Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYS IOLO GY
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY edited by
...
5 downloads
338 Views
22MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYS IOLO GY
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MICROBIAL PHYSIOLOGY edited by
A. H. ROSE School of Biological Sciences Bath University England
D. W. TEMPEST Laboratorium voor Microbiologie Universiteit van Amsterdam Amterdam-C Th-eNetherlands
Volume 15
1977
ACADEMIC PRESS London New York San Francisco A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jouanouich, Publishers
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road London NWI United States Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 Fifth Avenue New York, New York 10003
Copyright 0 1 9 7 7 by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD.
All Rights Reserved N o part of this book may be reproduced in any form by photostat, microfilm, or any
other means, without written permission from the publishers
Library ofCongress Catalog Card Number: 67-19850 ISBN: 0-12-027 7 15-8
Printed in Great Britain by William Clowes and Sons Limited London, Colchester and Beccles
Contributors to Volume 15 D. E. ATKINSON, Molecular Institute and Biochemistry Division, Department of Chemistty, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90024, U.S.A. A. T . BULL, Biological Laboratory, University ofKent, Canterbury C T 2 7NJ, England. (Present address :Department of Applied Biology, University of Wales Institute ofStience and Technology, C a r d g CFI 3 N U , Wales) A. G. CHAPMAN, Molecular Biology Institute and Biochemistry Division, Department of Chemistry, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90024, U.S.A. M. CRANDALL, School of Biological Sciences, University of Kentucky, Lexington, Kentucky 40506, U.S.A. I . E. D. DUNDAS, Institutt for Generell Mikrobiologi, Universitetet i Bergen, Bergen, Nonuay R. EGEL, Institut fur Biologie 111 der Universitat Freiburg, 0 - 7 8 0 0 Freiburg, Schanzlestrasse +I I ,Federal Republic of Germuny C. G. ELLIOTT, Botany Department, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, Scotland W. N. KONINGS, De artment ofMicrobiology, Biolo ‘cal Centre, University of Groningen, Kerk Lan 30, Haren, The Netherla s V. L. MACKAY, Waksman Institute of Microbiology, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NewJersey 08903, U.S.A. A. P. J . TRINCI, Department of Microbiology, Queen Elizabeth College, University of London, London W8 7 A H England
2
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents The Physiology and Metabolic Control of Fungal Growth
. .
. . .
A T BULL and A P J TRlNCl
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .‘ I1. Mathematical Modelling of Fungal Growth . . . . . . . . . A. WhyModel? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Approaches to Modelling . . . . . . . . . . . . C. The Applicability of Classic Models to Fungal Growth . . . . . I11. Growth of Undifferentiated Mycelia . . . . . . . . . . . A. Regulation of Mycelial Form . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Polarization of Hyphal Growth . . . . . . . . . . . C . Regulation of Branch Initiation . . . . . . . . . . . D. Hyphal Growth Units of Different Strains and Species . . . . . E. Effect of Environment on Hyphal Growth Unit Length . . . . F. RegulationoftheSpacialDistributionofHyphae . . . . . . IV. Colony Growth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Colony Differentiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Mould-Induced Changes in the Substrate . . . . . . . . C. Kinetics of Colony Expansion on Solid Media . . . . . . . D. Colony Expansion as a Parameter of Mould Growth . . . . . E. Comparison of the Colonization of Solid Substrates by Moulds and Unicellular Micro-organisms . . . . . . . . . . V . Fungal Growth in Submerged Liquid Culture.Technical Considerations VI . Kinetics of Fungal Growth in Submerged Liquid Culture . . . . . A. RatesofGrowth . . ,. . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Transient States and Oscillatory Phenomena . . . . . . . C. “Macroregulation” of Growth . . . . . . . . . . . D . Maintained and Starved States . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Transport Controlled Features of Growth . . . . . . . . . A . Transport-Limited Growth . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Transport Regulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Modulation of Fungal Transport Processes . . . . . . . . VIII . Metabolic Control in Fungi . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Intermediary Metabolism . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Anaplerotic Metabolism . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Aspects ofTermina1 Oxidation . . . . . . . . . . . IX. RNA Synthesis and Function: Rate-Limiting Parameters of Growth . . A . Efficiency of Protein Synthesis . . . . . . . . . . . B . Concerning Polyamines . . . . . . . . . . . . . X. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii
2 3 3 4 7 13 14 14 15 19 20 23 23 23 21 29 33
35 36 40 40 43 46 41 48 48 50 53 51 57 62 61 71 12 14 16 16
viii
CONTENTS
Physiology of Halobacteriaceae
. . .
1 E D DUNDAS
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Classification of Extreme Halophiles . . . . . . . . . . I11. Intracellular and Extracellular Salt Concentrations . . . . . . A. Intracellular Salts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Extracellular Salts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Subcellular Structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Cell Envelopes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Ribosomes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Vacuoles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Flagella . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Halophilic Proteins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Metabolic Pathways . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Halophilic Enzymes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Lipids in Halobacteriaceae . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Electron-Transport Chain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Transport Across Membranes . . . . . . . . . . . . IX. Effects of Light . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Photophosphorylation . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Effect on Growth and Viability . . . . . . . . . . . X. Nucleic Acids and Their Enzymology . . . . . . . . . . XI . Phage-Host Relationships . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI1. Ecological Considerations on the Existence of Obligate Extreme Halophilism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI11. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
85 86 88 88 90 91 91 94 96 99 100 101 102 104 106 107 109 109 110 111 113 114 116 116
Sterols in Fungi: Their Functions in Growth and Reproduction CHARLES G . ELLIOT I. I1. I11. IV. V.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Functions of Sterols: Possible Approaches to the Problems . . . . Sterols in Model Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Subcellular Distribution of Sterols in Fungi. and States of Binding . . Effects of Sterols on Metabolism and Vegetative Growth . . . . . A. e t h i u m and Phytophthora . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Saccharomyces and Other Fungi . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Effects of Sterols on Asexual Reproduction . . . . . . . . . VII . Sexual Hormones of Achlya . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Effects of Sterols on Sexual Reproduction in Homothallic Species of Pythium and Phytophthora . . . . . . . . . . . . .
121 123 130 135 141 141 144 148 149 152
CONTENTS
ix
IX. Reproduction in Heterothallic Species of Pythium and Phytophthm
. . . . . .
X. Sterols and Sexual Reproduction in Ascomycetes and Basidiomycetes XI . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI1. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
156 162 165 166 166
Active Transport of Solutes in Bacterial Membrane Vesicles
.
WIL N KONINGS
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Membrane Vesicles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Isolation Procedures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Physical Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Purity of Membrane Preparations . . . . . . . . . D. Functional Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Orientation of the Vesicle Membrane . . . . . . . . . F. Localization of D-Lactate Dehydrogenase in Membrane Vesicles from Escherichiu coli . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Active Transport Coupled to Electron Transfer Systems . . . . . . A . Coupling to Respiratory Chain . . . . . . . . . . . B . Couplingto AnaerobicElectronTransfer Systems . . . . . . C . Coupling toCyclic ElectronTransferSystems . . . . . . . IV. Energy Coupling to Active Transport . . . . . . . . . . . A. Role ofAdenosine 5'-Triphosphate and the ATPase Complex . . . B . Mechanism of Energy Coupling . . . . . . . . . . . C. Energy-Dependent Binding of Solute to Carrier Proteins . . . . V. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
175 177 177 180 183 184 194 200 203 203 217 223 225 225 228 239 243 244 244
Adenine Nucleotide Concentrations and Turnover Rates. Their Correlation with Biological Activity in Bacteria and Yeast
.
.
ASTRID G CHAPMAN and DANIEL E ATKINSON
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Concentrations and Fluxes ofAdenine Nucleotides in uiuo . . . . . A. Adenine Nucleotide Turnover . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Turnover ofATP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. RegulationofATP Utilizationand Regeneration . . . . . . . D . Sampling of Microbial Cultures for Adenine Nucleotide Determinations E. Changes inAdenineNucleotide Concentrations . . . . . . .
254 256 256 261 268 269 272
X
CONTENTS
I11. Concentration of ATP. Total Adenine Nucleotide Concentration. and . . . . . . . Energy Chargein Relation to Cellular Activities A . Relation between ATP Concentration and Growth Rate . . . . . B . Variations in Adenine Nucleotide Levels during Growth . . . . C. Adenine Nucleotides in Mutant Strains Arrested in Growth . . . . D . Correlation between Kinetics in vitro and Observations in vivo . . . E. Relation between Energy Charge and Total Adenine Nucleotide Concentration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Phage Infection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G . Other Nucleotides . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . H . RNASynthesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . Protein Synthesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. General Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
282 282 285 286 287 289 290 291 293 295 297 300
Physiology of Mating in Three Yeasts
.
.
MARJORIE CRANDALL RICHARD EGEL and VIVIAN L MACKAY
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . A. Ecology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . General Characteristics C . Lifecycles . . . . . . . . . . I1 . Hamenula Winget . . . . . . . . . A . Mating Type Locus . . . . . . . . B . Haploid Functions . . . . . . . . C. DiploidFunctions . . . . . . . . 111. Schizaracchmomycespobe . . . . . . . A . Mating Type Locus . . . . . . . . B . HaploidFunctions . . . . . . . . C . DiploidFunctions . . . . . . . . IV . Saccharomyces cerevisiae . . . . . . . . A . Mating Type Locus . . . . . . . . B . Haploid Functions . . . . . . . C. DiploidFunctions . . . . . . . . V. Comparative Discussion . . . . . . . A. Steps in Yeast Conjugation Compared . . B . Evolutionary Aspects of Sexual Reproduction C. Comparison with Mammalian Systems . . VI . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . Author Index . . . . . . . . . . . Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
307 309 310 310 313 313 314 327 331 331 336 347 350 350 354 377 384 384 390 391 392 392 399 419
The Physiology and Metabolic Control of Fungal Growth A. T. BULL* and A. P. J. TRlNCl Biological Laboratory, University of Kent, Canterbury CT2 7NJ, England; Department of Microbiology, Queen Elizabeth College, University of London, London W8 7AH. I. Introduction
.
.
.
.
.
11. Mathematical Modelling of Fungal Growth
.
.
. . .
.
. . .
.
. . .
.
. .
.
. . . . . .
A. Why Model? . . . . . . B. Approaches to Modelling . . . . C. The Applicability of Classic Models to Fungal Growth . 111. Growth of Undifferentiated Mycelia . . . . . A. Regulation of Mycelial Form . . . . . . B. Polarization of Hyphal Growth . . . . . . . C. Regulation of Branch Initiation . . . . . . . D. Hyphal Growth Units of Different Strains and Species . . E. Effect of Environment on Hyphal Growth Unit Length . . F. Regulation of the Spacial Distribution of H p h a e . . . 1V. Colony Growth . . . . . . . . . . . A. Colony Differentiation . . . . . . . . . B. Mould-Induced Changes in the Substrate . . . . . C. Kinetics of Colony Expansion on Solid Media . . . D. Colony Expansion as a Parameter of Mould Growth . . E. Comparison of the Colonization of Solid Substrates by Moulds and Unicellular Micro-organisms . . . . . . . V. Fungal Growth in Submerged Liquid Culture. Technical Considerations VI. Kinetics o f Fungal Growth in Submerged Liquid Culture . . A. Rates of Growth . . . . . . . . . . B. Trmisient States and Oscillatory Phenomena . . . . C. "Macroregulatioti" of Growth . . . . . . . D. Maintained arid Starved States . . . . . . . VII. Trailsport Controlled Features of Growth . . . . . A. Traiisport-Liiiiited Growth . . . . . . . . B. Transport Regulation . . . . . . . . . C. Modulatioii of Fungal Transport Processes . . . .
* Present address: Department ol'Applied Biology. Uiiivcrsity ol'W i i h Technology, Cardill; CFI 3NU 1
Illbtittitc
2 3 3 4 7 13 14 14
15 19 20 23 23 23 21 29 33
35 36 40 40 43 46 47 4X *X 50
53
ol'Scicncc i l ~ l c l
2
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
VIII. Metabolic Control in Fungi . . . . . . . * A. Intermediary Metabolism . . . . . . . B. Anaplerotic Metabolism . . . . . C. Aspects of Terminal Oxidation . . . . . . . IX. RNA Synthesis and Function: Rate-Limiting Parameters of Growth A. Efficiency of Protein Synthesis . . . . . . B. Concerning Polyamines . . . . . . . . X. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
57 57 62 67 71 12 74 76 76
I. Introduction “The modern era of mould metabolism has only scarcely begun, but signs of an immense advance in the numerous phases of the field are unmistakable. Their importance is recognized, practically and academically’’.Thus commented Jackson Foster in the introduction of his unique contribution to the study of fungal physiology and biochemistry, “Chemical Activities of Fungi” (Foster, 1949). A vast mycological literature had accumulated by the time of Foster’s original persuasion, in 1936, to prepare a critical account of fungal metabolism and, it is worth recalling, several aspects of this subject had already been established during the previous century. Pre-Foster fungal physiology had relied extensively on a classical response-to-stimulus type of approach, an approach unfortunately that generated much conflicting and confusing data. It was Foster’s conspicuous talent and understanding that brought together much of this data in an intelligible form and was instrumental in orientating subsequent researches. I t is appropriate, therefore, by way of a preface to our main discussions, to examine the current status of fungal biochemistry. We would advocate, from an admittedly biased position, that fungi unquestionably are the organisms of choice for the study of numerous aspects of microbial biochemistry: one needs only to ponder their extreme morphological diversity and plasticity, their unrivalled biosynthetic capacities, especially with respect to secondary metabolites, and their utility as model systems in the biochemical analysis of mating behaviour, differentiation, ageing and so on, to find the validity of this assertion. And yet our knowledge of fungal biochemistry remains rather fragmentary, while specific reference to investigation of growth physiology shows that the majority of work has been done with bacteria. Two important reasons for this situation can be proffered that have their bases in: (a) long-standing technical difficulties of growing mycelial fungi; and (b) lack of adequate kinetic analyses of
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
3
their mode of growth. Accordingly, we have devoted a portion of this review to the practicalities of growing filamentous fungi, and have developed at greater length mathematical treatments of mould growth and discussed the applicability of some existent models. We have singled out the growth of surface colonies for particular discussion because, despite the fact that it is a technique used by mycologists ad libitum,it has received little critical analysis; moreover, it has been the subject recently of renewed interest. Strain instability also has plagued the efforts of the fungal physiologist, and this has been an especially acute problem in relation to the Fungi Imperfecti many of which are of major interest in the context of commercial fermentations. Problems of strain selection and strain degeneration can seriously hamper prolonged continuous-flow culture experiments with moulds and care has to be taken to check biological stability under these conditions. The scope of this article is such that we have, of necessity, been selective in our choice of topics to discuss. The selection has been resolved in two ways: by taking those areas of fungal physiology and biochemistry that have been researched in depth, and by attempting to indicate areas that are as yet largely unexplored but seem to us to warrant special attention. In addition we have tried to keep as a theme running throughout the discussion, the modulation of fungal metabolism in response to growth conditions. Palpable absences from this article are references to “secondary” or “shunt” metabolism, at which fungi are most adept, and to the metabolic control of differentiation: in both of these areas, notable advances have been made in recent years (see Smith and Anderson, 1973). But one of our prime objectives in the following pages is to demonstrate to the microbial physiologist and biochemist that the fungi arguably are among the most propitious and alluring of all micro-organisms that he can select for his studies and that von Haller’s eighteenth century portrayal of them as “a mutable and treacherous tribe” is no longer the most apposite of epithets. 11. Mathematical Modelling of Fungal Growth A.
WHY MODEL?
Any mathematical modcl of growth attempts to specify interrelationships between the many components of the system, physical, chemical and biological and, clearly, such components must be
4
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
capable of being quantified. The system then is usually described for convenience by a series of differential equations which, depending on the complexity of the-model, may be solved manually or by the aid of computing techniques. A model is likely to be of practical value only if it is mathematically tractable and can be analysed to predict responses to defined environmental conditions, and if it provides a reasonable fit of the experimental data. Topiwala (1973) recently has cautioned that apparently successful models do not conclusively validate basic assumptions made in the model because alternative models may produce similar conclusions. Nevertheless, if a given theory of growth cannot be modelled satisfactorily it is unlikely to be a valid one. What then are the purposes of modelling? First, in formulating models, all descriptions and definitions need to be rigorous, free of ambiguity and be capable of being expressed in mathematical terms. Thus, the microbiologist is obliged to think precisely and systematically about the growth system under study, and for which experimental data can be obtained. Second, models have a conceptual function in helping to focus attention on, and in revealing, fundamental properties of the system. Consequently models enable predictions to be made of the behaviour of the biological system under a limitless range of conditions which may not have been investigated in the laboratory. Indeed computer simulation studies now provide important strategic approaches in both research and process microbiology. An instructive example in the fungal field is provided for the griseofulvin fermentation by Calam et al. ( 197 1). Finally, following on from the latter point, modelling can be a considerable guide in the design of experiments and in the interpretation of experimental data. B . APPROACHES TO MODELLING
Numerous types of mathematical models have been proposed to describe microbial growth and behaviour, and these reflect the particular approaches and objectives prescribed by the modeller. The majority of this research, reported in the chemical-engineering, biochemical and sanitary literature, is frequently overlooked by the microbial physiologist and we feel that it is pertinent to include a brief resume of the main criteria considered in model construction. Although the microbial physiologist most often is concerned with population dynamics, any population of micro-organisms comprises
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
5
individuals whose size, composition and metabolism is distributed over a definable range that itself is dependent on the growth conditions. Thus, models that recognize the differing physiological states of individuals in a population are termed segregated. However, it is more usual to neglect the variations between individuals (thus simplifying the mathematics and avoiding statistical correlations) and instead to treat population dynamics in terms of variations in average properties; models of the latter type are called unsegregated (distributed or non-segregated). In passing we should note that, in models based on a distribution of individuals of different physiological states, the distribution per se may be dependent on the existent environment. These models are referred to as being structured. Again, however, most of the models with which a microbiologist is familiar disregard population structure and more simple unstructured modelling terms of reference are adopted. Unsegregated models also may be endowed with structure if composition changes of the population during the course of cultivation are admitted. For example, biochemical structure was incorporated into an unsegregated growth model by Ramkrishna el al. ( 1966) who divided microbial biomass into G mass (nucleic acids) and D mass (proteins) components. Because the growth rate of individual micro-organisms cannot be predicted with complete certainty, stochastic population, or probabilistic, models have been formulated that take into account the variability of generation times. Once more, due to the “formidable mathematical difficulties” that arise “when one attempts to model only very simple biological phenomena” (Frederickson et al., 19701, stochastic models are usually disregarded in favour of simpler deterministic models. In summary, therefore, most of the commonly used mathematical models of microbial growth are unsegregated, unstructured and deterministic, assumptions that are largely valid when population sizes are large, i.e. the kinetics of microbial growth can be developed on the lines of established chemical reaction kinetics. The classic example of a model of this type is that proposed by Monod ( 1942, 1949) and having its origins in the much neglected researches of M’Kendrick and Pai (191 1). The latter showed: (1) that exponential growth proceeded in batch cultures as long as the “nutriment” supply was unlimited; (2) that the rate of growth was proportional to the number of organisms present (i.e. that growth was autocatalytic); and (3) that they were clearly appreciative of such growth co-efficients as yield and
6
A. T. BULL AND A.
P. J. TRlNCl
maintenance. Monod related the specific growth rate (p) to the concentration of growth limiting substrate (s) thus: p =pcmax SI(K,+ S), where pmax is the maximum value of p under a given set of growth conditions and K, is the substrate saturation constant ( K , = S at p =pmax/2). Although the Monod expression is formally analogous to the Michaelis-Menten equation relating enzyme reaction velocity to substrate concentration, there are important distinctions between the two models. Thus, the rate constant, p, in the Monod equation is a logarithmic function of S, whereas v in the Michaelis-Menten equation is related linearly to S. Further, whereas the Michaelis-Menten constant, K,, has a mechanistic basis, K , is an empirical constant. From its first proposition, the Monod model was recognized as an oversimplification but it should be remembered that its original objective was in the curve-fitting of experimental data. Two other unsegregated growth models, less widely used than that of Monod, will be mentioned briefly. The first of these, the logistic equation, includes a term to describe the decrease in growth rate as the limiting substrate becomes exhausted and predicts a maximum population or stationary growth phase in batch cultures. The logistic equacion can be variously expressed (cf. Tsuchiya et al. 1966; Hockenhull and MacKenzie, 1968; Maynard-Smith, 1968) one form of which is: x=
xOePt
l-px.(l - P )
where x and xo are microbial biomass concentrations at time t and o, and p is a constant which may be written: = Y(So+ YxJ where Y is the yield factor with respect to the growth-limiting substrate, concentration S,at zero time. Finally we wish to draw attention to a threeconstant growth model (Dabes et al., 1973) which embodies Blackman kinetics (i.e. the concept of a rate limiting step in a biological process). Dabes and his colleagues considered the situation in which two slow enzymic steps were separated by fast reactions, the overall equilibrium constant of which is not large, and their model, unlike the Monod and logistic equations, contain three constants :
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
7
B is the growth-limiting substrate saturation constant, and A is a constant incorporating overall and rate-limiting equilibrium constants. This model has the potential of indicating the proximity of ratelimiting reactions to each other from the magnitude of B relative to Ap,,,; as B approaches zero, the equilibrium constant between the reactions increases. In the following section we examine the applicability of existing models, particularly those referred to above, to describe growth of filamentous fungi. In short, how adequate for fungi are models developed to express the growth of unicellular micro-organisms? C . THE A P P L I C A B I L I T Y O F C L A S S I C MODELS T O FUNGAL GROWTH
At the outset, the extreme morphological plasticity of fungi must be recognized. In liquid culture, a particular species may grow as a diffuse mycelium, in the form of variously sized pellets or other aggregations or, quite frequently, may develop a yeast-like morphology. Diffuse mycelial and pellet growth will be considered here while the growth of surface colonies of fungi will be examined in detail in subsequent parts of this article (p. 29). 1. Distribution $Metabolic Activities in Mycelial Systems
I f we wish to approach fungal growth in terms of unsegregated, unstructural models, an immediate question arises : are metabolic activities distributed evenly among the hyphal cells of a multicellular mycelium? In other words, is the mycelium differentiated biochemically? We will assume for the present that significant morphological differentiation does not occur during unrestricted growth in batch cultures or in steady-state continuous-flow cultures. Unfortunately there have been very few studies of the distribution of activities along fungal hyphae. Fencl et al. (1969) used micro-autoradiography to analyse the distribution of RNA synthesis in Aspergillis niger mycelia growing in batch and multi-stage chemostat cultures. Synthesis of RNA was distributed evenly throughout the mycelium as long as batch cultures were growing exponentially, but differential synthesis occurred in stationary-phase mycelia. This fungus showed diauxic growth on a sucrose-nitrate medium, and unequal RNA and protein synthesis was evident in the mycelia of the second exponential phase (Machek and Fencl, 1973). However, when mycelia from either
8
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
the stationary or the second exponential phase were given a nutritional shift-up, the distribution of activity reverted to that typical of the first exponential phase. The results from multi-stage chemostat experiments substantiated these findings. A three-stage chemostat culture was established in which: (1) the dilution rate ( D )in the first stage was 0.04 h-’; (2) fresh medium was fed to the third stage to make D equal to 0.17 h-l; and (3) additions were not made to the second stage, i.e. conditions which were considered to resemble those at the onset of the stationary phase in a batch culture. In all three vessels the mycelium behaved as a homogenous entity, all hyphal cells synthesizing RNA even if at a very low rate as in the case of the stage 2 population. Data from Terui’s laboratory strongly support the findings of the Czech workers. Shinmyo and Terui ( 1970)observed uniform incorporation of 14C-adenineand I4C-guanosine into “pulpy” (i.e. diffuse) mycelia of A . niger growing as hanging drop microcultures, and also noticed that all hyphal cells had a uniform growth potential, i.e. longitudinal growth of apices or formation of branches in subapical cells. Similar observations to the latter have been made on chemostat cultures of A . nidulans (M. E. Bushell and A. T. Bull, unpublished experiments). On the basis of these analyses, therefore, it seems justifiable to treat rate relationships in moulds in terms of the average kinetics discussed above (Section 11, B; p. 4). I t must be stressed that our last conclusion applies on4 to liquid cultures of diffusely growing mycelia. Shinmyo and Terui (1970) pointed out that the distribution of growth activities in the hyphal cells of pellets was highly heterogeneous. Much earlier Camici et al. (1952) had reported that the centres of dense pellets of Penicillium chrysogenum contained mycelium that was frequently dead or autolysing, observations later confirmed in other species by Yanagita and Kogane ( 1963a). Indeed, the latter authors showed that extensive morphological differentiations occurred in mycelia adjacent to the central spaces in pellets while, at a metabolic level, RNA synthesis was strictly limited to the peripheral hyphae of the pellet. Thus, although pelleted growth may be desirable for the formation of certain fungal products, for example ergot alkaloids (Tonolo et al., 1961), citric acid (Clark, 1962) and certain enzymes (a-galactosidase; Kobayashi and Suzuki, 19721, their highly differentiated nature makes them totally unsuitable for most metabolic studies. In passing we should note that, like pellets, surface colonies of fungi
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
9
become differentiated metabolically, and usually morphologically, with increasing age and this process is clearly evident from changing enzyme patterns. Isaac (1964) described a clear differentiation of Rhizoctoniu soluni colonies with respect to the distribution of cellulase
activity; enzyme production was associated with short branched hyphae in old parts of the colony but not with young hyphae produced apically or by subapical branching. A study of phosphorus metabolizing enzymes in Aspergillus niger by Nagasaki ( 1968) illustrates a similar age-dependent differentiation in surface colonies. More recently Skowronski and Gottlieb ( 1970)analysed metabolic changes that occur in the peripheral (actively growing) hyphae from young and old colonies of R. soluni. They made the interesting conclusion that factors responsible for growth limitation in old colonies probably were located in the peripheral hyphae, such hyphae from old colonies having greatly diminished rates of respiration and protein synthesis. Moreover, the deficient protein synthesis appeared to be due to inhibitory factors in the soluble fraction of the hyphae; ribosomes from these hyphae retained the capacity to synthesize protein at close to maximum rates. The plugging of septa1 pores and the consequent prevention of translocation is a further manifestation of differentiation in a fungal colony (Trinci and Collinge, 1974b). We will return to this subject in Section 1V.A (p. 23).
2. Some Examples of Fungal Growth Modelling Only quite recently has it become widely appreciated that filamentous fungi possess the ability to grow exponentially (6.Mandels, 1965), and the perpetuation of the contrary view seems to rest on the fact that these organisms grow by linear apical extension of their hyphae. However, exponential increase in total mycelial length or mass does occur by the generation of new hyphal apices at a rate proportional to the total mycelial length; this condition is realized either by branch formation or by hyphal fragmentation by shearing forces in a stirred culture. In passing it may be noted that very little quantitative data have been published on hyphal fragmentation in stirred fermenters, and information on hyphal-length distribution at different shearing rates is lacking. Recently, however, Japanese workers have made a valuable contribution to the analysis of mycelial strength and have provided a comparative standard against which to assess the intensity of shearing
10
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
shock (Tanaka, Takahashi and Ueda, 1975; Tanaka, Mizuguchi and Ueda, 1975). In practice, the Monod model can produce good approximations of fungal gowth, and this is illustrated in Figure l a with reference to the batch cultivation of Geotrichum lactis in a defined glucose-nitrate medium. The departure of the observed data from that predicted is highly suggestive of oxygen limitation occurring when the biomass concentration exceeds about 2 g 1-I. The model also demonstrates the relative unimportance of K , as a determinant of growth under conditions of substrate excess. We noted earlier that the Monod model does not predict a decreasing growth rate as the substrate becomes limiting, and even when the value for K, is very small (Fig. la) a significant deceleration phase may be evident. Consequently, the logistic law, which embodies the principle of a maximum population, may be a more appropriate model to adopt. Constantinides et al. (1970) found that growth of Penicillium was very closely predicted by the logistic equation. Similarly, growth of wild-type Aspergzllus nidulans is fitted much more closely by the logistic than by the Monod equation (Fig. lb). The significant divergence of the Monod plot and the experimental data may be explicable in terms of an over-estimated rate of substrate utilization, or of a substantial channelling of carbon into extracellular product(s). The extensive synthesis of extracellular melanin that begins towards the end of exponential growth (Carter and Bull, 1969; Rowley and Pirt, 1972) is an argument in support of the latter hypothesis. Figure l a also demonstrates the utility of the logistic model; whereas the Monod equation accurately predicts exponential growth, the logistic equation in addition provides an acceptably accurate modelling of the decelerating growth rate phase. The pronounced morphological, as well as biochemical, differentiation which moulds may display necessitates models additional to those discussed so far. Thus, Emerson (1955) argued, on quite reasonable grounds, that the growth rate of a filamentous fungus should be somewhat less than exponential and he predicted that growth would follow a cube root law. Emerson’s own observations with Neurosporu cratsa sustained such a cube root growth model, and other workers have confirmed this fact subsequently. The ensuing confusion over exponential or cube-root expressions of fungal growth has persisted in the literature for many years and was only conclusively resolved by Pirt ( 1966). Pirt deduced that cube root growth was a characteristic of fungi growing as pellets, rather than as diffuse mycelia, and he argued that
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
I
I
I
5
10
I
15 20 Time ( h )
1
I
25
30
11
(a)
Time(h)
(b) FIG. 1. (a).Time-course of growth of a batch culture of Geotrkhum cundidum, from the data of Trinci (1971). Observed values for biomass production are indicated by . Computer simulations based on the Monod model for &value of 9 mg I-' are indicated by . . . ., and for a &value of 24 mg I-' by - - - -,and for the Logistic model by -. Computor simulations (Bushel1 et al., 1976) incorporate the growth constants of Fiddy and Trinci (1975). (b). Time-course of growth of a batch culture of Aspergillus nidulans 224 based on the data of Carter and Bull ( 1969). Observed values for biomass , and the concentration of glucose in the culture by A . production are indicated by . Predictions from the Monod model are indicated by - and from the Logistic model by - - - - (Bushel et ul., 1976).
12
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
once a pellet exceeded a critical size growth was restricted to a peripheral zone by constraints on substrate diffusion. Trinci ( 1970), and more recently Huang and Bungay ( 1973), have supplied convincing experimental proof of Pirt’s model and have provided quantitative data on the dimensions of the peripheral growth zone. To our knowledge, Blackman kinetics have not been used to model mould growth, but in their paper Dabes et al. (1973) have made some pertinent observations on yeast respiration and growth. Commenting on the data of Terui and Sugimoto (19691, Dabes and his colleagues argued that, while it was the availability of electrons that determined the maximum rate of respiration, the apparent &value for oxygen “is set by the cytochrome system close to the point of oxygen utilization”. The fit of respiration rates by the three-constant model is claimed to be good support for the idea of two widely separated rate-limiting steps in yeast respiration. These preliminary analyses recommend that more attention should be given to Blackman-type kinetics by the microbial physiologist. All of the models of fungal growth referred to above neglect mycelial differentiation or the effects of cell age. An attempt to model growth of Aspergillus awamori based on the existence of discrete states of mycelial differentiation has been made by Megee et al. (1970). Although they succeeded in modelling many features of mould fermentations on the basis of age-dependent parameters, the differentiation states incorporated into the model were defined with reference to surface colonies, and such an extrapolation may be unwarranted. The concept of a mean cumulative age” introduced by Aiba and Hara (1965) is also relevant in the context of age-related phenomena in filamentous fungi. The mean cumulative age, defined as the cumulative age of all mother and daughter cells of a particular mycelial system divided by the total number of cells in that system, provides a common time scale for comparing batch and continuous-flow cultures. Aiba and Hara (1965) illustrated their hypothesis by reference to the penicillin fermentation, and concluded that mean cumulative age analysis could offer scope for designing continuous processes from observations made on batch culture%. In coklusion, it is essential to recognize that mathematical description of microbial growth is a continuing quest and that refinement of models must be limited by our ability to define physiological changes in precise mathematical terms. Fungal physiologists, and mycologists 66
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
13
in general, usually find the rigorous demands of growth-modelling discouraging and also, perhaps, have been too disposed to seek simple mathematical expressions in the hope of deriving a universal quantitative description of batch growth. Dawson and Phillips (1974) have argued that most growth models have limited utility “if only because simple models have extremely restricted applications and complex models are self-defeating’’ in the sense that critical data needed to test their validity are lacking. At this stage, therefore, the mycologist might adopt mathematical modelling most advantageously as a conceptual aid in the problem of understanding fungal growth. 111. Growth
of Undifferentiated Mycelia
A distinction may be made between differentiated and undifferentiated mycelia (Steele and Trinci, 1975). A fungal spore germinates upon a solid medium to form an undifferentiated mycelium which increases in size and differentiates into a “mature” colony. The differences which distinguish the hyphae of undifferentiated mycelia from those at the margin of mature colonies are listed in Table 1. Most studies of the growth and cytology of moulds have been made upon hyphae at the margin of “mature” colonies. However, the basic features of fungal growth are more likely to be displayed by the hyphae of unTABLE 1. Comparison between the characteristics of hyphae of differentiated and undifferentiated rnycelia Undifferentiated mycelia Hyphae formed during exponential growth on solid media or submerged culture 1. The hyphae of a single mycelium have more or less the same diameter 2. Each hypha has the same maximum extension rate (Emax)
3. Hyphae have relatively short extension zones 4. Hyphae do not usually branch subapically
Differentiated mycelia Hyphae formed at the margin of colonies on solid media The hyphae are usually differentiated into wide “leading” hyphae and narrower branch hyphae “Leading” hyphae have faster rnaximum extension rates than primary and secondary branches “Leading” hyphae have relatively long extension zones “Leading” hyphae often branch subapically
14
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
differentiated mycelia since the mechanisms involved in regulating mycelial form may be obscured by the differentiation process involved in colony formation. A.
R E G U L A T I O N O F MYCELIAL FORM
The thallus of a mould, unlike that of a unicellular micro-organism, is well adapted to colonize solid substrates such as plant surfaces, soil
and solidified culture media. An advantage of the filamentous form is that the organism can increase in size indefinitely without altering the ratio between protoplasmic volume and surface area. Thus, exchange of substances between the mycelium and the medium involves transport over only short distances. The fact that hyphae branch at more or less regular intervals ensures that solid substrates are effectively and efficiently covered by the mycelium. At least three mechanisms must be involved in regulating the formation of undifferentiated mycelia: ( l ) Regulation ofhyphal polarity. Hyphal growth is polarized, i.e. extension is confined to the hyphal tip. (2) Regulation of branch initiation. Germ tubes increase in length to form “main” hyphae from which primary branches are produced. In their turn, the primary branches give rise to secondary branches and so on. The predictable form of a mycelium indicates that there is a mechanism which regulates the frequency of branch initiation. (3) Regulation ofthe spatial distribution of hyphae. Hyphae formed by an undifferentiated mycelium tend not to grow in contact with one another. Contact between adjacent hyphae is minimized by an “avoiding” reaction known as autotropism (Robinson, 1973). Thus there is a mechanism which regulates the spatial distribution of the hyphae within a mycelium. B.
POLARIZATION O F HYPHAL GROWTH
The mechanism which initiates and subsequently maintains the polarity of hyphal growth is not known. Growth initially becomes polarized during germ tube formation; fungal spores are often spherical and hence lack any obvious polarity. The onset of polarity may be prevented by manipulating the cultural conditions; for example, at temperatures of 37OC and below, conidia of Aspergillus niger germinate in the normal way and form a mycelium but, on incubation at 44OC, a supra-optimal temperature for this fungus, polarity is in-
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
15
hibited and the conidia increase in volume and dry weight to form giant, coenocytic, spherical “cells” which have very thick walls (Smith and Anderson, 1973). Growth of these structures becomes polarized (the cells germinate forming hyphal outgrowths) when the incubation temperature is lowered to 3 O O C . Mucor rouxii, which also forms a mycelium under normal conditions, grows in a non-polarized, yeastlike manner when it is cultured under anaerobic conditions in the presence of carbon dioxide (Bartnicki-Garcia, 1963). Thus nonpolarized (isotropic) growth may be associated with conditions which are unfavourable far growth. Hyphal polarity is clearly governed by some endogenous regulatory mechanism since the filamentous form is maintained in submerged culture. Further, entire filaments as well as the individual compartments of Geotrichum candidum hyphae grown in batch culture are polarized with respect to branch initiation (Fiddy and Trinci, 1975). Moulds grown in submerged culture are not of course subjected to the environmental gradients associated with colony growth on solid media (Park and Robinson, 1966). The tubular form of a hypha is presumably a consequence of the apical transport and deposition of the vesicles involved in hyphal extension. The vesicle may contain wall precursors and/or enzymes which synthesize and lyse cell-wall polymers (Bartnicki-Garcia, 1973). Hyphal extension (tip growth, branching, spore germination) always appears to be associated with the fusion of vesicles with the existing wall. The mechanism which regulates hyphal polarity presumably operates through its effect on the apical transport and/or deposition of these vesicles. Factors which disrupt normal vesicle transport and/or deposition may thus result in isotropic growth. C . REGULATION OF B R A N C H INITIATION
Growth of undifferentiated mycelia may be studied by following their formation from spores on solid media overlaid with cellophane (Trinci, 1974).The cellophane ensures that the mycelia are formed in a single plane and can thus be photographed in their entirety. Mycelia which have a total hyphal length of only a few millimetres may be regarded as undifferentiated. Certainly, such mycelia lack differentiation into leading hyphae of wide diameter and branch hyphae of narrower diameter (Trinci, 1973a). However, undifferentiated mycelia
16
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
may not form a distinct morphology and physiological state of development but simply represent a transient stage in colony formation (Steele and Trinci, 1975). Growth of an undifferentiated mycelium from a spore initially occurs under environmental conditions which remain relatively constant. The physical and chemical characteristics of the medium will only be significantly changed after it has supported a certain amount of biomass production. Therefore the cultural conditions which prevail during the initial stages of mycelial growth on a solid medium will be similar to those present during the early part of the exponential phase of' growth of a batch culture. Certainly the morphology of undifferentiated mycelia produced under these two cultural conditions is very similar (Steele and Trinci, 1975). 1. M aximurn Extension Rates o f Individual Hyphae
of Undgerentiated
Mycelia
The initial rate of extension of a branch of an undifferentiated mycelium is dependent upon its parent hypha. Branch hyphae of Aspergillus nidulans, Geotrichum candidum and Mucor hiemalis attain their maximum extension rates when they are, respectively, about 400, 400 TABLE 2. Mean and maximum extension rates of the hyphae of undifferentiated mycelia grown at 25OC. Mean values are quoted f standard errors of the mean. From Trinci (1974) Species
A.\pergillus nidulans Geolrichum candidum Mucor hiemalis Penicillium chrysogenum Neurospora crassa spco 1
Mean hyphal extension rate ( E , pm h-'1
** 8 * 0.3 21 *I
33 4 48 3 125 k 11
Maximum hyphal extension rate (Em.,, p n h-') 80 120 330
49
and850pm long (Trinci, 1974). These values thus represent the maximum lengths of the peripheral growth zones (Trinci, 1971) of these hyphae. The hyphae of an undifferentiated mycelium thus appear to have a maximum rate of extension which is strain specific (Table 2).
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
2. Mean Extension Rate o f the Hyphae
17
of Undgerentiated Mycelia.
The mean rate of hyphal extension ( E ) of a mycelium may be calculated from the equation:
where H o is the total hyphal length (pm) of the mycelium at zero time, H , the total hyphal length one hour later, Bo the number of hyphal tips at zero time, and B ; the number of hyphal tips one hour later. The mean hyphal extension rate of a mycelium may also be estimated (Steele and Trinci, 1975) from the equation: E=Gp
(2)
where G is the mean length of the hyphal growth unit (Trinci, 1973b) of the mycelium, and p the organism’s specific growth rate. The symbol a has been used to denote specific growth rate in several publications in this field. Since G and p are constants, E must also be a constant. The mean hyphal extension rate (calculated using equation 1) of Geotrichum candidum increased until the mycelium had formed three tips and thereafter remained constant (Trinci, 1974).The low standard deviations calculated for the mean hyphal extension rates of the mycelia of different moulds (Table 2) suggests that E is a specific feature of undifferentiated mycelia. 3. Growth of UndiJerentiated Mycelia from Spores
Undifferentiated mycelia initially increase in total length at an exponential rate (Trinci, 1974); in the case of Mucor hiemalis, exponential growth continued until the mycelium had a total hyphal length in excess of about 15 mm. The exponential phase is followed by a period during which there is a progressive deceleration in growth rate. The duration of the exponential phase is probably influenced by the length of the mould’s hyphal growth unit; that is, deceleration is likely to occur earlier for species which form dense mycelia (e.g. Penicillium chrysogenum) than for species which form sparse mycelia (e.g. Mucor hiemalid. The onset of the deceleration phase is probably correlated with certain adverse changes in the composition of the medium (e.g.
18
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
changes in pH value or secondary metabolites or nutrient concentration) and with differentiation of the mycelium (e.g. the formation of narrow branch hyphae and wide “leading” hyphae). During the early part of the stage during which the total hyphal length of the mycelium is increasing exponentially, branches are formed at relatively infrequent intervals. Eventually the number of branches increases exponentially at more or less the same specific growth rate as the total hyphal length of the mycelium (Fig. 2). f
5120
2560 I280 -
--
0 c -4Og 5
320 -
f
160-
80-
20 - 01
0
I 2
4
tip production I
I
I
6
8
10
12
Time ( h )
FIG. 2. Growth of mycelium of Geotrichum candidum on solid medium. The number of hyphal tips (O), total length (0)and length of the hyphal growth unit (0)are plotted as a function of time. The figure is reproduced by permission of Cambridge University Press.
The ratio between the total hyphal length of an undifferentiated mycelium and its number of branches has been called the hyphal growth unit(Caldwel1andTrinci, 1973;Trinci, 1973b).After spore germination, the hyphal growth unit of an undifferentiated mycelium increases in length until the germ tube produces its first branch. At this point the hyphal grown unit is halved. The amplitude of the oscillations in the length of the hyphal growth unit decreases progressively as the undif‘ferentiatedmycelium increases in size. Eventually the hyphal growth unit attains a more or less constant value (Fig. 2). Growth of an un-
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
19
differentiated mycelium may be thought of in terms of the duplication of a hypothetical “growth unit” which consists of a tip and specific length of hypha. The apparently contradictory observations that the biomass of a mould grown in batch culture increases at an exponential rate whilst individual hyphae extent at a linear rate are reconciled by the fact that there is an exponential increase in Up number (Caldwell and Trinci, 1973). Similarly, an individual bacterium may increase in mass at a linear rate whilst the population increases in number exponentially (Kubitschek, 1970).The “hyphal growth unit” of a mycelium is a physiological, but not a morphological, entity. It is simply the mean length of hypha per tip, and it clearly differs qualitatively from the “growth units” (i.e. the cells) of unicellular micro-organisms. The observation that the extension rate of the hyphae of an undifferentiated mycelium of Mucor hiemulis varied from 2 1 to 329 pmlh (Trinci, 1974)suggests that the length of hypha actually associated with each tip probably varies over wide limits ; the observed difference in extension rates presumably reflect differences in the length of hypha associated with each tip (Trinci, 1971). The relationship between hyphal length and tip number (i.e. the hyphal growth unit) may also be investigated by studying populations of undifferentiated mycelia (Caldwell and Trinci, 1973; Trinci, 197313; Trinci and Collinge, 1973; Morrison and Righelato, 1974).The hyphal growth unit of a population of undifferentiated mycelia of Neurospora crussu spco 1 was relatively constant (Trinci, 1973b)suggesting that there is a direct relationship between total hyphal length and tip number. D. H Y P H A L G R O W T H U N I T S O F D I F F E R E N T S T R A I N S A N D S P E C I E S
The hyphal growth unit is strain- (Trinci, 1973a, b ; Morrison and Righelato, 1974) and species-specific (Table 3). The observation that some spreading colonial mutants (spco) of Neurospora crassu have the same specific growth rate as the wild type (Trinci, 1973a) but different hyphal growth unit lengths indicates that these mutations affected the spatial distribution of the organism’s biomass but not its rate of production (Trinci, 1973a).The mean and maximum hyphal extension rates of these strains have presumably also been altered by the mutations. There is a considerable variation amongst the fungi in hyphal growth unit length (Table 3).
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
20
TABLE 3. Hyphal growth units ofundifferentiated mycelia of fungi grown at 25OC o n solid defined medium (Trinci, 197 1). The hyphae measured had 3-8 tips. The medium was supplemented with thiamine and biotin for the phycomycetes. Values are quoted k standard errors ot'the mean. ( I . J. Caldwell and A. P. J. Trinci, unpublished results) Hyphal growth unit (G,pm)
Species Cunninghamella sp Rhizopus slolonifer M ucor rammanianus MUCOThiemalis Aclinomucor repens" Aspergillus niger Aspergdlus wenlii Aspergillus gtganteus Penicillium clavtforme Penicillium chyogenum Geolrichum candiduma Cladosporium sp Verlicillium sp Fusarium vaucerium Fusarium avenaceum Trichoderma viride
35 f 9 124 f 31 31 f 10 95 f 22 352 k 97 I? f 14
6 6 k 15 7lf9 104 f 18 48 f 10 110 f 28 59f 1 1 8 2 2 17 682 f 26 620 f 164 160 f 31
"Grown at 3oOC.
E. EFFECT O F E N V I R O N M E N T A L C O N D I T I O N S O N H Y P H A L GROWTH U N I T LENGTH
1. Temperature
Hyphal growth unit length is riot affected by temperature (Trinci, 1973b). This suggests that specific growth rate ( p ) varies directly with mean hyphal extension rate ( E ) (i.e. the ratio Elp is a constant). This certainly appears to be so (Table 4).Presumably the maximum hyphal extension rate (E,,,,J of an undifferentiated mycelium also varies TABLE 4. Specific growth rate and mean hyphal extension rate of undifrerentiated mycelia of NeUrOSPOTa crassa spco I . p was determined in batch culture. From Trinci (1974) Temperature (OC)
25
Mean hyphal extension rate ( E , pn h-')
Specific growth rate (K, h-9
Elp
21 38
0.26 0.45
81 88
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
21
directly with specific growth rate. Thus temperature alters the rate at which the hyphal growth unit is duplicated but not its length. Similarly the mean cell mass of bacterial populations grown in batch culture is not altered by temperature (Schaechter et ul., 1958). 2. Inhibitors
Hyphal growth unit length may or may not be altered by inhibitors of mould growth (Caldwell and Trinci, 1973; Trinci, 1973a, b). The effect of an inhibitor depends upon the nature of’ the inhibition and the concentration employed. When hyphal growth unit length is not altered by an inhibitor, this suggests there is a direct relationship between the effect of the inhibitor on the mould’s specific growth rate and its effect on the mean extension rate of its hyphae (i.e. the ratio E / p is not altered by the inhibitor). Cycloheximide, unlike deoxycholate and triphenyl tin acetate, causes a decrease in hyphal growth unit length. 3. L-Sorbose L-sorbose inhibits the extension rate of Neurosporu crussu hyphae without apparently affecting the mould’s specific growth rate (Trinci and Collinge, 1973). Thus L-sorbose causes a dramatic decrease in hyphal growth unit length, inducing N . CTUSSU to branch profusely. Like the spco mutations of Neurosporu crussu (Trinci, 1973a), the maximum specific growth rate of L-sorbose treated mycelia remains unaltered but the spatial distribution of the mould’s biomass is changed. L-Sorbose, and substances which act like L-sorbose, would be expected to induce moulds to grow in a colonial or semi-colonial manner. 4. Medium Composition
Qualitative changes in medium composition may affect hyphal growth unit length as well as altering specific growth rate (Katz et al., 1972; Morrison and Righelato, 1974). The results of Katz et al. (1972) suggest that there is an inverse relationship between specific growth rate and hyphal growth unit length (Table 5 ) . It would seem that varying the composition of the medium altered the specific growth rate of Aspergillus niduluns without having a corresponding effect on the mean hyphal extension rate of its mycelia (i.e. the ratio, E / p did not remain
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
22
TABLE 5. Et'frct of medium composition on hyphal growth unit length Mediuni
Specific growth -rate (p, h-')
Hyphal growth unit length ( G ,pm)
Estimated mean rate of hyphal extension ( E , m h-l)''
(a) A\pergzl/u.\ uidu1an.s at 3OoC (calculated from the data of Katz el al., 1972) Malt extract Defined medium with acetate as the carbon source Defined medium with L-tryptophan as the nitrogen source
0.14
c. 33b c. 7Sb
11.9 10.2
0.11
c. 12Ob
13.2
0.36
(b) Periicillium chrysogenuin T 14 (Morrison and Righelato, 1974) Complex niediuni Defined medium
0.24 0.14
4 3 f 10 60k9
10.3 8.4
Estimated using Equation 2 (p. 1 7 ) . bEstimated from the data of Katz el al., (1972).
a
constant); medium composition appears to have had little effect on mean hyphal extension rate (Table 5 ) . 5 . Conclusions
Under a given set of environmental conditions the total hyphal length of a mycelium, and the number of its tips, increase exponentially at the same specific growth rate (pu).Thus the ratio between total hyphal length and tip number (i.e. the hyphal growth unit) is a constant as is the mean rate of hyphal extension ( E l . The relative constancy of the length of the hyphal growing unit during mycelial development suggests that branch initiation, like the division of unicellular microorganisms, may be regulated by the changes in cytoplasmic volume which accompany growth, i.e. when the mean volume of cytoplasm (length of hypha) per hyphal tip exceeds a critical volume (length) it induces the mycelium to initiate a new branch. Mutations or cultural conditions which cause a deceleration in the mean rate of extension of a mould's hyphae without altering ;he organism's specific growth rate (i.e. altering the ratio, E / p ) will result in
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
23
a decrease in the length of the hyphal growth unit. The spreading colonial mutants of Neurosporu crma are such mutants (Trinci, 1973a,b) and L-sorbose such a factor (Trinci and Collinge, 1973). Mutations or cultural conditions which cause an increase in the organism’s specific growth rate without causing a corresponding acceleration in the mean rate of extension of its hyphae (i.e. again altering the ratio EIp) will also result in a decrease in hyphal growth unit length. Presumably this is what happened when Kau et ul. ( 1972) altered the specific growth rate of Aspergzllus niduluns by changing the composition of the medium (Table 5 ) . Altering the specific growth rate of a mould by temperature changes causes a corresponding change in the mean rate of extension of its hyphae (i.e. temperature does not alter the ratio, Elp) and thus hyphal growth unit length is not affected by temperature. F. REGULATION O F T H E SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION O F HYPHAE
The spatial distribution of the hyphae of undifferentiated mycelia in part results from negative autotropism, i.e. hyphae tend to grow away from each other. Autotropism is thus a mechanism which helps to ensure that solid substrates are effectively and efficiently covered by mycelia. The hyphae at the periphery of a fungal colony grow radially outwards from the centre. This phenomenon has usually been explained in terms of a negative chemotropic response of the hyphae to some unknown factor(s) which accumulate in the environment. However, Robinson (1973) has recently suggested that the phenomenon can be explained in terms of a positive chemotropic response to oxygen. Negative autotropic responses of undifferentiated hyphae have been observed where the responding hypha was up to 30 jm away from the hypha to which it was reacting (A. P. J. Trinci, unpublished observation). Thus, negative autotropism may result from a response to some unknown substances which diffuse from hyphae and accumulate in the environment, or to a gradient in a nutritional factor (including oxygen) which is established in the immediate vicinity of hyphae.
IV. Colony Growth A. COLONY DIFFERENTIATION
A mycelium increases in size and gradually differentiates into a “mature” colony which subsequently extends radially across the substrate at a linear rate. This differentiation probably occurs as a direct
24
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
response to the changes induced in the medium by growth of the mould. “Mature” colonies can be divided into at least four morphological zones (Yanagita and Kogane, 1962): (1)the extending zone (which is equal to the peripheral growth zone; Trinci, 197 1 ), made up of the peripheral, sparse network of vegetative hyphae not supporting aerial hyphae; (2) the productive zone, made up of a much denser network of vegetative hyphae supporting aerial hyphae; (3) the fruiting zone, where asexual and/or sexual reproductive structures are formed; and (4)and aged zone, made up of the “aged” and autolysing hyphae at the centre of the colony. Although it is convenient to recognize these zones, there is a continuous differentiation of the colony from its periphery to its centre. 1. The Peripheral Growth Zone The width of the peripheral growth zone of a “mature” colony remains approximately constant as it expands radially across the substrate (Yanagita and Kogane, 1962;Trinci, 1971).The hyphae in the peripheral growth zone, unlike those of young mycelia, are usually differentiated into wide “leading” hyphae and narrower branch hyphae (Butler, 1961; Trinci, 1973a). The “leading” hyphae are oriented radially outwards from the centre of the colony with their apices more or less at the same level, giving a smooth outline to the colony (Butler, 1966). Hyphae at the outer fringe of the peripheral growth zone are thin walled, full of protoplasm (Butler, 1966)and rich in RNA and DNA (Yanagita and Kogane, 1962). The cytoplasm in hyphae more distant from the margin of the colony is vacuolated and the degree of vacuolation increases distally (Park and Robinson, 1967). Intrahyphal hyphae (Lowry and Sussman, 1966 ; Trinci and Righelato, 1970)are rarely if ever formed in the peripheral growth zone, and the septa1 pores of septate hyphae usually remained unplugged (Trinci and Collinge, 1973). Anastomoses (Buller, 1933) are not usually formed between hyphae in the peripheral growth zone. In some moulds, e.g. Neurosporu crassu, formation of a mature colony involves a differentiation process which results in the formation of wide “leading” hyphae having a faster maximum extension rate than the hyphae of the organism’s undifferentiated mycelium (Trinci, 1973b; 1974). This type of differentiation may be lacking in some moulds or not so marked; for example, the maximum extension rate of the leading hyphae of Geotrichum candidum colonies is not very much
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
25
faster than that of hyphae of its undifferentiated mycelium (Trinci, 1974). In most fungi, the hyphae in the peripheral growth zone branch monopodially, i.e. wide, fast growing “leading” hyphae subtend narrower, slower growing branch hyphae. Butler (1961) found that, if the extension rate of the “leading” hyphae of Coprinus dimminutus colonies was taken as loo%, then the extension rates of the primary and secondary branches were 66% and la%, respectively. Primary branches formed by “leading” hyphae at the margin of colonies of Aspergillus niduluns and Geotrichum cundidum had extension rates which were 20% and 30% less than their parent hyphae (Trinci, 1970).Thus, the peripheral growth zone hyphae d o not all have the same maximum extension rate. Butler (1961)found a positive correlation between the extension rate and diameter of “leading” hyphae of colonies of Coprinus disseminutus. There was a similar correlation between the diameter of the leading hyphae of spreading colonial mutant colonies of Neurosporu crassu and their extension rates (Trinci, 1973b). Little consideration appears to have been given by mycologists to the reason why most moulds have a monopodial branching pattern. Leopold (1971) concluded that monopodial branching is the most economical in terms of branch length for the efficient exposure of the leaves of trees to light and drainage of river basins by streams. This suggests that a monopodial branching pattern is probably a very efficient and economical way for a mould to colonize solid substrates, i.e. it ensures efficient cover of the substrate by the mould at the expense of a minimum production of biomass. The leading hyphae of colonies of Allomyces sp. (Emerson, 1955)and Geotrichum cundidum (Trinci, 1970) branch dichotomously as well as laterally, whilst those of Aspergillus niduluns branch sup-apically producing two or more branches per tip (Trinci, 1970). After dichotomous branching in G. cundidum, the extension rate of the branches accelerates until each attains the extension rate of the parent hypha. Dichotomous or sub-apical branching is rarely observed in the undifferentiated mycelia of these same species. Sympodial branching patterns have been observed in Ascobolus immersus colonies where parent hyphal tips are successively overtaken by their branches (Chevaugeon, 1959). The density of the hyphae at the circumference of a mature colony remains more or less constant as it increases in radius. This observation suggests that there is a periodic generation of new leading hrphae
26
A. T. BULL AND A.
P. J. TRlNCl
as the colony increases in diameter. Presumably these new leading hyphae arise as the result of primary branches increasing in diameter and growth rate until they assume the position and characteristics of leading hyphae (Trinci, 1973b). The transformation of a primary branch into a leading hypha probably occurs as a chance event when such a branch happens to extend into a relatively uncolonized part of the substrate at the fringe of the colony. The density of hyphae (Plomley, 1959; Trinci, 197 1) and biomass per unit area (Gillie, 1968) increase from the margin of the colony inwards. In the case of hyphal density, the increase occurs exponentially, suggesting that growth within the peripheral growth zone is rapid. 2. The Productive Zone
Like the peripheral growth zone, the width of the productive zone remains more or less constant. This region consists of a dense mat of vegetative hyphae which, unlike the peripheral growth zone, supports aerial hyphae. Some or all of the aerial hyphae may eventually be associated with reproductive structures. In fungi such as Mucor mucedo, the vegetative aerial hyphae are morphologically distinct from the sporangiophores which will eventually support the sporangia. The differentiation from mycelial to aerial growth is presumably associated with the deceleration in growth rate observed in this region of the colony. The cytoplasm of hyphae in this zone is very vacuolated and well endowed with reserves such as glycogen and lipid (Butler, 1966). The walls of productive zone hyphae are generally thicker than those of hyphae in the peripheral growth zone. Branch hyphae formed within the productive zone become progressively narrower as branching proceeds, and their growth is more meandering and less radially directed (Plomley, 1959). The septa1 pores of septate hyphae are usually plugged (Trinci and Collinge, 1973) and additional septa may be formed (Butler, 1966). Intrahyphal hyphae may be produced in this zone, and anastomoses between hyphae may occur in fungi other than the phycomycetes (Buller, 1933). 3. The Fruiting Zone
The width of the fruiting zone is less constant than the two zones considered previously. The mycelium is very dense and consists of highly vacuolated hyphae, some of which may be autolysing. Intra-
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
27
hyphal hyphae may be present. The mycelium may support asexual and/or sexual reproductive structures, the former usually preceding the latter in their development. The induction of reproductive structures is probably associated with the establishment in the environment of conditions which are relatively unfavourable for growth; for example, exhaustion of a nutrient or accumulation in the medium of inhibitory products. The formation of reproductive structures in at least some species is associated with a turnover of certain cytoplasmic and wall polymers. Exhaustion of the carbon source in the medium induces formation of a-1,s glucanases in Aspergillus nidulans which degrade the a1,3 glucan component of the wall (Zonneveld, 1974). The breakdown products of such wall polymers may supply the carbon and energy required for sporulation. In the fruiting and aged zones of the colony, the nucleic acids which were present in the mycelium may become associated with the reproductive structures (Yanagita and Kogane, 19621, suggesting that there is a turnover of these polymers. 4. The Aged Zone
As a colony increases in radius a progressively larger proportion of it is made up of a central aged zone of indefinite diameter. It is composed largely of autolysing hyphae and reproductive structures. B. M O U L D - I N D U C E D C H A N G E S I N T H E SUBSTRATE
The spatially separated regions of the colony already described reflect temporal changes which occur as the substrate is progressively colonized by the mould. Differentiation of the mould almost certainly reflects, and is induced by, the changes in the substrate which result from mould growth. The physical changes include an increase in the relative humidity above the medium, greater temperature constancy and changes in medium viscosity (Park and Robinson, 1966). However, there is little doubt that the crucial changes in the medium which are correlated with differentiation of the mould are of the chemical type discussed below. 1. Nutrient Concentration
The concentration of nutrients in the environment decreases progressively as colonization proceeds, but whether or not this has a direct effect upon the growth rate of the mould depends upon the original nutrient concentration and the affinity of the mould (K,value)
28
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
for the particular nutrient which may eventually limit growth. Moulds, like bacteria, generally have a high affinity for essential nutrients h e . a low K,value); thus, the concentration of the limiting nutrient has to be decreased to a very low level before it causes a lowering in growth rate. For example, the K, (glucose) values of Fusarium aquaeductuum and Geotrichum candidum are 0.3 (Steensland, 1973)and 1.0 mg l-l, respectively (Fiddy and Trinci, 1975). In the case of these fungi, the concentration of glucose in the medium would have to fall below about 45 nig 1-I before growth rate became glucose-limited. Growth of course would not continue for long at such concentrations because the glucose would very quickly become exhausted (cf. Section 11, C,2; p. 9 ) . Nutrient concentrations will obviously have a very significant effect on the maximum biomass of mould per unit area of substrate (i.e. on the yield). I t is a common microbiological practice to compose media so that one particular nutrient, usually the carbon and energy source, becomes exhausted before the rest, and hence determines the final yield. However, it is often difficult to decide which is the limiting nutrient in many of the media conventionally used by mycologists; for example, Vogel’s medium for Neurospora crussa (Vogel, 1956) and Czapek Dox medium (Ainsworth and Bisby, 1961). With these media, it is unlikely that the concentration of the carbon source ultimately limits growth.
2. Oxygen Tension The oxygen tension at the base of a dense mycelial mat probably is decreased to a level at which it limits growth rate. The growth rate of such hyphae will then be limited by the rate of diffusion of oxygen from the air above the colony. A decrease in oxygen tension may lead to the accumulation of secondary metabolites in the medium (e.g. citric acid).
3 . Changes in PH value
The pH value of the substrate may change as a result of the utilization of nutrients during growth (e.g. when the nitrogen source is ammonium sulphate or sodium nitrate) and/or by accumulation of secondary metabolic products (e.g. citric acid). The pH value of the medium is particularly likely to change when it has little buffering capacity.
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
29
Changes in the pH value of the medium are likely to affect the mould’s growth rate and may also encourage production of certain secondary metabolites. 4. Accumulation
of Secondary
Metabolites
Accumulation of products of secondary metabolism in the medium is likely to lower further the organism’s growth rate, and thus trigger a positive feedback mechanism. Sometimes crystals, or water-soluble pigments, may be deposited in the medium (Raper and Thom, 1949; Nobles, 1948). The changes in the substrate will increase progressively as the fungal biomass per unit area increases during colonization. The chemical changes which occur in one part of the medium will tend to spread throughout the medium by diffusion. However, the radial growth rate of the colonies of most fungi is likely to exceed the rate at which chemicals such as secondary metabolites diffuse through the medium. I t is unlikely, therefore, that secondary metabolites and products of autolysis formed at the centre of the colony will diffuse through the medium at a sufficiently fast rate to attain significant concentrations in the peripheral growth zone of the colony. Hyphae at the margin of a fungal colony continually extend into medium having a composition which is identical, or very similar, to the composition of the original uninoculated medium. C . KINETICS O F COLONY EXPANSION O N SOLID MEDIA
Pirt (1967) pointed out the need to define: (1) the factors which govern the radial growth rate of microbial colonies; (2) the relationship between radial growth rate and mass growth rate; and (3) the factors which cause differentiation within colonies. Some progress has now been made towards these ends. Gillie ( 1968) determined the dry weight of successive one-cm segments of linear colonies of Neurosporu crassu grown on solid medium in growth tubes. Such plots of mould dry weight against distance from the margin of the colony will of course reflect the temporal changes in biomass which occur as any given part of the medium is colonized by the mould. Gillie’s results showed that during the first two days of the growth of N. crussu on a given region of the medium the mould
30
A. T. BULL AND A.
P. J. TRlNCl
biomass increased with time. Subsequently as the mould started to autolyse there was a decrease in biomass per unit area of substrate. The radial expansion of fungal colonies may be divided into four phases (Trinci, 1969):(a)lag, the period between inoculation and germtube emergence; (b) exponential, during which the colony increases in radius at an exponential rate; (c) deceleration, the period between the termination of the exponential phase and the onset of the linear phase; and (d)linear, during which the colony increases in radius at a constant or linear rate. In some fungi there is a deceleration from the linear growth rate as the colony approaches the margin of the Petri dish (see the chapter by Carlile, in Hawker and Linton, 197 1). The exponential and deceleration phases are usually of comparatively short duration, and in Aspergillus nidulans are completed by the time the colony has grown one mm from the edge of the inoculum (Trinci, 1969). Thus for most of its growth a fungal colony expands at a linear rate. The rate of the linear phase is not influenced by the ploidy of the nuclei (Lhoas, 1968). 1. Influence
of Peripheral
Growth Zone Width on Radial Expansion
Pirt (1967) suggested that growth of a microbial colony was restricted to a peripheral annulus and that growth in the centre of the colony eventually stopped due to exhaustion, or near exhaustion, of a particular nutrient. In the case of fungal colonies it has been shown that the peripheral hyphae have a much higher metabolic activity than hyphae of other regions of the colony. The rates of uptake of [3Hlleucine,13H]uridine and [3H]N-acetylglucosamine,for example, are fastest in the peripheral 2 to 3 mm of Trichoderma uiride colonies indicating that the rate of synthesis of RNA, protein and chitin is fastest in this region of the colony (Galun, 1972). Similarly, hyphae of the peripheral 1.5 mm of Aspergillus niger colonies have a faster rate of 32Puptake than other parts of the colony (Table 6). The decrease in the rate of uptake of these various compounds with distance from the colony margin suggests that there is a decrease in growth rate from the periphery to the centre of the colony. Smith ( 1924) was the first to suggest that “although the actual.extension occurs at the tip, there are grounds for believing that the parts of the hypha behind the tip contribute to the activity of the latter”. This hypothesis was subsequently implicitly or explicitly supported by the
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
31
TABLE 6. Uptake of 32P by colonies of Aspergillus n i p . Adapted from Yanagita and Kogane (1963b) Region o f the colony
Peripheral growth zone Productive zone Fruiting zone Aged zone
Width of 3zP uptake 32Puptake expressed as a the region (c.p.m./mgdry wt) per cent of the rate (mm) of uptake in the peripheral zone 1.5 2.0 4.5
3.5
4,800 1,500 300 140
100
31 6 3
~
work of Zalokar (19591, Clutterbuck and Roper (1966), Lhoas (19681, Trinci (1971) and Kau et al. (1972). Trinci ( 197 1) has shown for a number of fungi that the radial growth rate of their colonies (K,) is a function of the width of the peripheral growth zone ( w ) and the organism’s specific growth rate. Thus, K,= wp
(3)
The concept defined by Equation 3 may be considered in terms of unbranched leading hyphae traversing the peripheral growth zone of the colony. The protoplasm in such hyphae increases at, or close to, the mould’s maximum specific growth rate. This hypothetical hypha, and the colony, will only grow at a linear rate if the width of the peripheral growth zone remains constant, i.e. as the peripheral hyphae increase in length by a specific increment at the margin of the colony an equivalent increment of length is removed from the peripheral growth zone of the hypha at its inner margin. However, the hyphae in the peripheral growth zone branch, and thus some of the protoplasm produced by leading hyphae is almost certainly directed to support the initial growth of its branches (Trinci, 1970, 1974). Further, the specific rate of synthesis of protoplasm within the peripheral growth zone is likely to decrease with distance from the margin of the colony. Thus Equation 3 is unlikely to provide more than a first approximation of the rate of expansion of fungal colonies. To summarize, the peripheral growth zone has the following characteristics: (1) In colonies growing at a linear rate the width of the peripheral growth zone remains constant; (2) only growth within the peripheral zone contributes to radial expansion of the colony; regions of the colony distal to the peripheral growth zone increase in biomass (e.g. continue to branch and form a dense mycelium, and also
32
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
reproductive structures) but this growth rate does not contribute to radial expansion; and (3) growth within the peripheral growth zone is rapid and occurs at or close to the organism’s maximum specific growth rate for the prevailing conditions. The relationship defined by Equation 3 may be tested by calculating the theoretical radial growth rate of a colony from the width of its peripheral growth zone and the organism’s maximum specific growth rate and comparing this value with the observed colony radial growth rate (Trinci, 1971).
2 . Determination
of Peripheral
Growth Zone Width
The maximum width of the peripheral growth zone may be determined by calculating the minimum length of a hypha which extends at the same rate as the expansion rate of the colony. This may be done by severing peripheral growth zone hyphae and then determining their subsequent growth rate (Ryan et al., 1943; Clutterbuck and Roper, 1966; Lhoas, 1968; Trinci, 1971; Trinci, 1973; Trinci and Collinge, 1973). This method probably overestimates the length of the peripheral growth zone because of the damage which results from cutting. In the case of septate hyphae, the cutting damage appeared to be restricted to three intercalary compartments (Trinci, 197 1). The septa1 pores in the region of the cut may be plugged with Woronin bodies (Reichle and Alexander, 1965; Trinci and Collinge, 1974b)which limit loss of protoplasm. An alternative method of measuring peripheral growth zone length is to determine the length of a branch when it first attains its maximum extension rate (Trinci, 1974). For a number of fungi there is close agreement between the hypothetical colony radial growth rates, calculated from peripheral growth zone and specific growth rate measurements, and observed rates (Trinci, 197 1). The spreading colonial mutants of Neurospora crassa form colonies which are more compact and have a slower rate of expansion than colonies of wild type strains (Garnjobst and Tatum, 1967). Some of these mutants have the same maximum specific growth rate as the wild type but much slower colony radial growth rates. As predicted by Equation 3, there is a linear relationship between the rate of expansion of the colonies of these mutants and the width of their peripheral zones (Trinci, 1973b). In the case of fungi having septate hyphae it is possible that the peripheral growth zone only extends from the tip to the first septum and, in those fungi which have complete septa (i.e. lack pores), e.g.
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
33
Geotrichum candidum, Basidiobolus ranarum and Mucor hiemalis, there is little doubt that the peripheral growth zone is restricted to the apical compartment. The leading hyphae of G. candidum colonies had a mean apical compartment length of 290 k 99 pm compared with an experimentally determined peripheral growth zone width for the colonies of 423 k 129 p.Many fungi, such as Aspergillus nidulans and Neurospora crassa, form septa which initially have unoccluded central pores large enough to allow the translocation of vesicles and organelles such as nuclei (Trinci and Collinge, 1973). It is possible that the peripheral growth zone of these hyphae is limited by the plugging of the septal pores (Trinci and Collinge, 1973). The plugging of septal pores may be initiated by the establishment in the medium of conditions which inhibit growth (see Section IV, B; p. 27). Septa1 plugging may thus be considered as an ageing phenomenon. As mentioned earlier, the establishment in the substrate of conditions which are unfavourable for growth is probably related to the rate of increase in biomass per unit area of substrate. This in turn is probably a function of the organism’s specific growth rate and branching pattern, the rate of increase being fastest for strains with low hyphal growth unit values, i.e. strains which branch profusely. It is possible that there is a direct relationship between hyphal growth unit length and peripheral growth zone width (Trinci, 1973b). Certainly Morrison and Righelato (1974) have also come to this conclusion. D. C O L O N Y E X P A N S I O N A S A P A R A M E T E R O F M O U L D G R O W T H
Colony radial growth rate is only a reliable parameter of growth under conditions where it varies directly with the organism’s specific growth rate (i.e. the ratio KJp is a constant). It follows from Equation 3 that colony radial growth rate will only be directly related to the specific growth rate when the width of the peripheral growth zone of the colony remains constant. 1 . Eflect of Temperature
The width of the peripheral growth zone of a colony remains more or less constant when its rate of expansion is altered by temperature (Trinci, 197 1). Thus, colony radial growth rate may be used to determine the effect of temperature on mould growth (i.e. the ratio KJp is a canstant 1.
34
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
2. Effect o f Growth Inhibitors
Inhibitors such as qdoheximide apparently do not alter peripheral growth zone width (Trinci and Gull, 1970) at least at comparatively low concentrations. Under these circumstances, colony radial growth rate is a reliable parameter of growth (K,/c( is a constant). Several workers have shown that colony radial growth rate decreases with the logarithm of the inhibitor concentration in the medium (Trinci and Gull, 1970; Fevre, 1972; Bret, 1972). The basis for this relationship is not known. 3. Effect o f L-Sorbose It has been known for a long time that L-sorbose causes some moulds to grow in a “colonial” form, i.e. form dense colonies which have a lower rate of expansion (Tatum et al., 1959). L-Sorbose caused a
decrease in the hyphal growth unit of Neurosporu crassu (i.e. it branched more profusely) but did not affect the mould’s specific growth (Trinci and Collinge, 1973). The decrease in colony radial growth is correlated with a decrease in the width of the peripheral growth zone which in turn is presumably correlated with the observed increase in branching frequency. Cellobiose may also induce some fungi to grow in a “colonial” form in a similar way (Wilson and Niederpreum, 1967; Wilson, 1970). 4. Nutrient Concentration
The rate of expansion of glucose- and arginine- “limited” fungal colonies increased linearly with the logarithm of the nutrient concentration (Trinci, 1969; Gillie, 1968; Fiddy and Trinci, 1975). Again the basis of this relationship is not known. Most fungal colonies attain their maximum rate of expansion at very low nutrient concentrations (below about 150 mg I-’ for glucose and 80 mg I-’ for arginine). Fiddy and Trinci (1975) have shown that over the “glucose-limited” range there is a direct relationship between the radial growth rate of Geotrichum candidum colonies and the width of their peripheral growth zones. Thus, the deceleration in colony radial growth rate at glucose concentrations below about 100 mg 1-’ could be entirely accounted for by the observed decrease in peripheral growth zone width. Glucose concentration has little effect (Fiddy and Trinci, 1975) or no
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROVVTH
35
effect (Trinci, 1969) on internode length (the mean distance between adjacent primary branches produced by “leading” hyphae). Thus the variation in colony hyphal density with glucose concentration is not related to the frequency of branch initiation, but rather to their subsequent growth. At low glucose concentration branches are initiated, but most of them only grow for a short period of time before the substrate (glucose) in their vicinity becomes exhausted. At low glucose concentrations, therefore, very sparse colonies are formed but they expand at almost the maximum rate. This feature of the growth of fungal colonies clearly has some ecological significance.
5 . Growth of Diflerent Strains and Species Colony radial growth cannot be used as a parameter to compare the specific growth rates of different fungal species (Trinci, 197 1)or strains (Trinci, 1973a). The rapid rate of expansion of the colonies of many phycomycetes is largely due to their having wide peripheral growth zones rather than to their having particularly fast specific growth rates. Colonies of some phycomycetes, e.g. Rhizopus stolonijh, may have wide peripheral growth zones because their hyphae lack septa. In addition the density of hyphae at the margin of such colonies is much less than in the case of colonies of fungi like Penicillium chrysogenum which expand very slowly. E . C O M P A R I S O N O F T H E C O L O N I Z A T I O N OF S O L I D SUBSTRATES BY M O U L D S A N D UNICELLULAR M I C R O - O R G A N I S M S
The filamentous morphology of moulds enables them to colonize solid substrates more efficiently than non-motile, unicellular microorganisms. The polarization of growth within hyphae allows fungi to form colonies which have much wider peripheral growth zones than bacterial colonies (e.g. w equal to about 8.5 mm for Rhizopus stolonijer colonies (Trinci, 197 1) compared with about 90 pm for Escherichia colz colonies (Pirt, 1967)).Thus fungal colonies are able to expand across solid substrate at much faster rates than bacterial colonies although fungi usually have the slower specific growth rates. The wide peripheral growth zones of fungal colonies result in their having radial growth rates which usually exceed the rates of diffusion of chemicals in the medium. Thus secondary metabolites and other products formed at the centre of the colony diffuse through the medium at a slower rate
36
A. T.
BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
than the rate of expansion of the colony, and hence do not affect the growth rate of the peripheral hyphae. Similarly the rate of diffusion of nutrients from uncolonized parts of the medium towards the margin colony is slow compared with the rate of expansion of most fungal colonies. The leading hyphae of fungal colonies are continually growing into uncolonized medium which has approximately the same composition and pH value as the uninoculated medium. However, in the case of bacterial colonies which expand at very slow rates (Pirt, 19671, there will be a tendency for secondary metabolites formed at the centre of the colony to diffuse through the medium and inhibit growth at the periphery of the colony. In addition the concentration of nutrients in the uncolonized region of the medium surrounding the bacterial colony may be significantly lowered or even exhausted because of diffusion towards the colony (Rieck et al., 1973). These effects probably explain the gradual deceleration in the rate of expansion of bacterial colonies with time (Pirt, 1967). The growth of fungal colonies is initiated at much lower nutrient concentrations than bacterial colonies, and fungal colonies attain their maximum rate of expansion at lower nutrient concentrations than bacterial colonies (4 g 1-I for Escherichia coli (Pirt, 1967)compared with 75 mg 1-' for Mucor hiemalis; Trinci, 1969). These latter differences probably resulted from the fact that fungi, unlike bacteria, have a mechanism which regulates biomass density per unit area of substrate according to the concentration of nutrients in the medium. Thus the filamentous habit enables moulds to distribute the biomass which a solid substrate will support to maximum advantage in spreading the colony. Finally the filamentous habit enables fungi, unlike bacteria, to penetrate a solid substrate such as agar-gelled media (Trinci, 1969; Trinci, 1973a); hyphae appear to grow down into the medium at a rate similar to their growth rate across its surface.
V. Fungal Growth in Submerged Liquid Culture. Technical Considerations A variety of operational difficulties accompany the submerged cultivation of fungi. These difficulties are compounded when continuous-flow cultures (the method of choice for analysing fungal growth and metabolism; Bull and Bushell, 1976)are selected, and they
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
37
have undoubtedly inhibited the widespread use of chemostats in fungal research. Basically, the problems are related to the rheological properties of fungal cultures, the propensity of fungi to accrete over fermenter walls and internal surfaces, and to an extremely variable growth morphology. In this section brief consideration is given to the practicalities of fungal fermentations and the solution of common technical problems. A critical assessment of methods for measuring mycelial growth has been made by Calam ( 1969) and, while this topic will not be developed further here, two points may be emphasized. First, that considerable care needs to be taken to obtain representative samples from fungal cultures, especially when small scale laboratory equipment is used, and the position of sampling points, velocity of sample take-off (Solomons, 1972) and culture heterogeneity all exert a pronounced effect on the quality of the sample. Second, it is worth noting that culture absorbance can be used as an accurate growth parameter provided that measurements are restricted to biomass concentrations of less than about 2 g I-' (Trinci, 1972; Solomons, 1975). The relevance of this observation lies in the possibility of continuously monitoring mycelial growth and, thereby, developing turbidostat systems for fungi. As far as we are aware turbidostat culture of moulds has yet to be exploited. The growth form of fungal cultures profoundly affects metabolism; the relationship may be direct and reflect growth of the organism in, say, a yeast-like, mycelial or pelleted form (see p. 14) or, indirect via changes in the rheological properties of the culture. Unlike bacteria, yeasts and fungal pellets, suspensions of diffuse mycelia are nonNewtonian in character; that is their apparent viscosities are a function of the shearing produced by agitation, and the suspension may be heterogeneous with respect to the mass transfer of substrates and products. The apparent viscosity is also dependent on the mould concentration, and Solomons and Weston (19611, among others, have shown conclusively that it may be impossible adequately to aerate high-viscosity cultures in laboratory-scale fermenters. Similarly, the critical dissolved oxygen tensions for fungal cultures become greater (respiration at a submaximum rate) as the culture viscosity increases (Phillips and Johnson, 1961 ; Steel and Maxon, 1966). Unfortunately, even though adequate aeration may be provided, the degree of mixing and distribution of nutrients in a fungal culture may have an adverse effect on growth (Donovick, 1960). These effects can be exacer-
38
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
bated in continuous-flow cultures of fungi that are commonly operated at low dilution rates, i.e. < 0.03 h-? At these low rates an increasing proportion- of the energy source is consumed for “maintenance” purposes, a situation that appears to be aggravated by poor mixing. Experimental support for this view was provided by Hansford and Humphrey (1966) who observed that higher fungal yields could be obtained at low dilution rates by use of multifeed distribution and improved mixing. Various other means have been proposed for circumventing growth limitations associated with the rheological characteristics of fungal cultures. Thus, increasing the agitation but not the air flow rate (Brierley and Steel, 19691, lowering the biomass concentration, or establishing pelleted growth (approximation to Newtonian fluid) enhance culture aeration. Some recent work in Moo-Young’s laboratory has revealed that addition of water-soluble polymers to fungal cultures increased both the mass transfer of oxygen to the liquid (Moo-Young et al., 19591, the specific growth rate and other growth parameters (Elmayergi and Moo-Young, 1973). Increased rates of potassium transport induced by higher concentration gradients across the mycelial surface were considered responsible for these effects. For further information on the rheology of mycelial cultures, the reader is directed to the review of Steel (1969) and the morphology model of Roels et af. (1974). Accreted fungal growth creates difficulties in any culture system, and particularly in continuous-flow types. It provides heterogeneous conditions where, for example, anaerobic metabolism may occur in a well aerated fermenter. Bungay et al. ( 1969), using an elegant microprobe technique, showed that respiration could be prevented in microbial accretions of only 150pm thickness. When the thickness of such accretions exceeds the penetration depth of nutrients, detachment from the support surface begins, and subsequent blockage of feed and emuent lines may quickly follow. Accreted growth in chemostats leads additionally to variable culture volumes, the possibility of inadvertent feedback conditions (Solomons, 1972)and an increase the value of D,,,, (Topiwala and Hamer, 197 1). Clearly, each of these effects may vitiate the maintenance of steady-state conditions. The prevention of accreted growth essentially is a biochemical engineering problem, and several fermenter designs and operating conditions have been proposed to alleviate the problem, especially in continuous flow systems. For
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
39
further information, the interested reader is directed to the papers of Righelato and Pirt (1967), Brunner and Rohr (19721, Bull and Bushel1 (19761, Means et al. (1962) and Dawson (1963). It is sufficient to say here that the conventional stirred-tank type of fermenter can now be adapted easily for continuous culture of fungi, and one such reliable design has been reported by Rowley and Bull (1973). It has been a common experience to find that the critical dilution rate of fungi in chemostat cultures is significantly less than the value of p,,,,,derived from batch cultures grown under similar conditions. Thus, studies with Aspergzllus nidulans, A. niger, Fusarium graminearum and Mucor hiemalis (Carter and Bull, 1969; Fencl and Novak, 1969; Ng et al., 1974; Solomons, 1972; Lynch and Harper, 1974) suggested that steady state dilution rates exceeding about 50%p,,,,, (batch) could not be established. Solomons has suggested (Solomons, 1972 ; Solomons and Scammell, 1974) that such premature washout from chemostats could be due to a growth rate dependency on vitamins, and that the higher growth rates in batch cultures were consistent with a sufficiency of growth factors being present in the spore inoculum. Thus, F. graminearium was found to have a requirement for both biotin and choline. An explanation of this phenomenon, based on the obligatory accumulation of a growth-limiting “intermetabolite”, was favoured by Novak and Fencl(1973).These authors obtained some evidence for the ammonium ion being the critical intracellular metabolite when A. niger was grown in a glucose-nitrate medium; depletion of the ammonium pool occurred when D was approximatrely 4O%pma,(batch),and subsequent nitrite accumulation was considered to cause culture intoxication and washout. However, in our experience, the growth form of the fungus can be the crucial factor in determining Dct.11. Experiments with the hyaline 13 me1 mutant of A. niduluns and the wild-type strain used by Carter and Bull (1969) revealed that D,,,, values within 1% of pm.xCOUld be obtained without any modification of the medium or incubation conditions (M. E. Bushell and A. T. Bull, unpublished results). Similarly the Dorltof both strains could be decreased to about 5 5 4 0 % ,urn.=when chemostat cultures were established from suboptimal spore inocula (
40
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
observed that the onset of pelleted growth in A . niger chemostat cultures predisposed them to washout. Finally, the effects of nonmetabolized polymer additions to fungal cultures add support to our conclusions. Elmayergi -and Scharrer ( 1973) found that carboxypolymethylene (0.3%w/w) significantly enhanced the specific growth rate of A niger in batch cultures (50 to 70% increases were recorded) and the only convincing explanation of this effect was the change in fungus morphology from a pelleted to a pulpy form. VI. Kinetics of Fungal Growth in Submerged Liquid Culture
The growth kinetics of mycelial fungi has been the subject of a recent excellent review by Righelato (1975) and in a parallel essay Bull and Bushel1 ( 1976) have examined the environmental control of fungal growth. These articles include the first comprehensive accounts of continuous-flow culture studies of fungi; the present discussion, therefore, is intended to orientate the reader and provide some terms of reference for discourses on the metabolic aspects that follow. A.
RATES OF G R O W T H
I t is interesting to recall that simple forms of continuous-flow cultivation of fungi were being attempted prior to the development of the chemostat theory. Wean and Young ( 1939), for example, developed what is now recognized as a fed-batch system for growth of Pythium debaryanum, and reported increased yields and pH stability compared to simple batch cultures. The mathematical treatment of such fedbatch cultures has appeared only recently (Pirt, 1974). Although prolonged linear rates of growth under quasi-steady state conditions are possible by this form of cultivation, the first genuine chemostat experiments with fungi are accreditable to Hofsten et al. (1953). Hofsten et al. ( 1953) grew Ophiostoma multiannulatum at a dilution rate of approximately 0.14 h-' and reported apparent yields from glucose of 0.43 to 0.70 g g-', depending on the concentration of glucose in the inflowing medium. The latter value indicates that carbon other than that from glucose was being assimilated. However, a definitive testing of the applicability of chemostat theory to filamentous fungi was not made until Pirt's extensive studies of the pencillin fermentation (Pirt and Callow, 1960; Pirt and Righelato, 1967 ; Righelato et al., 1968). Subse-
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
41
quently the growth kinetics of several other fungi-mainly aspergilli-under continuous-flow conditions have been described. Typical steady state biomass and substrate concentrations as functions of dilution rate are shown in Fig. 3 for a glucose-limited chemostat culture of Aspergillus nzdulum 13 mel. The excellent agreements between experimental and theoretical values of X at dilution rates > 0.05 h-* demonstrates the validity of applying the general chemostat theory to filamentous fungi. The glucose saturation constant, K,, determined from a Lineweaver-Burk plot of S against D, was 0.1 1 g 1-' and is similar to values reported for other fungi. Although this value is small relative to SR,energy-substrate affinities several hundred-fold greater are known for Fusarium uquaeductuum(Steensland, 1973)and Neurosporu crmsa (Fiddy and Trinci, 1975).The small number of Ksdeterminations for other nutrients have been compiled by Bull and Bushell (1976) and Fiddy and Trinci (1975). Figure 3 also illustrates that, in accord with chemostat theory, the output of mycelium reaches
Dilution rote ( D ; h-' 1
FIG.3. Influence of dilution rate on the steady-state concentrations of biomass (0) and of residual glucose (0)in a glucose-limited chemostat culture of Aspergillus niduluns I3 me1 (ATCC 28270). The theoretical biomass production ( P ; 0)cuiyc was ca~cdatcd from the equation:
where Y = 0.43 g biomass g glucose-', S, = 15 g glucose I-', K,= 0.1 1 gglucosc I-I, ;und pa..= 0.205 11-! Biomass productivity was calculated as the product of D, and
x
e.,
determined by coniputor analysis. Unpublished data of M . E. Bushell and A. T. Bull.
42
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
a maximum at a dilution rate of 0.165 h-l. Morphological differentiation of the culture occurred at the extremes of the growth rate range; thus, as D approached Dcrit,pelleted growth was induced, whereas at dilution tates below 0.05 h-' the mycelium became profusely branched and produced conidia. The decreased growth yields evident at low dilution rates can be accounted for by the existence of a maintenance energy requirement; that is, energy for macromolecular turnover, osmoregulation, and movement, for example. The glucose maintenance coefficient for A . nidulans 13 mel, calculated from qslucose measurements, is 0.019 glucose g biomass-' h-l, a value very similar to those for other moulds (0.022 g g-' h-l, Penicillium chrysogenum; Righelato et al., 1968; 0.018 g g-' h-*, wild type A . nidulans 224; Carter et al., 1971). In chemostat cultures the significance of the maintenance coefficient becomes marked as D is decreased to low values. Righelato ( 1975) has calculated that the glucose maintenance requirement was only 10% of the total glucose utilization rate when P. chrysogenum was grown at p,, but amounted to 70% of the consumed glucose when D was made 0.005 h-l; the latter growth rate is typical of penicillin fermentations. The proportion of glucose diverted for maintenance functions in A . nidulans 13 me1 growing at pmaX, 0.05 and 0.02 h-' was 4, 13 and 26%, respectively. These values are comparable to ones derived for bacteria where, at maximum growth rates, about 10% of the total energy output was used for maintenance purposes (Stebbing, 1973). Maintenance requirements for oxygen have been determined for several moulds, and the values of 0.55,0.7 1 and 0.75 mmol g biomass-' h-t respectively, for A . nidulans 224 (Carter et al., 19711, Trichoderma uiride (M. A. Zainudeen personal communication) and P. chrysogenum (Mason and Righelato, 1976) are consistent with complete oxidation of the glucose used to meet the maintenance requirement. Not surprisingly, maintenance energy requirements increase under conditions of environmental stress such as high salinity (Watson, 1970) and high temperature (MatschCand Andrews, 1973). Watson recorded a 10-fold rise in the glucose maintenance coefficient for Saccharomyces cerevisiae when sodium chloride was added to the growth medium by a concentration of 1 M . The number of careful measurements of pmaxforfilamentous fungi is depressingly small (see Solomons, 1975, for a compilation). Most values are in the range 0.2 to 0.3 h-' but rates as high as 0.6 h-'
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
43
(Geotrichurncandidurn)and 0.8 h-' (Achlya bisexualis) have been reported by Trinci (1972) and Griffin et al. (1974). Recently the phenomenon of hypertrophic growth (Powell, 1972) has attracted attention; this is the condition in a two-stage chemostat where p in the second stage (p2)greatly exceeds p,,,.x. To our knowledge hypertrophic growth has not been reported for moulds but Vrana (1973) has provided an important insight into the phenomenon as it occurs in Candidu utilis. Under the conditions of Vrana's experiments, pm.x was 0.35 h-! When the dilution rate of the second stage (D2) was 1.10 h-', the rate of RNA synthesis was greater than that of DNA (i.e. the population departed from balanced growth, the organisms enlarged, produced filaments and multiple budding, and started to grow hypertrophically; p2 = 0.60 h-'). The lower differential rate of DNA synthesis produced a situation where a proportion of daughter cells lacked DNA. At the other end of the growth rate range there appears to be a finite limit below which part or all of the population differentiates and ceases to grow; this limit has been termed the minimum specific growth rate (p,,,I,J and has been determined experimentally with at least two species. Under glucose-limited conditions pmInfor P . chrysogenum was about 0.0 14 h-*. Below this growth rate the specific rate of penicillin synthesis (q,,J decayed (Pirt and Righelato, 19671, massive turnover of nucleic acids occurred and the culture conidiated (Righelato et ul., 1968). The Pu,l,of glucose-limited A. nidulans 13 me1 was approximately 10% ofpUm.x (M.E. Bushel1 and A. T. Bull, unpublished experiments); again it was identified with major morphogenetic change in the organism, and concomitantly the efficiency of ribosomes in protein synthesis reached a minimum (see Section IX, A; p. 72). Critical determinations of growth yields of fungi have been made with several species, and the reader is referred to the recent reviews by Righelato ( 1975), Solomons ( 1975) and Bull and Bushel1 ( 1976) for discussions of fungal growth efficiency. 8 . TRANSIENT A N D OSCILLATORY PHENOMENA
When a steady state is perturbed by a point or permanent change, a period of re-adjustment is required before a new steady state becomes established. Thls re-adjustment period is manifest as a transient state, the analysis of which may uncover control mechanisms for growth rate and provide practical information for the operation of steady-state
44
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
continuous-flow cultures. Hardly any studies of this sort have been made of filamentous fungi but the value of the approach has been amply demonstrated by work with yeasts. When the Monod model is applied to the analysis of perturbations resulting from stepwise changes in, say, the dilution rate or growthlimiting substrate concentration, a smooth transition towards the new steady-state biomass concentration is predicted. However, much more complex transient state kinetics usually are encountered, and the results of work by Gilley and Bungay (1967) with Saccharomyces cerevisiae clearly illustrate this point. Thus, an abrupt change in D caused the yeast population to oscillate in size, and the time required for the oscillations to damp out was related to nutrient concentration and to the size and range of the change in dilution rate. Comparable experiments with moulds have not been reported, but M. E. Bushell and A. T. Bull (unpublished data) have analysed the response of glucoselimited populations of Aspergillus nidulans to step-up and step-down changes in dilution rate. Under step-up conditions (see Fig. 41, whereas the increase in dilution rate was accommodated within three culture
UI 0
.-s m
Time ( h )
FlG. 4. Oscillations in biomass concentration, efficiency of protein synthesis and specific growth rate during a step up in dilution rate in a chemostat culture of AJpergillus niduluns 13 mel. At zero time, the dilution rate of the steady-state culture ( D = 0.125 ti') was increased to 0.175 h-'. Steady-state conditions at the higher dilution rate were established after about 12 h, that is after about three doubling times. Transient values ofp were calculated from the equation: dxldt = p X - DX.The efficiencyof protein synthesis ( E ) is given by the expression g protein g RNA-' multiplied by the specific growth rate.
'
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
45
doublings, the protein synthesis requirements for the higher growth rate were met almost immediately (see Section IX, A; p. 72). Although the response to an altered growth environment mav be rapid, as in thc case of protein synthesis, other metabolic systems may take longer to stabilize, and this is seen in the flux of metabolites through the pentose phosphate pathways in A . nidulans (Carter and Bull, 1969). Following a stepwise decrease in the dissolved oxygen tension troni 150; to 2 1 111111 Hg, the respiratory quotient and activitv of the pentose phosphate pathway oscillated, and only attained new steady-state levels after seven culture doublings; the biomass concentration reached steadv state in about 60% of this time. I t is important to realize, therefbre. that even if’ biomass and growth-limiting substrate concentrations have reached steady states other culture parameters may still be exhibiting transient beha\ w u r . Pye (1969) made a very detailed investigation ofglycolvtic flux oscillations following the addition of glucose and trehalose to. yeast suspensions. Oscillations in NADH, concentration were thought to be induced by the allosteric activation of phosphofruktokinase. Such a control mechanism produced a predictable short-cycle oscillation and, due to the point stimulation (hexose addition), the oscillations eventually damped out. More recently Poole et al. (1973) have attempted to resolve oscillatory respiratory activity in synchronously dividing populations of Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Respiration was considered to comprise two components, only one of which oscillated and, although the control mechanism has not been identified, i t possibly relates to a Pasteur effect. Finally the phenomenon of rhythmic mycelial growth of fungi on solid and non-agitated liquid media has long been known and examined by mycologists. Nectria cinnabarina, for example, produces colonies consisting of concentric rings or spirals, about 1 mm apart, that define growth rate oscillations with a 16-hour period. Winfree (1973) has proposed a number of models that attempt to interpret rhythmic growth patterns of this type; he considers that the most acceptable model is based on a unique unstable state, established at spore germination, persisting in the peripheral growth zone of the colony and damping out rapidly behind this zone. Although the nature of this metabolic instability is imprecisely defined at present, it appears to be focused o n an oscillating flux of carbohydrate through catabolic and hyphal wall-synthesizing pathways (Lysek and Esser, 197 1); ’
46
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
Bornefeld and Lysek, 1972. The interested reader will find the stimulating papers of Winfree (1970,1973)a valuable source offurther information and ideas. A circadian rhythm’ of conidiation has been recognized for many years in Neurosporn cru.wz, and several classes of morphological mutants liave been described in which the periodicity has been disturbed. In the (01 niutaiits, for example, a partial block in pentose phosphate pathway has been implicated as a specific biochemical lesion (Brody, 1970; see also Section VIII, C; p. 70). Halaban (1975) recently has described a palch mutant that produced alternatively, o n a medium containing 5% glucose, sparse and dense aerial hyphae with a periodicity of about 50 hours but had retained the wild- type circadian rhythm of conidiation. She also showed that the period was a function of glucose concentration, and that it decreased with decreasing glucose concentration. In this niutant, the biochemical lesion was found to involve a loss of the low-affinity glucose transport system (see Section VII, C ; p. 5 3 ) . The causal relationship between this transport deficiency and the morphological growth rhythm has not been explored but its basis could reside in an altered plasma membrane. c . “MACROREGULATION”
O F GROWTH
A growth regulatory system recently has been described in Neurospora c r a m that may be an example of a distinct class of overall or macroregulatory” phenomena. Reissig and Glasgow ( 197 1) have proposed that a galactosaminoglycan found extracellularly, and in the walls, of N . c r a m is a mediator molecule in such a regulatory mechanism. The polysaccharide (MW about 1 x lo6 daltons) produced by colonial mutants and by wild-type strains causes a severe decrease in the growth rate when added to young cultures. The effects induced by galactosaminoglycan included vacuolation, agglutation, a lethal effect on conidia and an impairment of transport functions, from which data the plasma membrane appears to be a probable candidate for the site of interaction. Conidia exposed to galactosaminoglycan lose the capacity to transport substrates and to form colonies. Subsequently Glasgow and Reissig (1974)have investigated the killing kinetics of galactosaminoglycan and found that one to three “hits” were lethal. However, each “hit” required about lo5 molecules of the glycan. The low probability of a “hit” per molecule suggests that only a few of the total binding sites for galactosaminoglycan function as receptors for (6
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROVVTH
47
lethal events. The biochemical nature of the lethal event awaits elucidation. Similarly the occurrence of this phenomenon in fungi has not been surveyed but it is interesting to note that galactosaminoglycans are wall components of other fungi such as Aspergillus nidulans (Bull, 1970). D . MAINTAINED A N D STARVATION STATES
When a fungal population becomes depleted of nutrients its subsequent course of development depends on which nutrient is first exhausted. The classic study of differential nutrient exhaustion on fungal growth is that of Borrow et al. ( 1961) on Gibberellafujiikuroi. Their experiments, made in batch fermenters, revealed that, depending on the sequence of nutrient depletion: (1) growth could continue at a linear rate; (2) growth could cease but synthesis of storage and secondary metabolites continue, and (3) exhaustion of endogenous substrates could lead to autolysis. Lysis could be prevented by supplying carbonand energy-depleted populations with an appropriate substrate at the maintenance rate. The behaviour of non-growing, carbon-starved and maintained cultures has been intensively analysed with Penicillium chrysogenum and Aspergtllus nidulans 224. (Trinci and Righelato, 1970 ; Bainbridge et al., 197 1). Following the onset of glucose deprivation in glucose-limited chemostat cultures of these fungi, the biomass concentration declined with a half-life of about 50 to 60 hours. Massive degradation ofprotein, RNA and DNA had occurred after 120 hours and post-starvation levels were about 25% (P. chysogenum)and40% ( A . nidulans) of zero-time values. In contrast, changes in carbohydrate were much less significant and reflected the lack of carbon storage materials in the mycelium; little change in wall thickess was reported. Catabolic activities (q,,, TCA cycle flux) declined rapidly during the initial 10 hours of starvation. Attempts were made to monitor viability changes in starving A . nidulans cultures, and even after 96 hours the viability index was 0.6. However, viability determinations on filamentous organisms are difficult to make, and the value obtained is likely to have been an overestimate. When the glucose feed rate to chemostat cultures of the two species was lowered to the maintenance ration, fungal dry weight remained constant and, after fluctuating slightly, so did the protein and carbohydrate contents. Under these conditions the Penicillium mycelium differentiated, and conidia were produced in large numbers. This
48
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
difyerentiation was reflected in the rapid and large turnover in RNA and DNA. On the other hand, the RNA content of maintained Aspergillus cultures varied little, and conidiation was very slight. Respiratory activity decayed following a lowering of the glucose supply rate to maintenance levels but the respiratory quotient remained close to unity. However, considerable changes in glucose catabolism were observed in A . nidulans (Bainbridge et al., 197 1). During the preceding steady state about 20% of the glucose was metabolized via the pentose phosphate pathway, but within 10 hours of switching to a maintained state the flux through the Embden-Meyerhof pathway was essentially 100%. This change is related to the minimal biosynthetic requirement for NADPH, in maintained populations. The capacity to synthesize penicillin was lost from maintained cultures of P. chysogenum at a rate related inversely to the previous steady-state dilution rate (Pirt and Righelato, 1967). Not all secondary biosyntheses decay in this fashion as demonstrated by the continued production of melanin by A . nidulans.
VII. Transport- Controlled Features of Growth A . TRANSPORT-LIMITED GROWTH
Detailed studies of transport phenomena in fungi have been made with relatively few species and most information is related to Saccharomyces cerevisae and other yeasts, Aspergillus nidulans and Neurospora crassa. Nevertheless a wide range of transport systems has been reported in fungi (Rothstein, 1966; Burnett, 1968; Kotyk and Janacek, 1970; Jennings, 1974). It is not out intention to re-iterate this body of information but, instead, we wish to explore the relationship between transport, and its control, and growth. In addition we will emphasize the significance of mechanisms which fungi possess for modulating their transport and assimilation processes in response to the growth environment. The kinetic treatment of transport-limited growth given by Van Uden ( 1967, 1969)is the most useful starting point for these discussions, but to date few other workers have followed his lead. Van Uden analysed transport-limited growth from the viewpoints of diffusion kinetics (passive diffusion mechanism) and Michaelis-Menten kinetics
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
49
(facilitated diffusion and active transport mechanisms). For transport systems obeying Michaelis-Menten kinetics it can be shown that:
where kmaXis the maximum transport rate of the growth-limiting nutrient, Y is the yield factor, S, and S, are the concentrations of growth-limiting nutrient in the medium and the organism, respectively, and K,, and K,, are respectively the Michaelis constants of transport of the limiting nutrient into and out from the organism. Because the value of S2 is usually very low, the second term in parentheses can be omitted, while a maintenance term can be added to p in order to correct for the variation in yield with growth rate. Similarly Lax will be a function growth rate because of concomitant changes in organism size (and hence surface area). Tests of this model have been made with a non-growing yeast suspension and it was found that: (a) the rate of glucose assimilation by aerobic populations was limited by the rate of phosphorylation (by hexokinase) and was not transport-limited; and (b) assimilation by anaerobic populations was transport-limited and subject to competitive inhibition by L-sorbose (Van Uden, 1967). Moreover, transport-limited growth was observed in glucose-limited chemostats under anaerobic conditions and under aerobiosis with a respiratory-deficient strain. The K , (glucose)value was lower by a factor of ten than previously published values (e.g. Van Steveninck and Rothstein, 1965, reported a value of about 5 x M ) and it is tempting to speculate that the affinity difference is a consequence of selection under circumstances of substrate limitation. Van Uden ( 1969) has also examined diffusion transport of growthlimiting nutrients and found that in neither glycerol- nor oxygenlimited populations of Candida utilis was the diffusion process a significant control on the specific growth rate. However, it should be recalled that diffusion-limited situations are readily established in pelleted cultures of fungi. Virtually nothing is known about transport-limited growth of filamentous fungi, but the establishment of transport-limited cultures offers many interesting experimental possibilities, some which are clearly suggested from the work of Von Meyenburg ( 197 1) on bacterial growth. For example, mutants having increased K m values for various nutrients can be used to produce high densities of organisms in batch cultures under growth rate-limiting substrate concentrations.
50
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
B . TRANSPORT REGULATION
Nutrient uptake is effectively controlled in fungi at the levels of transport activity and synthesis and clearly, if uptake is under metabolic control, nutrient assimilation (and hence growth) will be increasingly efficient. Fine control of transport in fungi frequently is achieved by feedback inhibition. Uptake of amino acids and pyrimidines, for example, is usually subject to very specific feedback inhibition. A detailed analysis has been made of the way by which acetate prevents utilization of a large number of sugars by Aspergillus nidulans (reviewed by Romano, 1973). Acetate exerts its effect on sugar transport, not on sugar metabolism, and acetyl-CoA appears to be the most likely regulator molecule. In this context it is interesting to speculate that the potentiating effects of acetate on secondary metabolite synthesis in fungi may be due to a sparing of sugar uptake rather than to its provision as a precursor. Sugar transport into filamentous fungi seems not to involve a phosphorylation step. Indeed, phosphorylation of sugar analogues such as Z-deoxy-D-glucose, which was taken as presumptive evidence of group translocation, has been shown conclusively to be a post- transport event mediated by intracellular kinases (Brown and Romano, 1969). Repression control of transport affects uptake, by fungi, of various nutrients including amino acids and vitamins (Wiley, 1970; Hiitter, 1973; Rogers and Lichstein, 1969). Amino-acid transport has been studied extensively in Neurospora crassa, a fungus that has three specific systems for neutral, basic and acidic amino acids, and a fourth nonspecific system. The operation of these transport systems is affected by the growth environment, and especially interesting is the fact that nonspecific transport was induced under conditions of nitrogen exhaustion (Benko et al., 1969). Ammonium ions probably repressed the latter system when there was a sufficiency of nitrogen, and the internal ammonium ion concentration fell four-fold following starvation. The results of the work of Wiley (1970)on tryptophan transport in N . c r a m has shown that, as in bacteria, repression of fungal transport systems caused a marked decrease in the concentration of specific binding proteins. Vitamin nutrition can exert a profound influence over amino-acid transport and the maintenance of pool sizes and, consequently, may determine whether or not growth is balanced. Studies of this kind have related mainly to yeasts (e.g. Moat et al., 1969) but biotin deficiency
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
51
decreases the transport of glucose and ammonium ions into Aspergillus nidulans (Desi and Modi, 1975). The precise effect of biotin in the Aspergillus system is not known; the glucose-binding proteins from biotin-deficient and replete mycelia appeared to be identical, therefore the effect may be one of repression or may be indirect. As we have already noted, vitamin uptake itself may be under repression control. Thus the biotin uptake system of Saccharomyces cerevisiae is repressed by high exogenous concentrations of the vitamin (Cicmanec and Lichstein, 1974) and turnover of the system occurs under such conditions of repression. However, repression of synthesis enabled only a slow adaptation to a changing exogenous biotin status and rapid responses were accommodated by a biotin excretion mechanism. Cicmanec and Lichstein (1974) suggest that excretion prevented biotin accumulation during the period when repression and turnover of the transport system was occurring, and before it was fully repressed. Indeed, excretion may be a widespread control process in the regulation of sizes of fungal metabolite pools, even when uptake of the compound is controlled by a specific feedback inhibition. Excretion will be an especially important means of pool regulation under circumstances of endogenous overproduction. Regulation of amino acid and pyrimidine pools in yeast, via excretion, has been discussed by Grenson ( 1973) but data on emux mechanisms are scarce. The work of Jennings and his colleagues has revealed a particularly interesting control over the rate of sugar uptake by the marine fungus Dendvphiella salzna that simultaneously maintains osmotic homeostasis in the mycelium. 3-0-Methyl glucose was not metabolized by D . salzna but was accumulated by an active transport mechanism. However, the mycelial concentrations of arabitol and mannitol fell as the methyl glucoside was taken up, so that the total soluble carbohydrate pool size remained remarkably constant (Jennings and Austin, 1973). A channelling of polyols into polysaccharide synthesis appeared to occur in proportion to the amount of sugar transported. A stable internal osmotic pressure is of significance in fungi, where apical hyphal rupture is readily induced by osmotic shock. Sugar transport in Dendryphiella also is inhibited by acetate, but whether acetyl-CoA or a polyol is the regulating compound remains to be elucidated (Holligan and Jennings, 1973). Polyols are synthesized during acetate utilization, and if they do inhibit sugar transport their significance in the regulation of internal osmotic pressure is reinforced. Repression of nitrogen-metabolizing enzymes and nitrogen-
52
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
transport systems by ammonium ions, or other nitrogen-containing metabolites, is a widespread phenomenon in fungi and illustrates the tightly integrated nature of regulatory mechanisms. Our understanding of ammonia regulation is especially detailed in Aspergillus niduluns, where two control systems have been revealed: (i) the extracellular ammonia concentration determines the rate of uptake of Lglutamate, urea and thiourea, and the activity of certain enzymes such as nitrate reductase; (ii) the intracellular ammonia concentration determines the rate of uptake of ammonia. Ammonia was preferentially utilized by A. niduluns and A. clauatus when growth occurred on a mixture of nitrogen sources (Robinson et al., 1973, 1974) and one repercussion of this situation relates to the practice of using ammonia gas for control of pH value in commercial fungal fermentation. Thus, the major nitrogen source and/or supplementary nitrogen compounds may be inefficiently utilized due to ammonia repression, or inhibition of the respective uptake systems. Similarly it has been argued that in the absence of extracellular ammonia it may be disadvantageous for a fungus to utilize any single nitrogen source exclusively (Pateman et ul., 1973) and advantageous simultaneously to utilize nitrate, glutamate or purines if they are available. The latter systems are not regulated by intracellular ammonia until its concentration exceeds about 4 mM at which point efflux commences. One class of mutants (gdhA) lack the normal NADP-linked glutamate dehydrogenase and are derepressed for both types of ammonia regulation, and Pateman et al. (1973) have presented a unifying model of theie ammonia effects in which NADP-linked glutamate dehydrogenase assumes a regulatory function. Plasma membrane-bound NADPlinked glutamate dehydrogenase is thought to complex with extracellular, but not intracellular, ammonia and thereby regulates the category (i) processes. A second glutamate dehydrogenase regulatory complex may be formed with intracellular ammonia when the enzyme is displaced from the membrane and affects ammonia uptake. When Lglutamate was the sole, or main, source of carbon, ammonia regulation of glutamate transport was alleviated and NADP-linked glutamate dehydrogenase was rapidly turned over (Kinghorn and Pateman, 1974). Although Pateman’s hypothesis requires rigorous experimental testing, it is consistent with many of the established observations, and notably that gdhA mutants are not defective in any known transport function. However, Arst and Cove ( 1973) have challenged the
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
53
idea of a direct role for NADP-linked glutamate dehydrogenase in this context, and favour the view that a product of the areA locus (mutations which produce pleiotropic loss of ability to use sources of nitrogen other than ammonia) plays a more direct role. Until more data are forthcoming, resolution of this control system cannot be made. C. MODULATION O F FUNGAL TRANSPORT PROCESSES
Major imbalances in sizes of metabolite pools can have serious consequences for microbial growth and may be growth retarding, or even lethal. Therefore, ability to modulate substrate uptake and metabolism in the face of a changing nutrient status confers considerable selective advantage on an organism. As we have seen, lowering the polyol pool in Dendryphiella in response to non-metabolizable sugar accumulation provides osmotic homeostasis. Fungi can also respond to large fluctuations in nutrient availability in other ways. First, they can synthesize and maintain a large excess of transport components; this is the situation with phosphate uptake by Rhodotorulu mbru organisms (Button et ul., 1973) in which half of the components are operative at a growth rate of 0.5 ,urnaxand only 4% at prnam Clearly the maintenance-energy requirement for such a system will be high. Alternatively, fungi have evolved high- and low-affinity systems for uptake of individual nutrients, the operation of which is mediated by their extracellular concentrations. Two transport systems for glucose are known in Neurosporu crussu that are distinguishable on the basis of their affinities. Scarborough ( 1970a, b) described a low-affinity facilitated diffusion system (apparent K,,, = 8 mM) that was operative when the fungus was grown in glucosecontaining media (about 9 g1-3. However, when growth occurred in media containing a similar concentration of fructose, or on a low concentration of glucose (about 0.2 g P I , an alternative high-affinity active transport system was induced (apparent K, = 10 pM). A similar dual glucose transport system has been detected in ungerminated conidia of this fungus (Neville et ul., 1971). The differential operation of these alternative uptake systems has obvious implications in the efficiency of growth and germination. It can be argued that, when glucose is plentiful, active transport is uneconomical and the constitutive facilitated diffusion system can maintain an adequate intracellular concentration. On the other hand, the high-affinity system enables effective uptake under conditions of severe glucose limitation.
54
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
I t is interesting to note that sugar assimilation as well as transport may be modulated according to prevailing growth conditions. For example, Roberts ( 1970) has described two systems for lactose and galactose metabolism in Aspirgillus niduluns that are regulated by pH value. The first, operative in galactose-grown mycelia at pH 4 to 6.5, involved p-galactosidase and transphosphorylation, while the nature of the second system has not been established fully but may involve direct oxidation of galactose (Fantes and Roberts, 1973). The second system was operative at a pH value of 7.5. Fantes and Roberts pointed out that pgalactosidase activity was essential for conidial germination, though not for mycelial growth, but a mechanistic interpretation of these observations remains to be made. Recognition of this alternative route helps to rationalize certain inconsistent data (Paszewski et ul., 1970)on the regulation of lactose utilization. Sucrose assimilation by the ergot fungus Cluviceps purpureu also provides an interesting example of metabolic modulation. Dickerson ( 1972) reported that when sucrose was the sole carbon source it was metabolized via p-fructofuranosidase; two molecules of sucrose were transfructosylated to form a trisaccharide (F2-6G1-2F) and assimilable free glucose. Further glucose release was provided from a second transfructosylation of the trisaccharide with sucrose to yield a tetrasaccharide (F2- 1F2-6G1-2F)plus glucose. With the exhaustion of glucose these oligosaccharides may be hydrolysed or transglycosylated with release of fructose; fructose assimilation occurred only in the absence of glucose, and was growth inhibitory at a concentration greater than 30% (w/v). I t has been proposed (Nisbet, 1975)that the transfer system regulates fructose concentrations so as to maintain non-inhibitory levels and to provide a carbohydrate reserve. Furthermore, the transferase system was operative under circumstances of low energy demand and low concentrations of free sugars; a hydrolytic system replaced transglycosylation under conditions of high catabolic activity (e.g. at the time of sphacelial to sclerotial differentiation in parasitic and axenic cultures), or when the availability of free sugars was high. Modulation of glycerol-assimilation pathways has been described for bacteria (Neijssel et uf., 1974) and similar high- and low-efficiency glycerol-uptake processes might exist in fungi. For example, glycerol kinase synthesis in Neurosporu crussu is induced by low temperature, whereas at normal growth temperatures (26OC) the enzyme is rapidly inactivated (North, 1973, 1974). The latter may represent a control
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
55
system, albeit an uneconomic one, for regulating uptake of glycerol under circumstances where a simple diffusion process is adequate for the needs of the organism. Transport of anions, such as sulphate and phosphate, is known to occur via separate systems in a number of fungi. Sulphate transport in Neurospora crasa, for example, is mediated by two distinct permeases; permease I has low substrate affinity ( K , = 200 pM), and is associated with conidia, whereas permease I1 has a much greater affinity ( K , = 8 pM) and is mycelial in location (Marzluf, 1970). Synthesis of these transport systems is repressed by methionine. The specificity of fungal sulphate permeases has some interesting consequences for growth. In N . crmsa, chromate competes for sulphate permeases (Roberts and Marzluf, 197 1) while SO:-, S,Oi; SeOi-and MoOf enter Aspergtllusnidulansby a common permease. Tweedie and Segal( 1970) have argued that molybdate transport by the sulphate uptake system may be disadvantageous because the latter was controlled by sulphur nutrition; under conditions of sulphur sufficiency, the sulphate permease was repressed and molybdate assimilation via this route prevented. Uptake of Mo02,- by the sulphate- transport system also ceased under acidic conditions (below a pH value of 5 ) . Consequently molybdate uptake by A. nidulans may occur by some additional system. More recently Reinert and Marzluf (1974) have shown that N . c r a ~ ~possesses a a low-affinity transport system for glucose 6-sulphate that is distinct from both the glucose and the sulphate transport systems, and again is methionine repressible. Glucose 6-sulphate can serve as a sole source of sulphur but is not a significant source of carbon. An interesting example of modulation of transport systems is that for the uptake of phosphate by N . crassu. Two phosphate-transport systems have been described, one of which has high afinity, and is derepressed under phosphorus starvation conditions; the other lowaffinity system ( K m = 123pM) is sufficient to support exponential growth under conditions of phosphate sufficiency (Lowendorf et ul., 1974). These authors calculated that a phosphate flux of about 1.20 mmol. 1 cell water-' min-' would be necessary to support exponential growth of N . crassa at a rate of 0.27 h-l, and observed a flux (J)of 1.63 mmol . I cell water-: at pH 5.8, and an external phosphate concentration of 37 mM. A further finding of considerable interest was the dependence of K , on the pH value of the medium. Over the range of pH values from 4.0 to 7.3, theJ,,, oscillated around a mean value of
56
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
1.42 mmol. 1 cell water-'min-', but the K , increased from 10 pM to 3.62 mM. Does the dependence reflect two separate transport systems? The data of Lowendorf et al. (1974) eliminated such an explanation, and, of the single-system models considered, OH- or H+modification of the transport mechanism was most consistent with the experimental evidence. The OH- ions could compete with PO:- at the binding sites, or PO:- may be cotransported with H+; in either case a high external pH value would affect transport. It should be emphasized that the effects of changes in external pH value on the efficiency of nutrient uptake may be explicable in terms other than those proposed by Lowendorf et al. (1974). Thus, a carrier that can exist in protonated and unprotonated forms will have different K , values for its substrate(s1,and the proportions of the two forms will be pH-dependent. An elegant illustration of such a modulation is found in the work of Tanner (19741, albeit with a microalga, on sugar transport. Over the range of pH values from 6.0 to 8.8, the amount of high-affinity (i.e. protonated) carrier ( K m = 2 10 pM) decreased commensurately with an increase in low-affinity (i.e. unprotonated) carrier ( K , = 50 mM). To our knowledge comparable systems have not yet been reported to occur in fungi. As a final example of mechanisms which fungi have evolved for modulating their assimilation of nutrients we will consider ammonia. Among the possibilities for ammonia assimilation in protists are routes involving aspartase, NADP-linked glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH) and the glutamine synthetase-glutamate synthase (GS/GOGAT) system. In bacteria, the significance of the GS/GOGAT system lies in its efficiency for scavenging ammonia in ammonia-limited environments; the apparent K , values for GDH and GS in Aerobacter aerogenes are 10 mM and 0.5 mM, respectively (Meers et al., 1970). In a recent review, Brown et al. (1974) stated that the only clearly demonstrable pathway of ammonia assimilation in moulds and yeasts is the synthesis of glutamic acid via glutamate dehydrogenase and that GOGAT had not been demonstrated in these organisms. Brown and Stanley (1972) had suggested a number of ways in which the relatively high K , of glutamate dehydrogenase for ammonia is counteracted in yeasts: (a) NH, rather than NH,+ is the native substrate, and the variation in K , with pH value ensures that the higher the intracellular pH value the more active is the glutamate dehydrogenase at low extracellular ammonia concentrations; (b) synthesis of a large excess of
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
57
glutamate dehydrogenase also enables effective ammonia assimilation. Subsequently GOGAT has been demonstrated in several yeast genera (Roon et al., 1974; Johnson and Brown, 19741, but its presence in mycelial fungi has not been definitely established. Roon et al. (1974) found that the apparent K,,, of glutamate dehydrogenase and GOGAT were approximately equal (about 10 mM) in Saccharmyces cerevisiae and they suggested that the glutamate synthase (GOGAT) had a function that was auxiliary to glutamate dehydrogenase, or else had a different subcellular location. However, Johnson and Brown ( 1974) measured the contents of glutamine synthetase, as well as GOGAT and glutamate dehydrogenase, in several Schizosaccharomyces species, and concluded that assimilation of low or growth-limiting concentrations of ammonia was the likely function of the GUGOGAT pathway, and that the glutamate dehydrogenase route would operate in environments containing an excess of ammonia. VIII. Metabolic Control in Fungi A.
INTERMEDIARY METABOLISM
1. Fermentative versus Oxidative Metabolism
Most fungi are strictly aerobic organisms that can grow at wide extremes of dissolved oxygen tension but, additionally, a fav authenticated examples of facultative anaerobic species are known (Bull and Bushell, 1976). However, many fungi can ferment carbohydrates anaerobically with the formation of ethanol, lactic acid and other products, and the flux partitioning of substrates between the various glycolytic pathways is considered below. The rate of carbon dissimilation via fermentative and oxidative pathways in fungi is sensitive to oxygen availability, and especially to the concentration and nature of the carbon source. Until quite recently, the regulation of these pathways and its relationship to growth rate was known only for yeasts. Thus, early studies of batchgrown Saccharomyces cerevisiae organisms (Polakis and Bartley, 1965 ; Polakis et al., 1965; Gorts, 1967) demonstrated that, although glucose inhibited synthesis of enzymes of the TCA cycle, glyoxylate cycle and electron- transport chain, fermentative metabolism could provide a high rate of energy generation and support high specific growth rates
58
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
(about 0.4 h-'1. Following glucose disappearance, the accumulated ethanol was assimilated by the now derepressed oxidative pathways. These workers also made the important discovery that carbon substrates that supported lower specific growth rates (compared with glucose) also caused much less repression of respiration. Van Wijk ( 1968) extended these investigations, and examined catabolite repression of respiratory enzymes and a-glucosidase in Sacch. ceverisiae and Sacch. carlsbergensis. He found that a strong positive correlation existed between the specific activities of a-glucosidase and enzymes of the TCA cycle during growth on various sugars, but oxygen availability did not change the correlation; i.e. the correlation was not due to a direct effect of respiration on a pool of repressing catabolite(s1.Subsequently glucose-limited chemostat experiments confirmed the relationship between the fermentation-oxidation state and specific growth rate (Fiechter and von Meyenberg, 1966; Beck and von Meyenberg, 1968). The degree of fermentative metabolism increased with dilution rate and, at dilution rate values greater than 0.2 h-l, the q 0 2was repressed and the respiratory quotient rose from unity to 7 (at D = 0.42 h-'). Of course, not all yeasts are sensitive to catabolite repression of respiration, and Kluyveromycesfragilis, for example, exhibits the Pasteur effect when grown on glucose (Chassang-Douillet et al., 1973). Detailed studies of fermentative-oxidative transitions in filamentous fungi have been made in continuous cultures of Aspergillus nidulans 224, and with two phycomycetes, namely Mucor genevensis and Cokeromyces poitrarsi. With glucose-limited cultures of A . nidulans, a qualitative change in carbon catabolism was observed at a dilution rate of 0.055 h-', corresponding to a stimulation of fermentation (Carter and Bull, 1969; Carter et al., 197 1); a decreased yield from glucose accompanied this change. Similarly, a shift to fermentative metabolism occurred at dissolved oxygen tensions below 30 mm Hg (Carter and Bull, 1969). An interesting feature of these shifts towards fermentation in A . nidulans was the differential enhancement of the pentose phosphate pathway compared to the Embden-Meyerhof pathway (see p. 59). Rogers et al. (1974) analysed the effects of oxygen on carbon metabolism in glucose-limited and glucose-excess continuous cultures of M . geneuensis. Under glucose-limitation (SR = 5 g l-'), a shift from fermentative to oxidative metabolism accompanied an increase in the dissolved oxygen tension (DOT) from < 0.1 to about 8 mm Hg, and concomitantly the yield increased five-fold. Respiration was severely
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
59
repressed under conditions of glucose-excess (S, = 60 g 1-’ ; S = 20 to 40 g 1-l) even when the DOT was maintained at approximately 50 mmHg. An essentially similar change in glucose catabolism, with a change in DOT, was observed with cultures of C. poitrassi (Rogers and Gleason, 1974). Considerable evidence exists linking fermentative to oxidative transitions with yeast-mycelium dimorphism in fungi, particularly in members of the Mucorales. In other words, “filamentous morphology in fungi might be regarded in many instances as a morphogenetic expression of the Pasteur effect” (Terenzi and Storck, 1969). Terenzi and Storck induced a yeast morphology in M . rouxii by exposure of the organisms to phenethyl alcohol, an agent that did not affect the q 0 2 value or cytochrome synthesis but is believed to uncouple oxidative phosphorylation. Phenethyl alcohol progressively repressed conidium and mycelium development in Neurospora crassa (Turian et al., 19721, and increasingly restricted oxidative metabolism. In the absence of inhibitors, these morphogenetic events seem to be regulated specifically by glucose and not by the oxygen status of the medium (Rogers et al., 1974; Rogers and Gleason, 1974; Schulz et al., 1974; Friedenthal et al., 1974).
2. Flux Partitioning between the Embden-Meyerhof Pathway and the Pentose Phosphate Pathways A variety of glycolytic sequences are known to occur in fungi, including the Embden-Meyerhof (EM) pathway and the hexose monophosphate pathways (such as the pentose phosphate (PP) and Entner-Doudoroff pathways), and usually two such pathways (most often the EM and PP) operate simultaneously. When the EM and PP pathways are present together, the former usually predominates, and rather less than 30 to 40% of the carbon flux is via the PP route. The factors regulating partition of carbon between the alternative glycolytic pathways are not fully known; moreover little study has been made of their operation under varying growth conditions. In discussing this subject it is useful to reiterate the particular synthetic functions of the pentose phosphate pathway, viz. provision of pentose sugars, especially ribose 5-phosphate for nucleotide synthesis, and provision of NADPH, for synthesis of glutamate, fatty acids and sterols. Blumenthal ( 19651, in his review of fungal glycolysis, remarked that
60
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
there had been no systematic studies made of the effects of physical and physiological variables on the relative functioning of glycolytic pathways. During the intervening decade, however, a few such analyses have been reported. Thus, Carter and Bull (1969) found that the proportion of glucose catabolized via the pentose-phosphate pathway by glucose-limited chemostat populations of Aspergzllus nidulans 224 (nitrate as nitrogen-source) varied directly with dilution rate up to a maximum of 37% at Furthermore, and in contrast to Escherichia coli (Bengali and Hempfling, 19721, enzymes of the pentose-phosphate pathway, such as glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase, were induced by glucose (Carter and Bull, 1969) and the flux through the pathway increased dramatically following transient rises in the glucose concentration (Carter and Bull, 1969; 1971). Subsequently Smith and his colleagues (Ng et al., 1974) extended this type of analysis to A. niger, and obtained analogous results with glucose-limited organisms (ammonia as nitrogen-source) but found citrate-limitation partially repressed both the EM and pentose-phosphate pathways. Earlier experiments by Smith and Ng (19721, using batch cultures, suggested that phosphorylating enzymes acting before fructose diphosphate cleavage (i.e. hexokinase and phosphofructokinase) appeared to regulate glycolysis, and application of the cross-over theorem (Chance et al., 1958) for identifying control sites in glycolysis revealed a distinct control point between fructose 6-phosphate and fructose 1,6-diphosphate. Phosphofructokinase is subject to multivalent allosteric control by a number of effector molecules, including ATP and citrate. Thus, excessive flux through the EM pathway is likely to be prevented at the level of phosphofructokinase by ATP and, because the equilibrium constant of the isomerase is close to unity, fructose 6-phosphate will not accumulate; instead glucose 6-phosphate is channeled into the pentose-phosphate pathway. The observed effects of citrate (Ng et al., 1974) also may be interpretable in terms of phosphofructokinase inhibition. Recently Mian et al. ( 1974) have reported similar growth rate-dependent fluxes of glucose through the different glycolytic pathways in yeasts. As the dilution rate of a glucose-limited chemostat culture was increased from 0.1 to 0.5 h-I, the flux through the pentose phosphate pathway increased linearly from about 25% to 60%. When steady-state cultures of A. nidulans were deprived of an exogenous carbon and energy source, or when .such cultures were
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
61
supplied with a glucose feed only slightly in excess (1.5 times) of the maintenance ration, the flux through the pentose-phosphate pathway rapidly decayed and within, respectively, 4 and 10 hours the flux was almost undetectable (Bainbridge et al., 1971). These changes were entirely consistent with those of the macromolecular composition of starved and maintained populations, and reflect their negligible biosynthetic demand. Data on the effect of dissolved oxygen tension on flux partitioning is rather confused (see Blumenthal, 1965) and only one systematic examination has been described (Carter and Bull, 1969). When the dissolved oxygen tension of steady-state cultures ( D = 0.05 h-') of A . nidulans was decreased stepwise, relatively small flux changes occurred in the EM and pentose-phosphate pathways until values between 5 and 10 mm Hg were attained. At this point, however, the flux through the pentose-phosphate pathway rose from about 30%, and reached a maximum of 55% as the dissolved oxygen tension approached a critical value (1.75 mmHg; Carter and Bull, 1971); simultaneously, the specific activity of glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase increased three-fold. The sharp rise in pentose-phosphate metabolism at these low DOT values was paralleled by the appearance of NADPH,-linked dissimilating nitrate reductase activity (see below; p. 62). The pentose-phosphate pathway appears to play a vital role in differentiating fungal cultures. One of the first observations of this correlation was made by McDowell and De Hertogh ( 1968) who described a preferential stimulation of the enzymes of the pentose-phosphate pathway during sporulation of Endothia parasitica in submerged culture, while Carter and Bull (1969) revealed an identical situation in conidiating batch cultures of Aspergillus nidulans. Comparable studies of conidiation in A . niger (Smith et al., 197 1) initially did not corroborate this presumed association between a high rate of flux through the pentose phosphate pathway and morphogenesis. However, L-glutamate was a major component of the growth medium used by Smith et al., (197 1) and would likely relieve the increased demands for NADPH, occurring during sporulation. Subsequent experiments with nitratecontaining media produced results that were in full agreement with those of McDowell and De Hertogh ( 1968) and Carter and Bull ( 1969) (Ng et al., 1972). The last authors found that highest EM pathway activity occurred in vegetative cultures. Secondary metabolite formation in penicillia and aspergillus was favoured when glucose catabolism
62
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
proceeded via the EM route (Bu’Lock et al., 1965; Carter and Bull, 1969; Shih and Marth, 1974). Finally, what is the function of nitrate in regulation of the pentose phosphate pathway? Apart from the work already described, nitrate has been shown to enhance the pentose-phosphate pathway in other fungi such as Dendryphiella salina (Holligan and Jennings, 1972). Recent data from Cove’s laboratory suggests that the availability of NADP is not a primary modulator of pentose-phosphate pathway activity, as proposed by Osmond and Ap Rees (1969). Hankinson and Cove (1974) and Hankinson (1974) have postulated that a product of the nirA gene in A . nidulans is necessary for synthesis of nitrate reductase, and of pentose-phosphate enzymes. The nir product is inactivated by nitrate reductase per se, but when nitrate is available it binds to nitrate reductase and hence the inactivation of the nir product is relieved. This effect of nitrate is augmented by its inhibiton of mannitol I-phosphate dehydrogenase (MDP)activity (Hankinson and Cove, 19751, an enzyme that, in vim, has fructose 6-phosphate reductase activity. Assuming that recycling of fructose 6-phosphate occurs via the pentose-phosphate pathway when A . nidulans is grown on nitrate, glucose-6-phosphate isomerase is essential for the recycling. However, mannitol phosphate dehydrogenase competes with the isomerase for substrate and nitrate-directed inhibition of the former enzyme may be important in alleviating such competition. B. ANAPLEROTIC METABOLISM
Anaplerotic sequences have evolved as a means of replenishing the supply of intermediates of the TCA cycle that are drawn off for biosynthetic purposes, thereby preserving the energy-generating function of the cycle. In fungi, anaplerotic metabolism is provided by : (i) the glyoxylate cycle; (ii) acetyl-CoA synthetase activity; and (iii) direct fixation of carbon dioxide. A variety of acceptor molecules for carbon dioxide have been reported to be present in fungi including pyruvate, phosphoenolpyruvate, acetyl-CoA and 3-methylcrotonyl CoA. The “malic” enzyme (NADP-linked t-malate enzyme) now is considered not to have an anaplerotic function, but to have catabolic activity and to be significant in the generation of NADPH,. 1. The Glyoxylate Cycle The conversion of isocitrate, by isocitrate lyase, to succinate and glyoxylate, and subsequent condensation of the latter with acetyl-CoA,
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
63
enables the decarboxylating reactions of the TCA cycle to be bypassed and a net synthesis of succinate to occur. The glyoxylate cycle operates in fungi when growth occurs on acetate, and usually is inactive in fungi grown on a carbohydrate. For example, Aspergillus nidulans developed an active glyoxylate cycle when grown in acetate-containing media (Armitt et al., 19701, but when glucose was present (even the very small concentrations found at low dilution rates in glucose-limited chemostats; Carter, 19681, the cycle was inoperative. However, not all carbohydrates repress isocitrate lyase synthesis, and acetate was utilized preferentially when gresent in the medium along with sucrose (Armitt et al., 1970); nevertheless, it has to be pointed out that addition of sucrose to an acetate-containing medium prevented synthesis of glyoxylate-cycle enzymes in Neurospora crassa (Flavell and Woodward, 197 1). The question of whether the cycle is under induction or repression control has received some attention and, although the evidence has been somewhat conflicting, it is generally accepted that acetate does not act as an inducer. On the contrary, acetate metabolism probably effects removal of metabolite(s) that repress synthesis of glyoxylate-cycle enzymes and Kornberg ( 1966) concluded that phosphoenolpyruvate (or a related intermediate) was the repressor in bacteria. Data on the co-ordinacy of isocitrate lyase and malate synthase regulation in fungi has been equivocal (see Armitt et al., 1970; Flavell and Woodward, 197 11, and this suggests that effectors additional to phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) may be involved in controlling their synthesis. The activity, as well as the synthesis, of the lyase in N . crassa may be regulated by phosphoenolpyruvate (Sjogren and Romano, 1967). 2. Carbon Dioxide Fixation The stimulatory effects of carbon dioxide on fungal growth have been reported on many occasions, and for a wide range of taxonomic and ecological groups (Rockwell and Highberger, 1927 ; Barinova, 1954; Cantino and Horenstein, 1956; Macauley and Griffin, 1969; Harvey and Hodgkiss, 1972; Hartman et al., 1972). For example, growth of Verticillium albo-atrum was very severely curtailed in a carbon dioxide- free atmosphere when glucose and glycerol were the carbon sources (94% and 97% decreases, respectively) whereas deprivation of carbon dioxide did not affect growth on TCA-cycle intermediates (Hartman et al., 1972). Under the latter conditions, the glyxoylate cycle is operative and fulfils an anaplerotic function. The essential role of carbon dioxide-fixing systems in fungal growth on carbohydrates also
64
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
can be gauged from the properties of mutants. Skinner and Armitt ( 1972) produced pyruvate carboxylaseless mutants of Aspergillus nidulans that would not grow on sugars alone, but would do so when the medium was supplemented with amino acids that could furnish C, intermediates. A number of enzymes have been implicated in carbon dioxidefixation in fungi, and of these pyruvate carboxylase (E.C. 6.4.1.1.) has been reported most widely. Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylating activity also has been observed, but the identity of such activity as PEP carboxylase (E.C. 4.1.1.3 1.) or PEP carboxykinase (E.C. 4.1.1.32.) is still subject to debate. Thus, Bushel1 and Bull (1974b) claimed that the high rate of PEP carboxylation by A. nidulans growing on glucose was due to PEP carboxylase and not to a carboxykinase working in reverse direction; PEP carboxykinase is usually ascribed a decarboxylating role (Scrutton, 197 1) and is important in gluconeogenesis. Hartman and Keen ( 1973) originally considered that carbon-dioxide tixation in V . albo-atrum was mediated by pyruvate carboxylase and PEP carboxykinase, but in the light of further research have concluded (Hartman and Keen, 1974b)that in uiuo the carboxykinase functions in gluconeogenesis. Moreover, the levels of PEP carboxykinase were low in mycelia grown on sugars or glycerol, and high on aspartate and TCA-cycle intermediates, while PEP carboxykinaseless mutants of Neurospora crassa could grow on sucrose but not on acetate as carbon sources (Flavell and Fincham, 1968). Recently Beever (1975) has produced evidence to suggest that the synthesis of PEP carboxykinase in N . crassa was under derepression and not induction control, and that a glycolytic intermediate caused the repression. PEP carboxykinase usually is assayed at pH 6.5 (Scrutton, 197 1)andthe pH optimumof the V. albo-atrum enzyme was found to be 6.2 (Hartman and Keen, 1974b). I t is significant, therefore, that the pH optimum of the A. nidulans PEPcarboxylating activity is 8.7 (M. E. Bushell and A. T. Bull, unpublished data), indicative of PEP carboxylase activity. Moreover, the A. nidulans activity also corresponds to PEP carboxylase by virtue of its lack of bound cofactors. However, comparatively little is known about the regulation of PEP carboxylase and PEP carboxykinase, most attention having been afforded to pyruvate carboxylase. All fungal pyruvate carboxylases appear to have biotin as a bound factor, and exhibit an optimum activity at a pH value of about 8. Additionally, Mg2+and K + or NH: are
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
65
required for activity. Various metabolites act as modifiers of pyruvate carboxylase activity: L-aspartate is a negative modifier and causes feedback inhibition, while acetyl CoA has been shown to act as a positive modifier in Rhizopus nigricans (Overman and Romano, 1969), in Saccharomyces cereuisiae (Miller and Atkinson, 19721, and in Helminthosporium cynodontis (Clarke and Hartman, 19731, and to reverse aspartate inhibition in V . albo-atrum (Hartman and Keen, 1974). In contrast, acetyl CoA did not activate the pyruvate carboxylase from A. nzger (Bloom and Johnson, 1962; Feir and Suzuki, 19691, from A. nidulans (M. E. Bushell and A. T. Bull, unpublished data) or from N. crussa (Beever, 1973). Finally, studies of Penin'llium camemberti (Stan and Schormuller, 1968; Stan, 1972) and Sacch. cereuisiae (Miller and Atkinson, 1972) revealed that the activity of pyruvate carboxylase also is regulated by the adenylate energy charge of the cell. A model of regulatory interactions at the pyruvate branch point involving pyruvate carboxylase has been advanced by Miller and Atkinson, and is summarized in Fig. 5 .
FIG. 5. Diagram showing the action of pyruvate carboxylase and regulatory interactions at the pyruvate branchpoint. Positive and negative effects are shown. Anabolic and catabolic reactions by ----. Sites of modifier action reactions are shown by -, are indicated by-. When the adenylate energy charge is low, the ATP demand is high and oxidation of pyruvate to acetyl-CoA and its entry into the tricarboxylic-acid cycle are favoured. However, when the energy charge is high, ATP can be used for anabolic reactions. A high energy charge causes accumulation of acetyl-CoA, and oxidation of pyruvate is inhibited. In turn, the activity of pyruvate carboxylase is enhanced by mass action and allosterically activated by acetyl-CoA. The rate of carbon-dioxide fixation is subsequently regulated by feedback inhibition of pyruvate carboxylase by L-aspartate. After Miller and Atkinson (1972).
66
A. T. BULL AND A.
P. J. TRlNCl
Remarkably few data have been collected on the effects of culture conditions on carbon-dioxide fixation by moulds. Continued pyruvate carboxylase activity under conditions of nitrogen limitation has been revealed as the means of fumaric acid production in high glucosecontaining media by Rhizopus nigricans (Overman and Romano, 1969). The inability to remove respiratory carbon dioxide, either by fixation or culture ventilation (see Bull and Bushell, 19761, can produce growth inhibition. Thus the auto-inhibition of spore germination can frequently be attributed to carbon dioxide toxicity, and one interesting illustration of this phenomenon is provided by work on Agaricus bisphorus (Rast and Bachofen, 1967 ; Rast and Stauble, 1970).Accumulation of respiratory carbon dioxide prevents spore germination in this fungus, but the inhibition can be reversed by isovaleric acid. This volatile acid is converted to 3-methylcrotonyl-CoA via isovaleryl-CoA, the former intermediate compound being enzymically carboxylated with the eventual production of acetoacetate and acetyl-CoA. Bushell and Bull (1974b, and unpublished experiments) have investigated the fixation of carbon dioxide by glucose-limited chemostat populations of Aspergillus nidulans 13 mel, and found that the activities of pyruvate carboxylase and presumed PEP carboxylase were growth rate-dependent. The activity of pyruvate carboxylase increased linearly as the dilution rate was decreased from approximately 0.15 to 0.05 h-l, while that of PEP carboxylase passed through a maximum at D = 0.1 1 h-l. The sum of the two carboxylase activities agreed closely with in vim measurements of total H14C0, incorporation. The decreased rates of carbon dioxide fixation at high dilution rates were correlated with a decreasing total mycelial protein content; because the major incorporation of H14C0, was into protein, the decreasing carboxylase activities at D > 0.1 1 h-’ appear to reflect a lowered anaplerotic requirement in response to changing rates of protein synthesis. Although the affinity for HCO, of pyruvate carboxylase (about 11 mM) was twice that of PEP carboxylase, the V,,, values of the two enzymes was in a 1 :3 ratio, an observation suggesting modulation of carbon dioxide-fixing systems to meet increasing anabolic requirements. The effect of variations in steady state HC0,- concentration was also examined. As the HCO,- concentration was raised from 2.5 mM to 7.0 mM, the biomass yield was increased by 23%and, in keeping with the measured K , values, a differential synthesis of PEP carboxylase
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
67
occurred. Such data could have important implications in the optimization of processes for production of fungal protein. Finally, some interesting reports have appeared recently on the activity of anaplerotic and gluconeogenic enzymes in yeasts growing diauxically on glucose and ethanol. First, Divjak and Mor (1973) claimed that PEP carboxykinase, as well as pyruvate carboxylase, was very active during glycolytic growth of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, an observation not in accord with the generally accepted regulation of this enzyme by glucose repression. Furthermore, PEP carboxylase was reported to be strongly repressed by glucose and was synthesized only after glucose depletion from the medium. A subsequent study of this system by Haarasilta and Oura (1975) has produced more readily interpretable data. Thus only pyruvate carboxylase was present throughout, and its activity was regulated by aspartate; glyoxylate enzymes and gluconeogenic enzymes (PEP carboxykinase and hexose diphosphatase), in contrast, were synthesized following the complete utilization of glucose. In addition to glucose repression of PEP carboxykinase, Haarasilta and Oura (1975) showed that the addition of glucose to cultures growing on ethanol caused a rapid decrease in PEP carboxykinase activity, and they suggested that this may be due to proteolytic inactivation of the type reported by Holzer et al. (1973)for yeast tryptophan synthase. At present, results from these two studies are difficult to reconcile but the suggestion of Haarasilta and Oura (1975) that the assay reaction mixture used by Divjak and Mor (1973) for PEP carboxykinase may have produced equivocal results, deserves serious consideration. C . ASPECTS O F TERMINAL O X I D A T I O N
Two features of respiratory metabolism common to most fungi are a functional TCA cycle and an electron- transport system closely similar to that found in animals and higher plants. Tricarboxylic-acid cycle activity has been reported for members of all of the main taxonomic groups, although it may be weakly functional or, occasionally, absent. The aquatic phycomycete Aqualinderella fermentans is an example of the latter type and it derives energy solely from a homolactic fermentation (Held et al., 1969). The TCA cycle appears to be fully operative in A . niger, even during the phase of growth in which citric acid is produced (Ahmed et al., 1972),and presumably sufficient citric acid is recycled to
68
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
meet the cells' biosynthetic requirements. Fungal electron transport involves a flow of electrons from NADH, and substrate through a system including cytochromes 6, c and uug (see Fig. 6) and containing up to three energy conservation sites. Again in common with higher plants, fungal respiration may proceed via cytochrome pathways or alternate pathways (see p. 70). However, little quantitative information has been published on electron-transport chain components and how they are affected by, and related to, growth conditions and growth efficiency in fungi. Descriptions of respiratory components and oxidative SHAM
U I I
Succmmte-FP~Fe/S
I I I
\I
FIG. 6. Diagram showing the cytochrorne and alternative respiratory pathways that operate in lungi. Solid lines indicate the cytochrome pathway and dashed lines the alternative pathways; arrows indicate the sites of action of inhibitors. FP, and FP, indicate flavoprotein dehydrogenases, and Fe/S non-haem iron protein. SHAM indicates salicyl hydroxamate.
phosphorylation in fungi, reviewed by Lindenmayer ( 1965) and by Watson (19761, will not be restated here. Phenotypic modifications of the electron-transport chain and energy conservation sites have been clearly revealed in Torulu utilis growing under different conditions of nutrient limitation (Light, 1972). Mitochondria from carbon (glycerol)-limited chemostat cultures had three energy conservation sites associated with the electron-transport chain but, when iron- or sulphate-limitations were imposed, Conservation at site 1 (between NADH, and cytochrome b) was lost. Furthermore, NH;- and Mg*+-limitationexperiments prove that the loss of site 1 conservation reflected specific deprivations of iron and sulphur, and not repression caused by an excess of glycerol. Predictably the loss of an energy conservation site had a profound
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
69
effect on growth efficiency, and the yield from glycerol was 33%lower under iron-limiting conditions compared with glycerol-limitation. Although inhibition of respiration, loss of conservation sites and uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation all clearly affect growth by diminishing energy generation, the metabolic state of mitochondria may exert other regulatory effects. Synthesis of valine from pyruvate, and isoleucine from pyruvate and threonine, by Neurospora crassa, are dependent on the integrity of a five-component enzyme complex. Bergquist et ul. ( 1974b) showed that valine synthesis was severely depressed if respiration and oxidative phosphorylation were disturbed. This regulation of amino-acid synthesis, via the functional integrity of the enzymic machinery, is reversible and illustrates an additional rapidly responding mechanism of metabolic control. The manner in which energy metabolism regulates growth has been increasingly studied over the past decade; such studies in moulds have been few, and mainly concerned with Neurospora. Slayman ( 1973) found that the intracellular ATP content ((ATPI,)of N . crussu was not constant during exponential growth but, if the total adenylate nucleotides were examined, an average energy charge value of 0.72 obtained throughout the exponential phase. This value is within the range typical for metabolically active micro-organisms. When mycelia were transferred to buffer lacking a nitrogen source, the (ATP), stabilized at a level equivalent to 2.5 mM, the maximum observed during exponential growth. Using a non-growing system to study the effect of metabolic perturbations on the energy status of the fungus, Slayman (1973)derived a minimal ATP turnover rate of 0.44 mMmin-’ when respiration was inhibited with cyanide. However, under these conditions, continued adenylate kinase activity probably caused some resynthesis of ATP, a suggestion supported by the fact that the ATP turnover calculated from steady state respiration rates, was much higher ( 1.17 mM min-’1. Slayman has argued that this rapid turnover of ATP coupled with the facts that N . crassu lacks energy-storage compounds and cannot generate energy from its polyphosphate reserves, may make it very susceptible to “metabolic accidents” such as respiratory blockage. Short- and long-term compensatory mechanisms for circumventing such a block probably revolve around the feedback control of glycolysis by the adenine nucleotide ratio, and the induction of the alternate cyanide-resistant respiratory pathway (see below; p. 701, respectively. A pattern of fluctuation in the size of the ATP pool
70
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
resembling that of N . C ~ U S S has U been reported for cultures of the woodrotting fungus Formes annosus (Johansson and Hagerby, 1974). A second peaking of the ATP pool in this species corresponds to the generation of energy from mobilization of storage materials. Similarly, a rapid turnover of ATP occurred in the presence of uncouplers such as pentachlorophenol. Oscillations in the sizes of adenosine nucleotide pools have recently been implicated in the circadian rhythm of conidiation (see Section VI, B ; p. 46) of N . crassa (Delmer and Brody, 1975). These authors observed no clear oscillation of (ATPL but a circadian oscillation of the energy charge from 0.65 to 0.93, correlating with the conidiation rhythm, was clearly demonstrated. Continuous illumination of N . crassa cultures obliterated the conidiation rhythm and produced an average energy charge in the peripheral zone hyphae of 0.73. Moreover, the oscillations in conidiation and energy charge could be phaseshifted by light. The underlying cause of the energy-charge oscillation may be a partial uncoupling of oxidative phosphorylation, but definite proof of this hypothesis has yet to be established. We have already suggested that respiration in Neurospora crassa and other fungi usually proceeds via the conventional electron- transport chain. However, growth of wild-type strains in the presence of antimycin or cyanide, or, of respiratory mutants, frequently induces an alternative, cyanide-resistant, route that is sensitive to salicyl hydroxamate (SHAM)(Fig. 6). Cyanide-resistant respiration was recognized in several fungi at the time Lindenmeyer ( 1965) reviewed the subject and, subsequently, has been studied in depth in N . crussa (Lambowitz and Slayman, 1971; Colvin et al., 1973; Edwards and Kwiecinski, 1973; Bergquist et al., 1974) and has also been reported in Mucor (Rogers, Clark-Walker and Stewart, 1974). The physiological significance of this alternative system has excited considerable attention, particularly since it is not coupled to phosphorylation. Edwards and Kwiecinski (1973) have proposed that the alternative oxidase in N . cras~a may be associated with the NADH, limb of the electron-transport chain; thus, derepression of the alternative oxidase might prevent the accumulation of reduced nicotinamide nucleotide, thereby stimulating ATP generation via substrate level phosphorylation. Work in Slayman’s laboratory (Slayman et al., 1975) has further investigated this possibility. Experiments with the mutant poky F revealed that the efficiency of the alternative pathway in ATP generation (via substrate level and
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
71
site I phosphorylations) was about 13% that of the wild-type cytochrome pathway, and that sufficient ATP could be produced in the absence of the latter pathway to enable slow growth to occur. The percentage of ATP coming from substrate level and site-I phosphorylations, in the presence of cyanide, was dependent on the rate of glycolysis and hence on the nature of the carbon-energy substrate. Moreover, differences in growth rate of other respiratory mutants reflected the proportional flux of electrons along the cytochrome and alternative pathways. Because the latter system is inefficient in ATP production, regulatory mechanisms ensure that the cytochrome system operates preferential whenever possible. Thus, under normal growth conditions, electron flux is partitioned so that the cytochrome pathway is saturated and the alternative pathway only takes up excess electron flow; the means of flux partitioning is not known. Regulation at the level of synthesis also occurs, but again the mechanism has not been elucidated. However, the induction of cyanide-resistant respiration in M . genevensis occurred only at very low values of dissolved oxygen tension ( ( 5 mm Hg) (Rogers et d.,19741, a result that seems to implicate oxygen in the regulation of its synthesis. IX. RNA Synthesis and Function: Rate-Limiting Parameters of Growth
In this final section, we wish to consider some aspects of macromolecule synthesis, particularly the synthesis of RNA and protein, in terms of overall rate-limiting processes in fungal growth. Earlier in this article we referred to attempts at growth modelling based on the concept of a rate-limiting step (Dabes et al., 1973; see Section 11, B; p. 12) and it is in this context that the following discussion of RNA synthesis, and its functioning in protein synthesis, will be set. Inquiries of this nature have, until very recently, been restricted to prokaryotic micro-organisms, but sufficient data now are accumulating from experiments with yeasts and moulds to enable comparable analyses of fungal growth. A brief statement of macromolecular synthesis in bacteria will be a useful preliminary to the assessment of the fungal data. Koch (197 1) has provided a valuable analysis of the overheads for protein synthesis in enteric bacteria and, having shown that the ribosome is the most expensive item in the protein-synthesizing
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
72
machinery, he argued that it should be used at maximum efficiency. The notion of ribosomes functioning with a constant efficiency was proposed some years earlier by Maaloe and his colleagues (see Maalse and Kjeldgaard, 19661.-They observed that the number of ribosomes per bacterial genome was proportional to the specific growth rate, and concluded that the organism was functioning with maximum economy. In other words, growth at twice a given rate would require twice as many ribosomes to accommodate the doubled rate of protein synthesis. The constant-efficiency hypothesis subsequently has gone into decline, and Koch’s own data have been instrumental in its reappraisal. For example, following a 17-fold step increase in dilution rate, the rate of protein synthesis in chemostat populations of E . coli increased seven-fold before any net increase in RNA had occurred. Koch concluded that slowly growing organisms possessed “extra” nonfunctioning but rapidly mobilized RNA. Finally, Koch has compared the step times for transcription and translation in micro-organisms, and remarks that the ribosome’s capacity for peptide-chain elongation is about three times less that of the RNA polymerase’s capacity to add nucleotides to the messenger RNA. With this background we will examine macromolecule synthesis in fungi. A.
EFFICIENCY OF PROTEIN SYNTHESIS
The value of continuous-flow cultures for the investigation of protein synthesis is forcibly demonstrated by the results of Koch’s experiments (see above). Nevertheless, the availability of such data for fungi is almost nil. A recent publication by Griffen et al. (1974)dealing with protein synthesis in Achlya bisexualis presents data purporting to be consistent with the hypothesis of a constant ribosome efficiency. The latter experiments were made in a variety of batch-culture systems, variously aerated and containing different nitrogen sources as a means of modifying the specific growth rate. Statistical analysis of the data of Griffen et al. ( 1974) by Bushel1 ( 1974) has revealed that the correlation between RNA concentration and p, and protein concentration and p, are unsatisfactory and this places some doubt on their interpretation in terms of the Maalse hypothesis. A critical discussion of relationships between different macromolecular species in Candzda utilis organisms was developed by Ahoy and Tannenbaum (1973).They expressed the efficiency ( E ) of RNA ( R )
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
73
in protein synthesis ( P ) , in steady-state chemostat populations, as a function of dilution rate: E =(P/N x D
(g protein g RNA-lli’).
The ribosomal efficiency of the Candida increased linearly with dilution rate up to about 0.8 +ax, and thereafter remained constant. Analysis of our continuous-culture data for Aspergillus niduluns (Bushell and Bull, 19761, and recalculation of that published by Bu’Lock et al. (1974) for Gibberella JujiiRuroi, also revealed a linear increase of ribosomal efficiency with D which became constant at dilution rates greater than 0.65 p,,.x. In addition we (A. M. T. McGetrick and A. T. Bull, unpublished experiments) have investigated the influence of some culture variables on the ribosomal efficiency of A . niduluns, growing under steady-state conditions. The stability of the proteinsynthesizing system was remarkably high, the ribosomal efficiency changing hardly at all with the medium pH value (3.1 tb 6.9) or salinity (0 to 8% NaCI). However, the ribosomal efficiency doubled as the growth temperature was increased from 22°C to 3OoC, remained constant over the range 30°C to 42”C, and started to fall at still higher temperatures. These data are consistent with the view that lowering the temperature decreases ribosomal activity, and that more RNA is synthesized such as to maintain the rate of protein synthesis, and thus maintain p, at the fixed dilution rate. Bushell and Bull (1975) also calculated the ribosomal efficiency during the transient stage following a step-up in dilution rate of a chemostat culture of A . niduluns (see Fig. 4, p. 44). An almost immediate and marked increase (three-fold) in ribosomal efficiency occurred and overshot the ultimate steadystate value. This observation provides further confirmation of Koch’s view of excess protein-synthesizing capacity at low growth rates. The identity of the “extra” RNA is evident from the work of Varricchio and Monier (197 1) and Harvey (1973) with E . coli. Thus, the concentration of ribosome subunits and free ribosomes decreased with increasing growth rate, while the polysome concentration rose concomitantly. The subunit plus free ribosome pool functioned as a reserve so that the polysome population could increase quickly in response to increased growth rate. Harvey (1973) found that the percentage of polysomes increased from about 30 to 70% as p was increased from 0.3 to 1.2 h-’ and that the response to a nutritional stepup was very rapid (detectable after 30 seconds) and was completed
74
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
within 2 to 5 minutes. The question is, does a similar system operate in fungi ? The data are less extensive, and relate to ribosome changes during spore germination, but results from work with species of Fusarium (Cochrane et al., 197 l),-Bhiropus (Roheim et al., 1974) and Neurospora (Mirkes, 1974) are entirely consistent with a rapid shift in free ribosomes to polysomes. The accumulated results signify that the constant ribosome efficiency hypothesis is valid in a limited sense, but must be related only to polysomes. The most recent confirmation of this view comes from the work of Plaut and Turnock (1975) on Physarum polycephalum. The proportion of ribosomes associated in polysomal complexes rose from about 50%to approximately 70% as the dilution rate of chemostat populations was increased from 0.02 to 0.07 h-'; concomitantly the efficiency of protein synthesis increased by 50%over the same range of dilution rates. However, one cautionary note needs to be added which is relevant to these studies; data on protein turnover rates are lacking, and if the latter occurs to a significant extent then ribosome efficiencies will have been underestimated. Extrapolation from the above observations suggests that, in C. utilis and A . nidulans, all ribosomal subunits and free ribosomes are associated in functional polysomes at growth rates significantly below ,umax(i.e. at 0.3 ,urnaxand 0.65 pmas, respectively). However, an alternative or supplementary rate limitation might be imposed by the peptidechain elongation rate which conceivably reaches a maximum at submaximum growth rates. Once again the quantity of data in this area is small, especially for fungi. Of interest is the observation that the peptide chain-elongation rate increased linearly with growth rate in E . coli, but at growth rates exceeding 0.4 pmax the elongation rate became constant (Forchhammer and Lindahl, 197 1 ) . The only comparable data for fungi relates to Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and Boehlke and Friesen ( 1975) have recently reported that the elongation rate varied directly with the specific growth rate of the yeast and ranged from 2.8 amino acids per second at 0.09 h-'to 10 amino acids per second at 0.43 h-'. With our present knowledge, it is impossible to ascert whether peptide-chain elongation per se is the primary rate limitation to growth rate in fungi. B . CONCERNING POLYAMINES
By way of concluding this treatment of growth regulation and macromolecule synthesis we would like to refer briefly to the role, or roles, of polyamines. These organic cations are thought to confer stability on nucleic acids and to stimulate their synthesis, as well as that
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
75
of proteins. Fluctuations in endogenous polyamine concentrations have been shown to accompany changes in growth rate and to be correlated with differentiating systems (see Cohen, 197 1, for review). Thus, the view has steadily developed that polyamines may be important regulators of cell growth, and within the past few years work has been reported that supports such a claim in fungi. Studies with prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms have suggested a degree of functional exchangeability between polyamines and magnesium ions, and that enhanced polyamine synthesis occurs under conditions of Mg2+(andK)' deprivation. The first convincing evidence for such a reciprocal interchange between Mgz+and polyamines in fungi was provided by the work of Viotti et al. ( 197 1) with Neurospora c r a m . This group observed a decrease in mycelial magnesium during the mid-exponential growth phase and a concomitant increase in spermidine and spermine. Moreover, under these conditions of magnesium insufficiency, the increased concentrations of polyamines appeared to prolong exponential growth at an unaltered rate for several hours; the rate of RNA synthesis was also sustained under these conditions. Viotti et al. ( 197 1) demonstrated that the Mg2tpolyamine reciprocity occurred at the ribosomal level. This type of analysis was further developed by Bushell (1974) and Bushell and Bull ( 1974a) using chemostat cultures of Aspergillus niduluns. Under carbon-limited growth conditions they found that the mycelial Mg2+concentration fell (nearly six-fold) with increasing dilution rate and, whereas the molar ratio MgZf:RNA appears to be growth-rate independent in carbon-limited bacteria (Tempest, 19691, it varied significantly in the fungal system. When the polyamines (spermidine and spermine) were considered in this context, however, the molar ratio polyamines plus Mg2+:RNA was constant at approximately two. Bushell found that the polyamine :Mg2+ratioincreased logarithmically as a function of ribosomal efficiency, a result that indicated an increasing differential requirement for polyamines at higher rates of protein synthesis. This finding is consistent with known functions of polyamines; as ribosomal efficiency approaches a maximum (see Section IX, A; p. 73) increased polyamine requirements for tRNA synthesis and aminoacylation, mRNA binding to 30s ribosomal subunits and the formation and stabilization of polysomal complexes are highly probable. Polyamine concentrations, and synthesis, also have had preliminary investigation in differentiating fungi. Thus, putrescine pools increased
76
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
several fold in Physarum polycephalum during the emergence of plasmodia from the dormant spherule stage (Mitchell and Rusch, 1973). Spermidine concentration was found to correlate with protein synthesis activity during diiferentiation. I t is interesting to note that, although putrescine is a precursor of spermidine, the two polyamines are under independent control in Physarum, and both occur in high concentrations. The latter observation points to distinct but as yet undefined functions of the molecules,
X. Acknowledgements I t is our pleasure to thank all those students, research collaborators and colleagues whose contributions over the years have done so much to stimulate and sustain our personal interests in the fungi. During the preparation of this review we have enjoyed the helpful comments and criticisms of three colleagues in particular Drs. Michael Bushell, Howard Slater and Ben Zonneveld. Much of our own research has been funded by the Science Research Council to whom we wish to express our gratitude. REFERENCES
Ahmed, S. A., Smith, J . E. and Anderson, J . G. (1972). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 59, 5 1. Aiba, S . and Hara, M. (1965). J o u m l of General and Applied Microbiology, Tokyo 11, 25. Ainsworth, G. C. (1961). “Ainsworth and Bisby’s Dictionary of the Fungi. 5th Edition”. Commonwealth Mycological Institute, Kew. Alroy, Y. and Tannenbaum, S. R. (1973). Biotechnology and Bioengineering 15, 239. Armitt, S., Roberts, C. F. and Kornberg, H. L. (1970). Federation ofEuropean Biochemical SocielieJ Letlers 7, 23 1. Arst, H. N. and Cove, D. J. (1973). Molecular and General Genetics 126, 111. Bainbridge, B. W., Bull, A. T., Pirt, S. J., Rowley, B. I. and Trinci, A. P. J. (197 1). Transaction, o/ the British Mycological Society 50, 37 1. Barninova, S. E. (1954). Mikrobiologzya 23, 521. Bartnicki-Garcia, S. (1963). Bacleriological Reviews 27, 293. Bartnicki-Garcia, S. (1973). In “Microbial Differentiation” (J. M. Ashworth and J. E. Smith, eds.). pp. 245-268. Cambridge University Press, London. Beck, C. and Meyenberg, H. K. von (1968). Journal ofBacteriology 96, 479. Beever, R. E. (1973). Neurospora Newsletter 20, 15. Beever, R. E. (1975). Journal of General Microbiology 86, 197. Bengali, Z. H. and Hempfling, W. P. (1972). Bacteriologkd Proceedings p. 145. Benko, P. V., Wood, T. C. and Segel, I. H. (1969). Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics 129, 498.
Bergquist, A., Eakin, R. A., Eakin, R. T. and Wagner, R. P. (1974a). Biochemical Genetics 12, 39.
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROVVTH
77
Bergquist, A., Eakin, E. A., Murali, D. K. and Wagner, R. P. (1974b).Procppdinp o f f l h p National Acaderny v/ Science of the United States of America 71, 4352. Bloom, S. J. and J ~ ~ I I S O I IM. , J. (1962).Journal ofBiologica1 Chemist? 237, 2718. Blumenthal, H. J . (1965).In “The Fungi”, Vol. I. ( G . C. Ainsworth and A. S. Sussman, eds.), pp. 229-368. Academic Press, New York and London. Boehlke, K. W. and Friesen, J. D. (1975).Journal of Bacteriology 121. 429. Borneleld, T. and Lysek, G. (1972).Archives f u r Mikrobiologie 87, 119. Borrow, A. E., Kessell, R. H. J., Jeffreys, E. G., Lloyd, E. C., Lloyd, P. B. and Nixon, D. (1961). Canadian Journal ./Microbiology 7, 227. Bret, J . P. (1972). Cornptps Rendus, Hebdomadaires des Siances de lilcademie des Science, Serie D . 274, 1155. Brierley, M. R. and Steel, R. (1959). Applied Microbiology 7, 57. Brody, S. (1970).Journal o/ Bacteriology 101, 802. Brown, C. E. and Roniano. A. H. (1969).Journal of Bacteriology 100, 1198. Brown, C. M., Macdonald-Brown, D. S. and Meers, J. L. (1974). Advances in Microbial Physiology 11, 1 . Brown, C. M. and Stanley, S. 0. (1972).Journal of Applied Chemis? and Biotechnology 22, 363. Brunner, H. and ROhr, M. (1972). Applied Microbiology 24, 521. Bull, A. T. (1970).Journal of General Microbiology 63, 75. Bull, A. T. and Bushell, M. E. (1976).In “The Filamentous Fungi”, Vol. 2 (J. E. Smith and D. R. Berry, eds.), pp. 1-13 Edward Arnold, London. Buller, A. H. R. (1933). Researches on Fungi, Vol. V , Longmans, Green, New York. Bu’Lock, J. D., Detroy, R. W., Hostalek, S. and Munim-al-Shakarchi, A. (1974). Transactions of the British Myological Society 62, 377. Bu’Lock, J . D., Hamilton, D., Hulme, M. A., Powell, A. J., Smallev, H. W., Shepherd, D. and Smith, C. N. (1965). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 11, 765. Bungay, H. R., Whelen, W. J. and Sanders, W. M. (1969). Biotechnology and Bioengineering 11, 765. Burnett, J. H. ( 1968). Fundamentals ~JMycology.546 pp. Edward Arnold, London. Bushell, M. E. (1974). Ph.D. Thesis: University of Kent at Canterbury, England. Bushell, M. E. and Bull, A. T. (1974a).Journal ofGenera1 Microbiology 81, 271. Bushell, M. E. and Bull, A. T. (1974b).Proceedings ofthe Society f o r General Microbiology 1, 69. Bushell, M. E. and Bull, A. T. ( 1976).Journal of Applied Chemistry and Biotechnology 26, 339. Bushell, M. E., Bull, A. T. and Slater, J. H. ( 1976). In preparation. Butler, G. M. ( 1961). Annals of Botany (London) New Series 25, 341. Butler, G. M. (1966). In “The Fungi”, Vol. 2 (G. C. Ainsworth and A. S. Sussman, eds.), pp. 83-112. Academic Press, New York and London. Button, D. K., Dunker, S. S. and Morse, M. L. (1973).Journal ofBacteriology 115, 599. Calam, C. T. (1969). In “Methods in Microbiology”, Vol. 1 (J. R. Norris and D. W. Ribbons, eds.) pp. 567-591. Calam, C. T., Ellis, S. H. and McCann, M. J. (197 1). Journal of Applied Chemistry and Biolechnology 21, 18 1 . Caldwell, I . Y. and Trinci, A. P. J. (1973). Archives f u r Mikrobiologie 88, 1. Camici, L. C . , Sermonti, G. and Chain, E. B. (1952). Bulletin of the World Health Organisation 6, 265. Cantino, E. C. and Horenstein, E. A. (1956). Mycologia 48, 7 7 7 .
78
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
Carter, B. L. A. 11968). P1i.D. Thesis: University of London. Carter, B. L. A. aiid Bull, A. T. (1969).Biotechnology and Bioengineering 11, 785. Cater, B. L. A. arid Bull. A. T. (1971). Journal of General Microbiology 65, 265. Carter, 9. L. A,, Bull, A. T., Pirt, S. J. and Rowley, B. I. (1971). Journal ofBacten‘ology 108, 309. Chance, B., Higgins, J., Holmes, W. a n d Connellv, C. M. (1958).Nalure, London 182, 1190. Chassang-Douillet, A,, Ladet, J., Boze, H. and Galzy, P. (1973).Zeitschrzft-fir Allgemeine Mikrobiologic, 13, 193. Chevaugron, J . i 1959). Cornptes Rendus, Hebdomadaires des Seances de l’academie des S C ~ P P I C Svrir P A , D 248, 138 1. Cicmanec, J . F-. and Liclistein, H . C. (1974). Journal ofBacteriology 119, 718. Clark, D. S. 11962).Carcadian Journal of Microbiology 8, 133. Clarke, G . A. arid Hartnian, R. E. (1973).Bacteriological Proceedings p. 140. Clutterbuck, A. J. aiitl Roper, J . A. (1966).Genetic Research 7, 185. Cochrane, J . C., Rado, T. A. and Cochrane, V. W. (1971). Journal ofGenera1 Microbiology 65, 45. Cohen, S. S. ( 197 1). Introduction to the Polyamines. Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs, N.J. Journal ofBacteriology 116,1314. Colvin, H . J., Saucr, B. L. and Munkres, K. D. (1973a). Colvin, H.J., Sauer, B. L. and Munkres, K. D. (1973b). Journal ofBacteriology 116, 1322. Constantiriides. A,, Spciiccr, J. L. and Caden, E. L. (1970).Biofechnology and Bioengineering 12, 803. Dab&, J . N;, Finn, R. K. arid Wilke, C. R. (1973).Biotechnology and Bioenpneen’ng 15, 1159. Dawson, P. S. S. (1963).Canadian Journal ofMicrobiology 9, 671. Dawson, P. S. S. and Phillips, K. L. (1974).Advances in Applied Microbiology 17, 195. Delmer, D. P. and Brody, S. (1975).Journal of Bacteriology 121, 548. Desi, J. D. and Modi, V. V. (1975).Experientia 31, 160. Dickerson, A. G. (1972).Biochemical Journal 129, 263. Divjak, S. and Mor, J.-R. (1973).Archiv f i r Mikrobiologie 94, 191. Donovick, R. (1960).Afiplied Microbiology 8, 117. Edwards, D. L. and Kwiencinski, R. (1973). Journal of Bacteriology 116. 610. Elmayergi, H.and Moo-Young, M. ( 1973).Biotechnology and Bioengineering Symposium No. 4;507. Elmayergi, H. arid Scharrer, J. M. (1973).Journal of General and Applied Microbiology, Tokyo 19, 385. Emerson, R. (1955).In “Aspects of Svnthesis and Order in Growth” (D. Rudrick, ed.), pp. 17 1-208. Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J. Journal of General Microbiology 77, 471. Fantes, P. A. and Roberts, C. F. (1973). Feir, H. A. and Suzuki, 1. (1969).Canadian Journal of Biochemistry 47, 697. Fencl, Z., Machek, F. a n d Novak, M. (1969). In “Fermentation Advances” (D. Perlman, ed.), p. 301. Academic Press, New York. F e d , Z. and Novak, M. (1969).Folio Microbiologia 14, 314. Fevre, M. (1972).Zeihchrifl .fur Ppanzenphysiologie 68, 1. Fiddy, C. and Trinci, A. P. J. (1975).Archives ofMicrobiology 103, 191. Fiechter, A. and Meyeliberg, H . K. von (1966).Pathologie und Microbiologie 29, 696. Flavell, R. B. and Fincham, J. R. S. (1968).Journal ofBacten‘ology 95, 1063. Flavell, R. B. and Woodward, D. 0. (1971). Journal of Bacteriology 105, 200. Forchhammer, J. and Lindahl, L. (1971). Journal of Molecular Biology 55, 563. Foster, J. W. (1949).Chemical Activities ojFungi. Academic Press, New York. Fredrickson, A. C., Megee, R. D. and Tsuchiya, H. M. (1970).Advance.r in Applied MicrobioloQ 13, 419.
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
Friedenthal, M., Epstein, A. and Passerson, S. (1974).Journal
79
of General Microbiology 82,
15.
Galun, E. (1972). Archiv f u r Mikrobiologie 86, 305. Carn,jobst, L. and Tatum, E. L. (1967). Genetics 57, 579. Gilley, J . W. and Bungay, H. R. (1967). Biotechnology and Bioengineering 9, 617. Gillie, 0. J. (1968). Journal of General Microbiology 51, 185. Glasgow, J . E. and Reissig, J . L. (1974). Journal of Bacteriology 120, 759. Gorts, C. P. M. (1967). Antonie van Leeuwenhoek S S , 451. Grenson, M. (1973). 111 “Genetics of Industrial Microorganisms”, Vol. I1 (Z. Vanek, Z. Hostalek and J. Cudlin, eds.), pp. 179-193. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Griffin, D. H., Timberlake, W. E. and Cheney, J. C. (1974). Journal of General Microbiology 80, 38 1. Grove, S. N., Bracker, C. E. and Moore, D. J. (1970). American JournalofBotany 59,245. Haarasilta, S . and Oura, E. (1975). European Journal ofBiochemistry 52, 1. Halaban, R. (1975). Journal of Bacteriology 121, 1056. Hankinson, 0. (1974). Journal of Bacteriology 117. 1121. Hankinson, 0. and Cove, D. J. (1974). Journal ofBiologica1 Chemist? 249, 3244. Hankinson, 0. and Cove, D. J. (1975). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 21, 99. Hansford, G. S. arid Humphrey, A. E. (1966). Biotechnology and Bioengineering 8. 8 5 . Hartman, R. E. and Keen, N. T. (1973). Phytopathology 6S, 947. Hartman, R. E. and Keen, N. T. (1974a). Journal of General Microbiology 81, 15. Hartman, R. E. and Keen, N. T. (1974b). Journal of General Microbiology 81, 21. Hartman, R. E., Keen, N. T. and Long, M. (1972). Journal ofGeneral Microbiology 73.29. Harvey, R. and Hodgkiss, I. J. (1972). Transactions ofthe British Mycological Society 59,409. Harvey, R. J. (1973). Journal of Bacteriology 114, 287. Hawker, L. E. and Linton, A. H. (1971). “Microorganisms: Functions, Form and Environment”, Edward Arnold, London. Held, A. A., Emerson, R., Fuller, M. S. and Gleason, F. H. (1969). Science, New York 165, 706.
Hockenhull, D. J . D. and MacKenzie, R. M. (1968). Chemistry and Indust? 607. Hofsten, B. von, Hofsten, A. von and Fries, N. (1953). Experimental Cell Research 5,530. Holligan, P. M. and Jennings, D. H. (1972). New Phytologist 71. 583. Holligan, P. M. and Jennings, D. H. (1973). New Phytologist 72, 315. Holzer, H., Katsunuma, T., Schott, E. G., Ferguson, A. R. and Betz, H. (1973). Advances in Enzyme Regulation 11, 5 3 . Huang, M. Y. and Bungay, H. R. (1973). Biotechnology and Bioenginem’ng 15, 1193. Hiitter, R. (1973). In “Genetics of Industrial Microorganisms”, Vol. I1 (Z. Vanck, S. Hostalek and J. Cudlin, eds.), pp. 109-124. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Isaac, P. K. (1964). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 10, 621. Jennings, D. H. (1974). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 62, 1. Jennings, D. H. and Austin. S. (1973). Journal of General Microbiology 75, 287. Johansson, M. and Hagerby, B. (1974). Physiologia Plantarum 32, 23. Johnson, B. and Brown, C. M. (1974). Journal of General Microbiology 85, 169. Katz, D., Goldstein, D. and Rosenberger, R. F. (1972).Journal ofBacteriology 109, 1097. Kinghorn, N. R. arid Pateman, J. A. (1974). Molecular and General Genetics 128, 95. Kobayashi, H. and Suzuki, H. (1972). Journal of Fermentation Technology 50, 835. Koch, A. L. (1971). Advances in Microbial Physiology 6, 147. Kornberg, H. L. (1966). Biochemical Journal 99, 1. Kotyk, A. and Janacek, K. (1970). “Cell Membrane Transport”, Plenum Press, New York. Kubitschek, H. E. (1970). Journal of Theoretical Biology 28, 15. Lambowitz, A. M. and Slayman, C. W. (1971). Journal of Bacteriology 108, 1087.
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
80
Leopold, L. B. (1971). Journal of Theoretical Biology 32, 339. Lhoas, P. (1968). Genetical Research 12, 305. Light, P. A. (1972). Journal of Applied Chemistry and Biotechnology 22, 509. Lindenmeyer, A. (1965). In “The Fungi”, Vol. I. ( G . C. Ainsworth and A. S. Sussman, eds.), pp. 301-347. Academic Press, New York. Lowendorf’, H. S., Slayman, C. L. and Slayman, C. W. (1974). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 373, 369. Lowry, R. J. and Sussman, A. S. (1966). Mycologia 54, 541. Lynch, J . M. and Harper, S. H. T. (1974). Journal of General Microbiology 85, 91. Lysek, G. and Esser, K. (1971). Archiv fur Mikrobiologie 75, 360. McDowell, L. L. and DeHertogh, A. A. (1968). Canadian Journal of Botany 46, 449. M’Kendrick, A. G. and Pai, M. K. (1911). Proceedings ofthe Royal Society ofEdinburgh 31, 649.
Maalse, 0. and Kjeldgaard, N. 0. (1966). “Control of Macromolecular Synthesis. A Study of’DNA, RNA and Protein Synthesis in Bacteria” Benjamin Inc., New York. Macaulay, B. J . and Griffen, D. M. (1969). Transactions ofthe British Mycological Society 53, 223.
Machek. F. and Fencl, Z. (1973). Biotechnology and Bioengineering Symposium No. 4, 129. Mandels, G. R. (1965). In “The Fungi”, Vol,. 1. ( G . C. Ainsworth and A. S. Sussman, eds.), pp. 5 9 9 4 1 2 . Academic Press, New York. Marzluf; G. A. (1970). Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics 138, 254. Mason, H. R. S. and Righelato, R. C. (1976).Journal ofApplied Chemistry and Eiotechnology 26, 145.
Matscht., N . E. and Aridrews, J. F. (1973). Biotechnology and Bioengineering Symposium No. 4, 7 7 .
Maynard Smith, J . ( 1968). “Mathematical Ideas in Biology”, C.U.P. London. Means, C. W., Savage, G. M., Reusser, F. and Koepsell, H. J. (1962). Biotechnology and Bioerrgrneering 4, 5 . Meers, J . L., Tenipest, D. W. and Brown, C. M. (1970).Journal of General Microbiology 64, 187.
Megee, R. D., Kinoshita, S., Fredrickson, A. G. and Tsuchiya, H. M. (1970). Biolechnuloff: and Bioengineering 12, 7 7 1. Meyenberg, H. K. von ( 197 1). J o u m l of Bacteriology 107, 878. Mian, F. S., Fencl, Z., Prokop, A., Mohagheghi, A. and Fazeli, A. (1974). Folia Micrvbiulogia 19, 191. Miiler, A. L. and Atkinson, D. E. (1972). Archives ofBiochemistry and Biophysics 152,431. Mirkes, P. E. (1974). Journal of Bacteriology 117. 196. Mitchell, J . L. A. and Rusch, J. P. (1973). Eiochimica et Biophysica Acta 297, 503. Moat, A. G., Ahmad, F., Alexander, J. K. and Barnes, I. J. (1969).Journal ofEacteriology 98, 573.
Monod, J . (1942). “Recherches sur la Croissance des Cultures Bacteriennes”, Hermann et Cie, Paris. Monod, J . (1949). Annual Review of Microbiology 3, 37 1. Moo-Young, M., Hirose, T. and Geiger, K. H. (1969). Biotechnology and Bioengineering 11, 725.
Morrison, K. B. and Righelato, R. C. (1974). Journal ofGeneral Microbiology 81, 517. Nagasaki, S. (1968). Journal of General and Applied Microbiology, Tokyo 14, 147. Nei,jssel, 0. M., Hueting, S. Crabbendam, K. J. and Tempest, D. W. (1974). Proceedings of the Society for General Microbiology 1, 14. Neville, M. M., Suskind, S. R. and Roseman, S. (197 1).Journal ofBiologica1 Chemistry 246, 1249.
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
81
Ng, A. M. L., Smith, J. E. and McIntosh, A. F. (1974).JournalofGeneral Microbiology 81, 425.
Ng, W. S., Smith, J. E. and Anderson, J. G. (1972).Journal ofGeneralMicrobiology 71,495. Nisbet, L. J. (1975). Ph.D. Thesis: University of London. Nobles, M. K. (1948). Canadian Journal of Research C26, 281. North, M. J. (1973). Federation of European Biochemical Societies Letters 35, 67. North, M . J. (1974). Journal ofBactenology 120, 741. Novak, M. and F e d , Z. (1973). Biotechnology and Bioengineering Symposium 4, 43. Osmond, C. B. and Rees, T. (1969). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 184, 35. Overman, S. A. and Romano, A. H. (1969). Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 37, 457. Park, D. and Robinson, P. M. (1966). In “Trends in Plant Morphogenesis” (E.C. Cutter, ed.), pp. 27-44. Longmans, Green and Co., London. Park, D. and Robinson, P. M. (1967). In “Aspects of the Biology of Ageing”, pp. 323-336. Cambridge University Press, London. Paszewski, A., Chojnacki, T., Litwinska, J. and Ga.jewski, W. (1970). Acta Biochemica Polonica 17, 385. Pateman, J. A., Kinghorn, J. R., Dunn, E. and Forbes, E. (1973). Journal OfBacteriology 14, 943.
Phillips, D. H. and Johnson, M. J. (1961). Journal of Biochemical and Microbiological Technology and Engineeenng 3, 27 7. Pirt, S. J . (1966). Proceedings ofthe Royal Society B 166, 369. Pirt, S. J. (1967). Journal of General Microbiology 47, 181. Pirt, S. J. (1974). Journal ofApplied Chemistry and Biotechnology 24, 415. Pirt, S. J. and Callow, D. S . (1960). Journal ofApplied Bacteriology 23, 87. Pirt, S. J. and Righelato, R. C. (1967). Applied Microbiology 15, 1284. Plaut, B. S. and Turnock, G. (1975). Molecular and General Genetics 137, 211. Plomley, N. J. B. (1959). Australian Journal of Biological Sciences 12, 53. Polakis, E. S . and Bartley, W. (1965). Biochemical Journal 97, 284. Polakis, E. S . , Bartley, W. and Meek, G. A. (1965). Biochemical Journal 97, 298. Poole, R. K., Lloyd, D. and Kemp, R. B. (1973). Journal ofGeneral Microbiology 77, 209. Powell, E. 0. (1972). Journal of Applied Chemistry and Biotechnology 22, 71. Pye, K. E. (1969). Canadian Journal o f Botany 47. 27 1. Ramkrishna, D., Fredrickson, A. G. and Tsuchiya, H. M. (1966). Journal ofFermentaiion Technology 44, 210. Raper, K. B. and Thom, C. ( 1949). “A Manual of the Penicillia”, Williams and Wilkins Co., Baltimore. Rast, D. and Bachofen, R. (1967). Archiv fiir Mikrobiologie 57, 392. Rast, D. and Stauble, E. J. (1970). New Phytologist 69, 557. Reichle, R. E. and Alexander, J. V. (1965). Journal o f c e l l Biology 24, 489. Reinert, W. R. and Marzluf, G. A. (1974). Biochemical Genetics 12, 97. Reissig, J. L. and Glasgow, J. E. (1971). Journal ofBacten‘ology 106, 882. Rieck, J . T., Palumbo, S. A. and Witter, L. D. (1973). Journal of General Microbiology 74, 1.
Righelato, R. C. (1975). In “The Filamentous Fungi’’, Vol. I (J. E. Smith and D. R. Berry, eds.), pp. 79-103. Edward Arnold, London. Righelato, R. C. and Pirt, S. J. (1967). Journal of Applied Bacteriology SO, 246. Righelato, R. C., Trinci, A. P. J., Pirt, S. J. and Peat, A. (1968).Journal ofGenera1 Microbiology 50, 399. Roberts, C. F. (1970). Biochimicu et Biophysica Acta 201, 267. Roberts, K. R. and Marzluf, G. (1971). Archives ofBiochemistry and Biophysics 142, 651.
82
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
Robinson, J. H., Anthony, C. and Drabble, W. T. (1973).J o u m l ofGenera1 Microbiology 79. 65.
Robinson, J. H., Anthony, C. and Drabble, W. T. (1974).Journal ofGeneral Microbiology 85, 23.
Robinson, P. M. (1973). The Botanical Review 39, 367. Rockwell, E. and Highberger, J. H. (1927). Journal of Infectious Diseuses 40, 438. Roels, J . A., Van den Berg, J. and Voncken, R. M. (1974). Biotechnology and Bioengineering 16, 181. Rogers, P. J., Clark-Walker, G. D. and Stewart, P. R. (1974).Journal ofBacteriology 119, 282.
Rogers, P. J. and Gleason, F. H. (1974). Mycologia 66, 919. Rogers, T. 0. and Lichstein, H. C. (1969). J o u m l ofBacteriology 100, 565. Roheim, J. R., Knight, R. H. and Van Etten, J. L. (1974). Developmental Biology 41. 137. Romano, A. H. (1973). In “Genetics of Industrial Microorganisms”, Vol. 11. (Z. Vanek, Z. Hostalek and J. Cudlin, eds.), pp. 195-212. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Roon, R. J., Even, H. L. and Larimore, F. (1974). Journal ofBucteriology 118, 89. Rothstein, A. (1966). In “The Fungi”, Vol. I. ( G . C. Ainsworth and A. S. Sussman, eds.), pp. 429-455. Academic Press, New York and London. Rowley, B. I . and Bull, A. T. (1973). Laboratory Practice 286. Rowley, B. I . and Pirt, S. J. (1972). Jounal of General Microbiology 72, 553. Ryan, F. J., Beadle, G. W. and Tatum, E. L. (1943). American Journal of Botany 30, 784. Scarborough, G. A. (1970a). Journal of Biological Chemistry 245, 1694. Scarborough, G. A. (1970b). Journal of Biological Chemistry 245, 3985. Schaechter, M., Maalse, 0. and Kjeldgaard, N. 0. (1958).Journal ofGmeral Microbiology 19, 592.
Schulz, B. E., Kraepelin, G. and Hinkelmann, W. ( 1974). Journal
of General Microbiology
82, 1.
Scrutton, M. C. (197 1). In “Methods in Microbiology”, Vol. 6A. (J. R. Norris and D. W. Ribbons, eds.), pp. 479-541. Academic Press, London and New York. Shih, C. -N. and Marth, E. H. (1974). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 338, 286. Shinmyo, A. and Terui, C. (1970). Journal ofFernentation Technology 48. 146. Sjogren, R. and Romano, A. H. (1967). Journal ofBacteriology 93, 1638. Skinner, V. M. and Armitt, S. (1972). Federation of European Biochemical Societies Letters 20, 1618.
Skowronski, B. S. and Gottlieb, D. (1970). Journal ofBacteriology 104, 640. Slayman, C. L. (1973). Journal of Bacteriology 114, 752. Slayman, C. W., Rees, D. C., Orchard, P. P. and Slayman, C. L. (1975). Journal of Biological Chemistry 250, 396. Smith, J. E. and Anderson, J. G. (1973). Symposium ofthe Society for General Microbiology 24, 295.
Smith, J. E. and Ng, W. S. (1972). Canadian Journal ofMicrobiology 18, 1657. Smith, J. E., Valenzuela-Perez, J. and Ng, W. S. (1971). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 57. 93. Smith, J . H. (1924). New Phytologisl 29, 65. Solomons, G. L. (1972). Journal of Applied Chemistry and Biotechnology 22, 217. Solomons, G. L. (1975). In “The Filamentous Fungi”, Vol. I. (J. E. Smith and D. R. Berry, eds.), pp. 249-264. Edward Arnold, London. Solomons, G. L. and Scammell, G. W. (1974). British Patent No. 1346046. Solomons, G. L. and Weston, G. 0. (1961). Journal ofBiochemica1 and Microbiological Technology and Enginrering 3. 1. Stan. H.-J. (1972). International Journal of Biochemistry 3, 573.
THE PHYSIOLOGY AND METABOLIC CONTROL OF FUNGAL GROWTH
83
Stan, H.-J. and Schormuller, J. (1968). Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 32, 289. Stebbing, N. ( 1973). Subcellular Biochemistry 2, 167-180. Steel, R. (1969). In “Fermentation Advances” (D.P e r h a n , ed.), pp. 491-514. Academic Press, New York. Steel, R. and Maxon, W. D. (1966). Biotechnology and Bioengineering 8, 97. Steele, G. C. and Trinci, A. P. J. (1975).Journal of General Microbiology 91, 362. Steensland, H. (1973). Archiu f u r Mikrobiologie 93, 287. Steveninck, J. van and Rothstein, A. (1965). J o u m l of General Physiology 49, 235. Tanaka, H., Mizuguchi, T. and Ueda, K. (1975). Journal of Fermentation Technology 53, 35.
Tanaka, H., Takahashi, J. and Ueda, K. (1975). Journal ofFermentation Technology 53, 18. Tanner, W. (1974). Transactions of the Biochemical Society 2, 793. Tatum, E. L., Barratt, R. W. and Cutter, V. M. (1959). Science, New York 109, 509. Tempest, D. W. (1969). In “Microbial Growth” (P.Meadow and S. J. Pirt, eds.), pp, 87-1 11. Cambridge University Press, London. Terenzi, H. F. and Storck, R. (1969). Journal of Bacteriology 97, 1248. Terui, G . and Sugimoto, M. (1969). Journal ofFermentation Technology 47, 382. Tonolo, A., Scotti, T. and Vero-Barcellona, L. (1961). Scientyc Reports Ofthe Institute Superiore di Sanita 1, 404. Topiwala, H. H. (1973). In “Methods in Microbiology”, Vol. 8. (J.R. Norrisand D. W. Ribbons, eds.), pp. 35-59. Academic Press, London. Topiwala, H. H. and Hamer, G. (1971). Biotechnology and Bioengineering 13. 919. Trinci, A. P. J. (1969). Journal of General Microbiology 57, 11. Trinci, A. P. J. (1970). Transactions ofthe British Mycological Society 55, 17. Trinci, A. P. J. (1971). Journal of General Microbiology 67, 325. Trinci, A. P. J. (1972). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 58, 467. Trinci, A. P. J. (1973a). Archiufdr Mikrobiologie 91, 113. Trinci, A. P. J. (1973b). A r c h f u r Mikrobiologie 91, 127. Trinci, A. P. J. (1974). Journal ofGenera1 Microbiology 81, 227. Trinci, A. P. J. and Collinge, A. (1973). Journal of General Microbiology 78, 179. Trinci, A. P.J. arid Collinge, A. (1974a). Transactions ofthe British Mycological Society 62, 351.
Trinci, A. P. J . and Collinge, A. (1974b). Protoplasma 80. 57. Trinci, A. P. J. and Gull, K. (1970). Journal ofGenera1 Microbiology 60, 287. Trinci, A. P. J. and Righelato, R. C. (1970). Journal ofGenera1 Microbiology 60, 239. Tsuchiya, H. M., Fredrickson, A. G. and Aris, R. ( 1966). Advances in Chemical Engineering 6, 125.
Turian, G., Peduzzi, R. and Lingappa, B. T. (1972). Archiu f i r Mikrobiologie 85, 333. Tweedie J. W. and Segal, I . H. (1970). Biochimica et Biophysica A d a 196, 95. Uden, N. Van. (1967). Archiu f u r Mikrobiologie 61, 381. Uden, N. Van. (1969). ZeitschriJ f u r Allgemtine Mikrobiologie 9, 385. Varricchio, F. and Monier, R. (1971). Journal of Bacteriology 108, 105. Viotti, A., Bagni, N. Sturani, E. and Alberghina, F. A. M. (197 1). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 244, 329. Vogel, H. J. (1956). Microbial Genetics Bulletin 13, 42. Vrana, D. (1973). Biotechnology and Bioengineering Symposium No. 4 , 161. Watson, K. (1976). In “The Filamentous Fungi”, Vol. 2 (J. E. Smith and D. R. Berry, eds.), Edward Arnold, London pp. 92-120. Watson, T. G. (1970). JournalofGeneral Microbiology 64, 91. Wean, R. E. and Young, J. E. ( 1939). Phytopathology 29, 895.
a4
A. T. BULL AND A. P. J. TRlNCl
Wijk, R. van (1968). Proceedings van de Koninklyke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen, Serie C7 1, 137. Wiley, W. R. (1970).Journal o f Bacteriology 103,656. Wilson, R. W. (1970).Canadian Journal o f Microbiology 16,629. Wilson, R.W. and Niederpreum, D. J. (1967).CanadianJournal ofMicrobiologr 13, 1663. Winfree, A. T.(1970).Proceedings ofthe Institute ofElectn'ca1 and Electronics Engineers Symposium on Adaptive Processes 9 ( X X I I I ) , 4.1-4.7. Winfree, A. T. (1973).Journal o f Theoretical Biology 38, 363. Yanagita, R. and Kogane, F. (1962).Journal o f General and Applied Microbiology, Tokyo 8, 201. Yanagita, T . and Kogane, F. (1963a). Journal o f General and Applied Microbiology, Tokyo 9, 179. Yanagita, T. and Kogane, F. (1963b).Journal ofGeneral and Applied Microbiology, Tokyo 9, 313. Zalokar, M . (1959).Amrican Journal o f Botany 46, 555. Zonneveld, B.J. M . (1974).Journal of General Microbiology 81, 445.
Physiology of Halobacteriaceae I. E. D. DUNDAS lnstitutt for Generell Mikrobiologi. Universitetet i Bergen. Bergen. Norway. I . Introduction . . . . . I1 . Classification of Extreme Halophiles
. .
. .
. .
.
. .
. .
. .
. . .
111. Intracellular and Extracellular Salt Concentrations
A . Intracellular Salts
. .
. .
. .
. .
.
. .
. . .
.
. .
. . .
.
. .
. . .
.
. .
85 86
88 88
90 B . Extracellular Salts 91 IV . Subcellular Structures . . . . . . A . Cell Envelopes . . . . . . . . . . . . 91 B . Ribosomes . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 C . Vacuoles . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 D . Flagella . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 V . Halophilic Proteins . . . . . . . . . . . 100 A . Metabolic Pathways . . . . . . . . . . . 101 B . Halophilic Enzymes . . . . . . . . . . . 102 . . . . . . . . . . 104 VI . Lipids in Halobacteriaceae VII . Electron-Transportchain . . . . . . . . . . 106 VIII . TransportAcrossMembranes . . . . . . . . . . 107 IX . Effects of Light . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109 A . Photophosphorylation . . . . . . . . . . 109 B . Effect o n Growth and Viability . . . . . . . . 110 X. Nucleic Acids and Their Enzymology . . . . . . . . 111 XI . Phage-HostRelationships . . . . . . . . . . 113 XI1. Ecological Considerations o n the Existence of Obligate Extreme Halophilism . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 XI11. Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . 116 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 116
.
I Introduction
Since prehistorical time. salt has been used by Man to preserve otherwise highly perishable materials such as fish. meat and hides . Spoilage of such highly salted products under unfavourable storage conditions could nevertheless be a serious economic problem . 85
86
I. E. D. DUNDAS
Bacteriologists became interested in the halophilic bacteria responsible because of the economic interest involved and because of the intriguing problems inherent in the ability of living organisms to function and proliferate in saturated brines. In recent times, the practice of cool storage has largely obviated the economic problems due to halophilic spoilage, at least in industrialized areas. Interest in extremely halophilic organisms has not decreased however. Even with the recent advances in our understanding of the physiology of these micro-organisms the basis for extreme obligate halophilism is far from clearly understood and remains an exciting scientific challenge. In addition to this, many scientists not primarily interested in extreme halophilism find that halophilic bacteria, their enzymes and organelles, are uniquely well suited to a study of general biological phenomena such as electron transport or transport of molecules across membranes. This review will concern itself only with extremely halophilic organisms, mainly with those classified in the 8th edition of “Bergey’s Manual” ( 1974) in the family Halobacteriaceae. This arbitrary delimitation is a convenient one, but ignores the fact that these organisms only represent one extreme of a continuum in the relationship between organisms and the salts in their external and internal milieux. Limiting a review of halophilism to this group of organisms is thus an artificial and unsatisfactory restriction which nevertheless limits the review to a manageable size. Excellent reviews with similar scopes have previously been published (Larsen, 1967; Kushner, 1968) and, as the present review will concern itself only with more recent developments, readers are referred to these reviews for older material. Extremely halophilic bacteria contain characteristic lipids having ether-linked alkyl groups instead of normal ester-bound fatty acids. The chemistry, metabolism and function of these unusual lipids has been thoroughly reviewed recently by Kates (1972). 11. Classification of Extreme Halophiles
Halophilism is not an easy parameter to include rationally in a taxonomic scheme. Growth of all micro-organisms is influenced by the presence of salt in their milieu. The influence may be positive or negative, depending on concentration; the tolerance range may vary considerably and the relation may be of an obligate or facultative nature. Extreme halophiles have been defined as those organisms which show best growth with 2 6 3 0 % (w/v) sodium chloride in their growth
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
87
medium (Larsen, 197 1). This definition would allow inclusion of organisms able to grow suboptimally in low concentrations of salt. In the 8th edition of “Bergey’s Manual” (1974), N. E. Gibbons defines as members of the family Halobacteriaceae rods and cocci requiring more than 12% (w/v) sodium chloride for growth. All members of the family are thus obligate halophiles and, to the extent that they show optimal growth with more than 20% (w/v)sodium chloride, they can be termed obligately extreme halophiles. The inclusion of coccoid forms among the Halobacteriaceae is amply justified by the growing awareness of the striking similarities between them and the rod-shaped Halobacteria spp. The two types of organisms may be isolated from the same natural sources and after the same enrichment procedures. Both are obligately extreme halophiles. Both are aerobic and have respiratory, never fermentative, metabolism. Both contain similar isoprenoid pigments, bacterioruberins and retinal (Kushwaha et al., 1973). Both rods (Larsen, 1967) and cocci (Brown and Cho, 1970; Steensland and Larsen, 197 1) lack muramic acid residues in their cell walls. Both have very high intracellular salt concentrations (Larsen, 1967). Both have unique cell-envelope lipids with di-ether linkages (Kates, 1972) and similar DNA base ratios (Kocur and Bohacek, 1972) and both have a major and a minor (satellite)DNA component (Moore and McCarthy, 1969a). I t is tempting to speculate on the possible correlation between some of the striking common characteristics of Halobacteria spp. and their obligate extremely halophilic nature. In spite of the notoriously pleomorphic nature of many members of the Halobacteriaceae family and of the many striking similarities between the hormally coccoid and other forms, one must accept the inclusion of coccoid forms in a separate genus, namely Halococcus, both because of their general shape, their thick polysaccharide-containing cell wall and because of their higher resistance to osmotic damage. The genus Halobacterium was divided into five species in the 7th edition of “Bergey’s Manual” (1957). The division was based on rather unsatisfactory criteria, nitrate reduction and chromogenesis among others. The 8th edition of “Bergey’s Manual” recognizes only two species, namely Halobacterium salinarium and Halobacterium halobium, mainly on the basis of some differentiation in DNA homology (Moore and McCarthy, 1969b). Three species are described as incerta sedis. Zwilling et al. ( 1969)attempted to elucidate the immunological relationships among some Halobacterium species. While showing a close immunological relationship among the Halobacterium strains tested, they
88
1. E.
D. DUNDAS
were also able to demonstrate four immunologically distinct and mutually exclusive groups. Some groups included strains classified in separate species by “Bergey’s Manual”. Immunological studies of obligately extreme halophiles do present difficulties. The antigen will necessarily be used in a denatured state due to decreased salt concentration, and the formed antibody can in any case hardly be expected to be active towards the original antigen in its natural very salty environment. I t is entirely possible that these facts do not preclude a satisfactory immunological taxonomic approach. Our knowledge of the members of the genus Halobacterium seems at present to be insufficient for a subdivision into species on other than rather subjective criteria. It seems a distinct possibility that the great homogeneity among the Halobacteriaceae to some extent reflects a bias on the part of the investigators. The original interest in the organisms as spoilage agents of proteinaceous materials led to the development of specific enrichment and isolation methods which are still in general and nearly exclusive use (Gibbons, 1969; Eimhjellen, 1965). Enrichment, o r plating on rich media containing yeast and protein hydrolysates, can hardly be expected to yield a flora representative of the varied halophilic microbial flora adapted to survival and proliferation in a saltern or salt lake. Isolation of carbohydrate-metabolizing extremely halophilic bacteria (Tomlinson and Hochstein, 1972a) and of halophilic photosynthetic bacteria (Raymond and Sistrom, 1967, 1969) has been reported. A photosynthetic facultatively aerobic halophilic spirillum with a growth range of from 2.5% to 25% (w/v) sodium chloride and a Halobacterium sp. able to grow with only glutamine and arginine as carbon and energy sources have recently been isolated in the author’s laboratory from the mother liquor in a Portuguese saltern. These reports raise the speculation that extreme halophilism may commonly occur in bacteria with much more variegated general physiology than that represented in the family of Halobac teriacea. 111. Intracellular and Extracellular Salt Concentrations A . INTRACELLULAR SALTS
Since Christian and Waltho (1962) demonstrated the very high intracellular salt concentrations in species of Halobacterium and Halococ-
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
89
cus, disappointingly little has been done to study the normal internal salt concentrations of extreme halophiles. Inferences as to the composition of the internal milieux have been drawn from the effects of salts on the metabolic machinery and internal structures, but little direct work has been done. It seems that the data of Christian and Waltho (1962) may be generally valid for organisms in the Halobacteriaceae family. In fact, serious doubts could be raised about including in the family any obligately extremely halophilic organisms with intracellular salt concentrations which varied markedly from that established by Christian and Waltho (1962). There are, in principle, at least two mechanisms by which an organism might cope with the adverse effects of an extremely high extracellular salt concentration. The Halobacteriaceae seem to have solved some of the problems by allowing an approximately isoosmotic internal salt concentration even if maintaining an extremely high molal concentration ratio of potassium to sodium. A high internal concentration of salt makes it essential that the whole metabolic and regulatory cell machinery be extremely halotolerant. Some organisms may counteract high extracellular salt concentrations by maintaining a lower intracellular salt concentration allowing for a more normal metabolic apparatus. Borowitzka and Brown ( 1974) argue that all unicellular organisms which can thrive in concentrated solutions of electrolytes or non-electrolytes must do so, at least partly, by accumulating a solute of compatible type. Working with a halophilic species of Dunaliella viridis, which apparently excludes sodium ions effectively allowing a moderate potassium uptake, they found intracellular glycerol contents of 4.4 molal after grown in 4.25 M sodium chloride. It seems possible that similar mechanisms might operate in other unicellular extremely halotolerant or halophilic organisms. Any mechanism for accumulating compatible electrolytes or non-electrolytes by production or uptake, whether glycerol or potassium ions, would require an energy expenditure. Van Uden ( 1968) suggested the use of chemostat cultures for studying maintenance requirements of growing cells. Watson ( 1970) reported that increased external salt concentrations forces Saccharomyces cerevisiae in chemostat cultures to expend extra maintenance energy resulting in lower ynTp values. Increases in external concentrations of sodium chloride also led to greatly increased glycerol production per unit of biomass formed. The intracellular concentration of potassium ions did
90
I. E. D. DUNDAS
not vary with increased external concentrations of sodium chloride. Some influx of Na' occurred, but a ratio of extracellular :intracellular Na' equal to 10: 1 was maintained. It would have been extremely interesting in view of the work of Borowitzka and Brown (1974) on Dunaliella viridis to know whether these yeast cells also accumulated glycerol internally when growing in the presence of high concentrations of sodium chloride. I t may well be that the ratio of surface to volume and the general biosynthetic capabilities of the organism determine what mechanisms can be evolved for coping with high external concentrations of salt, and that small extremely halophilic bacteria, with restricted metabolic capabilities, are forced to tolerate a high intracellular concentration of salt. It has been shown that Halobacteria spp. may maintain an extremely high intracellular :extracellular ratio of K' for several days in the absence of any added energy source (Gochnauer and Kushner, 197 1). Even artificial vesicles of cell envelopes devoid of cytoplasmic material were able to maintain high intracellular K'concentrations for several hours in the absence of added energy sources (Andersen, 1975). Lanyi and Silverman ( 1972) showed that Pretention in whole cells was not due to any binding to cytoplasmic material. The work by Andersen ( 1975) also indicated that the major factor in K'retention is the impermeability of the cell envelope. B. E X T R A C E L L U L A R SALTS
I t is to be expected that obligately extreme halophiles are particularly well adapted for growth in the saline environment where they are normally found. An interesting new Halobacterium strain, namely H . uolcanii, isolated from Dead Sea sediment shows optimal growth at the unusually low sodium chloride concentration of 12% and would thus not qualify as an extreme halophile but fulfills the criteria for inclusion in the genus Halobacterium. Optimal salt concentrations for this strain mimick strikingly the saline composition of Dead Sea water from which it was isolated (Mullakhanbhai and Larsen, 1975). The most commonly available source for isolation of Halobacteria spp. is salt produced by solar evaporation of sea water. This fact may have led to an overemphasis on the importance of sodium chloride in growth media. The requirements for potassium and calcium ions, and especially the requirement for high concentrations of magnesium ions,
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
91
should not be surprising in view of the natural habitat where the organisms grow and proliferate. It is probably more correct to view the mother liquour from solar evaporation pans and not the harvested salt as a natural habitat for halobacteria. The composition of the mother liquor is characterized by its very high magnesium-ion content and by having a concentration of sodium chloride of about 4.5 M at the end of a salt harvest period (Lepierre, 1936). I t may be appropriate here to re-emphasize the point made by Weber (1949) that it might be fruitful to pay more attention to the original habitat in future work on extracellular salt relationships of halobacteria. The external salt concentration may have a great influence on the survival of halobacteria. Gochnauer and Kushner ( 197 1) showed that omission of K+ decreased the ability of H . halobium to survive in salt solutions. The lack of success in maintaining isolates of extreme halophiles by freeze-drying (Gibbons, 1969) could be due to difficultieswith the control of water activity in preparations where salts represent the bulk of the material. Eimhjellen ( 1965) reports that cells of Halobacten‘um spp. may survive in salt for several years. The survival rates are not likely to be identical for all members of the halophile flora. While the bacterial flora of newly harvested salt probably is not fully representative of that in the saltern, this original salt flora is subject to further changes on storage. K. Eimhjellen (personal communication) indicates that storage under liquid nitrogen is satisfactory for pure cultures of extreme halophiles.
IV. Subcellular Structures
Extreme halophiles possess a normal array of subcellular structures. Their composition and their relationship to salt concentration may be unique. Their functions in the cell are “normal”, but must be carried out in the abnormal environment of near-saturated salt solutions. A.
CELL ENVELOPES
I t is rather surprising that two so markedly morphologically different bacterial groups as the halococci and halobacteria should both lack the constituent peptidoglycan in their cell envelopes (Reistad, 1975 ; Steensland and Larsen, 1969). Cell envelopes of the two groups are
92
I. E. D. DUNDAS
very dissimilar in many other aspects. Halococcus cell walls have strong anatomical resemblances to the walls of the non-halophilic Micrococcaceae (Steensland and Larsen, 197 1). In contrast to halobacteria, halococcus celIs are very resistant to low ionic environments, and their walls are quite resistant to disrupture by mechanical treatment. I t is not clear what compounds might be responsible for the mechanical strength of halococcal cells. Residues of amino acids and hexosamines constitute only 7-15% of the dry weight of the cell walls. There is a marked similarity in the chemical composition of walls of difrerent Halococcus strains. Noteworthy is the presence of gulosaminuronic acid which previously only has been found in Vi’ibrio prirahaemolyticus (Reistad, 197 5). Cell envelopes of halobacteria on the other hand are most fragile structures. Lowering the ionic concentration. of the suspending medium to about 12% sodium chloride by dilution with water or various ionic or non-ionic solutions causes severe disarrangement of the envelope (Larsen, 1967, 1973). Slight mechanical stress, like picking up a colony with a dry inoculum loop, may cause massive disruption of cells. The spectacular chemi-osmotic and mechanical fragility of Halobaclerium envelopes stimulated work on their morphology and composition. The surface layer of a halobacterium presents a regular hexagonal pattern when replica preparations are viewed in the electron microscope. D’Aoust and Kushner (1972) indicate that this hexagonal pattern can best be described as a honeycomb network forming the outer layer of the envelope. After mechanical disruption of cells, the cell envelope fragments tend spontaneously to form closed vesicles (Steensland and Larsen, 1969; Stoeckenius and Rowen, 1967). The vesicles exhibit the same hexagonal pattern as the whole cells (Andersen, 1975), which is taken as an indication that they have the normal “outside out” orientation of whole cell envelopes. The orientation of the membrane is crucial in interpreting the results from experiments on transport across vesicle membranes. Andersen ( 1975) utilized vesicles from H . salinarium which apparently all had the normal outside-out topology. Kanner and Racker (1975) on the other hand found that a portion of their vesicles prepared from H . halobium seemed to have the inverted outside-in topology. The mechanism for vesicle formation is not well enough understood to predict the final topology of the vesicles, and extreme care must be taken in in-
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
93
terpreting minor differences in experiments on transport across vesicle membranes. Andersen ( 1975) studied transport phenomena associated with Halobacterium vesicles. It is remarkable that even quite small vesicles are continuous structures and do not allow leakage of contained material. The ability to form such small closed vesicles seems to indicate a remarkable fluidity in the envelope material. Thin sections of halobacteria show that they are surrounded by a three-layered unit membrane which again for some strains may be surrounded by a second structure forming a complex envelope. The envelope proteins are acidic in nature with at least five mole percent excess of acidic amino-acid residues. Diaminopimelic acid has not been found (Steensland and Larsen, 1969). Mjelde (1971) found that most cell-envelope amino sugars of H . salinarium were present as glycoproteins. Detectable amounts of peptidoglycan were not found, strengthening the hypothesis that polysaccharides play a negligible role in cell-envelope structure. An unique feature of H . salinarium cell envelopes seems to be the presence of sulphated acidic polysaccharides as reported by Koncewicz ( 1972). Mescher and Strominger (1975) studied the effect of several antibiotics, supposedly active in interfering with peptidoglycan synthesis, on H . salinarium, H . halobium and H . cutirubrum. Insensitivity of these bacteria towards the antibiotics was to be expected as peptidoglycan is not a constituent of their cell walls. With the exception of bacitracin, the antibiotics were indeed quite ineffective. Bacitracin, however, induced sphere formation by the normal rod-shaped bacteria even at concentrations as low as a few micrograms per ml. Mescher and Strominger (1975) suggest that bacitracin interferes with synthesis of the cell-envelope glycoproteins and possibly also with synthesis of saturated isoprenoid chains of membrane lipids. The results support the suggestion that glycoproteins and lipids play a role in maintaining cell-envelope morphology. Hsia et al. (1971) concluded from work using electron spinresonance labels that dissolution of the cell membrane of H. salinarium in media of low ionic strength was accompanied by changes in protein conformation and in lipid-protein interactions. In the course of a thorough study of the electron-transport chain of halobacteria, Lanyi ( 197 1) also studied more closely the salt-dependent dissolution of cell envelopes. A sequential solubilization of envelope components on lowering the sodium chloride concentration was demonstrated, flavo-
94
I. E. D. DUNDAS
proteins and the outer layer of the envelope being removed first. The components solubilized by a slight decrease in sodium chloride concentration exhibited a marked specificity for sodium chloride for remaining in the envelope. Components which were solubilized only at low concentrations of sodium chloride showed little salt specificity, remaining attached when sodiurn chloride was substituted by sodium nitrate or perchlorate. Solubilization of the envelopes with hydrophobic bond-breaking agents, such as urea, and di- and tetramethyl urea, also indicates that components showing high specificity for sodium chloride and requiring high concentrations of salt for remaining in the membranes were bound by predominantly hydrophobic forces, while the binding of components with low salt specificity and requiring low concentrations of salt, were predominantly ionic in character. Brown and Stevenson (1971) have shown that the composition of membrane fractions from H . salinarium may vary with the phase of growth. I t was remarkable in this connection that the molar ratio of menaquinone-8 (vitamin K,-40) to carotenoid in the membrane remained constant regardless of growth phase. Lanyi ( 1972a, b) has shown that treatment of H . cutirubrum cells and cell-envelope vesicles with Triton X- 100 results in the appearance of menadione reductase, an enzyme normally bound to the inside of the envelope. Respiring cells were resistant to Triton X- 100 while respiration-inhibited cells lysed rapidly. Respiring cells did lose the integrity of their cell envelope, and resistance to Triton X-100 seems to be due to the inability of the detergent to penetrate the lipid phase of membranes of respiring cells (Lanyi, 1973). Studies on the effect of Triton X-100 in shifting the absorption spectrum of the membranebound carotenoid bacterioruberin also indicated that the lipidmembrane layer is protected against derangement by its respiratory activity. Lanyi (1972b) points out that such a protection against detergents by respiratory activity is analogous to the substrate stabilization effects on many enzyme systems. The effect seems to be a good example of a “normal function” operative under highly abnormal extremely halophilic conditions. 8. RIBOSOMES
Ever since Bayley and Kushner (1964) isolated ribosomes from H . cutirubrum and reported on their unique relations to high K+and Mg2+
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
95
concentrations, interest in the function and structure of these organelles in halobacteria has remained high. A most important development occurred when Bayley and Griffiths ( 1968a, b) showed that halobacterial ribosomes function normally in protein synthesis when their specific ionic requirements were satisfied. There was no evidence for any abnormalities in the genetic code for the amino acids. Ionic requirements may be different for maintaining ribosome integrity and for achieving optimal amino-acid incorporation. Ribosome stability was achieved in 0.1 M Mg2+whileoptimal amino-acid incorporation occurred in the presence of 0.02-0.04 M Mg? The presence of 3.8 M K+ and 1.0 M Na+was required for stabi!ity and activity. The observation that high Na+ concentrations increased the fidelity of translation is noteworthy. Rauser and Bayley (1968) noted that the stability of polyribosomes from H . cutirubrum depended specifically on the concentrations of both Mg2+and NH: ions. Visentin et al. (1972) were able selectively to remove groups of proteins from the 30 S and 50 S subunits of 70 S ribosomal particles from H . cutirubrum. This work has been continued by Strcbm and Visentin (1973) who have determined the molecular weights of the selectively extracted ribosomal proteins and compared them with analogous proteins from Escherichia coli. The acidic nature of the proteins released form halobacterial ribosomes has been known since the work of Bayley and Kushner (1964). Strcbm et al. (1975) have further studied the selective removal of 5 S RNA and proteins from 50 S ribosomal subunits. An acidic alanine-rich 50 S ribosomal protein from H . cutirubrum shows an extensive amino-acid sequence homology with analogous ribosomal proteins from E . coli (Oda et al., 1974). Such amino-acid homologies re-emphasize the questions about the evolutionary relationships between extreme halophiles and other organisms. I t is suggested that the rather high degree of conservation in the amino-acid sequence of this protein indicates that it is important in the basic function of protein synthesis on ribosomes. Further work along these lines may clarify the interrelations between normal function and abnormal saline environments. Visentin et al. (1972) extracted rRNA particles from 70 S ribosomes of H . cutirubrum and found that the 16 S and 23 S rRNA from the halophilic organism had a higher percentage of G + C (56.1 and 58.8%) than the corresponding rRNA from E . coli (53.8 and 54.1%). I t may be that this higher G + C percentage reflects the higher ionic concentrations to which H . cutirubrum ribosomes are normally exposed.
96
I. E. D. DUNDAS C . VACUOLES
Some Halobacterium species are conspicuously vacuolated, a characteristic which they share with some cyanobacteria, green and purple sulphur-bacteria and a few non-photosynthetic bacteria. Falkenberg (1974) gave a good review of present knowledge about vacuoles especially in halobacteria. Cohen-Bazire et al. ( 1969) point out that gas vacuoles from halobacteria and photosynthetic bacteria are strikingly similar both in general morphology and in fine structure. Vacuoles from all of these prokaryotic organisms are cylindrical structures with conical ends; the bounding membrane is a single layer nonunit membrane. The controversy about whether vacuoles contain gas or not seems to have been definitively settled. The structures contain gas which is freely exchangeable with gas in the medium. Vacuoles will collapse on being subjected to sudden increases in pressure (Walsby, 197 1). It is generally held that the gas vacuoles serve to position the aquatic micro-organism at an appropriate depth in the water column. Halobacteria, being strictly aerobic and living in strong brines with limited oxygen solubility, would presumably profit from flotation. During evaporation, the brines in a saltern may contain appreciable concentrations of oxygen even at the greatest depth. This is presumably due to the turnover of relatively oxygenated surface water with the increasing density due to evaporation. In the absence of evaporation, saltern brines may however rapidly become quite anoxic and the Dead Sea is permanently anoxic at depths below 40 m. Vacuolation may be a rather unstable character, some Halobacterium strains losing their vacuoles on subculturing in the laboratory (Larsen el al., 1967). Some Halobacterium strains, notably those classified as belonging to the species H . halobium, seem to be vacuolated at all stages of the cell cycle. Some Halobacterium strains produce non-vacuolated cells which become vacuolated on ageing. Vacuolization in such strains seems to be dependent on the physiological state of the cells, older colonies exhibiting circular zones and sectors with different degrees of vacuo1iza t ion. Isolation of vacuoles by fractional centrifugation is hampered by the fact that these structures collapse on exposure to the pressure increases in the centrifuge tube. Falkenberg ( 1974) obtained highly purified
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
97
preparations of vacuoles from halobacteria by graded filtration of a preparation of lysed cells followed by flotation centrifugation. Comparison of vacuole membranes from two species of Halobacterium and the cyanobacteriumAnabaenaflos-qua (Falkenberg, 1974 ; Falkenberg et al., 1972) demonstrated that the membranes contained only protein and that these proteins contained unusually high proportions of non-polar amino-acid residues. Sulphur-containing amino acids were not found. Vacuole proteins from the extreme halophiles were considerably more acidic than those from the cyanobacterial vacuoles. Krantz and Ballou ( 1973), investigating vacuoles from another strain of H . halobium, found small amounts of tightly bound Dgalactose and phosphate. It seems possible, however, that this material may represent tightly bound contaminants. All gas-vacuole membranes from different halobacteria seem to be composed mainly or totally of proteins, and their amino-acid composition is similar and quite characteristic. Vacuole membranes from Halobacterium species 5 and H . halobium Brown (Falkenberg, 1974) are very similar in the mole percentage of their amino-acid residues. Similarities also exist between vacuole proteins from H. halobium Brown and Halobacterium species 5 as compared with those of H . halobium Delft (Krantz and Ballou, 1973). These statements hold true even though Falkenberg (1974) has shown that the vacuole from Halobacterium species 5 contains two protein species of molecular weights 12,900 and 15,100 daltons, respectively. The amino-acid composition of the two protein species was quite similar. It is not so surprising that vacuole proteins are similar in the cyanobacteria Anabaena and Microcystis (Falkenberg et al., 1972). More surprising is perhaps the degree of similarity found between the vacuole proteins from Halobacterium and Cyanobacterium spp. (Table 1). While the results presented in Table 1 are based solely on statistical probabilities, they do seem to support the view that vacuoles from presumably distantly related organisms are markedly similar not only morphologically but also as regards their proteins. Vacuoles and their proteins seem to be very well suited for comparative studies to elucidate halophilic properties of structural proteins. The ability to assess small structural variations by measuring changes in resistance to pressure-induced collapse (Walsby, 197 1 ) opens up possibilities for studying otherwise undetectable salt effects on a halophilic structural protein (Falkenberg, 1974).
TABLE 1. Relationships between pairs of proteins as estimated by the sum of squared differences in the contents of 15 amino acid residues (SAQvalues) Protein species Ribosomal 70s Fractions Escherichia colilHalobacteriumculisubrum Escherichia colilHalobaclerium cutirubrum Halobacterium cutirubrumlHalobacterium cutirubrum Vacuole Proteins Halobacleriurn halobium (De1ft)lHalobacteriumhalobium (Brown) Halobacterium halobium ( Delft)/Halobacleriumsp. 5 Halobacleriurn halobium (Delft)/Microcystis sp. Halobacleriurn halobiurn (De1ft)lAnabaenasp. Microcysfis sp.lAnabaena sp. Halobaclerium sp. 5AIHalobacten'urnsp. 5B RNA Polymaases Halobaclehum cutirubrurn subunit atsubunit Halobacleriurn cutirubrum subunit alEscherichia coli
SAQValue 247
160 120
References Spahr ( 1952),Bayley (1966) Spahr (19621,Visentin el al. (1972) Bayley (1966),Visentin et al. (1972)
m
P 24
27 96 73 23
21 12 298
Krantz and Ballou (19731, Falkenberg, (1974) Krantz and Ballou (19731, Falkenberg, (1974) Krantzand Ballou (19731, Falkenberg, (1974) Krantz and Ballou (19731, Falkenberg, (1974) Krantz and Ballou (1973), Falkenberg, (1974) Krantz and Ballou (19731, Falkenberg, (1974) Lanyi (1974) Lanyi (1974)
0
C
z CI
L
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
99
D. FLAGELLA
Members of the genus Halobacterium are motile, exhibiting polar flagellation. The flagella can be stained by silver impregnation methods (Blenden and Goldberg, 1965). Fully grown cultures contain, in addition to flagella lophotrichously attached to cells, large amounts of loose flagella. These loose flagella sometimes aggregate in thick spiral bundles visible under the light microscope. These bundles are analogous to those reported for Proteus and Bacillus species (Frank and Hoffman, 1968; Wilson and Combs, 1970). Attempts at harvesting halobacterial flagella by traditional procedures, that is by shearing flagella from cells by shaking, resulted in excessive contamination by cell debris. The fragile Halobacterium cells tend to break before flagella shear off. Loose flagella and the flagellar bundles can be harvested directly by fractional centrifugation and by isopycnic centrifugation in gradients of caesium chloride. While such preparations probably are not pure enough to warrant chemical studies, such as amino-acid analysis, they appear microscopically pure and can be used in morphological studies on the effect of salts and solvents on flagella aggregation and morphology. T. Torsvik in my department found that flagellar bundles dissagregate into individual flagella on exposure to M-NaCI. Even in the presence of 4 M-NaCI, the bundles would dissagregate if exposed to 6 M-urea. Exposure to 8 M-urea caused disintegration of individual flagella. Morphological changes on exposure to a salt-free environment were slow. Dialysis against water for several hours caused the flagella to loose their uniform, helical morphology, but they did not disintegrate completely. Conventional procedures for disintegration of flagella, such as lowering the pH value, did not cause disintegration of flagella from halophiles. Attempts at electrophoretic analysis of urea-disintegrated flagella were unsuccessful, possibly because of hydrophobic aggregation of the proteins. T. Torsvik has recently found that 0.5%MgCI, protects flagellar integrity even in the absence of other salts. This finding raises the hope of purifying flagellar protein by conventional physicochemical procedures. While the flagellar proteins from Halobacterium salinarium thus seem to be distinct from the flagellin of other bacteria, the energy requirements for motility resemble those of some
100
I. E. D. DUNDAS
aerobic non-halophilic bacteria. Arginine is able to sustain motility under anaerobic conditions, presumably as a result of ATP formation from the ornithine carbamoyl transferase-catalysed reaction.
V. Halophilic Proteins Lanyi (1974) has recently published an excellent review on the saltdependent properties of proteins from extremely halophilic bacteria. A traditional theory for explaining the properties of halophilic proteins holds that the role of Na' and K+ is to shield mutually repulsive negatively charged groups within the protein molecule. The well established facts that halophilic proteins generally are more acidic than their non-halophile analogues, and that many halophilic proteins become less compact on lowering the salt concentration in the media, agree with the theoretical model. Bulk protein from both Halobacterium and Halococcus strains have a much greater excess of acidic amino acids than their non-halophile counterparts (Reistad, 1970). Many individual protein species from extreme halophiles also contain unusually high proportions of acid amino-acid residues. Lanyi and Stevenson ( 1970) studied the enzyme menadione reductase in some detail with respect to its relationship to salts. They found that hydrophobic binding forces contribute largely to its stability at high salt concentrations. Lanyi ( 1974) makes the point that rather low salt concentrations would be suflicient to satisfy charge-shielding effects alone. At high salt concentrations, new hydrophobic interactions are formed within the molecule, such interactions not being stable enough at lower salt concentrations. The relative importance of hydrophobic interactions for many halophilic proteins is evident from a calculation of their hydrophobicity parameters (Lanyi, 1974) as compared with non-halophilic proteins. Lanyi also points out that the cation specificity exhibited by many halophilic structural and functional proteins need not be solely or even largely due to specifically steric effects. The preference of binding of specific ions could be due to a larger net free-energy difference obtained when the specific ion is removed from its hydration shell in the aqueous environment and placed near the site of binding. It is obviously important to differentiate between salt effects on the stability and the activity of proteins. From these considerations, one would naturally expect halophilic proteins as a general rule to be rather acidic
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
101
and to contain a fairly high proportion of hydrophobic amino-acid residues. While this may be generally true, extreme hydrophobicity or electrostatic charge of proteins may obviously be due to other than halophilic considerations. Professor R. Dowben pointed out that protein-sequence relationships could be inferred from data on amino-acid composition of proteins (EidsP, 1972). Data on sulphur-containing amino acids and tryptophan are not useful in this connection due to their general unreliability. The sum of the squared differences of the molar concentrations of paired amino acids from two proteins (SAW is an index of their relatedness. Recently, Dayhoff et al. ( 1975) suggested a similar procedure for assessing protein relatedness. Table 1 (p. 98) gives SAQvalues based on 15 amino-acid residues from various halophilic and non-halophilic proteins. While the considerations are based solely on the statistical probability that proteins with low SAQ values have similar amino-acid sequences, one may assume that a value of SAQ smaller than 50 indicates a very high probability that large sequence homologies exist. It may be argued that the apparent relatedness of H . halobium and cyanobacterial vacuole proteins is due to factors other than sequence homology. It would be interesting to compare other enzymes and flagellar proteins by this method. A.
METABOLIC PATHWAYS
Larsen (1967) stated that there was no reason to believe that the general metabolic patterns of extreme halophiles differed basically from those of non-halophiles and that the uniqueness of the differences seemed to lie solely in the halophilic nature of the enzymes. There is no reason to modifjr this general view today. All enzymes of the citrate and glyoxylate cycles have been detected in H . salinarium (Aitken and Brown, 1969). I t was long an accepted general view that extremely halophilic bacteria utilize carbohydrates very poorly if at all, but it has been demonstrated that H . halobium, H . cutirubrum and H . salinarium do utilize glycerol, sodium succinate and sodium pyruvate especially in media with high levels of potassium (Gochnauer and Kushner, 1969). Tomlinson and Hochstein (1972a) isolated carbohydrate-metabolizing extremely halophilic bacteria which grew, albeit suboptimally, on various carbohydrate-containing media. One of the isolates (designated M 6) was studied more closely. It utilized both
102
I. E. D. DUNDAS
glucose and galactose with concomitant production of pyruvate and acetate (Tomlinson and Hochstein, 1972b). The same strain was able to metabolize glucose via a modified Entner-Doudoroff pathway in which oxidation of glucose preceeds phosphorylation (Tomlinson et al., 1974). That hexokinase activity also was detected in the crude extract would indicate that glucose might also be metabolized by other pathways. Lipid metabolism in halobacteria seems to be unusual in that it proceeds by the malonate instead of by the more usual mevalonic pathway (Bergey’s Manual, 1974). The end products, phosphate esters of 1,Z-di-O-(dihydrophytyll-glycerol, are certainly unique (JOO and Kates, 1968). Squalenes are also among the lipids found both in extreme (Tornabene et al., 1969) and in more moderately halophilic organisms (Mullakhanbhai and Francis, 1972). Several workers (Marshall and Brown, 1968; Brown and Pearce, 1969) have reported finding different concentrations of lipid constituents in H. halobium depending on the growth phase. Such results emphasize the need for well defined growth conditions for obtaining reproducible results. Halobacteria adapt well to chemostat cultivation which may be a method of choice for similar studies. It was early recognized that arginine might be an interesting amino acid in the metabolism of extreme halophiles (Weber, 1949). Ducharme et al. (1972) also found that arginine was rapidly removed from the medium by H. cutirubrum. Arginine metabolism in H. salinarium seems to be similar to that in many non-halophiles (Larsen, 1967). The amino acid is degraded via the arginine desimidase pathway, and the resulting citrulline converted to ornithine with production of carbamoylphosphate in a reaction catalysed by ornithine carbamoyltransferase. This enzyme shows many of the normal regulatory properties of the analogous non-halophilic enzymes (Dundas, 1972). Chemostat experiments indicate that arginine to a great extent functions as a readily available energy source in the medium. B.
HALOPHILIC ENZYMES
Lanyi and Stevenson (1969) assumed that the role of high concentrations of ions was not primarily to lower water activity in the medium, but to interact directly and specifically with the conformation of enzymes. They pointed out that the observed specificities of ion pairs might be due to the high ionic strengths in the media. Such pair specificities were not likely to be expressed at low concentrations of ions. Accepting the suggestion (Lanyi, 1974) that the typical halophilic
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
103
enzyme is a protein with an excess of acidic and hydrophobic aminoacid residues, the possible specific and general effects of high concentrations of salts are so varied as to defy any simplistic unifjring model. Charge shielding may be accomplished by Father low concentrations of ions; salting out of hydrophobic groups would require higher salt concentrations. For these effects, ion specificity might be achieved by simple steric or thermodynamic considerations. In addition, ions may be directly involved as a substrate in the enzymic conversions as has been suggested by the work of Aitken and Brown (1972). Griffiths ( 1970a, b) purified amino-acyl-tRNA synthetase from H . cutirubrum and found that the transfer reaction required 0.4 M-NH,CI for maximum activity while the ammonium ion at the same time acted as a competitive inhibitor with the respect to the amino acid (Grifiths and Bayley, 1969). The different ionic interactions may specifically affect enzyme activity, stability, or both. The individual structure of an enzyme, such as the existence of sulphydryl groups in halophile isocitrate dehydrogenase (Hubbard and Miller, 1970)or protein subunits (Louis and Fittt, 1971a1, may further complicate the picture. It is not surprising that several enzymes from H . salinarium are rather thermophilic (Keradjopoulos and Wulff, 1974). The low-temperature lability of several enzymes, including threonine deaminase (Lieberman and Lanyi, 19721, aspartate carbamoyltransferase (Norberg et al., 1973) and alanine dehydrogenase (Keradjopoulos and Wulff, 1974), probably reflects the cold sensitivity of hydrophobic bonds important for enzyme structure. Many regulatory mechanisms operative for normal enzymes have been shown to be active for halophilic systems. Feedback and product inhibition have been found for several enzymes, including aspartate carbamoyltransferase (Liebl et al., 1969; Norberg et al., 1973) and ornithine carbamoyltransferase (Dundas, 1972). The regulatory properties reported for citrate synthase from H . cutirubrum are noteworthy as resembling those in Gram-positive organisms (Cazzulo, 1973).The low molecular weight of the halophilic citrate synthase might not correlate so much with its similarities with the enzymes from Gram-positive organisms as with the unusually low molecular weight found for DNAdependent RNA polymerase (Louis and Fitt, 197 lb), polynucleotide phosphorylase, and RNA-dependent RNA polymerase from the same organism (Louis et al., 1971). One is reminded of Ingram’s prediction (Ingram, 1947) that the solubility of halophilic enzymes in high concentrations of salts might
104
1. E. D. DUNDAS
involve their existence as smaller molecular aggregates. Sigmoidal kinetics suggestive of allosteric interactions have been found for several enzymes, namely threonine deaminase (Lieberman and Lanyi, 19721, ornithine carbamoyltfansferase (Dundas, 1972) and aspartate carbamoyltransferase (Liebl et d.,1970;Norberg et d.,1973).Aitken and Brown ( 1972) found that sigmoidal kinetics for activity of an isocitrate dehydrogenase from H . salinarium depended on high concentrations of sodium chloride allowing polymerization of enzyme subunits into trimers or tetramers. All work on halophilic enzymes thus far indicates that the mechanisms underlying activity and regulation are similar to those that operate with non-halophilic enzymes. Further insights into those features of halophilic enzymes that are of importance in permitting “normal” function in abnormally saline environments will probably necessitate isolation of pure enzyme preparations, both for studying stoicheiometrically the various enzyme-salt interactions and for determining hydrophobicity and acidity parameters based on amino-acid analysis. Purification of halophilic enzymes has always been a difficult task, due to their instability in media containing low concentrations of salt. Several approaches will facilitate future work. Chromatography on calcium apatite (Norberg and Hofsten, 1970; Hochstein and Dalton, 1973;Dundas, 1970)is especially appropriate as the procedure is not disturbed by high concentrations of salt. Many halophilic enzymes are protected by the presence of their substrates, and several halophilic enzymes can be re-activated from low-salt inactivation by addition of salt especially if they contain stabilizing disulphide bridges. The protective effects of polyamines (Hochstein and Dalton, 1968, 1973; Lanyi, 1969b1,glycerol and ethylene glycol (Lanyi and Stevenson, 1969) on various halophilic enzymes is especially interesting. In this connection, the point should be made that, working with highly concentrated solutions, molality and not molarity may be the correct concentration reference. In concentrated solutions of sucrose, ornithine carbamoyltransferase activity reflects the molal and not the molar concentration of salt in the assay solution. VI. Lipids in Halobaaeriaceae
The lipids in members of the Halobacteriaceae have a strikingly difrerent composition from those of more normal bacteria. Already in
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
105
1962 it was reported that H. cutirubrum lip5ds consisted mainly of diphosphatidylglycerol assumed to contain only ether-linked alkyl groups (Sehgal et al., 1962). Subsequent work, mainly by Kates and his group, has confirmed this assumption and led to a closer understanding of many intriguing aspects of lipid structure and metabolism in members of the Halobacteriaceae (Kates, 1972). In an elegant paper, it was shown that the unique lipids with ether linkages were not restricted to organisms in the genus Halobacterium, but were also typical of the halococci (Kates et al., 1966). Most work on lipids from extreme halophiles has been. carried out on H. cutirubrum, but enough has been done on other extreme halophiles that organisms in the Halobacteriaceae, also as regards lipid structure and metabolism, emerge as an unusual but surprisingly homogeneous group. Most if not all of the lipids in these cells are found associated with the membranes of the cellular envelope. The lipids consist in all studied cases of polyisoprenoid chains bound by ether linkages to glycerol. Fatty-acid residues are not detectable by normal analytical procedures, but synthesis of trace amounts of fatty acids can be demonstrated using isotopically labelled acetate (Kates et al., 1968). This extremely low content of fatty-acyl residues is in striking contrast to the situation found for moderately halophilic and non-halophilic bacteria where fatty-acyl residues represent a major fraction of the lipid content. Relatively little has been done on the biosynthesis of fatty acids since Kates et al. (1968) demonstrated that a pathway for fatty-acid synthesis might exist. Working with cell-free extracts from H. cutirubrum, Pugh et al. (197 1) found a salt-tolerant fatty-acid synthetase. It thus seems that the malonyl-CoA pathway for fatty-acid synthesis is present in halobacteria. They found the fatty-acid synthesis to be severely inhibited by salt. The evolutionary implications of the existence of a severely saltinhibited malonyl-CoA pathway in halobacteria are far from clear. One might assume that the presence of only trace amounts of fatty acids is somehow important for the organisms, in which case the severe salt sensitivity of the biosynthetic pathway enzymes would be of minor importance. The major pathway for lipid synthesis in H. cutirubrum proceeds from acetate via mevalonate as an intermediate (Kates et al., 1968).
The ether-linked alkyl groups in halobacterial lipids have been shown to have a structure corresponding to dihydrophytyl (phytanyl) (Kates et al., 1965). Isotope-labelling experiments with whole cells show that glycerol is an effective precursor for both the glycerol and
106
I. E. D. DUNDAS
the phytanyl moieties of the lipid. The fact that the label in 1(3b3Hglycerol is totally retained in the glycerol moiety of the lipid indicates that aldo-keto isomerizations can not occur in this part of the pathway. Kates ( 1972) argues that dihydroxyacetone itself, or a separate pool of dihydroxyacetone phosphate, might serve as an intermediate, and points out that the unknown metabolic steps from dihydroxyacetone or dihydroxyacetone phosphate to the diphytanyl glycerol ether probably represent the really unique steps in the pathway for biosynthesis of ether linkages in a dialky glycerol ether. Biosynthesis of the phytanyl moiety probably proceeds by normal metabolic pathways as far as the production of dimethyl allyl pyrophosphate. The biosynthetic pathway for phytol from dimethyl allyl pyrophosphate which occurs in plants is largely unknown, but there is no specific reason to assume that this pathway is different in the halobacteria (Kates, 1972). Kates ( 1972) discusses the potential function of diphytanyl ether lipids in extremely halophilic bacteria. He suggests that the membrane lipids might contribute towards structural stability as the diether analogue of phosphatidylglycerophosphate has a strong affinity for Mg2+. This would also at least in part explain the importance of magnesium ions in maintaining the structural integrity of halobacteria. The saturated nature of the lipids would also protect the membranes against peroxidation under aerobic conditions. A most interesting point is made in suggesting that the lipid may play a role in selective ion transport by the membrane. Synthetic model membrands constructed with the diphytanyl ether analogue of phosphatidylglycerophosphate have properties which would render them highly selective for K+ transport (Kates,1972). If a fundamental common characteristic of extreme halophiles is their ability to counteract a high external concentration of salts by maintaining an internal compatible solute with high concentrations of potassium ions, then one would also expect membranes with lipids specially well suited for selective transport of potassium ions to be a common characteristic for this group of bacteria. In this connection, it is interesting to note that the lipids from the moderately halophilic bacterium H. volcanii were quite similar to those in previously investigated extreme halophiles. VII. Electron-Transport Chain
The presence in halobacteria of a fairly normal electron- transport chain, able to oxidize succinate, glycerol phosphate or NADH,, and
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
107
containing cytochromes of the b, c and a types, was established early (Lanyi, 1968, 1969a). it may be remarked that some work on electrontransport using “particulate fractions”, obtained by homogenizing cells in media containing high concentrations of salt, may have given preparations containing closed envelope vesicles. As some components of the electron-transport chain are localized on the inner surface of the envelope (Lanyi, 1972a1, permeability phenomena may have influenced the results obtained. Cheah (1969) studied the properties of the electron-transport particles of H. cutirubrum and reported the presence of cytochromes o and a,, both reducible by ascorbate. The c-type cytochrome present could not be reduced by ascorbate alone, but was reduced by ascorbate-tetramethyl-p-phenylendiamine (TMPD). Electron-transport particles from H. iialobium contained cytochromes o and a, and a predominant complex of b-type cytochromes. Both the membrane-bound a- and b-type cytochromes could be reduced by ascorbate alone or ascorbate-TMPD (Cheah, 1970a). Thus, a feature peculiar to extreme halophiles seems to be the ability of their cytochromes a,, a, or o to be reduced by ascorbate alone. The ascorbate-induced respiration and the cytochrome oxidase activity in H. culirubrum proceed at higher rates in the presence of high concentrations of K+ than with equimolar Concentrations of Na’. This may reflect the higher intracellular concentrations of K+ in intact H. cutirubrum cells (Cheah, 1970b). On the basis of work on H . salinarium and H. cutirubrum, Cheah (1970a) proposes an electron-transport chain for these organisms in which ascorbic acid reduces some of the b-type cytochromes. A by-pass from the cytochrome-b complex to cytochrome oxidase was indicated by the insensitivity of ascorbate oxidation to low concentrations of 2-heptyl-4-hydroxyquinoline-Noxide which effectively inhibits reduction of cytochrome c by the cytochrome b complex. VIII. Transport Across Membranes Halobacterium salinarium is able to carry out energy-dependent transport of glutamate; this transport is specifically dependent on the Na+ outside the cells (Larsen, 1967). A thorough study of glutamate transport in H . salinarium vesicles has been made by Andersen ( 1975). The vesicles were composed of seemingly structurally complete cellenvelope material with a normal outside-out topology. Care was taken to ensure that the vesicles were empty of any cytoplasmic material. The
108
I. E. D. DUNDAS
contents of such vesicles could be changed by varying the composition of the media in which they were formed. With ascorbate as an oxidizable substrate, vesicles accumulated glutamine against a gradient of 1 :230,000. The transpoft mechanism had an absolute requirement for K+ inside the vesicles and Na'outside. Glutamate did not diffuse out of the vesicles even under conditions where the uptake mechanism was inhibited. As the amino acid exists in its free form inside the vesicles, it follows that the membranes must be impermeable to glutamate. The Na' gradient and the K+ gradient necessary for optimal glutamate uptake could not by themselves furnish the energy for uptake. Vesicles containing the same internal concentration of K+ or Na' as the suspending medium were able to effect glutamate uptake. Vesicles were able to accumulate glutamate even if the directions of the K'and Na+ gradients were reversed. In the absence of ascorbate, no glutamate uptake occurred, even in the presence of steep gradients of K + or Na'. Constructed pH value gradients across the vesicle membranes did not give rise to glutamate uptake. Ferrocyanide alone did not support glutamate uptake but, together with ascorbate, it was able to function as an electron donor to the electron-transport chain. Ascorbate was shown to reduce b- type cytochromes in the electron- transport chain. Adenosine triphosphate does not seem to be involved in glutamate uptake. The presence of ATP within or outside the vesicles did not give rise to any glutamate transport. Convincing evidence that phosphorylation reactions were not involved was obtained when it was shown that arsenate did not influence uptake, even if incorporated in the vesicles. Halobacterium vesicles were also shown to be capable of accumulating several other amino acids simultaneously with glutamate. The glutamate-uptake mechanism may be specific in that glutamate uptake was unaffected by the presence of other amino acids. Whole cells of H . salinarium were able to accumulate glutamate after starvation for eight hours, even in the absence of added respiratory electron donors. Very recently, MacDonald and Lanyi ( 1975) reported that cell-envelope preparations from H. halobium, which contains bacteriorhodopsin, were able on illumination to take up leucine against a 1000-fold gradient. In contrast to the impermeability of H. salinarium envelopes to glutamate diffusion, H. cutirubrkm envelopes seem to allow rapid loss of accumulated leucine. The leucine-uptake system in H . cutirubrum was also unaffected by arsenate, and required Na+ in the external medium. The work by Andersen (1975) and
PHYSlO LOGY OF HALOBACTER IACEAE
109
MacDonald and Lanyi (19 75) re-emphasizes the possibilities offered by extreme halophiles for studying fundamental biophysical phenomena. IX. Effects of Light
Natural aquatic milieux with very high concentrations of salt are also as a rule subjected to intense solar irradiation. It was natural to suppose that organisms able to benefit from this irradiation, or able to protect themselves against eventual deleterious effects of too intense light, would have some ecological advantage. Moore and McCarthy ( 1969b) suggested that halobacteria might have evolved from phototrophic bacteria. Photosynthesis, photophosphorylation, photooxidation of vital molecules and light re-activation after lethal ultraviolet irradiation have been demonstrated for members of the natural bacterial flora in’ salterns. Normal chlorophyll-mediated photosynthesis, however, has not been found in any organism which otherwise would qualify for inclusion in the family Halobacteriaceae. A . P H O T O P H O S P H O R Y LATI O N
An extremely exciting development occurred when Oesterhelt and Stoeckenius (1971) reported that the previously isolated “purple membrane” from H . halobium (Stoeckeniusand Kunau, 1968)contained bacteriorhodopsin as the single protein component. Photo-exitation of the “purple membrane” resulted in a net translocation of protons from the bacterial cells (Oesterhelt and Stoeckenius, 1973) and it was argued that the resultant electrochemical gradient might be used by the cell to satisfy, some aspects of its energy requirements. As was subsequently shown by Danon and Stoeckenius (19741, “purple membrane” is implicated in photophosphorylation in Halobacterium halobium. Under anaerobic conditions, the ATP level in H . halobium drops rapidly to a low level. Aeration or illumination will restore the level of ATP to its normal value. The fact that specific inhibitors of photosystem I1 in normal photosynthesis were ineffective against photophosphorylation in H . halobium was taken to indicate that the bacteriorhodopsin-mediated phosphorylation is different from normal non-cyclic chlorophyll-mediated photophosphorylation. Specific inhibitors of the ATP-synthesizing enzyme of nonhalophilic bacteria inhibited both oxygen- and light-mediated phosphorylation in H . halobium, indicating that one enzyme might be
110
I. E. D. DUNDAS
responsible for ADP phosphorylation in this organism. Uncouplers functioning as proton translocators also inhibited phosphorylation, implying that a proton gradient indeed might be active in the phosphorylation (Danon and Stoeckenius, 1974). The fact that supplying oxygen to the anaerobic cells caused the ATP levels to rise even in the absence of exogenous substrate indicates an endogenous electron donor as a n energy source. A possible, if unlikely, explanation for the light-mediated anaerobic phosphorylation might then be that illumination induced utilization of some endogenous anaerobic energy substrate. That such an explanation is fallacious is clearly shown by Racker and Stoeckenius ( 1974). Reconstituted phospholipid vesicles containing the purple-membrane fraction from H . halobium and mitochondria1 oligoniycin-sensitive ATPase were able to carry out light-dependent phosphorylation. Spin-label studies of the purple membranes from H . halobium indicate that they are extremely rigid structures and that their proton translocation occurs by some pore mechanism rather than being dependent on the mobility of the protein in the membranes (Chignell and Chignell, 1975). Oesterhelt et al. (1974) reported that the chromophore in bacteriorhodopsin, on illumination in the presence of hydroxylamine, yielded retinaloxime. The purple membrane became white due to loss of retinal after the treatment but could be reconstituted simply by adding retinal (Oesterhelt and Schuhmann, 1974). The reconstituted membrane functioned normally. The chromophore in the purple membrane seems to consist of a charge-transfer complex between retinyllysine and an appropriate side chain of the membrane protein. The ease in isolating the purple membrane, the possibility of incorporating it in model lipid membranes for studying basic aspects of proton translocation, light-mediated energy convertions and similar fundamental mechanisms, make its discovery one of the most exciting recent developments in biophysics. The intense interest in the field is evident from the not less than seven reports on research on bacterial rhodopsin published in the February 1975 issue of the Biophysical Journal. B . EFFECTS O N G R O W T H A N D VIABILITY
There seems to be no doubt that the carotenoid pigments of'Halobacterium spp. exert some protective effect against the deleterious effects
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
111
of intense visible light (Larsen, 1967).While Dundas and Larsen (1962) measured the deleterious effect of visible light by the decrease in growth rate, Clausen (19721, using more intense light, was able to demonstrate a direct lethal effect on a colourless mutant of H . salinarium. Several potentially light-sensitive compounds are present in the cells. Catalase is rapidly destroyed by photo-oxidation in the colourless mutant but not in its pigmented progenitor. Flavins are also possible targets for photo-oxidative destruction. Menaquinon-8, a compound involved in the NADH, oxidative pathway in halophiles, is also quite sensitive to light derangement (Marque2 and Brodie, 1970). E. Clausen (unpublished observations) argues that the carotenoids of Halobacterium spp. may have a two-fold protective effect, viz. a direct shielding in the 380nm and 440-530nm range and as an indirect excitation energy scavenger” for illumination in the 400-430 nm range. These conclusions are based on the action spectrum for the carotenoid-protective effect and on measured inactivation rates for catalase activity. Flavins seem to be implicated as endogenous photosensitizers The cartotenoid pigmentation of extreme halophiles has also been assumed to be implicated in photoreactivation of ultraviolet-killed cells. Hescox and Carlberg ( 1972)reported that ultraviolet-treated populations of H . cutirubrum, with only 1% survivors, were nearly completely re-activated after 45-60 minutes illumination in the 300-400 nm range. The use of diphenylamine-treated cells is not ideal for studying the role of carotenoids in the photoreactivation mechanism, even if growth is reported not to be affected. The use of suitable nonpigmented mutants would obviate any undetected effects of diphenylamine. Hescox and Carlberg (1972) indicate that the high guanine + cytosine (G + C) content of halobacterial DNA may render it less susceptible to damage by thymine dimerization during ultraviolet irradiation. L6
X. Nudeic Acids and Their Enzymology
Moore and McCarthy ( 1969a)extended earlier work on nucleic acids from extreme halophiles to show that DNA satellite bands occurred in all species tested in the genera Halobacterium and Halococcus. They concluded that the satellite probably was not attributable to intracellular parasites or viruses, and that it could not be due to cultural contamination. The percentage of G + C in the main DNA component
112
I. E.
D. DUNDAS
from five strains of Halobacterium and one of Halococcus varied from 66 to 69% while the corresponding satellite DNA varied from 57 to 60%. The amount of satellite DNA per cell was estimated to be about equal to 15 copies of a normal-bacteriophage genome. Renaturation studies wiih DNA indicated that the satellite probably does not represent multiple copies of an episomal fragment (Moore and McCarthy, 1969b). Base-sequence homology studies indicated a considerable degree of relatedness among Halobacterium strains. Both DNA from the satellite and the main component of a Halobacterium strain were equally able to form hybrid DNA duplexes with total DNA from other Halobacterium strains. The degree of homology between satellite and main component DNA, however, was not assessed. It would have been interesting to know the degree of homology between purified satellite DNA from different Halobacterium strains in view of speculations as to the possibility of satellite DNA representing specifically halophilic genetic information. Fitt and his coworkers have worked extensively on the nucleic-acid enzymology of H . cutirubrum. Peterkin and Fitt ( 197 1) purified polynucleotide phosphorylase 2 17 -fold and described it as a normal halophilic enzyme dependent on high concentrations of salt for activity and stability. As the enzyme could not be re-activated from the salt-free state, purification was carried out in the presence of salt. Deoxyribonucleic acid-dependent RNA polymerase, purified 150-fold from H. cutirubrum, seems to be a normal enzyme insomuch as it showed a specific requirement for native DNA as template (Louis and Fitt, 197 la) and also required the presence of all four trinucleotides for optimal activity. I t had an absolute requirement of Mg2+and Mn2+ for activity. Most striking was the fact that the enzyme, with calf thymus DNA as a template, behaved as a non-halophilic enzyme. The presence of 0.5-M NaCl or KCl in the assay medium resulted in a 94% decrease in enzyme activity compared with activity in the absence of K+and Na+. This salt inhibition, however, does not occur when native H . cutirubrum DNA is used as a template (Louis and Fitt, 197 lc). Under these conditions, optimum polymerase activity was observed in the presence of 2.5-M or higher concentrations of salts. Stability of the enzyme, as regards activity with both template types, required salt concentrations about 2-M, as is normal for many halophilic enzymes. The implications of an enzyme able to function normally with a “nonhalophilic” substrate and behaving as a typically halophilic enzyme with its normal substrate are quite interesting.
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
113
Louis and Fitt (1971b) have also purified a RNA-dependent RNA polymerase from H . cutirubrum 2800-fold. This enzyme is relatively insensitive to changes in NaCl or KC1 concentrations both as regards activity and stability. They argue that the possibility of this enzyme being virus-induced is remote, as the H. cutirubrum strain used does not develop plaques on agar or grow more slowly than other strains of H . cutirubrum. In this connection, one is reminded of the fact that H . salinarium strain 1 was carried as a pure culture in several laboratories for about 20 years before it was shown that it harbours a phage (Torsvik and Dundas, 1974).Griffiths (1970a)has shown that at least two isoaccepting types of phenylalanyl-tRNA can be found in H . cutirubrum. Nucleic acids, their enzymology and their function in protein synthesis, representing fundamental functions common to all organisms, seem to be areas offering fruitful possibilities for comparative work on halophiles and non-halophiles. XI. Phage-Host Relationships
Until recently, halobacteria were among those few bacterial groups for which bacteriophages had not been found. During work on isolation of flagella from H . salinarium, phage particles were observed in the electron-microscope preparations (Torsvik and Dundas, 1974). Repeated subculturing of H . salinarium from late log-phase batch cultures led to eventual lysis of the cultures. Phages could be isolated from these lysates by isopycnic caesium chloride centrifugation (Torsvik, 1976).The phage particles contain double-stranded DNA in polyhedral heads and possess contractile tails. Lysis also occurs when H . salinarium is cultivated in a chemostat for prolonged periods of time. Aliquots of an inoculum, which gave rise to a lysing phage-producing culture, could be stored for several days at 4OC. O n transferring to fresh medium, these inocula invariably gave rise to lysing phageproducing cultures. Phage, purified by caesium chloride centrifugation, causes lysis when introduced into cultures at high levels of infection. I t has not been possible to induce phage-producing lysis by ultraviolet irradiation or by any other means. Repeated single-cell isolations gave clones which still produced phages. Colonies of H . salinarium on agar will, after several weeks growth, show central zones of lysis. Phages can be isolated from such colonies, and have been isolated from three different strains of halobacteria. No sensitive host has been found yet, and single phage particles do not form plaques.
114
I. E. D. DUNDAS
I t is suggested (Torsvik, 1976) that the phage is a temperate one that rarely mutates to virulence. The phage shows some halophilic qualities, and it is morphologically stable in 6%NaCl but begins to disintegrate on exposure t7, 4% NaC1. Using analytical centrifugation, it was shown that phage DNA is not identical with either the main component or the satellite of the host bacterium. The described bacteriophage for H. salinarium offers limited possibilities for studies on the phage-host genetic system in halobacteria. Among other factors, the absence of a sensitive host able to allow plaque formation renders experimentation dependent on the electron microscope for demonstration and enumeration of phage particles. Wais et al. ( 19751, on the other hand, report isolation of a phage able to infect H. cutirubrum with a plating efficiency of 1.0. This phage is dependent on rather high concentrations of salt in the suspending medium for survival, and is also morphologically quite similar to the phage for H. salinarium. The existence of bacteriophages for halobacteria opens up the exciting possibility of applying phage-host genetics to the problem of extreme halophilism. Also, phage-protein components offer a new array of halophile proteins for further comparative studies.
XII. Ecological Considerations on Existence of Obligate Extreme Halophilism I t is a common and understandable view point that concentrated brines represent an extreme environment. From the view point of obligate and extremely halophilic organisms, however, a low-ionic environment is an extremely lethal one and saturated brines the least stressfull environment possible. Some saline environments, like the Dead Sea, the Great Salt Lake in U.S.A. and similar bodies of water, may be large enough to maintain such high salinities at all times so that obligately extreme halophiles always have some region in the habitat where they may survive. Smaller bodies of water, pools and flats along. the seashore, where seawater has been concentrated by evaporation, are much more transiently highly saline environments. Nevertheless it has been reported that extremely halophilic bacteria can be isolated directly or by enrichment from such sources. Their existence in these environments seems to be generally assumed (Kushner, 1968). Reports have even been published on the isolation of extreme
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
115
halophiles from enrichment cultures using inocula from salt-free or marine sources (Larsen, 1962, 1967). Work on adapting extreme halophiles to growth in the presence of low concentrations of salt, or marine bacteria to growth in media containing high concentrations of salt, have not given convincing results. I t is nevertheless too facile to assume that all reports on the isolation of extreme halophiles from sources which temporarily have low salt concentrations are the result of faulty sterile techniques. Salterns in temperate climates are inoperative in the winter months and become covered with a blanket of fresh water. Salt from these salterns contains a normal flora of halophilic organisms, and it is possible that some part of the saltern stored salt nearby, or implements used in the working of the saltern, carry over enough bacteria for re-inoculation of the brines when they again reach the necessary concentration. The same possibilities do not seem to exist for small flats and pools along the seashore which only contain concentrated brines in the summer months. Larsen ( 1967) argues convincingly that the number of mutations necessary for converting a marine bacterium into an extremely halophilic one is probably much too high for such a transformation to be successful in the laboratory, even assuming that the substitution of acidic for non-acidic amino-acid residues in the proteins is the only change necessary for obtaining halophilic character. It seems reasonable to assume that the amount of new genetic information necessary for changing a non-halophile into an extreme halophile is so great that it only can be obtained by normal evolution mechanisms in Nature or, possibly, by the acquisition by a non-halophile of a rather large amount of halophilic information by some sort of gene-transfer mechanism. The existence of extreme halophiles in transiently extremely saline bodies of water tempts one to speculate about these possibilities, and about possible roles for satellite DNA or for extremely halophilic phages in this connection. The collection of extremely halophilic bacteria as described in “Bergey’s Manual” ( 1974) represent a strikingly homogeneous group, and it is tempting to correlate the characteristics common to the group with their extremely halophilic character. Insomuch as this group may represent an artificially selected subgroup of extremely halophilic bacteria isolated from much the same sources and by very similar enrichment and isolation techniques, such correlations may be mis-
116
I. E. D. DUNDAS
leading. Gibbons ( 1960) and Weber ( 1949) report isolating colourless halophilic bacteria from saline lakes. I found that the majority of organisms of the bacterial population, even in red brines of a saltern, may be colourless or white. Efforts should be made to broaden our concepts of how to isolate extremely halophilic bacteria with regard to enrichment techniques. The view that marine and freshwater environments are “normal” and brines abnormal leads to the assumption that the halophilic way of life has evolved from life forms in normal environments. Assuming that the current concept of prebiological evolution and the origin of life is plausible, then concentration of preformed prebiological organic molecules to a level where generation of “organisms” could occur would cause a concomitant increase in the concentration of any salts present in the “primordial soup”. An anaerobic extreme halophile might thus represent a rather primitive life form. The fact that some extreme halophiles are able to carry out anaerobic photophosphorylation (Danon and Stoeckenius, 19741, by a seemingly more primitive mechanism than normal photosynthesis, might be relevant in this connection. With the current and increasing interest in halophilism and extremely halophilic bacteria, it is important that we do not become hampered by unnecessarily narrow preconceptions of the possible range within extremely halophilic bacteria. To the extent that this article has broadened the view in this respect, my goal has been achieved. XIII. Acknowledgements I wish to thank the Gulbenkian Institute of Science and the staff at
the Laboratory of Microbiology at Oeiras, Portugal, for making possible a one-month visit to study the halophilic bacterial flora of Portuguese salterns. REFERENCES
Aitken, D. M. and Brown, A. D. (1969). Biochimica et Biophysics Acta 177, 351. Aitken, D. M. and Brown, A. D. (1972). Biochemical Journal 150, 645. Andersen, K. (1975). Doktor Ingenisr. Thesis: The Technical University of Norway, Trondheim. Bayley, S. T. (1966).Journal of Molecular Biology 15, 420. Bayley, S. T. and Grifiths, E. (1968a). Biochemistry, New Y o d 7, 2249. Bayley, S. T. arfd Griffiths, E. (1968b). Canadian Journal ofBiochemistry 46, 937.
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
117
Bayley, S. T. and Kushner, D. J. (1964).Journal of Moletular Biology 9,654. “Bergey’s Manual of Determinative Bacteriology” (1957).(R. S. Breed, E. G. D. Murray and N. R. Smith, eds.), 7th edition. William and Wilkins Co., Baltimore. “Bergey’s Manual of Determinative Bacteriology” (1974).(R. E. Buchanan and N. E. Gibbons, eds.), 8th edition, William and Wilkins Co., Baltimore. Blenden, D. C., and Goldberg, H. S. (1965).Journal ofBacteriology 89, 899. Borowitzka, L. J. and Brown, A. D. (1974).Archives of Microbiology 96, 37. Brown, A. D. and Cho, K. Y. (1970).Journal of General Microbiology 62, 267. Brown, A. D. and Pearce, R. F. (1969).Canadian Journal ofBiochemistry 47, 833. Brown, R. H. and Stevenson, J. (1971).Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 37, 89. Cazzulo, J. J. (1973).Federation o f European Biochemical Societies Letters 30, 339. Cheah, K. S. (1969).Eiochimica et Eiophysica Acta 180, 320. Cheah, K. S . (1970a).Eiochimica et Eiophysica Acta 205. 148. Cheah, K. S. (1970b).Federation o f European Biochemical Societies Letters 7, 301. Chignell, C. F. and Chignell, D. A. (1975).Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 62, 136. Christian, J . H. B. and Waltho, J. A. (1962).Eiochimica et Biophysica Acta 65, 506. Clausen, E. (1972).Cand. real. Thesis: University of Bergen, Bergen. Cohen-Bazire, G., Kunisawa, R. and Pfennig, N. (1969).Journal ofBactenology 100, 1049. Danon, A. and Stoeckenius, W. (1974).Proceedings of the National Academy ofsciences ofthe United States o f America 7114). 1234. D’Aoust, J. and Kushner, D. J. (1972).Canadian Journal of Microbiology 18, 1767. Dayhoff, R. E., Hunt, L. T. and Dayhoff, M. 0. (1975).EiophysicalJoumal 15, 294a. Ducharme, L., Matheson, A. T., Yaguchi, M. and Visentin, L. P. (1972).CanadianJournal of Microbiology 18, 1349. Dundas, I . E. D. (1970).European Journal ofEiochemistry 16, 393. Dundas, I. E. D. (1972).European Journal of Biochemistry 27, 376. Dundas, I. E. D. and Larsen, H. (1962).Archiv f u r Mikrobiologie 44, 233. Eidsl, G. (1972).Cand. real. Thesis: University of Bergen, Bergen. Eimhjellen, K. ( 1965). Zentralblatt f u r Eahteriologie, Parasitenhunde, Infektionskranhheiten und Hygiene, Abt. I , Suppl. 1 126. Falkenberg, P. (1974).Doktor Ingenisr. Thesis: The Technical University of Noway, Trondheim. Falkenberg, P., Buckland, B. and Walsby, A. E. (1972).Archiv f i r Mihrobiologie 85,304. Frank, M. E. and Hoffman, H. (1968).Canadian Journal ofMicrobiology 14, 941. Gibbons, N. E. (1969).I n “Methods in Microbiology”, (J. R. Norris and D. W. Ribbons, eds.), vol. 3B, pp. 169-183. Academic Press, New York. Gochnauer, M. B. and Kushner, D. J. (1969).CanadianJournalofMicrobiology 15, 1157. Gochnauer, M. B. and Kushner, D. J. (1971).Canadian Journal ofMicrobiology 17, 17. Griffiths, E. (1970a).Federation of European Biochemical Societies Letters 10,225. Griffiths, E. (1970b).Canadian Journal of Biochemistry 48, 944. Griffiths, E. and Bayley, S. T. (1969).Biochemistry, New Yorh 8, 541. Hescox, M. A. and Carlberg, D. M. (1972).Canadian Journalof Microbiology 18, 981. Hochstein, L. I. and Dalton, B. P. (1968).Eiochimica et Biophysica Acta 167, 638. Hochstein, L. I. and Dalton, B. P. (1973).Eiochim’ca et Eiophysica Acta SO?, 216. Hsia, J. C., Wong, P. T. S. and MacLennan, D. H. (1971).Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 43, 88. Hubbard, J. S. and Miller, A. B. (1970).Journal ofBacteriology 102, 677. Ingram, M. (1947).Proceedings ofthe Royal Society ofLondon Seties E 134, 181.
118
I. E. D. DUNDAS
C. N. and Kates, M. (1968).Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 152,800. Kanner, B. I. and Racker, E. (1975).Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 64. 1054. Kates, M., Yengoyan, L. S. and Sastry, P. S. (1965).Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 94,252. Kates, M., Palameta, B., Joo, C. N., Kushner, D. J. and Gibbons, N. E. (1966). Biochemistry, New York 5, 4092. Kates, M., Wassef, M. K. and Kushner, D. J. (1968).CanadianJournal ofBiochem’stry 46, 971. Kates, M. (1972).In “Ether Lipids, Chemistry and Biology”, (F. Snyder, ed.), pp. 351-398. Academic Press, New York. Keradjopoulos, D. and Wulff, K. (1974).Canadian Journal ofBiochistry 52, 1033. Kocur, M. and Bohicek, J. (1972).Archiv fiir Mikrobiologie 82, 280. Koncewicz, M. (1972).Biochemical Journal 130, 40. Krantz, M. J. and Ballou, C. E. (1973).Journal ofBacteriology 114, 1058. Kushner, D. J. (1968).Advances in Applied Microbiology 10, 73. Kushwaha, S. C., Gochnauer, M. B., Kushner, D. J. and Kates, M. (1973).Canadian Journal of Microbiology 20, 241. Lanyi, J . K. (1968).Archives ofBiochemistry and Biophysics 128, 716. Lanyi, J. K. (1969a).Journal of Biological Chemistry 244, 2864. Lanyi, J. K. (1969b).Journal of Biological Chemistry 244, 4168. Lanyi, J. K. (1971). Journal of Biological Chemistry 246, 4552. Lanyi, J. K. (1972a).Journal of Biological Chemistry 247, 3001. Lanyi, J. K. (1972b).Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 282,439. Lanyi, J . K. (1973).Biochemistry, New York 12, 1433. Lanyi, J. K. (1974).BacteriologicalReviews38,272. Lanyi, J. K. and Silverman, M. P. (1972).CanadianJournal ofhficrobiology 18, 993. Lanyi, J. K. and Stevenson, J. (1969).Jourrnal of Bacterioloa 98, 61 1. Lanyi, J. K. and Stevenson, J. (1970).Journal ofBiological Chemistry 245, 4074. Larsen, H.( 1962).In “The Bacteria”, ( I . C. Gunsalus and R. Y. Stanier, eds.), vol. IV, pp. 297-342, Academic Press, New York. Larsen, H. (1967).Advances in Microbial Physiology 1, 97. Larsen, H.(1971).In “Encyclopedia of Science and Technology”, 3rd edition, pp. 374-376. McGraw-Hill Book Company Inc., New York. Larsen, H. (1973).Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 39, 383. Larsen, H.,Omang, S. and Steensland, H. (1967).Archiv fiir Mikrobiologie 59, 197. Lepierre, C. (1936).“A Industria d o sal em Portugal”. Instituto Superior de Ciencias Economicas e Financeiras, Oficinas Grificas Lisboa, Portugal. Liebermann, M. M. and Lanyi, 1. K. (1972).Biochemistry, New York 11, 211. Liebl, V., Kaplan, J. G. and Kuskner, D. J. (1969).CanddianJournal ofBiochemistry 47, 1095. Liebl, V., Kushner, D. J. and Kaplan, J. G. (1970).Folia Microbiologica 15, 202. Louis, B. G. and Fitt, P. S. (197la). Federation of European Biochemical Societies Letters 14, 143. Louis, B. G. and Fitt, P. S. (1971b).Biochemical Journal 121, 621. Louis, B. G. and Fitt, P. S. (1971~). Biochemical Journal 121, 629. Louis, B. G., Peterkin, P. I. and Fitt, P. S. (1971).BiochemicdJournal 121. 635. MacDonald, R. E. and Lanyi, J. K. (1975).Biophysical Journal 15, 65a. Marquez, E. D. and Brodie, A. F. (1970).Journal ofBacteriology 103, 260. Marshall, C. L. and Brown, A. D. (1968).Biochemical Journal 110,441. JOO,
PHYSIOLOGY OF HALOBACTERIACEAE
119
Mjelde, A. (197 1). Doktor Ingenisr. Thesis: Technical University of Norway, Trondheim. Moore, R. L. and McCarthy, B. J. (1969a). J o u m l of Bacteriology 99, 248. Moore, R. L. and McCarthy, B. J. (1969b). J o u m l ofBacteriology 99, 255. Mullakhanbhai, M. F. and Francis, G . W. (1972). Acta Chem’ca Scandinauica 26, 1399. Mullakhanbhai, M. F. and Larsen, H. (1975). Archives f o r Mimobiology 104, 207. Norberg, P. and v. Hofsten, B. (1970). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 220, 132. Norberg, P., Kaplan, J. G. and Kushner, D. J. (1973).J o u d ofBacteriology 115, 680. Oda, G., Strsm, A. R., Visentin, L. P. and Yaguchi, M. (1974). Federation ofEuropean Biochemical Societies Letters 43, 127. Oesterhelt, D. and Schuhmann, L. (1974). Federation of European Biochemical Societies Letters 44, 262. Oesterhelt, D., Schuhmann, L. and Gruber, H. (1974). Federation of European Biochemical Societies Letters 44, 257. Oesterhelt, D. and Stoeckenius, W. (1971). Nature New Biology 233, 149. Oesterhelt, D. and Stoeckenius, W. (1973). Proceedings ofthe National Academy ofSciemes ofthe United States of America 70, 2853. Peterkin, P. I. and Fitt, P . S. (1971). Biochemical J o u m l 121, 613. Pugh, E. L., Wassef, M. K. and Kates, M. (197 1). Canadian J o u m l ofBiochemistry 49,953. Racker, E. and Stoeckenius, W. (1974).J o u m l ofBiologica1 Chemistry 249, 662. Rauser, W. E. and Bayley, S . T. (1968). J o u m l ofBacteriology 96, 1304. Raymond, J. C. and Sistrom, W. R. (1967). Archiu f i r Mikrobiologie 59, 225. Raymond, J. C. and Sistrom, W. R. (1969). Archiufiir Mikrobiologie 69, 121. Reistad, R. (1970). Archiu f u r Mikrobiologie 71, 353. Reistad, R. (1975). Archives of Mimobiology 102, 7 1. Spahr, P . F. (1962). Journal of Molecular Biology 4, 395. Steensland, H. and Larsen, H. (1969). J o u m l of General Microbiology 55, 325. Steensland, H. and Larsen, H. (1971). Det Kongelige Norske Videnskapers Selskab, Skrifter No. 8-197 1, Universitetsforlaget, Trondheim. Sehgal, S. N., Kates, M. and Gibbons, N. E. (1962). Canadian Journal ofBiochemistry and Physiology 40, 69. Stoeckenius, W. and Kunau, W. H. (1968). J o u m l of Cell Biology 38, 337. Stoeckenius, W. and Rowen, R. (1967).Journal of Cell Biology 58, 365. Strsm, A. R., Hasnain, S., Smith, N., Matheson, A. T. and Visentin, L. P. (1975). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 383, 325. Strsm, A. R. and Visentin, L. P. (1973). Federation ofEuropean Biochemical Societies Letters 37, 274. Tomlinson, G . A. and Hochstein, L. I. (1972a). CanadianJournal ofMicrobiology 18,698. Tomlinson, G. A. and Hochstein, L. I. (1972b). Canadian J o u m l ofMimobiology 18, 1973.
Tomlinson, G . A., Koch, T. K. and Hochstein, L. I. (1974). Canadian J o u m l of Microbiology 20, 1085. Tornabene, T. G . , Kates, M., Gelpi, E. and Oro, J. (1969).J o u m l of Lipid Research 10, 294.
Torsvik, T. (1976). Cand. real. Thesis: University of Bergen, Bergen. Torsvik, T. and Dundas, I. E. D. (1974). Nature, London 248, 680. Van Uden, N. (1968). Archiu f u r Mikrobiologie 62, 34. Visentin, L. P., Chow, C., Matheson, A. T., Yaguchi, M. and Rollin, F. (1972). Biochemical Journal 130, 103. Wais, A. C., Kon, M. and MacDonald, R. E. (1975). Nature, London 256, 314.
120
I. E. D. DUNDAS
Walsby, A. E. (1971). Proceedings o f t h e Royal Society ofLondon, Series B 178, 301. Watson, T. G. (1970). Journal $General Microbiology 64, 91. Weber, M . M. (1949). Biological Review of City College of New York 11, 9. Wilson, W. T. and Combs, L. E. (1970). Canadian Journal ofMicrobiology 16, 521. Zwilling, B. S., Rowen, R. and Stotzky, G. (1969). Journal ofBacteriology 98, 384.
Sterols in Fungi: Their Functions in Growth and Reproduction CHARLES G. E L L I O T Botany Department, University of Glasgow, Scotland. I. Introduction
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
11. Functions of Sterols: Possible Approaches to the Problems . . . . . . . 111. Sterols in Model Systems
.
.
.
.
.I21
.
. 130 . 135 . 14 I
.
IV. Subcellular Distribution of Sterols in Fungi, and States of Binding . . V. Effects of Sterols on Metabolism and Vegetative Growth A. Pythium and Phytophthora . . . . . . . .
VI. VII. VIII. IX. X. XI. XII.
. 125
.I41
B. Saccharomyces and Other Fungi . . . . . . . . 144 . . . . . . 148 Effects of Sterols on Asexual Reproduction . . . . . . . . .I49 Sexual Hormones ofkhlya Effects of Sterols on Sexual Reproduction in Homothallic SpeciesofPythium and Phytophthora . . . . . . . . . . . .I52 Reproduction in Heterothallic Species of Pythium and Phytophthora . 156 162 Sterols and Sexual Reproduction in Ascomycetes and Basidiomycetes Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . 165 . . . . . . . . . . .lG6 Acknowledgements References . . . . . . . . . . . . . 166
I. Introduction
My interest in the subject of this review began with the observation that Phytophthoru cuctorum would grow on a simple medium containing sucrose, asparagine, mineral salts and thiamin, but that on this medium it remained purely vegetative. On the other hand, when grown on oatmeal agar, oospores were produced in abundance. The factors in oats responsible for the difference were found to be sterols (Elliott et ul., 1964). Addition of sterols to the simple basal medium changed the mode of growth from vegetative to reproductive. Similar findings were reported about the same time for various species of Phytophthoru and Pythium (Hendrix, 1964, 1965; Haskins et al., 1964; Harnish et ul., 1964; Leal et ul., 1964). It is worth noting that, in 121
122
CHARLES G. ELLIOTT
1937, Leonian and Lilly had found that some substance extracted by alcohol from peas was required for reproduction of Phytophthoru. However they considered the active compound in the extract not to be a sterol but some unknown compound which they could not separate from sterols. Since that time, advances in our knowledge of the chemistry and biosynthesis of sterols in other organisms, the development of analytical techniques (particularly gas-liquid chromatography), and the availability of a wide range of pure sterols, have clarified the problem, and it is now clear that it is indeed the sterols which are the required growth factor in Phytophthoru spp. Species of Pythium and Phytophthoru are unable to synthesize sterols. Thus sterols are not detectable in mycelium grown in the absence of sterols (Elliott et ul., 1964; Schlosser and Gottlieb, 1966; McCorkindale et ul., 1969) and incorporation of labelled sterol precursors (acetate and mevalonate) into sterol-like material does not occur (Hendrix, 1966, 1975b; Schlosser et ul., 1969). Richards and Hemming (1972) reported that mevalonate was incorporated into farnesol, geranylgeraniol, dolichols and ubiquinones in Phytophthoru cuctorum. Squalene was not labelled; but D. Gottlieb (personal communication) finds that squalene is synthesized, but is not cyclized to sterol. Langcake (1975) reports that Phytophthoru infeestuns can convert lanosterol to a compound which he thought was possibly cholesterol, but cholesterol, cholestanol, sitosterol and stigmasterol are not converted to other sterols. Knights and Elliott ( 1976) find that A7 and A5*’-sterolsare converted to the corresponding A5-sterolsby Phytophthoru cuctorum. Species of Pythium and Phytophthoru are all plant pathogens, and it is evident that they obtain the sterols necessary for their reproduction from their hosts. It is perhaps surprising that more fungi cannot synthesize sterols, as they mostly inhabit environments where sterols would be expected to occur. The sterol content of spores of Plusmodiophoru brassicue varies significantly according to the sterol composition of the host, suggesting at least partial heterotrophy (Knights, 1970). The rusts however synthesize sterols. The predominant sterols in their uredospores are A’-stigmastenol, A7*24(28’-stigmastadienol and A’-ergostenol (Jackson and Frear, 1968; Nowak et ul., 1972). A7-Sterolswere found in rust-infected leaves and not (or only exceptionally) in healthy leaves (Nowak et al., 1972; Lin and Knoche, 1974). This indication that the fungus synthesizes sterols was confirmed by the finding that these par-
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
123
ticular sterols became labelled when germinating uredospores were supplied with [14Cl-mevalonateor acetate (Lin et al., 1972). I t is notable that, unlike other basidiomycetes, the rusts do not contain ergosterol. Those oomycetes which synthesize sterols (e.g. species of Achlya, Saprolegnia) also do not contain ergosterol, but rather fucosterol and its relatives (McCorkindale et al., 1969). Ergosterol was not detected either in two chytridiomycetes and two hypochytridiomycetes (Bean et al., 1972). The occurrence and biosynthesis of sterols in fungi have been reviewed by Weete (1973, 1974) and also by Goodwin (1973). A list of fungi and the sterols found in them is given by Bean (1973). The lipids of yeast were reviewed by Rattray et al. (1975). Biological aspects of sterols in fungi were reviewed by Hendrix ( 1970). 11. Functions of Sterols: Possible Approaches to the Problems
The object of this review is to discuss the function of sterols in fungi, with special reference to sexual reproduction ; the effect on sexual reproduction is the most striking aspect of the sterol requirement in Phytophthora. A general approach to this problem in fungi might be to consider what happens when sterol synthesis is inhibited. This inhibition might be the result of gene mutation, so that some step or steps in the biosynthesis of sterol cannot be carried out. As already indicated it appears that pythiaceous fungi cannot convert squalene to sterols. Species of Pythium and Phytophthora are very favourable organisms for studying the function of sterols. One can simply compare the mycelium grown with and without sterol. Evidently, in these fungi, sterols are not essential for vegetative growth. If sterols are essential for
FIG. 1. Structure of stigmastane, indicating the numbering of carbon atoms in sterols.
124
CHARLES G. E L L I O l l
I
IV
&
H b:H
11
111
V
VI
HO@H,C kH,
&OH VIII
VI I
IX
FIG. 2. Ring systems of sterols. See Table 1 for sterols in which these occur. TABLE 1. List of principal sterols mentioned in the text, with systematic names and index to their structures shown in Figs. 2 and 3. Common name
Systematic name C,
B-nor-5-cholesten-3~-ol
Coprostanol Cholestanol Cho lest ero I A’-Cholestenol 7 - Dehvdrocholesterol Epicholcsterol Zymosterol
5/hholestan-S/J-ol 5a-cholestan-3/?-ol 5-cholesten-3~-ol 5a-cholest- 7-en-3p-01 5,7-cholestadien-3~-ol 5-cholesten-3a-ol 5a-cholesta-8,24-dien-3/3-ol
Campesterol A5-Ergostenol A7-Ergostenol
(24R)-24-methyl-5-cholesten-3~-ol (24S)-24-methyl-5-cholesten-3/3-ol (24S)-24-methyl-5a-cholest-7-en-3g-ol
C,
Side chain
sterol
B- Norcholesterol
C,
Ring system I
A
I1 I11 IV
A A A
V VI VI I VIII
A A B
sterols
A
Jterols
IV
C
IV V
D D
125
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
+A+* A
C
G
B
D
E
F
H J FIG. 3. Side chains of sterols.
K
TABLE 1 . 4 co n t i n u ed) Common name
Systematic name
Ring system
(24R)-24-methyl-5,2ZE-cholestadien- IV Ergosterol Episterol Ergostadienol AS.l.24 (28)-
3/3-01 (24R)- 24- methyl-5,7,22E-cholestatrien3/3-01 24-methylene-5a-cholest-7-en-3P-01
VI V
Side chain
E E F
(24R)-24-inethyl-5a-cholesta-8(9),22E-VIII
E
dien-3/3-ol. 24-inethylene-5,7-cholestadien-3/3-ol
VI
F
C,, sterols IV (24R)-24-ethyl-5-cholesten-3/3-ol V (24R)-24-ethyl-5a-cholest7-en-3/3-01 (24R)-24-ethyl-5,7-cholestadien-3~-olVI IV (24S)-24-ethyl-5,22E-cholestadien-
G G G H
Ergostatrieiiol
3/3-01
(24S)-24-ethyl-5,7,22E-cholestatrien8/3-01 24E-ethylidene-5-rholesten-3/3-ol
(24R)-24-ethyl-5,22E-cholestadien-
VI
H
IV IV
J
IX
B
K
3/3-01 Lanosicrol
C,, sterol 4a,4/3, 14a-trimethyl-5a-cholesta-8,24: dirn-3~-ol
126
CHARLES G . ELLIOlT
vegetative growth in other organisms, then pythiums and phytophthoras must make some substance which can do the same job. But it is apparent that this hypothetical substance cannot fulfil the role in reproduction which sterols have. In species of Saccharomyces, mutants in which the later stages of ergosterol synthesis are blocked, are known. These mutations were selected as conferring resistance to polyene antibiotics (see p. 145). Other ways in which sterol synthesis can be inhibited are to subject the organism to anaerobic conditions (see p. 1461, or to use drugs which inhibit particular steps in biosynthesis (pp. 147 and 162). An alternative and complementary approach is to consider the effect of molecular shape on activity. The approach is complementary because, when the terminal stages of synthesis are blocked, a precursor of different structure may accumulate and it may have some but different activity. Both the configuration of the ring system (Fig. 2) and of the side chain (Fig. 3) are important. The configurations of the ring systems are illustrated in photographs of models in Fig. 4(a-f). There is a fundamental difference in shape between molecules with the 5a and 58 configuration. In the former, there is a regular alternation of the carbon atoms above and below the plane through all the rings. In the latter, the molecule is bent at the A ring end (Figs. 4(aHb)).The position of the hydroxyl group at C-3 also is important. Ifit is in thepposition, the oxygen atom lies in the plane of the rings of the 5a or A5 sterols (i.e. an equatorial configuration; Figs. 4(b) and (c)).A double bond between C-5 and C-6 flattens the B ring somewhat, and alters the position of the C-4 hydrogens relative to those at other positions in ring A (see Figs. 4(b) and (c)),but a more extreme flattening of the B ring occurs with a double bond between C-7 and C-8 (with or without As).I t will be noticed that A7 brings the “axial” methyl groups (C-18 and C- 19) closer together (compare Figs. 4(d) and (el with (a), (b) and (c)). A double bond between C-8 and C-9 results in greater joint flattening of the B and C rings (Fig. 4(f)). An indication of the overall degree of flatness of the molecule is given by the number of the axial ahydrogen atoms which are coplanar. For Sa-cholestanol, those attached to carbons 1, 3, 5 , 7, 9, 12 and 14 are coplanar; for A5cholestenol, 1, 3, 9, 12 and 14; for A8-cholestenol,1,3, 12 and 14, and for A7-cholestenol,1, 3 and 14. In the last instance, it is notable how far the a-hydrogen attached to C- 12 is from this plane. The numbering of the carbon atoms is indicated in Fig. 1.
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
127
The shape of the side chain is modified by substituents at C-24and double bonds at various positions. An ethyl or methyl group which replaces one of the hydrogen atoms at C-24can be either in the a or p position (Figs. 3, C and G;compare with D and K).The ethyl group of sitosterol (Figs. 2 and 3, IVG) and stigmasterol (IVH) is in the a position; that of poriferasterol (IV K),and the methyl group of ergosterol (VI D)are orientated. In the R and S terminology, sitosterol is (24R)-24-ethyl-5-cholesten-3p-o1. But, under the rules of terminology, the double bond at C-22 causes the ethyl group of stigmasterol to be designated S, and stigmasterol is (24S)-24-ethyl-5,22E-cholestadien3p-01. These variations in the shape of the sterol molecule can result in great variation in biological activity. A very high degree of specificity in their activity is one of the principal characteristics of steroids (Grant, 1969). A third method of approach is to study changes in sterol content or state of binding during the growth cycle, and to corrblate these with metabolic changes in the mycelium. In higher organisms, sterols have three principal functions; as precursors of other steroids, as hormones, and as membrane components (Heftmann, 1971). Heftmann (1970, 1971) points out that plants, as well as animals, produce sterols and from them CZ1, C,, and C,, steroids, and he argues that the fundamental biochemical similarity between all living organisms implies that these compounds have similar roles in plants and animals. In recent years, there have been great advances in our understanding of the action of steroid hormones at molecular level (Jensen and DeSombre, 1972;O’Malley and Means, 1974).A great deal is known about how these hormones bind to cytoplasmic receptors which are characteristic of the target tissues, and how these hormone-receptor complexes then bind to chromosomes leading to synthesis of RNA and specific proteins. At the physiological level, one is struck by the remarkable diversity of effects that hormones induce. We are still far from understanding how events at the molecular level account for this diversity, except that it is evident that a hormone can switch on a sequence of genetic events. Thus, administration of ecdysone to Drosophilu larvae brings about puffing (the sign of gene activity) first in one band of the giant chromosomes, followed by puffing in other bands in a definite order (Ashburner, 1970),so that a complex pattern of metabolic activity can be built up. One of the physiological effects of hormones is on transport across
128
CHARLES G. E L L I O l l
FIGS. 4(a-1). Photographs of models of sterols to illustrate the configuration of the ring systmi. (a) Coprostanol; (b) Cholestanol; (c) Cholesterol; (d) A’-Cholestenol; (e) 7-Dehydrocholesterol; (D A8-Cholestenol.
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
129
130
CHARLES G. ELLlOlT
membranes. Indeed, this is the principal effect of the mineralocorticoids and the vitamin D complex, but oestrogens too, for example, modify transport into the tissues that show the more dramatic responses to the hormone. Formerly, the possibilities that hormone action resulted from direct effects on permeability or on enzyme activity were considered (see Tepperman and Tepperman, 1960; Riggs, 1970). In work on fungal sterols, we are faced with a particular difficulty. As will be discussed later in this review, sterols as components of membranes have a pronounced effect on permeability, in model systems at least. Therefore we have to try to distinguish whether the effects of sterols on, say, species of Phytophthora, result from direct consequences of the presence of sterols in the plasma or mitochondria1 membranes, or whether there are effects which can only be attributed to a hormone-type action. On the whole, it seems that sterols in model membranes affect simple diffusion, but hormones in cells control active energy-requiring transport of specific ions or molecules. 111. Sterols in Model Systems
Nes ( 19741, in an admirable article, has reviewed the occurrence of sterols and sterol-like substances, and drawn attention to the small range of structures found in the dominant sterols of eukaryotes. Evidently only a few structures can fulfil the particular role which fiee sterols perform in the membranes where they occur. Few organisms are known which do not use sterols for this role. One is Tetruhymena pynyormis, which produces instead tetrahymenol, a compound which can adopt a shape similar to that of a sterol. When supplied with exogenous cholesterol, Tetrahymenu pyntormis incorporates it into its membranes (converting it into A5~7~22-cholestatrienol) and the amount of tetrahymenol synthesized is greatly decreased (Connor et al., 1969). Evidently the sterol is a more satisfactory molecule for performing the role in membranes. However, Nozawa et al. (1975) found that, when T. pyriiormis is grown with ergosterol, the replacement of tetrahymenol by ergosterol is accompanied by extensive changes in phospholipid and fatty-acid composition, and also by ultrastructural changes visible in the electron microscope. Some mycoplasmas require an exogenous source of sterol for growth (Edward and Fitzgerald, 1951; Smith and Lynn, 1958); these are now placed in the genus Mycoplasma. The genus Acholeplasma comprises organisms which do not require sterols. Achole-
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
131
plasma laidlawii and A. granularum synthesize cartotenoids which Nes (1974) supposes play a similar role to sterols, but A. axanthum does not make pigmented carotenoids (Tully and Razin, 1969, 1970). Sterols are adsorbed into the membranes of both the sterol requirers and nonrequirers (Smith and Rothblat, 1960; Tully and Razin, 1969). The effect of exogenous sterol supplied in serum to A. laidlawii is to decrease the amount of carotenoid in the membrane (Smith, 1963) bht, when the sterol is added without serum, it is incorporated without significantly affecting the carotenoid content (Razin and Cleverdon, 1965).
FIG. 5. Diagram showing possible mode of interaction between cholesterol and lecithin with stearoyl and linolenyl chains (Vandenheuvel, 1963). CCC indicates the carbon atoms of glycerol; P, phosphorus; N, nitrogen ofcholine; and 0, the hydroxyl oxygen of' cholesterol.
The way in which cholesterol can fit into a phospholipid layer has been discussed by Finean ( 19531, Vandenheuvel (1963) and Brockerhoff ( 1974). The dimensions of the cholesterol molecule are such that, if the 3-hydroxyl of the sterol is associated with the nitrogen of the choline of the lecithin, the end of the cholesterol side chain fits neatly under the fatty-acyl chain where it bends at the cis double bonds (as in linoleic acid; Fig. 5; Vandenheuvel, 1963). Brockerhoff (1974) proposed a model based on hydrogen bonding between the 3hydroxyl group of the sterol and the carboxyl oxygen of the fatty-acyl chain. Edwards and Green (1972) showed that extra carbon atoms in the side chain decrease the ability of sterols to pack into phospholipid layers, campesterol being less readily incorporated than cholesterol, and sitosterol than campesterol. This could be related to the well known fact that ergosterol and sitosterol are less readily absorbed in the human intestine than cholesterol (Glover and Morton, 1958). Our understanding of the role of sterols in membranes has been es-
132
CHARLES G. ELLIOlT
pecially advanced by the use of physicochemical techniques applied to model systems-the lipid monolayer spread on water, and the bilayer “liposome” produced by mixing lipid with salt solution-as well as on membranes themselves. The membranes of mycoplasmas in particular are admirable objects for such experiments (Razin, 1973). The physicochemical studies were reviewed by Oldfield and Chapman (1972). Demel el al. (1967) and Chapman et al. (1969) showed that incorporation of cholesterol into a lecithin monolayer decreased the area occupied by each molecule. The magnitude of the affect increased with increasing proportion of cholesterol (De Kruyff et al., 1972). Darke et al. (19721, in a study using nuclear magnetic resonance, showed that cholesterol and lecithin formed a complex in which their molar ratio was 1 : 1 ; when the proportion of cholesterol in a bilayer was less than half, its distribution was clustered. However, Verkleij et al. (1974) found, using freeze-fractured liposomes, that lecithin bilayers containing only 1&15 mole per cent cholesterol were homogeneous. Rand et al. (1975) described a 1 : 1 molar complex between cholesterol and lysolethicin, and emphasized that their interaction was quite different from the interaction of cholesterol with the diacyllecithins. Addition of cholesterol to a lecithin decreases the amount of movement which the fatty-acyl chains of the lecithin can undergo. Thus the temperature at which the transition between the more rigid gel phase and the less rigid crystalline phase occurs is lowered, and the amount of heat adsorbed at the transition point is decreased (Ladbrooke et al., 1968). More recently, the use of electron spin resonance (ESR also called electron paramagnetic resonance, EPR), in which the freedom of movement of the electron of an introduced free radicle can be studied, has provided much information. For example, Hsia and Boggs (1972) and Mailer et al. ( 1974) showed that cholesterol restricts the freedom of movement of the hydrocarbon chains of fatty acyl groups, and Butler et al. (1970) compared the effects of a number of steroids. Kroes et al. ( 1972) similarly showed increased viscosity in erythrocyte membranes from guinea pigs fed a cholesterol-supplemented diet; their erythrocytes contained about twice the control amount of cholesterol. Feinstein et al. (1975) used a fluorescent probe to show that cholesterol decreased membrane fluidity. Rothman and Engelman (1972) showed with models how the presence of cholesterol in the membrane restricts the movement of the carboxyl half of the fatty-acyl chain, while some movement is still possible at the free end.
STEROLS I N
FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
133
Work with artificial membranes has shown that sterols affect their permeability. When they contain cholesterol, their permeability to water is decreased (Finkelstein and Cass, 19671, the rate at which liposomes swell in hypotonic solutions is diminished (De Gier et al., 1968) and the rate of loss of sequestered glucose is also decreased (Demel et al., 1968). Both cells of Acholeplasma laidlawii, and liposomes prepared from their lipids, showed lower permeability to glycerol and erythritol when the cells has been grown in cholesterol-containing medium (De Kruyff et al., 1972; McElhaney et al., 1973). The latter authors, and also De Kruyff et al. (1973), emphasized the effect of fatty-acid composition on membrane permeability, but incorporation of cholesterol had no effect on the fatty-acid composition, and thus the diminished permeability with cholesterol could be attributed to cholesterol (De Kruyff et al., 1972). Rottem et al. (1973) adapted the sterol-requiring species Mycoplasma mycodes var. Capri to grow without sterol, and showed that the adapted cells were more fragile osmotically, and were more permeable to erythritol. The effects of other sterols besides cholesterol on molecular spacing in monolayers and on permeability of liposomes have been studied by Demel et al. (1972a, b). Their papers give no indication of the variability of the results, but it appears that the effects of sterol structure on both phenomena are very similar and are comparable to the effects on cell permeability (De Kruyff et al., 1972, 1973). The ESR studies by Butler et al. ( 1970) also give essentially similar ordering of the compounds. In general, cholesterol (Figs. 2 and 3, IVA) has the greatest effect in all of these systems, with cholestanol (IIIA), A’cholestenol (VA), 7 -dehydrocholesterol (VIA) and B-norcholesterol (IA) similar. Molecules without a side chain (5a-androstan-3p-01 and 5-androst-en-Sp-01) have little effect, as is also the case with 3ahydroxysterols (e.g. epicholesterol; VIIA) and coprostanol (IIA) with its 58 configuration. Of the sterols with extra carbon atoms in the side chain, sitosterol (with a saturated side chain; IVG) has a similar effect to cholesterol, and stigmasterol (IVH) and ergosterol WID) (with a double bond at C-22) are less effective. These conclusions are in agreement with the effects of steroids on growth of mycoplasmas (Smith, 1964; Smith and Lynn, 1958; Rottem et al., 1971). I t is interesting to note that, in agreement with Nes’s (1974) hypothesis, carotenoids have similar effects to sterols on permeability. Huang and Haug (1974) grew A . laidlawii on acetate-containing
134
CHARLES G. ELLIOlT
medium (and thus increased the mount of carotenoids) and on propionate (thereby lowering the content of carotenoids). The carotenoid-enriched cells had less fluid membranes (as indicated by the ESR spectrum) and the cells were tougher to lyse and less permeable to glycerol. The effect of sterol composition on permeability and fragility of membranes has also been studied with erythrocytes and their ghosts by Bruckdorfer et al. (1968a, b). Erythrocytes readily lost cholesterol to sterol-depleted plasma or pure phospholipid dispersions. When these treated cells were re-incubated with dispersions of lecithin and sterol, the sterol was absorbed into the membranes, different sterols being taken up to different extents. Ergosterol was taken up to a remarkably poor extent. I t was found (Bruckdorfer et al., 1969) that the erythrocytes incub'ated in lecithin alone (which lost 3348% of their cholesterol) were very fragile and permeable to glycerol. As compared with cells re-incubated with cholesterol, those in which there was partial replacement of cholesterol (IVA) by A'-cholestenol (VA), 7 -dehydrocholesterol (VIA) or B-norcholesterol (IA) showed considerably decreased fragility, while incorporation of stigmasterol (IVH)or ergosterol (VIE) effected slight increases and decreases, respectively, although they replaced cholesterol to a very limited extent. The S-oxosteroids increased fragility and also permeability to glycerol. Coprostanol (IIA) and 7 -dehydrocholesterol (VIA) caused some decrease in permeability, but A'-cholestenol (VA) and Bnorcholesterol (IA) had little effect. Edwards and Green (1972) found that, in a replacement system, sitosterol (IVG) and campesterol (IVC) were incorporated into erythrocyte membranes to a lesser extent than cholesterol, the enlarged side chain being inimical to adsorption. In higher plant tissues, the effects of sterols on permeability have been studied by Grunwald (1968, 1971). He found (1968) that cholesterol was highly effective in reversing the methanol-induced leakage of betacyanin from beetroot cells, but sitosterol (IVG) and stigmasterol (IVH) were less effective; ergosterol (VIE) increased the leakage. With barley roots (Grunwald, 197 11, cholesterol was most effective at 10 pM at decreasing ethanol-induced permeability (but it increased leakage at 100 pM);campesterol (IVC)was less effective and stigmasterol (IVH) and sitosterol (IVG) had little effect. The evideuce already discussed shows that the occurrence in
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
135
membranes of 3/3-hydroxysterolswith 5a- or A5-configurationsand a side chain decreases their permeability, and cholesterol is one of the most effective in this respect. But it must be remembered that not all membranes are alike in their lipid composition. Besides species differences, the membranes of different organelles are different, in sterol as well as phospholipid composition (Dod and Gray, 1968; Siekeviu, 1970). The differences are no doubt related to the structural requirements associated with the different enzymic proteins which are bound to the membranes; the lipid composition would require to be adapted to the physiological activity of the membrane. Also, Smith ( 1969) has argued that sterols in mycoplasmas are actively associated with transport across the membranes; especially, he believed that the sterol glucosides found in those species which use glucose as an energy source are sterols caught in the act of moving glucose into the cell. More recently other transport mechanisms have been found (see Razin, 1973, p. 66). Wiley and Cooper (1975) studied the effect of cholesterol enrichment on transport of Na' and K+across erythrocyte membranes, and suggested that the excess cholesterol could influence the position of the protein carrier within the membrane, or decrease its ability to move within a more viscous micro-environment. IV. Subcellular Distribution of Sterols in Fungi, and States of Binding
A number of fungi absorb sterols from their medium, even those which synthesize them (Hartman and Holmlund, 1962). Study of the uptake of sterols from solutions of various concentrations provides evidence as to the mechanism of uptake. With simple physical adsorption, we expect, from the Freundlich adsorption isotherm, a linear relation between the logarithms of the concentration supplied and the conceytration in the adsorbing surface. The evidence in Phytophthora cactorum (Elliott and Knights, 1974) is in agreement with this expectation, as are the much more extensive data on mycoplasmas (Smith and Rothblat, 1960) and mammalian tissue-culture cells (Rothblat et al., 1967). The uptake of cholesterol by Acholeplcwmu laidlawii was also shown to follow first-order kinetics by Gershfeld et al. (1974). Uptake of various sterols by Phytophthera infestans was investigated by Langcake (1975) who found that cholesterol (IVA) and cholestanol (IIIA) were taken up much more than sitosterol (IVG) and stigmasterol (IVH),
136
CHARLES G. ELLIOlT
while ergosterol (VIE) was very poorly taken up. Hendrix (1975a) found that sitosterol and cholesterol were taken up less readily by Achlya spp. than by Pythium spp. The sterol taken up by Phytophthora and Pythium spp. is recoverable partly as free sterol and partly as ester (Hendrix et al., 1970; Gain, 1972; Elliott and Knights, 1974; Hendrix, 1975b). Hendrix et al. (1970) considered that all of the sterol could be readily extracted from the mycelium, but Elliott and Knights (1974) found that about 10%of the cholesterol taken up from the medium was not recovered with a 7 h Soxhlet extraction with acetone, but it was recovered if the acetoneextracted mycelium was hydrolysed with 6-N HCl or by pyrogallol in methanolic potassium hydroxide. We have also shown (B. A. Knights and C. G. Elliott, unpublished observations) that the residue remaining after prolonged extraction with acetone contains sterol by combustion of the residue and analysis of the carbon dioxide produced for radioactivity. Cholesteryl oleate added to cultures growing without sterol is taken up by P. cactorum much more slowly than free cholesterol (Elliott and Knights, 1974). We believe that the ester must be converted to free sterol before it can be absorbed. The free sterol content of the mycelium reaches a constant value per unit weight about 12 h after addition of free sterol to the culture, and despite the slower rate of uptake of oleate the free sterol content per unit weight reaches the same constant value within 24 h of adding the ester (Fig. 6). The amount of sterol ester in the cells follows a different pattern according to whether the culture is supplied with free sterol or with ester. With free sterol supplied, much sterol is taken up, and much is found as ester, in harvests made soon after addition of the sterol to the cultures; later the amount of ester declines. Presumably the ester formed in the early stages is de-esterified, thus keeping the free sterol content constant as the weight of mycelium increases. With oleate supplied, less sterol is taken up at first, and little of it is found as ester (Fig. 6; Elliott and Knights, 1974). These results are consistent with the view that free sterols are found in membranes, while the sterol present in the cell in excess of that required free in the membranes is esterified and located elsewhere (Nes, 1974).We have not investigated the distribution of free sterol and ester in P. cactorum, but Sietsma and Haskins (1968) fractionated cells of Pythium acanthium grown with cholesterol, and reported that 79%of the
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWH AND REPRODUCTION
137
-0-0
;---fp---.---:--
Time ( h ) from addition of cholesterol to medium
FIG. 6. Changes with time in sterol and sterol ester content of mycelium of Phytop h h m cactorum, following addition of cholesterol or cholesteryl oleate to six-day-old cultures. U indicates changes in the content of free sterol in ecetone extracts of mycelium (free cholesterol supplied in medium); o----O of sterol ester in extracts of mycelium (free cholesterol in medium);. --- Aof free sterol in acetone extracts of mycelium (cholesteryloleate supplied in medium);A---Aof sterol ester in extracts of mycelium (cholesteryl oleate in medium). Data of Elliott and Knights (1974).
sterol was in the protoplast membrane, 18%in mitochondria and 3%in endoplasmic reticulum. Their assay was by the Liebermann-Burchard assay, and esters were not investigated. Langcake (1975)reported that 71% of the cholesterol taken up by Phytophthora infeestuns was in the supernatant after centrifugation of blended mycelium for 15 min at 2 O O O g and 86% of the sterol of this was sedimented after 30min at 160,000g. The subcellular distribution of ergosterol in the ascomycete Aspergdlus niger was studied by Barr and Hemming (1972).They found that about half of the free sterol was in the mitochondria1 fraction (identified by the presence of ubiquinone), but the largest proportion of ester was in the heaviest fraction (sedimentingat 500 g after 10 mid. More critical information comes from the work on yeast (Saccharomyces cereviseae) by Hossack et al. (19731, who found that the membranous fraction (identified by phosphatidylinositol kinase) contained primarily free sterol, while the fraction consisting of low-density vesicles contained sterol esters and very little free sterol. Such vesicles are present in the growing hyphal tip (Bartnicki-Garcia, 1973kin yeast in the young bud (Moor, 1967)-and they contribute directly to the extending plasmalemma. I t seems possible that the sterol esters of the
138
CHARLES
G. ELLIOlT
vesicles serve as a ready source of the sterol required for the new membrane. Hallermeyer and Neupert ( 1974) found that ergosterol was present in the outer mitochondria1 membranes of Neurospora crassa, but there was no sterol in the inner membrane. Assay of the amounts of free sterol and ester in mycelium is however dependent on the methods of chemical extraction used. Adams and Parks ( 1967) showed that different extraction procedures removed different amounts of sterol from yeast. Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains a mannan in the cell wall which binds sterol (Thompson et al., 1973), making it water soluble and resistant to extraction with the usual lipid solvents; this bound sterol can be extracted after hydrolysis with alkaline pyrogallol (Adams and Parks, 1968). Sterol-binding polysaccharides were also described from Rhizopus arrhizus, Penicillium roquefortii and Saccharomyces carlsbergensis by Pillai and Weete ( 1975). Hence, studies on variation in the sterol content of mycelium during the growth cycle, using a single method of extraction only (as was done by Van Etten and Gottlieb (1965) with Penicillium atrouentum) are of limited value. In our analysis of sterols in Neurospora crassa (Elliott et al., 19741, we extracted the dried mycelium first with acetone, and then subjected it to alkaline pyrogallol hydrolysis. The acetone extract contained “readily extractable” free sterol and sterol esters; the alkaline pyrogallol extract was of “tightly bound” sterol. The occurrence of a large tightly bound fraction was characteristic of conidia and of senescent mycelium. It appeared that there was transfer of sterol from a readily extractable to a tightly bound state with the onset of senescence. Sterols were synthesized during active growth of the mycelium, with the amount of ester more or less parallel to free sterol. When accumulation of dry matter ceased, the free-sterol fraction continued to increase in size for a couple of days, apparently at the expense of the esters. Increase of free sterol at the expense of esters was noted in yeast by Madyastha and Parks (1969). In Phycomyces blakesleeanus, the composition of the free-sterol fraction is relatively constant during growth of the culture, but there are marked changes in the ester fraction. Thus, the proportion of episterol varies from 31 to 37% in the free-sterol fraction but from 45 to 76% in the ester fraction at different stages of growth; ergosterol forms from 49 to 66% of the free sterols but from 18 to 48% of the esters. The proportion of ergosterol esterified increases during the first 30 h of incubation, then declines somewhat and increases again after 45 h (Bartlett and Mercer, 1974). The composition of ester and free-sterol
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
139
fractions differ also in Saccharomyces cereuisiae (Barks et af., 19741, and in Leptosphaeria typhae (Alais et ul., 1974).Atallah and Nicholas (1974)have suggested that esters may be important during biosynthesis; hence, perhaps, the greater diversity in the esterified sterols. DupCron et a f . (1972) found a small proportion of the sterol of potato tuber tissue in the supernatant after centrifugation of the material at 100,OOOg. This had a very large amount of sterol ester. They considered the occurrence of ester in the cytosol reflected a function in transport of sterol round the cell. The amount of sterol ester did not decline during starvation in Phycomyces blahleeanus (Bartlett and Mercer, 1974); thus sterol ester can act as a reserve for sterol but not for energy production. In potato tuber during storage, the sterol esters increase while the glucosides decrease; the free-sterol content remains more or less constant (DupPron et ul., 1971). Synthesis of sterols and sterol esters was followed during growth of Saccharomyces cereuisiae by Bailey and Parks (1975).They found that synthesis of C,, sterols continued throughout the logarithmic phase of growth, but the amount of sterol ester remained at a constant low value until the onset of the resting phase when it rapidly increased. While ergosterol formed the major sterol at an early stage of growth (92%of all sterol), it decreased to 40%at a later stage, concomitant with the appearance in substantial quantities of ergosterol precursors, especially A5.7-ergostadienoland zymosterol, and these were found mainly in the ester fraction. While zymosterol (Figs. 2 and 3, VIII B) is readily methylated at C-24, its esters are not, and, in general, esters of the precursors are not metabolised to ergosterol. Thus Bailey and Parks (1975)suggest that sterol esters may have an important role to play in the regulation of sterol synthesis. Alais et al. (1974)compared the sterols of Leptosphaeria typhae grown in light and in the dark. In the light-grown cultures, ergosterol was the only sterol found in the free state but, in the dark-grown cultures, there were small amounts of episterol, A7-ergostenol and ( ?) 24-ethyl-5cholestenol. The ester fractions also differed, the dark-grown cultures containing a considerable proportion of C,, and C,, sterols. It is to be noted that light induces formation of sexual structures in this fungus. Safe (1973)investigated the sterols of Mucor rouxii in the filamentous and yeast-like phases induced by growth under aerobic and anaerobic conditions, respectively, and found differences in sterol composition and binding. Under aerobic conditions, 90% of the sterol readily extractable with chloroform-methanol was ergosterol, but the tightly bound fraction (obtained by alkaline pyrogallol hydrolysis of the
140
CHARLES G. ELLIOTT
chloroform-methanol extracted mycelium) contained only 33% ergosterol together with A7J4(28)-ergostadienol (25%). Under anaerobic conditions, several sterols appeared in the readily extractable fraction as well as in the tightly bound fraction, but their proportions in the two fractions were different. Differences in the relative proportions of ergosterol and di-unsaturated sterols in the two fractions were also found in Neurospora crassa (Elliott et al., 1974). Safe and Caldwell(1975) reported further studies on the distribution of sterols between the cell wall and cytoplasm of Mucor rouxii in relation to the mode of binding, and they studied a yeast-like phase induced by phenethyl alcohol as well as that induced by anaerobiosis. Changes in the binding state of sterols in yeast were described by Adams and Parks (1967). Their technique was to grow cells anaerobically and then aerate them in a medium containing KH,PO,, 1% glucose and ['4C-methyllmethionine, so that the ergosterol synthesized was labelled at c-28. Cyclic changes in the amount of sterol extractable after saponification with 40% potassium hydroxide and after hydrolysis with hot 0.1-N HCI, were observed. The amounts of sterol recovered by these two methods, when added together, gave a constant value from the fourth hour after the beginning of aeration; up to this time, sterol was being synthesized. It was suggested that the sterol extracted with the base and acid treatments represented different pools, and that there was a shift of some sterol from one pool to the other according to the metabolic state of the cells. Starr and Parks ( 1962) observed that the time of occurrence of the drop in the amount of base-extractable sterol of cells aerated in glucose was determined by the glucose concentration, and was associated with exhaustion of sugar from the medium and a switch to respiratory utilization of the ethanol which had accumulated during fermentative metabolism. When the cells were aerated with acetate as energy source, the amount of baseextractable sterol increased to a maximum value which then remained constant (Adams and Parks, 1967). Also, when cells were aerated with glucose in the presence of acriflavine, which prevents adaptation to respiratory competence, the drop in base-extractable sterol did not occur (Adams and Parks, 1969). Synthesis of sterols during ascus formation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae has been investigated by Esposito et al. ( 19691, Henry and Halvorson (1973) and Illingworth et al. (1973). Incorporation of labelled acetate into lipid occurs in two stages (Esposito et al., 19691, the second of
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
141
which co-incides with the appearance of the ascospores (Henry and Halvorson, 1973). Illingworth et al. (1973) noted an increase in free sterol proportional to the amount of new membrane formed, but there was a much greater increase in the amount of sterol ester, which was associated with the development of vesicles. Crystals observed in hyphae of Neurospora crassu (Tsuda and Tatum, 196 1) and Phymatotrichum omnivorum (Baniecki and Bloss, 1969) and considered to be ergosterol, have recently been shown to be proteinaceous (Hoch and Maxwell, 1974).
V. Effects of Sterols on Metabolism and Vegetative Growth A. P Y T H I U M
A N D PHYTOPHTHORA
An immediate effect of the uptake of sterol by Pythium sp. is to make the cells less permeable. Cholesterol-grown cells “leak” nucleosides and proteins less than ones grown without sterol (Sietsma and Haskins, 1968). Child et al. ( 1969) compared leakage of material from mycelium grown with and without cholesterol; after an initial loss attendant on transferring cholesterol-grown cells to fresh medium or water, there was no further leakage of material absorbing at 260 nm, of nitrogen or of protein, and no change in conductivity of the suspending fluid, whereas loss continued with cells grown without added cholesterol. Loss of carbohydrate however was greater with cholesterol-grown cells. Species of Phytophthora and Pythium grow faster in the presence of sterols than on medium without added sterols. This is true both for dry weight and hyphal extension. The amount of increase in growth with sterols is not as great as with lecithin, but the growth rate with lecithin and sterol is greater than on medium supplemented with lecithin only (Hohl, 1975). With Pythium acanthium, addition of cholesterol to the medium shortens the lag phase of growth or accelerates growth in the early exponential phase; the total mycelial mass grown with or without cholesterol is the same (Child et al., 1969), or eventually the mycelial mass without cholesterol may exceed that grown with cholesterol (Brushaber et al., 1972). In several other Pythium species and in Phytophthora cactorum, cholesterol-grown cultures attained a greater maximum weight (Schlosser and Gottlieb, 1968; Elliott, 1972a). Sterols require to be added to the medium for asexual reproduction
142
CHARLES G. ELLIOlT
by sporangia (Hendrix, 1965, 1967; Chee and Turner, 1965; Elliott, 1972a; Langcake, 1974). Their incorporation also increases the ability to survive at high and low temperatures (Haskins, 1965; Sietsma and Haskins, 1967). Sterols -increased the number of propagules produced by Pythium sylvaticum, but those grown without sterols survived in soil as well as those grown with sterols (Kaosiri and Hendrix, 1972). Various sterols have different effects on vegetative growth and they affect aspects of growth differently (Langcake, 1974). Langcake’s results with P. inzstans are summarized in Table 2. The difference between cholesterol and stigmasterol is particularly intriguing. The effect of sitosterol is intermediate but generally much closer to that of TABLE 2. Ellects of several sterols on growth of Phytophthoru infeestuns (Langcake, 1974, 1975)
Stcrol
;Idclrd None
Cfiolrstrrol Cholrst;inol Si Iostrrol Stigniastrrol Ergosrcrol L;iii~~tc-r~l
Stcrol content ofmycelium (% ofdrv wt)
Dry weight of eight-day cultures (mg)
Colony diam. at 14 days (cm)
Sporangium production’
-
15.8 28.3 27.9 27.8 24.6
12.0 39.9 54.0 46.1 58.9 35.1 15.5
0.6 28.6 20.5 33.3 25.1 22.1 15.2
0.19 0.19 0.09 0.11
Trace -
-
6.0
~
A plug I cm in diameter was cut from the culture and shaken in 2 ml water. The number of sporangia liberated was counted in a 10 pl sample.
cholesterol. Cholesterol gives heavier cultures than stigmasterol (although the difference in weight is not actually significant) but, with stigmasterol, hyphal elongation is much faster (the difference being highly significant). Could a difference in their effect on the cell membrane account for these phenomena? The more permeable membrane might facilitate deposition of material at the hyphal tip, and so promote faster elongation; the less permeable might retain material within the cell and thereby increase its weight. Sterols appear to promote more active cellular metabolism. Schlosser and Gottlieb ( 1968) investigated glucose metabolism in Pythium ultimum grown with and without cholesterol. They found that glucose uptake was faster in cultures with cholesterol than without, but the difference was less than one would expect from the rate of dry
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
143
matter production. However, the cultures containing cholesterol produced 65%more carbon dioxide per unit of glucose consumed, indicating a much greater energy production in the sterol-containing mycelium. Pythium acanthium grown with cholesterol produced a greater quantity of lipid than when grown without it (Brushaber et al., 1972). Sietsma (1971) showed that, in Pythium spp. grown in the presence of cholesterol, most of the enzymes of the tricarboxylic-acid cycle, some aminotransferases and glutamate dehydrogenase showed higher activity than when the
144
CHARLES G. ELLIOlT
weight of tissue). The authors suggested that sterols occurring in high localized concentration in older roots changed the fungus from its aggressive pectolytic enzyme-producing phase to a less aggressive reproductive phase. Defago et al. (1975) showed that the relationship between the amount of cholesterol supplied to Pythium paroecandrum and its pathogenicity depended on other constituents of the host plant. Thus, with sugar beet (Beta vulgaris) and tomato (Lycopersiconesculentum), the severity of disease symptoms decreased with increasing sterol concentration, as the plants contained saponins to which sterol-containing mycelium is sensitive, whereas mycelium without sterol is not sensitive to saponins. Pea (Pisum sutivum) and soy bean (Glycine max) contain no saponins, and here disease severity increased with increasing sterol concentration. With lucerne (Medicago sativa), the severity of symptoms increased with sterol concentration despite the presence of saponins, as the plant contains tannic acid, and cholesterol in the mycelium imparts some resistance to tannic acid. Langcake (1974) tested the suggestion of Elliott and Knights (1969) that, in plant tissues containing a high ratio of sterol precursors (e.g. cycloartenol) to sterols, the precursors would interfere with growth and sporulation of Phytophthora and Pythium spp. and confer resistance on the host tissues. Langcake (1974) found, contrary to expectation, that leaves of the potato varieties Majestic and Ulster Chieftain, which were susceptible to blight (caused by Phytophthora infestand, contained more cycloartenol relative to sitosterol than the resistant Pentland Dell. He also found that extracts of Majestic and Pentland Dell leaves, added to medium at concentrations adjusted to give the same amounts of sitosterol, had a similar ability to promote growth of P . infeestans, despite the difference in their cycloartenol content. B. S A C C H A R O M Y C E S A N D O T H E R F U N G I
The study of sterols in Saccharomyces cerevisiae has recently been considerably advanced by the use of mutants with altered sterol composition, and by a physiological technique which similarly allows replacement of ergosterol by other sterols. Sterol-requiring yeast mutants were described by Karst and Lacroute ( 1973) and by Sprinson and his coworkers (Gollub et al., 1974; Trocha et al., 1974). These mutants are “petite”, and the sterol deficiency is apparently due to a defect in biosynthesis of haem (Bard et al., 1974). Haem is required in sterol syn-
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN
GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
145
thesis for oxygenation reactions concerned with removal of the C- 14 methyl group. The other kind of sterol mutants investigated are the polyeneresistant strains. Polyene antibiotics act by complexing with sterols in membranes (Lampen, 1966; Kinsky, 1967). They inhibit growth of fungal cells, but not in species of Phytophthora or Pythium grown without sterols-the antibiotics may even increase growth of Pythium (Defago et al., 1969). However, when these fungi are grown with sterol, they become sensitive to polyenes (Schlosser and Gottlieb, 1966; Van Etten and Gottlieb, 1967; Schlosser, 1972; Sietsma and Haskins, 1968; Child et al., 1969) and soluble material leaks out of the cells. Mutants of Neurospora crassa ( Grindle, 197 31 and Saccharomyces cereuisiue (Woods, 1971; Molzahn and Woods, 1972; Bard, 1972; Parks et al., 1972) resistant to polyene antibiotics contain different sterols from the wild-type sensitive strain, and it appears that each of four genetically different mutants of Sacch. cereuisiae has a different lesion in the biosynthetic pathway from zymosterol to ergosterol (Barton et al., 1974). The sterols of double mutants were as expected from the lesions observed in single mutants (Barton et al., 1975). Another mutant selected for nystatin resistance in the presence of cholesterol by Karst and Lacroute (1974) was found to be unable to convert squalene to lanosterol. Bard (1972) remarked that the sterols in his mutant strains must be effective in meeting the structural and functional requirements of the cell, but that the antibiotic has a greater chemical affinity for the sterols terminal in the biosynthetic pathways, i.e. ergosterol and cholesterol. Fryberg et al. (1974) adapted yeast to grow in concentrations of 30, 100, 200 and 300 units of nystatirdml, and they found that the strains which were resistant to the highest concentrations were blocked earliest in the synthetic pathway (and contained A8*24(28)ergostadienol (Figs. 2 and 3 VIIIF)) while those resistant to the lowest concentrations were blocked at the latest stage (and produced A’***ergostadienol WE), instead of ergosterol). Karst and Lacroute (1973) noted that a sterol-requiring mutant of yeast growing in ergosterol-containing medium was sensitive to nystatin at a concentration of 8 pg/ml but, when grown with cholesterol, sitosterol or stigmasterol, its sensitivity was less, 15 pg/ml being required for inhibition. Several people have investigated the ability of various sterols, when added to the medium together with the antibiotic, to reverse the anti-
146
CHARLES G. ELLIOTT
fungal activity of the polyenes (Gottlieb et al., 1960; Perritt et al., 1960; Zygmunt and Tavormina, 1966; Lampen et al., 1960; Gale, 1974) and in some cases the complexing of sterol and polyene in the absence of fungus was studied.-But these investigations have not included a sufficient range of sterols to provide any clue as to why absence of ergosterol confers resistance to nystatin on the yeast mutants. The physiological technique of replacement of ergosterol by other sterols depends on the fact that, during anaerobic growth, yeast cells require an exogenous source of sterol and unsaturated fatty acid (Andreasen and Stier, 1953, 1954).This sterol requirement arises from the need for molecular oxygen in the formation of 3-oxidosqualene, the first step in the cyclization of squalene to sterol. Proudlock et al. ( 1968) found a relatively “all or none” effect in the ability of sterols of various structures to support anaerobic growth. A number Of 5 a or A5 sterols (including, remarkably, 5a-cholestan-3a-ol) supported growth equally well. Hossack and Rose (1976) supplied anaerobic cells with a sterol other than ergosterol, and achieved considerable enrichment of the cells with the foreign sterol. The effects of this modification on the ability of protoplasts to stretch was investigated. The main finding was that protoplasts containing sterols with a double bond in the side chain (ergosterol, stigmasterol) are considerably more stable and burst less readily than those with a saturated side chain (cholesterol, 7-dehydrocholesterol, A’-ergostenol, campesterol or sitosterol). The presence of Azz sterols in the membranes thus endows them with a limited capacity to stretch (Hossack and Rose, 1976). As already noted, ergosterol and stigmasterol decrease the packing of molecules in a film less than sterols with a saturated side chain (Demel et al., 1972a). I t is obvious that species of Phytophthora and Pythium could provide much precise information on the effect of sterols on membrane structure and permeability, since the sterol content can be so directly controlled. I am not aware of such experiments having been reported, although protoplasts of Pythium sp. were prepared by Sietsma et al. (1968, 1969). The amount of sterol supplied to yeast cultures during anaerobic growth affects the performance of the cells when they are subsequently aerated. Cultures grown anaerobically with high concentrations of ergosterol in the medium adapt to aerobic growth more rapidly than,those with only low concentrations-the activities of succinate dehydrogenase and cytochrome oxidase increase linearly with
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
147
time (and not by an S-shaped curve) in the presence of high concentrations of ergosterol (Hebb and Slebodnik, 1958). The effect of ergosterol on the ultrastructure of Saccharoqces cerevisiue was described by Wallace et al. (1968). Adding ergosterol to aerobically-grown cultures produced no visible effect. Cultures incubated anaerobically without sterol or unsaturated fatty acid showed only vague outlines of mitochondria. With oleic or palmitoleic acids or Tween 80, but no sterol, extensive membranous structures appeared in the cells, but not normal mitochondria. However, with Tween 80 and ergosterol, mitochondria profiles were much more clearly defined, and extra membranes were not found. It seems that such mitochondria would be ready to assemble and use the respiratory enzymes immediately they were formed, With the obligate aerobe, Candida parapsilosis, addition of ergosterol and unsaturated fatty acid to the medium during growth under low aeration greatly enhanced the clarity of the mitochondrial profiles without increasing growth rate (Kellermanet al., 1969). The conclusion here seems to be that ergosterol is fulfilling a structural role in mitochondrial membranes. This was also the conclusion of Thompson and Parks (1972) from their investigation of cytochrome oxidase. Associated with an 80-fold purified preparation of the enzyme, and necessary for its activity, was a lipid component which included ergosterol. However, ergosterol itself, when added to the enzyme, did not promote its activity, but unsaturated fatty acids did. Notable use of nystatin-resistant mutants has been made by Thompson and Parks ( 1974) to study physiological activity in relation to sterol structure. Wild-type cells contained ergosterol ; one mutant contained A5*7~22J4(28)-erg~~tatetren~l; two others contained As*nnergostadienol. When grown fermentatively in glucose-containing media, all strains had similar temperature optima but, when required to respire ethanol, the strains with A8J2-ergostadienol had lower temperature optima, and lower upper limits for growth, than those containing the A5*’-sterols.Differences were also found in the activity of sterol methyl transferase in mitochondria, attendant on the alteration in sterol structure from A5n7to As. The As-sterol appears to be less effective as a repressor of the enzyme than ergosterol. The effects of inhibitors of sterol synthesis are discussed in Section X,p. 162 in connection with sexual reproduction; but here we will note that certain fungicides are inhibitors of sterol synthesis (triarimol,
148
CHARLES G. E L L I O l l
Ragsdale and Sisler, 1972; S-1358, Kato et al., 1974, 1975). Ragsdale (1975) showed that, in Ustilago maydis, triarimol inhibits removal of the 14-methyl group, inserkion of the double bond at C-22 and the reduction of the double bond at C-24(28). The morphological effects were that sporidia enlarged and became multicellular and multinucleate; no more sporidia were budded off from these cells. The controls without triarimol continued sporidial production, the cells remaining unbranched, unicellular and uninucleate (Ragsdale and Sisler, 1972, 1973). The related compound triforine also inhibits ergosterol synthesis in Neurospora c r a m (Sherald et al., 1973). These authors also found that certain mutants of Cladosporium cucumerinum and Ustilago maydis, selected for resistance to triforine, were resistant to triarimol, and its other analogues, ancymidol and EL-241. VI. Effects of Sterols on Asexual Reproduction A well nourished mycelium is a sine qua non for asexual reproduction, and it is perhaps because of this that sterols are required for sporangium formation in species of Phytophthora (see page 14 1).
However, induction of asexual reproduction in fungi presumably involves the switching on of genes which are repressed during earlier stages of growth. We know nothing of the means whereby this is brought about at the chromosomal level. Could a steroid hormone be involved ? In the imperfect ascomycete Stemphylium solani, ergosterol can replace the requirement for light for induction of conidiation (Sproston and Setlow, 1968). The ergosterol was dissolved in 5% dimethyl sulphoxide in 0.1-M KH,PO,; the solvent itself induced some conidium formation. Ergosterol at 0.5 pg/ml further enhanced conidium production, although concentrations above 0.8 ,ug/ml caused inhibition of conidium formation. Ethanol, propylene glycol and ethylene glycol also increased conidiation. Sproston and Setlow ( 1968) suggested that the similar inducing effect of ergosterol and of ultraviolet radiation and solvents could be due to the freeing of internally bound sterol by the latter agents, and this release of free sterol is the triggering mechanism for conidium formation. Baniecki and Bloss ( 1969) reported that ergosterol stimulated conidium production by Phymatotrichum omnivorum but, in this case, it did not substitute for the light requirement; both light and sterol were re-
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
149
quired. I t seems that ergosterol itself is not required but that its vitamin D product is, since vitamins D, and D, and dihydrotachysterol were stimulatory to conidiation. VII. Sexual Hormones of Achlya I begin the discussion of the effect of sterols on sexual reproduction in fungi with the sex hormones of Achlya spp., for here the involvement of sterols, through steroid hormones, is clearly understood, thanks to the elegant work of Dr. Alma Barksdale and her associates. The control of reproduction in Achlya spp. by a series of hormones was demonstrated in the classic experiments of Raper ( 1939, 1940). He showed that a hormone, A, produced by female plants of A . bisexualis and A . ambisexualis induced formation of antheridial branches in the male plant. The male plant was then induced to produce a second hormone, B, which had the effect of stimulating production of oogonia by the female plant. Raper supposed there was a third hormone, C, produced by the oogonial initials, which attracted the antheridial branches; when the antheridial branches made contact with the oogonial initials, the antheridia were delimited, and a fourth hormone, D, then led to delimitation of the oogonia from the oogonial initials. Following the work of Raper and Haagen-Smit (1942), hormone A was isolated from culture filtrates and partly characterized by McMorris and Barksdale (1967) who named it antheridiol. Its structure was elucidated by Arsenault et al. (1968), and confirmed by synthesis (Edwards et al., 1969, 1972; Fig. 7, I and 11). 23-Deoxyantheridiol (Fig. 7, I and VI) was also found in culture filtrates of female plants (Green et al., 1971). Antheridiol is active towards species of Achlya and Thraustotheca, but it is not active towards Allomyces and Dictyuchus (A. W. Barksdale, personal communication). Antheridiol is taken up by both male and female plants of Achlya spp., but only male plants react to it (Barksdale and Lasure, 1973). The primary morphological effect of antheridiol on the male plant is to induce branching within the space of two hours or so. Other compounds can also induce branching, but it is only antheridiol-induced branches which can develop into antheridia. In media containing a high concentration of nitrogenous nutrients, however, the antheridiol-induced branches may become vegetative (Barksdale, 1970). The branches are attracted to polystyrene balls soaked in antheridiol, and antheridia are delimited by the hyphae in
150
CHARLES
* +$
G. ELLIOlT
I
* yl-$
0
0
I1
111
V 0
0 IV
VI
CH,OH
(CHJ,CHCOO VI I FIG. 7 . Formulae of antheridiol and its isomers. I, ring system; 11, the 22s 2SR side chain of antheridiol; 111, the 22s 23s side chain; IV, the 22R 23s side chain; V, the 22R 23R side chain; VI, the side chain of 23-deoxyantheridiol. VII, structure of oogoniol- 1 .
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
151
contact with the balls; thus it appears that the functions of hormone C, postulated by Raper, are fulfilled by antheridiol (Barksdale, 1963). While branching is the first visible result of antheridiol treatment of a male plant, this is of course the consequence of a number of processes at a molecular level. Kane et al. (1973) and Horowitz and Russell ( 1974) showed that the antheridiol-induced branching is inhibited by actinomycin D, and thus depends on RNA synthesis. Silver and Horgen ( 1974) reported that antheridiol treatment induced accumulation over an 8-h period of a species of RNA rich in adenylic acid, presumably messenger-RNA; addition of actinomycin D or cordycepin inhibited its accumulation. Cordycepin (3’-deoxyadenosine) inhibits the addition of polyadenylic acid to RNA and conversion of heterogenous nuclear-RNA to messenger-RNA (Darnel et al., 197 1). Thomas and Mullins (1967, 1969) found that the level of cellulase in cells rose following antheridiol treatment, reaching a maximum in two hours. Cellulase production, as well as branching, was inhibited by puromycin and p-fluorophenylalanine. Mullins and Ellis ( 1974) reported that antheridiol treatment brought about accumulation of vesicles at the points where branches were formed; such vesicles contain cellulase (Nolan and Bal, 1974). Thus antheridiol has similar properties to the more extensively studied steroid hormones of mammals and insects, in that it stimulates production of RNA and protein and induces a series of specific morphogenetic events. The principal sterols of Achlya bisexualis are fucosterol, 24methylenecholesterol, 7 -dehydrofucosterol and cholesterol ( Popplestone and Unrau, 1973). 7-Dehydrofucosterol and fucosterol can be converted to antheridiol by the fungus (Popplestone and Unrau, 1975). Antheridiol and its C-22 and C-23 isomers have been synthesized and it was shown that the configuration of the side chain profoundly affects the activity of the compound (Barksdale et al., 1974). The 22s 23R compound (antheridiol; Fig. 7, I and 11) is active at a concentration of 6 pg/ml, but the 22R 23s ( I and IV) and 22s 23s ( I and 111) compounds have less than one thousandth of the activity of antheridiol (active at 20 ng/ml) and the 22R 23R (I and V) compound has even less activity (active at 400 ng/ml). 7 -Deoxy- 7 -dihydro-antheridiol is active at 0.11 ng/mg. Replacement of the 22-hydroxyl group of 7-deoxy-7dihydro-antheridiol acetate by an 0x0 group decreases its activity to about one-fiftieth (Barksdale et al., 1974). 23-Dehydro-antheriodiol
152
CHARLES G. E L L I O l l
(Fig. 7, I and VI) (found in culture solutions) has no activity at 28 ng/ml (Green et al., 197 1). Various male and hermaphroditic strains of Achlya spp. (and one weak female strain) have been found to convert antheridiol to a more polar compound, metabolite A, and in some strains to a second metabolite B. Production of metabolite A is inhibited by actinomycin D and cycloheximide. Evidently an enzyme is produced which destroys the hormone. Neither metabolite is identical with hormone B (Musgrave and Nieuwenhuis, 1975). Hormone B is produced by male strains of A . ambisexualis when stimulated by antheridiol, and it induces formation of oogonia in the female plant. Male plants respond to antheridiol, female plants to hormone B. Hermaphroditic strains of A . heterosexualis produce hormone B without the necessity for stimulation by antheridiol. Such strains also react to both antheridiol and hormone B, which is the basis of their hermaphroditic behaviour (Barksdale and Lasure, 1973). However, it was found that treatment of strain 8-6 of A . heterosexualis with antheridiol greatly stimulates its production of hormone B. 7-Deoxy7 -dihydro-antheridiol also stimulates production of hormone B, but the 22R 23s isomer of antheridiol, and fucosterol, are inactive (Barksdale and Lasure, 1974). The structure of three compounds having hormone B activity, named oogoniol-1, -2 and -3, has recently been described by McMorris et al. (1975). They are C,, steroids, but differ from antheridiol in not having a lactone ring in the side chain, and in being esterified at C-3 (Fig. 7, VII). While hormones A and B control the formation of the male and female organs-antheridia and oogonia-respectively, their conjugation is controlled by a third hormone, the delimiting hormone. A. W. Barksdale (personal communication) believes this hormone D is produced by antheridial branches and acts on both antheridia and oogonia. VIII. Effects of Sterols on Sexual Reproduction in Homothallic Species of Pythiwn and Phytophthoru
The most striking effects of adding sterols to cultures of Pythium and Phytophthora are the ensuing morphogenetic changes. In Phytophthoru cactorum, the outer parts of the colony first become much more extensively branched. Gametangia (oogonia and antheridia) are then produced on these branches and subsequently the oospores develop inside the oogonia.
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
153
The structure of sterols in relation to their activity in effecting reproduction has been extensively studied (Haskins et al., 1964; Elliott et al., 1966; Elliott, 1972b).The results with P. cactorum (Elliott, 1972b, and unpublished work) are as follows. The most active are the C,, plant sterols, which have an ethyl group with the a-configuration at C-24 of the side chain (sitosterol; Figs. 2 and 3, IV G, p. 124) and stigmasterol (IV HI) or a 24-ethylidene group (fucosterol (IV J) and avenasterol). The C,, sterols have much lower activity, i.e. fewer oospores are produced with the same sterol concentration. The C,, sterols (24methyl) are intermediate in their effect. The configuration of the 24methyl group is important, the a configuration conferring greater activity than the p ; thus campesterol (IV C) is more active than A’-ergosterol (IV D), and stigmasterol (IV H) than poriferasterol (IV K)at all concentrations. A double bond in the B ring is essential; cholestanol (111A) is much less active than cholesterol (IV A), and ergostanol (I11D) than A5-ergostenol (IV D). However, A’-cholestenol (V A) and 7dehydrocholesterol (VI A) gave more oospores at high concentrations and fewer at low concentrations than cholesterol (IV A), and the same holds for A’-stigmastenol (V G) and 7-dehydrositosterol (VI G) as compared with sitosterol (IV G). The double bond at C-22 does not appear to have any significant effect as indicated by equal activity of A5-ergostenol (IV D) and brassicasterol (IV E), and of sitosterol (IV G ) and stigmasterol (IV H). Defago et al. (1969) reported that polyene antibiotics could induce oospore formation in Pythium acanthium in the absence of sterols. Hendrix and Gutman (1968, 1969) found oestradiol inhibited production of oospores by cholesterol or sitosterol in six strains of Pythium; there was no significant effect with two other pythia or with Phytophthora cactorum. In most, but not all, cases, oestradiol decreased vegetative growth (colony diameter), but reproduction was inhibited at lower concentrations of oestradiol than was growth rate. Inhibition of oospore formation by oestradiol could be reversed by increasing the concentration of cholesterol or sitosterol, but to a different extent in various fungi. The 17p-hydroxyl group is important in this interference; 17a-oestradiol and 17p-oestradiol-17-acetate are not inhibitory, although 17p-oestradiol-3-acetate is (Hendrix and Guttman, 1972). The sterol side chain occupies the 17s position. Experiments on the effect of C,,, C,, and C,, steroids on the permeability of liposomes were reported by Bangham et al. ( 1965), Sessa and Weissmann (1968) and Heap et al. (1970). The synthetic oestrogen,
154
CHARLES G. ELLIOlT
diethylstilbestrol, also inhibits oospore production in P. cactorum ( G .A. Bean and C. G. Elliott, unpublished results). The most notable point about the relative activities of various sterols in promoting oospore production in P. cactorum is that they bear little relationship to their effects on structural stabilization and permeability of lipid films and cell membranes. Thus, in the latter systems, AZ2sterols generally have different effects from those with saturated side chains (e.g. Demel et a/., 1972a, b; Rottem et a/., 1971; Hossack and Rose, 19761, and cholestanol (and sometimes sitosterol also) is generally equivalent to cholesterol. Thus it would seem that the effect on reproduction cannot be simply one on permeability of membranes. It may be, of course, that the composition of higher-plant membranes is such that the rules for the effects of sterols on simple lecithin films and animal membranes do not apply, but Grunwald’s (1968, 197 1) results suggest this is not so.Perhaps the degree of leakiness obtained with the C,, sterols is required for the deposition of the cellulose walls of higher plants and of the oomycetes. Phytophthora species too, being higher-plant pathogens, have access to the predominantly C,, sterols of higher plants. But the evident importance of the C-24 ethyl or methyl group and of its a configuration suggest that this structure has in itself a particular metabolic significance. Thus, it could be that C-29 is involved in the formation of a structure similar to the lactone ring in the side chain of antheridiol. Antheridiol biosynthesis involves oxidation of C-29 of fucosterol to form a carboxyl group. I t is therefore perhaps highly relevant to sexual reproduction that species of Pythium and Phytophthora metabolize cholesterol and sitosterol to more polar compounds (Hendrix et al., 1970; Elliott and Knights, 1974; Hendrix, 1975a, b) although Hendrix (1975b) could find no relationship between sterol metabolism and reproduction; the polar metabolite was formed both by species which produced oospores under the experimental conditions and by those which did not (i.e. heterothallic species in single culture). Polar metabolites are produced from cholesterol and sitosterol supplied to species of Pythium and Phytophthora but not to Achlya bisexualis or A. ambisexualis (Hendrix, 1975a). The metabolite described by Hendrix is slightly more polar than kryptogenin (Fig. 8; Hendrix, 1975a). Heftmann (1971) goes so far as to speak of all A5-sterols being “metabolized to the same hormone”.
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
155
The low activity of cholestanol is particularly interesting as, although few oospores are formed, the number of oogonia produced is as high as with cholesterol, but most of them abort (Elliott, 1968, 1972b). Abortive oogonia are also produced with cholestanol by Pythium periplocum and P. prolatum (Hendrix and Guttrnann, 1972)and by Phytophthora dreschleri (G. A. Bean and C. G. Elliott, unpublished observations). It was found (Elliott, 1968)that cholestanol added with cholesterol lowered the number of oospores compared with that produced with cholesterol alone, with “kinetics” resembling competitive inhibition. But this was so only at high concentrations of sterol; at low concentrations, the substances acted synergistically. I considered that these results show that sterols have effects on sexual reproduction during at least two separate stages of development (gametangialformation and conjugation), and that the steric requirements for activity at these stages are different. Such an interpretation is compatible with a hormone-type action, but not with a simple permeability model.
HO FIG. 8. Structure of kryptogenin.
It will not be easy to prove that an endoge.noushormone is involved in regulation of reproduction in these homothallic species. In heterothallic species, there is a much better chance of identifying a hormone produced by one of the interacting strains. Indeed Kouyeas (1953) observed oospore formation in the heterothallic Phytophthora paracitica in one or both members of a mated pair when they were separated by a porous filter. Also, he reported oospore formation by one strain when it was grown in the culture filtrate of the other. However, similar experiments reported by Stamps (19551, Apple (1959)and Brasier (1972) gave negative results. In the Zygomycetes, the hormonal role of trisporic acid was apparent from work with heterothallic species, in which the two strains make characteristic contributions to synthesis of the compound ( Gooday, 197 4). Werkman and Van den Ende ( 197 4) investigated the effects of homothallic species on the precursors of tri-
156
CHARLES G. ELLIOTT
sporic acid, and concluded that the control of sexual development in homothallic species was not essentially different from that in heterothallic forms. IX. Reproduction in Heterothallic Species of Pythium and Phytophtlroru
Before describing reproduction in the Pythiaceae and the little that is known of its control, it would seem desirable to give some account of the system of “relative sexuality” as it exists in Achlya spp. An understanding of the morphological events at mating is essential for an investigation of their chemical control. The various isolates of Achlya ambisexualis and A . bisexualis can be placed in a single series as regards their interactions one with another, ranging from strong male on the one hand to strong female on the other. In an intermediate position are strains which can act as male or female depending upon whether they are paired with an isolate which lies further to the female or male side (Barksdale, 1960). The strains differ in their production and response to antheridiol and hormone B (Barksdale and Lasure, 1973). In pairings between a homothallic and a female heterothallic strain, the homothallic strain produces antheridial branches which interact with oogonia produced on the heterothallic strain. When male strains were paired with homothallic strains, it was not generally possible to say whether any of the oogonia were produced as a result of interstrain interaction, or whether they were all due to self stimulation by the homothallic strain; but in one particular combination, both mature and abortive oogonial initials were induced by the male (Barksdale, 1960). Mating in the heterothallic species Pythium sylvaticum was described by Papa et al. (1967). Isolate 1063-7 was always the male (antheridial) parent, and isolate 1063-8 the female (oogonial)parent. At the boundary between the two strains, the appearance of the male side was “smooth”, and the female “rough” due to penetration of male hyphae some distance into the female culture. Pratt and Green ( 197 1) showed that there were differences in the strength of the sexual response among a large number of isolates; they could be arranged in an approximate gradient. In any one mating, one strain generally behaved as male, one as female. Thus, the situation in Pythium sylvaticum resembles that in Achlya bisexualis; but sexuality in Phytophlhora is more complicated. Heterothallic species of Phytophthora can normally be assigned to one
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
157
or other of two mating types or compatibility groups, namely A1 and A2 (Savage et al., 1968). Mating occurs between an A1 strain and an A2 strain, and not between two A l s or two A2s. Strains reacting with neither tester were isolated by Shepherd and Pratt ( 1973). Within each
of the mating types, differences in sexual potency occur. Galindo and Gallegly ( 1960) grew pairs of strains of P. infestans into opposite sides of a plain agar block and traced the origin of the antheridial and oogonial branches. They found that any one isolate behaved chiefly or entirely as male in some matings, as female in others, and in others the same isolate produced both antheridia and oogonia. In each mating type (A1 and A2), the strains could be arranged in a series, strong male (acting as male to most other strains) to strong female (female to other strains). I t is to be noted that Galindo and Gallegly’s results indicate that all oospores are the result of crossing between the two mating types. Savage et al. (1968) reported that either mating type could produce the antheridia and oogonia in the interspecific crosses P. infestans A1 x P. capsici A2 and P . capsici A1 x P. infestans A2 ; they implied that the phenomenon was a general one. Kouyeas (1953) arranged strains of P . parasitica in a series depending on the strength of their sexual reaction. Oogonium size was characteristic of some strains. Kouyeas (1953) used the distribution of oogonial sizes in crosses to determine the frequency with which each of the interacting strains functioned as female parent. Huguenin (1973) labelled one of the interacting strains of P. palmivora with the fluorescent dye, calcofluor white. According as the oogonium, the antheridium, both or neither were fluorescent, the origin of the antheridia and oogonia could be determined. Three A1 strains (26, K and 570) and two A2 strains (L and 36) were studied. When paired with strain L, 570 formed the oogonial parent in 7 1.5%of pairings, K formed the oogonia in 36.8% of pairings and 26 in 3.1%. When paired with strain 36, K formed the oogonia in 100%of pairings, 570 in 73.0% and 26 in 62.0% of pairings. These relationships are shown diagramatically in Fig. 9. It will be noted that the relative sexual expression of strains K and 570 differs according to the strain they are paired with. In addition, a substantial proportion of self fertilization was observed, particularly of the A2 strain when it carried the fluorochrome. Stamps ( 1953) reported that, in some matings between strains of P. cryptogea and P . cinnamoni, all oospores were hybrids, but in other matings selfing of the qptogea or the cinnamoni partner could occur as well.
CHARLES G. ELLIOlT
158
Brasier (1972)studied the interaction between a number of strains of P . palmivora. He scored the numbers of oospores formed on each side of the line where the two isolates met, and found significant variation between strains in their-mean score, both among the A1 mating-type strains and among the A2s. This indicated a gradient in sexual potency in both mating types, with, one might suppose, decreasing ability of strains to act as female parent, and increasing maleness, along the gradient. Brasier, however, thought that the result of the interstrain A1
9
A2
1
L
6
FIG. 9. Relative sexuality of three A1 strains of Phytophthorapalmiuora when paired with two A2 strains. From Huguenin (1975).
interaction was to make each strain produce selfed oospores. He noted that some strains produced oospores in single culture much more readily than others I$ Stamps, 1953; Apple, 1959)and that the strains which produced the most oospores in paired matings were those which produced the most oospores in single culture. He also found that some strains of each mating type (again those which tended to produce oospores in single culture) produced oospores when grown in combination with the homothallic P. heveae; no interspecific hyphal pairing was detected. I t seems hardly possible to draw a general conclusion from these morphological observations on interstrain pairings. Is the effect of the strains on one another to stimulate one to act as male parent, the other as female in a strict interstrain relationship? Can one strain act as both male and female parent in a cross? To what extent can one strain induce the other to undergo self reproduction? It seems that different species (and different strains of one species) do different things. But genetical evidence should provide more definite evidence on the occurrence and extent of selfing. Sansome (1970)discussed the possibility of selfing to account for the peculiar segregation ratios observed for mating type and other
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
159
characters in P. drechsleri by Galindo and Zentmyer (1967).However, one must ensure that the characters used to evaluate the extent of selfing are suitable. Mating type in P. drechsleri is unsuitable because its inheritance has unusual features, whereas drug resistance showed simple Mendelian inheritance in the same crosses (Khaki and Shaw, 1974). Khaki and Shaw (1974)crossed strains resistant to p-fluorophenylalanine or chloramphenicol with wild type; the resistant F, progeny were crossed with both parents, and F, progeny of different mating type were intercrossed. Segregation in crosses of the F, to the sensitive parent [Rr+(A2)x r+~+(Al), r+being the wild-type drug-sensitive allele and R the resistant mutant] would be sensitive to selfing, which would give rise to deviation from the expected 1 : 1 ratio or to heterogeneity TABLE 3. Segregation for drug resistance in Phytophlhora drechsleri, showing the results of backcrosses of F, (and for mutant C1 of two heterozygous F, cultures) to a sensitive parent. Data of Khaki and Shaw (1974).
Mutant FA 1
c1
C 1(F2) c 2
Total
Resistant
Semitive
68 60 25 18 43 214
51 48 19 25 32 181
between crosses. Khaki and Shaw's (1974)data (Table 3) are homogenous (& = 3.14,P 0.7-0.5)and the totals give ax;,, value of 2.75 (P 0.1-0.05)against the expected 1 : 1. However, there is a fairly consistent excess of resistant offspring. If a proportion p of the resistant parents undergo selfing, the expected proportions, 4 and 4, become 4 + @ and 4- &, and the data give a value for p of 16.7%. Such a hypothesis however is unnecessary. There is no indication of selfing of the heterozygous resistant F, (of the other mating type) in the backcrosses to the resistant parents, as these crosses gave no sensitive offspring. The conclusion then is that all oospores are of hybrid origin, but it would be much more certain if doubly marked strains were available. Khaki and Shaw (1974)collected oospores from the region where the two cultures met (D.S. Shaw, personal communication). It should be noted however that, when the wild-type strains of P. drechsleri (6500A1
160
CHARLES G. ELLIOTT
and 6503 A l l are mated by inoculating them on opposite sides of a petri dish, oospores are found not only where the two cultures meet but throughout much of the A1 culture. Oospores are not formed in either strain grown by -itself under otherwise similar conditions. The effect of sterols on reproduction in heterothallic species have received far too little attention. Child and Haskins (1971) found that addition of cholesterol and a number of other sterols to paired cultures of Pythium sylvaticum and P. catenulatum greatly stimulated oospore production; in the absence of sterols, only a weak mating reaction occurred. They noted that, in these matings, oospores were produced not only where the strains met but also within the area occupied by one of the strains. In a mating between P. sylvaticum 1063-7 and 1063-8, oospores were formed within 1063-7 which Papa et al. ( 1967 had shown functioned as male (antheridium producing) in this mating. Child and Haskins (1971)also found that, when P. sylvaticum 1063-7 was grown by itself with cholesterol in the medium, oospores were produced; this did not occur in the absence of cholesterol, nor did it occur when strain 1063-8 was grown with cholesterol. Similar results were found with single cultures of the P. catenulatum strains, the responsive strain again being that which had the morphology of the male strain. They supposed that sterol regulated promotion of oogonial structures. Thus, a tendency to femaleness was induced in male strains, but maleness was not induced in female strains. One might speculate that the increased sterol supply stimulated the female strain to produce more of a hormone (analogous to antheridiol) which induced the male strain to produce another hormone (like hormone B) to which both it and the female strain responded by producing oogonia. Cholesterol could also directly stimulate production of hormone by the male strain, leading to selfing. Pratt and Mitchell (1973)investigated the effect of cholesterol on matings of Pythium sylvaticum and Phytophthora capsici. The strains were inoculated singly into medium with or without cholesterol ( 10 mg/l), and allowed to grow into opposite sides of plain agar blocks between the two nutrient media. With the Pythium isolates, addition of cholesterol to the male culture only had little effect, but a great increase in the number of oospores maturing in the plan agar block was observed when cholesterol was added to the female cultures, and a still greater stimulation occurred when it was added to both. This result is compatible with Child and Haskins’s (1971)results if the effect of
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
161
cholesterol is to stimulate the female strains to produce an antheridiollike hormone. With Phytophthora capsici, Pratt and Mitchell ( 1973)found that the number of oospores formed was greatly increased by adding cholesterol to the A1 strain, more still by adding it to the A2 strain, and most of all when added to both. They suggested that addition of cholesterol to only one strain led to increased oospore production because either strain might function as both male and female. Their interpretation was that the effect of cholesterol on oospore development relates to the amount present in the gametangial initials, supposing that a large amount occurred in the larger oogonium, a small amount only in the smaller antheridium. In conclusion, the results with Pythium species seem to be fairly easily interpreted in terms of a hormonal system similar to that in Achlya spp. In the heterothallic phytophthoras, there is a separation of strains into two mating types, within each of which there is a gradation from strong males to strong females. The mating-type system, which seems to be superimposed on the relative sexuality system, is in some ways similar to the mating-type system in the heterothallic ascomycetes such as Neurospora crmsa, but it is not such an effective barrier to self fertilization as obtains in N . crassa. Although much more work needs to be done, one can make the general hypothesis that the interaction of strains of different mating type results in crossing along the line where the two cultures meet, and the interstrain reaction may stimulate selfing in one or both of the partners further back from the junction. One can hardly doubt that such a system is hormonally controlled. An interesting point is that A2, but not Al, cultures of Phytophthoru spp. can be induced to form oospores by volatile metabolites of Trichoderma spp. (Brasier, 197 1, 1975; Pratt et al., 1972). More recently, it has been reported that oospores can be induced to form in A2 cultures (but not A l ) by treatment with the fungicide chloroneb (Noon and Hickman, 1974) and even simply by cutting the hyphae with a scalpel (Reeves and Jackson, 1974). It thus seems that a variety of agents, perhaps relatively non-specific, can overcome the barrier to self compatibility in A2 strains, whereas with A1 strains this is not so. Damage to A2 hyphae of a kind to induce branching is, maybe, the stimulus to oogonium formation. But stimulation of A1 strains is only possible by A2 strains. The natural interaction of strains must be specific. Further genetical evidence is needed to clarify the extent of crossing and selfing.
162
CHARLES G. ELLIOlT
X. Sterols and Sexual Reproduction in Ascomycetes and Basidiomycetes The clearest evidence for involvement of sterols in reproduction in ascomycetes is in the work of Nelson et ul. (1967) on Cochliobolus curbonum. Perithecia of this fungus are produced in culture by inoculating two compatible mating types on opposite sides of a strip of sterilized senescent maize leaf lying on the surface of Sach’s agar (Nelson, 197 1). When SKF 3301-A, a compound known to inhibit sterol synthesis in other organisms, was added four days after mating, perithecial development was inhibited by appropriate concentrations of the drug. Its addition seven days after mating impaired ascus development, and at 11 days ascospore formation was affected. At the same time, vegetative growth and conidium formation (normally sparse in this kind of experiment) were greatly increased. Chromatographic differences in the non-saponifiable extract of matings with and without SKF 3301-A were noted. The inhibition of development was prevented by adding squalene, sitosterol, ergosterol, cholesterol or cholestanol. According to Holmes and Di Tullio (19621, SKF 3301-A inhibits sterol synthesis at a stage between mevalonic acid and squalene. Mating is not successful if the two strains of Cochliobolus are paired on filter paper lying on Sach’s agar, but Fries and Nelson (1972) found that a chloroform-methanol extract of maize leaves would stimulate perithecial development if applied to the filter paper at any time prior to perithecial initiation; addition of a water extract of the leaves also further stimulated perithecial production. Sterols from the chloroform-methanol extract were effective, but not as effective as the crude extract; fatty acids from the saponified extract had no effect. When sterols were added to matings on filter paper, perithecia were produced, provided that zinc was also added (Nelson, 1971). The effects of inhibitors of sterol synthesis were investigated in Sorduriujmicolu (Elliott, 1969). In medium containing SKF 3301-A, there was an abrupt change in hyphal growth rate when the colony had covered about half the petri dish, and where this change occurred a ring of perithecia developed ; subsequently perithecia were produced in concentric rings. Except at the highest concentrations tested, perithecial production exceeded that in the drug-fiee controls. O n the other hand, a different compound, AY9944, inhibited perithecium formation at concentrations which had little effect on hyphal growth rate.
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
163
This compound inhibits saturation of the double bond at C-7 in animal material (Chappel et al., 1964; Horlick, 1966) and in high concentration it also inhibits reduction of A'* (Lutsky et al., 1975). In the alga Chlorellu ellipsoidea it inhibits conversion of A* to A7 in the sterol molecule as well as reduction of A14 and insertion of Azz (Dickson and Patterson, 1972). However, it is not possible to say whether the effect on reproduction in Sordariufimicola is related to any effect on sterol synthesis; there was no evidence of annulment of the inhibition by cholesterol (Elliott, 19691, but it seems unlikely that the cholesterol added was sufficiently taken up by the fungus. Zearalenone (Fig. 101, a metabolite of Gibberella zeae (Fusariumroseum) which has oestrogenic properties in animals (see Mirocha and Christensen, 1974), was found to affect sexual reproduction in some 39 ascomycetes and also several species of Pythium and Phytophthoru (Nelson, 1971). Nelson (1971) studied particularly the effect on Cochliobolus curbonum, and found it to stimulate perithecial production at concentrations of 0.01 to 1.Opg per culture. It was most effective when applied just prior to the time the sexual process was initiated, and its stimulatory abilities were quantitatively affected by the time of application. Higher concentrations (10 pg or more per mating) decreased the number of perithecia formed. Concentrations of the
Go I
HO
\
HO
0& O H
0 I1
I11
FIG. 10. Structural formulae of oestrone (I) and alternative ways of presenting the structural formula of zearalenone (11 and 111).
164
CHARLES G . ELLIOlT
compound which stimulated sexual development had no effect on vegetative growth. These points suggest that zearalenone is serving as a hormone-type regulato-r. Wolf and Mirocha ( 1973) showed that zearalenone affects reproduction in Gibberella zeae, the fungus which produces it, the exogenous compound augmenting the effect of that produced endogenously. Synthesis of zearalenone by G. zeae was inhibited by “Dichlorvos”, which also inhibits perithecial production; this effect was annulled by zearalenone (Wolf et al., 1972; Wolf and Mirocha, 1973). It seems highly significant that an oestrogen should have a hormone-like effect on reproduction. The sterols which affect reproduction in Cochliobolus carbonum could be metabolized to smaller molecules with hormonal effects, just as in animals. Various ascomycetes and Fungi Imperfecti have remarkable abilities to transform steroids (Charney and Hertzog, 1967). Such faculties would be meaningless if they were not required for the fungus’s own metabolism. My colleagues and I are approaching the question of involvement of sterols in reproduction by examining sterile mutants of Neurospora crassa (Elliott et al., 1974). We suppose that, if it were possible that sterility resulted from altered sterol metabolism, qualitative or quantitative differences in sterol content as compared with the fertile wild type might be detectable. Yanagishima ( 1969) reported that Saccharomyces cerevisiae secretes hormones which cause swelling of cells of opposite mating type. It was also reported that testosterone causes swelling of cells of the a but not the a mating type and that oestradiol causes swelling of a but not a (Yanagishima et ul., 1970). The yeast hormones were considered to be steroids (Takao et al., 1970), but the a hormone was subsequently identified as n-octanoic acid (Sakurari et al., 1974). On the other hand, a factor produced by a cells which causes elongation of a cells (Duntze et al., 1970) and which inhibits DNA synthesis in them (Throm and Duntze, 1970; Bucking-Throm et al., 1973) is a peptide of molecular weight of between one and two thousand daltons (Duntze et al., 1973). The sterols of Coprinus lagopus were studied by Defago et al. (1971). They found that monokaryotic and vegetative dikaryotic mycelium, whether grown in shaken or static culture, contained mostly A59’ergostadienol (50 to 70 times as much as of ergosterol), but that the fruiting bodies contained about equal quantities of these two
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
165
sterols. In shake cultures, sterol synthesis continued for a longer period, and the sterol content reached a higher value per culture, than in static cultures. However, in shake culture, the amount of sterol per unit weight decreased between the third and ninth days and then rose; the primordia of the fruiting bodies appeared at about 15 days. In static culture, the sterol content per unit weight increased between two and six days, and fruiting bodies were then initiated; the sterol content of the mycelium then declined. In this study, the sterol was recovered only by one method, that is by extraction of the non-saponifiable material. Holtz and Schisler (197 1, 1972) did not detect any sterol in the vegetative mycelium of Agaricus bisporus, but free sterols (ergosterol, A5n7ergostadienol and A7-ergostenol) were found in fruit bodies. Sterols were, however, found in both vegetative mycelium and fruit bodies by Byrne and Brennan (1975). XI. Conclusions
Work on model membranes, and on the homone system of Achlya spp., have together provided a framework with which we can interpret the effects of sterols on growth and development in species of Pythium and Phytophthora. We have reached the stage where we can formulate hypotheses and test them. More work needs to be done with model systems on the C,, arid C,, sterols but, as far as the information goes, it is clear that stigmasterol lowers permeability less than cholesterol in such membranes. These sterols appear to have different effects on vegetative growth of Phytophthora in25tans (Langcake, 1974, 1975).With more information of this kind, we could see how their effects are correlated with the results with the models. In particular, we need information on the permeability of fungal membranes; work with yeast protoplasts shows the way in which this might be carried out. As regards sexual reproduction, the comparison of cholestanol and cholesterol in P. cactorum indicates that sterols have separate effects on reproduction at oogonium formation and at conjugation, which is readily comprehensible on the basis of a hormonal system like that in Achlya spp., but not if reproduction depended primarily on permeability of membranes. There is obviously a great deal to be clarified about reproduction in the heterothallic Pythium and Phytophthora; what we do know enables us to formulate a hypothesis on lines similar to those for Achlya.
166
CHARLES G. ELLlOlT
The role which sterols play in controlling reproduction in ascomycetes is not yet clear. The work with zearalenone suggests that any steroid hormone which might be involved is more likely to be a small molecule (CI9or C,,),not a true sterol. The importance of sterols as essential structural components of membranes, and their consequent importance in efficient metabolism, are well established in yeast, but their precise functions are still hardly understood. In the zygomycetes, control of reproduction by trisporic acid is well understood (Gooday, 1974). The precise function of sterols here is unknown. Bu'Lock and Osagie ( 1973) observed an increased ergosterol content in mated, as compared with single, cultures of Blukesleu tn'sporu, but this could be attributed merely to the autocatalytic stimulation of isopentenoid synthesis by trisporic acid. In the basidiomycetes, consideration of the problem of sterol function has hardly begun. XII. Acknowledgements It is a pleasure to acknowledge my indebtedness to my colleague Dr. Brian A. Knights for advice on many points of chemistry mentioned in this review, and also because it is his collaboration which has made possible the work on sterols with Phytophthoru and Neurosporu done in this Department. Much of this work has been supported by grants from the Science Research Council. I am also grateful to Professor A. H. Rose for his comments on the draft of this review. REFERENCES
Adams, B. G . and Parks, L. Adanis, B. G. and Parks, L. Adams, B. G . and Parks, L. Alais. J., Lablache-Conibier,
W. W. W. A.,
(1967). Journal ofCell Physiology 70, 161. (1968). Journal $Lipid Research 9, 8 . (1969). Journal ofBacteriology 100, 370. Lacoste, L. and Vandewalle, B. (1974). Phytochernistry
13, 2833.
Andreasen, A. A. and Stier, T. J. B. (1953).Journal ofCellular and Comparative Physiology 41, 23.
Andrrascn, A. A. and Stier, T. J. B. (1954).Journal ofCellular and Comparative Physiology 43, 271.
Applr. J . L. (1959). fh.vtopathology 49, 37. Arsrnault, G . P., Bieniann, K., Barksdale, A. W. and McMorris, T. C. (1968). Journal / h i Amrriran Chrinicnl Society 90, 5635. Ashburncr. M. (1970). Advances in Insect Physiology 7 , 1. Arallah. A. M . and Nicholas, H. J. (1974). Lipids 9, 613. Bailey R. B. and Parks, L. W. (1975). Journal of BacterioloRy 124, 606.
of
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
167
Bangham, A. D., Standish, M. M. and Weissmann, G.(1965).JournalofMolecular Biology 13, 253. Baniecki, J. F. and Bloss, H. E. (1969).Phytopathology 59, 680. Bard, M. (1972).Journal of Bacteriology 111, 649. Bard, M.,Woods, R. A. and Haslam, J. M. (1974).Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 56, 324. Barksdale, A. W. (1960).American Journal of Botany 47, 14. Barksdale, A. W. (1963).Mycologia 55, 627. Barksdale, A. W. (1970).Mycologia 62, 411. Barksdale, A. W. and Lasure, L. L. (1973).Bulletin ofthe Torrey Botanical Club 100, 199. Barksdale, A. W. and Lasure, L. L. (1974).Applied Microbiology 28, 544. Barksdale, A. W., McMorris, T. C., Seshadri, R., Arunachalam, T., Edwards, J. A., Sundeen, J. and Green, D. M. (1974).Journal of General Microbiology 82, 295. Barr, R. M. and Hemming, F. W. (1972).Biochemical Journal 126, 1193. Bartlett, K. and Mercer, E. I. (1974).Phytochemistry 13, 1115. Bartnicki-Garcia, S. (1973).Symposium of the Society for General Microbiology 23, 245. Barton, D. H. R., Corrie, J. E. T., Widdowson, D. A., Bard, M. and Woods, R. A. (1974).Journal of the Chemical Society, Perhin Transactions I, 1326. Barton, D. H. R., Gunatilaka, A. A. L., Jarman, T. R., Widdowson, D. A., Bard, M. and Woods, R. A. (1975).Journal ofthe Chemical Society, Perhin Transactions I, 8 8 . Bean, G. A. (1973).Advances in Lipid Research 11, 193. Bean, G. A., Patterson, G. W. and Motta, J. J. (1972).Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 43B, 935. Brasier, C. M. (1971).Nature New Biology 231, 283. Brasier, C. M. (1972).Transactions of the British Mycological Society 58, 237. Brasier, C. M. (1975).New Phytologist 74, 183. Brockerhoff, H. (1974).Lipids 9, 645. Bruckdorfer, K. R., Demel, R. A,, d e Gier, J. and Van Deenen, L. L. M. (1969). Biochimica el Biophysica Acta 183, 334. Bruckdorfer, K. R., Edwards, P. A., and Green, C. (1968a).European Journal of Biochemistry 4, 506. Bruckdorfer, K. R., Graham, J. M. and Green, C. (196813).European J o u m l ofBiochemistry 4, 512. Brushaber, J. A., Child, J. J. and Haskins, R. H. (1972).CanadianJournal $Microbiology 18, 1059. Bucking-Throm, E., Duntze, W., Hartwell, L. H . and Manney, T. R. (1973).Experimenla1 Cell Research 7 6 , 99. Bu’Lock, J. D. and Osagie, A. U. (1973).Journal of General Microbiology 76, 77. Butler, K. W., Smith, I . C. P. and Schneider, H. (1970).Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 219, 5 14. Byrne, P. F. S. and Brennan, P. J. (1975).Journal $General Microbiology 89, 245. Chapman, D., Owens, N. F., Phillips, M. C. and Walker, D. A. (1969).Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 183, 458. Chappel, C., Dubuc, J., Dvornik, D., Givner, M., Humber, L., Kraml, M., Voith, K. and Gaudry, R. (1964).Nature, London 201, 497. Charney, W. and Herzog, H. L. (1967).“Microbial Transformations of Steroids: a Handbook”. Academic Press, New York. Chee, K. H. and Turner, N. A. (1965).New ZealandJoumlof Ap’culturalResearch 8, 104. Child, J. J., Dcfago, G. and Haskins, R. H. (1969).Canadian Journal ofMicrobiology 15, 599.
168
CHARLES G. ELLIOTT
Child, J . J . and Haskins, R. H. (1971).Canadian Journal $Botany 49, 329. Conner, R. L., Mallory, F. B., Landrey, J. R. and Iyengar, C. W. L. (1969). Journal o f Biologral Chemistry 244, 2325. Darke, A., Finer, E. G., Flook, A. G. and Phillips, M. C. (1972).Journal ofMolecular Biology 63, 265. Darnell, J . E., Philipson, L., Wall, R. and Adesnik, M. (1971).Science, New York 174, 507. Dklago, G., Child, J. J. and Haskins, R. H. (1969).Canadian Journal ofMicrobiology 15, 509. Dklago, G., Fazeli, A. and Schweizer, H. (1971).Zentralblatt f u r Bacteriologie, Pnra.si(rnkzrnde. Infeektionskrankheiten und Hygiene, Abteilung 2, 126, 1. Dkfago, G. and Kern, H. (1975).Phytopathologische Zeitschrii 84, 34. Dklago, G., Memmen, K. F. and Kern, H. (1975).Phytopathologische Zeitschrii 83, 167. De Gier, J., Mandersloot, J . G. and Van Deenen, L. L. M. (1968).Biochimica et Biophysica Actn 150, 666. De Kruyll; B., De Greef, W. J., Van Eyk, R. W. V., Demel, R. A. and Van Deenen, L. L. M. (1973).Biochimica el Biophysica Acta 298, 279. Dr Kruvll; B., Demel, R. A. and Van Deenen, L. L. M. (1972).Biochimica et Biophysica Actn 255, 33 1. Demel, R. A., Bruckforfer, K. R. and Van Deenen, L. L. M. (1972a).Biochimica et Bioph?.cirn Actn 255, 3 11. Denid. R. A., Bruckforfer, K. R. and Van Deenen, L. L. M. (1972b).Biochimica et Biophvrira Actn 255, 32 1. Demel, R. A., Kinsky, S. C., Kinsky, C. B. and Van Deenen, L. L. M. (1968).Biochimica el Biophy.sicn A d a 150, 655. Dernel, R. A.. Van Deenen, L. L. M. and Pethica, B. A. (1967).Biochimica et Biophysica Arla 135, 11. Dirkson, L. G. and Patterson, G. W. (1972).Lipids 7, 635. Dod, B. J . and Gray, B. M. (1968).Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 150, 397. Duntm, W., MacKav, V.and Manney, T. R. (1970).Science, New Yorek 168, 1472. Duntze, W., Stotzler, D., Bucking-Throm, E. and Kalbitzer, S. (1973).European Journal 01 Biochemi.ttry 35, 357. Dupkron, R., Brillard, M. and Dupkron, P. (1972). Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaire des Sbnnre.r de 1’Acnd;mie des Sciences, Paris 274D. 2321. Dupkron, R., Dupkron, P. and Thiersault, M. ( 197 I ) . Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaire des Sbnnrrs de lilcndbmie des Sciences, Paris 273D,580. Edward, D. G . ff. and Fitzgerald, W. A. (1951).Journal of General Microbiology 5, 576. Edwards, J . A., Mills, J. S. Sundeen, J. and Fried, J. H. (1969).Journal ofthe American Chrmiral Societ? 91, 1248. Edwards, J . A., Sundeen, J.. Salmond, W., Iwadare, T. and Fried, J. H. (1972). 7’e/mhrdrorr Letters, 79 1. Edwards, P. A. and Green, C. (1972).Federation o f European Biochemical Societies Letters 20, 97. Elliott, C. G. (1968).Journal of General Microbiology 51, 137. Elliott, C. G. (1969).Journal of General Microbiology 56, 331. Elliott, C. G. (1972a).Transactions of the British Mycological Society 58, 169. Elliott. C. G. (197%). Journal of General Microbiology 72, 321. Elliott, C. G.. Hendrie, M. R. and Knights, B. A. (1966). Journal $General Microbiology 42. 425.
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
169
Elliott, C. G., Hendrie, M. R., Knights, B. A. and Parker, W. (1964). Nature, London 203, 427.
Elliott, C. G . and Knights, B. A. (1969).Journal ofthe Science ofFood and Ap’culture 20, 406. Elliott, C . G. and Knights, B. A. (1974). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 360, 78. Elliott, C. G., Knights, B. A. and Freeland, J. A. (1974). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta360, 339. Esposito, M. S . , Esposito, R. E., Arnaud, M. and Hahorson, H. 0. (1969). Journal of Burltriology 100, 180. Feinstein, M. B., Fernandez, S . M. and Sha’afi, R. I. (1975). Biochimica el Biophysica Acla 413, 354. Finean, J . B. (1953). Experientia 9, 17. Finkelstein, A. and Cass, A. (1967). Nature, London 216, 717. Fries, E. R. and Nelson, R. R. (1972). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 18, 199. Fryberg, M., Oehlschlager, A. C. and Unrau, A. M. (1974). Archives ofBiochem’stry and Biophysics 160, 83. Gain, R. E. (1972). Mycologia 64, 198. Gale, E. F. (1974). Journal of General Microbiology 80, 451. Galindo, A. J. and Gallegly, M. E. (1960). Phytopathology 50, 123. Galindo, A. J. and Zentmyer, G. A. (1967). Phytopathology 57, 1300. Gershfdd, N. L., Wormser, M. and Razin, S. (1974). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 352, 371. Glover, J . and Morton, R. A. (1958). British Medical Bulletin 14, 226. Gollub, E. G., Trocha, P., Liu, P. K. and Sprinson, D. B. (1974). Biochemical and Biophysiral RPsearch Communications 56, 47 1. Gooday, G . W. (1974). Annual Review of Biochemistry 43, 35. Goodwin, T. W. (1973). In “Lipids and Biomembranes of Eukaryotic Microorganisms”, (J. A. Erwin, ed.), pp. 1-40. Academic Press, New York. Gottlieb, D., Carter, H. E., Wu, L. and Sloneker, J. H. (1960). Phytopathology 50, 594. Grant, J. K. (1969). Essays in Biochemistry 5, 1. Green, D. M., Edwards, J. A., Barksdale, A. W. and McMorris, T. C. (1971). Tetrahedron 27, 1199. Grindle, M. (1973). Molecular and General Genetics 120, 283. Grunwald, C. (1968). Plant Physiology 43, 484. Grunwald, C. (197 1). Plant Physiology 48, 653. Hallermeyer, G. and Neupert, W. (1974). Hoppe-Seyler’s Zeilschnift fur PhysiologiJche Chemie 355, 279. Harnish, W. N., Berg, L. A. and Lilly, V. G. (1964). Phytopathology 54, 895. Hartman, R. E. and Holmlund, C. E. (1962). Journal ofBacteriology 84, 1254. Haskins, R. H. (1965). Science, New York 150, 1615. Haskins, R. H., Tulloch, A. P. and Micetich, R. G. (1964). Canadian Journal of Mirrobiolom 10, 187. Heap, R. B.-,-Symonds, A. M. and Watkins, J. C. (1970). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 218, 482. Hebb, C. R. and Slebodnik, J. (1958). Experimental Cell Research 14, 286. Heftmann, E. ( 1970). “Steroid Biochemistry”, Academic Press, New York. Heftmann, E. (1971). Lipids 6, 128. Hendrix, J. W. (1964). Science, New York 144, 1028. Hendrix. J. W. (1965). Phytopathology 55, 790. Hendrix, J. W. (1966). Mycologia 58, 307.
170
CHARLES G. ELLIOTT
Hendrix, J. W. (1967). Mycologia 59, 1107. Hendrix, J. W. (1970). Annual Review of Phytopathology 8, 111. Hendrix. J . W. (1975a). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 21, 735. Hendrix, J . W. (1975b). Mycologia 67. 663. Hendrix, J. W.. Bennett, R. D. and Heftmann, E. (1970). Microbios 5, 11. Hendrix, J . W. and Guttinan, S.-M. (1968). Science, New Yor& 161, 1252. Hcndrix, J . W. and Guttman, S.-M. (1969). Microbios 2, 137. Heridrix, J . W. and Guttman, S.-M. (1972). Phytopathology 62, 763. Henry, S. A. and Halvorsen, H . 0. (1973).Journal ofBacten’ology 114, 1158. Hoch, H. C. and Maxwell, D. P. (1974). Canadian Journal ofhficrobiology 20, 1029. Holmes, W. L. and Di Tullio, N. W. (1962). AmericanJournalofClinical Nutrition 10,310. Hohl, H. R. (1975). Phytopathologische Zeitschntt 84, 18. Holtz, R. B. a d Schisler, L. C. (1971). Lipids 6, 176. Holtz, R. B. a d Schisler, L. C. (1972). Lipids 7, 251. Horlick, L. ( 1966). Journal of Lipid Research 7, 116. Horowitz, D. K. and Russell, P. J. (1974). Canadian J o u d of Microbiology 20, 977. Hossack, J. A. and Rose, A. H. (1976).J o u m l of Bateriology 127,67. Hossack, J . A., Wheeler, G. E. and Rose, A. H. (1973). In “Yeast, Mould and Plant Protoplasts”, (J. R. Villaneuva, I. Garcia-Acha, S . Gascon and F. Uruburu, eds.), pp. 2 1 1-227. Academic Press, New York. Hsia, J . C. and Boggs, J. M. (1972). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 266, 18. Huang, L. and Haug, A. (1974). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 352, 361. Hugueniii, B. (1973). Cuhiers de l’O@ce de la Recherche ScientiFque et Technique Outre-mer, ririr Biologit- 20, 59. llling\h.orth, R. F., Rose, A. H. and Beckett, A. (1973).Journal oflaten’ology 113, 373. Jackson, L. L. and Frear, D. S. (1968). Phytochemistry 7, 651. Jensen, E. V. and De Sombre, E. R. (1972). Annual Review OfBichemistry 41, 203. Kane, B. E., Reiskind, J. B. and Mullins, J. T. (1973). Science, New York 180, 1192. Kaosiri, T. and Hendrix, J. W. (1972). C a n u d i a n J o u d ofBotmy 50, 891. Karst, F. and Lacroute, F. (1973). Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 52. 741.
Karst, F. and Lacroute, F. (1974). Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communicutions 59, 370.
Kato, T., Tanaka, S., Ueda, M. and Kawase, Y. (1974). Agricultural and Biological Chemislry 38, 23 7 7. Kato, T., Tanaka, S . , Ueda, M. and Kawase, Y. (1975). Agricultural and Biological Chemishy 39, 169. Kellerman, G. M., Biggs, D. R. and Linnane, A. W. (1969). J o u m l of Cell Biology 42, 378.
Khaki, 1. A. and Shaw, D. S. (1974). Genetical Research 23, 75. Kinsky, S . C. (1967). In “Antibiotics”, (D. Gottlieb and P. D. Shaw, eds.), vol. 1, pp. 122-14 1. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Knights, B. A. (1970). Phytochemistry 9, 701. Knights, B. A. and Elliott, C. G. (1976). Biochim’ca et Biophysica Acta 441, 341. Kouyeas, V. (1953). Annales, Institut Phytoputhologique Benuhi 7 , 40. Kroes, J., Ostwald, R. and Keith, A. (1972). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 274, 71. Ladbrooke, B. D., Williams, R. M. and Chapman, D. (1968). Biochim’caet Biophysica Acta 150, 333.
Lampen, J. 0. (1966). Symposium ofthe Society for General Micsobiology 16, 111. Lampen, J . 0.. Arnow, P. M. and Safferman, R. S. (1960).J o u m l ofBacteriology 80,200.
STEROLS IN FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN G R O W H AND REPRODUCTION
171
Langcake, P. (1974). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 63, 573. Langcake, P. (1975). Transactions of the British Mycological Soceity 64, 55. Leal, J. A., Friend, J. and Holliday, P. (1964). Nature, London 203, 545. Leonian, L. H. and Lilly, V. G. (1937). American Joumul of Botany 24, 700. Lin, H.-L., Langenbach, R. J. and Knoche, H. W. (1972). Phytochemistry 11, 2319. Lin, H.-K. and Knoche, H. W. (1974). Phytochemistry 13, 1795. Lutsky, B. N., Hsiung, H. M. and Schroepfer, G. J. (1975). Lipids 10, 9 McCorkindale, N. J., Hutchinson, S. A., Pursey, B. A., Scott, W. T. and Wheeler, R. ( 1969). Phytochemistry 8, 86 1. McElhaney, R. N., d e Gier, J. and Van der Neut-Kok, E. C. M. (1973). Biochimica et Biofhysica Acta 298, 500. McMorris, T. C. and Barksdale, A. W. (1967). Nature, London 215, 320. McMorris, T. C., Seshadri, R., Weihe, G. R., Arsenault, G. P. and Barksdale, A. W. (1975). Journal ofthe American Chemical Society 97, 2544. Madyastha, P. B. and Parks, L. W. (1969). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 187, 858. Mailer, C., Taylor, C. P. S., Schreier-Muccillo. S. and Smith, I. C. P. (1974). Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics 163, 67 1. Mellano, H. M., Munnecke, D. E. and Sims, J. J. (1970). PhytoPathology 60, 943. Mirocha, C. J. and Christensen, C. M. (1974). Annual Review of Phytopathology 12, 303. Molzahn, S. W. and Woods, R. A. (1972). Journal of General Microbiology 72, 339. Moor, H. (1967). Archiv f u r Mihrobiologie 57, 135. Mullins, J. T. and Ellis, E. A. (1974). Proceedings ofthe National Academy ofSciences ofthe United States of America 71, 1347. Musgrave, A. and Nieuwenhuis, D. (1975). Archives of Microbiology 105, 3 13. Nelson, R. R. (197 1). I n “Morphological and Biochemical Events in Plant-Parasite Interaction”, (S.Akai and S. Ouchi, eds.), pp. 18 1-205. Phytopathological Society of Japan, Tokyo. Nelson, R. R., Huisingh, D. and Webster, R. K. (1967). Phytopathology 57, 1081. Nes, W. R. (1974). Lipids 9, 596. Nolan, R. A. and Bal, A. K. (1974). Joumul ofBacteriology 117, 840. Noon, J. P. and Hickman, C. J. (1974). Canadian Journal ofBotany 52, 1591. Norman, C. and Calderone, R. A. (1971). Phytopathology 61, 904. Nowak, R., Kim, W. K. and Rohringer, R. (1972). Canadian Journal ofBotany 50, 185. Nozawa, Y.,Fukushima, H. and Iida, H. (1975). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 406, 248. Oldfield, E. and Chapman, D. ( 1972). Federation of European Biochemical Societies Letters 23, 285.
O’Malley, B. W. and Means, A. R. (1974). Science, New York 183, 610. Papa, K. E., Campbell, W. A. and Hendrix, F. F. (1967). Mycologia 59, 589. Parks, L. W., Anding, C. and Ourisson, G. (1974). European Joumul ofBiochemistry 43, 451.
Parks, L. W., Bond, F. T., Thompson, E. D. and Starr, P. R. (1972). Journal ofLipid Research 13, 3 11. Perritt, A. M., Phillips, A. W. and Robinson, T. (1960). Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 2, 432. Pillai, C. G . P. and Weete, J. D. (1975). Phytochemistry 14, 2347. Popplestone, C. R. and Unrau, A. M. (1973). Phytochemistry 12, 1131. Popplestone, C. R. and Unrau, A. M. (1975). Canadian Journal of Chemistry 52, 462. Pratt, B. H., Sedgley, J. H., Heather, W. A. and Shepherd, C. J. (1972). Australian Journu1 of Biological Sciences 25, 861. Pratt, R. G. and Green, R. J. (1971). Canadian Journal ofBotany 49, 273.
172
CHARLES G. ELLIOTT
Pratt, R. G. and Mitchell, J. E. (1973). Canadian Journal ofBotany 51, 595. Proudlock, J. W., Wheeldon, L. W., Jollow, D. J. and Linnane, A. W. (1968). Biochim’ca el Biophysica Acta 152, 434. Rand, R. P., Pangborn, W. A., Purdon, A. D. andTinker, D. 0. (1975). CanadianJournal of Biochemistry 53, 189.Raper, J. R. (1939). American Journal of Botany 26, 639. Raper, J. R. (1940). American Journal of Botany 27, 162. Raper, J. R. and Haagen-Smit, A. J. (1942). Journal ofBiologica1 C h i s t r y 143, 311. Ragsdale, N. N. (1975). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 380, 81. Ragsdale, N. N. and Sisler, H. D. (1972). Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 46, 2048. Ragsdale, N. N. and Sisler, H. D. (1973). Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology 3, 20. Rattray, J. M. B., Schibeci, A. and Kidby, D. K. (1975). Bacteriological Reviews 39, 197. Razin, S. (1973). Advances in Microbial Physiology 10, 1. Razin, S. and Cleverdon, R. C. (1965). J o u m l of General Microbiology 41, 409. Reeves, R. C. and Jackson, R. M. (1974). Journal of General Microbiology 84, 303. Richards, J. B. and Hemming, F. W. (1972). Biochemical Journal 128, 1345. Riggs, T. R. (1970). In “Biochemical Actions of Hormones”, (G. Litwack, ed.), vol. 1, pp. 157-208. Academic Press, New York. Rothblat, G. H., Hartzell, R., Mialhe, H. and Kritchevsky, D. (1967). In “Lipid Metabolism in Tissue Culture Cells”, (G. H. Rothblat and D. Kritchevsky, eds.), pp. 129-149. Wistar Institute, Philadelphia. Rothman, J. E. and Engelman, D. M. (1972). Nature New Biology 237, 42. Rottem, S., Pfendt, E. A. and Hayflick, L. (1971). Journal of Bacteriology 105, 323. Rottem, S., Yashouv, J., Ne’eman, Z. and k i n , S. (1973). Biochim’ca et Biophysica Acta 323, 495.
Safe, S. (1973). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 326, 471. Safe, S. and Caldwell, J. (1975). Canadian J o u m l of Microbiology 21, 79. Sakurari, A., Tamura, S., Yanagishima, N., Shimoda, C., Hagiya, M. and Takao, N. (1974). Ap‘cultural and Biological Chemistry 38, 231. Sansome, E. (1970). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 54, 101. Savage, E. J., Clayton, C. W., Hunter, J. H., Brennerman, J. A., Laviola, C. and Gallegly, M. E. (1968). Phytopathology 58, 1004. Schlosser, E. (1972). Phytopathologische ZeitschriJ 74, 9 1. Schlosser, E. and Gottlieb, D. (1966). Journal ofBacteriology 91, 1080. Schlosser, E. and Gottlieb, D. (1968). Archiufir Mikrobiologie 61, 246. Schlosser, E., Shaw, P. D. and Gottlieb, D. (1969). Archivfir Mikrobiologie 66, 147. Sessa, G. and Weissmann, G. ( 1968). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 150, 173. Shepherd, C. J. and Pratt, B. H. (1973). Australian J o u m l of Biological Sciences 26, 1095. Sherald, J. L., Ragsdale, N. N. and Sisler, H. D. (1973). Pesticide Science 4, 719. Siekevitz, P. (1970). New England Journal of Medicine 283, 1034. Sietsma, J. H. (1971). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 244, 178. Sietsma, J. H . and Haskins, R. H. (1967). Canadian Journal ofMicrobiology 13, 361. Sietsma, J . H. and Haskins, R. H. (1961). Canadian Journal ofBiochemistry 46, 813. Sietsma, J. H., Eveleigh, D. E. and Haskins, R. H. (1968). Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 34, 331.
Sietsma, J. H., Eveleigh, D. E. and Haskins, R. H. (1969). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 184, 306.
Silver, J. C. and Horgen, P. A. (1964). Nature, London 249, 252. Smith, P. F. (1963). Journal of General Microbiology 32, 307.
STEROLS I N FUNGI: THEIR FUNCTIONS IN GROWTH AND REPRODUCTION
173
Smith, P. F. (1964). Journal ofLipid Research 5, 121. Smith, P. F. (1969). Lipids 4, 331. Smith, P. F. and Lynn, R. J. (1958). Journal ofBmteriology 76, 264. Smith, P. F. and Rothblat, G. H. (1960). Journal of Bmteriology 80, 842. Sproston, T. and Setlow, R. B. (1968). Mycologia 60, 104. Stamps, D. J. (1953). Transactions of the British Mycological Society 36, 255. Starr, P. R. and Parks, L. W. (1962). Journal of Bacteriology 83, 1042. Takao, N., Shimoda, C. and Yanagishima, N. (1970). Development, Growth and Dttferentiation 12, 199. Tepperman, J. and Tepperman, H. M. (1960): Pharmucological Reviews 12, 301. Thomas, D. des S. and Mullins, J. T. (1967). Science, New York 156, 84. Thomas, D. des S. and Mullins, J. T. (1969). Physiologia Plantarum 22, 347. Thompson, E. D., Knights, B. A. and Parks, L. W. (1973). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 504, 132.
Thompson, E. D. and Parks, L. W. (1972). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 260, 601. Thompson, E. D. and Parks, L. W. (1974). Journul ofBacteriology 120, 779. Throm, E. and Duntze, W. (1970). Journal ofBacteriology 104, 1388. Trocha, P. J., Jasne, S. J. and Sprinson, D. B. (1974). Biochemicaland Biophysical Research Communications 59, 666. Tsuda, S. and Tatum, E. L. (1961).Journal ofBiophysical and Biochemical Cytology 11, 17 1. Tully, J. G. and Razin, S. (1969). Journal ofBmteriology 98, 970. Tully, J. G . and Razin, S. (1970). J o u m l $Bacteriology 103, 751. Vandenheuvel, F. A. (1963). Journal ofthe American Oil Chemists Society 40, 455. Van Etten, J. L. and Gottlieb, D. (1965). Journal ofBacteriology 89, 409. Van Etten, J. L. and Gottlieb, D. (1967). Journal of General Microbiology 46, 377. Verkleij, A. J., Ververgaert, P. H. J. Th., de Kruyff, B. and Van Deenen, L. L. M. (1974). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 373, 495. Wallace, P. G., Huang, M. and Linnane, A. W. (1968).Journal of Cell Biology 37, 207. Weete, J. D. (1973). Phytochemistry 12, 1843. Weete, J. D. (1974). “Fungal Lipid Biochemistry”. Plenum Press, London and New York. Werkman, B. A. and Van den Ende, H. (1974).Journal $General Microbiology 82, 273. Wiley, J. S. and Cooper, R. A. (1975). Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 413, 425. Wolf, J. C., Lieberman, J. R. and Mirocha, C. J. (1972). Phytopathology 62, 937. Wolf, J. C. and Mirocha, C. J. (1973). Canadian Journal of Microbiology 19, 725. N o d s , R. A. (1971). Journal ofBacteriology 108, 69. Yanagishima, N. (1969). Planta 87, 110. Yanagishima, N., Shimoda, C., Takahashi, T. and Takao, N. (1970). Development, Growth and Differentiation 11, 217. Zygmunt, W. A. and Tavormina, P. A. (1966). Applied Microbiology 14, 865.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Active Transport of Solutes in Bacterial Membrane Vesicles WIL N. KONINGS Department of Microbiology, Biological Centre, University of Groningen, Kerklaan 30, Haren, The Netherlands I . Introduction
.
11. Membrane Vesicles
IV.
V. VI.
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
.
.
. . . . . . .
.
. . . . . .
. .
. . . . . .
. .
.
.
Isolation Procedures . . . . Physical Properties . . . . Purity of Membrane Preparations . . . . Functional Properties . . . . . . . Orientation of the Vesicle Membrane . . . . Localization of D-Lactate Dehydrogenase in Membrane Vesicles . . . . . . . . . from Escherichia coli . Active Transport Coupled to Electron Transfer Systems . . . A. Coupling to Respiratory Chain. . . . . . . . B. Coupling to Anaerobic Electron Transfer Systems . . . C. Coupling to Cyclic Electron Transfer Systems . . . . Energy Coupling to Active Transport . . . . . . . A. Role of Adenosine 5’-Triphosphate and the ATPase Complex . B. Mechanism of Energy Coupling . . . . . . . C. Energy-Dependent Binding of Solute to Carrier Proteins . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . , . . , . . . . . A. B. C. D. E. F.
111.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . .
.
. . . . . .
.
175 177 177
180 183 184 194 200 203 203 217 223 225 225 228 239 243 244 244
I. Introduction Growth and survival of bacteria can only occur if the organisms are able to transfer solutes from the external milieu into the cytoplasm. For most solutes, the cytoplasmic membrane forms the only osmotic barrier within the bacterial envelope; thus an understanding of the mechanism by which solutes can pass the cytoplasmic membrane is an essential prerequisite for a better understanding of the physiological and ecological features of bacteria. 175
176
WIL N. KONINGS
Solute translocation through the cytoplasmic membrane might occur by processes which do not require metabolic energy, like passive diffusion and facilitated diffusion, or at the expense of metabolic energy by the mechanisms of group translocation and active transport (for definitions see Kaback, 1972). The metabolic energy-dependent processes are thought to be the major bacterial mechanisms involved in the accumulation of solute in the cytoplasm. The two processes differ in an important aspect: in group translocation, the transported molecule is changed covalently during passage through the membrane, while in active transport the solute is accumulated in an unmodified form in the interior of the cell. The initial studies on energy-dependent accumulation of solutes were performed with intact bacterial cells, and the pioneering work performed in the Institut Pasteur in Paris led to a widespread interest in bacterial transport phenomena. These studies supplied essential infomation about the nature, specificity and kinetic properties of the bacterial transport systems. In order to explain the results of these studies, several models were devised. It became increasingly apparent, however, that the results of studies with whole cells were subject to many interpretations and could supply only limited information about the molecular mechanisms of transport. The main problems arose trom the diffculty of separating reactions occurring in the cytoplasm (and periplasmic space) from those occurring in the cytoplasmic membrane; consequently, it was not possible to obtain much insight into the energy requirements of transport processes. This led to a search for adequately defined experimental systems, which in essence retained only the structural and functional properties of the cytoplasmic membrane. A major step in that direction was the isolation of bacterial cytoplasmic membrane vesicles by Kaback ( 197 1). Transport studies in these membrane vesicles contributed considerably to our understanding of the molecular mechanism of transport, and in the present review I shall focus attention mainly on the developments derived from these studies. A number of aspects of bacterial transport, such as studies in whole cells, genetics of bacterial transport systems and the role of the periplasmic binding proteins, will only be mentioned where relevant to this discussion. The reader interested in a summary of bacterial transport in general, or in specific aspects of bacterial transport systems,’ is referred to several excellent reviews (Cirillo, 1961 ;
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 177
Holden, 1962; Pardee, 1968; Kaback, 1970a, b; Lin, 1971; Oxender, 1972; Halpern, 1974; Boos, 1974, 1975; Hamilton, 1975; Simoni and Postma, 1975). 11. Membrane Vesicles A.
ISOLATION PROCEDURES
The isolation of the cytoplasmic membrane from bacterial cells, in such a way that they form closed membrane vesicles which are physiologically active with regard to integrated membrane functions, has been described by Kaback ( 197 1). The procedure consists in essence of two steps: (1) conversion of the organism into an osmotically sensitive form, and (2) controlled lysis of that form in the presence of nucleases and a chelating agent (Fig. 1). The osmotically sensitive form, termed protoplasts for Gram-positive organisms and sphaeroplasts for Gram-negative organisms, can be obtained by two distinctive methods, viz. the penicillin method and the lysozyme-EDTA method. SPHAEROPLAST
n
GRAM-NEGATIVE CELL
CM
GRAM-POSITIVE CELL ~treotment ~ in ~ o hypotonic medium
~
o~noio/ ,\ ,
hypotonic medium
a00 VESICLES
FIG. 1. Scheme for the isolation of bacterial membrane vesicles. LPS indicates lipopolysaccharide layer, CW cell wall, CM cytoplasmic membrane.
The former method involves exposure to penicillin of cells growing rapidly in the presence of a suitable osmotic stabilizer, like hypertonic sucrose. This results in unbalanced growth in which the cell outgrows its peptidoglycan shell. With actively growing cells this method leads to
178
WIL N. KONINGS
the formation of sphaeroplasts, or protoplasts, which lyse rapidly in a hypotonic environment. The penicillin method is a rather tedious procedure, requiring several dilution steps, and therefore has been used only occasionally.The more generally employed procedure is the lysozyme-EDTA method. In Gram-negative bacteria, the peptidoglycan layer of the cell wall is located between an external lipopolysaccharide layer and the cytoplasmic membrane. In order to expose the peptidoglycan layer to the hydrolytic action of lysozyme (muramidasel, treatment of the cells with EDTA at alkaline pH values is required. Such a treatment of Gram-negative cells, suspended in a hypertonic medium, results in the rapid formation of sphaeroplasts (Fig. 1). It should be mentioned here that both the penicillin method and the lysozyme-EDTA method result in sphaeroplasts which still contain the lipopolysaccharide layer, and fractions of this layer will be present in the final membrane vesicle preparation. In order to obtain optimal results, each organism requires specific conditions of incubation and treatment; thus, variations have to be applied to the nature and/or molarity of the incubation buffer, temperature, and duration of incubation with lysozyme and EDTA. For some organisms, more extensive modifications of the lysozyme-EDTA method have been developed. For Pseudomonas aeruginosa, the use of chelating agents such as Tris-HC1 and EDTA has been avoided by performing the lysozyme treatment in a sucrose solution in the presence of 2.5% (w/v)lithium chloride (Stinnett et al., 1973). For Gram-positive organisms, which lack the lipopolysaccharide layer, the peptidoglycan layer is directly accessible for lysozyme, and therefore protoplasts can be obtained rapidly from Bacillus subtilis without the use of EDTA (Konings et al., 1973). For Staphylococcus aureus, rapid formation of protoplasts was obtained by degradation of the cell wall with lysostaphin in a hypertonic medium (Short et al., 197 2a, b). The second step in the formation of membrane vesicles is the controlled lysis of the protoplasts or sphaeroplasts. Transfer of these osmotically sensitive forms to a hypertonic medium results in swelling, followed by lysis and release of the intracellular contents. The cytoplasmic membrane re-anneals by an unknown mechanism, yielding closed and empty membrane vesicles which can be easily sedimented. During lysis, the intramembranal milieu equilibrates with the external medium; therefore, the greater the lysis ratio (i.e. the ratio of the
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 179
volume of protoplasts or sphaeroplasts to the volume of the lysis solution) the more dilute are the intramembranal contents. During lysis, intracellular DNA is released which adheres to the membranes and makes the preparation difficult to handle. The addition of deoxyribonuclease (DNase) to the lysate results in a rapid decrease of the viscosity of the solution. In order to remove RNA as well as DNA, the lysis fluid is usually supplemented with EDTA and ribonuclease (RNase). The EDTA facilitates release of RNA from the membrane which is subsequently degraded by the RNase. Since Mg2+isrequired for DNase activity, it is necessary to add an excess of magnesium salt to the lysates after they have been exposed to EDTA. After lysis, the membrane vesicles are extensively washed in an EDTA-containing buffer and isolated by differential centrifugation. The whole isolation procedure requires several homogenization steps. In order to obtain membrane vesicles with the highest possible transport activity, it appears to be essential to perform this homogenization in the most gentle way so as to avoid mechanical damage of the membranes (Altendorf and Staehelin, 1974; Futai, 1974a). Usually this goal is reached by performing homogenization of the membranous pellets with a hypodermic syringe fitted with an 18 gauge needle. Further, drastic changes of the incubation temperature should be avoided. For some organisms, good results have been obtained when all steps were performed at room temperature, except for the lysozyme treatment which usually was performed at 37OC (A. Bisschop and W. N. Konings, unpublished results). A considerably shorter procedure is available for the isolation of membrane vesicles from Gram-positive organisms (Konings et al., 1973). Due to the absence of the lipopolysaccharide layer, it is possible to combine the conversion of cells into an osmotically sensitive form and the lysis step. Treatment of the cells with lysozyme in a hypotonic medium leads to partial hydrolysis of the cell wall, and this results in extrusion of the cytoplasmic membrane followed by lysis. After further degradation of the remaining pieces of the cell wall, the cytoplasmic membranes are isolated by differential centrifugation, as already described. This procedure circumvents protoplast formation and has the further advantage that it is less time-consuming and gentler since it requires fewer homogenization steps. The procedure has special advantages for organisms like B. subtilis that produce exoproteases. During protoplast formation, these enzymes are excreted into the incubation medium and partially degrade membrane proteins. As a conse-
180
WIL N. KONINGS
quence the membrane vesicles obtained are labile and lose their activity within a few hours (Konings and Freese, 1972). The “one step” isolation procedure drastically diminishes this effect, and the membrane vesicles may be kept at room temperature for a prolonged period of time without significant loss of activity. A modification of the lysis procedure is also employed for the preparation of membrane vesicles from anaerobically grown Escherichia coli (Konings and Kaback, 1973). Lysis of the sphaeroplasts is performed in small volumes of hypotonic medium (usually 2 g wet-weight of sphaeroplasts in 10 ml of 10 mM potassium phosphate buffer, pH 6.6, containing 2 mM magnesium sulphate), avoiding extensive washing of the vesicles. This procedure, which has also been employed for other anaerobic organisms (Konings et al., 19751, yields membrane vesicles which retain components involved in anaerobic electrontransfer systems, in contrast to procedures which require large lysis volumes. For the isolation from the phototrophic organism Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides of membrane vesicles which perform active transport processes, it appeared essential to perform the lysozyme-EDTAand the lysis step in media with a controlled redox potential between zero and 100 mV (Hellinperf et al., 1975). The membrane vesicles are usually suspended in 0.1 M potassium phosphate buffer (pH 6.6) to a concentration of 10 mg membrane protein per ml. Small aliquots are rapidly frozen in liquid nitrogen. When the membrane vesicles are kept at temperatures below -8OOC (usually in liquid nitrogen) the activity can be retained for several months. Prior to the experiments, the membrane vesicles are rapidly thawed by incubation at 46OC, and during the experiment they are usually kept at room temperature. B.
PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
The structures observed in electron micrographs (see Fig. 2) of ultrathin sections of membrane vesicle preparations reveal structures which are almost exclusively intact membranous sacs (Kaback, 197 1; Konings et al., 19731, surrounded by a single trilaminar layer, which is 6.5-7.0 nm thick. The diameter of the vesicles varies from 0.1 to 1.5pm for E . coli (Kaback, 1972) and from 0.1-0.5 p for B. subtilis (Konings et al., 1973). These diameters are smaller than those from the corresponding sphaeroplasts and protoplasts. The surface to volume ratio, which for a
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 181
FIG. 2. Electron micrographs of thin sections through Bacillus subtilis cells, protoplasts and membrane vesicles. A. Whole cells; B. Details of cell layers ofwhole cells; C. Details of the cytoplasmic membrane of protoplasts; D. Detail of a vesicle membrane; E. Survey of a typical membrane preparation. Taken from Konings et al. (1973).
182
WIL N. KONINGS
sphere varies as the reciprocal of its radius, is therefore much smaller than andN. protoplasts, or the corresponding 182 it is for sphaeroplastsWIL KONINGS whole cell. The inner volume of the vesicles is 2-4 pl per mg membrane sphere (Kaback, varies as the reciprocal ofand its radius, much protein 19 7 Oa; Konings Freese, is19therefore 7 2). During lysissmaller of the than it is for sphaeroplasts and protoplasts, or the corresponding sphaeroplasts, or protoplasts, the original cytoplasmic membrane obwhole cell. Theinto inner vesicles is 2-4 pl membrane viously breaks a volume numberof ofthe pieces resulting in per the mg formation of protein (Kaback, 1970a; Konings and Freese, 1972). During lysis of the several vesicles per cell. sphaeroplasts, protoplasts, the original cytoplasmic membraneand obThe vesicles or appear to be devoid of cytoplasmic constituents viously breaks into a number of pieces resulting in the formation of cell-wall fragments, as is clearly shown by electron micrographs of several vesicles per cell. serial thin sections of vesicle preparations (Fig. 2) (Konings et al., 1973). The vesicles to beoften devoid of cytoplasmic constituents and Frequently, oneappear or more concentrically arranged “internal cell-wall fragments, as is clearly shown by electron micrographs of serial thin sections of vesicle preparations (Fig. 2) (Konings et al., 1973). Frequently, one or more often concentrically arranged “internal
-
0 8 - 0
t Osmolority ( m M )
FIG.3. Effect of the osmolarity of the incubation medium on the initial rate (3 min; 0) and steady state level (0)of t-glutamate uptake by membrane vesicles from Bacillus subtilh W23. Uptake experiments were performed in K- hosphate buffer pH 6.6 with ascorbate ( 10 mMkphenazine methosulphate (10 p&f as energy source. The osmolarity was adjusted by variation of the buffer concentration. (Taken from W. N. Konings, unpublished results).
P
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 183
vesicles” are observed, which most probably are the result of enclosures of small vesicles within bigger ones. Only a small fraction of these internal vesicles (15%, see p. 196) result from invagination. An essential feature of any system that it is to be used as a model for the study of solute transport is that it must have a continuous surface (i.e. it must be able to retain transported solutes). Electron micrographs of serial thin sections of membrane vesicles indicate that the vesicles are closed structures (Konings et al., 1973). This contention is supported by studies of the surface of membrane vesicles by electron micrographs of negatively stained vesicles (Kaback, 1972; Konings et al., 1973; Altendorf and Staehelin, 1974). More convincing evidence of membrane continuity has been provided by experiments demonstrating that the vesicles are osmotically sensitive (Kaback and Deuel, 1969; Kaback, 197 1) so that they shrink and swell appropriately when the osmolarity of the medium is increased or decreased. The diffusion barrier properties of the membranes of the vesicles are also demonstrated by the observation that the initial rates, and the steadystate levels, of transport strongly depend on the outside osmolarity. The highest initial rates, and steady-state levels, are obtained at an osmolarity which is slightly higher outside than within the membrane vesicles (Fig. 3). C.
PURITY OF M E M B R A N E VESICLE P R E P A R A T I O N S
The purity and homogeneity of the membrane vesicles have been established by a number of criteria. Membrane vesicles from E. coli contain less than 5% of the cell’s DNA and RNA, but 1 6 1 5 % of the protein and at least 70% of the phospholipids initially present in the whole cells (Kaback, 197 1, 1972). Moreover, almost all of the cytoplasmic enzymes are lost, as is demonstrated by polyacrylamide disc gel electrophoresis (Kaback, 19711, and less than 1% of the activities of cytoplasmic enzymes such as glutamine synthetase, p-galactosidase, fatty acid synthetase and leucine-activating enzyme are found in the vesicle preparation. Of the “periplasmic enzymes” (Heppel, 1967), only 2% or less are found in membrane vesicle preparations from Gram-negative organisms. The membrane vesicles contain very low concentrations of endogenous energy sources such as NADH, D-lactate and succinate, as is indicated by the low endogeneous rates of oxygen consumption and active transport of solutes (Barnes and Kaback, 1971; Konings et al.,
184
WIL N. KONINGS
1973) (see p. 203). Expressed as a function of dry weight, the membrane vesicles are approximately 60-70% protein, 3040% phospholipid and 1% carbohydrate (Kaback, 1971). Vesicles prepared from the ML strains of E. coli have less than 3% (w/w) lipopolysaccharide whereas vesicles prepared from a number of other strains of E coli and Salmonella typhimurium have 7 to 17% (Kaback, 1972).
D . FUNCTIONAL PROPERTIES
In contrast to the cytoplasmic enzymes, membrane vesicles retain a number of membrane-associated enzymes and perform several integrated membrane functions. 1. Phospholipid Synthesis
Membrane vesicles from E. coli catalyse, in the presence of cytidine 5’-triphosphate, synthesis of phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylglycerol from serine and a-glycerol phosphate, respectively; they also produce endogenously phosphatidic acid or diglyceride (Weissbach et al., 197 1; Thomas et al., 1972, 1973). Furthermore, these membrane vesicles can synthesize cyclopropane fatty acids by transferring the methyl group from S-adenosylmethionine to an unsaturated fatty acid moiety esterified to endogenous phosphatidylethanolamine (Cox et al., 1973). In addition, the vesicles catalyse exchange of the y phosphate of ATP, or other nucleotide triphosphates, with the phosphate group of phosphatidic acid, and phosphorylation of ADP by a process independent of oxidative phosphorylation can be observed (Thomas et al., 1972, 1973). 2. Nucleotide Metabolism
Membrane vesicles contain enzymes involved in the degradation of nucleotides, and those from B. subtilis contain both exo- and endonuclease activity. Components involved in the process of genetic transformation also appear to be present in membrane vesicles from competent cells of B. subtilis, and these vesicles demonstrate a higher binding of deoxyribonucleicacid than do vesicles from non-competent cells (Joenje t t al., 1974, 1975).
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 185
3. Electron- TranJfer Systems
An important feature of membrane vesicles from bacteria is the presence of functional electron-transfer systems such as the respiratory chain, anaerobic electron-transfer systems and cyclic electron-transfer system. A wide diversity exists in the electron carriers which participate in these systems, but they usually include dehydrogenases, quinones, non-haem iron proteins, flavines, several types of cytochromes and terminal oxidases. In membrane vesicles from most of the bacteria so far investigated, these electron carriers are at least partially retained. Special precautions, however, have to be taken in order to retain sufficient levels of all electron carriers in the membrane vesicles kom some organisms (Dutton et al., 1975; P . A. M. Michels and W. N. Konings, unpublished results). a. The Respiratory Chain. Membrane vesicles from aerobically grown aerobic or facultatively aerobic bacteria contain a respiratory chain to which several dehydrogenases can be coupled. The nature of these dehydrogenases varies in the different organisms, and in many depends strongly on the growth conditions (Konings and Freese, 1972; Dietz, 1972; Short and Kaback, 1974; kczorowski et al., 1975). Membrane vesicles from aerobically grown E. coli contain high activities of TABLE 1. Oxidation of substrates by membrane vesicles from Escherichia coli, Bacillus
subtilis and Staphylococcus aureus. Rate of oxygen uptake (ng-atoms/min/mg membrane protein)
Substrate (20 m M )
Escherichia coli ML 308-225
None
<1
l lactate
330
L-Lactate Succinate NADH a-Glycerol phosphate
91
540 270
-
Bnn'llus subtilis 60015
Staphylococcus aurew U-7 1 glucose
gluconate
-=1 -=1
<4
-=4
14
<1 34
82 20 174 14
12 70 14
630 56
234 190
Escherichia coli ML 308-225 was grown in a medium containing 1% Na-succinate (Barnes and Kaback, 197 I), Bacil1u.1subtilis 60015 in nutrient sporulation medium (Konings and Freese, 1972). and Staphylococcur auras U-7 1 in a synthetic medium containing glucose or a complex medium containinggluconate as the primary energy source (Short and Kaback, 1974).
186
WIL N. KONINGS
D-Lactate dehydrogenase
NADH +f p Dehydrogenase Succinate dehydrogenase
/ 1
__+
Fe-Q
cytb,
cy' Fe-Q
--f
a2
c y t o -02
FIG. 4. Respiratory chain of Escherichia coli. f, indicates flavoprotein, Fe-Q non-haem iron-ubiquinone, cyt cytochrome. After Cox et al. ( 1970).
D-lactate dehydrogenase, succinate dehydrogenase or NADH dehydrogenase. Membrane vesicles from B. subtifis contain high activities of NADH dehydrogenase and succinate dehydrogenase; growth of B . subfilis on glycerol results in the induction of L-a-glycerol phosphate dehydrogenase and growth on L-lactate, of L-lactate dehydrogenase (Konings and Freese, 197 1, 1972). In vesicles from other organisms yet other dehydrogenases are found, such as L-malate dehydrogenase in Azotobacter vinelandii (Barnes, 19 7 2) and D-glucose dehydrogenase in Pseudomonas aeruginosa (Stinnett et af., 1973). Most dehydrogenases are coupled very effectively to the respiratory chain, as is evident from the observations that the corresponding substrates are oxidized by the membrane vesicles at a high rate (Table 1; Barnes and Kaback, 197 1; Konings and Freese, 1972; Short et al., 1972a). In membrane vesicles from E. coli, oxidation of D-lactate, L-lactate, succinate, or a-glycerol phosphate results in a stoicheiometric conversion to pyruvate, fumarate or dihydroxyacetone phosphate, respectively (Kaback and Milner, 1970; Barnes and Kaback, 1970). Upon addition of the substrates, an extensive reduction of respiratory chain intermediates (including flavins and cytochromes) is observed (Fig. 4). In membrane vesicles from E . coli, addition of the substrates D-lactate, succinate, or NADH results in reduction of flavoprotein, and cytochromes b, a, and a2 (Barnes and Kaback, 197 1). Together with cytochrome o these cytochromes belong to all the classes of cytochromes known to be present in E . coli (Smith, 1961). Similar observations have been made with membrane vesicles from B. subtifis. With NADH as substrate, essentially complete reduction of the flavoproteins, and the cytochromes b, c,, c, and a has been observed (Konings and Freese, 1972). Further evidence for the involvement of the respiratory chain in oxidation of
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 187
the substrates is obtained from inhibition experiments with respiratory-chain inhibitors. The sites of inhibition by amytal, 2heptyl-4-hydroxyquinoline-N-oxide (H0QNO 1 and cyanide have been well established in E . coli (Cox et ul., 1970) and B . subtilis (Miki et al., 1967). The location of the amytal-sensitive site in the respiratory chain of E . coli is the flavine group between D-lactate dehydrogenase and cytochrome b , ; HOQNO acts between cytochrome b, and cytochrome u2, perhaps at a quinone-containing component, and cyanide blocks cytochrome u2. These inhibitors severely block oxidation of Dlactate, succinate and NADH (Table 4 ; p. 208). b. Anaerobic Electron-Transfer Systems. Growth of E. coli under anaerobic conditions in the presence of nitrate results in induction of the anaerobic electron-transfer system with nitrate as a terminal electron acceptor (Koningsand Boonstra, 1976). The terminal oxidase in this electron-transfer system is nitrate reductase, which catalyses reduction of nitrate to nitrite. In E . coli, formate serves as the most effective electron donor for nitrate respiration (Taniguchi and Itagaki, 1960; Wimpenny and Cole, 1967; Cole and Wimpenny, 1968; RuizHerrera and DeMoss, 1969; Lester and DeMoss, 1971). Membrane vesicles isolated from E coli, grown anaerobically in the presence of Nitrate Respiration Formate
NADH Deh ydrogenase
/
I
Fumarate Reduction L-a-Glycerolphosphate
dehydrogenase
-+
fp
-
(FebMQ
- (cyt b , )
fumarate reductase
tiumarate
FIG. 5 . Anaerobic electron-transfer systems of Escherichia coli. f indicates flavoprotein, Fe-Q non-haem iron-ubiquinone, Fe- MQ non-haem iron-menaquinone, and cyt cytochrorne. The involvement of the electron-transfer components which are placed in brackets is not unambiguously established.
188
WIL N. KONINGS
nitrate, retain the nitrate respiration system. These membrane vesicles contain a high formate dehydrogenase and nitrate reductase activity, and electrons are transferred effectively from formate dehydrogenase to nitrate reductase (Konings and Kaback, 1973; Boonstra et al., 1975a). This electron transfer occurs most likely via ubiquinone (Enoch and Lester, 1974), non-haem iron protein (Taniguchi and Itagaki, 1960) and cytochrome b, (Fig. 5 ) (see for review: Konings and Boonstra, 1976). Nitrate respiration has been demonstrated also in membrane vesicles fiom the obligately anaerobic Veillonelfaalcalescens organisms that had been grown in the presence of nitrate (Konings et al., 1975). In these membrane vesicles, several dehydrogenases are coupled to nitrate respiration, viz. L-lactate dehydrogenase, formate dehydrogenase, L-malate dehydrogenase, L-a-glycerol phosphate dehydrogenase and NAD H - dehydrogenase. In another anaerobic electron-transfer system, fumarate functions as terminal electron acceptor (see for review: Konings and Boonstra, 1976). Growth of E. coli anaerobically on glycerol as a carbon source and fumarate as electron acceptor results in the induction of anaerobic L-a-glycerol phosphate dehydrogenase and fumarate reductase. These two enzymes constitute a hnctional complex which is membranebound and which catalyses dehydrogenation of L-a-glycerol phosphate and reduction of hmarate without involving any cofactor (Fig. 5). The terminal oxidase, fumarate reductase, converts fumarate to succinate. Membrane vesicles from these cells retain high activities of L-a-glycerol phosphate dehydrogenase and fumarate reductase, and electron transfer occurs via flavins (Miki and Lin, 1973) menaquinones and, most likely, non-haem iron proteins (Singh and Bragg, 1975). It is of interest that Singh and Bragg (1975) recently demonstrated, with a cytochrome deficient (haem A-) mutant of E. coli, that the participation of cytochromes in this electron-transfer system is not essential. c. Cyclic Electron Transfer Systems. Phototrophic bacteria contain cyclic electron-transfer systems in addition to the respiratory chain. Electrons are derived from reduced bacteriochlorophyll, in a lightdependent process, and transferred to acceptors (the nature of which is a point of discussion) and thereupon via quinones and cytochromes back to oxidized bacteriochlorophyll (Fig. 6). These systems may be operative under aerobic as well as anaerobic conditions. Most of this photosynthetic apparatus is localized in invaginations of the cytoplasmic membrane, the so-called chromatophores (Tuttle and Gest,
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 189
FIG.6. Cyclic electron-transfersystem of Rhodopseudomom sphaeroides. P,,, indicates bacteriochlorophyll with absorption band at 870 nm, Pa photorhedoxin, Q ubiquinone, and cyt cytochrome.
1959; Oelze and Drews, 19721, and several procedures have been described for their isolation (Tuttle and Gest, 1959; Cohen-Bazire, 1963; Oelze and Drews, 1972; Holt and Marr, 1965). Recently a procedure was developed for the isolation of cytoplasmic membrane vesicles from the facultative phototrophic bacterium Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides (Hellingwerf et al., 1975). These membrane vesicles are distinct from chromatophores in that they are oriented as the cytoplasmic membrane (see p. 194), in contrast to chromatophores, and perform active transport processes. Furthermore, the average diameter of the vesicles is several times the diameter of the chromatophores (Oelze and Drews, 1972; Gibson, 1965). Membrane vesicles isolated from cells grown anaerobically in the light contain a functional cyclic electrontransfer system, as is demonstrated by the observations that light can supply the energy for active accumulation of amino acids and lipophilic cations, and by the presence of bacteriochlorophyll (Hellingwerfet al., 1975).
4. Ca2+-Mg2+-Activated ATPase
Membrane vesicles from several strains of E. coli, prepared by the lysozyme-EDTA method, hydrolyse ATP at a high rate. The rate of hydrolysis is increased by destroying the permeability barrier of the vesicles with detergents like Triton X-100 or toluene, and also by sonication (VanThienen and Postma, 1973; Futai, 1974a; Hare et d.,1974; Short and Kaback, 1974).The significance of these observations will be
190
WIL N. KONINGS
discussed below in the section on Orientation of vesicle membrane
(p. 194).Only a fraction (20-60%) of the CaP+-MgP+-dependent ATPase activity present in intact cells is retained in the membrane vesicles (Short and Kaback, 1975; Futai, 1974a). Washing of the vesicles with, for instance, medium containing low concentrations of salt (van Thienen and Postma, 1973: Short and Kaback, 1975)results in further losses of the ATPase activity, indicating that a considerable fraction of ATPase is not firmly bound to the membrane vesicles. Although the components involved in oxidative phosphorylation (the electron-transfer systems and CaP+-Mg4+-ATPase) are present in the membrane vesicles, oxidative phosphorylation does not occur in the presence of oxidizable substrates (Konings and Freeze, 1972; Klein and Boyer, 1972). This lack of oxidative phosphorylation capacity is not due to an ineffective coupling of ATPase to the energy-generating site(s)of the respiratory chain, but to the inability of ADP to reach the properly located ATPase at the inner side of the membrane (Van Thienen and Postma, 1973). Membrane vesicles, prepared from sphaeroplasts of E. coli lysed in the presence of ADP and inorganic phosphate (Pi),produced ATP with D-lactate and succinate as electron donor, and also when an artificial pH-gradient was formed across the membrane (Tsuchiya and Rosen, 1976). Synthesis of ATP required Mg2+and ADP and was inhibited by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide and carbony1 cyanidep- trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone.Such a synthesisof ATP was not observed in membrane vesicles prepared from a mutant lacking the ATPase. In this respect, it is of interest that membrane vesicles from E. coli, prepared by breakage of the cells by passage through a French-press cell, are capable of catalysing oxidative phosphorylation with several physiological oxidizable substrates (Hertzberg and Hinkle, 1974). 5 . Group- Translocation Transport Systems
In a group- translocation transport system, the transported solute is covalently changed during transport through the cytoplasmic membrane. Two group translocation systems, the phosphoenolpyruvate phosphotransferase system (PTS) and the adenine phosphoribosyltransferase system, have been investigated in detail in membrane vesicles. In addition, evidence has been presented for a group translocation function of the enzyme system acetyl coenzyme A:
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 191
butyryl coenzyme A transferase for uptake of butyrate in membrane vesicles from E. cob (Frerman, 1973) and of a system in which I7phydroxysteroid dehydrogenase is an essential component for the translocation of testosterone in membrane vesicles from Pseudomonas testeronii (Watanabe and Po, 1974). a. The Phosphoenolpyruvate Phosphotransferase System (PTS). The PTS has been described by Kundig et al. (1964).This system was shown to be responsible for the translocation, and concomitant phosphorylation, of several carbohydrates in a number of facultative aerobes (Hengstenberg, 1973; Cirillo, 1973; Harris and Kornberg, 19721, but apparently not in obligate aerobes (Romano et al., 1970). Besides its primary role as a translocating system for sugars, the PTS has been implicated in playing an important role in a number of regulatory functions (Roseman, 1972). Translocation and phosphorylation of sugars occur by the PTS via a series of reactions, as is schematically shown in Fig. 7 for E. coli. The protein fractions that take part in this phosphoryl transfer are both cytoplasmic and membrane constituents and can be classified into two groups : the general (non-sugar specific)proteins and the sugar-specific proteins.
\
f
I
CYTOPLASMIC MEMBRANE
r
PEP
xnz;
Pyruvate
I
Sugar- phosphate
)Sugar
\
FIG. 7 . The phosphoenol pyruvate phosphotransferase system in Escherichza coli. PEP indicates phosphoenol pyruvate, H Pr histidine-containing phosphocarrier protein, IIA Enzyme 11-A, 11-B Enzyme 11-B, and 111 Factor 111. Taken from Kundig (1976).
192
WIL N. KONINGS
The general PTS proteins, Enzyme I and the phosphocarrier HPr, are both cytoplasmic proteins. The main function of these proteins is the formation of phosphorylated HPr, which serves as the central phosphoryl donor for all membrane-associated PTS reactions. Both Enzyme I and HPr have been purified to homogeneity for several organisms (Anderson et al., 1971; Kundig, 1976). Enzyme I has a molecular weight of approximately 80,000 daltons and HPr is a histidine-containing protein with a molecular weight of 9,600 daltons. Both proteins seem to be constitutively synthesized. The sugar-specific proteins comprise a family of pairs of sugar-specific proteins, each pair being necessary for the phosphorylation of one sugar. Of each pair, at least one protein is a firmly-bound membrane component. A sugarspecific protein, which is soluble, has been called Factor 111. The sugar-specific proteins are either constitutively synthesized or inducible. In any given bacterial cell many different sugar-specific pairs of PTS proteins (11-A/II-Bor III/II-B) may function simultaneously in the transfer of the phosphoryl moiety to a given sugar, all utilizing the same central phosphoryl donor P HPr. The sequence of phosphoryl transfer proceeds from P HPr to one of the sugar-specific PTS proteins and then to the sugar. The last step, the formation of sugar phosphate, requires the second sugar-specific PTS protein and this protein is always membrane-bound. The number of sugars that are transported via the PTS varies for different organisms. In Staphylococcus aureus the PTS has been reported to be involved in the phosphorylation of hexoses (glucose, N-acetylmannosamine, fructose), glycosides (a-methylglycoside, salicin, thio/?-D galactosides), alditols (glycerol, mannitol, sorbitol) and disaccharides (maltose, melibiose, lactose) (Hengstenberg, 1973; Cirillo, 1973). In E. coli, however, the PTS has been reported to be involved in the transport of relatively few sugars (glucose, fructose, mannose, mannitol and probably maltose; Tanaka et al., 1967). The information available about the PTS has been reviewed extensively (Roseman, 1972; Kaback, 1970a, b; Kundig, 1976; Kornberg, 1972).Evidence has been presented that the components of the PTS are present in the membrane vesicles from E. coli, B. subtilis and S. lyphimurium at sufficiently high concentrations to allow vectorial phosphorylation of glucose and related monosaccharides (Kaback, 1969a).This means that the sugars are phosphorylated during the transport process through the vesicle membrane, which results in the ac-
- -
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 193
cumulation at the inside of the sugar-phosphate. The most direct evidence of this mechanism is given by double isotope experiments in which the intravesicular pool is preloaded with 14C-glucoseunder conditions in which there is no phosphorylation of the sugar. After removal of the external isotope, the preloaded vesicles are exposed to 3H-glucose in the presence of phosphoenolpyruvate. The phosphorylated sugar found inside is almost exclusively 3H-glucose 1phosphate. Experiments with mutants of E. coli and S . typhimurium defective in Enzyme I or HPr demonstrated that uptake and phosphorylation of the sugar by the membrane preparations were obligatorily dependent on phosphoenolpyruvate and that the effect of phosphoenolpyruvate had to be mediated by the phosphoenolpyruvate phosphotransferase system (Kaback, 1968; 1969a). In addition, it was demonstrated that a stoicheiometric relationship exists between the disappearance of 3*Pphosphoenolpyruvate and the appearance of 32P in the sugar phosphate, suggesting that phosphoenolpyruvate provided the energy for the simultaneous uptake and phosphorylation of sugar. The uptake of sugar via the PTS is subject to rigorous control (Kaback, 1969b). Glucose or a-methylglucoside transport and phosphorylation are non-competitively inhibited by glucose 6phosphate, glucose 1-phosphate and by a variety of related hexose phosphates. The inhibitory sites for the 6-phosphate and 1-phosphate esters are accessible from either side of the membrane and are distinct and separate; moreover inhibition of glucose transport by glucose 1phosphate was antagonized by glucose 6-phosphate and vice versa. These experiments, especially when considered in conjunction with the independent experim2nts of Lowry et al. (1971)and Kornberg (19721, strongly suggest that sugar phosphates (glucose 1-phosphate in particular) may be central metabolites in the regulation of carbohydrate transport and utilization in general. b. The Adenine Phosphoribosyl Transferme System. Another group translocation system is the adenine phosphoribosyltransferase system which is involved in the uptake of purines (Hochstadt-Ozerand Stadtman, 1971a, b, c). In the transport process, adenine is converted to AMP according to the following reaction : adenine + PRPP
adeninephosphoribosyltransferase
t
AMP+PPi
(1)
194
WIL N. KONINGS
Studies in membrane vesicles demonstrated that AMP is accumulated inside the membrane vesicles during adenine transport. The enzyme adenine phosphoribosyl- transferase is located at the outside of the membranes and variations in enzyme activity are reflected by changes in adenine transport. The transport of purine nucleosides in E . coli requires an additional membrane-bound enzyme (Hochstadt-Ozer, 1972) adenosine phosphorylase, which catalyses the reaction : adenosine + Pi
-
adenine + ribose 1-phosphate
(2)
The free adenine is then transported by reaction 1. Transport of pyrimidines in Salmonella typhimurium involves a transport system coupled to the respiratory chain (Hochstadt-Ozer and Rader, 1973); this seems to be analogous to the transport systems that will be discussed later (p. 203). 6 . Active Transport Solute transport by an active transport mechanism occurs via a specific carrier protein present in the cytoplasmic membrane; it is generally believed that the solute combines with this carrier. The carrier-solute complex formed at the outside of the membrane crosses the membrane and is modified at the inner surface in such a way that the carrier has a lowered affinity for the solute. This results in release of the solute at the inside of the membrane. The carrier can move back to the outside surface of the membrane and again combine with solute. This process requires metabolic energy and results in the accumulation of solutes against an electrochemical or osmotic gradient. Membrane vesicles from many organisms perform active transport of a wide variety of solutes in the presence of a suitable energy source. The available information about active transport in membrane vesicles will be discussed on p. 203. E. ORIENTATION OF VESICLE MEMBRANE
For interpretation of the experimental data on integrated membrane functions, it is essential to have knowledge regarding the orientation of the vesicle membrane with respect to the orientation of the cytoplasmic membrane of intact cells. There is a considerable amount of evidence that membrane vesicles isolated by the lysozyme-EDTA procedure, with gentle homogenization steps, have the same orienta-
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES I N BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 195
FIG. 8. Electron microscopy of freeze-etched cells, protoplasts and membrane vesicles from Bacillus subtilis W23. A. Replica of an intact cell showing two fracture faces of the cytoplasmic membrane. B. Replica of an intact cell showing the inner fracture face (left and the outer fracture face (right) of the cytoplasmic membrane. C. Replica of a protoplast showing the inner fracture face (left) and the outer fracture face (right) of the toplasmic membrane. D. Replica of a membrane vesicle showing the inner fracture ace (left)and the outer fracture face (right) of the membrane. The arrows indicate the direction of the shadow. Taken from Konings et ul. (1973).
7
196
WIL N. KONINGS
tion as the cytoplasmic membrane in whole cells. The major lines of evidence are: (i) Transport of solutes from the external medium into the vesicles is supposed to occur only by “right-side out” membrane vesicles. The initial rates of transport and the steady-state levels of accumulation of solutes in membrane vesicles from E. cofi (Lombardi and Kaback, 1972),Staph. aureus (Short et af., 1972b)and B . subtifis (Konings et af., 1973)are similar to those observed in intact cells. (ii) Freeze-etch electron microscopy studies demonstrate that the inner and outer fracture faces of the cytoplasmic membrane from intact cells are morphologically different. The inner (convex)fracture face has a high particle density whereas the outer (concave) fracture face has a low particle density (Fig. 8). The texture observed in the fracture faces of membrane vesicles is very similar to those observed in intact cells (Kaback, 197 1 ; Konings et af., 1973; Altendorf and Staehelin, 1974); an orientation with a higher particle density in the outer fracture face than the inner fracture face was never observed in membrane vesicles. However, such an orientation has been observed in about 15% of the vesicles which are enclosed in other vesicles (Konings et al., 1973). Probably these “internal” vesicles result from invaginations of the outen membrane layer. These observations demonstrate that the particle distribution is a good indication of the orientation of the membrane. (iii) The localization in the rpembrane of the membrane-bound enzymes, succinate dehydrogenase and NADH dehydrogenase, was studied with the membrane-impermeable electron carrier 5-N-methylphenazonium-3-sulphonate (MPS) in membrane vesicles and intact cells from B. subtilis (Konings, 1975). In both preparations, succinate dehydrogenase appears to be exposed to the outside while NADH dehydrogenase is localized at the inside. Furthermore, studies with antibody against D-lactate dehydrogenase demonstrated that this membrane-bound enzyme is exclusively present on the inner surface of the vesicle membrane (see below; p. 200). (iv) Rosen and McClees ( 1974) have demonstrated that inverted membrane vesicles, prepared by passing cells through a French-press cell, do not transport proline in the presence of the electron donor Dlactate, but do catalyse calcium accumulation. In contrast, vesicles prepared by osmotic lysis do not exhibit calcium transport but accumulate proline effectively in the presence of D-lactate. (v) Recently, Short et af., (1974a) demonstrated that essentially all vesicles in a preparation catalyse active transport. Vinylglycolate (2-
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 197
hydroxy 3-butenoate) is transported by membrane vesicles from E. coli ML 308-225 by the lactate transport system. Subsequently, vinylglycolate is oxidized by membrane-bound D- and L-lactate dehydrogenases to yield a reactive electrophile (presumably 2-0x0 3butenoate) which then reacts with sulphhydryl-containing proteins on the membrane. Essentially all of the vinylglycolate taken up is covalently bound to the vesicles. The limiting step for this labelling of the membrane protein is the transport of vinylglycolate. With SHlabelled vinylglycolate, it was possible to estimate the number of vesicles which transport this compound in the presence of the artificial electron donor ascorbate-PMS (Konings and Freese, 197 1; Konings et al., 197 1) by examining the vesicles by radioautography in the electron microscope. Each vesicle that takes up vinylglycolate is overlaid with exposed silver grains. Essentially all of the large vesicles in a preparation could be labelled in this way, while the size of the smaller vesicles is such that their proximity to individual silver grains in the emulsion may be limited. The same radio-autographic results were obtained with [SH]aceticanhydride, a reagent which reacts non-specifically with the vesicles. The major reason why the evidence presented above for a right-side out orientation of the membrane vesicles is not generally accepted lies in the difficulty of accounting for the relative effects of different physiological electron donors on transport in E. coli membrane vesicles. Membrane vesicles from E. coli catalyse active transport of amino acids and several other metabolites in the presence of an appropriate electron donor (see below; p. 203). In the absence of an electron donor, hardly any uptake is observed. As will be discussed below there is no relationship between the ability of the vesicles to oxidize a particular electron donor and the ability of that electron donor to catalyse active transport. For instance D-lactate, as well as a number of other compounds, is oxidized by E. coli membrane vesicles at a high rate, yet D-lactate is by far the best physiological energy source for transport (Table 2). When the membrane vesicles are oriented as the cytoplasmic membranes of intact cells, these and other observations can be explained by a specific localization of the coupling site for transport in a segment of the respiratory chain between D-lactate dehydrogenase and cytochrome 6 (see Fig. 4; Kaback and Barnes, 1971). An alternative explanation, however, can be offered if some of the
198
WIL N. KONINGS
TABLE 2. Respiration and transport by membrane vesicles from Eschrichia coli ML 308-225. Proline transport and the rate of oxygen consumption were measured with membrane vesicles from cells grown in a glucose-medium. (Taken from Kaback and Hong, 1973). ~~~
Electron donor None D-Lactate D,L-a-Hydroxybutyrate Succinate L-Lactate NADH
Transport of proline (nmoles/min/mg protein)
Rate of oxygen uptake (ng-atoms/min/mg protein)
0.02 1.26
<1 300 60 125 50 620
0.09 0.07 0.20
0.38
vesicles in a preparation are inverted. This explanation is based on the following assumptions : (i) electron donors which are ineffective with regard to transport are oxidized only by enzymes located at the inner side of the cytoplasmic membrane; (ii) the permeability of the vesicle membrane to these electron donors is low; and (iii) the observed oxidation of these electron donors by a vesicle preparation is due primarily to inverted vesicles. Several lines of evidence argue against the first assumption. It has been demonstrated that all of the electron donors which are oxidized by vesicles reduce the same cytochromes both qualitatively and quantitatively (Barnes and Kaback, 1971; Konings and Freese, 1972). If a percentage of the vesicles was inverted, and only these inverted vesicles would oxidize an ineffective electron donor such as NADH, it is dificult to understand how NADH could reduce all of the cytochromes in the preparations. Furthermore, although NADH is generally a poor electron donor for transport in E. coli membrane vesicles, it is the best electron donor for transport in B. subtilis membrane vesicles (Konings and Freese, 1971, 1972). Moreover, it has been demonstrated that intact cells ofB. subtilis, which are depleted for endogenous energy sources, oxidize NADH at a high rate and that NADH effectively drives transport of amino acids (Konings, 1975). Hampton and Freese (1974) observed that the oxidation of NADH in membrane vesicles from B. subtilis show biphasic kinetics, while oxidation of this substrate by whole cells has only one affinity constant; thus they concluded that some of their vesicles were open or inverted. These authors also observed that treatment of the membrane vesicles with proteolytic enzymes caused a 50%
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF SOLUTES IN BACTERIAL MEMBRANE VESICLES 199
decrease in NADH oxidation rate. This effect on NADH oxidation was not observed in membrane vesicles prepared according to Konings et al. ( 1973). Furthermore these membrane vesicles have a several-fold higher transport activity than the preparation of Hampton and Freese ( 1974).These apparently contradictory results can be best explained by the differences in isolation procedure, the main one being that the procedure applied by Konings et al. ( 1973) is more rapid and requires fewer homogenization steps. Observations made with mutants of E. coli deficient in certain dehydrogenases also argue against the assumption that electron donors which have a low efficiency in the energization of transport are oxidized mainly by inverted vesicles. Vesicles prepared from a mutant deficient in D-lactate dehydrogenase exhibit normal transport in the presence of the electron donor succinate, but not