This page intentionally left blank
Andcl-son: Dasic Notions of Condcnsctl 1lqattc1-f3hysics, ARC ppl>k, lSBN 0-201-32830-9 Atiyah: K-'fheory, AB@ ppl~k,1SBK 0-201-40792-2 Rcthc: fntcr-mctliatc Quantum Mechanics, ABC pphk, ISRK 0-201-32831- 3
Ciicmmoxtr: I3tctrocrt) namic s of Particles and Ptasrnas, ARC ppbk, 1SBX 0-20147986-9 Ilacitlscjn: Physics of Xanneutrat f31asn-ras, ABC pphk ISBK 0-201-57830- 1
ctTf-,si~agnat: Corrcrptual 1.oundations (lua~ltumMtchanics, AKC ppbk, 1SBK 0-7382-0104 9 iieynn.ran: f3hoton-Haclran fntcr-actions, ARC pphk, XSBK 0-201- 36074-8 Iscynman: Quantum l:tcctrodynamics, ABC ppbk, ISBN Q- 201 - 36075-4 iieynn.ran: Statistical ~lqcchanics,ARC pphk, XSBK 0-201- 36076-4 I:cynman: * f i r o r >of 1.utrdanrcrrtal 1'1-occsscs, ABC ppbk, fSBK 0-201- 36077-2 iiorstc.r: l4ydrotljnamic X;tuctuations, Drokcn Symmcrry, and Correlation X;unctions, ARC pphk, ISRPU' 0-201-41049-4 Ccli-hfann/Xe'eman:'fhe kightfotct Way, AB@ pplk, 1SBK 0-7382-0299-1 Gon&icd: Quantun.r Mechanics, ARC pphk, ISRN 0-201-40633-0 Kactanoff/Bajm: Qr~a~rtrim Statistical Mechanics, AKC ppbk, ISBN 0-201-41i1.2-6-X KhaIarnikoc :An Intro to thc "Theory of Stipcr-Ruitlity, AARC pphk, ISRN 0-7382-0300-9 Ma: Modern'fheory of Criticat t%henomena, ABC ppbk, ISBN Q-"138-0301-7 Migtlal: Qualitatixcl Mellttods in Quantum Theory, AARC pphk, fSI3S 0-7382-0302-9
r\lcgclc/Orfand: Quantum Many- t%articlc Systems, ABC pplhk, lSBN Q-"138-0052-2
No/iei-cs/X'incs:'I'hcory of Qtianturn I,icluicls, ABC pphk, ISRK 0-7382-0229-0 Koziercs: Df"hcoryof interacting Iscrmi Systems, AB@ ~ j p l ~ kISBN , 0-201- 32824-0 X'arisi: Statistical I.:iejd 'I'hcory, ABC pphk, ISRK 0-7382-0051-4I'iincs: Etcmcntary I k c i ~ t i o r r sin Solids, ABC ppbk, fSBN 0-7382-01 1 5-4 1'incs:'I'hc 1Wanj-Body X'robtcm, ABC pphk, ISRK 0-201-32834-8
Q u i g : Garrgc*Ibcaricsof the Strong, Weak, and I:lccti-omagnctic fnteractiorrs, ABC pplzk, ISWK 0-0-201-32832-1 Richartison: Fxpcrin-tcntal'lkchniyues in Condensed Martcr X'hysics at I ow 'fempcratnrcs, ABC pphk lSRS 0-201 - 36078-El 12ohrlich: Classical Chargcs t%articlcs, ABC ppbk ISBN 0-201-48 300-9 Schi-iegcr: Theory of Supcrconducti~ity, ARC jq"fhk fSI3S 0-7382-0120-0 "ihwingcr: t%articlcs, "iourccs, and Ficfdr Vol. 1, I"IBC plibii ISB?; Q-"182-0053-0 Schwingcr: Particles, Sources, and Fictds Vol. 2, ABC: ppEA ISBX 0-7382 -0054-9 Schwingcr: Particles, Sctui-ccs, and Ficlcts'riol. 3, ABC pphk
ISRX 0-7382-0055-7 "ihwingcr: Quantum Kinematics and Dynamics, I"IBC plibii, ISBK 0-"182-030 3- 3
"Thorn: Structura! Stability and 1Worphogcnesis,ARC ppbk, ISB?; 0-201-40685-3 Whyld: Mathematical Mcthods for 13hhysics,ABC pppbk, ISBN 0-"138-0125-1
NTERACTIONS
RICHARD P. FEYNMAN late, California Institute of Technology
" L
i
/
*
~*q%
Addvnnccd Book Pmgnm,
i
- , /' A Member af the Xlcrseus Books Group
Libmry of Congress Catalogixlgin~Pu'Et1ica;tion Data Feynman, Richard PhiHips. Photon-hadron tnteracrrions I Richard Feynman. p. cm. - (Advanced book cfassics series) Originally published : Reading, Mass. : W. A. Benjamin, Advanced Book Program, 2912. (Frontiers in physics) Includes index, 1. Photon-hadron mteract-ions. 2. Hadron interacdons. 1. Title. XI, Series.
QC/93,S,IE)428F49 1989
539.1Y544~19
89-30697
XSBN 0-201-36014-8 (paperback)
Copyright O 1912, 1998
All: rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a renieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any meatas, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written pemission of the publisher. Printed in the United States of America, Westview Prcss 1s a Mcmhcr of the Perscus Books Group.
Cover design by Suzanne Weiser
2345678910 First printing, February 1998
Find us on the World Wide Web at htt~:www.we~ieli~~ress.com
Editor's Foreword
Addison-Wesley's F~ontiersin Physics series has, since 1961, made it possible for leading physicists to communicate in coherent fashion their views of recent developments in the most exciting and active fields of physics-without having to devote the time and energy required to prepare a formal review or monograph. Indeed, throughout its nearly forty-year existence, the series has emphasized informality in both style and content, as well as pedagogical clarity. Over time, it was expected that these informal accounts would be replaced by more formal counterparts-tex tbooks or monographs-as the cutting-edge topics they treated gradually became integrated into the body of physics knowledge and reader interest dwindled. However, this has not proven to be the case for a nurnber of the volumes in the series: Marry works have remained in prim on an on-demand bmis, while others have such intrinsic value that the physics community has urged us to extend their life span. The Aduanced Book Classics series has been designed to meet this demand. It will keep in print those volumes in Frontiers in Physics or its sister series, Lecturre Notes ~ n Supipkments d in Physics, that continue to provide a unique account of a topic of lasting interest. And through a sizable printing, these cIassics will he made available at a comparatively modest cost to the reader. These notes on Richard Feynman's lectures at Caltech on the topic of photon-hadron interactions, in which he developed his theory of partons, were first published some twenty-five years ago. As is the case with all of Feynman's lectures, the presentation in this work reflects his deep physical insight, the freshness and originality of his approach to understanding physics, and his overall pedagogical wizardq. As a result, this volume will always be of fundamental
importance to anyone interested in understanding the development of quantum chromodynamics (QCD)--the theory of quarks and gluons--which explains hadron-hadron interactions at high energies. David Pines Urbana, Illinois December 1991
Preface
Many of us wem first in~dtlcecito the concepts of the p m n model from this b k At h t lllme the eompting view ww one in which there were no elemenm pheles, E v e ~ p d c l e was suppsd tn, be a campsite of evey other pdcle. The ideas and conmpts in &isbook h v e helpd pave &e way far our undersmding of the constituentname of trra&ons which evennially led ts the Quantum Chmnndynamic (WD)&wq of qu&s and gluo'ns, & is m e of most of Feynmank b b s , the maximum bnefit is o b ~ n e ifd one has previowly studied the subjeer in some d e ~ fFcynmank . unique:p r s p t i v e can br;be a p ~ w i a t d by rwdws with a mlid b ~ k g o m din the subject. Although this book is dmost l8 yms otd, it still is an excellent referace, It a m a s on the raomntenkd rmding fistof &I thecmmtwD b k s , Tke bkprovidcs a g d undersmdingof ltfte m d d from rheman who invenkd it. In the "pre-QGW or "'naive" "on m d e i tfie constituents within ha&ons were assume8 u> b hunded in the transvers dlr~tion,The pmbability of finding a pmon wifftin a high momentm ha&on wi& a lmge msverrze momentum was assumed to fd1 like a Gaussian or an expnential. W D ells us that this is not exactfy &rueand givesa p w e r law fall-off in the transverg momentum, Beeause of this, many ""nve" "on mode8 e x p t a ~ o nare s mabifid (in an inzportant way) by Xogarlrhmic faem, Feynmru?used t;s laugh when his pmon mdeI was refened to as "n&ve,'"and he wollld say, ""At l m t X got it ~ g hup t to lag;&&rns." We all miss Feynman v e q much a d it is through books like this hat his id= live on,
Vita
Richard P. Feynmn Born in 1918 in Brooklyn,Richard P, Feyrrmm receivedhis %,D. from Princem in 1942, &spite his youth, he played an imwmat part in the mnhattan Reject at Las AImw World W N 11. Suwuenrfy, he taught at Gomen and at the WiEsmia ins tit^ of Twbnolqy, In 19Cj5 he r e c d v d the Nob1 Rize in Physics, along witb Sin-Imm Tanzmaga and Jutian Schwinger*far his wark in qwntum elm@dyamies. Dr. F e ~ won m his NakI Prize for suaessfuflyresolvingpmblents wirh the Wry.of qmtum elee&&ynmics, He aka e r a d a m e m a G c d of W& in~mcGonssuch fm&enral work in the man play& a key mk in the devefopment of q w k theory by puwg made1 of high energy pmmn callisian prmsses, Beyond these achievements, Dr. Rynman introducd bsic new cmputa~onal S which, Whniqws and nob~ons intophysics, aboveall, the ubiquiausFeynmn thl:way perfiaps mare than my other famdim in raent scientific hisw, have in whkh bak physiGaX qrmgses m mnceptualizd and calcufaM, was a a m a W ly effwtive &=-re Of alI his nmerous &wads,he ud of the & m ~ dM&l for Tmhlng which he wan in f 972. T k was FeynmanLechrresonPhysics, originally published in 1963.were described in ScientiftcAmesican as "tough, but nourishing and full of flavor. ARer 25 guide for -hers and for the it>est d ibeginning students." fn order to un&rstan&g of physics among the lay public, Ilr:Feynman wrote The Physicgl h w & &.E9,: Tbre Strer~geT k o v QfLighf and mat^ fir: numbr of advac& publieations that have k o m e class&refeerences an Riehard Feynmm died on F e b r u q 15, r988.
Editor's Foreward Special Preface Vita Preface
1-5
GENERAL THEORETICAL BACKGROUND Fast Order Coupling C @ ~ r n & o of n Gwent 2nd @da C~upling Uni&ty 2nd
Immpic Spin, Smgeness, CenedM C
Consemarion of C m e d M Cumn@ SJnmM#@on &@Light Cone Vacuum Expectation of V,, f l, 2) No&: h o y i n g Point Cornnzu~r
bblems
618
LOW ENERGY PHOTON REACTIONS
8-10 QUARK MODEL OF RESONANCES The Qu& Mdel Note Roblern CJcuIadon of MW Elements Feymm, Kislhge~and Ravndal, Phys. &v. (I97 X)
11-12 PSEUDQSCALAR MESON PHOTOPRODUCTION, HIGH ENERGY p%udascaiath/ifaon Phompxduetion--Nigher Energies References
13-14 E-CHANNEL EXCHANGE PHENOMENA tehannel Excbnge Pknomena Comments S-Chmnef Resomees Venezima Fomuh Estimaks af Coupling Cartsbnts
I4-%lVECTOR MESONS AND VECTOR MESON DQMIINAMCE HYPOTHESIS Roprties of Veemz Memns Elecmn RMuetion of Vecmr Mmarts Vwtw Mema Mminancie M d e l 175 as ifs VDM md Photon Ha&on In&r%tians Difhctive RMuc~onof P, M, ~t Q h r Tmts of VBM Shdowing in Nuclei To Sunnmae the Position of VDM
22-24 ELECTROMAGNETIC FORM FACTORS Elecmm;lgnedc Fom Factors Nuelmn
In b b Fmtam (emtin@ Pion Fom F=&r b t o n Fom h;ac&r for Positive q2 Note
25-26 ELlECTRON~PRQTQNSCA
DEEP mELASTXC REGION Xnelatic Eicxmn Nuclean SeaWng
fnehtic Bjecmn Nuelm Samring (eontinud) mwv of tfie Inelastic Elec&onb m n $catering
26-33 PARTON MODEL P m n Mdei n Mdef (eontinud) I'beW a Regim The Re@aaNW X = 1 The Region -q2Large Finite &gumeat &ilt ' = r Gene& R e ~ abut k the Power Law (q"f P m n s as Qwks Mamenwm C h c d by the Qwks Mdets Future Ta& of Chagd b p Inelastic Scszt&~ngwith Spin
M-35 TESTS OF THE, PARTON MODEL Angular Momentum in P m n Wave Fmcdom
-
r Expriments Testing P m n Idea (mlQ p + p v+v- + Anything EEeemn P& RducGon of
36-37 INELASTIC S C A n E R m G AS PIROPERTmS;OF OPERATORS
38
LIGHT CONE ALGEBRA
39-41 PROPERTES OF COMMUTATORS IN MQMEWIJM SPACE e o ~ d eofs Cornrnumwrs in Mommtum Spw Region I Base sr Femi Quaks Region 11 Region liIX
02-47 ELECTROMAGNETIC SELF ENERGY Efe~tFQmagne~c Self Energy Co~ghm Fomu1a Exprasion for Sdf Ewrgy in T e r n s of W Only O&cg Elw&om@e~c Energia,Qumk Mdel Elecmmpe~cSelf Mss, Q m k Mdel (continued) I = 2 2 s Differe agnetie W s Differences F d e r Cammm& on Elm CornpenEffet ~ p y +p OX Y ~ I ~n C o m p ~ nEffmt far Very SmaIE Q , V Forwad Gornpton Scattp;ringfrom Non-Relarivistic Scbwdinger Eqw~an +
4&49 OTHER TWO-CURRENT EFFECTS
50-51 HYPOTHESES IN THE PARTON MODEL
52-54 HADRON-HADRON COLLISIONS AT
EXTREME ENERGIES
55
FINAL HADRONIC STATES IN DEEP WELASTIC SCAmERINC IntPIrxtion of P m n s with the Efmmmapetie field Ragion of Finite #, V + Continuity of Large qzand Small x Region
56-57 PARTONS AS QUARKS
Preface The most advanced corn% in graduatl:theoretid physics at Caltmh is "*id Togih h T b r e ~ c aPhysics," l Esh yesu the professor &mmthe &piewith which he will deal, This y w (1971-73, having just come back from the 1991 Inemahonal Symposium on Elwmn auld Pho~onI n ~ r ~ l i oat n sHigh Energies, held at Come11Univemity, my own in&resrin the subjst was:mud, md f chase to malyu: thev&ous theoreticat questions ~ k tad hat eanference, The Eeetmsaerns1ves&me sa exmsive &at the deeision waxr made to put &em in@W k fom, with the tfioughr t hs other p p l e might atso be inmesM. Thus, the reps of the Comelt conference should be mnsidered W a compmian volume to these lectme notes. The references given here are far from comple@,but a full list of references is givert in the Rwdings of rhe Symposium, publish4 by the tory of Nuctw Stdies, Comdl tlnivenity, Jan The m & ~ dis d 4 t with on an advanced level; far ins-=, kmwEedge of the theory of hadron-hadran interactions is assumed. I have tried to analyze in detail where we stand theoretically today. The ueament is somewhat uneven; for example, I should have l&& trr study the &wryof the decay of the in more detail than I was able to do, On the o&er hand, there are long discussions of vector m a o n dominmce and af inelastic scattering. The possible consequencesof the parton model are fully discussed. Time did not pernit me to complete the original plan which was to include the Wry of weak interaction currenrs which are so closely related to elecmmagnetic cments. Many thanks must g o t Muro Cisneros whoedited,corrected,andextended the l e c ~ efrom s my class now. Wilhout his effort, this book would not have k n possible. X afso wish to &ank Ms. Helen Tuck for typing the leemre notes.
Photon-Hadron Interactions
This page intentionally left blank
Theoretica Background
Lecture l
One very powerful way of experLmentally i n v e s t i g a t i n g t h e strongly
i n t e r a c t i n g p a r t i c l e s (hadraas) fs t a look a t the@, t o probe them with a Imm p a r t i c l e ; i n p a r t i c u l a r t h e photon (no o t h e r i s E u x m a s w e l l ) .
This
per&ta a much f i n e r c o n t r o l of v a r i a b l e s , and probably decreases t h e t h e o r e t i c a l c a p f e x i t y o f trhts i n t e r a c t i o n s ,
F"or example Sn an ordinary
hadron-hadron coLlSsion l i k e np -, sp we a r e h i t t i n g two unknoms together, and f u r t h e r , we can only vary t h e energy, we cannot vary t h e
y
+p
"P
p
"t
2
of t h e pion
In f a c c a "pion f a r off its aass s h e l l " may be a
which mast be mw2. maningless
(3
- or at
l e a s t hi&fy conrplicated i d e a ,
C?n t h e o t h e r hand in.
n we knaw t h e y Is s i n g l e and d e f i n i t e , and we can vary the cgL
of t h e y by using v i r t u a l y % svi,
for e x m p l e , e l e c t r o n s c a t t e r i n g
We a r e a a s s d n e ; t h a t we do knaw t h e photon,
QED has been checked s o
c l o s e l y t h a t we know t h a t i f t h e p h o t m propagator were off by a f a c t o r of the form (1
- qZ/h2)-1
t o about 5% for q
2
then h exceeds 4 o r 5 &V.
a s high a s ( 1 &V)
s h a l l a a s w QED is exact.
2
.
The w l i t u d e s a r e k n w n
For t h e r e s t of t h i s course we
There Is already evidence, a s we s h a l l sear, t h a t
i n v i r t u a l photon-hadmn c o l l i s ions the photon a c t s nomaf Ly (i.e
., obeys
QED expectations) up t o A of 6 t o B EeV,
At any r a t e we s h a l l suppose QED exact
- where
we m a n by QED the standard
i n t e r a c t i o n theory f o r eleetrone, muGns and photons.
Exact, but i n c o q l e t e
f o r hadrons a r e charged and i n t e r a c t a l s o with the QED system. f i r s t : how we s h a l l a s s w e
-
He discuss
we can describe t h i s i n t e r a c t i o n .
Since eL is small i t is natural, t o describe t h e i r i n t e r a c t i o n i n a s e r i e s of orders i n e ,
One photon exchange, two photon exchange,
etc.
( f t might
be thought t h a t t o describe t h i s coupling we s h a l l have t o have so= dynamical theory of t h e hadrons
- ultimtely,
of course, yes
- but
detailed
some
things can be s a i d i n general r e s t r i c t i n g t h e m t x i x elements whatever the underlying hadran dynaaics
- and
i t is these r e s t r i c t i o n s we seek i n t h i s
lecture.) Tfie no coupling ease presents no problem.
The f a c t o r giving the m p l i t u d e
t h a t a hadron system goes from an incoming s t a t e In, in>, t o an outgoing s t a t e cm, out1 is: S=
-
<m, out
/
n , in>
11.1)
The S matrix 1s t h e t r a n s f o m t i o n lnatrlx fram the ""l"representation t o the "out" representation Sm
cn, i n [ = cm, out1
(1
n
*a
Tfie Beate In, Ln> m a n s a s t a t e tirt-ilch f a r i n the p a s t is a s p p t a t i c a l l y f r e e s t a b l e hadrons (otilble
in
strong
i n t e r a c t i o n s only, e.g.
no i s "stable'f)
described by momenta, and h e l i c i t i e s , a l l contained via t h e index n ,
The s t a t e
m, out has t h e s e t of indices m wgth t h e s m e space of i n d i c e s , but represents a s t a t e which i n t h e f u t u r e is asyruptotically i n s i t u a t i o n a, Thus t h e S m c r i x is r e a l l y t h e u n i t w t r r i x but i n a mixed representation,
e d i f f e r e n t l a b e l i n g f o r i n c a n g and outgoing s t a t e s .
Supposing these s t a t e s
are a l l t h e r e a r e , consemation of p r o b a b i l i t y r e q u i r e s
(In t h e s p e c i a l case t h a t the s t a t e n represents a s i n g l e s t a b l e p a r t i c l e t h e i n and out s t a t e s a r e t h e same).
General Theoretical Bmkground
The general coupling of e l e c t r o n s and hadroas is represented by t h e
The electron-photon system goes from s t a t e N t o M, t h e hadtons from n i n t o liJe suppose t h e only i n t e r a c t i o n
m out,
- and
phatm
possible is by t h e exchange of a
t h i s phaton i s characterized by a p o l a r i z a t i o a p, mamentm q:
That is t o say (supposing we could memure the amplitllde) we? define i n a given elrpertnent t h e q u a n t i t y
This is dane by renoving f r m t h e measured m p l i t u d e the knam (by QED theory) factors
I f is then our f i r s t supposition t h a t t h i s quantity
2ii(q),
depends
only on the s t a t e s m, n of t h e hadron system m d only t h e v i r t u a l =meaturn q and p o l a r i z a t i o n
of t h e v i r t u a l photon,
3,
depends i n no way an how
t h e photon was made (eg. whether by v ' s o r e l e c t r a n 8 o r on the angles and energies of t h e e l e c t r o n f o r fixed q and phaton p o l a r i z a t i o n ) . This is a s t r o n g assumption.
It has been v e r i f i e d most completely for
t h e case of proton form f a c t o r masurements, but is o f t e n a s s w d i n checking equipment, comparing r e s u l t s fro= one lab t o another e t c . We emphasize then t h a t
We assume i t .
(q) is an exgeriaentally defined q w a t i t y
definable i n p r i n c i p l e f o r all q. Me f i n d i t convtmient t o define a new matrix J non-mixed representation a s
80 we,
now w r i t e
defined i n a
-
To deal with t h i s s little more abstractly, the quantity f
QED be described a s the m r r i x e l e m n t (betwe-
U
*
%2
m, i n
9
tbe leptons) of an operator,
the vector p o t e n t i a l operator f o r the leptons s ( q ) , all considered k n m
Ft %us the f i r s t order i n t e r a c t i o n
and cempatible by QED i n any s p e c i f i c case,
is d e ~ c r i b e dby the matrix ay(q) Ju(q) d4q
+ higher
order.
The l comes f r m the zero order ( h e r e we saw the S matrix is r e a l l y the unit faaerix i n an
xed representation).
Unitarity requires t o f i r s t order
o r , @Lama (q) is a r b i t r a r y , U
U
= J
U*
-
(d
a(-q)* transpose)
J Le h a m i t i a n , Ec
Since all q are
avsflable we can define Fourier T r a n s f o m
(and f o r a lapace), Titus the couplilng f a
You m y , i f you wish simply a s e m
F" J
U M
0, c m s e m a t i o n of current f o r
hadraw, or e l s e note the following discmeion.
It is not, s t r % c t l y , true t h a t obtained from expeziment. When i t come.
from Bq. (1.5) can be c m p l e t e l y
That is because a (q) is not cmpletelry a r b i t r a v . P
f r w the usual diagram rules i t always s a t i s f i e s qUap(q)
Thus one component of a
Ft
(the one i n direction
-
0.
$1 is always miseing (unless
7
General TheareficalBackground q2 = 0) and thus one compment of J
v"
t h e component i n t h e d i r e e r i o n q
li
is
&@sing, We f i n i s h t h e deflnitiort of JP by ehoosing qI.lJU = 0. F i r s t , f o r q2
This we do i n the following way.
m
0, a f r e e proton of
-
but f o r a f r e e photon e 18 undefined t h e coupling is- e J (q) v ll bi t o i t could be added uq (e; = e + oq ) any o. This can make no e f f e c t so U Ir our consistency with QED demands cg J = O a t l e a s t when q2 = 0. This is a ll lt 2 physical property J must s a t i s f y . ZE it is not t r u e f o r general q redefine 2 q (q J )/q Evidently replace t h e o l d v i a J ' J a new J "0 Ir v U U V ' J 2 qbiJut = 0, and no new pole a t q2 O is introduced by t h e new l / q term f o r
polarization e
li
-
its
numerator qvJv vanishes e t qZ
mat
-
o f o t h e r r e s t r i c t t o n s on
.
-
0.
These we wish t o find.
J (l)?
t h a t i f badrons a r e g w e m e d
s i n c e i t is a l o c a l operator f i e l d theory suggests r-
7
by an m d e r l y i n g f i e l d theory then
l i k e aeparated (spbofizecf by
X1
For e x a w l e
(l), @
1.
2
= 0 i f 1 and 2 a r e space
you wish you may a s s m e t h i s
-
but i t is very i n t e r e s t i n g t h a t we can prove i t from our a s s a p t i o n t h a t the
s t r e n g system i n t e r a c t s with QED (subject t o s y s t e a a t i c e r r o r s i n proof due t o t a c i t assumptions.
This w y not be an i a p o r t a n t point b u t i t is f n t e r e s e i n g
s o X will. waste your clme by proving i t ) .
This i e v i a dfagrams of t h e type whose m p l i t u d e depends on a computable
f a c t o r from t h e leptons" times a matrix elelnent depending on the two a o m n t a and p o l a r i z a t i o n s of t h e N o v i r t u a l photons -1/2 VUv (g1. this
is s m e t r i c a f - i n ql
+-,
q2, u
c-t
v, f o r Bose
q2).
A8 defined
statistics a m g photons
does not p e M t us t o d i s t i n g u i s h t h e phatons s o no o t h e r function can be experimentally defined,
Using an undxed r e p r e s e n t a t i o a , and coordinate
space (via double Fourier t r a n s f o m ) we can represent t h i s m p l i t u d e as
* ~ np a r t I of t h i s course ' ~ e p t o n s fw t i l l mean s-, e
+
,-ii 4, p"
ORI,~,
-
The contribution from t h e QED lepton a i d e can be figured f o r each diagram, and c m , a s shorn i n QED theory, be generally w r i t t e n a s the matrix element (batwean i n and o u t photon-lepton s t a t e s ) of t h e tione ordered product of the operator a y ( l ) and a (2) (symbolized
Since a r b i t r a q a(l)a(Z)
IJ
be made V
Ct v
can
is a q e r i m n t a l i l y defined,
I wish now t o prove a nmber o f things, ao i t w i l l be m z e convenient
eo r e a t r i e t t h e i n t e g r a l t o tl > t 2 and w r i t e t h i s and t h e f i r s t two orders a s
Evidently one can w r i t e an e n t i r e a a r i e s af functions t o ever inereasing order.
+
This gives the r e s t r i c t i a n fusing a
+
obtained by w r i t i n g T T (L@
over a l l tl, tq.
=
a)
l and expanding t o 2nd order.
The 2nd i n t e g r a l
t2 and a p a r t t2 c tl
X t can be s p l i t i n t o a p a r t tl
in t h e l a t t e r r e l a b l e varieiblea 1, 2 (and p, v) t o g e t
NW,
i f we could a s s w e t h a t within the range of p o s e f i l e QED s t a t e s a r b i t r a r y
values for a (1) av(2) can be generated (which i s true) and a l s o independently U f o r a (2) a (1) (which is f a l s e ) we could conclude t h a t v
lii
iJ v
( l , 2) - J V ( 1 ) J v f 2 ) f o r tl
But o u t s i d e t h e l i g h t cone f o r e x m p l e a r e n o t Independent, they a r e equal,
(2.5)
t2
0 s o the
products
To proceed t h e r e f a r e more c a r e f u l l y
General Theoretical Backgroltnd wri t e
t o get
Now the f i r e t f a c t o r must vanish, f o r we could take t h e case t h a t a(21, & ( l ) c o m a r e f i r s t ( f a r example one photon from
art,
e l e c t r o n , another f r m a muan i n
I w e a t order) hence we s u r e l y always ~ u s have t
d e t e m i n i n g t h e r e a l p a r t af V
PV
In a d d i t i o n I n general we mm& have
(1, 2 ) .
(caking a d j o i n t of l a s t term)
The c m u t a t o r i s zero outsfde trhe l i g h t cone,
Xnaitrfe I believe we can mke
i t a r b i t r a w (although s o w l i t t l e f u r t h e r study of epecia2 cases i a necessary
t a v a r i f y t h i s ) hence we deduce
v y y ( l p 2)
m
J p ( l I Jy(2)
(2 99)
1 is i n foetrard light cone of 2. We have alnnost proved
i n s i d e t h e l i g h t cone of 2.
Eq. (2,5)
but not f o r a y tl > t2, anly f a r tl
The d i f f e r e n c e is very iwortanr: because
Eq, (2 , S ) , t o be r e l a t i v i s t i c a l l y i n v a r i a n t requires o u t s i d e the light: cone,
E q . (2 ,S) a l s o i a a a t u r a l if hadirons coma f r w any
rurderlying f i e l d theory, f o r then our p i c t u r e o f coupling i f Cl > t p can Lep tans
Wadrons
-
cut
be cut a t a t between t2 and t2; t h e f i r s t coupling is J ( l ) and the aecoad U
is J,(2),
so we g e t the product,
But one m y be averse t o a e s d n g t h a t
strong interactions can be deser%bed by a c m p l e t e s e t of s t a t e s (and that t h e complete @ e t can be trrlren as
[R,
in> ) a t any a r b i t r a r y tim.
Nevertheless
if we continue our study of the r a q u i r w a t e r for consistency with QED t o 4th order we can do i t , Proof
P
% i s point If
not: important, but we do include the proof f o r completeness,
(2.5) were r i g h t then 2. would be
i t is eome polyoomial in ay ( l ) , (av( (Rant. naw on we o&t the polarization $adices
way with the position indices).
- they
always go i n an obvious,
?he f i r s t order is made t o agree with Jir(l)
80 i n gemrixl w e can w r i t e CU(12) represents the devlatlon of V(l.2) J(1) J I Z ) )
f o r tr
NW &D. f o d n T g'T
fro=
t2)
t5
check u n i t a r i t y the erp - % h a factors go out.
and 41;h order i n a the U ( 1 2 3) t e r n does not enter.
so we conclude U i s hennitian aa before.
NW I n 4th order we have
TO 2nd
To second order we have
U e v c r v h e r e , and U ( 1 2)
O if
II
General Theoretical Background I n t h e l a s t i n t e g r a l we have tS of t
5
tg but no p a r t i c u l a r r e l a t i o n
t6 and t 7
and t7 there a r e 6 r e l a t i v e orders.
We replace i n each t h e verriables
tlA2, t e , t4 i n t h a t order
The l a s t t e r n gives
Uf12) U(34) a(1) a(2) a (3) a(4) : &CD
= ABCD
U(13) V(24) & ( l ) a(3) a(2) a(4) : ACBD
AF,B)D + ABCD
U(141 U(23) a ( l ) a(4) a(2) a(3) : ADSC
A C ~ ,q
U(23) U(14) a(2) a(3) a(1) a(4) : BCAD =
BE,A ~
U(24) U(l3) a(2) a ( 4 ) a ( l ) a(3)
BDAC
U(34) U(12) s(3) a ( 4 ) a ( l ) a(2)
CDAB
-
+ ABCD
+ AB@, D+ p, ~
C
+DABCD
B@,
4~ E,~
D
+C
C[D,
A]B
E, ~
D
+BACE. ]B +
C
f
+ A@,
+
ABED,4+ ABCD
B ~ D+ ABCD
(2.12)
and the f f r s c term i s
Now we g e t mny obvious r e l a t i o n s .
For example the c o a f f f e i e n t of ABCD mwt
be zero (take ease a l l 4 p o t e n t i a l s c o m u t e ) ,
We belteve t h a t the vector
potentgal a is an a r b i t r a r y functton of space and time.
We can t h e r e f o r e
chooee It t o be d i f f e r e n t fro= zero only I n four small regions of space time around t h e points 1, 2 , 3 and 4; c a l l these regions ol, a2,
03, 04.
For
o a r s p e c i a l i n t e r e s t here take the case t h a t the v a r i a b l e s have the follawtn-ng l f ght cone propertgee
CB*D] Only
D, C]
- 0
and [A,
[D,
g$0
1 is outside the l i g h t cone of 2, 3 is outside the l i g h t cone of 4.
Omitt5ng
t h e AI3CD t e r n which we noted was indepandently zero and c o l l e c t i n g what 18 l e f t i n this caee we g e t
E, ~ a11 t h e term. a r e cwf f i e i e n t s of F, AD o r CB B, 4 But vltimarely we a r e l e f t with U(24) U(13) E, AI] [B,
Only the thArd term need. t o be turned erovnd t o
C
+B E,
g E, g then
and muat a l l vanish. or ftnally
$&ace the c o m a t a t o r s a r e s u f f i c i e n t l y general, X think we can crsnclude the i n t e g r a l w i l l be zero only i f the integrand f a and U(13)
a
O even i f 1 is
outside t h e l i g h t cone of 3, End of Proof We can therefore conclude
I n the proofs of (2.9) and (2.16) we have assuned t h a t a(il. tl) and tl). a(f2,
t2g a r e s u f f i c i e n t l y general functions of 1 and 2 (when
2 is i n the l i g h t cone of 1 ) .
Me believe t h i s t o be true,
X t i s left to
those i n t e r e s t e d in Gnare rigorouhl proof@ t o v e r i f y thSe, f o r example by t r y i n g t o construct a b a s i s ,
Lecture 3
We found i n the previous l e c t u r e Vliv(l, 2) = Ju(l) Jv(2)
f o r tl
t2
General Tlzeorerical Background furthemre
This means the a r l g i n a l s m e t r i c VIIV(l, 22) can be v r l t t e n
The l a s t terns corns because t h e r e could be a 6 ( t l
a 6 4 (1-2) term o r gradients thereof--leading
-
t 2 ) t e r n , o r by r e l a t i v i t y
t o j u s t a constmt: o r polynomial
under Fourller t r a n a f o m , These s e a ~ j l lt e w would m a n t h a t t h e a b s t r a c t f a m f o r T would be l s k e
thus adding a l o c a l term a t one space time point, but second order i n a ( l ) a s appears i n QED f o r the i n t e r a c t i o n with a s c a l a r p a r t i c l e , f o r e x a m l e . Of course, i n s t e a d i t could contain g r a d i e n t s , a s F
P'J
Tktere c m be higher t e r n s f o r higher orders. t h a t T m u s t be e x p r e s s i b l e i n t h e form T
(1) F
Pv
( l ) f o r exaaple,
In s h o r t what we have found is
m
an operator &pending on a(1) only, f o r emmple of f o m 3 ( l ) a (1)
+S
Pv
l
a
l
variables,
+
,
.
P
Y
where J
,S
+
a r e operators i n t h e hadron
Such a form is of course, a l s o , t h e i m e d i a t e result: of
supposing a l o c a l f i e l d theory f o r hadrons. Research Problem % a t experiments could b e s t e s t a b l i s h existence o r non-existence of s e a g u l l s ? I n QED f o r s p i n 1 / 2 t h e r e i s no s e a g u l l , f o r s p i n 0 t h e r e l a (but with M e m r Duffin matrices t h e r e is not:
- resolve
this!)
Since a l l
q u a n t i t i e s a r e defined by experiment t h e r e a l t t y of suck s e a g u l l s f a r hadrons i s an experimentally d e t e m i n a b l e f a c t , Thus we s e e a knowledge of matrix elements of J alone shauld deternine P a l l s c a t t e r i n g amplitudes V, The r e s t r i c t i o n (3.2) an the m t r i x elements of J They lead t o nrany relations--dispersion
a r e very important,
r e l a t i o n s f o r example.
t h i s s u b j e c t l a t e r when we dlscuss deep i n e l a s t i c ep s c a t t e r i n g .
We r e t u r n t o
m e r e are
Photon-Hadron Interactions
14
eome s p e c i a l technical d i f f i c u l t i e s comfng from the highly divergent nature of some of these expressione eo mathematical r i g o r requires a l i t t l e more I n p r a c t i c e they give trouble only i n the vacuum expectation
attention.
(of, f o r example V ) and i n no other problem and eo they can be avoided beet lJ v
by disregarding them.
(They have been analyzed by Schwinger,
and a r e c a l l e d
t r i v i a l Schwinger t e r m ) . Conrervation of Current We suppose now t h a t current i e conserved i n the more conventional sense t h a t we w i l l take i t t o be t r u e t h a t quantum electrodynamics cannot determine a (1) completely, but a gradient a (1) + V ~ ( 1 )( ~ ( 1 )i e an a r b i t r a r y function, U
Li
not an operator) can be added t o i t (i.e. i f a d i f f e r e n t gauge were w e d i n the lepton theory) wlthout a l t e r i n g the physics.
- i / (1) a,, (1) d~~ = 1 - 1[ J,,(l) (av (1) + V , (X (1))) 1
Thus T
E] = TE +vX] eo
J,,
+vyx (1))
d~~
-
+/
V,,, (12) {(a,
(1)
+
(a,, (2)
o r t o f i r s t order i n X (3.5) (3.6) e t c .
Equation (3.5) we have already diecuscled; (3.6) gives rromething new.
but
(lyJ,,
(l) J v ( 2 i T
V,,{,,(l)
by equation (3.5; except t h a t V
v
-
Using (3.3)
0
does not commute with the time ordering
operation i n
C
J,, (1)
Jv(2)
0(tl-t2)
J,,(l)
Jv(2) + 0(titl)
J,, (2) J,,(l)
I T
We have a l e o t o d i f f e r e n t i a t e the 0 with respect t o t.
Thw when U = 0,
General Theoreticat Background we g e t from t h i s an e x t r a t e r a
t h e equal time c o m a t a t o r of Jo(Z) aad JV(2),
Thue i n general
I n our application t h i s leads t o
PIetually I have sfarglified the d i s c w s i o n of t h e s e a g u l l s , f o r gradients a l s o 4 appear on the 6 (l, 2 ) , but the poSnt we want t o make i s Chat the eqmk time c o m u t a t o r of
charge density
and c u r r e n t ls d e t e m i n e d by serngulls,
p a r t i c u l a r , i f as may people (@,g,
e l l - a n a l have sauggestcitd s e a g u l l s vanish
(by analogy t o QED where t h e coupling i s purely t h e r e a r e no s e a g u l l diagr-)
In
$A y $ d ~CO tr li
B
s p l n I f 2 EIald
we would have
w e have no d i r e c t t e e t of t h i a y e t kltbough we do have t e s t s of
Vbt
V
YV
(1, 2)
bmrk Sehwiager has painted out t h a t ( 3 . 8 ) is i q o a e i b l e . and Jv
-
1, 2 , 3 is v r i t t e n on the vector
3 it
Becawc: i f . Jo
says
Therefore takf ng divergence because
p
-
3
g .
But
8
is t h e operaroz Hp-pH where X i s t h e
U & l t o n i a n of t h e aystem ( a s s a n g there is one-generally s t a t e operator)
Naw
t&e
t h e energy of
OK
t h e v s e u w expactation v a l w ,
b a t t h e energy of the i n t e = d i a t e
P
0).
s t a t e n be En, we have
but
pan
-
- E.
aod i f the vacurn i s the l w e s t a t a t e we must have En
O so
wbich f s inrfrasaible, But t h i s a r g m a t applies as well t o QED i t e e l f where we Lknw we hava no eaagulls i n the oxrlg%nal f i e l d operator f o r the lagrangian, we do not r e a l l y coPrgare thire fo-1
It come because
fie2d theory d i r e c t l y t o experrimat but
rewve aom divergent vaeum d i a g r m a t the begfm%n$, l%%s problem appears
We can indeed
e n t i r e l y aesociated wfth the vacuurn problem mid could be reawed.
have the analol3y of QED; %Q seagullat a d have equation ( 3 , 8 ) s a t i s f i e d f o r ever-y problem except the vacurn,
The precise s t a t e m n t is that (3.8) holds
i f fronr the c m u t s t o r you subtract i t e vacurn expectation value t i m s r unit mtrix,
The hadronic s t a t e s n, m of a w t r i x e l e m n t of J such a@ .;m/J ir
can be c l a s s i f i e d i n t o d e f i n i t e nondyaadcal quantum n-era
U
I na
o f isospin and
strangenesa (both of which, we a c l s w , a r e perfectly consemad by the strongly intaracting syatem above).
The J nratrix say have elemnta between different
values of the quantm riders, but: i t mmt of Course coa@erve charge. F r m the very low race of K'
-*
no
+y
er d
+
y
+n
(alt;bou& C@
+
East enaugfi) we cmclude Cltat weak interactions a r e invalved here, think
J
n
+y
#.e
Thus we
has zero nzatrix elements bemean etaces of different strangeness,
h m g a e t s of d i f f e r e n t isoepin we can descrlbe the r e s u l t by saying J has
p a r t s of X spin
fn
0 (isoscalar), f:
I (isovector), 1
2 (i~aoteaaor)etc.
and w e appropriate Glt?bsch Gordtvr coefficianta t o r e l a t e ampxitudes amng
diffetctnt multiplets.
Slnee J daee riot change charge i t nnust only LnvoLve
the 3rd emponeat, i f it: i e isovector for e x a ~ p l e , The f a c t that proton a d
General 'rheoreriealBackground
+
neutron have charges
l, O already shows that J Is not pure i s o s c a l a r
independent of isoapln, nor pure isovectox (where the charges would have t o be opposite) but contains a l i n e a r co&inatIon of these two, t o require X tested.
No expsrixnent s e e m
2 , but I do not know him precisely o r extensively t h i s ha5 been
Recently so= evidence w a s claimed f o r the need of an 5
i n comparing y p
+
n;'~
and y N
i .
2 coqorxent
%-p a t energies near the d resonance--but i t
appears that correctiaas f o r dauterm s t r u c t u r e (for The y neutron r a t e is inferred fram y D data) *re
incorrectly analyzed.
Host t h e o r i s t s today a s a a e h1
.p
O o r &X:
P
L only f o r J , (This i s 1.1
evidently s fumdamntaf. question because i t t e l l s somthing of haw 3 is " u l t t m t e l y '"coupled
; f o r further strong interactions c m s e r e n g X-spin
cannot a l t e r & i s rule-+@ see ""ln'>tbroulgtr
the strong d p m i c couplling i n
t h i s respect a t Least because the strong coupling consemas t h i s Z spin eharactar ,) Having available a ~ a t r i xelements cmlJ in> f o r a variety of s t a t e s n (and m)
v
a l l s f the s a m X-@pin m l t l p l e t
pe&t;s
an@by appropriate l i n e a r cmbiaation
always t o i s o l a t e the pieces due t o the i s o s c a l a r and isavector p a r t separately.
Thus we can define matrix e l e m n t a and therefore operators f a r J5 (q) nnd J " ( ~ ) . ?J
U
But f o r the vector we could a l s o calculate (via Cl&sch Cordm ccefficients) m t r i x elements b e t ~ e o s! p ~ e c i f i c s t a t e s of other cmponents of the vector current jW(g) o r
(with isospin + l o r -1).
U;
I n t h i s way new kinds of
currencsare defiaable. "Illis would J u s t be an exercise i n Cleibech Clcrdan c o e f f i c i e n t s , but we think so= of these currants a r e p h y e i c a w important also, current ~''(~1 is the
v
W&
interaction
Ffe think the
nonatrangenaes e h a ~ g i n gnonparity violating parr of
(an a s e w t i o n k n m ss WC). This leads t o a suggestian
by which these extensions gf current: a r e w e f u l i n a p w e r f u l t h e o r e t i c a l w a y (&ll-Wn) * is (in our point Ft of view i n these lectureslakind of accident i r r e l e v a n t t o strong interactions,
That QED i a coupled t o JU, o r we& interaction
t o+'J
They J u s t lead ucs t o a t o o l t o study h a d r w , but: hadroa &ateractions can be analyzed alone.
Nevertheleas we deduced a. rider of r e l a t i o n s from asfj&ng
e i t h e r t h a t these currents c a m from soae apeastor i n a f i e l d theory underlying
hadrons, o r t h a t hadrona a r e suck that weak perturbation f i e l d s could be coupled (we w i l l w e the l a t t e r hypothesis),
We can expect, f o r any two points and
components of current ~ ~ ( and 1 ) ~ t ( 2 )that they c o m t e i f 1, 2 are apace P Like separa ted
llhis La a new arsrtvtion, on J and the hadron system.
We a r e trying to Lnduce new laws md restrictLonrs
We know
V
- 0 for 1 x . 1
our electrowgnetic current, is an Lsovector and isoacalar,
where J,
Ustag isospin only
how f a r is i t possible t o go t o prove say t h a t the tsovector p a r t , o r the
+
etc. c m a t e l
Xn the realm of isospia what we ass-
here 1s that
the apace-like carnutation law is t r u e not only f o r the t o t a l curreat J~
+ Jv3 but
ale0 f o r the isoscalar part alana with i t s e l f , the isoveeror
part alone with i t s e l f , the isoscalar part: with the iaovector part and generalizations fox the Leovector p a r t with different I spin compment directioas. We caa a l s o have the s c a t t e r i n g of an 3larogPnary a-type vector "photont' t o a b-type photon governed by
That is, extend the concept of vector potential a (1) t o contain mather U
Lndex a , the type, carrying f o r e-ple
isospia o r straageness,
men the coupling
t o external potentlals could be
Gonservation of h n e r a l i z a d Currents
-,
We want the consewation laws analogouss t o V1.I V v*' (1 2)
-
the case i f I spin which we k n w is exactly conserned. of an I
l p a r t i c l e v i a JV'. U
than the i n i t i a l , so
m
0.
Take f i r s t
Consider the scattering
?he charge of the f i n a l s t a t e is one higher
General Theoretical Ba~kground
;3
(tl,
I),
V+ JP (tl,
Xf
(4.51
but t h e last, equal tiw c o m a t a t o r is by hypothesis (4.1) zero outside the 3
mwt be a m u l t i p l e of 6 (g-g'),
l i g h t cone-it
V+
shows s must be J y (g)
.
say s ( ~ ) 6 ~ ( ~ - x " )Equation . (4.1)
Hence t h e equal time commutation r e l a t i o n r e s u l t s ,
( t h i s a s s m e s t h e r e a r e no s p e c i a l t e r n i n
8(x1,
E2) &ich would i n t e g r a t e
o u t , a question we s h a l l s e e r e l a t e d t o s e a g u l b again). Eqtxatlon (4.6) and its g e n e r a l i z a t i m t o t h e much wider group SU3 x SU3
arc! Gelf-&nnfs equal tim comulirtor r e l a t i o n s ,
They represent the f i r s t
guessed d p m i c a l property of hadrons t h a t is nor simply a consequence of r e l a t i v i s t i c quantum mechanics geaeral principles, We c m a l s o describe t h i s from t h e point of view of a property of t h e s c a t t e r i n g function . : ;V
Talre the case one p o t e n t i a l is
+ isospio,
o t h e r I$. Since current is conserved you might e t f i r s t think Pp, ;V but t h e e r r o r is t h a t t h e p o t e n t i a l v, 2 c a r r i e s i n a charge e l e c t r o m w e t l c p o t e n t i a l (coupling 3) a180 conserved,
C O U ~ ~t o~ the B
+.
the (1, 2)
So only
+ rneson
tyi
-
the
i s charm
E.g. d i a g r a m a r e l i k e
Their sum eonservea charge, and ift h e photon had p o l a r i z a t i o n e proportional t o i t s oun momentum t h e sum would give zero.
y. =
~ ~ ' ( 1 2, ) is j u s t )J v
the s m of t h e f P r s t two, t h e l a s t one is (38~~flly cmputcible and is c l e a r l y a f i r s t order hadronic nracrix e l e a e n t of a current J
v'
i n thLs cage J~ i t s e l f .
musr one em e a s i l y show t h a t
o~J:(~I
AS
-
3 ( j u s t by I-spin from V J (1) Er Er
we shall, show i n a m m n t ( 4 . 7 ) is equivalent
CO
o
(4.6) i f no s e a g u l l s e x i s t ;
i f they do e x i s t ( 4 . 7 ) 18 t r u e but (S. 6 ) has t o be madifled.
(4.7) is t h e
0,
more fundamntal r e l a t i o n , t o (4.6) we s u b s t i t u t e (4.3) i n t o ( 6 . 7 ) -
To show t h e r e l a t i o n of (4.7)
s o w r i t i n g 64(1-2) on the r i g h t s i d e of (4.7) o r 6 (tl-t2) the r e s u l t (4.6) s i n c e
g
,J3 = 0. U U
63(i1-;21
we obtain
I n general s e a g u l l terms must be added, b u t
we do not k n w i f they e x i s t . The generalization t o a general Lie group with generators commutation r e l a t i o n [ G ~ , $3
V~,V;;(~,
= fzb
(
with
by d e f i n i t i o n ) (wb), = fzb
( f r . 10)
2) = 64(1-2) 3 Y b ( l )
m e s e m y be obtained from noting t h a t the generalization of a gauge t r a n a f o m t i o n -r a + P X is, i n the group aa -t aa + qVXa + (X P P D P li unchanged by such a t r a n s f o m t i o n we Efnd
a'
a s a f u n c t i o n a l relation-or
X
ay)'.
Supposing T[d
is
c a l l f n g 6T/Sa(l) t h e functional d e r i v a t i v e one
e a s i 1y deduces
f o r afll X ( l ) , s o i n t e g r a t i n g by p a r t s we have
kthen T is w r i t t e n i n a p w e r s e r i e s i n a (4.2) and is s u b s t i t u t e d i n t o (4.111, zero and f i r s t order t e r n give (4.9) and (4.10). Since idsospin is exactly cclinserved (4.91, when SU
3
(4.16) mwt be e x a c t l y s a t i s f i e d
r e s t r i c t e d t a trhe t h r e e s p i n components of vector c u r r e n t s ,
% a t of
which i a only ""almost" s a t i s f i e d ? G11-Mnn has proposed t h a t $U3,
although
nor: exactly s a t i s f i e d f o r the e n t i r e hadronic system may be more and w x e
accurately s a t i s f i e d as shorter aad shorter space-tim i n t e r n a l s a r e invalved, That is how i t would behave i f an wderlying f i e l d theory had propagator gradient terms s a t i s f y i n g SU3, but mass-like terms violating SUy
+ Gmq
where m is a nonSU3 invariant matrix, q a r e quark operators).
is a strangeaeas changing curreat, h a d n g f o r e-plf? A, N then v .Ja(l) $ O becwse A, ~t v
IN>
= O, < A / JEI E>
-
If
J'
a w t r i x e l e w n t beWeen
have dif ferent mases.
a ~ z u say, therefore +allE 1 IN>
cannot be zero, ) That: is P $(l) P P na(2j. Then
9 q+
(E .g.
(If A, N a t r e e t
-
= (uA-wHjo
fs equivalent t o another operator, say
4 H c r v the l a t t e r p r e s w b l y does not contain a s i n g u l a r i t y a s strong a@ 6 (1-2)
us say the 64 (1-2) s i n g u l a r i t y
but i f SUg is v a l i d a t small enough distmces-let of V vBb is correctly given by (4.10). Ir Ctv
%vs we say
4 where "ssfaootk" is l e s s singufar than 6 (1-2).
eqttaf
tinrc?
Then we c m s t i l l deduce the
e m a t a t o r r e l a t i o n s under the above a s s q t i o n s of smoothaees of
the SU3 vioXating term.
Equating the singular t e r n i n ((412) aad (4.12)
we f i n d
(eeagufl t e r n have been imored). These relatfons a r e 05 very great I n t e r e s t because they a r e aonliaear requiring absolute scales,
Thus ( i f valid) they can serve as supplying
absolute s c a l e definitions t o the currents so t h a t the r u l e t h a t weak i n t e r a c t l m of hadrons i s V therefore testable,
+A
(rather than V
-
Thls p a r t i c u l a r t e s t has bean m d e by Adler and
Weisberger uslng fCAC t o take the pion coupling of the a x i a l current.
.7A) is d e f l n d l e m d
We d i s c w s how @-**at
ah,
a mmure? of the divergence
m r e d i r e c t t e s t s c m be made
by neutrino scattering l a t e r on i n the course ( i n Part XI),
I s zero i f 1 is outeide the l f g h t cone of
2 , nonzero
inside.
What kind of s i n g u l a r i t y does i t have j u s t passing
through, o r near t h e li&t cone,
For f r e e f i e l d s of any noass i n f i e l d 2 theory the c m u t a t o r has a 6(sI2) type s i n g u l a r i t y across t h e cone. There
i8
experimental evidence from i a e X m t i c s c a t t e r i n g experilnents of e l e c t r o n s
on protons t h a t the s i n g u l a r i t y of
Ir
Is of t h e s m e type
2 (gradients of) 6(s12) where s12 is t h e i n t e r v a l from l t o 2.
We s h a l l discuss
t h t s FBatter i n coasidttrable d e t a i l where we discuss these experiments,
At this
time we s h a l l a l s o develop f u r t h e r o t h e r formal properties of the c a r n u t a t o r o r tlm ordered products of J
li
operators,
m a s e matters w i l l therefore be
deferred u n t i l l a t e r , f o r I f i n d them e a s i e r t o d i ~ c u a swhen c e r t a i n experiments a r e i n &nd,
I n order, however, not t o leave t h i s t h e o r e t i c a l diseusslan eentirely i n t h e a i r , I s h a l l i l l u s t r a t e one a p p l i c a t i o n of it--the simplest, t h e vacum expectation of V
I.lv
( l , 2).
ThSs is a function only of t h e d i f f e r e n c e l
- 2,
Its Eouxier t r a m f o m , i n t o v a r i a b l e q - d i c h we w i l l c a l l Vpy(q) La needed, 2 f o r e x m p l e , t o c a l c u l a t e vacum p o l a r i z a t i o n correctione ( t o order e ) due to hadrm.
It represents t h e d i a g r m bdrons
If we w r i t e i n momentvm space 4 [ V (-q, q) /o> = -q q v(q2) Ir v
Ft v
+
2 6y,b(q ) (by
2 r e l a t i v i s t i c iavariance, gauge invariance implies b = q v o r we have 4
1 vp, (-S,
4) / 0'
I f we w r i t e ( b y v a new pole a t q2
(6
uv qZ
- 24p9v ]b
-
- qvqv) v(q21. we s e e b mmt go t o zero BS q
(4.15) +
0 i n order t o avoid
Q
O.
Acting on conserved c u r r e n t s t h e l a s t term vanishes.
TIse serge@ of buibbles propagating between two c u r r e n t s is
23
General Theoretical Backgragnd We note there is no mass r e a o m l i z a t i o n of the photon, the pole is s t i l l a t qZ
-
0, but the residue i a altered t o
4mL where a v(O) (vhich -----y
1-4ne i a t u r n cuc i n f i n i t e ) is lost i n charge r e n o m l i z a t i a a , 2
near q2
a
O t o get v(q )
t o f i r s t order i n e
2
+
my
Tf we s t a r t expandlrng
2 q b, we can write the renormalized propagator
as
so 4ne2i b measures the vacuum polarization correction due t o hadross i n such predminantly low enerll;y QED problem as the h& Shift etc. 2
I h e imeginary part of v(q ) f o r q2
O is the "virtual photon ltfetima"
ltnd gives the r a t e o f production o f hadrons i n (say) an electron-position eolliaion,
Because the iwginary part of the mplitude represents a loss i n
probability that a photon remine a photon
+
m
l
+ 4 ~ e ~ & vi.e. ( ~ ~ Prob. )
1 + 4ne2 i (v-v*)
X t is therefore dgreetly accessible t o experiment,
to tbe imginary p a r t by a dispersion relntion.
2
2 + e-
lae i ,p1)7 'moa, / '$ (4)10' 9
detemined a f t e r suitable
We w i l l discuss t h i s matter i n d e t a i l i n the aexr Lecture.
Consider the process
iE2y
The r e a l part is related
Therefore hadronic vacurn
polarization e f f e c t s (to ordere2) could be c-letely experimnts a r e done,
.
+
hadrons iln s t a t e ra out,
It is gmeretad
Hence t h e p r o b a b i l i t y i s proportional t o
Thus i f we could Bleasure t h e t o t a l cross s e c t i o n f o r e*
+
+
hadrons i n any
s t a t e as a function of the energJT E of t h e e l e c t r o n o r p o s i t i o n i n t h e case (qo = ZE,
m out
6
'01
-
0 , qZ = 4 ~ ' ) we can d i r e c t l y measure Zmoyt
Imout>(mau,/
JP(-%)
t o w r i t e t h i s i n t h e Eom
W
- q26 UV ) 8 (qo)p(q2) because we know t h a t
being lowest) no hadron s t a t e mout
$I
o r q2
. -
q2 p(p
?-
2
.
(2mV12 and q* 2
Par erample, p(q )
0.1
-
O f o r qo
0.
e
PV
(g)
-
Q ales8
~ h u sp(q2) exist. only f o r
O f o r q2 < 0, i.e.,
Is i f q
mwt be p o s i t i v e , f o r e
puV(q)
is nonzero, t h e lowest possible
s t a t e is a p a i r of pions with mmntmn Q hence p
2 (ZmT)
O ( t h e vacum s t a t e
if qo
could be excgtad.
(Xn f a c t i f Q, t h e apace l i k e m e n e r n of
qo > 2
/ Jy (q) 10,
~ ~ ( / 042 )
R e l a t i v i t y and gauge Savariance p e d t s (quqv
0 ' / Ju ( - g ) / moyt><mout
2 space l i k e q
.
Further
(qo, 0, 0, 0) and t h e p o l a r i z a t i o a
af t h e v i r t u a l photon were x,the sm of absolute squares mwt be p o s i t i v e on
the r i g h t hand a i d e of (5.2). zero i f q2 < (2%)
2
2
m e r e f o r e p(q ) is p o s i t i v e f o r q2 > (2%)
2
,
.
Therefore
(F, T, s t m b f o r Fourier trmsfanen),
NW we can work out the c o w t a t o r md tim ordered product,
Note t h f s c m be m i t t e n as
F i r s t the comatator
25
General Theoverr'calBackground Therefore the vacurn expectation of the c m u t a t o r i n space is
which i a zero outslde the Light cone, becawe ~ ~ ( 1 , 2is. )
It is i n t e r e s t i n g
t h a t the proof t h a t the esmutaeor vanishers outside the l i g h t cone, a s a d n g r e l a t i v i t y is s o skmple for t h e vacuusn ex;pecCatian.
(At the end of these notes
the e o m t a t a r , propagator and t h e i r Fourier t r s a s f s m s a r e I t s t e d )
.
To get
the time? ordered product we need
To gat the F. T. we need a convolution with the F. T, of @(tl-tZ)
Therefore
P* T.
CO/ i
10%
where q' meaoa ( q i , 'Q = qtqf
-h
~ ~ ( (211 1 ) ~ ~ T
Q).
F l r s t do the case li.v
- 6 t t q2 and comes o u t of
-
tst
the integral.
for d e n
q'q'
Ir v
- Spvq' 2
Then change the s i g n of
q f f%nthe second t e r n i n t e g r a l to get
-
F.T. C O /(
J~(~)J~(~)]/Q5 , (qtqt
- ,e
dp; O
-
- btt9 2)
V t t (q9
The i n t e g r a l i e just l
'
qo-n'2+i.. 0
ar chenging vargnble Vt,(P)
= (ntqt
from q; t o q;2
- 6t,P29
- qZ
-?
get
1
(5 e 9 )
&are Set 2s the F. 5, of' a gosssble s e a g u l l a w c t a t f o n i n the vacuuat, m e t be
8
c o m t a n t , or a fZnIte polynoeaf. i a q, and muet be r e a l .
It
W can
w e s s (generalizing wv from tt--however s e e note belrrw) t h a t writing VyV(q)
(qiiqy
- 6Uv421
v(q2) we have,
where S, a t worst, is a E t n i t e polynoaalal i n q; a t b e s t f t is zero, imaginary p a r t of i v ( q2
1
Note the 2 p14 1 a s previously remarked physically we can a l s o
write
This is a dispersion r e l a t i o n f o r v(q 2 1, expressing v f o r a l l q 2 i n t e r n of its imaginary p a r t (which i n t h i s -%se is (a) nonzero only f o r q2
2 (2mw) , (b)
m a s u r a b l e by accessible experiments.) I f ( ~ ( s )is the cross s e c t i o n f o r a n n i h i l a t i o n of electron-positron f n t o m y hadrons where s is t h e t o t a l C.m. energy squared, we have
a(s)
(4~e~)~p(s)/2
s o the vacurn polat.Zzation is given d i r e c t l y i n t e r n s o f experiment bp
The Lamb s h i f t correction (or eorrection t o the magnetic m m n t of t h e e l e c t r m , 2 e t c . ) due t o hadion vacum polarf zation depends on 4ne i v ' ( 0 ) which is
X t is expected today fox reasons t o be discussed l a t e r t h a t o ( s f m y , f o r
large
S
vary a s constant/s sa the i n t e g r a l would converge and be d e t a d a e d
ewerimatally. Xn general t h e possibility of use o f such
B
relation.
2 value of q (SW O o r
m)
;uz
S mwt be resolved t o get trhe g r e a t e s t
otherwise i f v(qL) is k r ) m sawwhere
a t some s p e c i a l
we can convert t o a subtracted dfspersion r e l a t i o n .
I.e. suppose f t i s k n m S Ss a constant, but n o t a p o l y n o d a l i n,'q 2 is k n m . -#(g1)
Subtract from (5.10)
S does not appear.
f o r q 2 its value when q2
and
2 ql t o get
This s m e t r i c k helps i f the i n t e g r a l on mL looks divergent.
Cer~eralTheorerim/ Bmkgr~und Ihe integral on m2 may n w converge b e t t e r f o r large m
2
.
In our application any conetant S i e uninteresting, as we have seen the value of v(O) is of no i n t e r e s t today became it: is l o s t i n shazge r e a o m l i z a t i o n , Hence supposing S does not have a q2 term (aesumptioo of no bad aeagulle) we would write a dispereion relatLon f o r the quantity v(q2)
- v(@), the only quantity
of physical significancct
Thua we m y look fomard i n the near future (when e x p e r i w t a l r e s u l t s f o r
2 p(m ) w i l l be =re
2 c o w l e t e ) t o being able t o W e a ( f i r s t order i n e 1
correction i n QED calculations of the e f f e c t s of loops invo1Mng hadrons,
+ * p+v-)
In a recent mwkturemnt of ~ { e-e
2 of the Q1 resanance t o p (m ) has been observed,
an e f f e c t o f the contribution n I s cows from the interference
of the graphs 4.
It
+ 2
2 a t a q near aa4,
S, .
It
m ,
e
e
In the first: order 5n *%eh the e f f e c t contributes only the
Is seen, t h i s is observed as a s l i g h t o s c i l l a t i a n
AbS an e x m l e we cctlculate the rnodfficatlon to @(@'em-t. y * ~ " ) when '"adrons'"
i n the above graphs is the $ resonmca only,
Zn this ease
CS, 1s)
(S. 17)
Mhere p mans principal part,
28
Photon-Hadxon Interactions l m e r l i m i t i n t h e i n t e g r a l (5.18) can be s e t t o
e r r o r because t h e resonance is very narrow.
The cross s e c t i o n f o r
-"
with n e g l i g i b l e
Carrying out t h e i n t e g r a l we find:
u+p- production from ef e- is t h e r e f o r e
where a. is the c r o s s s e c t i o n f o r the process i n the absence of @-photon interactions. We need not have evaluated t h e Pntegral i n (5.18) t o g e t the r e a l p a r t 2 of iv(q )
.
Uhat t h e r e l a t i o n (5.15) says is t h a t iv(qZ) is an a n a l y t i c
function with no poles i n the l m e r half plane and such t h a t Zm a l l we need t o do is guess an a n a l y t i c f i m g l n a r y p a r t is
.l 2
T
p(=
f and which has the c o r r e c t poles i n t h e upper h a l f
Xn t h i s case, t h e function is easy t o gueas
plane.
theref o r e
Meking t h e s u b t r a c t i o n a t q2 = O we get (5.19).
Note: Let us calculaCe o t h e r uu components in (5.8). P;
F i r s t t n s o q;q:
- bpVqtZ
QX*
m e r e f o r e get
80 this is OK b e c w s e t h e f a c t o r q0 t t case,
q:
-
Qx
m l t i p l i i e s the serne i n t e g r a l a s i n t h e
Traubla come h m e v e r i n the m c a e f o r then 2
2
( q i -Q 1 f o r the q;2
the c a e f f l c i e a t i s
does n o t change d i r e c t l y t o q2 a s required, but
we have i n s t e a d an e x t r a correction of q i 2
- qoZ which
cancels the denominator
80 we get
&ere C i e a constaint ( i n f i n i t e no doubt)
5
We ewld get r i d af C by a s a a g d l type t e r n but we a r e eoafused becauee ordered produet alone s e e m not t o be t e l a t i v i s t i c a l l y i n v a r i m t ,
the t*
Apparently <01 [.lU (1) , J~(2#/ 0%
-
D outside l i g h t cone t a n f t enough.
so= l f d t on the singular behavior
when cl
m
t2 near xl
p:
I
*
71
x2 is a t o required
It is s a t i s f i e d
(for rczlativlstie invariance) ancl is not s a t i s f i e d here, f o r every other r e a l problm,
Wareafter we drop it supposgng s o w t e r n l i k e
d3x is added t o the Hsmiltonian t a s t r a i g h t e n i t out.
the t r l v f a l ScWiager tern,
Perhaps
"m
It is called
f n g m t m e l e c t r o d p d c s the t r i v i a l S c b i n g e r
t e r n is controlled by calculat%ngby r e p l a t o r s , i.e., of mss m2 minw a t e r n with naae n2
1
+
propagatl-sg electrons
2 ) need not be positive and
h2 ea .(p
p (mZ,do2 is t k e n zero. Certain funetiow and t h e i r t r m f o m a r e t w o r t m t .
111 where
S
2
Jl
Propagator
- &Ml
.t.
i n time l f k e regiom m d s
Far l m g e s, H is asympicotically II
%
e"'-.
m
-2
i a space l i k e regloarrii,
For smll s
For f r e e f i e l d s o f a o a a a m i t i s just < ~ l E t # ( 2 ) ,4fl11 T
The c-utator
function
,
30
Photon-Hadran Inreractbvzs
For free fields P t i s 41
for real
B
only.
Outside the light cone i t 28 zero.
Far amall s
Prablem 5.1,
Shaw t h a t the total erosa aectioa to produce any hadrons from ef at energy E
4-
4- e'-
E: 18 p(q2)
(3
where q2
4E
2
.
PrabLem 5 . 2 .
2
Find g(q ) for muon paZr production. for q 2
4
2
.
Prcittfem 5.3,
Use p(s2) of problem 5.2 to find vtq2)
- v(O)
for the vacuum polarisation
Low Energy Photon Reactions
Lecture S
bference:
R, L. Walker, Phys, Rev.
182,1729
(1969).
A8 our f i r s t exper%wntal. subject we t&e up low energy photoprsduction
of pions from nucleoas,
W n g the iadividusl reactloas a r e
y.tg-+n++n y+p-*so+g
y+n+nm+p y+n-+ro+n The f i r s t two a r e the mat extensively stutfif?ci. Today data on various polarfzation a d spin case@ are also available. things which depend on
C.H.)
2
CNn
is aften called e.
1 S
l W> (*l2
f o r q2
m2
-
+
Evidently we a r e measuring
0. me ( t o t a l energy io the
2mvW
where vLAg f s the energr
c f the pihoton i n tbe lab system (Ear us v goes Eroa O t o 2 say),
nat the m l y atcltrix e l e m n t s from I s t a t e s a t these enotrgie8
etc. a r e a l s o possltble but. we d%aews these l a t e r ,
mese a r e
The
rullst
&exacteristic fearure of the behavior Fe rapid chmges i n mgular
d i s t r i b u t i m with enerw.
su&
m a-
+p
+p
-+
r"lAs feature ilr c h a r a c t e r i s t i c of hsdrm c ~ l l i @ i o n s
alao a d is Snterpr&ted aer due t o resonanca.
s m e z e s w w c e s appear here, of
COUXE~, W
i n s scatteriag,
The
The ghafon data
has been emlalaed ancl rrnalyzed i n consfde;c&la derail. on t h b b a g s ,
F%mt
we d i a c w s tbe general ""eeory" oof tesonrsncesrr. of the T guarr%xmwt have a apecisl propatty o f
A g m e r a l e1-at:
separability def Sned by tbe f o l l w i n g circcolllsian like G
+X
t o wh D
J.
B
+G
J.
D
+E
+ P.
taprces,
Suppose we img&ne a
h a pasaibiliey is t h a t A
in one part of space (via e l e m n t
C ~ I S I A Bm>ci then e B
r e e l p a r t i c l e goer off acrosa the. roar5 t o hit: G t o d That b
~ E E T ~ I must T / ~have > m infinity--a
eatiafy p*
.%7
+ pg
- pc
pX and :p
% is positive)
hit first
X W
8
+ F via G + X
+
E + F.
singularity when the maenta
hru Ule valve
%2
f o r e r e a l pareiela X.
residua a f the singvlarity .i <EP~'~/O~?*. When: p
2 % (and
+B
is vely near
the behavior 2s very =eh as i f rm i d e a l f r e e p a r t i c l e
- %2 + i&)-',
of w s %2 propagated s o the ~ p l i t v d ev a r i w a s p (:
&re specieicallp i f S is written
8fi
- (2*) 4 164 (pg-pi)
TEb
a r e s o m c e [don't c m f u r e T rJdth T@] wed pre*owrlp).
&@re(pA + pg is r i @ t ) .
- pc)
2
fa evff i c i m t l y eloae ro %2
(and the sign of the energy
There m a t be a corresponding singular behavior f o r every way
t h a t the m w t a eaa be e d i a a d Snto the m e m t t t o a of
S-
strrble p a r t i c l e ,
lfhe emet: form o f the s i n m l a r i t y cola@@f r m an sftaXytic extrapolation from the fmginary part
a r e posslbla, If
B
s m f l perturbation lsueh
abl week
intaraction) a c t s t o make s t a r s X
s l i g h t l y ~ f s b l md a of decay r a t e TX it c m be s h a m t h a t the oodificatioa
Low Energy Photon Reactions near the resonance is t o replace
( n e r e a r e a l s o s l i g h t m d i f i c a t i a n s of is the a m e ) ,
%
and the reslrlues, but the form
The non-relatlrjristic f o m is
In non-relativistic theory t h i s is the farm no rnatter what I' L due to, It has been found that such resoant: bcchavior of the T mtrix is e&ibtbited
(Hera ehe width I" is not produced by weak external
by strong interactkons.
perturbation, but is a consequence of the strong Satexaction f t s e l f , )
They have
the follokring characteristics, T varies in l r e i t Wfgner fashion
Zlzio only means s-thlng
precirjie i f I' Is small enough that the v a r l s t f o ~
R~
f n the r e s i d w factors < c d l ~ f
(as near threshold behavior--there
&>
are e i t h e r negligible o r well knwn
a proper variation af I' wfth Q m y have
t o be included),
me
resonmcea appear i n wny rerrctioaa a t the a-
S-
(given I-spin, angular ammtm, strangenms,parirry).
Properties I s a t e b l e of such reso.aaaces. o f reso-ees
ija
stronl$ interaet20nsl
lnatrs m d
width
The Table of P a r t i c l e
What f s the waning of the existence
There a r e
lea of nwrow reamances
i n 0&hr f i e l b . a)
Ataac sgstew.
The wciced levels of a t o w a r e stsltrle except fox
coupling with li&t, The n a r r m e s s of the &sewed resowaces i n the e M s s i o ~ f o r e z q l e , is h-
spectrurn of an at-,
2 wupling e b) &sewed.
.
Nuclei.
The eoapling is k n m t o bs large but nsrrcrw resoasmces are
In fdzis case the orfgZn of the n a r r m e s s of tbe r e s o m c e s c m
s t i l l b e mderstczod,
In the decay of esr excimd nuclew of high A by the
a % s e i o a of a neutron; f o r concentrate enaa& W
t o be d w t o the s d X v a l w of the
~t
l e , i t I s hard f o r the wave flurction t o
enarw aon a single tleutron t o escape,
Other a f f e c t s such
cet?nrifugaf b a r t i e r s account f o r Ebe anarrmeas of rmonancea i n nuclear
physics.
Koaa of the above e f f e c t s s e w t o appear i n p e r t i c l e physiea,
But also
ressnancas a r e generally not s o n a r r w , the width is &out a fourth of the spaclng t o the next reeomnce i n the er-
chmel,
The e a n f n g of the appearanc
etreng latertretfom is aot a d e r s t o o d ,
o f rerarrnances
A t f i r s t theoretical
physiciata did not expect reaonmces f r m strong coupling f i e l d theory, they realized i f i t were strong eaougb there were. ""lobraric strrtes".
Then
But the
exact naeadng of the existence of thscre resonances Tor wderlying t h e o ~;ts not clear.
Lecture '2
We discuss a a d e r of p r o b f e i n genera2 i n using ree-acm,
i n the
apeclfie f o m used by Walker, a)
Em m c h Is resoamcea and how anoch i e backgroad? Can the backgrow4
befiw s resonlujce be sinrply t a f l a of other r a a m a e e s ?
Ef
B
lChw
varies l i k e a(E) % a(%)
+ @(&ER)
If we w r i t e a resonance
then our reslmanco Is
a general; backpound a c m o r be d e f i a a m l a s s one i e apecifSc &out
the variation of
c-rant write .cl]>,
e.g.
W
y
o r ather expf l e i t %o-
v although It has mrit of being precise,
it m y depend on how we
a d s e a a b i t arbitrslcy
In practicicit e m t & m s we knew T wt vary because we a r e cloee t o a threshold where i. varies menew,
East.
p2"'
f o r e m l l Q where L ia the o r b i t a l imgu2.r
This Eom camot be correct f o r large Q beeawe i t b l m s up too
To deal with that m i r i c a l l y Wa&er choee
Low Energy Photon fieactions
f o r the r a t e a =son coaplm t o a proton, a t h angular
mmtzlm
a.
For a
photon a s i d l a r
term was wed,
x was a r b i t r a r p (at d o a t ,350 &V
P236 where ,160 was w d ) .
far a l l r e s o n a c e s exct?pt the
But chmginig x 3,s 1ike ehanging a(E) ,--it d i s t o r t s
the f o m and leaves the qumtion--W b i g is the t a i l af a resonace? w o r a s i b l e to Pusmer except a r b i t r a r i l y , Probltira.
Fa (q/go]1/2 has implications f o r the expression b e l w
m e use of 'l threshold,
These a r e not used by Walhr (violating dispersion relations).
What a r e they2 'Et.leor%sta lgke t o choose the inf i ~ t a l ymrrcrw resanaace approst2mtion; a is c ~ n ~ t w the t , backgroaad i a
ce baclrgxauds--or
rather ' k f f e c t s of resoarnew f a r froer
their r e r s m a t ewxgy"", This last. concept: h quotes is very s u b t l e arid hard t o define but i r s used glgbly f o r a11 kiads o f &gags today f n theory, aa we s h a l l see,
b)
Can T be e q r e s s e d e a t i r e l y
the erne a
+b
+
c
abl
a s m of rarsonant: tern? Cowider
+d
meae a r e raeoaancea %n the
t3
ehe=X
of the kind
;and have a e m
Then t h e r e a r e resonmcea %n the t channel fratn d i a g r m of the f o r a
For a r e a l ewerimeat none of these a r e resonmt s i n c e t s O, a l l a r e f a r wag. A thaorerical question 5s : S b u l d we add (7.1)
This
t o (7.2)
(and u reai.macecs)?
only meam somthing i f (7.11 i s pracleely defined, It i s a t e a e t of theory (called Ve-~t~rzlmoor e z t e n d d duality) today
t h a t we shaulet s a t add (7.1) aad (7.2) b u t t h a t i n the sum af e ehmnal reeonances a l m e i a the t c h m e l behavior c-letely t o apply t o the -giaaq Aja
defined; t h i s is supposed
p a r t only,
expression has becm foand Tor (?,l) whicfii when s m a d glvee somthing
(Venezimo). t h a t can be wrictl~nm a a m of t Chmael t ' e s ~ l i \ m ~ m d f f f i e u l t i w af defIInftion i n practice,
What Walker did was t o take a t e r n
f a r each r e s w n c e & a t he k n a abaut, p l w a backgromd, the ~ L f t l l d eas the
%eae a r e
In f a c t he wrote
of three parts:
( l ) @-channel resomnces
(2) the pion exchange (3) background,
(l]
The resoamit: w a e s aad width@were talren from. the nN seatcering
data which had been analyzed by a w l i t u d e s f o r each chmnel (of angular
meaturn, I spin, parity).
A corurtant, tho maertx ~ B / J ~ \i.e. w> ~ R / T \ ~ N ~
f o r each resonance had t o be deternrined e w i z a s a l l y , by ad;justAnlng t o f f t: data, (The other f a c t o r < E N ~ T ~ Rw>a s ssv@jll&le from n acacterisg). ( 3 ) The '%ackgraundv' was a slawly vatyZng -litode
i n each chameX,
CootSnesai. of f i t of paramfaro i n (l) i e r judged i f the background can be made t o vary tslauly, o r at; l e s s t s m o t h l y ,
backgrqround t e r n would be r e a l but:
T t was hctped t h a t a11 theae
smU imaginary nm ultimately
needed i n so= c h a m l s , possibly beeawe resonanees a r e left out, or have
37
Law Energy Pltororz Rcactr'orrs fnaccurate p a r w e t e r s ,
mext time
Walker does t h i s he w i l l r e l a x the condition
t h a t the background m p l i t u d e be r e a l , )
Lecture 8
We continue with the di~sua~a~ilon of the t e r n used by Walker.
(2)
t c f i m e l a pole,
T h l e Is fsm diagrslcn A
la diagram which does not e x i s t f o r +@--but r e %Illsay aore about t h i s l a t e r ) . E t leads t o s term l i k e
-
where
8<;21
y51
ul>
is an m p i r i e a l determination of how a ' s couple a t t h e i r
pole, empirleelly
This f a c t o r t-42 varies rapidly with t f o r
14.8.
eaaall t , lesdtng t o a rap%&angular dependence. may
from the nucleon.
S m l 1 t lneaasr
lan
effect far
m e e f f e c t 18 t h a t s nucleon hais a chance t o be seen
ss a nucleon with a n' around i t spread r e l a t i v e l y f a r out, a s
i n mplitude.
I f thh%s v i r t u a l
B
is k i t with a photon f t ean be e m t out
fomards aad. appear r e a l ( " d o a d " ' ) having received its necessarg energy and meat=
f r m the photon,
It goes f a i r l y aharpLy forward--at
higher eaergiee
a t l e a s t and a f f e c t s the m p l i t u d a s fn a l l valuw of s-&aanel lrtaplar mmntraaa incluBing high v a l u w , where f o r low energies and =mat& no ferraaaaces a r e large,
So it gives the nrajox c o n t r ~ u t ? l a aa t tha h i e e r angular
Since there the rapid v a r i a t i o n wgth t near t pale 42
.OZ
4.:
0 f.s essential
we;
a r e near the
G ~ V ' and we can e m i d e r It trueororthy and accurate.
To be
sure, a t the higher energiee lawer sagular mmmts invoxve i t f o r t; l a r g e and
SO
the f o r .
l/t-Getc. may be wrong o r smblguow (we
follow the principle--the
man we r a n t t o
contr%butioa of poles 2s well defined only f o r
pm-ters
near t h e i r resonaace),
But here the a m l i t u d e is slawly energy
d e p d e n t and i t s exact value Ear the l m a s t one o r
WO
angular m e n t a
(a, p wave@) is l o s t %a the background mplltudea we a r e rrddgng &away.
(He backwomd was added f o r very high angulsr =mattan). The exprearsion we have written f o r the a p l f t u d e i s not gauge invariant, hwwer,
f
The R springs lrm a source m4 doesn't conserne charge,
be co:orablned t o other t e m o t o &a
f t cowletesly gauge invariant.
T t arust
Qne obvious
c a n t e a e r f e the a channel resonance cosresponding t o the unexeited nucleon a t 938,
We
be e l f i i n a l
C=
pat these together asc follcrws ( l e t chargas on Initial. nucleon
nuclem e2, pion en)
these &&v@
With
4
replaced by
the three a q r e @ a i o n sgive
Note %a i n e l w i a of d i a g r m I Z T f o r the nuclean reeonance r a i a d e ue of Eh@question of whet;her we should not: a l s o have added to our law energy s channel
Low E~ergyPhoton Reacti;ons resonances, such
W
the 4, such d i a g r w as
The w w e r i s certainly yes,
They were not included by Glialker but again they
are r e l a t i v e l y s l w l y varying f o r a positlve e n e r m w ,
They a r e f a r off from
their x e s o m c e (hi&appears belw thxeahofd at negat5ve The gauge invariance of Mx
+ MIX +
U$
is seen t o hold even i f tbe
r t e r n a t e d t t e d , m e e e t e m contrgbfbute only low sngular
an-loa
momentm a t law energy as does the e n t i r e I T and Tlf, and does not vary p a r t i c u l a r l y rapZtlly with k. l / k singular behavier. constirnt
ets
k
-t
For small L a11 three t e r n have the expectad
The mamlausl m g a e t i c te-
O beeawe there
&B
l n I1 aad TIE go t a a
a k In the n w r a t o r also.
Since the?.
b a c k g r o d t e r n was a r b i t r a r y except it was rusrsmed t h a t it was a) smll i n hi&er angular mementm s t a t e s , b) slowly vazylng I n energy; we could omit the a m l o u s mmeat t e r n asd inelude thea i n the background,
Walker did t h i s
and found, perhaps surprisingly, t h a t Sf be l e f t these anmZous mment tern
out, the backgroud
watit
d e f i n i t i o n of the '"pfn
a a l l e r than i f ha l e f t them in, exchange tenn" is I
his e w l i c i t
%W
+ IX + 111 with v1
p2
O
(an e w r w a i o n he c a l l 8 the?. ""elecrxie Born tern"'), We Bee t h a t he caulit j u s t have w e l l l e f t out the nomon;taloufl w m n t t e r n too d w e d a s h p 1 e r exprearsion--readily generalized t o etake gauge i n v ~ r i a n t
fn a r a t i o n a l way Epion excbasrge tern,
t h e lsst tm vgniehea because $l
-
For
M on the % n i t i d s t a t e .
18 l i k e a a o s t p t i c w m n t t e r n 2n t h a t i t has no pole a s k-
The secand t e w -i.
O; i e is of lcw
angular wmentunr and slow emrgy bebavfor; i t can be t&ea i n t o the bsck;ground, Leaving out all such w m n t t e m , 8s they only e o n t r a u r e t o undefiaed backgremd we find the pion exchange t a r n c m be w r i t t e n i n a gauge invariant f @m:
"pies exefrmge tern"
(for na,ew
0 and &g is raplaeed by
favarisnt q r e s s i a n )
@,gl
.
-
eZ
SO
we ~ t f l l have . a gauge
Zt f s w i d e n t t h a t the ""pan exchange ternft hhaajr no p r e c L e defingtion (sme parr of the nucleon
resonance t a r n is added).
'Ebe &Iguity
of e m c t l y
what p a r t i e a c a d w c because the d i g u i t ; y is fslwly v a q f a g and e a s i l y Elbsorbed i n the deffnftion of '"background". caae, a t any k2 (not only k2
We would suggest f o r a getneral
0 ) and my i n i t i a l & f f n a l s t a t e t h a t we take
j u s t the t e r n
.rf fnli> 5s the m l i t u d e f o r the d i a a r m
Since s t r i c r l y t h i s is off s h e l l s-
d e f h f t i o n by theory m y be used, althawgh
a l l we c m be sure of Is t h a t the recliduie on &elf i a correct, term'qo~es not have
2
The
""no
exchmge
). The mlagular dependence is slw and shows no
forward peak. Any form l i k e
f a r m y a would be af l righe, but (8.5) has the v i r t u e t h a t tbe @Angular bekavior
M
k
+
-+
O s p h y s i c d l g correct,
I have gone t h r m & t h i s long d i s e w s l o n t o shaw t h a t Walker c no tXsaoretical e r r s r of principle i n h i s etbocrl of f i t t i a g .
rrdjuatabls
parmetere of f i t were the desZred quaatitfear
l 1
Walker gives the value of the . a t r h elelnent a s A:
Low Energy fioton Reactions
l
r a t h e r than c f 1J.e i> directly.
41
Suppas@ a resonance of mase m1 decays i n t o a
nuclean energy E2, and a phomn each of monentu. Q.
(Q
-
(m:-m2
2
)/Zmlj
.
If the photm goes off i n the z direction with partitive h e l i e l t y +1, there a r e two h e l i c i t i e o poesible f o r ehe proton -112, $112, i n tnich case t h e h e l i c i t y of the decaying resoaence A@ C312 or +1/2. anti f o r whether It is proton o r neutron
A i a gSven for each ease,
[sea Table 8.1).
Quark Model of Resonances
The various baryon raanaaces h a w been successfully c l a ~ l e i f i e dby the quark =@del; they a r c as i f they were m d e of three q w r h ,
Each q w r k has
s p i s 112; three possible unitary spin e t a t e s u, d, a ; u, d a r e 1 spin +l/2,
-I/2 artrmgenees zero; s L K spln Q, s S,
d.
-1; charges a r e +2/3 f o r u, -113 f o r
It i a a s s w d that the s t a t e is separable h its depedence on u n g t a ~
spin, r e w l a r spin, and s-
additional internal, coordinate o r coordinates
having ctxaracreristics of i n t e r n a l o r b i t a l laatioa, The nucleon a c t e t a d the I m e s t d e c i m t require no "orBieW cmtributiorr, but the next s e t of levels of odd p a r i t y are wderstoad, as getting t h e i r parity
and swmnta,
of t h e l r angular ~ W U C W
f r m a f i r s t azcitation of an o f i i t a l angular
m e s o "'quarkft c m be lcoked upon as abstract indices t o describe
a wave function ( i n which ease w e need three indices each of vizlch can be a u n i t a q & s spin contaitxliag g a d s , taksag therefore 3. x 2 (or 3 x 4 uasalng
Dirae apfnorar?) valum and mother S-space vector index f o r the mgular
tm.
Mtenrative&y bE the picture fa tmken aroxe l i t e r a 2 l y acit particles
going a r o d eadh other we wwld be l@&
t o e w a c t fxo imtemal, degrees of
freedom and two angazar m m t a whL& could coarbine.
%%is leads t o the
e ~ c t a t i a nof a greater variety aX s t a f a s t h m dow the other v i m , but t h i s
42
Quark Model of Resonance$ excess only a r i s e s a t second i n t e r n a l e x c i t a t i o s , o r s t a t e e of p o s i t i v e parity Today t h e r e $8 no s u r e evideace t h a t these two angular m a e n t a
of hi&er arrtsaes,
are n e c e s s a v (a s t a t e needing them oa the 1970 t a b l e is a m eomidered uacertain) Emever, we w i l l szuppoee they ezciet, md w i l . 1 study a r a t h e r ""realf>hysical
FJiev of the arodel,
The
&S
t r a c t theory wf t h oae aagular not e x l e t as a
f o m l a t e d c l e a r l y emu@ t o do c a l c u l a t i o m with it--ft
tm alternative. I w i l l J w t b r i e f l;g renriad you of the fdeag and elemntarfr cwequtmcea of the q w r k a t d e l ,
A qulmtm s t a t e of three &jecta can have
properelee w d e r p e m t a t i m s of thelpe objects. change sign, a n t i @
one of S poes%bi-blle
X t may be
t r i e A,or i n cm@ of two a t a t e s of
&.X
which upon p e m t a t f o m become Iirvaar e d i w t l o w of themelves,
Thus
i f X r e p r e e a t s t h e two mixed s t a t e r , c o d i a e S with X say mkea a s t a t e of t r y X, A with A is ay-trfc c d i a a t i o m of the f m r etat-
pradwt
S
X
S, X with X mkw with d i f ferttnt l i n e a r
e i t h e r 3 , X c r A, Chw
A
With u a f t a v s p i n there a r e three eholces. f o r each quark or 27 s t a t e s .
(since cm& mt be d i f f e r e a t ) ,
S
The r e m i n i n g 16 a r e 8a and 88.
Thw the
l & dee-t
X =
octet
A
s%mglet:
Only such
There
s t a t e s l u u ~ l ~u ~, d ,etc. ~ aad only 1 s n t i s
a r e 10 sy-trie
;FIU3
.
laultipfeta a r e found -ng
&a baqons.
possfbilftierr there is no a x l t h y m t r i c s f a t e ,
Psr s p i n with two
The ay-trfc
i a s p i n 312
quartet, the X (two) 58 s p i n 112 doublet, symdbokfztzd by superserlpt 4 o r 2, m r e f o r e c o a i n i n g s p i n a d = & t a w @piawe can mike the f o l l d n g
.
m l t i p l e t e (SU6 arultiplete) , S c m erne fronr $ * S o r X * X v l a chart d o v e so
/ S> [X'
Iri3
--
-
or B ' 'L '8 5' o r and 28
56 s t a t e s ?Q s t a t e s
2@
20 s t a t e s .
W
Ffaally we combine t h i s with i n t e r n a l o r b i t a l motion,
We can ttttnk of a
h a m n i c o s c i l l a t o r force f o r defin%teness. The mswer depends on the degree
of excitation of the o r b l t s N. We are t o make m overall c~mpletc?lys m e t r i c l a l s t a t e ,
N
No i n t e r n a l motion.
0.
v
merefore pure ( 5 %
2 = 410312,
2
$112
the well km Zcrwest decimet and o c t e t ,
N
I, One salt of excitation has the
P
~ o v e( r e l a t i v e coordinates onXy) XI 3. X2 f s impossible.
..1
X smetry.
+ X3
Because the (3% canat
where X is a position of
Only differences c m be inmlved, f i e
Im,
1133
a quark
states:
--Ji; (TRl - X2 - X,) f
"F get overalf. 152, t h i s o r b i t a l
\X,
mat: be c o d i n e d with unitary spin aacl
spin f ~ o>r 70, Fgnally whea the unit of mgular m e n t m h eodfned with the spin i n v a r i o w ways to make differrstnt t o t a l asgular amenturn j, a l l o f odd parity, we find
have been found*
~ lthese l multipkets (except the Note -
I f an abject can be i n oae sE a n u d e r of conditiom with three such objects f o m s t a t e s l i k e condition z, the second r, t h l r d y.
1 zxyz
X,
y, z..,
we c m
waning the f i r s t object is i n
Prom t h i s and its permvtations l x y etc. ~
Qrrark Nodcl rt f Resc~iznrrrr:~ we can: Esm the states 05 definite sy-try
If two say xy are the sam state y
x replace I x y z ~+ lyxz> bp &/xxz>.
I f three are equal only the S sunrivm
Im>S Im>.
Codfning two suck statefir in a product- we f gnd
With theae rules and the rules for co&inlng state fa the. quark w d e l can be constmcted,
angular momnta. any lsgecific
c-l
or
:
!$q
s
;
'
$
P S p
S3
O
$
Quark Model of Resonances
8 q u
Photon-Haa'ronInteractions
Resonance m a e s ml goes t o photon wmentum Q and f i n a l hadrons (see IE col-)
m2,
-8
JZ
is the reeonance spin projectLon along the direction of m t i c n
of the decw photon of b e l t c i t y 4-1.
Lecture 9 The Quark &del (cont.)
N
m
2,
P
Two o r b i t a l e x c i t a t i m each af Eype X can n&e S, X , A m d tbe t o t a l
o r b i t & angular ma, eari b e 2, 1, O rsa it t u r n out the s t a t e of sy-trg
hm t o t a l L
l, s t a t e s S or II caa have 2 ox 0 .
"
The?.20 has not been seen,
4
A
Eleacc we c m d e ,
S
S
g,,
A,,
X t has ao m t r i x e l e m n t aS any operator (fike
J,,) operating on one quark a t a time t o *the proton,
Two q u a r b a t l e a s t awt
have t h e i r w t i m chauzged t o get t o the 20 f r m the? fundmental We have def2nite need f o r the b6.2'1 L
can be gotten i n no other way.
4
m
119, 312+ have
Ibo ather h ' & of t h i s s e t of d e c b t s a t
a L a been seen a t roa&ly &ra
trrultiplet is eapected as a
+
because of a b of spin 7 / 2 which
A
sanre energy.
recurreace of the f m e t m n t a l
and i a 2.1 (6e12 i s mm2 above,
lCfiis a t o accounts well t a r the o c t e t
4-
A puzzling s t a t e Ls bhe 112 Roper reaonanee a t 2.16.
as evidence of the
This whole
=at
Xt; is best f i t t e d
is puzzling about t h b s t a t e is its lw
Quark Mode E of Rgsonarzcttc; mass es compared t o the
2
a t 2.85 vhieh is beat f i t t e d i n
The q w r k d e l
mme. two s t a t e s a r e identical i n tbebr SU(6) p r o p a r t l a ,
with hsmoaic dynmics predicts the= t o be of the s m e m s since they both The large -a
correspond t a two i n t e r n a l e x e i t a t i o m , ha-nic
d y n d c s sray be too a i m l e .
difference sfims t h a t
%he R q e r resonance is a breathing m d e
o s c i l l a t i o n of the nucleon; i t is l i k l y that a21 breathing =odes of oscillstiaxr Lead t o s resonance of lower mass than those with a m t orbiea2 angular m a e n t m . I I
C
Efm not been seen,
m
a r e the s t a t w chat a r e expected i f there were only one i n t e r n a l degree of freedonr, Ew good
the evidmce t h a t they are there,
require t h m : 1/2+~(1780)possibly ~70.0'1 m2
,/~'N(~sso)
possibly $ 7 ,2'~!
7/2'~(1990)
[70,23 m2
-
-
not be eweered.
m e r e a r e three s t a t e s t h a t m y
3.16
m2 = 3.46
3.96.
The l a t t e r s t a t e would have t o be degree of Ereedozn only--but
The 70's aoald
; it would be farpossible w i t h o m
it $a nat: well established,
P a r t i c l e tables, but: not on the 1971 tatrles:)
(It w w on the 1970
The f i r s t could a l s o be
a higher '%reathliagU m d e exclt&tioa of the nucleon, the rset being rruclesn
jlZte
second, ilf only one i n t e r n a l motion is a l l w e d , would have r o be the
missing o c t e t frant the
at J
3/2.
d i f f e r e n t from the mass2 = 2.85 of the 5
If s o i c s w s 2 = 3.46 is very 5/2 s t a t e so the w u a l r u l e of
smll spin o r b i t coupling would have t o be abazldoned, TTrua the ewkdenee is i n fsvar o f requir5ng two i n t e r n a l degrees of freedca
but i t i e not conclusive. Probf m,
P
A ~ o resemeb d problem is t o carefully study the properties of the 20
v i a the quark model ancl propoae the wisest: way t o look f o r i t esrperimntally, The d i f f i c u l t y i n &serving the 20 b t h a t I f we ass-
we probe the b a q w
through aa operator which a c t s on m e quark a r o tiw (regardless of the m t u r e of &a operator) then the 26 cannot be reached frola the nueleon,
The reason f o r
t h k is t h a t the 26 i s a n t i s
t r i c i n f t s SU6 indices & f l e t h e nucleon b
t o t a l l y @ m e t r i c , Operating on one of the q m r b i n the nucleon s t i l l leaves the other two i n a a y m e t r i c s a t e , %ere a r e m y Btatee p o s s f i l e a t l4 = 3.
.
Regge recurrence af
The wst i q o r t ~ n tis surely the
A fekt s t a t e s of t h i s are apparently
hae
I
4,
P
A d of s p i n 11/2 probably from
Calculation of W t r i x Elemats. The siraplerint application of the q w r k rnodel is t o c d c u l a t e rnatrix e l e m a t s w e r d n g a nonrelativiatie
SchrBdinger equation f o r the q u a r k ,
There a r e
d f g u i t i e a of factors l i k e a 2 / 5 o r B /a (energies and lllassas of f i n a l a d
2 2
i n i t i a l s t a t e ) but f o r our ghotoelectrfc mtrirr e l e m n t s Mey a r e sra;dl. See R. Walker " a n g l e pion photoproduction
Sfn
the reslmance regfan" Xnternationatf
Spposiunr on ELectron and Photon I n t e r a c t i o m st Hi@ Energies, Daresbur)., EngTmd, 1963.
See d a o references therein,
One s i w l y works out the @ t a t = of a systtarn with Bmilconian of three hamanic o s c i l l a t o r s :
One takes the s p i n and unitarty s p i n dependence8 t o f a c t o r out frm the i a t e m d mtion. The i n t e r a c t i o n of one quark, say l, w i t h an electrornapetic f i e l d is taken
where el its the eharge w the quark.
PLatdx e l ~ n t of s t h i s operator (with i\
the appropriate plane wave f o r a ptroton) between s t a t e s n of the B<onian, 19 ,L)
givedl us our n&ers
l
f o r <EM .lf p> t o warpare, t o e~ergmernt.
v
The q m t i t i e s ut, w, g, are p a r a t e r @ ; e; is the gyro-mment of the quark.
lChe Bfrac value g w
1 w o r k very well. a d i t was chosen t o be I.
The value of
is guctrpsr;cl ss MO HeV s o the l e v e l spaciag w i l l be rar~&ly ri&t--the
of xa is &@sea (as 340 @V)
t o f i t the proton = w e t i c m a e n t ,
ts t h a t rectult are given i n t a b l e 8.1 next t o
value
The wlucts of larilt
col-
Quark Model of Resorzatzces Anon-rel,
NR
A
k n m values.
.
It is seen t h a t there is remrkablp good agreement with the
A l l the s i p s a r e ri&t and sm~rllv d u w a r e predicted t o be
a m f l , sometimes by s e l e c t i o n rules generated by the mdel--eoaetiaes by cancell a t i o n of t e r n f o r o r b i t and spin coupling,
(me t e m containing p i n the
colum f o r a r e rtze ones c m t r s u t e d by spin--the fomalas a r e fro= St
v
a relativistic mdfficatian.
case),
mey a r e v i r t u a l l y the s m e
8s
the n o n r e l a t i v i s t i c
Finally the orders of tnagnftude are generally very close-the
worst
is tbe FI5/1688) with +312 halicitpl m proton which 1s off by a factor 2. is
W
Xt
possible that t h i s is an e r r o r of the theory, m t h a t It is a eystematPc
e r r o r of kTalksr% f i t t h e r e he a t t e r l , f o r siraplfcity, a rider of resoaanellrs which the quark nodel says should not be smS1, Smexal questiom a r i s e f f t h i s is r e a l ,
F i r s t a non-relativisti c theory
is surely not valid contagning p a r t i c l e s of mrtmol, 340 MeV i n which the f i r s t Second, with such law quark w s there should be
excitation i 8 400 MeV.
We have w e d Bose s t a t i s t i c a ,
I f the quarks can be f r e e i t can be proven
that spin 1112 implies Fermi s t a t i s t i c e .
The only way out fa to aaeupse three
kinds o r "'coloxsfhf quarks f o r each Sllg type and say t h a t the bound s t a t e s are pure eingleta i n the new index,
For e x m l e , baryons m a t be i n the 34 s t a t e
containing one o f each color thus m t i a
t r l c i n the eofor, t o say naw t h a t
quarks obey Femi s t a t i s t i c s require8
t r y i n the other indices.
S
(A f o m l
way of d e d i n g wlth t h i s called p a r a s t a t i s t i c s c m be shown t o be exactly equivalent t o the three colors of F e w quark theory,)
Lecture l 0
, tried
t o remdy the point
t h a t a n o n r e l a t i v i s t i c theory was d l l g u o u s l n hew you applied i t t o a probfm of relatLvPatie k l n e m t i c s by =king a a e a r y &ere the rules a t l e a s t were relativislicalily stated.
Such a theory t o be complete would have t o be a
r e l a t i v i s t i c f i e l d thee-
which is too c w l l c a t a d t o calculate.
s i w l e theory of s t a t e s , but a t the ewenee of unitarity-+ich trouble l a t e r on--but
They ooade a ateant consider&le
a t h a s t relatfvSstically u n d i g a o u s rules could be
fornulated.
The a e t r e s u l t f o r our photon m t r i x ePemnts is 60 g%ve a l w s t
exsctfy the s-
n m r i c s l result
of great i n t e r e s t here.
W
the non-relativiatie ewe--so
it is not
(Xt does s o rJith oaa 1ess arbltrarjr constant, hmever.1
I w e r t h e i e s s wc o u t l i n e the nlethad. They noted *at
the het
2mE = p2
+ m2w2x2 and t h a t ZmH was nearly the difference of the squares of the
mere m
4
W (or mass) of the s t a t e s .
Thus t o get (mssaj2 t o be equally spaced
they could w e an eigw-vector operator f o r Paase2 which wag a h a m n i c o s c i l l a t o r , which they c a l l n2, s o the quark masa disappears on
The only c o w t a n t is the ri&t haad efde,
Thus l e t
(10.2) G is a c a s t a n t , pa is 4 - d i w ~ f o n a l quark a. m seen
This i n recipxoeal is a propagator X/K.
Its poles (K
0) give
-S
as follaas:
Take out the car. m t P m
nturn operators 5,
rr
(wlth coordinates x, y) fPnd
E3 i s t h e E w i l t o n i a n f o r trvo o s c i l l a t o r s ,
N
-
No have poles i n K as (p2
- H)-',
Thus s t a t e s of aigen-value 2
o r propagate ae p a r t i c l e s of mass
-
No.
Begge slopes indicate m&sZincresses by 2 per u n i t of angular momatran, hence take R f.05 &V. 1.05 (&V)
Evidently these are separated by Q.
(For the baryon photoelectric matrix elententa there are no further (effective) adjustable constants. 1
2
If
X,
is perturbed by 6K the propagator becows
s o 2.ct f i r s t order the dkturbance &M becams
o r the appropriate p e r t u r b a t i o ~ sof r n Z v h f e h is the r e l a t i u i s t i e T matrix el-ntrs
defined bp the u s w l r e l a t i v i s t i c pules--58
J u s t t h e rrzstrix elenents
of &g bemeen e i g a stagers o f W,
% a t about spin? The lack of =eh
s p i n o r b i t coupling auggwrs t h a t s p i n
f a c t o r s from the r e s t of .Clre wave fuaet"ferr---thus t h e operator K is t h e s m e e q r w a i o a t i a e s a wave ftulction with three d2rae Cc cmpanenl: i n d i c w ?atbough it does not a f f e c t those indices i n no electroourgoetic f i e l d .
2 Laeerpreted =mits equal I$ )
50
is
Barever :p
wfrea an e l e c t r o m g n e t i c ELeld i a operating
the operator f a
(10.4) ea,
%,
eC a r e t h e chargw on the three quarks,
The f i r a t order perfu&atlcnt t h w gives t h e carrent aperator f o r mmntm Q:
M t r h elmentzo of t h l s a r e taken betmen s t a t e s of the a y s t a , But tba systeog has too m a y @ t a r e s . (2) The 44%mensional o s c i l l a t o r has time-cmponent s t a t e s which have negative norat (or negative mergp
the f o m e r but see b e l ~ w ) . To avoid t h i s it
%S assumd
-
prefer
they a r e not excited
-
so the ertperiwntal s t a t e s s a t i s f y the subsidiary condition of being i n the r e a t s t a t e of t h e o s c i l l a t o r $.a the direction of t h e 4-=turn ( i f ay* ~d
b
U
*
P
V
are ereation operarrra f o r the two ~ . c & 1 1 ~ t o r e ) ,
of the a t a t e
Photon-Hadron Interactions (2) By taking 4 t o involve Dtrac spinoras twice a s m n y s t a t e s a s d e s i r e d a r e
included (Q and T i ) ,
To avoid t h e p a r t s of t h e epenor appropriate t o antiquark
s t a t e s other sllbsidiary c o n d i t i m s a r e assumed,
where m is t h e mass of t h e s t a t e (m2
P P 1. U 1.l
( 3 ) The c u r r e n t i s not gauge
2
i n v a r i a n t u n l e s s t h e mss d i f f e r e n c e s used a r e e x a c t l y NSt (i.e. C is a t r u e coastant).
These m t r i x e l e m n t s a r e computed with t h e t r u e experimental mass
which =ay not have e x a c t l y a s e p a r a t i o n Nbl. s t a t e s a r e unaffected.
Transitions f r m
2
2
8p t o q u a r t e t
Also t h e E15(1688) is unaffected f o r i t s mass2 is almost
e x a c t l y 2R above t h e proton,
The uncertainty involved f o r a l l elements of t h e
t a b l e (except w a y ) is probably very small, W i t t i n g such s t a t e s [10,6) and (10.711 teems a canplete s e t is n o t used and, s i n c e t h e m i t t e d s t a t e s have negative nom8, mean@ t h a t slatrix e l e m n t s w i l l be g e n e r a l l y too l a r g e by ever increaaing f a c t o r s a s t h e mass discrepancy of i n i t i a l and f i n a l s t a t e r i s e s .
=B c m p u t e a l l klnde of =son
decay widths
(via PCAC using t h e divergence of t h e a x i a l c u r r e n t f o r t h e pion coupling operator) and f i n d t h i s t o be t h e case.
To compensate they d i v i d e by
a factor
( E ~ u ~ )f o- r~ t h e spins, and include a curoff f a c t o r
(wgth cr d e t e ~ n e de a p i r f c a l l y t o f i t , a*
I/Q,
These do n o t s e r i o u s l y a f f e c t our mtrix e l w n t s , of c u r r e n t , f o r lower s t a t e s ( t h e t h e o r e t i c a l 1688 would be 40% higher without them) they have been included i n t h e nmbere given i n t a b l e (8.1).
It is seen t h a t no e s s e n t i a f
ntodiflcation o f the n o n - r e l a t i v i s t i c model i s implied f o r these m t r f x elements of J U* %%e t a b l e a l s o contafns one meson e n t r y , t h a t f o r w r e l a t i v i t y is very important.
-+
a
+ y;
here
The sgreeaent i e good but recent experimmts
give s t i l l l o w r r e e u l t s ( m r e l i k e .IS].
The value corns from obsexrvation
Quark Mode/ of Resonances into a
of t h e branching r a t i o r a t e of t h e
+
y.
Beside thesenon-diagonal. matrix elements t h e r e is, of course, t h e diagonal element
Is
1
f a c t o r of t h e proton
ThPs f s knom f o r a l l mowntuzn 9 a s t h e f o m
Proton,.
- we d i s c u s s here only t h e low q r e s u l t s ,
(which of course c a m % out r i g h t ) and t h e m g n e t i c naaent. (as used here) is q u i t e unsuccessful t h e r e , p
The quark model
The r e l a t i v i s t i c theory gives
- 2.00 f o r t h e neutron ( t h i s
3.00 Nuclear atapetons f o r t h e proton and
convpares t o 2.79 and - L 9 1 experimrzntally),
t h e charge
It ( l i k e %U3) givee uA
112 utd
-l "00,but i n t h e nagneton of the A hence -0.84 Nuclear mgnetoas.
Experiment is -0.70 3- 0.0'1.
(The r e m o n i t I@magnetons of t h e =ss, of t h e s t a t e
i s i n s t e a d of energy perturbation W(@*B)
-
p(o-B) we have perturbation of messZ
a r e t h e cr%mple riders),
s o t h e values of
Supposing t h a t a l l t h i s serve8 a s evidence f o r t h e quark model, where do we go fro% here?
Me have these possAbilitIea;
I Extensions and improvements i n p r i n c i p l e of theory:
a)
Extension t o o t h e r current; matrix elements,
Naturally a i a X current
elernenta can be c a l c u l a t e d d i r e c t l y f r m t h e s m e model ( p u t & + yfll) few a r e k n o w by @-decay,
and a
They come o u t wrong by t h e saae f a c t o r , i f theory is
m u l t i p l i e d by .71 i t agrees with experkmnt (e.g., model and 1.23 experlmentaklyl.
for
Q
we g e t 5/3 from t h e
Ue%ng PGAC czaaplltudes f o r resonance pion
e s i s s i o n t o nucleon can b e calculated with general success, except f o r a n m b e r of very s e n s i t i v e rnatrfx elements cthich coae out aa t h e d i f f e r e n c e of two l a r g e terms.
For d e t a i l s see
matrix elements f o r qZ b)
- we w i l l d i s c u s s t h e photoeZectrie
Cl l a t e r .
S t a r e s of negative norm,
The8e cause a11 kind@ of m b i g u i t i e s and
uncertainties.
F i r s t , nobody has any idea f o r t h e f a c t o r s introduced by t h e
s p i n (except
consider t h e wave equation t o be t h a t f o r a tw-cmponeat
XQ
spinor wwe function
- t h i s has not been worked
out
- on
the face of i t , i t
appears It would v i o l a t e p a r i t y ,) Second, we have negative n o m time-like states,
In t h I s regard, a s u g g e s t i m was aaade by Fujirnaxa,Kobayashi
, Narniki,
Progr, Theor, Phya, (El.yoto) 41) 1193 (1970). R R uae t h e "wave functiont' 2 2 ezp [ t 2 x yZ r ] f o r t h e ground s t a t e of t h e o e c i l l a t o r s ( a l l o t h e r s a r e 2 ssmply g o l m m i a l s times t h i s f a c t o r , ) The exploding e t cm cmly bbe c o n t r o l l e d
-
- -
by negative norm.
PMI use instead exp [-t2
-
X'
- y2 - z 2 1 which they point
out is a l s o a solution o f
which is a f t e r a l l the sm of four independent o a c i l l a t o r s f a r t , x , y, z each of &ich can be i n its grouad s t a t e ,
The t-
o s c i l l a t o r now caatributes
2 negatively t o mass , and we can have s t a t e s below the ground s t a t e and even
s t a t e s of negative m 2
.
Again we s h a l l have t o say somethl-ng l i k @ "the s t a t e s
a r e not excited" or emetbin8
- but a t l e a s t f t i s an a l t e r n a t i v e view,
Thus the wave functions i n mmatm variables have the E
*ere
2
P is the four-vector oaowntuat of the overall s t a t e li"
=
Q
~
2
.
(The
- others multip2-y by polynonrlals,) two s t a t e s PI t o P2; P2 - P1 q
grouad a t a t e wave Emctioa IsS;Lnrply t h i s f a c t o r Hatrix elementa of currents eiq
' between
*
involve overlap i n t e g r a l s l i k e
&ich is e a s i l y integrated t o give a f o m f a c t a r
%W,
f o r exmpla, the form f a c t o r f o r the proton ( a s s s d n g no spin factors)
&ere : P
pZ2
2 . (P1-P 1j2
-
q
2
comes out
2
It i s seen t h a t f o r large (negative q ) t h i s behaves a s l / q
fora factor, itnd i t generally f i t s rather well!
For the photoelectric matrix elements (q2
-
4 as does the r e a l
0 ) a s s a i a g the s t a r e s observed
Quark Model of Resonanees are those whose tim s t a t e is not excited, a l l the raatrix e l e m n t s a r e nearly m1H2 exactly the same a s FKR (ecpect f o r an occasional facfor of N13/P1*P2
-
;*;H which is close t o l ) except they a l l carry the form f a c t o r F, i t is theoretScally much mare s a t i s f y i n g than FKIl because it is no longer ehosenir a r b i t r a r i l y ) a i c h i n t h i s case works out t o be
wt.rfch is mu&
l i k e FMR e q l i r i c a l P except f o r the 4 i n the ewonent (so it is
very close t o F m r s F t o the fourth power).
mis cuts off mu& too f a s t and
m&ea the poor f f t of the 1688 even mueh m r e unsatisfactory and a l s o destrcvys other cmea t h a t f i t t e d well, Extension t o higher order perturbation, i n p a r t i c u l a r matrix eleaaents of
c)
the succession of two current operators,
Scatterdxtg of photon, eleetronta1p1etic
=ss differences o r non-Ieptonic weak decays require the raatrix e l e m n t of the prodwt of tva currents.
1x1the l a t t e r ease the two currents a r e a t the s a m
space t f m point: and we can prove t h a t i f the quarks a r e Bose the f a m w AT = 112 r u l e f o r these decays is explained. perturbation &K
6K.
Haever, i n
A n a t u r a l suggestion is the second order S
ng aver a l l s t a t e s I n the propagator l/K
%bat should we do? or) SW over aX3 s t a t e s fncluding time s t a t e e w i th negative norn, and i-nclude
no a r b i t r a r y f o m factors.
6) S m over only physi cal e t a t e s (no tim s t a t e s excited) using sorne assumd form factor, y)
- i f so, what factor?
Use the system of F u j i m r a e t a l . e
ng over a l l s t a t e s inc3iuding those
of negative energy, %ere a r e wkward prczblem associated with each way (wSX1 the comutators vanirsh outside the l i g h t cone?) a d nothing precirirct o r d e f f s a t e has y e t been propssed t o coware t o expergmat,
We shall, discuss t h i s problem again when we
have developed further t h e o r e t i c a l tools,
r? ,g,
d h w r a i a n r e l s t igns ,
XI Modoficatiom o f the SpeclEjlc Wlrdel of the Theory. Cm the thaotrg be laodifSed t o be 2n greater degree ta agreeraent w f e h
e-rsmt?
The best cl= t o s t a r t with f s probably the r e a l value of the
mass2, which r e a l l y do depend on t h e SU3 m d s p i n character.
Perhaps t h e
most i q o r t a n t c l u e is t h e l a r g e separation of t h e n, R , n b s p s t e m contrasted with t h e small d i f f e r e n c e s ( a l l accounted f o r by the e x t r a mass2 f o r strangeness) of p , w, 4.
It s e e a s t o Sndicate t h e i n t e r a c t i o n f o r c e is not a v e c t o r , but
an a x i a l vector, octets,
AR i n t e r e s t i n g problem is t h e s p l i t of G and h i n t h e baryoa
The s % q l e quark model p r e d i c t s them t o b e degenerate.
Next coBes the c o r r e c t i o n s t h a t the quark model, t a p l i e s t o i t s e l f f o r physical consiateacy.
For e x e l e suppose, using P U G o r a m d i f i e d quark raode2,
t h a t has come kind of d i r e c t coupling, t h a t a pion, h , m d P a r e coupled - w e can c a l c u l a t e a n mpf.Ltude f o r
This ZatpZiea, of course, t h a t t h e d can decay i n t o v , P and thus t h e h has
a width,
But i n t h e o r i g i n a l theory t h e d was an exact energy l e v e l .
We can g e t
the width by gmagining the d e l t a propagates a l s o v i a v e r t i c a l dtagxaw l i k e
t h e quark model, givea t h e coupling t o be used f a t e r as the b e g h a i n g of s o w p e r t u r b a t i o n expansion. propagator F m
This successful+ i n d u m s an i m g i n a r y p a r t t n t h e
- but a t t h e s w time c o r r e c t s t h e r e a l p a r t s o t h e experi-
m n t a l mss is not the m c o r r e c t e d m s a from t h e d i r e c t use of the quark model.
Wow much is the c o r r e c t i o n armd can we w e i t t o mderstiwad so= p a r t o f say t h e L ,A
msse difference, t h e
4@2@
s p l i t i n the
perturbation theory is hard t o use, i t has a tendency t o diverge, i t s e e m t o h v o l v e couplings f a r away f r o a t h e i r mass shell,, t h e r e a r e w n y more s t a t e s than J u s t the Pn a v a i l a b l e t o the A , e t c , we a r e p a r t l y c o m t i n g the s m e t h i n g twice
F i n a l l y and most impartant
- vrhapa
- maybe
i n t h e e w a t i o n f o r the
quarks we s t a r t e d with already cmtahlns so= of t h e physics of i n t e r a c t i o ~ t h a t we have l a t e r put i n t o t h e perturbation c o r r e c t i m . Clue t o these u n c e r t a i n t i e s nobody has worked thetae thlngs o u t ,
(For
Quark Model of Resonance8 It
another exmple, how much is the w g n e t i c m m n t of the proton corrected? has so-
q l i t u d e t o be a d e l t a and a pion, o r even
'Ibis question Is very serious,
e;
proton end a pion). For
m a t Is the quark model a mdtr?f f a r ?
mong a s e t of i d e a l s t a t e s which is the calculation of f i r s t order eoupl%aj.ne;s l a t e r t o be usad i n s o m defgnite prescription (for e m q l e , a s e r i e s of d i a g r m s l i k e a f i e l d theory perturbation expansim) t o c o q u t e the f i n a l h d r m world? The quark theory i s an i n e o m l e t e theory.
Ho d e f i n i t e prescrlptlon is
gXven as t o what t o do next t o correct i t , or even t o use i t c m p l e t e l y i n a c a r r e c t and c m a i s t e n t (with u n i t a r i t y , f o r e m p l e ) =-er. reaches a dead end,
As such rlt
It ahows t h a t c e r t a i n r e g u l a r i t i e s e x i s t mong the hadron
s t a t e s , but a preclse statement of what t h f s m a n s o r what t h l s r e a l l y b p l i e s one should include lin deaipining a more adeqwxe theory is till laekiag.
It
It? a
mst iapartlsatt problem i n the theory af the strong i a t e r -
act%ons ,
Tfila ""dead end" h aa) a r e s u l t of our lack of i m g i n a t l o n of how t o go f u r t h e r and b) face.
ix
problem t h a t every '"narrow resonance a p p r o x h t i o a ' % a s
to
Pseudosca ar Meson Photoproduction, High Energy
Me now cornider &at happctns a t hie,hex mergy
- i n partictalax from
S to 3.8 GeV (as f u l l data i n the t r a n s i t i o n ragion 2 t o 4 &V
the analysts d i r e c t l y by
slnas
is lacking),
Here
af resmanwa is hopeless as tao mny a r e involved.
A f u l l a~a;Zyaiaof a p l i t u d e e does not e x i s t , nraiaily cross eractiom and a few
t r y ntessuremnts with polarized photons, ox polarized t a r g e t s does e x l e t b u t oar t h e o r e t i c a l s k i l l a t analysing the araplltracte Ear each h e l f c i t y e t c . is
nat y e t goad,
m e r e f o r e t h i s wif3 be w r e of as eatpirical sumey painting out
problem, r a t h e r than a complete theoretical analysis undergtand t h i s regloa
- in s h o r t , we do
aot
.
b f e r e n cee Diebold '%g& Energy Photoproduction", H i & esnexu physfca conference, Boulder, Colorado 119691, Wiik ""Phstopxoduction of pseudoscalar ~llesonb~'"International s m p o s i m
on e l e c t r m and photon interactions a t hzlgh aenergiea, Cornell (2971). We s h a l l stutly i n t h i s parr; oen3.y B very a w l 1 f r a c t i o n of the toraf, photon
60
nucleon cross section a t high energy.
The c r o s s section f o r yp
n+n i s , f o r
+
e x a m l e , 0.6% of the t o t a l a t 4 GeV. Ttre t o t a l c r o s s section f o r -y an p shows bumps due t o the 1236, l560 and I t is most& f l a t above 3 GeV, i t f a l l s
l700 resonance@ a t low energies,
( t h i s is about 11220 of np cross sectton).
from 125 ub t o 113 ub, fro= 5 t o 15 &V
The reactions go increasingly i n t h e Eomard d i r e c t i o n s o t h a t i t is convenient t o p l o t them a s functions of t f o r given @ ( o rk , t h e photon The slope of the t dependence vartea r e l a t i v e l y slowly
nroraenturn i n the l a b , ) ,
with k, and c e r t a i n c h a r a c t e r i s t i e regions f o r t a r e noticed.
s peak i n t h e backward d i r e c t i o n , swll g iven
U,
There is a l s o
&ere i P is b e s t t o p l o t u f a r
S.
An earpirical r u l e , n o t precise, but very good f o r comparing d a t a a t various energies is t h a t a l l the cross s e c t i o n s vary nearly a s k-' direction, and a s km3 i n t h e backward d i r e c t i o n .
i n the f o w a r d
The reason f o r t h i s is n o t well
2
mderstood. %at is, k d a l d t is a nearly Eixetd functian of t , 2 1 (GeVI the curves f o r d i f f e r e n t reactions a r e each d i f f e r e n t , OS
a chart fram ~ i e b o l d h e e p o r r(reproduced here i n f i g . 12-11,
precise data, v a r i a t i o n s of f ( t ) with s a r e smothed over
B e l w t about They a r e given
(r"his is not
- t o get exact n d e r e
- but they a r e e x c e l l m t representations o f
sea d e t a i l e d experimental refxtrts things f o r a survey such a s t h i s , ) Above c
1 a l l reactions agree i n f a l l i n g v e v much l i k e e3'.
of t h i s rewlner w h o m ,
The cavse
I n cmpar&n,ntgt o hadron c a l l i s i o n s t h i s r u l e ls seen
t o be m8t accurBte f o r photon reactions but is seen a l s o i n m y s t r o n g i n t e r aetim cases, f o r e x m l e in f o w a r d (w-p-tng o r 4-
+
ward (n p+pn 1 (6, Fox),
f .R
++
p l c G 1 as well a s in back-
Z t m y be r e l a t e d t o =other
strong f n t e r a c t i m r u l e ;
t h a t i n high energy incluaivive reactions &fag a r e dfstribtsted i n t r m s v e r s e mamntm P
1
laeeons o r baryons these p a r t f c l e s 3 ~ 2 aa e '&La is a l s o t r u e of
.
photon induced inclusive r e a c t l o w . This f s only t r u e i n a rou* -2 2 ~ ~ 2 f o r small :p to e f o r l a r g e PI Z
:P$-
eanse, e
.
The theory of transverse m m n t m d i s t r i b u t i o n s a t high eaer&y and h&& t
is wide open,
Z t is a very good problera t o work on.
Very suprisingly backward photoproduction pc&@ a r e t h e only ones t h a t se&ngl;y
da not obey the r u l e ,
They a r e very f l a t
- f l a t t e r than anything e l s e ,
varying m about e off wtth
W
1.2
H (This i a not t r u e f o r y p b W- *ich
U,
i n the backward dLrection, =re
has, a rapid f a l l
l i k e e3U.)
The bczhaviour a t elaaller t t t e l ) can q u a l i t a t i v e l y be explained by the idea of the exchanges of Regge poles of the fallowing t r a j e c t o r i e s : n, and s t r m g e n e s s analogue K and nearly degenerate A2
p W
K* a d nearly degenerate K;** Ihe k -'
behaviour vauld not be eapected, f o r the variovs t r a j e c t o r i e s have
d i f f e r e n t i n t e r c e p t s and slopes. about amplitudes
- i t rnust
varying nearly t h a t way t o g e t i t out.
But the k-'
cannot be s true asymptotic r u l e
be a s o r t of accidental r e s u l t of several t e r m
- allthough quantitatively
i t La always a b i t of trouble
This can be seen beeawe i f the a p l i t u d e varied t m l g aa sd,
or r a t h e r , i n correct n o m l f z a t i o n , were constant, &e photon coupling v%& i s o s c a l a r and fsovector would d i f f e r i n phase by 90' and would not i n t e r f e r e ,
+
n e r e f o r e we would expect dcrldt ( y p n n) = do/& (yn-+n-p) and they c e r t a b l y a r e not e q w l .
0 ' The reason ieoscalar and isovector d i f f e r h phase by 9 any amplitude f (s) the a n t i p a r t i c l e amplitude i s f(ei"s)*. f o r a n t i p a r t i c l e 8 i t is B* edwaau.
is real,
For isovector coupling t h e m l i t u d e s a r e the s-
m t i p a r t i c l e hm opposite I-spin thus B s h m that
For
~s""
lhus i f f (8)
But f o r aa isoscalar coupling the amplitudes
f o r p a r t t c l e and g n t i p a r t i c l e a r e opposite, thfa requires Bs C
is t h i s .
m
e h v (-inalZ),
xc exp (-ira/Z), because the c' i e r e a l .
This
' 0 9 and By d i f f e r i n phase by .
In &egge theory the exchanp af a trajectory can be interpreted as a surn over t chmnel resonsnces,
In each case the palartzation of the exchanged
resmance i s w e d up i n getting a s bigb a power of e a s possible, by being In the direction of the two 10ngitudha1 m m n t a , where a vector p a r t i c l e is exchanged ( t fixed hi& B Pl
Pj,
5
B R ~there
P4) P1
Take, f o r e x q f e , the ease
is no spin f l i p at: e i t h e r vertex
63
Pseudoscalar Meson Photoprrrdtrction,High Energy The a ~ a p l i t u d egoes l i k e C (Pf e ) (Pi e ) Pf PZ 3 S. The spin is t h e r e f o r e P01 n o t a v a i l a b l e t o carry l o n g i t u d i n a l angular momntutn. If t h e r e is a k e l l c i t y f l i p bh a t m e of the v e r t i c e s , the s p i n of t h e exchange is again used up i n the term with t h e highest power of s; hence t h e r e is a f a c t o r qdh or both v e r t i c e s have a f l i p the amplitude goes a s l a t e r i s t r u e i f the b h a r e of opposite
silgn,
fi/'''l
' /"I'
G'"'. ideally.
If This
i t i s required by t h e o v e r a l l
Bowever 5f t h e A X a r e equal, say t o 1, we
conservation of angular Illomntm.
errpect t but t h i s is not required by angular monentm conservation. i n such cases t h e e f f e c t 1s l o s t by &soration.
Xn f a c t ,
Absorption carrectione for small
impact p a r m t e r s reduce t h e t t o i t s lowest physical p o s s i b i l i t y (in t h i s e x a q l e t o a c o n s t m t ) . Qnly fE the coupllstlgsrealcLy f a c t o r i z e raust it be
' ldh21
tldhll
a t h e r n i a e absorption can reduce t h e power.
Lecture 1 2 Pseudoacalar k s a n Photoproduction
- Higher
k e r g f e s (continued)
We a w discuss each case fn c l o s e r &tail (following G. Fox] yPn-dft
This case can be explained simply by n exchange,
At t h e photon t a n
v e r t e x we must have a f l i p of h e l i c f t y , a t t k e p& vertex none is necessary 2m (because of the p-A mass d i f f e r e n c e ) ; hence t h e amplitude i s E/(t)n shmfng
a d i p a t t = 0, a maximm a t t (@20-2
,a
0).
-q . 2
n exchange expects km2 c r o s s s e c t i o n s
Gauge fslvarlant one p i m elrcttarrge with absorption corrections
works f i n e i n thks case,
We have a h e l i e i t y f l i p a t the yn vertax aad one (from parity) a t the nucleon vertex, at t
Hence i d e a l l y we a x p c t tl (r-% 2 ) , thcre should be a drop
O but i f we look a t the data i n ffigure 12-1 we see there i e a spike i n
the forward direction.
The answer t o t h i s is:
""became of absbsorptfon"",
To uorderstand how absorption a f f e c t s the ~ l l t u d e , p e r f a ma Fourier t r a n s f o m
t o the. i ~ a c pt a r m e t e r representation. p i a , now l o o k izke
V
The a m l i t u d e t o find a
which i s an odd function of b.
t o r h i s pion with amplitude t h a t goes XiLe VP (eqb)
, the
m e photon couples
f i r s t gradient is
because the pion 1s i n a P wave with respect t o the nucleon, the second grad5eat 1. because the photon couples t o the pion i o a P wave.
VD (emYb) is a funetion
t h a t looks l i k e
The f a w a r d m l i t u d e is proportional t o the i n t e g r a l of t h i s function which
is 2era s o we s t i l l hwe& explain& the obscmed peak..
&sorption i e here
introduwd, pions which a r e gscattered by photons wlLtb sasal2 impact p a r m t e r do not always get out becawe there f s a good chance f o r them t o i n t e r a c t strongly with the nucleon.
) be m u l t i p l e d The f v n c t i m V'J ( e - ~ ~must
a
function a(b) like:
The i n t e g r a l of the pmduct a(b) W (@-lrb) gives the f o n a r d amplitude whieh i s n w non zero.
The r e s u l t is t h a t the m p l i t u d e is
G, Fox has noticed t h e enrpirical r u l e t h a t s e t t i n g C
2
2 The m p l i t u d e becorns m% / (r+n )
rnaay cases. a3 trong
.
-
X works very w e l l i n
(Such peaks a r e co-n
in
i n t e r a c t ions, e ,g., p n change. exchange pn-g) 4"
%e d i f f e r e a c e b e t m e n da/dt(yp+n a) cmd d ~ / d t ( ~ n w - shows ~) t h e presence The amp1itudes i n the two cages go a s
of p-like exchange, .E.
yp-*nn=n+p+A2 yn
+
-
n p
n
-
p
+ A2
The n and p i n t e r f e r e caherently because the p coupling Is m h l y due t o s p i n f l i p (see below),
Tfie s i g n of couplSng agrees a l s o wlth what i s expected by (Xt a l s o agrees with t h e s i g n i n a s i m i l a r s t r o n g i n t e r a c t i a n
naive quark =del. case n p w = 71% and
= W-p .) The expected energy dependenw f o r various
t f o r the p i s not c l a a r l y seen,
Perhapa f o r smll t pions d m i n a t e .
For
t near -4.5 a dig is expected i n yp+nop by the f a c t t h a t o(p) = O there (roughly
a(p) = 0 -5-t.t).
I n Regge theorp the m l i t u d e f o r a p t r a j e c t o r y exchange is
proportional t o
me pole i n (sinno)-' and by ( r ( a ) ) - l ,
a t a-O i s " k i l l e d twice" by the phase i n the numarator
so the contribution of t h e p t r a j e c t o r y vaoiehes af t
The d%p is seen more c l e a r l y i n r'p-mOo; f l i p -1itud.e
m
-0.5.
i n Tprnop the zero being i n a double
m y be obscured by absorption,
In s e l n g l e f l i p q l f t u d e i t
shauld show up.
%
a d a, a r e t h e cross s e c t i o n f o r photo=
polarized perpendicular and
p a r a l l e l t o t h e p l a e of s c a t t e r b g respectively.
Errpedmntally A looks lib
66
Photon-HadronInteractions
f o r small t o,
5,
for
G
.2
7
01 is
sidering the exchanges hi&contribute t o by n a t u r a l p a r i t y exchange (f unnatural p a r i t y exchange
p.
(-1)
J
mis
smll.
e.g.
G&
and
p,& )
G,,.
can be explained by con-
c1 f s contributed only
a*, is contributed only be
(F = -(-l)J e.g. R )
To see t h i s consider the followfng picture:
%e photon corns f n with polarizatfon
;in plena of skeet, i f t h i s is
reflected i n a d r r o r i n the plane a f s c a t t e r t n g everything l a o b the
8-
except t h a t since there is a pseudacscalar p a r t i c l e the mp/irude changes sign, i t is therefore zero,
Consider sow a photon coming ia with perpeadicultitr polarization:
scalar
Again r e f l e c t i n a neirror i n the plane af scattering,
changes sign, but
there is another change i n sign because of the pseudoscalar p a r t i c l e s o a natural p a r i t y exchmge can cantribute t o ak.
S i d l a r argwents can be used
In the case of pian exchange, generalization t o t r a j e c t o r i e s of higher angular mraentuar. gives our rule. 331e reason f o r the as G,~
t r y cuwe c m nar~be seen as follaws.
by geomtry, as there i s no spaz;cial rutis.
have the &*Xi
tudw
At t = O
For i d e a l n exchange we
67
Pxerrdosrralsrr Meson Photaproductia~,High Energy
AA
for Ail
;A
p we
-1/2
lie
have AB
0
-
O
% = -U2 t o
$ 0.
Prom abaarptkan (t.0
correction) u e must have
g e t zero croaa s e c t i o n using 6. Fox's r u l e f o r s i n e .
should go t o zero a t small t.
t o s t a r t a t zero a t t
Neglecting i t we expect t h e a s
0 , r i s e rapidly t o 1 a t t = -aa2 (which i t daes
e x p c r i m n t a l l y ) and t a f a l l o f f t o ~ a r dzero f o r higher t.
L t does f a l l o f f
s l i g h t l y , t o perhaps 0.8, but n a t eus much a s expected; presumably o t h e r t e m l%ke ALP a r e beginning t o contribute strongly. ~0""""~'~s da/dt f o r t h i s reaetion shows a very sharp forward peak, i t 1s due t o photm exchange ( c a l l e d PrimAaff e f f e c t ) , t h e diagram is
we icaar chat
a'
couples t o two photons f r o m its d r c q .
p r a d d e s t h e mst accurate way t o m a s u r e
I n fact, t h i s effect
t h e l l i f a t i m f o r no+yy; the exchmged
photon in the Primkoff effect: i e a l w e e m it@mass s h e l l . For l: outside the f o m a r d p@&, the reaetion can come from saae exehange
-
we expect the w t o p r e d m i n a t e (see b e l w ) asd t o have a s t r o n g s i n g l e f l i p
( f l &p a t ya vertex, non-f l l p at nucleon vertex) does show the d i p when a ( t )
O a t t = 0.5.
.
Thus St vanishes a t t = 0, and
%a energy dependence i s e n t i r e l y
wrong f o r slnalf t ,
sZa(t)-2e1
A p l o t of e x p e r i a e n t a l a ( t ) (from d a l d t
near O f. ,2 f o r a l l t out t o -1.2
a
where i t m y be -l, Xf u we expect yn+nOn t o
0
be equal,
The r a t i o
i s I f o r small t , f a l l s t o 0.6 near t
0.5 and
VP~@P r i s e s again t o 1 a t l a r g e t , t r y f o r polarized photon p a r a l l e l clt and perpendicular a_C t o the production plane has a l s o been measured,
A
(5- / (5+a,, 1.
The c r o s s
s e c t i o n is p r e d w n a n t l y q except: near t h e d i p when a,, m y be a s much a s 202, YP K + X
YP X + h
These r e a c t i o n s a r e due t o K* and K** exchange.
A b i t of K exchange a t
lower t m k e s A g r e a t e r than the C because the coupling KE"A i a bigger than UC (see below). YVOP This is dominated by p exchange l n s t e a d of u exchange, s o no d i p is seen a t -0.5
becaukle of t h e dollble f l i p .
Q u a n t i t a t i v e f i t s have been a t t m p r e d along these l i n e s , but each need,@ s e v e r a l complicating f e a t u r e s l i k e absorption, b g g e c u t s e t c .
I t is n o t worth
our while t o follow any of them i n s p e c i f i ~ d e t a i l f o r na one nodal autontatically e a s i l y gives d e t a i l e d f i t s t o a l l the r e a c t i o n s , Wkat we can say however, is t h a t i n t h i s Large a region ( a t Leaet f o r small t ) the concept of t channel e x h a n g e s seems to be a guiding p r i n c i p l e t h a t i s f a i r l y successful, even =re
This same e f f e c t i s seen i n hadron c o l l i s i o n s i n
d e t a i l ; i t is not a p a r t i c u l a r aspect of photon c o l l i s i o n s .
There-
f o r e the discussion of t h e next l e c t u r e w i l l be =ore general. kfr? derive now the r e l a t i v e s t r e n g t h o f various couplings from t h e quark
model,
The a r g a n t s abave use these r e s u l t s ,
To get these r e l a t i v e s t r e n g t h s we a s s m e mesons couple through currents. 'Ithe c u r r e n t s a r e obtained by taking t h e meson quark wavefunctions and i n t e r p r e t i n g t h e quark s t a t e s a s c r e a t i m and a n n i h i l a t i o n operators. We have p
U ;
-dz, w
U;
+ &X;hence
p couples t o a nucleon l i k e a
c u r r e n t with u charge + l , d charge -l, o cauples l i k e u charge +f, d charge + l , A photon couples l i k e
U
1
charge 2 / 3 , d charge -l/3 o r lilce ?; w t
I
p.
a neutron t h e coupling of t h e p is reversed i n s i g n , t h e w is not. yp =
1
p .t
1
go
yn =
l
Tp +
I ij; w which gives a
yp-p, w
a
3(yn+p).
To Therefore
The couplings go
like
t o ctrrtrge
t o magnetic momnt
Therefore p couples roaialy t o spin, t h e flip m p l i t u d e predarninates but f o r the
UJ
no such predominance occurs,
F r m no = u z no and
(which have the saHle
photon t o d d
-f
- d z we g e t t h e couplings of 4
-(-
$4
For t h e rt
2
3+
(-
1
1
$?= y,
U;
I)
t a y and r'.
Rence betcwctea
ancl d z signa) c o w l i n g t h e photon t o u plus
t o w S t Is c ~ u g f i n gt o
U
minus coupling t o
l, therefore
L
(2 s s -
U;
- dzl
the r a t i o Is reversed
Jii;
Pseudasealar *sons
couple to nucleon o c t e t via SU3 with P
2, D
lcJ
3, thua
Exchange Phenomena
There have been a nu&er of theoretical views a s t o how t o mderstarxd these t channel exchmge e f f e c t s and X w i l l d k ~ c u s sa n ~ e ofr then,
They
a r e closely Laterrelated and a r e undoubtedly t o a Large extent, d i f f e r e n t ways of describing the @am@thing,
f w i l l give a very brief: diiscusetlcn of each,
indicating t h e f r relatlcmsh2p63i t o each olrher and t h e i r v a r i o w degrees of incomplete~ess. 50m of the ways of underatandlng t exehangea a t large a are: a)
Tha g e o m t r i c a l o r impact p a r m t e r viwpoinl:
b)
The Regge pole fonnuls
c)
t -channel resonances
d)
@-channel resonanees , The f i r s t v%ew fhalj been cfiiscuesed m a t c a p l e t s l y bp Warari) notea thst
as s*,
the angular momata can get very high s o t h a t i f the Rth o r b i t a l
mmnrumi 18 selected *ere ever reore accurateJly.
R=kb is kept f&xed a s a increases we cani deflne b
This b ultimte3iy beernes the 2 4 i m n s i o n a l space vector
perpeadicular t o the plane a f coLliclion and is the Fourcter t r a n s f o m variable correeponding t o CA l the transverse rrtomatuka trransfax vector.
71
s ) can t h e r e f o r e be w r i t t e n m
h p l i t u d e s A(&,
iip S
A(qLt
a(i;,
81
d2g
and t h e behaviour of A is studied by describing a(K# B) using geometrical i n t u i t i o n t o a s s i s t i n understandhg a(Ks s) r a t h e r than trying t o gather i n t u i t i o n of A(Q1,
S)
directly.
B-iffraction is r e a d i l y understood by supposing t h e r e is an ~ l i t u d feo r a p a r t i c l e t o pase through a t a r g e t without i n t e r a c t i n g h l c h is very small f o r saall b, but r i s e s t o one o u t s i d e t h e t a r g e t . A(&
S) would look lLke
The energy dependence of t h i s m p l i t u d e (nearly independent of enrrrgy) is taken from experiment, (Zt is vaguely understood a s a s t r o n g i a t a r a c t i o n a f an object of flxed s i z e , ) A r e a c t i o n 1Ske charge enchmge, say n-prron
a t f i m d b that tbe
X-
is described by supposirtg, (The
gofng through has aorne amputude t o change t o a a'.
energy dependence of t h i s a a p l i t u d e m y again be guessed Erora e x p e r i m n t , a r frm m o t h e r t h e o q l i k e Regge pole theory,)
This m p l i t a d e is Largest i n a
ring
because f o r Large b s o i n t e r a c t i o n occurs while f o r small b t h e r e i e l l t t f e chance of g e t t i n g through,
In crudest approximtion we c m say a l l corns Eron,
a r i n g a t r a d i u s R, leading i n Fourzer transform t o an emplitude l i k e ~ f o r no h e l i c i t y fZip,
mis
~ R).
expects a d i p a t t = &,f5 wltich is somtkmes found.
(
6
t -ChannelExchange Phenomena Par a s i n g l e h e l i e i t y f l i p where the m p l i t u d e mwt vary acfocsgi the lapact parameter plane as ei', zero a t t
the r e s u l t i a
J~(GE). Bor R
I fe-
t h i s has a
-0.5 and is, i n t h i s m d e l the or&&%of the dip a t t h i s t i n
pion exchaage s c a t t e r i n g , photm productioo o f no e t c . t;heary we sdllsociated wf t h the zero of a l t ) )
(The dip t h a t in Regge
.
This sodel does give, with some exceptions, a rough description of the general behrwiour, but i t is not a eaaplcrta theor~rbemuse the energy dependence of m p l i t u d e s is not understood, nor a r c the coupltng strengths. The view t h a t a p a r t l c l e is a point travellrrg a t a fixed l w a c t p a r m e t e r d i m n s f m i n tka transverse plane
rather than a structuze wlth f h t t e
(i.e. ttto pie p l a t e s colfidlag) is an oversimplificatione Atteapte t o deal wlch t h i s have s o Ear, lead t o c m p l i e a t t o n s and & t g u i t i e s
and ao c l e a r
d - p f g ~ t ep i c t o r e hlrlg emerged, bl
The h g g e pole fsmuLaa. r e s u f t from a susgestion ( m t i v a t e d by an analysis
of non-relatlvietic cpcattarlng by Wn;?gge) that the q l h t u d e Euncticra f o r two body reaction A(&,t) be studted
an ~ ~ l g u l=mat= ~lr
adjt
aa m a l y t i e Zmct i m o f the energy
v a r i d l e Sn the t & m e & , a,
a d
Q:
For large s the auralytic
Eamala was suggested ai(t) A(s,t) = ( 2 + /) B$(t) e i 1 where a sm over s p e c i a l values of i (called polea) and a ccratinum of ivaloes (ca&led cuts) i a
;ta
general eqrzcted,
Mearly any fuaction can be s a expaded
but the usefulness of tbe idea dependri, oa sing f u r t h e r aasuaptfans,
as
8-
the h r g e a t or% would detrsrrnlne A, iuld i t was hoped t h a t the poles would
have theae, definLnitely above the a va2uea Where the cues s t a r t , behaw a s @(C)
w&d
Evidently
be f a c t o r i d l e
a a m of a wry few t e r n s of t h i s form. @&C)
Bm(t) In a r e a e t i m A
extended to poaftlve t would be
rta
i- B -c
80
A wuld
I f so. B{t)
C t D, and a ( t ) i f
integer f o r those C equal t o the mss of a tm, I t f s only a t such a t t h a t A
r a a l p a r t i c l e of: amropriarte angular could heve a pole l f k e s i n g u l a r i t y In t, Far c e r t a i n rcacthons (e.g. n p*
On) t h a e expectations hawe been
b r i l l i a n t l y c o a f i m d , but paera1l.y cmpl$caCioas s e t i n ,
For e
p b n e x e b g e we saw how a b a a q t l a n , a concept from v i e v o t n t (a) often raadgfie$ the s m 3 e pole picture.
Xn the ""pre'' b ~ e vvieM g any ao&fhcation
of t h e s i w l e pole formula f o r A(s,t) can be described, of course, by adding
- but what
cuts
e u t s t o add, and how s t r o n g l y r e q u i r e s outside i d e a s , l i k e
borrowings from the absorption raodel.
The e u t s s t a r t , f o r l a r g e s, r i g h t a t t h e
p o s i t i o n of the pales and cannot be e a a i l y separated from them. It i s fownd e w i r i c a l l y t h a t a c t ) is n e a r l y a ~ t r a l e ; h t 1Zne.
The reason
f o r t h i s is m k a o m . Also t o d e s c r i b e the nearly eonstaat t o t a l c r o s s s e c t i o n s a speciaf. t r a j e c t o r y was invented, t h e pomeron, vfth a s p e c i a l value one f o r a a t t = Q , without any dynamic explanatictn of t h i s p a r t , This theory 5 s a g a b incampfete as no 5 n f o m t i o n is supplied f o r g e t t i n g B(t)
, and,
euts.
i n p r a c t i c e ntare iraportant , f o r d e t e r d n i n g the r i s e and behavior of
Atte~aptst o avoid using t h e absorption =del
("conspiracies ," e t c . ) have
failed , 0bv;Cously s o w kind of f a t e g r a t i a n of the ideas of a, b w i l l be t h e moat profitable, c)
The r e l a t i o n of t h e Regge ffom t o t h e p a r t i c l e s on t h e t r a j e c t o r y t a n be
looked a t another way (van Nave).
Suppose we have a theory which would give a Then t h e Born t e r m
sequence of p a r t i c l e s of e v e r increasing angular mmentm. representing f i r s t order exchange of a l l these a Regge-like sum. : m
is t h e mass
2
I give an example.
of a S c a l a r :, m
4-
Qi
t-
channel p a r t i c l e s w i l l give
Let t h e mass2 go as of a vector,: m
+ 2ll
p a r t i e l e , e t c . The exchange of these f o r a r e a c t i o n A + B
S
mo2
4-
nn, where
of a tensor (spin 2)
+ G
+D
where f o r
s i ~ l r p l f c i t yA, B, 6, D a r e s c a l a r , goes a s
The s f o r v e e t o r comes from (PA + PC) d over
c,
e a t t h e upper coupling and (Pg
4-
P$
*
Likewise s Z f o r t h e tensor e m s if .rje w e t h e f u l l
e at
75
t -ChannelExchange Phenomena two tensor indices t o carry Fnfarnration about PB + PD Erm vertex t o couple t o 2 2 P + P t o make ((PA + PC).(PB + PD)) or s i n the l m i t . Cn a r e squares of A e l e t mn
coupling constants.
A m
setting u
For large
C
8
1 "1
m
0
'+
and (t-mo
2
)In =
say, our sum is
nn, and l e t Cn equal l / n
- nzo
(C..=
.eman
m
I:
9
exp (t-mo2-n~)x dx
&(t) the i n t e g r a l can be transformed t o
the upper linnlc on the i n t e g r a l c m tie put
t o get the a s p p t o t i c
m,
fo m "m
r(-a
l St
(t))
(13,lr)
resldvea of t h i s fuoetion('l
The pales and the o r i g i n a l s e r i e s .
- (iir
reproduce
I n general m y RfIgge term can be expadad By its pokes
4-n t (co&ng from B f t ) and the
p a r t i c l e s and ceupliags. a Regge term derived,
-*E)
seriw i $ then s van Bove a e r i e s d e t e w a b g
Or laom guess cafl be mde o f s t a t e s and resfdues
Thelac two fa-
a r e m t h e m t i c a l expressions af the s a m
theory, and perrnlt d i f f e r e n t pofats of v i m of the as= a e t i m s another 1s =re
snd
thing; sometims an&,
auggestlve of a n w Idea,
C o m nt s For negatgve s the s e r i e s (13.3) gives aa a w l i t * suggested t h a t the c o e f f i c i e n t s cannot f a l l
r i s i n g as e8,
quiicly W lJn!
L t is
&tersatfvely
one, e a t say t h a t the values f o r negat%ve S a r e taken from the a s m t o t i c f o m f o r positive s by a n a l y t i c contlnuatlon, Clearly i n chia sunt, f o r negative t, we a r e Ear may from the true reeonsnces and are again i n the poaitfon of not knovgng whet the r e a l
SUE
should be unless
we have a caaplete theory, Such a n a l y t i c axtenelon formXaa a r e hard t o we practical;ly
- f o r e x w l e h a t does o b s e m s d o n of: the f i r s t
the s e r l a l t e l l
about the a s p p r o t i c farrxll
~ b )
tm reaonaaices of
I f t h e r e were no o t h e r terms the a s p p t o t i c s behavior would go a s
from m.
2
,
we can g e t a l i t t l e information on the behavior of o ( t ) . I don't tmw
i t work?
- t h e a n a l y t i c extension
S.
Yet
hm
does
of approximate flanctions, o r
earpiricalfy p a r t i a l l y deterntjlned f m c t i o n s i s a aathematical problem I do not understmd nor t r u s t , nor can 5 guess e r r o r s . suppose a sm of t channel resonances gives of t h e L
-
l term by &C.
To show t h e type of d i f f i c u l t y ,
BS"~';
n m change t h e c o e f f i c i e n t
Surely t h e sum i s now BS"")
+
9
which f o r
t -ml,
l a r g e s goes a s s .
The point i s a m d i f i c a t i o n of t h e second t e r n only is not
"natural" oor "sraooth" and changes the? r e s u l t d r a s t i c a l l y .
%atever physically
causes t h e change i n t h e f i r s t : t e r n chmges a l l the cKTner t e r n a b i t i n such a way t h a t t h e a s p p t o t i c f o m
only IILildly a l t e r e d .
To s u m r i z e the van Nave sm is not r e a l l y useful except t h e o r e t i c a l l y , X f you have same theory of a l l the t-channel resonances and t h e i r c o u p l b g s then
you can be assured t h e theory w i l l lead t o Regge a s w p t o t i c behaviour
- or i f
you have s o w theory leading t o k g g e a s m p t o t i c behaviour you a n , by laoktng a t t h e poles (in tf)f n i t s expression deduce *ere implied ( a ( t )
C-channel r e s o n a c e s a r e
i n t e g e r ) and something &out: t h e i r couplings,
S m i n g t h e t-ehmnel resonances suggested by the ttamonic o s c i l l a t o r
quark rnodcll f o r =son t h i s amzmner,
resonances
(@l
does give an expected Regge behaviour in
Detailed nusnerical comparisons have not y e t been nrade,
Lecture l 4 dl
S-(=haanel Resonances b o t h e r t h e o r e t i c a l idea is t h a t a31 of the behaviour a t high energy a l s o
can be understood by j u s t continuing our s c h m n e l resanmce a n a l y s i s (e.g. Walker) t o higher energy.
by
A behaviour l i k e a dfp fixed i n t , a s s increases msms
a f e a t u r e t h a t appears at: gradually decreashe; angles E!
and sharper angular d i s t r i b u t i o n r e s u l t s ,
tls s o t h a t a s h a v e r
This m a n e t h a t hipJler and higher
angular mwnturn s-chanael resonances atuat be contributing a s s i n c r e a s e s , t h i s is, of course, a l l r i g h t f a r avail&lle a t higher
S.
rje
b o w higher a n g d a r mantent-
But
reaooances a r e
The approximate s t a b i l i t y of E(t) curves a s
S
vartes
does imply a g r e a t d e a l about how t h e resonances and t h e i r couplings mwt behave a t l a r g e s,
That the e n t i r e curve c o w s fro% s m i n g
S
channel (and, some would say,
u chaanel) resonances only i s a tremendous r e s t r i c t i o n which, i f t r u e , might n id only exact expression t h a t can be s o s t r o n g a s t o guide cbeary t o t h e one m
do t h i s
-
thus, much a t t e n t i o n has been paid t o t h i s rdea.
Most s t a t e m a t s
a r e , a t first., not t h a t aoabitious, because comparison t o experiaent again is aeaning2ess i f we have t o decide an t h e hypothetical value o f a resonances f a r from t h e i r resonant energies, 2
2
SW
of
Instead i t i s noted t h a t the -1
iraaginary p a r t a f a resonance DgE-E ) at. 'l 14) i s only l a r g e near the resonance s o t h e p r i n c i p l e Is studied Ln t h e f o r a I s A(a,t) = C R IL (S-charnel resonances)
(14.1)
except; perhaps f o r t h e paneron. Such questions as the c m t r i b u t i a n of u channel resonances (which a r e always o f f resonance s o t h e i m g i n a r y p a r t Is very sraall, zero f o r i n f i n i t e l y narrow resonaacesl and whether the pion exchange t e r n (which is r e a l ) should be included a r e sidestepped I n t h i s way. It
tpuat
be emphasized t h a t ss-cfianael poles are e x p l i c i t l y
For i f
an i n t e g r a l over a continurn is a l s o fncluded nearly a l l f u n c t f o m b l s , t ) can be
so represented. If we add t h e p r f n c i p l e ( d u a l i t y ) t h a t the t - c h e n e l behavl-or ( r e s u l t i n g
Erm t h e @-channel poles) must i f a n a l y t i c a l l y extended, have poJes a t t h e same massZ f o r t h e same quantum numbers a s t h e s-channel resonances we have such a severe r e s t r i c t i o n t h a t perhaps only a nearly m i q u e s o l u t i o n e x i s t s , and hence a s o l u t i o n of t h e s t r o n g interactPon physics could r e s u l t , done i n t h i s d i r e c t i o n nnfght be wrong added
- success
hakl n o t be=
-- perhaps S - c h m e l
attained,
and c-&annel
Huch @ark has been
Naturally t h e p r h c i p l e
r e s o n a c e s ntust be s e p a r a t e l y
- o r what a m m f s t o t h e s a m thing s charnel c u t s a r e necessary i f t h e
awliturXe is t o c o r r e c t l y represent t h e hagh energy behavior i n a a d t. is no physical p d a c i p l e underlying t h e d u a l i t y hypatheses
gmsrs a t a possfble ntcrthematl-cal property of an m l f i t u d e ,
There
- i t is #imply a It f s an observation
a t low energy t h a t mplFtudes a r e d o d w t e d by r m o m c e s , so t h a t s m s o r t of i n f t n i t e l y narrow resonance a p p r o x h a t f a a m y be a good s t a r t i n g point.
But
is t h i s a l s o v a l i d a t high ener&y &ere i n mar, colfilsiona many p a r t i c l e s a r e produced?
Can they be wnderstoad a s the products of cascade d i s h t e g r a t i o n of
resonances o r Is t h e r e an important c o n t r i b u t i o n of d l r e c t coupling t o t h e continuum?
We remexnber t h a t a t high s the two body final. s t a t e we have s t u d i e d s e e m t o be only a very small p a r t of t h e cross s e c t i o n ,
The multibody s t a t e s trhlch
c o n s t i t u t e t h e major p a r t of t h e c o l l i s i o n c r o s s s e c t i o n w i l l be discussed l a t e r . Veneziano f o m u l a Such ideas a r e encouraged by the e x i s t e n c e of a E ~ c t i o n(Veneziano) which can be expanded e n t i r e l y i n t e r n of @-channel poles
- or
t-channel poles, and
which has Regge behavior a t high energies.
where a ( s ) f s a s t r a i g h t l i n e i n S , The residue6 a t the poles i n s o m g e n e r a l i z a t i o n s a r e not n e c e s s a r i l y always p o s i t i v e i n cases &ere they should be, This is only a p o s s i b l e f o r a f o r A(a , t ) i f t h e s c a t t e r i n g p a r t i c l e s a r e spinless
- much work without
generalize t h i s ,
c l e a r conclwfon has been done i n t r y i n g t o
Also t o generalize f r m 4-point t o n-point
B fundmental problm is this: Now p r e c i s e l y a r e we t o c o r r e c t I t ? qlrark model.)
fmctions,
This is a narrow resonance a p p r o x i w t i o n , (The s a m questfon we discwered f o r t h e
Again pertzaps t h e s a m question i n anather language
- this
is
presumably n o t d i r e c t l y t h e fornufa f o r A(s,t) but f o r a deeper m p l i t u d e t h a t mst s t i l l be, a s
tire
nright say, ""corrected f o r ab-beorptlon,"
no
we have
the Born term of s a m expansion? A t t a p e s t o extend d u a l i t y o r Veneziano Fdaas t o p h o t o e l e e t r l c couplings have been s i n g u l a r l y unsuccessful.
However, t h e problem of t h e m a r h e m t i c e l
behavior of photon couplings should not be disregarded.
They a r e e s p e c i a l l y
important because they c o n t a h beside a , t a new varkable qZ t h e mass
2
t h e photon (which may f o r e x a q l e be v f r t u a l via e l e c t r o n s c a t t e r i n g ) .
of The
amplitude A(@,t,qZ) has a n a l y t i c p r o p e r t i e s i n a l l 3 v a r i a b l e s s, t and a l s o q
2
(we s h a l l study them l a t e r ) and t h i s increase i n r e s t r i c t i o n s m y be very
h e l p f u l i n sugges r i n g f o r m o r t h e o r i e s . F i n a l l y we can ask whether a d y n a i c a l mdef. (suck a s t h e 3 quark =del) of hadrons couLd be expected t o lead t o gust t h e sum of resonance@ and couplings needed t o generate mgtinly forward s c a t t e r i n g ,
I think i t i s very l i k e l y t o have
r -Channel Exchange Phenomena no d i f f i c u l t y ,
We may draw the following diagram;
XE we suppose the photon and pion each couple t o one quark
- but each t o a
d i f f e r e n t one'then quarks a and b have l a r g e momnta m13 the m p l i t u d e t h a t t h e f i n a l configuration a , b, c i s h a a s i d e proton s t a t e , where they p r e a m b l y have snzall r e l a t i v e momntum is very swJ1.
Thus a t h i @ energy t h e mst
important case i s t h a t a s i n g l e quark a receives t h e photon and e d t s t h e pion:
Ttre n e t m w n t w E g e t s is only t h e mmnturn t r a n s f e r k-q anand t h e m p l i mdr? a b e i s a s i w l e proton is l a r g e f f
, and
only ff , t h i s t r m f e r Is smll,
Therefore t h e pion goes f o m a r d i n a way characterized by a function of t b e mmentm transfer, A t any r a t e a dynamical theory of s c h m e l . resonances alone might n o t
f i n d i t too d i f f i c u l t t o o b t a i n apparent, t-channel exehange e f f e c t s .
I n a nu&er of cases we e s t i m t e d s i z e s of couplfng e x m p l e , we s a i d pexchange was =l-nfiy
constants,
f l i p from a nucleon,
For
Such thing8 come
from theory outalde t h e lispact p a r m t e r , o r Rtlgge theory whi& l e f t such constants u n d e t e d n e d .
They could c a m front o t h e r e w e r i m e a t s (e.g.
f l i p is
l a r g e c m be got from a nucleon s c a t t e r h g ) but nevertheless t h e o r i e s a r e a v a i l a b l e f o r & a t t o expect,
mwt: be knom
- and
We used m i n l y $U3, but even h e r e FID r a t i o s
these a r e given w e l l by SU6, or h a t I have c a l l e d a
quark model e s t i m t e . The ""quark model" used here i s rreal3;y not the s m e a s t h e h a m o a i c quark
=del used f o r the
S
resonances applied t o t resonmces.
We a r e not dealing
with t resonmces b u t r a t h e r with t t r a j @ c t o r i e s , The q u m t i t a t i v e theory of t r a j e c t o r i e s to be expected fro= any ( i n p a r t i c u l a r from the harmonic) quark m d e l has n o t been worked o u t . t o count
- t o m&@
Rather we a r e uslng t h e "*ark
model" j u s t
up SUg a d PID r u l e s ,
Even then we gmplicitfy supposed eomth%n~ngt h a t m y people have w e d (but t o our bowledge has only l a s t week been e q l i c i t l y fornurated by Kislinger)
.
We assumd t h e p (or u) tra$eet;or)t wae coupled %n t h e earn proportion
as currents a r e coupled (of t h e appraprLate qumtunr n&ers w u a l l y corns i n two s t e p s .
(l)
t h e vector =sons
I
l, 0).
This fdea
on t h e i r m s a s h e l l couple
l i k e c u r r e n t s and (2) t h e pewr+ t r a j e c t o r i e s couple l i k e the p,w,4
zzrrsons do,
Stated =re precisely consider t h e m p l i t u d e s f a r t h e Lollowfnq d i a g r m .
The r a t i o o f these a ~ l p l i t u d e sis clljl& p qumturn n u d e r s ,
I c ~ f j l C *em > 4 is t h e current with
Me have assused t h e a p l i t u d e s have n o t been corrected far
absorption. b o t h e r E a m d a t i o n of t h i s "quark comting'"am
is t o draw d i a g r a m %or
t. exchmges bemeea hadrons 1&e
i ~ l y i n gt h a t batyons a r e QQQ and =sons
are
i n t e r a c t i a n c m be l a r g e l y mderstaod aa a
i n the ursual, way but t h a t t h e o f tern each repreaeating t h e
s c a t t e r i n g of one quark i n one hedron with one i n another. (Lipkin). It l s c l e a r t h a t our i n t e r p r e t a t i o n s of higher eaergy s c a t t e r h g codinem
t -ChannelExchange Phenomena s e v e r a l ideas,
%at i s evidently lacklng today i a so=
bines these n i c e l y together.
o v e r a l l d e w t h a t com-
I n t h e past tao much a t t e n t i o n has been paid to
forcing the amplitude i n t o one m l d o r anorher rather: thaa combining the? =re well e s t a b l i s h e d and c e n t r a l ideas o f each o f the= into aom synthesis.
Vector Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothesis
Before we discuss production of vector rnesons by photons we f f r s t diseuaa the e i w l e r problem of photon-vector =am
couplhlng,
In a c o l l d i n g beam experiment we can measure eC+einterpreted of course as a v i r t u a l photon o f posgrtve q2
.r
-
hadrons.
(2E,)
2
This is
and gives
us a dirace maeure of
f o r pos&tgve q
2
. This ~ t a t r i xe l e m n t is ilodaated by three reaonaaees a t
2 ajuf table valuea o f q cooxe~pondiagt o the p ,w, Qi n e u t r a l =sons jufi t
l i k e the photon, For example t f the hadrons is a p a i r of X ' s , K%.-
vely
of spin l-,
snvlll
background
the erose seerion f s
2
) end then rises way above @ The a beautiful Breit-Mimer curve of d d t h 4.7 ,7 @V,
unless q2 ts close t o (1020) I;n
2
(ie m
+
interpretation, of course, is t h a t we have gone &rough a rrtsonsnce, the Q, via
Vector Mesons and Yeetor M w n Dominance Hypothesis a dgagram l i k e
To analyze t h i s ve have two amplitudes, one purely hsdronic
U
. ;
P e
U
where e
U
< $ ~ J ~ / oa > t the mass
U The second factor
the photon polarization,
3.8
P
e
a@
and
~ t a ybe
2
of the
written
y ~ ~ d x l ~ a c ivector on af the vector p a r t i c l e .
2.3
(There i s no generally accapted emvention f o r haw t o w r i t e One way is t o write m
F@. 2 m /Zy @
Q,
so y+ is
l
2/g
0
4
-
F+ f o r what we have c a l l e d F+, others w r i t e
gm, but s t i l l others use the same l e t t e r y
Q
f o r another
way of expressing the coupling.) The exper2meaterer avoid a l l t h e ambiguity by noting t h a t the d i a g r m a b w h p f i e s rhat a f r e e
e e . C
(p
=son would have a c e r t a i n r a t a t a disintegrate i n t o
n e y give t h i s r a t a ( h i e h c w s =re d i r e c t l y frora experimnt m p a y ) efe-
+$'l
=
1.36 t .I x 10~'GeY
e i t h e r d i r e c t l y or as a braurching r a t i o , c m e c t i o n (for any vector meoa V of ( a =1!137)
as
For the
P+ = ,080 (GeV)2 o r @:/4
(.
A s b p l e calculation shows the
neglecting electron
-8
n
-
-8)
13.3.
One can look i n t h i s energy region f o r other products (such a s 3n, or rtoy) and find the resonance again
- thus detenngning the hadronie m p l i t a d e s f a r
Q33n o r @noy, w u a l l y given in the fom of branchinp r a t i o s , Tn t h e case the f i n a l e t a t e i s 3n there i s mother reamance a t 782 &V, the
IJ
mson
- it is studied i n tha same way,
AgaZn studygng 2n fknlnaf s t a t e s a l a r g e resonance near 765 of width aromd
125 &V,
This l a r g e width a&ee con@%derable& L p i t y
(i.a aaawptione of how
2
I' v a r i e s with q ) i n d e t e m i n i n g t h e constants, -a
and width,
t r i c , sharper on t h e hlgh errer@ sfde.
A
Further t h e
smll shoulder is
- t h i s e f f e c t i s i n t e r p r e t e d a s i n t e r f e r e n c e with the
nearly apparent
resonance aslsuraing there i s a f k n i t e a w l i t u d e f o r w 2 a .
w
(Thle v i o l a t e s i s o s p h ,
tlnd i s an electromagnetic e f f e c t which we will, d i s ~ ~ 3i n~ the 3 next l e c t u r e , ) Values f u r t h e various constants f o r t h e vector mmon m y be found i n t h e P a r t i c l e Properties Table,
There is now s o m a d d i t i o n a l d a t a from t h e
Oraay Storage Mngs (S, Lrrf rancois , 31971 Z n t e r n a t i m s l s p p o s i u m on e l e c t r o n and photon i n t e r a c t t a n s a t high a e r g y ) ,
Sam of t h e differences from P a r t i c l e
Table r e s u l t s a r e new data but so= a r e due t o an a l t e r e d way af reducing data, especially for the p,
We s h a l l have t o wait f o r new p a r t i c l e tablea t o thrash
these d i f f e r e n c e s o u t ,
B New Q1
P a r t i c l e Tables
f 2 * 1 t .7) x
B ( + + ~ B - )= 46.4 2 2.8%
~(4yrOy)
('25 2 ,091 X
B($-*%$)
B(++Jn)
(14.7 2 2.2) x
B(++3n)
m
~(ur.n'y) = '07 2 '02
ru total. = 4.2
.O4
B(ws2n)
r tube%-> 780
mp2 l"
P
r P-*C?+@-
r
,02
1.0 NeV
2 '02
(Phase 87' t 15')
6
total. = 153
6.0 2 .3 &V
BCWSR)
= 90 2 4%
rw
= 11.4
B(w2n)
.c
~(.-+e'e-)
= ~ 0 6 6t ,0017)~
P
3
1 3 &V
6.5 t .5 keV
= 2.27
2 gw/4n =58.3 2
g( /4n
-
755
nt
l'
13.3
P
+
+ 0,9
,009 2 .Q02
10
t o t a l = 125 2 20
r P+e'e-
C a f e d a t i n g from t h e l a t e s t Oreay d a t a , we g e t 2 gp /4n
= 18.2 2 5%
~ ( w - . n ~ y =) 9.3 "-22
.76 2 .08 k e ~
2
35.4 c 4%
2 , 7 MeV
~ ( @ q O y ) ~ o seen t
p
Branching r a t i o
BC#+n"y)
rg t o t a l = 4,7
w
-
7.5 2 .9 keV
85
Vector Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothesis but Clrstzy snaking "corrections f o r f i n i t e widthf' "reduces t h e data i n some o t h e r
Nota,
Now t h a t we have d a t a f o r t h e r a t e s
and
W T I ~ we
can compare t h e
predictions of t h e quarlc model with h a r m n i c dynanaics of Femma, U s l i n g e r
and Ramdal. Orsay
Quark Model r @ s y = 1.73 x furny
GeV
I , O 2 . J 4- 1 0 " ~%V, .6 f .2 x 10"~ &V.
1.92 x 10-'GeV
W e will make a digression frm our m b n discussion of vector =sans consider t h e i n t e r e s t i n g f e a t u r e of w
-p
to
interference.
The reason w can go i n t o Zn is t h a t t h e s t a r e / w > is not pure / w a > (U;
4'
+ dhj
isospin zero b u t has a small admixture of i p
Lsospin one i n i t ,
p
- 2a
: U (
- dr)
This mix%ag is due t o e l e c t r o d y n m i c s .
We consider the w
tude t o be i n a
2
-
-
p system a s a two-stare system where Cpo is t h e ampli-
s t a t e and Cwo i s the m p l i t u d e t o be i n an wo s t a t e .
the =ass n a t r i x f s
therefore the t r u e w i s
E16
Photon-WadranInrmetions
6 can be given i n terms of t h e branching r a t i o f o r w2r
Frm Orsay e x p e r g w n t a l d a t a the abow branching r a t i o Jls 4 f 2X we t h e r e f o r e
obtain
14
3 * 7 1 .9 &V.
by fitting t h e "shoulder"
The phase 55 the w-p i n t e r f e r e n c e is detennkaed ia
+
(@'P
m a r the
+. A X-)
I f 6 is negative t h e phase of & / ( l 9
is 87' J: 15'.
p
resonance; t h e value
+ 561)
is l09*, which is
in f a i r agreement with t h e a p e x h e n t .
We can understand t h e rolxing a s due t o e m r g y of
WO
e f f e c t s : ( l ) The electroroagaetic
is not e q w l t a t h e energy of dB because of t h e d i f f e r e n c e i n s e l f
energy of t h e objects and t h e d i f f e r e n c e of energy of %nteiactlon, (22 m e r e i s a c c n t r i b u t i a n d w t o a m i h i l a t i o n p.
+
y
-+
g,,
wo
+
y
+
wo go
+
Y
+
w
.
We can g e t estimates f o r the two above e f f e c t s from t h e knowledge a f K*'
+ p -'p
-
.
Let the s e l f energy o f d be a mass d i f f e r e n c e s and from P P and t h e matual energy aE d x be -b; then the s e l f energy o f u is 4a tund t h e
K*'
and
m t u o l energy of Prom w
=
a 1
U ;
is (m;+
- Sb because the photons a c t twiee on double t h e charge. - (ug - -X], P+ = uZ,K*+ u s and K*' = d z dz), p.
-
K
we obtain t h e f o l l o d a g electrotaawetic s e l f energies
But we a l s o have a raatrjjr e l m e n t b e t m m <po[ and Iw5> 1 3a (4a a) 2 (4b b)
- -
from t h i s alone the mass m t r f x i s
-
- %/Z
Vectsr Mesons and Vector Meson L)smin'naneef-lypefhest's Slnce
K*'
-
= 3a
+ 0 p - p we have 3a
- 3b/2
+ 3b
= 9b/2 m
(K*'
- K*') - (pi - p o t )
Note t h a t i n eq. (15 -5) we have w r i t t e n p" f a i n d i c a t e t h a t p''
instead of p',
t h i s is only
does nor contain the contribution from t h e a n n i h i l a t i o n
t e r n which we c a l c u l a t e next,To f i r s t order i n e
Let x be t h e amplitude f o r
2 42'
is x i 3 (see l e c t u r e 16).
(U;
- d3)
+
2 the change i n ~ s s s18 given
, the
y
amplitude f o r
--1
42
(U;
+ dz)
The maa8 aratrix due t a the a n n i h i l a t i o n term is therefore
proportional t a
We already have one -try f o r the full matrix
+
of t h i s matr%x, Am
61
1.53 lvleV we therefore have
Addlng the contributions from the electromagnetic s e l f arass and f r m the annihilhtion t e r n t o the non-diagonal matrix e l e w n t we find
and since
- p'')
-(p'
6
-
--
-l,02 &V
+
f r m data i n the p a r t i c l e
-2.4 .k 2 . 1 &V,
- K*') -
+ (K@
.5 &V
6
(p'
(p
C
- pot)
(U ,fO)
- p') - 1.53 EleV
- K*') - '0( - p)' tables, (K* - K*') -8 +3 (K*
E(eV
and 'p(
-)'p
But we do not t r u s t these r e s u l t e , especially the p mass
difference, we oaly say chat they Pndicate t h a t 6 i s l i k e l y t o be negative,
P e 'e 4 t t u
The yp coupling of the form
'
i s not gauge invariant aod
would give a f i n i t e massZ f o r the photon v i a
The coupling i s A P,
f o r exmple.
However ~ Bwe ean~ couple ~ the~ f i e l d s P
~
u'J
of the photon sad
X t leads t o
which i s evidently gauge invariant.
Since eye q is always zero we aee our
pole behaves l i k e @I
The l a t t e r term has no pole s i n g u l a r i t y and is "lost" fn the background of other than pole t e r n and e f f e c t i v e l y t o eY
e P t i . e , 2 C nr
P P
WC?
can use a restdue just prapartionaf
2
=
Vector mesons (continued) Me n m return t o our discussion of vector m e s w ~ . We can see what %U3 2 given a t the end o f l e c t u r e 14, Wtz gives f o r the r a t f o s of the couplings
89
Vector Mesons and VeerorMeson Dominance Hypothesis use t h e s i w l e quark model ( f o r c o w t i n g only) and assu&ng t h e Q,
18
purely
J couples t o @ p a i r proportional t o i t s char*
strange quarks.
4
88
+
- 113
- 3-13
Noting t h a t these a r e values f o r the coupling F, euld t h a t g is t h e r e c i p r o c a l we f i n d -2
gp
:gu
-2
:gI
-2
9:1:2
Various p o p l e have t r i e d t o c o r r e c t t h i s f o r SUS breaking, but nobody r e a l l y b m s how,
The f i r s t is, t o what e x t e n t Is
There a r e two questions,
The low valae oE the Q1
I s e e no way t o d e t e r d a e t h a t .
t h e ip pure ?:a
brsnchinlng r s t l o is i n t e r p r e t e d Fn the
+ 2%
m d e l by s a y h g t h a t the 4 being
made of purely s t r a n g e quarks f h d s i t hard t o go i n t o non-trange
objects
(S),
I f so, a l l t h e ~ l l t u d at o go t o ny coaea frorn an a a x t u r e of t h e w s t a t e , (U;
the
+ dx) /fli n + comes out
the 4 wave functfon,
in
t o about: .l0, although t h e r e is so= uncertainty 5: .03 a s t o
how =ss f a c t o r s e n t e r .
Prablern.
I n t h i s way the m p l i t u d e t o f i n d
t h e s t a t e is 99X pure ss,
This i a only 1% prob&ility,
b k e a. theory t o e s t i m t e haw much Q,
+
3n would be expected i f
i t i s due t o t h e f a c t t h a t 4 has a small admixture of u s t a t e ; assurnfag (for
no e x c e l l e n t reason) t h a t
8;
c a a o t go t o 3~r.
&re importmt i s the question of SU3 brealring because the m s e e s a r e not equal.
Par one e x e q l e of m b i g u i t i e s , s k o u l d we compare P 's d d i e c t l y with
, or
the $U3 predicted r a t i o s , o r should i t be \/mv should bear the s i a p l e r a t i o s ?
P /m v
V
o r what, which
$U3 cannot t e l l us and nobody r e a l l y laxows how
t o c a l c u l a t e i t , although varioue guesses have Been made.
(I p r e f e r F,/%
f o r a t h e o r e t i c a l rewon, but one which is r e a l l y not profound o r necessary). These questions probably do not strongly a f f e c t the p,w r a t i o , a s t h e m s s e s a r e close together,
As you sec? the r a t i o 9 : 1 5s not very Ear o f f , (and, i n s p i t e
of the u n c e r t a i n t l e a , the cp i s a l s o about right). Vector Heson Dominance Model 4.
To s u m e r h a we e x h i b i t the photon t o n
n
- w l i t u d e near
t h e pole of t h e
p (the only m e of the three
when q2*
4, u,
P
which couples t o the pion) a s
h e would ordinarily expect other terms (such a s a d i r e c t
HL 2 e
P
caupling of photon t o pions or various other ""tntemdiate to this.
statesf') t o be added
Tiris, of cauree, would a o t chaage the behaviour near the pole ((trrtrlch,
unfortunately f o r the p is not so definite a s the width Pp is r a t h e r large, whicb tnakes mny d i f f i c u l t i e s in practice i n f i t t i n g i t , nevertheless i n t h i s thaor e e f c a l discussfan we s h a l l neglect i t ) .
Aslother way t o say i t is t o suppose
2
the n w r a t o r has a f a c t o r F;(q ) which varies with q
2
again t o say the "constants" f p n z o r gp vary with q2 m
P
being defined.
such t h a t &(m
2 P
) = ,l or
only t h e i r value a t g
2
All these ways say the same thing so we s h a l l not argue
about them. Nevertheless a bold hypothesi.8 has been suggested (vector =son dominance) t h a t t h i s expression with f other t e r n ,
(Inn
/g constant i s a l l there i s t o i t p
I see no good physical reason for' t h i s ,
another mystertortkl hopothesfs of the 8an analogous thing with a pion pole a t the pole,
m
P
m q2
-
- there a r e na
It i s made i n analogy t o
kind, BGAC, t h a t works,
- but only extend i t from g2
melee we do
mwZ
m
.Q2
0. Here we suggest eq. (16.2) i s v a l i d nor only near q
2 but a l s o f o r a l l q o r a t l e a s t t o q2
0.
W e b o w f a r long wave leagths the pion looks l i k e a s h p l e point charge
ao t h a t ss
2
-t
C? (use crossing t o cooverc
cn'/~~/n'>
(pllr+ pZV) f o r q2
+
Q,
hence f o r (16.2) t o be trw we mwt have (neglect problor suppose Tp deperrds m q
2
+ 1+ lr
t o cn / J n
we have (16.3)
generated by
I'p,
2 and vmLshes a t the (2an) threshold and below).
2
Vector Mesons and V e t o r Meson Dominance Hypothesis 2
= 2.56
gp / S A
w e l l within the LOZ m c e r t a i n t i e s i n detemining these quantities. 2
It would a l s o imply t h a t the f o m factor F%/q
+ I J 1~
m
(l+(-q2)/m
P
2 Fw(q
'I-'.
(plu
/
f o r the pion, written
pZu) would, f o r negative q2, have t o be exactly
f
We s h a l l look a t what evidence there i s l a t e r
- s o far i t
looks very p o d . The idea i s extended t o the case of Lnteractions with aslg s t a r e
- for
example i n i n t e r a c t i o n s with the nucleon the part due to fsovector would b e Fa2 J~ isovector 2 L 2 SN/Q\N> (16 '42 Bp (q -mp 1
--
IN>
IN'
p with p o f a r i z a t i m U.
The term < M / p
IN>,
the coupling o f a p to a nucleon
is defined only a t the p pole, and there has an e l e c t r i c and ntametic part s o
%NI
we c m w r i t e as
+
C~
1.
.
IN)
(y$-dyy)
Thus, expressing the
ksovector
part of' the current coupling i n t e r n OE the txswllly defined form factors w e have
(q2)yV +: F
=
~ 3
-
2
l
2
imp 1
(l-q
Thus we predict t h a t Fl/F2
Cl ~NI--~~+S g~ Cl/CZ
-$ ( Y ~ # + Y ~ ) ~ N ~ +(~~l-l(l~)/~'
i a independent of q
2
( f a i r ) and Ff varies
2 2 2 This l a t t e r is not good, l/(l-q /m 1 i s b e t t e r .
as i/(l-q2/mp2).
P
a r e teatgng (1) f o r l a r g e negative abviously VMD c-ot v a l i d from qZ
(q2)
m
P
'
qL
- far
&re w e
frm the p pole and i t f a i l s .
z.
be an exact p r h c i p f e f o r a l l q
But lnaybe i t is nearly
t o 0. W e must discues extensions of the idea and f u r t h e r
evidence ,
n f u r t h e r conclusion Is no
from the nucleon case above is t h a t Cl/gp = l. There
way t o g e t the p coupling t o the nuclem, C
1 o r C2, xitholtt d i g u i t y a t
preseat (or ever? is it a Ilzattar of definition < I S I ~ P / N >c m n a t have alZ the, p a r t i c l e a physically on tb m s shell!), f o r e-ple,
e x i s t s f o r the ccupling of t h e p-like t r a j e c t o r y
c a l l p-exhange i s mbiguous,
Som bowledge, from nN scattering
- but
- or
f o r what we
the extrapofation from p-trajectory t o p-pole exchaage
The l a t t e r {p-pole exchange) has azl m p l i t u d e varying as
8
buc
the t e m associated with p trajectory exchange do not, and they are not supposed t o i n Regge theory i t s e l f . A s M l a r ezpresrplon using the
W
trajectory is t o give the i s o s c a l a r
92
Photon-Hadron Interactions
coupling,
Since t h e mass of t h e w i a n e a r l y equal t o t h a t of t h e p , the
i s o s c a l a r and Fsowector f o m f a c t o r s should have the same dependence as q2 they do even though t h i s depndence is not t h e (l-qZm
-
expected.
P
Lecture 17 Vector Meson Dodnance Model (continued) I n g r e a t e r g e n e r a l i t y a l l t h r e e a e u t r a l vector xaesons my be involved, For example, i n coupling t o an arbf t r a r y badran s t a t e we w r i t e
'V with p o l a r i z a t i o n p
(or of caurse by c r o s s i n g f o r any t r m s i t i o n hadrons X
-c
hadrons P)
I)
%at t h e l e f t s i d e of (17.2) gives t h e t o t a l of a12 t h e ways t h a t Ju em couple is t h e general s t a t e m n t of t h e hypothesis of vector dodnmanee, already seen tim i t predilcted t h e
p m
coupllng constant,
+
t h i n g f o r t h e $U coupling, sag (PR K"? qZ* O might be w r i t t e n (p s o we have t h e svm of
l
-
+ pZu) with
l~ (K+K-
1 V)
We have
Can we do a s i & l a x
We know t h a t t h e current operator at c o e f f i c i e n t l b e c e w e the charge is l ,
muat equal 1. Thw i f we w r i t e
we would have
The problent now is t h a t althougb we do know t b e t h r e e have too m n y unknoms i n (17.4)
+4 +R K implies
fvX;+K-/4r = 1.47).
G
( f r m experiraent) we
t o r e l a t e i t t o experilneat,
(The r a t e t h a t
We need some r u l e t o p a r t i t i o n the b i t e of
c u r r e n t bemecn p , w , and C$, A very suggestive t h i n g t o t r y is t o express the quark mdef i d e s t h a t
the
~5
is pure
gs,
and thus couplee only with t h e s quarks i n a system,
f which
suggests we invent t h r e e c u r r e n t s J ~ ,J ~ ,
COUP^. only
mis
t o t h e U quarks,
93
Vector Mesons and ;E/edorMesorr Doininarree Hyparliesis the d q u a r b , o r t h e
quarks (as though each had unf c charge),
S
exaaple, t h e e l e c t r i c current (charges on
U,
d, s, a r e
+ 2/3,
Then, for
-113, -l/3
respectively) &B :
- 71 - f l being g - dx), 1
&3
Jel Then, the p
JY
(17.5)
J6
(U;
we define a "@-type currentt' a s J@ d
(JU + J ) and a 4 type, which s i n c e 4
likewise an u-type 3@
-J.
m
~ i -(.FU
-J~>,
i s j u s t J'
m
-
hence f o r e m w l e
Now obviowly w e suppose the three pieces i n t o vhlch
it%
a r e the corresponding vector m s a n resoaant pieces of (17.5).
s p l i t i n (17.6)
This inay be w r i t t e n
i n a very s i q l e way, f f t h e gV r e a l l y have the r a t i o s of the quark m d e l (Lecture
14) we a r e saying, of course
the sm f o r all q w r k s is
where t h e constant,
Bowever
M
.
s t i l l must define i n an e x p e r i m n t a l l y d e f i n i t e way what JY, J ~ Js. ,
W e can use i s o s p i n ,
o r J P , J@,J' are.
hypercharge and quark number (or
) a s three conserved q u a a t i t i e s (each d e f l n i t e f a r a
r a t h e r , baryon n-er@ particular transition X
+
Y) t o serve inntead of quark nmbera. P
represent t h e current of Z-component isospin;
J
m -JZ
+$
JY
to write
+
- JY + ,IB
Js
quark, IZ d 113 f o r t h e currftnril you g e t one f o r JU, zero f o r J and
(beesiluae if you erubstitute f o r e x q l e the guaaturn n d e r 6 of t h e
+ 112, Y
-+
11'3, B
J", e t c , )
Hence J"
'
cvrrent of hypercherge, J~ c a r r e a t
of beirym n u a e r (equals l 1 3 tims t h e current of quark n*er)
Jd
Thue l e t J
...FZ
m
U
lPlis then deflnes precisely what we m a n by t h e currents h (14.5) and (14.6). f
l e , l e t us apply t h i s t o the K K4"
couplinge of J' t o K
+ 1/2, Y
-
C
1, B
(we a l s o calculate .lP,
-
decay of the 4 .
.JW
We need the
f o r cnnpleteoess).
For the K+,
O, sa a t zero q2;
m u s e o & i a b g t h i s with ( 1 4 . 9 ) and (14.7) we see we a m t have
defining how the t o t a l of ( l ) i n (17.41 is partitgonad,
2
which agrees p r f e c t L y with the f4 m/4n
-
1.47 from
(
A t my r a t e we predict
4"
-+
K K- and g
4'
2
/4r
13.3
f r o m 4 + e\-.
How slow is 4
-+
3n cmparczd t o w
-+
3nl
(p
goes 18% Co 3n, but I' i e only 4
so the p a r t i a l width i s only .7 MeV while i t is B? &V is l a r g e r f o r the QI but -re t h e ~ ~ l a t r fe xl e m n t varies,
for the
W.
Phase apace
detalXeZt ana1ysSs would require knowledge of how I f e is the polarization of the vector nreaon
llnd PI, p2, p 3 the four vectors of the three pions the emplitude must be constant eliYap eli plv p2@ pgp.
The "constmt" f o r the 4 has ta be about 0.1 a f its value
f o r t h e w.
Lecture l 8
Ismss The 41 appears ea act ast pure
L.
&at is the significarxce of a l e
- or
r a t h e r how can we d e f i ~ e& i s h t e r m a f q w t m nu&trra o r r u l e s without
9.5
Ymmr Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothesis r e f e r r i n g t o the quark m d e l ? We don't k n w how,
Wcr t r y t o say t h a t i t w u p l e s
weakly t o s t a t e s which have no strange p a r t i c l e s i n them, s o not t o 3n but yes to
E,
Yet such an idea "a s t a t e t h a t has no strange p a r t i c l e s i n it" $8 not
readily definable.
has no o v e r a l l
Due t o s t r o n g i n t e r a c t i m s a s t a t e l i k e
qwntuat a m b e r s t o d i s t i n g d s h i t from 3n; I n f a c t v i a v l x t w l i n t e r a c t i o n s
-
should couple strongly t o 35 ( f o r example through a tairtual w, KK
the
.g-*
u
3n.I
m e r e f o r e the question r e m i n s , what keeps the 4 Exono coupling strongly with 3n'l From the paaitat of view of
i s s e l e c t e d from the
~1
quark =del we &&t t r y t o say t h a t the
l -&ZM~] state
state
of the w simply by the f a c t t h a t s quark@
carry a l a r g e r =ss (or a d i f f e r e n t Faceraction energy) than non-strmge quarks, So i n lowest order of perturbation theory t h e e i g e n s t a t e s of energy a r e and
1( u ; ~ z ) . G
But then we f i n d these s t a t e s a r e unstable, and a s a kind of
perturbation they decayiy,i t turns out wItb s m l l widths.
- there is a u coupling equal t o - L is n o t small
s t a t e s f o r e x m p l e Qt
coupling of 4' and o0 t o every meson s t a t e (with t h e of t h e Q, coupling).
fi-
+.@E
But t h i s ""perturbatione1
-*
w
Thus f o r these v i r t u a l mson
there a r e d i a g r a w
4-
W
l? which mix t h e 4, w s t a t e ,
These d t a g r w cannot be calculated, (the above
diverges quadratfcally) and no w l c u l a t i m of such v i r t u a l strong f n r e r a c t i s n s h any problem has ever been successful.
But usually the q u m t i t a t i v e idea
t h a t i f the s t a t e s can be connected v i a strongly i n t e r a c t f n g virtuin1 s t a t e s they can go i n t o each other is v a l i d .
The coupling constants £+E aad fMa a r e s o
large they would seem t o have e f f e c t s of order I, t h a t is, t o strongly m i x the o r i g i n a l pure &a and
1(u%d;i).
a
Of course i t Is always possible t h a t t h e world t h a t the cmbination
as is not
18
s i w l y complicated,
i s o l a t e d by p r h c i p l e i n the beginning; but the
vex)r v i r t u a l i n t e r a c t i o n s s e l e c t s o m l i n e a r ta&ination of be t h e
I$
[and the orthogonal c*ination
the co&ination Is
and
1 (UCM~]t o
&I
f o r the w) and i t j u s t coraes out t b a t
L,
Then perhaps it %a r e a l l y possible t o tmderstmd why 4 but is the a~lcllbtlessof 4
-+
.c
ny i s eo sraalf,
3%r e a l l y obvious I n t h i s model of the s t a t e ?
But s r e l l @ore s t r i b f n g is t h e f a c t t h a t t h i s "accident" %a repeated again!
+
For the mesons of spin 2 where the Z(l25Q) goes nicely i n t o 2n or 4r end i n t o
S. The f(1514) goes p r e d s d n a t e l y i n t o '&l
and even h t o G%-k*and not i n t o
nn i n s p i t e of the even l a r g e r phase apace.
(The quark w d e f r a t e s (Fep-n,
-
U s l i n g e r , b m b l ) using pure l ( u s d x ] f o r the f ( 1260) and a; 42' a l l high, but the relatkvlve proportions a r e right.) m e e x p e r i m n t a l and quark m d e l
NOTE:
(m)r a t e s
f o r f (1514) a r e
+
f a r 2 w s o n s are;
There are i n addition two hadronic phenomaa ilesociated w%rh the 4 unless the QI Is, l i k e
vhlch axe =expected
+ 88
+ nn
N
thou& the 4 were not coupled t o the M, N* (a aucleon
trajectory) j m c t i o n , (relathe to p
+N *N ++
The f i r s t is badward praduction of rfr i n r B N
of zero s t r m g e a e s s ,
It: %B very weak,
weakly cowled t o hadronic s t a t e s
,S ;
AgaZn p 4-
p + Q1 + a n
is very etrangly suppressed
for exmple) a s thou& the $B%
8
a d
carnot be lazade fro=
the non-strange quark@ in the a t b e r p a r t i c l e s ,
VDM aad Photon XIadron Interactions b n p l e t e vector diminan= i ~ l f e tsh a t the photon carnot i n t e r a c t with a kadron except a s i t f i r s t becoms
et
p , w o r $B,
i n general) i n t e r a c t s with the hadrons,
and then t h i s
p, w
o r 4 (say V
Thus we would expect t o f&ad so= kind
of r e l a t i o n beween awXitudes l i k e h p (7
f
A
+
B) = v
%v
@ + A +
B).
There a r e several, p e e t i w involved i n using the f o m l r t . are t h e o r e t i c a l questioas of - w a g .
Since y has
F i r s t , there
= 0, the vector meon
97
f/eeforMesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothegig 0, f o r which s t r i c t l y
an the right s i d e should be a v i r t u a l vector meson of q2
It might be argued t h a t sixlee -ss
no d e f i n i t i o n can be given,
s t a t e inco&ag p a r t i c l e miglrt have the least e f f e c t a t high
on the i n i t i a l (here E
8,
L=:
p
a n T a y f o r f i n i t e glass) t h i s m l a t i o n m y be mst nearly correct Ear r e a l vector -sons
on the right-hand s i d e a t very high
S,
b o t h e r related d l g u i t g i s
t h a t the photon has only WO golarizationa, h e l i c i t y
f;
l, so the equatloa has
But h e f i c f t y i s
only m a a i n g f o r the corresponding h e l i c i t y ?: l s t a t e s of V ,
not a r e l a t i v i s t t c a l l y invariant concept and depends on the Erme.
Most
t h e o r i s t s have corn t o the conclusion i t is i n the s-chmnel f r m e t h a t the
is reduced by going t o
p h e l i c l t y should be 2 1, A t any r a t e t h i s -certainty
Thus we s h a l l , t o avold auch c o q l i c a t e d discussion, limit our-
large s also.
selves t o c a p a r t s o n s t o experiment a t the h i @ e s t energies now avallsble. The next question is how we a r e t o o b t d a the vector =son or mplltudes V
+A
-P
crass sections
B, a f t e r a l l V mson beerne a r e aot available,
Sowtims
t h e o r e t i c a l a r g w n t s are available, but i f they a r e too complicated they a r e The m a t useful s i q l e cases a r e :
not uaeful t o t e s t WM.
a) Pseudoscalar =son production, i n p a r t i c u l a r p b) Biffraetion ( e l m t l c ) s c a t t e r h g from nuclems p
+ Nuclaw
J.
+N p + N
J.
n
+ N.
+
p
+N
o r nucleus
+ Nueleus,
p
kle discuss each i n turn, We can study the r e a c t l m p
reversed reaction n
+N
+
has been studied a t L5 &V
p
+ H,
+M
nap
+. 'p
n
+ 1\1
by experimntally s t u d y h g the
&ich should have the @ m e-2itudia.
a d reported by D.W.G.S.
This
Leith, fieno-oloa
Naturally the p is not observed d i r e c t l y
a n f e r e n c e , l971 (Caltech) p. 555. but
+
C
n is inferred fro= s coarplete study of n- p -, n v- a loolting tn
the appropriate Hltlse region of the two outgofng piona. be made f a r palra of pions, say i n mutwl v i r t m f p decay.
However the data a t low
S
Sow corrections mmt
waves, &icb a r e not due t o t hias been nlcely malyzed i n d e t a i l
t h e o r e t i c a l l y and we caa describe the r e s u l t a , and empare t o W# e x w c t a t i o n s , We evidently wish t o c m a r e these r e s u l t s t o reactions lib y
and
y
N
+
n N i e r e l a t e d d i r e c t l y by W t o nip
acleaaxl l i n e a r co&ination of P , we drop i t , and the w
M,
+*
interference.
-*
V'
n where V'
-+
W+
is a vector
Sinctl the $ coupling to =sons
mM
+p
is smir
then predicts f o r e x q l a that (by
+
a r e "fnsity r a a t r b e l e w a t s t o proJect out the h e l i e i t y 2 f reactions. -2 -2 is about: 9/1 so the second t e r n is Data i n the o reaction a r e lacking, but g P /gw (pll]
probably never large. 10 times
do
be a s -11
p
((n-
+
I n addition, a t 8 GeY
-r
p' n) is i t s e l f about
w n) i n the f a w a r d direction, so the w contribution might
a s 1%t o the
p-w interference
(E' p
mM
result,
The s m could not have been s a i d of a
term. ( f o r an a w l i t u d e of order .l i n t e r f e r i n g with 1 can w k e
a 20% e f f e c t , b u t i t @square is only B ) . m a t i s the reason t h a t the c q a r i s o n i s made t o the suzn of yg
+
+
n. a and yn
+
n-p croas sections
- for i n that a m
the p-w interfereace t e r n (from isospin considerations) cancels out ( s s doaa the P-+
interference), The cross sections f o r
4 3 1 1
the h e l i c i t y c a b i n a t i o n s of the p have been
aaasured (and reported %XI the f o m of density matrices) bp measuring the angular
+8-
dietributiona of the p a i r of pions n the polarized p
2
.
r e s u l t i n g f r o a the dlafntegration of
We a l s o have d a t a with polarized phot~r-e(perpendicular and
p a r a l l e l t o the plane of production a d s o can make two camparisona.
The vector
dminanee model predie ts then,
where daldt (yN
+ nN)
m m the average of dafdt
(m
-,-P) and dcldt (yp
and the p % are densktg nnattrix e r e m a t s i n the h e l l c i t y f r a ,
3.
.+
E
The r e e u l t s of
such a corrtparisan appear aa, follows (polarization data f o r photons a t 15 &V a r e not y e t available, but a p a s s e d extrapalation front 8 &V was nzade does not a f f e c t the ccrlnparlson of the s m of
5
8nd
3,
mmured as the .ctnpolarlzed cross section a t 15 GeV),
- this
which is of course
n)
98
Vector Mesons and Tdecror M e m L)amr"naneeWvmthesis
Kt &Vfc
c t
The r e s u l t s axe seen t o agree i n eexaety the f c m a r d d i r e c t i o n and generally f o r the uonatural p a r i t y exchange oil
.
, but
c l e a r l y disagree away from t
-
O for
Thus YOH a s s general theorem cannot be exactly c o r r e c t (barring the possi-
bZlity a f an mamw w c o n t r i b u t i m i n t h i s region], %W
photoas do not couple exactly ae off =ss
J w t how do they couple?
To make progress we should study t h e nature of the
deviations front a s t r i c t VDH and f i n d t h e i r c h a r a c t e r i a t i c a , we a good theory, which a t present we da not have develop
- we
But
sM.11 vector =sons.
For exmple! h&
- but should be able
cottld say why these various c r a s s s e c t l agree ~ ~ ~ for
to and f o r
the f o m a r d d i r e c t i o n , and why not Ear %? Perhaps s o m clues can be obtained from t h i s exmple s o we study i t f u r t h e r . The values of t we a r e studying here a r e sa small t h a t s i n g l e pion exchange ought t o d o d n a t e both cross sectionrr (Lee.
y
a s well ars p).
T f tbie
were e m c t l y t r u e without a b s o q t i o n corrections we would expect a r e l a t i o n between the cross sectiona s i m i l a r t o (18,2), (18,3), o r (18.4) simply because
The only difference (aside from t h e massZ dlffe'rence of o, y and selection
aE t h e c o r r e c t h e f i c i t y m p l l t u d e s t o c m a r e ) would be t h a t the y is coupled r e t h e plv
+ pZy of
t h e pions v i a a f a c t o
we would expect a r e l a t i o n l i k e
and the p v i a
Hence
t o replace (18,1), and corresponding r e l a t i o n s f o r the cross sections ( l 0 6 % ~(l8,3), (18.41 with g
P
replaced by fpww2). m e r e f o r e insofar as these r e l a t i o n s agree
f o r small t we have not made m y new r e s t of the vector dominance r e l a t i o n s other than t h a t fpwT2S gp2, a t e s t t h a t we have already seen works very well. t h a t equality of c a u p l h g constants w a s
cul
If
accident then the law t agreement
k.:uid only m a n chat s i n g l e pion exchange dorafnates both reactions a t small t
-
somthing we expect t o be t r u e on other grounds. On the other hand even a t low t , fi
deviate
- how could t h a t
m% f o r example, the two theories
corn about? The one pion exchange term aim t , of course,
b e corrected f o r absorption,
The differences between o
yH
and a
at low
&
met
l i k e l y c m be attributed t o differences i n the degree t o which a b s a r p t i m uludifies the m e pion exchange ezpectation. In the f i r a t place (see LE?ith% report) a f a i r f i t t o the p d a t a is given by a one pion exchange model corrected f a r absorption (due t o P.K.
Phy;s. Rev,
W i l l i w ,
1812 (1970)) f o r the a w l i t u d e e t h a t concern us t h i s gkvee
and
We have already sees t h a t the anabsorbed one pion exchange gfves f o r theere m p l i t u d e s { i n connection with the discussion of photaproduction)
-
This leads
and t h a t i d e a l absorption would subtract 1112 from each m p l i t u d e , t o zero A,
i f -t
:m
and f o r large t equal amplitudes f o r
Al.
All
and hence
t o ail asymmetry t h a t r i s e s from O a t t = O t o l a t t = mwZ and f a l l s beyond t h a t t o 0. photon,
% i s agrees with the a s
t r y observed f o r the Q, but not f o r the
1%the photon case the f a l l off f o r large t i s only aodazrate, t o say
0.5 o r so,
Thus f o r the photon i t looks l i k e a more appropriate correction
f o r absorption lnfght be t o subtract -re
l i k e 213 from the two mplltCLdes.
t r y i s 1 f o r t = 2mnL and f a l l s t o 0.6 f o r large t
- not
in
Vector Mesons and Vector Meforr D O I P Z ~N~yZp ~ f~l ~t t C ~ iCs We r e a l l y do not exactly k n w why the sub-
disagreement with experiment).
Possibly i n
t r a c t e d t e r n f o r absorption should always be the f u l l 1 / 2 ,
t h i s case e x t r a contributions (isoecalar o r isovector?) a r e contributing t o l%e point
t h e photon case t o increase the 112 appropriate t o t h e p case,
here is an ef f e e t d i f f e r e n t f o r p and y and hence df f f e t e n t Era= expectations of VD& (unless i t could possibly a r i s e from the u term).
Emever the c o r r e c t
c o n ~ t a n ttern t o use i a detemined e x p e r k n t a l l y by the cross s e c t i o n f o r t
3
O which is j u s t proportional t o t h e square of t h i s constant with known
coefficients,
This dete-nes
But a much =re
t h a t the constaat is indeed 212 t o 16%.
s t r i k i n g difference is the difference a f a
This difference is already l a r g e a t sml1 t
- the oB f
and a
YZ
EL'
drops o f f much Easter
Why? X dont t know. X thlnk the onystery here is $ay the cr YL* P1 f a l l s s o f a s t , In t h e E i t eo OPE plus a b s o r p t i m i t c~asfound empirically than does a
2
that a f a c t o r e"('lraz
needed t o be included i n these cross sections.
P. K, k f i l l i a m had suggested such a f a c t o r f o r absorption e f f e c t s but expected a much s l n r e r f a l l o f f ( l i k e e3('em'Z').
To what i e sueh a rapid f a l l off duel
Such a rapfd v a r i a t i o n is e n t i r e l y unexpected, method of analyzing t h e d a t a , m's i n a m u t w l s-tprave (not a
near
-t
-
It is very possibly due t o the
The e f f e c t of an m p l i t u d e t o produce a p a i r of 1))
has t o be subtracted away,
The value of
mzZ is e s p e c i a l l y s e n s i t i v e t o what is done here ( a t t
-
p
It
O o r -t
2 10mn
i t Is not s e n s i t i v e , ) Nevertheless there is a contribution t o n a t u r a l p a r i t y
exchange which is d i f f e r e n t f a r y and p ( v i o l a t i n g VD&). theofy of &ere and when such deviatgons should a r i s e ? probles t o analgze t h i s i n m r e d e t a i l .
How can we m&e a @e leave i t aa a
Onet obv%ous p o s s i b i l i t y seeing the
l a r g e n d e r i n the elrponent is t o be reminded t h a t t o t a l absorption e f f e c t s
(as seen i n e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g ) do f a l l off a s expbt with b of order 8 o r 9 f o r n nuclean s c a t t e r i n g .
So perhaps a c a r e f u l anaZysis of absarption, o r
a l s o of t h e p o s s i b i l i t y t h a t the source BE t h e pion is i n d e f i n i t e by the s i z e of the nucleon or the p, w i l l explain it.
The point of explaining i t , however,
i r s t h a t t h e drop off is much slower f o r the photon c a m .
Ttzerefore whatever
the c a m e i t works d i f f e r e n t l y i n p and y pseudoscalar production,
Zn i t s study
1Zes t h e p o s s i b i l i t y o f understanding physically h e r e t h e ideas of VDH go wrong.
The problem cannot be d i f f i c u l t
- the e f f e c t shows up
f o r smll t and
hence f o r l a r g e i m a c t p a r a m t e r and therefore i n a realm *are
physical
phenomna a r e usually underetand&le,
The next topic we take up is the dgffractive production of vector mesons by photo=.
here, to
A t f g r s t we study the p =son
f o r amre detailed data is available
I w i l l not go i n t o a s m c h d e t a i l i n the r e s u l t s a s we a r e aceudlit~rned
- Ear a
f u l l r e w t report see:
@off: 1971 Zntennatima1 Conference m Electron and Photon Interactions a t High Energy, Cornell, Zthaca, N.P
., (1971).
Our aain concern ~513.be a cofnparison t o V W , The go production i n yN
+
the cross section approaches
B
looks very tauch Like d i f f r a c t i o n s c a t t e r i n g , constant a t hi& energy sad hat^ the typical
dawndencl; of such ~ c a t t e r b g , But how does the photon a f f r a c t Snto a
Qne
m w e r ie provided by V M , from the expected w l i t u d e relation (18.1) we expect 1
(because of. I spin change i t is expected that
@W '
rapidly with Lznergy s o only the p t e r n remains).
+
p%
or
w i l l fall
$ON +
Wat do not know d i r e c t l y the
cxoss section of p' on nucfeoas but we c m e q e c t i t t o be a typical e l a s t i c
.
scatter&ng
G crude use of the q w r k -del
supposing the quarks t o s c a t t e r independently
of t h e i r spin directian m d t o be s l & l a r l y d i s t r i b u t e d inside the
and no
p'
suggests a ( p 0 ~ )p. 6 ( n 0 ~ ) . Thie l a t t e r is not Ixnown by d i r e c t experitoenr but [o(n-#
isospin gives i t as
t o t a l cross section f o r yN behaves,
+
+
W-&)
+ o(%'~
+
aCN)].
It does turn our t h a t the
p ' ~ varies with enerm i n j u s t the way
$ [6(n'~)+
o(n%)
Xn f a c t the t o t a l cross ~ e c t i o ais given correctly by t h i s r u l e and
equation (19.1) with g
Et
-
2.8.
There is s 15%m c e r t a i n t y because the observed process is yN
+
N
C
nf
+
n-
and there a r e uneertafatia;is i n i n t e r p r e t a t i o n due t o so-called bck-type diagram i n a i c h the y becomes two pions Rat a t the p reeonmce and one pion s c a t t e r s l i k e
l
k t o r Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance Hypothesis
i n s t e a d of
A s t r i c t adherence t o VDN would, a s f a r a s I can s e a expect t h e analogue
f o r p s c a t t e r i n g t o 2n v i a
but t h e point is i n estimating just t h e e f f e c t of t h e s h p l e p e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g s o we can use our no s c a t t e r i n g malogy, This idea t h a t
yXrl -a p N
tells
W
about pP1
-+
pN pernalts us t o
S
The polarjlzation af t h e p coming out can be w a s u r e d .
behavior i n another way,
I t i s very nearly purely transverse and polarized a s the incident y ray.
This
3s excel l e n t evidence t h a t t h e p r a w s s of e l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g ( a l s o c a l l e d pomeron exchange) does nor change t h e h e l i c f t y i n the c e n t e r of =ss syatemn. , Were t h e d i f f r a c t i o n t e r n is svlaller s o o t h e r processes axe a l s o
e f f e c t i v e , i n p a r t i c u l a r one pion exchange a t t h e lower energies.
The n a t u r a l
p a r i t y exchange has besides t h e gomeran exchange a l s o possible A2 exchange ao t h e purely d i f f r a c t i v e p a r t ha8 n o t been separated out yet f o r a c l e a r t e s t . , The e x p e r i m n t s show some L n c a s i s t e n c y but d a t a lis a v a i l a b l e .
One wily t o t e s t t h e r e l a t i o n s of VDM i a t o conrparr? t h e forward d i f f e r e n t i a l cross s e c t i o n f a r yN W
-+
W,
%h'is
-c
VX wfth t h e f o m a r d d i f f e r e n t i a l c r o s s sectjton f o r
l a t t e r c m probably be estimated f a i r l y w e l l froin t h e o p t i c a l
theorcorn using quark model estimates f o r t h e t o t a l cross s e c t i o n s f o r W, (The quark model estirnate f o r t h e
aT(@p)
=
+
This gives a f i t with g
P
aT(~-p) 2
p, w
and 4 are:
- oT(w p) f
-
/ 4 n = 2.6 2 .3, 8;
l 5 mb
-
at 5
%v.)
24 t 5 and g
t8
m
22 2 6 .
Only
104
Photon-Hadron Interactions
the :g
seems too big.
It could mean the quark estimate of
-
is too b i g
l 0 lab would f i t b e t t e r .
k c t u r e 20 Diffraction production of v e c t o r m a m a can a l s o be seen, and m r e copiously and c l e a r l y fro= y on n u c l e i , A.
(Referwee: K. C o t t f r i e d "'Nuclear
Photoprocesses irnd vector doninance", Ceornell Gmference, 1971,) d i f f i c u l t i e s f o r the
since the f i n a l 3n s t a t e
%ere a r e
is hard t o m a s u r e , and t h e g
i s s o wide t h a t t h e o r e t i c a l q w 8 t i o n s of i n t e ~ r e t i a e d: a t a sire i n v o l w d .
The
c l e a r e s t case e x p e r % w n t a l l y f e 4 production, h w e v e r much more d a t a e x i s t s f o r the p ,
In these e x p e r i m n t s an p production observations a r e m d e of 2%
production by photons on n u c l e i , of course. t h e 2n is seen a t t h e p =ss, e f f e c t with w
-+
The 4 d a t a
X t is a s
A b e a u t i f u l resmance i n wss of
t r i c a l shouing t h e i n t e r f erence
Zn just a s i n e%- production, it3
now good,
The dependence an h, t h e mass nmber of the
nucleus, gives us some idea of a d e t e r a n a t i o n of g+.
W'
and the absolute cross s e c t i o n p e w t s a
Wowever an tmcc?;rta&nty a r i s e s f o r the r e s u l t s depend
s e n s i t i v e l y on the choice of m w k m quantity, t h e r e a l p a r t of the forvard @W s c a t t e r i n g amplitude f+4. Let aON= xrnfO4/~e is i n s u f f i c i e n t t o determine a l l three q u a n t i t i e s g
2
4
Then the d a t a if
/4n, oO, and o 4s'
g & / 4 n i s its Orsay vaiue 13.3 then we caa only conclude t h a t a m y be @ i n the range 8 t o l 4 aib ( a t about 7 &V) perhaps f r o a .3 t o -,S and o
-
,
possibly a b i t lower tlsan the quark m d e i r u l e s would suglgest, but l i t t l e c m be s a i d . TZze p d a t a i s m r e e x t e m i v e .
Were the l a r g e width causes s o w confusion
as t a what p a r t of t h e data i s t o be a t t r i b u t e d t o p production.
Again we
2
have three parameters g / 4 n , opMand apN. h e g e t s agreement with expectations P i f we ehooee apN 4 . 2 4 (but i t i s n o t well determined). The d e t a gives
-
t h e "good valuesff ( a t 8.8 GeV) gp2/4n
-
2.6 and o
well d e t e M n e d and r e s u l t s depend on i t , )
PN
Therefore the phenomnon of vector
meson productim e x i s t s and behaves closely l f k e a d i f f r a e t i o ~process, and could we11 be i n q u a n t i t a t i v e agreement. with the
VX)PII,
Does t h i s t e s t the
105
Yecror Mesons and Vector Mesorz Dominance Hypothesis Z think not because f o m l a (19 , l ) applied t o d i f f r a e t f o n scatterlstg
mdel?
- nmely
c m be derilred ( a t very h i & energy) f r m ano&er hypothesis
that
c l a s t i c s c a t t e r i n g of the p is much l a r g e r than d i f f r a c t i v e d i s s o c i a t i o n
the
s c a t t e r i n g of the p ( t h e process by which pEii
+
p*N where p* is s o w o t h e r
s t a t e of the s a m isospin a s the p , m a n d .tJhich survives a s s d i f f r a c t i o n diasocfatfon ( a s H% perhaps an*
-+.
o r nM
M%
-+.
-c
W).
Such
r*N) a r e i n other reactions
30% of t h e e l a s t i c scatrering fro@ t h e nucleon s o there i s
no reason n o t t o ass-
i t f o r the p,
Furthemore f o r the p we s h a l l only
have t o a s s m e t h a t the p a r t of d i f f r a c t i o n dissociation t o those p * having s p i n 1- ( l i k e t h e photon) is smll empared t o t h e e l a s t l e ,
a d i r e c t expergmental confimtialon o f t h e f a c t t h a t
-c
There is a l s o
@*H
where p * i s
any iaospin one, 1- s t a t e , produced Iln a d i f f r a c t i o n d i s s o c i a t i v e way does not f a l l wtth energy, For productian on n u c l e i our a s s u q t i o n (of the d o ~ i n a n c eof e l a s t i c
- f o r t h e e2aprtfe comes the a t i r e n ~ c 1 e w- whereas t h e
d i f f r a c t i o n diseociatialon) is ever more t r u e a s A r i s e s from d i f f r a c t i o n from the shadow of
p a r t i c l e s produced by d i s s o c i a t i o n can e o m only fro= its edge. The point
is L t i s riot doainimce of the y t o p t h a t we r e q u i r e f o r
the v a l i d i t y of equation (?19,1), i t w u l d a l s o follow from do&nmce of P
-+
i n the products o f the d i f f r a c t i o n of p
P
0s
nucleon and nucleus.
We can s e e how t h i s works most c l e a r l y i a the case of s c a t t e r i n g from a l a r g e nucleus where our a s e u w t l o n is most nearly v a l i d , considering yA t o P&
-+
PA,
-t.
pft
analyze t h e reverse reaction
gA. -, yA
Instead of
and compare i t
m e high energy pA s c a t t e r i n g appears, i n say t h e
C.=,
a s followap;
The waves of. the Incomfng p c o w I n from t h e l e f t and f a l l upon the nucleus where they a r e absorbed. wave lengths i f
S -,
A s h o r t distance ( a i c h c m be m n y
beyond t h e t a r g e t eay at the datted l i n e the wave
function is nearly the o r i g h a 2 , p wave f m r z t i m with aihole a@ a ffunctioa of
106
Photon-Hadron Interactions
b, the irapace p a r m t e r .
byond t h a t the waves Qowly d i f f r a c t i n t o the
s h a h i n a way d e t e m h e d by Euygens principle.
- alb) is the -1i-
Zf l
tude t o E b d a p a t 6 (so a is near 1 f o r b a m l l e r than the nuclear radius, and near O beyond) the i r p l i t u d e f o r an outgoing wave of transverse m m n t m
Q is j(l-a(b))
eiQob dZb f(q). ikr f(l-a(bl> d%
%
The amplitvde a t P is appronimately
Of course the l gives only the fomard be= m d doesntt i n t e r e s t us
is j u s t a s i f the
p c-
out only across the face of the nucleus.
- it
To be sure,
i f the p ware not a p o h t p a r t f c l e but say rnade of p a r t s (indicated by the braided l i n e ) we could not precisely define everything h t e m of aa m p l i t u d e But
t o give rz. p , but would seed a function of a l l the p a r t s as variables.
c l e a r l y f o r b outside the nucleus the p a r t s a r e i n the aaae r e l a t i v e a ~ l i t u d e as i n a p
- only near
of the p a r t s
the edge is there sow d i s t o r t i o n of the r e l a t i v e behavior
- and 80 a projection possibLble i n t o eoae other than the p.
the a w l i t u d e a(b1 is c l e a r l y t h a t f o r a
p
But
except near the edge; so t h a t elastrlc
s c a t t e r i n g is much l a r g e r (for nuclei, a t l e a s t ) than d i f f r a c t i o n dissociation, 3.
-
How we have noted from experlrnent by e e t h a t tJhenever we have a p present there is an amplitude t h a t t h i s p w i l l d i s i n t e g r a t e t o e+e'
(via a
photon) and therefore there i s a source of the e l e c t r o m g n e t i c f i e l d given by jij
Y xamp. t o find p polarized i n direction P, (Pp P
m
- a current - Hp2/gp).
-
Tlrw In our problem a t each point P there is a c u r r a t source of electro-
- thus the t o t a l q l i t u d e f o r finding a photon
m g n a t i c f i e l d of s i z e $(P) g o h g out with wave vector
gout is
!@(P)
e
-ik@at *P 3 d P,
expression f o r $(P) In t h i s the convolution of e-ik r/ -Zkout *I3 gives r:
1 m ,( B w k2 + mP2 and kautZ
If we s u b s t i t u t e our -ikout"P and e just 0) so we eventually get the
k -k
outgoing a ~ l p l i t d ef8Vtpbton is
where QOut is the transverse p a r t of Lout.
The i n t e g r a l i s the same as f o r the
p e l m t i c s c a t t e r h g so the a w l i t d e s a r e proportional
2
mwt bear the r a t i o bnr? /g
- the @roessections
2 D
Oae can of course carry the w t h e m t i c s out i n more d e t a i l separating
107
Vector Mesons and FlecforMeson Dominance Hypolhesis the z and transverse molenew c a r e f u l l y t o s e e j w t how t h e a s s m p t i o n of high energy i s v a l i d .
It is e m y t o urlderstmd i f t h e d i f f r a c t i o n of the
wave i n t o the shadow i e omitted.
ir; 2
shadow is j u s t e
-
kPr
E
Then the w v e going f o m a r d behind the
(l-a(b)) h e r e the incident p i s of enertgy E a d The amplitude t o ma*e a photon of energl E, transverse
-m ' / 2 ~ .
P
momentun Q, hence longitudinal moment= :k
A
-
E
- Q2/ZE a s
1/2E f a c t o r has been included t o take aceaunt of the r e l a t f v t s t t e
normaltrations f o r the incoming and outgoing p a r t i c l e s .
The m P
d i f f r a c t g m i n t o t h e s h a d w maLes i t m
P
'
'-
1/m 2
Q is wrong
(ae though the
fox p's s d a g i n t h i s direetZon).
It is evident t h a t the poferization of the y L s the s a w f o r t h i s process.
~zs t h a t
of the p
This f e a t u r e has been h e c k e d e x p e r i m n t a l l y very c a r e f u l l y
and is very eytribing, the p p o l a r i z a t i o n produmd by paftlrized photons is nearly purely t h a t of t h e photon. Often i t has been auggesred t h a t VDM p r e d i c t s i t s f o m l a (19.1) v i a a diagrlun Like
V
1
suggehlting the photon b e c m s a v i r t u a l p o; zero q L , and hence t h a t the coupling FD (or
q2
m
P
'
- mP2lg P )
should be t h a t appropriate f o r q2
-
O i n s t e a d of
+
where i t i s measured i n e em. It i s a r e s t of YDH t o f i n d t h a t t h i s
constarnt is unchmged i n t h i e range.
But we*have seen, by consfderation of
the reverse reaction, neglaetgng diffraction dissoeiiation t h a t the appropriate conetant should be t h a t of ra and no extrapolation i s involved. P J. a n d u l a haa3 c o n f i m d my a r g m n t by an. a r g a m t front dispersion theary m d the reduction f o m u l a ,
The a s s w t i o n of neglect of d i f f r a c t i o n d i s s o c i a t i o n e w e s i n h e r e ,
Near
the edge, t h e p a r t s of t h e p may n o t be i n p r e c i s e l y t h e sarne r e l a t i v e Htotion t o produce a p , but they m i & t
s t i l l produce a photon,
It m a n s an i n t e r f e r i n g term of o r d e r ~@*/rn~:
*ere
(Pp* i e t h e coupling of
p*
tlmes t h e amplitude t o make p*
t o photons) su-d
i t mwt be smll co&sg only near the edge.
Clearly t h i s is small.
on p*.
For n u c l e i a t l e a s t
The point is n o t s o much t h a t F
P"
i s sm11 (&%eh i t m y be, a s s o l i t t l e p* s e e m t o be produced by photons on
n u c l e i (vhlch measures
bur t h a t t h e nvmber o f p* produced by p v i a
d i f f r a c t i o n d i s s o c i a t i o n is smll. Other Tests of VIM I f VDH were c o r r e c t we expect t h e photons t o have amplitudes l/% t o be
various vector =sons
s o t h a t the t o t a l c r o s s s e c t i o n o f y t e on p i s l/%&
times t h e t o t a l c r a s s s e c t i o n of each of the vector meons.
(neglecting passibjle i n t e r f e r e n c e e f f e c t s of u and g). t h e p (becauee of t h e 9:1:2
-
o,(pp)
r a t i o of
%'
mis
and o(+p) is small).
We expect
is dominated by
We estimate
ot(@p) by t h e quark m d e l ss equal ~ ~ ( n ' p )fa scheme which we checked
i n our a(yp
-F.
Vpb consicierarians Ixbove).
kle f i n d e x p e r i m n t a l l y t h a t atot(ypb
is too l a r g e by 4QX, a s though o t h e r processes = r e available t a the photon t o i n t e r a c t with t h e proton besides go1ng throu*
v i r t u a l vector =sons,
A very s i a l a r cheek giving precisefiy t h e s a m r e s u l t i s Ca we eq. f 18.1)
t o say A(yp
.+
YP)
° I
Again t h e d o d n a n t term 5 s t h e
p,
XndependatZy of the r e l a t i v e phases we
The q w a t i t i e e on the r i g h t h m d s i d e a r e available d i r e c t l y by e x p e r i m n t . Ihe dependence of dao/dt (yp
O f o .4 h V
2
-+
Vp) on s (from 2.7 t o 5.2 &V)
and on t (from
) a r e w e l l represented by t h e r i g h t hand s i d e , but i t i 8 always only
about 112 of t h e e x p e r h e n t a r c r o s s section!
Thus VDEl f a l l s here.
This is i n ka~cordw i t h the tiOX e r r o r i n the t o t a l c r a s s s e c t i o n t e x t , f a r the o p r i c a l theoreoln reLatee ilo/dt (yp square of a t
+
yp) i n the forward d i r e c t i o n t o t h e
(YP) (assuming s o wt h i n g about phases)
.
Vetor Mesons and Vector McwfrBorrrirrancrfH j p o t l t c ~ ~ ~ i s
How should the t o t a l cross s e c t i o n f o r y+ iducleus vary with the rnass We knew f o r eollisiclns with hadrons nuclear atarter
n u d e r of the nueleus A?
is nearly opaque ((because a hadxon-nucleon is c m a r a b l e t a the spacing of t h e nucleons) and t h e r e f o r e t h e c r o s s s e c t i o n f o r A nucleons is n o t the sunr of a contribution from each (hence otat
%
A o nucleon) because nucleons i n the
f r o n t shadow those i n back s o ultimately f o r l a r g e A. i t goes as t h e area; of the nucleus o r
.
On the. o t h e r band f o r photon-nucleus
c o l l i s i o n s a. f i r s t glance would
suggest t h a t the nucleus now being transparent fay nucleon is much smaller than nuclear spacing i n a nucleus) each nucleon would s e e the f u l l bean and hence t h e c r o s s s e c t i o n would go a s A ( t i m s t h e simple nucleon g h o t m cross s e c t i o n ) . Or,
t h e o t h e r hand t h e VLlM shows t h a t t h i s l a t t e r canclusion cannot be A photon m p l i t u &
r i g h t i n general f o r i t is i n c o r r e c t i f the V I M is c o r r e c t . should be proportional t o t h e p amplitude
- the l a t t e r
is a hadronic m l i t u d a
-
hence the photon cross s e c t i o n proportional t o t h e p cross s e c t i o n m d t h e r e f o r e varying aar A2f3
(F. neglect the? contributions of w and Q, i n t h i s q u a l i t a t i v e
d i s c m s i o n , t h e i r contributions a r e e a s i l y r e i m t a t e d ) . The reason is t h a t i n the s % y l e view we img1ned t h e i n t e r a c t i o n y
+ nuclem
= X t o be a l a c a l process of y on nucleon, t h e y i n t e r a c t h g a e a r
h e r e the nucleon is located can become v l r t u a l hadrons
- but VDM reminds us (e,g.
t h a t t h i s is n o t so.
A y
2n, but most i w o r t m t l y a p ) Tar away I n
f r o n t of the t a r g e t , and the, d r e w 1 hadrons propagate a long way t o t h e nucleon to interact,
A r e a l photon is a pure i d e a l photon plus a v i r t u a l hadron with
amplitude l/dE accord%ng t o perturbation a e o r y where bE is t h e m e r g y d i f f e r e n c e of t h e s t a t e of given momntm m @oton md as hadran, the energy Is very sml1 f o r l a r g e v.
%us i f i t is a p
while t h a t of t h e photon is v s o dP; %h'is
- vs
m 2/2\1, P is a l s o t h e distance ahead of t h e nucleon &ere
t h e photon-hadxan conversioa occurs,
m
I f t h i s is l a r g e coapared t o t h e m a n free,
path of p i n t h e nucleus then shadowing occurs (Azi3 1, i f i t is small, no s h a d w i n g (A), The physical i d e a can be seen b e s t f $ r s t f o r a simple mdr?l c m s i s t i n g of
two t h f a slaba a, b of nucfear ntatter me i n front of the other by d.
@e s h a l l
calculate according t o WH, d
I f a p m r e inrpinging suppose the smll p r o b d i l i t p of being absorbed
i n the f i r s t l a y e r is fa; i n b alone f f p iarp~i.n@d that the p gate t o b
is
(1-5) so the product
fb.
But &a probability
%+
lDade in b is ( 1 - 5 )
The
t o t a l cross section i s thua fa+(l-fa)% = f +f -f f the l a s t t e r n representing a b a b
L e t us ealculiare the prob&iIfty Ear any product8 lnade i n b i f a 2s present
by photone v i a VDM.
Xf a f e not presflnt the q l i t u d e t o find a p a t b
product i s proportfoaaf to the m p l f t u d e the y converts t o p a t x
('\/TF
(the
Y
:!&has3
) and theo the p a r r i v e s a t d.
Thi. Is
hhets been taken r e l a t i v e t o the photon phase a t x
.c
d I.e.
the
abwe expretsalon c o a t a i ~ satt addltfonaa! f a c t o r exp I-ik d ) ) where the k Y
clre the L-vector f o r y o r p a t the same frequency. large?
V (mk.
Y
Y.
- kP
m '/'v
P
'5 for
1*
When a is present (21.1) is valid an* the ad&tioaal factor f o r
x
Xence L Y
Q
for d > x
0, For x 1-fa/2.
t o get throulpk s =
c
O we have
%S f o r
O we have
B e total. m l l t u d e ( b e e g r a t e xf is therefore pxoportfonaf, t a f
The =in
-i(k -k )d P
(21.3)
t e r n has an m p l i t u d e proporrfanclf Cc?
m-------
Id
arpect, the term i n shedaring fa corms i n various ph$es
as=
- and i o a more complete
Vector Mesons and Fector Meson Dominance Hypothesis problem with a continurn of l a y e r s would cancel out f o r (k -k )d Y P
111
1.
Thus t h e e r i t e r i o n f o r s c a t t e r i n g involves v, shadwing should be canrplete
for
V
J.
"
One ~ z n extend t h i s e m f l y t o a t h i c k l a y e r i n one dirnrznsion.
WE? seek the
a q l i t u d e co fInd a p a t x {for t h a t v i l Z l a t e r be used by squaring and s w i n g m t o g e t t h e t o t a l cross section.
W e have two cases g 0:
Y
4
y converts a t
Y > 0:
y
O md y
>
O
Y, propagates ss
p to
0; propagates a s p in mdium t o x
c m v e r t s a t y, propagates in mdiw t o
X.
The aaplf tude is proportional t o
( t h e phases have been taken r e l a t i v e t o the photon phase a t
X,
i.e.
t h e above
expressions contain the a d d i t i o n a l f a c t o t sxp (-ik X)), V
I n t e g r a t i n g over Y the a w l i t u d e a t x is
Here k
P
si"
i n the mdiutn.
k
P
At very high
V
i t has an iaaginary p a r t (representing
absorption) which is f i n i t e and fixed, the, r e a l p a r t goes, of course with v, but
m y d i f f e r froan i t bp a f h i t t ? m w t ,
Thus a s
V
+ m,
k -k Y
P
'*
k a fixed
a d e r (rJhose inailg2nary p a r t gives t h e p absorption cross s e c t l a n and whose phase i s the phase of forward p nucleon s c a t t e r i n g ) . 2 Thus i f k -k =
P
exttct proportion t o p absorlption, hence absorption, A f u l l calculation Including t h e s p h e r i c a l g e w t r y of t h e nucleus hae
been w d e .
They show a
V
dependence of atot(A)/Aa(nucleon)
f o r various nuclei
(see C;attfreid% report).
Ttze data does not show mu&
V
dependence
- (But L t is not f a r o f f ,
e x p e r i w n t a l e r r o r s a r e large enough, and the experimnt is very hard a t Tower energies) but not autsitie expectations
- hovever the wyrrrptotic valuers
of otot (A)/AofOr(H) a r e closer t o '87 f o r C, .15 f o r Cu and .60 (with large error) f o r Pb. These a r e a l l understmdsible i f the t a t a l croes section i s considered
70% W H and 30%s o w t h i n g e l s e ; (as we have srten is true) and i f the something
-
e l s e goes just as A purely, showing no shadowing, (for v
m)
values of ctot (h)/Ao (H) should d i f f e r fmm 1 by only 702 of the VDM
theoretical value f o r t h i s difference
.
Measurements a l s o e x i t fo v i r t u a l photons.
2 k = v - L
2*3
Y
Then the a y m p t o t l c
For them q2
m9.d sok-k Y
-
-Q2 and
Thw we expect fro= VDEI t h a t we again get
P
a v dependent shadowing, the p a r a m t e r d e t e d n i n g the extent of shadowing begng
((m
2
+ Q2)/2v
(In Au f a r g2
2 insread of m /2v.
No v dependence of shadowing is seen
0.5) i n strong disagreement with mlH predfctions.
I f we correct
VDM by allowing a c e r t a i n percentage of "other processes" which do not show shadwing, of course, l e s s shadowing is expected. 2
But we sboufd a l s o note tha
fraction of s o w t h i n g e l s e must r i s e with Q , The p so \IDH cross sections should f a l l as (m probably f a l l s only as
2
+ Q2~-2,
m p l i t u d e f a l l s a s I&2 3. Q2 1
he actual cross section
2 f o r large Cj (see l a t e r ) henee the f r a c t i o n of photon
cross sections &ich can be associated with d r t u a l vector aceson production
(mM cmtrZ;bution)
mwt f a l l aa photons become m r e virtus1,
for Au a r e not surprising.
%%us the r e s u l t s
f 13
Vector Mesons and Vector Meson Dominance f-lypothest To S m w r i z e the P o s i t i o a of WM I n t e r a c t i o n of photons of small q
2 (or q2 = 0) is very s t r o n g l y influenced
by t h e nearby poles a t the mass of t h e vector mesons,
fubstctntial p a r t s of t h e
i n t e r a c t i o n can be understood tas being due t o L a t e m e d i a t e v i r t u a l vector meson couplfng
- but,
a f course, n o t a l l t h e coupling can be s o described
[ f a r exanple only 70X of the t o t a l yp c r o s s s e c t i o n a t high energy Ss
80
described), In t h e s p e c i a l case altl the coupling t o p?lm t h e dodnance i s m r e eamplete,
as evfdenced by d i r e c t e r p r i m n t e'e-
+-n'n
(showing mainly t h e p, w peek;
not a l a r g e badrground and n o t much e l s e resonant has been found t o q2 and by t h e f i t of constants f pnn
"^
L
gO.
4 ~ e ~ '
(This w i l l be discussed f u r t h e r i n
l e c t u r e 24, i n reference t o t h e cfispersim Cheory of t h e pion f o m f a c t o r , ) F i n a l l y mrirarpurements e x i s t on n u c l e t f o r phseon produetion of Incsherent po(-t
" 0.1
+, .n-
GeV) aa w e l l as f a r production of o t h e r p a r t i c l e s such a s n 4-
m z a d even w0 ( a l s o Ii ). Were t h e theory is complicated By a n m b e r of f e a t u r e s
such a8 t h e absorption of t h e p a r t i c l e leaving t h e nucleus. p r e d i c t s rapid v a r i a t i o n s i n Aef only a small v a r i a t i o n , i f any,
The W M theory
WSt f t energy, &ereas e x p e r i m n t s i n d i c a t e (See G o t t f r i e d , f t h a c a Conference (1971) and
Diebold, High Energy Physics Conference a t Boulder, A p r i l 1969). present no expfanatlon k n m f o r t h i s discrepaaey n i c e problem,
There is a t
- its study would =aka a
X doubt t h a t the f a c t t h a t t h e y couples only p a r t i a l l y t o VDM
is s u f f i c i e n t t o account f o r t h e l a r g e discrepaxlcy, these incoherent f f n a l s t a t e s is prabably involved.
So= & t e a i n t h e theory of
-
Electromagnetic Form Factors
Nucleon: The rnstrix e l e m n t for the interaction of an electron, say, and a proton involves the diagonal e l e m n t of the current operator
U.
IF>.
Using
r e l a t f v i s t i c invariance and gauge invarimce t h i s can be written 2x1 the form
< P ~ I J ~ I P ~ ' (;21~M~l
+
l
( Y ~ ~ ~ Y ~ ) P ~ I ~ ~ >
where uf u2 a r e S-sginors describing 'the i n and out: proton 0f w m n t a pl, p2 rnolarentunt
transfer q
p2
- pl.
2
F1 and F2 are functions of q only, Other
linear coxnbinatfons of PI and F2 h w e also been defined,
lnost
w e d a r e (the
so-ealled eliectric and aragnetlc f o m factors)
clearly a s q2
+
O PI i s the charge:
Fl procon(0)
and Fe are the anoraalous m m e t i c m m n t a ,
GM(Ol
-
pp
l, PI neutron(0)
Hence GE(0)
-
O
l f o r p, O f o r n
is the t o t a l nagnetic ooment.
Ttrese have been masured by scatterdng electrons from proton@ @ i a s t i c a l l y .
The f i r s t order amplitude is
(Gk,
uj a r e electron spfnorsl
l14
Electromagnetic Form Factors 4 ne
2
The cross s e c t i o n a r i s i n g from t h i s is:
m
lab
P
By varying both .E
m d 0 we can vary q
2
and 8 hdependently, and thus
v e r i f y whether the bracket i n (22.2) does vary l i n e a r l y v i t h tanZ (812) f o r 2 fixed q , It: works well, s o both GE and C& can be extracted f o r the proton.
Data f o r GM i s m r e accurate than GE