This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
0 leads to charge superselection rules, as we next demonstrate. Consider the two-point function given by (2.4) in the zero-mass limit; we have (0\
= —^/w(
(x)){(L_\
2
" (_^2£2y
2-±?-
« ^){-li2e2)-2^1{^)1/\l-iae^d^±i^d^)
.
Recalling (3.11) we define the current ^{x), following Mandelstam [9], as the limit " ^ -
l i m i ^ ) f c + ^){J"(.;e)-(0|J"(^;e)|0)}
,
(3.12)
1
For if = - 1 (space-like) the cluster decomposition property requires
lim
• • •?(«+/"?)V'(*pfi) • • • V ' ^ n M y . r f i ) • • • >A(y») |o>
/J—*00
= <0 I V>(xi) • • • V ( z P M i / i ) • • • ? ( » , ) I 0><0 | t/>(z»fi) ' • • i M ^ M y ^ i ) • • • MVr.) I 0).
45
3.3 The Massive Thirring Model where
2
Z(c) is the renormalization constant
Z(e) = 2(-^r-^^
•
One finds jn(x) = --e^d^ipix)
.
(3.13)
7T
Returning to the equation of motion (3.2), substituting for the Dirac field and the current expressions (3.6) and (3.13), and using (3.11), we see that /? is fixed as a function of the coupling constant,
01 7T
1 1 - 4
(3.14)
'
7V
Other bilinears can also be computed. Prom (3.6) we have iPl(x + e)iP2(x) = ^(-H2e2)-^:e-2iMx):
.
(3.15)
We therefore arrive at the identifications N$il>]{x) = J±-:cos 2/3
{x-1) = Yv(n\x)1n
.
(3.34)
The fields ?(") can be calculated by substituting (3.34) back into (3.33), and equating to zero the terms with the same power in 7. One thus easily obtains for the
The Thirring model
50 first three terms
,
= -%dl
I(J was introduced by Mandelstam [9] who was able to write the fundamental fermion of the massive Thirring field, in terms of the bosonic field, thus generalizing the results summarized in Eqs. (3.13)-(3.18). As we discuss next, the fermionic field obtained in this way describes the soliton as well as new particle states of the sine Gordon theory, which cannot be interpreted as conventional bound states; there is no element in the local field algebra which connects the vacuum of the sine-Gordon theory to the non-trivial soliton states. We shall discover in a later chapter, that the particle scattering of the fundamental field of the sine-Gordon theory can, in turn, be described in terms of the scattering of bound states of the soliton states.
3.4.1
Fermions in t e r m s of bosons
In order to find a bosonisation formula for the fermion field, we note that there is a natural candidate for the fermion in the sine-Gordon theory: the soliton. The fundamental property of this soliton operator is encoded in the equal time (ET)
54
The Thirring model
commutator 8 [LP(y),iP(x)}ET = 2irp-1ip(x)8(x1-y1)
.
(3.40)
The commutation relation is in particular realized by the operator
*l
1>(x) = ^ e - t - n e
(^J.
(3.41)
Note that for a zero mass free field
(y)]ET = i5{xl — y1) implies />oo
/ p{ii2W2 = l . Jo Using (3.45), the integral in ( 3.46) is convergent only if j32 <
8TT
(3.46)
.
This is a condition for the sine-Gordon theory to be well defined. In order to define the mass operator (3.42) we compute its vacuum expectation value; using the representation ip(y) = — i& f' ^, we infer that [sin @
— a. Hence (3.51) shows that this symmetry is spontaneously broken. This is however not the most general situation. In fact, given a dual algebra of the form / ei2v/N4>(y)fi(x) IMWW , is a spinor field obeying Bose statistics. Thus there exists an additional contribution to the functional measure transforming under a chiral transformation with just the inverse of the Jacobian (4.113), • oo. Finally, let us remark that we have supposed in our analysis that D was a positive semi-definite operator. This is true if D = (i ft)2, but is no longer true, if i ft is replaced by the (in Euclidean space non-Hermitian) Dirac operator with axial coupling of the gauge field, ift = i ?)+ A~f5. Various methods have been proposed to circumvent this problem [27, 20, 28, 29].
i \M \
, y1 > x1 y <x
.
,2 .
n
it has been demonstrated [24] in the framework of axiomatic QFT, that regardless of the form of the Lagrangian C(>, d^), the following properties in this case hold:
i.
W(M) = O ,
2.
(<M>=0
.
3. Whenever
(>} = 0 and (/x) = 0
,
the mass gap vanishes.
The above theorem expresses a deep relationship between the spectrum and the vacuum expectation values of order and disorder fields. Let us examine how these ideas may be used to obtain the order and disorder operators of a QFT defined by a Lagrangian £(>, d^ifi). It is useful to first review briefly the corresponding situation of the one dimensional Ising model in statistical mechanics. The Hamiltonian reads in this case J
ff=-J^<73(n)a3(n+l)-^a1(n)
,
57
3.5 The Soliton as a Disorder Parameter
where <Ji(n) are the Pauli matrices. The Hamiltonian is invariant under the transformation az{n) -¥ —a3(n), a\(n) ->• ci(n). This system is known to posses two phases [25, 26], characterized by (
n <m .
.
,„ _0s (3.52)
An operator realization of ^ 3 (n*) is [25] ^(n*)
= J J
(3.53)
One finds that for J > 1, (/i3) = 0, while for J < 1, (/J 3 ) 7^ 0. Consider for example one of the ground states for J > 1 (ordered phase), characterized by all spins oriented up:
|o>J>1=|---fr---t--->
•
The action of ^ 3 (n*) on this state turns it into the state I ••• t t U • • • )
•
Hence // 3 (n*) has the character of a soliton operator, which creates Bloch walls from the ordered ground state. In the disordered phase, we have (/J 3 ) ^ 0. Hence the phase transition {fi3) = 0 —> (/z3) ^ 0 at J = 1 can be viewed as a soliton condensation. The above quantum mechanical description of the one-dimensional Ising model is known [25] to have an equivalent description in two-dimensional classical statistical mechanics defined by the partition function
S = 5>-*M
,
where H is the discrete, classical Hamiltonian H[o) = -jY^a{n)°{n+
?{»))
,
(3.54)
'
( 3 - 55 )
58
The Thirring model
where H'[a] differs from (3.54) by the fact that the coupling J is replaced by —J along an arbitrary curve C along the dual lattice sites connecting n\ and n\ (see Figure 3.2). Notice that the curve C cuts the links of the original lattice, each of which is in turn associated with a pair of spin variables.
Figure 3.2: Curves C and C' connecting the points n* and nj of the dual latti We may thus evidently write (3.56) where ff/,w_/2^M -"cL<7J~\0
for
f(/i)GC for f ( / i ) g C
The correlation function (3.56) is actually independent of C. This is easily seen by making the change of variable a(n) —>• <x(—n) for sites n belonging to an arbitrary region R bounded by the closed curve V = C — C (see Figure 3.2), which leaves (3.56) invariant. Hence, {(J.(nl)n(r%))c = (fj,{nl)fj,{n*2))c, . This path independence is important in order to have locality properties of the correlation function (3.56). playing a crucial role in the construction of the disorder operators of QFT. We first apply the above ideas to the construction of the quantum kinks of theories of the type where ^ is a local, complex scalar field [27]. Let us assume the theory to have a Z(N) symmetry,
fv
,
(3.57)
where Cc is the analogue of He in (3.56), and is to be determined by the requirement that the correlation function (3.57) be independent of the chosen path C. To this end consider the change of variable <j>(x) -> eta<j>(x), for a; in a region S bounded
59
3.5 The Soliton as a Disorder Parameter
by C — C. Choose a — ^ corresponding to the Z(N) symmetry of the Lagrangian. Since the integration measure is left invariant by this transformation, we have (fi(x)fi*(y))c
= N"1 fv
d2x{{C+Cc)+{5C+SCc)}
= N'1 fv
_
Hence, independence of the integration path C requires Cc - Cc< +6C + SCC = 0 •
Assuming the potential V ((f), <j>*) to be invariant under the above transformation, we have, 5C = -iaffytftinOiS) + a2cf>*
dlle(S) = (J-Qt2(z-Oellvdzv
.
Making use of this representation, we are thus led to the identification [27] Cc = -ia
fV
52(z-0^dtv
Jxfi 2
+a cj>*{z)4>(z) I" d£„ fV dVfl52(z - 052(z - v). Jxfi
(3.58)
Jxfi
With this identification, the correlator {H(x)fj,*(y)) = N-1
fv
(3.59)
is independent of the choice of C. The above result can be cast into a more transparent form, by defining the external field Alt(z;C) = [
e^52(z~Od^
•
Jxfi
In terms of this field, the functional integral (3.59) takes the form (H(x)ti*{y)) = N-1
I'v
^
where DM is the covariant derivative D^ = <9M — iaA^. The path independence is now an expression of the invariance of the functional integral under the gauge transformation 4>{x) -> eiae^4>{x) , A^x-C) -> A^{x;C) + dM0(S)
.
60
The Thirring model
From Eqs. (3.58) and (3.59) we extract the following operator representation, in Minkowski space, for the disorder operator a
fi{x)=e
C^*^
It is straightforward to check, that this operator satisfies the dual algebra (3.51), and hence is the quantum field theoretic generalization of the kink operator H3(n*) of the Ising model. We specialize now to the case of a massive 0 4 type theory with potential V(<j>, f) = m V 4 » + A ( > + ^ )
+ -£- {r
.
This potential possess a Z(4) symmetry cj> -> el~*~ <j>. This system can be shown to exist in three phases: 1. symmetric phase: {4>)=Q ,
(/x)^0
,
<M«)A**(l/)>,
-» const.
|i-y|->oo
The phase corresponds to a kink condensate. 2. partially broken phase: (4>)=0 , (M)=0 ,
<ji(x)tS(y))
-f
\x-y\~a
but (<j>2) 7^ 0. Here only the Z{2) symmetry is broken. The \i operator creates massless kinks [28], in agreement with a general theorem [24]. 3. completely broken phase: (0)^0
,
(M)=0
,
< M * K (!/)>,
-?
\x-y\-ae-m\*-v\
.
\x-y\-+oo
In this case fj,(x) creates massive kinks with m 2 ~ (|>|2). Let us now return to the sine-Gordon theory. Repeating the line of reasoning exposed above, we find this time ((i(x)n*(y)) = Jv
,
(3.60)
where
+ \(j)
f
^ jV^d^{z-i)^z-n).
(3.61)
61
3.6 Conclusion
From (3.60) we extract the following representation for the soliton operator in Minkowski space: li{t,x)=e
-1
,
(3.62) 1
where we have specialized the curve C to lie parallel to the x axis. The exponential (3.62) is nothing but the soliton operator introduced in (3.53)! The above method of constructing order and disorder operators from a given symmetry of the bosonic Lagrangian in question, can also be used as a tool for constructing bosonic representations of the fermionic operator of other models via the composition (3.50).
3.6
Conclusion
We presented the full quantum solution of the massless Thirring model in terms of free fields. Our building blocks were the exponential fields defined in Chapter 2. The correlators have been computed in closed form, and further properties of the model have been established. The model is conformally invariant at the classical as weel as at the quantum level [29]; as it turns out, it is completely equivalent to a free bosonic theory. We next allowed for a mass of the fundamental fermionic field. Perturbation theory in the mass parameter showed a very important feature: at quantum level, the model is equivalent to the bosonic theory of the sine-Gordon field. The fact that a bosonic theory may describe fermions was suspected long ago [6], before the actual proof of this fact, and has been discussed by several authors. The full quantum equivalence has been proven by Mandelstam (Eq. (3.41), who also provided the required equivalence in the charged sector, as opposed to Coleman's equivalence, Eqs. (3.16), (3.17) and (3.18), valid only for neutral bilinears in the fermions. Nevertheless, the aforementioned features are not the only surprising features of the theory; it also exhibits in both the fermionic and bosonic languages, an infinite number of conservation laws, which are a consequence of the Lax pair (3.26) and (3.27), in the case of the Thirring model, and (3.31), (3.32) in the sine-Gordon case. This is a feature discussed at length in the literature. As a consequence one may exactly calculate the full S-matrix for both of these theories [30, 31, 32], as well as some form factors [33]. These S-matrices will be constructed in Chapter 8. Finally we presented a discussion of the order-disorder operators of the theory, which provides a deeper physical insight, as well as a method for constructing fermions out of order and disorder operators.
Bibliography [1] W. Thirring, Ann. of Phys. 3 (1958) 91. [2] W. Glaser, Nuovo Cimento 9 (1958) 990. [3] K. Johnson, Nuovo Cimento 20 (1961) 773.
62
BIBLIOGRAPHY
[4] F. Scarf and J. Wess, Nuovo Cimento 26 (1962) 150. [5] B. Klaiber, Helv. Phys. Acta 37 (1964) 554; Lectures in Theoretical Physics, Boulder 1967, Gordon and Breach, New York, 1968. [6] D. Finkelstein and J. Rubinstein, J. Math. Phys. Skyrme, Proc. Roy. Soc. A260 (1961) 127.
9 (1968) 1762; T.H.R.
[7] S. Coleman, Phys. Rev. D l l (1975) 2088. [8] J.A. Swieca, Fortschritte der Physik 25 (1977) 303. [9] S. Mandelstam, Phys. Rev. D l l (1975) 3026. [10] P.P. Kulisch and E.R. Nissimov, Pisma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 24 (1976) 244; R. Flume, Phys. Lett. 62B (1976) 93; I.Ya. Aref'eva and V.E. Korepin, JETP Lett. 20 (1974) 321; R. Dashen et al Phys. Rev. D l l (1975) 3424; B. Berg, M. Karowski and H.J. Thun, Phys. Lett. 62B (1976) 63, 187; B. Yoon, Phys. Rev. D132 (1976) 3440; R. Flume et al Phys. Lett. 64B (1976) 289. [11] N.N. Bogoliubov and O.S. Parasiuk, Acta Math. 97 (1957) 227; K. Hepp, Commun. Math. Phys. 2 (1966) 301; W. Zimmermann, in Led. on Elementary Particles and Quantum Field Theory, 1970, Brandeis U. Summer Institut; J. Lowenstein, Seminars on Renormalization Theory, Maryland 1972; P. Lam, Phys. Rev. D6 (1972) 2154. [12] M. Karowski and H. J. Thun, Nuovo Cimento 38A (1977) 11; R. Flume and S. Meyer, Lett. Nuovo Cimento 18 (1977) 238. [13] K. Pohlmeyer, Commun. Math. Phys. 46 (1976) 207. [14] M.D. Kruskal and D. Wiley, American Math. Society, Summer Seminar on Nonlinear Wave motion, ed. by A.C. Newell (Potsdam NY 1972). [15] V.E. Korepin and L.D. Fadeev, Theor. Math. Phys. Zamolodchikov, Pisma v JETP 25 (1977) 499.
25 (1975) 1039; A.B.
[16] J.H. Lowenstein and W. Zimmermann, Nucl. Phys. B86 (1985) 77; E. Abdalla, M. Gomes and R. Koberle, Phys. Rev. D18 (1978) 3634. [17] B. Berg, Nuovo Cimento 41A (1977) 58. [18] B. Berg, M. Karowski and H.J. Thun, Phys. Lett. 64B (1976) 286. [19] G. Kallen and J. Toll, J. Math. Phys. 6 (1965) 299. [20] S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. 118 (1960) 838. [21] H. Neuberger, Thesis, Tel-Aviv Univ. 1976; M. Bander, Irvine, Prep. (1975); M. Halpern, Phys. Rev. D12 (1975) 1684; H. Lehman and J. Stehr, Desy-Prep. 1976/29. [22] B. Schroer and T. Truong, Phys. Rev. D15 (1977) 1684.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
63
[23] L.P. Kadanoff and H. Ceva, Phys. Rev. B 3 (1971) 3918). [24] R. Koberle and E.C. Marino, Phys. Lett. 126B (1983) 475. [25] E. Fradkin and L. Susskind, Phys. Rev. D17 (1978) 2637. [26] J. Kogut, Rev. Mod. Phys. 51 (1979) 659. [27] E.C. Marino, Nucl. Phys. B217 (1983) 413; B230 (1984) 149; A.A.S. de Macedo and E.C. Marino, Phys. Rev. D40 (1989) 1360. [28] E.C. Marino, B. Schroer and J.A. Swieca, Nucl. Phys. B200 (1982) 473. [29] P. Furlan et al Rivista del Nuovo Cimento 12 (1989) 1; L. Heck, Fortschritte der Physik 27 (1979) 169; M. Gomes, J. Lowenstein, Nucl. Phys. B45 (1972) 252. [30] A.C. Scott, F.Y. Chu and D.Mc. Laughlin, Proc. of the IEEE 61 (1973) 1443. [31] L A . Takhtadzhyan and L.D. Fadeev, Theor. Math. Phys. 21 (1975) 1046; M.S. Alblowitz, O.J. Kaup, A.C. Newell and N. Segur, Phys. Rev. Lett. 31 (1973) 125. [32] L.D. Fadeev and L A . Takhtadjan, Hamiltonian Methods in the Theory of Solitons, Springer, 1987; S.P. Novikov, Theory of Solitons: the inverse scattering method , New York, Contemporary Soviet Mathematics, 1984; R. Rajaraman, An Introduction to Solitons and Instantons in Quantum Field Theory, North Holland, 1982. [33] M. Karowski and P. Weisz, Nucl. Phys. B139 (1978) 455.
This page is intentionally left blank
Chapter 4
Determinants and Heat Kernels 4.1
Introduction
Within the path-integral framework, the non-perturbative calculation of n-point functions in gauge theories involves as intermediate step the calculation of Green functions and functional determinants in an external gauge field A^x). By functional determinant we mean the determinant of an operator D[A] defined in (continuum) Euclidean space, whose value depends on the choice of the field configuration A(x). In the cases of interest, such operators will be differential operators depending locally on the external field. The computation of functional determinants requires regularization of divergent expressions. The methods used, although seemingly quite different, are all abstracted from the corresponding definition in the finite dimensional case. Among these, we cite the heat-kernel, ^-function, proper time and Fujikawa method, which play a central role in this chapter. These methods will also allow us to calculate explicitely the functional determinant associated with the Dirac operator in an external Abelian and non-Abelian gauge-field. We shall see that the path-integral framework also provides a suitable framework for dealing with zero-modes, and for establishing their relation to the topology of the manifold. In particular, we shall provide an unconventional derivation of the Atiyah-Singer theorem relating the index of the Dirac operator to the number of zero-modes of positive and negative chirality. In all these considerations the heat-kernel associated with the operator in question will play a fundamental role. We discuss a variety of methods for obtaining its asymptotic expansion and corresponding Seeley coefficients, and illustrate them in terms of specific examples which shall be needed in later chapters. The present mathematical framework also provides a natural basis for discussing Quantum Field Theory at finite temperature. We have thus reserved the final section of this chapter to some selected topics on this matter.
66
Determinants and Heat Kernels
4.2
Functional Determinant, one-loop diagram
In the Feynman path-integral approach to quantum field theory one is naturally led to the consideration of determinants of differential operators. Indeed, functional determinants arise in quantum field theory whenever one is dealing with a functional integration of the Gaussian type; that is, whenever the action in question is a second order polynomial in the fields over which we wish to integrate. This may be an exact characteristic of the Lagrangian, as in the case of the fermionic action of QED/QCD; it may be the result of an approximation (semi-classical or effective potential in a ^ expansion); or it may be the result of rewriting quartic interactions in some fields as a second order polynomial in these fields at the expense of introducing new, auxiliary degrees of freedom ((CPN~X, Thirring, Gross-Neveu models). Conversely, one may represent the determinant of some operator in terms of a Gaussian functional integral over Grassmann-valued fields. This is a very useful technique for dealing with the Faddeev-Popov [1] determinant arising in the process of fixing the gauge. The Mathews-Salam representation [2] of the Euclidean generating functional of fermionic correlation functions in QED illustrates how functional determinants make their appearance in physics. It is given by Z[J, v,rj}=
f dfj,[A][V$\[Vrl>] e-So[A\-sF[i,^,A\
= f dfi[A] e-SaMdet(i
Jw+tn)
0 + iM + e4) e!vG(x,y,A)r,
^
(4J)
where d/z[.<4] is the Faddeev-Popov measure [1] in some suitable gauge, the action SG(SF) is associated with the gauge-field (fermions) and G(x,y; A) is the fermionic Greens-function in an external field1 A^: (i 0 + iM + e 4)G{x,y; A) = 5{d) (x - y)
.
The logarithm of a functional determinant has a simple interpretation in terms of Feynman diagrams: it may be represented as an infinite sum of properly weighted one-loop fermion diagrams whose vertices depend on the operator in question. This is easily seen on a formal level. Thus consider an Hermitian operator D which we decompose into a free (D0) and an interacting part (Dj) as follows: D^Do
+ Dj
.
Borrowing familiar formulae from matrix algebra, we write UJD = hidetD = tx\n{D0 + DI) u D =ln—^—— = tx\n(l
~ (-l)n+1
=E 1
(4.2)
D^1DI)
+
L L2
,
1
— trtt-^/)"},
(4.3)
T h e appearance of the imaginary mass is peculiar to the Euclidean formulation. A^ denotes here a Hermitian - in general matrix valued - vector field.
67
4.2 Functional Determinant, one-loop diagram
where DQ1DI is to be regarded as a (non-local) operator, and where tr denotes the trace with respect to internal indices as well as space-time. The functional U>D possesses the obvious property, U_D. = UJD — W.D0. D
o
The sum (4.3) has a simple graphical interpretation: it is given by the sum of (connected) one-loop graphs as shown in Figure 4.1, with • —Dj for each vertex, • DQ1 for each propagator, a • (—1) overall factor for being a fermion loop, and • (""i1^ = - combinatorial factor for a diagram of order n. nI
n
°
Figure 4.1: Graphical computation of the determinant. As an example consider the Euclidean Dirac operator of massless QED, i p = (i ^ + e 4)
,
(4.4)
with A^{x) some arbitrarily chosen external gauge-field configuration. According to (4.3) we have
-#
L det(i 0 ) 1 ^
n
\i 0 *7
= e f d*xSE(0) £{x)
- y
d4x J diySE{x-y)4(y)SE{y-x)4{x)
(4.5)
+ --- ,
where SE{X) is the inverse of i $ (see Appendix B). As the first term in (4.5) already shows, there arise ambiguities as a result of divergencies, which will have to be treated by an appropriate regularization technique. In this chapter we shall examine various such techniques which do not rely on perturbation theory. The exponential of the series (4.5) has a simple representation in terms of a functional integral. Let {ca(x)} be the components of a complex-valued Grassmannian field, with {ca(x)} their complex-conjugate. The dimensionality of the index a matches that of the matrix-valued operator D; c and c are assumed to obey the
Determinants and Heat Kernels
68
Berezin [3] integration rules given in appendix C. The ratio of determinants of D and D0 is then represented by det£> _ e" D _ fVcVce-fddx'Dc UD detD0 ~ e o ~ jVcV-e-fd*xcD0c
'
where d is the dimensionality of (Euclidean) space-time. The virtue of considering the normalized ratio (4.6) resides in the fact that the leading divergence is thereby eliminated. The formal correctness of (4.6) may be established in different ways. One way consists in expanding the integrand of (4.6) in powers of Dj as follows,2 e-
_ fVcVce-fdd*-cD°cZn=o
^Lf(^/c)]"
(4?)
ddx cDoC
fVcVce-f
'
and then to perform the functional integration. The result is the exponential of the sum of connected one loop diagrams as given by (4.3). Another way of formally verifying the correctness of the identification made in (4.7) is to suppose D and .Do to be operators defined on a compact manifold M, with a discrete eigenvalue spectrum and a complete set of eigenfunctions: Dun = Xn[D]un DQvm = \m[D0]vm
,
(4.8) .
(4.9)
For the time being we shall assume that D and Do have no zero eigenvalues. Expand the fields ca(x), ca(x) in (4.7) in terms of the above eigenfunctions: ca{x) = "^2 anun(x)a
= ^
n
bmvm(x)a
,
(4-10)
,
(4.11)
m
Ca{x)=^anu\l{x)a
= ^2,bmv\n(x)a
n
m
with an, an, bn, bn Grassmann-valued c-number coefficients. Choosing un and vm to be orthonormal with respect to a measure d/j,(x) on M, / djjL{x)u]l(x)un'{x) = 8nn,
,
dnixtyltWvmi(x)
= 5mm>
,
(4.12)
we make the change of variables VcDc -> Yl dandan
,
(4.13)
,
(4.14)
n
VcVc->~[[dbmdbm
2 Dj may be a local or non-local operator. For compactness of notation we shall frequently refrain from specifying the integration variables.
4.2 Functional Determinant, one-loop diagram
69
in the numerator and denominator of (4.7) respectively. Introducing the expansions (4.10) and (4.11) in (4.7) and using (4.8), (4.9) and (4.12), we obtain e" D
SXlndandane-Y,^T^
=
e D
" °
!Y[mdbmdbme-T.^0]lmam
Now, fi-$>[i>]5n-n
=
Y[ e - ^ P P — = J J ( l - \n[D]anan) n
.
n
The last equality only holds, because of the Grassmann properties a^ = a^=^ 0. Furthermore, according to the Berezin [3] integration rules (see appendix C),
f J ] dandan e~ D MDp»«»
=
"* n
J J An[jD ] ,
(4.16)
n
with a corresponding result for the denominator in (4.15). Hence, we conclude that e"D _ II„An[i>]
n„A„[A>]
(4.17)
This confirms once more the identification made in (4.7). If there are zero-modes present, then these should be omitted in (4.17), resulting in det'D e"'° Y['Xn[D] { det'D0 U'K[Do] ' ' e«'Do where the prime indicates omission of zero-modes. Hence det'D is just the subdeterminant corresponding to the non-vanishing eigenvalues of D. The existence of zero-modes is not seen in perturbation theory. The divergencies occurring in the loop-integrations implicit in (4.3) have their reflection in the non-existence of the product (4.17) because of the (in general unbounded) growth of the eigenvalues with r n o o . Thus again, a regularization procedure has to be given for defining the determinant via (4.17). Such procedures will be discussed in detail now.
4.2.1
Determinants and the Generalized Zeta-Function
Elliptic operators Definition (4.17) can be used to calculate wo in terms of an infinite sum involving the eigenvalues A„[Z)]. In order to get an answer for generic field configurations A, we need to know the eigenvalues as functionals of A. This is generally not possible. Hence a direct calculation starting from (4.17) will in general be feasible only for specific field configurations. For a generic field configuration one has to develop special techniques. All of these are based, in one form or another, on the definition (4.17), and correspond to different regularizations of the in general divergent product (4.16), as we shall see.
70
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Let D be a differential operator of order m defined on a d-dimensional, compact manifold M, D
=
h
E
(«){Z)D^
.
(4.19)
\a\<m
Here x = (£1, • • •, x^) £ M. are local coordinates, 3 (a) — (a±, • • •, aj,) is a multiple index, with \a\ = a\ + • • • + a<j, b^(x) = bai. ..ad(xi, • • • ,Xd) are smooth, Ixk matrix valued functions, and f)\a\
£)(") = (_^(a) dx?--dx t ad<
•
We associate with (4.19) the characteristic polynomial
£ ha){x)i^= £ bai-adm?i---ad |a|<m
>
\a[<m
where £ € M. The restriction of the sum to (a): \a\ = m leads to the definition of the principal symbol associated with D,
£
W*K ( a ) >
\ot\=m
The principal symbol a defines a homomorphism from a k- to a /-dimensional vector space. D is said do be elliptic if its principal symbol is invertible for all f ^ 0, i.e., if the homomorphism defined by a turns into an isomorphism. This requires that I = k and that (7 has no zero eigenvalues for ^a' ^ 0. Example 1: Euclidean Dirac operator in Sft2 , D = —ij^d^. In this case m = 1 and bio = 7 i , &oi = 72 a n d cr(a;;£) = £ . The eigenvalues of O~D are determined by the secular equation,
A 2 -(£x 2 +£ 2 2 )=0
.
Hence this operator belongs to the class of elliptic operators. Notice that the corresponding operator in Minkowski-space does not satisfy the criterion of ellipticity! It is for this reason that we shall always work in this chapter in Euclidean space. Seeley expansion For us, the central importance of elliptic operators resides in the following theorem due to Seeley [4] and Gilkey [5]: let D be a positive elliptic operator of order m on a compact Riemannian manifold; then there exists an asymptotic expansion for the diagonal part of the associated heat kernel exp(-tD), as given by (x\exp{-tD)\x) 3
= — l - ^ [ a 0 { x \ D ) + ai(x\D)t (iirt) "•
+ • • •] .
(4.20)
These coordinates may serve to label only patches in M as it happens if a non-trivial topology is involved. We use a hat to distinguish them from the cartesian coordinates x in 9td.
4.2 Functional Determinant, one-loop diagram
71
The expansion coefficients a,k(x | D) are referred to as Seeley coefficients [4]. For elliptic operators of second order, these can all be calculated! Furthermore, we shall see that for a special class of operators D, the calculation of d e t D can be reduced to the calculation of the first few of these coefficients. We may in fact relax the positivity condition on D such as to include semipositive operators. This will be important, in order to be able to discuss the effect of instantons, which turn out to induce zero-modes of the Dirac operator (4.4). The (-function We shall generally suppose D to be a semi-positive, elliptic, (matrix-valued) differential operator of order m defined on a compact manifold M. of dimension d. Let dfi(x) be the measure 4 on M., and let A„, ipn be the corresponding (real) eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of D: Dtpn = Xn
.
We choose n
/
d^(x)fi(x)(pm(x) = 6mn
.
By assumption, all eigenvalues are positive or zero. We may define a generalized (-function [4] by
C(s\D)=^2'X-s[D]
,
(4.21)
where the prime on the sum indicates that zero-eigenvalues are to be omitted. We may write (4.21) in the compact form, C(s\D) = tv(D-°)
,
where the trace includes the internal degrees of freedom and is to be taken over the subspace orthogonal to the zero-modes. £(s | D) can be analytically extended to a meromorphic function of s in the whole complex plane, with s = 0 a regular point [4]. Its value at s = 0 may be calculated in terms of the Seeley coefficients, as we shall see. The quantity of immediate interest to us is obtained by differentiating (4.21) with respect to s: d( (4.22) ds (A„)s
SciJ'i-E
This suggests to define det'D by [In det'D}( = lim s—>0 4
ds
(s\D)
-C'(0 I D)
(4.23)
If we choose to parametrize i b y i = (xx,---,xd) £ tHd, then dn(x) = ddx^/g(x), where g(x) = det(g/Jl/(x)) with 3^t/(x) the induced metric tensor on M.. In that case S(x,y) = g~x/2(x) x
8d{x-y).
72
Determinants and Heat Kernels
The prime in (4.22) indicates the restriction of the sum to the subspace of nonvanishing zero-modes where D is invertible. The calculation of det'D is of course plagued by the usual ambiguities related to the ultra violet divergencies of fermion-loop graphs. The definition (4.23) by analytic extension to s = 0 corresponds to a very specific choice of regularization, the so called (^-function regularization . By normalizing det'D with respect to the free operator D05 l n ^ ^ = -(C'(0|I>)-C'(0|Po))
,
(4.24)
we eliminated the ambiguity associated with the leading divergence. The operators D (D0) of interest in general carry a dimension. This means that the eigenvalues An, and hence the measures (4.13) as well as (4.14) carry dimensions, so that the corresponding Berezin integration rules must involve a dimensional scale parameter M. In different terms: the eigenvalues An appearing in the definition (4.21) of the ^-function should be normalized with respect to that scale. Hence, unless the number of eigenvalues of D and Do match (no zero-modes of D), there will exist an ambiguity associated with scale transformations of the measure in (4.7). It is easily recognized from (4.22) that this ambiguity is of the form £(0 | D)ln M. In order to make this ambiguity explicit, we should thus write [6] w J2 . = - [ C ' ( 0 | Z ? ) - C ' ( 0 | I > o ) ] + [ C ( 0 | / ? ) - C ( 0 | ^ o ) ] l n M
.
(4.25)
This scaling ambiguity still does not exhaust all the possible ambiguities. We return to a discussion of this point later in section 4.8. Meromorphy of ((s\D) The meromorphy of ((s | D) and its regularity at s = 0 are most easily recognized by introducing the (matrix valued) heat kernel associated with D, which satisfies the equation (jt+D\h(t;x,y\D)=0
,
*>0 ,
(4.26)
,
(4.27)
with the initial condition hap(0;x,y\D) where 5^(x,y)
= 6aP6^(x,y)
denotes the <5-function on the compact manifold Ad. We have, [ dfi{x)h(0;x,y
| D) = 1 .
The solution of (4.26) is evidently given by haP(t;x,y\D) 5
= ^2e-tx"ipn(x)aiptl(yh
>
n T h e spectrum of Do will, for the cases of interest, contain no zero-modes.
(4'28)
4.2 Functional Determinant, one-loop diagram where the sum includes the zero eigenvalues. h(t;x,y of the integral trace-class operator e~tD,
\ D) is the continuous kernel
= (x\e-tD\y)
h{t;x,y\D)
73
,
(4.29)
where {|^)} denotes an orthonormal set of states on M:
/•
dn(x)\x)(x\
=l
,
(x\y)=6W(x,y)
.
To prove the meromorphy of ((s\D) we define a generalized (matrix-valued) ^-function £(s; x, y\D) via the Mellin-transform of the heat-kernel (4.24), after subtraction of the contribution from the zero-modes, in order to guarantee the convergence of the (-integration at t = oo [7]: Caf3(s;x,y\D) Here, P^(x,y)
= -— 1 s \ ) Jo
dtt^lK^x^D)
- P^(x,y)}
.
(4.30)
is the (matrix-valued) projector on the zero-modes
i,S)(4.y) = E^0)(*)-^or(»)-8 • n
Note that the integrand in (4.30) decays exponentially with t —• oo. Using (4.28), and performing the t-integration in (4.30) one finds C(';*,y|2>) = £ ' *
2
%
M
,
(4.3D
and in particular f dn{x)tiC(s;x,x\ D) =((s\D) . (4.32) /• For D an invertible operator (no zero-modes) we recognize in ((s; x,y | D) just the meromorphic extension of the kernel of D~s:
as;x,y\D)
= (x\D-s\y)
.
(4.33)
In the mathematical literature [4, 8] also the notation K-s(x,y;D) denote the r.h.s of (4.33). In this notation (4.32) takes the form C(s \D) = J dn(x)tTK_s(x,x;D)
.
is used to
(4.34)
The definition of the kernel K-S(x,x; D) can be extended to include any (Hermitian or non-Hermitian) invertible, elliptic differential operator of order m defined on a compact manifold without boundary [4, 8]. The meromorphy of £(s;x,x | D) is now easily demonstrated. The only singularities in s of (4.30) arise from the lower end-point of the (-integration. Choose e to lie within a small interval around t = 0 for which the Seeley expansion (4.20)
74
Determinants and Heat Kernels
converges. Splitting the integration range into [0,e] and [e, oo), we have for an operator of even order m, (is;x,x I D) = ~ — ~ ^
'
'
f dtt*-1-
r(s) (4TT), (4TT)£ JO
h o r f ) - (47r)™i-P ( 0 ) (x,x)} + regular
x{(a0 + a1t +
,
(4.35)
where r is to be determined below and where regular stands for the remaining holomorphic part. The poles arising from the lower endpoint integration are evidently located at s=
k , k = 0,1,2, ••• . m Now, JTTJY has simple zeroes at s — 0, —1, —2, • • •. Taking d/m to be an integer,6 we see that ((s; x,x\ D) has simple poles at s = 1,2, • • •, — (— integer) , (4.36) m m but not at s = 0. This proves the announced meromorphy of £(s; x,x \ D) in s, and its regularity at s = 0. According to (4.36), r is to be chosen r > ^L. We have [7] for the residue at the pole at s = — — k
In particular, since s = 0 is a regular point, we obtain from (4.35), aO;x,x\D) = ^f^-pW(x,x)
.
(4.37)
(47r)m
Now tr J d»(x)P^
(£, x) = Y,f M&)
,
with the trace taken over the matrix indices, and N is the number of zero-modes. It therefore follows from (4.37) and (4.32) that C(0\D)=ix-^r-N
,
(4.38)
(47r)m
where, in general, ak =
dfj,(x)ak(x)
.
(4.39)
The Seeley coefficients play a central role in the computation of functional determinants. 6
In this book we generally have m = 2, i.e. d/m = 1.
75
4.2 Functional Determinant, one-loop diagram
4.2.2
One Point Compactification
Before we demonstrate how the Seeley coefficients may be calculated, we shall comment on the manifold M. the operator D is to be defined on. Stereographic projection of Dirac operator Theorems about differential operators usually refer to operators defined on a compact manifold, or to boundary value problems. Under suitable asymptotic conditions one may compactify SRd. The most familiar method is that of stereographic mapping of 3?d onto a d-dimensional sphere Sd in d + 1 dimensions, whereby infinity is mapped either on the north or the south pole [9]-[12]. In the case of the Dirac operator (4.4) this presupposes a sufficiently good asymptotic behaviour for the gauge field A^. Thus, a given gauge field tending to pure gauge at infinity will in general live on the stereographic sphere on a patch excluding either the north or the south pole. If the Dirac operator is to exist on the whole sphere, then the winding (Pontryagin) number 7 associated with A^ will have to be integer. Consider, in particular, the stereographic projection of 5t2 onto a two-dimensional sphere of radius R, with infinity being mapped onto its south-pole. Let ? be the vector from the south pole to the point (£1,2:2) G Jt2 (see Figure 4.2). If R is the radius of the stereographic sphere, its length r' is given by 2R
'
(4.40)
cos$
where $ is the angle between f1 and the z-axis. If we denote by
Figure 4.2: Stereographic projection of the real plane onto a two-dimensional sphere. If we denote by r" the segment of the vector f extending from O to the intersection point of f1 with the sphere, we also have r"sintf = i?sin6>
,
r"costf = R(l + cos6)
,
(4.41)
were 9 is the polar angle defined in Figure 4.2 and r" = | r" |. From (4.41) one obtains sin<9 tan v = . l + cos0 7
In the mathematical literature it is referred to as the first Chern number [14].
76
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Combining (4.40) and (4.41) we have
M = 1,2
^ = ir^ ' with f=(R
(4 42)
-
-
sin 9 cos
4R2-x2 ^ i ^ , , ,
,
&=¥>
x
»
, , (4.43)
-
Let (£M) be the angular variables 8 6=0
,
(4-44)
labelling a point on the sphere, and let ds2 be the square of Euclidean element of length ds2 — S^dx^dx,,. In terms of the variables (4.44) on the sphere, the element of lenght is ds2 = g\p(£)d£\d£p, with g\p(£) the induced metric, -
tt\
dx
-
»
dx
»
From (4.42) and (4.44) one finds ds2 = \ *
X 2
) da2 ,
with da2 = R2d82 + R2 sin2 Odtp2 ,
the square of the element of length on S2. Hence the stereographic mapping corresponds to a conformal mapping. In the literature it is common to consider instead the stereographic mapping of yM = 2x^ onto S2, which leads to the slightly modified formulae [12] 2 o D2
D„ Rr„
2R
r
» -
r
2
+ x
2
X
»
r3
>
~
2 / D2 (R -x„ 22 \R2+x2
\
R
,
(4.45)
and correspondingly ds2 = Cl^da2
2R2 ~ nr R T+ x~ x2
, with QR -
2
'
(4.46)
From (4.46) we see that da2 = gliu(x)dxtldxv
,
with gltv{x) = Sl2R{x)5ltv
•
(4.47)
The integration measure on the stereographic sphere is ^fgd2x, with g = det(g^) 8
£i i £2 correspond to £1 , £2 defined earlier.
= QR
.
(4.48)
77
4.2 Functional Determinant, one-loop diagram
The Dirac operator (4.4) will be of central importance in our discussions. We now show how to project it from SR2 onto the stereographic sphere. Proposition 1 i l ^
= ^n2R(x)VHsablab
+ l)V
,
(4.49)
where
and where sab, lab are the spin and orbital angular momentum operators, Sab — 2€abc&c
With pa = \-gr Proof: Using
,
Lb = raPb ~ HPa
,
(4.50)
. M
1 ( dx„\
d
i \drfij
dxv
it is a simple algebraic exercise to show that, • a
i-
iRR2-x2
A ~ M ~ „ ~ „ , -arii
R2
2
J
H
As a consequence, we have for lab, ifxv —
tyx^Oy
XJ/O^J
x
,
- — {R2 -x2)d,j,
h^ = -^ llxvdv
.
Using these results proposition 1 is verified by explicit algebraic calculation. Relation (4.49) converts the Dirac operator «7M9M into the hyperspherical operator SabLb + 1Proposition 2
p = -^n2R(x)vHsabLab + i)v , where Lab = lab + lab, with lab given by e lab = --^(raAb
-rbAa)
,
and A.=
\&
+ *iAp
+
! g A .
,
•
(4.51)
78
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Proof: First of all, we check, that A^ lives in the tangent space of the stereographic sphere: raAa = 0 . The proof proceeds again algebraically. One finds, after some calculation, "
G
"•
G.
+ ^ ( - R 2 - z 2 )(7 • A) + -jj(x • A)(-y • x)
I = sablab = -e^e^x^Av
.
Using the relation l^lulx
= S^-yx - <5MA7„ + ^A7M
,
one finds after further calculation, fi2 2R\
tt-'-rK^-Jr)*" • R J \ R
Combining this result with our previous result for i @ one obtains [12] (i?+4)
= jp2RViDt3V
,
(4.52)
with Ds2 =1 + sabLab being the Dirac operator on the stereographic sphere.
4.2.3
The associated Dirac operator
The eigenvalue spectrum of the (dimensionless) operator Dsi is, evidently, discrete Ds2un(Q) = A n ti n (fi)
,
(4.53)
where fl stands for the variables (4.44) defined on the sphere. The eigenfunctions are chosen to be orthonormal
/ dSlul(n)um(£l) = 6nm , and are complete, u n (ft)„4(fi')/3 = Sa062(Q - n')
^
.
n
In order to establish the link with the usual Dirac operator, we consider instead of the eigenfunctions un, the functions un defined by Un = RVun
.
From (4.52) and (4.53) it then immediately follows that i flun = X„QRun
,
(4.54)
4.2 Functional Determinant, one-loop diagram where A„ = \n/R.
79
Since
w - ^ - n i ' . * = > ' = $*' it follows from (4.53) that, / d2xftR(x)ul(x)um{y)
= 6nm
,
YJ^n{x)av)n{y)fi=^-R152{x-y)
(4.55) .
(4.56)
Hence, solving the eigenvalue problem (4.53) is equivalent to solving the associated eigenvalue problem (4.54) with (4.55) and (4.56). Since ,/g = fi^j, expressions (4.55) and (4.56) are not yet in the standard form. In order to get them in standard form, define __i
u„ = n R 2 u „
,
(4.57)
i $> = ttx*i # f t |
•
(4.58)
Then the eigenvalue problem reads i $>un = \iiin
,
(4.59)
with
^2un{x)aun(y)0
= —5a05{2)(x-y)
.
One easily verifies that the operator i p is Hermitian with respect to the measure dPxyfg. The usefulness of the stereographic projection resides in the following observation. Consider the functional ew<*>
fVipv^e-f42*^™
fThpThf>e~S'px^*^*
where we have assumed the Jacobian of the transformation tp -»• ip to cancel in the ratio. (This we expect to be true if the dimension of the space spanned by V> and i> is the same, i.e., if there are no zero-modes). Expand now tp in terms of the eigenfunctions of i fi{i 0), r/i = J^r bnun and make the change of variable fVifjVifi -> / Y[n dbndb„. We then obtain (the last manipulation is formal) efrip-ui9)
=
U^njA]
I1M0]
=
detifi
detifi
=
det[Si^i
$0.%) _ detiT/)
det[fi~*i 0fi£]
deti
9
Hence, as a result of the underlying conformal invariance, the dependence on R formally drops out, if there are no zero modes. (See section 4.8 for a more detailed discussion of this point).
80
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Vortex on the stereographic sphere Let us emphasize that the one-point compactification of the Dirac operator discussed above presupposes that the gauge field A^ lives on the corresponding compact manifold M. This will be the case if A^ tends to a pure gauge-field configuration at infinity, i.e. ->• g-1{x)dfig{x)
eA^x)
,
g{x) € SU{N)
.
(4.61)
\x\ —• oo
Afj, then exists on coordinate patches of M., as we now illustrate. Example: Let A^ be given by the U(l) vortex-field
we have A^x)
-»• ~-e^x^
= \d»k
,
(4.63)
with A(x) = narcctn—. Hence the vortex-field (4.62) has the property (4.61) of being pure gauge at infinity. As we now show, it admits, as a consequence, a one-point compactification if n is an integer. Identifying Euclidean infinity with a circle of radius R -> oo , and parametrizing £1,2 on this circle by R and an angle 6, Xi = RsinO, x2 = Rcos9, we have A(R,0)=n6
.
(4.64)
Hence (4.62) corresponds to the Pontryagin number n: 2 fddh x
fdn
According to (4.51) the field corresponding to A^ on the stereographic sphere of radius R is given by > J" =
iM = - ^ e ^ ^
1 2
.
» 43=0
.
Let us write Aa, a = 1,2,3, in terms of the coordinates of that sphere, with the south pole identified with Euclidean infinity. From (4.45) and (4.43) we have R sin 9 cos ip 1 + cos 9
R sin 6 sin
Defining a unit vector tangent to the stereographic sphere, pointing in the azimuthal direction ev = (— sin<£,cos?) we have [7] A
n
sin<9
„
~
4.3 Calculating Seeley Coefficients
81
We see that A does not exist globally on the stereographic sphere, but only on a patch which excludes the south pole. We could have considered however equally well a stereographic mapping where the north pole is identified with infinity. In that case one obtains -, _ 4
n
sin#
„
-, _
=
2^Rl-cos96'p
'
^3
=
°
'
Thus A and A' live on two different, but overlapping patches defined by (7)
- 7T < 9 < 7T ,
(II)
0 < 6 < 27T
respectively. In the region of overlap, both A and A' are defined and are in fact related by Al
A
U
eRsmv Recalling that „ d Id I d 5 = e'rQr _ — + ~<>rd6 e - — + ~vrsm6d
i->^
f**i
j
'
we therefore see that ^4' is just the gauge transformation of A, A' = A + -VA e
,
with A given by (4.64). A' and A thus differ by a bonafide gauge transformation if n is integer. Correspondingly gauge invariant quantities exist in this case globally on the stereographic sphere.
4.3
Calculating Seeley Coefficients
There exists a variety of methods for computing the Seeley coefficients. Among these the method of Gilkey is quite general and allows for the computation of the Seeley coefficients of a very large class of not necessarily positive semi-definite operators. We shall however discuss more pragmatic approaches such as the perturbative approach, as well as the methods of Schwinger-DeWitt and Fujikawa.
4.3.1
The perturbative approach
The perturbative method involves an iterative procedure for solving the heat-kernel equation in terms of a power series expansion in the potential describing the deviation of the operator in question from the non-interacting case. We illustrate the procedure for the case of the Euclidean Laplace-Beltrami operator A = -^dagaby/g-db v9
,
(4.65)
82
Determinants and Heat Kernels
with g = det gab{x), where gab(x) is the Euclidean metric denned on a two-dimensional manifold M. The operator (4.65) will play a central role in Chapter 18. The functional determinant of (4.65) is invariant under conformal transformations (see Chapter 18), so that we are free to calculate it in the so-called conformal gauge, where the Euclidean metric tensor gab takes the form 9ab(x) = e*W6ab
,
with 4>{x) a conformal Weyl field. Correspondingly we have for Eq. (4.65) in the conformal gauge A = e-^d2 , d2 = Sabdadb • (4.66) To obtain the Seeley expansion of the corresponding heat kernel h = etA we follow the procedure adopted by O. Alvarez [13] by writing Eq. (4.66) in the form A = 82 + V
,
where V=(e-*-l)d2
.
In operator notation, the corresponding heat-kernel equation (4.26) can then be written in the form (dt - d2)h = Vh which, taking account of the initial condition (4.27) is readily shown to be equivalent to the integral equation
h(t;t,V) = h0(t;t-r])+JdtlJd2l;'h0(t-t';t-e)V(l;')h(tl;e-V)
.
(4.67)
where ho(t; £—£') is the matrix element of the heat-kernel ho — eta for the Laplacian —d2 in two-dimensional flat space,
M*;e-?) = ^ e - ^ , also satisfying the initial condition (4.27). By setting £ = r\ and iterating this equation, we obtain from here the Seeley-DeWitt asymptotic power series expansion in the parameter t. It is easy to see that to order 0(y/i) it is sufficient to consider the first iteration of Eq. (4.67) :
h(t; £, 0 ~ Mi; 0) + / df J d2d'h0{t - *'; f - £')Vtf)W\ £' ~ 0 • (4-68) Hence to this order, we can regard the potential as a perturbation. The calculation is simplified by using the conformal invariance in order to make a judicious choice of coordinates. Selecting a particular point f' in our manifold M, one can choose local conformal coordinates such that the Weyl field appearing in the conformal factor in (4.66), as well as its first derivative, vanish at that point:
0(0=0,
0„0(O = O
(4-69)
83
4.3 Calculating Seeley Coefficients
We choose (4.69) to hold at the point £ labeling the left-hand side of equation (4.68). Noting that in the limit of interest, t -» 0, the free heat kernel h0 in Eq. (4.67) is exponentially damped for £' away from the point £, we conclude that we need to know the potential V(£') only in a small neighbourhood of the point £, where properties (4.69) are supposed to hold. Assuming <j>{x) to be a smooth function of x around x = £, it can be regarded as small in this neighbourhood, so that we are allowed to make the approximation
v(o ^ -\(e - zne - tfdadtma2 + o((e - o3) • Equation (4.68) reduces correspondingly to
f dt' f d2C
h{t;Z,0~h0(t;Q)+
x ho(t - t';e - o \-\(e - tne - obdadb
^^0
= -^-t-^d24>(0+O(Vi) .
(4.70)
This is the desired DeWitt-Seeley expansion for the Laplace-Beltrami operator in the conformal gauge. The corresponding determinant is going to be computed at the end of section 4.5.
4.3.2
The Schwinger-DeWitt method
This method involves a recursive procedure based on the coincidence limit of well known Schwinger's proper-time representation of the heat-kernel. We illustrate it for a class of differential operators of particular interest to us. The result is contained in the following Theorem: Let A be the Hermitian order-two operator defined on 5Rd, A = DlDli+X
,
X* = X
,
(4.71)
with Dfj, = dfj, — iAp, where A^ and X are Hermitian matrix valued fields. Then, (x | e- e A | x) = — — r [ l + ai(*)e + a2(x)e2 • • •] (47re) 2
with ax = -X a
2 = \x2-\{D2X)
+ ^[Dll,Dv]2
.
(4.72)
Determinants and Heat Kernels
84
Proof: We seek solutions to the heat equation 9 {-
+ (DlDtl+X)}h(t;x,y)=0
,
with the initial condition, h(0;x,y)
= 6^{x-y)
.
(4.73)
The singular behaviour (4.73) in x, y suggests making the Ansatz h(t; x, y) = f(t; x, y)h0{t; x, y)
,
(4.74)
with h0(t;x,y)
=
e~» , (Ant) 2 and a = |(a; — y)2. The function ho satisfies the equation (--A)ho(t;x-y) = 0
,
h0(0;x-y)
.
(4.75)
(4.76)
with the initial condition = 6^(x-y)
Now,
£>],£>„ = -d^ + itfM a u
+ 2iA„dll + A^
d a
» u
A simple calculation yields, using (4.76) DlD^fho
= ho(DlD^f)
- h0 ( ^ ) (£>t -
Dll)f
- h0dtf
.
Substitution of the Ansatz (4.74) into the above equation then leads to a differential equation for / itself:
3
Af-?£{Dl-Dlt)f
+ dtf = Q .
(4.77)
Following de Witt [15, 7] we make the Ansatz f(t;x,y)
= b0(x,y) + h(x,y)t
+ b2(x,y)t2
+ •••
,
substitute into Eq. (4.77), and compare powers in t, obtaining r1
: tl :
9
d^aD^bo = 0
,
Abt - ^a{Dl - D^)bl+1 + (I+ l)bl+1=
(4.78) 0,1 = 0,1,-••
(4.79)
We omit specification of the operator A in the argument of the heat-kernel and zeta function.
4.3 Calculating Seeley Coefficients
85
Let us denote the coincidence limit y —>• x by bi(x,x) - [bi](x) = at(x)
.
From the initial condition (4.73) one has a0 = [b0] = 1
•
In general we have for I > 0, ai = --[Abi-i]
,
where the bracket denotes the coincidence limit y —> x. Calculation of a-i From (4.79) we have ai(x)
= [Ab0] = [DlDpboKx) +X(x)
.
Now, from to the parallel-transport equation (4.78) one finds, [£>+DM6o]=0
.
Hence we finally obtain ai = -[Abo] = -X
.
The calculation of the higher Seeley coefficients by the de Witt method becomes increasingly involved. We leave the calculation of a-i as an illustration using the Fujikawa method in the following subsection. Example 1: The Dirac operator of
QED2/QCD2
As we have seen, the Seeley coefficients are defined for compact, semi-positive operators. Hence the above technique is not directly applicable to the Dirac operator (4.4). We can however circumvent this problem by making the following observation: from (4.31) we have
as;x,x\^m
= E'"U*xlyX)
•
Here An and un are the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the eigenvalue problem (4.59), and the sum extends over the positive and negative eigenvalues A„. Using (4.57), (4.58) and (4.48) one has
^as;x,x\(i$>)2)
= nR(x)as-,x,x\(im2)
with
tr C ( S ;,,,|(^) 2 ) = E '
! f
^
M
,
(4.80)
86
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Furthermore, defining
A„>0
*•
n
'
A„<0
n
*•
'
and using the fact, that for every eigenvalue A > 0 of i P with eigenfunction un there exists an eigenvalue — A < 0 with eigenfunction 75 un, one has tr((0;x,x\iP)=tr((0;x,x\{ifl)2) tT{'(0;x,x
, \ (i J?)2)
\i $>) =-tiC'(0;x,x
(4.81) .
(4.82)
It thus suffices to calculate the Seeley coefficients a& of D = (i P)2, with i fl = ift+ e 4
,
(4.83)
and A^ a Hermitian Lie algebra valued field. They are related to the Seeley coefficients dfc of (i p)2 by ^fgak = ^Rdk- We have {iip)2 = D\D^X
,
(4.84)
with X=-biinAF^
,
(4-85)
and Fpu = d^A,, - dvA^ - i[A^ Av\
.
(4.86)
Hence it follows from (4.81) and (4.82), ai = - j [ 7 / i . 7 ^ ] ^
-
(4-87)
and in two dimensions, 10 e ai = -zlh^vF^
4.3.3
.
(4.88)
T h e Fujikawa m e t h o d
It is remarkable that the Seeley coefficients do not depend on the dimension of spacetime. This is easily understood in the context of the Fujikawa approach where one departs from h(t;x,y\D)=e-tD*S2(x-y) , (4.89) and represents the ^-function as a Fourier integral. Expression (4.89) then takes the form h(t;x,y\D) = J-^e-^ie-^e^)
.
Let D be again the square of the Dirac operator, D = (i fl)2. We expand the exponential in powers of tDx. To this end it is economical to treat e~tDew'x as 10
In d = 2 our conventions are if^-y5 = e^vlv
and \[l^,lv)
= if-y.v'V'•
(4.90)
4.3 Calculating Seeley Coefficients
87
an operator acting on some function f(x) to be set equal to 1 at the end of the calculation. Noting that e-ipxD»eipx =ip^ + Dfi , and e~ipxDeipx
= p2 - 2ip• D + D
,
we have for the diagonal part of the heat kernel after a rescaling \fip = k, 2
,x\D) = J- d k
-(k2-2iy/tk-D+tD)
or expanding in powers of t, we have h(t;x,x\D)
e~k2 ^
= —
- fey/ik • D - t£>)
.
(4.91)
1=0
We now expand the binomial as i
(2iVik • D - tD) =J2
(-)l~jt'~i/2(2ik-D)jDl-j
J2
,
(4.92)
j=0 dist.perm
where the sum over all distinct permutations replaces the usual binomial factors, since the binomial involves non-commuting operators. Noting that the terms odd in kfj, give a vanishing contribution to the integral, we can set j = 2r. Collecting the terms of a given order in t, we can cast (4.91) into the form of a Seeley expansion h(t;x,x\D)
= Y^tmam{x)
,
(4.93)
ra=0
with the Seeley coefficients given by 11 (4.94) r=0
dist.perm
The Gaussian k integration is elementary. Using in particular d
f ddakk J ird/2 Id 1
/ ^72 ddk
/
e
2 k
k k
* i*k»= <W
.
(4-95)
1
—JJ^ e~ can k^Kk\kp + 5y.\8ofvpthe + S^S^x) Actually these coefficients be shown= to-(S^Sxp be independent dimension, of space-time d. This is the consequence of the independence of the fc-integration of d. 11
88
Determinants and Heat Kernels
performing the permutations in (4.92) and setting equal to zero all terms involving differential operators acting on a constant to the right, one finds for the first two non-trivial Seeley coefficients the result oi = -X
(4.96)
a2 = \x2
4.4
- liD^X)
+ ^[D^,D„][D„
Dv] .
Computing Functional Determinants
Although £(0 | D) may generally be calculated exactly in terms of the Seeley coefficients, a similar computation of UID = In det'D
,
will only be possible for a restricted class of operators. All methods are based on the behaviour of det D under an infinitesimal change D —> D + SD. They however correspond to different regularization procedures. 4.4.1
(-function regularization
Here one departs from the definition [6, 16, 17] wD = -('(0\D)
,
and considers the infinitesimal variation 5UID =
a.c.
-±(((s\D
+
8D)-as\D))
s->0
= a.c.^-\sti'{D-s-15D)} , J s-»o ds L where a.c. stands for analytic continuation and tr' denotes the trace over the subspace orthogonal to the zero-modes of D. In the case where tr'(D~s~15D) admits an analytic extension to s = 0, one evidently has 6wD = [ti'(D-,-16D)]s=o
•
(4-97)
Comparing this result with aetU as obtained by using the familiar property lnde*D = trlnZ?
,
(4.99)
of determinants, we see that (4.97) defines a particular regularization of the generally divergent trace (4.98).
4.4 Computing Functional Determinants
89
The variation (4.97) is explicitely computable in terms of the corresponding Seeley coefficients if D~15D is of the form D-15D
= ^2D~'y"pnD^
,
(4.100)
n
with 7„ natural numbers and {pn} local operators with the property = Pn(x)6d{x-y)
(x\pn\y)
.
Indeed, using the cyclicity of the trace, we find in this case 6wD = {tr[D-sD'18D]}
= {^
= I dn(x)ti[C(0;x,x
| D's
f dfi(x)ti[(x
| D)p(x)}
\ x)pn{x)]}
_
,
(4.101)
where
= ]T>» • Hence for 5D of the form (4.100), cients a,k{x | D).
SUJD
is computable in terms of the Seeley coeffi-
Example : QED2 axial anomaly Consider the Euclidean chiral U(l) transformation i p -s- e 75,5e(l) i jp e^W
,
(4.102)
which implies (actually valid for arbitrary 56), 6(i JJ)) = i #>75<50 + j5S6i
Defining D = (if))2,
TJ) .
we have, correspondingly 6D = lh56D +
2VD-J566\/D
+ Dj556
,
(4.103)
where y/D = i1J). The result (4.103) falls into the category of variations (4.100). Using the cyclicity of the trace we have from (4.101), using (4.37), 5tu{ip) = l-5uj(ip)2 =l-fd2xAtr
fe&
- P<°>(x,x)\
l556(x)
.
In the absence of zero-modes we thus have, using (4.85), 5oj{ip) = J d2x A(x)56{x)
,
(4.104)
where Ax)
= ^r^F^(x)
.
Z7T
is just the anomaly in the divergence of the axial vector current.
(4.105)
90
Determinants and Heat Kernels
4.4.2
Proper-time regularization
Consider representation (4.30) for the ^-function. We have C(s;x,y
T'(s) r°° dt p ^ J jts[h(r;x,y
| D) = -
+
\ D) -
TtSlntlh(t>x'y\D)-p°(x>y^
W)I
P0(x,y)}
( 4 - 106 )
•
For s > 0 the integral converges, and we may replace /0°° by / ° ° . Keeping e > 0, we may now go over to the limit s -t 0, obtaining the alternative (proper-time) representation [13] ytr(e-tD-P0)
.
(4.107)
Note that the projector PQ insures that the integral converges at t = oo. We now derive the analog of Eq. (4.97) in the proper-time regularization scheme. Consider again the case where zero-modes are absent. Then uD+6D - *D = - J" j tr( e - ' < » + " » - e~tD) . Now, e-t(D+6D)
tr( e-^D+SD^
_
e-tD
=
_ f1
dX e-XtD{tSD)
Jo tD - e~ ) = -t tr e~tDSD
e(X-l)tD
^
.
Hence, OO
8OJ
/
dtti e~tD5D = tr{e~eDD^SD)
.
(4.108)
Comparing this result with (4.97) we see that (4.108) and (4.97) represent the proper-time and C-function regularization of the formal expression (4.98), respectively. If D~1SD is a local operator, we need to know only the small e expansion of the diagonal elements of e~eD', as given by the Seeley expansion (4.20), i.e. {x\ e-eD\x)
= -\T[a0+ea1 (47re) m
Example: QED2 axial anomaly From (4.103), (4.108) and (4.109) we have -SU>D
in agreement with (4.104).
= / d2x
A(x)56(x)
+ ---]
.
(4.109)
4.4 Computing Functional Determinants
4.4.3
91
T h e Fujikawa point of view
The functional 5U>D can also be viewed as the logarithm of the Jacobian of the transformation VcDc —> Vc'Vd, in (4.6), as we now show. This is the point of view taken by Fujikawa [18] who was the first to develop a method for studying chiral anomalies in the path-integral framework without resorting to perturbation theory. Fujikawa's observation of the non-invariance of the fermionic measure VtpVip in QED under chiral transformations provided an important break-through in the conceptual understanding of chiral anomalies from the path-integral point of view. In particular, it provides a systematic method for a transparent derivation of anomalous chiral Ward-Takahashi identities within a purely path integral framework, without the need of explicitly adding anomalous terms — calculated from Feynman graphs — to the action. In fact, it is understood by now that all known anomalies can be viewed as being a result of the non-invariance of the functional measure under some symmetry transformation [19, 20]. Nevertheless, as we now demonstrate, Fujikawa's approach is just another variant of what was said above. In the Fujikawa approach the definition of det ^ t " l D D> in terms of the path-integral (4.6) represents the starting point. He considers the situation where the transition from D to D + 6D can be seen as a change of variable of integration. Thus consider det[D + 6D] __ det[D] ~
JVcVce-^D+5D^ JVcVce-SM
(4 110)
'
'
with S[D] = f ddxcDc
.
Now, S[D + 5D] = f{c(l
+ ^8DD~X)D(\
+ 0({6D)2)
+ ^D^SD)^
.
Hence, redefining the fields as c -» c' = (1 + -D-l5D)c
,
c ^ ^ ^ l
+ W
1
)
,
(4.111)
2,
L
we have S[D + SD] = fddxc'Dc' formation (4.111), defined by
+ 0({SD)2).
Hence the Jacobian J of the trans-
VcVc = JVc'Vc1
,
(4.112)
•
< 4 - 113 )
is just the l.h.s. of Eq. (4.110), that is T J
=
det(D + 5D) detD
To evaluate the Jacobian factor we expand c(c) in a complete set of orthonormal functions (fn: c a; = ( ) ~52an
92
Determinants and Heat Kernels dv(x)
/
where an(an) are elements of an infinite Grassmann algebra. We have a corresponding expansion for c' and c' with coefficients a' and a!. The connection between the two sets of coefficients is given in terms of a unitary transformation, a1 — Ua
,
a' = a'U
,
where (we assume again D~X5D to be local operators), dfi(x)^prn(x)-D~18D(pn(x)
Umn = Smn+
,
1
+ / dfj,(x)(pm(x)-SDD
(fn(x)
.
Now, using the property (4.99) of determinants, we have Y[ da'nda'n = Y[ dandan e~tr n
ln
< Ft/ >
.
n
Note that due to the Grassmann character of the a„'s, the Jacobi determinant is just the inverse of what one has in the usual (bosonic) case [21]. With the usual replacement
VcVc -» Yl d^n I I d a n n
'
(4.115)
n
one has VcVc=
e=S„/
(i
''(I)^(1)(l!DB~l+D"1,SD)^(I)Dc'Dc'
Since J^ n ipn{x)Tpn{x) — 5(0), the above expression is divergent and in general requires regularization. Formally we have however VcDc=
etrD~l5DVc'Vc'
,
or, with the definition of J given by (4.112), \-aJ = tTD-l5D
= 5ujD
,
(4.116)
in agreement with (4.113) and (4.98). Note that the change in sign in ln J relative to the bosonic case was essential for this agreement. Although the calculation of (4.116) cannot depend on the choice of basis functions, it will depend on the choice of regulator. The choice of regulator depends on the symmetry one wishes to preserve. It should however be chosen such as to make the trace in (4.116) well defined. Fujikawa considered [18] the case of D being the square of the Dirac operator i P, and 8D as corresponding to the chiral transformation (4.103).12 For this case (56 is to be regarded as an operator) 5w{m2 12
= Iim4tr[e-£'D75<5(9]
,
(4.117)
Actually Fujikawa considered the active point of view of calculating directly the Jacobian J of the transformation (4.102).
93
4.4 Computing Functional Determinants
where e~eD is a damping factor introduced in order to regulate the trace. Fujikawa chose a manifestly gauge invariant regularization with D = (i fl)2. His evaluation of the trace (4.116) did not make use of Seeley's expansion, but followed the procedure to be outlined next. Write (4.117) in the form Sutf, = f ddxA(x)56{x)
,
(4.118)
with A{x)=2]imYi
.
(4.119)
n
Note that A corresponds to a regularization of Y^n iPnix)l5'Pn(x) which Fujikawa has referred to as primary definition of anomaly [18]. In terms of Areg the Jacobian (4.116) reads for a finite chiral rotation J(0)
2
=eifd
x8(x)A(x)
_
(4.120)
Although the choice of
as an operator)
(i V>)2 eipx = {-D^D^ + X) eipx , [-DuD* + X] eipx = eipx [(p„ - *£>M)2 + X] . Hence, A(x) = 2 lim t r i 75 / 7 ^ 7d e-^-2ip.D-D»+x] £->o+ |^ J (27r)
\ J
Making the change of variable yfep — k and expanding the resulting integrand in powers of e one sets A(x) = 2£lrm+ ~ ttfafj^
e~k2[l + 2iVik • D+eV2-eX
+
For two dimensions we need not compute higher order terms in e. Using JA-4s e~fc2 = -^, and tr7 5 = 0, we have for the axial anomaly A=-—ti{j5X}=^-e^F^
,
(4.121)
which, when substituted into (4.118), yields (4.105). The fact that no further subtraction is needed is a consequence of working in two dimensions.
94
Determinants and Heat Kernels
The result (4.121) agrees with our earlier calculations, and demonstrates explicitly the independence of the result on the choice of basis. The same result is obtained by working with the eigenfunctions of i qi [13]. On the other hand, working with the regulator 1 = lime_>o e~e(-l^> , one finds A = 0, i.e. a trivial Jacobian [22]. (This is evident from the above calculation leading to (4.121)). , 4 = 0 corresponds, as we shall see, to the absence of an anomaly in the divergence of the axial vector current, although at the expense of gauge invariance. Indeed it is well known, that there exists no regularization respecting both gauge and chiral invariance. Basically one is confronted with defining what has been referred to by Fujikawa [18] as the primary anomaly, i.e. A = 2^
amounts to computing n
where An are the eigenvalues of i JJ). As was shown by Fujikawa, the replacement
where f(z) is any smooth function which rapidly converges to zero as z —> oo, leads to the same result for A, thus indicating that the sum representing the primary anomaly is conditionally convergent. Formally this sum states that A = 2 t r 7 5 . The fact that it does not vanish - contrary to what one would naively expect has its origin [24] in the spectral asymmetry of the operator P, which in fact conforms to the Atiyah-Singer theorem [25] (see section 7). This is exemplified by the aforementioned non-covariant choice of the regulator, which leads to a vanishing anomaly. It is interesting that conventional perturbation theory is in agreement with this chiral asymmetry, if a gauge invariant, Pauli-Villars regularization is employed. In the path-integral framework, the anomalous Ward identity for the divergence of the axial vector current now emerges as follows [26]: the Pauli-Villars regularization of the fermion-loop diagrams is equivalent to the addition of Cpv = (pi ft(p — M
v~4>V4> = j-xv~$v$
,
showing the invariance of VipVipVcpVcp for finite Pauli-Villars mass. The corresponding Ward identity now follows in the normal way [27] from the transformation property of the modified Lagrangian under the simultaneous local chiral transformations ip(x) ->• eia(xh^(x) and
4.5 A Theorem on a one parameter family of factorizable operators 95 One obvious way consists in considering the operator i ft 4- i ^ 7 5 obtained by analytical continuation from A^ to iA^, and then to continue back at the end of the calculation. It is not surprising that the final result is found to agree with the result obtained by naive application of the ^-function method to the non-Hermitian operator ip. Another approach was considered by Fujikawa [27]. It consists, in considering the eigenfunctions of the Hermitian, positive semi-definite operators ft ft andftft: $P
= \l
;
W V n ( z ) = >?nn{x)
,
An G R
.
For a suitable choice of phase this corresponds to ft
!
ft
4>n = Kfn
•
(4.122)
The Fujikawa analysis is then repeated by expanding tp(ip) in terms of the complete set of eigenfunctions tpn{4>n)- Since a gauge transformation induces a similarity transformation on ft ft andftft, the eigenvalues A„ are gauge invariant. Hence the outcome of the calculation will be gauge invariant and thus cannot coincide with the result obtained by analytic continuation in A^.
4.5
A Theorem on a one parameter family of factorizable operators
Starting from the proper-time representation (4.107) for the determinant of an operator, we now prove a theorem about a class of operators, which will play an important role in our discussion of two-dimensional gauge-theories. Theorem: [30] Let Kr be an invertible operator parametrized by r having the polar decomposition Kr = nrQfir , (4.123) where fir and Q,r are local operators in d dimensions, (x\nr\y)
= nr(x)6d(x-y) d
(x\nr\y)=Tir(x)6 (x-y)
, ,
satisfying the boundary conditions fi0 = ^o = 1, and where Q does not depend on r. Define (r):= In detK$Kr . Then T"^ ar
= 7 7 - 7 X / d2xti(Wr(x)+Wr(x)) (47re)'« J
(Airs) ™
fd2xtT{Wr(x)a^(x)
+ Wr(x)b^(x)}
(4.124) + 0(e2
96
Determinants and Heat Kernels
where Wr(x) and Wr(x) are the Hermitian matrix valued functions (the dot denotes differentiation with respect to r)
wr(x) = {nr{x)n;1(x)) + ((ir(x)n-1{x))^ Wr{x)
1
= (fi; {x)nr(x))
,
(4.125)
,
(4.126)
1
+ (fi~ {x)Ur(x))i
and where a\- and b\- ' are the coincidence limits of the first non-trivial Seeley coefficients in the small e expansion of the heat kernel associated with KrK\ and K\KT respectively: (x | e-'K*Kl
| x) = - 4 - r [ l + eal»{x) + 0(e2)]
,
(4.127)
.
(4.128)
(Aire) m
(x | e " ^ * - | x) =
+ebW(x)
-±-T[1
+ 0(s2)}
(47T£)-
Proof: To begin with, notice that the theorem makes a statement about a very special variation 5ru>D of a particular class of positive-definite operators which are parametrized by r. We have (for the time being we exclude the possibility of zero modes) U(r)
= - [°°-tie-tKlK*
.
Je t Differentiating with respect to r we have dtti{(klKr
+ KlKT)e-tK*K*}
.
(4.129)
Now, K\Kr
= K\{tlrSl-x)Kr
+ KlKr^tr)
.
Introducing these expressions in (4.129), using the cyclicity of the trace and the property we find ti{(KlKT
+ KtKr) e~tK^}
= ti{WrKrKl
e~tK^
+ Wr K\Kr
e~tK^}
= _ ± tl{Wr e-tKrKi + Wr e-tK±Kr} ) (4130) dr where Wr and Wr have been defined in (4.125) and (4.126). Upon substituting (4.130) into (4.129), the ^-integration may now be trivially performed, to yield ib{r) = tr[W r e-eK^
+ Wr e~eK^\
.
Making use of (4.127) and (4.128), we obtain the announced result (4.124). By integrating this expression in r from r = 0 to r = 1 we can in principle obtain det(KjKi) det S
In-
4.5 A T h e o r e m on a one p a r a m e t e r family of factorizable o p e r a t o r s Example: The QED2
97
determinant
Parametrizing the gauge field A^ in the Lorentz gauge as A^x)
= ^vdv0{x)
,
(4.131)
we have for the corresponding Dirac operator i If) = (ifi + w^duO)
5
b
»i 0e> aPi <> = e„77""t
We define the corresponding one-parameter family of operators Kr = e'^'i
Ve'i*9
,
corresponding to the gauge connection A£' {x) — rA^ (x), and Q = i $, ftr = fir = er^e. We obtain correspondingly from (4.125) and (4.126), Wr = Wr = 2-y59, so that (4.124) reduces for £• = 1 to duj f d2 = r I —^ tr (ai(x)"f56(x)) dr
= re f —^
6(x)elll,Ffiu(x)
Integration from r = 0 to r = 1 yields, upon solving (4.131) for 6(x), w(l)-w(0)=ln
det(t P)2
det(i 0) 2 ,2
= - ^
f d2x f d2yeXpFXp{x)DE{x-y)efu/Ffll/(y)
= -£ J d2x j'd2yAtl(5»v-d-^)Av
, (4.132)
.
In the Lorentz gauge, (4.132) reduces to the familiar Schwinger result [31]. Example: Beltrami-Laplace operator in conformal gauge The general idea underlying the derivation of the above theorem may be applied to a quick calculation of the functional determinant of the operator (4.66). For
,
and correspondingly w(r) = In detMj. . Using the heat-kernel representation of the functional determinant, we have dt tr (
98
Determinants and Heat Kernels
or making use of the Seeley expansion (4.70), 1 iwe
u(r) = - I d2x
r 12?r
(4.133)
Integrating with respect to r from r = 0 to r — 1 we finally obtain In
det(e-^a2) _ 2
det(d )
1 24TT
fd2x
(4.134)
Since this result is quadratic in <j>, we can now drop the restriction on
4.6
The QCD2 functional determinant
The QCD2 effective action has been computed in a variety of ways. As examples we shall discuss in Chapter 11 the perturbative procedure, as well as the method of Polyakov and Wiegmann based on the integration of the anomaly equation for the axial vector current. Here we shall present a method based on heat-kernel techniques. The first calculations based on this approach have been restricted to the so-called "decoupling" gauge. Shortcomings of these calculations are that the corresponding gauge conditions (Alvarez's integrability conditions [13]) cannot be globally implemented, except for SU{2). The calculation below does not rely on such a choice of gauge [30]. Indeed, we may apply theorem (4.124) to a gauge-independent computation of W[J4]. TO this end we notice that in two dimensions A± can always be written in the form eA.. = Vid-V-1
,
eA+ = U'^id+U
eAll = ^{6llv-iellv)Vdl,V-1
,
(4.135)
+ ±{6llv+iellv)U-1dvU
,
with U and V taking values in SL(N, C), the complexification of We now rewrite the Dirac operator using the identity 7/lJ 4 M
= nP-VidyV-1
+ lvP+U~HdvU
(4.136)
SU(N).
,
with P+(~) the projector on right- (left-) handed fermions, P± = | ( 1 ± 75) . Define
v
0
1 u-M
'
u n-( ~\o
°v
u
Then,
o-ao f ° ^^=[_u-id+u_d+ = ifi + e4
Vd-V^ + d0
.
The Dirac operator thus has the structure of (4.123).
(4.137)
4.6 The QCD2 functional determinant
99
In order to apply the theorem (4.124), we define interpolating fields Ur and Vr depending on a continuous parameter r 6 [0,1], subject to the boundary conditions Ur{x):
U0(x) = l
,
U1(x) = U(x)
,
Vr(x):
V0(x) = l
,
Vl{x) = V{x)
,
with a corresponding definition of Clr, fir and A^J'. Then (4.137) becomes,
Now (compare with (4.84)) (i B[A^}f
= -DMD£)
- ^e^Ftf
,
where, F$ = d„AP-dvAP -ie[AP,AP] = [DP,DP]. Hence the corresponding first non-trivial Seeley coefficients is given by (see (4.88)) a{{\x)
= \l^vF^}
.
(4.138)
Following the notation of (4.125) and (4.126), we furthermore have
^=i'*T c>-Vi+^ Wr=[
U^Ur r r n 0
0
T „>_1 VrV-
)+hc.
Now, from A± = AT we deduce that U* = V
,
V* = U
,
so that Wr = (U-1Ur-VrV-1)l6
.
Furthermore, Wr = Wr. Applying formula (4.124) and using (4.138) we thus finally have w(r) = ^
J d2xtr[(U-lUr
+ W^^Ffi]
.
(4.139)
We next rewrite the r.h.s. in a manifestly gauge-invariant form. In terms of (4.135), the gauge transform of A^, A^ = g~1Alxg + kg~ldlig, reads eA%=i(g-1U-1)(d+Ug)
,
eAB_=i(g-1V)(d-V-1g)
.
Hence, under gauge transformation, U->Ug
,
V-^g-lV
.
100
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Since the functional determinant should be gauge invariant, we expect it to depend only on the gauge invariant quantity G = UV
.
We therefore define (jrr — Ur Vr
We make now a number of observations, which may be explicitely verified [34]: i) d-.{G-ld+Gr)
= ieV^F^Wr
=
ii) d+(G-ld„Gr)
= ieV^F^lVr
-
ili) G~lGr = V-^U^Ur
- VrV'^Vr
ieV^F^lVr [G-ld+Gr,G-ld-Gr] .
Hence, expression (4.139) for w may be cast into the manifestly gauge invariant, expression JcPxtiUVrG^GrV-^iVrd-iG^d+GjV-1)]
w(r) = i = ^-
2TT
= -^
J
[d2xiv{G-lGTd^{G^d+GT)] +iellv)tx[G-1Grdll(G-1dvGr)]
f ^xiS^
=^ f
(fxtl^Grd^G-^Gr)]
~in J'
.
(4.140)
The first term can be put into a more convenient form. Indeed, tilG^Grd^G-^Gr)]
= a M tr[G7 1 G r (G- 1 a M G r )] + \^tv[{d,G-l)(d,Gr)]
.
Hence, dropping in (4.140) the contribution from the surface term at ir-infinity, and doing the r-integration, we finally obtain, for the (Euclidean) effective action W^[A]
= ~(CJ(1)
- w(0)) = -T^[UV]
,
(4.141)
where r(£)[G] = ^ | c i 2 a ; t r P M G - 1 ) ( ^ G ) ] i 4-7T
/
dr f d 2 a;c^ v tr[(G- 1 S r G r )(C?- 1 a M G r )(G- 1 a i ,G r )]
(4.142)
101
4.7 Zero-modes
is the Euclidean version of the Wess-Zumino-Witten action 13 introduced in Chapter 9. The result (4.141) for W^ B ^[J4] is manifestly gauge-invariant and has also been obtained from perturbation theory [35]. It is remarkable that, except for an overall sign, it has the same form as the Euclidean version of the Wess-Zumino-Witten action Swzw, expression (9.8), for the choice n = 1, which we have denoted here 14
b y r( £ ). Using the Euclidean version of the Polyakov-Wiegmann formula (9.24) introduced in Chapter 9, T^[AB]
= T^[A]
+ VW[B] + -!- fd2xtv[(A-1d+A){Bd-B-1)} 4lT J
(4.143)
and recalling (4.135), we recognize that det(i 0 + e4) = e - ^ / d 2 ^ 2 , e r ( E , ^ ] e r < - > ! v - ]
_
As we shall see in Chapter 14, —T^[U] and — r ^ f V ] are the effective actions of the Dirac fermions with pure right- and a left-coupling to the gauge field, for a chirally symmetric regularization. The first factor above thus shows that a gauge invariant regularization is incompatible with a simple factorization of det(i j& + e A) into a right and left piece! This observation plays a fundamental role in the PolyakovWiegmann method.
4.7
Zero-modes
4.7.1
Axial anomaly equation in t h e presence of zero-modes
The Dirac operator i (jl + e A1 anti-commutes with 75. Hence there exists for every eigenvalue A„ a corresponding eigenvalue of opposite sign. Hence, with A„ the " A s s u m i n g that G(x) tends to the identity (.Attends to pure gauge) as | x |-> 00, we may identify the points at infinity. 3?2 may then be viewed_as a large two-sphere S2. The mapping G from S2 into SU(N) can be extended to a mapping G of a solid ball B, with boundary S 2 , into SU(N). This allows us to write (4.142) as (C123 = 1)
r(B)[G] = i - J d2xtT[(dliG'1)(d"G)} "l^r" /
^"^iMiG
l
diG){G
X
djG){G
l
dkG)]
.
This expression is just twice the equivalent bosonic action obtained by Witten for the case of Majorana fermions, where G defines the mapping from B into O(N). 14 The second (topological) term in (4.142) is often referred to as the Wess-Zumino term, and denoted by T[G]. We shall also refer to it as the Wess-Zumino action and denote it by Swz[G]. The renormalization of the theory with action (4.142) can be discussed [36] along the lines of Coleman's work on the sine-Gordon equation.
102
Determinants and Heat Kernels
eigenvalues of the associated Dirac operator (4.58), we have
A„^0
15
(KY
Introduce the short-hand notation
as\(ip)2)o
A
=as\(im2)-c(s\{im
•,
thus, in the ^-function regularization
±C'(0\(ip)2)\*
W[A] = C'(0\i$>)\* = lim
r_l
^1
2
InA^h,^ A (\2jA]y)\o ' A„^0 y
where the summation extends over all (non-vanishing) eigenvalues. Taking the variational derivative with respect to Aa^, one has \
SW[A] 5A?.(x)
A
linJ V
cSA„ «<5Aj(x) s+l
s->o
+ 0(s)
Now, from the eigenvalue equation (4.54) and the normalization (4.55) follows that / d2xuni pun = Xn or
SXn = X"5Aa(x\ / (FxttRulun SA-(x) "5A-(x)
,
+ u\l(x)e'ylj.taun(x)
.
(4.144)
The first term on the r.h.s. vanishes, since the u n 's are normalized. Hence \p, 1 a^ ^ {XIY 5A°(x) = — 7^6 (XI)' SW
(ui(x)e^taun(x)) Xn
(4.145)
Note that the Dirac Green's function satisfying
iPG(x,y\A)=5W{x-y)
,
has the spectral representation
G(x,y | A)ap = E 15
un(x)au*n(y)p Xn
The spectrum of ip consists of all integers different from zero, each eigenvalue being 2n-fold degenerate. This degeneracy (c-conjugation ) is partially split in the presence of a gauge field A^.
103
4.7 Z e r o - m o d e s
in the absence of zero-modes. Hence the s -> 0 limit in (4.145) can be regarded as a regularization of the familiar (divergent) expression J^(x\A) = -ti(ta^G(x,x\A))
,
for the case that zero-modes are present. Noting that
Vf (uttalllUn) = 0 , we obtain from (4.145) our first result, V?Jl(x\A)=0
,
(4.146)
where we have identified the l.h.s. of (4.145) with the external field current, i.e. e oA^yx) For the axial-vector-current, we expect to have, in analogy to (4.145), ^ x | A ) =-ax.E>[U"(8)^r""(!g)] A
n
"
(4-148)
"
To see this, it is convenient to take W[A, A] = - I n det[i ft + e 4 + ie 4J5]
,
as a starting point, with un, A„ the eigenfunctions corresponding to this new (still Hermitian!) Dirac operator, and to compute 18W[A,A) e 6AaJx) From Jd2xQn(x)ull(x)un(x) in analogy to (4.144),
A=0
_ ^"" 2 ? s->0 t-^ (A „) s + l
= 1 and f cPxu^i
( f Ta " J1 . = \5A .(x)< A=O
A=0
ql + e A" + ieA'~f*>)un = An, we find
eulix^^eiinix)
One therefore obtains from here the expected result, Eq. (4.148). Now, Vf{unhnlstbun)
= -2\n(lRuly5taun
•
hence it follows from (4.148) and (4.80) that V°»J5/(x
I ,4) = 2O fi (z)tr* a 75 C(0; x,x\(i
If))2)
.
(4.149)
The r.h.s. of (4.149) represents the axial anomaly. It can be calculated using the Seeley expansion (4.20). Moreover, in two space-time dimensions the combined equations (4.146) and (4.149) may be integrated to give W[A] itself, as we now illustrate for the case of QED2
104
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Example: Effective action of QED2 For QED2 (without zero-modes) we have (see (4.86)) a x
fi«(a:K(0; x, x I (i ipf)\ 2 \ _= -l( )^
_
e
= iz^e^F^ (4TT) ~ 8?r
.
Recalling further 17^75 = eM„7„, we have 75 - e
7
or the equations (4.146) and (4.149) now read dMJM = 0 , dllJll = ~€liVF'lv
(4.150) (4.151)
.
Z7T
This anomaly equation has the solution Jfl{x\eA)
= -^ j ' d2ydlDE{x-y)e^F^+d^
,
(4.152)
where T is an up to now arbitrary function, which is however restricted by Eq. (4.151) to satisfy t\T = 0. If JM is to be normalizable, then T can only be a constant. Thus JM is determined, and it remains only to integrate equation (4.147), with JM(a: | A) given by (4.152). In the present example this is easily done, and the result is just (4.132). This illustrates how in two dimensions the effective action itself may be obtained by the joint integration of the equations for the divergence of the vector and axial vector current. Note that this is a non-trivial property of two dimensions. Although the anomaly is also computable in four dimensions, the same is not true for the effective action. In the preceding example, W[A] was obtained by integrating (4.147). This was easily done, since JM (a; | A) was found to be a linear functional of A^. In the general case this integration is formally also possible, as we next show.
4.7.2
Atiyah-Singer Index Theorem
The Atiyah-Singer theorem [25] is the outgrowth of a long development in algebraic topology. It relates a topological invariant to the index j(D) of a bounded operator on Ti, defined by 7(D) = indexD = dimkerD - dimker/jt
,
(4.153)
where ker£>:= {^ en;D^
= Q} ,
is the null space of D, and D^ is the adjoint of D. D is called a Fredholm operator if the dimensions of the null-spaces of D and D^ are finite: dimkerD < oo,dimkerZ)t < 00. Most operators a physicist becomes confronted with have a vanishing index. This is true for operators (defined on a compact manifold which
105
4.7 Zero-modes
are Hermitian or are of the form 1 + K, with K compact. Whereas the triviality of the index for Hermitian operators follows directly from its definition (4.153), the latter statement can be understood in terms of the equivalence of the vanishing index with the validity of the Fredholm alternative: "Either the inhomogeneous equation (1 + K)ip = x has a unique solution for every x, or the homogeneous equation has a finite number of linearly independent solutions". In the last case the adjoint equation has the same number of solutions. As we now show, the winding number n of a gauge field A^, in two dimensions, is just the index of the operator D = -d1+ id-z + ie{Ai + iA2) Noting that • n
I 0
D
«0=lx>t o we define Indexi^» = k e r i ^ | 7 5 = 1 - k e r i ^ | 7 5 = _ ! = i V + - AT_ where N+(N_)
,
(4.154)
is the number of zero-modes of i Tp of positive (negative) chirality.
Proposition: N+-N-=n
.
(4.155)
The determination of the zero-mode asymmetry from the axial anomaly relation was first suggested by Coleman [37] and further elaborated on by a number of authors [38]-[43]. We shall provide here a physicist's proof [12]. Our starting point is the U{\)- axial vector current in the presence of an (Abelian or non-Abelian) external gauge field A^. Taking account of the possible existence of zero-modes, it is defined in a way analogous to that given by Eq. (4.148):
w^) = -« 6 £,uJ (a;)i7\2s+l7 M (a;) i
M 5
n
Correspondingly we have dpj'lix
| A) = 2fi H (z)tr 7 5 C(0;x,x\(i I?)2)
,
which replaces (4.149). Taking account of possible zero-modes, and recalling (4.37), (4.86), this becomes [12, 38, 39, 43] d»J'l{x\A) = ^Ue^v{x)-2nR{x)YJU(f{x)1bu^{x)
.
(4.156)
Notice that the first term on the right hand side is just twice the Pontryagin density. Since the definition of Jjj excludes the zero-modes, it is natural to suppose that J^ tends to zero at infinity. Hence integrating (4.156) over 3?2, and dropping the surface term at infinity, we obtain 2 '2,. t r e fd x
y^
106
Determinants and Heat Kernels
where tr refers to the trace in group space. For an SU(N) Lie algebra valued field Fpy this trace vanishes, {iri{SU{N)) ~ 0) and N+ - iV_. For QED2, on the other hand, the first term is just equal to the winding number of the gauge-field (7Ti(C/(l)) — Z), and we obtain the result (4.155). Let us explicitly illustrate the above result for the case of the Abelian vortex field (4.62). It is convenient to define the (complex) light-cone variables Z = X\
— %X2
,
Z = X\ + iX2
•
In terms of these variables the associated Dirac eigenvalue problem (4.54) in the external vortex field (4.62) on the unit sphere (R = 1) takes the form 0
2d
-Qd*-"T&;)\(ui\=
n
? + rk;
°
2A
u
/ \ 2/
("i
i + zz\u2
We only consider the solutions to the zero-eigenvalue problem. Making the Ansatz
A0)J~ v(i+^)M0) one finds that ip[ ' and
that is
1>l°J(s) = (£-)iM*i±ix2)]l-1r
,
1
,.tX±
, n^O
.
(4.157)
Here \x is just a mass parameter to give ip\ ' the dimension | . There is no need to orthonormalize these solutions. The condition of normalizability restricts l± to take the values / = 1,2, • • • \n\. Hence there are exactly N± =\ n \ zero-modes, with N+=n
,
N_=0
for
N^=n
,
AT+ = 0 for
n >0 , n< 0
,
(4.158)
so that the Atiyah-Singer index theorem (4.155) is satisfied for the vortex (4.62), with the additional property peculiar to QED2, that the zero-modes associated with a vortex configuration of a given winding are of one chirality, only (vanishing theorem). As we shall explicitly show in Chapter 12, this is also a property of arbitrary gauge-field configurations in two dimensions. 16 For QCDA figurations.
this vanishing theorem has been proven Ref. [59] to hold only for instanton con-
4.8 Ambiguities in Functional Determinants
4.8
107
Ambiguities in Functional Determinants
We have contemplated here various methods for calculating functional determinants. Because of the singular nature of Quantum Field Theory, the results thereby obtained are in general not identical. Thus the proper-time regularization requires in general the introduction of counterterms to cancel the singular terms in Seeley's expansion (4.109).17 However, just as in the case of any renormalizable Quantum Field Theory, the resulting ambiguities can be classified, so that for suitable normalization conditions, unambiguous results are obtained. In the following we examine in general the nature of these ambiguities.
4.8.1
Ambiguities in the regularization
To begin with let us examine the relation between the determinants obtained via the above two regularization schemes. Splitting the integral in (4.106) into the intervals (0,e), (e, oo) and taking the limit s -» 0 one finds [In det'D}i = [In det'D}t + C(0\D)lne
.
(4.159)
Note that the ambiguity is of the same form as that associated with a change in scale of the eigenvalues (see Eq. (4.25)). Now, if we consider ratios of determinants such as , detD U>_D_ = In -—— , D o detD0 then such a scale should not matter, provided that the dimension of the space on which D and Do act is the same. This excludes the case where D, but not Do, has zero-modes. Let us check this idea for the case that D is the Dirac operator (4.83). If the gauge-field A^ has non-zero winding (Pontryagin) number n, then i p will have . In two dimensions the number N of zero-modes will be just n itself, (see Atiyah-Singer Theorem and vanishing Theorem in section 7 of this chapter). From (4.38) and (4.88) we thus have, for two dimensions,
C(P\iP)-C(O\i0)
= -N
,
(4.160)
which indeed vanishes if there are no zero-modes. There exists another method of regularization, which we refer to as the PauliVillars regularization of a determinant [44, 7]. It is given by [lndetD]pv.
£(*..(• IS)
(4.161)
where
w^> = E'{^|><^} 17 It was a peculiarity of QED2 and QCD2 that these, a priori singular, contributions vanished identically for purely kinematical reasons. This however does not mean that there exists no ambiguity in the calculation of the QED2/QCD2 determinant.
108
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Here Mi, • • • Mv are dimensionless Pauli-Villars regulator masses to be sent to oo after setting s = 0. The number v is related to the polynomial bound and spectral density of the asymptotic spectral values. The minimal value of v is that, for which Cp.„.(0 | D) and Cp.«.(0 I D) exist without the need of analytic continuation. This places restrictions on Mk and v which are most conveniently determined by relating the s —> 0 behaviour to the small ^-behaviour in the inverse Mellin transform of (4.161). Thus, writing
i
Cpv{sl D) =
r00
T{s) J0
v
(
dt
''~M
/ dfj,(x)[h(t;x,x
1+
cke~M^
£
| D) -P0(x,x
\ D)]
we see that Cp.«.(0 I D) exists in the ordinary sense if V
V
*=1
k=\
and v = —. m
A simple computation yields [7, 32] [In deW)p.v.
= -Cp.„.(0 | D) = [In detD}^ + ({0 \ D)\n M
A.
T^i
ll
(4?r)m
M
k
k
where ^(0 | A) is the value of £(s | A) obtained by analytic continuation,
In M = Y^ckIn Mfc , k
and ar are the coefficients defined in (4.39). For QED2, — = 1 and a0 = 0, so that the ambiguity is again of the form (4.159), [In det'A\c, = [In det'A]t + C(0 | A)ln e = [In detA]p.v. - C(0 | A)ln M
4.8.2
.
Dependence on the scale parameter
Strictly speaking, our discussion of the QED2/QCD2 determinant has concerned the operator i $> which depends on the radius of the stereographic sphere. The difference (4.160) is seen not to depend on R. This is in fact a general property, which is however not shared by ('(0 \ i P) - ('(0 \ i 0). Hence the normalized determinant will in general depend on R. It is in fact easy to show that it will be independent of R, if and only if the trace of the energy momentum tensor vanishes,
4.8 Ambiguities in Functional Determinants
109
that is, in the absence of a trace anomaly. Such an anomaly will always occur if zero modes are present. This follows from the fact that independently of the dimension d of space [17, 6] /
d W M * ) l o = -K(0 | (* $>?) - C(0 I (i P)2)} •
(4.162)
In four dimensions the trace #MM ^ 0 even in the absence of zero-modes. In d = 2, where trai = 0, the dependence on R will only enter through the zeromodes. However, as we shall see in Chapter 12 this dependence on R cancels in the correlation functions. In d = 4 this is not the case, and the limit R —> oo has to be taken at the end, after proper renormalization. To demonstrate (4.162), we consider as starting point (4.60), with g the determinant of the induced metric g^v defined in (4.47). It is convenient to write the action in (4.60) in the form SF = /
d2xgflv(x)'4)(x)ij^D„ip(x)
This allows us to define the energy-momentum tensor associated with the Dirac field by i — SW 6nv(x) = ^{Hxh^D^^x^A = — . 2 ogfiV(x) In particular, 1 — *=• = -(ip{x)iW^{x))A
9^0^
= g^v{x)-
5W —
.
(4.163)
The left hand side is just the trace of 0 p „. We now want to calculate the r.h.s. We have SW _ IS('{0\ {if?)2) _ = Sg^{x) 2 Sg^x) SXn/Sg^(x)
^
V
u„(x)
- A ^1Q (A2) 7 ^
+^ )
•
(4-164)
is easily calculated; from the Dirac equation (4.59), i.e. / d2xglll/ull(x)i-y^Dvun(x)
= A„
,
(4.165)
one obtains
Hence, substituting this result into (4.164) one finds, upon using once more (4.165), SW 9^{x)--—— = -^gtrC{0;x,x\{i^)2) og^v\x)
,
or ' „ / •
SW 9 v{x)
"
Jg^Ax)
A
o = " [ C ( 0 ' { i P)2) ~ C(0 ' { i ^ )2)] '
(4.166)
110
Determinants and Heat Kernels
which establishes (4.162). Let us now demonstrate the relation between the independence of det(i $)/i 0) and the trace-anomaly. We have from (4.54) and (4.55), / cPxu^i lf)un = Xn
.
The independence of A„ only enters through un. obtains
From the above equation one
From the normalization condition (4.55), we have
or R SXn = - I A„ SR
d2xn2R(x)^ul(x)un(x)
Correspondingly, we obtain J2„n2/„N
a;2
R±W[A\ = -to»\Y. j * * ^ * ) *
u
UX)un(x)
(A,)
= -Jd2x(nR(x)^)^aO;x,x\(i&)2)
;
or, because of (4.163) and (4.166), R ^ ^
= f^x(pR(x)R^)gllveilv(x)
.
This proves that W[A] will not depend on R, if and only if there is no trace-anomaly. Nevertheless, the effective action approaches an R-independent limit as R —> oo. This follows from the fact that the effective action approaches an R-independent limit as R —¥ oo: R
5R
~ 2^(Xl)^HK
-2s J d2x^[nR{x)jp)}_^ = - 2 / d2x^(Ofl^a
5R 2v „
s=0
,it i
—
) [ < ( s ; x>x I (* ^ ) 2 ) ] - ° = ° '
4.9 Mass expansion in proper-time regularization
4.9
111
Mass expansion in proper-time regularization
The proper-time regularization also provides us with a method for obtaining a systematic expansion of the Euclidean effective action In det(d+ im + eJ^) in inverse powers of the fermion mass to all orders of the coupling constant [45], [46]. We shall illustrate the method for the case of QCDi with fermions of bare mass m. As we shall see, the heat-kernel method provides in this case an efficient way of computing the first few terms of such an expansion where, to order 0 ( l / m 2 ) , the triangle and box diagram contribute in addition to the simple second-order self-energy diagram. As we have seen, heat-kernel calculations are performed in Euclidean space. Denote by D the Euclidean Dirac operator
D :=P + m , where Z?M is given by D^ = d^ — ieA^, with A^ a Hermitian, Lie-algebra-valued gauge field in the fundamental representation of SU(N): A„ = raAl
,
tr TaTb = Sab .
We seek an expansion of the Euclidean effective action
-W[A] 1 J =
lndet{f-'e4\m)
det($ + m)
in powers of 1/m. Heat kernel methods require a semi-positive operator. Because of the nonhermiticity of the Euclidean operator D = If + m we have In det D ^ | l n det DDK We shall therefore follow a procedure differing somewhat from the ones adopted previously in this chapter. Formally we have for an arbitrary variation D -» D+SD, Sin det D = tr(5DD~1) (see (4.97)). As we have seen, this expression is in general divergent. The propertime regularization amounts to the replacement of (4.97) by (compare with (4.108)) «51n det D = tr(5Z>D _1 e- ei
,
with K some suitable positive operator, and e a parameter regulating the expression. For an arbitrary variation 5D, the operator 5DD~l is non-local. This means that off-diagonal elements of the heat kernel e~eK are involved in the computation of the trace, rendering the trace computation in general untractable. 18 As we now show, we can nevertheless obtain a power series expansion in 1/m, by making the gauge-covariant choice 19 K = £>£>* = - TJ)2 + m 2 . Making use of the representation D~x=
dtD^e-tDD' ./o
18
For gauge transformations &DD~X is local, which is the reason for being able to compute gauge-anomalies exactly. 19 For m j£ 0 D and Z)t have no zero-modes.
112
Determinants and Heat Kernels
we observe t h a t in this case
20
we can write [45] oo
/
dtti[5DDh~tDDl]
.
(4.167)
Since 5DD^ is a local operator, only knowledge of t h e diagonal elements of the heat kernel h(t;x,y\Drf):=(x\e-tDDi\y) are now required. T h e price we have t o pay is t h a t these elements are now required for general values t & [e, oo]. We now consider variations of the one-parameter family of connections A^=rA„.
,
D ( r ) = $ - ie4{r)
+m
.
(4.168)
This parametrization has proven very useful in connection with t h e Zumino descent equations [47]. W i t h
SAW =dr A^
,
8DW = —iedrA'
we have, using (4.167) dW[A(r)] _ dr ie /
(4.169)
d3xtr{A(x)(-E>ir)+m)h(t;x,-:v\ - (V>(-
dt
This integral is not computable in general. In t h e limit m —>• oo it is, however, dominated by the lower endpoint, so t h a t we can replace h(t;x,y\— P)2) by the asymptotic series in t (we omit from now on the superscript "r", unless explicitly required): oo
h(t;x,y\-(p)2)
= h0(t;x-y)J2>>i(x,y\A)tl
,
(4.170)
1-0
where bi(x,y\A) are the off-diagonal Seeley-DeWitt coefficients h0(t;x - y) is the heat kernel associated with t h e two-dimensional Laplacian as given by (4.75). 20
An alternative way of arriving at this result is to note that det£>2 = T T ( - > 2 + m 2 - 2im\)(-X2 A>o
+ m2 + 2im\)
oo
=
[J
(\2+m2)=det(tfD)
,
A=— oo
where A are the eigenvalues of i p, and where we have used the fact that the non-negative eigenvalues A come in positive and negative pairs ±A. A quick way of also arriving at the above result is to note that [48] det(f) + m)2 = det(j{D + m)det[-y5(fZ> + m)^5] = det DD*, where we have made use of the cyclic property of the trace, one the one hand, and the anticommutativity of 7 5 with 7^, on the other.
4.9 Mass expansion in proper-time regularization
113
Substituting (4.170) into (4.169), performing the i-integration, and further integrating both sides of (4.169) with respect to the parameter r, we obtain the desired expansion in terms of powers of 1/m: det(Q - ie4 + m) ^ -ie y ^ T(l)
(A 171)
2
dettf + m)
V
(4TT) £ j j (m )< fd2x
f
drtr{4(a:)(#(r) +
'
'
m)bt{x,y\A^)} x=y
The computation of the Seeley-DeWitt coefficients bi(x,y\A) and their derivatives in the coincidence limit y = x proceeds now as in subsection 4.3.2. Substitution of (4.170) into the heat-kernel equation
§i-m2)h{t;x,y\-m2) = o , leads to the recursion relations (I = 1, 2,...) = ((DD2-X)bl-1
lbl + (x-y)tiD*bl
,
(4.172)
and the parallel transport equation ( i - y)MZ?»6o = 0
,
(4.173)
where X is given by Eq. (4.85), that is X = — §75eM„i<)l,/, and where riiv — o^A.v
O^A.^
ie[A.fi, Av\
As an illustration, let us calculate (4.171) up to order 0 ( l / m 2 ) . To this order only the terms with / = 1,2 need to be considered in the expansion. We therefore need to calculate the coincidence limits [DM60], [&i] and [D^b{\. By construction, b0 is normalized such that [&o] = 1The coefficient bo(x,y) is obtained by solving the parallel transport equation (4.173) subject to the normalization condition bo(x,x\A) = 1: b0(x,y\A)=Peiefcdz»A^
,
(4.174)
where " P " stands for "path ordering" along a path C connecting the points x and y. Choosing for this path a straight line parametrized as follows, z(r;x,y)
= XT + (l-r)y
,
r = [0,1]
we may write (4.174) in the form i. I
I A\
IT, ie I
bo(x,y\A) =Te
Jo
dTB(T;x,y\A)
' ,
where "T" now denotes the usual time-ordering operation with respect to T, and where B(r;x,y\A) = {x - y ) ^ ^ ; x,y)) .
114
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Defining the auxiliary functional 7
/
i A\
b0(T-,x,y\A) we see that bo(r;x,y\A)
m ie I
=Te
dr'B(T':x,y\A)
'y|
Jo
;
,
satisfies the integral equation
6 0 (r;x,y\A) = 1 + ie [ CIT'B(T';X,y\A)b0{T';x,y\A) Jo
.
(4.175)
Prom the definition of B(T; X, y\A) one immediately computes the coincidence limits
[d*B(T;x,y\A)]=All(x) [d;dxvB(T; x, y\A)] = r (OMx)
+ dvA»{x))
2
[&Z&l&lBiT; x,y\A)] =T (d^A^x)
+ d„dvA^x)
+dfldvAa{x))
.
By straightforward differentiation of (4.175) we then find after some calculation, upon setting T = 1, [—b0(x,y\A)]=ieAli(x) ox n
(4.176)
' dx^dx ^ -balxMW^^M^+dvMxV-liM^M*)} ' 2 v
idx
gx
dx
(4-177)
b0(x,y\A)} = ^(dadMx)
+dadvAll(x)
~ ^[(^A^x)
+ d„All(x))Aa
- ^\Aa{x)(d»Au{x) + iAa(x){Ati(x),Av(x)}
+
dlldvAa{x))
+ (
+ {a -B- LI)}
+ duA^x))
(4.178)
+ (cr o v) + (a o /j,)} .
Using these results, one finds after some further algebra [Dlbo(x,y\A)]=0, [D;D:b0(x,y\A)}
(4.179)
= - y ^ ( i ) ,
[Dl(D*v)2bo(x, y\A)} =
e
-DvFv»{x)
(4.180) (4.181)
where Dv acts on a Lie-algebra valued field F in the usual way: DliF =
dF-ie[A^,F}.
From (4.179) and the tracelessness of the gamma-matrices it follows that the I = 0 term in the asymptotic expansion (4.171) vanishes, showing the expected absence
115
4.10 The F i n i t e T e m p e r a t u r e H e a t K e r n e l of a linear growth in the mass. Hence we have
Now, setting I = 1 in the recursion relations (4.172) and using (4.180), we obtain [bx] = {((Drf
- X)bo] = -X
(4.182)
with X given by (4.85), that is X = -§7 5 e,,„i' , /1 „. Setting again Z = 1 in (4.172), applying D^ to both sides of this equation, and using (4.179), we further obtain in the coincidence limit 2 [D,M] = [D^Dv)2b0] - [D^Xbo] ie e r = -DUFVIM + -^D^expFxp
.
Using (4.182) we see that the Z = 1 contribution to the O(-) term also vanishes since tr7 5 7 M = 0. Hence the leading term is of order O(-^z), and is given by
det(9-ie4 + m) = det($ + m)
t# 2
487rm J
f1 J0
dr
() w
"
(,)
(
}
vX
v
'
Finally, performing the r-integration one finds the expected gauge invariant result , det(d — ieA + m) e2 f ,, ,„,..•> v M w ; det($ + m) 1927rm2 J This completes our illustration. The method has also been applied for the calculation of the fermion determinant in 2+1 dimensions, where one is led to order 0(l/m) to a Maxwell-Chern-Simons theory [46].
4.10
The Finite Temperature Heat Kernel
The calculations in the preceding sections all refer to zero temperature. The usual experiments conducted in the laboratory can be described in terms of QFT at zero temperature. Standard cosmology however predicts matter at extremely high temperatures in the early universe. The usual point of view is that in the very early universe higher symmetries were present which disappeared in the course of the cooling process. The phase transitions involved in the breakdown of such symmetries are of great interest, and must be described in the framework of QFT at finite temperature. Dolan and Jackiw [49] have been the first ones to investigate the symmetry behaviour of QFT at finite temperature. They showed, for instance, that in massless electrodynamics in two dimensions the gauge boson acquired a mass which was
Determinants and Heat Kernels
116
independent of the temperature. Their results were rederived by Reuter and Dittrich [50], using the C-function prescription. There exists an extensive literature discussing the finite temperature formalism in QFT [51]. There are essentially two approaches refered to as the real and imaginary time formalism. For the study of the thermodynamical properties of a system at equilibrium only the partition function Z = t r e _ / 3 i f is required, and the latter formalism is the appropriate one. The same applies to the heat kernel treatment of functional determinants. The real-time (or closed-path) formalism, on the other hand, is most appropriate if one is interested in Minkowski Green functions at finite temperature, as defined by <*(*,)*(„) • • • « ( « . ) ) , =
£
" ' -
W < n |
* ' ^
2-in
1
--•*
M
M
•
(4.184)
e
where /? = 1/T, the sum is taken over a complete set of states, and $ stands for a generic field. In what follows we shall only be concerned with the calculation of the partition function Zp at finite temperature. As it is discussed in a number of textbooks [51], for a Hamiltonian quadratic in the canonical momenta, one is led (after Gaussian integration over the momenta) to the simple result Z0=
f V[fields] e-fo
dTL fields
^
^
,
(4.185)
where LE is the Euclidean Lagrangian obtained by analytically continuing the Minkowski Lagrangian in time to the negative imaginary time axes: x° —• —IT, the Euclidean time-integration is restricted to the range [0,/? = 1/T], and where the boson (fermion) fields are required to satisfy periodic (antiperiodic) boundary conditions in time with period A T = /?. In Fourier space this means that only integer (half-integer) Matsubara frequencies [52] are allowed, so that the usual Fourier Integral over frequencies turns into a discrete sum. In the case where the Lagrangian is quadratic in some matter fields, the computation of the partition function (4.185) involves at an intermediate stage the computation of a functional determinant in the presence of an (Euclidean) "external potential". This is where the heat kernel methods to be discussed below become relevant. A finite-temperature (T > 0) or thermal quantum field can be visualized as a sea of virtual particles occupying space together with a thermal gas of real particle excitations. The virtual particle sea is independent of the temperature T. It can however be deformed by coupling it to a static background potential. This is generally known as the (static) Casimir effect (see e.g. the general references cited in [55]). Gauge theories present a Casimir problem with particular features related to the underlying gauge invariance. These concern in particular the spacial energy distribution of a charged thermal matter field when coupled to a static background electromagnetic field. The resulting distortion of the virtual sea and thermal plasma (as we now refer to the thermal gas consisting of both positively and negatively charged
4.10 The Finite Temperature Heat Kernel
117
particles) is revealed by a local analysis in terms of the ground state expectation value of the thermal stress tensor. The problem of charged quantum fields coupled to a uniform electromagnetic background field is an old one, going back to famous papers of Euler, Heisenberg [53] and Schwinger [54]. There has been done a great deal of subsequent research, reviewed in books [51] and elsewhere (see e.g. Refs. in [50]). In recent times modern quantum field theoretical methods have been applied to this traditional problem (see e.g. Ref. [55] and references therein). In the following we illustrate how heat-kernel methods can be used in order to gain some insight into the local response of scalar thermal matter fields to a background electromagnetic field. Although the discussion concerning scalar fields can easily be carried out in arbitrary spacial dimensions d, we shall keep in line with the general spirit of this book, and choose d = l. 2 1 Hence we shall work on a cylinder of circumference /? = 1/T along the (Euclidean) "time" direction, corresponding to space being infinite. In order to better appreciate the special effects resulting from the minimal coupling to background gauge potential we begin by considering a thermal scalar field in presence of a static background potential V and then extend this discussion to the case where bosonic and fermionic matter fields are minimally coupled to a static gauge potential A^. Special attention is drawn to the periodicity features and their relation to the topology R x S1 of our space-time. These features become explicit for the choice A^ = (Exi + const., 0) of the gauge potential, and are also found to be characteristic of the finite temperature Schwinger model (see Chapter 13.)
4.10.1
Scalar field in a static background potential
Let us begin with the simple case of a scalar quantum field interacting with a static background potential V(xi) in one-dimensional space. We wish to study the thermodynamical properties and vacuum Casimir energy of this system using heat kernel methods. As already mentioned we shall work in Euclidean space-time using the imaginary time or Matsubara formalism. Correspondingly we impose periodic boundary conditions in Euclidean time on the scalar field <^>(a;i,a;2), 22
•
(4.186)
Euclidean space-time is then a cylinder RxS1. The spectral operator for the theory in question is [—A + F(a;i)], where A is the two-dimensional Laplacian. The vacuum and thermodynamical properties of the system can be computed from the bilocal heat kernel
h^(t;x,y) = J2^tXlMx)4>l(y) ,
(4.187)
k
where A| and
For a general discussion in d dimensions, see Ref. [56]. Throughout this section we use the Euclidean notation {x^} =
(x\,xi).
118
Determinants and Heat Kernels
With
2
+ ^
,
(4.188)
where the spatial modes ifin(x\) a n d associated spectum {w 2 } are determined by solving the auxiliary eigenvalue problem [-dl + V(x1)]tpn(xi)
= w^„(a;i) .
subject to the condition that the eigenfunctions be normalizable in 1Z. The Euclidean thermal correlator 23 has the spectral representation (
^
)
V
=
E
/*oo Jo
l
^
#
(4-189)
-i
P
m
n
We may perform the Matsubara sum by using the Jacobi identity ^2
e-b(m-a)*
e-^e~i2™1
= J^Y1
m= — oo
(4.190)
l= — oo
with the result °°
/»00
(
dth(t;x,y)T=0
^O
"£
2 2
e-^e'^^-^,
(4.191)
J=-oo
where hit- cr. Tii\ h(t;x,y) =0
\ I i^2)1J2e~tUlllP^x)'Pn(yi) ==zJ^-e4irt
(4-192)
is the T = 0 bilocal heat kernel of the operator [-A + V ^ ) ] . Hence, for a static background potential the T > 0 correlator decomposes into two distinct and well defined parts: the virtual sea part (1 = 0 contribution) which is independent of T and coincides with the T = 0 correlator, and the thermal gas part (1^0 contribution) which exhibits the full temperature dependence and vanishes exponentially as T->0: (4>(x)4>(y))p
= (
+ {
Now, from ((j>(x)
We do not distinguish between operator and c-number valued functions.
4.10 The Finite Temperature Heat Kernel
119
then shows that the finite part of the stress-tensor can, for T ^ 0, be written in the form n
i_e-/3w„
— 1 sea "T" /-~i n rpfiU
n
'
epun
—I
'
. /TT/if
-* sea "•"
gas
At finite temperature the mode sum is thus modified by the familiar Bose-Einstein distribution, in agreement with one's expectations. This completes our brief review of a "usual" Casimir problem at T > 0.
4.10.2
Scalar field in a static background gauge potential
We next consider scalar fields minimally coupled to an Abelian background gauge potential A^(x). On a space-time cylinder R x S1, the periodic boundary condition in Euclidean time for the field
, .
(4.193)
On the cylinder R x S1 we cannot gauge A2 to zero, if one is to respect the periodicity properties (4.193) of A^ and 4>. All configurations eA2 can however be mapped into the interval [0, ^S-] by a bonafide gauge transformation. (See Chapter 13 for a more detailed discussion of this point.) Only constant configurations of the form eA2 = ^ p can be gauged to zero by making the (allowed) gauge transformation 24 eA2 ->• eA2 + d2A with A = ^ x 2 . Consider now, in particular, the static background gauge potential eA2(Xl)
= Ex! + 2ira/0,
Ax = 0
,
(4.194)
corresponding to a constant background electric field along the xi direction. 25 This potential will be of particular interest in Chapter 13, where we discuss the finite temperature Schwinger model in the presence of instantons. The relevant spectral operator in this case is the gauged Laplacian — .D2, where D^ = d^ — ieA^ couples the quantum scalar field to a static background gauge potential Ali(x). 24 Another way of stating this is to observe that in this exceptional case the gauge transformation can be absorbed into the Matsubara index m via the transformation m —> m + N. For this reason eA2(xi) is always gauge equivalent to a configuration taking values in the range [0, 2K]. In the zerotemperature limit, on the other hand, we may always gauge ^2(11) to zero. Indeed, the discrete Matsubara frequencies ki = ^?p. t u r n m t 0 a continuous variable ki in the range - c o < ki < 00, and the corresponding gauge change in A2 may be absorbed into a shift in &2 under the integral
Jdk2.
25 Note that the configuration (4.194) is gauge equivalent to the configuration eA2(xi) 27ra//3, Ax = A(n).
= Ex\ +
120
Determinants and Heat Kernels
For later comparison it will convenient to first consider the (at first sight, trivial) case E = 0. The thermodynamical and vacuum properties of the system can be computed from the bilocal heat kernel (4.187), where A;2 and
+{id1f
ct>l{x) = \2l4>l{x)
,
(4.195)
with 4>i(x) subject to the boundary conditions on the cylinder. This eigenvalue problem can be solved by separation of variables with the Ansatz = -j=ei2!fLx0(pk(Xl)
Mx)->4>mk{x)
,
(4.196)
where the periodicity in X2 has been implemented, and where ipn{x\) are normalized eigenfunctions of (idi)2:
The eigenvalues are correspondingly given by + *J
t = » i
>
(4-197)
where am = -m— + —a
,
m = 0, ± 1 , ± 2 , • • •
.
(4.198)
We thus have for the diagonal elements of the heat kernel oo
h^\t;x,x\D) = Y,
,
e a
"' ™ / dke-tk'ipkixjtptix!) ,
(4.199)
m = — oo
Using the definition of the theta function [57] Q(z,p)=
oo ]jT
2
ei«m
pei2xmz
(4.200)
m=—oo
we may write (4.199) in the form h^x,x\D)
= I e - « ( ¥ ) V ( ¥ - ) ' c - ^ e (i%t x
+
f ^e-tk*
ip
,i%t) (4201)
J 27T
Making use of the identity [57] e f e r i ^ / i e - ^ e f - . - l , -ip \p p
(4.202)
4.10 The Finite Temperature Heat Kernel
121
find
h^\t;x,x)
= h(t;x,x) 1 + 2 Y^ ( - 1 ) " 1 cos(m27ra)e-
(4.203)
m—l
where h(t; x, x) is the zero-temperature diagonal heat kernel h{t;x,x)
1 f dki dkx = —== / — : V47Ti J
-tkf
(4.204)
27T
Indeed, for /3 —> oo,
yl-
e - ' < ->
J
2TT
2
e
=
(4.205)
/4?rt
so that we are led from (4.199) to (4.204) in the limit /? —>• oo. Notice that in this simple case of a constant gauge field the finite temperature heat kernel factorizes into the zero-temperature part, and a temperature dependent part depending periodically on a. This periodicity is a consequence of the periodicity of A2 and the allowed gauge transformations on this cylinder. Expression (4.203) also provides a clean separation between the temperature-independent ("sea") and temperaturedependent (thermal gas or "plasma") part. We now turn on the electric field in (4.194) by choosing E ^ 0. The eigenvalue equation (4.195) is now replaced by 2-7T
(f>i(x) = \f
(id2 + EXl + — a ) 2 + {idtf
(4.206)
Making again the Ansatz -2^m
1
4>i{x) - >
0
X2
yn{x-i_)
,
(4.207)
and defining 2na
2TT
Xm = Xl m
- EP
+
(4.208)
W
we arrive at the eigenvalue equation d2
dxl
-
\2„Wn{xm)
(4.209)
This is just the harmonic oscillator eigenvalue problem in Schrodinger theory with orthonormal eigenfunctions n 2
lfin(xm)^2-
/ ~(-Ye-i^2mHn{^Xm)
A2=2E(n+i),
n = 0,1,2,...
.
(4.210)
122
Determinants and Heat Kernels
Here the Hn (z) are Hermite polynomials satisfying Hn — 2zH'n + 2nHn = 0. In Eq. (4.209) the m-dependent backgrounds Vm(x\) = E2x2n are identical harmonic oscillator potentials centered at equidistant positions x\ = (m — a)2Tr/(3E. This periodic arrangement of identical potentials leads to periodic structure along xi (with period Azi = 2ir/PE) in the Euclidean stress tensor T^u{x) and other local quantum functions [56]. The m-dependence of
1
^ ) («;^y) = ^E e < m ^ ( * a ~ w ) E e " < 2 B ( n + i Vn( a : m )^(y f n ) p n=0 E 2n sinh(2.E£)
4E«'
imZg-(x2-y2)
xe The mode sum ^ Ref. [57])
ie(x1-»/i)2coth(2St) 2
tanh(St)
(4.211)
here has been performed with the help of the identity (see e.g.
Y,^X^yHn(x)Hn(y) n=0
-Exmym
e
(l-z2)-1/2exp\-^[2xy(l-z)-z(x-yM.
=
'
*>
'
Alternatively one can use the Feynman-Kac formula [58] for the propagator in the harmonic oscillator problem (see Chapter 13) . The diagonal part of the heat kernel (4.211) may be written in the form hW(t;x,x)
=
E l+2 2^cos[nf3(Exi 4-7T sinh Et n=l
2-nas + —— )]e
(4.212)
o™"'
where we have made use of the identity (see (4.190))
- y
„ — Ext, t a n h S t
E
•in(2iva+xi0E)
4-7T t a n h Et
(4.213)
n= — oo
Note that already in this simple case the factorized form of the heat kernel deviates substantially from expression (4.203) obtained in the E = 0 case. In the limit E —> 0 the heat kernel (4.211) smoothly becomes the free-space heat kernel as it should h,W{t;x,y)
-)• - ^ e - f ^ - w )
2
/^!
-*(-™^+f)2e™^(x2-y2)
E
^
0
.
4TT£
For the diagonal heat kernel this reduces t o expression (4.199), and correspondingly t o (4.203). Remarkably, the dependence on m so conspicuously absent from the
123
4.11 Conclusion
E > 0 spectrum (4.210) reenters in the E = 0 spectrum "through the back door" via xm labelling the sites of the harmonic oscillator potentials [56]. Let us finally observe that the heat kernel (4.212) has the form of a Fourier expansion, hW(t;x,x) = ^hl?)(t;x1)cos(n(3eA${x1)), (4.214) n
with periodicity ^ in the variable CAQ(XI), and "Fourier coefficients" /ijj?'(t;x\) only depending on the electric field. As is argued in Ref. [61] this is expected to be a general result for static gauge fields, also applicable to 3+1 dimensions. In that case, /i„ (t; xi) will be a function of the electric and magnetic fields. The periodicity of h^(t;x,x) under the gauge transformation eA0 -+ eA0 + ^ is, however, not a property of Minkowski space.
4.11
Conclusion
In a path integral framework, the non-perturbative calculation of n-point functions in gauge theories typically involves as an intermediate step the calculation of Green functions and functional determinants in an external gauge field. As we have seen, in 1+1 dimensions such quantities may be exactly calculated in the case of fermions minimally coupled to an Abelian and non-Abelian gauge field. We have emphasized in this chapter heat-kernel techniques, which have been shown to provide powerful tools for summing one-loop diagrams, and are particularly suited for dealing with zero-mode problems as well as Quantum Field Theory at finite temperature. There exists a very extensive mathematical literature on this subject, which evidently is outside the scope of this book, and which the mathematically inclined reader is asked to consult. An extensive list of references to this literature can be found in the article on topological methods for gauge theories [38] by B. Schroer, as well as in Refs. [7, 60]. Gilkey's method for calculating the Seeley coefficients, including the case of non-invertible operators, has been extensively discussed in a "digestible" way for physicists by Gamboa-Saravi et al in Refs. [8]. The Fujikawa approach has similarly been discussed and applied to a variety of problems by Fujikawa himself. As we have tried to exhibit, all of these approaches are equivalent if due attention is paid to the ambiguities, and we shall have ample opportunity to apply them in the chapters to follow.
Bibliography [1] L.D. Fadeev and V.N. Popov, Phys. Lett. 25B (1967) 29.. [2] P.T. Mathews and A. Salam, Phys. Rev. 94 (1954) 185. [3] F. Berezin, The Method of Second Quantization, Academic Press, New York, London (1966). [4] R.T. Seeley, Am. Math. Soc. Proc. Symp. Pure Math. 10 (1967) 288.
124 [5] P.B. Gilkey, Proc. Symp. Pure Math. 601.
Bibliography 27 (1973); J. Diff. Geom. 10 (1975)
[6] S.W. Hawking, Commun. Math. Phys. 55 (1977) 133. [7] K.D. Rothe and B. Schroer, Field Theoretical Methods in Particle Physics, ed. W. Riihl, Plenum, N.Y., 1980. [8] R.E. Gamboa-Saravi, M.A. Muschietti and J.E. Solomin, Commun. Math. Phys. 89 (1983) 363; ibid 93 (1984) 407; R.E. Gamboa-Saravi, M.A. Muschietti and J.E. Solomin, Commun Math. Phys 93 (1984) 407; R.E. GamboaSaravi, G.L. Rossini and F.A. Schaposnik, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 11 (1996) 2643. [9] P.A.M. Dirac, Ann. Math. 36 (1935) 657. [10] S.L. Adler, Phys. Rev. D6 (1972) 3445; R. Jackiw and C. Rebbi, Phys. Rev. D14 (1976) 517. [11] J. Kiskies, Phys. Rev. D16 (1977) 2535. [12] N.K. Nielsen and B. Schroer, Nucl. Phys. B127 (1977) 493. [13] O. Alvarez, Nucl. Phys. B216 (1983) 125; ibid B238 (1984) 61. [14] J.W. Milnor and J.D. Stasheff, Characteristic Classes, Annals of Mathematics Studies 76, Princeton University Press 1974. [15] B. DeWitt, Dynamical Theory of Groups and Fields, Gordon and Breach 1965; N.K. Nielsen, Nordita preprint 78/24. [16] R.E. Gamboa-Saravi, M.A. Muschietti, F.A. Schaposnik and J.E. Solomin, Ann. of Phys. 157 (1984) 360. [17] J. Singe, in Relativity: The General Theory, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1960; J.S. Dowker and R. Critchley, Phys. Rev. D 1 3 (1976) 3224; J.S. Dowker, J. Phys. A l l (1978) 347; N.K. Nielsen, H. Romer and B. Schroer, Nucl. Phys. B136 (1978) 445. [18] K. Fujikawa, Phys. Rev. Lett. 42 (1979) 1195; Phys. Rev. D21 (1980) 2848; Phys. Rev. D22 (1980) 1499(E). [19] K. Fujikawa, Phys. Rev. Lett. 44 (1980) 1733; Phys. Rev. D23 (1981) 2262. [20] K. Fujikawa, Proceedings of Nato Advanced Research Workshop Super Field theories, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, B.C. Canada, 1986; Proceedings of the Kyoto Summer Institute, 1985, ed. T. Inami (World Scientific, Singapore, 1986). [21] C. Itzykson and J.B. Zuber, Quantum Field Theory , Mc Graw Hill, 1980. [22] G.A. Christos, I. C. Trieste preprint 82/97, 1982.
Bibliography
125
[23] R.T. Seeley, Annals Math. Soc. Proc. Symp. Pure Math 10 (1967) 288 [24] K. Fujikawa, Proceedings of the 1988 Stefan Banach Workshop, Gauge Theories of Fundamental Interactions, Warsaw, Poland. [25] M.F. Atiyah and I.M. Singer, Amer. Math. Soc. 69 (1963)422; Ann. Math. 87 (1968) 596. [26] R. Banerjee, Phys. Lett. B174 (1986) 313. [27] K. Fujikawa, Phys. Rev. D31 (1985) 341. [28] L. Alvarez-Gaume and P. Ginsparg, Nucl. Phys. B243 (1984) 449. [29] H. Banerjee, R. Banerjee and P. Mitra, Zeitsch. fur Phys. C32 (1986) 445. [30] K.D. Rothe, Nucl. Phys. B269 (1986) 269. [31] J. Schwinger, Theor. Phys. (IAEA) Vienna (1963) 88. [32] M.A. Atiyah, R. Bott and V.K. Patodi, Inv Math. 19 (1973) 279; P.B. Gilkey, The Index Theorem and the Heat Equation, Math. Lect. Series, Publish or Perish Inc. 1974. [33] A.M. Polyakov and P.B. Wiegmann, Phys. Lett. 131B (1983) 121; 141B (1984) 223. [34] M. Forger, private communication. [35] M. Makowka, G. Wanders, Helv. Phys.. Acta 59 (1986) 1366. [36] D. Gepner, Nucl. Phys. B252 (1985) 481. [37] S. Coleman, unpublished. [38] B. Schroer, Acta Physica Austriaca, suppl. XIX (1978) 155. [39] M. Hortascu, K.D. Rothe and B. Schroer, Phys. Rev. D20 (1979) 3203. [40] J. Kiskies, Phys. Rev. D15 (1977) 2329. [41] L.S. Brown, R.D. Carlitz and C. Lee, (1977). [42] R. Jackiw and C. Rebbi, Phys. Rev. D16 (1977) 1052; Phys. Rev. D 1 3 (1976) 339. [43] M. Ansourian, Phys. Lett. 70B (1977) 301. [44] A.S. Schwarz, Commun. Math. Phys. 64 (1979) 233. [45] H. Leutwyler Phys. Lett. 152B (1985) 78; J. Gasser and H. Leutwyler, Ann. Phys. N.Y. 158 (1984) 142. [46] K. Rothe, Phys. Rev. D48 (1993) 1871.
126
Bibliography
[47] B. Zumino, W. Yong-Shi and A. Zee, Nucl. Phys. B239 (1984) 477. [48] M.P. Fry, Phys. Rev. D47 (1993) 2629. [49] L. Dolan and R. Jackiw, Phys. Rev. D9 (1974) 3320. [50] W. Dittrich and M. Renter, Lecture Notes in Physics: Effective Lagrangians in Quantum Electrodynamics (Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1984), Vol. 220. [51] A. Das, Finite Temperature Field Theory, World Scientific Publishing, 1997; H.J. Rothe, Lattice Gauge Theories, An Introduction, 2nd edition, World Scientific Publishing, 1997. [52] T. Matsubara, Prog. Theor. Phys. 14 (1955) 351. [53] H. Euler and W. Heisenberg, Z. Phys. 98 (1936) 714. [54] J. Schwinger, Phys. Rev. 82 (1951 664. [55] A.A. Actor, Phys. Rev. D 50 (1994) 6550 [56] A.A. Actor, K.D. Rothe and F.S. Scholtz, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 32 (1999) 7463. [57] The Bateman Manuscript Project: Higher Transcendental Functions, eds. A. Eredelyi et al. (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1983), vol.2. [58] R. Feynman and Hibbs, Quantum Mechanics and Path Integrals, McGraw-Hill 1965. [59] M.F. Atiyah, V.G. Drinfeld, N.J. Hitchin and Yu.I. Manin Phys. Lett. 65A (1978) 185. [60] F.A. Shaposnik, Quantum Mechanics of Fundamental Systems II, Ed. C. Teiltelboim and J. Zanelli, Plenum, 1989. [61] A.A. Actor and K.D. Rothe, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 33 (2000) 4585.
Chapter 5
Self-interacting Fermionic Models 5.1
Introduction
In this Chapter we consider self-interactions of a multiplet of fermionic fields. The symmetry group will be taken as being either O(N) or SU(N) ® U(l) ® 17(1). These models have a long history, having been introduced by Nambu and Jona Lasinio in four dimensions, in order to describe the phenomenology of elementary particles [1]. They are referred to as the Gross-Neveu and chiral Gross-Neveu model, respectively [2]. At the classical level they describe the interaction of massless fermions, being conformally invariant. At the quantum level however, a mass gap is generated by the S-matrices of quantum fluctuations, leading to asymptotically free theories. These are solvable in the N —S- co limit, and an expansion in powers of 1/N may be defined. Both models possess an infinite number of conservation laws [3, 4] which survive quantization [4], and as a consequence, the S-matrices of the models may be computed exactly. In section 5.2 we discuss the (^(AQ-invariant model, and in section 5.3 the chiral model. The interaction of these fermionic theories with a models will be discussed in Chapters 6, 7 and 8. An important issue concerns chiral symmetry breaking in the chiral Gross-Neveu model, suggested by the dynamical generation of mass, since the appearance of Goldstone bosons is forbidden in two-dimensional space-time [5]. We shall see, in terms of the operator solution of the model, that this paradox is resolved by the fact that the chirality carrying field decouples from the physical fermion fields, which are massive, but carry no chirality.
5.2
The 0(N) Invariant Gross-Neveu Model
This model, first introduced by Nambu and Jona-Lasinio [1], describes a quartic Fermi-type self-interaction of an Applet of Majorana fermions transforming as a fundamental representation of the orthogonal group O(N). The Lagrangian is given
128
Self-interacting Fermionic Models
by
C = fo Hi + \g(^i)2
,
(5.1)
where the summation over repeated indices is implied. This is the most general O(N) invariant, renormalizable and conformally invariant theory for self-interacting Majorana fermions in two dimensions. 1 It presents the discrete symmetry tp -> 75^-
5.2.1
Classical conservation laws
The classical model is integrable, having an infinite number of conservation laws.2 The semiclassical study of the model reveals a very rich structure, and the time independent solutions of the equation of motion can be computed systematically [6]. This is a consequence of the fact that the Noether current associated with O(N) rotations, given by
jjf = hfil^
,
satisfies &*$ = 0
(5.2)
as a consequence of the O(N) symmetry. Using the equation of motion of the Lagrangian (5.1) as well as a Fierz transformation, it also satisfies3 drfi-dvjj* + 2g[jfl,jl/]i^0
.
(5.3)
This is a crucial identity. It implies integrability by assuring the compatibility of the differential equations [7, 3] 8llU = 2gUj^
.
(5.4)
Indeed, taking the derivative with respect to xv of (5.4) and subtracting the resulting equation from the one with / i H i / w e obtain the integrability condition 1 We have, for two-dimensional Majorana (anticommuting) spinors, the identities ipfstp = 0 = i/rfpil), which follow from the anticommutation of the components, and from the definition i/> = ^ i t y = ^,-yO for a Majorana field, with a charge conjugation matrix being unity; in the Weyl representation, the charge conjugation matrix is C = 75; we use the Majorana representation, (A.8)-(A.10), in this Chapter. We also have the identity <5a/3<57^ = |[5a<5<57^ + {ly,)as{lt')-1p +
(7 5 )a<s(7 5 )7/3], for Majorana fields the Fierz identity ip^jipjipi = — §(V'iV'i)3> where a sum over repeated indices is implicit. In the particular case of 0 ( 2 ) symmetry the Lagrangian (5.1) is just that_of the Thirring model as one sees by defining a Dirac field V D = i>i + tyz , and using 2 We have discussed integrability of the sine-Gordon equation, and will in Chapter 6 discuss integrable non-linear sigma models. For the moment, integrable means that the model has higher conservation laws, which are not directly associated with a Lie group symmetry of the Lagrangian. It is rather related with the existence of a set of differential equations for a matrix valued field. These differential equations depend on a potential, which is in turn, related to the integrable model in question [3]. _ 3 We use t h e equation of motion iftipi = —gV'fcV'AV'i. which implies idli{i>jl,1lbi>i) = +2g^i/nj)jf5i(>i, as well as the Fierz identity ^jl^l^k^h^^i = ^jfsi'f'l'k^kTherefore, using (A.10), we have e^d^J,, = -2gt'"'ipiiuil>k,>l>k/y^j< il0ia which (5.3) is obtained.
5.2 The 0(N)
Invariant G r o s s - N e v e u Model
129
(5.3). Using current conservation and (5.3) it is also possible [8] to establish the following linear system of equations for any value of the parameter A: d^U^
= -gUW
[(1 - cosh 2A) j M + sinh 2AeM1, j v ]
.
(5.5)
As a result of equations (5.2) to (5.5), there exists a one parameter family of conserved currents given by the expression jW = uW {(CoSh 2A - 2) j M - sinh 2AC/1„ j " } t/ ( A ) _ 1
.
(5.6)
The current (5.6) can be shown to be conserved. Expanding j / , in powers of A, and proceeding as in Chapter 3 one obtains an infinite number of conserved currents and charges (for a more detailed discussion see Chapter 6), thefirstnontrivial (matrix-valued) charge being given by Q(2) = / dy1dy2e{y1 - y2)jo(t,yi)jo(t,y2)
+-
dyji (t, y)
. (5.7)
One may construct an infinite number of conserved currents in terms of any conserved current J** satisfying the zero-curvature condition [Dli,Dv]=dlJv-dvjlt
+ 2g\jll,jv]=0
,
(5.8)
where £>M denotes the covariant derivative as given by D^ = d^ + 2gj^. The algorithm is very simple [9]. We start out with fy = j M . Consider a conserved current jjT , and the corresponding potential, that is
Construct yj1
' as j< n+1 >=Z?„j< n >
.
(5.9)
This new element is also conserved. Indeed, using the conservation of j M , one has
or recalling definition (5.9) of j/P , one finds ^•(n+l)
= eitvD*j(n)v
=
e^D^D-jin-l)
=
Q
;
(510)
where use has been made of Eq. (5.8). Therefore we have an infinite number of conserved charges in the classical theory. They obey a non-linear algebra (see section 7.5).
5.2.2
Effective potential a n d /3-function i n a | expansion
We study now the quantization of the Gross-Neveu model. The Lagrangian (5.1) may be rewritten in terms of an auxiliary field a{x) as C='$W>-j-
+ \<>W> •
(5.H)
Self-Interacting fermionic models
130
Since the dependence on the auxiliary field a is quadratic, and does not involve derivatives, the equation of motion of a is given by the constraint a = giptl)
,
which, when substituted into (5.11), reproduces (5.1).4 The idea of introducing the auxiliary field is to enable one to first integrate over the fermions, what is equivalent to computing the functional determinant det(z $ + a). The effective potential V^(a) is defined as (— \ times) the logarithm of the determinant for constant a: V^'(a) = —-In det(i $ + cr) ,
a = constant
.
Its computation corresponds to summing the one loop fermion diagrams at zero momentum [2] (see Figure 5.1); we have the result
The sum (5.12) corresponds to the expansion of the logarithm rW(„\'.//<")
iV ff JLI cPk " 2 J (27T (2^ ln
N
I1"*
87
In—r- - 1 A2
where a cut-off has been introduced, after Wick rotation, at k2 = A2 in order that the integral be well defined. Taking into account the tree contribution as well, we finally obtain TV 2 1 2 . + + — Veff(
This effective potential, whose form is given in Figure 5.1 has a maximum at the origin, and a minimum at the point a1 -mz
= Az2e
—N -*2-
(5.13)
The maximum at the origin has several consequences. If we try to quantize the theory around a = 0 in the large N limit, we obtain a tachyonic contribution to the effective four fermion interaction [2]. On the other hand, quantization around one of the minima at a — ±m (Eq. (5.13)) means that the discrete symmetry (5.14)
i> - » 7 5 ^ 4
Alternatively, we can write - — a2 +-.aipip =4g 2
— (a-gi>ip)2 Ag
+-g{tpip)2 4
•
The first term may be completely eliminated integrating over cr, leaving no trace of that field.
5.2 The 0{N) Invariant Gross-Neveu Model
131
I F i g u r e 5 . 1 : Calculation and form of the effective potential.
of the original Lagrangian (5.1) is spontaneously broken by a mass term ^mtjjip. Hence, for this choice of the vacuum, a mass is spontaneously generated for the fermionic field. The interpretation of m as the mass of the fermionic field requires that it be renormalization group invariant, i.e.
A2
^+«4H
0
(5.15)
This permits the computation of the /3 function of the model,given by 2
m = -Ng
(5.16)
2TT
The sign of the /? function shows that the theory is asymptotically free. Moreover,
•- + --0-
+ --O-O- + - - 0 0 - 0 -
F i g u r e 5.2: Summation of bubble diagrams contributing t o fermion interaction in the large N limit.
the cut-off A and the bare coupling constant g(A) can both be eliminated from the theory, in favor of the generated mass parameter alone. This "mass transmutation" simplifies considerably the discussion of the theory. The "mass transmutation" phenomenon might provide a dynamical mechanism for generating masses in theories which are massless ab initio, worthwhile to understand [10]. In the limit N -> oo with gN fixed, the bubble diagrams of Figure 5.2 have to be summed (this is a geometric series) and the theory may be solved. We are going to look for corrections in powers of 1/N. To this end, we rewrite the theory in a way as to allow for the systematic calculation of the corrections. The generating functional is given by Z[rj\ =
IV^VaeH'*'*{W9+<')1'-4;<'3+*N>}
(5.17)
expanding a around the vacuum expectation value (a) = — m, a = —m +
a
3
(a) = 0
(5.18)
132
Self-Interacting fermionic models
and defining $L[cr] = i ft — m + -?=, we can write the functional integral in the form Z[7?] = / 2 ? ^ a e * ^ 2 ^ ( ? + ^ [ " r l ) A F [ " ] ( ^ + A [ S ] " S ) - ^ " 1 ^ ^ " 2 - 7 ^ m S } .
(5.19)
We integrate out the fermions, writing the determinant thus obtained as det #[cr] = tr In $.[0]
.
Substituting this expression in (5.19) we have the result Z[rj\=
fvaei-l'd2x^~^MarlTI'^a2+^^ma}+^tT^~m+^)
.
(5.20)
The fact that a has vanishing vacuum expectation value, implies that all tadpoles cancel against the linear term in a, that is m / d2xa + — / (fxatr
J
/ -—rr^
= 0
J (2TT 2 k2 - m2
2J
.
(5.21) V
'
Using a cut-off A for the momentum integral, 5 we obtain Eq. (5.13) for the mass. The P function has been computed in (5.15), (5.16). A comment concerning this procedure is in order at this point, if one aims at computing higher order corrections. The higher order /3 function may depend on the renormalization procedure used to calculate the fermion four point function. The two loop 0 function computed by normalizing the fermion four point function as in the symmetric theory (m = 0) gives again (5.16).6 If instead, the renormalization constants are computed using the non-symmetric theory, a different j3 function is obtained [12, 13, 14],
«9) = - ^ + Wa /*i 2 l + 4 o 2'/ / u 2 2TT with a2//J,2 related to g by, y ' l + 4a 2 //i 2 - 1 _
4TT
where the second expression is a modification of the gap equation (5.21) [14]. The 1/iV correction to the above result has been also discussed in the literature [12]. The two apparently conflicting results are seen to be correct, with different interpretations for the respective /3 functions [14]. Indeed we can rewrite the generated mass (5.13) in terms of renormalized parameters. The renormalized coupling constant g([i) is defined, at one loop level, by 1
1
JV
A
- —7r I n -n 5(A)
5
,
g(fj-) We perform a Wick rotation in the momentum integral, obtaining 1
mN
, A/ 2m/ "
r, /
J0
2
dx — - s2
x +l
(. =zm I
\
1 iv,- , A- ^-\ i „ 1 In —^r 2g 4TT m2J
This procedure is correct. See, in this respect, Ref. [11].
(5.23)
5.2 The 0{N) Invariant G r o s s - N e v e u Model
133
and we obtain from (5.13), m2 = i?e"^)
.
(5.24)
In general we can write this result in an explicitly renormalization group invariant way in terms of the /3 function as o - f9
,
mz
5.2.3
-is
= /x 2 e J ^
.
The ^ Expansion: Feynman rules
From (5.20) we are able to derive systematically new Feynman rules corresponding to the 1/N expansion of the model. The leading order contribution in 1/N to the IP I two point function of the field a is given by the second term in the expansion of the the logarithm in (5.20), plus the tree graph contribution (see Figure 5.3). k+p
—h-*-h-
-v~<^i>--f
-TTTT
k
~P~
2gN
Figure 5.3: Tree-and one-loop diagrams contributing to the a two-point function.
The corresponding momentum space result reads,
f(p)-
'
yP
'
2gN
\rfd2k
(* + ")[*+*+"1
(525)
2
J (2TT) {k - m2)[(k + p)2 - m2} 2
2
{
'
'
We perform a Wick rotation, and use the fact that the logarithmically divergent part of (5.25) cancels the cut-off dependent constant —— upon use of (5.13), (5.23), and (5.24), leaving a finite result: the renormalization of the model within the 1/N expansion is very simple due to the mass transmutation. Performing the elementary integral in (5.25) one obtains, after cancellation of the divergent term, 7
f^'J^^i^zS . 471-y 7
W n havp W e haVe
P d2k
t
-p2
(¥+m)W+rf+m]
J j2^tT^-m2Wk+P^-'m'2]
v
v - p * + 4m2 + v c ^ _
-
2
f1 .
(2^T Jo
dx
f j2i.
J
d
k2-p2x(l-x)~m2
fe
(5. 26 ) >
,. ,
[fc2_m2+'p2,(1_,f
WhlCh Can
be trivially integrated in the angle variables; the radial integration can be performed and results
•h Si dx { i l n A 2 - ila {~m2 +P2x^ ~ *)) + -ffiffi^i*-,)}-
See 15 for this in
I l
tegral.
Self-Interacting fermionic models
134
The
(5.27)
The Feynman rules can now be read from (5.20) and are summarized in Table 5.1 where we have defined p2 = 2m 2 (1 — cosh#) = —4m2 sinh 2 | . Table 5.1 a- propagator
(0 | a(p)a(-p)
| 0)
ip propagator
<0|Va(p)^(-p)|0>
iprpa vertex
0'(p)'/ , a(9)'/ , /3(-P-9)
(l»)Af(p)''=
-j^
In the 1/N expansion, the renormalization of the model is very simple. By the power counting theorem [16], the only divergent diagrams are those for which the superficial degree of divergence, given by 5{Y) = 2 - ±N* - Na
,
is non-negative, where T denotes the diagram, N$ the number of external fermion lines, and Na the number of external a lines. Thus, we have divergencies in the two- and four-fermion correlation functions, in the two-fermion one-cr correlation function, and in the inverse a propagator. The latter, as well as the divergence of the fermion two-point function, can be absorbed in the fermion and a wave function renormalization, and in the mass renormalization (or equivalently, due to mass transmutation, in the coupling constant renormalization). The superficial degrees of divergence of the remaining correlation functions are actually negative in the 1/iV-expansion, if we consider an appropriate sum of diagrams of the same order. The cancellation mechanism occurs between the diagrams displayed either in Figure 5.4 or in Figure 5.5: consider a diagram with the external lines tpi and ipi', then form a new diagram, joining those lines into a a line, which in turn reproduces the pair I/J* and ip again (see the diagram of Figure 5.4), i.e. the above mechanism was used in the first two, and in the last two diagrams of Figure 5.5). It is easy to verify that the diagrams are of the same order in I/TV, due to a factor of N arising from the fermion loop. The cancellation is due to the fact that the blob is logarithmically divergent, which is thus a (cut-off dependent) constant when shrunk to a point. In this case,
/ Vcj(j{x)(j{y)ez
82 SJ(x)SJ{y)
J
<TI
SJ(x)5J{y)
!*>«*/«-
•fvaeif1'
Ta-2Ja)
-jr-1)r(
5.2 The 0(N) Invariant Gross-Neveu Model
135
\ /
F i g u r e 5.4: Cancellation mechanism of lowest order divergencies.
A F i g u r e 5.5: Cancellation mechanism of higher order divergencies.
due to the definition (5.27), the divergent pieces cancel as shown in figures 5.6 and 5.7 (the a propagator is minus the inverse of the renormalized fermion loop).
F i g u r e 5.6: Cancellation mechanism concerning diagrams of figure 5.4: the same divergent constant appears in both diagrams, differing by a minus sign.
5.2.4
Leading order S-matrix elements
The l/N expansion of the model is very useful to check several results concerning the S-matrix, which will be computed exactly for the Gross-Neveu model in Chapter 8. The essential property allowing for the computation of the exact S-matrix is its factorization in terms of 2 body S matrices. In turn, this property is equivalent to the statement that the probability of pair production is zero 9 . 9 In a factorizable amplitude, the intermediate states (after 2 body collisions) are on shell. Consider the amplitude of pair production, and the 3 body amplitude in Figures 5.8 and 5.9, related by crossing. In Figure 5.8 the intermediate particle momentum r = —pi + P2 + P3 is on shell if either pi = p 2 or p i = p 3 , which are correct configurations. However, in Figure 5.9,
Self-Interacting fermionic m o d e l s
136
F i g u r e 5.7: Cancellation mechanism concerning diagrams of figure 5.5.
"Pl + P 2 + P3
Pi
P2
P3
F i g u r e 5.8: Three body scattering amplitude.
This has been proven in general [17]. Indeed, the absence of pair production in this model is verified by a very simple computation, using the 1/N expansion [4, 18]. The lowest order amplitude is given by diagrams of Figure 5.10, which are of the order -^. We will use the fact that in two-dimensional space-time, one loop diagrams are exactly computable in terms of tree diagrams times a two-propagator loop (see [19], [20], Chapter 3 and Figure 5.11). This is due to the fact that the result of performing the k° integration using the theorem of residues is a rational function, after a convenient change of variables. The rational function thus obtained may be decomposed into partial fractions, with coefficients calculated at the respective residua. This leaves us with a coefficient given in terms of a sum, where each term of the sum is given by the product of all but two propagators and vertices. The momentum integration only receives a contribution from points where the poles of the two selected propagators coincide. The remaining integral is trivial, and it is given in terms of the function AI ^ f A(p)=
1
d2k
7 (2TT) w (k + 2
Pi)
2
1 -m (k
27ryV(p 2 - 4m 2 ) 47rm2sinh#
2
In
2
+ Pj)
-
m2
y/—p2 + 4m 2 — \f— i \f-p2
+ 4m 2 + (5.28)
r = p\ +/>2 +P3, consequently r 2 > 3m 2 , by the two-dimensional kinematics. Therefore, the total amplitude for pair production (or annihilation) must be zero, in a factorizable amplitude, when all diagrams are added.
5.2 The 0(N)
Invariant Gross-Neveu Model
137
Pl+P2+P3
Pi
P2
P3
F i g u r e 5.9: Amplitude for pair production related to figure 5.8 by crossing.
with p = Pi~Pj,p2 have used
= —4m2 sinh 2 6/2, pi = m(cosh#;, sinh#;), 8 = 9i —9j. Here we
J (2n ) 2 [k2 + a ( l - a)p2 — m2 + is]2
An m 2 - a ( l - a)p2
'
(5.29)
as well as a ( l — a) / da 2 m -a(l-a:)p2 Jo
v/p2(p2_4m2)
In
^/p2(p2-4m2)-p2 I
x
/p2(p2_4m2)+p: (5.30)
-rU.IH l.X.
V
F i g u r e 5.10: Diagrams of order ^
V -ct>-
contributing to the amplitude of pair products
V
—
-o-
V
V
+ ^ -
+ -<&-
F i g u r e 5 . 1 1 : Explicit computation of the first diagram of figure 5.10. The dashes in the intermediate figure mean use of the cutting rule (Chapter 3), where the momenta are such that the dashed lines are on shell; each diagram here cancels two corresponding diagrams in figure 5.10.
138
Self-Interacting fermionic models
The above procedure permits one to compute the first diagram of Figure 5.10 exactly in terms of the other six tree diagrams, and shows that they add up to zero. Using the 1/N expansion we are able to obtain the S-matrix up to second order. The two particle scattering amplitude for fermions with isospin i,j and rapidities 61,62, has the general form 10
(e'1k,0,2i\e1i,e2j) = = [ax{6)5ikPl a ik
- [ai(e)5 6
+ a2(e)SilSkj
+ a 3 (0) W ]
ik
+ <j2(9)5 6i' + (73(0) W ]
<J(0i - 0i)6(02 - &2) S(BX - 6'2)5{e2 - 9[) ,
where 0 = 61 — 62. To lowest order perturbation in jj, we have the contribution due to exchange of the auxiliary a particle (Figure 5.12). Using the Feynman rules given in Table 1 one finds [4] 2TT
<7l(0) = l +
(5.31)
JVsinhtf
*<»> = £
(5.32)
2-Ki
(5.33)
N(iix - 9)
The computation can also be extended to one loop order. A perturbative expansion of the S-matrix, may also be obtained in this case (see also [21] for further details). p
q
q I
p
q
p
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 5.12: Lowest order contribution to (5.31), (5.32) and (5.33).
5.2.5
Quantization of t h e non-local charge
Our next aim is to quantize the non-local charge (5.7) in order to obtain nonperturbative results from the model. Divergencies in this non-local charge arise from the short distance singularities of the product of two currents in the first term. We therefore, consider the Wilson expansion
\j»{x + e)M*)\
= Y,C${e)0{ay(x)
10
,
(5.34)
Notice that instead of the usual momentum delta function, we use deltas in the rapidity. To compare with the usual perturbative calculations, we need to include a factor m2 *inh g > since
S(P0 -P'OMPI - P i ) =
mi^(e_ei)S(0i
- «i W * - «i)-
5.2 The 0(N)
Invariant G r o s s - N e v e u Model
139
where 0{a}(x) are local field operators and CJi" (e) are c-number functions. The dimension of the operators 0{ay (x) can be classified by making use of the asymptotic freedom of the theory [2, 24]. Since the left hand side of (5.34) has dimension 2, there are only contributions to the right hand side coming from algebra valued operators of dimension 1 and 2. Therefore one finds [25, 26] \3v{x,e),jv(x)\
= C%{e)jP{x) + D%{e)dajp(x)
.
(5.35)
There are constraints from P T and CP invariance, as well as current conservation, restricting the coefficients G^v{e) and D^(e). The first two imply ^ „ ( e ) = - C ^ ( - e ) = C^(e)
,
Using Lorentz invariance, we may thus obtain the general structure of the coefficients, which read
^nA£) - Ci~^r~+ ° 2 — p ^(e)-^i
-T2
+ G3_
+ D2
pyr
~2
K £v6 TO+W» \ h°+\C2Z£a»EVEPE ° 2 ' e2 (e 2 ) 2
+iMw Asymptotic freedom implies that 1 1
Ci = 0 ( | £ | - ° )
,
A = 0(|£|-°)
•
Current conservation implies several constraints. One of them is d G1 = - 4 ^ - 2^ {D1(-x2)
- D3(-x2))
d = -2x— (Dx(-x2) da;
- D3(-x2))
dl
(5.36)
_ cc, or, for e° — 0, -is1 =
Cx{-x2)
.
(5.37)
We define the cut-off charge <9i =
/
dyidy 2 e(yi - y2)jo(t,yi)j0(t,y2)
- Zs
dyjx(t,y)
\yi—j/2\>S
In Ref. [25], one supposes that the fundamental fields have only logarithmic singularities; therefore, a smearing in the space coordinate would be enough to define correlators. In this case it is possible to compute the C;'s exactly. We do not need them, however [28].
Self-Interacting fermionic models
140
which will be finite in the limit 6 —> 0, if we define the cut-off as 12 Z5 = 2(D1(-62)
- D3(-52))
.
(5.38)
From the fact that the expansion (5.35) contains no further term, we also have conservation of the non-local quantum charge, which follows from ^
L
= fdy{[jo(t,y)Jx(t,y
+
6)]-(5^-6)}
-2(D1(-S2)-D3(-52))Jdy^(t,y)^0
as
S -»0
.
We may thus define the quantum non-local charge as the limit Q« = lim Q]j We examine now its action on asymptotic states. We could follow reference [25] and compute Qm/°ut in terms of asymptotic states. Although the results turn out to be correct, the procedure is not rigorous. We shall thus follow [28] and [29], computing first the action on one particle state and then on two particle states, which is our aim. Details not shown in the text are presented in Appendix G. The Lorentz transformation acts on the non-local charge as N —2 J*'
[T,QV] =
,
(5.39)
IT
where J y is the isospin operator acting on a 0{N) vector | 9, k) as
jij\e,k)
= isik\9,j)-isjk\e,i)
= (iij)kl\e,i)
.
(5.40)
Since the non-local charge commutes with translations, it must annihilate the vacuum: Qij\0)=Q
.
Moreover, it is a second order antisymmetric tensor and, on a one particle state, must satisfy Qij\0,k)=g(e){5'k\6,i)-Sik\9,j)}
.
On the other hand, the generator of Lorentz transformations acts on a one particle state as T\e,i)
= -^\e,i) d9'
.
12
The divergent piece arises from the first, linearly divergent term in the Wilson expansion (5.35). We have Qs =
finite
+ /
dx\ -
C l
^
' \ / dyji(t,y)
Therefore we find (5.38) after using (5.36) and (5.37).
- Zs /
dyji(t,y)
141
5.3 Chiral Gross-Neveu Model Applying (5.39) on a one-particle state, we find .N-
dg
2
-i
de
7T
Since Qij is odd under parity, we have ,N - 2 9(0) = ~iTherefore QH\e,k)
= ]^e{Vk\6,i)-6ik\9,j}}
.
(5.41)
ITT
The action of the charge on two-particle states is described in Appendix G. For a two-particle state with different momenta we have (fa ® ^41Q"^'|>i ® h) = limt_,.±oo / dxdy e(x - y ) x X {
Qmn\0i,ii02j) =
\91,k-,e2,i){-[{rnr)ik{rnyl-(imryl(rn)ik'\ ITT
Z7T
J
and (0i,*;02,j I Qmn = {01,k;e2,l
| {[(J m r )' f c (I™)'' - (J™")"(I™H
TV — 2 + —: 9AImn)ikVl
+
ITT
/V — 9 -92{Imnyl5ik\ ITT
-i . i
The constraints on S-matrix elements [4] implied by the action of the non-local charge on asymptotic states are discussed in Chapter 8 and Appendix G, where we also show that as a result of these constraints, there is no pair production.
5.3
Chiral Gross-Neveu Model
This model is a generalization of the previous one, promoting the discrete symmetry (5.14) to a global continuous chiral (7(1) symmetry [2] V> ->•
eie~*5ip
142
Self-Interacting fermionic models
and the trivial symmetry tjj -> —ip to a global U(l) symmetry i> -> eiaip
.
In fact, ip now is a complex Dirac field (see footnote 1), so that the symmetry is now SU(N) <8> U(l) ® U(l). The Lagrangian is given by C = i & fal>i + ^g[(^i)2
- bPils^i)2}
,
(5.42)
where the summation over the SU(N) index i is understood. The Lagrangian (5.42) again defines an integrable model [3, 8]. The Noether current associated with the U(N) symmetry is given by Use of the equation of motion and Fierz transformation, shows that it satisfies Eq. (5.2), as well as equations (5.8) to (5.10). This demonstrates the integrability of the chiral Gross-Neveu model, and implies the existence of a non-local conserved charge of the form (5.7).
5.3.1
Cancellation of infrared singularities
In order to obtain the 1/iV expansion of this model, we have to reformulate it. As in the previous case, the theory can be reduced to a quadratic form in ip at the expense of two auxiliary fields, C =ii> flip- —(a2 +7T2) +:ip(a +iTT-f5)ip .
(5.43)
However, the 1/JV expansion of the model using the above Lagrangian cannot be performed, due to serious infrared (IR) problems [30]. Indeed, if we try to do it, we find a massless pole in the IT propagator, which plays the role of a massless ("would be") Goldstone boson, whose appearance is forbidden in two dimensions by the Coleman-Mermin-Wagner theorem [5]. In order to deal with this problem, it is common practice to write the fields in terms of a + iir = pe1^, such that the Lagrangian reads C = hp jhl>~ —P2 + pipe^'ip
.
(5.44)
We are going to discuss the quantum theory associated with the above classical Lagrangian in three different ways, obtaining similar results. The more pedestrian approach consists in the extensive use of the bosonization formulae of Chapter 2. The fermionic fields are bosonized in terms of an iV-plet y>»- The situation is analogous to the massive Thirring model, and one obtains the equivalent bosonic Lagrangian N
C=-^2(dtl
N
+ ^PJ2™s(
(5.45)
143
5.3 Chiral Gross-Neveu Model
It is now convenient to use "fermionization" formulae in order to rewrite (5.45) in terms of new fermion fields xpi [31, 32], by making the identifications irpi Wi = - \d„ ((pi + Z L
-=)
\
V47T'
ipiipi = 7rcos(
+ l
Piv4'ir)
,
Z7T
The Lagrangian (5.45) then takes the form [32] —
-
1
-=- -
\
-=-
N
C = 4>ii @i)ilg- —p2 + pipiipi + -d^HnYl^i »7T + ^-{d^Y z
(5.46)
The important point is that the massless field
±i
the Lagrangian (5.44) takes the form
C = *[iV + P
+
1
! ^ +
PJ-^1>--p+P-
(5.47)
It is convenient to consider an auxiliary Lagrangian £ ' obtained from (5.47) by the substitution <9M -» £>M = dM — iA^, with A^ an "external" £/(l)-field:
£ = i> (ip>+P+lA^+p-1—^-)
v- - \P+P-
(5.48)
The corresponding effective action is given by iW[A,p+,p-}=
In det (ip
+ p+^-^+p. 2
1 _ 7 5
(5.49)
2
The effective Lagrangian (5.48) is invariant under the local transformation
Afi -»• Ap + e^vdv(p P±^e^p± ,
,
the generator of the corresponding infinitesimal transformation being T[
5 = J d2xL^dv "uS**
s
p-1 5p-
s p+1— 5p+
}•
(5.50)
144
Self-Interacting fermionic models
The effective action (5.49) however breaks this local invariance. Indeed, the external field axial vector current SW oAv
= tpVJv(x,A)=etlv—-
Jti(x;A)
,
(5.51)
exhibits the well known Adler-Bell-Jackiw anomaly [33, 34, 35], which in 1+1 dimensions takes the form (see Chapter 4) &kh
= Tr?vFi™
•
(5-52)
Using (5.51) and (5.52) one finds [23, 22]
Hence W[A] is not gauge invariant as a result of the anomaly (5.52). From here it immediately follows, using (5.50), that T2y\W
f d2x{d»
=~
Tn[
,
n>2
,
(5.53)
.
Since finite transformations are obtained by exponentiating T, the corresponding series truncates when eT is applied to W: eT^W
= W+^
2TT
[d2x vt^Fuu
J
- ^
/ d 2 x (d^f
2-7T J
.
Therefore
W[Alt-elll/d,'
P-} + ^ J
= d2x e^F^v
- ^ J d2x (d^)2
.
In particular, we obtain for the actual case of interest, A^ = 0, TV r
W[0, p+, p-] = W[e^d"p,
e - * p + , e * V ] + ^ J
.
(5.54)
The left hand side is just the effective action associated with (5.47), while the first term on the right hand side is the effective action associated with (5.46), if we make the identification ip — f. This proves the equivalence of Lagrangians (5.46) and (5.47).
5.3.2
T h e ^ expansion
The large TV expansion of the model defined by the Lagrangian (5.46) can be explicitly performed [32], following the method described in Eqs. (5.17) to (5.27). The
145
5.3 Chiral Gross-Neveu Model
propagator of the p field is exactly the same as that obtained for the a field in the 0{N) case. 13 The zero'th order contribution to the p-propagator is thus given by expression (5.26), with the diagrams depicted in Figure 5.3. From (5.25) and (5.26) we obtain for f (p) 27T tanh § where 8 is defined by p2 = —Am2 sinh
"S£" 9,lv F i g u r e 5 . 1 3 : Diagrams contributing to the two-point function of the field Ali—y/Nclt„a'/(t:.
Since only d^ occurs in (5.46), we just need the two point function of A^ = vNttxvdv4>. We thus have to compute the diagrams of Figure 5.13, as given by 14
""W ~
Sn9^
4try
(# + m)7„(#+ ji + m) m2)[(k +p)2 — m]
{2n)2^{k2_
Performing the integral one finds / — p2 + Am21 \/—p2 + 4m 2 — y/—p2 2TT V -P2 y/-p2 + Am2 + v / 3p* 1 f) — 0 t a n h -(# M „p 2 - p^pv) 1
^w=^\H^F-^ y ,
f
2
\ ~ v , a>,^ - p**)
where p2 = -Am2 sinh 2 | . The vertices are shown in Figure 5.14. The amplitudes for particle scattering are thus all free from IR divergencies, and may be computed without difficulty. We shall compute the two particle scattering amplitude in lowest order. The S-matrix elements have the general structure (0iM£Z I <M;02j> = {ux(9)8ik5jl + u2(e)Sil6kj)5(e1 {Ul(e)5a5ki + u2{9)Sik5jl)5(e1
- 0'1)5{e2 - 0'2) + - d'2)8(62 - e[) .
13
We first redefine p — — m + -y^p; the condition that the field p has zero vacuum expectation value, implies that the mass parameter m be given by the expression (5.13). 14 This integral is convergent if a reasonable regularization is used. Indeed, the only divergent piece comes from / d 2 fctr7 f ,7 P 7„ 7
/ d2kk2f{k2)
,
which vanishes due to the identity 7^7^ j p = 0. Therefore, the integral may be performed using the residue theorem. The anomaly cancels between the two terms, as it should, since the second term corresponds to the effective action.
146
Self-Interacting fermionic models
;YuY 5
F i g u r e 5.14: Interaction vertices corresponding to the Lagrange density (5.46).
The lowest order contributions to ui(8) are given in Figure 5.14. The p exchange diagram contributes a term N " h e (the p-propagator at zero momentum is a constant), while the A^ exchange contributes /
47ri\
(—-k)2
i
V AT/4msinh<9 The resulting amplitude is found to be U l (0)
,
ffi
M
,
.
N
= l + ^coth(^
.
(5.56)
We shall verify in Chapter 8 that this is indeed the lowest order approximation of the exact solution. Particle-antiparticle backward scattering vanishes. This may also be verified by a perturbative calculation, using an IR cut-off [27].
5.3.3
Operator formulation
This model may also be studied in the operator formalism, which leads to the 1/7V expansion, and a correct understanding of the relation between the "would be" Goldstone boson and chiral symmetry. Since the fields tpi lie in the fundamental representation of U(N), we have the following bosonic representation [36]
with i = 1 , . . . , N. Since the x'is satisfy15
are
SU(N) valued; they are not independent, but
N
J2xi(x)=0
.
(5.58)
»=i
The field x i s the potential of the conserved U{1) current. Its zero -mass character will ensure that the U{1) symmetry is not spontaneously broken. 16 15
The independent fields are given by Xf = X ) T / / ^ l r > w h e r e T%D a r e t h e generators of the "torus" of SU(N), and
147
5.3 Chiral Gross-Neveu Model
In the above, K;is a Klein factor, necessary to enforce the correct anticommutation relations among different \p[s. Due to the U{\) x U{1) symmetry, the divergence and the curl of the 1/(1) current vanish, so that the field xix) is massless. Therefore the fermion fields contain the so-called infraparticles [37], and we need to extract them in order to arrive at the physical fields of the theory. They are given by j,i(X)=K
/Ze^{75Xi(x)+/JVxi(x°,y1)} V 27T
_
(559)
The ip fields (5.59) will be found to correspond to the field ^ in (5.46). These fields no longer carry E/(l) x C/(l) charge, and transform as a representation of SU(N). The constraint (5.58) implies V'i ~ 7 TTie»i•••<"-!^i ' " ^ i v - i ' ( 5 - 60 ) (n-1)! where on the right hand side a suitable redefinition of the Klein factor and the normal product prescription is required. Eq. (5.60) states that the antifermions of the chiral Gross-Neveu model can be viewed as a bound state of N — 1 fermions. We shall use this fact to determine the S-matrix and its pole structure. Asymptotically one expects ip to describe massive particles, so that one should have [36] rp(vt,t) -> ^ { e - i m 7 _ 1 ' a ( m 7 t ; ) + e ' ^ ^ ' S ^ n v y t ; ) }
,
(5.61)
vl*l The fields ipi carry spin s = | ( 1 — 1/N), as can be seen from Eq. (2.47). They have the property (see (2.40)), 4>(x, t)j>{y, t) = e2'"<x-y^(y,
t)j,(x, t)
,
implying an unusual statistics for the creation and annihilation operators defined in (5.61) tf{p)ai(p') = e ^ ^ - P V f c V t e ) • Since no scattering theory is known for particles with the above statistics, it is necessary to replace the field xf> by another field tp' with a well defined statistics. This is achieved by introducing in (5.57) free massless scalar and pseudoscalar fields B and A, quantized with metric opposite to that of x{x)i i n such a way that the divergent infrared behavior of ip induced by x(^) is compensated, without affecting the statistics. We define [36] xP[(x) = eVfrfr
A
^+B^^i(x)
.
Correspondingly, the operators a* ,a,tf ,b are related to a\ a, ¥, b by a
JF in\P) = ain(P)e -t I \ t ( \ 2iri(s-|) f N0„t(p')dp'
(5.62)
148
Self-Interacting fermionic models
where N m are the corresponding particle number operators. Since we expect ip\(x) to be a local field describing massive degrees of freedom, we should have in the far past and future [38] ip'(vt,t)
->
-i=[e-imT_1'aou«(m7u)+eimT"lt6L(m7u)]
.
(5.63)
Substitution of ip in terms of ip' in (5.42) leads formally to the Lagrangian
£ = & Hi + \9[$rt'i)2
- bP'nsri)2} - \{d,Af
+ -?=lp'jS1»iP>dfiA--{Lj1»ip'dtiB
-
\{d,Bf
,
(5.64)
where we allowed for general couplings a and /?, which after renormalization should reduce to y/n as the renormalized value. We will came back to this point after obtaining the ^ expansion, which we consider next. The effective action obtained from the Lagrangian (5.64) after introduction of the auxiliary fields a and 7r (compare with (5.43)) is given by Seff = -iN ti In i i ft + a + in-y5 + - ^ = 7 5 dA--^=
I
VN
- i J d2x{a2 +*2)-\j
VTT
dB\
J
d2x[(d,A)2 + (d.B)2} .
The field a is found to have a non-vanishing vacuum expectation value (a) = — m, so that it is convenient to write a 7=
u = —m H
,
and
IT =
w —=
The second order contribution to the effective action is then given by s 2
i ff=l2tTfd2xd2y(iP-m)~1 x
i7NHy)+7N*{yh5+7N15 1
x (i
fi-m)-1
—a(x)
my)
my)
~7w
%
)
Ot
+ y=Tr(x)^s + -T=l5
@A{x)--
- ^ fd2x(a2+n2) + ^ jd2x{AuA + BUB) . The proper functions are given in terms of the one loop diagrams tabulated in Figure 5.15. There are mixed functions as well. We summarize the results. For the a two-point function
d2k
fi + m 2
2
2
ji+tf + 'i
) k - m (k + p)2 - m2
gN
5.3 C h i r a l G r o s s - N e v e u M o d e l
iy5
149
iy5
i
-#»<^>»//-
~i'-<^>-#"
(a)
«/W<^>W>.
(b)
p
P
(d)
-iap v y 5 y,
lap"ir s Y„
x
(c)
(e)
F i g u r e 5 . 1 5 : Diagrams contributing to the jr(o),
i / — p2 + 4m 2 \/—p2 + 4m 2 — \/—p2 n ~ 2n Y -p2 ^ / - p 2 + 4m 2 + y/^P _-j
e
(5.65)
~ 2TT tanh §
'
which is the same as (5.55). For the •n two-point function we have f d2k
-
(2TT)
i
ji + m
2 /0
2
fc - m
— p2 Y -p2 + 4m 2 /
2TT
n
2
fi+ p1 + m
i
'° (fc + p)2 - m2
gN
y/—p2 + Am2 — \/—p2 ^/-p2 + 4 m 2 + y /Z^2
t 61 2TT coth f
~
(5.66)
For the 1PI two-point function involving A and B one finds f
(n\
2 n
,r
f
= -i—p2
d2k
7 M 75(^ + m ) 7 ' / 7 5 ( ^ + ^ + m )
.2
- ip2 + (2ma)2fW7r
7T
= Wsinh^{l4(l--^)} r B B ( P ) = /3 t r y {2ir)2{ka_ma)[{k
+
(5.67)
p)i_m2]p^-v
Q
= -ip2 = 4 i m 2 sinh2 -
,
(5.68)
where we used, in (5.67), the contribution of the Adler anomaly, and in (5.68), current conservation. We also have the mixed term k
d* 5 f^) = -atr|A^ 72
jt + m 2
' k -m
2
ji+ p'+m lo
{k+p)2
- , . ma / c o t h | \ = -2mar™(p) = - — I — j ± \
-m2^*
.
(5.69)
150
Self-Interacting fermionic models
All other 1PI two-point functions involving B are found to vanish. In order to obtain the a and B propagators we just invert (5.65) and (5.68) respectively. The computation of the A and it propagators requires on the other hand, the inversion of the 2 x 2 matrix p
/
A 7T7T
1
\l\rA
TA
TAA
whose determinant is given by (using Eqs. (5.66), (5.67), (5.69)) det T = - i p 2 ( l + a2/ir)Tww
= 4im2 sinh2 i(i
+ —) 2ni — coth §
We find D{p)-
iT
~ ^
^(p2)
( p 2 )
with DA(P2)=
1
p2 1 + a2/n
2,_0_cothf
Dn(p2) =2TT
1+ ^ ( 1 - - ^ )
1 2ma p2 1 + a 2 /7r
£>,rA(p2)
We now fix the parameters a and /? in (5.64) by requiring that the IR divergencies cancel. We expect to obtain for the non-renormalized values, a = oo (corresponding to aren = y/n and j3 = j3ren = ^/TT, since B couples to a conserved current). As a matter of fact, if we consider the fermion-fermion interaction to lowest order in the JJ expansion (see Figure 5.16) we verify that for a —> oo, the mixed propagator D^A gives the contribution (Figure 5.16 b,c). The subscripts refer to 0+0
i 2ma2 p2 i + «i It
{PnU(Plh5u(pi)u{p2)'y5ltlu(p2)
+PMM(pi)757/iu(Pl)"(P2)75M(P2)}
(5.70) We use the equation of motion for the free spinor « ( p ' ) 7 s ( / - ?0«(p) = -2mu(p')7 5 u(p)
,
in order to reduce Eq. (5.70) to the form Ai66+i6c = 2T5--5-U75 puu'7 5 P"' 1 + v_p* 7T
2 Q:
= 2
rl 1+ —
2 -P\lPv
~ 9nvP
—
o P
wy^uwy^u
u
—1 a
1
/c 7, \
,
(5-71)
151
5.3 Chiral Gross-Neveu Model
O n (a)
U~<^>.
(b)
[wuwuwJ
(c)
tOOMWOwd
(d)
(e)
(e)
F i g u r e 5.16: Contribution to fermion fermion scattering at order i-.
where we used the identity e^ppC^p^ = pPp" - g^p2. The exchange of a 7r gives a vanishing contribution for zero momentum transfer. Indeed, w(p)75u(<7)u()75w(p) = m 2
tr
0 — -v 0— v 7 5 ( cosh — h 75 sinh — h
• sinh • i *—+ zjo
X 1. •171 sinh • i * —-— + X ^J
vanishes in the limit q —>• p because of the trace, so that Ai6a = 0
.
Finally, the B exchange gives the contribution A 1 6 e = -^Pz2uru(p)u'l"u^ p
,
p*
which partially cancels (5.71) , leaving us for a —• 00 and /3 = ir, with Aie = A i 6 / - 2m7 M uu'7 M u'
,
which leads again to the result (5.56) . We have thus verified in the N —> 00 limit that both Lagrangians (5.46) and (5.64) lead to the same result for U(l), as they should. In the limit a —> 00, the renormalized coupling aren indeed turns out to be y/n, as one reads off from the four-point function, and the pole in the 7r-propagator vanishes. To summarize, we conclude that part of the field (5.57) which carries chirality decouples [31, 32, 36, 39] from the physical spectrum and the remaining part describes an SU(N) multiplet with a well defined factorizable S-matrix (see Chapter 8). As we shall show in Chapter 17 there exists however a critical point in the coupling constant, where these conclusions are not realized, and the theory is conformally invariant.
5.3.4
Quantization of non-local charge
The discussion of the existence and conservation of a non-local charge in the quantum chiral Gross-Neveu model follows exactly the same pattern as in the O(N) invariant model. No anomaly exists in this case, since (5.35) gives all possible candidates to the Wilson expansion. As for the asymptotic result, there exist however
152
BIBLIOGRAPHY
differences due to the different symmetry group in question; thus, in (5.39) we have to replace N - 2 by• N, and in (5.41) only the first term is present. It is not difficult to see that the action of the charges on asymptotic states is given in this case by
Qab\0ii;02j) = \6ik;e2i)\-(iac)ik(rby' "• ac ki cb lj (Oii;02j\Qab = (e1k;02l\\-{I ) (I ) L
Qab\eii;e2j) = \0ik-,02i)\-(iacyk(i<:byl L
ac ki cb l (Oii;hj\Qab = (e1k;e2l\\-(I ) {I ) i L
+ —e1{iab)iks^>1 + —e2(iab)jlsik] in
in
J
+ —01(Iab)ki5'i + —62(Iab)ljSik] J in in + — ^ j 0 6 ) ' * ^ ' - —0i(iab)1^ sik] J in in ab ki l ab l ik + —0l(I ) 6 > - —0~2{I y 6 ]J in in
, , , ,
where 7 a b are the SU(N) generators defined analogously to (5.40). These formulae will be used in Chapter 8 to fix the exact S-matrix of this model as well.
5.4
Conclusions and Physical Interpretation
The Gross-Neveu models are simple but physically rich models. The semi-classical analysis, both in the O(N) and in the SU(N) x U{\) x [/(l)-symmetric cases reveals that the models have a rich bound-state structure [4]. As we shall see in Chapter 8, in the O(N) symmetric case the complete S-matrix can be computed, thus providing a reasonable understanding of the Gross-Neveu model. The case of the chiral Gross-Neveu model is particularly interesting, due to the chiral symmetry breaking issue. Since, as we saw in the previous section, a mass term is dynamically generated for the fermion, one could be led to conclude that the chiral symmetry is broken, which is prohibited in two-dimensional space-time17.[5] This problem has been discussed at length by several authors [31, 32, 39]. The interesting outcome is that the chirality carrying field decouples from the theory (Eq. (5.62)). In the operator language, this is realized by the factorization of the auxiliary fields A and B. The physical fermions, as given by either (5.59) or (5.62), though exhibiting a non-vanishing mass gap, are chiral singlets. This physical picture is carried over to the supersymmetric C P W _ 1 model, and reflects the fact that antiparticles are bound states of particles, in both, the Gross-Neveu model, and in the supersymmetric ( C P ^ - 1 model. This permits the computation of the S-matrix for these two cases [40] The chiral Gross-Neveu model will also appear in Chapter 12, when we study the so-called U(l) problem in the context of QED2, where an interesting physical interpretation is obtained.
Bibliography [1] Y. Nambu and G. Jona-Lasinio, Phys. Rev. 122 (1961) 345. [2] D. Gross and A. Neveu, Phys. Rev. D10 (1974) 3235. [3] A. Neveu and N. Papanicolau, Commun. Math. Phys. 58 (1978) 31. 17
Gauge theories play a special role in this respect; see Chapter 10.
153
BIBLIOGRAPHY
[4] A.B. Zamolodchikov and Al.B. Zamolodchikov, Phys. Lett. B72 (1978) 481. [5] S. Coleman, Commun. Math. Phys. 31 (1973) 259; N.D. Mermin and H. Wagner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 17 (1966) 1133. [6] R. Dashen, B. Hasslacher and A. Neveu, Phys. Rev. D12 (1975) 2443. [7] A.C. Scott, F.Y. Chu and D.Mc. Laughlin, Proc. of the IEEE 61 (1973) 1443. [8] T.L. Curthright and C. Zachos, Phys. Rev. D24 (1981) 2661. [9] C. Brezin, C. Itzykson, J. Zinn-Justin and J.B. Zuber, Phys. Lett. 82B (1979) 442. [10] S. Coleman and E. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. D 7 (1973) 1888; D l l (1975) 3040. [11] K. Symanzik, Renormalization 1970.
of theories with broken symmetry,
Cargese,
[12] H. Fleming and K. Furuya, Nuovo Cimento 49A (1979) 101. [13] H.D.I. Abarbanel, Nucl. Phys. 130 (1977) 29. [14] H. Fleming, K. Furuya and J.L. de Lyra, Nuovo Cimento 53A (1979) 405. [15] I.S. Gradshteyn and M. Ryzhik, Table of integrals, series and products, A. Press, 1980. [16] S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. 118 (1960) 838. [17] D. Iagolnitzer, Phys. Rev. D18 (1978) 1275. [18] B. Berg, M. Karowski, V. Kurak and P. Weisz, Phys. Lett. 76B (1978) 502. [19] B. Berg, Nuovo Cimento 41A (1977) 58. [20] G. Kallen and J. Toll, J. Math. Phys. 6 (1965) 299. [21] A.B. Zamolodchikov and Al.B. Zamolodchikov, Ann. Phys. 120 (1979) 253. [22] A. DAdda, A. Davis, P. di Vecchia and P. Salomonson, Nucl. Phys. (1983) 45.
B222
[23] A. Polyakov and P. Wiegmann, Phys. Lett. 131B (1983) 121; 141B (1984) 223. [24] K. Wilson, Phys. Rev. 179 (1969) 1499. [25] M. Liischer, Nucl. Phys. B135 (1978) 1. [26] E. Abdalla, A. Lima-Santos, Rev. Bras. Fis. 12 (1982) 293. [27] E. Abdalla and M.C.B. Abdalla, Nuovo Cimento 57A (1980) 334. [28] M. Liischer. Erratum of Nucl. Phys. B135 (1978) 1, unpublished.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
154
[29] D. Buchholtz and J.T. Lopuszanski, Lett. Math. Phys. 3 (1979) 175. [30] B. Berg and P. Weisz, Nucl. Phys. B145 (1978) 205. [31] E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B145 (1978) 110. [32] E. Abdalla, B. Berg and P. Weisz, Nucl. Phys. B157 (1979) 387. [33] B. Zumino, Les Houches, 08/1983, (Notes by K. Sibold); Nucl. Phys.B253 (1985) 477; B. Zumino, Wu Young Shi and A. Zee, Nucl. Phys. B239(1984) 477; L. Baulieu, Nucl. Phys. B241 (1984) 577; R. Stora, in New Developments in Quantum Field Theory and Statistical Mechanics, eds. M. Levy and P. Mitter, Plenum, N. Y., 1977. [34] W. A. Bardeen, Phys. Rev. Cimento 60A (1969) 47.
184 (1969) 1848; J. Bell and R. Jackiw, Nuovo
[35] S. Adler, Phys. Rev. 177 (1969) 2426; in Lectures on Elementary Particle Physics and Quantum Field Theory, ed. S. Deser et al., MIT Press (1970). [36] R. Koberle, V. Kurak and J.A. Swieca, Phys. Rev. D20 (1979) 897; E 2638. [37] B. Schroer, Fortschritte der Physik 11 (1963) 1. [38] H. Araki and R. Haag, Commun. Math. Phys. 4 (1967) 77. [39] A.J. da Silva, M. Gomes and R. Koberle, Phys. Rev. 20 (1979) 895. [40] E. Abdalla and A. Lima-Santos, Phys.. Rev. D29 (1984) 1851.
Chapter 6
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects 6.1
Historical development
Non-linear sigma models have extensive applications in statistical mechanics as well as in quantum field theory. Historically they have been introduced by Schwinger [1] and used in field theory by Gell-Mann and Levy in the sixties to describe the phenomenology of pions [2], realizing the expected current algebra [3, 4] in terms of a quantum theoretic model. The main drawback was the lack of renormalizability [5]. Moreover, the great success of non-Abelian gauge theories, which have become a cornerstone in the field theoretic description of elementary particles, has left the sigma models at a secondary level [6]. Their revival is due to various developments which we will describe in this and the following chapters. First of all, there have been activities on the statistical mechanics of sigma models, with applications to spin dynamics [7]. Also, it became clear in the late seventies that sigma models are, in several ways, closely related to Yang-Mills theories [8, 9, 10, 11]; they were therefore used as a field theoretic laboratory for understanding the theoretical basis of more realistic theories. More recently, sigma-models have appeared in string theory, whose Lagrangian is of the sigma-model type [12, 13]. These models also appear naturally in the low-energy description of supergravity and of string (or superstring) theory, mainly in the framework of Kaluza-Klein schemes [14]. In addition, they provide realizations of certain infinite-dimensional algebras, such as the Kac-Moody algebras [15], which are very important in the context of string theory and conformal field theory. Finally, sigma models appear quite naturally in several other field-theoretic problems that we shall discuss: integrable models [11, 16], confinement [10], -^-expansion [10, 17], Wess-Zumino effective actions [15], non-Abelian generalization of the bosonization technique [15, 18], and others.
156
6.2
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
Sigma models and current algebra
The sigma model was originally introduced in four dimensions and used to describe the phenomenology of P.C.A.C. (partially conserved axial current). It was not a purely geometrical model, but rather given by the Lagrangian [2, 3] C = Co + &
,
(6.1)
which is the sum of two terms, a SO(4) symmetric Lagrangian
, , 2 1 ^ 2 _i_ ^?2\
^ /
2 , =;2\2
and the perturbation C\ given by Ci = ca . Co is symmetric under the group 50(4), or equivalently, under the chiral group, SU{2) x SUX2), which is realized as %
i -*
•>/>->• ip + -a • rip - -/3 • f'ysip 7T —)• 7T — S A 7T + /3<7
a —> a — (3 • -it
,
,
.
The Noether currents associated with these symmetry transformations are the vector current
and the axial vector current A
l
= ~ ^ M T S T V + •*% - ad^
,
which are associated with the transformations labelled by the parameters a1 and /?*, respectively. L\ breaks this symmetry; more precisely, it respects the vector part but breaks the axial part. Therefore, the vector current remains conserved (CVC hypothesis) but the axial current develops a non-vanishing divergence which is, in fact, proportional to the pion field (PCAC hypothesis) [2, 3]: d»A\
= C7T*
.
This is in accordance with the fact that the operators 7rs interpolate between the vacuum and the one-pion states [3]: (01^(0)1^(9)) =zhij
•
157
6.2 Sigma models and current algebra We therefore have the following relation for the pion decay constant:
f„ml = cZ% . A more detailed look at the quantum theory associated with the Lagrangian (6.1) reveals that C\ induces a non-vanishing expectation value v for a. We thus define a new field s with vanishing vacuum expectation value by a = s+ v
,
(s) = 0
.
In terms of s (rather than a), the Lagrangian is of the form C = Ca + £b, where Cb contains the piece linear in s: g{s + in • TIS)]4> + ^(O 9 ^) 2 ~
Ca=i>[^$-m-
A*2)
+ i((aS)2-M^2)-A^(52+7r2)-^(52+7r2)2 Cb = {c-vnl)s
,
(6.2)
,
(6.3)
and where we have introduced the new mass parameters m = gv
;
/z2 = fi2 + Xv2
;
^ 2 = /j? + 3\v2
.
For v ^ 0, the pion fields if and the sigma field a are no longer degenerate in mass, as they were in the original Lagrangian CQ. The parameter v is determined from the requirement that (s) = 0. In lowest order, equating the coefficient in Eq. (6.3) to zero gives v = cjp?v. Obviously, when £ i ^ 0, the SU(2) symmetry is broken explicitly. But even when £i = 0, we may have two phases: for p? > 0 , we are in the symmetric phase: the minimum of the potential occurs at a2 + 7?2 = 0 , i.e., a = irl = 0,v = 0, and the fermions remain massless. For /j,2 <_0j on the other hand, we are in the socalled Goldstone phase [19, 6], where the SU{2) symmetry is spontaneously broken: the minimum of the potential occurs at cr2+7r2 = — /U2/A ^ 0 , i.e., V——/J,2/X^0, and the fermions acquire a non-zero mass, while the pion fields TT describe massless (Goldstone) bosons. The problem with this model is the fact that the particle corresponding to the field a, has not been observed experimentally. One possibility to get rid of this particle is to realize the chiral SU(2) symmetry non-linearly, by imposing the constraint cr2+ff2 = / 2
.
(6.4)
In this case f^ is the only parameter of the theory (formally this corresponds to taking the infinite coupling limit A -> oo). The model is now described entirely by the geometry of the target manifold on which it is defined, that is, the sphere 5 3 . For example, we can use Eq. (6.4) to eliminate the a field from the Lagrangian, obtaining
A) =^t+
9{\/W^i
+ in • 775)]^ + \(dn)2 + \ ( J
2
^
,
(6.5)
158
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
C^c^Jl^p .
(6.6)
In four dimensions, the non-linear sigma model as denned by Eqs. (6.5) and (6.6) is unfortunately not renormalizable. A study of its renormalization properties has been performed long ago [5]. In lowest order new counterterms such as {dH • di?)2 are required. Therefore, this theory is at best a phenomenological low-energy approximation of some more realistic model. In two dimensions, the non-linear sigma model as defined by Eqs. (6.5) and (6.6) (without the matter interaction) is a special case of the general class of nonlinear sigma models that we are going to study from now on. These models have a geometric origin - just like non-Abelian gauge theories. In the present chapter we shall, at the purely classical level, define non-linear sigma models, and their interaction with matter fields, from the geometric point of view, and investigate their integrability. In the next chapter we shall discuss quantization of these models, and consider further formulations.
6.3
Two-dimensional a models: preliminaries
Our aim is to provide a general framework for defining classical non-linear sigma models. We are particularly interested in theories that are integrable, i.e., that exhibit an infinite number of conservation laws, as well as in models relevant to more realistic quantum field theory. We begin with the simplest series of non-linear a models, namely the spherical models, more commonly known as the 0(./V)-invariant non-linear sigma models or, somewhat abusively, the 0(N) (sigma) models; these have played an interesting and peculiar role in the recent development of quantum field theory. Classically, the field configurations in this kind of model are maps (f from some base space (usually flat Minkowski space or Euclidean space) to the (N - l)-dimensional sphere S ^ - 1 , so any such map can be viewed as a multiplet of N real scalar fields ?,, i = 1,..., N, subject to the quadratic constraint V?2 = tpupi = 1
,
(6.7)
with dynamics governed by the Lagrangian
C=±(d
•
(6.8)
(Here and in the following, summation over repeated indices is understood, as usual.) This is, of course, just the Lagrangian for the free field, but the presence of the constraint (6.7) implies that the model is not a free field theory. In fact, variation of the Lagrangian (6.8) with respect to
+ (d^j••dllipj)
,
(6.9)
which is obviously a non-linear partial differential equation. One way to derive (6.9) is by enforcing the constraint with the help of a Lagrange multiplier term that is
6.3 Two-dimensional a models: preliminaries
159
added to the Lagrangian, giving £ = \(d
•
(6.10)
Then varying the Lagrangian (6.10) with respect to the Lagrange multiplier A yields the constraint (6.7), while varying it with respect to
,
which can be achieved by performing an appropriate conformal transformation. 1 Then d%v=-ip-^±d-ip
+cot ad+ad+
8Hip = -(p-^d+ip
,
+ cfAad-ad-V
(6.11) .
(6.12)
Differentiating (6.11) with respect to a; - , or (6.12) with respect to x+, and inserting back the other equation now leads to the following equation of motion for a: d+d-a
+ sin a = 0 .
This is the sine-Gordon equation [22]. An analogous connection can be established between the 0(4) sigma model and the complex sine-Gordon theory [21]. Therefore, the results on the sine-Gordon equation described in Chapter 3 and the analogous 1
This is allowed in the classical theory, which is conformally invariant.
160
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
results that hold for the complex sine-Gordon equation [24] suggest that the 0(3) and 0(4) models are both integrable. Actually the 0(N) sigma model is integrable for any value of N, in the following sense. Consider the Noether current j ^ associated with the 0(./V)-transformations, which is a vector field with values in the real antisymmetric (N x JV)-matrices, with matrix entries {Jn)ij = fidlfj =
.
(6.14)
On the other hand, it follows from the constraint (6.7) that it also satisfies the identity dlljv-dvj^ + 2[j^ju] = Q . (6.15) This implies, for example, conservation (i.e., time-independence) not only of the standard Noether charge
0(1) = fdyj0{t,y)
,
but also of the non-local charge Q<2) = / dy1dy2e{y1 - y2) jo(t,yi) Jo(t,y2) + / dyjx(t,y)
,
(6.16)
as can be verified from Eqs. (6.14) and (6.15) by direct calculation. Note that these charges are - just like the current itself - real antisymmetric (N x 7V)-matrices, so the commutators and products appearing in Eqs. (6.15) and (6.16) are to be understood in the sense of (N x Ar)-matrices. In fact, QW and O/2) are just the first two members of an infinite series of conserved charges Q^ which - except for O/1) - turn out to be non-local and which can be derived by an appropriate expansion in the spectral parameter based on the linear system associated with this problem; a detailed exposition will be given, in a more general setting, later on in this chapter. The way in which the sigma field in the O(N) sigma model can be coupled to fermions so as to preserve these classical properties can be derived by using supersymmetry. To this end, we extend the multiplet of N real scalar fields tpi to a multiplet of N real scalar superfields $ , on which we impose the same quadratic constraint as before: *i*i = l • (6.17) The superfield expansion of the fields $» reads, in the Majorana representation for the gamma matrices (see Appendix A) *i{x,0)
= (pi(x)+Hi{x)+'^60Fi{x)
,
(6.18)
where 9 is a two-component Majorana spinor. In terms of the component fields ipi (the scalar fields), ipi (the Majorana spinor fields which are their fermionic partners)
161
6.3 Two-dimensional a models: preliminaries
and Fi (the auxiliary fields), the constraint (6.17) becomes
,
fiipi = 0
,
(fiiFi = -ip^i
.
(6.19)
The corresponding Lagrangian can be written
C = i J dOdOTWiDSi , where D$i is the superderivative of $;, with spinor components determined from Da = -^-t(ma
= (loU~-ihfie)adll
,
(6.20)
and the rules of Berezin [25] integration are such that
Sdteee = 4
.
(6.21)
/ •
Using (6.18) and (6.20) to compute the superfield expansion for the superfields D$i and carrying out the fermionic integrals according to the standard rule (6.21) of Berezin integration, we obtain C=\d*ipidll
+ 2FiFi
.
(6.22)
Variation of the Lagrangian (6.22) with respect to the fields ipi, ipi and Fi under the constraints (6.19) (e.g., by means of the Lagrange multiplier method described before) leads to the following equations of motion: Wd^i
+ {jPtpj d^j + (^-Vi) 2 )
dpipj - 2 ( ^ ) Ft = 0
Hi + bPi^i) i>i = 0
,
Fi = \($i1>i)
, (6.23) (6.24) (6-25)
Inserting Eq. (6.25) back into Eqs. (6.22), (6.23) and (6.24), we can eliminate the auxiliary field both from the Lagrangian and from the remaining equations of motion, arriving at [26] 1 „„ „ i - «. , 1 ,-r C = g S'Vi d^i + \ i>ifA + \{^i)2 L =
(6.26)
as the Lagrangian, d^d^i
+ (d^tpj dptpj) tpi - iip^ipi
d^tfj = 0
(6.27)
as the bosonic equation of motion and i(6ij - ipitpj) Hi + &ji>i) i>i=0
(6.28)
162
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
as the fermionic equation of motion. In particular, we see that the bosonic sector is the usual O(N) sigma model, while the fermionic sector is nothing but the GrossNeveu model discussed in Chapter 5. The Noether current JM associated with the O (.^-transformations is now the sum J»=j,+j™
(6-29)
of a contribution j ^ from the bosonic fields
•
(6-30)
Again, this current is conserved due to the equations of motion (6.27) and (6.28): d" JM = 0
.
(6.31)
On the other hand, it follows from the constraints (6.19), together with the fermionic equation of motion (6.28), that it also satisfies the relation dli{Jv+j™)-dv{Jll+3™)
+ 2[Jll,Jv] = Q .
(6.32)
This implies, for example, conservation (i.e., time-independence) not only of the standard Noether charge QW=
jdyJ0{t,y)
,
(6.33)
but also of the non-local charge
Q{2)= Jdy1dy2e(y1-y2)J0(t,y1)J0(t,y2)
+ J dy(Jx+tf){t,y)
,
(6.34)
as can be verified from Eqs. (6.31) and (6.32) by direct calculation. Again, Q^ and Q(2) are just the first two members of an infinite series of conserved charges Q(") which - except for Q^ - turn out to be non-local and which can be derived by an appropriate expansion in the spectral parameter based on the linear system associated with this problem; a detailed exposition will be given in a more general setting, later on in this chapter. A natural question that poses itself at this point is of course whether this intriguing structure is specific to the 0(N) sigma models or whether it can be extended to other classes of non-linear sigma models, and if so, to which. For example, considering the sphere SN~X as the quotient space SN~1 = 0(N)/0(N - 1) or jN-l
=
SO(N)/SO(N-l)
one may ask what happens if one replaces the orthogonal group O(N) by the unitary group U(N) and hence, the (N - l)-dimensional sphere SN_1 by some quotient space such as SU(N)/SU{N-1) or SU(N)/U(N-1), the latter being nothing but the complex (N — l)-dimensional projective space [27] (CP^- 1 S SU(N)/U(N
- 1)
,
6.3 Two-dimensional a models: preliminaries
163
whose points are, by definition, just the one-dimensional subspaces (rays) in the space C^. Thus we are directly led to the extremely interesting series of non-linear sigma models commonly known as the
i
together with a freedom under U(l) gauge transformations Zi(x)
-»• eia(x)
Zi(x)
,
reflecting the fact that the original fields Z{ and all of their gauge transforms are just different parametrizations of the same physical field. In this approach, one must make sure that all physical quantities are gauge invariant, which requires the use of covariant derivatives U/iZi = O^Zi
IZ^A-p
,
where A^ is a U(l) gauge potential which transforms according to A* -> An + d»a
(6-36)
under U(l) gauge transformations. The dynamics of the model is then governed by the Lagrangian [29] C = WFiDpZi . (6.37) Here, the U(l) gauge potential appears as a Lagrange multiplier, so its equation of motion expresses it in terms of the fields Zi A^ = -izjd^Zj
.
(6.38)
One of the attractive features of the C P W _ 1 models is that they possess instanton solutions for any N. To see this, we must pass from Minkowski space to compactified Euclidean space, which is the two-sphere S2, so the classical field configurations are now maps from S2 to C P W _ 1 . These Euclidean field configurations fall into distinct topological classes, called homotopy classes, and due to the fact that TT2(
— 9
/
"^ ^^v
fJ-^i L)vZ% — (,
I (t X Cfj_i/ U^Ay
,
164
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
with AM given by Eq. (6.38) and ei 2 = 1. Equivalently, using the boundary conditions on the fields Zi at infinity in Euclidean space which guarantee that they represent a map which extends to the point at infinity in S2, we can write, for \x\ large, Zi(x) ~ g(x)zi
,
where g is a phase function describing a mapping from the unit circle U(l) in xspace to the group U(l); then Q is the winding number of g. Now the Euclidean action S = f (fxC obeys the inequality S>2ir\Q\
,
which follows directly from \(Dll±iellvDv)z\2>0
.
The condition for the action to be a minimum is therefore ellvD„z = ±iDtlz
.
(6.39)
This is (depending on the sign) called the self-duality or anti-self-duality condition. Thus the solutions of Eq. (6.39) are minima of the action within their topological class, which is fixed by Q. Next, introducing the fields u\3' given by Jf\x)
=Zi(x)/Zj(x)
,
which, conversely, reproduce the fields Zi (up to an arbitrary phase) according to
k0)(*) .\J / (
it is not difficult to verify that Eq. (6.39) is further simplified; it becomes
This simply means that the ui\J' must be arbitrary functions of Xi ± ix2, i.e., arbitrary holomorphic or antiholomorphic functions. The O(N) sigma models or S1*^1 models and the C P ^ - 1 models have one specific model in common, namely the 0(3) sigma model, which is nothing but the non-linear sigma model on the manifold S2^
,
[Le.SO(3)<*SU(2),SO(2)°
,
(6.40)
so the two series generalize this one model in different directions. Explicitly, the diffeomorphism in Eq. (6.40) is realized via the identification fa
— ZiVtjZj
>
where i,j = 1,2, a = 1,2,3 and the aa denote the Pauli matrices. Under this identification, the two Lagrangians (6.8) and (6-37) become identical.
6.3 Two-dimensional a models: preliminaries
165
As in the case of the O(N) sigma model, the C P W _ 1 model turns out to be integrable for any value of N. Indeed, the Noether current j M associated with the Sf/(iV)-transformations, which is now a vector field with values in the complex traceless antiHermitean (N x jV)-matrices, with matrix entries tii*)ij = ZiD^Zj = Zi D^Zj - D^Zi Zj
,
(6.41)
again satisfies the conservation law (6.14) together with the identity (6.15), with the same consequences for integrability [11, 16, 30] as before. Moreover, the entire series of (EPN~X models present instanton solutions, whereas in the series defined on the sphere, this is valid only for the 0(3) case. Again as in the case of the O(N) sigma model, the way in which the sigma field in the
Zitpi = 0, i/jiZi = 0
(6.42)
and together with a freedom under U(l) gauge transformations Zi[x) -»• eia^
Zi{x)
,
TPi{x) -»• eia^
^(x)
which leads to the introduction of covariant derivatives D^Zi = d^Zi - iziAp
,
D^ipi = d^ipi - iipiA^
,
with Ap a U(l) gauge potential which transforms as usual (i.e., according to Eq. (6.36)) under t/(l) gauge transformations. The dynamics of the model is now governed by the Lagrangian £ = S^2?Mzi + i ^ ^
+ i[^i)2-(^175^)2]
•
(6-43)
Again, the U(l) gauge potential appears as a Lagrange multiplier, so its equation of motion expresses it in terms of the fields Zi and tpf. A„ = -izjd^Zj
- -^fi^j
.
In particular, we see that the bosonic sector is the usual C P N _ 1 model, while the fermionic sector is nothing but the chiral Gross-Neveu model discussed in Chapter 5. Also, the Noether current JM associated with the 5t/(A r )-transformations is again the sum J it = 3n + 3fi of a contribution j ' M from the bosonic fields Zi, with matrix entries as given in (6.41), and a contribution jjf from the fermionic matter fields ipi, with matrix entries ULL )ij
=i'4'jl^i
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
166
Again, it satisfies the conservation law (6.31) together with the relation (6.32), with the same consequences for integrability as before. Moreover, if we drop the constraints (6.42) as well as the fermionic self-interaction terms in the Lagrangian (6.43), we obtain what we shall call the minimal model [31] which as we shall see, is still integrable. We now want to discuss how the various non-linear sigma models discussed so far fit into a common geometric framework and, in particular, what are the general conditions under which they define (classical) integrable systems.
6.4
Purely Bosonic Non-linear a Models
In this section we shall consider the general formulation of bosonic non-linear sigma models from a mathematically well defined point of view, and the particular case where the model displays the so-called dual symmetry. This formulation of sigma models developed and analysed in great detail by Eichenherr and Forger [32, 33, 34], exhausts, in particular the problem of integrability in the context of the purely bosonic case. The section ends with an example, where we obtain the Grassmannian (and in particular the <EPN~l) models as a particular case of the general set up.
6.4.1
Formal developments
Preliminaries Generally speaking, a non-linear sigma model is a field theory of maps between manifolds. More precisely, the classical field configurations in such a model are (smooth) maps
,
(6.44)
leading, upon variation of the corresponding action S=±JcPxy/te\9'",9i3d»
>
(6-45)
to the equations of motion d„
$"" ( V ^ V * + T)k d^
,
(6.46)
with
v^cw* = d^du^ - r£„dv . Here, the g^u and gij are the components of the given metric tensor on X with respect to x^ and on M with respect to ipl, respectively, while the T*v and T k are the corresponding Christoffel symbols, r
^ = 2 flKA (d»9«"
+ dv9K
» ~ 9K9^
'
6.4 Purely Bosonic Non-linear a Models
167
T
U = 2 9tl (di9ik + dkgij - digjk)
,
and \g\ = |det (gM„)| • Moreover, the gtj, r!-fc etc. are to be considered as functions on X (or appropriate domains therein) by looking at them as functions on M (or appropriate domains therein) and then composing these with the map
,
(6.47)
to be supplemented by the constraints expressing the fact that the ^-valued field ip appearing here must be restricted to lie on the embedded submanifold M: this is exactly the situation we encounter in the 0(N) sigma models and also in the (Tjpiv-i models if we employ the formulation in terms of projector fields (cf. Eq. (6.35)). Indeed, we can easily make contact between the two forms (6.44) and (6.47) of the Lagrangian if we reexpress the constrained E-valued field
168
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
former with respect to curvilinear (local) coordinates on the submanifold M of E. Thus
and so (6.44) and (6.47) become identical, with
General mathematical set up So far, we have merely come to the conclusion that the target space M should be some (connected) Riemannian manifold. This of course still leaves us with an enormous freedom of choice and hence calls for some organizing principle. One such principle - and a natural one if we remember that all the important applications of non-linear sigma models in physics have to do with symmetries and symmetry breaking - comes from group theory: the idea is to classify the target space M according to the "size" of its symmetry group G, which is essentially its isometry group. 5 The two extreme possibilities here are that M either has no symmetries at all or has sufficiently many symmetries to link any two given points. In the first case, the isometry group of M is trivial (consists of the identity alone) or is at best discrete. This situation is in a certain sense generic, a typical example being provided by the so-called Calabi-Yau spaces [40] which play an important role in the compactification of extraneous space-time dimensions in string theory [41]. In the second case, the isometry group of M acts transitively on M, which means that for any two given points in M, there is an isometry of M taking one into the other. In other words, M must be a Riemannian homogeneous space. All other cases are intermediate between these two because any Riemannian manifold can be uniquely decomposed into the disjoint union of orbits under its isometry group [42]. In any case, however, the symmetry group G is not completely fixed by the target space M alone; in fact there are technical advantages in retaining some flexibility in the choice of G. Therefore, we simply assume we are given some connected Lie group G, with Lie algebra Q, which acts transitively on M by isometries; this action of G on M will be written in the form6 GxM-+M (9, m) -> g • m
, (6.48)
and induces an action
GxTM^TM 5 Isometries of a Riemannian manifold are invertible smooth transformations of that manifold onto itself with smooth inverse which preserve the metric [38, 39]. 6 Any action of G on M by isometries defines a homomorphism of G into the isometry group of M which, however, is in general not an isomorphism: it may have a non-trivial kernel, consisting of elements in G that act trivially on M, and its image is in general some subgroup of the isometry group of M; what is needed is just that this subgroup is sufficiently large so that its action on M is still transitive.
6.4 Purely Bosonic Non-linear a Models
169
of G on the tangent bundle TM of M, as well as a representation
g^XK{M) X -&• XM
, >
of Q in the Lie algebra XK{M) of Killing vector fields on M.7 Explicitly, the action of an element g in G on a tangent vector u in TM is defined by letting g act on a curve in M having u as its derivative, that is, ii u = ^m(t)
, t=o
g-u = g • {-gm{t) t=o
dt
t=0
whereas the value of the fundamental vector field XM on M associated with a generator X in Q at a point m in M is defined by letting the one-parameter group generated from X act on m, XM{m)
= —(exp(tX)
• m)
dt
t=o
In the rest of this chapter, we shall only consider non-linear sigma models with enough symmetries to exclude the presence of accidental degeneracies. In mathematical language, this means that we suppose the action (6.48) of G on M to be transitive. We also fix, once and for all, an arbitrary reference point m 0 in M and define H to be its stability group: then if is a closed subgroup of G and M becomes identified with the homogeneous space, or coset space, G/H: M = G/H
.
(6.49)
Of course, this coset space cannot be completely arbitrary because we must take into account that M should be a Riemannian manifold on which G is supposed to act by isometries. As a result, it turns out that the stability group H will be compact, the coset space G/H will be reductive and the G-invariant Riemannian metric on M will be induced from a biinvariant pseudo-Riemannian metric on G.8 In particular, the statement that the coset space G/H is reductive means that if Q is the Lie algebra of G as before and HcQ denotes the Lie algebra of H c G, there exists an //-invariant subspace M of Q which is complementary to the Lie subalgebra H of Q, so that we have an //-invariant direct decomposition 9 Q = U®M 7
,
(6.50)
Killing vector fields on a Riemannian manifold are vector fields on that manifold along which the Lie derivative of the metric vanishes. 8 In mathematically rigorous form, such conclusions can only be drawn if we impose certain technical conditions on the choice of G and (hence) of H. In all cases of practical importance, however, these conditions are met, so we shall not go into any details and instead refer to the literature [30, 11]. 9 Here H-invariance refers to the representation of H on Q or on its subspaces obtained by restriction of the adjoint representation of G on Q to H.
170
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
In particular, if-invariance of this decomposition implies the following commutation relations: [H,U\cH , [H,M]cM . (6.51) For later use, we mention already at this point that the coset space G/H is called (locally) symmetric if in addition we have the commutation relation
[M,M]cH .
(6.52)
At the opposite end, we have the possibility that
[M,M]cM
.
(6.53)
This actually means that M. is an ideal in Q, so taking the exponential, we see that M appears as a normal Lie subgroup of G. In any case, M. can be identified with the tangent space TmoM to M at the reference point mo - just as Q (or %) can be identified with the tangent space T\G to G (or T\H to H) at the group unit 1. Therefore, the (^-invariant Riemannian metrics ( . , . ) M on M are in one-toone correspondence with the //-invariant positive definite scalar products (.,.)M on M. - just as the biinvariant pseudo-Riemannian metrics (., -)G on G are in oneto-one correspondence with the G-invariant (more precisely, v4d(G)-invariant) nondegenerate scalar products (., .)g on Q; then the statement that the former is induced from the latter simply means that the direct decomposition (6.50) is orthogonal with respect to {-,-)g and that (.,.)g restricted to M. coincides with (.,.)M- We can therefore afford to drop the indices on the various metrics or scalar products and denote them all by the same symbol (.,.), without danger of confusion. Non-linear sigma models on the symmetric space M — G/H With these technicalities out of the way, we can proceed to the formulation of the non-linear sigma model on M = G/H in which G appears as the global symmetry group while H appears as the gauge group. The idea is simply to represent the field configurations of the model not by maps
,
(6.55)
where h is any map from U to H, represents exactly the same field configuration. Conversely, any two maps from U to G representing the same field configuration must be related according to Eq. (6.55). In other words, describing the non-linear sigma model on M in terms of G-valued fields g rather than M-valued fields ip amounts to introducing the subgroup if as a gauge group, with gauge transformations acting by multiplication from the right, g - » 9 • h - gh
,
(6.56)
6.4 Purely Bosonic Non-linear a Models
171
whereas in both formulations, the group G is a global symmetry group, with global symmetry transformations acting by multiplication from the left, 9 - > So • 9 = 9o9
,
V - > 9o •
(6.57)
(The index 0 is supposed to indicate that go should not depend on a;.) Since all physical quantities must as usual be gauge invariant, it is important to have an associated gauge potential which can be used to define covariant derivatives. This gauge potential ylM, as well as the covariant derivative D^g of g itself, can be constructed directly from the left invariant Maurer-Cartan form on G (with the field g inserted), g-1dg = {g-1d^g)dx» , by taking the orthogonal projection (.)« from Q onto H (which annihilates M) resp. the orthogonal projection (.)M from Q onto M. (which annihilates W); cf. Eq. (6.50). Note that in contrast to the situation in gauge theories, this gauge potential Afj, is not an independent field, but the corresponding gauge field F^ is defined as usual. Explicitly, A„ = (9~1dlig)H , F^ = d^Av - dvAii + [Ap, Av]
, ( 6 - 58 )
• D»9 = gk^ = dy.g - gA^ * M = ( 5
_ 1
M M
.
The notation can be justified by observing that under gauge transformations (6.44), Ap behaves as a gauge potential while F^v, fcM and D^g are gauge covariant: A^ -> Afl-h
= h~1A)ih + h~1d^h
,
kf, -> fcM • h = h^k^h , D^g ->• D^g • h = (Df.g) h .
(6.59)
The transformation laws (6.59) dictate how one must define higher covariant derivatives; for example, DfiD„g = dllD„g - D„g A^ Lf\i<^v
=
Ofi,Kv + [•"•tu
,
kv\
In particular, we have the following identities, which will be of central importance later on: fF = -fe,y« D^k,, - D„k^ — -[k^, kv]M
,
(6.60) (6.61)
•
They can be proved quite easily from the Maurer-Cartan structure equation (with the field g inserted): dr{g-1dvg)-dAg-1dlig)
+ \g-%g,g-1dl,g]=0
.
(6.62)
172
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
Indeed, this equation holds identically for fields g taking values in G, and as a consequence for g~1dg taking values in Q; due to the commutation relations (6.51), equation (6.62) implies Eq. (6.60) when projected onto H and gives Eq. (6.61) when projected onto M.. In this formulation, the Lagrangian of the non-linear sigma model on M = G/H can be written in terms of the field
(6.63)
or in terms of the field g: C = ±{D»g-1,D»g)
~{g-1D»g,g-1Dllg)
=
= -\{D»gg~\Dtigg-1)
.
(6.64)
The corresponding equation of motion reads DfiDllg-Dtigg-1Dfig
=0
,
(6.65)
or equivalently, D"^
= 0 .
Obviously, the Lagrangian (6.63) is gauge invariant (cf. (6.56)) as well as globally invariant (cf. (6.57)), because the metric (.,.) on G is assumed to be biinvariant. The global G-invariance leads to a (/-valued Noether current which is explicitly given by 3n = -D^gg'1 = -gk^g~l . (6.66) Obviously, this current is gauge invariant and is conserved: 9MjM = 0
.
(6.67)
In fact, the conservation law (6.67) is not only a consequence of the equation of motion (6.65) but is completely equivalent to it - a rather characteristic feature of non-linear sigma models. Moreover, conjugating the identity (6.61) by g gives the following identity for the current: dnjv - dvjtl + 2\jn, jv] = g[k^, kv]M g~l
6.4.2
•
(6.68)
Dual s y m m e t r y and higher conservation laws
Although non-linear sigma models defined on general Riemannian homogeneous spaces are interesting in their own right and are useful in a purely theoretical context (e.g., in the description of the scalar sector in supergravity [14] or superstring theories [43]) as well as in particle physics phenomenology [36], there are particular cases where their dynamical structure is restricted by the existence of infinitely many conservation laws, thus rendering them classically integrable. We investigate now the geometric conditions for that situation to occur [11, 16, 33, 34, 42].
173
6.4 Purely Bosonic Non-linear a Models
The approach that we shall follow is to look for a non-trivial family of (/-valued potentials A\, ' depending on a spectral parameter A and satisfying, for all values of A, a zero curvature condition
F W = M i A ) - ^ 4 A ) + [4 A) ,4 A) ] = 0 ,
(6.69)
so that the following system of first order linear differential equations dJJw = U^Alx) ,
(6.70)
also called the linear system or the Lax pair associated with the problem, is integrable, for all values of A; its solution, the so-called monodromy matrix, then serves, in a way to be explained below, as the generating functional for an infinite number of conservation laws. The basic Ansatz is that the components of the potentials A^ should be linear combinations, with A-dependent coefficients, of the components of the Noether current j : A^=R(\);jK , where -R(A) is some (2 x 2)-matrix. In order to maintain Lorentz invariance, however, we must require R(X) to commute with all proper orthchronous Lorentz transformations, with (2 x 2)-matrices of the form I . , , I. (This guarantees that under proper orthochronous Lorentz transformations, A^ ' transforms like j M , i.e. as a vector, and hence U^x' transforms as a scalar.) It follows that m RW
_fa(A)
/3(A) \
~{m
a(X)) '
implying with functions a (A) and /3(A) to be determined. It is now straightforward to compute the curvature in Eq. (6.69): c""FW = 2/3 d»j, + 2a c"" dtfv + (a2 - /32) e"" l
= 2/33"j M + a e»»g[k^kv]Mg~
%,jv]
2
+ (a - (32 - 2a) c " " ^ , ^ ]
= 2/3 d"j M + e"" g ((a2 - /32 - 2a) [*M> kv] + a [*„, kv]M) 9*1 • Hence from (6.67) and (6.68) we see that there are precisely two cases in which there exists a non-trivial solution [32]: a) either M is a (locally) symmetric space, i.e., [,M,.M] CH (cf. (6.52)) and a2 - /32 - 2a = 0 or
(a - l ) 2 - /32 = 1 ,
with the solution a(A) = 1 =FcoshA (both signs are allowed),
,
/3(A) = - s i n h A
,
174
Non-linear a Models: Classical Aspects
b) or M is a Lie group (in fact a normal Lie subgroup of G), [M, M] c M (6.53)) and a 2 - /32 - a = 0 or (2a - l ) 2 - 4/?2 = 1 ,
(cf.
with the solution a(A) = ^ ( l T c o s h A )
,
/3(A) = - | s i n h A
,
(both signs are allowed). It can be shown [32] that the second alternative can be reformulated as a special case of the first one, so in what follows we shall concentrate on the latter. In differential geometry, symmetric spaces play an outstanding role because they constitute a class of Riemannian manifolds 10 that is particularly well understood: in fact they have been completely classified more than half a century ago by E. Cartan [42]. Geometrically, they can be defined as those (connected) Riemannian manifolds M for which the geodesic reflection in any given point m of M 1 1 defines an isometry. To be precise, one must distinguish between locally symmetric spaces, where the geodesic reflection in any point of M is supposed to be an isometry of some open neighborhood of that point onto itself, and globally symmetric spaces, where it is assumed that the geodesic reflection in any point of M extends to an isometry of M onto itself; the former can also be characterized as those (connected) Riemannian manifolds whose curvature tensor R is invariant under parallel translations, or to put it differently, is covariantly constant: Vi? = 0 . As suggested by the terminology, the two types of symmetric spaces are locally indistinguishable 12 and differ only in certain global properties, the main such property being completeness. 13 When studying non-linear sigma models, it is therefore sufficient to consider only globally symmetric spaces which in addition can be assumed to be simply connected whenever that may seem convenient.14 These spaces are directly amenable to group-theoretical techniques because they turn out to be homogeneous,15 so they can be written as in Eq. (6.49), and we have an orthogonal 10
In this book, the term "symmetric space" will always mean "Riemannian symmetric space" . The simplest way to visualize the geodesic reflection in m is to use normal coordinates around TO, in which the geodesies passing through TO appear as the straight lines passing through the origin: then geodesic reflection in m appears simply as ordinary reflection in the origin. 12 A theorem in the theory of symmetric spaces states that every point in a locally symmetric space has an open neighborhood which is isometric to some open neighborhood of some point in some globally symmetric space; see Helgason [42], Chapter 4 section 5. 13 For Riemannian manifolds, the two notions of completeness - completeness as a metric space (every Cauchy sequence converges) and geodesic completeness (every geodesic can be extended to arbitrary values of its affine parameter) - are equivalent. 14 Another theorem in the theory of symmetric spaces, showing that this may be done without much loss of generality, states that a globally symmetric space is complete and that conversely, a complete locally symmetric space is, possibly up to a covering, globally symmetric; in fact, it is globally symmetric provided it is also simply connected; otherwise, one may have to replace it by some covering space - such as the universal one - and use the fact that any covering space of a complete locally symmetric space is once again a complete locally symmetric space. 15 The group of isometries of a globally symmetric space acts transitively on that space. 11
6.4 Purely Bosonic Non-linear a Models
175
direct decomposition as in Eq. (6.50) with commutation relations (6.51) and (6.52). Now if we look at Eq. (6.50) as a decomposition of Q into ^-invariant subspaces, we find that both "H and M will in general still be reducible under H. But if M turns out to be irreducible, then the symmetric space M — G/H itself is said to be irreducible. Even in that case, however, % will in general still be reducible and, being a compact Lie algebra, can be decomposed into the orthogonal direct sum of irreducible subspaces [44], r
U = ^-Hi
,
(6.71)
4=0
with commutation relations [Hi,Hj] = {0}
for
ifj
.
Here, Ho denotes the center of ~H (which is irreducible if and only if it is onedimensional), while the Tii, i = 1 , . . . , r, denote the simple ideals in the semisimple part of H. For later use, we also note that the 7^-valued fields A^ and F^ introduced above then decompose accordingly, as follows [44]:
4/1 = 4°>+4 1 >+---+4 r) , F»V = F$+F$+•••+¥$
.
(6.72) (6.73)
Th