ERKKI KOSKENNIEMI
The Old Testament Miracle-Workers in Early Judaism
Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testam...
225 downloads
2693 Views
11MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ERKKI KOSKENNIEMI
The Old Testament Miracle-Workers in Early Judaism
Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 2. Reihe 206
Mohr Siebeck
Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament • 2. Reihe Herausgeber / Editor Jorg Frey Mitherausgeber / Associate Editors Friedrich Avemarie • Judith Gundry-Volf Martin Hengel • Otfried Hofius • Hans-Josef Klauck
206
Erkki Koskenniemi
The Old Testament Miracle-Workers in Early Judaism
Mohr Siebeck
ERKKI KOSKENNIEMI, born 1956; Classical studies at the University of Turku; 1979 Mag. phil.; 1984 Mag. theol.; 1992 PhD at Abo Akademi; Adjunct Professor at the University of Helsinki, Joensuu and of at Abo Akademi; teacher of biblical theology in Lutheran Evangelical Asso ciation in Finland.
ISBN 3 - 1 6 - 1 4 8 6 0 4 - 8
ISSN 0 3 4 0 - 9 5 7 0 (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament, 2. Reihe) Die Deutsche Bibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliographie; detailed bibliographic data is available in the Internet at http://dnb.ddb.de. © 2 0 0 5 by Mohr Siebeck Tubingen, Germany. This book may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, in any form (beyond that permitted by copyright law) without the publisher's written permission. This applies particularly to reproductions, translations, microfilms and storage and processing in electronic systems. The book was printed by Gulde-Druck in Tubingen on non-aging paper and bound by Buchbinderei Held in Rottenburg. Printed in Germany.
Preface I did not know where the path would lead me in 1983/84, when I prepared to leave Finland to study classical philology in Tubingen with the gentle help of the DAAD. After my master's thesis on Apollonius, which luckily was written only in Finnish and never printed, I was anxious about the theme of my further study. I could not find a way to approach Apollonius of Tyana, the primary target of my interest, and not Philostratus, who wrote about Apollonius in about A.D. 220. Shortly before leaving Finland I thought I had found a solution: I abandoned Apollonius and started to investigate Philostratus and his intentions. It took time before I - a young student of classical philology - realised that I had reinvented redaction criticism and done a lot of needless work seeking the method. Yet, I finally felt that I had advanced, and my time in Tubingen was a good one, during which I enjoyed and benefited from the deep knowledge of the philologists at the university. After my work was almost ready, I posted it to, among others, Professor Jukka Thuren (Abo Akademi), who had been my teacher during the slow progress of my theological studies. Typically for him, he reacted immediately, realising that my ideas had direct consequences for New Testament scholars: If Apollonius in Vita Apollonii Tyanensis was mainly a product of the third and not of the first century A.D., he was to be used only cautiously as a parallel figure to Jesus, although this had been common. After two enthusiastic weeks of work I could clarify my view on Apollo nius in the New Testament exegesis to my teacher, and also present it to Professor Martin Hengel, who had kindly invited me to his Oberseminar, and now strongly encouraged me to continue on the course I had chosen. I then published my work on Philostratus (Der philostrateische Apollonius, 1991), and wrote my theological dissertation on how Apollonius had been used in New Testament exegesis {Apollonius von Tyana in der neutestamentlichen Exegese. Forschungsbericht und Weiterfilhrung der Diskussion, 1994). I challenged the view that Gentile miracle-workers were a common phenomenon among the Greeks and Romans and that they were a model for Jesus as he was presented in the Gospels. Scholars were never able to name these many alleged men, but uncritically used Apollonius when constructing the famous concept of "divine man". I wondered why Jewish miracle-workers were so sorely overlooked by the scholars.
VI
Preface
The present book investigates the way the biblical miracles of the Old Testament figures, such as Moses, Joshua and Elijah, are retold in early Judaism. Some stories appear often and they share common nonbiblical details, which leads to the supposition of a strong written and oral tradi tion. I hope to still publish a book on historical Jewish miracle-workers in Jesus' times, but even if that book is published someday, I still have no solutions to several fascinating questions on the miracles of Jesus in the Gospels, especially concerning the historical Jesus. This, then, is the third book by the anxious man who found a sudden solution to an impossible problem, and I do not know how many there will still be. It took about ten years before the first two were finished, and more than ten before the ap pearance of this volume. If anything, this process has taught me patience. I owe my warm thanks to several scholars. Prof. Antti Laato generously gave of his time to help me, and Prof. Martin Hengel's advice has been of great value during the decade this book was written. The learned recom mendations of Prof. Jorg Frey have improved this book. The warden of the Tyndale House in Cambridge, Dr. Bruce Winter, and Dr. David InstoneBrewer helped me during the most difficult phases of the work. Timo Nisula, M.A., M.Th. always combines friendship with a strong indicium. The scholars at the Centre of Excellence of the Finnish Academy, especially professors Lars Aejmelaeus, Karl Gustaf Sandelin and Timo Veijola, have helped me greatly. My father, Prof. Heikki Koskenniemi, and brother, the Rev. Olli Koskenniemi, have offered many opportunities to discuss my views. Nancy Seidel, M.A. has corrected the language. During the writing of my book on Apollonius and New Testament exege sis, our family grew by five sons. During the last ten years, Tuomas, Jo hannes, Antti, Jaakko and Pietari have grown up to be eager partners in discussions, and their love has given me strength and joy. My wife Marja has not only allowed me to work but also supported and encouraged me. "A wife of noble character who can find?" (Prov 31:10). For a professor to lead an impatient young student of classical antiquity into the rich world of the New Testament and to become his Doktorvater should have been enough. However, during the most difficult phases of the writing of this book, Professor Jukka Thuren still guided a slightly older student into the world of early Judaism. It is a pleasure to dedicate this book to him, although, as with all my works intended for his desk, it comes terribly late.
Table of Contents 1. Introduction
1
a. Preliminary definition of the task b. What is a "miracle"? c. Competing miracle-workers and a story about a modern category d. Jewish miracle-workers in religious-historical study e. A more precise definition of the task and method
1 1 3 5 11
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
17
a. Introduction b. Moses c. Joshua d. Elijah e. Elisha f. Isaiah g. Conclusion
17 19 26 31 37 39 41
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees a. Introduction b. Abraham c. Moses d. Conclusion
44 46 54 62
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
64
a. Introduction b. The dialogue at the burning bush c. The plagues told in advance d. The miracle at the Red Sea e. A miracle-worker - but how much more? f. Conclusion
64 66 69 73 81 86
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography: Artapanus a. Introduction b. The leader is called c. The return, plagues and d. The Red Sea and the desert e. Conclusion
44
freedom
89 89 92 96 103 105
VIII
Table of Contents
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo a. Introduction b. The literal interpretation of the miracle stories c. The allegorical interpretation of the miracle stories d. Miracles explained rationally? e. Miracles of the prophet f. God or Moses? g. Miracles and legitimisation h. Conclusion
7. Many Miracles: The Lives of the Prophets a. Introduction b. Isaiah c. Jeremiah d. Ezekiel e. Daniel f. Elijah g. Elisha h. Conclusion
8. Militant Miracles: Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum a. Introduction b. Moses c. Joshua d. Kenaz Excursus: Magical practices in L.A.B e. Samson f. David g. Elijah /Phinehas h. Conclusion
9. Toning Down the Miracles? Josephus a. Introduction b. Moses c. Joshua d. Samson e. Solomon f. Elijah g. Elisha h. Conclusion
108 108 110 129 146 148 151 155 156
160 160 163 165 169 177 184 186 187
189 189 192 203 206 214 216 219 224 225
228 228 231 249 255 259 264 271 278
Table of Contents
10. Conclusion a. LXX b. The texts retold c. The themes d. The Greek influence e. Biases and functions of the miracle stories f. The audience g. The roles of God and man and Moses' extraordinary position h. Geography and chronology
IX
281 281 282 290 292 293 297 297 299
Bibliography
301
Index of References
321
Index of Subjects and Scholars
346
1. Introduction a. Preliminary
definition of the task
The task of this book is to study how the Old Testament stories about He brew miracle-workers were used in early Jewish literature. Everyone retell ing a biblical story left his trace, making it possible to study what he re tained, what he left, what he added and what he changed. The study also reveals the early Jewish tradition, as well as various biases reshaping the stories through nonbiblical details circulating in the oral and literary folk lore of different eras.
b. What is a
"miracle"?
Neither the Old nor the New Testament contains anything that could be characterised as a definition of a miracle, and the early Jewish texts do not help either. Moreover, the Old Testament uses a variety of terms. God's miracles are riVm, mK*?Q3, mn« or D T I D I Q : All these words have been used in different ways during the long history of the Jewish tradition and they may include things not usually covered by modern definitions of miracle. A definition can thus not be based on an ancient term. David Hume formu lated possibly the most famous modern definition, which is very close to Aristotle's words: A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature. But even 1
2
3
4
5
1
nt>iy in the sense of God's 'mighty deeds' occurs in Deut 10:21; Jer 33:3; 45:5; Ps 71:19; 106:21; Job 5:9; 9:10; 37:5. 2 Kgs 8:4 uses it for Elisha's mighty deeds. On the word see Jenni 1984, 402-409. m«*?S3 (from K*?s) points mostly to God's saving deeds in the past (Exod 3:20; Job 37:14). It does not necessarily mean a breaking of what we call the laws of nature, but that God helps in a hopeless situation, perhaps in a very "natural" way; see Albertz 1984, 416-420. rriR occurs 79 times in the Old Testament in all historical layers. On rm in the Old Testament see Stolz 1984, 91-95. irriDiD occurs in Exod 4:21 when God speaks to Moses about the miracles he should make in Egypt. In Joel 3:3 it points to phenomena in the skies. Aristotle said that a miracle was n a p a (|>uaiv (GA 770b). The similarity is, of course, not a coincidence, since Aristotle's philosophy deeply influenced the medieval learned world. Spinoza symbolized a milestone on the road to the modern concept. He dealt with the possibility of miracles in 1670: God has created the world and its harmony and a 2
3
4
5
2
1. Introduction
that is very problematic in the study of the early Jewish material. The idea of the laws of nature as separate from God's almighty power is seldom even alluded to in the Jewish texts. Generally there are no laws to be bro ken by an unusual event. God's help may come in a very natural way and still be praised as his "miracle". Since Jewish texts thus do not give a basis for a definition, and the modern view differs greatly from the world view of the writers, the use of the term "miracle" is difficult. Further, it is not always obvious whether, for instance, physical strength should be consid ered a miracle or not: David's unexpected triumph over Goliath may not have been supernatural in 1 Sam (although obviously in L.A.B. 61), but Samson indeed had superhuman powers in Judges and certainly in L.A.B. Some miracles are perhaps interpreted "rationalistically" in part of the tra dition, but does a natural explanation mean that the writer has not believed in miracles? It is impossible to find an unambiguous definition covering the Jewish as well as the modern perspectives. It is understandable that most studies dealing with miracles define the miracle very briefly or even omit the definition altogether, as Barry Blackburn and Werner Kahl do. Actually, Eric Eve suggests a new terminology, reserving the word "mira cle" for the biblical phenomenon and using the concept "anomaly" for a supposed exception to the laws of nature. Nevertheless, a sufficient defi nition is possible. Bernd Kollmann studies the New Testament terminology and observes that a modern view is incompatible with it. He uses a short definition: 6
7
"In dieser Untersuchung wird der Begriff Wunder im uberkommenen Sinne als Sammelbezeichnung fur auBergewdhnliche, aufsehenerregende Taten Jesu wie anderer Gestalten der Antike verwendet." 8
It may be considered problematic that a modern category including dispa rate material is applied to the ancient texts, but Kollmann's formulation provides a basis for the definition: A miracle is a fortuitous breaking of what we (although not the writers) call the laws of nature and which God 9
miracle breaking the good order is not only a positive thing. A miracle is against nature and against reason (see G. Maier 1986, 50-51). On these works see below p. 4, 9, and 15. Eve 2002, 1-2. Kollmann 1996, 53-54. John P. Meier (1994, 512-515) also uses a short definition: "A miracle is (1) an un usual, startling, or extraordinary event that is in principle perceivable by any interested and fair-minded observer, (2) an event that finds no reasonable explanation in human abilities or in other known forces that operate in our world of time and space, and (3) an event that is the result of a special act of God, doing what no human power can do." However, it should be emphasized that also this definition results in a modern, collecting category. 6
7
8
9
1. Introduction
or his agent allegedly causes. several times in this study.
3
The theme, of necessity, must be discussed
c. Competing miracle-workers and a story about a modern category The study of the biblical miracles has held a central position in the New Testament exegesis from at least the early 20 century. Richard Reitzenstein (1906, 1910) and Gillis Wetter (1916) considered that the first Christians lived in an atmosphere of tough competition. This view is ex pressed in the work of Helmut Koster (1982): th
11
12
"Miracles were performed not only by Christian missionaries, as described in the Acts of the Apostles and as Paul encounters them in the opponents of 2 Corinthians, but also by Jewish preachers, Neopythagorean philosophers, and by many other teachers, physicians, and magicians. The entire scale of miraculous deeds of power was commonly used, from magical tricks to predictions of the future, from horoscopes to the healing of diseases and maladies, even the raising of dead people. In those circles which were addressed by these philosophers of the marketplace, the power of speech and the greatness of miracle would have more profound effects than the depth and dignity of rational, moral, and religious insight." 13
14
The competition with the "mob of divine or deified men" allegedly led the first Christians to remodel their image of Jesus according to a pagan pattern, and make him a Hellenistic divine man (0e?os avrjp). The ac commodation to this model or the reaction against it allegedly colours all canonical Gospels, the pre-Pauline tradition, Second Corinthians, First Thessalonians and Philippians. 15
10
There are several borderline cases, such as the exceptional military strength men tioned above. One of them is divination, either in dreams or through different particles or astrological skills. They are excluded from the present study, but if a text retelling the Old Testament miracles deals with these techniques with the aim of accepting (as Artapanus) or rejecting them (as Liber antiquitatum biblicarum), they are briefly men tioned. Hellenistische Wundererzahlungen (1906) and Die hellenistischen Mysterienreligionen nach ihren Grundgedanken und Wirkungen (1910). "Der Sohn Gottes". Eine Untersuchung iiber den Charakter und die Tendenz des Johannes-Evangeliums. Zugleich ein Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Heilandsgestalten der Antike. Helmut Koster, History, Culture, and Religion of the Hellenistic Age 1-2, (1982, 1, 357). "Mob of divine or deified man", Morton Smith 1970, 184. A survey of the history of the research is found in Koskenniemi 1994, 114-168. 11
12
13
14
15
4
L Introduction
The concept of divine men was rarely motivated by ancient sources and it is widely criticised today. The Graeco-Roman world knew famous fig ures with a reputation for being miracle-workers, but both the heroes such as Hercules and men from the past such as Pythagoras should be compared to the Old Testament figures rather than to historical Jewish miracleworkers. Scholars have been able to name very few pagan miracle-workers from the time of Jesus, although it has been somewhat easier to name miracle-working gods, rulers and anonymous magicians. Moreover, the concept is ambiguous in many ways. For example, Reitzenstein, Gillis Wetter, Otto Weinreich and Ludwig Bieler differed greatly from each other, and were all heavily influenced by the ideologies current in the late 16
17
16
The most important critique of the hypothesis of divine men comes from Klaus Berger, Otto Betz, Martin Hengel and Barry L. Blackburn (see Koskenniemi 1994, 232-233); my book Apollonios von Tyana in der neutestamentlichen Exegese (1994) is also very critical. David du Toit (1997) showed later in a detailed analysis that the words 6e?os avrjp (av8pco7TOs) were not a fixed terminus technicus. See also the critical article of Aage Pilgaard (1995) and the review in Hans-Josef Klauck's The Religious Context of Early Christianity. A Guide to Graeco-Roman Religions (2000, 174-177). On Bernd Kollmann's book see below p. 9. See Koskenniemi 1994, 207-219. The last pre-Christian pagan miracle-worker known to us is Menecrates, who lived about 300 BC. Alexander of Abonuteichos is the first pagan miracle-worker known to us from contemporary sources after the time of Jesus. His floruit was in about 150 AD. The man mentioned in most studies is Apollonius of Tyana, who lived in the first century AD. However, the main source is Vita Apollonii Tyanensis of Lucius Flavius Philostratus, which was written in the religious world of the early 3 century (see Bowie 1978, Dzielska 1986 and Koskenniemi 1991). The main lines of my dissertation (1994) have received mostly positive reviews so far (November 2003); see Peres 1995, 447-448; Thummel 1995, 801-802; Ziegenaus 1995, 154-155; Danker 1996, 757-758. Jaap-Jan Flinterman, however, criticised them in a long review (1996). He relies more on the sources on Apollonius than I do and considers it possible to deal with the historical Apollonius. Moreover, he claims that there were more miracleworkers in Jesus' time, especially since it is not easy to draw the line between miracleworkers and magicians. I fully agree with Flinterman that Apollonius was considered a magician before Philostratus (see Koskenniemi 1994, 211). However, although some prominent scholars have tried to define here the historical nucleus, the historical figure escapes us (Koskenniemi 1991, 58-69; I returned to the theme in an article, which is in print). Also, neither Flinterman nor other scholars (Werner Kahl was not yet aware of my book; see Kahl 1994, 58-61) have added many new figures to my list. Although it is not easy to differentiate between magicians and miracle-workers, I considered it important, after all the confusing discussion, to collect the names of the historical persons who acted as miracle-workers and to study the common magical practices separately. The 0e?os ocvrjp-hypothesis was constructed with very few sources and great ideological fervour, moreover, with no respect for Jewish sourcees. It now seems reasonable to study the religious-historical parallels carefully, step by step. Flinterman's article plays an impor tant part in this work. On the discussion and open questions see also Klauck 2000, 168177. 17
rd
1. Introduction th
5
th
19 and early 20 centuries. Some recent scholars have regarded the model as a Hellenistic concept, while others have seen it as a modern concept. It is thus not possible to speak about the divine man model; it includes several different models, partly mutually exclusive. 0e?os ccvrip should no longer be considered as a fixed and Hellenistic but as a modern concept. The best solution is to realise that the whole concept is rather part of the western history of ideas and to investigate the Graeco-Roman paral lels to Jesus' miracles without this modern pattern, which has clearly hin dered rather than helped scholarship. 18
19
d. Jewish miracle-workers
in religious-historical
study
The fact that we know of very few pagan miracle-workers makes Jewish men with such a reputation more significant than ever. They have been investigated, but often through the perspective of the BeTos avrjphypothesis. It is obvious that the old History of the Religions school did not show enough interest in them, but sought more parallels from the "Hel lenistic" world. Although there is no reason to return to the old opposi20
21
18
H.D. Betz (1983, 235) considers 0e?os avrjp to be an ancient pattern, which is treated by the ancient writers in many ways and in many phrases and which could be interpreted in several ways (1983, 364). Kollmann agrees and cites H.D. Betz (1996, 5859). It is rather problematic that the archetype of these interpretations seems to remain a platonic idea. H.D. Betz cannot convincingly show that 0e?os avrjp was an ancient cate gory. Unlike most supporters of the hypothesis, Corrington regards "the divine man" as a modern, hypothetical category (The "Divine man His Origin and Function in Hellenis tic Popular Religion, 1986; for a review see Koskenniemi 1994, 95-98). E.g. Willi Schottroff characterises Moses in Eupolemus, Philo, Josephus and Artapanus as 0e?os avrjp (1983, 229-233). Most scholars suppose that the Jews had learned the concept from the Greeks and then mediated it to the first Christians (the view of Fer dinand Hahn 1963; see Koskenniemi 1994, 121). Precisely this view is studied and criti cised by Holladay in an early and important study of the 0s?os avrjp -hypothesis. Ac cording to Holladay, the Jewish writers did not remove the line between God and man, but drew it very clearly (Theios aner in Hellenistic Judaism: a Critique of the Use of This Category in New Testament Christology, 1977; reviewed in Koskenniemi 1994, 88-90). Corrington criticises Holladay's work severely and claims that Holladay has overlooked the social factors in early Judaism (Corrington 1986, esp. 46-47). Louis Feldman's new and undoubtedly correct approach is to list the general virtues of the heroes in the pagan literature without constructing a fixed pattern (1998a, 82-131). Bultmann offers a representative example in his famous Geschichte der synoptischen Tradition (1921, 147). According to him, scholars earlier considered the Old Testament the source of Christian miracle stories. Bultmann sees this as no longer credible, because the similarities are limited. Bultmann speaks now about a genealogy, but uses analogy to deal with the pagan stories (see Koskenniemi 1994, 45). Some scholars have always ob19
2 0
21
6
1. Introduction
tion between "Hellenistic" and "Jewish", it is strange how small a role the Jewish miracle-workers have had in the discussion about divine men. Si multaneously, characteristic Jewish features in the concept of miracle have been overlooked. The last decades have shown signs of better times, as the "new History of the Religions school" seeks the roots of Christianity in Judaism. However, neither the Jewish sources, which today are much wider than in the heyday of the 0 E T O S avrjp-hypothesis, nor the rich secon dary literature is given enough attention even to date. The pagan miracle-workers have thus won the interest of scholarship during the last century and provided most of the background for the New Testament study of Jesus' miracles. Yet, there have always been scholars who have observed the Jewish parallels. Two of them in particular pro vided an impulse to scholarship and deserve to be mentioned. Paul Fiebig (Judische Wundergeschichten im Zeitalter Jesu etc., 1911) argued that many Rabbis made miracles in Jesus' time, and that it was part of the Rabbi's image. Only the echoes of the vivid discussion between Fiebig and his opponent Schlatter, which related to the miracles of the his torical Jesus, can be heard today, but this debate was one of the most sig nificant in this area. These scholars opened the door for a study of the Jewish background of the New Testament miracles, but there were few who stepped in. Vivid research followed the first edition of Die Zeloten by Martin Hengel (1961), in which he investigates the movements, which revolted against the Romans and their religious background. Hengel's work has been subject to a discussion and severe criticism. Horsley and Hanson, for example, regard the zealots in his works as historical fiction. According to them there was not a unified movement before the Jewish war, in which armed revolt and the Jew ish religion were combined. Hengel responds to his opponents in the preface 22
23
24
25
26
served the Old Testament material. Berger, a critic of the 0e7os ccvrip-concept, empha sized the stories about Elijah and Elisha (Berger 1984, 305-306). Hengel was the first to use the phrase when introducing a book written by Larry W. Hurtado (1988). The programme of the school is formulated in Jarl Fossum's article "The New Religionsgeschichtliche Schule: The Quest for Jewish Christology" (1991). See also below, p. 82. Charlesworth (1995, 72) characterises the situation as follows: "In the sixties, when we considered the Old Testament Pseudepigrapha we usually meant 17 documents, but now we frequently mean at least 65. Then we examined about 12 Dead Sea Scrolls, but now well over 400." See Becker 2002, 16-21. Horsley and Hanson 1985, xiii-xvii. Horsley (1994, ix-xi) underlines the political relevance of New Testament scholar ship and openly expresses the political relevance of his own study: Observing the Jewish agrarian people and their problems leads to a better understanding of the South American theology of freedom. 2 2
2 3
2 4
2 5
2 6
1. Introduction
1
and appendix of the English translation of his work. The unanimity of the scholars is obvious in the articles in the Cambridge History of Judaism III. However, Smith, who considers the concept of Horsley and Hanson absurd, attacks Hengel even more strongly. In contrast, Gabba is sympathetic to Hengel's position. Schaper characterises the zealots as "the left wing of Phari saism." The present book, which must often deal with the combination of religion and politics, certainly illuminates the question. During the discussion on the zealots, the research advanced in many ways. P.W. Barnett introduced the term "sign prophets", referring to men who tried to legitimate themselves as leaders by repeating Old Testament miracles (1981). Recently Rebecca Gray collected the evidence in Josephus (1993), and many figures have now been studied in detail. However, because, for instance, Atomus (Jos. Ant. 20,141-143) cannot be labelled either as a zealot or a "sign-prophet", he, as most men of his type, is usually not mentioned. The phenomenon of the historical figures has still not been studied thoroughly enough. The Jewish miracle-workers were again drawn to the centre of New Tes tament scholarship by Geza Vermes (Jesus the Jew, 1973; The Gospel of Jesus the Jew, 1981), who could combine his studies with the newly awak ened quest of the historical Jesus. Vermes underlined the Old Testament miracle-workers, especially Elijah and Elisha, and named many Jewish healers, exorcists and miracle-workers from the times of Jesus. He re garded the historical Jesus as one of the holy miracle-workers of Galilee. This view can either be accepted or rejected, but Vermes' studies are cited even today in discussions about the historical Jesus. Fiebig, as well as Vermes, dealt with historical, non-biblical Jewish miracle-workers, and several scholars have subsequently studied these figures. New Testament scholars can justly be criticised for what the Germans call Steinbruchsmentalitat: historical Jewish miracle-workers have all too often been studied because of the needs of New Testament scholarship; and the passages on 28
29
30
31
32
33
34
2 7
Hengel 1989b, xiii-xvii; 380-404. Smith 1999, 542-544, 566. "We cannot say with certainty exactly when this name (sc. Zealot) was first used, not least because the term was pregnant with religious and political significance the roots of which went back a long time", Gabba 1999, 154. Schaper 1999, 422. Prophetic figures in late Second Temple Jewish Palestine. The evidence from Jose phus. New York / Oxford 1993. Vermes 1973,58-85. Vermes 1973, 223. Goodman studied the differences between Judaism in Galilee and in Judea in the Cambridge History of Judaism 3 (1999, 569-617), but he did not deal with the miracles. See Becker 2002, 291. 337-340. 2 8
2 9
3 0
31
3 2
3 3
3 4
8
1. Introduction
Honi the Circle-drawer in Crossan's and Meier's books, for instance, lack the depth present in Green's and Becker's studies. However, these fig ures are studied vigorously. A further step was taken with Michael Becker's recently published dis sertation on rabbinical miracle-workers. According to Becker, the early rabbis were unwilling to tell about miracles made by men. This included biblical figures, as well as extra-biblical persons. Some miracles, however, were intimately connected to the history forming the Jewish identity, and were retold without reservation. That does not mean that they did not have to deal with miracles, but Becker's study reveals that the early rabbis wres tled long and hard with the problem. Statistics show the indisputable fact that the early collections contain fewer miracle stories, whereas the num ber grows markedly in the later texts. Becker's study confirms that the development in the Jewish world corresponds with the Graeco-Roman world, where miracle-workers were numerous from the late second century AD. 35
36
37
38
Just as the Graeco-Roman miracle-workers known to us were either his torical figures known from contemporary sources or great men of the dis tant past, their Jewish counterparts were either contemporaries of the early Jewish writers or figures known from the Old Testament. Much research must still be done on the historical, non-biblical figures for a clearer pic ture of the background of New Testament Christology. It is surprising, however, how little even the later traditions concerning the figures men tioned in the Old Testament have been studied. They are often noted sim ply in passing. On the other hand, scholars such as Martin Dibelius (1919) and Rudolf Bultmann (1921) tried to note the Jewish as well as the Graeco-Roman parallels, although their intention was to underline the "Hellenistic" world. Otto Bocher (1970, 1972) and Gerd Theissen (1974) have continued this kind of work. Some scholars have always pointed to the Old Testament and some very recent works attest that the Old Testa39
3 5
See Green 1979, 621-647; Crossan 1991, 142-148; Meier 1994, 581-584; Becker 2002, 291-337. "Wunder" und "Wundertdter" im fruhrabbinischen Judentum. Studien zum literarischen und historischen Phdnomen im paganen und fruhjiidischen Kontext und seine Bedeutung fur das Verstandnis Jesu (2002). See the summary in Becker 2002, 406-414. See Koskenniemi 1994, 207-219. In 1978, Michael Goulder, in investigating the Gospels, made cautious observations on Elijah's and Elisha's miracles; see 1978, 266-281 and also 1989, 304-305. Richard Glockner studied the connections between the Psalms and New Testament miracle stories (Neutestamentliche Wundergeschichten und das Lob der Wundertaten Gottes in den Psalmen. Studien zur sprachlichen und theologischen Wundergeschichten und Psalmen, 36
3 7
3 8
3 9
9
1. Introduction
ment miracle-workers are being given more attention today than some dec ades ago. However, Kollmann's book, mentioned above is a good exam ple of an unbalanced way to deal with the texts: He closely studies the traditions about Pythagoras, but not the traditions about Moses, Elijah or Elisha, which were certainly very close to the early Christians. Moreover, here as so often, the characteristic feature of the Jewish area, the combina tion of miracles of the past with the hope of future miracles, is mainly overlooked. It is now time to pay attention to the traditions about the Old Testament miracle-workers. 40
41
Many studies contain valuable material on the Old Testament heroes in later Jewish literature, but the timeline between the Old Testament and rabbinic literature is long and includes a great number of sources. Some special studies and works cover some parts of this vast material, some more or less all of it. Some figures have always been eagerly studied. Moses offers a good example: The early parts of the tradition have been thoroughly investigated, but descriptions given by later writers, such as Ezekiel the Tragedian, Artapanus or Pseudo-Philo in Liber antiquitatum biblicarum, still offer extensive work for scholars. Other figures, such as David and Solomon, have received less attention. Much of the research covers a part of this rich material. Some studies follow traditions about heroes. Willy Schottroff, for example, investigated the images of the Old Testament miracle-workers in his RAC article 1983). Klaus Berger noted the Old Testament stories in his Formgeschichte des Neuen Testaments, 1984, 305-306. Kahl is well aware that the Jewish side is neglected (see 1994, 21-22), and Craig Evans closely studies the Jewish miracle tradition (1995, 213-244). Jesus und die Christen als Wundertater. Studien zu Magie, Medizin und Schamanismus in Antike und Christentum (1996). Kollmann criticises some scholars, espe cially O. Betz and Glockner, because they one-sidedly observe the Old Testament and Jewish traditions and forget the Hellenistic parallels (1996, 26-27). He tries himself to observe both sides when studying the miracles of Jesus and the first Christians. Neverthe less, he overlooks several Graeco-Roman parallels, such as Eunus (about 136/135-132 BC, Liv. perioch. 56; Flor. epit. 2,7; Diod. 34); Damigeron (second century BC, Apul. apol. 90; Arnob. nat. 1, 52; we have only fragments of his own work de lapidibus), Publius Nigidius Figulus (about 100-45 BC; for the sources see Koskenniemi 1994, 209); the eremite in Plutarch (first century AD, Plut. mor. 421a-b); Peregrinus Proteus (died 165 AD, Lukian Peregr.; Gell. 8,3. 12,11; Athenag. suppl. 26,3-5) Arnuphis (about 174 AD, Dio Cass. 71,8-9, Hist. Aug. M. Aur. 24,4); Julianus (in the time of Marcus Aurelius, Prokl. Krat. 72, 10; rep. 2, 123, 12; Arnob. nat. 1, 52; Iul. epist. 12), Apsethus (before Hippolytus' haer. [222 AD], Hippol. haer. 6,7-8); and Neryllinus (about 177 AD, Athenag. suppl. 26,3-5). I give a list of the known pagan miracle-workers in my book; see Koskenniemi 1994, 207-219. On the other hand, Kollmann carefully notes such his torical figures as Theudas and the Egyptian, but shows no interest in the tradition of re telling new variants of the Old Testament miracles. 4 0
41
10
/. Introduction
(1983). However, he only observes the "divine men" (^GottmenscherT) of the Old Testament (Moses, Elijah, Elisha) and leaves aside even many later traditions about them. He also overlooks the Old Testament figures, such as David and Solomon, mentioned as miracle-workers only in the later tradition and not in the Old Testament. David L. Tiede (1972) and Carl L. Holladay (1977), two early critics of the 0 E T O S avrjp theory, studied many of the most important texts, and made observations still valuable today. Some studies do not follow the tradition of an individual miracle-worker through different texts, but instead concentrate on a certain text and all its heroes. In his monumental work, Louis Feldman studied the way in which Josephus treated the Old Testament figures, including all the miracleworkers. This does not mean that the work is complete because Feldman's work has been heavily criticised by Mark Roncace, who scrutinised his depictions of Deborah and Gideon, and Christopher Begg challenges Feldman's view in his study of Josephus' description of Elisha. Never theless, Feldman has collected and discussed a huge amount of material, which has been helpful in this study. Although there are no such works on, for example, the Lives of the Prophets or Liber antiquitatum biblicarum, the commentaries of Anna Maria Schwemer and Howard Jacobson are an equal contribution to the study of these texts. Eric Eve's book (Jewish con text of Jesus' miracles, 2002), in which the writer studies the role of the miracles in almost all relevant Jewish texts, deserves special attention. Eve has taken upon himself a huge task, because his work not only deals with the human miracle-workers, but also with the views on miracles, whether they be done by men or God, and he expands his investigation to historical figures such as Honi and the "sign prophets" in Josephus. The wide scope of the study necessarily means that he cannot investigate all the texts thor oughly enough. Scholars are now eagerly investigating the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha, and many studies and articles are of valuable help to the present work. Becker covers the rabbinical literature in his dissertation mentioned 42
43
44
45
4 2
Schottroff 1983, 220-233. He does not deal with the passages in Ben Sira, Ezekiel the Tragedian and L.A.B. Deborah and Gideon are not presented as miracle-workers in Josephus, and they are not treated in the present work, but Roncace's article may also affect other figures stud ied by Feldman. Roncace investigates Josephus' passages, but notes none of the strong redactional biases found by Feldman, and concludes in his article: "A close reading of the stories does not produce the results that Feldman claims. ... If the stories of Deborah and Gideon are any indication, then it appears that much of this work remains to be done" (2000, 247-274). Feldman promptly responded (2001, 193-220), but did not re move all doubts concerning his work. See below p. 271-278. See below e.g. p. 19, 109 and 162. 4 3
4 4
4 5
1. Introduction
11
above. However, there is still much to do before the Jewish tradition is observed as well as it deserves to be.
e. A more precise definition of the task and method The present work concentrates on the early Jewish interpretations of the miracles made by Israelites mentioned in the Old Testament. The Old Tes tament tells about many men who saved the nation with their great deeds, or manifested with their miracles that Israel's God was with them. They could be saviours of the nation, as Moses, or its great leaders, as Joshua, or miracle-working prophets, as Elijah and Elisha. They also could be strange figures, as Samson, the fighter with superhuman powers. It is interesting to note how their stories were retold in the Jewish texts. Some things may be omitted, intentionally or not, some things may be emphasized, and some totally new traits may appear in the picture. Moreover, it is interesting to discover which figures still play a role in the later traditions and which are largely forgotten in the sources we have. Certain elements were apparently crucial in different periods of Jewish history. Miracles could be connected with deep wisdom, with physical strength, great leadership or even with entertainment. In Judaism, unlike in Greek thought, they also could be linked with the glorious past of the nation and with an eschatological hope. The Jewish writers do not only retell new variations of the Old Testament miracles (possibly adding totally new features such as the prince of de mons, Mastema, in the events of Egypt in The Book of Jubilees). They also tell totally new stories about the Old Testament heroes. The Lives of the Prophets tells about Ezekiel, and some texts about men hardly mentioned in the Old Testament, such as Kenaz in L.A.B. The study of these stories and the traditions behind them is important, because they reveal the current values and hopes of the writers and their circles. This study aims to cover all Jewish literature, from the Old Testament to Liber antiquitatum biblicarum and Josephus. The early rabbinic literature is covered in Becker's book. The vast amount of material includes very disparate elements, as well stories and shorter passages. There are two ways to structure the material. One way would be to study all the tradi tions, for example, about Abraham; to collect every miracle-story we have about him and in so doing, track the history of the tradition. Some good studies of this kind have been done. I do not know of a study about Abra ham as a miracle-worker, and the traditions about Moses have been col lected only superficially. Elijah, however, has been investigated more 46
4 6
Many scholars have done valuable work. Willy Schottroff deals with Moses in his article "Gottmensch" in RAC (1983). Oberhansli-Widmer has collected abundant mate-
12
7. Introduction
thoroughly. An alternative, which has been chosen here, is to study the most important texts containing miracle stories about the biblical figures. It seems to offer better opportunities to investigate the role of the miracles and the biases of the different writers, and to trace the historical develop ment in Israel. It also enhances the collection of details that the tradition added to the biblical stories, and clarifies which stories passed into extinc tion in early Judaism. The shorter passages outside these writings, in which the miracles are mentioned or even briefly retold, will be observed to illus trate the texts receiving greater attention. In the study of recounted passages from the Old Testament, a series of questions is asked concerning every text. The writer has used either the Hebrew or the Greek text as the original. The first problem is the role of the Septuagint. Firstly, many books of LXX differ considerably from the Hebrew text, revealing the complicated his tory of the latter. In the texts studied below, the numerous deviations in the versions of the conquest of Jericho (Jos 5:13-6:27) make clear that the He brew original the translators used differed from the Masoretic text. The study of the Greek translation is thus useful even if it is compared with texts written originally in Hebrew (such as The Wisdom of Ben Sira and Jub.). Secondly, the Septuagint is not merely a translation; it is the first stage in the midrashic tradition of contextualizing and applying the He brew original, and the question is whether the intention of those translat ing the miracles-stories can be traced. Regardless of whether the devia tion is based on a different original or on an intentional change in the text, it may reveal a traditional, Hebrew interpretation. LXX is analysed in sev eral chapters dealing with writers who used the biblical stories, and the results are collected and evaluated in chapter 10. The task of identifying the biblical passages referred to is often easy and is part of the basic work of the editor or translator of the text (e.g. the Loeb editions of Philo and Josephus), but the passage that is paraphrased may 48
49
50
rial in her article in TRE (1994), but the material is too vast to be studied thoroughly in an article. On Elijah see especially Ohler 1997. See Hengel 2002, 84-85. See Hengel 2002, 85-90. Karl Ludwig Schimdt, for example, once expressed the common view that the Septu agint, in dealing with the fundamentals of the Jewish religion, was also strongly influen ced by the Hellenistic spirit ("Und gerade durch die genannte Septuagintabibel, die ja mehr als eine blofie Ubersetzung aus dem Hebraischen ins Griechische, namlich auf weite Strecken hin eine Hellenisierung sogar des herben semitischen Monotheismus bedeutet, ist das Judentum eine der selbstsichersten und werbekraftigsten Religionen des romischen Reiches geworden" (1927, 48). 4 7
4 8
4 9
5 0
13
1. Introduction
not be the only biblical text influencing the retold passage. It is a difficult task to identify the passages in Pseudo-Philo, for instance, because Liber antiquitatum biblicarum often links several other texts (the Psalms, for example) with the narration. A careful study is needed to find all the texts used or referred to. The subject has been extensively discussed, but the discussion should be continued. How the writers used the biblical ma terial, especially in the miracle stories, is always interesting. A thorough study is also needed to reveal the new traits in the stories and the biases of the writers. They may include omissions, additions, clarifica tions or alterations, with some details occurring repeatedly in different texts and revealing a common tradition. In dealing with all major versions of the retold stories about the biblical miracle-workers, the present study should throw more light on these common and traditional traits, which are collected in chapter 10. One important question involves the influence of Jewish and Gentile traditions. De Sampsone 23-24, for example, attests the obvious fact that the biblical stories were recounted in Jewish meetings and reveals that there were different oral traditions. Philo also considered the stories told by the elders as a source to be used alongside the Scriptures: 51
"[I will] tell the story of Moses as I have learned it, both from the sacred books, the wonderful moments of his wisdom which he has left behind him, and from some of the elders of the nation; for I always interwove what I was told with what I read, and thus believed myself to have a closer knowledge than others of his life's history" (Mos. 1,4).
We thus know that there was an oral tradition, that we have only fragments of the written, and part of all that was merged with the later traditions and written down in the texts dating after the scope of this study. As a result, dating the tradition is often very difficult. Some scholars intend to empha size the chain of the tradition and have often supposed that the traditions written down later were already known to writers such as Ezekiel, Philo and Josephus. Others have been more sceptical. On the other hand, some trait may resemble a Greek or Roman story. The versions of Moses' death are similar to the stories about the end of some Graeco-Roman famous men. The question is, did the writer himself borrow from the Gentile tradi tion, did he know it at all, or had the Jewish and Graeco-Roman traditions merged at an earlier stage? Although we may not be able to decide conclu sively whether a writer introduced a new trait to the biblical story or bor rowed it from an oral or written tradition, the question should be dealt with. 52
51
See below e.g. p. 195. Feldman generally supposes that the traditions were early and influenced the way Josephus deals with his material; see below, for example, p. 263. Jacobson is more cau tious and is well aware of the problems; see p. 75. 5 2
14
1. Introduction
The writers did not live in a vacuum. They were writing for a certain audience. Some Jewish authors wrote their works almost exclusively for the Jews, as the writer of The Book of Jubilees or Pseudo-Philo in his L.A.B. On the other hand, Philo and Josephus also intended their works for Gentiles. Differentiation between Jews and Gentiles, however, is not enough. Both audiences should be further analysed. What kind of Gentiles or what kind of Jews were supposed to read the story? Did many Jews, as often supposed, rationalise the miracle stories because of sceptical Gentile readers? It would be important to know more about each audience, and how it influenced the work. Moreover, since writers lived both in and out side Palestine, the geographical factor has to be observed, and finally, when all the texts are studied, some chronological lines can certainly be drawn in the final chapter. Many Jewish texts were written during crucial periods in the history of Israel, but the writers rarely if ever considered the Scripture as belonging only to the past. Everyone retelling the biblical original could adapt the holy past to his own situation. We could ask how much this was done consciously or not - in retelling the stories about the plagues in Egypt, the great exodus, the way in the desert and the conquest of the land in the times before and after the destruction of the Temple in 70 AD. Miracles are, of course, always only one piece of the picture a writer draws of a biblical hero. While some writers do not mention, for example, Moses' miracles at all, in Philo's and Josephus' texts he is a philosopher, general, statesman and miracle-worker. Although it is unnecessary to deal with all these features in this study, we should ask what role the miracles play in the picture and what their function is. It is not always easy to treat them separately. Do mighty deeds make somebody a divine being, as many supporters of the 0e7os avrjp hypothesis have supposed? What other fea tures are linked with the miracles? It is important to ask these questions, especially if the stories are heavily remodelled on the biblical original. Why are the stories remodelled and what is the result? It is clear that usually, if not always, in the Old Testament God performs miracles, but may use a man as his agent. Also, the later Jewish writers followed the same method of retelling Old Testament miracles. It is often questionable whether a man can be called a "miracle-worker" at all. God may not use any human agent in the Old Testament, as for example, when destroying Sodom and Gomorrah, but Moses' person is very closely con nected with the plagues in Exodus. It is understandable that the roles of God and his possible agent strongly vary in such retold versions as the events in Egypt, at the Red Sea and in the desert. In some Jewish texts Moses' role is reduced to the point of no longer being mentioned (The 53
On Artapanus see p. 104, on Philo see p. 109-110, on Josephus see p. 228.
15
1. Introduction
Book of Wisdom highlights divine wisdom and not Moses), but sometimes (as in Artapanus or Josephus) he may appear as a more independent actor. The texts that characterise a man as a miracle-worker, as well as the roles of God and his agent in these texts, are studied here. Kahl developed a use ful tool for this work (1994): He tried to separate the different roles in the stories by identifying the "Bearer of the Numinous Power" (= BNP) actu ally causing the miracle, the "Mediator of the Numinous Power" (=MNP) used as the agent of the BNP, and the "Petitioner of the Numinous Power" (=PNP) asking the BNP to make the miracle. Eve asked the question studying many Jewish texts in his book (2002), but there is certainly still work to be done. 54
As seen above it is not easy to define a miracle, and even the genre "mira cle-story" is a subject under dispute. Scholars have long taken the exis tence of the genre for granted. In 1919, Martin Dibelius concluded (Formgeschichte des Evangeliums) that the early Christian stories were either short accounts ("Paradigmas") or longer narratives ("Novellen"), and that the latter were close relatives of Hellenistic stories. The birth of the Chris tian miracle stories has been based on either an extension of a paradigm from the Christian or non-Christian tradition, or on a non-Christian novel adopted and applied to Jesus. Rudolf Bultmann went on in his Geschichte der synoptischen Tradition to characterize the style of the miracle stories and give a list of stories similar to ones included in the New Testament. Gerd Theissen developed the methodology in his Urchristliche Wundergeschichten (191 A, transl. 1983) connecting the study of the mira cle stories with sociological aspects. Although all these scholars assumed the existence of the genre "miracle-story", this view has been justly chal lenged. Glockner pointed to the Psalms as the background of the New Tes tament miracle stories (Neutestamentliche Wundergeschichten und das Lob der Wundertaten Gottes in den Psalmen, 1983), abandoning the link be tween a miracle and a story. Fundamental criticism against the former scholarship came with Klaus Berger's two studies, "Hellenistische Gattungen und Neues Testament" (=1984b) and Formgeschichte (= 1984a), and radically new definitions of the central terms of form-criticism. They also concern the "miracle stories": Berger flatly denies the existence of such a genre, claiming that it is not a classical genre but a modern description defining the material poorly. According to him the "miracle stories" of the 55
56
57
5 4
5 5
5 6
5 7
Kahl 1994, 62-65. Dibelius 1919, 36-56, esp. 54-55. Bultmann 1921, 135-136. Bultmann 1921, 142-146.
16
I. Introduction
New Testament belong to several narrative genres. Recently, Kahl (1994) has also emphasized the variety of the genres in which the Gospel writers presented Jesus as a BNP. The criticism is also justified concerning the material studied in the present work: Ben Sira, for example, may describe the miracles of the ancient heroes in Laus patrum, Philo uses them in his ethical discourses and Josephus retells the history of Israel. It is very diffi cult to include them all in a single genre. The genre of a "miracle-story" is thus not an assumption here. Miracles of an Israelite could occur in very different kinds of texts, and they are all important. However, it is useful to study what kind of miracles occur in early Judaism, when the mighty deeds of the Old Testament figures were retold. A summary of "themes", follow ing mainly Theissen's catalogue, is given in chapter 10. 59
60
61
58
Berger 1984a, 305-307. Kahl 1994, 237. The Old Testament also tells about miracles made by non-Israelites, but Balaam, for example, is not included in this study. See below, p. 290. 5 9
6 0
61
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira a. Introduction As many other Jewish texts, the Wisdom of Ben Sira, written in Hebrew in about 180-190 and translated into Greek in approximately 130, has be come newly current. While not even a fresh commentary had existed some decades earlier, by the 1970s intensive research and even strong dis agreement had arisen on the main lines and goals of the work. Since then many detailed studies have revealed interesting new features of the work and about 600 publications regarding it were published between 1980 and 1997. Nevertheless, many questions are still open, and although many of them are part of the background of the present study, some may be clearly significant. In particular, the impact of politics and the writer's attitude toward Hellenism, both of which are discussed vividly, are relevant prob lems when investigating the role of the miracles, and the question that should be asked is how much Ben Sira contemporized the biblical stories. Although many important themes in the text have been studied, the role of the miracles in the work has not. While the main target of this study is the Hebrew original, the Greek translation is an interesting reworking of it and may reveal some independent tendencies. However, for most parts of the 1
2
3
4
5
1
Scholars agree almost unanimously on this date; for the older view, that the translator came to Egypt not in the 38 year of Euergetes II, i.e. 132, but already in the 3 century, see Stadelmann 1980, 1-3 and Reiterer 1997, 37. We have now the commentaries of Snaith (1974), di Leila and Skehan (1987) and Sauer (2000). Beentjes 1997, V. Did Ben Sira belong to the upper or lower echelons of society? Some scholars, such as Smend (1906, 345-346) have considered Ben Sira a member of the wealthy class, but Reiterer (1997, 35-37), as Tcherikover before him, assumes that he came from the poorer class and then rose in status. The question of his profession is closely connected with this problem. Stadelmann considers him a priest and scholar (1980, 14-26) and follows the line of Schlatter: "Gelehrte, die nichts als Gelehrte waren, kamen fur Jerusalem zuerst bei Sirach vor" (Stadelmann 1980, 17; cited also by Hengel 1991, 132 and Kieweler 1992, 53). Wright (1997, 189-222) underlines his support for the priests: "Ben Sira is a scribe, perhaps even a priest" (1997, 219). See below p. 31-36. th
2
3
4
5
rd
18
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
text we have only the Greek version and are thus unable to compare it with the original. The miracles of the Old Testament heroes are alluded to very briefly in some passages. Most of them are connected to the circle of exodus, the desert traditions and the conquest of the land (Sir 16:10; 38:5; 43:15-16). There was no need to retell or explain the stories, since it was assumed that the audience was familiar with the texts. The brief references are by no means uninteresting; on the contrary, they show how prominent the Old Testament miracles were in Israel. Moreover, the example in Sir 38:5 gives information about the writer's view. Nevertheless, although the miracles play a major role in only one part of the work, they are of notable signifi cance. Laus patrum, Sir 44-50, is an important section that has been given a variety of interpretations, and in which Ben Sira apparently discloses the influence that both the Jewish and Greek traditions had in helping him shape the hymn, although many literary models were written in prose and not in verse. On the other hand, the writer had many examples to follow in the holy writings. The Old Testament contains short presentations of Israel's his tory, such as Deut 26:5-11; Jos 24:2-25; Ps 78:105-106 and 135-136, Neh 9 and Ezek 20. Von Rad, however, already recognised the difference be tween Laus patrum and the earlier presentations: It was no longer God and his hidden or open presence but the famous men of the past that were the subject of praise. The Greek tradition also offered a model for short biographies, explain ing why Sir differed from the traditional Hebrew way of dealing with his tory. The most famous example of such biographies is Cornelius Nepos' 6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
6
It is interesting that Ben Sira rejects divination in Sir 34:5 and prays for new miracles in Sir 36:5 (see below p. 31-36). In Laus patrum he refers to the deeds of David (Sir 47:3) and mentions that Enoch was taken to heaven (Sir 49:14). The passages, together with passages dealing with Moses and Joshua, are disputed below. The numeration follows Ziegler's edition of Septuagint, which is concordant with Beentjes' Hebrew text (1997). See below p. 20. Mack could still easily count the number of works on the hymn in 1985, 3, but since then the research has been prolific. On a history of the research see Reiterer 1997, 55-57. See Kieweler 1992, 59; Coggins 1998, 78-83. See von Rad 1989 (1962), 367-369; Mack 1985, 7. 217. Von Rad 1970, 330-331; see also Lee 1986, 23-31. It is strange that Whybray seems to be unaware of the long discussion. He denies the influence of Greek historiography and Greek and Hellenistic models (1999, 139). Whybray cites several Old Testament texts which touched on the history of Israel, but fails to see (as von Rad did) that the view is now different. On the historiographical and encomiastic influence see Mack 1985, 120-137. 7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
19
De viris illustribus, although long before Nepos the philosophical tradition had created a way to briefly present a man and his deeds. Diogenes Laertius gives a good (although late) example of this genre in his work on the most famous philosophers. This type could be encomiastic, as Nepos' work was, but not necessarily. In the public and private libraries, espe cially, there was a need for works that briefly presented writers and his torical figures to the broader, superficially educated population. Given the transition from prose to Hebrew verse, Ben Sira was - as far as we know the first Jew who used the form of the Hellenistic short biographies to ful fil his task. Laus patrum is thus generally considered an important part of the work. Mack's analysis shows that it is carefully formulated and that the charac terisation of the fathers follows a well-planned pattern. He names their office, election, covenant, virtues, deeds, historical setting and rewards. The pattern works well but is not used mechanically. As far as I know, the role of the biblical miracles in Laus patrum has never been thoroughly in vestigated, although von Rad, and subsequently Stadelmann noted impor tant details. Eve deals with miracles in Ben Sira and makes many impor tant observations, but he writes quite briefly and without reference to sev eral important works. 15
16
17
18
b. Moses 19
Ben Sira is not the first early Jewish writer to write about Moses, but the first known to us to discuss the role of Moses' miracles. Moses occurs in 20
1 5
It is clear that the hymn shows encomiastic features, but, as he tries to show in his book (1986), it can hardly be labelled an encomium. The transition from prose to Hebrew verse means that the writer could not directly use any of the Greek genres. Von Rad inquired about the Hellenistic genre helping Ben Sira to shape the picture of Elijah, but could not find the answer (1970, 331). Later, the problem was solved when the study advanced to the Greek short biographies; see Mack 1985, 124-128; Mack Murphy 1986, 376-377 and Schwemer 1995, 43-50. Mack 1985, 17-26. Eve (2002, 106-114) does not refer to von Rad (1970), Tiede (1972), Middendorp (1972), Hengel (1974), Stadelmann (1980) or Beentjes (1989). Sauer's commentary (2000) and Ska's (1999), Whybry's (1999) and Hoffken's (2000) important articles ap parently came too late to be observed by him. Many Jewish writers deal with Moses, but not necessarily with his miracles. We, for example, have only a few fragments of Demetrius' work, written about 221-204 B.C. (see Walter 1989, 387; Collins 2000a,33-35). Alexander Polyhistor, who included these fragments in his lost work, has not cited the title (see Walter 1975,280-283; Holladay 1983,51-54). The method was Aporiai kai lyseis, common in the exegesis of Homer's works, in which the different passages were explained. Fragments F4 and F5 point to 1 6
17
1 8
1 9
20
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
Laus patrum, but also elsewhere in some passages which will be treated here. The writer mentions the 600,000 soldiers only briefly (Sir 16:10). More interesting for the present study is how Sir cites a miracle performed by Moses. It is part of the famous praise of the physician (Sir 38:4-7): 21
"God makes the earth yield healing herbs, which the prudent should not neglect. Was not the water sweetened by a twig that people might learn his power? He endows humans with the knowledge to glory in his mighty works, through which the doctor eases pain and the druggist prepares his medicines." Ben Sira clearly alludes to the story told in Exod 15:22-27, retold by several Jewish writers studied in the present book. Does the Septuagint already reveal some tendency in rendering the passage? The LXX translates the name m o / Meppcc (TTiKpi'cc) in v. 23. p is translated as £iiAov 25. God's words in v. 26 are given in the participle and not in the substantive 'iccxpds (l^sn m.T '»* o / eyed y a p E'IUI Kiipios 6 'icouevds as. Some of these details may be of some importance in the texts studied in the present book, al though hardly in Ben Sira. 22
m
v
The role of the physician in early Judaism is certainly obscure, but the Graeco-Roman point of view is not easy to define either. A simplified view sometimes suggested is that the traditional Old Testament belief banned the medicine used by the Greeks. It is easy to quote many critical passages from the Old Testament to show that it may have been considered a sin to seek help from physicians. According to Snaith and Sauer, Ben Sira is influenced by the Hellenistic view. The question is, however, 23
Moses' miracles, but contain no new interpretations. Appparently comparing Demetrius with Artapanus, Alexander Polyhistor claimed that the former wrote in accordance with the holy writings. Collins also includes Demetrius in the "faithful chroniclers" (Collins 2000a, 33). Aristobulus deals briefly with the miracles in Exodus in Fr. 2,8, rejecting all anthropomorphic interpretations. Moses' miracles are mentioned in the Dead Sea Scrolls, sometimes briefly (as in 4Q226, 4Q422, 4Q434 and 4Q491), sometimes more extensively, but the text follows very faithfully the biblical original (4Q365). It is possi ble that even the mutilated 4Q377, which calls him "anointed", mentions his miracles (Zimmermann 1998,332-342). On Moses in Sir see Tiede 1972, 181-182; di Leila - Skehan 1987, 509. 510-511; Sauer 2000, 306-307. See Snaith 1974, 183-185; di Leila - Skehan 1987, 438-444; Sauer 2000, 260-263. The English translations given are by di Leila and Skehan (1987). Sauer (2000, 260-263) quotes the biblical passages in which the Lord is called healer: Gen 20:17; Exod 15:26; Deut 32:39; Ps 30:3; Isa 57:18. In 2 Chr 16:12 Asa seeks help from the physicians and not from God. Only the last of these texts unequivocally criticises the physician as such, while the others have different targets in addition to the physicians. 2 0
21
2 2
2 3
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
21
clearly more complicated. We know that medical treatment could be com bined with religious ideas in very different ways in classical antiquity as well as in early Judaism. Classical antiquity knew several medical traditions: Some were the first steps in empirical science, and medicine advanced strongly in Ptolemaic Egypt. Some traditions were related to religion, and healing gods were very popular. These two branches of traditions could easily be combined. The temples of Asclepius, for example, were centres offering a variety of medicaments and even longer cures. When magical treatments are added to the list of traditions it should be obvious that there is no "Hellenistic" view on the role of the physician, but many different views and their com binations. Also the view that medicine was banned in early Judaism is hardly cor rect. Admittedly Asa is criticised in 2 Chr 16:12 for seeking help from the physicians and not from God, and 1 En. 7:1 considers magical medicine as something taught to men by the Watchers. Common sense, however, tells us that these passages are not the entire truth: Men were ill and also treated in the Old Testament times. According to Exod 21:18-19, a man hitting another has to pay the costs ( K S T asm p TOSD p-i) and "Elijahu, the physician" is mentioned in a seal from the late seventh or early sixth cen tury. The Deuteronomistic belief explicitly rejected several arts of magi cal techniques (e.g., Deut 18:9-12), but Isa 1:4-9, Jer 8:22 and Jer 46:11 attest that a medical treatment was not always banned in Israel. Even Isa 38:21-22 / 2 Kgs 20:1-11 link God's help with a medical cure when a poul tice of figs is used to heal Hezekiah's boil. We know of different ways in which God's help and medical treatment were later integrated. Philo (Alleg. Interp. 2,6; Ios. 11,63) or Josephus (Vita 404, 421) never found it problematic. The community in Qumran, despite its awareness of 1 En. 7:1, seems to have used healing herbs and exorcistic techniques and repre sented a view close to the one in Jub. The most obvious parallel to Sir 38:1-15 is the book of Tobit, in which God's angel, who is ominously named Raphael, teaches the young Tobias to heal his old father (Tob 3:1624
25
26
27
2S
2 4
On the medicine of classical antiquity see Kollmann 1994, 61-72; Nutton 1999, 1107-1117. See van Cangh 1982, 264-269; Koskenniemi 1994, 220-221. Asclepius' cult cannot be regarded as a monolithic ideology. Chronological and pos sibly even geographical factors meant that the combination of religion and treatment was seen in different ways. Aelius Aristides writes that people stayed in sanctuaries for long periods (see LiDonnici 1995, 48-49). See Kaiser 2001, 12-19, who gives clear evidence of a positive attitude to medical cures. See below p. 51. 2 5
2 6
2 7
2 8
22
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
17; 11:7-8). In this book the apotropaic technique and medical cure are combined with the idea that God is the healer. Becker observes that the early rabbis often mention physicians in the Mishna and Tosefta. It is hardly a coincidence that Ben Sira, writing about the role of the physician, quotes Moses' miracle, because immediately after Moses casts the twig and makes the water sweet, God says to him: "If you listen carefully to the voice of the Lord your God and do what is right in his eyes, if you pay at tention to his commands and keep all his decrees, I will not bring on you any of the diseases I brought on the Egyptians, for I am the Lord, who heals you" ("|»s"i mrr •»» o ) . Ben Sira thus reads Exod 15:25 very carefully, linking the miracle with verse 15:26: Moses acts skilfully, and this is precisely the way in which God acts as healer through his agent. But does Ben Sira rationalise the event? Sauer interprets the passage as displaying a marked rationalistic tendency, but offers no argument. Eve approaches the question briefly. It is obvious, though, that the term is problematic. Ben Sira hardly tries to rationalise the miracle. His concept of miracle differed from the modern one. According to Ben Sira, God helps his people in many ways. Philo later attests the view that the wood Moses cast naturally had such an ef fect, and apparently Ben Sira was also aware of the explanation that the water miracle was analogous to a physician's treatment: According to him, God has created everything and is able to let his people know how to treat others. The methods God uses to help his people may differ, but it is al ways God the Creator who should be praised. The combination of medi cal treatment and God's help differs somewhat from Tob or Jub., but all of these texts link the two in some manner. Ben Sira also retells other biblical stories without reservation. His link ing of a biblical story with the work of a physician does not indicate ra tionalisation, but the merging of different views into one. Labelling this view as Hellenistic or Jewish is problematic, since both cultures clearly 30
31
32
33
34
2 9
See Kottek 2000, 9. See Becker 2002, 385-388. "Eine bemerkenswert rationalistische Einstellung verrat Ben Sira dadurch", Sauer 2000, 262. According to Eve (2002, 108) Ben Sira does not make the work of the physicians more miraculous by association with the Mosaic story; he makes the Mosaic story less miraculous. However, the question is apparently not put properly, because neither of the two seems to be Ben Sira's intention. Philo mentions this as a possible explanation; see below p. 122. The Hebrew and the Greek texts differ markedly in Sir 38:15. The Hebrew reads im KSTI 'as ? naarr inenr ^a ? «oin, but the Greek 6 ccuapTccvcov evavri TOU noirjaavoTOs auTOV euTTeooi sis X ^P S 'taTpou. Eve (2002, 108) does not consider the text to be contradictory to a positive attitude towards the physician. 3 0
31
32
3 3
3 4
1
1
£
a
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
23
included several positions, most of which combined medical cures with religious beliefs. Ben Sira's way of alluding to the biblical stories makes it generally diffi cult to speak about a "numinous power." Consequently, Moses is not a BNP ("Bearer of Numinous Power") or a MNP ("Mediator of Numinous Power") in Kahl's terminology; instead, he could be considered a PNP ("Petitioner of the Numinous Power"). The function presupposed in the story has changed: When Moses in Exodus rescues his people by mediat ing God's help, the goal of the narrative is to connect the work of the phy sicians with God's helping hand. Ben Sira tells more about Moses' miracles in Laus patrum (Sir 44:2345:5): "From him he had spring the man, who should win the favour of all the living; Dear to God and humans, Moses, whose memory is a boon. God made him like the angels in honour and strengthened him with fearful powers, wrought swift miracles at his words and sustained him in the king's presence. He gave him the commandments for his people, and revealed to him his glory. For his trustworthiness and meekness God selected him from all humankind. He permitted him to hear his voice, and led him into the cloud, where he gave into his hand the commandments, the law of life and understanding, that he might teach his precepts to Jacob his covenant decrees to Israel." Ben Sira's brief summary of Moses' life does not allow a deeper study of its relation to the Hebrew and Greek texts of the Pentateuch (for a detailed comparison see pp. 20, 57, 66, 70, 74, 92, 99 and 123). However, one verse has played an important role in the scholarly debate, namely, Exod 7:1. In this verse (nvish crn^K -pnn] ntn) a man is appar ently honoured more highly than anywhere in the Old Testament, and Moses is called a god. Both Exod 7:1 and Exod 4:16 are highlighted in the studies investigating early Juda ism. Scholars supporting the OeTos avrjp hypothesis believed that the Jews were led to reinterpret their heroes as divine beings and half-gods. Exod 7:1 opened the door to this kind of reinterpretation, and it is interesting to examine whether or not it was used. In any case, the L X X preserves the sense of the Hebrew text (SESCOKO: oe 0e6v Qccpccco) without any trace that the words were problematic to the translators. However, here the Hebrew and Greek texts of Ben Sira differ (see below). 35
3 5
This view occurred sporadically earlier but was formulated by Hahn in his Chistologische Hoheitstitel (1963, 292-308).
24
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
Ben Sira mentions Moses more briefly than Aaron or many other persons after him. As usual Ben Sira shows less interest in certain periods of his tory or events than in persons. It is not easy to say which miracles pre cisely are referred to, especially because the Hebrew text is mutilated in 45,2-3: : t r a r m insotn Dvfr[ ] b'l (in margin) : -pn *Efr inptm nna [ ]-n rwn (in margin) 36
w
[
]-n
[...] %] irri2n
The Greek text reads E V Aoyois auTou OTjjjeTa KccTerrauaev eSo^aaev a u x o v KaTa rrpoacoTrov {JaaiAecov.
Skehan translates the Greek as "wrought swift miracles at his words", which seems to be correct. According to Eve, Ben Sira only refers to the miracles that Moses performed in the presence of the Pharaoh, "that is, the signs with rod and hand and the plagues", and he wonders why the mira cles of the Red Sea crossing and wandering in the wilderness are passed over in silence. However, it seems impossible to restrict the miracles re ferred to so precisely. The Pharaoh was of course present at the Red Sea, and unless the plural (3aaiAecov is a mistake it may even include the battle against Amalek or other nations. The fact remains, however, that although the water at Marah is mentioned in another context, Moses' miracles are reported only briefly. According to Skehan - di Leila and Eve, the reason is Ben Sira's desire to emphasise Aaron as the source of the Levitical priesthood. Still, the brief mention of Moses does not mean that he is relegated to a minor role in the hymn. On the contrary, in Sir 45:1-5, Ben Sira calls attention to two of his accomplishments: i.e., the miraculous leadership and the Law. These two aspects of his mission raise him above every other human being. Aaron may be the privileged heir, but Moses is the pioneer in Ben Sira. The hymn usually mentions the office of the fa ther, but it is now absent. This may indicate that Moses' mission was not easy to characterise: He was teacher, prophet and ruler, and his office was, as Mack says, certainly sui generis. Neither the events in Exodus nor the 37
38
39
40
41
36
See Mack 1985, 49. Eve 2002, 109. Di Leila - Skehan 1987, 510-511; Eve 2002, 110-111. Aaron is clearly given a larger role (Sir 45:6-26). The story about Dathan and Abiram and the "band of Korah" (cf. Num 16:1-17:31) is mentioned in this passage (Sir 45:18). Ska 1999, 186-187. See Mack 1985, 30. 37
3 8
3 9
4 0
41
25
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
journey in the wilderness is reported extensively: An allusion is enough, here as well as in Sir 43:16. Moses' miracles ( O T H J E T O C , Sir 45:3; the Hebrew text is mutilated) are alluded to very briefly, obviously because they were so well-known to the audience that they did not need to be retold. His role is summarised in words apparently essentially different in the Hebrew and Greek texts. The Hebrew text in Sir 45:2 is fragmentary. MS B reads crn^ ] with 'D*n in the margin. Vattioni reads Errf?[K IZPK ira]i, Tiede wrt7N2 irrcri (his translation: "he made him [Moses] as glorious as God"), but di Leila reads DTfrto m r o n . The Greek translation reads copoicooEv auxov 5ol;r) 42
4 3
44
45
46
47
4 8
t /
49
ayicov.
Alan Lowe, who is working on the manuscripts of Ben Sira, kindly checked the reading in manuscript B (Oxford). In his view, more letters can be read than Beentjes indicates in his edition: : D'orion insom •"'n^n* in3[ D ]i ™ (2a in margin), •nmon (2b in margin) : -pn "izb inpmn ino m m "Q-Q mm (3a in margin) : TTQD n[K ip *rm DOT imsn Although the exact Hebrew words are uncertain, they apparently followed the thought in Exod 7:1 (runs ? d'IYtk jam). The LXX still follows the sense of the Hebrew text, but Philo as well as the Samaritan tradition and ,
,
50
51
1
42
onn *)T irom in Sir 43:16 seems to point to Ps 114:4 and p'n *pnn mm in Sir 43:17a to Exod 14:21. A very similar allusion to Ps 114 is seen in Pseudo-Philo's L.A.B.; see below p. 195. On the word, see below p. 67-67. According to Mack, Ben Sira "recognised (the Pentateuch) as an epic and regarded it as significant mainly as an epic." The model is assumed to be the study of the Homeric epic in the Hellenistic schools "and especially among the Stoics" (1985, 114. 228-229). However, the view is hardly correct. Ben Sira shows very little signs of an allegorisation. Beentjes 1997, 78. Tiede 1972, 181-182. Di Leila - Skehan 1987, 509. Snaith (1974, 220-221) gives no Hebrew text, but according to him the Hebrew text compared Moses to a god, echoing Exod 7:1; the Greek translator misunderstood god to be angels. Sauer cites the manuscripts and gives a translation ("Gott lieB ihn hintreten", 2000, 306). The Vulgate reads similem ilium fecit in gloria sanctorum. Ben Sira apparently wrote in3[D]i, but, as in 44:23b the scribe has confused the rare verb H3D with the familiar pD. The small circles, which are in the manuscript, denote a variant reading. In ina[ D ] i (2a) n is not sure, and both the initial i and 3 are still more uncertain. In 3a the second i in mrriK is not sure, and the n in - m a is still more uncertain. In 3c uvn is uncertain, but fits the ink marks well. In 3d kti is definite and the b is fairly certain; all the following let ters are very uncertain but do fit the remaining ink. 4 3
4 4
4 5
4 6
4 7
4 8
4 9
5 0
51
,
,
, ,
26
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
the rabbinic texts found it problematic. The Greek text of the Wisdom of Ben Sira seems to share the problem, rendering the text in a changed form, in which copoicoaev auxov 5O£T] ayicov apparently indicates angels. Ben Sira himself seemed to have a problem with the Hebrew words. In neither Exodus nor in Sir do they mean deification, but a legitimisation by miracles: Moses' nature is not divine; he is a messenger of God. The Jewish tradition was, as Holladay noted, very careful not to mix the roles of God and man, and the Greek text is evidence of this view. The miracles certainly make clear in the Wisdom of Ben Sira that Moses is God's agent, but his miracles can be treated briefly, because he no longer needs legitimisation in a work written for Jews. In the passage dea ling with Joshua (Sir 46:1) Ben Sira refers to Moses as r w o n rwn m m . That he was a prophet (Deut 18:18) did not even need to be mentioned to the Jewish audience. 53
54
55
56
5 7
c. Joshua 58
After Aaron and Phinehas, Ben Sira summarises the miracles of Joshua: "Valiant conqueror was Joshua, son of Nun, aide to Moses in the prophetic office. Formed to be, as his name implies, the great saviour of God's chosen ones, wreaking vengeance on the enemy and giving to Israel their inheritance. What glory was his when he raised his hand to brandish his sword against the city! Who could withstand him
5 2
See below p. 153 and Holladay 1977, 124-125. Di Leila and Skehan cite Exod 4:16; 7:1 but also Ps 8:6 and interpret the Hebrew text to mean angels (1987, 509). For Abraham, Philo uses the words Tooe, CXYYeAoie, YCYOVWC, (Sacr. 5). Oberhansli-Widmer (1994, 354-355) regards Sir 45:1-2 as the first example of Moses' divinisation in Jewish literature (1994, 354-355). However, she completely over looks Exod 7:1 as the source of the verses as well as the difference between the Hebrew and Greek texts. See Tiede 1972, 181-182; Holladay 1977, 124-125. Holladay summarises his study as follows: "As to the question of whether in Helle nistic-Judaism it became easier for Jews to conceive of a divine man because the line of demarcation between man and God had become blurred, we have seen evidence that sug gests that Hellenization among Jews, rather than bridging the gap, only widened it" (1977, 235). See below p. 27. On Joshua in Sir see Snaith 1974, 227-230; Stadelmann 1980, 189-192; di Leila Skehan 1989, 517, 518-520; Sauer 2000, 313-316. 53
5 4
55
5 6
57
58
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
27
when he fought the battles of the Lord? Was it not at his same hand the sun stopped, so that one day became like two? He called upon the Most High God when he was hard pressed, with enemies on every side; And God Most High gave answer to him with the driving force of glistening hail. Which he rained down upon the hostile army till on the slope he destroyed the foe; That all the doomed nations might know the Lord was watching over his people's battles. And because he was a devoted follower of God and in Moses' times showed himself loyal, he and Caleb, son of Jephunneh, when they opposed the rebel assembly, averted God's anger from the people and suppressed the wicked complaint because of this, those two alone were spared of the six hundred thousand infantry, to lead the people into their inheritance, the land flowing with milk and honey" (Sir 46:1-8).
The book of Joshua tells four stories about Joshua, which are clearly mira cles: the crossing of the Jordan (Jos 3:1-5:1), the conquest of Jericho (Jos 5:13-6:27), the hailstones (Jos 10:8-14) and the stopped sun at Gibeon (Jos 10:12-13). Ben Sira heavily condenses the extensive biblical material. The LXX does not attest to any clear redactional tendencies in these passages. On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX, see below p. 249.
The last two events alone, which in Joshua are mostly miracles of God, are directly mentioned in the Wisdom of Ben Sira, and possibly with some inaccuracies. The omission of the first two, however, does not detract from the miraculousness of Joshua's leadership, especially because the hailstones are also mentioned in Sir 43:15. The Hebrew text uses the bibli cal words TODm m to characterise Joshua, but adds rwon (G: SidSoxos 59
60
61
5 9
Joshua's mission, of course, was "to lead the people into their inheritance" (Sir 46:8). Yet, the crossing of the Jordan is not retold in detail. According to Snaith, Ben Sira erringly connects Joshua's prayer with the hailstorm, whereas Jos 10:14 links it with the halting of the sun and moon (Snaith 1974, 229). The note is correct, but apparently Ben Sira has presumed that Joshua prayed prior to God's words "Do not be afraid of them" (Jos 10:8). Di Leila and Skehan (1987, 517) observe another possible inaccuracy, when Ben Sira links the miracle of halting the sun with Joshua's hand and not with his voice (Sir 46:4). However, it is also possible that Ben Sira supposed that Joshua was praying with raised hands. On similar questions, see below p. 36. Jos 1:1; Num 11:28. 6 0
61
28
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira 62
Mcouafj ev TTpo^riTEiais). Joshua is not only a helping hand, but also Moses' successor, and so Joshua is included among the prophets, not be cause of his words but because of his deeds. Moreover, this was the only time he was called a prophet: Josephus also calls him by this name (5id5oxos . . . E T T I . . . T O C ? S Trpo(|>r|TEiais, Ant. 4,165). If Josephus follows a tradition, it may have antedated Ben Sira's work. In Ben Sira, the miracles of Joshua are not only an isolated event in Joshua's life but clearly the main part of his mighty deeds. From the vast material included in Josh, the writer picked two of the four miracles for his short summary, and they thus play a prominent role. In contrast to Josh, the miracles now belong to the heart of Joshua's mission. They show that "the Lord was watching over his people's battles", and are now tightly bound with Joshua's militant leadership. Did Ben Sira believe that Joshua's miracles were important for his own time? This question, a sub ject of vivid discussion in the last 30 years, needs to be asked again. It is a wide issue that also has consequences for an interpretation of the miracles in the work. In 1972, Th. Middendorp published a book on the Wisdom of Ben Sira. He defended the view already presented long before, that the original work was not at all anti-Hellenistic. On the contrary, he identified some one hundred alleged quotations from Greek literature, about half of them from Theognis. Although the work was originally written in Hebrew, Mid dendorp assumed that Ben Sira had used a Greek florilegium and that his work was intended to be a schoolbook in the Greek manner. Some impor tant passages were now regarded as interpolations from the Maccabean 63
64
65
66
Sauer (2000, 313-316) correctly underlines Joshua's militant nature in The Wisdom of Ben Sira, but fails to see his prophetical mission. He is not only the servant of the prophet Moses, but also - as the Greek translation understandably puts it - his 5td5oxos in this mission. Ska (1999, 183.184) observes the innovation. See Snaith 1974, 228-229. Die Stellung Jesu Ben Siras zwischen Judentum und Hellenismus (1972). Particularly Pautrel tried already in 1963 to establish a connection between Ben Sira and the Stoics (Ben Sira et le Stoicisme). Middendorp 1972, 7-34. Middendorp supposed that the writer knew Greek literature better than the translator, who could no longer find the original Greek expressions (1972, 8). The contacts between Ben Sira and Greek writers have been studied and discussed long before and after Middendorp. Most scholars agree that Ben Sira was under Hellenis tic influence, but some deny the proposed direct literary contacts. On this question see Mack 1985, 91. 222-223; Hengel 1991, 149-150; Reiterer 1997, 41-43. Kieweler (1992) scrutinised the evidence presented by Middendorp and found it very weak. Indeed, Mid dendorp fails to give exact citations but works with the similarity of the ideas. However, many ideas were common to the Greek as well as to the Hebrew literature and it is diffi cult to prove Middendorp's assertion that Ben Sira used a Greek florilegium. 6 3
64
6 5
6 6
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
29
period. Middendorp's book was immediately and severely criticised in a review (1974) by Hengel, who had represented a totally different view in Judaism and Hellenism (the first German edition in 1969 and the second in 1973). Since these studies the alleged anti-Hellenism - aggressive or not - in the work has divided scholars. Some of them underline the national colouring of the work and Ben Sira's connection of all universal wisdom with Israel. Other scholars emphasize Ben Sira's contacts with Greek thought and deny any contradiction with it. The study of heroes' miracles may shed light on the question. Joshua's mighty deeds clearly belong to the history shaping the identity of Israel, and he is not called a prophet by coincidence; he guarantees the continuity of the covenant. Ben Sira considers him to be the bridge be tween Moses and the judges (especially Samuel). The promise in Deut 18:18 is applied to Joshua, who gave his people their heritage in the Prom ised Land. Sir 46:1-8 is undoubtedly marked by pride in the leader's militant power. Joshua attacks "all doomed nations" (mn na, G has only eBvn, Sir 46:6). Here the miracles have become a significant part of his image. Neither ad68
69
70
71
72
6 7
See below p. 34-36. Hengel 1974, 83-87, reprinted with an epilogue in Kleine Schriften 1 1996, 252-257. Hengel calls Middendorp's book "eine typische Anfangerarbeit." In his view, Midden dorp failed to demonstrate the alleged literary relations between The Wisdom of Ben Sira and many Greek sources, overlooked the fact that in Ben Sira's work, wisdom dwells exclusively in Zion, and excluded everything that did not fit his view, considering them as later additions. The German edition of Schurer considers Ben Sira a traditionalist. "Es ist die Zeit des hereinbrechenden Hellenismus. Der Vertreter gehort zu den Altglaubigen und beklagt es tief, dafi die gottlose Manner das Gesetz des Hochsten verlassen haben (41,8)" (4. ed. 3 [1909], 3, 215). R. Smend claims that Ben Sira had a deep hatred of the Greeks (1906, xxiv) and expressed a Jewish declaration of war against Hellenism (1907, 33). See also Hengel 1974, 83-85; repr. 1996, 252-257. These scholars may not deny that Ben Sira was a cultured man of his time and familiar with Greek literature, but consider his book to be a reaction against the wholesale acceptance of Greek ideas to the detriment of their faith. Recently the national colouring has been stressed by Whybray 1999, 138, Sauer 2000, 30-31 and VanderKam 2001, 117: "Ben Sira's purpose seems to have been to convince his audience, presumably Jewish, that the true wisdom was not to be sought in the books and teachings of the Greeks but in the writings and instruction of the Jewish tradition." Pautrel (1939, 545) stressed Ben Sira's contacts with Greek thought. In Mack's view Ben Sira's book reveals "the marks of an erudite cosmopolitan" and "openness to Helle nistic thought" (1985, 85; similarly also Mack - Murphy 1986, 374-375). Eve considers Ben Sira opposed "not to Hellenism as such, but to any form of modernization that threatened what he saw as the ancestral faith" (2002, 106-107). On the history of research see Marbock 1997, 42-43. On his own view see Marbock 1999, 170-173. See Becker 2002,211. Stadelmann 1980, 191. 6 8
6 9
7 0
71
7 2
30
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
ditions nor alterations to the biblical original were needed; the picture is now radically changed. The biblical material opens the door for a reinterpretation, but only after a careful selection of the material. Miracles and politics are combined in an aggressive way. With the exception of Laus patrum the work admittedly contains very few verses showing Ben Sira's political activity. He may advise the reader not to get mixed up in political matters, but he also reveals his interest in the life of his people. Appar ently Ben Sira thought that God's covenant with David as it once was belonged to history and that it was the High Priest who represented conti nuity. If that is true, one theocracy had made room for another, although the latter was less militant and possible satisfied to control only a narrow segment of society. Nevertheless, Israel's past offered enough fuel for political zeal. The word cnn, admittedly omitted in the Greek translation, shows that this fuel is by no means absent in Sir, although the target of the aggression is not yet clear. Even so, or possibly for that reason, later inter pretations of Joshua as a hero were controversial and he caused a moderate writer such as Josephus many problems. This kind of leader could be and indeed was used for political purposes during turning points in Israel's history. Some scholars (especially Stadelmann and Hengel) have seen a line leading from Ben Sira to the later Jewish movements such as the later apocalyptic prophets and even John the Baptist. Ben Sira's description of the great conqueror certainly gave enough evidence to those who desired a politically-minded Joshua. His miracles were emphasized and adapted to new situations. The German slogan, Die Endzeit entspricht der Urzeit, re veals a specific Jewish trait, which did not belong to Greek concepts of miracles. It is easy to quote Ben Sira and label Joshua as a PNP ("He called upon the Most High God ... and God Most High gave answer to him with the 73
74
75
76
77
78
7 3
Middendorp (1972, 163-164), as well as Hengel, underlines the writer's caution, but Hengel also attributes a clear political view to him (1991, 134). According to Midden dorp and Mack (1985, 58-59) he followed the politics of Simon the High Priest. Ben Sira does not forget David but, interestingly enough, mentions him in a strange place in the hymn, which otherwise follows a chronological order. He is mentioned in connection with Phinehas, after Aaron and before Joshua. Priest suggests that Ben Sira represented a belief in two Messiahs attested already in Zech 6 and common in Qumran (Priest 1964-66, 111-118). Also, the passage on Elijah shows that a sort of "Messianism" cannot be ruled out in Sir (see Martin 1986, 107-123). See Stadelmann 1980, 157. Mack, too, considers Simon's ministry to be the climax of the sacred history in Sir (1985, 49-52). According to Mack (1985, 84-85), Ben Sira was, as were the High Priests, happy with the Temple and cult and did not try to expand the power of the priests to the eco nomic or political world. See below p. 251-254. Stadelmann 1980, 179-184; Hengel 1991, 135-136. 7 4
75
7 6
7 7
7 8
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
31
driving force of glistening hail"), and indeed he can serve as a good exam ple of this label. Joshua's role is, however, not merely that of a man in prayer. He also acts as a leader sent by God. In fact, the comments on the sun in Sir could be interpreted to mean that none other than Joshua himself is the BNP, and that he alone makes the miracle ("Was it not at his same hand the sun stopped"). This tension between two passages so close to each other demonstrates that Kahl's terminology cannot be used without a framework within which to interpret the text. Jewish texts at times may depict someone as an independent miracle-worker without any mention of God. The question is how much interpretation between the lines there was. The audience is a crucial factor influencing the interpretation. Artapanus' text was obviously intended for both Jews and Gentiles, and different read ers undoubtedly understood Moses' role in different ways. This is not a problem in Ben Sira, and there is not even the need to be concerned about "a certain amount of poetical licence", because the passage on the glis tening hail already provides a more conventional view of Joshua's role: God is obviously the BNP initiating the miracles, but Joshua is clearly his tool, the mediator of God's help (MNP). Miracles play an interesting role in this passage. They do more than merely legitimate Joshua. The writer goes one step further to show how a legitimated leader takes his people to war without any hesitation or fear. His prophetical leadership (rwoaa n$ft rrwti) proves that God watched over his people. In the view of Ben Sira, this obviously did not only refer to the distant past. 79
80
d. Elijah The words about Elijah, again in Laus patrum, form a passage important in many ways (Sir 47:25-48:11): 81
"Their sinfulness grew more and more, and they lent themselves to every evil till a like there appeared a prophet whose words were as a flaming furnace. Their staff of bread he shattered, in his zeal he reduced them to straits; By God's word he shut up the heavens and three times brought down fire.
7 9
See below p. 105. Eve 2002, 111. On Elijah in Sir see Snaith 1974, 238-240; Stadelmann 1980, 197-200; di Leila Skehan 1987, 532-534; 1992, 931-945; Ohler 1997, 6-12; Sauer 2000, 325-327 and Eve 2002, 109-110. 8 0
81
32
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
How awesome are you, Elijah! Whose glory is equal to yours? You brought a dead child back to life from netherworld, by the will of the Lord. You sent kings down to destruction, and nobles, from their beds of sickness. You heard threats at Sinai; at Horeb avenging judgements. You anointed the bearer of these punishments, the prophet to succeed to your place. You were taken aloft in a whirlwind, by fiery captors, heavenward. You are destined, it is written, in time to come to put an end to wrath before the day of the Lord, to turn back the hearts of parents toward their children, and to re-establish the tribes of Israel. Blessed is he who have seen you before he dies! .—« (Sir 48:1-11). 82
The wide biblical material on Elijah offered many aspects to be summa rised. Early on, von Rad wondered why Ben Sira had selected the miracles of the prophet. As in Joshua's case they are strongly underlined and form the essence of Elijah's character. This is emphasized by the context: David's rule is an ideal period followed by an age of decadence and sin. Elijah, the prophet of fire, the bearer of punishment and the miracleworker appears in this situation. The biblical Elijah makes and witnesses many miracles. He closes the heavens with his prayer and is fed by ravens (1 Kgs 17:1-6). The widow who gave him a room and bread miraculously receives food every day (1 Kgs 17:7-16) and gets her son back from death (1 Kgs 17:17-24). The Spirit of the Lord takes Elijah and carries him long distances (1 Kgs 17:12. 49). God answers his prayer with fire on Mount Carmel (1 Kgs 17:16-39) and delivers the long expected rain (1 Kgs 18:41-45). Elijah prophesies the death of King Ahaziah (2 Kgs 1:1-8). The fire from heaven twice con sumes the men sent for him (2 Kgs 1:9-15). He is taken to heaven miracu lously (2 Kgs 2:1-18). 83
84
Ben Sira again strongly abridges long biblical passages, and a comparison between the Hebrew and the very faithful translation does not facilitate an understanding of his text. On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX, see below p. 265.
8 2
The Hebrew text is corrupt in l i b , the Greek reads Kai oi ev ayocTrrjoei KEKoaurmevoi (ms. KEKOiurjuEvoi) / Kai y a p f|us?s £corj £na6ue0a. Sauer considers the verse an interpolation (2000, 325-327). On the reading and the verse, see also di Leila Skehan 1987, 531-532. "Er sieht die Propheten fast nur noch als Wundermanner", von Rad 1970, 331. Stadelmann 1980, 197-198. 8 3
8 4
33
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
Although briefly, Ben Sira chooses a great deal from the biblical material: Elijah closes the heavens, calls for the fire from heaven three times, raises the son from the dead, prophesies Ahaziah's death and is taken to heaven. In the short summary, of course, most of the details are omitted, opening the door to speculations. In any case I do not believe that Jezebel and Baal were left out because the writer was afraid of the pagan rulers. Because the whole biblical story is condensed (as Snaith notes, "three times brought down fire" includes the events at Mount Carmel), there is no reason for guesswork. Elisha is very militant against the pagans in Sir. Ben Sira's short passage does not reveal any clear changes compared with the biblical stories. He neither retells Elijah's miracles nor even lists them, but only alludes to the material he clearly supposes to be known to everybody. The implied audience consists of Jews who had learned their lessons well. Yet, something is left out. Neither the food brought by the ravens nor the widow are mentioned, nor the long distance the Spirit car ried Elijah. The stories alluded to help us to understand why these parts of the tradition are omitted: The miracles of the past were also important when Ben Sira wrote his work. The miracles that he chose to retell did not concern the daily lives of individuals, but the nation as a whole. The miracles Ben Sira selected were of political importance. Elijah sent kings to destruction (cf. 2 Kgs 1:1-8) and "anointed the bearer of these punishments" (cf. 1 Kgs 19:16). The second part of the verse suggests that it is not Jehu, who killed Baal's prophets, who is referred to, but Elisha. The kings of the Northern Kingdom play no role in the glorious past of Israel. The real leadership belongs to a few figures who preserved the continuity of the covenant between God and Israel. One of them is Elijah, whose mighty deeds are not just isolated phenomena, but an essential part of his prophetical mission. This idea of mission would answer von Rad's apt question as to why Ben Sira makes the prophets "almost exclusively miracle-workers." Joshua is Moses' successor nwnn and Elijah the suc cessor of Joshua as leader of the nation. The covenant and continuity is a central theme in Laus patrum and it is here that Elijah's miracles find their place. Other material - the widow, the son and the ravens - is omit ted. For Elijah as well as for Joshua the hero's miracles are emphasized. 85
86
87
88
89
90
8 5
Middendorp 1972, 65; followed by Stadelmann 1980, 198 Snaith 1974,239. The Greek text has 6 X P (3aoiAs7s e'»S avTaTroSouo: (v. 8), which indicates •obo. However, the Hebrew text has moi^n tfro rrenian. Snaith (1974, 239-240) and Sauer (2000, 325) follow the Greek text, but see di Leila - Skehan 1987, 531. See Stadelmann 1980, 199-200. See above p. 31. Stadelmann 1980, 158. 8 6
8 7
8 8
8 9
9 0
, C 0 V
34
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
The miracles are essential parts of the holy history at decisive moments. This history shaped the identity of the nation. The biblical Elijah, the man without compromises, offers many opportu nities to show how miracles could change the world. The militant prayer in chapter 36 has sometimes been considered an interpolation, but it per fectly matches the bias described above: 91
92
93
"Come to our aid, God of the universe, and put all the nations in the dread of you! Raise your hand against the foreign folk, that they may see your mighty deeds. As you have used us to show them your holiness, so now use them to show us your glory. Thus they will know, as we know, that there is no God but you. Give new signs and work new wonders; show forth the splendour of your right hand and arm; rouse your anger, pour out wrath, humble the enemy, scatter the foe. Hasten the ending, appoint the time when your mighty deeds are to be proclaimed: Let raging fire consume the fugitive, and your people's oppressors meet destruction; smash the heads of the hostile rulers, who say: 'There is no one besides me!'" (Sir 36:1-12). 94
95
The age in which Ben Sira lived was not a peaceful one, but a time of con tinuous struggle between the Ptolemaic and Seleucidic rulers over the rule 91
It is difficult to share Whybray's view that Ben Sira's work lacks a view on history: "There is no continuity here, no sense of cause and effect, no feeling of a history moving towards a recognisable goal" (1999, 139). The continuity is formed from covenant and the goal of the history described is that the High Priests take over the role of the great kings. See Schurer 2 (1979), 498: "It is clear, that the author not only pleads, but really hopes, for the destruction of Israel's enemies and a glorious future for the nation corre sponding to God's promises." On the prayer see di Leila - Skehan 1987, 420-423, Hengel 1991, 152-153 and Sauer 2000, 247-251. See Middendorp 1972, 125-132; Mack - Murphy 1986, 374-377; Eve 2002, 113-114. However, even these scholars consider the interpolation very old, from the Maccabean period. The theory about an interpolation is not accepted in the commentaries; see Snaith 1974, 174; di Leila - Skehan 1987, 420-423; Sauer 2000, 251. Snaith (1974, 174-175), di Leila - Skehan (1987, 421-422) and Sauer (2000, 250) connect these works with the miracles of the exodus. This is probable but by no means certain. The Hebrew text reads -n^ir y* "iDiKn naiD T I K D mi roan. The verse has led scholars to various speculations. Middendorp (1972, 129) interprets this to mean Antiochus' bust in the temple. Di Leila - Skehan (1987, 422) and Sauer (2000, 250) understand it to refer to the Seleucids. 9 2
9 3
9 4
9 5
35
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
of Palestine. He himself knows that "dominion is transferred from one people to another because of the violence of the arrogant" (Sir 10:8), and the prayer cited above reflects the harsh reality of his own age. The words enn imt pom T Tmn nsia ran ma / eyKcuvioov armeia Kai aAAoicoaov 6au|jaaia, So^aaov x ^ P
a
*ai Ppaxiova 5e£iov (Sir 36:6) link
miracles with the help of God. It is no coincidence that Ben Sira, treating Elijah in Sir 48:10, adds a new feature to Maleachi's verses (Mai 4:5-6), the restoration of the tribes of Israel (cf. Isa 49:6). The restoration, men tioned also in Sir 48:10, is the goal and the task of the returning prophet. Elijah not only belongs to the past; he is also a future prophet. The miracles of the past were part of the present in Israel, and they formed an important part of the Jewish eschatology. The concept of Elia redivivus is attested to in Mai 3:23-24, in the New Testament (Luke 1:17 and Matt 11:10; 11:14; 17:10-13), apparently in a text from Qumran (4Q558), and it is commonplace in Mishna. Even if these few words do not allow a study of the eschatology of the work here, Sir 48:1-11 is an early passage indicating this expectation. Subsequent to Middendorp's book cited above there have been two alter natives to choose from: Middendorp also considers the verse Sir 48:10 an early interpolation, and regards the whole association between the miracles and politics as post-Maccabean enthusiasm. However, it is easy to rec97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
9 6
Middendorp characterises the period: "Die Zeit der Makkabaer unterschied sich tatsachlich grundlegend von den ruhigen Jahren ptolemaischer Herrschaft" (1972, 113). He is by no means alone in considering the age peaceful, but the view is challenged by some, such as Martin (1986, 118-119). In 198-180, when the work was written, the "dominion" had recently been "transferred from one people to another", i. e. from the Egyptians to the Seleucids. Hengel's summary of the period after the death of Alexander is totally different from Middendorp's: "The struggle for Phoenicia and Palestine was for the next 150 years a decisive factor in the policies of both kingdoms" (Hengel 1989a, 49). According to Stadelmann (1980, 165) Ben Sira has identified Elijah with the suffer ing servant in Isaiah, but the few words we have do not allow such a judgement. See di Leila - Skehan 1987, 534. See Stadelmann 1980, 200. Middendorp (1972, 134-135) attributes the words to a glossator. Martin (1986, 111-113) correctly connects Sir 36 with the passage dealing with Elijah and sees in him some kind of Messianic light. The view is also implied in 4Q521. See Zimmermann 1998, 314-316; Schreiber 2002, 529-534 and below p. 224. The view is also confirmed in Sib. Or. 2:187-202. On the Lives of the Prophets, see below p. 184. Cf. Lee 1986, 211-212: "Restoration of the tribes by Elijah may be Sirach's attempt to attribute a future 'political' deed to the prophet to go along with those he has already accomplished." Middendorp 1972, 134-135. He recognises the miracles and writes: "Die Erneuerung von Zeichen und Wundern durch ein neuerliches Eingreifen Gottes in die Geschichte 97
9 8
9 9
100
101
102
103
104
36
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
ognise a link between the miracle-working and politically active prophet and the other nationalistic passages in the work, and it leads one to con clude that the writer had a consistent view of the past and present of his people. The biblical Elijah, a strong, zealous and powerful politician, would be problematic for some Jewish writers trying to tone down his political activ ity. Ben Sira was still free to go in the opposite direction and identify God's power with the political miracles of the prophet. Elijah's most re markable miracles are reported briefly but clearly with pride and joy. Elijah may not have been an independent miracle-worker who could be termed a BNP, but he certainly mediated God's power among his people. 105
106
Some scholars have claimed that Ben Sira erred here, as in Joshua. The Old Testament does not say that Elisha was anointed, and if Sir 48:8 originally contained the kings, it is another inaccuracy: Elijah did not anoint Jehu but Elisha's pupil, and Hazazel is not anointed in the Old Tes tament at all. The words in Sir 48:6 (nra D O ^ O imon / o KOCTO:yaycov PaaiXeTs e'is arrcoAeiav apparently point to Ahaziah, but the plu ral C P D ^ D / (3ocaiAe7s is difficult in any case, if the harsh sentence against Ahab is not meant (1 Kgs 21:21-29). These details may be called mistakes, yet since God tells Elijah to anoint Elisha and the kings (1 Kgs 19:15-16) Ben Sira may have deemed this as sufficient. As in the passage dealing with Joshua, all inaccuracies are small and they can quite easily be ex plained. They also show how eager Ben Sira is to relate miracles dealing with rulers. The miracles are at the heart of Elijah's mission and their role is clear. They are part of his mission and manifest the presence of God's power. The eschatological hope of Israel was intimately connected with the glorious past. 107
108
seines Volkes (Verse 6, 7), gar noch im Sinne von Zorngerichten, entspricht in keiner Weise dem an der Stoa geschulten Gottesbild Ben Siras" (1972, 131; see also 1972, 127). In any case, the miracles play an important role in Laus patrum and are in agreement with the view in the prayer. See below p. 269. See above p. 27. Sauer 2000, 326. As Sauer (2000, 326) notes, it was not Elijah but Elisha who anointed the kings, Hazael, king of Aram and Jehu, king of Israel. Ben Sira may be inaccurate, but Sauer is equally "inaccurate", because it was not Elisha but his anonymous pupil who anointed Jehu (2 Kgs 9:6), and Hazael is not anointed at all in the Old Testament (however, see 2 Kgs 8:13). 105
106
107
108
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
37
e. Elisha Elisha is also one of the chosen fathers in Laus patrum, immediately after his master: 109
"When Elijah was enveloped in the whirlwind, Elisha was filled with his spirit. Twice as many signs he wrought, and marvels with every utterance of his mouth. His life long he feared no one, nor was any able to intimidate his will. Nothing was beyond his power; from where he laid buried, his dead body prophesied. In life he performed wonders, and after death, marvellous deeds. Despite all this the people did not repent, nor did they cease their sinning until they were rooted out of their land and scattered all over the earth But Judah remained, a tiny people, with its ruler from the house of David. Some of them did what was right but others were extremely wicked" (Sir 48:12-16). 110
Among the Old Testament figures, Elisha most certainly can be called a miracle-worker. His mighty deeds are reported in 2 Kgs 2-13. The great number and nature of his biblical miracles have led some scholars to re gard this part of 2 Kgs as a model of collections that allegedly preceded the Gospels. Elisha's miracles in the Bible differ slightly from Elijah's: A great part of them happened in the daily life of his kinsmen. The biblical Elisha hits the water of the Jordan with Elijah's cloak and crosses the Jor dan (2 Kgs 2:1-18), heals the water in Jericho (2 Kgs 2:19-22) and curses the children, who were soon eaten by bears (2 Kgs 2:23-25). He saves the troops of the kings (2 Kgs 3:1-27), fills the jars of a widow with oil (2 Kgs 4:1-7), foretells the birth of a son to a woman who gives him a room and bread (2 Kgs 4:8-17) and raises him from the dead (2 Kgs 4:18-37). Elisha makes a poisonous food edible (2 Kgs 4:38-41), feeds hundred of men with twenty loaves (2 Kgs 4:42-44) and heals Naaman the Syrian (2 Kgs 5:1111
109
On Elisha in Sir see Snaith 1974, 241-242; Stadelmann 1980, 200-204; di Leila Skehan 1987, 534-535; Sauer 2000, 327-328; Eve 2002, 109-110. Actually the Old Testament tells of only one miracle after Elisha's death, namely the story mentioned by Ben Sira. This may be considered another small error. Achtemaier (1972a, 175-179) supposed the existence of "miracle-catenae", which were modelled on the stories about Moses, Elijah and Elisha. This view has become more common recently; see Moore 1990, 151-152. Goulder already observed the stories care fully in 1978, 266-281. 1 1 0
111
38
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
18). He severely punishes Gehazi (2 Kgs 5:19-27), takes an axhead from the Jordan (2 Kgs 6:1-7) and helps kings and mighty men in various ways (2 Kgs 6:8-23; 6:24-7:20; 8:7-15; 13:14-19). Even after his death his bones bring a murdered man back to life (2 Kgs 13:20-21). Clearly, most of the biblical material consists of miracles. Ben Sira gives a brief summary of Elisha's miracles. The Septuagint follows the Hebrew original very faithfully and does not help to clarify Ben Sira's passage. On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX see below p. 272.
Ben Sira's summary of Elisha's life is interesting. As in 2 Kgs the mira cles form the main part of his depiction. The words in 2 Kgs 2:9 are inter preted to mean that Elisha doubled the miracles his forerunner made ( w r n ^ "jrrna o^bmb / Yevvrj0r)Tco 5rj SiirAd ev m/euijcm oou ett' e|je). Elisha's role is by no means diminished here. He can justly be called an MNP; it is only the contexts that preclude him from being considered an independent BNP. Although the short passage identifies only one story, namely the dead man returning to life in 2 Kgs 13:20-21, Ben Sira makes it clear that the miraculously found axhead was not the essence of Elisha's mission. Mundane miracles seem to have been rather uninteresting to Ben Sira. They are included in the summary, but another type of miracle clearly interests him more. Similarly to Elijah and others, Elisha formed a link between the good kings and the high priests who inherited the covenant God made with David. Elisha's mighty deeds were an essential part of his mission to convert Israel. Nonetheless, in spite of his miracles the peo ple did not return to the Lord, leading to the exile of the Israelis, with only a small number remaining in Judah. Ben Sira deals rather light-heartedly with the centuries. The political role of the prophet at this decisive mo ment of Israel's history is now clearly emphasized; as a matter of fact it is his only role. Ben Sira hardly wrote this passage because of an antiquarian interest; the passage on Elijah and chapter 36 reveal the adaptation of the biblical stories, the hope of new miracles. Joshua's and Elijah's miracles were a decisive part of their mission, a manifestation of God's power and presence. Moses did not need a legitimi sation in The Wisdom of Ben Sira, but the function of his miracles is simi lar to that of the mighty deeds of Joshua and Elijah. The miracles and the prophecy build a unity: VWOL K : U vnnnoi "ODD K^D] vb 121 (Sir 48:13). 112
113
114
1 1 5
112
Stadelmann 1980, 200-201. Stadelmann 1980, 203-204.215. Snaith observes that Ben Sira ignores Amos and Hosea, apparently because he used the books of Kings (Snaith 1974, 242). Snaith (1974, 241) and di Leila - Skehan (1987, 532) correct the Hebrew text (iroa to K33) and follow the Greek (Kai sv Koiurjaei eTrpo<J>rJTeuaev TO acouo: auxou). Sauer's translation shows that he seems to retain the reading ("... und noch nach seinem Tode 113
114
115
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
39
The miracles are not isolated phenomena in the passages on Elijah and Elisha; they are intimately linked to the mission to convert Israel. How ever, Elisha's mission failed. The people did not repent, and were scattered all over the earth, a rare example of a legitimisation rejected by God's peo ple. It is interesting that Ben Sira, waiting for the restoration of Israel (Sir 36:13; Sir 48:10), mentions the "scattered" tribes. Elijah's and Elisha's miracles should have been enough to convert the people, but they were not. This is not the only occurrence of the hymn giving to a father a place on the dark side of Israel's history, but rather seems to belong to the general pattern of the characterisation. In Sir 36:1-12 the writer prays for new miracles and waits for Elijah's return in Sir 48:10. We cannot say with certainty whether he linked these two hopes, but it seems probable. 116
117
/ Isaiah Ben Sira attributes a remarkable passage to Hezekiah and the dramatic events during his reign, and the king is treated positively. Nevertheless, the most important person in the passage is not Hezekiah but Isaiah the prophet: 118
"But they called upon the Most High God and lifted up their hands to him. He heard the prayer they uttered, and saved them through Isaiah. God struck the camp of the Assyrians and routed them with a plague. For Hezekiah did what is right and held fast to the paths of David, as ordered by the illustrious prophet Isaiah, who saw the truth in visions. In his lifetime he turned back the sun and prolonged the life of the king. By his dauntless spirit he looked into the future and consoled the mourners of Zion. He foretold what should be till the end of time, hidden things that were yet to be fulfilled" (Sir 48:20-25).
wurde Leben erschaffen durch sein Fleisch", 2000, 327). Stadelmann 1980, 202-203. See Mack 1985,23. On Isaiah in Ben Sira see Snaith 1974, 242-244; Stadelmann 1980, 204-208; di Leila - Skehan 1987, 536-539; Beentjes 1989, 77-88; Sauer 2000, 328-330; Eve 2002, 109-110 and especially Hoffken's detailed analysis (2000, 162-175). 116
1 , 7
118
40
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
Isaiah's miraculous deeds are reported in a very similar way in 2 Kgs 18:13-20:11 and Isa 36:1-38:22. In the passages treated here (Isa 37:1420; 36-37 / 2 Kgs 19:14-20; 35-37 and Isa 38:1-8; 21-22 / 2 Kgs 20:1-11) the major difference between the texts is the different location of the words on the poultice of figs (Isa 38:21-22 / 2 Kgs 19:7-8). It is not certain which of the texts is the original or whether both texts are from a common source, and the divergence of the texts reveals its complex history. We cannot determine whether Ben Sira followed 2 Kgs or Isaiah or both, but his view is definitely different from 2 Chr 32, where the prophet's role has been almost totally forgotten. The Greek version of Sir seems slightly more faithful to the biblical originals than the Hebrew. 119
120
121
122
It is certainly useful to ask again whether LXX reveals any significant alterations in translating the biblical stories of Isaiah. LXX follows the Hebrew text in Isa 37:14-20; 36-38 very accurately. In 37:14 it omits mm rra ironpn. In v. 38 LXX has n a x a x p o v
(sic; MT viTro, cf. 2 Kgs 19:37 0sou auxou) and in e'.s ' Apurjviav (MT em» p « ; cf. 2 Kgs 19:37 s\s yr\v Apapccr). In 2 Kgs 19:14-20; 35-37 LXX omits impm ^ s r n mm in v. 15. In Isa 38:1-9; 21-22 LXX replaces m« with TOU naxpds oou in v. 8 and adds b fjAios in the same verse. Isaiah's advice after Hezekiah's hymn (21-22) differs rom the Hebrew text: :mm ma nbim o rm no impm -ram :'rm ymn'bv vnD-i D^DWI rbyi iwzr imi>er nam / Kai EITTEV Hoaias rrpos E^EKiav Aa(3E TTaXd0r)V 'EK CUKCOV Kai xpTv|/ov Kai KaxcJ-rrXaaai Kai uyiris Eorj. Kai STTTEV E^EKias Touxo TO OTJUETOV oxi avaprjoouai sis xov OTKOV Kupiou xou 0EOU. In 2 Kgs 20:1-11 m» is rendered with cjtimeTOV in v. 9-10 (as in Isa 38:7; 22). In v. 11 LXX omits rm rnuoa mm im. All in all, it is very difficult to find any traces of conscious redactional biases of the translators concerning the miraculous, although the translators have slightly diminished the difficulties the location of Isa 38:21-22 causes. 123
124
Stadelmann already noted that Ben Sira diminished Hezekiah's role: It is not he (as in Isa 37:4-19 / 2 Kgs 19:14-20) but the people who pray to the Lord for help (Sir 48:20). Isa 38:1-6 / 2 Kgs 20:1-6 tells how the sick king's prayer resulted in help from the Lord, but this is omitted in The Wisdom of Ben Sira. Although the king is also presented in a positive light, Isaiah has a more prominent role. As in Isa 36-39 and 2 Kgs 18-20, the prophet is Hezekiah's teacher, and it is now the prophet who prolongs the
119
See Laato 1988, 271-296. See Laato 1988, 277-278. Isa 61:1-3 was certainly in Ben Sira's mind. On the reminiscences from Isaiah see Hoffken 2000, 170. See Hoffken 2000, 163-171. The Septuagint often modernizes names of biblical places and peoples; see Siegert 2000,214. Stadelmann 1980, 204-205. 120
121
122
123
124
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
41
king's life, and God redeems his people "by his hand" (Tn ojr&m Truer / eAuTpcoaaxo C C U T O U S ev x* P Haaiou, Sir 48:20). Moreover, his person is underlined in the miracle. While in 2 Kgs 20:811 Isaiah prays and God makes the miracle, it is now Isaiah who "turns back the sun." The role of the prophet has grown: he certainly can be called an MNP, and since God is not mentioned at all it is only the wider context that prevents the miracle from being solely attributed to the prophet. Similarly to Elijah and Elisha, Isaiah is also presented as a man of politi cal significance. Although he is already a politically powerful man in the Old Testament it is interesting that the miracles are now the device under lining his significance. If the writer saw God's covenant with David broken, it is understandable that he did not emphasize the role of the Davidic king. It was Isaiah the prophet and not the king who represented the continuity of the covenant between God and Israel, and the miracles manifested which line in history was the correct one. {
{
126
127
128
g. Conclusion The biblical miracles play a major role in Laus patrum. Ben Sira uses the biblical material to reveal his strong pride in the history of Israel. The glo rious past formed the identity of the nation, and the biblical miracles were an essential part of it. There is no need to repeat the miracles; the audience consisted of Jews and short allusions were enough to remind them of the stories. Moreover, the manner of alluding to miracles is already very so phisticated in Sir. He may combine the wood cast into the water by Moses with the work of a physician, because the following verse in Exodus speaks about God as healer, or refers briefly to a psalm alluding to a story told in Pentateuch. Ben Sira was the first known writer to retell the biblical miracles and it is difficult to distinguish tradition from something of his own invention. There is no clear evidence of Greek influence in the stories except for the form, but some details may already have belonged to the Jewish heritage in Ben Sira's time. At least Philo followed him in specula-
125
TrpooE0r|Kev £cor|v PccoiAe? (Sir 48:23). The mutilated Hebrew text cannot be read. See Hoffken 2000, 171-172. Hoffken plausibly points to the similar miracle made by Joshua, Sir 46:4 as a back ground. A certain caution is necessary: David's position in Laus patrum does not fit the chronological order, but underlines his significance; see above p. 30. 126
127
128
42
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
tions concerning the twig cast into the water and Josephus calling Joshua a prophet. The short passages do not allow a detailed study of the roles of God and man. Moses' casting of the twig into the water has a smaller role than in Exod 15:22-27, but apparently the Hebrew text of Sir rendered the thought in Exod 7:1 faithfully, while the Greek text is different. Joshua seems to be more than a PNP, and it is only the larger context that prevents him as well as Elijah, Elisha and Isaiah from being called independent miracle-wor kers, some kind of BNPs. However, although God is not necessarily even mentioned, as in the passage dealing with Elisha, the verses cannot be iso lated. The miracles of these men were not absorbed by wisdom, as in Wis dom, and they did not become mere messengers as in Chronicles, but their great deeds were retold with pride. The central question concerns the interesting mixture between miracles and politics. Did Ben Sira draw attention to the miracles, because he thought they were actually important? As seen, some scholars have underlined Ben Sira's political activity in this context, while others have been rather scep tical. There are very few passages in the work that can be interpreted from a political point of view, and it is generally lacking in material that could be used for a political programme. The conclusion, however, that the writer has little or no interest in political life is only partially true. Laus patrum, but also Sir 36, which is an original part of the work and not an interpola tion, contain material worth noting. Moreover, Ben Sira's method of using the biblical miracle stories shows that they were not merely Trapd5o£a, but that the mighty deeds had a political and prophetic significance. He clearly chose miracles that were significant for the history of Israel, while others were of no interest to him. It is strange that the crossing of the Jor dan did not interest him, either in the age of Joshua or in the times of El isha. Did Ben Sira have a political programme? Did he think that the mighty deeds told in the Scripture belonged solely to the past of the nation? The writer certainly had a view of the past and present of Israel, but there is not enough evidence that he had a political programme. Perhaps he was satis fied as long as the Temple stood and the Law was taught. Von Rad doubted whether Ben Sira himself understood how much he had developed the heritage, which he believed he was mediating. Here we may have the 129
129
"Als deren (Vater) Treuhander betrachtet er sich; man kann sogar fragen, ob er sich der Tatsache iiberhaupt bewuBt was, daB und wie er selbst diese uberkommende Traditi on nicht unerheblich weiter gebildet hat" (von Rad 1970, 307).
2. Miracles and the Glorious Past: The Wisdom of Ben Sira
43
answer to the question of how Ben Sira treated the biblical miracles. He was eager to retell them and emphasize their political significance. They were part of the great past shaping the identity of the nation, but they did belong solely to the past, and the writer hoped that they could be repeated, moreover, in a militant context (Sir 36:6). Elia redivivus is expected to restore the nation, and the biblical miracles certainly influenced the view of contemporary times. Ben Sira obviously linked the eschatological future of Israel with its glorious past. Even so, the miracles were not part of a consistent political programme. Ben Sira considers himself to be rather the last of the wise men, not the first with a new political view. However, the militant Joshua and Elijah described by Ben Sira were especially open to an interpretation that called for revolts. This possibility was realised later. Although it was not Ben Sira's intention, he was, also here, an important link to the later prophets and movements.
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees a. Introduction Many Jewish texts studied in this work have been found in modern times. One very central early Jewish text was already well known in the early Church, but modern scholars first became aware of it in the mid-nineteenth century. In the text, The Book of Jubilees, God speaks to Moses and lets the "Angel of Presence" tell him about the creation and the history of the world up until Moses' own time. Some parts of the story follow quite accu rately the biblical original, but the anonymous writer also allows himself a great deal of freedom. R.H. Charles once dated the work between 135 and 105 BC and consid ered the writer a Pharisee, but the work is now generally considered to antedate this period today. According to VanderKam the latest historical event alluded to in the work is Judas Maccabeus' battle in 161 BC, and it is written before the break between the Essenes and Jerusalem. Since VanderKam's study the work has generally been dated to about between 161 and 140, with smaller variations. The provenance of the work is usually supposed to be in the antiHellenistic, religious circles opposing the new spirit of the times in Seleucidic Jerusalem, and more precisely the writer saw himself as belonging to 1
2
3
4
5
6
1
Charles (1902, Ixxiii-lxxxiii) gives a list in Jewish, Samaritan and Christian writers quoting or referring to the work. The Ethiopian version was edited in 1859 and translated into English by Charles in 1902 (VanderKam 1977, v; van Ruiten 2000, 1-2). "The Book of Jubilees was written in Hebrew by a Pharisee between the year of the accession of Hyrcanus to the high-priesthood in 135 and his breach with the Pharisees some years before his death in 105 BC" (Charles 1902, 1). A still later date was com monly supposed in the 19 century (see VanderKam 1977, 208-211). VanderKam 1977, 283. See Frey 1997, 324-325. Wintermute (1985, 44) gives precisely these years, Berger (1981, 300) the years 145140; Nickelsburg (1984b, 101-103); Halpern-Amaru (1999, 2) 160-150 and VanderKam 161-152 (1989, v; 2000, 448). Charles considered that the writer's objective was to defend Judaism against the at tacks of the Hellenistic spirit (1902, xiii). See also Berger 1981, 298 and Endres 1987, 237-238; Knibb 1989, 17; VanderKam 1997, 19-22. 2
th
3
4
5
6
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
45
7
the line of priestly writers going back to Levi. I Mace 1:11 tells about the Jewish renegades ending the separation between the Jews and the Gentiles. These people were obviously the opponents of the writer and his circles. The nation was divided, and while the reformers tried to establish contact with the Gentiles, the writer and his circles argued for the separation, and found hope in the nation's past. The work was very popular in Qumran. 8
9
10
The work is written in Palestine, and since Charles (1913), Hebrew is gen erally supposed to be its original language. Although some doubts have been raised the fragments found in Qumran confirm this opinion. The work was translated into Greek and from Greek into Ethiopic, which forms the basis for the scholarship. 11
Endres noted the great liberties the writer allowed himself with the text. The text was holy, but it did not prevent a free rendering of the stories. On the other hand, the writer only rarely adds a passage freely, and even then it is usually linked in some way to tradition. The subject of the work is biblical history up until Moses, which led the Church fathers to give the work the name Little Genesis (x\ AsTrrrj yeveots). It means that there are not many human miracle-workers in 12
13
7
See Frey 1997, 324; VanderKam 1997, 19. VanderKam 1997, 19-22. See Berger 1981, 298-299; Wintermute 1985, 45-46. Van Ruiten notes that the work speaks negatively of the actual Temple, but positively about the former sanctuaries (e.g. Eden) and about the future Temple. The reason is that the actual Temple was deficient and had to be restored (van Ruiten 1999, 215-227). The numerous fragments and the theological character led Delcor in the Cambridge History of Judaism II to suppose that the work was not only copied but also written by the Essenes, perhaps by several hands and not before 153 (Delcor 1989, 435-436). This view is by no means a new one but was represented, for example, by Jellinek (1855). Schiirer (German ed. 3 [1909], 375) rejected it with arguments that are still valid: There is no doubt that Jub. and the Essenes had much in common, but the work lacks some features, such as ritual washings, which were important in Qumran. The opposite view, that Jub. is written outside the society and before its origins, is held by scholars as Noack (1957-58, 191-207) and Wintermute 1985, 44. VanderKam correctly concludes: "Theo logically, Jub. and the Qumran texts are intimately related and are the product of a com mon and distinctive tradition; and the author of Jub. was not a member of the exiled Qumran society" (VanderKam 1977, 280-282). About one fourth of the Latin text, also translated from Greek, is preserved, and we also have Syriac fragments (Wintermute 1985, 42). On the history of the text see Berger 1981, 285-294; Wintermute 1985, 41-43 and VanderKam 1989, vi-xxxi. VanderKam edited the critical text (1989a), and his translation is used in the present work. Endres 1987, 249-259. Charles (1902, xv-xvi) supposed that the name goes back to the Hebrew title, be cause the form fj MiKpoyeveots also occurs. According to him the epithet "little" points 8
9
10
11
12
13
46
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
the Old Testament either to be studied or excluded. Nevertheless, the work tells about the miracles of two Old Testament heroes, Abraham and Moses, in both cases with new, interesting details. As far as I know, only Eve has studied thoroughly the role of miracles in the work, and his general con clusion is that they are not given much attention. However, there is still scope for further study, especially because he overlooks essential features in the passages concerning Abraham. 14
b. Abraham The angel tells Moses about Abraham's conversion and youth. Abraham was only a boy of 14 when he saved the fields in Chaldea. His opponent was no human being, but Mastema, the prince of the demons. In Jub. 11:11-24 Mastema sends ravens and other birds to eat the seed: "Then Prince Mastema sent ravens and birds to eat the seed which would be planted in the ground and to destroy the land in order to rob mankind of their labors. Before they plowed in the seed, the ravens would pick (it) from the surface of the ground. For this reason he named him Terah: because the ravens and bird reduced them to poverty and ate their seed. The years began to be unfruited due to the birds. They would eat all the fruit of the trees from the orchards. During this time, if they were able to save little of all the fruit of the earth, it was a great effort" (Jub. 11:11-13).
The young Abraham realised that the idols and impurity led people astray and began to pray to the Creator. His prayer brought results: "When the time for planting seed in the ground arrived, all of them went out together to guard the seed from the ravens. Abram - a child of 14 years - went out with those who were going out. As a cloud of ravens came to eat the seed, Abram would run at them before they could settle on the ground. He would shout at them before they could settle on the ground to eat the seed and would say: 'Do not come down; return to the place from which you came'! And they returned. That day he did (this) to the cloud of ravens 70 times. Not a single raven remained in any of the fields where Abram was. All who were with him in any of the fields would see him shouting: then all of the ravens returned (to their place). His reputation grew large throughout the entire land of the Chaldeans. All who were planting seed came to him in this year, and he kept going with them until the seedtime came to an end. They planted their land and that year brought in enough food. So they ate and were filled" (Jub. 11:18-22).
Compared with Genesis, with the Hebrew text and LXX, everything is ei ther taken from tradition or freely invented. Because the writer only sel dom adds anything not based on tradition (although he often allows himto the many details in the book. Also, Schiirer (German edition, 3 [1909], 375) notes that Jub. is more extensive than Genesis, but is of the opinion that the words emphasize the canonical value of the biblical book. Eve 2002, 155-172. 14
47
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
self a great deal of freedom), there is cause to look for biblical passages that may have influenced the text. Gen 15:11 may have served as a back ground, as it tells about Abraham and the birds disturbing his sacrifice. LXX does not give any direct evidence of the view that the birds were demons, translating Gen 15:11: Keener) 5 ' opvecc S T T I TOC ocopaTo; T C C 5ixoTO|JT]MC6(3OS O K O T S I V O S payees psyaq (cf. Ps 92:5). It is thus understandable that the ravens and birds in Jub. are reinterpreted as demons and the young Abraham knows how to expel them. The story can be called an exorcism, although the sober words of the lad hardly meet the definition of opKOs. The demonology of the work offers the framework in which the miracle-story is placed. Abra ham has to fight against the evil powers. This is the most interesting fea ture of the miracle stories in Jub. The Book of Jubilees follows a strong tradition of presenting Abraham's life very freely. Legendary material on him was common in early Judaism and it is also present in Philo and Josephus, for example, in L.A.B. 6-8 and Apoc. Ab. 1-12. But how strong was the tradition of Abraham as a man making miracles? The texts presented by S.T. Brock are a special case: the late Syrian tradition may reveal a very close parallel to the story quoted and it is hard to exclude the possibility that it even antedates Jub. Brock cites two Syrian texts, the writing of Jacob of Edessa (died 708) and Ca tena Severi (compiled by a monk named Severus in 861). It is unclear whether Severus used Jacob's text or whether they used a common source, but Brock supposes that the tradition followed by these writers was very old and even older than the tradition cited in Jubilees. The story presented and translated by Brock relates the history of the young Abraham. Because of its broad concordance with The Book of Jubi lees it is easy to consider it only a secondary version. It contains, however, some very interesting details, especially in the story about the ravens. Ac cording to the Syrian texts, it is not Mastema but God who sends the ra16
17
18
19
20
11
15
Endres 1987, 249-259. Wintermute 1985,40. Eve does not deal with this story, although he studies the stories about Abraham (2002, 160-163). Kollmann 1996, 60 correctly differentiates between exorcism and other apotropaic techniques. Charles quotes other Christian writers who were aware of the story; see Charles 1902, 88; however, they clearly depend on Jub. See Brock 1978, 135-152. Brock 1978, 142. 16
17
18
19
2 0
21
48
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
vens as punishment for idolatry. In Jub. Abraham is fourteen years old, works with his family and drives off the ravens easily. In the Syrian tradi tion he is fifteen years old, is sent by his father and exhausted in the long encounter with the birds before God helps him. The Syrian tradition does not use the story to show how Abraham invented the plough. Whether or not the Syrian tradition is an independent variant of the story told in Jub. is difficult to determine. Jacob of Edessa mentions "the Jewish histories", and we cannot exclude the possibility that both texts used a common source. It would be tempting to assume that Jub. has resolved the problem by making Mastema the source of evil. If that is correct, and the texts have a common tradition, we have proof that Abraham had to fight against demons more often in the early midrashic tradition. Also, other texts written after Jub. certainly depict Abraham as a mira cle-worker. The most important texts are Genesis Apocryphon and, in some sense, The Apocalypse of Abraham. It is significant that both texts deal with demons, revealing a common tradition with Jubilees. Genesis Apocryphon, an Aramaic text from Qumran, was written at the turn of the era. The whole work, which shows no specific Essene traits, and was perhaps written outside of the community, is a paraphrase of Genesis. Theologically, the text is considered to be the closest work to Jub. and possibly even dependent on it. It paraphrases Gen 12, supple menting it with Gen 2 0 and adding new elements: The Pharaoh takes Sarah from Abraham, who prays for the ruler to be punished so that every body will see who the Lord on earth is. God sends a spirit (EHDD mi) that torments the ruler for two years and that no Egyptian physician or magi cian can exorcize. Abraham is asked to pray for the Pharaoh and to lay his healing hands on him. He refuses to do it before the king gives Sarah back. Only then is Abraham willing to help: 22
23
24
25
26
27
28
"I prayed for [...] and laid my hands upon his head. The plague was removed from him; [the evil spirit] was banished [from him] and he lived" (IQAp Gen" 20,28-29). The background of the story is in Gen 12:10-20, but Gen 20:1-18 also has to be studied to determine whether LXX includes significant alterations, and possibly attests a tradition of interpretation. In Gen 12:10-20 LXX gives in 12:15 the responsibility to the officials
2 2
See Brock 1978, 140-141. See Brock 1978, 137. For a similar version of a story, see below p. 58. On Genesis Apocryphon see Nickelsburg 1984b, 104-107; Maier 1995, 1, 211-212; Eve 2002, 177-182. Wintermute 1985, 43-44. Abraham's prayer (Osswald 1960, 20-23), as well as the illness, are taken from Gen 2 3
2 4
2 5
2 6
2 7
20. 2 8
Eve (2002, 160) justly notes that Jub. shows no interest in developing the story (Jub. 13:13).
49
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
of the Pharaoh (npm / e'larjyayov). In 12:17 the Hebrew text has cr'na o^aa and LXX eTaouoTs ueyaAois, but it adds Kai novripoTs as in 12:19 EVCCVTIOV oou. In Gen 20:1-18 LXX adds in 20:2 ec|>opri0r| y a p s'lireiv O T I Tuvrj uou e a x i v , urjiroTE aTTOKTEivcoatv auTOV o'l avSpss TTJS TTOAECOS 5t' auxriv and in 20:4 e'Svos ayvouv Kai. In 20:5 the Hebrew text has romaa-trm, but LXX Kai auxr|v. In 20:11 crrr™ n«T is translated with Seooepeia and in 20:16 WYV moD with S'IS xiurjv x o u npoocoirou aou. Although some details are interesting, LXX shows no clear bias in the translation of the passages.
It is problematic to use the younger text to shed light on The Book of Jubi lees, especially because the writer of Genesis Apocryphon may have known The Book of Jubilees. In any case, the text is influenced not only by Jubilees, but is part of a broader midrashic tradition. Gen 12, comple mented by Gen 20, is reinterpreted as an exorcism, and the way to the exorcism was not far to go. However, clear changes were necessary be fore Abraham could, as in Jubilees, fight against evil spirits. Abraham prays to God for punishment, but when the Pharaoh is helped, God is no longer mentioned. It is Abraham who is sought after to help and he helps. It is true that he prays to God and acts, in Kahl's words, as a PNP, but his role is now different from what it was in the beginning of the story. The apotropaic technique is clear and interesting. That the healer or exorcist lays his hands on the tormented is said to be unique in early Judaism, but Eve plausibly points out 2 Kgs 5:11 LXX (67n0rjoei xrjv X P c
30
31
32
By
a
33
34
The word 'exorcism' is used here very cautiously. There is no clear opKOs expelling the demon. However, the father prays in Gen 20:12-16 for the punishment - the man acts as an "eisorcist." Some scholars have supposed that Gen 12 has lost the element (a dream or a sooth sayer) making Pharaoh aware that Abraham had not told the whole truth; see Osswald 1960, 9. Also, Philo (Abr. 96-98) describes the punishment of the king and his household vividly, but mentions no spirit. Eve 2002, 177. Beyer 1984, 176. It does not occur in the early rabbinic sources, but has parallels in Mesopotamian texts (see Becker 2002, 147). Eve 2002, 179. See Philonenko-Sayar - Philonenko 1982, 417-419. Rubinkiewicz also considers a later date possible, up until the middle of the second century AD (1983, 682-683). 2 9
3 0
31
3 2
3 3
3 4
50
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees 4
"And it came to pass when I saw the bird speaking I said this to the angel. What is this, my lord?' And he said, this is disgrace, this is Azazel!' And he said to him: 'Shame on you, Azazel! For Abraham's portion is in heaven, and yours is on earth, for you have selected here, (and) become enamoured of the dwelling place of your blemish. Therefore the Eternal Ruler, the Mighty One, has given you a dwelling on earth. Through you the all-evil spirit (is) a liar, and through you (are) wrath and trials on the generations of men who lived impiously. For the Eternal, Mighty One did not allow the bodies of the right eous to be in your hand, so through them the righteous life is affirmed and the destruction of ungodliness. Hear, counsellor, be shamed by me! You have no permission to tempt all the righteous. Depart from this man! You cannot deceive him, because he is the enemy of you and of those who follow you and who love what you wish. For behold, the garment which in heaven was formerly yours has been set aside for him, and the corruption which was on him has gone over to you" (Apoc. Ab. 13:4-14).
In this text Abraham also has to fight against an evil spirit and again the demon takes the form of a bird. Although it is the angel and not the father who expels the spirit, Abraham is honoured and elevated to a higher posi tion than in Jubilees. In Apoc. Ab. Abraham is not yet, but is becoming the master of spirits, even of Azazel, the prince of demons, whose former garment has been set aside for him. Abraham is thus reinterpreted as the lord over demons in the early Jew ish texts at least three times. Although the two texts cited are markedly younger than Jubilees they certainly help us to understand it. Apparently a broad tradition had given Abraham control over the demons; in fact Jub. 12:19-20 is part of this tradition: Abraham burns the house of idols and, as Lange correctly observes, rejects astrology, immediately seeking God's help against evil spirits in his hymn. It is noteworthy that even the com munity in Qumran used hymns to expel demons. When the attention is focused on a new figure introduced in Jubilees, Abraham's new role becomes clear. Abraham's real opponent is not a hu man being but Mastema, the prince of demons. According to Alexander, he seems identical to Belial, Satan, Melciresha, and possibly also to Beelze bub and Abaddon. He appears in Jubilees, first in the stories about Noah's time {Jub. 10:8; 11:5.11; 17:16; 18:9.12; 19:28; 48:2. 9; 12:15; 49:2). When the demons have led astray, blinded and killed his grandchil35
36
37
38
3 5
The biblical story is extensively retold and reinterpreted also in L.A.B. 33:5-7, but the demon is absent. Lange 1997, 383-384. Abraham prays: "Save me from the hands of evil spirits which rule over the thought of the heart of man, and do not let them lead me astray from follow ing you, O my God; but establish me and my seed forever, and let us not go astray hence forth and forever." See below p. 220-222. nnotOD occurs in Hos 9:7. Belial is called "the Angel of Enmity" (HOBBD ybti) in 1QM 13,10-12. On Mastema see Endres 1987, 27-28, Olyan 1993, 66-67 and Alexander 1999, 334. 341-344. On his mission given by God see below p. 58. 3 6
3 7
3 8
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
51
dren, Noah prays for help before God, who tells his angels to bind all of the demons. Mastema, however, prays that they should not all be bound: "Lord creator, leave some of them before me; let them listen to me and do everything that I tell them, because if none of them is left for me I shall not be able to exercise the au thority of my will among mankind. For they are meant for (the purpose of) destroying and misleading before my punishment because the evil of mankind is great" (Jub. l O ^ ) . 40
God instructs the angels to leave a tenth of the demons for Mastema / Sa tan (both names occur in the story), but also tells an angel to teach Noah the method of how to control the deeds of Mastema (Jub. 10:10). The methods taught by the angel show that common Mediterranean magic had become a part of the Jewish belief. As in Tob 11:7-8 the good powers tell how to control the evil. The name and role of the angel Raphael demon strate the common tradition: The angel heals and teaches to heal, because the Lord is the healer of Israel ("]Ksn mrr ^ Exod 15:26). The view is contrary to the texts (as in 2 En. 7:1; 8:3) in which the use of these meth ods means that the man follows the fallen angels. The origin of evil is a theme discussed vividly in apocalyptic literature. Some writers consider evil primordial, some as part of the original crea tion. The texts may even suppose a revolt in Heaven or that God's angels originally had a positive mission, but rebelled on the Earth. Sometimes mankind is the origin of evil. Jub. 4:15 tells that the angels mentioned in 41
42
43
44
3 9
Lange considers this prayer a hymnic exorcism (Lange 1997, 383), and Abraham certainly fights the evil spirits, but there is no opKos (see above p. 47). On the story see Alexander 1999, 347 and van Ruiten 2000, 338-340. Van Ruiten considers 1 En. 15-16 a possible background for this passage, although the view on de mons and their power is different in the two texts. The note apparently is correct, because Jub. only rarely adds a passage without any basis in the biblical text (see van Ruiten 2000, 370). See Kottek 2000, 87-88. See above p. 20. Lange (1997, 384-385) considers the text an attempt to integrate Greek medicine into Jewish monotheistic thought, and he compares the text with Tob 11 and Sir 38:1-15 quoting Snaith's words on Greek medicine. However, as seen above (p. 20-22), neither the Jewish nor the Greek view was monolithic. Kollmann 1994, 297-299. See Collins 1995. On the explanation that evil is primordial and not created, see Collins 1995, 34-35. 1 En. 6-13 tells that the angels rebelled and that their descent to Earth was already a part of their sin (1 En. 15:11-16:1). Jub, possibly aware of the Enochic version (see VanderKam 1999, 169-170), presents another version: The angels had a mission from God and they were not yet evil in heaven. Man is the origin of evil, esp. in 4 Ezr. 7:1; 2. Bar. 48:42; 2 En. 18:3 (see Collins 1995, 35-37). The origin of the demons is also explained in different ways. In 1 En. they emerged from the slain bodies of the rebelling Giants (1. En. 15:9-16:1). 1QS 3,17-4,1 regards the demons as part of the original creation and likens them to figures in Persian mythology, (see Collins 1995, 3133). The texts in Qumran may call mi angels as well as demons, but differentiate be tween them (Alexander 1999, 331). 4 0
4 1
4 2
4 3
4 4
52
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
Gen 6 had been sent on a mission by God but sinned (Jub. 5:1-11). Jub. 7:21-27 describes how evil they were and also mentions the demons. The most important passage in the work is undoubtedly the one quoted above (Jub. 10), showing that the demons were on God's mission. The story about Mastema and his demons is crucial to the interpretation of Abraham's new features in Jub. His work in the fields does not form a separate detail of his life but shows his place in the war against Mastema and his troops. As in the two latter texts cited above, he is compelled to fight against demons. Jubilees also ascribes his temptation in Gen 22 to Mastema (Jub. 17:5-17). The lad expelling the demons acts as an exor cist, or more exactly, uses an apotropaic technique. But why did the writer reshape Abraham's image and make him a master over the demons? If we ask for the Sitz im Leben for this story, two an swers are possible, and both may be correct. Firstly, it is conceivable that the father of the nation acted as a model and shield for the later exorcists: The controversial art of wisdom needed to be defended, and what Abraham himself did could not be wrong. The second possibility may be the more plausible: The war between the good and evil powers is a central theme in the belief represented by the writer and his movement. Although it is not present in as many of the retold stories as might be expected (as in Gen 3) and the dualism is not as developed as later in Qumran, the story about Abraham serves as a model for a good Jew of how to obey God and be protected by the good powers; the view can thus be classified as ethical dualism. This tradition is attested in the apotropaic hymns in Qumran (esp. 11Q11) and occurs in the New Testament (Matt 4; Luke 4). It is ap parent in Jub. 12:19-20 and consequently in the whole work. The miracles are thus connected with the war between good and evil powers in Jub. There is no reason to believe that this was his own innova tion; he certainly formulated the belief of his circles. As seen, he also had several followers. This feature was not and could not be common in the Graeco-Roman world. Admittedly, the Greek world knew bad spirits also before Xenocrates, Plato's follower in the Academy, formulated his three categories and attributed rrdOrj to Saijjoves, and the contacts between the Greeks and the East increased soon. However, the fight between God and 45
46
47
48
49
4 5
See below p. 58-59. The jealousy of angels / Saltan is also attested e.g. in 2 En. 31 and the Life of Adam and Eve 14, L.A.B. 32:1-3 and Gen. R. 55:4. On Mastema's God-given mission, see be low p. 58-59. See e.g. VanderKam 1977, 264-267; Berger 1981, 282; Wintermute 1985, 47-48; Hengel 1991, 221. On the different patterns of dualistic thought, see Frey 1997, 275-335. See Frey 1997, 284. See below, p. 180. 4 6
4 7
4 8
4 9
53
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
Satan is not a Western, but an Eastern tradition. Consequently, the inter pretation of miracles like that in Jub. was strange in the Graeco-Roman world. The Book of Jubilees was written in Palestine in Hebrew, and, moreover, apparently in anti-Hellenistic circles. It is thus interesting that the story about the young Abraham reveals a typical Greek topos. As the miracleworking Abraham teaches the people to handle a plough and to hide the seed in the earth, he is presented as irpcoTOs EuprjTrjs of a useful tech nique. The inventor of a new knowledge or technique was never forgot ten in classical antiquity. It is a topos that was common in Greek literature, and it is easy to find, especially in the writings of the Egyptian Jews. It was a part of the interpretatio Graeca in the Jewish belief, helping the Jews to find their place in the Graeco-Roman society as a learned and wise nation. The Jews could not accept the claim that they had never produced wise men such as Socrates, Zeno and Cleanthes or the fact that they were not even mentioned by the masters of classical Greek literature. Their response was that all wisdom was derived from the Jews. In Artapanus's fragments Abraham and Moses are praised for teaching the Egyptians not only astrology but also the letters and agriculture, and Aristobulus and Philo derived the wisdom of the Greek philosophers from Moses. Even The Book of Jubilees adopted a traditional Greek element and presented Abraham as i r p c o T o s euprjTrjs of how to plant seed so that the ravens could not eat it. In Jub., agricultural knowledge is combined unhesitatingly with the wisdom Noah learned from the good angels in order to control Mastema and his demons. A distinction between the different types of wis dom is not made. It is enough to know that Abraham, as Solomon in the later texts, mastered them all. A Greek topos had found its place in the anti-Hellenistic text. 50
51
52
53
54
55
A traditional Greek topos is thus accepted, but a common Mediterranean and Jewish element is interestingly enough disregarded. Abraham is re garded in many texts as an expert in astrology. The only passage in Gene sis that could be the starting point of this tradition is that in which he is told to look at the stars (Gen 15:5). Siker's collection of evidence on
5 0
On TrpcoTOS eupnTrjs see Kleingunther 1933, 1-55, Vhraede 1962, 1191-1278 and Holladay 1977, 220-229. See Josephus c. Ap. 2,135. See Chapter 5. See/r. 3-4 (= Euseb. hist. eccl. 13,12,1-8). E.g. Heracleitus (Alleg. Interp 1,108); Socrates (QG 2,6); Zeno (Prob. 53-57). See below p. 259-264. 51
5 2
5 3
5 4
5 5
54
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
Abraham in Graeco-Roman writings shows that the father of the nation was often presented as a master of astrology, at least since the time of Berossus. This view divided the Jews. Some accepted it with pride, while others rejected it. In the writings of Pseudo-Eupolemus (FGrHist 3,724, Fr. 1) and Artapanus (Artap. 1) Abraham taught astrology to the Egyp tians, but there is nothing in Jubilees about this. Astrology is rejected in Deut 18:10-11 and also in Isa 44:24-25, and even more radically in 1 En. 8:3, although it does not mean a rejection of all kinds of divination. Jubi lees implicitly condemns astrology, when Cainan discovers astrological lore engraved in stone: 56
57
58
"He read what was in it, copied it, and sinned on the basis of what was in it, since it was the Watcher's teaching by which they used to observe the omens of the sun, moon, and stars and every heavenly sign" {Jub. 8:3).
It is thus not surprising that Abraham watches the stars from evening until daybreak, but understands that they did not help him achieve real wisdom: "All the signs of the stars and signs of the moon and the sun - all are under Lord's con trol. Why should I be investigating (them)? If he wishes he will make it rain in the morn ing and evening; and if he wishes, he will not make it fall. Everything is under his con trol" (Jub. 12:17-18).
Astrology, magic and divination are strongly rejected in many early Jewish texts, but as Lange notes, the same texts also show that the writers were well aware of the practices rejected and sought ways to block the evil spir its. Jub. rejects astrology but even though the writer has abridged them, it does not omit biblical dreams altogether. Astrology is not rejected be cause it is useless but because it means contact with evil spirits. 59
c. Moses A second passage in which the Old Testament miracles are retold by the angel deals with Moses and his times. The writer briefly retells the sto ries of Moses' birth and youth, making some understandable additions and alterations (Jub. 47:1-12). The miracles first gain importance when Moses returns to Egypt. 60
61
56
Siker 1987, 193-197. On astrology in early Judaism, see Lange 1997, 397-408. See Lange 1997, 401-403. See Lange 1997, 394. On Moses in Jub. see Charles 1902, 248-253; Tiede 1972, 188-190; Wintermute 1985, 139-140 and VanderKam 1989b, 309-315. The calendar is, of course, important to the writer, but he also adds the sentence "Amram, your father taught you writing" (Jub. 47:9). Egyptian or Graeco-Roman educa5 7
5 8
5 9
6 0
61
55
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
The plagues are recounted briefly, but it is possible to examine the redac tion and details: "You performed the signs and miracles which you were sent to perform in Egypt against the pharaoh, all his house, his servants and his nation. The Lord effected a great revenge against them on account of Israel. He struck them and killed them with blood, frogs, gnats, dog flies, bad sores which break out in blisters; (and he struck) their cattle with death; and with hailstones, with these he annihilated everything that was growing for them; with locusts which ate whatever was left for them from the hail; with darkness; (and with the death of) their firstborn of men and cattle. The Lord took revenge on all their gods and burned them up. Everything was sent through you, before it was done, so that you should do (it). You were speaking with the king of Egypt and in front of all his servants and his people. Everything happened by your word. Ten great and severe pun ishments came to the land of Egypt so that you could take revenge on it for Israel. The Lord did everything for the sake of Israel and in accord with his covenant which he made with Abraham to take revenge on them just as they were enslaving them with force" (Jub. 48:4-8). Jub. retells briefly Exod 7:14-12:36. If some early Jewish traditions influenced the trans lation in LXX, it is very difficult to link them with Jub. On a detailed comparison be tween the Hebrew text and LXX, see below p. 70 and 99.
The events in Egypt are retold in an interesting way. The preceding mira cles are omitted in the heavily abridged account (but see Jub. 48:9-12). He fixes the number of plagues at ten, unlike, for example, in Artapanus and the order is only slightly changed (boils and hail are listed in reverse order, cf. Exod 9:14-35). The writer returns to the death of the firstborn in telling about Passover (Jub. 49:1-16). The dialogues between Pharaoh and Moses are only briefly summarised, but the words attest the character of a mani festation: Moses speaks in public and everything happens by his word (cf. m m in Sir 45:3). The dialogues between God and Moses are omitted, which is not a coin cidence in Jub. God is sovereign while the angels act as his agents: It is the Angel of Presence who talks with Moses in Jub. and retells everything to a man who was present all the time and an important part of the events. God does not speak with Moses, and Aaron is not even mentioned. The roots of the development can be traced to the Hebrew text of the Old Testament, where the roles of God and his angels are unclear enough to open the door to different interpretations. Exodus tells how God revealed himself to Moses at Horeb: while Exod 3:4 tells expressis verbis about God speaking to Moses; Exod 33:11 has D^Erta era, but Exod 3:2 has yba 62
63
tion or competition with the teachers was not necessary in an anti-Hellenistic work! On Moses' early years in LXX, see below p. 92. See below p. 99. The dialogues between God and Moses are often removed in the retold versions; see Artapanus below p. 105, Philo p. 112, Josephus p. 234. 6 2
6 3
56
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
In Exod 14 God is active, but Dvr^Kn ybn also occurs in Exod 14:19. LXX replaces God with ayyeAos Kupi'ou in Exod 4:23, which is not un usual (see Job 20:15). mm.
65
The substitution o f angels for God in LXX provided a context for Jub's version of the stories. The main school of thought in Jewish theology, al ready attested in the fragments of Aristobulus, considered God's anthro pomorphic features increasingly difficult and distanced him from the hu man world, letting angels take the role as communicators with men. Various functions were attributed to different angels - such as Iaoel, Raphael or Zervihel. It is thus understandable that all of God's dialogues with Moses are removed in Jub. as most Jewish writers - but not all! either diminished or removed the dialogues between God and men in the miracle stories. The "Angel of Presence" is a good example of early Jew ish angelology as a device to reduce God's anthropomorphic features and to distance him from the human spheres, which, in addition to the drastic reshaping of the roles of God and man, necessitated extensive changes in the retold stories. 67
68
69
70
Mastema, who attacked Abraham, could not, of course, leave Moses alone: "The prince of Mastema would stand up against you and wish to make you fall into the pharaoh's power. He would help the Egyptian magicians and they would oppose (you) and perform in front of you. We permitted them to do evil things, but we would not allow healings to be performed by them. When the Lord struck them with bad sores, they were unable to oppose (you) because we deprived them of (their) ability to perform a single sign" (Jub. 48:9-10).
Mastema was also active in the last events of the exodus: "On the fourteenth day, the fifteenth, the sixteenth, the seventeenth, and the eighteenth the prince Mastema was bound and locked up behind the Israelites so that he could not accuse them. On the nineteenth day we released them so that they could help the Egyp tians and pursue the Israelites. He stiffened their resolve and made them stubborn. They were made stubborn by the Lord our God so that he could strike the Egyptians and throw them into the sea. On the fourteenth day we bound him so that he could not accuse the Israelites on the day when they were requesting utensils and clothing from the Egyptians - utensils of silver, utensils of gold, and utensils of bronze; and so that they could plun-
6 4
On m,T -jtfra. see Michl 1962, 61-68. See below p. 57. See Birnbaum 2003, 315-317. See Hengel 1991,231-233. On the different angels, see Michl 1962, 65-68. L.A.B. interestingly enough adds such dialogues; see below p. 196. On Ezekiel, see p. 66, on Artapanus, see p. 105, on Philo, see p.l 12, on Josephus, see p. 234. 6 5
6 6
6 7
6 8
69
7 0
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
57
der the Egyptians in return for the fact that they were made to work when they enslaved them by force. We did not bring the Israelites out of Egypt empty-handed" (Jub. 48:1519).
It was thus Mastema who was Moses' real opponent in Egypt and the mov ing power behind the Egyptian sorcerers. Moses and the sorcerers were only servants who were supported by their masters. The war between pow ers is thus present again. Although Moses did not act as a BNP in Exodus, his role is now reduced. He is no longer an MNP and hardly even a PNP. The angels ("we") have absorbed his role almost completely. 71
72
Mastema takes on an interesting role in the stories about Moses and Is rael. He has to be bound while the Israelites take the booty; otherwise his accusations would apparently prevent the plunder. When he is bound, Is rael can leave Egypt; on the other hand, he and his demons have to be freed so the Egyptians can be punished. God is almighty, but Mastema is necessary; yet, his accusations are dangerous and the good angels must both bind and free him. Mastema already has a similar role in the stories about Abraham: When Gen 22 tells how God tested Abraham, Jub. makes it Mastema's plot. What Abraham does he does before an angel and Mastema, who feel shame at seeing Abraham's faith (Jub. 17:15-18:19). His role is still more irrational in the stories about Moses: It was not rrnra who was sent by God (as in Exod 12:23), to kill the firstborn in Egypt, but Mastema (Jub. 49:2). On the other hand, Mastema calls the Egyptians to pursue Israel (Jub. 48:12). According to Exod 4:24-26 God was about to kill Moses, who was saved by Zipporah. LXX replaces God with dc'yyeAos xupiou in Exod 4:24 mm vnwsn / auvrjvTrjaev auxco ayyeAos Kupiou The Book of Jubilees attributes this attempt to Mastema: 73
74
75
76
71
77
Moses' opponents are mentioned only briefly. On their role in Philo, see above p. 113 and 134; in Artapanus p. 100, and in Josephus p. 236. It is understandable that the stories about Jannes and Jambres serving evil powers were told according to traditions similar to Jub., where the real opponent was Mastema. See Eve 2002, 157-159. See also Bonneau - Duhaine 1996, 346-348. "Them" in Jub. 48:16 points to demons (Berger 1981, 545; VanderKam 1989b, 314). JTITOD is mentioned in 2 Sam 24:15-17 and 1 Chr 21:14-17 and also in 4Q511. A list shedding light on the demonic world in Qumran is in 11Q11,2, 3-4 (see Alexander 1999, 332). On notDOD see above p. 50. E.g. Ezekiel the Tragedian follows the biblical presentation faithfully and sees here God's angel (Ezek. Trag. 159). "You were eating the Passover in Egypt when all the forces of Mastema were sent to kill every firstborn in the land of Egypt - from the pharaoh's firstborn to the firstborn of the captive slave-girl at the millstone and to the cattle as well" (Jub. 49:2). 7 2
7 3
7 4
7 5
7 6
7 7
58
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
"You know who spoke to you at Mount Sinai and what the prince of Mastema wanted to do to you while you were returning to Egypt - on the way at the shady fir tree. Did he not wish with all his strength to kill you and to save the Egyptians from your power because he saw that you were sent to carry his power" (Jub. 48:2-3).
Although Jub. was originally written in Hebrew, it is tempting to see a historical development: the Hebrew Scripture could already occasionally use God and God's angel interchangeably. LXX takes the next step by re placing God with God's angel in order to reduce God's anthropomorphic features: Aristobulus' fragments show that this kind of theology existed in the early second century. It also opened the way for Jub.'s interpretation that it was neither God nor his good angel but Mastema, a bad spirit. An interesting parallel attesting the theological wrestling with evil even earlier is that the Chronicler reinterpreted 2 Sam 24:1 in an analogous way and replaced God with Satan in 1 Chr 21:1. Mastema / Satan is thus clearly a factor used to explain the difficulties in the text of the Old Testament or to remove the elements that could be in terpreted as the dark parts of God. Mastema is a controversial and irra tional figure, but Israel's God is not. It is typical of Jewish demonology that the war between good and evil may be severe, but it does not detract from God's sovereignty. In the old est texts of the Old Testament Satan plays the role of the heavenly accuser. The Booh of Jubilees has preserved the thought that Mastema / Satan serves God the Almighty and is on a mission from him. Some early Jewish texts have made things easier by denying this mission, a feature distin guishing Jub. from the developed cosmic dualism present in Qumran. It is also the answer to the question of why the fallen angels and demons are mentioned so rarely in Jub. VanderKam justly notes that the fallen angels are absent, for instance, in Gen 3, retold in Jub. 3, and considers the theme much less dominant in Jub. than in 1 En} Yet, Mastema and his troops do exist to lead the people astray according to God's plan, and this is why they cannot be totally rooted out (Jub. 10:7-9; 15:31-32). They have, how ever, no right to torment the righteous, only the "sons of Beliar" (Jub. 15:33). The miracles are now part of this strange type of war. God has allowed Mastema / Beliar to rule the Gentiles, who have no pro tection against being misled to idolatry and sinfulness by the demons (see 78
79
80
81
1
7 8
Berger 1981, 282; Wintermute 1985, 47-48; Steudel 2000, 339-340; VanderKam 2001,99-100. The early rabbinic tradition gives Satan a less prominent role; see Becker 2002, 172175. On this topic, see Alexander 1999, 341-344; Steudel 2000, 336-339. See above p. 51. VanderKam 1999, 153-154. 7 9
8 0
81
8 2
59
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
Jub. 7:27; 11:4-5). Mastema's mission is to lead astray the Egyptians at the Red Sea (Jub. 15:31; 48:12). Israel, on the contrary, is ruled by God and his angels and is protected from the evil spirits (Jub. 15:32). Abraham gives up idolatry and is saved from evil spirits (Jub. 12:19-20). Joseph's rule means that there was no Satan or evil in Egypt (Jub. 40:10; 46:2), and that will also be the destiny of the purified Israel (Jub. 50:5). The holy spirit will once purify Israel (Jub. 1:23). In the present, however, Beliar is a constant threat in his attempts to seduce Israel (see Jub. 1:20; 1:19; 1:28). The Israelites are thus in continual danger and need protection. The Book of Jubilees' reinterpretation of the biblical miracles is clear and interesting. What the work tells us about Abraham and his battle is not totally new, but it is a reinterpretation. The entire story of Moses and his work in Egypt is heavily revised and put into a new framework. Pharaoh and his troops are no longer Moses' real opponents; now it is Mastema. Moses' role is now changed, although already in Exod he was only God's servant and not an independent actor. Some Jewish texts (Artapanus, Pseudo-Philo and Josephus) give Moses a more independent role, but not The Book of Jubilees. In the reinterpretation in Jub. both struggling sides have a powerful master behind them. God supports Moses and Israel while Mastema supports the Egyptians, resulting in a war between the good and evil powers. This war is the theological framework for the biblical mira cles. The theology we meet in The Book of Jubilees is also well known else where, especially in the early Dead Sea scrolls, which go further. Frey in particular emphasizes that it is "crude oversimplification to conflate the dualisms of the War Rule and of the instruction on the two spirits into a single type of 'Qumran dualism'." A further definition is needed, and he differentiates between ten different kinds of dualism. According to Frey the early Jewish form was a multidimensional pattern consisting of cosmic, ethical and psychological elements; however, the later texts in Qumran attest that the ethical and especially psychological elements were weak ened or totally removed and all that was important was to belong to the correct group, i.e. to the Community. But how does this pattern fit Jub., especially its miracle stories? 83
84
85
8 3
See Hengel 1991,218-224. Frey 1997, 280-284. The main kinds occurring here are 1) cosmological dualism supposing the cosmic division of the world and of humanity into two opposing forces of good and evil, darkness and light 2) ethical dualism supposing two mutually exclusive groups according to virtues and vices and 3) psychological dualism internalising the contrast between good and evil. Frey 1997, 275-335. 8 4
8 5
60
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
It is difficult to find traces of psychological dualism in the miracle sto ries elsewhere in Jub. Admittedly, Abraham faces a hard struggle in the crucial moment he leaves the false gods (Jub. 12:16-21), but the miracleworking Abraham and Moses do not fight the evil or weakness in their hearts, although the biblical version of the reluctant Moses would have offered support for this interpretation. The ethical side is present in Jub. 10, where spirits under Mastema's rule lead foreign peoples astray and Noah learns how to block them, or even when Abraham is tested. The miracle stories, however, attest only cosmic dualism: Mastema uses his angels, but expands his rule also to the Pharaoh, Egyptian sorcerers and soldiers. It is not difficult to draw the line between the good and bad sides, be they spirits or men. Although the idea of a multidimensional pattern of dualistic views works well in Jub., the cosmic side is strongly emphasized in the miracle stories. The war between good and evil powers is present, although not as force fully as in the later texts of Qumran, which also occasionally deal with the biblical miracle stories. CD, quoting and approving Jub.} shows that the war was applied to Moses: 6
"For in ancient times there arose Moses and Aaron, by the hand of the prince of lights and Belial, with his cunning, raised up Jannes and his brother during the first deliverance of Israel" (CD 5,17-19). 87
We do not have numerous examples of the way that the community in Qumran used the biblical miracle stories, but what we have shows that Jub. 's reinterpretation of the stories about Abraham and Moses was, of course, not alien to the community. It is understandable, that i) many looked to the past, beyond the present evil leaders of their people to the glorious history which defined the nation and ii) they looked upon the he roes of the nation anew as forerunners of the war between the powers. Some smaller details were certainly already traditional in the times of Jub. An interesting nonbiblical detail is that God took revenge on all Egyptian gods and burned them (apparently their statues). Artapanus relates a similar fact, namely that because of the plague of hail and earthquakes most of the temples collapsed (Artap. 3,33). It is a common feature in early Judaism that the disasters in Egypt were God's justified punishment for all that the Egyptians had done to his people and it occurs repeatedly in Jub} 88
9
8 6
See VanderKam 1977, 255-258. On the dualism in CD, see Frey 1997, 303-306. Wintermute 1985, 139. Charles translates "all their idols the Lord took vengeance and burned them with fire" (1902, 251). The idea occurs again in Jub. 48:14 and Jub. 48:15-18. Ius talionis is very common in L.A.B. (see below p. 194). 8 7
8 8
8 9
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
61
This time God's promise to Abraham in Gen 15:14 offers a solid biblical background. The angels permitted Moses' opponents to do "evil things", i.e. repeat some of the plagues, but prevented their attempt to heal the bad sores Exod 9:11 only says that "they could not stand before Moses". The heavily abridged story suggests that the Egyptian magicians not only tried to emu late the plagues, as in Exod, but also to stop them. Actually, Jannes was sought to help the Egyptians resist Moses in Jan. Jam. 26 and T. Sol. 25, and the Neoplatonist Numenius wrote that Jannes and Jambres could ob struct all of Moses' miracles in Egypt (Eus. praep. ev. 9,8). Thus the men were also well known among the Gentiles (see Plin. nat. 30,11 and Apul. apol. 90,5). The tradition behind Jub. is obviously broader than the few references in the story would lead one to believe, and the midrashic fea tures attested in the texts quoted were clearly known to the writer. 90
The events at the Red Sea are retold briefly, but the story contains some important details. "Despite all the signs and miracles, the prince of Mastema was not put to shame until he gained strength and cried out to the Egyptians to pursue you with all the Egyptian army with their chariots, their horses - and with all the throng of the Egyptian people. I stood between you, the Egyptians, and the Israelites. We rescued the Israelites from his power and from the power of the people. The Lord brought them out through the middle of the sea as if on dry ground. All of the people whom he brought out to pursue the Israelites the Lord our God threw into the sea - to the depths of the abyss - in place of the Israel ites, just as the Egyptians had thrown their sons into the river. He took revenge on 1,000,000 of them. 1,000 men (who were) strong and also very brave perished for one infant of your people whom they had thrown into the river" (Jub. 48:12-14). Jub. summarises Exod 13:17-14:31. On a detailed comparison of the biblical story in the Hebrew text and in LXX, see below p. 74.
Mastema, of course, is again scheming and calls the Egyptians to war. God's angel mentioned in Exod 14:19-20 is now identified as the Angel of Presence, who is talking with Moses ("I stood"). The roles are not easy to distinguish: The angel says "we rescued the Israelites", but implied that it was the Lord who brought them out of Egypt and threw the Egyptians into the sea. While it is unclear what God had done directly, and what he had done indirectly through his angels, it is clear that Moses' role is heavily reduced: he now listens to the angel's report on what really happened at the Red Sea. There are no desperate people crying to Moses, no Moses dividing the sea and no reaction of the Egyptians. It is God and his angels who are fighting against evil powers; human beings are the less important 9 0
In L.A.B. 47,1 some manuscripts read Jambres, but apparently Zambri in manuscript M is correct, see Dietzfelbinger 1979, 227; Jacobson 1996, 1045.
62
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
actors. The numbers of Egyptians are a nonbiblical detail common with Ezekiel the Tragedian (Ezek. Trag. 203).
d. Conclusion The Book of Jubilees tells about the miracles of Abraham and Moses, the two most important figures of Israel. Although the stories are not extensive compared with the entire work, the miracles are by no means unimportant in Jub. The biblical stories are reinterpreted and put into the new frame work of a battle between good and evil powers. This is worth a closer look, and other Jewish texts also connect miracles and this war in a similar man ner. It is a typical Jewish feature, which did not originate from Greek thought, in which the necessary elements did not exist. There was no God and Satan, as in the Jewish religion in its many variants. This is a crucial difference with regard to Greek thought, and its background should be sought from the East, not from the West. The war between good and evil powers is an important element in Jub., but the writer has not followed the characteristic course for the developed forms of dualism in the Qumran. Mastema and the fallen angels are absent in the retold Gen 3, and, above all, Mastema is on a mission from God, which was often denied in the Qumran. However, Jub. is an important step towards a theology in which a man is a target of attacks by the evil powers. Mastema's accusations are a constant threat to Abraham, Moses and the people they lead, and the war goes on: Healing is permitted or prohibited, the vessels are given or not given, the Egyptians are led to war against Is rael but blocked by the good powers. The function of the miracle is thus multifaceted in the story in the Jubilees. Apparently the contemporization of the miracle stories concerns the in dividual as well as the entire people. Moses even more than Abraham is the model of a good Jew who obeys God's voice when in difficulty and is consequently attacked by evil but protected by good powers. The way of Abraham and Moses should also be the way of the readers of Jub. The test may be hard, but the righteous is not left alone, not even in the turbulent times of the second century BC. The traditional thought of legitimisation through miracles can also be discerned clearly: Moses' miracles are a manifestation of God's power, but the idea of legitimisation is even more emphatic with Abraham. Through his rejection of idols and his prayers to the Creator, the new religion is legitimised by his marvellous power to control the demons and to help mankind. The location of the story of Abraham's conversion is not fortui-
3. Miracles and the War between Powers: The Book of Jubilees
63
tous. When Terah, Abraham's father, was born, Mastema sent ravens to devastate the country (Jub. 11:9-13). Then Abraham is born and he begins to pray to the Creator, soon after which he expels the ravens sent by Mastema (Jub. 11:18-24). The miracle manifests the truth of the new relig ion. The story, however, may also have another function. Abraham, the fa ther, was not the only man who was willing to control the demons. He was one link in the long chain of history. The legend was told not simply be cause of an antiquarian interest, or for entertainment, but because the chain was still in effect during the times in which Jub. was written. There were clearly Jews in the early second century who were thought to be able to control demons. It is conceivable, even probable, that the reinterpreted father of the nation served as their patron. Our only regret is that because of their brevity, the short stories in Jub. do not tell more. Yet they contain many details later common in Jewish texts. Firstly, the Angel of Presence indicates that God is now at a distance and the angels have taken the role of communicators between God and men. Secondly, this figure is early evidence of different angels being given dif ferent tasks in God's kingdom. Thirdly, Abraham acts as an exorcist in Jub., but also in IQAp Gen™ and in The Apocalypse of Abraham. An inter esting feature is that Jub., a text critical of the Hellenistic reforms, makes use of the classical rrpcoTOS 6upr|Trjs-motif.
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian a. Introduction 1
The miraculous departure from Egypt was treated by Ezekiel in the form of a drama named Exagoge. The exact date of the work cannot be deter mined with certainty. Ezekiel uses the Septuagint, which roughly sets the terminus post quern. His 269 verses known to us are quoted by Eusebius (praep. ev. 9,28-29) and partly (verses 7-40) also by Clement of Alexan dria (strom. 1,23,155-156) and Pseudo-Eustathius (v. 256-269 in Commentarius in Hexaemeron PG 18,729), who used the lost work of Alexander Polyhistor (about 50 BC). Scholars have proposed several dates for vari ous reasons, but no general agreement has been found. Irina Wandrey and John J. Collins, for example, see no possibility for a more exact dating than those presented above. The work does not only interest theologians. No other Hellenistic trag edy is preserved so extensively, which means that Ezekiel also is an aid 2
3
4
5
6
7
1
The play apparently was not the only one written by Ezekiel, because Clement o f Alexandria calls him ' E£rjKif]Aos o TCOV ' IOUSOUKCOV TpaycoSicSv Troir)Trjs (Clem. Alex, strom. 1,23,153). On Ezekiel and his work see Snell 1971, 170-193; Jacobson 1983, 5-13; Vogt 1983, 115-118; Nickelsburg 1984b, 125-130, Holladay 1989, 329; Gauly et al. 1991, 217-218; Barclay 1992, 34-37; Barclay 1996, 132-138; Collins 2000a, 224-230. Many Jewish texts treated in the present study were long forgotten by scholars, but not many were as sorely neglected as Exagoge. His verses were edited and commented on by L.M. Philippson in 1830 and by Joseph Wieneke in 1931. However, the play never played a great role in scholarship. August Nauck (1889) excluded Ezekiel in his famous edition of Greek tragic fragments; see Vogt 1983, 118-120 and Jacobson 1983, 1-2. The evidence is clear and it was well known already in the first half of 19 century; see Jacobson 1983, 40-41. On Alexander Polyhistor see Montanari 1996, 478-479. Wandrey 1998, 354; Collins 2000a, 225. Fraser argues for the latter part of the third century in his famous Ptolemaic Alexandria (1972, 707). Vogt mentions the alleged visi tation of the phoenix during the reign of Ptolemy III Euergetes and considers it a possible help for dating the tragedy (1983, 117). Robertson dates it to the first half of the second century (1985, 803-804) and Jacobson to the second (1983, 5-13). Holladay leaves the problem open within the period mentioned (1989, 308-312). Vogt, strangely enough, doubts whether the drama can be called a tragedy ("... kann freilich kaum als eine Tragodie im engeren Sinne des Wortes gelten, auch wenn es bei Eusebios einmal als solche bezeichnet wird", Vogt 1983, 115). Nevertheless, very few have doubted that Aeschylus' Persians, clearly a model for Ezekiel (see below p. 79-80) 2
3
4
5
6
th
65
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
to understanding the tradition of Greek tragedy. That the work happens to be written by a Jew apparently living in Alexandria makes the situation very complicated and challenging. No one has found a convincing answer to the questions of the intended audience of this play, or whether it was ever performed. Some passages led Collins to suppose that Ezekiel repre sented a less exclusive form of the Jewish religion. According to him, Eze kiel dropped the obligation of circumcision when speaking about the Pass over (v. 175-192), and he also mentions that Zipporah was given to a "stranger", i.e. Moses (v. 67). The present study may provide material for a further discussion. Traditionally Exagoge is considered a rather clumsy work, but recent scholarship has revised this judgement. Bruno Snell, an expert in Greek poetry and metrics, investigated the play and considered it to be much bet ter than its reputation. The most important studies are the commentaries written by Howard Jacobson (1983), and Holladay (1989), comple mented by a review of Jacobson's study by Pieter W. van der Horst. The main disagreement between Jacobson and van der Horst concerns the in9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
is a tragedy, although it, like Exogoge, describes the triumph over a hostile army. Van der Horst does not totally rule out the possibility that the work is a pseudonym, because he considers vv. 68-69 evidently based upon the first chapter of the Book of Ezekiel (1984b, 355-356). Ezekiel is often studied by scholars with a strong Judaistic background, although often even by those with a solid classical education, such as Jacobson. However, e.g. the studies of Snell (1971, 170-193) and Gauly et al. (1991, 216-219) give a fresh view of people usually dealing with classical drama. Neither Vogt (1983, 117) nor van der Horst (1984b, 357) will exclude Kuiper's old suggestion from 1900 that the writer was a Samaritan. There may be some similarities between Exagoge and Memar Marqa, but why should a Samaritan have chosen the name of the famous prophet from Judah? Although the view is mostly accepted, it is not unproblematic, because we have no direct evidence for it and Ezekiel seems to make some mistakes in Egyptian geography. See Jacobson 1983, 13-17; Holladay 1989, 312-313; van der Horst 1984, 357; Robertson 1985, 804. Collins 2000a, 225-226; see also Gruen 1998, 129. Schiirer was not as merciless as some others: "Sprache und Verse (jambische Trime ter) sind leidlich flieBend" (3 [1909], 502). Ezekiel's tragedy was at one time almost ridiculed in the research, and echoes of this are still audible in e.g. Fraser 1972, 708, but in more recent times his skill has received recognition; see Jacobson 1983, 2-3. Snell sees another difficulty in almost all verses with a metrical problem, and doubts if the text is correct. "Also ist die Metrik Ezechiels besser als ihr Ruf und wir konnen getrost manche Anomalien wegkonjizieren" (Snell 1967, 31-32). A similar judgement in Strugnell 1967, 449-457. The Exagoge of Ezekiel, 1983. Jacobson's translation is used in the present study. Pages 301-529 in Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors 2 (1989). "Some Notes on the Exagoge of Ezekiel", 1984. 7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
66
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
terpretation of Moses' vision, now very current among the scholarship investigating early Christology. The drama is named' E^aycoyrj, not "E£o5os, and although it is obvious that Ezekiel made use of the Septuagint, it is not clear whether the title was intentionally changed or not. If it was intentional, the idea of people at taining freedom would be replaced with the idea of God or Moses, or both, giving them freedom. It is thus not surprising that the miracles have a sig nificant role in the extant verses. 18
b. The dialogue at the burning bush Ezekiel lets Moses briefly tell about his childhood and early years (Exod 1:1-2:25 / Ezek. Trag. 1-58). The first passage dealing with miracles shows Moses in a dialogue with God, who reveals himself in the burning bush (Exod 3:1-4:17). The passage also contains the biblical miracles of the rod as snake and the leprous hand. 19
0
21
"God: What is that in your hands? Speak quickly. Moses: A rod wherewith to chastise beasts and men. God: Throw it on the ground and withdraw quickly. For it shall turn into a fearsome snake and you will marvel at it. Moses: There, I have thrown it. Oh, Master, be merciful. How dreadful, how monstrous. Have pity on me. I shudder at the sight, my limbs tremble. God: Have no fear. Reach out your hand and seize its tail. It shall turn back into a rod. Now put your hand into your bosom and withdraw it. Moses: There, I've done it. It's become like snow. God: Put it back into your bosom and it shall be as it was before" (Ezek. Trag. 120-131). The Septuagint renders the text in Exod 3:1-4:17 quite faithfully, however, with several interesting details and even with some important deviations. Some smaller deviations may reveal the complicated history of the Hebrew text, but they are of no importance to the present theme. LXX omits •'n'wn "in in 3:1 and renders 17
See below p. 81-86. Both'E£ayeoyrj, and"E£o6os occur as titles of the biblical book. Philo uses E£aycoyrj in Migr. 14, Her. 14 and Somn. 1,117. The divine voice of Dionysos appears in Euripides' Bacchae 576 sqq, and the early comedies, such as Aristophanes' Frogs, put him on the stage, (on gods in classical plays, see Snell 1971, 179). Some scholars have considered it impossible for a Jew to insert the voice of Israel's God into a drama. On this discussion, see Jacobson 1983, 19-20 and below, p. 77-79. On the theophany at the burning bush, see Jacobson 1983, 97-112; Holladay 1989, 451-478. On the leprous hand, see below p. 72. 18
19
2 0
21
67
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian 22
-En in 3:4 with T! EOXIV, and the names of the peoples are changed (3:8). It is certainly a contextualization that 'wier "op? is consistently rendered with yepouoia (3:16; 3:18; even 4:30). LXX does not use oPeTv but has EuAa(3E?xo in 3:6. Some details common to both versions must also be noted. LXX has preserved some anthropomorphic traits of God, which were later problematic for Philo: God utters the word TIK / KccTePnv to help the oppressed people (3:8) and his wrath is mentioned (4:14). The rather strange 4:8 nan b^-> is rendered with xfjs (t>covf]s xou a n u s i o u : Rengstorf thought that the words might point to the wider range of Moses' miracles, but also Exod 20:18 has rftpn n« D'tn nvn (LXX ecopa xrjv ^covrjv), and these odd wordings were noted in early Judaism. The words the Hebrew text uses for miracles are translated quite consistently here, as well as in the other parts of Exodus analysed in the present study. arjueTov (3:12; 4:30), common already in profane Greek, is the standard translation of nu* in LXX. rm I arjUEiov is not only an extraordinary event, but it points in the correct direction. mtfjsa (from tfra) is translated into S a u u d a i a (Exod 3:20). The Hebrew word refers mainly to God's saving deeds in the past (also in Job 37:14). It does not necessarily mean a break ing of what we term the laws of nature; it indicates that God helps in a hopeless situation, in a very "natural" way. nsiD does not occur in this passage, but in Exod 4:21, where it is translated as x s p a s . It is common in profane Greek as the adjective X E p d c x i o v . In 23
24
25
26
27
28
LXX, Tepas is a translation of nsiQ in 34 of 38 occurrences in LXX a translation of nsia, 29
but a derivation offc^alies behind it on t w o occasions (Exod 15:11; Jos 28:29). In ex tra-biblical Greek x l p a s means 'sign', 'wonder', 'marvel' or 'portent', something which is TTcepd <|>uoiv. LXX uses the word in peculiar way: XEpas, as the original Hebrew nsia, is given by God. The words orjueTa Kai XEpaxa may also occur in extra-biblical Greek (Polyb. 3,112,18; Plut. Alex. 75,1 706 a-b), but are used in an interesting way in LXX. D^riDiDi mrm appears in Israel's credo in Deut 26:5-11: "So the Lord brought us out of Egypt with a mighty hand and an outstretched arm, with great terror and with miracu lous signs and wonders" (LXX: ev orjueiots Kai EV XEpaaiv, Deut 26:8). In LXX the phrase onus? a Kai x l p a x a is reserved for Moses and his miracles. 30
31
32
A detail worth noting is the translation in 4:6 and 4:7. In the first verse LXX has omit ted the word runxo and has only EyEvrjBn f| xsip auxoG cooei xicov. Consequently 4:7 has i\s xrjv xpocxv xf]s aapKos auxou. Jacobson noted the deviation and regarded it as
a well-considered alteration: Many pagan authors attested the anti-Jewish version of exodus, according to which the Hebrews were expelled from the country because of the pestilence in Egypt. It is no wonder that the translators avoided the words AETrpa and
2 2
The Septuagint often modernizes names of biblical places and peoples; see Siegert 2000,21. Rengstorf 1964, 210. See also Deut 5:24. See Jacobson 1983, 99-100. See Liddell - Scott s.v. arjUETov. See Rengstorf 1964, 199-268. mK is almost always translated into oriUE?ov. On the other hand, in about 80% of the occurrences, ma lies behind criUE?ov. See Albertz 1984, 416-420. 2 3
2 4
2 5
2 6
2 7
2 8
See Liddell - Scott s.v. X E p a s , XEpdoxtov.
2 9
Rengstorf 1969, 117-118. Aristot. gen. an 770b; Rengstorf 1969, 115. See Rengstorf 1969, 113-127. Rengstorf 1964,219-220.
3 0
31
3 2
68
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian 33
34
Aoiuos. In the same manner ~a~i ("bubonic plague") is in 9:3 rendered as 8dvaTos. Jacobson is apparently right, because the distorted version of the exodus is well attested among the Jews as well as the Gentiles. However, the Jews who retold the Scripture did not necessarily avoid the word Aoiuos, although one would except them to have done 35
In retelling the miracles, Ezekiel follows LXX: However, he has SpccKcov instead of 6$\s used in Exod 4:3: Both words fit the iambic trimetre, but the writer has preferred the word used in Exod 7:9-12. Instead of a leprous hand, Ezekiel has the hand coorrEpei x»cov. Whether Ezekiel intentionally avoided Aeirpa and A O I M O S or only followed LXX (cooei X ^ ) chose eooTrepsi because of the metre is another question. The fragment breaks off and there is no evidence of the third miracle, namely, when God tells Moses to take water from the Nile and throw it on the ground (Exod 4:9). This miracle may have been included in the origi nal play, but we cannot be sure. In his introductory comment on 120-131 Polyhistor said: "And concerning the rod and other wonders, he speaks thus in dialogue." Jacobson takes the word Kai TCOV a'AAeov TepaTcov as evidence of a third miracle, presuming that the water Moses threw on the ground turned to blood. This is possible, and Josephus includes this de tail (Ant 2,273), but it is speculative, because Polyhistor may also have in mind the list of miracles later referred to by God. Although precisely these verses do not tell about the reluctant, biblical Moses willing to reject the call, and about Aaron being needed as his helper, both elements are included in the previous verses (Ezek. Trag. 114119); Moses even says that he is not eloquent (v. 113-115). Aaron is often omitted from the retold stories, but Ezekiel is remarkably faithful to the biblical original, although neither Aaron's miracles nor his rod are men tioned in the verses we have. In Ezekiel, Moses is not concerned with how to make the Hebrews be lieve, but with how to convince the Pharaoh (cf. Exod 4:29-5 A). Jacobson sees here as well as in Exod. R. 3,16 a bias to exonerate Israel, but al though this possibility cannot be excluded, there is also another and per haps more plausible explanation. In Exodus the miracles serve to legiti,c
v
a n a <
37
38
39
40
3 3
See Jacobson 1983, 106-107; Holladay 1989, 468-469, and below p. 231. On the word "n~i see below p. 71. See below p. 231. See below pp. I l l and 239. See below p. 72. Jacobson 1983, 102-104. See p. 55, 128 and 235. Jacobson 1983, 101. However, he offers a reconstruction of the tragedy and supposes that Moses has met with the elders of the people (1983, 35). I do not see how it is thus possible to exclude the difficulties with the Hebrews. 3 4
35
3 6
3 7
3 8
3 9
4 0
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
69
mate Moses to his own people. Such a legitimisation was generally no longer needed in the Jewish texts studied in the present work, and espe cially not before Moses' own people. His position was strong and needed no justification. Simultaneously it means that the miracles have lost their original function and perhaps have found new ones, or are simply omitted as here. This is an argument, although perhaps a weak one, for the view that the play was not intended for a Gentile audience. It is interesting that Moses is not presented as in Artapanus: a calm man untouched by the events; instead, as in Exodus, he is described as being afraid of the snake and trembling. Apparently one reason is that Ezekiel wants to enhance the dramatic quality of the scene; yet he has also pre served Moses' words about not being a good speaker. The human traits of the leader are significant. Here he is by no means a BNP, or even an MNP or PNP; he is only a terrified man - as in Exod 4. Thus, although many Jewish writers avoided it, Ezekiel, following the biblical Exodus, presents God in a dialogue with Moses. Jub. introduces the "Angel of Presence" to tell Moses of the events, Artapanus reduces God to a "divine voice", Philo rejects God's anthropomorphic features and sees an angel in the burning bush, and even Josephus is rather restricted. Ezekiel is different, but not the only one following the biblical original. L.A.B., a Palestinian text written in Hebrew, also does not hesitate to add this kind of material. There are two explanations for the path Ezekiel took. Philo acted from deep theological convictions as did apparently L.A.B. in the opposite direction. Can such reasons be Ezekiel's as well? The second possibility is obviously the more probable: Ezekiel merely faithfully followed the biblical original. 41
42
43
44
c. The plagues told in advance Unhappily we do not know how many verses there were before the frag ment containing verses 132-174 in the original play. In any case, God is speaking again to Moses and foretelling everything that shall happen be fore the freedom: 45
"With this rod you shall work all kinds of plagues.
41
On Ben Sira, see p. 26, on Artapanus, see p. 95, on L.A.B. p. 199. In Philo the theme is more complicated; see p. 155-156. Jacobson 1983,98. On Jub. see above p. 61, on Artapanus below p. 105, on Philo p. 112 and Josephus p. 234. See below p. 196. On the plagues, see Jacobson 1983, 112-121; Holladay 1989, 471-478. 4 2
4 3
4 4
4 5
70
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
First, the river, all the springs and pools will flow blood. I shall bring a multitude of frogs and lice upon the land Thereafter, I will sprinkle on them ashes from a furnace and fierce sores will erupt on their bodies. Flies will come and torment many of the Egyptians. Afterwards there will come in its turn a pestilence and all who possess hard hearts will die. Then I will make the heavens violent: hail mixed with fire will descend and lay men dead. Crops and animals will be destroyed. I will bring darkness for three whole days and will send locusts which will destroy all the remaining crops and the young shoots. And after all this I shall slay the firstborn children. Thus, I shall bring to an end the arrogance of this evil people. And king Pharaoh will not be persuaded by anything I say until he sees his firstborn son a corpse. Then in fear he will quickly send forth the people" (Ezek. Trag. 132-151). 46
Ezekiel summarises the plagues very briefly, but it is possible to follow up on the word ing in LXX in Exod 7:14-12:36. In the first plague (pi I cnua, Exod 7:14-24) the oppo nents (CTDtnn / ettcxoiSoi, 7:22) are mentioned as well as their means (•n D ?3 / <|)apuccKEiais), similarly in 8:3; 8:14; 9:12. Both the Masoretic text and LXX (7:15) refer to the rod which had once changed into a snake (c?m / 6c|>iv, not pn / 5pc(Kcov as in 7:10). LXX adds in 7:19 too ocSeX^co oou. In the plague of o-jmas / (BaTpocxoi (Exod 7:268:11). LXX has omitted o n s o fixrhv in v. 8:1, and a further alteration is rendering of WTfon mrro as ouk eotiv d'AAos TrAr|V Kupi'ou (8:6). The development is from monolatry to monotheism (cf. 9:14, where the translation follows the Hebrew text). The third plague (•» / okv?<|>es, Exod 8:12-15) is a faithful translation of the text we have. In the plague of 3iv I kuvouuioc (Exod 8:16-28) the Masoretic text is uncertain in 8:19 (ma or rfra / StaoToArjv); in 8:24 LXX adds irpos tov Kiipiov. In the fifth plague, in regard to live stock (Exod 9:1-11), ill is translated 0dvccTOs UEyas ac|>65pa (9:3). In the sixth plague (pro /eAiai, Exod 9:8-12) LXX adds the servants in v. 9:8. In the plague of nVTip /covai, ill I xdAa£a and m I nup (|>Aoy(£ov (Exod 9:13-35) LXX is concordant with MT. In the eighth plague (nma / ccKpi's, Exod 10:1-20) v. 10 is as unclear in LXX as in the He brew text, crip rrn is translated ofvsuos votos in 10:13. In the ninth plague (Exod 10:2129) the kind of darkness ("jon mi I vpTiAa(|)TiT6s okotos) is interesting. In the final plague (Exod 11:1-12:36) the most interesting detail is the subject of the plague, which is definitely God himself (11:4 / syco; 12:13 wrmtb *p - TTAriyr) tou EKTpipfivai). 47
,
l
48
49
The translation of Ezek. Trag. 149 given by Jacobson is apparently incorrect and I have replaced it with the line rendered by Holladay (1989, 379). ttei'oetou can be derived either from irdoxco, as Jacobson takes it, or from tte(0co, as he is well aware of (1983, 119-121). Exod relates that Pharaoh was personally struck by several plagues (8:4; 8:21; 9:14). Nevertheless, Jacobson chooses the first alternative, because it is supported by the later Jewish texts. On this question, see also Holladay 1989, 477. See also Propp 1998, 292-310. On the darkness, see Durham 1987, 141-143. Jub. attributes the deed to Mastema (see above p. 57). 4 7
4 8
49
71
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
All in all, the plagues are rendered very faithfully but with some interesting details, the most important being the word ion / 0dvaTos [liycxs o(|)65pa in 9:3. LXX consequently translates the Hebrew word 0dvccTos, and apparently Jer 15:2 already attests this inter pretation, non denotes a fatal pestilence, which comes upon men and domestic animals, but it is not possible to identify the precise disease. 50
Ezekiel summarises the plagues very briefly, but it is possible to follow up on the wording in LXX. di|ja, Exod 7:14-24, occurs in v. 133, p d r p a XOi in LXX Exod 7:26-8:11 is PaTpdxcov T E TTAf}0os (v. 135) and O K V T CJ>BS, Exod 8:12-15 OKVITTCXS EMPCXACO x 9 O V ( ( V . 135). Kuvofjuia is used as in LXX (Exod 8:16-28 / v. 138); the word A O I J J O S is used for the plague on livestock (Exod 9:1-11 LXX: 0dvccros uiycxs ac|>6Spa, v. 139-140). EAKTI, a w i t h LXX Exod 9:8-12 / v. 137 is EAKTJ TTiKpd. LXX x«^«C ™p ^Aoyi^ov (Exod 9:13-35) is in Ezekiel x « ^ a ^ a ... G U V Ttupt in v. 141142. aKp(5a TTOAATIV (Exod 10:1-20) is rendered ccKpi'Sas T E TTEJJ^CO (145-146), and ^TlAa^rjTos O K O T O S (Exod 10:21-29) is now only O K O T O S (v. 144). In the last plague (Exod 11:1-12:36) TrpcoxoxoKOs is changed to diroKTEvco ... TTpcoToyova (v. 147-148). Ezekiel thus adheres to the words of LXX very closely. The order of the plagues is slightly changed, but their number (ten) is preserved, although Fraser strangely refers to "the seven plagues". The order is changed: the boils plague, the sixth plague in Exodus, is fourth in Ezekiel and consequently KUVOJJUICX is the fifth and pestilence the sixth. The locusts and darkness have changed position. Unlike Philo, Ezekiel does not explain his new order. Jacobson tries to explain the changed order by referring to Philo, and indeed TTiKpdvco 5' oupccvov may indicate the intention to divide different plagues into different elements as Philo did. Yet, another and perhaps better explanation is also available: it was not easy to briefly render the plagues in metre. A good parallel example is Prudence, the Christian poet, who attempted to write the story of 18 Chris tian martyrs in verse, and realized that the names would not fit the metre. He elegantly apologised for his action (carminis leges amor aureorum / 51
52
53
54
nominum
parvi
facit,
et loquendi
/ cura
de Sanctis
vitiosa
non
est /
nec
4,165-168) and broke the metric rules. Similarly, Eze kiel had to change some words and their order if he was to retain the iam bic trimetre. Nevertheless, he followed the biblical original very closely, far more closely than many other Jewish writers included in the present study. However, some deviations may be important. rudis
5 0
51
5 2
53
5 4
umquam,
per.
Mayer 1978, 125-127. See also Holladay 1989, 471-480. Fraser 1972, 707. See below p. 114. Jacobson 1983, 115-117; see also Holladay 1989, 473-474.
72
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
The first plague is retold very briefly, and it is unnecessary to ask (as Jacobson does) why the fish do not die in Ezekiel. The entire story of Exo dus (Exod 7:14-24) is given only two lines and the frogs aiou^es and boils together only three: B A K T ] TTiKpcx is now limited only to men. K U V O M U I O C does not awaken interest, but when describing x^Aa£a ... auv n u p i Eze kiel adds the words TriKpdvco 5' oupavov. The phrase might possibly be connected with Philo's speculations on the different roles of the ele ments. Several Jewish writers, but not Ezekiel, describe the darkness as unconventional, being full of demonic beings. The final plague is limited only to men. The only really significant deviations are in the fifth biblical plague (Exod 9:1-11). Firstly, this plague, as well as two others, is limited to men. But secondly, it is strange that 0dvocTos a(|)65pa is rendered with A O I J J O S . Many scholars have observed that LXX has removed n i n ^ D in Exod 4:7 and periphrased pestilence with EyevTi0T) f] x^P C X U T O U coaei Xicov because of the anti-Jewish version of the exodus. It may be true, but it apparently does not mean that all early Jews considered the topic difficult. Although Ezekiel follows the words in Exod 4:7, he now goes in the opposite direction and freely adds A O I J J O S to his text. Why did Ezekiel choose this word? Gruen claims that the supposed negative version of Exodus is the result of the distorting lens of Josephus, and although this view is more than problematic, it seems that scholars have exaggerated the impact of anti-Jewish propaganda on the Jewish writers. Ezekiel does not avoid the key word that is supposed to have been problematic to the Jews, but Ezekiel has limited the plague to human victims (SavouvTon 5' ols evecrn KapSta O K A T I P C X ) . Jacobson cites Ps 78:50 LXX and some later Rabbinic texts allegedly harmonising two traditions, that the plague struck only humans or possibly animals, and suggests that Ezekiel was following a tradition. However, one cannot go beyond speculations. 55
56
57
58
59
60
Miracles are generally not easy to put into a drama, especially not the miracles described in Exodus, and Ezekiel understandably chose simple technical methods. That God enumerates the plagues in advance is a way to avoid the problems connected with dramatizing them. The transforma tion of events into speech is understandable and necessary. This transfor mation and the heavy abridgement necessarily lead to substantial changes, 61
Jacobson 1983, 114. See below p. 114. See below p. 238. See above p. 231-232. See below p. 231-232. Jacobson 1983, 117; see also Holladay 1989, 474. Jacobson 1983, 112-113; van der Horst 1984, 359.
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
73
especially in the roles of God, Moses and Aaron. It is no wonder that Aaron is absent (as in many Jewish texts), although he is mentioned ear lier, but the role of Moses is also greatly diminished. It is God who tells in advance what he is going to do. However, it is unnecessary to ask what Moses is in Kahl's terminology: The reduction of Moses' role is a literary device, which has resulted in a slight lack of consistency. Although God speaks to Moses of the plagues as his own deeds, the passage opens with God's words to him: sv TTJ5E pdpSco TrdvTa Troirjcreis KCXKCX ( V . 132). We do not have enough material at our disposal to be certain whether the supposed Jewish traditions already existed in Ezekiel's times, or whether they ever existed at all. One thing is certain: Ezekiel follows the Bible as faithfully as is possible for a tragedian, and with greater exactness than many others who retold the biblical events. The writer of Jub.,for example, takes more liberties with the text, as does Artapanus (see chapters 3 and 5). Jacobson rightly points out that there was no tradition preventing one from freely retelling Old Testament events, and that the beginnings of the midrashic tradition are already attested in LXX. 62
d. The miracle at the Red Sea In the two fragments mentioned above, God thus tells about the miracles in advance. However, an Egyptian messenger relates the great miracle at the Red Sea (cf. Exod 13:17-14:31) afterwards in the fragment containing verses 193-242. The messenger tells how the Egyptians pitched camp and awaited the coming battle eagerly: 63
"Then, divine wonders and portents began to occur. A large pillar, looking like a cloud, suddenly appeared and took up a position between our camp and that of the Hebrews. Then their leader Moses took the staff of God with which he had previously wrought the prodigies and plagues against Egypt and striking the surface of the Red Sea he split it in two. All of them rushed energetically and swiftly through the sea's pathway. We entered the path quickly, on their track. We hastened forward, but encountered night. Suddenly, the wheels of the chariots would not turn, as if they were bound fast. From the heavens came a great flash, as if of a fire. It seemed that God was helping them. When they had reached 6 2
6 3
Jacobson 1983, 18. See Jacobson 1983, 136-152.
74
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
the other side, a large wave surged around us. One man, on seeing this, cried out: 'Let us run back home and flee the power of the Supreme One. For He is helping them, but is wreaking our destruction.' Then the path was washed away and the army perished" (Ezek. Trag. 204-219). LXX has preserved in Exod 13:17-14:31 the very anthropomorphic view of God in v. 13:17. In v. 13:18 the Hebrew text has moom, but LXX nspnTrj 5e yeved. The literal translation of rrcn T D in 14:8 has led to the strange ev xeipi uv|;r)Arj. In 14:19 both texts have the angel ("ja^D / d'yyeAos). The Hebrew text in 14:20 is apparently corrupt (rr^rrriK -je?nm / Kai eyevexo OKOTOS Kai yvoc|>os, Kai SifjA0ev fj vu£ ). unp rrra nTtf is rendered ev dveuco VOTCO Piai'co in v. 21.
The words Ezekiel lets the messenger use for the miracles occur in 220221. eneiTa 0ei'eov dpxexai x e p a a x t c o v 0auudaT 'i5ea0ai
A short while later (224-226) Ezekiel tells about the rod of Moses XaPcov pdpSov 0eou TTJ 5rj irpiv A'lyuTrrcp KOKO ar|ue?a Kai x e p a T a e^eMrjoaTo. 64
The words used are not surprising at all. As seen above, the word orjijeTov is the standard translation of m» in LXX and T e p a s that of nsia. LXX translates DTiaiQi mniK as ar\[is\a Kai x e p a r a (Deut 26:8) and with these words refers to Moses' miracles. This is the language Ezekiel fol lows in his drama, both here and in the description of the burning bush, which is O T U J E T O V , xspaoTtov and a m o T i a (v. 90-93). 65
66
Although it may not be obvious at first, a closer study reveals that almost everything in Ezekiel has been told in Exod. The Egyptian troops could not pursue the Israelites because the cloud brought darkness (Exod 14:20), the Lord made their wheels stop, he looked down from the pillar of fire at the Egyptian army and the Egyptians cried out in fear (Exod 14:25-26). All is admittedly expressed now in a dramatic fashion, but only some details are additions or alterations. The question is, which of them are traditional and which are new. The speaker and the whole situation are already additions to the biblical narrative. Ezekiel, of course, again uses a device to dramatize the miracle, but does he represent a tradition? Philo and Josephus emphasize that there
6 4
6 5
6 6
See above p. 67. See Rengstorf 1969, 113-127. Rengstorf 1964,219-220.
75
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian 67
was not a single survivor, as if to rebuke a contradictory tradition. Jacobson supposes that both of them are critical of Ezekiel's play, but they apparently only repeat Exod 14:28, saying that there was no survivor (ou K(XTeAsi(|>0r| e£ C C U T C O V O U 5 E els). The number of Egyptians (a million in Ezekiel, v. 203) is a common, nonbiblical detail, but the Jewish writers disagree on the number. Josephus has a detailed account of the troops, but Jub. agrees with Ezekiel (Jub. 48:14). It is understandable that a number was given in the midrashic tradi tion, but the number reveals here a tradition common to the two texts, the other of which was written in Palestine and the other in Egypt. Ezekiel adds a detail that the Israelites were unarmed (v. 210). This de tail is common in early Judaism and shared by Philo and Josephus, al though L.A.B. has a different view. The reason is obvious: Although the Hebrew text has moom in Exod 13:18, LXX has T T E M T T T T I 5 E ysved. Eze kiel, Philo and Josephus obviously follow a midrashic tradition exaggerat ing the miraculous event, but L.A.B. adheres to the line giving crtDom pre dominance over the view that the people had no weapons. Demetrius the Chronographer shows that the problem was discussed among Egyptian Jews: The nation was certainly armed in the battle against Amalek. It is interesting that Josephus here complies with LXX, and apparently the Septuagint again reveals the problematic history of the Hebrew text. A more significant difference between Exodus and Exagoge seems to be that in Ezekiel the water is split immediately after it is struck by Moses (laxioev) and not during the following night (Exod 14:21). However, it is not only an understandable dramatic effect in the tragedy but also a widely known tradition in the Jewish texts (Philo, L.A.B., Josephus). Actually, Exodus allows for both inter pretations, although neither the Hebrew nor the Greek text says expressis verbis that Moses strikes the sea with his rod. The Hebrew text has inapm urr^v jv rm rrem "|tDD"n« cnn nrwi in Exod 14:16; LXX K C U ou Eirapov *rrj pdpSco aou K C U E K T E I V O V TrjV x ^ p a ° u 'sin xr|v 0dAaaoav K C U pfj£ov auxrjv. On the other hand, rro crnp n r a is 68
69
70
71
72
a
73
6 7
See below p. 121 and 241. Jacobson 1983, 151-152. See below p. 240. See Philo (p. 119), Josephus (p. 240), L.A.B. (p. 194) and Holladay 1989, 499-500. "Some asked how the Israelites had weapons, since they came out unarmed. For they said that after they had gone out on a three-day journey, and offered a sacrifice, they would return again. It appears, therefore, that those who had not been drowned made use of the other arms" (Dcm.fr. 5). Philo uses the word (paysTaa) for the sea (see below p. 119). On L.A.B. see below p. 194, on Josephus see p. 241. The Vulgate reads tu autem eleva virgam tuam et extende manum super mare et di vide ilium. 6 8
6 9
7 0
71
7 2
73
76
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
translated ev CCVSJJCO VOTCO (3iaico in Exod 14:21, suggesting a slow divi sion of the sea. It is no surprise that the story was developed in the later tradition and that the rod of Moses became an important element. Exod 4:17 mentions the powerful rod (nnarrna rrncwn im "]T3 npn ntn ntDDrrmi) and Exod 4:20 tells that Moses took the rod (D'rfwn nm'm I xr)V pd(35ov xrjv i r a p a T O U 0EOU) with him when he left Midian. Moses and Aaron both use their rods, Moses to hit the earth (Exod 7:20) and Aaron the Nile (Exod 8:17). Moses' rod is mentioned again when he hits the rock with it (Exod 16:5). When he lifts his hand to help Israel's fight against Amalek, he does not raise his rod; Exod 16:9 says, however, that it was in his hand. The rod had a special role in early Judaism: Ezekiel mentions the rod al ready in v. 132 (EV TTJ5E pccBSco TrdvTcc TROIRJAEIS KCCKCX) and Artapanus gives it a prominent position. Deut.R. 3,8 connects God's holy name with the power of the rod: "It (the sea) saw the Tetragrammaton engraved upon the staff and parted." Jacobson even considers the possibility that Ezekiel in v. 121 knew and criticised the tradition according to which Moses' rod was not an ordinary one but a magical rod given by God to Adam. How ever, the texts Jacobson cites as parallels are late, and there is no reason to believe that Ezekiel knew the tradition. Early on, the Old Testament ex plains the origin of the rich tradition. Many Jewish writers included the event of Moses' striking the sea, tak ing for granted that he divided the sea with his rod. Jacobson's close stud ies of the Jewish texts show that some texts underline the role of Moses' rod while others minimize it. In addition to Ezekiel, the hitting of the sea is mentioned in Artapanus, Philo, L.A.B. and Josephus. Jacobson correctly notes that Isa 11:15 and Zech 10:11 also suppose that the sea was hit, al though in these cases it was God who did it. Jacobson considers the detail important. His answer to why Ezekiel pre ferred one tradition to another is that, contrary to the Hebrew tradition and similarly to most Jewish Hellenists, Ezekiel wanted to emphasize Moses' role in the miracle. This is undoubtedly partly true: Moses at the Red Sea is clearly an important MNP in Ezekiel's text.Nevertheless, the view should not be accepted without reservations. Early on, Exodus describes the event of Moses dividing the sea with his rod. When Moses raises his hands to support Israel's fight against Amalek in Exod 17:8-16 the rod is not raised, but clearly mentioned. Moreover, Jewish writers, cited by Ja cobson himself, might at times stress God's role more, at times Moses' 75
76
77
78
7 4
7 5
7 6
7 7
7 8
See below p. 105. Jacobson 1983, 105-106. See pp. 105, 119, 194 and 241. Jacobson 1983, 141-144. Holladay correctly traces Ezekiel's verse to LXX (1989, 504-505).
11
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
role, but Moses was never forgotten. We have texts in which Moses disap pears almost totally, but also texts in which God's role seems to be greatly reduced. While this is especially true of Artapanus, some Jewish texts written originally in Hebrew also attribute a considerable role to Moses; particularly the writer of L.A.B. cannot be labelled a "Jewish Hel lenist." Ezekiel's passage is more well-balanced than the biblical origi nal: On the one hand, Moses' action is important, but on the other hand, in v. 230-242 it is God's power that destroys the hostile army. Obviously, the tragedian was fond of dramatic effects and he emphasized Moses' role. However, he was following a rich tradition, and can well be described as taking the middle course. 79
81
The detailed presentation of the Egyptian troops and strategy leads us to a more important theme: knowledge of the Greek culture. It was not unproblematic for a Jew to present the events of Exodus on stage. Josephus (as the Letter of Aristeas* ) criticises Greek tragedians who tried to use biblical material in their dramas. Philo cites all the masters of tragedy. He also enjoyed the theatre, which some scholars take as a sign of his "unorthodoxy", but we do not know enough about Judaism in this period to determine whether he broke the rules or whether they even existed. We do not know how many Jews wrote tragedies: Nicolaus of Damascus, who 2
83
84
7 9
Jacobson (1983, 142-143) justly points e.g. to Ps 114 and Wis 19:7-9. However, Ps 77:17-21, which he mentions, is not the only text that does not diminish Moses' role. See p. 192-202. The strategic order described in the verses was first used in 217 BC; see Jacobson 1983, 149-150; 215-216; Gauly et al. 219. Josephus also gives a detailed account of the troops; see below p. 240. See Arist. 312-316. According to Robertson (1985, 804) Arist. criticizes writers such as Ezekiel. Theodectes had tried to use parts of the holy writings in his tragedy, but gave up the task after becoming blind, and Theopompus lost his mind for 30 days for similar reasons (Ant. 12,113). Josephus' aim was not to criticize Ezekiel or other Jews who followed him, but to respond to the question of why the Jews were so rarely mentioned in the mas terpieces of Greek literature. However, Josephus never names Aeschylus, Sophocles or Euripides. On the view that Philo and Josephus criticized Ezekiel, see above p. 75. In his article (1960) Feldman investigates how the Jews in Hellenistic Egypt main tained "their orthodoxy while assimilating the secular knowledge of their day" and "the degree to which Egyptian Hellenistic Jewry deviated from orthodoxy" (1961, 215). A deviation is that Philo often went to the theatre. Ezekiel's play is "still further evidence of deviation from orthodoxy", because God or his voice was on stage (1961, 226-227). Feldman thus presupposes that i) a kind of orthodoxy existed in the beginning and ii) that the theatre was a deviation from it. Both points are difficult to defend, although it admit tedly was not unproblematic to use tragedy and dramatic effects to retell the sacred his tory. Jacobson (1983, 19-20) correctly observes that we cannot draw conclusions on the rules for the Second Temple Jews from the Rabbinic evidence. 8 0
81
8 2
83
8 4
78
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
at least had connections to Judaism, may have, and those who forged the verses of the great masters certainly had some knowledge of the art of tragedy, but we do not know the names of Ezekiel's predecessors, and we do not know how extensive this knowledge was. Nevertheless, Greek trag edy was based on pagan mythology and could not be understood without a deeper knowledge of it. There are signs of a hostile attitude towards Greek tragedy among the Jews, but others were fond of it. Not only did they go to the theatre but they also forged verses in which Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides were made spokesmen for the Jewish religion. But what was Ezekiel's attitude towards the Hellenistic culture? Ezekiel uses the form of Greek drama very skilfully. His language is influenced by Euripides, and his themes, above all, by Aeschylus. The vivid interest in the best preserved Hellenistic tragedy has prompted many difficult questions concerning the possible chorus and technical de vices. A question by far more important to our theme is whether the work was ever intended to be performed on the stage at all, or whether it was simply meant to be publicly recited: Many scholars have doubted that Eze kiel would have put God and his miracles on the stage. It is also not easy to define the audience. Jacobson supposes that it consisted of Jews as well 86
87
88
89
90
91
85
A drama written by AapocaKrivos is mentioned by Eustathius, but it is not clear whether he is Nicolaus of Damascus or not; see Jacobson 1983, 4. On Nicolaus of Da mascus, see Spoerri 1979, 109-111. See Attridge in OTP 2 (1985, 824-829). On the question, see Jacobson 1983, 19-20. See above p. 65 sq. Jacobson 1983, 23-31; van der Horst 1984, 358. On the question about the chorus and proposed alternatives, see Jacobson 1983, 3133. 88. He can find no convincing evidence that there was a chorus in the play, but does not exclude the possibility. In his opinion the obvious choice is Raguel's daughters (1983, 32). V. 65 (TOUTCOV TrocTfjp) seems to attest that they were present, and hardly for any other role than to form a chorus. On the other hand, Raguel's daughters could hardly be present in the dialogue between God and Moses in the desert and even less in Egypt or in the desert on the way to Canaan. It is tempting to speculate that the Egyptian messen ger talked to a chorus, which consisted of Egyptian women or sorcerers, as the chorus in Aeschylus' Persians consisted of Persian wise men. The Roman tragedies had a chorus, and it is conceivable that Ezekiel's play had several choruses. This would solve the prob lem that the place and audience change between acts, but the fact is that we do not have any evidence of lyrical parts of the tragedy. Jacobson cites Euripides' Bacchae 576 sqq as a model: Dionysus is heard but not seen and the actor speaks offstage (1983, 99). Technically it was not difficult, but it may have been problematic theologically. The question is an old one: Schiirer rejected these doubts, which were known to him (3 [1909], 502). On the question, see Vogt 1983, 117-118, Robertson 1983, 804-806 and Holladay 1989, 315. It is interesting that classical scholars remain uncertain (Snell 1971, 175-176; Gauly et al. 1991, 219). 8 6
8 7
88
8 9
9 0
91
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
79
as Gentiles. But is Jacobson's supposition true, and where and in what situation would the tragedy have been performed? Furthermore, what was its function? Hengel presumes that Exagoge was performed in Jerusalem, but if that is true it was apparently not the original location Ezekiel had intended. It is very difficult to find a Sitz im Leben for the play. Moreover, Ezekiel also broke two important rules of a tragedy when he changed the location between scenes and allowed for a long intermission between them. These problems have led some scholars to assume that the tragedy was never performed on stage. Yet, according to many scholars, Ezekiel re vised his material enough to perform it on stage. We do not know enough about Hellenistic tragedy or early Judaism to give the final answer to the question, but a tentative proposal may not be too audacious. But first, it is important to yet take a closer look at the function of Aeschlylus' Persians. Technically, Exodus was not easy to put on stage, but neither was the defeat of the Persians in Salamis. Aeschylus lets a Persian messenger tell about the catastrophe in Susa before the old Persian wise men, who form the chorus. He lets the man give a detailed account of how "the enemy", i.e. the Athenian audience of the tragedy, destroyed the unbeaten navy in Salamis. Aeschylus' Persians had ingeniously shown how a decisive mili tary victory could not only be treated on stage but also transformed into a tragedy. The chorus mourns the loss of the army, which, as the audience knew very well, has recently burned Acropolis. As mentioned above, we know little about other Jewish tragedians, but it is clear that no one writing a tragedy like Exagoge could have conformed to Aeschylus' style by chance. The messenger, the detailed description of the overwhelming troops and the catastrophic end of the speaker's own side are not a coincidence. The greatest of the Old Testament miracles has found a new form resembling a masterpiece of the Athenian tragedy. Aeschylus' intention was to praise Athens, namely, the people who formed his audience. Besides the form and content, did Ezekiel also borrow the function and Sitz im Leben of his model? In Ezekiel's play it is not Israel but God who is praised, and with him, of course, Moses, the Jewish relig ion and the sacred history of the people. The ideal time to perform this tragedy would have been during the Passover in Egypt. Philo tells about the choirs singing in praise of the events {Spec. 2,217-219). Admittedly we 93
94
95
96
9 2
Jacobson 1983, 17-18. Hengel 1996, 296-297. See Jacobson 1983, 98-99. On other historical tragedies, see Jacobson 1983, 3-4. The parallels have been collected by Jacobson, who considers Ezekiel to have been influenced also by Herodotus. See Jacobson 1983, 136-140. 9 3
9 4
9 5
9 6
80
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
do not know anything about Jewish tragedies performed in Egypt, but if Exagoge was ever performed on stage, I would suggest that it was to an intellectual Jewish audience celebrating the Passover in Alexandria. Exagoge means an original kind of interpretatio Graeca: Jewish history and the Jewish religion proudly take the form once used in the cult of Dio nysus. Although the form of the miracle stories is completely new, the con tent is mainly left untouched. Ezekiel allows himself some liberties, as noted above, but fewer than many Jewish writers treated in the present study, such as the writer of Jub. Ezekiel's work, written and perhaps also performed on the stage, reveals his dual heritage. He knows Greek drama well enough to be able to compose his own, and he is sufficiently bound by his Jewish heritage to faithfully follow the presentation in Exodus. As noted above, particularly Collins supposes that Ezekiel represents a less exclusive form of Judaism. The present study, however, has shown that Ezekiel follows the biblical original very closely and that he is more faithful than most of the Jewish writers treated in this study. Collins' view is thus based on two passages cited above. That Zipporah was given to a "stranger" (v. 67) means that mixed marriages are tolerated, and that Eze kiel does not mention circumcision when speaking about the Passover (v. 175-192) means that he avoids the most well known feature of Judaism. However, both arguments have their weaknesses. The "stranger", Moses, is a figure sui generis and it is not surprising that Zipporah is given to him. Many figures of the Old Testament took wives from foreign peoples, as Moses did in Exodus. Some texts, such as Joseph and Aseneth, deal with the problem, but the fact that Ezekiel does not is by no means a strong ar gument for Collins' view. Also, although the subject of circumcision is dropped in the 18 trimetres of the summarised Exod 12, it does not neces sarily mean that he intentionally avoided it and wanted to present a more open religion to the Gentiles. Such an attitude can justly be associated with a man who writes a tragedy according to the Greek model, but such con clusions should be made with caution. Jub. for example, does not mention circumcision in connection with the Passover (Jub. 49), although the theme is crucial in the work (see Jub. 15:25-32). Ezekiel, although a dramatist, is more like "faithful chroniclers" than Jub. or Pseudo-Philo. 97
98
99
t
Ezekiel did not end his drama with the death of the Egyptians. Some verses (243-269) apparently contain only a part of the speech a messenger, per haps a scout, held before Moses. He describes with enthusiasm the wonEzekiel's Moses does not, as Artapanus', teach writing to the Egyptians, but he re ceives a royal education (Ezek. Trag. 36-38; see Jacobson 1983, 78). Barclay 1992, 35; 1996, 134-135. Collins 2000a, 225-226, see also Gruen 1998, 129. 9 8
9 9
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
81
derful nature of Elim, which is briefly mentioned in Exod 1 5 : 2 7 . Ezekiel was not the only one, but perhaps the first to praise Elim, and thus he seems to follow the model of Greek Utopias. It is interesting that he mentions a rock from which the twelve springs flow: 100
r r r i y a s a < | ) u a a c o v SCOSEK
SK
yias
TTETpas
(v.
250).
Obviously, Ezekiel has combined the wonders of nature with the rock giv ing water in the desert. Although these few words do not allow for a de tailed study, he seems to have known the tradition attested in Pseudo-Philo and Rabbinic sources, according to which the rock giving water followed Israel in the desert. This is more evidence showing that although Ezekiel knew the Greek culture well, he was also well aware of his Jewish roots. 101
e. A miracle-worker - but how much more? Ezekiel's only intention in the cited passages is to present the great events of the past. One passage, however, must be noted, because it reveals the function of Moses' mission and also of his miracles. The passage concerns Moses' dream of a great throne touching the clouds of heaven: "I [i.e. Moses] had a vision of a great throne on the top of mount Sinai and it reached till the folds of heaven A noble man was sitting on it, with a crown and a large sceptre in his left hand. He beckoned to me with his right hand, so I approached and stood before the throne. He gave me the sceptre and instructed me to sit on the great throne. Then he gave me the royal crown and got up from the throne. I beheld the whole earth all around and saw beneath the earth and above the heavens. A multitude of stars befell before my knees and I counted them all. They paraded past me like a battalion of men. Then I awoke my sleep in fear" (Ezek. Trag. 68-82).
Moses' father-in-law interprets the dream: God has given a good sign to Moses, who will get a great throne, become a judge and leader of men and know "what is, what has been and what shall be" (v. 8 3 - 8 9 ) . 1 0 2
1 0 0
See Jacobson 1983, 152-166. Jacobson 1983, 154. On Pseudo-Philo, see below p. 197. On Moses' dream, see Jacobson 1983, 89-97; Holladay 1976, 89-97; Runia 1988, 48-75; Holladay 1989, 438-451; Hengel 1995, 190.191; Collins 2000a, 226-228; Eskola 2001, 86-90; Lierman 2004, 95-102. 101
1 0 2
82
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
The dream seems to be an addition to Exodus. However, Ezekiel, as the writer of Jub., was apparently rather reluctant to add to the text something without any background in the Scripture. Scholars have pointed out several theophanies in the Old Testament, and Jacobson and recently Eskola plau sibly suggest Exod 24:9-10 as a possible starting point for the tradition: 103
"Moses and Aaron, Nadab and Abihu, and the seventy elders of Israel went up and saw the God of Israel. Under his feet was something like a pavement made of sapphire, clear as the sky itself."
It is impossible to separate Moses' miracles from the rest of his mission and from this passage in Ezekiel. It is clear that Moses is honoured in a very special way, but what does this dream mean? Who is the one who gives him the throne, and what is the position Moses is given in the dream? Is there a discrepancy between the dream and Raguel's interpretation? Ezekiel tells that Moses awakes from sleep (e£ U T T V O U ) , and Polyhistor definitely treats the passage as a dream ( T O V oveipov occurs twice, Euseb. praep. ev. 9,29,6-7); should it be regarded as exclusively a dream, or as a vision as well? This important passage has many interpretations. Jacobson studies it as Moses' dream and excludes any mystical interpretation. It is interpreted as only a dream, an imaginary event, even an attack against mystical interpretations. On the other hand, van der Horst characterises Jacobson's interpretation as "diametrically opposite" to his own. He connects the vision with merkabah-mysticism. Moreover, the passage is a key point in the current scholarship investigating early Christology. Some scholars have already had the courage to speak about a new Religionsgeschichtliche Schule, and the passage in Ezekiel is often mentioned. A correct reading of this passage is thus of great importance. 104
105
106
103
Jacobson 1981, 276-277; Eskola 2001, 87. In his paper in 1976, Holladay tried to show that Moses was presented as a Greek pocvxis and thus competes at Sinai with Apollo of Delphi for the position of God's spokesman (1976, 447-452). However, the Jewish background is much closer to Eze kiel's passage than the Greek. Holladay seems to have rejected his own proposal in his commentary (1989, 438-451), and it is also rejected by Collins (2000, 226). Jacobson has dealt with the passage in his commentary, as well as in the article "Mysticism and Apocalyptic in Ezekiel the Tragedian" (1981); in addition to his review, van der Horst has written on Jacobson's book in "Moses' Throne-Vision in Ezekiel the Dramatist" (1984a). On the phrase, see above p. 6. The crucial difference is that the "new" school, repre sented, for instance, by Fossum and Hengel, traces the roots of early Christology to Jew ish sources and to the exaltation of several figures (see Fossum 1991, 645-666, and also Zeller 2001, 312-313). Fossum does not cite sources in his article, but Ezek. Trag. is certainly among them. Hengel (1995, 190-191) and Eskola (2001, 86-90) use Ezekiel's passage in their studies. The lively investigation of Christology has led to several vigor ous attempts to accurately define divinization; see Lierman 2004, 97-100. 104
105
106
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
83
The man on the throne is described with archaic words (<|>eoTa yEVVcaov Tiva). <J>cos is the archaic word for man, either in the general sense, in stead of avrjp (//. 17,377), or as the opposite of woman (Od. 6,129; Soph. Ant. 910) or the gods (upos Saipova (|>COTI jjdxeoSai, //. 17,98). But who is this c|>cos? Is he a human figure or God? Both explanations occur, and both include difficulties. If <|>cos, as is generally the case, refers to a man and not to God, it is not easy to decide who this human figure might be. Ezekiel is obviously not speaking about the Pharaoh. The Egyptian ruler never had a position such as the one now given to Moses. Moreover, Moses definitely does not take his new position by force (5E£I<5 5E \xo\ EVEUOE), either in the vision or in Raguel's interpretation. Moses himself is Ejj(t>o(3r|8£is when he has the vision, as well as when the miracles fill him with fear (v. 124-125). Could <))cos be an angelic or human figure, such as Abraham, Enoch or the Son of Man, who gives the throne to Moses of his own free will and in response to God's commandment? In this case, competition with other figures is not ruled out. Most scholars have taken c|>cos to mean God, which is not unproblematic, because this means that Israel's God is described as a man. Robertson chooses this alternative, and sees precisely here the significance of the pas sage. The most recent commentary by Holladay suggests a human figure, but Holladay, like Collins, is uncertain. However, Ezekiel uses a 107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
107
Against Holladay 1989, 442; however, he is very uncertain. Oberhansli-Widmer (1994, 355) deals with the passage in her TRE-article and sees in the dream an underlined deification of Moses, but not in Raguel's interpretation of the dream, an underlined deification of Moses. Vogts translates v. 85 dpd ye [liyav xiv e^avaoTrjoeis Spdvov "Wahrlich, einen GroBen wirst du vom Thron vertreiben" (1983, 125) and takes e£avioTr||Ji to mean "expel" and not "raise up" or "erect". The text should be corrected (Spovou / Spdvov). On the history of the research see Holladay 1983, 447-448. Oberhansli-Widmer follows Vogt's translation and interprets Moses in the vi sion as God, but he interprets Raguel's words as referring to the Pharaoh and as a con cession to Ezekiel's Jewish audience (1994, 355). Even Holladay saw in his earlier arti cle a discrepancy between the dream and its interpretation by Raguel: Moses is presented in the vision as a king, but in the interpretation as a prophet (1976, 447-449). Jacobson (1981, 278-279) rejects Gutman's old view that <|>cds refers to Enoch. "What Ezekiel describes is simply a 4>cos, yet this <()cds is in some sense divine, most probably a surrogate for the Deity himself." In his commentary he is very careful and speaks only about the figure" (1983, 89-97). Hengel emphasizes that a competition between different figures cannot be demon strated (1995, 190-191). Meeks 1967, 148; van der Horst 1984, 363-365; Hengel 1995, 190-191; Borgen 1997, 39; Gruen 1998, 131; Eskola 2001, 87. Robertson 1985,812. Holladay 1989, 442. On Jacobson's view, see above n. 109. Collins 2002, 226. 108
109
110
111
112
113
114
84
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
very archaic formulation, and it may be related to the "The Ancient of Days", (ya* p™, Dan 7:9). This leads to the conclusion that the figure is indeed God himself giving Moses a new position. It is equal to the position God himself has in Aristobulus' Fr. 4,5. Scholars have collected abundant material paralleling this passage, both from Jewish and Greek sources, from dreams and visions. As noted above, Jacobson mainly deals with dreams and suggests that Ezekiel deliberately chose to present the passage as a dream, in refutation of the stories about Moses' deification, cosmic kingship and throne-mysticism. Van der Horst, on the contrary, concentrates precisely on the parallels in merkabah mysticism and on the biblical Ezekiel, and expands his study even to vi sions. A parallel is drawn between the dreams and the passage, especially as it is interpreted by Jacobson. Both the Jewish and the Greek traditions contain many important dreams, which may form the background to the play. On the other hand, many Jewish visions also offer close parallels to Ezekiel's passage. Ezek 1:1-28 is certainly a vision, and it has undoubtedly influenced Ezekiel's text. Jacobson's commentary, though, has juxtaposed the wrong alternatives. There is no need to separate dreams and visions as sharply as Jacobson does: The main point is the position of the figure before God, not the way in which the information is given to the narrator. Ps 110 is neither a dream nor a vision, but Jacobson also justifiably ob115
116
117
118
119
115
The first target of Jacobson's article (1981) is Goodenough's view that Ezekiel owes much to Orphic sources. However, he expands his criticism and also tries to separate Ezekiel's text from the "mysticism" presented in e.g. Philo and 1 En. (1981, 272-277). See van der Horst 1984, 363-369. Moreover, van der Horst does not rule out that the work is a pseudonym, used to conceal Ezekiel's interest in mysticism: "The fact that vv. 68-89 are so evidently based upon the first chapter of the biblical Ezekiel ... might raise the suspicion that the author has assumed this name as a pseudonym" (1984, 355-356). Lierman (2004, 91) pays rather much attention to the question of whether Moses should be considered divine or royal, but this distinction may miss the point; on the enthroned figures, who were neither royal nor divine, see below p. 85. Above all, Joseph's dream (Gen 36:7-11) is to be mentioned. Daniel sees in his dream / vision how "thrones were set in place, and the Ancient of Days took his seat", and how e?3K "H approached the Ancient of Days and was led into his presence. He was given authority, glory and sovereign power; all peoples, nations and men of every lan guage worshiped him" (Dan 7:9; 13-14). Dreams in early Judaism are collected in Lange (1997, 30-35). Dreams were not only common in Greek drama; precisely in Persians Queen Atossa is informed of the catastrophic defeat (Pers. 184). The interpretation given by Raguel resembles, as Jacobson notes, the Greek tradition more than the Jewish point-by-point interpretations. Jacobson also cites some dreams in Herodotus (1,107-108; 1,209; 5,56; 7,12; 7,19; Jacobson 1983, 92-96). This seems to have too great an influence on Gruen; see Gruen 1998, 128-135. 1 1 6
117
118
119
85
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
serves it. The main question is the position given to Moses in Ezekiel the Tragedian, not the device Ezekiel used to tell the story to his audience. What is thus the role of Moses in Ezekiel's passage? In Jacobson's inter pretation it seems to be purely immanent: The passage is a dream since the Old Testament and the Greek models included dreams to announce asuccession. The view is hardly correct. Since Jacobson's commentary, religiohistorical study has advanced considerably regarding all the angelic and human beings with a special status before God and his throne in early Ju daism. Ezekiel is not the only source in which a man is allowed to see God's throne. The Old Testament provides a strong basis for the later tra dition (Exod 19:16-18; Isa 6; Ezek 1, ZXTDan 3:54-55). The theme was topical in early Jewish literature: God's throne was often seen in visions and several figures were connected with it. Enoch saw God enthroned in the Book of Watchers (1 En. 4:18-20) and he lived with God's angels dur ing six jubilees (Jub. 4:19). Many Old Testament heroes have their own thrones in heaven. The Messiah or messianic figures exalted are pre sented in the Dead Sea scrolls as well as in other texts. Moses, of course, is one of the exalted figures in early Judaism. Moses' role is thus purely immanent according to Jacobson's position, but other scholars have seen here a divine kingship or even divinization. Moses admittedly becomes a ruler with all the power given by God, but does Ezekiel present him as a godly figure? It was once common to suppose that the Greeks had taught the Jews to reinterpret their heroes as divine men, a blend of God and men. However, as Holladay in particular 121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
120
Jacobson 1983, 90-91. On recent developments, see Eskola 2001, 1-15. See Eskola 2001,65-71. Not only human beings, but also angels such as Jaoel in Apoc. Ab. 10:8 may have a special status. Enoch sits in 2 En. closer to God than Gabriel (J 24, 1) and is called the "lesser JHWH" later in 3 En., where he is transformed into "Metatron" (on Metatron, see Hengel 1995, 191-194). Adam and Abel have a throne (T. Abr. 11:9; 12:4; 13:2) as well as Abraham, Isaac and Jacob (T Isaac 2:7) and Job (T. Job 33). On David's position, see Hengel 1995, 194196. The enigmatic "Elected One" in 1 En. 45:3; 51:1-3 is apparently a figure likened to the exalted patriarchs; see Eskola 2001, 91-96. The Scrolls often present God's throne and may give an extraordinary position to other figures; see 4Q491 fr. 11, col. I, 12-13 or lQSb 4, 25sqq (see Hengel 1995, 201203; Eskola 2001, 79-86). A Davidic Messiah sits on the throne in 4 Ezr. 12:32-33. See, for example, below on Philo p. 151-155 and on L.A.B p. 199-202. Moses has a throne only in Ezek. Trag. (see Hengel 1995, 196-201), but has perhaps a similar position in L.A.B. (see below p. 199-202). Borgen 1997, 38-39, Collins 2000a, 227. Van Horst 1984a, 27. 121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
86
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
has pointed out, the Jewish texts are extremely cautious and do not deify any man. It was assumed by scholars that Pentateuch opens the door for a reinterpretation, but this door, as far as we know, has never been used. Moses is called God in Exod 7 : 1 , but this idea is never developed in the Jewish literature. The Septuagint still translates literally ( 5 E 5 C G K C X O E 0 E 6 V Oapccco), but the Greek version of Ben Sira has changed the sense, and Philo has to explain the verse. Caution can also be discerned in Exagoge. The exalted figures, such as the Son of Man in Dan 7 , have a special status and "his dominion [becomes] identical to God's domin ion." Ezekiel's Moses has a high status, but there is no reason to speak about divinization. Moses' miracles, as retold in the play, do not empha size the role of the hero. It is Israel's God who is active and Moses is his agent. Admittedly, God gives his throne to Moses in Exagoge, but there is no sign of God withdrawing, and God's miracles and the dream fill Moses with the terror of God. Moreover, as Holladay notes, Moses is expressis verbis called B V T J T O S ( V . 1 0 2 ) . God is and remains the Lord in the world. Although it is not enough to characterize the Moses in Ezekiel's passage a king, an enthronization does not mean divinization. The later writers could describe several heavenly figures and still remain monotheists. The human features of the leader are apparent in the tragedy and they should not be overlooked. Ezekiel goes far but not as far as 3 En. calling Enoch "the lesser YHWH". 130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
/
Conclusion
Miracles play a notable role in Ezekiel's drama. The most surprising fea ture in Exagoge is that the drama very closely follows the biblical original. There was no tradition of quoting the holy texts exactly, as the rabbis did, and many devoted Jews allowed themselves a great deal of freedom. Eze kiel remains faithful to Exodus, although he has to write in iambic trimetres and not in prose. He is one of the few Jewish writers to put God in a dialogue with Moses as Exodus does. Many miracles were not suitable for dramatization, whether on the stage or only read. Ezekiel had to find a new 1 3 0
Holladay 1977,235-236. See above p. 25. See below p. 151-155. Hengel 1995, 185. Contrary to van der Horst 1984, 26-29. See Hengel's reservations, 1995, 191. Lierman (2004, 97-100) presents the recent attempts to define divinization in early Judaism. The terror after the dream is a common feature; see Holladay 1989, 446. Holladay 1989, 438. See Hengel 1995, 190-191; Eskola 2001, 89. 131
132
1 3 3
1 3 4
135
1 3 6
137
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
87
way of presenting the plagues and the miracle at the Red Sea. He tells of each one of the plagues through God's speech, and when he imitates Aes chylus and lets an Egyptian describe the catastrophe, he adds very few to tally new traits to the story. That a Hellenistic Jew followed so faithfully the original was perhaps a way to anticipate criticism against the holy his tory being put on the stage. Some details attest Ezekiel's acquaintance with the tradition. The Graeco-Roman world must have been well-known to him, and the descrip tion of Elim seems to be influenced by Greek Utopias. The Jewish tradi tion is strongly present. Although the details of Moses hitting the Red Sea and the importance of his rod have their roots in Exodus, Ezekiel owes to his predecessors the number of Egyptians (one million) and says that the Jews were unarmed. LXX allows such an interpretation, but the Hebrew text does not. It is interesting that although he follows LXX, avoiding the word nmsD in the theophany at Horeb, he freely chooses this word to de scribe the plagues. The pestilence does not seem to have been a sensitive theme for Ezekiel. Moses' role in the miracles is different from that of Exodus, and actually it varies in different fragments of the tragedy. As a whole, it is difficult to use Kahl's terminology, because the transformation from verse to tragedy has strongly influenced Ezekiel: Moses' role is reduced in the plagues told about in advance by God, but his role becomes more significant at the Red Sea. If we look over the technical devices that a tragedy required, we rec ognize an interesting duality. On the one hand, in his dream, Moses attains a position in heaven similar to what he and, for instance, Enoch, Abraham, Melchisedek and the Son of Man are given in some other texts; on the other hand, his human qualities are strongly underlined: Moses, for exam ple, is afraid of the snake at the burning bush and he is called S V T J T O S . God's role is generally emphasized slightly more than in the biblical origi nal, although Moses and God are both mentioned at the Red Sea and Moses hits the water with his rod. Ezekiel borrowed Aeschylus' device for turning a glorious siege into a tragedy. As the Athenians watched a Persian messenger tell about the ca tastrophe at Salamis, the Jews could watch an Egyptian messenger tell about the Pharaoh and his troops. Aeschylus glorified Athens, Ezekiel the Jews and their sacred history. It is an original form of interpretatio Graeca: Ezekiel knew the Gentile tradition well enough to be capable of using the form and language originally belonging to the cult of Dionysus. However, his main intention, which is also the function of the miracles told, is to retell the sacred history and glorify God's own people - possibly to a Jewish audience during the Passover in Alexandria. Unlike Ben Sira, Ezekiel does not directly connect miracles with an eschatological hope. There is no trace of a political adaptation of biblical
88
4. Dramatic Miracles: Ezekiel the Tragedian
miracles. However, the greatest miracles of the glorious past and Moses on the godly throne imply that also in his view God's miracles and protective power did not only belong to the past.
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography: Artapanus a. Introduction Many Jewish writers have been overlooked in the biblical exegesis Artapanus has won a special position in the studies of the History of the religions school. As an example of a "Hellenistic" or even "polytheistic" Jew, scholars have vividly discussed him and his texts. From the very be ginning, his Moses served as one of the best examples of a 0e7os avrjp in Hellenistic Jewish texts. Artapanus lived in Egypt, and according to some scholars, in the coun tryside rather than in Alexandria; but the arguments are not strong enough to exclude the capital. It is not easy to accurately define the time in which he wrote his work TTepi' louScucov or' louSa.Kc! , although the limits are easily drawn. In the same way as Ezekiel the Tragedian he uses the Septuagint and antedates Alexander Polyhistor, whose work is summarized by Eusebius and Clement of Alexandria. 1
2
3
4
1
5
The first to use Artapanus' fragments to this end was Otto Weinreich, a very influen tial early advocate of the theory. Weinreich labels Moses in Artapanus a 0eTos avrjp ("sein Moses is dem hellenistischen Ideal des 0eTos avrip, des philosophischen Kulturbringers und Thaumaturgen, weitgehend angenahert", 1929, 299). Moreover, the typical evolutionistic features of the early form of the theory, such as mana, are clearly present in Weinreich's study ("... paBt aber ebensowohl zu judischen wie gemein-antiken Vorstellungen von der Macht des Namens bzw. der Manabegabten 0e?oi avSpcoiroi und Propheten", 1929, 304). On the 0s?os avrjp-theory and mana see Koskenniemi (1998, 458-459). Georgi (1964, 148-151) and Walter (1980, 122) also use the concept. A critical survey of the studies using the 0e?os avrjp concept for Artapanus' text is found in Holla day 1977, 199-232. See Fraser 1972, 1.704; Holladay 1983, 189; Collins 2000a, 39. The main argument is that Artapanus' text does not look like other Jewish texts that we know from Alexandria. However, we have only a small selection of the rich literature produced by the Alexan drian Jews and it is not easy to determine what kind of text the diverse community could or could not produce. Eusebius mentions once the title' louSaiKoi (praep. ev. 9,18,1) and twice (praep. ev. 9,23; 9,27), as Clement (strom. 1,154,2), the title TTepi' louSaicov. There is no reason to suppose that there are two separate works; see Collins 1985, 889. See Collins 1985, 890. On Alexander Polyhistor see Montanari 1996, 478-479. 2
3
4
5
90
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
While some scholars have abandoned any attempts to date him more ac curately, others have proposed different decades. It is generally supposed that Artapanus wrote after the Maccabean revolt had provoked a propagandistic counter-attack by the Seleucids, and the growing anti-Judaism had allegedly led Artapanus to use his Moses as a shield to protect his people. It seems obvious that the anti-Jewish propaganda was generally known among the cultured Greeks soon after the Maccabean revolt, although Gruen recently questioned it, but it is not certain whether this struggle played a role in Artapanus' fragments or not. The role of Manetho, an Egyptian priest who wrote his work in the 3 century, has been confusing in modern research. The question of genre is exceptionally important, and it is not enough to merely use the phrase "rewritten Bible." The most extensive fragment deals with Moses, and has led some scholars to speak about a "Mosesromance". Moses, however, is not the only biblical hero in Artapanus. The work can hardly be labelled as a romance at all, since the first two 6
7
8
9
r d
10
11
12
6
Barclay (1992, 31) sees no possibility for a more accurate dating, nor does Schurer 3.1. (1973), 521-525. Holladay suggests the period about 180-145 (1983, 189-193) and Walter (1976, 124-125; 1989, 401-402) and Weber (2000, 60) about 100 BC. See, for example, Holladay 1977, 215-217; Charlesworth 1981, 283; Collins 1985, 892; Oberhansli-Widmer 1994, 353. See below p. 231. In his thorough analysis Tiede sees no signs of an attack against anti-Judaism in Ar tapanus' work. He is a rare exception among the scholars (Tiede 1972, 174-176), but his view is based on a solid study; see Koskenniemi 2002, 23. Manetho is mostly considered the first anti-Jewish writer to write a distorted version of the Exodus. According to Jacoby his criticism was not directed to the Jews, but the later anti-Jewish writers made use of his text in their propaganda. This view is rejected by Kasher (1985, 6.327-332), but Gruen justly says that applying the concept of antiJudaism to Manetho, whose story we only know through Josephus, grossly oversimplifies the matter (1998, 55-64). Although Manetho possibly identified Hyksos with Jews, he perhaps did not know the biblical story nor distort it (Collins 2000b, 61-62). According to Collins (2000b, 52-62), Artapanus refuted Manetho's account, but simultaneously used Manetho's story and Gentile legends, sometimes to invert and refute them. Among them, Walter 1980, 121; Schottroff 1983, 232. Fraser, strangely enough, calls it a "Life of Moses" (1972, 704), perhaps following Weinreich ("Artapanos gibt nicht so sehr einen 'Roman', obwohl er auch eine Liebesgeschichte hat, als vielmehr den erbaulichen (Bios eines 8e?os avrjp ..." 1929, 307). All the same Fraser concludes later: ".. it seems probable that the complete text contained a fairly full account of the story of the residence of the Children of Israel in Egypt with a few embellishments" (1972, 706). A romantic aretalogy is suggested by Hengel (1991,2.62), but the existence of the whole genre "aretalogy" is questionable today (Berger 1984b, esp. 1218-1231; on the discus sion, see Koskenniemi 1994, 103-114). The work is classified as a romance by Schwartz in his article in PRE (1895, 1306); Walter 1980, 120-123; and Holladay 1983, 190-191 (Holladay preferred 1977, 215 the characterisation "national romantic history"). 7
8
9
10
11
12
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
91
fragments deal with Abraham and Joseph, and it is difficult to find a model for a romance dealing with several heroes living in different centuries. The theme of the work apparently was "Jews in Egypt", because Abra ham's and Joseph's lives are studied from the Egyptian perspective, and that is precisely what the title ( louSatKcc) known to us implies. Given the romantic colouring the genre is thus historiography. We do not know how much the most extant third fragment dealing with Moses has been abridged by Polyhistor and Eusebius, but in oratio obliqua it gives a con tinuous description of Moses' life from his birth up until his being in the desert with the people, telling nothing about his death. Apparently it was one part of the nation's history and the first two fragments belonged to the earlier phase. Holladay is right in saying that the work is not the serious history of Herodotus or Thucydides, and Collins' words characterise the work well: 13
14
15
16
"... Artapanus is engaged in what might be called competitive historiography (with the understanding that historiography here can include a liberal component of legend and romance)." 17
No scholar denies nor can deny the syncretistic elements in Artapanus. Nevertheless the views of scholars differ essentially. Consequently, also the miracle-making Moses is understood in different ways. I have tried to deal with the theme in an article, which is also an attempt to study the so cial setting of Artapanus. The fragments are commented on by Holladay (1983), who already treated them extensively in 1977. Eve's remarks, 18
19
20
13
Walter supposes that the passages on Abraham and Josephus were rather a preface to Moses' life, which was told extensively (1980, 121-122). However, all we have of Ar tapanus is the six pages in Jacoby's edition. The work undoubtedly was larger, the pas sage on Moses as well as these on Abraham and Josephus. Artapanus' text is traditionally classified as history, as, for instance, in Schurer (German ed. 3 [1909], 477-480), and his fragments are edited in FrGrHist. Walter speculates on the possibility that Artapanus has given a report on Moses' death and assumption (1980, 136). Holladay 1983, 190. Collins 2000a, 39-40. Schurer 3.1.(1971), 521-525, Walter (1976, 123) and Holladay do not emphasize the syncretistic elements in Artapanus' fragments. Barclay (1992, 31), on the contrary, con siders him "a polytheistic Jew", and repeats this view still more strongly in 1996 ("Even as a Jew his is both a monotheist and a polytheist"). A good overview of the question and the older scholarship is in Holladay 1977, 199-205. "Greeks, Egyptians and Jews in the fragments of Artapanus." Theios aner in Hellenistic-Judaism: a Critique of the Use of this Category in New Testament Christology (1977); Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors vol 1 (1983). Holladay's translation is used in the present study. Other important studies are Tiede 1972, 146-177; Collins 1985, 889-903; Barclay 1992, 28-46; Mittmann-Richert 2001, 156-171; van Uytfanghe 2001, 144-145. See also my article mentioned above. 14
15
16
17
18
19
20
92
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
especially on the agent of the miracles, mean that many important ques tions have been asked recently, but the details and flow of the tradition have not been thoroughly investigated. 21
The first two fragments are short and do not ascribe miracles to Abraham or Joseph. Yet it is interesting that Abraham taught astrology to the Egyp tian king (Artap. 1,1). As mentioned above, even among the Gentiles Jews had a reputation for being great astrologers. The Jewish writers, however, had different opinions about these skills: Some of them excluded astrology from their portrayal of Abraham, but others proudly emphasized the fa ther's knowledge in this area. Artapanus saw no reason to exclude astrol ogy as one of Abraham's skills. Both Abraham and Joseph are presented as TTpcoxoi euprjTai of different things. This is a major tendency in Artapanus and will be treated in con nection with the third fragment. The passage dealing with Moses is of crucial importance regarding the miracles. 22
23
24
b. The leader is called Moses' early years (Exod 1:1-2:25) were often retold in early Judaism, and like many other writers, Artapanus adds an abundance of extra-biblical material presenting Moses' early years. Although he adds no miracles, some features essentially belong to the picture of the Lawgiver. In the Hebrew text God makes the houses for the midwives, while LXX has 'eTTOirjoav (Exod 1:21). £cooyove?T6 a u T o in Exod 1:22 is perhaps slightly more active than the Hebrew )vnn mrr^Di and allows the interpretation that the girls were intentionally raised to serve as concubines of the Egyptians (see p. 192-193). LXX thus does not seem to open new doors for new interpretations, when it renders Moses' early years up until he meets God at Horeb, but translates the passage quite literally.
Exodus treats Moses' early years with silence, but Artapanus has filled the gap with new material, elaborating the story with many new details. He partly follows a broad midrashic tradition, which is also present in Jub., Philo and L.A.B. Artapanus gives names to the persons in the biblical story: Merris, the Pharaoh's barren daughter, was betrothed to Chenephres. 25
2 1
2 2
2 3
See Eve 2002, 232-241. On Jub., see above p. 53. Ps. Eup. Fr. 1 and 2 (Euseb. praep.ev.
9,17,3-4 and 8; 9,18,2) and Siker 1987, 193197. Artap. 1-2. See below p. 93-94. On Jubilees, see Jub. 47, on Philo, below p. 110-111, on L.A.B., p. 192-193, and on Josephus, below p. 232-234. 2 4
2 5
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
93
Artapanus
The Greeks called Moses Musaeus, the teacher of Orpheus. The priests called him Hermes, because he interpreted (5ia T T I V . . . sppTiveiav, Artap. 3,6) their holy writings. He taught the Egyptians many useful skills, in cluding the making of ships and weapons and the study of philosophy. He divided the country into 36 nomes and apparently even founded pagan cults (Artap. 3,4). Artapanus even makes Moses a good Egyptian general and leader of the people. Chenephres envies Moses and sends a man named Chanethothes to kill him; however, warned by Aaron, Moses kills him in self-defence and flees to Arabia (Artap. 3,5-19). In Artapanus, the life of Moses is Hellenized from the very beginning. Sesostris, an Egyptian hero traditionally mentioned in the studies on Ar tapanus, is said to have divided the country into 36 nomes (Diod. 1,54,3), and even to have been a military genius. As in the short fragments deal ing with Abraham and Joseph, the entire civilisation is based on Jewish wisdom. The topos of irpcoxos euprjTrjs already present in Jub., is rarely as clear as here: Moses, like Abraham and Joseph, is the great wise one, the source of a very different kind of wisdom. Many Jewish texts claim that the wisdom of the great Greek philosophers was derived from Moses, and Philo proudly sets the Torah above all the wisdom in the world. According to him, God created the world and gave the Torah: that is the reason why the world is in harmony with the Torah and the Torah is in harmony with the world (Op. 1-3); consequently, he could respect all good philosophers. Artapanus, who wrote some time before Philo, clearly emphasizes Moses' person, but the attitude is the same. All real wisdom in the world springs from Judaism. Orpheus, Musaios and Hermes may all serve to this end. Eve considers the topos to be Artapanus' answer to the anti-Jewish propaganda, and that he was willing to show that the Jews were a blessing rather than a burden to Egypt. This is possible and even probable, but the common topos and the competitive character of Ar tapanus' work are sufficient explanations for his text. It is obvious that Artapanus generally tried to contemporize the biblical stories. As the Egyptian Jews were generally anxious to identify with the Greeks rather than the native Egyptians, Artapanus did not find fault with 26
27
28
19
30
31
32
2 6
See below p. 98. On Sesostris and Artapanus, see Tiede 1972, 153-155.167. Artapanus certainly was familiar with this kind of legendary material. However, Holladay points out that many features were commonplace and that only two of them are known to us solely through the Sesostris-legend and Artapanus (Holladay 1977, 210). See Diod. 1,53-56; Herodot 2,102-106 and Tiede 1972, 153 See above p. 53. On the topos in Artapanus, see Holladay 1977, 220-229. See e.g. Aristobulus,/r. 3-4; Jos. c. Ap 1,162-165; c. Ap. 2,257. Eve 2002, 233. 2 7
2 8
2 9
3 0
31
3 2
94
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
the Greeks. He did, however, criticize the Egyptians, especially their lead ers. The ordinary Egyptian people might be characterised as friendly, also in the miracle stories, but their leaders, who had Egyptian names, were not. Artapanus' version also reveals contacts with the Jewish midrashic tradi tions, which hardly started with him. Philo also knew the extra-biblical detail that the Pharaoh's daughter had been married for a long time and that the lack of an heir was a threat to the Pharaoh. Also, according to Josephus, Thermuthis (as he calls the Pharaoh's daughter) had no children of her own and was worried about the succession. These texts imply a strong tradition, in Egypt as well as in Palestine, although Artapanus calls the daughter Merris not Tharmuth / Thermuthis as the two Palestinian texts do (Jub. 47:5 and J o s e p h u s ^ . 2,219-213). Both Artapanus and Josephus make Moses an Egyptian general before his escape from Egypt (Ant. 2,238-253), and emphasize his military gen ius. It is understandable that Moses' military skills were generally high lighted, following the model of Hellenistic historiography, but the tradition of Moses as an Egyptian general is worth noting, especially because this detail also occurs in texts written in the Palestinian and Egyptian context. Everything shows that the Jewish tradition - Palestinian and Egyptian regarding the early years of Moses was merged with the Greco-Roman. 33
34
35
The theophany in Exod 3:1-4:17 is retold very briefly in the fragment we have from Artapanus. In Artapanus' account God does not call to Moses in the burning bush, but Moses prays to God for his oppressed people: "While he was making his appeal to God, suddenly, he says, fire appeared out of the earth, and it blazed even though there was neither wood nor any other kindling in the vicinity. Frightened at what happened, Moses fled but a divine voice spoke to him and told him to wage war against Egypt, and as soon as he had rescued the Jews, to return them to their ancient fatherland. Taking courage from this, he resolved to lead a fighting force against the Egyptians, but first he went to Aaron his brother" (Artap. 3,21-22). On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX in Exod 3:1-4:17, see p. 66.
We have Artapanus' text in oratio obliqua, summarised by Alexander Polyhistor and after him Eusebius, which means that caution is necessary. Nevertheless, some comments are possible. In its present form the fragment does not tell about the dialogue between God and Moses. The burning bush and even the angel are absent, and God's answer to his prayer is only a "fire from the earth" (at<|)Vi5tcos 3 3
3 4
3 5
See Koskenniemi 2002. See below p. 111. On Josephus, see below p. 233.
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
4>rjaiv
Artapanus
95
yfjs nup ava^efjvcn, Kai T O U T O KaeoBai, {iXris \IT[TS ^uAetas ouarjs B V T C O T O T T C O , Artap. 3,21). The fragment tells nothing about the miracles, only about a divine voice. However, Moses throws his rod and it becomes a snake, as in the biblical original, but this happens only later in Egypt. It is virtually certain that Artapanus himself omitted the dialogues and the miracles, because God generally does not take part in the dialogues in Artapanus' fragments. God is also reduced to a divine voice in Artap. 3,36. The miracle is not rationalised; on the contrary, it is possibly greater than in Exod} and the tenor of the story, especially, must be observed. God does not try to persuade Moses, but he is the Lord, and Moses is frightened and flees. Artapanus offers only one variant of the bias to reduce God's anthropomorphic features and avoid putting him in a dialogue with men. The story has lost several important features because of the missing dia logues. There is no reluctant leader and there are no miracles persuading him to go to Egypt. Moses does not mention his lack of eloquence, he does not fear the mission and does not need miracles to legitimate himself in the presence of his own people. All these features are understandable, because Artapanus is keen to reduce Moses' human weaknesses, and his Moses needed no legitimation. However, Artapanus does not completely remove these weaknesses; he has preserved the central element of the theophany, namely that Moses was frightened and he describes how Moses flees the strange phenomenon. The journey to Egypt is changed into a military campaign (aTpocTeueiv E T T ' ATyuTTTov ... S U V C C J J I V T T O A E M I C C V ETrayEiv). Gruen takes Artapanus' text as a "direct testimony" of a Jewish tradition on mobilisation against Egypt, and even Holladay considers such a tradition possible. However, Artapanus lacks consistency, and instead of leading an army, Moses goes to the Pharaoh alone. It is true that Josephus also presents the military side of Moses' character, but his account is logical and consistent, while Ar tapanus has totally reshaped this sacred history. The journey to Egypt is a military campaign here but not later in the fragments. Artapanus allows himself great liberties, not only in the biblical text but also in terms of a logical plot. He apparently knew the tradition of Moses as an Egyptian general, but the campaign against Egypt is his own invention. EK TTJS
aXKr\s
Ttvos
36
1
38
39
40
3 6
3 7
3 8
3 9
4 0
See below p. 99. Walter 1980, 133. On Jub., see p. 61; on Philo, see p 112. Holladay 1977, 69-71; Gruen 1998, 65. On Josephus, see below p. 233.
96
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography: Artapanus
Some early Jewish texts clearly reduce Aaron's role and may not even mention him. He appears in Artapanus' text, and is given a new role in warning his brother; Moses is also sent to him as in the biblical original. Still Aaron and his miracles are left out in the latter parts of the story. Ar tapanus' Moses needs no help. 41
c. The return, plagues and freedom Moses thus is on a mission to aTpccxeueiv sir At'yuirTOV, but he goes to the ruler alone. When the Pharaoh hears Moses' claim he immediately im prisons the hero, but at night the doors of the prison open of their own ac cord, some of the guards die and others are overcome with sleep. Moses goes to the palace and wakens the Pharaoh: 42
"Startled at what happened, the king ordered Moses to declare the name of the god who had sent him. He did this scofmgly. Moses bent over and spoke into the king's ear, but when the king heard it, he fell over speechless. But Moses picked him up and he came back to life again. He wrote the name on a tablet and sealed it securely, but one of the priests who showed contempt for what was written on the tablet died in a convulsion" (Artap. 3,24-26).
The imprisonment of Moses is a nonbiblical but also an understandable addition: According to Exodus he had killed a man and escaped. This might be the reason Artapanus adds the story and consequently also the passage about the miraculous escape from prison. Josephus also says that the Pharaoh called Moses a criminal, which is apparently only an under standable midrashic feature giving no reason to suppose dependence on a written source. The escape from prison was once taken as a common motif in GraecoRoman literature. In Weinreich's view there are no parallels to the story in early Judaism, but there are in Greek literature, and he cites Euripides' Bacchae and Philostratus' VA 7,38; 8,30. However, Philostratus' work is late and when Holladay examines Weinreich's evidence for the view that Artapanus used Euripides' play he finds differences as well as similarities, and, justly, is not convinced. The passage is hardly borrowed from Eurip43
44
45
41
Jub. (see p. 55) and Philo (see below p. 128) reduce Aaron's role. On Josephus, see p. 235. As Collins noted (1985, 889), Clement's text seems to be a little less miraculous. However his summary is much shorter than that of Eusebius and there is no possibility for conclusions. See below p. 236. On the story, see Tiede 1972, 165-170. Weinreich 1929, 298-309. 4 2
4 3
4 4
4 5
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
97
Artapanus
ides. A closer parallel is Sesostris, who is saved; however, not from prison but from fire (Herod. 2,107, Diod. 1,57,7-8). Given Artapanus' fa miliarity with the Greek spirit, the Jewish tradition also offered parallels to the story. Isa 45:2 and Ps 107:10-14 should be noted as possible starting points of the tradition, although Weinreich did not observe them. Abra ham and his friends are freed in an extrabiblical addition effracto ostio carceris in L.A.B. 6,9. The History of the Rechabites, too, tells how the angel led the Rechabites out of prison: 47
48
"On the first night, a brilliant light shone upon us; and angels of God in glorious form appeared to us. And they led all of us out from prison and placed us in the air that is above the land" (Hist. Rech. 10:5).
Joseph and Aseneth explain that the Lord heard Aseneth's prayer when she was threatened by Dan, Gad, Naphtali and Asher, and "at once their swords fell from their hands on the ground and were reduced to ashes" (Jos. Asen. 27:11). A dislike of the native Egyptians is present here as it often is in Ar tapanus' fragments. The Pharaoh falling over speechless and the mocking priest punished severely are good examples of wicked men leading the simple people. The Egyptian names of the leaders generally helped Ar tapanus' readers to identify the opponents with the lower layers of the population in Ptolemaic Egypt, and when Artapanus mentions a priest showing contempt for Israel's religion he is able to attack the Egyptian religion with the help of the miracle stories. The two extra-biblical miracles in the Pharaoh's house, the death and re suscitation of the Pharaoh and the punishment of the priest (Artap. 3,2426) are interesting in many ways. We do not have many stories about the resuscitation of dead people in Graeco-Roman sources before 200 AD. Diogenes Laertius attributes such a miracle to Empedocles, quoting Heraclides Ponticus from the 4 century as his source (Diog. Laert. 8,67). Pliny (nat. 7,124; 26,12-15;, Aulus Cor nelius Celsus (2,6) and Apuleius (flor. 19) relate a miracle performed by the physician Asclepiades, but the man revived was apparently not dead. Apuleius tells another story about the prophet Zatchlas (metam. 2,28-29) and Lucian tells two (Alex. 24; Philops. 26). With the exception of the story about Empedocles all are from a markedly later period than those told by Artapanus. The Jewish texts, on the other hand, contain many, 49
th
50
4 6
4 7
4 8
4 9
5 0
See Holladay 1977, 205-209 and 1983, 240. See also Walter 1976, 122. See also the Christian stories in Acts 5:17-26; 12:6-17; 16:23-30. Weinreich 1929, 303; Holladay 1977, 205. See Koskenniemi 1994, 195-196. On Asclepiades, see Koskenniemi 1994, 210-215.
98
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
clearly older parallels. The stories about Elijah and Elisha, with all the later versions studied in the present work, offer material clearly closer to Artapanus than to the pagan literature. It is not surprising that precisely the name of Israel's God produces the great miracles. The holy name was perhaps the most important contribu tion of the Jews to the Mediterranean world and it was widely used in magic. Moses' magical skills were known to Pompeius Trogus (32,2,11), Pliny the Elder (nat. 30,2,11) and Numenius {fir. 18). Jews in general had a reputation for such skills in the view of Juvenalis (sat. 6,546-547) and Lucian (Alex. 32,13) and often in PGM. Josephus also connects the holy name with Moses' miracles in Egypt (Ant. 2,275-276). It obviously has magical power in Artapanus' extra-biblical additions. It is also worth noting that Israel's God is proudly placed above all other gods. Artapanus was not a strict monotheist, but his Moses serves "the Lord of the universe." Other peoples may serve other gods, and Artapanus may follow a tradition originating from Deut 4:19-20 and Deut 32:8, in which Moses seems to say that God has given to the Gentiles gods to serve. Israel, however, must serve only God and this religion is supreme. Artapanus' Judaism is by no means "fully compatible" with pagan relig ions, but the correct word to characterise his view is monolatry. It is important to note Moses' role in the miracles. A man is rarely an independent miracle-worker in the Jewish texts we have, but Artapanus' Moses is not merely a PNP, but an MNP - or should he be called a BNP? He neither prays to God nor uses a gesture, but acts alone. It means that the difficult question of context is raised again: Ben Sira could say that Joshua stopped the sun with his hand, but the immediate context as well as the entire book directed to a Jewish audience precludes any interpretation that Joshua acted alone. However, now the situation was drastically different, especially if Artapanus could find non-Jewish readers, as he clearly in tended, and also reach his goal. There was thus no Jewish analogia fidei to prevent interpretations not compatible with the Old Testament belief. Eve correctly notes that Artapanus does not say that God opens the doors or kills the mocking priest, but that the doors open auxopdxcos and the 51
52
53
54
5
56
57
58
51
On Elijah and Elisha in Ben Sira, see above p. 31-39; in the Lives of the Prophets, see p. 184-186; in Josephus, see p. 264-278. Tiede 1972, 169-170. The pivotal study is Gager's Moses in Graeco-Roman Paganism (\972) 134-161. See Holladay 1983, 240. On other magical features, see below p. 102. Barclay 1992, 31. See Koskenniemi 2002, 30-31. On this question, see Tiede 1972, 165; Eve 2002, 234-235. See above p. 30. See below p. 105. 5 2
9
53
5 4
55
5 6
5 7
5 8
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
99
Artapanus
holy name kills the priest. Different readers certainly interpreted the events in different ways, but what was Artapanus' own intention? Appar ently he, contrary to the translator of Ben Sira or even Philo, was not afraid that Moses would attain too high a position through his miracles. Eve is certainly right in calling it a hopeless task to try to extract from his frag ments a clearly defined theology of miracles or a reflected division of the roles of God and human agents. In any case, Artapanus does not com pletely remove Moses' human traits, as seen above: God is distant, but present with his power. 60
61
Artapanus returns to the biblical original after the story. Although the legitimisation before Israel's elders is left out (see Exod 4:27-4:31), Moses makes miracles at the Pharaoh's court. Artapanus omits the first failed visit (Exod. 5:1-23) or possibly replaces it with the story about imprisonement. Although this story immediately continues, it is obviously Artapanus' ver sion of the second visit (Exod. 6:28-7:13): "The king then told Moses to perform some sign for him. So Moses threw out the rod, which he held and made it a snake (pdpSov EKpaAovxcc 6<J>iv iroifjsai). Since everyone was terrified, he seized it by the tail, picked it up, and made it a rod again" (Artap. 3,27). Artapanus thus retells Exod 6:28-7:13. LXX translates O'na© Wxvctycovos in v. 6:30. The important words in v. 7:1 are translated literally runs ? crrfra ynru mo / ' l6ou Ss'ScoKCX oe 0E6V Oapaco). In v. 7:3 the words TinirnK are translated with TOC GX]\IB\(X \IOM and n3iD"n«'i with rd T S p a T a . In v. 7:9 the Hebrew text does not use the word on: as in 4:3, but has prfr, and even LXX has changed the word (not 6<(>is, but SpccKcov). Moses' op ponents are • DDn, D'DCDD and nacnn, and in LXX oo^iOTai and <|>ap|jaKoi and ETTOCOISOI (7:11). 1
,,
,
As seen above, LXX uses two different words for the snake: it is 6<|>is at Horeb and again on the river (Exod 7:15), but Spccxcov at the Pharaoh's court (Exod 7:9-10). Artapanus chooses the word oc|>is, although he omits all miracles in the theophany at Horeb. Another interesting feature is that the opponents are absent, although they soon appear. Artapanus does not differentiate between the second visit and the plagues (Exod 7:14- 2:36), but goes directly to the set of catastrophes: "He then stepped forward a few steps, struck the Nile with his rod, and the river flooded, inundating all of Egypt. It was from that time that the flooding of the Nile began. When the stagnant water began to smell, the animals in the river perished and the peoples as well began to die of thirst. Once these mighty wonders were accomplished, the king said
Eve 2002, 236. On Ben Sira see above p.23-26, on Philo see below p. 151-155. Eve 2002, 240.
100
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
that he would release the people after a month if Moses would restore the river to its banks. So Moses again struck the water with his rod and the waters subsided. When this had been done, the king summoned the priests who were over Memphis and threatened to kill them and destroy their temple unless they too performed some marvel lous act. Then, using charms and incantations, they made a serpent and changed the col our of the river. The king became arrogant as a result of such performances as this and consequently mistreated the Jews with every kind of vindictive chastisement" (Artap. 3,28-31). On a detailed comparison of plagues (Exod 7:14-12:36) in the Hebrew text and LXX, see p. 70. 62
The plague on the river is drastically changed in several ways. When Moses (not Aaron as in Exod 7 : 1 9 - 2 0 ) struck the Nile, the river flooded the first time and from that moment yearly. The stagnant water began to smell and the fish died, but the water did not become blood. That it changed col our when the Egyptians imitated Moses seems to be only a sign of Ar tapanus' inconsistency. When Artapanus says that this was the first time the river flooded, it is not "a rationalising touch", but a form of the topos mentioned above. Artapanus is eager to make all his heroes TrpcoTOi EuprjTCCt of various things. Now he also interprets the biblical miraclestory to serve the same end: Moses was the greatest of all and his ministry was a blessing to everyone who lived in Egypt. Artapanus may exaggerate the miraculous, but, when needed, he can also give a natural explanation if it shows Moses in a good light. The Pharaoh (unlike in Exodus) asks Moses to restore the river, which causes Moses to hit the river again. Artapanus thus freely elaborates on the biblical original, which tells nothing about the end of the plague. The opponents, previously absent, now appear, but it is not easy to de fine what kind of people they are. It is impossible to define the precise original sense of the Hebrew words, and although LXX translates faith fully the Hebrew text in Exod 7 : 1 1 , both of these versions may have dif ferent connotations and open to door for different interpretations, crcon is neutral and used in a positive sense, for example, in Gen 4 4 : 3 3 . ^ E D and its derivations are always pejorative and point to sorcery (for example, Exod 2 2 : 1 7 ) . Dftcnn is a loan word and used when speaking of Egyptian (also in Gen 4 1 : 8 ; 2 4 ) or Babylonian (Dan 1 : 2 0 ) soothsayer-priests and also of Daniel (Dan 4 : 6 ) . The words used in LXX are OO$\OT<X'\ and (|>ccp|JC(Kot and E T T C X O I S O I ; the first impression is a negative one, although Dan 4 : 9 63
64
65
66
6 2
See Holladay 1983,241. Collins notes the problem and suggests that Alexander Polyhistor has omitted the blood (1985, 902); however, Artapanus gives a totally new explanation for the plague. Eve 2002, 238. See above p. 93. See Houtman 1995, 372-373. 6 3
6 4
6 5
6 6
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
101
LXX uses the latter for Daniel. Dcnn, as used in the Hebrew text, can be understood to mean "priest", as Artapanus does, and Josephus agrees with him. Still, the "priests" were able to repeat Moses' miracles only by "us ing charms and incantations" - even that a nonbiblical addition. Appar ently, Artapanus had no clear idea of the opponents. He soon calls them physicians (Taxpoi), and he only uses the story to revile the Egyptian re ligion. A major difference in Artapanus - at least in our fragment - is that Aaron is absent and does not throw his rod before the Pharaoh. Moses alone performs the miracles, as he does in Ezekiel's verses. Although Aaron is mentioned earlier, as noted above, he no longer plays a role. Moses needs no helping hand and does not engage in dialogue with God, who is not even mentioned. The problem regarding the different interpreta tions is present again. A reader who is not aware of the biblical original undoubtedly considers Moses a powerful miracle-worker acting alone, in Kahl's terminology a BNP, but a Jew, knowing the biblical original in Exodus, had a more comprehensive view. 67
68
69
The success of the Egyptian priests leads the Pharaoh to use brutal vio lence against the Hebrews, and Artapanus goes on retelling the plagues: "When Moses saw this, he performed more signs and struck the ground with his rod and raised up a certain species of winged creatures to scourge the Egyptians. As a result of his actions, they all broke out in body sores. Even the physicians were unable to cure those who were suffering with the sores. Thus once again relief came to the Jews. Once again, Moses used his rod to raise up frogs as well as locusts and fleas. It was for this reason that the Egyptians set up a rod in every temple. They do the same with Isis be cause the earth is Isis and it produced these wonders when it was struck with the rod. Since the king persisted in playing the fool, Moses produced hail and earthquakes throughout the night so that those who fled the earthquakes perished in the hail and those who tried to avoid the hail were destroyed by the earthquakes. Also at that time all the houses and most of the temples collapsed. Finally, after enduring such calamities, the king released the Jews. After they had procured from the Egyptians many drinking ves sels as well as not a little clothing and numerous other treasures, they crossed the river towards Arabia. They covered a considerable distance and then came to the Red Sea in three days" (Artap. 3,28-33).
The extraordinarily interesting report shows several omissions, alterations and additions when compared with the text of Exodus. The order of the plagues is changed. The darkness and the death of the firstborn are totally omitted and replaced with new catastrophes. Artapanus 6 7
On Moses' opponents in Jub., see above p. 57; in Philo, below p. 113 and 134; in Josephus, below p. 236. On Artapanus and the Egyptian religion, see Koskenniemi 2002, 26-31. See above p. 96. 6 8
6 9
102
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography: Artapanus
obviously did not consider the plagues a fixed set of ten calamities. In any case, he links the plague of the river closely with the meeting in which Moses' rod is changed into a snake and calls both TspaTcx. Unlike in Exodus, there is no opportunity for the Pharaoh to free the people between the plagues, for which Artapanus uses the usual term oripeTa (Artap. 3,31). The next plague, "a certain species of winged crea tures" (£codv T I TTTrjvov), seems to be part of a broader tradition. Although Holladay is uncertain, this certainly is the fourth biblical plague, flies ( K U V O M U I C X , Exod 8:16-28). Philo also describes the flies in a manner that may help to understand Artapanus' words: They were not ordinary flies, and Artapanus tries to describe them. Moses' rod, carefully mentioned here as well, then calls forth the frogs (pccTpccxoi, as in Exod 7:27), locusts ( a K p i 5 a s , as in Exod 10:12) and fleas ( G K V ( ( | > E S , as in Exod 8:13). They seem to form a unity, but we do not know whether this is a result of epitomization. The hardened attitude of the Pharaoh is mentioned again before the following catastrophes, of hail (xcxAa^a, as in Exod 9:22) and earth quakes ( O E I O I J O U S ) . The earthquakes destroy "all the houses and most of the temples" and replace the firstborn's death as the final and decisive plague that ends the slavery (cf. Exod 11:1-2:36). The earthquakes might not be totally nonbiblical: they may be only an exaggeration of hail; or possibly Isa 25:2 and especially Ps 77:17-19 and Num 33:4 LXX form the background. Also, according to Jub., God took revenge on the Egyptian gods by burning them. Nonetheless, it is obvious that omitting the death of the firstborn (which according to speculation, is due to the redaction of Polyhistor) has not made the story much friendlier. That the physicians were unable to cure the people struck with the sores might be commonplace in the miracle stories, but it is evidence of what Jub. seemed to presume: the Egyptians tried to heal the people but they could not, and now Artapanus calls the opponents IccTpoi.The LXX <|>dp|jaKOi (Exod 7:11) may have been a bridge leading from the Hebrew D'SBDD to the common physicians. Although $dpMCCKOs in our sources is always a pejorative word, (|)dp(jaKov is ambiguous and means a 'poison' as well as a 'medicine'. It is still more interesting that several passages again show the influence of magic. Moses uses his rod to call forth and to end the flood (Artap. 70
71
72
73
74
75
7 0
TepccTcc occurs earlier, in Artap. 3,29. On the words, see above p. 74. Holladay 1983, 242. On Philo's interpretation, see below p. 117. See Walter 1980, 135; Holladay 1983, 242. Freudental (1875, 216) and Holladay (1983, 242) consider that Polyhistor has omit ted the death of the firstborn; however, it is by no means certain. See Holladay 1983,242. 71
72
73
7 4
75
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
103
3,28-30), to call "the winged creatures" (Artap. 3,31), frogs, locusts and fleas (Artap. 3,32), as well as to later open the way through the sea and to close it (Artap. 3,36-37). Much of the story is based on Exodus, but Ar tapanus has added magical elements. Moses' rod is not an ordinary rod in Exod either (Exod 4:17), and it already plays a role in Ezekiel's Exagoge. It is interesting to note that one of the features of the Egyptian religion that Artapanus disparaged was that they worshipped the rod in every temple, including the temple of Isis (Artap. 3,32). Yet, the instrument that struck Israel's enemies has even more magical power in Artapanus than in Eze kiel and gives the whole story a new tone. Magic is also present in other additions, i.e. that God's name whispered into the king's ear kills him immediately and that the priest who showed contempt for the name written on a tablet meets a painful death. On the other hand, Artapanus reveals his dual attitude to the power of magic: The priests, under Pharaoh's threat, had no other choice than to repeat Moses' miracles with their charms and incantations. Although it is true that Artapanus does not distinguish the arts of the priests from Moses' skills, it is obvious from Artapanus that Moses did not use the same methods - "my miracles and your magic" is Artapanus' maxim. It was not only the lower echelons of the population that were unable to draw the line between magic that was acceptable and that which was not; the same difficulty could be found at the top of Graeco-Roman society, and it was by no means a strange feature in early Judaism. 76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
d. The Red Sea and the desert We have only a few lines summarising the rest of Artapanus' work. There is a short narrative of the miracle at the Red Sea and a still shorter one on the journey in the desert. See above p. 75. See Koskenniemi 2002, 26-31. It is not obvious how Artapanus' passage should be understood: Does he attribute a role to Isis, i.e. the earth, which produces the marvels (see Eve 2002, 239-240)? Appar ently this is only one of several comical misinterpretations of the Egyptians. The sacred animals, which occur also in Artap. 3,35 and which are ridiculed by the Jews as well as by the Romans, belong to this context; see Koskenniemi 2002, 28. On Moses' rod in Artapanus, see Tiede 1972, 170-174. Tiede 1972, 172; Eve 2002, 238. It is possible that Artapanus here makes a counter-attack on people who considered Moses a sorcerer (see Holladay 1983, 241). See Koskenniemi 1994, 224-226. Josephus proudly presents Solomon as a master of these arts and reveals a broader tradition; see below p. 259. 7 7
7 8
7 9
8 0
81
8 2
8 3
104
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX, see above p. 74.
Artapanus presents two different traditions regarding the miraculous es cape: "Now the Memphians claim that Moses, being familiar with the countryside, watched for the ebb tide, then led the multitudes through the dry part of the sea. The Heliopolitans, on the other hand, claim that the king rushed down on them with full force, carrying with them all the sacred animals because the Jews were crossing the sea, having taken the possessions of the Egyptians" (Artap. 3,35).
A superficial reading could give reason to think that Artapanus wanted to rationalise the biblical miracle-story and was trying to remove an obstacle. Many scholars have explained the stories of several Jewish writers in this way, but, to my knowledge, this explanation has been used very rarely for Artapanus, who served as an example of a Jew who loved "Hellenistic" miracles. Nevertheless, the passage in Artapanus is a good example of how inadequate such an explanation can be. As most of the Jewish writers, he retold many biblical miracles and even exaggerated them, and there is no reason to think that he would want to make the miracle at the Red Sea more credible through rationalisation. He hardly uses the literary technique of distancing himself from the miraculous story, but rather makes a su perficial attempt to transform Exodus into a sort of romantic history. One example of this is that the booty taken from Egypt is now the reason why the Pharaoh pursued the Hebrews. It also explains why the way to Egypt is changed in Artap. 3,22 into a military campaign, although the reinterpre tation contradicts itself later in the fragment. Artapanus allows himself plenty of freedom and is not always consistent. Artapanus goes on with the "Heliopolitan" tradition: 84
85
86
87
"The divine voice came to Moses instructing him to strike the sea with his rod and divide it. When Moses heard this, he touched the water lightly with his rod and the stream di vided, and the multitude passed through the dry channel. When the Egyptians went in together in hot pursuit, he says that a fire blazed in front of them, and the sea again flooded their path. All the Egyptians were consumed by fire and the flood" (Artap. 3,3637).
Georgi (1964, 155) however, considers the passage a rationalisation. According to him, Hellenistic Jewish writers connected the miracle and its rationalisation "in gleichem Atemzug." The view is hardly correct concerning Artapanus. On Philo, see below p. 110; on Josephus p. 228. The technique was admittedly common as of Herodotus (hist. 2,3-4); see Tiede 1972, 135, Walter 1976, 135 and Holladay 1983, 243. There might be echoes of several traditions here. On the one hand, the booty taken from Egypt (Exod 11:2-3) was very important for the writer of Jub. (see Jub. 48:19). On the other hand, the anti-Jewish tradition that labelled the Jews as thieves may have influ enced the story (Fraser 1972, 705; see also below p. 231-232). 8 5
8 6
8 7
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
105
The passage epitomises quite faithfully the biblical original. In any case, some features are hardly fortuitous. It is not surprising that the rod is men tioned again. Unlike the story in Exod 14, Moses hits the sea with the rod and the water is divided immediately. Yet, Artapanus does not stray far from the biblical story and the changes are traditional. The flood com bined with fire is a further step away from Exod 14:24. It is understandable that there is no desperation of the people as in Exod. 14:10-14, no quarrel against the leader and no dialogue between God and Moses. God is re duced to a "divine voice", as already in the theophany in Artap. 3,21. Ar tapanus cannot be characterised as a strict monotheist. He could retell freely the sacred history, but he was deeply rooted in the early Jewish tra dition of honourably reducing the anthropomorphic features of Israel's 88
The way in the desert is described in only a few words in our fragments. 90
"After the Jews had escaped the danger, they spent forty years in the desert. Mean while, God showered upon them meal similar in texture to rolled millet resembling the colour of snow" (Artap. 3,38).
There are few words, allowing only a few conclusions; nevertheless the key passage reveals Artapanus' intended audience. He did not assume that his readers knew the miracle of manna (Exod 16:1-36; Num 11:4-36) but tried to describe it in his own words ((SpEXOvros C C U T O ? S T O U 0 E O U Kpipvov opoiov E X U J J C O X ° TrccpociTArjcHov Tr]v x p o a v ) . It is evidently an attempt to find a broad audience in addition to those who had learned their lessons well. He also reached his goal, because his fragments are summarised by Alexander Polyhistor, a pagan author. I
v
i
e. Conclusion Artapanus took great liberties in his retelling of the biblical stories. He (as well as many later Jewish writers) did not hesitate to give a new shape to the stories of exodus and Moses. This gives us an opportunity to study Ar tapanus' own views on miracles and to inquire the function of the miracles.
8 8
8 9
On Ezekiel, see above p. 75, on Philo, see below p. 119, on Josephus, see p. 241 On Jub., see above p. 61, on Philo, see p. 112, on L.A.B., see p. 194, on Josephus, p.
234. 9 0
A manuscript reads TpiaKOVxa and was preferred by Freudenthal as lectio difficilior; see Holladay 1983, 243. If the reading is correct it would be evidence that Artapanus could make mistakes in retelling the biblical story.
106
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
A feature which should not be overlooked is Moses' role in the miracles, and, moreover, on two levels. Aaron's role is almost omitted, and even God is only rarely mentioned. In the biblical Exodus it is God who is in control. Moses and Aaron are only his servants, and sometimes totally bewildered. Artapanus has re duced God to a "divine voice" (Artap. 3 , 2 1 ; 3 , 3 6 ) . But although Artapa nus' Moses is more assured as to what to do than the occasionally helpless leader in Exodus, the fact that God's role as a speaking and guiding agent has been reduced to a minimum has not reduced his power and sover eignty, but rather increased it. God does not discuss things with men, but wields authority through his sovereign power. He is 6 rfjs o'lKouMewis S E O T T O T T I S ( 3 , 2 2 ) , who (apparently) opens the doors of the prison ( 3 , 2 3 ) and whose name, whispered into an ear, is enough to kill the Pharaoh ( 3 , 2 5 ) . Artapanus, thus, added magical features to the stories, hardly re flecting on the line between acceptable and unacceptable forms of magic. God is now at distance and, as noted in the previous chapter, it has neces sarily led to a redistribution of the roles in the stories. The question is, who was Artapanus' intended audience, and how did it understand his work? A reader well aware of the biblical stories certainly saw the new version in the perspective of the biblical original, but Artapanus obviously wrote his work for people not knowing the original stories. These readers undoubt edly interpreted Moses as a powerful, independent miracle-worker, in Kahl's terminology a BNP, occasionally led by a divine voice. It is not easy to evaluate the impact Artapanus had on the Gentile audience, but the fact that the stories about Moses were well-known among the cultivated pagans implies that he and the writers of his art did have readers, and we owe the fragments of his work to Alexander Polyhistor. Some details attest that Artapanus was also aware of both the GraecoRoman and the Jewish traditions. At times he seems to follow the stories of Sesostris, the Egyptian hero, but the most important feature is that the topos of Trpcoros euprjTrjs has a marked role in Artapanus' texts. What his work shows is an attempt to pre sent men who were wiser, greater and mightier than the Greek heroes. Unlike Philo, the field on which he tried to compete with the pagans was not that of deep philosophy. He was familiar with popular belief and daily Egyptian life. It is understandable that the yearly flood in his view is a miracle made by Moses. Some details attest that Artapanus was also familiar with the Jewish tra dition. The name of Tharmuth is traditional, and Moses' rod has a special position in his work as elsewhere in early Judaism. The opponents are characterised as Egyptian priests, as in Josephus, and because they are
5. Miracles in Popular Historiography:
Artapanus
107
called physicians, Artapanus apparently shared with Jub. the view that they tried to heal the victims of the plagues. It is not easy to find specific contemporizations in the miracle stories, but a general view presents itself. As most of the Jewish writers in Egypt, Ar tapanus did not appreciate native Egyptians and their culture and religion, but sought rather the favour of the Greeks. The way in which Artapanus writes about the Egyptians struck by plagues and killed at the Red Sea is compatible with this view. As mentioned, many scholars have assumed that Artapanus tried to use Moses as a shield against anti-Jewish attacks. Some degree of scepticism towards this view is only reasonable. Certainly the work attests the Jewish tendency to identify more with the Greeks than the Egyptians, and this can be regarded as an apology. However, the main function accorded to the miracles in this work of "competitive historiography" is simple to discern. A free and proud retelling of Israel's history, in which one's hero beats every opponent, can be entertaining.
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo a. Introduction We know Ezekiel and Artapanus only from scarce fragments of their works, but happily we need not study every Jew from some few scant pages nor has every Jewish writer been forgotten. Philo's works give us the opportunity to study his thoughts on the role of the biblical miracleworkers, the problem being the wide scope of his production. No Jewish writer knew the Greek culture as Philo did. Born about 20-10 BC he received an excellent education in Alexandria, the centre of the learned world. He saw the pogroms in the Egyptian city and took part in a delegation to Caligula in 40 AD. The latest date of his life, mentioned in his works, seems to be the year 47. 1
Philo's way of dealing with the biblical texts both literally and allegorically has often been investigated. Dawson formulates well the function of Philo's work: 2
"In contrast to modern historical-critical exegesis of scripture, which begins with the assumption that the ancient communities that produced the text were radically different from our own, for Philo exegesis of the Pentateuch was first of all commentary on the actual history of the community to which he belonged." 3
Similarly, Peder Borgen named his important book Philo of Alexandria. An exegete for his time, expressing the growing interest in the way Philo adapts the biblical stories for his contemporary readers. This question is asked concerning the literal as well as the allegorical interpretation. Although Philo's exegetical method is well researched, his method of retelling the biblical miracles is usually only discussed in passing by scholars. Some details, however, have been investigated thoroughly, as Borgen has done in his study of manna, and some individual miracle sto4
1
He may be pointing to the horse race mentioned by Pliny (nat. 8,160) in the year 47 (Borgen 1997, 14-26; Mondesert 1999, 878-879). On Philo's exegetical tradition, see esp. Alexandre 1986, 13-17 and Borgen 1997. On the allegorical method, see below p. 129-131. Dawson 1992, 116. Borgen, Bread from Heaven, 1965. 2
3
4
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo
109
ries, but not necessarily Moses' miracles, are included in studies concern ing other themes that have been the subject of intensive investigation. Since Meeks (1976), some scholars have suggested that Philo may have also used these stories to illuminate his own times. In his chapter dealing with Philo, Eve does not present a detailed study of the stories about Moses, nor does he inquire whether Philo tried to adapt the stories. He also does not investigate the tradition and the details known to Philo, and chooses to almost completely leave out the allegorical interpretation. Philo's production nearly totally lacks the biblical miracle-workers, the main reason being that the production known to us is basically a commen tary on the Pentateuch, and there were not many biblical miracle-workers to leave out. He deals almost exclusively with the stories about Moses, as well as those about Aaron, but Joshua's role is markedly diminished, and includes no miracles. Is the Pentateuch, however, the sole reason for the lack of miracle stories in Philo's works? He does not, as does Pseudo-Philo in L.A.B., select new stories from the tradition about completely new mira cle-workers. He may retell the life of Abraham quite freely and in new details, but in retelling Gen 12, the role he gives to Abraham is not the same as in Genesis Apocryphon. He tells no new stories about miracles, either Abraham's or the prophets'. Rare exceptions may occur. A story about Elijah is interpreted allegorically: The woman was a widow, which means that she was free from "passions which corrupt and maltreat the mind" and she remembers her sins (cf. 1 Kgs 17:8) as every mind that is on the way to be widowed and empty of evil (1 Kgs 17, Deus 136-138). The prophet had a higher revelation and was taken to Heaven as Enoch (QG 1,86). Otherwise the miracles of the biblical heroes are not retold or rein terpreted, only left out. Did he find the miracles problematic? Actually, with only a few exceptions, the early rabbis were also reluctant to tell about man-made miracles, or even the biblical miracles. According to many scholars, the Jews were not keen to retell miracles, because they feared the pagans would mock them for being too credulous. This is a 5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
5
On Moses as "divine man", see below p. 151-155. Eve 2002, 53-85. On Moses in Philo, see Meeks 1967, 100-131; Tiede 1972, 101-137; Holladay 1977, 103-198; Schottroff 1983, 229-231; Beegle 1992, 916; Barclay 1992, 37-40; OberhansliWidmer 1994, 350. See Feldman 2003, 165-178. See e.g. Abr. 70-71; 95-96. On astrology in Philo, see below p. 111. Cf. QE 2,3, where Philo interprets Exod 22:22 in this way. A special case for Philo, as for some other Jewish writers, is Balaam and his proph ecy; see p. 146 sq. See Becker 2002, 271-289. 6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
110
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
common way to interpret Josephus, but it also occurs in the studies con cerning Philo. Nevertheless, Philo retells the biblical stories about Moses so often and extensively, interpreting them sometimes literally, sometimes allegorically, that they offer the opportunity to study the role of miracles in Philo's thought. 15
b. The literal interpretation of the miracle stories Philo is famous for his allegorical interpretation, but it is interesting to see that he also can treat the biblical miracle stories very literally, especially, but not exclusively, in Vita Mosis, where he retells the life of the hero. Vita Mosis belongs to the wide category of "rewritten Bible", and can be likened to Hellenistic biographies. Who its supposed readers were has long been debated, but it seems to be addressed partly to sympathetic Gentiles, and the work is conceived by the author as a sort of introduction to Juda ism. Borgen points to Mos. 2,43-44, and supposes that the work was writ ten before the pogroms and that Philo expected the Gentiles to accept the Torah as their Law. It does not mean that the work was not directed to the Jews; on the contrary, his own nation was meant to be the main audi ence, but Philo apparently used a doubled strategy. Philo is keen to pre sent Egypt to his readers as though the country and its climate were unfa miliar (for example, Mos. 1,5-7). It may demonstrate that he also intended this work to be read outside of Egypt. 16
17
18
19
20
21
The events of Moses' birth (Exod 1:1-2:25) are embellished with some new details: Philo clearly knows more than he tells. 22
On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX, see above p. 92.
14
See p. 228. Georgi applies the interpretation to Artapanus' fragments; see above p. 104. See below p. 110. The way out of Egypt is briefly summarised in Hypoth. 6,2-4. The details of the bib lical original often occur and they are mentioned below. See Tiede 1972, 106. Mondesert 1999, 880. Borgen 1987, 19. "Moses may be praised by Philo as much to encourage the cultured Jew who tends to be embarrassed of his tradition as to win respect from the non-Jew" (Tiede 1972, 107); see also Dawson 1992, 122. David M. Hay (1991, 52) plausibly supposes that Philo, knowing that Plato, among others, had been read for centuries, expected or at least hoped for a wide and continuing audience. Philo characterises only briefly Moses' parents and family (Mos. 1,7-12). 15
16
17
18
19
2 0
21
2 2
111
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo
An extra-biblical miraculous detail in Philo is that the girl is Pharaoh's "only, cherished daughter", who had been married for a considerable time but had never borne a child, and her father's kingdom was under threat of falling into the hands of strangers (Mos. 1,13). Also, Artapanus and Josephus say that the princess was barren. She had artificially enlarged the shape of her womb to make Moses pass as her real child and not a foundling (Mos. 1,19). Moses is, of course, a gifted child and soon exceeds his teachers from Egypt, Assyria, Chaldea and Greece (Mos. l,19-33). It is interesting that Moses is a master in Chaldean as well as in Egyptian astrology (Mos. l,23-24). When he kills the cruel Egyptian he is not a vile criminal, but a ruler-to-be and a political threat allegedly seeking the kingship (Mos. 1,45-46). Moses is a master in everything, also in manag ing flocks, which, under him, increase even in difficult regions (Mos. 1,6364). All this is told to glorify the legislator, sometimes straining the lim its of human power. 23
24
25
26
27
The meeting with God at Horeb (Exod 3:1-4:17) is presented extensively Mos. 1,65-84). On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX in Exod 3:1-4:17, see above p. 66.
Philo describes the theophany in the bush, which is called T O TepdoTiov and TE0au|jaToupyr|(j8Vov (Mos. 1,71) and interprets it allegorically. He paraphrases the miracles God showed to Moses (arj|je?a, Mos. 1,77; 6au|jaTOUpyrj|jaTa, Mos. 1,71; 1,82), telling all three slightly more ex tensively than in Exodus, but without any significant alterations other than dramatisation (Mos. 1,77-81). Unlike Josephus, Philo does not tell about 28
23
29
See above p. 92 and below p. 233. Artapanus gives Moses teachers from different nations and lets him be a master of all of them; see p. 93. Philo does not completely reject astrology, but has strong reservations; see esp. Op. 58-60, Mig. 178-179; Abr. 82-83. According to Philo, Abraham could only see the stars and the rest of the visible world, but he realised the error: things created have no capacity to control the future. It is the invisible world that is real; the visible is not (see Sandmel 1984, 18). On CnXos in Philo, see Seland 2002, 460. Meeks (1976, 50) notes the topos that the king is shepherd of his people (esp. in Mos. 1,62). "In the midst of the flame was a form of the fairest beauty, unlike any visible object, an image supremely divine in appearance, refulgent with a light brighter than the light of fire. It might be supposed that this was the image of him that is; but let us rather call it an angel or herald, since, with a silence that spoke more clearly than speech, it employed as it were the miracle of sight to herald future events" (Mos. 1,66). See below p. 133. 24
25
26
27
28
29
112
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo
the water-miracle at the theophany, but that God only promises the mira cle. Moses' hand is not leprous but AeuKOTepcc x»ovos (Mos 1,79): Philo either avoids the word Aoipos, or more probably only follows LXX. The snake-miracle (Philo uses the word SpbcKcov, Mos. 1,77) is repeated a little later when Moses starts his mission, but now God and Moses are alone together "like pupil and master", and during the lesson Moses learns to make the miracle by putting his hand to his bosom not once but twice to learn how to make the miracle. It is important to note that Philo does not say that Moses saw God, but a light, r\v av T I S uTTETOTTrioev e'iKova T O U O V T O S el veer KaAs(a0co 5e ayyeAos, and God speaks to Moses 5ia XP^l^M^Sv. In Exod 33:11 God speaks with Moses D'ErtK cms, and in Exod 3:4 it is God himself in both the Hebrew text and the LXX. Philo's version, however, is different. In Exod 3:2 it is, admittedly, God's angel and not God himself that calls Moses, but Philo has chosen the angel and removed God. Jub. introduces the Angel of Presence and Artapanus reduces God to a "divine voice." In Philo's theology God is not anthropomorphic and he is not susceptible to passion in any form. He denies categorically in QG 2,62 that man was created in the image of the Father of Universe, but of his logos. Since it is impossible for a man to see God, he sends the powers which are indica tive of his essence (QE 2,37; 2,47). The device is different, but the theol ogy is the same as in Jub. and Artapanus. The first known representative of the idea is Aristobulus: The anthropomorphic features of the Old Testa ment God are honourably reduced. Moses is reluctant, as in Exodus, but the reasons for the missing elo quence are new and Philo relates many of them: Firstly, the reason is given in Mos. 1,83-84: all human eloquence is, of course, dumbness compared with God's, and "the brother" (Aaron is not named, either here or in the rest of stories) is thus not more eloquent than Moses but his interpreter, ep|jr|V6\JS (Mos. 1,83-84). Secondly, Philo identifies eloquence with skills not suitable for a righteous man, which is clear when he deals with Moses' opponents. The third reason stems from Philo's way to deal with the 30
31
32
33
34
35
36
30
See above p. 235. On Ezek. Trag., see p. 72; on Josephus, see p. 235. On Philo and the pestilence in Egypt, see below p. 117. Philo briefly mentions the three miracles also in Det. 177, when speaking about the orjiJeTov God set to Cain. Usually God shows the nature of each object by means of signs (5id OTjpeiou) as in the case of Egypt. Philo thus plays with two different senses of 31
32
cmjjetov. 33
34
35
36
See especially Deus 51-68 and the comments of Williamson 1989, 74-85. See Helleman 1990, 60. On Aristobulus and the tradition preceding Philo, see Borgen 1987, 13-14. See below p. 134.
113
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo
story allegorically. Whatever the explanation, it is obvious that the liter ate Philo could not consider Moses' lack of eloquence as comparable to human beings, especially when presenting him to a Gentile audience. 38
Philo omits the problematic story about Sippora and God willing to kill Moses (Exod 4:24-26). The miracles in the presence of the elders of Israel (Exod 4:30) are retold, but transferred to the phase after the growing op pression (Mos. 1,90). Philo obviously does not exonerate his people, be cause the elders' disbelief is told in Mos. 1,74. The snake-miracle is retold in Moses' encounter with the Egyptians (Exod 6:28-7:13; Mos. 1,91-94). On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX in Exod 6:28-7:13, see above p. 99.
In Philo's text the short notes in Exodus have grown into stories: The event of "Moses' brother" waving his staff conspicuously ( K C C T a a e i o a s [id\a ETTiSeiKTiKcos) and flinging it on the ground is described dramatically. The most interesting detail, however, is not the dramatisation but the way Philo uses the story to berate his philosophical opponents. Philo calls the sorcer ers oofyiOTCXi and M^yoi, simultaneously attacking both the "sophists" and magicians: Aaron's miracle illustrates that it was not an effect of a v 8 p c o T r c o v ao<|>ia|jaTa KCCI Te'xvas (Mos. 1,94), as the tricks of the sor cerers were. Philo often equates the magicians with his philosophical op ponents (as in Migr. 82-85), using the biblical story either literally or alle gorically to do so. He also equates "the sins of the Amorites" with sophis tical arguments (Her. 304). The "ways of the Amorites" referred later to magic and Philo already seems to make the connection here. As seen above, Moses' Egyptian opponents played very different roles in early Judaism, and Exod 7:11 is open to several interpretations: craDn / ao(]>iaTai, C P S E D D / 4>ap|jaKo{ and crDcnn / 6 T T C C O I 5 O I can evoke various connotations. Philo does not consider the men priests, but chooses the worst alternative he knows, and likens them to his philosophical oppo nents, aoiaTai, and the magicians he despised. The philosophical oppo nents are often attacked in the allegorical interpretation. Philo's view on magic is ambiguous, as so often in classical antiquity, and he differentiates 39
40
41
42
See above p. 133. On Philo's view on rhetorics, see Alexandre 1986, 13-27. See below p. 134. On "the ways of the Amorites", see below p. 214. On Moses' opponents in Jub., see above p. 57; in Artapanus, below p. 100; in Josephus, below p. 236. On the allegorical interpretation of the opponents, see above p. 134. 3 8
3 9
4 0
41
4 2
114
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
between two forms of magic: The "true magic" (x\ ocATi0r|s ijayiKrj), which is acceptable, studies nature scientifically and is practised by the kings of Persia. Another art of magic, KCCKOTEXVICC, the way of charlatans and lower people, deals with charms and incantations. This is rejected by Philo (Spec. 3,100-103; Prob. 74), who actually considers it a religious duty to kill those who practice it. 43
Philo retells the ten plagues (Exod 7:14-12:36) with many new details.
44
On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX in Exod 7:14-12:36, see above p. 70.
Philo gives two different principles so important to him that they change the biblical order of the plagues. These are the idea of the four elements and different agents performing the miracles. Firstly, the Greek theory of the elements is readily adopted to interpret the holy writings. Philo sees the four elements in the war against the Egyptians and divides the plagues to correspond to each of them. The second reason for changing the order is the division between the different agents and their interaction with the dif ferent elements. The first three plagues belonged to the denser elements, earth and water, and were committed to "the brother of Moses"; the second set of three belonged to air and fire, and were given to Moses alone; the seventh belonged to both Moses and Aaron, and the last three God re served for himself. All the plagues have new features. According to Philo, water (Exod 7:14-24; Mos. 1,98-101) is the first tar get, because the Egyptians believe it to be the original source of All. The Pharaoh and the Egyptian magicians are removed from the exaggerated story. The river is afflicted immediately "from Ethiopia to the sea". Not only the fishes but also a great multitude of men die, and the new wells dug by the Egyptians along the Nile (Exod 7:24), are filled with blood (CUMCC, as in LXX). Like Artapanus, Philo completes the story by ending the plague. The Egyptians (not the Pharaoh as in Artapanus) ask Moses 45
46
4 3
See Seland 2002, 460 On the plagues, see Tiede 1972, 134-135. They are mentioned briefly in Mut. 125. Philo gives the division in Mos. 1,96-97 and repeats it often in Mos. 1,96-146. The theory of the elements (OTOIXETCX) was originally created by the Jonian monists. a x o i x s T a was "That out which everything is made, that from which the things first came" (Arist. metaph. 983b,7). Thales gave this status to water, Anaximenes to air, Anaximander to TO aireipov. The theory of four elements (pi^couaTa) comes from Empedocles. It had become the standard view, accepted by monistic, as well as dualistic, philosophers prior to Philo (on the theory see Kraft 1997, 978-980). The theory was commonplace in early Judaism and occurs, for example, in Wis 16:16-17, in which the plagues in Egypt are described. Philo uses the theory often (e.g. Op. 52; 131, Her. 152153), but is also critical and warns of deifying the elements (see Decal. 52-55; Cont. 3-6; Det. 8; Plant. 10). 4 4
4 5
4 6
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
115
and "his brother" to end the disaster. Philo does not say here that the water was good to the Hebrews, but he mentions it a little later (Mos. 1,144), and the same idea also occurs in Josephus andDeut. R. 3:8. The plague of frogs (PccTpocxoi, as in Exod 7:26-8:11; Mos. 1,103-105) has been rewritten. There is no dialogue between Moses and Pharaoh, but Pharaoh promises that they can "leave the land" (the biblical original says that they wanted to sacrifice for God). The plague is dramatized, but it is mainly paraphrased faithfully according to the biblical original. However, the Egyptian magicians are absent again and it is not Pharaoh but the Egyptian people who ask Moses to free them from the frogs. Moreover, the war against the elements is present when the aquatic animals colonise the opposite region. The biblical story about gnats (OKV?(|>SS, Exod 8:12-15; aKvTrres Mos. 1,107-112) especially interested Philo, and not only because it was the first in which God used the earth to afflict the Egyptians. He asks why God chose gnats to punish the Egyptians and gives the answer himself:God does not want to destroy the Egyptians; he wants to teach them a lesson: God does not choose the strongest and greatest, but the smallest to carry out his punishment. Philo then makes a smooth transition to the allegorical interpretation. It is worth noting that "God's finger" is mentioned (Mos. 1,112), not by the Egyptian magicians, who are absent again (Exod 8:19), but by "all Egypt." The mention about the offending practice of sacrifice (Exod 8:21-25) is omitted here, like the whole dialogue between Moses and Pharaoh, but mentioned in Mos. 1,87. The plague of hail (x«Aa^a as in Exod 9:22-35, Mos. 1,118-119) leads to the three punishments mediated by Moses and dealing with the higher elements, air and fire. The rage of the elements is present again. The natural antagonists, thunderbolts and hail, offer a strange scene, and some animals (slaves are not mentioned) survive half-burnt, serving as a warning to the beholders. The plague is preceded by a learned introduction to the Egyptian climate, but as usual not through God's dialogue with Moses (Mos. 1,113-117). In Philo, Moses neither meets Pharaoh nor warns him; consequently Philo does not say that God intentionally raised the Pharaoh to show his power (Exod 9:13-16). 47
48
49
50
4 7
See below p. 237. In Mig. 85 God's finger points to the holy writings. In Sacr. 51 Philo interprets the passage allegorically: Exodus points to virtues, which were abominations in Egypt. The story is the subject of pride in Wis 16:15-23, where the miracle is attributed solely to God. Like Philo, the writer seems to allude to the roles of the different ele ments. 4 8
4 9
5 0
116
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
The fifth plague in Philo (ccKp(5es, eighth in Exodus, Exod 10:1-20; Mos. 1,120-122) has been remodelled. Again, Moses does not meet Phar aoh as in Exodus, and Philo does not include the statement that the He brews wanted to feast e o p T r j in honour of the Lord. Moreover, the wind ( V O T O S PtcnoTccTos, LXX ave|jos V O T O S , Hebrew text nnp rrn) causes many problems, and in addition to the locusts, plays a big part in the disas ter. Philo himself lived in Egypt, and was keen to describe the climate in the country, as if writing to people not aware of it. The Pharaoh is men tioned, but only in dialogue with the Egyptian authorities, and the long discussion between Pharaoh and Moses is omitted, as are God's words pre ceding the plague. The sixth plague in Philo ( G K O T O S , ninth in Exodus, Exod 10:21-29; Mos. 1,123-125) is heavily dramatized. The dialogues with the Pharaoh are again omitted, and in fact it is only Moses who feels pity and prays to God for help without any contact from the Egyptians. The will to sacrifice is omitted, as is the entire dialogue, and so are Moses' words that not even the Hebrews yet knew what they were going to sacrifice. The darkness is partly described "rationalistically", but some exaggeration is involved. Philo considers the possibility of an extraordinary eclipse of the sun and the presence of unusual clouds. However, the darkness was unnatural (Mos. 1,126 o Trccaocv 'i5eav <|)COT6S O U Trapa5ex£To): Even the light of fire could not dispel it and it not only hampered the sight but the other senses as well. Philo, as later L.A.B., Josephus and Melito of Sardes, thus adds the detail that the darkness was not of a conventional kind. This is based on LXX (vpr|Aa(j)rjT6s O K O T O S ) , and it has a significant parallel in Wis 17, where the plagues are generally attributed to God, and the role of human agents is drastically reduced. The darkness is described vividly and extensively. The large number of ghosts cannot be expelled by the light of stars or candles. Philo is aware of the tradition and also interprets the darkness allegorically. The seventh plague in Philo is the sixth in Exodus (LXX BXKT\ in Exod 9:8-12, Philo EAKT) and E'AKCOOIS in Mos. 1,127-129). It is now obvious that the war between the elements and the Egyptians defines the order. Aaron and Moses now govern the earth and air, and work together: Together they take the ashes from the furnace, but only Moses scatters them in the air. Thus the lower elements governed by Aaron and the higher governed by 51
52
53
54
51
Also Wis 17:1-21 retells the story extensively and with new details. See below p. 110. See below p. 193 and p. 238. According to T. Simeon 8 the Egyptians had predicted that an unnatural darkness would follow, when Joseph's bones would be exported from the country (see also T. Joseph 20). See below p. 135. 5 2
5 3
5 4
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
117
Moses strike Egypt together. The sores are exaggerated, but the sorcerers are absent again, and Philo says nothing about the presence of the Pharaoh. The plague of flies, the fourth in Exodus, is the eighth plague in Philo's version, and leads to punishments without a human agent (Exod 8:16-28; Mos. 1,130-132). Exodus uses the word ma, but Philo, like LXX, calls them KUVOMUICC ("dog-fly"), considering them a combination of the two most shameless animals of land and air, the dog and the fly. Artapanus called them £coov T I irrrivov (Artap. 3,31) and seems to agree with Philo that they were not flies of an ordinary kind. L.A.B. (L.A.B. 10,1) and Josephus (Ant. 2,303) share this view. Again, all dialogue with Pharaoh is omitted from the story, but even more interesting, the offending manner of sacrifice (Exod 8:22) has again disappeared along with the dialogue. The ninth plague in Philo, the death of livestock, is the fifth in Exodus (LXX 0avccTOs M^yas ad>65pa in Exod 9:1-11; POTTOKTIMCXTCOV 0dvaTos in Mos. 1,133). It is mentioned very briefly, and the lack of a dialogue with Pharaoh is no longer surprising. What is interesting is that Philo does not avoid the word, which is considered to be difficult for the Jews; on the contrary, he mentions that the death of lower animals often precedes XoijjiKa appcoaTT]|jaTa. As seen above, Jacobson explains the LXX trans lation of n m s D as a result of anti-Jewish propaganda current at the time, which led the translators to avoid words with negative connotations, such as XeiTpa or Xoi|j6s. Philo's word offers contrary evidence. He seems to have no problem with the disease bad enough in the same context, and he speaks of it, although the original did not have the pestilence. The final punishment, the death of the firstborn (TrpcoxoTOKos as in Exod 11:1-12:36; Mos. 1,134-139), is not interwoven with the Passover in Vita Mosis. Consequently, there is no blood on doorframes and no punishing angel. The mourning and fear of the Egyptians is presented dra matically, with the help of an allusion to Euripides. The first to call par ents father and mother had died. There is no preceding or succeeding dis cussion between Moses and Pharaoh, but it is the Egyptian people who now consider the king to be the reason for the plagues and drive the He brews out of the country. The Hebrews collect their booty and start their journey unarmed. 55
56
57
5S
59
5 5
See above p. 72 and p. 235. On the question, see below p. 66. The Book of Wisdom also retells this plague, attributing the miracle to God's wisdom (Wis 18:10-19). Passover often occurs, as in Alleg. Interp. 2,34; 3,165, but it is interpreted allegorically. As Colson notes (1934, 346) the words are very close to TrpcoTrj 6 EKCcAeacc Traxepa Kai au TraTS EME (Iph. Aul. 122). Philo was very fond of Euripides and quotes him often, e.g. Alleg. Interp. 3,202; Prob. 99-103; Spec. 4,47. 5 6
57
5 8
5 9
118
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
In a concluding passage (Mos. 1,143-146) Philo expands the biblical statement in Exod 9:4; 9:26, saying that all the chastisements applied to the Egyptians, none of them to the Hebrews. The Hebrews - and this is obvi ously Philo's fabula docet - were not only spectators, "but learn thereby of the finest and most profitable of lessons - piety. For never was judgement so clearly passed on good and bad, a judgement which brought perdition to the latter and salvation to the former" (Mos. 1,146).
Philo is thus clearly fond of the miracles preceding Israel's freedom. He retells them extensively and vividly and often exaggerates the plagues in a work that was obviously also intended for a Gentile audience. A strong oral and written tradition stands behind his text, which shares many details in common with other writings. Although generally faithful to the biblical original, Philo has made some alterations. It is interesting that he has con sistently removed some elements occurring repeatedly in the biblical origi nal. Firstly, although he briefly mentions the sacrifice of the Hebrews in Mos. 1,87, he does not say anything about the will to offer a sacrifice when de scribing the plagues and even omits the Passover. The reason is unclear. Did Philo only smooth over the difficulties in the story, because it was not the true intention of the Hebrews to offer a sacrifice in the desert? Or did he think about his non-Jewish readers, who could not take part in sacri fices? The description of Egypt's climate shows that he sought readers other than Alexandrine Jews. According to Borgen, Philo wrote Vita Mosis for Gentile readers who were expected to accept the Law (Mos. 2,43-44), and for the Jews to prepare them for their universal role; this is in accord with the situation in Alexandria before Gaius. This may explain why Philo omitted the references to a strange type of sacrifice. Or did the sacri fices simply not play a role in his thought? The most plausible reason, however, is that anti-Jewish propaganda claimed that the Jews practised human sacrifices. The strange type of sacrifice was dangerous enough to be omitted. Secondly, even the sorcerers are consistently omitted. Whatever the rea son - perhaps he was careful not to equate Moses with the sorcerers - it is clear that Philo was not willing to develop the theme of competition. Philo disliked magicians and sorcerers and considered it a religious duty to kill them. Admittedly, Philo's style of writing did not favour dialogues. He has also remodelled or removed the dialogues between human figures, as well as all 60
61
62
Borgen 1987, 18-19. See Jos. c. Ap. 2,89-102 and Rokeah 1995, 286-287. See above p. 114.
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
119
dialogues between God and men in the plagues. The reason is the same that led him to reshape the theophany at Horeb: Philo avoided anthropo morphism and anthropopathism. Thus he is not keen to describe the dia logues between God and Moses as they are written in Exodus. A feature very strongly present is the Greek theory of the four elements. It is so important to Philo that he changes the order of the plagues to clar ify the reason for the events: God has created the world and given the Law, which is the reason why God's commandments are in harmony with the universe (Op. 3). Since Pharaoh broke this harmony it meant a war of the elements (Mos. 2,52-53). Moses, on the other hand, was sent by God, the reason why "each element obeyed him as its master" (Mos. 1,156). The theory of the elements was common property in Philo's times, and a Jew ish Platonist could very well cite them when retelling the holy writings, especially when he could join a broad midrashic tradition admiring the miracles of manna and water in the desert, which interchanged the usual roles of heaven and earth. In the first book of De vita Mosis Philo also paraphrases the miracle at the Red Sea (Exod 13:17-14:31; Mos. 1,167-180) and returns to it in the sec ond book, adding important material. On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and Septuagint in Exod 13:17-14:31, see above p. 74.
Philo has removed God's words to Moses (Exod 13:1-3) and, of course, even his soliloquy in Exod 13:17, and generally emphasizes Moses' role as the leader of the people; however, he does not forget T E p d a x i o v , the cloud that was like a tall pillar (Mos. 1,163-166). Pharaoh's army has the look of an army of Philo's own time (Mos. 1,168), and the whole story is told dramatically. Unlike in some Jewish texts, the entire unarmed nation is in a state of panic. Moses uses his mind and speech simultaneously, his mind to pray to God and his speech to speak calmly to the people. Then, in an interesting new detail, he becomes IvGous and prophesies that the enemy will disappear into the depths (Mos. 1,173-174). There is again no dialogue between God and Moses in Philo, and the pillar and angel are transferred to the moment the Egyptians try to catch the Hebrews crossing the sea. A tremendous south wind ( V O T O S , as in LXX; cf. Hebrew nri? wip n n , east wind) drives the sea back; the tide is partly but not the real reason for the event (Mos. 1,176). Moses is then commanded (rrpoaTaxBeis) to strike 63
64
6 3
On Ezek. Trag. also describing the army, see above p. 77-78. This is actually a result of a very exact reading of Exod 14:13-15: Moses is very calm when speaking to his people, but God asks "Why are you crying out to me?" Philo's answer is that Moses simultaneously spoke silently to God and aloud to the peo ple. 6 4
120
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
the sea with his rod and the sea is suddenly divided (payE?oa). The sea rolls down upon the Egyptians, leaving no survivors. Philo follows Exod 15 and mentions the songs of victory. Although Philo is anxious to use the story allegorically he does not reject its literal sense, but many alterations must be noted. Philo has under stood the narrative problems of the story and he has tried to resolve them. The Egyptian troops appear early in the morning, but do not attack, and the only activity during the daytime is Moses' speech. The wind comes at sun set, then Moses' striking of the sea - a very traditional element - and the sudden division of the sea. Unlike in Exodus the pillar now stands between the Hebrews and Egyptians, preventing the attack. Exodus has both inupT / pf]£ov and the wind. Apparently Philo understands pfj£ov to mean 'strike', because here he has paysTacc and in Mos 2,253 pocysv when retelling the events. Philo has thus inverted the order and apparently tried to retain both elements. In Philo's texts God does not stand in dialogue with men, and as we have seen, this view has led him to edit the miracle stories. The words on the pillar are interesting. Philo considers the pillar to be "one of the lieutenants ( T C O V U T r d p x c o v T I S ) of the great King, an unseen angel, a forerunner on whom the eyes of the body were not permitted to look". Exod 14:19-20 mentions God's angel, and Jub. identifies him with the Angel of Pres ence. Philo is also very careful and retains the gap between the visible and invisible worlds. It is significant that Philo not only considers Moses' words to Israel a prophesy, but also writes that he was £ V 0 o u s . This feature was so impor tant to Philo that he returned to it in the second book and wrote extensively on it. It also leads to important questions, which are treated later. The rejoicing choruses after the defeat of the enemy play an important role. They not only occur repeatedly in Vita Mosis {Mos 1,180; 2,256), but according to Philo, the song of the choruses was always on the lips of the Jews. Spec. 2,216-219 and Cont. 83-85 especially attest how the great exodus was an important part of the glorious past. It is a source of strength for Ben Sira and the writer of Jub., and Ezekiel may have written his play to glorify it during the Passover. The past was obviously used to interpret the presence, and apparently also the future. In Spec. 2,217-219, 65
66
67
68
69
70
6 5
See below p. 136. On Ezek. Trag., see above p. 75, on Artapanus 105, and on Josephus below p. 241. See above p. 61. See p. 148-151. See below p. 148-151. Mishna presupposes that the miracle at the Red Sea is remembered daily (m. Ber 1:5; cf. /. Ber 1:10; 2:1). 6 6
6 7
6 8
6 9
7 0
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo
121
Philo describes extensively the Jewish way to remember the Passover, and gives the content of the canticles sung in the feast. In Cont. 83-87 he tells how the Essenes in Egypt (apparently in their daily prayers) form choirs of men and woman, and after both have made their own contribution, they form a single choir as a copy of the choir set up at the Red Sea. But the passages on the Passover are not the only biblical passage, which attest the role of the past for Philo. Although he understandably often writes obliquely as a result of living in a society controlled by the Romans, his writings clearly attest his eschatological hopes. This is obvious, above all, in the blessing of Balaam (Praem. 93-97; Mos. 1,288-291). Philo shared the hope for the central role of the Jewish nation and for a Hebrew emperor ruling all nations. Some details reveal a Hebrew tradition, which is either accepted or re jected, and now we must expand our study to cover the entire production of Philo. That Moses strikes the sea is commonplace, and Philo on several occasions emphasizes that the Hebrews were unarmed (Mos 1,170; 172; 174). The same is related in Ezekiel and Josephus, but not in L.A.B.; the disagreement seems to be based on the difference between the Hebrew text and LXX. A new feature is the drying of the sea to such an extent that the sand was completely dry. This is emphasized in Mos. 2,254 (sKpaupeoffr] y a p f) vpaMMOS), although it apparently is implied in Mos (ava£r)pccv0EV 656s eupeTa KCCI AecocjxDpos): The detail occurs perhaps in Jub. 48:8-12, and apparently even in L.A.B. Some Jewish writers maintained that not all the Hebrews panicked, and that some wanted to fight. Philo does not have this detail, but he also states that the nation was divided. According to the second book, some were ready to suffer the most miserable death while others wanted to throw themselves into the sea (Mos. 2,249-255). In Ezekiel's drama an Egyptian soldier survives to tell about the catas trophe, but Philo considers otherwise, and he seems to emphasize the fact. Was it his intention to criticise Ezekiel, or a common tradition, or did he simply repeat the biblical detail? According to Jacobson he re buked a competing tradition, as did Josephus, but this is only guesswork. 71
72
74
75
71
See Borgen 1997, 261-281, esp. 265-268; Mondesert 1999, 898-901. See above p. 74. On the same view in Ezek. Trag., see p. 75, in Josephus p. 240, on L.A.B. p. 194. On these details, see below p. 194. "The two sections of the sea rolled upon them from either side, united and sub merged them, horses, chariots and all, with not even a torchbearer (TTUp<|>6pov) left to announce to the people of Egypt the sudden disaster" (Mos. 1,179). See Jacobson 1983, 152. On Ezekiel, see above p. 77. 7 2
73
7 4
7 5
122
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
In Vita Mosis Philo retells the miracles in desert. The people find water as in Exod 15:22-27 (Mos. 1,181-187), but before and not after Elim. On a detailed comparison between the Hebrew text and LXX in Exod 15:22-27, see above p. 20.
The story is greatly expanded and dramatized. "Knowing the weakness of his creatures, and particularly of mankind" Moses prayed and God helped him. He sent in advance the power of his grace (TTJV '(AECOV CCUTOU 5UVCX|JIV) and "opening the vigilant eye of the suppliant's soul, bade him lift and throw into the spring a tree which he showed him, possibly formed by nature to exercise a virtue which had hitherto remained unknown, or possibly created on this occasion for the service which it was destined to perform. Moses did as he was bid, whereupon the springs became sweet, and were converted into drinkable water, so that no one could even guess that they had originally been bitter, since no trace of tang remained to remind one of its former bad ness" (Mos. 1,185-187).
Philo exaggerates the effect of the miraculous event. The Hebrews felt as though they had risen from a banquet: cooTrep euro Soivrjs KCU 'lAapas e u c o o x i a s 6 O T i a 0 e v T e s KCU MEQUOVTES O U TT]V EV OTVCO \JSQT\V aAAa TTJV vrj(|>dAiov f ] V f j K p c c T i a a v x o TCXS TTPOTTOCJEIS A a p d v T E s n a p d TT\S EUOEPETCCS T O U TrpoEOTcoTOs d p x o v T O s ("feeling as though they had risen from a banquet and merry-making, and elated, with the intoxication not of wine, but of a sober carousal which the piety of the ruler who led them had invited them to enjoy"). The wonderful water is reminiscent of the Utopia of Elim in Artapanus' fragment, and there is an obvious con nection with Ben Sira's interpretation in which the twig is linked with the work of the physician. The story raises two questions: 1) Is it adequate to say that Philo has tried to rationalise the biblical original when he says that the tree was possibly unknown until Moses needed it? 2) What is meant by God sending "the power of his grace to Moses"? Both questions are important and are treated later in this study. 77
78
79
7
The wasps sent by God are mentioned in QE 2, 24 and treated briefly both literally and allegorically. On the hornets (cf. Exod 23:28; Deut 7:20; Jos 24:12), see Bietenhard 1986, 190-191. See above p. 50. On the interpretation of the water-miracle in Ben Sira, see p. 20. Philo had no prob lem with the work of the physicians, but mentions them often (see e.g. Prov. 2,60; Cher 15; Sacr. 121; QE 2, 25) and names also Hippocrates several times (Op. 105; 124; Mut 10). See below p. 146-148 and p. 148-151. 7 7
7 8
7 9
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
123
The Pentateuch contains two versions of the story about manna, in Exod 16:1-36 and inNum 11:4-35. In Exod 16:1-36 some minor details only again prove that the Hebrew original the trans lators used differed from the Masoretic text: In 16:6 the Masoretic text has ^tner'-'n, but LXX ouvccycoyrjv uicov lapar|X; in 16:8 MT v^v, but LXX Ka0' f|Ucov, and in 16:8-9 mrr is twice rendered 0eou (also in 16:33). In v. 16:23 the Hebrew text has only Kin, but LXX TOUTO TO pfj|ja ecrnv, and in 16:29 LXX adds Tr|V f||jepcxv TCXUTTIV. In v. 16:31 the Hebrew text is 'PiOcrTPn, but LXX utoi lopanA. In 16:33 nna rasas is rendered axdJJVOV xpvjoouv. Only a few details are of some significance to the content: In 16:13 LXX does not have opxu£, which would be equal to "frtD (Coturnix coturnix), but 6pTuyourJTpa. Liddell - Scott - Jones suppose (s.v.) it to be Rallus grex, 'a bird which migrates with quails', but the erroneous identification is based only loosely on Aristoteles' ornithological wis dom (!). Moreover, the end of the verse in LXX does not yet mention manna at all. In v. 16:14 p i o s o n o is rendered cooet KOpiov AEUKOV. In v. 16:32 the agent has changed: ... DDriK w j n r a ... DDna TfoKn but ov 'e^dyeTe upeTs ... cos e£riycxyev u p a s Kupios. 80
The second version of the story (Num 11:4-36) tells more extensively about quails, and about the spirit which rested on the seventy elders and Eldad and Medad. Some details lead us back to the Hebrew original the translators used: In v. 11:4 is translated KCCI KcxSiocxvTes, in 11:5 LXX adds Scopedv, in 11:14 LXX adds TO pfj|Jo: TOUTO, and in 11:28 the Hebrew text has virnQ, but LXX 6 EKXEKTOS. Moreover, in v. 11:28 "aner ^pi is not rendered yepouoicx, but Trpea|3uTEpoi TOU Aaou A a o u (11:30), unlike, for exam ple, in Exod 3:16; 3:18 and 4:30, and why is again translated opTuyoprJTpcx (11:32).
Philo retells the story about manna in extenso, but not twice, and follows mainly the version of Exodus; the short mention of quails in Exodus, how ever, is expanded in Mos. 1,209. Philo takes the story from Numbers, nevertheless omitting almost all the essential features of the version, including God's dialogue with Moses, the epiphany, the spirit resting on the elders and the severe punishment follow ing the quails. These omissions generally relate to his bias to eliminate God's anthropomorphic features. Philo returns to the story in Spec. 4,126130, dealing now with the punishment: Moses censures those who suppose that luxurious living is the greatest happiness. The story is thus used as a tool for ethical and philosophical teaching. Philo tells about manna more extensively than about the quails, although not as extensively as in Exodus (Mos. 1,191-209). That Moses is possessed of divine inspiration ( 6 5E K a T a T T v e u a 0 e i s I v S e o u s yiveTai KCCI BeaTri^ei 81
8 0
Liddell - Scott - Jones call the bird Rallus grex, apparently denoting Rallus aquaticus, 'water rail'. The bird is not common in Palestine, even less in the desert, because it dwells in humid districts. It does not migrate long ways as quails (Coturnix coturnix), and does not associate with them. Aristotle (Arist. hist. anim. 7,16 597b) apparently means that the birds appear and disappear simultaneously with the quails. On the allegorical interpretation, see below p. 141. 81
124
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
82
Mos. 1,200) may be an echo of the spirit in Numbers. Philo's ex planation is that mortals provide the yearly fruits from the earth, but God can allow the air to produce food instead of water, as the earth produces water, i.e. the river of Egypt waters the fields (Mos. l,201-202). The story about manna shows close familiarity with both the Jewish and the Greek traditions. The bread from heaven is a miracle praised in several early rabbinic sources (Exod. R. 25:2; 6; Mek. 16:4), as well as in the New Testament. Although it is difficult to date the midrashic features, the simi larities are so obvious that they certainly are based on the same traditions as Philo. God allows both heaven and earth to be the source of bread and water, and the people admire the interchange of heaven's and earth's func tions. There is no reason to think that the latter texts are directly dependent on Philo; they are part of a common tradition. On the other hand, also the Greek theory of the four elements serves again as a device for inter preting the biblical story, although the word OTOixeTa or the elder pi^cojjaTa is not used. Philo apparently saw no problem in combining these two traditions and does not hesitate to present the latter in Moses' speech, possessed by the divine rrveuMCc. Here as well as in Mos. 2,258-267 Philo uses the story about manna to emphasize the importance of the Sabbath: that manna had not decayed on the seventh day was an irrefutable answer to the unresolved question passed down from generation to generation; namely, the question of when the world was born (Mos. 1,207). This or)|je?ov led Moses to announce the Sabbath. Philo directs the words to his Gentile audience. The Sabbath is not only a Jewish custom, but a universal festival, and Gentiles observing it attest the superiority of the Torah. Tcc5e,
83
84
86
87
The people get water from a rock as in the biblical original (Exod 17:1-7; Num 20:1-13 I Mos. 1,210-213). Septuagint follows the Hebrew original faithfully in Exod 17:1-7. In v. 17:6 the Hebrew text has nun, but LXX 6 Accds uou. The names are translated in v. 17:7 ( n m o and HOD,
TTeipaouos and AoiSopnois). The deviations are small, also in the second version of the story (Num 20:1-13). In v. 20:4 the Hebrew text has "orttR DO? ma ?, but LXX airoKTeTvai f|uas. In v. 20:5 LXX adds 4
82
Philo repeats the event in Mos. 2,258, where Moses speaks eTnGsiccaas to the peo
ple. 83
On the allegorical interpretation of manna, see below p. 124. See Borgen 1965, 9-20. See below p. 148-151. See Weiss 1991, 99-100. Aristobulus had already connected the holy number seven with the Sabbath, and Philo follows his example to make the Jewish feast universal (see Borgen 1997, 68). The well which "the princes dug" (Num 21:16-18) is presented in Mos. 1,255-257). 8 4
85
8 6
87
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
125
xouxo. In 20:8, LXX uses the plural, indicating that Aaron is included (nKsm and rrpcam, but E£OIOETE and TroxieTxe).
Philo's version is definitely the first of the two biblical versions, although he has, of course, removed the dialogue between God and Moses. He says nothing about the theophany or God's words to the effect that Moses and Aaron will not lead the people to their heritage. Other features are also of interest. The rod, so important in Ezekiel and Artapanus, is also here f] *iepd (3aKTr]pia, and the miracle happens when Moses is 0EO(|>opr)0eis. 88
"... whereupon Moses, taking that sacred staff with which he accomplished the signs in Egypt, under inspiration smote the steep rock with it. It may be that the rock contained originally a spring and now had its artery clean severed, or perhaps that then for the first time a body of water collected in it through hidden channels was forced out by the im pact" (Mos. 1,211).
Philo seems to give a rationalistic explanation for the event, but continues with the theme in a crucial passage, which illustrates that the term "ration alistic" is not easy to use. Nevertheless, the problem has to be noted and it is treated below. 89
Philo also tells about the miraculous battle against Amalek (according to Philo, Phoenicians) and about Moses' prayer and hands, which were deci sive in the battle (Exod 17:8-16; Mos. 1,214-219). LXX renders CTGMK with avSpas Suvaaxous in 17:9 and adds Kai i5ou in the same verse. In 17:10 the Hebrew text has orftn'?, but LXX KOU e£eA0cov Trapexd£axo. In 17:15 LXX adds Kupi'co, and in 17:16 rr od- ?!) T D is translated ev xeipi Kpuc|>a(a. 1
_ ,
The whole story in Philo emphasizes the tactical situation more than the biblical original. Moreover, Philo contemporizes the story by changing the enemy from Amalekites to Phoenicians and embellishes it with new de tails. He writes about Moses' hands and prayer as follows: "But, when they were about to engage the fight, his hands were affected in the most mar vellous way (xepccxcoSeaxccxov TI aunPafvei TTCC0OS nepi x d s X^? S auxou). They became very light and very heavy in turns, and, whenever they were in the former condi tion and rose aloft, his side of the combatants was strong and distinguished itself the more by its valour, but whenever his hands were weighed down the enemy prevailed. Thus, by symbols, God showed that earth and the lowest regions of the universe were the portion assigned as their own to the one party, and the ethereal, the holiest region, to the other; and that, just as heaven holds kingship in the universe and is superior to earth, so this nation should be victorious over its opponents in war. While, then, his hands became successively lighter and weightier, like scales in the balance, the fight, too, continued to be doubtful; but, when they suddenly lost all weight, the fingers serving them as pinions, a
See above p. 75 and 102. See below p. 146-148.
126
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
they were lifted on high like the tribe that wings its ways through the air, and remained thus soaring until the Hebrews won and undisputed victory ..." (Mos. 1,217-218).
The Greek theory of four elements is again part of Philo's biblical exege sis, although the word OTOixeTa does not occur. The higher part of the universe belongs to God's people, the lower, the earth, to their enemies. The Greek theory did not remain unchanged during the centuries between Thales and the first century AD, but was represented in different forms. The passage shows a close relationship with the Aristotelian view, which formed the basis for the philosophical tradition in the Hellenistic period. Philo has omitted the rod of Moses (Exod 17:8), but added that Moses pu rifies himself T O ? S e'lcoBoai KaOappoTs (Mos. 1,216), obviously reducing the magical character of the story. A parallel in Mishna is to be noted.
90
91
All Jewish writers who retold the revolt of Korah and his supporters also remodelled it; Philo does the same (Num 16:1-17:31; Mos. 2,278-287). 92
93
In v. 16:1 the Hebrew text has npn, but LXX Kai EAa'AnaEV, and in v. 16:8 K] ij?OIO is ren dered eWaKouaocTE uou, which indicates W Q E . In 16:5 and 16:11 the Septuagint has 6 Beds and rrpos TOV 0E6V (mrr, m r r " ^ ) . In 16:14 the Hebrew text has *b but the Sep tuagint e'i Kai In v. 16:15 ETTtSuiinua shows that the translators had man and not -nan in their original. In 16:16 *]rnir ?pi nriK is translated' Ayiaaov Trjv auvaycoyrjv aou, and in l
16:24 and 16:27 LXX omits DTQR nro ]m. In v. 16:29 m p a is translated kcct 'ETTIGKE^IV
and in v. 16:30 mrr k i t rmniraKi ccAX fj ev <(>dauaTi 5ei£ei Kupios. A clear deviation is in v. 17:2-3, where the Hebrew text is wwsnn mnna n« nanp *o nK^rrmT 0«rrmi nsnian p o Dntos]n n ^ n , but the Greek Kai TO irup TO aAAoTpiov TOUTO cnrsTpov 'EKE?, OTI
fryiaaav TCX TrupeTa TCOV auapTcoAcov TOUTCOV 'EV TOIS vpuxaTs auTcov. In verses 17:23 and 17:26 LXX adds K a i ' Aapcov, and has in the latter plural ETroinaav instead of the Hebrew singular. In spite of some deviations there is no trace of a theological redac tion of the miracle-story.
In Num the claim of the rebels is that the whole community is holy and, thus, the priesthood should be accessible to them (Num 16:3; 10). Philo, too, speaks about the sacrifice, but emphasizes other points. First of all, it is the statesman Moses who is challenged, as rulers often are ("This is what happens when subjects attack their rulers to confound that most ex cellent promoter of the common weal, order", Mos. 2,277). But secondly, the main target of Korah and his allies is Moses' prophecy. The rebels 94
9 0
See Kraft 1997, 980. According to Mishna, Moses' hands did not decide the battle; the decisive factor was that the thoughts of the Hebrews were either good or bad (m. Rosh HaSh. 3:8a-b). See Becker 2002,133-134. On L.A.B., see below p. 198-199, on Josephus see p. 244-246. On Korah in early Judaism, see also Derrett 1993, 59-78; Feldman 1998b, 91-109. Philo mentions the event briefly in Fug. 145 and retells it extensively in Praem. 7578; however, the story breaks off and there is an obvious lacuna in the text. All dialogue between God and Moses is removed again. 91
9 2
9 3
9 4
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
127
claim that the priesthood was not ordered under divine direction but by a false account (Mos. 2,278). This charge results in a new prophesy. Philo uses the words pETafiaAcov E I S irpocj>TiTr|v, "transformed into a prophet", as Colson translates (Mos. 2,280). Moses prophesies the earth opening and "living men descending into Hades." The prophecy replaces the theophany: mm--QD and God's dialogues with Moses are totally omitted. And, of course, the elements are again involved in the punishment: The earth swallowed them up and the ether added the rainstorm (an extrabiblical de tail unless the plague given by God in the cloud is not meant, Num 16:3250). Philo cuts out the story and does not mention the quarrels following Korah's death. The connection between prophecy and miracle is interesting and it will be studied more closely below. 95
Philo treats the biblical account (Deut 34:1-8) of Moses' death in two pas sages. LXX translates the report on Moses' death very literally. The only point in which the texts differ is v. 34:4: the Hebrew text has rbv, but the Septuagint n p o s MCOUOT|V. Thus, the Septuagint gives no evidence of any speculations on Moses' death.
Mos 2,288-291 tells that Moses' twofold nature of soul and body was re solved by God into a single unity, v o u s . When he was being exalted the divine spirit fell upon him and he prophesied his own end ( c o s 'ETEAEUTTIGE urjuco TEAEUTTJOCXS* MOS. 2,291). This is only an explanation of why the Pentateuch, attributed to Moses, contains an account of Moses' death. The parallel story in Virt. 72-79 does not add much to the material, but QG 1,86 gives a more detailed account of Moses' destiny. Generally death is not the end for worthy and holy men; it is a translation and approach to another place. Moses, however, was a special case: "For he seemed to be rapt away and become invisible. For then he was not found. And this is shown by the fact that when he was sought, he was invisible, not merely rapt from their eyes. For the translation to another place is nothing else than another position; but he is said (to have moved) from a sensible and visible place to an incorporeal and intelli gible form. This gift the protoprophet also obtained, for no one knew his burial-place. And still another, Elijah, followed him on high from earth to heaven at the appearance of the divine countenance, or, it would be more proper and correct to say, he ascended" (QG 1,86).
We have several versions of Moses' death, some of them included in this study. The story in the Pentateuch presented, above all, two points, which offered an opportunity for speculations, which could be closely related with Gentile views. First of all, "Moses" tells about his own death, and 96
On prophecy, see below p. 148 On L.A.B., see below p. 199; on Josephus and the possible Greek models, see p. 245.
128
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
secondly, Deut 34:1-8 first tells about the death and burial of Moses and then says that he was "a hundred and twenty years old when he died, yet his eyes were not weak nor his strength gone". These two details allowed different speculations about the end of his earthly life, namely that he pre served his appearance after his death. In Philo's version Moses does not die, but his end is paralleled by Elijah's ascension. What Philo says about Moses' end must be viewed against his ideas about anthropology and the destiny of man generally. The soul is pre-existent, a visitor in this world, residing in the body (Deus 1-2), while death is the soul's separation from the body (Alleg. Interp. 1,105-108). However, although death generally means the freeing of the soul, a holy man's death is always something spe cial, as was Abraham's: 97
98
"So too, when Abraham left this mortal life, 'he is added to the people of God' (Gen 25:8), in that he inherited incorruption and became equal to the angels" (Sacr. 5).
The texts quoted attest that Philo had no problem in reconciling Moses' death with his philosophy. Moses, although the best and wisest of all, went the way every man, especially the wise man, goes. To summarise, we can recognise some clear lines of direction in Philo's paraphrase of the miracles in Egypt. Philo is generally very exact in retelling the biblical stories. He stands, of course, in the midrashic tradition and consequently can add and empha size what he deems important. He often exaggerates the miracles, al though he sometimes even diminishes the miraculous. Still, he is quite faithful in rendering the biblical original. He gives Aaron a role almost equal to that given in the Pentateuch, although he seems to be unwilling to call him by name. He omits very few biblical miracles and treats most of them literally. The punishment of Miriam (Num 12:1-16), however, and the story about the bronze snake (Num 21:4-9) are interpreted only allegorically. In any case, a literal interpretation of the biblical miracle sto ries was by no means strange to Philo. 99
100
9 7
For this observation I thank Prof. Ruairidh Boid (Melbourne), who was kind enough to send me his unpublished manuscript (A Pair of Ancient Samaritan Eschatologies). He investigates the rich traditions of Moses' death among the Samaritans. Borgen (1984, 125) cites also Mark 9:2-8 par attesting the thought that Moses did not die. Philo himself tells about this tradition in Mos. 1,4: "(I will) tell the story of Moses as I have learned it, both from the sacred books, the wonderful moments of his wisdom which he has left behind him, and from some of the elders of the nation; for I always interwove what I was told with what I read, and thus believed myself to have a closer knowledge than others of his life's history" (see Borgen 1984, 124). See below p.l42and 141. 9 8
9 9
1 0 0
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
129
Philo
Philo tends to remove all human weakness from Moses' image. Exodus presents him as a reluctant leader, not eloquent enough, and occasionally anxious about his own rebellious people. In one way or another Philo has reduced or removed these features, and it is important to observe the passages exalting Moses above other human beings (see below p.151-155). Whether a Palestinian midrashic tradition can be separated from the Al exandrian is an old problem, and Philo's large production is perhaps the best source for an answer to the question. However, it does not seem possible to trace separate traditions in the details of Exodus. What we have in Philo we may have also in Sir, Jub. or in Ezekiel / Artapanus, or in both. But did Philo adapt the biblical stories to shed light on his own times? Some stories denote that he did, but we also need to study the allegorical stories before coming to a conclusion. Two interesting features give reason for a closer examination. On the one hand, Philo combines Moses' miracles with prophecy. On the other hand, he seems to treat some miracles "rationalistically." Both problems are treated in more detail below. 101
102
103
c. The allegorical interpretation of the miracle stories Philo is famous for his allegorical interpretation of the Bible, so it is not surprising that he also interprets the miracle stories in this way. It is impor tant, firstly, to understand his exegetical method and, secondly, to study whether he used the method to adapt the stories to his own world: Some scholars have questioned whether Philo used the allegorical interpretation as a commentary on life in his contemporary Alexandria. Borgen has stud ied Philo's words on Hagar and Sarah, i.e. on the Greek and Jewish educa tion, observing that Philo was worried about the possibility of Jewish youth being led astray from the Jewish belief. Whether Philo contempo rized the miracle stories to teach his fellow Jews (as especially Meeks and Birnbaum have assumed concerning some details) is worth asking. The pivotal study of Irmgard Christiansen (Die Technik der allegorischen Auslegunswissenschaft bei Philon von Alexandrien, 1969) on the method Philo used is still an important tool for an analysis of the pas sages, although it can justifiably be called too schematic. She showed 104
105
106
107
See also Holladay 1977, 174-177. On the history of the question see Borgen 1984, 124-125. See below p. 148-151. Borgen 1997, 163-164; Birnbaum 2003, 322-323. See below p. 132. On Philo's allegorical method and its roots in general, see also Sandmel 1984, 13-
130
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
that Philo did not merely borrow the method from Homeric interpretation, applying it arbitrarily to the Scriptures, but that he used a well-reflected tool filling all scientific requirements of his own time. The method fol lowed the Platonic doctrine of ideas: Plato considered the world of ideas real and tried to find it behind individual beings. His followers tried to sys tematise the world with the dialectic, diaeretic technique of disposing real ity, often with the help of the ten Aristotelian categories. A good exam ple is Speusippus' use of the method to define animals and plants. In the dialectic, diaeretic technique, an individual plant was defined by contrast ing it with other plants to find its 6 v with help of its |jr| 6 v , but the func tion of the system was to find the One including everything (TrdvTa Trepiex )Philo shared the concept, but in his view the world of ideas was hidden in the words of the Scripture, and the diaeretic technique was used to carefully define the individual truths in the Scripture, the result being to find their relationship with other phenomena or concepts ( T O 6Tepov), mostly outside the Scripture, but defined in the same way and presented as symbolic of the biblical word. This relationship between two concepts defined similarly and diaretically is the core of the allegori cal method, and the intention was to find the general truth behind individ ual truths. Christiansen's book is complemented by Dawson's chapter on Philo in his Allegorical Readers and Cultural Revision in Ancient Alexan dria (1992). Philo never defines his allegorical method and often only briefly justifies his interpretation. In fact, he may not always have a systematic analysis in mind: Yet, Philo is often treated too systematically. Nevertheless, he some times gives a full argumentation for his view. The pattern is then as fol108
109
o v
1 1 0
111
112
113
114
22; Borgen 1984, 128-132 and especially Dawson 1992, 23 (non-Jews) and 74-82 (Jew ish writers). On Philo's allegory of the miracle stories, see also Tiede 1972, 132, Schottroff 1983, 229-231. Eve almost totally excludes the allegorical interpretation (2002, 53; but see 2002, 81-82). Borgen 1997, 149. The Stoics are usually considered eager allegorists, but the evidence for this tradi tional view is surprisingly meagre; see Long 1997, 198-210. Booth (1994, 160-161) quotes several interesting passages showing how important the dialectic between the opposite concepts was to Philo. Christiansen 1969,30-35. A reason why the truth was hidden in Philo's view was that Moses had to use human language in spite of its limitations; he used many words referring to the same objects and Philo is eager to find the synonyms (Dawson 1992, 91-97). Christiansen 1969, 29-46. On the way the eternal truths ended up in the Septuagint; see Dawson 1992, 85-90. Christiansen 1969, 47-98. Christiansen 1969, 53-74 studies the passages in Somn 1,102-104 / Exod 22:25; Somn. 1,33-156/Gen 3:1; Alleg. Interp. 2,72-76 /Gen 48:19 and Alleg. Interp. 3,90-93. 107
108
1 0 9
1 1 0
111
m
1 1 3
1 1 4
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
131
Philo
lows: 1) Philo quotes a biblical verse 2) he claims that a concept is T O ETepov, a symbol of another concept, 3) he shows the similarity between the definitions of the two concepts using either diaeresis or the etymology of the biblical name. Concerning the miracle stories interpreted allegorically, Philo sometimes gives an extensive argumentation, but often we only have to guess his line of thinking. The stories are very often interpreted with the help of a single, important pattern: Egypt represents everything bad and the escape from there is a spiritual emigration. Philo lived in Egypt, but he tried to find points of contact with Greeks, and did not hide his general dislike of the Egyptians (see e.g. Legat. 162173) and especially of their religion (Post. 165, Contempt. 7-8). Allegorically "Egypt" means TTCX0OS (Congr. 85-88) or land of the passions (Alleg. Interp. 3,38; 3,81; 3,94). This allegory is obvious outside and in side the retold miracle stories. The golden bull represents Egyptian vanity (Mos. 2, 270), Egypt is the land of sophists (for example, Migr. 83-85), and even the offensive Hebrew way to sacrifice (Exod 8:26) refers to vir tues, which were abomination in Egypt (Sacr. 51). The king of Egypt, "that is of the body", is 6 a v T i 0 E O s vous (Conf. 88) or "the mind which usurps the place of God" (Somn. 2,182-183). Since Egypt is the land representing everything bad, the way out repre sents the righteous man's own development. The whole Book of Exodus derives its name from the fact that the holy law means E^aycoyr] of the soul from the body. Philo formulates it very clearly in Migr. 14 (cf. even Migr. 151-155): 115
116
117
"Right well, then, did the Sacred Guide inscribe one entire sacred book of the Law giving 'Exagoge' or 'Leading out', for the name thus found was appropriate to the ora cles contained in it. For being well qualified to train men and fully furnished for the ad monition and correction, he contemplates the task of taking out all the population of the soul right away from Egypt, the body, and away from its inhabitants."
This thought is repeated again and again in Philo. Post. 155-156 uses the same theme: The whole way from "Egypt" means a battle against the bod ily passions and sexual lust, whose appeals to turn back are constantly heard. In the same way as Moses withdrew from Egypt, the soul flees the passions (Alleg. Interp. 3,12-13). These passages show that Philo 118
119
1 1 5
1 1 6
1 1 7
1 1 8
1 1 9
This was a common attitude among the Jews; see Koskenniemi 2002, 20-23. On sophists, see below p. 134. Philo, as Ezekiel (see p. 66), calls the biblical book' E^aycoyrJ. See also Agr. 88-89. See also Alleg. Interp. 3,37-39; 3,81; 3,175; Cher. 74-77; Sacr. 135.
132
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo
considers the way from Egypt a spiritual emigration, and Philo uses the whole of the exodus as a lesson in ethics, i.e., the soul must be free from bodily passions. Abraham's departure from Chaldea was a similar spiritual 121
emigration. The pattern of spiritual emigration is a good example of Philo's use of the allegorical method. He tries to advance from details in the Scripture to universalities and to find the similarities between two concepts. In this pattern Egypt easily finds its STEpov namely rrdSos, and all the details, repeated again and again, find their correct place in his interpretation. On the other hand, Philo is, as shown by Helleman, heavily and openly dependent on Plato's Theaetetus. In Fug. 60-64 he quotes this text, and considers it man's mission to flee this earthly sphere and return home in ouoicoais 0ec3 (cj>uyr| 5e O M O I C O O I S 8eco KaTa S U V C C T O V ) . According to the Platonists and Stoics, the invisible world, Koajjos vorjxds, is real, but the visible, K O O I J O S cnaSrjTtKOs, is unreal, and Philo shares this basic view. This is undoubtedly the sense of the entire spiritual exodus in Philo. Moses' miracles are often interpreted similarly. Philo uses the sto ries on exodus to universalise the Jewish religion and to link it with Greek wisdom. Exodus was not, as Dawson notes, celebrated once a year; it now became ever-present. An important - and difficult - question is whether Philo used the pattern to contemporize the stories, using the past to elucidate life in contemporary Alexandria, as especially Meeks and Birnbaum have generally sug gested. As seen above, Philo generally disliked the native Egyptians, but the Greek population was also active in the pogroms in the years of Ca ligula. But although Philo does not hide his views in Legatio, he never un ambiguously uses the pattern to support his fellow Jews, who were under political pressure. If this was his intention, he writes with extreme caution. Moreover, as seen above, we cannot date Philo's treatises exactly. Borgen supposes that Vita Mosis was written before the pogroms and that Philo still had hope that the Gentiles would accept the Law, but Meeks considers this text to be a part of Philo's defence against attacks. The most obvi122
123
124
125
126
127
Symbolically, the entry into the country was an entry into the right philosophy; see 0*2,13. SeeAbr. 66-69; Migr. 9-10; 195 and Sandmel 1984, 17-18. Cf. also the way through Edom, Deus 148-161; Agr. 65. Helleman 1990, 51-71; see also the parallel work of Runia 1988, 48-75. See Helleman 1990, 51-54. See also Deus 31-32 and Migr. 9-10. Dawson 1992, 98-99. Meeks 1976, 45-54; Birnbaum 2003, 323-324. Borgen 1986, 19; Meeks 1976, 45-54. 121
122
123
124
125
126
127
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
133
Philo
ous adaptation seems to be the words o C C V T O E O S vous in Conf. 88, which Birnbaum plausibly connects with Gaius. 128
The story about the burning bush could be interpreted allegorically (Mos. 1,67-70) as a symbol of people suffering wrongs: "Yet that which burned was not burnt up, and this was a sign that the sufferers would not be destroyed by their aggressors, who would find that the aggression was vain and prof itless while the victims of malice escaped unharmed" (Mos. 1,67).
Some scholars have plausibly seen here an adaptation of the story. The Jews were oppressed in Alexandria, but they would never be defeated. The problem is again the date of the work. The question is asked again, when all evidence is collected. The rod of Moses, so important to Artapanus and possibly to Ezekiel, also awakens Philo's interest in the theophany (Exod 4:1-4:17). However, Philo's interpretation is totally different, although he also calls it f) 'lepa (3aKTr]pia (Mos 1,211). This is a part of a wide and important treatise dealing with Gen 2:18-3:1, according to which the creation of Eve must not be taken literally. God created first the mind, and then the senses and passions to be its servants (Alleg. Interp. 2,1-11). The treatise tells how the mind must be able to control pleasure. Passions and senses are thus T O ETEpov for Eve. Biblical miracle stories are often used to clarify this pat tern. Philo finds here a |JE0££IS between the rod and education. The rod is a symbol of T r a i S E i a , and a good education, like a rod, supports a virtu ous man. If the soul throws it away, it seeks more lust than virtue (just as Moses' rod became a snake) until the man again takes control over the passions (Alleg. Interp. 2,90-93). A good education was an important theme for Philo, and here, too, he adapts the biblical story to elucidate its significance. Exodus tells us that Moses lacked eloquence (Exod 4:10), and the literal, but especially the allegorical, interpretation gave Philo the opportunity to explain the Lawgiver's words. In Det. 38-40 he briefly deals with the theme, which he treats more extensively in Mig. 78-85, describing how God promised Abraham Aoyos - Philo's interpretation of the word EuAoyrjaco (Mig. 70-117). He uses Moses' lacking eloquence as part of his argumentation. The pairs of concepts are now Moses / Aaron and vous / Aoyos. Moses is vous and Aaron Aoyos. vous does not need help in deal129
130
131
132
133
Birnbaum 2003, 324-325. Meeks 1976, 48-49; Birnbaum 2003, 323-324. See below p. 157. On Moses' rod in Artapanus, see p. 102, on Ezekiel, see p. 102. See Christiansen 1969, 47. See Goulet 1994,357.
134
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
ing with God, but only dealing with alaSrjais, TTCCOOS and oco(ja, which are represented by Egypt and the "sophists." Aaron, i. e. speech, is needed to defeat the Egyptian magicians, i.e. wrong philosophers ridiculing God's miracles. The opponents are connected with the rod and snakes in the allegorical interpretation. When Aaron's rod becomes a snake and eats the snakes of the Egyptian magicians, it has a deeper sense: 134
"For all the arguments of sophists are devoured and done away with by Natures manysided skill, and the acknowledgement is made that these events are the 'Finger of God', and the word 'finger' is equivalent to a divine rescript, declaring that sophistry is ever defeated by wisdom, for Holy writ, speaking of the tables on which the oracles were engraved, says that they were written by the 'finger of God' wherefore the sorcerers can no longer stand before Moses but fall as in a wrestling-bout vanquished by the sturdy strength of the opponent" (Migr. 83-85).
The pairs of concepts are now Moses / ydyos and true philosophers / It is by no means the only passage in which Philo regards the sorcerers as both sophists and sorcerers. Philo calls the sorcerers ooc|)iG T O U (as LXX, Exod 7:11; Exod 7:26 oi enaoiSoi) and [idyox in Mos. 1,92-94 and equalises them also in Det. 38-40 and Migr. 76-85. "Sophist" is generally one of the worst words Philo can use to characterise a man. He not only means Protagoras (Post. 35), but generally his followers, too (e.g. Det. 1; 72). Philo thus uses the words in LXX to interpret the sorcerers as false philosophers. After Socrates, it was common to criticise the rhetori cians and sophists for using speech and words for the purpose of seduc tion, and for Philo this was one, although not the only reason, why Moses lacked eloquence. Philo uses the biblical miracle-story to fight his contemporary philosophical opponents, partly supported by Platonic criticism. ao<|>iOTai.
135
136
137
138
The plagues are sometimes interpreted allegorically and the symbols are usually easily found. The plague which turns the Nile into blood is part of a larger context (Somn. 2,237-260). In Joseph's dream of standing on the edge of the river (Gen 41:17), Philo considers the river a symbol of speech. Both river and speech flow outward and both can be either beneficial or harmful. Philo does not deal with earthly rivers, but connects the passage with ethical in-
Also in QE 2,27, Moses is the most pure and God-loving mind and Aaron his word and the unlying interpreter of the truth (see QE 2,44). On the literal interpretation of the opponents, see above p. 113-114. See de Romilly 1975, 91; 69-88. See Winter 1997, 92; 104-105, and above p. 134. See Winter 1994,91-94. 1 3 5
1 3 6
1 3 7
1 3 8
135
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation: Philo
struction. The two rivers, Euphrat and the river of Egypt (Gen 15:18), mean soul and body (Somn. 2,255-258). The river of Egypt changed into blood represents speech that calls for censure: it is ill-trained, ignorant and practically soulless, and cannot provide nourishment, for none can drink the speech of indiscipline. A good river produces fish (=thoughts), but a bad one kills the thoughts as the Nile kills the fish; moreover, it produces only frogs. Christiansen's pattern works perfectly: Philo 1) quotes a bibli cal verse, 2) says that speech is T O eTepov to the river, and 3) defines both concepts to show the similarity. The frogs mean "soulless opinions and conjectures, which produce noise and sound destitute and devoid of all reality." Pharaoh wanted to put off being free of them until "tomorrow", just as evil people want to main tain the unchanging level of their godlessness (Sacr. 69-71). The plague is only one link in a long chain of evidence against Cain's offering. The evidence consists of two parts: he offered "after some days" instead of at once, and he did not offer the first-fruits (Sacr. 52). The frogs belong to the former part. Good deeds should be done eagerly and without delay; Pharaoh is presented as a typical man acting as Cain and not seeking help from God, as 8Trajj(|>opiaTai generally do, seeking help from every other direction but only reluctantly from God. The uncommon darkness (vpTiAa^rjTOs . . . O K O T O S ) is understandably contrasted with God's light: The children of Israel had light in all their dwellings, which means that the darkness did not touch the body but the soul (Somn. 1,114; 117). This is a detail in a long passage (Somn. 1,72119), in which Philo interprets the words "for the sun was set" (Gen 28:11) as meaning several things, including human beings, sense-perception, God's word or God himself. The darkness in Egypt is part of the argumen tation for the last alternative (Somn. 1,87-119). Exod 22:25-27 tells man to give back the garment to the poor before the sunset. Philo takes the gar ment for reason (Aoyos), which is the only thing man really needs before the sun sets, i.e. before God leaves men in terrible darkness, as once hap pened to the Egyptians. The darkness, interpreted metaphorically as in Wis 17-18, is here only a small detail in the argumentation in which God is T O 139
140
ETepov to the sun.
t
The firstborn of the Egyptians are interpreted as lust, desire and other vices in Somn. 2,266. The context is the passage mentioned above about speech as a good or bad river, but now Philo gives human lips (xeTAos) two possibilities, citing the words about the bank (yjf\\os) of the river (Gen 41:17): either be silent or talk wisely. An argument encouraging si139
The frogs and the hail are briefly mentioned in Mut. 20-21. The passage is closely related to the interpretation of Gen 37, where "all the sophists of Egypt, augurs, ventriloquists, soothsayers" etc. sprang up from the Nile (Somn. 1,220). 140
136
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
lence is Moses' message to the Israelites: "The Lord will fight for you; you need only to be still" (Exod 14:14). As God's power once subdued the Egyptians, so his aid destroys "lust, pleasure, grief and fear, and injustice, folly, licentiousness with all their brethren and kin" and helps a man learn ing to be quiet and waiting for God's help. The pairs of concepts is thus river / speech and x^Aos = bank / x^os = human lips. The Passover and the destroyer, omitted in Mos. 1, occur in Alleg. Interp. 2,34, in the treatise dealing with the mind's mission to control the senses and passions. In this passage the context is Adam's sleep, sent by God, which means the mind's trance when it ceases to be engaged with the ob jects appropriate to it. Every soul meets this change, but God's people, unlike those who do not know him, do not sleep until they die. The de stroyer blocked from Israel's houses is destruction threatening the soul. Sacr. 62-63 also interprets the Passover as a fight against the passions. 141
142
143
144
The details in the final struggle between the Egyptians and the Hebrews (Exod 13:17-14:31) are often interpreted allegorically, as seen from the examples above. In Conf. 60-82 Philo explains Gen 11:2. Philo tells about a people who moved eastward and found a plain in Shinar, which he interprets "shaking out." According to Philo they actually moved away from virtues and shook them out. This is again applied to individuals, and the Egyptians, shaken and disordered in Exod 14:25, represent those who love the body, "who are shewn to us as flying not from the water but under the water, that is under the stream of passions" (Conf. 70). The events at the Red Sea thus serve as a small detail in the argumentation that moving to Shinar allegorically means moving away from virtues. In Philo, the king of Egypt was not an ordinary king, but "the boastful mind with his six hundred chariots, that is the six movements of the or ganic body" and the soldier did not ride a horse against Israel, but a soul with passion (Ebr. 111). This is only a part of a larger context and is of minor importance. Philo deals with several views on wine in Moses and sees it, among other things, as a symbol of foolishness or foolish talking (11-153). An example is a disobedient son, who is compared to the Israel ites' noisiness and worshipping of the golden calf; the opposite of this
See also Sacr. 134, where Philo deals with Num 3:13, comparing the firstborn of Egypt to "the most dominant elements of blind passion" and the firstborn of Israel to virtue. See also Alleg. Interp. 3, 165, Migr. 25 and Her. 255 See above p. 133. The context is presented above; see p. 135. 142
143
144
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
137
noise is the victorious song after the events at the Red Sea. Also here the smaller detail is used in ethical instruction. The cloud between the two peoples was A o y o s , which separates the good people from the evil. 145
"For on minds of rich soil that could send in gentle showers the drops of wisdom, whose very nature exempts it from all harm, but on the sour of soil, that are barren of knowl edge, it pours the blizzards of vengeance, flooding them with a deluge of destruction most miserable" (Her. 203-204).
Logos or wisdom is also identified with the cloud in Wis 10:17-19 and Philo obviously borrows from the same tradition, in which wisdom is pre sented as a widely independent being. Philo also deals with Moses' prayer at the Red Sea in Her. 14-19, eluci dating Abraham's bold way of speaking to the Lord (Gen 15:2-3). Exodus does not tell about Moses' prayer, but God asks why Moses is shouting at him, showing, according to Philo, that man is not in contact with God with his body but with his soul. In Conf. 36 the death of the Egyptians did not mean the separation of the soul from the body, but the end of godless teaching and thoughts. In this treatise Philo again plays with the word x ^ o s , now in Gen 11:1, and takes it to mean both human lips and a river bank: It allows him to link the events on the bank of the river with his moral instruction. A "symphony of evil" not only lives in multitudes, but also inside an individual. As Moses met Pharaoh on the "lip" of the river, so too were the Egyptians destroyed on the "lip" of the sea. Somn. 2,279-282 has mainly the same content. It is not only the Egyptian army but also, and especially, the wrong phi losophy that wars against virtue and is beaten. The context here is also XeTAos, although the aspect is different. 146
147
148
149
150
145
The horse is a symbol for passion, and the Egyptian rider is a mind in control of the passions - both are four-legged, because Philo adopts the view of four passions. The wider context is the main instruction in the treatise described above (see p. 133). The same interpretation occurs in Agr. 82-83. See Sandelin 1986, 106-107. "For Israel, it says, saw the Egyptians dead on the edge of the sea - not elsewhere. And when he says 'dead' he does not mean the death which is the separation of soul and body, but the destruction of unholy doctrines and of the words which their mouth and tongue and the other vocal organs gave them to use" (Conf. 36). Somn. 2,269-270 identifies briefly the rider cast into the sea with passion. On the one hand, the event meant a requital of all evil done by Pharaoh, but the story had a deeper sense: "Three messages, the best of tidings, does this text proclaim to the soul, one that the passions of Egypt have perished, a second that the scene of their death is none other than the lips of that fountain bitter and briny as the sea, those very lips through which poured forth the sophist-talk which wars against virtue, and finally that their ruin was seen" (Somn. 2,279-280). See above p. 134. 146
147
148
149
150
138
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
The praise after God's miracle is reinterpreted. Miriam (aTa0r)ais) led women, Moses ( v o u s ) men, "for it is right with both mind and sense to render hymns and sing blessings to the Godhead without delay" (Agr. 7983). Although briefly, cuo0r)ois is thus established as T O ETEpov for Miriam and v o u s for Moses. The events in Egypt were not the only subject that could be interpreted allegorically. The way in the desert was another. The entire journey was, of course, the way out of Egypt, the country of the body, and it took more than three days because of the "mixed and roughed multitudes" (Migr. 154). Spiritual emigration is a crucial theme in Philo's works. The water miracle at Marah (Exod 15:22-27) offers a possibility for sev eral interpretations, although the main pattern remains the same: That the water at Marah was bitter denotes that pleasure still harasses the wise man and tries to tempt him back to Egypt, i. e., to his earlier manner of life, but God produces the love of labour instead of the hatred of labour. In the passage in Post. 155-157 quoted above it is easy to define Philo's train of thought. In the wider context (Post. 124-157) the key word is water. Philo uses etymology as his tool, claiming that Seth means TroTiajJos, and the way is open for establishing water as T O ETEpov for wisdom: As water gives life to seeds and plants, so wisdom shoots up and improves (Post. 125). In this context the water at Marah is applied to an individual willing to return to "Egypt", but God prevents it with his food for the soul. Philo makes use of a broad tradition originating in the Old Testament (Prov 16:22 LXX). The interpretation in Congr. 163-167 is similar, but now the context is a proper education, which is an obvious contemporization. Philo was afraid that his fellow Jews would seek a Greek education only to get a good posi tion. He points to the right path: Although Hagar, the Greek education, 151
153
154
151
Cf. Mos. 1,147. Philo clearly uses the topic as an exhortation against intermarriage in his times: He uses hard words about the mixed people. They were accompanied by a "promiscuous, nondescript and menial crowd, a bastard host, so to speak, associated with the true-born. These were children of Egyptian women by Hebrew fathers, into whose families they had been adopted." On intermarriage in early Judaism, see Sanders 1994, 266. See above p. 131. See Sandelin 1986, 94-95. The question was a burning one in Alexandria. Philo, worried about the motives of his fellow Jews, applied a well-known Hellenistic allegory to the suitors of Penelope: a man may seek education because of bad motives (Alleg. Interp. 3,167). Philo applies this view to sacred history and to the relation between Abraham and Sarah / Hagar; see Borgen 1984, 116-117; Borgen 1997, 125; 162-165. 152
153
1 5 4
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
139 155
is needed, it is definitely subordinated to Sarah, the real philosophy. It means that a student is tested as Israel was in the desert, with the bitter water at Marah. Some people fail, but others let neither hunger nor thirst enslave them, and they will finally find their way. Also, in Migr. 36-38 the bitter water is combined with an exodus, but it is the spiritual wandering of Abraham that is used as model for everyone. This context contains Philo's famous words on inspiration given by God (Migr. 34-35) and immediately afterwards the passage telling how God makes everything sweet: 156
"Now the thing shewn is the thing worthy to be seen, contemplated, loved, the perfect good, whose nature it is to change all that is bitter in the soul and make it sweet, fairest seasoning of all spices, turning into salutary nourishment even foods that do not nourish. So we read: 'The Lord showed him a tree and he cast it into the water', that is, into the flabby, flaccid mind teeming with bitterness, that its savagery might be sweetened away. This tree offers not nourishment only but immortality also, for we are told that the Tree of Life has been planted in the midst of the Garden, even Goodness with the particular virtues, which accord with them to be its bodyguard. For it is Virtue that has obtained as it own the central and most honourable place in the soul. Such is that which is shown, and he that sees it is the wise man, for fools are blind or dim-sighted."
It is not surprising that Philo uses the story to teach ethical discipline and spiritual emigration out of the visible world. However, it is interesting that the tree is not an ordinary piece of wood, but a part of the Tree of Life. The same interpretation occurs in L.A.B 11,15. This interpretation leads Philo to the speculations quoted above. 157
158
159
The water from the rock (Exod 17:1-7 / Num 20:1-13) can also be inter preted allegorically (Alleg. Interp. 2,86), and the context in the treatise is
155
The water in Elim meant an entrance to virtue "for just as gateways are the begin nings of a house, so are the preliminary exercises of the schools the beginning of virtue" (Fug. 183). "But this result is brought about not by toil unaided, but by toil with sweetening. He says 'the water was sweetened', and another name for the toil that is sweet and pleasant is love of labour. For what is sweet in toil is the yearning, the desire, the fervour, in fact the love of good", Congr. 166. See Sandelin 1986,91-92. See below p. 242. Philo had no problem accepting the physicians. He mentions ap proving of Hippocrates (e.g. Op. 105; 124) and physicians generally (e.g. Alleg. Interp. 2,6; Cher. 15). The well dug by princes, mentioned in Num 21:16-18, occurs in Ebr. 112-113, and is interpreted similarly to the water of Marah. The well is wisdom, which lies deep below the surface and gives forth a sweet stream of true nobility for thirsty souls. In Fug. 183 the water in Elim means a gateway to virtue (see Sandelin 1986, 94-96). 156
157
158
159
140
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
described above: mind must have control over the senses and pleasures. The Hebrews tortured by the drought of passions are helped by God, "for the flinty rock is the wisdom of God, which he marked of highest and chiefest from his powers, and from which he satisfies the thirsty souls that love God".
Although Philo expresses this only in a few words, he seems to be aware of both the Jewish and non-Jewish traditions concerning the wisdom as a spring or well, which he now (and in Somn. 2,221-222) applies to bibli cal events. The passages on water from the rock are always connected with those on the food given by God. The following three passages illustrate Philo's fondness for this theme: 161
"And when they have been given water to drink, they are filled also with the manna, the most generic of substances, for the manna is called 'somewhat', and that suggests the summum genus. But the primal existence is God, and next to him is the word of God, but all other things subsist in word only, but in their active effects they are in some cases as good as non-subsisting" (Alleg. Interp. 2,86). "And indeed it says 'Behold I rain upon you bread from heaven'. Of what food he can rightly say that it is rained from heaven, save of heavenly wisdom which is sent from above on souls which yearn for virtue by him who sheds the gift of prudence in rich abundance, whose grace waters the universe, and chiefly so in the holy seventh (year), which he calls Sabbath (Mut. 259-260). "You see of what sort the soul's food is. It is a word of God, continuous, resembling dew, embracing all the soul and leaving no portion without part in itself* (Alleg. Interp. 3,169, see even 162-172). 162
The same thought appears with small variations: Manna is the heavenly food God gives to the soul (Fug. 138; Mut. 259-260; Deus 155), and the erring people, of course, prefer "the onions and the garlic, which give great pain and trouble to their eyes and make them close, or the other illsmelling things" of Egypt to it (Her. 79-80). Manna means the heavenly wisdom that God gives to people who seek virtue, and as seen above, Philo is clearly aware of a broad tradition interpreting the biblical story about manna. As Sandelin notes, Deut 8:3 LXX links manna with God's 163
164
160
165
See above p. 133. See Sandelin 1986, 94-96. Philo uses manna to show that God does not let those who feed on the divine words live in misery and suffering; the common people believe that God lets them suffer, be cause they have never tasted wisdom (Congr. 173-174). Det. 118 uses manna to teach the nature of the proper education. Philo contrasts manna / wisdom with encyclical studies in Mut. 259-260 (see Borgen 1997, 164). See above p. 123 and Borgen 1965, 9-20. Sandelin 1986, 104. 161
162
163
164
165
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
141
Philo 166
also Wis 16:20 says that manna was the food of angels. Thus al though this interpretation is not Philo's own, he eagerly adopts it. pfjua;
Philo also gives a slightly allegorical interpretation to the story of quails (Exod 16:1-36; Num 11:4-36): Desire was victorious over the Hebrews, who could not fight against it (Spec. 4,128-130). The literal and allegorical interpretations overlap here, and it is easy to understand: The biblical story not only deals with lack of food, but also with lack of spiritual strength, and it opens the door for Philo to interpret the punishment in Num 11:4-36 as punishment for gluttony and an uncontrolled life. 167
Exod 17:8-16 tells how Moses prayed for Israel when watching the battle between Israel and Amalek and how Aaron and Hur had to hold his hands up. Philo deals with the story twice in the third book of Legum allegoriae. In Alleg. Interp. 3,45 the context is that a soul finds in God the spring and aim of its own doings. Moses did find it, and consequently his hands were heavy unlike those of evil men, and he was steadied by "Aaron, the Word, and Hur, which is 'Light.'" Another view is offered later in the same book (Alleg. Interp. 3,186). Now he pays attention to the fighting nations and compares the battle to ethical life. Philo explains Gen 3:15, interpret ing the war between the snake's seed and the woman's seed as the war be tween passion's seed (pleasure) and the mind's seed (sense). The story about Amalek follows this pattern; the combatants are no longer two peo ples, but mind and passion. The diaeresis in Alleg. Interp. 3,185 follows the pattern described by Christiansen, and the war between the two peoples is only a detail in Philo's interpretations, although this time he also defines Amalek etymologically. 168
"...'Whenever Moses lifted up his hands, Israel prevailed, but when he dropped them, Amalek prevailed', showing that when the mind lifts itself up away from mortal things and is borne aloft, that which sees God, which is Israel, gains strength, but when it has lowered its special powers and grown weak, immediately passion, named 'Amalek', which means 'a people licking out', will become strong: for in very deed it eats up the whole soul and licks it out, leaving behind in it no seed or spark or virtue."
Philo does not use the story about Miriam's punishment (Num 12:1-16) in a literal sense in Vita Mosis, and the story is seldom mentioned in early Judaism. 166
See Sandelin 1986, 73-81. On Philo's way to use the material and parallels to the Christian writers and midrashic tradition, see the detailed exegesis in Borgen 1965, 2858. See above p. 123. 168 On the interpretation in Mishna, see above p. 126. 1 6 7
142
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
LXX calls the women A'iSioTnaaa (cf. rrBDrr) thus placing ©ID on the m a p . In v. 1 2 : 4 LXX inverts the order of Aaron and Miriam, and in v. 1 2 : 6 Kuptco would imply mrr ? in the translator's original, although our Hebrew text has mrr. In v. 1 2 : 8 mrr nJDn is ren dered TT)V 5 6 £ a v Kupiou, which may be a slight theological reworking of the original. In 1 2 : 1 0 frwD runxD is translated Xenpcoaa eoaei showing no traces of finding nmxD difficult. In v. 1 2 : 1 2 LXX adds coosi eKxpcoucc; in v. 1 2 : 1 5 the Hebrew text has *pRmi?, but the Septuagint has scos EKaOapioBn. 1 6 9
1
Philo, however, uses this story, but only allegorically (Alleg. Interp. 2,6567), and the wider context is the mind's control over the senses and pleas ures described above. The mind has three alternatives, a v c u o x u v T i a , aiScos and the lack of both (=bad, good and indifferent). Miriam repre sents vous under the power of a v c c i o x u v T i a , attacking Moses when he deserved praise. Philo does not, of course, interpret the Ethiopian woman literally, because he rejects intermarriage, but takes her to mean the unal terable steadiness of his soul. Philo does not seem to find the story prob lematic, since he mentions it only briefly, and it does not trigger, as of ten, an allegorical interpretation showing how impossible a literal read ing of the biblical passage would be. 170
171
172
Num 21:4-9 tells how the Israelites were punished with the venomous snakes and healed with a bronze snake. Philo deals with the story twice, in both passages with a widely similar view. The story teaches the control of pleasure. 173
LXX translates in v. 2 1 : 4 DtfrrosD sprn as Kai coXiyovpiixriaev b Xaos. In v. 2 1 : 5 the Hebrew text has w r ^ n , but LXX e^rjyayes, and the difficult bpbpn nn^n is rendered ev TCO dfpTco TOO SictKevco. In v. 2 1 : 6 the snakes, crsitDn O'rcmn, are rendered TOUS 6<J>EIS TOUS SavocTOiivTas. In v. 2 1 : 6 the words TCOV uieov laparjA implies that the translators had 'ptner ^nn in their original and not ^tnETQ, as in our Hebrew text. The translation is thus very literal.
Alleg. Interp. 2,76-84; 87, a treatise which generally deals with the mind's control over the senses and pleasures, naturally considers snakes to be symbols of various pleasures, and Philo happens to give an excep tionally thorough argumentation for the view a little earlier (Alleg. Interp. 2,74-75). Pleasure brings death - not separation of the soul from the 174
175
1 7 0
171
1 7 2
1 7 3
1 7 4
1 7 5
On the geographical names in the Septuagint, see Siegert 2 0 0 0 , 2 1 4 - 2 1 5 . See above p. 1 3 3 . On Philo and intermarriage, see Spec. 3 , 2 9 ; Virt. 3 5 - 3 6 . See Dawson 1 9 9 2 , 1 0 4 . The story is also alluded to in Wis 1 6 : 5 - 1 4 . See above p. 1 3 3 . Christiansen uses the passage to illuminate Philo's method; see Christiansen 1 9 6 9 ,
67-71.
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
143
body, but ruination of the soul through vice. The situation, however, is not hopeless: "Everyone, then, 'whom a serpent shall have bitten, when he looks on it shall live.' This is quite true. For if the mind, when bitten by pleasure, the serpent of Eve shall have suc ceeded in beholding in soul the beauty of self-mastery (O0)(|)poauvn), the serpent of Moses, and through beholding this, beholds God himself, he shall live; only let him look and mark well (povov 'ISETCO KCCI KaTavonaccTco)" (Alleg. Interp. 2 , 8 1 ) .
The pairs of terms are thus poisonous serpent / pleasure and Moses' ser pent / aco(|>pocnjvri. Here, as in Agr. 95-98, Philo sees a deeper meaning in the material of the healing snake: The firm metal shows that a man, al though once bitten by pleasure, can with self-mastery resist temptation and be saved. Philo shows in Agr. 95-98 his way to connect the literal interpretation with the allegorical. He first retells the biblical story literally, and the tran sition to the allegorical is interesting: "Told in this way these things are like prodigies and marvels (<|>o:a|jo:cnv E'OIKE KCCI TEpccai), the serpent emitting a human voice and using quibbling arguments to an utterly guileless character, and cheating a woman with seductive plausibilities; and another proving the author of complete deliverance to those who beheld it. But when we interpret words by the meanings that lie beneath the surface, all that mythical is removed out of our way, and the real sense becomes as clear as daylight" (Agr. 9 6 - 9 7 ) .
The "real sense", which is "as clear as daylight" is that the story attacks the wrong philosophy: In both passages the snake undoubtedly has the voice of the Epicureans; in addition, the phrases "pleasure" and "selfmastery" let us conclude that the snake, which has bitten the mind with pleasure, then uses the arguments of philosophers airo TCOV KrjiTcov to charm its victims. Philo teaches that a man can return to the right path and stop listening to the beguiling voices. The literal sense is never re jected in the miracle stories, but the allegorical sense is the real and higher interpretation of the holy text. 176
It is a communis opinio that for Philo the allegorical method was not a de vice to destroy the literal. This view is also confirmed in this study of the miracle stories. There are very few passages in which Philo tries to avoid the literal sense with the help of the allegorical method. 177
176
On Epicurus in Philo, see Aet. 8 and on Epicureans Post. 2 . Although Philo men tions the Epicureans only twice, it is clear that their views are often his target; see Booth 1 9 9 4 , 1 5 9 - 1 7 2 . Frey ( 1 9 9 4 , 1 6 4 ) correctly identifies the snakes in Alleg. Interp. 2 , 8 1 with the snake in Paradise; however, he does not see the obvious link to the Epicureans. Wolfson: 1 9 4 7 , 1 . 1 2 2 - 1 2 6 ; Mondesert 1 9 9 9 , 8 8 7 - 8 8 8 . See however, e.g. Alleg. In terp. 2 , 1 9 , where Philo rejects the literal sense of woman's creation. 177
144
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
As seen above, some scholars have taken some features of the miracle stories as clear adaptations. Meeks tried to link the Egyptians with the opponents of the Jews in Philo's own time, more specifically with Gaius. Meeks undoubtedly asked an important question, but direct evi dence is scarce. If Philo wanted to covertly attack Gaius or Roman rule, he has hidden his message very skillfully. On the other hand, Philo had a well-thought-out view on statesmen, rulers and kings, which he could not help expressing when retelling the biblical events. The Alexandrian offi cials and Roman rulers of his own times formed the context in which Philo presents a Furstenspiegel to his reader, although Gaius is not directly men tioned and may not even be meant. As seen, the glorious past of Israel meant more to Philo than is often understood, and he had a developed, eschatological view. That we are not able to date precisely Philo's treatises makes investigating the details very difficult. Borgen's opinion that Vita Mosis was written before the pogroms fits the analysis presented above. Hay inquires about the implied readers of Philo and finds good answers; but unhappily, he does not focus his study on Vita Mosis, and the general answers are undoubtedly different from those concerning this work. The miracle stories imply that he indeed included Gentiles in his audience. It is easier to find other features in the stories that were relevant to the Gentile audience in Philo's time. It is interesting to compare Philo's literal interpretation with the anti-Jewish propaganda known to him. He almost consistently omitted all biblical verses pointing to the strange or offending manner of sacrifice, and he even dropped the whole story about Passover. Apparently he definitely wanted to present Moses to Gentile sympathisers, knowing that the Israelite manner of sacrifice was heavily attacked in antiJewish propaganda. On the other hand, although he does not mention pestilence at the burning bush, and says that Moses' hand was AeuKOTepa Xiovos, he adds of his own will the words AOIJJIKCX ccppcooTripaTa, when retelling the biblical plague. He also tells that the Egyptians expelled the Israelites from their country. Apparently Philo did not consistently remove everything, which was criticised by anti-Jewish writers. Generally, Philo pays very little attention to anti-Jewish writers. He seldom mentions them (but see Conf. 2 and of course Hypoth.), and when introducing Moses he does not, as Josephus, attack anti-Jewish writers, but regrets that the Greeks do not mention him (Mos. 1,1-3). 178
179
180
181
182
Meeks 1976, 48-49. On the literal interpretation and possible adaptations, see below p. 132. See above, p. 121. See Hay 1991,20-52. See below p. 231-232.
6. Miracles in Literal and Allegorical Interpretation:
Philo
145
What Philo wrote on the Sabbath was an attempt to universalise the Jew ish feast, and he seems really to have believed that the Gentiles could adopt one of the most eminent features of Judaism. He was not writing to an imaginary audience: the annual celebration of the LXX translation had attracted a number of non-Jewish sympathisers, and it is conceivable that eschatological hope was especially alive before the pogroms. But Philo also uses the miracle stories - both literally and allegorically to attack his philosophical opponents or to adopt a view taken from the Greek tradition. Few can hear the voice of the Epicureans in the snake's voice, but it was not a problem for Philo. He also attacked people who used their education for selfish ends. The warning not to follow the way of the Egyptian sorcerers, i.e. "sophists", was also meant for those among