EuroGOOS Publication No. 7
OPERATIONAL OCEANOGRAPHY THE CHALLENGE FOR EUROPEAN CO-OPERATION
Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management Directorate-General for Public Works and Water Management National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management/RIKZ
Elsevier Oceanography Series Series Editor." David Halpern (1993-) FURTHER TITLES IN THIS SERIES Volumes 1-7, 11, 15, 16, 18, 19, 21, 23, 29 and 32 are out of print. 8 E. LISITZIN SEA-LEVEL CHANGES 9 R.H. PARKER THE STUDY OF BENTHIC COMMUNITIES 10 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) MODELLING OF MARINE SYSTEMS 12 E.J. FERGUSON WOOD and R.E. JOHANNES TROPICAL MARINE POLLUTION 13 E. STEEMANN NIELSEN MARINE PHOTOSYNTHESIS 14 N.G.JERLOV MARINE OPTICS 17 R.A. GEYER (Editor) SUBMERSIBLES AND THEIR USE IN OCEANOGRAPHY AND OCEAN ENGINEERING 20 P.H. LEBLOND and L.A. MYSAK WAVES IN THE OCEAN 22 P. DEHLINGER MARINE GRAVITY 24 F.T. BANNER, M.B. COLLINS and K.S. MASSIE (Editors) THE NORTH-WEST EUROPEAN SHELF SEAS: THE SEA BED AND THE SEA IN MOTION 25 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) MARINE FORECASTING 26 H.G. RAMMING and Z. KOWALIK NUMERICAL MODELLING MARINE HYDRODYNAMICS 27 R.A. GEYER (Editor) MARINE ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION 28 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) MARINE TURBULENCE 30 A. VOIPIO (Editor) THE BALTIC SEA 31 E.K. DUURSMA and R. DAWSON (Editors) MARINE ORGANIC CHEMISTRY 33 R.HEKINIAN PETROLOGY OF THE OCEAN FLOOR 34 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) HYDRODYNAMICS OF SEMI-ENCLOSED SEAS 35 B. JOHNS (Editor) PHYSICAL OCEANOGRAPHY OF COASTAL AND SHELF SEAS 36 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) HYDRODYNAMICS OF THE EQUATORIAL OCEAN 37 W. LANGERAAR SURVEYING AND CHARTING OF THE SEAS 38 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) REMOTE SENSING OF SHELF-SEA HYDRODYNAMICS 39 T.ICHIYE (Editor) OCEAN HYDRODYNAMICS OF THE JAPAN AND EAST CHINA SEAS 40 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) COUPLED OCEAN-ATMOSPHERE MODELS 41 H. KUNZENDORF (Editor) MARINE MINERAL EXPLORATION 42 J.C.J NIHOUL (Editor) MARINE INTERFACES ECOHYDRODYNAMICS 43 P. LASSERRE and J.M. MARTIN (Editors) BIOGEOCHEMICAL PROCESSES AT THE LANDSEA BOUNDARY 44 I.P. MARTINI (Editor) CANADIAN INLAND SEAS
45 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) THREE-DIMINSIONAL MODELS OF MARINE AND ESTUARIN DYNAMICS 46 J.C.J. NIHOUL (Editor) SMALL-SCALE TURBULENCE AND MIXING IN THE OCEAN 47 M.R. LANDRY and B.M. HICKEY (Editors) COASTAL OCENOGRAPHY OF WASHINGTON AND OREGON 48 S.R. MASSEL HYDRODYNAMICS OF COASTAL ZONES 49 V.C. LAKHAN and A.S. TRENHAILE (Editors) APPLICATIONS IN COASTAL MODELING 50 J.C.J. NIHOUL and B.M. JAMART (Editors) MESOSCALE SYNOPTIC COHERENT STRUCTURES IN GEOPHYSICAL TURBULENCE 51 G.P. GLASBY (Editor) ANTARCTIC SECTOR OF THE PACIFIC 52 P.W. GLYNN (Editor) GLOBAL ECOLOGICAL CONSEQUENCES OF THE 1982-83 EL NINO-SOUTHERN OSCILLATION 53 J. DERA (Editor) MARINE PHYSICS 54 K. TAKANO (Editor) OCEANOGRAPHY OF ASIAN MARGINAL SEAS 55 TAN WEIYAN SHALLOW WATER HYDRODYNAMICS 56 R. CHARLIER and J. JUSTUS OCEAN ENERGIES, ENVIRONMENTAL, ECONOMIC AND TECHNOLOGICAL ASPECTS OF ALTERNATIVE POWER SOURCES 57 P.C. CHU and J.C. GASCARD (Editors) DEEP CONVECTION AND DEEP WATER FORMATION IN THE OCEANS 58 P.A. PIRAZZOLI WORLD ATLAS OF HOLOCENE SEA-LEVEL CHANGES 59 T. TERAMOTO (Editor) DEEP OCEAN CIRCULATION-PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL ASPECTS 60 B. KJERFVE (Editor) COASTAL LAGOON PROCESSES 61 P. MALANOTTE-RIZZOLI (Editor) MODERN APPROACHES TO DATA ASSIMILATION IN OCEAN MODELING
Elsevier Oceanography Series, 62
OPERATIONAL OCEANOGRAPHY
THE CHALLENGEFOR EUROPEAN CO-OPERATION J.H. Stel, Editor-in-Chief Netherlands Geosciences Foundation, The Hague, The Netherlands Proceedings of the First International Conference on EuroGOOS 7-11 October 1996, The Hague, The Netherlands
Edited by
H.W.A. Behrens J.C. Borst L.J. Droppert Directorate-General for Public Works and Water Management National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management/RIKZ, The Hague, The Netherlands
J.P. van tier Meulen KNMI, De Bilt, The Netherlands
ELSEVIER
Amsterdam
- Lausanne
-
New
York
- Oxford
- Shannon
- Singapore
- Tokyo
1997
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
EuroGOOS Office, Room 346/18 Southampton Oceanography Centre, Empress Dock, European Way, Southampton, SO 14 3ZH, United Kingdom Tel: +44(0)1703 596 242 or 262 Fax: +44(0)1703 596 399 E-mail:
[email protected] WWW: http://www.soc.soton.ac.uk/OTHERS/EU ROGOOS/eu rogoosindex.html
ISBN: 0 444 82892 3 91997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers Copyright Clearance Center Inc. can be obtained from the CCC publication may be made in the outside of the U.S.A., should be otherwise specified.
in the U.S.A.- This publication has been registered with the (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. Information about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science B.V., unless
No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands.
International Advisory Committee: EuroGOOS
Woods J.D.; Chairman; Imperial College, London University. Flemming N.C.; Director EuroGOOS members
Belgium Belgium Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Greece Ireland Italy Italy Netherlands
Nihoul, J.C.J.; GeoHydrodynamics and Environment Research (GHER) Pichot, G.; MUMM, Department of Environment Buch, E.; Royal Danish Administration of Navigation and Hydrography M~.lkki, P.; Finnish Institute of Marine Research David, P.; IFREMER Kohnke, D; Bundesamt for Seeschiffart und Hydrographie Triantafyllou, G.; Institution of Marine Biology of Crete Tziavos, C.; National Centre for Marine Research Wallace, J.; Marine Institute Cabibbo, N.; ENEA Garaci, E.; Consiglio Nazionale Delle Ricerche (CNR) Droppert, L.J.; National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management (RIKZ) Stel, J.H.; Netherlands Geosciences Foundation (GOA) Netherlands Johannessen, O.M.; Nansen Environmental and Remote Sensing Center Norway Saetre, R.; Institute of Marine Research, Bergen Norway Piechura, J; Institute of Oceanology, Polish Academy of Sciences Poland Banda, E.; Comision Interministerial de Cienca y Technologie Spain Ruiz de Elvira, A.; Puertos del Estado, Clima Maritima Spain Dahlin, H.; Swedish Meteorological and tIydrological Institute Sweden United Kingdom Mason, P.J.; Meteorological Office United Kingdom Palmer, D.; National Rivers Authority (NRA) United Kingdom Shepherd, J.G.; Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)
Steering (Scientific) Committee Flemming, N.C. Director EuroGOOS, UK, Chairman SMHI, Sweden Dahlin, H. RIKZ, Netherlands Droppert, L.J. IFREMER, France Glass, M. CNR, Italy Vallerga, S.
Organizing Committee Akkerman, R. Behrens, H.W.A. Borst, J.C. Dongen, F. van Droppert, L.J. Flemming, N.C. Kersbergen, T. Onvlee, J. Stel, J.H. Thiemann, R. Wensink, H. Wolf, R. de
North Sea Directorate National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management (RIKZ) EuroGOOS-Netherlands secretariat Oceanographic Company of the Netherlands National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management (RIKZ) EuroGOOS secretariat, Southampton, UK Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute Netherlands Geosciences Foundation Delft Hydraulics Advisory and Research Group on GEO Observation Systems and Services EDS
Conference organization Congress Office ASD
Sponsors European Commission IOC (Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission) EUROMAR (Eureka Project on Marine Technology) ESA (European Space Agency) The Netherlands EuroGOOS Group
vii
Preface If we could rise above the Earth, Socrates said, we would realise "this is ...the true Earth" and only then we would understand the world we live in. Twenty five centuries later we have developed the technology to fulfil Socrates dream. What did we leam? As all organisms we modify our environment. However, our footprint on the Planet is smashing. Almost half of the land has been transformed by human action; since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, the carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere has increased some thirty percent, mainly as a result of the combustion of fossil fuel; half of the fresh water resources is used by humans; sixty percent of the human population lives near the coast and as a consequence, half of the mangrove ecosystem is destroyed by human activity. Two-thirds of the world marine fish resources is either overexploited or at their limit of exploitation. Since Socrates at least a quarter of the bird species have been driven into extinction. Human enterprises such as agriculture, urbanisation, industry, recreation and international commerce is of such a magnitude that we are changing the Earth more rapidly than we are understanding it. We live on a sparkling blue island of life in space, the third planet from the sun in our solar system. We now understand that all parts of the Earth System, the oceans, the atmosphere, the solid earth, the biosphere and the near space surroundings, make up a continuously interacting entity. Significant changes in one system may have long-term effects on the others. Some of the processes that shaped the Earth as we know it today, are the result of relentless geophysical forces acting over millions of years. Others express the more rapid action of global change by oceanic and atmospheric forcing. These processes act on time scales of decades to centuries; timescales which concur with human activities and the life span of human societies. From space the earth's atmosphere is a thin and seemingly fragile gaseous skin protecting the earth surface from the harshness of space. From the ground this perspective is harder to appreciate. We take it for granted that the atmosphere protects us from the sun's most harmful rays, provides a moderate and stable climate, and renews and cleans itself to provide fresh air to breathe. We live at the bottom of this ocean of air which is deeper than any ocean of water and are subject to its changes, which we call weather. We all admire the daily television weather tbrecasts, which in fact reflect the power of the international World Weather Watch and its associated data delivery system. We take the benefits of weather forecasting for granted and also are accustomed to bear the costs of this multi-billion dollar enterprise, because of its benefits to both the public and private sectors of society. The atmosphere is probably the best known component of the Earth. Why don't we have such a system for the ocean? "l'he answer to this question most likely is "because we live in the ocean of air instead of the one of water". Oceans are the dominant feature of the earth, covering some seventy percent of
viii its surface. They play a key role in the chemistry of the atmosphere, the shaping of climate and weather and the hydrological cycle. The ocean also is a treasury of biological diversity although most marine species are still waiting to be discovered. The dazzling results of large, international multidisciplinary studies of the ocean organised under the auspices of the International Council of Scientific Unions, the World Meteorological Organisation, the International Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO etc., together with the availability of new technology, such as dedicated satellites and supercomputers, paved the wa)~ for the development of global observing systems for the climate, the ocean and the land. The benefits of the El Nifio and Seawatch monitoring and forecasting systems clearly signal the possible economic return on investments in a Global Ocean Observing System, in GOOS. The increasing dialogue between scientists, policy makers and politicians through existing UN agencies and new interfaces such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and the Megascience Forum of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development culminated in the acceptance of among others, the GOOS initiative at the 1992 Rio Conference. GOOS is an international programme for a permanent global framework of observations, modelling and analysis of ocean variables which are needed to support operational services around the world. Just as the World Weather Watch for meteorology, GOOS is a global effort to collect and distribute data to the entire world in real-time so that the various states can make their own products and shape them to local and regional use. Around 2010, GOOS will address issues such as climate assessment and prediction, living marine resources, coastal zone management and development, and health of the ocean through its marine meteorological and oceanographic operational services. GOOS is an effort which also needs co-operation on a national and regional level. The regional level is a crucial one and differs because of the variety in the development stage of marine capabilities per region. In Europe, with a large number of existing national bodies for marine (operational) activities, EuroGOOS - an open and loose association of agencies - was a right and major step forward. The programme of the First EuroGOOS Conference in The Hague, The Netherlands reflects that implementing GOOS at least means dialogues between policy makers, politicians, scientists, the marine industry and operators of existing monitoring systems. The conference was a success, brought EuroGOOS at the right political levels and is leading to increased national and European funding. Moreover, apart from cooperation with industry for the development of new technology, capacity building activities in developing countries is crucial for implementing a truly global ocean observing system. This was also recognised during the first EuroGOOS Conference. We have realised Socrates'dream to watch the Earth from space and the realisation is dawning that our home Planet is a human dominated one. As stewards of the future, we have the responsibility to seek scientifically sound policies for a sustainable management of the Earth. A truly global GOOS is an essential element of this endeavour. Dr. Jan H. Stel Editor-in-Chief
Expression o f gratitude The Dutch government through the National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management (RIKZ) of the Ministry of Transport, Public Work and Water Management was pleased to host the first international conference of EuroGOOS, the European Association for the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS). Some two hundred participants from most West European countries as well as from far away countries such as Australia, Indonesia, Kenya, Korea, Brazil, USA. and China admired the flying geese during the impressive laser show at the opening of the conference. During three days experts, business leaders, administrators, engineers, scientists and decision makers exchanged ideas about the need for and the economic and social return of operational oceanography in Europe, thus about EuroGOOS. The conference was a smasher and radiated a European spirit of co-operation and leadership. The commitment of the international GOOS community is also reflected in the proceedings of the first international EuroGOOS Conference which are in front of you. In eighty papers the European expertise and the links of EuroGOOS with GOOS and developing countries are presented. The contents of this volume follows the programme of the conference with introductions and policy papers on the first day, a series of parallel session on the second day and a round table discussion at the third day. All papers have been refereed by at least two referees. Also on behalf of the referees we want to thank the authors that they have been willing to make their revision in due time. We also want to thank all referees for their serious and important work, which they have often done in short time periods. Thc co-operative efforts of referees and authors have improved the quality of the papers considerably.
The Editing Committee
The EuroGOOS Conference John Woods EuroGOOS Chairman Graduate School of the Environment, Imperial College, University of London, SW7 2AZ
The purpose of the EuroGOOS Conference held in the Hague in October 1996 was to discover whether the Strategy developed over the last two years by the EuroGOOS association of 22 leading national agencies to generate a greatly expanded, accurate and reliable flow of information about the marine environment, starting early in the 21st century, would match the priorities perceived by representatives of European governments, the European Commission, European Agencies, Industry and the Scientific Community. Before embarking on detailed planning of EuroGOOS trials of future operational systems in the seas around Europe and beyond, it was important to find out whether the information to be provided would meet the needs of managers of governmental and industrial organisations responsible for making decisions about major environmental problems in coastal waters and global change. The cost of gathering the information planned by the EuroGOOS consortium will be substantial and will require concerted action by the governments funding it nationally or through European programmes. It is therefore important that the underlying strategy is understood and agreed by all concerned before we begin to seek commitments. It is equally important that our partners outside Europe are aware of what we are proposing to do, both in the seas around our continent and further afield. Ultimately, useful forecasting of the marine environment in any particular location will depend on the availability of information about the future state of the open ocean beyond the boundaries of that location. The EuroGOOS Strategy therefore has two streams: the first is to improve the quality of marine information in European home waters, and the second is to collaborate with similar organisations in other continents to create a new global ocean observing and modelling system that will provide the open ocean forecasts needed to achieve the best possible performance by local marine information services everywhere. The EuroGOOS strategy envisages our national agencies making a major contribution to that challenging task of globalizing ocean forecasting. It is believed to be technically possible, and likely to produce benefits equivalent to those achieved by the globalization of atmospheric forecasting, to which the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) made a leading contribution. One purpose of the EuroGOOS Conference was to explain and seek approval in principle for that proposed contribution of Europe to the globalization process.
xii The Conference also provided an opportunity to take stock of the state of marine science and technology in Europe relevant to the EuroGOOS Strategy, and the state of information services and customer needs at the end of the 20th century. It was necessary to demonstrate that the major steps proposed in the EuroGOOS Strategy are timely in terms of the underpinning state of scientific understanding and technical capability, and in terms of the needs of the public and private sectors. It was important to demonstrate that investment through the EC Marine Science and Technology (MAST) programme had achieved its goal of creating a coherent community of marine scientists and engineers in Europe. It was important to show that intergovernmental joint ventures, like those of the North Sea Task Force, could benefit from provision of a coherent information service based on collaborative implementation of best practice involving new techniques such as data assimilation into mathematical models. It was important to take note of the impact of the European Space Agency through its ERS 1/2 ocean satellites, and the potential of ECMWF and other European bodies, such as the Environmental Agency. Some of the most impressive presentations at the EuroGOOS Conference revealed national commitments to establish operational ocean forecasting systems in coastal waters and globally. Initially, these systems will make use of whatever observations happen to be available, including ESA satellite data: they are, in effect, operational ocean forecasting systems of opportunity. This development has come several years earlier than predicted when EuroGOOS was established, and provides both a spur to faster implementation of the Strategy and a sound framework for moving ahead. As in atmospheric forecasting, the main cost of ocean forecasting will lie in collecting the observations. The Conference provided an opportunity for all participants to learn about recent developments and assess future needs. The brilliant organisation of the EuroGOOS Conference and associated Exhibition by our Dutch hosts led by Dr. Leen Droppert ensured that we had the right environment in which to achieve our goal. The Strategy was presented in detail to the participants coming from a wide cross-section of both public and private sectors. Their views on every aspect of the Strategy were consulted by a series of opinion polls. This volume of Proceedings provides an opportunity for wider dissemination of the EuroGOOS Strategy and the results of the Conference. Encouraged by the success of the Conference and the positive response of the participants to the EuroGOOS Strategy, the EuroGOOS Association has moved forward in 1997 to publish the EuroGOOS Plan which is available through national members or from the EuroGOOS Director, Southampton Oceanography Centre, SO 14 3ZH, UK. On behalf of the members of the EuroGOOS Association it is my very great pleasure to thank the sponsors (The European Commission, The Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission of UNESCO, The EC Eureka Project on Marine Technology (Euromar), The European Space Agency, and the Netherlands EuroGOOS Group), everybody who made presentations on the platform or in the exhibition hall, and especially the members of the Organising Committee for making the EuroGOOS Conference such a memorable event and a resounding success.
xiii
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
PAGE
Preface ...................................................
VII
Expression of gratitude
........................................
IX
EuroGOOS
........................................
XI
Conference
INTRODUCTIONS
The Netherlands and EuroGOOS by Mrs. A. Jorritsma-Lebbink, Minister of Transport, Public Works and Water Management, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
European dimensions of ocean and climate forecasting by H. Tent, representing the European Commissioner for Science and Technology, Mrs. E. Cresson and Deputy Director of DG XII, Belgium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7
The global aspects of megascience by P.A.J. Tindemans, The Netherlands Chairman OECD Megascience Forum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11
POLICY The EuroGOOS Strategy by J.D. Woods', Chairman EuroGOOS; Imperial College, London University, United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
19
Cost benefit analysis of TOGA and the ENSO observing system by P.G. Sassone, R.F. Weiher, ENSO-Forecasting Group, USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
36
The World Weather Watch: Is an ocean equivalent meaningful or realistic? by P.E. Dexter, R.C. Landis, T.W. Spence, WMO, Switzerland
51
.......
The challenge to observe the world ocean circulation and its variability by W.P.M. de Ruijter, Utrecht University, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . (Presented by G. Komen, The Netherlands) Regional GOOS for sustainable development and management by G. Kullenberg, J.P. Rebert, Executive Secretary Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC), Paris . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (Presented by G. Holland, Canada)
61
69
Costs and benefits of operational oceanography: the effects of scale and aggregation by N.C. Flemming, Director EuroGOOS, United Kingdom . . 80
XIV
P O L I C Y - A n e x a m p l e of a n a t i o n a l a p p r o a c h On the German approach to GOOS and EuroGOOS
W. Lenz, Germany
TECHNOLOGY:
93
............................................
Instruments/Monitoring Networks
SEAWATCH, Performance and future S.E. Hansen, J.H. Stel, Norway~The Netherlands- Keynote Lecture
..........
101
SeaNet: European workshop on fixed monitoring networks in the North Sea region R. van der Poel, J. Rozema, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
111
A proposed new ship-of-opportunity towed vehicle and sensor suite designed for coastal, shelf and ocean basin survey R. Burt, J. A iken, T.J. Dunning, R. Williams and others, United Kingdom . . . . . .
119
Development of METNET- An operational offshore meteorological and oceanographic data network I. Leggett, I. Bellamy, F. Dolan, United Kingdom .....................
125
Long-term stable sensors for bio-optical measurements H. Barth, R. Heuermann, K.-D. Loquay, R. Reuter, U. Stute, Germany . . . . . . . .
133
EGOS - European Group on Ocean Stations. A continuously operating Data Buoy programme in the North Atlantic L. G. Golmen, Norway . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
141
Upper ocean measurements using the Autonomous Profiling Vehicle (APV) K. McCoy, D. Jacobs, USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
148
REMSSBOT, Integrated environmental management through integrated environmental information sources H. Niesing, W. Roose, J.C. Borst, R. de Wolf The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . .
153
Seanet - Data Interface Group - Measuring network Flemish banks. Hydro-Meteo-System for the North Sea D. Vermeir, G. Dumon, B. de Putter, Belgium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
160
Development of an acoustic method and prototype instrumentation for size and concentration measurement of suspended sediment A.S. Schaafsma, A.M. Lafort, D. Guyomar, The Netherlands~France . . . . . . . . . .
168
XV
TECHNOLOGY:
Remote Sensing
ESA's support of operational oceanography: current status and future plans J.A. Johannessen, G. Duchossois, The Netherlands~France- Keynote Lecture
179
A review of the possible applications of satellite earth observation data within EuroGOOS O.M. Johannessen, L.H. Petterson, E. Bjcbrgo, H. Espedal, G. Evensen, T. Hamre, A.D. Jenkins, E. Korsbakken, P. Samuel, S. Sandven, Norway . . . . . .
192
Wave modelling and operational forecasting at E C M W F J.-R. Bidlot, B. Hansen, P.A.E.M. Janssen, United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
206
The bathymetry assessment system G.J. Wensink, G.H.F.M. Hesselmans C.J. Calkoen, J. Vogelzang, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
214
I C E W A T C H - Ice SAR monitoring of the Northern Sea Route
O.M. Johannessen, A.M. Volkov, V.D. Grischenko, L.P. Bobylev, S. Sandven, K. Kloster, T. Hamre, V. Asmus, V.G. Smirnov, V.V. Melentyev, L. Zaitsev, Norway~Russia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
224
COASTWATCH: Using SAR imagery in an operational system for monitoring coastal currents, wind, surfactants and oil spills O.M. Johannessen, E. Korsbakken, P. Samuel, A.D. Jenkins, H.A. E,wedal, Norway . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
234
Operational determination of satellite derived sea surface temperature and wind speed from NOAA AVHRR and ERS SAR images S. Lehner, S.W. Dech, A. Holz, R. Meisner, M. Niederhuber, P. Tungalagsaikhan, Germany . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 243 Hydrographic laser fluorosensing: status and perspectives R. Reuter, R. Willkomm, O. Zielinski, W. Milchers, Germany
..............
Operational use of NOAA AVHRR imagery in the marine environment J.N. Roozekrans, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
251
259
xvi
ECONOMICS: Benefits/Costs Estimates of the costs and benefits of operational oceanography at the single industry level N. C. F l e m m i n g , United K i n g d o m - K e y n o t e lecture
.....................
269
Implications of EUROGOOS on marine policy making in a small maritime economy M. White, G. O'Sullivan, l r e l a n d
.................................
278
Cost/benefit analysis of GOOS - some methodological issues M. Brown, F r a n c e
...........................................
286
Metocean data collection: short-term costs and long-term benefits? C.J. Shaw, The N e t h e r l a n d s
.....................................
294
ECONOMICS: Logistics/Structures The economics of operational oceanographic services P. Ryder, U n i t e d K i n g d o m - Keynote lecture
.........................
305
System Architecture for GOOS: lessons learned from another sector A. C. van Tol, The Netherlands
...................................
314
Issues in the operational provision of marine information G. C a m p b e l l Italy
...........................................
322
BALTIC
Towards a Baltic operational oceanographical system, 'BOOS' H. Dahlin, S w e d e n - Keynote lecture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
331
Finnish operational oceanographical service H. Gronvall, F i n l a n d
.........................................
336
Oceanographic monitoring network in the Danish waters E. Buch, D e n m a r k
...........................................
344
Polish Oceanographic Service: present status and prerequisite to join EuroGOOS W. Krzyminski, Z. Dziadziuszko, P o l a n d . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
351
xvii ARCTIC Operational climate monitoring program of the Arctic ice cover O.M. Johannessen, E. Bj$rgo, M. Miles, N o r w a y - Keynote lecture . . . . . . . . . .
361
Variability of Arctic Sea ice thickness- statistical significance and its relationship to heat flux P. Wadhams, United Kingdom
368
...................................
Coupled Ecosystems in the ice-covered Arctic Ocean 385
R. Gradinger, M. Spindler, Germany . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ATLANTIC Global ocean data assimilation of temperature data: preliminary results N. Pinardi, S. Masina, A. Navarra, K. Miyakoda, E. Masetti, Italy
..........
395
EMMA: A cost-efficient system for generating time series of in situ profiling
measurements at fixed locations J.-P. Guinard, France . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
401
Sampling strategies for oceanographic features J. (;rook, C. Schofield, United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
408
J.P. van der Meulen, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
422
Strategic approach to real time data acquisition and dissemination on a global scale Azores current system modelling and monitoring M. Alves, A. Simoes, Portugal
...................................
428
Operational marine models at the Norwegian Meteorological Institute E.A. Martinsen, B. Hackett, L. Petter R4~ed, A. Melsom, Norway . . . . . . . . . . . .
436
A pilot ocean monitoring site at Azores islands A. Simoes, R. Duarte, M. Alves, Portugal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
444
xviii NORTH-WEST SHELF: Physical models
Towards dynamic coupling of open ocean and shelf sea models A.M. Davies, J. Xing, United Kingdom - Keynote lecture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
455
Wave prediction and data assimilation at the North Sea A.C. Voorrips, H. Hersbach, F.B. Koek, G.J. Komen, V.K. Makin, J.R.N. Onvlee, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 463
Data assimilation in the Continental Shelf Model K.B. Robaczewska, A.W. Heemink, M. Verlaan, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . .
472
Coastal operational modelling within the EUREKA-EUROMAR Project OPMOD: Experiences from continuous operation in the Elbe estuary since 1994 K.C. Duwe, I. Nohren, K.D. Pfeiffer, Germany . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
483
A new storm surge forecasting system M.E. Philippart, A. Gebraad, The Netherlands
........................
487
NORTH-WEST SHELF: Ecological models
The importance of high frequency data in ecological modelling J.l. Allen, United K i n g d o m - Keynote lecture
.........................
499
An integrated data-model system to support monitoring and assessment of marine systems R.J. Vos, M. Schuttelaar, The Netherlands~France . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
507
Data assimilation for coastal zone monitoring and forecasting G. Evensen, H. Drange, Norway . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
516
NOWESP: North-West European Shelf Programme W. van Leussen, The Netherlands" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
523
The Integrated North Sea Programme (INP) H. van Haren, P. Ruardo, H. Ridderinkhof D. Mills, The Netherlands'/ United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
529
Monitoring phytoplankton blooms continously with SEAWATCH technology K Tangen, Norway . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
539
xix MEDITERRANEAN
The EuroGOOS Mediterranean Test Case: science and implementation plan N. Pinardi, P. De Mey, G.L. Manzella, A. Ruiz de Elvira a n d the E u r o G O O S Mediterranean Test Case Scientific Steering Group, Italy Keynote lecture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
549
Scaling considerations and sampling strategies in monitoring aquatic ecohydrodynamics 558
Y. Papadimitrakis, J. Nihoul, Greece~Belgium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The application of broad-band acoustic tomography to the monitoring of the shallow water environment: Validation and trends 568
J.-P. Hermand, Italy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Seasonal variability of the Levantine intermediate waters in the Western Mediterranean- Algerian/Provencal basin A. Perilli, N. Pinardi, A. Ribotti, R. Sorgente, L. Calise, M. Sprovieri, Italy
....
576
REGIONAL GOOS Development of North-East Asia Regional Global Ocean Observing System (NEAR-GOOS) D.Y. Lee, K. Taira Lee, Korea
...................................
587
A monitoring system for the Indian-Atlantic connection P.J. van Leeuwen, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
596
Australian planning towards GOOS P.A. Riley, N.R. Smith, Austrialia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
603
G O O S Modules
Health of the Ocean-module: The HELCOM example J.M. Leppanen, Finland - Keynote lecture
...........................
615
Why is EuroGOOS important for coastal managers? J. Dronkers, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
624
Living marine resources-module: the provision of scientific advice on fisheries R.S. Bailey, E. Kirkegaard, D e n m a r k . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
631
XX
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
Lego for capacity building J.H. Stel, The Netherlands- Keynote lecture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
643
Increasing the involvement of IOC member states in GOOS through capacity building: The Indonesian experience A. Soegiarto, Indonesia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
656
Capacity building for the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS): Development needs and requirements for Eastern Africa E. Okemwa, M. Odido, Kenya . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
663
Capacity building for GOOS: developments, needs and requirements for the Caribbean and adjacent regions R. Steer-Ruiz, Colombia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
673
Coastal management: Global change...global observation? M.J.F. Stive, G. Baarse, R. Misdorp, The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
684
DISCUSSIONS and CONCLUSIONS
Next steps by N.C. Flemming Director of EuroGOOS, United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
697
Future technology requirements for operational oceanography by J.J. Bosman, Chairman of the EuroGOOS Technical Plan Working Group (TPWG), The Netherlands . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
702
Operational Oceanography - a challenge and an opportunity for Europe by D. Prandle, Chairman of the EuroGOOS Scientific Advisory Group (SAG), United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
706
GOOS concepts by J.D. Woods, Chairman of EuroGOOS; Imperial College, University of London, United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
711
Round Table Discussion
715
.......................................
Closure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
733
Author Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
741
List of Participants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
743
List of Reviewers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
753
INTRODUCTIONS
L.J. Droppert, Conference Chairman
Mrs. A. Jorritsma-Lebbink Minister of Transport, Public Works and Water Management
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
The Netherlands and EuroGOOS Speech by the Minister of Transport and Public Works, Ms. A. Jorritsma-Lebbink.
Ladies and gentlemen, The first International Conference on EuroGOOS is already one well-filled morning old. You have heard much about the importance of GOOS, which as you all must know by now, stands for Global Ocean Observing System. Words have been spoken about EuroGOOS, the European Association of Agencies promoting GOOS, various case studies have been presented, and you should now know all about the challenge to observe world ocean circulation and its variability. Thankfully, this kind of conference has a lunch break and hopefully you are refreshed and ready to listen to my story. The Dutch have a remarkable love-hate relationship with the sea. On the one hand, the sea has brought us much good over the years: trade and transport, fishing, minerals, a rich ecology and recreational opportunities. But on the other hand, the sea is a threat: Lying below sea level, we must wage a constant effort to keep our feet dry and there is a constant threat of pollution to our marine environment. The Dutch continental shelf does not, incidentally, lay sole claim to this kind of problem as rivers, seas and oceans are not accustomed to staying within country boundaries. Therefore problems in this area also deserve an international approach in the best sense. Which brings me exactly to where I want to be: at EuroGOOS. This assemblage of services, institutions and companies should give the GOOS concept greater influence on a European level. What exactly is the GOOS concept? Simply put; it is a worldwide co-operative effort to observe the oceans and world seas, in order to discover what is currently happening and enable the prediction of future changes. This fulfils some of the ideas in Agenda 21 of the UNCED conference in Rio de Janeiro, 1992, which has profound importance to The Netherlands and hence our strong feelings for EuroGOOS. This commitment has been illustrated by the founding of two Dutch governmental committees in EuroGOOS. A national sounding-board group, the EuroGOOS-Netherlands group, also acts as a forum for the government, research institutes, and the business community to work together as a dynamic unit. Hence, it is certainly of no coincidence that the organisation of the first International Conference on EuroGOOS is a Dutch event. The Netherlands also has a great interest in the actual workings of the promoted Global Ocean Observing System. Take safety for instance. For our low-lying country, it is extremely
important to have an accurate tidal prediction system, as we really want to keep these dry feet
dry~ The shipping, fishing, and offshore industries must likewise be fully informed of predicted tides, wave conditions and current speeds. Not only for their safety, but also to allow responsible admittance policies in the major ports. It is not economically sound to keep a ship unnecessarily held up for a tide and it is certainly a problem if a ship is let in when the water level is too low. A grounded ship. You can imagine the mess... In these and other such emergencies, pollutants can readily enter the water and reliable dispersion models are required to effectively combat such pollution. The Netherlands does not only have an interest in good prediction systems for the present. Governing means looking ahead, which may be even truer for a country that lies several meters below sea level. For our children's sake alone, we want to make sure our country is here in another fifty years. So we must take timely precautionary measures to keep the dikes and storm flood gates in good shape. We must take steps to prevent unfortunate developments and we must look ahead to the future. I'm not just thinking about the rise in sea level, but also the changes in storm patterns over the North Atlantic. Ladies and gentlemen, The importance of GOOS to our country lies not only in safety, but there is a definite economic aspect as well. I emphasised this earlier concerning the admittance policy for the major ports. But of further economic interest is 'know-how' and its application within government, research institutes, consulting bureaus and the business community. For example, the know-how we have earned through the years of struggle against the sea, with our delta works. The Netherlands would be pleased to see its costly investment in acquiring this knowledge paying off. This could be in open competition with other countries, or better still, as an international co-operative effort leading to mutual gain. EuroGOOS can play an important role in that effort. Cost-benefit analyses have actually shown that investments in operational oceanography are profitable for a single country. By combining our powers as European governmental organisations in this area, we can create optimal framework conditions for the European business community. A single country need no longer possess all the specialist knowledge itself and can consciously choose to use another countries' know-how. Spreading specialisation throughout Europe, with perhaps multinational regional centres, would help the entire European community. The concern for our security and the impetus for our economy are not the only reasons for The Netherlands to support GOOS, and thus EuroGOOS, so strongly. GOOS can also give greater insight into the effects of climatic change on the environment. The Netherlands is concerned about the consequences of possible climatic change caused by humans. Not only because of the rise in sea level, but also future agricultural interests, food supply, spread of
disease and desertification. It is not always easy to discern which changes are natural, and which must be ascribed to human influence. In good trade jargon, the latter is called anthropogenic influence. This influence is often difficult to ascertain, given the natural variability of the ecosystem itself. With closer observation and monitoring of the seas and oceans, we will be able to spot the difference sooner. To get a better grasp of the unmanageable subject of climatic change, we must gain a better understanding of the global role that the ocean plays. To know more about that, we must also observe and measure things worldwide. Fortunately, this is quite possible with today's satellites. However, the parties involved will have to co-operate on an international level, as demonstrated by the Climate Variability Program of the World Climate Research Program, in which The Netherlands participates. GOOS can also contribute to a steady international data exchange on oceanography. Such data exchange has been achieved for some time in meteorology. With agreements made within the World Meteorological Organisation, data can be spread and used all over the world via the Global Telecommunications System. If we want to have actual marine monitoring systems in oceanography, then we must construct a similar, flawlessly operating infrastructure for this field. It is a challenging, but highly rewarding task for EuroGOOS. Ladies and gentlemen, The Netherlands does not merely have a great interest in EuroGOOS, but we also have much to offer EuroGOOS, such as our knowledge of the sea and the major expertise we have built up over the years. We also have extensive experience with high-tech measuring instruments: from measuring tools to operational rotating measuring nets. We have always been active in developing current, wave and storm surge models. These models run in real time and assimilate conventional and satellite observations. In the area of integral water management, The Netherlands has built a strong reputation. The idea of integral water management is reflected in our vision for coastal management, as enacted by the Coastal Zone Management Centre. I am thus not exaggerating when I say The Netherlands has an impressive wealth of knowledge to offer. Knowledge we are glad to make available to Europe and the world and assist in the sorely needed capacity building in the developing countries. That is necessary, as a real global observation network will never be possible if these countries don't participate. It is important that they are not left behind and it is in our own interest to help countries wherever necessary in this capacity building. Moreover, ocean research, Coastal Zone Management and GOOS, will take an important place within UNCED. And in the follow-up to UNCED the relationship with developing countries will play just as big a role. We can truly say that capacity building is crucial for the success of UNCED.
I further anticipate that GOOS and EuroGOOS will have a major impact on international cooperation. I already mentioned the international data exchange in the field of oceanography and the capacity building in developing countries. Furthermore, GOOS will definitely influence work by the North Sea ministers conference, the Oslo-Paris Commission (OSPARCOM) and the independent World Commission on the oceans. Their positive work on behalf of the seas and oceans depends on good observations, clear interpretations and a reliable control system to evaluate the effects of the measures taken. In my opinion, the set of instruments to be developed and the knowledge of GOOS and EuroGOOS will definitely contribute to this. Ladies and gentlemen, In only a year and a half it will be 1998, which will be a memorable year. It will be recorded in the history books as the UNESCO Year of the Ocean and a specialised world exhibition will be held in Lisbon. I think it would be a fine idea to hold the second EuroGOOS conference at that time and would be glad to see EuroGOOS make notable progress in this period. I want to be part of making that happen, by heightening the attention paid to GOOS and EuroGOOS, through the Dutch government. This conference demonstrates this intention. I hope that the coming days will be pleasurable and fruitful and will bring the Global Ocean Observing System one important step closer to realisation. Thank you.
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
E u r o p e a n d i m e n s i o n s o f o c e a n and climate forecasting Mr. H. Tent, Representative of the European Commissioner for Science and Technology, Mrs. E. Cresson and the Deputy Director of DG XII, "Science, Research and Technology".
1. S O M E G E N E R A L P O I N T S A B O U T T H E B E N E F I T S O F O P E R A T I O N A L OCEANOGRAPHY FOR EUROPE An obvious fact, and of crucial significance, is that 13 out of the 15 members of the EU are coastal states. The exceptions being Luxembourg and Austria. If as Europeans we look at our history, culture and economies, we are continuously reminded that the sea is a vital and integral part of Europe. For European citizens the sea is a major source of food, a place for leisure and a highway for trade, yet there is growing concern amongst us all that the marine environment, especially around Europe, is in danger. We fear depletion of fish stocks, pollution and possible impacts of climate change, such as sea level rise and its consequences for coastal areas. The general perception is for a common goal, to forecast and attempt to counteract these many threats. The temperature, climate, and weather of Europe are determined mainly by the pattern of currents in the North Atlantic Ocean. We know that these currents are subject to changes, some of which are quite abrupt (10-year scale). Therefore it is relatively easy to assess the benefits that farmers, fishermen or others would derive, if accurate forecasts of weather and sea state could be extended to a range of 10-30 days; which is not the case today. Fisheries has already been mentioned; this being among one of the important sectors of marine based industries such as ship building, transport and civil engineering in the coastal zone. In general, marine based industries and services have to face uncertainty, damage or loss of efficiency due to unpredictable events occurring at sea: storms, waves, erosion, shifts in fish stock migration, toxic algal blooms etc. It is worth while putting the magnitude of these industries in perspective: 3 to 5% of input to the EU GNP are generated directly by marine based industries and services. The value added directly by these activities is in the range 110-190 billion ECU/year. Three of the main sectors of maritime industry, shipbuilding, transport and resources, provide more than 800 000 jobs in the EU. The total number of jobs in the full range of marine industries and services in the EU is in the order of 1-1.5 million. These figures were taken from the brochure "The strategy for EuroGOOS" and are worthy of recall.
Thus, there are strong reasons why Europeans should want to jointly develop a modern system for information on the marine environment. What is needed is twofold: continuous descriptions of the present state of the sea and continuous forecasts of the future condition of the sea. Together this is "Operational Oceanography". In our view, Europe is well equipped to start this process. We have a long tradition of investment in instrumentation and organisations for various forecast types. Examples being, the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) and storm surge warning systems. We have world class institutions and modelling groups who process information using the most advanced technologies currently available. As all this information will have to be made rapidly available, in a useable format, to a variety of users (industry, government agencies and local authorities), we can expect the development of a new sector of business, particularly through small, specialised companies.
2. WHY THE C O M M I S S I O N IS I N T E R E S T E D IN E U R O G O O S . Bearing in mind, what has previously been discussed. The Commission is interested in EuroGOOS because the activities developed under EuroGOOS will have the potential to: 9 promote the efficiency and competitiveness of European marine industries and services, 9 develop a new class of business: the business of operational oceanography, 9 promote sustainable management of marine resources (especially living resources), 9 protect the environment, 9 introduce advanced technology to safeguard national resources. All the points listed above are high priorities on the EU agenda.
3. E U R O P E A N PROJECTS OF R E L E V A N C E TO E U R O G O O S On-going in MAST: some examples: PROMISE (PRe-Operational Modelling In the Seas of Europe): ten partners from seven EU/EEA countries. Objective: to test models simulating actual conditions on an hourly basis in the North Sea and off the Spanish Atlantic coast. MMS 20(0+ (Marine Monitoring System 2000+ for the North Sea Region): a concerted action and co-ordination of national users. Objective: to create an integrated European marine monitoring and forecasting system for the North Sea region based on fixed monitoring networks of national origin. Some projects on special developments in marine instrumentation, e.g.: "Instrumentation for marine C O / f r o m remote platforms", or "CYTOBUOYS, upgrading flow cytometry for buoy mounted operation".
Shared between MAST, Environment and Climate and INCO: Planned revival of ENRICH, the European Network on Research in Global Change. ENRICH aims primarily at improving research co-operation and collaboration on Global Change, between scientific undertakings in the European Union and states associated with the RTD Programmes in Central and Eastern Europe and the Newly Independent States from the former Soviet Union. Some of the planned activities: 9 development of co-operative links and networking actions, 9 exchange of data and scientific information, 9 building research capacity to address the issue of regional implications of Global Change; the impacts on natural resources, 9 develop science agendas or plans of mutual interest to EU and neighbours e.g. The Mediterranean. These to be co-ordinated with single activities. The second call of MAST-Ill will most probably generate proposals relevant to GOOS and EuroGOOS. Among the priorities identified for that call was operational forecasting. Thus it can be expected that projects relevant for the objectives of EuroGOOS will be implemented in the coming year.
4. THE FIFTH FRAMEWORK PROGRAM, FP5. It is too early to give details, but the Commissions reasons for supporting the concept of EuroGOOS, as given above, allow a certain optimism for possible opportunities in FP5. Some objectives of FP5 are: 9 Satisfy our citizens' expectations for improved quality of life, work and environment, by making systems, products and services easy and safe to use within a perspective of sustainable growth. 9 Make research more comprehensible, visible, and accessible, despite modem science becoming increasingly complex, to ensure science and technology is accepted and adopted by our citizens. 9 Produce research with a positive impact on employment and competitiveness. Given the frame of discussion, it can be indicated that: 9 Without prejudice to the final structure, the number of subjects was kept deliberately small. 9 When a rigorous economic case for mediating the benefits can be established, the focus is on the targeting of activities and the impact the research will have on people's lives. This includes unlocking the resources of the living world and ecosystem. As the life sciences and the environment are literally vital to people's lives and have a critical impact on health. Europe must realise the full potential of its scientific and technical assets in these areas, as these are also promising in terms of the growth of markets and the creation of jobs.
10 Concerning the environment, the development of environmental regulations, tax incentives and wider adherence to the principle of responsible behaviour is desirable. This calls for a greater understanding of the interaction between environmental factors, the introduction of advanced forms of technology in order to safeguard natural resources and reduce the use made of them, and the tackling of the problems of pollution and waste. This also calls for basic studies related to global environmental change, the basic meteorological patterns, natural hazards and European ecosystems.
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
The global aspects of m e g a s c i e n c e Dr. P.A.J. Tindemans Director Research and Science Policy, Ministry of Education and Science, Europaweg 4, 2711 AH Zoetermeer, the Netherlands In his speech Dr. P.A.J. Tindemans discussed the nature of the Megascience Forum of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, the megascience aspects of GOOS and EuroGOOS and its implications to organisation and especially international decision making as well as the relation between the European Community and EuroGOOS.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Operational oceanography is a megascience activity which requires planning and decision making at the national, regional and global level. This is one of the findings of the Megascience Forum of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), which has drawn the attention of the international community to the megascience aspects of oceanography. The Megascience Forum of the OECD has organised a so called expert meeting on oceanography in September 1993 in Tokyo, Japan. In the same year the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS) took shape. I think it is fair to say that the Megascience Forum by organising the expert meeting on oceanography and the subsequent recommendations to the OECD member-states and to the international organisations involved, has accelerated the acceptance of the GOOS-concept and through that of EuroGOOS. It has been a special merit of the Forum that it has made governments and research organisations more aware of the necessity of co-ordination and organisation at a global and regional level, as far as ocean observation is concerned. Furthermore by underlining the benefits of GOOS, both public and private, it has contributed to a growing societal appreciation of operational oceanography. First I would like to present a brief outline on the background of the Megascience Forum followed by the megascience aspects of GOOS and EuroGOOS and the implications of these aspects to the organisation, especially the international decision making. I would like to conclude with some remarks on the relation between the European Community and EuroGOOS.
2. THE M E G A S C I E N C E F O R U M We have to implement global programmes in an environment where national policy prevails. How to shape national policies so as to support instead of benignly tolerate or even oppose
global co-operation that is so vital for making progress? How to align national research priorities as much as possible with those of international research programmes How to establish links between agencies responsible for science policy and science funding and the government agencies responsible for instance for global environmental policy? The Megascience Forum of the OECD was established to address the above mentioned issues, in order to help promote a coherent approach to projects with very large financial and manpower requirements and with a view to optimise scarce world resources the Dutch minister for Education, Culture and Science, Mr. Ritzen was a strong advocate of the Forum. It has been created in June 1992 for a period of three years. In September last year the mandate of the Forum was extended for another period of three years. The principal functions of the Forum are to: 9 Serve as a clearing house, to exchange information about megascience projects and megascience programmes. 9 Promote discussion among governments of possible new projects and programmes in an early stage of their development. 9 Act as a catalyst to initiate new co-ordinating bodies or mechanisms without taking an operational role for itself. 9 Undertake analytical and statistical studies. The Forum is a pioneering advisory body: it is explicitly not an operational decision making forum. But it or rather the group of OECD-ministers backing the Forum, has created a mechanism which may lead all the way up to real life: negotiations and decisions. According to the ministers in their meeting of September 1995 the Forum has been very successful during its first term. It has (and still does) contributed in one way or another to establishing a global village of scientists. The central aspects of megascience: costs, scale and uniqueness and the urgency of co-operation are in the mind of many decisionmakers. The Forum has organised expert meetings in six selected scientific fields where megaprojects or plans play a key role (astronomy, deep-drilling, oceanography, neutron beams and synchrotron radiation sources, particle physics and global change). The Forum has published different reports and studies as a result of these expert meetings. 9
Furthermore, the Forum identified generic issues common to megascience projects and megascience programmes such as data handling. The data issue was also a central element in the expert meetings on global change and on oceanography. Other generic issues were: the planning of megafacilities, decisionmaking at national and international level, funding and management, access to the facilities and the scarcity of human resources. GOOS will be confronted with most of these issues, not in the least with data infrastructure and data management. As far as that last issue is concerned, several problems can be identified which must be addressed national research agencies, the global scientific community and governments: 9 to find an appropriate balance between the rights of scientists who produce data. 9 to maintain control for a reasonable time, against the desirability of the immediate wide release of scientific results.
13
9 to assure that adequate financial support is available for analysing and archiving data resulting from large programmes. 9 to resolve technical problems associated with data quality, comparability maintenance, archiving and retrieval. 9 to assure free and open communication of scientific results. 9 to determine conditions of access to archives. I expect that the data issue will be preponderantly on the agenda of the new Forum. The Forum will articulate more precisely the different missions concerning the handling of data. A lot of practical legal and economical questions also have to be solved. Under its new mandate the Forum has been authorised to establish working groups in specific disciplines (where appropriate mechanisms are not readily available) and working groups to address cross-cutting policy questions like the data issue and problems of access to large facilities. A first set of such working groups has been initiated on neutron sources, on nuclear physics, on barriers to megascience (legislative and administrative obstacles to co-operation and access to megafacilities) and also on bio-informatics. This last group will focus on the co-ordination of the development of information systems to support large research projects in the biological sciences, with special emphasis on biodiversity and the study of neurological system. Working groups can exchange information on national research plans and project, compare project priorities, receive input from non-governmental scientific organisations (such as the European Science Foundation and International Council of Scientific Unions) and explore projects for international co-operation. If opportunities for co-operation are identified, interested governments (not the Forum) have to determine whether they wish to participate in negotiations for international projects. Such a working group could be a first step to decisions by governments. Working groups and also the Megascience Forum itself, are pioneers for governments. No more but also no less. In practice the Forum has had a direct influence in the scientific community, it has put megascience at the political agenda and in specific fields it has(like global change, continental drilling and oceanography) contributed to a better organisation and decision making structure.
3. M E G A S C I E N C E S ASPECTS OF GOOS AND E U R O G O O S Let us look now more closely to GOOS or EuroGOOS as an expression of megascience. GOOS should become a permanent system for collecting and processing data of the ocean as well as from coastal and shelf waters. However, in order for GOOS to achieve its objectives there must be effective alliances between relevant research and operational agencies and institutions at the national-, regional- and international level. These are typical megascience aspects of oceanography. The most important conclusions of the Megascience Forum expert meeting on oceanography were:
9 A system like GOOS is urgently needed. 9 GOOS (as a real megascience activity and as a long-term scientifically based international system for operational data collection, data analysis, exchange of data and data products, technology development and transfer) is making strong demands for international cooperation (on a global as well as a regional level), organisation (mixed bottom-up and topdown), multidisciplinary scientific support, involvement of the developing countries, finances etc.. 9 GOOS is producing or could produce a lot of important public goods and also a lot of profitable private goods. So economic analyses of the potential benefits of GOOS-derived data and information are important to its implementation. With help of the Megascience Forum some cost/benefit studies have been carried out. For example the Seawatch Europe project of the European Marine environment programme (EUROMAR) which is an on-line monitoring and surveillance system of the North Sea and is a regional component of GOOS. The data are available to public authorities, fisheries, tourist industry, research institutes and for defence purposed. The Seawatch system is operative in various countries amongst those also developing countries. The main revenues occur in oil and gas exploitation, commercial fisheries and meteorological forecasting. As I mentioned before, co-operation and organisation at national-, regional and global level are necessary for GOOS to achieve its objective. The Forum has called the special attention of the governments to these aspects of GOOS. GOOS is combining national, regional and global efforts. Effective "alliances at the national level are important. These "alliances are the responsibility of the national governments and the national research councils. At the global level the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC) is an important player (with others like ICSU and WMO) with its intergovernmental committee for GOOS (I-GOOS) and its advisory body J-GOOS. The IOC/I-GOOS seems to be the right forum to launch an operational programme like GOOS although it has to gain still more strength and authority. The regional level is very crucial and it will not surprise you that I at this EuroGOOS meeting, will dwell on it for a moment. An operational programme like GOOS can only function with the help of strong regional subsystems. One of these is EuroGOOS and this first annual conference is an expression of its growing strength and prestige. As far as I understand EuroGOOS is a very open and loose association of agencies which is organising mainly concerted actions to implement elements of GOOS. It has strong supporters in the ESF and the European Union. Components of observational systems like GOOS are mostly developed by the research community. However, the research organisations and institutions are not the entities to run these systems once they become operational. Therefore, it is of utmost importance that operational entities of a range of user communities (fisheries, transport, environment, safety, etc.) will take over once the system becomes operational. It is, however, an illusion to think that a 'global master plan' of organisations will achieve this. The difficult question then is how to organise that responsibility. Here I am raising two issues.
15
9 Firstly, the necessary financial resources are lacking, unless new systems replace old ones. For instance METEOSAT a meteorological satellite, was established at the expense of the so-called weather ships which were no longer required. Through this mechanism the budget became available for setting up an operational entity such as EUMETSAT. 9 Secondly, choices must be made and priorities which key variables must at least be measured what is the simplest system that will do the job in a cost effective matter. This means a close co-operation between the scientific community and operational organisations.
4. THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION AND EUROGOOS When considering organisation and co-operation aspects of GOOS, here is a prime candidate for making the concept 'Co-ordination through co-operation', launched by the European Commission, operative into a mechanism to strengthen Europe's input for GOOS (EuroGOOS). If Europe wants to be competitive it does need to better co-ordinate the national and European activities in the field of RTD. The European Commission now participates in the OECD Megascience Forum. The Forum stated that early consultation and close co-operation between the political level and the practical/scientific level is often decisive to the success of megascience projects. The Commission could well play a role as an actor in the development of the European contribution to GOOS by bringing together operational entities, science funding agencies and potential clients in the member states and in taking the lead in becoming a launching customer for the services. The Netherlands will, during its presidency (January 1997-July 1997), take the initiative to place EuroGOOS on the agenda of the European Commission. Hopefully this conference will provide a good basis for future activities. I wish you a week of stimulating discussions and a successful outcome in terms of new and intensified co-operation, across national, institutional and disciplinary boundaries.
POLICY
H. Tent, European Commission
J.D. Woods, Chairman EuroGOOS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stei, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
19
T h e E u r o G O O S Strategy J.D.Woods Graduate School of the Environment, Imperial College, University of London, SW7 2AZ.
EuroGOOS is the European contribution to the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS), which will provide the basis for operational ocean forecasting in the 21st century. GOOS is now being designed by an international team of scientists and technologists sponsored by the UN (IOC and WMO) and by the International Council of Scientific Unions. EuroGOOS is an association of 22 national agencies in 14 European states (in October 1996). Its strategy has two thrusts: (1) to foster the collaborative development of local operational systems designed to provide end users in the public and private sectors with environmental information they need about the seas around Europe and in more distant regions where there are special European interests; and (2) to provide a concerted European input to the team designing a global monitoring and analysis system which will provide information about the changing state of the open ocean needed by local operational systems wherever they exist. This paper summarizes the strategy adopted by the EuroGOOS Association, including a realistic analysis of the customer base and resources available in Europe now and likely growth in the future (Woods et al 1996).
1. The Global Ocean Observing System The Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS) is an international programme preparing the permanent global framework of observations, modelling and analysis of ocean variables needed to support operational ocean services wherever they are undertaken around the world (Woods 1995). GOOS is promoted by two UN Agencies: the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC) and the World Meteorological Organization (WMO). The Joint Scientific and Technical Committee responsible for designing GOOS is sponsored by those UN Agencies and the International Council of Scientific Unions (ICSU). GOOS was launched at the Second World Climate Conference in 1990. In addition to addressing the needs of coastal and offshore activities for marine environmental information, it will also provide the ocean component of the Global Climate Observing System.
1.1 The overall strategy for GOOS There is a growing demand for environmental information about the ocean to serve customers in both the public and private sectors. Their requirements are usually for information about
20 an area that is a tiny fraction of the World Ocean. Their needs are met by a service industry whose principal tools are observations and models covering the region of customer interest. In recent years there has been rapid development of the technologies used in observation and modelling, with the result that the information provided to customers has increasing spatial and temporal resolution and includes an increasing range of information. In particular, the advent of models that accurately simulate the three-dimensional velocity field at high resolution has opened the way to prognostic modelling of water quality. We expect that these advances in technology will lead to a rapid growth of local area marine information services during the next few decades. They will serve the needs of Government (in defence and in meeting statutory commitments regarding the use of the sea) and Industry (in reducing costs of coping with environmental hazards and satisfying the requirements of legislation). The benefits to those customers are sensitive to the quality of the environmental information provided. New kinds of information, for example on water quality, can open the way to improved procedures for managing problems of the environment. Other kinds of information, for example variable currents and the stability of sediments on the continental slope, can be a pre-requisite for commercial investment in offshore industry. Equally important is how far into the future will it be possible to predict the variation of key aspects of the marine environment. For example, recent technical advances in the prediction of wind waves promise substantial benefits for customers concerned with a wide variety of activities from coastal defence and ship-routeing to climate prediction. All prognostic models used to provide marine environmental information depend on non-linear equations, which are known to make forecasts sensitive to the uncertainty in initial conditions. Nevertheless, useful forecasts can normally be achieved provided adequate observations are available to initialize the model integrations. While these universal results of complexity or chaos theory have been successfully studied in weather forecasting, their application to marine environment prediction is still in its infancy. For most marine applications, we do not yet know the theoretical limits to predictability, nor do we have a theory that can guide the design of observations to approach those theoretical limits, as is now being achieved in weather forecasting. Scientific research on these issues is a high priority in GOOS.
1.2 The open ocean boundary condition problem It is already clear that the principal cause of premature loss of predictability, common to all local forecasting systems, is the lack of information about changes that are occurring in the ocean beyond the geographical limits of the model. For example, the recent advances in prediction of wind waves have arisen largely from taking into account the arrival of swell from distant storms (Komen et al. 1994). The limit to how far into the future it is possible to forecast water quality in North West European Shelf seas depends on uncertainty about the advection of seawater properties (physical, chemical and biological) into the area from the North Atlantic Ocean.
21
1.3 Variability in the open ocean Analysis of archive data (Levitus & Antonov 1995) and comparison of World Ocean Circulation Experiment data with earlier survey data (Gould 1996) show convincingly that the state of the open ocean is varying continuously on time scales of seasons, years and decades. This variation does not only occur in the surface waters, but extends to depths exceeding one kilometre. So it is not sufficient to assume that the conditions at the boundary of a local area forecasting system are constant. The manager of the local system needs to obtain information about how the boundary conditions for his model will change over the period of his forecast. It is likely to be prohibitively expensive for each local service to make the open ocean observations, analysis and predictions to describe its own open sea boundary conditions. Provided that there are enough local operations scattered around the ocean, it will become financially sensible to share the cost of a common system which will meet their separate requirements for open boundary information. Initially, that requirement might be satisfied by a shared system on the scale of a single ocean basin. However, attempts to do that have suffered from uncertainty about the variation at their own open boundaries. The annual and decadal variations encountered in one ocean basin are part of a global circulation. The first realistic simulations of ocean structure and circulation in single ocean basins were made in the mid-1990s (Webb 1991). It is now possible to simulate the transient eddies of ocean weather globally.
1.4 Using the global models to serve local needs As these global models become more realistic over the next decade, it will become possible to adapt them to deliver the information needed by local models. The aim will be to predict the flow of information from the open ocean to each local site. It is expected that a global model asimilating observations made in the open ocean will be capable of predicting the future variation of conditions on the boundary of each local operation. To do so it will accurately simulate the two ways in which information is transported around the ocean: advection by currents and teleconnexion by waves of different kinds (gravity, buoyancy, Kelvin, Rossby, etc.). The Gulf Stream provides an example of a permanent current responsible for significant large-scale advection; smaller-scale advection by the transient currents in geostrophic eddies is often parametrized in terms of eddy diffusion. An example of teleconnexion in the transmission of information about the surface elevation of the ocean by Kelvin waves which travel along the coasts, which provided the basis for early forecasting of tides and storm surges. More recently, valuable experience has been gained about the flow of environmental information by Equatorial Kelvin waves across the Pacific and it has been shown that observations in mid-Pacific can be used to forecast the E1 Nifio of South America. This capability is now being exploited in an operational forecasting system. In general the challenge is to make observations upstream in the open ocean track followed by information as it travels to the sites of local ocean services. Making observations further upstream extends the lead time for predicting change in the boundary conditions at the end sites. But going too far upstream runs the risk of the information being dissipated along the way.
22 1.5 The design of G O O S That approach underlies the design of the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS). The goal is to collect the data needed to ensure that global models will deliver the information required at the boundaries of local models all round the world, and the information needed by meteorologists making predictions of future changes in the global climate (Karl 1996). We do not yet understand the nature of the global circulation of the ocean sufficiently to design such a GOOS. In particular we do not know enough about how information is transported around the ocean by currents and planetary waves under the continual influence of the atmosphere, although impressive progress is being made (Chelton & Schlax 1996). We need to know what the information paths are, so that we can ensure that observations are made upstream along those paths. And we do not yet know how information flowing through the oceans is dissipated, limiting the distance upstream from which useful information can be obtained, and therefore the limits to predictability in a particular location. Resolving these issues is a high priority for scientific research, which will draw heavily on the new data set collected by the World Ocean Circulation Experiment (Woods 1985).
1.6 The technology for GOOS The development of a global marine information capability depends on the anticipated availability of two technologies: prognostic models and supporting observations. Both technologies are already based on solid achievements in scientific research projects and are being developed at a rate that promises mature systems suitable for operational use by A.D. 2020. Pre-operational systems will be tested well before that target date. A number of candidate codes exist for global ocean models. Intercomparisons of current versions are showing their relative strengths and weaknesses. The leading models all achieve impressive simulations of well documented features of the ocean circulation, but they differ in particular details. The upper ocean models designed to predict El Nifio have already demonstrated useful capability to track the flow of information across the ocean. The limits to predictability of those models are being explored. Global, full-depth models are in an earlier stage of development, and have not yet demonstrated a general capability to track information across the ocean, or to document its dissipation. That is a pre-requisite for designing a system of observations that will maximize information deliverables. Achievement of global modelling goals will depend on the availability of adequate computer power. The target for analysis of WOCE data, the Teraflops computer (one million computations per microsecond), is expected to be available in the late 1990s. The target for prognostic modelling of the water quality (which incorporates plankton ecosystem simulation) is the Petaflops computer, which is likely to be available by A.D. 2020. Although the design of an economical but effective global observing system must wait for development of suitable global models, the key technologies needed for making observations are now clear, and in many cases they have been tested. Satellite observations of the ocean are now routinely possible with a suite of instruments first introduced in the late 1970s and now
23
mature. They include active radars for measurement of sea surface elevation (altimeter), wind stress and waves (scatterometer) and imaging (SAR), and visible and infrared imagers for ocean colour (mixed layer sediments and chlorophyll) and surface temperature. Tools for monitoring the internal variability of the ocean depends on the deployment of instruments on moorings, on surface drifters and deep floats and, looking to the future, on autonomous vehicles such as Autosub. The overall capability has been summarized in reports of the OOSDE These concern measurements that will be made routinely as part of a permanent system. Pre-operational investigations are clarifying how to optimize the assimilation of information from such observations into prognostic models. In addition it will be necessary to make some observations on a one-time basis, notably improved mapping of ocean bathymetry to a specification set by the needs of global circulation models; a SCOR working group is working on this pre-requisite for ocean forecasting. There is a need for further development of the technology required to implement GOOS. However, the state of existing pre-operational systems and the rate of progress being made with global modelling and development of related observing systems is encouraging and provides a sound basis for planning with a target of establishing an operational system within twenty years. 1.7. Timetable
Given the present state of ocean observation and modelling, and the significant scientific uncertainties concerning information flow around the ocean, it is unlikely that we can design a GOOS in less than ten years. Once designed and agreed by the operators, it will take another decade to implement the observing system on technical grounds alone. There may be additional delays because of funding and legal considerations. So an operational GOOS is unlikely to feasible before A.D. 2020. There is much to be done to resolve scientific issues and to design the GOOS if it is to meet this target. That is why GOOS is being promoted now, before the critical mass of customers for global environmental information exists. It is assumed that by AD 2020 the demands of local services all round the world will have grown to the point where they can collectively justify the investment in a GOOS. The designers of GOOS assume that national and regional organisations will continue to foster the growth of local services by supporting the essential R&D and systematic observations. The pioneering examples are being established by industrialized countries; but support from overseas aid agencies (at national, regional and international level) will foster the transfer of that technology to developing countries where the benefits of marine environmental information will be even greater as coastal populations grow rapidly in the 21 st century. 1.8. S u m m a r y To summarize, there will be a rapid demand for local marine environment information and forecasts during the coming decades. That demand will be met by local operational services each using observations and a high resolution limited area model in the area of interest to their customers. The environmental products they provide will improve substantially through con-
24 tinuing investment in R&D. As these local services become mature, their performance will be limited largely by uncertainty concerning future changes in their open ocean boundary conditions. That uncertainty will be reduced by the provision of information derived from global ocean models supplied with a permanent stream of observations designed to maximize the information flow to the various customer regions. The most cost effective approach will be to design a collaborative observing scheme which will meet the needs of all local operational services around the world. This is now being designed under the name GOOS. The technology needed for GOOS already exists or is in an advanced stage of development. The lead time for implementing GOOS is likely to be twenty years, taking into account the need for applied scientific research and trials, and obtaining the necessary investment and licences to operate in national EEZs. Meanwhile the design process for the global system will be progressed concurrently with the development and proliferation of local marine environmental services all round the world. 2. EuroGOOS EuroGOOS is the European component of GOOS, and consists of an Association of national Agencies working together to foster European participation in GOOS, and the development of operational oceanography for the benefit of Europe. At present (October 1996) EuroGOOS has 22 Members in 14 European countries. The goal of EuroGOOS is to foster collaboration between those national Agencies during the design and trials phase of GOOS with a view to achieving economies and faster progress. The primary focus for EuroGOOS is on the development of effective local operational services for the public and private sectors in the seas around Europe and in more distant regions with which Europe has strong connections. In parallel with that development, EuroGOOS will work with the international team designing the global observing and modelling system to ensure that it meets the needs of the European end users. The economic philosophy underpinning EuroGOOS is that any investment in marine environment services, whether local or global, must be justified by the incremental benefits they bring to the end users in the public and private sectors. The EuroGOOS strategy therefore starts by identifying the goals and benefits of EuroGOOS. 2.1. The goals of EuroGOOS EuroGOOS has three goals: 1.
To create in Europe the new business of operational services and forecasting of the ocean and coastal seas.
2.
To exploit the advances in scientific understanding and technical capability resulting from the R&D investment in oceanography during the last thirty years.
3.
To focus international development of operational ocean services and GOOS onto the specific needs of Europe.
25 2.2. The benefits to Europe Operational oceanography presents Europe with the opportunity to profit from previous investment in marine science, and to develop a new business which will directly employ some 5000 people, with a turnover of the order of 500 Million ECU per year. This business will support and improve the performance of existing maritime industries and services which have an annual GNP value in the EU of 110-190bn ECU/year. The additional economic benefit created by improvements in efficiency, better decision making, and better management of the environmental problems is expected to be in the range 2 to 5bn ECU per year. Forecasts of the state of coastal seas and oceans for days to decades into the future will add several percent to the revenue of all maritime industries. They will produce benefits of the same order of magnitude in improved seasonal and inter-annual climate forecasts which will create a statistical basis for improved management of agriculture, water supplies, and power generation. Europe should be able to capture at least one third of the global business in operational marine observation and forecasting outside Europe. Operational oceanography generates a demand for new technology, field survey skills, and computing services, which can be exported globally
2.3. The penalty from taking no action Failure to exploit the previous investment, and failure to invest further by developing the skills of government agencies and commercial companies throughout Europe will lead to less efficient maritime industries, increased losses from poor environmental management and marine pollution, increased public health risk, and penetration of European markets by nonEuropean organisations offering services to Europe. On the global scale, European service companies would fail to gain their share of a global market measured in billions of dollars. Inadequate marine environmental prediction systems will result in lack of investment in projects which appear environmentally sensitive, but which could be acceptable and beneficial. European politicians negotiating on issues such as fisheries, pollution and climate change, would have to rely increasingly on non-European models and predictions provided by non-European agencies
2.4. The European advantage Europe has particularly strong assets in its advanced computer-based modelling, strong space agencies, advanced maritime industries, strong environmental management policies, and accumulated skills from decades of investment in basic and strategic marine science. Europe has a strong network of marine laboratories, a fleet of research and survey vessels, strong meteorological services, and a range of companies with worldwide skills in coastal and offshore services. Efficient operational oceanography demands an economically designed array of observing systems, buoys, satellites, ships, gathering data from each sea area according to a scientifically designed sampling scheme: experience of European collaboration in space and weather forecasting shows that we can work together at all geographical scales. This collaboration requires planned installation of observing systems, rapid exchange and transmission of data, preferably within a few hours, computation of the best description of the state of the sea
26 or ocean, and rapid dissemination of data and forecasts to users. The European Principles of Competitiveness, Cohesion, Subsidiarity, Human Capital, and European Identity provide an excellent political framework for collaboration within EuroGOOS to achieve the goals of successful operational ocean services.
2.5. EuroGOOS and its customers We have identified numerous sectors of the growing business of operational oceanography, and Members have compiled lists of hundreds of potential customers in each country. Many of the data and forecasts obtained by European and Government agencies will be processed further by commercial companies in the value-added industry, and transmitted through a chain of intermediaries to customer groups requiring very different products. The final benefits accrue within individual industries and activities such as: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12.
Offshore oil and gas Fisheries Mineral extraction Defence Pollution management Climate prediction Port operations Coastal protection Ship-routeing Aquaculture Tourism Public health
2.6. Guiding principles We identify guiding principles for the development of operational oceanography. The services derived from operational oceanography must be targeted towards identified user groups. There must be a continuing dialogue with potential users of operational marine data and forecasts. All operations, data gathering, modelling, and forecasting, should be done with optimum planning of installations and services so that coastal states and agencies share responsibilities without duplication. New technology of sensors, satellites, and computer modelling can be implemented so as to produce a new range of cost-efficient services. The full benefits of operational oceanography are only obtained when observations and modelling are integrated at scales from global, to regional, to local. It is possible to develop and improve existing systems in parallel with the consistent introduction of new technology and new science so that we converge towards an optimal system in 5-10 years time. Europe should systematically transfer technology and capacity building to developing countries, especially in the southern hemisphere, in order to ensure that all Member States of the UN System are able to participate in GOOS and benefit from it. New training systems are needed in Europe to provide expert staff in operational oceanography.
27
Europe has global interests in the development of GOOS, and should collaborate technically with the major overseas participants including America, Australia, China, India and Japan. The European sea areas of especial interest are the marginal and semi-enclosed seas, Baltic, North West European shelf seas, the Mediterranean and Black Seas, and the adjacent Arctic Ocean. Europe has a special requirement to understand and predict the Atlantic both for reasons of short term economics, and for long term prediction of climate variability and climate change.
3. Components of the EuroGOOS strategy We have identified ten linked strategic sectors of action, and have started work in all sectors. The sectors are: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. I0.
Identification of customers, users, and beneficiary groups Estimation of the costs and benefits of operational oceanography. The Scientific Basis of EuroGOOS. The Technology needed for EuroGOOS. Development, Trials, and Case Studies Design and optimization of the observing system Numerical modelling, data assimilation and forecasting. Products, services, value added, and services to the end user. Interfacing with those planning the global aspects of GOOS. Links to other European scale organisations and programmes.
These strategic sectors provide areas of activity where the pursuit of consistent objectives can be maintained with steadfast purpose. It is unlikely that any of these components of the strategy will ever be dropped. Each sector of activity is analysed below in terms of overall strategy and specific targets for the short term (1996-98), medium term (1998-2002) and the long term (2002 to 2006 and beyond). We shall now briefly summarize the EuroGOOS strategy in each of these ten sectors.
3.1. Identification of customers, users, and beneficiary groups The overall strategy is to identify and maintain contact with a customer base of many hundreds of organisations; to understand their needs for marine environmental data and forecasts; to update this information regularly; and to develop a dialogue between EuroGOOS Members and customers and potential customers. The short term targets (to end 1998) are to identify the addresses and personal contacts for at least 100 potential customers and user agencies for operational oceanographic information and forecasts in each country which has a Member Agency in EuroGOOS; and to establish a preliminary list of non-European users. The medium term targets (to end 2002) are to develop a routine system of acquiring customer address lists from exhibition catalogues, conferences, and surveys of product users; to continue a regular schedule of dialogues with customers and user groups through conferences
28 and workshops and feedback exercises; and to check the lists against performance or uptake of information and forecast products. The long term target (to 2006 and beyond) is to broaden the customer base by strengthening links to climate variability forecasting and land based users of climate data.
3.2. Estimation of the costs and benefits of operational oceanography. The overall strategy is to justify investment in operational oceanography. Specific goals are to analyse and publicize the economic facts about the need for operational oceanographic data and forecasts; to improve the techniques of gathering economic information on marine industries and services; to develop a standard methodology for all European countries to use in estimating the economic and social scale of marine industries and services; and to promote theoretical analysis and publication of economic models for international operational oceanography. The short term targets (to end 1998) are to participate in workshops on economics and costbenefit analysis of GOOS (most recently at Washington, May 1996); to organise sessions on economics of operational oceanography at the first EuroGOOS Conference (The Hague, October 1996); and to ensure that the study of economics of GOOS is supported at an international level with particular attention to the needs of developing countries. The medium term targets (to end 2002) are to complete country-by-country descriptions of the scale of national maritime industries and services on a standard basis and to aggregate those data to produce a European overview; to develop intermediate models of international economics of GOOS and EuroGOOS; and to advance economic modelling of the benetits of climate change forecasting in association with GCOS. The long term targets (to end 2006 and beyond) are to complete multi-parameter models combining economic models of marine industries and services, models of the uptake and application of forecast information, and the resulting economic and social benefits; and to adapt or develop economic and social models for the tangible benefits of EuroGOOS, taking account of environmental economics.
3.3. The Scientific Basis of EuroGOOS. The overall strategy is to obtain the best available scientific advice for the design and implementation of an observing system; to ensure that numerical models are developed and tested with the capability to meet the requirements of EuroGOOS; to analyse plans for the implementation of EuroGOOS and detect if there are scientific flaws which could undermine the system; and to analyse the limits of predictability of models, and to develop scientifically sound procedures for assimilation of data into models. The short term targets (to end 1998) are for the Scientific Advisory Working Group (SAWG) to produce a draft Scientific Plan for incorporation into the EuroGOOS Plan by the end of 1997; to identify in this Plan priorities for scientific work in the next few years; and to foster
29
applied research aimed at establishing the limits of predictability for each of the target forecast products. The medium term targets (to end 2002) are to confirm the scientific criteria to support practical modelling and prediction of shelf seas in terms of water chemistry, nutrients, oxygen, etc.; and to ensure that satisfactory progress is being made in process studies and specification of operational modelling criteria for the North Atlantic and Arctic Oceans. The longer term targets (to end 2006 and beyond) are to ensure that scientific criteria are thoroughly established for the observing system needed to support climate monitoring and forecasting based on analysis of WOCE and CLIVAR data; to foster EuroGOOS members collaboration in data gathering for climate forecasting; and, in shelf seas, to establish the science base for water quality modelling, including suspended particulate matter, ecosystem and aspects of fisheries recruitment. 3.4. The Technology needed for EuroGOOS. The overall strategy is to analyse existing technological systems available for operational oceanography; to estimate the optimum technology needed to implement each phase of a developing operational service; and to identify the gaps in technology and foster the development and application of new technology to improve forecasting. The short term targets (up to end 1998) are for the Technology Plan Working Group (TPWG) to create an inventory of instruments used at present in operational oceanography in Europe and to identify the gaps and cquipmcnt nccdcd in thc short, medium and long terms; and by means of reports to suggest means to promote the development of the mos! urgently needed devices. The medium term targets (up to end 2002) are for Members to investigate the practical applications on a routine basis of techniques that are at present experimental, such as acoustic tomography, new sensors for chemical and biological variables, combinations of sensors and telecommunications, automatic data quality control, data assimilation and the use of autonomous underwater vehicles, midwater floats and acoustic tracking. The long term targets (to end 2006 and beyond) are for members to collaborate in using the most cost-effective and advanced technology which supports the gathering of operational data, and the running of operational models at the Teraflop level.
3.5. Trials, Development and Case Studies The overall strategy is to have EuroGOOS members conduct paper studies to identify essential trials and tests and then to establish collaborative arrangements between the relevant groups of members to carry out trials or pilot projects as required in the European Regional Seas, and in the Atlantic ocean; to identify the need for one more European Centres for modelling trials, data assimilation and optimization of sampling strategy.
30 The short term targets (up to end 1998) are to identify the priority systems and technologies which need to be developed at each geographical scale to meet the particular needs of each region; to combine the plans of the scientific and technology working groups and regional requirements in order to design trials of systems and pilot projects; and to consult with manufacturers who may be interested in participating in such trials. The medium term targets (up to end 2002) are for EuroGOOS members to collaborate in conducting trials of new operational systems, technology, data transmission networks, data assimilation schemes; and generate test products at regional seas scale, Atlantic scale and globally. The long term targets (to end 2006 and beyond) are to develop trials systems that incorporate models run on very high performance computers, seagoing technology which is today at an early stage of development, and satellite missions that are only now being planned.
3.6. Design and optimization of the observing system The overall strategy is progressively to deploy new observational instruments, data transmission systems and establish modelling centres in such a way as to provide a continuously improving range of economically useful products and to generate those products with the optimum observing and sampling design at the lowest feasible cost. The short term targets (up to end 1998) are to establish designs for the optimum observing scheme and rate of development for each Region and for the Atlantic, drawing on the results of the other EuroGOOS groups; and to begin testing and implementing those designs in the regions that are most advanced. The medium term targets (up to end 2002) are to improve procedures for optimizing the observing system and to conduct trials of different options through varying assumptions and model boundary conditions exploring the sensitivity to information from available global models, inclusion of particular observing systems, and improvements in the accuracy and number of data acquisition sites. The long term targets (to end 2006 and beyond) are to optimize the observing system and correctly allocate resources as the design evolves; and to manage the review and trials procedures to assist in the phasing in of new technology.
3.7. Numerical modelling, data assimilation and forecasting. The overall strategy is to develop, test, implement and progressively upgrade the most effective numerical models for those marine variables and parameters which are of highest priority for users of operational forecasts; to identify and compare the best modelling systems for different variables, regions and scales; and to develop the most efficient data assimilation schemes for operational ocean simulation and forecasting.
31 The short term targets (to end 1998) are to transfer existing research models and prototype models into the operational sector; to concentrate initially on data assimilation and models of physical variables including tides, meteorological forcing, sea level, wind stress, waves, surface currents and sea ice; then to introduce profiles of currents, temperature, salinity, chlorophyll; to accelerate the development of research models into operational models; and to discover the limits of predictability for different variables, models, regions and scales. The medium term targets (to end 2002) are to implement operational models in all European Seas predicting hydrodynamic variables, nutrients, water quality, chlorophyll and primary production, suspended sediment load and sediment transport, and coastal erosion; implement operational models for the Atlantic and Arctic Oceans to monitor and forecast surface temperature, upper ocean heat content, full depth profiles of temperature and salinity, sea ice cover, directional wave spectrum, surface currents, quasi-geostrophic eddy fields, circulation in three dimensions, depth of buoyant convection, thermocline ventilation, upper ocean nutrients, chlorophyll, carbon dioxide and primary production. The long term targets (to end 2006 and beyond) are to foster collaboration in Europe and with similar groups in America, Asia and Australia to ensure that the best modelling techniques in the world is used to satisfy the needs of European end-users for marine environmental intormation. 3.8. Products, value-added, and services to the end user.
The overall strategy is to produce regularly a full range of competitive marine data products and services designed to meet economic, social and environmental needs; and which can be transmitted through an array of value-added data processing organisations to a wide range of end users. The short term targets (to end 1998) are to complete the user data requirements survey; to compile an address list of at least 2000 potential end-users of operational marine environmental information; to correlate the variables and products required to various classes of end-users and regions; to prioritize the design of products; and to conduct dialogue with user groups through the EuroGOOS Conference in October 1996 and other meetings. The medium term targets establish a core list of large cies prepared to participate the customer list to conduct
(up to end 2002) are to improve communications with customers; commercial organisations and government and international agenin developing a funding base for operational satellites; and to use surveys for improved data products and services.
The long term targets (to end 2006 and beyond) are to establish a continuous and automatic monitoring system for customer services, which records products being used most frequently, scales and variables most frequently required, problems most frequently encountered in satisfying requests; to undertake routine comparisons of services required within Europe and
32 around the World; and to maximize promotion of European operational oceanographic services globally.
3.9. Interfacing with those planning the global aspects of GOOS. The overall strategy is to develop policies for furthering GOOS and coordinating the best possible European participation in GOOS, identifying where the greatest value is added by collaboration; and to ensure that the global design and implementation plans for GOOS are balanced to provide the best data sets and models, producing scientific, economic and environmental benefits on an equitable basis. The short term targets (up to end 1998) are to specify EuroGOOS objectives and capabilities for observing and modelling the Atlantic and Arctic Oceans within the framework of GOOS; to identify those components of the global observing system that could be contributed by Europe, especially with regard to remote sensing; and to identify regions in other oceans (Indian, Pacific, Southern) where European skills could contribute to GOOS. The medium term targets (to end 2002) are for EuroGOOS members to participate in the design and development of the global observing system, and to make available to GOOS planners the results of studies and trials undertaken in the European Seas and the Atlantic. The long term targets (to end 2006 and beyond) are for EuroGOOS to maximize its contribution to and return from participation in GOOS by coordinating applied research and operational projects, advising on the plans for operational satellite schedules and exploiting the technological systems developed in Europe; and to promote collaboration between members in the provision of technology transfer to developing countries to help facilitate their full participation in GOOS.
3.10. Links with other European scale organisations. The overall strategy is to link efficiently with other European organisations so as to promote the rapid development of operational oceanography without duplication, overlap or excessive bureaucracy. The short term target (to end 1998) is to make initial contact with those of the European organisations listed below (see w The medium term targets (to end 2002) are to establish routine communications with other European agencies and organisations and where appropriate to enter into joint ventures in order to pursue the goals and objectives of GOOS. The long term targets (end 2006 and beyond) are to maintain strong communications and joint ventures with other European agencies and organisations.
33
4. Resources, Assets and Opportunities Europe possesses a world-class range of facilities for the development of operational oceanography. These include numerical modelling groups, satellite design and launch capabilities, research ships, experience of working globally in both operational services and global marine science experiments, existing regional and local marine operational forecasting services, experience of marine robotic instruments and autonomous underwater vehicles, a well-informed and technically experienced user community ready to benefit from improved environmental data and forecasts, a strong marine science programme with integration across Europe between many laboratories, a strong high technology manufacturing base and a wide range of marine service companies.
4.1. Trans-national organisations Europe benefits from a number of European trans-national organisations which have an interest in maritime development and marine science and technology. These include: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
The European Union and its Commission (EU and EC) The Council of Europe The European Space Agency (ESA) The European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) European Meteorological Satellite Organisation (Eumetsat) The European Science Foundation (ESF) European Research Programmes (Framework and Eureka) European Environmental Agency (EEA) Olso and Paris Commission (OSPARCOM) Marine Industries Forum (MIF)
Organisations with a majority of European members and interests in marine technology include: I. 2. 3. 4.
Group of Seven leading industrial countries (G7) Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES)
4.2. Methods and activities EuroGOOS has started a programme of activities which includes design studies and surveys of customers and data requirements, trials of technology and systems, test case studies of the design for operational services in a variety of sea areas, workshops, publications and communications with industry, demonstration projects, collaboration with other European Agencies and Programmes, organisation of a major Conference, communications with GOOS programmes in the USA, Australia, and North East Asia, scientific analysis of the possible improvements to marine numerical models, estimation of the limits to predictability in shelf seas, optimal design of an observational sampling strategy, and identifying gaps in technology.
34
5. The EuroGOOS Plan
Following the EuroGOOS International Conference in the Hague in October 1996, the various working groups and studies carried out by EuroGOOS will be drawn together to create the inputs for the EuroGOOS Plan, which will contain more detailed analysis of costs and future sources of funding. Operational oceanography will need to be funded by a combination of commercial sales of products and services, the provision of services and forecasts to government agencies with statutory responsibilities, national support in the public good, and European or international funding to provide European and global services. In the immediate future, while preparing the EuroGOOS Plan, effort will be devoted to: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Foster partnerships, projects, and joint ventures between Members of EuroGOOS. Develop relations with existing and potential users and partners Foster links with European industries providing the tools needed for operational oceanographic services. Develop relations with European Institutions. Develop relations between EuroGOOS and International GOOS, other regional bodies in GOOS, and other international organisations: Organise European summer schools and seminars. Strengthen the EuroGOOS Association. Identify sources of funding for EuroGOOS.
EuroGOOS will make a special effort to identify technical, instrument, and system requirements which could be provided by European companies. Manufacturers and service companies will be provided with information on the technology requirements, and encouraged to participate in trials and prototype tests of systems. At the global level EuroGOOS has strong working relations with both the lntergovernmental Committee for GOOS (I-GOOS) and the Joint Scientific and Technical Committee for GOOS (J-GOOS). 6. Conclusion Operational oceanography provides an opportunity for investment and development which promises to produce a significant economic return to Europe, and provide extensive benefits in management of the environment, protection of public health and safety, and climate prediction. The scale of the new business of operational marine forecasting will be of the order of 500 million ECU/year, and 5000 new jobs. Europe is in an excellent position to take on a global role in operational oceanography, for which there exists a sound foundation in existing scientific and technological assets. If we do not decide to invest in operational oceanography, European organisations will suffer diseconomies, and will have to buy the services and forecasts from outside Europe. The EuroGOOS Association of leading national agencies serves as the collaborative base for rapid and cost-effective development of a new service industry which will provide an ever wider range of high quality marine information to end users in the public and private sector.
35 REFERENCES
D. B. Chelton and M. (3. Schlax (1996). "Global Observations of Oceanic Rossby Waves." Science 272, 234-8. J. Gould (1997) WOCE Data Guide 1997 WOCE Report No. 150. 12pp. T.S. Karl (Ed.) (1996) Long-Term Climate Monitoring by the Global Climate Observing System Dordrecht, Kluwer, 648pp. (3.J.Komen, Cavaleri, L., Donelan, M., Hasselmann, K., Hasselmann, S., & Janssen, P. A. E. M. (1994). Dynamics and Modelling of Ocean Waves. Cambridge University Press. S.Levitus & Antonov, J. (1995). "Observational evidence of inter-annual decadal-scale variability of the subsurface temperature-salinity structure of the World Ocean." Climate Change, 31,495-514. D.Webb ( 1991) "FRAM - the Fine Resolution Antarctic Model" In: D.(3.Farmer & M.J.Rycrofl (eds.) Computer modelling in the Environmental Sciences Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1- 14. J.D.Woods (1985) "The World Ocean Circulation Experiment" Nature 314, 501-511. J.D.Woods (1995) "The Global Ocean Observing System" Marine Policy 18, 445-452. J.D.Woods, H.Dahlin, L.Droppert, M.Glass, S.Vallerga & N.C.Flemming (1996)"The Euro(3OOS Strategy", Euro(3OOS Publications No. 1, Southampton Oceanography Centre, Southampton, 178pp.
36
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge for European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Cost Benefit Analysis of TOGA and the ENSO Observing System'
Peter G. Sassone* with Rodney F. Weiher** *School Of Economics, The Georgia Institute Of Technology, Atlanta, GA. 30332 USA ; Phone: (404) 894-4912, Email:
[email protected] **Chief Economist, National Oceanic And Atmospheric Administration, Washington, D.C. 20230 USA; Phone: (202) 482-0636, Email:
[email protected]
R&D programs intended to develop climate prediction capabilities are costly. But if they are successful, they yield continuing economic benefits. However, because such benefits are difficult for private companies to capture, it falls to the public sector to pursue them. Public sector decision makers, before funding climate research programs, must be convinced that such programs serve the public interest, i.e., that their economic benefits exceed their economic costs. The purpose of this paper is to shed some light on that issue. Specifically, we construct a cost benefit analysis of the recently completed TOGA (Tropical Ocean Global Atmosphere) program. TOGA, a successful 10 year international scientific effort to understand and model the ENSO (El Nino / Southern Oscillation) phenomenon, has led to models which are capable of predicting ENSO events a year or so in advance. In our cost benefit analysis, we used estimates of the benefits of climate forecasts to the U.S. agricultural sector, the actual historical and the estimated future costs (to the U.S.) of the research, development and operationalization that climate forecast system, and a 36 case sensitivity analysis. Our results indicate that TOGA will provide a real economic return on investment to the U.S. of at least 13% to 26%, depending on the assumptions made in the analysis. This is substantially in excess of the hurdle rate of 7% usually used by the federal government. We conclude that the TOGA program was a sound use of public resources, and that additional funding of climate forecasting R&D efforts (at both the national and international levels) merits serious consideration.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N The successful prediction of climate, which may be viewed as long term average weather patterns, has economic value. Farmers who know in advance whether the coming growing season will be warmer or cooler than average, or wetter or drier, can adjust their planting strategy to take advantage of this information - perhaps by planting earlier or later, or using a different variety of seed, or altering the mix of crops planted. If the climate prediction is correct, and if farmers take account of that prediction in their decisions, then (all else equal) they will produce a more successful harvest. In like manner, water resource and hydro-
37
electric managers could make better decisions about releasing or retaining water in reservoirs if they knew in advance whether the coming months would be more or less rainy than usual. Aquaculture and the management of construction projects would also benefit. Climate prediction of this sort - several months to a year or two in advance - relies on models based on scientific understanding of atmosphere and ocean dynamics and interactions, and on an extensive data gathering system. These models are developed through research which involves detailed and long term in situ measurements of climate variables, and through sophisticated computer modeling. The data gathering system involves air, water and land based instruments, reaching across much of the globe. Both the development of climate models and their subsequent operationalization involve significant costs.
2. T H E E C O N O M I C S OF C L I M A T E F O R E C A S T S Climate forecasts are public goods. A public good, as defined by economists, has two key characteristics: non-rivalry and non-excludability. Non-rivalry means that one person's consumption of the good or service does not diminish the amount of that good or service available for others' consumption. Non-excludability means that once the good is provided for anyone, it is readily and freely available to anyone else. In other words, it is difficult or impossible to exclude anyone from partaking of the good, once it's made available to anyone. Economists often cite national defense and clean air as examples of public goods. A climate forecast, because it is non-rival and non-excludable, is also a public good. The concept of a public good is important because it explains how a good or service may be highly valued 2 by the members of society and, yet, why private sector firms would be unwilling to produce it. This unwillingness is a simple consequence of non-excludability: if a firm can't prevent people from consuming the good without their paying for it, then many people won't pay (or at least would underpay), and the firm would not be able to recover its costs. In other words, in the case of public goods, there is a divergence between the private and the social return on the investment required to produce the good. 3 The social return on the investment may be substantially greater than the private return. Economists recognize, therefore, that an important role of government - even in a market based economy - is the provision of certain public goods. However, all goods that satisfy the criteria of being public goods do not merit public funding. It is not difficult to identify some public goods whose costs exceed their value to society. For example, nightly fireworks shows over the mall in Washington, DC would qualify as public goods (being both non-rival and non-excludable), yet the social value of those nightly displays surely would be less than their cost. We can conclude that only those public goods which also pass the cost benefit test should be provided by government. The cost benefit test is that the value of the benefits to society (of the public good) should exceed its costs to society. In some cases, it is relatively straightforward to estimate the benefits and costs of government programs, and in other cases it is quite difficult. Usually, when difficulties are encountered, it is the benefits that are the more problematic. It's important to recognize, however, that difficulty in quantifying benefits (or costs) does not render those effects any less real.
38 In the post-WWII era, much research and development came to be recognized as a public good, and much R&D consequently was supported by the federal government through grants and contracts with universities and private research organizations, and through the establishment of federal research units. Early in that period, the cost benefit test (while often recognized) was not widely demanded or applied by government decision makers. Beginning in the Reagan era, cost benefit analyses became more widely mandated; and in the fiscally conservative '90s, the pressure to "cost-justify" government expenditures has increased. Today, while climate research and forecasting programs are widely recognized as public goods, the costs and benefits of those programs are subject to increasing scrutiny. Indeed, there is widespread concern in the scientific community that such programs will likely not receive significant future funding unless there is compelling economic justification.
3. C L I M A T E RESEARCH P R O G R A M S Climate research has been funded, on a small scale, by the federal government at least since the DOT's Climatic Impact Assessment Program (CLAP) and the NSF's NORPAX program of the early '70s. 4 In 1984, the U.S. government joined with a number of other countries in the ten year T O G A (Tropical Ocean Global Atmosphere) program, which focused on understanding ENSO events. ENSO (El Nino / Southern Oscillation) refers to quasi-periodic climate episodes originating in the tropical Pacific, and affecting weather patterns in South and Central America, as well as in the southern U.S. 5 These climate episodes, with irregular annual periodicity, sometimes bring warmer and wetter weather (El Nino), sometimes colder and drier weather (Southern Oscillation or La Nina), and sometimes "normal" weather. The variation in climate is sufficiently dramatic as to cause widespread flooding in some years and drought in others. The breakthrough in understanding the ENSO phenomenon was made in 1969 by Norwegian meteorologist, Jacob Bjerknes. He recognized that the ENSO cycle was driven by the interaction of the atmosphere and the ocean in the tropical Pacific, and that models accounting for this interaction could predict ENSO events. The TOGA program's objectives were: 6 1.
2. 3.
To gain a description of the tropical oceans and the global atmosphere as a time dependent system, to determine the extent to which this system is predictable on time scales of months to years, and to understand the mechanisms and processes underlying that predictability To study the feasibility of modeling the coupled ocean-atmosphere system for the purpose of predicting its variations on time scales of months to years; and To provide the scientific background for designing an observational and data transmission system for operational prediction if this capability is demonstrated by coupled ocean-atmosphere models.
The TOGA Program is recognized among the scientific community as a major success. Based on that research, there now exist at least several ENSO prediction systems that have demonstrated prediction skill at least a season in advance. Perhaps the currently most successful coupled ocean-atmosphere model is that of Zebiak and Cane, which has predicted several ENSO events at least a year in advance. 7 Based on TOGA research, in 1995 the
39
National Weather Service began issuing seasonal average temperature and precipitation forecasts for the continental U.S. for overlapping 90-day periods, out to a year in advance. These forecasts are published in a new monthly NWS product, Climate Outlook. In addition, another new product, monthly Outlooks, (forecasts for 30-day periods) will soon be issued by the NWS. Based on the demonstrated successes of the TOGA program, follow-on programs have been developed and proposed by the scientific community. These proposals fall into 2 categories: the operationalization of past research and the conduct of new research. NOAA's plan for an Operational ENSO Observing System falls into the first category. 8 During its 1985-95 lifetime, TOGA was developed, operated and funded as a research program. The plan now is to evolve this research program into an operational program for collecting data and making routine ENSO forecasts. This would be a key contribution of the U.S. to the international scientific community's GOOS and GCOS programs, which were formally established in 1991 and 1992, respectively. The GOALS program falls into the second category. It is envisioned as a 15 year research program building on the success of the TOGA program. "The plan calls for an expansion of observational, modeling, and process research to include the possible influences of the global upper oceans and time-varying land moisture, vegetation, snow, and sea ice." The question faced by U.S. budget authorities regarding these and other proposed climate programs is whether the benefits exceed the costs. However, the determination of the costs and (especially) the benefits of climate programs is not an easy matter. While cost benefit analysis is a highly refined and widely accepted tool used frequently by economists to evaluate alternative public sector investments, there are certain characteristics of climate prediction investments which render them inherently more difficult (than conventional public investments such as roads, bridges, buildings_) to assess. These characteristics include: 9 Uncertainty about the ultimate actual costs of the programs. 9 Uncertainty about the ultimate success of the proposed research. Unlike a project to build a road or a bridge (where there is virtual certainty that the project can be accomplished), projects to develop climate prediction models are not guaranteed to succeed. The research simply may not uncover the hoped-for correlations and regularities among the variables. 9 Even if the science is successful, the actual benefits of a (correct) climate forecast for a given season will be contingent on the actual climate which occurs. That is, if the actual climate is extreme, and if it's correctly forecasted, the benefits will be greater than if the actual climate is normal (and it is correctly forecasted). Of course, the benefits in a cost benefit analysis must be estimated for many years into the future, and there's no way of knowing what seasonal climate patterns will actually occur so far in advance. 9 Cost benefit analysis (CBA) carries out an economic comparison of a proposed public investment versus a baseline, that is, versus a scenario in which the proposed investment project is not carried out. The two scenarios are assumed to be alike in every other salient respect. (This is the ceteris paribus assumption commonly used in economic analysis.) Thus, CBA inherently compares the incremental benefits in the project scenario (that is, the gains over the baseline) to the incremental costs in the project scenario (the costs in excess of those incurred in the baseline scenario). In the case of a climate project, because climate research has already advanced to the point of enabling climate forecasts (albeit
40 imperfect ones), the baseline scenario must include a statement as to what forecast would be issued absent the proposed project, and what the consequences of that forecast would be. This would be a highly speculative basis for a CBA. 9 Finally, the behavioral responses to climate forecasts would have to be specified for both the baseline and the project scenarios. That is, the extent to which the forecasts will be "believed" and acted upon by the relevant economic sectors in the future would have to be specified. Today, there simply isn't a sound basis on which to make credible long term forecasts of those parameters. The dilemma, then, is that a CBA of climate research is necessary to assist U.S. budget officials in making funding decisions, yet the construction of such a CBA is fraught with difficulties. A workable way around this dilemma is to focus on the recently concluded TOGA program, and on the proposed operationalization of the climate forecasting capability developed under its aegis. That is, one can view TOGA along with a subsequent operationalized ENSO forecasting system as a single program - extending 10 years into the past and perhaps 15 - 20 years into the future. This CBA would ask whether that program is worthwhile. The analysis would be retrospective with regard to the R&D costs of TOGA and prospective with regard to the costs of the operationalized observing and forecasting system. The benefits would be the future value of the seasonal to interannual ENSO forecasts which would be provided by the system, along with any additional scientific benefits not captured as part of the value of improved forecasting. In what follows, we adopt the shorthand, TOGA/EOS, to stand for the combined TOGA program and NOAA's proposed ENSO Observing System. This approach to a CBA, while not overcoming all of the problems mentioned previously, strikes a balance between tractability and pertinence. It's tractable because the TOGA portion of the program has already occurred, so its costs and scientific outcomes are known with certainty. The EOS portion of the program is in the near future, so its costs can be estimated with some degree of confidence. This approach to CBA is pertinent because it is an objective assessment of the economic value of an actual climate research program. As such, it provides some insight into the potential value of similar research programs. In a sense, the proposed climate research programs of today are where the TOGA program was in 1985: a climate research program with substantial potential benefits, but also with a great deal of uncertainty.
4. T H E P U R P O S E OF THIS STUDY The purpose of this study is to address the benefits and costs of climate research programs, and thereby support government decision makers who have budget responsibility in this area. More specifically, our purpose is to present the results of a cost benefit evaluation of a combined TOGA/EOS. The CBA, described below, finds that a lower bound estimate o f the social real internal rate o f return 9 of the combined TOGA/EOS program ranges from approximately 13% to 26%, depending on the particular assumptions employed in the calculations.
41 5. THE CBA F R A M E W O R K
The fundamental concept in CBA is the comparison of alternative scenarios (or time lines). The baseline scenario is what happens without the proposed policy or program. The alternative (or project) scenario is what happens with the proposed policy or program. The impact of the policy or program is the difference between the two scenarios. The goal of CBA is to adequately identify and quantify that difference in monetary terms. CBA is almost always motivated by an impending policy or program decision, and the CBA is best seen as a decision-aid. Cost benefit analysis generally proceeds along the following lines. The first step is clearly to identify precisely the issue to be addressed. That is, for exactly what policy or program are we trying to estimate the benefits and costs? And exactly what is the baseline? As already discussed, in this case we've chosen to focus on the TOGA/EOS program. The second step in a CBA is qualitatively to identify the benefits and costs. This is done by filling in the details associated with each scenario, and identifying where the scenarios coincide and where they diverge. Where the scenarios coincide, no further CBA consideration is required, because there is no difference between scenarios. Where the scenarios diverge, those differences must be explicitly identified. The third step is to quantify in physical dimensions ( person-years, tons, bushels, etc.) those identified costs and benefits. The fourth step is to estimate the monetary value of those quantified physical effects. This is usually conceptually straightforward when treating costs, but it is sometimes quite challenging when dealing with certain benefits. In fact, it is in the valuation of benefits that economic theory makes its most important contributions to cost benefit analysis. Finally, the last step is to aggregate the monetary effects over time using present value analysis, to perform relevant sensitivity calculations, and to summarize results and conclusions. Because CBAs are usually prospective (forward-looking), there often is substantial uncertainty about the values of many variables relating to future costs and benefits. There are two principal ways of dealing with uncertainty in CBA. One technique is the use of sensitivity analysis. Assuming that net present value (NPV) is the criterion being used in the CBA, sensitivity analysis determines how responsive (sensitive) the calculated value of NPV is to changes in the uncertain variables. The goal is to determine whether the conclusion of the analysis (whether the proposed investment is/is not worthwhile) is substantially affected by different plausible values of those key variables. Sensitivity analysis can be done in a variety of ways, some more sophisticated than others. Perhaps the simplest approach is to vary one variable at a time (often from "best" case to "worst" case values) and calculate the corresponding values of NPV. A sophisticated approach is to construct probability density functions for each key variable, and then (usually through a Monte Carlo analysis) construct the probability density function for the project's NPV. In this way, the probability that NPV exceeds 0, or is in one range or another, can be readily estimated. The second technique for dealing with uncertainty is by constructing intentionally conservative estimates of costs and benefits, thereby insuring that the final calculations yield a lower bound estimate of the net benefits of the program. In practice, the two techniques of sensitivity analysis and of using intentionally conservatively biased estimates of costs and benefits can be combined, as we have done in this analysis.
42 6. THE CBA M O D E L FOR CLIMATE R E S E A R C H
Our approach is to carry out an analysis of the combined TOGA/EOS program using, as the costs of the program, the actual historical costs of TOGA along with the projected costs of the ENSO Observing System as proposed by NOAA. In the model, the benefits of TOGA/EOS are the projected "expected" benefits to the U.S. agricultural sector of annual ENSO forecasts. The costs and benefits are aggregated using present value analysis. Specifically, the internal rate of return (IRR) for the entire investment is calculated. IRR is a widely used, and intuitively appealing, summary measure of the economic value of an investment. 1~ The IRR is an especially useful summary measure of the value of TOGA/EOS because it is independent of where, in the time line of the project, the analysis is grounded. In other words, in using the IRR criterion, it doesn't matter whether we carry out the calculations as though we were in 1985 and we were looking at the entire TOGA/EOS program unfolding into future; or whether we assume we're in the year 2010 looking back at the entire program; or whether we're in 1996 looking back at TOGA and forward to EOS. As long as we use the same annual cost and benefit values in each calculation, the resulting IRR will be the same whether viewed from 1985, 1996, or 2010. For convenience, the annual values of costs, benefits and related calculations are organized in a spreadsheet and shown in Table 1. Columns A and B show the time index and the corresponding years relevant to the analysis. Note that 1995 is indexed as time period "0." Column C shows the TOGA-related costs incurred by federal government agencies in each year up to and including 1995. These agencies include NOAA, NSF, NASA, and ONR. Column D shows the cost of ship time (ships are used to deploy and tend buoys). Column E is the sum of C and D. Column F is the relative price index (for federal non-defense purchases). The index is anchored at 1987 (index = 100), and the index in each year is stated relative to 1987. For example, the value of 130.5 for 1994 means that a given bundle of goods purchased by the federal government in 1994 would cost 30.5% more than that same bundle would have cost in 1987. In other words, the effect of inflation was to increase the costs of goods to the government by 30.5% over the period 1987 to 1994. Using the price index allows us to remove the effect of inflation. For convenience, we adjust all costs to equivalent 1995 values. This is done by constructing in column G a new index anchored at 1995, and then multiplying each value in column E by that new index. Note that the new index (column G) is simply 134.0 (the 1995 price index in column F) divided by the column F index value for that particular year. For example, the 1984 index value in column G is 134.0 / 91.3 = 1.47. This means that costs incurred in 1984 can be converted to their equivalent 1995 value by multiplying them by 1.47. These equivalent costs of the TOGA program are shown in column H. Note that although the costs in column H are adjusted for inflation, they are not adjusted to account for the present value of those historical costs. The adjustment for present value, done through the internal rate of return calculation discussed below, takes account of the investment return that could have been earned on resources consumed in earlier years. Turning now to the ENSO Observing System, current government planning documents indicate an expected annual cost of the system of $12.3 million. That value is shown in column I as the future annual cost, expressed in 1995 dollars. For the purpose of this analysis, we use the estimates developed by Adams et al. of the social benefits related to the U.S. agricultural sector of improved ENSO forecasts.
--
TARLE ...- 1.
BENEFIT ANALYSIS WORKSHEET B
A
.............TIME ..... INDEX . ....
0 E Annual estlrnated U S . Oovt TOGA- current c o d Of related current ship Ume not Total current costs (OW) from Included annual costs = U.S. govt budget elsewhere gOvtcOd+ ship C
..... FISCALYEAR docu.m.enb...........
parameter value:
formula: -11 -10 -9 -8 -7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 sum 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 ....20 . ...... . ...: ....................
1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 201 1 2012 2013 2014 2015
$4,624 $6,041 $5.227 $16.615 $17,276 $12,595 $20,910 $32,185 $35.700 $30,925 $30.1 70 $10.400 $222,668
I?!!.*!
F
H
0
lmpllcii price dCnator for federal nondefense purchases. 1987-1 W Factor to adjust [Source: BE&. 1995 current costs
I Estimated annual postTotal pre-1995 1995 costs of corn ENSO expressed In Observing 1995 dollan System. In 1995
..........
J
Percent d agrlcultum declslon maken urlng forec
$12,300
$1.275 $355 $917 $ 70 $437 $1,260 54.607 $2.065 $1,058 $12,043
C+D $4,624 $6,041 $5,227 $17.890 $17,631 $13,512 $20,980 $32,622 $36,960 $35,532 $32,235 $1 1,458 $234,711
91.3 95.7 98.6 100.0 101.4 107.3 112.0 116.9 120.2 124.7 130.5 134.0
.................
G’E $6.787 $8.459 $7,104 $23,972 $23.299 $16,874 $25,101 $37,394 $41,203 $38,182 $33,099 $11.458 $272,932
1.47 1.40 1.36 1.34 1.32 1.25 1.20 1.15 1.11 1.07 1.03 1.OO
..:.:...
K
1
Estlmaled annual
bcneflIa to us
agricultun of ENSO forecasts. In 1995 dollan
$240.000 S266;OOO J’(ab0ve)
Estimated annual net btneflk In 1995 dollan (000).
............................... ......... .*.:.......
K-H-I ($6.787) ($8,459) ($7.104) ($23.972) ($23,299) ($16.874) 625,101) ($37.394) ($41,203) ($38.182) 033.099) ($11.458)
$12.300 $12.300 $12,300 $12,300 $12.300 $12.300 $12,300 $12,300 $12.300 $12,300 $12,300 $12,300 $12.300 $12.300 $12,300 $12.300 $12,300 $12.300 $12.300
50.00% 57.50% 65.00% 72.50% 80.00% 87.50% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00% 95.00%
%?.?
?_530086..
.........
............
$120.000 $138,000 $156.ooO $174,000 $192,000 $232,750 $252,700 $252.700 $252.700 $252.700 $252,700 $252,700 $252,700 $252.700 $252.700 $252.700 $252.700 $252,700 $252.700
$107,700 $125,700 $143.700 $161,700 $1 79,700 $220,450 $240.400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240,400 $240.400 P
‘W
44 These figures, discussed below, are a measure of the gain in consumers' and producers' surplus associated with improved information. At the top of column K of Table 1, the figures $244,000 and $266,000 are shown. These are the estimates produced by Adams et al. of the expected annual value (in 1995 dollars) of 60% and 80% skill levels (respectively) ENSO forecasts. These estimates assume that all farmers heed and act on the forecasts. Because there is likely to be incomplete acceptance by farmers of ENSO forecasts, at least initially, we have built into the CBA model a "forecast acceptance curve." A range of forecast acceptance curves were used in the analysis, and are discussed below. The particular curve illustrated in Table 1 embodies the assumption that acceptance starts off at 50% level, and builds to a maximum of 95% over a six year period. The resulting dollar benefits, shown in column K, are the product of column J and either $240,000 or $266,000 (depending on the assumption made about the accuracy of the forecast system. Finally, column L shows the annual net benefits (benefits - costs) of the TOGA/EOS investment. Column L is calculated as columns K - H - I. The internal rate of return calculation (technically, the real internal rate of return) is calculated from the values in column L, which show the annual flows of resource values either consumed or generated by the TOGA / EOS program.
7. M E A S U R E M E N T OF B E N E F I T S
As mentioned above, in this study we have relied upon the results of a recent study by Adams et al. of the value to U.S. agriculture of alternative skill levels in forecasting ENSO events. This study (forthcoming) builds on methodology and results of a previous study by the same authors which focused on southeast U.S. agriculture. ~ The methodology employs a Bayesian "value of information" framework. In their initial study, Adams et al. estimated the value of improved ENSO forecasts to southeastern U.S. agriculture as $145 million (for perfect forecasts) and $96 million (for 80% accurate forecasts). That initial research was recently modified and extended by Adams et al. to cover the entire U.S. agricultural sector. This latest study
"evaluated the economic value of three forecast skill levels with regard to the three ENSO states. These forecast skill levels are 1) a modest forecast skill level of .6 probability (technically, .6 is the probability of a forecast of a specific ENSO phase, given that the phase occurs); 2) a forecast skill level (improvemenO to .8 probability (a "high" skill level) and 3) a perfect forecast (probability of 1.0). These three skill levels and three states o f nature frame the set of possible economic consequences (considered in the study). The economic consequences associated with all forecast skill-outcome (ENSO phases or states o f nature) combinations are measured against a common base - the economic value o f a "no-skill" forecast situation, where producers follow historical crop management decisions each year.
.12
The results of this latest study (which are not entirely comparable to the previous results) indicate that the annual value of perfect ENSO forecasts is $323 million, the value of high skill (80% accurate) forecasts is $266 million, and the value of modest skill (60% accurate) forecasts is $240 million. These figures are "expected" annual values, in 1995 dollars. The expected value is computed by assuming that E1 Nino, La Nina, and "normal" climate are each
45
likely to occur in the future according to their actual historical relative frequencies, and that the forecast skill (60%, 80%, or 100%) is independent of the actual climate. At the present time, the research of Adams et al. is the only work we could identify which has attempted to quantify - at the national level, and taking general equilibrium considerations into account - the economic value of ENSO forecasts. In the cost benefit analysis reported here, we have used the recent Adams et al. figures as the expected benefits of improved ENSO forecasts. By ignoring the benefits in economic sectors other than agriculture, we are understating the actual benefits - perhaps to a substantial extent. ~3 Also, by ignoring any benefits which would accrue to other countries affected by ENSO events (e.g. in Central and South America), we are further understating total benefits. ~4 Also, by using the Adams et al. 1995 values as the values for future years as well (effectively assuming a stagnate U.S. agricultural sector), benefits are further understated. Thus, we believe it is appropriate to interpret our results as lower bound estimates of the value of the TOGA/EOS program. In order to deal further with the uncertainties in the analysis, four parameters were varied in our sensitivity analysis: the ENSO forecast skill level, the future time horizon, the rate of acceptance of ENSO forecasts by the agricultural sector, and the annual (future) cost of the ENSO Observing system (including the cost of generating and disseminating the forecasts). By varying these four parameters, thirty six scenarios were generated and evaluated.
8. RESULTS Table 2 shows the results of our cost benefit evaluation of the 36 scenarios just mentioned. Note that the forecast skill level was allowed to assume 3 values: 60% accuracy, 80% accuracy, and a combination 60%/80% that allows for improvement in ENSO forecasting as more data are collected and models are refined. In 60%/80% case, we assumed that forecast skill improves from 60% to 80% after 5 years into the EOS program. The time horizon over which future benefits are counted was set at two values: 10 years and 20 years. The ten year perspective is admittedly short, because we would expect that ENSO (and other climate phenomena) forecasts would continue to be made indefinitely into the future. The issue, from the CBA perspective, is how long into the future we can credibly associate the benefits of ENSO forecasts with the costs and results of the TOGA program. It is certainly conceivable that new climate theories and forecasting models may evolve, and such models may not stand directly on the foundation laid by TOGA. Thus, while it is admittedly difficult to pin down a "best" time horizon, 10 and 20 years may reasonably bound the contribution of TOGA. Agriculture has become an increasingly sophisticated economic sector, highly dependent on technology and knowledge. Today, farmers routinely adopt new technologies, such as hybrid seed or new herbicides, pesticides and fertilizers. Some research on the diffusion of new technology in the agricultural sector suggests that new technology becomes substantially absorbed into the industry over a period of less than a decade. While ENSO forecasts are a somewhat different kind of "technology" than farmers are accustomed to dealing with, we assumed here that the adoption and use of such forecasts by mainstream agriculture will not be remarkably different from farmers' adoption of other new technologies. Thus, for our sensitivity analysis, we posited three "ENSO forecast adoption" scenarios.
46
TABLE 2 S U M M A R Y OF R E S U L T S REAL IRR FOR TOGAJENSO OBSERVING SYSTEM (FY84 TO FY05 OR FY15) FOR SELECTED PARAMETER VARIATIONS FORECAST
BENEFITS
RATE OF
ANNUAL
SKILL
TIME
FORECAST
COST OF
REAL
CASE
LEVEL
HORIZON
ADOPTION
ENSO OBSER SYS
IRR
1
60%
10
SLOW
$12.3M
13.39%
2
60%
10
SLOW
$17.3M
12.87%
3
60%
10
M ODE RATE
$12.3 M
19.50%
4 5
60% 60%
10 10
MODERATE I M M EDIATE
$17.3 M $12.3 M
19.14% 23.88%
6
60%
10
IM M EDIATE
$17.3 M
22.93%
7
60%
20
SLOW
$12.3M
17.16%
8
60%
20
SLOW
$17.3M
16.78%
9
60%
20
M OD ERATE
$12.3 M
21.52%
10
60%
20
MODERATE
$17.3 M
21.22%
11
60%
20
I M M EDIATE
$12.3 M
25.13 %
12
60%
20
I M M EDIATE
$17.3 M
24.26 %
13
80%
10
SLOW
$12.3M
14.51%
14
80%
10
SLOW
$17.3M
14.03%
15 16
80% 80%
10 10
MODERATE MODERATE
$12.3M $17.3M
20.75% 20.42%
17
80%
10
IMMEDIATE
$12.3M
25.22%
18
80%
10
I M M EDIATE
$17.3 M
24.29 %
19
80%
20
SLOW
$12.3M
18.09%
20
80%
20
SLOW
$17.3M
17.74%
21
80%
20
MODERATE
$12.3 M
22.63%
22
80%
20
M ODE RATE
$17.3 M
22.35%
23
80%
20
I M M EDIATE
$12.3 M
26.37%
24 26
80% 60%180%
20 10
IM M EDIATE SLOW
$17.3 M $12.3M
25.51% 14.06%
26
60%180%
10
SLOW
$17.3M
13.57%
27
60%180%
10
MODERATE
$12.3M
19.98%
28
60%180%
10
MODERATE
$17.3M
19.64%
29
60%180%
10
I M M EDIATE
$12.3 M
23.57%
30
60%180%
10
IM M EDIATE
$17.3 M
23.30%
31 32
60%/80% 60%180%
20 20
SLOW SLOW
$12.3M $17.3M
17.81% 17.45%
33
60%180%
20
MODERATE
$12.3 M
22.04%
34
60%180%
20
MODERATE
$17.3M
21.75%
35
60%180%
20
I M M EDIATE
$12.3 M
24.93%
36
60%/80%
20
I M M EDIATE
$17.3 M
24.68%
15
MODERATE
$14.8 M
20.35%
10 TO 20 YRS
SLOW TO IM MEDIATE
AVERAGES: RANGES:
60% TO 80%
$12.3M TO $17.3 M
12.87% TO 26.37%
.~.:-:-:.:-:.:-:-:.:-:-:-:-:~:-:-:-:-:-:-:.:-:-:~.:.:.:-:-~:.:-:-:.:.:-:~:.:-:~:.:-:~:.:.:~:-:-:-:-:-:-~-~-:~:.:~:~:~:~:-:-:~:-:-:-:-:~:~:-:-:-:.:~:-:.:~:~:-:-:-:-:-~-~-:-:-:~:-:~:-:~:~:.:~:~:-:-:-:~:.:-:-:-:-:-:-:~:-:-
47 In one scenario, which we labeled the "SLOW" rate of forecast adoption, we assumed that initially only 10% of the agricultural sector heeds (and acts on) the forecast. In successive years, that percent grows to 20%, then 30%, etc.; finally peaking at 90% in the ninth year, and remaining at 90% thereafter. In another scenario, which we labeled the "MODERATE" scenario, the initial acceptance is 50%, growing linearly to 95% over a six year period (and remaining at 95% thereafter). This is the scenario reflected in Table 1. Finally, as the most optimistic case, we assumed that there would be "IMMEDIATE" 95% acceptance.
9. C O N C L U S I O N S The calculated real internal rate of return for the 36 scenarios of the combined TOGA / EOS program is shown in the last column of Table 2. The real IRR values range from about 13% to 26%. The Office of Management and Budget recommends to federal agencies that such IRRs be compared to a hurdle rate of 7%. ~5 The reasoning is that "(t)his rate approximates the marginal pre-tax rate of return of an average investment in the private sector in recent years." In other words, had resources not been absorbed by TOGA and (prospectively) the EOS, and if those resources had remained in the private sector, they could have been invested in private sector projects generating a real return of about 7%. Thus, the opportunity cost of the capital absorbed by the TOGA/EOS programs is 7%. We should, therefore, judge those programs economically worthwhile only if they generate returns to society at least as great as the cost (real 7%) they impose. ~6 By this criterion, the TOGA / OEFS program handily passes the CBA test. Importantly, the range of results produced by the sensitivity analysis (the 36 cases) falls entirely on the "up" side of the hurdle. Considering these results, and subject to the usual qualifications, we can be reasonably confident that the TOGA/EOS program represents sound use of society's resources. Furthermore, it is clear from the analysis that if one focused solely on the prospective EOS program, accepting TOGA as a now sunk cost, its real IRR would be substantially higher than those values reported above. Thus, we can confidently conclude that the presently proposed ENSO Observing System, built on TOGA, is a worthwhile public investment. Finally, as suggested above, one might say the proposed GOALS program today is where TOGA was in 1985 -- a promising but uncertain climate research program. Our results here suggest that climate research has measurable and substantial economic payback. That is a clear argument in favor of society's continuing a modest stream of investment in climate research.
10. F U R T H E R E C O N O M I C R E S E A R C H NEEDED
The analysis presented here takes an aggregate perspective on climate research and on the operationalization of research programs. That is, we have analyzed the programs as a whole, without inquiring into economic decisions and trade-offs that might be made within each program. Whether we are focusing on EOS, GOALS, GOOS or GCOS, cost effectiveness analysis (CEA) as well as cost benefit analysis (CBA) may be useful. While CBA focuses on
48 the value of the program as a whole (and takes as given the resource allocation within the program), CEA may be used to aid the resource allocation decisions that must be made as a program takes shape. For example, there is a potential trade-off of labor versus capital in some areas of climate research. Insofar as the objectives of a climate research program may be achieved in several ways (e.g. by having more scientists working on a problem, or having more instruments in the field for expanding the database, or by having more powerful computers), CEA would be a useful tool to help decision makers allocate their budgets efficiently. In order to carry out CEA within climate research programs, a model of research progress would need to be constructed. Such a model would attempt to capture the marginal costs and the differential marginal contributions of the various inputs (budget items such as different kinds of sensing instruments, different kinds of labor inputs, different kinds of computer hardware/software,_) in the climate research and operational forecasting processes. Using this information, it would be possible to investigate and implement trade-offs among inputs, and thereby to enhance the efficiency of the programs. The economic efficiency ideal, which would be targeted by a CEA, is that the inputs into the program should be structured so that the last dollar spent on each type of input makes the same contribution to the overall success of the program. Another important area of economic research, alluded to previously, is the quantification of the benefits of climate forecasts in areas besides agriculture. For example, research should be pursued to quantify the benefits to water resource management, off-shore oil exploration, fisheries, coastal management, etc. Encouraged by the success of the TOGA program, more ambitious climate programs---such as GOALS have been proposed by the climate research community. GOALS would attempt to integrate global land, ocean and atmosphere elements into a global climate model. If the effort is even partially successful, there would be substantial economic benefits to many parts of the world. As an effort requiring international cooperation, GOALS faces numerous hurdles. Not the least of these would be economic justification. A CBA of GOALS would follow the outline used here for the TOGA/EOS program. There would, however, be some additional complexities. Some countries from which financial support and scientific cooperation are solicited may resist unless it can be demonstrated that the economic benefits to themselves outweigh their economic costs. In other words, a CBA would have to investigate not only the total costs and benefits, but also their distribution among the world's political boundaries. In order to provide this economic justification, research is needed along the following lines. 9 First, we need to understand the ways in which climate, and decisions based on expectations about climate, affect the economies of the world. Of course, we can extend the knowledge we have gained in the U.S. to other countries, recognizing that agriculture is a key sector almost everywhere. However, especially in non-temperate climates and in non-industrialized economies, there may be other economic sectors affected by climate and climate expectations in ways not yet fully understood. The challenge is, on a country by country (or at least region by region) basis, to identify those sectors and quantify the relationships among output, climate, and climate-expectations-related production decisions. Importantly, this information can be used to shape the priorities within GOALS, itself---perhaps by directing initial efforts at the highest value opportunities.
49 Also, this information might usefully influence how the program is financed, asking countries with greater expected benefits to contribute more generously to the effort. 9 Second, we need to understand how, and at what rate, improved information about seasonal to interannual climate will affect economic decisions in different countries. As mentioned previously, unless climate forecasts are heeded, they have no economic impact. (A related issue here is how best to disseminate climate forecasts. One can imagine that culture, tradition, and even religion may influence how readily forecasts are accepted.) It would be useful, in this regard, to track acceptance and use of the new NWS monthly and seasonal climate forecasts in the U.S. as in initial indication of the rate of their acceptance and use in an industrialized economy. 9 Third, we need to construct a credible estimate of the long run costs of GOALS research and its subsequent operationalization. Based on our experience with TOGA, this task may not be quite as daunting as it may have appeared only a few years ago. With cost estimates in hand, it would be possible to construct economic breakeven analyses, which would determine the minimum level of success needed to justify the program on a country by country (or region by region) basis.
NOTES
This research was supported by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). The authors are pleased to acknowledge the helpful comments of the following individuals on an earlier draft of this paper: Rich Adams, Martin Brown, Richard Lehman, Bruce McCarl, Don Spillman and William Woodward. Of course, responsibility for any errors or omissions remains with the authors. 2 Value is usually measured as informed and rational consumers' willingness and ability to pay for something, rather than going without it. 3 Private return is the financial gain (profit) to firms producing and selling the product. Social return also includes those gains to consumers (willingness to pay in excess of actual payments) which are not appropriated by firms. This latter gain is called consumers' surplus. 4CIAP was a research effort, funded through the USDOT, to assess the climate impacts of a proposed fleet of supersonic transport (SST) aircraft. NORPAX (North Pacific Experiment) pioneered the use of expendable bathythermograph profiling from volunteer observing ships. 5There is some evidence of ENSO effects in Europe and Northern Africa, as well. 6 National Research Council GOALS for Predicting Seasonal-to-lnterannual Climate, Washington, DC 1994. 7Zebiak and Cane "A Model E1 Nino/Southern Oscillation" Mon. Wea. Rev. 115:2262-2278, 1987. g Michael Johnson et al., Transition Plan Towards an Operational ENSO Observing System, NOAA, November 1995. 9 Our terminology needs explanation. "Lower bound" means that we have used conservative estimates of costs and benefits so our results are likely not to overstate the value of the
50 program. "Social" means we've included benefits to consumers as well as producers. "Real" means that in our analysis we have removed the effects of inflation. "Internal rate of return" is discussed below. 10 IRR is often used in evaluating financial investments, such as the purchase of securities. For example, a bond which costs $1000 and which pays the holder $100 per year in interest, and which then returns the principal of $1000 along with the final $100 interest payment has an IRR of 10%. Another way of interpreting the IRR is as that discount rate which, if used to calculate the net present value of the investment, would result in a value of $0. A project's calculated IRR should be compared with the opportunity cost of that investment (the rate of return that could be earned in the next best investment). Currently, OMB suggests a real value of 7% as the appropriate hurdle rate 11 Adams et al., "Value of Improved Long-Range Weather Information," Contemporary Economic Policy, Vol. XIII, July 1995 ~2Personal communication between Adams and one of the authors. ~3 Research, sponsored by NOAA, is currently underway to quantify the value of climate forecasts in other climate sensitive sectors, such as hydroelectric power, natural gas, water management, and fisheries. ~4 Whether to include "spillover" benefits to other countries in a CBA depends on the perspective and purpose of the CBA. Certainly, a global CBA perspective - as discussed later in this report- would include those benefits. t5 OMB Circular A-94 (revised), 10/29/92: Guidelines and Discount Rates for Benefit-Cost Analysis of Federal Programs 16 It's worth noting that even if society would have chosen to consume, rather than invest, the resources absorbed by the TOGA / EOS programs, the conclusion remains unchanged. This is because, in choosing to consume rather than accept a 7% real return, society reveals that present consumption is worth at least as much as the flow of future consumption that could be financed by the investment of those resources.
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
The World Weather Watch:
51
Is an ocean equivalent meaningful or realistic?
P.E. Dexter, R.C. Landis and T.W. Spence WMO, CP 2300, CH-1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland
This paper reviews the origin, structure and operations of the World Weather Watch, and analyzes the reasons for its success. It then considers whether something equivalent may be realizable for the oceans.
1. INTRODUCTION Meteorological services are required for the safety of life and property, the protection of the environment, and for the efficiency and economy of a wide range of weather sensitive activities. Central to the provision of these services as well as to related research and development activities, is the generation and exchange between national meteorological centres of observational data, analyses and forecasts on a variety of time and space scales extending from instantaneous to longterm, from local to global. The World Weather Watch is the international cooperative system through which vital meteorological and related information required by individual countries, by other WMO programmes and relevant programmes of other international organizations is collected, processed and distributed in real-time on a world-wide basis. The system involves the frequent and regular observation of a wide range of meteorological elements from thousands of locations on land and sea, in the air and from outer space; the rapid collection and exchange of the observations; the preparation of information and charts describing the current and forecast weather; and the dissemination of this information to all national Meteorological and Hydrological Services that require it. It is based on the reality that all parts of the global weather system are always interactive and thus no one country can be fully self-sufficient in the provision of all of its meteorological and related services. Implementation of the WWW system is through application of the concept that each Member country undertakes, according to its means, to meet certain responsibilities in the agreed globally cooperative scheme. The main functions of the WWW programme are planning, organization and coordination of the facilities and arrangements at the global and regional levels, the design of observing and communications networks, the standardization of observing and measuring techniques, the development and use of common communications and data management procedures, and the presentation of both observations and processed information in a manner that is understood by all, regardless of language, as well as supporting activities that assist national Meteorological and Hydrological Services to obtain maximum benefits from the programme.
52 The WWW programme embraces, in cooperation with other agencies and organizations, as appropriate, meteorological programmes in extra-territorial regions and for outer space. It also includes the Tropical Cyclone Programme that aims to provide timely warnings and to reduce the adverse impact of damaging tropical storms.
2. HISTORY
If a date has to be assigned to the beginning of the modem era in meteorology it would have to be 20 December 1961, when the General Assembly of the United Nations (UNGA) called for a concerted approach to weather forecasting making full use of new technologies. By this time, following the creation of the United Nations itself in 1945, the World Meteorological Convention had been adopted in 1947 and, in 1951, the new intergovemmental World Meteorological Organization had been established to replace the old non-governmental IMO. The relevant resolution of UNGA gave an immense stimulus to the work of WMO in exploring the physical forces affecting weather and climate and in further developing its traditional activities related to weather forecasting. This series of events led directly to the creation of the World Weather Watch, perhaps the single most important event in a century of international meteorology. Acting on the General Assembly resolution, WMO prepared and presented to the following session of the Assembly an initial report which discussed in broad outline a worm weather watch combining satellite and conventional observations, a network of world and regional weather service centres, and a telecommunication system. Following a new UNGA resolution urging further development of the concept, in April 1963 the Fourth Meteorological Congress enthusiastically adopted the idea of the World Weather Watch which became a reality four years later with the approval of the WWW Plan. A fundamental principle was that the WWW would be implemented and operated by Members themselves to the extent that their resources permitted and in accordance with the agreed Plan. The implementation of facilities in areas outside national territories would be based on voluntary participation of countries providing equipment and services from their resources. To assist states less able to contribute to and benefit from the global system, a Voluntary Assistance Programme (now called the Voluntary Cooperation Programme) was established to coordinate and provide assistance to Members in implementing elements of the WWW. At the same time, WMO signed an agreement with the International Council of Scientific Unions to develop jointly the Global Atmospheric Research Programme (GARP). GARP's main purpose was to understand the transient behaviour of large-scale atmospheric fluctuations in order to increase the accuracy of forecasts for a period of one day to several weeks. Additionally, GARP was to determine the statistical properties of the general circulation of the atmosphere that could lead to a better understanding of the physical basis of climate. As a result, GARP became a synergistic research element for the development and planning of the WWW. These and most of the other ideas and principles formulated at the inception of the WWW are still valid today.
53 3. STRUCTURE, OPERATIONS AND APPLICATIONS OF THE W W W The overall objectives of the WWW are: (i) To maintain an effective world-wide integrated system for the collection, processing and rapid exchange of meteorological and related environmental data, analyses and forecasts; (ii) To make available, both in real-time and non-real-time, as appropriate, observational data, analyses, forecasts and other products to meet the needs of all Members, of other WMO programmes and of relevant programmes of other international organizations; (iii) To arrange for the introduction of standard methods and technology which enable Members to make best use of the WWW system and ensure an adequate level of services, and also the compatibility of systems for cooperation with agencies outside WMO; (iv) To provide the basic infrastructure for GCOS and other WMO and international programmes for climate monitoring and studying of climate issues. The WWW functions on three levels: global, regional and national. It involves the design, implementation, and further development of three closely linked and increasingly integrated core components: Global Observing System (GOS) consisting of facilities and arrangements for making observations at stations on land and at sea, and from aircraft, meteorological satellites and other platforms; Global Telecommunication System (GTS) composed of an increasingly automated network of telecommunications facilities for the rapid, reliable collection and distribution of observational data and processed information; Global Data Processing System (GDPS) consisting of World Regional/Specialized and National Meteorological Centres to provide processed data, analyses, and forecast products. WWW support functions assist in the coordination and integration of the three core components: WWW Data Management (WWWDM) which is to coordinate, monitor and manage the flow of data and products within the WWW system in accordance with international standards to assure their quality and timely delivery to meet Members' individual needs and those of other WMO programmes; WWW System Support Activity (SSA) to provide guidance, technical and scientific information, and training to those involved in the planning, development and operation of WWW components; and to initiate, coordinate and evaluate various WWW cooperative activities and support actions. This includes the Operational Information Service to collect and distribute information on facilities, services, data and products made available within the WWW system. Five other WMO programme activities contribute directly to support WWW operations: an instruments and methods of observation programme; a tropical cyclone programme; WMO satellite activities; emergency response activities; and WMO Antarctic activities. The Commission for Basic Systems (CBS) is the technical commission of WMO which is entrusted with the technical responsibility for the WWW system. Some 130 countries are members of this Commission which holds its sessions every two years. The CBS coordinates the operational requirements of the Member countries and converts them into implementation plans, standardized
54 procedures and practices. They are submitted in the form of recommendations to the Executive Council for approval. Active cooperation between the WMO regional associations and CBS is becoming increasingly important in the future with a view to responding to the specific needs of and implementation in the regions.
Figure 1. The World Weather Watch is a global system for the collection, analysis and distribution of weather and other environmental information
Figure 2. World Weather Watch programme planning and implementation
55 In addition to its support for the operational requirements of national Meteorological and Hydrological Services for meteorological and related data and products, the WWW is increasingly seen as providing a base observations network and communications and data management infrastructure which will be and are critical to the success of related international environmental systems such as GCOS, GOOS, IGOSS and the GlobalAtmosphere Watch (GAW). 4. ANALYSIS The WWW has been evolving for over 30 years, and will continue to evolve even more rapidly in the future. To a very large extent it has been successful in meeting its immediate and still primary goal, which is to satisfy the requirements of national Meteorological Services for atmospheric and related environmental data and products, so that they in turn can provide the environmental services required by a wide range of national and international user communities. This success has come about for three fundamental reasons: The WWW has been designed and implemented in response to clearly expressed national requirements for meteorological data and services, The WWW is clearly focussed in terms of data types, products and services to be delivered~ The WWW itself provides a focus, rationale and mechanism for developing national Meteorological Services world-wide.
Figure 3. Areas of fellowship awards indicating WMO's support for WWW-related training During the next decade, advances in technology are expected to contribute to an enormous increase in the level of services provided by the WWW basic systems. Mechanisms are now in place to ensure that the WWW will make the best possible use of these advances, and in some cases even lead and influence future developments in science and technology. Present inadequacies in the
56 system, in particular the global disparities in observational data availability and in telecommunications facilities are well recognized, and it is hoped and expected that technological advances will greatly help to overcome these. In any case, the WWW will continue to remain focussed on and pursue its basic goals of providing the international infrastructure for meteorological and related services, and of ensuring that all countries, to the maximum extent possible, both contribute to and benefit from the operation of the system.
5. GOOS AND THE W W W - CRITERIA F O R A W O R L D OCEAN W A T C H The GOOS concept has been in existence, in one form or another, for more than seven years now, and while many man-years and several forests of paper have been expended in trying to elaborate this concept, we sometimes seem no nearer an agreed specification than in the beginning - perhaps further! Nevertheless, there is probably broad agreement on certain aspects, including overall objectives: (i)
(a) (iii) (iv)
(v)
To specify in detail in terms of space, time, quality and other relevant factors, the marine observational data needed on a continuing basis to meet the common and identifiable requirements of the world community of users of the oceanic environment; To develop and implement an internationally coordinated strategy for the gathering or acquisition of these data; To facilitate the development of uses and products of these data, and encourage and widen their application in the use and protection of the marine environment; To facilitate means by which less-developed nations can increase their capacity to acquire and use marine data according to the GOOS framework; To coordinate the ongoing operation of GOOS and ensure its integration within wider global observation and environmental management strategies.
There is also some agreement on elements of the system: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv)
A routine, long-term observing system; Data and information management; Data analysis, modeling, products and services; Capacity building.
Superficially, and as generalities, these objectives and system elements are remarkably similar to those for the WWW. However, it is when the specifics are addressed, or even when the questions what, why and how are asked ,that the difficulties begin. The GOOS module concept is widely recognized, though not widely understood, and its practical value is now under question. Nevertheless, the modules provide a useful starting point when attempting to address specifics since, to a certain extent, they provide a classification of potential GOOS applications.
57 Before analyzing the modules, however, and in the context of this paper, it is postulated that essentially the same criteria must be applied to a possible future World Ocean Watch as have been instrumental to the success of the WWW. In summary: 9 There must be clear, expressed requirements for the global exchange of oceanic data and products, and for services to users derived from these; 9 The system must be reasonably focussed in terms of data types, products and applications; 9 The involvement of all maritime countries, in terms of both contributions and benefits, is clearly defined, with mechanisms in place to facilitate involvement according to this definition. If these criteria are accepted, then the analysis of GOOS as a World Ocean Watch, at least on a module basis, becomes relatively straight forward: 9 Climate: Requirements largely known and accepted; clearly focussed, while accepting that specific data types and scales will evolve; national benefits and contributions may be easily identified and supported; 9 Health o f the ocean: Requirements developing, primarily local or regional, though methodologies may be global; reasonably well focussed, though evolving; national involvement may be defined but difficult to implement in a global context; 9 M a r i n e living resources: Requirements yet to be clearly defined, especially for global operational data exchange; focus not yet available; national involvement not defined; 9 Coastal: Requirements available, but national or perhaps regional, though methodologies may be global; focussed only in terms of existing met/ocean services; national involvement and interests strongly expressed, though not always clearly defined, especially in context of a global system; 9 Where G O O S services have been defined, these are mostly in practice those already existing and deriving from the WWW and related systems (e.g. IGOSS); the role of GOOS will thus at best be as a supporting or value-adding system. When, as is always the case, the modules are regarded as parts of some integrated system, it becomes even more difficult to define clear global requirements or to define a focus, both of which are essential to an ocean equivalent WWW concept. It is thus clear that, without negating the overall value, objectives and strategy of GOOS, the World Ocean Watch equivalent of the WWW really only has meaning in the context of an ocean observing system for climate.
6. A W O R L D OCEAN W A T C H F O R CLIMATE Many of the requirements for upper-ocean and atmospheric data for global climate studies are so closely linked that it is likely that a World Ocean Watch for climate will be implemented and maintained in close complementarity to the WWW, making use of many of the same data collection, exchange, processing, modeling and management facilities. Where additional oceanic variables are required for climate, such as deep circulation and carbon flux, some extension of these facilities may nevertheless be the most appropriate. In this context, a schematic for a possible World Ocean Watch for climate is shown in Figure 4.
58
Figure 4. Schematic of a possible World Ocean Watch for Climate Evidently, this World Ocean watch will contain basic system elements equivalent to those of the existing WWW:
59 An observing system based on a scientific design provided by bodies such as the Ocean Observations Panel for Climate and the CLIVAR Upper Ocean Panel, beginning with existing terrestrial and satellite-based observing platforms and data collection facilities, evolving with developing technologies, and maintained through a mix of operational and research programmes; A data exchange system, for operational exchange of ocean data on a global basis, using both an enhanced GTS and Intemet-type facilities and internationally agree common formats; A data processing and data management system, including national, regional and global centres, oceanographic, meteorological or even dedicated purely to climate modeling. It is not irrelevant to note that many of the elements of this World Ocean Watch are now in place, in the WWW, the Integrated Global Ocean Services System of IOC and WMO, and the International Oceanographic Data and Information Exchange of IOC. IGOSS in particular is modeled directly on the WWW in the way envisioned for the World Ocean Watch. The WWW, IGOSS and IODE are all adapting to the developing ocean climate requirements of GOOS and GCOS as they become known, and will continue to do so in the future. It makes sense, and indeed is the only conceivable practical approach that the World Ocean Watch part of GOOS should be constructed and operated through these existing systems.
7. CONCLUSIONS The World Weather Watch is an established operational environmental monitoring and services programme which has been evolving for more than 30 years. It has been largely successful in meeting its fundamental objectives because: 9 9 9
It has been designed and implemented in response to clearly expressed national requirements for data and services; It is clearly focussed in terms of data types, products and services; It itself provides a focus, rationale and mechanism for the development of national Meteorological Services worldwide.
If an ocean equivalent of the WWW is to come about, it must satisfy much the same criteria for success. Analysis shows that only the climate module of GOOS would be sufficiently focussed, with well defined requirements, and would be able in turn to act as a focus and catalyst for the development of operational oceanography at the national level, so as to eventually form an effective, operational World Ocean Watch, similar to the WWW. In this case, it is also clear that many of the building blocks for such a World Ocean Watch for Climate are already in place, and it is the only practical approach that this part of GOOS should be constructed through these existing mechanisms, including the WWW, IGOSS and IODE.
60 REFERENCES
1. 2. 3.
WMO 1996: The World Weather Watch Programme 1996-2005, Fourth WMO Long-term Plan, Part II, Vol. 1, WMO/TD-No. 700. IOC 1996: Towards operational oceanography: The Global Ocean Observing System, IOC/INF-1028. The Ocean Observing System Development Panel 1995: Scientific design for the common module of GOOS and GCOS, Dept. of Oceanography, Texas A. and M. University, 265 pp.
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
61
The challenge to observe the World Ocean circulation and its variability W.P.M. de Ruijter Institute for Marine and Atmospheric Research Utrecht, Princetonplein 5, 3 584 CC Utrecht, The Netherlands
A central issue driving many new developments in the oceanographic sciences is the need to predict variability and changes at a wide range of temporal and spatial scales. Climate variability and, more general, Global Change are examples in which the oceans play a key role. But also locally, for instance in problems concerning water quality and coastal zone management, predictive systems are essential tools. Such systems depend on a basic understanding of the phenomena, availability of reliable data and developments of observational and computing technology. In all categories recent progress has been substantial.
1. PREDICTION Prediction of changes in our environment and, related to that, determining to what degree human activities are causing these variations, poses a major challenge to the community of atmospheric and oceanographic scientists: the basic description and understanding of the ocean-atmosphere system (including shelf seas and coastal zones) has to be raised to such a level that significant improvements can be made in the diagnostic and predictive capabilities. Given the scale and complexity of the system, involving also inherent limits to predictability, this can only be achieved by international collaboration and global investments in research and observational systems. The World Ocean Circulation Experiment (WOCE), which is in its final observational stage, and the Climate Variability programme (CLIVAR) are good examples of such collaboration. Both are components of the World Climate Research Programme (WCRP) in which research on the physical components of the climate system is co-ordinated. Development of models and theory goes together with global scale observations and intense local process oriented studies. Surely, the description and understanding of the present day ocean circulation is vastly improved by these programmes. It also shows that reliable and operational prediction of ocean and climate variability at inter-annual and decadal time scales is within reach. But it depends crucially on having available, at regular time intervals, an update of the actual state of the world ocean circulation, its stratification and density structure and the associated buoyancy transports and fluxes at interfaces. Like in weather prediction these data are necessary to repeatedly initialise the global ocean and climate models from which state its evolution can be forecast by forward integration of the model equations.
62 The need for GOOS, a Global Ocean Observing System, is clear. A scientific design for a climate component for GOOS has been presented recently (see Ocean Observing System Development Panel, 1995). Here, after a short treatment of some general scientific issues related to climate and ocean prediction, we will briefly discuss the large scale ocean circulation, its stability and variability and possible consequences for ocean monitoring. Oceanography is rapidly evolving toward the same level of maturity as meteorology. Where there is a directly measurable societal need or economic benefit, forecasting systems have been developed and are operational. Examples are tidal and storm surge prediction and, more recently, operational prediction of wind waves. These operational systems have in common that they predict phenomena that are periodic or relatively short lived and form the dominant signal in the observations. So they are relatively easy to monitor and model. Given a dense enough observational network to determine their present state the evolution of these dominant phenomena can be predicted by forward integration from that initial state using a proper mathematical model. 1.1. Residuals and accumulation
The next class of forecasting targets is of a much more complex nature. First of all, this is due to large spatial and long time scales involved with subtle non-linear interactions between slow and fast components of the system. An important example in the GOOS context is the interaction of the ocean's slow, thermohaline circulation and fast atmospheric heat and water transports in the coupled climate system. For climate predictions on interannual and decadal time scales the buffering and transport capacity of the large scale ocean circulation and its internal variability, has to be understood, correctly modelled and monitored. A related key problem (both observationaUy and for modelling) is that one often has to determine the long term accumulated effect of small residuals that are an order of magnitude smaller than the dominant phenomena in the system. For example, on the continental shelf, in particular in the coastal zone, a key question is how tides, waves, wind and density driven currents interact to produce net transports of water, heat, nutrients, sediment and other substances. Often tides and waves are the dominant signal. They are periodic and would not lead to net transports if not for non-linear rectifying processes that induce small residuals and asymmetries. These residuals are an order of magnitude smaller than the main signal. Both observing and modelling them is therefore very complicated. Predicting their accumulated effects even more so because small errors can easily add up to a signal of the same order as the structures one is aiming for. Determining the net global-scale transport of heat and fresh water in the ocean and the atmosphere and understanding the processes leading to these transports is another example within this class. In the ocean this means extracting the thermohaline transports as a residue from a signal that is dominated by the wind-driven circulation, involving major currents like the Gulf Stream and intense mesoscale (scales of order 100 km) eddies (e.g. Bryden, 1993). The Gulf Stream is part of an almost closed subtropical gyre system. However, these cycles, driven by a cud in the wind stress, are not completely closed. Cross-gyre residual transports are an order of magnitude smaller than that in the gyres itself. As an extra complexity these cross-gyre exchanges are partly due to the mesoscale eddies that develop as instabilities on the western boundary currents in their confluence
63 regions and after separation from the coastal boundary. Over vast ocean areas exchange with the deeper layers takes place by a combination of turbulence and slow up- and downwelling, so slow that it can not be directly measured. Many of the key interactions that determine net transports or strength of feedback processes take place at interfaces within one of the components or at the boundary between different components of a coupled system. Cross frontal exchanges of heat, fresh water and chemical substances are essential in determining their global distribution as are the fluxes across the air-sea interface. Other important examples are the sediment-water interfaces, the boundaries between ice and the atmosphere and the ocean-ice-atmosphere interfaces, where deep ocean convection is driven. The latter process is generally very localised, of small scale and intermittent, mostly taking place in remote polar areas (Killworth, 1983). Consequently, it is extremely hard to capture these events and their integrated effects by in situ observations. A major complicating factor is the fact that exchange processes at the above interfaces are in general characterised by small scale instabilities and turbulence, the effects of which have to be parameterised at some level in the models.
2. THE LARGE SCALE OCEAN CIRCULATION The redistribution of heat between equatorial and polar regions takes place in approximately equal amounts by the oceans and the atmosphere (e.g. see Bryden, 1993). Net meridional fresh water transports of ocean and atmosphere are almost mirror images: the oceans return most of the fresh water exported via the atmosphere (e.g. Schmitt, 1994). A major part of the oceanic heat transport in the northern hemisphere is realised by the Atlantic Ocean thermohaline overturning circulation. Due to its large buffeting capacity and thermal inertia, the ocean has a stabilising effect on short term climate changes. However, evidence in particular from the Greenland ice cores shows that in the past the climate state over the North Atlantic region has switched between warm and cold modes on time scales of decades only (e.g. GRIP-members, 1993). Climate variability at such time scales over Western Europe is largely coupled to variations in the ocean's large scale circulation and associated thermohaline transports (e.g. Keig~n et al., 1991; Broecker, 1991). Buoyancy fluxes at the air-sea interface continuously alter the thermohaline properties of the underlying water masses. Excess evaporation and cooling over the subtropical and Northern Atlantic destabilize the water column which may result in convective overturning. In polar areas cool and salty water sinks into the deep ocean. The largest water mass thus entering the deep sea, the so-called North Atlantic Deep Water, spreads southward across the equator and flows into the Indian and Pacific Oceans via the Antarctic Circumpolar Current. A return flow has to exist in the upper layers of the ocean to compensate for the outflow of deep water from the Atlantic. The properties (in particular temperature and salinity that determine the buoyancy) with which these waters return into the Atlantic represent the integrated effect of mixing and water mass transformation processes during their journey through the other ocean basins. The thermohaline characteristics of these interbasin return fluxes affect the stratification of the Atlantic and thus its stability and the strength of the overturning circulation (e.g. Gordon, 1986). The degree to which the characteristics of these return fluxes determine the Atlantic overturning, as compared to the impact of the surface heat and fresh water fluxes and internal mixing processes
64 in the basin itself, is a matter of active research (e.g. Rintoul, 1991; Weijer et al., 1997). According to the latest estimates (e.g. Schmitz, 1995) approximately two thirds of the compensating flow into the Atlantic returns via the Drake Passage at intermediate level. The remaining part, warmer and saltier, enters at thermocline level via the Agulhas Current extension around South Africa (e.g. Gordon et al., 1992). The latter takes place largely by enormous eddies (with diameters of order 200-300 km) that pinch off from the Agulhas Current retroflection and penetrate the Atlantic (e.g. Lutjeharms and Van Ballegooyen, 1988; Gordon et al., 1987; Feron et al., 1992). The very large variability of ring shedding and circulation around the tip of South Africa makes it extremely hard to estimate the interbasin fluxes in this area from observations. Most reliable, so far, are estimates from hydrographic and tracer data, but these only provide snapshots of a highly variable signal (e.g. Van Ballegooyen et al., 1994). The same holds for the separation and confluence areas of the major western boundary currents, where part of the "residual" exchange between the wind-driven ocean gyres takes place. A global ocean forecasting system should therefore involve a monitoring system of these areas of high eddy-activity and interbasin exchange. This can be realised by combining in situ data and satellite observations (particularly those from radar altimetry) with a detailed high resolution numerical model of these areas (e.g. Van Leeuwen & Evensen, 1996; Robinson et al., 1989). Such well-tuned regional data assimilation systems could be nested in a larger-scale ocean circulation model. Regional monitoring systems are also necessary for the varying fluxes through the Drake Passage and Bering Strait to determine constraints on the salinity and water budgets over the Atlantic basin and the other oceans (e.g. see Wijffels et al., 1992). The nett evaporative flux over the subtropical Atlantic is partly carried into the Pacific across Central America by the prevailing trade winds. It helps to stabilise the North Pacific stratification, inhibiting Pacific deep water formation (Warren, 1983). A significant portion of this atmospheric flesh water transport returns as an interocean flux via the Bering Strait (e.g. Wijffels et al., 1992).
2.1. Stability and variability The rapid climatic fluctuation between warm and cold periods as observed in the ice-cores and other paleodata are thought to be related to variations in the strength of the Atlantic overturning circulation (e.g. Broecker et al., 1985). Both simple box and more complex numerical modelling studies have shown the existence of multiple equilibria of the thermohaline circulation under identical heat and freshwater flux boundary conditions at the surface (e.g. Stommel, 1961; Bryan, 1986; Weaver & Hughes, 1994). Different modes can exist depending on the competition between a heat-induced poleward overturning and a salinity-induced equatorward overturning circulation component. The buoyancy effect of surface wanning at low latitudes is counteracted by excess evaporation which raises the salinity of the surface layer and thus reduces its buoyancy. In polar regions the effect of cooling is opposed by net precipitation. Switches from one mode to the other or oscillations between different modes may be related to a subtle interaction between the Atlantic poleward overturning circulation (the "ocean conveyor belt", Broecker, 1991), atmospheric fresh water transport from the evaporative Atlantic to the Pacific, and the melting or growth of the northern polar ice sheets. The observed climate variability during the last glacial period, which terminated suddenly after the Younger Dryas cold period (+ 10.000 years BP, e.g. Dansgaard et al., 1989), may be attributed to this ocean-ice atmosphere interaction mechanism (Broecker, 1991).
65 However, during the last interglacial (Eemian) period (+ 120.000 years ago) such large scale ice sheets were not present, whereas the fluctuations between warm and cold periods, as inferred from the ice core data, were of comparable amplitude and time scales to those in glacial times. Weaver and Hughes (1994) have shown that a random component of sufficient amplitude added to the mean surface fresh water flux can provide the perturbation necessary to trigger the switches between the different North Atlantic circulation modes. They speculate that the variability of the warmer Eemian climate was related to a more variable hydrologic cycle during that period. If our present climate is warming it might shift into a more Eemian-like state, including much reduced stability. 2.2. Variability of the wind-driven circulation As noted earlier, the wind-driven circulation is the dominant signal in the observed ocean flow field, particularly in the upper ocean layers. The wind-driven currents play an important role in the basin scale transports, mixing and redistribution of heat, salt and fresh water. Intergyre and interbasin transports are strongly influenced by the characteristics of the western boundary currents and their variability. The latter may be related to localised barotropic and/or baroclinic instability, giving the mesoscale eddy activity at scales of order tens of kilometres. But these jets also vary on seasonal and interannual time scales. Variability at such scales can be related to changes in the forcing wind field. But recent modelling studies show that under steady wind forcing the wind-driven gyre system also exhibits multiple steady states (e.g. see Dijkstra and Ghil, 1997, for a review) between which the actual circulation may switch or oscillate. The results of these idealised studies indicate that perturbations to which the gyres are most unstable originate in the confluence and separation regions of the western boundary currents.
3. DISCUSSION In the fluctuations in the thermohaline circulation described above, the hydrologic cycle plays a key role. Other modelling studies have also shown a large sensitivity of the ocean's stability to the spatial pattern of the surface fresh water forcing (e.g. Tziperman et al., 1994). A key component of an observation system for ocean climate should therefore be aimed at determining the climatology of the surface buoyancy fluxes. Combined with a monitoring system for interbasin exchanges it provides necessary constraints for models of the dynamics and thermohaline transports in the different ocean basins, their global scale connection and their stability and variability (see also OOSDP, 1995; Wijffels et al., 1992). We have also discussed the usefulness of monitoring the confluence and separation regions of the major western boundary currents of the world ocean circulation. These seem to be areas where perturbations arise first that may develop into oscillations or rapid transitions at the gyre scale. Early detection of such developing perturbations and subsequent assimilation in an appropriate ocean circulation model may add significantly to the predictive capability of the evolution of the basin scale circulation at interannual and probably also at decadal time scales.
66 These results from systematic stability studies of the large scale ocean circulation (e.g. Dijkstra & Ghil, 1997) are still rather preliminary due to limited computing power, among other things. But they have the potential to develop into a key aid for an optimal design of a large scale ocean circulation observing system by addressing systematically the following relevant questions: Can the stability of the present ocean climatic state be determined7 What other stable or periodic equilibria are possible at the present external forcing, geometry, ice-sheet conditions etc.? How stable are these circulation modes, i.e. can we determine the amplitude and spatial structure of the perturbations that can generate a switch to another equilibrium state? If so, then that can provide a clue as to where the ocean and climate observations should be concentrated. So far, the results point to the areas of high mesoscale eddy activity. Deducing relatively slow flow modulations from the high frequency and large amplitude eddy signal is quite an observational challenge. An in situ observational system that captures all the relevant scales would have to be very dense. Satellite observations, particularly those from radar altimetry, are essential in determining the statistics of the highly variable surface velocity field. A major problem is that at the small scales of these boundary currents and eddies the absolute mean sea surface velocity field can not yet be determined from the altimetric data. At these scales the geoid is not known accurately enough to separate it from the surface height expression of the mean velocity field. A dedicated gravity mission is necessary to fill in this gap. In the mean time studies are ongoing that try to approximate the mean sea surface dynamic topography and thus the mean ocean surface circulation from the observed temporal variability (e.g. Feron et al., 1997). It is based on the observation that in these areas the eddy field interacts significantly with and modifies the mean circulation. It appears possible to improve the estimates of the mean sea surface velocity field by using satellite altimeter observations of horizontal eddy momentum and vorticity fluxes in the average balances (see. Fig. 1). In principle, such a method could form the basis of a monitoring system for such highly energetic areas. The continuity of satellite altimeter observations is therefore of high priority for future climate studies aiming at Global Ocean and Climate Forecasting. Of course these remote sensing data have to be complemented by in situ observations that add vertical information. New techniques for efficient ocean monitoring are becoming available. Examples are acoustic tomography, subsurface floats and unmanned autonomous vehicles such a the British Autosub, a motorised vehicle with sensors to collect data while cruising the ocean along undulating paths. If all this is in place, and combined with ocean (and climate) models into a monitoring and forecasting system, then the "Slocum mission into the ocean" as envisioned by Henry Stommel (1989) will be on the way. The dominant role of the large scale circulation in the Atlantic Ocean in establishing climate and its variability over Europe suggests a European focus on this ocean area. This should also include the important convection and sinking areas in the Arctic and other (sub)polar seas as well as the interbasin exchanges with the South Atlantic.
67
Figure 1: a) The Mean Sea Surface Dynamic Topography (MSSDT) in the Agulhas Extension (in dynamic cm.) from Levitus, 1982 climatology, relative to 1000 dbar; b) the mean divergence of the eddy vorticity flux (in 10-13s2), derived from satellite altimeter observations; c) improved MSSDT (i.e. surface flow field) from solving the averaged vorticity balance, in which the observed eddy-vorticity flux from (b) acts as a forcing ("eddy-stress") ACKNOWLEDGEMENT. Research related to this paper was supported by the Dutch National Research Programme on Global Air Pollution and Climate Change and the Space Research Organisation of the Netherlands (SRON).
REFERENCES Broecker, W.S. - Oceanography 4 ( 1991) 79-89 Broecker, W.S., D.M. Peteet, D. Rind - Nature 315 (1985) 21-26 Bryan, F.- Nature 323 (1986) 301-304 Bryden, H.L. - Geoph.Monogr.(AGU) 75 (1993) 65-84 Dansgaard, W., J.W.C. White, S.J. Johnson- Nature 339 (1989) 532-533 Dijkstra, H.A., M. Ghil - submitted (1997) Feron, R.C.V., W.P.M. de Ruijter, D. Oskam - J.Geoph.Res. 97 (1992) 9467-9477 Feron, R.C.V., W.P.M. de Ruijter, P.J. van Leeuwen - J.Geoph.Res., in press (1997) Fu, L.L., J. Vazquez, M.E. Parke - J.Geoph.Res. 92 (1987) 749-754 Gordon, A.L. - J.Geoph.Res. 91 (1986) 5037-5046 Gordon, A.L., J.R.E. Lutjeharms, M.L. Grtindlingh - Deep Sea Res. 34 (4a) (1987) 565-599
68 Gordon, A.L., R.F. Weiss, W.M. Smethie, M.J. Warner- J.Geoph.Res. 97 (1992) 7223-7240 GRIP-members - Nature 364 (1993) 203-207 Keigwin, L., G.A. Jones, S.J. Lehman - J.Geoph.Res. 96 ( 1991) 16811-16826 Killworth, P.D. - Rev.Geophys.Space Phys. 21 (1983) 1-26 Levitus, S. - Climatological atlas of the world ocean, NOAA Prof. Pap., 13, U.S. Dept. of commerce (1982), 173 pp. Lutjeharms, J.R.E., R.C. van Ballegooyen - J.Phys.Oceanogr. 18 (1988) 1570-1583 OOSDP - Ocean Observing System Development Panel, An Ocean Observing System for Climate- Texas A&M Univ. (1995) 265 pp. Rintoul, S.R. - J.Geophys.Res., 91 (1991) 2675-2692 Robinson, A.R., M.A. Spall, L.J. Walstead, W.G. Leslie - Dyn.Atmos.Oceans 13 (1989) 301-316 Schmitt, R.W. - The ocean freshwater cycle - OOSDP 4 (1994) Schmitz, W . J . - Rev. of Geoph. 33 (1995) 151-173 Stommel, H. - Oceanography 2 (1989) 22-25 Stommel, H. - Tellus, 13 ( 1961) 224-230 Tziperman, E., J.R. Toggweiler, Y. Feliks, K. Bryan - J.Phys. Oceanogr. 24 (1994) 217-232 Van Ballegooyen, R.C., M.L. Grtindlingh, J.R.E. Lutjeharms - J.Geoph.Res. 99 (1994) 14.053-14.070 Van Leeuwen, P.J., G. Evensen - Mon.Weath.Rev. 124 (1996) 2898-2913 Warren, B.A.- J.Mar.Res., 41 (1983) 327-347 Weaver, A.J., T.M. Hughes - Nature 367 (1994) 447-450 Weijer, W., H.A. Dijkstra, P.J. van Leeuwen, W.P.M. de Ruijter - in preparation (1997) Wijffels, S.E., R.W. Schmitt, H.L. Bryden, A. Stigebrandt - J.Phys.Oceanogr. 22 (1992) 155-162
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
69
Regional G O O S for Sustainable D e v e l o p m e n t and M a n a g e m e n t
G.Kullenberg and J.P. Rebert Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission, 1, rue Miollis, 75015 Paris
1. INTRODUCTION The ability to determine the present state of systems and predict their future conditions is the cornerstone for adequately protecting and managing ocean and coastal areas and for rational use and development of their living and non-living resources. Effective management of oceans and coastal areas is often limited by the high degree of uncertainties in the present information. We need to develop the ability to assess and predict both natural and anthropogenic changes in marine and coastal ecosystems. Ultimately, striking a sustainable balance between environmental protection and economic development is not possible without predictive capabilities. The long time scale of changes in the ocean and the ocean/atmosphere feedback provide the basis for reliable predictions of the changes, such as of El Nifio Southern oscillation (ENSO) events, provided adequate data are at hand. This lead time allows decision makers the unique opportunity to intelligently plan ameliorative actions which can result in realizable savings. There is also worldwide concern about climate change and sea level rise. Response strategies should be based on sound information. Improved systems to collect, interpret, synthesize and disseminate data and information are essential to reduce uncertainties and to improve predictability. Moreover some seas, especially the coastal areas, are increasingly polluted from the adjacent land via rivers, via the atmosphere, and maritime and dumping activities, on a scale that threatens to impair ecological functions and reduce marine living resources. Effective management and control measures by individual countries require regular and reliable information on the distribution, transport and fate of various contaminants coming from different sources, including those on regional and global scales.
Systematic global observations of the world oceans are required to improve our knowledge and predictive capabilities which will be the basis for more effective and sustained use of the marine environment, with associated economic benefits. In recognition of the need, the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED, 1992) has called for the development of a global system of ocean observation to help develop understanding and to monitor change. The Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS) is the response to this call, but it is more than this. GOOS will provide the framework for the unprecedented enhancement of
70 marine data and information for all kinds of use: industrial, environmental and managerial. In 1989, the IOC Assembly had already called for initiation of GOOS. The establishment of GOOS had also been urged by the Second World Climate Conference (1990) to provide the oceanographic data needed by the Global Climate Observing System (GCOS) initiated by the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC), the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the International Council of Scientific Unions (ICSU) in 1992. The UNCED (Chapter 17 (17.102) urged States to support "the role of the IOC in cooperation with WMO, UNEP and other international organizations in the collection, analysis and distribution of data and information from the oceans and all seas, including as appropriate. through the Global Ocean Observing System, giving special attention to the need for IOC to develop fully the strategy for providing training and technical assistance for developing countries through its Training, Education and Mutual Assistance (TEMA) programme". GOOS is also of utmost importance for the implementation of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change(FCCC). Article 5(b) of the Convention calls upon the Parties to "support international and intergovernmental efforts to strengthen systematic observation and national scientific and technical research capacities and capabilities, particularly in developing countries, and to promote access to, and the exchange of, data and analyses thereof obtained from areas beyond national jurisdiction". UN Convention on Biological Diversity in its article 7 (b) also refers to "Monitor, through sampling and other techniques, the components of biological diversity identified pursuant to sub-paragraph (a) above, paying particular attention to those requiring urgent conservation measures and those which offer the greatest potential for sustainable use".
2. APPROACH AND STRATEGY GOOS has been initiated by the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC). The World Meteorological Organization (WMO), the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the International Council of Scientific Unions (ICSU) have agreed to co-operate in this endeavor. GOOS is aimed at establishing a global framework for the gathering, coordination, quality control, distribution and the generation of derived products of all kinds of marine and oceanographic data of common utility, as defined by the requirements of a full spectrum of user groups. It will provide systematic ocean observations to meet the needs of a wide range of users having immediate practical purpose as well as long term concerns such as assessing the state of the marine environment, its health and its resources, including the coastal zone forecasting short term climate variability and long term environmental change supporting an improved decision-making and management process - one which takes into account potential natural and man-made changes in the environment and their effects on human health and resources.
71 The major elements of GOOS are operational, oceanographic observations and analyses, timely distribution of data and products, data assimilation into numerical models leading to predictions, and capacity building within participating Member States to develop analysis and application capability. Several of these application areas are already well-developed, or are developing, as a result of recent research. GOOS places great emphasis on building with a strong scientific foundation and taking advantage of existing observational systems where they are deemed effective and appropriate. GOOS will be developed on a sound scientific basis using the findings of existing, on-going research programmes such as the World Ocean Circulation Experiment (WOCE), the Joint Global Ocean Flux Study (JGOFS) and the Land Ocean Interaction in the Coastal Zone (LOICZ). Operational programmes sponsored by IOC and WMO including Integrated Global Ocean services (IGOSS), International Oceanographic Data Exchange (1ODE), the Global Sea Level Observing System (GLOSS) and the Data Buoy Cooperation Panel (DBCP) form a foundation. GOOS will utilize operational observing methods, both remote sensing and in-situ measurements obtained from ships, towed and anchored systems, drifting buoys, sub-surface floats and coastal stations. Emphasis will be placed on the open exchange of data with data bases accessible to all participating countries. As a basis for organization, for use-friendliness and ease of planning, GOOS has been defined in terms of five modules: (i)
Climate Monitoring, Assessment and Prediction; this module is common with the ocean component of GCOS-Global Climate Observing System;
(ii)
Monitoring and Assessment of Marine Living Resources;
(iii)
Monitoring of the Coastal Zone Environment and Its Changes;
(iv)
Assessment and Prediction of the Health of the Ocean;
(v)
Marine Meteorological and Oceanographic Operational Services. It should be noted that these modules are inter-related and will share observations, data networks and facilities, as needed, within the one integrated system.
73 4. GOOS STATUS Substantial progress has been achieved in scientific design of the GOOS Climate module (which constitutes the oceanographic component of GCOS). Actions are under way to prepare an implementation programme for this module. Health of the Ocean Module is in an advanced state of development. Steps have been taken to initiate the design of Living Marine Resources Module and Ocean and Marine Meteorological Services Module. Coastal Module is an especially difficult aspect of GOOS. The GOOS Coastal module require an interdisciplinary approach and is aimed at providing the necessary infrastructure needed for service providers to a wide range of coastal area management's. This module has a high priority to many coastal states because of the importance of the coastal area for development and the intimate effects of coastal changes on economic development and human habitation. Present efforts of international community are focused on formulation of an approach to planning GOOS coastal module, description of practical problems and economic and social implications, justification of the need for a global coastal GOOS and its relationship with other GOOS modules. In parallel with the design and planning of GOOS modules special attention is given to the studies of practical applications and economic benefits of GOOS, formulation of GOOS strategic plan, preparation of the GOOS Handbook, formulation of GOOS data management strategy and implementation of capacity building activities.
5. ANALYSIS OF REGIONAL PERSPECTIVES GOOS has been defined as a globalframework or system for the gathering, coordination, quality control, distribution and the generation of derived products of all kinds of marine and oceanographic data of common utility, as defined by the requirements of a full spectrum of user groups. There was a proposal to define GOOS as "an array of national observing systems, linked by common techniques, protocols and data management". GOOS will use a globally co-ordinated, scientifically-based strategy to allow for monitoring and subsequent prediction of environmental changes globally, regionally and nationally. Implementation will be carried out by Member States through nationally-owned and operated facilities. GOOS data will allow regular global and regional oceanographic analyses and predictions. In order to define national and regional requirements for ocean services, and eventually establish such regional services, as well as to define and co-ordinate related capacity building activities, a regional approach in planning and follow-up execution of GOOS has been recommended. Regional development in general is premised on a group of nations joining together and combining resources to focus on a single set of objectives and resulting in greater overall
74 benefit than if they acted individually. GOOS regional development is based on this premise, but has the additional benefit of contributing to the global communities interests. By providing data and information to a global data and information management system each contributing region plays an integral role in establishing a global network for monitoring the oceans and coastal areas of the world. Regional development of GOOS will be initiated by nations who agree to undertake a programme of action that is in conformance with the general GOOS principles and policies such as agreement to share data and information in a full and open manner, adherence to certain standards, methodology, data and information management specifications, established by I-GOOS and J-GOOS etc. It is important to note that within two operational programmes of IOC i.e. IGOSS and 1ODE a decentralized system of Responsible and Specialized Oceanographic centers has been established to deal either with a specific data product or specific geographical region. Within GLOSS a number of regional sea-level programmes have been initiated. Global Coral Reef Monitoring Network initiated recently by IOC also includes regional approach to its development. Two regional GOOS activities have been initiated. One by a consortium of European agencies -EuroGOOS, the second -NEARGOOS in Northeast Asia among four countries within the IOC WESTPAC region. There have been a number of other national and regional efforts concurrent with the international planning activities such as the TAO array in the Pacific, a Pilot Research Moored Array in the Tropical Atlantic (PIRATA), SEAWATCH in the North East Atlantic, climate and sea-level monitoring programmes in the Caribbean, South Pacific regions, the Indian Ocean, the Mediterranean and the Black Sea. The IOC Regional Committee for the Southern Ocean (1996) recommended actions aimed at developing a comprehensive Southern Ocean component of GOOS. The I-GOOS Planning session (1996) recommended some regional studies on socio-economic benefits of GOOS, particularly in South East Africa, West Africa, the Mediterranean and North Africa, Latin America. The IGOOS also recommended to convene in cooperation with the regional bodies of IOC, WMO and UNEP, regional workshops to assess developing countries requirements in order to facilitate their potential contribution. In IOC many research and ocean services programmes as well as training and technical assistance activities are being implemented through the IOC regional activities which presently include ( map from the IOC brochure "A Strategy for the Ocean"): 9 9 9 9 9 9
IOC Black Sea Regional Committee; IOCARIBE-IOC Sub-Commission for the Caribbean and Adjacent Regions; IOCSOC-IOC Committee for the Southern Ocean; WESTPAC-IOC Sub-Commission for the Western Pacific; IOCEA-IOC Regional Committee for the Central Eastern Atlantic; IOCINCWlO-IOC Regional Committee for the Co-operative Investigations in the North and Central Western Indian Ocean; 9 IOCINDIO-IOC Regional Committee for the Central Indian Ocean;
75
INTERGOVERNMENTAL OCEANOGRAPHIC COMMISSION REGIONAL BODIES
The major tasks of the IOC regional bodies are (i) to define regional problems, the solution of which calls for international co-operation, and promote, develop and co-ordinate the required marine scientific research programmes and related activities; (ii) implement and coordinate the regional components of global marine scientific research programmes and activities of the Commission; (iii) promote the development and use, at the regional level, of ocean services; (iv) assist with the identification of training, education and mutual assistance needs in the region and promote the required TEMA activities; (v) formulate, evaluate proposals for extra-budgetary projects; (vi) co-operate with regional bodies of other UN agencies and organizations; (vii) follow-up to UNCED, including GOOS. At present only IOCARIBE and WESTPAC have regional secretariats located in Cartagena, Colombia and Bangkok, Thailand. All other regional bodies are supported from the IOC Secretariat in Paris. UNESCO, UNEP and WMO have also regional bodies and activities which are cases different from those established under the IOC. There are many other organizations actively involved in coordination of national efforts for the studies oceanic regions, such as ICES (North Atlantic), PICES (North Pacific), (Mediterranean), SOPAC (South Pacific), SPREP (South Pacific).
in many regional of some CIESM
76 The I-GOOS (1993) considered that regional mechanisms will play a key role in implementing GOOS. Regional cooperation is needed between nations in order to establish integrated regional networks, improve data communications, provide mechanisms for endogenous capacity building and facilitate funding of joint participation to large scale elements of GOOS. Co-ordination among various regional activities is essential to ensure most rational use of limited national and international resources available and to strengthen national and regional capacities and capabilities, to enable all countries participate in GOOS and to use effectively the GOOS data and data products for national and regional applications. There are two oceanic regions-Southern Ocean and the Arctic Ocean which require special attention by most technologically advanced countries to develop GOOS due to the special requirements for observations in such remote and environmentally hazardous regions. GOOS may lead us eventually to the use in future natural, oceanographic regions of the World Ocean. The regional endeavours of NEAR-C~OS, Black Sea GOOS, in the Caribbean, and in the Southern Ocean have been initiated through the IOC regional bodies, in an organized, stepwise position. These activities are all to be seen as regional pilot projects which follow the basic approach and requirements of the "global" GOOS. Data exchange agreements, capacity inventories, training and mutual assistance are essential parts in all. Furthermore, they all aim at addressing regional priority needs, and have to be realistic in the approach. The efforts, to a large extent, must be built initially on existing means. Co-ordination is organized through national coordinators. Co-ordination has also been sought with SEAWATCH, and joint activities have been planned. Regional workshops to initiate similar actions are at presently planned for the northern and western Indian Ocean associated with IOCINDIO, in Goa, India, November 1996; and with IOCINCWlO, in Mombassa, Kenya, also in November 1996. These will involve the regional countries, with participation of a few outside experts. Expected outputs are regional plans for pilot activities.
6. SOCIO-ECONOMIC STUDIES. Demonstrations of economic benefits already exist, such as the cost benefit analysis of TOGA and the ENSO observing system ( a report prepared for NOAA-Economic group). The study concluded that the presently proposed ENSO Observing System, built on TOGA, is a worthwhile public investment. Further economic studies are required to more precisely define and quantify the socio-economic benefits that could be derived from a fully implemented GOOS. The cost/benefit studies are needed nationally, regionally and globally.
77 The I-GOOS (1995) considered the following types of socio-economic studies: (i)
global aggregate analysis of the scales of maritime industries and services;
(ii)
national and state level assessments of percentage of GNP attributable to maritime industries and services;
(iii)
economic cost-benefit studies of the land-based effects of marine prediction of climate fluctuations;
(iv)
analysis of the economic theory and methodologies in public good economies of global marine information systems;
(v)
customer reviews and surveys to identify what operational marine parameters are required by industry, regulating authorities, and other user groups.
Global analysis of the benefits of operational oceanography may be carried out in cooperation with the OECD. National GOOS socio-economic studies have been undertaken by UK, USA and Australia. Some socio-economic studies on the benefit of marine meteorological services have been made by WMO. In May 1996 the Workshop on socio-economic aspects of GOOS was held in Washington DC. The Workshop included seminars on the economics of the use of predictions based on TOGA; the economic methods for evaluating the value of information (VOI) provided by environmental research; methods for identifying the data needs of particular industries and services; the evaluation of non-market goods; the cost-benefit analysis (CBA) of a moored buoy observing system; and the methodology of international assessments of CBA. The Workshop recommended a number of research projects addressing the value of information in agriculture and fisheries related to ENSO prediction; energy and water industry value of ENSO prediction; water quality in the coastal zone; benefits of scientific co-operation within GOOS; VOI for improved coastal and climate forecasts in South East Asia, West Africa and the Mediterranean and Latin America. The following principles for socio-economic assessments, CBA, and VOI studies were recommended by the Workshop: (i)
Use accepted principles of cost-benefit analysis;
(ii)
adopt common assumptions of what GOOS will provide;
(iii)
explicitly state all assumption;
(iv)
define a baseline world, without GOOS;
78
(v)
compare with alternative assumptions of products from GOOS used to generate socioeconomic benefits;
(vi)
specify the scope of benefits, what is included or excluded, identify costs and benefits, identify costs and benefits presented separately on an annual basis;
(vii)
state monetary dimensions, dollars or numbers, real or nominal;
(viii)
state discount rate used.
What is important now is to share the experience in CBA and VOI studies among the countries and encourage other countries to undertake such studies. Such work requires close and active interaction on national level among scientific, political and user community groups. This process will lead eventually to the establishment of the new or improved national mechanisms for GOOS planning and implementation. It is important to demonstrate the effectiveness of GOOS as soon as possible. We need to produce and demonstrate products produced on national and international levels ( from existing operational activities and pilot GOOS activities) and make critical assessments of the benefits of those products for various user community groups.
7. CONCLUSION Existing observational systems are funded from a combination of operational and research programmes. It is essential that GOOS be established with long-term funding, as a permanent service rather than depending upon data collection by research activities that are limited duration. GOOS represents a recognition that oceanography is now an operational discipline. The establishment of fully operational GOOS will require at least 20 years. Rather than a beginning and an end point of implementation, GOOS is envisioned as a continuously evolving entity. It should use the experience and the mechanism established within existing national and international operational programmes with progressive integration of new technology for data acquisition and communication, ocean and coupled models, improved knowledge of the ocean and its interaction with atmosphere in the course of implementation of global research programmes such as WCRP, IGBP and better understanding of the requirements of various marine user community groups for oceanographic services. It is also of great importance for success of the GOOS to establish and maintain close interactions with other planned global observing systems, particularly GCOS and GTOS, especially in designing and planning climate and coastal modules of GOOS. Joint efforts have been recently initiated to develop an integrated strategy and identify priorities for implementation. The Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission has agreed to lead the development and implementation of GOOS in cooperation with WMO, UNEP and ICSU. This has been recognized by Second World Climate Conference and UNCED. IOC should not be confused
79 with the IOC Secretariat. It is an international organization within UNESCO comprising 125 Member States. It has been agreed upon by the Governments themselves to work through the IOC in the development of GOOS. Since GOOS is cross-sectorial and must serve several user communities, it is clear that there must be co-operation in order to ensure that the interests of the different sectors are properly taken into account. It is the task of IOC, as the only international organization dealing with all aspects of the World Ocean, to ensure proper coordination of GOOS among Member States, UN Agencies and various regional organizations, the Global Climate Observing System and the Global terrestrial Observing System as well as global scientific research programmes.
REFERENCES
1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6. 7.
8. 9. 10.
Towards operational oceanography: the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS), IOC/INF- 1028, Paris, 26 April 1996 The case for GOOS. Report of the IOC Blue Ribbon Panel for a Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS), IOC/INF-915, Paris, 27 January 1993 IOC Committee for the Global Ocean Observing System (I-GOOS), First Session, Paris, 16-19 February 1993, IOC reports of Governing and major Subsidiary bodies, UNESCO. First Planning Session of the IOC-WMO-UNEP Committee for GOOS, Melbourne, Australia, 18-21 April 1994, IOC, UNESCO. IOC-WMO-UNEP Committee for GOOS (I-GOOS-II), Second session, Paris, 6-9 June 1995, IOC, UNESCO. Strategy Sub-Committee (SSC) of the IOC-WMO-UNEP Committee for GOOS (IGOOS), Second session, Paris, 25-27 March 1996. Second Planning Session of the IOC-WMO-UNEP Committee for the Global Ocean Observing System (I-GOOS), Washington DC, USA, 16-17 May 1996, IOC, UNESCO. Joint IOC-WMO-ICSU Scientific and Technical Committee for GOOS (J-GOOS), Second session, Paris, France, 24-26 April 1995, IOC, UNESCO. United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Text. UNEP/WMO Information Unit on Climate Change (IUCC), IUCC and Climate Change Secretariat. Report of the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development, Chapter 17 (Rio de Janeiro, 3-14 June 1992), UN document A/CONF.151/26 (Vol. 110), 13 August 1992.
80
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
C o s t s a n d b e n e f i t s o f o p e r a t i o n a l o c e a n o g r a p h y : the e f f e c t s o f scale a n d aggregation N C Flemming EuroGOOS Office, Room 346/01, Southampton Oceanography Centre, Empress Dock, Southampton SO 14 3ZH, UK.
This paper summarises the information available for assessing national and international benefits and costs from GOOS and suggests improvements in methodology and standardisation.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Operational oceanographic forecasts and analyses can be applied to maritime and coastal industries and services directly, and can also be incorporated into climate and weather forecasts for land-based use to improve the accuracy or forecast period of existing services. In either case, the economic and social benefit can only be calculated in advance if the scale, revenue, or numbers of people affected in the industry or service are known. The inputs and outputs from the activity must be known, and its interactions with other parts of the economy and social fabric. The activities must be quantified in value in some way, and the future value of the activities estimated with and without the benefit of ocean monitoring, modelling, and forecasting. Most of this paper is concerned with analysing the maritime industries and services, although I will refer to land-based applications sorr~tirnes. In general, the land-based benefits accrue from long term planning and management of resources, water, food production, urban planning, forestry, and energy, and so are conventional in nature, but long-term in benefit and pay-off, of the order of 2-20 years. The maritime benefits generally accrue from short term operational management of industries and services, and have a complex and unusual detailed structure, but produce benefits in the short term of days to months, and cumulative pay-off in months to a few years. The two classes of benefits are complementary. Designing a system which produces the short-term benefits will produce the return on investment which is needed to justify the long-term haul, and eventually the benefits from seasonal and multi-annual climate forecasting. Looked at as a discounted cash flow, the maritime and coastal short-term benefits generate a return which prevents the system going heavily into the red before we obtain benefits from seasonal and multi-annual climate forecasting. Taking the most cautious and pessimistic view, if long-term statistical or probabilistic forecasting of climate (other than ENSO, and the total impact of global warming) eventually turns out to be impossible, or so uncertain that
81 predictions do not justify mitigating action, the cumulative and aggregated benefits of the short-term processes should still justify the total investment. It is for this reason that analysis of how to estimate the aggregate of short-term multi-industry benefits is so important. There have been several attempts to quantify the economic scale of maritime industries in the last sixteen years (Pontecorvo et al., 1980; Broadus et al., 1988; Franklin 1989; National Research Council, 1989; Huxley, 1990; Florida State University 1993; GCOS, 1994; OECD, 1994; Adams et al., 1995; EC Task Force on Maritime Systems of the Future, 1995; Flemming, 1995a, 1995b; Australian Marine Industries and Sciences Council 1996; Sassone, 1996; Woods et al., 1996). The motives for these studies have ranged from national and multi-national macro-economic studies to identify the general economic importance of a range of industries for planning purposes, through to single industry studies and analysis of decision trees in response to forecasts. OECD 1994 concludes that for the non-landlocked developed countries the proportion of GNP generated by marine industries is generally in the range 3-5%. The make-up of this in terms of industries varies considerably, with different countries being dominated by, for example, offshore oil and gas, or shipbuilding, or fisheries, or tourism. For the EU countries collectively the maritime GNP is in the range 110-190 bn ECU per year (Woods et al., 1996).
1.1. Problems to be analysed There are three groups of technical difficulties in trying to identify the aggregate value of marine industries and services, and to understand the structure within the aggregate: i) Traditional structure of the bureaucracy. Existing systems of classifying industries, employment, and research expenditure do not separate activities into marine and non-marine. National statistics of industries and models of the economy and GNP usually do not include categories for marine industries other than for the obvious activities of ship-building, ship operations, and fisheries. ii) There is a functional, practical difficulty of identifying all the maritime industries and activities, extracting information on the maritime components of larger industries such as construction, rlr,x:hanical engineering, or electronics, classifying and categorising these sectors, deciding consistently what is marine or non-marine, how much military activity to include, and measuring the revenue, production, and employment, of so many sectors and sub-sectors. iii) There is need for professionalism in economics and procedures for measuring and aggregating value over a range of activities which have different characteristics, public good versus commercial, long term versus short term, service or manufacturing, plus environmental amenities and intangible benefits such as preserving wildlife and biodiversity. The best economists who have tackled these problems have not known the structure of the industry well. The scientists and practitioners of operational oceanography are amateurs in economics, like myself. 1.2. Summary of objectives of this paper Given the complexity of the problems outlined above, it is not possible to present clear answers in this short paper. I will list what has already been done in some countries so far, illustrate to what extent these initiatives achieve a genuine representation of the aggregate value of maritime industries and services, and try to present a map for the way ahead. This investigation and synthesis should be continued for several years to come, both to establish aggregate values, and to show the
82 different ways in which the patterns of industry and employment in different countries can benefit from operational oceanography, GOOS, and EuroGOOS. There is a need for aggregation at national, regional (e.g. European) and global levels. In particular developing countries need assistance to analyse and assess the profile of industries and benefits which are relevant to them. It will be valuable if EuroGOOS can establish working relationships with OECD Megascience Forum and the relevant sections of the EU-EC to study these matters. The need for a centralised and recognised form of statistics of marine economics which can be aggregated or disaggregated above and below the national level, does not pre-suppose that GOOS itself is directed and constructed on a rigid global plan. Many of the functions of GOOS, but not all, can be assembled from resources at the national and agency level. Nevertheless, all the participants in this exercise of self-interested assembly need to have economic and social justification for their commitment.
2. B U R E A U C R A T I C D I F F I C U L T I E S IN A G G R E G A T I N G M A R I T I M E INDUSTRIES AND SERVICES The process of identifying, valuing, and aggregating the maritime sector requires work, and hence expenditure. The task is not easy: it cuts across governmental departmental boundaries; it seeks to identify and include sub-sectors of industries which do not necessarily see themselves as maritime. It necessitates the identification of numerous new service and information technology businesses. This expenditure of effort itself needs justifying. Why should we do it? What has changed in the last 5-10 years to make this necessary now? I am not trying to justify an attempt to create a notional "maritime community of industries", nor am I seeking to change administrative practices or the definition of governmental department boundaries and responsibilities. My concern is only with the ability to estimate the economic, social, and environmental value of these industries and services in a rigorously defined way so that different parts of the system can be added up and aggregated to estimate a total value through time. The sub-totals must be obtained in a consistent way so that they can be aggregated between countries, or for the whole of Europe, or even globally if possible. The need for this is new, and the reasons are clear. During the 1980s the number of parameters and characteristics of the marine environment which could be analysed through numerical modelling steadily increased. (Prandle et al., 1996; Komen et al., 1994; Foreman and Bell, 1996). As the physical and biological understanding of the sea increased, and as computing power and modelling techniques improved, it was possible to refine the temporal and spatial resolution of models, increase the geographical coverage, extend the forecasting period, and improve the accuracy and range of variable included. These developments are summarised by Smith, 1991; Davies, 1990; Hasselman and Oriol, 1993; Anderson and Willebrand, 1992; Prandle, 1993; Prandle and Matthews, 1990; Pinardi et al., 1995; Woods, 1995, and the future potential is demonstrated in the reports of the J-GOOS Panels (OOSDP, HOTO, LMR, and Services). The synthesis of input data through modelling, whether diagnostic or prognostic, and the ability to derive a huge range of varied and specialised products from a single observing system with a limited range of models using the input data, creates the possibility of satisfying the needs of hundreds of varied and distinct groups, industries, services, environmental interests, who work at sea or on the
83
coast. There is no need to force these groups into some sort of administrative package to justify our conclusions: but it is necessary to find out what types of data or forecasts would be of value to each group or sub-sector. It has not been possible to conceive of such models or products before, and therefore the need for this economic and societal analysis did not exist. It does exist now, and it would be a serious mistake to fail. Conventional sources of information on business activities, government bodies etc., are: Central Statistical Office. Treasury/Ministry of Finance reports on business, trade, imports and exports. Trade and Industry Associations annual reports. Annual reports of government agencies responsible for regulating particular sectors, such as a Ministry of Fisheries, Ministry of Energy publishing data on offshore oil and gas, or a Department of Environment publishing its expenditure on marine wildlife management. Department of Trade, Commerce, Industry annual statistics on business classification, revenue, sales, and exports/imports. European statistics. Global authority statistics such as FAO, UNCTAD. Industry summaries from trade exhibition catalogues. These sources each have hidden assumptions which make it technically difficult either to extract the marine component, or to compare like with like. If the industry consists of a few large companies, the aggregating agency may have access to reliable input figures. If there is a base to the pyramid of hundreds or thousands of small companies, what effort has been made to include their figures, or have they been ignored? Or ks it actually legitimate to ignore them? How has military expenditure and activity been treated? Have the same conventions been used all the time in estimating total revenue, or net incorrJe, or value added? Have downstream benefits been included or excluded? Are the figures really unbiased, or have they been compiled by an agency with a vested interest? Is the classification system so old-fashioned that many modem activities, or subsectors, have been over-looked? National statistics cannot be aggregated directly to obtain a European total since, in future, as benefits accrue on a global or European scale the increased prosperity in one sector could lead to decreases in another. These interactions should be considered when projecting models of benefits into the future. If the European initiatives to develop and improve maritime industries and services is to progress efficiently many of these questions have to be answered, and we need to define a standard rr~thodology. This will help the Maritime Industries Forum, the planning of marine research investment in Fratr~work 5, and the design of GOOS and EuroGOOS. It would be a great advance if all European countries gave their GOOS/EuroGOOS Committees the brief to participate in this exercise.
84
3. FACTUAL SUBSTANTIVE PROBLEMS DUE TO LACK OF KNOWLEDGE OF MARINE AND COASTAL INDUSTRIES, OR LACK OF AVAILABLE DATA The maritime industries and services have evolved very rapidly in the last 20 years. The heavy manufacturing and resource-extraction industries no longer dominate the marine sector in many countries. The impact of micro-electronics, powerful small computers, acoustics, new materials, environn~ntal regulations, satellite navigation and position systems, remote sensing, and numerical modelling, have resulted in hundreds of new start-up companies, and new divisions or subsidiaries of large established companies. In several large European countries coastal tourism is the greatest marine revenue earner. There are numerous service activities in data communications, supply of components, conduct of environmental impact surveys, providing contract data processing, insurance consultancy, instrument calibration, foundation engineering studies, etc., which may be carried out by small specialised companies which are themselves controlled by much large companies classified as nonmarine. Research institutions, regulatory authorities, and government agencies have set up new sections, taken on new responsibilities, merged, or been closed down during the last few years. It is a genuinely difficult technical matter to define and classify correctly these activities in an up-to-date manner, which will not itself be out of date within a year or two. Nobody wants to waste good working time by filling in forms and conducting unnecessary surveys, but we need to find some way of disaggregating, analysing, and then re-aggregating the data in order to make our case for consistent investment. Disaggregation too far leads to hundreds of specialised "one-off' niche markets which are too small and varied to justify concerted investment. Aggregation at too high a level clumps the sum of these niche markets with something quite different like road-building or aviation, and the marine component simply disappears. This is a technical issue, not a governmental or bureaucratic one. It is solvable for any one country. A first attempt to do this was published in the UK CCMST Report 1990, and the exercise has been up-dated by the UK IACMST for publication in late 1996 (Pugh and Skinner, 1996). But repeated arbitrary decisions have to be made which are not obvious after completion of the analysis. Figures from different countries cannot then be aggregated. This exercise should be conducted in several European countries in order to obtain a consistent picture of the modem marine and maritime industries and services. To do the work for one country would probably require about 6 staff-months of work by a person fully familiar with all the details. Longer if there was a substantial learning curve, including errors and false starts. When the exercise had been conducted a few times it may become clear that there are many short cuts in the analysis where some marine factors are predictable proportions of others which are much easier to measure. GOOS and EuroGOOS are designed to generate data products and information and forecasts which are of economic and social value. To design these products we must understand the variables which are needed, the observations which have to be made, and the manner in which the many sectors of the business and governmental world will actually use the products. These factors have received considerable attention in the last few years, and papers in the First EuroGOOS Conference provide further analysis. The benefit depends upon the percentage of people in an industry who chose to receive and act on the information, the accuracy of the information, and the percentage of times that the recipients chose to act on the information when it is in fact correct.
85
4. T H E O R E T I C A L E C O N O M I C P R O B L E M S B A S E D ON V A L U E A D D E D , DISCOUNTING, INFLATION, DOUBLE-COUNTING, CUSTOMER/OPERATOR BENEFITS, ETC. This section indicates the areas of technical complexity in assessing the value of maritime industries and services which arise from economic methodologies and professional skills and techniques which are not familiar to the non-expert. The general problem of trying to apply cost/benefit analysis to global scale technological innovation is discussed by Brown (1995). 4.1. Discount rate Brown (1995) and Sassone (1996) suggest that it is more realistic to use a social discount rate than a market or commercial rate. This results in a lower annual percentage discount, and hence a higher relative value for long term projects than would otherwise be the case. 4.2. Calculating value-added by an industry or sector At a national level the annual value of an activity should be measured by its value added to the GNP. This is substantially less than the annual revenue. The habit of suggesting that the value of an industry is its immediate income, plus all the downstream activities, employment, services, and retail outlets should be avoided. Since several other industries could claim the same downstream benefits this process results in multiple counting and is immediately rejected by Government financial officials. It is better to be conservative in estimating the value of an industry, and make sure that the figures are proof against criticism. 4.3. Value s u m m e d over several years When the value of an activity or investment needs to be summed over several years, possibly decades, it is necessary both to correct the value of money each year to remove the effects of inflation, and discount the value to allow for interest. This process was carried out in detail by Huxley (1990) to calculate the benefits derived from wave forecasting in the North Sea (see Hemming 1996). 4.4. Public sector versus market sector Some marine activities are public services, such as charting, navigational services, lighthouses, regulatory bodies and certification authorities, channel dredging, traffic separation, search and rescue, while others are commercial such as oil and gas production, or laying cables. Both sectors can benefit strongly from better environmental data and forecasts. However, the sectors behave differently from an economic point of view, and need to be assessed separately. Some services conform to the economic class of public good. There may be conflicts of interest, or cases where benefits in one sector reduce benefits in others.
86
4.5. Non-material benefits Preservation of wildlife, protecting the unspoiled beauty of coasts which might be developed with roads and hotels, conserving wetlands for fish spawning and migrating birds, protecting marine biodiversity, are activities which are very difficult to evaluate in money terms. There are several theories as to how this should be done, but I am not going to discuss them here. Adoption of a standard procedure would at least make different assessments comparable. 4.6. Benefits to operators and customers Some types of forecast will benefit all operators equally, giving none of them a corrg~titive advantage. The costs for the sector will go down, which is to the advantage of the customers for that activity, rather than the operators in it. 4.7. Utilisation and up-take of information As mentioned in the previous section the benefit to an industry of improved information or forecasts depends upon the way in which the experts in that industry chose to use or trust the information. Since forecasts are never 100% correct, the assessment of risk for the operator using the forecast is complex. This task involves both a technical understanding of the industry, plus the use of a range of standard risk assessment and decision tree models. 4.8. Estimation of costs and aggregation of costs The full costs of operational oceanographic systems have not yet been evaluated. There are both technical and economic issues, since many of the components needed for an advanced operational forecasting system exist already, or, in the case of satellite systems, may be launched anyway for other reasons. The range of questions which have to be answered is outlined by Flemming (1995b).
5.
CONCLUSIONS
9 The value of environmental information and forecasts to the maritime economy must be calculated using all types of industry and service as beneficiaries. Otherwise the estimate may be an underestimate by 50%. 9 The impact should be based on a conservative estimate of value added in each industry, eliminating knock-on effects, and double counting. 9 Different industries react in different ways: some are much more information dependent than others. Some impacts of new information simply improve routine management; other impacts will enable decisions to be made, or resources to be exploited, which could not have been considered previously. 9 There is a need for a standard assessment methodology at EU level, or jointly with OECD, or GOOS and IOC at the global level. 9 Because aggregates are industry dependent, and impact/usage dependent in terms of up-take and usage, the developing countries need special treatment.
87 ACRONYMS
CCMST ENSO EU EuroGOOS FAO GCOS GOOS HOTO IACMST IOC J-GOOS LMR OECD OOSDP UNCTAD
Co-ordinating Committee on Marine Science and Technology E1Nifio Southern Oscillation European Union European Global Ocean Observing System Food and Agriculture Organization (UN) Global Climate Observing System Global Ocean Observing System Health of the Ocean Inter-Agency Committee on Marine Science and Technology Intergovemmental Oceanographic Commission (Unesco) Joint Scientific and Technical Committee for GOOS Living Marine Resources Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Ocean Observing System Development Panel United Nations Conference on Trade and Development
REFERENCES
Adams R M, Bryant, K J, McCarl, B A, Legler, D M, O'Brien, J, Solow, A, and Weiher, R, 1995. Value of improved long-range weather information. Contemporary Economic policy, vol. XII, p. 10-19. Anderson, D L T and Willebrand, J, 1992. Recent advances in modelling the ocean circulation and its effects on climate. Reports on Progress in Physics, 55(1), 1-37. Andersen, N, 1996 (Ed) Health of the Ocean. Report of the HOTO Panel to the Joint Scientific and Technical Committee of GOOS. Australian Marine Industries and Sciences Council, 1996. Australian Marine Industry Development Strategy. Department of Industry, Science, and Tourism, Canberra. 38pp. Broadus, J M, Hoagland, P, and Kite-Powell, H L, 1988. Determining the structure of the United States marine instrumentation industry and its position in the world industry. Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution Technical Report. WHOI-88- 55.28 pp. Brown, M, 1995. Cost/Benefit analysis of large-scale S&T projects: some methodological issues. OECD Megascience Forum, Organisation for Economic C-operation and Development, Paris, 60pp. CCMST, 1990. Marine Technology in the United Kingdom. Committee on Marine Science and Technology, London. 162 pp. Davies, A M (Ed), 1990. Modeling marine systems. Volume 1. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press. 297pp. (Volume dedicated to Dr N S Heaps). Davies, A M (Ed), 1990. Modeling marine systems. Volume 2. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press. 442pp. (Volume dedicated to Dr N S Heaps). European Commission, 1995. Marine Sciences and Technologies. Second MAST days and EUROMAR market, 2 vols. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities. ISBN 92-827-5010-8. 788 + 637pp.
88 Hemming, N C, 1995a. Making the Case for GOOS. Sea Technology, January 1995, pp 44 49. Hemming N C, 1995b. The economic case for a global ocean observing system. 2nd International Conference on Oceanography, Lisbon, 1994. 16pp. Florida State University, 1993. Workshop on the economic impact of ENSO forecasts on the American, Australia, and Asian continents. Executive Summary and Panel Reports, Florida State University, Tallahassee, Florida. 86 pp. Foreman, S J and Bell, M J, 1996. FOAM - an operational forecast system for global ocean temperatures, pp.49-56 in: Oceanology International 96: The Global Ocean - towards operational oceanography. Conference proceedings, Volume 2. Kingston-Upon-Thames: Spearhead Exhibitions. 388pp. Franklin, J J, 1989. An indicator-based profile of Australian marine research activity. Centre for Technology and Social Change. University of Wollangong, Australia. GCOS, 1994. Report of the GCOS Working Group on Socio-Economic Benefits. Washington DC. 6 pp plus extensive annexes and bibliography. Hasselmann, K and Oriol, E, 1993. ERS-1 data assimilation into sea state models, p. 13 in, Proceedings of the second ERS-1 Symposium: Space at the service of our environment, 1114 October 1993, Hamburg, Germany, Volume I, (Ed. B Kaldeich). Noordwijk: European Space Agency. 1360pp. (ESA SP-361). Huxley, G, 1990. A cost benefit analysis of wave research at the National Institute of Oceanography over the period 1950-1965. CCMST Report " Marine Technology in the United Kingdom", Annexe 18, Appendix II. IACMST, 1993. Survey of UK Requirements for GOOS Data Products. Inter- Agency Committee for Marine Science and Technology. 22 pp. plus Annexes. Komen, G J, Cavaleri, L, Donelan, M, Hasselmann, K, Hasselmann, S, and Janssen, P A E M, 1994. Dynamics and modelling of ocean waves. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 532pp. National Research Council, 1989. Committee on Opportunities to Improve Marine Observations and Forecasting (1989). Opportunities to Improve Marine Forecasting. National Academy Press, Washington DC., 125 pp. Nowlin, W, 1995 (Ed). Ocean Observing System Development Panel. Report of the OOSDP to CCCO. OECD 1994. "Oceanography", the OECD Megascience Forum. OECD Publications, Paris. 167 pp. Pinardi, N, Rosati, A and Pacanowski, R C, 1995. The sea surface pressure formulation of rigid lid models. Implications for altimetric data assimilation studies. Joumal of Marine Systems, 6(1/2), 109-119. (Discussion: 121-123). Pontecorvo, G, et al., 1980. Contribution of the Ocean Sector to the United State Economy. Science 208 (30) p. 1000-1006. Prandle, D, 1993. Water-quality modelling in shelf seas: looking backwards and forwards after the North Sea Project. Ocean Challenge, 4(1/2), 16-17. Prandle, D, Ballard, G, Flatt, D, Harrison, A J, Jones, S E, Knight, P J, Loch, S, Mcmanus, J P, Player, R and Tappin, A, 1996. Combining modelling and monitoring to determine fluxes of water, dissolved and particulate metals through the Dover Strait. Continental Shelf Research, 16(2), 237-257.
89 Prandle, D and Matthews, J, 1990. The dynamics of nearshore surface currents generated by tides, wind and horizontal density gradients. Continental Shelf Research, 10(7), 665-681. Pugh, D, and Skinner, L, 1996. An analysis of Marine-related Activities in the UK economy and supporting science and technology. IACMST Information Document 5. Southampton Oceanography Centre. 52pp. Sassone, P G, 1996. Cost Benefit analysis of TOGA and the ENSO observing system. Report prepared for NOAA-Economics Group. Draft presented at NOAA Workshop on Economics of GOOS. Also: First EuroGOOS Conference. Shepherd, J, 1996 (Ed) Report of the GOOS Panel on Living Marine Resources, Workshop. Massachusetts. Smith, N, 1991. The role of models in an ocean observing system. (A background paper prepared on behalf of the Ocean Observing System Development Panel). Melbourne, Australia: Bureau of Meteorology Research Centre. 85pp. (OOSDP Background Report No.I). Woods, J D, 1985. The World Ocean Circulation Experiment. Nature 314. pp.501-511. Woods, J D, 1992. Monitoring the Ocean In: B Cartledge (ed) Monitoring the Environment O U P Oxford. pp. 123-156. Woods, J D, 1994. "The Global Ocean Observing System". J Marine Policy 18, pp.445-452. Woods, J D, 1995. "Ocean forecasting and the Global Ocean Observing System". In Hempel, G (ed), 1995. "The Ocean and the Poles." Gustav Fischer Verlag, Jena. pp.65-74. J D Woods, H Dahlin, L Droppert, M Glass, S Vallerga and N C Flemming, 1996. "The Strategy for EuroGOOS", EuroGOOS Publication No. 1, Southampton Oceanography Centre, Southampton. ISBN 0-904175-22-7.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Policy An example of a national approach
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
93
O n the G e r m a n a p p r o a c h to G O O S a n d E u r o G O O S W. Lenz I Zentrum fOr Meeres- und Klimaforschung, Universit~t Hamburg, Bundesstr. 55, D-20146 Hamburg, Germany
The idea of GOOS, the Global Ocean Observing System, was first launched by IOC in 198911]. The second World Climate Conference in 1990 took up this idea and urged its establishment to provide the oceanographic data needed by the Global Climate Observing System (GCOS) initiated in 1992. In the same year, the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) in Rio de Janeiro called for the development of a global system of ocean observation to help understand and monitor changes. In all these international bodies German representatives were present and they started a process to support the idea of GOOS in Germany. The following report is a compilation of activities on the governmental, academic and industrial side. It is by far not complete and represents the personal view of the author only.
1. ON THE BEGINNING OF GERMAN INVOLVEMENT IN GOOS The German IOC-Section, which is associated with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs became active in 1992 by forming an ad hoc working-group on GOOS. Six persons from scientific institutions and governmental agencies were nominated. They drafted a manuscript "Der deutsche Beitrag zu GOOS" (the German contribution to GOOS) dealing with the five modules, which had been defined by the Blue Ribbon Panel for GOOS of the IOC, an ad hoc panel of internationally-recognized experts. The manuscript was published as a color brochure under the title "GOOS - Ziel und Bedeutung" (GOOS - aim and meaning) [2]. The difference between the published title and the proposed one obviously shows, that the official position was first just to inform on GOOS and wait for response within the German community of marine scientists, governmental agencies as well as private industry. The Ministry for Research and Technology, too, responded to the IOC recommendation to support GOOS. In its latest programme for marine research, published in 1993 [3], GOOS was mentioned and it was stated that a more intensive participation in the planning of GOOS should be supported.
1Chairman of the German Committee for Marine Research and Technology
94 The Bundesamt fiir Seeschiffahrt und Hydrographie (BSH), a board of the Ministry of Transportation, was charged with functions of a national secretariat for GOOS to plan, coordinate and manage the German contributions to GOOS. It represents Germany in international planning activities and maintains a contact office.
~
2. THE INITIATIVE OF DEUTSCHF~ KOMITEE FUR MEERESFORSCHUNG UND MEERKSTECHNIK The Deutsches Komitee fiir Meeresforschung und Meerestechnik (DKMM; German Committee for Marine Research and Technology) was founded in 1973 to stimulate the communication between academic marine institutions and the marine technology industry in Germany for establishing a marine technology market. This is done by the distribution of relevant information and by organizing meetings. Members of the Committee are scientific societies with maritime ambition as well as commercial companies. As far as we know such a non-governmental committee is unique in European countries. Of course, this Committee became active early starting an initiative to foster the GOOS idea in circles it has access to. The subject was introduced to a broader audience in 1993 at its annual meeting and it used the newsletters of its member societies to distribute information on GOOS stressing the importance of this up-coming challenge for marine science and industry. When EuroC.K)OS was founded in December 1994 by the signing of the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) in Rome, the BSH became the national member, whereas the DKMM received the status of observer.
3. NATIONAL ACTIVITIF_~ After signing the MoU, German governmental circles enhanced fostering the EuroCK)OS idea. It was hoped that future EU MAST progralmnes would at least concentrate on the development of EuroGOOS-technology - delegating the decision of sponsoring to the European level. In September 1995, a regional technology association of four medium-sized towns in northern Germany (K.E.R.N., see below) awarded a prize for marine technology to a Norwegian company (Aanderaa) and a German one (ME-Meerestechnik/Elektronik), which have gained extraordinary reputation by producing reliable instruments for operational oceanography. The State Secretary of the Ministry of Education, Science, Research and Technology was invited to address the prize-winners and in his laudation he stressed the importance of German contributions to GOOS. The president of BSH declared at the same meeting that BSH is ready for leadership in German GOOS/EuroGOOS-activities if provided with the necessary governmental support. In 1995, the BSH published a survey on current and planned operational programmes, which could be considered as the German contribution to GOOS [4]. This survey is a very valuable compendium to demonstrate German activities which are related to GOOS. To help to overcome the scientific institutions reservation towards operational oceanography the DKMM estabished a working sub-group on GOOS to bring scientists and technologists at
95
one table together. The first meeting took place on 15 November 1995. Some recommendations of this meeting are listed below: - Companies need more reliability in the investment on GOOS technology. The development of technology should be internationally backed by standardisation of measuring methods as well as in instrtunental components in order to reach high production numbers. GOOS technology should not be restricted to coastal and near surface applications, but should also be applicable to deep sea measurements. GOOS measuring technology should seek permanent operation with as little maintenance as possible to make it also available for developing countries. - Research on anti-fouling coating of sensors should be given a high priority. - The experiences of ESA in making high amounts of data useful for customers should be incorporated. - The conversion of military developments into civil applications is a laudable aspiration; their products are usually three times more costly, but they are more robust and have a far greater durabiliy, which is particularly desirable for deep sea missions; such a conversion was very successful with the ADCP. - An exhaustive dialogue is necessary between governmental research and industry. It is essential to create a market for GOOS/EuroCaS)OS-products, otherwise the idea will fail. -
-
-
Although most of the participants of the working group were not familiar with GOOS and EuroGOOS-papers, it turned out that their recommendations are quite similar to the ones published in the GOOS-papers. Special emphasis was laid on the problem of standardisation. This suggestion being one of the most important traditions in German industrial success did not come as a surprise. Regarding EUROMAR, whose headquarter is located in Germany, the German government strongly supported the respective activities and initiatives to take up the technological challenges arising from EuroC,-OOS. In this context it was welcomed that EUROMAR received observer status in the EuroGOOS framework.
4. ACTIVITIES IN 1996 The activity of discussing the German engagement in GOOS and EuroCA)OS has increased during this year. Four quite different initiatives called for a meeting. In chronological order they are - with main discussion points: 24.01.96 Deutsches Komitee fOr Meeresforschung und Meerestechnik (DKMM), (Hamburg) second meeting of its working group on GOOS technology development; ten agencies and companies had sent delegates: Discussion on the future of German marine technology. Founding an institute for marine research technology - on governmental and/or on academic basis?
96 Technologie-Region Kiel, EckernfOrde, Rendsburg, Neumtinster (K.E.R.N.), 13th Technology-Circle; about 25 persons mostly from companies and local administrations were present; the programme consisted of two speeches by the president of the BSH and the GOOS secretary: For small- and medium-sized companies the period between start of development and delivery should not exceed 1-11A years. - The technical control of monitoring systems should be given to consulting companies.
08.02.96 (Kiel)
-
18.04.96 (Hamburg)
Gesellschafi fOr Maritime Technik (GMT) in co-operation with Verband fOr Schiffbau und Meerestechnik (VSM) and DKMM; 20 persons mostly from c ompanies were present: - Projects to be part-f'lnanced by the government on the basis of 50% privately owned capital. - How to represent industrial interest at the up-coming GOOS-workshop of the BSH.
23/24.04.96 (Rostock)
Bundesamt ffir Seeschiffahrt und Hydrographie (BSH) and University of Rostock; this national workshop on GOOS was sub-titled "demands for a scientific concept for the German contribution" and was more like a symposium with 15 contributions and a final discussion; ca. 75 persons were present: Germany as an industrial nation with responsibilities should participate in GOOS and should do this in intercorrelation between users, operational services, research and technological development. - German monitoring programmes on hydrography along the coast as well as on stock recruitment should be considered as national contribution to GOOS. The "Science Plan" of CLIVAR should be taken as the scientific basis; standardisation of methods and sensors. -
-
GMT, DKMM, BSH and GKSS (hosting the newly established contact office for marine research technology) will have another GOOS related meeting in November 1996 in the building of Stock Exchange in Hamburg. The aim is to intensify information and discussion between the three parties (science, industry and administration) as well as to deliberate on the establishment of working groups for each module and to bring in line recommendations for the next concrete steps. It is expected that these working groups will define projects for the industry.
5. ON THE PROBLEM OF NATIONAL CO-OPERATION The recent activity of several meetings demonstrates the increasing interest in GOOS/EuroC~OS particularly on the governmental as well as on the commercial side. It also demonstrates the endeavour to find a common platform, which is difficult to get in Germany as stated in a study on high-tech-transfer into marine research and marine controlling technology, which had been produced on behalf of the Ministry of Education, Science, Research and Technology.
97
It was published in early 1996 and is available for everyone on the internet under "ftp://ftp.gkss.de/pub/htt-studie". GOOS related results are summarized to the effect that GOOS exists on paper only, up to now, and that not a few experts still see a big questionmark behind the implementation of the GOOS modules. It is further mentioned that Germany is extremely cautious in regard to GOOS and, if this is not changed, it will lead to negative consequences especially in the development of insmunents. German industry is ready and ambitious to start development and production of new GOOS technology. It is ready to take off waiting for distinct boundary conditions within funding and knowing that in some other European countries industry has already started.
REFERENCES 1. IOC Resolution XV-4 Global Integrated Ocean Observing System Development (Report of the Fifteenth Session of the IOC Assembly [Paris, 4-19 July 1989] Doc. SC/MD/91). 2. Bundesamt fOr Seeschiffahrt und Hydrographie (ed.), GOOS - Ziel und Bedeutung, 35 pp., Hamburg, 1994. 3. Bundesministerium fOr Forschung und Technologie, Meeresforschung - Programm der Bundesregierung, Bonn 1993. 4. Bundesamt fOr Seeschiffahrt und Hydrographie (ed.), Global Ocean Observing System Statusbericht iiber Programme, die als deutscher Beitrag zu GOOS eingebracht werden kOnnen. Berichte des BSH, No. 7, 100 pp., Hamburg und Rostock, 1995.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
TECHNOLOGY Instruments/Monitoring Networks
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
SEAWATCH, S.E. Hansen
101
Performance and future
a, J.H.
Stel b
a OCEANOR, Pirsenteret, 7005 Trondheim, Norway bNetherlands Geosciences Foundation, Laan van N.O. Indie 131, 2543 BM The Hague, The Netherlands Operational oceanography has become an option and a reality to an extent which was not possible a decade ago. Modern techniques now allow for the collection of new types of especially "green" data. Data are transferred from remote locations using satellite links to support operational applications both in oceanography and in meteorology. Operational oceanography is comparable to weather forecasting in meteorology. As a consequence issues such as synoptic data collection, uniform data-quality, real-time transmission of data, data management, data assimilation in numerical models, assessment and forecasting and finally the dissemination of products tot users, are also relevant in operational oceanography. In this paper the performance and future of the Seawatch system is described. Seawatch is a result of the Eureka/Euromar partnership. Seawatch Europe was in operations from 1990-1994. It was partly operational and partly experimental. Valuable experience was gained in operating large scale regional monitoring systems. Daily reports were distributed to different users, weekly reports were issued and distributed widely, quarterly and annual reports were issued for in-depth presentations of the marine environment as deducted from the data obtained by the Seawatch buoy network. A strong point of Seawatch is that it is commercially off-the-shelf and state-of-the-art technology. In a report of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD, 1996) the benefits of the Seawatch system are clearly demonstrated. The global potential for the Exclusive Economic Zone is an estimated 50 units of ten buoys with a running costs of $ I00 million per year. Within the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC), the initiator of the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS), Seawatch is seen as an important building block for GOOS, with special relevance to the marine meteorology and oceanographic forecasting, the health of the ocean, and the coastal zone management modules.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N The resources of the ocean are highly and is some cases critically important to the economy of coastal states and the well being of some 60 % of the people living on this planet. The annual GNP contribution from the global maritime industries and services is an estimated $ 800 billion
102 to $1 trillion (Flemming, 1995). At present it is difficult to come to grips with the global benefits of ocean forecasting systems. However, the economic benefit for the agricultural sector in the USA of the existing E1 Nifio forecasting system is a $ 323 to $ 266 million for respectively a perfect and high skill (probability of 0.8) forecast (Adems & Kite-Powell, 1996). In the case of Seawatch Europe it was calculated that if Seawatch information could avoid a delay of 105 minutes in the start up of a production well in the oil and gas exploration sector, it would have covered its costs of operation. Just as with the E1 Nifio system these benefits only give the tip of the iceberg as many other economic sectors such as fisheries, energy and tourism also benefit from the same ocean forecasting systems. Last May the EU decided to half the yearly quota for the European herring fisheries because a possible depletion of this fish stock. More than twenty years ago marine biologists of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisations (FAO) estimated that ocean fishery could not sustain an annual yield of more than 100 million tons. That number was reached in 1989 and equals the world production in beef and poultry together. Recent FAO reports indicate over-fishing and depletion of fish stocks a combination of pollution and over harvesting is killing many inland seas and coastal estuaries. The tension between the continuously expanding human demands and nature's various limits affect not only food supply but also overall economic growth. In a World Bank report (Pearce & Warford, 1993) the annual costs of pollution damage in 1990 in Germany various from 1.7 to 4.2 percent of the GNP. Tourism is the second largest industry in the world and might be the world's largest industry around the year 2000. In the Netherlands some 38 million people visit the coast annually for recreational activities. Tourism has a significant impact on the economy. In many countries tourism may be the most important part in its economy. A clean environment is essensial to attract the tourists. At the same time an increased tourism may be a threat to the environment. The fact that some coastal areas and seas are reaching the limits of their natural tolerance is now recognised internationally. During the last few years, the subject of the marine environment has been put on the political agenda in almost all industrialised countries in the West. In the development of policies for tourism and fisheries there is a need for reliable information. This is the type of information that SEAWATCH supports. More and more industries are investing greater resources to improve their "green" profile by taking an active stance on environmental questions and by using the environment to increase their market share. Recognition by the leaders of major international corporations means that, according to the well-known British environmental expert John Elkinton, the 1990's will be "the green decade, in which care for the environmental consciousness and the rising demand for "green" products are the driving forces behind the increased environmental activity which has forced companies to go on the offensive. At the same time the marine environment has become one of the hottest political topics. This is demonstrated by the activities of the newly established Independent World Commission on the Oceans; a Bruntland like Commission which will report during the 1998 Year of the Ocean. This shows that the time is right for GOOS, which will facilitate the professional production and distribution of up-to-date information about the maritime environment.
103 2. SEAWATCH
Seawatch is originally designed as a monitoring and forecasting system for the marine environment in northern Europe (Seawatch-Europe). It has, however, developed into a state of the art off the shelf system which also has been implemented in other parts of the world. Seawatch Europe represents the main limb of the Seawatch tree from where most Seawatch developments were initiated. It was formed by the following partners: Statoil, Norske Shell, Norwegian Scientific Council, Norwegian State Pollution Control Authority, the Swedish Meteorological and Hydrographical Institute and Oceanor. The motivation for each of the partners may vary from getting access to design values for offshore constructions to obtaining data for operational purposes, forecasts of algal blooms, pollution monitoring , R&D and weather-forecasting. The overall objective is, however, the creation of a regional marine monitoring and forecasting system as a joint project by a number of European countries. So far, Germany, Sweden, the Netherlands, Norway and the UK have participated in the project. Together they established a Seawatch Advisory board which met twice a year and a Quality Assurance group with four representatives appointed by the Advisory board. The QA members are specialists in chemical, biological and physical oceanography. The terms of reference for this group was to evaluate the documentation of the data quality obtained in the Seawatch Europe project. The years 1990 and 1991 were a development period focusing on new instrumentation and optimal buoy location. Since 1992 the project was partly experimental and operational. The operational program included 10-12 buoys deployed in Europe and 5-6 buoys in Thailand. The experimental program of Seawatch concentrated on sensor development (orthophosphatc, CTD string), improvement of numerical models and dissemination systems for ocean data and information. At present Seawatch systems are used or installed in Bangladesh, India, Indonesia, Norway, Spain and Thailand. Moreover discussions are under way with Greece, Korea, Mexico and the USA. These efforts clearly show the potential of SEAWATCH as an instrument for the realisation of GOOS. Since 1990 continuous observations of 15-20 independent parameters in the ocean gave insight in numerous marine phenomena and processes. Observed extreme waves draw considerable attention from the offshore industry. Algal blooms are followed from an early stage and allow for precise descriptions of these blooms along the coast throughout the year. Toxic algae blooms have been discovered in due time to give warnings to the fish farming industry in Norway and Sweden and to insurance companies. Current and wave data from Seawatch have been used by the oil industry in particular in connection with marine operations. Subsurface temperature forecasts are also in operation. Monitoring of oceanographic processes such as the inflow of saline water into the Baltic were made possible by Seawatch with a hitherto unknown precision. Radioactivity observations from Seawatch are an important measure to discover illegal dumping or radioactive leakage's from nuclear power plants. After several years of development an operational nutrient sensor has been attached to the Seawatch system. This sensor will contribute
104 to the monitoring of nutrient salts in the water masses. At present it is deployed on two of the operational buoys of Seawatch Europe.
2.1. Basic Elements The Seawatch system has three main parts (Figure 1) being: real time observations based on fully equipped oceanographic buoys, data management and forecasting services and data and information distribution. The real time observation is primarily based on oceanographic buoys. These buoys are equipped with sensors to monitor air-pressure, air-temperature, wind speed, wind direction, wave height, wave period, seasurface current speed and direction, surface salinity and temperature, water temperature and salinity from surface to some 50m depth, radioactivity, light transmission, oxygen and nutrient salts. A small, powerful computer inside the buoy manages the observations, performs necessary analysis of the data and prepares the observations for further transmission via satellite (Figure2) to Oceanor's offices in Trondheim, Norway, within one or two hours depending on the passage of the Argos satellite. The development of a link with the Inmarsat satellite system was part of the experimental program within Seawatch Europe. This will not only allow for a continuous flow of data from the buoy but also for a two - way communication.
Figurel Basic elements of SEAWATCH
105
2.2. Supplementary observations The observations form the buoys in operation in Norway and Thailand are supplemented by a network of land-based observers from fish farms, aquaculture research stations and lighthouses. The daily observations include sea-surface temperature and salinity, water turbidity (secci depth),water colour, weather observations, occurrence of jellyfish, fish behaviour and appetite. Each observer can also collect water samples in special containers which are send to Oceanor for identification of algae etc. In Thailand the Department for Fisheries is responsible for these analysis. For the validation of the quality of the chemical data like the nutrient, radioactivity and salinity data, water samples are taken and analyzed at dedicated laboratories. These data are also stored in the database with a reference to the buoy observations.
2.3. Data management and forecasting services The data received by Oceanor from the Argos Services in Toulouse, France are subject to an automatic control. This is followed by a manual data control by a biologist and meteorologist/oceanographer each morning between 08.30-10.00. Immediately after this meeting the data will be corrected and released for distribution to the users. The procedure is that both the corrected and raw-data file are stored. This allows for a new assessment of the original data file if necessary. Each morning two types of forecast are prepared. One is addressing a description of the algae distribution. The other one gives a bottom water temperature forecast for the Norwegian Trench with a prediction up to 72 hours. After the forecasting meeting the information is released and made available to the users by the PC based Ocean-lnfo system (Figure 3).
Figure 2 The S E A W A T C H buoy
106
2.4. Data and information distribution The data received at Oceanor are stored in a database, which archives the data automatically as well as all information about instrument records, service reports and supplementary data for validation. Seawatch makes use of an Arc-Info geographical information system to integrate different sources of data which have reference to geographical co-ordinates. Results from numerical models are easily presented on top of AVHRR data received from satellites. Time series from the buoys are nicely presented in the frame of an overall presentation of the buoys. The GIS system which is implemented on a UNIX workstation, is primarily for the larger users of the system and is called OCEAN-GIS. The majority of the users have installed a PC based system to connect to the central data base at Oceanor via a modem or over INTERNET. This is called the OCEAN-INFO system. OCEANINFO has three parts (Figure 3) being: a presentation module for presenting data and text information, a presentation module for maps and pictures and a communication module for receiving data and text information.
Figure 3 Ocean -Info
107
3. SOME E X A M P L E S OF S E A W A T C H O B S E R V A T I O N S One important and interesting event was the inflow of 300 km 3 of fresh saline water to the Baltic. On 21 March 1993 a Seawatch buoy was deployed east of Bornholm to monitor the inflow by means of a temperature/salinity string from the sea-floor to the sill depth of the Gotland basin. An outflow from the Skagerrak in excess of 1.0 Sv was estimated using the transport model Makrillen. Currents in the order of 1 m/s were measured at several locations. In January and February 1993 strong lows pressure which produced violent winds occurred. One of the deepest lows ever observed happened during this period. Considerable damage to buildings, sea walls and power supply cables took place. Due to the extreme winds, waves also reached extreme heights. Between 27 December 1992 and 14 March 1993 the average significant wave heights at Haltenbanken was 5.7 m (Figure 4). At the Nordkappbanken buoy waves in excess of the 100 year wave were measured.
Figure 4 Observation at the Haltenbanken winter 92/93 High water level also occurred during the last quarter of 1992. In the German Bight the sea elevation was almost 2 m above the mean. The Outer Oslofjord had between 5 and 19 January 1993 a sea elevation 0.45 m above the mean. The water elevation was predicted by the operational numerical model of the Seawatch system. A classical spring bloom of algae was recorded from late February through March 1993 in the Seawatch Europe area, with a maximum in the middle of March in the Kattegat and along the
108 Norwegian west coast. By the end of March the bloom was spreading northwards from MidNorway, but had still not developed in the offshore waters of Mid-Norway. In most of the area from the Baltic to Mid-Norway the bloom was dominated by the diatom Skeletonema costatum. Further north and in some of the fjords high concentrations of other diatoms or the prymnesiophyte Phaeocystis pouchettii were observed. Fish mortality (Atlantic salmon and rainbow trout) in fish farms on the Norwegian west coast was associated with high concentrations of Skeletonema costatum. The total loss of fish probably exceeded 100 tonnes. For the first time in Norway mussels and other bivalves were toxic in the winter period (January-February) due to the occurrence of the PSP producing dinoflagellate Alexandrium excavatum. Deep water formation in the Skagerrak was monitored with temperature sensors close to the seafloor. Due to extreme atmospheric cooling over the North Sea-Plateau the water which occupied over the shallow plateau became dense and suddenly cascaded down the slope into the deepest parts of the Norwegian trench. The temperature dropped from approx. 7.5 ~ 5.5 ~ within 4 hours. Some days later a minimum temperature was measured to 4.9 ~ (Figure
5)
Figure 5 Temperature observations in the Norwegian Trench
109
4. P E R F O R M A N C E OF S E A W A T C H Based on daily records over the last two years the average data recovery for all sensors and for all buoys has increased from 89% in 1994 to 94% in 1994. Some of the buoys have a 100% data recovery. Taking into consideration that some of these buoys are working under the most hostile conditions one could expect in the North Sea, we conclude that the Seawatch buoys have reached a high performance level. Some of the sensors are subject for further development and improvement. The data recovery table (Figure 6) includes all types of failure from erroneous or suspicious data to sensor damage caused by ships or fishing activities as well as all situations where the buoys drifted from its positions.
Figure 6 Datarecovery from SEAWATCH in 1994
5. S E A W A T C H AND E U R O G O O S Some countries in northern Europe have a long standing experience with local, mostly coastal monitoring systems or networks. During feasibility studies within the context of Seawatch Europe it became clear that some of the established national monitoring organisations saw little or none at all advantages for linking these systems with a regional system. Often Seawatch was seen as a competitor to their national development schemes. This has, however, changed dramatically mostly due to some initiatives to link existing national monitoring systems around the North Sea and the development of EuroGOOS. In the southern part of Europe the situation is different as often no monitoring networks exists. In these cases the potential of the Seawatch system is high
110 as it offers an easy way to install a brand new, off the shelf system, tailor made to the needs of the governmental clients. Here Seawatch offers and interesting state-of-the-art building block for a regional GOOS system. This is even more so in developing countries lacking monitoring networks at all. Here Seawatch offers both the technology, training and protocols for data exchange. An interesting example for the implementation of a regional GOOS component are the Seawatch systems in India, Bangladesh, Thailand and Indonesia which together could form the nucleus for the South Western Pacific GOOS. In the cost-benefit analysis of Seawatch Europe the by OECD (1996) it is estimated that a 100200 Seawatch units of ten buoys would cover the needs for GOOS. Assuming that most countries firstly will invest in their EEZ, a market potential of at least 50 ten buoy units is foreseen. The projected operational costs of these systems are some $ 1 0 0 million annually and commensurates with the questimate made by Flemming (OECD, 1994) for other components of GOOS.
REFERENCES
1. Adams, R. & H. Kite-Powell, 1996. Benefits of Improved ENSO Forecasts: Empirical Evidence and Research Needs. In: NOAA-IOC workshop on socio-economic aspects of the Global Ocean Observing System: Assessing Benefits and Costs of the Climate and Coastal Modules. Appendix 3. 2. Flemming, N.C., 1995. The case for GOOS. Sea Technology, January, 44-49. 3. OECD, 1994. Oceanography, The Megascience Forum, Paris. 4. OECD, 1996. Megascience: The OECD Forum, The Costs and benefits of SEAWATCH 5. Pearce, D. & J. Warford, 1993. World Without End. Worldbank. 6. Stel, J.H. & B.F. Mannix, 1996. A benefit-cost analysis of a regional Global Ocean Observing System; Seawatch Europe. Marine Policy, in press.
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 1997 Elsevier Science B.V.
lll
SeaNet E u r o p e a n w o r k s h o p o n f i x e d m o n i t o r i n g n e t w o r k s in the N o r t h S e a r e g i o n R. van der Poel and J. Rozema North Sea Directorate, P.O. Box 5807, 2280 HV Rijswijk, The Netherlands
At present all countries around the North Sea operate fixed monitoring systems for proper management and scientific research of the marine environment. These systems feature differences with respect to technical concept and application. However, they all deliver valuable data to study the dynamics of the marine system in the North Sea basin for application in the management of the marine environment. Recognition is growing among agencies which operate national marine monitoring networks, that an integrated use of the existing networks and the development of an integrated system concept are necessary from an economic and operational point of view. In view of this the initiative has been taken for a European Workshop on Fixed Monitoring Networks in the North Sea Region. Five goals have been formulated: 9 Promotion of on-line data exchange between fixed monitoring networks. 9 Standardisation of data collection and processing methods. 9 Co-operation in the development of new measuring techniques and sensors, and testing of existing sensors. 9 Exchange of experience in data communication. 9 Exchange of experience in data collection, particularly from fixed structures. Benefits from these goals are: 9 Easy use of data from other monitoring networks. 9 Reduction in the number of measuring locations and a reduction of cost, in some cases. 9 Shared know-how and technology. 9 Improved use of models by wider availability of information. After 6 workshops the following results have been accomplished: 9 A feasibility study for a Marine Monitoring System for the year 2000 and beyond (MMS2000+) has been carried out. 9 Information is available on all fixed measuring locations, in each country. 9 Information is available on all the different measuring techniques and processing methods used in each country. 9 Every operator of a fixed monitoring network is aware of the existence of the networks owned by the different countries. 9 Exchange of information has already been accomplished.
112
1. INTRODUCTION At present all countries around the North Sea operate fixed monitoring systems for the correct management of, and scientific research on, the marine environment. These systems have many differences with respect to technical concept and application. They do however have one thing in common, in that they all deliver valuable data to study the dynamics of the marine system in the North Sea basin for application in the management of the marine environment. For an optimum use of the existing facilities and infrastructure there are two major thresholds: 9 Most systems are meant for use on a local or national scale only. The transnational exchange of data for use on a regional scale is still an exception. 9 In most systems the integrated approach of real time in-situ measurements, the use of fixed platforms, buoy stations and satellites, and operational data-assimilation modelling to produce complete and detailed information and forecasts is not yet implemented.
1.1. Why SeaNet? The need to survey the current status of marine monitoring networks in the North Sea region and to initiate the discussion between the monitoring authorities concerning the exchange of data and future co-operation was recognised. Hence the Rijkswaterstaat North Sea Directorate (the Netherlands) and the Bundesamt f'tir Seeschiffahrt und Hydrographie (Germany) took the initiative for an International Workshop on Fixed Monitoring Networks. Participants of the Workshop are governmental agencies responsible for local or national monitoring networks in Norway, Sweden, Denmark, United Kingdom, the Netherlands, Germany, Belgium and France. These governmental agencies are: Countn/ Belgium Denmark France Germany Great Britain the Netherlands Norway Sweden ,.
,,
Name of institute Ministn/of the Flemish Community Royal Danish Administration of Navigation and" Hydrography IFREMER Nantes Bundesamt fur Seeschiffahrt und Hydrographie M E T office Rijkswaterstaat, North Sea Directorate Norwegian Pollution Control Authonty Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute ....
Contact person Telephone G. Dumon +32 59554246 E. Buch +45 32689500 J.P. Berthome +33 40374106 D. Kohnke '+49 4031903400 I. Pratt +44 344854914 R. van der Poel +31 703366600 I. Thelin +47 22573400 H. Dahlyn +46 11158000 i
.......
. . . .
All these countries operate networks in the North Sea. Data is often used for regional purposes: vessel traffic services, lock control, decision making for storm surge barriers and scientific research. However, in order to make predictions on wave heights, offsets of sea level etc., models require data not restricted to the national part of the continental shelf. Some data exchange is currently realised, but is on a bi-lateral basis. When looking at The Netherlands for example, data are continuously retrieved from locations at the English part of the continental shelf (Shell platforms Auk Alpha and North Cormorant) and from the Belgium measuring network "Vlaamse banken". The data from the UK are (among other things) used for vessel traffic services and for ship guidance to the harbour of Rotterdam (calculating tide windows), whilst the data coming from Belgium are used for the storm surge barrier in Zeeland.
113
2. O B J E C T I V E S The procedures adopted in the meteorological world were used as a model when formulating the objectives. A standard for exchanging information was defined and a system for exchanging data was implemented. The objectives of SeaNet are: 9 A homogenous distribution offixed monitoring sites The distribution of measuring locations in the North Sea can be more effective, especially near the continental borders, when it is possible to retrieve data from neighbouring countries. 9 Promotion o f on-line data exchange betweenfixed monitoring networks Users of data coming from a particular network are often not aware of the availability of data coming from other existing networks and are therefore limited. Current data exchange between countries serves one particular interest and is not accessible for other users. 9 Standardisation o f data collection, processing methods and validation techniques Standardisation among the different networks creates greater accessibility to the different end-users. It becomes much easier to compare data and to use data originating from different networks in any particular application. 9 Co-operation in the development of new measuring techniques and sensors, and testing of existing sensors Shared knowledge of sensors and parameter measurement can be cost-effective. Knowledge on how to measure hydrological parameters, such as waves (wave height, spectra, sea level, etc.), is available in almost every country, but may not be the case for other parameters such as biological (nutrients, algae, etc.). 9 Exchange o f experience in data communications Data communication is one of the most difficult problems of monitoring network operation. The large area over which measuring locations are situated and the difficulties in reaching these locations (long travel times, high costs etc.), together with the extreme conditions in which the equipment is placed, create a data communication bottleneck. 9 Exchange o f experience in data collection, particularly on fixed structures Problems with data collection are created by similar factors as those discussed for data communications. Exchange of experience in this field can also be very cost-effective.
3. W H A T H A S BEEN A C H I E V E D 3.1. Knowledge of what is measured and where Overviews have been generated (position, owner, type of construction, etc.) for all the existing locations in each monitoring network (see Figure 1).
La:al~rme
SInJ:Uet~e
Figure 1. Small part of a location overview
114
Furthermore, information on parameters calculated, sensor heights, etc. are available for each location in the form of geographical overviews and tables. In order to make this accessible to everyone, a DOS presentation program has been made (MARLS diskette) and is also available on the intemet (http://www.minvenw.nl/projects/seanet) Figure 2 is an example geographical overview showing all locations equipped with some kind of meteorological, hydrological or biological instrument.
9
,
~
*
,. ~ ~ - .......,",-,~
.,~ . j
:' ,i,.
i
..... -
"
.......
J"
,,,. -
,I,.. A
9
~.
....."
"--" _~-.
.-z,_
~..~.~
~,,"
"~".,',..., ...... ",~, ~ ~r'-..~.~ * .~ "'," , -~'t~ - ' ~ ~ . ~ ' ~ -
,r
~.
. I
...
._. ,11, .,, .J i..,,.p -,,"~., -,...,f . 9 .~"
i
~
-,,r
_ t_t...
,-
"~
..' ~ ' ~
. ! . ,",',i. . ~~_,11i~ _
_.x~ -~
,. - - - , , , .,,.~,"~.,. - . . . . ~ , , - " " ,,, ..--.
,~.~...,,,~
-.
-
: ~
~ " ~n.,,, ~ ,., , ~ rr ...,
~,
',,.
9 ",,,~: $
-w,,c"
-'-'
"<" r" ) ~.,:.....',-
, . ~,
T ~
j:
t,". -'"' r
t
.,j.,
'-.: t- t.._.._~
-,',.-""~\...,.i-
~
Figure 2. Overview of measuring locations in the North Sea region
3.2. E C M A S T III - C o n c e r t e d a c t i o n
At the start of 1995 an EC MAST III proposal for concerted action was made to support cooperation between European countries. The aim was to get financial and other support from the EC for joint projects. This proposal was accepted at the end of 1995 and as a consequence the continuity of SeaNet has been secured for the next couple of years.
115
3.3 Marine Monitoring System 2000+ (MMS2000+) During the third SeaNet workshop, participants decided to investigate the feasibility, and define a plan to realise, the integrated use of data from fixed monitoring networks around the North Sea. It was called the Marine Monitoring System 2000+ initiative for the North Sea Region. Four goals were formulated: 9 Survey information end user needs and the opportunities for the fixed monitoring network agencies around the North Sea. 9 Define a system based on the integrated use of national networks and the integration of monitoring and modelling techniques. 9 Facilitate the technological developments needed to establish such an integrated system. 9 Organise the implementation of a marine monitoring and forecasting system for the North Sea Region. The first phase called the SeaNet survey, was to meet the first goal, and was successfully completed in June 1996. Between February and April 1996 a selected group of 56 so called "Key persons" was interviewed, representing 42 organisations from the eight different North Sea countries. The interview consisted of four parts: 9 Needs / parameters. 9 Benefits / applications. 9 Opportunities / technologies. 9 Cost / incentive. One of the questions asked, was the importance of in-situ measurements, remote sensing and operational modelling, both now and in 2005. It was interesting to find that the in-situ measurements will become of less importance towards 2005, but will stay most important, relative to the remote sensing and operational modelling. The results are given in Figures 3, 4 and 5.
Figure 3. The importance of in-situ measurements now and in 2005 It is expected that the importance of in-situ measurements will decrease towards the year 2005. But it will not become less important than operational modelling (Figure 4).
116
Figure 4. Importance of operational modeling now and in 2005 Despite the high expectations of remote sensing in the early 90's, remote sensing is at present found not to be very important. The importance will grow in the near future, but not become larger than in-situ measurements or operational modelling (Figure 5).
Figure 5. Importance of remote sensing now and in 2005
4. S E A N E T - E u r o G O O S
SeaNet was started before the GOOS program. But as GOOS developed, and especially the European component (EuroGOOS), it became clear that the SeaNet goals and EuroGOOS goals were much alike, when looking at the area of interest of SeaNet. The aim of GOOS is to design and implement a scientifically based system of ocean observations and predictions to fulfil economic, social, environmental and scientific objectives. EuroGOOS identifies European priorities for operational oceanography, promotes the development of scientific, technological and computer systems, assesses the economic and social benefits and establishes a concerted European approach for GOOS and methods for routine collaboration between European agencies. EuroGOOS covers all aspects of operational oceanography and SeaNet covers the fixed monitoring network modules for the North Sea region. Perhaps SeaNet will be one of the groups that can contribute to EuroGOOS in the future.
117 The differences between EuroGOOS and SeaNet may originate from their development: SeaNet is a typical bottom-up initiative, while GOOS is a top-down initiative. As a consequence the participants of SeaNet are more practically / operationally oriented while GOOS participants are derived mainly from the science sector. Another difference is of course the scale of SeaNet, which is on a sub-regional scale compared to EuroGOOS.
5. FUTURE PLANS
5.1. Follow-up to Marine Monitoring System 2000+ During the SeaNet meeting in Brugge, June 1996, it was decided to create three project groups: 9 The data interface project group From the SeaNet survey it appeared that the SeaNet data interface for data management and transfer is essential to accomplish the first phase of SeaNet. Realisation and installation of this dedicated interface between a national network and the SeaNet members will make the basic version of SeaNet a reality. The goal of this project group is to design a plan for such an interface, is the most important one and also the one closest to implementation. 9 The current / temperature / salinity (CTS) project group Good instruments have been developed, such as the Acoustic Doppler Current Profilers for current measurement, but when implementing these instruments in fixed monitoring networks all kind of problems occur. One of the most difficult problems being the transmission of data to the shore. The goal of this project group is to combine experience in this field of interest and to facilitate ways to overcome the still existing difficulties. This project group is somewhat further from realisation compared to the data interface project group. 9 The bio-effects /contaminants (BEC) project group This is the project group furthest away from implementation. Attempts have been made to develop instruments for the different parameters (e.g. the MERMAID project), but these are not very well known to the organisations running the monitoring networks or the endusers. The goal of this project group, is to combine the knowledge and experience which is available within the North Sea countries and propose an approach to measure the requested parameters (results from the SeaNet survey) and how to implement this within the existing fixed monitoring networks.
5.2. Standardisation When exchanging data between the different fixed monitoring networks, one of the difficulties is the comparison of these data with each other. Taking tides as an example, the reference levels, ways of processing data and calculating parameters, quality control methods, time stamps, etc. can all be different. The ultimate goal for exchanging data is that everyone is using the same standard for collecting and processing data. During the last couple of SeaNet meetings, attempts were made to find an existing standard that was acceptable for every SeaNet participant. The FIESTA-report came very close, but did
118
not meet the accuracy and frequency demands needed for operational use. An outstanding action, still to be realised, is a method of updating this standard in such a way that it is acceptable to everyone. Overviews have been created to make it possible to compare data at present, which contain the information most needed when doing this kind of work. An example can be found in Figure 6. AIR PRESSURE Country name
Sensor type
Range
Unit
Precision/ Resolutio n
BELGIUM
DENMARK
Multur BA 90 W. Lambacht Jomo 4AB Aanderaa S. 2810
hPa
hPa hPa hPa
913.3 945 950 920
-
1113.3 1055 1050 1080
0.5/0.1 +0.3 +0.5 +0.2
not relevant
Figure 6. Detail of an overview on data measurement
6. C O N C L U S I O N S When executing the SeaNet survey, one of the interesting results was the enthusiastic response towards the SeaNet initiative. Many people expressed a feeling that this initiative is happening at a very good moment in time. This reflects the growing interest for data not limited to the national parts of the continental shelf. With respect to EuroGOOS, the SeaNet workshop can be one of the groups that can contribute on the subject of fixed monitoring networks.
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge for European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
119
A p r o p o s e d n e w s h i p - o f - o p p o r t u n i t y t o w e d v e h i c l e a n d s e n s o r suite d e s i g n e d for coastal, s h e l f a n d o c e a n b a s i n s u r v e y . R. Burtl,j. Aiken 2, T.J. Dunning', R.Williams 2 and others IChelsea Instruments Ltd., 2/3 Central Avenue, West Molesey, Surrey KT8 2QZ UK. Tel (44) 181 941 0044 Fax (44) 181 941 9319 Email
[email protected] 2plymouth Marine Laboratory, Prospect Place, The Hoe, Plymouth PL 1 3DH, Devon, UK. Tel (44) 01752 633100, Fax (44) 1752 633101 Email
[email protected] A new towed vehicle and associated sensors for ship-of-opportunity deployments are proposed to comply with the priorities for operational oceanography under EuroGOOS. Additional new sensors, along with the standard set of depth, temperature, conductivity, chlorophyll a, fluorescence, turbidity, optical transmittance, bioluminescence, nutrient, redox and dissolved oxygen, are being prepared for this new vehicle such as the Fast Repetition Rate Fluorometer and a laser particle counter. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Technologies which can aid the remote acquisition of data and data transmission to a ground station are the crux of initiatives like GOOS. Affordable monitoring strategies designed to answer the problems facing the management of the oceans and continental shelf resources are required. It is realised that one of the most cost effective methods for spatially and temporally monitoring the environmental variables necessary for evaluation of the status and 'health' of the oceans and coastal seas is by the use of towed instrumentation (Williams, 1995). Developments during the last 15 years in instrumentation and remotely sensed measurements of water colour from space, together with increased data processing and storage capabilities have allowed us to approach this task with some realism. Currently the cheapest way to monitor environmental variables and associated parameters on a seasonal basis requires the sampling strategy embodied in CPR (Continuous Plankton Recorder) ship-of-opportunity deployments (Gamble & Hunt, 1992). Many of the towed instruments, to date, suggested for the GOOS programme were designed and built for specific earlier programmes and do not fulfil the rigorous requirements and sensor carrying capacity required today and in the future. Together with a EU consortium we are addressing this problem and intend to specifically design and construct a fully packaged and palleted state-of-the-art towed sensor system for shipof-opportunity deployments for measurement of upper ocean environmental variables and
120 transference of data collected onboard by satellite, or other communications, to shore. An EU award has allowed us to establish partners and a concerted programme for submission to MAST IV. This new towed system will be based on the systems developed and constructed by Chelsea Instruments since the early 1980's. These systems have been developed along with UK's leading oceanographic laboratories to meet the growing requirement for versatile cost effective data gathering and the incorporation of emerging sensor technologies.
2. P R O C E D U R E S The main design criteria of this self contained unit is its own winch, cable, power supply, PC and satellite / communications package with a minimum size footprint, palleted for ease of handling and use onboard ship. The target is to construct a 'friendly' portable system which can be easily fitted to the stern quarter of a vessel, fully operated by one person and integrated into other deck sensors and activities. The vehicle will be designed for maximum depth and undulation amplitude attainable at maximum towing speed with vehicle stability at top speeds (20 knots). Currently the Nv-Shuttle (Burt, 1995), on which this development will be based, offers improved hydrodynamic performance, enlarged instrumentation space and sensor capacity over previous vehicles together with a l.t-processor servo mechanism and mission management system which integrates flight control and sensor data acquisition (Figure 1). The new-style construction of stainless steel space-frame, poly-propylene cladding, moulded nose and tail fairings, has evolved iteratively through design modifications and engineering trials over the last three years and will form the basis of the new development. The robust space frame has been adopted to provide ease of access to the payload bay. In the present system it is capable of accommodating the new generation of mechanical, optical and acoustic plankton counters, comprehensive optical suites and in situ chemical sensors as well as temperature conductivity and depth; this will also be the case for the new body. The Nv-Shuttle, with its enhanced hydrodynamic performance can undulate from the surface to 75 m at 10 knots on typically 250 m of unfaired 8mm o.d. steel cable with no additional diving planes ("wings"). With faired cable it can be towed to operational depths of 150 m. The data from the physical, chemical and biological sensors, resolved to a depth of 0.25 m, can be logged in situ or transmitted up to the towing cable to a ship-board computer using a power line modem. The standard cable for use will be the Rochester 7-H-314A (high strength) cable, which has a 8.2 mm diameter and is available with seven cores to enable the installation of demanding sensor suites. The present power line modem only requires two electrical conductors within the tow cable for power, vehicle control and data transfer, leaving five cable elements available for new sensor technology.
121
The operator will be able to control the vehicle using the CI AQUASOFT environment through a shipboard PC. The l.t-processor will log the flight parameters for the vehicle throughout the undulation, such as body depth, pitch, roll, tail plane angle, towing bridle angle, altemator speed and voltage, and controller characteristics. These data can then be used to adjust the flight pattem for future missions to achieve revised performance. This, in theory, will enable the mission controller to perform flight pattern revisions in real time at any stage of the deployment; this will be implemented in the new system. Data from the sensor suite can be transmitted to the ship in real time, displayed, stored for post trial analysis, compressed and transmitted to shore or stored within the vehicle. Position data from the ship's navigation system can also be incorporated along with input from deck sensors. The operational philosophy and capability of this vehicle will be to obtain, in its ship-ofopportunity mode, high-resolution, quasi-synoptic measurements, of regular seasonal/annual coverage, unobtainable by conventional research ship methods. The project addresses the aim of communicating data up the cable to a shipboard computer to be relayed by satellite, to a shore base. Operationally, this system can provide measurements of physical and biogeochemical processes and fluxes on basin scales. The vehicle can cover distances up to 900km per day on high speed merchant ships. This scale of measurement, surveyed quasi-synoptically, is complementary, to the scales observed in daily satellite imagery of the oceans (wave height, altimetry, sea surface temperature and water colour). In this mode the vehicle will provide the added dimension of vertical structure, with depth ranges from 5 to 40 m at 5 to 8.5 m s -~ on unfaired towing cable providing unique synergy with satellite large area observations. 3. SENSORS
With a versatile, but obviously finite payload any current and future sensors for this new vehicle need to be small size, low power consumption, reliable rugged construction and with stable electronic sensing and output signals compatible with low-power logging or computer systems. The programme is aimed at specifically investigating the reduction of sensor power demand (some applications may rely on in situ battery packs), operation in high flow rate regimes and pressure cycling during undulating. The new generation of sensors such as the Fast Repetition Rate Fluorimeter and optical particle analysers are currently bulky and relatively power hungry. These will be minituarised in future but there is a current requirement to accommodate them in existing measurement programmes. The incorporation of up and downwelling irradiance sensors, particularly in the SeaWiFS bands, is very important for assessing satellite or remote imagery. Obtaining the optical attenuation coefficients of the water and its reflectance above and below the water is essential. The attitude performance of the vehicle must be known to correct the angular response of the sensors. An overall modular approach will be taken to allow inter-changeability of sensors. Of particular importance is the type and suitability of underwater connectors in such a highly energetic environment.
122 4. R E C E N T D E P L O Y M E N T S OF CI SYSTEMS Many of these towed CI systems are now in use world-wide in environments ranging from shallow inshore areas to blue water areas by commercial, academic and military users. Data from some of the current towed vehicles in operation around the world are used to demonstrate performance, endurance, and sensor carrying capacity of the present vehicles and to illustrate what can be achieved from such a development. During 1995/96 Nv-Shuttle has been deployed in several major oceanographic cruises in the Mediterranean Sea (HMS BEAGLE), the Arabian Sea and Indian Ocean (RRS DISCOVERY and the University of Washington R/V THOMAS G THOMPSON), the Equatorial Pacific (IRONEX II, R/V MELVILLE) and the Atlantic Meridional Transect (AMT) (Robins, et al. 1996; Robins & Aiken, 1996) on the British Antarctic Survey vessel RRS JAMES CLARK ROSS from the UK to the Falklands. The IRONEX II cruise, an iron fertilisation experiment, in the Equatorial Pacific south of the Galapagos Islands, featured the first ever deployment of a Fast Repetition Rate Fluorimeter (FRRF) in situ, in an Undulator (CI's Nv-Shuttle), providing measurements of photosynthetic parameters through the surface, iron-fertilised layer, down to the deep chlorophyll maximum at 70-80m. It was agreed by all participating scientists, that the FRRF/Nv-Shuttle combination provided a unique data set which made a totally original and fundamental contribution to understanding the factors controlling photosynthetic processes in the IRONEX-2 experimental patch (Behrenfeld, in press). Nv-Shuttle and Aquashuttle are being used on the Atlantic Meridional Transect, UK to Antarctica (Robins, et al 1996). The cruises in 1995/96 form part of a series of Atlantic transects over three years to acquire data for calibration of remotely sensed observations, in particular the validation of remote sensed products (chlorophyll concentration etc.); the development of whole-water column algorithms; the interpretation of remote sensing observations; the determination of phytoplankton characteristics and photosynthetic parameters; relationship of the partial pressure of CO2 in surface waters with biological production; identify nutrient regimes; and characterise plankton community structure, including the accurate determination of carbon values in accordance with Joint Global Ocean Flux Study (JGOFS) protocols. The ship used for this programme was the RRS JAMES CLARK ROSS. The shuttles were towed for most of the transect giving a full Atlantic section of key parameters such as temperature, chlorophyll and salinity. The primary objective of this research was to investigate basic biological processes in the open Atlantic Ocean over very broad spatial scales (50~ to 50~ covering 12,000 km). This is fundamental for the calibration, validation and understanding of remotely sensed observations of biological oceanography. It is also important for understanding
123 plankton community structure over latitudinal scales and the role of oceans in global carbon cycles. The programme also attempts to meet the needs of international agencies (e.g. NASA, NASDA & ESA) in their implementation of 'Sensor Intercomparison and merger for Biological and Interdisciplinary Ocean studies (SIMBIOS)', a programme to develop a methodology and operational capability to combine data products from the various ocean colour missions. In the longer term, the AMT project aims to enhance our ability to model global primary production, at basin scales, and to develop ecosystem dynamics models which will be important to our ability to forecast change. These examples are given for research cruises utilising towed vehicles to effectively obtain all their primary data. The gain from using this strategy on ships or craft-ofopportunity is enormous and should be pursued vigorously. To bring together the 'state of the art' marine technology to investigate oceanographic processes at the basin scale provides a unique opportunity to improve our understanding of biological oceanography and interpretation of remote sensing. REFERENCES 1. Behrenfield, M.J., Bale, A.J., Kolber, Z.S., Aiken, J. and P.G. Falkowsku (in press). Confirmation of Iron limitation of phytoplankton photosysnthesis in the equatorial Pacific Ocean. Nature. 2. Burt, R., 1995. Nv-Shuttle: A towed oceanographic vehicle development under the DTI SPUR Programme. Undulations, 5:2-4. 3. Robins, D.B., & J. Aiken, 1996. The Atlantic Meridional Transect : An oceanographic research programme to investigate physical, chemic'd, biological and optical variables of the Atlantic Ocean. Und. Tech. 21 (4): 8-14. 4. Robins, D.B., Bale, A.J., Moore, G.F., Rees, N.W. + 6 authors. 1996. AMT-I Cruise Report and Preliminary Results. NASA Tech. Memo. 104566, Vol. 35 S.B. Hooker and E.R. Firestone, Eds., NASA Goddard Space Flight Centre, Greenbelt, Maryland, 87pp. 5. Gamble, J.C., & H.G. Hunt, 1992. The Continuous Plankton Recorder: a long-term basin-scale oceanic time series. In. Proceedings of the Ocean Climate Data Workshop, 18-21 Feb. 1992. NASA Goddard Space Flight Centre, Greenbelt, Maryland, pp. 277-293. 6. Williams, R., 1995. Evaluation of new techniques for monitoring and assessing the health of Large Marine Ecosystems. pp.257-272, NATO ASI Series, 128, Evaluating and Monitoring the Health of Large-Scale Ecosystems, Ed. D.J. Rapport, C.L. Gaudet, and P. Colow, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
124
Figure 1. The Nv-Shuttle towed undulating vehicle on which the new development will be based offers improved hydrodynamic performance, enlarged instrumentation space and sensor capacity together with la-processor servo mechanism and mission management system which integrates flight control and sensor data acquisition.
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Development of METNET-
125
An Operational Offshore Meteorological and
Oceanographic Data Network Ian Leggett a, Ian Bellamy band Frank Dolan b a UESC/9, Shell U.K. Exploration and Production, 1 Altens Farm Road, Aberdeen AB 12 3FY b InstallOcean Ltd, 5 Omega Park, Alton, Hants GU34 2QE
Shell U.K. Exploration and Production (operator in the U.K. sector of the North Sea for Shell and Esso, hereinafter referred to as Shell Expro) has a continuous requirement for the display of accurate meteorological and oceanographic (metocean) data on its offshore platforms and at onshore bases to assist with the safety and efficiency of operations. With a requirement to replace many of the existing metocean stations on its offshore platforms Shell Expro has taken advantage of PC based technology and the existing Shell telecommunications network (STN) to develop a real-time metocean data network (METNET) unique in the offshore industry. This paper outlines the reasons for METNET, gives details of the system's development and its benefits, and looks to potential future enhancements. It also highlights some areas of potential concern associated with the automation and networking of metocean systems.
1. T H E R E A S O N S F O R M E T N E T
The North Sea can experience some of the worst metocean conditions in the world, including severe winter storms, cold temperatures and fog. Extreme conditions such as these will clearly have an impact on offshore operations, but it should also be appreciated that more 'typical' North Sea conditions can affect activities as well. The main types of offshore operations affected by metocean conditions include: 9 9 9 9 9 9
Helicopter flying and helideck operations. Vessel activities. Crane lifts. Tanker loading. Drilling. Diving.
Each one can only take place safely within certain metocean limits which vary depending on the particular operation. For example, helideck operations cease when wind speeds exceed 60
126 knots, but crane lifts cease when they exceed only 40 knots; vessel activities around platforms are generally limited to significant wave heights of less than 5 m. With many routine daily operations having the potential to be disrupted by the prevailing metocean conditions, Shell Expro recognised the importance of ensuring that key offshore and onshore personnel have access to as much metocean data as is necessary in order to : 9 Plan operations as safely and efficiently as possible. 9 Ensure objective decision making during weather sensitive operations. and as a result the requirement for a real-time metocean network was established.
2. T H E M E T N E T S Y S T E M
2.1. Overview The development of METNET has been driven essentially by the requirement to enhance the safety and efficiency of Shell Expro's daily operations. The key elements in this development have been: 9 9 9 9 9 9 9
Upgrading and/or installation of metocean stations on all manned platforms. Standardisation of metocean sensors, computer hardware and software. Setting up metocean data links within the STN. Reliability of data sources, including the availability of back-ups. Availability of data in real-time for offshore and onshore users. Rapid updating of information. User friendly display (and logging) of information.
As Shell Expro's operations essentially take place in 3 main geographical areas (Northem, Central and Southern North Sea), the development of METNET has mirrored this. Thus there is a METNET North, METNET Central and METNET South all linked to a hub in Shell Expro's Aberdeen base. Work on the offshore part of METNET began in October 1993, followed by the onshore part in 1994. Implementation of the complete network is well advanced with 15 offshore stations currently operational of which 11 key stations are sending data back to Aberdeen at 1 minute intervals as follows (see Figure 1): 9 METNET North - Brent A, Cormorant A, Dunlin A and North Cormorant. 9 METNET Central -Auk, Fulmar, Gannet and Kittiwake. 9 METNET South - Clipper, Leman and Sean.
127
M E T N E T STATIONS IN TIlE N O R T H SEA
. . . . . . . ,,',.
~'~'~cD
g
NORWAY
~
60o
9
een
ee/r~/e~8~
/
n (;itnnet
C~ceanroute Abet'dee,* s~ ~
A
~JZulmu r A i .~ ]"L
,
, / o ' ~ ~-~ UNITED
Shell
KIN[GDOM
Expro
HOLLAND Leman
A:- Reporting
Station
B r e n t C:- N o n R e p o r t i n g S t a t i o n Metocean Telecommunications
Figure 1.
Link
r
128
2.2. Typical Offshore System Each platform is equipped with a basic metocean station capable of measuring wind speed and direction, air temperature and barometric pressure. The data is gathered and logged on the platform using a Hewlett Packard (HP) 382 work station hosting a HP75000 data logger. The key stations noted above also have a variety of additional sensors to measure wave height and period, wave direction, cloud height and visibility, and the following table shows the distribution of these sensors by platform: Platform
Wave Height and Directional Wave Period Data Brent A Yes No Cormorant A No No Dunlin A No No Cormorant N Yes Yes Kittiwake Yes No Gannet Yes No Auk A Yes Yes Fulmar A No No Leman A Yes No Sean P Yes No Clipper Yes No Table 1. Wave, Cloud and Visibility Sensor Availability
Cloud Horizontal Height Visibility Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes No No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No by Platform
The HP382 performs all the data processing and quality control checks as well as handling all the necessary telecommunications requirements. A schematic of a typical platform system is provided in Figure 2.
Figure 2. Typical Offshore Metocean Data Collection Schematic
129
2.3. Data Distribution 2.3.1. Platform Based Data is distributed to users around each platform every minute using a simple 2 wire RS-232 asynchronous communication link to 'Remote Display Units' (RDU). The latter are in fact dedicated PC's running purpose-built data display software. Each data packet consists of 40 values which contain the metocean parameters most commonly used. Each RDU can be separately configured to display data in a number of different formats, e.g. 9 parameter box display, helideck graphic display, 3 parameter real time graph display. Additionally each RDU stores data at 10 minute intervals so that historical data listings and graphs can be called up. 2.3.2. Offshore to Onshore Data from each key station is sent to Aberdeen at 1 minute intervals using the existing STN and it is received by a specialised UNIX workstation. The purpose of this UNIX workstation is to collect all data and redistribute it as required. The UNIX workstation runs specially designed software written in 'C' to collect data on an interrupt basis at 1 minute intervals. Each offshore station is assigned a dedicated 'process' which is controlled by an ASCII based set-up file. This set-up file tells the process how to configure the incoming data stream, where it should be sent to and any other relevant aspect. A schematic of the inter-platform and shore network is shown in Figure 3. 2.3.3. Onshore to Offshore The UNIX workstation process can also send data from Aberdeen to offshore platforms. This is undertaken at 1 minute intervals using the existing STN. The data is received offshore by the RDU' s and can be displayed alongside data from that platform's own system. A maximum of 4 stations can be sent offshore using a combined data stream approach i.e. each platform offshore only requires one telecommunications connection to Aberdeen. This enables personnel on one platform to view the metocean conditions at several other platforms nearby. 2.3.4. Onshore Shell Expro One of the primary reasons for the establishment of METNET was to enable personnel within the Shell Expro offices in Aberdeen to access metocean data in near real time. All incoming data on the UNIX workstation is processed into a 40 channel RDU compatible ASCII file and stored in the master sub directory on the workstation. The RDU software used by personnel in the Shell Expro offices has been modified to read data from a file as well as data sent over an asynchronous link. The file is read over the existing Shell Expro onshore LAN using NFS gateway software. 2.3.5. Onshore Third Parties A number of third parties receive metocean data from Shell Expro in near real time (at least every 10 minutes) These include the Rijkswaterstaat (Directie Noordzee), Oceanroutes (Shell Expro's weather forecast contractor) and the U.K. Met Office. At present the data is distributed in a semi fixed format which is controlled by the set-up file.
130
Figure 3. METNET data Distribution Network
2.4. Data Display/Logging Data is displayed in a variety of different tabular and graphical formats to suit the users individual requirements. Special aviation format screens have also been provided to enable users to 'see' 4 platforms at the same time. The displays are fitted with a 2 stage preset alarm threshold system so that when parameters exceed a certain value they change colour. A 'traffic light' colour scheme has been adopted using amber for the first stage and red for the second stage. Normal conditions are indicated by blue. Processed data is stored on both the hard disc and floppy disc of the main HP computer system at hourly intervals. Raw data is stored when certain 'storm' threshold conditions have been exceeded. Additionally data is logged by the remote displays at 10 minute intervals so that historical graphs together with a data grid can be made available for a maximum of the last 30 days.
131 3. B E N E F I T S OF METNET
3.1. General METNET constitutes a considerable investment for Shell Expro However the Company recognises that such investment is necessary to enhance operational safety and decisionmaking. A more detailed list of the benefits of METNET is provided in the following sections. 3.2. Ease of Use and Objective Decision-Making The display software has been designed to provide the user with a simple to use, yet powerful and flexible means of viewing metocean data. This has been achieved by developing a number of standard 'screens' to present the information both in tabular and graphical format. Additional tailor-made screens have also been produced to satisfy particular requirements. All controls are mouse-driven obviating the need for a keyboard. The tabular displays also have 2 alarm thresholds to assist with objective and consistent decision-making during weather-sensitive operations. 3.3. Networking of Data The exchange of data between platforms provides a back-up data source in case of problems on any one individual platform. The use of networking also leads to optimisation of sensors whereby expensive (e.g. cloud height and directional wave data) sensors do not have to be installed everywhere but can be shared amongst platforms. The provision of data from offshore to onshore helps to improve weather forecasts by providing the forecasting contractor with real-time site specific data. 3.4. Accuracy and Comparability of Data The use of a common suite of Shell Expro recommended sensors, hardware and software provides data that is not only as accurate as possible, but also ensures comparability between platforms. 3.5. Data Logging Whereas the ability to log data onto floppy and hard disks is not of direct benefit to daily operations it is of considerable importance for data quality and metocean studies as follows: 9 Quality control of all data. 9 Inter comparison of data between platforms. 9 Incident analysis. 9 Long term database. 9 Operational statistics. 9 Design criteria. 9 Climate variability. 3.6. Maintenance and Spares The standardisation on field-tested and fully proven sensors and computer hardware and software together with standardised system architecture reduces the number of spares which must be held, and also reduces the frequency and duration of offshore maintenance visits.
132
3.7. Reduction in Operating Costs All of these benefits translate into improved information offshore, enhanced safety and reductions in operational costs.
4. C O N C E R N S Despite the fact that METNET is a fully operational system providing valuable data for daily operations, a number of concerns have arisen which occasionally impact on its use and availability: 9 The METNET system is reliant on the STN to carry data. Whilst, in general, this is a very reliable system, data losses over the network do occur at random intervals. 9 There is a danger that with so much data available to the user then the '2 watch' syndrome may arise. This is where 2 adjacent sensors give different results. In the majority of cases it is for very valid reasons, but users need to be educated in understanding and interpreting the data. 9 The reliability of some sensors, in particular 'optical' devices such as cloud height and visibility sensors is less than satisfactory.
5. F U T U R E Future plans for METNET include: 9 The completion of the network for manned platforms by end 1996. 9 Potential extension of METNET to unmanned platforms, mobile installations, jack-up rigs etc. 9 Incorporation of weather forecasting information in the METNET PC display. 9 Dissemination of data to more third party users. 9 Potential collaboration with other offshore operators, and similar EU initiatives.
6. C O N C L U S I O N S Present computer technology has enabled detailed metocean data to be presented to a growing community of offshore and onshore users in presentation formats tailored to their individual requirements. This ensures objective and consistent decision-making during weather-sensitive operations. The operational, scientific and strategic usefulness of the data has been enhanced by standardising equipment, logging of data, and establishing an infrastructure for data exchange between platforms. METNET is providing a cost-effective solution for the networked monitoring of offshore weather conditions, and in this respect is an important tool to assist with safe working offshore.
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge for European Co-operation
edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
133
L o n g - t e r m Stable Sensors For Bio-Optical M e a s u r e m e n t s H. Barth, R. Heuermann, K. -D. Loquay, R. Reuter and U. Stute*
*Carl von Ossietzky University of Oldenburg, Physics Department, D-26111 Oldenburg
Hydrographic conditions are often characterised by large amounts of dissolved and particulate matter. These substances influence the optical properties of seawater, and the radiative transfer in the water column. Attenuation coefficient and fluorescence are optical parameters which depend sensitively on suspended and dissolved substances. These measurements are of interest in determining of absorbing, scattering and fluorescent matter. Two new probes have been developed for this approach: a multispectral attenuation meter and a multichannel fluorometer. Particular emphasis has been put on the long-term stability of the optical set-ups. Areas of application of these instruments are bio-optical and bio-chemical studies in estuaries and coastal zones as components of profiling probing systems or autonomous stations.
1. INTRODUCTION The measurement of fluorescent and absorbing matter in the water column is well-known in marine biology and chemistry. Prominent examples of optically detectable substances are gelbstoff (Coloured Dissolved Organic Matter, CDOM [3,9]), mineral particles, chlorophyll a and other phytoplankton pigments like phycoerythrin, phycocyanin and certain xantophylls (see, e.g., Yentsch and Yentsch [ 11 ]), but also aromatic amino acids bound to proteins in algae and bacteria [ 10,4] which can be detected with fluorescence and/or photometry. Identification of specific absorption and fluorescence bands of these substances with fluorescence (Heuermann et al. [6]) and attenuation measurements (Barth et al. [ 1]) requires a set of different excitation and emission wavelengths. If realised within a single probe, then the instruments can be utilised in different applications like, for example, biogeochemical studies of the carbon cycle, tracer experiments, pollution monitoring, and phytoplankton classification. To meet these requirements, two new instruments with a new conceptual design have been developed: a) a multi-wavelength in situ fluorometer, which includes 9
a 3-channel excitation that can be set at wavelengths in the UV and/or VIS, allowing a
9 9
specific excitation of fluorescent substances, a modular set-up of up to 10 detection channels at selectable wavelengths and, a design of the path of rays such that the requirements for optical stability of the signals and hence for in situ operation over extended periods of time can be met.
134 In Figure 1, excitation and emission wavelengths are given that are appropriate for carbon flux studies within JGOFS. To illustrate the meaning of these wavelengths, emission spectra of two algal cultures, the green algae Dunaliella and the red algae Porphyridium, are given in the same figure, displaying the fluorescence bands of their pigments. Samples of these cultures were not free of gelbstoff and bacteria, which explains the strong intensities of gelbstoff and tryptophan-like fluorescence. They demonstrate that the emission bands generally overlap in presence of many fluorophores. An evaluation of the signal intensity of a fluorescence band requires a careful subtraction of background signals from other fluorophores. This background correction can be performed if a sufficiently high number of detection wavelengths is available in that spectral range. This strongly supports the usefulness of a multi-wavelength fluorescence detection.
Figure 1. Position of detection wavelengths and information gathered at this wavelength with 270, 420 and 530 nm excitation. The underlying spectra were measured on cultures of the green alga Dunaliella and the red alga Porphyridium.
b) an in situ polychromatic attenumeter (PAAL), which measures the intensity loss of a near-parallel light beam along a light path r in water, yielding data on the total attenuation coefficient c. The wavelength-dependent coefficient c of Lambert's law dI/I = - c r is a composite of several terms which describe absorption and scattering by molecules and particles: C(~,) = Cw(~) + Cpp(~) + Ctp(~) + ad (~,)
[l/m],
(1)
where the indices w, pp and tp and d refer to contributions from water, phytoplankton, transparent particles, and gelbstoff and are shown in Figure 2. The term ad (~) is the gelbstoff absorption coefficient; scattering of this material is negligible, and only absorption needs to be considered.
135
RIVER ELBE, G E E S T H A C H T
J U L Y 6, 1994
DUNALIELLA
,rE
"~
"
~1~
MEASUREMENT
c(~) - cw (~) ........... cpp(~)
o E
o
o
Z
3
2~ Z U.i
1
"",..,..,,.\.\
- ....
010 Z
0 to 0
Z U.I 5
MEASUREMENT
7-
(J I-Z UJ 0 U_ It. LI.I
~15 o
LL LI..I
TERTIOLECTA
8
20
c ( ~ ) - c w 1~) .
6-
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
%ply.)
5 4 ....................
,\
x
0
~-~.. I
400
i'---~
500
....
x/nm
i ....
600
i
700
,
300
" 400
500
61)0 " 7()0
800
x/nm
Figure 2. Attenuation spectrum measured in situ in the German Bight (left) and with a laboratory culture of Dunaliella Tertiolecta (right). Reconstruction of the data is done with Eq.(1). The range of attenuation coefficients can vary by about 4 orders of magnitude from coastal waters to the open ocean. To avoid systematic errors of the measured data from this variability, an easy adaptation of the instrument to a path length suitable for a given application is required. Finally, transmissometers are mostly calibrated with purified water in the laboratory. In field applications this calibration can be degraded by sensor drift and by absorbing and scattering layers on the surface of optical windows: the growth of biogenic layers during phases of enhanced biological productivity limits the use of transmissometers for longterm applications. With the new transmissometer PAAL (Polychromatic Attenumeter with Adjustable Path Length), calibration is done in situ using a light path with variable length, with the further advantage of making the instrument suitable for applications in waters with a wide range of attenuation characteristics. Algorithms have been developed for the interpretation of data in terms of attenuating substances. During measurements, the concentrations of gelbstoff and suspended particulates are derived and displayed e.g. as depth profiles in real time. A more sophisticated algorithm can be utilised with stored data to differentiate suspended matter specifically into phytoplankton and non-chlorophyllous particles.
136 2. TECHNICAL REALISATION Both instruments consist of submersible probe housings with a maximum depth of operation of 6000 m and onboard control units which are connected by a single conductor cable of a winch to the deck unit or via a standard RS232 serial interface. A simultaneous operation of both probes is realised by using an underwater processing unit. 2.1. The Multi-wavelength Fluorometer Layout: A schematic diagram of the submersible part of the instrument is shown in Figure 3. It consists of the following modules:
power supply telem etry
detection assembly max. 10 modules
light source
probing
and
Figure 3. Schematic diagram of the underwater probe. Signal excitation is done at three wavelengths by irradiation of the measuring volume below the probe housing with optical fibres. Detection of scattered and fluorescent light is done with a set of optical fibres which are positioned in a way that their field of view and the outer surface of the optical window overlap. The detector assembly consists of 10 modules with individual optical filters for wavelength separation (Figure 1).
head
The light source: A short-arc flash lamp with fused silica bulb envelope for enhanced UV output is used and operated with 20 Hz repetition rate. Because of its short length of 1.5 mm, the arc can be considered a point light source from which three nearly-parallel light beams are derived, allowing a wavelength selection by use of interference filters. The light beams are coupled into optical fibres which connect the light source assembly to the probing head (Figure 3). The optical bandwidth (fwhm) of the interference filters is 10 nm typically. Although larger bandwidths would result in higher output intensities, and hence a better sensitivity of the instrument, the low values chosen are required for a sufficiently monochromatic excitation of water Raman scattering. A specific detection of water Raman scattering is given a high priority for the purpose of signal calibration, as discussed below in more detail. Because of the low Raman efficiency at 530 nm excitation, the fibres used for this and the 270 nm wavelength are combined using a bifurcated fibre bundle.
137 The detector modules: The detector assembly consists of 10 modules with identical mechanical and electronic layout, equipped with individual optical filters for definition of detection wavelengths. As with the light source assembly, the modular concept of these detection channels and the use of optical fibres for signal transmission provide a high flexibility and reliability, and an easy and stable optical adjustment of the entire set-up. In each module, wavelength selection of the fibre output is done by interference and glass blocking filters. Intensity of the spectral channel defined in this way is measured by small sized photomultipliers. The high voltage required for PMT operation can be set via telemetry from the onboard unit. This control circuit, the high voltage DC/DC-converter and the electronic circuitry for PMT signal processing are integrated into each detector module. In this way a maximum redundancy is obtained, since a defective detection channel would not lead to a malfunction of the entire probe. The probing head: The optical fibres from the light source assembly are fed to two probing heads for 270/530 nm and 420 nm excitation, respectively, positioned above two fused silica windows. Surrounding the excitation fibre and in a conical position with respect to it, the probing heads carry up to six detection fibres. This optical setup corresponds to a backscattering configuration, in contrast to the 90 ~ configuration of many other in situ fluorometers. The tilt angle of the detection fibres with respect to the excitation fibre is such that their fields of view coincide well outside the probe housing. The measuring volume depends on the light attenuation coefficients of the sea water which can be strongly variable. However, a determination of its actual size is not necessary, since the fluorescence readings are normalised to the intensity of water Raman scattering which is excited in the same measuring volume. This approach is generally done with hydrographic lidar data, again making use of the poor dependence of the Raman scatter efficiency on temperature and salinity variations (Chang and Young [2]; Marshall and Smith [8]). The fields of view of signal excitation and detection overlap completely on the outer surface of the optical windows. A common ray path of excitation and emission through identical windows then opens a way to correctly measured fluorescence intensities. This holds for signal losses which originate from absorbing layers on the window surface due to bacterial growth or organic films, provided the transparency loss remains moderate. These effects are again corrected by water Raman scatter normalisation. Moreover, these layers must be assumed to be free of fluorescent components. In this way, weak contaminations of window surfaces can be considered like other instrumental characteristics, e.g. variations of the lamp intensity. Thus, water Raman scattering is used to calibrate the sensitivity of the instrument with respect to long-term variations of instrumental parameters, and to correct the data for variations of the measuring volume due to variable turbidity of the water. When using excitation wavelengths above the blue part of the spectrum, however, the Raman efficiency is low, and a separation of this signal from underlying fluorescence - e.g. due to gelbstoff- becomes difficult. Therefore, the 530 nm excitation fibre is combined with the 270 nm excitation fibre and transmitted through the same optical window. Because of the broad spectral distance, fluorescence signals induced by these wavelengths do not interfere with each other, since the efficiency of phycocyanin and fucoxanthin is close to zero in the UV region.
138
2.2. The polychromatic attenumeter PAAL Layout: PAAL is a hydrographic probe designed to collect spectra of attenuation coefficients in the visible wavelength range. It can be used as a component of probing systems for depthprofiling use, or as a towed instrument for time-series measurements. The prototype consists of a cylindrical probe housing with two separate optical windows in the bottom. A motor-driven retroreflector can be set manually via telemetry or automatically at distances between near-zero and 200 mm from these windows (Figure 4), which allows to set the optical path length up to 400 mm. The main housing contains a flash lamp as the light source and an optical set-up to produce collimated light beams for the sample and reference signal detection. Signals are simultaneously measured in spectrally resolved form using two miniaturised grating polychromators.
Figure 4: Scheme of the polychromatic attenumeter with adjustable path length.
Light Source, optical path length and self-calibration procedure: The light source is a xenon flash lamp, with high emission intensity over the entire wavelength range of interest, which is operated with 2 Hz repetition rate. To achieve optimum performance, the path length r in water needs to be carefully adopted to the expected range of attenuation coefficients. For a good dynamics of the signal and hence high sensitivity of the instrument, r should be in the order of the inverse attenuation coefficient. To allow for an easy adaptation of the path length in water to a wide span of optical characteristics of the water, a movable retroreflector mounted on a threaded rod and driven by a motor is part of the instrument. The constraints of optical misalignments related to movable mirrors have been overcome by using a triple prism, yielding a 180 ~ reflection angle of the incident beam virtually independent of the angle of incidence. The instrument is calibrated in situ with signal readings I1 and 12 at two different optical path lengths in water, yielding c ( r 2 - r l ) = l n I 1 / I 2 . Instrumental factors like spectral characteristics and reflection losses cancel out. This holds also for the effect of optical windows contaminated due to bacterial films or other matter, which otten occurs during in situ operation. A calibration routine is performed prior to each measurement. During moored applications, measurements can be performed at selectable time intervals and initiated with the
139 same calibration routine, which allows long-term measurements with high stability of the data that are difficult to realise with conventional instruments.
Polychromatic spectrometers: An essential feature of the probe is to collect spectra in a single shot of the flash lamp. This is realised with polychromatic spectrometers from CARL ZEISS, Oberkochen, Germany, developed by this company in a subproject of the transmissometer development programme.
Substance specific attenuation spectra: When compared with instruments for single wavelength operation, the rationale of a multispectral transmissometer lies in the information content of the entire attenuation spectrum, from which substance specific features can be extracted (Eq. 1). In a second step, these features can then be related to relevant parameters, like e.g. the concentration of absorbing or scattering matter, if such relations exist and hold with sufficient accuracy. Within the accuracy of the instrument, the attenuation coefficient of water Cw is independent of salinity and temperature. Therefore, a spectrum of purified water, free of dissolved organic matter and particles due to active carbon and membrane filtration, is subtracted from the total spectrum c(###) as a first step of the data interpretation. With these assumptions, Eq. (1) can be written as c ( ~ ) - Cw (E) - OtCpp(~,) + 13Ctp(~) + ~/ad(~)
[l/m]
,
(2)
where the terms with asterisk denote are dimensionless spectral functions related to specific substances or substance classes as defined previously. The goal of the data interpretation is to determine the preceding factors ###, ### and ###, which describe the relative contributions of individual substances to the entire spectrum: these factors contain information on the substance concentration. The inversion of the spectra is done with the assumption that the optical properties of transparent and absorbing particles are known (van de Hulst [7]). The spectra are inverted with the ansatz of a particle size distribution of the Junge type, and an exponential wavelength dependence of the absorption coefficient of yellow substance (Barth et. al. [ 1]). A code has been developed for a real-time interpretation at high data rates, yielding information on the particle size distribution and on yellow substance. A more sophisticated Monte Carlo calculus, that can be used on stored data, allows to discriminate phytoplankton from other types of suspended matter. The same algorithm can be used e.g. in time series measurements on moored stations to derive detailed information on suspended particles and dissolved organic matter in time steps of minutes, that cannot be obtained with other methods.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Development of both instruments was supported by grants from the Federal Minister of Research and Technology, Bonn, within the frames of EUROMAR MERMAID and JGOFS. The polychromatic attenumeter PAAL was realized jointly with ME Meerestechnik Elektronik, Trappenkamp, Germany.
140
REFERENCES
1.
Barth H., Grisard K., Holtsch K., Reuter R., Stute U., 1997, A polycromatic in situ transmissometer for measurements of suspended particles and yellow substance in water, Appl. Optics, in press. 2. Chang C.H., Young L.A., 1974, Seawater temperature measurement from Raman spectra. Research Note 960, Avco Everett Research Laboratory, Everett, MA, January 1974, 82 pp. 3. Chen R.F., Bada J.L., 1992, The fluorescence of dissolved organic matter in seawater. Marine Chemistry, 3 7, 191-221. 4. Determann S., Reuter R., Wagner P., Willkomm R., 1994, Fluorescent matter in the eastern Atlantic Ocean. Part 1: method of measurement and near-surface distribution. Deep-Sea Research, Vol. 41, No.4, pp. 659-675. 5. Determann S., Reuter R., Willkomm R., 1996, Fluorescent matter in the eastern Atlantic Ocean. Part 2: vertical profiles and relation to water masses. Deep-Sea Research, Vol. 43, No. 3, pp. 345-360. Heuermann R., Loquay K.-D., Reuter R., 1995, A multi-wavelength in situ fluorometer for hydrographic measurements. EARSeL Advances in Remote Sensing, Vol. 3, No. 3 VII, pp. 71-77. van de Hulst H. C., 1974, Light Scattering by Small Particles, Wiley and Sons, New York, 470 pp. Marshal B.R., Smith R.C., 1990, Raman scattering and in-water ocean optical properties. Applied Optics, 299, 71-84. Mopper K., Schultz C.A., 1993, Fluorescence as a possible tool for studying the nature and water column distribution of DOC components. Marine Chemistry, 41,229-238. 10. Petersen H.T., 1989, Determination of an Isochrysis galbana algal bloom by L-tryptophan fluorescence. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 20, 447-451. 11. Yentsch C.S., Yentsch C.M., 1979, Fluorescence spectral signatures: the characterization of phytoplankton populations by use of excitation and emission spectra. Journal of Marine Research, 37, 3,471-483. .
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 1997 Elsevier Science B.V.
141
E G O S - E u r o p e a n Group on Ocean Stations A continuously operating Data B u o y p r o g r a m m e in the North Atlantic Lars G. Golmen NIVA, The Norwegian Institute for Water Research Nordnesboder # 5, 5005 Bergen, Norway Tel: -47 55 30 22 57, Fax: -47 55 30 22 51 e-mail:
[email protected]
EGOS; the European Group on Ocean Stations, is a joint European project for the acquisition of meteorological and oceanographic data in the North Atlantic Ocean. The data are telemetered in near real-time from data buoys via satellites to shore, and disseminated via GTS with minimum time-delay to met. centers for use in weather forecasting. Presently EGOS maintains a continuously operational network of 15-25 drifting data buoys and 6-7 moored buoys in the North Atlantic. Data quality is continuously monitored, and reports on the status of the program are issued each month by the Technical Secretariat of EGOS. Meteorological parameters are emphasized, but the sampling programme may be enhanced in the future to also include more oceanographic parameters, and it is anticipated that EuroGOOS may provide and support links to new users of buoy data from EGOS.
1. THE EGOS PROGRAMME EGOS, the European group on Ocean Stations, was established in 1988 with the objective to maintain an operational network of drifting and moored buoys in data sparse areas in the North Atlantic and to co-ordinate the deployment of drifting buoys provided by EGOS members, whenever needed. EGOS co-ordinates data dissemination and secures that data quality is adequately monitored. Information on the operational status of the buoys shall be provided to members and co-operating parties on a regular basis. The programme is managed by a committee, composed of one member from each of the participating states, and is based on voluntary contributions. EGOS has established a Technical Secretariat to coordinate the programme. A common fund to support its administrative activities including the Secretariat is managed by the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) on behalf of the EGOS management committee. The project is based on an exchange of Letters of Intent between the directors of the participating institutions or services. The cost of the purchase and operation of the drifting buoys have been estimated to GBP 26,000 per operational buoy year. This does not include deployment costs, as all buoys currently are deployed by ships of opportunity. Likewise the annual cost of operating the moored buoys have been estimated to GBP 100,000 per buoy station per year (EGOS 1996b).
142 As much of the operations are benefiting from voluntary support from several met. centra etc. it has been difficult to assess the exact figures. EGOS consists (1996) of the Denmark: Germany: Iceland: Ireland: The Netherlands: Norway: Sweden: United Kingdom:
following eight members: Danish Meteorological Institute German Weather Service Icelandic Meteorological Office Irish Meteorological Service Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute Norwegian Meteorological Institute Swedish Meteorological and Hydrologiccal Institute United Kingdom Meteorological Office
France (Meteo-France) is likely to become a new member in 1997. EGOS is an Action Group of the Data Buoy Co-operation Panel, DBCP, and co-operates closely with the World Meteorological Organization, WMO and the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission, IOC. EGOS meetings are held twice each year. The winter meetings are hosted by either WMO or IOC. Reports on the EGOS Drifting Buoy Programme are issued on a monthly basis in the EGOS Technical Document series. More comprehensive annual reports are also made, e.g. EGOS (1996a). Reports on technical and operational matters are also from time to time issued as EGOS Technical Documents, e.g. EGOS (1994).
2. T H E O P E R A T I O N A L
PROGRAMME
EGOS maintains a continuous operational network of drifting buoys at a level of about 15 to 25. Figure 1 shows the number of drifting buoys in operation at the end of each month during the period January 1993 - July 1996. A total of 20-30 buoys are deployed each year. The drifting buoys are expendable, and are not intended for recovery and reuse. However, some buoys that drift ashore are recovered and may be re-deployed after careful inspection and overhaul. The average operational lifetime for buoys in the EGOS Programme is in excess of 200 days, as is indicated by Table 1. Buoys drifting in the harsh environments in EGOS North tend to have a shorter lifetime than buoys drifting in calmer and warmer waters farther south. Table 1. Average operational lifetime for EGOS Drifting Buoys during the years 1990-1995. The lifetime is the period that operational data are available on the Global Telecommunications System (GTS). YEAR
LIFETIME
YEAR
LIFETIME
1990
128 days
1993
218 days
1991 1992
123 days 273 days
1994 1995
279 days
186 d a y s
In addition to the drifting buoys 7 moored buoys are operated in the North Atlantic to the west of the British Isles (Figure 2).
143
EGOS driffing buoys are deployed and operated in an area bounded by 25~ and 66~ latitude and usually between 45~ longitude and the European continent (see Figure 2). The buoys are deployed by ships of opportunity sailing from Iceland to the eastern coast of the United States, by ships en route from Denmark to the Cape Farewell and by ships sailing from United Kingdom to the Caribbean. Recently some buoys have been deployed from aircraft. The EGOS Programme is divided into two sub-programmes: EGOS North, for buoys deployed north of 50~ and EGOS South, for buoys deployed south of 50~ Because of its importance as a development area for cyclonic weather systems most of the Programme activity is in the EGOS North area.
Number of operational drifting buoys
.
[ ] EGOS SOUTH
1
Figure 1. The number of drifting buoys in operation during the period Jan. 1993-July 1996. The division between EGOS South and EGOS North is along 50 ~ N. Most buoys operate in the EGOS North Area. Various types of drifting buoys are used in the EGOS programme. Most common have been the Metocean FGGE type buoys, some with wind sensors. Buoys manufactured by CMR in Bergen are also used regularly. Recently some WOCE SVP-B drifters have been deployed. The EGOS buoy data are, in order of importance: 9 Air Pressure 9 Sea Surface Temperature 9 Air Pressure tendency 9 Wind Speed and Direction 9 Air temperature All of the EGOS drifting buoys report air pressure, pressure tendency and sea surface temperature. Most also report air temperature and a smaller number also report wind speed
144
and wind direction. Data reports all include the latest asynoptic observation; most also contain the last or last two synoptic observations, or contain stored information to enable synoptic observations to be generated. The moored buoys have a more comprehensive observing programme than the drifting buoys and include observations of humidity and significant wave height and period. They operate in the Eastern Atlantic, just off the European continental shelf, in water depths of 2000 to 3500 m. The drifting buoys transmit the data via the Argos System and the data are received at the Local Users Terminals (LUTs) in Oslo, Sondre Stromfjord and Toulouse and further disseminated via the GTS. See DBCP (1995a) for a presentation of the Argos system, and DBCP (1995b) for a guide to the GTS sub-system within Argos. By utilizing these three LUTs the data reception rate for the EGOS buoys is increased by more than 50%, relative to data reception based on a single LUT. Furthermore the time-gap with no data received because of the orbit configuration is substantially reduced. The number of independent (new) data reports from each drifting buoy is on the order of 20 per day. The time-lag between observation and data reception at the operational center varies considerably. Approximately 90% of all observations are received within 90 minutes with a mean time lag of approximately 30 minutes. Data retrieval for the moored buoys is via the Meteosat geostationary satellite operated by EUMETSAT. Data quality is monitored by the Icelandic Meteorological Office on a day to day basis. Weekly and monthly analyses and statistics are produced by at the UK Meteorological Office and are included in the EGOS Monthly Report. Table 2 presents statistics for Air Pressure data for various EGOS drifting buoys in the month of January, 1996. It is seen that the averages for biases generally are within a few tenths of a hectopascal, which may be considered very satisfactory. Table 2. Statistics for air pressure observations from EGOS drifting buoys in January 1996. See text below for explanation. WMO Id. No.
65594 44769 65581 44760 44742 44727 44728 44770 44763 44773 44774 44616 44613 44765 62694 44777 44761
Argos Id. No.
1252 1253 1299 2947 2953 2974 3024 3035 3O98 3132 3162 3318 3324 4178 9306 14733 14736
Number of observations
Bills hPa
Standard dev., hPa
% gross error
1669 1624 20 482 944 1293 1565 726 1545 1098 1366 1702 1302 1467 1750 535 819
-0.3 0.0 -0.3 -0.2 -0.7 -0.2 0.2 -0.1 0.1 -0. l 0.0 0.7 -0.3 -0.3 -0.6 -0.2 0.2
1.8 1.6 3.2 1.4 1.5 1.9 1.7 1.0 1.7 2.0 1.9 2.0 1.7 1.9 2.9 2.1 1.9
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 3 0
145
Explanation to Table 2: The column "Number of observations" shows the number of observations received at Bracknell via GTS during January, 1996. Identical observations having exactly the same positions, time and observed value have been eliminated, but the total includes similar reports, differing only by a small amount, received from the same Argos satellite overpass. This number may thus exceed the actual number of truly independent or new observations that may be in the range 500-700 per month. The column marked "Bias" gives the average observation of biases over the month relative to reference values provided by the UK numerical forecasting system (these are short-term forecasts or background fields). The background values have been interpolated to the observation position, but no interpolation has been made with regard to time; the validity time of the background field is the nearest synoptic hour (00, 06, 12, or 18 UTC). Corrections have been made for known biases in the background pressure fields and the resulting estimates of the observation biases are thought to be accurate to about + 0.5 hPa. The column headed "Standard deviation" gives a measure of the standard deviation in absolute (not relative) values of the differences of observations from the computed background values. The column headed "% Gross Errors" gives % of observations with gross error over the month. These observations differ from the computed background pressure field by 15 hPa which is far in excess of the likely background error. The statistics for bias and standard deviation are calculated excluding these observations. Information on dubious data and monthly quality statistics are distributed according to D B C P guidelines. The Icelandic Meteorological Office operates an automatic I N T E R N E T mail service "
[email protected]" to facilitate the exchange o f data quality information among users. If a buoy produces doubtful or erroneous data the Technical Secretary will, atter a consultation with the data quality services, act to have these sensor data removed from the GTS.
EGOS Drifting & Moored Buoys, July 31, 1996 (WMO numbers)
,j
60--
44768, ,4Jutlb
47ep64045 *
~p0,m
62105A62106'
44T 4771~
4477~
44774~ r
40--
30
44 ~Tb
"S ~
m
4477~
, Moored B u o ~ - ~
ItA?IRfIL
-60
-50
-
9DriVing Buoys ~1
t~ l t ~ l l l t i i t i t i i i i
-40
-30 -20 Longitude
-lO
o
lO
Figure 2. Map showing the position o f E G O S buoys in operation on July 31, 1996. The map covers some more than the main area o f interest to E G O S (see text).
146 3. TECHNICAL D E V E L O P M E N T S New developments, tests and evaluation are coordinated within EGOS by a Technical Subgroup. The main objectives of this group are to enhance the data network through improved quantity, quality and timeliness of data, reduced operating costs, and optimal use of the resources available. Some examples of recent activities are: 9 The evaluation of lower cost barometers for drifting buoys through laboratory tests and operational deployments. 9 The incorporation of a GPS receiver into a drifting buoy to provide buoy position as an inherent part of the data message. 9 The development and implementation of a comprehensive set of pre-deployment tests and calibration checks for drifting buoys. 9 Evaluation of alternative observing programmes. 9 Evaluating and performing deployments of drifting buoys from aircraft as an alternative to deployment from ships.
4. EGOS AND E u r o G O O S
EGOS may be relevant to EuroGOOS both due to its organizational and operational structure and to the fact that it represents nine years of successful multi-lateral co-operation between a number of European institutions. The present (Oct. 1996) number of members is eight (see Para. 1.3), but institutions from other countries may become members in the near future. Members mostly have been meteorological institutes but oceanographic institutions may be members as well. The main EGOS task is to provide meteorologists with near real-time observational data to be used in daily weather forecasting. The primary parameter is air pressure. Parameters already sampled by EGOS buoys should be relevant to EuroGOOS (Woods et al. 1996). But if some form of link between EGOS and EuroGOOS will be considered, other parameters than those presently sampled should be incorporated in the sampling programme, especially for the drifting buoys. These may be equipped with e.g. sub-surface sensors for monitoring the upper ocean. Enhancing the sampling programme of EGOS buoys to include more oceanographic parameters is practically feasible. But it will require more resources and funding, and more efforts must be laid on data quality monitoring of data which presently to a significant extent is performed voluntarily by the data users. At any rate the current organizational and operational structure of EGOS may form a solid platform onto build an oceanographic observational programme in those parts of the North Atlantic that will be of special interest to EuroGOOS.
REFERENCES 1. DBCP (1995a): Guide to data collection location services using Service Argos. Techn. Doc. No. 3, DBCP, Toulouse, 88 pp. 2. DBCP (1995b): Reference guide to the GTS sub-system of the Argos processing system. Techn. Doc. No. 2, DBCP, Toulouse, 62 pp.
147 3. EGOS (1994): Minimum Specifications and Guidelines for the Operation of EGOS Drifting Buoys (by W. Jones and T. Kvinge). EGOS Techn. Doc. No.88, CMR, Bergen, 23 pp. 4. EGOS 1996a: Annual Report 1995 of the European Group on Ocean Stations. EGOS Techn. Doc. No. 131, CMR, Bergen, 16 pp. 5. EGOS (1996b): Report on the EGOS management committee meeting held at the UK Met. Office, Beaufort Park, June 4-6, 1996. EGOS Techn. Doc. No. 142, CMR, Bergen, 11 pp. 6. Woods, J. D., H. Dahlin, L. Droppert, M. Glass, S. Vallerga and N. C. Flemming (1996): The Strategy for EuroGOOS. EuroGOOS publ. No. 1, Southampton Oceanography Centre, Southampton, UK.
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge for European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
148
U p p e r O c e a n M e a s u r e m e n t s Using The A u t o n o m o u s Profiling Vehicle ( A P V ) Kim McCoy* and D. Jacobs *Ocean Sensors, Inc. 9883 Pacific Heights Blvd., San Diego, CA 92121 Tel (619) 450-4630 Fax (619) 450-4640; Email:
[email protected] Website www.oceansensors.com The APV is a surface de-coupled autonomous multi-profile instrument. The small (<10 liters) free drifting device is useful for the acquisition of physical oceanographic data (CTD). Autonomous profiles of the water column have provided high resolution spatial and temporal data sets useful to ground truth Global Climate Models which use satellite based SST data. The moored configuration of the APV supports long-term physical and biologically important observations related to coastal and nearshore dynamics including upwelling and eddy variability. Observations made in shallow water (<100 m) provide data with temporal fluctuations in the surface and bottom boundary layers. The addition of RF transmission for data recovery and GPS for geographical position greatly reduce the logistics associated with the collection of large scale data sets. Data from free drifting deployments and moorings as shallow as 6 meters are presented. 1. ESTUARINE MONITORING DEPLOYMENTS Extended APV time series allow the long-term monitoring of coastal and estuarine dynamics. Small scale (<100 m) features are easily observed. A profile to 20 meters depth and return to surface can require less than 5 minutes. During this period one downward and one upward profile are obtained. Given a mean horizontal water velocity of say, 10 cm/sec , horizontal features of 20 meters length scale are easily resolved. DEPTtt TIME SERIES 16JUL96 SN335 0
-6
-----
0
20
1 40
TIME IMINUTESl
60
The data in Figures 1 and 2 represent an effort to resolve dynamics in shallow estuaries. Figure 1 is a time series plot of depth vs. time which demonstrates the ability to function in very shallow water. Figure 2 shows a 6 minute segment of the record from minute 38 to minute 44 where the APV is resident at the bottom. The surface gravity waves of approximately 50 cm amplitude are easily recognized in the bottom record. The instrument ~, deployed in such a manner, will resolve the
Figure 1. Dive cycles in shallow water ~The APV utilizes technology covered by domestic and foreign patents
149 BOTTOM TIME SERIES 16JUL96 SN335
horizontal advective processes as well as provide an indicator of the surface gravity wave field.
-4.3 -4.5
~1
,
IL,
AILI
Ill J, ,]
-4.7
With the addition of GPS and Radio Frequency Telemetry (RF) the APV can be set adrift at sea and allowed to meander with the currents. Surface or sub-surface velocity vectors result from the instrument remaining at the surface or at depth. The instrument collects data during the sub-surface vertical profiling periods and stores the data in RAM. The GPS provides global position information and the RF provides the ability to telemeter the data to a remote location (frequently to a ship).
~ I,n,J
D E P T H [m -4.9
P/fl I t~dll011kl'l,t IIllllll II 11! Illll?ll'l II, 1[I11~ I IT~I 1 !I T
-5.1 t .VE
1~ SSUR~ :IEL
-5.3
40
38
42 TIME [MINUTES]
Figure 2. Surface gravity wave signal in bottom pressure record S A L I N I T Y IPSU! 26.8 0
27
27.2
27.4
27.6
27.8
_
28
o __
28.2
28.4
28.6
I~le
i
.......f::! t
it ...... i
S A L I N I T Y O W I ' S I D E O F B A G A, DAY 9 31 J U L 1996
Figure 3. Salinity intercomparison (high gradient region) with Guildline Portasal The data in Figure 3 was collected in Saanich Inlet in Canada in support of long-term global CO2 monitoring efforts. The instrument (CTD and fluorescence sensors) was set adrift while tethered to a surface buoy, limiting excursions to 26 meters. Strong salinity and fluorescence gradients were observed throughout the water column due to local freshwater sources. Discrete water samples were collected at several depths. The samples were analyzed with a salinometer (Guildline Portasal) and compared with the APV salinity values. The results are graphically represented in Figure 3. The results are well within the expected values and demonstrated the ability to autonomously and accurately profile the water column. The implementation of the APV in the study greatly reduces the logistics while providing high quality data over extended un-attended periods. The combination of CTD and fluorometer
150
provides data sets which cross correlate phytoplankton primary production and physical parameters. The project will continue for the next several years with international funding from Japanese, Canadian and US sponsors.
2. USER SPECIFIED PROFILES
The data represented in Figure 4 is from a biological study of euphausiid vertical migration patterns. During the day the euphausiids typically remain in deeper water and migrate to the upper ocean during the night. The ability of the instrument to 'mimic' the euphausiid daily migrations greatly enhances the researchers ability to resolve points of interest. The APV may be programmed to suit the requirements of the research project. The maximum and minimum allowable depths, maximum elapsed time, low battery, etc. are all user selectable parameters.
Figure 4 demonstrates two separate profiles. Profile 1 is a shallow ,, v PRC~FILE -20 active hover with minimum depth set for .40-~ 10 meters and the DEPTH [m ] \ maximum depth of 20 \ -60 PR( IFILE ! ~. . . . meters. Profile 2 -80 specified 90 and 110 meter maximum and -100 minimum depths. The frequency of hover -120 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 control increases the TIME [MINUTES] closer the maxima and minima. In the interest Figure 4. User selected dive cycles in open water of energy conservation it is advised to reduce the active hover (maintain depth) periods. In both profiles the hover is terminated by reaching the maximum specified time of 40 minutes. The number of cycles and length of record is limited only by the available stored energy. Should the requirement arise, the operator may reprogram the APV via the RF link. 0
-
OCEAN SENSORS APV CYCLICAL DIVING
\
/
3. INSTRUMENT DYNAMICS The APV can easily be adapted to have a desired sink or rise rate between 0.05 and 40 cm/sec. Figures 5 to 8 show depth, temperature, chlorophyll and salinity respectively. Figure 5 demonstrates the repetitive nature of each dive cycle. The instrument slowly (1 to 2 minutes) becomes negatively buoyant. A gradual increase in the sink rate is observed. The terminal velocity is reached within the first few meters and continues until the end of the tether is reached at 24 meters depth.. Hysteresis is observed in the data between the up and down profiles due to the upward pointing sensor placement. A pump provided an increase in the
151
flow through the fluorometer. The CTD sensors provide accurate data during the upward profile without the aid of a pump. The dynamics between the instrument, tether, wind and current are very non-linear. Algorithms have been developed to aid the prediction of dive times (time to bottom and return to surface) with untethered vehicles. APV TEMPERATURE 01 AUG 96
APV DEPTH RECORD 01 AUG 96
I 1
-12
I
DEP~I -16
V
-20 -24
0
IJ
t ~
1 t
~J
~
200 SAMPLES
D:
tlVj
-20 -24
400
19 13 15 17 TEMPERATURE [I)EO C]
11
Figure 6. Temperature profiles showing differences between up and down profiles
Figure 5. Multiple dive cycles in shallow water during which CTD and chlorophyll data was collected APV CHI,OROPt tYI.I, 01 AIJG 96
APV SALINITY 01 AUG 96
iii!!
-12 DEPT -16
.
.
.
.
!
-2011111
-20 -24
t....... . . . .
.
.
0
5 CHLOROPHYLL
.
10
.
.
[micrograms/ml]
Figure 7. Chlorophyll profiles with pumped flow through the sensor
.
.
.
-24 427
28
SALT [PSU]
Figure 8. The strong salinity gradient is observable in high resolution profiles
17 1
29
152 4. S U M M A R Y
The APV has been demonstrated to be an effective tool for autonomously acquiring estuarine and coastal ocean data from remote locations over extended periods. The cost of data acquisition is significantly (factor of 10 to 100) decreased. The instrument is capable of routinely profiling as deep as 500 meters 100 times and proportionately more in shallower water (e.g. >500 times to 100 meters). The APV is a new tool which is being applied to a set of problems which have global significance. Special thanks to the University of Bremen, Scripps Institution of Oceanography, Institute of Ocean Sciences, University of Maryland, and Japan Electric Power Industry
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
REMSSBOT, integrated environmental e n v i r o n m e n t a l i n f o r m a t i o n sources
management
153
through
integrated
H. Niesing a, W. Roose a, J. C. Borst b and R. de Wolf ~ a M i n i s t r y of Transport, Public Works and Water Management, Directorate-General for Public Works and Water Management, Directorate Zeeland, P.O. Box 5014, 4330 KA, Middelburg, The Netherlands b National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management, P.O. Box 20907, The Hague, The Netherlands CEDS Leidschendam, P.O. Box 406, 2260 AK, The Netherlands
Physical and administrative entities related to environmental topics may vary locally to regionally. This is especially the case in oceanography. Managing this information, can be difficult and can cost a significant amount of time. One obstacle may be the lack of knowledge with regard to the information available in neighbouring administrative entities. For tackling these problems, REMSSBOT (Regional Environmental Management Support System Based on Telematics) will benefit from access to different information sources. The innovative aspect of the REMSSBOT system is that the administrative and environmental managers have access to one another's data on an independent base while maintaining control over their own data. This concept results in several linked databases which, though physically separated, appear as one. This so-called virtual database contains all metadata about the different databases. It is a catalogue in conformance with the guidelines of the Catalogue of Data Sources (CDS) developed by the European Environmental Agency. The REMSSBOT system consists of several elements: The Catalogue of Data Sources (CDS), different applications to search within the CDS, the possibilities to actual access the required information and a tool to handle the accessed information (GIS application). Together this is called the REMSSBOT demonstrator, which is implemented at the participating administrations. REMSSBOT is supported by the European Commission within the framework of the Telematics Application Programme (DG XIII). Public administrations of the regions Piemonte (Italy), Attica (Greece) and Scheldt (Netherlands & Belgium) participate in this project. This paper briefly describes the general project and goes into detail on the demonstrator for the river Scheldt.
1. INTRODUCTION Many local and regional environmental management boards, like those in the regions cooperating in REMSSBOT, are faced with the challenges of changing from management by topic and zone to the integrated management of larger areas and even cross border management. All public administrations have some form of information technology (IT)
154 systems supporting their activities. A lot of these institutions are already using information systems for environmental information registration and management, designed according to their needs and organisation. Although these systems are well operating individually, they are usually incompatible to each other and for this reason they lead to incompatible information. This resulted in incompatible systems and in many cases, incompatible information for each environmental topic as well as for management boards in different regions. Neighbouring administrations are not aware of each others information, activities etc. The question, "what information is available at which location?" becomes more important, especially in environmental management, as the environment is not caught by administrative boundaries. The obvious way to overcome these obstacles would be to design and implement a new IT system, which satisfies all user requirements at all local sites. In addition to the complexity and costs involved in such an effort, it would imply postponing any improvement in environmental management during the time that the new system is designed and implemented. Political and financial efforts to realise this would imply major investments, which are not realistic. The REMSSBOT system seeks an alternative method of assisting the local and regional authorities with the implementation of integrated management, by deploying a telematic solution. This solution is based on a catalogue in conformance with the guidelines of the
Catalogue of Data Sources (CDS) of the European Environmental Agency (EEA). The CDS implemented in the REMSSBOT system describes the information which is available at certain location (the so-called meta-data) and provides IT systems with the automated procedures to access the actual information (an extension to the CDS). The supporting tools allow users to navigate through the catalogue and explore information sources regardless environmental topic and location. The information which becomes available, regardless type and format, must be compatible to the existing software. The main goal of REMSSBOT is to contribute towards a better integrated environmental management in the future. Another important aspect of REMSSBOT is that data providers will maintain control of their database, as the available information can only be viewed and retrieved but not modified in the original database.
2. MAIN OBJECTIVES OF REMSSBOT The main objectives of the REMSSBOT system are to: 9 Stimulate integrated environmental management development, with the system under consideration, rather than geographically determined boundaries such as land frontiers, as the central basis of policy plans. 9 Share experiences, knowledge and all types of information on environmental topics between administrations and their water managers concerned with an ecosystem. 9 Develop an environmental management support system which can be used for a wide variety of environmental topics and management levels. 9 Facilitate the search for, and access to, specific environmental data by several well developed navigation systems. 9 Increase velocity and quantity of environmental information available through the use of REMSSBOT.
155
9 Develop a capability for the implementation of different types of integrated environmental information management through the use of a catalogue of data sources. 9 Disseminate widely, all types of publicly available environmental information concerning the ecosystem.
3. R E G I O N A L F I E L D S O F A P P L I C A T I O N In the three regions, different types of environmental problems occur. The R E M S S B O T system will be an important supporting tool. The regional administrations with their specific management topics are: 9 In Italy, in the region Piemonte, public administration officers involved in the management of the administrative and technical procedures of industrial plants will be supported. These plants have information concerning the risk of accidents caused by specific industrial activities related to relevant quantities of hazardous substances. 9 In Greece, to support the local environmental managers in the Attica region, several measurement points in the regional area will be integrated into a system to show conditions on air quality, solid waste disposal and bathing waters. 9 In the Dutch and Flemish part of the river Scheldt catchment area, water managers and policy makers will be informed about the ecological functioning of the water system. Accessing the databases of neighbouring administrations (with measured parameters), documents (projects, investigations etc.) and maps (geographical reflection of the measured parameters in a certain area) are the main issues.
4. S C H E L D T A P P L I C A T I O N OF R E M S S B O T
4.1. Environmental problems in the Scheldt region The source of the Scheldt river is situated in Northern France, near Gouy-le-Catelet and just north of Saint-Quentin. The river, which is about 350 km long, flows through France, Wallonia, Flanders and the Netherlands and reaches the North Sea between Vlissingen and Breskens. The estuary is situated downstreams of Gent (length: 160 km). This part consists of a fresh water, a brackish and a salt water zone. Some 11 million people live in the catchment area (Santbergen, 1994). The river Scheldt is of great importance for a wide variety of uses, such as fishing, agriculture, shipping, industry, drinking water and recreation. For centuries, these activities have benefited from the river basin. During the last decades, however, the development of the economical interests has increasingly become in conflict with the ecological functioning of the system. The high number of inhabitants, the high degree of industrialisation and the agricultural use of a large part of the area resulted in a considerable pressure on the river ecosystem. The ecological problems in the Scheldt basin are partly due to the enclosure of wetlands for
156 agricultural use and, more recently, for a wider variety of industrial and port related, urban, safety and recreational purposes. As a result of this, the river Scheldt is, unfortunately, still one of the most polluted river systems in Western Europe (Meire, 1993).
4.2. Integrated water management approach During the last decades it became more clear that changes designed to serve sectoral interests have also resulted into the to river's degradation. Fortunately, awareness is growing that a balanced and equal freshwater distribution, and the quality and functioning of aquatic systems is the joint responsibility of riparian states that share these systems. The idea of an integrated water system approach for policy making which goes beyond human borders, is growing. In the Scheldt sub-project, the river basin approach for integrated river basin management is the basic concept. The most important concept in integrated water management is that the water system is the central issue in this approach. A water system is a geographically defined area, a hydrological unit containing all the necessary elements for the proper functioning of the system. This includes the ground and surface water, the soil, and the banks or shores as well as the surrounding countries and everything related thereto. In order to manage a transboundary water system in an appropriate way, a main issue is the access to all kinds of information and the integration of such information to make a common policy. This is important for a variety of activities such as international policy making and research or monitoring of the (ecological) state of the considered system.
5. D E M O N S T R A T O R The demonstrator is the first realisation of using all components of the REMSSBOT system at different locations for the use of the water manager. Central element in the REMSSBOT system is the Catalogue of Data Sources (CDS) developed by the European Environmental Agency (EEA). The Catalogue of Data Sources (CDS) is a database providing metadata from different providers participating in REMSSBOT. The CDS gives information about the type of data that is available at a specific location and provides IT systems with the automated procedures to gain access to the actual information. The system allows users to navigate through the catalogue and to explore information sources, regardless of the environmental topic and location. The CDS provides an overview of all available data about the chosen subject (tables, documents, maps etc.), the so-called metadata. The disposal of the metadata occurs by means of keywords, a tree search system and a zooming system based on geographic co-ordinates. There should be an easy integration of the information, which means that, whenever possible, information should be presented in a format that can be understood by the user. Especially when the information comes from different data providers, conversions to a standardised format may be needed. This information can be used by water managers by using several applications at the administration locations. These applications, together with the CDS and the connected databases, form the REMSSBOT demonstrator. Water managers at different levels or
157
locations, will use one specific application more often than the another one. Within the demonstrator, realised at different places, the next applications will be realised:
9 A Search Information System (SIS) application gives broader and better search possibilities and access to various types of data and from different sources. This system gives access to detailed information (measured data, maps, documents) for professionals working at the participating administrations. There is no public access to this information. 9 A GIS application (Schelde GIS) produces geographical maps reflecting the water quality by showing the concentrations of a chosen parameter (e.g. a nutrient or metal). This application depends on spreadsheets with the most recent measured parameters from the different administrations. These data are delivered by the administrations participating in the project. 9 The Flemish Environmental Agency and the Scheldt Information Centre (SIC, formed by various parties, amongst which the Rijkswaterstaat, the National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management and the Province of Zeeland) will use REMSSBOT to connect their WWW server, which informs any organisation and institute (libraries, universities, etc.) about the general and specific activities of the administrations in the Scheldt region.
6. T E C H N I C A L C O N C E P T OF R E M S S B O T The main objective of REMSSBOT is the sharing of environmental information, not by building a centralised data warehouse, but by keeping the data at its original location and connecting these separate databases. This means that REMSSBOT is, in fact, a logical data warehouse, but that the physical location of the data remains as it is. The user should be able to identify the information available at a certain location and retrieve the information. There should be a transparent access to the information source at the regional data provider's location. Information may even need to be accessed in parallel from several sources (Data Provider) to serve the user's request. The user can find out where the required information comes from, but it is not necessary to know this in order to access the information. The REMSSBOT system defines several types of services: R-Information (description of environmental information for which the data provider must be contacted). R-Product (documents, spreadsheets, flat files, HTML pages, maps that can be downloaded) R-Process (structured (tabular) data from the contributing data providers' databases). REMSSBOT defines an underlying layer of services, the elementary services, which rely on object oriented technology, in particular on CORBA (Common Object Request Brokering
158 Architecture). These services are designed to accomplish tasks such as data retrieval, filtering and the communication between the CDS and the data provider (Lievens et al, 1996)..
7. E X P E C T E D R E S U L T S The following results of the REMSSBOT project are expected: 9 The disposal of digital information and metadata can facilitate searching for documents and data, using keywords, co-ordinates or a tree search system, even when this is within the department or organisation itself. 9 The data level within REMSSBOT has a wide range. It varies from rude measurement values, experiment and investigation reports to policy papers. The environmental issues which makes the contents of the system also varies within the three regional sub-projects. The users require this broad scope, in order to be able to apply REMSSBOT on several levels and topics of environmental management. The users have different interests, but although the type of data varies enormously, the concept remains the same. The concept is which data is available about an item, where it is and how does it become available. The fact that REMSSBOT has a broad scope of contents and users is a challenge which can demonstrate the strength of the concept used by REMSSBOT. The goal, to have a better knowledge of each others' activities, such as investigations, measured values and methods used, can be served using the REMSSBOT system. This creates
159 more understanding for each others' policy, prevents duplicate investigations, and provides an accurate overview of water quality parameters in the river Scheldt catchment area. The demonstrator can facilitate integrated water management development which places the aquatic ecosystem as central basis of policy plans, instead of geographical boundaries which are determined by man.
REFERENCES
1. Lievens, E. and P. Gallo, 1996. Guidelines for the system architecture, REMSSBOT project (Document D 3.02). 2. Meire, P.M., 1993. Wader populations and macrozoobenthos in a changing estuary the Oosterschelde (The Netherlands). 1 : 311 .Universiteit van Gent, Faculteit der Wetenschappen Vakgroep Morfologie, Systematiek en Ecologie Academiejaar 1992-1993. 3. International Scheldt Group (ISG) / Santbergen, L.L.P.A., 1994, Water quality management in the Scheldt basin (interim progress report 1993), 1 : 129, Report AX94.013, Middelburg, The Netherlands.
160
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Seanet- Data Interface Group- Measuring Network Flemish Banks Hydro-Meteo-System for the North Sea ir. D. Vermeir ~a) and ir. G. Dumon ~b) (a) Head of Information Technology Dept.,NV HAECON Consulting Engineers, Ghent,Belgium ~b)Senior Engineer, Ministry of the Flemish Community, Coast and Harbour, Ostend, Belgium The Ministry of the Flemish Community, Coast and Harbours Service, has built up a hydrometeo data collection network for the North Sea. The installation of this network was necessary to provide information for the strom-surge warning service, to monitor the traffic in the important chipping channel leading to the port of Zeebrugge and the Western Scheldt, to monitor the North Sea activities of the Ministry of the Flemish Community and to create a data-bank for the Belgian part of the North Sea.
1. INTRODUCTION In 1975, at the time of the expansion of the harbour of Zeebrugge (Northern part of the Belgian coast) and of the execution of protection works for the coast, it became obvious that there was a need for : - statistical information of the hydro-meteo parameters for the determination of the project criteria ; on-line information relative to the data concerning sea conditions for works execution ; - information to be used as input for mathematical models (diffraction, refraction, a.s.o.). Additional information was needed along the navigation channels towards the harbour of Zeebrugge and the Western Scheldt Mouth. Indeed, a specific guaranteed depth is required to insure safe passage along these navigation channels, which are characterised by a tide differential of 4 meters covering a 12 hours time span ; ships' passage is then allowed within a tide range. It is thus required to guide and optimise navigation : to make maximal use of the available depth (combination of tide and ebb) so that waiting time of ships be reduced to a minimum ; to make optimal use of the available depth to limit the channel dredging. The "Measuring Network Flemish Banks" was created in response to the above aims. At the beginning the Network consisted of two measuring systems : - a mini Hydro-Meteo system which gathered wave data and meteorological information on the coast (winds, temperatures, insolation ...) ; - a network of measuring piles made up of several piles placed at specific locations at sea, which enabled collection of hydro-meteo information. Those measuring systems were, for historical reasons, set up independently from one another, and this made it necessary to integrate them in one global monitoring system. Concurrently, the data provided by those systems had to be completed by data from the foreign measuring networks and, moreover, it was necessary to have prediction data at hand. -
-
-
161
For this reason the Department Environment and Infrastructure, Administration for Water-infrastructure and Maritime Affairs, Coastal Harbours Service, gave the Joint-Venture HAECON - C.E.I. the assignment to set up a global monitoring system :
Hydro-Meteo-System for the North Sea. 2. F U N C T I O N ( S )
OF THE HYDRO-METEO
SYSTEM
The function of the Hydro-Meteo System is determined by : the goals of the Hydro-Meteo System ; - the System's users ; - the services to provide for with the system. -
2.1.
Goals
of the
hydro-meteo
system
1. Gathering of the actual hydrographic and meteorologic information along the Flemish coast and on the Belgian Continental Platform, and, more specifically along the navigation channels. Collection is insured by the Local Acquisition Centres (LACs) ; 2. On-line handling of the data acquired by the LACs and their storing in a central data bank, together with information received from foreign measuring networks ; 3. Data exchange with the national and international instances (Royal [Belgian] Meteorological Institute, [Dutch] State "Waterstaat", Thames Barrier, Bracknell, Reading) which dispose of actual and predicted hydro-meteo (forecasts) data for the North Sea ; 4. Acquisition of the predicted hydro-meteo information using mathematical models ; 5. Dissemination of the actual and/or predicted hydro-meteo data to the Hydro-Meteo System users. 2.2.
Users
of the
hydro-meteo
system
Users of the Hydro-Meteo System are grouped as "internal" and "external" users. Internal users are the services which are responsible for the functioning, use and maintenance of the system and include : -the Coastal Harbours Service responsible for the functioning, management and maintenance of the system ; - the forecast and information system responsible for the use of the Hydro-Meteo Systems data to produce prediction (forecast) data, work carried out by meteorologists. Users who request from and/or feed information to the Hydro-Meteo System and which do not belong to the group of the Internal Users, are external users. They are : - the nautical authorities of Zeebrugge and Flushings ; - the Royal [Belgian] Meteorological Institute ; - the Management Unit of the Mathematical Model ; - the Dutch measuring networks (State "Waterstaat", North Sea Directorate .... ) ; - the British Measuring Networks (National Meteorological Office Bracknell, Thames Barrier) ; - the Scheldt radar (Extended in-land Radar Chain UWRK) ; - private instances (Construction Companies, Study bureau, Beasac ...) ; - future as yet unspecified user.
162
2.3. S e r v i c e s ( s ) p r o v i d e d b y the h y d r o - m e t e o s y s t e m The service intended to be provided by the Hydro-Meteo System may be subdivided in: - maritime traffic ; - prevention ; - information providing ; - data exchange with other measuring nets.
2.3.1. Maritime traffic The services to provide are : - management of the maritime traffic in the navigation channels ; - insuring safe passage, to wit availability of the actual and predicted hydrologic and meteorologic conditions, especially those along the navigation channels ; - reduction of ships' waiting times, viz. optimisation of harbour's traffic ; - optimal use of the available water depth in order to optimise in turn dredging operations.
2.3.2. Prevention The services to provide are : - warning for possible heavy wave attack along the axis of the Zeebrugge locks (to provide protection of the locks' doors). - storm forecasts (e.g. removal in-time of strand cabins and other material so as to prevent damage, such as in De Haan) ; - storm flood warning ; - dangerous currents in harbours accesses ;
2.3.3. Information role Service providing concerning information supplying encompasses : - placing at disposal of H y d r o - M e t e o System data in relation to studies, assessments, expert testimonies .... ; - help tool to plan work at sea or on the coast ; - carrying out of special activities at sea, such as: * the handling of the Mont Louis wreck ; * the handling of the Herald of Free Enterprise wreck.
2.3.4. Exchange of data The H y d r o - M e t e o System is coupled with other measuring networks and it makes its information available to external instances such as : -the Dutch Measuring Network (Middelburg), with a continuous reciprocal data exchange ; - the Belgian Royal Meteorological Institute, for : * requests from the H y d r o - M e t e o System of the mathematical model data of the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) at Reading and the National Meteorological Office Bracknell ; * requests from the [Belgian] Royal Meteorological Institute of the sea-sited and Flemish coast located sensors data ; - the Management Unit of Mathematical Models for input of models, control of the models' forecast and models calibration.
163
3. BUILT-UP
OF
THE
HYDRO-METEO
SYSTEM
3.1. Introduction
The basic components of the Hydro-Meteo System are illustrated on fig. - Local Acquisition Centres ; - Connections with the external measuring networks ; - Mathematical Models Computer System ; - Central Collection- and Processing Service ; - Forecast and Information Service. 3.2. Local
acquisition
1. They are :
centres
The Local Acquisition Centres, LACs, are responsible for the local collection of data from the sensors placed on the Belgian Continental Platform and along the Flemish Coast. LACs process data on-line, transforming that the collected raw values into parameter values such as wave height, wave period, wind velocity, air temperature, visibility, etc. The sensor grid of the Flemish Banks Measuring Network consists of : - seven measuring platforms (MOW0. MOW.s, MOW7) with different sensors to measure wave parameters, wind, temperature and air parameters at sea, current parameters, visibility, etc . . . . - a number of wave buoys of the following type : - W A V E R I D E R [one-dimensional spectrum e (f)] - W A V E C [two-dimensional spectrum E (f, 0)] - telemetric sea level meters in the harbours of Nieuwpoort, Ostend and Zeebrugge ; - current meter at the entrance of the Port of Zeebrugge ; - a meteorological station on the Flemish Coast at Zeebrugge (Locks building) that measures parameters relative to wind, temperature, barometric pressure, precipitation, insolation . . . . . The measuring sensors at sea send their information by a radiosender to the LACs. Receivers are located in the LACs which pick up the data. Due to geographical position of the sensors, there are three acquisition Centres, so that all information may be received. These are : - Residence De Mast (Fig. 2) to collect wave buoys information from the W A V E R I D E R and W A V E C buoys ; - the Oceanographic and Meteorological Station (Fig. 3) to collect the MOW5 measuring pole data, sensors placed along the Flemish Coast and wave buoys of the W A V E R I D E R and W A V E C types ; - the Measuring Poles Network (Fig. 4) to collect the data relayed by the measuring poles MOW0...MOW4 and MOW7. Every local acquisition station is equipped with a mini-computer whereon the following functions are implemented : - controlling of the data-acquisition equipment for the sampling of the sensors' signals ; - storage of the raw data ; - on-line processing of raw data to parameter values and storage in a local data file. The Local Acquisition Centres function separately and independently one from the other.
164
Figure 1. Dataflow Hydro-Meteo-System
l:iguve 2. Local Acquisition Centra Residence De Mast - Ostend
Figure 3. Local Acquisition Centra Oceanographic and Meteorological Station Zeebrugge
165
Figure 4. Local Acquisition ('entra Measuring Platlbrm - Ostend
l.igtl~e 5. ('entral Hydro-Meteo Database
Figule r
(~entral Collection and Processing Center
166
3.3. L i n k s w i t h e x t e r n a l m e a s u r i n g n e t w o r k s The links with the external measuring networks aim at achieving the hydro-meteo parameters data exchange. Thus, the available information is not limited to the Belgian Continental Platform and the Flemish Coast, but is expanded to the North Sea. The links provide connections with : - the [Belgian] Royal Meteorological Institute which furnishes the Hydro-Meteo System with data originating from the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts' (ECMWF) mathematical model in Reading (G.B.) and the National Meteorological Office Bracknell (G.B.); - the Dutch measuring network, which provides to and requests data from HMS data file ; - the Thames Barrier in London and the National Meteorological Office Bracknell which feed tidal data gathered along the British Coast into the Hydro-Meteo System. The above data exchange occurs on an uninterrupted basis. 3.4. M a t h e m a t i c a l m o d e l s c o m p u t e r s y s t e m The mathematical models' computer system is used principally for the "wave prediction model" and the 'It-storm model" developed by the Mathematical Models' Management Unit. Forecasts can be requested through the presentation system of the Mathematical Models Computer System and a forecasts' selection is stored in the Hydro-Meteo System's central data file. The latter are then available to the users. 3.5. C e n t r a l a c q u i s i t i o n a n d p r o c e s s i n g s e r v i c e The tasks of the Central Collection and Processing Service encompass : - collection of the hydro-meteo data of * the Local Acquisition Centres (Belgian Continental Platform and Flemish Coast) ; * the external measuring networks (actual information and forecasts) ; * forecasts of the mathematical models computer system ; - the build-up of the central data file ; - off-line data processing ; - information distribution ; - management of the central data file ; - management of the network. The central acquisition and processing Centre is the core and includes the main computer. That computer contains the central data file (figure 5) where all data of the LACs, external measuring networks and Mathematical Models Computer System, as well as actual forecast data are centralised. The Local Acquisition Centre and the Mathematical Models Computer System are directly linked with the main computer (figure 6) by means of various communication apparatus. There is a backup line with the main computer through the Belgacom data network (DCSnetwork), because of the LACs enormous importance as well as their continuous need for data.
167
3.6.
Forecast
and
information
service
The main function of the Forecast and Information Service is the analysis and interpretation of the collected data, which consists in : 1. the control and improvement of the actual and forecast data ; 2. the use of the mathematical models computer with the hydro dynamic wave forecast model and specifically: * follow-up of the model's performance during the various runs, e.g. the generation of the forecasts ; * interpretation, control and processing of the output data (e.g. the forecasts) of the model. 3. the utilisation of other mathematical models, such as tide astronomical model, statistical tide prediction, hydrodynamic tide model and statistical wave forecast ; 4. follow-up and spelling-out of forecasts concerning weather prediction, wave climate, swell and water stand (level) ; 5. preparation of forecast notices on a continuous basis ; 6. preparation of special forecast notices during the exceptional meteorological conditions ; 7. general providing of information at the request of the Direction ; 8. statistical analysis and data processing for storing the collected data in the archives (records). 3.7.
Software
build-up
It follows from the above description that various programmations had to be developed to set-up the Hydro-Meteo System. Software (eventually) developed can be subdivided as follows : - data acquisition software to relay data acquisition apparatus from the LACs (RMO, MPN, OMS) ; - on-line processing to calculate parameters and derivated parameters in the LACs and their storage in local files ; - data communication software to request data from the LACs and external measuring networks ([Belgian] Royal Meteorological Institute, [Dutch] State Waterstaat, Thames Barrier) and to store them in the central database ; - programmation for the build-up, control and management of the central data file on the main computer ; - communication and control programmation for the data exchange with the mathematical models computer system ; - data processing software for the control and correction of data in the central database ; - off-line processing software for information from the central data file ; - on-line print-out at various sites ; - distribution of data from the central data file ; - back-up and storing of the central data file ; - programmation for the computer network management.
168
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge for European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Development of an acoustic method and prototype instrumentation for size and concentration measurement of suspended sediment Arjen S. Schaafsma l, Ad M. Lafort I and Daniel Guyomar 2 lDELFT HYDRAULICS, P.O. Box 177, 2600 MH Delft, The Netherlands* 2TECHSONIC, Les Alisiers, Route des Alisiers, Z.I. Les Trois Moulins, 06600 Antibes, France*
This paper gives a brief account of the present state of development of an acoustic attenuation spectroscopy technique for the measurement of suspended silt and sand and a short discussion of some related measurement techniques for suspended sediments.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N A good knowledge of the movement of suspended sediments is important for operational coastal, estuarine and harbour management. Some relevant quantities are the concentration, the particle size distribution and the velocities of the suspended sediment particles. These parameters are required as a function of time and preferably in three dimensions, to describe the sediment movement completely. Also, one would like to make predictions as to what would happen under specific, either natural or manmade conditions. In principle, a complete description of present and future movements of suspended sediment can be obtained by a combination of mathematical models and observations. The observations possibly include remote sensing (from the air) as well as in situ measurements, i.e. in the water column itself. The present paper is devoted to a specific aspect of the observation part of the problem, that is the further development of an acoustic attenuation spectroscopy (AAS) method, as mentioned in the title, for in situ measurements of concentration and particle size distribution and the parallel development of a prototype instrument based on this method: an Acoustic Spectroscopy Sediment Meter (ASSM). Before considering this specific method in more detail, a brief presentation of the context of the measurement problem and of some related techniques that are presently used for suspended sediment measurements, is given.
The authors gratefully acknowledgesupport by the EC (projects SMART/ISUSATand TRIDISMA),the LWI-CUR programme (project no. 2, Rivers) and the National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management/RIKZ of the Dutch Ministry of Transport, Public Works and Water Management.
169 2. STATE OF THE ART OF OPERATIONAL MEASURING METHODS Measurements are really needed as input for or in combination with mathematical models, because the available models need to be further validated and improved by tuning them to observations. For example, as regards coastal sediment transport, the present models are more advanced and detailed than the available experimental data sets [ 1]. Observations can be made over larger or smaller spatial scales. Remote sensing from aircrafts or satellites covers the largest scales. By optical techniques it can provide data related to the concentration of the fine size fraction of suspended sediment (< 50 jam, i.e. silt, clay) at the water surface. Because of the inherent size dependence of these techniques one has to accept a relatively large error, or perform calibrations on simultaneously collected samples. Also, the coarser sediment particles (> 50 ~m, i.e. sand) will generally not be detected, since in the first place, they are not usually present at the surface and in the second place, the optical techniques are relatively insensitive for larger particles. This illustrates that complementary in situ measurements in the water column are needed, which only can be carried out on smaller spatial scales than the remote sensing. The two main in situ measurement methods for suspended sediments are optical and acoustic techniques, in historical order. Over the last 10-15 years, more effort has been put into the further development of acoustic techniques, because they have certain important advantages [2-12]. Optical techniques, however, are used at present [13,14]and will be used in the future, though it is expected that it will show most fruitful to employ a combination of optical, acoustic (and other) techniques. In principle, the optical techniques for field use are point measurements. Two of them will be mentioned here: extinction and diffraction. Extinction, or transmission measurement, probably is the optical technique that is still most widely used, because it is relatively cheap. It provides data related to the suspended sediment concentration. However, the main disadvantage is that the sensitivity is strongly size dependent (proportional to the inverse size), as are the optical techniques used in remote sensing. Therefore, it is necessary to take samples for calibration regularly. The optical diffraction technique has been developed for the laboratory, but now some field version instruments (commercial prototypes) are available [ 13,14]. It provides a particle size distribution in the whole relevant range of sediment particle sizes, but it does not provide the concentration. Also, the instrument will not function if the concentration of fine sediment particles is higher than a few hundred mg/1, because of too high extinction. The acoustic techniques have as the main advantages (over optical techniques) that a relatively wide range of frequencies can be used, which provides selective sensitivity for particles of different sizes, and that they can be used for profiling, over smaller or larger ranges. The optimum frequency for probing particles is inversely proportional to the particle size and the desired profiling or measuring range determines the frequencies that can be used (or vice versa), since the water attenuation increases with the square of the frequency. An approximative indication of the mutually linked size, frequency and spatial ranges, is illustrative if one distinguishes by application. For the measurement of 'sand only ', i.e. particle size > 50 ~m, the required frequency range is up to 10 MHz, which leads to an available spatial range of about 0.5 m. For the measurement of the full range of sediment particles, that is 'silt (or clay) and sand', where the lower size limit is of the order of 1 to 5 lam, one needs to go up in frequency to 100 MHz, which results in a spatial range of the order of a few
170
centimetres, that is a limitation to local or point measurements. Because of the particle size dependent sensitivity, the distinction by sediment size range, i.e. sand or both sand and silt, is also useful for the following brief summary of some related and complementary acoustic techniques and (prototype) instrumentation for suspended sediment measurements. For the purpose of point measurements of sand concentration and transport, quite a number of systems have been developed [2-12]. Most of them are single frequency systems (between 1 and 5 MHz) based on back- or side- scattering [4-6,8], some on attenuation [9-12] and, as far as the present authors are aware of, in one case only on a combination of (side) scattering and attenuation [7]. The latter principle allows the elimination of the attenuation from the scattered signal, providing a considerable extension of the (linear) concentration range, as well as reduced size dependence. A new variation on this principle has recently been developed into an instrument which can measure sand concentration and 2 velocity components, giving the local transport in 2 dimensions. This is a 5 MHz system, which should be calibrated with the natural sand that it is actually used for, although it has been shown that the sensitivity is fairly constant for sand sizes between 100-300 ~tm [7]. The instrument is also available on a commercial basis [15] and a 5-fold version (allowing 5 measuring points in the vertical) has recently been built and applied in the field [16]. Acoustic profiling techniques to obtain estimates of the sand concentration and the average particle size along a line of 1-2 m length of above the bottom, illustrated in Figure 1 (right hand side), are presently in the research stage. Pioneering work has been done by two groups, Hay et al. [6,8] and Thorne et al. [4,5], employing acoustic backscattering (ABS) techniques in the 1-5 MHz range. These two authors and coworkers measured profiles of the
adjustable position
1 -2m
bottom Figure 1. Illustration of field deployment of two complementary techniques: (left) ASSM local measurement of concentration and particle size distribution of sand and silt and (right) ABS profiling system for concentration and average particle size of sand, as well as 3D-velocity profiles.
171
backscattered intensity for 3 different frequencies (1, 2 or 2.25 and 5 MHz). This intensity depends on the backscattering and attenuation characteristics of the particles along the profile, which both are size and frequency dependent. This poses an inversion problem in order to derive the concentration profile, which is not so easily solved, since it depends on assumptions about the attenuation, which is not measured. Nevertheless, the first results are promising: estimates of the concentration profile can be obtained with an order of magnitude (factor 10) accuracy and one may expect to achieve a resolution of average size of a factor of 2 in the particle size range of 100 ~tm and upwards. The further development of this technique into a more accurate tool is one of the main the goals of the recently started EC project TRIDISMA, which includes also the measurement of the velocity profiles in order to derive the sediment transport [ 17]. In the present context it may be useful to note that now available ADCP (Acoustic Doppler Current Profiling) systems, which have been primarily designed for current profiling (i.e. for obtaining estimates of the signal frequency) over a typical ranges of 10-50 m waterdepth or more, have been used to obtain estimates of sediment concentration profiles, although no consistent publications are available in the open literature. The use of present ADCP's for this purpose should be treated with care and is of limited value, for two main reasons. In the first place, to obtain concentration estimates, one uses the amplitude of the backscattered signals, whereas these systems were not primarily designed to treat amplitude information sufficiently accurate (i.e. within a few percent) as required for concentration measurements. In the second place the use of multiple frequencies would be required to alleviate the problem of the particle size dependence of the backscattered amplitudes, as is done for the ABS systems mentioned above. However, because of the relatively large spatial range, the use of higher frequencies than about 1 MHz is not possible and lower frequencies do not provide independent information in the sediment particle size range, so actually only a single (independent) frequency is available, with an optimum sensitivity Ibr particle sizes of about 500 ~tm and larger (for 1 MHz and lower frequencies respectively). Now, turning to the application of silt and sandpoint measurements, a technique based on acoustic attenuation spectroscopy (AAS) has been developed in the past decade by Schaafsma
Figure 2. Sensor unit for ASM (Acoustic Sediment Meter), showing diametrically opposed pairs of transmit and receive transducers to perform Attenuation Spectroscopy. The diagram is appromimately to scale, the 4 lowest frequency pairs of transducers are at a distance of 20 cm from each other.
flow ~direction)
172
et al. [9-12]. This technique employs frequencies in the 1-100 MHz range to detect particles with size of about 5 ~tm and larger and measure partial (per size class) and total concentrations in the range of 0.05-5 kg/m 3, with a size resolution of about a factor of 2. The present paper will focus on this method, show the present state of the art and the ongoing developments, in particular that of a prototype Acoustic Spectroscopy Sediment Meter (ASSM).
3. DEVELOPMENT OF PROTOTYPE INSTRUMENT During the last 3 years the development of the AAS method formed part of the EC project SMART/ISUSAT [18], which resulted in a so called research-phase instrument, of which the sensor unit is shown in Figure 2. For field measurements the sensor unit will be fixed at some position above the bottom as illustrated in Figure 1. This figure also illustrates the complementary use of the local AAS and profiling ABS techniques, where the AAS method can provide the attenuation data required for solving the inversion problem, mentioned before, as well as provide estimates of the local silt concentration.
3.1. Experimental and theoretical approach The acoustic attenuation spectroscopy method has been developed further by a combination of laboratory experiments on real suspensions and a newly developed numerical physical model, using finite and boundary element methods (FEM-BEM), which allows the modelling of the acoustic scattering by arbitrary shaped particles [19]. As a first step, the model was implemented for acoustically rigid and immovable particles. Both the numerical model and the experiments focused on those aspects, which are relevant for sediments, especially the variety
Figure 3. Measured and calculated normalized attenuation spectra as a function of the nondimensional size/frequency parameter ka, for four size fractions of sand and quartz particles and modelled shapes, which are increasingly non-spherical (from left to right). The attenuation ot is normalized by the volume concentration C v and the wavenumber k. Further, a m is the sediment particle's effective radius measured by optical diffraction and ap the equal volume sphere radius of the polyhedral model shapes.
173
of (non-spherical) particle shapes, building on the semi-empirical work along these lines, carried out before [20]. Typical measured attenuation spectra for four different, relatively narrow, size fractions of sand and quartz particles are shown in Figure 3, where a comparison is made with the results of the numerical calculations. The selected size fractions have an increasingly non-spherical shape, from left to right in the figure. This was determined by scanning electron microscopy measurements on samples of the size fractions. The particles have rather irregular shapes, characterized by (more or less) plane faces and (more or less) sharp edges, not similar to a distorted sphere. For the numerical modelling, a series of polyhedral shapes was therefore chosen and the results for the icosahedron, octahedron, cube and tetrahedron are shown in the figure, also in order of increasing shape irregularity. To quantify the deviation from a spherical shape, the ratio of the particle's projected area to that of a sphere of the same volume has been used, which is the reason that the effective equal volume radius ap appears in the normalization of the calculated spectra in Figure 3. Note also that the attenuation is normalized with an extra factor 1/k, where k is the wavenumber, which leads to a 1/fbehaviour (fbeing the acoustic frequency) at high values of ka. Further, in order to make the modelling results directly comparable to the measurements on real particle suspensions, the calculated attenuation cross section was averaged over a large number of incident angles. This corresponds to the orientation average measurement result that one obtains on a real suspension, since this measurement averages over all particles in the detected volume (this is a relatively large number of particles) and the particles are randomly oriented due to the turbulent motion of the water in the laboratory set-up. The main point to notice regarding the result in Figure 3, is the trend of increasing (peak-)attenuation with increasing shape irregularity, which is present in the measured data and
commands
transmit
user interface
results
settings
data
acquisition ii module '
/ /
model parameters 1
! signals
I Particle Size Distribution Concentration , Shape
interpretation t module
calibrated spectra
i
receive T,
'/ t
s
raw spectra
calibration module
Figure 4. Diagram of the hardware and software modules of the prototype ASM (Acoustic Sediment Meter). The water temperature T and salinity s are measured parameters, used for the calibration.
174 is relatively well described by the numerical model. The physical reason is that the orientation average projected area of a particle, with respect to an equal volume sphere, is larger the more its shape deviates from spherical [21]. It may also be noted that the enhancement of the attenuation is considerable, a factor of 1.8 was found experimentally for the quartz particles. Therefore, as regards the solution of the inversion problem in backscatter profiling measurements, one should be extremely careful as to what value of the attenuation one uses in the inversion scheme. The present results show that it is not sufficiently accurate to use a value estimated from a sphere model. Therefore, the suggestion has been made to perform the same type of numerical calculations as referred to here, also for the backscattering cross section, that is to calculate the orientation average values for a number of different representative irregular shapes [ 19].
3.2. Technological approach The main technology achievement so far has been the realization of the required accuracy (of 0.1 dB) in the wide frequency band used (1-100 MHz). This wide band enables the coverage of a relatively wide range of sediment particle sizes, including fine sand and silt particles. However, the measuring frequency that can be obtained with the present researchphase instrument, about one spectrum per minute, is too low for representative field trials. Users have required a measuring frequency of about 2 spectra per second. Therefore, the main technological challenge for the prototype instrument is to realize a sufficiently fast data collection and (real time) processing system and to integrate the different modules of the system. This development is presently underway and is illustrated in Figure 4. The user interface will enable to programme the measurements, view the results and store the data. The collected raw data will be calibrated using recent and stored calibrations (of the pure water attenuation) and interpreted in terms of the theoretical model outlined above. A deconvolution scheme for the translation of an attenuation spectrum into a particle size distribution will be developed and implemented in the interpretation module.
4. SUMMARY OF RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS An acoustic attenuation spectroscopy method has been developed that can measure suspended sediments concentrations in the range of 0.05-5 kg/m 3 and distinguish particle sizes in the range of 5-1000 ~tm with a size resolution of a factor 2 and a concentration accuracy per size band of 20%. These, together with a required measurement frequency of about 2 Hz are the specifications used for a prototype instrument ASSM (Acoustic Spectroscopy Sediment Meter), which is under development. The use of attenuation data for the further development of the ABS profiling technique has been discussed. These two techniques are complementary and may be fruitfully deployed in the field simultaneously. In order to derive concentration profiles from ABS measurements, one needs to know the sediment attenuation along the profile. However, this quantity is not directly measured by the ABS, which can cause relatively large errors. This problem is even more serious, if one tries to derive sediment concentrations from ADCP measurements, because of the larger ranges and lower frequencies involved. The Acoustic Spectroscopy Sediment Meter can significantly reduce the uncertainty involved in the profiling techniques, by providing accurate attenuation data at distinct points of the profile.
175
REFERENCES
.
10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
19. 20. 21.
L.C. van Rijn, personal communication (1996). D. M. Hanes and D. A. Huntley, Continental Shelf Res., 6 (1986) 585-596. D. M. Hanes, C. E. Vincent, D. A. Huntley and T. L. Clarke, Marine Geology, 81 (1988) 185-186. P.D. Thorne, C.E. Vincent, P.J. Hardcastle, S. Rehman and N. Pearson, Mar. Geol. 98 (1991) 7-16. P.D. Thorne, P.J. Hardcastle and R.L. Soulsby, J. Geophys. Res., 98(C 1) (1993) 899-910. A. E. Hay and J. Sheng, J. Geophys. Res. 97(C 10) (1992) 15661-15677. A.S. Schaafsma and W.J.G.J. der Kinderen, Proceedings of the IAHR Symposium on Measuring Techniques in Hydraulic Research, edited by A.C.E. Wessels, (Balkema, Rotterdam, 1986) pp. 125-136. A.M. Crawford and A. E. Hay, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 94(6), (1993) 3312-3324. A.S. Schaafsma and A.J. Wolthuis, Progress in Underwater Acoustics, edited by H.M. Merklinger (Plenum, New York, 1986), pp. 153-160. Schaafsma, A.S., Ultrasonics International '89, Madrid, 3-7 July, Butterworth & Co. Ltd. (1989) p. 388-93. Hay, A.E. and Schaafsma, A.S., J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 85(3) (1989) 1124-38. Schaafsma, A.S., 2nd European Conference on Underwater Acoustics, edited by L. Bjerno (European Commission, Luxembourg, ISBN 92-826-8000-2) 2 (1994) 863-68. Y.C. Agrawal and H.C. Pottsmith, Cont. Shelf. Res., 14 (1994) 1101-1121. Le Haitre, M., Le Noac'h, A., Lewen, M. and Szychter, H., Proceedings of International Conference OCEAN-94, Brest, France, 13-16 September 1994. W.J. Taal and D.A. Spaargaren, DELFT HYDRAULICS Report, B329, 1994. P.G.L. van den Heukel, Inst. for Mar. and Atm. Res., Utrecht Un. Report R96.09, 1996. MAST III Project TRIDISMA, Project Coordinator C.E. Vincent, Un. of East Anglia UK. Schaafsma, A.S., Guyomar, D., Vanderborck, G., Bjorno, L., Kozhevnikova, I.K. and Person, R., Marine Sciences and Technologies, edited by K.G. Barthel a.o., CEC, Brussels, Luxembourg, 2 (1993) 605-11. Schaafsma, A.S., Lafort, A.M., Mazoyer, Th. and Guyomar, D., accepted for publication in Acta Acustica, March 27 (1997). Schaafsma, A.S. and Hay, A.E., accepted for publication in J. Acoust. Soc. Am., November 11 (1996). H.C. van de Hulst, Light Scattering by Small Particles (Dover, New York, 470 pp., 1981), p. 110.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
TECHNOLOGY Remote Sensing
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge for European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
179
E S A ' s support o f operational o c e a n o g r a p h y : current status and future plans J. A. Johannessena and G. Duchossoisb a Earth Sciences Division, ESA-ESTEC, P.O. Box 299, 2200 AG Noordwijk, The Netherlands. b ESA Earth Observation Mission Management Office, ESA HQ, 8-10 Rue Mario Nikis, 75738 Paris Cedex 15, France.
While remote sensing observations provide detailed synoptic coverage of relatively large surface areas, it is only in combination with in situ observations (preferably coincident in time and space) that a three dimensional picture of the oceanographic conditions can be obtained. Models, on the other hand, which need data for reliable initialization, are offering advanced capabilities for validation and interpretation of the remote sensing observations. This synergy, in turn, leads to better understanding of the underlying processes. Thus, it is only when remote sensing observations are combined with in situ observations and models that an optimal system for ocean monitoring and prediction is achieved.
1. INTRODUCTION Nearly six years after the launch of ERS-1 in July 1991, and about 2 years after the launch of ERS-2 in April 1995 (they operated almost one year in tandem), it is widely recognized that the ERS satellites are making a major contribution to the observation and monitoring of the global ocean and sea ice covered regions of the Earth. The combination of microwave and infrared instruments onboard the ERS-1 satellite provide observations of sea surface roughness, sea surface slope, sea surface temperature and sea ice conditions. The situation for scientific disciplines studying the global oceans, the regional and coastal seas and the polar oceans has therefore improved markedly, and our understanding of the dominating geophysical processes has undoubtedly advanced. Improved understanding, coupled with regular temporal and spatial data coverage, are in turn providing better means for initialization of models as well as for validation of model output. Through data assimilation the errors in model predictions and forecasts have subsequently been reduced. This paper will: a) highlight some of the major results achieved with ERS-1 and ERS-2, in particular emphasising the contribution to operational oceanography; b) outline the future plans of ESA in support of operational oceanography; and c) view the relevance of a) and b) in the context of the strategy for EuroGOOS [1 ].
180 2. ACHIEVEMENTS In addition to a large span of scientific achievements from the ERS observations [see 2-3], the gradual transfer of applications from experimental towards operational users have surpassed expectations [4-5]. As a result it is now generally recognized that Europe is playing a major role in the provision and application of satellite data for operational and climate monitoring purposes, i.e.: 9 Assimilation of ERS data into weather and sea state forecasting is operational. 9 Marine applications especially in ice monitoring, oil slick detection and bathymetric survey are becoming operationally established. 9 Marine climatological data bases based on 5 years of ERS data are produced and regularly updated. Users are, as a result of these achievements, anticipating long-term continuity of these data as inputs to planned operational applications. An overview of the primary applications of the ERS-1 and ERS-2 instruments (i.e. active microwave radar altimeter, scatterometer, and SAR and infrared radiometer ATSR) is provided in Table 1. It includes applications such as weather forecasting, sea state forecasting, offshore activities, ship routing and ship detection, fisheries, sea ice monitoring, oil pollution monitoring and coastal processes and shallow water bathymetry monitoring. INSTRUMENTS IR-Vis
Active
Microwave
Applications
ATSR
Altimeter
S A R image mode
Weather forecasting
~/
~/
(4)
~/
(4)
~/
(4)
Offshore activities
3/
~/
~/
4
Ship routing
~/
"~/
~/
~/
Sea state forecasting Current modelling
4
Ship detection
W i n d scatt.
4 N/
~/ ~/
~/
Fisheries
~
Sea Ice
~]
3/
Oil pollution
~/
~/
Coastal Zone
~/
3/
Bathymetry
S A R wave mode
"~/
~/ (4) (~/)
~/
Table 1. Overview of the primary application areas of the ERS observations versus instruments. Parenthesis indicate predominantly research
181 In the following subsections major achievements will be highlighted within a few application classes such as weather forecasting, sea state forecasting, current modelling and sea ice monitoring. 2.1. W e a t h e r and sea state forecasting
The suite of active microwave instruments flown on the ERS-1 and ERS-2 satellites is providing for the first time consistent and regular global wind and wave data in near real time (within three hours of observations), filling the gaps existing with conventional observation systems. This has opened up exiting new opportunities for wind and wave research, wind and wave modelling, and the assimilation into operational models for the production of short term weather and sea state forecasts. Moreover, these data are also used to support climate models. In the following subsection the operational observations of the near surface wind field and the sea state conditions are briefly described. A more comprehensive discussion of this is reported in [4] and [5]. Wind Field: The ERS-I/2 satellites obtain complementary surface wind measurements from the radar altimeter and the scatterometer (Table 1). While the altimeter measures wind speed for areas directly below the satellite at a horizontal scale of about I0 km, the scatterometer provides a measure of both wind speed and direction over a swath of 500 km width at a spatial resolution of 50 kin. A complete global coverage is obtained in three days. The quality of these wind field observations is widely recognised, and they enable for example small-scale low pressure systems and frontal lines to be identified properly compared with model background plots [3,5]. However, the dual directional ambiguity of the solutions must be removed. In a newly developed removal scheme, called PRESCAT, [6] demonstrate that approximately 95% of all such ambiguities can be correctly removed. In turn, the improvements in the initial wind field data provided by the ERS scatterometer data have a beneficial impact on analyses and short-range forecasts, probably mainly from the improvements on the subsynoptic scales [6]. For example, the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting (ECMWF) provides operational meteorological forecast services, as well as sea-state forecasting services, to the national meteorological services of its seventeen participating states [7]. Since 1992 ERS scatterometer data have been used in combination with SSM/I passive microwave data and NOAA TOVS data, balloon and airborne measurements, buoy and shipborne observations and weather-station reports in the provision of meteorological services. These data form the basis of an initial analysis field produced at 1200 UTC daily. The numerical forecasting model (operated on a dedicated Cray C90-16 computer) then propagates the initial data forward in time steps of twenty minutes to provide forecasts in six-hour steps for up to five days ahead, and twelve-hour steps for five to ten days ahead. Both global and regional forecasts are provided. These forecasts are transmitted to national weather services every six hours via the Global Telecommunications System. The ERS scatterometer data are incorporated in such a way as to correct forecast surface wind fields continually over the oceans. These corrections are then propagated through the numerical model to provide corrections to other parameters such as atmospheric pressure, temperature and humidity. Trials have demonstrated that the incorporation of scatterometer
182 data improve the accuracy of the short-range forecasts by approximately five percent over forecasts where scatterometer data were not included. In particular, the use of scatterometer data to improve the accuracy of the wind data for tropical cyclones has proven very useful, so that initial values of atmospheric parameters at the model grid points better match the actual values. Ocean Waves: Coincident with the wind field observations from the ERS radar altimeter and scatterometer are observations of the sea state conditions (Table 1). The radar altimeter measures the significant waveheight along the satellite ground track, while the synthetic aperture radar (SAR) provides retrievals of the directional ocean wave spectrum either in wave mode operation (conducted in synergy with the scatterometer) or in full image mode. In the wave mode small SAR imagettes of 10 km x 5 km are acquired every 200 km along the scatterometer's near range coverage. These data are distributed to weather services for operational wave monitoring, analyses and forecasting (within three hours of observation) via the Global Telecommunication System (GTS). For the first time these data allow wave modellers to obtain global information on two-dimensional wave spectra. In combination with the scatterometer wind field retrievals these data furthermore provide capabilities to separately study the wind sea, swell propagation and dissipation [4]. This particularly has contributed to a provision of better wave forecasts since the ERS SAR wave mode data are allowing improved initialization of the swell field in the model. Moreover, the improved estimates of the wave spectrum (i.e. partitioning of the wave field into wind wave and swell components) are in turn used to refine wind field retrievals [8]. In addition to the improvement in marine weather and sea state forecasting worldwide, the use of off-line products from ERS-1 is also providing benefits to the offshore industry as well as many other coastal activities. Time series of sea state information are being developed as a basis for predicting the sea state at a given time and location. This assists in a whole range of activities such as planning the timing and logistics of offshore activities to minimise risks to personnel, assessing marine risks, coastal defence planning, wave energy resource evaluations and setting engineering design parameters. With the continuity of data offered by ERS-2, longer time series will increase the potential value of these data sets. Historic wave and wind information is also being used for hindcast as well as to confirm ocean and weather conditions at particular locations and at specific times. In turn, this is helping insurance companies in risk analysis, and the settlement of claims. An example of the direct application of the improved sea state prediction is found in a recent pilot demonstration project for shiprouting [9]. Based on an extended inversion scheme [ 10], a general assimilation scheme for improved wave and wind analysis and forecast has been developed [11]. Together with standard ECMWF data this was used to optimize shiprouting including the calculation of optimal ship routes as well as the derivation of statistics for cost savings on ensembles of routes. Another example is the Cliosat system [12] which is a new, commercial, wave climatology service developed by MeteoMer. The Cliosat system is based solely on satellite data including ERS radar altimeter, scatterometer and SAR wave mode data. It provides standard products including:
183
9 Statistics and histograms of significant wave height, peak period and peak direction. 9 Scatter diagrams of significant wave height, peak period and peak direction combinations. 9 Estimates of extreme values of wave height and ranges within specified areas. These data are available for any part of the world, including remote and poorly documented areas, and are used primarily by marine engineers. 2.2. Modelling of ocean circulation In its near-polar orbit the ERS altimeter samples, in contrast to TOPEX/POSEIDON (T/P) (and Geosat), ocean topography at high latitudes. The 35-day repeat period is near optimum for spatial-temporal sampling of mesoscale ocean phenomena. The ground track pattern (Figure 1) created by the 501 orbital revolutions of the satellite within the repeat period is sufficiently dense to observe Kelvin and Rossby waves in equatorial regions, midlatitude eddies and even to pick up smaller scale variability at high latitudes. At the same time the repetition period of 35 days is sufficiently short to enable the evolution of these features in time to be followed. Moreover, during the last decade, the technique of radar altimetry has become very precise, allowing quasi-global measurements of sea level to be obtained. Analyses of almost four years of T/P altimetric data have shown that they provide observations of the ocean dynamic topography at an absolute accuracy of 3-4 cm. In comparison, the ERS-1 orbits are typically accurate to within 15 cm. However, since T/P and ERS-1 flew simultaneously, the more precise T/P data can be used to reduce the ERS-1 orbit error to about 8-10 cm using global minimization ofT/P + ERS-I dual crossover differences [13]. The same is possible for ERS-2, but with improved orbit determination from the PRARE (Precise Range and RangeRate Equipment) the differences are expected to be less. The ocean exhibits variations in temperature, density and salinity over scales that can vary from a few centimetres to hundreds or even thousands of kilometres. Mesoscale features such as currents and fronts give rise to sudden changes in ocean properties. These features strongly influence local ocean circulation. Conventional data gathering methods rely on the deployment of a number of instruments such as conductivity-temperature-depth (CTD) sondes, expendable bathythermographs (XBTs), and drifting surface and subsurface buoys. This is both expensive and time consuming, and will always be limited in coverage. Ocean topography derived from satellite altimetry nicely complement such in situ observations and, combined with numerical modelling, it opens the way to a better operational forecast system for ocean circulation. The Service Hydrographique et Oceanographique de la Marine (cf. France) has developed a preliminary version of an operational system for analyzing and forecasting ocean circulation [14]. This service, known as SOAP (SOAP is a French acronym for Nowcast and Forecast Operational System), is based on the assimilation of radar altimeter data into a numerical model of ocean dynamics which transforms the satellite surface information into three dimensional descriptions of ocean current and transports. Since the summer of 1993, SOAP has been operating routinely to describe the Azores frontal dynamics and ocean forecast reports have been provided to Navy users every fortnight. ERS fast delivery radar altimeter
184
Figure 1. The ERS-2 radar altimeter coverage of the North East Atlantic in one 35-day repeat cycle. data and orbit data are retrieved and processed to produce daily maps of current variability. Validation of the model output suggests that the use of radar altimeter data in the numerical model significantly improves the description of the Azores frontal dynamics. The NOAA ERS operational system of the tropical Pacific, for example, uses ERS altimeter range measurements converted to sea heights for sea level monitoring. This is based on incorporation of a precise satellite orbit (provided by Delft University of Technology) and corrections for tides, troposphere and ionosphere. The timeliness of this NOAA ERS sea
185
level product has, since November 1995, been available within 8 hours (Cheney and Lillibridge, personnel communication). Time series of this product are also used at NOAA to follow changing sea level patterns as they relate to the ENSO cycle. This, together with other pilot demonstration results not presented here, highlights the potential improvement in the modelling of ocean circulation arising from the assimilation of accurate radar altimeter data into numerical global ocean models. A more comprehensive discussion on this subject is presented by [15] in the session on EuroGOOS Regions: Atlantic II. Moreover, the availability of accurate sea surface temperature data from the ATSR instrument, at a horizontal scale of about 1 to 10 km, in synergy with the altimetric topographic observations and a modelling system, provides a means of further describing ocean circulation in the vicinity of frontal zones. And since the higher retrieval accuracies of the ATSR surface skin temperatures can be converted to more reliable bulk temperatures, accurate comparisons with in-situ temperature measurements are possible. From the ATSR observations accurate monthly means of global sea surface temperature are produced regularly at a scale of 50 km x 50 km, while high quality wind field data (derived from the scatterometer) are used to improve the estimates of wind stress and the corresponding forcing field used in ocean circulation modelling. In combination with the quality and regularity of the ocean topography observations, the provision of these data has helped advance ocean modelling capabilities. In particular, a deeper understanding of the evolution of the 1991 to 1993 Southern Ocean Oscillation (El Nifio and La Nifia), the tracking of Rossby waves and equatorial Kelvin waves, and the modelling of global tides and mean sea level have been possible [see for example 16-18]. 2.3. Sea ice
ERS observations in the hostile polar environment contribute to global monitoring of sea ice, to detailed studies of air-sea-ice interactive processes as well as to operational applications related to ship navigation, ocean drilling and oil explorations. Long term monitoring of the evolution of the sea ice cover in the polar regions, using the ERS scatterometer, complements the use of passive microwave observations in climate change studies, while the ERS SAR data is used in operational applications as well as in process studies. The high resolution imaging capabilities of the SAR is, in particular, useful for monitoring: ice concentration, extent, type and floe size distribution ice motion land fast ice and shear zones ice ridges locations of leads and polynyas The extreme sea-ice conditions along the northern coast of Russia, for instance, limit human activities, and shipping traffic is severely hampered for most of the year, with only two or three months of ice-free conditions along the coast. Russia has a major need for extensive year-round sea transportation to support settlements along the Siberian Coast and
186 rivers, as well as for transport between Northern Europe and the Pacific through the Bering Strait. This Northern Sea Route generates considerable savings (as it is shorter than using the Suez Canal), reducing the transit time by approximately 10 days. Shipping activities in the region are supported by an extensive operational sea-ice monitoring and forecasting service assisting the icebreaker fleet based at Murmansk. The production of sea-ice maps and forecasts is conducted using information from ice breakers, other vessels, polar weather stations and airborne surveys, together with NOAA AVHRR images and ERS SAR imagery delivered in near real time. These forecasts are then distributed to the ice-breaker fleet and shipping in the region. In particular, it has been documented in demonstration projects [19] that the use of ERS SAR data improves the identification of leads and other ice features of interest for navigation within ice-infested waters.
2.4. Summary In summary, the major contribution from ERS-1 and ERS-2 to operational oceanography includes: Improved quality of near surface wind field and surface waves for wind and wave forecasting. 9 More accurate global statistical description of wind and wave climatology. 9 Better quality of wind stress data for ocean circulation modelling. Improved mapping of ocean topography for modelling of the mesoscale to the global scale ocean circulation. 9 Improved modelling of tides and storm surges. Improved monitoring of sea surface temperature for indicators of climate change. 9 Improved capabilities to detect and monitor climate events such as El Nifio. 9 Improved monitoring of sea ice conditions. While the temporal and spatial coverage of the SAR wave mode data together with radar altimeter data, scatterometer data and the 50 km x 50 km averaged ATSR data are satisfactory for global and regional application, the requirement for high resolution coverage in coastal zones makes the weather independent SAR image mode data particularly attractive. Despite the increase in data flow and corresponding computational constraints, the analysis of the full resolution SAR images serve a range of purposes within the coastal environment from pilotoperational application to process studies as suggested in Table 2. Some of these application areas indicated in Table 2 are further discussed in the subsequent presentations in this Session on Remote Sensing Technology [20-22].
187
AREA
OPERATIONAL APPLICATION & FORECASTING
G E O P H Y S I C A L FEATURE
COMPONENT
WAVES
LENGTH DIRECTION SIGNIFICANT WAVEHEIGHT
POLLUTION
OIL SPILL
SEAFLOOR
SHALLOW WATER BATHYMETRY, SANDBANKS GROWTH & DECAY
SEA ICE
LEADS, ICE CONCENTRATION
WIND
SPEED DIRECTION
ATMOSPHERIC BOUNDARY LAYER
ATMOSPHERIC GRAVITY WAVES, ROLLS, KATABATIC WINDS, CONVECTIVE CELLS, VAN KARMAN AND STORM STRUCTURES
SURFACE CURRENT
FRONTS EDDIES UPWELLING INTERNAL WAVES
SLICKS
NATURAL FILM
PROCESS STUDIES
Fable 2. Summary of the achievements in coastal ocean environmental monitoring and pilot operational application with the use of ERS SAR.
3. ESA's FUTURE P L A N S The continuity of the ERS type measurements for global, regional and local operational oceanography is ensured by ESA's future approved satellite program, i.e. Envisat to be launched in 1999, followed by the joint ESA/Eumetsat METOP series of operational satellites with the first launch in 2002. This is shown in Table 3, which in addition to the continuity aspect also identifies an important new ocean colour sensing capability, namely the Medium Resolution Imaging Spectrometer (MERIS) on Envisat. In comparison to other ocean colour sensing instruments (i.e. SeaWIFS, Mos, OCTS) it should be noted that MERIS has coincident swath overlap with some ASAR operating modes. This will allow for interesting examination of for example surface film coverage versus biomass. By the end of the assumed life time of Envisat (about 2004), there will therefore exist a near 15 year, continuous and globally homogenous data base of weather independent, microwave radar altimeter, scatterometer and SAR data. The provision of such high quality data for weather forecasting, sea state forecasting, modelling of ocean circulation, and sea ice monitoring emphasize the important contribution of satellite data for ocean studies and monitoring over the next decade. Already the success of the ERS scatterometer has led to it being considered as an operational sensor on the METOP series (Table 3).
188
INSTRUMENTS SATELLITES
ERS-I
Radar Altimeter
Scatterometer
Synthetic Aperture Radar
InfraredVisible Radiometer
RA
AMI
AMI
ATSR
RA
AMI
AMI
ATSR-2
ASAR
AATSR
Imaging Spectrometer
(1991-1996) ERS-2
(1995- 2000) ENVISAT (1999- 2004)
RA-2
METOP (2002- 2017)
MERIS
ASCAT
Table 3. Overview of ESA's present and future approved satellite program and corresponding instrument with contribution to operational oceanography. The operating time is indicated. Beyond these approved missions, starting from about 2004, ESA will commence its dual mission concept (Table 4) consisting of: a) the Earth Explorer Missions which are research and demonstration missions with the aim of advancing the understanding of different processes which govern the Earth/atmosphere system [23], and b) the Earth Watch Missions which are operational missions addressing the requirements of specific application areas in Earth Observation [24]. ESA's F U T U R E DUAL M I S S I O N C O N C E P T CANDIDATE EARTH EXPLORER
MISSIONS
CANDIDATE EARTH WATCH MISSIONS
Magnetometry
Coastal Zones
Gravity and Steady-State Ocean Circulation
Polar Ice
Land Surface Processes and Interaction
Open Ocean
Earth Radiation
Land Surface
Atmospheric Dynamics
Atmospheric Chemistry
Atmospheric Chemistry Atmospheric Profiling Precipitation Topography Table 4. ESA's future candidate dual Earth Explorer and Earth Watch Mission Concept
189 4. S U M M A R Y AND R E L E V A N C E TO E u r o G O O S
Despite the fact that both ERS-1 and ERS-2 are pre-operational missions, ESA's contribution to operational oceanography has grown steadily since the launch of ERS-1 in 1991. In addition ESA's approved satellite programmes, Envisat and METOP (jointly with Eumetsat), ensure the continuity of ERS type data as well as new data into the next century. In view of the five major application modules of GOOS and EuroGOOS, including: l) 2) 3) 4) 5)
ocean climate, living marine resources, marine weather and operational ocean services, health of the ocean, and the coastal zones.
ESA's current contribution is therefore mainly to modules 1), 3) and 5), and to a lesser extent to 4). These modules will continue to be covered also by the future approved programmes (up to 2004), and ocean colour sensing (i.e. MERIS on Envisat) will provide new contributions to modules 2) and 4). For the future, beyond 2004, five areas of economic interest are identified as candidates for Earth Watch Missions, namely: coastal zones, polar ice, open ocean, land surface and atmospheric chemistry (Table 4). These candidate missions were recommended during the Earth Observation User Consultation Meeting in 1994 [24]. Some of these are perhaps more relevant to the EuroGOOS data capture systems, but in the longer term the outcome of the Earth Explorer Missions will also contribute to new and dedicated observing systems, in particular, for climate change studies. As pointed out in the strategy for EuroGOOS [1] the use of an integrated global ocean observing system, schematically illustrated in Figure 2, consisting of remote sensing and
Figure 2. Integrated observing system concept
190
in situ observation components together with dedicated model and assimilation tools defines an important baseline. Different versions of such systems are currently in use both in operational numerical weather predictions and in climate modelling. It is foreseen that such systems will gradually improve in the future as a result of better interpretation and utilization of remote sensing data, and development of better in situ observing systems, ocean model and assimilation methods. Such advanced integrated systems will also give some insight into requirements on spatial and temporal coverage for remote sensing observations, and could therefore play an important role in the definition of Earth Watch Missions focussed on monitoring coastal zones, open ocean and sea ice covered regions. Further for the definition of the Earth Watch Mission concept, and, in particular, the candidate Coastal Zone Earth Watch (CZEW) Mission there is a need for discussion with the European Commission and other relevant organisations and programmes such as EuroGOOS and LOICZ to explore, in detail, their possible role in the mission preparation and exploitation. Moreover, it is also clear that during the preparation of the Earth Watch Mission concept specialized user groups such as ECMWF and national weather prediction centres (NWP) must be consulted and future meteorological satellite observing systems such as METOP must be taken into account.
REFERENCES.
1.
2.
3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
8.
9.
J.D. Woods, H. Dahlin, L. Droppert, M. Glass, S. Vallerga, and N.C. Flemming, The strategy for EuroGOOS, EuroGOOS Publication No. 1, Southampton Oceanographic Centre, Southampton, ISBN 0-904175-22-7. ESA SP-361, Proceedings of Second ERS-1 Symposium, Space at the service of our environment, ESA publication division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, volI and II, January, 1994. ESA SP-1176/I, New Views of the Earth. Scientific Achievements of ERS-1, ESA publ. div., Noordwijk, The Netherlands, April, 1995. ESA SP-383, Proceedings Second International Workshop on ERS Applications, ESA publ. Div., Noordwijk, The Netherlands, February, 1996. ESA SP-1176/II, New Views of the Earth. Application Achievements of ERS-1, ESA publ. div., Noordwijk, The Netherlands, February, 1996. A. Stoffelen and D. Andersen, Ambiguity removal and assimilation of scatterometer data, Q.J.R. Meteorol. Soc. 123, pp. 491-518, 1977. H. Roquet and A. Woods, In ESA SP-1176/11, New Views of the Earth." Application Achievements of ERS-1, ESA publication division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, February, 1996. K. Hasselmann, P. Heimbach and S. Hasselmann, "Application of near real-time ERS-1 SAR wave mode data, Proceedings Oceanology International 96 " The Global Ocean Towards Operational Oceanography, vol. 3, pp. 181-195, Spearhead Exhibitions Ltd, Ocean House, Surrey KT3 3LZ, UK, 1996. S. Lehner, Test of new onboard ship routing system, ESA SP-383, Proceedings Sec.
191
10.
11. 12. 13.
14. 15.
16. 17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23. 24.
International Workshop on ERS Applications, ESA publication division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, February, 1996. C. Brtining and S. Hasselmann, Extraction of wave spectra from ERS-1 SAR wave mode spectra by an improved SAR inversion scheme, Proceedings First Workshop on ERS-1 Pilot Projects, ESA publication division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, Oct., pp. 45-49, 1994. G.J. Komen et al., Dynamics and Modelling of Ocean Waves, Cambridge Univ. P r e s s , 1994. P. Lasnier, In ESA SP-1176/II, New Views of the Earth. Application Achievements of ERS-1, ESA publication division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, February, 1996. P.Y. Le Traon, P. Gaspar, E. Bouyssel and H. Makhmara, Using Topex/Poseidon Data to Enhance ERS-1 Data, Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology., vol. 12, pp. 161-170, February, 1995. P. Bahural, In ESA SP-1176/11, New Views of the Earth. Application Achievements of ERS-1, ESA publication division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, February, 1996. P. De Mey, Forecasting and nowcasting with regional and global ocean data assimilation systems (ODAS), In proceedings EuroGOOS. Operational Oceanography, The Challengejbr European Co-operation, pp. 263-268, 1996. D.B. Chelton and M.G. Schlax, Global observations of Oceanic Rossby Waves, Science, 272, pp. 234-238, 1996. P.D. Cipollini, D. Cromwell and G.D. Quartly, Variability of Rossby wave propagation in the North Atlantic from TOPEX/POSEIDON Altimetry, Proceedings ~?[IGARSS'96, Lincoln, Nebraska, vol. I, pp. 91-93, 1996. ESA SP-414, t'roceedings ~>[Third ERS-I Symposium, Space at the service of our environment, ESA publication division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, vol I, II and III,May, 1997. O.M.Johannessen, S. Sandven, and V. Melentyev, ICEWATCH: Ice SAR Monitoring of the Northern Sea Route, ESA SP-383, Proceedings Second International Workshop on ERS Applications, ESA publication division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, February, 1996a. O.M.Johannessen, E. Bj~rgo, L.H. Pettersson, S.Sandven, E. Korsbakken, A. Jenkins, P. Samuel, G. Evensen, H. Espedal, and T. Hamre, Proposed strategy for the use of remote sensing in EuroGOOS In proceedings EuroGOOS. Operational Oceanography, The Challenge.fbr European Co-operation, pp. 93-114, 1996b. J.R. Bidlot et al., Wave modelling and operational forecasting at ECMWF, In proceedings" EuroGOOS. Operational Oceanography, The Challenge for European Cooperation, pp. 115-122, 1996b. G.J. Wensink et al., The bathymetry assessment system, In proceedings EuroGOOS. Operational Oceanography, The Challenge for European Co-operation, pp. 123-130, 1996. ESA SP-1196, Reports for Assessment. The Nine Candidate Earth Explorer Missions, ESA publ. div., vol. 1-9, Noordwijk, The Netherlands, 1996. ESA SP-1186, Report of the Earth Observation User Consultation Meeting, ESA publ. div., Noordwijk, The Netherlands, 1994.
192
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
A r e v i e w o f the possible a p p l i c a t i o n s o f satellite earth o b s e r v a t i o n data within E u r o G O O S Ola M. Johannessen '), Lasse H. Pettersson, Einar Bjorgo, Heidi Espedal, Geir Evensen, Torill Hamre, Alastair Jenkins, Erik Korsbakken, Paul Samuel, and Stein Sandven Nansen Environmental and Remote Sensing Center Edvard Griegsvei 3a, N-5037 Bergen-Solheimsviken, Norway. *) also at Geophysical Institute, University of Bergen.
This paper summarise the current and near future marine applications of satellite earth observation (EO) within the five defined modules of EuroGOOS. The conclusions indicate that several applications of EO data are beneficial or even exclusive for efficient information retrieval. The ultimate use of EO data will be most beneficial through an integrated use with field observations, numerical prediction models, using advanced data assimilation techniques. The operationalization of EO data in the EuroGOOS context has perspectives in current applications, near future operational implementation and longer term development, both with respect to development of methods and new sensor technologies.
1. STATE OF THE ART Remote sensing will play a key part in the marine monitoring activities defined within the Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS) as incorporated into EuroGOOS [Woods et al., 1996]. Considerable economic and social benefits are expected from operational services as numerical coupled forecast models will improve, partly due to more frequent and higher quality remote sensing data and advanced assimilation techniques to fully utilise the information content in these data. This will benefit and increase safety for the operations of the merchant fleet, fishing-, offshore- and aquaculture-industries. It will also improve management of coastal zones, provide an early warning of floods, protect the marine environment and improve monitoring of large-scale climate change. Remote sensing techniques have, over the last two decades or so, been developed to the stage that reliable information products of ocean wind, waves, sea surface temperature, ice conditions, eddy and frontal location and propagation as well as water quality parameters can be produced routinely from various earth observation (EO) sensors [e.g. Ikeda and Dobson, 1995]. So far the most frequent variables retrieved from satellite sensors used in national and international pre-operational or operational applications are related to wind, waves, temperature and sea ice conditions. Figure 1 gives a summary of the main geophysical features and processes that can be observed with different satellite remote sensing sensor systems and processing tools available today. Using remote sensing EO data it is important to
193
consider that satellites observe only the ocean surface. In order to achieve three-dimensional marine information and forecasts, remote sensing data together with in-situ data must be assimilated in numerical models. Hence an integrated approach is essential in order to take advantage of the information embodied in satellite EO data for the ocean and coastal regions. !
GEOPHYSICAL VARIABLES & FEATURES
SURFACE REMOTE SENSING MONITORING USING Visible Thermal Passive SAR Radar Near IR IR MicroW. Altimeter
Scatterometer
TEMPERATURE FRONTS CURRENT FRONTS
~t
MESO-SCALE EDDIES UPWELLING WIND FRONTS
dip
WIND SPEED WIND DIRECTION SURFACE WAVES INTERNAL WAVES WATER QUALITY
dip dip dip dip dip dip dip dip
dip dip dip
dip dip
dip
AI.GAE BI.OOMS
dip dip
SURFACTANTS
Oil. SPlI.L TURBIDITY / St'DIMFNTS !!!
SEA ICE
l('l:, CONCIiNTRATION
9
ICE TYPI-S
dip dip
dip
dip
dip
ICE MOTION ICl- i-IXiE
* 9Cloud-free and/or Daylight Dependent
9
9 ~:
dip dip
dip
Cloud and Daylight Independent
Figure 1 Geophysical oceanographic features and processes observed by remote sensing techniques. Based on Johannessen et al. [1993].
2. SATELLITE E A R T H O B S E R V A T I O N A P P L I C A T I O N S Within the EuroGOOS framework, five major application modules are defined for marine and coastal monitoring and forecasting [Woods et al., 1996]: 1. Climate monitoring, assessment and prediction
2. Monitoring and assessment of marine living resources 3. Monitoring o f the coastal zone environment and its changes 4. Assessment and prediction of the health of the ocean 5. Marine meteorological and oceanographic operational services
194 To monitor key parameters relevant to the five EuroGOOS modules, a wide range of satellite systems and sensors are available or will become available within the next few years. Large-, regional- and meso-scale weather and ocean features in the European waters can be monitored by polar orbiting EO satellites with sensors operating in a wide range of the electromagnetic spectrum. Passive or active microwave sensors acquire data independent of daylight and clouds, ideal for high latitude observations of sea ice and climate change monitoring, but are also used to monitor wind, waves, ocean currents and oil spills. Visual and infra-red (IR) sensors monitor sea surface temperature, fronts, currents, eddies and ocean colour. Small-scale features such as local pollution and floods can be monitored with polar orbiting radar and high-resolution visual satellite sensors. In the following, we will give examples of satellite-retrieved products mainly from European waters which can be applied or developed for application within the defined goals of the five EuroGOOS modules. 2.1 Surface Wind The sea-surface wind can be mapped at global-, regional- and meso-scales with various microwave satellite EO sensors, such as the scatterometer, microwave radiometer, radar altimeter and the Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) sensors. The radar scatterometer on e.g. the European ERS satellites provides global and regionalscale estimates of wind speed and direction, at a resolution of 50 km, covering a swath width of 500 km with an accuracy of +2 m/s and 20 ~ [Topliss and Guymer, 1995]. These wind estimates are obtained using empirical algorithms and calibrated by field measurements, and the data are also use in operational forecasting services by European meteorological services [e.g. Paci and Campbell, 1996, Breivik et al., 1996] Wind speeds at global scale are also available from radar altimeters on currently ERS-2 and TOPEX/Poseidon satellites. The resolution is typically about 7 km along-track and the track spacing varying with latitude and satellite orbit, being typically a few tens of kilometres in European waters. Measurements of brightness temperature (emissivity) using e.g. the Defense Meteorological Satellite Program (DMSP) Special Sensor Microwave/Imager (SSM/I) passive microwave radiometer, the wind speed can be estimated at global and regional scales with a resolution of 50 km over a swath width of 1400 km. Empirical algorithms have been developed for retrieval of the wind speed. At regional and meso-scales, the SAR sensors on the ERS-2, JERS-1, Radarsat, and ENVISAT (from 1999) satellite, can be used to estimate the wind speed and direction, with a spatial resolution down to a few kilometres. Wind information at this high spatial resolution is required for coastal and marginal ice zone applications, where the resolution and reliability of the wind scatterometer is too coarse, see Figure 2. Near-surface wind parameters retrieved from satellites will play an important role in
EuroGOOS modules 1, 3 and 5.
195
Figure 2: Velocity wind field derived from an ERS-1 SAR image (left) on September 17, 1995. Wind speed ranges from 7 to 13 m/s. SAR wind vectors derived from two SAR passes, each 300 by 100 km, off the coast of southwest Norway. Red arrows indicate the standard meteorological information.
2.2 Ocean Waves
Routine global and regional measurements of significant wave height are currently available from the radar altimeters on ERS-2 and TOPEX/Poseidon satellites. Wave period and direction can be derived from satellite SAR sensors. Present operational services include assimilation of satellite radar altimeter derived significant wave heights into regional wave forecasting models, and significant improvements in the wave analysis and short-term forecasts for the North Sea have been achieved [Breivik et al., 1996]. The several RA sensors available over the last 20 years (ERS-1/2, TOPEX/Poseidon, Geosat, Seasat, GEOS-3) provide significant climatological wave height information (as well as wind speed) [Paci and Campbell, 1996]. With careful inter-calibration between the different RA instruments, these data provide a unique long term data series. The use of significant wave height from radar altimeter data in conjunction with ERS scatterometer data for wind, produces encouraging improvements in wave prediction models [Le Meur et al., 1996]. The ERS SAR image mode data coverage, with a 100 km swath width, is still rather limited for regional and meso-scale applications, although at larger spatial scales the ERS SAR Wave Mode provides 5x5 km large images about every 200 km along the satellite track. SAR wave mode data are currently used as supplementary information to improve forecast wave directions in operational wave prediction models. Figure 3 shows swell waves breaking on the shorelines of Norway, including the effects of depth refraction, shadowing and diffraction. Climatological wave height information is applicable for offshore oil industry design and operational planning purposes, as well as for coastal engineering design, marine and harbour
196
Figure 3:ERS-1 SAR image off western Norway, showing the island of Fedje in the left part of the image and the oil refinery at Mongstad. Swell waves can be seen propagating in from the Norwegian Sea on the left, breaking on the rocky shores in the west, and shadowing and possibly diffraction of the waves by reefs, shorelines and islands can be seen. (Image width 25.6 km). Copyright 9ESA.
architecture, ship routing etc. under EuroGOOS module I. The ability of SAR in detailed mapping of the wave fields near shorelines is useful in monitoring the coastal environment and its changes, studies of wave refraction by bottom features, evolution and changes of sandbank locations in shallow-water areas, as well as in charting bathymetry in poorlysurveyed regions, all applicable within EuroGOOS module 3. The operational and preoperational wave information products mentioned above are applicable within the EuroGOOS module 5.
2.3 Ocean dynamics 2.3.1 Sea surface temperature
Earth observation satellite sensor systems developed primarily for operational meteorological applications have proved to also be efficiently used in operational oceanography. The thermal infrared channels of e.g. the NOAA AVHRR (Advanced Very High-Resolution Radiometer) and from the ERS ATSR (Along Track Scanning Radiometer) sensor systems provide information on the sea surface temperature (SST) distribution at scales down to 1 km and at an accuracy of 0.2~ under cloud-free conditions. The SST embodies significant information related to a wide range of marine environmental phenomenon, including information on e.g. coastal and meso-scale circulation ( Figure 4). [Johannessen and Mork, 1979; Johannessen et al., 1993], regional ocean circulation
197 [Johannessen, 1986], fisheries [Pettersson, 1990], algae blooms (see Figure 7) [Dundas et al., 1989], the marginal ice zone [Johannessen et al., 1987], as well as for global climate studies [Reynolds, 1989] and EO data assimilation in physical ocean circulation models [Stanev, 1994]. Remote sensing of sea surface temperature fits into EuroGOOS modules 1, 3 and 5.
Figure 4: One of the first thermal infrared satellite images published to document the meso-scale meanders and eddies of the Norwegian Coastal Current [Johannessen and Mork, 1979].
2.3.2 Ocean circulation features
Satellite radar altimetry provides estimates of the sea surface topography, which is related to large-scale geostrophic currents, meso-scale features (jets, fronts and eddies), tides and the marine geoid. Tidal signatures can be singled out and altimetry thus represents a new data source for tidal predictions, particularly in the open ocean and in remote areas where conventional data are sparse [Andersen et al., 1995]. The variability of the radar altimeter height measurements at one location is due to changes in the sea surface topography, caused by the ocean circulation and its eddy kinetic energy [Samuel et al., 1994]. Altimetry measurements can be used to produce estimates of the instantaneous geostrophic current velocity field (see Figure 5).
Figure 5: Geostrophic current velocity field in March, 1988, computed from the mean sea surface elevation from the OPYC model and sea surface height anomalies from the Geosat altimeter [Samuel et al., 1994].
198 Under certain environmental conditions the SAR is able to image the surface signature of ocean circulation features such as eddies, meanders, fronts and jets, thereby providing qualitative information on their structure and evolution [Johannessen et al., 1994; Johannessen et al., 1996b]. Many of the ocean circulation features cause various signals, both resolvable as differences in temperature, colour and current shear, this encourage a multi-EO sensors approach for analysis of various ocean dynamic parameters. Such combined information are advantageous under different environmental conditions and therefore well suited for operational use (Figure 6) [Johannessen et al. 1996b]. Satellite monitoring of ocean circulation features as described here fits primarily in EuroGOOS modules 3 and 5.
Figure 6: Expressions of the Norwegian Coastal Front on October 3, 1992 in a NOAA AVHRR image at 14:20 UTC (left) and a SAR image acquired at 21:35 UTC. Both images cover the same 100 km by 300 km region. From Johannessen et al. [1993]. Copyright 9ESA/NERSC.
2.4 Water quality Mapping and monitoring of the "water quality", involves a wide range of marine environmental parameters. Limited to the possible applications of satellite EO data, the "water quality" term is primarily related to harmful algae blooms, sedimentation, suspended or dissolved particulate pollution from various sources, and surface films or surfactants, including oil pollution. 2.4.1 Algae Blooms An algae bloom may have sub-surface peak bloom, and hence is not always fully detectable from above, but an integrated surface signal from the Chlorophyll-a pigment causes the ocean colour signal. The light absorption characteristics of phytoplankton and other optical active water constituents is a basis for use of ocean colour satellite sensors. The US Coastal Zone Colour Sensor (CZCS) from 1978-86 demonstrated the usefulness of this type
199
of earth observation technique to map the world-wide distribution of marine chlorophyll. In the open ocean, the ocean optics are not as complex as in the coastal areas, where sediments and dissolved organic matter significantly impact the radiation signal measured by the satellite earth observing sensors. The algae themselves have limited moving capabilities and hence a measure of the advection of water masses with an identified bloom may be done indirectly through monitoring of the ocean circulation. Under favourable cloud-free conditions, thermal infrared earth observation data may be used to map the meso-scale ocean circulation patterns, boundaries and advection water masses and ocean fronts, using consecutive images over the same area. An example of operational use of this type of satellite data during an outbreak of a harmful algae bloom resolves the variability in the sea surface temperature during six consecutive images covering the southern part of Norway during a 15 days period in MayJune 1988 (Figure 7) [Dundas et al., 1989].
Figure 7: Time series of AVHRR thermal infrared images during the toxic bloom of Chrysocromulina polylepis in Norwegian waters in May, 1988. During this event the advection of warm coastal waters and the toxic algae front turned out to be coherent. The arrows indicate the advection of the warm water front in the Norwegian Coastal Current.
Spaceborne ocean colour sensor systems had not been available through the last decade since CZCS. During just the last 2 years, two ocean colour sensors have become available on research satellites - the Indian Modular Optoelectronic Scanner (MOS) and Japanese Ocean Colour and Thermal Sensor (OCTS). During the next several years, several ocean colour sensors are planned to be launched by most major space agencies. Algae monitoring using satellite ocean colour EO techniques fits into the EuroGOOS modules 2, 3, 4 and 5.
2.4. 2 Oil slicks and Natural film The major oil spills at sea polluting the marine environment to a varying degree are from e.g. tanker accidents (Figure 8) or spills from fixed installations. Regular oil releases from ships in transit, e.g. when cleaning tanks, are a smaller but more frequent source of pollution,
200
taking into account how often such spills occur during regular ship operations also in marginal seas. Spaceborne radar (SAR) sensors are used operationally to detect and monitor such types of marine oil spills. It has been documented that the SAR has the capability to detect oil spills at high spatial resolution (30 m), even in the presence of cloud cover. Tromse Satellite Station in Norway is running a near real time oil spill detection demonstration service which started in 1994 [Pedersen et al., 1996]. The main goal of this service is to provide the user community with reliable information on possible oil spills within two hours after the satellite has passed over the area.
Figure 8:ERS-1 SAR image of the bay of La Coruna, Spain, taken on December 13, 1992, 10 days after the accident with the oil tanker "Aegean Sea". Copyright 9ESA.
The challenge in detecting oil slicks on the ocean surface using satellite SAR images lies in distinguishing oil from other environmental phenomena with similar effects. Oil slick lookalikes may include natural film, grease ice, threshold wind speed areas, wind sheltering by land, rain cells, current shear zones, internal waves and upwelling [Hovland-Espedal et al., 1994]. In addition, natural film on the ocean surface influences air-sea fluxes of momentum, latent heat and gases. Satellite based SAR may prove to be very useful, and perhaps the only means to quantifying global scale natural film distribution. Satellite remote sensing of natural or man made surface slicks fits into EuroGOOS modules 1, 3, 4 and 5. 2.5 Sea ice
2.5.1 Ship routing Satellite data are considered the most important, and often the only, source of input to national weather services producing ice maps for remote areas. European ice services in Russia, Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Germany and Norway use AVHRR and SSM/I data to regularly produce large-scale ice maps. The first use of ERS-1 SAR data in the Northern Sea Route took place during L'Astrolabe's 1991 expedition [Johannessen et al., 1992b]. In 1995, a co-operation between the European Space Agency (ESA) and the Russian Space Agency (RKA) was established for joint use of satellite ice monitoring data in the Northern Sea Route in support of ship navigation [Johannessen et al., 1996c].
201 Based on the differences in the radar backscatter characteristics caused by the various ice types and conditions, the ERS SAR demonstrates good capability to distinguish between the main ice types such as the ice edge, multi-year ice, first-year ice, young ice and new-frozen ice [Johannessen et al., 1996c]. Different classes (Figure 9), forms and features of ice can also be identified such as fast ice, drifting ice, river ice, shear zones, leads, polynyas, ice topography (ridges and hummocks) and ice edge processes. However, in many cases the SAR backscatter data are ambiguous and it is difficult to classify ice the types correctly without additional information. This is particularly the problem for identification of various stages of young ice and firstyear ice, for quantification of surface roughness and to distinguish ice and open water during melt conditions. In spite of some limitations, the ERS SAR has proven to be a very useful instrument which can provide quantitative data on most of the important ice parameters except ice thickness. Interpreted images and maps can be distributed in near realtime to icebreakers, oil exploration ships or platforms, fishing vessels, rescue services, coast guard, Navy, research vessels, cruise ships and other vessels within 2-3 hours after the satellite overpass. In the future, more accurate information on many ice parameters may be retrieved from EO data sources. Higher resolution images will contribute to considerable improvement of ship navigation based on information about ice types, leads and ice ridges. Information on ice thickness may be provided in the future using new developed EO instruments based on laserand radar-altimetry technology. Ice monitoring services fits within EuroGOOS module 5.
Figure 9: SAR image of November 4, 1993 used to find the best route for Russian vessel Sovetsky Soyuz, during her eastward voyage. Navigating through the lead denoted A-B-C, along the Taymyr coast, past Cape Chelyuskin, consisting of 15-30 cm thick ice only a few days old was much faster and less difficult and hazardous than alternative routes. Copyright 9ESA/NERSC.
2.5.2 Arctic climate
Sea ice has been routinely monitored by passive microwave sensors since 1973, with a short gap from 1976-78. Several studies looked into the extent and variability of the Arctic sea
202 ice as measured from the NOAA Electrically Scanning Microwave Radiometer (ESMR) and Scanning Multi-frequency Microwave Radiometer (SMMR) and the DMSP SSM/I sensor. Figure 10 shows sea ice concentrations during winter and summer conditions obtained from SSM/I. Long time series are preferable for producing reliable high-quality time series of Arctic sea ice [Johannessen et al., 1996a] in order to study climate variability. Recent analyses of Arctic time series combine data from SMMR and SSM/I to generate a time series from 1978 to present [Bjorgo et al., 1997]. Statistical analysis of the data show a statistically significant decrease of 5.7 % in Arctic sea ice extent over the last two decades. Large scale operational monitoring of Arctic sea ice as described here fits into E u r o G O O S module 1.
Figure 10: Arctic sea ice extent from passive microwave satellites. Monthly average of 1993 March (left) and September (right) ice conditions. White indicates 100 sea ice concentration.
3. DATA ASSIMILATION Over the last decade there has been a rapid development of various data assimilation methods for use of satellite EO information within ocean and ecosystem models. At present, none of these methods are used operationally. The currently available data assimilation applications for Ocean General Circulation Models (OGCMs) are based on rather simplistic assimilation schemes, which do not take into account proper error statistics. The limitations are due to strong non-linearity of the meso-scale ocean dynamics and huge numerical load associated with such modelling. Currently, the most relevant EO data to be assimilated in operational ocean models are the radar altimeter data, sea surface temperatures or sea ice information. These data are already available for use in pre-operational data assimilation systems, however in an operational system, the access time and observation frequency becomes important. Real-time analyses and predictions of meteorological parameters must be used to ensure a proper forcing of the model in order to generate realistic predictions of the marine system. To better assimilate the information of the ocean states, an Ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF) has recently been proposed [Evensen, 1994]. This methodology has proven to be very efficient when used with less complicated, but still non-linear dynamical models. There is a
203 significant ongoing development of advanced data assimilation methods for OGCMs. Figure 11 shows a snapshot of the upper layer stream function where Geosat altimeter data are assimilated into a two-layer circulation model for the Agulhas Current south of South Africa. Operational EO data assimilation fits primarily into EuroGOOS modules 1, 3 and 5.
Figure 11: Assimilation of Geosat altimeter height anomalies in a multi-layer quasi-geostrophic model for the Agulhas retroflection area. The model runs with assimilated EO data gave more realistic predictions (shown) of the upper layer stream functions [Evensen and Van Leeuwen, 1996].
4. CONCLUSION Satellite remote sensing should play a key part in all five EuroGOOS modules. Table 1 gives an overview of which satellite remote sensing products are operational today and which will be operational in the near future. As seen in the table, these are products that all fit in the five EuroGOOS strategy modules. By focusing on applied research toward operational services, remote sensing will, in synergy with field observations and modelling data, contribute to benefit individual industries and activities as listed in Woods et al. [1996]. It is important that relations between the remote sensing and user communities be further developed and that focus be set on future user needs. EuroGOOS provides an excellent means for developing existing and future operational satellite remote sensing oceanography products.
204 Table 1: Overview of the status of remote sensing products and applications relevant to the five EuroGOOS modules.
EuroGOOS Module
Products and applications
1, 4 , 5 1,5
Global sea surface temperature Large scale wind speed Large scale wind direction Local wind velocity Global significant wave height Local wave spectra Global mean sea level Large scale currents Meso-scale circulation Phytop, lankton "Water quality'" Oil spill and surfactants Sea ice kinematics Sea ice classification Sea ice extent Ship routing in sea ice
1,5
1, 5 5 1 1, 5 2, 3, 4 3, 4
1, 3, 4, 5
1, 5 1, 5 1, 5 5
NOTES: ,/' Good Requires improvements
Data available Present 4" 4"
Future 4" 4"
=~ 4"
4" 4"
=~ =~
4" 4"
=~ ~ ~
,/" ,/" ,/ 4"
4"
4" ,/
Assimilation in models Present 4"
Future 4" ,/"
4"
4" 4" ,/" 4"
~
~
4" ,/ ,/ 4" 4' 4'
The five EuroGOOS modules:
1. Climate monitoring, assessment and prediction 2. Monitoring and assessment of marine living resources 3. Monitoring of the coastal zone environment and its changes 4. Assessment and prediction of the health of the ocean 5. Marine meteorological and oceanographic operational services
REFERENCES Andersen, O.B., Woodworth, P.L., and Flather, R.A. (1995), lntercomparison of recent ocean tide models, J. Geophys. Res., 100(C12), pp.25261-25282. Bjergo, E., Johannessen, O.M., Miles, M., 1997: Analysis of merged SMMR-SSM/I time series of Arctic and Antarctic Sea ice parameters, 1978 -1995. Geophysical Research Letters 24, pp. 413-416. Breivik, L.A., Reistad, M., Schuyberg, H., and Sunde, J. (1996), Application of ocean surface wind and wave information from ERS in atmosphere and ocean monitoring and numerical forecast models, in Proc. Second ERS Applications Workshop, London, 6-8 December, 1995, number ESA SP-383, pp. 61-64, ESA Publications Division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands. Dundas, I., Johannessen, O.M., Berge, G., and Heimdal, B. (1989), Toxic algal bloom in Scandinavian waters, May-June 1988, Oceanography, 2(1). Evensen, G. (1994), Inverse methods and data assimilation in nonlinear ocean models, Physica D, 77, pp.108129, Review article. Evensen, G. and van Leeuwen, P.J. (1996), Assimilation of Geosat altimeter data for the Agulhas current using the ensemble Kalman filter with a quasi-geostrophic model, Mon. Weather Rev., 124, pp.85-96. Hovland-Espedal, H.A., Johannessen, J.A., and Digranes, G. (1994), Slick detection in SAR images, in Proc. IGARSS'94, IEEE Press. Ikeda, M. and Dobson, F.W., editors (1995), Oceanographic Applications of Remote Sensing, CRC Press, Boca Raton.
205
Johannessen, J.A., Roed, L.P., Johannessen, O.M., Evensen, G., Hackett, B., Pettersson, L.H., Haugan, P.M., Sandven, S., and Shuchman, R. (1993), Monitoring and modeling of the marine coastal environment, Photogrammetric Eng. and Remote Sensing, 59(3), pp. 351-361. Johannessen, J.A., Vachon, P.W., and Johannessen, O.M. (1994), ERS-1 SAR imaging of marine boundary layer processes, Earth Observation Quarterly, 46. Johannessen, O.M. (1986), Brief overview of the physical oceanography, in The Nordic Seas, chapter4, pp. 103127, Springer-Verlag, New York. Johannessen, O.M., Bj~rgo, E., and Miles, M. (1996a), Operational climate monitoring of the Arctic ice cover, This issue. Johannessen, O.M., Johannessen, J.A., Svendsen, E., Shuchman, R.A., Campbell, W.J., and Josberger, E. (1987), Ice-edge eddies in the Fram Strait marginal ice zone, Science, 236, pp. 427-439. Johannessen, O.M., Korsbakken, E., Samuel, P., Jenkins, A.D., and Espedal, H.A. (1996b), COAST WATCH: Using SAR in an operational system for monitoring coastal currents wind, surfactants and oilspiil, This issue. Johannessen, O.M. and Mork, M. (1979), Remote sensing experiment in the Norwegian Coastal Waters, Technical Report 3/79, Geophysical Institute, University of Bergen. Johannessen, O.M., Sandven, S., Skagseth, tO., Kloster, K., Kovacs, Z., Sauvadet, P., Geli, L., Weeks, W., and Louet, J. (1992b), ERS-I SAR ice routing of L'Astrolabe through the Northeast Passage, in Central Symposium of the 'International Space Year', Munich, Germany, ESA, SP-431. Johannessen, O.M. et al. (1996c), ICEWATCH - Ice SAR monitoring of the Northern Sea Route, This issue. Le Meur, D., Roquet, H., and Lef6vre, J.-M. (1996), Use of ERS wind and wave data for numerical wave modelling at Meteo-France, in Proc. Second ERS Applications Workshop, London, 6-8 December, 1995,. number ESA SP-383, pp. 53-56, ESA Publications Division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands. Paci, G. and Campbell, G. (1996), Operational use of ERS-I products in marine applications, in Proc. Second ERS Applications Workshop, London, 6-8 December, 1995, number ESA SP-383, pp. 43-46, ESA Publications Division, Noordwijk, The Netherlands. Pedersen, J.P., Seijelv, L.G., Bauna, T., Strom, G.D., Follum, O.A., Andersen, J.H., Wahl, T., and Skoelv, A. (1996), Towards an operational oil spill detection service in the Mediterranean? The Norwegian experience: A pre-operational early warning detection service using ERS SAR data, in Proc. ERS Thematic Workshop on Oil Pollution Monitoring in the Mediterranean, Frascati, Italy, ESA. Pettersson, L.H. (1990), Application of remote sensing to fisheries. Vol.l, Technical Report EUR 12867 EN, Commission of the European Community, Joint Research Centre, Ispra, Italy. Reynolds, R.W. (1989), A real-time global sea surface temperature analysis, J. Climate, 1, pp. 75-86. Samuel, P., Johannessen, J.A., and Johannessen, O.M. (1994), A study on the inflow of Atlantic water to the GIN Sea using GEOSAT atimeter data, in Nansen Centennial Volume on the Role of the Polar Oceans in Shaping the Global Environment, edited by Johannessen, O.M., Overland, J.E., and Muench, R., number85 in Geophysical Monograph, American Geophysical Union. Stanev, E.V. (1994), Assimilation of sea surface temperature data in a numerical ocean circulation model. A study of the water mass formation, in Data Assimilation: Tools for Modelling the Ocean in a Global Change Perspective, edited by Brasseur, P.P. and Nihoul, J. C.J., volume 119 of NATO ASI, pp. 33-58, SpringerVerlag Berlin Heidelberg. Topliss, B.J. and Guymer, T.H. (1995), Marine winds from scatterometers, in Oceanographic Applications of Remote Sensing, edited by lkeda, M. and Dobson, F.W., chapterl 3, pp. 205-222, CRC Press, Boca Raton. Woods, J., Dahlin, H., Droppert, L., Glass, M., Vallerga, S., and Flemming, N. (1996), The strategy for EuroGOOS, EuroGOOS publication no. 1, Southampton Oceanography Centre, Southampton, ISBN 0904175-22-7.
206
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
W a v e m o d e l l i n g a n d o p e r a t i o n a l f o r e c a s t i n g at E C M W F J.-R. Bidlot, B. Hansen, P.A.E.M. Janssen European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts, Shinfield Park, Reading, RG2 9AX, United Kingdom. E-mail: Jean.Bidlot @ecmwf.int
This paper presents the operational wave forecasting system at ECMWF. The range of potential applications for the global ECMWF wave model has exceeded the original expectations of merely producing reasonable wave forecasts and now can be viewed as an indispensable tool for the production of high-quality dynamically consistent data sets for the ocean surface. A few examples are given. We also reiterate the need for more real time wave data for the continuation of wave model development.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Over the years, accurate weather forecasts have become an essential tool for any ocean users, equally important is the current and future knowledge of the ocean state. However, even now with the advent of operational remote sensing of the oceans, a relatively small portion of the ocean surface is observed (even less for the ocean interior) and large parts of the oceans remain unobserved. It is therefore imperative to develop methods to optimally use this limited amount of observations if ocean forecasts are to be improved. Operational numerical models can actually provide the necessary tools to rapidly combine observations in a manner consistent with the dynamics of the system and fill in the missing information. Besides providing useful analysis tools, models should also deliver reliable forecasts for the coming days. It is with this forecast reliability that ECMWF has set up its wave forecasting system. As it is, the best estimates for present and future sea states are determined by combining observations and model initial prediction (first guess). This assimilation process yields analysed fields, reconstructing initial conditions closest to reality, that should lead to better forecasts. However, the capabilities of the ECMWF wave model are not limited to simply generating analysis followed by forecasts, products which are by themselves valuable for the shipping industry, fisheries, and offshore operators, but the system is also useful for the quality control of the observations by using the model as a monitoring tool. A brief description of the ECMWF operational wave forecasting system is given in section 2. This is followed, in section 3, by a few examples of how a numerical model can be an essential part of global observing system. Final remarks are gathered in section 4.
207
2. O P E R A T I O N A L WAVE F O R E C A S T I N G AT E C M W F In the past decade, we have seen considerable progress in the field of ocean wave modelling. In the middle of the 1980's, a group of wave modellers set up the third generation wave model WAM which solves the energy balance equation for surface gravity waves including nonlinear wave-wave interactions (Komen et al., 1994). An operational version of the numerical code is maintained at ECMWF. Since November 1991, cycle 4 of the W A M model has been running operationally at ECMWF. It has been implemented on the globe with a current resolution of 1.50 and on the Mediterranean and Baltic Sea with a resolution of 0.25 ~ A 10-day forecast is issued once a day following a one-day analysis, which uses analysed E C M W F wind fields and ERS altimeter wave data. Integrated parameters such as significant wave height, mean wave period, and mean wave direction (for total, windsea and swell) are disseminated once a day to the E C M W F member states involved in the wave projects. Furthermore, E C M W F archives all integrated parameters for the analysis and forecasts every 6 hrs., while the analysed two-dimensional wave spectrum is stored once a day. In addition, monthly means have been archived since January 1995. Examples of the type of fields that can be retrieved are presented in figures 1. An extensive verification of the wave forecasting system has recently been carried out (Janssen et al. 1997), and shows the net improvement of the system over the years to an extent that we have an improved confidence in the model analysis and forecast results.
Figure 1a. Significant wave height field as produced by the analysis of the ECMWF wave forecasting system for the globe. Contour spacing is 1 meter. Date and time are as indicated.
208
Figure 1b. Wave height field as produced by the analysis of the ECMWF wave forecasting system for the Mediterranean Sea. Contour spacing is 1 meter. Date and time are as indicated. Note the exceptionally high sea state. 3. B E N E F I T S F R O M T H E O P E R A T I O N A L WAVE M O D E L It is obvious that for economical and safety reasons an accurate knowledge of the present and future sea states is essential. Such global knowledge should directly benefit the maritime industries. As an example, we have presented in figure 2a the root mean square error obtained when wave height analysis and forecasts are compared with buoy observations for a period of 13 months. It shows the deterioration of the wave forecast after day 4 or 5. Similar conclusions were also reached by comparing the forecasts with the corresponding verifying analysis. By looking at statistics such as the anomaly correlation (normalised correlation of forecast anomaly and verifying anomaly with respect to climatology, Janssen et al. 1997), it was shown that useful forecasts are generally produced up to day 5 for the northern hemisphere, up to day 7 in the tropics and up to day 4.5 for the southern hemisphere.
Figure 2a. Root mean square error for wave height obtained from the comparison of the wave analysis and forecasts with observations at 30 buoys from 9511 to 9611. For details on the buoys see the legend of figure 2b.
209 WAVE HEIGHT BIAS from January 1995 to J u l y 1996 - e9 -
0.5
all
HW
--i-
-*-
NPC
JAPAN ~
.-E3- USWC - o -
USEC " ~ ' - NEATL
0.25
~
A
E
o ,
(n
..... "
_< m
-~ -_~ ~
~
~ "
-0.25
"
\
~
:
-
'
"
-0.5
'
_
@
1t....
~
-:...at ......nl
-
"
~ . ~ . . . ~ .." ""z"l~.. " ....: . . . . . . "ix" ,,A,..... ..... ........
_ _ _ , L ' - _ ."
......... ...'" ..,A.,
..Jr ..... ~ . .
dr
,~
-0.75 t"" , .....$ .... , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan fob mar ,,ix may Jun Jul aug eel) oct nov dec Jan feb mar six may Jun iul
months
WAVE HEIGHT RMSE from January 1995 to J u l y 1996 -e-9
all
-!
HW
-4k- JAPAN -IN-
L...... ,~ ..... , .....,
0.75
Or)
NPC E l
USWC - O - USEC--r
NEATL
/t
~' .......A
-
/ \
. . i
n
0.5 "'It'"
rr
,,.
_
. ....
0.25
Jan feb m,,r six m,,y Jun JuI aug sop oct nov dec Jan feb mar six rely Jun Jul
months
WAVE HEIGHT SYMMETRIC SLOPE from J a n u a r y 1995 to July 1996 1.2
--e-
all
--ll-
HW
--4,- JAPAN --iN- NPC
~
USWC - O - USEC " ~ " NEATI.
1.1
Z. ...
M~
//*" " t
1 .
.~" 0
'.,<-.-II......
.
9
nt -*,/
0.8 . . . . . . . 0"71-n feb mar ~
~
i"
4..
"-
~ .....
~9.....
r -* \
. ~ __ '
/I \
~
..,,,...a ....I:'. "
/ @,~
/ ...11:..,
..~ ..........
" ~ ' _ ~
,, .......
m;ly Jun JuI l u g ~
oct nov c l ~ Jan fol) m'sr II~x m~'y Jun IuI
months
Figure 2b. Time series of monthly statistics from the comparison of wave model analysis with observations at 30 ocean (deep water) buoys. The buoy data are obtained every hour via the GTS and a basic quality control procedure is used to remove outliers before averaging over 6 hour time windows which are centered around synoptic times. Bias, root mean square error (RMSE), and symmetric slope are plotted for all 30 buoys as well as for particular areas as Hawaii (HW, 4 buoys), Japan (2 buoys), the North Pacific (NPC, 5 buoys), off the West and East Coasts of the US (USWC, 6 buoys, USEC, 6 buoys) and the North East Atlantic (NEATL, 7 buoys). Negative bias denote lower model values with respect to the buoy observations.he symmetric slope is defined as the ratio of the sum of the squares of the model results with the sum of the squares of the observations The model products are also used to generate appropriate boundary conditions for regional models which, in turn, can produce high resolution forecasts useful to many coastal activities. In addition, a global wave model offers more potential applications which may well prove crucial if one wants to build a reliable global f r a m e w o r k for the observation and modelling of the oceans. A few examples are presented in the following sections.
210
3.1 Altimeter data monitoring In partnership with the European Space Agency (ESA), since the launch of ERS-1, ECMWF has been involved in the validation and the continuous quality monitoring of the real time altimeter wave and wind products. The quality of the ERS-1 observations was found to be satisfactory despite of the inherent underestimation of the wave height (Queuffeulou et al. 1996) and resulted in the use of those data in the wave model analysis. From August 1993 until April 30, 1996, ERS-1 altimeter wave heights were assimilated using the Optimal Interpolation scheme from Lionello et al. (1992). A detailed performance analysis is given in Janssen et al. (1997). The monitoring of the satellite data is twofold. Firstly, the altimeter observations are compared with the model first guess values (model field before the assimilation step). Secondly, the analysed and forecast fields are compared with independent ocean buoy data available on the Global Telecommunication System (GTS). This last comparison is unfortunately limited to the few regions where buoy data are made available (along the United States coasts, and around the British Isles and Japan). Should any alteration to the quality of the altimeter product result in changes in the wave products, then ESA will be notified promptly. Note that this exercise would certainly profit from increased data availability if more countries were to put their wave observations on GTS. Similarly, in this framework, the quality and suitability of the new ERS-2 altimeter data were evaluated during the ERS-2 commissioning phase. As one of the steps in that study, we performed parallel runs for December 1995 in which ERS-2 or no data were assimilated instead of ERS-1. By comparing the results with the model first guess and with buoy data, it was found that the use of ERS-2 wave data seemed to give better results, in particular for buoys located in the storm track areas. However, there is still a negative wave height bias (too low model values compared to buoy data) at those latter locations, while there is hardly any bias in areas dominated by swell. Most likely the negative bias is caused by a small underestimation of the wave height by the altimeter (as was the case for ERS-1). This subject is further discussed below. The favourable results lead to the prompt substitution of ERS-1 by ERS-2 in the data assimilation (on April 30, 1996). The effect of this reduced bias for the months following the switch to ERS-2 is clearly illustrated when the operational analysis is compared to buoy data (figure 2b), with a definite reduction of the model analysis bias, root mean square error and a more symmetric scatter as indicated by a symmetric slope closer to 1.
3.2 Buoy-altimeter data cross comparison In the ECMWF system, altimeter wave heights and winds are operationally gathered with the corresponding model values. Similarly, all buoy reports available on the GTS are collocated with the operational analysis. The idea is to merge those two sets of files to obtain corresponding buoy-altimeter collocations. A direct comparison of those 2 types of data is unwise as they may actually still contain erroneous data points and represent different time and spatial scales. In our system, the satellite data are in fact super observations obtained after quality check and along track-averaging of 30 consecutive data points (the super observations are used in the data assimilation). On the other hand, the hourly buoy data are as found on GTS. From the buoy model collocations, it is a simple matter to reconstruct hourly time series and use the time series themselves to perform a basic quality check on the data. This quality check procedure will only keep values that are within acceptable physical range (e.g., 0 < Hs < 25 m), will try to detect faulty instruments by
211 removing all constant records of over one day long, and will remove outliers by looking at the deviation from the mean of each monthly data record and from the deviation from one hourly value to the next. B u o y and altimeter data are then collocated if the satellite super observation falls within a selected radius from a buoy location and the corresponding buoy observation is then obtained by computing the average over a 6 hour time w i n d o w centered around the time of the satellite super observation. The corresponding model values at both locations are also added to the list. This way, an extra selection of the buoy-altimeter collocated data set is possible by discarding all data for which the relative difference between the two model values e x c e e d s a certain threshold. We believe that this extra information can be very useful in filtering out data that are not representative o f the same wave (or wind) system even though they fall well within the selection radius.
a)
1'~
;
1~
ersz
9
i
. . . . . ,I I
_
I
uF
. . . . .
i !, i i, i ! i ! i," , ] .. ,, - ,1 - - 7, - - ~, - - ~, - - ~ ,- - + -, ~, ; ~~..-./ ]; 1 ~- . . . . . II
+ . . . . .Ii I I ' I '-
-
I '
-i-
-
I
- -
8~-
~
,
'i
,
-'-
7/i-
-
, -. . . . .
/
;
,
3 - - *
00
i
1
I
:
l
,. . . . . .
' i
71
, i
,
I~ . . . . . iI
-
7
/ -
:
~
-
~t~It'~
-
i
-~ -
1 1 - '
+
I=
~
2
i
i
i
i
~-.~,.,~,+-
~
~
--r
,
~..
,
.. ,*" ~.:-OL...~.
o~
"
,'V-
-
-
[
- .
'
|
~- -
:
-
1
-
1
;
-
,
-
T
,
...... : ..... !
3
4
5
6
I
-
'
!
!
9
10
l
I
t
',
i, ' i
7
.
i i
~
I
",
I
.... t_
7
I
i
,
i
1
- - - t- ....
Hs (m)
i
/'l "
t . . . ,. , , . , . . i /
f..'/
I--~--,I.I..'~",---;--1
3
4
,
i
I
i
,I + '.'_l/ /'~'-;~ ll"""'~" -
'
I
_ ',
, +
3
11
i
i
. . . . . . . ~. . . . . . . . ,
2
8
ENTRIES = 2125 ALTIMETER MEAN = 2.140 STDEV = 1.088 B U O Y M E A N = 2 . 2 5 0 S T D E V = 1.277 F I T Y o n X (solid) : S L O P E = 0 . 8 3 0 I N T R = 0 . 2 7 2 F I T X o n Y (dash) :SLOPE = 1.143 INTR = -0.197 RMSE= 0.346 BIAS=-0.110 C O R R C O E F = 0 . 9 7 4 SI = 0 . 1 4 6 S Y M M E T R I C S L O P E (dot) = 0 . 9 2 8
buoy
.................. Ill ,l
1
-/-r
/
L.-"
.,:...~j~ i
i
8
00
-
~-- i "
t
9 -9
7
u'.YRe"
-
t
,O--er,:~2,,
r
-
+
,-+:.-L,'z;
Hs (m)
b)
I---I I/
I
I
.'#Y
I
/i r
'
I
~
'
;
.. /
_~- _-'~i,i,'Tf- . . . . .
'.,"r
~ ..... I
I
I I
I
5
6
7
I
8
I.
~
I
~-
_ -I
'
I
'
I
. . . .
I
I I
9
10
11
E N T R I E S = 1304 A L T I M E T E R M E A N = 2 . 6 9 8 S T D E V = 1.051 B U O Y M E A N = 2.941 S T D E V = 1 . 1 5 9 F I T Y o n X (solid) : S L O P E = 0 . 8 7 9 I N T R = 0 . 1 1 3 F I T X o n Y (dash) : S L O P E = 1 . 0 6 8 I N T R --- 0 . 0 5 9 RMSE = 0.383 BIAS = -0.243 C O R R C O E F = 0 . 9 6 9 SI = 0 . 1 0 0 S Y M M E T R I C S L O P E (dot) = 0 . 9 1 6
buoy
Figure 3. Scatter diagrams of significant wave heights from June'95 to July'96. Any ERS-2 altimeter super observation that falls within a 100 km radius from the location of a buoy and with an associated model misfit of 0.25 (see text) was collocated with the corresponding 6 hour averaged buoy datum. The fit Y on X is defined as Y = SLOPE * X + INTR and the fit X on Y as X = SLOPE * Y + INTR. In figure 3a, all data are used. Where as only data for which both altimeter and buoy wave heights are greater than 1.5 m are considered in figure 3b.
212 For that purpose, we define the model misfit as being the absolute difference between the model value at the buoy location and at the altimeter super observation normalised by the model value at the buoy. Figure 3a shows the result for ERS-2 of this collocation from June '95 to July '96, as well as the associated statistics (Romeiser 1993). The obvious problem with the low ERS-2 altimeter wave height is apparent (artificial cut-off of low wave heights, ESA 1996), however if all low waves below 1.5m are removed from the record (figure 3b), a better fit is obtained and the statistics indicate an underprediction of the ERS-2 observed wave height by about 8% (compared to 15% for ERS-1, for the period June '95 to May '96). The subject of how wave height is derived from the ERS-2 observations is still under investigation and any change in the algorithm could therefore be tested against consistent buoy measurements assuming the wave model is used as a filter for the consistency of the wave field both in space and time.
3.3 Buoy data cross validation Confident in the performance of the wave forecasting system, we can use the wave model results for an actual quality control of buoy observations. An example is given in figure 2b, where we show time series of the rms error and bias over a year and a half for all buoys and for particular areas such as Hawaii, etc. Clearly, in the first half of 1995 the North-East Atlantic area is an outlier. Prompted by our concerns, the data producer replaced the communication software buoy by buoy and the consequences of that action are clearly visible in the second half of 1995 and on.
3.4 SAR inversion In principle, wave spectral information can be retrieved from Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) observations, providing the ocean communities with a bulk of information never seen before. However, the SAR spectra have to be converted to wave spectra. This inversion process requires prior information on the shape of the wave spectrum. This first guess is obtained from the wave model itself. In turn, these observed wave spectra can be used for the analysis, bearing in mind that, for the assimilation, it is crucial to know to what extent the wave model has been used in the retrieval of observed spectra (Hasselmann et al. 1996, Breivik et al. 1996).
3.5 Benefits for atmospheric modelling As set up at ECMWE the wave model may be used as a diagnostic tool to search for problems in the surface wind fields of the atmospheric model. There are some suggestions that momentum and energy transfer from atmosphere to ocean is sea state dependent. In order to obtain a consistent momentum and energy balance, one has to couple wind and wave. Such coupled wind-wave model already gives an improved climate in the Northern Hemisphere (Janssen and Viterbo 1996). Investigation is under way to examine the impact of surface roughness of ocean waves on the medium range forecasting of extratropical cyclones by finding the best suitable coupling mode between the atmospheric and the wave model. Finally, as we are just beginning to understand results from the coupled ocean wave/atmosphere model, the accurate modelling of ocean waves might prove to be a necessary component for the future simulations of the atmosphere-ocean system from small to the climate scales.
213 4. C O N C L U S I O N We have seen that the ECMWF wave forecasting system is a useful tool in providing ocean wave analysis and forecasts for up to 10 days. This information is undoubtedly needed for the continuous and efficient use of the seas by the shipping industries and offshore operators. Moreover, the numerical model should be viewed as a necessary tool to integrate sparse observations over the vast oceans. It is also an indispensable component in the elaboration of a reliable ocean data network by providing regular quality checks on the existing data, background information for the retrieval of oceanographic parameters, and easy testing of new retrieval algorithms for remote sensing data. We have also mentioned the need for more real time data, freely available via GTS, to insure the future development of those operational procedures. In the near future, the resolution of the global model will be increased to 0.50 (December 96), making ECMWF products even more attractive to near-shore operators. We sincerely hope that model analysis and forecasts will be an integral part of a global ocean data network for the benefit of the whole ocean community. REFERENCES Breivik, L.-A., M. Reistad and H. Schyberg (1996), "Assimilation of ERS SAR wave spectra in a numerical wave prediction model", DNMI Research Report no 31. ESA (1996),"Calibration of ERS-2 radar altimeter FDP/OPR data", Ed. Benveniste, ESRIN. Hasselmann S., C. Brtining and K. Hasselmann (1996), "An improved algorithm for the retrieval of ocean wave spectra from SAR image spectra", J. Geophys. Res., CI01, 16615-16629. Janssen P.A.E.M., B. Hansen and J.-R. Bidlot (1997), "Verification of the ECMWF wave forecasting system against buoy and altimeter data", to appear in Weather and Forecasting (December 1997). Janssen P.A.E.M., and P. Viterbo (1996), "Ocean waves and the atmospheric climate", J. Climate, 9, 1269-1287. Komen, G.J., L. Cavaleri, M. Donelan, K. Hasselmann, S. Hasselmann and P.A.E.M. Janssen (1994), "Dynamics and Modelling of ocean waves", Cambridge University Press. Lionello, P., H. GUnther and P.A.E.M. Janssen (1992), "Assimilation of altimeter data in a global third generation wave model". J. Geophys. Res., C97, 14453-14474. Queuffeulou, P., A. Bentamy, Y. Quilfen and J. Tournadre, (1996), "Validation of ERS-1 and TOPEX POSEIDON altimeter wind and wave measurements". To appear in J. Geophys. Res. Romeiser, R. (1993), "Global validation of the wave model WAM over a one year period using Geosat wave height", J. Geophys. Res. C98, 4713-4726.
214
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
The Bathymetry Assessment System
G.J. Wensink, G.H.F.M. Hesselmans, C.J. Calkoen a, and J. Vogelzang b aARGOSS, P.O. Box 61, 8325 ZH Vollenhove, The Netherlands bRijkswaterstaat, Rijksinstituut voor Kust en Zee/RIKZ, P.O. Box 20907, 2500 EX The Hague, The Netherlands
In the presence of current and wind, submerged topographic features of the sea bed produce contrasts in radar images. These contrasts can be quantitatively understood and modeled, based on hydrodynamics and electromagnetic scattering theory. A suite of models has been developed based on the generally accepted imaging mechanism, which consists of three steps: (1) surface current modulation by the bathymetry, (2) modulation of the (small) wave spectrum by wave-current interaction, and (3) radar backscattering by the sea surface. In order to invert this depth-radar backscatter relation, a data assimilation scheme has been developed. These numerical models have implemented, leading to the Bathymetry Assessment System (BAS). An example of an application in the Dutch coastal waters is presented.
1.
INTRODUCTION
Bathymetric data of shallow seas are of vital importance for shipping, fishery and all kinds of offshore activities as well as coastal management. Traditionally, depth information is collected from ships using (single or multi beam) echo sounders. Bathymetric surveys are therefore time and cost consuming. Remote Sensing methods may improve the efficiency of bathymetric surveys, since they give an instantaneous overview over large area's at relatively low costs. In 1969 de Loor c.s. discovered that under suitable conditions (moderate wind and strong tidal current) bottom topography is visible in radar images [De Loor and Brunsveld van Hulten, 1978; De Loor, 1981 ]. This was a great surprise: the sea surface is an almost perfect conductor at radar frequencies and, as a consequence, the microwave radiation does not penetrate into the water column, but reflects from the surface only. In 1978 the SEASAT satellite was launched, carrying for the first time an imaging radar in space. The nice images of bottom structures in the Southern Bight of the North Sea and in the Nantucket Shoals at the eastern coast of America further demonstrated the potential of microwave techniques.
215 The results of SEASAT aroused much interest in the phenomenon, both from the experimental and from the theoretical side. Alpers and Hennings [1984] came with the first model of the imaging mechanism. This model proved to be essentially correct, not only for bottom topography but also for other phenomena causing surface current variations like internal waves, fronts and ship wakes. It could also be applied to the optical window, especially when looking into the reflection of the sun on the sea surface. Surface expression of bathymetry can, under suitable conditions, even be observed with the naked eye, a fact known for centuries by sailors and fishermen. The ERS-1, carrying a C-band Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR), was launched succesfully in 1991. It was followed by ERS-2 in 1995. Now radar images became available at a regular base. This motivated a number of studies, supported by the Netherlands Remote Sensing Board (BCRS) and the European Commission (EC), in which the various submodels in the imaging mechanism were improved and practical applications were considered. Given the depth of an area, the wind speed and its direction, and the tidal phase, it is now possible to predict quantitatively, with reasonable accuracy, how a radar image will look like. This is nice from a scientific point of view, but for practical use one would like to go the other way round: predict the depth given the radar image. This is not feasible by analytical inversion of the imaging model, due to its complexity. Therefore numerical techniques were developed to achieve this, leading to the Bathymetry Assessment System (BAS). BAS constructs a depth map from one or more radar images (and a reduced number of traditional echo soundings. The soundings are needed to adjust some model parameters which are not well known. They are also used as constraints to the depth map. One may view the BAS as an "intelligent interpolator" which interpolates between transects of echo soundings using the depth information in radar images. The accuracy of the resulting depth map depends, of course, on the distance between the transects. In section 2 the imaging model and the principles behind the BAS will be discussed in more detail. In section 3 some results of recent demonstrations will be given in terms of accuracy, possibilities and limitations. As it stands now, the BAS is a pre-operational system. Future developments and improvements for arriving at a fully operational system will be given in section 4. This paper end with some conclusions in section 5.
2.
B A T H Y M E T R Y ASSESSMENT SYSTEM
Under favourable meteorological and hydrodynamic conditions (moderate winds of 3 to 9 m/s and significant tidal currents of 0.5 m/s or more), air- or space borne Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) imagery shows features of the bottom topography of shallow seas (Alpers and Hennings 1984, Vogelzang et al., 1989). The imaging mechanism of mapping sea bottom topography by imaging radar consists of three stages (a more detailed mathematical formulation is given in Calkoen et al., 1993):
216 (1) Interaction between (tidal) flow and bottom topography results in modulations in the (surface) flow velocity. This relation can be described by several models with an increasing level of complexity: continuity equation, shallow water equations, and the Navier Stokes equations. (2) Modulations in surface flow velocity cause variations in the surface wave spectrum. This is modelled with the help of the action balance equation, using a relaxation source term to simulate the restoring forces of wind input and wave breaking. (3) Variations in the surface wave spectrum cause modulations in the level of radar backscatter. To compute the backscatter variations a simple Bragg model can be used, but also available are two-scale and first iteration Kirchoff (Holliday) models. Based on the above three stage mechanisms, a suite of computer models has been developed and operationalized at ARGOSS. Models with different levels of complexity and physical detail are available for each step. These models describe the flows, waves and electromagnetic scatter and can be used for a quantitative analysis of radar imagery. In its most basic form, the three models described above consist of: (1)
The continuity equation relates current velocity in the direction perpendicular to bottom features (Up) and depth (d) : Up=C/d. c is a constant. The current velocity is proportional to the inverse of the depth. The current velocity in the direction parallel to the features in the bottom topography is constant according to the continuity equations.
(2)
The Action Balance Equation describes the sources and sinks of action caused by wind input, dissipation and non-linear wave interactions: dA/dt-S. Relying on weak hydrodynamic interaction theory an equilibrium (action) spectrum can be assumed. First order Taylor expansion yields a linear source term SIm(A)=-tu(A-Aeq). S describes the relaxation of the action spectrum (A) towards its equilibrium value Aeq.
(3)
First order Bragg scattering is the simplest model for relating the radar cross section of the sea surface, c~0,to the wave height spectral density W: O'o = 8~(k cosO)~[G~p(O)[ 2 [W(qn) + ~P(-q~)], with Othe angle of incidence and k the radar wavenumber. The function G contains the polarisation dependence with subscripts ct and [3 referring to the polarisation of the incoming and scattered radiation, respectively. The radar cross section is proportional to the wave height spectral density evaluated at (plus or minus) the Bragg wavenumber qB given by: qB=2 k sin(O).
This suite of computer models generate the radar backscatter given the bathymetry and the wind. In order to invert this depth-radar backscatter relation, a data assimilation scheme has been developed, minimizing the difference between the calculated and the measured radar backscatter by adjusting the bottom topography.
217 The imaging model in BAS contains two-dimensional models. This means that the flow and the wave field need not be schematised as onedimensional, in the same direction as the radar look direction. However, a fully two-dimensional data assimilation scheme for BAS is presently not yet available. At the moment two one-dimensional limits of BAS are available: one in which the Figure 1. Bathymetry Assessment System main depth variations are supposed to lie perpendicular to the flow direction and one in which the depth variations are mainly parallel to the flow. These two limiting cases are called the sand wave system and the channel system, after their main application. The structure of this modular system is shown in figure 1.
3.
RESULTS
3.1.
Project area
The Bathymetry Assessment System has been applied in the "Plaatgat area", which is shown in figure 2. The purpose of the project is to assess the applicability of (the current version of) the BAS and assess its accuracy as a function of the distance between section lines. The area of interest, is a tidal inlet in between the Dutch islets Ameland and Schiermonnikoog in the Waddenzee, north of the Netherlands. The area measures 10 km by 8.5 km. The project area lies approximately between 6 ~ and 6 ~ 8' 30" E, and 53 ~ 28' and 53 ~ 32' 40" N.
Figure 2. Map of the northern part of the Netherlands showing the project area. The axes show the location in the "Rijksdriehoek" coordinate system.
The "Plaatgat" channel, running from the centre-south part of the project area to the north-west, is the main shipping route between the North Sea and the harbour of Lauwersoog. Due to natural processes this channel moves to the east and silts. At the same time the "Westgat", a channel west of the Plaatgat, is getting deeper. A map of the bottom topography is shown in figure 4. In view of the morphological dynamics, Rijkswaterstaat, North Netherlands
218 Directorate, has decided to measure the bottom topography in this area with intervals of three months. The Bathymetry Assessment System requires, amongst others, SAR data and a limited number of sounding data. Most important are the SAR images from which the depth maps are constructed. The limited number of ship's soundings are needed to calibrate model parameters in BAS. Other required in situ measurements are: the wind speed and direction, and the tidal phase from which the flow field and the water elevation is computed. In this study the following data sets were obtained: ERS-1 images, hydro-meteorological conditions, sounding data, positioning data. A list of acquired images is shown in table 1. This table also lists the hydro-meteorological conditions at the recording times of the radar images. Table 1 Inventory of available ERS-1 SAR imagery and acquisition Orbit Frame Date Time wind (1995) (GMT) speed 20787 1071 July 6 21:39 3 m/s 20909 2529 July 15 10:32 5 rn/s 21016 1071 July 22 21:36 8 m/s 21181 2529 Aug 3 10:35 5 rn/s 21410 2529 Aug 19 10:21 6 rn/s 21682 2529 Sep 7 10:34 10 m/s
hydro-meteo conditions during SAR data wind direction south west south west north west north north east south east
tidal phase (Harlingen) low 0.5 h > high 2 h > low 2.5 h > high 1.5 h < low 4 h < low
All Plaatgat area images clearly show the breaker banks of the islet of Schiermonnikoog on the bottom right side, and tide land on the bottom left side, except for the image of July 15 which was obtained during high tide conditions. These land features, although most prominent in the images, are not relevant for BAS, because BAS only considers submerged areas. Almost all images also show signs of a shoal in the upper centre. The shoal causes highest contrasts and sharpness in the image of August 3. This image also shows most details in the channel in between the breaker banks and the tide land. For this reason the August 3 image is considered most suitable for use in BAS (figure 3). In the ship's sounding data the distance between two ship's tracks was approximately 200 m, except in the south-east part of the project area, where the distance was approximately 100 m. Along a ship's track, depth measurements were obtained at an interval of approximately 30 cm, but for this project the set of measurements was condensed to an interval of about 3 m. Rijkswaterstaat, Directorate North Netherlands, made available a depth map of the Plaatgat area based on these soundings. The ship's soundings reveal small scale depth variations along tracks. These undulating features can reach heights of more than 50 cm at wave lengths of approximately 30 m, which is the
219
resolution of the ERS SAR. This means that the SAR images cannot resolve these short sand waves and therefore neither can BAS.
Figure 3. ERS-1 SAR image of the Waddenzee acquired at August 3, 1995.
3.2.
Computation of the Plaatgat bathymetry using BAS
The Bathymetry Assessment System uses an imaging model, which contains a flow, a wave and a radar backscatter model, to simulate a SAR image for a given first depth assessment. The simulated SAR image is compared with the measured images and the ship's measurements and observed differences are used to adjust the first assessed depth map with the help of data assimilation techniques. The Plaatgat area has a two-dimensional bottom topography. In the deeper northem part the tidal flow is mainly east-west. Here the sandwave system is applicable. In the middle-southern part of the area a channel runs in north-south direction. The tidal flow here goes in the same direction. For the southern part of this channel the channel system can be used. In the centre of the area the channel turns to the west. The channel system can be applied on the western part of this channel. Neither of the two one-dimensional systems is suitable for the bend in the channel. In the south-western part of the area tide land lies above sea level. This part cannot be handled by BAS (or by echo sounders).
220 Because the whole Plaatgat area cannot be handled by a single one-dimensional system, it is divided in three sub-areas: one for the deeper northern part, one for the north-south part of the channel and one for the east-west part of the channel. The results are combined in one single map. In the accuracy analysis the sub-areas are considered separately. 3.3.
D e t e r m i n a t i o n of the a c c u r a c y o f the d e p t h a s s e s s m e n t
After generation of a depth map, its accuracy was determined with the help of ship's soundings which were not used by BAS. From the gridded depth assessments produced by BAS we calculated the depth along the ship's tracks using bilinear interpolation. The measured and simulated ship's soundings were compared in a statistical analysis. It is difficult to find reliable measures for the accuracy of two-dimensional depth maps. In the neighbourhood of steep channel slopes a small error in position can result in large errors in the depth. Moreover, the ship's measurements themselves show a noise level of the order of 20 cm. In this study we determine the following statistical error measures: bias, rms error and 5% exceedence level. Furthermore, the measured and assessed depths are plotted in scatterplots, histograms and difference maps. Figure 4 shows the depth map of the test site produced with BAS. The map shows three subareas which were processed and analysed in detail: the Plaatgat subarea in the south-east, the Westgat sub-area in the west and the deeper outer part in the north. Tables 2 and 3 give statistical measures for the accuracy of the depth estimates computed with BAS for the three sub-areas of the project area. Table 2 Statistical measures for function of the distance Distance between tracks 100/200 m 600 m 1000 m
the accuracy of the BAS depth assessments as a between calibration tracks for the Plaatgat sub-area. bias rms abs (cm) 5% (cm) (cm) (cm) 0 10 7 19 -1 22 16 47 -1 28 18 56
Table 3 Statistical measures for the deeper north sub-area (see also table 2). Distance between bias rms abs (cm) 5% tracks (cm) (cm) (cm) 100/200 m 0 9 7 18 600 m -2 23 17 49 1000 m
2
26
19
58
The statistical measures in these tables are computed from the depth differences, i.e. the computed minus the measured depth on the validation tracks. The bias is the average value of the depth difference, rms is the root mean square, and abs is the average of the absolute value of
221 the depth difference. The 5% value is computed by sorting the absolute values of the differences and looking up the value at .95 times the number of entries. The results for track intervals of 100/200 m cannot be used to determine efficiency improvements by using BAS, but serve the purpose of showing the minimum possible error for a given area. The bend in the main channel in the project area is part of both the Plaatgat sub-area and of the Westgat sub-area. As neither of the available one-dimensional BAS systems is applicable, the depth estimates in this bend were kept out of the statistical analysis.
Figure 4. Bathymetric map of Plaatgat based on all section lines. Contour levels are drawn at 2 m interval. Depth is shown on a linear grey scale.
4.
FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS
The present version of BAS can be improved on several points. In the first place, the BAS can now only be operated by specialists ("men in white coats"). In order to arrive at a more user-friendly system which can also be operated by non-specialists, many actions which now are performed by hand must be automated. First steps in this direction are now being made. A second improvement pertains to the inversion technique. The current version of BAS can be applied only to two limiting flow fields: a field in which the current velocity varies along the
222 stream lines (sandwave model) and a field in which the current velocity varies perpendicular to the stream lines (channel model). Therefore a given area must be divided in sub-area's, depending on the model to be applied. This requires a priori knowledge on the bottom. In many practical cases, like a bended tidal channel, the current velocity will vary both along and perpendicular to the stream lines. Though such situations are easily handled by the forward model, the existing one-dimensional inversion scheme prohibits extraction of depth information. Only with a fully two-dimensional inversion scheme the BAS can be applied on all kinds of bottom structures. A third point is noise (speckle) in the radar images which complicates depth assessments. Speckle is inherent to images made with coherent radars. However, its influence can be reduced by using more images of an area (multi-temporal analysis) or by improved SAR processing methods. The latter possibility is under investigation now. A fourth point is automatic detection of non-bottom features like slicks (natural or man-made), ships, ship wakes and fronts. These features can be recognised and classified immediately by a specialist. However, when one is aiming at routine use, such unwanted features must be detected (and mitigated) automatically. Finally, improvements are possible on the radar side. The SAR's carried by ERS and RADARSAT operate at C-band. At lower frequencies (L- or P-band) the modulations caused by bottom features are stronger. Moreover, radar images are less influenced by slicks and inhomogeneities in the wind field at lower frequencies. The resolution of nowadays spaceborne imaging radars is about 30 m. For some applications this may be too coarse. Use of (expensive) airborne systems or dedicated small satellites may be considered to overcome the limitations of existing spaceborne systems.
5.
CONCLUSIONS
In this paper the Bathymetry Assessment System (BAS) is presented. The BAS is a system that constructs depth maps from radar images and a limited number of echo soundings. The BAS can be applied in shallow seas (depth up to 30 to 40 m) with strong tidal current (0.5 m/s or more). Its accuracy depends on the distance between the echo sounding tracks. In its current version, the flow field caused by the bathymetry must be quasi one-dimensional, due to the inversion scheme. Demonstrations in quasi one-dimensional area's indicate that when a mean-root-square error of 20 cm to 30 cm is allowed, the distance between the tracks can be enlarged to 500 m or more, depending on the nature of the area. Above shoals, where soundings are difficult, a track distance of 1 km to 2 km seems feasible. This may give rise to a considerable reduction in shipping time. BAS does not cover all possible user requirements for bathymetric surveys. For example, ship wrecks are generally too small to cause disturbance at the sea surface, which are large and strong enough to be visible from space. Presently, they can only be detected with echo sounder or sidescan sonar. In shipping channels up-to-date depth information is needed after every major storm. Suitable satellite images may not be available in time. In that case a shipborne system is required. We conclude that the BAS is a very promising system for improving the efficiency of bathymetric surveys. However, fimher effort is needed to arrive at an operational system.
223 6.
1.
2.
3.
4. 5. 6.
REFERENCES
Alpers, W., and Hennings, I., A theory of the imaging mechanism of underwater bottom topography by real and synthetic aperture radar. Journal of Geophysical Research, C89, 10529-10546, (1984) Calkoen, C.J., Wensink, G.J. and Hesselmans, G.H.F.M., ERS-1 SAR imagery to optimize the NOURTEC ship-based bathymetric survey:feasibility study, Delft Hydraulics report H1875, November 1993. Calkoen, C.J., and Wensink, G.J., Use of ERS-1 SAR imagery to optimize ship-based bathymetric surveys in the Waddenzee: feasibility study. Delft Hydraulics report H 1985, December 1993. De Loor, G.P., and Brunsveld van Hulten, H.W., Microwave measurements over the North Sea. Boundary Layer Meteorology, 13, 113-131 (1978) De Loot, G.P., The observation of tidal patterns, currents and bathymetry with SLAR imagery of the sea. IEEE Journal of Oceanic Engineering, 6, 124-129, (1981) Vogelzang, J., Wensink, G.J. de Loor, G.P.,Peters, H.C. Pouwels, H., and van Gein, W.A., Sea bottom topography with X-band SLAR, BCRS report BCRS-89-25, (1989)
224
ICEWATCH
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
- Ice SAR monitoring
of the Northern
Sea Route
O. M. Johannessen a, A. M. Volkov b, V. D. Grischenko c, L. P. Bobylev d, S. Sandven ~, K. Kloster a, T. Hamre a, V. Asmus b, V. G. Smirnov ~, V. V. Melentyev d and L. Zaitsev d ~Nansen Environmental and Remote Sensing Center (NERSC), Edvard Griegsvei 3a, N-5037 Solheimsvik, Norway Tel: + 47 55 29 72 88, fax: + 47 55 20 00 50 bNPO Planeta, B. Predtechenskii Street 7, 123242 Moscow, Russia Tel: + 7 095 255 97 49, fax: + 7 095 200 42 10 CArctic and Antarctic Research Institute (AARI), Bering Street 38, 199397 St. Petersburg, Russia Tel: + 7 812 352 15 20, fax: + 7 812 352 26 52 dNansen International Environmental and Remote Sensing Center (NIERSC), Korpusnaya Street 18, 197042 St. Petersburg, Russia Tel: + 7 812 235 74 93, fax: + 7 812 230 79 94 The use of Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) images from satellites is currently tested ill oi)('ratiolml sea ice nlonitoring, an(i will play a more important role when SAR d a t a become available on a regular basis over all ice-covered areas. SAR images, with a resollltion of 1(}0 In, can be used to distinguish different ice types and to map leads, polynyas, shear zones, landfast ice, drifting ice and location of the ice edge. The SAR is the only instrument that provides high resolution images of such ice features under different cloud and light conditions. In several demonstration projects the Nansen Centers in Bergen and St. Petersburg have used ERS-1/2 SAR images to monitor sea ice conditions in the Northern Sea Route. The projects have been performed in close cooperation with ice breakers belonging to Murmansk Shipping Company (MSC), one of the most important users of ice information in Russia. From 1995 SAR ice monitoring is established as the first joint project in earth observation between the European Space Agency and the Russian Space Agency. The objective of this project called ICEWATCH is to make SAR data from ERS and ENVISAT available for Russian users of ice data on an operational basis. The Northern Sea Route is the sailing route along the coast north of Russia from the Barents Sea in west to the Bering Strait in east (Figure. 1). The ice conditions restrict sea transportation which requires ice class vessels as well as ice breaker assistance throughout the year. In summer there is traffic in the whole sailing route, whereas in winter it is mainly the western part which is used serving the ports on the Yenisei River. An extensive ice monitoring and forecasting service has been built up in Russia over the last 50 years based on data from satellites, aircraft, vessels, ice stations and coastal stations. Use of spaceborne SAR has not been a part of this service. NERSC first demonstrated use of ERS-1 SAR data for near real-time ice mapping in
225
- ~ ~ / / ~ , \ \ \ \ /"-... " /-. ChukchiSea" '~Bering . . . .Barents . . - Sea ~ _~_* ": "~/'-~, ~- / \ / .-, /~ _ _ , /'%... "-\ '- Q Strait \~ j ~ ? /l /; a /NovavaZemlya / ~ ~ / ~ ) \ " " ( ~ / Y "-~[ X/~~ ", New-Sibe'rian"~East Siberian Sea / / y ' ~ -~'~ / ,
60
>
YugorStrait ........... _ ~ _ f ~ ' ~ . . ~ . / / .\ ..
/ "
70
o~kson / / I - "
... "--.
80
90
100 110 120 130
140
150
160
Figure 1. Map of the Northern Sea Route. The bold line shows the xnain saililig I'()!1|.(~, wllih' the dashed lines indicate alternatiw', routes used if t)ennitted by ice con(titi(ms.
tile Nr Sea Rolltc iIl Allgllst 1991, only a few weeks ~fftr tlw lallll('h ()t" tll(, ERS-1 satellite. SAR deriver sea i{,e Illaps were then scllt |)y tclefax t{) t.ll(' Fr~,lWll t)()lar vess~,l "L'Ast,r~lal~C' r ller voyage thI'(mgh the Northeast Passage fr~lll Norway t.~ .latmll [1,2]. This (leinr ioIl was evalllated as very iIlt.erestillg })y t.lle cat)t.aiIls aIl(1 sea i{'e ('xt)erts <m t)oar(t tlw RllSsian i<:c breakers which escort('(t "L'Astrolat)('." thr()ugh t lw i(:r (,()v(;rcd i)arts of the r()llte. Sill(:(~ 1993 SAR ice inonitoring (t(qn()nstrations |lave ])(;(ql carried out on several Russian ice breakers [3,4]. Ill all these (tenlonstration cxt)crilncnts , a s(:ientist from the Nansen Center ill St. Petersburg stayed Oil board the ice breakers and analyzed the SAR. ilnagcs in cooperation with the cat)taill and ice tfilots. In a(htiti()ll to the ice navigation these ('xperilncnts Mso had sci(mtific o|).jectives to study sea i(,e t)|lell()mena and their SAR signature along the Northern Sea Rout(; at differellt tiln(,s ()f the year. In .]almary an(t February 1996, ERS SAR d a t a files were transferred dire(,tly to a Russian ice breaker "Vaygach" moving in ice covered areas [5], by means of Ininarsat COnlmction, a modeln and a PC. The time lag from the satellite overpass to reception of images on board the ice breaker was at a minimum of 5-6 hours, which enabled the captain to select the optimal sailing route (Figure. 2). The expected result of the ICEWATCH project is to integrate llSe of satellite ERS SAR d a t a in the Russian Ice Service, and illako. SAR. d a t a readily available for a number of users who need detailed ice. information.
226
Figure 2. ERS SAR image from January 26, 1996, which was transferred to a Russian ice breaker in near real-time. Original data @ ESA/TSS 1996.
227
1. S E A I C E P A R A M E T E R S ERN SEA ROUTE
DERIVED
FROM SAR DATA IN THE NORTH-
Sea ice parameters observable by SAR can be categorized in three main classes: Ice boundaries and features. The most important boundaries which can be detected in SAR images are ice edges, ice floe identification and boundaries between areas of different ice types. The most common observable ice features are leads, shear zones, ridge areas and ice edge phenomena such as ice eddies, ice tongues and wave propagation in ice. The detection of boundaries and features requires some backscatter gradients which can be enhanced by image processing techniques such as histogram equalization, filtering, line detection and other methods. Motion of ice features. With repeated SAR coverage over the same area, it is possible to observe the displacement of ice features which can be recognized in images obtained with an interval of a few days. There are several algorithms that calculate the ice motion by mltomatically recognizing features such as ice floes and leads. The ice motion vectors sh()wn in Figure. 3 are calculated by a spatial correlation technique [6] using images taken at three day interval in the Ot) river estuary in February 1994. The images show the })()lln(laries t)etween moving and stationary ice, such as "stamukha" whi('h is ice stuck t() the sea b()tt()~n (area A), m~(1 landfast ice stuck t() the shores of islands (area B) an(t ('()asts (ar(~a C). The iInages also stl()w ail exaIllt)l(~ ()f coastal t)()lynya f()rlnati()ll (ar(~a D) when s()llth(~rly winds (trives t h(~ l)ack ice ilorthwards, leaving areas ()f ()t)en water wlli(,}l r(,fr(,ezes (tll(, to the low air tenlt)('ratllres. Cla,.s'.sifi(:ation of i(:(: typ('.s. SAR t)a('ks(:attcr statisti('s for vari()lls i('(, t yi)(~s aIl(t sllrfa(,(, (:llara('teristi('s are inlI)ortant int)llt (tata f()r ice ('lassifi('ati()ll, a ll(t is })as(,(t ()ll a lllllll})(q" a wlli(tati()ll (~xI)('rilnents [7,8]. H()wever, the t)a('kscatt(~r vallles f()r (tilf(u'(ult i('(~ t.vt)('s ()v('rlat) (I:igllre. 4). For instan('e, ill the interior t)ack i('e in wiilter, liilas, gr(3' ,vliit(, i('(~ aIl(t sIn()()tli first-year ice may give tlm same |)acks('atter value, (tel)ell(ling; ()Ii tile ~nete(>r<>h>gical (,(>nditi(>ns an
f freezing. Thus, in a a l)ixn~ fielt)servati()ns, meteorological (lata m~(t ot, tmr satellite data.
2. A N A L Y S I S
OF ERS SAR DATA REQUIREMENTS
In the Northern Sea Route, TromsO Satellite Station can receive and process SAR images as far east as 107~ which includes the Vilkitskogo Strait, which is one of the nlost difficult areas for ice navigation. In the East Siberian Sea and the Clmkchi Sea, Alaska SAR Facility can receive and process SAR data. At present, no receiving station can obtain SAIl data in the Laptev Sea. Thus, a receiving station in central Siberia is needed to enable downlink and distribution of SAR data in the whole Northern Sea Route. An example of a 3-day SAR coverage of tile Kara Sea region is shown in Figure. 5. The gaps in tile 3-day coverage is about 200 kin along the route. A one-month coverage of this area, which is the most important part of the sailing route in the winter, would require 250 ERS SAR scenes. Coverage of the whole sailing route west of Cape Chelyuskin
228
Figure 3. Ice motion ice-covered Ob river 15 cm/s in northerly the Yamal Peninsula
derived from tw(~ ERS-1 SAR images covering 300 by 100 km in the estuary obtained on 24 and 27 February 1994. Mean ice velocity is direction. A indicates an area of stationary ice, B is an island, C is and D is a coastal polynya. Original data @ ESA/TSS 1994.
229
Figure 4. ERS SAR backs(:atter vallms obtained from several validation experiments [8].
Figure 5. Available ERS-1 SAR images in the Kara Sea during a 3-day period.
230 would require about 500 scenes per month. In the summer season, when ships traverse the whole Northern Sea Route (NSR), the data requirements will be variable, depending on the total amount of sea ice. To provide year round ice information, the number of ERS SAR scenes needed to cover the major parts of the NSR would be of order 5000 per year. The ERS SAR data requirements for an operational system can be summarized as follows: 1. The limited SAR coverage of the ice areas, and the lack of a receiving station covering the Laptev Sea are limiting factors in an operational service. Optimal use of SAR d a t a in the most important parts of the sailing route is necessary to improve the monitoring capability. 2. The ESA data ordering system is acceptable, but the advance time needed to order SAR scenes should be reduced. The processing and distribution procedures used at TromsO Satellite Station satisfies the needs of an operational ice monitoring system which needs data in near real-time. 3. Larger SAR swath width than 100 km is needed. With 500 km swath width, which is now available from Radarsat and is planned to be available from Envisat in 1999, the SAR data coverage requirements will be satisfied. 4. Transmitting ERS SAR images to users at sea in near real-time is difficult, mostly because the Inmarsat services are limited at high latitudes. Other communication incthods need to be tested towards users at sea. Operational transmission of d a t a to MOH in Dikson and other land-based users is more convenient. 3. T H E C U R R E N T ROUTE
RUSSIAN
ICE SERVICE
FOR THE NORTHERN
SEA
The ice monitoring and forecasting is organized under the Russian Hydro-Meteorological Committee [3]. One of the key institutions operating the ice monitoring service is the Marine Operational Headquarter (MOH) located in Dikson. The MOH operates the ice services in cooperation with Murmansk Shipping Company and the Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute. The ice service uses a wide range of observations froIn satellites, aircraft, ice breakers, helicopters, coastal stations and drifting ice stations. Ice forecasting, both short-term and long-term, is also included in the service. One of the spaceborne sensors used for ice monitoring is the side-looking radar (SLR) offered by the polar orbiting Okean satellites. The SLR operates at 3.2 cm wavelength, with VV polarization. SLR images are available along 500 km wide swaths at 1.5 km resolution, and are used to map areas of ice (multi-year, first-year) and open water over major parts of the Arctic. An example of SLR imagery covering the eastern Barents Sea and some of the Kara Sea is shown in Figure. 6. The first-year ice is seen as gray signature around Novaya Zemlya and in the northeastern Barents Sea. The multi-year ice is seen as bright signature north of Franz Josef Land. Open water in Pechora Sea has the darkest signature in the left-hand image. In addition to radar data, Okean also provide passive microwave and optical data in the SLR swath. The data from the Okean satellites, which have been in operation since 1983, are processed and interpreted in Research and Production Association NPO Planeta which has an archive of radar images of different regions of the Arctic. In the ICEWATCH project, the roles of SLR data as complementary data to SAR is explored [5].
231
Figure 6. Okean SLR single orbit image and a mosaic of two orbits showing sea ice in the western part of the Northern Sea Route. Image courtesy NPO Planeta.
232 4. A N O P E R A T I O N A L I C E M O N I T O R I N G S Y S T E M ERN SEA ROUTE USING ERS SAR DATA
FOR THE NORTH-
In order to establish use of ERS SAR data in the operational Russian ice service the following elements must be included:
1. Selection of S A R coverage in strategic areas Since ERS cannot provide SAR coverage for the whole sailing route it is i m p o r t a n t to focus the data acquisition to critical areas such as the Kara Gate, Jugor Strait, Vilkitskogo Strait, the New Siberian Islands and Long Strait which can all be covered by existing receiving stations. 2. Real-time access to SAR data The acquisition of SAR scenes in near real-time is an essential part of an operational system. Near real-time is considered to be within 6-12 hours after the satellite overpass. A time delay of 2-3 hours is currently performed in production and distribution of SAR images from TromsO Satellite Station. Similar access to SAR data is needed for the whole Northern Sea Route. 3. Data ordering procedure Ordering of SAR data is currently a two-step operation. First, request for SAR ac(tuisition over a given area is submitted to ESA ESRIN about a month in advance. A data production order is then submitted to tile receiving station 1-7 days in advance. This data ordering procedure should be streamlined in an operational system. 4. Interpretation of SAR images The validation experiinents have provided good insight into many ()f the ice characteristics of the Northern Sea Route and how they are reflected in the SAR iInages. In situ observations of ice and meteorological parameters have been useful in the interpretation of the SAR images [1 4]. An interpretation catalogue for SAR ice signatures for ice observers in the Northern Sea Route needs to be produced. 5. Quantitative ice parameters from SAR Classification of multi-year ice, first-year ice, thin ice and open water can usually be derived from the SAR images. In the summer, when the ice and snow is melting, it can be difficult to identify the ice edge and classify ice types. Ice motion and ice concentration can be calculated. Ice edge, leads and polynyas can be accurately mapped. Ice thickness cannot be estimated from SAR images, and methods for localizati(m of ridges are not well developed. It is also difficult to distinguish different stages of young ice because the backscatter changes rapidly as the ice is deformed. More validation studies are needed for better quantification of ice types and ice phenomena in SAR images. 6. Linking ERS data to the Russian ice monitoring services Routines are currently established to transmit SAR data to the users in Russia. Near real-time data are obtained from TromsO Satellite Station, while off-line d a t a are ordered from ESRIN. The Russian receiver is NPO Planeta which forward the data to Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute, MOH in Dikson, Murmansk Shipping Company and selected ice breakers. Direct links to the ice breakers are necessary to provide real-time data which are coordinated with the ship's sailing schedule.
233 5. C O N C L U S I O N
ERS-1 SAR images have been used in ice monitoring of the Northern Sea Route in several demonstration campaigns since 1991. The experience from use of SAR data on board Russian ice breakers to assist in ice navigation is very positive although ERS-1 can only provide data in selected parts of the Northern Sea Route. In this project a concept for integrating ERS SAR data in the Russian ice monitoring service is demonstrated. The system is currently tested in pilot demonstration phase. In addition to data acquisition and interpretation the project will also address data integration and classification, data transmission techniques and assessment of user requirements. 6. A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T
The project has been supported by the Norwegian Research Council (through a SAR strategy programme), European Space Agency, Russian Space Agency and Murmansk Shipping Company. REFERENCES
1. Johannessen, O.M. et al., ERS-1 SAR ice routing of "L'Astrolabe" through the Northeast Passage. Arctic News-Record, Polar Bulletin 8 (2), 26-31, 1992. 2. ().M..lohannessen and S. Sandven, ERS-1 SAR ice routing of "L'Astrolabe" throllgh the N()rth(;ast Passage. NERSC techIfical report no. 56, February 1992. 3. ().M..l()hanlmSSen, L.H. Pettersson, S. Sandven, V.V. Meleiltyev, M. Miles, K. Kloster, L.P. Bol)ylev, M. Stette, A. Drottning an(l K.Ya. K(m(tratyev, Real-tiIlw st;a i(,c nl()llit.()rillg ()f the Northern Sea Route using ERS-1 satellite radar inlages. Terra Orbit Techni(:al ReI)ort no.1/94, Bergell, ,llfly 1994, 33 Pt). 4. O.M..lohalllmSSen, S. Sandven, K. Kloster, M. Miles, V.V. Melentyev and L. Bobylev, A Sea Ice Monitorillg system for the Northern Sea Route ERS SAR (tata. NERSC Techni('.al Report no. 103, September 1995, 50 I)P5. O.M. Johannessen, A.M. Volkov, V.D. Grischellko, L.P. Bobylev, V. AslmlS, T. Hamre, K. Kloster, V.V. Melentyev, S. Sandven, V.G. Smirnov, J. Solhaug and L. Zaitsev, ICEWATCH Real-Time Sea Ice Monitoring of the Northern Sea Route Using Satellite~ Radar Technology, NERSC Technical Report 113 (in preparation). 6. K. Kloster, H. Flesche and O.M. Johannessen, Ice motion from airborne SAR and sate.llite imagery. Adv. Space. Res. 12 (7), 149-153, 1992. 7. R. G. Onstott, SAR and Scatterometer Signatures of Sea Ice, in Microwave Remot(; Sensing of Sea Ice, F. Carsey (editor), American Geophysical Union, 1992, 73-104, AGU Geophysical Monograph 68. 8. S. Sandven, O.M. Johannessen, K. Kloster and M. Miles, SIZEX'92 ERS-1 SAR validation experiment. EARSeL Advances in Remote Sensing Vol.3 (2-XII), 50-56, 1994.
Operational Oceanography. The Challengefor European Co-operation 234
edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
C O A S T W A T C H : U s i n g S A R i m a g e r y in an o p e r a t i o n a l s y s t e m f o r m o n i t o r i n g c o a s t a l c u r r e n t s , w i n d , s u r f a c t a n t s a n d oil spills O. M Johannessen*, E .Korsbakken, P. Samuel, A. D. Jenkins and H. A. Espedal Nansen Environmental and Remote Sensing Center, Edvard Griegs vei 3a, N-5037 Solheimsviken, Bergen, Norway; Phone: +47-55 29 72 88, Fax: +47-55 20 00 50, [email protected] *Also at Geophysical Institute, University of Bergen, Norway.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N The capability of the ERS-1 and ERS-2 synthetic aperture radar (SAR) for imaging geophysical phenomena near the sea surface has been demonstrated in many studies [ 1-11 ]. The phenomena include 9 atmospheric features in the marine boundary layer such as wind and atmospheric gravity waves. 9 wavelength and propagation direction of ocean surface waves 9 ocean surface features, reflecting * oceanic fronts and eddies * internal waves * bottom topography in shallow water 9 manmade oil spill and natural surface film In order to quantify these mesoscale upper ocean and atmospheric boundary layer processes, a tandem ERS-1/2 ESA AO experiment was carried out in the Skagerrak, off the south-west coast of Norway, during September 1995. The data collected
Figure 1 The experimental area, showing SAR coverage in gray, the location of moorings (M = metocean buoy, C1/C2 = current meter moorings), and ship track. The field experiment took place from 11 September to 1 October 1995.
235
Further results from this experiment will be published in Journal of Geophysical Research (JGR Ocean) and other journals in the near future.
1.1 Remote sensing The ERS SAR coverage shown in Fig.1 shows that ample use was made of the tandem ERS1/2 SAR imagery at 24-hour separation, and also ascending/descending ERS passes at 11-13hour separation. There was also substantial cloud-free coverage by ERS ATSR and NOAA AVHRR infra-red sensors, giving good information on the ocean surface thermal structure.
1.2 Ship-borne instrumentation The University of Bergen research vessel R/V H~kon Mosby was employed in the field program, to make in situ meteorological and oceanographic measurements, and to deploy and retrieve current meter moorings, a metocean buoy, and a "mini research vessel" for surface microlayer sampling. The ship was directed to locations of interest using analyses of SAR and infra-red (AVHRR/ATSR) satellite images which were downloaded and processed by Tromsr Satellite Station, postprocessed and analysed at the shore operations centre at NERSC in Bergen, transmitted to the ship and subsequently downloaded to the shipboard computer system. The Norwegian Meteorological Institute also provided a special operational forecast service, for meteorology and sea state.
1.2.1 Meteorology An Aanderaa weather station provided wind, pressure, air temperature and humidity observations from the H~kon Mosby. The Naval Postgraduate School (NPS) weather station duplicated these observations, with additional observations of turbulent wind components using an ultrasonic anemometer and turbulent humidity fluctuations using an Ophir hygrometer. Surface-layer aerosol particle size distribution in the range 0.3-200 ~m was measured continuously, and regular rawindsonde launches were performed.
1.2.2 Ship-borne radar/radiometer In situ measurements were made by an Environmental Research Institute of MichigardUniversity of Michigan team, using a rail-mounted system consisting of a C-band dual-polarized Doppler radar, C-band radiometer and video camera. The measurements collected during the experiment include the following situations: box patterns, near the NPS buoy, and during typical wind-wave situations; transects of current fronts, temperature fronts, and surfactant regions; periods of low wind, and of high wind; breaking waves, atmospheric fronts, and rain showers. Radiometer data were collected on five occasions, on September 17, 18 and 20, for a total period of approximately 10 hours.
1.2.3 Oceanographic measurements The sea surface temperature (SST) was recorded continuously, with supplementary SST observations being made with a thermistor suspended from the ship so that it skimmed the water surface. Temperature and salinity measurements down to 200 m depth were made using a SeaSoar towed CTD (Conductivity Temperature Depth instrument). The current profile was
236 measured from the bottom of the ship to the seabed or maximum 500 m depth with an Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP). 1.3 Moored instruments and instruments deployed from the research vessel 1.3.1 Metocean buoy The NPS metocean buoy measured two-dimensional wave spectra using a Hippy Datawell sensor. It also measured pressure, vector wind, air and sea temperature, humidity, turbulent fluctuations in wind, temperature and humidity, and aerosol particle size distribution. 1.3.2 Current measurements Two sub-surface current meter moorings were deployed, with Aanderaa current meters at 25 m, 50 m and 100 m depth and at 25 m above the sea bottom. 1.3.3 "Mini research vessel" (Surface sub-sampler) A remotely-controlled platform "INTERFACE II" was deployed on September 13, 15 and 18. It was approximately 1.5 m long, lm wide and remotely controlled from the ship and it is equipped with a rotating Teflon drum to take direct samples of the surface microlayer. It was also equipped with air and sea temperature sensors and a K-band radar.
2. CURRENT RESEARCH AT NERSC The data acquired from the COAST WATCH'95 program is used in the process of validation and improvement in SAR ocean models and SAR operational applications. 2.1 Coastal currents Several of the SAR images from the COAST WATCH'95 show oceanic fronts which can be explained as the effect of current gradients. No models are presently available which can accurately quantify the currents from SAR images. The interpretation of such phenomena is based on coincident in situ measurements from ADCP and SeaSoar. SAR may provide information about the spatial and temporal variations of the current, current shear and convergence/divergence and the location of the ocean fronts, based on experience from observations of similar features. 2.2 Wind retrievals An analysis system to derive the wind field at high spatial resolution (10 x 10 km) from SAR images has been implemented for validation purposes. The system is based on a combination of CMOD4 [ 12] wind retrieval model and the correlation between the azimuth cut-off in the SAR image power spectrum and the near ocean surface wind speed [ 13]. Such high resolution wind vector retrievals will be a important part of an operational coastal zone monitoring module of EuroGOOS, particularly in regions where the resolution (50 • 50 km) of the Wind Scatterometer is too coarse.
237
2.3 Surface Slicks Oil spills and films of natural surfactant materials, provided they are of sufficient extent, are readily observed as low-backscatter patches in SAR images (e.g. [5], [11], [14] - [18]). One of the main practical problems is to distinguish natural films from manmade oil spills for use in an automatic surveillance system for oil spill detection. Oil spills detected by satellite remote sensing in coastal waters have been verified visually from aircraft observations [19]. Natural films observed with SAR have also been sampled directly using a remotely controlled mini research vessel.
3. RESULTS
3.1 Ocean fronts and coastal jets A coastal jet (narrow intense current) was observed during the latter part of the field program. This phenomena is shown in Fig.2 and in the AVHRR and SAR images in Fig.3 (taken two days after). From the ship the sea-surface temperature was measured to be 8~ inside the dark region and 12~ outside, simultaneously by the image in Fig.2. The air temperature was 8~ at the time of observation. SAR images obtained 2 hours before and 11 hours after the AVHRR image are shown to the right of the AVHRR image in Fig.3. A remarkable feature of the SAR image at 10.41 UTC (descending track) is that it shows the western edge of the dark feature shown in the AVHRR image, i.e. the radar backscatter pattern reflects the sea temperature. This is likely to be a result of the increased atmospheric stability as the air flows over the colder water, reducing the wind stress and thus the growth of short wind-waves. The wind was light (2-3 m/s) at the SAR observation time, so a change of stability can have a large effect on short wind-wave generation. The warmer water to the east of the dark AVHRR feature is moving westwards along the coast as a coastal jet: typical current speeds measured by the ship-borne ADCP were 60 cm/s, and sharp changes in the current were measured when the ship moved across the wavelike (frontal) boundaries shown in the right-hand SAR image in Fig.3.
Figure 2. SAR image from 1995 September 27, 10:36 UTC, shows a frontal line advancing from the west, with cellular rain-shower features. In the calmer region in the central part towards the top of the image, a oceanic jet (frontal feature) can be seen.
238
Original ERS SAR data vESA/TSS 1995.1mageanalysis NERSC Figure 3.Left: NOAA 1 AVHRR image, 1995 September 30, 12:30 UTC, indicating sea surface temperature. Cold regions appear dark. Right: ERS-2 SAR image, 10:41 UTC, with ship track indicated. A frontal feature (jet) can be seen along the coastline. Centre: ERS- 1 SAR image, 21:37 UTC.
3.2 Surface slicks There were unfortunately no ERS SAR images obtained at times when slick samples were taken by the "mini research vessel". However, the air and sea temperature measurements as the vessel was driven through a natural slick, are of considerable interest. They show that the nearsurface water temperature is higher in the presence of a slick, presumably as a result of reduced wave-induced mixing and thus greater stratification of the water column. Analysis of slick material indicates that they were composed predominantly of natural surfactant materials from marine organisms, rather than from terrestrial sources as seen in slicks in fjord regions [ 11 ]. More foam was also present in the slicks observed offshore, presumably as a result of increased wave action.
3.3 Atmospheric fronts, rain showers and wind velocity Fig.2 shows a mosaic of three ERS-2 SAR images from 1995 September 27, 10:36 UTC, showing rain cells in an atmospheric frontal zone. The aerosol measurements from R/V H~lkon Mosby will be correlated with the rain signatures in the SAR images. It should also be possible
239 to find correlation between the cloud cover in infrared images and rain activity in SAR images to improve the confidence in the interpretation of the SAR image features. Fig.4 shows a mosaic of three ERS-2 SAR images from September 17, and the wind vectors derived from a combination of azimuth cut-off analysis and the CMOD4 algorithm. Wind vectors are computed using or0 and spectral averages over approximately 10 x 10 km. The derived wind speed ranges from 5 to 11 m/s and agrees very well with the measured in-situ wind speed from R/V H~tkon Mosby and the NPS metocean buoy; the computed wind direction also shows a good agreement with the in situ observations and the wind streaks seen in the lower part of the image. It is fairly well documented that these wind streaks reflect the near surface wind direction [20]. The derived wind speeds are also in good agreement with the predictions in the Norwegian Meteorological Institute 24-hour forecast for the same period.
Figure 4. Left: ERS-2 SAR image 17 September 1993. Right: SAR image location outside the coast of Norway. The small square shows the location of R/V H~tkon Mosby (wind speed: 7 m/s) and the triangle shows the location of the bouy (wind speed: 1 1 m/s). Centre: The wind vector field derived from the SAR image spectral characteristics and the CMOD4 wind retrieval algorithm. The dots indicate land or ambuiguity problems with the wind direction. The wind speed ranges from 5 to 11 m/s.
240
3.4 Ocean and coastal Monitoring system The examples given of SAR products from COAST WATCH'95 are partly predefined in an ocean and coastal monitoring project which was carried out at NERSC in 1995-96 [ 18]. The main objectives were to involve users and to demonstrate SAR products for an integrated monitoring service. A survey of potential users of the monitoring service was carried out and a demonstration case study was proposed which initially included The Fedje Ship Traffic Control Centre in western Norway as a end user. After an iteration process with feedback from the user, the system will be operationally tested for a few months followed by a cost-benefit analysis of the service. The suggested organization of the service for a demonstration project is shown in Fig. 5. A discussion of the marine monitoring and forecasting system is also found in [19].
Figure 5 Suggested organisation of the service for a demonstration project with the Fedje Ship Traffic Control Centre.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The work described was carried out under the Strategic Program for SAR remote sensing at NERSC, funded by the Norwegian Research Council. Ship time was provided by the University of Bergen, and ERS-1/2 data were provided under the European Space Agency AO Program.
241 REFERENCES
[1 ]
J.A. Johannessen, L. P. R~ed, and T. Wahl, "Eddies detected in ERS-1 SAR images and simulated in reduced gravity model," Int. J. Remote Sensing, vol. 14, pp. 2203-2213, 1993.
[21 J. Vogelzang, G. J. Wensink, M. W. A. van der Kooij, and R. van Swol, "Mapping of sea bottom topography with ERS-1 C-band SAR," In ESA [ 10], pp. 945-948.
[31 W. Alpers and B. Br] mmer, "Atmospheric boundary layer rolls observed by synthetic aperture radar aboard the ERS- 1 satellite", J. Geophys. Res., vol. 99, pp. 12613-12621, 1994. [4]
M. Bao, C. Br] ning, and W. Alpers, "A generalized nonlinear ocean wave-SAR spectral integral transform and its application to ERS-1 SAR ocean wave imaging," In ESA [10]
[5]
H . A . Hovland-Espedal, J. A. Johannessen, and G. Digranes, "Slick detection in SAR images," In Proc. IGARSS'94, Pasadena, California, August 8-12, vol. 4, pp. 2038-2040, Pisacataway, New Jersey: IEEE, 1994.
[6]
J.A. Johannesen, G. Digranes, H. Espedal, O. M. Johannesen, P. Samuel, D. Browne, and P. W. Vachon, "SAR Ocean Feature Catalogue". Noordwijk, The Netherlands: ESA Publications Division, SP- 1174, 1994.
[7]
R. A. Shuchman, J. A. Johannessen, C. Rufenach, and C. Wackerman, "Determination of wind speed and direction using ERS-1 data during NORCSEX'91," In Proc. Second ERS- 1 Symposium, Hamburg, 1993 October, ESA SP-361, 1994.
[8]
P. W. Vachon, O. M. Johannessen, and J. A. Johannessen, "An ERS-1 synthetic aperture radar image of atmospheric lee waves," J. Geophys. Res., vol. 99, No. C11, pp. 2248322490, 1994.
[9]
S. Nilsson and P. C. Tildesley, "Imaging of oceanic features by ERS 1 synthetic aperture radar," J. Geophys. Res., vol. 100, No. C1, pp. 953--967, 1995.
[10] Proc. Second ERS-1 Symposium, Space at the Service of Our Environment, Hamburg, 1993 October. Noordwijk, The Netherlands: ESA Publications Division, ESA SP-361, 1994. [11] H. A. Espedal, O. M. Johannessen, and J. C. Knulst, "Natural films in coastal waters," Proc., IGARSS'95, Florence, Italy, 1995 July 10--14, pp. 2106-2108. Pisacataway, NJ: IEEE, 1995. [12] A. C. M Stoffelen. and D. L. T. Anderson, "ERS-1 Scatterometer characteristics and wind retrieval skill", in proceedings of the first ERS-1 symposium, Cannes, France, 4-6 November 1992, ESA-SP 359 Vol.1 pp 41 -47,1993. [ 13] V. Kerbaol, B. Chapron, T. E1 Fouhaily and R. Garello, "Fetch and Wind Dependence of S AR azimuth cutoff and higher order statistics in a Mistral wind case", Proceedings of the IGARSS'96 Lincoln Nebraska USA, 1996. [ 14] J.C. Scott, "Surface films in oceanography", ONRL Workshop Report C-11-86, p. 19, 1986.
242 [ 15] W. Alpers and H. HI hnerfuss, "Radar signatures of oil films floating on the sea surface and the Marangoni effect", J. geophys. Res. 93:3642-3648, 1988. [16] A. R. Ochadlick, Jr., P. Cho, and J. Evans-Morgis, "Synthetic aperture radar observations of currents collocated with slicks", J. geophys. Res. 97(C4):5325-5330, 1992. [ 17] M. Gade and W. Alpers, "The German surface film experiments during the two SIRC/X-SAR missions", EARSeL Newsletter 3/95, 1995. [ 18] P. Samuel, S. Sandven, T. Hamre and L. H. Petterson, "Use of SAR in ocean and coastal monitoring", Technical report no:l 1 l, Nansen Environmental and Remote Sensing Center, 1996 [ 19] P. Samuel, E. Grong, H. Espedal, H. SOiland, T. Hamre, I. Martinussen, and S. Sandven, "Integrated operational use of SAR images in marine forecasting: A feasibility and demonstration project for detection of oil spill and other phenomena at the sea surface", Special Report No. 33, NERSC & Programme for Ocean Monitoring and Forecasting, Bergen, Norway, 1995. [20] J. A. Johannessen, P. W. Vachon and O. M Johannessen, "ERS-1 SAR imaging of marine boundary layer processes", Earth Observation Quarterly, ESA, 1995. [21] J. A. Johannessen, R. A. Shuchman and O. M Johannessen, "Synthetic Aperture Radar on ERS-1" in Oceanographic Applications of Remote Sensing ( Edited by M. Ikeda and F. W. Dobson), ISBN 0-8493-4525-1, 1995.
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge [br European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 1997 Elsevier Science B.V.
243
Operational determination of satellite derived sea surface t e m p e r a t u r e and w i n d speed from N O A A A V H R R and E R S S A R images S. Lehner, S. W. Dech, A. Holz, R. Meisner, M. Niederhuber & P. Tungalagsaikhan Deutsche Forschungsanstalt for Lutt- und Raumfahrt (DLR) Deutsches Fernerkundungsdatenzentrum (DFD) Oberpfaffenhofen, D-82234 Wessling, Germany email: Susanne.Lehner@dlr. de
The intention of DLR's remote sensing activities is to provide the user community with geophysical information both on land and ocean surfaces in near real time with highest possible reliability on the thematic quality. Towards this end, the German Remote Sensing Data Centre (DFD) as part of the Germany's aerospace research establishment (DLR) operates a High Resolution Picture Transmission (HRPT) Station for the operational acquisition of Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) data. Additionally, DFD functions as a national Processing and Archiving Facility (PAF) for ERS-1/2 data on behalf of ESA. Also, high resolution SAR data from ERS missions can be captured in near-real time by DLR's X-band facilities at the DFD in Neustrelitz, enabling operational derivation of maritime and climatological parameters. This paper describes the value adding processes for the operational derivation of Multichannel Sea Surface Temperatures (MCSST) from NOAA AVHRR data in order to generate daily, weekly and monthly temperature maps of the Mediterranean including the Black Sea, the northeastern Atlantic including the Baltic and North Seas, and the region around Madeira and the Canary Islands. Emphasis is given to special sensor processing steps such as calibration, navigation and cloud-screening for the available products. The ERS SAR is used to derive parameters such as mesoscale wind fields, currents and water levels for the needs of coastal management. Since the SAR works with the same wavelength as the scatterometer, the signal can be evaluated by the same algorithm used for the scatterometer signal (CMOD4 Algorithm from ESA). The wind direction is determined by a method that uses the average direction of wind rows visible on SAR images. Comparisons of wind measurements using recalibrated ERS SAR images to ground truth data are given. Finally, the application potential is outlined and network data distribution, including public access to all products via DLR's Intelligent Satellite Information System (ISIS), are described.
1. INTRODUCTION The derivation of Multichannel Sea Surface Temperatures (MCSST) and windfield maps is described and an example of combining the two measurements for two consecutive SAR im-
244 ages is given for a 100 by 150 km area in the Golfe du Lion in the northwestern Mediterranean Sea. 1.1 Derivation of Sea Surface Temperatures MCSST products derived from NOAA AVHRR data were the first results of DLR's AVHRR pathfinder activities. The goal of this product palette is to provide the user with MCSST maps of highest possible reliability and quality that are at the same time easy to access via ISIS and WWW (see last page). After a phase of definition, the operational production chain based on TeraScan TM software was launched in March 1993 coveting the entire Mediterranean and Black Seas. Since then, daily, weekly, and monthly data sets have been available in near real time. In addition, MCSST maps coveting the northeastern Atlantic including the Baltic and North Seas and the region around the Island of Madeira, equivalent to the "Mediterranean MCSST maps" have been added since August 1994. The most important aspects of the MCSST maps from the user's viewpoint are precise image registration and sophisticated cloud screening to ensure the best possible geometrical accuracy and cloud clearing. It is then guaranteed that only cloudfree pixels are taken for the later process of MCSST derivation [1 ]. 1.2 Derivation of Windfields The measurement of mesoscale windfields is needed as input for a variety of models e.g. to derive currents, sea state or related transport processes. Validation of the model results with conventional ground truth measurements usually requires enormous efforts in large campaigns. Studies concentrated on deriving mesoscale windfields from 100 by 100 km ERS SAR images. The resolution of these images is about 25 m. Due to backscattering at the rough ocean surface, the dominating effect determining the s o
values of the ocean surface is the wind speed. Therefore, radiometrically calibrated SAR images offer a unique opportunity to make synoptic mesoscale wind measurements that were never before possible. The backscatter can be derived theoretically, calculating the Bragg scattering at the ocean surface due to roughness at the scale of the radar wavelength. An algorithm based on this theory and on heuristic parameter tuning is ESA's scatterometer wind retrieval algorithm CMOD4 [2]. The wind direction is taken from additional information in the image like windstreaks or wind shadowing on the water surface due to cliffs at the coast.
2. M A J O R PROCESSING STEPS FOR MCSST PRODUCTS
Table 1: Overview of AVHRR sea surface temperature and SAR wind speed product specifications
245
2.1 Automatic prenavigation / interactive supervision Automatic navigation of the satellite data is performed using an orbit model and timely orbital information. Appropriate coastline areas with significant features are selected in 1deg x 1deg boxes and tested for cloudiness. For the cloudfree boxes a cross correlation algorithm between the "real" coastline in the satellite image and the coastline of the reference data set (WDBII) is run. Based on the yielding vector array, the satellite's yaw, pitch, tilt, and roll angles are corrected. The complete procedure is first done unsupervised, then the results are checked interactively and if necessary corrected manually. This is done for each scene before the remapping procedure is applied and ensures best possible quality. 2.2 Calibration Solar channels 1 (0.581.tm- 0.68~tm) and 2 (0.725~tm- 1. ll.tm) of AVHRR are calibrated into "technical albedo" as described by NOAA [3]. These channels are not taken into account for the generation of the MCSST, but are needed for the cloud testing procedure. For the NOAA11 AVHRR time-adjusted calibration coefficients provided by Teillet and Holbe [4] are applied. For the NOAA-12 AVHRR pre-launch coefficients and for NOAA-14 AVHRR postlaunch coefficients are used as updated by NOAA (on the internet http://orbitnet.nesdis.noaa.gov/ora/text/nrao01.txt). Thermal channels 3 (3.551.tm - 3.93~tm), 4 (11.31am 12.31am) and 5 (11.51am - 12.51am) are calibrated into radiances with reference temperature data from the internal blackbody on bord and the cold space (in-flight calibration). These are then converted into brightness temperatures (or equivalent blackbody temperature) using the inverse of Planck's radiation equation. The nonlinearity between counts and radiances is considered. The resulting radiometric resolution is 0. I~ 2.3 Cloud Screening and Clearing To ensure that MCSST values are derived for cloudfree water surfaces only, several cloud tests are performed which are based on the principal characteristics of water bodies. The tests consider typical spectral and textural parameters of a cloudfree water body (e.g. dark, warm, and homogenous surface) and are changed from case to case depending on the specific characteristics of the individual scene [5]. A WDBII based land/sea mask in 1 km geometrical resolution is used to mask remaining MCSST values over land areas. 2.4 Derivation of the Multichannel Sea Surface Temperature (MCSST) The formula applied to obtain the Multichannel Sea Surface Temperature is based on the brightness temperature of AVHRR channels 4 and 5 (T4 and T5). The technique is known as the "Split Window Technique" and contains a correction for water vapor in the atmosphere that could otherwise lead to a significant drop in derived brightness temperatures, depending on the climatological region down to several ~ The formula applied is according to McClain [6]: MCSST = A'T4 + B*(T4-T5) + C*(T4-T5)*(SEC(sza)-I) + D*(SEC(sza)-I) + E Coefficients A, B, C, D and E are day/night specific for every AVHRR instrument. They are obtained from of empirical buoy measurements and are provided by NOAA. SEC(sza) is the secant of the satellite zenith angle.
246 2.5 Geographical coverage The data sets are remapped into a standard Mercator projection with a geometrical resolution of 1.1132 km at the center of the satellite map. Figure 1 shows the areas of coverage for the MCSST products.
Figure 1: Areas of coverage for the AVHRR MCSST products (temperature in degree C) 2.6 Synthesis Three daily MCSST maps are composed containing up to five daily NOAA acquisitions. They are calculated using the maximum temperature value given at each pixel's position in order to minimize remaining cloud influences, as contamination of clouds leads to lower MCSST estimates. Weekly and monthly products are based on the daily maximum images using the average MCSST value at each pixel's position.
3. SAR DERIVED WINDFIELDS 3.1 Calibration of the SAR Images To determine the windfields, the SAR images have to be calibrated, converting the grey levels of the image into calibrated backscatter cross sections s 0. Unfortunately, during the studies it became clear that ERS-1 SAR has a serious calibration problem, due to saturation of the analog-to-digital converter. This saturation affects the SAR raw data and occurs mainly when imaging large areas of homogenous bright backscatter, which is especially the case for inland ice or ocean surfaces in medium to strong wind conditions [7]. However, for large homogeneous areas the power loss can be estimated by using a correction look up table for the already processed PRI SAR image. This is the essence of the algorithm
247 derived by ESA [8]. A description is given on ESA's WWW server. Due to the reduced gain settings of ERS-2, the problem is less severe for ERS-2 S AR images and therefore these are more suitable for windfield measurements. 3.2 Windfield Derivation
The wind speed is derived from the SAR image using the method suggested by Rosenthal [9]. First, the wind direction is determined from wind patterns in the image. The recalibrated image is averaged to at least 200 m pixel size to reduce speckle, and then wind speed is determined pixelwise by ESA's wind retrieval algorithm CMOD4.
Figure 2: SAR derived windfield in the Golfe du Lion, 20. April 1992, 10:28 UTC
248
4. CASE STUDY F R O M THE G O L F E DU LION As an example, an overlay of two consecutive geocoded ERS-1 SAR scenes from the Rhone delta with the respective MCSST map is considered. The SAR images were taken on the 20 April 1992 10:28 UTC, the NOAA overpass occurred about three hours later at 13:55 UTC. Figure 2 shows the windfield derived from two consecutive SAR images (separation line in black), grey values correspond to wind speed, the contour lines give the absolute value of the measurement. In the southwest, windstreaks which are in the direction of the wind can be detected. In this area the derived windspeed is with 11 m/s strongest, too. Fourier analysis of the streaks yielded a wind direction of 340 degrees, which agreed with the ground truth measurement at Marseilles. This wind direction was used over the whole image to derive the windspeed with the ESA wind retrieval algorithm CMOD4. The highest wind speed measured was about 12 m/s. In Figure 3, the three parallel cuts (as indicated in Figure 2) of wind speed measurements at distances 15 km, 55 km and 95 km from the coast are plotted. 14
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
12 o,
10 _
-
E
--
",/
\
,
.
/
,
j
""
,
." .f
"
/',-
/\
El_
-
.E
/:.'J'"\,"\.
,.
','~ "'\,'7 ./,. ,-\,.. ~,. 9
V'
. 4
"--"
.
/,~ ~
J
"-
-0 -
'k.. .. ~
9
_
r
v
..~.,"/,..V
~
A
]"~'~....xA/'%]\ .
.
.
-
\
J "~
\
~,~
=.=
/ ~,
.
-
"X ,
r v
"~
,
' r~ ,'\'L,,..
' ''%' ~"
'
'
15 krn
_
95 km
__.. ,
,
~
-
;
~" v \ .~
. . . .
0
_
X.~
__
_
0
--
-
"~ j " ,
F ,,
q I
~
~
~
20
I
~
t
40 Oistonce
ocross
,
I
~
~
60 the
SAR I m o g e
,
I
80
,
,
,
H I
100
[kin]
Figure 3 S AR derived wind speeds, cuts parallel to the coast Obviously the wind picks up away from the coast from about 4 m/s to 12 m/s and is stronger in the west than in the east, which agrees well with the ground truth from Meteo France. At 12:00 UTC the wind speed at Marseilles was measured to be 4 m/s, and 15 m/s further west at Montpellier. At the Rhone delta features can be detected that are due to slicks and not to changing wind speed. These features are only apparent at very low windspeeds and then of course influence the wind speed measurements. At wind speeds above 6 m/s those effects become negligible.
249
Figure 4 shows the MCSST measurements overlaid with contours of the windspeed measurements. In the area of high windspeed the sea surface has cooled to 12 degrees due to stronger evaporation. As there is a time difference of three hours between the two satellite measurements, some of the features may have moved.
Figure 4: Golfe du Lion, SST in ~ overlaid with a contour plot of wind speed in rn/s
250 Data access is possible via ISIS, the "Intelligent Satellite Information System" of DLR [ 10], data is free of charge.
For further help, please contact DFD's "Helpdesk": Tel.: +49-(0)8153-28-2802, Fax: +49(0)8153-1343, email: [email protected] or [email protected]
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
Part of the work was funded by the German Ministry of Research (BMBF) under contract No. 03F0165C. The data were kindly provided by ESA as part of the ERS AO project AO02.D 113.
REFERENCES
1. S.W. Dech, Proceedings of"The Meteorological Satellite Data Users' Conference", Winchester, UK, EUMETSAT-Publications EUM P 17, Darmstadt, (1995) 595-599. 2. E. Stoffelen and D. Anderson, Advance Space Research, 13, 5, (1993) 53-60. 3. L.N. Lauritson, G. J. Porto,W. Frank, NOAA Technical Memorandum NESS 107 (1979). 4. P.M. Teillet, B. N. Holben, Can. J. Rem. Sens., 20(1) (1994) 1-10. 5. R.L. Bernstein, J. Geophys. Res., Vol. 87, No. C12 (1982) 9455-9465. 6. P.E. McClain, W. G. Pichel, C. C. Walton, Journal of Geophysical Research, Vol. 90, C6 (1985) 11587- 11601. 7. S. Lehner, J. Horstmann, W. Rosenthal, W. Koch, J. Geophys. Res. (1997) in press. 8. Laur, H., P. Bally, P. Meadows, J. Sanchez, B. Schaettler, E. Lopinto, Issue 2, Rev. 1 (1996), to be published 9. W. Rosenthal, S. Lehner, J. Horstmann, W. Koch, Proc. of the 2nd ERS Appl. workshop, ESA SP-383 (1996) 355-358. 10. G. Strunz, H.-J. Lotz-Iwen, International Archives of Photogrammetry and Remote Sens ing, Vol. 30, Part 3/2 (1994) 801-805.
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge for European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen
251
9 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Hydrographic Laser Fluorosensing: Status and Perspectives R. Reuter, R. Willkomm, O. Zielinski, W. Milchers University of Oldenburg, Physics Department, D-26111 Oldenburg, Germany*
In 1991 the German Ministry of Transport put a Dornier DO 228-212 aircraft into operation, for maritime surveillance of the German territorial waters in the North Sea and the Baltic Sea. The aircraft is equipped with Side-Looking Airborne Radar and a UV/IR scanner for the detection of oil spills. For a more detailed analysis of spills, two new instruments, a Microwave Radiometer and a Laser Fluorosensor, were integrated in 1993. An overview of the Laser Fluorosensor specifications is presented. It is the first instrument of its kind that meets operational requirements for long-term use on board an aircraft. By using a conical scanner, it allows two-dimensional mapping of the sea surface in the nadir range, with 150 m swath width from an altitude of 300 m. Maps of oil film thickness and substance classes are derived from these measurements as part of the pollution control operation. For hydrographic applications the sensor is used to measure the concentration of gelbstoff and algae by their fluorescence, and the attenuation by the water Raman signal. Kriging interpolation between flight tracks is used to generate maps of these parameters. Based on experience with the airborne instrument, the feasibility of fluorescence measurements from space using platforms at altitudes of up to 800 km is studied. A cloudless, horizontally stratified atmosphere, including aerosols and ozone, is taken into consideration. A simulation based on Fermat's principle is used to describe the radiative transfer. The Results are presented in this paper.
1 INTRODUCTION In 1985 two Dornier DO 28 D2 aircraft were procured for maritime surveillance by the German governmental authorities. These aircraft were equipped with side-looking airborne radar (SLAR) for detecting oil slicks over large distances, a UV/IR scanner for mapping the sea surface in the nadir range, and TV and photographic cameras. In the second generation of the German maritime surveillance system, the addition of a microwave radiometer (MWR) and a laser fluorosensor (LFS) completed the mission equipment. The new mapping sensors allow for a wider analysis of oil spills in terms of film thickness and hence the discharged volume. LFS data also contain information on the type of spilled substance. Moreover, various hydrographic and biological data can be measured, such as seawater turbidity and concentrations of phytoplankton and gelbstoff, which are useful parameters for estimating ecological conditions in coastal waters. A Dornier DO 228-212 aircraft www.physik, uni-oldenburg.de/Docs/las/
252
allows a flight time of up to 6 hours. An overview of this second generation surveillance system in an early stage of its implementation is given by Grtiner et al. [6]. The hydrographic fluorescence lidar is described extensively in the literature (e.g. the review by Measures [13]). Signals from natural organic compounds,in seawater, like gelbstoff and phytoplankton pigments, generally interfere with the fluorescence emission of oils and need consideration when interpreting data. The measurement of these naturally occurring substances is described in several papers [2, 4, 5, 7, 14]. Layout and specifications of the LFS developed at the University of Oldenburg and examples of two-dimensional images from oil slicks are described in Reuter et al. [ 15]. The application of the sensor for mapping hydrographic features, the Kriging algorithm for interpolation between flight tracks, and (based on the experience with the operational airborne system) some aspects of a combined hydrographic/atmospheric lidar in space are presented here.
2 THE LASER F L U O R O S E N S O R The LFS is an airborne fluorescence lidar for analysing the upper layers of the sea from aircraft flight altitudes of 100 to 300 m. It consists of: 9 an XeCI excimer laser for the analysis of oils, gelbstoff and organic pollutants, 9 an excimer laser-pumped dye laser for chlorophyll fluorescence excitation, and hence the measurement of phytoplankton distributions, 9 a telescope with 20 cm entrance aperture, and a 12-channel spectrograph, 9 a conical scanner for two-dimensional mapping of the sea-surface, and 9 a VME-Bus computer for instrument control and on-line data analysis. Since November 1993 the LFS has been operated as a component of the sensor package in a maritime surveillance aircraft. The prototype has been checked in mechanical, electronic and climatic endurance tests (crash calculations, eye safety of the laser at the operational altitude and qualification of the gas reservoir) and is now certified for permanent aircraft use. Table 1. Laser F l u o r o s e n s o r specifications Operating properties size (1 x w x h) 1,270 x 355 x 978 mm 3 laser unit 961 x 460 x 944 mm 3 detector unit weight 315 kg flight height 1,0()() ft typ. electrical power l.() kVA/3.4 kVA standby/at 110 Hz pulse rate Lasers emission wavelength pulse energy/pulse length beam divergence rep. rate peak/average Te le scope entrance aperture f-number
XeCi excimer 308 nm 150 mJ/20 ns 2 x 10 mrad 220 Hz/110 Hz Casse grain 20 cm f/10
dye: polyphenyl 2 382 nm 20 mJ/15 ns 3 mrad 20 Hz/20 Hz
253
Scanner full scan angle swath width pixel-to-pixel distance
conical type, 20 Hz max. scan frequency, selectable 28 ~ across-flight, 35 ~ in-flight 150 m at 300 m flight altitude 10 m typ. at 300 m flight height, 110 Hz average rep. rate
Spectrograph detection channels detection wavelengths wavelength selection detectors AJD conversion
12 discrete, modular, optical bandwidth 10 nm typ. 332, 344, 365,382, 407, 441, 471,492, 551,592, 650, 684 nm dichroic beam splitters, glass blocking and interference filters compact head-on PMT, range gated 12-channel gated integrator, 11 bit resolution
3 M E A S U R E M E N T S FROM ONBOARD AN AIRCRAFT
3.1 Data acquisition a n d processing The fluorescence signals from gelbstoff and algae are normalised to the Raman signal for compensation of attenuation effects. Calibration of the sensor against laboratory measurements leads to absolute concentrations. "['he attenuation coefficient can be estimated from the inverse Raman scattered signal, if the data are compensated for geometrical (i.e. flight altitude and geometry of scan) and sea state effects at the air-water interface. The background signal from daylight can be a problem when intense sun glitter directly reaches the detector or when the fluorescence signals are very weak. For routine operation, algorithms have been derived to rccognise faulty data and exclude them from further processing steps. Problems with sun glitter arc minimised by selecting footprints of the scan pattern lying in the opposite direction compared with the azimuth of the sun. The signal-tobackground ratio can be further improved by selecting lower flight altitudes.
3.2 (;eostatistical interpolation of data In oceanographic applications the use of a scanner installed on board a low flying aircraft is not meaningful because of the much larger geometric structures in comparison to oil spills. For this purpose, it is necessary to measure along several distant tracks over the area of interest. The data found along these tracks are interpolated over the whole area using geostatistical methods (Schulz-Ohlberg [16]). The advantage of these methods is the use of statistical information contained in the data. Assuming the same statistical bchaviour of the data over the whole area, the variogram
r(h)-
1
Z [Z(x+ h)- Z(x)]
2 N ( h ) N(h)
(t)
can be derived. The correlation of data between points is statistically described as a function of their distance h, where N(h) is the flequency of points with distance h. T(h) can be interpreted as a statistical distance of measured data between spatial distant points. Using both this information and the Kriging method, the distribution of a parameter is estimated with a minimal uncertainty as a linear combination of measured values. The minimised variance is given for the whole area and this intbrmation is used to establish an optimised pattern of the flight tracks. The distribution estimated with Kriging shows little fluctuation because of the
254
mean value characteristic of the interpolated data. As an advantage, large-scale structures become more obvious. 3.3 Experimental Results Flights with the LFS operating in the hydrographic mode have been performed in the Canary Islands region and over the coastal waters of Germany, i.e. the German Bight and the Western Baltic. The algorithms for automatic selection of footprints and filtering during data processing have successfully provided reliable results. An on-line test of the data quality during measurements is important to ensure the operation of the sensor with an optimal set-up under changing conditions (mainly a change of water type).
Figure 1: Mapping of the near-surface gelbstoff distribution, Canary Islands region, June 1995. The dotted lines show the flight tracks of four missions. Gelbstoff fluorescence was measured at 441 nm and normalised to the area of the 344 nm water Raman band as a quantitative measure of the fluorescence intensity. This signal, denoted as Raman units RU [3], is in the order of 2-10 .3 /nm at 308 nm excitation wavelength. Data measured along the flight tracks of three missions are used to derive a two-dimensional distribution with Kriging. The algorithm also provides a map of estimation errors which are zero on the flight tracks and increase at more distant points (not shown here). Under the hydrographic conditions in the German coastal areas the sensor is operated at 300 m altitude, providing data of the attenuation coefficient, and of gelbstoff and phytoplankton chlorophyll concentrations. Measurements under daylight conditions have also been performed over waters with open ocean conditions, such as in the region of the Canary Islands, where gelbstoff fluorescence is low. Chlorophyll concen-
255
trations of about 0.5 m g / m 3 can only be measured at night-time because of the high daylight background.
4 M E A S U R E M E N T S F R O M SPACE It has been shown that airborne laser remote sensing of hydrographic conditions is routinely carried out in coastal zones. However, a global monitoring programme (e.g. the Earth Observing System, EOS) calls for a long-term and large-scale investigation of oceanographic processes. Some of these measurements could be achieved by a hydrographic lidar in space. In this chapter the simulation of such a system is presented as well as solutions to some specific problems. Finally the potential of a combined hydrographic/atmospheric lidar is discussed.
4.1 Radiative transfer in the atmosphere Satellites on low earth orbits, between 300 and 800 km above sea level, are possible space platforms for a hydrographic lidar. From these altitudes the laser beam and the detected fluorescence of a possible lidar are subject to atmospheric influences that weaken and deflect the signal. The solar induced background signal depends strongly on both actual weather conditions and the angle between the sun and the detector. The signal-to-background ratio is essential tot intormation retrieval. Sources of atmospheric influences for the optical information in the visible and near ultra-violet region are Rayleigh scattering (with its typical ~-4 dependence) and absorption by ozone (O3) (especially below 320 nm). This factor is considerably higher than attenuation by tropospheric and stratospheric aerosols. In addition to these well-known effects [1, 9, 10, 11], two factors should be examined for a complete dcscription. A hydrographic lidar in space will change its position during the time of light propagation in the atmosphere. So an angular correction will be necessary ~. Furthermore, a beam of light started under a laser-zenith angle ;e 0 ~ is deflected by the variable refraction index of air, resulting in a slant path. By modelling the radiative transfer it will be possible to calculate the deviation and attenuation of the optical signal. 4.2 Simulation of a hydrographic iidar-in-space In this simulation of light propagation, a cloudless and horizontally stratified atmosphere is taken into consideration. The US Standard Atmosphere of 1962 with additional information on ozone and aerosols is applied [10] for the purpose of testing. The refractive index n(z) at an altitude z depending on the temperature T(z), the partial pressure of air p(z), the partial pressure ot" water vapour D~2o(Z), and the wavelength )~, are calculated using the equation by McClatchey and Selby [l l]: ( (n(z)-l))
106 -
77.46+
0.459~tm 2 ) 22
p(z) K T(z) hPa
PH2o(Z) ( 4 3 . 4 9 _ 0 . 3 4 7 / . t m 2 ) 1013hPa ~2 . (2)
For a flight altitude of 300 km the plattorm moves -15.5 m during the time elapsed between firing the laser signal and its return. Therefore, the centres of the laser illuminated region and the detector field of view also are at a distance of -15.5 m. Assuming circular patterns and a 0.6 mrad divergence for both components this leads to an overlap of only 89% of the possible maximum. A small angle correction of 0.0029~ at the detector for a nadirlooking laser would compensate this movementand allow tbr a 100% overlap.
256 The slant path calculation is solved using Fermat's variation principle, stating that light always takes the shortest optical path, via the Euler-Lagrange differential equation. Implementing this solution in an integration over the altitude z, the deviation of a light beam of wavelength X starting at z~ under an angle O(Zl) can be calculated by
/
n ( zn(z) l)sin| x ( z ~ ) - x ( z , ) + "zj
' ) 1-
n(z)
/
sin2|
dz,
(3)
with n(z)=n(T, p, Pn2o, X) being the refractive index of air following equation (2). As mentioned before, the movement of the platform during the time of light propagation calls for a small angular correction, e.g. at the detector. In the first approximation one can show that a detector under an angle of sin Odor -- (.Xd~ --
dz,
X probe
n(z)
Zprobe
will correct the platform movement if XFobe is the centre of the laser illuminated area calculated via Eq. (3) and x,t~t is approximated by Xdet = 2 t vs~t, with t being the time the laser pulse takes from the platform to the sea surface. 100 - .9 a~ ot-
-a r'-
._~ >
Xprobe(685nm)- Xprobe(308nm)
_
altitude=3OOkm
l
1 .mlm-,mm..-mm~
0.1
.m I
j
~, ~ ~, ~, ~ | ~, ~ ~ ~c3~ 40,
II ~ oll"~
groundii!iii~i~iil
.o_
-60
10
20
30
40
50
laser-zenith angle
60
(')laser [o]
70
80
+ :=t~ ~ ~ii
/ ~ . -20
track
;': i i ~
ii i! ii ::i ::! i! ii ::i ::i!~ ::.L 6~:: .~': ~:: ~ : : :: ;: ~6::~:: ~:' ~ : : ~ ' :: ' '
,0
l
!ii~ iiiiii_~!~
:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
~ "~ -20.
O.Ol jil, "-
0.001 ~ 0
ii iii i ii ii ii il ii ii il iii~ . ~!i ! ii
._, 2o. E ~c- 0
9
,
0
9
,
20
9
,
40
9
,
60
.
,
80
il i! ~ ~=: ,
,
100
.
,
120
.
,
140
position in direction of flight [km]
Figure 2. Effect of dispersion of a laser beam Figure 3. Example of a scan pattern (altitude with a variable laser-zenith-angle measured via 300 km, X 355 nm, pulse rep. rate 10 Hz, the deviation distance for two wavelengths, max. scan angle 10~ Calculating the deviation of a light beam (equation (3)), for a different wavelength X, it is possible to estimate the effect of dispersion at a given laser-zenith angle O~ser. Figure 2 shows the difference of these deviations Xprobe at 685 and 308 nm. It is shown that the wavelength dependence of the refraction index can be practically neglected for | ~ It is possible to calculate complete scan patterns of a hydrographic lidar using the given equations, for reasons of optimisation and illustration. Figure 3 shows such a scan pattern on the German Bight and Figure 4 summarises some proposed features of the instrument.
257
4.3 Layout of a spaceborne iidar A possible laser source is a frequency tripled Nd:YAG-laser (X,=355 nm) using the absorption gap of ozone between 350 and 450 nm. Matvienko et al. [8] proposed the 1064 nm emission for simultaneous retrieval of atmospheric information. In fact the use of Nd:YAG-laser frequencies is well known from atmospheric campaigns like the Lidar In-Space Technology Experiment (LITE) [12]. A combined oceanic/atmospheric lidar offers the possibility to combine oceanographic measurements with actual atmospheric corrections, yielding quantitative concentrations of fluorescent matter in the surface layer of the ocean. Table 2. Proposed specifications of a hydrographic lidar in space laser laser type diode pumped Nd:YAG-iaser emission wavelength 1064, 532, 355 nm pulse repetition rate 10 Hz beam divergence 0.3 mrad platform flight altitude 300 800 footprint distance 740 770 footprint diameter 90 240
km m m
Figure 4. Illustration of a hydrographic lidar in space
5 DISCUSSI()N As a result of LFS development, an instrument is available which is qualified for permanent installation on board an aircraft. This instrument meets the operational specifications for long-term use in maritime surveillance. The use of a scanner and a laser with high pulse firing rate yields two-dimensional maps of the sea surface. When compared with nadir-looking lidars utilised earlier, the new instrument is a powerful tool when analysing oil spills and other structures on the ground with comparatively small geometric scales. The experimental results described in this paper demonstrate the performance of the LFS and its capability of mapping medium-scale hydrographic features. The area covered by one flight with the Dornier DO 228 aircraft is about 50,000 km 2. Pollution control flights performed over German coastal areas on a regular basis provide an opportunity to monitor the change of hydrographic parameters over time scales of one week. Additionally, it has been stated that a spaceborne hydrographic lidar offers the possibility of long-term and large-scale monitoring of bio-optical components like yellow-substance and chlorophyll. The simulation of radiative transfer via a specific solution of Fermat's principle enables the optimisation of lidar angle configuration. It is also shown that effects caused by dispersion in the atmosphere can be neglected at small laser-zenith angles. For an improved
258
correction of fluorescence signals a simultaneous measurement of atmospheric parameters of a combined hydrographic/atmospheric lidar is proposed and possible specifications are given.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The development of the Laser Fluorosensor was financially supported by the DLR Project Executive Department of Environmental Protection and Technologies, Bonn, on behalf of the Federal Ministry for Research and Technology. The authors are grateful to the staff of the Naval Air Wing 3 in Nordholz, for their co-operation during the hydrographic experiments.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12.
13. 14. 15. 16.
B. Bartsch, T. Braeske, R. Reuter. Appl. Optics, 32, No. 33 (1993) M. Bristow, D. Bundy, C.M. Edmonds, P.E. Ponto, B.E. Frey, L.F. Small. Int. J. Remote Sensing, 6, (1985) 1707-1734 S. Determann, R. Reuter, P. Wagner, R. Willkomm. Deep-Sea Res. 41, (1994) 659-675 A. Dudelzak, S. Babichenko, L. Poryvkina, K.J. Saar. Appl. Optics, 30, (1991) 453-458 R.J. Exton, W.M. Houghton, W. Esaias, R.C. Harriss, F.H. Farmer, H.H. White. Appl. Optics, 22, (1983) 54-64 K. GriJner, R. Reuter, H. Staid. GeoJournal, 24.1, (1991) 103-117 F.E. Hoge, R.N. Swift and J.K. Yungei. Appl. Optics, 25, (1986) 48-57 G.G. Matvienko, G.P. Kokhanenko, M.M. Krekova, I.E. Penner and V.S. Shamanayev. In: Lidar Techniques for Remote Sensing II, SPIE, Vol. 2581 (1995) E.J. McCartney: Optics of the Atmosphere - Scattering by Molecules and Particles, John Wiley & Sons (1976) R.A. McClatchey, R.W. Fenn, J.E.A. Selby, F.E. Volz and J.S. Garing: Optical Propertics of the Atmosphere (3rd Ed.), AFCRL-72-0497, Env. Res. Papers, No. 471 (1972) R:A: McClatchey and J.E.A. Selby: Atmospheric Transmittance from 0.25 to 28.5mm: Computer Code LOWTRAN 3, AFCRL-TR-75-0255, Env. Res. Papers, No. 513 (1975) M.P. McCormick, D.M. Winkler, E.V. Browell, J.A. Coakley, C.S. Gardner, R.M. Hoff, G.S. Kent, S.H. Melfi, R.T. Menzies, C.M.R. Platt, D.A. Randall and J.A. Reagan: Scientific Investigations Planned for the Lidar In-Space Technology Experiment (LITE), Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 74, No. 2 (1993) R.M. Measures: Laser Remote Sensing. Fundamentals and Applications, John Wiley & Sons, New York, (1984) 510 pp. R. Reuter, D. Diebel, T. Hengstermann. Int. J. Remote Sensing, 14, (1993) 823-484 R. Reuter, H. Wang, R. Willkomm, K.D. Loquay, T. Hengstermann, A. Braun. EARSeL Advances in Remote Sensing, 3, (1995) 152-169 J. Schulz-Ohlberg: Die Anwendung geostatistischer Verfahren zur Interpretation von gravimetrischen und magnetischen Felddaten, Deutsches Hydrographisches Institut, Wiss.-Techn. Berichte, 6 (1989)
Operational Oceanography. The Challenge for European Co-operation edited by J.H. Stel, H.W.A. Behrens, J.C. Borst, L.J. Droppert, J. v.d. Meulen 1997 Elsevier Science B.V.
259
Operational use of NOAA AVHRR imagery in the marine environment J.N. Roozekrans Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute (KNMI) PO Box 201, 3730 AE De Bilt, The Netherlands E-mail: [email protected]
Since early 1990 KNMI has been running an operational system to produce and distribute image-products, based on AVHRR data received in real time from the NOAA-satellites. Maps of sea surface temperatures (SST) and total suspended matter concentrations (TSM) in the North Sea and IJsselmeer are produced with regular frequency (minimal once a week). If necessary, daily maps are produced indicating locations of blooms of Coccolithophore algae in the North Sea, drifting layers of Blue Algae, and/or ice-cover on the water-surface of the IJsselmeer. Digital image-files on floppy-disk and colour-coded hardcopies of the maps are available for the user. During the last decade KNMI, in co-operation with other institutes, has put considerable effort into the stimulation of operational use of the NOAA image-products in the marine environment. In the perspective of EuroGOOS the KNMl-service could be a useful contribution to a monitoring system for the European coastal waters.
1. THE MARINE E N V I R O N M E N T AND R E M O T E S E N S I N G The water quality of oceans and seas has become more and more the subject of concern for marine ecologists and biologists because of threatens to the flora and fauna. The North Sea is especially subjected to many sources of environmental stress: outflow of polluted rivers, offshore-industry, shipping (oil-spills, accidents), fisheries, etc. The effects of this stress can be very dynamic in time and space. Therefore a regular and complete monitoring of the marine environment belongs to the most important tasks in the management (policy-making and inspection) and research of the North Sea. 1.1. Remote sensing as a monitoring tool
Complementary to conventional measurements from ships, buoys and platforms, remote sensing has proven to be a potentially useful technique to fulfill this task. The strongest point of remote sensing is the synoptic view of large areas, which can not be obtained from the point measurements. However, operational use of remote sensing for monitoring the marine environment is hampered by some weak points: the limited amount of measurable parameters, the limited accuracy of remote sensing observations and the data accessibility. We are at the edge of a new and very promising era of satellite remote sensing of marine parameters. ERS, SeaWiFS, Meris, Modis, etc. will provide a wealth of data in the near future.
260
However, currently the NOAA-AVHRR is the only suitable satellite-system for the operational monitoring of both temperature and colour of sea surfaces [1]. No other currently available operational satellite-system offers the same combination of relatively high accuracy, high temporal and spatial resolution, relatively low costs and high accessibility to data.
1.2. The NOAA-AVHRR satellite-system Since the end of the 1970's satellites of the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) of the USA have been orbiting the Earth. Two satellites are operational and each passing over twice a day. One of the main sensors on board the NOAAsatellites is the Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR). The AVHRR measures radiation in five different bands: band
1:
.58
-
.68
~m
(red)
band band band band
2: 3: 4: 5:
.72 3.55 10.30 11.50
-
1.10 3.93 11.30 12.50
~m ~m ~m ~m
(near infrared) (infrared) (thermal infrared) (thermal infrared)
Each picture element (pixel) represents an area of about 1.1 km z. The field of view of the sensor is __+ 2500 km wide. The radiometric resolution of the A VHRR is 10 bits (1024 levels). NOAA-satellite data are continuously broadcasted to the Earth. Any receiving station, (equipped with the right hardware) viewing the satellite can receive the data in real time and free of charge.
2. OPERATIONAL REAL-TIME NOAA AVHRR SERVICE AT KNMI In 1985 KNMI started a research and development project to define products and to set-up an operational service for production and distribution of NOAA-AVHRR image products for the Dutch users [2]. The combination of the need for information of the North Sea environment, the potential of the NOAA AVHRR system to provide this information and the availability of a high quality groundstation for NOAA AVHRR data urged KNMI to build an operational system for the real-time production and distribution of NOAA-AVHRR image products. Considerable effort has been put into the definition of the system (hardware) and automation (as much as possible) of the data-processing. The form of the products and the mode of distribution was chosen after intensive consultation of potential users. In January 1990 the service became operational and, since then, AVHRR-products of the North Sea have been archived routinely at KNMI. After the finalization of the system, a major step towards operational application of the products by Dutch users was entered. In August 1995 the system has been extended towards the production and archiving of SST-
261
maps of all European coastal waters and a large part of the North Atlantic Ocean. 2.1. System-configuration Since 1982 KNMI has operated a HRPT-receiving station for NOAA-data to be used for weather forecasting. The KNMI station is the only operational HRPT-type station in The Netherlands. In 1991 a new HRPT-station was installed at KNMI by VCS Engineering in Bochum. This station is able to provide already calibrated image-files in OpenVMS format. A DEC Alpha-3000/600 workstation is connected to the HRPT-station for processing of AVHRR image-files for Earth-observation purposes. Image products are transfered to a MS-DOS PC/AT via an Ethernet/LAN connection. This system is equiped with a hardcopy-device (Tektronix 4693DX Thermal Wax colour printer) and an Optical Disk archiving-system. 2.2 Real-time p r o c e s s i n g o f N O A A - A V H R R d a t a All overhead orbits are automatically processed on the DEC workstation immediately after reception of the data by the KNMI-groundstation. This processing includes the following steps: - navigation using 1 day old TBUS-data - cloudmasking (the APOLLO scheme of Saunders and Kriebel [3] is used) - atmospheric correction - polar stereographic projection of images KNMI has developed a software-package for automatic performance of the AVHRR-data processing. The package is based on the APOLLO-algorithms of the Brittish Met Office. The following manually operated processes are necessary to make the final image-products ready for the user: - exact navigation by fitting projected imagery to a fixed land/sea mask - production of weekly and monthly composite-images - quality inspection (i.e. final cloudscreening) - production of quantitative imagery using groundtruth-data 2.3. Standard A VHRR image-products
Full resolution (lkm) image products are routinely produced for areas that are of direct interest to potential Dutch users: the North Sea (between 50 ~ and 60 ~ N) and the IJsselmeer. The field-of-view of the KNMI receiving station covers most coastal waters of Europe and a large part of the Atlantic Ocean. In August 1995 KNMI started to produce weekly composite SST-maps (with 2kin resolution) of the European coastal waters. Upon request, KNMI is able to process and deliver full-resolution image products of areas within the field-of-view. The following image-products are routinely extracted from all overhead orbits, received at KNMI: A. Sea Surface Temperature (SST): Band 4 and 5 are used to derive a true SST using the "Split Window" technique: ssr
=
a
+ 8.r4
+
c.r5
~c
(I)
262
T4 and T5 are the brightness temperatures in the AVHRR-bands 4 and 5. For A, B and C coefficients, see Llewellyn-Jones et al. [4]. The accuracy of the SST's is ___ 0.5 ~ under normal atmospheric conditions. SST-images can be composited to derive weeny or monthly cloudfree SST-maps. B. "Red" reflectance of the water-column (REF)" Band 1 (red part of the spectrum) can be corrected for atmospheric distortions using an algorithm, originally developed for CZCS-data [5]" (Chl
-
Rayleigh,1)
-
(Ch2
-
Rayleigh,2)
R~" =
~
(2)
Transmission,1
Chl and Ch2 are the reflectivities in bands 1 and 2. Rayleigh,* and Transmission,1 are atmospheric interferences of the signals measured by the satellite. These components are calculated using models taking into account the sun- and view-angles. The term Ch2 - Rayleigh,2 is assumed to be representative for the aerosol-scattering of red light in the atmosphere. This assumption is based on the theory that all downward near-infrared radiation is absorbed by the water and thus all measured near-infrared radiation is scattered by the atmosphere. REF-images show qualitative turbidity-patterns near the sea surface. The signal is dominated mainly by non organic particles, like silt, in the upper water-column. Coccolithophore algae are very reflective, because of their calcium carbonate plates and are readily visible in the REF-images. C. Total Suspended Matter concentrations (TSM): The REF-images are quantified towards TSM using the following formula" Log(
TSM
)
=
A
*
Log(
REF
)
+
B
(3)
A and B are to be found for every separate image by regression analysis of formula (3) using a dataset of TSM-data, measured in situ at different locations at the same time as the NOAA-pass, together with the geo-located REF-values. The accuracy of the TSM image-data is very much dependent on the availability of a suitable in-situ TSM-dataset for the regression-analysis. The datasets must be suitable in terms of having enough dynamic range of TSM-concentrations and having a not-toolarge time difference between in-situ measurements and the NOAA-pass. Generally, it can be assumed that the concentrations in a NOAA TSM-image may have an inaccuracy of not more than 50% of the true concentration-values. D. Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI)" Ch2 NDVI
=
-
Ch 1
+
Ch I
-Ch 2
(4)
Ch 1 and Ch2 are the reflectivities in bands 1 and 2.
263 The NDVI is well-known to be a very useful indicator for green vegetation on land surfaces. For water surfaces the NDVI is normally negative. In the case of a floating layer of Blue Algae at the surface, the NDVI will be positive. So NDVI-imagery can be easily used for the monitoring of floating layers in fresh waterbodies, like the IJsselmeer. E. Ice-cover maps: The thermal bands of the AVHRR are well suited to map the ice-cover of large waterbodies. A very effective way to discriminate between ice and open water is to look at the difference between band 4 and 5. The higher the difference, the more significant is the indication of the presence of ice: T4
-
T5
>
+
1
~
~
(5)
ice
This method is based on the different emissivities of ice and water in both bands [6]. TABLE 1" Summary of NOAA AVHRR products
Product I[ResolutionI[ ,req of availability][Accuracy ][Area cover I SST
1 km 2 km
6x/24 4x/24
h; h;
1 comp./week 1 comp./week
< 0.5 < 0.5
REF
1 km
2x/24
h;
1 comp./week
qualitat.
TSM
1 km
2x/24
h;
1 comp./week
NDVI
1 km
2x per
24 h o u r s
qualitat.
IJsselmeer
Ice
1 km
6x per
24 h o u r s
qualitat.
IJsselmeer
C C
<50%
North Sea Europe North
Sea
North
Sea
2.4. Distribution of A VHRR-products to users The image-products are distributed to users as colour-coded maps (printed on paper or transparency) and/or as digital (8-bit) files on a MS-DOS floppy-diskette (by mail) or tranfered via Internet. Dedicated PC/AT software has been developed by KNMI and available for the user. This software (the NOAAPC-package) can be used for display and analysis of image-products on MS-DOS PC/AT systems equiped with EGA or VGA videocards.
3. APPLICATIONS AND USERS IN THE N E T H E R L A N D S Since the start of NOAA-AVHRR activities at KNMI in 1985, several institutes in The Netherlands have researched the potential of AVHRR-products as an information source for their own tasks. Starting in June 1990 seven Dutch institutes routinely obtained AVHRRproducts on an experimental basis and free of cost. Most of them operate in the marine area. In particular, the Tidal Waters Division, the Directorate North Sea and the Inland Waters Division of Rijkswaterstaat (a government agency) have put considerable into
264 several studies on the application of AVHRR-imagery. These studies, some of which are financed by the Dutch Remote Sensing Board in the framework of the National Remote Sensing Program, have resulted in six reports [7-12]. The following main conclusions concerning the usefulness of AVHRR-products for the Rijkswaterstaat, are derived from these reports: The AVHRR-bands are not appropriate for the real-time detection of algal blooms in the North Sea, unless it is a Coccolithophore bloom, which is strongly reflective of "red" light [ 13]. The NDVI of water surfaces is a strong indicator of floating layers of Blue Algae (so called "green soup") in fresh water bodies like the IJsselmeer. Daily NOAA-monitoring of the dynamics of the layers provides an early warning to authorities, dependent on clean IJsselmeer-water, like drinking water companies, marinas, fishermen, etc. - AVHRR SST- and TSM-imagery can be very useful to complement in-situ measurements and model-output to describe the transport of substances in the North Sea and IJsselmeer (i.e. the outflow of polluted river-water into the North Sea). The synoptic view is very attractive and an eye-opener in certain complex situations. - AVHRR SST- and REF-images can be used for the "real-time" support of researchvessels or -airplanes. By locating fronts or watermasses in the imagery, vessels or planes can be navigated towards places of high interest. - The monitoring of ice-cover of the IJsselmeer using NOAA AVHRR, provides useful real-time information for shipping and authorities responsible of buoys and beacons. -
-
Several research-institutes in The Netherlands, The Netherlands Institute for Research on the Sea (NIOZ), Delft Hydraulics (WL), the National Institute for Coastal and Marine Management (RIKZ) and the Institute for Fishery Research (RIVO), are using AVHRRimages in research-projects: - NIOZ has thoroughly researched the potential of the NOAA-AVHRR optical bands to observe turbidity parameters in coastal waters [14]. - NIOZ is researching the use of SST-images of the Atlantic Ocean for heat-flux estimations in climate-studies [10]. - Delft Hydraulics has developed a system for the assimilation of SST-data in a 3Dtemperature model of the North Sea [7]. Furthermore, they have developed an integrated data-model system, including NOAA AVHRR "colour" images, to support the monitoring of transport of suspended matter in the North Sea (see paper of Vos et al.). - RIKZ has used time series of NOAA AVHRR SST-imagery in the development of a model describing the dynamics of the river Rhine plume in the North Sea [ 15]. RIVO is researching the correlation between SST and the locations of spawn of hering in the North Sea. Monthly composites of SST-imagery is used for this study. -
KNMI itself is investigating the possibilities of assimilation of SST-data in numerical weather forecasting models. It is well known that the surface temperature of the ocean and the North Sea has a large influence on the weather in The Netherlands.
265 4. CONCLUSIONS ON THE STATE OF THE ART OF OPERATIONALIZATION The following conclusions can be drawn concerning the state of the art of the operationalization of the use of NOAA AVHRR data in the marine field in The Netherlands: An operational AVHRR data-production and -distribution system for the monitoring of the marine environment was established at KNMI in January 1990. A VHRR-imagery has shown high operational potential for mainly three types of applications