STUDIES
IN I N T E R F A C E
SCIENCE
Particles at Fluid Interfaces and Membranes Attachment of Colloid Particles and Proteins to Interfaces and Formation of Two-Dimensional Arrays
STUDIES
IN I N T E R F A C E
SERIES D. M 6 b i u s
Vol. I Dynamics of Adsorption at Liquid Interfaces
Theory, Experiment, Application by S.S. Dukhin, G. Kretzschmar and R. Miller Vol. ~. An Introduction to Dynamics of Colloids by J.K.G. Dhont
Vol. 3 Interfacial Tensiometry by A.I. Rusanov and V.A. Prokhorov Vol. 4 New Developments in Construction and Functions of Organic Thin Films edited by T. Kajiyama and M. Aizawa
Vol. 5 Foam and Foam Films by D. Exerowa and P.M. Kruglyakov Vol. 6 Drops and Bubbles in Interfacial Research edited by D. M6bius and R. Miller Vol. 7 Proteins at Liquid Interfaces edited by D. M6bius and R. Miller
SCIENCE
EDITORS and R. M i l l e r
Vol. 8 Dynamic Surface Tensiometry in Medicine by V.N. Kazakov, O.V. Sinyachenko, V.B. Fainerman, U. Pison and R. Miller Vol. 9 Hydrophile-Lipophile Balance of Surfactants and Solid Particles
Physicochemical Aspects and Applications by P.M. Kruglyakov Vol. io Particles at Fluid Interfaces and Membranes
Attachment of Colloid Particles and Proteins to Inteocaces and Formation of Two-Dimensional Arrays by P.A. Kralchevsky and K. Nagayama
Particles at Fluids Interfaces and Membranes Attachment of Colloid Particles and Proteins to Interfaces and Formation of Two-Dimensional Arrays
PETER A. KRALCHEVSKY
Laboratory of Chemical Physics and Engineering Faculty of Chemistry, University of Sofia, Sofia, Bulgaria KU N IAKI N A G A Y A M A
Laboratory of Ultrastructure Research National Institute for Physiological Sciences, Okazaki, Japan
200I
ELSEVIER Amsterdam - London-
N e w Y o r k - O x f o r d - Paris - S h a n n o n -
Tokyo
ELSEVIER
SCIENCE
B.V.
S a r a B u r g e r h a r t s t r a a t 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
9 2001 Elsevier Science B.V.
All rights reserved.
This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Science, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising o1 promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available tbr educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier Science Global Rights Department, PO Box 800, Oxtbrd OX5 I DX, UK; phone: ~+44) 1865 843830, fax: (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. You may also contact Global Rights directly through Elsevier's home page (http://www.elsevier.nl), by selecting 'Obtaining Permissions'. In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (978) 7508400, fax: (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London WIP 0LP, UK: phone: (+44) 207 631 5555; fax: (+44) 207 631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of Elsevier Science is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier Global Rights Department, at the mail, fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made.
First edition 2001 L i b r a r y o f C o n g r e s s C a t a l o g i n g in P u b l i c a t i o n D a t a A c a t a l o g r e c o r d f r o m t h e L i b r a r y o f C o n g r e s s h a s b e e n a p p l i e d for.
ISBN: 0 444 50234 3 O
The
paper
(Permanence
used
in
of Paper).
P r i n t e d in T h e N e t h e r l a n d s .
this
publication
meets
the
requirements
of
ANSI/NISO
Z39.48-1992
PREFACE
In the small world of micrometer to nanometer scale many natural and industrial processes include attachment of colloid particles (solid spheres, liquid droplets, gas bubbles or protein macromolecules) to fluid interfaces and their confinement in liquid films. This may lead to the appearance of lateral interactions between particles at interfaces, or between inclusions in phospholipid membranes, followed eventually by the formation of two-dimensional ordered arrays. The present book is devoted to the description of such processes, their consecutive stages, and to the investigation of the underlying physico-chemical mechanisms. For each specific theme the physical background is first given, that is the available experimental facts and their interpretation in terms of relatively simple theoretical models are presented. Further, the interested reader may find a more detailed theoretical description and review of the related literature. The first six chapters give a concise but informative introduction to the basic knowledge in surface and colloid science, which includes both traditional concepts and some recent results. Chapters 1 and 2 are devoted to the basic theory of capillarity, kinetics of surfactant adsorption, shapes of axisymmetric fluid interfaces, contact angles and line tension. Chapters 3 and 4 present a generalization of the theory of capillarity to the case, in which the variation of the interfacial (membrane) curvature contributes to the total energy of the system. Phenomenological and molecular approaches to the description of the interfacial bending moment, the curvature elastic moduli and the spontaneous curvature are presented. The generalized Laplace equation, which accounts for the latter effects, is derived and applied to determine the configurations of free and adherent biological cells; a convenient computational procedure is proposed. Chapters 5 and 6 are focused on the role of thin liquid films and hydrodynamic factors in the attachment of solid and fluid particles to an interface. The particles stick or rebound depending on whether repulsive or attractive surface forces prevail in the liquid film. Surface forces of various physical nature are presented and their relative importance is discussed. In addition, we consider the hydrodynamic interactions of a colloidal particle with an interface (or another particle), which are due to flows in the surrounding viscous liquid. Factors and mechanisms for detachment of oil drops from a solid surface are discussed in relation to washing. Chapters 7 to 10 are devoted to the theoretical foundation of various kinds of capillary forces. When two particles are attached to the same interface (membrane), capillary interactions, mediated by the interface or membrane, may appear between them. Two major kinds of capillary interactions are described: (i) capillary immersion force related to the surface wettability and the particle confinement into a liquid film (Chapter 7), (ii) capillary flotation force originating from interfacial deformations due to particle weight (Chapter 8). Special attention is paid to the theory of capillary immersion forces between particles entrapped in spherical liquid films (Chapter 9). A generalization of the theory of immersion forces allows
vi one to describe membrane-mediated interactions between protein inclusions into a lipid bilayer (Chapter 10). Chapter l l is devoted to the theory of the capillary bridges and the capillary-bridge forces, whose importance has been recognized in phenomena like consolidation of granules and soils, wetting of powders, capillary condensation, long-range hydrophobic attraction, bridging in the atomic-force-microscope measurements, etc. The treatment is similar for liquid-in-gas and gasin-liquid bridges. The nucleation of capillary bridges, which occurs when the distance between two surfaces is smaller than a certain limiting value, is also considered. Chapter 12 considers solid particles, which have an irregular wetting perimeter upon attachment to a fluid interface. The undulated contact line induces interfacial deformations, which are theoretically found to engender a special lateral capillary force between the particles. Expressions for the dilatational and shear elastic moduli of such particulate adsorption monolayers are derived. Chapter 13 describes how lateral capillary forces, facilitated by convective flows and some specific and non-specific interactions, can lead to the aggregation and ordering of various particles at fluid interfaces or in thin liquid films. Recent results on fabricating twodimensional (2D) arrays from micrometer and sub-micrometer latex particles, as well as 2D crystals from proteins and protein complexes are reviewed. Special attention is paid to the methods for producing ordered 2D arrays in relation to their physical mechanisms and driving forces. A review and discussion is given about the various applications of particulate 2D arrays in optics, optoelectronics, nano-lithography, microcontact printing, catalytic films and solar cells, as well as the use of protein 2D crystals for immunosensors and isoporous ultrafiltration membranes, etc. Chapter 14 presents applied aspects of the particle-surface interaction in antifoaming and deJoaming. Three different mechanisms of antifoaming action are described: spreading mechanism, bridging-dewetting and bridging-stretching mechanism. All of them involve as a necessary step the entering of an antifoam particle at the air-water interface, which is equivalent to rupture of the asymmetric particle-water-air film. Consequently, the stability of the latter liquid film is a key factor for control of ~baminess.
The audience of the book is determined by the circle of readers who are interested in systems, processes and phenomena related to attachment, interactions and ordering of particles at interfaces and lipid membranes. Examples for such systems, processes and phenomena are: formation of 2D ordered arrays of particulates and proteins with various applications: from optics and microelectronics to molecular biology and cell morphology; antifoaming and defoaming action of solid particles and/or oil drops in house-hold and personal-care detergency, as well as in separation processes; stabilization of emulsions by solid particles with application in food and petroleum industries; interactions between particulates in paint films; micro-manipulation of biological cells in liquid films, etc. Consequently, the book could be a useful reading for university and industrial scientists, lecturers, graduate and post-graduate students in chemical physics, surface and colloid science, biophysics, protein engineering and cell biology.
vii
Prehistory. An essential portion of this book, Chapters 7-10 and 13, summarizes results and research developments stemming from the Nagayama Protein Array Project (October 1990 - September 1995), which was a part of the program "Exploratory Research for Advanced Technology" (ERATO) of the Japanese Research and Development Corporation (presently Japan Science and Technology Corporation). The major goal of this project was formulated as follows: Based on the molecular assembly of proteins, to fabricate macroscopic structures (2D protein arrays), which could be useful in human practice. The Laboratory of Thermodynamics and Physicochemical Hydrodynamics (presently lab. of Chemical Physics and Engineering) from the University of Sofia, Bulgaria, was involved in this project with the task to investigate the mechanism of 2D structuring in comparative experiments with colloid particles and protein macromolecules. These joint studies revealed the role of the capillary immersion forces and convective fluxes of evaporating solvent in the 2D ordering. In the course of this project it became clear that the knowledge of surface and colloid science was a useful background for the studies on 2D crystallization of proteins. For that reason, in 1992 one of the authors of this book (K. Nagayama) invited the other author (P. Kralchevsky) to come to Tsukuba and to deliver a course of lectures for the project team-members entitled: "Interfacial Phenomena and Dispersions: toward Understanding of Protein and Colloid Arrays". In fact, this course gave a preliminary selection and systematization of the material included in the introductory chapters of this book (Chapters 1 to 6). Later, after the end of the project, the authors came to the idea to prepare a book, which is to summarize and present the accumulated results, together with the underlying physicochemical background. In the course of work, the scope of the book was broadened to a wider audience, and the material was updated with more recent results. The major part of the book was written during an 8-month stay of P. Kralchevsky in the laboratory of K. Nagayama in the National Institute for Physiological Sciences in Okazaki, Japan (September 1998 - April 1999). The present book resulted from a further upgrade, polishing and updating of the text. Acknowledgments. The authors are indebted to the Editor of this series, Dr. Habil. Reinhard Miller, and to Prof. Ivan B. Ivanov for their moral support and encouragement of the work on the book, as well as to Profs. Krassimir Danov and Nikolai Denkov for their expert reading and discussion of Chapters 1 and 14, respectively. We are also much indebted to our associates, Dr. Radostin Danev and Ms. Mariana Paraskova, for their invaluable help in preparing the numerous figures. Last but not least, we would like to acknowledge the important scientific contributions of our colleagues, team-members of the Nagayama Protein Array project, whose co-authored studies have served as a basis for a considerable part of this book. Their names are as follows. From Japan: Drs. Hideyuki Yoshimura, Shigeru Endo, Junichi Higo, Tetsuya Miwa, Eiki Adachi and Mariko Yamaki; From Bulgaria: Drs. Nikolai Denkov, Orlin Velev, Ceco Dushkin, Anthony Dimitrov, Theodor Gurkov and Vesselin Paunov. October 2000
Peter A. Kralchevsky and Kuniaki Nagayama
viii
Photograph of the process of 2D array formation from latex particles, 1.7 gm in diameter, under the action of the capillary immersion force and an evaporation-driven convective flux of water (see Chapter 13); the tracks of particles moving toward the ordered phase are seen [from N.D. Denkov, O.D. Velev, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, H. Yoshimura, K. Nagayama, Langmuir 8 (1992) 3183].
ix
CONTENTS
Preface CHAPTER 1. PLANAR FLUID INTERFACES
1
1.1. 1.1.1. 1.1.2. 1.1.3. 1.1.4.
Mechanical properties of fluid interfaces The Bakker equation for surface tension Interfacial bending moment and surface of tension Electrically charged interfaces Work of interfacial dilatation
2 2 6 8 11
1.2. 1.2.1. 1.2.2. 1.2.3. 1.2.4. 1.2.5.
Thermodynamical properties of planar fluid interfaces The Gibbs adsorption equation Equimolecular dividing surface Thermodynamics of adsorption of nonionic surfactants Theory of the electric double layer Thermodynamics of adsorption of ionic surfactants
12 12 14 15 20 25
1.3. 1.3.1. 1.3.2. 1.3.3. 1.3.4. 1.3.5. 1.4. 1.5.
Kinetics of surfactant adsorption Adsorption under diffusion control Adsorption under electro-diffusion control Adsorption under barrier control Adsorption from micellar surfactant solutions Adsorption from solutions of proteins Summary References
37 38 41 48 53 55 56 58
CHAPTER 2. INTERFACES OF MODERATE CURVATURE: THEORY OF CAPILLARITY
64
2.1. The Laplace equation of capillarity 2.1.1. Laplace equation for spherical interface 2.1.2. General form of Laplace equation
65 65 66
2.2. 2.2.1. 2.2.2. 2.2.3.
Axisymmetric fluid interfaces Meniscus meeting the axis of revolution Meniscus leveling off at infinity Meniscus confined between two cylinders
71 72 75 77
2.3. 2.3.1. 2.3.2. 2.3.3. 2.3.4. 2.4. 2.5.
Force balance at a three-phase-contact line Equation of Young Triangle of Neumann The effect of line tension Hysteresis of contact angle and line tension Summary References
8O 8O 85 87 92 98 99
CHAPTER 3. SURFACE BENDING MOMENT AND CURVATURE ELASTIC MODULI
105
3.1. 3.1.1. 3.1.2. 3.1.3.
Basic thermodynamic equations for curved interfaces Introduction Mechanical work of interracial deformation Fundamental thermodynamic equation of a curved interface
106 106 106 109
3.2.
Thermodynamics of spherical interfaces
112
3.2.1. Dependence of the bending moment on the choice of dividing surface 3.2.2. Equimolecular dividing surface and Tolman length 3.2.3. Micromechanical approach
3.3. 3.3.1. 3.3.2. 3.4. 3.5.
Relations with the molecular theory and the experiment Contributions due to various kinds of interactions Bending moment effects on the interaction between drops in emulsions Summary References
112 115 117
123 123 129 132 133
CHAPTER 4. GENERAL CURVED INTERFACES AND BIOMEMBRANES
137
4.1. 4.2. 4.2.1. 4.2.2. 4.2.3. 4.2.4.
Theoretical approaches for description of curved interfaces Mechanical approach to arbitrarily curved interfaces Analogy with mechanics of three-dimensional continua Basic equations from geometry and kinematics of a curved interface Tensors of the surface stresses and moments Surface balances of the linear and angular momentum
138 140 140 142 145 147
4.3. 4.3.1. 4.3.2. 4.3.3. 4.3.4.
Connection between the mechanical and thermodynamical approaches Generalized Laplace equation derived by minimization of the free energy Work of deformation: thermodynamical and mechanical expressions Versions of the generalized Laplace equation Interfacial rheological constitutive relations
151 151 154 157 158
4.4. Axisymmetric shapes of biological cells 4.4.1. The generalized Laplace equation in parametric form 4.4.2. Boundary conditions and shape computation
162 162 164
4.5. 4.5.1. 4.5.2. 4.6. 4.7.
168 168 174 178 179
Micromechanical expressions for the surface properties Surface tensions, moments and curvature elastic moduli Tensors of the surface stresses and moments Summary References
CHAPTER 5. LIQUID FILMS AND INTERACTIONS BETWEEN PARTICLE AND SURFACE
183
5.1. 5.1.1. 5.1.2. 5.1.3. 5.1.4.
184 184 186 191 197
Mechanical balances and thermodynamic relationships Introduction Disjoining pressure and transversal tension Thermodynamics of thin liquid films Derjaguin approximation for films of uneven thickness
5.2. Interactions in thin liquid films 5.2.1. Overview of the types of surface forces 5.2.2. Van der Waals surface forces 5.2.3. Long-range hydrophobic surface force 5.2.4. Electrostatic surface force 5.~2.5. Repulsive hydration force 5.2.6. Ion-correlation surface force 5.2.7. Oscillatory structural and depletion forces 5.2.8. Steric interaction due to adsorbed molecular chains 5.2.9. Undulation and protrusion forces 5.2.10. Forces due to deformation of liquid drops
201 201 203 211 212 216 220 224 231 235 237
xi
5.3. 5.4.
Summary References
240 241
CHAPTER 6. PARTICLES AT INTERFACES: DEFORMATIONS AND HYDRODYNAMIC INTERACTIONS
248
6.1. Deformation of fluid particles approaching an interface 6.1.1. Thermodynamic aspects of particle deformation 6.1.2. Dependence of the film area on the size of the drop/bubble
249 249 254
6.2. 6.2.1. 6.2.2. 6.2.3. 6.2.4. 6.2.5. 6.2.6. 6.2.7.
Hydrodynamic interactions Taylor regime of particle approach Inversion thickness for fluid particles Reynolds regime of particle approach Transition from Taylor to Reynolds regime Fluid particles of completely mobile surfaces (no surfactant) Fluid particles with partially mobile surfaces (surfactant in continuous phase) Critical thickness of a liquid film
258 259 260 261 261 263 264 265
6.3. 6.3.1. 6.3.2. 6.3.3. 6.4. 3.5.
Detachment of oil drops from a solid surface Detachment of drops exposed to shear flow Detachment of oil drops protruding from pores Physicochemical factors influencing the detachment of oil drops Summary References
268 268 276 280 282 284
CHAPTER 7. LATERAL CAPILLARY FORCES BETWEEN PARTIALLY IMMERSED BODIES 287
7.1. 7.1.1. 7.1.2. 7.1.3. 7.1.4. 7.1.5.
Physical origin of the lateral capillary forces Types of capillary forces and related studies Linearized Laplace equation for slightly deformed liquid interfaces and films Immersion force: theoretical expression in superposition approximation Measurement of lateral immersion forces Energy and force approaches to the lateral capillary interactions
288 288 294 296 299 303
7.2. 7.2.1. 7.2.2. 7.2.3.
Shape of the capillary meniscus around two axisymmetric bodies Solution of the linearized Laplace equation in bipolar coordinates Mean capillary elevation of the particle contact line Expressions for the shape of the contact line
3O8 308 312 314
7.3. 7.3.1. 7.3.2. 7.3.3. 7.3.4.
Energy approach to the lateral capillary interactions Capillary immersion force between two vertical cylinders Capillary immersion force between two spherical particles Capillary immersion force between spherical particle and vertical cylinder Capillary interactions at fixed elevation of the contact line
316 316 321 327 328
7.4. 7.4.1. 7.4.2. 7.4.3. 7.5. 7.6.
Force approach to the lateral capillary interactions Capillary immersion force between two cylinders or two spheres Asymptotic expression for the capillary force between two particles Capillary immersion force between spherical particle and wall Summary References
334 334 341 343 345 347
xii CHAPTER 8. LATERAL CAPILLARY FORCES BETWEEN FLOATING PARTICLES
351
8.1. 8.1.1. 8.1.2. 8.1.3. 8.1.4. 8.1.5.
Interaction between two floating particles Flotation force: theoretical expression in superposition approximation "Capillary charge" of floating particles Comparison between the lateral flotation and immersion forces More accurate calculation of the capillary interaction energy Numerical results and discussion
352 352 354 356 358 361
8.2. 8.2.1. 8.2.2. 8.2.3. 8.2.4. 8.2.5. 8.2.6. 8.2.7. 8.3. 8.4.
Particle-wall interaction: capillary image forces Attractive and repulsive capillary image forces The case of inclined meniscus at the wall Elevation of the contact line on the surface of the floating particle Energy of capillary interaction Application of the force approach to quantify the particle-wall interaction Numerical predictions of the theory and discussion Experimental measurements with floating particles Summary References
367 367 369 374 376 379 382 386 392 394
CHAPTER 9. CAPILLARY FORCES BETWEEN PARTICLES BOUND TO A SPHERICAL INTERFACE
396
9.2. 9.2.1. 9.2.2. 9.2.3. 9.2.4.
Origin of the "capillary charge" in the case of spherical interface Interfacial shape around inclusions in a spherical film Linearization of Laplace equation for small deviations from spherical shape "Capillary charge" and reference pressure Introduction of spherical bipolar coordinates Procedure of calculations and numerical results
397 401 401 404 406 409
9.3. 9.3.1. 9.3.2. 9.3.3. 9.3.4. 9.4. 9.5.
Calculation of the lateral capillary force Boundary condition of fixed contact line Boundary condition of fixed contact angle Calculation procedure for capillary force between spherical particles Numerical results for the force and energy of capillary interaction Summary References
412 413 414 417 420 422 424
9.1.
CHAPTER 10. MECHANICS OF LIPID MEMBRANES AND INTERACTION BETWEEN INCLUSIONS
426
10.1. 10.2. 10.2.1. 10.2.2. 10.2.3.
Deformations in a lipid membrane due to the presence of inclusions "Sandwich" model of a lipid bilayer Definition of the model; stress balances in a lipid bilayer at equilibrium Stretching mode of deformation and stretching elastic modulus Bending mode of deformation and curvature elastic moduli
427 430 430 435 438
10.3. 10.3.1. 10.3.2. 10.3.3. 10.3.4. 10.3.5.
Description of membrane deformations caused by inclusions Squeezing (peristaltic) mode of deformation: rheological model Deformations in the hydrocarbon-chain region Deformation of the bilayer surfaces The generalized Laplace equation for the bilayer surfaces Solution of the equations describing the deformation
444 444 446 447 450 452
xiii
10.4. Lateral interaction between two identical inclusions 10.4.1. Direct calculation of the force 10.4.2. The energy approach
454 454 457
10.5. 10.6. 10.7.
460 463 465
Numerical results for membrane proteins Summary References
CHAPTER 11. CAPILLARY BRIDGES AND CAPILLARY BRIDGE FORCES
469
11.1. 11.2. ll.2.1. 11.2.2.
Role of the capillary bridges in various processes and phenomena Definition and magnitude of the capillary bridge force Definition Capillary bridge in toroid (circle) approximation
470 472 472 474
11.3. 11.3.1. 11.3.2. 11.3.3. 11.3.4.
Geometrical and physical properties of capillary bridges Types of capillary bridges and expressions for their shape Relations between the geometrical parameters Symmetric nodoid-shaped bridge with neck Geometrical and physical limits for the length of a capillary bridge
477 477 480 483 486
11.4. 11.4.1. 11.4.2. 11.5. 11.6.
Nucleation of capillary bridges Thermodynamic basis Critical nucleus and equilibrium bridge Summary References
492 492 496 498 499
CHAPTER 12. CAPILLARY FORCES BETWEEN PARTICLES OF IRREGULAR CONTACT LINE
503
12.1. Surface corrugations and interaction between two particles 12.1.1. Interfacial deformation due to irregular contact line 12.1.2. Energy and force of capillary interaction
505 505 508
12.2. 12.2.1. 12.2.2. 12.3. 12.4.
512 513 514 515 516
Elastic properties of particulate adsorption monolayers Surface dilatational elasticity Surface shear elasticity Summary References
CHAPTER 13. TWO-DIMENSIONAL CRYSTALLIZATION OF PARTICULATES AND PROTEINS
517
13.1. 13.1.1. 13.1.2. 13.1.3. 13.1.4. 13.1.5.
518 518 522 524 527 529
Methods for obtaining 2D arrays from microscopic particles Formation of particle 2D arrays in evaporating liquid films Particle ordering due to a Kirkwood-Alder type phase transition Self-assembly of particles floating on a liquid interface Formation of particle 2D arrays in electric, magnetic and optical fields 2D arrays obtained by adsorption and/or Langmuir-Blodgett method
13.2. 2D crystallization of proteins on the surface of mercury 13.2.1. The mercury trough method 13.2.2. Experimental procedure and results
530 530 532
xiv 13.3. Dynamics of 2D crystallization in evaporating liquid films 13.3.1. Mechanism of two-dimensional crystallization 13.3.2. Kinetics of two-dimensional crystallization in convective regime
535 535 542
13.4. Liquid substrates for 2D array formation 13.4.1. Fluorinated oil as a substrate for two-dimensional crystallization 13.4.2. Mercury as a substrate for two-dimensional crystallization
55O 550 554
13.5.
Size separation of colloidal particles during 2D crystallization
556
13.6. Methods for obtaining large 2D-crystalline coatings 13.6.1. Withdrawal of a plate from suspension 13.6.2. Deposition of ordered coatings with a "brush"
561 561 564
13.7. 2D crystallization of particles in free foam films 13.7.1. Arrays from micrometer-sized particles in foam films 13.7.2. Arrays from sub-micrometer particles studied by electron cryomicroscopy
566 566 568
13.8. 13.8.1. 13.8.2. 13.8.3. 13.9. 13.10.
Application of 2D arrays from colloid particles and proteins Application of colloid 2D arrays in optics and optoelectronics Nano-lithography, microcontact printing, nanostructured surfaces Protein 2D arrays in applications
Summary References
CHAPTER 14. EFFECT OF OIL DROPS AND PARTICULATES ON THE STABILITY OF FOAMS 14.1. 14.1.1. 14.1.2. 14.1.3.
Foam-breaking action of microscopic particles
14.2. 14.2.1. 14.2.2. 14.2.3. 14.2.4. 14.2.5.
Mechanisms of foam-breaking action of oil drops and particles
14.3. 14.3.1. 14.3.2. 14.3.3. 14.4. 14.5.
Control of foam stability; Antifoaming vs. defoaming Studies with separate foam films Hydrodynamics of drainage of foam films Scheme of the consecutive stages Entering, spreading and bridging coefficients Spreading mechanism Bridging-dewetting mechanism Bridging-stretching mechanism
Stability of asymmetric films: the key for control of foaminess Thermodynamic and kinetic stabilizing factors Mechanisms of film rupture Overcoming the barrier to drop entry
Summary and conclusions References
572 572 573 577 58O 582
591 592 592 594 600 602 602 606 611 613 615 617 617 620 623 626 628
Appendix 1A: Equivalence of the two forms of the Gibbs adsorption equation Appendix 8A: Derivation of equation (8.31) Appendix 10A: Connections between two models of lipid membranes
633
Index Notation
641 651
635 636
CHAPTER 1 PLANAR FLUID INTERFACES
An interface or membrane is one of the main "actors" in the process of particle-interface and particle-particle interaction at a fluid phase boundary. The latter process is influenced by mechanical properties, such as the interfacial (membrane) tension and the surface (Gibbs) elasticity. For interfaces and membranes of low tension and high curvature the interracial bending moment and the curvature elastic moduli can also become important. As a rule, there are surfactant adsorption layers at fluid interfaces and very frequently the interfaces bear some electric charge. For these reasons in the present chapter we pay a special attention to surfactant adsorption and to electrically charged interfaces. Our
purpose
is to
introduce
the
basic
quantities
and
relationships
in
mechanics,
thermodynamics and kinetics of fluid interfaces and surfactant adsorption, which will be further currently used throughout the book. Definitions of surface tension, interfacial bending moment, adsorptions of the species, surface of tension and equimolecular dividing surface, surface elasticity and adsorption relaxation time are given. The most important equations relating these quantities are derived, their physical meaning is interpreted, and appropriate references are provided. In addition to known facts and concepts, the chapter presents also some recent results on thermodynamics and kinetics of adsorption of ionic surfactants. Four tables summarize theoretical expressions, which are related to various adsorption isotherms and types of electrolyte in the solution. We hope this introductory chapter will be useful for both researchers and students, who approach for a first time the field of interracial science, as well as for experts and lecturers who could find here a somewhat different viewpoint and new information about the factors and processes in this field and their interconnection.
2
Chapter 1
1.1.
MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF PLANAR FLUID INTERFACES
1.1.1.
THE BAKKER EQUATION FOR SURFACE TENSION
The balance of the linear momentum in fluid dynamics relates the local acceleration in the fluid to the divergence of the pressure tensor, P, see e.g. Ref. [1 ]: dv
,o~=-V.P dt
(1.1)
Here ,o is the mass density of the fluid, v is velocity and t is time; in fact the pressure tensor P equals the stress tensor T with the opposite sign: P = - T . In a fluid at rest v - 0 and Eq. (1.1) reduces to V.P=O
(1.2)
which expresses a necessary condition for hydrostatic equilibrium. In the bulk of a liquid the pressure tensor is isotropic, P=PsU
(1.3)
as stated by the known Pascal law (U is the spatial unit tensor; P~ is a scalar pressure). Indeed, all directions in the bulk of a uniform liquid phase are equivalent. The latter is not valid in a vicinity of the surface of the fluid phase, where the normal to the interface determines a special direction. In other words, in a vicinity of the interface the force acting across unit area is not the same in all directions. Correspondingly, in this region the pressure tensor can be expressed in the form [2,3]: P = Pr (exex +eyey)+PNeze: Here ex, ey and e~ are the unit vectors along the Cartesian coordinate
(1.4) axes, with ez being
oriented normally to the interface; PN and Pr are, respectively, the normal and the tangential components of the pressure tensor. Due to the symmetry of the system PN and Pr can depend on z, but they should be independent of x and v. Thus a substitution of Eq. (1.4) into Eq. (1.3) yields one non-trivial equation:
9PN = 0 9z
(1.5)
Planar Fluid hTterfaces
3
In other words, the condition for hydrostatic equilibrium, Eq. (1.3), implies that PN must be constant along the normal to the interface; therefore, PN is to be equal to the bulk isotropic pressure, PN = P8 = const. Let us take a vertical strip of unit width, which is oriented normally to the interface, see Fig. 1.1. The ends of the stripe, at z = a and z = b, are supposed to be located in the bulk of phases 1 and 2, respectively. The real force exerted to the strip is b FT(real) - I e r (z)dz
(1.6)
a
On the other hand, following Gibbs [4] one can construct an idealized
system consisting of
two uniform phases, which preserve their bulk properties up to a mathematical dividing surface modeling the transition zone between the two phases (Fig. 1.1). The pressure everywhere in the idealized system is equal to the bulk isotropic pressure, P8 =PN. In addition, a surface tension cy
[Real System,]
z=b PT...PN
Phase 2
[Idealized System[
ez~l~ey
Phase 2
0".~
transition zone
Z=Z 0
\ [,,~ividing
surface!
PT. PN Phase 1
Phase 1 z=a
Fig. 1.1. Sketch of a vertical strip, which is normal to the boundary between phases 1 and 2.
4
Chapter I
is ascribed to the dividing surface in the idealized system. Thus the force exerted to the strip in the idealized system (Fig. 1.1) is b
F T idealized)
=
f
PN de - Cr
(1.7)
a
The role of cy is to make up for the differences between the real and the idealized system. Setting
-r/7(idealized)-----7"v(re~ from Eqs. (1.6) and (1.7) one obtains the Bakker [5] equation for the
surface tension" +oo
r - I (PN -
Pr )&
(1.8)
--oo
Since the boundaries of integration z = a and z = b are located in the bulk of phases 1 and 2, where the pressure is isotropic ( P T - PN), we have set the boundaries in Eq. (1.8) equal to +oo. Equation (1.8) means that the real system with a planar interface can be considered as if it were composed of two homogeneous phases separated by a planar membrane of zero thickness with
26 24 22 20
~
0
18 e..)
;a~ "r
14
M
10
%
Liquid, phase I
Gas, phase II
8 4 2 0
.......
- -.
-2 -18
-16
-14
-12
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
z-zv , Angstroms Fig. 1.2. Anisotropy of the pressure tensor, AP, plotted vs. the distance to the equimoleqular dividing surface, .:-Z.v, for interface liquid argon-gas at 84.3 K; Curves 1 and 2 are calculated by the theories in Refs. [8] and [10].
Planar Fluid Interfaces
5
tension 6 given by Eq. (1.8). The latter equation gives a hydrostatic definition of surface tension. Note that this definition does not depend on the exact location of the dividing surface. The quantity AP - PN -
Pr
(1.9)
expresses the anisotropy of the pressure tensor. The function AaD(z) can be obtained theoretically by means of the methods of the statistical mechanics [6-9]. As an illustration in Figure 1.2 we present data for AP vs. Z-Zv for the interface liquid argon-gas at temperature T = 84.3 K; Zv is the position of the so called "equimolecular" dividing surface (see Section 1.2.2 below for definition). The empty and full points in Fig. 1.2 are calculated
by means of the
theories from Refs. [8] and [10], respectively. As seen in Fig. 1.2, the width of the transition
450 .................. ~. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , ...... 400 ............................................................................. (1) ........................................................ i...........................
300 ~ .~
....i ! i
~00 i.....i-............i............i........... ........................i.....
~' ....i....................................................
0I ~ 150 100 i.....i...........i.............i............i............!............ j i , ../ , 1. , ! ? " "~
~o
~
~ .....................
~...........
i::
i k . "........ . . .{............. . . . }............{...........i...........i I
..............i........................
~.~-~o .ii i i i i i
v
iiii
-100
150 2OO -250
-14 -12 -10
-8
-6 z-z
-4 v
,
-2 0 2 Angstroms
4
6
8
10
1
--.o-(1) .......
(2)
.....
(3)
Fig. 1.3. Anisotropy of the pressure tensor, zXP, plotted vs. the distance to the equimoleqular dividing surface, =-Zv, calculated by the theory in Ref. [10] for the phase boundaries n-decane-gas (curve 1), gas-water (curve 2) and n-decane-water (curve 3).
6
Chapter 1
zone between the liquid and gas phases (in which AP :/: 0) is of the order of 10 A. On the other hand, the maximum value of the anisotropy AP(z) is about 2 x 108 dyn/cm, i.e. about 200 atmospheres, which is an impressive value. The area below the full line in Fig. 1.2 gives the surface tension of argon at that temperature, a = 13.45 mN/m, in accordance with Eq. (1.8). Curves 1, 2 and 3 in Fig. 1.3 present AP(z) calculated in Ref. [10] for the interfaces ndecane/gas, gas/water and n-decane/water, respectively. One see that kP(z) typically exhibits a single maximum for a liquid-gas
interface, whereas AP(z) exhibits a loop (maximum and
minimum) for a liquid-liquid interface. For all curves in Fig. 1.3 the width of the interfacial transition zone is of the order of 10 A.
1.1.2
INTERFACIALBENDING MOMENTAND SURFACE OF TENSION
To make the idealized system in Fig. 1.1 hydrostatically equivalent to the real system we have to impose also a requirement for equivalence with respect to the acting force moments (in addition to the analogous requirement for the acting forces, see above). The moment exerted on the strip in the real system (Fig. 1.1) is
M
(real)
b j PT (Z) zdz
(1. lO)
O
Likewise, the moment exerted on the stripe in the idealized system is [11]: b
M(idea~zed)-- f Pu zdz - OZo + 7l B 0
(1 11)
a
Here z = z0 is the position of the dividing surface and B0 is an interfacial bending moment (couple of forces), which is to be attributed to the dividing surface in order to make the idealized system equivalent to the real one with respect to the force moments. Setting M~ide'li~ed~=M t'~''l' fiom Eqs. (1.8), (1.10) and (1.11) one obtains an expression for the
interfacial bending moment:
P la n a r Flu id In te ifa ce s
7
~c,o
Bo
- 2 ~ (PN - iT ) (~.o - z)dz
(1.12)
-co
As in Eq. (1.8) we have extended the boundaries of integration to +~,. From the viewpoint of mechanics p o s i t i v e Bo represents a force moment (a couple of forces), which tends to bend the dividing surface around the phase, for which ex is an outer normal (in Fig. 1.1 this is phase 1). The comparison of eqs (1.8) and (1.12) shows that unlike o, the interfacial bending moment Bo depends on the choice of position of the dividing surface z0. The latter can be defined by imposing some additional physical condition; in such a way the "equimolecular" dividing surface is defined (see Section 1.2.2 below). If once the position of the dividing surface is determined, then the interfacial bending moment B0 becomes a physically well defined quantity. For example, the values of the bending moment, corresponding to the equimolecular dividing surface, for curves No. 1, 2 and 3 in Fig. 1.3 are, respectively [10]: B0 = 2.2, 2.3 and 5.2x 10-11N. One possible way to define the position, z0, of the dividing surface is to set the bending moment to be identically zero:
I
Bo zo:z,
=0
(1.13)
Combining eqs (1.8), (1.12) and (1.13) one obtains [2] +co
~.s - - -
-IT
(7
~1.14)
-co
Equation (1.14) defines the so called surface o f tension . It has been first introduced by Gibbs [4], and it is currently used in the conventional theory of capillarity (see Chapter 2 below). At the surface of tension the interface is characterized by a single dynamic parameter, the interfacial tension cy; this considerably simplifies the mathematical treatment of capillary problems. However, the physical situation becomes more complicated when the interfacial tension is low such is the case of some emulsion and microemulsion systems, lipid bilayers and biomembranes. In the latter case, the surface o f tension can be located far from the actual transition region between the two phases and its usage becomes physically meaningless.
8
Chapter I
Indeed, for o--90 Eq. (1.14) yields z, -9oo. Therefore, a mechanical description of an interface of low surface tension needs the usage of (at least) two dynamic quantities: interfacial (surface) tension and bending moment. In fact, B0 is related to the so called spontaneous curvature of the interface. In Chapter 3 we will come to this point again.
]. ].3. ELECTRICALLYCHARGEDINTERFACES As a rule, the boundaries between two phases (and the biomembranes, as well) bear some electric charge. Often it is due to the dissociation of surface ionizable groups or to adsorption of charged amphiphilic molecules (surfactants). It should be noted that even the boundaries water-air and water-oil (oil here means any liquid hydrocarbon immiscible with water) are electrically charged in the absence of any surfactant, see e.g. refs. [12] and [13]. If the surface of an aqueous phase is charged, it repels the coions, i.e. the ions of the same charge, but it attracts the counterions, which are the ions of the opposite charge, see Fig. 1.4. Thus a nonuniform distribution of the ionic species in the vicinity of the charged interface appears, which is known as electric double laver (EDL), see e.g. Ref. [14]. The conventional model of the EDL stems from the works of Gouy [15], Chapman [16] and Stern [ 17]. The EDL is considered to consist of two parts: (I) interfacial (adsorption) layer and (II) diffuse layer. The interfacial (adsorption) layer includes charges, which are immobilized (adsorbed) at the phase boundary; this includes also adsorbed (bound) counterions, which form the so called Stern layer, see Fig. 1.4. The diffuse layer consists of free ions in the aqueous phase, which are involved in Brownian motion in the electrical field created by the charged interface. The boundary, which separates the adsorption from the diffuse layer, is usually called the Gouv plane. The conventional theory of the electric double layer is briefly presented in Section 1.2.4 below. For our purposes here it is sufficient to take into account that the electric potential varies across the EDL: Iff = ~z). The thickness of the diffuse EDL could be of the order of hundred (and even thousand) nm, i.e. it is much greater than the thickness of the interracial transition zone (cf. Figs. 1.2 and 1.3). This fact requires a special approach to the theoretical description of the
9
Planar Fluid Interfaces
charged interfaces, which can be based on the expression for the M a x w e l l electric stress tensor
[181 Non - aqueous ^ , , . i f ' ~ phase ~J" V N.I~-'J,,~
Aqueous phase
!
/D
@
Coions
@
Counterions
@
,/V%
Diffuse layer
4
Surfactant adsorption
| =-
Stern layer
of adsorbed counterions
layer
L c-"
._o ,,.., ell)
Counterions
Coo
c--
S
.o_ r o
Coions
0
r
Z
Fig. 1.4. Sketch of the electric double layer in a vicinity of an adsorption monolayer of ionic surfactant. (a) The diffuse layer contains free ions involved in Brownian motion, while the Stern layer consists of adsorbed (bound) counterions. (b) Near the charged surface there is an accumulation of counterions and a depletion of coions, whose bulk concentrations are both equal to c~. E
~
E
Pk - (P, + - - E - ) ~;k - - - E E k (i, k - 1,2,3) 8n 4n" '
(1.~5)
Here ~;k is the K r o n e c k e r symbol (the unit matrix), 8 is the dielectric permittivity of the m e d i u m ( usually water), E, is the i-th c o m p o n e n t of the electric field,
I0
x = ,,vl1 y = x? and
z
= -1-3 are Cartesian crmrciiriales, ariti P., i s ari isnti-opic pressui-r, u!hich
ciin vary across thc EDL due to the osmotic effect of the dissolved ionic species. Ar; already mentioned. ill the
UBSC
of plaiic iiitcrfacc
WE
havc ly =
W,x;)>and rhcn Eq. (1.15)
reduces to the following two expreasioris: (1.17)
c P,.= P,,t = P,,r= P , t--
( 4 J1‘
(1.18)
-
8a d?
Eqs. (1.17) 2nd ( I . IS) can be applied to dcscribc thc. prc.ssurc tc.tisoi-within h c difl’usc par1 uf the electric double laycr.
Now! let us Ir)cate the plane := 0 in the Chuy plane separating the diffuse (at z > 0 ) froin t.hc ndstrrpliori layer. Then by means o l the H:tkker equation ( I -8) one can r e p r t x n l h e s u r t x e tcnsion 0 as I suiii uf corilributions from the adsorption and diffuse layers:
whci-c
(1.20)
Substiluting Eqs. (I.17) and ( 1 , 18) inlo thc ahovc cquiition fur
00.
m c obt.ains
a gerirral
expression for thc cunrrihutiori of the r l j / r i $ e layer, to the interfacial tcnsion [ 19,201: 11.21)
Planar Fluid Interfaces
11
interfacial tension o'. Explicit expressions for O'd, obtained by means of the double layer theory for various types of electrolytes, can be found in Table 1.3 below.
1.1.4.
WORK OF INTERFACIAL DILATATION
Let us consider an imaginary rectangular box containing portions of phases 1 and 2, and of the interface between them. As before, we will assume that the interface is parallel to the coordinate plane xy, and the sides of the rectangular box are also parallel to the respective coordinate planes. Moving the sides of the box one can create a small change of the volume of the box, tSV, with a corresponding small change of the interfacial area, 6A. The work tSW carried out by the external forces to create this deformation can be calculated by means of a known equation of fluid mechanics [1 ]: 6W - - f ( P " v
t~D)dV
(1.22)
Here 5D is the strain tensor (tensor of deformation) and ":" denotes double scalar product of two tensors (dyadics): (AB) : (CD) = (A- D ) ( B - C )
(1.23)
Since we consider displacements of the sides of our rectangular box along the normals to the respective sides, the strain tensor has diagonal form in the Cartesian basis [21,22]: ~D - exex
~(dx) ~(dy) ~(dz) dx + e y e Y dy + e z e z dz
(1.24)
Here 6(dx) denotes the extension of a linear element dx of the continuous medium in the course of deformation. Equation (1.24) shows that the eigenvalues of the strain tensor are the relative extensions of linear elements along the three axes of the Cartesian coordinate system. Substituting Eqs. (1.4) and (1.24) into Eq. (1.22) one can derive [22]:
-
+ dx
dy
+ ~ dz
dx4vdz+
(PN -- P;
6(dx) dx
6(dy) dy
"
The increments of the elementary volume and area in the process of deformation are
12
Chapter 1
6 ( d V ) = dydz 6(dx) + dxdz 6 ( @ ) + dxdy 6(dz),
6(dA) = dy 6(dx) + dx 6(dy)
(1.26)
Combining Eqs. (1.8), (1.25) and (1.26) one finally obtains (1.27)
a W = -PN 0~" + CY6A
Here --PNO~7 expresses the work of changing the volume and c~6A is the work o f interfacial dilatation. Equation (1.27) gives a connection between the mechanics and thermodynamics of
the fluid interfaces.
1.2.
T H E R M O D Y N A M I C A L P R O P E R T I E S OF PLANAR FLUID I N T E R F A C E S
1.2.1.
THE GraBS ADSORPTION EQUATION
Let us consider the same system as in section 1.1.4 above. The Gibbs fundamental equation, combining the first and the second law of thermodynamics, is [2,4] d U - T d S - PNdV +erdA + ~_~lttidN~ ,
(1.28)
i
where T is the temperature; U and S are the internal energy and entropy of the system, respectively; J./i and Ni are the chemical potential and the number of molecules of the i-th component (species); the summation in Eq. (1.28) is carried out over all components in the system. Equation (1.28) states that the internal energy of the system can vary because of the transfer of heat (TdS) and/or matter ( ~ j2idN i ), and/or due to the mechanical work, 6W, carried i
out by external forces, see Eq. (1.27). Following Gibbs [4], we construct an idealized system consisting of two bulk phases, which are uniform up to a mathematical dividing surface modeling the boundary between the two phases. Since the dividing surface has a zero thickness, the volumes of the two phases in the idealized system are additive: V = V~+
V ~2~
(1.29)
Planar Fluid Interfaces
13
We assume that the bulk densities of entropy, s (k), internal energy, u (k), and number of )
molecules, n~k , are known for the two neighboring phases (k = 1,2). Then the entropy, internal energy and number of molecules for phase "k" of the idealized system are: S (k)= s(k)V (k~"
U (k)= u(k)V (k)"
N5 k)= n~k)V (k)
( k - 1,2)
(1.30)
Each of the two uniform bulk phases has its own fundamental equation [2,4]" a u " ' - T a s '~' - P . a v " ' + ~ l a , aN) ~' i
(1.31)
dU(2' - rdS'2) - V~ dV'2' + Z It, dN~ 2) i
It is presumed that we deal with a state of thermodynamic equilibrium, and hence the temperature T and the chemical potentials Pi are uniform throughout the system [23]" in addition, PN = Pg = const., see Eq. (1.5) above. Next, we sum up the two equations (1.31) and subtract the result from Eq. (1.28); thus we obtain" dU (') - T dS C') + cy dA + ~__~p, dN i(') ,
(1.32)
i
where U (s) --~ U - U
(l) - U
(2) ,
S (s) -~
S -
S (1) - S (2) ,
N(')i
= N i _ Ni- (1) _ N ~ 2 )
(1.33)
are, respectively, surface excesses of internal energy, entropy and number of molecules of the i-th species; these excesses are considered as being attributed to the dividing surface. Equation (1.32) can be interpreted as the fundamental equation
of the interface [4,24]. Since the
interface is uniform, then dl~U ~, dS (') and dNi' ~can be considered as amounts of the respective extensive thermodynamic parameters corresponding to a small portion, dA, of the interface; then Eq. (1.32) can be integrated to yield [2,4]: U (s) - T S Is) + e r A + Z I I i N ~ st ,
(1.34)
i
Finally, we differentiate Eq. (1.34) and compare the result with Eq. (1.32); thus we arrive at the Gibbs [4] adsorption equation:
Chapter 1
14
da
St"~ - -~dV A
(1.35)
- EFidldi i
where F, = N~" = A
(n, ( ~ ) - nr 1) )d~, + -~
(H i ( ~ ) -
H i-('~) ]/d7
(1.36)
zo
is the adsorption of the i-th species at the interface; ni(z)
is the actual concentration of
component "i" as a function of the distance to the interface, z, cf. Eq. (1.33); z0 denotes the position of the dividing surface. Figure 1.5a shows qualitatively the dependence ni(z) for a nona m p h i p h i l i c component, i.e. a component, which does not exhibit a tendency to accumulate at
the interface; if phase l is an aqueous solution, then the water can serve as an example for a non-amphiphilic
component.
On the other hand, Figure
1.5b shows qualitatively the
dependence ni(z) for an amphiphilic component (surfactant), which accumulates (adsorbs) at the interface, see the maximum of hi(Z) in Fig. 1.5b.
1.2.2.
EQUIMOLECULAR DIVIDING SURFACE
As discussed in section 1.1.2 above, the definition of the dividing surface is a matter of choice. In other words, one has the freedom to impose one physical condition in order to determine the position of the dividing surface. This can be the condition the adsorption of the i-th component to be equal to zero [4]:
F;1:0:~v- 0
(equimolecular dividing surface)
(1.37)
The surface thus defined is called equimolecular dividing surface with respect to component "i". In order to have F ; - 0 the sum of the integrals in Eq. (1.36) must be equal to zero. This
means that the positive and negative areas, which are comprised between the continuous and dashed lines in Fig. 1.5a,b and denoted by (+) and (-), must be equal.
15
P l a n a r Fluid Interfaces
ni
n~'
(a)
"i
!
~
,(z)
(b)
_,
Zv
Z
0
Zv
Z
Fig. 1.5. Illustrative dependence of the density ni of the i-th component on the distance z to the interface for (a) non-amphiphilic component and (b) amphiphilic component; Zv denotes the position of the equimoleqular dividing surface; n,(~) and nit2~are the values of n,. in the bulk of phases 1 and 2. As seen in Fig. 1.5a, if component "i"
is non-amphiphilic (say the water as a solvent in an
aqueous solution), the equimolecular dividing surface, z = Zv, is really situated in the transition zone between the two phases. In contrast, if component "i"
is an amphiphilic one, then the
equimolecular dividing surface, z = Zv, is located far from the actual interracial transition zone (Fig. 1.5b). Therefore, to achieve a physically adequate description of the system, the equimolecular dividing surface is usually introduced with respect to the solvent; it should never be introduced with respect to an amphiphilic component (surfactant).
1.2.3.
T H E R M O D Y N A M I C S OF A D S O R P T I O N OF N O N I O N I C S U R F A C T A N T S
A molecule of a nonionic surfactant (like all amphiphilic molecules) consists of a hydrophilic and a hydrophobic moiety. The hydrophilic moiety (the "headgroup") can be a water soluble polymer, like poly-oxi-ethylene, or some polysaccharide [251; it can be also a dipolar headgroup, like those of many phospholipids. The hydrophobic moiety (the "tail") usually consists of one or two hydrocarbon chain(s). The adsorption of such a molecule at a fluid interface is accompanied with a gain of free energy, because the hydrophilic part of an adsorbed molecule is exposed to the aqueous phase, whereas its hydrophobic part contacts with the nonaqueous (hydrophobic) phase. Let us consider the boundary between an aqueous solution of a nonionic surfactant and a hydrophobic phase, air or oil. We choose the dividing surface to be the equimolecular dividing
16
Chapter 1
surface with respect to water, that is Fw - 0. Then the Gibbs adsorption equation (1.35) reduces to do" - - F 1 d/.t 1
(T = const.)
(1.38)
where the subscript "1" denotes the nonionic surfactant. Since the bulk surfactant concentration is usually relatively low, one can use the expression for the chemical potential of a solute in an ideal solution [23]" It 1 - ll~ ~ + k T In c I
(1.39)
where Cl is the concentration of the nonionic surfactant and /t{ ~ is a standard chemical potential, which is independent of Cl, and k is the Boltzmann constant. Combining Eqs. (1.38) and (1.39) one obtains dcy - - k T F 1d In c I
(1.40)
The surfactant adsorption isotherms, expressing the connection between Fj and c~ are usually obtained by means of some molecular model of the adsorption. The most popular is the Langmuir [26] adsorption isotherm, F1
Kc 1
~ = ~ F~ 1+ K c 1 which stems from a lattice model of localized adsorption of n o n - i n t e r a c t i n g
(1.41) molecules [27].
In Eq. (1.41) F~ is the maximum possible value of the adsorption (Fj-->F= for c~--+oo). On the other hand, for c~---)0 one has FI -- Kc~; the adsorption parameter K characterizes the surface activity of the surfactant: the greater K the higher the surface activity. Table 1.1 contains the 6 most popular surfactant adsorption isotherms, those of Henry, Freundlich, Langmuir, Volmer [28], Frumkin [29], and van der Waals [27]. For Cl--+0 all other isotherms (except that of Freundlich) reduce to the Henry isotherm. The physical difference between the Langmuir and Volmer isotherms is that the former corresponds to a physical model of localized adsorption, whereas the l a t t e r - to non-localized adsorption. The Fmmkin and van der Walls isotherms generalize, respectively, the Langmuir and Volmer isotherms for the case, when there is interaction between the adsorbed molecules; fl is the parameter,
Planar Fluid Interfaces
17
Table 1.1. The most popular surfactant adsorption isotherms and the respective surface tension isotherms. 9 Surfactant adsorption isotherms
(for nonionic surfactants" at. ,, ---- C 1 )
r~
Henry Kal, ' =
Freundlich
i
Kai, ' -
r,
11/m
Langmuir Kal. ` =
Volmer
~ exp/ ~ /
Kal, =
Frumkin
Ka I = "
van der Waals
F1 -r,
F
exp kT
~a,= F1 exp/~ ~
F ' -F~
2~ /
F ' -F~
kT
9 Surface tension isotherm
o r - o r o - k T J +or d
(for nonionic surfactants: o-d - O) Henry
j-~
Freundlich
j_~ m
Langmuir J--F
In 1 - ~ - f
Volmer F Frumkin
- Fl
J--rlnl-~
E ] 13Fl2 ~r
van der Waals j
m
F -F 1
kT
18
Chapter 1
which accounts for the interaction. In the case of van der Waals interaction ]3 can be expressed in the form [30,31]:
u(r) 1 - exp ----~--
[3--zckT ro
where
u(r) is
~--rc f u(r)rdr ti)
the interaction energy between two adsorbed molecules and r0 is the distance
between the centers of the molecules at close contact. The comparison between theory and experiment shows that the interaction parameter ]3 is important for air-water interfaces, whereas for oil-water interfaces one can set ,B = 0 [32,33]. The latter fact, and the finding that ]3 > 0 for air-water interfaces, leads to the conclusion that fl
takes into account the van der Waals
attraction between the hydrocarbon tails of the adsorbed surfactant molecules across air (such attraction is missing when the hydrophobic phase is oil). What concerns the parameter K in Table 1.1, it is related to the standard free energy of adsorption, A f - / / I ~ -/~1, . (0~, which is the energy gain for bringing a molecule from the bulk of the water phase to a diluted adsorption layer [34,35]:
~/
K - ~1 exp
F
kT
(1.42)
Here 8~ is a parameter, characterizing the thickness of the adsorption layer, which can be set (approximately) equal to the length of the amphiphilic molecule. Let us consider the integral
J-
c! dc, C , ~C1-
i 0
dlnC'dFl r, dr 1
(1.43)
The derivative d In c~/dFl can be calculated for each adsorption isotherm in Table 1.1, and then the integration in Eq. (1.43) can be carried out analytically. The expressions for J, obtained in this way, are also listed in Table 1.1. The integration of the Gibbs adsorption isotherm, Eq. (1.40), along with Eq. (1.43) yields o =G o
-kTJ,
(1.44)
which in view of the expressions for J in Table 1.1 presents the surfactant adsorption isotherm, or the two-dimensional (surface) equation of state.
Planar Fluid Interfaces
19
Table 1.2. Expressions for the Gibbs elasticity of adsorption monolayers (valid for both nonionic and ionic surfactants), which correspond to the various types of isotherms in Table 1.1. Type of surface tension isotherm
Gibbs elasticity Ec
Henry
E G =kTF 1
Freundlich
EG
=kT F1 m
Langmuir E G - kTF 1
F~ - F1
Volmer
F2 e c - kTr~ (v= - Vl
Frumkin
)2
Ec -kTF~(F~F~-F12/~F, )kT
van der Waals EG - kTF1
F2 (F~ - F 1)2
2flF 1 kT
An important thermodynamic parameter of a surfactant adsorption monolayer is its Gibbs (surface) elasticity: (1.45)
Expressions for Ec,, corresponding to various adsorption isotherms, are shown in Table 1.2. As an example, let us consider the expression for Ec;, corresponding to the Langmuir isotherm" combining results from Tables 1.1 and 1.2 one obtains Ec - F
kTKc 1
(for Langmuir isotherm)
(1.45a)
One sees that for Langmuirian adsorption the Gibbs elasticity grows linearly with the surfactant concentration c~. Since the concentration of the monomeric surfactant cannot exceed the critical micellization concentration, CI~ CCMC, then from Eq. (1.45a) one obtains
20
Chapter 1
EG ~ (EG)max --
~kT
KCcMc
(for Langmuir isotherm)
(1.45b)
Hence one could expect higher elasticity Ec for surfactants with higher CCMC;this conclusion is consonant with the experimental results [36]. The Gibbs elasticity characterizes the lateral fluidity of the surfactant adsorption monolayer. For high values of the Gibbs elasticity the adsorption monolayer at a fluid interface behaves as tangentially immobile. Then, if a particle approaches such an interface, the hydrodynamic flow pattern, and the hydrodynamic interaction as well, is approximately the same as if the particle were approaching a solid surface. For lower values of the Gibbs elasticity the so called "Marangoni effect" appears, which can considerably affect the approach of a particle to a fluid interface. These aspects of the hydrodynamic interactions between particles and interfaces are considered in Chapter 6 below. The thermodynamics of adsorption of ionic surfactants (see Section 1.2.5 below) is more complicated because of the presence of long-range electrostatic interactions in the system. As an introduction, in the next section we briefly present the theory of the electric double layer.
1.2.4.
THEORY OF THE ELECTRIC DOUBLE LAYER. B o l t z m a n n equation a n d activity coefficients. When ions are present in the solution, the
(electro)chemical potential of the ionic species can be expressed in the form [23] ]1 i - ].1~O) + k T In a i + Z i e l l t
(1.46)
which is more general than Eq. (1.39) above; here e is the elementary electric charge, gt is the electric potential, Zi is the valency of the ionic component "i", and a/is its activity. When an electric double layer is formed in a vicinity a charged interface, see Fig. 1.4, the electric potential and the activities of the ionic species become dependent on the distance z from the interface: ~t = ~z), ai = ai(z). On the other hand, at equilibrium the electrochemical potential, p,, is uniform throughout the whole solution, including the electric double layer (otherwise diffusion fluxes would appear) [23]. In the bulk of solution (z.--->~) the electric potential tends to a constant value, which is usually set equal to zero; then one can write
( 1.47)
( I .48) Setting equal the expression for p , at z - w and that for pi at some finite z. and using Eqs. ( I .46) and ( I .47), one obtains [ 2 3 ] :
where ui- denotes the value of the activity of ion "i" in the bulk of solution. Equation (1.49) shows that the activity obeys a Boltzmann type distribution across the electric double Iaycr
(EDL). If the activity in the bulk, u,-, is known, then Eq. (1.49) dekrrnines the activity a,(zj in each point of the EDL. Thc studics on adsorption of ionic surfactants [32.33,20] show that a good agreement between theory and experiment can be achieved using the following expression for
(l,-
:
( 1S O )
where c,~.,is the bulk concentration of the respective ion, arid the activily coefl'icienl y? is to be calculated from the known semicmpirical formula [37]
logy, = -
AIZ+Z I J I I+Brl,&
+bl
(1.51)
which originates from the Debye-Huckel theory; I denote? the ionic strcngth of thc solution:
whcre the surnmation is carried out o w r all ionic spccics in thc solution. When the solution onntairis a mix1tir.r of scvei-;~l trlecti-oly~es.[hen .kq. ( I .S 1 ) defines
for each separaie
eleclrulytc, with Z , and Z being thc valcnces of the cations and anions fur this clcctrolyte, but with I hcinp ltic fntirl ionic strcngth o f thc solution, accounting Ihr all dissolved ionic species
[37]. The log in Eq. ( 1 .S 1 ) is decimal. tl, is the diainetcr of thc ion. A, H , a n d b are parameters,
Chapter 1
22
whose values can be found in the book by Robinson and Stokes [37]. For example, if the ionic strength I is given in moles per liter (M), then for solutions of NaC1 at 25~
the parameters
values are A = 0.5115 M -1/2 Bdi = 1.316 M -1/2 and b = 0.055 M -l Integration
of Poisson-Boltzmann
equation.
The Poisson equation relating the
distribution of the electric potential ~ z ) and electric charge density, pe(z), across the diffuse double layer can be presented in the form [14] d21// 4Jr ----5- = - ~ P e dz e
,
(1.53)
Let us choose component 1 to be a coion, that is an ion having electric charge of the same sign as the interface. It is convenient to introduce the variables ~(Z)
-
Zle~(z)
.-.
k------~'
_
Z~ -_ Z k
Pe
Z1
Pe - Zl e ,
For symmetric electrolytes ~ and
/~e
(k = 1,2 .... N)
(1.54)
thus defined are always positive irrespective of whether
the interface is positively or negatively charged. Combining Eqs. (1.49), (1.53) and (1.54) one obtains d 2ci:)
2
=
2
1 ~r fie -
dz
1
2
N
Kc Z ziai ~ exp(-zi~) i=l
(1.55)
where 2 81~Z1e2 tr C ekT
(1.56)
As usual, the z-axis is directed along the normal to the interface, the latter corresponding to z = 0. To obtain Eq. (1.55) we have expressed the bulk charge density in terms of effective concentrations, i.e. activities, pe(Z)= ~_~Zieai(z), rather than in terms of the net concentrai
tions, P e ( Z ) - Y _ ~ Z i e c , ( z ) . For not-too-high ionic strengths there is no significant quantitative i
difference between these two expressions for Pe (z), but the former one considerably simplifies the mathematical derivations; moreover, the former expression has been combined with
23
Planar Fluid Interfaces
Eq. (1.49), which is rigorous in terms of activities (rather than in terms of concentrations). Integrating Eq. (1.55) one can derive dO / 2 N -~z - tr Z a;= [exp(-z,O)- 1]
(1.57)
i=1
where the boundary conditions O[z_~= =0 and (dO/dz)~._,= =0 have been used, cf. Eqs. (1.47), (1.48) and (1.54). Note that Eq. (1.57) is a nonlinear ordinary differential equation of the first order, which determines the variation of the electric potential O(z) across the EDL. In general, Eq. (1.57) has no analytical solution, but it can be solved relatively easily by numerical integration. Analytical solution can be obtained in the case of symmetric electrolyte, see Eq. (1.65) below. Further, let Ps be the surface electric charge density, i.e. the electric charge per unit area of the interface. Since the solution, as a whole, is electroneutral, the following relationship holds [ 14]:
cx~ (1.58)
Ps - - ~ p ~ ( z ) & 0
Substituting Pe(Z) from Eq. (1.55) into Eq. (1.58) and integrating the second derivative, d 2 9 / dz 2, one derives
/d
/2
_
~--o - ~ ~c/5,,
P"-Z~e
The combination of Eqs. (1.57) and (1.59) yields a connection between the surface charge density, Ps, and the surface potential, Os = O(z=0), which is known as the Gouy equation [15,38]: 112 Ps ---
tCc
aioo
i=1
s
,
s
--
kT
(1.60)
Note that because of the choice component 1 to be a coion, the sign of Os and /5, is always positive and that is the reason why in Eq. (1.60) we have taken sign "+" before the square root.
Cl1crpter I
24
To obtain an expression for calculating the diffuse layer contribution to the surface tension, o,/, we first corribirie Eqs. (1.2 I ) and ( I S4):
(1.61) A substitution of Eq. ( 1.57) into Eq. (1.6 I ) yields
( I .62)
Expressions for flf,obtained by tneans
or Eq. ( I 5 2 ) for solutions of surfactant and various
e.lectrolytes, can he found in Table 1.3 below, as well as in Ref. [20]. Atiulylicul expressiorz.s ,Jir 21:21 elactrolyte. Analytical cxprcssion for O(z) can bc
obtained in t.hc siiiiplcr case- when the solution contains only symmetric, Z1:Z,electi-olyte, that is Z. = -.ZI (Z, = 0 for i > 2 ) . In this case Eq. ( 1.57) can be rcpi-escntcd in the form
(2, :z, electi-0lyt.c)
( I .63)
where
c N
K
I
;K (
( I .64)
1-1
is known a s the Debye screerlirig parai~ieter.The integration of Eq. ( I .63) yields ;in analylical expression for the variation of thc electric potential @ ( z ) across the EDL 1141:
(I)( z ) = 4arctanh tad1 Equation
(
2
1
>xp(-m)
(2l:Zl electrolyte)
( I .6S)
I .65) shows that the electric potcntial, crcatcd by the charged interface, decays
exponenlially i n the depth of solLilion, that is O(:) = exp(-o) for z+m.
The irlversc Debye
paraiiictcr, dl,trcprcscnts a decay length, which characterizes the thickness of thc EDL. The
Gouy equation ( I .60). giving the conriectiori bctwccrl sut-l'acc cliargc and surl'ucc potcntial, also sirriptifits l o r 2,:Zj eleclrolyte:
25
Planar Fluid Interfaces
( Z 1:Z 1 electrolyte)
(1.66)
where F~ and F2 are the adsorptions of the ionic components 1 and 2, respectively. For the same case the integration in Eq. (1.62) can be carried out analytically and the following simpler expression for the diffuse layer contribution to the surface tension can be derived [19,38,39]"
O'd = - ~
cosh
- 1
(Z1 :Zl electrolyte)
(1.67)
K"c
The above equations serve as a basis of the thermodynamics of adsorption of ionic surfactants.
1.2.5.
THERMODYNAMICS OF ADSORPTION OF IONIC SURFACTANTS
Basic equations. Combining Eqs. (1.46), (1.47) and (1.49) one obtains a known expression for the chemical potential" /.t;-/.t~ ~ + k T l n a i .
The substitution of the latter
expression into the Gibbs adsorption equation (1.35) yields [ 19,33,40,41 ]: N
dcr - -kT~.~ Fi d In a~=
(T = const)
(1.68)
i=1
Here with F i we denote the adsorption of the i-th component; F; represents a surface excess of component "i" with respect to the uniform bulk solution. For an ionic species this means that ,-,.,
F i is a total adsorption, which include contributions from both the adsorption layer (surfactant adsorption layer + adsorbed counterions in the Stern layer, see Fig. 1.4) and the diffuse layer. Let us define the quantities
Ai - f[a~(z)-a~=]dz ,
Fi - F i - A ~
(1.69)
0
Ai and Fi can be interpreted as contributions of the diffusion and adsorption layers, ,-,.,
respectively, into the total adsorption F;. Using the theory of the electric double layer and the definitions (1.69) one can prove (see Appendix 1A) that the Gibbs adsorption equation (1.68) can be presented into the following equivalent form [20]
26
Chapter
1
N
do- a - - k T Z Ei d In ais
(T = const)
(1.70)
i=1
where ~, = o- - o-d is the contribution of the adsorption layer into the surface tension, o-j is the contribution of the diffuse layer, defined by Eq. (1.21), and
ais
-
aioo e x p ( - Z i ~ s ) ,
Zi
Zi Z1
(1.71)
is the subsurface activity of the i-th ionic species. The comparison between Eqs. (1.68) and (1.70) shows that the Gibbs adsorption equation can be expressed either in terms of o-, F; and aim, or in terms of o-~, Fi and ais. In Appendix 1A it is proven that these two forms are
equivalent. To derive explicit adsorption and surface tension isotherms, below we specify the type of ionic surfactant and non-amphiphilic salt in the solution.
Surfactant and salt are 1:1 electrolytes. We consider a solution of an ionic surfactant, which is a symmetric 1"1 electrolyte, in the presence of additional common symmetric l'l electrolyte (salt). Here we assume that the counterions due to the surfactant and salt are identical. For example, this can be a solution of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) in the presence of NaC1. We denote by Cl~, c2~ and c3= the bulk concentrations of the surface active ions, counterions, and coions, respectively. For the special system of SDS with NaC1 cl=, c2= and c3~ are the bulk concentration of the DS-, Na + and CI- ions, respectively. The requirement for the bulk solution to be electroneutral implies c2~ = cl= + c3~. The multiplication of the last equation by ~'+, which according to Eq. (1.51) is the same for all monovalent ions, yields a2~ = al~+ a3~
(1.72)
The adsorption of the coions of the non-amphiphilic salt is expected to be equal to zero, F3 = 0, because they are repelled by the similarly charged interface (however, A3 :~ 0: the integral in N
Eq. (1.69) gives a negative A3, see Fig. 1.4; hence F 3 - A 3 r 0). Then the Gibbs adsorption equation (1.70) can be presented in the form
do- a - - k T ( F l d l n a j s
+ F2dlnazs)
(1.73)
The differentials in the right-hand side of Eq. (1.73) are independent (one can vary independently the concentrations of surfactant and salt), and moreover, d o , , is an exact (total) differential. Then according to the Euler condition [23] the cross derivatives must be equal, viz. (1.74)
A surfactant adsorption isotherm,
r, = r,(a,~,a 2 , ) , and
r2= r2(u, , u 2 , ) ,are thrrmodynuinically ~
a counterion adsorption isotherm,
cornpatible if they satisfy Eq. (1.74). Integrating Eq.
( I .74) one obtains
r, =-
dJ
(1.75)
d In q c
where we have introduced the notation
( I .76)
To determine the integration constant in Eq. (1.75) we have used the condition that for u l \= 0 (no surfactant in the solution) we have
r,= 0 (no surfactant adsorption) and r,=0 (no binding
of counterions at the headgroups of adsorbed surfactant). The integral J in Eq. (1.76) can be taken analytically for all popular surface tension isotherms, see Table 1 . 1 . Differentiating Eq. (1.76) one obtains
rl = d J / d l n u , , \ . The substitution of the latter equation, together with Eq.
(1.75) into Eq. ( I .73), after integration yields
o(,
-
kTJ ,
( 1.77)
where 4) is the value of o for pure water. Combining Eqs. ( I . 19) and (1.77) one obtains the surface tension isotherm of the ionic surfactant:
where o,/ is given by Eq. (1.67) and expressions for J , corresponding to various adsorption isotherms, are available in Table 1 . 1 . Note that for each of the isotherms in Table 1 . 1 depends on the product K u , , , that is
r,
r,= r,( K U , , ~ Then ). Eq. (1.76) can be transformed to read
Chnpter 1
28
(1.79)
Differentiating Eq. ( I .79) one can bring Eq. (1.75) into the form [20]
r, = r,
dInK
(1 3 0 )
~
d In a 2 s
which holds for each of the surfactant adsorption isotherms i n Table 1 . 1 . Note that Eq. ( 1 2 0 ) is valid for a general form of the dependence K = K( a ? , ) , which expresses the dependence of the equilibrium constant of surfactant adsorption on the concentration of the salt in solution. Let us consider a linear dependence K = K( u z 5), that is K =KI +K 2 ~ 2 s
(1.81)
where K I and K2 are constants. The physical meaning of the linear dependence of K on a 2 , in Eq. (1.8 1 ) is discussed below, see Eqs. ( I . 1 18)-( 1.128) and the related text. The substitution of Eq. (1.8 1) into Eq. (1 3 0 ) yields [20] (1.82) Equation (1.82) is in fact a form of the Stern isotherm [ 17,381. One can verify that the Euler condition (1.74) is identically satisfied if
r?is substituted
from Eq. (1 3 2 ) and l-1 is expressed
by either of the adsorption isotherms in Table 1.1. In fact, Eq. (1.81) is the necessary and sufficient condition for thermodynamic compatibility of the Stern isotherm of counterinn adsorption, Eq. (1.82), with either of the surfuctant adsorption isotherms in Table I . I . In other words, a given isotherm from Table I . I , say the Langmuir isotherm, is thermodynamically compatible with the Stern isotherm, if only the adsorption parameters K, K, and K? in these isotherms are related by means of Eq. (1.81). The constants K I and K2 have a straightforward physical meaning. In view of Eqs. ( I .42) and (1.81)
(13 3 )
29
Planar Fluid Intelfaces
where A/.t(~ has the meaning of standard free energy of adsorption of surfactant from ideal dilute solution to ideal adsorption monolayer in the absence of dissolved non-amphiphilic salt; the thickness of the adsorption layer ~ is about 2 nm for SDS. Note that the Langmuir and Stern isotherms, Eqs. (1.41) and (1.82), have a similar form, which corresponds to a statistical model considering the interface as a lattice of equivalent, distinguishable, and independent adsorption sites, without interactions between bound molecules [27]. Consequently, an expression, which is analogous to Eq. (1.83), holds for the ratio K2/K~ [the latter is a counterpart of K in Eq. (1.41)]: - (0)] K---L= c~--L2exp A]./2
K1
Foo
(1.84)
kT
where (39 is the thickness of the Stern layer (c.a. the diameter of a hydrated counterion) and A
~2(0) has the meaning of standard free energy of adsorption (binding) of a counterion from an
ideal dilute solution into an ideal Stern layer. In summary, the parameters K~ and/(2 are related to the standard free energies of surfactant and counterion adsorption. The above equations form a full set for calculating the surface tension as a function of the bulk surfactant and salt concentrations (or activities), o " - o'(aloo,a2oo). There are 6 unknown variables: o, ~,,a~.,.,F~, a2., and F 2. These variables are to be determined from a set of 6 equations as follows. Equation (1.49) for i = 1,2 provides 2 equations. The remaining 4 equations are: Eqs. (1.66), (1.78), (1.82) and one surfactant adsorption isotherm from Table 1.1, say the Langmuir isotherm.
Comparison of theory and experiment. As illustration we consider an interpretation of experimental data by Tajima et al. [42,43] for the surface tension vs. surfactant concentrations at two concentrations of NaCI: c>o= 0 and c3~ = 0.115 M, see Fig. 1.6. The ionic surfactant used in these experiments is tritiated sodium dodecyl sulfate (TSDS), which is 1:1 electrolyte (the radioactivity of the tritium nuclei have been measured by Tajima et al. to determine directly the surfactant adsorption). Processing the set of data for the interracial tension O"
=O'(Cloo,C2oo) as a function of the bulk concentrations of surfactant ions, c~oo, and
counterions, c2oo, one can determine the surfactant adsorption, Fl(clo~,c2oo), the counterion
Chapter I
30
TSDS-water-air
/
40 A
9 9
E
z E
30
No salt 0.115MNaCI .
.
.
.
/
, ~
.
t,_
L
20
U L
1 0 -2
2
i
3
i
i
i
,1LI
0-1
2
i
3
i
i
r i.~,1
100
i
2
r
3
,i
~ i i ]1
101
TSDS concentration (mM)
Fig. 1.6. Surface pressure at air-water interface, o'0-o-, vs. the surfactant (TSDS) concentration, cl=, for two fixed NaCI concentrations: 0 and 0.115 M; the symbols are experimental data from Refs. [42] and [43]; the continuous lines represent the best fit by means of the theory from Ref. [20]. adsorption, F2 (cloo,c2=) , and the surface potential, ~t (c~oo,c2=) . To fit the data in Fig. 1.6 the Frumkin isotherm is used (see Table 1.1). The theoretical model contains four parameters, /3, F=, K~ and/(2, whose values are to be obtained from the best fit of the experimental data. The parameters values can be reliably determined if only the set of data for o'-o-(c1=,c2= ) contains experimental points for both high and low surfactant concentrations, and for both high and low salt concentrations; the data by Tajima et al. [42,43] satisfy the latter requirement. (If this requirement is not satisfied, the merit function exhibits a flat and shallow minimum, and therefore it is practically impossible to determine the best fit [20]). The value of F~, obtained in Ref. [20] from the best fit of the data in Fig. 1.6, corresponds to 1 / F ~ - 37.6 .~2. The respective value of K~ is 156 m3/mol, which in view of Eq. (1.83) gives a standard free energy of surfactant adsorption A/,t~~ = 12.8 kT per TDS- ion, that is 31.3 kJ/mol. The determined value of K2/K~ is 8.21x10 -4 m3/mol, which after substitution in Eq. (1.84) yields a standard free energy of counterion binding A~t~~ kJ/mol.
1.64 kT per Na + ion, that is 4.04
31
Planar Fluid Interfaces
TSDS-water-air 1.0 E
0.9
._o
0.8
o
0.7
-o
0.6
Q.
ltl
0.5
= o
0.4
1/) = (1)
E
Q
o
m
0.3
0.2
TDS- adsorption ] ~ Na+ adsorption ~
.........
/ It
I
0.1 0.0
10-5
i
2
3
~
'
i
i-,l
1 0-4
t
2
i
3
i
,
i1/
[
10-a
i
2 3
i
I
i
i
I
t
10-2
TSDS concentration (M) Fig. 1.7. Plots of the calculated adsorptions of surfactant F~/Foo (the full lines), and counterions F2/Foo (the dotted lines), vs. the surfactant (TSDS) concentration, c~oo. The lines correspond to the best fit of the data in Fig. 1.6 obtained in Ref. [20]. The value of the parameter fl is positive
(2flF~kT = +0.8), which indicates attraction between
the hydrocarbon tails of the adsorbed surfactant molecules. Figure 1.7 shows calculated curves for the adsorptions of surfactant, F 1 (the full lines), and counterions, F 2 (the dotted lines), vs. the TSDS concentration, cloo. These lines represent the variation of Fj and F 2 along the two experimental curves in Figure 1.6. One sees that both F~ and F 2 are markedly greater when NaC1 is present in the solution. The highest values of FI for the curves in Fig. 1.7 are 4.30 x 10 -6 mol/m 2 and 4.20 • 10 .6 mol/m 2 for the solutions with and without NaC1, respectively. The latter two values compare well with the saturation adsorptions measured by Tajima [42,43] for the same system by means of the radiotracer method, viz. F 1 = 4.33 x 10 -6 mol/m 2 and 3.19 x 10 -6 mol/m 2 for the solutions with and without NaC1. In Fig. 1.8 the occupancy of the Stern layer, 0 - F 2 / F 1 , concentration for the curves in Fig. 1.7. For the solution
is plotted vs. the surfactant
without NaCI F 2 /F~ rises from 0.15
Chapter 1
32
TSDS-water-air 0.8 0.7
,.-" CO t'O
1 5 M NaCI
0.6
salt
0.5
0.4
o t-
O.. O O
O
0.3 0.2 ,1
i
ii
10-2
~
2
3
i
i
LI
1 0-1
t
2
3
P
~
I
L
ql
1 00
1
2
3
I
I
II
1 01
TSDS concentration (mM)
Fig. 1.8. Calculated occupancy of the Stern layer by adsorbed counterions, F2/Fj, vs. the surfactant (TSDS) concentration, Cl=, for two fixed NaC1 concentrations: 0 and 0.115 M. The lines correspond to the best fit obtained in Ref. [20] for the data in Fig. 1.6. up to 0.74 and then exhibits a tendency to level off. As it could be expected, the occupancy F 2 /F~ is higher for the solution with N a C I even at TSDS concentration 10 .5 M the occupancy is about 0.40" for the higher surfactant concentrations 0 levels off at F 2 / F] = 0.74 (Fig. 1.8). The latter value is consonant with data of other authors [44-47], who have obtained values of F 2 /F~ up to 0.70 - 0.90 for various ionic surfactants; pronounced evidences for counterion binding have been obtained also in experiments with solutions containing surfactant micelles [48-53]. These results imply that the counterion adsorption (binding) should be always taken into account. The fit of the data in Fig. 1.6 gives also the values of the surface electric potential, g t . For the solutions with salt the model predicts surface potentials varying in the range I W, I= 55 - 95 mV within the experimental interval of surfactant concentrations, whereas for the solution without salt the calculated surface potential is higher: lip'., I= 150 - 180 mV (note that for TSDS I/t has a negative sign). Thus it turns out that measurements of surface tension, interpreted by means
Planar Fluid Interfaces
33
of an appropriate theoretical model, provide a method for determining the surface potential N.~ in a broad range of surfactant and salt concentrations. The results of this method could be compared with other, more direct, methods for surface potential measurement, such as the electrophoretic ~'-potential measurements [12,13,54,55], or Volta (AV)potential measurements, see e.g. Ref. [56].
Surfactant is 1:1 electrolyte, salt is Z3:Z4 electrolyte. In this case we will number the ionic components as follows: index "1" - surfactant ion, index "2" - counterion due to the surfactant, index " 3 " - c o i o n
due to the salt, and index " 4 " - c o u n t e r i o n due to the salt. As
before, we assume that the coions due to the salt do not adsorb at the interface:
F3 = 0. The
counterions due to the surfactant and salt are considered as separate components, which can exhibit a competitive adsorption in the Stern layer (see Fig. 1.4). The analogs of Eqs. (1.81) and (1.82) for the case under consideration are [20]:
K = K l + K2a2s + K4a4s
Fi
-- = F1
Kiais K1 + K2a2s + K4a4s
(1.85)
(i = 2 , 4 )
(1.86)
where KI, K2 and K4 are constants. All expressions for surfactant adsorption isotherms and surface tension isotherms given in Table 1.1 are valid also in the present case. Different are the forms of the Gouy equation and of the expression for o j , which depend on z3 and z4 in accordance with Eqs. (1.60) and (1.62). In particular, the integration in Eq. (1.62) can be carried out analytically for some types of electrolyte. Table 1.3 summarizes the expressions for the Gouy equation and o-(l, which have been derived in Ref. [20] for the cases, when the salt is 1:1, 2:1, 1:2 and 2:2 electrolyte. (Here 2:1 electrolyte means a salt of bivalent counterion and monovalent coion.) One may check that in the absence of salt (a4~ = 0) all expressions in Table 1.3 reduce either to Eq. (1.66) or to Eq. (1.67). More details can be found in Ref. [20].
Gibbs elasticity ,for ionic" surfactants. The definition of Gibbs (surface) elasticity is not well elucidated in the literature for the case of ionic surfactant adsorption monolayers. That is the reason why here we devote a special discussion to this issue.
Chapter I
34
Table 1.3. Special forms of the Gouy equation (1.60) and of the expression for
CQ
, Eq. (1.62), for
solutions of surfactant which is 1: 1 electrolyte, and salt which is 1: I , 2: I , 1.2 and 2:2 electrolyte
Type
Expressions
of salt
obtained from Eqs. (1.60) and ( I .62)
1:1
2: I
I :2
g,
= (1 - v z + V
I/?
Y )
q=
2:2
I
I
5)
Planar Fluid Interfaces
35
The physical concept of surface elasticity is the most transparent for monolayers of insoluble surfactants. The changes of cy and FI in the expression Ec, =-F~(0o/0F 91 correspond to variations in surface tension and adsorption during a real process of interracial dilatation. In the case of a soluble nonionic surfactant the detected increase of cy in a real process of interfacial dilatation can be a pure manifestation of surface elasticity only if the period of dilatation, At, is much shorter than the characteristic relaxation time of surface tension, At << "c•. Otherwise the adsorption and the surface tension would be affected by the diffusion supply of surfactant molecules from the bulk of solution toward the expanding interface. The diffusion transport tends to reduce the increase of surface tension upon dilatation, thus apparently rendering the interface less elastic and more fluid. To describe the variation of the surface tension after an initial dilatation one is to solve the diffusion equation using an appropriate initial condition (see Section 1.3.1 for details). In such a case the Gibbs elasticity, Ec~, enters the theoretical expressions through this initial condition, which corresponds to an "instantaneous" dilatation of the interface (that is At << ~-,~), see e.g. Ref. [57]. This "instantaneous" dilatation decreases the adsorptions Fi and the subsurface concentrations ci, of the species (the subsurface is presumed to be always in equilibrium with the surface), but the bulk concentrations c;= remain unaffected [58,59]. This initially created difference between ci, and c;= further triggers the diffusion process. Now, let us try to extend this approach to the case of ionic surfactants. In the case of solution of an ionic surfactant, a non-uniform diffuse electric double layer (EDL) is formed in a vicinity of the interface; this is the major difference with the case of nonionic surfactant. The main question is whether or not the electric field in the EDL should be affected by the initial "instantaneous" dilatation of the interface. This problem has been examined in Ref. [60] and it has been established that a variation of the electric field during the initial dilatation leads to theoretical results devoid of sense. This is due to the following two facts" (i) The speed of propagation of the electric signals is much greater than the characteristic rate of diffusion. (2) Even a small initial variation in the surface charge density ,o, immediately gives rise to an electric potential, which is linearly increasing with the distance from the interface (potential of a planar wall). Thus a small initial perturbation of the interface would
Chapter 1
36
immediately affect the ions in the whole solution; of course, such an initial condition is physically unacceptable. In reality, a linearly growing electric field could not appear in the ionic solution, because a variation of the surface charge density would be immediately suppressed by exchange of counterions, which are abundant in the subsurface layer of the solution (see Fig. 1.4). The theoretical equations suggest the same: to have a mathematically meaningful initial condition for the diffusion problem, the initial dilatation must be carried out at constant surface charge density p, (p, = const, means also ~ , = const., see Eq. 1.66). Thus we can conclude that the initial "instantaneous" interfacial dilatation, which is related to the definition of Gibbs elasticity of a soluble ionic surfactant, must be carried out at Ps = const. From Eq. (1.19) one obtains
(dcy)p~ - (da. )o~ + (dad)p,
(1.87)
We recall that cr~ and cyd are, respectively, the contributions of the adsorption and diffusion layers to the total interfacial tension, or. An interfacial dilatation at constant p.,. and O.3 does not alter the diffuse part of the EDL, and consequently, ( d c r a ) p . , - 0 . Since, or,,-or 0 - k T J , the expressions for J in Table 1.1 show that or,, depends only on F~ at constant temperature. Then the definition of Gibbs elasticity of nonionic adsorption layers, Eq. (1.45), can be extended to ionic adsorption layers in the following way:
Ea--r,
~
.p,--rl~-~
r
(1.88)
The dependence of o" on FI for nonionic surfactants is the same as the dependence of oi, on F1 for ionic surfactants, see the surface tension isotherms in Table 1.1. Then Eqs. (1.45) and (1.88) show that the expressions for Ec, in Table 1.2 are valid for both nonionic and ionic surfactants. The effect of the surface electric potential on the Gibbs elasticity Eo of an ionic adsorption monolayer is implicit, through the equilibrium surfactant adsorption FI, which depends on the electric properties of the interface. To illustrate this let us consider the case of Langmuir isotherm; combining expressions from Tables 1.1 and 1.2 we obtain E c - F k T K a ~ , . Further, using Eqs. (1.49) and (1.81) we derive
E G - F~kTa,~ (KI e - * ' + K2a2~ )
(for Langmuir isotherm)
(1.89)
Planar Fluid Interfaces
37
Equation (1.89) visualizes the effect of salt on Ec: when the salt concentration increases, a2oo also increases, but the (dimensionless) surface potential ~s decreases; then Eq. (1.89) predicts an increase of Ec with the salt concentration. Note also that the values of Eo, calculated from the fits, like that in Fig. 1.6, depend on the type of the used adsorption isotherm; for example, the Frumkin isotherm gives values of E(;, which are systematically larger than those given by the van der Waals isotherm. The latter is preferable for fluid interfaces insofar as it corresponds to the model of non-localized adsorption. The definition of Gibbs elasticity given by Eq. (1.88) corresponds to an "instantaneous" (At << "tb) dilatation of the adsorption layer (that contributes to 0%) without affecting the diffuse layer and od. This will cause an initial change in the subsurface concentrations c;, of the species, which will further trigger a diffusion transport of components across a changing electric double layer. Thus we reach again the subject of the adsorption kinetics, which is considered in the next section.
1.3.
KINETICS OF SURFACTANT ADSORPTION
When a colloidal particle approaches an interface from the bulk of solution, or when an attached particle is moving throughout the interface, the surfactant adsorption layer is locally disturbed (expanded, compressed, sheared). The surfactant solution has the property to damp the disturbances by diffusion of surfactant molecules from the bulk to the interface (or in the opposite direction). If the particle motion is slow enough (compared with the relaxation time of surface tension "tb) the interface will behave as a two-dimensional fluid and surface elastic effects will not arise. On the contrary, if the characteristic time of the process of particle motion is comparable with or smaller than re,, the motion of the particle will be accompanied by surface elastic effects and adsorption dynamics. The criterion, showing when the latter effects would appear, is related to the relaxation time of the surface tension r~. Our attention in the present section will be focused on the theoretical results about "tb obtained for various types of surfactant adsorption, as follows: (i) adsorption under diffusion control, (ii) adsorption under electro-diffusion control, (iii) adsorption under barrier (kinetic) control,
38
Chapter 1
(iv) adsorption from micellar solutions, (v) adsorption from protein solutions. Our purpose is to give a brief review and related references in the context of the subject of this book; detailed information about the variety of experimental methods and theoretical approaches can be found elsewhere [58-66].
1.3.1. ADSORPTIONUNDERDIFFUSIONCONTROL Insofar as we are interested mainly in the relaxation time zc~, we will restrict our considerations to a physical situation, in which the interface is instantaneously expanded at the initial moment t = 0 and then (for t > 0) the diffusion transport of surfactant tends to saturate the adsorption layer, and eventually to restore the equilibrium in the system. In other words, the interfacial expansion happens only at the initial moment, and after that the interface is quiescent and the dynamics in the system is due only to the diffusion of surfactant. The adsorption process is a consequence of two stages: the first one is the diffusion of surfactant from the bulk to the subsurface and the second stage is the transfer of surfactant molecules from the subsurface to the surface. When the first stage (the surfactant diffusion) is much slower than the second stage, and consequently determines the rate of adsorption, the process is termed adsorption under diffusion control; it is considered in the present section. The opposite case, when the second stage is slower than the first one, is called adsorption under
barrier (or kinetic) control and it is presented in Section 1.3.3. If an electric double layer is present, the electric field to some extent plays the role of a slant barrier; this intermediate case of adsorption under electro-diffusion control, is presented in Section 1.3.2. Here we consider a solution of a nonionic surfactant, whose concentration, c 1 =c~(z,t), depends on the position and time because of the diffusion process. As before, z denotes the distance to the interface, which is situated in the plane z = 0. The surfactant adsorption and the surface tension vary with time: F~ = F~(t), cr = o(t). The surfactant concentration obeys the equation of diffusion: c~ c c)t
t
= D, 692c~ c? Z
(z > 0, t > 0)
(1.90)
Planar Fluid Interfaces
39
where D~ is the diffusion coefficient of the surfactant molecules. The exchange of surfactant between the solution and its interface is described by the boundary condition d F~ = D1 o1 cl
dt
(z = 0, t > 0)
(1.91)
~z
which states that the rate of increase of the adsorption F~ is equal to the diffusion influx of surfactant per unit area of the interface. The three equations necessary to determine the three unknown functions, cl(z,t), Fl(t) and o'(t), are in fact Eqs. (1.90), (1.91) and one of the adsorption isotherms, F~ = F~(c~), given in Table 1.1. Except the Henry isotherm, all other isotherms in Table 1.1 give a nonlinear connection between F1 and c~. As a consequence, an analytical solution of the problem can be obtained only if the Henry isotherm can be used, or if the deviation from equilibrium is small and the adsorption isotherm can be linearized:
r, (,) - tie
e
--
]
(1.92)
Cls stands for the subsurface concentration; here and hereafter the subscript "e" means that the respective quantity refers to the equilibrium state. The set of three linear equations, Eqs. (1.90)-(1.92), have been solved by Sutherland [65]. The result, which describes the relaxation of a small initial interfacial dilatation, reads:
F~(t)-Fle =exp
O'(t)--l~e
rfc
(1.93)
where (1.94)
is the characteristic relaxation time of surface tension and adsorption, and 2
oo
2
erfc(x) - ----~exp(-x )dx
(1.95)
~//17 x
is the so called complementary error function [67, 68]. The asymptotics of the latter function for small and large values of the argument are [67, 68]:
2
A'+ o(.x')
erfc(.x) = I - --x
c- , ?
& + (I(
for x << I ;
erfc(x) = -[I
$11
for .X >> I
(1 3 6 )
Combining Eqs. ( I ,931 and (1.96) one obt.ains the short-time and longtime asymptotics of the surface tcnsion rclaxation:
(f
>> z),
( I 38)
Equation (1.98) is oftcn used as a test t o vei-ify whether the adsorption process is under diffiision control: data for A q t ) = q t ) - 0, are plotted vs. I / &
and it is checked if- tho plot
complics wich a straight line. We recall that Eqs. (1.97) a n d ( I .9X') arc valid in the case of a snirrll initial pei-tiii-bal.ion;alternalive asymptotic expi-essions for the case of h - g e inilia1
perturbation hnvc bccn derived for nonionic surfactants by Hansen [h9l and for ionic surfactants by Danov ct al. [70].
Using thermodynamic trilnslormations one can relate the dci-ivative in Eq. (1.94) to the Gihhs elasticity Ec;; thus ELI.( 1.94) can be expressed i n an altcmativc form:
Substituting &; frorri Table 1.2 i n t o Eq. (1.99) one could obtain cxprcssions foi-
Z ,
corresponding to the various adsorption isothcrrns. In the special case of Langmuir adsorption isothcrrn onc can present Eq. ( 1.99) in [he Lor111
IT
I
( ~ r . " .-, )I '
: -
r),
(I
-I- Kc, I'
I), (I
( AT-,)
'
.
+ I<(;/( I:".,kT))' ~
(for Langmuir isothcrm)
( I . 100)
Equation ( I , IOO) visualizes the vcry strong dcpendcnce of the rtlaxalion liirle on thc sut-lratant concentration
L'I;
i n gcnciA,
tn
can vai-y with inany order5 of riiagnitlrde as
;I
function of c .
Equation ( I , 100) shows dso that high Gibbs elasticily corrcsponds to short rclaxation time, and vice vci-sa.
41
Planar Fluid Interfaces
As a quantitative example let us take typical values of the parameters: K~ = 15 m3/mol, 1/F~o= 40/~2, D~ - 5.5 x 10-6 cm2/s and T=298 K. Then substituting c1= 6.5 x 10-6 M in Eqs. (1.45a) and (1.100) we calculate Ec -- 1.0 mN/m and ~'~r= 5 s. In the same way, for Cl= 6.5 x 10.4 M we calculate Ea ~ 100 mN/m and ~'cr= 5 x 10-4 s. As already mentioned, to directly measure the Gibbs elasticity Ec, or to precisely investigate the dynamics of surface tension, one needs an experimental method, whose characteristic time is smaller compared to ~'cr. Equation (1.100) and the above numerical example show that when the surfactant concentration is higher, the experimental method should be faster. Various experimental methods are available, whose operational time scales cover different time intervals. Methods with a shorter characteristic operational time are the oscillating jet method [71-73], the oscillating bubble method [74-77], the fast-formed drop technique [78,79], the surface wave techniques [80-83] and the maximum bubble pressure method [84-88]. Methods of longer characteristic operational time are the inclined plate method [89, 90] and the dropweight techniques [91-93]; see Ref. [64] for a detailed review.
1.3.2.
ADSORPTION UNDER ELECTRO-DIFFUSION CONTROL
Let us consider a solution of an ionic surfactant and salt; for simplicity we assume that the counterions due to the surfactant and salt are the same (an example is SDS and NaC1, both of them releasing Na + counterions; the coions are DS- and C1-). The adsorption of surfactant at the interface creates surface charge, which is increasing in the course of the adsorption process. The charged interface repels the new-coming surfactant molecules, but attracts the conversely charged counterions; some of them bind to the surfactant headgroups thus decreasing the surface charge density and favoring the adsorption of new surfactant molecules. The transport of the i-th ionic species, with valency Zi and diffusion coefficient Di , under the influence of electrical potential gt, is described by the set of electro-diffusion equations [58,59,94]:
at
-
az
+
kT
c/
-~z
(z > O, t > O)
i = 1,2,3
(1 101)
Chapter 1
42
The indices i = 1, 2 and 3 denote the surfactant ion, the counterion and the coion, respectively; ci is the bulk concentrations of the i-th ion which depends on time t and the distance z to the interface. The second term in the parentheses in Eq. (1.101), the so called "electromigration" term, accounts for the effect of the electric field on diffusion. The electric potential ~ is related to the bulk charge density through the known Poisson equation,
O 2~ _ Oz ~
47ce [Z,c, + Z~c~ + Z~c 3 ] , e - -
(1 102)
Now we have two adsorbing species" the surfactant ions and the counterions; the colons are not ,...,
expected to adsorb at the interface: F'3 = 0; on the other hand, 1-'3 - A 3 ve 0, see Eq. (1.69). Then the generalization of Eq. (1.91) is
d F i _ D ( Ol Ci Zie o~~ ) ~ + -c dt ~z kT ' o~z
(z =0, t > 0)
i = 1,2.
(1.103)
Note that the supply of surfactant ions to the interface is promoted by the gradient of concentration, Vcl, but it is opposed by the gradient of electric field, V~. The two effects compensate each other in such a way, that the effect of gc~ is slightly predominant (otherwise, there would not be surfactant adsorption). For the conversely charged counterions these tendencies have the opposite direction with a predominant effect of V ~. It is not an easy task to solve the electro-diffusion problem based on Eqs. (1.101)-(1.103). Dukhin et al.
[95-98] have developed a quasi-equilibrium model assuming that the
characteristic diffusion time is much greater than the time of formation of the electrical double layer, and consequently, the electro-diffusion problem is reduced to a mixed barrier-diffusion controlled problem. Bonfillon and Langevin [99] investigated the case of small periodic surface corrugations. MacLeod and Radke [94] obtained numerical solutions of the electro-diffusion problem without taking into account the effect of counterion binding, i.e. the formation of a Stern layer. Analytical results for the long-time asymptotics of adsorption and surface tension have been obtained in Refs. [60,70,100] without making simplifications of the physical model. Assuming
43
Planar Fluid Interfaces
small deviations from equilibrium the adsorption isotherm is linearized and a counterpart of Eq. (1.92) is obtained:
AF i
(t) --r i (t)--
i~
El, e
where Ac. ( t ) - c i , ( t ) - q , ~ ) ,
eA C I s (f)-]-
G~ C2sL
e
1104)
-"
"
i =1,2, are the perturbations in the subsurface concentrations of
surfactant ions and counterions. As usual, the subscript "s" denotes subsurface concentration and the subscript "e" refers to the equilibrium state. We recall that in the case of ionic surfactant two types of adsorptions can be introduced: Fi, which is mostly due to the surfactant ions and counterions immobilized at the interface, and F i - F i + A i which includes also a contribution from the whole diffuse EDL, see Eq. (1.69). Equation (1.104) expresses a local equilibrium between surface and subsurface; such an equation cannot be written for F i , because the latter quantity has a non-local, integral character. The result for the long-time asymptotics of the adsorption relaxation, derived on the basis of Eqs. (1.101)-(1.104), is [60,70] a F , (t) _ E ( t ) - r,,~ _ r ~ r , t AF' i (0) - F; (0) - Fi,e
(t >> r ; , i = 1,2)
(1.105)
where the adsorption relaxation time ri is defined as follows [60,70]" ri -
g~2 + gG2 (,~)
gi,G, (~,) +
(i = 1,2)
(1.106)
P
where ~cis the Debye screening parameter, Eq. (1.64), and the following notation is used"
g = gl,g22 - gl2g2,,
g ji ~ t r
(i,j = 1,2) e
P - I + ~ "2 + ( g l , - g21)~"3 + ( g 2 2 - g ~ 2 ) / ~ ,
--h-
/
1 -7"/ D,
7/ +-D3
11'2 ,
... q-
1
7"/
~" - exp(-~,~,~ / 2)
1
+--+ D2
l-r/ D3
/.'2 ,
7/=
c~ c2~
44
il= 1
for small initial perturbation: Ar,(O) << r,
A = (1 + c-wr,.m+ c,-'
for large initial perturbation:
r,(O)= 0
The above algebraic equations enable one to calculate the relaxation times of surfactant and counterion adsorption.
71 and T?
, using Eq. ( I . 106). From Eqs. (1.74), ( 1 .81), ( I 3 2 ) and the
adsorption isotherms in Table I . 1 (with u r s=cJ one can deduce relatively simple expressions for the coefficients g,, [60]:
4;
J
(1.108)
: -
'I
-
kTT,
Using the expressions for Ec; for the various isotherms in Table 1.2, one can easily calculate
J,, and all coefficients g,l from Eqs. ( I . 107)-( I . 108). The result for the long-time asymptotics of the surface tension relaxation is [60,70]:
( t >> T ~ )
for [urge initial perturbation ( I ,109b)
where the characteristic relaxation time is determined by the expression [70]
w = 2 tanh-
@\.
~
J'l
where, as usual,
2
( 1 . 1 10)
is the equilibrium value of the dimensionless surface potential, cf. Eq.
(1.54) and the relaxation times
51
and
zl are given by Eq. (1,106). It should be noted that
usually A = I and, therefore, the values of T ~ zz , and z, are not so sensitive to the magnitude of
45
Planar Fluid Interfaces
the initial perturbation: small or large. In this respect zl, ~= and ~,~ can be considered as general kinetic properties of the adsorption monolayer from an ionic surfactant [70]. Let us now discuss the similarities and dissimilarities of the adsorption relaxation under diffusion and electro-diffusion control, which correspond to the cases of nonionic and ionic surfactants, respectively. In both cases AFt(t) and Ao-(t) tend to zero proportionally to 1/x/t, cf. Eqs. (1.98), (1.105) and (1.109). Hence, from the fact that the plot of Ao-(t) vs. 1/4~ is linear it is impossible to determine whether the adsorption is under diffusion or electro-diffusion control. The difference is that the slope of this plot depends on the concentration of added salt in the case of electro-diffusion control. Another difference is that for nonionic surfactants the relaxation time is the same for adsorption and surface tension, see Eq. (1.105), whereas for ionic surfactants these relaxation times are different:
vG~ "c~ ~ ~2. The latter difference
originates from the presence of diffuse electric double layer, whose relatively slow relaxation affects stronger ~-,~ than T~ a n d s . To visualize the difference between ~,~, "El and ~h, and to examine their dependence on the concentration of the dissolved salt, below we consider an illustrative example. The values of the parameters/~, F~, K~ and K2 , determined from the fits of the data in Fig. 1.6 (see Section 1.2.5) can be used to calculate the values of all parameters entering Eq. (1.106) and (1.110). Figure 1.9 shows the relaxation times of surface tension, surfactant adsorption and counterion adsorption, zo, L , and z-=, respectively, calculated in this way in Ref. [70]. They are plotted as functions of the surfactant concentration, c1=, for a solution, which does not contain NaCI" c 3 -
0. First of all, one notices the wide range of variation of the relaxation
times, which is 3 - 4 orders of magnitude. In particular, the relaxation time of surface tension, T~, drops from 0.1 s down to 1•
-5 s. Next, one sees that systematically z=<~'l < z ~ the
difference between these three relaxation times can be greater than one order of magnitude for the lower surfactant concentrations. Thus one can conclude that the terms with ~.~.e in Eq. (1.110), which lead to a difference between L and ~-o, play an important vole, especially for the lower surfactant concentrations. Figure 1.9 demonstrates that the approximation v~ =z'~, which is widely used in literature, is applicable only for the higher surfactant concentrations,
46
Chapter 1
1 0 -1
"~ ,...,
"-,, .
10-2
",.\ \
E
._ tO
..
10-a ~2
X
rr
.....-
"
10-4
10-5 2
a
4
5
6
7
10 0
1.5
2
3
4
5
6
7
TSDS concentration (mM)
Fig. 1.9. Relaxation times of surface tension, z,~, of surfactant adsorption, "el, and of counterion adsorption, "c2, calculated in Ref. [70] for surfactant solutions without added salt by means of Eqs. (1.106) and (1.110) as functions of surfactant (TSDS) concentration, c~oo, using parameters values determined from the best fit of the data in Fig. 1.6; a large initial perturbation is assumed. for which "t'o-->'c~. Note also that
V2
keeps always smaller than "c~ and "c,~, that is the
adsorption of counterions relaxes always faster than does the adsorption of surfactant ions and the surface tension. Moreover, r 2 exhibits a non-monotonic behavior (Figure 1.9). The initial increase in "c2 with the rise of the TSDS concentration can be attributed to the fact that the strong increase of the occupancy of the Stern layer, F 2 / F I , with the rise of surfactant concentration (see Fig. 1.8, the curve without salt) leads to a decrease of the surface charge density and a proportional decrease of the driving force of counterion supply, V ~ . To demonstrate the effect of salt on the relaxation time of surface tension, in Fig. 1.10 r~ is plotted vs. Clo~ for a wider range of surfactant concentrations (than that in Fig. 1.9) and for 4 different salt concentrations denoted in the figure. A g a i n , one sees that "c~ varies with many orders of magnitude: from more than 100 s down to 10 -5 s. As seen in Fig. 1.10, the addition of salt (NaC1) accelerates the relaxation of the surface tension for the higher surfactant
47
Planar Fluid Intel~lces
TSDS-water-air
No salt
mM NaCI 50 mM NaCI
20
....... 1 02
~-~.~Qz~:~.~L~.
55.
.........
" *-.~
9
115 mM NaC!
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 01 (/) v
o~
E o
1 0o 1 0-1
..i-.,
to x to
1 0-2
n"
1 0-3
m
(1.1
,
\ ,
\
9
~ 9 9.
,, 9
1 0-4
,~
9
9 9.
,,
...
1 0-5
i I
0-a
i
2
i
i
i
3 4 5
i
i
i ~ J
1 0 -2
l
2
h
L
t
3 4 5
I
i
i
i I
1 0 -1
i
i
2
3 4 5
;
i
t I
100
TSDS concentration (mM)
Fig. 1.10. Relaxation time of surface tension, z',~, vs. surfactant (TSDS) concentration, cj=, calculated in Ref. [70] by means of Eq. (1.110) for four different NaCI concentrations using parameters values determined from the best fit of the data in Fig. 1.6; a large initial perturbation is assumed. concentrations, but decelerates it for the lower surfactant concentrations. This curious inversion of the tendency can be interpreted in the following way. The accelerating effect of salt at the higher surfactant concentrations can be attributed to the suppression of the electric double layer by the added salt. For the lower surfactant concentrations (in the region of Henry) the latter effect is dominated by another effect of the opposite direction. This is the increase of (o~F/c)c,~)c~
due to the added salt. Physically, the effect of (o~F/c?c,~)c~
can be explained
as follows [60]. At low surfactant concentrations the diffusion supply of surfactant is very slow and it controls the kinetics of adsorption. In the absence of salt the equilibrium surfactant adsorption monolayer is comparatively diluted, so the diffusion flux from the bulk is able to
quickly equilibrate the adsorption layer. The addition of salt at low surfactant concentrations strongly increases the equilibrium surfactant adsorption (see Fig. 1.7); consequently, much longer time is needed for the slow diffusion influx to equilibrate the interface (the left-hand side branches of the curves in Fig. 1. I0). More details can be found in Ref. [60,70].
48
Chapter 1
1.3.3.
ADSORPTION UNDER BARRIER CONTROL
The adsorption is under barrier (kinetic) control when the stage of surfactant transfer from the subsurface to the surface is much slower than the diffusion stage because of some kinetic barrier. The latter can be due to steric hindrance, spatial reorientation or conformational changes accompanying the adsorption of the molecules. The electrostatic (double-layer) interaction presents a special case, which is considered in the previous Section 1.3.2. First, we will restrict our considerations to the case of pure barrier control without double layer effects. In such a case the surfactant concentration is uniform throughout the solution, Cl = const., and the increase of the adsorption Fl(t) is solely determined by the "jumps" of the surfactant molecules over the adsorption barrier, separating the subsurface from the surface:
dVl
~ = dt rad s
and
rde s
(1.111)
Q - rads(C,,F~)--rdes(F1)
are the rates of surfactant adsorption and desorption. The concept of barrier-limited
adsorption originate from the works of Bond and Puls [101], and Doss [102]. Further this theoretical model has been developed in Refs. [103-110]. Table 1.4 summarizes the most popular expressions for the total rate of adsorption under barrier control, Q, see Refs. [108112]. The quantities Kads and Kdes in Table 1.4 are the rate constants of adsorption and desorption, respectively. Their ratio gives the equilibrium constant of adsorption K e = Kads / Kdes = lPooK ,
(1.112)
The expression Ke = F=K, is valid for the Henry, Langmuir, Frumkin, Volmer and van der Waals isotherms; likewise, for the Freundlich isotherm Ke --- F=KF; the parameters Foo, K and KF are the same as in Table 1.1. Setting Q = 0 (which corresponds to the equilibrium state of
the system) each expression in Table 1.4 reduces to the respective equilibrium adsorption isotherm given in Table 1.1, as it should be expected. In addition, for
/3
= 0 the Frumkin
expression for Q reduces to the Langmuir expression. For F~ << F= both the Frumkin and Langmuir expressions in Table 1.4 reduce to the Henry expression. Substituting the expressions for Q from Table 1.4 into Eq. (1.111) and integrating one can derive explicit expressions for the relaxation of surfactant adsorption:
49
Planar Fluid Interfaces
Table 1.4. Expressions for the total rate of reversible surfactant adsorption, Q, corresponding to six different kinetic models [110]. Total rate of reversible adsorption
Type of adsorption isotherm
Q - raas (c I ,F 1) - rdes (1-'1)
Henry
Q = K a d s Cl -- gdesF1
Freundlich
Q -- gads Kin-1 c~n - KdesFl
Langmuir
Q = Kad~C, 1 - ~F1 / - gdesFl
Frumkin
F1
exp(- 2/3 F l
/
Volmer Q - KadsC1 -- KdesF1
F~
exp(
roo - r ,
~r~
F1 -r
/
1
)
van der Waals Q-KadsCl-KdesF1 F~F~-F1 exp( F1F~- F 1
2flF1)kT
O'(t)-O'e = Fl(t)-Fl'e = exp(t--~)
a(o)-a~
F, (o)- F,,~
(1.113)
k,-r~
Equation (1.113) holds for Ao(t) = o(t) - oe only in the case of small deviations from equilibrium, whereas there is not such a restriction concerning
AFt(t) = F~(t) - Fl,e" the
relaxation time in Eq. (1.113) is given by the expressions To" _
(Kde s
T o. =
/
)-1
Kde s +
(Henry and Freundlich) KadsCl
F
/'
(Langmuir)
(1.114)
(1.115)
Equation (1.113) predicts that the perturbation of surface tension, Ao-(t) = o(t) - oe, relaxes exponentially. This is an important difference with the cases of adsorption under diffusion and electro-diffusion control, for which Ao'(t) oo 1/47 ,cf. Eqs. (1.98), (1.105) and (1.109). Thus a
50
Chapter 1
test whether or not the adsorption occurs under purely barrier control is to plot data for ln[Ao-(t)] vs. t and to check if the plot complies with a straight line. When the rate of transfer of surfactant molecules from the subsurface to the surface is not-tooslow compared with the rate of diffusion, one deals with the more general case of mixed barrier-diffusion control [110]. In such a case, the "kinetic" boundary condition (1.111) is used
in conjunction with the "diffusion" boundary condition (1.91). Numerical analysis of this process has been performed on the basis of the Henry and Langmuir models [113], and the Frumkin model [111]. Analytical solution of the mixed (diffusion-barrier) problem has been published in Ref. [59] for the case of the Henry isotherm: F 1( t ) - Fj (0)
rl, e - r l (0)
= f(~:,b2)- FU:,b~),
F('c,b) -
1-exp(b 2r)erfc(b ~r}-)
(1.116)
2b x/a 2 - i
where z = Kdest is dimensionless time, b~,2 = ~ + (0~ 2_ 1)~/2 are dimensionless parameters with o~
-
Kads/(4D 1Kdes )1/2 being a dimensionless diffusion-kinetic ratio; the complementary error
function erfc(x) is defined by Eq. (1.95). Equation (1.116) is valid not only for a > 1, but also in the case c~ < 1 (fast diffusion). Despite the fact that in the latter case b~ and b2 become complex numbers, Eq. (1.116) gives real values of Fl(t). In the limit c~ --+ 0 (complete barrier control) Eq. (1.116) reduces to Eqs. (1.113)-(1.114). In fact, Eq. (1.116) describes the transition from diffusion to adsorption control: for a > 1 / ~ -
the diffusion control is
predominant and AF(t) ~: 1/~/7 for t--+~; on the other hand, for o~ < 1 / ~
the barrier control is
predominant and AF(t) decays exponentially for t-->~,. One can estimate the characteristic time of relaxation under mixed diffusion-barrier control by using the following combined expression: ~'o = ~
1 (
o~+
01r -1 11/2)2
(1.117)
For o~ << 1 Eq. (1.117) reduces to the result for barrier control, Eq. (1.114), whereas for o~ >> 1 Eq. (1.117), along with Eq. (1.112), gives the expression for diffusion control, Eq. (1.94), for the Henry isotherm. Other results for the mixed diffusion-barrier problem can be found in Refs. [114-1181.
51
Planar Fluid Interfaces
The case of mixed barrier-electrodiffusion control also deserves some attention insofar as it can be important for the kinetics of adsorption of some ionic surfactants. We will consider the same system as in Section 1.3.2, that is a solution of an ionic surfactant M+S - with added non-amphiphilic salt M+C -. Here S- is the surfactant ion, M + is the counterion and C- is the coion due to the salt. First, let us consider Langmuir-type adsorption, i.e. let us consider the interface as a twodimensional lattice. Further, we will use the notation 00 for the fraction of the free sites in the lattice, 0~ for the fraction of the sites containing adsorbed surfactant ion S-, and 02 for the fraction of the sites containing the complex of adsorbed surfactant ion with a bound counterion. Obviously, one can write 00 + 01 + 02 = 1
(1.1 18)
The adsorptions of surfactant ions and counterions can be expressed in the form: F1/Foo = 01 + 02 ;
F2/F= = 02
(1.1 19)
Following Kalinin and Radke [1 19], let us consider the "reaction" of adsorption of S- ions: A0 + S - = AoS-
(1.120)
where A0 symbolizes an empty adsorption site. In accordance with the rules of the chemical kinetics one can express the rates of adsorption and desorption in the form: rl,ads = Kl,ads00 Cls ,
rl,des = Kl,des01
(1.1 21 )
where, as before, C~s is the subsurface concentration of surfactant; Kl,ads and Kl,des a r e constants. In view of Eqs. (1.1 18)-(1.1 19) one can write 00 = (F~ - FI)/F~ and 01 = (Fl - F2)/F~. Thus, with the help of Eq. (1.121) we obtain the adsorption flux of surfactant: Q! - rl,ads- rl,des = Kl,adsCls(F~,- F I ) / F ~ - Kl,des(Fl -- F2)/F~
(1.122)
Next, let us consider the reaction of counterion binding: AoS-+ M += AoSM
(1.123)
The rates of the straight and the reverse reactions are, respectively, r2,ads --= K2,ads01 C2s,
r2,des ----K2.des02
(1.124)
Chapter 1
52
where g2,ads and g2,des are the respective rate constants, and C2s is the subsurface concentration of counterions. Having in mind that 01 = (F1 - F2)/F= and 02 = F2/F=, with the help of Eq. (1.124) we deduce an expression for the adsorption flux of counterions" Q2 - r2,ads- r2,des = K2,ads C2s(Fl - F 2 ) / F o o - K2,des F2/Foo
(1.125)
Up to here, we have not used simplifying assumptions. If we can assume that the reaction of counterion binding is much faster than the surfactant adsorption, then we can set Q2 - 0, and Eq. (1.125) reduces to the Stern isotherm: F2 F1
-
Kstc2s Kstc2s
Kst -= K2,ads/K2,des
,
(1.126)
1+
Note that Eq. (1.126) is equivalent to Eq. (1.82) with/(st = K2/K~. Next, a substitution of F2 from Eq. (1.126) into Eq. (1.122) yields Q1 - rl,ads- rl,des = Kl,ads Cls(F~- F I ) / F ~ - Kl,des(1 +/(St CZs)-1F1/F~
(1.127)
Equation (1.127) shows that in the adsorption flux of surfactant is influenced by the subsurface concentration of counterions, Czs. If there is equilibrium between surface and subsurface, then we have to set Q1 - 0 in Eq. (1.127), and thus we obtain the Langmuir isotherm for an ionic surfactant:
Kcls = F1/(Foo-
F1),
K-= (Kl,ads/Kl,des)(1 + Kst Czs)
(1.128)
Note that the above expression for the adsorption parameter K is equivalent to Eq. (1.81), with K! = Kl,ads/Kl,des. This result demonstrates that the linear dependence of K on C2s can be deduced from the reactions of surfactant adsorption and counterion binding, Eqs. (1.120) and (1.123). In the case of
Frumkin-type adsorption isotherm an additional effect of interaction between the
adsorbed surfactant molecules is taken into account. Then, instead of Eq. (1.122), one can derive QI - r l , a d s - rl,des = Kl,ads C l s ( F ~ - F l ) / F ~ - fl,des(Fl - Fz)/F~o
(1.129)
where Fl,des depends on Fj, because an adsorbed surfactant molecule "feels" the presence of other adsorbed molecules at the interface. The latter dependence can be expressed as follows
53
Planar Fluid Interfaces
Fl,des -- Kl,desexp I - 2flF~ kT J
(~.130)
see Table 1.4 and Ref. [110].
1.3.4.
ADSORPTION FROM MICELLAR SURFACTANT SOLUTIONS
As known, beyond a given critical micellization concentration (CMC) surfactant aggregates (micelles) appear in the surfactant solutions. In general, the micelles exist in equilibrium with the surfactants monomers in the solution [50,51]. If the concentration of the monomers in the solution is suddenly decreased, the micelles release monomers until the equilibrium concentration, equal to CMC, is restored at the cost of disassembly of a part of the micelles. The relaxation time of this process is usually in the millisecond range. The dilatation of the surfactant adsorption layer leads to a transfer of monomers from the subsurface to the surface, which causes a transient decrease of the subsurface concentration of monomers. The latter is compensated by disintegration of a part of the micelles in the
IIIII 0
0
0
0
0
O
0
demicellization
SUBSURFACE LAYER
v
. . . .
fdi~fusi-'on . . . . . . . . I convection
~di~fiasion" "- " / convection
demicellization ,.-~ O ~ g
BULK
assembly
Fig. 1.11. In the neighborhood of an expanded adsorption monolayer the micelles release monomers to restore the equilibrium surfactant concentration at the surface and in the bulk. The concentration gradients give rise to diffusion of micelles and monomers.
54
Chapter 1
subsurface layer, see Fig. 1.11. This process is accompanied by a diffusion transport of surfactant monomers and micelles due to the appearance of concentration gradients. In general, the micelles serve as a powerful source of monomers which is able to quickly damp any interfacial disturbance. Therefore, the presence of surfactant micelles strongly accelerates the kinetics of adsorption. The theoretical model by Anianson et al. [120-123] describes the micelles as polydisperse aggregates, whose growth or decay happens by exchange of single monomers:
K7 Aj+-->Aj_ 1 +A 1
(/'=2 .....M)
x;
(1.131)
+
Here j denotes the aggregation number of the micelle; K j and K j are rate constants of micelle assembly and disassembly. The general theoretical description of the diffusion in such a solution of polydisperse aggregates taking part in chemical reactions of the type of Eq. (1.131 ) is a heavy task; nevertheless, it has been addressed in several works [ 124-127]. Approximate models, which however account for the major physical effects in the system, also have been developed [ 128-134]. The basis of these models is the experimental fact that the size distribution of the micelles has a well pronounced peak, so they can be described approximately as being monodisperse with a mean aggregation number, m, corresponding to this peak. Other simplification used is to consider small deviations from equilibrium. In this case any reaction mechanism of micelle disassembly gives a linear dependence of the reaction rate on the concentration, i.e. one deals with a reaction of "pseudo-first order". As an example, we give an expression for the relaxation of surface tension of a micellar solution at small initial deviation from equilibrium derived in Ref. [125]:
a(t)-a~
r, ( t ) - r, ~
1
a(o)-a
F, ( 0 ) - F,.~
g, - g2
where E ( g , v )
- g exp(g 2r)erfc(g~-),
(1.132)
Z -- t/Zd.,
g,.2 -- [ l + ~/l + 4 v , / V,,, ] / 2 ,
r, - (OF, / ?c, ; ~ / D, .
(1.133)
55
Planar Fluid Interfaces
"c,,, and z~l are the characteristic relaxation times of micellization and monomer diffusion, see Ref. [135]; K~l is rate constant of micelle decay; as earlier, the subscript "e" refers to the equilibrium state and m is the micelle aggregation number. In the absence of micelles one is to substitute za/z,,,--->O; then gl = 1, g2 = 0, and Eq. (1.132) reduces to Eq. (1.93), as it should be expected. One can estimate the characteristic time of relaxation in the presence of micelles by using the following combined expression: 4za
(1.134)
According to the latter expression zo ~ z,,, for 2~ >> rm and zo~'cj for 2"j << 2"m. Note, that Eq. (1.134) is applicable only for small perturbations. An approximate analytical approach, which is applicable for both small and large deviations from equilibrium, is developed in Ref. [ 134].
1.3.5.
ADSORPTION FROM SOLUTIONS OF PROTEINS
The kinetics of adsorption of proteins and other macromolecules is a complex process, in which several steps, some of them occurring simultaneously, can be conceptually identified [136,137]: (i) transport of the native protein to the interface by diffusion; (ii) adsorptiondesorption from the phase boundary, which can happen under barrier control, see section 1.3.3; (iii) changes in the molecular structure (denaturation) including unfolding and spreading of the molecules over the interface; (iv) rearrangement of some structural groups of the adsorbed protein molecules. Many results accumulated in this field can be found in Refs. [63,138-140]. As an example let us consider a process of protein adsorption including stages (i) and (iii). We denote by F~ and 1-'2 the adsorptions of the native and the denatured protein, respectively. The changes of F1 and F2 due to the denaturation process are equal by magnitude but have opposite signs. Then the interfacial mass balances for the two modifications of protein at the interface take the form [ 141 ]:
--" ~
~ --.
q
C; O
.0
~
0
9
~
"
r
~
~
~,
~
~
.,-
-,
~
~ ~ --.
~ ~"
-
0
=
-.
~ ~
~.
o_
O
=r
~
ON
~
~"
,-i
~
~
'-~ =~"
:
0
:::::1
0
~
_0 , .
~-<. ~
~
~ m"
~"
~ I~
r~
~L
~"
E
B
9
=r
O
0
~ ~ ..
O
~
--"
m
~
~-
t,a
~
4~
~,
F
III
I
~
4~
~ ~
O
9
~
I
'-~
~
II
I>
~
._.
+
~
o
. e~
~~ II
-
~
-,.
4~
'o' II
~
~
~.
.
o
~..,. ~
=..
9
~- . m
9
~
~-~
~
-a
~.
=;" ~
"
~
~ ;~
I
I .-
-
I
I
L/I
Planar Fluid Interfaces
57
order of micrometers because of the formation of a diffuse electric double layer in a vicinity of the phase boundary. In the latter case the interfacial tension (and the bending moment as well) can be expressed as a sum of a double-layer and a non-double-layer contribution, Eq. (1.19). The thermodynamics of fluid interfaces describes how the composition in the bulk of solution determines the composition at the phase boundary and the interfacial tension. Various surfactant adsorption isotherms can be used to process experimental data; the most popular of them are listed in Table 1.1, where the respective surface tension isotherms are also shown. In the case of solutions of ionic surfactants two types of adsorptions can be introduced: F~, which represents a surface excesses of component "i" with respect to the uniform bulk solution, and Fi representing a surface excess with respect to the non-uniform diffuse electric double layer, see Eq. (1.69). Correspondingly, the Gibbs adsorption equation for a charged interface can be expressed in two equivalent forms, Eqs. (1.68) and (1.70). Not only surfactant ions, but also counterions, do adsorb at the interface; the counterionic adsorption can be described by the Stern isotherm, Eq. (1.82), which is thermodynamically compatible with the surfactant adsorption isotherms (Table 1.1) if only Eq. (1.81) is satisfied. The occupancy of the Stern layer by adsorbed counterions could rise up to 70 - 80 % (Fig. 1.8) and should not be neglected. The double-layer contribution to the interfacial tension depends on the valence of the electrolyte, see Table 1.3. The value of the Gibbs elasticity, Ec, of an adsorption layer determines whether the interface behaves as a two-dimensional fluid or as an elastic body. This rheological behavior can strongly influence the attachment of a particle to an interface, as well as the capillary forces between attached particles. Definitions for Gibbs elasticity of adsorption layers from non-ionic and ionic surfactants are presented and discussed, see Eqs. (1.45), (1.88) and Table 1.2. For soluble surfactants the effect of the Gibbs elasticity can be suppressed by the diffusive supply of surfactant to an expanding interface; the diffusion tends to render the interface more fluid. Thus one can estimate whether or not the effect of Gibbs elasticity will show up by a comparison of the characteristic adsorption relaxation time with the characteristic time of the specific process. Expressions for the relaxation time of surface tension, v•, are presented for the cases of adsorption kinetics under diffusion control: Eq. (1.94); electro-diffusion control:
58
Chapter 1
Eq. ( 1.110); barrier control: Eqs. (1.114)-(1.115), mixed diffusion-barrier control: Eq. (1.117), adsorption from micellar solutions, Eq. (1.134), and adsorption from protein solutions, see Eq. (1.140). The quantities introduced in Chapter 1, and the relationships between them, are important for the theoretical description of the particle-interface interaction and the particleparticle capillary forces, as this will be seen in the next chapters.
1.5.
REFERENCES
I.
L.D. Landau, E.M. Lifshitz, Fluid Mechanics, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1984.
2.
S. Ono, S. Kondo, Molecular theory of surface tension in liquids, in: S. Fltigge (Ed.), Handbuch der Physik, vol. 10, Springer, Berlin, 1960, p. 134.
3.
J.S. Rowlinson, B. Widom, Molecular Theory of Capillarity, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1982.
.
.
.
.
~
.
J.W. Gibbs, The Scientific Papers of J.W. Gibbs, vol. 1, Dover, New York, 1961. G. Bakker, Kapillarit~it und Oberfl~ichenspannung, in: Handbuch der Experimentalphysik, Band 6, Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft, Leipzig, 1928. F.P. Buff, J. Chem. Phys. 19 (1951) 1591. I.W. Plesner, O. Platz, J. Chem. Phys. 48 (1968) 5361. C.A. Croxton, R.P. Ferrier, (1971), J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 4 (1971) 2433. A.I. Rusanov, E.N. Brodskaya, Kolloidn. Zh. 39 (1977) 646.
10. T.D. Gurkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, Colloids Surf. 56 (1991) 119. 11. T.D. Gurkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, Colloids Surf. 47 (1990) 45. 12. A. Graciaa, G. Morel, P. Saulnier, J. Lachaise, R.S. Schechter, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 172 (1995) 131. 13. K. Marinova, R. Alargova, N. Denkov, O. Velev, D. Petsev, I.B. Ivanov, R.P. Borwankar, Langmuir 12 (1996) 2045. 14. J.Th.G. Overbeek, Electrochemistry of the Double Layer, in: H.R. Kruyt (Ed.), Colloid Science, Vol. 1, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1953; J. Colloid Sci. 8 (1953) 420. 15. G. Gouy, J. Phys. Radium 9 (1910) 457. 16. D.L. Chapman, Phil. Mag. 25 (1913) 475. 17. O. Stern, Ztschr. Elektrochem. 30 (1924) 508.
Planar Fluid Interfaces
59
18. L.D. Landau, E.M. Lifshitz, Electrodynamics of Continuous Medium, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1960. 19. S. Hachisu, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 33 (1970) 445. 20. P.A. Kralchevsky, K.D. Danov, G. Broze, A. Mehreteab, Langmuir 15 (1999) 2351. 21. L.D. Landau, E.M. Lifshitz, Theory of Elasticity, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1970. 22. A.I. Rusanov, Phase Equilibria and Surface Phenomena, Khimia, Leningrad, 1967 (in Russian); Phasengleichgewichte und Grenzfl~ichenerscheinungen, Akademie Verlag, Berlin, 1978. 23. J.G. Kirkwood, I. Oppenheim, Chemical Thermodynamics, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1961. 24. L. Boruvka, A.W. Neumann, J. Chem. Phys. 66 (1977) 5464. 25. M.J. Schick, Nonionic Surfactants: Physical Chemistry, M. Dekker, New York, 1986. 26. I. Langmuir, J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 15 (1918) 75. 27. T.L. Hill, An Introduction to Statistical Thermodynamics, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1962. 28. M. Volmer, Z. Physikal. Chem. 115 (1925) 253. 29. A. Frumkin, Z. Physikal. Chem. 116 (1925) 466. 30. L.D. Landau, E.M. Lifshitz, Statistical Physics, Part 1, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1980. 31. T.D. Gurkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, K. Nagayama, Colloid Polym. Sci. 274 (1996) 227. 32. E.H. Lucassen-Reynders, J. Phys. Chem. 70 (1966) 1777. 33. R.P. Borwankar, D.T. Wasan, Chem. Eng. Sci. 43 (1988) 1323. 34. B.V. Derjaguin, Theory of Stability of Colloids and Thin Films, Plenum, Consultants Bureau, New York, 1989. 35. E.D. Shchukin, A.V. Pertsov, E.A. Amelina, Colloid Chemistry, Moscow University Press, Moscow, 1982 [in Russian]. 36. Y. Tian, R.G. Holt, R. Apfel, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 187 (1997) 1. 37. R.A. Robinson, R.H. Stokes, Electrolyte Solutions; Butterworths, London, 1959. 38. J.T. Davies, E.K. Rideal, Interracial Phenomena; Academic Press, London, 1963. 39. J.T. Davies, Proc. Roy. Soc. Set. A, 208 (1951) 224. 40. D.G. Hall, in: D.M. Bloor, E. Wyn-Jones (Eds.) The Structure, Dynamics and Equilibrium Properties of Colloidal Systems, Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1990; p. 857. 41. D.G. Hall, Colloids Surf. A, 90 (1994) 285.
60
Chapter 1
42. K. Tajima, M. Muramatsu, T. Sasaki, Bul. Chem. Soc. Japan 43 (1970) 1991. 43. K. Tajima, Bul. Chem. Soc. Japan 43 (1970) 3063. 44. K. Tajima, Bul. Chem. Soc. Japan 44 (1971) 1767. 45. A.W. Cross, G.G. Jayson, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 162 (1994) 45. 46. S.B. Johnson, C.J. Drummond, P.J. Scales, S. Nishimura, Langmuir 11 (1995) 2367. 47. R.G. Alargova, K.D. Danov, J.T. Petkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, G. Broze, A. Mehreteab, Langmuir 13 (1997) 5544. 48. J.F. Rathman, J.F. Scamehorn, J. Phys. Chem. 88 (1984) 5807. 49. S.S. Bert, M.J. Coleman, J. Marriot, J.S. Johnson Jr., J. Phys. Chem. 90 (1986) 6492. 50. M.J. Rosen, Surfactants and Interfacial Phenomena, Wiley, New York, 1989. 51. J. Clint, Surfactant Aggregation, Chapman & Hall, London, 1992. 52. R.G. Alargova, K.D. Danov, P.A. Kralchevsky, G. Broze, A. Mehreteab, Langmuir 14 (1998) 4036. 53. K. Bijma, E. Rank, J.B.F.N. Engberts, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 205 (1998) 245. 54. R.J. Hunter, Zeta Potential in Colloid Science, Academic Press, New York, 1981. 55. R.G. Alargova, I.Y. Vakarelsky, V.N. Paunov, S.D. Stoyanov, P.A. Kralchevsky, A. Mehreteab, G. Broze, Langmuir 14 (1998) 1996. 56. J. Mingins, D. Stigter, K.A. Dill, Biophys. J. 61 (1992) 1603. 57. A. Ozawa, A. Minamisawa, K. Sakai, K. Takagi, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 33 (1994) L-1468. 58. S.S. Dukhin, G. Kretzschmar, R. Miller, Dynamics of Adsorption at Liquid Interfaces, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1995. 59. K.D. Danov, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, " Equilibrium and Dynamics of Surfactant Adsorption Monolayers and Thin Liquid Films", in: G. Broze (Ed.) Handbook of Detergents, Vol. 1: Properties, M. Dekker, New York, 1998. 60. K.D. Danov, P.M. Vlahovska, P.A. Kralchevsky, G. Broze, A. Mehreteab, Colloids Surf. A 156 (1999) 389. 61. A.I. Rusanov, V.A. Prokhorov, Interfacial Tensiometry, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1996. 62. E.I. Franses, O.A. Basaran, and C.-H. Chang, Curr. Opinion Colloid Interface Sci. 1 (1996) 296. 63. D. M6bius, R. Miller (Eds.), Proteins at Liquid Interfaces, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1998. 64. P. Joos, Dynamic Surface Phenomena, VSP BV, AH Zeist, The Netherlands, 1999. 65. K.L. Sutherland, Austr. J. Sci. Res. A5 (1952) 683.
Planar Fluid Interfaces
61
66. A.F.H. Ward, L. Tordai, J. Chem. Phys. 14 (1946) 453. 67. M. Abramowitz, I.A. Stegun, Handbook of Mathematical Functions, Dover, New York, 1965. 68. G.A. Korn, T.M. Korn, Mathematical Handbook, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1968. 69. R.S. Hansen, J. Chem. Phys. 64 (1960) 637. 70. K.D. Danov, V.L. Kolev, P.A. Kralchevsky, G. Broze, A. Mehreteab, Langmuir 16 (2000) 2942. 71. Lord Rayleigh, Proc. Roy. Soc. (London), 29 (1879) 71. 72. N. Bohr, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. (London) Ser. A, 209 (1909) 281. 73. R. Delay, and G. P6tr6, Dynamic surface tension, in: E. Matijevic (Ed.) Surface and Colloid Science, Vol. 3, Wiley, New York, 1971, p. 27. 74. R. Miller, G. Kretzschmar, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 37 (1991) 97. 75. K.-D. Wantke, K. Lunkenheimer, C. Hempt, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 159 (1993) 28. 76. C.-H. Chang, E. I. Franses, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 164 (1994) 107. 77. D.O. Johnson, K. J. Stebe, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 182 (1996) 525. 78. T. Horozov, L. Arnaudov, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 219 (1999) 99. 79. T. Horozov, L. Arnaudov, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 222 (2000) 146. 80. M. van den Tempel, E.H. Lucassen-Reynders, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 18 (1983) 281. 81. D. Langevin, Colloids Surf. 43 (1990) 121. 82. C. Lemaire, D. Langevin, Colloids Surf. 65 (1992) 101. 83. D.O. Grigorev, V.V. Krotov, B.A. Noskov, Colloid J. 56 (1994) 562. 84. K.J. Mysels, Colloids Surf. 43 (1990) 241. 85. P.A. Kralchevsky, Y.S. Radkov, N.D. Denkov, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 161 (1993) 361. 86. V.B. Fainerman, R. Miller, P. Joos, Colloid Polym. Sci. 272 (1994) 731. 87. V.B. Fainerman, R. Miller, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 176 (1995) 118. 88. T.S. Horozov, C.D. Dushkin, K.D. Danov, L.N. Arnaudov, O.D. Velev, A. Mehreteab, G. Broze, Colloids Surf. A, 113 (1996) 117. 89. R. van den Bogaert, P. Joos, J. Phys. Chem. 83 (1979) 17. 90. D. M6bius, R. Miller (Eds.) "Drops and Bubbles in Interfacial Research", Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1998. 91. C. Jho, and R. Burke, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 95 (1983) 61.
62 92. P. Joos, J. van Hunsel, Colloid Polym. Sci. 267 (1989) 1026. 93. V.B. Fainerman, R. Miller, Colloids Surf. A. 97 (1995) 255. 94. C. MacLeod, C. Radke, Langmuir 10 (1994) 3555. 95. S. Dukhin, R. Miller, G. Kretzschmar, Colloid Polym. Sci. 261 (1983) 335. 96. S. Dukhin, R. Miller, G. Kretzschmar, Colloid Polym. Sci. 263 (1985) 420 97. S. Dukhin, R. Miller, Colloid Polym. Sci. 269 (1991) 923. 98. S. Dukhin, R. Miller, Colloid Polym. Sci. 272 (1994) 548. 99. A. Bonfillon, D. Langevin, Langmuir 10 (1994) 2965. 100.P.M. Vlahovska, K.D. Danov, A. Mehreteab, G, Broze, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 192 (1997) 194. 101.W.N. Bond, H.O. Puls, Phil. Mag. 24 (1937) 864.
102.K.S.G. Doss, Koll. Z. 84 (1938) 138. 103. S. Ross, Am. Chem. SOC.67 (1945) 990. 104.C.M. Blair, J. Chem. Phys. 16 (1948) 113. 105. A.F.H. Ward, Surface Chemistry, London, 1949. 106. R.S. Hansen, T. Wallace, J. Phys. Chem. 63 (19.59) 108.5.
107. D.G. Dervichian. Koll. Z. 146 (1956) 96. 108. J.F. Baret, J. Phys. Chem. 72 (1968) 275.5.
109. J.F. Baret, J. Chem. Phys. 65 (1968) 89.5. 110. J.F. Baret, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 30 (1969) I. I 1 1 . R.P. Borwankar, D.T. Wasan, Chem. Eng. Sci. 38 (1983) 1637. 1 12. L.K. Filippov, J. Colloid Interface Sci. I64 ( 1994) 47 I .
1 13. R. Miller, G. Kretzschmar, Colloid Polym. Sci. 258 ( 1 980) 8.5.
114. C. Tsonopoulos, J. Newman, J.M. Prausnitz, Chem. Eng. Sci. 26 (1971) 817
115. A. Yousef, B.J. McCoy, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 94 (1983) 497. 116. Z. Adamczyk, and J. Petlocki, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 118 (1987) 20.
I 17. Z. Adamczyk, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 120 (1987) 477.
I 18. J. Balbaert, P. Joos, Colloids Surf. 23 ( 1987) 259.
I 19. V.V. Kalinin, C.J. Radke, Colloids Surf. A, 1 14 (1996) 337.
Planar Fluid Interfaces
63
120. E.A.G. Aniansson, S.N. Wall, J. Phys. Chem. 78 (1974) 1024. 121. E.A.G. Aniansson, S.N. Wall, J. Phys. Chem. 79 (1975) 857. 122. E.A.G. Aniansson, S.N. Wall, in: E. Wyn-Jones (Ed.) Chemical and Biological Applications of Relaxation Spectrometry, Reidel, Dordrecht, 1975, p. 223. 123. E.A.G. Aniansson, S.N. Wall, M. Almgren, H. Hoffmann, I. Kielmann, W. Ulbricht, R. Zana, J. Lang, C. Tondre, J. Phys. Chem. 80 (1976) 905. 124. C. D. Dushkin, I. B. Ivanov, Colloids Surf. 60 (1991) 213. 125. C. D. Dushkin, I. B. Ivanov, P. A. Kralchevsky, Colloids Surf. 60 (1991) 235. 126. B. A. Noskov, Kolloidn Zh. 52 (1990) 509. 127. B. A. Noskov, Kolloidn Zh. 52 (1990) 796. 128. D. H. McQueen, and J. J. Hermans, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 39 (1972) 389. 129. J. Lucassen, J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. 172 (1976) 76. 130. R. Miller, Colloid Polym. Sci. 259 (1981) 1124. 131. R. H. Weinheimer, D. F. Evans, and E. L. Cussler, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 80 (1981) 357. 132. D.E. Evans, S. Mukherjee, D.J. Mitchell, B.W. Ninham, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 93 (1983) 184. 133. P. Joos, L. van Hunsel, Colloids Surf. 33 (1988) 99. 134. K.D. Danov, P.M. Vlahovska, T. Horozov, C.D. Dushkin, P.A. Kralchevsky, A. Mehreteab, G. Broze, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 183 (1996) 223. 135. G.C. Kresheck, E. Hamori, G. Davenport, and H.A. Scheraga, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 88 (1966) 264. 136. E. Tornberg, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 64 (1978) 3. 137. J.D. Aptel, A. Carroy, P. Dejardin, E. Pefferkorn, P. Schaaf, A. Schmitt, R. Varoqui, J.C. Voegel, in: J.L. Brash and T.A. Horbett (Eds.) Proteins at Interfaces: Physicochemical and Biochemical Studies, ACS Publications, Washington, DC, 1987. 138. J.D. Andrade (Ed.) Surface and Inteffacial Aspects of Biomedical Polymers, Vol. 2: Protein Adsorption, Plenum Press, New York, 1985. 139. J.L. Brash and T.A. Horbett (Eds.) Proteins at Interfaces: Physicochemical and Biochemical Studies, ACS Publications, Washington, DC, 1987. 140. R. Miller, V.B. Fainerman, A.V. Makievski, J. Kr~gel, D.O. Gfigoriev, V.N. Kazakov, O.V. Sinyachenko, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 86 (2000) 39. 141. G. Semen, G. Geeraerts, P. Joos, Colloids Surf. 68 (1992) 219.
64
CHAPTER 2 INTERFACES OF MODERATE CURVATURE: THEORY OF CAPILLARITY
This chapter gives a brief presentation of the conventional theory of capillarity, which is based on the Laplace and Young equations, and neglects such effects as interfacial bending moment and curvature elastic moduli (the latter effects are subject of the next Chapter 3). The Laplace equation is derived by a force balance per unit area of a curved interface, as well as by means of a variational method. Various forms of Laplace equation are presented depending on the symmetry of the phase boundaries. Special attention is paid to the physically and practically important case of axisymmetric interfaces. Equations are given, which describe the shape of sessile and pendant drops, of the fluid interface around a vertical cylinder, floating solid or fluid particle, hole in a wetting film, capillary "bridges", Plateau borders in foams, the profile of the free surface of a fluid particle or biological cell pressed between two plates, etc. The values of the contact angles subtended between three intersecting surfaces are determined by the force balance at the contact line, which is given by the Young and Neumann equations. It is demonstrated that these equations (likewise the Laplace equation) can be derived by variation of the thermodynamic potential. The rule how to calculate the net force exerted on a particle at an interface is discussed. Linear excess energy (line tension) can be ascribed to a contact line. When the contact line is curved, the line tension gives a contribution to the Young and Neumann equations. The presence of line tension effect is indicated by dependence of the contact angle on the curvature of the contact line. The contact angles can vary also due to the phenomenon hysteresis, which is considered in relation to the line tension effect. The chapter represents a basis for most of the subsequent chapters since the subjects of first importance in this book are the shapes of the menisci around attached particles, the shapes of fluid particles approaching an interface, the balances of forces exerted on particles at interfaces, and various kinds of capillary forces.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature." Theor3, of CapillariO,
2.1.
THE LAPLACE EQUATION OF CAPILLARITY
2.1.1.
LAPLACE EQUATION FOR SPHERICAL INTERFACE
65
Let us consider a spherical interface between two fluid phases (spherical liquid drop or gas bubble). In Fig. 2.1 Pl and P2 denote the inner and outer pressure, respectively; R is the radius of the spherical dividing surface (defined as the surface of tension) and o- is the interfacial tension. Let us make the balance of all forces exerted on a small segment of the dividing surface situated around its intersection point with the z-axis (Fig. 2.1) and corresponding to a central angle 0. The area of this segment is A(O) = 2rtR2(1 - cos0) = 71;R202
(0 << 1)
(2.1)
(0 << 1)
(2.2)
The length of the circumference encircling this segment is L(0) = 2rtRsin 0 = 2rtR 0
Then the balance of the forces acting on the segment, resolved along the z-axis, reads: P1A(O) = P2 A(O) + (o"sin0)L(O)
(2.3)
The left-hand side of Eq. (2.3) represents the force directed upwards, whereas the right-hand side expresses the forces acting downwards (Fig. 2.1); these forces should counterbalance each other for an equilibrium interface. Substituting Eqs. (2.1) and (2.2) into Eq. (2.3), and carrying out the transition 0--->0, one obtains the Laplace equation of capillarity for a spherical interface
[1]: 2o
~ = P ~ -P2 R
(2.4)
Equation (2.4) shows that the pressure exhibits a jump, Pc = PI - P2
(2.5)
across a spherical interface; Pc is called capillary pressure, or Laplace pressure. In the limit R---~0 (planar interface) Eq. (2.4) yields P~ - P2, as this must be for a flat dividing surface, see
Chapter 2
66
i Rsin0..
.......... ~- . . . . . . . ,~,,
P~
'~c~sinO
~O ~ J R
~sinO,
-
|
!
\
/ \
/ N
/ \
%
l
Fig. 2.1. Balance of forces exerted on a segment of spherical interface or membrane of tension cr and radius R; the segment is encompassed by the circumference of radius Rsin0, where 0 is a central angle; P~ and P2 denote the inner and outer pressure, respectively. Section 1.1. The above purely hydrostatic derivation of the Laplace equation reveals its physical meaning: it expresses the normal force balance per unit area of the interface. Below we proceed with the derivation of the form of Laplace equation for an arbitrarily curved interface.
2.1.2.
GENERAL FORM OF LAPLACE EQUATION
Derivation by minimization of the grand potential. Let
us consider a two-phase fluid
system confined in a box of volume V, see Fig. 2.2. The volumes of the two phases are V~ and V2 ; we have Vz + V2 = V. We assume also that the chemical potentials of all components in the system are kept constant. Then the equilibrium state of the system corresponds to a minimum of the grand thermodynamic potential, s [2-4]:
f 2 - - I P l d V - IP2dV+crA v~
(2.6)
v2
where A is the area of the interface; the pressures P~ and P2 depend on the vertical coordinate z due to the effect of gravity:
Interfaces o f Moderate Curvature: Theoo, of CapillariO,
67
phase 2 9
V1
phase 1 0
x
Fig. 2.2. Sketch of a two-phase system composed of phases 1 and 2, which occupy volumes V~ and V2, respectively; z = u(x,y) is the equation of the phase boundary.
PI(Z) =
Plo-
(2.7)
P2(z) = P 2 0 - p 2 g z ,
plgz,
PI0 and P20 are constants, p~ and P2 are the mass densities of the two neighboring fluids, and g is the acceleration due to gravity. Let z =
u(x,y)
to be the equation describing the shape of the
interface. Then the area of the interface is A-
f dx ~x/ 1-1- U2x + U2 , ~0
Ux - -
, au ax
U,. ----
A0 is the projection of the interface on the coordinate plane
(2.8)
au oN
xy.
In addition, one derives
u(x,y)
b
(2.9) v~
Ao
o
v~
Ao
u( x, y )
where z = 0 and z - b are the lower and the upper side of the box (Fig. 2.2). The substitution of Eqs. (2.8) and (2.9) into Eq. (2.6) yields
f2 - ~dxdyL(u(x, y),ux(x, y),u, (x, y))
(2.10)
Ao
where
L(u,ux,u,)-- P,(z)&- P2(z)&+~ l+u~ +u ~ 0
u
(2.11)
68
Chapter 2
Equations (2.10) and (2.11) show that the grand potential f2 depends as a functional on the interfacial shape u(x,y). Then the necessary condition for minimum of f2 is given by the known Euler equation [5,6]" cgL
o~ cgL
cg u
O x O ux
O cgL ~ ~ = 0
(2.12)
O y cg u Y
Differentiating Eq. (2.11) one obtains cgL
~9u = -P1(u) + P2 (u)
(2.13)
Next, differentiating Eq. (2.1 l) one can derive O cgL 03 o~L ~ ~ + ~ ~ = 2 H o
Ox cgux
(2.14)
O y OUy
where we have used the notation
2H -VII 9I
Vn u
(2.15)
I
~/1 + IgllU] 2
VII
9 ~e
X
0
(2.16)
=--Ox+ey 0 y
Here VII is the two-dimensional gradient operator in the plane xy; H defined by Eq. (2.15) is a basic quantity in differential geometry, which is termed mean curvature of the surface [5,7,8]. Note that Eq. (2.15) is expressed in a covariant form and can be specified for any type of curvilinear coordinates in the plane xy (not only Cartesian ones). Substituting Eqs. (2.13) and (2.14) into Eq. (2.12) we obtain a general form of Laplace equation of capillarity [ 1]" 2Her = P2(u) - Pl(U)
(Laplace equation)
(2.17)
When the pressures Pl and P2 are dependent on the position in space, as it is in Eq. (2.7), their values at the interface enter the Laplace equation; in such a case the capillary pressure, P c -
Pl(u)
-
P2(u), varies throughout the interface.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature." Theory of Capillarity
69
Various forms of Laplace equation. The mean curvature can be expressed through the two principle radii of curvature of the surface, R1 and R2 [5,7]"
. . . . +~ 2 R~ R 2
(2.18)
Combining Eqs. (2.17) and (2.18) one obtains another popular form of Laplace equation [9]:
O" ~ + ~ R1 R2
= P l ( u ) - P2(u)
(Laplace equation)
(2.19)
For a spherical interface the two principal radii of curvature are equal, R1 = R2 = R, and then Eq. (2.19) reduces to Eq. (2.4). The original form of Eq. (2.17), published by Laplace in 1805, can be obtained if the right-hand side of Eq. (2.15) is expressed in Cartesian coordinates and the differentiation is carried out [1 ]" + Uy Uxx --
(1
UxUy +
+ Ux U)9,
2+//2)3/2
+Ux
= [P2(u) - Pl(u)]/c~
(2.20)
y
Here uxx, Uxy and Uyy denote the respective second derivatives of u(x,y). One sees that in general the Laplace equation, Eq. (2.20), is a second order non-linear partial differential equation for determining the shape of the fluid phase boundary, u(x,y). The way we derived Eq. (2.20) shows that its solution, u(x,y), minimizes the grand thermodynamic potential, ~2, and consequently, corresponds to the state of mechanical equilibrium of the system. For interfaces of rotational or translational symmetry Eq. (2.20) reduces to an ordinary differential equation (see below), which is much easier to solve. If the curved interface in Fig. 2.2 has translational symmetry along the y-axis, i.e. z = u(x), then Uy = 0, Uxy= Uyy- 0, and Eq. (2.20) reduces to: u .~:~. 2 )3/2
= (P2 - Pl)/O"
(translational symmetry)
(2.21)
l+u x
If the curved interface has rotational symmetry around the z-axis (axial symmetry), then it is convenient to introduce polar coordinates (r, q3) in the plane xy. Due to the axial symmetry the
70
Chapter 2
equation of the interface has the form z = u(r). Then introducing polar coordinates in Eq. (2.15) one can bring Eq. (2.17) into the form [10]"
l d l r u r l = ( P 22) - P1/2 l)/cYO rdr +u r
(rotational symmetry)
(2.22)
where Ur -- du/dr. Sometimes it is more convenient to work in terms of the inverse function of z = u(r), that is r = r(z). In such a case Eq. (2.22) can be transformed in an equivalent form [10,11]: ~, 1 192 - Pl (1 + re2) 3/2 + r ( l + r z2) 1/2 = ~ ' 0 . .
dr q - dz '
d 2r ~ - dz-"
(2.23)
Two equivalent parametric forms of Laplace equation are often used for analytical and numerical calculations [ 10,11 ]: dsinq~ dr
t
sinq~ r
=
Pc G
,
dz tan(p = _ + ~ dr
(2.24)
(the angle q9can be defined with both positive or negative sign) and d(p ds
=
Pc o
sinq9 , r
dr ~ = cosq~, ds
dz ds
= sinrp
(2.25)
Here q) is the meniscus running slope angle and s is the arc length along the generatrix of the meniscus z = z(r); Pc is the capillary pressure defined by Eq. (2.7)" the sign of Pc is to be specified for every given interface. Equations (2.25) represent a set of three equations for determining the functions (,0(s), r(s) and z(s), which is especially convenient for numerical integration [11]" note that Eq. (2.24) may create numerical problems at the points with tan(p = _+~,, like the points on the "equator" of the fluid particle in Fig. 2.3. The Laplace equation can be generalized to account for such effects as the interfacial bending elasticity and shearing tension" such a generalization is important for interfaces and membranes of low tension and high curvature and can be used to describe the configurations of red blood cells, see Chapters 3 and 4.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theoo' of CapillariO'
71
Z.
phase 3
| w(r)
....... I ..... "
[
\
l
R ..........
3u(r)
o
Fig. 2.3. Cross-section of a light fluid particle (bubble or droplet) from Phase l, which is attached to the boundary between Phases 2 and 3. The equations of the boundaries between phases 1-2, 13 and 2-3 are denoted by u(r), v(r) and w(r), respectively; (Pc, 0 and gtc are slope angles of the respective phase boundaries at the contact line, which intersects the plane of the drawing in the point (rc,zc); ~ r ) is a running slope angle; R is "equatorial" radius and Rs is the curvature radius of the surface v(r), which can be a thin film of Phase 2, intervening between Phases 1 and 3.
2.2.
AXISYMMETRIC FLUID INTERFACES
Very often the boundaries between two fluid phases (the capillary menisci) have rotational (axial) symmetry. An example is the fluid particle (drop or bubble) attached below an interface, I
lhr
II
er Fig. 2.4. Menisci formed by the liquid around two vertical coaxial cylinders of radii R1 and R2: (I) Meniscus meeting the axis of revolution; (II) Meniscus decaying at infinity; (III) Meniscus confined between the two cylinders; hr is the capillary rise in the inner cylinder; hc and gtc are the elevation and the slope angle of Meniscus II at the contact line r = R2.
Chapter 2
72
which is depicted in Fig. 2.3: all interfaces, u(r), v(r) and w(r), have axial symmetry. In general, there are three types of axially symmetric menisci corresponding to the three regions denoted in Fig. 2.4: (I) Meniscus meeting the axis of revolution, (ll) Meniscus decaying at infinity, and (Ill) Meniscus confined between two cylinders, 0
2.2.1.
MENISCUS MEETING THE AXIS OF REVOLUTION
The interfaces u(r) and v(r) in Fig. 2.3 belong to this type of menisci, as well as the interfaces of floating lenses and any kind of sessile or pendant drops/bubbles. Such a meniscus is a part of a sphere when the effect of gravity is negligible, that is when the capillary (or Bond) number is small:
~c - gb2AP ~or << 1
(2.26)
Here, as usual, g is the acceleration due to gravity, Ap is the magnitude of the difference in the mass densities of the two fluids and b is a characteristic radius of the meniscus curvature. For example, if Eq. (2.26) is satisfied with b = Rl, see Region I in Fig. 2.4, the capillary rise, hr, of the liquid in the inner cylinder is determined by means of the equation [ 13]
hr = (20"cosO0/(Ap g RI)
(2.27)
a is a contact angle which can be both acute and obtuse, depending on whether the inner surface of the cylinder is hydrophilic or hydrophobic; in the case o~ > 90 ~ hr becomes negative and the inner meniscus is situated below the level of the outer liquid far from the cylinders in Fig. 2.4. To obtain the equations for the shape of the lower interface, u(r), of the fluid particle in Fig. 2.3 let us fix the coordinate origin at the bottom of the particle. Combining Eqs. (2.5), (2.7), (2.24) and (2.26) one can obtain the Laplace equation in the form: dsinq9 sinq9 2 fic ~ + ~ = -+e z, dr r b -b-y-
tanq9 . . . .
dz dr
b-
20~ Pl0 -P20
(2.28)
Here b is the radius of curvature at the bottom of the bubble (drop) surface, where z = 0, see Fig 2.3; the parameter e takes values +1. For sessile type drops or bubbles the mass density of the
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
73
fluid particle (Phase 1) is smaller than that of Phase 2, Pl < P2, and e = +1; for pendant type drops/bubbles Pl >/)2 and e = -1. The definition of the sign of tan(p in Eq. (2.28) leads to (p = n:
at
z = 0.
(2.29)
Equations (2.28) allow one to determine the meniscus profile in a parametric form, that is r = r((p) and z = z(q~). Let us consider three cases corresponding to different values of the capillary number tic.
(i) No gravity deformation: /3c = 0. Such is the case of small fluid particles (drops, bubbles) for which the gravitational deformation can be neglected. In this case the only solution of the Laplace equation, Eq. (2.28), is a spherical meniscus: r((p) = sinq~ b
9
z(q~) b
= 1 + cos(p.
(2.30)
If the boundaries of small fluid particles or biological cells have a shape, which is different from spherical, this is an indication about the presence of an effect of the interfacial (membrane) bending elasticity, see Chapter 3.
(ii) Small gravity deformation:/~c << 1. In this case the solution of Eq. (2.28) can be obtained as truncated asymptotic expansions with respect to the powers of/3c, see Ref. [ 14]:
r((P----~) =sinq~+eb/3c
[i3
+/3c2 7 + T c ~
( ~ c o t ~(P-+sin2(p --21sin(p]
2in2 ,asian/ l/ q~-7
~
sinq~-
z((p) = l + c o s q g + s f l c I3 sin2q)+72 lnsin (p 2 -7'
(2.31) l+-~cot2~
(1 + cos(p)]
cot
(15~
~
(2.32)
For /3c--+0 Eqs. (2.31) and (2.32) reduce to Eq. (2.30). Equations (2.31) and (2.32) are applicable with a good accuracy for 15~ (p < 180 ~ see Refs. [14,15] for details. In the case when 0~
q~ < 15 ~ instead of Eqs. (2.31) and (2.32) one can use the following asymptotic
expansions [14,15]:
74
Chapter 2
r = P-
_z
b
27p 7 + 108eflcP 5 + 144/~2P 3 -8e,~i~P 2 54(3p 4 + 2e[3 p2) + O(/3 c )
= 2 _ 1 ( p P + 52 e 13c l n ~P + O ( f 1 2 ) 2e
(2.33)
( 0 o < (p <
15 o)
8 l((p+ ~~02 ..l_~/~c ) ' see Ref.
where e is the Napier number, ln(e) = 1, and p --~
(2.34)
[15] for more
details. Other approximate solutions of Laplace equation can be found in Refs. [ 11,16]. For example, if the meniscus slope is small, Ur2 << 1, Eq. (2.22) reduces to a linear differential equation of Bessel type, whose solution reads z(r) = u(r) = 2[I0(qr) - 1]](bq2),
q =_(Ap g/(y)l/2,
Ur2
<<1
(2.35)
where I0(x) is the modified Bessel function of the first kind and zeroth order [5,17,18]. (iii) The gravity deformation is considerable and tic is not a small parameter. In this case one can integrate numerically the Laplace equation in its parametric presentation, Eq. (2.25). Despite the fact that in the presence of gravitational deformation the Laplace equation has no exact analytical solution, it is curious to note that there is an exact formula for the volume of a sessile or pendant drop (bubble), irrespective of the magnitude of the gravitational deformation. For example, the volume Vl of the lower part of the drop (bubble) in Fig. 2.3, that is comprised between the planes z = 0 and z = z~, is 27r
Zc
r(z)
zc
V1 - ~dooldz I r d r = ~ I d z r 2 ( z ) o o o o
Zc
- Jrzcr~-2~Idzzr(z) o
dr dz
(2.36)
Here co denotes the azimuthal angle in the plane xy, r= r(z) is the generatrix of the interfacial profile, r~ is the radius of the contact line (Fig. 2.3); at the last step in Eq. (2.36) we have integrated by parts. On the other hand, Eq. (2.28) can be expressed in the form d 2 - - ( r s i n qg) = - r dr b
2 +e q zr
(2.37)
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
75
where q is defined by Eq. (2.35). Next, one multiplies Eq. (2.37) by dr/dz and integrates for 0 < z < Zc; in view of Eq. (2.29) the result reads: 2 Zc dr rc +eq 2~dzzr(z)~
rcsintp c -
b
o
(2.38)
&
The integral in Eqs. (2.36) and (2.38) cannot be solved analytically; however, this integral can be eliminated between these two equations to obtain
W 1 - I t , z c /.2 q.. ~
c
- q
eq2
(2.39)
sin (Pc
where qgc is the value of the slope angle q9 at z = Zc, see Fig. 2.3. Similar expression can be obtained also for the volume V2 of the upper part of the fluid particle in Fig. 2.3, that part situated above the plane z = Zc.
2.2.2.
MENISCUS DECAYING AT INFINITY
Examples are the outer meniscus, z = w(r) in Fig. 2.3 and the meniscus in the outer Region II in Fig. 2.4. In this case the action of gravity cannot be neglected insofar as the gravity keeps the interface flat far from the contact line. Let z = 0 be the equation of the aforementioned flat interface. Then P10
= P20
in Eq. (2.7) and the capillary pressure is Pc = Apgz; the Laplace
equation (2.22) for the function z(r) takes the form: Zrr
0 + z2)
•r 3/2 -I-
/2
rO + Z2r~
=q
2
d2z
& Z,
Z r ~-~
dr
,
Zrr
dr 2
(2.40)
Equation (2.40) has no closed analytical solution. The region far from the contact line has always small slope, Zr2 << 1. In this region Eq. (2.40) can be linearized and reduces to a modified Bessel equation; in analogy with Eq. (2.35) one derives
z(r) = A K0 (qr)
(Zr2 << 1)
(2.41 )
where A is a constant of integration and K0(x) is the modified Bessel function of the second kind and zeroth order [5,17,18]. The numerical integration of Eq. (2.40) can be carried out by
Chapter2
76
using Eq. (2.41) as a boundary condition, together with
Zr=-qAKl(qr)
for some appropriately
fixed r >> q-l [ 11 ]" the constant A is to be determined from the boundary condition at r = Re. Approximate analytical solutions of the problem are available [14,19-21]. For the case, when the radius of the contact line R2 (Fig. 2.4) is much smaller than the characteristic capillary length, q-l, Derjaguin [ 19] has derived an asymptotic formula for the elevation of the contact line at the outer surface of the cylinder r = R2:
(qR2)2 <<
hc = -R2 sin gtc ln[qR2 ye (1 + cosg4.)/4],
1
(2.42)
Here gtc is the meniscus slope angle at the contact line (Fig. 2.4), q is defined by Eq. (2.35) and Te = 1.781 072 418... is the Euler constant [17]. Note that Derjaguin's formula (2.42) is valid not only in the case 0 < ~c < 90 ~ but also in the case 90 ~ < gtc < 180 ~ in which the meniscus has
10
z
........................../ ....................
Fig. 2.5. Sketch of a circular hole in a liquid wetting film of thickness hc on a solid substrate; gtc is the contact angle and r0 is the radius of the "neck" of the meniscus. a neck, see e.g. Fig. 2.5. If the condition
(qR2)2 <<
1 is satisfied, the constant A in Eq. (12.41)
can be determined [ 19,14]"
z(r)- R2 sin l/tc K0(qr)
zr2 << 1,
(qR2)2 <<
1
(2.43)
Particles floating on a fluid interface of entrapped in a liquid film usually create small interfacial deformations, for which Eqs. (2.42) and (2.43) are applicable. These equations will be used below in this book to describe quantitatively the lateral capillary forces due to the overlap of the interfacial deformations (menisci) formed around such particles.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
If the condition
Zr 2 <<
77
1 is not fulfilled close to the cylinder r = R2, in this region one can use an
alternative "inner" asymptotic expression [ 14],
h incEarccoh/ r / accoh/ ' /1 R 2 sin I/tc
sin ~c
(qR2)2 << 1
(2.44)
In Eq. (2.44) r _> R2 and h,. is given by Eq. (2.42); arccoshx = ln[x+(x 2 - 1)1/2]; Eq. (2.44) has meaning for z > 0 . For large values of r Eq. (2.44) predicts negative values of z(r), which indicates that this asymptotic formula is out of the region of its validity. Higher order correction terms in Eqs. (2.42)-(2.44) are derived in Refs. [14,20]. If the thickness hc of the liquid film in Fig. 2.5 is small enough one can use (qhc) 2 as a small parameter and to obtain asymptotic expansions for the meniscus profile. In this way O'Brien [21] has derived an expression for the radius of the "neck", r0 (the meniscus has a vertical tangent at r = r0): r0 = - he{ In[ -~ q r0 7e cot(lffc/2)] }-l
(qhc )2 << 1,
90 ~ < ~c < 180 ~
(2.45)
For given hc and ~. the radius of the "neck" (or "pinhole") r0 can be calculated from Eq. (2.45) by iterations. For ~c = 90 ~ the radii of the neck and contact line coincide, r0 - R2, and in this special case Eqs. (2.42) and (2.45) coincide. For gtc--9 180 ~ the asymptotic formula (2.45) is not valid and another procedure of calculations is suggested in Ref. [21]; alternatively, Eq. (2.25) with Pc. = Ap g~ can be integrated numerically.
2.2.3. MENISCUS CONFINED BETWEEN TWO CYLINDERS, 0 < R1 < r < R2
This type of capillary menisci include the various capillary bridges (Fig. 2.6a), the channels (borders) in foams and some emulsions, as well as the borders around the model thin liquid films in the experimental cells of Scheludko [22-24] and Mysels [25]; such is the configuration of fluid particles or biological cells pressed between two surfaces, see Fig. 2.6b and Refs. [26,27]. The shape of these menisci have been first investigated by Plateau [28] and Gibbs [29] in connection to the borders in the foams
78
Chapter 2
If the gravitational deformation of the meniscus cannot be neglected, the interfacial shape can be determined by numerical integration of Eq. (2.25), or by iterative procedure [30]. If the meniscus deformation caused by gravity is negligible, analytical solution can be found as described below. Equation (2.24) can be presented in the form d
(rsin (p)- 2k, r,
k, = P~ - P2 2a
dr
TZ
(2.46)
. ,,i I
,,
0
o
Pt
(a)
(b)
Fig. 2.6. Capillary bridges between two parallel plates: (a) concave bridge, (b) convex bridge; rc is the radius of the three-phase contact line; ro is the radius of the section with the plane of symmetry; P1 and P2 are the pressures inside and outside the bridge, respectively. The pressures in phases 1 and 2, P1 and P2, and the coordinate of the point with vertical tangent, r0, are shown in Fig. 2.6. To determine the shape of the menisci depicted in Figs. 2.6a and 2.6b we integrate Eq. (2.46) from r0 to r to derive sin (p - k~ r + r~ r
- k I r0)
(2.47)
New,t, using Eq. (2.47)and the identity tan(p= • sin(p/(1- sin2(p) 1/2 one obtains dz kl @2 _ ~ )+ r0 d---~= +[(r 2 _ 4 ) ( r , 2_r~)l/21k, l,
1 - k I r0
r, -
(2.48)
k,
Equation (2.48) describes curves, which after Plateau [28,31,10] are called "nodoid" and "unduloid," see Fig. 2.7. One sees that the nodoid (unlike the unduloid) has points with horizontal tangent, where dz/dr = 0. With the help of Eq. (2.48) one can deduce that the
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
79
meniscus generatrix is a part of nodoid for klro ~ ( - ~ , 0)u(1, +~), whereas the meniscus generatrix is a part of unduloid for kl r0 ~ (0, 1).
Z ~
Z ~
(nodoid)
(unduloid)
I I
I
R1
R2
1
_
0
(a)
R1
R2
(b)
Fig. 2.7. Typical shape of the curves of Plateau: (a) nodoid, (b) unduloid. The curves are confined between two cylinders of radii R1 and R2.
In the special case klro= 1 the meniscus is spherical. In the other special case, klr0=0, the meniscus has the shape of catenoid, i.e.
1, Qualitatively, the catenoid looks like the meniscus depicted in Fig. 2.6a; it corresponds to zero capillary pressure and zero mean curvature of the interface (Pc= 0 and H = 0). In this case H = 0 because the two principle curvatures have equal magnitude, but opposite sign, at each point of the catenoid. This is the reason why it is called also "pseudosphere". The meniscus has a "neck" (Fig. 2.6a) when k~ro ~ ( - ~ , 1/2); in particular, the generatrix is nodoid for klro~ (-~o, 0), catenoid for klr0=0, and unduloid for klro~ (0, 1/2). For the configuration depicted in Fig. 2.6a one has rl > r0 (in Fig. 2.7 Rl = r0, R2 = rl) and Eq. (2.48) can be integrated to yield
Chapter 2
80
z ( r ) : +_ r0F(q)l,q, )+ rlsgnk I E(q~,,ql ) - r r ,
where sngx denotes the sign of x, q l = ( 1 - r o Z / r l 2 ) 1/2 , sin(pl=ql-l(1-ro2/r2)l/2; F(q),q) and E(O, q) are the standard symbols for elliptic integrals, respectively, of the first and the second kind [5,17,18]:
F(q~, q) -
d_lff , 41_ q2 sin 2~
r
E(O,q)
f - 0
,/l - q2 sin 2 ~ d ~
(2.51)
A convenient numerical method for computation of F(O, q) and E(q~,q) is the method of the arithmetic-geometric mean, see Ref. [ 18], Chapter 17.6. The meniscus has a "haunch" (Fig. 2.6b) when klro 9 (1/2, +oo); in particular, the generatrix is unduloid for klro 9 (1/2, 1), circumference for klro= 1, and nodoid for klro 9 (1,+oo). For the configuration depicted in Fig. 2.6b one has r0 > r~ (in Fig. 2.7 R~ = r~, R2-" r0) and Eq. (2.48) can be integrated to yield z ( r ) - _+[(r0 - 1/k I )F(q~2, q2 ) - r0 E(q~2,q2 )],
(r1 < r < r0 )
(2.52)
where q2 = (l-r1 2 /ro 2 ) 1/2, sin~ = q2 -1(1 - r 2/ro 2 )1/2 More about capillary bridges can be found in Chapter 11. Equation (2.52) has been also used [26,27] to describe the shape of drops and blood cells entrapped in liquid films.
2.3.
F O R C E BALANCE AT A THREE-PHASE-CONTACT LINE
2.3.1.
EQUATION OF YOUNG
As discussed in Section 2.1.2, the Laplace equation is a differential equation, which needs boundary conditions to obtain an uniquely defined solution for the shape of the interface. In Section 2.1.1 we demonstrated that the Laplace equation can be derived as a necessary condition for minimum of the grand thermodynamic potential f2 by using variations in the meniscus shape u(x,y) at fixed boundaries. In addition, the boundary conditions for Laplace equation can be derived in a similar way by using variations in the meniscus shape at mobile boundaries, see e.g. [8,32-34].
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
81
V2
(2)
A2
8u!.
8u, A1
(1) v
0
Xl
Y
Fig. 2.8. Sketch of a two-phase system composed of phases 1 and 2 occupying volumes Vi and V2 separated by an interface of equation z = u(x); A1 and A2 are the contact areas of the respective phases with the right-hand side wall; a is contact angle; 5u(x) and 8u~ represent variation in the shape of the interface and in the position of the contact line, respectively.
Let us consider again a two-phase system closed in a box of volume V = V~ + V2, see Fig. 2.8. For the sake of simplicity, let us assume that the meniscus has a translational symmetry along the y-axis; then the meniscus profile is z = u(x). Let the right-hand-side wall of the box (Fig. 2.8) be a vertical solid plate situated at x = Xl. W e consider variations, 8u(x), of the meniscus profile for movable contact line at the vertical wall at x = Xl. The grand potential f2 can be expressed in the form
- - _ [ P 1 d V - f P2dV+(ya + O',sal + (Y2sa2 vj
(2.53)
where A~ and A2 are the contact areas of the vertical wall with phase 1 and 2, respectively (Fig. 2.8); 0-,,3 and O2s can be interpreted as surface excess densities of f~ for the boundaries s o l i d / p h a s e 1 and s o l i d / p h a s e 2. Since the meniscus has translational symmetry, one can write
xl
u(x)
0
0
Xl
b
0
u(x)
(2.54) Vl
Vl
82
Chapter 2
where l is the length of the meniscus along the y-axis; z = 0 and z = b are the lower and the upper side of the box (Fig. 2.8). The area of the boundary between phases 1 and 2 is x,
~/ l+u 2
a-lldx 0
c)u u~--
(2.55) c?x
'
Let the variation 8u(x) of the meniscus profile is accompanied by a variation 8Ul of the position of the contact line at the vertical wall at x
= Xl.
Then 8A~ =
-
~n 2 =
1~b/1 and in view of Eqs.
(2.53)-(2.55) the first variation of the grand potential f~ can be expressed in the form: Xl
,Sf~ -lI(,SL)dx +(~,, - ~2, )hSu~
(2.56)
0
where
Pl(z)dz-
L(u, U x ) - -
0
(2.57)
P2(z)dz+o" l+u2x u
Differentiating Eq. (2.57) one obtains aL = c?L au + c?L - - d((~u) - -
Ou
(2.58)
c?ux dx
Next, we integrate by parts the last term in Eq. (2.58)"
oaUx
ax
x=xI
ZLi-y
au,-
audx
(2.59)
Combining Eqs. (2.56)-(2.59) one derives
~ ~'~ -- I
--~R -- -'~X "-~Rx
~ u dx
k l ~ u x x=xl -t--O'ls- O'2s l ~ U 1
(2.60)
We already know that the meniscus profile satisfies the Laplace equation, Eq. (2.21), which is equivalent to the equation o~__L_L_ d | @0=. (_,_9 1| _, ' )
9u
dx to.
)
Hence, the integral term in Eq. (2.60)is equal
to zero. Furthermore, the necessary condition for minimum is ~5U2 = 0, and 8uj is an independent and arbitrary variation. Then the term multiplying 5u~ in Eq. (2.60) must be equal to zero:
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
83
[9~-~uL ) +c~,-c~,-0
(2.61)
x= x I
Using Eq. (2.57) and the identity ux = tan(p, where (p is the running slope angle, one can derive: c? L
0- u x
0- tan (p
c?ux
41+u 2
~/1 + tan2 (p
Finally, in Eq. (2.62) we set x
= Xl
= 0-sin (p
(2.62)
and take into account that (sin(p)x=x I - c o s ~ , where c~ is
the contact angle (Fig. 2.8)" then Eq. (2.61) transforms into the Young [35] equation: 0-2, = 0-1, + 0- cosa
(Young equation)
(2.63)
An equivalent equation has been obtained by Dupr6 [36] in his analysis of the work of adhesion. We derived Eq. (2.63) for the special case of meniscus of translational symmetry, however, this equation has the same form for arbitrarily shaped meniscus and solid surface, see e.g. Ref. [8]. The above derivation of Young equation, which is similar to the derivation of Laplace equation in Section 2.1.1, implies that the Young equation expresses the balance of forces per unit length of a three-phase-contact line, likewise the Laplace equation expresses the force balance
per unit area of a phase boundary. According to Gibbs [29] 05, and 0-2, can be interpreted as surface tensions (forces per unit area): O"1sand 0"2, oppose every increase of the "wet" area (without any deformation of the solid) in the same way as 0- opposes every dilatation of the interface between fluids 1 and 2; Gibbs termed 0-I, and 0"2, "superficial tensions". Equation (2.63), presented in the form coso~ = (0-2s- 0-~,)/0-, shows that the contact angle o~ can be expressed in terms of the three surface tensions, which in their own turn are determined by the excess molecular interactions in the zone of the phase boundaries (Section 1.1.1). Therefore, the magnitude of the equilibrium contact angle is determined by the intermolecular forces. It is worth noting that ~5~ = 0 is only a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for a minimum of the grand potential f~. This condition is fulfilled also in the case of maximum and inflection
84
Chapter 2
point of f2. Quite surprisingly, Eriksson & Ljunggren [37] established that for gas bubbles attached to a hydrophobic wall the Young equation can correspond to a maximum of f2, i.e. to a state of unstable equilibrium. Further, in Ref. [38] the conditions for stable or unstable attachment of a fluid particle (drop, bubble) to a solid wall have been examined. The force interpretation of the Young equation is illustrated in Fig. 2.9a. One sees that Eq. (2.63) represents the horizontal projection of the vectorial force balance 13' + O'ls + O'2s + fR ----0
(2.64)
where the underlined sigma's denote vectors, each of them being tangential to the respective interface and normal to the contact line; fR is the vector of the bearing reaction, which is normal to the surface of the solid substrate and counterbalances the vertical projection of the meniscus surface tension" fR = cr sino~
(2.65)
Equation (2.65) can be useful in the analysis of the forces applied to a particle, which is attached to an interface (see below). Note that the thermodynamic interpretations of or, o'~s and crzs as surface excess densities of the grand thermodynamic potential f2 are completely compatible with their mechanical interpretation as forces per unit length (Fig. 2.9a) insofar as boundaries of a liquid phase are considered and deformations of the solid walls are neglected. These two interpretations (as energy per unit area and force per unit length) are mutually complementary, in spite of the fact that some authors favor the thermodynamic and other ones - the mechanical interpretation. As already mentioned, Gibbs [29] interpreted O~s and crzs as tensions opposing the increase of the wet area on the solid surface without any deformation of the solid. On the other hand, differences between energy per unit area and force per unit length appear if deformations of the solid surface take place, see e.g. Refs. [39-43]. Then the force per unit length becomes a two-dimensional tensor, whereas the energy per unit area remains a
scalar, and consequently, these two quantities cannot be equal" the trace of the tensor (the surface tension of the solid) is related to the excess surface energy per unit area by means of the Shuttleworth equation [39-43]. Deformations of the solid phase are out of the conventional capillary hydrostatics and thermodynamics, and will not be considered here.
hzterfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
85
V
fluid 2
N eum ann triangle
l
/
sinc
(3)
w(r)
(Yv
!A (2)
~
1
u(r)
(a)
], ~J~,
(b)
Fig. 2.9. Force interpretation of (a) Young equation (2.64) and (b) the Neumann triangle (2.66); fR is the bearing reaction of the solid substrate, which counterbalances the normal projection of the surface tension, o'sina; a and t3 are contact angles.
2.3.2.
TRIANGLEOF NEUMANN
Three-phase-contact line can be formed also when all the three phases are line of intersection of the menisci
u(r), v(r)
and
w(r)
fluid:
such is the
in Fig. 2.3 (drop or bubble attached to an
interface) and Fig. 2.9b (liquid lens at a fluid phase boundary). In this case one can prove (again by a variational method, see e.g. Refs. [32,33]) that the force balance per unit length of the contact line is given by the Neumann [44] vectorial triangle: ff~, + ~v + _~w = 0,
(Neumann triangle)
(2.66)
see Fig. 2.9b and Refs. [3,31,45,46]. In this case there are two independent contact angles: a and 13. Applying the known cosine theorem to the triangle in Fig. 2.9b one obtains: 0.w 2 ---- 0.u 2 + 0.v 2 +
2o;,0-v c o s o ~ ,
0-v2 "- 0.u 2 q- 0.w 2 -F
20.,,0.w cosfl,
(2.67)
From Eq. (2.67) one determines [3,46-48] 0.2
coso~ -
2
2
w-0., -o'v, 20.,,0.v
2
2
2
cosfl - 0-v - 0 - , -0-w 20.,0. w
(2.68)
86
Chapter2
Equations (2.68) relate the contact angles o~ and/3 to the three interfacial tensions. Hence, we again arrive to the conclusion that the magnitude of the contact angles is determined by the intermolecular forces (which determine also the values of the sigma's) and, moreover, the contact angles do not depend on applied external fields such as gravitational or centrifugal. Note however, that if a line tension is present at the contact line (Section 2.3.3), the contact angle becomes (in principle) dependent on applied external fields as proven by Ivanov et al. [32]. It must be emphasized that the above conclusions related to the physical nature of the contact angles are valid only for the true, i.e. correctly defined, contact angles. Experimentally, by means of some optical method the shapes of the interfaces at some distance from the contact line are usually determined, and then by extrapolating them until they intersect the contact angle is found, for review see e.g. Refs. [30,49,50]. The first problem encountered when this procedure is carried out in practice is that the minimum distance from the contact line, at which one can still obtain experimental information about the interfacial shape, is limited by the magnification of the microscope [51]. The second problem is related to the transition region in a narrow vicinity of the contact line in which the interactions between the three neighboring phases affect the interfacial tensions and the shape of the interfaces. Although the width of the transition region (it was estimated to 1 lain in Ref. [52]) is smaller than the resolution of the optical methods, if some of the experimental points happen to lie there, this will again affect the extrapolation procedure, and hence - the value of the macroscopic contact angle. The only way to avoid these two errors is [32]: (i) to make sure that all experimental points used lie outside of the transition region and (ii) to carry out the extrapolation of the surface in such a way that its shape at all points satisfies the Laplace equation with the macroscopic value of the surface tension.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theor)' of Capillarity
87
2.3.3. THE EFFECT OF LINE TENSION
As discussed above, the true thermodynamic contact angle is subtended between the
extrapolated surfaces, which obey the Laplace equation. On the other hand, the interactions between the phases (the disjoining pressure effects) in a vicinity of the three-phase-contact line may lead to a deviation of the real interfacial shape from the extrapolated surface and to a variation of the interfacial tensions in this narrow region. In such a case, to make the idealized system (composed of uniform bulk phases and interfaces obeying the Laplace equation at constant surface tension) equivalent to the real system, some excesses of the thermodynamic parameters can be ascribed to the three-phase contact line. The excess linear density of the grand thermodynamic potential f2 has the meaning of a line tension, likewise the excess surface density of f2 is identified as the surface tension, see e.g. Ref. [53]. Furthermore, the line tension can be interpreted as a force, directed tangentially to the contact line, just like the tension of a stretched fiber or string [54]. For the first time the concept of line tension was formulated by Gibbs [29] in his theory of capillarity. The thermodynamic theory of systems with line tension was developed by Buff and Saltsburg [45], and Boruvka and Neumann [53]. The theory of line tension for systems containing
thin liquid film was worked out in Refs. [52,55,56]. Following Veselovsky and
Pertsov [54], let us consider a small circular portion (arc) of a curved contact line with length s, curvature radius rc and line tension K', which is depicted in Fig. 2.10. The considered portion of the contact line is situated symmetrically with respect to the x-axis, which is chosen to pass through the center of curvature O. Due to the action of line tension, a force of magnitude • and direction tangential to the contact line is exerted at both ends of the considered arc (Fig. 2.10). Then one obtains s = 20 rc,
IfxI = 2resin0
(2.69)
where fx is the sum of the x-projections of the two forces due to the line tension. Then it turns out that the existence of line tension leads to the appearance of a force
o'~ - l i m ~ o--,0 s
=-
rc
(2.70)
Chapter 2
88
X
t
x s
t
i
i I x
C
t
~\
/
x
i \ x
I
C
1//
r
O Fig. 2.10. The line tension ~, acting tangentially to a small portion (arc) of a curved contact line, leads to the appearance of a force per unit length o-~ = tc/rc, which is directed toward the center of curvature of the arc, point O; rc is the curvature radius of the considered elementary arc of the contact line.
acting per unit length of the contact line. In each point of the contact line this force, ~ ,
is
directed toward the center of curvature (toward the center of the circumference, if the contact line is circular). The above derivation is valid for any smooth curved line, insofar as every small portion of such a line can be approximated with an arc of circumference [7]. If the effect of line tension is included into the Young equation, Eqs. (2.63) and (2.64) acquire the more general form [57]:
0"2,` - 0"1., + 0" c o s a + - r
(2.71 )
(3"+O'ls+(Y2s+O'tr +[R =0
(2.72)
In this case the contact line belongs to a solid surface and the force interpretation of ~; and ~
is
similar to the interpretation of _~s and O'2s given by Gibbs (see above); in particular, tr can be interpreted as a force, which opposes the extension of the perimeter of the wet zone in every process of variation of the wet area without any deformation in the solid substrate.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
N eum ann quadrangle
(~./4-~(~,; ~
89
i t
hl
,,2
I
!
,
P i m
' !~ 2re ,I
(3)
,
(Jv
i
I
(2) ~ / ( y ~ ,
(a)
(b)
Fig. 2.11. Balance of forces per unit length of the contact line (a) around a floating lens (b) around a spot of tension ?'1 and thickness hI in a liquid film of tension T2 and thickness h2; cry:is the contribution of line tension. Likewise, the Neumann triangle, Eq. (2.66) transforms into a "Neumann quadrangle" defined by the following vectorial equation [32,48,58-60] ~, + ~v + ~w + ~,,-= O,
(2.73)
see Fig. 2.11a. Note that Eq. (2.73) can be derived from the thermodynamic condition for minimum of the thermodynamic potential [32,33]. To do that the capillary system is considered as being built up from bulk (three-dimensional) phases, surface (two-dimensional) phases and line (one-dimensional) phases [53,60]. Then the grand potential is expressed in the form: f2 - - Z P Vi + Z CrmA,, + Z tcnL,, i
m
(2.74)
n
where the indices "i", "m" and "n" numerate the bulk, surface and line phases" as usual, P denotes pressure, V - volume, 0 - surface tension, A - area, to- line tension and L - length. Next, let us consider a circular spot of radius rc, thickness h~ and tension y~ formed in a foam (or emulsion) film of thickness h2 and tension ?~, see Fig. 2.1 lb. Such spots are typical for the transition from primary to secondary film (from common black to Newton black film) in foams
90
Chapter 2
[25,61,62], as well as for the multiple step-wise transitions in the thickness of liquid films containing surfactant micelles or other spherical colloid particles [63,64]. The force balance per unit length of the line encircling the spot is (Fig. 2.1 l b): K"
- - =)'2 -71 rc
(2.75)
Equation (2.75) is obviously a linear counterpart of the Laplace equation (2.4). One could estimate the magnitude of tr for the spot in Fig. 2.11 b in the following way [64]. The periphery of the spot can be approximated with a step of total height Ah
= h2 - hi.
The excess energy due
to the formation of the spot is tr = o-Ah, where o" is the surface tension of the film. Thus with typical values o" = 36 mN/m and Ah = 5 nm one calculates tr = 1.8 x 10-l~ N. It should be noted that this estimate is pertinent to the system depicted in Fig. 2.11 b, and it is certainly irrelevant for other systems and/or configurations. What concerns the sign of tc, it must be positive if the shape of the spot is circular. Indeed, at tr > 0 each deviation from circular shape (at constant spot area) would lead to an increase of the length, L, of the contact line encircling the spot and of the line energy, teL; therefore, the spot will spontaneously acquire a circular shape, which minimizes the line energy. Such circular spots are observed also in adsorption monolayers of insoluble molecules, like phospholipids, which exhibit coexisting domains of different twodimensional phases [65-67]. In some cases, however, the boundaries between such coexisting domains are highly irregular and unstable, which can be attributed (at least in part) to the action of negative line tension. Note, that in (physically) two-dimensional systems, like the film in Fig, 2.1 l b, there is no other force, but a positive line tension, which tends to keep the shape of the contact line circular. That is the reason why the line tension is an effect of primary importance for such "two-dimensional" systems, in which the contact line separates two surface phases (Fig. 2.1 l b). Quite different is the case of a
three-phase-contact line, see Fig. 2.1 l a and Eq. (2.73). In order
to minimize the surface area (and energy) the fluid interfaces acquire axisymmetric shape and their lines of intersection (the three-phase-contact lines) are usually circumferences. Then even a negative line tension cannot disturb the regular shape of the contact line, which is preserved by the surface tensions in the Young equation (2.71) and Neumann quadrangle (2.73). The
htterfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theor3' of Capillarity
91
(J2sl 7 . ( y s i n o~
(2) 61
Fig. 2.12. Balance of forces per unit length of the contact line of a small solid sphere attached to the planar interface between the fluid phases 1 and 2; o" is the interfacial tension, o'l.,,and o'2.,,are the two solid-fluid tensions, o'~ is the line tension effect, fR is the bearing reaction of the solid particle: fR + o'~sina = o'sino~. accumulated results for three-phase systems show that the line-tension term turns out to be only a small correction, which can be (and is usually) neglected in Eqs. (2.71)-(2.73), see Section 2.3.4. As an example for application of the Young equation (2.72) let us consider a small spherical particle attached to the interface between two fluid phases, Fig. 2.12. We presume that the weight of the particle is small and the particle does not create any deformation of the fluid interface [68,69]. All forces taking part in Eq. (2.72) are depicted in Fig. 2.12, including the normal projection, osino:, of the interfacial tension.
Its tangential projection, ocoso~, is
counterbalanced by O2s + O"tcCOS~- t~ls in accordance with the Young equation. Then one could conclude (erroneously!) that o s i n a and/or oscsino~, which have non-zero projections along the z-axis (Fig. 2.12), give rise to a force acting on the particle along the normal to the fluid interface. If such a force were really operative, it would create a deformation of the fluid interface around the particle, which would be in contradiction with the experimental observations. Then a question arises: how to calculate correctly the net force exerted on a fluid particle attached to an interface at equilibrium?
92
Chapter 2
The rule (called sometimes the principle of Stevin), stems from the classical mechanics and it is the following: The net force exerted on a particle originates only from phases, which are o u t e r with respect to the given particle: the pressure of an outer bulk phase, the surface tension
of an outer surface phase and the line tension of an outer line phase. (For example, if a particle is hanging on a fiber, then the tension of the fiber has to be considered as the line tension of an "outer line phase".) In our case (the particle in Fig. 2.12) the o u t e r forces are the pressures in the two neighboring fluid phases 1 and 2, and the surface tension, o, of the boundary between them. The integral effect of their action gives a zero net force for the configuration depicted in Fig. 2.12 due to its symmetry. Then there is no force acting along the normal to the interface and the latter will not undergo a deformation in a vicinity of the particle. (Such a deformation would appear if the particle weight and the buoyancy force were not negligible.) On the other hand, the solid-fluid tensions, o~, and O'2s, the tension o'~-due to line tension, and the bearing reaction of the solid, fR, cannot be considered as outer forces. However, O'~s, Cr2s and o'~ also affect the equilibrium position of the particle at the interface insofar as they (together with o) determine the value of the contact angle o~, see Eq. (2.71).Additional information can be found in Chapter 5 below, where balances of forces experienced by particles attached to the boundary between two fluids are considered.
2.3.4. HYSTERESIS OF CONTACT ANGLE AND LINE TENSION
The experimental determination of line tension is often based on the fact, that the presence of a ~rc term in Eqs. (2.71) and (2.73) leads (in principle) to a dependence of the contact angle o~ on the radius of the contact line rc (o', o'ls and O2s are presumably constants), see Refs. [70-79]. However, there is another phenomenon, the hysteresis of contact angle, which also leads to variation of the contact angle, see e.g. Ref. [80]. Both phenomena may have a similar physical origin [75]. The fact that a hysteresis of contact angle takes place with liquid menisci on a s o l i d substrate has been known for a long time [81,82]. It is an experimental fact that a range of stable contact angles can be measured on a real solid surface. The highest of them is termed "advancing", and
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of CapillariO,
93
the lowest one -"receding" contact angle. The difference between the advancing and receding angles is called "the range of hysteresis", or shortly, "hysteresis" [83,84]. The widely accepted qualitative explanation of this phenomenon is that the hysteresis is caused by the presence of surface roughness and chemical heterogeneity of the real solid surfaces [75, 85-96]. From this viewpoint, the Young equation is believed to be valid only for an ideal solid surface, which is molecularly smooth, chemically homogeneous, rigid and insoluble [84]. However, hysteresis of contact angle can be observed even on an ideal solid surface if a thin liquid film is formed in front of an advancing meniscus, or left behind a receding meniscus; this was proven theoretically by Martynov et al. [97], see also Refs. [98,99]. In this case the hysteresis is due to the action of an adhesive surface force within the thin film, which opposes the detachment of the film surfaces and facilitates their attachment. Such forces are present (and hysteresis is observed) not only in wetting films on a solid substrate, but also in free foam and emulsion films stabilized by usual surfactants [100-102] or by proteins [99]. It turns out that, as a rule, one observes hysteresis of contact angle and only with some special systems hysteresis is completely missing. Such special systems can be liquid lenses on a fluid interface [30, 103-107] or thin films without strong adhesive forces [108]. The occurrence of hysteresis is different for a completely fluid three-phase-contact line and for a three-phase contact involving one solid phase: In the former case at complete equilibrium (immobile contact line) an equilibrium contact angle is established [99-102]; in contrast, in the latter case (in the presence of solid phase) it is practically impossible to figure out which angle, could be identified as the equilibrium one within the range between the receding and advancing angles. Coming back to the line tension issue, in Fig. 2.13 we demonstrate, that in some cases the line tension could be a manifestation of the hysteresis of contact angle. Let us assume that for some value of the contact angle, c~ = o~1, the Young equation (2.63) is satisfied (Fig. 2.13a). Due to the hysteresis another metastable contact angle, a2, exists (~2 > ~1, see Fig. 2.13b). From a macroscopic viewpoint the force balance in Fig. 2.13b can be preserved if only a line tension term, c~r = ~rc, is introduced, see Eq. (2.71) with o~= o~2. Indeed, the surface tensions o', ~y~,.
94
Chapter 2 (y G 0.2s ,,._
0.2s
/ ./////z ///,
(a)
/
,c / / / / / / / / ,
7~7/
'
///////
"~/
(b)
Fig. 2.13. Sessile liquid drop on a solid substrate. (a) Balance of the forces acting per unit length of the contact line, of radius r, ; o" is the surface tension of the liquid, o-is and o-2.,,are the tensions of the two solid-fluid interfaces, al is contact angle. (b) After liquid is added to the drop, hysteresis is observed: the contact angle rises to a2 at fixed r, ; the fact that the macroscopic force balance is preserved (the contact line remains immobile) can be attributed to the action of a line tension effect o-~. and o2s are the same in Figs. 2.13a and 2.13b, and the difference between the contact angles (a2 > oq) can be attributed to the action of a line tension. The interpretation of the contact-angle hysteresis as a line tension could be accepted, because, as already mentioned, the two phenomena have a similar physical origin: local microscopic deviations from the macroscopic Young-Laplace model in a narrow vicinity of the contact line. When the meniscus advance is accompanied by an increase of the contact radius re, a positive line tension must be included in the Young equation to preserve the force balance (Fig. 2.13b). In the opposite case, if the meniscus advance is accompanied by a decrease of rc, then a negative line tension must be included in the Neumann-Young equation to preserve the force balance. The shrinking bubbles, like that depicted in Fig. 2.3, correspond to the latter case and, really, negative line tensions have been measured with such bubbles [109,110, 100-102]; see also the discussion in Ref. [111]. Theoretical calculations, which do not take into account effects such as surface roughness or heterogeneity, or dynamic effects with adhesive thin films, usually predict very small values of the line tension from 10-~ to 10-~3 N, see Table 2.1. On the contrary, the experiments which deal with real solid surfaces, or which are carried out under dynamic conditions, as a rule give much higher values of tc (Table 2.1). The values of tc in a given experiment often have variable magnitude, and e v e n -
variable sign [70-73,100-102,109,110]. Moreover, the values of ~"
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of CapillariO'
95
determined in different experimental and theoretical works vary with 8 orders of magnitude (Table 2.1). Table 2.1. Comparison of experimental and theoretical results for line tension to. Researchers
Theory /
System
Value(s) of line tension K (N)
Experiment Tarazona & Navascues [112]
Theory
Solid-liquid-vapor contact line
-2.6 to -8.2 x 10-11
Navascues & Mederos [113]
Experiment
Nucleation rate of water drops on Hg
-2.9 t o - 3 . 9 x 10-~~
de Feijter & Vrij [52]
Theory
Kolarov & Zorin [114]
! Foam films
= - 1 • 10-12
Experiment
Foam films
- 1.7 x 10- 1 0
Denkov et al. [115]
Theory
Emulsion films
-0.95 t o - 1 . 5 7 x 10-13
Torza and Mason [59]
Experiment
Emulsion films
Ivanov & coworkers [100-102, 109-111]
Experiment
Foam film at the top of shrinking bubbles
-1 x 10.7 to = 0
Wallace & Schtirch [116,117]
Experiment
Sessile drop on monolayer
+1 to +2.4 x 10-8
Neumann & coworkers [118-121]
Experiment
Sessile drops
+1 to +6 x 10- 6
Gu, Li & Cheng [122]
Experiment
Interface around a cone
= +1 x 10- 6
Nguyen et al. [123]
Experiment
Silanated glass spheres on water-air surface
+1.2 to +5.5 x 10-6
,
!
-0.6 t o - 5 . 8 x 10-s
|
There could be some objections against the formal treatment of the contact angle hysteresis as a line-tension effect. Firstly, some authors [124-126] interpret the hysteresis as an effect of static friction (overcoming of a barrier), which is physically different from the conventional molecular interpretation of line tension, see e.g. Ref. [112]. Secondly, a hysteresis of contact angle can be observed also with a straight contact line (r~.-->oo); if such hysteresis is interpreted as a line tension effect, one will obtain ;c~oo, but cr~:= to/re will remain finite.
96
Chapter 2
If o'~ in the Neumann "quadrangle" Eq. (2.73), is a manifestation of hysteresis, then o'~ is not expected to vary significantly with the size of the particles (solid spheres, drops, bubbles, lenses). On the other hand, rc can vary with many orders of magnitude. Consequently, if the line tension effect in some system is a manifestation of a contact angle hysteresis, then one could expect that the measured Itcl = Io%clrc will be larger for the larger particles (greater rc) and smaller for the smaller particles (smaller rc). Some of the reported experimental data (Table 2.1) actually exhibit such a tendency. For example, in the experiments of Neumann and coworkers [118-121] and Gu et al. [122] rc = 3 mm and one estimates an average value o-~ = 1 mN/m; in the experiments of Ivanov and coworkers [ 100-102,109,110] the mean value of the contact radius is rc-- 35 lain and one estimates Io,cl = 1.4 mN/m; in the experiment of Torza & Mason [59] rc = 15 gm in average and then Io-~1 = 2 raN/m; in the experiments of Navascues & Mederos [113] rc = 23 nm and one obtains Io~1 = 20 mN/m. One sees, that in contrast with Itr which varies with many orders depending on the experimental system, Io-~1 exhibits a relatively moderate variation. Then a question arises whether tr or o~ is a better material parameter characterizing the linear excess at the three-phase contact line. In the experiments with slowly diminishing bubbles from solutions of ionic surfactant [100102] it has been firmly established that the shrinking of the contact line is accompanied by a rise (hysteresis) of the contact angle, o~, and appearance of a significant negative line tension, K-. When the shrinking of the contact line was stopped (by control of pressure), both c~ and Itcl relaxed down to their equilibrium values, which for tc turned out to be zero in the framework of the experimental accuracy (_+1.5 x 10-s N). This effect was interpreted [100-102,111] as a "dynamic" line tension related to local deformations in the zone of the contact line, which are due to the action of attractive (adhesive) forces opposing the detachment of the film surfaces in the course of meniscus advance. Arguments in favor of such an interpretation are that a measurable line tension effect is missing in the case of (i) receding meniscus (expanding bubbles) [100-102] and (ii) shrinking bubbles from nonionic surfactant solution [108]. In the latter case the adhesive surface forces in the film are negligible. Finally, let us summarize the conclusions stemming from the analysis of the available experimental and theoretical results for the line tension:
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theoo' of Capillarity
97
1) The line tension of three-phase-contact-lines can vary by many orders of magnitude depending on the specific system, configuration (contact-line radius) and process (static or dynamic conditions). The sign of line tension could also vary, even for similar systems [70-73]. In some cases this could be due to the fact, that the measured line tension is a manifestation of hysteresis of contact angle; in this case the variability of the magnitude and sign of the line tension is connected with the indefinite value of the contact angle. Hence, unlike the surface tension, the line tension, to, strongly depends on the geometry of the system and the occurrence of dynamic processes. This makes the theoretical prediction of line tension a very hard task and limits the importance and the applicability of the experimentally determined values of tc only to the given special system, configuration and process. 2) The line tension of three-phase-contact lines is usually a small correction (an effect of secondary importance) in the Young equation or Neumann triangle, and it could be neglected without a great loss of accuracy. 3) In contrast, the line tension of the boundary between two surface phases (see e.g. Fig. 2.1 lb) is an effect of primary importance, which determines the shape and the stability of the boundaries between domains (spots) in thin liquid films and Langmuir adsorption films.
2.4.
SUMMARY
The pressure exhibits a jump on the two sides of a curved interface or membrane of non-zero tension. This effect is quantitatively described by the Laplace equation, which expresses the force balance per unit area of a curved interface. In general, the Laplace equation is a second order nonlinear partial differential equation, Eq. (2.20), determining the shape of the interface. This equation, however, reduces to a much simpler ordinary differential equation for the practically important special case of axisymmetric interfaces and membranes, see Eqs. (2.22)(2.25). There are three types of axisymmetric menisci. (I) Meniscus meeting the axis of revolution: the shapes of sessile and pendant drops and some configurations of biological cells belong to this type (Section 2.2.1). (II) Meniscus decaying at infinity: it describes the shape of the fluid interface around a vertical cylinder, floating solid or fluid particle (including gas bubble and oil lens), as well as around a hole in a wetting film (Section 2.2.2). (Ill) Meniscus
98
Chapter 2
confined between two cylinders (Section 2.2.3): in the absence of gravitational deformation the shape of such a meniscus is described by the classical curves "nodoid" and "unduloid", which represent linear combinations of the two elliptic integrals of Legendre; such menisci are the capillary "bridges", the Plateau borders in foams, the shape of the free surface of a fluid particle or biological cell pressed between two plates. For all types of axisymmetric menisci the available analytical formulas are given, and numerical procedures are recommended if there is no appropriate analytical expression. In reality the fluid interfaces (except those of free drops and bubbles) are bounded by threephase contact lines. The values of the contact angles subtended between three intersecting phase boundaries are determined by the force balance at the contact line, which is termed Young equation in the case of solid particle, Eq. (2.64), and Neumann triangle in the case of fluid particle, Eq. (2.66). It is demonstrated that the force balance at the contact line (likewise the Laplace equation) can be derived by variation of the thermodynamic potential. Linear excess energy (line tension) can be ascribed to a contact line. The line tension can be interpreted as a force tangential to the contact line, which is completely similar to the tension of a stretched string of fiber from mechanical viewpoint. When the contact line is curved, the line tension gives a contribution, o~, in the Young and Neumann equations, see Figs. 2.10, 2.1 l a and Eqs. (2.72) and (2.73). The latter equations express force balances, which influence the equilibrium position of a particle at an interface. The rule how to calculate the net force exerted on such a particle is presented and illustrated, see Fig. 2.12. The accumulated experimental results for various systems show that the line tension a of threephase-contact line can vary by many orders of magnitude, and even by sign, depending on the specific system, configuration and process. In some cases the measured macroscopic line tension can be a manifestation of contact angle hysteresis; in such a case the variability of the magnitude and sign of the line tension is connected with the indefinite value of the contact angle. The line tension of three-phase-contact-lines (see Table 2.1) is usually dominated by the surface tensions of the adjacent interfaces, and therefore it is a small correction in the Young equation or Neumann triangle. In contrast, the line tension of the boundary between two surface phases (see Fig. 2.1 l b and Eq. 2.75) is an effect of primary importance, which determines the shape and the stability of the respective contact lines.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
2.5.
99
REFERENCES
1.
P.S. Laplace, Trait6 de m6canique c61este; suppl6ments au Livre X, 1805.
2.
S. Ono, S. Kondo, Molecular theory of surface tension in liquids, in: S. Fltigge (Ed.), Handbuch der Physik, vol. 10, Springer, Berlin, 1960, p. 134.
3.
J.S. Rowlinson, B. Widom, Molecular Theory of Capillarity, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1982.
4.
J. Gaydos, The Laplace Equation of Capillarity, in: D. M6bius, R. Miller (Eds.) "Drops and Bubbles in Interfacial Research", Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1998.
5.
G.A. Korn, T.M. Korn, Mathematical Handbook, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1968.
6.
G. Arfken, Mathematical Methods for Physicists, Academic Press, London, 1970.
7.
A.J. McConnell, Application of Tensor Analysis, Dover, New York, 1957.
8.
R. Finn, Equilibrium Capillary Surfaces, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1986.
9.
L.D. Landau, E.M. Lifshitz, Fluid Mechanics, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1984.
10. H.M. Princen, The Equilibrium Shape of Interfaces, Drops, and Bubbles, in: E. Matijevic, (Ed.) Surface and Colloid Science, Vol. 2, Wiley, New York, 1969, p. 1. 11. S. Hartland, R.W. Hartley, Axisymmetric Fluid-Liquid Interfaces, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1976. 12. P.A. Kralchevsky, K.D. Danov, N.D. Denkov, Chemical Physics of Colloid Systems and Interfaces, in: K.S. Birdi (Ed.) Handbook of Surface and Colloid Chemistry, CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1997. 13. A.W. Adamson, Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, Wiley, New York, 1976. 14. P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, A.D. Nikolov, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 112 (1986) 108. 15. P.A. Kralchevsky, A.S. Dimitrov, K. Nagayama, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 160 (1993) 236. 16. P. Concus, J. Fluid Mech. 34 (1968) 481. 17. E. Jahnke, F. Emde, F. L6sch, Tables of Higher Functions, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1960. 18. M. Abramowitz, I.A. Stegun, Handbook of Mathematical Functions, Dover, New York, 1965. 19. B.V. Derjaguin, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 51 (1946) 517. 20. L.L. Lo, J. Fluid. Mech. 132 (1983) 65. 21. S.B.G. O'Brien, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 183 (1996) 51. 22. A. Scheludko, D. Exerowa, Kolloid-Z. 165 (1959) 148.
1O0
Chapter 2
23. A. Scheludko, Proc. Koninkl. Nederl. Akad. Wet., B65 (1962) 87. 24. A. Scheludko, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 1 (1967) 391. 25. K.J. Mysels, J. Phys. Chem. 68 (1964) 3441. 26. A. Hadjiiski, R. Dimova, N.D. Denkov, I.B. Ivanov, R. Borwankar, Langmuir 12 (1996) 6665. 27. I.B. Ivanov, A. Hadjiiski, N.D. Denkov, T.D. Gurkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, S. Koyasu, Biophys. J. 75 (1998) 545. 28. J. Plateau, Mere. Acad. Roy. Soc. Belgique 33 (1861), sixth series and preceding papers. 29. J.W. Gibbs, The Scientific Papers of J.W. Gibbs, Vol. 1, Dover, New York, 1961. 30. A.S. Dimitrov, P.A. Kralchevsky, A.D. Nikolov, D.T. Wasan, Colloids Surf. 47 (1990) 299. 31. G. Bakker, Kapillarit~it und Oberfl~ichenspannung, in: Handbuch der Experimentalphysik, Band 6, Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft, Leipzig, 1928. 32. I.B. Ivanov, P.A. Kralchevsky, A.D. Nikolov, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 112 (1986) 97. 33. J. Gaydos, A.W. Neumann, Thermodynamics of Axisymmetric Capillary Systems, in: A.W. Neumann & J.K. Spelt (Eds.) Applied Surface Thermodynamics, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1996, p. 53. 34. S. Ljunggren, J.C. Eriksson, P.A. Kralchevsky, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 191 (1997) 424. 35. T. Young, Philos. Trans. Roy. Soc. London 95 (1805) 55. 36. A. Dupr6, Theorie Mecanique de la Chaleur, Paris, 1869, p. 368. 37. J.C. Eriksson, S. Ljunggren, Langmuir 11 (1995) 2325. 38. P.A. Kralchevsky, Langmuir 12 (1996) 5951. 39. R. Shuttleworth, Proc. Phys. Soc. (London) A63 (1950) 444. 40. C. Herring, in: W.E. Kingston (Ed.) The Physics of Powder Metallurgy, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1951. 41. G.C. Benson, K.S. Yun, in: E.A. Flood (Ed.) The Solid-Gas Interface, Vol. 1, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1967. 42. J.C. Eriksson, Surface Sci. 14 (1969) 221. 43. A.I. Rusanov, Kolloidn. Zh. 39 (1977) 711; J. Colloid Interface Sci. 63 (1978) 330. 44. F.E. Neumann, in: A. Wangerin (Ed.) Vorlesungen tiber die Theorie der Kapillaritfit, Teubner, Leipzig, 1894, p. 161.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarit3'
101
45. F.P. Buff, H. Saltsburg, J. Chem. Phys. 26 (1957) 23. 46. F.P. Buff, in: S. Fltigge (Ed.) Encyclopedia of Physics, Vol. 10, Springer, Berlin, 1960, 298. 47. N.F. Miller, J. Phys. Chem. 45 (1941) 1025. 48. P.R. Pujado, L.E. Scriven, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 40 (1972) 82. 49. P.A. Kralchevsky, K.D. Danov, I.B. Ivanov, Thin Liquid Film Physics, in: R.K. Prud'homme (Ed.) Foams: Theory, Measurements and Applications, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1995, Section 3.3. 50. J.K. Spelt, E.I. Vargha-Butler, Contact Angle and Liquid Surface Tension Measurements, in: A.W. Neumann & J.K. Spelt (Eds.) Applied Surface Thermodynamics, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1996, p. 379. 51. B.A. Pethica, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 62 (1977) 567. 52. J.A. de Feijter, A. Vrij, J. Electroanal. Chem. Interfacial Electrochem. 37 (1972) 9. 53. L. Boruvka, A.W. Neumann, J. Chem. Phys. 66 (1977) 5464. 54. V.S. Veselovsky, V. N. Pertsov, Z. Phys. Khim. 8 (1936) 245. 55. I.B. Ivanov, B.V. Toshev, B.P. Radoev, in: J.F. Padday (Ed.) Wetting, Spreading and Adhesion, Academic Press, New York, 1978, p. 37. 56. G.A. Martynov, I.B. Ivanov, B.V. Toshev, Kolloidn. Zh. 38 (1976) 474. 57. B.A. Pethica, Rep. Prog. Appl. Chem. 46 (1961) 14. 58. A.I. Rusanov, Phase Equilibria and Surface Phenomena, Khimia, Leningrad, 1967 (in Russian); Phasengleichgewichte und Grenzfl~ichenerscheinungen, Akademie Verlag, Berlin, 1978. 59. S. Torza, S.G. Mason, Kolloid-Z. Z. Polym. 246 (1971) 593. 60. I.B. Ivanov, P.A. Kralchevsky, in: I.B. Ivanov (Ed.) Thin Liquid Films, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1988, p. 91. 61. P.M. Kruglyakov, in: I.B. Ivanov (Ed.) Thin Liquid Films, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1988, p. 767. 62. D. Exerowa, P.M. Kruglyakov, Foam and Foam Films, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1998. 63. A.D. Nikolov, D.T. Wasan, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, Ordered Structures in Thinning Micellar Foam and Latex Films, in: N. Ise and I. Sogami (Eds.) Ordering and Organisation in Ionic Solutions, World Scientific, Singapore, 1988, p. 302. 64. P.A. Kralchevsky, A.D. Nikolov, D.T. Wasan, I.B. Ivanov, Langmuir 6 (1990) 1180.
102
Chapter 2
65. H. M6hwald, Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 41 (1990) 441. 66. U. Retter, K. Siegler, D. Vollhardt, Langmuir 12 (1996) 3976. 67. M.J. Roberts, E.J. Teer, R.S. Duran, J. Phys. Chem. B 101 (1997) 699. 68. V.N. Paunov, P.A. Kralchevsky, N.D. Denkov, K. Nagayama, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 157 (1993) 100. 69. R. Aveyard, B.P. Binks, P.D.I. Fletcher, C.E. Rutherford, Colloids Surf. A 83 (1994) 89. 70. A.B. Ponter, A.P. Boyes, Canadian J. Chem. 50 (1972) 2419. 71. A.P. Boyes, A.B. Ponter, J. Chem. Eng. Japan 7 (1974) 314. 72. A.B. Ponter, M. Yekta-Fard, Colloid Polym. Sci. 263 (1985) 1. 73. M. Yekta-Fard, A.B. Ponter, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 126 (1988) 134. 74. D. Platikanov, M. Nedyalkov, V. Nasteva, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 75 (1980) 620. 75. J. Gaydos, A.W. Neumann, Line Tension in Multiphase Equilibrium Systems, in: A.W. Neumann & J.K. Spelt (Eds.) Applied Surface Thermodynamics, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1996, p. 169. 76. D. Li, Colloids Surf. A 116 (1996) 1. 77. J. Drelich, Colloids Surf. A 116 (1996) 43. 78. Y. Gu, D. Li, P. Cheng, Colloids Surf. A 122 (1997) 135. 79. A. Marmur, Colloids Surf. A 136 (1998) 81. 80. R.J. Good, M.N. Koo, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 71 (1979) 283. 81. N.K. Adam, The Physics and Chemistry of Surfaces, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1941. 82. R. Shuttleworth, G.L.J. Bailey, Discuss. Faraday Soc. 3 (1948) 16. 83. R.E. Johnson Jr., R.H. Dettre, in: E. Matijevic (Ed.) Surface and Colloid Science, Vol. 2, Wiley, New York, 1969, p. 85. 84. A. Marmur, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 50 (1994) 121. 85. F.Z. Preisach, Z. Phys. 94 (1935) 277. 86. D.H. Everett, W.I. Whitton, Trans. Faraday Soc. 48 (1952) 749. 87. R.J. Good, J. Phys. Chem. 74 (1952) 5041~ 88. J.A. Enderby, Trans. Faraday Soc. 51 (1955) 835. 89. R.E. Johnson Jr., R.H. Dettre, J. Phys. Chem. 68 (1964) 1744.
Interfaces of Moderate Curvature: Theory of Capillarity
103
90.
T.D. Blake, J.M. Haynes, in: J.F. Danielli et al. (Eds.) Progress in Surface and Membrane Science, Vol. 6, Academic Press, 1973, p. 125.
91.
J.D. Eick, R.J. Good, A.W. Neumann, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 53 (1975) 235.
92.
A.W. Neumann, in: J.F. Padday (Ed.) Wetting, Spreading and Adhesion, Academic Press, New York, 1978, p. 3.
93.
R.J. Good, in: R.J. Good & R.R. Stromberg (Eds.) Surface and Colloid Science, Vol. 11, Plenum Press, 1979, p. 1.
94.
I.D. Mayergoyz, Mathematical Models of Hysteresis, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1991.
95.
A. Marmur, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 168 (1994) 40.
96.
J. Drelich, J.D. Miller, R.J. Good, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 179 (1996) 37.
97.
G.A. Martynov, V.M. Starov, N.V. Churaev, Kolloidn. Zh. 39 (1977) 472.
98.
V.M. Starov, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 39 (1992) 147.
99.
K.D. Danov, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, Chapter 9 in: G. Broze (Ed.) Handbook of Detergents, Part A.: Properties, Surfactant Science Series, Vol. 82. Marcel Dekker, New York, 1999, Section V.C.
100. I.B. Ivanov, A.S. Dimitrov, A.D. Nikolov, N.D. Denkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 151 (1992) 446. 101. A.S. Dimitrov, A.D. Nikolov, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 151 (1992) 462. 102. I.B. Ivanov, P.A. Kralchevsky, A.S. Dimitrov, A.D. Nikolov, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 39 (1992) 77. 103. J. Mingins, A.D. Nikolov, Ann. Univ. Sofia Fac. Chem. 75 (1981) 3. 104. R. Aveyard, J.H. Clint, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 93 (1997) 1397. 105. A. Dussaud, M. Vignes-Adler, Langmuir 13 (1997) 581. 106. P. Chert, S.S. Susnar, A. Amirfazli, C. Mak, A.W. Neumann, Langmuir 13 (1997) 3035. 107. P. Chen, S.S. Susnar, C. Mak, A. Amirfazli, A.W. Neumann, Colloids Surf. A 129 (1997) 45. 108. L.A. Lobo, A.D. Nikolov, A.S. Dimitrov, P.A. Kralchevsky D.T. Wasan, Langmuir 6 (1990) 995, Figs. 10 and 13. 109. P.A. Kralchevsky, A.D. Nikolov, I.B. Ivanov. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 112 (1986) 132.
104
Chapter 2
110. A.D. Nikolov, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov. A New Method for Measuring Film and Line Tensions, in: K.L. Mittal & P. Bothorel (Eds.) Surfactants in Solution, Vol. 6, Plenum Press, New York, 1987, p. 1.537.
1 1 I . T.D. Gurkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, J. Disp. Sci. Technol. 18 (1997) 609. 1 12. P. Tarazona, G. Navascues, Physica A 1 1.5 (1982) 490. 1 13. G. Navascues, L. Mederos, Surf. Technol. 17 (1 982) 79.
I 14. T. Kolarov, Z.M. Zorin, Colloid J. USSR 42 (1980) 899. I 1.5. N.D. Denkov, D.N. Petsev, K.D. Danov, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 176 (1995) 189. 116. J.A. Wallace, S. Schurch, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 124 (1988) 4.52. 1 17. J.A. Wallace, S. Schurch, Colloids Surf. 43 (1990) 207. 118. J. Gaydos, A.W. Neumann, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 120 (1987) 76
119. D. Li, A.W. Neumann, Colloids Surf. 43 (1990) 19.5. 120. D. Duncan, D. Li, J. Gaydos, A.W. Neumann, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 169 (199.5) 2.56. 121. A. Amirfazli, D.Y. Kwok, J. Gaydos, A.W. Neumann, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 20.5 (1998) 1.
122. Y. Gu, D. Li, P. Cheng, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 180 (1996) 212. 123. A.V. Nguyen, H. Stechemesser, G. Zobel, H.J. Schulze, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 187 ( 1 997) 547. 124. R. Finn, M. Shinbrot, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 123 (1987) 1. 12.5. S.D. Iliev, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 194 (1997) 287. 126. S.D. Iliev, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 2 13 (1 999) 1.
105
CHAPTER 3 SURFACE BENDING MOMENT AND CURVATURE ELASTIC MODULI
This chapter is devoted to a generalization of the theory of capillarity to cases, in which variations of the interfacial (membrane) curvature give an essential contribution to the total energy of the system. An interface (or membrane) possesses 4 modes of deformation" dilatation, shearing, bending and torsion. The first couple of modes represent two-dimensional analogues of respective deformations in the bulk phases. The bending and torsion modes are related to variations in the two principle curvatures of the interface, that is to the presence of two additional degrees of freedom. From a thermodynamic viewpoint, the curvature effects can be accounted for as contributions of the work of interfacial bending and torsion to the total energy of the system; the respective coefficients are the interfacial (surface) bending and torsion moments, B and |
The most popular model of the interfacial curvature effects provides
an expression for the mechanical work of flexural deformation, which involves 3 parameters: bending and torsion elastic moduli, kc and k C, and spontaneous curvature, H0. Initially we consider the simpler case of spherical geometry. The dependence of the bending moment B on the choice of the dividing surface at fixed physical state of the system is investigated. The connection between the quantities bending moment, Tolman length and spontaneous curvature is demonstrated. Micromechanical expressions are derived, which allow one to calculate the surface tension and the bending moment if an expression for the pressure tensor is available. From the viewpoint of the microscopic theory, various intermolecular forces may contribute to the interfacial moments B, |
and to the curvature elastic moduli, kc and kc. Such are the van
der Waals forces, the steric and electrostatic interactions. The interfacial bending moment may give an essential contribution to the interaction between deformable droplets in emulsions. In general, the curvature effects are expected to be significant for interfaces of low tension and high curvature, including biomembranes.
106
Chapter 3
3.1.
BASIC THERMODYNAMIC EQUATIONS FOR CURVED INTERFACES
3.1.1.
INTRODUCTION
The curvature dependence of the interfacial tension was first investigated by Gibbs in his theory of capillarity [1 ]. The approach of Gibbs has been further developed by Tolman [2], who established that such curvature dependence appears for sufficiently small liquid drops or gas bubbles, whose radii are comparable with the so called Tolman length, ~o" The latter represents the distance between the surface of tension and the equimolecular dividing surface, see Chapter 1. Further development in the thermodynamics of curved interfaces was given in the works of Koenig [3] and Buff [4-6]. Kondo [7] investigated how the choice of dividing surface affects the surface thermodynamic parameters; see also Refs. [8-11 ]. An additional interest in the curvature effects has been provoked by the studies on microemulsions [12-20]. The biomembranes, lipid bilayers and vesicles represent another class of systems, for which the curvature effects play an essential role on the background of a low interfacial tension. The predominant number of works on lipid membranes is based on the mechanics of shells and plates, originating from the studies by Kirchhoff [21], Love [22], see also Refs. [23-25], and on the related theory of liquid crystals [26-28], rather than on the Gibbs thermodynamics. The mechanics of biomembranes is a complex and rich in phenomena field, whose importance is determined by the fact that such membranes are basic structural and physiological element of the cells of all living organisms. In particular, in Chapter 10 below we apply the mechanics of curved interfaces to describe theoretically the membrane-mediated interaction between proteins incorporated in a lipid bilayer.
3.1.2.
MECHANICAL WORK OF INTERFACIAL DEFORMATION
First we will make an overview of the most important equations in the thermodynamics of the curved interfaces. The work of deformation of an elementary parcel, AA, of a the boundary between two fluid phases, can be expressed in the form [29-31 ] (5%= 7 fi a + ~ fi fl + B 6 H + O fi D ,
&-
~AA)/AA
(3. l)
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
107
Here 5Ws is the mechanical work of deformation per unit area of the phase boundary; 5o~ is the relative dilatation (increase of the area) of the surface element AA. If 5u~1 and ~tt22 are the two eigenvalues of the surface strain tensor, then 5 a and 513 can be expressed as follows: ~ a -- I~Ull -k- ~tt22 ,
(3.2)
~/~ = (~Ull-- I~b/22
see also Eq. (4.22) below. Consequently, 5o~ and 513 characterize the isotropic and the deviatoric part of the surface strain tensor. In particular, 513 characterizes the interfacial deformation of shear, see Fig. 3.1. Likewise, the surface curvature tensor has two eigenvalues, Cl and c2, representing the two principal curvatures; then 1 n - -~(c I nt- c 2 ),
1
O = ~(c,- ce)
(3.3)
are the mean and deviatoric curvature; the latter is a measure for the local deviation from the spherical shape.
Dilation
A//~~NkC~
D Bending
Shear
Reference State
B
D
C
A
A
B
D
Reference State
C
Torsion
Fig. 3.1. Modes of deformation of a surface element: dilatation, shear, bending and torsion.
Chapter 3
108
Equation (3.1), without the term ~Sfl, was first formulated in the classical work by Gibbs [1 ], and without the curvature terms - in the study by Evans & Skalak [25]. In particular, ? a a is the work of pure dilatation (aft = 0; &?l
= (~72 = 0 ) ;
~
is
the work of pure shearing (ao~ = 0;
(~1 = (~}C2 = 0), BaH is the work of pure bending (&l = &2; ao~ = aft = 0) and OaD is the work
of pure torsion (&l = -&2; ao~ = aft = 0), termed also "work of saddle-shape deformation", see Fig. 3.1. Correspondingly, B and | are called the interfacial bending and torsion moments [15]. Often in the literature the Gaussian curvature
K = c1c2 = H 2 _
(3.4)
D 2
is being chosen as an independent thermodynamic parameter, instead of the deviatoric curvature D; then Eq. (3.1) is transformed in the equivalent form
aw~ = ?~o~ + {afl + CIaH + C2~K
(3.5)
Equation (3.5), without the term ~ f l , is used in the works by Boruvka & Neumann [32] and Markin et al. [33]. A comparison between Eqs. (3.1) and (3.5) yields [31,34]: B = C 1+
2 C 2 H,
|
= - 2C 2D
(3.6)
Equation (3.1) is more convenient to use for spherical interfaces (D = 0), and Eq. (3.5) - for cylindrical interfaces (K = 0). Below we will follow the Gibbs approach, and will use H and D as thermodynamic variables; the latter have a simple geometric meaning (Fig. 3.1), and the respective moments B and | have the same physical dimension, in contrast with C 1 and C 2. In general, the surface moments B and | depend on the curvature. The latter dependence can be expressed in an explicit form by introducing some model of the interfacial flexural theology. The following rheological constitutive relation, introduced by Helfrich [23,24], is frequently used in literature
W f - 2kc(H-Ho)2+ k--cK
(3.7)
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
109
Here wf is the work of flexural deformation per unit area of the interface" Ho, k c and k c are constant parameters of the rheological model" H0 is called the spontaneous curvature, k c and k c are the bending and torsion (Gaussian) surface elastic moduli. From Eq. (3.1) it follows
awf-
(3.8)
BaH + OaD
Combining Eqs. (3.4), (3.7) and (3.8) one derives [34,35]
B-
I 3H
6)
D - B~ + 2(2kc+k-c)H'
_(<) ~ c3D
H - - 2kcD
(3.9)
where Bo = -4kc Ho
(3.1 O)
is an expression for the bending moment of a planar interface in the framework of the Helfrich model. In general, Eqs. (3.9) can be interpreted as truncated power expansions of B and O for small deviations from planar interface (small H and D; quadratic and higher-order terms neglected). On the other hand, the original Helfrich formula, Eq. (3.7), has been postulated to give the leading term in the power expansion of wf in the case when H is close to H0. If the values of B0 and k c are known for a planar interface (H = 0) and then H0 is formally calculated from Eq. (3.10), there is no guarantee that the obtained result for H0 could be physically interpreted as a spontaneous curvature, i.e. that for H = H0 the free energy of flexural deformation wf has a minimum. In other words, if Eq. (3.8) is integrated, along with Eq. (3.9), in general there is no guarantee that the integration constant will be equal to 2 k c H g , cf. Eq. (3.7).
3.1.3.
FUNDAMENTAL THERMODYNAMICEQUATION OF A CURVED INTERFACE
Let us consider an elementary interfacial parcel of area dA. The Gibbs excesses of internal energy, entropy and number of molecules from the/-the species, corresponding to this parcel, are dU,-
uL,.dA,
dS,-
s, dA,
d~,-
co, dA,
d N 7 - FidA,
(3.11)
Chapter 3
110
where u s, s s, cos and
F i are
surface densities of the respective quantities. Further, let the area dA
of the elementary parcel increases with (3.12)
5 ( d A ) - 5 ( d A ) dA - 5o~ dA dA
due to the occurrence of some thermodynamic process. The Gibbs approach to nonuniform interfaces consists in application of the fundamental equation of an uniform interface locally, i.e. to every element dA of the nonuniform interface [1 ]. (Of course, this approach is more general and applicable to any nonuniform phases, not necessarily curved interfaces.) Thus, in the course of a thermodynamic process the variations of the parameters in Eq. (3.11) obey the fundamental equation k
8 ( d U s) : T(~(dS s ) + E l t i d ( d N
s) + 8W s
(3.13)
i=1
where T and ]-/i a r e the temperature and chemical potential, and 6Ws is the mechanical work of deformation of the surface element dA. In keeping with Eq. (3.1) one can write [30, 31 ]: (SW , = (Sws dA = (y (Sa + ~ (S fl + B (SH + | 6 D ) dA
(3.14)
With the help of Eqs. (3.11) and (3.12) one obtains =
+ ,. 6
)da
(3.15)
Similar expressions can be deduced also for dS, and dNi ~ . In this way the fundamental equation (3.13) can be transformed to read [29-31 ] k
aus - T(Sss + ~__,,uiaFi + ( 7 - c o , ~ o ~ + ~ [ 3 + B a H + |
(3.16)
i=1
where k
co, - u , - Ts, -~_~ It i F i
(13.17)
i=1
is the surface excess of the grand thermodynamic potential. Differentiation of Eq. (3.17) and substitution of the result for ~u, in Eq. (3.16) yields
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
111
k
~ co - - s , ~ T - ~__ F ~~ t.t i + O, - co , )~ a + ~ (~ ,13 + B (~H + | ~ D
(3.18)
i=1
If the interface can be treated as a t w o - d i m e n s i o n a l f l u i d , then the interfacial tension equals the density of the surface excess grand thermodynamic potential [1] ? ' - co,
(3.19)
Equation (3.19) can be obtained in the following way. Imagine an elementary interfacial parcel of area dA, whose boundary is a contour permeable for the transport of all components. An imaginary process of expansion of this contour at constant intensive parameters (#T = 0, ~#i = 0, ~13 = 0, ~H = 0, ~D = 0) leads to enlargement of the parcel owing to the transfer of molecules across the permeable boundary line. In the course of this process matter with the same intensive properties, and especially with the same co,, is added to the considered parcel. Then, setting &o, = 0 in Eq. (3.18) we arrive at Eq. (3.19). If the interface represents such a two-dimensional fluid, then Eq. (3.19) is valid irrespective of whether components, which are insoluble in the bulk phases, are present at the interface. In this case, from Eqs. (3.18) and (3.19) we obtain a generalizes version of the Gibbs adsorption equation: k
~y--s,.~T-~_Fi~l.t
, +~fl
+ B~H
+|
(3.20)
i=1
cf. Eq. (1.35). It is worthwhile noting that the sign of B and | is a matter of convention. It is determined by the choice of the direction of the running unit normal to the interface, n. From the differential geometry it is known that the surface tensor of curvature, b, can be defined as the surface gradient of n [36]: b = -V~n
(3.21)
The latter equation is known also as the Weingarten's formula [37]. Since the principal curvatures, cl and cx, are the eigenvalues of b, then in view of Eqs. (3.3) and (3.21) an inversion of the direction of n will lead to a change of the sign of H and D. Moreover, ~wf in
112
Chapter 3
Eq. (3.8) must not depend on the choice of direction of n; consequently, the inversion of the direction of n leads also to an inversion of the sign of B and |
From Eq. (3.8) it could be
realized that a positive B tends to bend the interface around the inner phase, that is the phase for which n is an outer normal. The latter rule is general, i.e. it is independent of the choice of the direction of n.
3.2.
THERMODYNAMICS OF SPHERICAL INTERFACES
3.2.1.
DEPENDENCE OF THE BENDING MOMENT ON THE CHOICE OF DIVIDING SURFACE
Spherical fluid interfaces are often observed due to the fact that the spherical shape corresponds to minimal surface energy if the gravitational deformation is negligible. After Gibbs [1] an interface can be modeled as a mathematical dividing surface separating two bulk phases. As noticed in Chapter 1, in reality there is a narrow transitional zone between the two phases, whose thickness could be from few angstroms to dozens of angstroms. For that reason, a problem arises about the exact definition of the position of the dividing surface. From symmetry considerations it follows that in the case of spherical interface the dividing surface must be a sphere. However, an additional condition must be imposed to uniquely define the radius of this sphere. It can be proven [7,8] that for an arbitrary definition of the spherical dividing surface the following two equations hold:
d w , = 7dc~ +
a
+
~a
-~a d a
- P~ -PI~
(3.22)
(3.23~
Here a is the radius of the dividing surface, PI and PII are the pressures, respectively, inside and outside the spherical drop (bubble, vesicle); [O~/Oa] is a formal derivative of )'with respect to the radius a; here and hereafter the brackets symbolize formal derivatives, which correspond to an imaginary variation of the choice of a at fixed physical state of the system. The comparison of Eqs. (3.22) and (3.1) (the latter for ~fl= 0, ~D = 0 and a = - l / H ) yields [29-31]:
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
B - a 2 [ ~ l-~-a '
113
(3.24)
that is the formal derivative turns out to be proportional to the bending moment B. One way to uniquely define the dividing surface is to impose the additional condition the formal derivative of y to be always equal to zero:
- 0
(3.25)
a -a x
This special dividing surface, introduced by Gibbs [1], is called the surface of tension, cf. Eq. (1.13); here its radius is denoted by a,. For this dividing surface Eq. (3.23) reduces to the common capillary equation of Laplace: = PI - Pn
(3.26)
a s
Eliminating P I - Pn between Eqs. (3.23) and (3.26) we obtain
dy
2 +-ydx x
2-
0
(3.27)
where we have introduced the notation
x-
a/a,,
y-y/y,
(3.28)
The solution of Eq. (3.27), satisfying the boundary condition y(1) = 1, reads 1
y ( x ) - 3x 2
2
+ -x 3
(3.29)
The latter equation, first derived by Kondo [7], describes the dependence of the interfacial tension yon the choice of the dividing surface at fixed physical state of the system. From Eqs. (3.24), (3.28) and (3.29) one can deduce a similar dependence for the bending moment B [29]: B -
B
2ya
=
x 3 -1 2x 3 + 1
(3.30)
Chapter 3
114
y,B
4
3 . ~ .... ".......... i .... i ..... i .... i ..... i ..... i..... i ..... ..... i ..... i .... i ..... i ..... '..... i..... '..... i ..... i .... i ..... i .... i ..... i ..... i..... i..... ..... i..... i .... 3 2.5 2 1.5 1
i
,.
0.5
:
:
" .....................
i .....................
0
.............................................
.--~---~------~-
......
- 1
-1.5
......
~
.
.
O.
~
i
" .....................
" ......................
" ....
-
-o.5 ...................-~--~..............i...... B = i
B/(2ya)
...~........................................................................
.............................. ~...................... ~.............................................................................................. .
.
.
.
.
.
0.5
.
0.9
'
1.3
.
.
.
. . 1.7
.
.
. . 2.1
.
.
.
2.5
2.9
x = a/as
Fig. 3.2. Dependence of the thermodynamic interfacial tension, 7, and the dimensionless bending moment, B , on the choice of the dividing surface (of radius a) for a fixed physical state of the system. Equations (3.29) and (3.30) are illustrated graphically in Fig. 3.2. In accordance with Eq. (3.25), the surface of tension corresponds to the minimum of the curve 7 vs. a. Moreover, the dimensionless bending moment, B , which takes part in the Laplace equation, 2y (1 + B ) = PI - e l i ,
( 3 . 3 1 )
a
cf. Eq. (3.23), (3.24) and (3.30), turns out to be a function of a with bounded variation (Fig. 3.2). In addition, one could verify that the dependence B vs a,
B
-
2(a2asl a
--#Ysas
,
(3.32)
as
which stems from Eqs. (3.28)-(3.30), satisfies the differential equation [31]
E
-~a
- 27,
(3.33)
which is analogous to Eq. (3.24). The surface of tension turns out to be convenient in many cases, because it simplifies the shape of the Laplace equation, which determines the shape of interfaces in the capillary hydrostatics,
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
115
see Chapter 2. On the other hand, as noticed by C. Miller [17], in the case of low interfacial tension (critical emulsions, microemulsions, lipid vesicles, biomembranes) the mathematical surface of tension is situated away from the physical transition zone between the two phases; see also eq. (3.62) below. In such a case, which is equivalent to the presence of essential contribution from the interfacial bending moment, it is appropriate to use the equimolecular dividing surface.
3.2.2.
EQUIMOLECULAR DIVIDING SURFACE AND TOLMAN LENGTH
As mentioned above, an additional condition must be imposed to define uniquely the radius of the dividing surface. Instead of setting the formal derivative [O~'/Oa] equal to zero, as it is for the surface of tension, one could require the formal derivative to be equal to the physical derivative, viz.
(3.34) 7aa ~=av -- ~av
where a v is the radius of the dividing surface defined by Eq. (3.34), termed the e q u i m o l e c u l a r dividing surface [2,3,6,8]; see also Section 1.2.2 above. The partial derivative 0~4/Oav is related to the physical dependence of ~'v on av for fixed values of the other thermodynamic parameters of state. Different possible choices of the latter parameters correspond to different definitions of av. The distance (~ = a v -
(3.35)
as
between the surface of tension and the equimolecular dividing surface is called the Tolman length. Tolman [2] has derived the equation
,0/120 )
(3.36)
a v
Y0 -
lim ?'v, a v ---~oo
~0 = lim a v ----)oo
(3.37)
116
Chapter 3
which expresses in first approximation the physical dependence of Yv on the interfacial curvature. Setting a = av in Eq. (3.32) and expanding in series for &lay << 1 we obtain [38]:
2ro, o +... The next terms in the expansion (3.38) can be found only if the dependence ~ = g)(av) is known. From Eqs. (3.36) and (3.38) we deduce B0
7'v - 7o
- + ....
B 0 - B,,la~ - 2)'o~ 0
(3.39)
a v
The last equation allows estimates for the magnitude of Bo to be made. For example, for the surface of liquid argon at temperature -188.85~
we have ~'0 = 13.45 raN/m, & = 3.6 A, see
Ref. [39], and then from Eq. (3.39) we compute B0 = 9.7 x 10 -12 N. Equation (3.39) demonstrates the connection between the Tolman length, &, and the bending moment B0, which in its own turn is proportional to the Helfrich's spontaneous curvature H0, see Eq. (3.10); all these quantities are related to the curvature dependence of the surface tension. Another relationship between the Tolman length and the parameters of the equimolecular dividing surface can be obtained in the following way. From Eqs. (3.28) and (3.29) one can deduce
Vav - s/2 -
+
- 3
3a v
/
(3.40)
Likewise, from Eqs. (3.26), (3.30) and (3.31) we obtain 27' v av
+
Bv 2
av
=
27' s
(3.41)
as
The elimination of ~/as between Eqs. (3.40) and (3.41), along with Eq. (3.35), yields the sought for expression for ~ [31 ]"
- a~. 1 -
)'v-By/av ?'v +5i Bv / av
(3.42)
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
117
Equation (3.42) shows that the sign of ~ is connected with the sign of Bv: indeed, one could verify that Eq. (3.42) yields g)v > 0 for By > 0, and vice versa, & < 0 for Bv < 0.
3.2.3.
MICROMECHANICAL APPROACH
Mechanical definitions of surface tension and bending moment. The hydrostatic approach to the theoretical description of curved interfaces has been developed by Buff [5], Ono & Kondo [8] and Rusanov [9]. Owing to the spherical symmetry, the pressure tensor can be expressed in the form [8]
P = PN erer + Pr(eoeo + % % )
(3.43)
where (r, 0, q~) are polar coordinates with center in the center of spherical symmetry; e r, e 0 and e~0 are the unit vectors of the curvilinear local basis; PN and P:r represent the normal and tangential component of the tensor P with respect to the spherical interface. Let us consider a part of the system, which is confined between two concentric spheres of radii rl and r2, see Fig. 3.3. The total force acting on the shaded sectorial strip (Fig. 3.3) is [8] r2
(3.44)
dO I PT rdr rl
see Fig. 3.3 for the notation. The respective force moment is given by the expression r2
dO I PT r2 dr
(3.45)
rl
Following Gibbs [1] we define an idealized (model) system consisting of one spherical dividing surface of radius a and two bulk fluid phases, I and II, which are uniform and isotropic up to the very dividing surface. The pressure in the idealized system can be expressed in the form
~-={PI for eli for
r
(3.46) r>a
As noted in Chapter 1 (Figs. 1.1 - 1.3) the pressure tensor P is not isotropic in a vicinity of an interface. To compensate this difference between the real and the idealized system, the dividing
118
Chapte r 3
Ztd0
Z
\
X
(a)
O-
\
~
~
(b)
/
~
_IM
~
rl
I
/
Y~
v
Fig. 3.3. Sketch of the real and idealized systems, and of the sectorial strip (shaded) used to give a mechanical definition of the surface tension, o', and the bending moment, M.
surface is treated as a membrane with surface (membrane) tension o" and surface bending moment M, see Fig. 3.3b. Then the counterparts of Eqs. (3.44) and (3.45) for the idealized system are [311" r~ dO ~ -firdr - crdO
(13.47)
rl
r2
dO
f -fir 2dr - ~ a - d O
+ MadO
(3.48)
rl
To make the idealized system mechanically equivalent to the real one, we require that the force and the moment acting on the sectorial strip in the two systems (Fig. 3.3) to be equal. Thus setting equal the expressions in Eqs. (3.44) and (3.47) we obtain
oa - f (P--Pr)rdr rl
Likewise, from Eqs. (3.45) and (3.48) we derive
(3.49)
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
0-a 2 -
M a - f (-fi-Pr )r2dr
119
(3.50)
I"1
In the above mechanical derivation we deliberately have used the notation o- and M for the
mechanical surface tension and moment. Indeed, it is not obligatory the latter to coincide with their
thermodynamic analogues, y and B, defined by Eq. (3.1). Relationship between the mechanical and thermodynamical surface tension. Under
conditions of hydrostatic equilibrium the divergence of the pressure tensor is zero, that is V.P = O. In the considered case of spherical symmetry the latter equation yields [39] d
~tr(r2 pN )= 2rPr
(3.51)
Integrating the latter equation we derive
IPrrdr=2(Pnr22-pIq2 )
(3.52)
rl
Substituting Eqs. (3.46) and (3.52) into (3.49) we obtain a version of the Laplace equation" 20-
a
(3.53)
= P~-P.
The comparison of Eqs. (3.53) and (3.3 l) yields B
? ' - 0-
(3.54)
2a
To find a unique relationship between the couple of mechanical parameters (0-, M) and the couple of thermodynamical parameters (y, B) we need a second relationship, in addition to Eq. (3.54). Such an equation can be obtained in the following way. Let us consider a purely lateral displacement of the conical surface depicted in Fig. 3.3a. The work of this displacement, carried out by the outer forces, is [8] p~
r2
dW - - f (Pr 2ffrsin Odr)rdO - - door Pr r2 dr rl
rI
(3.55)
120
Chapter 3
where 27r
d m - sin OdO f dq9 = 2Jr sin0 dO
(3.56)
0
is the increment of the spatial angle at the vertex of the cone corresponding to the considered infinitesimal displacement of the lateral surface. An alternative expression for dW is provided by thermodynamics [8]"
dW - - P I dVI - Pn dVn + ydA
(3.57)
where V~ and Vn represent the volumes of phases I and II, and A is the area of the spherical dividing surface. By means of geometrical considerations one obtains a
dVi - dco f dr r 2" q
r2
dVit - doo f d r r 2 a
dA=a2 dco
(3.58)
Setting equal the two expressions for dW, Eqs. (3.55) and (3.57), and using Eqs. (3.46) and (3.58), one deduces [8] r2
(3.59) rl
Finally, by comparing Eqs. (3.50) and (3.59) we obtain the sought for second equation connecting the mechanical and thermodynamical parameters" y=cr
M
(3.60)
Equations (3.54) and (3.60) imply the following relationship between B and M: B = 2M
(3.61)
Generalized versions of Eqs. (3.54) and (3.61) for an arbitrarily curved interface are derived below, see Eqs. (4.79) and (4.81). Equation (3.54) shows that for a curved interface there is a difference between the mechanical and thermodynamical surface tension. This difference is zero only if the dividing surface is defined as surface of tensions, for which B = 0 by definition, cf. Eq. (3.25). However, from a
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
121
physical viewpoint the surface of tension not always provides an adequate description of the real phase boundary or membrane. To demonstrate the latter fact we will use the equation [31 ] 3
~-a v 1-
1/3
O-v - TBv / a v
(3.62)
O" v
which follows from Eqs. (3.54) and (3.42). For interfaces of low interfacial tension, Ov--+0, e.g. microemulsions or lipid membranes, Eq. (3.62) gives ~---~ ,,% that is the surface of tension is situated far away from the real boundary between the two phases; see also Ref. [ 17].
Micromechanical expressions for ~, 7 and B. The functions Pu(r) and Pr(r) provide a micromechanical description of the stresses acting in the transitional zone between the two neighboring phases [5]. Such a description takes an intermediate position between the
macroscopic description in terms of quantities like o, 7 and B, and the microscopic description in terms of the correlation functions of the statistical mechanics, see e.g. Refs. [39-42]. Convenient for applications are expressions which represent the macroscopic parameters as integrals of the function
AP(r) = PN (r)- PT (r),
(3.63)
AP(r) characterizes the anisotropy of the pressure tensor P in a vicinity of the phase boundary, see Eqs. (1.8) and (1.12), as well as Figs. 1.2 and 1.3. For a spherical interface Buff [5] has derived the expression
7,-
i
r2 AP (r)--Tdr,
r~
(3.64)
as
which is valid only for the surface of tension. Below we describe the derivation of other micromechanical expressions obtained in Ref. [31], which are valid for an arbitrary choice of the spherical dividing surface. Equation (3.51)can be represented in the form
dPN - 2AP dr
r
(3.65)
122
Chapter
3
The integration of Eq. (3.65), along with Eq. (3.53), yields r2
~r - S Ap a
(3.66)
r
rl
The latter equation specifies that the analogous expression, derived by Goodrich [43], refers to the mechanical surface tension, o, rather than to the thermodynamical one, y. Further, from Eqs. (3.46) and (3.59) we obtain ae
-
l a 3 (PI
3
-
PH ) -
r: -31 (plr13-pllr32)-fPTr2dr
(3.67)
!-1
On the other hand, the integration of Eq. (3.51 ) yields re
re
2fPTr2dr-Pi,
rzS-Piq3-~PNredr
rl
(3.68)
rl
With the help of Eqs. (3.53), (3.66) and (3.68) one can eliminate PI and Pu from Eq. (3.67)
[31].
i ,r)l ar -+U ldr
(3.69)
rl
In accordance with Eq. (3.24) we differentiate Eq. (3.69) to derive a micromechanical expression for the interfacial bending moment B [31 ]"
2 zXP(r) B _ ~rl
/a / --r
a
dr
(3.70)
The same expression for B can be obtained by substitution of the expressions for cr and ?', Eqs. (3.66) and (3.69), into Eq. (3.54). Moreover, the differentiation of Eq. (3.70), in accordance with Eq. (3.33), leads to Eq. (3.69). The latter facts demonstrate that the theory is selfconsistent. Equations (3.66), (3.69) and (3.70), which are valid for an arbitrary choice of the spherical dividing surface, have been used in Refs. [44, 45] to calculate the contribution of the van der Waals forces to the interfacial bending moment B.
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
123
3.3.
R E L A T I O N S W I T H T H E M O L E C U L A R T H E O R Y AND T H E E X P E R I M E N T
3.3.1.
CONTRIBUTIONS DUE TO VARIOUS KINDS OF INTERACTIONS
A typical example for an electrically charged fluid interface is shown in Fig. 3.4: the surface charge is due to the presence of an adsorption layer of ionic surfactant. Upon bending of the interface (decrease of the radius a of the equimolecular dividing surface) the distance between the charges of the surface-active ions increases. This is energetically favorable owing to the presence of repulsive forces between ions of the same electric charge. As a result, a surface bending moment appears, which tends to bend the interface around the non-aqueous phase. In reality, not only the electrostatic interactions, but also other type of forces contribute to the interfacial bending and torsion moments; such are the van der Waals forces and the steric interactions between the hydrophilic headgroups and the hydrophobic tails of the surfactant molecules (Fig. 3.4). From Eq. (3.16) it follows
B
~ OH
s,,v~,a,fi,D
Insofar as the van der Waals, the electrostatic, and the steric interactions can be considered to be independent, they give additive contributions to the surface density of the internal energy u~. Then, from Eq. (3.71) it follows that these interactions give also additive contributions to the interfacial bending and torsion moments, B - B ~w + B ~l + B st ,
O --O ~w +O ~1 +O st
(3.72)
Here and hereafter the superscripts "vw", "el" and "st" denote terms related to the corresponding interactions. In view of Eqs. (3.9) and (3.72) B0, kc and k C can be expressed in the form Bo
-
l:~ VW
el
st
--0 +B0 + B 0 ,
kc-kc
vw
el
st
+kc +kc ,
--
--wv
--el
--st
k,.-k c +k C +k C
On the other hand, having in mind Eq. (3.10), one sees that the spontaneous curvature,
(3.73)
124
Chapter 3
B ov w + B(~t + B~t H0 = -
(3.74)
4(kc"w + k~el + k st )
is not additive with respect to contributions from the various interactions; instead, H0 represents a ratio of additive quantities. In Ref. [45] an expression for the van der Waals contribution, Bo w, to the bending moment of the boundary between two fluid phases has been derived:
B~
5
1
~5JrAn
(3.75)
AH _ ~2 (O, l l p 2 _ 20~12/91P2 A- Of22P 2)
(3.76)
Here 7'0 is the interfacial tension of the planar boundary between the two pure fluids (without surfactants) AH is the Hamaker constant, p~ and /92 are the number densities of the two neighboring phases, a;k are the constants in the van der Waals potential: ui~ = -ai~/r6;
the
subscripts "1" and "2" refer to the phase inside and outside the fluid particle, respectively. In general, Bo w tends to bend around the phase, which has a larger Hamaker constant [45]. Equation (3.75) has been derived by means of Eq. (3.70) and an appropriate model expression for the anisotropy of the pressure tensor, AP. For an oil-water interface Eq. (3.75) predicts Bow = 5 • 10-11N. Theoretical expressions for k~ w and k~.w are not available in the literature. The contribution of the steric interaction can be related to the size and shape of the tails and headgroups of the surfactant molecules [46-53]. The following expression was proposed [52] for such amphiphiles as the n-alkyl-poly(glycol-ethers), (CzH4)n(OCHzCH2)mOH:
Bg' = -
where ~ - ( n -
lr Zv 2b~ kT
4a M 4
gr Zv3 b k T k~ t = ~ ( 1 64a M 5
+ lZg')
(3.77)
m ) / ( n + m) characterizes the asymmetry of the amphiphile, v is the volume of
an amphiphile molecule, aM is the interfacial area per molecule, k is the Boltzmann constant, b is a molecular length-scale in the used self-consistent field model [52].
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
125
o t 1
/
/ (a) Fig. 3.4.
(b)
Sketch of a "molecular condenser" of thickness d, which is formed (a) from adsorbed surfactant ions and their counterions and (b) from adsorbed zwitterionic surfactant. The dividing surface (of radius a) is chosen to be the boundary between the aqueous and the nonaqueous phase; l~ and 12 are the distances from the "charged" surfaces to the dividing surface.
Expressions for the electrostatic components of the bending moment, B~ t , and the curvature elastic moduli, k~,' and k~e' , have been also derived. For example, one can relate B~' , k~' and k~.~l to the surface Volta potential, AV, which is a directly measurable parameter [54]:
1 + --d--
e d (AV)2 /
k, '-
ce'
.
. . 24rc
.
(3.78)
II 112 / l + 3--d + 3 ~Z-
d
+3
(3.79)
/ d2
(3.80)
Here e is the dielectric constant, d is the distance between the positive and negative charges; the other notation is explained in Fig. 3.4. In Eqs. (3.78) - (3.80) AV must be substituted in CGSE-
Chapter 3
126
units, i.e. the value of AV in volts must be divided by 300. Note that AV expresses the change of the surface potential due to the presence of an adsorption monolayer. AV can be measured by means of the methods of the radio-active electrode or the vibrating electrode [55], which give the change in the electric potential across the interface. Equations ( 3 . 7 8 ) - (3.80) could be used when the model of the "molecular condenser" is applicable, viz.: (i) when there is an adsorption layer of zwitterions or dipoles, such as nonionic and zwitterionic surfactants or lipids, at the interface; (ii) when the electrolyte concentration is high enough and the counterions are located in a close vicinity of the charged interface to form a "molecular capacitor"; (iii) when the surface potential is low: then the Poisson-Boltzmann equation can be linearized and the diffuse layer behaves as a molecular capacitor of thickness equal to the Debye screening length [56]. For example, taking experimental value of the Volta potential for zwitterionic lipids [57], AV = 350 mV, and assuming e = 78.2, d - 5 ' ,
ll/d << 1, from Eqs. (3.78) - (3.80) one calculates B~/ =
4.2 x 10 -11 N, k el = 1.4 x 10-20 J and k~Yt = - 0 . 7
x
10-20 J.
Since, B~t , kf / and k~Y~ are proportional to (AV) 2 their sign does not depend on the sign of the surface potential AV. For oil-water interface Bo t and Bo w have the same sign: both of them tend to bend the interface around the oil phase. In contrast, for air-water interface B~l and Bo w have the opposite signs: B~l bends around the gas phase, while B~w bends around the water phase (the phase of higher Hamaker constant). Equations ( 3 . 7 8 ) - (3.80) show also that B~l, k~land k~Y/ depend on the choice of the Gibbs dividing surface through the distances Ii and 12. Moreover, if d
-
12-11
> 0, then k~yt is
positive, whereas k~ ~ is negative and k-~Y~ = - k f z/2. It is interesting to note that the same relationship, k-~YI = - k [ 1/2, has been obtained by Ennis [51] in the framework of a quite different model taking into account the steric interactions. The surface charge density o,, i.e. the electric charge Q per unit area of the "plate" of the molecular condenser (Fig. 3.4), is simply related to AV:
Surface Bending M o m e n t and Curvature Elastic Moduli
127
Q eAV as . . . . A 4rd
(3.81)
Then a substitution of AV from (3.81) into Eqs. (3.78) - (3.80), in view of the identity d = 12- 1~, leads to Bo I - ~2zr o ' , 2 (12z - l()
(3.82)
E
ke t
- 4reOs2
k~fl _
9
1
-2kc
el
(3.83)
As mentioned in Chapter 1, see Fig. 1.4, the double electric layer consists of a Stern layer and a diffuse layer, composed, respectively, of bound and free counterions. Correspondingly, the bending moment and the curvature elastic moduli are composed of contributions from these two layers [31,58]" Bo I
1~Stn l~ dif = "-'o + ~o ,
kcel = kcStn + kcdif ,
--el -- Stn -kc = kc + kc dif
(3.84)
If the Stern layer is situated at a distance 12 from the dividing surface, then it can be proven [31 ] that n-'0 9 Stn , kcStn and ~?tn . can be expressed by analogues of Eqs. (3.82) and (3.83)
BStn 0
2re _2 (122
-
-
~O-s 6
l 2) -
(3.85)
-
kS],, _ 47c a ~2(l 3 - 13 ), 3e
k2stn --
1
k cStn
(3.86)
2
where, as before, 1~ is the distance between the surface charges and the dividing surface, see Fig. 3.4a. In the case of low surface electric potential, the Poisson-Boltzmann equation, describing the diffuse electric double layer (see Chapter 1) can be linearized. In such a case it turns out that the counterions can be treated as being situated at a distance 12 + ts-1 from the dividing surface, where U l is the Debye length, see Eq. (1.56) and (1.64)" the derived expressions for Bo l, k,el and k~ 1 in this case are [31]
Clrcrpier-3
128
BG'
771 =-af[(12+K-l)2-If]
(3.87)
&
(3.88) The latter equations look like Eqs. (3.82)-(3.83) in which
12
is formally replaced by
(12
+ K-').
In accordance with Eq. (3.84) the respective contributions of the diffuse part of the electric double layer can be obtained by subtraction of Eqs. (3.85)-(3.86) from their counterparts among Eqs. (3.87)-( 3 38):
2n B t f =--0'(21, &
K-' + K - ? )
(low surface potential)
(3.89)
(3.90)
In the case of moderate and high surface electric potentials the expressions related to the Stern layer- Eqs. (3.85)-(3.86) can be applied again, whereas Eqs. (3.89)-(3.90) are no longer valid. In this more complicated case expressions for B,d", k:1- and
FF have been derived by means
of a thermodynamic approach 1311, and independently in Ref. [59] by using a hydrostatic approach based on Eqs. (3.146), (4.149j and (4.150'1 - see below. The results are [3 1,581
K-
Here
1
(3.91)
is the bulk concentration of a Z : Z electrolyte; x and y are quantities related to the
C~J
surface potential as followx
(3.94)
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
129
In the latter expression the signs "+" and " - " refer to an electric double layer, respectively, inside an aqueous drop and outside a non-aqueous drop (bubble). Setting 12 = 0, that is
neglecting the distance between the equimolecular dividing surface and the surface of location of the bound counterions, Eqs. (3.91)-(3.93) are reduced to the expressions derived by Lekkerkerker [59]. Numerical calculations based on Eqs. (3.84)-(3.86) and (3.91)-(3.93) show that Bo t is dominated by ~0Rst", i.e. by the contribution of the Stern layer, whereas k,el and k~.~t contain a considerable contribution from the diffuse layer, that is from k{ 1if and k-flU . The magnitude of B~l, k~land k-c~l is higher for lower electrolyte concentrations. For example, for co = 10-5 M one computes B~l-- 5 x 10-11 N, k~/~ 1 x 10-19 J and ~-e/=-3 x l0 -19 J [58].
3.3.2.
BENDING MOMENT EFFECTS ON THE INTERACTION BETWEEN DROPS IN EMULSIONS Interaction between deforming emulsion drops. The collisions between the drops in an
emulsion are accompanied with a flattening in the zone of contact between such two drops, see Fig 3.5. The conditions for the formation of a flat film between two similar droplets have been studied by Danov et. al. [60] and Denkov et al. [61]. A modeling of the shape of a deformed drop with portions of a sphere and a plane (Fig. 3.5) proved to be a very good approximation [62]. Despite the fact that area of the formed flat film is relatively small, its appearance leads to a strong enhancement (with dozens of kT) of the energy of interaction between the two drops.
I I
h' Fig. 3.5. Scheme of two emulsion drops deformed upon collision; the magnitude of the radius, r, of the formed flat film and its thickness, h, are exaggerated.
130
Chapter 3
We have in mind interactions due to the various components of the disjoining pressure: electrostatic, van der Waals, steric, depletion, oscillatory-structural, etc., see Chapter 5 for details. It has been taken into account [61,63] that if an initially spherical droplet deforms at fixed volume, its surface area increases, which gives rise to an effective interdroplet repulsion. Moreover, work of flexural (bending) deformation is conducted when the initially spherical interface in the zone of contact is converted into the planar surface of the film (Fig. 3.5). To estimate this work one can use Eq. (3.7); viz. by expanding Eq. (3.7) in series, keeping linear terms with respect to the curvature one obtains [63] WT ( H ) - 2re r 2 w f = 27r r 2 (2k CH 2 + B o l l + . . . ) ,
( r / a ) 2 << 1.
(3.95)
cf. Eq. (3.10); here r is the radius of the flat film; the multiplier 2 accounts for the fact that the film has two surfaces. The increment of W T , which is due to the formation of a flat film, is A W f = WT (O) - Wu ( H ) - - 21r r2 Bo H + O ( H 2 ) - 21r r 2 Bo / a + . . .
(3.96)
The bending moment can be estimated as follows: I B0l = I Bo w + B~tl -- 5 • 10-1IN, see the numerical values given above in this chapter. Using the latter value together with k T = 4 . 1 x l 0 -21 J (room temperature) and a tentative value r - - a ~ 2 0 ,
from Eq. (3.96) we
estimate
Consequently, for emulsion drops of radii 10 --6cm < a < 10 -4cm the contribution of the interfacial bending moment to the energy of interaction between two drops will be 2 k T < I A W f f < 200 k T . In other words, we arrive at the conclusion that the interfacial bending
moment B0 could be important for the interactions between sub-gin, and even lure-sized, drops [63]. This conclusion is intriguing insofar as it is usually believed that the bending energy is essential only for objects of very high interfacial curvature, like the nuclei of a new fluid phase and the droplets in microemulsions. It should be also noted that B0 > 0 for emulsions type "oil-in-water", whereas B 0 < 0 for emulsions type "water-in-oil". Consequently, in view of Eq. (3.96) the energy of interfacial
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
131
bending deformation contributes to a repulsion between oil drops in water (AWr > 0), but to an attraction between water drops in oil (AW r < 0 ) [63]. For example, Koper et al. [64] have observed formation of doublets (with energy of bonding = l0 kT ) from aqueous microemulsion drops dispersed in oil; this phenomenon could be attributed, at least in part, to the effect of AWf < O. Interactions between drops in double emulsions. As mentioned above, the effect of the interfacial bending moment B0 can be important for emulsion systems of low interfacial tension. It has been demonstrated by Binks [65], that after intensive stirring in such systems one could observe a simultaneous formation of emulsion and microemulsion drops, see Fig. 3.6. Having in mind the above discussion, one expects that AWu > 0 helps for stabilization of the formed emulsion. Indeed, for AWT > 0 the bending moment opposes the flattening of the drops in the contact zone thus decreasing the probability for formation (and consecutive rupturing) of a thin liquid film between two colliding droplets; in other words, the bending moment counteracts the coalescence of emulsion drops. It is reasonable to assume that the condition AWl > 0 is fulfilled for the microemulsion drops, which do not increase their size with time, despite the intensive Brownian collisions between them. For the system depicted in Fig. 3.6a the microemulsion drops are in the continuous phase, i.e. the emulsion and microemulsion drops have the same sign of the curvature. Therefore, one could expect that
9 (a)
(b)
Fig. 3.6. Sketch of an emulsion drop coexisting with smaller microemulsion drops (a) in the continuous and (b) in the disperse phase. The running unit normal to the interface, n, is directed from phase 1 toward phase 2.
Chapter3
132
AWI > 0 for the emulsion drops, as well. On the contrary, for the system depicted in Fig. 3.6b, that is the microemulsion drops are in the
disperse phase, the emulsion and microemulsion
drops have the opposite sign of the curvature, which is determined by the direction of the unit normal n, see Eq. (3.21). Hence, if
A WI > 0 for the micro-emulsion drops, then A Wf < 0 for
the emulsion drops. Consequently, for the system in Fig. 3.6b the bending moment contributes to an
attraction between the emulsion drops and favors their coalescence.
According to Davies and Riedal [66] both types of emulsions, those from Fig. 3.6a,b and 3.6b, are formed upon stirring. That type of emulsion survives, for which the coalescence is slower. If the effect of the interfacial bending moment dominates the interactions between the emulsion droplets, one can expect that the emulsion in Fig. 3.6a will survive [63]. In fact, this is observed experimentally; viz. the emulsion which contains microemulsion drops in the continuous phase is more stable [65]. It is worthwhile noting that in emulsions the effect of the interfacial bending moment acts simultaneously with other type of interactions between the droplets, such as the surface forces of various origin: van der Waals interactions, electrostatic (double-layer), steric, depletion, oscillatory-structural, hydration and other forces. For that reason, the analysis of the stability of an emulsion needs a careful estimate of the relative contributions of various factors to the dropdrop interaction energy; see Ref. [67] for details. It should be also noted that the bending effects may influence the stability of an emulsion when the rupturing of thin emulsion films happens through nucleation of pores, see e.g. Ref. [68].
3.4.
SUMMARY
An interface (or membrane) possesses 4 modes of deformation: dilatation, shearing, bending and torsion (Fig. 3.1). The first couple of modes represent two-dimensional analogues of respective deformations in the bulk phases. The bending and torsion modes are related to variations in the two principle curvatures of the interface, that is to the presence of two additional degrees of freedom. From a
thermodynamic viewpoint, the curvature effects can be
accounted for as contributions of the work of interfacial bending and torsion to the total energy
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
133
of the system; the respective coefficients are the interfacial (surface) bending and torsion moments, B and |
see Eq. (3.1). The most popular model of the interfacial curvature effects
provides an expression for the mechanical work of flexural deformation, Eq. (3.7), which involves 3 parameters: bending and torsion elastic moduli, kc and k C, and spontaneous curvature, H0. First we have considered the simpler case of spherical geometry. The dependence of the bending moment B on the choice of the dividing surface at fixed physical state of the system is investigated, see Eq. (3.32), (3.33) and Fig. 3.2. The connection between the quantities bending moment, Tolman length and spontaneous curvature has been demonstrated, see Eqs. (3.10) and (3.39). Micromechanical expressions, Eqs. (3.69) and (3.70), allow one to calculate the surface tension and the bending moment if an expression for the pressure tensor is available. From the viewpoint of the microscopic theory, various intermolecular forces may contribute to N
the interfacial moments B, |
and to the curvature elastic moduli, k~ and k c , see Eqs. (3.72)
and (3.73). Such are the van der Waals forces, Eq. (3.75), the steric interactions, Eq. (3.77) and the electrostatic interactions, Eqs. (3.78)-(3.80) and (3.82)-(3.93). The interfacial bending moment may give an essential contribution to the interaction between deformable droplets in emulsions, see Eq. (3.96). In general, the curvature effects are expected to be significant for interfaces of low tension and high curvature. An example are the biomembranes, which usually have low tension. The present chapter is an introduction to the next Chapter 4, in which the general theory of curved interfaces and biomembranes is considered.
3.5.
REFERENCES
1. J.W. Gibbs, The Scientific Papers of J.W. Gibbs, Vol. 1, Dover, New York, 1961. 2. R.C. Tolman, J. Chem. Phys. 17 (1949) 333. 3. F.O. Koenig, J. Chem. Phys. 18 (1950) 449. 4. F.P. Buff, J. Chem. Phys. 19 (1951) 1591. 5. F.P. Buff, J. Chem. Phys. 23 (1955) 419.
134
Chapter 3
6. F.P. Buff, The Theory of Capillarity, in: S. Fltigge (Ed.), Handbuch der Physik, Vol. X, Springer, Berlin, 1960. 7. S. Kondo, J. Chem. Phys. 25 (1956) 662. 8. S. Ono, S. Kondo, Molecular Theory of Surface Tension in Liquids, in: S. Fltigge (Ed.), Handbuch der Physik, vol. 10, Springer, Berlin, 1960, p. 134. 9. A.I. Rusanov, Phase Equilibria and Surface Phenomena, Khimia, Leningrad, 1967 (in Russian); Phasengleichgewichte und Grenzfl~ichenerscheinungen, Akademie Verlag, Berlin, 1978. 10. J.S. Rowlinson, B. Widom, Molecular Theory of Capillarity, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1982. 11. J. Gaydos, Y. Rotenberg, L. Boruvka, P. Chen, A.W. Neumann, The Generalized Theory of Capillarity, in: A.W. Neumann & J.K. Spelt (Eds.) Applied Surface Thermodynamics, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1996, p. 1. 12. J.E. Bowcott, J.H. Schulman, Z. Elektrochem. 59 (1955) 283. 13. J.H. Schulman, J.B. Montagne, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 92 (1961) 366. 14. W. Stoeckenius, J.H. Schulman, L.M. Prince, Kolloid-Z. 169 (1960) 170. 15. C.L. Murphy, Thermodynamics of Low Tension and Highly Curved Interfaces, Ph.D. Thesis (1966), University of Minnesota, Dept. Chemical Engineering); University Microfilms, Ann Arbour, 1984. 16. M.L. Robbins, in: K.L. Mittal (Ed.) Micellization, Solubilization and Microemulsions, Vol. 2, Plenum Press, New York, 1977. 17. C.A. Miller, J. Dispersion Sci. Technol. 6 (1985) 159. 18. P.G. de Gennes, C. Taupin, J. Phys. Chem. 86 (1982) 2294. 19. J.Th.G. Overbeek, G.J. Verhoeckx, P.L. de Bruyn, H.N.W. Lekkerkerker, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 119 (1987) 422. 20. N.D. Denkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, C.S. Vassilieff, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 143 (1991) 157. 21. G. Kirchhoff, Crelles J. 40 (1850) 51. 22. A.E.H. Love, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A 179 (1888) 491. 23. W. Helfrich, Z. Naturforsch. 28c (1973) 693. 24. W. Helfrich, Z. Naturforsch. 29c (1974) 510. 25. E.A. Evans, R. Skalak, Mechanics and Thermodynamics of Biomembranes, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, 1979.
Surface Bending Moment and Curvature Elastic Moduli
135
26. P.G. de Gennes, Physics of Liquid Crystals, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1974. 27. H.W. Huang, Biophys. J. 50 (1986) 1061. 28. A.G. Petrov, The Lyotropic State of Matter: Molecular Physics and Living Matter Physics, Gordon & Breach Sci. Publishers, Amsterdam, 1999. 29. I.B. Ivanov, P.A. Kralchevsky, in: I.B. Ivanov (Ed.) Thin Liquid Films, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1988, p. 91. 30. P.A. Kralchevsky. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 137 (1990) 217. 31. T.D. Gurkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, Colloids Surf. 47 (1990) 45. 32. L. Boruvka, A.W. Neumann, J. Chem. Phys. 66 (1977) 5464. 33. V.S. Markin, M.M. Kozlov, S.I. Leikin, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 2, 84 (1988) 1149. 34. P.A. Kralchevsky, J.C. Eriksson, S. Ljunggren, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 48 (1994) 19. 35. S. Ljunggren, J.C. Eriksson, P.A. Kralchevsky, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 161 (1993) 133. 36. C.E. Weatherburn, Differential Geometry of Three Dimensions, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1939. 37. A.J. McConnell, Application of Tensor Analysis, Dover, New York, 1957. 38. P.A. Kralchevsky, T.D. Gurkov, I.B. Ivanov. Colloids Surf. 56 (1991) 149. 39. J.G. Kirkwood, F.P. Buff, J. Chem. Phys. 17 (1949) 338. 40. J.H. Irving, J.G. Kirkwood, J. Chem. Phys. 18 (1950) 817. 41. T.L. Hill, An Introduction to Statistical Thermodynamics, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1962. 42. F.M. Kuni, A.I. Rusanov, in: The Modern Theory of Capillarity, A.I. Rusanov & F.C. Goodrich (Eds.), Akademie Verlag, Berlin, 1980. 43. F.C. Goodrich, in: Surface and Colloid Science, Vol. 1, E. Matijevic (Ed.), Wiley, New York, 1969; p. 1. 44. P.A. Kralchevsky, T.D. Gurkov, Colloids Surf. 56 (1991) 101. 45. T.D. Gurkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, I.B. Ivanov, Colloids Surf. 56 (1991) 119. 46. J.L. Vivoy, W.M. Gelbart, A. Ben Shaul, J. Chem. Phys. 87 (1987) 4114. 47. I. Szleifer, D. Kramer, A. Ben Shaul, D. Roux, W. M. Gelbart, Phys. Rev. Lett.60 (1988) 1966. 48. S.T. Milner, T.A. Witten, J. Phys. (Paris) 49 (1988) 1951.
136
Chapter 3
49. I. Szleifer, D. Kramer, A. Ben Shaul, W.M. Gelbart, S. Safran, J. Phys. Chem. 92 (1990) 6800. 50. Z.G. Wang, S. A. Safran, J. Chem. Phys. 94 (1991) 679. 51. J. Ennis, J. Chem. Phys. 97 (1992) 663. 52. N. Dan, P. Pincus, S.A. Safran, Langmuir 9 (1993) 2768. 53. P.A. Barneveld, J.M.H.M. Scheutjens, J. Lyklema, Langmuir 8 (1993) 3122; Langmuir 10 (1994) 1084. 54. P.A. Kralchevsky, T.D. Gurkov, K. Nagayama, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 180 (1996) 619. 55. A.W. Adamson, A.P. Gast, Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, Wiley, New York, 1997. 56. J.Th.G. Overbeek, Electrochemistry of the Double Layer, in: Colloid Science, Vol. 1, H. R. Kruyt, Ed., Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1953. 57. S.A. Simon, T.J. McIntosh, A.D. Magid, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 126 (1988) 74. 58. P.A. Kralchevsky, Curved Interfaces and Capillary Forces between Particles, Thesis for Doctor of Science, Faculty of Chemistry, University of Sofia, Sofia, 2000. 59. H.N.W. Lekkerkerker, Physica A 167 (1990) 384. 60. K.D. Danov, N.D. Denkov, D.N. Petsev, I.B. Ivanov, R.P. Borwankar, Langmuir 9 (1993) 1731. 61. N.D. Denkov, D.N. Petsev, K.D. Danov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 (1993) 3326. 62. N.D. Denkov, D.N. Petsev, K.D. Danov, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 176 (1995) 189. 63. D.N. Petsev, N.D. Denkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 176 (1995) 201. 64. G.J.M. Koper, W.F.C. Sager, J. Smeets, D. Bedeaux, J. Phys. Chem. 99 (1995) 13291. 65. B.P. Binks, Langmuir 9 (1993) 25. 66. J.T. Davies, E. K. Rideal, Interfacial Phenomena, Academic Press, New York, 1963. 67. I.B. Ivanov, K.D. Danov, P.A. Kralchevsky, Colloids Surf. A 152 (1999) 161. 68. A. Kabalnov, H. Wennerstr6m, Langmuir 12 (1996) 276.
137
CHAPTER 4 GENERAL CURVED INTERFACES AND BIOMEMBRANES
Mechanically, the stresses and moments acting in an interface or biomembrane can be taken into account by assigning tensors of the surface stresses and moments to the phase boundary. The three equations determining the interfacial/membrane shape and deformation represent the three projections of the vectorial local balance of the linear momentum. Its normal projection has the meaning of a generalized Laplace equation, which contains a contribution from the interfacial moments. Alternatively, variational calculus can be applied to derive the equations governing the interfacial/membrane shape by minimization of a functional - "the thermodynamic approach". The correct minimization procedure is considered, which takes into account the work of surface shearing. Thus it turns out that the generalized Laplace equation can be derived following two alternative approaches: mechanical and thermodynamical. In fact, they are mutually complementary parts of the same formalism; they provide a useful tool to verify the selfconsistency of a given model. The connection between them has the form of relationships between the mechanical and thermodynamical surface tensions and moments. Different, but equivalent, forms of the generalized Laplace equation are considered and discussed. The general theoretical equations can give quantitative predictions only if theological constitutive relations are specified, which characterize a given interface (biomembrane) as an elastic, viscous or visco-elastic two-dimensional continuum. Thus the form of the generalized Laplace equation can be specified. Further, it is applied to determine the axisymmetric shapes of biological cells; a convenient computational procedure is proposed. Finally, micromechanical expressions are derived for calculating the surface tensions and moments, the bending and torsion elastic moduli, kc and k C, and the spontaneous curvature, H0, in terms of combinations from the components of the pressure tensor.
Chapter4
138
4.1.
THEORETICAL APPROACHES FOR DESCRIPTION OF CURVED INTERFACES
A natural mathematical description of arbitrarily curved interfaces is provided by the differential geometry based on the apparatus of the tensor analysis. Our main purpose in this chapter is to demonstrate the application of this apparatus for generalization of the relationships described in Section 3.2 for spherical interface. Firstly, the generalization of the theory includes presentation of the surface stresses and moments as tensorial quantities. Secondly, generalizations of the theoretical expressions, such as the Laplace equation and the micromechanical expressions (3.69)-(3.70), are considered. A special attention is paid to the connection between the two equivalent and complementary approaches: the thermodynamical and the mechanical one.
The thermodynamical approach to the theory of the curved interfaces, which is outlined in Sections 3.1 and 3.2 above, originates from the works of Gibbs [1] and has been further developed by Boruvka & Neumann [2]. In this approach a heterogeneous (multiphase) system is formally treated as a combination of bulk, surface and linear phases, each of them characterized by its own fundamental thermodynamic equation. The logical scheme of the Gibbs' approach consists of the following steps: (1) The extensive parameters (such as internal energy U, entropy S, number of molecules of the i-th component Ni, etc.) and their densities far from the phase boundaries are considered to be, in principle, known. (2) An imaginary idealized system is introduced, in which all phases (bulk, surface and linear) are uniform, the interfacial transition zones are replaced with sharp boundaries (geometrical surfaces and lines), and the excesses of the extensive parameters (in the idealized with respect to the real system) are ascribed to these boundaries; for example - see Figs 1.1 and 3.3. (3) The Gibbs fundamental equations are postulated for each bulk, surface and linear phase. Since the densities of the extensive parameters can vary along a curved interface, a Local formulation of the fundamental equations should be used, see Eq. (3.13). (4) The last step is to impose the conditions for equilibrium in the multiphase system. These are (i) absence of hydrodynamic fluxes (mechanical equilibrium) (ii) absence of diffusion fluxes
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
139
(chemical equilibrium) and (iii) absence of heat transport (thermal equilibrium). As known [3], the conditions for thermal and chemical equilibrium imply uniformity of the temperature and the chemical potentials in the system. The conditions for mechanical equilibrium are multiform; examples are the Laplace and Young equations (Chapter 2). All conditions for equilibrium can be deduced by means of a variational principle, that is by minimization of the grand thermodynamic potential of the system, see Chapter 2 and Section 4.3.1.
The mechanical approach originates from the theory of elastic deformations of "plates" and "shells" developed by Kirchhoff [4] and Love [5]; a comprehensive review can be found in Ref. [6]. For the linear theory by Kirchhoff and Love it is typical that the stress depends linearly on the strain, and that the elastic energy is a quadratic function of the deformation. Similar form has Eq. (3.7), postulated by Helfrich [7,8], which expresses the work of flexural deformation as a quadratic function of the variations of the interfacial curvatures. Evans and Skalak [9] demonstrated that a relatively complex object, as a biomembrane, can be treated mechanically as a two-dimensional continuum, characterized by dilatational and shearing tensions, and elastic moduli of bending and torsion. The logical scheme of the mechanical approach consists of the following steps: (1) Strain and stress tensors, as well as tensors of the moments (torques), are defined for the bulk phases and for the boundaries between them. A phase with a (nonzero) tensor of moments is termed continuum of Cosserat [10]; the liquid crystals represent an example [11]. Here we will restrict our considerations to bulk fluid phases without moments; action of moments will be considered only at the interfaces. (2) Equations expressing the balances of mass, linear and angular momentum are postulated; they provide a set of differential equations and boundary conditions, which describe the dynamics of the processes in the system. In particular, the Laplace equation (2.17) can be deduced as a normal projection of the interfacial balance of the linear momentum; see Eq. (4.51) below and Refs. [ 12-14]. (3) The properties of a specific material continuum are taken into account by postulating appropriate theological constitutive relations, which define connections between stresses (or moments) and strains. In fact, the rheological constitutive relations represent mechanical
Chapter 4
140
models, say viscous fluid, elastic body, visco-elastic medium, etc. In Section 4.3.4 we demonstrate that the Helfrich equation (3.7) leads to a constitutive relation for the tensor of the interfacial moments. In summary, the thermodynamical and the mechanical approaches are based on different concepts and postulates, but they are applied to the theoretical description of the same subject: the processes in multiphase systems. Then obligatorily these two approaches have to be equivalent, or at least complementary. One of our main goals below is to demonstrate the connections between them. The combination of the two approaches provides a deeper understanding of the meaning of quantities and equations in the theory of curved interfaces (membranes) and provides a powerful apparatus for solving problems in this field. Below we first present the mechanical approach to the curved interfaces and membranes. Next we consider the connections between the thermodynamical and mechanical approaches. Further, we give a derivation of the generalized Laplace equation by minimization of the free energy of the system. A special form of this equation for axisymmetric interfaces is considered with application for determination of the shape of biological cells. Finally, some micromechanical expressions for the interfacial (membrane) properties are derived.
4.2.
M E C H A N I C A L APPROACH TO ARBITRARILY CURVED INTERFACES
4.2.1.
A N A L O G Y WITH MECHANICS OF THREE-DIMENSIONAL CONTINUA
Balance of the linear momentum. First, it is useful to recall the "philosophy" and basic equations of the mechanics of three-dimensional continua. Consider a material volume V, which is bounded by a closed surface S with running outer unit normal n. On the basis of the second Newton's law it is postulated (see e.g. Ref. 15) d dt f dV p v - ~ dsn . T + f dV p f v
S
(4.1)
v
Here t is time, v is the velocity field; T is the stress tensor; ds is a scalar surface element; p is the mass density; f is an acceleration due to body force (gravitational or centrifugal). Equation
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
(4.1) expresses the
integral balance
141
of the linear momentum for the material volume V; indeed,
Eq. (4.1) states that the time-derivative of the linear momentum is equal to the sum of the surface and body forces exerted on the considered portion of the material continuum. Using the Gauss theorem and the fact that the volume V has been arbitrarily chosen, from Eq. (4.1) one
local balance
can deduce the
of the linear momentum [ 15]:
dv p ~ = V-T + pf
(4.2)
dt
In the derivation of Eq. (4.2) the following known hydrodynamic relationships have been used:
d !dVpvdt
@ dt
~-+
ldvId(pv) v L dt
+ pvV. vI
pV. v = 0
(4.3)
(4.4)
Equation (4.3) is a corollary from the known Euler formula, whereas Eq. (4.4) is the continuity equation expressing the local mass balance [15].
Rheological models.
The continuum mechanics can give quantitative predictions only if
a model expression for the stress tensor T is specified. As a rule, such an expression has the form of relationship between stress and strain, which is termed rheological constitutive relation (defining, say, an elastic or a viscous body, see below). The vectors of displacement, u, and velocity, v, are simply related: du v=~
(4.5)
dt
Further, the strain and rate-of-strain tensors are introduced: = [ g u + ( g u ) T]
kit --[Vv +(Vv) T]
(strain tensor)
(4.6)
(rate-of-strain tensor)
(4.7)
As usual, V denotes the gradient operator in space and "T" denotes conjugation. The tensors and ~ are related as follows: = ~ 8t Here 8t denotes an infinitesimal time interval.
(4.8)
142
Chapter 4
An elastic body is defined by means of the following constitutive relation [ 16] T = ~ Tr(O)U + 2/~ [ O - .~1Tr(O) U]
(Hooke's law)
(4.9)
where U is the spatial unit tensor; ,~ and/1 are the dilatational and shear bulk elastic moduli; as usual, "Tr" denotes trace of a tensor. Note that ,~ and/,t multiply, respectively, the isotropic and the deviatoric part of the strain tensor O. (The trace of the deviatoric part is equal to zero, i.e. no dilatation, only shearing deformation). Similar consideration of the isotropic part (accounting for the dilatation) and deviatoric part (accounting for the shear deformation) is applied also to viscous bodies and two-dimensional continua (interfaces, biomembranes), see below. The substitution of Eq. (4.9) into the balance of linear momentum, Eq. (4.2), along with Eq. (4.6), yields the basic equation in the mechanics of elastic bodies [I 6]:
dZu 1/t)VV u + f p T t ~ - ~ v ~ . + (x+~9 p
(Navier equation)
(4.10)
Likewise, a viscous body (fluid) is defined by means of the constitutive relation [ 17] T = - P U + ~'vTr(~) U + 2 r/v [~ - ~Tr(~) U]
(Newton's law)
(4.11 )
where P is pressure, ~'v and r/v are the dilatational and shear bulk viscosities; in fact r/v is the conventional viscosity of a liquid, whereas ~',, is related to the decay of the intensity of sound in a liquid. The substitution of Eq. (4.11) into the balance of linear momentum, Eq. (4.2), along with Eq (4.7), yields the basic equation of hydrodynamics [15, 17]: P dv d--t - _Vp+rlvVZv + (~'v +~r/v )VV-v + p f
(Navier-Stokes equation)
(4.12)
In Section 4.2.4 we will consider the two-dimensional analogues of Eqs. (4.1)-(4.12). Before that we need some relationships from differential geometry.
4.2.2.
BASIC EQUATIONS FROM GEOMETRY AND KINEMATICS OF A CURVED SURFACE
The formalism of differential geometry, which is briefly outlined and used in this chapter, is described in details in Refs. [12, 18-20]. Let (u I ,u 2) be curvilinear coordinates on the dividing surface between two phases, and let R(ul,uZ,t) be the running position-vector of a material
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
143
point on the interface, which depends also on the time, t. We introduce the vectors of the surface local basis and the surface gradient operator:
3R
a~
= ~
3u ~ ,
V -a ~'~ s
c?
( / t = l 2)
9u"
'
(4.13)
Here and hereafter the Greek indices take values 1 and 2; summation over the repeated indices is assumed. The curvature tensor b is defined by Eq. (3.21); b is a symmetric surface tensor, whose eigenvalues are the principal curvatures c~ and c2. The surface unit tensor U, and curvature deviatoric tensor q are defined as follows
1
U, =a/~ a ~ ,
q =-~ (b-HU,)
(4.14)
where, as before, H and D denote the mean and deviatoric curvature, see Eq. (3.3). For every choice of the surface basis the eigenvalues of Us are both equal to 1; the tensor q has diagonal form in the basis of the principal curvatures and has eigenvalues 1 a n d - 1 . In particular, the covariant components of Us, a~v = a/~. a v
(4.15)
represent the components of the surface metric tensor; here "-" is the standard symbol for scalar product of two vectors. The covariant derivative of auv is identically zero, a;~u,v = 0, whereas the covariant derivative q,~,.v of the components of the tensor q is not zero, although its eigenvalues are constant at each point of the interface; in particular, the divergence of q is [ 13]:
q,~u,~ _ 1 (a,~uH ~
-D
-q~.uD '~ )
(4.16)
In view of Eq. (4.14), the curvature tensor can be expressed as a sum of an isotropic and a deviatoric part:
bzu = H a;w + Dqxu The velocity of a material point on the interface is defined as follows
(4.17)
144
Chapter 4
(4.18) II
, Ll
According to Eliassen [21], the interfacial rate-of-strain tensor, which describes the twodimensional dilatational and shear deformations, is defined by the expression:
du v _-10auv _-2~Vu,vl" 2 ~t 2
+ Vv _ 2buy v ('))' '~
(4.19)
v~ - a v. v 9
v (n) = n. v
(4.20)
where
are components of the velocity vector v. Despite the fact that we will finally derive some quasistatic relationships, it is convenient to work initially with the rates (the time derivatives) of some quantities. For example, if ~t is a small time interval and /-;/ is the time derivative of the mean curvature then ~H = H~t is the differential of H, which takes part in Eq. (3.1). We will restrict our considerations to processes, for which the rate-of-strain tensor has always diagonal form in the basis of the principal curvatures. For example, such is the case of an axisymmetric surface subjected to an axisymmetric deformation [9]. A more general case is considered in Ref. [22]. In such cases the quantities ~ and fl, defined by the relationships
r
av duv,
fi = q/~V duv,
(4.21)
express the local surface rates of dilatation and shear [23]. Then, the infinitesimal deformations of dilatation and shearing, corresponding to a small time increment, ~St, will be ~o~ = a ~ t;
~fl = fi ~ t
(4.22)
The latter two differentials also take part in Eq. (3.1). In view of Eq. (4.21) we can present duv as a sum of an isotropic and a deviatoric part 1
duv - 2 6~auv +2 ~ quv
(4.23)
145
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
4.2.3.
TENSORS OF THE SURFACE STRESSES AND MOMENTS
Owing to the connections between stress and strain, an expression similar to Eq. (4.23) holds for the surface stress tensor [24]" (4.24)
0"uv - 0" auv + 77 q~v
(Each of Eqs. 4.23 and 4.24 represent the respective tensor as a sum of an isotropic and a deviatoric part.) Let 0"1 and 0"2 be the eigenvalues of the tensor 0"uv. The tensions 0"1 and 0"2 are directed along the lines of maximum and minimum curvature. From Eq. (4.24) it follows 1 0. -- --(0.1 -'1-0" 2 )"
1 77 -- 7 (0"1 -- 0"2)
2
(4.25)
n
----//,
l_ t3"11
M12
(a)
(b)
n
2 N21 u
,ii;
"- N22
N12
Nil
(c)
Fig. 4.1. Mechanical meaning of the components of (a) the surface stress tensor, O'uuand o'u(n)" (b) the tensor of surface moments Muv" (c) the tensor of surface moments Nuv. The relationship between Muv and Nuv is given by Eq. (4.29).
146
Chapter 4
In fact, the quantity 0- is the conventional mechanical surface tension, while r/is the mechanical shearing tension [9,24]. The physical meaning of the components 0-~v (/t,v = 1,2) in an arbitrary basis is illustrated in Fig. 4.1. Note that in general the surface stress tensor ~ is not purely tangential, but has also two normal components, o"~n~,/t = 1,2, see Refs. [6, 12]" ffq_ - a~av0- ~v + a/~no"/~(n)
(4.26)
In other words, the matrix of the tensor __ffis rectangular:
_ (0..11 0.12 0-1(n)] O" [0.21 0.22 0.2(n)
(4.27)
Let us consider also the tensor of the surface moments (torques), 1 M/a v - ~ ( M 1
1 + M z ) ajav +-~ (M 1 - M z )
(4.28)
qjav ,
which is defined at each point of the interface; M1 and M2 are the eigenvalues of the tensor Muv supposedly it has a diagonal form in the basis of the principal curvatures. In the mechanics of the curved interfaces the following tensor is often used [6, 12] (4.29)
N~v = M ,a, ev,~
where euv is the surface alternator [19]" el2-qt-a -, e 2 1 - - ~ a ,
ell = e 2 2 - - 0 "
a is the
determinant of the surface metric tensor auv, see Eq. (4.15) The mechanical meaning of the components of the tensors Muv and Nuv is illustrated in Fig. 4.1b,c. One sees that N~l and N22 are normal moments (they cause torsion of the surface element), while N~2 and N21 are tangential moments producing bending. In this aspect there is an analogy between the interpretations of Nuv and 0-uv (Fig. 4.1 a). Indeed, if v is the running unit normal to a curve in the surface (v is tangential to the surface), then the stress acting per unit length of that curve is t - v.~ and the moment acting per unit length is m - v.N. On the other hand, as seen from Eqs. (4.28) and (4.29), the tensor Nuv is not symmetric. For that reason the symmetric tensor Muv is often preferred in the mechanical description of surface moments [6, 9]. A necessary condition for mechanical equilibrium of an interface is
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
buv Nuv - e aft ~
147 (4.30)
,
which expresses the normal resultant of the surface balance of the angular momentum; see also Eq. (4.44) below. Substituting O'nv from Eq. (4.24) and Nnv from Eqs. (4.28)-(4.29) into Eq. (4.30) one could directly verify that the latter condition for equilibrium (with respect to the acting moments) is satisfied by the above expressions for Ouv and Nu,,.
4.2.4.
SURFACE BALANCES OF THE LINEAR AND ANGULAR M O M E N T U M
Balance of the linear momentum. First, let us identify the surface (two-dimensional)
analogues of Eqs. (4.1)-(4.4). Following Podstrigach and Povstenko [12] we consider a material volume V, which contains a portion, A, from the boundary between phases I and II, together with the adjacent volumes, V~ and VII, from these phases, see Fig. 4.2. In analogy with Eq. (4.1) one can postulate the integral balance of the linear momentum for the considered part of the system [ 12]:
(4.31) Y=I,II Vy
A
=, I Sy
Vy
a
L
II
Fig. 4.2. Sketch of a material volume V, which contains a portion, A, of the boundary between phases I and II; V~, VII and $I, S~I are parts of the volume V and its surfaces, which are located on the opposite sides of the interface A.
In Eq. (4.31) the subscript "s" denotes properties related to the interface; VI, VII and SI, SII are the two parts of the considered volume and its surface separated by the dividing surface A; L is the contour which encircles A; v is an unit normal, which is simultaneously perpendicular to L
148
Chapter 4
and tangential to A (Fig. 4.2); F is the surface excess of mass per unit area of the interface; as before, n is running unit normal and ~ is the surface stress tensor, see Eq. (4.26) and Fig. 4.1. For the sake of simplicity we will assume that the normal component of the velocity is continuous across the dividing surface: (v I - v, )-n - (v n - v, )-n - 0
(4.32)
Then the surface analogues of Eqs. (4.3) and (4.4) have the form [21]:
d l dVFv =! dV [ d ( F V )s+ F v ~ V . v I dt a dt 9 , s
(4.33)
dF dt
(4.34)
FV.,. 9v s - 0
--+
The latter equation is valid if there is no mass exchange between the bulk phases and the interface. Next, we will transform Eq. (4.31) with the help of the integral theorem of Green, which in a general vectorial form reads [12, 25]"
IdAV, . T - ~ d l v . T - I d A A
L
2H n . T
(Green theorem)
(4.35)
A
Here T is an arbitrary vector or tensor; the meaning of v is the same as in Fig. 4.2. If T is a purely surface tensor, viz. T-aUaVT, v, or if T has a rectangular matrix like that in Eqs. (4.26)-(4.27), then n .T = 0 and the last integral in Eq. (4.35) is zero. In particular, the Green theorem (4.35), along with Eq. (4.26), yields
~dlv " ~ - I d A V s "~ L
(4.36)
A
With the help of Eqs. (4.32)-(4.34), (4.36) and the versions of Eq. (4.1) for the material volumes VI and VII, from Eq. (4.31) one deduces the local surface balance of linear momentum [121" F dv, _ V .,..or + Ff, + n- (T n - T~ )
dt
(4.37)
Here T~ and Tn are the subsurface values of the respective tensors. The last term in Eq. (4.37),
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
149
which accounts for the interaction of the interface with the two neighboring bulk phases, has no counterpart in Eq. (4.2). Differential geometry [18-21] yields the following expression for the surface divergence of the tensor o" defined by Eq. (4.26):
V s -o- - (o-,vn -bvno-v(n))a n +(bnv(Tnv +o-~(n))n
(4.38)
Here bnv are components of the curvature tensor, see Eq. (4.17). In view of Eq. (4.38), the projections of Eq. (4.37) along the basis vectors a n and n have the form F i n - f f V v ~ - b v U f f v(n~ + V f ~
+(rll n)n -T, (n'u)
~t= 1,2
(4.39)
(normal balance)
(4.40)
Fi (n) -o--,~(n) +bnvt~Tnv +Ffs (n) +(Til n)(n) _Zi (n)(n))
where i n and i(n) are components of the vector of acceleration, dvs/dt. Equations (4.39) and (4.40) coincide with the first three basic equations in the theory of elastic shells by Kirchhoff and Love, see e.g. Refs. [6, 12]. B a l a n c e o f the a n g u l a r m o m e n t u m .
In mechanics the rotational motion is treated
similarly to the translational one. In particular, instead of velocity and force, angular velocity and force moment (torque) are considered. Three- and two-dimensional integral balances of the angular momentum, i.e. analogues of Eqs. (4.1) and (4.31), are postulated; see Refs. [6, 12] for details. From them the local form of the surface balance of the angular momentum can be deduced [ 12]" a F(&o/dt)
- V, 9N + F m , + n- [(~" _~)U, + ~ . ~]
(4.41)
The last equation is the analogue of Eq. (4.37) for rotational motion. Here o~ is a coefficient accounting for the interfacial moment of inertia; co is the vector of the angular velocity; m, is a counterpart of f, in Eq. (4.37)" N - a u a v N ~v + a u n N n(n)
is the tensor of the surface moments (Fig. 4.1c); _~;- anavenv
(4.42) is the surface alternator.
Comparing Eqs. (4.37) with (4.41) one sees that for rotational motion N plays the role of ff for translational motion. Using Eq. (4.38) with N instead of o , along with Eqs. (4.26) and (4.42),
150
Chapter 4
one can deduce equations, which represent the projections of the surface balance of the angular momentum, Eq. (4.41), along the basis vectors a~, and n [12]: a Fj ~ - N,Vvu - b ~v' N v (n ) + Fm sP + 8 v'lv av~" cr )~(n)
aFJ
(n) -
Here j~ and
NPp (n), +buy NUV + Fm(n)s -e~uv ~
j(n)
/1 = 1,2.
(4.43)
(normal balance)
(4.44)
are the respective projections of the angular acceleration vector & o / d t .
Equations (4.43) and (4.44) represent the second group of three basic equations in the theory of elastic shells by Kirchhoff and Love, see e.g. Refs. [6, 12]. S i m p l i f i c a t i o n o f the equations. For fluid interfaces and biomembranes one can simplify
the general surface balances of the linear and angular momentum, Eqs. (4.39)-(4.40) and (4.43)-(4.44), by using the following relevant assumptions: (i) Negligible contributions from the body forces (fs = 0) and couples (ms = 0). (ii) Quasistatic processes are considered ( i a = i (") = O, j a = j(n)= 0). (iii) The stress tensors in the bulk phases are isotropic: T I =-P~U,
T n =-PI, U
(4.45)
(iv) O'uv and Muv are symmetric surface tensors defined by Eqs. (4.24) and (4.28). (v) The transversal components of the tensor N are equal to zero (Na{n)= 0); in such a case, with the help of Eq. (4.29), we can transform Eq. (4.42): N-a
(4.46)
a a/~ N ~/~ - a a a/~ M y e
If the above assumptions are fulfilled, then Eq. (4.44), representing the tangential resultant of the surface balance of the angular momentum, is identically satisfied; see Eq. (4.30) and the related discussion. The remaining balance equations, (4.39), (4.40) and (4.43), acquire the form: v
vin)
o'~ + (q q~ ),v - b~v o"
,
2Her + 2Dq + o'~ (n) - Pn - PI
p = 1,2.
(4.47)
(normal balance of linear momentum)
(4.48)
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
O"p(n) --
- M , v,L/V
151 /.t = 1,2.
(4.49)
To derive Eqs. (4.48) and (4.49) we have used Eqs. (4.17) and (4.29), respectively. Finally, s u b s t i t u t i n g o "p(n)
from Eq. (4.49) into Eqs. (4.47) and (4.48) we obtain
cr,u + (71 q v ) ,v - - b u y M vz.~. ]-/V
2Her + 2Drl - M,~ v - Pn - PI
/.t = 1,2. (generalized Laplace equation)
(4.50) (4.51)
Eqs. (4.50) and (4.51) have the meaning of projections of the interfacial stress balance in tangential and normal direction with respect to the dividing surface. In fact, Eq. (4.51) represents a generalized form of the Laplace equation of capillarity. Indeed, if the effects of the shearing tension and surface moments are negligible (r/= 0, MUV= 0), then Eq. (4.51) reduces to the conventional Laplace equation, Eq. (2.17). In addition, a version of the generalized Laplace equation can be derived by using the thermodynamic approach, that is by minimization of the free energy of the system, see Eq (4.71) below. Of course, the two versions of that equation must be equivalent. Thus we approach the problem about the equivalence of the mechanical and thermodynamical approaches, which is considered in the next section.
4.3.
C O N N E C T I O N B E T W E E N M E C H A N I C A L AND T H E R M O D Y N A M I C A L A P P R O A C H E S
4.3.1. GENERALIZED LAPLACE EQUATION DERIVED BY MINIMIZATION OF THE FREE ENERGY
In this section we will follow the pure thermodynamic approach, described in Sections 3.1 and 3.2, to derive the generalized Laplace equation. Our goal is to compare the result with Eq. (4.51) which has been obtained in the framework of the mechanical approach. With this end in view we consider the two-phase system depicted in Fig. 4.2. The grand thermodynamic potential of the system can be expressed in the form ~:2- f2 b + f2,
(4.52)
where ~)b and ~2~ account for the contributions from the bulk and the surface, respectively. For the bulk phases one has
152
Chapter 4
5 f~b = -P~ 5V~ - Pn 5Vn,
V = V~ + V u
(4.53)
The integral surface excess of the grand thermodynamic potential f~,, and its variation 8f2,, can be expressed in the form f2, - f (o, dA,
(4.54)
A
5 a s - 5 I o o , dA - I ( S cos +(.o, 5 o~) dA , A
(4.55)
A
where COs is the surface density of f~s, defined by Eq. (3.17); we have used the fact that 5a = ~dA)/dA, and the integration is carried out over the dividing surface between the two phases. A substutution of 5(o, from Eq. (3.18) into Eq. (4.55), along with the condition for constancy of the temperature and chemical potentials at equilibrium, yields 5 f~, - I 0 ' 5 a +~ 5 ~ + B S H + 0 5 D) dA
(4.56)
A
The combination of Eqs. (4.52), (4.53) and (4.56) yields [23, 26]: 5 ~2 - -(P~ - PH )6V~ - P~ O3/ + f O/"Sa +~ 5[3 + BSH + 0 5 D ) d A
(4.57)
A
Let us consider a small deformation of the dividing surface at fixed volume of the system, 5V = 0. The change in the shape of the interface is described by the variation of the positionvector of the points belonging to the dividing surface, 5 R =~'" a , + g t n ,
(4.58)
at fixed boundaties: ~'1 _ ~-- 2 _ Iff -- 0 ,
lff./t -- 0
over the contour L
(4.59)
Here ~'u = vUSt and gt = v(n)st are infinitesimal displacements; L is the contour encircling the surface A. With the help of Eqs. (4.19)-(4.22) we obtain [23, 26] 5o~ = auG~u.G - 2HN,
5 fl = qU~u.~ - 2 Dgt.
(4.60)
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
153
Likewise, using the identities [ 12, 21 ] (n)v /2/- H,ov c~ + ( H 2 + D 2 ) v (n) + ~ a vv v,p
(4.61)
D - D.crv 'r + 2 H D v (n) + i q,V v(n).,v
(4.62)
we deduce ~H - H , ~ "~ + ( H 2 + D2)lff +~ a"vV,ov "
riD- D.a~ ~ + 2HDllt +~'4
q'.,v
(4.63)
The substitution of Eqs. (4.60) and (4.63) into Eq. (4.57), along with the condition for thermodynamic equilibrium, fig2 = 0, leads to [23, 26]: 0 = I { ( B H , , +|
~ + [PII - P I - 2 H T - 2 D ~
+ ( H 2 + D2)B + 2 H D |
A
A
(4.64) A
where we have used the auxiliary notations M "G _ 71 B a U ~ +71 | q.O
(4.65)
'?'"~ - 7 a v~ +~ qV~
(4.66)
f ~ is called the "thermodynamic surface stress tensor" [22]. Next, we transform the integrands of the last two integrals in Eq. (4.64) using the identities: ~, , ~ ~-,.o = ( 7'"~ ~-, ).o - ~. , o .o ~',
M .o- V,vo- - (M vo- gt,. ),~ - M "~
(4.67) V,.
(4.68)
M uo ,o-V,. - (M uo ,o- V),, - M uo ,,o- V
(4.69)
The first term in the right-hand side of Eqs. (4.67)-(4.69) represents a divergence of a surface vector. Integrating the latter, in accordance with the Green theorem, Eq. (4.35), we obtain an integral over the contour L, which is zero in view of Eq. (4.59). Thus the last two integrals in Eq. (4.64), which contain derivatives of ~', and I/L are reduced to integrals containing ~', and
154
Chapter 4
themselves. Finally, we set equal to zero the coefficients multiplying the independent variations ~'~ and I//in the transformed Eq. (4.64); thus we obtain the following two condition for mechanical equilibrium of the interface [26,23,22,13]"
y,; + (~ q (~),a - BH,; + | -2HT-2D~
,
/1 - 1,2;
+ ( H 2 + D 2 ) B + 2 H D O + I ( B a ~v +|
(4.70)
-PI-Pn
(4.71)
Equation (4.71) represents a thermodynamic version of the generalized Laplace equation. From a physical viewpoint, Eqs. (4.70)-(4.71) should be equivalent to Eqs. (4.50)-(4.51). This is proven below, where relationships between the thermodynamical parameters 7, ~, B, |
and the
mechanical parameters or, r/, M~, M2 are derived. For other equivalent forms of the generalized Laplace equation - see Section 4.3.3.
4.3.2.
W O R K OF D E F O R M A T I O N : T H E R M O D Y N A M I C A L A N D M E C H A N I C A L E X P R E S S I O N S
Relationships between the mechanical and thermodynamical surface tensions and moments. In the thermodynamic approach the work of surface deformation (per unit area) is expressed as follows"
5Ws-~'5o~ +~Sfl + BSH + 0 5 D ,
(4.72)
see Eq. (3.1). On the other hand, the mechanics provides the following expression for the work of surface deformation (per unit area and per unit time)" (~ W s
6t
= (s:(V~ v + Us x co) + N'(V~ o)),
(4.73)
see e.g. Eq. (4.26) in the book by Podstrigach and Povstenko [12]. As in Eqs. (1.22)-(1.23), here the symbol ":" denotes a double scalar product of two tensors. The vector co expresses the angular velocity of rotation of the running unit normal to the surface, n, which is caused by the change in the curvature of the interface [24]:
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
m -nx~
155
dn
(4.74)
dt
Here "x" denotes vectorial product of two vectors. Hence, the vector m is perpendicular to the plane formed by the vectors n and dn/dt, which means that m is tangential to the surface. Equation (4.73) (multiplied by &) should be equivalent to the thermodynamic relationship, gq. (4.72). Since _c is a surface tensor ( n . ~ = 0), one can prove that ~ :(Us x m) - 0. Next, with the help of Eqs. (4.23) and (4.24), one derives [24]
,," (Vs v)- o ' , t . -oa+,t
(4.75)
Further, after some mathematical transformations described in Ref. [24], one can bring the term with the moments in Eq. (4.73) to the form N:(Vs m) = (Ml + m2) (/-I + 5I H a + 51 D/~) + (M1 - M2) (O + 7I D a +17 U/~)
(4.76)
Combining Eqs. (4.73), (4.75) and (4.76) one obtains (~Ws (~t
=o-a+rID +(M 1+M2)(H+IHa+IDfl) 2
1
(4.77) 1
+ ( M 1- M e ) ( b + - D a + - H / ~ ) 2 2 Further, taking into account that ~H - H~t, ~D - / ) ~ t and using Eq. (4.22), we get
' l +M2)H+2(M1-M2)D , ] ~0~+ (~ws- [cr+2(M + rl+2(M l
+M2)D+2(M1-M2)H (~+
(4.78)
+(M 1+Mz)~H +(M1-M2)~D which represents a corollary from Eq. (4.73). Comparing Eqs. (4.72) and (4.78) one can identify the coefficients multiplying the independent variations [24]" B - Ml+M2
(4.79)
|
(4.80)
l -M 2
Chapter 4
156
y-o'+
(4.81)
l OD 7 B H + -~
- 7 / + 7I B D + I ~ |
(4.82)
Discussion. Equations (4.79)-(4.80) show that the bending and torsion moments, B and
|
represent is|
and deviatoric scalar invariants of the tensor of the surface moments, M.
The substitution of Eqs. (4.79)-(4.80) into (4.28) yields 1 0 q ~v M ~v = 71 B a ~v + -~
(4.83)
In addition, Eqs. (4.81) and (4.82) express the connection between the mechanical surface tensions, o-, r/, and the thermodynamical surface tensions ~' and ~. For a spherical interface D = 0 and MI = M2 = M. Then Eqs. (4.79) and (4.81) are reduced to Eqs. (3.61) and (3.60), respectively, while Eqs. (4.80) and (4.82) yield | latter relationship holds for an is|
0, ~ - 7 " / - 0" the
deformation of a spherical surface.
The concepts for the surface tension as (i) excess force per unit length and (ii) excess surface energy per unit area are usually considered as being equivalent for a fluid phase boundary [2729]. Equation (4.81) shows that this is fulfilled only for a planar interface. In the general case, the difference between o" and ?' is due to the existence of surface moments. This difference could be important for interfaces and membranes of high curvature and low tension, such as microemulsions, biomembranes, etc. An interesting consequence from Eq. (4.82) is the existence of two possible definitions o f f l u i d interface [ 13, 14]. From a mechanical viewpoint we could require the two-dimensional stress tensor, o'v,,, to be is|
for a fluid interface (a two-dimensional analogue of the Pascal law).
Thus from Eq. (4.25) we obtain as the mechanical definition of a fluid interface in the form 7"/-0. The intriguing point is that for 7"/=0 Eq. (4.82) yields ~ = 7I BD + 7~|
and
consequently the mechanical work of shearing, ~3/3, is not zero if surface moments are present. On the other hand, from a thermodynamical viewpoint we may require the work of quasistatic shearing to be zero, that is ~ - 0 , for a f l u i d interface. However, it turns out that for such an
157
General Curved lntelfaces and Biomembranes
interface the surface stress tensor ouv is not isotropic: indeed, setting { - 0 in Eq. (4.82) we obtain q = - ( 7I B D + 7l o l l ) . In our opinion, it is impossible to determine which is the "true" definition of a fluid interface (7"/=0 or ~=0) by general considerations. Insofar as every theoretical description represents a model of a real object, in principle it is possible to establish experimentally whether the behavior of a given real interface agrees with the first or the second definition (q = 0 or ~ = 0).
4.3.3.
VERSIONS OF THE GENERALIZED LAPLACE EQUATION
First of all, using Eqs. (4.81)-(4.83), after some mathematical derivations one can transform Eqs. (4.70)-(4.71) into Eqs (4.50)-(4.51), and vice versa [14]. This is a manifestation of the equivalence between the mechanical and thermodynamical approaches, which are connected by Eqs. (4.81)-(4.83). In particular, Eqs. (4.51) and (4.71) represent two equivalent forms of the generalized Laplace equation. Another equivalent form of this equation is [14,22]: -2HT-2D~
+( H2 + D 2 ) B + 2 H D O + ( V s V s )
:M
(4.84)
= P~ - P n
The most compact form of the latter equation is obviously Eq. (4.51). In terms of the coefficients Cl and C2, see Eqs. (3.5) and (3.6), the generalized Laplace equation can be represented in another equivalent (but considerably longer) form [35]: 2 H 7 + 2 D ~ - C l (2H 2 _ K ) - 2 C 2 H K l v 2-y
s Cl - 2HV~2 C 2 + b ; Vs v s C 2
= /19II --
PI
(4.85)
Boruvka and Neumann [2] have derived an equation analogous to (4.85) without the shearing term 2D~. These authors have used a definition of surface tension, which is different from the conventional definition given by Gibbs; the latter fact has been noticed in Refs. [26] and [30]. In an earlier work by Melrose [31] an incomplete form of the generalized Laplace equation has been obtained, which contains only the first, third and fourth term in the left-hand side of Eq. (4.85). Another incomplete form of the generalized Laplace equation was published in Refs. [32-34]. Further specification of the form of the surface tangential and normal stress balances, Eqs. (4.50)-(4.51), can be achieved if appropriate rheological constitutive relations are available, as discussed in the next section. For other forms of the generalized Laplace equation - see Eqs.
Chapter 4
158
(4.99), (4.103), (4.107) and (4.110) below.
4.3.4.
INTERFACIAL RHEOLOGICAL CONSTITUTIVE RELATIONS
To solve whatever specific problem of the continuum mechanics, one needs explicit expressions for the tensors of stresses and moments. As already mentioned, such expressions typically have the form of relationships between stress and strain (or rate-of-strain), which characterize the theological behavior of the specific continuum: elastic, viscous, plastic, etc." see e.g. Refs. [6,20,35,36]. In fact, a constitutive relation represents a theoretical model of the respective continuum; its applicability for a given system is to be experimentally verified. Below in this section, following Ref. [14], we briefly consider constitutive relations, which are applicable to curved interfaces.
Surface stress tensor if_. Boussinesq [37] and Scriven [38] have introduced a constitutive relation which models a phase boundary as a two-dimensional viscous fluid:
rY,v -rYa,v + rlda,v d~ + 2r/s (d,v - 2 a , v d~ )
(4.86)
where d,v is the surface rate-of-strain tensor defined by Eq. (4.19), d~ is the trace of this tensor; r/d and r/s are the coefficients of surface dilatational and shear viscosity, cf. Eq. (4.11). The elastic (non-viscous) term in Eq. (4.86), o" a,v, is isotropic. Consequently, it is postulated that the shearing tension 7/ is zero, see Eq. (4.25), i.e. there is no shear elasticity. In other words, in the model by Boussinesq-Scriven the deviatoric part of the tensor O,v has entirely viscous origin. In Eq. (4.86) o" is to be identified with the mechanical surface tension, cf. Eq. (4.81). For emulsion phase boundaries of low interfacial tension the dependence of o" on the curvature should be taken into account. From Eqs. (3.39) and (4.81), in linear approximation with respect to the curvature, we obtain o" _ 70 + 7I Bo H + O ( H 2 )
(4.87)
where 7o is the tension of a flat interface. For example, for an emulsion from oil drops in water we have B0
=
10 -10
N and H =
105cm -~" then we obtain that the contribution from the
curvature effect to ry is 7 Boll -~ 0.5 mN/m. For such emulsions the latter value could be of the
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
159
order of 7o, and even larger. Therefore, the curvature effect should be taken into account when solving the hydrodynamic problem about flocculation and coalescence of the droplets in some emulsions. Since the surface stress tensor ~ has also transversal components, cr ~(n), see Eq. (4.26), one needs also a constitutive relation for o~(n) ( y = 1,2). In analogy with Eq. (4.86) cr ~(n) can be expressed as a sum of a viscous and a non-viscous term [ 14]" 0"/~(n) -- O'ffvOn) + tw/'t(n) "" (0)
(4.88)
The viscous term can be expressed in agreement with the Newton's law for the viscous friction
[14]: O./~(n) (v)
- Z , v (n),/~
(4.89)
v (n) is defined by Eq. (4.20). As illustrated schematically in Fig. 4.3, equation (4.89) accounts for the lateral friction between the molecules in an interfacial adsorption layer; this effect could be essential for sufficiently dense adsorption layers, like those formed from proteins. Zs is a coefficient of surface transversal viscosity, which is expected to be of the order of r/s by magnitude. For quasistatic processes (v --)0 and cr/~,,c)n) --)0 ), the transversal components of _~ reduce to cr (~'(n) Then, in keeping with Eqs. (4.49), (4.83), (4.88) and (4 89), we can write [14]: 0) "
i-
I
lateral friction between ~ s u r f a c e molecules
I
Fig. 4.3. An illustration of the relative displacement of the neighboring adsorbed molecules (the squares) in a process of interfacial wave motion; u is the local deviation from planarity.
160
Chapter 4
O'S(n) t~'sV(n)'/a - 7 l(Ba~V + O q /Jv ),v
(4.90)
_
The surface rheological model, based on the constitutive relations (4.86) and (4.90), contains 3 coefficients of surface viscosity, viz. r/d, r/s and Z,- Moreover, the surface bending and torsion elastic moduli do also enter the theoretical expressions through B and O, see Eqs. (3.9) and (4.90). Tensor o f the surface m o m e n t s M. Equations (3.9) and (4.83) yield an expression for
the non-viscous part of M: M(0)~,v _ 89
+ Oq uv ) _ [ 8 9
uv
(4.91)
In keeping with Eqs. (4.17), (4.49), (4.90) and (4.91) the total tensor of the surface moments (including a viscous contribution)can be expressed in the form [14]: M ~ = [-~B o + 2(k,: + k c ) H ]a/~v - k~.b ~v - Zs v~176 a~v
(4.92)
The latter equation can be interpreted as a rheological constitutive relation stemming from the Helfrich formula, Eq. (3.7). With the help of the Codazzi equation, b ~'v'z = b vz'~ , see e.g. Ref. [ 19], we derive: b~,v - avzbpV, ~ = avzb vz,u - 2 H , ~
(4.93)
The combination of Eqs. (4.92) and (4.93) yields (4.94)
M uv,v - 2kc H ' u - Zs v~
In the derivation of Eq. (4.94) we have treated B0 as a constant. However, if the deformation is accompanied with a variation of the surface concentration F, then Eq. (4.94) should be written in the following more general form: M m' l ' F 4' + 2 k c H '~ - Z ' V (")'~ ; ,v _ 7Bo
B ~'
3B~ OF
(4.95)
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
161
p The term with B0 has been taken into account by Dan et al. [39], as well as in Chapter l0 below, for describing the deformations in phospholipid bilayers caused by inclusions (like membrane proteins). In the simpler case of a quasistatic process (v (n~ - 0) and uniform surface concentration (F '~' = 0) Eq. (4.95) reduces to a quasistatic constitutive relation stemming from the Helfrich model: M uv ,V _ 2k~. H 'u
(4.96) m
It is worthwhile noting that the torsion (Gaussian) elasticity, k C, does not appear in Eqs. (4.94)-(4.96). Then, in view of Eq. (4.49) and (4.94), k c will not appear explicitly also in the tangential and normal balances of the linear momentum, Eqs. (4.39) and (4.40), which for small Reynolds numbers (inertial terms negligible) acquire the form
(T,v~ nt- bg (2kc s ' v -/~s v(n)'v ) - (TI(n)tt - ZIl n)p )
/1 = 1,2.
b~v 17/~v- (2kc n'pv -)(,sv(n)'~V )a~v - (TI(n)(n) -TII n)(n) )
(4.97)
(4.98)
o vv is to be substituted from Eq. (4.86). It should be noted that Eq. (4.98) is another form of the generalized Laplace equation. In vectorial notation and for quasistatic processes (v (n~ --> 0) Eq. (4.98) reads (4.99)
b ' f f - 2kcV,2H = n - ( T i - Tn).n
Application to capillary waves. As an example let us consider capillary waves on a flat
(in average) interface. It is usually assumed that the amplitude of the waves u (see Fig. 4.3) is sufficiently small, and consequently Eqs. (4.97) and (4.98) can be linearized:
O" V 2 b/
keg2 V 9
V ~, o ' + r / j V
s
V .vn +r/, s
2 6~b/
V
,vn 2
-- Ti(in)(n)
_
_
n.(T I - T n)-U,
where we have used the constitutive relation, Eq. (4.86), and the relationships
(4.100)
(4.1ol)
Chapter 4
162
2H = V ,u, 2
v (n) = ~3/,/ 'at
vii-aUvu
One sees that in linear approximation the dependent variables u and
(4.102)
VII
are separated: the
generalized Laplace equation, Eq. (4.100), contains the displacement u along the normal, whereas the two-dimensional Navier-Stokes equation (4.101) contains the tangential surface velocity, vii. In the linearized theory the curvature elasticities participate only trough kc in the b
normal stress balance, Eq. (4.100)" k C does not appear.
4.4.
AXISYMMETRICSHAPESOFBIOLOGICALCELLS
4.4.1.
THE GENERALIZEDLAPLACEEQUATIONIN PARAMETRICFORM
Equation (4.99) can be used to describe the shapes of biological membranes. For the sake of simplicity, let us assume that the phases on both sides of the membrane are fluid, i.e. Eq. (4.45) holds (the effect of citoskeleton neglected). Then substituting Eqs. (4.17), (4.24) and (4.45) into Eq. (4.99) one derives [14] 2Ho" + 2 D r / - 2kcV,2H = P n - PI
(4.103)
Further, let us consider the special case of axisymmetric membrane and let the z-axis be the axis of revolution. In the plane xy we introduce polar coordinates (r,q~); z = z(r) expresses the equation of the membrane shape. Then V,.2H can be presented in the form (see Ref. 37, Chapter XIV, Eq. 66):
VgH 1(| -
'
- -
r
+
z , -9 ) - l / 2 d I ( r 1 + z
t2 )-1/2_~F1
~rr
(4.104)
where & z' - - - - tan 0
dr
(4.105)
with 0 being the running slope angle. The two principal curvatures of an axisymmetric surface are ci = d(sinO)/dr and c2 = sinO/r. In view of Eq. (3.3), we have
GeneralCurvedInterfacesandBiomembranes dsin0 sin0 2 H = ~ + ~ ,
dr
163
dsin0 2D=--
r
sin0 --,
dr
(4.106)
r
Finally, with the help of Eqs. (4.104)-(4.106) we bring Eq. (4.103) into the form [14]
( d. s i n O . cr(dsinO + .s i n O )+7/ . dr
r
s i n O .) ~AP + r
dr
cos0 d
dr
{ r c o s 0 - d- I l ~ r dr
(rsin0)
1}
(4.107)
where AP = P u - PI. Equations (4.105) and (4.107) determine the generatrix of the membrane profile in a parametric form: r =
r(O), z = z(O). In the
special case, in which 7/= 0 and k c = 0
(no shearing tension and bending elasticity), Eq. (4.107) reduces to the common Laplace equation of capillarity, Eq. (2.24). The approach based on Eq. (4.107) is equivalent to the approach based on the expression for the free energy, insofar as the generalized Laplace equation can be derived by minimization of the free energy, see Section 4.3.1. The form of Eq. (4.107) calls for discussion. The possible shapes of biological and model membranes are usually determined by minimization of an appropriate expression for the free energy (or the grand thermodynamic potential) of the system, see e.g. Refs. [7,9,40-49]. For example, the integral bending elastic energy of a tension-free membrane is given by the expression [7] We - ~[2kc (H - H0) 2 +
kcK]dA
see Eq. (3.7). The above expression for
(4.108)
We contains
as parameters the spontaneous curvature
H0 and the Gaussian (torsion) elasticity k c , while the latter two parameters are missing in Eq. (4.107). As demonstrated in the previous section H0 and
k C must
not enter the generalized
Laplace equation, see Eq. (4.99); on the other hand, H0 and k C can enter the solution trough the boundary conditions [22]. For example, Deuling and Helfrich [43] described the myelin forms of an erythrocyte membrane assuming tension-free state of the membrane, that is cr = 7/= 0 and AP = 0; then they calculated the shape of the membrane as a solution of the equation ld ---
r dr
(r sin 0) = 2H0 = const.
(4.109)
It is obvious that for o" = 7/= 0 and AP = 0 every solution of Eq. (4.109) satisfies Eq. (4.107),
164
Chapter 4
and that the spontaneous curvature H0 appears as a constant of integration. In a more general case, e.g. swollen or adherent erythrocytes [50], one must not set 0" = 0 and AP = 0, since the membrane is expected to have some tension, though a very low one. To simplify the mathematical treatment, one could set r / = 0 in Eq. (4.107), i.e. one could neglect the effect of the shearing tension. Setting 71 = 0 means that the stresses in the membrane are assumed to be tangentially isotropic, that is the membrane behaves as a two-dimensional fluid. In fact, there are experimental indications that 77 << 0" for biomembranes at body temperature [9, 51 ]. Thus one could seek the membrane profile as a solution of the equation [50]
0" ~ + dr
4.4.2.
r
- AP+--cos r
dr
rcos
dr
-~r
(rsin0)
]t
(4 110)
BOUNDARY CONDITIONS AND SHAPE COMPUTATION
To find the solution of Eq. (4.110), along with Eq. (4.105), one needs 4 boundary conditions. The following boundary conditions have been used in Ref. [50] to find the shape of erythrocytes attached to a glass substrate (Fig. 4.4): (i-ii) z = 0 and 0 = 0 at r = 0, i.e. at the apex of the membrane (the point where the membrane intersects the z-axis); (iii) the membrane curvature varies smoothly in a vicinity of the membrane apex; (iv) 0 = 0t, for r = rf (Oh - contact angle; r f - radius of the adhesive film); (v) the total area of the membrane, At, is known; this condition was used in Ref. [50] to determine the unknown material parameter (4.111)
~ = 0"1kc
To solve Eq. (4.110) it is convenient to introduce the auxiliary function
F =
dsin0 -
dr
t-
sin0
2
r
b
,
b -
20"
,
(4.112)
AP
where b is constant if the effect of gravity on the membrane shape is negligible. Then Eq. (4.110) acquires the form
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
165
c
6 E
,-
4
o
3
.-"O L O
/
5
\
O
.~
'...v, ,..~
2
>
'// 7:;
..,~
tD
1 .
-~.
.
.
-4
.
.
-3
//..... .
.
-2
.
.
-1
.
.
0
.
.
1
.
.
2
.
.
3
.
4
5
Horizontal coordinate (gm)
Fig. 4.4. Shape of an erythrocyte adherent to a glass substrate, determined in Ref. [50]; the zone of the flat adhesion film is in the lower part of the graph. (a) For osmolarity 143 mOsm of the hypotonic solution the non-adherent part of the membrane is spherical; the shape for (b) osmolarity 153 mOsm and (c) 156 mOsm is reconstructed from experimental data by solving Eq. (4.110) for kc= 1.8 x 1 0 -19 J and for fixed membrane area AT = 188 gm 2. cos0 d (
r
dr
r cos0
dF) dr
- AF
(4.113)
It is convenient to use as an independent variable the length of the generatrix of the membrane profile, s, whose differential is related to the differentials of the cylindrical coordinates (r,z) as follows"
dr - cos0 ds;
dz - sin 0 ds
(4.114)
The introduction of s as a variable of integration helps to avoid divergence in the procedure of numerical integration at the "equator" of the erythrocyte, where cos0 = 0. The differential of the membrane area, A, is simply related to ds:
dA = 2fords Combining Eqs. (4.112) and (4.114) one obtains
(4.115)
Chapter 4
166
dO - -
ds
=
2
sin0
b
r
(4.116)
~ F(s)
Likewise, from (4.113) and (4.114) one derives
d2F I cosO I dF ~ = ~ F - - ds 2 r ds
(4.117)
Equations (4.114)-(4.117) form a set of 5 equations for determining the 5 unknown functions
r(s), z(s), O(s), F(s) and A(s). In particular, the functions r(s) and z(s) determine the profile of the axisymmetric membrane in a parametric form. Following Ref. [50], to determine the profile of the adherent erythrocyte (Fig. 4.4) one starts the numerical integration of Eqs. (4.114)-(4.117) from the apex of the membrane surface, i.e. from the upper point of the profiles in Fig. 4.4, where the generatrix intersects the axis of revolution. The boundary conditions are: r(s=0) = 0;
z(s=0) = 0;
O(s = 0) - 0
and
A(s=0) = 0
(4.118)
b is assumed to be a known parameter; in Ref. [50] it has been determined from the experimental data. Finally, the two boundary conditions for Eq. (4.117) are:
F(s=0) = q
and
dF -- = 0 ds
for s = 0
(4.119)
The latter boundary condition removes a divergence in Eq. (4.117) for s = 0 (r = 0). On the other hand, q is a unknown parameter, which is to be determined, together with the other unknown parameter ~,, from the area of the free (non-adherent) portion of the membrane:
AF = A T - ~ rj2
(4.120)
where At is the total area of the membrane, assumed constant; rr is assumed to be known from the experiment. The two unknown parameters, q and 2, are to be determined from the following two conditions: r - rl
and
0 - 0h
for
A = AF
(4.121 )
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
167
,/" A
E
v
=I.
2
f,,'"
,,,,, ,
/
b
.,L. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
-
a,.
t~
e.m
"~ O O
o
0 -1
.~ x._
-2
>
-3
-,..i
...........................................
t...-
'\
/
\
/ ",
/ -,
-4 -6
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Horizontal coordinate (gm)
Fig. 4.5. Shape of a closed membrane calculated in Ref. [50] by means of Eq. (4.110)" (a) spherocyte; (b) discocyte corresponding to cr= 1.8x 10 -4 mN/m and AP = 0.036 Pa; (c) discocyte corresponding to o" = 3.6 x 10 .4 mN/m and AP = 0.072 Pa; k C and Ar are the same as in Fig. 4.4. To obtain the profiles of adherent cells shown in Fig. 4.4 one can start the integration from the membrane apex, s =0, with tentative values of the unknown parameters, q and ~,. Further, the integration continues until the point with A = AF is reached. Then we check whether Eq. (4.121) is satisfied. If not, we assign new values of q and X and start the integration again from the apex s = 0 . This continues until we find such values of q and )~, which lead to fulfillment of Eq. (4.121). These values can be automatically determined by numerical minimization of the function * ( q ' / ~ ) - [r(AF " q ' & ) - r[ ]2 + [O(A F . q,/~) - 0 ~ ]2
(4.122)
with respect of q and X. Thus one determines the values of ~ and q. The curves in Fig. 4.5 illustrate what would be the shape of the same erythrocyte (of the same fixed area A T - 188 ~lm2 as in Fig. 4.4) if it were not attached to the substrate. In other words, Fig. 4.5 shows the shape of a free (non-attached) erythrocyte of area AT at various values of the membrane tension o" and the transmembrane pressure difference AP, specified in the figure caption. The curves in Fig. 4.5 are obtained in Ref. [50] by numerical integration of Eqs. (4.114)-(4.117). As before, the integration starts from the apex of the profile, i.e. from the
Chapter 4
168
intersection point of the generatrix with the axis of revolution, where we set s = 0. The numerical integration starts with a tentative value of q in Eq. (4.119). The value of q is determined from the condition that when the integration reaches the membrane "equator", where cos0= 0, the membrane area must be A = At~2. Since the membrane profile is symmetric with respect to the "equatorial" plane, in this case we carry out the numerical integration above the equator, and then we obtain the profile below the equator as a mirror image. Of course, one can continue the numerical integration after crossing the equator and the same profile will be obtained; however, due to accumulation of error from the numerical procedure this could decrease the accuracy of the calculated profile for the higher values of s (below the equator). Such calculations indicate that the generalized Laplace equation, Eq. (4.110), or the equivalent set of equations (4.114)-(4.117), has at least two types of solutions for a free (non-adherent) erythrocyte of fixed area and given membrane tension or. The first type is a "discocyte" like those in Fig. 4.5. The second type looks like an oblong ellipsoid of revolution, which resembles the shape of a red blood cell penetrating along a narrow capillary (blood vessel).
4.5.
M I C R O M E C H A N I C A L EXPRESSIONS FOR THE SURFACE PROPERTIES
In the Section 4.3.2 we derived the formula for the work of interfacial deformation, Eq. (4.72), starting from a purely phenomenological expression, Eq. (4.73); as a result we obtained relationships
between
the
surface
thermodynamical
and
mechanical
properties,
Eqs.
(4.79)-(4.80). In the present section we will derive again Eq. (4.72), however this time by taking excesses with respect to the bulk phases; this alternative approach provides
micromechanical expressions for the surface properties of an arbitrarily curved interface, such as generalizations of Eqs. (3.69) and (3.70).
4.5.1. SURFACE TENSIONS, MOMENTS AND CURVATURE ELASTIC MODULI Basic relationships. Our purpose here is to extend the hydrostatic approach to the theory of a spherical phase boundary from Section 3.2.3 to the general case of an arbitrarily
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
169
curved interface. We follow Refs. [23,26]. As discussed in Chapter 1, in a vicinity of a real fluid interface the pressure P represents a tensorial quantity, which depends on the position in the transition zone between the two phases. After Gibbs [1 ], let us define an idealized (model) system, which is composed of two homogeneous and isotropic fluid phases, I and II, separated by a mathematical dividing surface. If R(ul,u 2) is the running position vector of a point from the dividing surface, we can present the position-vector of a given point in space in the form: r - R ( u l , u 2) + 2 n ( u l , u 2)
(4.123)
As before, n is the running unit normal to the interface; 2~is the distance from the given point in space to the dividing surface. The pressure in the idealized system can be expressed in the form
P - PU,
P = P~O(-&)+ Pn0(&)
(4.124)
where {~ 0(A,) -
for~<0; for & > 0,
(4.125)
is the step-wise function of Heaviside; P~ and Pn are the pressures in the bulk of the respective two neighboring phases, while U is the unit tensor in space. Having in mind Eq. (1.22), one can express the work of interfacial deformation, produced during a time interval St, [52]:
f~w= dA = - I ( P - P ) A
9( ~ t )
dV
(4.126)
V
As before, &v, is the work of interfacial deformation per unit area, d A - a l / Z d u l d u
2
is a
surface element, and W is the spatial rate-of-strain tensor (the strain tensor is ~ = W~t): 1 [ V w -k- (Vw) T]
(4.127)
Here w is the velocity field in the bulk phases and the superscript "T" symbolizes conjugation. For slow quasistatic processes one can use the kinematic formula of Eliassen [21 ]" w-
v-,~(V~v).n
(4.128)
where the surface velocity v is defined by Eq. (4.18). Equation (4.128) corresponds to such a
170
Chapter 4
deformation, for which every material point is fixed at a point of the curvilinear coordinate network (u I ,u 2,/~ ), which moves together with the deforming dividing surface. In particular, every layer of material points, corresponding to ~ = const., remains parallel to the dividing surface in the course of deformation. The integration in the left-hand side of Eq. (4.126) is carried out over an arbitrarily chosen parcel A from the dividing surface, while the integration in the right-hand side - over the corresponding cylindrical volume depicted in Fig. 4.6. The lateral surface of this volume is perpendicular to the dividing surface. The vectorial surface element of the lateral surface can be expressed in the form [21 ]: (4.129)
ds = v . L d/~ dl
where dl is a linear element on the contour C, and v is an outer unit normal to C, see Fig. 4.6; L = (1-2)~H)U s +~b
(4.130)
in Eq. (4.129) is a surface tensor, cf. Eqs. (4.14) and (4.17). The volume element d V can be expressed in the form [53]: X = ( 1 - / ~ H ) 2 - ~ 2 D 2= 1 - 2M-/+/~2K
dV=zdAd),,
(4.131)
A substitution of w from Eq. (4.128) into Eq. (4.127) yields [23]
i ! !
\
; '1 x-o i
A--~. 1
I
Fig. 4.6. An imaginary cylinder, whose lateral surface is perpendicular to the dividing surface between phases I and II, and whose bases are parallel to it; n and v (nA_v) are running unit normals to the dividing surface and to the contour C, respectively; moreover, v is tangential to the dividing surface.
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
171
- a u a v [(1 - 2)~H)(wu, v + wv, ~ ) + ~,(wu,c~bGv + wv,c~b ~ ) - 2(buy - ~ Kauv )v ~n)]/22"
(4.132)
Next, with the help of Eqs. (4.17), (4.19), (4.21), (4.128), (4.132) and the identities (4.61)-(4.62) one can prove that [23] (U s "~F)U s + ( q ' ~ ) q - ( Z U s a + 2 " q ~ - Z / ~ L I ( t - 2 ~ q . L D ) / 2 "
(4.133)
Since the surface parcel A has been arbitrarily chosen, from Eqs. (4.126) and Eq. (4.131), we get: ws - - ~ ( P ~
9~ ) ~ t 2" d/~,
ps = p _ ~
(4.134)
A further simplification of Eq. (4.134) can be achieved if some specific information about the process of deformation is available. To specify the process one can assume that the surface rate-of-strain tensor can be expressed in the form [23]: 9 - 8 9 s "~F)U s + 89
~)q
(4.135)
The latter equation implies that the tensor ~F has diagonal form in the basis of the principle curvatures. In other words, the deformation of the dividing surface is related to the deformation in the adjacent phases. Using Eq. (4.135) we obtain: ps . q j _ ~ ps . [ U s ( U s . qj) + q (q. qj)]
(4.136)
Equation (4.136) can be also obtained using the alternative assumption that the pressure tensor can be expressed in the form P
7(Us "P)U s + 8 9
(4.137)
From Eq. (4.137) one can deduce Eq. (4.136) without imposing any limitations on the form of the rate-of-strain tensor qJ. The expression (4.137), which has been introduced by Buff [54, 55], means that at every point two of the eigenvectors of the tensor P are directed along the lines of maximal and minimal curvature of the surface/~ = const., passing through this point, whereas the third eigenvector is always normal to the dividing surface. In other words, the orientation of the eigenvectors of P in a vicinity of the phase boundary is induced by the geometry of the
Chapter 4
172 interface, which is a reasonable presumption from a physical viewpoint.
Combining Eqs. (4.133), (4.134) and (4.136) one obtains again the known expression for the work of surface deformation, 8Ws = ?'(5o~+ ~(5~ + B3H + |
see Eq. (3.1), where [23, 26]"
7 - - l fUs .Pszd
(4.138)
~ - - 8 9 f q" pSzd/~
(4.139)
B-
(4.140)
f L " P~,d~, q#
)-i
j'(q. L)" PS/~d/~
|
(4.141)
/1,1
Equations (4.138)-(4.141)provide general micromechanical expressions for the interfacial tensions and moments of an arbitrarily curved interface. In the special case of a spherical interface of radius a Eqs. (4.138) and (4.140) reduce to known expressions first derived by Tolman [56]: these are Eq. (3.59) and the equation ae B - 2 j"(Pv - P)(1 + ~ / a)~dA
(4.142)
The special form of Eqs. (4.138)-(4.141) for a cylindrical surface can be found in Refs. [14,22].
Expressions for the spontaneous curvature and the elastic moduli k C and k c . From Eqs. (4.140)-(4.141) one can deduce micromechanical expressions for the bending moment of a planar interface, B0, and for the bending and torsion elastic moduli, k C and k c . We will use the simplifying assumption for "tangential isotropy", which has been introduced by Buff [53]" m
ps _ p§ Us + pN nn;
P§ - P T - P ;
From Eqs. (4.17) and (4.130) we obtain
P~v --PN - P
(4.143)
173
'1.L = ( I - M ) q + A D U ,
(4.143)
A substitution 01' Eys. (4.143)-(4.144) i n l o I%].
(4.141) yields
7
8 = 211 t;';t"dL
(4.145)
i l
The comparison of the lattcr equation with Eq. (3.9) gives "1
k, =-j,yi%a
(4.146)
4
Equation (4.146) ha\ been fir41 obtained by Helfrich [57].Further, from Eqs. (4.17) and (4.130) oiic can derive
I, = (I-AH)IJ, + A 13 q
(4.147)
Substituting Eqs. (4.143) and (4.147) inio Eq. (4.140) we get (4.148)
From the latter equation, in view of Eqs. (3.9), (3.10) and (4.146), we obtain (4.149)
(4.150)
As usual, H,, is the spontaneous curvature. Equations (4.149) and (4.150) have been first
obtained in a quite different way. respectively, by Helfrich [571 and Szleifer et al. [58]. Equations (3.136).(4.149)and (4.150) wcrc utilized by Lckkcrkcrkcr [59] for calculating the electrostatic components of B,, , k , and
Lc.,see Eqs. (,3.91)-(3.93).
Froin the above equations we can deduce also expressions for the coefficients CI and C?, see
Eqs. (3.5) and (3.h), in the framework of the simplifying assumption for tangential isotropy, Eq. (4.143). For example, combining Eqs. (4.135) and (4.148) with Eq. (3.6)one can derive
Chapter 4
174
C2 - - 1 0 _ _ i p r 2D ~j
h Cl - B - 2 C 2 H = 2 f P T ~ f l ,
22d2;
d]t
(4.151)
fl,l
Likewise, a combination of Eqs. (4.131), (4.138) and (4.143) yields x2
~ ' = - I ( 1 - 2 H ~ + K ~ Z ) P T ~ d2
(4.152)
21
Equations (4.151) and (4.152) are equivalent to the results by Markin et al. [30] (the latter ,-v
authors use the notation J = - 2 H and CI =-C1/2).
Expressions for the surface densities of extensive thermodynamic parameters. In Ref. [23] a micromechanical derivation of the fundamental thermodynamic equation, Eq. (3.16), was given, which provided expressions also for the adsorptions of the species, 1-'~, and the surface excesses of internal energy Us and entropy Ss, as follows ;~
r k - f(n k -gk)zdA,
,h
us - f ( u - g ) z d ~ , ,
,h
s,-
f(s--s)zdA
(4.153)
Here Z is defined by Eq. (4.131), n~, u and s are bulk densities of the k-th spacies, internal energy and entropy in the real system; the respective densities in the idealized system are -n
k
t 0 ( - X ) + n~IO (X),
-= l l k
g - uIO ( - X ) + uIIO (X),
-g - slO ( - X ) + snO (X)"
the superscripts 'T' and "II" denote properties of phases I and II. Note that the expression for F1, in Eq. (4.153) represents a generalization of Eq. (1.36) for an arbitrarily curved interface.
4.5.2.
TENSORS OF THE SURFACE STRESSES AND MOMENTS
General micromechanical expressions. Following Ref. [26] let us consider a sectorial strip AA, which is perpendicular to the interface and corresponds to a linear element dl from an arbitrarily chosen curve C on the dividing surface (Fig. 4.7). As usual, n and v (n_l_v) are, respectively, running unit normals to the dividing surface and the curve C. It is presumed that the ends of the sectorial strip ALl,, corresponding to ,%= &l and 2, = 2,2, are located in the volume
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
175
2=22
11
/
Fig. 4.7. Sketch of a sectorial strip, which is perpendicular to the dividing surface. The strip corresponds to an element dl from the curve C on the dividing surface; n and v are running unit normals to the surface and the curve C, respectively; in addition, n _1_v.
of the two adjacent phases, i.e. far enough from the interface to have isotropic pressure tensor P. The force acting on the strip AA, in the real system is
I dsn.
(4.154)
P
AAs
In the idealized system the pressure tensor is assumed to be isotropic by definition, see Eq. (4.124); to compensate the difference with the real system, a surface stress tensor, if, is introduced. Hence, the force exerted on the strip AAs in the idealized system is
iidsn.P)-v.~dl
(4.155)
AAs
Demanding the f o r c e acting on the strip AA, to be the same in the real and idealized system, we obtain [ 14]: ~2
v
.ff - - v-
I dXL- P ' ,
P" - P - P ,
(4.156)
Xl
where we have used Eq. (4.129). Likewise, demanding the m o m e n t acting on the strip AA, to
176
Chapter 4
be the same in the idealized and the real system, we obtain [14]" '~2
v.N-v.~xR--v,
fdXL. P s xr
(4.157)
~,1
Using the arbitrariness of v and the identity a v x n - a U e u v ,
from Eqs. (4.123), (4.156) and
(4.157) one deduces [14]: ~2 P
_ _ ]dAL.p s
(4.158)
d A]
~2
N--
[d~L-P
s
(4.159)
Q~
In addition, with the help of the identities M - N-e_
and e - e - - U s
from Eq. (4.159) one
derives
M - [dAAL.ps
o
(4.160)
Us
Equations (4.158)-(4.160) represent the sought for micromechanical expressions for the tensors of the surface stresses and moments, see Fig. 4.1. It is worthwhile noting that in contrast with the tensor o-, the tensors M and N, defined by Eqs. (4.159) and (4.160), have no transversal components (components directed along n), which is consonant with Eqs. (4.28) and (4.46). In addition, Eq. (4.83) shows that the bending and torsion moments, B and O, are equal to the trace and the deviator of the tensor M: B-Us'M,
O-q'M
(4.161)
The substitution of M from (4.160) into (4.161) gives exactly Eqs. (4.140) and (4.141), which is an additional evidence for the selfconsistency of the theory presented here. Likewise, from Eq. (4.24) we obtain O" _ I U5
, . ,0 -
7/ _ 1 5 q ' o "
Combining Eqs. (4.158) and (4.162) one derives [ 14]"
(4.162)
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
177
~2
o - _ - 7 [ d A L " ps __
(4.163)
1
~2
r / = - g 1 ] ' d 2 ( q . L ) . ps
(4.164)
One can verify that if the micromechanical expressions for 7, {, B, |
a and 77, Eqs.
(4.138)-(4.141) and (4.163)-(4.164), are substituted into Eqs. (4.81) and (4.82), the latter are identically satisfied; this is an additional test for selfconsistency of the theory. m
Special case o f tangentially isotropic tensor P: From the definition ps = p _
p it
follows that in such a case the tensor ps will be also tangentially isotropic, cf. Eq. (4.143), and 7 will be given by Eq. (4.152). From Eqs. (4.139), (4.163) and (4.164) we obtain ]t.2
(4.165)
- - I d/~ (1 - M-/)Pr ~
O-
)q ~2
- O,
71 - - D I d ~ P ~
- --y~ (BD + O H
)
(4.166)
hl
As mentioned at the end of Section 4.3.2, two alternative definitions of f l u i d interface are possible: (i) mechanical: the surface stress tensor, o', is isotropic, that is r/= 0. (ii) thermodynamical: no work is produced upon a deformation of surface shearing, i.e. { = 0. Equation (4.166) shows that the hypothesis for tangential isotropy, Eq. (4.143), is consistent with the thermodynamic definition for fluid interface, that is { = 0. On the other hand, from the tangential isotropy of the tensor P (and P ' ) does not follow isotropy of its surface excess, the tensor Or, cf. Eq. (4.158). In fact, the anisotropy of o- stems from the anisotropy of the curvature tensor b of the arbitrarily curved interface, see Eqs. (4.130) and (4.158). The fact that the hypothesis for tangential isotropy of the pressure tensor P is consistent with the thermodynamic definition of surface fluidity should not be considered as an argument in
Chapter 4
178
favor of the latter definition. One should have in mind that, in general, the statistical mechanics predicts a non-isotropic pressure tensor P in a vicinity of an arbitrarily curved interface; see the review by Kuni and Rusanov [60].
4.6.
SUMMARY
In mechanics the stresses and moments acting in an interface or biomembrane can be taken into account by assigning tensors of the surface stresses, ~, and moments, M, to the phase boundary, see Fig. 4.1. Three equations determine the shape and deformation of a curved interface or biomembrane: they correspond to the three projections of the vectorial local balance of the linear momentum, see Eqs. (4.37), (4.39) and (4.40). Additional useful information is provided by the vectorial local balance of the angular momentum, see Eqs. (4.43)-(4.44), which imply that the tensor M is symmetric, and that its divergence is related to the transverse shear stress resultants of ~, see Eqs. (4.28) and (4.49). The normal projection of the surface linear momentum balance has the meaning of a generalized Laplace equation, which contains a contribution from the interfacial moments, see Eq. (4.51). Alternatively, variational calculus can be applied to derive the equations governing the interfacial/membrane shape by minimization of a functional - " t h e thermodynamic approach". The surface/membrane tension depends on the local curvature of the surface and should not be treated as a constant Lagrange multiplier. The correct minimization procedure is considered in detail in Section 4.3.1. In the theoreti6al derivations one should take into account also the work of surface shearing, even in the case offluid interface/membrane; see the discussions after Eqs. (4.83) and (4.166). Thus it turns out that the generalized Laplace equation can be derived in two alternative ways: mechanical and thermodynamical, cf. Eqs. (4.50)-(4.51) and Eqs. (4.70)-(4.71). This fact provides a test for a given surface mechanical (theological) model: if a model is selfconsistent, the two alternative approaches must give the same result. The connection between them has the form of relationships between the mechanical and thermodynamical surface tensions and moments, see Eqs. (4.79)-(4.82). Different, but equivalent, forms of the generalized Laplace equation are considered and discussed, see Section 4.3.3. In fact, the mechanical and
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
179
thermodynamical approaches are mutually complementary parts of the same formalism. The general theoretical equations can give quantitative predictions if only theological constitutive relations are specified, which characterize a given interface (biomembrane) as an elastic, viscous or visco-elastic two-dimensional continuum. The most popular constitutive relations for the tensors of the surface stresses ~ and moments M are Eqs. (4.86) and (4.96), which stem from the models of Boussinesq-Scriven and Helfrich. The latter leads to a specific form of the generalized Laplace equation, which is convenient to use in applications, such as determination of the axisymmetric shapes of biological cells, see Eq. (4.103) and the whole Section 4.4. In particular, the axial symmetry reduces the generalized Laplace equation to a system of ordinary differential equations, for which a convenient method of integration is proposed (Section 4.4.2). Finally, micromechanical expressions for the surface tensions and moments are derived in terms of combinations from the components of the pressure tensor, see Eqs. (4.138)-(4.141) and (4.158)-(4.164). As corollaries from the latter general equations one can deduce theoretical expressions for calculation of the bending and torsion elastic moduli, kc and k C, and the spontaneous curvature, H0, see Eqs. (4.146), (4.149) and (4.150).
4.7.
REFERENCES
1. J.W. Gibbs, The Scientific Papers of J.W. Gibbs, Vol. 1, Dover, New York, 1961. 2. L. Boruvka, A.W. Neumann, J. Chem. Phys. 66 (1977) 5464. 3. J.G. Kirkwood, I. Oppenheim, Chemical Thermodynamics, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1961. 4. G. Kirchhoff, Crelles J. 40 (1850) 51. 5. A.E.H. Love, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A 179 (1888) 491. 6. P.M. Naghdi, The Theory of Shells and Plates, in: Handbuch der Physik, S. Fltigge, Ed., Vol. Via/2, Springer, Berlin, 1972. 7. W. Helfrich, Z. Naturforsch. 28c (1973) 693. 8. W. Helfrich, Z. Naturforsch. 29c (1974) 510.
180
Chapter 4
9. E.A. Evans, R. Skalak, Mechanics and Thermodynamics of Biomembranes, CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, 1979. 10. E. Cosserat, F. Cosserat, Theorie des corps deformables, Hermann, Paris, 1909. 11. A.G. Petrov, The Lyotropic State of Matter: Molecular Physics and Living Matter Physics, Gordon & Breach Sci. Publishers, Amsterdam, 1999. 12. Ya. S. Podstrigach, Yu. Z. Povstenko, Introduction to Mechanics of Surface Phenomena in Deformable Solids, Naukova Dumka, Kiev, 1985 (in Russian). 13. S. Ljunggren, J.C. Eriksson, P.A. Kralchevsky, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 161 (1993) 133. 14. P.A. Kralchevsky, J.C. Eriksson, S. Ljunggren, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 48 (1994) 19. 15. J. Serrin, Mathematical Principles of Classical Fluid Mechanics, in: S. Fltigge (Ed.), Handbuch der Physik, Vol. VIIF1, Springer, Berlin, 1959. 16. L.D. Landau, E.M. Lifshitz, Theory of Elasticity, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1970. 17. L.D. Landau, E.M. Lifshitz, Fluid Mechanics, Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1984. 18. C.E. Weatherburn, Differential Geometry of Three Dimensions, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1939. 19. A.J. McConnell, Application of Tensor Analysis, Dover, New York, 1957. 20. R. Aris, Vectors, Tensors and the Basic Equations of Fluid Mechanics, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, 1962. 21. J.D. Eliassen, Interfacial Mechanics, Ph.D. Thesis (1963), University of Minnesota, Dept. Chemical Engineering; University Microfilms, Ann Arbour, 1983. 22. S. Ljunggren, J.C. Eriksson, P.A. Kralchevsky, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 191 (1997) 424. 23. P.A. Kralchevsky. J. Colloid Interface Sci. 137 (1990) 217. 24. T.D. Gurkov, P.A. Kralchevsky, Colloids Surf. 47 (1990) 45. 25. L. Brand, Vector and Tensor Analysis, Wiley, New York, 1947. 26. I.B. Ivanov, P.A. Kralchevsky, in: I.B. Ivanov (Ed.) Thin Liquid Films, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1988, p. 91. 27. S. Ono, S. Kondo, Molecular Theory of Surface Tension in Liquids, in: S. Fltigge (Ed.), Handbuch der Physik, vol. 10, Springer, Berlin, 1960, p. 134. 28. J.T. Davies, E. K. Rideal, Interfacial Phenomena, Academic Press, New York, 1963. 29. A.W. Adamson, A.P. Gast, Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, Wiley, New York, 1997. 30. V.S. Markin, M.M. Kozlov, S.I. Leikin, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 2, 84 (1988) 1149.
General Curved Interfaces and Biomembranes
181
31. J.C. Melrose, Ind. Eng. Chem. 60 (1968) 53. 32. Ou-Yang Zhong-can, W. Helfrich, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59 (1987) 2486. 33. Ou-Yang Zhong-can, W. Helfrich, Phys. Rev. A 39 (1989) 5280. 34. Ou-Yang Zhong-can, Phys. Rev. A 41 (1990) 4517. 35. M. Reiner, Rheology, in: S. Flfigge (Ed.), Handbuch der Physik, Vol. VI, Springer, Berlin, 1958. 36. E.D. Shchukin, A.V. Pertsov, E.A. Amelina, Colloid Chemistry, Moscow Univ. Press, Moscow, 1982 (in Russian). 37. M.J. Boussinesq, Ann. Chim. Phys. 29 (1913) 349. 38. L.E. Scriven, Chem. Eng. Sci. 12 (1960) 98. 39. N. Dan, P. Pincus, S.A. Safran, Langmuir 9 (1993) 2768. 40. H. Funaki, Japan J. Physiol. 5 (1955) 81-92. 41. P. Canham, J. Theor. Biol. 26 (1970) 61. 42. H.J. Deuling, W. Helfrich, Biophys. J. 16 (1976) 861. 43. H.J. Deuling, W. Helfrich, J. Physique 37 (1976) 1335. 44. P.R. Zarda, S. Chien, R. Skalak, J. Biomech. 10 (1977) 211. 45. H. Vayo, Canadian J. Physiol. Pharmacol. 61 (1983) 646. 46. S. Svetina, B. Zek~, Eur. Biophys. J. 17 (1989) 101. 47. U. Seifert, K. Berndl, R. Lipowsky, Phys. Rev. A, 44 (1991) 1182. 48. B. L.-S. Mui, H.-G. Dobereiner, T.D. Madden, P.R. Cullis, Biophys. J. 69 (1995) 930. 49. A.G. Volkov, D.W. Deamer, D.L. Tanelian, V.S. Markin, Liquid Interfaces in Chemistry and Biology, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1998. 50. K.D. Tachev, J.K. Angarska, K.D. Danov, P.A. Kralchevsky, Colloids Surf. B: Biointerfaces 19 (2000) 61. 51. E.A. Evans, R.M. Hochmuth, in: A. Kleinzeller & F. Bronner (Eds.), Current Topics in Membranes and Transport, Vol. 10, Academic Press, New Work, 1978; p. 1. 52. A.I. Rusanov, Phase Equilibria and Surface Phenomena, Khimia, Leningrad, 1967 (in Russian); Phasengleichgewichte und Grenzfl~chenerscheinungen, Akademie Verlag, Berlin, 1978. 53. F.P. Buff, J. Chem. Phys. 25 (1956) 146.
182
Chapter 4
54. F.P. Buff, Discuss. Faraday Soc. 30 (1960) 52. 55. F.P. Buff, The Theory of Capillarity, in: S. Flfigge (Ed.), Handbuch der Physik, Vol. X, Springer, Berlin, 1960. 56. R.C. Tolman, J. Chem. Phys. 16 (1948) 758. 57. W. Helfrich, in: Physics of Defects (R. Balian et al., Eds.), North Holland Publ. Co., Amsterdam, 1981; pp. 716- 755. 58. I. Szleifer, D. Kramer, A. Ben Shaul, D. Roux, W. M. Gelbart, Phys. Rev. Lett.60 (1988) 1966. 59. H.N.W. Lekkerkerker, Physica A 167 (1990) 384. 60. F.M. Kuni, A.I. Rusanov, in: The Modern Theory of Capillarity, A.I. Rusanov & F.C. Goodrich (Eds.), Akademie Verlag, Berlin, 1980.
183
CHAPTER 5 LIQUID FILMS AND INTERACTIONS BETWEEN PARTICLE AND SURFACE The collision of a colloid particle with an interface, or with another particle, is accompanied by the formation of a thin liquid film. The particle(s) will stick or rebound depending on whether repulsive or attractive forces prevail in the liquid film. In the case of an equilibrium liquid film the repulsive forces dominate the disjoining pressure, which is counterbalanced by the action of transversal tension, the latter being dominated by the attractive forces in the transition zone film-meniscus. The Derjaguin approximation allows one to calculate the force across a film of uneven thickness if the interaction energy per unit area of a plane-parallel film is known. Next we consider interactions of different physical origin. Expressions for the van der Waals interaction between surfaces of various shape are presented. Hypotheses about the nature of the long-range hydrophobic surface force are discussed. Special attention is paid to the electrostatic surface force which is due to the overlap of the electric double layers formed at the charged surfaces of an aqueous film. The effects of excluded volume per ion and ionic correlations lead to the appearance of a hydration repulsion and an ion-correlation attraction. The presence of fine colloidal particles in a liquid film gives rise to an oscillatory structural force which could stabilize the film or cause its step-wise thinning (stratification). At low volume fractions of the fine particles the oscillatory force degenerates into the depletion attraction, which has a destabilizing effect. The overlap of "brushes" from adsorbed polymeric molecules produces a steric interaction. The configurational confinement of thermally excited surface modes engenders repulsive undulation and protrusion forces. Finally, the collisions of emulsion drops are accompanied with deformations, i.e. deviations from the spherical shape. They cause extension of the drop surface area and change in the surface curvature, which lead to dilatational
and
bending
contributions
to
the
overall
interaction
energy.
The
total
particle-surface (or particle-particle) interaction energy is a superposition of contributions from all operative surface interactions. In addition, hydrodynamic interactions, due to the viscous friction in a liquid film, are considered in the next Chapter 6.
Chapter 5
184
5.1.
MECHANICAL BALANCES AND THERMODYNAMIC RELATIONSHIPS
5.1.1. INTRODUCTION A necessary step in the process of interaction of a colloidal particle (solid bead, liquid drop or gas bubble) with an interface is the formation of a liquid film (Fig. 5.1). For example, a liquid film of uniform thickness can be formed when a fluid particle approaches a solid surface, see Fig. 5.1 a. The shape of such a film is circular; the radius of the contact line at its periphery is denoted by rc. From a geometric (and hydrodynamic) viewpoint a liquid film is termed thin when its thickness h is relatively small, viz. h/rc << 1. From a physical viewpoint a liquid film is called thin if its thickness is sufficiently small that the molecular interactions between the two adjacent phases across the film are not negligible; as a rule this happens for h _< 100 nm [1]. These molecular interactions across the film are often termed surface forces [2,3]. The surface force per unit area of the film is called disjoining pressure, H, [4]. In general, the disjoining pressure depends on the film thickness, H = H(h). Since H is an excess pressure in the thin liquid film with respect to the bulk liquid, H vanishes in a thick film, that is I-I--->0 for h---~,x,. The disjoining pressure can be both repulsive (H > 0) and attractive (1-I < 0). A repulsive disjoining pressure may keep the two film surfaces at a given distance apart, thus creating a stable liquid film of uniform thickness, like that depicted in Fig. 5.1a. In contrast, attractive disjoining pressure destabilizes the liquid films. In the case of two solid surfaces interacting across a liquid H < 0 leads to adhesion of the two solids. If one of the film surfaces is fluid, the attractive disjoining pressure enhances the amplitude of the thermally excited fluctuation capillary waves, which grow until the film ruptures [5-9], see Section 6.2. In the case of a solid particle approaching a solid surface, the gap between the two surfaces can be treated as a liquid film of nonuniform thickness (Fig. 5.1b). Similar configuration may happen if the particle is fluid, but its surface tension is high enough, and/or its size is sufficiently small. If the interface is fluid, it undergoes some deformation produced by the interaction with the
185
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
approaching particle (Fig. 5.1c). When the liquid film ruptures, one says that the particle "enters" the fluid phase boundary. The occurrence of "entry" is important for the antifoaming action of small oil drops; this is considered in more details in Chapter 14 of this book. If a particle is entrapped within a liquid film (Fig. 5.1 d), two additional liquid films appear in the upper and lower part of the particle surface. Such a configuration is used in the film trapping technique (FTT), which allows one to measure the contact angles of Bm-sized particles [10], and to investigate the adhesive energy and physiological activation of biological cells [11,12]. (See also Fig. 5.6 below.) In this chapter we first derive and discuss basic mechanical balances and thermodynamical equations related to thin liquid films and equilibrium attachment of particles to interfaces (Section 5.1). Next, we consider separately various kinds of surface forces in thin liquid films (Section 5.2). In Chapter 6 we present an overview of the hydrodynamic interactions particle-interface and particle-particle. (Section 6.2). film of uneven thickness \
film ~,
, l h .solid
~, ,
I
,~
,
, so!id, iquid
~
llqmd
(a)
(b)
_ _ _ . f film 3
film
liquid ~
(c)
film I
(d)
Fig. 5.1. Various configurations particle-interface which are accompanied with the formation of a thin liquid film: (a) fluid particle (drop or bubble) at a solid interface" (b) solid particle at a solid surface; (c) solid or fluid particle at a fluid interface; (d) particle trapped in a liquid film.
186 5.1.2.
Chapter 5
DISJOINING PRESSURE AND TRANSVERSAL TENSION
Figure 5.2 shows a sketch of a fluid particle (drop or bubble) which is attached to a solid substrate. At equilibrium (no hydrodynamic flows) the pressure Pt in the bulk liquid phase is isotropic. The pressure inside the fluid particle, Pin, is higher than Pt because of the interfacial curvature (cf. Chapter 2): 20" R
= P/n - P~ - P c
(5.1)
where 0" is the fluid-liquid interfacial tension, Pc is the capillary pressure (the pressure jump across the curved interface), and R is the radius of curvature. The force balance p e r unit area of the upper film surface (Fig. 5.2) is given by the equation [ 13] Pin = P! + 1-I(h)
(5.2)
In other words, the increased pressure inside the fluid particle (Pin > Pl) is counterbalanced by the repulsive disjoining pressure I-I(h) acting in the liquid film. For a given I-I(h)-dependence, this balance of pressures determines the equilibrium thickness of the film. The comparison of Eqs. (5.1) and (5.2) shows that at equilibrium the disjoining pressure is equal to the capillary pressure: Fl(h) = P,:
(5.3)
Next, let us consider the force balance per unit length of the contact line, which encircles the plane-parallel film [ 14,15]: + _of + __x= 0
(5.4)
The vectors ~, _or and _xare shown in Fig. 5.2" 0" f is the tension of the upper film surface, which is different from the liquid-fluid interfacial tension 0" (as a rule 0" f < 0"), see Eq. (5.5) below. ~: is the so called transversal tension which is directed normally to the film surface. The transversal tension is a linear analogue of the disjoining pressure" r accounts for the excess interactions across the liquid film in the narrow transition zone between the uniform film and the bulk liquid phase. (Microscopically this transition zone can be treated as a film of uneven thickness and a micromechanical expression for ~"can be d e r i v e d - see Ref. 15.) Note that, in
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
187
4t liquid
. /
......
.... Ih "4,'
Fig. 5.2. Sketch of a fluid particle which is attached to a solid surface. A plane-parallel film of thickness h and radius rc is formed in the zone of attachment; Pin and Pt are the pressures in the inner fluid and in the outer liquid; II is disjoining pressure; o" and d are surface tensions of the outer fluid-liquid phase boundary and of the film surface; ~"is transversal tension. general, Eq. (5.4) may contain an additional line-tension term, cf. Eq. (2.73), which is usually very small and is neglected here; see Section 2.3.4 and Eq. (5.31) below. The horizontal and vertical projections of Eq. (5.4) have the form: o- y = o" c o s a
(5.5)
~'-asina
(5.6)
where o~ is the contact angle. Since c o s a < l, Eq. (5.5) shows that o" f
< O'.
In addition, Eq. (5.6)
states that the transversal tension ~"counterbalances the normal projection of the surface tension with respect to the film surface. To understand deeper the above force balances, we will use a thermodynamic relationship,
3a ~ Oh
=-H,
(wetting film)
(5.7)
which is derived in the next Section 5.1.3. The integration of the latter equation, along with the
188
Chapter 5
boundary condition lim o- f (h) - o-, yields h----),,~
cx~
o-f (h) - o- + II-I(h)dh
(5.8)
(wetting film)
h
In fact, the integral oo
I(h)--- fn(h; h
(5.9)
h
expresses the work (per unit area) performed against the surface forces to bring the two film surfaces from an infinite separation to a finite distance h; f(h) has the meaning of excess free energy per unit area of the thin liquid film. Comparing Eqs. (5.5) and (5.8) one obtains
1 i II(h)dh
cosa - 1 +--
- 1 -t- f~( h )
(3" h
(wetting film)
(5.10)
(f/o- << 1)
(5.11)
O-
In addition, the combination of Eqs. (5.6) and (5.10) yields
"t= G [ 1 - ( l + f / o - ) z ~ / Z ~ ( - 2 f o - ) l / 2
Equations (5.10) and (5.11) show that the interaction free energy must be negative, that is f < 0; otherwise equilibrium attachment of a particle to the interface (Fig. 5.2) is impossible. The condition f < 0 is often satisfied because at long distances the integrand 1-I(h) in Eq. (5.9) is negative, which in a final reckoning can give a negative f For aqueous films the disjoining pressure is often a superposition of electrostatic repulsion and van der Waals attraction [ 16,17]: H(h) = C exp(-tch)
AH 6~h3
(5.12)
Here C is a constant, tc is the Debye screening parameter and AH is the Hamaker constant; see Section 5.2 for details. A typical shape of the H(h) dependence, determined from Eq. (5.12), is shown in Fig. 5.3; the portion of the curve on the left of the primary minimum is due to the short-range Born repulsion, which is not accounted for in Eq. (5.12). One sees that the equation II(h) = Pc may have three roots corresponding to three possible equilibrium states the liquid
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
/
189
electrostatic barrier
rI=P
primary minimum Fig. 5.3. A typical disjoining pressure isotherm, 1-I vs. h, predicted by Eq. (5.12). The intersection points of the curve I-I(h) with the horizontal line I-I = Pc correspond to equilibrium states of the film: Points 1 and 2 - stable primary and secondary films; Point 3 - unstable equilibrium state. film, see Eq. (5.3). Point 1 in Fig. 5.3 corresponds to a film, which is stabilized by the double layer repulsion; sometimes such a film is called the primary film or common black film. Point 3 corresponds to unstable equilibrium and cannot be observed experimentally. Point 2 corresponds to a very thin film, which is stabilized by the short range repulsion; such a film is called the secondary film or Newton black film. Transitions from common to Newton black films are often observed with foam and emulsion films [ 18-21]. As an example, let us assume that the state of the film in Fig. 5.2 corresponds to Point 1 in Fig. 5.3. Then obviously II(h~) = Pc > 0, i.e. the disjoining pressure is repulsive and keeps the two film surfaces at an equilibrium distance h~ apart (film of uniform thickness is formed). On the other hand, the attractive surface forces (the zone of the "secondary minimum" in Fig. 5.3) prevail in the integral in Eq. (5.9). In such case we have f(h~) < 0 and consequently, the contact angle a does exists, see Eq. (5.10), and the transversal tension ~-is a real positive quantity, see
Chapter 5
190
•••sjn ~
Plateau border
p,
Pin i .....
h_l_2__ _~, .r t Pin .Pt+ H-r
-h/2
ro
"i Fig. 5.4. Schematic presentation of the detailed and membrane models of a thin liquid film: on the leftand right-hand side, respectively. Eq. (5.11). Note that in Fig. 5.2 H and v have the opposite directions; indeed, as seen from Fig. 5.3, and Eqs. (5.9) and (5.11), their values are determined by the predominant repulsion (for H) and attraction (for v). The fact the directions of H and "r are opposite has a crucial importance for the existence of equilibrium state of an attached particle at an interface. To demonstrate that let us consider the total balance of the forces exerted on the fluid particle in Fig. 5.2. If the particle is small (negligible effect of gravity), then the integral of Pl over the surface of the fluid particle in Fig. 5.2 is equal to zero. Then the total balance of the forces exerted on the particle reads [22,23] /D'c 2 171 ---- 21fro ~"
(5.13)
i.e. the disjoining pressure H, multiplied by the film area, must be equal to the transversal tension ~, multiplied by the length of the contact line. Thus it turns out that the fluid particle sticks to the solid surface at its contact line (at the film periphery) where the long-range attraction (accounted for by r) prevails; on the other hand, the repulsion predominates inside the film, where H = Po > 0. The exact balance of these two forces of opposite direction, expressed by Eq. (5.13), determines the state of equilibrium attachment of the particle to the interface. Note that the conclusions based on Eq. (5.13) are valid not only for particle-wall attachment, but also for particle-particle interactions, say for the formation of doublets and
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
191
multiplets (flocs) from drops in emulsions [24]. For larger particles the gravitational force Fg, which represents the difference between the particle weight and the buoyancy (Archimedes) force, may give a contribution to the force balance in Eq. (5.13), [22,23]: 7D"c2 H -"
2a'rc 7: + Fg,
Fg - Ap g Vp
(5.14)
Here Ap is the difference between the mass densities of the fluid particle and the outer liquid phase, g is the acceleration due to gravity and Vp is the volume of the particle.
5.1.3.
THERMODYNAMICSOF THIN LIQUID FILMS
First, we consider symmetric thin liquid films, like that depicted in Fig. 5.4. Since such films have two fluid surfaces, the respective thermodynamic equations sometimes differs from their analogues for wetting films (Section 5.1.2) by a multiplier 2; these differences will be noted in the text below. Symmetric films appear between two attached similar drops or bubbles, as well as in foams. As in Fig. 5.2, Pin is the pressure in the fluid particles and Pt is the pressure in the outer liquid phase (in the case of f o a m - that is the liquid in the Plateau borders). The force balances per unit area of the film surface and per unit length of the contact line (see the lefthand side of Fig. 5.4) lead again to Eqs. (5.2)-(5.6). It should be noted that two different, but supplementary, approaches (models) are used in the macroscopic description of a thin liquid film. These are the "detailed approach", used until now, and the "membrane approach"; they are illustrated, respectively, on the left- and righthand side of Fig. 5.4. As described above, the "detailed approach" models the film as a liquid layer of thickness h and surface tension cr f . In contrast, the "membrane approach", treats the film as a membrane of zero thickness and total tension, T, acting tangentially to the membrane - see the right-hand side of Fig. 5.4. By making the balance of the forces acting on a plate of unit width along the y-axis (in Fig. 5.4 the profile of this plate coincides with the z-axis) one obtains the Rusanov [25] equation: 7' = 2or f + Pch
(Pc = P i n - Pt)
(5.15)
Chapter 5
192
Equation (5.15) expresses a condition for equivalence between the membrane and detailed models with respect to the lateral force. In the framework of the membrane approach the film can be treated as a single surface phase, whose Gibbs-Duhem equation reads [23,25,26]: k
dT--sf
d T - Z Fidlai
(5.16)
i=l
where )' is the film tension, T is temperature, s f is excess entropy per unit area of the film, Fi and lai are the adsorption and the chemical potential of the i-th component. The Gibbs-Duhem equations of the liquid phase (1) and the "inner" phase (in) read k
dPz = Svx d T + ~,niX dl-ti,
Z - l , in
(5.17)
i=l
where Svz and n/z are entropy and number of molecules per unit volume, and P72 is pressure in the respective phase. Since Pc - Pin - Pl, from Eq. (5.17) one can obtain an expression for dPc. Further, we multiply this expression by h and subtract the result from the Gibbs-Duhem equation of the film, Eq. (5.16). The result reads k
d T : -'~dT + h dPc - ~_, r-'id].li
(5.18)
i=l
where
s'~ = s f +(s ~ - s v' )h,
Fi - F + (n~ - n[ )h,
i=1 ..... k
(5.19)
An alternative derivation of the same equations is possible, after Toshev and Ivanov [27]. Imagine two equidistant planes separated at a distance h. The volume confined between the two planes is thought to be filled with the bulk liquid phase "/". Taking surface excesses with respect to the bulk phases, one can derive Eqs. (5.18) and (5.19) with ~" and F i being the excess surface entropy and adsorption ascribed to the surfaces of this liquid layer. A comparison between Eqs. (5.18) and (5.16) shows that there is one additional term in Eq. (5.18), viz. h dPc. It corresponds to one supplementary degree of freedom connected with the
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
193
choice of the parameter h. To specify the model one needs an additional equation to determine h. For example, let this equation be F~ - 0
(5.20)
Equation (5.20) requires h to be the thickness of a liquid layer from phase "/", containing the same amount of component 1 as the real film. This thickness is called the thermodynamic thickness of the film [28]. It can be of the order of the real film thickness if component 1 is chosen in an appropriate way, say, to be the solvent in the film phase. Combining Eqs. (5.3), (5.18) and (5.20) one obtains [27] k
(5.21)
d y - -'~dT + hdrI - ~ [-)U~LIi i=2
Note that the summation in the latter equation starts from i=2, and that the number of differentials in Eqs. (5.16) and (5.21) is the same. A corollary from Eq. (5.2t) is the Frumkin equation [29] /OT~
=h
(5.22)
For thin liquid films h is a relatively small quantity (h < 10-5 cm)" therefore Eq. (5.22) predicts a rather weak dependence of the film tension 7' on the disjoining pressure, l-I, in equilibrium thin films. By means of Eqs. (5.3) and (5.15) one can transform Eq. (5.21) to read [28] k
(5.23)
2dry f - -'~dT - FId h - ~_~ I-'id Jxi i=2
From Eq. (5.23) the following useful relations can be derived [27,28]
tehl.2
2( c?~Yf
=-I-I
(symmetric film)
(5.24)
cr i ( h ) - r +-~ f H(h)dh
(symmetric film)
(5.25)
. . . . . ]-t k
c,o
h
Note that the latter two equations differ from the respective relationships for a wetting film,
Chapter 5
194
Eqs (5.7) and (5.8), with multipliers 2 and 1/2; as already mentioned, this is due to the presence of two fluid surfaces in the case of a symmetric liquid film. Note also that the above thermodynamic equations are corollaries from the Gibbs-Duhem equation in the membrane approach, Eq. (5.16). The detailed approach, which treats the two film surfaces as separate surface phases with their own fundamental equations [25,27,30]; thus for a flat symmetric film one postulates k
dU f - T d S f + 2o- f d a + ~_~l.tidNf - H A d h ,
(5.26)
i=I
where A is area; U f , S f and N f are excesses of the internal energy, entropy and number of molecules ascribed to the film surfaces. Compared with the fundamental equation of a simple surface phase [31 ], Eq. (5.26) contains an additional term, -IIAdh, which takes into account the dependence of the film surface energy on the film thickness. Equation (5.26) provides an alternative thermodynamic definition of the disjoining pressure:
I The thin liquid films formed in foams or emulsions exist in a permanent contact with the bulk liquid in the Plateau borders, encircling the film. From a macroscopic viewpoint, the boundary film/Plateau border can be treated as a three-phase contact line: the line, at which the two surfaces of the Plateau border (the two concave menisci) intersect at the plane of the film, see the right-hand side of Fig. 5.4. The angle t~), subtended between the two meniscus surfaces, represents the thin film contact angle corresponding to the membrane approach. The force balance at each point of the contact line is given by the Neumann-Young equation, Eq. (2.73) with o-w = 7', and o-u = o-v = 6. The effect of the line tension, ~c, can be also taken into account, see Eq. (2.70). Thus for a symmetrical flat film with circular contact line (Fig. 5.4) one obtains [14] K"
7' + - - = 2o" c o s a 0 r0 where r0 is the radius of the respective contact line.
(5.28)
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
'
re2
d
~i ;
1 ; 0/
rcl
/
195
)
'
fluid 2
_/'_-IN
/
\
\'~
\
fluidl
~
Plateau
border
/
!
Fig. 5.5. Schematic presentation of the force balances in each point of the two contact lines at the boundary between a spherical film and the Plateau border, see Eq. (5.32); after Refs. [23,32]. There are two film surfaces and two contact lines in the detailed approach, see the left-hand side of Fig. 5.4. They can be treated thermodynamically as linear phases; further, an onedimensional analogue of Eq. (5.26) can be postulated [ 14]: (5.29)
d U L - T d S L + 2 ~ d L + E l . t i d N i c +'cdh i
Here Uc, SL and N~ are linear excesses, ~ is the line tension in the detailed approach and
(5.30) L ~ Oh
is a thermodynamical definition of the transversal tension, which is apparently an onedimensional analogue of the disjoining pressure II - cf. Eqs. (5.27) and (5.30). The vectorial force balance per unit length of the contact lines of a symmetric film, with account for the line tension effect, is [14] ~ +_o-r+ $ + c~:= O,
I~r{= ~ / r c
(5.31)
Chapter 5
196
A
OuterSet of Interference Fringes B
_ ~ Air._./.-.------__./ if
/
~ r = n C ~ ~ I ~
~
InnerSet of Interference Water Fringes
Asymmetric PlaneParallel Cell-Water-Air FoamFilm Film
~ TCR AmAb
? OtherProteins I Glycocallx
Fig. 5.6. Operation principle of the Film Trapping Technique. (A) A photograph of leukemic Jurkat cell trapped in a foam (air-water-air) film. The cell is observed in reflected monochromatic light; a pattern of alternating dark and bright interference fringes appears. (B) Sketch of the cell trapped in the film. The inner set of fringes corresponds to the region of contact of the cell with the protein adsorption layer (C). From the radii of the interference fringes one can restore the shapes of the liquid meniscus and the cell, and calculate the contact angle, o~, the cell membrane tension, CYc,and the tension of the cell-water-air film, T; from Ivanov et al. [ 12].
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
197
see Fig. 5.4; the vector cy~, expressing the line tension effect, is directed toward the center of curvature of the contact line, see Chapter 2 for details. In the case of a curved or non-symmetric film (film formed between two different fluid phases) Eq. (5.31) can be generalized as follows [23]: r
K
+ -~f + $i + _ci = 0,
i = 1,2
(5.32)
see Fig. 5.5 for the notation. Equation (5.32) represents a generalization of the NeumannYoung equation, Eq. (2.73), expressing the vectorial balance of forces at each point of the respective contact line. Equation (5.32) finds applications for determining contact angles of liquid films, which in their own turn bring information about the interaction energy per unit area of the film, see Eq. 5.10. Experimentally, information about the shape of fluid interfaces can be obtained by means of interferometric techniques and subsequent theoretical analysis of the interference pattern [33]. This approach can be applied also to biological cells. For example, as illustrated in Fig. 5.6, human T cells have been trapped in a liquid film, whose surfaces represent adsorption monolayers of monoclonal antibodies acting as specific ligands for the receptors expressed on the cell surface. From the measured contact angle the cell-monolayer adhesive energy was determined and information about the ligand-receptor interaction has been obtained [ 12].
5.1.4.
DERJAGUIN APPROXIMATION FOR FILMS OF UNEVEN THICKNESS
In the previous sections of this chapter we considered planar liquid films. Here we present a popular approximate approach, proposed by Derjaguin [34], which allows one to calculate the interaction between a particle and an interface across a film of nonuniform thickness, like that depicted in Fig. 5.1 b, assuming that the disjoining pressure of a plane-parallel film is known. Following the derivation by Derjaguin [2, 34], let us consider the zone of contact between a particle and an interface; in general, the latter is curved, see Fig. 5.7a. The "interface" could be the surface of another particle. The Derjaguin approximation is applicable to calculate the interaction between any couple of colloidal particles, either solid, liquid or gas bubbles. The only assumption is that the characteristic range of action of the surface forces is much smaller than any of the surface curvature radii in the zone of contact.
198
Chapter 5
,4,~,, .
(II)
.
.
.
.
.
')/ .
.
.
.
"]~' 'x l
y9
[h_
"
s " "~fD v
(I)
"
~x \
(a)
(b)
Fig. 5.7. (a) The zone of contact of two macroscopic bodies; h0 is the shortest surface-to-surface distance. (b) The directions of the principle curvatures of the two surfaces, in general, subtend some angle co. The length of the segment
OIO2
in Fig. 5.7a, which is the closest distance between the two
surfaces, is denoted by h0. The z-axis is oriented along the segment O102. In the zone of contact the shapes of the two surfaces can be approximated with paraboloids [2, 34]: z, = 71q x( + 89
z2 = 7c2x 2 1 2 +2c2y2,1 ..,. 2
2,
(5.33)
p
Here c~ and c~ are the principal curvatures of the first surface in the point O1" likewise,
C2
and
c~ are the principal curvatures of the second surface in the point O2; the coordinate plane xiYi passes through the point Oi, i = 1,2. The axes xi and Yi are oriented along the principal directions of the curved surface Si in the point Oi. In general, the directions of the principle curvatures of the two surfaces subtend some angle co (0 < co < 180~ see Fig. 5.7b: x 2 -- x 1 COS(D +
y] sinco,
Y2 = - x ]
sinco +
Yl COSCO
(5.34)
The local width of the gap between the two surfaces is (Fig. 5.7a) h = h0 + zl +
Z2
(5.35)
Combining Eqs. (5.33)-(5.35) one obtains [2, 34] h = ho + 89a x 2 +-~1 B y2 + C x l y]
(5.36)
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
199
where A, B and C are coefficients independent of x~ and yl: A = cl+
p
C2 COS2(D + C2 sin2o9
p
B = c~ + C = (c 2 -
(5.37)
p
C2 sin2o9 + C2 COS20) p c 2 ) cos(_/)
(5.38)
sinm
(5.39)
Equation (5.36) expresses h(xl,Yl) as a bilinear form; the latter, as known from the linear algebra, can be represented as a quadratic form by means of a special coordinate transformation
(Xl, yl) --> (x, y): h -- h 0 + 1 c x 2 - k - l c t y 2
(5.40)
This is equivalent to bringing of the symmetric matrix (tensor) of the bilinear form into diagonal form:
/
~/
1
'
(5.41)
Since the determinant of a tensor is invariant with respect to coordinate transformations, one can write (5.42)
c c" = A B - C 2
Further, we assume that the interaction free energy (due to the surface forces) per unit area of a plane-parallel film of thickness h is known: this is the function f(h) defined by Eq. (5.9). The "core" of the Derjaguin approximation is the assumption that the energy of interaction, U, between the two bodies (I and II in Fig. 5.7a) across the film is given by the expression U
(5.43)
; ; f (h(x, y)) dxdy
where h = ho + 89 x 2 +lc'y2. Further, let us introduce polar coordinates in the plane xy:
x
-~cccosq9,
y-
cosq9
Since h depends only on p, Eq. (4.43) acquires the form
(5.44)
200
Chapter 5
21r
oo
U = ~ f f ( h ( p ) ) pdpdtp
(h = ho + 1/92)
(5.45)
o o Integrating with respect to tp and using the relationship dh = p dp one finally obtains [2, 34] oo
2Jr ~f(h)dh, U(h~ = - ~ h o
(interaction energy)
(5.46)
E - cc'=c,c; +c2c 2 + (c,c 2 +c;c2)sin z co +(c,c 2 +c;c2)cos 2 co
(5.47)
The last expression is obtained by substitution of Eqs (5.37)-(5.39) into Eq. (5.42). We recall that oJ is the angle subtended between the directions of the principle curvatures of the two approaching surfaces. It has been established, both experimentally [3] and theoretically [35], that Eq. (5.46) provides a good approximation for the interaction energy in the range of its validity. The interaction force between two bodies, separated at a surface-to-surface distance h0, can be obtained by differentiation of Eq. (5.46):
F(ho)=
~U = ~-~ 2/r f (ho) Oho
(interaction force)
(5.48)
Next, we consider various cases of special geometry:
Sphere-Wall: This is the configuration depicted in Fig. 5.1b - particle of radius R p
situated at a surface-to-surface distance h0 from a planar solid surface. In such a case Cl = c 1 = p
1/R, whereas c2 - c 2 = 0. Then from Eqs. (5.46)-(5.47) one deduces oo
U(h0)= 2zcg ~f(h)dh, ho
(sphere-wall)
(5.49)
Truncated Sphere - Wall: For this configuration, see Fig. 5.1 a, the interaction across the plane-parallel film of radius rc should be also taken into account [36-39]: oo
U(h o )= 2JrR f f(h)dh + ~'r~f (ho)
(truncated s p h e r e - wall)
(5.50)
h0
Two Spheres: For two spherical particles of radii RI and t surface distance h0 one has cl = c 1 = 1/RI and c2 = c 2 p
=
R2
separated at a surface-to-
1/R2. Then Eqs. (5.46)-(5.47) yield
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
U (ho ) - 2JrR1R2 i R, + R 2 f (h ) dh
201
(two spheres)
(5.51)
In the limit R1---~R and R 2 ~ , Eq. (5.51) reduces to Eq. (5.49), as it should be expected.
Two Crossed Cylinders: For two infinitely long cylinders (rods) of radii rl and r2, which are separated at a transversal surface-to-surface distance h0, and whose axes subtend an angle p
p
co, one has Cl = 1/r~, c I = O, c2 = 1/r2 and c 2 = 0. Then Eqs. (5.46)-(5.47) lead to [2]
U(ho)- 2zt'-~lre i f ( h ) d h sin co
(two cylinders)
(5.52)
h0
The latter equation is often used to interpret data obtained by means of the surface force apparatus, which operates with crossed cylinders [3]. For parallel cylinders, that is for co-->0, Eq. (5.52) gives U ~ , , ; this divergence is not surprising because the contact zone between two parallel cylinders is infinitely long, whereas the interaction energy per unit length is finite. In the surface force apparatus usually co = 90 ~ and then sin co = 1. The interaction force can be calculated by a mere differentiation of Eqs. (5.49)-(5.52) in accordance with Eq. (5.48). The Derjaguin approximation is applicable to any type of force law (attractive, repulsive, oscillatory) if only the range of the forces is much smaller than the particle radii. Moreover, it is applicable to any kind of surface force, irrespective of its physical origin: van der Waals, electrostatic, steric, oscillatory-structural, etc. forces, which are described in the next section.
5.2.
I N T E R A C T I O N S IN THIN LIQUID F I L M S
5.2.1.
OVERVIEW OF THE TYPES OF SURFACE FORCES
As already mentioned, if a liquid film is sufficiently thin (thinner than c.a. 100 rim) the interaction of the two neighboring phases across the film is not negligible. The resulting disjoining pressure, H(h), may contain contributions from various kinds of molecular interactions. The first successful theoretical model of the interactions in liquid films and the stability of
202
Chapter 5
colloidal dispersions was created by Derjaguin & Landau [ 16], and Verwey & Overbeek [17]; it is often termed "DLVO theory" after the names of the authors. This model assumes that the disjoining pressure is a superposition of electrostatic repulsion and van der Waals attraction, see Eq. (5.12), Fig. 5.3 and Sections 5.2.2 and 5.2.4 below. In many cases this is the correct physical picture and the DLVO theory provides a quantitative description of the respective effects and phenomena. Subsequent studies, both experimental and theoretical, revealed the existence of other surface forces, different from the conventional van der Waals and electrostatic (double layer) interactions. Such forces appear as deviations from the DLVO theory and are sometimes called "non-DLVO surface forces" [3]. An example is the hydrophobic attraction which brings about instability of aqueous films spread on a hydrophobic surface, see Section 5.2.3. Another example is the hydration repulsion, which appears as a considerable deviation from the DLVO theory in very thin (h < 10 rim) films from electrolyte solutions, see Section 5.2.5. Oscillations of the surface force with the surface-to-surface distance were first detected in films from electrolyte solutions sandwiched between solid surfaces [3,40]. This oscillatory
structural force appears also in thin liquid films containing small colloidal particles like surfactant micelles, polymer coils, protein macromolecules, latex or silica particles [41 ]. For larger particle volume fractions the oscillatory force is found to stabilize thin films and dispersions, whereas at low particle concentrations it degenerates into the depletion attraction, which has the opposite effect, see Section 5.2.7. When the surfaces of the liquid film are covered with adsorption layers form nonionic surfactants, like those having polyoxiethylene moieties, the overlap of the formed polymer brushes give rise to a steric interaction [3, 42], which is reviewed in Section 5.2.8. The surfactant adsorption monolayers on liquid interfaces and the lipid lamellar membranes are involved in a thermally exited motion, which manifests itself as fluctuation capillary waves. When such two interfaces approach each other, the overlap of the interfacial corrugations causes a kind of steric interaction (though a short range one), termed the fluctuation force [3], see Section 5.2.9. The approach of a fluid particle (emulsion drop or gas bubble) to a phase boundary might be
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
203
accompanied with interfacial deformations: dilatation and bending. The latter also do contribute to the overall particle-surface interaction, see Section 5.2.10. In a final reckoning, the total energy of interaction between a particle and a surface, U, can be expressed as a sum of contributions of different origin: from the interfacial dilatation and bending, from the van der Waals, electrostatic, hydration, oscillatory-structural, steric, etc. surface forces as follows [43]: U = Udil + Ubend + Uvw + Uel + Uhydr + Uosc + Ust + ""
(5.53)
Below we present theoretical expressions for calculating the various terms in the right-hand side of Eq. (5.53). In addition, in the next Chapter 6 we consider also the surface forces of
hydrodynamic origin, which are due to the viscous dissipation of energy in the narrow gap between two approaching surfaces in liquid (Section 6.2). In summary, below in this chapter we present a brief description of the various kinds of surface forces. The reader could find more details in the specialized literature on surface forces and thin liquid films [2, 3, 42-45]
5.2.2.
VAN DER WAALS SURFACE FORCE
The van der Waals forces represent an averaged dipole-dipole interaction, which is a superposition of three contributions: (i) orientation interaction between two permanent dipoles: effect of Keesom [46]; (ii) induction interaction between one permanent dipole and one induced dipole: effect of Debye [47]; (iii) dispersion interaction between two induced dipoles: effect of London [48]. The energy of van der Waals interaction between molecules i and j obeys the law [49] uij (r) --
a iJ r6
(5.54)
where uij is the potential energy of interaction, r is the distance between the two molecules and o~ij is a constant characterizing the interaction. In the case of two molecules in a gas phase one has [3, 49]
Chapter 5
204
p2
2
_ ~ i Pj -1" (p20~Oj -[- p j2 O~Oi )jr. 37~O~oiO~ojhpViV j a ij -3kT v i nt-V j
where Pi and O(.oiare molecular dipole moment and electronic polarizability, hp = 6.63•
(5.55)
TM J.s
is the Planck constant and vi can be interpreted as the orbiting frequency of the electron in the Bohr atom; see Refs. [3, 50] for details. The van der Waals interaction between two macroscopic bodies can be found by integration of Eq. (5.54) over all couples of interacting molecules followed by subtraction of the interaction energy at infinite separation between the bodies. The result of integration depends on the geometry of the system. For a plane-parallel film located between two semiinfinite phases the van der Waals interaction energy per unit area and the respective disjoining pressure, stemming from Eq. (5.54), are [51 ]: An fvw =-12:rt.h-------T,
Hvw = -
~ fvw An ol-----~=-6tch------T
(5.56)
where, as usual, h is the thickness of the film and AH is the Hamaker constant [44, 51 ]; about the calculation of A H - see Eqs. (5.65)-(5.74) below. By integration over all couples of interacting molecules Hamaker [51 ] has derived the following expression for the energy of van der Waals interaction between two spheres of radii R1 and R2:
Uvw(ho)=
At/
Y
X2 + x y + x
_~ x 2
y
+xy+x+y
X 2 -k-xy-]-X ) +21nx2 + x y + x + y
(5.57)
where x = h 0 / 2R 1,
y = R 2 ] R~ < 1
(5.58)
as before, h0 is the shortest surface-to-surface distance. For x << 1 Eq. (5.57) reduces to Uvw (ho)=
A~I Y = - 2n'RI R~2 An 12 (1 + y)x R 1 + R 2 12g'ho
(5.59)
Equation (5.59) can be also derived by substituting fvw(h) from Eq. (5.56) into Derjaguin approximation (5.51). It is worthwhile noting, that the logarithmic term in Eq. (5.57) can be neglected only if x << 1. For example, even when x = 5 x 10-3, the contribution of the
Liquid Filmsand InteractionsbetweenParticleand Surface
205
logarithmic term amounts to about 10% of the result (for y = 1); consequently, for larger values of x this term must be retained [44]. For the configuration
sphere - wall,
which is depicted in Fig. 5.1b, an expression for the
interaction energy can be obtained setting R1 ~ o,, and R2 = R in Eqs. (5.57) and (5.58):
U vw(h~
AI4 ( ~2R 2R +~+21n
--~-
ho
ho
2R + h o
)
(5.60)
2R + h o
Alternatively, substituting fvw(h) from Eq. (5.56) into the Derjaguin approximated formula (5.49) one derives Uvw (ho)_
A/_/ 2R 12 ho
(5.61)
which coincides with the leading term in Eq. (5.60) for Next, let us consider the configuration
ho/(2R) << 1.
truncated sphere - wall, which
is depicted in Fig. 5.1 a.
An expression for the interaction energy in this case has been derived by Danov et al. [37]:
Uvw (ho ) -
-AH(2R12 / h~ ~re2 2R ho + h---7+ ~ + 21n l + ho 1+ ho
where l - R + (R 2 -
2re2 ]
(5.62)
lh
re{)1/2. Alternatively, substituting fvw(h) from Eq. (5.56) into Derjaguin
approximated formula (5.50) one obtains Uvw (ho )= - - AH(2R_ ~ --~o +
h-~ore2)"
(5.63)
Obviously, the latter approximate expression contains the two leading terms in the right-hand side of Eq. (5.62) for ho--->0. In the case of film between
two identical deformed emulsion droplets,
like those depicted in
Fig. 3.5 with a = R, r = rc and h = ho, the respective droplet-droplet interaction energy can be expressed in the form [37]
AHIR-;-- +-7~re2 +-73 + 21n(__~) - 12re2 Roj h Uvw (ho ) = --72IZLno h~ 4
(ho, re << R)
(5.64)
Chapter 5
206
Equation (5.64) represents a truncated series expansion; the exact formula, which is rather long, can be found in Ref. [37]. Expressions for Uvw for other geometrical configurations are also available [52]. Further, we consider expressions for calculating the Hamaker constant An, which enters Eqs. (5.56)-(5.64). For that purpose two approaches have been developed: the microscopic theory due to Hamaker [51] and the macroscopic theory due to Lifshitz [53].
Microscopic theory: its basic assumption is that the van der Waals interaction is pairwise additive, and consequently, the total interaction energy between two bodies can be obtained by interaction over all couples of constituent molecules. Thus, for the interaction between two semiinfinite phases, composed from components i and j, across a plane-parallel gap of vacuum, one obtains Eq. (5.56) with AH = Aij, where Aij is expressed as follows
A 0 --~2piPjO~ij
(5.65)
p/and pj are the densities of the respective phases and o~ijis a molecular parameter defined by Eq. (5.55). Usually, the dimension of Pi and pj is expressed in molecules per cm 3, and then AH and A 0 have a dimension of energy. For a plane-parallel film from component 3 between two semiinfinite phases from components 1 and 2 the microscopic approach gives again Eq. (5.56), but this time the compound Hamaker constant is determined by the expression [44]
Au -
A132 =
A33 +
AI2 -
A13 -
A23
(5.66)
Here A 0 (ij = 1,2,3) is determined by Eq. (5.65). If the film is "filled" with vacuum, then/93 = 0 and Eq. (5.66) reduces to AH = A~2, as it could be expected. If the Hamaker constants of the symmetric films, viz. Aii and Ajj, are known, one can estimate Aij (i:/:j) by using the approximation of Hamaker
Aij=(A~ Ajj
(5.67)
If components 1 and 2 are identical, AH is positive. Therefore, the van der Waals interaction between identical bodies is attractive across any medium. Besides, two dense bodies (even if nonidentical) will attract each other when placed in medium 3 of low density (gas, vacuum).
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
I
3L
2L
207
hi2
!
1L
1R
2R
3R
4R
hll h21
"1 I ,..|
Fig. 5.8. Sketch of two multilayered bodies interacting across a medium 0; the layers are counted from the central film 0 outward to the left (L) and right (R). On the other hand, if the phase in the middle (component 3) has an intermediate Hamaker constant between those of bodies 1 and 2 (say All < A33 < A22), then the compound Hamaker constant AH can be negative and the van der Waals disjoining pressure can be r e p u l s i v e (positive). Such is the case of an aqueous film between mercury and gas [54], or liquid hydrocarbon film on alumina [55] and quartz [56]. It is worthwhile noting that the liquid helium climbs up the walls of containers because of the repulsive van der Waals force across the wetting helium film [3, 57, 58]. Equation (5.66) can be generalized for multilayered films. For example, two surfactant adsorption monolayers (or lipid bilayers) interacting across water film can b e modeled as a multilayered structure: one layer for the headgroup region, other layer for the hydrocarbon tails, another layer for the aqueous core of the film, etc.). There is a general formula for the interaction between two such multilayered structures (Fig. 5.8) stemming from the microscopic approach [52]: fvw - - ~_~ NL ~-~ NR a ( i , j)2 , i=l j=l 12rth o
a ( i , j ) - a i,j - ai,
, - a i - j + Ai- ,j ~
(5.68)
where NL and NR denote the number of layers on the left and on the r i g h t from the central layer, the latter denoted by index "0" - see Fig. 5.8 for the notation; Ai,j (= A O) is defined by Eq. (5.65). Equation (5.68) reduces to Eq. (5.56) for N L - NR - 1 and hi1 = h.
208
Chapter 5
Macroscopic theory: An alternative approach to the calculation of the Hamaker constant A/_/in condensed phases is provided by the Lifshitz theory [53, 57], which is not limited by the assumption for pairwise additivity of the van der Waals interaction, see also Refs. [2, 3,52]. The Lifshitz theory treats each phase as a continuous medium characterized by a given uniform dielectric permittivity, which is dependent on the frequency, v, of the propagating electromagnetic waves. A good knowledge of quantum field theory is required to understand the Lifshitz theory of the van der Waals interaction between macroscopic bodies. Nevertheless, the final results of this theory can be represented in a form convenient for application. For the symmetric configuration of two identical phases i interacting across a medium j the macroscopic theory provides the expression [3]
AH =-Aiji -A~ v=~ +A/~/v.>~
I 12 E i -- E j
kT Ei -[-~-'J
+
(5.69)
16-v/2-(n2 +nj
where ei and ej are the dielectric constants of phases i and j; ni and nj are the respective refractive indices for visible light; as usual, hp is the Planck constant; Ve is the main electronic absorption frequency which is ~ 3.0xl015Hz for water and the most organic liquids [3]. The first term in the right-hand side of Eq. (5.69), A/}v=~ , the so called zero frequency term, expresses the contribution of the orientation and induction interactions. Indeed, these two contributions to the van der Waals force represent electrostatic effects. Equation (5.69) shows that this zero-frequency term can never exceed 3 kT -- 3
x 10 -21
J. The last term in Eq. (5.69),
A~v>~ , accounts for the dispersion interaction. If the two phases, i and j, have comparable densities (as it is for emulsion systems, say oil-water-oil), then a/}v>~ and a/}v=~ are comparable by magnitude. If one of the phases, i or j, has low density (gas, vacuum), as a rule A~v>~ >> A~y=~ in this respect the macroscopic and microscopic theories often give different predictions for the value of AH. For the more general configuration of phases i and k, interacting across a film from phase j, the macroscopic (Lifshitz) theory provides the following expression [3]
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
AH = Aijk = "~ij~
+ ~lijk
--
kT
209
J
(5.70)
+
Upon substitution k = i Eq. (5.70) reduces to Eq. (5.69). Equation (5.70) can be simplified if the following approximate relationship is satisfied: (5.71) that is the arithmetic and geometric mean of the respective quantities are approximately equal. Substitution of Eq. (5.7 l) into (5.70) yields a more compact expression: 3hpVe(?l 2 --?12)(?l 2 - n ~ ) AH = Aij ~ =
kT '~i + •j
e k + ej
+ 164~-(n2 + n~
)3/4 (n 2 + nj2)3/4
(5.72)
Comparing Eqs. (5.69) and (5.72) one obtains the following c o m b i n i n g relations: (V=o, _ A ijk L iji
[A(V=O)A(V=O, ]1,2 kjk
(5.73)
(v>0) (v>0) A (V>~ = [Aiji Akjk ] 1/
(5.74)
The latter two equations show that according to the macroscopic theory the Hamaker a(V-~ (orientation + approximation, Eq. (5.67), holds separately for the zero-frequency term, "ijk induction interactions) and for the dispersion interaction term, a(v>0) "ijk 9 Effect o f e l e c t r o m a g n e t i c
retardation.
The asymptotic behavior of the dispersion
interaction at large intermolecular separations does not obey Eq. (5.54); instead u 0 o~ 1/r 7 due to the electromagnetic retardation effect established by Casimir and Polder [59]. Experimentally this effect has been first detected by Derjaguin and Abrikossova [60] in measurements of the interaction between two quartz glass surfaces in the distance range 100-400 rim. Various expressions have been proposed to account for this effect in the Hamaker constant; one convenient formula for the case of symmetric films has been derived by Prieve and Russel, see
210
Chapter 5
Ref. [42]:
i/l+
2
where, as usual, h is the film thickness; the dimensionless thickness h is defined by the expression "~
2 ]1/2 2 7 W e
h - nj (n2 + n j ,
h
,
(5.76)
c
where c = 3.0 • 10 l~ cm/s is the speed of light; the integral in Eq. (5.75) is to be solved numerically; for estimates one can use the approximate interpolating formula [42]:
~O+2hz)exp(-2hZ)dz= 0
(1+2z2) 2
rc ~
rch 1+ - ~
(5.77)
For small thickness A/~v>~ , as given by Eqs. (5.75), is constant, whereas for large thickness h one obtains A/~ >~
h -1. For additional information about the electromagnetic retardation
e f f e c t - see Refs. [3,42,52]. It is interesting to note that this relativistic effect essentially influences the critical thickness of rupture of foam and emulsion films, see Section 6.2 below.
Screening of the orientation and induction interactions in electrolyte solutions. As already mentioned, the orientation and induction interactions (unlike the dispersion interaction) are electrostatic effects; so, they are not subjected to electromagnetic retardation. Instead, they are influenced by the Debye screening due to the presence of ions in the aqueous phase. Thus for the interaction across an electrolyte solution the screened Hamaker constant is given by the expression [50]
A H =A (v=~ (2tch)e -2rh +A (v>~
(5.78)
where A (v-'--~ denotes the contribution of orientation and induction interaction into the Hamaker constant in the absence of any electrolyte" A (v>~ is the contribution of the dispersion interaction; tr is the Debye screening parameter defined by Eqs. (1.56) and (1.64). Additional information about this effect can be found in Refs. [3, 42, 50].
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
5.2.3.
211
LONG-RANGE HYDROPHOBIC SURFACE FORCE
The experiment sometimes gives values of the Hamaker constant, which are markedly larger than the values predicted by the theory. This fact could be attributed to the action of a strong attractive hydrophobic force, which is found to appear across thin aqueous films sandwiched between two hydrophobic surfaces [61-63].
The experiments showed that the nature of the
hydrophobic force is different from the van der Waals interaction [61-69]. It turns out that the hydrophobic interaction decays exponentially with the increase of the film thickness, h. The hydrophobic free energy per unit area of the film can be described by means of the equation [3]
fhydrophobic= - 2 y e -h / 2~)
( 5.79 )
where typically y = 10-50 mJ/m 2, and 20 = 1-2 nm in the range 0 < h < 10 nm. Larger decay length, 2o - 12-16 nm, was reported by Christenson et al. [69] for the range 20 n m < h < 90 nm. This long-ranged attraction entirely dominates over the van der Waals forces. The fact that the hydrophobic attraction can exist at high electrolyte concentrations, of the order of 1 M, means that this force cannot have electrostatic origin [69-74]. In practice, this attractive interaction leads to a rapid coagulation of hydrophobic particles in water [75, 76] and to rupturing of water films spread on hydrophobic surfaces [77]. It can play a role in the adhesion and fusion of lipid bilayers and biomembranes [78]. The hydrophobic interaction can be completely suppressed if the adsorption of surfactant, dissolved in the aqueous phase, converts the surfaces from hydrophobic into hydrophilic. There is no generally accepted explanation of the hydrophobic force [79]. One of the possible mechanisms is that an orientational ordering, propagated by hydrogen bounds in water and other associated liquids, could be the main underlying factor [3, 80]. Another hypothesis for the physical origin of the hydrophobic force considers a possible role of formation of gaseous capillary bridges between the two hydrophobic surfaces [65, 3, 72], see Fig. 2.6a. In this case the hydrophobic force would be a kind of capillary-bridge force; see Chapter 11 below. Such bridges could appear spontaneously, by nucleation (spontaneous dewetting), when the distance between the two surfaces becomes smaller than a certain threshold value, of the order of several hundred nanometers, see Table 11.2 below. Gaseous bridges could appear even if there is no dissolved gas in the water phase; the pressure inside a bridge can be as low as the equilibrium
Chapter 5
212
vapor pressure of water (23.8 mm Hg at 25~
owing to the high interfacial curvature of
nodoid-shaped bridges, see Chapter 11. A number of recent studies [81-88] provide evidence in support of the capillary-bridge origin of the long-range hydrophobic surface force. In particular, the observation of "steps" in the experimental data was interpreted as an indication for separate acts of bridge nucleation [87].
5.2.4.
ELECTROSTATIC SURFACE FORCE
The electrostatic (double layer) interactions across an aqueous film are due to the overlap of the double electric layers formed at two charged interfaces. The surface charge can be due to dissociation of surface ionizable groups or to the adsorption of ionic surfactants (Fig. 1.4) and polyelectrolytes [2,3]. Note however, that sometimes electrostatic repulsion is observed even between interfaces covered by adsorption monolayers of nonionic surfactants [89-92]. First, let us consider the electrostatic (double layer) interaction between two identical charged plane parallel surfaces across a solution of an electrolyte (Fig. 5.9). If the separation between the two planes is very large, the number concentration of both counterions and coions would be equal to its bulk value, no, in the middle of the film. However, at finite separation, h, between the surfaces the two electric double layers overlap and the counterion and coion concentrations in the middle of the film, t/lm and t/Zm, are not equal. As pointed out by Langmuir [93], the electrostatic disjoining pressure, Fief, can be identified with the excess osmotic pressure in the
middle of the film: I-Iel -- kT(nlm + n2m -- 2n 0 )
(5.80)
One can deduce Eq. (5.80) starting from a more general definition of disjoining pressure [2,23]: I-I = P N -- Pbulk
(5.81 )
where PN is the normal (with respect to the film surface) component of the pressure tensor P and Pbulk is the pressure in the bulk of the electrolyte solution. The condition for mechanical equilibrium, V.P = 0, yields OPN/OZ = 0, that is PN = const, across the film; the z-axis is directed
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
213
Z
vl
--ram
~)
~
e
e
film
"--~ - " ~
@ 0
bulk x solution
|
/
l',X,,.
/,'
vs
@
(a)
(b)
Fig. 5.9. (a) Schematic presentation of a liquid film from electrolyte solution between two identical charged surfaces; the film is equilibrated with the bulk solution. (b) Distribution ~(z) of the electric potential across the liquid film (the continuous line): ~,,, is the minimum value of ~t(z) in the middle of the film; the dashed lines show the electric potential distribution created by the respective charged surfaces in contact with a semiinfinite electrolyte solution. perpendicular to the film surfaces, Fig. 5.9a. Hence H, defined by Eq. (5.81), has a constant value for a given liquid film at a given thickness. For a liquid film from electrolyte solution one can use Eq. (1.17) to express PN :
PN = ezz = Po ( Z ) - 87[7~ dz
(5.82)
where, as usual, ~ z ) is the potential of the electric field, e is the dielectric permittivity of the solution, Po(z) is the pressure in a uniform phase, which is in chemical equilibrium with the bulk electrolyte solution and has the same composition as the film at level z. Considering the electrolyte solution as an ideal solution, and using the known expression for the osmotic pressure, we obtain Po(z) - Pbulk = k T [ n l ( z ) + n2(z) - 2n0]
(5.83)
where n~(z) and n2(z) are local concentrations of the counterions and coions inside the film. The combination of Eqs. (5.81)-(5.83) yields
214
Chapter 5
kT[nl(z)
1-Iel-"
+ r/2(z) -
2n0] - ~
(5.84)
Equation (5.84) represents a general definition for the electrostatic component of disjoining pressure, which is valid for symmetric and non-symmetric electrolytes, as well as for identical and nonidentical film surfaces. The same equation was derived by Derjaguin [44] in a different, thermodynamic manner. Note that I-Ie~, defined by Eq. (5.84), must be constant, i.e. independent of the coordinate z. To check that one can use the equations of Boltzmann and Poisson:
ni(z) = no exp[-Zie~z)/kT]
(5.85)
d2~ _ dz 2
(5.86)
~
m
D
~
47r Z Z i e n i ( z ) e i
Let us multiply Eq. (5.86) with d~t/dz, substitute n~(z) from Eq. (5.85) and integrate with respect to z; the result can be presented in the form
8~ ~,-~z ) _ kT ~"ni(z)i
= const.
(5.87)
The latter equation, along with Eq. (5.84), proves the constancy of 1-Iel across the film. If the film has identical surfaces, the electric potential has an extremum in the midplane of the film, (du//dz)z=o = 0, see Fig. 5.9b. Then from Eq. (5.87) one obtains e 8~
dN / (~,-~z ) - ~r[n~(z) + n2(z)] = - kr(nlm + n2m)
(5.88)
where nim - ni(O), i = 1,2. One can check that the substitution of Eq. (5.88) into Eq. (5.84) yields the Langmuir expression for 1-Id, that is Eq. (5.80). To obtain the dependence of 1-Id on the film thickness h, one has to first determine the dependence of nlm and n2m on h by solving the Poisson-Boltzmann equation, and then to substitute the result in the definition (5.80). This was done rigorously by Derjaguin and Landau [16], who obtained an equation in terms of elliptic integrals, see also Refs. [2, 44]. However,
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
215
for applications it is much more convenient to use the asymptotic form of this expression: l-Iel(h) =
C exp(-~'h)
for exp(-~h) << 1
(5.89)
where C is a constant independent of h; as usual, ~" is the Debye screening parameter. The constant C was determined by Verwey and Overbeek [17] in the following way. Let us consider a film of two identical surfaces and let us deal with a solution of symmetric
electrolyte: Zl = -Z2 - Z. Combining the Boltzmann equation (5.85) with Eq. (5.80), and expanding in series, one obtains
[
I-Ie~ = 2nokT cosh
kT
1 ~ nokT
- 1
kT
(5.90)
2
where gtm - gt(0) is the potential in the middle of the film (Fig. 5.9b), which is assumed to be small: ~_
/
<< 1
(5.91)
Note that we have set gt = 0 in the bulk of solution, see Eq. (5.85); hence small gtm means a
weak overlap of the two double electric layers in the middle of the film. In such case one can use the superposition approximation,
I//m =
2~1, that
is the potential in the middle of the film is
equal to two times the potential at a distance h/2 from a single surface, see Fig. 5.9b for the notation. Since gtl is also a small quantity, with the help of Eq. (1.65) one obtains gtm -- 2gtl -- 8tanh Zegt,
4kT
exp -
(5.92)
---2-
where g~ is the value of the electric potential at the surface of the film. The substitution of Eq. (5.92) into Eq. (5.90) yields [17]
1-Ie, (h)
64nokT(tanhZellts12 exp(-x'h) 4kT
for exp(-tch) << 1
(5.93)
By integration of Eq. (5.93) one can derive expressions for the free energy (per unit area) due to the electrostatic interaction, fd(h), as well as the interaction energy between two bodies, Uel(h0),
216
Chapter 5
with the help of Eqs. (5.9) and (5.49)-(5.52). It is interesting to note, that when gts is large enough, the hyperbolic tangent in Eq. (5.93) is identically 1 and I-Iej (as well as fel and Ue0 becomes independent of the surface potential (or charge). Equation (5.93) can be generalized for the case of 2:1 electrolyte (divalent counterion) and 1:2
electrolyte (divalent coion) [94]: Vi:j
II~l=432n(2)kT tanh--4-
exp(-r..h)
(5.94)
where n(2) is the concentration of the divalent ions, the subscript "i:j" takes value "2:1" or "1:2", and
v21:lnI,/,+2ep///1
,2 lnE(2exp(/+l),1
(5.95)
Equation (5.93) can be generalized also for the case of two non-identically charged interfaces of surface potentials g61 and gts2 for Z:Z electrolytes [2]
1-Ie'(h)= 64n~
7~ - tanh('Z]egts~ '
k-l,2
(5.96)
Equations (5.93)-(5.96) are valid for both low and high surface potentials, if only exp(-r,,h) << 1. The comparison of these equations with Eq. (5.89) allow one to determine the parameter C for each specific system. In addition, the expression for the total interaction energy U = Uvw + Ue~ can be used to predict the critical electrolyte concentration for coagulation in a colloid, see e.g. Ref. [3,44]. Likewise, one can determine the critical concentration of electrolyte which is needed for colloid particles to adhere to an interface with the same sign of the surface charge.
5.2.5. REPULSIVE HYDRATION FORCE
The DLVO theory predicts that the height of the electrostatic barrier (see Fig. 5.3) decreases with the increase of the electrolyte concentration in solution. In other words, the added electrolyte suppresses the electrostatic repulsion. In contrast, the experiment [95-98] shows that sometimes at higher electrolyte concentrations (above c.a. 10-3 M) a strong repulsive force is
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
/
-
217
-
,~'~'--0 1 M
'~,__.,,
10
Vs = -128.4 mV electrolyte" KC1 T = 298 K v = 1.2x 10-27m 3
-2
--"~.~\\
10
M
, 103
t
E
Z
f ,
III
f
,,
.
\
"... -...
\
...~... 0
,o-4 ...
\ 9
0.1
-. \
10
"-. 20
30
40
50
h [nm]
Fig. 5.10. (a) Theoretical dependence of F/R - 2z0~on the film thickness h for various concentrations of KC1, denoted in the curves. For all curves the surface potential is gts = -128 mV, the temperature is 298 K and the excluded volume per ion is v = 1.2 x 10-27 m3; results from Ref. [100l. detected, which completely dominates the effect of the van der Waals attraction at short distances (h < 10 nm), see Fig. 5.10. This repulsive interaction is called the hydration force. It appears as a deviation from the DLVO theory for short distances between two molecularly smooth electrically charged surfaces. {Note that sometimes other, different effects are also termed "hydration force", see Ref. [99] for review. } Experimentally the existence of hydration repulsive force was established by Israelachvili et al. [95,96] and Pashley [97,98] who examined the validity of DLVO-theory at small film thickness in experiments with films from aqueous electrolyte solutions confined between two mica surfaces. At electrolyte concentrations below 10 -4 M (KNO3 or KCI) they observed the typical DLVO maximum, However, at electrolyte concentrations higher than 10 -3 M they did not observe the expected DLVO maximum; instead a strong short range repulsion was detected; cf. Fig. 5.10. Empirically, the hydration force appears to follow an exponential law
[31:
Chapter 5
218
fhyar = f0 exp(-h/2o) where, as usual, h is the film thickness; the decay length is 2o -- 0 . 6 - 1 . 1
(5.97) nm for 1:1
electrolytes; the pre-exponential factor, f0, depends on the specific surface but is usually about 3 - 30 mJ/m 2. The hydration force stabilizes thin liquid films and dispersions preventing coagulation in the primary minimum (that between points 2 and 3 in Fig. 5.3). In historical plan, the hydration repulsion has been attributed to various effects: solvent polarization and H-bonding [101], image charges [102], non-local electrostatic effects [103], existence of a layer of lower dielectric constant, e, in a vicinity of the interface [ 104, 105]. It seems, however, that the main contribution to the hydration repulsion between two charged interfaces originates from the finite size of the hydrated counterions confined into a narrow subsurface potential well [ 100]. (The latter effect is not taken into account by the DLVO theory, which deals with point ions.) Indeed, in accordance with Eq. (1.65), at high electrolyte concentration (large to) and not too low surface potential t/rs, a narrow potential well is formed in a vicinity of the surface, where the concentration of the counterions is expected to be much higher than its bulk value. At such high subsurface concentrations (i) the volume exclusion effect, due to the finite ionic size, becomes considerable and (ii) the counterion binding (the occupancy of the Stern layer) will be greater, see Fig. 1.4. The formed dense subsurface layers from hydrated counterions prevent two similar surfaces from adhesion upon a close contact. This is probably the explanation of the experimental results of Healy et al. [106], who found that even high electrolyte concentrations cannot cause coagulation of amphoteric latex particles due to binding of strongly hydrated Li + ions (of higher effective volume) at the particle surfaces. If the Li + ions are replaced by weakly hydrated Cs + ions (of smaller effective volume), the hydration repulsion becomes negligible, compared with the van der Waals attraction, and the particles coagulate as predicted by the DLVO-theory. The effect of the volume excluded by the counterions becomes important in relatively thin films, insofar as the aforementioned potential well is located in a close vicinity of the film surfaces. In Ref. [100] this effect was taken into account by means of the Bikerman equation [107, 108]:
219
L i q u i d Films a n d Interactions b e t w e e n Particle a n d Surface
1-v~_~nk(z) n i(z)
-
1--v~nko
U i -~ -
ni~
Z i e llt ~
(5.98)
kT
k
Here z is the distance to the charged surface, ni and
kT units)
energy (in
Ui are the
number density and the potential
of the i-th ion in the double electric layer; nio is the value of
ni in the
bulk
solution; the summation is carried out over all ionic species; v has the meaning of an average excluded volume per counterion; the theoretical estimates [100] show that v is approximately equal to 8 times the volume of the hydrated counterion. The volume exclusion effect leads to a modification of the Poisson equation (5.86); it is now presented in the form
,E d2111 ZZien~expUi ~.
4:re dz 2
i
n i =--
--= p ( Z ) ;
i
where
p(z)
ni~
1+ v Z
1+ vZ n; expUi
nkO
(5.99)
k
denotes the charge density in the electric double layer. For v = 0 Eq. (5.99) reduces
to the expression used in the conventional DLVO theory. Taking into account the definition of
Ui, one
can numerically solve Eq. (5.99). Next, the total electrostatic disjoining pressure can be
calculated by means of the expression [328]
Fl+v~_.n]exp(-Zkelltm/ kT)1
I11m
H:~t = -
IPmdl]l-o
- ~ l n [.
~
1--~vv~ ~k
(5.100)
where the subscript "m" denotes values of the respective variables at the midplane of the film. Finally, the non-DLVO
hydration
force can be determined as an excess over the conventional
DLVO electrostatic disjoining pressure: Hhydr
1-[ tot 1-[ DLVO --'= ~ e l -- ~ e l
(5.101)
DLVO is defined by Eq. (5.80), which can be deduced from Eq. (5.100) for v -+ 0. The where H el effect of v :~ 0 leads to a larger value of gtm, which contributes to a positive (repulsive) Hhydr. Similar, but quantitatively much smaller, is the effect of the lowering of the dielectric constant,
Chapter 5
220
e, in a vicinity of the interface [! 00]. The quantitative predictions of Eqs. (5.99)-(5.101) are found to agree well with experimental data of Pashley [97,98], Claesson et al. [109] and Horn et al. [110]. In Fig. 5.10 results from theoretical calculations for F/R - 2rtf vs. h are presented; here F is the force measured by the surface force apparatus between two crossed cylinders of radius R; as usual, f is the total surface free energy per unit area, see Eq. (5.9). The dependence of hydration repulsion on the concentration of electrolyte, KC1, is investigated. All theoretical curves are calculated for v = 1.2 x 10 -27 m 3 (8 times the volume of the hydrated K + ion), AH = 2.2 x 10 -20 J and Vs = -128.4 mV; the boundary condition of constant surface potential is used. In Fig. 5.10 for
Ce, = 5 x 10-5 and 10-4 M a typical DLVO maximum is observed. However, for Cel = 10-3, 10-2 and 10 -1 M maximum is not seen, but instead, the short range hydration repulsion appears. These predictions agree with the experimental findings. Note that the increased electrolyte concentration increases the hydration repulsion, but suppresses the long-range double layer repulsion.
5.2.6.
ION-CORRELATION SURFACE FORCE
The positions of the ions in an electrolyte solution are correlated in such a way that a counterion a t m o s p h e r e appears around each ion thus screening its Coulomb potential. The
latter effect has been taken into account in the theory of strong electrolytes by Debye and Htickel [111, 112], which explains why the activities of the ions in solution are smaller than their concentrations, see Refs. [ 113, 114] for details. The energy of formation of the counterion atmospheres gives a contribution to the free energy of the system called correlation energy [ 115]. The correlation energy provides a contribution to the osmotic pressure of the electrolyte solution, which can be expressed in the form [111, 112] k
I-losm - k T ~ n i i=1
kT~r 3
241r
(5.102)
The first term in the right-hand side of the Eq. (5.102) corresponds to an ideal solution, whereas the seconds term takes into account the effect of electrostatic interactions between the ions. The expression for Hemin the DLVO-theory, Eq. (5.80), obviously corresponds to an ideal
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
221
solution, that is to the first term in Eq. (5.102), the contribution of the ionic correlations being neglected. In the case of overlap of two electric double layers, formed at the surfaces of two bodies interacting across an aqueous phase, the effect of the ionic correlations also gives a contribution, FIcor, to the net disjoining pressure, as pointed out by Guldbrand et al. [116]. 1-Icor can be interpreted as a surface excess of the last term in Eq. (5.102). In other words, the ionic correlation force originates from the fact that the counterion atmosphere of a given ion in a thin film is different from that in the bulk of the solution. There are two reasons for this difference: (i) the ionic concentration in the film differs from that in the bulk and (ii) the counterion atmospheres are affected (deformed) due to the neighborhood of the film surfaces. Both numerical [116-118] and analytical [119,120] methods have been developed for calculating the
ion-correlation component
of disjoining pressure, I-Icor. Attard et al. [119]
derived the following asymptotic formula, which is applicable to the case of symmetric (Z:Z) electrolyte and sufficiently thick films [exp(-tch) << 1]:
I-Icor-
ZcorI-Ie 1
+O(e -~h )
Z2e2~ (ln2+ 21c) ~87r162
Aco r -
(5.103)
Here 1-Ie~is the conventional DLVO electrostatic disjoining pressure, see Eq. (5.80), and
Ic--~1 ( l + J ) l n 2 + J
2-2s 3+ s 2s(2s 2 -1) 2
2S 2 - - 3
-
-- l ) 3 '
Ps is the surface charge
J)ln(s+s 2) ~/sZ-lIl+J+4(2s2-
212
- 1)-3 larctan ~S-ls_ +1
s
s - 1+ 2~ePs ekT~:
~
2S
1(12
density, i.e. the net surface electric charge per unit area.
The theory [117-120] predicts that for films of identically charged surfaces Ilcor is (Acor < 0) and corresponds to
attraction, which
negative
can be comparable by magnitude with I-Ivw. In
the case of 1:1 electrolyte FIcor is usually a small correction to 1-Iel. In the case of 2:2 electrolyte, however, the situation can be quite different: for electrolyte concentrations above a certain
critical
value the ion-correlation attraction could become greater than the double layer
Chapter 5
222
10o A 2 area per charge 1:1
--.. .......
-2 -3
(b
~-4 ~
-7 10 -5
.
. 10 -4 .
.
3
.
:
3
. 10. -3
1 0,.2
,
,0,_1 1
,
, 10 0
electrolyte concentration [M]
Fig. 5.11. Theoretical dependence of 1-Icor/I-Iel on the electrolyte concentration for 1:1, 2:2 and 3:3 electrolytes calculated by means of Eq. (5.103); for all curves the area per surface charge is l e/ps I = 100/~2; after Ref. [ 121 ]. repulsion. In other words, in the presence of bivalent and multivalent counterions Hcor could become the predominant surface force. To illustrate the theoretical predictions, in Fig. 5.11 we present numerical data computed by means of Eq. (5.103). At constant Ps the coefficient Acor, multiplying Flel in Eq. (5.103), is independent of the film thickness h. In other words, for exp(-tch) << 1, the ratio Hcor/Hel is independent of h. In Fig. 5.11 we plot Hcor/Flel vs. the electrolyte concentration for 1:1, 2:2 and 3:3 electrolytes; we have used the value le/psl = 100 ~2 for the area per surface charge. The "critical" electrolyte concentration corresponds to the intersection points of the curves with the horizontal line a t - 1 in Fig. 5.11; for electrolyte concentrations above the critical one the calculated ionic correlation attraction becomes greater by magnitude than the double layer repulsion. One sees in the figure that for a 2:2 electrolyte the critical concentration is about 1 mM, whereas for a 3:3 electrolyte it is below 10-4 M. In the case of secondary thin liquid films, stabilized by ionic surfactant (h - h2 in Fig. 5.3), the measured contact angle is considerably larger than the theoretical value predicted if only van der Waals attraction is taken into account [122]. The experimentally detected additional
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
223
attraction in these very thin films (h = 5 nm) can be attributed to short range ionic correlation effects [123] as well as to the discreteness of the surface charge [2, 124, 125]. Short-range net attractive ion-correlation forces have been measured by Marra [126, 127] and Kjellander et al. [ 128, 129] between highly charged anionic bilayer surfaces in CaCI2 solutions. These forces are believed to be responsible for the strong adhesion of some surfaces (clay and bilayer membranes) in the presence of divalent counterions [ 128, 130]. On the other hand, Kohonen et al. [131 ] measured a monotonic repulsion between two mica surfaces in 4.8 x 10-3 M solution of MgSO4; the lack of attractive surface force in the latter experiments could be attributed, at least in part, to the presence of a strong hydration repulsion due to the Mg 2+ ions. Additional work is necessary to verify the theoretical predictions and to clarify the physical significance of the ion-correlation surface force. DLVO, corresponds to a In summary, the conventional electrostatic disjoining pressure, 1-Ie~- He~ mean-field model, i.e. ideal solution of point ions in the electric field of the double layer. The hydration and ionic-correlation components of disjoining pressure, Hhydr and 1-Icor, represent "superstructures" over the conventional DLVO model of the double-layer forces. In particular, Flhydr takes into account the effect of the ionic finite volume. In addition, Ilcor, accounts for the non-ideality of the electrolyte solutions, which is caused by the long-range electric forces
between the ions. The total surface force, due to the overlap of electric double layers, is equal to the sum of the aforementioned three contributions: -I el t~ = 1-Iel + l-lhydr + I-Icor
(5.104)
Note that in view of Eq. (5.89) and (5.103) one obtains I-Id + I-Icor= (1 + Acor)FIel = (1 + Acor)Cexp(-tch) = C exp(-tch) where C is a "renormalized" pre-exponential factor. In practice C is determined from the experimental fits and it is often identified with the pre-exponential factor in Eq. (5.93). Thus an apparent (lower) value of the surface potential ~ is determined neglecting the effect of the ionic correlations. Of course, this would be correct if IAco~l << 1. It turns out that the contribution of the ionic correlations can be detected if only an independently determined value
224
Chapter 5
of ~ is available. However, in the case of strong ionic correlations one could have 1 + Acor < 0, that is Hcor/Hel < - 1 in Fig. 5.11; in such a case the net interaction between similar surfaces would become attractive and the effect of I-Icor could not be misinterpreted as He~ at lower surface potential.
5.2.7.
OSCILLATOR Y STRUCTURAL AND DEPLETION FORCES
Oscillatory structural forces are observed in two cases: (i) In very thin liquid films (h < 5 nm) between two molecularly smooth solid surfaces; in this case the period of oscillations is of the order of the diameter of the solvent molecules. These, so called solvation forces [3, 40], could be important for the short-range interactions between solid particles in dispersions. (ii) In thin liquid films containing colloidal particles (including surfactant micelles, protein globules, latex beads); in this case the period of the oscillatory force is close to the diameter of the colloid particles, see Fig. 5.12. At higher particle concentrations these colloid structural
forces stabilize the liquid films and colloids [132-135]. At lower particle concentrations the structural forces degenerate into the so called depletion attraction, which is found to destabilize various dispersions [ 136-138]. In all cases, the oscillations decay with the increase of the film thickness; in the experiment one rarely detects more than 8-9 oscillations.
Physical origin of the oscillatory force. The oscillatory structural force appears when monodisperse spherical (in some cases ellipsoidal or cylindrical) particles are confined between the two surfaces of a thin film. Even one "hard wall" can induce ordering among the neighboring molecules. The oscillatory structural force is a result of overlap of the structured zones formed at two approaching surfaces, see Fig. 5.13 and Refs. [3,139-141 ]. A wall can induce structuring in the neighboring fluid only if the magnitude of the surface roughness is negligible compared with the particle diameter, d. If surface irregularities are present (say a rough solid surface), the oscillations are smeared out and oscillatory structural force does not appear. If the film surfaces are fluid, the role of the surface roughness is played
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
100
.
.
.
.
i
.
.
.
.
i
.
.
.
.
90
i
"
.
.
.
.
i
.
.
.
225
.
i
.
.
.
,
.
.
.
.
i
.
.
.
.
|
,
,
"
~:~i--'_~+, .g;~.~~, ..~%_i+"-.-',,~:_-4_:k~_~. , .
80 E
.
% :,S %~.;~i~-.,~'%~,.[+~ "!-',../;~.~"water
70
e-
o"
ra ffl
50
z
40
o ~
1-
~x
)o
ao 20 10 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
20
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
40
.
.
.
.
,
60
. . . .
80
,
100
. . . .
. . . . . .
120
140
160
TIME, seconds
Fig. 5.12. Experimental curve: thickness of an emulsion film, h, vs. time; the step-wise thinning of the film is clearly seen. The film is formed from micellar aqueous solution of the ionic surfactant sodium nonylphenol-polyoxyethylene-25 sulfate with 0.1 M NaC1; the height of a step is close to the micelle hydrodynamic diameter. The steps represent metastable states corresponding to different number micelle layers inside the film, see the inset; data from Marinova et al. [149]. by the interfacial fluctuation capillary waves, whose amplitude ( 1 - 5 / k ) is comparable with the diameter of the solvent molecules. Structural forces in foam or emulsion films appear if the diameter of the colloidal particles is much larger than the amplitude of the surface corrugations. Surfactant micelles can play the role of such particles; in fact the manifestation of colloid structural forces was first observed with foam films formed from micellar surfactant solutions. Johnott [142] and Perrin [143] observed that the thickness of foam films decreases with several step-wise transitions. This phenomenon was called "stratification". Bruil and Lyklema [144] and Friberg et al. [145] studied systematically the effect of ionic surfactant and electrolyte on the occurrence of the step-wise transitions. Keuskamp and Lyklema [146] suggested that some oscillatory interaction between the film surfaces must be responsible for the observed phenomenon. Kruglyakov et al. [147, 148] and Marinova et al. [149] observed stratification with emulsion films, see Fig. 5.12. Stepwise structuring of colloidal particles has been observed also in wetting films (with one solid surface) [150].
Chapter 5
226 a
b
c
d
h=O h=d
e
f
h=2d
g
h=3d
(a) I-Iosc
b A d il/5 ~/ /
Repulsive f [-[=Pc Attractive
I
1
I
2
I
3
I
4
I
5
h/d
(b) Fig. 5.13. (a) From right to the left: consecutive stages of thinning of a liquid film containing spherical particles of diameter d. (b) Schematic plot of the oscillatory-structural component of disjoining pressure, FI.... vs. the film thickness h. The metastable states of the film (the steps in Fig. 5.12) correspond to the intersection points of the oscillatory curve with the horizontal line FI = Pc, see Eq. (5.3). The stable branches of the oscillatory curve are those with ~I-I/Oh < 0; see Ref. [3] for details.
As a first guess, it has been suggested [ 148, 151 ] that a possible explanation of the phenomenon can be the formation of surfactant lamella liquid-crystal structure inside the film. Such lamellar micelles are observed to form in surfactant solutions, however, at concentrations much higher than those used in the experiments with stratifying films. The latter fact makes the explanation with lamella liquid crystal irrelevant. Nikolov et al. [41,132-135] observed stratification not only with micellar surfactant solutions but also with suspensions of latex particles of micellar size. The step-wise changes in the film thickness were approximately equal to the diameter of the spherical particles, contained in the foam film. The observed multiple step-wise decrease of the film thickness (see Fig. 5.12) was attributed to the layer-by-layer thinning of a colloidcrystal-like structure from spherical particles inside the film, which is manifested by the appearance of an oscillatory structural force [133]. The metastable states of the film (the steps) correspond to the roots of the equation 1-I(h)= Pc for the stable oscillatory branches with
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
227
OH~Oh <0; in Fig. 5.13 there are three such roots; cf. Figs. 5.3 and 5.13; Pc is the applied capillary pressure. The mechanism of stratification was studied theoretically in Ref. [ 152], where the appearance and expansion of black spots in horizontal stratifying films was described as a process of condensation of vacancies in a colloid crystal of ordered particles within the film. This mechanism was confirmed by subsequent experimental studies with casein submicelles and silica particles [153,154]. Additional studies with vertical liquid films containing latex particles indicated that the packing of the structured particles is hexagonal [ 155]. The stable branches of the oscillatory disjoining pressure isotherm were experimentally detected for films from micellar solutions by Bergeron and Radke [156]. Oscillatory structural forces due to micelles and microemulsion droplets were directly measured by means of a surface force balance [157, 158]. Static and dynamic light scattering methods were also applied to investigate the micelle structuring in stratifying films [ 159]. Theoretical expressions for the oscillatory forces. As already mentioned, the period of the oscillations is close to the particle diameter. In this respect the structural forces are appropriately called the "volume exclusion forces" by Henderson [160], who derived an explicit (though rather complex) analytical formula for calculating these forces. Modeling by means of the integral equations of statistical mechanics [161-164] and numerical simulations [165-167] of the oscillatory force of the step-wise film thinning are also available. A convenient semiempirical formula for the oscillatory structural component of disjoining pressure was proposed [168]
Hosc (h)= P0
~d 1
exp d.d2
(5.~05)
d2
= - Po
for O
where d is the diameter of the hard spheres, dl and d2 are the period and the decay length of the oscillations which are related to the particle volume fraction, qg, as follows [168]
d
+ 0.237 Aq9 + 0.633.A(p. 2"( )
d2 0.4866 . . . . d Aq)
0.420
(5.106)
Chapter 5
228
1
2
3
4
5
h/d
Fig. 5.14. Plot of the dimensionless oscillatory disjoining pressure, 1-loscd3/kT, vs. the dimensionless film thickness h/d for volume fraction q9= 0.357 of the particles in the bulk suspension. The solid curve is calculated from Eq. (5.105), the dotted curve - from the theory by Henderson [160], the dashed curve is from Ref. [162] and the x-points - from Ref. [165]; after Ref. [168].
Here Aq9 = qgmax- q9 with (Pmaxbeing the value of q9 at close packing: qgmax= *c/(3-~ ) = 0.74. P0 is the particle osmotic pressure determined by means of the Carnahan-Starling formula [ 169]
Po - n k T
1+ q~ + q92 -q9 3 ( 1 - q~)3 '
6q9 n - red3,
(5.107)
where n is the particle number density. For h < d, when the particles are expelled from the slit into the neighboring bulk suspension, Eq. (5.105) describes the so called depletion attraction, see the first minimum in Fig. 5.13. On the other hand, for h > d the structural disjoining pressure oscillates around P0, defined by Eq. 5.107. As seen in Fig. 5.14, the quantitative predictions of Eq. (5.105) compare well with the Henderson theory [160] as well as with numerical results Kjellander and Sarman [162] and Karlstr6m [165]. It is interesting to note that in oscillatory regime the concentration dependence of Ilosc is dominated by the decay length de in the exponent, cf. Eq. (5.106). Roughly speaking, for a
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
229
given distance h the oscillatory disjoining pressure Hosc increases five times when tp is increased with 10%, see Ref. [ 168]. The contribution of the oscillatory structural forces to the interaction free energy per unit area of the film can be obtained by integrating Hosc in accordance with Eq. (5.9): oo
fosc(h)- II-Iosc (h')dh'- F(h~
for h _>d
h
=F(d)-Po(d-h ),
for
F(h)- P~
ONhNd
[ d2
(5.108)
[ dl
If the colloidal particles are not real hard spheres, then their effective hard-core diameter can be estimated from the formula [134] (5.109)
d= [3 fl2/(4~)] 1/3
Where/32 is the second virial coefficient in the virial expansion of the osmotic pressure due to the particles,
Posm/(nkT)= 1 + flzn/2 +
...; ,62 can be determined by static light scattering [170].
In the case of electrically charged particles the effective diameter can be estimated from the expression [ 132] d
= dH +
2U 1
(5.110)
where dn is the hydrodynamic diameter of the colloid particles, which can be determined by dynamic light scattering [ 171 ].
Depletion interaction. With
the decrease of particle (micelle) volume fraction tp the
amplitude of the oscillations decreases and the oscillatory structural force degenerates into the depletion interaction (only the first minimum in the oscillatory curve in Fig. 5.13b remains). The latter interaction manifested itself in the experiments by Bondy [172], who observed coagulation of rubber latex in presence of polymer molecules in the disperse medium. In the case of plane-parallel films the depletion component of disjoining pressure is
Chapter 5
230 ...
I
...
....
%
m
..
J"
%
I
!
I
I i
., ..,
_
h0
I I
I \
/ %
%
j
Fig. 5.15. Schematic presentation of the overlap of the depletion zones around two larger particles of diameter dL separated at a distance h0. The centers of the smaller particles (of diameter d) cannot come closer to the larger particles than the circumferences denoted with dashed line.
]-I dep ( h ) -
-
Fidep(h)= 0
Po
for hd
(5.111)
which is a special case of Eq. (5.105) for small d2, see Ref. [3] for details. Evans and Needham [173] to measured the depletion energy of two interacting bilayer surfaces in a concentrated Dextran solution; their results confirm the validity of Eq. (5.111). Asakura and Oosawa [ 136, 137] published a theory, which attributed the observed interparticle attraction to the overlap of the depletion layers at the surfaces of two approaching larger colloid particles, see Fig. 5.15. The centers of the smaller particles, of diameter, d, cannot approach the surface of a larger particle (of diameter dD at a distance shorter than d/2, which is the thickness of the depletion layer. When the two depletion layers overlap (Fig. 5.15) some volume between the large particles becomes inaccessible for the smaller particles. This gives rise to an osmotic pressure, which tends to suck out the solvent between the larger particles thus forcing them against each other. The total depletion force experienced by one of the larger particles is [136, 137] Foep - - kTnS(h o )
(5.112)
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
231
where the effective depletion area is S (h0 ) - ~ ( 2 d L + d + h 0 )(d - h 0 ) for 0 < h 0
(5.113)
Here h0 is the shortest distance between the surfaces of the larger particles and n is the number density of the smaller particles. By integrating Eq. (5.112) one can derive an expression for the depletion interaction energy between the two larger particles, gdep(h0).
For dL >> d this
expression reads U d e p ( h o ) / k T ~ ---j3 q) --~(d d L - ho
)2 ,
O < ho < d
(5.114)
where q~ = 7cnd3/6 is the volume fraction of the small particles. The maximum value of Uaep at h0 = 0 is gdep(O)/kr -~ -3(pdL/(2d).
-7.5 kT.
For example, if dL/d = 50 and (p = 0.1, then gdep(0) =
This depletion attraction turns out to be large enough to cause flocculation in
dispersions and attachment of particles to surfaces [42, 138,174-177], as well as attraction between lipid bilayers [ 178, 179].
5.2.8.
STERIC INTERACTION DUE TO ADSORBED MOLECULAR CHAINS
The adsorption of polymeric molecules at an interface may lead to the appearance of polymeric brushes, see Fig. 5.16. The polymers could be attached to the surface by chemical bonding
(chemisorption, anchoring) of some groups. Alternatively, a polymeric coverage of the surface can be achieved by physical adsorption of nonionic surfactants, whose hydrophilic moieties represent water-soluble polymers (typically- polyoxyethylenes). When two surfaces covered with polymer brushes approach each other, the overlap of the brushes gives rise to a strong osmotic repulsion, which protects the surfaces from adhesion and the colloidal dispersions from coagulation [3, 42, 180-182]. This steric repulsion plays a role similar to that of the electrostatic repulsion with respect to colloid stability. Thickness of a separate polymeric brush. Obviously, the range of action of the steric
repulsion is determined by the thickness of the brush, L. The latter can be defined as the meansquare end-to-end distance of the hydrophilic portion of the chain. If a chain, composed of N
232
Chapter 5
L
Brush
Fig. 5.16. Polymeric chains adsorbed at an interface form a "brush" of thickness L. The overlap of the brushes formed at the two surfaces of a thin liquid film gives rise to a steric interaction.
segments, were completely extended, then L would be equal to lN, where 1 is the length of a polymeric segment. However, due to the Brownian motion L < lN. For an isolated anchored chain in an ideal (theta) solvent L can be estimated as [42] L -- L 0 - l ~ -
(5.115)
The solvent-polymer interactions may essentially influence L, and therefrom - the steric interaction. The osmotic pressure of either dilute or concentrated polymer solutions can be expressed in the form [183] Posm = 1 ~ --nv 1 + ln2 w nkT N 2 3
q-...
(5.116)
Here n is the number segment density, v and w account for the pair and triplet interactions between segments. In fact v and w are counterparts of the second and third virial coefficients in the theory of non-ideal gases [ 114]. v and w can be calculated if information about the polymer chain and the solvent is available [42] w 1/2
--
~ m / N A,
v - wl/2 (1 - 2Z),
(5.117)
where ~ (m3/kg) is the specific volume per segment, m (kg/mol) is the molecular weight per segment, NA is the Avogadro number and Z is the Flory parameter [ 114]: c Z ---~(ueP
+Uss - 2 U e s )
(5.118)
c is the number of the closest neighbors of a molecule, Ua8 stands for the energy of interaction
Liquid Films and Interactions between Particle and Surface
233
between molecules type "A" and "B" (A,B = P,S; "P" = polymeric segment, "S" = solvent molecule). The parameter v can be zero (see Eq. 5.117) for some special temperature, called the
theta temperature. The solvent at theta temperature is known as theta solvent or ideal solvent. At the theta temperature the intermolecular (intersegment) attraction and repulsion in polymer solutions are exactly counterbalanced. In a good solvent, however, the repulsion prevails over the attraction