whereas in the other two 34-electron species a single Ir-Ir bond results in shorter distances. In the Pd4 compound there are no Pd-Pd bonds and the CsH4-bridged Pd-Pd distance is as large as 3.595(2) the longest distance in this set of compounds. Therefore benzyne can bridge both bonded and non-bonded metal pairs and can accommodate a good range of metal-metal distances.
Figure 15. Examples of pbenzyne bridging two metal atoms.
254
I Molecular Clusterh
L
THF
THF
which includes bridges of the type shown
p.-
Mg
Scheme 6 . Formation of
: Mg
Mg
Mg4(C6H4)4(THF)4
1.14.5.3 Arynes bridging three metal atoms Four geometrically and electronically distinct forms of p3-benzyne, C to F in Fig. 14, have been currently identified. Most examples of p3-benzyne are for transition metals and then there are both a and 71 interactions between the arene and the metal atoms, types D to F. There is just one example of ligand type C, found in a p3-benzyne compound of magnesium, that seems to be supported purely by a-interactions. Scheme 6 shows the transfer of benzyne from the cyclic trimer Hg3(p-CsH4)3 to magnesium to give Mg4(THF)4(p&,jH4)4, which has a cubane structure diagrammatically represented in Scheme 6. The p3-benzyne ligand orthogonally caps a triangle of Mg atoms through a a-bond to one Mg atom and an unsymmetrical three-center 2-electron bridge across the other two manganese atoms, type C (Fig. 14).[781 This type of bridge has not been observed in transition metal compounds where 71 complexation seems to be favored instead. All the other forms of p3-benzyne bridge (D to F, Fig. 14) involve two a-M-C bonds and 71interaction. In the most common form D (p3-q1,q ' , q 2 ) ,the a-M-C bonds can span a bonded or non-bonded pair of metal atoms. Type E (p3-q1,q l , q ' ) involves two 0M-C bonds and a 71-interaction between just one carbon atom and metal, while F (p3-q1,q l , q 6 ) has so far only been found when one metal atom is not bonded to the other two and is really an extension of type B. p3-Benzyne ligands can be derived from various precursors, the simplest being benzene. An example is given in Scheme 7.
1.14 Multiple Interactions Betbt,een Arenes and Metal Atoms
255
H Double oxidative addition L
P-C and C-H cleavage
Scheme 7. A double oxidative addition of dimethylpheiiylphosphine to form a p - q ' , q ' , q2-ChH4 complex.
a. Double oxidative addition of benzene. Direct reaction of benzene with Os3(CO)12 yl, q2-C6H4)at about 460 K gives poor to moderate yields of Os3(p-H)2(,~~(3-q~, ( C O ) I J . ' ~The ~ ] rate of this reaction seems to be controlled by CO dissociation since Os?(CO)lo(MeCN)?reacts at 363 K.[x61The same product may be obtained by the > 290 nm) of Os3(,u3-q2,q 2 ,q2ChH6)(C0)9in toluene at UV-photoisomerization (i 278 K (Scheme l).[41Irradiation of the CbH6 compound isolated in solid Ar or CH4 matrices showed that the isomerization occurs without CO loss and a primary photoproduct of unknown structure was observed spectroscopically. It seems reasonable that the two oxidative additions occur sequentially so one intermediate although this may not be the intermediate is likely to be Os3(pCI-H)(p-C6H~)(C0)g, species that was observed. b. From benzyl alcohol or benzaldehyde. Thermolysis of the benzyl alcohol oxidative addition product Os3(p-H)(pu-OCH2C6H5)(CO)lo leads c i i Os3(p-H)2(p3-q1, q l , q2-C6H4)(C0)9 to benzene, benzaldehyde, Osi(CO)12 and O S ~ H ~ ( C O ) ~ ~Likewise, .["] benzaldehyde reacts with Os3(CO)12 to give Os3(p-H)( ~ - C ~ H ~ C O ) ( Cwhich O ) I ~decarbonylates . to give the same benzyne cluster.[881 c. From p3-phenylmethylidyne. At 493 K the alkylidyne compound Os3(p-H)3( L ( ~ - C C ~ H ~ ) ( isomerizes CO)~, to two isomers of the methylbenzyne cluster Os3(p-H)?(pj-q',q ' , $-C6H3Me)(CO)g.[8q1 This reaction is particularly interesting because of its reversibility. Another more rapid process in O S ~ ( , D - H ) ~ ( ~ ~ - C C ~ H ~ ) (C0)g leads to the intramolecular exchange of phenyl and hydride protons.[901 d. By aryne formation in the coordination shell of the cluster. The alkyne cluster Ru~H~(,u~-~'-7-oxabicyclo[2.2.l]hept-5-en-2-endo-y1 benzoate)(CO)s was synthesized by a double oxidative addition to Ru3(C0)12. On treatment with Me3SiOS02CF3 (TMSOTf),this cluster is reduced and benzoic acid is eliminated 9 ' . q2-C6H4)(C0)9and other products. This seems to be to give Ru3(p-H)2(p3-v1. the only example of benzyne synthesis in . r i f ~ . [ ~ ~ ] e. From phenyl phosphines or arsines. This is the first and most commonly applicable route. Nyholm and co-workers were the first to observe that the triphe-
256
I Molrczilur Clusters
nylphosphine ligand fragments on reaction with O S ~ ( C O ) ~ ~Two . [ of ~ ~ten~ ~ ~ ~ ” ~ and products are the benzyne clusters Osi(p3-q1,q’, q2-C6H4)(p-PPh2)2(CO)~ Os3(p-H)(p3-ql, q’, q2-C6H4)(p-PPh2)(CO)7( PPh3 ). Clearly the fragmentation of PPh3 has occurred and this type of chemistry has been applied to triarylarsine~,[~*] mixed alkylaryl phosphines and a r s i n e ~ , [ ~to~ ~ ferrocenylphenylphos~~] p h i n e ~ , [ ~ ~ and - to phenylphospholes.[’021The cleavage of, for example, PMe2Ph at a triosmium cluster (Scheme 7) requires an ortho C-H and a P-C bond to be cleaved in a double oxidative addition but the sequence of these fragmentations is not always clear, although there seems to be evidence that an orthometallation occurs first in some if not most cases. The evidence for the course of the thermolysis reaction of Osl(CO)11(PMePhz) is clearer. The observation of intermediates (Scheme 8) shows that in this case orthometallation occurs first, followed by benzene elimination (probably via phenyl transfer from phosphorus to metal as in Sec. 1.14.4). The generation of the CsH4 ligand occurs late in the reaction by a final P-C bond cleavage. There is considerable scope for isomerization and formation of isomers in these reactions leading to benzyne. In the conversion of Os3H3(pl-CPh)(CO)g to Os3(p-H)*(p3-q1,q ’ , q2-CsH3Me)(CO)g,the two possible isomers of methylbenzyne are p r o d ~ c t e d . ’ The ~ ~ ] benzyne formed is not always the expected one. For example, the thermolysis of Os3(CO)I1 (MezAsCsHqMe-2) gives the benzyne cluster Osl-
60 ___L
m R
Scheme 8. Established route for the conversion of OS~(,U~-PM~)(,U~-C~H~)(CO)~ from OS~(CO)I 1 (PMePhz). All compounds except that in square brackets have been fully characterized.
I . I 4 Multiple Inteructions Betiteen Arenes ~ i n dMrtul A t o i m
/!SAH*
/ \ I
0s
~
L H I O S
__
257
fi H +u*
Process B
os-
Scheme 9. Mechanism for the exchange of CH with OsHOs hydrogen atoms
(p-H)(~i-AsMez)!p3-q1, q ' . q2C6H4Me-4)(C0)9.The unexpected product, Os3(p-H)(p-AsMe2)(p3-q1,q l ,q2CgH40Me-3)(CO)9 is also obtained from O S ~ ( C O ) ~ I ( M ~ " s C ~ H ~ O M ~ - ~ ) .A' ~ possible '' origin of these rearrangements has been ~UJ-~'~ provided by spin saturation transfer experiments on O S ~ ( , L ~ - H )q~l ,(q2-C6H4)(CO)9.[1"31 In addition, to a very fast intramolecular rotation/flip (process A) of the benzyne and hydride migrations about the cluster edges, a much slower process B involving H-atoms moving between metal and aryne sites has been identified (Scheme 9). Equilibrium between phenyl and benzyne compounds could account for the rearrangements described above. This process allows site exchange of all carbon atoms in the 6-membered ring. The fast process A in Scheme 9 involves both rotation and flipping of the aryne. By introducing an isopropyl group into Os3(,u-H)(p-AsMe2)(p3-q'3 '1' ,q2-C6H;Pr)(C0)9, it was possible to show that the isomerization of the two isomers by aryne rotation occurred concomitantly with exchange of the diastereotopic isopropyl methyl groups MeA and MeB consistent with the flip shown in Scheme 9.r981Notice that the inversion process leads to the exchange of the diastereotopic methyl groups and that the high rate of inversion generally will prevent the separation of enantiomers. This dynamic mobility of the p3-benzyne is a characteristic behavior found in most cases. Although mode D (Fig. 14) is the most common form of p3-benzyne, mode E is observed as an alternative when the aryne bridges an open trinuclear cluster through rr bonds across a bonded pair of metal atoms. The bonding in Os3(p3-X)( ~ ~ - C ~ H ~ ) ( Cwhere O ) Y ,X = PPh,[961PMe,[94.951PFc,"''] PPhCr(CO)3,"041 or As(tolyl),[921 is probably best described as a di-a-bonded benzyne with an additional n-interaction with the third metal atom through one carbon rather than the more common two carbon atoms (Fig. 16). This seems reasonable in view of the open
258
I Molecular Clusten
Figure 16. Structure of the clusters M3(p3-PR)(p3-qi,q i , q i C6H4)(C0)9showing the n interaction in addition to two M-C a-bonds.
R
nature of the cluster but does not explain why the benzyne does not bridge the ends of the open cluster as in other cases. Benzyne is rapidly mobile in these compounds. Mode F of p3-benzyne is quite different since the ligand is an 8-electron rather in than a 4-electron donor. Thermolysis of R u ~ ( C O1){MeZAsCgH5Cr(C0)3), I which a Cr(C0)3 unit is y6-coordinated to the dimethylphenylphosphine ligand, gave as one of the two products the cluster R U ~ ( ~ - H ) ( ~ - A S M ~ ~ ) { ~ - C ~ H ~ C with a type F benzyne, apparently the only known example.['051
1.14.5.4 Arynes bridging four metal atom There are as many a five different modes G to K of p4-benzyne coordination (Fig. 14) but some of these only differ in detail. Thermal treatment of R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ ( P P ~ ~ ) leads to the tetra and pentanuclear clusters Ru4(CO)11(p4-PPh)(p4-y1,y I , y4-CsH4) y l , y6-C6H4) (Sec. 1.14.5.5).[1061It is believed that and Ru5(CO)13(p4-PPh)(p5-y1, y ', y1-C6H4), analthese are formed via the intermediate Ruj(CO)s(p3-PPh)(p3-y1, ogous to the known osmium compound from the corresponding reaction. Successive additions of Ru(CO), units would lead to the tetra and pentanuclear products. The benzyne ligand in the tetranuclear compound is coordinated as in G (Fig. 14) and is a 6-electron donor. The related compounds Ru4(CO)11(p4-PR)(p4-y1, y', y4C6H4) where R = F C " ~ 'or ] CH2NPh2['061are also known. These structures are clearly different from those of the known alkyne compounds R u ~ ( C O1)(p4-PR)(p4-y', I y -alkyne) where the alkyne bridges diagonally across the metal square and not parallel to one edge as with benzyne. Having more 71electrons, benzyne has a greater capacity to develop metal-carbon contacts than alkyne. The diagonal mode of benzyne coordination is unknown. Furthermore, mode H is also unknown for benzyne bridges, although this geometry may be an intermediate in the fluxionality of pq-y', y I , y4-C6H4 ligands in a process in which
'
1.14 Multiple Inteructions Between Arenrs and Metul Atoms
4?
iM M - -M\
tilted
M-
259
-M
\ M-M
almost vertical
M-M
tilted
vertical and diagonal
Figure 17. Different geometries of attachment of benzyne, 1,2-naphthyne, 2,3-naphthyne and 2,3thiophyne depending upon their ability to sustain v4 coordination in R u ~ ( C O1)(,ud-PR)(p4-aryne). ,
the benzyne flips while the C-C bond remains parallel to one M - M edge. In q ' , q4the corresponding 1,2-naphthyne species R u ~ ( C OI)(p4-Pnaph)(p4-q1, I C I ~ H ~formed ), from P(l-naphthyl)3, the ligand is still parallel to a M-M edge but much more closely vertical, approaching the geometry H.[ln8]One could argue that the double bonds in the 1,2-naphthyne are not set up for q4 coordination as for benzyne and so that the arene plane is nearly vertical with an angle of 73.5" to the II q ' , q4-C6H4). Conmetal plane compared with 51 . I " in R u ~ ( C O )(p4-PPh)(p4-q1, sistent with this it has recently been shown that the 2,3-naphthyne ligand achieves q4 coordination in a very similar manner to the benzyne compound because this mode of coordination is energetically favorable (Fig. 17).['09] Also the corresponding 2,3-thiophyne derivative is unable to accommodate q4 coordination but in this case the diagonal geometry like that of alkynes is adopted.["'] One would predict that 3,4-thiophyne would adopt the geometry of type G (Fig. 14). It is useful to explore this analogy between known alkyne systems and potential benzyne ones. For example, alkynes react with ruthenium carbonyl to form the Ru4(q2-alkyne)(CO)12, which form an octahedral Ru4C2 arrangement with the metal atoms in a butterfly geometry. Since the synthesis cannot be adapted to arynes, another method is needed. Oxidative addition of aryl iodides to R u ~ ( C O ) ~ ~ gives the p-q',q6 aryl complexes described in Sec. 1.14.4.5. However, we have found that some polycyclic iodoarenes undergo dehydrohalogenation to give clusters of the type Ru4(q2-aryne)(CO)~2. Scheme 10 shows one example of this reaction leading to p4-q1,q'-phenanthryne. Although the parent benzyne compound could not be synthesized, other aryne compounds such as methoxybenzyne, 1,2naphthyne, 9,lO-phenanthryne and 1,2-anthracyne clusters have been generated and shown to have the structure I (Fig. 14) like that of the corresponding alkyne
260
I Molecular Clusters
+
-
9
refluxing octane
I
Scheme 10. Dehydroiodination of iodophenanthrene to give a phenanthryne cluster.
The other types of q4-aryne (J and K in Fig. 14) have all been synthesized by introducing an aryl phosphine to the cluster, which is precoordinated to a Cr(CO), group. For example, PhP{C,jHsCr(CO)3}2,with two of the three phenyl groups q6 coordinated to chromium, reacts with Ru3(C0)12 to give the 50-electron cluster RU~(CO)~(,U~-P{C~H~C~(CO)~}{C~H~C~(CO)~) (Fig. 18). This has structure J (Fig. 14) and is closely similar to E but with the benzyne additionally q6coordinated to the Cr(C0)3 group and with a Cr-Ru bond.["'] Interestingly, if Rq(C0)12 is treated with the analogous tBu compound tBuP{C6H5Cr(C0)3}2, the product Ru3(C0)8(,u3-PtBu){,u~-CgHgCr(C0)3f has one CO fewer.["'] The Cr(CO)3 unit remains y6 coordinated to the benzyne but the R u ~triangle is now closed. Structure K (Fig. 14) with a plane of symmetry through the benzyne ligand is found. Whereas J corresponds to E, structure K corresponds to D. Another cluster with geometry J is formed when Ru3(CO)11{Me2AsCsHsCr(CO)3) is heated. One product Ru3(p-H)(CO)8(,u-AsMez) {,u&jH4Cr(C0)3)has structure J but with a closed R u triangle ~ (Fig. 18).
Figure 18. Examples of types J and K modes of benzyne coordination.
I . I 4 Midtilde Inteructions BetLoeen Arenes rind Metcrl A t o m
26 1
1.14.5.5 Arynes bridging five metal atoms Structure L (Fig. 14) has been found for Rus(CO)l?(pq-PPh)(ps-q', q l , q6-C6H4). It has been described as a model for the activation of benzene at a step on a ( I , 1 , l ) metal surface. The C6H4 ligand is bound parallel to the surface represented by a triangle of atoms. Activation of C-H bonds at metal atoms on the top layer of the step could generate a pj-q',q l , q6-CbH4 group as in L.['O6' Extending the number of metal interactions with the arene beyond this known limit would lead to the hypothetical fully metallated M12C6 unit (Fig. 19). Using reasonable C X and M-C bond lengths, however, leads to the conclusion that the metal shell would need to be extremely stretched to fit around the C6 core. The required M-M distance in M12C6 are about 3.5 A longer than normal M-M bond lengths. However, many of the structures in Fig. 14 are subunits of the M12C6 structure and there may be more structures to be found as subunits with more than five metal atoms. However, very large subunits of M12C6 will only be possible if many of the M-M contacts shown are non-bonding.
1.14.6 Some recent developments with naphthalene and anthracene Our knowledge of how polycyclic aromatics interact with clusters is limited, but we would expect naphthalene, anthracene, pyrene rtc. to be able potentially to form
262
I Molecular Clusters
Scheme 11. Naphthalene derivatives from R u ~ ( C O12) and diphenyl( I-napthy1)phosphine.
more extensive interactions with metals than monocyclics. Most known systems just involve n-interactions and there are examples of this with naphthalene in Mn2(CO)5(p-r4,q6-CloHs)['13] and with acenaphthalene in clusters.[tt41Compounds with both and TC metal-contacts are few. The cluster R u ~ ( C O reacts )~~ P~ q4-C1oH6) ~ ~ ~ ) ( ,(Sec. U~-~', with P(l-naphthyl)3 to give R L I ~ ( C O ) I I ( ~ U ~ -r', 1.14.5.4), the first example of a 1,2-naphthyne."0s1 The corresponding 2,3naphthyne compound is also known.['091In Section 1.14.5.4 we have also described the formation of another type of 1,2-naphthyne coordination corresponding to the phenanthryne cluster shown in Scheme 10. We have followed the tertiary phosphine approach by using Ph2PR where R = 1-naphthyl or 9-anthracyl to introduce these ring systems into clusters (Schemes 1 1 and 12).r11591161 Several products were isolated and characterized in each case. These contain coordinated naphthalene or anthracene but usually stubbornly still attached to phosphorus. Some naphthalene examples are shown in Scheme 11 show the different ways the naphthalene group is coordinated to metal clusters, mostly in the same types of way we have considered previously for benzene. However, in the one compound where naphthalene and phosphorus have separated, a remarkable new type of structure is found, which indicates that naphthalene and other polycyclic aromatics may generate quite different sorts of system to those of benzene. The product Ru6(p3-PPh)(p6-CloH6)(CO)14 is formed in low yield in the reaction of PhZP(1-naphthyl) with Ru3(C0)12 (Fig. 20). In this compound the naphthalene1,s-diyl ligand fits into the fold of a folded raft-like framework of six ruthenium atoms. There are two o Ru-C bonds to ruthenium atoms at the fold and two v 2 and
I . 14 Multiple hitrvuctions Between Arenes und Mctul Atoms
263
Figure 20. Two views of the core of the compound Ruh(CIOH6)(PPh)(CO)14,showing the p6q l , r l ' , q 2 .q'. q i , q 3 coordination of CloHh and the diagonal naphthalene incorporation into the
metal 'step'.
two 17' contacts to the other Ru atoms. Like RuS(p3-PPh)(p4-ChH4)(CO)l3 the ligand could be considered to be a model for arene binding at a step on a ( 1 . 1 . 1 ) metal surface, but unlike the ChH4 ligand, which lies parallel to the surface, the naphthalene ligand slots in at an approximately 45" angle at the step. This new type of arene-metal system is the first of this class of system. The only other examples are the tetraruthenium compound such as that in Scheme 10. We expect that other examples of this type of motif will be discovered before long. ) I ~have In the analogous reaction of PhlP(9-anthacy1)phosphinewith R u ~ ( C O we found a range of products, one of which is illustrated in Scheme 12. The anthracene group is still attached to phosphorus but is n-complexed through eight carbon atoms to a triangle of Ru atoms in a $, q 3 ,'71 manner. One should expect a more extended system to become available where a polycyclic arene lies parallel to a planar triangulated array of metal atoms. However, there is a mismatch of arene ring size and the size of metal-metal bonded triangles, that is a graphite-type layer does not match a (1. 1 . 1) type metal atom array well enough for this parallel arrangement of carbon and metal layers to be extended indefinitely. However, the structures that are appearing from this work illustrate that layers are being formed: a layer of metal atoms n-bonded to a layer of carbon atoms, a layer also containing metal atoms a-bonded to the carbon atoms, and then another layer of metal atoms n-bonded on the other face of the polycyclic aromatic. We predict that new forms of carbon-metal system will be developed based on this principle and that new features will emerge in this area of arene chemistry.
264
I Moleculur Clusters
Ru,(CO),, + Ph,P
fj
Scheme 12. One anthracene derivative from the reaction of R u ~ ( C Oand ) ~ ~diphenyl(9-anthracyl) phosphine.
References 111 E. 0. Fischer, W. Hafner, Z. Natur/iirsch., Ted B, 1955, 10, 665. [2] M. P. Gomez-Sal, B. F. G. Johnson, J. Lewis, P. R. Raithby, A. H. Wright, J. Chem. Soc., Cheni. Commun., 1985, 1682. [3] B. F. G . Johnson, J. Organornet. Ciiem., 1994, 475, 31. 141 M. A. Gallop, B. F. G. Johnson, J. Lewis, A. McCamley, R. N. Perutz, J. Clzeni. Soc., Chem. Commun., 1988, 1071; B. F. G. Johnson et al., Chern. Euu. J.. 1995, I , 252. [51 A. J. Deeming, M. Underhill, J. Organornet. Chem., 1972, 42, C60; J. Cliem. Soc., Dulton Trans., 1974, 1415. [6] I. Bach, K.-R Porschke, R. Goddard, C. Kopiske, C. Kriiger, A. Rufinska, K. Seevogel, Orgnnometallics, 1996, 15, 4959. (71 H. van der Heijden, A. G. Orpen, P. Pasman, J. Cliem. Soc., Chem. Cornniun., 1985, 1576. [8] G. Allegra, G. Tettainanti Casagrande, A. Immirzi, L. Porri, G. Vitulli, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1970, 92. 289. 191 W. D. Harman, M. Gebhard, H. Taube, Inorg. Chem., 1990,29, 567. [lo] D. R. Neithamer, L. Parkinyi, J. F. Mitchell, P. T. Wolczanski, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1988, 110. 4421. [ 1 I ] H. Omori, H. Suzuki, Y. Take, Y. Moro-oka, Organonzetallics, 1989, 8, 2270. [12] K. Jonas, J. Organomet.Chem., 1990, 400, 165. [ 131 K. Jonas, G. Koepe, L. Schiefcrstein, R. Mynott, C. Kriiger, Y.-H. Tsay, Angew. Chem.,Int. Ed. Eng., 1983, 22, 620. [I41 J. Miiller, P. E. Gaede, K. Qiao, J. Orgunomet. Clzem., 1994, 480, 213.
[IS] A. J. Blake, P. J. Dyson. B. F. G. Johnson. C. M . Martin, J. C/7er77. Suc.. C'lwn. Comnzun., 1994. 1471; A . J. Blake. P. J. Dyson, S. L. Ingham. B. F. G. Johnson, C. M. Martin, OryoIiorwftillics. 1995. 14. 862. [I61 F. A. Cotton. P. A. Kibala, W. A. Wojtczak. J. Aii7. C ' h 7 i . Soc.. 1991, 113. 1462. [ 171 E. L. Muetterties, Pure Appl. Chem., 1982. 54, 83. 118) R. F. Lin. G . S. Blackman, M. A. Van Hove, G. A. Somorjai. Actu C 1987. 43, 368. 1191 D. F. Ogletree. M. A . Van Hove, G. A. Somorjai. S u r f : Sc.. 1987. 183, 1. 1201 M. A. Van Hove. R. F. Lin. G. A. Somorjai. .I. Ani. C/ieni. Soc., 1986, 108. 2532. 121] C. M. Mate. G . A. Somorjai. Sitrf: Sc.. 1985, l60. 542. 1221 M. A. Gallop. M. P. Gomez-Sal. C. E. Housecroft. B. F. G. Johnson. J . Lewis, S. M. Owen, P. R. Raithby, A. H. Wright. J. Aii7. Clicw. Soc., 1992. 114. 2502. 1231 B. I-. G . Johnson, J. Lewis. M. Martinelli. A . H . Wright. D. Braga, F. Grepioni. J. (%lWi. SIC,.. Clierii. Coi77~7~~7.. 1990. 364. F. G . Johnson. J. Lewis. C . E. Housecroft, M. Martinelli, O r c p Ilop. B. F. G . Johnson. J. U. Kohler, J. Lewis. P. R. Raithby, Ai16qcii~. Cl7e177../ t i / . Ed. Em/.. 1994. 33. 1093; A . J. Edwards, N. E. Leadbeater. J. Lewis, P. R. Raithby. J . C / i c v i i . So(,., Dtrltori Trtrr7.s..1995. 3785. 1261 A. Inagaki. Y . Takaya, T. Takcmori. €1. S~iraki.J. Ai77. C/KWT. SOC,.. 1997, 110, 625. 1271 H. Wadepohl, K. Biichner. H. Pritzkow. O,.~/lrrr?oriietrrl/ic.s. 1989. 8, 2745. 1281 H. Wadepohl. K. Biichner. M. Herrniann. H. Pritzkow. Or