Millimeter-Wave Radar Targets and Clutter
For a listing of recent titles in the Artech House Radar Library, turn to th...
79 downloads
1869 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Millimeter-Wave Radar Targets and Clutter
For a listing of recent titles in the Artech House Radar Library, turn to the back of this book.
Millimeter-Wave Radar Targets and Clutter
Gennadiy P. Kulemin Technical Editor David K. Barton
Artech House Boston • London www.artechhouse.com
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Kulemin, G. P. (Gennadii Petrovich) Millimeter-wave radar targets and clutter / Gennadiy P. Kulemin. p. cm. — (Artech House radar library) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-58053-540-2 (alk. paper) 1. Radar targets. 2. Radar—Interference. 3. Millimeter waves. I. Title. II. Series. TK6580.K68 2003 621.3848—dc22 2003060064
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Kulemin, Gennadiy P. Millimeter-wave radar targets and clutter. — (Artech House radar library) 1. Radar—Interference 2. Backscattering 3. Radar targets 4. Millimeter wave devices I. Title 621.3’848 ISBN 1-58053-540-2
Cover design by Yekaterina Ratner
2003 ARTECH HOUSE, INC. 685 Canton Street Norwood, MA 02062 All rights reserved. Printed and bound in the United States of America. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. All terms mentioned in this book that are known to be trademarks or service marks have been appropriately capitalized. Artech House cannot attest to the accuracy of this information. Use of a term in this book should not be regarded as affecting the validity of any trademark or service mark. International Standard Book Number: 1-58053-540-2 Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2003060064 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents Preface
ix
Acknowledgments
xi
CHAPTER 1 Radar Characteristics of Targets 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Target RCS 1.2.1 RCS Models 1.2.2 RCSs of Real Targets 1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines 1.3.1 Analysis of Radar Reflection Mechanisms 1.3.2 Spatial-Temporal Characteristics of Explosion and Fuel Combustion 1.3.3 Radar Reflections from Explosion and Gas Wake 1.3.4 Centimeter Wave and MMW Attenuation in Explosions 1.3.5 Radar Backscattering from Sonic Perturbations Caused by Aerodynamic Object Flight 1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets 1.4.1 Target Statistical Models 1.4.2 Real Target Statistical Characteristics 1.4.3 Echo Power Spectra 1.5 Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets 1.5.1 Diffuse Scattering Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics 1.5.2 Multiple Surface Reflection Influence References CHAPTER 2 Land Backscattering 2.1 Classification and Physical Characteristics of Land
1 1 3 3 7 18 18 23 28 34 41 55 55 58 62 72 72 78 84
89 89
v
vi
Contents
2.2 State of the Theory 2.2.1 RCS Models 2.2.2 Power Spectrum Model 2.3 Normalized RCS 2.3.1 Normalized RCS of a Quasi-Smooth Surface 2.3.2 Normalized RCS for Rough Surfaces Without Vegetation 2.3.3 Backscattering from Snow 2.3.4 Backscattering from Vegetation 2.3.5 Normalized RCS Models 2.4 Depolarization of Scattered Signals 2.5 Statistical Characteristics of the Scattered Signals 2.6 Power Spectra of Scattered Signals References
95 95 101 108 108 109 114 118 120 123 126 128 133
CHAPTER 3 Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
137
3.1 Estimation of Soil Parameters 3.1.1 Introduction 3.1.2 Soil Backscattering Modeling 3.1.3 Efficiency of Multichannel Methods 3.2 Soil Erosion Experimental Determination 3.2.1 Set and Technique of Measurement 3.2.2 Statistical and Agrophysical Characteristics of Fields 3.2.3 On-Land Radar Measurement Results 3.2.4 Aircraft Remote Sensing 3.3 Methods of Multichannel Radar Image Processing 3.3.1 Image Superimposing 3.3.2 Methods of Multichannel Radar Image Filtering 3.4 Soil Erosion Determination from Ratio Images: Experimental Results References
137 137 138 145 150 150 151 155 157 159 159 163 166 168
CHAPTER 4 Sea Backscattering at Low Grazing Angles
171
4.1 Sea Roughness Features for Small Grazing Angles 4.1.1 Sea Roughness Characteristics 4.1.2 Shadowing and Peaks in Heavy Sea 4.2 Sea Backscattering Models 4.3 Sea Normalized RCS 4.4 Depolarization of Scattered Signals 4.5 Sea Clutter RCS Model 4.6 Sea Clutter Statistics
171 171 184 189 193 197 202 206
Contents
vii
4.7 Radar Spike Characteristics of Sea Backscattering 4.8 Backscattering Spectra References
209 213 222
CHAPTER 5 Microwave and MMW Backscattering by Precipitation and Other Meteorological Formations
227
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4
Structure of Meteorological Formations Atmospheric Attenuation Backscattering Theory Experimental Results Review 5.4.1 Precipitation Backscattering 5.4.2 Cloud Backscattering 5.5 The Statistical Characteristics of Scattered Signals 5.6 Radar Reflections from ‘‘Clear’’ Sky (Angel-Echo) 5.6.1 Point Reflections 5.6.2 Backscattering from the Turbulent Atmosphere References
227 233 236 239 239 242 242 250 250 254 256
CHAPTER 6 Sea and Land Radar Clutter Modeling
259
6.1 Land Clutter Modeling 6.1.1 Initial Data 6.1.2 Peculiarities of Land Clutter Simulation 6.2 Sea Clutter Modeling 6.2.1 Peculiarities of Sea Clutter Simulation 6.2.2 Algorithm of Sea Clutter Simulation 6.3 Clutter Map Development 6.3.1 Initial Data for Modeling 6.3.2 Software Input and Processing Components 6.3.3 Raster Image Processing Module 6.3.4 Automatic Highlighting of Contours on the Raster 6.3.5 Steady Algorithm of Surface Recovery from Contours 6.3.6 Simulation of the Absolute Reflectivity References
259 259 262 267 267 268 276 276 277 278 280 282 283 284
CHAPTER 7 Clutter Rejection in MMW Radar
287
7.1 Influence of Propagation Effects on MMW Radar Operation 7.1.1 Introduction 7.1.2 Multipath Attenuation
287 287 288
viii
Contents
7.2 Influence of Rain and Multipath Attenuation on Radar Range 7.3 Influence of Land and Rain Clutter on Radar Detection Range 7.4 Land and Rain Clutter Rejection in Millimeter Band Radar 7.4.1 General Notes 7.4.2 Land and Sea Clutter Rejection 7.4.3 Rain Clutter Rejection References
290 292 297 297 298 305 311
About the Author
313
Index
315
Preface
For the last 40 to 50 years, the intensive development of the millimeter band of radiowaves has taken place to address communication, radar, remote sensing, and many other problems. The interest in this band is due to a number of millimeter wave (MMW) advantages in comparison to longer wave bands. With this interest comes the possibility of developing super wide bandpass communication paths between on-land points. The possible development of narrow beam formations for acceptable antenna sizes would enable better tracking, detection, and surveillance in modern radar. In addition, the reserve and stability to countermeasures would be higher. The successful solving of problems for low-altitude, on-land, and maritime target detection and tracking has determined the propagation effects of MMWs near land and sea surfaces and in the troposphere. Among them, we can note the multipath propagation attenuation and the attenuation in precipitation (e.g., rain, fog, and snow) limiting the maximal range of detection. The small influence of multipath attenuation in comparison with radar of the centimeter or longer wave band is the essential advantage of MMW radar. The precipitation influence does not show itself in microwaves, and it is necessary to take this limiting factor into consideration in the millimeter band at ranges of more than few kilometers. The second problem limiting the application of MMW radar is the land and sea clutter conditioned by backscattering from distributed scatterers and the volume clutter from such scatterers as precipitations; the latter role increases in the millimeter band and results in limitations in radar frequency. The investigations in propagation of MMWs have been carried out in the Institute for Radiophysics and Electronics of the National Academy of Science of the Ukraine for more than 50 years, and great experimental data were collected during this time. Part of these results obtained by the author or with his participation has been included in works presented to the reader. Millimeter Wave Scattering by Earth’s Surface at Small Grazing Angles by G. P. Kulemin and V. B. Razskazovsky published in 1987 in Russian was the first monograph in the former Soviet Union in which the problems of forward scattering and backscattering of MMWs by land and sea surfaces were discussed and the theoretical and experimental results were
ix
x
Preface
presented, including the statistical characteristics of arrival angles due to multipath propagation over the surface. This book remained unknown for a wide circle of readers. Since then, many new results have been obtained, and no other new books were published.
Acknowledgments The preparation and publishing of this work was made possible by the enthusiastic support of David K. Barton. He made significant technical and scientific contributions, as well as providing valuable editorial suggestions. It has been a pleasure to work with personnel of Artech House Publishers. Special thanks are due to Tiina Ruonamaa for support and attention.
xi
CHAPTER 1
Radar Characteristics of Targets 1.1 Introduction The knowledge of radar statistical characteristics for targets to be detected is the usual starting point for radar system designers. The approach to statistical characterization differs significantly depending upon the radar system functions to be investigated. For instance, the tasks of target recognition, target identification in noise and clutter, and simple target detection require different amounts of information on the target scattering properties. In the first case, the signal must be presented as a multidimensional random vector in sine space; in the last situation, it is enough to know the average signal power or energy. The knowledge of the latter characteristic is the starting point for any radar system design and analysis of predetermining feasibility and nature of all further radar signal-processing techniques. Therefore, the first and the most important target characteristic is the radar cross section (RCS). It is also necessary to know the probability density function (pdf) of RCS fluctuation for given conditions of target observation for derivation of radar energy requirements; the minimally needed characteristic is the average RCS value, which is contained in the expression for the target echo power. A sufficient number of theoretical and experimental papers are devoted to the investigations of the RCS for different targets, but this material is mainly presented in the periodical references and requires analysis and generalization. Besides, experimental data on target statistical characteristics in the shortwave part of microwave and MMW bands are limited, and this obstacle stimulated the author’s interest in target characteristics at these wave bands. Discussion of the results of target modeling using simple shapes and experimental investigations of radar characteristics for cone-cylinder bodies in the resonance area (ka ∼ 1, where k = 2 / is the wave number, is the signal wavelength, and a is the object diameter) seem to be most interesting. Chemical explosions and gas exhausts of operating engines are rather complex media involving some mechanisms for microwave backscattering [1, 2]. These mechanisms are competing for different stages of the explosions, and for long-life reflections the effects of microwave interaction with turbulent media possessing
1
2
Radar Characteristics of Targets
time-variable parameters are of great interest for physics. Moreover, there are possibilities of applications dealing with radar observation of explosions under battlefield conditions and with the detection of air targets with small RCS when backscattering is observed from gas wakes. The theoretical analysis of the radio wave scattering by a slightly ionized turbulent wake was performed in [3], and the radar method of measurements for the turbulent wake was considered in [4]. While considering the problem of a microwave reflection from an explosion area, attention is focused on the primary stage when the reflection from a shock wave ionized front (SWIF) is observed, and the reflection coefficient has the value approximately equal to unity (i.e., it is possible to consider the reflection from an ideally conducting body) [5]. Chemical explosions are the main object of investigations because the mechanism of backscattering at later stages of an explosion and that produced by a gas wake is the same. For this reason, the results concerning radar reflection from an explosion are significant. The operation of some types of radar and communication systems must be reliable when chemical explosions occur on propagation paths as found, for instance, in quarries or operation under battlefield conditions. In such situations, the spatial volume important for wave propagation becomes fully or partially blocked by the cloud formed by the explosion products and by accompanying particles of soil. This results in wave absorption. Further, the space surrounding the charge of explosives (where the explosion products—both solid and gas—and particles of soil are present) will be called simply the explosion volume. The main focus of investigators in studies of radio wave propagation through the explosion volume (as can be seen, for example, from survey [6]) was on the influence of the sand-dust cloud formed by soil particles and the influence of artificial smoke (e.g., phosphorus, hexachlorine, ethane, and oil fog). At the same time, obviously, the physical processes of microwave attenuation in the explosion volume of chemical explosives when there is no involvement of other substances are also interesting because even in this case rather large values of attenuation are observed experimentally. Detection of low-RCS airborne vehicles using the secondary effects observed during their flight through the atmosphere is also a significant issue [7]. Such effects may involve the following phenomena: the forming of an atmosphere shock wave due to object flight at ultra- and supersonic speeds; the presence of strong sound perturbation resulting in modulation of the atmosphere parameters; and the variation of turbulent troposphere parameters caused by intensive sound fields. Microwave scattering from atmosphere inhomogenities, which arise due to sound and shock wave propagation, can increase the total air-target cross section and improve radar efficiency. The statistical models of radar targets are considered using the common approach. It is shown that for derivation of detection characteristics, the standard
1.2 Target RCS
3
Swerling models can be extended to include chi-square distributions with small numbers of degrees of freedom. Special attention is paid to the results of experimental investigations of the echo power spectra for different classes of targets. The statistical characteristics of the echo from low-altitude targets are changed because of two circumstances [8]. First, the electromagnetic field from the target in the presence of multipath propagation is the sum of the direct wave and one reflected by the rough surface (sea or land). As it is known [9, 10], the statistical characteristics of a point nonfluctuating target placed over the surface are described by the Rician distribution. This is due to the influence of the statistical propagation factor, which introduces a diffuse component of electromagnetic field for the long paths with many random scatterers. In the shortwave part of the centimeter band and, particularly, in the millimeter band, the diffuse component of the electromagnetic field scattered by the surface increases along with the destruction of the specular reflection. In this situation, the spatial correlation radii of the field diffuse components over the target are often greater than the geometric dimensions of the target [10]. Then the received signal is a product of two terms: the first describes the target signal fluctuations in free space, and the second describes the fluctuations of the propagation factor. In addition, the statistical characteristics of the target echoes are changed because of the signal reflection from the target to the radar via the surface (multiple reflections). This effect, conditioned by the multiple reflections, can be significant for comparatively small ranges from the target to the surface when it is possible to neglect the propagation losses. Such interaction of the target and surface was first considered in [11] for a plane plate placed at an angle of 45° to the surface and the possibility of the RCS growth was shown. The analysis results of these mechanisms of target and surface interaction are presented and their influence on the radar target statistical characteristics is shown.
1.2 Target RCS 1.2.1 RCS Models
The choice of a radar target mathematical model is a rather complicated problem in the majority of situations, and it does not yield to exact analysis. While deriving diffraction from complex objects, we often use the results obtained for simple cases. The complex surface of the object is divided into several simple areas for which the reflection can be easily determined and described, and then the summing of partial contributions is performed according to techniques proposed in [12, 13]. Usually, the following geometrical shapes are used for approximation of the real targets and their parts: segments of spheres, ellipsoids and ogive objects, cone segments, cylinders or wires, plane plates, and dihedrals. Only the illuminated parts of such bodies must be taken into account. For derivation of
4
Radar Characteristics of Targets
reflection from these typical surfaces, Kirchhoff’s technique is the most widely applied because of its simplicity. The main difficulty for this approach lies in determining of the angle sector (target aspects) for which the derived expressions are valid and in the formula transformation for aspect changes. According to this approach, one supposes the independence of the bright points that contribute mainly into the total reflected signal (i.e., the effects of multiple reflection are not taken into consideration). This can result in significant errors in the determination of the object RCS because shapes such as the corner reflector are not taken into account. A separate problem is the technique of combining the bright point reflections. The calculation of the phase for every component makes sense only when there is an accurate description of the surface and knowledge of the operational frequency, such that the errors of relative phase predictions between the different target parts do not exceed a fraction of one wavelength. In this case, the technique permits us to estimate sufficiently accurately the complex target scattering pattern with the errors less than 1–2 dB [14, 15]. Only rough estimation of RCS is possible by means of signal noncoherent addition from all bright points if the accuracy of surface and frequency description is insufficiently high. It was proposed in [16] to use random relative phase with uniform distribution in the interval of [0, 2 ] for RCS estimation. This approach is valid if the number of bright points is rather large and the linear distances between them exceed the wavelength. Commonly, the use of the random phase model provides RCS estimation and permits us to determine its most important statistical characteristics. The technique of scattering pattern calculation for complex objects based on the geometrical optics approximation was proposed in [17, 18]. For example, the results of the scattering pattern derivation for a Convair-990 aircraft and a comparison with experimental data at a frequency of 10.0 GHz from these papers are presented in Figure 1.1; the experimental RCS values are integrated in the sector of aspect angles of 10°. The techniques of RCS derivation for comparatively simple objects are elaborated carefully for two cases: •
•
The wavelength is significantly greater than the target dimensions (Rayleigh scattering); The wavelength is significantly less than the target dimensions, corresponding to surface and edge scattering.
For the intermediate resonance region (wavelength comparable with the target dimensions), the establishment of some RCS relationships is a rather complicated problem, but there exist some techniques for approximation presented, in particular, in [16].
5
1.2 Target RCS
Figure 1.1 The scattering pattern of the Convair-990 aircraft at X-band: (a) horizontal plane and (b) vertical plane. (After: [17].)
Let us consider the techniques of the RCS evaluation for rather simple aerodynamic objects, which can be considered as combinations of round cones and round cylinders, both having limited dimensions. Much attention has been paid to derivation for the round finite cone [19, 20]. The scattering from its tip is given by
t =
2 ⭈ tan4 ␥ 16
(1.1)
where ␥ is the half angle at the cone tip and is the wavelength. This value is quite small in comparison with the scattering from the edge (cone base). For a cone with dimensions significantly greater than the RCS along the symmetry axis ( = 0) is determined as [20]
冉
1 ka sin /n = n 2
冊冉 2
cos
3 − cos n n
where n = 3/2 − ␥ /2, and a is the cone base radius.
冊
(1.2)
6
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Equation (1.2) shows that the RCS of a cone for the forward aspects does not depend on the wavelength and is determined by the base diameter strongly. This dependence is approximately ∼ a 2. For other angles, the RCS depends upon the electromagnetic wave polarization. In particular, the RCS for the vertical polarization is determined as [20]
冉 冋冉
冊 | 冋冉 冊 冉 冋冉 冊册 冋冉
ka sin /n = 2 n 4 2 ×
cos − 1 n
2
冊册 冊册 冊 冉
1 exp −i 2ka sin − sin 4
−1
3 − 2 − cos − cos n n
+ exp i 2ka sin − 4
×
cos − 1 n
−1
−1
(1.3)
冊 册| −1
2 3 − 2 − cos − cos n n for 0 < < ␥
and
冉
ka sin /n = 2 n 4 2
冊
2
1 × sin
冋冉
cos − 1 n
冊 冉 −1
3 − 2 − cos − cos n n
冊册
−1 2
for ␥ < <
2
Derivation of the cone RCS using (1.2) and (1.3), as a rule, gives estimates that are greater than those ones obtained experimentally. For example, for a finite round cone (␥ = 15°, 2a = 150 mm, = 0° ) the RCS derivation gives the value of = −15.5 dB(m2 ), while the experimental RCS is about −(20 − 25) dB(m2 ). A better match to the experimental results for a cone-cylindrical body, for the axial direction ( = 0° ), is defined by expression [20]
= a2
4 2 sin2 ( + ␥ )
2
冋
2 +␥
2 2 2 cos − cos +␥ +␥
册
(1.4)
RCS estimation for the same cone (␥ = 15°, 2a = 150 mm) according (1.4) gives = −18 dB(m2 ), closer to experimental results. For the second simple body—the cylinder of rather small length—the RCS can be determined as
7
1.2 Target RCS
3 1 (1 − q 2 ) sin 2qx = ⭈ ⭈ 2 8 ( /2)2 + {ln [cka (1 − q 2 )1/2/2]}2 4q 2
(1.5)
where q = cos , x = kl , l is the half-length of the cylinder, and c = 0.5772 is Euler’s constant. The analysis of (1.5) shows that the maximal RCS for cylinder takes place at angles of incidence close to normal with respect to the cylinder axis. Reducing the wavelength reduces the maximal RCS. The application of (1.1)–(1.5) for targets having dimensions comparable with the wavelength (i.e., in the resonance region) provides estimates only of the order of expected RCS in the most favorable situations. In particular, we performed a comparison of the predicted and experimental RCS for cone-cylinder objects using (1.2)–(1.5). The experiments were carried out at wavelengths of 3.0 and 0.8 cm, and the results are presented in Figure 1.2. It is worth noting that the RCS is higher by 10–15 dB for objects with diameters of 15.0 mm in comparison with diameters of 7.5 mm; this is significantly greater than that predicted by the geometrical optics approximation. The experimental RCS decreases by 14–20 dB for the smaller wavelength, while according to the derivations this should be only 4–12 dB. Thus, the modeling of the real radar target RCS, including objects with rather simple geometrical shapes, provides only the expected order of the RCS. More detailed data on the RCS and the scattering patterns can be obtained by natural experiments, especially for X- and Ka-bands, where the small-dimension constructive and technological target peculiarities are important. 1.2.2 RCSs of Real Targets
The RCSs for different classes of targets including marine, land, and air objects have been thoroughly investigated at X-band and longer wave bands, but less accurate and complete data are available for millimeter bands. RCS dependence on the wavelength, as a rule, is not evident or is totally absent for most radar targets having dimensions many times greater than the wavelength. It can be observed only for the objects for which the reflection is mainly caused by the corner reflectors on their surface. Such constructive elements are especially typical of ships and other marine vessels. In connection with this phenomenon, their RCS significantly exceeds their projected area in the plane perpendicular to the illumination direction. The RCS of objects usually approximately equals such projected area if the scattering is mainly caused by quasi-flat or curved surface elements. These effects allow us with some carefulness to use the quantitative data obtained in X-band for RCS estimation in millimeter bands. Let us more thoroughly consider the results of RCS measurements for targets of different classes. The RCSs of marine vessels are rather high, and their mean values are presented in Table 1.1 [21].
8
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.2 The scattering patterns of cone-cylinder bodies at X- and Ka-bands: (a) diameter 7.5 mm and (b) diameter 15 mm.
Table 1.1 RCS of Large Marine Vessels Mean RCS (m 2 ) > 2 ⭈ 104 3 ⭈ 103–104 50–250 35–140 0.3–0.4
Type Ships with over 104 tons displacement Middle-class vessels with 103–3 ⭈ 103 tons displacement Small vessels with 60–200 tons displacement Submarine in above water state Submarine periscope (height is 0.5m over water surface) Source: [22].
For practically all microwave bands (1–10 GHz), the median value of RCS from side aspects can be determined using the empirical expression from [22]
0.5 = 52 ⭈ f
1/2
D 3/2
(1.6)
1.2 Target RCS
9
where f is the operational frequency in GHz, and D is the ship displacement in kilotons. The mean RCS of these objects decreases with increasing range, as a result of the ship’s structure falling into the shadowing zone, and this dependence is presented in Figure 1.3 for ships of three classes [23]. For MMW bands, the mean RCS of large ships increases with frequency more quickly than suggested by (1.6). For ships with displacements less than 200 tons, this increase is 3–5 dB, and for ships such as motor vessels, it is 15–20 dB. This confirms the assumption that in millimeter bands, the corner reflector shapes of ship superstructures influence the mean RCS. As an illustration, the mean RCS dependence on range for three types of ships is presented in Figure 1.4. The RCS of the small marine targets presented in Table 1.2 are significantly less [24]. Such objects as marine buoys have a special place among small marine targets because they are characterized by rolling motions with height oscillations due to rough sea and the presence of an anchor. Their mean RCS decreases with increasing sea states due to the shadowing effect by sea waves. For instance, such change of RCS for a small marine buoy is about 7 dB for sea state changing from 1 to 5, while for the same change of sea state, the RCS change is 18 dB for a buoy of medium size and 9 dB for a large one. RCS values for various marine objects reported in [25] are presented in Table 1.3. The RCS of land objects also varies within rather wide limits depending on the object type. The mean forward aspect RCS for some land targets obtained while moving along a dirt road are presented in Table 1.4 [26]. The measurements are carried out at a 3-cm wavelength.
Figure 1.3 RCS dependence on the range for (1) trawler, (2) dry cargo ship, and (3, 4) tankers.
10
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.4 RCS dependences on range at wavelengths of 3.0 and 0.8 cm for (1) patrol boat, (2) tanker, and (3) motor ship.
The RCS of air targets at microwave have also been investigated. As shown in [27], the mean RCS for the piston-engine B-26 aircraft at forward aspects in the ±10° sector is 20–25 dB(m2 ), and a similar mean RCS is typical for the C-54 at the 3-cm wavelength. As was shown in [28], the mean RCS values are 8–15 dB(m2 ) for large jet aircraft, about 1 m2 for light aircraft of the L-200 type, and about −(0.9–3.3) dB(m2 ) for a Russian Mi-4 helicopter [23]. One of the main trends in modern military airplane construction is the design of low-observable vehicles, decreasing their detection probability by air defense
11
1.2 Target RCS Table 1.2 RCS of the Small Marine Targets Object Yacht, sailboat Scull boat Gum boat Large marine buoy with radar reflector Medium marine buoy with radar reflector Small marine buoy Channel cone buoy Man on windsurf Source: [24].
Mean RCS (m 2 ) = 3 cm = 8 mm 10–20 12–14 2–4 0.8–5.0 1.0–2.0 1.2–2.5 20–20 — 7–10 — 10 — 10 — 2.5–3.0 2.5–3.5
Table 1.3 RCS of Some Small Marine Objects
Source: [25].
Table 1.4 Mean RCS of Land Targets for Forward Aspects Object Tank Armored car Heavy artillery tractor Light artillery tractor Truck Source: [26].
Mean RCS (m 2 ) 6.0–9.0 8.9–30.0 15.0–20.0 10.0–15.0 6.0–10.0
radar systems. The efforts of the airplane designers led to RCS reduction over the past decades as illustrated in Table 1.5. The contributions of reflections from the different elements of the aircraft structure to the total RCS are determined by the aspect relative to the radar. For side aspects, reflections from the fuselage and vertical stabilizer are predominant, along with reflections from the leading edges of the wing and stabilizer. The contributions to the total RCS from different aircraft structures are illustrated in Figure 1.5.
12
Radar Characteristics of Targets Table 1.5 Airplane RCS (m2 ) Decreasing over Past Decades Airplane Type Bomber Fighter
1970s 50–100 5–15
1980s 5–10 1–3
1990s 0.5–1.0 0.1–0.3
Figure 1.5 Contributions of different structures to total aircraft RCS.
The main directions and trends of aircraft design with decreased RCS are presented in Table 1.6. Taking into consideration these trends, it is possible to predict that one can expect light and medium-weight aircraft with RCS of order 10−2–10−3 or less. This significantly decreases their detection range. Hence, it is necessary to find new characteristics of targets to ensure their reliable detection at great ranges. Data on the scattering properties of biological objects have significant interest for short-range radar designers. In some cases they are the desired targets, and in other cases they are false targets. The backscattering from a human body is determined by its mass and the radar operational frequency. The connection between frequency and RCS of a man is seen from data presented in Table 1.7.
13
1.2 Target RCS Table 1.6 Main Methods of Decreasing RCS Direction Flying apparatus aerodynamic shape and structural element improvements
Radio transparent and radio-absorbing material applications
Decreasing visibility of on-board antenna systems Ionized absorbing cloud (IAC) creation
Technical Realization Possibilities The removal of the sharp selvages, corner forms, gaps in aerodynamic surfaces. Decreasing the vertical stabilizer area. Use of the aerodynamic shape of the ‘‘flying wing’’ type. Integration of the glider-engine and gliderarmament systems. Use of composite material. Application of radio-absorbing coatings. Application of conducting material for gap removal. Antenna scattering in directions other than specular reflection to the radar. Decreasing numbers of antennas. Electronic gun use. Application of coatings using radioactive isotopes.
Table 1.7 Man RCS Dependence on the Frequency Frequency (GHz) 0.4 1.1 2.9 4.8 9.4 Source: [28].
Mean RCS (m 2 ) 0.033–2.33 0.1–1.0 0.14–1.05 0.37–1.88 0.5–1.22
It is seen that RCS of a man does not practically depend on the operational frequency in microwave bands. The scattering pattern presented in Figure 1.6 [29] shows that the RCS at 3-cm wavelength is maximal for frontal aspect and minimal for side aspect. The detailed investigation of backscattering from birds and insects is a rather hard problem for several reasons. The ratio of object dimension to wavelength can change over several orders, while the difference of the shape from spherical (even without considering the wings) leads to strong dependence of RCS on the observation aspect and the polarization of radiation. Besides, the target is not rigid, and its shape periodically changes with the wing flaps and respiration. The problem is more complex for determination of temporal RCS dependence because this is determined by target behavior (i.e., migration, local food extraction). The RCS dependences on the aspect for three bird species at 3-cm wavelength are presented in Figure 1.7. The RCS dependence on bird mass obtained in [30] is presented in Figure 1.8. The predicted values of the water sphere RCS at wavelengths of 3 and 0.8 cm are
14
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.6 Scattering pattern of a man. (From: [29]. 1984 Radio and Communication.)
Figure 1.7 The scattering pattern for three bird species at X-band: (1) pigeon, (2) starling, and (3) crow.
shown by the lines, the experimental data at the 3-cm wavelength are presented by the points. The simplest model for RCS estimation of biological objects is the equivalent water sphere for which mass is equal to the object mass. However the length-to-diameter ratio for bird body parts, containing water, equals to 2:1 or 3:1 [30].
1.2 Target RCS
15
Figure 1.8 RCS dependences on the bird mass at X-band (solid line) and Ka-band (dotted line). Points are the experimental data. (After: [30].)
The nonspherical shape of scatterers leads to the appearance of a cross-polarized component of the echo. This component value equals to −12 to −13 dB in comparison to the main one for the objects with RCS greater than 5 ⭈ 10−3 cm2. The dependences on wavelength of bird and insect RCS are presented in Figure 1.9. At wavelengths of more than 10 cm, the bird RCS can be approximated by the relation ∼ −4 where is the radar wavelength (i.e., Rayleigh scattering takes place). The maximal RCS value of birds at this band equals to 0.1–20 cm2, this value decreasing by 10 dB at a 3-cm wavelength and by 15 dB at a 30-cm wavelength. The insect RCS is 10−1–10−4 cm2 up to the wavelength of 8 mm. RCS values for some bird and insect species are presented in Tables 1.8 and 1.9 [30, 31]. In the period from spring to autumn, the majority of birds are above most of the land surface at heights of 1 to 2 km. The migrating birds of some species regularly fly at heights more than 4 km and appear at distances from the nearest land of more than 1,000 km. At the heights from 0 to 2 km, the volume density of the bird distribution is often from 10−7 to 10−6 m−3, and in regions of flock accumulations, densities of order 10−5 can be found for durations of days. If the radar resolution cell volume equals to 106–107 m3 (as typical of many radars at ranges less than 20 km), many such cells will contain at least one bird. Table 1.10 shows the order of bird density in the some regions of flocking (the bird number is summed in height); the data is averaged over the considerable geographical area [32]. It is necessary to take into consideration that factors of social behavior can raise the local density of the flocks, especially in approaches to places of night rest, bird colonies, or flock nutrition. In the last column of Table
16
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.9 Bird and insect RCS dependences on the wavelength.
Table 1.8 RCS of Birds at 10-cm Wavelength Type Pigeon Starling Sparrow Seagull Source: [30].
From Side 1.0 × 10−2 2.5 × 10−3 7.0 × 10−4 1.5 × 10−2
RCS (m 2 ) From Front 1.1 × 10−4 1.8 × 10−4 2.5 × 10−5 2.0 × 10−3
From Behind 1.0 × 10−4 1.3 × 10−4 1.8 × 10−4 —
Table 1.9 RCS of Insects at 10-cm Wavelength Type Butterfly Butterfly Bee Dragonfly Source: [30].
Wing Span (cm) 10.0 3.0 1.0 —
RCS (cm 2 ) 1.0 5.0–10−3 2–10−3 10−3
1.10, the estimates of the top averaged RCS are given. RCS bounds are wide because the target aspect, radiation polarization, and wavelength are not taken into consideration. These estimates are acceptable for wavelengths from X- to S-bands. The bird-averaged distribution by altitudes is presented in Table 1.11 [33].
17
1.2 Target RCS Table 1.10 Bird Density in Flocking Places Accumulation Type Winter refuges for crows, seagulls, geese, ducks in the littoral waters Stormy petrel migration by California coast Coastal and sea birds in the reproduction period Source: [32].
Area (km 2 )
Bird Number
Density (m −3 )
RCS (cm 2 )
<103
104–106
10−9–10−6
10–500
<103
>106
10−5
50–500
<105
109
10−7
50–500
Table 1.11 The Bird Distribution by Altitude Height (m) 250 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 Source: [33].
Percentage of Birds at Heights Lower Than Shown 45 65 80 90 100
The distributions of insect density in the air often can be greater by many orders than for birds. Some data from the works of Rainy and Johnson [30] are presented in Table 1.12; the RCS are given for X-band, and they represent the most probable values and are close to the real data. It appears that the insect distribution density often can exceed 10−5–10−4 m−3, and densities of order 10−3–10−2 apparently are found regularly for cases when the converging winds concentrate the insects. The greatest densities have most probably local behavior, and the typical concentration area for these cases does not exceed 100 km2. Thus, considerable data permit us to estimate the RCS of objects that can be either targets or interference to radar systems designed for the detection of small RCS objects.
Table 1.12 Distribution Density for Some Insects Object Middle butterfly during intensive migration Night butterfly All insects for 1 hour Source: [30].
Height (m) Near surface Near surface Near surface
Distribution Density (m −3 ) −2
10 10−2 101
RCS (cm 2 ) 10−2–100 10−1–100 10−3–100
18
Radar Characteristics of Targets
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines 1.3.1 Analysis of Radar Reflection Mechanisms
Let us first consider the possible mechanisms of microwave backscattering from an explosion volume. This point is the most complex for the analysis, and it includes the models of backscattering from a turbulent gas wake as a particular case. During the primary stage of an explosion, a dominant factor is the reflection from the SWIF. Depending on the ratio between the pressure p o of an undisturbed gas and the SWIF pressure p = p o + ⌬p , it is possible to classify three typical stages of the shock wave: • • •
Strong shock waves (p >> p o ); Shock waves of a middle range intensity (⌬p ∼ p o ); Weak shock waves (⌬p << p o ).
For strong and weak shock waves, it is possible to derive the analytical solution for the shock wave propagation equation. Its accuracy is determined only by the accuracy of some primary assumptions. The problem of the strong point-source explosion is solved in [34]. The author of the paper ignored the contra pressure of the medium. Taking contra pressure into account, this problem was solved on the basis of numerical integration in [35]. For a weak shock wave, the asymptotic expressions were also obtained (primarily in [36] and those in generalized form in [37]). For a strong shock wave, the gas density decreases sharply from the SWIF to the center; practically all of the gas mass is concentrated in the thin layer near the front surface. With increasing distance from the SWIF to the center, the pressure reduces by two to three times and remains practically stable for the entire sphere. The temperature increases from the front to the center—especially very quickly in the area of constant pressure, which is determined by the presence of particles heated by the shock wave, which in turn have high entropy and are located near the center. With the passage of time, the shock wave amplitude decreases and the front pressure diminishes asymptotically to the atmospheric level. Correspondingly, the SWIF gas compression decreases, and the shock wave propagation speed asymptotically diminishes approaching the sound velocity. The SWIF propagation law transforms from r f ∼ t 2/5 to r f ∼ a o t where r f is the SWIF radius, t denotes time, and a o is the sound speed (i.e., the shock wave transforms gradually to a sound wave). The zone with low pressure follows the compression area in such a wave, after which the air resumes its original state.
19
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
The high temperature of the SWIF, reaching 105K for the initial explosion stage, causes ionization of the air and creation of a plasma layer. In this case, the electromagnetic field reflection coefficient is described [38] in the following way:
|⌫|
2
冋
册
2 1 − (1 − n e /n*e )1/2 = 1 + (1 − n e /n*e )1/2
(1.7)
where n e is the plasma electron density in the SWIF; n*e = ( m /e 2 ) f 2 is the electron density corresponding to the plasma resonance frequency, f ; and m and e are the mass and the charge of the electron, respectively. According to [39], the critical electron concentration corresponding to the plasma resonance frequency in the SWIF can be reached in the air at temperatures of 3,000K for the 3-cm wavelength and 4,000K for the 8-mm wavelength. The presence of admixtures can decrease the temperature at which the critical concentration appears. Such temperatures in the SWIF exist for 80–100 ms after the explosion for the chemical explosives (like trotyl) that have a weight of 1 kg. In later stages, the ionization becomes lower than critical, resulting in a rapid decrease of the refractive index. Table 1.13 presents the RCS and the SWIF radius values derived from (1.7) and taking data [35] into consideration. The results are obtained for the explosion of a 1-kg trotyl charge at 3-cm wavelength; it was assumed that | ⌫ | was constant for the first Fresnel zone on the spherical SWIF. It is worth mentioning that for t > 200 s (corresponding to r f ≈ 1m), the rapid decreasing of RCS begins, and for t > 1 ms, the contribution of the shock wave ionization to a total reflected signal becomes insignificant. Microwave reflection from the discontinuity in concentration at the shock wave front is the second possible mechanism. For this case, the reflection coefficient can be determined as
冉 冊 n−1
| ⌫ | 2 = 2␥ p o
2
⭈ ⌬p 2
(1.8)
for an infinitely thin layer on the shock wave front and
Table 1.13 The Temporal Dependence of the SWIF Radius and RCS of an Explosion at 3-cm Wavelength Time from the Explosion Start ( s) SWIF radius (m) RCS (m2 ) Source: [1].
4.7 0.15 0.071
6.2 0.164 0.085
20 0.264 0.226
50 0.383 0.46
84 0.47 0.69
140 0.64 0.13
180 0.7 0.031
20
Radar Characteristics of Targets
|⌫|2 =
冉 冊 ⌬n 2
2
⭈
1 1 + 16 2⌬2/ 2
(1.9)
for a layer of finite effective width ⌬. In these expressions (n − 1) = 320 ⭈ 10−6 for a standard atmosphere when the altitude is 500m, ␥ is the adiabatic constant equal to 1.4 for air, ⌬p is the pressure discontinuity in SWIF, is the radar wavelength, and p o is the pressure of an undisturbed atmosphere. Taking into consideration the data on the SWIF pressure discontinuity derived from [17], we obtain | ⌫ | 2 ≈ 8 ⭈ 10−8 for the explosion of a 3-kg trotyl charge at 0.5s after the explosion start and | ⌫ | 2 ≈ 1.5 ⭈ 10−8 for 30 ms after the start of the explosion (i.e., the reflection coefficient is not large and it decreases rather slowly). The SWIF expansion, which results from a finite viscosity and the presence of turbulent pulsations of temperature, pressure, and speed, gives a considerable reflection coefficient decrease in comparison to values derived from (1.8). The estimates of the explosion RCS stipulated by this scattering mechanism have values comparable to the background reflection from the troposphere, and they are much less than the experimental data. Moreover, both mechanisms can cause reflections existing only for short intervals of time for which the SWIF does not exceed the limits of the radar resolution volume. But the reflections exist for a rather great time interval for area volume of relatively small dimensions. The analogous estimations of microwave reflections from the Mach cone taking place for an air vehicle flight with supersonic and ultrasonic speeds show that the ionization of a shock wave front becomes considerable for speeds greater than 2.5 km/s. For other speeds, the shock wave RCS is approximately equal to 10 (i.e., it is comparable to the troposphere reflective ability). Therefore, the reflections from the front of an explosion or from the Mach cone can be the important mechanism for the detection of these objects only for short time periods after the explosion or during the air vehicle flight at supersonic speeds. One more mechanism of reflected radar signal formation is conditioned by the perturbations arising in the explosion area after passage of the shock wave front. The refractive index pulsation intensity increases due to medium turbulence as well as to the chemical content changing in this area. For aerodynamic object detection, the reflections from the turbulent gas wake of an operating engine can be used. For real explosions, a volume occupied by explosion products is formed. Their compositions can be easily specified. The explosion products composition for 1 kg of trotyl C6H2(NO2)3CH3 is presented in Table 1.14. It is evident that the main components of explosion products are CO, CO2 , H2O, and N2 gases and amorphous carbon (soot); the contribution of the other ingredients is negligible. During the later explosion stages, the partial combustion of CO and C, with some additional carbon oxide formation, takes place. The noncombusted particles of carbon with dimensions of about 10−6–10−7 mm [40]
21
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines Table 1.14 The Composition of 1-kg Trotyl Explosion Products Products
Mole
Weight Gram
CO2 CO H2O C N2 NH3 Source: [1].
1.92 11.64 10.96 17.32 6.6 0.04
84.5 326 192 208 185 0.6
Dipole Moment (Debye)
Polarizationability
0.1 ± 0.05 0.112 ± 0.15 1.65 ± 0.25 — — —
2.6 ⭈ 10−24 2.02 ⭈ 10−24 1.5 ⭈ 10−24 — 1.84 ⭈ 10−24 —
according to these derivations cannot explain the RCS values observed for the explosion volume. For the total refractive index estimation in the explosion products volume, let us use the ratio presented in [41]: N = (n − 1) ⭈ 106 = 2 A o
冉
2 ␣o + M 3kT
冊
⭈ 106
(1.10)
where n is the refractive index; A o is the Avogadro number; denotes the density; M is the gas molecular weight; ␣ o and ␣ are the polarization ability and the dipole moment of the gas molecule, respectively; k is the Boltzmann’s constant; and T is the temperature in K. The contribution of different components and the total reflection coefficient of the formed mixture are presented in Table 1.15. It is seen that the maximum contribution to the refractivity is made by water in a molecular phase, while among the other components the influence of the carbon oxide is the most significant. It is worth noting that at high temperatures (typical for explosion products) the contribution caused by the molecule polarization can increase by several orders. Analogous phenomena occur for fuel combustion in turbojet and turboprop engines. In Table 1.16, we present the data on gas volumes for 1-kg kerosene combustion (kerosene is now the main type of fuel for modern aircraft) exhausting
Table 1.15 Gas-Like Explosion Products Refractivity for a 1-kg Trotyl Explosion Gas Type CO2 CO N2 H2O ⌺N Source: [1].
Percentage in Mixture 4.0 24 13.6 22
Contribution in Mixture N, N-Units Due to ␣ 0 , t = 20°C Due to 26 0.82 140 5.2 66 — 90 358.0 322 404.0
22
Radar Characteristics of Targets Table 1.16 The Chemical Composition and Refractivity of Combustion Products for 1 kg of Kerosene Gas Type Volume m 3 ⭈ kg −1 CO2 1.6 H2O 1.8 N2 9.1 Total refractivity Source: [1].
N for Pure Gas 700 1760 410
Percentage of Content 12.8 14.5 72.7
Refractivity 90.0 255.0 300.0 645.0
to the atmosphere under normal pressure. The results of refractivity derivation from (1.10) are also presented. According to the obtained estimates in the volume occupied by explosion products and fuel combustion products, the mixing of gas-like products with the surrounding air takes place under the influence of atmosphere turbulence and gravity. The sharp margins of areas with different refractive indices remain intact because of turbulent diffusion, the speed of which is greater than the speed of the molecular gas diffusion. Later, blurring of the turbulent product wake margins occurs, resulting from intermolecular diffusion. The dimensions of the volume occupied by the explosion products are limited. For an air explosion, the shock wave front moves more rapidly than the explosion products, so from the very beginning of the expansion process the pressure decreases in the area occupied by the explosion products. A short time later, after the explosion, its products will occupy the maximum volume V∞ , which is described for a spherical charge by radius r∞ [42] 3
r∞ = (20 − 30)r o = (20 − 30)  √C
(1.11)
where C is the charge weight in kg;  is the coefficient depending on the explosion substance density (for pressed trotyl it is equal to 0.053), and r o is the spherical charge radius in meters. The dimensions of the gas wake of an operating engine in the cross direction are also limited; the wake diameter is four to six times greater than that of the nozzle. Using the simplifying assumption on a turbulent isotropy for the area occupied by the explosion products and combustion products, it is possible to estimate a specific volume RCS of this area using [43]
=
⭈ 〈 ⌬n 2 〉 ⭈ k 2 ⭈ F n (k ) 8
(1.12)
where k = 2 / is the wave number; 〈 ⌬n 2 〉 denotes the refractive index fluctuation variance; and F n (k ) is the one-dimensional spatial spectrum of refractive index fluctuations.
23
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
Consequently, for the estimation of RCS of the explosion and engine fuel combustion volumes, it is necessary to know two local turbulence characteristics: the variance and the spatial spectrum of the refractive index. It is possible to expect that the normalized one-dimensional spectrum of the refractive index pulsations can be described as a spectrum of a random telegraph signal with a Poisson distribution of refractive index steps F n (k ) = [1 + (kL )2 ]−1
(1.13)
where L is some typical effective turbulence scale. For kL << 1, we have F n (k ) ≈ 1 and the volumetric normalized RCS ≈ −2; for kL >> 1, the specific RCS has a very insignificant dependence on radar wavelength. Therefore, from the point of view of radar detection, the latter mechanism seems to be the most important among those considered because it provides the greatest duration of the reflected signal. The next section is devoted to the estimations of the variance and of the spatial spectrum of the refractive index fluctuations for a disturbed volume. 1.3.2 Spatial-Temporal Characteristics of Explosion and Fuel Combustion
Experimental investigations into the spatial and temporal characteristics of the refractive index of the explosion volume were carried out using a refractometer and a thermoanemometer. The first instrument directly obtained the temporal fluctuations of refractive index differences at two different points of space; the second determined the speed pulsations in the air flow. The necessity of the use of two instruments was conditioned by considerable dimensions of the microwave refractometer open resonators, which prevented the estimation of the spectrum with wave numbers more than 1 cm (i.e., with linear dimensions less than 10–20 cm). The use of a thermoanemometer with a time constant about 0.01 second permitted us to investigate the inhomogeneous media with scales about 1 to 2 mm. Taking into consideration the similarity of the spatial spectra for a velocity field and the refraction index [43]. It was possible to combine the data obtained by these instruments. The data were recorded by a high-speed photoelectric recorder. For data processing, a sample with a duration of about 10 seconds was divided into segments, each having a duration of about 1 second. Two segments preceded the beginning of the explosion. For each segment, statistical and spectral processing was carried out. For the spatial spectra determination from the temporal spectra, the hypothesis of frozen turbulence was used [43], according to which the whole spatial stochastic field moves with a mean velocity of an air flow. This allowed us to obtain the spatial spectra of the refraction index fluctuations for spatial dimensions from 2 to 100 cm.
24
Radar Characteristics of Targets
The experimental investigations were conducted on an open flat surface. The trotyl charges with weights of 1–3 kg were placed at a height of about 1.5m above the surface. The refractometer and the thermoanemometer sensors were placed at a 10-m range from the explosion center. About 40 explosions were carried out for different wind speeds. Refractometrical investigations into the turbulence local characteristics for the explosion volume showed the following: 1. For 2–4 seconds at 10m from the center of the explosion of a 3-kg trotyl explosive, the root mean square (rms) value of pulsations exceeded (2–3) N -units, compared to (0.1–0.5) N -units for the undisturbed atmosphere. This phenomenon was observed both for calm weather and for a wind direction toward sensors. For the cross-wind direction, there was a 3–5 dB increase in the refractive index pulsation in comparison to the undisturbed atmosphere. The time interval when the effective value of fluctuations was more than 1 N -unit was equal to 3–5 seconds. The illustration in Figure 1.10 presents the refractive index pulsation values as the temporal functions for wind absence—Figure 1.10(a)—and for an explosion product moving toward the sensors—Figure 1.10(b). 2. The refractive index temporal fluctuation spectra retained their shape. Besides, for the frequency band from 5 to 30 Hz, the slope of the disturbed area spectra did not change in comparison to the undisturbed atmosphere spectra corresponding closely to the phenomena predicted theoretically for a homogeneous turbulent atmosphere. Figure 1.11 presents the refractive index temporal fluctuation spectra for the different moments of time after the explosion for the same experiment. Using the hypothesis of frozen turbulence [16], the transformation to spatial fluctuation spectrum was carried out (the lower horizontal axis). For the frequency region F < 5 Hz, a modification of the spectrum slope was observed for several experiments, probably resulting from the finite dimensions of the refractometer baseline (0.7m) acting as a spatial lowpass filter. Its influence also resulted in the structural functions that had a tendency to saturation for the baseline dimensions of 0.5–1m. 3. For approximately 70% of the experiments carried out in conditions of an explosion product movement toward the sensors, the difference of the correlation intervals of the flow velocity fluctuations was observed before and after the explosion. The decrease of the correlation interval at 2–5 seconds after the explosion start was typical (Figure 1.12) in comparison to the correlation interval for the undisturbed atmosphere. It was the evidence that the typical dimensions of the explosion product turbulence diminished for the case of movement toward the sensors in comparison to the undisturbed atmosphere.
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
Figure 1.10
25
Temporal dependence of the refractive index fluctuation rms values in explosion (a) without wind and (b) with a longitudinal wind. (From: [1]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
26
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.11
Instantaneous power spectra of the refractive index fluctuations in explosion. (From: [1]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
4. For a distance between the sensors and the explosion center equal to 17m, the fluctuation intensity before and after the explosion remained almost the same, excluding the cases of movement toward the sensors of the expanding volume occupied by the explosion product. Analogous results were obtained when the experimental study of local spatialtemporal characteristics was carried out for a gas wake of an operating jet engine. The investigations were made both for a jet engine model with fuel expenditure 2 g/s and for a MIG-21 aircraft engine. For the model experiments when the distance from the nozzle was of about 2–3m, the refractive index fluctuations were 10–20 dB more than ones for the undisturbed atmosphere reaching 〈 ⌬n 2 〉 = 100 (N -units)2. Reduction of the fluctua-
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
Figure 1.12
27
Temporal dependence of an air velocity decorrelation time after a 1-kg trotyl explosion. (From: [1]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
tion intensity occurred with increase of the distance from the nozzle; when the distance exceeded 8–9m, they decreased to the level of the undisturbed atmosphere. The shape of the spectrum of fluctuations for the gas wake was practically identical to the spectrum of undisturbed atmosphere; for their description the functional dependence ∼F −5/3 could be used. The spatial spectra obtained using the freezing approach with taking the local speed of the wake into account were characterized by the shift to the area of the large spatial wavelengths ⌳ for an increase of the distance from the nozzle. This resulted from the greater degree of generating small perturbations. The refractive index fluctuation intensity for a gas wake of the MIG-21 operating engine for the different distances from the nozzle and the regimes of operation is presented in Table 1.17. It is seen that with fuel expenditure increase, the same fluctuation intensity is observed for the greater distances. The frequency and spatial fluctuation spectra of the refractive index are analogous to those typical for the model of a gas wake, and they can be described using ∼F −5/3 and ∼ (1/⌬)−5/3 dependencies. Therefore, the refractive index fluctuations for the area occupied by the explosion products and for the operating engine gas wake possess the following features:
28
Radar Characteristics of Targets Table 1.17 The rms Values of Refractivity in the Gas Wake of an MIG-21 Aircraft Engine Operating Regime Minimal Nominal (normal) Maximal Source: [1].
•
•
•
Distance Along the Axis (m) from Nozzle 20 25 50 65
冠 ⌬N 2 冡1/2 ⭈ N-units 5.5 4.5 4.4 3.7
In the disturbed volume, the refractive index fluctuation intensity increases greatly in comparison to that of the undisturbed atmosphere, proving the applicability of the model proposed earlier for this region; The refractive index fluctuation spatial-temporal spectra shape of the disturbed areas is similar to the undisturbed atmosphere spectra; The dimensions of the disturbed volume are limited by the volume of explosion products propagation and by the nozzle gas flow.
1.3.3 Radar Reflections from Explosion and Gas Wake
The experimental study of the radar characteristics for the explosion area of a trotyl explosive was carried out at wavelengths from 10 cm to 4.1 mm. The parameters of the pulsed and continuous-wave (CW) radars used for experimental investigations are presented in Table 1.18. The data from the pulsed radars were recorded by a high-speed photoelectric recorder and by a 10-channel spectral analyzer of parallel type covering the frequency band from 10 to 500 Hz. With use of the spectral analyzer of this type, it
Table 1.18 The Parameters of the Pulsed and CW Radars Parameters Type Central frequency (GHz) Transmitter power: –Pulsed (kW) –Average (W) Polarization Pulse duration ( s) Repetition frequency (Hz) Antenna pattern width: –Azimuthal –Elevation Threshold sensitivity (Wt) Frequency band of analysis (Hz)
1 Pulsed
2 Pulsed
3 CW
4 CW
5 CW
3.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
74.0
250 — VV, HH 0.5
250 — VV, HH 0.7
— 10 VV —
— 4 VV —
— 0.6 VV —
1,750
1,100
—
—
—
2° 2.3°
0.5° 0.75°
2° 2°
1.5° 1.5°
0.6° 1.0°
10−12
0.5 ⭈ 10−12
2 ⭈ 10−18
10−17
5 ⭈ 10−17
500
500
0.10–40,000
0.10–40,000
0.10–40,000
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
29
was possible to obtain the instantaneous power spectra of the reflected signals. Moreover, the multichannel gate unit was used, which permitted us to obtain the explosion volume spatial dimensions. The data from the CW radars were recorded by the same recorder and by a 10-channel spectral analyzer of parallel type covering the frequency band of analysis from 0.01 to 40 kHz. When the position of the explosions was chosen, great attention was paid to the selection of the surface area with a clutter minimum level. The explosions of the trotyl charges with weights of 1 and 3 kg were carried out at a range of about 2 km from the pulsed radars and over 50m from the CW radars. Calibration of the radars was carried out by a set of the corner reflectors. The rms error of the RCS estimation was equal to 2 dB. We should like to note the following peculiarities of experiments: 1. The long-life reflections from the explosion products volume were the subjects of the study, but not the reflections from the short-time high-temperature nucleus; 2. Coherent processing techniques and Doppler frequency filtering in the frequency domain F < 10 Hz (in some experiments, 5 Hz) were used for removal of the obstructing reflections from environment. The RCS of the explosion in this case was determined as Fu
=
冕
G (F ) dF
FL
where G (F ) is the power spectrum of the reflected signal, and F L and F U are the low and the upper bandpass filter frequencies. Obviously, for strong dependencies of spectral density on frequency (which according to the results presented later did take place for reflections from the explosion), the RCS value depended significantly upon F L and F U for this method of data processing. The experiments showed that the maximum reflection level is observed for a radar antenna beam directed to the explosion center, and for wavelengths of 10 cm and 3 cm, the total RCS was equal to several square meters, reaching 10m in some cases. Besides, the RCS did not depend on the wavelength and polarization of the signal; only a dependence on wind direction was observed. The RCS for the crosswind was less than that for radial wind direction because of an explosion product drift from the explosion area by a cross-direction wind (i.e., the linear azimuth resolution of the radar was better than the radial one).
30
Radar Characteristics of Targets
The mean RCS values obtained in the frequency band from 10 to 500 Hz and 0.6s after the explosion are presented in Table 1.19. Table 1.20 presents the average RCS values measured for wavelengths 3 cm, 0.8 cm, and 0.4 cm in the band of analysis 5–200 kHz. It is seen, in particular, that a significant decrease in total RCS occurs for 3.2-cm wavelength due to the growth of the lower bound of frequency analysis. At the same time, the RCS for the surface explosion of 1-kg trotyl reached 0.2–0.3 m2 for a 3-cm wavelength and the same frequency band. The measurements of the dimensions of the explosion volume that formed the echo were carried out by means of the estimation of the azimuthal cross sections of this volume using narrow-beam antennas with main lobe widths less than 1°. They showed that the volume diameter was about 6–7m for the explosion of the trotyl charge (its weight was 1 kg) without the envelope and reached 8–10m for the explosion of charge with a metal envelope. Demonstrating this effect, Figure 1.13 presents the dependencies of the echo power when the antenna axis rotates by some angle with respect to the explosion center (curve 1 corresponds to the charge without the envelope, curve 2 corresponds to an enveloped charge). If we take into account that, according to (1.11), the limit diameter of the area occupied by the explosion product of a 1-kg trotyl explosion is equal to 2.2–3.2m, it is possible to suppose that the reflected signal is partially formed by a turbulent atmosphere created by the passing of the shock wave front. It is worth noting that the dimensions of the reflecting volume are determined in sufficient degree by the band of analysis of the echo and increase with decreasing low-bound frequency. For instance, for the wavelength of 3 cm, the reflecting volume effective dimensions are equal to 2.5–6m for a frequency band of 30–60 kHz and to 8.5–11m for a frequency band of 8–27 kHz. This phenomenon, in our opinion, is explained by the fact that the power spectrum of the reflected signal becomes poor in the high frequency area as the explosion products volume expands.
Table 1.19 The RCS of the Explosion for Band from 10 Hz to 500 Hz Wavelength (cm) 3.2 0.8 0.4 Source: [1].
⌬F ⭈ m 2 0.017 0.02 0.0035
Table 1.20 The RCS of the 1-kg Trotyl Explosion for the Frequency Band of 5–200 kHz Charge Mass (kg) Trotyl, 3 kg Trotyl, 3 kg Source: [1].
Wavelength (cm) 3.0 10.0
RCS (m 2 ) Cross Wind Longitude Wind 16.3 1.75 4.2 2.3
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
Figure 1.13
31
The angular dependencies of the echo at wavelengths of (a) 3 cm and (b) 8 mm: (1) trotyl explosion without metallic envelope, and (2) trotyl explosion with metallic envelope. (From: [1]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
The band of analysis essentially determines the duration of the signal reflected from the explosion. This is illustrated by the dependence of the signal duration on the lower bound frequency of the analysis band presented in Figure 1.14. If for F L = 10 Hz, the total duration was equal to 1–3 seconds; it decreased to 0.5–0.7 second when F L = 350 Hz. The power spectrum analysis of echoes has shown that in the frequency band of 10–500 Hz, the spectra are described by the relationship G (F ) ∼ F −5/3 (see
32
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.14
Echo duration as a function of filter low-band frequency. (From: [1]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
Figure 1.15). As the explosion evolves, the spectrum becomes poorer in the highfrequency region. When the wind had the direction from the explosion center toward the radar, the dependence could have the shape G (F ) ∼ F −1 − F 0 at frequencies less than 30 Hz due to the Doppler shift. The shape of the echo power spectrum does not remain the same in the high frequency region. The rapid decrease of the spectral intensity occurs during the explosion products volume expansion at F > 5 kHz. From the analysis of the instantaneous power spectra presented in Figure 1.16, which were obtained at a 3-cm wavelength for the 1-kg trotyl explosion, it is seen that during 6 ms after the explosion, the spectrum shape looks like G (F ) ∼ F −1; later, with the process evolution, it approaches ∼F −4 − F −5. Finally, it is worth mentioning that the use of circular polarization does not result in a change in the radar characteristics of the signals scattered by the explosion, in particular, reduction in the RCS. This obstacle excludes the use of scattering by ground particles as a possible model because in this case circular polarization will attenuate the intensity of the reflected signal. The results of radar observation of gas wake of MIG-21 and AN-24 aircraft are quite similar to those described earlier. These investigations were carried out with pulsed Doppler radar at a 10-cm wavelength. The experiments showed that these aircraft, moving both with sonic and ultrasonic speeds, have tails in the echo detectable up to distances 1000m. The existence or absence of the inverse optically visible track did not influence the intensity of radar tail essentially. These facts
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
33
Figure 1.15
Echo power spectra at the different moments of time after the explosion start obtained for the radar wavelength of 10 cm. (From: [1]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
Figure 1.16
Instantaneous echo power spectra from the explosion at a 3-cm wavelength. (From: [1]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
34
Radar Characteristics of Targets
permitted us to conclude that presence of this phenomenon was caused by scattering from the track created by the gas-like fuel combustion products. The estimates obtained showed that the RCS of the gas wake was about 10−4–10−2 m2, reaching values of 0.1 m2 in some cases, and the track length reached 500–1,000m. These RCS values corresponded well to ones predicted using the model considered in the first section of this chapter. If we suppose that the gas wake can be approximated by a cylinder with the diameter four to six times that of the engine nozzle and the refractive index fluctuation variance does not change along and across the axis, from (1.12) one can obtain the specific RCS = 3 ⭈ 10−7 m2/m (RCS for 1m of the track). We suppose here that ⌬N 2 = 25 (N -units)2 (see Table 1.5) and F (k ) = 0.1 for the nozzle diameter 1m at a 10-cm wavelength. Then the total RCS is equal to 10−4–10−3 m2, conforming enough well with the RCS of the track obtained experimentally. Experimental investigations into the microwave radar reflections from chemical explosions enable us to conclude that the most important mechanisms of scattering are the following: • •
The reflection from the SWIF for the initial explosion stage; The reflection from the gas-like explosion products for further evolution of the explosion.
The refractive index fluctuation intensity of the explosion volume is significantly greater than the fluctuation intensity in the undisturbed atmosphere. The spatialtemporal fluctuation spectra of the refractive index do not differ practically from the spectra of the turbulent atmosphere. The RCS of the explosion volume for chemical explosives with the weight about several kilograms reaches 10 m2, and the intensive reflections exist during intervals less than 1 second or several seconds. These characteristics do not practically depend on radar wavelength in the frequency band of 10–75 Hz. The reflected signal spectrum is rather wide, especially during the initial stage of the explosion products cloud formation. These peculiarities permit us to realize effective radar detection with clutter filtering in some situations. The backscattering from the turbulent gas wake of jet engines results in an increase in the RCS of aerodynamic objects. This phenomenon can be used for their detection, especially in the case of a premeditated RCS decrease of the object itself. 1.3.4 Centimeter Wave and MMW Attenuation in Explosions
The first important characteristic of the explosion volume that influences the total attenuation is the volume of explosion products flying away at the final stage. It is determined in [42] by
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
V∞ =
4 ⭈ r ∞3 = (1.5 − 6.5) ⭈ 103 ⭈ ⭈  3 ⭈ C 3
35
(1.14)
where C is the charge weight (kg) and  is the factor depending on explosion substance density (e.g., its value for compressed trotyl is equal to 0.053). The content of gas-like and solid explosion products can be easily determined for all known explosives and is presented in Table 1.14. It is seen that the main part of the explosion products is formed by gases CO2 , CO, N2 , H2O, and amorphous carbon C; the contribution of other substances is negligible. During the final stage of explosion evolution, partial burning of CO and C takes place forming carbon dioxide; this leaves part of the carbon sediments as a dust. Among gas-like products, only water vapor and oxygen, concentrated under high pressure at the shock wave front of the explosion, possess comparatively large dipole moments and attenuation spectra in the microwave band. The attenuation in carbon dioxide is significant only in the wavelength band 12.9–17.1m [44] (i.e., far from the microwave band). In the microwave band, there exist weak absorption lines (frequencies) of CO and NO [45], but their dipole moments have values about 0.1 Debye (approximately 20 times less than the dipole moment of water vapor) and the CO concentrations only 1.5 times higher than that of H2O. Therefore, these gases cannot play important roles in microwave absorption. For nonpolar molecules (N2 ), the dipole moment can appear as the result of collisions, but for usual conditions the absorption factor ␥ resulting from this phenomenon is much less than that for water vapor (␥ N 2 /␥ H2O = 10−6 ). The derivation of the oxygen absorption factor for a pressure of 10 atmospheres (this value corresponds to the shock wave front pressure at 0.5 ms after a 1-kg trotyl explosion) has shown that for wavelengths from 0.4 to 3 cm, ␥ had the values 1.27 ⭈ 10−3–2.3 ⭈ 10−2 m−1. Thus, the attenuation caused by this phenomenon is very small (taking into account that the width of its layer following the shock wave front equals several centimeters). Estimation of the water vapor absorption factor has shown that for the explosion of 1-kg trotyl, this factor does not exceed 4 ⭈ 10−3 – 6 ⭈ 10−2 m−1 in the same waveband (i.e., it has the same level as the absorption in oxygen). The second cause of microwave attenuation is the temperature ionization of air at the shock wave front and its heating due the burning of nonreacted remainders, which generates temperatures of about (2–3) ⭈ 103K. This effect can result in the longtime existence of plasma in the explosion products volume. The electron concentration in this situation is much less than critical, so in the microwave band the condition >> is satisfied and the absorption factor can be expressed by the following expression [46]
冉
n ⭈n ␥ = 0.1 2 e 2 1 − 0.3 2 e 2 + +
冊
−1/2
(1.15)
36
Radar Characteristics of Targets
where is the number of efficient collisions of electrons with molecules, is the frequency of the radar, and n e denotes the electron concentration. For typical plasma parameters of burning and for atmospheric pressure we use = 1011 s−1, n e = 108 cm−3. For f = 10 GHz, the absorption factor derived from (1.13) is equal to ␥ ≈ 7.5 ⭈ 105 cm−1 (i.e., the attenuation is very small). Furthermore, the absorption factor in plasma should decrease with decreasing wavelength, although experiments showed its growth. Finally, the third cause of microwave attenuation in explosions is absorption by solid explosion products. As is seen from Table 1.12, a large amount of carbon is given off during the detonation process. Carbon particle dimensions have the most probable radius 0 = 0.05–0.15 m [47] (i.e., usually they are much less than the wavelength). For derivation of absorption in such particles, the theory of Mie [48] can be used. For particles having << , the attenuation cross section is determined as
a ≈
4 2 2 6⑀ ″ ⭈ (⑀ ′ + 2)2 + (⑀ ″ )2
(1.16)
where ⑀ ′ and ⑀ ″ are the real and imaginary components of the dielectric constant, respectively. Taking into consideration that according to [49], the particle dimension distribution can be approximated by an exponential law with sufficient accuracy N ( ) = No ⭈
冉
2 ⭈ exp − o3 2 o2
冊
(1.17)
where N o is the total number of particles in a volume equal to 1 m3, the attenuation factor (specific attenuation per 1m) is
␥=
冕
N ( ) a ( , ) d ≈
冋
450N o o 6⑀ ″ (⑀ ′ + 2)2 + (⑀ ″ )2
册
(1.18)
It is seen from (1.18) that the attenuation factor grows inverse proportionally to the wavelength . However, it is necessary to take into account the frequency dependence of the dielectric constant, which can results in a weaker dependence of ␥ with wavelength. The results of the carbon complex dielectric constant derivation for burning temperatures using the data of [50] are presented in Table 1.21. It is seen from Table 1.21 that the real component of dielectric constant does not depend on wavelength, but the imaginary component quickly reduces with decreasing , especially in the millimeter band. Consequently, for frequencies higher
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
37
Table 1.21 Complex Dielectric Constant of Carbon for Burning Temperatures Wavelength (mm) 30 8.0 4.0 Source: [2].
⑀′ 2.02 2.02 2.02
⑀″ 10.8 2.7 1.35
than 30–40 GHz, the influence of this effect causes some decrease of the attenuation factor wavelength dependence in comparison with the ␥ ∼ −1 dependence. The derivation according to (1.18) for an explosion of 1-kg trotyl, which was done under the assumption that the probable radius of the particles was = 0.1 m and the total number of particles per specific volume occupied by the explosion products was equal to N ≈ 4 ⭈ 1019 m3, gave the results presented in Table 1.22. Let us estimate the total microwave attenuation for propagation through the explosion products volume. The length of the propagation path can be easily determined from the simplest geometry analysis (see Figure 1.17).
Table 1.22 Dependence of Attenuation Factor in Carbon Derived According to (1.16) Wavelength (mm) ␥ , m −1 Source: [2].
Figure 1.17
30.0 0.29
8.0 1.68
4.0 1.8
The geometry for derivation of microwave total attenuation in explosion area (T = the transmitter position, Rec. = the receiver position, O = the explosion center).
38
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Assuming r 1 >> , R >> , r 2 >> , and supposing r 1 = r 2 = r for simplicity, it is easy to calculate the path length of the transmitter-receiver line for angle with respect to the explosion center, l = 2r √q 2 − sin2 , tan << q
(1.19)
where q = R /r. If we assume that the particle distribution along this path is described by the expression N=
冉
No R ⭈ tan exp − ⌬ ⌬
冊
(1.20)
where ⌬ is the effective radius of the volume occupied by the explosion products (i.e., that the particle density exponentially decreases with increasing distance from area center), we get S=␥⭈l=
冋
册
冉
冊
450N o o3 R 6⑀ ″ 2r √q 2 − sin2 ⭈ exp − tan 2 2 ⭈⌬ ⌬ (⑀ ′ + 2) + (⑀ ″ ) (1.21)
Refractive focusing effects can exert influence on the signal intensity when the signal propagates through the explosion volume. Using the results of [43], it is easily shown that the relative growth of signal intensity ⌬ p /p beyond the spherical area is determined as ⌬ p /p ≈ 2
r (n − n o ) R
(1.22)
where r is the distance from the area center to the reception point, and R is the radius of dielectric sphere with refractive index n (usually n − n o << 1, where n o is the refractive index of the atmosphere). Substituting the experimental values r = 25m, R = 2.5 m, and n − n o = 300 ⭈ 10−6 (this value corresponds to maximal predicted ones) into (1.22), we obtain ⌬ p /p ≈ 6 ⭈ 10−3 (i.e., the influence of refraction is negligible). These estimates of the influence of diffraction on the dielectric sphere show that the inhomogeneous sphere with dimensions R << r , where r is the distance from the explosion center to reception point (see Figure 1.17), does not create significant focusing or defocusing effects [43] and, consequently, cannot change the intensity of the received signal significantly. As mentioned earlier, the experimental investigation into microwave attenuation in the explosion area was carried out at wavelengths of 3 cm, 0.8 cm, and
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
39
0.4 cm. The propagation path was of length 50m; the transmitter and receiver were placed at the ends and the explosions took place in the middle of the path. Trotyl explosives were used; their weights were 1 kg. To eliminate the influence of ground debris, the charges were placed at heights 1–2m over the land surface (on slabs or poles). Magnetron oscillators were used as transmitters, operating in the continuous regime with output power 1–10W. For measuring system calibration, polarization attenuators were used. They provided calibration accuracy of 0.2–0.5 dB; the worst value corresponded to the system with wavelength 4 mm. A typical temporal diagram of total explosion signal attenuation is presented in Figure 1.18. At the moment of charge explosion, rapid drop in the received signal intensity is observed. Maximal attenuation occurs for 30–50 ms for all investigated operating frequencies, increasing slightly (up to 10%) with increasing frequency. The sharp splash in the curve labeled ‘‘4’’ is the time of explosion. The recovery of the signal level takes place more slowly than its decay at the start of the explosion. The total duration of significant attenuation is about 80–100 ms. The results of the entire radar signal attenuation study for charge detonation on the transmitter-receiver line of sight are presented in Table 1.23, and the results of the attenuation factor measurements are given in Table 1.24. The significant differences between results obtained for the different experiments can be explained by the nonidentity of charges and conditions of their explosion (technical trotyl charges were used for the experiments). A comparison of Tables 1.23 and 1.24 shows that for 3-cm wavelength, satisfactory agreement of predicted and experimental attenuation coefficient values is observed, but for shorter wavelengths the difference increases.
Figure 1.18
Samples of temporal diagram for received power at wavelengths of (4) 3 cm and (3) 8 mm. (From: [2]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
40
Radar Characteristics of Targets Table 1.23 Maximal Total Attenuation (dB) for 1-kg Trotyl Explosion Wavelength (mm) 30 8.0 4.0 Source: [2].
Attenuation (dB) 3.2; 4.3; 6.5; 7.5; 11.0; 7.2; 7.1; 4.3; 3.2 13.8; 14.6; 11.7; 14.2; 11.3; 14.3 11.8; 8.7; 11.0; 9.0; 12.0
Average Attenuation (dB) 6.03 ± 2.4 13.3 ± 1.71 10.5 ± 1.94
Table 1.24 Experimental Attenuation Factors for Explosions of a 1-kg Trotyl Explosive Wavelength (mm) 30.0 8.0 4.0 Source: [2].
␥ , m −1 0.15; 0.3; 0.2; 0.35 3.3; 3.6; 2.8 3.8; 2.9; 2.8; 3.6
␥ , m −1 0.25 ± 0.075 3.2 ± 0.19 3.3 ± 0.22
When the explosion center is shifted by some angle with respect to the transmitter-receiver line of sight, less signal attenuation occurs. The observed experimental dependence S = f ( ) and the results of derivations performed according to (1.22) are presented in Figure 1.19. Satisfactory agreement of prediction and experimental data is observed. For a deviation angle ≈ 6° from the explosion center (for experiment geometry, this
Figure 1.19
The angular dependencies of total attenuation for wavelengths of 3 cm, 0.8 cm, and 0.4 cm. The solid line is the result of derivation from (1.21). (From: [2]. 1997 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
41
corresponds to 5–6-m shifting), attenuation is practically absent. This deviation corresponds to a distance between the line of transmitter-receiver and the charge position equal to 40r o (the lower axis of abscissas in Figure 1.19), where r o is determined by (1.12) and characterizes the dimensions of area occupied by the explosion products. The lack of knowledge of dissociation processes occurring in the explosion makes it difficult to explain the attenuation temporal dependence. One of the probable mechanisms is connected with the fact that after primary explosion products dispersal, burning of the small dispersed carbon particle takes the place due to the presence of a high temperature that is sufficient for burning (higher than 2,500K). In these conditions, the carbon particle concentration quickly decreases, resulting in recovery of the received signal level. The probability of this hypothesis is supported by data presented in [1], the author of which gives the following results: using brisant explosive (the weight was 36 kg), the dust was present for 5–10s after start of the explosion, and the attenuation for frequencies 35–140 GHz was not higher than 0.4 dB. Dust particle concentration had a value of about 108 m−3 (i.e., it was less than the primary carbon particle concentration that appeared as the result of detonation). In the explosion area occupied by trotyl explosive explosion products, significant microwave attenuation occurs, and it increases with increased radar frequency. The most probable mechanism for explaining the experimental data is the absorption by solid products of transformation, in particular, by amorphous carbon. 1.3.5 Radar Backscattering from Sonic Perturbations Caused by Aerodynamic Object Flight 1.3.5.1 Reflection from the Shock Wave Front Caused by Supersonic Flight
For straight flight of an object when its speed is V, a shock wave is formed in the homogeneous atmosphere. The shock wave possesses axial symmetry, and its shape is close to conical (Mach cone) with the object at its apex. For a cone angle 0 , the following expression is valid
0 = arcsin (a 0 /V ) = arcsin M −1
(1.23)
where a 0 is the sound speed and M = V /a 0 is the Mach number. This wave spreading to the sides of the trajectory includes increasing air mass, simultaneously with which its intensity diminishes, and transformation into a sound wave is observed. The pressure jump ⌬ p at the shock wave front (SWF) for flight of a body of revolution is determined as [51] ⌬ p (M 2 − 1)1/8 D = ⭈ kS ⭈ 3/4 p0 L (H /L )
(1.24)
42
Radar Characteristics of Targets
where L is the body length, H is the normal distance to the body flight axis, D is the equivalent maximal body diameter, p 0 is the pressure of surrounding gas, and k S is the body shape coefficient equal to o
kS =
1.19 (␥ + 1)
3/4
⭈
冢冕
F ( ) ⭈ L ⭈ dL
0
冣
⭈
L D
(1.25)
Here ␥ denotes the adiabatic constant, which for air is 1.4; F ( ) is the effective area distribution function [7, 52]
F ( ) =
√ 冕 L ⭈ 2
A eff (t ) ( − t )1/2
dt
0
in which A eff (t ) is the body cross section. As a rule, when the body of revolution configuration is simple the value ⌬ p can be calculated analytically, but for more complicated bodies (like aircraft) reliable data relating p to the SWF are usually obtained experimentally. According to [53], the SWF pressure difference is 50–200 newton m−2 (the larger value corresponding to a bomber) when aircraft speed equals (M1.5–M2) for distances 6–8 km from the aircraft trajectory. In a homogeneous atmosphere, ⌬ p decreases with the increase of distance to object according to the law ⌬ p ∼ r −3/4 and the rate of pressure variation in the interval between jumps is inversely proportional to r [54]. The pressure impulse, being the important effect of the shock wave on the medium, is expressed as t1
I=
冕
⌬ p (t ) dt ≈
1 ⌬p ⭈ T 2
(1.26)
to
where T = t 1 − t o and the parameter T is calculated on basis of the following expression for rate of pressure variation as a function of time d (⌬ p ) M ⭈ r −1 = 0.2 ⭈ dt 2 √M − 1
(1.27)
The considered dependences permit us to extrapolate the experimental data given in references into the area of comparatively small distances from the object.
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
43
Figure 1.20 presents the SWF parameter values for distances less than 1 km from the airplane (see shaded areas; the lower bound corresponds to a fighter and the upper one corresponds to a transport aircraft). Point 1 in Figure 1.20 is obtained for an F-4C moving at an altitude of 30m [55]. Satisfactory agreement is observed between predicted data presented in Figure 1.20 and the experimental data given in [1, 51, 55] and extrapolated to small distances. In Figure 1.20, the dependences ⌬ p (r ) and I (r ) are also presented for flight with the speed of M2 of a cone-cylinder body with diameter of 120 mm (curves 2). While pressure jump values for aircraft and cone-cylinder body have almost the same level, the pressure impulse for the second is one or two orders less. From the point of view of radar observation of the SWF and the interaction of the SWF with a turbulent atmosphere, the most interesting items are the spectra of pressure jump (see Figure 1.21). The duration of the N -profile, depending on the object shape and its speed, can vary within the limits 0.01–0.5 second. The theoretical spectrum of such an impulse decreases with increased frequency at the rate of 6 dB/octave (line 1). The experimental spectra (curves 2 and 3) are obtained in [51] for different atmospheric conditions. With increased frequency, the experimental spectra decrease with the slope close to that predicted. The spectra maxima are observed at frequencies of 10–20 Hz. Expansion of the front, due to atmosphere turbulence, results in reduction of the spectrum high frequency components. Electromagnetic field reflection from an infinitely thin SWF is determined by the refractivity jump, the reflection coefficient ⌫ given by
冉
n −n
| ⌫ | 2 = n1 + no 1 o
aaaaaaa aaaaaaa aaaaaaa aaaaaaa aaaaaaa Figure 1.20
冊
2
≈
⌬n 2 4
(1.28)
aaaaaaaa aaaaaaaa aaaaaaaa aaaaaaaa
(a) Pressure jump and (b) pressure impulse as functions of distance from an aircraft and a cone-cylinder body. (From: [7]. 1997 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
44
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.21
Power spectra of the pressure jump. (From: [51]. 1966 Acoustical Society of America.)
where n 1 and n o are the refractivity coefficients for the peak and atmosphere, respectively. Taking into account the adiabatic link between density and pressure for weak shock waves and the proportionality of refractivity coefficient to density, we get ⌬(n − 1) 1 ⌬ p = ⭈ n−1 ␥ p
(1.29)
冉 冊
(1.30)
and n−1
| ⌫ | 2 = 2␥ p
2
⭈ ⌬p2
where (n − 1) = 320 ⭈ 10−6 for a standard atmosphere at height about 500m above sea level. Because the SWF expands as it propagates in the atmosphere, the reflection coefficient is less than its value determined by (1.30) for an infinitely thin jump. Let us assume that the refractivity coefficient varies n0 =
再
n0
for x < 0
n 0 + ⌬n [1 − exp (−x /⌬)]
for x ≥ 0
(1.31)
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
45
where ⌬ is the effective front width and x denotes the direction normal to the front. It is easy to show that for this case
|⌫|
2
冉 冊
⌬n = 2
2
1
⭈ 1+
16 2⌬2
(1.32)
2
Two obstacles cause SWF expansion in the turbulent atmosphere. The first is that the presence of turbulent temperature pulsations results in sound speed fluctuations. The second is that the sound waves are carried by moving air, and therefore the presence of turbulent motions, described by turbulent pulsations of speed U ′, contributes to additional random distortions of front shape. In this case, the effective SWF width can be determined by the [56] ⌬ = 16
␥ p ⭈ ⑀ 2 ( + )2 L o o ␥+1 ⌬p
(1.33)
where L o is the outer scale of the atmosphere turbulence and ⑀ , , and are the parameters characterizing the atmospheric state. The value of L o increases linearly with altitude, changing from 1–2m near the land surface to 300–400m at the upper boundary of atmosphere. According to data presented in [57], for altitudes 100–200m, the typical value is L o ≅ 10m. The value of ⑀ 2 lies within the limits 10−7–10−5 and decreases with the altitude. The coefficient characterizes the turbulent pulsations of the sound speed a T , according to = a T /⑀ a o , and is usually close to unity. The coefficient characterizes the turbulent component of the flow speed U x′, which is parallel to the SWF normal and is equal to = U x′ /U o , where U o is the mean speed of the flow. When the wave propagates in the vertical direction the typical value of is 0.1–0.2. The results of deriving the effective width of the SWF for several parameters of turbulence ⑀ 2 ( + )2—carried out using (1.33)—are represented in Figure 1.22 by the solid lines. In the same figure, the experimental data [58] are shown for shock wave resulting from supersonic airplane flights. The dashed curve corresponds to dependence ⌬ = f (⌬ p ) for dry air when the SWF width is determined by intermolecular bonds and viscosity only. It is seen from Figure 1.22 that the real SWF width is two orders greater than the theoretical value for dry air, leading to reduction of the reflection coefficient. The dependences of the reflection coefficient upon the distance to the front derived according to (1.30) and (1.32) are presented in Figure 1.22(a). For distances about 10m from the object, the reflection coefficient is approximately equal to 10−10— almost the same in comparison with cases considered in Figure 1.22(b) and diminishing for greater distances.
46
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.22
(a) The effective front width and (b) the reflection coefficient as functions of distance to pressure peak ⑀ 2 <( + )2> equals to (1) 3 ⭈ 10−3, (2) 3 ⭈ 10−4, and (3) 3 ⭈ 10−5. (From: [7]. 1997 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
Taking into consideration that in the turbulent medium, besides SWF expansion, the SWF refractivity varies irregularly and reflection is possible in directions other than normal to the front. In this case, backscattering occurs due to the front roughness. This permits observation of reflections from the shock wave front in an angular region determined by the scattering pattern. For preliminary estimation, it is possible to use the assumption of fully isotropic scattering (meaning that the front distortions have amplitude less than the wavelength and a rather small correlation radius). This assumption results in higher estimates in comparison to the real data over much of space excepting the narrow region of angles near the direction of specular reflection. The effective radar cross section in this case is equal to
=
冕
⌫2(r ) dS
S il
where the integration must be carried out over an all-illuminated area. The estimates show that for 10-cm wavelength, when the antenna pattern width in both planes is about 0.01 radian and the distance to the object is 10 km, the value of the RCS of the SWF front at the distances from the object less than 10m is about 10−5–10−6 m2. This value is comparable with background reflections
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
47
from the turbulent troposphere. Taking into account that the spectrum maximum of the SWF pressure is observed at the frequencies 10–20 Hz (see Figure 1.21), the RCS of the SWF front can be greater at decimeter and meter wavelength in comparison with the estimates obtained for the centimeter waveband.
1.3.5.2 Microwave Scattering from Sound Perturbations in the Atmosphere
The airplane flights with near-sonic and supersonic speeds result in the appearance of a powerful sound wave field. For instance, the sound radiation power of ‘‘Phantom’’ airplane is about 10 millimeter waves. The sound wave propagation is followed by a dielectric constant variation of the medium and, as result, by electromagnetic wave scattering from these dielectric constant perturbations. Let us evaluate the scattered field intensity for this case. The dielectric constant of the medium in the sound wave field can be presented as e ( r›, t ) = ⑀ o + ⑀ 1 ( r›, t )
(1.34)
where ⑀ o = const denotes the dielectric constant of undisturbed medium, ⑀ 1 ( r›, t ) is the sound perturbation of the dielectric constant, usually ⑀ 1 ( r›, t ) << 1. The value of ⑀ 1 can be expressed from the Lorentz-Lorenz relationship [59] by the following
⑀ 1 ( r›, t ) ≈
n −1 ⑀o − 1 ⭈ ␦ = 2 o ⭈ ␦
(1.35)
where ␦ is the air density variation caused by the pressure changing due to the sound or shock wave propagation. It is expressed as
␦ 1 ␦ p = ⭈ ␥ p where is the air density. Taking into account that the sound speed in an undisturbed medium is equal to ao =
√
␥ ⭈ po o
after simple derivations we get from (1.13)
48
Radar Characteristics of Targets
⑀ 1 ( r›, t ) ≈ 2
no − 1 ⌬ p ⭈ 2 ao
(1.36)
The pressure variation in atmosphere during sound wave propagation can be presented as [60]
冋冉
›
冊册
R o √2 a o I o G a exp [−␣ (r − R o )] V ⌬p(r , t) = ⭈ exp −i ⍀t − k a r + k a r ao (1.37) ›
where G a is the normalized sound source directivity pattern, ⍀ denotes the frequency of the sound wave, k a = 2 / a is the acoustic wavenumber, V is a wind speed (later it is supposed that it is constant in the scattered area), I o denotes the sound field intensity measured for some sample range R o from source along the axis of radiation pattern, ␣ is an atmosphere absorption coefficient, and r is the current range from the sound source (see Figure 1.23). Substituting (1.37) into (1.36), we get
⑀ 1 ( r›, t ) =
冉
›
⑀1 V G cos ⍀t − k a r + k a r a ao
冊
(1.38)
where
⑀ 1 = 2√2 −1/2 a o−3/2 I o1/2 R o (n o − 1) exp [−␣ (r − R o )]
aaaaa aaaaa aaaaa aaaaa
Figure 1.23
Geometry for derivation.
(1.39)
49
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
The electromagnetic field reflected from the sound wave package can be described in the Born approach as k 2 exp (−i t ) E 1 (R 1 , t ) = 4 ⑀ o ›
冕冕 冕 |
—›
–›
e ik | R 1 − r
(V )
›
›
R1 − r
|
|
⑀ 1 ( r›, t )[ n›(⑀ o n›)] dV (1.40)
›
Here R 1 is the radius vector in the point of electromagnetic wave reception and denotes the frequency of electromagnetic field. Omitting the rather complex intermediate derivations, let us write the ratio of received-to-transmitted electromagnetic field power as
冉 冊
Pr Ro = 2I o Pt R1
2
(n o − 1)2 −2␣ (R 1 − R o ) k 2a 32 e 2 a o3 ⌬4R 14 | C 3 − C 2 /2R 1 |
冉
冤
V C1 + C2 x ao Vx × exp −4 2 2 − ⌬ C ⌬ ao 2 C3 − 2 2R 1
冉
冊 冊
2
冥
sin ⭈
冋
(1.41)
冉
冊册 冊册
a3 V 2⫿ 1− z o ao
冋
冉
V a3 2⫿ 1− z o ao
Here a 3 is the radial length of the sound package, k = 2 / is the wavenumber, ⌬ is the radar directivity pattern width, Vx and Vz are the speed vector projections onto the coordinate axes,
冋
C 2 = ik 2 ⫿
冉
V 1− z a ao
冊册
: C 3 = ik
冉
2 ⫿ / o 1 1 1 − 2 2+ 2 2R 1 R 1 ⌬a ⌬
冊
and ⌬a denotes the width of the acoustic source directivity pattern. It follows from (1.41) that the scattering of the electromagnetic field has a resonant character; its maximum occurring for / a determined by the expression 2−
冉
V 1− x a ao
冊
=0
(1.42)
The resonant maximum value is proportional to the number of wavelengths in the sound package (i.e., to the sound package length). Besides, the resonant length of the radiowave depends upon longitudinal component of wind speed Vz because the sound wave length is functionally connected with Vz . The wind speed cross component Vx leads to two effects, decreasing the level of reflected signal. The first phenomenon consists of sound wave package expanding
50
Radar Characteristics of Targets
out of the volume of the radar resolution cell; it is taken into consideration by the factor exp (−4Vx2 /⌬2a o2 ). The second effect deals with the distortion of the spherical shape of the sound wave phase front. In natural conditions, one more factor appears diminishing the backscattering efficiency. It is connected with turbulent pulsations of the atmosphere refractive index, which result in additional distortions of the sound wave phase front. The results of numerical derivation of the reflection coefficient for resonant scattering without wind, which were obtained for two radiowave bands (S- and X-bands), are presented in Figure 1.24. The derivations are carried out for the following values of parameters included in (1.39): a S = 200 a , R o = 10m, I o = 10 Wm−2, ⌬2 = 0.37 ⭈ 10−2, ⌬a2 = 0.03, T = 20°C, n o − 1 = 2.68 ⭈ 10−4, a o = 340 m/sec, = 1.29 kg/m3, ␣ = 2.5 ⭈ 10−2. It is seen that for the most favorable geometry and for distances between the radar and the sound wave source less than 100m, the ratio P r /P t is about 10−8–10−12, and it decreases with further distance (to −200 dB when the distance is about 500m). This means that the observation of radar reflections from sound waves is practically impossible at ranges typical for radar operation, especially for directions that do not coincide with normal to sound wave front. It is also worth noting that the main energy component in the jet propulsion engine sound radiation spectrum is concentrated in a frequency interval having a
Figure 1.24
Reflected signal ratio as a function of distance between the radar and sound wave source. (From: [7]. 1997 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
51
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
width less than 10 Hz [61]; the maximum of the weak shock wave spectrum also lies in the low frequency area (see Figure 1.21). This means that for radar detection of signals scattered by sound waves, it is more expedient to use the UHF or L-bands as in the case of detection of SWF reflections for supersonic flights. 1.3.5.3 Microwave Backscattering from Atmosphere Turbulent Perturbations Caused by the Interaction with Sound Field
Microwave signal backscattering from atmosphere turbulent perturbations is the result of their refractive index variations caused by temperature gradients or local humidity variations. The volume RCS in this case is determined as [62]
=
〈 ⌬n 2 〉 ⭈ k 2 ⭈ F n (k ) 8
(1.43)
where k = 2 / is the wave number, F n (k ) denotes one-dimension refractive index spectrum, and 〈 ⌬n 2 〉 is the variance of refractive index fluctuations. It is known [43] that the RCS is connected with the speed of energy dissipation ⑀ by the dependence ∼ ⑀ 2/3 and, consequently, ⑀ increase caused by any reasons leads to increased RCS. Shock wave or sound wave propagation in the atmosphere is accompanied by energy losses; part of the power is transformed into the power of turbulent motion, which can result in variation of energy dissipation speed and, as a result, in changing of the intensity and fluctuation spectrum of the refractive index. The sound intensity of the source of power P S at some range r is expressed as I (r ) =
PS 4 r 2
⭈ exp (−2␣ r )
(1.44)
It is easy to show that the sound energy loss of the sound wave is
 (r ) =
I (r ) ⭈ m;
m = 2␣
(1.45)
or
 (r ) =
mP S 4 r 2
exp (−mr )
(1.46)
The sound absorption coefficient in a homogeneous atmosphere depends on humidity and temperature, and for a standard atmosphere, it is equal to m = 4 ⭈ 10−5 at a frequency of 10 kHz. The presence of turbulent viscosity of T, which
52
Radar Characteristics of Targets
exceeds the cinematic viscosity of as T / ∼ R e [62], results in significant increase in the absorption coefficient; here R e is the Reynolds number. Taking into account that in the near-ground layer of the atmosphere R e ≥ 30–60 × 109, the sound energy loss rate is 10 times greater than that determined by (1.46). For example, for a sound source power P S = 5 MW and for range from the source equal to 10m the value of  , derived using (1.46), is  ≈ 0.01 m2sec−3, but taking into consideration the turbulent viscosity, it increases to  ≈ 0.2 m2sec−3. At the same time, the turbulent energy dissipation rate in lower atmosphere layers does not exceed 0.01–0.1 m2sec−3 [57] (i.e., it is approximately 10 times less than the additional energy obtained by atmosphere and due to the sound absorption). In several papers devoted to the concept of turbulence, it is shown that in some conditions the sound oscillations, even having relatively low power, can result in significant change of the turbulence characteristics. Omitting the theory, let us consider some conclusions and experimental results of such interaction investigations on the basis of papers [63–66]. 1. For rather great Reynolds numbers, there exist two-dimension speed fluctuations of a sinusoidal type (in atmosphere, their appearance is stipulated by Helmholtz instability). Under the influence of sound wave, having the frequency equal to the frequency of autooscillations of sinusoidal fluctuations, a sharp increase of fluctuations occurs. Sometimes several maxima at several frequencies occur, but always the main frequency can be distinguished. According to [65], for initial turbulence intensity approximately equal to 16%, the acoustic influence leads to the increasing of turbulent energy by 97%. 2. The spectra of the speed pulsations in the flow after acoustic influence have a resonant form. From the point of view of instability theory, the general tendency of resonant frequency behavior seems to be interesting. First of all, the resonant frequency is a continuous function of the flow speed, and for speeds less than 20 m/s it lies in the interval from 10 Hz to 1,000 Hz. 3. If the sound oscillations affect turbulent flow rather strongly, increase in the turbulence intensity occurs at the sonic frequency while its decrease takes the place at other frequencies [i.e., a transformation of F (k ) is observed]. 4. The influence of acoustic waves shows itself even when their intensity is not high. According to [67], the sound field amplitude must have the value about 0.01–0.1% of intensity of the main flow, and the sound field intensity does not exceed 0.001–1 W/m2. The forecasting estimates show that such a level of intensities can be expected at ranges less than some tens of meters from the object (e.g., airplane or missile), which produces this acoustic field. Experimental investigations were carried out, taking into account the complexity of the theoretical estimates of such sound wave interaction with atmospheric
1.3 Radar Reflections from Explosions and Gas Wakes of Operating Engines
53
turbulence and their influence on characteristics of the microwave backscattered field. An operating jet airplane engine was used as the source of intensive sound field. The parameters of the turbulent atmosphere were analyzed by two techniques. In the first, the measurements were made of flow speed turbulent pulsations for an engine operating in different regimes by means of thermoanemometer. The measured parameter in this case was the variance of the flow speed differences at several spatially separated points. The distance between sensors was 5 cm, and this provided a decrease in the influence of the direct sound field on the results of measurements. Because the air oscillations for frequencies of hundreds of Hertz, where the main part of the engine noise power is concentrated, were practically identical for both sensors, the signals received by them were mutually canceled. The experiment scheme is presented in Figure 1.25(a). The directions between the sensors and the axis of jet wake formed the angle 40°–60°, which excluded the entry of the combustion products into the displacement zone of the sensors. A sample of the process for a shutdown engine and for one operating in its nominal regime is demonstrated in Figure 1.25(b). It is seen that the speed fluctuation difference variance for the operating engine is larger than that with an undisturbed atmosphere. A forced engine operation regime did not lead to significant change in fluctuation variance in comparison with the nominal regime. The cumulative distributions of different variance are represented in Figure 1.26 (abscissa axis has the normalized values). It is seen that the influence of the sound field results in an increase in the speed difference variance in comparison
Figure 1.25
(a) The scheme of experiment and (b) the sample of flow speed turbulent pulsations for muffled and operating engine. (From: [7]. 1997 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
54
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.26
Cumulative distributions of flow speed different variance. (From: [7]. 1997 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
with the experiment when the engine is shut down. For the 50-m range, this difference is less evident and shows itself in the area of large variances only. Consequently, in the area of spatial scales of some centimeters, the sound influence on the turbulent atmosphere is observed only for ranges less than 10–20m. The second direction of investigations consisted of direct estimation of the microwave backscattering electromagnetic field level in the area of an operating engine. These measurements were performed with X-band continuous-wave radar. The illuminated spot was raised to the height of 100m over the aircraft to remove the reflections from its vibrating surface and from the area behind the engine. The minimal detectable RCS of this radar in the area of supposed backscattering was about 10−4–10−5 m2 in the filter bandwidth of 10 Hz. The observations have shown that the reflections from the atmosphere zone surrounding the aircraft did not exceed the minimal detectable level of RCS for all operation regimes of the jet engine. Therefore, further radar measurements are expedient using more sensitive radars. The results of investigation show that among three considered mechanisms of possible radar observation of aerodynamic objects using atmospheric sound perturbations caused by their flight, the most promising is the backscattering from
55
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
the shock wave front occurring during supersonic flight. The microwave backscattering from perturbations of the dielectric constant of the air, resulting from sound wave influence, turns out to be comparable with backscattering from natural turbulence of the atmosphere. The backscattering from the turbulent atmosphere due to variations in its spatial and temporal characteristics, caused by sound energy transformation into the power of turbulence, seems to be promising for radar detection and requires the further investigations with more sensitive radars. The general requirement is the use of L- or UHF-band radars for which these mechanisms appear to work more efficiently.
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets 1.4.1 Target Statistical Models
The statistical model of a target, as in general the description of its properties, must be developed with clear orientation to the scope of the problems being considered. Here the model analysis is chosen for applicability to the task of the detection and radar range estimation. The target model for this case has to correctly reflect only the fluctuation statistics of the signal amplitude or power (proportional to RCS) at a given moment of time. These properties are fully determined by the amplitude and phase relations of the elementary electromagnetic waves created by the target scattering elements in the radar receiver. For rather general assumptions about the characteristics of the bright points forming the radar target, it is possible to form the statistical description of the echo. The diffraction field (or signal amplitude) can be presented in the following way [68] S ( ) =
∑ A j e j
j
= X + iY
(1.47)
j
where A j is the echo amplitude of j th bright point. The phase j of every elementary signal depends on the range d j from the j th point to the plane of signal registration and the character of this point.
j = 2kd j + jo
(1.48)
The coordinate of d j can depend on the target aspect according to d j = d jo cos or in a more complicated manner for continuous change of the surface radius of curvature. For an unknown type of target motion and bright point distribution, the values d j can be considered as the random values with some distribution law p (d ). The pdf of phase does not practically depend on the distribution p (d ) and approaches a uniform distribution in the interval [− , ] if d / >> 2 .
56
Radar Characteristics of Targets
For slow change of amplitude A j in comparison with phase variation, the signal components in X and Y have asymptotically Gaussian distributions with equal variances (i.e., the echo is a narrowband Gaussian process). Generally, for symmetrical pdf p ( ), the mean value of the sine-component is equal to zero; the mean of the cosine-component is a ; and the variances of each component s 1 , s 2 are equal to a = X = nA 2 s 1 = nA 2 s 2 = nA 2
冕 冕
冕
p ( ) cos d
p ( ) cos2 d −
a 2
(1.49)
p ( ) sin2 d
The pdf of amplitude A is expressed as p (A ) =
冋
A d 2 (s 1 + s 2 )2 exp − − 2s 1 4s 1 s 2 √s 1 s 2
册
⭈
∑ (−1)m I m m
冉
冊 冉冊
s1 − s2 2 a A I 2m 4s 1 s 2 s1
(1.50)
For uniform phase distribution, we have a = 0, s 1 = s 2 and the amplitude pdf is Rayleigh: p (A ) =
冉 冊
2A A2 exp − n n
(1.51)
Such targets are called the Rayleigh targets. If among the elementary scatterers there exists a bright point nonfluctuating both in amplitude and phase, then the signal amplitude is described by the Rician pdf (a = c , s 1 = s 2 ) p (A ) =
冉
2A A2 + c2 exp − n n
冊 冉 冊 ⭈ I0
2c n
(1.52)
For more generalized case with s 1 ≠ s 2 one can find p (A ) =
冉
冤
k2 + 1 k2 + 1 k2 + 1 2 B2 + A A exp − k 2 2k 2 ×
∑ (−1)m I m m
where k =
2 √s 1 /s 2 ≠ 1, B = c /(s 1 + s 2 ) ≠ 0.
冉
k2 − 1 4k
2
冊
冊
A 2 I 2m (k 2 + 1) BA
(1.53)
冥
57
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
The set of parameters B = 0, k = 1 corresponds to the Rayleigh distribution, and B ≠ 0, k = 1 corresponds to the Rician distribution. For the objects with reflecting area dimensions many times larger than the wavelength, the parameter k differs from unity very little because the phase fluctuations in this case exceed . It permits wide use of the Rayleigh target model. It is worth noting that it describes well the scattering characteristics of complex targets if accuracy is not required in the pdf tails. To improve agreement between the model and experimental pdf, some authors made attempts to use more complicated concepts of real target reflection models. For example, there was the model in which the reflector forming the Rician distribution was augmented by high directivity reflectors with large RCS (comparable with total contribution from the other elements). Other models used strong specular reflections appearing only for narrow angle regions, resulting in RCS spikes for specific target aspects. However, these models did not receive the wide application in practice because of complexity or impossibility of multiple parameter estimations from the real data of these distributions. In the practice of statistical theory of radar, priority was given to the chi-square distribution, which for appropriate selection of parameters coincides rather well with the Rayleigh or produces enough accurate approximations of most empirical pdfs. The Swerling models [69] are widely used in radar theory as variants of the models with RCS variation according to chi-square distributions. The chi-square pdf takes the form [69] p ( , ) = =
冉 冊
1 ⭈ ⭈ ⌫( /2) 2 2
(v − 2)/2
冉 冊 冉 冊
exp −
2
(1.54)
2 2 (v − 2)/2 ( ) exp − 2 2v /2 ⌫( /2)
where 2 = / , ⌫( /2) is the gamma-function, is the mean RCS value, and is the number of degrees of freedom determining the ratio of the square of the mean RCS to RCS variance. Widely applied in radar, Swerling’s models are shown in Table 1.25. It is supposed in the first and third Swerling models that the received signals are nonfluctuating ones for one scan (slowly fluctuating pulse train) and uncorrelated between two scans. There are the varying signal fluctuations within one scan duration for the second and fourth models (independently fluctuating pulse train). For the Rayleigh case (1 and 2), the RCS pdf is described by the exponential law p ( , ) =
冉 冊
1 exp −
(1.55)
58
Radar Characteristics of Targets Table 1.25 The Swerling Models Type of Model Model 0 (Marcum’s model) Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4
RCS pdf
Echo Fluctuations
Stable target Rayleigh Rayleigh Four degrees of freedom Four degrees of freedom
No Slow Fast Slow Fast
Number of Freedom Degrees ∞ 2 2 4 4
For the two other models, the RCS pdf has the form p ( , ) =
冉 冊
4 2 exp −
(1.56)
They are similar to the RCS pdf of a target having one dominant stable scatterer together with many randomly distributed scatterers. In this sense, the expressions (1.55) and (1.56) give close results in the region of large probabilities. For the majority of complex targets, the Swerling models 1 and 2 are applicable, especially for observations over the angle range of about 360°. The application of the standard Swerling models, as a rule, leads to decreased estimations of RCS probabilities for the area of small values of probability, precluding reliable estimates of detection probability for a single signal at the area of correct detection probabilities of about PD ∼ 1. Besides, the Swerling models are poorly applicable to rather simple targets with small numbers of bright points. These difficulties were overcome by Weinstock [70, 71]. He extended the area of application of the chi-square distribution to degrees of freedom less than two. The number of degrees of freedom for some bodies of simple shape evaluated by Weinstock is presented in Table 1.26. This approach permits us to use the chi-square distribution for a wide class of approximations from Rayleigh and Rician ones to the popular log-normal distribution by adjusting of the numbers of degrees of freedom. 1.4.2 Real Target Statistical Characteristics
The most extensive experimental data are obtained for air target RCS distributions [72–75]. These results permit us to confirm that for air targets, the amplitude Table 1.26 The Number of Degrees of Freedom for Simple Bodies Type Randomly oriented cylinder Stabilized cylinder Randomly oriented bodies of spheroid shape Source: [70].
Freedom Degrees Number 0.6–1.4 4.0 4.0
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
59
distributions can be approximated rather well by the Rayleigh law up to amplitude values six times greater than the mean. As illustration, the cumulative RCS distributions for piston-engine and jet airplanes are presented in Figure 1.27 obtained in [72] at the 3-cm wavelength; the exponential distribution is showed by the dashed line. It is seen that the experimental results agree with the Rayleigh model in the area of most probable RCS values, although the RCS mean value is somewhat greater than in this model (within limits from 1.1 to 1.5) (i.e., the distribution does not predict the largest observed signal intensities). For jet airplanes, the agreement of the experimental results with the Rayleigh model is more satisfactory than for piston-engine aircraft. These results are obtained for long-period observation of targets or for averaging of signals over a wide aspect sector. If the observation time is small relative to the echo fluctuation period, a different chi-square law describes the experimental data. For long observation time and large airplane aspect change, the data approach the Rayleigh statistics ( = 2), and for small time of observation the degree of freedom number increases up to = 10. The results of
Figure 1.27
Cumulative RCS distributions of (a) piston-engine and (b) jet airplanes at the X-band. (After: [72].)
60
Radar Characteristics of Targets
freedom degree number determination for three types of airplanes and for a helicopter obtained at the wavelength of 10 cm are presented in Figure 1.28 [73]. It is seen that for a spectrum width of 20 Hz, good agreement between the experimental data and the Rayleigh model is observed for observation time more than 5 seconds. For air target observation over a sector of 10°, the freedom degree number decreases to values from 0.9 to 2.4. The RCS distributions for large land and marine targets, as a rule, coincide well with the Rayleigh model in the area of the most probable RCS values [23, 26]. The distributions tails, characterizing the probability of large RCS values, are usually higher than for the model. However, chi-square distributions with freedom degree number ≥ 2 can approximate the experimental results. As an illustration, the distributions of the instantaneous values of signal from the output of a phase detector are presented in the Figure 1.29(a) for onshore and inflatable boats. These data were obtained at the 3-cm wavelength and are plotted on a scale linearizing the Gaussian distribution. The amplitude distributions for an inflatable are presented in Figure 1.29(b) on a scale linearizing the Rayleigh law. Similar results are obtained for small marine targets. The amplitude distributions for marine buoys in X-band are closer to the Rician distribution, while for the majority of targets like motor boats, rowboats, spheres, and corner reflectors placed on the sea surface, the amplitude distributions are approximated by Rayleigh and Rician laws in a satisfactory way. As an illustration, the RCS cumulative distribution for an anchored sphere obtained at a 3-cm wavelength for sea state about of two is presented in Figure 1.30 [27]. The solid curves correspond to chisquare distributions with different number of degrees of freedom. It is seen that
Figure 1.28
Freedom degree number for airplanes and helicopter at S-band. (After: [73].)
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.29
61
(a) The cumulative instantaneous value distributions for inshore and inflatable boats and (b) amplitude distribution for inflatable boats at X-band.
the experimental data satisfactory coincide with the chi-square distribution for = 5–6. Some RCS distribution peculiarities are observed for simple cone-cylinder bodies. In the majority of situations during experimental investigations, their difference from Rayleigh model was noticed; in particular, the ratio of the power of the fluctuation component to the total power was equal to 0.03–0.19, which is less than the corresponding value for a Rayleigh target [23, 74]. RCS cumulative distributions for a cone-cylinder body with 150-mm diameter and about 500-mm length obtained at X-band are presented in Figure 1.31 [23, 26] (solid lines are the chi-square distributions with different number of freedom degrees). The comparison of the experimental data with the model permits us to assert that with reasonable confidence, the approximation of these data is possible by chi-square distributions with 0.8 ≤ ≤ 4.
62
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.29
(Continued.)
In spite of comparatively poor data for the statistical characteristics of biologic objects, apparently, it is possible to establish as a working hypothesis that the RCS distribution for man, large animals, and birds is lognormal with a standard deviation of 8–10 dB [29, 30, 75] and that the amplitude distribution of insect backscattering is Rayleigh. Consequently, the analysis of RCS experimental distributions for practically all types of targets confirms the validity of their approximation by chi-square distribution with different number of degrees of freedom for solving detection problems. For targets of complex shape, it is possible the use of the standard Swerling models for practically all cases.
1.4.3 Echo Power Spectra
The radar signals scattered from moving objects have Doppler frequencies determined by target velocity and aspect, and these frequencies can reach rather high values. Besides a linear motion, the motion of object can have angular and linear
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.30
63
Cumulative RCS distributions for anchored sphere at X-band and comparison with chi-square distribution.
oscillations in three planes. As a result of object vibration and oscillatory motion, the individual parts of the object can have different radial velocities with respect to the radar. This phenomenon creates the echo spectrum. For a complex object motion, including linear motion with some velocity V and an oscillating component mV cos (⍀ + ), where m is the modulation coefficient, the echo is frequency modulated with the spectral components that are equally spaced with respect to the Doppler frequency determined by target velocity and spatial orientation. Acceleration of the object results in spreading of the spectrum. As D. K. Barton showed [75, p. 82], the power spectrum of the echo from a target of complex shape can be presented as the spectrum of a Markov’s process with intensity reduced at frequencies above some defined ⌬F
64
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.31
Cumulative RCS distributions for cone-cylinder targets with diameter of 150 mm at X-band.
冋 冉
F − F0 G (F ) = G 0 1 + ⌬F
冊册
2 −1
(1.57)
where G 0 is the spectral density at frequency F 0 determined as F 0 = 2V / , V is the object radial velocity, and ⌬F is the half-width of the spectrum at the halfpower level. Then the spectral density decreases at the rate of 6 dB per octave for | F − F 0 | >> ⌬F. The signal power spectra at the X- and Ka-bands for all air targets including airplanes and helicopters are characterized by comparatively small spectrum width and large value of F 0 due to linear motion. So, for the L-200 aircraft, the effective
65
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
spectral width at X-band is 20–30 Hz at the −6 dB level, almost independent of the polarization This corresponds to the measured spectra results for piston-engine and jet airplanes of [72], the author of which expressed the normalized autocorrelation function as
( ) = exp (− / 0 )
(1.58)
where 0 is the correlation interval having a value close to 0.05-second 3-cm wavelength. For all piston-engine and jet airplanes for forward aspects, pronounced peaks in the spectra are observed that result from propeller or compressor vane rotation, as illustrated in Figure 1.32. For lower levels (less than −30 dB), one can expect spectral components with frequencies corresponding to fuselage vibrations. As is shown in [76], the fuselage vibrations for piston-engine and jet airplanes are described by the dependence G (F ) ∼ F −2 and have frequency components of 500– 600 Hz. Those components with vibration amplitude of I max ≥ 2.5 are found in the frequency band less than 40 Hz. In this situation at a wavelength of 8 mm, the phase modulation index is approximately equal to two, which is why the spectral components reach 150–200 Hz (i.e., noticeable spectrum spreading is observed).
Figure 1.32
Power spectrum for L-200 airplane at X-band. (From: [26]. 1995 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
66
Radar Characteristics of Targets
The echo spectra of helicopters have evident propeller modulation. To demonstrate this phenomenon, the power spectra of echoes from the Russian helicopter Mi-4 is presented in Figure 1.33, obtained at a wavelength of 3 cm for different aspects. For flight directions toward the radar, the power spectra are quite narrow; their width at the −10-dB level does not exceed 300–400 Hz. For increasing range between helicopter and radar, the spectrum spreads significantly. This can be caused by modulation of the echo by the rotating rear propeller. For a hovering helicopter, the spectrum central frequency F 0 shifts into the zero frequency area, and significant spectrum spreading at the level of (1–2) ⭈ 10−6 m2/Hz is observed up to frequencies of 10 kHz. Besides, there are the peaks of propeller modulation that are at 6–10 dB higher than the surrounding average level. The propeller modulation peaks were not observed at a wavelength of 8 mm, and the spectra were still wider, reaching 1 kHz at the −10-dB level. The echo power spectra for land objects are also comparatively narrowband, their width at the −3-dB level lying within the limits of ⌬F /F 0 = 0.06–0.23. The spectrum width values for some land objects at the 3-cm wavelength are presented in Table 1.27.
Figure 1.33
Power spectra of helicopter Mi-4 at X-band. (From: [26]. 1995 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
67
Table 1.27 Land Target Spectrum Width at Wavelength of 3 cm Object Tank Armored car Heavy artillery tractor Light artillery tractor Truck
Spectrum Width (Hz) at Level −10 dB −20 dB 50 200 50 190 115 400–600 100–300 300–550 50–135 200–450
Examples of power spectra for tank and truck at the wavelength of 8 mm are presented in Figures 1.34 and 1.35. It is seen from Table 1.27 that at low levels of intensity the spectrum width for targets of the first two types (caterpillar objects) is significantly less than for objects having a large number of independently moving parts (wheeled objects). The central frequency F 0 and spectral width ⌬F increase in inverse proportional to the wavelength.
Figure 1.34
Power spectra for tank at X-band.
68
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.35
Power spectra of GAZ-63 truck at X-band.
The power spectra for large marine targets caused by pitch, roll, and heave in rough sea are characterized by comparatively small width, not exceeding a few hertz in X-band, and rather large central frequencies. Let us determine the power spectra shape, taking into account that the spectrum of echo G ( ) is connected with the spectrum of target heave G z ( ) by the following relation [77] G ( ) = 2 ⭈ G z ( )
(1.59)
The spectrum of heave is determined by the spectrum of the waves G m ( ) through the transfer function K ( ) of the linear dynamic system. It is known that a dynamic system like a ship has a rather narrow passband, and its transfer function can be presented as [77]
69
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
| K ( ) | Z =
kZ 2 2 2 2 2 √(1 − / Z ) + 4 Z / Z
(1.60)
where Z is the natural frequency of ship oscillations, Z is the heave decrement, and k Z is the reduction coefficient. Then one can get the following expression for the power spectra of heave G Z ( ) =
| K ( ) | Z2
⭈ G m ( ) =
2 kZ G m ( )
(1 − 2/ Z2 )2 + 4 Z 2/ Z2
(1.61)
For the majority of ships and other marine objects, especially small ones, the natural frequencies of oscillations lie in the area Z >> , then 2 G m ( ) G Z ( ) ≈ k Z
(1.62)
(i.e., the spectrum of heave is proportional to the wave power spectrum). Taking into consideration that the spectrum of fully developed waves in the gravitational domain can be approximated as
冋 冉 冊册
G m ( ) =  g 2 −5 exp −0.74
g U
2
(1.63)
where U is the wind velocity, g is the gravitational constant, and  is the parameter, which weakly depends on the frequency varying from 2 ⭈ 10−3 in the low-frequency region to 10−2 in the high frequency region of the gravitational spectrum. Then it is possible to predict from (1.60) and (1.61) that the echo spectrum in the high-frequency region is described by the dependence G ( ) ∼ −3. Taking this into account, we derive the spectrum approximations for marine objects as [23, 26]
冋 |
G (F ) = G 0 1 +
F − F0 ⌬F
|册
n −1
(1.64)
where G 0 is the spectral density at frequency F 0 determined as F 0 = 2V / , ⌬F is the spectrum half-width at the −3 dB level, and V is the radial component of the target velocity in respect to the radar. The spectrum width and power index experimentally obtained for some marine targets at the 3-cm wavelength are presented in Table 1.28 and the spectrum width at wavelengths of 8 mm and 4 mm are shown in Table 1.29 (data were obtained for sea state 1–2). It can be noticed
70
Radar Characteristics of Targets Table 1.28 Spectrum Width and Power Index of Marine Targets at Wavelength of 3 cm
Object Onshore motor boat –Anchored –Moving Message cutter Cruiser yacht Sport yacht Motor boat Rowboat Inflatable boat Windsurf Anchored barrel
Spectrum Width (Hz) at Level (dB) −3 −10 2.0 5.0 7.0 4.0 6.0 3.0 2.0 8.5 7.0 5.0
4.6 10.0 15.0 10.0 12.0 11.0 5.5 20.0 19.0 11.5
Mean Index n 2.6 3.2 2.75 2.6 3.7 1.9 2.6 2.5 2.4 3.0
Table 1.29 Spectrum Width of Marine Targets at Millimeter Band Object Motor boat Boat Inflatable boat Navigation buoy Spherical buoy Spherical buoy
Wavelength (mm) 8 8 8 4 8 4
Spectrum Width (Hz) at Level −3 dB 13.0 8.5 8.0 5.5 0.6–0.8 0.65
that the power degree indices in the expression for target power spectrum usually decrease with decreasing object size or increasing sea state. The power spectra of biological objects have some rather typical peculiarities. The spectra of human echoes are narrowband, their width for the −3-dB level equal to 20–30 Hz and mean Doppler frequency F 0 for the motion is 80–100 Hz at the 3-cm wavelength. The echo amplitude and frequency modulation take a form controlled by motion of arms and legs and is expressed in the appearance of step modulation peaks. As an illustration, the current spectra of moving man and swimming man obtained at a 3-cm wavelength are presented in Figures 1.36 and 1.37. The signals scattered from birds are, as a rule, amplitude modulated ones. The frequency of modulation is inversely proportional to bird size. In [63], it was experimentally determined that the modulation frequency F m (Hz) is connected with the wing length l (mm) as F m l 0.897 = 572
(1.65)
The frequency of wing strokes for the white heron equals to 2–4 Hz, and is about 10 Hz for the swallow, 3–4 Hz for the seagull, and 6–7 Hz for ducks. The wing
71
1.4 Statistical Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.36
Power spectrum of moving man.
oscillations are nonsinusoidal, and there are a number of harmonic components in the echo. The velocity of birds can be about 15 m/s and more for migration and local flights, corresponding to Doppler frequencies of about 1 kHz at a 3 cm wavelength. The Doppler spectrum width can be determined as [63] ⌬F = 10.9Ad 0.21 −1
(1.66)
where A is the angular motion amplitude of wing for stroke and d is the distance from body to forearm end (m) excluding the length of flapping feathers. It is seen from (1.66) that a bird size change by 10 times leads to only 60% spectrum widening. As a rule, these spectra are rather narrowband; their width being not greater than 10–20 Hz at a 3-cm wavelength. The spectrum of the echo from a seagull obtained at X-band is presented in Figure 1.38. Thus, we have presented the experimentally obtained power spectra at microwave and millimeter bands for practically all types of targets and a convenient approximation of spectrum shape by expression of (1.64).
72
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Figure 1.37
Power spectra of swimming man at X-band.
1.5 Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets 1.5.1 Diffuse Scattering Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics
In the shortwave part of the centimeter band and, particularly, in the millimeter band, the diffuse component of the electromagnetic field scattered by the surface grows significantly together with the destruction of the specular reflection. In this situation the spatial correlation radii of the reflected diffuse component over the target is larger in most cases than the geometric dimensions of the target [78]. Then the received signal is a product of two terms: the first describes the radar target signal fluctuations in free space and second one describes the fluctuations of the propagation factor. This division was used in some papers [79, 80]. Later we will consider the point target placed over the rough surface that is statistically equivalent (in its RCS distribution functions and power spectra) to the real target. In this case, the surface influence reduces to modulation of the target echo. The signal amplitude and RCS in the point of reception can be presented as
1.5 Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets
Figure 1.38
73
Power spectrum of seagull at X-band.
A*t = A t ⭈ F 2
(1.67)
*t = t ⭈ F 4
(1.68)
where A t , t are the amplitude and RCS of the target in free space, respectively, and F is the surface propagation factor. Using the relations for the pdf the product of two random values [80] and assuming that the RCS probability function in free space is described by the standard Swerling models [69, 81], we obtain the expression for the probability function of the normalized RCS as ∞
p I ( ) = A 0
冕 冋冉 exp −
0
+⭈x x
冊册
dx ⭈ I 0 ( ␥ ⭈ x 1/2 ) x
(1.69a)
74
Radar Characteristics of Targets
for Swerling models 1 and 2, and ∞
p II ( ) = 4 A 0
冕 冋冉 exp −
2 +⭈x x
0
冊册
dx ⭈ I 0 ( ␥ ⭈ x 1/2 ) 2 x
(1.69b)
for Swerling models 3 and 4. Here
=
*i is the target RCS normalized to mean value. * i
A0 =
=
冉 冊
1 f2 exp − 02 . 2 d 2 d 1 2
2 d
f0 =
;
␥=
f 02 2
2 d
.
√1 + 0 − 2 0 cos is the specular reflection coefficient. 2
0 , d are the specular and diffuse reflection factors depending on surface roughness, radar wavelength and determined, for example, in [11]. I 0 is the Bessel function of zero order. Calculating (1.69) we obtain finally p I ( ) = A 0
p II ( ) = 8 A 0
冤∑ ∞
−1
∞
∑
=0
冉冊
␥ 2 ⭈ 2 2  2 ( !)
冉冊
␥ 2 ⭈ 2 2  2 ( !)
( − 1)/2
/2
K 冠2 √ 冡
K − 1 冠2 √ 冡 +
冉冊 
1/2
(1.70a)
⭈ K 1 冠2 √ 冡
冥
(1.70b) where K (⭈) is the modified Bessel function. Equations (1.70a) and (1.70b) permit us to obtain the moments for the RCS probability functions in the first and second Swerling models as ∞
m l (I ) = A 0 l !
冕 0
exp (− ⭈ x ) ⭈ I 0 (␥ x 1/2 ) x l ⭈ dx
(1.71a)
75
1.5 Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets ∞
−l
m l (II ) = 2 A 0 (l + 1)!
冕
exp (− ⭈ x ) ⭈ I 0 (␥ ⭈ x 1/2 ) x l ⭈ dx
(1.71b)
0
Comparing (1.71a) and (1.71b), it is easily to obtain the dependence connecting the moments for two models in the form m l (II ) = 2−l ⭈ (l + 1) ⭈ m l (I )
(1.72)
Equations (1.71a), (171b), and (1.72) permit us to obtain all l-moments of the normalized target RCS including the mean value, rms, and the skewness and asymmetry for most models. Let us consider some particular cases of the rough surface effect on the radar target statistical characteristics. For a weakly rough surface in the maximum of the interference lobe, when the condition f 0 / d > 1, is fulfilled, and for a surface with considerable roughness at great ranges, when the diffuse scattering coefficient d decreases more quickly than the specular reflection coefficient 0 , the propagation factor density function is close to the Gaussian distribution [78] p (F ) =
冋
1 (F − f 0 )2 exp − 2 2 d √2 ⭈ d
册
(1.73)
and for f 0 / d >> 1 p (F ) = ␦ (F − f 0 )
(1.74)
where ␦ (⭈) is the Dirac function. Then the RCS distribution of the target can be presented as
冉 冊 冉 冊
2* 1 p I (*t ) = ⭈ exp − t * t t* p II (*t ) =
2* 4*t exp − t 2 t* ( t* )
(1.75a)
(1.75b)
2 for the first and second Swerling models, respectively, where *t = t /f 0 . The comparison of (1.75) with the RCS distributions in the standard Swerling model shows that for a weak diffuse surface scattering, the common shape of the RCS distributions is retained and a scale transformation takes the place.
76
Radar Characteristics of Targets
For small values of f 0 / d << 1, typical for pure diffuse scattering and also in the interference minima of the electromagnetic field (f 0 → 0), the density function of the surface propagation factor has the form
冉 冊
(1.76)
p I ( ) = 2B 0 K 0 冠2 √  冡
(1.77a)
p II ( ) = 8 B 0 K 0 冠2 √  冡
(1.77b)
p (F ) =
F
exp − 2
d
F2
2
2 d
and the RCS distributions equal
The comparison of (1.75) and (1.76) shows the significant difference of the RCS distributions from the Swerling’s models at the last case. For great values of (i.e., in the band of the intensive spikes of the echo), using the asymptotic form [82] K v (z ) = z→∞
√
⭈ e −z 2z
(1.78)
one can show that the rate of decrease of the distribution for large values of target RCS in (1.77) is determined by the term exp (−2 1/2 1/2 ) and is less than in the Swerling models for all values of  ≠ 0. An examination of these models was carried out using experimental data on the statistical characteristics of the RCS for some types of the cone-cylindrical targets with a diameter of 100 mm moving over a land surface with a velocity of about 180 m/s. The cumulative functions of the RCS distribution obtained experimentally (curve 1) and derived with use of (1.77) for two values of the diffuse scattering coefficient (curve 2 for d = 0.2 and curve 3 for d = 0.4), and the RCS distribution for the first Swerling model (line 4) are presented in Figure 1.39; line 4 describes in the best way the target RCS distribution in free space [83, 84]. It is seen that except in the regions of high confidence, the data coincide with the derived model. The difference between the derived and experimental results in the initial part of the cumulative function can be explained by the use of the approximate method of derivation based on the inclusion of only diffuse echo (i.e., the application of the Gaussian distribution of the diffuse scattering coefficient instead of the Rician distribution) and the large errors of the experimental results in this part of the curve. The RCS distributions for targets over a land surface smoother decrease for the large values of the RCS in comparison with the standard Swerling distributions.
1.5 Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets
Figure 1.39
77
The RCS cumulative functions for cone-cylindrical targets. (From: [8]. 2001 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
Besides, the increasing of the RCS fluctuations is seen at small ranges when the specular component of the electromagnetic field is absent because of the increasing grazing angle and, as consequence, the increase of the roughness parameter. At large ranges, the specular component of the field increases, and, as result, the RCS distribution is near that for free space. The results of derivation of the RCS distribution quantiles for experimental data and distributions of (1.75) for two values of the diffuse scattering coefficients are presented in Table 1.30. It is seen from Table 1.30 that the surface effect leads to an increase in the intensive spikes of the RCS. Increasing the diffuse scattering coefficient by a factor
78
Radar Characteristics of Targets Table 1.30 The Comparison of the Experimental and Derived Quantiles of RCS Distributions
Conditions Experimental data for free space Derivation for d = 0.2 Derivation for d = 0.4 Source: [8].
Distribution Quantiles, dB (m 2 ) for Confidence Level 0.1 0.5 0.9 −13 −15 −24.5 −12 −18 −26 −8 −16 −26
of two leads to RCS growth by 4 dB for confidence level of 0.1. At the same time, the RCS values practically coincide for large confidence levels. Therefore, a diffuse scattering surface leads to RCS distribution transformation of radar targets, especially for regions of large RCS. 1.5.2 Multiple Surface Reflection Influence
Let us estimate the RCS change for low-altitude targets with very small altitudes. The geometry of this problem is presented in Figure 1.40. For echo power reflected by the target in the direction of the radar (the solid lines 1), the effect of the rough surface is absent. For this case, the target is characterized by RCS t ; for most of the targets, these characteristics are known rather well. Power is also reflected to the surface and back to the radar (dotted lines 2), increasing the target total RCS
⌺ = t + *t
(1.79)
where * t is the component created by the interaction of the target with the surface (bistatic scattering). One can estimate the power reflection from the target to surface direction using the bistatic RCS of the target in the direction of the surface. The power density at the surface can be determined as
Figure 1.40
The geometry of the problem: (a) the scattering directions and (b) the lighted area.
1.5 Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets
⌸2 =
Pt G t b (4 )2r 2h 2
79
(1.80)
where P t , G t are the transmitter power and antenna gain, respectively. r is the range from the radar to the target. h is the target altitude.
b is the target bistatic RCS. According to Crispin’s theorem [84, 85], the mean value of the bistatic RCS for all target aspects can be determined through the monostatic RCS. The power density at the target equals
⌸3 =
⌸2 0 S eff 4 h 2
(1.81)
where 0 = 0(␥ ) is the surface normalized RCS depending on the incidence angle ␥ and S ef−f is the area of the illuminated surface that effectively reflects in the target direction. The normalized RCS of the sea surface for small incidence angles ␥ strongly depends on the value of this angle. The normalized RCS for incidence angles from 0° to 15°, obtained in [86] at the wavelengths of 3.2 cm and 0.86 cm for different wind velocities, are presented in Table 1.31. The value of the effective incidence angle ␥ eff , determining the incidence angle interval for which the surface effectively reflects the field energy to the target direction can be determined as
Table 1.31 Dependence of the Sea Normalized RCS on the Incidence Angle Wavelength (cm) 0.86
3.2
Source: [8].
Wind Velocity (ms −1 ) 2.5–5.0 5.0–7.5 7.5–10.0 10.0–12.0 2.5–5.0 5.0–7.5 7.5–10.0
0 16 14 13 12 5 3 −1
0 (dB) for Incidence Angles (degree) 2.5 5.0 7.5 10.0 12.5 11 7 2.5 −5 −13 13 12 11 9 6 12.5 12 11 9.5 8 11.5 10.5 9.7 8 7 3 0.5 −2.0 −5.0 −7.5 2.5 1.5 0.5 −0.5 −2.5 −1.5 −3.0 −4.0 −5.0 −6.5
15.0 — 2 6.5 6.0 −10.5 −4.0 −8.0
80
Radar Characteristics of Targets /2
冕
␥ eff =
0(␥ ) ⭈ d␥
0
(1.82)
0(0)
The derivation results of ␥ eff from the data of Table 1.2 are presented in Table 1.32. It is seen from Table 1.32 that for increasing wind velocity, a broadening of the angle cone takes place, determining the effective reflection of the signal from the surface to the target direction. This area equals to S eff = (␥ eff ⭈ h )2
(1.83)
The reflected energy density at the radar is also determined by the target bistatic RCS ⌸4 =
⌸3 b
(1.84)
4 ⭈ r 2
Then, taking into consideration (1.80)–(1.84), the received power can be presented as 2
0 P G 2 2 S eff b Pr = t 3 4 ⭈ (4 ) r (4 h 2 )2
(1.85)
This expression is a radar equation for which the mean RCS for reflections from the surface equals to 2
*t =
0 b S eff (4 h 2 )2
2
=
2
0 b ␥ eff 16 h 2
(1.86)
It is seen from (1.86) that * t is proportional to the square of the target bistatic RCS. It is inversely proportional to the square of target altitude, and it increases Table 1.32 Dependence of ␥ eff on Wind Velocity Wavelength (cm) 0.86 3.2 Source: [8].
␥ eff (degree), for Wind Velocity (ms −1 ) 2.5–5.0 5.0–7.5 7.5–10.0 10.0–12.5 3.75 8.75 11.1 11.1 6.0 10.5 10.5 —
81
1.5 Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets
for increasing wind velocity because of the increasing effective angle. The derivation results of * t for some objects at the altitude h = 1m are presented in Table 1.33 (␥ eff values are taken from the Table 1.32). It is seen from Table 1.33 that significant growth of *t is observed for targets having a bistatic RCS considerably exceeding, in the surface direction, the monostatic RCS. For a nonfluctuating target moving over the surface, as shown in Figure 1.40, the reflected signal becomes a fluctuating one because of the surface effect. Let us consider this phenomenon for the movement over the sea. For known dependencies of 0(␥ ), one can determine the probability function of 0 and, consequently, * t , taking in consideration the amplitude modulation of the normalized RCS of the sea, because of the slope angle change of the scattering area caused by large waves. As is known [87], the probability function of the slope angles of the sea surface can be expressed as p ( ) =
冉
1 2 exp − 2 2 √2
冊
(1.87)
where is the rms value of the surface slope angles, which do not exceed ≤ 0.1 for sea [87]. Then we obtain using the results of [80] p ( * t ) = p [ 1 (* t )] ⭈
| |
| |
d 1 d 2 + p [ 2 ( * t )] ⭈ d * d*t t
(1.88)
Taking into consideration that the 0( ) dependence at the angular band of interest can be approximated with sufficient accuracy by
0( ) = 0 exp (−␣ ),
≥0
we obtain
Table 1.33 Values of *t for Different Objects
Type of Target Bullet of caliber 22 Sphere-cone-sphere with top half-angle 15° Cone with top half-angle 15° Source: [8].
Wavelength (cm) 3.2 0.86
b / b (dB) 1.25 7.5
3.2 3.2
6.0 −15.0
t* (dB) for Wind Velocity (ms −1 ) 2.5–5.0 7.5–10.0 −29.2 −30.3 −9.6 −4.3 −12.6 −54.6
−7.3 −49.3
82
Radar Characteristics of Targets
冋 册
1 0( ) = − ln 2 0
(1.89)
Using (1.86) for *t determination, we present it as
*t = ⭈ 0( ) =
再
⭈ 0 exp (−␣ 1 ),
1 ≥ 0
⭈ 0 exp (␣ 2 ),
2 < 0
(1.90)
where 2
=
2
b ⭈ ␥ eff 16 h 2
Then
冉 冊 冉 冊
1 *t 1 = − ln 2 ⭈ 0
2 =
(1.91a)
1 *t ln 2 ⭈ 0
(1.91b)
and
| | | |
1 d 1 d 2 = = d*t d*t ␣*t
(1.92)
Taking in consideration (1.91), (1.92), (1.88) can be transformed to the form
p ( * t ) =
冤
2 exp − √2 ⭈ ␣ *t
冉
ln2 −
*t ⭈ 0
2 ␣ 2
冊
冥
for 0 ≤ * t ≤ ⭈ 0 (1.93)
It is seen from (1.93) that the probability density of * t conforms to a truncated logarithmic Gaussian law. Introducing y = * t / 0 and  = ␣ , we have finally p(y) =
冉
冊
ln2 y 2 exp − , 2 2 √2  y
0≤y≤1
(1.94)
1.5 Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets
83
and the cumulative function
F(y) =
冦
2⌽ 0,
冉 冊
ln y , 
y≥0
(1.95)
y<0
where ⌽(⭈) is the Laplace function. The obtained distribution of *t has higher level of tails in comparison with the standard Swerling models. The probabilities of exceeding the median value by an amount y at wavelengths of 3.2 cm and 0.86 cm are presented in Figure 1.41. The analysis of these results shows that the increase of sea echo fluctuations in the millimeter band in comparison with the centimeter band leads to increasing the probability of the * t value exceeding the median value. For a simple shape target at small altitude the over the surface of a rough sea, the increase in the RCS caused by the reflection from the surface exceeds the monostatic RCS of these targets with 10% confidence.
Figure 1.41
Probability of median value exceeding by y. (From: [8]. 2001 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
84
Radar Characteristics of Targets
Thus, it is possible to arrive at the following conclusions: •
•
•
The flight of low-altitude targets over a diffuse scattering surface leads to a change in their distribution laws in the region of large values of RCS, in comparison with Swerling’s models. An analogous result gives the electromagnetic field reflection for the path target to surface. The RCS increase and higher level of tails in the RCS distributions are most visible for targets when the bistatic RCS in the surface direction exceeds the monostatic RCS. The effect of RCS increase is observed most strongly for target altitudes of meters over the surface. The differences of the RCS distributions from the Swerling models increase with the radar wavelength reduction.
It is necessary to note that these conclusions can be similarly applied to the land surface.
References [1]
[2]
[3] [4] [5]
[6] [7]
[8] [9] [10]
Kulemin, G. P., and V. B. Razskazovsky, ‘‘Radar Reflections from Explosion and Gas Wake of Operating Engine,’’ IEEE Trans. on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 45, No. 4, 1997, pp. 731–739. Kulemin, G. P., and V. B. Razskazovsky, ‘‘Centimeter and Millimeter Radio Wave Signal Attenuation in Explosion,’’ IEEE Trans. on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 45, No. 4, 1997, pp. 740–743. Neuringer, J. L., ‘‘Derivation of the Spectral Density Function of the Energy Scattering from Underdense Turbulent Wake,’’ AIAA Journal, Vol. 7, No. 4, 1969, pp. 728–730. Fox, J., ‘‘Space Correlation Measurements in the Fluctuating Turbulent Wakes Behind Projectiles,’’ AIAA Journal, Vol. 5, No. 2, 1969, pp. 362–368. Velmin, V. A., Yu. A. Medvedev, and B. M. Stepanov, ‘‘Radar Echoes from Explosion Area,’’ Journal of Experimental Techniques and Physics, Vol. 7, December 1968, pp. 455–457 (in Russian). Boynton, F. P., C. B. Ludwig, and A. Thomson, ‘‘Spectral Emissivity of Carbon Particles Clouds in Rocket Exhausts,’’ AIAA Journal, Vol. 6, No. 5, 1968, pp. 116–124. Kulemin, G. P. and V. B. Razskazovsky, ‘‘Radar Backscattering from Sonic Perturbations Caused by Aerodynamic Object Flight,’’ Proc. SPIE Radar Sensor Technology II, Vol. 3, No. 066, June 1997, pp. 194–202. Kulemin, G. P., ‘‘Sea and Land Surface Influence on the Statistical Characteristics of the Low-Altitude Radar Targets,’’ SPIE Proc., Vol. 4, No. 374, 2001, pp. 156–164. Shtager, E. A., Radiowave Scattering on the Complex Objects, Moscow, Russia: Radio i svyaz, 1986 (in Russian). Pavelyev, A. G., ‘‘About Scattering of Electromagnetic Waves by the Rough Surface and Frequency Spectrum of the Scattered Signal,’’ Radiotechnics and Electronics, Vol. 14, No. 11, 1969, pp. 1923–1931 (in Russian).
85
References [11] [12]
[13]
Kulemin, G. P., and V. B. Razskazovsky, Millimeter Radiowave Scattering by Earth’s Surface at Small Angles, Kiev, Russia: Naukova Dumka, 1987 (in Russian). Blore, W. E., ‘‘The Radar Cross-Section of Ogives, Double-Backed Cones, DoubleRounded Cones and Cone-Sphere,’’ IEEE Trans. on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-12, No. 5, 1964, pp. 582–590. Ruck, G. T., Radar Cross-Section Handbook, Vol. 1, New York: Plenum Press, 1970.
[14]
Crispin, J. W., and A. L. Maffett, ‘‘Radar Cross Section Estimation of Complex Shapes,’’ Proc. IEEE, Vol. 53, No. 8, 1965, pp. 972–981.
[15]
Beckmann, P., and A. Spizzichino, The Scattering of Electromagnetic Waves from Rough Surfaces, London, England: Pergamon Press, 1963; Norwood, MA: Artech House, 1987.
[16]
Crispin, J. W., and K. M. Siegel, Methods of Radar Cross-Section Analysis, New York: Academic Press, 1968.
[17]
Weiss, M. R., ‘‘Numerical Evolution of Geometrical Optics Radar Cross Section,’’ IEEE Trans. on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-17, No. 2, 1969, pp. 229–231.
[18]
Howell, N. A., ‘‘Computerized Ray Optics Method of Calculating Average Value of Radar Cross Section,’’ IEEE Trans. on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-16, No. 5, 1968, pp. 569–574. Crispin, J. W., and A.L. Maffett, ‘‘Radar Cross-Section Estimation of Simple Shapes,’’ Proc. IEEE, Vol. 53, No. 8, 1965, pp. 972–981. Keller, J. B., ‘‘Backscattering from a Finite Cone,’’ IRE Trans. on Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-8, No. 2, 1960, pp. 175–182. Dimova, A. I., M. E. Albats, and A. M. Bonch-Bruevich, Radiotechnical Systems, Moscow, Russia: Soviet Radio, 1975, p. 438 (in Russian).
[19] [20] [21] [22]
Skolnik, M. I., ‘‘An Empirical Formula for the Radar Cross Section of Ships at Grazing Angles,’’ IEEE Trans. on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, Vol. AES-10, No. 2, 1974, p. 292.
[23]
Kulemin, G. P., and V. B. Razskazovsky, The Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets, Inst. Radiophysics Electr., Kharkov, Ukraine, report ‘‘Shore,’’ 1993, p. 185 (in Russian).
[24]
Kulemin, G. P., et al., ‘‘About Selection Small Marine Targets from Sea Backscattering by Coherent Radar,’’ Signal Processing in Radiotechnic Systems, Aviation Institute, Kharkov, Ukraine, 1988, pp. 88–98 (in Russian).
[25]
Williams, P. D. L., H. D. Cramp, and K. Curtis, ‘‘Experimental Study of the Radar CrossSection of Maritime Targets,’’ Adv. Radar Techn., 1985, pp. 69–83.
[26]
Kulemin, G. P., and V. B. Razskazovsky, ‘‘The Radar Characteristics of Targets at X- and Ka-Bands,’’ Proc. SPIE, Vol. 2,469, 1995, pp. 132–141.
[27]
Kulemin, G. P. and V. B. Razskazovsky, ‘‘The Statistical Characteristics of Radar Targets,’’ Preprint IRE NASU, No. 92-2, Kharkov, Ukraine, 1992, p. 32.
[28]
Skolnik, M. I., Radar Handbook, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1970, pp. 13–27.
[29]
Nebabin, V. G., and V. V. Sergeev, Methods and Technique of Radar Recognition, Moscow: Radio and Communication, 1984, p. 152 (in Russian); trans., Norwood, MA: Artech House, 1995.
[30]
Von, T. P., ‘‘Birds and Insects As Radar Targets: A Review,’’ Proc. IEEE, Vol. 75, No. 2, 1985, pp. 35–63.
[31]
Mueller, E. A., ‘‘Differential Reflectivity of Birds and Insects,’’ Proc. 21st Conf. Radar Meteor., 1983, pp. 465–466.
86
Radar Characteristics of Targets [32]
[33]
[34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45]
[46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52]
[53]
Haykin, S. S., C. R. Carter, and M. V. Patriarche, ‘‘Identification of Areas of Bird Clutter and Weather Clutter Using Air Traffic Control Radar,’’ IEE Conf. and Exhib., 1975, pp. 172–173. Edgar, A. K., E. J. Dodsworth, and W. P. Warden, ‘‘The Design of a Modern Surveillance Radar,’’ Int. Conf. Radar: Present and Future, London, England, October 1973, pp. 8–13. Sedov, L. I., Methods of Similarity and Dimensionality in Mechanics, Moscow, Russia: Ed. of Phys.-Math. Lit., 1967 (in Russian). Ohocimsky, D. Y., ‘‘The Derivation of Point Explosion Taking Contrapressure into Account,’’ Proc. of Math. Institute (named after Steklov), Vol. 87, April 1966 (in Russian). Landau, L. D., ‘‘On Shock Waves,’’ USSR Ac. of Sc. Proc., Physics Ser., Vol. 6, January– February 1942, pp. 64–69 (in Russian). Korotkov, P. F., ‘‘On Nonlinear Geometrical Acoustics: Weak Short Waves,’’ Journal of Appl. Math. and Phys., No. 5, 1964, pp. 30–35 (in Russian). Lin, S. C., and J. D. Teare, ‘‘Rate of Ionization Behind Shock Waves in Air: Theoretical Interpretations,’’ Phys. Fluids, Vol. 6, 1963, pp. 355–375. Krinberg, I. A., ‘‘Air Electric Conductivity for Admixtures Presence,’’ Journal of Appl. Math. and Phys., No. 1, 1965, pp. 78–87 (in Russian). Baum, F. A., K. P. Stanyukovich, and B. I. Shehter, Explosion Physics, 1959 (in Russian). Nasilov, D. N., Radiometeorology, Moscow, Russia: Ed. Nauka, 1966 (in Russian). Adushkin, V. V., ‘‘On Shock Wave Forming and Explosion Products Flying Away,’’ J. Appl. Match. and Phys., No. 5, 1963, pp. 107–120 (in Russian). Tatarski, V. I., Wave Propagation in a Turbulent Medium, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1961. Kondratiev, K. L., Ray Thermal Exchange in Atmosphere, Leningrad: Gidrometeoizdat Ed., 1956 (in Russian). Britt, C. O., C. W. Tolbert, and A. W. Straiton, ‘‘Radio Wave Absorption of Several Gases in the 100 to 117 kMc/s Frequency Range,’’ J. Res. NBS., Vol. 6-D, January 1961, pp. 15–18. Bazhenova, T. V., Shock Waves in Real Gases, Moscow, Russia: Nauka Ed., 1968 (in Russian). Boynton, F. P., C. B. Ludwig, and A. Thomson, ‘‘Spectral Emissivity of Carbon Particles Clouds in Rocket Exhausts,’’ AIAA Journal, Vol. 6, No. 5, 1968, pp. 116–124. Van de Hulst, H. C., Light Scattering by Small Particles, New York: John Wiley, 1957. Aleksandrov, Ye. N., et al., ‘‘Solid Explosion Substances Crushing in Shock Wave,’’ Physics of Burning and Explosion, No. 3, 1968, pp. 84–89 (in Russian). Still, V. R. and G. N. Gloss, ‘‘Emissivity of Dispersed Carbon Particles,’’ J. Opt. Soc., Vol. 50, February 1960, pp. 186–191. Von Gierre, H. E., ‘‘Effects of Sonic Boom on People: Review and Outlook,’’ J. Acoustic Soc. Amer., Part 2, Vol. 39, No. 5, 1966, pp. S43–S50. Rizer, Y. P., ‘‘Sonic-Boom Propagation in Inhomogeneous Atmosphere to Side of Density Decreasing,’’ J. Applied Mechanics and Technical Physics, No. 4, 1964, pp. 269–274 (in Russian). Hubbard, H. H., ‘‘Nature of the Sonic-Boom Problem,’’ J. Acoustic Soc. Amer., Part 2, Vol. 39, 1966, pp. S1–S9.
References [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65]
[66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76]
87 Witham, G. B., ‘‘On the Propagation of Weak Shock Waves,’’ J. Fluid. Mech., Vol. 1, No. 9, 1952, pp. 290–318. Kane, E. J., ‘‘Some Effects on the Nonuniform Atmosphere on the Propagation of Sonic Booms,’’ J. Acoust. Soc. Amer., Part 2, Vol. 39, No. 5, 1966, pp. S26–S30. Plotkin, K. J., and A. R. George, ‘‘Propagation of Weak Shock Waves Through Turbulence,’’ J. Fluid Mech., Part 3, Vol. 54, 1972, pp. 449–467. Lamley, J., and H. Panofsky, The Structure of Atmospheric Turbulence, New York: Interscience Publishers, 1964. Maglieri, D. J., ‘‘Some Effects of Airplane Operations and the Atmosphere on the SonicBoom Signatures,’’ 2nd Conf. on Sonic Boom Res., NASA, 1968, pp. 19–23. Landau, L. D., and Ye. M. Livshits, Mechanics of Continious Media, Moscow, Russia: Gostehizdat, 1954 (in Russian). Blohintsev, D. N., Acoustics of Inhomogeneous Moving Medium, Moscow, Russia: Fizmatgiz Ed., 1981 (in Russian). Melnikov, B. P., ‘‘Noise Caused by Tu-124 Airplane Take-Off and Landing,’’ Acoustic J., Vol. 1, No. 2, 1965, pp. 138–146 (in Russian). Lane, J. A., ‘‘Radar Echoes from Tropospheric Layers by Incoherent Backscatter,’’ Electronic Letters, Vol. 3, No. 4, 1967, pp. 173–174. Shlihting, G., The Origin of Turbulence, Moscow, Russia: Foreign Literature Edit., 1962 (in Russian). Sato, H., ‘‘The Stability and Transition of a Two-Dimensional Jet,’’ J. Fluid Mech., Part 3, Vol. 7, 1960, pp. 321–329. Isatajev, S. I., and S. B. Tarasov, ‘‘On Acoustic Field Influence on Wake Directed Along Stream Axis,’’ USSR Acad. Sci. Proc., Fluid and Gas Mechanics, No. 2, 1971, pp. 164–167 (in Russian). Crow, S. C., and F. H. Champagne, ‘‘Orderly Structure in Jet Turbulence,’’ J. Fluid Mech., Part 3, Vol. 48, 1971, pp. 547–591. Shade, H., ‘‘Contribution to the Nonlinear Stability Theory of Inviscid Shear Layers,’’ Phys. Fluids, Vol. 7, No. 5, 1964, pp. 623–628. Delano, R. H., ‘‘Theory of Target Glint or Angular Scintillation in Radar Tracking,’’ Proc. IRE, Vol. 41, No. 3, 1953, pp. 61–67. Swerling, P., ‘‘Probability of Detection for Fluctuating Targets,’’ IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, IT-6, No. 4, 1960, pp. 269–308. Mayer, H. A., and D. P. Meyer, ‘‘Chi-Square Target Models of Low Degrees of Freedom,’’ IEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electr. Syst., Vol. AES-11, No. 5, 1975, pp. 694–707. Mayer, H. A. and D. P. Meyer, Radar Target Detection, New York: Academic Press, 1973. Moll, P. L., ‘‘On the Radar Echo from Aircraft,’’ IEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electr. Syst., Vol. AES-3, No. 3, 1967, pp. 574–577. Muchmore, R. B., ‘‘Aircraft Scintillation Spectra,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas and Propagation, AP-8, No. 2, 1960, pp. 201–212. Wilson, I. D., ‘‘Probability of Detecting Aircraft Targets,’’ IEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electr. Syst., AES-8, No. 6, 1972, pp. 757–762. Barton, D. K., Radar System Analysis, Dedham, MA: Artech House, 1979. Krendell, C., (Translat. Ed.), Random Oscillations, Moscow, Russia: Mir, 1967, p. 361 (in Russian).
88
Radar Characteristics of Targets [77] [78] [79] [80] [81] [82] [83]
[84] [85] [86] [87]
Nogid, L. M., Ship Stability and Its Behaviour at Rough Sea, Leningrad, Russia: Sudostroenie, 1967, p. 240 (in Russian). Barton, D. K. and H. R. Ward, Handbook of Radar Measurement, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1969; Dedham, MA: Artech House, 1984. Eaves, J. L., and E. K. Reedy, Principles of Modern Radar, New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1987, p. 712. Levin, B. R., Theoretical Foundations of the Statistic Radioelectronics, Moscow, Russia: Soviet Radio, 1969 (in Russian). Berkowitz, R. S., (ed.), Modern Radar, New York: John Wiley, 1968. Gradshtein, I. S., and I. M. Ridzik, Tables of Integrals, Sums, and Products, Moscow: Fizmatgiz, 1963 (in Russian); trans. New York: Academic Press, 1965. Kulemin, G. P. and V. B. Razskazovsky, ‘‘Complex Effects of Clutter, Weather and Battlefield Conditions on the Target Detection in Millimeter-Wave Radars,’’ Proc. SPIE, Vol. 2,222, 1994, pp. 862–871. Kelly, R. E., ‘‘On the Derivation of Bistatic RCS from Monostatic Measurements,’’ Proc. IEEE, Vol. 53, No. 8, 1965, pp. 983–988. Chernyak, V. S., Fundamentals of Multisite Radar Systems, Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Gordon and Breach, 1998. Skolnik, M. I., Radar Handbook, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1970. Cox, C., and W. Munk, ‘‘Statistics of the Sea Surface Derived from Sun Glitter,’’ J. Mar. Res., Vol. 13, 1954, pp. 198–227.
CHAPTER 2
Land Backscattering 2.1 Classification and Physical Characteristics of Land Classification of land for backscattering prediction must take into account the presence or absence of vegetation; for a surface without vegetation, the roughness is also an essential additional parameter, depending on the wavelength and grazing angle. According the Rayleigh criterion, the surface can be considered rough if the rms height deviation h meets the criterion h > ( /8) sin [1], where is the wavelength and is the grazing angle. Among surfaces without vegetation, quasismooth surfaces (e.g., a road with concrete or asphalt paving, rocks, salt-marshes, or dry salt lakes) are distinguished, to which a simple mathematical model can be applied. For estimating scattering properties of such surfaces, the essential parameters are the statistical characteristics of the roughness and the complex dielectric constant. The real and imaginary components ⑀ 1 and ⑀ 2 of the dielectric constant for concrete and asphalt in the MMW band are shown in Table 2.1. The statistical characteristics (rms height, correlation functions, spatial correlation radii, and angle slope deviation) of various surfaces are shown in Table 2.2. Surfaces without vegetation are in a separate group among rough surfaces. Their scattering properties are also determined by the complex dielectric constant and height deviation. The complex dielectric constant data for various surface types in the MMW band are shown in Table 2.3. The numerous experimental data sets on the dielectric constant of agricultural fields obtained in [4, 5] support the following conclusions. The frequency behavior of the dielectric constant for wet soils has the following tendencies: ⑀ ′ decreases and ⑀ ″ increases with increasing frequency from 4 GHz to Table 2.1 Dielectric Constants of Concrete and Asphalt Wavelength (mm) 30.0 8.6 2.2 Source: [2, 3].
Concrete ⑀′ ⑀″ 6.5 1.5 5.5 0.5 5.55 0.36
Asphalt ⑀′ ⑀″ 4.3 0.1 2.5 0.6 2.25 0.18
89
90
Land Backscattering Table 2.2 The Statistical Characteristics of Various Surfaces Cover Type Concrete Asphalt Sand Snow Soil harrowed Source: [2–4].
h , cm
(r )
0 , cm
1.6 ⭈ 10−2 0.4 ⭈ 10−1 0.2–0.6 0.1–0.3 2.0
√␥ 2
exp (−7r ) (1 + 2r 2 )−3/2 — — —
0.14 0.22 0.6–2.5 0.2–200 10.0–80.0
0.14 0.3 0.1–0.4 <0.2 0.5
Table 2.3 Complex Dielectric Constant for Some Covers at Wavelengths of 8 and 2 mm Cover Soil Soil (clay) Sand Sand Snow Ice Brick (red) Brick Pine board Source: [3].
Wavelength of 8 mm ⑀′ ⑀″ 3.0 0.4 7.0 3.5 3.0 0.56 7.0 4.4 2.0 0.4 ⭈ 10−2 3.1 0.7 ⭈ 10−2 — — — — — —
Wavelength of 2 mm ⑀′ ⑀″ — — 2.5 9.4 ⭈ 10−2 2.5 6.2 ⭈ 10−2 — — 1.4 10−2 — — 3.2 1.1 ⭈ 10−1 3.3 1.4 ⭈ 10−1 2.0 8 ⭈ 10−2
18 GHz. These dependences for a loam field, obtained for soil moisture from 0.02 g/m3 to 0.37 g/m3, are shown in Figure 2.1. The dependence of the dielectric constant on the volumetric moisture, measured at 10 GHz and 18 GHz, show that ⑀ ′ and ⑀ ″ depend very weakly on the soil type. As an illustration, Figure 2.2 shows the soil moisture dependence for five fields with different contents of sand, clay, and silt. It is seen that the soil content has insignificant influence. The roughness parameters of agricultural fields are determined by the means of tillage and change over wide limits. As an illustration, the summary of roughness parameters is presented in Table 2.4 for four fields with different tillage. The dielectric properties of snow cover play a significant role in backscattering model development and explanation of results. Much experimental data have been gathered for snow dielectric characteristics covering the frequency band of 0.8–37 GHz [6–9]. Models have been developed in which snow is represented as a two-component or three-component mixture [10, 11]. The model replaces the inhomogeneous medium by a homogeneous one with an effective dielectric constant ⑀ . It is possible to determine the dielectric constant of the mixture with rather simple models if the inclusions in the heterogeneous medium are small in comparison with the wavelength (permitting consideration only of the absorption while neglecting the scattering losses) and their shape is known.
2.1 Classification and Physical Characteristics of Land
91
Figure 2.1 Soil dielectric constant dependence on frequency. (From: [4]. 1985 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
Figure 2.2 Soil dielectric constant dependence on soil moisture for five fields at frequencies of 10.0 GHz and 18.0 GHz. (From: [4]. 1985 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
92
Land Backscattering Table 2.4 Summary of Roughness Parameters Type rms Height (cm) Field 1 0.40 Field 2 0.32 Field 3 1.12 Field 4 3.02 Source: [5].
Correlation Length (cm) 8.4 9.9 8.4 8.8
rms Slope 0.048 0.032 0.133 0.485
For dry snow (i.e., a mixture of air and ice) the real part of the dielectric constant in the microwave band does not depend on temperature or frequency but is a function of snow density. This dependence can be represented as [11]
⑀ ds ′ =
再
1 + 1.9 s
for s ≤ 0.5 g/cm3
0.51 + 2.88 s
for s > 0.5 g/cm3
(2.1)
where s is the snow density, which under natural conditions rarely exceeds 0.5 g/cm3. The experimental results obtained in the frequency band 0.8–37 GHz are described by (2.1) very well, as is shown in Figure 2.3. The imaginary part of the snow dielectric constant depends on frequency and temperature in a rather complex way. The dependence of the loss tangent on frequency is shown in Figure 2.4 [12] for snow density of 0.45 g/cm3 [9]. The dielectric constant of wet snow increases sharply because of the influence of water in its liquid phase. The content of liquid water in snow is usually described by a volumetric moisture m v that is the ratio of water volume to total snow volume. There are several models of wet snow dielectric properties. For the millimeter band, the modified Debye model gives the highest accuracy for the dielectric constant [13]. Numerous experiments for wet snow [12, 14] support the following conclusions. The real part ⑀ ′ of the dielectric constant increases with an increase in the volumetric moisture from 1.4 for dry snow to 3.3 for m v = 12% at a frequency of 2 GHz. It decreases with an increase in frequency to 1.35 for the millimeter band. With increasing frequency the real part of dielectric constant decreases. This is illustrated by Figure 2.5(a) obtained at a frequency of 10.0 GHz for moisture change from zero to 12%. The imaginary part ⑀ ″ for wet snow increases with increasing volumetric moisture—Figure 2.5(b). The maximal values are found at approximately the relaxation frequency, beyond which it decreases with increasing frequency. Land territories with vegetation form the third group. The complex dielectric constants of vegetation media are determined by their biometrical indices (e.g., vegetation volumetric density and square cover degree) and by the relative moisture content in the cellular tissue. The experimental data on the dielectric constant for corn leaves in the band 1.5–8.0 GHz, for volumetric moisture from zero to 0.8 g/cm3, are shown in Figure
2.1 Classification and Physical Characteristics of Land
93
Figure 2.3 Dry snow dielectric constant versus snow density. (From: [12]. 1986 Artech House, Inc. Reprinted with permission.)
2.6 [12]. The dielectric constant for wheat grains as a function of the weighted moisture is shown in Figure 2.7. The vegetation biometrical indices change continuously as a function of vegetation growth. The vegetation moisture can change as a function of season and weather conditions. The biometrical indices of some crops and grass for different periods of growth are shown in Table 2.5 [15]. In [3], the notion of the effective complex dielectric constant of a medium is introduced for investigations of propagation peculiarities in vegetation
⑀ eff = ⑀ eff (1 − i tan ␦ eff )
(2.2)
94
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.4 Dry snow loss tangent versus frequency. (From: [9]. 1986 IEEE. Reprinted with permission.)
where ⑀ eff and tan ␦ eff are the dielectric constant and loss tangent, respectively. The use of this parameter permits derivation of the reflection coefficients from the parameters of homogeneous dielectric media [16]. In [17], a simple expression for effective complex dielectric constant is obtained for homogeneous vegetation covers
⑀ eff = 1 + Bd ⑀ w M
(2.3)
where d is the weight of scattering elements in a unit volume, B is an empirical parameter equal to 0.3 for coniferous forest and to 0.6 for deciduous forest, ⑀ w is the dielectric constant of water at the radar frequency, and M is the relative weighted moisture content in the vegetation. It has been established that huge tracts of forest are homogeneous scatterers, just as are grass, cereals, and some types of bushes—all having an inhomogeneity of different degree. The averaged parameter values for coniferous and deciduous forests are shown in Table 2.6 [18]. Data on dielectric properties of vegetation are insufficient for general model development of land surfaces with vegetation.
2.2 State of the Theory
95
Figure 2.5 Frequency dependence (a) real and (b) imaginary parts of dielectric constant of wet snow for different water contents. (From: [12]. 1986 Artech House, Inc. Reprinted with permission.)
2.2 State of the Theory 2.2.1 RCS Models
Radars for detection of on-land and low-altitude targets are subject to land backscattering, characteristics of which depend on the land surface type, the vegetation state, the season, the radar operating frequency, and the wind velocity.
96
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.6 Dielectric constant versus volumetric water content for corn leaves. (From: [12]. 1986 Artech House, Inc. Reprinted with permission.)
There are significant difficulties in the development of theoretical models for land backscattering because of the variety of land types. The major theoretical works can be divided into two groups. In the first, the land surface is considered to consist of elementary scatterers (e.g., spheres and cylinders), for which the scattering properties are known and for which parameters are chosen to secure satisfactory agreement with experimental results. These models usually predict quite well the angular dependence of the normalized RCS, which is a measure of the scattered signal intensity, and the scattered signal statistical characteristics. The second group of works [1–3, 19–21] requires the choice of individual, exactly formulated backscattering parameters; however, these choices give large errors in derivations of scattered signals because of the idealization of the surface. The simplified models of first group are shown in Table 2.7 [22–24]. Here the grazing angle, related to the incidence angle by = /2 − , is used as a parameter. In the model proposed in [2] for grassy terrain, it is assumed that the scattering comes from long thin cylinders with considerable loss, permitting multiple scattering
97
2.2 State of the Theory
Figure 2.7 Dielectric constant versus water content for grain: (a) real and (b) imaginary parts. (From: [12]. 1986 Artech House, Inc. Reprinted with permission.)
Table 2.5 Biometrical Indices of Crops
Type Grass Grass Alfalfa Sugar beet Wheat Source: [15].
Weight (g/cm 2 ) 0.12 0.16 0.077 — 0.25
Height (cm) 10 17 18 55 110
Cover Degree (%) 100 95 90 95 25
Moisture (%) 86 85 87 — 36
Steam Amount (cm −2 ) 1.5 0.6 0.64 0.02 0.043
Steam Section (cm 2 ) 0.008 0.016 — — 0.096
98
Land Backscattering Table 2.6 Experimental Values of Model Parameters for Forests Forest Type Coniferous forest, thick Coniferous forest, thin Deciduous forest, thick Deciduous forest, thin Source: [18].
Parameters d M 10−4 0.4 5 ⭈ 10−3 0.6 10−4 0.6 5 ⭈ 10−3 0.8
Table 2.7 Simplified Models of Land Backscattering Model Diffuse scattering Diffuse scattering (Lambert law) Ament’s model Facet model Model of half-cylinders Model of half-spheres Vegetation model as cylinders
Angular Dependence of Normalized RCS sin2 sin ⌿ exp [−cot2 ( /2s 2 )] 4, 2 4, 2 sin2
RCS Dependence on Wavelength — — −2 −2, −6 −2, 0, −3, −1 −2, 0, −4, −1 —
Reference — — — [22] [23] [24] [2]
effects to be neglected. For small incidence angles close to normal incidence (grazing angle → 90° ), models have been developed to satisfactorily explain the experimental data. For example, in [25] a cover cloud model is proposed in which a cloud of identical particles with volumetric homogeneous distribution represents the vegetation. For simplicity in the cover cloud model, the approach of single scattering is used and the contributions of all particles are summed, taking into consideration the double attenuation in the cover layer between its surface and the particle. This model satisfactorily describes the experimental results in the band 8.6–17.0 GHz for incidence angles less than 70°. In [26], a dielectric layer model is proposed, in which the vegetation is represented by a homogeneous dielectric medium. This model is satisfactory at wavelengths from 1.65–3.75 cm for incidence angles close to nadir. A great number of discs with different spatial distribution is used as a model of forest foliage in [27]. Attempts have been made to formulate models of the second group via exact solutions to the electrodynamic backscattering problem, using measured surface parameters as initial data for derivation of the scattered signal. These models assume that all land surfaces can be divided into two classes: those with and those without vegetation. The surface without vegetation has a significant additional dependence on the degree of roughness. According to the Rayleigh criterion, the surface is rough if the rms deviation from the average surface is h > ( /8) sin . Otherwise it can be described as quasi-smooth.
99
2.2 State of the Theory
Theoretical models are based on methods of solving the problem of scattering by a statistically rough surface. Rather accurate models of backscattering based on Kirchhoff’s or small perturbation methods are strictly applicable only for quasismooth surfaces without vegetation (e.g., concrete or asphalt). For these surface models, it is sufficient for estimation of RCS to know the surface electrophysical characteristics such as the dielectric constant and surface roughness. For Kirchhoff’s method, it is assumed that for sufficiently gently sloping surfaces with the radii of curvature considerably greater than the wavelength, limiting conditions can be represented as those of the plane facets of which this surface consists. The problem is solved by introduction of local Fresnel coefficients followed by integration along the surface currents. The vector form of Green’s theorem is used to obtain the full scattering matrix [28]. For a strongly rough surface, the normalized RCS can be represented as in [19]
冉
2
0 =
Rf0
⭈ cos2  0 ⭈ exp −
sin4
cot2 tan2  0
冊
(2.4)
where tan  0 = 2 h l and l is the spatial correlation radius of surface roughness. Consequently, the value of  0 can be interpreted as the mean slope of the rough surface. The value of R f 0 is the Fresnel reflection coefficient of the plane surface, a function of its electrophysical characteristics. The use of reflection coefficients for the plane surface does not permit us to take fully into account the polarization effects on the scattered signal. The determination of the scattered electromagnetic field in the small perturbation method is based on the following assumptions, applicable to quasi-smooth surfaces. Let the surface height deviation be set as z = f (x , y )
(2.5)
Let us choose the plane z = 0 such that (2.5) describes the deviation from mean height z = 0. Then the small perturbation method is applied for small gently sloping roughness
| k h sin | << 1
|
|
df (x , y ) << 1; dx
|
(2.6a)
|
df (x , y ) << 1 dy
(2.6b)
The normalized RCS of a rough surface with complex dielectric constant ⑀˙ can be expressed as in [28]
100
Land Backscattering 0 HH = 4 k 4 sin4 | ␣ HH | S ( 0 ) 2
(2.7)
0 VV = 4 k 4 sin4 | ␣ VV | S ( 0 ) 2
where k = 2 / is the wavenumber; and S( 0 ) is the spectral density of surface roughness with a wavenumber
0 =
冉 冊 4
cos
(2.8)
The physical sense of (2.8) is that the backscattering takes place for the spectral component with a period one-half the radar wavelength. The Fresnel coefficients in (2.7) are determined by the surface dielectric properties and have the form
␣ HH =
␣ VV =
⑀˙ − 1
冠sin + √⑀˙ − cos2 冡2 (⑀˙ − 1) [⑀˙ (1 + cos2 ) − cos2 ]
冠⑀˙ sin + √⑀˙ − cos2 冡2
␣ HV = ␣ VH = 0
(2.9a)
(2.9b) (2.9c)
The absence of scattered signal depolarization is inherent in estimation of the normalized RCS in the small perturbation method characterized by (2.9c). This contradicts experimental results even for quasi-smooth surfaces. The coefficients of ␣ HH , ␣ VV depend very weakly on wavelength for small grazing angles, their change being not greater than 1–3 dB in the band 10–140 GHz. From (2.7) we see a strong dependence of normalized RCS on wavelength (inversely proportional to the fourth power of wavelength) and on grazing angle ( 0 ∼ sin4 ). The normalized RCS for vertical polarization is greater than that for horizontal by 8–10 dB. A comparison of derived and experimental results for quasi-smooth concrete or asphalt surfaces shows that the model (2.7) does not apply for these surfaces in the shortwave part of millimeter band because the surface becomes strongly rough. A comparative analysis of the two latter models leads to the conclusion that normalized RCS estimations using Kirchhoff’s method can be used for rather small incidence angles near nadir, while estimations using the small perturbation method can be used for incidence angles > 30–40°, but neither applies at extremely small grazing angles when the influence of shadowing is significant.
101
2.2 State of the Theory
This is why these models are not applicable for such surfaces as rough ones without vegetation or those with vegetation. The main way to derive general models in these cases is the development of empirical models based on experimental results.
2.2.2 Power Spectrum Model
The backscattering power spectra of land surfaces with vegetation are determined by the wind-induced motion of scatterers as the radar scans its volume and/or by radar platform motion. For identical radar transmitting and receiving antennas or for a single combined antenna, the signal at the receiver input from the j th scatterer in the far zone can be represented as u j (t ) ⬀
√P t j 2
rj
∞
G ( ) =
冕
⭈ G ( j ) ⭈ exp [i ( 0 t − kr j − j )]
(2.10)
f (x ) ⭈ exp (ikx sin ) dx
−∞
where P t is the transmitter power, j is the RCS of the j th scatterer, j is the phase of the signal from the j th scatterer, 0 is the radar frequency, k = 2 / is the wavenumber, r j is the range to j th scatterer, G ( ) is the antenna voltage pattern, and f (x ) is the electromagnetic field distribution at antenna aperture. The variables in (2.10) can be divided into two groups. The first group consists of the values r j and j , which change with radar platform motion and antenna scanning, and which can be functionally expressed through the current antenna position and time. The variables of the second group, j and j , characterizing the scatterer state at the present moment of time, are random functions of time in most cases and depend on the scatterer number. If the extent of each scatterer is small in comparison to its range, (2.10) can be written as the product of two factors, each containing the variables of one of these groups. Consequently, the scattered signal spectrum is the convolution of two spectra: The first describes the signal fluctuations resulting from scatterer motions and the second results from antenna scan and radar platform motion. The conclusions for a single scatterer can be generalized for the sum of scatterers. Assuming that all scatterers are in the far zone, the signal at the receiver input is U (t ) ⬀
∞
∑
j =1
1 2
rj
G ( j , t ) √ j (t ) ⭈ exp {i [ 0 t − j (t )]}
(2.11)
102
Land Backscattering
Then the autocorrelation function can be found as 〈 U (t ) U* (t ) 〉 ⬀
∑∑〈 j′
j
1 2 2 rj rj′
√ j (t ) j ′ (t ′ ) ⭈ G ( j , t ) G ( j ′ , t ′ )
× exp {i [ 0 (t − t ′ ) − j (t ) + j*′ (t ′ )]}
(2.12)
〉
Here the sign * denotes the complex conjugate value. Assuming that the scatterers are statistically independent and the phases of scattering are distributed uniformly in [0, 2 ], (2.12) can be written in form 〈 U (t ) U* (t ′ ) 〉 ⬀
∞
∑
j =1
1 4
rj
√ j (t ) j (t ′ )
(2.13)
⭈ G ( j , t ) G ( j , t ′ ) exp {i [ 0 (t − t ′ ) − j (t ) + j (t ′ )]} Taking into consideration the independence of scatterer fluctuations and antenna scanning, this expression can be transformed to 〈 U (t ) U* (t ′ ) 〉 ⬀
∑ 〈 A j (t ) A j (t ′ ) exp {−[ j (t ) − j (t ′ )]} exp [i 0 (t − t ″ )]〉 ∞
(2.14)
j =1
× 〈 G ( j , t ) G ( j , t ′ ) 〉 where A j (t ) ⬀
2 √ j (t ) ⁄ r j is the amplitude of the j th scatterer signal.
Let us note that R sj ( ) = 〈 A j (t ) A j (t ′ ) exp {i [ 0 (t − t ′ ) − j (t ) + j (t ′ )]} 〉
(2.15)
R Gj ( ) = 〈 G ( j , t ) G ( j , t ′ ) 〉
(2.16)
The expression (2.15) represents the autocorrelation function of the signal from the j th scatterer and (2.16) characterizes the antenna scanning law. Substituting (2.14) and (2.15) into (2.14), we obtain 〈 U (t ) U * (t ′ ) 〉 ⬀
∑ R sj ( ) R Gj ( )
(2.17)
j
The power spectrum is the Fourier transformation of the autocorrelation function, and hence for our case it is the convolution of the scatterer fluctuation spectrum and antenna-scanning spectrum. This leads to the conclusion that for
103
2.2 State of the Theory
determination of the spectrum of land backscattering caused by antenna scanning and radar platform motion, it is sufficient to find separately the spectra of scatterer fluctuation and of antenna motion (or the electromagnetic field modulation across its aperture). Let us consider the spectrum model formed only by the motions of scatterers under the influence of wind or other reasons. The scattering surface can be represented as a linear system with a transient response K (t ) = K 0 + ⌬K (t )
(2.18)
where K 0 characterizes the reflectors that are stable in time (e.g., buildings, bare soil, or rocks) and the second term characterizes the fluctuating scatterers (e.g., grass, branches, or leaves of trees). Then the autocorrelation function of this system can be represented as 2
g ( ) = K 0 + ( )
(2.19)
If the continuous signal is u (t ) = A cos 0 t at the system input, the autocorrelation function at the system output (the scattered signal) will have the form A2 2 R out ( ) = R in ( ) ⭈ g ( ) = [K 0 + ( )] cos 0 2
(2.20)
The power spectrum is the Fourier-transform of autocorrelation function and can be written as ∞
G 1 ( ) =
冕
R out ( ) ⭈ e −j d = a 2␦ ( − 0 ) + G ( )
(2.21)
−∞
where ␦ ( − 0 ) is the Dirac function, and a 2 is the ratio of stable to fluctuating components of scattered power (RCS). It is seen that the total power spectrum of the scattered signal consists of one component that is produced by scattering from stable reflectors and another produced by moving scatterers. The first term can considerably exceed the second for terrains without vegetation. Let us consider the power spectra of the surface model, for which the scatterers of branch, leaf, and grass types move under the influence of wind. The basis of this model is the derivation technique developed by G. S. Gorelik [29, 30] for radiowave scattering problems with moving inhomogeneities. Assume that the
104
Land Backscattering
scatterer velocity autocorrelation function reproduces with some scale correction that of the wind velocity. Assuming for simplicity that the signal amplitude from the j th scatterer is unity, one can obtain from (2.9) the expression for signal phase of j th scatterer
j = 2kr j (t ) + 0
(2.22)
where r j (t ) is the range from the radar to the j th scatterer, and 0 is the initial phase. From Figure 2.8 we have r j = r + x j sin
(2.23)
where x j is the scatterer displacement relative to its initial position. Without violating generality, one can choose the initial phase 0 such that
j = 2kx j (t ) sin
(2.24)
Assume that the velocities of the scatterers are a stationary random process, mutually independent, and have identical statistical properties and zero mean values. For a displacement velocity of the j th scatterer u j (t ), the displacement during time is t +
(⌬x j ) = x j (t + ) − x j (t ) =
冕 t
Figure 2.8 Geometry of derivation.
u j (s ) ds
(2.25)
105
2.2 State of the Theory
This value is stationary by the previous assumptions, and the phase difference has the analogous properties. The autocorrelation function is R ( ) = 〈 u (t ) ⭈ u (t + ) 〉 =
∑ ∑ 〈 cos [ 0 t − j (t )] cos [ 0 t ′ − j ′ (t ′ )] 〉 j
j′
(2.26)
where t ′ = t + . Because of statistical independence of j (t ) and j ′ (t ′ ) for j ≠ j ′ (2.26) can be written as R ( ) =
∑ 〈 cos [ 0 t − j (t )] 〉 + ∑ ∑ 〈 cos [ 0 t − j (t )] cos [ 0 t − j ′ (t ′ )] 〉 j
j
j′
(2.27)
where terms having j = j ′ in the second term are omitted. Taking into consideration the independence of the statistical properties of separate scatterers, (2.27) can be written in the form R ( ) = n 〈 cos [ 0 t − (t )] cos [ 0 t ′ − (t ′ )] 〉
(2.28)
+ (n 2 − n ) 〈 cos [ 0 t − (t )] cos [ 0 t ′ − (t ′ )] 〉 Under the assumption that the mean scatterer velocities are zero, 〈 sin ⌬ 〉 = 〈 sin 〉 = 〈 sin ′ 〉 = sin ( + ′ ) = 0
(2.29)
and for a uniform phase distribution in [0, 2 ] one can approximately assume [31] 〈 cos 〉 = 〈 cos ′ 〉 = 〈 cos ( + ′ ) 〉 = 0
(2.30)
Then (2.28) has the form R ( ) =
n cos 0 ⭈ 〈 cos ⌬ 〉 2
(2.31)
The envelope of the autocorrelation function
( ) = 〈 cos ⌬ 〉
(2.32)
106
Land Backscattering
is determined by the distribution of scatterer displacement probabilities because from (2.24) and (2.25) we have ⌬ = 2k ⌬x (t ) sin
(2.33)
Letting m = 2k sin , we obtain ∞
( ) = 〈 cos m ⌬x (t ) 〉 =
冕
cos m ⌬x ⭈ p (⌬x ) ⭈ d (⌬x )
(2.34)
−∞
If the scatterer displacements are described by a Gaussian distribution p (⌬x ) =
1
√2 (⌬x )
冋
exp − 2
(⌬x )2 2(⌬x )2
册
(2.35)
we obtain [32]
冋
( ) = exp −
m 2(⌬x )2 2
册
(2.36)
Consequently, the envelope of the autocorrelation function is determined by the mean square value of scatterer displacement, which is easily expressed through the autocorrelation function of scatterer velocities [30] R u ( ) = 〈 u (t ) ⭈ u (t ′ ) 〉 = (⌬u )2 ⭈ ( )
(2.37a)
where (⌬u )2 is the scatterer velocity variance. Actually [30],
2
冕
(⌬x ) = 2 ( − ) R u ( ) d 0
and
冤
n R ( ) = cos ( 0 ) ⭈ exp −m 2 (⌬u )2 2
冕 0
( − ) u ( ) d
冥
(2.37b)
107
2.2 State of the Theory
The spectral density is found as Fourier-transform of the autocorrelation function
2 G ( ) =
∞
冕
R ( ) cos ( ) d
(2.38)
0
n =
∞
冕
冤
2
cos ( − 0 ) ⭈ exp −m (⌬u )
0
2
冕
冥
( − ) u ( )
0
d
Taking into account that the autocorrelation function of the horizontal component of wind velocity at small heights above the surface is determined as [33, 34]
u ( ) = e −␣ | | cos 
(2.39)
(2.38) can be written in the form
n G ( ) =
∞
冕
冤
2
cos ( − 0 ) ⭈ exp −m (⌬u )
0
2
冕
( − ) e ␣ | | cos 
0
冥
d (2.40)
The solution of this integral has the form [35]
冉
冊∑
冢冋冉
m 2 (⌬u )2
m 2 (⌬u )2 n G ( ) = exp k2
⭈
where k = (␣ 2 +  2 )/2␣ .
∞
m =0
k2
m 2 (⌬u )2 k
2
(−1)m ⭈ m!
k2
+ km
冊
2
+ km
冉
m 2 (⌬u )2
册
+ ( − 0 ) 2
冣
冊
m
(2.41)
108
Land Backscattering 2
Letting m 2 (⌬u )2 = f , we obtain
冉 冊∑ 2 f 2
∞
n G ( ) = exp k
m =0
(−1m ) ⭈ m!
冉冊
2 f m 2
k
2
f ⭈
冉
k2 k2
冊
2
2
f
+ km
+ km
+ ( − 0 ) 2 (2.42)
The analysis of this expression shows that the power spectrum of land scattering 2 2 has different forms as a function of f /k 2. For f /k 2 >> 1, the expression for spectral density has the form [35] G ( ) ≅
冋
n ( − 0 )2 2 (2 f )1/2 exp − 2 2 f
册
(2.43)
Thus, for slow scatterer oscillations (small Doppler frequencies less than the −3 dB spectrum bandwidth), the power spectrum is practically Gaussian. The spectrum width is ⌬F =
f √2
⭈
√ (⌬u )2 =
2√2
√ (⌬u )2
(2.44)
From the analysis of (2.44), it can be seen that the land backscattering spectrum width is inversely proportional to wavelength and proportional to the rms wind velocity fluctuations. 2 In the region of higher frequencies when f /k 2 << 1, the power spectrum has the form [35] G ( ) =
n
冋
2
f /2k 2
( f /2k )2 + ( − 0 )
2
−
f /2k 4k 2 + ( − 0 )2
册
+...
(2.45)
where only the first terms are significant. Thus, for the frequency region greater than the spectrum width, the change of spectral density is described better by a power function with an exponent approaching two.
2.3 Normalized RCS 2.3.1 Normalized RCS of a Quasi-Smooth Surface
The normalized RCS is one of the most important and universal parameters characterizing the land backscattering, and it depends on such variables as the surface
2.3 Normalized RCS
109
type, wavelength (or frequency), grazing angle, transmitting and receiving polarizations, the season of year, and weather conditions. Although the normalized RCS concept is strictly applied only to homogeneous rough surfaces or flat land areas, it is also used in practice for a description of backscattering from nonuniform terrains (e.g., for towns or land areas with sparse trees). In these cases, it is necessary to use the normalized RCS concept with caution. The influence of the factors mentioned earlier has been investigated in the wide band from meter to short millimeter wavelengths and was generalized in [20]. The main conclusions for quasi-smooth surfaces are the following. Smooth surfaces are characterized by weak scattering (except at angles near nadir), and the angular dependence of normalized RCS for these surfaces is 0 ∼ sin3 , where is the grazing angle. As was noted in Section 2.2.1, theoretical models have been developed most completely for quasi-smooth surfaces, and the derivations of normalized RCS within the framework of these models are satisfactorily adjusted to experimental results. The rms error does not exceed 2–3 dB, and maximal error is 10 dB [12]. The dependence of 0 on wavelength can be represented as 0 ∼ −4. For grazing angles less than 30°, the RCS is from 6 dB to 10 dB higher for vertical polarization than for horizontal. As an example, the angular dependences of normalized RCS for concrete at wavelengths of 3.2 cm and 8.6 mm for vertical and horizontal polarizations of transmitting and receiving are shown in Figure 2.9, and the dependence of 0 on wavelength is shown in Figure 2.10 for concrete, asphalt, and gravel. The dependence of experimental normalized RCS on frequency for different types of road surfaces for horizontal polarization is presented in Table 2.8, confirming the conclusions on strong frequency dependence of the normalized RCS. The presence of a water film on the surface decreases the normalized RCS by 10 dB for small grazing angles, as shown in Figure 2.11; this is explained by the smoothing of surface roughness by the water. This same smoothing increases the normalized RCS for nadir radiation. For nadir radiation, the rms roughness height strongly influences the normalized RCS, leading to its decrease with increasing h . The values of normalized RCS for nadir operation in the frequency band 40–135 GHz are shown in Table 2.9. 2.3.2 Normalized RCS for Rough Surfaces Without Vegetation
Rough surfaces without vegetation have greater values of normalized RCS (by 15–25) dB and other angular and frequency characteristics in comparison with quasi-smooth surfaces In Figure 2.12, the angular dependences of the normalized RCS are shown for rough surfaces without vegetation at wavelengths of 1–3 cm. The normalized RCS of a rough surface without vegetation is a function of the surface roughness h and volumetric soil moisture m v [i.e., 0 = f ( h , m v )].
110
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.9 The normalized RCS of concrete versus grazing angle for (a) vertical and (b) horizontal polarizations. (After: [36].)
The growth of surface roughness changes the angular dependence of normalized RCS to 0 ∼ sin for highly rough terrains and the dependence of 0 on wavelength to 0 ∼ −1. As an illustration, the angular dependences of the normalized RCS for ploughed fields with different types of cultivation (degrees of roughness) are shown in Figure 2.13. It is seen that the angular dependence of the normalized RCS for k h ≥ 1.2 can be approximated as 0 ∼ sin . However, right up to these values of k h , the experimental angular dependences are satisfactorily adjusted to derivations according Kirhhoff’s method. For greater values of k h the surface is practically diffuse, as shown in Figure 2.13. All of these surfaces scatter diffusely
111
2.3 Normalized RCS
Figure 2.10
Dependence of normalized RCS for quasi-smooth surfaces on radar wavelength. (After: [36].)
Table 2.8 Normalized RCS (dB) Frequency Dependence of Different Surfaces at the Grazing Angle of 10° Frequency (GHz) 10.0 15.5 35.0 Source: [36].
Concrete −(30–54) −(29–45) −(20–43)
Asphalt −(26–46) −(25–39) −(18–33)
Asphalt-Gravel −(25–41) −(20–33) −(15–29)
Slag-Gravel −(25–44) −(18–34) −(18–28)
in the millimeter bands, and the angular dependence of the normalized RCS can be approximated as 0 ∼ sin . The second factor determining the normalized RCS is the dielectric constant, which depends on frequency, soil type, and its volumetric moisture. Increasing the volumetric soil moisture leads to increasing 0 and changes the frequency dependence of 0 because of increasing soil dielectric constant. However, the normalized RCS change of bare soil is less than 10 dB over the entire range of field moisture change; this is considerably less than the change caused by surface roughness.
112
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.11
Angular dependences of normalized RCS for dry and wet asphalt at wavelength of 8 mm and vertical polarization (VV). (After: [36].)
Table 2.9 Average Values of Normalized RCS for Nadir Radiation Surface Type Lake (smooth surface) Asphalt Concrete Sand, gravel Brick Veneer, thickness 5 mm Source: [36–39].
10.0 GHz 11.4 — — 6.5 — —
Normalized RCS (dB) at Frequencies, 40–90 GHz 70.0 GHz 20.0 15.2 16.0 — 15.2 11.5 −7.4 −1.2 — — — —
135.0 GHz — — — — 4.0 −10.0
As was shown in Section 2.1, the influence of soil type on its dielectric constant is rather small. The Fresnel coefficients in (2.7) depend rather weakly on the frequency. In this case, the dependence of normalized RCS on relative moisture can be represented by following empirical expression [11]
0 = 0.148m f − 15.96 (dB)
(2.46)
where m f = (m v /C v ) ⭈ 100%, m v is the volumetric soil moisture in grams per cubed centimeter, and C v is the field moisture capacity. The dependences of the
113
2.3 Normalized RCS
Figure 2.12
Angular dependences of the normalized RCS for three types of land.
normalized RCS on volumetric soil moisture are shown in Figure 2.14. It is seen that a volumetric moisture change from 0.05 g/m3 to 0.3 g/m3 leads to an increase in normalized RCS of 7–8 dB. Vegetation masks the soil surface, and in this case the total normalized RCS is determined as [11] 0 0⌺ ( , ) = veg ( , ) +
0 soil ( , ) 2 L ( )
(2.47)
0 0 where veg and soil are the normalized RCS of vegetation and soil, respectively, and L ( ) is the attenuation coefficient in the vegetation layer. At frequencies above 8 GHz and for grazing angles less than 60°, the contribution of the first term in (2.47) is predominant, because one can neglect the soil influence, and the contribution of the second term is significant at lower frequencies and for ≥ 60°. Figure 2.15 shows the attenuation in a vegetation layer for different types of plants as a function of the penetration depth at the 3-cm wavelength (X-band). Under conditions of incomplete surface screening, the normalized RCS dependence on the soil moisture takes the form [11]
114
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.13
Angular dependence of normalized RCS for different h . (From: [40].)
0 = 0.113m f − 13.84 (dB)
(2.48)
Thus, it is not as steep as for soil without vegetation, for which the normalized RCS is given by (2.46). The 0 dependences on soil moisture for bare soil and for soil with vegetation are shown in Figure 2.16.
2.3.3 Backscattering from Snow
Microwave backscattering from snow involves surface scattering by the air-snow and snow-soil boundaries and volumetric scattering by ice crystals within the snow layer. Multiple scattering also takes place, conditioned by the upper and lower boundaries. The normalized RCS of snow is determined by several factors: the radar frequency, the transmitted and received polarizations, and the grazing angle, as well as the electrophysical and geometrical properties of the snowpack [41]. The first snow parameter influencing the normalized RCS is its water equivalent
2.3 Normalized RCS
115
Figure 2.14
Soil normalized RCS dependences on moisture at 3–4.5 GHz. (After: [12].)
Figure 2.15
Attenuation dependences on the penetration depth for three types of vegetation.
116
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.16
Normalized RCS dependences on soil moisture for bare and vegetated surfaces. (From: [12]. 1986 Artech House, Inc. Reprinted with permission.)
W = s h
(2.49)
where s is the snow density and h is the snowpack height. The second parameter is the volumetric water content m v . The surface roughness parameters and ice crystal size distribution are also significant characteristics of snow. In most cases, the normalized snow RCS (if one does not take into consideration multiple scattering) can be expressed as [42] 2
0
=
ss0 ( ,
) +
s0( ′ )
+
␥ sa ( ′ ) L 2( ′ )
0 ( ′ ) ⭈ soil
(2.50)
where ss0 is the normalized surface scattering RCS of the air-snow boundary, 2 s0( ′ ) is the normalized volumetric scattering RCS of the snow, ␥ sa ( ′ ) is the 0 is the normalized power displacement factor of the air-snow boundary, and soil RCS of the underlying soil. The angle ′ is related to the incidence angle by
117
2.3 Normalized RCS
sin =
√⑀ s ⭈ sin ′
(2.51)
where ⑀ s is the dielectric constant of snow. For dry snow and small grazing angles (i.e., s0 ≈ 0), one can neglect the scattering from the air-snow boundary. In this case, only volumetric scattering and reflection from the snow-soil boundary determine the normalized RCS in (2.50), and the expression for the normalized RCS becomes 0 0(W ) = A 0 − (A 0 − soil ) ⭈ exp (−C 0 W sec ′ )
(2.52)
where A 0 and C 0 are coefficients depending on radar frequency, incidence angle and, polarization [43]. The dependences of the normalized RCS on the water equivalent of snow are shown in Figure 2.17. It is seen that the saturation of the normalized RCS is observed for snowpack height and its water equivalent growth, assuming the absence of soil influence on the scattering signal intensity. For wet snow, one cannot neglect the surface scattering of the air-snow boundary because of the large value of the snow dielectric constant resulting from water
Figure 2.17
The normalized RCS of snow versus depth of snow cover. (From: [43].)
118
Land Backscattering
in the liquid phase. In some cases, this surface scattering predominates in forming the scattered signal. A rapid decrease of the normalized RCS takes place with increase in liquid water content, as is shown in Figure 2.18. For m v ≥ 4–5% the rate of change of 0 decreases as a result of the considerable attenuation of the free water. The result is a predominant influence of the surface scattering. The frequency dependence of the normalized RCS for dry and wet snow is shown in Figure 2.19 [41]. First of all, one can see the interesting dependence of 0 on the liquid water content. A change of m v from 0% to 1.25% gives a decrease in the normalized RCS of about 1 dB in the decimeter band; the difference grows for increasing frequency, and it reaches the maximal value of 10–12 dB at 35.0 GHz. This difference decreases with further increase in frequency and is 2–3 dB at 140.0 GHz.
2.3.4 Backscattering from Vegetation
Vegetation leads to changes in RCS angular and frequency dependences. The smallest value of the normalized RCS is observed for thin vegetation covers. This value varies within limits of −(20 to 25) dB for grazing angles less than 10°. The back-
Figure 2.18
The normalized RCS of snow versus the volumetric moisture. (From: [43].)
2.3 Normalized RCS
Figure 2.19
119
The frequency dependence of snow normalized RCS. (After: [12].)
scattering is essentially diffuse, with an angular dependence of form 0 ∼ sin and very weak frequency dependence for all grazing angles less than 10°. Dense forests have the largest RCS in spring and summer as a result of the correlation of the scattering intensity with vegetation biomass. A high correlation between the normalized RCS and biomass is observed in the shortwave part of centimeter and in millimeter bands for grazing angles less than 60°–70°, where the soil influence is practically negligible. Thus, at 11 GHz for ≤ 60°, the correlation between normalized RCS and biomass exceeds 0.9 for both copolarization and cross-polarization [41]. An increase in biomass to 0.4 kg/m2 leads to increasing the normalized RCS by 3 dB (i.e., RCS change at a rate of 7.5 dB/kg/m2 ). There is considerable seasonal dependence of normalized RCS for vegetation covers. In the spring–summer period, the scattering intensity increases by 10–20 dB in comparison with the autumn–winter period, and the largest values are observed in June–July. This corresponds to an increase in biomass and vegetable water content during this time period. As an illustration, the seasonal changes of the normalized RCS and leaf cover coefficient are shown in Figure 2.20(a), and the seasonal changes of the normalized RCS and the vegetable water content are shown in Figure 2.20(b). There is no great difference in the normalized RCS for deciduous and coniferous forests in summer and autumn [44]. As noted in [20], no differences in the normalized RCS for coniferous forest in summer and winter are observed, while for deciduous forest this difference is 20–22 dB. There is a very significant influence of weather conditions on the normalized RCS. After a rain, the backscattering of grass increases by about 3 dB for all
120
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.20
(a) Cover coefficient and normalized RCS and (b) water content and normalized RCS dependence on season. (After: [40].)
grazing angles, and for forest this increase is 5 dB in comparison with dry weather [42, 43]. The dependence of normalized RCS for vegetation surfaces on the wavelength is very weak in centimeter and millimeter bands, having the form 0 ∼ f n where 0 ≤ n ≤ 1. The best approximation for frequency dependence for both forest and fields covered by the grass and agricultural plants has the form 0 ∼ f 0.6, giving satisfactory results from 3 GHz to 100 GHz. For grazing angles less than 1°, the experiments do not disclose even this much frequency dependence, as illustrated by Table 2.10 [20, 23, 38, 45]. 2.3.5 Normalized RCS Models
The features of land backscattering derived earlier permit us to develop several empirical models for normalized RCS of different terrain types. Table 2.10 The Vegetable Surfaces Normalized RCS for < 1° Vegetation Type Meadow (flat surface) Steppe (roughness heights up to 0.5m) Dry meadow Sparse mixed forest, bush Dense foliage forest
32 −27 −23 −20 −22 −12
Wavelength 12.5 −30 −23 −20 −20 −14.5
(mm) 8.6 −15 −23 −27 −23 −11
8.15 −25.5 −24 −21 −21 −8
4.1 −30 −2 −22.5 −21.5 −9.5
121
2.3 Normalized RCS
For the land surfaces with vegetation, the angular and frequency dependences for incidence angles from 0° to 60° (grazing angles greater than 30° ) and in the band 1–18 GHz can be represented by the empirical expression [46]
0 (dB) = a 0 + a 1 e a 2 + (a 3 + a 4 e −a 5 ) ⭈ exp [−(a 6 + a 7 ) f ]
(2.53)
where = 90° − is the incidence angle and a 1 − a 7 are coefficients determined by the transmitted and received polarizations; their values are shown in Table 2.11. The frequency dependence of the normalized RCS given by (2.53) is very weak at frequencies above 4 GHz, and at frequencies less than 4 GHz, 0 decreases very rapidly with decreasing frequency (i.e., frequency dependence appears in the decimeter band). At the same time, the angular dependence is that of diffuse backscattering. A simpler empirical expression (with fewer number of coefficients) for the normalized RCS of these surfaces was proposed in [47]
0 = D + 10␣ ⭈ log f + 8.6 ⭈ f ␣ − M (dB)
(2.54)
where the coefficient values are as shown in Table 2.12. Another model applies to the band 3–100 GHz, for grazing angles less than 30°, and is suitable for RCS description of various surfaces including quasi-smooth, rough with and without vegetation, snow, and city and country areas. The normalized RCS in this model has the form [21, 48]
0 (dB) = A 1 + A 2 log /20 + A 3 log f /10
(2.55)
Table 2.11 Coefficient Values for Use in (2.53) Polarization Horizontal polarization (HH) VV Cross polarization (HV) Source: [46].
a0
a1
a2
a3
a4
a5
a6
a7
2.69 3.49
−5.35 −5.35
0.014 0.014
−23.4 −14.8
33.14 23.69
0.048 0.066
0.053 0.048
5.1 ⭈ 10−3 2.8 ⭈ 10−3
3.91
−5.35
0.013
−25.5
14.65
0.098
0.258
2.1 ⭈ 10−3
Table 2.12 Coefficient Values for Use in (2.54)
␣  0.8 0.04 Source: [47].
D −15.5
M 0.1
122
Land Backscattering
Here f is the frequency in gigahertz, and is the grazing angle in degrees. The coefficients A 1 − A 3 for various types of terrain are shown in Table 2.13. The significant feature of this model lies in the replacing of the real terrain variety by a limited number of land surface types, which include all of the main terrain types. This is sufficient for land clutter estimations in typical conditions of radar operation. As an illustration, the angular and frequency dependences of the normalized RCS for deciduous forest are shown in Figures 2.21 and 2.22, obtained for a grazing angle of 10° by various authors, where the solid and dotted lines correspond to derivations according to (2.55). The variance of experimental data amounts to 10–15 dB, and this is associated with differences both in various land types and in the methods of experimental data processing. Table 2.13 The Coefficients A 1–A 3 in Land Clutter Model Terrain Type Concrete Arable land Snow Deciduous and coniferous forests, summer Deciduous forest, winter Grass with height more than 0.5m Grass with height less than 0.5m Urban territories (town and country buildings) Source: [48].
Figure 2.21
A1 −49 −37 −34 −20 −40 −21 −(25−30) −8.5
A2 32 18 25 10 10 10 10 5
A3 20 15 15 6 6 6 6 3
Normalized RCS 0 versus grazing angle for forest at wavelengths of 8 mm (curve 1) and 3 mm (curve 2).
2.4 Depolarization of Scattered Signals
Figure 2.22
123
Normalized RCS versus frequency for forest at = 10°.
Consequently, we have normalized RCS estimations for various types of land for practically all microwave and millimeter-wave bands.
2.4 Depolarization of Scattered Signals The polarization differences of backscattered signals are determined, to a major degree, by the ratio of surface roughness to wavelength. For quasi-smooth terrain (concrete, asphalt), the normalized RCS at grazing angles less than 30° is greater by 8–10 dB for VV than for HH, and HV components are practically absent [20]. This is in good agreement with the land surface model obtained by the small perturbation method for which the depolarization compo0 0 nents are zero ( HV = VH = 0). For bare rough surfaces, the difference between RCS values for HH and VV polarizations disappears as the rms roughness h increases, and the difference does not exceed 2–3 dB for grazing angles less than 60°. The normalized RCS ratio for co- and cross-polarizations for these surfaces is 7–15 dB [1] decreasing with reduced
124
Land Backscattering
wavelength and grazing angle and with increasing h . For example, in Figure 2.23, the dependence of 0 on incidence angle is shown for three soils with different h measured at the 3-cm wavelength, and in Figure 2.24 the copolarization to crosspolarization ratios are shown for wavelengths of 3 cm and 8 mm for soils with different erosion state [49]. The polarization ratios are small for land surfaces with vegetation. The ratio 0 0 VV / HH decreases with vegetation biomass growth. For agricultural plantings (e.g., potatoes, alfalfa, or sugar beets), this ratio is 2–3 dB at 10 GHz [50] and 3–4 dB between 10 and 100 GHz [51]. The copolarization to cross-polarization ratio varies over wide limits. As shown in [51], this ratio is 7–12 dB at the 3-cm wavelength, decreasing with grazing angle decrease, and is 10–12 dB at 9-mm wavelength (Figure 2.25). Thus, for various land surfaces, the polarization ratios at a 3-cm wavelength are shown in Table 2.14. The polarization features of signals scattered by snow are not pronounced. There is little difference between RCS for VV and HH polarizations for snow at frequencies above 10 GHz, and copolarization to cross-polarization ratio is about 10 dB for dry snow and 10–15 dB for wet snow. This ratio decreases with further increase in frequency, to 5 dB at 95 GHz and 3 dB at 140 GHz [41]. 0 0 For sea ice, the ratio of VV / HH is practically unity, and the copolarization to cross-polarization ratios are 3–10 dB in the band 10–40 GHz [52], depending on surface roughness. These data permit us to use the following hypotheses for description of land backscattering: •
0 0 The ratio VV / HH is 10 dB for quasi-smooth surfaces at 10 GHz, and its dependence on frequency is rather weak.
Figure 2.23
(a–c) The normalized RCS versus incidence angle for three types of soil. (After: [12].)
2.4 Depolarization of Scattered Signals
Figure 2.24
• •
125
0 0 Ratios cop / cross versus incidence angle at wavelengths of (a) 3 cm and (b) 8 mm for soils with different erosion states (curves 1–3). (From: [49]. 1995 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
This ratio is zero for all types of rough surfaces. The copolarization to cross-polarization ratio is 10 dB with the exception of quasi-smooth surfaces for which the cross-polarization components of the backscattered signal are very small.
Thus, the following expressions can be used for normalized RCS of land clutter
126
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.25
(a–c) Polarization ratios for vegetation at a 9-mm wavelength for different crops.
0 0 0 Table 2.14 Ratios of VV / 0HH and copal / cross , in Decibels, for 3-cm Wavelength
Surface Type Quasi-smooth Rough bare soil Rough surface with vegetation Snow Ice Town and country areas
0 VV ≅
冦
0 HH + 10 0 HH
0 0 VV / HH 8.0–10.0 2.0–3.0 2.0–3.0 0 1.0–2.0 0
冉 冊 f 10
0 0 copal / cross — 7.0–15.0 7.0–12.0 10.0–15.0 3.0–10.0 2.0–3.0
−1/2
for quasi-smooth surfaces
(2.56a)
for other surfaces
0 Here HH is the value of 0 from (2.55), and f is the frequency in gigahertz. The cross-polarized component of the normalized RCS is 0 0 0 0 cross = HV = VH ≈ HH − 10 (dB)
(2.56b)
for all types of surfaces other than quasi-smooth. For quasi-smooth surfaces, the cross-polarized component of the normalized RCS in model is zero (−∞ in decibels).
2.5 Statistical Characteristics of the Scattered Signals The fluctuations of backscattered signals from land are associated with the motion of scatterers within the resolution cell and the shift of the resolution cells due to
127
2.5 Statistical Characteristics of the Scattered Signals
radar platform motion and antenna scanning. This determines the normalized RCS temporal and spatial probability distributions ∞
0
p ( ) =
冕
p 冠 0 | m 冡 ⭈ p (m ) dm
(2.57)
−∞
Here p (m ) is the pdf that characterizes the spatial distribution of the fluctuations, p 冠 0 | m 冡 is the conditional pdf that describes the temporal fluctuations in a single resolution cell, and m is the mean value of the normalized RCS. The pdf of RCS can depend in various ways on the distribution of mean or median values p (m ) of 0 within the scan volume. This is because the RCS distribution in a single resolution cell is transformed, and the resulting distribution has larger tails (i.e., greater probability of occurrence of large RCS values). The temporal statistics of the scattered signal follows the RCS distribution within the limits of a single resolution cell p 冠 0 | m 冡. Typical approximations of experimental distributions of normalized RCS are the Rayleigh and Rician [1]. For these cases, the probability function of the in-phase (I ) and quadrature (Q ) components of the scattered signal are Gaussian with variance equal to the fluctuating component power and with nonzero mean value (the mathematical expectation) equal to the amplitude of the stable component. The stable component of the scattered signal is formed by reflectors that are stable in time (e.g., rocks, buildings, or bare surfaces). In some cases, its value is considerably larger than the fluctuating component. As result, the normalized RCS can be represented as a sum of two terms
0 = st0 + fl0 = fl0(1 + a 2 )
(2.58)
where st0 and fl0 are the normalized RCS of the stable and fluctuating components, respectively, and a 2 is the ratio of stable-to-fluctuating RCS. For various land types, the values of a 2 are determined by the mean wind velocity and the wavelength and are 30.7 2 ⭈ V −2.9
a2 =
冦
2
63 ⭈ V 2
−3
100 ⭈ V
−3
for forests for short vegetation
(2.59)
for bare land
For town and country areas, the a 2 values are approximately 104–105. In these expressions, is the wavelength in centimeters and V is the wind velocity in meters per second.
128
Land Backscattering
Two models are applied rather widely for modeling the probability distribution functions of land backscattering. In the first (the Rayleigh model), an ensemble of independent reflectors with random amplitude and phase produces the scattered signal. This is a typical model for land surfaces with dense vegetation. The pdf of the normalized RCS in this model is p ( 0 /m ) =
冉 冊
1 0 exp − m m
(2.60)
For terrains with the stable scatterers, a model using the Rician pdf is applied: p 冠 0 | m 冡 =
冋
1 + a2 0 ⭈ exp −a 2 − (1 + a 2 ) m m
册
冉√
⭈ I 0 2a
0
(1 + a 2 ) m
冊
(2.61)
where I 0 is the Bessel function of the first kind and zero order. The normalized RCS differs from the Gaussian model only for small sizes of the radar resolution cell, and this function can be represented as p ( ) =
冉 冊
b b − 1 − b exp ␣ ␣
(2.62)
This is the Weibull distribution of RCS. Here ␣ is the shape parameter and b is the slope parameter, b = 1 for the Rayleigh model (2.10). The experimental results of [53] showed that the b parameter for forest and grass in summer and in winter and for the wind velocities of 5–10 m/s is 10–15 (i.e., the Weibull distribution is rather similar to the Gaussian). Examples of these distributions for scattering from grass at 3.2-cm wavelength are shown in Figure 2.26. Therefore, it is possible to use the Gaussian pdf to describe the statistics of two quadrature components of the scattered signals from the land surfaces.
2.6 Power Spectra of Scattered Signals The power spectra of land backscattering are determined, as a rule, by fluctuations of scatterers that move under wind conditions and by volume scanning and radar platform motion. The influence of volume scan for various scanning methods that lead to power spectrum broadening is analyzed in detail in [10, 20], and radar platform motion is considered in [11]. The scatterer motions induced by wind fluctuations in the troposphere control the power spectrum of backscattering from terrain with vegetation. In the frame-
129
2.6 Power Spectra of Scattered Signals
Figure 2.26
Histograms of relative amplitude distributions for backscattering from grass at a 3-cm wavelength and for wind velocity (a) 5 m/s and (b) 7 m/s. (From: [53].)
work of this model, the power spectra are described as functions of the fractal type in which the spectral width and the power exponent are the functions of the wind velocity. The power spectrum can be represented as [20, 54] G ′ (F ) = a 2␦ (F ) + G (F )
(2.63)
where ␦ (F ) is Dirac’s function, which characterizes the scattering from the stable reflectors and G (F ) is the power spectrum of the fluctuating component. The experimental investigations of land clutter power spectra carried out by the author in 1966–1969 and later ones [20, 54, 55] showed that the power spectrum of the fluctuating component can be represented by the following empirical expressions
冋 冉 冊册
F G (F ) = G 0 1 + ⌬F 2(U + 2)
n −1
冉 冊
100 n= ⭈ f U +1
(2.64)
0.2
(2.65)
where F is the Doppler frequency; ⌬F is the −3 dB width of the power spectrum, which is the function of wind velocity, the operating frequency, and the land surface type; and n is the power exponent, which depends on wind velocity and vegetation type. For formal description of these values, one can use the following expressions for surfaces with vegetation
130
Land Backscattering
⌬F = 1.23 ⭈
冉 冊 3.2
⭈ U 1.3
(2.66)
where is the wavelength in centimeters, f is the frequency in gigahertz, and U is the average wind velocity in meters per second. The latter expression does not take into consideration the seasonal change and variations for various vegetation covers. As an example, the dependence of ⌬F on wind velocity is shown in Figure 2.27, where the dots are the experimental results and the solid line is from (2.66). The presence of vegetation and increase in biomass leads to an increase in the scattering intensity [i.e., increase of 10–15 dB in the spectral components for all frequencies in summer as compared with autumn and winter, with some decrease in the power exponent of (2.65)]. As an example, the backscattering power spectra for a swamp with grass and bushes are presented in Figure 2.28 for the 3-cm wavelength (the straight line 1 for summer, the line 2 for winter). The power spectra of backscattering from forest and grass at 3 cm in summer and winter are shown in Figure 2.29 [20, 53]. It is seen that the power exponent in (2.65) decreases in winter for forest and does not change for grass. It has been determined experimentally [20] that the power spectra of backscattering from land with vegetation extend over Doppler frequency bands in the order
Figure 2.27
The −3-dB spectrum bandwidth versus wind velocity for a 3-cm wavelength.
2.6 Power Spectra of Scattered Signals
Figure 2.28
131
Doppler spectra of backscattering from swamp with bushes at the 3-cm wavelength in summer (1) and in winter (2).
of 10–20 kHz. Examples of such spectra obtained at wavelengths of 3 cm, 8 mm, and 4 mm for forest and grass are shown in Figure 2.30. The power spectra of intensity (the amplitude spectra) have practically the same properties as the power spectra of coherent signals. First of all, square-law detection of signals with power spectra of the form G (F ) ∼ F −n does not broaden the amplitude spectrum in comparison with the power spectrum if the signal-tonoise ratio is chosen correctly. The amplitude spectral shape can be described by (2.64) and the spectral width by (2.66). For a light wind (about 1 m/s), the correlation interval decreases with reduced wavelength more rapidly than for moderate wind. This can be explained by the greater efficiency of the phase modulation of the scattered signal because the influence of small radial movements of the scatterers is more visible. There may be flatter spectra at low-frequency F for further reduction in wavelength.
132
Land Backscattering
Figure 2.29
Doppler spectra of backscattering from forest and grass at the 3-cm wavelength in (a) summer and (b) winter. (From: [53].)
Figure 2.30
The power spectra of backscattering from forest and grass at wavelengths of 3 cm, 8 mm, and 4 mm. (From: [48]. 1994 SPIE. Reprinted with permission.)
References
133
References [1] [2] [3]
[4]
[5]
[6] [7]
[8]
[9]
[10] [11]
[12] [13]
[14] [15] [16]
[17]
Melnik, Y. A., Radar Techniques of Earth Investigation, Moscow, Russia: Soviet Radio, 1980 (in Russian). Peake, W. H., ‘‘Theory of Radar Return from Terrain,’’ IRE Nat. Conv. Rec., Part 7, 1957, pp. 34–43. Andreev, G. A., and V. A. Golunov, ‘‘Scattering and Radiation of Millimeter Waves by Natural Formations,’’ Results of Science and Technique, Vol. 20, 1980, pp. 3–106 (in Russian). Hallikainen, M., et al., ‘‘Microwave Dielectric Behavior of Wet Soil—Part I: Empirical Models and Experimental Observations,’’ IEEE Trans. Geosc. Remote Sens., Vol. GE-23, 1985, pp. 25–34. Dobson, M. C., F. Kouyate, and F. T. Ulaby, ‘‘A Reexamination of Soil Textural Effects on Microwave Emission and Backscattering,’’ IEEE Trans. Geosc. Remote Sens., Vol. GE-22, No. 6, 1984, pp. 530–536. Cumming, W., ‘‘The Dielectric Properties of Ice and Snow at 3.2 cm,’’ J. Appl. Phys., Vol. 23, 1952, pp. 768–773. Sweeney, B. D., and S. C. Colbeck, ‘‘Measurement of the Dielectric Properties of Wet Snow Using a Microwave Technique,’’ Cold Region Res. and Eng. Lab. (CRREL), Hanover, NH, 1974, p. 84. Hallikainen, M. F., F. T. Ulaby, and M. Abdelrazik, ‘‘The Dielectric Behavior of Snow in the 3 to 37 GHz Range,’’ 1984 IEEE Int. Symp. (IGARSS-84) Digest, San Francisco, CA, August 1984, pp. 169–176. Hallikainen, M. F., F. T. Ulaby, and M. Abdelrazik, ‘‘The Dielectric Properties of Snow in the 3 to 37 GHz Range,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-34, No. 5, 1986, pp. 1329–1340. Polder, D., and J. H. Van Santen, ‘‘The Effective Permeability of Mixtures of Solids,’’ Physica, Vol. 12, 1946, pp. 257–269. Ulaby, F. T., A. Aslam, and M. C. Dobson, ‘‘Effects of Vegetation Cover on the Radar Sensitivity to Soil Moisture,’’ IEEE Trans. Geosc. Remote Sens., Vol. GE-20, No. 4, 1982, pp. 476–481. Ulaby, F. T., R. K. Moore, and A. K. Fung, Microwave Remote Sensing, Vol. 3: Active and Passive, Norwood, MA: Artech House, 1986, p. 1098. Boyarsky, D., et al., ‘‘Electric Models of Dry Snow Cover for Remote Sensing: Some Results of Theory and Experiment,’’ Scient.-Techniq. Conf. Statistical Methods and Systems of Remote Sensing Data Processing of Environment, Minsk, USSR, November 1989, pp. 82–83 (in Russian). Linlor, W. I., ‘‘Permittivity and Attenuation of Wet Snow Between 4 and 12 GHz,’’ J. Appl. Phys., Vol. 51, 1980, pp. 2811–2816. Andreev, G. A., and A. A. Potapov, ‘‘Millimeter Waves in Radar,’’ Foreign Radioelectronics, No. 11, 1984, pp. 28–62. Armand, N. A., et al., ‘‘Radiophysical Techniques of Environment Investigation,’’ in Problems of Modern Radiotechnics and Electronics, Moscow, AN USSR Pub., 1978 (in Russian). Zubkovich, S. G., Statistical Characteristics of Radio Signals Scattered from the Earth Surface, Moscow, Russia: Soviet Radio, 1968 (in Russian).
134
Land Backscattering [18]
[19] [20]
[21] [22]
[23] [24] [25] [26] [27]
[28] [29]
[30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37]
Redkin, B. A., and V. V. Klochko, ‘‘Derivation of Averaged Tensor of Vegetation Complex Dielectric Constant,’’ Radiotechnics and Electronics, No. 8, 1975, pp. 1596–1603 (in Russian). Beckmann, P., and A. Spizzichino, The Scattering of Electromagnetic Waves from Rough Surfaces, Pergamon Press, 1963; Norwood, MA: Artech House, 1987, p. 303. Kulemin, G. P., and V. B. Razskazovsky, Scattering of Millimeter Radiowaves by the Earth’s Surface for Small Grazing Angles, Kiev, Ukraine: Naukova Dumka, 1987 (in Russian). Ishimaru, A., Wave Propagation and Scattering in Random Media, New York: Academic Press, 1978. Ament, W. A., F. C. MacDonald, and R. D. Shewbridge, ‘‘Radar Terrain Reflections for Several Polarizations and Frequencies,’’ Proc. Symp. Radar Return, Arlington, NY, October 1959, pp. 346–349. Spetner, L. J., and I. Katz, ‘‘Two Statistical Models for Radar Terrain Return,’’ IRE Trans. Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-8, No. 5, 1960, pp. 242–246. Twersky, V., ‘‘On Scattering and Reflection of Electromagnetic Waves by Round Surfaces,’’ IRE Trans. Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-8, No. 1, 1960, pp. 81–89. Attema, E., and F. T. Ulaby, ‘‘A Radar Backscatter for Vegetation Targets,’’ Proc. Open Int. Symp. EM Propag. Nonionized Media, La Baule, France, May 1977, pp. 579–584. Bush, T., and F. Ulaby, ‘‘Radar Return from a Continuous Vegetation Canopy,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-24, No. 3, 1976, pp. 269–276. Zamaraev, B. D., Y. F. Vasilyev, and V. G. Kolesnikov, ‘‘Foliage Forest Normalized RCS Estimation at Millimeter Band of Radiowaves,’’ Spatial-Temporal Signal Processing in Radiotechnical Systems, Aviation Institute, Kharkov, Ukraine, 1985, pp. 50–53 (in Russian). Bass, F. G., and I. M. Fuks, Wave Scattering from Statistical Rough Surfaces, Moscow, Russia: Soviet Radio, 1972, p. 424 (in Russian). Gorelik, G. S., ‘‘On Scatterer Velocity Correlation Influence on the Statistical Properties of Scattered Radiation,’’ Radiotechnics and Electronics, Vol. 2, No. 10, 1957, pp. 1227–1233 (in Russian). Gorelik, G. S., ‘‘To Radiowaves Scattering Theory on the Wondering Inhomogeneities,’’ Radiotechnics and Electronics, Vol. 1, No. 6, 1956, pp. 695–703 (in Russian). Tikhonov, V. I., Statistical Radiotechnics, Moscow, Russia: Soviet Radio, 1966, p. 678 (in Russian). Gradshtein, I. S., and I. M. Rizhik, Tables of Integrals, Sums, Series and Products, Fizmatgiz, Moscow, 1963, p. 1100 (in Russian). Pinus, N. Z., and S. M. Shmeter, Aerology, Moscow, Russia: Gidrometeoizdat, 1965, p. 351 (in Russian). Zubkovsky, S. L., ‘‘Fluctuation Spectra of Wind Velocity Horizontal Component at Height of 4m,’’ Izv. AS USSR, Physics of Atmosphere and Ocean, No. 10, 1962, pp. 1425–1428. Malakhov, A. N., ‘‘About Generator Spectral Line Shape for its Frequency Fluctuations,’’ Journal of Experimentental and Theoretical Physics, Vol. 30, No. 5, 1956, pp. 884–889. Taylor, R., ‘‘Terrain Return Measurements at X-, Ku , and Ka Bands,’’ IRE Nat. Conv. Rec., Part 1, 1959, pp. 19–30. Long, M. W., Radar Reflectivity of Land and Sea, 3rd ed., Norwood, MA: Artech House, 2001.
References [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43]
[44] [45] [46] [47]
[48]
[49]
[50]
[51] [52]
[53]
[54]
[55]
135 Trebits, R. N., R. D. Hayes, and L. C. Bomar, ‘‘MM-Wave Reflectivity of Land and Sea,’’ Microwave J., Vol. 21, No. 8, 1978, pp. 49–53. King, H. E., et al., ‘‘Terrain Backscatter Measurements at 40 to 90 GHz,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-18, No. 6, 1970, pp. 780–784. LeToan, T., ‘‘Active Microwave Signatures of Soil and Crops,’’ Proc. IGARSS’82, Digest, Vol. 1, 1982, pp. Tp 2.3/1–Tp 2.3/5. Kulemin, G. P., T. N. Kharchenko, and S.E. Yatsevich, ‘‘Snow Remote Sensing by the Radar Techniques,’’ Preprint of IRE NASU, No. 92-8, Kharkov, Ukraine, 1992 (in Russian). Ulaby, F. T., W. H. Stiles, and M. Abdelrazik, ‘‘Snowcover Influence on Backscattering from Terrain,’’ IEEE Trans. Geosc. Remote Sens., Vol. GE-22, No. 2, 1984, pp. 126–132. Ulaby, F. T., and W. H. Stiles, ‘‘The Active and Passive Microwave Response to Snow Parameters: Part II—Water Equivalent of Dry Snow,’’ J. Geophys. Res., Vol. 85, No. C2, 1980, pp. 116–122. Kim, Y. S., et al., ‘‘Surfaces-Based Radar Scatterometer Study of Kansas Rangeland,’’ Remote Sens. Environ., Vol. 11, 1980, pp. 253–265. Grant, C. R., and B. S. Yaplee, ‘‘Backscattering from Water and Land of Centimeter and Millimeter Wavelengths,’’ Proc. IRE, No. 6, 1957, pp. 976–982. Ulaby, F. T., ‘‘Vegetation Clutter Model,’’ IEEE Trans. Antennas and Propagation, Vol. AP-28, 1980, pp. 538–545. Vasilyev, Y. F., B. D. Zamaraev, and G. P. Kulemin, ‘‘The Angular and Season Backscattering Dependences of Millimeter Radiowaves by Vegetation Cover,’’ Preprint of IRE NASU No 91-3, Kharkov, Ukraine, 1991, p. 26, (in Russian). Kulemin, G. P., and V. B. Razskazovsky, ‘‘Complex Effects of Clutter, Weather and Battlefield Conditions on the Target Detection in Millimeter-Wave Radars,’’ Proc. SPIE, Vol. 2,222, 1994, pp. 862–871. Kulemin, G. P., et al., ‘‘Soil Moisture and Erosion Degree Estimation from Multichannel Microwave Remote Sensing Data,’’ Proc. Europ. Symp. SPIE on Satellite Remote Sensing, Paris, Vol. 2,585, September 1995, pp. 144–155. Moore, R. K., K. A. Soofy, and S. M. Purduski, ‘‘A Radar Clutter Model: Average Scattering Coefficients of Land, Snow and Ice,’’ IEEE Trans Aerosp. Electr. Syst., Vol. AES-16, 1980, pp. 783–799. Skolnik, M. I., (ed.), Radar Handbook, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1970. Kulemin, G. P., ‘‘Growler Detection Method in Sea Clutter by Coherent Radar,’’ Proc. Sixth Int. Conf. Remote Sensing for Marine and Coastal Environment, May 2000, Charleston, SC; Veridan ERIM Int., Vol. 2, pp. II.47–II.54. Savchenko, A. K., S. J. Haimov, and G. P. Kulemin, ‘‘On the Experimental Study of Radar Backscattering from Land,’’ XVII Europ. Microwave Conf., Stockholm, October 1988, pp. 705–709. Kulemin, G. P. and V. B. Razkazovsky, ‘‘Land Backscattering Spectra of Centimeter and Millimeter Radiowaves for Small Grazing Angles,’’ Preprint of IRE NASU, No. 195, Kharkov, Ukraine, 1982, p. 39 (in Russian). Brukhovetskiy, A. S., and A. A. Puzenko, ‘‘About Signal Spectrum for Transversal Movement of Shadowing Reflectors,’’ Radiotechnics and Electronics, Vol. 15, No. 12, 1970, pp. 2533–2538 (in Russian).
CHAPTER 3
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods 3.1 Estimation of Soil Parameters 3.1.1 Introduction
Efficient use of agricultural fields requires application of modern remote sensing techniques for soil characteristic determination because the traditional methods of in situ measurements do not provide data detailed enough for practice and are too labor consuming. During recent decades, besides optical and infrared methods, radar methods of soil characteristic study have been intensively developed—in particular, nearsurface soil moisture estimation, determination of humus content, and degree of soil erosion. The high resolution and the weather independence of radars permit their practical application to remote sensing of large terrain areas through the use of airborne and spaceborne radars—synthetic aperture radar (SAR) or side-looking radar (SLAR). In radar remote sensing, the electromagnetic field scattered by the objects serves as a source of information about the physical and chemical properties of the surface. For this reason, the processes of microwave scattering from bare soil have been the subject of theoretical and experimental investigations for many years. This research activity was directed at finding a correlation between the parameters of the scattered electromagnetic field and the statistical and agrophysical characteristics of soil. The capability of active microwave techniques to sense near-surface soil moisture has a considerable research interest. The basis for microwave remote sensing of soil moisture is the dependence of the soil’s dielectric properties on its moisture content due to a large contrast between the dielectric constant of water and that of dry soil. Boundary conditions affecting soil characteristics include the smallscale random surface roughness generated by cultivation, soil erosion processes, azimuthally dependent ridge/furrow patterns, and the slope of a terrain element affecting the local angle of incidence. As is well known, the scattered signal intensity is determined by the statistical characteristics of the surface and the dielectric constant of the medium. However,
137
138
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
the range of the soil specific RCS variations due to moisture does not exceed 8–10 dB, while the roughness variations can lead to 15–25 dB of RCS variations. Consequently, the effects of surface roughness create obstacles to correct estimation of soil moisture. The use of the dual-polarization ratio of normalized RCS for obtaining unbiased estimation of the real part of the complex dielectric constant was first proposed in [1], and this ratio was also used in [2]. The application of multifrequency radar technique to determination of surface roughness was proposed in [3], where this approach was used for small incidence angles, and joint processing was not applied. In papers [4–8], the application of multichannel techniques to separate determination of near-surface soil moisture and surface roughness was proposed, and joint processing of data was used. Taking into account that roughness parameters depend mainly on mechanical and aggregate soil structure, the successful retrieval of this information permits determining soil areas with different degrees of erosion and analyzing the dynamics of their evolution. This chapter presents the results of theoretical and experimental investigations into multichannel remote sensing techniques applied to estimation of soil parameters in the microwave band. 3.1.2 Soil Backscattering Modeling
In modeling wave scattering from natural terrains, one generally expects a combination of surface and volume scattering, especially when a dry soil medium is inhomogeneous. The soil medium can be treated as a volume consisting of variable fractions of soil solids, aqueous fluids, and air. Soil solid material is a mixture of sand, silt, and clay, and it is characterized by a distribution of particle sizes (texture) and mineralogy of their consistent particles (particularly, a clay fraction). The particle diameter of clay is less than 2 m, the particle diameter of silt is between 2 m and 50 m, and the particle diameter of sand is between 50 m and 200 m. The water in soil is classified as free or bound water. Modeling of scattering from bare natural and agricultural soils starts from a characterization of the surface roughness and dielectric behavior of materials. The latter depends on several parameters, including the bulk density, the particle size distribution, the mineralogical composition, the content of organic matter, the content of bound and free water, the soil salinity, and the temperature. The problem of electromagnetic wave scattering from rough surfaces has been studied extensively for many years. However, because of the complexity of the problem, satisfactory solutions are available only when very stringent restrictions are imposed on the rough surface profile, the electromagnetic parameters of the irregular boundary, or the frequency. Models can be divided into two groups: field-approach models and intensity-approach models [9]. The disadvantage of the existing field-approach models is that they cannot in practice include multiple incoherent scattering beyond the second order. On the other hand, the intensity-
3.1 Estimation of Soil Parameters
139
approach models can include more multiple scattering terms and the interaction between surface and volume scattering, but it assumes a far field interaction between scatterers. We restrict ourselves to rough surface scattering models only and neglect volume scattering, although in practice these two effects are sometimes difficult to separate. For bare soil, the surface scattering is dominant only if the terrain can be considered homogeneous. Two rough surface scattering models are widely applied because of their simplicity: Kirchhoff’s model and the first-order small perturbation model [10]. In most backscattering applications, Kirchhoff’s model is used over the incidence angular region 0 < < 20°. This model is restricted to high frequencies and indicates that for perfectly conducting surfaces the backscattered fields do not depend on polarization. The small perturbation model is used over the angular range 20° < < 60°. Larger incidence angles are not considered because the scattering mechanisms for grazing incidence are likely to be different from a purely surface scattering phenomenon. Using a perturbational approach derived for surfaces with small gradients (k h < 0.3, where k = 2 / is the wavenumber and h is the rms roughness height), the backscattering field is shown to be strongly dependent on the polarization of the incident and scattered waves. Other scattering models are, perhaps, potentially more powerful than the previous ones, but they have not yet been extensively applied to the interpretation of experimental measurements. Without going into detail, we mention three methods that seem to be the most promising: the full-wave method of Bahar [11] bridging the wide gap existing between the perturbational solutions for rough surfaces with small slopes and the quasi-optics solutions, the diagram method [12], and the stochastic Fourier method [10]. These methods are not yet fully developed, but the results obtained appear to be very encouraging. In all of the models of rough surface scattering, the normalized RCS of surface characterizing the intensity of the scattered field is a product of two functions 0 pp ( f , i ) = D pp [⑀ s ( f ), i ] ⭈ S ( f , i )
(3.1)
The first function D (⭈), or so-called dielectric function, characterizes the dielectric properties of the scattering medium and depends upon the polarization pp = HH or VV, the angle of incidence i , and the dielectric constant ⑀ s . For these models, the dielectric functions are equal or proportional to the Fresnel reflectivity (i.e., they present equally the RCS dependence as a function of dielectric constant of the medium). Their main limitation is an inadequate estimation of the scattering coefficients for cross-polarized components of the scattered signals. The second function S (⭈) takes into account the surface roughness influence on normalized RCS, where f denotes the radar frequency.
140
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
For analysis of the capabilities of the multichannel method, we use the simple surface scattering models, particularly the small perturbation model described in the previous chapter. There are several reasons for this. First of all, the condition k h > 1 is usually fulfilled for agricultural soils with different methods of cultivation in the microwave band. Then, the small perturbation model can be used only for approximated estimation of the normalized RCS. However, the model derivations of normalized RCS dependences as functions of incidence angles, rms surface roughness, and soil moisture coincide rather accurately with the experimental results up to and beyond k h > 2.5–3.0 [12]. The most significant differences between the model and experimental results are observed for the cross-polarized components of the scattered signals. Besides, for the considered multichannel methods, we have used the ratios of the normalized RCS at different frequencies and polarizations, where the absolute error of RCS estimation from the perturbational model do not greatly influence the ratio values. For the case of backscattering we obtain D pp [⑀ s ( f ), i ] = | ␣ pp ( i ) |
2
2
S ( f , i ) = 8(k cos i )4 ⭈ h ⭈ W (2k cos i )
␣ VV =
(⑀ s − 1) [sin2 i − ⑀ s (1 + sin2 i )]
(⑀ s cos i + √⑀ s − sin2 i )2
␣ HH =
⑀s − 1
(cos i + √⑀ s − sin2 i )2
(3.2) (3.3) (3.4)
(3.5)
where W (⭈) is the surface roughness spectrum. The moisture content determination is based on the correlation between the dielectric function (3.2) and the soil dielectric constant, as well as on the dielectric function dependence on frequency and soil moisture. The results of simulation [5–7] have shown that the dielectric functions had a weak dependence upon frequency in the microwave band, while the soil dielectric constant differed significantly for different frequencies. This is illustrated in Figure 3.1. Analysis shows that the maximal differences of dielectric functions do not exceed 1 dB if the ratio of two frequencies satisfies the condition 1 < f2 /f1 < 2 − 3
(3.6)
(i.e., for the microwave band, the dielectric functions are practically frequency independent). The most obvious dependence of D on f takes place for moisture
3.1 Estimation of Soil Parameters
141
bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb
Figure 3.1 The dielectric functions D versus soil moisture for horizontal polarization, frequencies 1–18 GHz, and incidence angle 60°. (From: [5].)
0.05–0.2 g ⭈ cm−3. The lower bound of this interval deals with the appearance of free water molecules in the soil, and when the moisture content exceeds 0.2–0.25 g ⭈ cm−3, saturation of dielectric functions occurs. This phenomenon leads to two important conclusions: •
•
The potential moisture content sensitivity is equal for all frequencies in the microwave band. The weak frequency dependence of the dielectric functions permits soil moisture estimation for the upper soil layer and measurement of other statistical characteristics on the basis of joint analysis of multichannel remote sensing data.
As shown in [5], in the framework of the small perturbation approach, it is theoretically possible to separate and to accurately estimate the roughness and the moisture parameters on the basis of multichannel measurements without a priori knowledge of surface statistical characteristics. In the most simple case of twofrequency remote sensing, it is possible to select the frequencies f 1 , f 2 and the
142
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
angles of incidence 1 , 2 in such a way that the ratio of corresponding functions of roughness does not depend on surface statistical characteristics. The condition of such independence is described by the equation k 1 sin 1 = k 2 sin 2
(3.7)
Then the ratio of the RCS for two polarizations is 0 pp ,1 0 qq ,2
=
0 pp ,1( f1, 1) 0 qq ,2( f2, 2)
=
冉
冊
4 D pp (⑀ 1 , 1 ) k 1 cos 1 ⭈ D qq (⑀ 2 , 2 ) k 2 cos 2
(3.8)
Here pp , qq = HH or VV, ⑀ 1 = ⑀ ( f 1 ), and ⑀ 2 = ⑀ ( f 2 ). The ratio (3.8) is a function of dielectric constants, wavelengths, and angles of incidence, and it does not depend on surface statistical characteristics. Remote moisture determination can be performed with (3.8), taking into account that the dielectric constants are functions of the volume moisture content of the soil upper layer. Here we can consider five polarization ratios R1 =
0 HH, 1 0 HH, 2
; R2 =
0 HH, 1 0 VV, 2
; R3 =
0 VV, 1 0 HH, 2
; R4 =
0 VV, 1 0 VV, 2
; R5 =
0 HH 0 VV
(3.9)
The polarization ratio R 5 is the particular case when f 1 = f 2 = f , pp = HH, and qq = VV. It was proposed for the first time in [1], where it was shown that this ratio served for obtaining unbiased estimation of the real part of the complex dielectric constant; this ratio is also used in [5]. Moisture dependence R 5 for f = 10 GHz and for different angles of incidence is shown in Figure 3.2. The nonlinear behavior of this dependence is evident. The variation range of R 5 increases with an increase in the angle of incidence and for = 50°–60°, it is approximately equal to 6 dB. The maximal moisture sensitivity is observed for volume moisture content less than 0.25 g/cm−3 and is approximately equal to 0.24 dB/0.01 g/cm−3. For wetter soil, saturation is observed, and the sensitivity decreases by a factor more than 3. Analysis of ratios R 1 –R 4 as functions of the moisture is done in [5], where it is shown that forming of these estimates provides a maximum moisture content sensitivity greater than 0.1 dB/0.01 g/cm−3 when frequency ratio f 1 /f 2 = 1.2–2.5; this is practically available. Multichannel techniques for estimation of statistical characteristics for some surfaces in the framework of the small perturbation method is based on the use of the following relationship [4] SR i =
0 pp ( i , f 1 ) 0 pp ( i , f 2 )
=
D pp [ i , ⑀ s ( f 1 )] ⭈ S ( i , f 1 ) D pp [ i , ⑀ s ( f 2 )] ⭈ S ( i , f 2 )
(3.10)
143
3.1 Estimation of Soil Parameters
Figure 3.2 The R 5 ratio versus soil moisture at 10 GHz for incidence angles 20°–60° (From: [5].)
The weak frequency dependence of the dielectric function in the microwave band permits us to assume that D pp [ i , ⑀ s ( f 1 )] ≅ D pp [ i , ⑀ s ( f 2 )]
(3.11)
This assumption is permissible taking into account the fact that the instrumental accuracy of normalized RCS estimation is 1.5 dB, especially if the operation frequencies f 1 and f 2 are comparable [i.e., when ( f 2 − f 1 ) << ( f 2 + f 1 )/2 and f 2 / f 1 < 1.5]. In such conditions (3.10) is a function of surface parameters only and does not depend on ⑀ s ( f ). That is, SR i =
冉 冊 k1 k2
4
⭈
W (2k 1 sin i , 0) W (2k 2 sin i , 0)
(3.12)
where, as noted earlier, W is the two-dimensional surface roughness spectrum. It is possible to assume for simplicity that
冉 冊
4
SK i = SR i ⭈
k2 ; ⌳ 1, i = 2k 1 ⭈ sin i ; ⌳ 2, i = 2k 2 ⭈ sin i k1
(3.13)
144
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
The model of surface roughness spatial spectrum determines the further estimation of the statistical characteristics. Most often, surfaces with a Gaussian surface height distribution and any surface autocorrelation function are used. For surfaces with this height distribution and a Gaussian autocorrelation function, analytical expressions are available for cross checking. In addition, many surface scattering theories have been reported in the literature using the assumption of Gaussian height distribution, although the roughness spectrum of naturally occurring surfaces generally has more high frequency components than the Gaussian. For a Gaussian surface, the autocorrelation function is
⁄
2
( ) = h ⭈ exp (− 2 l 2 )
(3.14)
and the spatial power spectrum of roughness is W (⌳) =
2 h l 2
冋 冉 冊册
⌳l exp − 2
2
(3.15)
Here l is the spatial correlation radius, ⌳ is the spatial wavenumber. The exponential autocorrelation function of the surface is also used
冉 | |冊
2
( ) = h exp −
l
(3.16)
with a spatial power spectrum 2
⁄
W (⌳) = 4 h l 2 (1 + ⌳2l 2 )
(3.17)
The rapidly increasing number of applications of fractal models and fractal geometry in physics deserves close attention in studies of various areas, and particularly in remote sensing of land. It was first demonstrated by M. Berry [13] that for Gaussian statistics the surfaces with a simple power spectrum of the type W 1 (⌳) = C 1 ⌳−␣,
1<␣<3
(3.18)
are fractal rough surfaces. We note that the spectrum W is defined for any real ⌳, and therefore, the corresponding surface has no characteristic scales and the rms height is not defined ( h → ∞). For the values of the spectral exponent ␣ given by (3.18), the Fourier transform of W is a divergent integral; thus, the correlation function does not exist.
145
3.1 Estimation of Soil Parameters
The second surface type has the same expression for the roughness spectra but with an outer (or large scale) cutoff ⌳0 W 2 (⌳) =
再
C ⌳−␣
for ⌳ ≥ ⌳0
0
for ⌳ ≤ ⌳0
(3.19)
In view of the experimental data, type II surfaces appear to be of particular importance in the practice of remote sensing (here the usual case is ␣ = 2). We should like to note that for large ⌳ the spectra (3.17) and (3.18) are identical, but type II spectra have finite rms height h and infinite rms slope. For a Gaussian surface autocorrelation function, we find the correlation radius estimate as ˆl g =
√4 ln (SK i ) ⁄ 冠⌳2, i − ⌳1, i 冡 2
2
(3.20)
For surfaces with an exponential correlation function, the estimate of the correlation radius can be easily obtained as ˆl e = 冋(SK i − 1)
⁄ 冠⌳2,2 i − SK i ⌳1,2 i 冡册1/2
(3.21)
The estimate of the fractal spectrum exponent is
⁄
␣ˆ = ln (SK i ) ln (⌳2, i /⌳1, i )
(3.22)
The constant C is linked with h by the expression
⁄
h = 冠√C ⭈ ⌳1o − ␣ /2 冡 [a ⭈ sin ( /␣ )]
(3.23)
The value of ⌳0 is not greater than 2 when ␣ = (1–3⌳); for ␣ = 2, the value of C = h . Therefore, it is obvious that in the multichannel approach, we can obtain only one surface characteristic from the radar measurements: its correlation radius or the fractal spectrum exponent. 3.1.3 Efficiency of Multichannel Methods
The efficiency of considered multichannel approaches was investigated on the basis of the experimental results obtained in [3, 14]. As an example, the first surface
146
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
type is asphalt, for which the small perturbation method can be applied without limitations. The angular dependences of the normalized RCS for asphalt are obtained in [14] at frequencies of 8.6 GHz, 17.0 GHz, and 35.6 GHz for two polarizations (horizontal and vertical) and for the incidence angle region of 20–80°. Before analysis of asphalt dielectric and statistical characteristics, it is worth noting that the corresponding values are presented in some references (e.g., in [15, 16]). At frequencies of 10 GHz and 35 GHz, the averaged dielectric constants of asphalt are ⑀ a = 4.3 ± 0.5 and 2.5 ± 0.3, respectively. The surface roughness correlation radius and rms height are l = 0.22 cm and h = 0.04 cm. The derivation of the dielectric function D for the small perturbation model shows that, for asphalt, its frequency dependence should be taken into consideration. The difference between dielectric functions for frequencies of 10 GHz and 35 GHz is approximately 2–4 dB for incidence angle variation from 20° to 60°. That is why the use of (3.10) for asphalt statistical characteristics estimation at frequencies of 17 GHz and 35.6 GHz is impossible, as (3.11) is not valid for these frequencies. The dielectric constant of asphalt was estimated using the polarization ratio R 5 that is a monotonic function of ⑀ a . The averaged values obtained for all three frequencies are given in Table 3.1. These results match well with other reference data, and they confirm the practical applicability of polarization ratio R 5 for dielectric constant estimation. Using (3.10), estimation of asphalt surface roughness correlation radius and fractal spectrum exponent was performed. In this case (3.10) is a function only of l and ␣ . The data for every frequency and polarization were considered statistically independent. The estimates of surface parameters obtained for different channels and polarizations as well as their averages are presented in Table 3.2. It is seen from Table 3.2 that from the point of view of statistical reliability, the averaged estimate of the fractal spectra exponent is the best in comparison to similar estimates of correlation radius. Its confidence interval is approximately Table 3.1 Averaged Values of ⑀ a f (GHz) ⑀a
8.6 3.56 ± 1.22
17 3.34 ± 0.38
35.6 1.77 ± 0.51
Table 3.2 Estimates of Asphalt Surface Roughness Correlation Radius, Height rms Values, and Fractal Spectra Exponent f (GHz) 8.6 17.0 35.6 Averaged values
l g (cm) 0.71 0.41 0.20
l ex (cm) 0.69 0.50 0.26
hg (cm) 0.12 0.23 0.20
hex (cm) 0.14 0.25 0.21
0.44 ± 0.2
0.48 ± 0.24
0.20 ± 0.05
0.20 ± 0.05
␣ 1.34 1.66 1.61
C (cm) 0.107 0.111 0.093
1.39 ± 0.16 0.103 ± 0.008
147
3.1 Estimation of Soil Parameters
20% in respect to ␣ , while the range of respective confidence intervals for estimates of l is in the limit 50%. Estimates of the last unknown parameter h (or C ) were formed using (3.1) 0 by means of minimizing the difference between experimental data of pp and 0 theoretically derived approximate values of ˆ pp . Because the amplitude of fluctuations depends on (␣ − C ) value, it is easier to analyze not C but the value C , taking into account that C = C /M 4 − ␣ [m] (i.e., expressed in meters as well as h ). The estimates obtained for different frequencies are shown in Table 3.2. As seen from Table 3.2, the estimate of C is the best from the point of view of its statistical reliability. Its confidence interval is less than 5% with respect to its average value, while the analogous intervals for h lie in the limits 20%–30% of the estimates for Gaussian and exponential surfaces. As illustration of fractal approximation possibilities, Table 3.3 shows the derived values for the surface roughness spectra W (⌳i ) obtained using C estimates at different frequencies (here ⌳i = k 1 , k 2 , k 3 and i = 30°). These generalized data for all frequencies with application to average values of asphalt dielectric and statistical characteristics show that the Gaussian approximation is not appropriate. It is illustrated well by Figure 3.3, where the experimentally obtained data at 35.6 GHz for horizontal and vertical polarizations and the theoretical curves for Gaussian surface are compared. Figure 3.4 represents the angular dependence of 0 of asphalt at 35.6 GHz and model representations for exponential and fractal surfaces. The absolute average discrepancies of these curves from obtained values are 1.15 and 1.3 dB for exponential and fractal surfaces, respectively. In practice, the two approximations are equally valid. Analogous estimates of asphalt dielectric constant and its surface statistical characteristics were obtained for 8.6 GHz and 17 GHz. They coincide well with l and ␣ estimates obtained earlier, on the basis of which the dielectric constant estimates for asphalt were derived. Because for practical purposes we were interested in applicability of fractal spectra for description of surface roughness, this approximation is a subject of further consideration. The asphalt dielectric constant values obtained at 8.6 GHz and 17 GHz (␣ = 1.38) were equal to 3 ± 1.9 and 4.5 ± 2.0, respectively. The confidence intervals of these estimates were rather wide but they overlapped. This could result from the accuracy of measurements and the validity of assumption (3.10) for asphalt at these frequencies. It is worth noting Table 3.3 The Spectral Density of Asphalt Roughness (in Decibels) at Frequencies f 1 = 8.6, f 2 = 17.0, and f 3 = 35.6 GHz for i = 30° f (GHz) 8.6 17.0 35.6
W (k 1 ) −97.8 −97.4 −99.4
W (k 2 ) −101.9 −101.5 −101.0
W (k 3 ) −106.4 −106.0 −105.5
148
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
Figure 3.3 Angular dependence of 0 for VV and HH polarizations and their comparison with Gaussian models. (Solid and dotted curves are derived from models; signs are the experimental data.)
the very close values obtained for the latter model parameter C ( C ). We got C = 0.146 cm and 0.148 cm for 8.6 GHz and 17 GHz, respectively. The second type surface is a bare field. The experimental angular dependence of the normalized RCS for this field obtained at 4.7 GHz for two polarizations is presented in [3]. The soil is characterized by its high clay content (about 40%). The measurements have been carried out for dry soil (gravimetric moisture 4.3%) and for wet soil with gravimetric moisture (about 30.2%). The high clay content results in a temporally invariant rms surface roughness of about 2.5 cm. The estimates of exponent ␣ were formed from data of 0 using (3.22) and the regression analysis method, where the second frequency was 8.6 GHz. The | ⑀ | and ␣ data for dry and wet soils are shown in Table 3.4. The ␣ values for dry soil are practically identical for both polarizations, and they differ significantly for wet soil. Using C estimations, we derived the values of surface roughness spectral density, also presented in Table 3.4. The comparison of W (k ) for soil with W (k ) for asphalt at 17.0 GHz shows that the roughness influence on the normalized RCS of a field is greater than that for asphalt by 15–20 dB (see data in Table 3.3). The application of Gaussian and exponential models for the autocorrelation function permits us to estimate the correlation radius of field roughness. The surface roughness for this field does not satisfy the small perturbation model. In these conditions, the derived values of l are approximately 1 cm and do not correspond
3.1 Estimation of Soil Parameters
149
Figure 3.4 Angular dependences of 0 for VV and HH polarizations and their comparison with (a) exponential and (b) fractal models.
150
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods Table 3.4 The Values of | ⑀ |, ␣ , and W (k 1 ) for Dry and Wet Soil Polarization Gravimetric volume, % |⑀ | ␣ W (k 1 ) (dB)
HH 4.3 3 0.8–1.1 −(76.7–78.5)
HH 30.2 35 0.8–1.1 −(76.7–78.5)
VV 4.3 3 1.0–1.3 −(79.8–80.5)
VV 30.2 35 2.3–2.5 −(87.4–88.1)
to real values of l for agricultural fields. At the same time, the fractal approximation of surface spectra seems to be more suitable because the spectral exponent is in a good agreement with the value range (␣ = 1–3). Thus, the application of multichannel methods permits us to obtain the soil dielectric constant and, consequently, the soil moisture and the soil statistical characteristics using the fractal model for the surface spectra—even for rough surfaces when the limitations of the small perturbation model are inapplicable.
3.2 Soil Erosion Experimental Determination 3.2.1 Set and Technique of Measurement
One of the purposes of multichannel methods of remote determination of soil parameters is estimation of the degree of erosion, because this determines the soil fertility. The erosion influences the radar characteristics of the soil, and, consequently, one can find the correlation between the scattered signal and the soil statistical characteristics. An experimental study of the multichannel method of soil characteristics estimation has been carried out [17]. The agricultural field was located on a hill, and its different areas had average slopes between 2° and 8°. The cultivation performed 3 weeks earlier across the slope included plowing, disking, and harrowing. The soil type was chernozem (black soil) with four stages of soil erosion. Visual inspection indicated that the periodic row structure was almost destroyed by many rainfalls. A dual-frequency CW radar was used for experimental investigation with characteristics as shown in Table 3.5. The radar system included two radars with antennas placed on a common platform, the antennas receiving backscattered signals from the same area of surface. A peculiarity of this radar was the possibility of signal radiation with any linear polarization and simultaneous reception of two orthogonal components of the scattered signal. Radar measurements were followed by simultaneous in situ measurements of soil characteristics, including obtaining the surface profiles along and across the direction of cultivation, the moisture of the near-surface soil layer (from 2 cm to 5 cm in depth), and the agrophysical characteristics of the soil. Determination of the normalized RCS was made using the method of comparison with the RCS of a corner reflector for calibration. The latter was installed at
151
3.2 Soil Erosion Experimental Determination Table 3.5 The Main Characteristics of the Radar Wavelength (cm) Modulation Transmitted power (mW) Sensitivity (dBW) Antenna pattern width (degree) Polarization —Radiation —Reception Polarization isolation (dB) Maximal bandwidth of receiver (kHz)
3.2 CW 50.0 −165 10.0
0.8 CW 50.0 −155 10.0
H or V Two orthogonal components 35 2.0
H or V Two orthogonal components 30 2.0
a height of 3m over the land, providing a negligible influence of background surface clutter on the calibration accuracy. The main radar characteristics were the normalized RCS dependence on the incidence angles for two polarizations (horizontal and vertical) and for two wavelengths (3 cm and 0.8 cm), (i.e., four angular dependences—for copolarized and cross-polarized components of the scattered signal—for every polarization of the radiated signal). The measurements were carried out for an incidence angular interval 35°–70° with step of 5°. For the normalized RCS estimates, the averaging of angular dependence for several azimuthally spaced angles was used. This resulted in decreasing of the normalized RCS fluctuations to 1.0–1.5 dB. 3.2.2 Statistical and Agrophysical Characteristics of Fields
The erosion state of the soil areas was determined by the average-weighted diameter of water-stable aggregates and by the aggregation coefficient Ka [18]. This depends on the quantity and quality of humus, granulometer, and mineral content of the soil and characterizes the genetic particularity of the soil. The moisture and aggregate content characteristics are shown in Table 3.6. As seen from Table 3.6, the agrophysical characteristics of the soil in areas 1–3 are rather similar, and the most different properties are observed for area 4. The moisture measurements at the reference points were carried out by the thermostat-weight technique and showed that the moisture for the near-surface layer of the soil was rather homogeneous for all areas and the gravimetric soil moisture was near the field capacity. This was caused by weak soil drying because
Table 3.6 Weighted Soil Moisture and Aggregate Content Characteristics Terrain area Erosion degree Soil moisture (%) d (mm) Ka
1 Noneroded 16.2 0.85 0.57
2 Weakly eroded 12.9 0.46 0.39
3 Middle eroded 17.0 0.38 0.37
4 Heavy eroded 11.8 0.25 0.23
152
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
of the low air temperature (it was about 5°–6° ). Only the moisture in area 3 was higher than for the other areas because it was obtained for the day after a rain. For this reason, it was possible to neglect the moisture influence on the normalized RCS for different areas of soil. The surface roughness was measured with a profile meter with density of 1 measurement per 10 mm, which ensured errors not greater than 5 mm. The common length of every surface profile was 6–7.5m. The profile processing included the obtaining of autocorrelation functions and spatial spectra along and across the directions of cultivation. The method of cultivation can result in a significantly different degree of roughness for the same agricultural region. It is worth noting that for fields with a periodic structure, the rms surface height depends greatly on the profile orientation in respect to the plowing furrows. However, for fresh-plowed fields, the periodicity is often significantly distorted by presence of clods. The small and rather large clods appearing for breast plowing are oriented randomly. Their dimensions depend on the moisture and the soil type. In general, the surface normalized autocorrelation function can be approximated by
( ) = exp (−␥ ⭈ ) ⭈ cos (2 / )
(3.24)
where is the spatial coordinate. No statistical dependence between parameters ␥ and  was detected. A more general approximation can be used for dual-scale roughness (the typical cases are the plowed and harrowed fields), taking into account the peculiarities of the cultivation. For this case
( ) = (1 − A ) ⭈ exp (−␥ ) ⭈ cos (2 /L p ) + A ⭈ exp (− ) ⭈ cos (2 /L h ) (3.25) where the coefficient A is determined by the ratio of harrowing to plowing depths, L p denotes the distance between the furrows of plowing, and L h defines the distance between the furrows of harrowing. The observations show that the dynamics of change of field roughness (if the fields are not subjected to additional tillage) are fully determined by the atmosphere humidity conditions—the aggregate and mechanical soil contents. Initially, the roughness smoothing caused by rainfall can result in an increase of periodicity because the process of furrow destruction is more prolonged in comparison to the process of clod destruction. Table 3.7 shows the approximate range of h variations for different types of cultivation (the measurements were performed for along and across directions). It is worth noting that the percent content of clay in the soil is a basic factor determining the degree of field roughness after natural furrow and clod destruction. The mechanical and aggregate soil contents are subjected to slow permanent change
153
3.2 Soil Erosion Experimental Determination Table 3.7 Roughness rms Values h (cm) for Some Fields Measurements Along direction of cultivation Across direction of cultivation
Fresh Plowed >4–5 3–4
Plowed and Washed Off 3–5 2–3.5
Harrowed 1.5–3 1–2
Harrowed and Rolled <1.5 <1.5
and, as the result, to erosion. The field slope of about 5°–10° is the reason for the formation of heavily and medium-eroded areas. The mechanical and hydrophysical properties of such soils differ from those of noneroded soils. Therefore, we expect that in the borders of the same terrain, different degrees of erosion can be found as the result of the same cultivation. For such fields, successful separation of roughness and moisture effects and their accurate estimation offers the ability to retrieve information about the erosion process and its evolution. Figure 3.5 presents the correlation functions of roughness across the direction of cultivation just after plowing (curve 1) and 20 days later (curve 2) when the field became smoothed and rolled. The process of furrow destruction manifests itself in the removal of the periodic structure of the autocorrelation function. The autocorrelation functions of surface roughness along the direction of cultivation hardly differ from the autocorrelation functions of isotropic surfaces. Examples of spatial spectra for investigated land areas are shown in Figure 3.6. The spectra were obtained using the standard fast Fourier transform (FFT) and the maximum entropy methods (Berg’s algorithm). It is seen from Figure 3.6(a)
Figure 3.5 The spatial autocorrelation functions of plowed field (1) right after plowing and (2) 20 days after plowing.
154
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
Figure 3.6 The spatial spectra of investigated land lot obtained by (a) FFT and (b) maximal entropy method.
that harrowing leads to a second maximum appearing in the soil spatial spectrum, while the maximal entropy method smoothes this maximum. The rms values of surface roughness h for the cross direction are greater than for along furrow direction. In the spatial spectra, the second maximum appeared rather often; it is
155
3.2 Soil Erosion Experimental Determination
connected with the cultivation type. However, in our measurements, it is not observed due to washing off of the soil. For determination of roughness characteristics, the fractal approximation of spatial spectra was used. The average values of h and fractal exponent ␣ are shown in Table 3.8. The averaged exponent in the experimental spectra was equal to ␣ = 1.61 ± 0.89. For profiles with a strongly marked periodic row structure, the average value of ␣ of the fractal spectra does not change significantly; its values are ␣ = 1.64 ± 1.02. The data analysis showed that the value of h along the direction of cultivation did not practically depend on the degree of soil erosion, but we observed a decrease of h with an increase of erosion degree across the direction of cultivation. At the same time, a decrease of ␣ was observed along the direction of cultivation when the erosion degree increased. This shows an increase of the spatial correlation radius for noneroded soils in comparison to eroded ones. 3.2.3 On-Land Radar Measurement Results
The results of the angular normalized RCS dependence study have shown the following [6, 19, 20]: •
•
•
The normalized RCS for an 8-mm wavelength is greater by 3–6 dB than for a 3-cm wavelength for all selected surface areas and for both polarizations with reception of copolarized components. The normalized RCS values for vertical polarization exceed those for horizontal polarization by 0.2–8 dB, depending upon the degree of surface erosion. The speed of the angular RCS variations depends on the degree of erosion.
The longitudinal furrow structure of the field is a dominating factor in forming the scattered signal for horizontal polarization. The washing off of roughness for heavily eroded lots results in decreasing RCS in comparison with noneroded regions. At the same time, for vertical polarization, the RCS values for strongly eroded lots are greater than for noneroded ones. This is probably explained by the different degree of cross-furrow microstructure destruction, which is larger for strongly eroded soil. For example, Figure 3.7 shows the angular dependence of normalized
Table 3.8 Roughness Characteristics of Investigated Lots Erosion Degree Along furrows h (cm) ␣ Across furrows h (cm) ␣
Noneroded 1.7 1.8 2.1 1.9
Weakly Eroded 1.54 1.6 2.45 1.75
Middle Eroded 1.46 1.35 1.9 1.85
Heavy Eroded 1.28 1.3 1.8 1.7
156
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
Figure 3.7 Specific RCS vs incidence angle for areas with different erosion degree at 0.8 cm for (a) vertical and (b) horizontal polarizations; curve 1 is obtained for noneroded areas, the curve 2 for weakly and middle-eroded areas, the curve 3 for heavily eroded areas.
157
3.2 Soil Erosion Experimental Determination
RCS for areas 3 (middle eroded) and 4 (heavily eroded) obtained at 3 cm and 0.8 cm for horizontal polarization. The mean rate of angular variation of the normalized RCS is approximately 0.4–0.5 dB/degree for area 3 and about 0.2–0.3 dB/degree for area 4. This angular dependence can be understood because the exponent of the surface roughness fractal spectrum decreases with increasing degree of erosion, as seen from Table 3.8. Dual-channel polarization processing (using ratio R 5 ) has permitted us to emphasize its sensitivity to variations of soil agrophysical parameters. This is seen 0 0 from Table 3.9 where the polarization ratios HH / VV are shown averaged for all regions of incidence angles. The maximal value of this ratio at 3 cm is −6.6 dB for heavy eroded areas and 7.7 dB for non-eroded areas. Good correlation between the ratio R 5 and the agrophysical parameters of soil are observed. For incidence angles = 35°–45°, the maximum sensitivity of R 5 to agrophysical parameter variations is observed at 3 cm, but at 0.8 cm the maximum sensitivity is observed for the incidence angles greater than 60°. The angular dependence of the normalized RCS ratios for cross-polarized reception seems to have no correlation with soil erosion degree. The depolarization increases with wavelength decrease from −(10–13) dB for 3 cm to −(5–8) dB for 8 mm, and correlation of these values with erosion degree is not observed. In Figure 3.8, this dependency is shown for 3 cm and 0.8 cm and for the horizontal polarization. 3.2.4 Aircraft Remote Sensing
Sections 3.2 and 3.3 give the radiophysical model an experimental basis for determination of bare soil erosion from multichannel remote sensing data. According to this approach, one needs to have available a few radar images of the same terrain area (bare soil region) formed for VV and HH polarizations of transmitted and received sensing signals in the microwave band. But the availability of such images is not the only prerequisite for successfully measuring soil erosion using multichannel radar remote sensing data. There are also some normalized requirements on the imaging systems used, along with the algorithms of multichannel data processing. First, radar remote sensing systems should provide appropriate spatial resolution in order to be sensitive to local variations of normalized radar cross sections in the terrain region of interest. The desirable resolution is about 20 × 20 m2 or better, and this can be provided by either SLAR or SAR systems.
Table 3.9 The Ratio R 5 of Investigated Areas at 0.8 cm and 3 cm Erosion Degree 0 HH 0.8 cm (dB) 0 3 cm VV
Noneroded
Weakly Eroded
Middle Eroded
Heavy Eroded
11.4
6.0
3.4
−4.5
7.7
0.2
−3.1
−6.6
158
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
Figure 3.8 The ratios 0HV / 0HH versus the incidence angle at (a) 3 cm and (b) 0.8 cm (curves 1–3 are labeled as in Figure 3.7).
Second, RCS estimates for each pixel obtained from the observed radar images should be sufficiently accurate. This means that the imaging systems have to be properly calibrated [21], and it is also desirable to use either images with low levels of noise or to properly smooth them. At the same time, the presence of multiplicative noise is inherent in radar images, and this noise, also referred as speckle, is especially intense in images formed by SARs. Therefore, multichannel images are to be
3.3 Methods of Multichannel Radar Image Processing
159
processed in such a manner that the multiplicative noise is effectively suppressed, while the edges and fine details corresponding to local variations of RCS (and, respectively, different degree of soil erosion) are well preserved. Finally, the component images of multichannel remote sensing data should be properly registered (i.e., represented in a common spatial coordinate system with correspondence of the multichannel image cell to the element of the sensed terrain). In practice, the resolutions of different radars used for remote sensing are various, the linear resolution depending on range for all radars. Besides, the sensed terrain strips are sometimes obtained by radar during different flights of the radar platform, and, certainly, the images do not fully coincide. For example, we obtained 8-mm images from two approximately opposite directions of platform trajectory for radar operation with different polarizations while we were conducting the experiment. Terrain relief and Earth’s surface curvature are additional sources of geometric distortions of the radar image in multichannel systems for remote sensing. The images were obtained simultaneously by two radar systems at 10 GHz and 35 GHz installed onboard an IL-18D (Russian) aircraft [22]. The spatial resolution of the Ka-band SLAR was about 20 × 20 m2; for the X-band SLAR, it was approximately 30 × 30 m2; the average altitude was about 7,000m; and the agricultural field under investigation was observed at an incidence angle about 50°. The field dimensions were 1.2 × 1.2 km2, and the field occupied about 50 × 50 pixels.
3.3 Methods of Multichannel Radar Image Processing 3.3.1 Image Superimposing
The radar images are to be superimposed, using both linear and nonlinear techniques. For a case when we deal with analyzed terrain areas having relatively small sizes, it is possible to use the linear aphine transformation; otherwise, it becomes reasonable to apply a preliminary geometrical correction of images and then more complicated methods of nonlinear transformations of data arrays. In practice, several factors obstruct getting the image-to-topology map and image-to-image registration without errors. These factors are the fluctuations of the imaging system platform trajectory (for airborne systems), the curvature of the sensed terrain relief, and the nonlinear relationship between slant and ground range. So the task of accurate registration, transformation, and interpolation of multichannel remote sensing data is also important because these registration errors can result in errors in further interpretation for soil erosion determination, especially in the neighborhood of edges and details [23]. The procedure for image-to-image and image-to-topology map superimposing include the following stages:
160
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
1. Selection of common reference points in all images. This operation is performed by qualified experts using the corners of agricultural fields, or in more general cases any bright quasi-point objects (e.g., bridges, buildings, or highway crossroads) easily recognizable in all images can be selected as reference points and found interactively. Contour (edge) features of images can be used for reference point selection as well; sometimes image preliminary filtering is expedient. 2. Derivation of coefficients describing the aphine transform of the superimposed image to the coordinate system of the reference image or topology map. Being represented in a matrix form this aphine transform is [8] F=A⭈H+D where operator D =
(3.26)
再 冎 再 冎 再 冎 再 冎 Dx Dy
image H and matrix A =
denotes the transformation of superimposed
A 11 A 12
defines the scaling and rotation operaA 21 A 22 tions to be done over the same image H. Denoting the reference point F xi G xi coordinates as F xyi = and G xyi = , i = 1, 2, . . . , l for the F yi G yi superimposed and reference images (maps), respectively, the superimposing integral errors are determined by horizontal and vertical components ␦ h and ␦ v l
␦h = ␦v =
∑ (F xi − A 11 G xi − A 12 G yi − D x )2
(3.27)
i =1 l
∑ (F yi − A 21 G xi − A 22 G yi − D y )2
i =1
Equation (3.27) produces an equation system that can be uniquely solved with respect to A and D parameters for l = 3. But for l ≥ 4 (the greater l is, the higher the accuracy of superimposing), some optimization procedure should be applied; obviously, the requirement of total square mean error minimization is typical and reasonable. This leads to a solution of the equation system obtained after calculation of partial derivatives on matrix transform coefficients. These operations are rather easy; at the first stage, the matrix D parameters are estimated, and then the matrix A coefficients have to be derived. We also analyze the problem of how many reference points it is reasonable to select and what their optimal spatial locations are.
3.3 Methods of Multichannel Radar Image Processing
161
Usually the selection of 7–12 reference points forming an equilateral polygon is applicable to many practical situations. They should be placed as sparsely as possible in the sense of maximal total distance between them. This conclusion is quite trivial [24] and intuitively understandable. 3. Interpolation of superimposed image H to the coordinate grid nodes of the reference image G. The necessity of this operation is explained by the fact that both images are sampled, and after spatial transformation the majority of grid nodes for images do not coincide. Several methods can be used for transformed image interpolation after superimposition: nearest neighbor, bilinear, and bicubic [25]. The first method happened to be more expedient because it resulted in minimal dynamic errors in the neighborhood of edges and fine details. Besides, this method is very simple and requires minimal computational efforts. Bilinear and bicubic interpolation methods provide better visual perception but are more complicated. Because of these advantages, the first technique was applied in data processing. It is based on substitution by the nearest sample value or on linear (or median) approximation taking into account the four nearest neighbor pixel values, and it provides appropriate interpolation accuracy. The errors and distortions caused by interpolation are usually smaller than multiplicative noise existing in real images. Completing the discussion on image superimposing, it is worth mentioning that the errors of this operation can exceed one or two pixels; therefore, it is desirable to decrease them if possible during further stages of data processing. Let us demonstrate these effects for real multichannel radar remote sensing data. The airborne SLAR image of an agricultural region in the Ukraine is shown in Figure 3.9 ( = 8 mm, HH polarization). The multiplicative noise is not very intensive, its relative variance 2 ≈ 0.005. The SLAR image of the same region for VV polarization is shown in Figure 3.10. The multiplicative noise in this image has the same relative variance 2 ≈ 0.005. The general appearance of this image is in a sense similar to Figure 3.9 (because the same terrain region is sensed) and in another sense different, as Figure 3.10 is formed for another polarization. Just this simultaneous similarity and difference between component images of multichannel remote sensing data are exploited for retrieval of useful information from them and separation of factors affecting the RCS for different wavelengths and polarizations. Figure 3.11 shows the airborne SLAR image formed by another radar ( = 3 cm, HH polarization). The multiplicative noise in this image is more intensive ( 2 ≈ 0.011), although it is still Gaussian with a unity mean, as with both 8-mm images considered earlier. This image is also similar to those ones shown in Figures 3.9 and 3.10, but a small difference of resolution cell size between the images is seen.
162
Estimation of Land Parameters by Multichannel Radar Methods
Figure 3.9 Radar image of agricultural