This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
U
. ;
P e
U
where e
U
< $ ~ J ~ / oa > t the mass
U The second factor
the photon polarization,
3.8
P
e
a@
and
~ t a ybe
2
of the
written
y ~ ~ d x l ~ a c ivector on af the vector p a r t i c l e .
2.3
(There i s no generally accapted emvention f o r haw t o w r i t e One way is t o write m
F@. 2 m /Zy @
Q,
so y+ is
l
2/g
0
4
-
F+ f o r what we have c a l l e d F+, others w r i t e
gm, but s t i l l others use the same l e t t e r y
Q
f o r another
way of expressing the coupling.) The exper2meaterer avoid a l l t h e ambiguity by noting t h a t the d i a g r m a b w h p f i e s rhat a f r e e
e e . C
(p
=son would have a c e r t a i n r a t a t a disintegrate i n t o
n e y give t h i s r a t a ( h i e h c w s =re d i r e c t l y frora experimnt m p a y ) efe-
+$'l
=
1.36 t .I x 10~'GeY
e i t h e r d i r e c t l y or as a braurching r a t i o , c m e c t i o n (for any vector meoa V of ( a =1!137)
as
For the
P+ = ,080 (GeV)2 o r @:/4
(.
A s b p l e calculation shows the
neglecting electron
-8
n
-
-8)
13.3.
One can look i n t h i s energy region f o r other products (such a s 3n, or rtoy) and find the resonance again
- thus detenngning the hadronie m p l i t a d e s f a r
Q33n o r @noy, w u a l l y given in the fom of branchinp r a t i o s , Tn t h e case the f i n a l e t a t e i s 3n there i s mother reamance a t 782 &V, the
IJ
mson
- it is studied i n tha same way,
AgaZn studygng 2n fknlnaf s t a t e s a l a r g e resonance near 765 of width aromd
125 &V,
This l a r g e width a&ee con@%derable& L p i t y
(i.a aaawptione of how
2
I' v a r i e s with q ) i n d e t e m i n i n g t h e constants, -a
and width,
t r i c , sharper on t h e hlgh errer@ sfde.
A
Further t h e
smll shoulder is
- t h i s e f f e c t i s i n t e r p r e t e d a s i n t e r f e r e n c e with the
nearly apparent
resonance aslsuraing there i s a f k n i t e a w l i t u d e f o r w 2 a .
w
(Thle v i o l a t e s i s o s p h ,
tlnd i s an electromagnetic e f f e c t which we will, d i s ~ ~ 3i n~ the 3 next l e c t u r e , ) Values f u r t h e various constants f o r t h e vector mmon m y be found i n t h e P a r t i c l e Properties Table,
There is now s o m a d d i t i o n a l d a t a from t h e
Oraay Storage Mngs (S, Lrrf rancois , 31971 Z n t e r n a t i m s l s p p o s i u m on e l e c t r o n and photon i n t e r a c t t a n s a t high a e r g y ) ,
Sam of t h e differences from P a r t i c l e
Table r e s u l t s a r e new data but so= a r e due t o an a l t e r e d way af reducing data, especially for the p,
We s h a l l have t o wait f o r new p a r t i c l e tablea t o thrash
these d i f f e r e n c e s o u t ,
B New Q1
P a r t i c l e Tables
f 2 * 1 t .7) x
B ( + + ~ B - )= 46.4 2 2.8%
~(4yrOy)
('25 2 ,091 X
B($-*%$)
B(++Jn)
(14.7 2 2.2) x
B(++3n)
m
~(ur.n'y) = '07 2 '02
ru total. = 4.2
.O4
B(ws2n)
r tube%-> 780
mp2 l"
P
r P-*C?+@-
r
,02
1.0 NeV
2 '02
(Phase 87' t 15')
6
total. = 153
6.0 2 .3 &V
BCWSR)
= 90 2 4%
rw
= 11.4
B(w2n)
.c
~(.-+e'e-)
= ~ 0 6 6t ,0017)~
P
3
1 3 &V
6.5 t .5 keV
= 2.27
2 gw/4n =58.3 2
g( /4n
-
755
nt
l'
13.3
P
+
+ 0,9
,009 2 .Q02
10
t o t a l = 125 2 20
r P+e'e-
C a f e d a t i n g from t h e l a t e s t Oreay d a t a , we g e t 2 gp /4n
= 18.2 2 5%
~ ( w - . n ~ y =) 9.3 "-22
.76 2 .08 k e ~
2
35.4 c 4%
2 , 7 MeV
~ ( @ q O y ) ~ o seen t
p
Branching r a t i o
BC#+n"y)
rg t o t a l = 4,7
w
-
7.5 2 .9 keV
85
Vector Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothesis but Clrstzy snaking "corrections f o r f i n i t e widthf' "reduces t h e data i n some o t h e r
Nota,
Now t h a t we have d a t a f o r t h e r a t e s
and
W T I ~ we
can compare t h e
predictions of t h e quarlc model with h a r m n i c dynanaics of Femma, U s l i n g e r
and Ramdal. Orsay
Quark Model r @ s y = 1.73 x furny
GeV
I , O 2 . J 4- 1 0 " ~%V, .6 f .2 x 10"~ &V.
1.92 x 10-'GeV
W e will make a digression frm our m b n discussion of vector =sans consider t h e i n t e r e s t i n g f e a t u r e of w
-p
to
interference.
The reason w can go i n t o Zn is t h a t t h e s t a r e / w > is not pure / w a > (U;
4'
+ dhj
isospin zero b u t has a small admixture of i p
Lsospin one i n i t ,
p
- 2a
: U (
- dr)
This mix%ag is due t o e l e c t r o d y n m i c s .
We consider the w
tude t o be i n a
2
-
-
p system a s a two-stare system where Cpo is t h e ampli-
s t a t e and Cwo i s the m p l i t u d e t o be i n an wo s t a t e .
the =ass n a t r i x f s
therefore the t r u e w i s
E16
Photon-WadranInrmetions
6 can be given i n terms of t h e branching r a t i o f o r w2r
Frm Orsay e x p e r g w n t a l d a t a the abow branching r a t i o Jls 4 f 2X we t h e r e f o r e
obtain
14
3 * 7 1 .9 &V.
by fitting t h e "shoulder"
The phase 55 the w-p i n t e r f e r e n c e is detennkaed ia
+
(@'P
m a r the
+. A X-)
I f 6 is negative t h e phase of & / ( l 9
is 87' J: 15'.
p
resonance; t h e value
+ 561)
is l09*, which is
in f a i r agreement with t h e a p e x h e n t .
We can understand t h e rolxing a s due t o e m r g y of
WO
e f f e c t s : ( l ) The electroroagaetic
is not e q w l t a t h e energy of dB because of t h e d i f f e r e n c e i n s e l f
energy of t h e objects and t h e d i f f e r e n c e of energy of %nteiactlon, (22 m e r e i s a c c n t r i b u t i a n d w t o a m i h i l a t i o n p.
+
y
-+
g,,
wo
+
y
+
wo go
+
Y
+
w
.
We can g e t estimates f o r the two above e f f e c t s from t h e knowledge a f K*'
+ p -'p
-
.
Let the s e l f energy o f d be a mass d i f f e r e n c e s and from P P and t h e matual energy aE d x be -b; then the s e l f energy o f u is 4a tund t h e
K*'
and
m t u o l energy of Prom w
=
a 1
U ;
is (m;+
- Sb because the photons a c t twiee on double t h e charge. - (ug - -X], P+ = uZ,K*+ u s and K*' = d z dz), p.
-
K
we obtain t h e f o l l o d a g electrotaawetic s e l f energies
But we a l s o have a raatrjjr e l m e n t b e t m m <po[ and Iw5> 1 3a (4a a) 2 (4b b)
- -
from t h i s alone the mass m t r f x i s
-
- %/Z
Vectsr Mesons and Vector Meson L)smin'naneef-lypefhest's Slnce
K*'
-
= 3a
+ 0 p - p we have 3a
- 3b/2
+ 3b
= 9b/2 m
(K*'
- K*') - (pi - p o t )
Note t h a t i n eq. (15 -5) we have w r i t t e n p" f a i n d i c a t e t h a t p''
instead of p',
t h i s is only
does nor contain the contribution from t h e a n n i h i l a t i o n
t e r n which we c a l c u l a t e next,To f i r s t order i n e
Let x be t h e amplitude f o r
2 42'
is x i 3 (see l e c t u r e 16).
(U;
- d3)
+
2 the change i n ~ s s s18 given
, the
y
amplitude f o r
--1
42
(U;
+ dz)
The maa8 aratrix due t a the a n n i h i l a t i o n term is therefore
proportional t a
We already have one -try f o r the full matrix
+
of t h i s matr%x, Am
61
1.53 lvleV we therefore have
Addlng the contributions from the electromagnetic s e l f arass and f r m the annihilhtion t e r n t o the non-diagonal matrix e l e w n t we find
and since
- p'')
-(p'
6
-
--
-l,02 &V
+
f r m data i n the p a r t i c l e
-2.4 .k 2 . 1 &V,
- K*') -
+ (K@
.5 &V
6
(p'
(p
C
- pot)
(U ,fO)
- p') - 1.53 EleV
- K*') - '0( - p)' tables, (K* - K*') -8 +3 (K*
E(eV
and 'p(
-)'p
But we do not t r u s t these r e s u l t e , especially the p mass
difference, we oaly say chat they Pndicate t h a t 6 i s l i k e l y t o be negative,
P e 'e 4 t t u
The yp coupling of the form
'
i s not gauge invariant aod
would give a f i n i t e massZ f o r the photon v i a
The coupling i s A P,
f o r exmple.
However ~ Bwe ean~ couple ~ the~ f i e l d s P
~
u'J
of the photon sad
X t leads t o
which i s evidently gauge invariant.
Since eye q is always zero we aee our
pole behaves l i k e @I
The l a t t e r term has no pole s i n g u l a r i t y and is "lost" fn the background of other than pole t e r n and e f f e c t i v e l y t o eY
e P t i . e , 2 C nr
P P
WC?
can use a restdue just prapartionaf
2
=
Vector mesons (continued) Me n m return t o our discussion of vector m e s w ~ . We can see what %U3 2 given a t the end o f l e c t u r e 14, Wtz gives f o r the r a t f o s of the couplings
89
Vector Mesons and VeerorMeson Dominance Hypothesis use t h e s i w l e quark model ( f o r c o w t i n g only) and assu&ng t h e Q,
18
purely
J couples t o @ p a i r proportional t o i t s char*
strange quarks.
4
88
+
- 113
- 3-13
Noting t h a t these a r e values f o r the coupling F, euld t h a t g is t h e r e c i p r o c a l we f i n d -2
gp
:gu
-2
:gI
-2
9:1:2
Various p o p l e have t r i e d t o c o r r e c t t h i s f o r SUS breaking, but nobody r e a l l y b m s how,
The f i r s t is, t o what e x t e n t Is
There a r e two questions,
The low valae oE the Q1
I s e e no way t o d e t e r d a e t h a t .
t h e ip pure ?:a
brsnchinlng r s t l o is i n t e r p r e t e d Fn the
+ 2%
m d e l by s a y h g t h a t the 4 being
made of purely s t r a n g e quarks f h d s i t hard t o go i n t o non-trange
objects
(S),
I f so, a l l t h e ~ l l t u d at o go t o ny coaea frorn an a a x t u r e of t h e w s t a t e , (U;
the
+ dx) /fli n + comes out
the 4 wave functfon,
in
t o about: .l0, although t h e r e is so= uncertainty 5: .03 a s t o
how =ss f a c t o r s e n t e r .
Prablern.
I n t h i s way the m p l i t u d e t o f i n d
t h e s t a t e is 99X pure ss,
This i a only 1% prob&ility,
b k e a. theory t o e s t i m t e haw much Q,
+
3n would be expected i f
i t i s due t o t h e f a c t t h a t 4 has a small admixture of u s t a t e ; assurnfag (for
no e x c e l l e n t reason) t h a t
8;
c a a o t go t o 3~r.
&re importmt i s the question of SU3 brealring because the m s e e s a r e not equal.
Par one e x e q l e of m b i g u i t i e s , s k o u l d we compare P 's d d i e c t l y with
, or
the $U3 predicted r a t i o s , o r should i t be \/mv should bear the s i a p l e r a t i o s ?
P /m v
V
o r what, which
$U3 cannot t e l l us and nobody r e a l l y laxows how
t o c a l c u l a t e i t , although varioue guesses have Been made.
(I p r e f e r F,/%
f o r a t h e o r e t i c a l rewon, but one which is r e a l l y not profound o r necessary). These questions probably do not strongly a f f e c t the p,w r a t i o , a s t h e m s s e s a r e close together,
As you sec? the r a t i o 9 : 1 5s not very Ear o f f , (and, i n s p i t e
of the u n c e r t a i n t l e a , the cp i s a l s o about right). Vector Heson Dominance Model 4.
To s u m e r h a we e x h i b i t the photon t o n
n
- w l i t u d e near
t h e pole of t h e
p (the only m e of the three
when q2*
4, u,
P
which couples t o the pion) a s
h e would ordinarily expect other terms (such a s a d i r e c t
HL 2 e
P
caupling of photon t o pions or various other ""tntemdiate to this.
statesf') t o be added
Tiris, of cauree, would a o t chaage the behaviour near the pole ((trrtrlch,
unfortunately f o r the p is not so definite a s the width Pp is r a t h e r large, whicb tnakes mny d i f f i c u l t i e s in practice i n f i t t i n g i t , nevertheless i n t h i s thaor e e f c a l discussfan we s h a l l neglect i t ) .
Aslother way t o say i t is t o suppose
2
the n w r a t o r has a f a c t o r F;(q ) which varies with q
2
again t o say the "constants" f p n z o r gp vary with q2 m
P
being defined.
such t h a t &(m
2 P
) = ,l or
only t h e i r value a t g
2
All these ways say the same thing so we s h a l l not argue
about them. Nevertheless a bold hypothesi.8 has been suggested (vector =son dominance) t h a t t h i s expression with f other t e r n ,
(Inn
/g constant i s a l l there i s t o i t p
I see no good physical reason for' t h i s ,
another mystertortkl hopothesfs of the 8an analogous thing with a pion pole a t the pole,
m
P
m q2
-
- there a r e na
It i s made i n analogy t o
kind, BGAC, t h a t works,
- but only extend i t from g2
melee we do
mwZ
m
.Q2
0. Here we suggest eq. (16.2) i s v a l i d nor only near q
2 but a l s o f o r a l l q o r a t l e a s t t o q2
0.
W e b o w f a r long wave leagths the pion looks l i k e a s h p l e point charge
ao t h a t ss
2
-t
C? (use crossing t o cooverc
cn'/~~/n'>
(pllr+ pZV) f o r q2
+
Q,
hence f o r (16.2) t o be trw we mwt have (neglect problor suppose Tp deperrds m q
2
+ 1+ lr
t o cn / J n
we have (16.3)
generated by
I'p,
2 and vmLshes a t the (2an) threshold and below).
2
Vector Mesons and V e t o r Meson Dominance Hypothesis 2
= 2.56
gp / S A
w e l l within the LOZ m c e r t a i n t i e s i n detemining these quantities. 2
It would a l s o imply t h a t the f o m factor F%/q
+ I J 1~
m
(l+(-q2)/m
P
2 Fw(q
'I-'.
(plu
/
f o r the pion, written
pZu) would, f o r negative q2, have t o be exactly
f
We s h a l l look a t what evidence there i s l a t e r
- s o far i t
looks very p o d . The idea i s extended t o the case of Lnteractions with aslg s t a r e
- for
example i n i n t e r a c t i o n s with the nucleon the part due to fsovector would b e Fa2 J~ isovector 2 L 2 SN/Q\N> (16 '42 Bp (q -mp 1
--
IN>
IN'
p with p o f a r i z a t i m U.
The term < M / p
IN>,
the coupling o f a p to a nucleon
is defined only a t the p pole, and there has an e l e c t r i c and ntametic part s o
%NI
we c m w r i t e as
+
C~
1.
.
IN)
(y$-dyy)
Thus, expressing the
ksovector
part of' the current coupling i n t e r n OE the txswllly defined form factors w e have
(q2)yV +: F
=
~ 3
-
2
l
2
imp 1
(l-q
Thus we predict t h a t Fl/F2
Cl ~NI--~~+S g~ Cl/CZ
-$ ( Y ~ # + Y ~ ) ~ N ~ +(~~l-l(l~)/~'
i a independent of q
2
( f a i r ) and Ff varies
2 2 2 This l a t t e r is not good, l/(l-q /m 1 i s b e t t e r .
as i/(l-q2/mp2).
P
a r e teatgng (1) f o r l a r g e negative abviously VMD c-ot v a l i d from qZ
(q2)
m
P
'
qL
- far
&re w e
frm the p pole and i t f a i l s .
z.
be an exact p r h c i p f e f o r a l l q
But lnaybe i t is nearly
t o 0. W e must discues extensions of the idea and f u r t h e r
evidence ,
n f u r t h e r conclusion Is no
from the nucleon case above is t h a t Cl/gp = l. There
way t o g e t the p coupling t o the nuclem, C
1 o r C2, xitholtt d i g u i t y a t
preseat (or ever? is it a Ilzattar of definition < I S I ~ P / N >c m n a t have alZ the, p a r t i c l e a physically on tb m s shell!), f o r e-ple,
e x i s t s f o r the ccupling of t h e p-like t r a j e c t o r y
c a l l p-exhange i s mbiguous,
Som bowledge, from nN scattering
- but
- or
f o r what we
the extrapofation from p-trajectory t o p-pole exchaage
The l a t t e r {p-pole exchange) has azl m p l i t u d e varying as
8
buc
the t e m associated with p trajectory exchange do not, and they are not supposed t o i n Regge theory i t s e l f . A s M l a r ezpresrplon using the
W
trajectory is t o give the i s o s c a l a r
92
Photon-Hadron Interactions
coupling,
Since t h e mass of t h e w i a n e a r l y equal t o t h a t of t h e p , the
i s o s c a l a r and Fsowector f o m f a c t o r s should have the same dependence as q2 they do even though t h i s depndence is not t h e (l-qZm
-
expected.
P
Lecture 17 Vector Meson Dodnance Model (continued) I n g r e a t e r g e n e r a l i t y a l l t h r e e a e u t r a l vector xaesons my be involved, For example, i n coupling t o an arbf t r a r y badran s t a t e we w r i t e
'V with p o l a r i z a t i o n p
(or of caurse by c r o s s i n g f o r any t r m s i t i o n hadrons X
-c
hadrons P)
I)
%at t h e l e f t s i d e of (17.2) gives t h e t o t a l of a12 t h e ways t h a t Ju em couple is t h e general s t a t e m n t of t h e hypothesis of vector dodnmanee, already seen tim i t predilcted t h e
p m
coupllng constant,
+
t h i n g f o r t h e $U coupling, sag (PR K"? qZ* O might be w r i t t e n (p s o we have t h e svm of
l
-
+ pZu) with
l~ (K+K-
1 V)
We have
Can we do a s i & l a x
We know t h a t t h e current operator at c o e f f i c i e n t l b e c e w e the charge is l ,
muat equal 1. Thw i f we w r i t e
we would have
The problent now is t h a t althougb we do know t b e t h r e e have too m n y unknoms i n (17.4)
+4 +R K implies
fvX;+K-/4r = 1.47).
G
( f r m experiraent) we
t o r e l a t e i t t o experilneat,
(The r a t e t h a t
We need some r u l e t o p a r t i t i o n the b i t e of
c u r r e n t bemecn p , w , and C$, A very suggestive t h i n g t o t r y is t o express the quark mdef i d e s t h a t
the
~5
is pure
gs,
and thus couplee only with t h e s quarks i n a system,
f which
suggests we invent t h r e e c u r r e n t s J ~ ,J ~ ,
COUP^. only
mis
t o t h e U quarks,
93
Vector Mesons and ;E/edorMesorr Doininarree Hyparliesis the d q u a r b , o r t h e
quarks (as though each had unf c charge),
S
exaaple, t h e e l e c t r i c current (charges on
U,
d, s, a r e
+ 2/3,
Then, for
-113, -l/3
respectively) &B :
- 71 - f l being g - dx), 1
&3
Jel Then, the p
JY
(17.5)
J6
(U;
we define a "@-type currentt' a s J@ d
(JU + J ) and a 4 type, which s i n c e 4
likewise an u-type 3@
-J.
m
~ i -(.FU
-J~>,
i s j u s t J'
m
-
hence f o r e m w l e
Now obviowly w e suppose the three pieces i n t o vhlch
it%
a r e the corresponding vector m s a n resoaant pieces of (17.5).
s p l i t i n (17.6)
This inay be w r i t t e n
i n a very s i q l e way, f f t h e gV r e a l l y have the r a t i o s of the quark m d e l (Lecture
14) we a r e saying, of course
the sm f o r all q w r k s is
where t h e constant,
Bowever
M
.
s t i l l must define i n an e x p e r i m n t a l l y d e f i n i t e way what JY, J ~ Js. ,
W e can use i s o s p i n ,
o r J P , J@,J' are.
hypercharge and quark number (or
) a s three conserved q u a a t i t i e s (each d e f l n i t e f a r a
r a t h e r , baryon n-er@ particular transition X
+
Y) t o serve inntead of quark nmbera. P
represent t h e current of Z-component isospin;
J
m -JZ
+$
JY
to write
+
- JY + ,IB
Js
quark, IZ d 113 f o r t h e currftnril you g e t one f o r JU, zero f o r J and
(beesiluae if you erubstitute f o r e x q l e the guaaturn n d e r 6 of t h e
+ 112, Y
-+
11'3, B
J", e t c , )
Hence J"
'
cvrrent of hypercherge, J~ c a r r e a t
of beirym n u a e r (equals l 1 3 tims t h e current of quark n*er)
Jd
Thue l e t J
...FZ
m
U
lPlis then deflnes precisely what we m a n by t h e currents h (14.5) and (14.6). f
l e , l e t us apply t h i s t o the K K4"
couplinge of J' t o K
+ 1/2, Y
-
C
1, B
(we a l s o calculate .lP,
-
decay of the 4 .
.JW
We need the
f o r cnnpleteoess).
For the K+,
O, sa a t zero q2;
m u s e o & i a b g t h i s with ( 1 4 . 9 ) and (14.7) we see we a m t have
defining how the t o t a l of ( l ) i n (17.41 is partitgonad,
2
which agrees p r f e c t L y with the f4 m/4n
-
1.47 from
(
A t my r a t e we predict
4"
-+
K K- and g
4'
2
/4r
13.3
f r o m 4 + e\-.
How slow is 4
-+
3n cmparczd t o w
-+
3nl
(p
goes 18% Co 3n, but I' i e only 4
so the p a r t i a l width i s only .7 MeV while i t is B? &V is l a r g e r f o r the QI but -re t h e ~ ~ l a t r fe xl e m n t varies,
for the
W.
Phase apace
detalXeZt ana1ysSs would require knowledge of how I f e is the polarization of the vector nreaon
llnd PI, p2, p 3 the four vectors of the three pions the emplitude must be constant eliYap eli plv p2@ pgp.
The "constmt" f o r the 4 has ta be about 0.1 a f its value
f o r t h e w.
Lecture l 8
Ismss The 41 appears ea act ast pure
L.
&at is the significarxce of a l e
- or
r a t h e r how can we d e f i ~ e& i s h t e r m a f q w t m nu&trra o r r u l e s without
9.5
Ymmr Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothesis r e f e r r i n g t o the quark m d e l ? We don't k n w how,
Wcr t r y t o say t h a t i t w u p l e s
weakly t o s t a t e s which have no strange p a r t i c l e s i n them, s o not t o 3n but yes to
E,
Yet such an idea "a s t a t e t h a t has no strange p a r t i c l e s i n it" $8 not
readily definable.
has no o v e r a l l
Due t o s t r o n g i n t e r a c t i m s a s t a t e l i k e
qwntuat a m b e r s t o d i s t i n g d s h i t from 3n; I n f a c t v i a v l x t w l i n t e r a c t i o n s
-
should couple strongly t o 35 ( f o r example through a tairtual w, KK
the
.g-*
u
3n.I
m e r e f o r e the question r e m i n s , what keeps the 4 Exono coupling strongly with 3n'l From the paaitat of view of
i s s e l e c t e d from the
~1
quark =del we &&t t r y t o say t h a t the
l -&ZM~] state
state
of the w simply by the f a c t t h a t s quark@
carry a l a r g e r =ss (or a d i f f e r e n t Faceraction energy) than non-strmge quarks, So i n lowest order of perturbation theory t h e e i g e n s t a t e s of energy a r e and
1( u ; ~ z ) . G
But then we f i n d these s t a t e s a r e unstable, and a s a kind of
perturbation they decayiy,i t turns out wItb s m l l widths.
- there is a u coupling equal t o - L is n o t small
s t a t e s f o r e x m p l e Qt
coupling of 4' and o0 t o every meson s t a t e (with t h e of t h e Q, coupling).
fi-
+.@E
But t h i s ""perturbatione1
-*
w
Thus f o r these v i r t u a l mson
there a r e d i a g r a w
4-
W
l? which mix t h e 4, w s t a t e ,
These d t a g r w cannot be calculated, (the above
diverges quadratfcally) and no w l c u l a t i m of such v i r t u a l strong f n r e r a c t i s n s h any problem has ever been successful.
But usually the q u m t i t a t i v e idea
t h a t i f the s t a t e s can be connected v i a strongly i n t e r a c t f n g virtuin1 s t a t e s they can go i n t o each other is v a l i d .
The coupling constants £+E aad fMa a r e s o
large they would seem t o have e f f e c t s of order I, t h a t is, t o strongly m i x the o r i g i n a l pure &a and
1(u%d;i).
a
Of course i t Is always possible t h a t t h e world t h a t the cmbination
as is not
18
s i w l y complicated,
i s o l a t e d by p r h c i p l e i n the beginning; but the
vex)r v i r t u a l i n t e r a c t i o n s s e l e c t s o m l i n e a r ta&ination of be t h e
I$
[and the orthogonal c*ination
the co&ination Is
and
1 (UCM~]t o
&I
f o r the w) and i t j u s t coraes out t b a t
L,
Then perhaps it %a r e a l l y possible t o tmderstmd why 4 but is the a~lcllbtlessof 4
-+
.c
ny i s eo sraalf,
3%r e a l l y obvious I n t h i s model of the s t a t e ?
But s r e l l @ore s t r i b f n g is t h e f a c t t h a t t h i s "accident" %a repeated again!
+
For the mesons of spin 2 where the Z(l25Q) goes nicely i n t o 2n or 4r end i n t o
S. The f(1514) goes p r e d s d n a t e l y i n t o '&l
and even h t o G%-k*and not i n t o
nn i n s p i t e of the even l a r g e r phase apace.
(The quark w d e f r a t e s (Fep-n,
-
U s l i n g e r , b m b l ) using pure l ( u s d x ] f o r the f ( 1260) and a; 42' a l l high, but the relatkvlve proportions a r e right.) m e e x p e r i m n t a l and quark m d e l
NOTE:
(m)r a t e s
f o r f (1514) a r e
+
f a r 2 w s o n s are;
There are i n addition two hadronic phenomaa ilesociated w%rh the 4 unless the QI Is, l i k e
vhlch axe =expected
+ 88
+ nn
N
thou& the 4 were not coupled t o the M, N* (a aucleon
trajectory) j m c t i o n , (relathe to p
+N *N ++
The f i r s t is badward praduction of rfr i n r B N
of zero s t r m g e a e s s ,
It: %B very weak,
weakly cowled t o hadronic s t a t e s
,S ;
AgaZn p 4-
p + Q1 + a n
is very etrangly suppressed
for exmple) a s thou& the $B%
8
a d
carnot be lazade fro=
the non-strange quark@ in the a t b e r p a r t i c l e s ,
VDM aad Photon XIadron Interactions b n p l e t e vector diminan= i ~ l f e tsh a t the photon carnot i n t e r a c t with a kadron except a s i t f i r s t becoms
et
p , w o r $B,
i n general) i n t e r a c t s with the hadrons,
and then t h i s
p, w
o r 4 (say V
Thus we would expect t o f&ad so= kind
of r e l a t i o n beween awXitudes l i k e h p (7
f
A
+
B) = v
%v
@ + A +
B).
There a r e several, p e e t i w involved i n using the f o m l r t . are t h e o r e t i c a l questioas of - w a g .
Since y has
F i r s t , there
= 0, the vector meon
97
f/eeforMesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothegig 0, f o r which s t r i c t l y
an the right s i d e should be a v i r t u a l vector meson of q2
It might be argued t h a t sixlee -ss
no d e f i n i t i o n can be given,
s t a t e inco&ag p a r t i c l e miglrt have the least e f f e c t a t high
on the i n i t i a l (here E
8,
L=:
p
a n T a y f o r f i n i t e glass) t h i s m l a t i o n m y be mst nearly correct Ear r e a l vector -sons
on the right-hand s i d e a t very high
S,
b o t h e r related d l g u i t g i s
t h a t the photon has only WO golarizationa, h e l i c i t y
f;
l, so the equatloa has
But h e f i c f t y i s
only m a a i n g f o r the corresponding h e l i c i t y ?: l s t a t e s of V ,
not a r e l a t i v i s t t c a l l y invariant concept and depends on the Erme.
Most
t h e o r i s t s have corn t o the conclusion i t is i n the s-chmnel f r m e t h a t the
is reduced by going t o
p h e l i c l t y should be 2 1, A t any r a t e t h i s -certainty
Thus we s h a l l , t o avold auch c o q l i c a t e d discussion, limit our-
large s also.
selves t o c a p a r t s o n s t o experiment a t the h i @ e s t energies now avallsble. The next question is how we a r e t o o b t d a the vector =son or mplltudes V
+A
-P
crass sections
B, a f t e r a l l V mson beerne a r e aot available,
Sowtims
t h e o r e t i c a l a r g w n t s are available, but i f they a r e too complicated they a r e The m a t useful s i q l e cases a r e :
not uaeful t o t e s t WM.
a) Pseudoscalar =son production, i n p a r t i c u l a r p b) Biffraetion ( e l m t l c ) s c a t t e r h g from nuclems p
+ Nuclaw
J.
+N p + N
J.
n
+ N.
+
p
+N
o r nucleus
+ Nueleus,
p
kle discuss each i n turn, We can study the r e a c t l m p
reversed reaction n
+N
+
has been studied a t L5 &V
p
+ H,
+M
nap
+. 'p
n
+ 1\1
by experimntally s t u d y h g the
&ich should have the @ m e-2itudia.
a d reported by D.W.G.S.
This
Leith, fieno-oloa
Naturally the p is not observed d i r e c t l y
a n f e r e n c e , l971 (Caltech) p. 555. but
+
C
n is inferred fro= s coarplete study of n- p -, n v- a loolting tn
the appropriate Hltlse region of the two outgofng piona. be made f a r palra of pions, say i n mutwl v i r t m f p decay.
However the data a t low
S
Sow corrections mmt
waves, &icb a r e not due t o t hias been nlcely malyzed i n d e t a i l
t h e o r e t i c a l l y and we caa describe the r e s u l t a , and empare t o W# e x w c t a t i o n s , We evidently wish t o c m a r e these r e s u l t s t o reactions lib y
and
y
N
+
n N i e r e l a t e d d i r e c t l y by W t o nip
acleaaxl l i n e a r co&ination of P , we drop i t , and the w
M,
+*
interference.
-*
V'
n where V'
-+
W+
is a vector
Sinctl the $ coupling to =sons
mM
+p
is smir
then predicts f o r e x q l a that (by
+
a r e "fnsity r a a t r b e l e w a t s t o proJect out the h e l i e i t y 2 f reactions. -2 -2 is about: 9/1 so the second t e r n is Data i n the o reaction a r e lacking, but g P /gw (pll]
probably never large. 10 times
do
be a s -11
p
((n-
+
I n addition, a t 8 GeY
-r
p' n) is i t s e l f about
w n) i n the f a w a r d direction, so the w contribution might
a s 1%t o the
p-w interference
(E' p
mM
result,
The s m could not have been s a i d of a
term. ( f o r an a w l i t u d e of order .l i n t e r f e r i n g with 1 can w k e
a 20% e f f e c t , b u t i t @square is only B ) . m a t i s the reason t h a t the c q a r i s o n i s made t o the suzn of yg
+
+
n. a and yn
+
n-p croas sections
- for i n that a m
the p-w interfereace t e r n (from isospin considerations) cancels out ( s s doaa the P-+
interference), The cross sections f o r
4 3 1 1
the h e l i c i t y c a b i n a t i o n s of the p have been
aaasured (and reported %XI the f o m of density matrices) bp measuring the angular
+8-
dietributiona of the p a i r of pions n the polarized p
2
.
r e s u l t i n g f r o a the dlafntegration of
We a l s o have d a t a with polarized phot~r-e(perpendicular and
p a r a l l e l t o the plane of production a d s o can make two camparisona.
The vector
dminanee model predie ts then,
where daldt (yN
+ nN)
m m the average of dafdt
(m
-,-P) and dcldt (yp
and the p % are densktg nnattrix e r e m a t s i n the h e l l c i t y f r a ,
3.
.+
E
The r e e u l t s of
such a corrtparisan appear aa, follows (polarization data f o r photons a t 15 &V a r e not y e t available, but a p a s s e d extrapalation front 8 &V was nzade does not a f f e c t the ccrlnparlson of the s m of
5
8nd
3,
mmured as the .ctnpolarlzed cross section a t 15 GeV),
- this
which is of course
n)
98
Vector Mesons and Tdecror M e m L)amr"naneeWvmthesis
Kt &Vfc
c t
The r e s u l t s axe seen t o agree i n eexaety the f c m a r d d i r e c t i o n and generally f o r the uonatural p a r i t y exchange oil
.
, but
c l e a r l y disagree away from t
-
O for
Thus YOH a s s general theorem cannot be exactly c o r r e c t (barring the possi-
bZlity a f an mamw w c o n t r i b u t i m i n t h i s region], %W
photoas do not couple exactly ae off =ss
J w t how do they couple?
To make progress we should study t h e nature of the
deviations front a s t r i c t VDH and f i n d t h e i r c h a r a c t e r i a t i c a , we a good theory, which a t present we da not have develop
- we
But
sM.11 vector =sons.
For exmple! h&
- but should be able
cottld say why these various c r a s s s e c t l agree ~ ~ ~ for
to and f o r
the f o m a r d d i r e c t i o n , and why not Ear %? Perhaps s o m clues can be obtained from t h i s exmple s o we study i t f u r t h e r . The values of t we a r e studying here a r e sa small t h a t s i n g l e pion exchange ought t o d o d n a t e both cross sectionrr (Lee.
y
a s well ars p).
T f tbie
were e m c t l y t r u e without a b s o q t i o n corrections we would expect a r e l a t i o n between the cross sectiona s i m i l a r t o (18,2), (18,3), o r (18.4) simply because
The only difference (aside from t h e massZ dlffe'rence of o, y and selection
aE t h e c o r r e c t h e f i c i t y m p l l t u d e s t o c m a r e ) would be t h a t the y is coupled r e t h e plv
+ pZy of
t h e pions v i a a f a c t o
we would expect a r e l a t i o n l i k e
and the p v i a
Hence
t o replace (18,1), and corresponding r e l a t i o n s f o r the cross sections ( l 0 6 % ~(l8,3), (18.41 with g
P
replaced by fpww2). m e r e f o r e insofar as these r e l a t i o n s agree
f o r small t we have not made m y new r e s t of the vector dominance r e l a t i o n s other than t h a t fpwT2S gp2, a t e s t t h a t we have already seen works very well. t h a t equality of c a u p l h g constants w a s
cul
If
accident then the law t agreement
k.:uid only m a n chat s i n g l e pion exchange dorafnates both reactions a t small t
-
somthing we expect t o be t r u e on other grounds. On the other hand even a t low t , fi
deviate
- how could t h a t
m% f o r example, the two theories
corn about? The one pion exchange term aim t , of course,
b e corrected f o r absorption,
The differences between o
yH
and a
at low
&
met
l i k e l y c m be attributed t o differences i n the degree t o which a b s a r p t i m uludifies the m e pion exchange ezpectation. In the f i r a t place (see LE?ith% report) a f a i r f i t t o the p d a t a is given by a one pion exchange model corrected f a r absorption (due t o P.K.
Phy;s. Rev,
W i l l i w ,
1812 (1970)) f o r the a w l i t u d e e t h a t concern us t h i s gkvee
and
We have already sees t h a t the anabsorbed one pion exchange gfves f o r theere m p l i t u d e s { i n connection with the discussion of photaproduction)
-
This leads
and t h a t i d e a l absorption would subtract 1112 from each m p l i t u d e , t o zero A,
i f -t
:m
and f o r large t equal amplitudes f o r
Al.
All
and hence
t o ail asymmetry t h a t r i s e s from O a t t = O t o l a t t = mwZ and f a l l s beyond t h a t t o 0. photon,
% i s agrees with the a s
t r y observed f o r the Q, but not f o r the
1%the photon case the f a l l off f o r large t i s only aodazrate, t o say
0.5 o r so,
Thus f o r the photon i t looks l i k e a more appropriate correction
f o r absorption lnfght be t o subtract -re
l i k e 213 from the two mplltCLdes.
t r y i s 1 f o r t = 2mnL and f a l l s t o 0.6 f o r large t
- not
in
Vector Mesons and Vector Meforr D O I P Z ~N~yZp ~ f~l ~t t C ~ iCs We r e a l l y do not exactly k n w why the sub-
disagreement with experiment).
Possibly i n
t r a c t e d t e r n f o r absorption should always be the f u l l 1 / 2 ,
t h i s case e x t r a contributions (isoecalar o r isovector?) a r e contributing t o l%e point
t h e photon case t o increase the 112 appropriate t o t h e p case,
here is an ef f e e t d i f f e r e n t f o r p and y and hence df f f e t e n t Era= expectations of VD& (unless i t could possibly a r i s e from the u term).
Emever the c o r r e c t
c o n ~ t a n ttern t o use i a detemined e x p e r k n t a l l y by the cross s e c t i o n f o r t
3
O which is j u s t proportional t o t h e square of t h i s constant with known
coefficients,
This dete-nes
But a much =re
t h a t the constaat is indeed 212 t o 16%.
s t r i k i n g difference is the difference a f a
This difference is already l a r g e a t sml1 t
- the oB f
and a
YZ
EL'
drops o f f much Easter
Why? X dont t know. X thlnk the onystery here is $ay the cr YL* P1 f a l l s s o f a s t , In t h e E i t eo OPE plus a b s o r p t i m i t c~asfound empirically than does a
2
that a f a c t o r e"('lraz
needed t o be included i n these cross sections.
P. K, k f i l l i a m had suggested such a f a c t o r f o r absorption e f f e c t s but expected a much s l n r e r f a l l o f f ( l i k e e3('em'Z').
To what i e sueh a rapid f a l l off duel
Such a rapfd v a r i a t i o n is e n t i r e l y unexpected, method of analyzing t h e d a t a , m's i n a m u t w l s-tprave (not a
near
-t
-
It is very possibly due t o the
The e f f e c t of an m p l i t u d e t o produce a p a i r of 1))
has t o be subtracted away,
The value of
mzZ is e s p e c i a l l y s e n s i t i v e t o what is done here ( a t t
-
p
It
O o r -t
2 10mn
i t Is not s e n s i t i v e , ) Nevertheless there is a contribution t o n a t u r a l p a r i t y
exchange which is d i f f e r e n t f a r y and p ( v i o l a t i n g VD&). theofy of &ere and when such deviatgons should a r i s e ? probles t o analgze t h i s i n m r e d e t a i l .
How can we m&e a @e leave i t aa a
Onet obv%ous p o s s i b i l i t y seeing the
l a r g e n d e r i n the elrponent is t o be reminded t h a t t o t a l absorption e f f e c t s
(as seen i n e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g ) do f a l l off a s expbt with b of order 8 o r 9 f o r n nuclean s c a t t e r i n g .
So perhaps a c a r e f u l anaZysis of absarption, o r
a l s o of t h e p o s s i b i l i t y t h a t the source BE t h e pion is i n d e f i n i t e by the s i z e of the nucleon or the p, w i l l explain it.
The point of explaining i t , however,
i r s t h a t t h e drop off is much slower f o r the photon c a m .
Ttzerefore whatever
the c a m e i t works d i f f e r e n t l y i n p and y pseudoscalar production,
Zn i t s study
1Zes t h e p o s s i b i l i t y o f understanding physically h e r e t h e ideas of VDH go wrong.
The problem cannot be d i f f i c u l t
- the e f f e c t shows up
f o r smll t and
hence f o r l a r g e i m a c t p a r a m t e r and therefore i n a realm *are
physical
phenomna a r e usually underetand&le,
The next topic we take up is the dgffractive production of vector mesons by photo=.
here, to
A t f g r s t we study the p =son
f o r amre detailed data is available
I w i l l not go i n t o a s m c h d e t a i l i n the r e s u l t s a s we a r e aceudlit~rned
- Ear a
f u l l r e w t report see:
@off: 1971 Zntennatima1 Conference m Electron and Photon Interactions a t High Energy, Cornell, Zthaca, N.P
., (1971).
Our aain concern ~513.be a cofnparison t o V W , The go production i n yN
+
the cross section approaches
B
looks very tauch Like d i f f r a c t i o n s c a t t e r i n g , constant a t hi& energy sad hat^ the typical
dawndencl; of such ~ c a t t e r b g , But how does the photon a f f r a c t Snto a
Qne
m w e r ie provided by V M , from the expected w l i t u d e relation (18.1) we expect 1
(because of. I spin change i t is expected that
@W '
rapidly with Lznergy s o only the p t e r n remains).
+
p%
or
w i l l fall
$ON +
Wat do not know d i r e c t l y the
cxoss section of p' on nucfeoas but we c m e q e c t i t t o be a typical e l a s t i c
.
scatter&ng
G crude use of the q w r k -del
supposing the quarks t o s c a t t e r independently
of t h e i r spin directian m d t o be s l & l a r l y d i s t r i b u t e d inside the
and no
p'
suggests a ( p 0 ~ )p. 6 ( n 0 ~ ) . Thie l a t t e r is not Ixnown by d i r e c t experitoenr but [o(n-#
isospin gives i t as
t o t a l cross section f o r yN behaves,
+
+
W-&)
+ o(%'~
+
aCN)].
It does turn our t h a t the
p ' ~ varies with enerm i n j u s t the way
$ [6(n'~)+
o(n%)
Xn f a c t the t o t a l cross ~ e c t i o ais given correctly by t h i s r u l e and
equation (19.1) with g
Et
-
2.8.
There is s 15%m c e r t a i n t y because the observed process is yN
+
N
C
nf
+
n-
and there a r e uneertafatia;is i n i n t e r p r e t a t i o n due t o so-called bck-type diagram i n a i c h the y becomes two pions Rat a t the p reeonmce and one pion s c a t t e r s l i k e
l
k t o r Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothesis
i n s t e a d of
A s t r i c t adherence t o VDN would, a s f a r a s I can s e a expect t h e analogue
f o r p s c a t t e r i n g t o 2n v i a
but t h e point is i n estimating just t h e e f f e c t of t h e s h p l e p e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g s o we can use our no s c a t t e r i n g malogy, This idea t h a t
yXrl -a p N
tells
W
about pP1
-+
pN pernalts us t o
S
The polarjlzation af t h e p coming out can be w a s u r e d .
behavior i n another way,
I t i s very nearly purely transverse and polarized a s the incident y ray.
This
3s excel l e n t evidence t h a t t h e p r a w s s of e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g ( a l s o c a l l e d pomeron exchange) does nor change t h e h e l i c f t y i n the c e n t e r of =ss syatemn. , Were t h e d i f f r a c t i o n t e r n is svlaller s o o t h e r processes axe a l s o
e f f e c t i v e , i n p a r t i c u l a r one pion exchange a t t h e lower energies.
The n a t u r a l
p a r i t y exchange has besides t h e gomeran exchange a l s o possible A2 exchange ao t h e purely d i f f r a c t i v e p a r t ha8 n o t been separated out yet f o r a c l e a r t e s t . , The e x p e r i m n t s show some L n c a s i s t e n c y but d a t a lis a v a i l a b l e .
One wily t o t e s t t h e r e l a t i o n s of VDM i a t o conrparr? t h e forward d i f f e r e n t i a l cross s e c t i o n f a r yN W
-+
W,
%h'is
-c
VX wfth t h e f o m a r d d i f f e r e n t i a l c r o s s sectjton f o r
l a t t e r c m probably be estimated f a i r l y w e l l froin t h e o p t i c a l
theorcorn using quark model estimates f o r t h e t o t a l cross s e c t i o n s f o r W, (The quark model estirnate f o r t h e
aT(@p)
=
+
This gives a f i t with g
P
aT(~-p) 2
p, w
and 4 are:
- oT(w p) f
-
/ 4 n = 2.6 2 .3, 8;
l 5 mb
-
at 5
%v.)
24 t 5 and g
t8
m
22 2 6 .
Only
104
Photon-Hadron Interactions
the :g
seems too big.
It could mean the quark estimate of
-
is too b i g
l 0 lab would f i t b e t t e r .
k c t u r e 20 Diffraction production of v e c t o r m a m a can a l s o be seen, and m r e copiously and c l e a r l y fro= y on n u c l e i , A.
(Referwee: K. C o t t f r i e d "'Nuclear
Photoprocesses irnd vector doninance", Ceornell Gmference, 1971,) d i f f i c u l t i e s f o r the
since the f i n a l 3n s t a t e
%ere a r e
is hard t o m a s u r e , and t h e g
i s s o wide t h a t t h e o r e t i c a l q w 8 t i o n s of i n t e ~ r e t i a e d: a t a sire i n v o l w d .
The
c l e a r e s t case e x p e r % w n t a l l y f e 4 production, h w e v e r much more d a t a e x i s t s f o r the p ,
In these e x p e r i m n t s an p production observations a r e m d e of 2%
production by photons on n u c l e i , of course. t h e 2n is seen a t t h e p =ss, e f f e c t with w
-+
The 4 d a t a
X t is a s
A b e a u t i f u l resmance i n wss of
t r i c a l shouing t h e i n t e r f erence
Zn just a s i n e%- production, it3
now good,
The dependence an h, t h e mass nmber of the
nucleus, gives us some idea of a d e t e r a n a t i o n of g+.
W'
and the absolute cross s e c t i o n p e w t s a
Wowever an tmcc?;rta&nty a r i s e s f o r the r e s u l t s depend
s e n s i t i v e l y on the choice of m w k m quantity, t h e r e a l p a r t of the forvard @W s c a t t e r i n g amplitude f+4. Let aON= xrnfO4/~e is i n s u f f i c i e n t t o determine a l l three q u a n t i t i e s g
2
4
Then the d a t a if
/4n, oO, and o 4s'
g & / 4 n i s its Orsay vaiue 13.3 then we caa only conclude t h a t a m y be @ i n the range 8 t o l 4 aib ( a t about 7 &V) perhaps f r o a .3 t o -,S and o
-
,
possibly a b i t lower tlsan the quark m d e i r u l e s would suglgest, but l i t t l e c m be s a i d . TZze p d a t a i s m r e e x t e m i v e .
Were the l a r g e width causes s o w confusion
as t a what p a r t of t h e data i s t o be a t t r i b u t e d t o p production.
Again we
2
have three parameters g / 4 n , opMand apN. h e g e t s agreement with expectations P i f we ehooee apN 4 . 2 4 (but i t i s n o t well determined). The d e t a gives
-
t h e "good valuesff ( a t 8.8 GeV) gp2/4n
-
2.6 and o
well d e t e M n e d and r e s u l t s depend on i t , )
PN
Therefore the phenomnon of vector
meson productim e x i s t s and behaves closely l f k e a d i f f r a e t i o ~process, and could we11 be i n q u a n t i t a t i v e agreement. with the
VX)PII,
Does t h i s t e s t the
105
Yecror Mesons and Vector Mesorz Dominance Hypothesis Z think not because f o m l a (19 , l ) applied t o d i f f r a e t f o n scatterlstg
mdel?
- nmely
c m be derilred ( a t very h i & energy) f r m ano&er hypothesis
that
c l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g of the p is much l a r g e r than d i f f r a c t i v e d i s s o c i a t i o n
the
s c a t t e r i n g of the p ( t h e process by which pEii
+
p*N where p* is s o w o t h e r
s t a t e of the s a m isospin a s the p , m a n d .tJhich survives a s s d i f f r a c t i o n diasocfatfon ( a s H% perhaps an*
-+.
o r nM
M%
-+.
-c
W).
Such
r*N) a r e i n other reactions
30% of t h e e l a s t i c scatrering fro@ t h e nucleon s o there i s
no reason n o t t o ass-
i t f o r the p,
Furthemore f o r the p we s h a l l only
have t o a s s m e t h a t the p a r t of d i f f r a c t i o n dissociation t o those p * having s p i n 1- ( l i k e t h e photon) is smll empared t o t h e e l a s t l e ,
a d i r e c t expergmental confimtialon o f t h e f a c t t h a t
-c
There is a l s o
@*H
where p * i s
any iaospin one, 1- s t a t e , produced Iln a d i f f r a c t i o n d i s s o c i a t i v e way does not f a l l wtth energy, For productian on n u c l e i our a s s u q t i o n (of the d o ~ i n a n c eof e l a s t i c
- f o r t h e e2aprtfe comes the a t i r e n ~ c 1 e w- whereas t h e
d i f f r a c t i o n diseociatialon) is ever more t r u e a s A r i s e s from d i f f r a c t i o n from the shadow of
p a r t i c l e s produced by d i s s o c i a t i o n can e o m only fro= its edge. The point
is L t i s riot doainimce of the y t o p t h a t we r e q u i r e f o r
the v a l i d i t y of equation (?19,1), i t w u l d a l s o follow from do&nmce of P
-+
i n the products o f the d i f f r a c t i o n of p
P
0s
nucleon and nucleus.
We can s e e how t h i s works most c l e a r l y i a the case of s c a t t e r i n g from a l a r g e nucleus where our a s e u w t l o n is most nearly v a l i d , considering yA t o P&
-+
PA,
-t.
pft
analyze t h e reverse reaction
gA. -, yA
Instead of
and compare i t
m e high energy pA s c a t t e r i n g appears, i n say t h e
C.=,
a s followap;
The waves of. the Incomfng p c o w I n from t h e l e f t and f a l l upon the nucleus where they a r e absorbed. wave lengths i f
S -,
A s h o r t distance ( a i c h c m be m n y
beyond t h e t a r g e t eay at the datted l i n e the wave
function is nearly the o r i g h a 2 , p wave f m r z t i m with aihole a@ a ffunctioa of
106
Photon-Hadron Interactions
b, the irapace p a r m t e r .
byond t h a t the waves Qowly d i f f r a c t i n t o the
s h a h i n a way d e t e m h e d by Euygens principle.
- alb) is the -1i-
Zf l
tude t o E b d a p a t 6 (so a is near 1 f o r b a m l l e r than the nuclear radius, and near O beyond) the i r p l i t u d e f o r an outgoing wave of transverse m m n t m
Q is j(l-a(b))
eiQob dZb f(q). ikr f(l-a(bl> d%
%
The amplitvde a t P is appronimately
Of course the l gives only the fomard be= m d doesntt i n t e r e s t us
is j u s t a s i f the
p c-
out only across the face of the nucleus.
- it
To be sure,
i f the p ware not a p o h t p a r t f c l e but say rnade of p a r t s (indicated by the braided l i n e ) we could not precisely define everything h t e m of aa m p l i t u d e But
t o give rz. p , but would seed a function of a l l the p a r t s as variables.
c l e a r l y f o r b outside the nucleus the p a r t s a r e i n the aaae r e l a t i v e a ~ l i t u d e as i n a p
- only near
of the p a r t s
the edge is there sow d i s t o r t i o n of the r e l a t i v e behavior
- and 80 a projection possibLble i n t o eoae other than the p.
the a w l i t u d e a(b1 is c l e a r l y t h a t f o r a
p
But
except near the edge; so t h a t elastrlc
s c a t t e r i n g is much l a r g e r (for nuclei, a t l e a s t ) than d i f f r a c t i o n dissociation, 3.
-
How we have noted from experlrnent by e e t h a t tJhenever we have a p present there is an amplitude t h a t t h i s p w i l l d i s i n t e g r a t e t o e+e'
(via a
photon) and therefore there i s a source of the e l e c t r o m g n e t i c f i e l d given by jij
Y xamp. t o find p polarized i n direction P, (Pp P
m
- a current - Hp2/gp).
-
Tlrw In our problem a t each point P there is a c u r r a t source of electro-
- thus the t o t a l q l i t u d e f o r finding a photon
m g n a t i c f i e l d of s i z e $(P) g o h g out with wave vector
gout is
!@(P)
e
-ik@at *P 3 d P,
expression f o r $(P) In t h i s the convolution of e-ik r/ -Zkout *I3 gives r:
1 m ,( B w k2 + mP2 and kautZ
If we s u b s t i t u t e our -ikout"P and e just 0) so we eventually get the
k -k
outgoing a ~ l p l i t d ef8Vtpbton is
where QOut is the transverse p a r t of Lout.
The i n t e g r a l i s the same as f o r the
p e l m t i c s c a t t e r h g so the a w l i t d e s a r e proportional
2
mwt bear the r a t i o bnr? /g
- the @roessections
2 D
Oae can of course carry the w t h e m t i c s out i n more d e t a i l separating
107
Vector Mesons and FlecforMeson Dominance Hypolhesis the z and transverse molenew c a r e f u l l y t o s e e j w t how t h e a s s m p t i o n of high energy i s v a l i d .
It is e m y t o urlderstmd i f t h e d i f f r a c t i o n of the
wave i n t o the shadow i e omitted.
ir; 2
shadow is j u s t e
-
kPr
E
Then the w v e going f o m a r d behind the
(l-a(b)) h e r e the incident p i s of enertgy E a d The amplitude t o ma*e a photon of energl E, transverse
-m ' / 2 ~ .
P
momentun Q, hence longitudinal moment= :k
A
-
E
- Q2/ZE a s
1/2E f a c t o r has been included t o take aceaunt of the r e l a t f v t s t t e
normaltrations f o r the incoming and outgoing p a r t i c l e s .
The m P
d i f f r a c t g m i n t o t h e s h a d w maLes i t m
P
'
'-
1/m 2
Q is wrong
(ae though the
fox p's s d a g i n t h i s direetZon).
It is evident t h a t the poferization of the y L s the s a w f o r t h i s process.
~zs t h a t
of the p
This f e a t u r e has been h e c k e d e x p e r i m n t a l l y very c a r e f u l l y
and is very eytribing, the p p o l a r i z a t i o n produmd by paftlrized photons is nearly purely t h a t of t h e photon. Often i t has been auggesred t h a t VDM p r e d i c t s i t s f o m l a (19.1) v i a a diagrlun Like
V
1
suggehlting the photon b e c m s a v i r t u a l p o; zero q L , and hence t h a t the coupling FD (or
q2
m
P
'
- mP2lg P )
should be t h a t appropriate f o r q2
-
O i n s t e a d of
+
where i t i s measured i n e em. It i s a r e s t of YDH t o f i n d t h a t t h i s
constarnt is unchmged i n t h i e range.
But we*have seen, by consfderation of
the reverse reaction, neglaetgng diffraction dissoeiiation t h a t the appropriate conetant should be t h a t of ra and no extrapolation i s involved. P J. a n d u l a haa3 c o n f i m d my a r g m n t by an. a r g a m t front dispersion theary m d the reduction f o m u l a ,
The a s s w t i o n of neglect of d i f f r a c t i o n d i s s o c i a t i o n e w e s i n h e r e ,
Near
the edge, t h e p a r t s of t h e p may n o t be i n p r e c i s e l y t h e sarne r e l a t i v e Htotion t o produce a p , but they m i & t
s t i l l produce a photon,
It m a n s an i n t e r f e r i n g term of o r d e r ~@*/rn~:
*ere
(Pp* i e t h e coupling of
p*
tlmes t h e amplitude t o make p*
t o photons) su-d
i t mwt be smll co&sg only near the edge.
Clearly t h i s is small.
on p*.
For n u c l e i a t l e a s t
The point is n o t s o much t h a t F
P"
i s sm11 (&%eh i t m y be, a s s o l i t t l e p* s e e m t o be produced by photons on
n u c l e i (vhlch measures
bur t h a t t h e nvmber o f p* produced by p v i a
d i f f r a c t i o n d i s s o c i a t i o n is smll. Other Tests of VIM I f VDH were c o r r e c t we expect t h e photons t o have amplitudes l/% t o be
various vector =sons
s o t h a t the t o t a l c r o s s s e c t i o n o f y t e on p i s l/%&
times t h e t o t a l c r a s s s e c t i o n of each of the vector meons.
(neglecting passibjle i n t e r f e r e n c e e f f e c t s of u and g). t h e p (becauee of t h e 9:1:2
-
o,(pp)
r a t i o of
%'
mis
and o(+p) is small).
We expect
is dominated by
We estimate
ot(@p) by t h e quark m d e l ss equal ~ ~ ( n ' p )fa scheme which we checked
i n our a(yp
-F.
Vpb consicierarians Ixbove).
kle f i n d e x p e r i m n t a l l y t h a t atot(ypb
is too l a r g e by 4QX, a s though o t h e r processes = r e available t a the photon t o i n t e r a c t with t h e proton besides go1ng throu*
v i r t u a l vector =sons,
A very s i a l a r cheek giving precisefiy t h e s a m r e s u l t i s Ca we eq. f 18.1)
t o say A(yp
.+
YP)
° I
Again t h e d o d n a n t term 5 s t h e
p,
XndependatZy of the r e l a t i v e phases we
The q w a t i t i e e on the r i g h t h m d s i d e a r e available d i r e c t l y by e x p e r i m n t . Ihe dependence of dao/dt (yp
O f o .4 h V
2
-+
Vp) on s (from 2.7 t o 5.2 &V)
and on t (from
) a r e w e l l represented by t h e r i g h t hand s i d e , but i t i 8 always only
about 112 of t h e e x p e r h e n t a r c r o s s section!
Thus VDEl f a l l s here.
This is i n ka~cordw i t h the tiOX e r r o r i n the t o t a l c r a s s s e c t i o n t e x t , f a r the o p r i c a l theoreoln reLatee ilo/dt (yp square of a t
+
yp) i n the forward d i r e c t i o n t o t h e
(YP) (assuming s o wt h i n g about phases)
.
Vetor Mesons and Vector McwfrBorrrirrancrfH j p o t l t c ~ ~ ~ i s
How should the t o t a l cross s e c t i o n f o r y+ iducleus vary with the rnass We knew f o r eollisiclns with hadrons nuclear atarter
n u d e r of the nueleus A?
is nearly opaque ((because a hadxon-nucleon is c m a r a b l e t a the spacing of t h e nucleons) and t h e r e f o r e t h e c r o s s s e c t i o n f o r A nucleons is n o t the sunr of a contribution from each (hence otat
%
A o nucleon) because nucleons i n the
f r o n t shadow those i n back s o ultimately f o r l a r g e A. i t goes as t h e area; of the nucleus o r
.
On the. o t h e r band f o r photon-nucleus
c o l l i s i o n s a. f i r s t glance would
suggest t h a t the nucleus now being transparent fay nucleon is much smaller than nuclear spacing i n a nucleus) each nucleon would s e e the f u l l bean and hence t h e c r o s s s e c t i o n would go a s A ( t i m s t h e simple nucleon g h o t m cross s e c t i o n ) . Or,
t h e o t h e r hand t h e VLlM shows t h a t t h i s l a t t e r canclusion cannot be A photon m p l i t u &
r i g h t i n general f o r i t is i n c o r r e c t i f the V I M is c o r r e c t . should be proportional t o t h e p amplitude
- the l a t t e r
is a hadronic m l i t u d a
-
hence the photon cross s e c t i o n proportional t o t h e p cross s e c t i o n m d t h e r e f o r e varying aar A2f3
(F. neglect the? contributions of w and Q, i n t h i s q u a l i t a t i v e
d i s c m s i o n , t h e i r contributions a r e e a s i l y r e i m t a t e d ) . The reason is t h a t i n the s % y l e view we img1ned t h e i n t e r a c t i o n y
+ nuclem
= X t o be a l a c a l process of y on nucleon, t h e y i n t e r a c t h g a e a r
h e r e the nucleon is located can become v l r t u a l hadrons
- but VDM reminds us (e,g.
t h a t t h i s is n o t so.
A y
2n, but most i w o r t m t l y a p ) Tar away I n
f r o n t of the t a r g e t , and the, d r e w 1 hadrons propagate a long way t o t h e nucleon to interact,
A r e a l photon is a pure i d e a l photon plus a v i r t u a l hadron with
amplitude l/dE accord%ng t o perturbation a e o r y where bE is t h e m e r g y d i f f e r e n c e of t h e s t a t e of given momntm m @oton md as hadran, the energy Is very sml1 f o r l a r g e v.
%us i f i t is a p
while t h a t of t h e photon is v s o dP; %h'is
- vs
m 2/2\1, P is a l s o t h e distance ahead of t h e nucleon &ere
t h e photon-hadxan conversioa occurs,
m
I f t h i s is l a r g e coapared t o t h e m a n free,
path of p i n t h e nucleus then shadowing occurs (Azi3 1, i f i t is small, no s h a d w i n g (A), The physical i d e a can be seen b e s t f $ r s t f o r a simple mdr?l c m s i s t i n g of
two t h f a slaba a, b of nucfear ntatter me i n front of the other by d.
@e s h a l l
calculate according t o WH, d
I f a p m r e inrpinging suppose the smll p r o b d i l i t p of being absorbed
i n the f i r s t l a y e r is fa; i n b alone f f p iarp~i.n@d that the p gate t o b
is
(1-5) so the product
fb.
But &a probability
%+
lDade in b is ( 1 - 5 )
The
t o t a l cross section i s thua fa+(l-fa)% = f +f -f f the l a s t t e r n representing a b a b
L e t us ealculiare the prob&iIfty Ear any product8 lnade i n b i f a 2s present
by photone v i a VDM.
Xf a f e not presflnt the q l i t u d e t o find a p a t b
product i s proportfoaaf to the m p l f t u d e the y converts t o p a t x
('\/TF
(the
Y
:!&has3
) and theo the p a r r i v e s a t d.
Thi. Is
hhets been taken r e l a t i v e t o the photon phase a t x
.c
d I.e.
the
abwe expretsalon c o a t a i ~ satt addltfonaa! f a c t o r exp I-ik d ) ) where the k Y
clre the L-vector f o r y o r p a t the same frequency. large?
V (mk.
Y
Y.
- kP
m '/'v
P
'5 for
1*
When a is present (21.1) is valid an* the ad&tioaal factor f o r
x
Xence L Y
Q
for d > x
0, For x 1-fa/2.
t o get throulpk s =
c
O we have
%S f o r
O we have
B e total. m l l t u d e ( b e e g r a t e xf is therefore pxoportfonaf, t a f
The =in
-i(k -k )d P
(21.3)
t e r n has an m p l i t u d e proporrfanclf Cc?
m-------
Id
arpect, the term i n shedaring fa corms i n various ph$es
as=
- and i o a more complete
Vector Mesons and Fector Meson Dominance Hypothesis problem with a continurn of l a y e r s would cancel out f o r (k -k )d Y P
111
1.
Thus t h e e r i t e r i o n f o r s c a t t e r i n g involves v, shadwing should be canrplete
for
V
J.
"
One ~ z n extend t h i s e m f l y t o a t h i c k l a y e r i n one dirnrznsion.
WE? seek the
a q l i t u d e co fInd a p a t x {for t h a t v i l Z l a t e r be used by squaring and s w i n g m t o g e t t h e t o t a l cross section.
W e have two cases g 0:
Y
4
y converts a t
Y > 0:
y
O md y
>
O
Y, propagates ss
p to
0; propagates a s p in mdium t o x
c m v e r t s a t y, propagates in mdiw t o
X.
The aaplf tude is proportional t o
( t h e phases have been taken r e l a t i v e t o the photon phase a t
X,
i.e.
t h e above
expressions contain the a d d i t i o n a l f a c t o t sxp (-ik X)), V
I n t e g r a t i n g over Y the a w l i t u d e a t x is
Here k
P
si"
i n the mdiutn.
k
P
At very high
V
i t has an iaaginary p a r t (representing
absorption) which is f i n i t e and fixed, the, r e a l p a r t goes, of course with v, but
m y d i f f e r froan i t bp a f h i t t ? m w t ,
Thus a s
V
+ m,
k -k Y
P
'*
k a fixed
a d e r (rJhose inailg2nary p a r t gives t h e p absorption cross s e c t l a n and whose phase i s the phase of forward p nucleon s c a t t e r i n g ) . 2 Thus i f k -k =
P
exttct proportion t o p absorlption, hence absorption, A f u l l calculation Including t h e s p h e r i c a l g e w t r y of t h e nucleus hae
been w d e .
They show a
V
dependence of atot(A)/Aa(nucleon)
f o r various nuclei
(see C;attfreid% report).
Ttze data does not show mu&
V
dependence
- (But L t is not f a r o f f ,
e x p e r i w n t a l e r r o r s a r e large enough, and the experimnt is very hard a t Tower energies) but not autsitie expectations
- hovever the wyrrrptotic valuers
of otot (A)/AofOr(H) a r e closer t o '87 f o r C, .15 f o r Cu and .60 (with large error) f o r Pb. These a r e a l l understmdsible i f the t a t a l croes section i s considered
70% W H and 30%s o w t h i n g e l s e ; (as we have srten is true) and i f the something
-
e l s e goes just as A purely, showing no shadowing, (for v
m)
values of ctot (h)/Ao (H) should d i f f e r fmm 1 by only 702 of the VDM
theoretical value f o r t h i s difference
.
Measurements a l s o e x i t fo v i r t u a l photons.
2 k = v - L
2*3
Y
Then the a y m p t o t l c
For them q2
m9.d sok-k Y
-
-Q2 and
Thw we expect fro= VDEI t h a t we again get
P
a v dependent shadowing, the p a r a m t e r d e t e d n i n g the extent of shadowing begng
((m
2
+ Q2)/2v
(In Au f a r g2
2 insread of m /2v.
No v dependence of shadowing is seen
0.5) i n strong disagreement with mlH predfctions.
I f we correct
VDM by allowing a c e r t a i n percentage of "other processes" which do not show shadwing, of course, l e s s shadowing is expected. 2
But we sboufd a l s o note tha
fraction of s o w t h i n g e l s e must r i s e with Q , The p so \IDH cross sections should f a l l as (m probably f a l l s only as
2
+ Q2~-2,
m p l i t u d e f a l l s a s I&2 3. Q2 1
he actual cross section
2 f o r large Cj (see l a t e r ) henee the f r a c t i o n of photon
cross sections &ich can be associated with d r t u a l vector aceson production
(mM cmtrZ;bution)
mwt f a l l aa photons become m r e virtus1,
for Au a r e not surprising.
%%us the r e s u l t s
f 13
Vector Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance f-lypothest To S m w r i z e the P o s i t i o a of WM I n t e r a c t i o n of photons of small q
2 (or q2 = 0) is very s t r o n g l y influenced
by t h e nearby poles a t the mass of t h e vector mesons,
fubstctntial p a r t s of t h e
i n t e r a c t i o n can be understood tas being due t o L a t e m e d i a t e v i r t u a l vector meson couplfng
- but,
a f course, n o t a l l t h e coupling can be s o described
[ f a r exanple only 70X of the t o t a l yp c r o s s s e c t i o n a t high energy Ss
80
described), In t h e s p e c i a l case altl the coupling t o p?lm t h e dodnance i s m r e eamplete,
as evfdenced by d i r e c t e r p r i m n t e'e-
+-n'n
(showing mainly t h e p, w peek;
not a l a r g e badrground and n o t much e l s e resonant has been found t o q2 and by t h e f i t of constants f pnn
"^
L
gO.
4 ~ e ~ '
(This w i l l be discussed f u r t h e r i n
l e c t u r e 24, i n reference t o t h e cfispersim Cheory of t h e pion f o m f a c t o r , ) F i n a l l y mrirarpurements e x i s t on n u c l e t f o r phseon produetion of Incsherent po(-t
" 0.1
+, .n-
GeV) aa w e l l as f a r production of o t h e r p a r t i c l e s such a s n 4-
m z a d even w0 ( a l s o Ii ). Were t h e theory is complicated By a n m b e r of f e a t u r e s
such a8 t h e absorption of t h e p a r t i c l e leaving t h e nucleus. p r e d i c t s rapid v a r i a t i o n s i n Aef only a small v a r i a t i o n , i f any,
The W M theory
WSt f t energy, &ereas e x p e r i m n t s i n d i c a t e (See G o t t f r i e d , f t h a c a Conference (1971) and
Diebold, High Energy Physics Conference a t Boulder, A p r i l 1969). present no expfanatlon k n m f o r t h i s discrepaaey n i c e problem,
There is a t
- its study would =aka a
X doubt t h a t the f a c t t h a t t h e y couples only p a r t i a l l y t o VDM
is s u f f i c i e n t t o account f o r t h e l a r g e discrepaxlcy, these incoherent f f n a l s t a t e s is prabably involved.
So= & t e a i n t h e theory of
-
Electromagnetic Form Factors
Nucleon: The rnstrix e l e m n t for the interaction of an electron, say, and a proton involves the diagonal e l e m n t of the current operator
U.
IF>.
Using
r e l a t f v i s t i c invariance and gauge invarimce t h i s can be written 2x1 the form
< P ~ I J ~ I P ~ ' (;21~M~l
+
l
( Y ~ ~ ~ Y ~ ) P ~ I ~ ~ >
where uf u2 a r e S-sginors describing 'the i n and out: proton 0f w m n t a pl, p2 rnolarentunt
transfer q
p2
- pl.
2
F1 and F2 are functions of q only, Other
linear coxnbinatfons of PI and F2 h w e also been defined,
lnost
w e d a r e (the
so-ealled eliectric and aragnetlc f o m factors)
clearly a s q2
+
O PI i s the charge:
Fl procon(0)
and Fe are the anoraalous m m e t i c m m n t a ,
GM(Ol
-
pp
l, PI neutron(0)
Hence GE(0)
-
O
l f o r p, O f o r n
is the t o t a l nagnetic ooment.
Ttrese have been masured by scatterdng electrons from proton@ @ i a s t i c a l l y .
The f i r s t order amplitude is
(Gk,
uj a r e electron spfnorsl
l14
Electromagnetic Form Factors 4 ne
2
The cross s e c t i o n a r i s i n g from t h i s is:
m
lab
P
By varying both .E
m d 0 we can vary q
2
and 8 hdependently, and thus
v e r i f y whether the bracket i n (22.2) does vary l i n e a r l y v i t h tanZ (812) f o r 2 fixed q , It: works well, s o both GE and C& can be extracted f o r the proton.
Data f o r GM i s m r e accurate than GE.
Far the neutron u n c e r t a i n t i e s of t h e
deuteron wave functions w k e the deeernt;mations, e s p e c i a l l y of G much ER less certain
.
Wi&er e l e c t r s i n a ~ e t i ccorrections do corn i n , e s p e c i a l l y e f f e c t s fro= the
but they a r e l a r g e l y mrderstood and a l l w a d for.
This i s an intportant but
tedious correction t o t h e d a t a t o g e t t h e Ideaf photon exchange cross s e c t i a n . Exp@rIroentel r e s u l t s a r e ussua1J-y dsscrlbed by giving deviations from a s e t of c m l e t e l y enapirical approximations, R-5y
that
l a t t e r Erurctlsn i s c a l l e d ttre dipole function GD. Most accurately know is G pHP '!
*
I t vaguely Eollowa t h e f m c t i o n GB,
116
Photon-1ZiadronInteractions
For solall q2 i t v a r i e s as about l
C-/G~ GD Thus G
M
5
1.08 f o r 1 K -q2 c 6 .
+
2
(2.6 2 . l ) (+g 1 , very c l o s e t o t h e dipole.
Above -q2 = 8
the r a t i o f a l l s below l.
f a l l s somewhat f a s t e r than 1/q4 f o r l a r g e -q2
The e q u a l i t y
.
%hn ~ ~ ~a s 1within%the accuracy of the neutron =
data. For t h e neutron CB:
a t qZ
1 is .a045 t .0043.
One can f i t with GEnZ G&(T/(I
f
L0 -c)),
Neutron-electron s c a t t e r i n g a t low energy (using e l e c t r o n s i n a t o m ) gives about
/(G /U 1 f a l l s f o r l a r g e r q Z near 2 o r 3 s o i f put ae EI? W p A q , A is perhaps .8 (large e r r o r ) . Xt is n o t pass&ble t h a t G = C /p EP MP p For t h e proton G
l
+
2
2 2 f o r a l l q , f o r a t q2 = 4M the d e f i n i t i o n of these W o G ' s i n t e r n of F F2 become i d e n t i c a l , s o unless G
Ep
w e m w t have G = G a t q2 EP HP and m 1 a t q L O. The sLnp1e r a t i o s artlong G
4
md G
m vanish
~ Thus ~ .C
G&,
EP
/(G
l
and
here (which is very unllikely) / p )
W P
-2.79 a t q 2 - + 4 M 2 P
GEp, GEn which a r e nearly r i g h t would be
expected by pure v e c t o r m s o n domintulcs (wsum%ngthe mass of p and o equal, and t h a t $I couples only weakly t o the proton).
Bonever, a l l the f o m f a c t o r s would
D b u t of the meson propagator MpZ/(Eb
be m l t i p l e s n o t of G
2
-q
2
= (1
+ 92 / .58)-l. Thus
This supposes t h a t the photon couples t o a point charge nucleon via the p ,
.
-
2 2 2 2 Its small Q behavior i s 1 1.7 Q it has t h e wrong l a r g e Q behavior Q2 i n s t e a d of I 2,S Q , It is, of course, n o t expected t h a t W continue t o
-
2 2 work a s we go t o negative Q f u r t h e r and further: frorn t h e pole a t Q
. : -SU
2 P
.
But t h e r e is l i t t l e doubt t h a t t h e l a r g e s i z e of the charge square radius (i.e.
2 the c o e f f i c i e n t -2.6 o f Q ) i s contributed t o a l a r g e e x t e n t by v i r t u a l
P f s s , ZC is not r e a l l y c l e a r why these r a t l o s do maintain t h e i r values at, 2 0 out t o $ = 2 o r 3 GeV a s they do t o LO or 202.
We c m gain so-
h s L g h t i n t o t h e rrrembg of form f a c t o r s by looking a t
the. non-relativfstic cae;cse. For a spllnless systern the forto f a c t o r is j w t the arsmatua representation of the charge density, p(@
ei9*'
d%
\p(r)
2
(23.1)
for small q2, with p(r) normalized so t h a t
Expanding i n p w e r s o f
(sinQr/Qr
p(r) 4sr dr = 1 we get
2 4nr d r
I
- Q2
t
2
16)
where r L is the mm square charge radius P
An exlpanential eer
f(Q)
-
(1
+ ~'/o~)-'.
f i n i t e not zero,
f o r the. Pharge: density gives the dipole d i s t r i b u t i o n The
qa4 depeadenee saya t h e slope a t o r i g i n must be
X t f s , however, a o t a valid concluaim t o we non-relativistic
2 views t o study large Q
.
Hevertheless the conclusiorl is e s s e n t i a l l y c o r r e c t ,
R e l a t i v i a t i c s l l y the f a c t t h a t ss q2
+
the form faetora go t o zero
mans t h a t &ere is zero probability t o find the proton alone as a point &arge, Tk&s could r e s u l t i n f i e l d thrtary e i t h e r f r m there being no %deal f i e l d e n t i t y (parton) with quantum riders of the proton, o r e l s e , i f tfiere were such the r e a l protcra is always dressed, i t k m zera q ~ l l t u d eof being an Ldeal proton. Ta w k e a r e l a t i v i s t i c analague of a thing l i k e the hydrogen atom {whose
&arge dlbstribution is e'gr)
w e irtaagine two s p i a l e s s partic_llt?s held together vSCh
a sp$;nless Haws p o t e n t i a l generated by the weak etrchiagge o f same s c a l a r =son, then (1) the non-relarlvistic waw function ahovss a e'CLr behavior, (2) the. 2 form factor varies as l /4 ~ for large Q
.
For e x m l e , l e t one p a r t i c l e A be charged aE m o s of mms m2 held weakly non relativist-icallg.
nA
4-
%,
Eke other B n e u t r a l
The w@sof the proton i e m a r
I$ a d neglecting &m zero& order the r e l a t i v e motion the i n c a a a g proton
of wmntuln pl, aeans A haa momatum arpl aztd B has m m n t m bpl (a
-
HA+% v*m%>
Finally we want a bound proton of atomatm p2 hence p a r t s of znomc?atm &pZ, bpZ. We do t h i a by h i t t i n g A with the vaty largcz 9 ultimately ta hold together p
A
lauklt
pl-p2,
&erem f a r thrt p r o m
change m1g by @Q, hence an a m m t of
mnrentm bQ awe be passed o w r t o b (by aa exchmge of the rneeoa reswnsib2e f o r iaceract..lon o f A and B,
The d i a g r w a r e
*
2 f o r large Q2 hence l / Q4 f o r the f o m llhe two propagators each give l/€)
factor.
Thus the f i r s t d i a g r m is
Clhe second
2 a t large Q
.
I f vector nresoas a r e exchanged beween a p a r t i c l e of spin 112 and one of spin zero, a 9' appears i n the numerator due t o mamatic coupling. Non r e l a t i v l s t i c a f l y i f a eystem f s mde of 3 p a r t i c l e s , the large Q2 a s m t o t i c behavior depen& not on the s i n g u l a r i t y whtrn j u s t two e m together, but r a t h e r when a l l three a r e on top of one another. Aes we s h a l l see, euch picttuces a r e too s i q l e and in&equate,
mkiag very naive loodels t a compare t o the non-rcrlativi~tie ideas-.
We a r e only They w i l l
not agree with the i n e l a s t i c scattering.
Lecture 24 Pian Fom Factor Data e x i s t s a l s o f o r the pion form factor, f a r q2
It Is beat obtagned front the reaction a f yg
-+
-c
O (spacelike)
+
nn produced by a v i r t u a l
photon (generated by elcctron s c a t t e r i n p ) , e
P By gofng t o s u f f i c i e n t energy one cgfl obta%a a region rP;here v i r t u a l pion 2 excttangs? is .most % w a r t a n t w d t h a t thfe trirtuaf, a has a s nearly zero q
-
(and is therefore aa close to its w;qs shelf m passfile).
The coupling of the
1/11
Electromapetic Form Factors v i r t u a l n t o the nucleon i s knom i n t h i s region (gNwEy5,
2
15) s o t h e only
u n h m is t h e photon-pion coupling between a r e a l n and one that is nearXy r e a l , but a l a r g e momentum trcunsfer Q, -1.2 where Fv has f a l l e n t o 0.28.
Data is a v a i l a b l e out t o q2 is jwr about exact+
This
( f o r no k n m very good reasan) the isovector p a r t of
t h e nucleon form f a c t o r
Flp-Fin which
2 a l s o f i t s a l l lower 9
2 -P
f a i r l y well t o t h e pure YDn o r p meson pole (l
.
+ % 6 ~ , vhich
It w i l l a l s o f i t -1.2,
is .32 a t Cj2
-1.2). but not a t a l l well t o t h e form f a c t o r GD of q which is too low ('15 a t Q* 2 Me have already discussed t h i s f o m f a c t o r f o r p o s i t i v e q where i t has been -4
masured i n the reaction e e-
-+
+ -.
n n.
Me have an expefimentaf, curve which is
dominated by the p pole expression (with small uslderstood corrections f o r the w-p
ft: is i n t e r e s t i n g t h a t an extrapolation s o f a r i n t o
interference, e t c . ) ,
negative Q
2
s t i l l . works reasonably well.
+
The r a t e e e--+ a1.a- measures, of course,
only the absolute square 1 ~ ~ (/ qnor ~ the ) r e a l and imaginav p a r t separately. Wowever the shape of the curve (p resonslace) is s o siwle t h a t our physical understacting m y make a separation i n t o r e a l surd lmginar)t part8 not hopeless (e.g. we wrote previously, f o r t h e p a r t near the resonance (*p arid had s o w guertsee a s t o how 'l varied with q
2
.
both portlt$vct and negative.
one believes
- that F r ( q
2
) must be
ii. m )) P P
2
) over a large range
an a n a l y t i c function of i t s variable q2 w i t h
.
2 P(q ) has so imaginary p a r t only f o r qZ inreasared.
+
Me can then check the hypathesis t h a t every-
a branch c u t along t h e p o s i t i v e r e a l q2
relation
/l(q2-mp2
Zf t h i s can indeed be done we
would have F n f o m t i o n now knom o r soon available on F,(q of 'q
2
- i.e.
t h a t Pn s a t i s f i e s a dispersion
2 ( 2 ~ ) where a t l e a s t
I FT(q2)
2
is
A check on a guess f o r tha imaginary p a r t would be t o coapute t h e real
p a r t from (24.2) f o r qZ method %s t o f i t
1 F~ I
2
3
O and check / F 1 2 ( a l t e r n a t i v e l y a much e a s i e r equivalent n
by choosing physi c a l l y appropriate a n a l y t i c expressions
2 f o r the complex f m c t i o n FE(q )).
Thent having established a reasonable
2 2 f m F, Cq ) me c a l c u l a t e s FTl(q 1 f o r negative q (where i t Is r e a l ) t o c o w a r e t o
2
- in
the p o s i t i v e q2 region 2 the main feature i s t h e p resonance and up t o r a t h e r large q no other resonance,
exper-nt.
We already s e e t h a t i t w i l l w r k well
i n f a c t not a l a r g e production, has beem found, 2
Below t h e i n e l a s t i c threshold qZ
(4v) (and i n p r a c t i c e probably
d l s t m c e above i t a l s o ) the phase of F,(q
2
some
) must, by f i r s t order u n i t a r i t y , be
the s a m as the v-n s c a t t e r h g phase eh%ft, X n f o m t i o n on t h i s is recently becoming a v a i l a b l e from p i o n - d r t u a l pion scattering analyses.
This m y h e l p
i n analyzing the d i e p e r s i m r e l a t i o n , 2 2 How should we expect F,(q ) t o go f o r l a r g e q ?
the p r o b a b i l i t y of producing f u s t two available must be very low,
nt8 B e r e
T t wt f a l l off becawe
s o w y other s t a t e s a r e
The isospin eurrent generated by the p a i r of pion8
awt be coupled t o o t h e r badrons and we require t h i s coupling n o t t o r a d i a t e .
Aa we s h a l l underatmd b e t t e r l a t e r , t h i s leads one t o expect F t o fall. as s o w parer of q
2
f o r l a r g e q2, but we do not knar the power.
Hwever, these con-
s i d e r a t i o n s make i t n o t s o s u p r i s i n g (granting the e v r i - t a l 2 P%(q ) f o r p o s i t i v e
q2) t h a t f o r negative q2 even out t o -1.2
behaviar QE. the expression
is close t a the p pole formula {which a r i s e s from (24.2) i f m s t of t h e ilaagI,nary 2
p a r t Ss near nr ). P Sum r u l e s r e s u l t front the f o l f e d n g cansideratioas. disperaLm r e l a t i o n (26.2) is v a l i d , s i n c e we know P,(O)
If we put
3
-t
i n ( 2 4 . 2 ) , we would expect ~ 2
Tf t h e wasubttacted E
2
l we. must have
~ ) (t o q go as l / q
2
timee
2
Im ~ ( q ' ~dqv2 ) ( i f Fx(q ) went more slowly than l / q we would have t o 2 m F(qt2>dqs2diverges, ae indeed we would expect f o r k F(q' ) would 2 2 probclbfy a l s o f a l l slawer t k m l / q ' 1. I f we expect F",(q 1 t o f a l l fastet:
2 than l l q (we how no s u r e a r g w a t f o r t h l s ) we would have another r e l a t i o n
called a superconvergence r e l a t i o n . We e q e c t t o have an usubtriacted dispersion r e l a t i m v a l i d because i f 2 (26.2) had an u n h o m c a s t a n t added t o the right-hmd ~3idethen Pv(q 1 could
Eiectwmagnetic Form Factors not approach zero as q
2 +
m.
In any event
I21
have the subtracted r e l a t i o n
- (24.3):
(24.2)
I n practice ( 2 4 . 4 ) i e =re useful than (24,2) t o compare F,(q
2
for
negative qZ t o i t s experimental value s i n c e uncertainties from rhe contributions f o r l a r g e q f 2 where data i s unavailable a r e mu& smaller. Me can now see using (24.4)
wtxy f ram what we already know e x p e r i ~ a t a 1 S . y
2 2 f o r Fw(q ) f o r positive q2 the value f o r negarive q should be close t o the 2 p pole value even r a t h e r f a r out. h (24.4) we know LF(Q ) is d
- there is not mueh
2 2 f o r l a r g e r q2 ( a t l e a s t no resonance t o /Pz(q ) 2 2 and ( 2 4 , S ) does not contribute integrand f o r s t i l l larger q , f o r Q
the a pole 4GeV2
even as negative a s -1.2.
Thus F,(O)
of the p pole f o m l a nearliy. fpsT/gp
-
- F,(q 2)
But F,(O)
is given by the a n a l y t i c extensirrn
is (the accident of the VDM canstrainta
1, see l e c t u r e 16) given by the p pole formula nearly, as we have seen
2 e a r l i e r ; ehus F,(q ) should a l s o be. make t h i s d l s c u s s h n quantitative.
An i n t e r e s t i n g study would be t o t r y t o 4'
One can a l s o aak i f the data on (e e"" .+ n'n-)
is accurate enough t o a l s o damhate (24.3) and t h w explain the accident t h a t
rPWn/g P
=l*
The proton form factor f a r positgvo q @'c?-+
m-'
could bc? obtained from the reaction
m e r e a r e o a t y e t any qusntitatfvo experiments but they a r e expected (kxe experimnt near threshold saw no p a i r s , indicating Q, GE a r e
mmntarily, slaall there
2
- about
there q2 z 4.
an, small (or a m l l e r ) than the &pole Eamula calcularcrd
2 2 We would expect agafn t h a t Fl(q ) md P2(q 1 am m a l y t i c
functions s a t i s f y i n g a dispersian r e l s t i a n l i k e
(Wen a w l i t u d e s can be expressed f a orore than one way, such a s h e f i c i t y
f o r the l a t t e r t h a t the s f w l e s t dispersiga relacloss a r e supposed to hold, b l a t i o n s f o r other c d i n a t i o n s mst be deduced from these,)
This t h e we have a d i f f i c u l t y . q2 < 0 by e l e c t r o n s c a t t e r i n g and f o r q2
O to 4 2 1
by e'e-
aonghilation i n t o
But haw can i t be defined e x p e r i m n t a l l y i n the region
proton-antiproton palr. cg2
.42
i a masurable experimntally for
I do not km of a physical d e f i n i t i o n .
But i t is expected
(fron f i e l d t h e o v exanples etc.) t h a t IrnF(qi2) is not zero i n thihi. region 2
.
f a c t t h a t the i n t e g r a l i n (24.5) has a threshold at ( 2 ~ )
%us
- in
no m m t of
e x p e r i m n t a l data w i l l p e d t a very d e t a i l e d t e s t of (24.5) f o r a piece of the i n t e g r m d is cmpfetcely rxnavailable, 2
P(q ) it can be defined i n no-man's tion
- but
Of course, i f a theory is availerble f a r land (O
2
tq2 c 4H ) by a n a l y t i c a l continua-
i f we had a theory it would presmably already s a t i s f y (24.5)
a i d t h e proper thing t o do would be t o compare, it d i r e c t l y t o e x p e r i m a t i n the physically a v a i l a b l e region. Thus the dispersion r e l a t f o n s f o r nucleon Zom f a c t o r a r e not of auch d i r e c t use f o r cmparinng t o e v e r h e a t .
m: FJe append here a theoretical note on t h e expected position
of t h e
2
threetrald (24.5) b e l m which I= F(q ) can be e w e c t e d t o be zero. For a charge density e-ar c l a s s i c a l physics gives F 2 a f i r s t s i n g u l a r i t y a t C$
-a
2
.
1/(q2
m
A superposition of erponentfals /-f
e3
dA
Q being 92 =
+ a')
giving a continuum
whlcb ha. (h)e-~~dh
X
of a i n g u l a r i t i e s the lowes t govewr
+h
the e l m e a t expooential t a i l .
idea is v a l i d r e l a t i v i s t i e a l l y .
Thi.
( I t h a s beea s b o m t h a t t h e position of the s i n p l a r i t y is the s m aa t h e p o s i t i o n of the s i a g u l a r i t i e s i n Feynmn d i a g r m o f a process a s i f r e a l p a r t i c l e s were
For t h e proton the v i r t u a l s t a t e N (P gradient of) e'l"r/r,
+ B+ e f i s t s
with a
E
extending out a s
Its aquare, the charge d e a s i t y involves p o l m o d a k i n
l / r times e-2wr, t h e longest exponential i s therefore
211,
and the threshold a t
-8
.Ml whicfx v i r t u a f r y
2 ~ . A =re
i n t e r e s t f a g case is one say l i k e the C , of
can emit a K (=ss m) t o be a nucLeon =ss El2, with PI2 < ;MZ.
We obtain the
sfngularlSty by studyfag the perturbation d i a g r m but can aee its p o s i t i o n
Electromagnetic Form Factors phgsicall;g t h i s way:
We ask: how sharp s r i s i n g ( e l m indepmdemt) exgonential e l e c t r i c
potential can we t o l e r a t e before we get a diw~rgeecebecause the f i e l d risea f a s t e r t h m the charge density f a l l s ?
Thus we hawe a f i e l d of mmntroa Q ( i t Is pure ileag5nary able t o make the fC: meon from the 6.
The v i r t u a l s t a t e is a p a r t i c l e of lnaea Hi!
mmntunr 0, and one of tnaes m w m n t m =ss
H
l
f a ) and a r e j m t
+ Q2 where
of mrnentlnn G l q (Breir Eran-@, u
lp.
the i n i t i a f . s t a t e i s one o f
0).
The condition of j u s t divergence i s that t h i s s t a t e J u s t has
zero energy
denodna t o r
@h&@ equation is r e l a t i v i s t i c becawe i t conserws both energy and maomnturn). This has the solutjiaa
g2 if %2
-a2 = -kmZ g
- m2
is a t q2 m +a
2
.
+
2
-
2
The threshold (orhewise the sqvsre roots a r e not positive.) 2 That i t i s b e l w the energy 4m needed t o mke a p a i r , which
was the f i r s t guess, we c a l l t h i s For M22 3: M
- m2 2 / H2~
-m
2
c9n
""anomlous" tt'brshold,
the equation cannot be solved, the s i n g u l a r i t y n m
r e a l l y comes {normal threshold) when the photon e m f i r s t d e a pair tq2
-
4m2
.
124
Photon-HadronInteractions
Mote on the quark m d e l of F e y m n , U s l i n g e r and Ravndal, The f o m f a c t o r f o r t h e proton by FKR is
(l
-1.1
- q2/4~2)-1
enp MmMaasof theproton
",
which is very poor
-
i t c u t s o f f too f a s t a t high -q
expect t h e m d e l v a l i d f o r l a r g e Q instead of 1 + 2.6 q
2
.
2
1,
For smll q
2
2
( t h e r e i s no reason t o
i t goes a s aftout 1
0
l -1.7 q or l
+ ,5
"7 q
2
In t h e m d e l the photon coupling i a direct: (processes
2 l i k e VDM a r e not considered i f they were we would add a f a c t o r (l-q /m 2
-
21-'
or
g i v l n g b e t t e r understanding). The r a t i o GE w/GH comes our 1 + q 2 / 2 2 q
2
which f a l l s too f a s t with q2 (experiment is arovod l
+ .06
q
2
1.
( h o t h e x way of deallng with t h e quark equations glving a much b e t t e r f o m f a c t o r , b u t much worse S i t s t o photon e l e c t r i c matrix e l e w n t s Ls given i n Fugiaara e t a l .
Prog, m e o r , Phys.
For t h e pion FKR would g e t (mE'
183 (1970) .l p2
,021.
2
which is p a t e n t l y absurd ( f o r e n a w l e , having a zero a t a11 odds t h e worst d i s a s t e r of t h e i r =del
qL
-
-0.08!)
It i s by
- ( i t c o w s f x m t h e ad hoc way they
d e a l t with t h e s p i n of the quark m a f f e e r e d by t h e photon) t h a t one muLd think ;Ln honesty they would include i t i n t h e i r pcrper,
Tbey di&' t because, s u r p r i s i n g l y ,
they d i d n ' t think t o c a l c u l a t e i t when they wrote t h e i r paper!
ectron-Proton Scattering. Deep lne astic Region
Electron be-
p e r d t ua t o study reactions such as e p
It is controlled by the amplitude the f a c t o r ( x
&
P
(I
ip)
(X~J
S1
is
i n which only
m e m s c novel feature i s the a b i l i t y t o vary the q
v f r t u a l photon away f r a n p2 dSscuased) t o
2
9
X
Ip) is a d a m , and ao we c m ulasure t h i s m t r i x e l e m n t (or
rather its square),
2
(LZ y P ul)
x fiere
-c et
0 ( r e d photon erperlments, *ich
o f the
we already
negative, and i n f a c t t o the Ear negative region.
very e m r g e t i e (hi& -8)
2
Xn addition,
s t a t e s x can be excited h the hfgh energy tna&ines,
A great; d e a l of i n f o m t i m Is becadng evail&sble, and there? are may theoretical
2 q u e s t i a s especially f o r the? aw large q and h i & =ss s t a t e s
X.
Ttrre? simplest e x - p e r i m ~ t st o do are those whi& do aoc require atudying the
x s t a t e s a t a l l (am over poasPble s t a t e s
X)
but j u s t study the electron beam
-
126
Photon-Hadran Irtteraetions
its deflection m d energy d e t e d n e s the =-turn dete-aee
($.U
t r a n s f e r aad
the lab system) the enare;y of x above the proton
energy l o s s Theee
-S.
were d m e f i r s t asld a r e mst c q l e t a -we discuss f i r s t therefore t h e i r
exper-a&
w i l l occupy
r e s u l t s and t h e o r e t i c a l i n t e r p r e t a t i o n (*%eh Then we s h a l l return and
&SCW@
f o r -g
lectures)
ac3.
X
.
t o look
is &m.
tbe I&, of the electrun is m m u r e d aa well
The energgy loes v = E-EQn
as its 4-mntunt
W
what we e m expect the f i n a l s t a t e s
lgke mad how they do behave experimntal3ly a s f a r
p*q
it8
2
trernafer q , The i n v a r h t a of the problem a r e thus q
lvXV where p i s the 4-mnturn
of the protan,
2
and
A l l quantities nraaaured proper
t o the hadrons a r e ezpressed a61 fuactions of these two variables,
The prob-
a b i l i t y we memare i a then proportional t o
b the cgse of mpolarized e l e c t r a ~ s(there are no e x p e r i m a t s with polarfzed electrons and protans yet, but we s h a l l d f s c w s the theory l a t e r ) , average over electron s r a r o s contributes the spur l/2 sp
yV
yli) = 2 (klpkZv
+ klvkZl, - dliv
$ yv
kf k2).
".'.
the swa and
-
ul) (u y u ) 2 F t l While the hadron s t a r e eum
gives an expression we s h a l l c a l l Ruv
t r i c p a r t of rxpressfon for any spin), (spin of p averaged, Ss alau vv S 2 (Note, the mms of the f i n a l s t a t e s which we are generatfng is e q r e e s e d i n , t e r n 2 of our variables q , v a s m
l?
+2
Hv
+ q2
2 By varying v f o r given q we can vary: H
2
q
i s negative,
and look, f o r example, f o r f i n a l s t a t e
127
EEectrcz8-Proton Scatrering. Deep Inelastk Region From a r g m m t s of gauge Invariance and r e l a t i v i t y t h e B of Che t e n s o r
(which is a l l t h a t counts f o r unpolarized e l e c t r o n , and
Ps a l l t h a t survives i f the proton i s unpolarized) a m t have the f o m
S e ~ r a pl r o p e r t i e s o f
W1, W2:
The apparent, but unwanted pole@ a t qZ =
O came from t h e way we have Tc r e m v e t h e hil3fteat pole
w r i t t e n our expression and of course cannot be r e a l . 2
-dq2vl a s q2
we must have (pep) W2
but Wl can approach a constant Wl(O,v) 2 2 2 V22q ,v)
-+
4
D er
as
q2
2 2
W2 = -9 /v +
0.
W1
+
order q4 ae q
Hence f o r small qZ, Wl
2
-r
0,
W ~ ( O . ~ ~;I
-OVWICO,vl.
2 The d i r e e t t o t a l absorption crosrs s e c t i a n f o r m I m g i n a r y photon of mss 4 r o hit
k
proton would be
arornentum of photon i n p rest agstea. We haye two p o l a r i z a t i o n cases :
Transverse,
e
i s perpendicular t o qv and t o pU
Longitudinal.
S m t i a e s c a l l e d scalar:
These two c r o s s s e c t i o n s can be used ss p a r m e t e r a i n s t e a d of W
From t h e above Eomalas
It is canvenlmt t o define
I' W2'
Photon-Hadroninteractions
128
C d i n i n g t h e e l e c t r o n s p u r t o t h e expression f o r K
irv
we o b t a i n the t o t a l
cross s e c t i o n i n the lab.
Ia p r i n c i p l e i t is poseible t o g e t both W1,
k$,
t h i s is done i n s e v e r a l eases
-
but mast accurate is W2 a d o f t e n wftrzt i s given ie W2 m d e r aarne a s s m p t i o n about Wl.
For exarclgle we have
and o f t e n d a t a is given f o r
Problem:
+ ea
without resolving them,
G
is o f t e n smll.
Show t h a t f o r proton e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g
2 4M W1
-
2 :G
&(v
-q
+ q 2/2H)
Lecture 26
We s h a l l now gfve a kind of p r e l i d n a r y description of t h e e x p e r f m a t a l results
- so@@d e t a i l s w i l l be d e a l t with
further l a t ~ r , Firet a useful varfable 2
.
t o discuss t h e lower energy r e s u l t s i n i s t h e mses2 of the f i n a l s t a t e Hx 2 2 M' 4 2Mv + q We s h a l l , a t f i r s t , use :M and q i n our discuesion.
< B
.
function o :f M
W,
As
of course, g e t nothing belaw M? then s l a r g e e l a s t i c p&
-
whm t h e f i n a l s t a t e is j v e t a proton proportimal corresponding t o: H = 2 t o $(q 4 2Mv) and depending on GH, GQ as we have previously s t u d i e d , This
-
contribution f a l l s a s q2 r i s e s a s 1 / ( 1 Next, f o r fixed q
2
, aa: M
- q2 1.71) 2 .
v a r i e s , we s e e e " f i r s t t f r e s o n a c e e t Mx = 1236.
129
Eiecfron-&"roton Scattering, Deep f nelastic Region a "second" one near
.a
1520 and f i n a l l y a "thir$'>irouad
l700 and some fndication
Theoretically we should s e e more resonances, e.g. l535 but
of: a fourth a t l90Q.
undodtedly t h e 'kaeeond" peak is an unresolved d x t u r e of these twa while the one near 1700 s o m t i m s c a l l e d t h e 1688 resonance is probably t h a t with four others e w a c t e d near *at
energy,
Tne reaonmce a t 1407 ( t h e Rowr rasone~nce) has not been
seen i n these experimmts ,
can be f i t t e d m B r e i t - g i p e r peaks an a background whfch
These resonaxtees
gradually dominates i n t o a smooth curve .a :M
inereaaes.
How do the resmance s t r e n g t h s vary with q2? At verg low q
2
the behavior
depends t h e o r e t i c a l l y on the angular trowanturn of the s t a t e and @ t a r t s a s an appropriate p m e r of Q (gZ
2
-q ). Tor higher qZ, however, t h e s t r e n g t h of the
m s 0 m c : e s a l l f a l l more o r l e a s a s does the e l a s t i c peak. the r a t i o (do/&)
res
/(do/dQ)elastie
with -q2 oae find.
Zn f a c t i f one p l o t s
cvrvse which rise rapidly
from -ttzreshofd (photoelectric) values t o s a t u m t i m (In tnthe v i c i n i t y of one! o r 2 jut belou) f o r q2 > about 1 GeY
For l a r g e r q
2
.
and l a r g e v t h e r e is nothing l e f t of the reaonances, 2
i t wae suggested by Bjorken that t h e funcrion vW (q ,v) (and a L o Wl(q
2
2
2 -q /2Nv on3.y.
be a function of t h e v a r i a b l e x as a f a c t i o n of
u
llx).
2~v/-~'
This f e a t u r e , chatl m -q
true, 2
vM2 (q ,v)
2
+
approaches a f a c t i o n of
There ,v))
should
(Data La o f t e n presented a l s o
This has turned a u t t o be r a t h e r accurately 2 srsch t h a t -q 12M-v = x is b p t fixed,
W,
V +
X,
F(x) Is hm as B J o r b n scaling.
kle s h a l l
have a g r e a t d e a l t o say l a t e r of i t s t h e o r e t i c a l signiffcance. Present ( S a n u a ~1972) d a t a is a v a i l a b l e in the f o l l o a n g regicms.
Resonance h g i o n Scaling b g i o n Wl, W2 Separated
I n the region w regien 12
P
w
I n my v&ri&le.
4
4, s e a l i n g is observed above
4 f o r E$
,2
-pZ>
l; VW
2
<
= (2 ' 6 )2
.
In the
is a c m a t a n t uAthin e r r o r s and s c a l e s
The d a t a f o r vM2 looks a s follows
./
vWZp&
. l 8 f. l
f a r t h e proton
.l2
f o r t h e neutron
I (vwZn&
9
a
Data f o r the neutron [by s u b t r a c t i o n from t h e deuteron) is a l s o a v a i l a b l e , The r a t i o t o W
2~
looks l i k e
i t is consistent with a s t r a i g h t l i n e ( l
-
X)
from x
O t o '75.
mere are
i n d i c a t i o n s t h a t i t c u m e s away above t h e f i n e f o r l a r g e r x and cou2d reach a value as high a s .S(?)
far x
In the region where
+
I, but higher values a r e probably ruled o u t ,
and W2 can be separated, values of R can be found
-
they v a q from O t o 0.5 with l a r g e e r r o r s s o a o d e f i n i t e trend can be seen. f f R is ass-d
R
-
-03
w n s t a n t i t is .l8
(_112}/d o r with
R S q2/v2e
s c a l i n g t h a t R -. O f o r fixed
+
,143, t h e d a t a is a l s o conrpatible with In t h e l a t t e r ease we would expect with
X.
We now begir: a r a t h e r long t h e o r e t i c a l discussion of t h e S n e l a s t i c e scattering, 2
-q /2kf
=
X,
2 I*le s h a l l f i r s t ~ S B C U Et IhB e "deep" i n e l a s t i c region -q
", v
-+
",
o r region of BJorken s ~ a l i n g . F i r s t we s h a l l discuas what is
c a l l e d the parton =del
5
-".
-p
b r i e f l y ; then we s h a l l discuss general p r o p e r t i e s of W%,
and s e e t h a t they a r e conaectcrd t o t h e carnutator of two c u r r e n t s ,
Pinally
we cam back t o t h e parton model i n w r e d e t a i l , discussing suggestions t h a t t h e partons be i d e n t i f i e d with quarks, e t c . t h i s t a a =re
- and
then discuss the r e l a t i o n of
h e t r a c t representation c a l l e d GeL1-Hann's Llght cone algebra,
m e r e then f ollowrj: miscellanesutl discuas hn, ending w i th a t t a a p t s to unders tand.
Elecsron-Pr~$~n Scarrering, Deep Inelmtic Regi'on things io other regions of the qZ,v plane (l.e.
for smsller qZ, and, or sr
resoncrnceslj etc., (actually our diacuas&~,oas will not be ro neatly organized, we
shall wander
these oubjeets).
131
Parton Mode
Farton Model The parton =del
i a t h e conceptually e a s i e s t t o understand, although i t
appears a b i t s p e c i a l , as s p e c i a l assuaptions seem t o be m d e . a b s t r a c t considerations a r e t h e r e f o r e =re the m r e e l e m n t a r y v i e w o i n t .
Nare general
s a t i s f y i n g , but f i r s t we discuss
Ln discurpafng these arattere i t is b e s t t o
keep i n mind a l l t h e p r i n c i p l e s of r e l a t i v i t y , quantum ~ l e c h a a i c s ,u n i t a r i t y , imalycicity, e t c .
One way t o do t h i s is t o work i n a coaceptual w d e l .which
s a t i s f i e s a l l these p r i n e f p l e s siatultctneousfy,
%ere is no b o r n sinrgle m d e l
which does t h i s except f i e l d theory (and t h a t m y not do i t diverge!),
m d t h a t is a very c v l i e a t e d rm&l indeed.
- all exwles
lulevartheleas we s h a l l
t r y t o s e e what f i e l d trheory d g h t suggest. f n f i e l d theory the wme function f o r a s t a t e , such a s a proton, could be given by givgn~ngthe m p l i t u d e s t a fllnd various kinds of bare f i e l d p a r t i c l e s w v i n g with various m m n t a ,
'flhese bare f i e l d p a r t i c l e s we c a l l "partons"".
Somt?ims soroe phenomaa c m be understood d i r e c t l y i n t e r n of t h i s wave f m c t i o n but usually laatrix e l e m n t s t o wave fraxctions o f o t h e r s t a t e s mst be malyzed,
The wave function, however, i s not e a s i l y transfomed from one
x e l a ~ i v i s t i csystem t o another (the
Lconim rnuat be know) became rlt repre-
s e n t s a s l i c e a t a given t i ~ t e . Certain p r o p e r t i e s art? therefore =re
easily
seen from t h e wave function i n one system than i n another.
"re deep i n e l a s t i c
s c a t t e r i n g behavior is b e s t uatdn?-rstood fro@ t h e wave function f a r the proton with extrearely high raomlmtm P ( i n +z d i r e c t i o n ) . f o r a of t h e wave Eunctlon a s P +
I n f a c t we atudy the lirnfting
a.
Tn what v a r i a b l e s w i l l t h e wave Emetion have a l i m i t f n g form?
Froar a study
of the e h a r a e t e r of t y p i c a l f i e l d h m i l t o n i a n i n a few e x w l e s , and from a study of vefy high energy i n c l u s i v e hadraa c o l l i s i o n s we c ~ n c l u d et h a t i f t h e raomntuna of the parton i s aeasured proportional. t o P as &P and t h e t r m s v e r s e maomntunr i n absolute u n i t s k then t h e a w f i t u d e s depend onZy on 5, k f o r 5 s o smll t h a t 5P is a f w &V,
- (except
as P rises
6 af order 1 h V / P a r e c a l l e d "wee'"
t h e d i s t r i b u t i o n of "we" pertons f s probably b e s t described i n absolute pZ
k
variables,
As we s h a l l s e e the "weett r r g i i o
hard t o mafyze
- but the
m i n f e a t u r e s of t h e deep i n e l s t i c s c a t t e r i n g does n o t involve them). The f a c t t h a t Er,
is f i n i t e i a
conaepuence of f i e l d theory
- (in
e, a t least:
La any obvious way, a d l r e c t
f a c t perturbation theory daes not give t h i s
r e s u l t , and therefore must n o t be r e l i a b l e here) i t is siarply guessed a t frm t h e ubiquitous reaullt of high e a e r a colllissians t h a t t h e t r m a v e r s e aromnta
-
= ( - 4 @V)
a v a i l a b l e t o the prodvcts averages about
2
.
But g r a t i n g t h i s , the &P s c a l i n g is elrpected fram f i e l d thmry ( a l t h o u e today w e could base t h i s a l s o d i r e c t l y on experiment, i t i a t h e s e a l i n g
ltlw
f o r the l o n g i t u d i n a l aramntum of the products fn very h i & energy c o l l f sSons). So=
suggestion of bow i t works is t h i s ,
i~seen t o be m d e up of two p a r t s
0%
The q f f t u d e t h a t a s t a t e af energy E
anera
E;n
E;1
$.
E2 i s domf.nated ( i n
perturbation theory) by a f a c t o r
But the z colgpanent of raowatucn of t h e parts 1s t h a t of t h e whole P S e t PI
m
5Z P, P2
m
E2P. El + f2
1.E m d P 2 + H 2 q S l?
+
the f i r s t p a r t and kl Ptfi t r m e v e r s e w ~ n t u m ,we have
Therefore A/ (E
- El
p2
+ p2,
I f HI is t h e nags of
(The P i n t h e n w r a t o r is w u a l l y absorbed 5% n o m l i z a t i m or La the form
c2.
f o r A, the e s s e n t i a l l y complicated bahavior of t h i s is a f l m c t i m of Cl,
2 2 kl f i 2, A r g m n t s l i k e these were o r i g i n a l l y used t o predict the inclueive scaling, a d they h a m been c o n f l m d by elrperimnt. F u r t h e m r e we see Cl (outside the wee region) must be positive partons a r e g o h g vigoreusly baekward negative, i t should be
/ cl[
- became (26.2)
em the rl&t hand side.
lgl
- no
not valSd i f FI is
men ( i f Cl is negafive)
- EL - E2*
( 1 - / & ~ 1 - g ~ ) P 24 P so the dencmtnator is not small but large 2 and the m l i t u d e 2s l / F 2 smiler thaa the precacding ca8e.
E
We envieaf~ethe proton of wmntusl P as beeig nrade of partens of m w n t a giP a l l sharing la various proportions F;% the mawntm of the proton, a l l 4 I l e behteen O and l ( e l s e some other w u l d have t o be negative since
1
=l).
kle s h a l l therefore think of &a t n c o d n g proton a s a box of parfons sharing the momntm and p r a c t i c a l l y f r e e ,
Another m y t o laok a t t h i s is t o take a
d y n a c v % w of the parts i n the r e a t system and ass-
f i n i t e energy of gater-
action amng p a r t s s o as time goes on they change t h e i r m m n t a , a r e created or m i h i l a t e d , etc., i a f l n i t e tims.
But m\tfiag a t large .siomntm F these t i e s
a r e d i l a t e d by the r e l a t i v i s t i c t r a x l s f o m t l o n s o as P r i s e s things chmge m r e and w r e slowly, m t i l u l t i m t e l y they appear not t o be i n t e r a c t i n g a t a l l . men the proton is h i t by the photon the interaction operator J U couples t o one nearly) ntum p2 S pl + partoa o r anather and kao&s it t o a new s t a t e of f;f the parton had
2
m we would expect a r a t e propoxtiojlonsll t o
g
Parron Model
I35
( t h e f a c t o r s 1 / 2 5 m d 1/2E a t e included because of the n o w a l i z a t i o n s of
(%l
2
I n f a e t , due t o t h e i n t e r a c t i o n energies asavmed f i n i t e , t h e
and KpV).
e n e x e loser i 8 n o t just t h a t f o r a f r e e p a r t i c l e but d i f f e r s from i t by an m k n o m (but. f i n i t e which m y vary with
X,
etc.)
Fox s p i n zero partons /&l2
-
(plu
+
P~,) (plv
+
pZv)
For erpin 112 partons
y2+ ~
1/2 s p ( v l + m) .iP
m
(2 PIw
+
2 Plv PZu
I Y ~ )
- 2 6uv(~1*q))
(27.3)
(We s h a l l c a l c u l a t e f o r s p i n 112, j u s t s t a t e r e s u l t s f o r s p i n Q,)
tkfngs easy we v L l l omit all t e r w i n q by gauge invariance. cfrc-tances
W
Thus i n
can w r i t e p
l
Ir:
in K
U'J
To m k e
because we know haw t o g e t them
put plv i n place of pZV. I n Our l i m i t i n g
= 5P
Y
t o an e x c e l l e n t approxinaatian where P
M
is
the four-momntm of t h e proton ( s t r i c t l y i t i s v a l i d f o r t h e z component only,
b u t we have seen t h a t implies i t f o r t h e t component El
-
&E; mid t h e traunsverse
coaponents being only f i n i t e a r e r e l a t i v e l y s m l l ) . Therefore i f f (x)dx
g.
a m b e r of partons with azomentum between x and &dx
each weighed
by t h e charge squared ( i n w i t n of e l e c t r o n &arge) we have
Kyy
-;
(4 P
, l
2 Pv W2 - 4 6 w v M W I)
( t h e f i r s t l/& eomen from t h e normalizing f a c t o r s 2E/2E1). we have (6~t.q)' -ni2 -6
-
Mv goes t o
with -q2
-
25 ( P e q )
+ q2 + c2
- m2 - b ;
2 Hvx t h i s becomas 2 Mv (g-X)
Xnaide the d function but as
+
-*
-
and P a q
( f i n i t e ) o r nearly
1 6 (&-X), 6 (2 MV (5-X)) = Therefore we have, i n t e g r a t i n g t h e 6 f m c t i o n , 2Mv
for large
V
and we have functions of x
2
-q /2Nv only.
I f we w e d s e a l a r partons, the formula f o r vU2 i s =changed
but Wl
0.
Zf the f x a c t i a n of the partonr, hi&a s p i n l / 2 (weighed by t h e i r @harm sgusred) a t momentum x i e v(%) we get U
2 =changed,
ZMWl
-
y(x)
f( X ) .
The r a t i o
(r
R 8
2 ' i . O
O t
i n the s c a l i n g l f d t wouZd be
In the r e g i m s t u d i e d R is of order '18 2 110 s o s c a l a r partons,
y
is l a s s than .2, not m y
A nrucfi w r e l i k e l y hypothesis is
The value of R reminbng today e x p e r i m n t a l l y bciag due Ca our h a d n g n o t enough e n e r w and
to be f u l l y i n t h e s c a l i n g l i m i t .
E.g.,
R
q Z / t would a l s o f i t
the data and give zero i n the s c a l i n g l i m i t ,
This i~a very profound c o n c l u s ~ nabout t h e s t r w t u r e of t h e u n h r l y i n g theory f o r hadrons.
We m w t mtch t o s e e i f R r e a l l y does approach zero a s the
s c a l i n g l i m i t is reached.
If charged partoas a l l c a r r i e d the f t n z d a n e a l charge 2e then charge squarred i s l f n our wits and thus we could say m l y 18% of t h e momntuae, is c a r r i e d by charged partons i n t h e proton (because i x f ( z t ) r t t m i n h r , 82X would be c a r r i e d by n e u t r a l s ,
m
. l 8 t .@l)
- the
%%.is 18% is s u r p r i s i n g l y sstall.
If t h e partans a r e quarks and c a r r y charges l i k e k 2 1 3 ~ 2 1 / 3 the percentage o f wmntuar c a r r i e d by t h e quslxks could be fiie;her,
We s h a l l dShicuss such a wile1 i n
Illore d e t a i l , but i t turne o u t even then i t is necessary to a s e u m s o m t h i n g e l s e n e u t r a l c a r r i e s p e r t of the momentum.
The i d e a s leading t o the s c a l i n g f o m u l a e (27,5)
e r e very r e l i a b l e ,
By
m k i n g f u r t h e r ~tssumptlonsabout the wee region we can understsnd o t h e r aspect8 of
and
kl;?.
It muat be realized we a r e now elaborating on our o r i g i n a l parton
i d e a deve1oping them f u r t h e r t o wderstand m r e f e a t u r e s of the f ( x ) curve, data f o r vW;? s e e m t o approach a constant (,32) as x
J.
ate
O which nteansr t h a t f(x)
would go as , 3 2 1 ~showing a nrem n u a e r of partons r i s i n g as
X
f a l l s i n t o the
wee regian (@U& t h a t the na&er a f wee partons is f i n i t e and independent of P,
and t h e m a n t o t a l nu*er with P),
of partons i n a stata? of raanrentuta P r i s e s logarithmically
% f a i s not e n t i r e l y uaexpected, i t is the s a m a s the distrZbutian of
products i n hadronic c o l l i ~ i o n s . The way t h i s appears t o happen can be gathered by studping the f i e l d theory equations a t high energy, and a l s o the perturbation
t h e o v of: larelshlstrdlung. i n a dk/E =
dPZ
I n the l a t t e r case n e u t r a l parricfedt a r e generated -+
dxlx distribution,
These neutral@ can generate
p a i r s eo the srnall x region contains l a r g e a d nearly equal n d e r s of p e r t i c l e a and a n t i p a r t i c l e s ,
The f i e l d equation approach suggests the
thing; and
S-
f u r a e r t h a t the law region is @aerated i n higher order perturbation from the higher m m a t a by a s e r i e s of cascades x
-c X'
-, X" going d m i a x.
fn either
cakte we conclu& the character of the pczift3 will be as a whole n e u t r a l and therefore the sby other m-
f o r proton ttnd neutron,
n e s e expectations have been made
also, f o r e x e l e L ethe , dxlx leads t o a constant cross s e c t i o n
f o r v l r t w l photons (of filred but l a r g e , negative mws sqruared),
That these
cross section8 should be a constant is elepected fram cmsidexations t h a t these photms have an aaplitudcr t o he v i r t u a l fiadrons ( l i k e the? constant cross s e c t i s n a ( t h e w g i c word 9-ron" the s a m f o r proton m d neutron.
p ) and
hadrgns give
is w a d t o "elrl>lainf' t h i s ) ,
'Thus we expect vW
a s x -c O aa 2n t o equal vW2~ ;tadeed they t u n t out t o do; both f(x) f o r p and a approach the same .32/x fox
smll a.
We a l s o lmar experimentally t h a t a t q2
The facc t h a t f ( x ) s e e m t o go as , 3 2 1 ~as x
0 -c
Q
TP
t o 32 a t 16 &V.
O i q L i e a that the t o t a l
cross s e c t i o n f o r v i r t w l photons of energy v on protans is a conetant a s energy goes t o does, x
f o r fixed w d l a r g e negative q2, j u s t as t h e r e a l photon cross s e c t i o n
We c m expect, a s long a s we a r e an the high s i d e of t h e wee region, t h a t
b/P v l t h b large enou*
Eenw the tr-vecee
t h a t , sar our I s a a e u r e m t s t e l l us, f(x)
virtual photon c r a s s sect&= $8
,321~~
i n the aealing I f a t .
And for x on the h i & s i d e of t h e wee region (-q
2
large
At t h i s point we m y well g m s s (these considerations a r e independent of t h e parton m&l) *at
happens f o r v l a r g e b u t -qL i s n o t l a r g e enough t h a t
-q 2 /ZHv is f a r enough o u t of the wee region
l &VIP.
t h e total, photo-cross s e c t i o n i s independent of v.
Ve know f o r q2
-
O
For o t h e r -qL, t h e tarreliable
2 2 YDH would give a f a c t o r -m /(q -m$
2 2 2 i n t h e amplitude o r 11/(l-q /m ) ) i n t h e P cross s e c t i o n t i m e a v independent t e r n ( l a r g e v>. %Fa i s c l e a r l y wrong f o r P
l a r g e -q 2 ( f a r from t h e p pole) f o r i t f a l l s as (-q2)-2, we have gust seen Ss experimatalliy found, above,
i n s t e a d o f (-q2)-I
But we can c e r t a i n l y guess
t h a t , f o r each -q2 t h e croas s e c t i o n i s c o n s t w . ~but dependent on -q
-
at -q
2
.
We do not a t present know C(-q
4n2e2 c(-~'),
as
2
) except f o r q2
m
2
f o r l a r g e v,
O and l a r g e
We need a good theol-y f o r t h i s functian. t h e a m b e r of partons is i n f i n i t e , t h e laonrentum contained i n
Althau*
them is f i n i t e , of course, because t h e total. nrsaatuan o f a l l p a r t a m n e u t r a l and charged is 1, ( u n i t s of P),
We have f o r t h e wmrztm c a r r i e d by a l l charged
partons weighed by e2 0
F o m d a for R @e may g e t
calculating a
fdea of haw R behaves a s we approach t h e ecafing limit by d i r e c t l y i n t h i s region,
kle work i n t h e system i n which q is
pure space-like
P
U.
q
m
(E, P,00)
=
(0, -2Px, 0, 0)
%v
4,qv - 2
Use Equation (27.4) with a l l q, put back i n t o
2
= diag. (1, 0, -l, -1)
Nar t o get ns
r(C-r)-k)).
(the expression f n the 6 function becomes ( 4
coqonent af both sides; however, i f the HIS were exact the
we want the t
z coargonent would exactly veulish ( f r m gauge invariance) .To avoid e r r o r s of t-z, v
differencer of large q w t i t i e s we take p
piu pZv +
a
t-z so 6
)1v
vmisks,
- plZ) (cZ - pZS) ( t h i ~is equivalent t o replacing the polerizatiaa
( E ~
of the photon e B = (1. 0, 0, O) by eB'
. NW
r e s u l t by gauge invarimce)
; (l,
1, 0, a); we should g e t the same
pZz rune backwards so cl
-
But pIz runs Eamard ea E 1 Plz 2(2x -{)p. 2 2 Here kL+m is the man perpendicular mnsnttlm plus the -ss2
- pZz - 2 [pZzI -C
-12
, &2* 2 p
of the partoo (at E),
a a t e v a r t h a t mans, but a t l e a s t i t i a the square of same fgnlnite energy.
as
and R a r e given by
This e x p l l c i t dewadence an mL is arrmeous.
The deviations i n the parton
w d e l of calculations u s h g f r e e partons a t e probably t o set 215 (a bbdlsxg energy correction) uncertainties oa a l l e f f e c t i v e parton Basses, the e r r o r c-B
i s assudmg i n cl
- plz
f r e e parton and a s t w r e cmplieated,
&at
E
1
Xn t h i s s p e c i a l case
,is j u s t the k i n e t i c energy of the
When operatots involve d / d t i n Schroedinger
perturbation theary t h e i r exact expreasisn is u s w l l y m r e cmplieated than j u s t the b h e t l c energy operator,
The fomula f o r B should be
The elr;pected f a l l i n g trend with l/(-q
the e r r o r s a r e large.
' l I f we estgmate *
hadronic colXisione, a d m 2
2
is s o a m l ) , we find R
B * .3
2
) is not evident i n the data, but
.25(GeV)
2
indepndent of x as i n
of the sattte order (else we could not explain why
* (2t46)/(-q2)
; f o r -q2
7 (near center of data)
1 &A/? not unreasonrrtrle c q a r e d t o the average
.l.@.
Photon-Hadr~nInreractl'ans Lecture 29
We c m get so=
q u a l i t a t i v e ideas of t h e region near x = 1 by f i r s t etudying the
e x t r e m cease x = I, the e l a s t i c form f a c t o r s , a t l a r g e coordinate system with q = (0, -Q, m m n t m of t h e proton
IJI
ii
opposite d i r e c t i o n ,
0, 0) a pure space-like vector.
(E, P, 0, 0) must have P
the proton has mmantm P'= 'b: 4 ql
vl-r
We take t h e
= (E,
-P, O I Q)
Q I 2 , a f t e r the c o l l i s i o n with z component i n t h e
For l a r g e Q, hence l a r g e P, we can describe t h e i n i t i a l
s t a t e of t h e proton a s an m l i t u d e f o r various configurations ( i n W
Pp t h e
suppose f o r example, the canflguratlon contains two non-ee
X,
kL).
Let
partone and two
wee, and draw a picture:
Before
Figure 29 ,l
low we ask t h a t the f i n a l s t a t e ( t h e ""after" "piere) t h a t is, EL f a c t o r
-
be only a proton
-P I " a f t e r s t a t e t f > ,the (complex conjugate o f )
q l i t u d e t h a t t h e a f t e r s t a t e appears i n t h e proton wave function,
But a l e f t
arovlng proton can never ( f o r l a r g e P) look l i k e the a f t e r p i c t u r e because i t contains a backward nulving parton (x2), (and any estimate of its =ss square i s 2
order P
.
requiring order
binding energy contributions t o get the ,ss2
dovn
2 t o N 1. P Thw I n s o f a r e s the proton looka l i k e " b e f ~ r e ' 9 t contributes very l i t t l e
t o e l m t i c scattering. *ere
To s c a t t e r e l a s t i c a l l y we nrust s t a r t with a configuration
one parton has nearly a l l t h e m e n t u r n , x = J and a l l the r e s t are wee,
say below l / P .
Before
Figure 29.2
Parran Model Now t h e siningle f a s t one is reversed by the i a c o a n g photon, t h e energy
is n o t changed
@U&,
and the f i n a l configuration is possible f o r a proton
beeawe wee partons (those with absolute pz f i n i t e say below order l GeV) can ga backwards a s w e l l
ss forwards.
Therefore t h e s c a t t e r i a g e l i t u d e ( f o m
f a c t o r ) is proporrlonal t o t h e square of the ~ l i t u d et h a t a proton looks l i k e '%afore1\ hence proportional t o t h e p r o b a b i l i t y t h a t the proton has a l l partons but one i n the wee region. We now s e e q m l i t a t i v e l y why t h i s should be e o m gnverse pcxnirer of 9 i n the following m n n e r .
If t h e bramW&lung a n a l y s i s of the "sea" "(dx/x)
region has any q u a l i t a t i v e r e a l i t y we can judge t h e p r o b a b i l i t y t h a t no p a r t i c l e s have t h e i r x above no o f order l/Q t o be e-= above t h i s smd c is 80-
where
n is
t h e mean n m b e r expected
e m s t a n t t o allow f o r correlritiona (unlike f i r s t order
b r e w t r a h l u n g which i s purely Poisson, perhaps each ""poton" could make two of some o t h e r o b j e c t , e t c . , s o t h a t the mm rider of p a r t i c l e s would be higher but proportional t o s o m vaguely defined "man n d e r of s t a r i s t i e a l l y indeprmdmt eventst"
).
Now we have seen, f o r smfl x a t f e a s t ,
another constant a I n xo where
X
1
- hence n,
R
gaea
the mean nvmber a b ~ v exo is a
o is s o w urnknm upper l i m i t where t h e dx/x i d e a s break down. m
%us f o r small enough xo, e-"
t i e s a power of xo,
v a r i e s as e r p (ca (h
- I n xl))
That is, t h e p r o b a b i l i t y no Lfsea'"articles
m
B
cmstant
are outside
the wee region f a l l s a s a power of Q, There m y be so=
s p e c i a l partons t o m k e up t o t a l quantum a m b e r s whieh
a r e not parts. of the s e a which mwt a l s o be i n t h e wee region, s t u d i e s of the f i e l d equations a s well
But s c a l i n g
0 t h t~h e~o r e t i c a l a r g m n t e ( r e l a t e d
( ~ 3
t o kgge-type behavior) suggest very s t r o n g l y t h a t they would show behavior the f o m
X'
dxlx where
> 0,
of
and thus t h e i r p r o b a b i l i t y t o be found i n t h e
region belaw xo would alsto f a l l a s a power o f xo, We conclude t h a t the p r o b a b i l i t y t h e proton looks l i k e our parton near \
X
l with a l l the o t h e r s below s a m low linait
X
f a l l s a s a pawer of xor say
xi.
In partPcular then f o r x wee of order l / Q , we f l n d the p r o b a b i l i t y varying as Q-, Thus the f o r a f a c t o r GM of a proton (and GE a l s o , s e e belaw) should f a l l a s a power of Q, Q - ~ , Experiraentally y is probably a l i t t l e Larger than 4,
The f a c t t h a t the f o m f a c t o r f a l l s toward zero as Q proton (as P
+ W)
has a zero a w l i t u d e t o appear
=am t h a t a
-c
a ssingle partan.
mia
m y be becawe no d n ~ z eparton has the precise quantunt n d e r s of t h e proton, but even i f i t did, a = r e cogent reason is t h a t the probability of finding a p a r t m without o t h e r f i e l d s generated by i n t e r a c t i o n fro= f t (represented by t;he s e a d x l x ) is zero, (Just m
it3
expected fram t h e theory of bre-aahlung).
our a n a l y s i s of the r a t i o R
os/ot described i n the previovs l e c t u r e c m
be aas w e l l applled t o t h e e l a a t i c piece x
*ere
2 LA + m2
2 d is the value f o r the s i n g l e parton with nearly a l l the menturn.
But t h i s r a t i o
(M
-
expressed i n t e r m of GE, GM is s i m l y
proton mass).
for large q
2
experiment.
1, We therefore find
.
Thus we expect GE/GM t o approach a constant
-
2
(L,
+ m2
215
i/k
A g r e a t p r a b l ~ a ti s f a m d when we estimate the constant from
I f GM*lrGe
disturbingly small!
2 2.79we find (liA+m2 t
Y
But data a t q2
about .6 (and f a l l i n g ? ) s o (k,
2
+ m2
&l1
.l1 ( G ~ V I ~
1
2.6 even shows GE/CM is l e s s than 1,
2
All
c ,041
Haw we can s e e haw f(x) should vary f o r x near 1, say
1 iy with y staall.
X
X.
Let is f i n d the t a t a l probabilfty that: x exceeds X. -y i . e , again f i n d one parton with nearly a l l the m m n t m ,
y whi&
kte
f(x)dx* tJt?
=Ugt
t o t a l mnrc?;ntiun of a l l
That is mat the s a w a s the probrilbility t h a t none
the olfhenit c a o t exceed y ,
can exceed x
the!
-Y
worked out a s YmY, but a 1 i t t X a coneidexation of the
problela soon s k w s t h a t Z t does vary with the s a m pswer, but with a dff f e r e n t constant i n f r o n t , o r a l t e m a t i v r ? l y one d e t a i l t o check f C,)
( m i s is w e t e a s i l y seen by C B work ~
Wenca
ot
kind of d i m n s i o n e l analysis;
out t h e case of a &x/x Poisson d i s t r i b u t i o n i n
Parron Model f o r emall y, o r
f o r x a e a r l.
That is, we expect the power law of the e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g t o he
l, In p a r t i c u l a r we r e l a t e d t o t h e power law o f t h e bebavior o r f ( x ) near x 3 expect f [X) a [l X) or. a l i t t l e higher, Data is not i n disagreentent with
-
this,
(Thia r e l a t i o n was f i r s t published by W e l l snd Yan.)
Can we extend these ideas t o g e t s e m understilnding of why t h e
Reeanances.
2
resmances f a l l with about the s a m power of Q f o r l a r g e Q a s does t h e e l a s t i c (Here we a r e studying t h e region l a r g e q2,2Nv
peak?
:M
+ 2Hv
= b?
-
2
3 -q2,more
precisely
Perhaps i t is b e t t e r t a franLly t u r n t h e
(-q ) f i n i t e . )
q u ~ s t i a n&out the o t h e r way rlnd ask what the f a c t t h a t the reaonancee f a l l off a s t h e e l a e t S c peak with -q
resanmces
2
tells
uct
about the wave function of these
.
I f we e x c i t e say t h e A
C
our p i c t u r e again c m a o t look lLke f i g u r e 29.1
'+
f o r the "'after" p i c t u r e could n o t be a d w d n g rapidly t o t h e l e f t becausle i t contains s o w partons going i n t h e wrong d i r e c t i o n .
a s i n f i g u r e 29.2,
We a u s t b s t e a d bave
but t h i s time fslatead of asking whether t h e last p i c t u r e
looks l i k e e protonswe k s k w i t h what amplitude doen i t leak 1Lke a A*? again expect a 6'
t o bave a sea region, e t c ,
by a f a c t o r p4'2(in
non-wee parton,
, and
Me
t o have a d i f f i c u l t y maaured
amplitude, f o r a proton 97/2)to
a p p a r with a s i n g l e
We conclude from e x p e d m n t t h e y' prob&1y equals y
can probably invent a p o s t e r i o r i a r g m n t : t o j w t i f y t h i s ,
- and
(For exaarple* the
s e a may be very e i d l a r i n the two c m e s becausse they a r e generated by t h e saw
- t h a t is,
partm
the f a c t o r =asurea
t h e chance t h i s parton is bare of non-wee p a r t i c l e s is what
- and i t is the aame parton
Fn e i t h e r ctlse.)
B e wee partons
l e f t aver from t h e o r i g i n a l r i g h t nroving protons have s n l y a c e r t a i n a a r p l i t u h t o be 2n t h e c o r r e c t proportions (of n d e r s non-9 dependent raomnta, etc.) appropriate t o a l e f t - m v i n g proton
.
3.
t o a Ll
- and a
X t i s the r a t i o of these non*
CO be
d i f f e r e n t a q l i t u d e t o b e appropriate
dependeat a q l i t u d e s (aquared) which
rlc?ter&nes t h e ultireate r a t i o o f t h e p r o b a b i l i t y of producing bLh+t o protaa a t 2
large Q
.
(Xt is always possible i n p r i n c i p l e of course t h a t f o r some p a r t i c u l a r
rescmance t h i s a~tplituldei s zero and such a resonarsee would f a l l f a s t e r with Q than t h e e l a s t i e peak, ) TZlese r e l a t i o n s of power laws f o r e l a s t i c peak, resonanees, and ~ y m p t o t i c f(x) a r e s o i n t e r e s t i n g t h a t i t is i a p o r t m t t o n o t i c e t h a t they can be expressed i n a general p r i n c i p l e (I am stron@y indebted t o J.D. Bjorken f o r d i s c w s i o n s on t h i s idea) q u i t e a p a r t from any parron theoxy i n t e r p r e t a t i o n ,
Stated i n
t h i s way they a r e seen t o be r a t h e r profound and represent a fuldaatental new property of high energ)r c o l l i s i o n s ( f o r corresponding r e l a t i o n s a r e expected m l a t i n g exclugive and i n c l u s i v e hadron reactions a t high energy) , Suppose we p l o t uW2 f o r a given l a r g e q2 against
<- -
ZHu(l-X) 2 ( X is near l and Znv * H and 2 l-Xa r e just proportional. Ve f i n d a s e t a f resanances a t appropriate Mx
2 M -q (l-X)
2 -q ). We note the s c a l e of: H
and the t a i l of t h e "background1'cum (l-x)'-'dx
NW when we increase q 2
as (q I-'
2
o r (-q2)7
(<-M2)'-ld(~;)*
2 a l l the resonances f a l l (but s t a y i n t h e a m e place' Mx ),
a s we have seen, but the sire of the '%background1' canre
a l s o f a l l s a s (q2j'.
-
( a t a given
That i a t h e "bsckground" (by background I mean t h e high x
t a l l of t h e a c a l i n g region ftrnction f ( X ) ) bear8 a fixed r a t i o t o t h e reaotlancea, P 2 I t is n o t possible by going t o higher q (or int hadronie c o l l i e l o n e t o higher s ) t o s e p a r a t e even w r e c l e a r l y t h e resonance@ from t h e backgrowd, nor do t h e resonance8 f a l l l n t o the background md get l o s t .
Put another way, the back-
ground c m be c o n s i s t e n t l y dewed ae due t o ovigrlapping reeonances o r t a i l s of reeonanees i t s e l f and a l l reeonmees u l t i m t e l y f a l l o f f t h e saw w a y (as a p m e r of q
2
2
as q
cowlsultantary
increases).
wily@
Bohr would l i k e t h i s , he would say t h e r e are two
of viewing t h e background, a s continuum singLa p a r t i c l e
s t a t e s leadfng t o ~ c a l f n gexpectations, o r arr l a r g e a d e r r a of resonanme
- and
nature conspires to make i t r ioapessible t o decide i n the interatrildiat;e r e d o n (large: H
- 2)which .i
correct.
2
)
Parton Model Lecture 30
We w i l l ar&e t h e a s s m p t i o n t h a t f o r any s t a t e (e.g. p o r A ) a9 mmntum Q inerernes the d i s t r i b u t i o n =ng
wee x
(m
f i n i t e motaenturn) approaches a dclfinitcl
Rather, =ore e x p l i c i t l y f o r aux c m e , we? a s s u m
d f s t r i b u t i m independent of Q.
t h a t the anplitude f o r t h e proton t o be a s i n g l e parton and a given d i s t r i b u t i o n aarclng were raaolkentrnn ( e , g, helm 2 &V)
and nothing i n between f a l l s somehow with
Q but the distxgbution amag the weres approaches a d e f b i t e a s y w t o t e , (e.g. a w l i t u d e f o r no w e e l q l i t u d e f o r one of nromntm 300 b V / m l i t & e f o r two a t
100 MeV and 400 MeV e t c . b e c m conbstmt r a t i o s ) ,
1, weee a t Ewmnta k ' s sf proton a t Q>= F (Q)f (kfs) P psi
( t h e index 1 i n d i c a t e s parton e w e ) and s i l n i l a r l y f o r a resonance,
Hence the
s c a t t e r i n g of a photon, which turns a r o m d the f a s t parton from Q t o Qv(e.l~;.
tn a coordinate system &ere q
U
(Q-Q\ 0 , 0, W')).
The a q l i t u d e is proportional t o
We e r ~ p i l i e i t l ysuppose t h e l a s t f a c t o r i e not zero. OP
q u m t m n-er
(e.g.
(For c e r t a i n resonance@,
Z spin) reasons i t ndght be zero, those, m y f a l l f a s t e r
w l c h Q, but we study the ones which a r e nor s p e c i a l i n t h i s way,)
The answer
mwt be r e l a r i v l s t i c a l l y S n v a r i m t , however, and thus be a function only of q2
at.Xenee
F
P
(9) Pb(Q1) is a flmction of W' only, from which we can
deduce t h a t both F (Q) end FA(Q) must be of t h e form l / ( 2 ~ ) ' / ~ (a constant P can be abaorbed i n t h e second factor).
m- aw. p where s(p, b)
-+
-2 i
A
( q 2 ) q / 2 a ( p , A)
Ja,iOfAif-E>
d
3
dapeade, on t h e s t a t e s p, A, but not an q
2
.
Photon-EdronInteractions
146
I f two s t a t e s have d i f f e r e n t powers of Cj i n t h e i r P(Q) must be orthogonal i n t h e sense j ~ ~ { l r ) f ~ ( - d3k k)
O
then they
- usually because
of
d i f f e r e n t q w n t m n a e r s , l i k e char@ strangeness o r isospin {or z angular m m n t w ) i n t h e wee s y s t e a , Ttre p r i n c i p l e discussed a t t h e end of the previous l e c t u r e very l i k e l y applies t o high energy hadxron c o l l i s i o n s also; although not our d i r e c t i n t e r e s t i n t h i s course, Z w i l l b r i e f l y o u t l n e hov i t &ght w r k there. t h+B Consider an exclusive reaction ( a t fixed o r zero mmntsan t r a n s f e r Z
G
=+
Resonance X, where W, B, C, a r e fixed,
e.m. be p and t h e outgoing wmentlm, a f C
Let t h e incaning w m n t a i n the
- - pc
pn, s
kp2 goes t o i n f i n i t y ;
snd imagine we measure the ~ s s i n gmass of the resonance by
(Ph + Pg 2
-
-MA
2
sfl-X)
=
CHBZ-~t.
+ MA2
-$fl s (1-X) .
-+
PR
Thw p l o t resonance data as l? m
2 , of course, but say a s s'~(d)d ( a is negatfve);
As s v a r i e s resonance@ s tay a t fixed
tbir s i z e goes d m v e w l i k e l y a s a power of a ,
a s expeeted f o r exclusive reactions, where a is the l e a s t negative p o s s i b i l i t y Ear
an exchmge of s o m t h i n g t h a t a c c o w t s f o r the q u m t u n w b e r changes fro= A t o Bat s i n c e we are not r e a l l y looking a t the products as t m i n c l w i v a reaction &ere,
It
5 this
t h i s s c a l i n g region near
X
f o r x near l,
must go
X
&v. Hence
only.
2
= l w f l l go i n t o the resonmces f o r large l4 only i f
e a ~ ( ~ 2 j d n=Z s'~(s(1-x))de(l-X) f m c t i o n P(.(%-1))
can be thougtxt of
has been a r g w d , (R.P. Felyn-,Fhys,
L e t t , 23 1415 (1969)) the grclbabillty should be a f m c t i o n of
C,
W
1s a function of (~(2-x))'-'
X
m l y , not o f s .
Hence t h l s
and the scaled r e s u l t goes
M
(l-x)*-'dx
(There are s i t u a r f o n s , f o r e x m l e , where C and A a r e both proton@
t h a t 10: is t e e a i c a l l p hard t o g e t t o h i & enough x t o avoid c o n t d a a t i c m of p's disintegzrareb from o t h e r hadron resona~lcesC',
etc., but these m e t e r s cannot
canerem us i n d e t a i l here; t b e r a s u l t has n a t bem r e a d i l y checked, therefore .)
r i z e what we know o r surrnfse about v? RegLon
Z)
h r g e v , laxse -q
2
2
but -q /W
x m&, cailled f@).
5
X
2
(-Q /v
2
and W1 i n the high v rct&on.
fhite, )Wl.
2ml i a r a function
of
2
v
Region 11)
Large v , fixed -q
Repion III)
2 Large v, l a r g e -q but f i n i t e
88
-+
W.
ZMv C-M~
(The l a s t f a c t o r 2Hv is the normalization from :nd
2
(-q )
.
t o dxl..
In order t h a t t h e three regions f i t together we have,
(X;
1x1
(XI; I I I )
f o r smZl
X,
for large
eq2,
f (X) goes a s a/x 2 g(-q ) goes as a.
(a
.32)
f o r x near 1, f(x) goes a s h(1-xly-l -y 4 or 5 2 2 2 2 1-1 for large h (Hx -H ) goea a s A(% -M )
M:-2,
In region I we e x p e c t s l a t t a f a l l w%tb tnereasing I n region I X we expect uslot to approach soas V
+
v as
11-0o r l/(-q 21.
f i n i t e L i m i t &pending on -q
-, (This mans vW2 i s f i n i t e , M2 is of the sme order
asl
2
2
2
(-q /v )W
I
but fs n o t equal t o i t ,)
In region ZIf ve expect os/et t o f a l l with increasing 2 2 I n the s p e c i a l region o f srrmll q2: W2 -q Wl/v + order q 4 / v ;
v as 1/v.
2
as= q ,
f a l l i n g c o e f f i c i e n t (q2)-'/
2
( a l q W).I n t h e diecussion o f the previous l e c t u r e
we saw p m e r e where y could depend on the q w t u r n n m b e r s of the wee group, like t o t a l isospio, m g u l a r lamntum e t c .
and there is a lowest one. dfscrolte; V
-y0
y
These a r e d i s c r e t e s o t h e yiVe are d i s c r e t e
Emever, t b r e is trrmsverse mlaentm which is not
could ctepend on the transverse liloentraxt of the 2
+ ylkA
f"asl~parton
s a y as
s o the r e s u l t i s
Naturally we should l i k e t o ga f u r t h e r and find o u t xnortr. about whaP qumtw
Photon-Badron Interactions n u d e r s t h e partons c a r r y .
& i t t u r n s o u t from present e x p e r i m n t s only a few
things can be l e a r n e d , but f u t u r e e x p e r l m n t s c m add i n f a m t i o n which g r e a t l y r e s t r i c t s the possibilities.
We d i s c u s s t h i s by choosing an example, t h a t
charged parcons c a r r y t h e quanturn n m b e r s of quarks.
(Zn such a model Gell-Mann's
equal time c u r r e n t tlomutation r e l a t i o n s a r e a u t o m t i c a l l y s a t i s f i e d . )
We a r e
the t h r e e quark m d e l , t h e n m b e r of quarks m y be, indeed must be,
not =king inffnite,
h e is i m d i a t e l y s t r u c k w i t h t h e question a s t o whether our explanation of s c a l i n g i a p o s s i b l e a t a l l i f t h e partons do n o t have i n t e g e r charges.
The
i d e a was t h a t the outgoing parton (now quark) could escape without f u r t h e r l a r g e (as P) i n t e r a c t i o n t o u l t i m a t e l y r r m l v e i t s e l f i n t o an outgoing bundle of
hadrons
.
But i t fs a quark (knowing no low energy hadrons a r e of charge 213 say) i t cilnnol t u r n i n t o hadrons u n l e s s i t picks up t h e e x t r a l 1 3 charge by dragglng along another parton quark.
I f t h i s e x t r a parton i s from t h e ongoing ones o f Itlomntm
of o r d e r P t h e m m n t m changes ( d t r e c t l o n B t o A) would be of o r d e r P and t h e a s u q t i o n t h a t bending f o r c e s a r e small, apparently required i n o u r d e r i v a t i o n , wauld f a i l ,
QR t h e o t h e r hand, i t is p o s s i b l e peffiaps t h a t t h e e x t r a quarks
a r e found m n g t h e wee partons, which a r e n a t u r a l t o my hadron wave f w c t i o n and s i n c e hadrons golng i n d i r e c t i o n A or B s h a r e t h e s a m wee region they could exchmgo quarks t h e r e , =king
up t h e necessary i n t e g e r s .
T h i @ is n o t c l e a r l y
s a t Z s f a c t o r y but i t is an e x c i t i n g adventure t o t r y the i d e a t h a t charged partons a r e simply quarks, s e a consequences, devise experiments t o test them; and i f they a r e found t o succeed, t o r e t u r n with more z e s t t o the q w s t i o n o f how Nature
mwt then be r e s o l v i n g t h e apparent: paradox among: a.
Partons c a r r y quark quantum numbers
b.
Wadrms do n o t
c.
S c a l i n g works,
Ln t h i s s p i r i t we look t o discovering by what m a n s we can check ( a ) .
At
the very l e a s t we a r e giving an e x a w l e of how experirnenr could lead t o f u r t h e r i d e n t i f i c a t i o n of the character of partons. To describe the parton d i s t r i b u t i o n i n a proton we would have s i x functions, u(x) d(x)
= No, of up quarks with coomntm dam
=
Similarly
<(X),
"
z(x) and
It
$1
X
to *dx
if tt
8s
art?, t h e n d e r s of anti-up, a n t i - d m and
anti-strange quarks with momntum between
X
and x+dx i n t h e proton.
The t o t a l charge on a proton is +l s o
The stranrjfeness i s zero so 1 fs(x) s(x)]dx Q.
-
-
These equations have the s o l u t i o n fu(x)
- -u(x)]dx
= 2
That i s , the n e t number of each kind of quark is j u s t the number o f t h a t k i d S-n the simple n o n - r e l a t i v i s t i c $-quark model,
(X) from 2W1 P ( o r vM2/x) is t h e nuabet of each kind weified by t h e square of t h e charge:
The observed function f
hence
Measurements on the ep s c a t t e r i n g of course give us only t h i s sum and we cannot e x t r a c t the s e p a r a t e t e r m from t h i s alone, neutron s c a t t e r i n g too,
On t h e o t h e r hand we have d a t a on
The neutron i s given by the same f o m d a except u(x)
would n6w be the nu&er of up-quarks in t h e neutron,
However, by ieospin
r e f l e c t i o n the neutron functions a r e got from chose of the proton by replacing u by d, d by u.
Thus, i f u(x) c o n t l n w s t o b e a s defined, the nuraber of
Photon-HadronInteractions
150
" u p s 8 9 n t h e proton is a l s o t h e n d e r of d m s i n t h e neutron, we have 1
f n (X)
(U(X)+ ; ( X ) 1 +
4
(d ( x ) + x ( x )
We have d a t a on both these functions,
+ $ (S (x)+F(x) )
The r a t i o fn/f
P
behaves l l k e
It has been suggested t h a t possibly f I f l-x f a l l i n g t o zero a s X + O, We n p s e e i m d i a t e l y t h a t t h i s is impossible i f charged partoas a r e quarks; s i n c e
u(x),
et^,
;;(X)
, are
c m n o t f a l l below .25,
a21 p o s i t i v e E I f
The o r i g i n a l d a t a
only went up t o &out x -. .8 and hall f a l l e n t o perhaps , 3 s o ' 2 5 was a possible fixnft a s
X -+
1 but we have s i n c e learned t h a t there w a s a ariatake i n the computer
p r o g r m and i t is c l o s e r t o .4 f o r
X
near l,
However, J u s t f o r an exercise, & a t could we deduce i f f / f was shorn t o be n P jwt 114 m x + l ? That m a n s d ( x ) f a l l s t o zero f a s t e r than u(x) a s x I. This -+
would r e s u l t i f we supposed t h a t t h e .r ( i n (q2)""y o r (l-xly-') t o t a l i s o s p i n zero is e m l l e r than the
y
f o r wee partone of
f o r i s o s p i n one (only one non-ee
Then t h e leadin@ t e r n ( l a w s t y) would require t h a t t b e f a s t parton
parton).
have the s m e i s o s p i n a s t h e proton, up-quark only (since t h e wees a r e i s o s p i n zero),
However, i n t h a t case t h e p r o b & i l i t y of e x c i t i n g t h e A resonance (of
isospfn 3/21 would f a l l f a s t e r than t h e e l m t i c
peak f o r one can only make a
A f r o a wees with i s o s p i n m e (as t h e leading quark can only c o n t r i b u t e 1/21.
Thus we would expect: t h e
resonance t o f a l l off with q
2 f a s t e r than o t h e r s
(data is i n s u f f i c i e n t t o i n d i c a t e whether t h i s is t r u e o r f a l s e i n f a c t ) . f a l l s helm 1 i t "almost P t h a t alraost s u r e l y (?) the
We can a r g w ( i f partons a r e quarks) t h a t i f fn/f surely" fafa8 t o 114 a s f o l l w s : values f o r
y
for different q u m t m n d e r a
one t h e r e f o r e dominates. we have
We f i r a t ass-
for I
-
-t
and t h a t
F1rst mong t h e s i m l e r ones of zero s t r w g e n e s s quarks
O and yl f o r I
have eventually (as x
the wee a r e = e q u a l
l) a pure L
l. Hence depending on which is smaller we o.
(Z
o r pure I
l amng the wees.
For X
t h e non-rJee quark awt be (112, 112) or u, t h i s gives i m d i a t e l y f n /If P
O
2 (charge of d ) /(charge of u j 2 = 1/4.
If I
m
1 t h e non-vee quark can be u o r d (+l)d
with weight given by the appropriate Clebsch-Gordan c o e f f i c i e n t p = (@)U, n
m (0)d -
-
I-l)u therefore
Bexi= cn the a 8 a u q t i m of unequal y ' s e i t h e r f / 4 ox 312 is the limit ( t h e r e f o r e i f below 1, i t is 1/41.
(There i s t h e p o s s i b i l i t y t h a t the aan-ee
antlquark, i n char case i f Z
O dominates f / f
n
P
quark is an
213 but t h i s p o s s l b f l i t y is
considered very unlikely f o r p and a ) , Another s t a t e m y be wees of strangeness + l and the non-ee
pure
X t is
S,
unlikely t h i s is e a s i e r than t h e non-strange cme, b u t even ea the r a t i o would be one, hence excluded. Several ntodels have been m d e wlzich p r e d i c t r a t i o 8 b e l w l but: above l / 4 . A l l of these a s s u m t h e lack of c o r r e l a t i o n of f a s t quark quantum, nu&ers and wee s t a t e charlscter which
t~rz e x p l f c f t l y
a r g m d f o r , t h a t is, they i w l y a degeneracy
yl = Y0 i n which case, af course, o t h e r values a r e possible, The reader cm show t h a t the r a t i o of GM f a r proton and neutron c a m s o u t 2
2
= -1.4 a t q 0). P n 'fhe case t h a t t h e t o t a l iangular m o w n t m among the wees is zero c~houldibe t r i e d -2 f o r i s a s p i n zero weea, for: l a r g e -q
first.
(it s t a r t s a t p /p
E
Show a l s o t h a t GM f o r the proton is p o s i t i v e f o r l a r g e -q2.
s a na s i g n
change i n necessary as q2 r i s e s , which is s a t i s f a c t o r y became e x p e r i m n t a l l y
GM f o r t h e protan never seems t o f a l l t o zera, 2 G ~ I G-r ~O and G; is p o s i t i v e a t l a r g e -q
Isaspfn one f o r t h e weas gives
.
Lecture 32
Another i n t e r e a t l n g stuity is t h e t o t a l rnorrrenturn c a r r i e d by each kind o f quark, let U
I[ufx)
+ ;(.)]X
d~: D
m
[d(x) + ;i(n)lx dx;
S
m
+ z(x)]r
be t h e t o t a l laoaentm c a r r i e d by up (plus anti-up) quiatks, e t c . =an we knaw
/x
fp(x)dx
'18, I n fa(.)&
.l2 s o
dn
Now i f we a s s w e t h a t &ere a r e no n e u t r a l partons beside quarks (e.g. no "gluons")
a l l t h e eomntwn? of t h e proton i s quarks, we would have l
U + B + S
Solving these equations we have U unreasonable,
- that
m
,76,
This r e s u l t i o c l e a r l y
314 of the momentum of t h e non-strange object proton is t o
be found i n t h e s t r a n g e q w r k s , cannot be quarks
'21, D = .03, S
- t h e r e mst be
m i s t n d i c a t e s most s t r o n g l y t h a t a l l partons sernre n e u t r a l ones carrying =menturn,
say N.
This
nwmenrw can be thought of a s i n t h e f i e l d , i f any, by which the quarks i n t e r a c t ; (possibly f o r exaatple a n e u t r a l pseudovector) which i f represented I n f i e l d theory by i n t e m d i a t e f i e l d partons a r e usually c a l l e d gluons.
I n the region near
X
4
O the functions f
P
and f
pondiag t o i n f i n i t e riders of quarks and antiquarks. is f i n i t e , so@ eq. 31.2 and diseussioa.)
behavior s o i f u(x)
diverge a s .32/x,
(The n e t n m b e r of q u a r k
and f must have the Barme P u(x) d ( x ) = dfx) , Cfct do
Further f
a / x f o r s m l T x then
-
;(X)
not think we could prove s(x) and i t s equal
:(X)
corres-
-
nuust equal t h a t value akeo
because SU(3) i s not p e r f e c t , but i t rnay n o t be f a r m a y ( i f indeed i t is not e q u a l ) , Art i n t e r e s t i n g q u a n t i t y is the raeasure of how u and d approach each o t h e r as X
4
0; although each is i n f i n i t e , , t h e d i f f e r e n c e is f i n i t e 9nd i n t e g r a b h .
Experiment gives about .l7 f o r the i n t e g r a l
/
\fp(x)
- fn(x) ldx but
0
i s l a r g e f o r i t &pends p r e c i s e l y cm the satall d i f f e r e n c e near
X
the e r m r
O (as i t is
S o w people (as f o r e x m p l e Efaschos, Wetaskopf and Kuti) have t r i e d t o guess the functions u, d, e t c . , by =king
simplifying a s s m p t i o n s h i c k a r e chosen f o r
t h e i r sinq7licity r a t h e r than t h e i r physical n e c e s s i t y ,
Such p r e d i c t i o n s may o r m y
not succeed, i f they f a i l a l l we s a y is n a t u r e is n o t s o s i w l e ,
Unlike t h e i d e a
o f the parton model we have w e d eo f a r , the additional asrsmptione made i n these
raodele have i n general na physical backing. we, give an e x m g l e of such a eheoxy here:
I n ease any of you a r e I n t e r w t e d
It: i s t h a t the wees o r dx/x region
153
Parton Model is m d e e n t i r e l y of m c o x r e l a t e d p a i r s , and t h a t on t o p of these there? a r e three "valence quarks" of tbe kind of the three quark rnodel anand the wave fuarction of these is a a i q l e product of independent pieces, aixnplicity,)
That 18, i f u(x) is t h e t y p i c a l s e a d i s t r i b u t i o n and v ( x ) t h a t o f
a valence quark we would w r i t e U
=
a+2v
f o r the proton,
U
J1
v(x) dx
*"a
f ( t o g e t 32., 2 f .
t o i n f i n i t y ( a s . 4 4 / x ) but x v(x) w m n t a c a r r i e d by quarks S and S
*"
(We do not expect such
lr
O
+
as
x
-t
Near x
-*
O i t is a(x) that. goes
0. This p r e d i c t s f o r the t o t a l
2D -U s o t h e d a t a (32 ,l) gives U = .36, B
O ( s u r p r i s e ) hence we a r e i n
S-
-18
kind of trouble ( a cannot be zero) 2
mlears t h e experilaenta2. e r r o r s allow A t any r a t e some atonrenturn (46%) must be i n gluons,
It p r e d i c t s
(fp(x) -fn(x) )dx
1
5
which is hard but n o t iorpossible t o r e c m c i l e with t h e experimnfal, -17. I t a l s o p r e d l c t s vWZa/vW 2~ f a s t e r than v.
-*
2 / 3 (hencc probably wrong) by supp~sII118t h a t a x
So Ear no d i r e c t d a t a is accurate enou* charged partonr a r e quarks,
+
1,s f a l l s
t o t e e t o r e l i & n a t e the i d e a t h a t
However f u r t h e r experinrents c m ,
We give two e x w l e s ,
neutrino arcartering and polarized e l e c t r o n and proton s c a t t e r i n g ,
*
Me erhall df s c w s the i n e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g of neutrinos from proton g plus anything i n d e t a i l i n the l a s t p a r t of t h i s course.
-c
u
IJe da not k n w weak
i n t e r a c t i o n theorry at3 weld, ari3 quantupl electroctyna&ca but can use tkasa experim a t s themselves t o t e s t i t (@,g, i f i n t e r a c t i o n f s n o t a point-like four fernion f n t e r a e t i m s c a l i n g w i l l f a i l i n the farm derived below)- but s w p o a i n g i t : is a l l r i g h t f o r now, we suppose the coupling with quarks i e with t h e quark quantum numbers from
is Gabibbo's angle, s i n we talsc
= 0,
2
\
.06.
(F y It (l+iy51v) ( ~ ' y , ( l + t ~ ~ ) ~ )
qmrk t o cos Be d C s i n BC
For
s t l r ~ n p lai i t y
s
where
of our rough diecueaion here
154
Photog-H~droaInteractions %an i f we s c a t t e r
ox
(z t o 3 .
quarks
to P
+ it
up quarks (swding
Thus we would expecc t o lDeasure j w t
U
+ ;Ii f
U
t o d)
the curreat
The A is just l i k e V f o r refatOviatic
were pure vector, b a t i t is V-A. p a r t i c l e s (except the
can a f f e c t an&
is not reversed for a n t i p a r t i c l e s as i t is f o r V.)
sllpx
Xf for the V-A current irnatrix ele-t
we write
i n analogy t o e l e e t r o d p d c s we f i n d t h a t tbe ganeral form by canvention is
-
(4 P P W UV2
nUV
- 4 2 6 vv 2-
2
W
% paqAw3] ~ ~ ~
(leaving out a l l tern proportional t o q the U, v end proportional t o (=ss
U
~
~
(33.2)
beeawe chey give a m l l e f f e c t s a t
2
P) ). Ml,
W2 are a s i n @ l e c t r g c i t ex*Pt ~
they contain W and GA (nearly e q w l ) ; the new Erm W cowtp from interfereace VA. 3
In the scaling re&oo vW2, 2W1, vUJ scale to three functions f2(x), f 1.(X), 2
.
flvP
= z(;
flv"
=
r;P
= 2(u
(x = -q /2Mv)
-
If partons have spin 112, f 2
+a
2 sin 6 )
~ ( d u+ cos2 e + s
sin e)
-
rlv"
+
2
d coa 6
+ a .o,2e
~ ( + d
COS
2
2
+ B s i n2 8) B
+ 9s i n2 B)
- s sin28) fin = 2(X - u cos2 B - s i n2 8) 2 2 fjYp = -2(u - CI coe 8 - s s i n B) 2 2 B s i n 8) fp -2(d r i p
= 2(;-
2 d cos 8
S
U COB
B
Thus we have many relations, f o r e x a w l e
flM
- f j vP =4(d cos2 B i s i n2 8) - r3vn =4(u cos2 e + s s i n 2 8)
P:f
+
flvP
-
*
8
-
P f;
=4(;i cos2e
See a l s o Appendix B
+
2
s i n B)
2 x fl
.
fj(r)
For the quark m d e l we get
2
Neglecting s i n 8 4
; flYP +
4
a iV" +f
f3vP
-
Sum rules I
(flYP
- flvp)dx
-
'(f3YP
+ f;Pjdx
the f i r s t is Adlet's
-
slrrn
2 (2
-2(-2
- cos2 8)
2
- cos281%-6
r u l e (net quark laorfel depenhnt)
, the
t h i r d was f i r s t
derived by Llwellyn Smgth and Gross, Distribution predictions
-
- f3Yp
r*
+
2(-(U-;)
-6(feg
2
cos t3 (4-;i)
- fen) + s i n2@
+ s i n2 B ((s-F}
(S-;}}
- (d-3))
(33.7)
the l a s t term cm probably be neglected, It gives a very c l o ~ echeck on the =del. Alrao
6 cos2ec (fep
- fen)
+ s i n2 B
((S-;)
- (d-;i))
by subtraction with the prev;toue, relation c m Ire used t o e l i & a a t e the last term. i f them was any doubt, B , . .
Knarledge of f
ivp, fep, fen
a l l a r s us to obtpin
separately m d fgVP permits f u r t h e r separation i n t o 2 sin 8
U,
G, d,
+ G, 3 + d,
a, s +
+s
neglecting
Ifthe electron b e m and the proton i e polarized i n the deep i n e l a e t i c
s c a t t e r i n g we caa o b t a h a t i l l mm i n f o m t i o n , t h i s t i m about haw the partons are polrrrized i n s polarized proton.
all the charged partons have spin 312,
For definiteness we s h a l l sera-
For a p a r t i c l e a t r e s t the s t a t e =ay be described by saying the s p i n is i h saw p a r t i c u l a r space d i r e c t i o n
a.
h l a t i v i s t i c a l l y t r m s f o m e d s p i n s t a t e s can be
h s c r i b a d by a u n i t four-vector polar
satisfying
S
lu
( t h e t r a n s f o m d s is a s though i t were a
1 and ss p m 0 (pli = oaamntrtm o f s t a t e ) , GJhen U it taking mtrix e l e w n t s we can use s p u r s and sm over s t a t e s i f we replace the vetctsar)
B 13
S1
wua2 p r o j e c t i o n o p e r a t a r into the spin s t a t e
sit,
v
+ m by
the more coraplete
This s f~ a pseudowetar. li
W)
(i-iys&)/2 t o p r o j e c t
The s p i n s t a t e of p i n t h e
JV f a c t o r of
need not be t h e sane as the s p i n of p i n the
f
U
f a c t o r ; but the quantity we want
clttpendr; on s p i n aa a. 2 x 2 w t r i x (density ntatrix) one of w o s t a t e s h, one of two o u t .
However a l l the i n f o r a t i o n i s contained i f the diagonal i s k n m f o r
a l l s t a t e s , n o t anly f o r p
p ' = +z o r
but a l s o f a r p = p"
--E
f o r example (%n f a c t , these: t h r e e md p = p ? we consider only diagonal caaes p
s p i n p'
-X
W
S
X
= ((4-z)
+
a r e enough i n our ease), but f o r various
S p.
(-z)fi
Thw
WPv can then
be shorn ut be of rhe f o m
(disregarding t e r n praportional to Q Gl,
G2 a r e two new functions of q
2
U
o r qv) where W1, W2 a r e a s before and
, v,
What do we expect f o r these new functions G1, G 2 in the deep i n e l a s t i c region accclrding t o the partcln model?
Xf a parton has wmntunr pl = xP and
s p i n deseribed by wli the s c a t t e r i n g t o p2
-
pl +q is described by
Let us use f o r example t h e coordinate system where t h e photon has pure z c w a n e nt
NW
f i r s t suppose the h e l i c i t y of the protan is
-4,
thus
S
(P,
E,
0, O)/M,
Parron Model
l57
Further l e t
2
*
(charge)
h-(X) = No. of partons
*
(charge)' with h e l i e i t y
-
f o r hel.
+ and
The 6 f m c t i o n gives G(&-x)/ZPiu i n t h e s c a l i n g
lilnit,
w e have
[(P1,
W"
cl, D, @)/m
-"/m
+
with tzelicity 3. i n a proton of h e l ,
h+(x) = No, a f gartons
- i n a proton of wY
-
-
hel.
f i ~ ' / r n for hel.
-.
W@ t h e r e f o r e have
t h e r e s u l t s we already k n w 2Wl
f (xf
-
h+*-
The f i r a t i n t e g r a l gfves
xf(X).
and v?
second
f n t e g r a l gives (G1
2~'v
- 2xG2) = h+(n) - h_(.)
therefore the? Eunctbn G1
-2
X
G2 scales..
Suppose now t h a t the proton i s polarized i n + S'
W'
= (0, Q, 1, O f f o r parton wfth pol.
+X
and
X W'
d i r e e t i o n , we have
-
-s" f o r pox, -X,
k+(x) = No, of partona
*
(charge) 2 with p a l .
f
k-(x)
*
(charge)' with pol.
- x +a n proton of pol. -
-
No. of parmns
x i n a protan of pole + X.
We have an expression of the type (33,111 with h+ repkaced by k+ and h- replaced by k- from which we derive
3 therefore the function 2M vGl
+
2 2 2M v E2 scales.
2 3 Henee from (33.12) and (33.13) E?v G2 s c a l e s and Hv Cl s c a l e s and we w r i t e
2
I4 vG2
-
g1(x1.
2 Hv G2
g2 (X).
These a r e the s c a l i n g p r e d i c t i o n s f o r s p i n cases.
The term i o G2 i n (33.12) is r e l a t i v e l y n e g l i g i b l e (order l / v times term i n G1). We have
Of course, these new functions gl, g2 cannot be obtained fro% f(x) because new d i a t r $ b u t i a m a r e involved, the n d e r of partom with various spin8 is a t a t e s of various k e l i c i t g , so t h a t we &rive nothing but the scaling rulea even i f we use a s p e c i a l 111ode1l i k e qmrks, e t c .
However, i n t h a t =del we cm obtafn a
remrkable sum r u l e of Bjorken. Me can w e our proton wave f m c t i o n (described by partan) not only t o obtain predictlone f o r deep i n e l a s t i c s c a l l n g but l i k e any other weve function w e can write the ernectation value of varioua operators f o r i t ,
We have already done
'-W '.
t h a t t r i v i a l l y when we m o t e j
v
a8 the operaro
t o t a l charge on the proton t o be expressed as
(uZ)
- 7l (d-3) - 7j-l (e
NOW we n % l l d i s c w s the expectation of a leas t r i v i a l operator, the a x i a l B
decily operator f o r p
pi^'Av In>
i(;
y
-+
Y
p v 5 a
n trmeitions,
It is wrLtten empirically as
1 (G /G ) end e q e r i m e n t a l l y GA/GV A
V
1.23 2 .02.
"t
$.
i n the quark m d e l the operator .lAu is the sun over quarlcs of .r y y fr P 5
Theoretically '4-
I spin
r a i s i n g OR). Xf we change the X spln t a t h i r d mwonent we can use the r e l a t i o n
We calculate both s l d e s f o r
it
p m t m w v i n g f a s t t o the r i @ t tlith mmntraa f
and spin a' and sunr on proton s t a t e s via a spur Operator correctly projecting. the l e f t s i d e we have the correspanang sum on quark@, thus
d with m i g h t
+
1 / Z f o r u,
G
-
1/2 f o r d,
2
f ~ ~ / ~ ~ ) s ' ~Wow j 2 the . @urn
on the l e f t is exactly the i n t e g r a l over x of 2 gl, (or 2(g1+g2) depending on the? s p i n CM@)& a t we needed f o r deep i n e l a s t i c ep s c a t t e r i n g except the weighte i n the l a t t e r case were 4 / 9 f o r
U,
u,1/9 f a r d,
a and 119 f o r a ,
g
for
z, S/9 for d, X, 1/9 f o r s, f o r the neutron) whL3ie here we want 1/2 f o r u, ,; - 1/2 f a r d, z. But the difference of gl f o r proton glp mid neutron gin has weights 1 / 3 f o r U, U, - 113 f o r 4, iio r 2/3 of & a t the prtrjton (or 119 f o r
we want,
U,
Hence we have f o r the two p o k r i z a t i o n cases
On
-
L,
((33.16) is BJorbn's relation).
From these we conclude
(p, g2n)dx 0. 0 This coaes merely from the equality of the coefficient f o r the polarization z and x cases, were;
dtn
equality which would have t o hold no HItitter Mhat the weights
so we can conclude i n d i d d w l l y
1
g2dx = O
a reault e5 rotational, s
(33.18) t r y (angular etomntraa conseirvatlon)
.
Tne f i r s t relatlon is more remrkable and would r e s t simdtaneously the
quark view, and the interpretation of the weak current a s y (1.t.i~ ) not only for 5
the e l e m a t a r y p a r t i c l e s e
, Ve,
Pu"V
If
,
s
but a l s o f o r the elearentarg constitmnt.
quarks (or quark gumturn ambers on spin 112 partoas).
It@ verification, o r
f a i l u r e , would have a mast decisive e f f e c t on the direction aE future high energy theoretical physics,
Tests of the Parton Mode
Lecture 34
g u l a r raomentwet considerations ( t h a t 0 t h e proton is s p i n 1/2 and t h e parton is s p i n 2/21. This b r i n g s up a general research prablea about msngular o;xlraf;ntum and p a r t on wave f m c t i o n ~( fttneeZons of
X
and transverse raomnturn k L ) . The dependearn o f these functions on the
t r m s v e r s e w m n t a kA is not knom, and a r e very i n t e r e a t t a g tchearetically , C m my i n f o m t i o n an t h i s , o r o t h e r questions, be got by studying t h e angular
m m n t w p r o p e r t i e s of parcon wave functions? i f a y an the wave ffunetian corn
For e z a q l e , h a t r e s r r i e t i a n s
from the f a c t t h a t the t o t a l rmgular mmnturn
of the proton is j m t 1/2? Or, suppose t h e parton p r o b a b i l i t y d f s t r i b u t i o n f(x) were k n m for a d o f h e l i c i t y f o r a 15 of h e l i c l t y
+
f
312, What could you say about the d i s t r i b u t i o n
1/2?
D r e l l has suggested m o t h e r expergmat which can b e predicted by h m x e d g e of the parton d i s t r i b u t i a n .
Again we w e t h e parton as
quark w d e l t o describe
t h e idea, b u t i t can of course be analyzed the @amway i n o t h e r representations f o r parcone. p
+ i;)
The r e a c t i o a i a p
+p
-t
p+p- -4 anything.
a t very high s (e.g. P ia CH is l a r g e ) d e s a
f 66
Proton plus proton (ar il+iiep
a ~ whose r energy is
proportional t o P, and whose z colnpment of mnsentuon is of order P, as P
-i.
m.
'fhe p i c t u r e is
the 1.1 p a i r Ss m d e from the a n n i h i l a t i o n o f a parton i n proton A and anti-partan
ia proton B and t h e o t h e r partons j u s t keep gain8 on t o m&e f i n a l hadrona, the By s u i t a b l e choice of t h e energy and momntmn ( i n z d i r e c t i o n ) of
'knything".
rhe p's we can d e t e M n e xl and x2 of t h e itnnihilating partons,
(Thw if,
i n the CM, t h e morm?ntm of the ~ 0 l l i d i n gprotons is P, and t h e energy -and t o t a l z component masentm of the p 'e i r r
E
pZ, we have by conservation of atomntm
and energy
I t w i l l be e a s i e s t t o nreasme the p a i r a t l a r g e angles ( t h e angular d i s t r l -
bution is 3.
+
2 cos 8) s o no great: l o s s of intentlity occurs here, and backgrowd
hadrons which s h ~ u l dm v e primarily i n z a r e e t i o n a r e avoided. chosen h m e v e r , t h e raornenta of t h e two p ' s give d i r e c t l y P x l , P%
If 8
O La
becauaa i n such
a one-dirartntianal c o l l i s i o n of r e l a t f v f s t f c p a r t i c l e s t h e oldlnoentm of the f i n a l p a r t i c l e s is t h e s a w a s t h a t of t h e i n c i d e n t p a r t i c l e s , The cross s e c t i o n f o r t h i s is t h e crose, s e c t i o n f o r r e l a t i v i s t i c p a i r 4 a n n i h i l a t i o n ( e (l
* cos2 B
partons t o a n n i h i l a t e ; e.g.
2
}/l6 E ) tianes t h e chance G of flstding the approprfate for p
+ g,
i f partons a r e quarks:
To be v a l i d , o f coume, the wee region must be avoided ( t h a t is, P m u s t be
high mough t h a t Pxl, Px2 a r e l a r g e c q a r e d t o 1. &V)
.
One might a t f i rsc be
concerned t h a t the / P ~ / PBeate > we s t a r t with i e n o t a s t a t i o n a r y s t a t e , for
protons s c a t t e r v i a strong interactions
SO
the p o s s i b i l i t y e x i s t s t h a t the parton
d i s t r i b u t i o n s are f i r s t distullbed by ""strong" "taractions to d
e
U'S.
bef0ll.e they annihflam
But we a r e co&ng t o mderstand t h a t the "strong interactioagFg
are not so strong i n t h i s senae
- t h a t i n hadron4adron collieions
the farrt partons t h a t i n t e r a c t , but the wees.
i t is not
ThLs accomts f o r low mmentm
t r m a f e r m d s c a l i n g i n very hLgb energy hadron caljlfstons
- so
CIS
15ng
88
we
avoid t h i s wee i n t e r a c t i n g region (interactions vjia f i n i t e energies, not of order F) the p a r t a m a c t aa f r e e p a r t i c l e s nearly
((as
P
-+ m ) .
Obvfously with enough data we could see? i f a form l i k e (34.1) could work a r i f we ham
U,
G etc.
-
from neutrino s c a t t e r i n g we could t e s t i t a r e c t l y .
h e t u r e 35
Gronau has painted out that with no further data than we already have we could calculate t h i s f a c t o r C i n a t l e a s t one region, Lnw a l l the frmefions U, as/%.
u
d.
3 go
as a/rl with the same a , snd
B.
9. as
&ere as m y be close t o a (but not necessarily exactly equal, say a -8 with 8 anurll; SUS seys as = a but i t
consider (a
G,
Xf xl is sm11, we
I)
W
iiir
incorrect),
0, end then say what the e f f e c t of i t i a .
We s h a l l f i m t
Hence i n t h i s region
.24) we have
But the l e s t f a c t o r i s j u s t fep[x), so C i t s predictable %n t h i s region,
the Z W l
f o r the proton and i a Lnovn,
It s h w s t h a t Drell's experimnt could
e a s i l y serve aa a test: of m y parton =del
- and w i l l be an i n t e r e s t i n g e x p e r i m a t
t o watch* I f I) is not zero we get
so i t s e e m that there is l i t t l e e f f e c t from any reason&le B , for z l , x X 2smll
For exaraple,
Tests of the Farton Model a very weak dependence on B ,
+
I n a similar way we could describe the proton lntiprocon ease m-+u+uX t would be detemined by a f a c t a r
anything,
" l . , "
Zf f i n a l l y , the functions u, u e t c . a r e d e t e d n e d f o r the proton, the correrponding functions f o r the. picn %(X), (dif f t c u l t t o get enough energy) a
+p
e t e . ccufd be obtained Ebrougb
%(X)
+n
+ PM ''
f o r nar
Drell has suggested t h a t anather f u n d e n t a g experigletnt m y yield infornation about the character of partons.
Xt i s e++em
+
ang hedrans a t hi& energy,
W
would expect to pmduee some spln l f 2 partan p a i r of &arge ei,
I
2 (et/@) uo *ere
+- + e E? +p v-].
oo i a the cross aiectfon f o r a p h 112 p a i r prodaction (e.g.
Now t h i s pair wouM turn i n t o hadrons
- and i f the energy i s hlgh
anough,af nearly the a m energy a s tb virtutil s t a t e of a parton p a i r , i f there were a nmber af parton p a i r types of &arges el, e2 e t c . ,
crass section oe+*--,
Thus
the t a t e l
htrdrons is j u s t the total. to m&e each pair:
That is, the xirtfo approrseheer a w s t a n t , and the constant i s tbe sunn of
squares of psrton charge s
d on each type t h a t e x i s t s .
I f there a r e any
1 1 .e 2 f a r each spin zero spin O partgns they would contribute . i;a s strongly (e.g. B parton)
.
We c e l l D
e t s ' D r e l l 's conatant!'
For example i f parmnr a r e quarLa we expect
1
:e
$ + $ + $-
2/3 f o r D.
If partons mst carry i n t e g r a l charges, and be spin 112, the sm rnust be a t l e a s t
l.
I n the c a s e of quarks we would have t h e d k f f i c u l t i e s tre have disregarded
a s t o how a p a i r o f oppositely m v i n g charges of hadrons of i n t e g r a l charge,
m e r e lnay be
2 213 say can t u r n i n t o a n l p
way t o g e t the required e x t r a
S-
quarks gram a s o f t s e a of p a i r s , buc one can perhaps l e g i t l m t e l y q w s t i o n whether the above a r g m e a t s a r e e n t i r e l y c l e a r , f;nvolviag as they do an assumption t h a t the parton s t a t e s go e n t i r e l y i n t a badmn s t a r e s . t a do t h i s and orait s t a t e s o f quark quantum numbers?
1s i t r e a l l y c o n s i s t e n t It; would be most e x c i t i n g
i f the r a t i o does corn o u t 2 f 3 a s we311 i t rai@t, Ear t h e t h e o r e t i c a l qucrstions prodwed by such a simple answer would be very i n t e r e s t i n g . be worthwhile aa an
I think i t would
e x e r c i s e beforehand t o a s s m e t h e r e s u l t was = a l l y 213 and
s e e what paradoxes, i f any, would then have t o be resolved.
-
As we discussed previously t h e o r e t i c a l l y ( l e c t u r e 5 ) , the t o t a l c r o s s s e c t i o n
f o r o(e'om
any hadrons) es a function of q
2
(q2 = 48, E
€24 energy) determines
t h e vacuum expectation value of t h e product of c u r r e n t s
The vacurn s c a t t e r i n g of v i r t u a l photons by v i r t u a l hadrons is d e t e w n e d by
P.T.
< Q /( J ~ ( ~ ) J ~ lTI@> (z)
-
(qwqv
where dispersion theory t o l d ue Xm(iv)
(1
-
2
1 P
2
dyV)v(q 2 p(q 1,
+ above quantity) i s t h e f a c t o r by whieb a photon propagator I l q 2 must be
m u l t i p l i e d f o r f i r s t order e f f e c t of v f r t m l hadrons b e e ,
The low e n e r m t e s t s , l i k e e f f e e t on L a b shift depend j u s t on the towest
q
2
o r only on ivl((0) t h a t is "roday we can begln t o say something q u i t e d e t a i l e d about t h i s , f o r i n the
region (2to,) production.
2
t o J u e t above 1 &V
a t h e croas s e c t i o n is d m i n a t e d
2 Perhaps p(q ) s e t t l e s down t o D/6n f o r l a r g e
by t h e p , w, Q,
4 f a i r l y soon.
Although one d g h t suppose we d g h t have t o go deeidedliy above t h e nucleon
Tests Crf the Partsn Model
l65
p a i r c r e a t i o n , t h i s .may n o t be t r u e ; s o f t p a r t i c l e production my dominate a t a l l energies and reach its asyatptote sooner. A , Cisneroa has calculated the various hadranic contributions t o i v ' (0) , The contributions from t h e p, u and (a turn out t o be ten tims l a r g e r than
the l a r g e q2 contribution under reasonable assumptions about the l i k e l y value of 2 Dre11's constant and t h e value of q2 a t vhich p(q ) a t t a i n s i t s asymptote.
Data frem e'e-
i n t e r s e c t i n g r i n g s can be used d i r e c t l y t o obtafn t h e
contribution from the p ,
The d a t a is s i n p l y i n a e t t e d i n t h e formula
to obtain
(%at was used h e r e was the d a t a on the pion f o m f a c t o r which is alnrost tsvevthing t h e r e is i n y l v i r e u a f )
I,
p
-c
hadrone,
The 4n i n e l a s t i c i t y i s very
small even a t q Z = (.B G~v)').
+ we
In t h e case of t h e w and
a s s u m W M , which works w e l l i n t h i s type
In t h i s case tthe cantr2bution from the vector =son v = w o r QI is
of processr.
2 Prom the r e l a t i o n In (iv(q ) )
1
p(q
2
1 we deduce
For a very narrow resonance, which i s a good approxfrncrtion f o r w and 4, 2
we have p(q )
2 2 mv h-22n6(q ):m-
the value of ivf(0) i s simply
(35 -131 (This formula gives i v ' (0) P
5.3 n I O -''~V&
f o r t h e 0, i n good agreement with
what was obtained above w i n g the d a t a d i r e c t l y . ) and Q, a r e t h e r e f o r e
The contrrlbutions of t h e w
We now evaluate the cantribution from the ""tail" attained its asynrptotic v a l m D/6n a t q 2
%h' is
gives ivPt(O)
.84
X
2
qo
is as l o w se 1 GeV2 and D
10~'~ q ~ -I f:~ q .
is the q w r k value 2 / 3 we have .56
X
of p(q 2 ) a s s w n g i t has
10""~
f o r ivVt(O). We believe the
a c t u a l value of the non-vector meon emedbutiorx not t o be mueh l a r g e r than t h i s , we =sign t o i t lOOX uncertainty,
Adding the varioutt contributitoas w e get
ivy01 =t7,3ti,a)xia-2~e~-2 hadrons This corresgonda t o a correction t o the mwetaic
of the mwns of
2 For comparison, iv'(0) f o r muons i s [4n 15 M
1.1
15.3
X
10-'
&vw2#
s a the hadxonic: contributiaa is about one half a@large, Away from q2*
0, the contributions t o i(v(q 2 1 - (0)) from the t a i l of p(q 2 )
grow a s the vector =son
contributlions f a l l , s o the m c e r t a t n t i e s a r e greater,
h o t h e r expectation of i n t e r e s t from the parton w d e l is the anlyular d i s t r f butioo of hadronlic products i n high energy e'e-
-
collisions.
2 Ue expect t h a t partens of s p i n 212 arc2 produced with an (&+cos 8) rusgular dilsrrjtbutim and t h a t t h e f i n d obsemed hadroas w i l l have smll transverse nromnta r e l a t i v e to the direction 8 &n &which the partons were p r o h e e d a t hi& energy,
aou&
Iba b u r s t s of oppositely w v h hadrms ~ a r e ewected which w i l l determine
the m g f e 8,
f f &ere a r e aleo charged p a r t m s of spln O the angular d l s t r i b u t i a n
w i l l be (l
+ cos 2 e) + l Do
(1
- cos28)
f sonertarxts f o r partons of spin 112 cvrd spin O where D and D are ~ c e l % 112 2 reepectively, For q w r b rse expect of course only a ( l + cos B) d i s t r i b u t i o n ,
astic Scattering as Properties of Operators
We s h o d d now l i k e t o turn back t o a p ~ i n tof vfew, described more part i c u l a r l y i n the f i r s t Lectures of this course, of the e l e c t r o d p a d c properties of hadrons as being; raeasuremmts of properties of the current operators J (1). M For e x q l e there we s a i d we expected t h a t the corrtrnutetor [Jv(2), f (1) 1 would It vanish i f 1, 2 were outside each o t h e r s l i g h t cone, Sacmd order i n t e r a c t i o n s were described by matrix e l e m n t s of a second operator V
vU
(2, 1) which w e s h w e d
would be ezpressible as a time ordered product of the f f r s t ones J
(written
iJ
iJv(2)
1) IT)
As we have seen the e p s c a t t e r i n g m a s u r e s a function which we have w r i t t e n as
Ve now consider i t i n a .more abbstraet way.
F i r s t we note t h a t i f the s t a t e s
p and x are imagined te contain t h e i r c e a t e r of mss raglnentusl f a c t o r s , t h e
2 2 2n6(NX -(pfq) )would be m e c e s s a r y , Eor the c l a s s of s t a r e s
X'
now
man ancl
Thus K
i s t h e expectation on the protoll of the product of two operators,
V@
We have measured i t only f o r qZ
O but i t e x i s t s a l s o f o r qZ > O and of
course t h e e n t i r e function f o r a l l q2 both p o s i t i v e and negative belongs together theoretically.
For p o s i t i v e tqZ, however, &ere is a small technical point.
We
wish to a l t e r t h e d e f i n i t i o n because we do n o t wish d i a g r m which do n o t a f f e c t the proton a t a l l , thus
proton
Such t e r n s do n o t exist f o r the non-diagonal m t r i ~ elements of the product of o p e r a t a r s term < $ / Jv(-qv) Jy(q) / p > and we should l i k e t o define K ss t h e l i m i t of t h i s a s $
-"
p t o o b t a i n a s u i t a b l y useful, d e f i n i t i o n of matrix elelrnents
of t h e product operator.
We can g e t the s a w r e s u l t i f we explJlcitly saubtract
t h e contrlbutlons of t h e discomected d i a g r a m of t h e type above, write
-
~ , ()- 4 ) ~ , ( 9 ) / p > ~ ~ ~ (' d 9
Hence we
-
Then i f t h e f i n a l p is changed t o p b l i g h t l y d i f f e r e n t , t h e expression def b e d by (36,l) is coat inuous , klca would l i k e t o consider, f o r t h e o r e t i c a l pwpases, v a r i o w o t h e r current@
beside eleetromagnetie nanat) (i.e.
- we can have various $U3 generalizations
i n a n o c t e t (or
currents with d i f f e r e n t charge n d e r t l ) and a A a l currentls a s well.
Thus we l e t these indices (SU3 and a x i a l ) as w e l l ss t h e P, v i n d i c e s of space be contained i n a s i n g l e l e t t e r A ( c a l l i n g J v ( l )
A(1) e t c . ) t o save w r i t i n g
i n general a r g w n t s , aad can always go back and i n s e r t i n d i c e s a t the end, Thus i f A is any operator of our allowed s e t ( f o r our e x a q l e e , a vector o r
a x t a l vector l o c a l current i n SU3 o c t e t o r possibly s i n g l e t ) we w r i t e (obviously the diagonal proton a t a t e can be generalized i m d i a t e f y too, b u t we leave chat f o r the s t u h n t ) ,
Inelastic Scattering as Propertigs of Operafors And l a s t l y we omit w r i t i n g the l a s t t e r n Ear s h p l i c i t y , but you awt
remxnber t h a t , f o r diagonal lsatrix e l e m a t s i t i s there. %A is the diagonal r ~ a t r i xelerrrent o f t h e product of two operators,
Evidently we c m d;gflne s corresponding thing i n space:
K depends only on the d i f f e r e n c e
Since the diagonal e
q
-
2p
-
Or
We e x p l i c i t l y c a l l t h e coaponents of
2-1, its Fourier transform is KBA(q).
{V, -$l i n the system where t h e p r o t m is a t r e s t (others v i a r e l a t i v i s t i c
tranafomtion),
6)
KBA(v.
Thus
2s a t r e a t
m
-C
a11 x
2 I (6)1p>& ( E ~ - E ~ - V I
2Ex
(36.3)
Since K gives t h e product operator we can f i n d from i t the c o m u t a t o r as w e l l as t h e
ordered operator so useful i n s c a t t e r i n g .
tixntj
kle note, i n our case ( i n the r e s t system of the proton), s i n c e the, proton
Is the lowest =ss o f all, s t a t e s of b a ~ y o nn d e r one (and A dwe not: change baqon n d e r ) that
P;x
E
P
f o r a l l x.
Hance i f
no s t a t e can be reached by A(v, q)Ip> i f v
O
V .c
Q the 8 function is zero
- and (Ip>
-
a t reat)
Now t h e carnuttitor m t r i x element is defined by CBA(Z,l)
m
RgA(2, 1)
- Kh8(1*
2,
sa i t s Fourier t r m s f o m @ a t i s t i e s
We note t h a t X can be obtained from G and d e e versa because of ( 3 6 . 4 ) . %(v.
and CB*(-v,
4) -6)
-
cBA(v I
-
-CmLB(v,
6)
v >
Thus
o
(26' 6 )
6).
Thus 9.1% rar?asur&ng%(v,
w-tator
for
Q) ue a r e w a s u r i n g the Fourier trcrnsfom oE the
o f two c u r r e n t s ,
We s h a l l d-isccrss t h e cmsequenws a f t h i s i n t e r e s t i n g r e s d t i n a craomnt, but while we have these equations before u s we wish to derive a fczv Eomulm f o r the s c a t t e r i n g a q l i t u d e whlch we w i l l need l a t e r i n t h e w a r s @ , Aa we have
discussed the s c a t tering q l i t u d a f a r am inceaing photon ( v i r t u a l o r real) coupled t o J (1) say A(1) t o an outgoing one coupled t o B is detts-dned by the operator
we diacusa the e f f e c t of seaguljta ( i f there are any, 6 (2-X)
type terms) l a t e r
and omit them f o r a wbile,
If i n p a r t i c u l a r we are intezleclted i n the Eomard s c a t t e r i n g aw1itude TBA(4 00" a proton with a photon of mmnturn q we need the Pourier t r a a a f o m
(The superscrfipt F indgcates- t h a t the choice of
siw
of the i m g i n a r y part
f o r negatfve frequencies is taken accordgag t o the convention of Fewmn i n h i s
QED papers; there is a dif f e r e a t choice called u w a l amplitude.
which is
often very useful,) To take the Fourier transfofln of the f i r s t t e r n i n ( 3 6 . 8 ) we have a product o f @(t2-tl) & w e P.T.
i s i/(v+ic) and B(Z)A(1)
we have the convolutlian of these,
whose P.T. i s %A(v,
P
use
&t
hence
In the s m e way the a e c ~ n dterm is the
convolution of -%/(v-%E) (the F.T. of @(tl-tZ) and Km(-v,
NOW
6) and
4).)
Hence
inscvr-v>
where we have exp1icitl-y added possible seagull t e r n aBA which L s sinply an u n k n m ( f i n i t e order) polpemial i n v,
8, Thus
the s c a t t e r i n g m p l i t u d e is,
except: f o r a golynmial, ESfven i n t e r n of the comutator, Megatiw
V,
58 of course, not defined by experimnt,
Hawever i t can be
obcdned from nnssasuremnts of the reaction with a n t i p a r t i c l e s (using
A
f o r A)
v i a the connection implied by (36 ,IQ) m d the r e l a t i o n f o r comutatars ( r e s u l t i n g
f nelasric Scattering as Propertl'es of Operators from the f a c t t h a t
a))* -
(c,,(,
is the adjoint operator t o A)
a, - -c,
(V,
41
(-V.
so t h a t (36,101 i m l l e s
F
TBA(v.
6)
-
T&(-w*
41
h o t h e r more- usual convention (causal a ~ l i t u h )t o define the negative frequency exteasion changes the a i m of the imaggnary p a r t f o r negatlve frequencies
a, -
T;~(~,
T;~(~,
*
C
Thus (TgA(v, 9 ) )
-
a, +
c
CBA(~.
.
4)
T s (-v.
and a l s o (37.1) beeoms n m
(vhlch is j u s t as good a way af describing s c a t t e r i n g
The s i p i f i e a n e e o f F
a s T ) i n coordinate space can a m be seen.
e
(=I
given by an expression 1ik
( 3 6 . 9 ) except t h a t the sign of the +ic i n the l a s t term I s reversed,) In (37 .l) we have expressed
things i a terols of the carnutator but the l a s t t e r n caa be
m r e @%=plyexpressed a s the product operator, from (36.5) and (36.6) we have
6)
@(-v) v,(C ,,
-irC
-
-
-KABf-v,
41,the
F.T. (B(2)A(1)IT
f o r t2 2 tX,we have B(P)A(1) A(1)8(2)
- A(I)B(Z)
P.T. of eA(1)B(Z).
Hence (37.1) says
- FeT.A(1)B(2)
- A(l)B(Zf
P
[BQ2), A(1) 1 and f o r t2
have
1.0
. By retarded e m u r a t o r f o r t2 C t
c tl"V
we mean the c o w t a t o r
1:
froar. t h i s , (37.2) i s d i r e c t l y obvious. (Rmrk,
The (3(t -t ) i n 37.3 a t f i r s t s i g h t &es the r e s u l t not relet2 1 t i v i s t i e a l l y invariant, u n t i l i t f a realized t h a t the comutator Eacmr is zero Ear a p a c e l i u regions so the p l a e t2
t1 c= be t i l t e d a r b i t r a r f l y as requrfreci
172
Photon-Hrzdron Interactions
by Lorentz transformation.
This i s true a t lease i f Eke comutatox is not too
singular a t equal times which
it9
often true,
T i A defined here not r e l a t i v i e t i c a l l y
MEficulties s o m t i w a a r i s e A i n g
isvariant unless corresponding non-invar$ant
terms (called Schwinger t e r n ) a r e added i n t o the '%eagullif part of (37.3) .) Expression (37.3) serves as a general definition of the Chew amplitude, i . e , i n space-tinart lit is the retarded comutbitor, even when we do not have the diagonal e l e m n t a , or lowest s t a t e s (so the product operator is O f o r v
0).
The general definlltion of the Feyman ampiftude is the time ordered operator ( 3 6 . 8 ) . They d i f f e r by the product operator.
Note on various refations b a l l t y conditions
Crossing C
6)I *
fTM (v,
-
-
a, T',
P
T ~ ~ ( ~ .
-6)
T&
(-V,
Imginary Part G
iTa
(V,
a))* -
4,
a, - -~G,(V, a)
~,(T;
(37.8)
The crBA s a t i e f y r e a l i t y and croiilsiag relations required t o keep then
valid f a r T, GM*
(v,
Nmlg
41
m
G Z
(-\?p
-4)
-
0 s (v,
The commutator a t equal times t2
vlth respect t o v f o r a l l v, since equal t i m c ~ m u t a ton i relation
61
tl can be obtained by integrating CBA(v,
e" (t2-rl)dv/2n
6 (t2-t l).
6)
Hence Cell ELann 's
173
Inelastic Scartorirzg as Properties of Operafors becomes upon Fourier t r a n s f o m f o r our diagonal element on t h e proton, a,
a constant, Independent of
6,
This is c a l l e d a s u s r u l e .
We now r e t u r n t o our study of the f a c t t h a t i n xneaeurlag R
BA (v, Q) we a r e
m a s u r i n g t h e F,T,
of t h e c o m u t a t o r of two c u r r e n t s ,
we s h a l l ask a r e ( l ) Mhat limitations on the F.T.
As examples of q m s t i o n s
r e s u l t from t h e f a c t t h a t t h e
c o m u t a t o r vanishes outeide the l i g h t cone?
12) From e x p e r i m e n t ~ lf a c t s about
the behaviar of IZ ( e .g, Bjorken s c a l i n g ) &at
do we Ittarn about the character
of t h e c o m u t a t o r ? It behooves us t o study the general behavior of c o m u t a t o r s , and we begin
our study with the c o m u t a e a r of two a c a l a r f i e l d s of mss nn i n a syhstem without
We can express 4C1) i n t e r n s of c r e a t i o n a d m n l h i l a t i o n operators i a the usual way
Were
W
k
=
is the c o r r e c t frequency t o describe the o p e r a t o r ' s
developmat in time f o r t h e r e 1s no i n t e r a c t i m s o the enerC?;y i e ; t h a t of a f r e e particle.
The
commute with each o t h e r , and the %*'S, only a and a* do n o t
c o m t e i f they belong t o the s m e %:
We work out (37.21)
i m e d i a t e l y by fomhlng t h e c o m u t a t o r , w i n g (37.131, of
an expression l i k e (37.12).
Dropping t e r n which obviaualy c o m u t e we a r e l e f t
with:
The a c t u a l i n t e g r a l can now be done
- i t invobea
Here we w i l l j u s t do t h e s p c i a l caae m
-
Bessel functions,
0, and say what the case 'm
$ 0
174
Phorsn-Hadran Inreractions
gives, l e w i a g d e t a i l s t o the st-nt,
-
In (37.14) put
&OS@,
%
-
L for m
-
O t o get
singular 6 f w c t i o n on the 1i&t cone. For f i n i t e
we obtain &e
s h g u f a r i t y on the ligttt cone, zere
outside i t of coursle, aab a Bessel Emetion inside:
Thus we see t h a t the c-utator
f o r f r e e part?iclea is zero outside the l i g h t
c m @ and singular ( l i k e 6 f m c t i o n ) m the l i g h t cone, We helve discussed the singularit2ea of two f i e l d s , dil~cussthe ~ J n g u X a r i t i e ef r m tnuo currents. f i e l d theory J (1)
(2p+ ap)# ( l )
Also i n s t r u c t i v e i$ t a
Qne suck current ~ g h br e i n a free
@ ( l ) f o r spinor f ?ields. M an e x a w l e we w i l l leave out tlzeee gradients, e t c . asld fgnd the c-utator P
6(1)
or
h
for
"currentsW"tat a r e simply squares of a s c a l a r f i e l d
where s ( 2 , l ) i o the f r e e EgeeM c o m a t a t o r we worked out before. 2
has the s a m s i n g u l a r i t y sgn (t2-tl)6(52)
Clearly K
8s a ~ t c dbefore f o r C, but thts t i m
tnu1t;lplied bp an operator function of two pcsitions F f 2 , l ) called often a b i l o c s l operator,
This operator is needed, of course, only m the l i g h t cone.
Its matrix elements give functions of xZY-xlli
( f o r e x q l e of t2-tl f o r a
dtagonal elemnt: i n a system of a partlclie a t r e s t ) .
So i n g e w r a l the
sinlngularities along the cane a r e raodaated by a f m c t i o n of the distance from the origin of the cane, Far interactgag hadrons the e m u t a t o r of currents outeide the liglnt cone also, and non-zero only i w i d e . h w i t &as
the t r ~ s i t i o na s we cross the l i g h t cone,
ir,
elrpected to be; zero
An i n t e r e s t i n g question is
So-
s o r t of jump Is
i n slope? Or possibly i t has 6
Is i t i n value or on*
expected p r e s m b l y .
Such a question is a f m d m n t a l one
function a s the f r e e p a r t i c l e case does.
Me have the Fourier t r m a f o m e x p e r i w n t a l l y i n K
UV
(v,
$3
, B. olngular
behavior corresponds t o so= s o r t of high v, high 4 l l m i t ; so i t is the b e h a d o r a t large v, Q t h a t gives us the answer t o the question. experiaents indicate R(v, Q) s a t i s f i e s BJorken scaling function of 6
But i n t h i s region
- t h a t Is,it
58 only a
2
-q /2&,
The most otxaightfomard way t o a a l y z e t h i s is t o take the inverse t r a n s f o m of K, using the BJarken l i m i t aad aeeisrg what s l n g u l a r i t i e s i t g i m s
- then
concluding the character of the s i n g u l s r i t i e s , because they depend only on the high v, Q I i d r a r e the ame f o r the c m p l e t e function as they a r e f o r the Bjorkcm X i r n i t .
We wZl2 not t r y t o be rigorous, becauee f o r oae thllng we r e a l l y
do not know, experimentally, R f o r q2 Let Q be along the z axis.
h r g s v , QZ is nearly
V
-q2
p
0, nevertheless we can see what happens. ~
i n f a c t qZ = *MC.
~
(q>v)(qz-v) ~ v
ZMvE, ~ hence f o r
The Fourier inverse of e f m c t i o n
o f F, only would look l i k e
where s ( t ) i s the F,T, of the s t r u c t u r e f u t c t i o n f ( F ) , To put i t in anather s l i g h t l y m r e rigorous way we nors
Now omit f o r
41
xaOfDent the 2Hu (suppose we took the txmsforn of M ) and
a
note f a r l ~ r g ev, qa t h a t t o a good enough approltimatten the 6(q 2+ZWvB) can be replaced by 6 ( q 2 + 2 ~ v ~ + d ~ 2So ) . we get f o r large enough v, (q2+ Z M ~ B + ~=B(q+@p12) '
Now we can i n s e r t , i f ve. wlsh, a sgn(v) t o keep the as f o r a F.T. cf a c o r n t a t o r , m d f o r large v t h l s is j u s t sga(*BH] proton is a t r e s t ) .
Hence a s p p t o t i c a l f y
( i f the
1 76
NW
Phutoa-Hadrm Interactions
the F.T. i s easy f o r we know t h a t F.T.
sgn(t)d(s
2
2 sp(vId(q I
s o that f o r a four vector a
hence P,T.W2
noting P*x
- jf
( ~ ) d 8e-iBP*xapn(t)6(t
2
2
-R )
MC we have our previous r e s u l t
- t h a t the significance of Bjorken
ecaling is t h a t the s h g d a r i t y of the current operators has s i n g u l a r i t y on the l i g h t cone.
a,
6 fuaction-like
To be =re precise we w i l l have t o include all.
&e P P factors, etc., and define everything precisely U v gradients of 6-fwctions involved,
- there w i l l then be
The beat way t o eay i t i n a general way is
t h a t scaling shows t h a t the sfslgularitfee on the l i g h t cone of the current carnutatore a r e J w t of the s a m severity as they would be f o r f r e e p a r t i c l e fields, m i a is, of course, what we expect from the parton interpretation f o r there we a s s w d I n the f f n a l stateax(vhich beeme tlhe h t e m d i a t e s t a t e s of the c m a t a t o r ) the partons can be consfdered a@ free,
Thus there Is no surprise
i n the conclusion, i t is m l y t h a t we whLElh t o s t a t e what we have discussed (scaling) in an a b s t r a c t and general wag (as a r r a n t comatator sialngularities) with m%nimm references t a a model.
Although the s t a t e m n t s t i l l s e e m t o r e f e r
t o f r e e p a r t i c l e f i e l d s , that i a only a shorthand t o writing 8 and 8 ' functions on the l i g h t cone, Each general property of partons we assmed s a i d smathing m x e e x p l i c i t about the character of the singularity.
For exmple, t~ r~aycharged partow
are spin 112 i e t o say the a i n g u l a r i t i e s are l i k e those 6 o r t e r i s t i c of f r e e Dirac f i e l d comutatoro, r e s u l t s a r e related.
ffunctions charac-
Ea addition, vector and iai& vector
I f , f o r exanple, one adds t h a t partona a r e quarks c e r t a i n
n m r i c a l l r e l a t i a n s are implied, aa we have seen, between the s f n g d a r p a r t s of the comutators of variaus klzlds of currents.
( m a t i s t o say f o r examle, our
Inehtie Scattering as Propertiw of Operators r e l a t i o n s among feP and f i p , f i P e t c . implied by expressing everything i n terms of the s i x f m c t i o n s
U,
z, d , 3, s, z,)
Quarks, a s f r e e p a r r i c l e s , have n o t been fowd. a s t o whether the & t a i l e d views sf tbe partan =del
There a r e many questions a r e correct f o r quarks.
In
p a r t i c u l a r , the question whether a s i n g l e parton quark moving out i n recoil, need
o r need not rake i t s non-integral qwatum a m b e r with i t . In addition i t i s o f t e n very useful t o aee, vllen r e s u l t s bave been obtelned from a traodel, J u s t how mu& depends an the rnodel and whether i n f a c t the r e s u l t s carnot be s t a t e d aa a general mathematical p r i n c i p l e without: recourse t o a s p e c i f i c model, =del
In t h a t way, i f i t p r o w s l a t e r t h a t too a m y d e t a i l s of the
a r e f a u l t y , we can r t l l l begin again having learned s o w general properties
of hadrons w%thout being c a m i t t e d t o a11 t h e o t h e r s , m e r e f o r e S t i s i n t e r e s t i n g t o note t h a t t h e parton m&l is equivalent t o the general statement: (and one mueh c l o s e r t o d i r e c t elrperimental r e s u l t s ) t h a t c m u t a t o r s have 6-IXLe Zigbc-coae s i n g u l a r i t i e s
.
Light Cone A
Lecture 38
AR I n t e r e s t i n g qt1138tion mswered by Britzsch i3nd a l l - m n (1971 Coral
Gables conferenca)
Ss haw t h e s c a l i n g r e s u l t s of t h e "partons as quarks" c m
be s t a t e d i n a way wbf ch
- at the end
doesn't involve quark wave f m c t i c n s
o r operators a t a l l , We wish t o s t a t e t h a t t h e Sight cone a i n g u l s r i t i e s a r e l i k e those f a r f r e e
quark (spin 112, SU t r i p l e t ) comutatorB. 3
We man, of course, t h e l a r s s t
6' o r d type of s i a g t t l s r i t p , as we say t h e '%leadingw ( i n high frequency)
singdarity,
F i r s t we s e e what t h e s i n g u l a r i t i e s a r e libre 2 f currents were
represented by quark f i e l d s * ( X ) ,
a M r a e s p i n o r carrygag SUS i n d i c e s on which
3 x 3 rrratriees h can act, a"he conanuratror o f two splnar f i e l d s of m s m is e e s i l y worked o u t (as we did f o r Base f i e l d s ) i t is
( J u s t ss t h e propagator i s
+m
(f + m) /(p2
- m21 i n s t e a d of
l/(pZ
-
2
SB
1 so this
c o w s l i k e v i s e i n t o the commutator ( t h e r e a l p a r t of t h e propagator).
Since we a r e looking f o r the leading s i n g a a r I t y near the l f e t cone Gm Is.
Light Cone A fgebra J(+
2
and the w s t e r n i s
s2t
where
w l l e r than the large gradient, thus
is the square i n t e r v a l from 1 t o 2 and 2 means "the leading
slnguLaritfes near the l i g h t cone are equal. '' It i s e a s i l y v e r i f i e d t h a t the- r e s u l t s we: obtain here f o r the c m a t a t o r s
of two currents each a b i l i n e a r form i n
v,
a m exactly tk s a m ðer we
suppose s ) the f i e l d s obey the usual a n t i c o m t a t l o n r e l a t i o n s a t equal, e l m @
--
T(%)$(i;2)
Y ( x ~ ) # ( x ~+)
-
- Z2) and +(Z1),+(Z2) anticommute a s i s
&'(gl
appropriate t o Fern2 p a r t i c l e s ; o r we suppose b) the spin 1112 f i e l d s abey 3 c-utation r e l a t i o n s ~(%)y(;~) F(xl) +(x2) 6 (g2 and
-
-
cornate
eu3
- 5)
+(z2)
is approprgate t o Bose p a r t f c l e s ,
Thfs i s very Iuterleratl-ng becawa i t says the ""Bose qusrrk" "del
whfch
is appropriate a t low energies i a f a no fundmental way %a contradicttlion t o '"partens
as quarlcsl%t higher enerm.
a8 808e quarks
We
can call t h i s partan ~ltoclel""prtonsr
."
Next a current of SUS type a (deseribedw ha) i s
where f o r e x a w l e f o r e l e c t r i c current h" Is diagonal say hY
-3 ) .
diag.(2/3,
- l/>,
For axial current8 change y p t o
NW when we comute
currente,
WO
r e s u l t (see reference f o r detagla),
find a s h p l i e but tedFousZy complicated
W
Tc i l h s c r a t e the idea, r-Jhich i s a l l we
intend t o do here, we t&e the ease of two electrFc curreate, and also drap several t e r n s which would vanish i f w e took s p i a averaged matrix e h m n t a , then a l l that aumives i a f ~ : ( 2 ) , $:(l)
2
Bp
(
E
(
~
~
-
l
~
~
)
~
(
~
-
,P-&
~ ~s t (~2 . 1~ ) ~ 1 aT ( 1~~ 2~1) Y ~ Y ~ Y (38.3)
(plug other t e m a dropped)
(2,l on ntutwl l i g h t cone) and h
6
is diag, (4/9, 1/9, 119)
hYhY i n our caeee.
Mow we s t i l l see the quark f i e l d s in ( 3 8 . 4 1 , but the Idea n w i s t o dis-
regard
equation (38.4) and t o suggeet t h a t e q w t i o n (38.3) ( i t s generalization
t o a r b i t r a r y currents and i n c h d f n g ola;ttted t e r n of c o ~ r s e )a r e geaerally valid.
They give the l i g h t cone singuXarities and define, on the l i g h t cone a t l e a s t
.
a s e t of new operators Va(2-1).
It Ss t h e matrix elements of these operators
which give us our s t r u c t u r e functions. No d i r e c t inrplication is m d e t h a t they can be expressed a s (38.4). Eqwtion (38.4) as well a s (38.11, (38.2) a r e j u s t s c a f f o l d i n g t o a r r i v e a t (38.3) and a r e henceforth t o be forgotten, quark operators a r e seen.
I n (38.3) no e x p l i c i t
Instead only soae new b i l o c a l operators a r e defined
(mctanfng depending on two points).
They a r e defined only on t h e l i g h t cone by
the very equations (38.3) f\
[This system would be a t r u e "algebra" i f the p r o p e r t i e s of the ,J" could now be defined independeatly,
For e x a m l e , an ideal. s i t u a t i o n ( i n f a c t a
complete theory of t h e hadrans) would r e s u l t i f equations giving the Comutatars of such
ps
could be given i n t e r n of J% and
seem possible,
A l i t t l e can be done, hcwever.
?'S
themselves,
T h i s does not
Wfth the fonn (38.4) t h e
R
e o m u t a t o r s of two :g's which have t h e i r v a r i a b l e s on t h e s a m l i g h t ray (e.ge ~ : 2 ( 3 , 4 ) f*'(l,i?)] ,
3,4,1,2
*ere
cone) again can be expressed a s m but i t is n o t much. reactions l i k e e
+p
a l l l i e on a s i n g l e generator of a l i g h t This r e l a t i o n has been a l s o hypothesized,
E t gives p r e d i c t i o n s f o r c e r t a i n two-current i n c l u s i v e -c
e
+
p+
+ p- + any
those expected fro= t h e garton =del
hadrans.
They a r e , of csurse, J u s t
i n t h e s a m conditions,
Me discuss them
later,]
I n order t o w e equation (38.3) we must take the Fourier t r a n s f o m , and f o r t h a t we can w e t h e r e s u l t (very s i m i l a r t o those we have already derived, we leave d e t a i l s t o you) i f q
(v, 0, 0, u 4- N Q
t h a t is, i t involves only t h e i n t e g r a l along t h e ray t = z camon t o t h e plane t = e(from eiv(t-z))
a d t h e l i g h t cone.
Naturally every r e s u r t of t h i s theory i s a l s o a r e s u l t of t h e "parton as quarkw "eory
f o r t h e l a t t e r is a model of t h e f a m e r ; but n o t every parton.
r e s u l t can be derived from (38,3),
I t i s possible, therefore, t h a t =any of
them a r e wrong and only (38.3) and n o t the conrplete f i e l d model may survive.
Light Cane Algebra Therefore i t is i n t e r e s t i n g t o compare the t h e o r i e s f o r varfous types of predictions raade by t h e parton a s quarks theory,
They seem t o be of t h r e e
classes. A.
Scaling, r e l a t f a n s among scalfslg functions, sum rules.
B,
Sgecial a r g m e a t a about the s t r u c t u r e futlctions derived by a r g u m n t s about hadron c o l l i s i o n s and o t h e r a r g w n t s ; l i k e dx/x behavior, t o x near l, s t r u c t u r e function
r e l a t i o n of form f a c t o r power
{I.-XI~ e t c . C, Applications t o experiments of D r e l l type e+
+P p -t any
+ e-
+
hadrans o r
hadrms, etc. p + p + Glass A a r e e x a c t l y those derlved from Sight-cone algebra, obtained from l i g h t cone algebra by d e f a u l t , discussion of how t h e a a t r i x elemeat of '?{2,l)
Class B a r e aoC
That is, they simply m o u n t t o a mtght behave,
X I is n o t a
s p e c i f i c a s s m p t i o n o f the m d e l but an attempt t o go f u r t h e r t h a t leads t o Class B r e s u l t s
-a
s e r i o u s attefDpt t o discuss the nratrix elements of t h e l i g h t
corn algebra would lead fo r e s u l t s in t h i s c l a s s . Class C a r e very i n t e r e s t i n g , a s they seem beyond (38,3) and require so= extension, even thou*
they appear evident from t h e perton view.
It f e therefore
here, t e s t i n g these t h a t a r e a l choice can be made a s t o ðer the extensions of the parton model beyond t h e expectationcl of (38.3) a r e r e a l l y sound, Tlze reason the c u r r e n t c o m a t a t o r oa t h e l i g h t cone is n o t s u f f i c i e n t f o r reactions l i k e p
+p
+
p
+ + U- + X
is t h a t we do need m t r i x eletaents l i k e
but t h i s time a s we take t h e l i r a i t
M
the anomntum of t h e c u r r e n t operator
increases we a r e a l s o changing t h e s t a t e pp; t h e r e l a t i v e mamentm of t h e two protons mwt a l a o increase,
This f e an a w h a r d l i m i t f o r a theory of operators.
It is a very i n t e r e s t i n g question,
1s t h e r e so= general a b s t r a c t way
without quark f i e l d s (partons) t o describe a l l these Class C parton p r e d i c t i o n s also?
Or a r e they perhaps wrong, m r e l i a b l e extensions of t h e idea?
And what becomes of the questian of how the partons c m @ a p a r t i n t h e proton without exhibiting quark qwntura nu&ers m n g the f i n a l s t a t e s ?
Does
current algebra h e l p us t o solve i t ? Perhaps, i t s e e m t o be t r a m l a t e d i n t o "are there any representations possible of t h e algebra (38.3) &ich do not imply quark quaatuta nu&ers atoong t h e localized s t a t e s ? t h i s anathemtiral f o m than i n physical a r g m n t s .
It may be m r e t r a c t a b l e i n
Properties of Commutators in Momentum Space
Lecture 38
We now cm@t o discuss what general properties a carnutator has t o have i n Hlomnturn space, such t h a t its Fourier trslneforrn w i l l be zero outside the l i g h t cane of configuration space. This is c l e a r l y a prolnising l i n e t o follow t o a u p p k m a t physical, i n t u i t i o n on the properties of Wvv.
At present not a great deal can be s a i d , but f o r your
i n r e r e s t i a your future research &at has been done here m y prove f m i t f u l ,
First we can
so-
obvlous r e m r k s ,
I f we multiply a comutator ( i n
space-tim) by a function G which is 1 inside sad zero outside a l i g k t cone we recover the w m u t a t a r (except, a s is the case, t h a t it is s i n g d a r right m the l @ t cone where our funct%on G is poorly defined). isfi
2 2 l6aP,V,(l/q ) (O.V.
Since the F.T.
of G
pxincfpal value) we have the convolution theoran
( p l w piece@ from the 1igbr cone). (C(q) is the F,T, of a carnutator,) Xn a similar vein, since the F,T, of we see that G mwt b v e the form
182
O
is f b n i sgn(qio)a'(q
2
183
Properties cif Commutatorsin Momentum Space
O f course
plus l i g h t cone pieces,
.wr?
can say a l s o i n (39.1) t h a t the C(u1 sf
the iategrautd is any function F(u) a t a l l , and the C t h a t c o w s out on the l e f t w i l l be the F.%',
o f a ftlnetim zero outside the l i g h t cone,
1 have n a t been
much use aE these observatiom.
able t o m&
I n using the simple views h o v e we awl: be careful of one paint.
'Z"he
f u n c t i ~ nwe multiplied Gix,tZ by, G ( x , t ) , wars &fined as l i n s i d e the l i g h t cone
and O outside; h a t i s i t exactly on the l i g b t cow? ordinarily that is such a fsrnalli region t h a t i t &as
T t i s i n d e f i d t e there, no difference in the i n t e g r a l
over space tiw of C ( x , t ) G(x,r) but i n f a c t i t make@ a great mcextaiaty because Gfx,tlhas a 6 function s i n g u l a r i t y j u s t &ere G(x,t) is poorly defined.
We can
correctly straightctn out our Eomulas f o r t h i s e f f e c t i n the following way,
kle
c a l l Ca(q) the a e m p t a r i c C(q) g i v h g just the light-cone 6 s i n g u l a r i t i e s ,
man
C(q)-Ga(q)
has no l i g h t cone s i n g u l a r i t y m d eo equat20n 139.1) f o r e x a w l e , holds
i f G is replaced by C-C,
on both eridee.
Qne c m then s i q l i f y o r rearrmge tfie
equation t a obtain one flke (39.2) but with s a m ~ d d i t i o n a lt e r n r e l a t e d t o the litght cone beethaiviar, A f sr more s u b t l e and useful observation was ~nzadeby Dyson,
i n m a y probless we a l s a know C(qf
He noticed,
O f a r c e r t a i n regions of q space (where
oo incermodiate s t a r a a may be available).
For example, f o r qO
v > O the
lawest s t a t e avall&lle f o r the f i a a l s t a t e x is the pratan i t s e l f , aroving with lasoaentlzla Q (space p a r t a t q ) hence with energy
v
hen-
and f i b w i s e v < + H -
*
&son he@ proved that the necessary a d suf f i c i e n t condf tioton f o r G(q)
veniah i n repion S
S1(q)
to
q0 < S2(q) and t o have a Povrier transform vanish
oufsi4e the l i @ t cone i a t b s t C(q) cam be written tldt
where @ vanfbshr?cr outside a regiaa R, but i s othbtmlsrst a r b i t r a r y ,
The regllon R
i s such t h a t t h e (q-u)2-s2
hyperboloid does not penetrate region S.
That i t i s a s u f f i c i e n t conditian i s easy t o see ( t h e g r e a t d i f f i c u l t y of t h e proof i s t o show i t i s necessary),
We have already seen t h a t the f r e e
p a r t i c l e c o m u t a t o r Cm(x,t) is zero a u t s i d e the l i g h t cone, s o t h e F,T. 2
2
1
(q -m 1 s p ( q
is zero o u t s i d e the l i g h t cone,
by anything, i n parCicular by P
iu-X
But i f C,,(x,t)
of
is m l t i p l i e d
( o r any superposition over U) It i s s t i l l
zero o u t s i d e the l i g h t cone, hence F.T. eiue"~m(n,f)
sgn(qo-uo ) 6 ( ( q - ~ 1 2 - d ) . 2 2 Hence superposing with weight @ ( u , s ) various cases of u and m s2 we g e t
I t i~ easy t o see, by drawing hypczrbolzls t h a t f o r our caee t h e region R
2 o f i n t e g r a t i o n where @(u,s ) does n o t vanish i s a s follows
i n s i d e two canes For a2 >
2
For s2
M!
h0k/4
U
i n s f de region bounded by M -lug/
-
u
h c i d e n t a l f y , t h e s c a t t e r i n g a q f i t u d e t h a t corresponds t o t h i s c m u t a t o r ( w i n g 337.2) becorns
where o (from s e a g u l l s ) is a polynomial i n q u ( f o r the amplitude
replace
LE(qo-aO) by i h ) . One of the d i f f i c u l t i e s I n w i n g the Dyeon representation is t h a t the function @
is n o t unique, m n y can give t h e s a m G(q).
has Been derived (I suspect not: aa rigorously
Another very s i m i l a r representatian asj
Dyaon's) by b s e r , C i f b e r t and
Sudarshm e s p e c i a l l y f o r a problern l i k e eure where C is a function only of t h e two i n v a r i a n t s
QL,
v,
i t is
185
Propertb of Commutatorsin &mefiturn S p c e This is, of course, j u s t Dyeon's representation i f the four vector
U
can be
a s s m d t o have only a time component, t h a t is, only a contponent i n t h e p
P
df r e c t i o n . There is again the expectation t h a t B(a,B) is zero o u t s i d e a more l i m i t e d
-G/Mt o
Leave our expressions i n t a c t , j u s t rentexnbexing If(a,B)
6 for
6
2 H
.
2 M , B only runs from
range i f o
In f a c t i f a
.t.
&/M, but we in
this region of a .
L t is c2ear t h a t if C is zero on t h e l i g h t cone various gradients a r e s o s e v e r a l p o s s i b i l i t i e s e x i s t with d i f f e r e n t i n t e g r a l p w e r s of v [from
&so,
zero up t o any f i n i t e v a l m ) with correrrpanding B functions; h u t we have taken the one appropriate t o 2Wl.
Equivalently we c m w r i t e our f o m with a new
definition f a r o,
I n addition, f o r our c m e , t h e a s y m e t r y i n
tlrtnas
f o r the e o m u t a t o r becorns
t h e property t h a t
T h t ~representation is very nice, and h is prob&ly tyQiq2y deter&ned by HI.
The weaicnera, h w e e r , i s t h a t no physical i n t e r p r e t a t i o n o r ezrpressfon
i n t e m of nratrix e l e m n t s is given f o r h(cr,@), T'hereEore we cannot use any physical i n t u i t i o n I n g w s f r h g haw h should behave? (other than using our h w l e d g e of how M brsheves and trorking bakward), @ay
- such a f w c t i o n f o r h(a,f3)
4.8
m a t 8s t o say we c a m o t a t any s t a g e
too 'krazy" "yeically
behave s o and fro i n t h i s mgion, e t c .
- or
i t ought ta
As we s h a l l see, t h i s i a a s e r i o u s
weakaess i n t h i s carse. We am t u r n t o s e e how h(a,B)
=WC
behave In order t o produce a function
2MWl behavlng a s we expect (see UcCWcs 3l)for l a r g e
F i r s t of a11 we have t h e s e a l i n g l%&t
Bere
= f ( X ) a Emetion of
X
only.
v
+ m.
Eq. (39.7)
V
(we t a b v
2
-q
givemt
O throughout).
.r m, - q 2 / 2 ~ v
-
x finite.
(sgn(v+BM) = I f o r
large v, s i n c e v > M).
Now i f we a s s u m b(a ,B) lnvcalved here, so
v
f a l l s away rapidly enouejrt with a only f i n i t e
c;
are
the
a c m be dropped i n the 6 function and we have
X believe i t was t h i s a r g
t with t h e Dyson retpresentacican which e i t h e r
+
OD
l e d Bjorken t o Iris s c a l i n g hypothesis, o r helped t o confilaa h i e e w p i c i o n e of
its t r u t h , qL >
o
scaling
We have here a ISOR=+ should go i n the p o s i t i v e q 4-q
2
jJe:
2
2
c m n w deternine how the f m c t i o n 2M1(q r v )
s e a l i n g region.
Letting v
+ m,
q2
-r
such t h a t
m
/22Vfv = x' is f f n i t e we have 2Wl =
(D, -xt))da which again s c a l w ; but
even m r e , from the s
NW c m we s e e t h i s rernarkablle r e s u l t from the partan model? equally well derive t h e funetion f o r qZ
; .
Can we
0 by using physical a r g u m ~ t s l We
w i l l explain q u a l i t a t i v e l y haw P t corns etbout. Por p o s i t i v e q2 we muat be concerned i n the c o m a f a t o r (36.1) with the 2 subtracted v a c u w p i e m , I n the vacurn we eaa a e p a i r s , and a t high q jwt
kle a r e concerned with hcrw t h i s p a i r production probability is tllodified by t h e presence of a proton
At f i r s t one oofght think the niodification must c o w throwgIr i n t e r a c t i o n of
187
Proparties of Commutaforsin Momentum Space the newly fnade paxtons with those i n the proton
- in
i n t e r a c t i o n about which
we know l i t t l e except t h a t i t is f i n i t e and i a not involved i n our derivation o f f(x) f o r negative q
2
exclueion principle
.
But a t high energy a: =re important effect: Ss the
- partons c a n o t be m d e i f
the proton ( i f F e d s t a t i a t i w is a s s m d ) . b i l i t y t o produce a the charge is 2/31,
Thus i n our diagram the proba-
t o the l e f t mid u t o the r i g h t a t x ' i s 4 / h U i t s (for Hmever, i t is a l t e r e d a t those x by the chance, u(x), that:
a u parton is present i n the protan. t o (4/9u(x9; i f the
they a r e already pre8ent Sn
G
Thus we have a contribution p r o p o r t i o n d
parton is w v i n g fomard i t is (4/13)~(xV. ZE a d par-
ton p a i r is produeed the probability Ss 119, mdifsed by the chance af f i n a n g
a d partoa already i n the proton, the contribution i s (1/9)d(xV, e t c . ) the e n t i r e contribution is 4/9[u(x8 f&(x")l+
1/9[d(x')+d"(xt) )l
Thus
+ 1/53 [a(x ")+;(X"
)l
o r fep(xt) ss required.
I n =king atstisties,
2
the analysis f o r q positive we aae-d
the quarks obeyad F e d
I f Bose s t a t i s t i c s a r e used i n the f o m l expression of the con-
pLeted surn over s t a t e s (34.1) we kave aoae changes,
F i r s t there is a change i n
s i g n of the F e w exclueion e f f e c t turning i n t o a Base tendency t o increase m i s s i o n beeawe a p a r t i c l e is already present,
sip
iin
men there is =other
chage in
the closed-loop diagram 4 [JJIO> when changing f rorn F e d t o Boae
s t a t i e t S e s [see, f o r exmple, R,P, Fe
, Phys,
756 (1949) 1,
Rev.
On the other Ixmd with the Botle s t a t i s t i c s sign the iaagiaary p a r t of
< O ~ J J ~ Ois> negative and i t cmnat be written ae a sum of positive p r o b a b i l i t i e s C ll
2
, but
1s minus t h a t
SW.
'Fais circurnstmce i s the b w i a of the
X
w u a l proofs of the r e l a t i o n of s p i n md ~ l t a t i s t i e s ;spin one-half p a r t i c l e s c m o t be consftltently gncerpreted ss Bose p a r t i c l a s , incerpre t a t i o n o f Base qmrlcs would
e e 3.
-I.
l%e mst s t r a i g h t f o w a r d
the "'Dxelf Constant" defined f o r the
any hctdrons ctose section waufd have the impassible value -21 3 ,
a%
course a c o w l e t e l y naive i n t e r p r e t a t i o n af quarks a s Bose p a r t i c l e s would a l s o lead t o the wrong r e s u l t t h a t the wave function would be s the i n t e r e h a n p o f two protm&. problem would be? remved.
I f quarks obey para-stetretics both of these
Me c o n t i n w our discussion of equation (39.7) now turning t o the region v
+
-, -q2 f i n i t e .
Here we expect 2W
which we have wrftten a s 2F?tW3
1
t o go a s v times a function of q
2
2Hv g(-q )I(-q
2
)
.
2
I n t h i s region c u r equation
(39.7) reads
a t f i r s t sight, for v
-+
=, we could forget -'-a
i n the 6 and obtain ZW1
9D
h(cr,o)da,
a czcnstant indepndent of q
2
asld evidently i n c o r r e c t ,
-
Elmever,
0 the "ceanstant" would, by (39.3) be f(o) which we know is i n f i n i t e , a s f o r small
% i s suggests t h a t we assume f o r smll 13 chat h ( o , ~ ) is singular.
ajx.
f(x)
X,
Sllbstitutfng i n the Antegral above gives
f o r small 8 ,
Thus
gives t h e -q g(-
2
) a s -q
2 2
dewndence of the t o t a l - v i r t u a l photon cross s e c t i o n , g e t s l a r g e approache
Finally we t u r n t o region 111: kept f i n i t e .
of MH -; '
There we expect 2MWl
only.
(~:-d)
v
+
-, large
-q
2
but
m
2Hv
- (-g 2 3
2 2 (-q2)-yh(~x -M )ZHv where h i s a fvncrion
The ( q q 2 ) ~is t y p i f i e d by t h e e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g (H:-M~
and y i n perhaps 4 o r 5. h
Tke I&&tof
goes ss A(H:-M~I'-'.
Far n near 1, f(n) A ~ ( l - x ) y - l and f o r l a r g e M:+~~
0)
Properties Ilf Cczmmuratavs in Nortleii;tttnSpace I n t h i s region our equation (39. '7) reads
dg &(H~-M~+~MV(B-X)-B)~(~,B>
Again a "natural" gvess (neglect
M:-$*
(40.1)
r e l a t i v e t o 2Mv(~-l) in the 6 function)
OJ
l e a d s t o t h e wmng answer:
do h (a ,l),
2Wl
a c a a s t a n t indepenrtenr of
JO But again we can f i x i t up by a more eomplicared guess f o r the behavior
*$-:M
of h(o,B) near B = I.
-
X
y
Because, from (39.9
do h(a,x)
$8
zero a8
X
+
1 (like
Therefore one way t o g e t t h e answer would bc t o aesume t h a t h(o,B)
goes t o zero near B
I, For e m q l e suppose
D(o) (l-Bjy-'
h(a,8)
D(a)da
A,
wf(*l
(Xf we =sum y &pen& on a we c m be m r e general and
g e t n e a r l y t h e s a w f i n a l r e s u l t except: wSth e o m slow logarithmic dependence@, which &ght i n f a c t be &ere i n t h i s region, eweriarrzntally) X-@
.
This is not: k s r m very w e l l
S u b s t i t u t i n g i n t o (4a.l) and i n t e g r a t i n g ( t h e B f w c t i o n s a y s
2 2 (Hx -M -a)/2Mv) we g a t
hence of t h e c o r r e c t farm i f ( c a l$l-:H
= 13
X
%is appears a t f i r s t s a t i s f a c t o r y ; h w i l l hawe the r i g h t m p p t o t i c behavfor hiy-' f o r l a r g e h i f D(o) f e l l s o f f fast enough with
U,
and
mwever, we w i l l agaLn be fooled i n our q u a l i t a t i v e expectations f o r h(X) fro= t h i s equrztion i f
W@
suppose t h a t D(U) is a sinrple funetion,
llhe operation of
i n t e g r a t i o n i n ( 4 0 . 3 ) is a very poverful sraoothing operation; f a r no siarpXf?
D(@) would we be l e a d t o guess what we k n w i s t r u e
- t h a t h ( ~ )shows a s e r i e s
of peab and v a l l e y s f o r s m l l h , t h e r e s o n a c e p e a s ,
I t f s n o t t h a t (40.3)
aays resonance p e a b a r e inqpossible
- i t is t h a t
( 4 0 . 3 ) plus a @-ss t h a t D(#)
is not too c o w l i c a t e d (i.e. does not vary ia a rapid and peculiar way) f a i l s t o do so. D(A)
To s e e t h i s take the case
g1
dS
y
4 and note t h a t (lr0,3) can be solved as
(40.4)
h(&)
J
The fourth d e r i v a t i v e of a reaonmce o s c i l l a t e s i n a very s p e c i a l nrmner
.
(For
a mueh more i n t e l l i g e n t way t o &a1 with t h e resonance regfan s e e Cornwall, Corrigan and Norton, Phys, Rev,
536, (l"31)
a d the next section.)
r i z e t h i s i n v e s t i g a t i o n , the Deser, Gilbert, fudarslhan representation
is useful a s a f o m l t o o l t o g e t dispersion r e l a t i o n s , e t c .
It is, eis of course
i t ought t o be, cs;pabfe of representing what we know of the experimental d a t a
with s o m function h(o,B). utility
- by
But i t i s disappointing i n t h a t its p r e d i c t i v e
-
gwasine, ""reasonable" hbrsv%or f o r h(~r,t?;) is not very g r e a t f i r s t
becausie we have no physical. p i c t u r e of what the function f s , lad second I t s e e m l i k e a function t h a t behaves I n a way a s cornglicated. a s ( I f n o t = r e
coqlicated
&an) the data i t s e l f .
It s e e m t h a t h ( # , @ ) Is n o t , i n f a c t , a function t h a t has much d i r e c t physical s i g n i f i c a n c e md is purely an a r t i f i c i a l expression i n a c e r t a i n m t h e m t i c c r l form of t h e f a c t t h a t the c a m t a t o r vmgsbes outside the l & t COne * It h g h t pay t o try t o Elind another representation of t h i s f a c t i n which
the k e r n e l Eunctions may have s o w d i r e c t physical representation,
Scattering i n the Deser, G i l b e r t , Sudarshan representation Given the c o m a t a t o r i n any f o m we c m find the s c a t t e r i n g amplitude
2
T(q ,v) correspandfng t o i t by w i n g the dispersion r e l a t i o n (37.2) , f t is e a y t o s e e by d i r e c t s u b s t i t u t i o n of (39.7) t h a t t h e s c a t t e r i n g kThich has 2 t h e rLght s p i n depsndence (i.e. 6uv q -q Irq v p a r t ) t o corxespond t o 2 N 1 ( c a l l i t
191
Properties af Commutators in Momentum Space This is t h e causal m p l i t u d e c o n v ~ n t i o n ,i n the Feynmn convention t h e 2 The "eeagufls" a r e a polynomfal i n q ,v,
i e sgn(v+MB) is replaced siarply by i t s .
2 This can be r e a d i l y v e r i f i e d ( s i w 1 y n o t i c e t h a t rsgn(vM8)6(q +;?Hvfl*)
-
s~R(v+MB)
2 2 2 112 where we have w r i t t e n E = +(G+M B +q ) ).
~ @ * N B ) ~ - E ~ )(6(v+MB-E)-6(v+MB+E))/ZE
& t e 1: Bftcauee we a r e expressing Tl
8bi
an i n t e g r a l with a v f a c t o r times t h e
i n t e g r a l we have r e a l l y been working with W/v and Tlv; but there is a pole i n v(%
+
0 as v
+
To avoid t h l s use i n our dispersion r e l a t i o n
0 but Tl does n o t ) ,
V1/v t o g e t fT1(q
2
,v)-T1(4
2
,O))/v.
Note 2: X t is evident Eroar (40.5) and (4Q.B) t h a t although derived front the
P
dispersion r e l a t i o n PR
V
f o r fixed Q {space p a r t of q) they a l s o s a t i s f y a
dispersion r e l a t i o n i n v f o r fixed q
2
2 (for q
Q) (a one@ s d t r a e t e d dispersion
relation)
2 ( h s d n g =a eeagulla beyond a conatcurt term absorbed i n Tl ( q ,Q).
This c m be
seen by d i r e c t s u b s t i t u t i o n of (40.6) i n t o (4Q.6a), relnembering t h a t W ( ~ ~ , - V =. ) 2
-W(q , v t ) , i.e.
t h a t h(cr,B) m-h(a,-S).
Consider
everything i s c l e a r except t h e icegrctft should be icsgn(*M6). work with v
Q (T is s ~ e t r i l c i n
V).
Then f o r q 2
Let us choose t o
O t h e r e i@ no pole i n
( s 2 + 2 ~ ~ v a + i c ) - ' i f fl is negative, the s i p of i c is a r b i t r a r y ; we may replace by sgn(v.t.4il8).
I f B > 0, sgnB
(For v negative the s i g n reversea.)
-b
= sgn(*m)
Itence we have
s o i t is s t i l l , c o r r e c t ,
I92
Photon-Hdrsn Interactions
Wl/vp is a y m e t r i c s o we? c m s e t t h e range front Q t o l&u
'- ( v + i ~ ))
-
2 -h/( - v ' ~ + ( v + ~ c ))
.
with l/(v'-(v+ik))
.t
F r w t h i s equation (40.6a) follows.
For W which c o n v e r p e Easter we expect a corresponding uneubtracred 2
d%apersion r e l a t i o n
2
for q
W2 (q , v ' )
For qZ
Q these a r e of course t h e Kronig-Kramers
2
4
.
O
formula9 r e l a t i n g r e a l and
i m g i n a r y p a r t s of the index of r e f r a c t i o n ( f o w a r d l i g h t s c a t t e r i n g ) which
is necessary i f s i g n s l s a r e not t a corn out before they go i n t o a block of s c a t t e r i n g nratsrial,
We t r y now once again (msucc;essFully a s i t w i l l turn a u t ) t o t r y t o oBtktin s o w expected l i d t a t i m s on 2MWI b e c a w e we kaow i t is a caueaf (zero outside the l i g h t cone i n space) c m u t a t a r , v a l i d not only f o r l a r g e
V
Ttris time we s h a l l use behavior
For e x a q l e we h o w f o r t h e
but f o r my xeglon.
e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g , i f t h e proton were a point &arge we would have f o r v > 0, 2 2W1 Z H ~ 6 ( ( p + q ) ~ - d )= 2Hv6(q +ZHv). (To g e t the c o r r e c t s
-
p o s i t i v e and negative t h i s can be w r i t t a n = r e 2 6 ( q +2m?rv)
- sgn(v-M)S(q
2
-2Mv)).
2 Mv(sgnCv+M)
c o r r e c t l y a s 2Wl
This is o b d o u s l y cauaal
- as
W@
have seen
-
Ear i t coaes from perturbation theory o f fielcls. Now in the r e a l world t h i s is a d t i p l i e d by a f a c t o r ( t h e square of t h e 2 e l s e t i c form f a c t o r ) , a f a c t i o n of qZ, say f (q 1 which f e l l s o f f gradually. 2 f o r negative q , from q2
-
Q, to behave a s (_q2)-y f o r l a r g e -q
2
.
One would
expect such m d u l a t i a n of the f w c t i o n expected f a r point-like particles r o represent some kind of s m a r i a g of t h e point and t o perhaps irayrly a lack of causality
-a
lack which must be balanced by c o r r e c t contributions from t e w
o f f t h e e l a s t i c mass s h a l l (correeponding t o o t h