PLANT BREEDING REVIEWS Volume 23
Plant Breeding Reviews is sponsored by: American Society for Horticultural Science Crop Science Society of America Society of American Foresters National Council of Commercial Plant Breeders
Editorial Board, Volume 23 M. Gilbert I. L. Goldman C. H. Michler
PLANT BREEDING REVIEWS Volume 23
edited by
Jules Janick Purdue University
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Copyright © 2003 by John Wiley & Sons. All rights reserved. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey Published simultaneously in Canada No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 750-4470, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008, e-mail:
[email protected]. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services or for technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at (800) 762-2974, outside the United States at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317) 572-4002.
Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: ISBN: 0-471-35421-X ISSN: 0730-2207 Printed in the United States of America 10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
Contents List of Contributors 1. Dedication: Dermot P. Coyne Bean Breeder, Geneticist, Humanitarian
vii 1
James R. Steadman and Jules Janick
2. Strategies for Genetic Improvement of Common Bean and Rhizobia Towards Efficient Interactions
21
Carla Snoeck, Jos Vanderleyden, and Stephen Beebe I. Rhizobium-Common Bean Symbiosis II. Bean Breeding III. Selection of Optimized Rhizobium Strains for Bean Inoculation IV. Conclusions and Future Prospects Literature Cited
3. Developing Marker-Assisted Selection Strategies for Breeding Hybrid Rice
22 26 36 53 58
73
Yunbi Xu I. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. X. XI.
Introduction Features of Hybrid Breeding Components of Marker-Assisted Selection Germplasm Evaluation Traits Requiring Testcrossing or Progeny Testing Environment-Dependent Traits Quality Traits Gene Introgression and Whole Genome Selection Prediction of Hybrid Performance and Heterosis Seed Quality Assurance General Discussions Literature Cited
75 77 81 90 99 107 112 117 125 147 151 156 v
vi
CONTENTS
4. Significance of Cytoplasmic DNA in Plant Breeding
175
Ursula Frei, Edmundo G. Peiretti, and Gerhard Wenzel I. Introduction II. Some Basic Information on DNA in the Cytoplasm of Plants III. Agronomic Traits Influenced by Cytoplasmic Factors IV. Breeding Using Cytoplasmic Factors V. Conclusion Literature Cited
5. Flowering, Seed Production, and the Genesis of Garlic Breeding
176 177 179 187 201 203
211
Philipp W. Simon and Maria M. Jenderek I. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII.
Introduction Garlic Production Trends Garlic Taxonomy and Genetic Variation Garlic Growth and Reproductive Biology Garlic Seed Production Progress in Garlic Breeding and Future Prospects Conclusions Literature Cited
6. Cultivar Development of Ornamental Foliage Plants
211 212 215 218 227 235 239 240
245
Richard J. Henny and Jianjun Chen I. II. III. IV. V. VI.
Introduction Origin of New Cultivars Breeding Techniques Breeding Objectives Foliage Examples Future Prospects Literature Cited
246 248 255 260 267 281 283
CONTENTS
7. Preservation of Genetic Resources in the National Plant Germplasm Clonal Collections
vii
291
Gayle M. Volk and Christina Walters I. Introduction II. Clones as Genetic Resources III. Maintenance of Genetic Diversity in Clonal Collections IV. Clonal Collections in the NPGS V. Cryopreservation Principles VI. Cryopreservation: Variables to Consider VII. Application of Cryopreservation Technologies to Vegetative Materials VIII. Conclusions Literature Cited
292 294 302 308 314 319 328 332 333
Subject Index
345
Cumulative Subject Index
347
Cumulative Contributor Index
363
List of Contributors Beebe, Stephen, Centro International de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT), A. A. 6713, Cali, Colombia Chen, Jianjun, University of Florida, IFAS, Mid-Florida Research and Education Center (MREC), Apopka, FL 32703,
[email protected] Frei, Ursula, Department of Agronomy and Plant Breeding, Center for Life and Food Sciences, Technical University of Munich, D-85350 FreisingWeihenstephan, Germany Henny, Richard J., University of Florida, IFAS, Mid-Florida Research and Education Center (MREC), Apopka, FL 32703,
[email protected] Janick, Jules, Department of Horticulture and Landscape Architecture, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47904-2010,
[email protected] Jenderek, Maria M., National Arid Land Plant Genetic Resource Unit, United States Department of Agriculture—Agricultural Research Service, San Joaquin Valley Agricultural Science Center, Parlier, CA 93648 Peiretti, Edmundo G., Department of Agronomy and Plant Breeding, Center for Life and Food Sciences, Technical University of Munich, D-85350 FreisingWeihenstephan, Germany Simon, Philipp W., Vegetable Crops Research Unit, United States Department of Agriculture—Agricultural Research Service, Department of Horticulture, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI, 53706 Snoeck, Carla, Centre of Microbial and Plant Genetics (CMPG), Department of Applied Plant Sciences, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Kasteelpark Arenberg 20, B-3001 Heverlee, Belgium,
[email protected] Steadman, James R., Department of Plant Pathology, University of Nebraska– Lincoln, Lincoln, NE 68583-0722,
[email protected] Vanderleyden, Jos, Centre of Microbial and Plant Genetics (CMPG), Department of Applied Plant Sciences, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Kasteelpark Arenberg 20, B-3001 Heverlee, Belgium,
[email protected] Volk, Gayle M., National Center for Genetic Resources Preservation, United States Department of Agriculture—Agricultural Research Service, 1111 S. Mason Street, Fort Collins, CO 80521,
[email protected] Walters, Christina, National Center for Genetic Resources Preservation, United States Department of Agriculture—Agricultural Research Service, 1111 S. Mason Street, Fort Collins, CO 80521 Wenzel, Gerhard, Department of Agronomy and Plant Breeding, Center for Life and Food Sciences, Technical University of Munich, D-85350 FreisingWeihenstephan, Germany,
[email protected] Xu, Yunbi, RiceTec, Inc., P.O. Box 1305, Austin, TX 77512. Present address: Department of Plant Breeding, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853-1901.
[email protected] ix
Dermot P. Coyne
1 Dedication: Dermot P. Coyne Bean Breeder, Geneticist, Humanitarian James R. Steadman Department of Plant Pathology University of Nebraska–Lincoln Lincoln, Nebraska 68583-0722 Jules Janick Department of Horticulture and Landscape Architecture Purdue University West Lafayette, IN 47907-1165 Volume 23 of Plant Breeding Reviews is dedicated to the brilliant career of Dermot Patrick Coyne, who tragically passed away on April 12, 2002, following complications from treatment of hepatitis while this review was being prepared. It is some consolation for us that Dermot was aware of this dedication and, in his quiet way, expressed pleasure with this recognition. Dermot was an inspired and talented plant breeder who devoted his life to the improvement of beans for the farmers of Nebraska and the world. He was intensely concerned with the task of making progress to achieve genetic improvement of crops. Dermot was a kind and gentle man who loved life. His loss was unexpected and he will be sorely missed by family, friends, students, colleagues, and by the many farmers in the Americas and Africa whom he tried to help and the billions of poor people of the world whom he strove to assist.
Plant Breeding Reviews, Volume 23, Edited by Jules Janick ISBN 0-471-35421-X © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 1
2
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH Dermot was born on July 4, 1929, in Dublin, Ireland. A defining event in his life was his mother’s death when he was nine and his subsequent entry into foster care in a rural part of Ireland. A scared and grieving little boy was introduced to plants under the gentle care and guidance of Mrs. Margaret Edwards. After his father remarried when he was 11, he returned to Dublin but never forgot all that Mrs. Edwards had taught him. He took pleasure in growing vegetables to feed his family during the food shortages of World War II. He identified and spent time visiting with the neighborhood’s best gardeners, read all he could about vegetable production, and put to practice in his own garden what he learned. He always knew what it was like to be poor and to live on a farm. He held farmers in high esteem and knew that they had wisdom even when they lacked science. During 1947–1948, he completed a oneyear course in general horticulture at Johnstown Agricultural College in Wexford, and in 1948–1949 he received training at the National Botanic Gardens in Dublin. He received a Senior Certificate in Horticulture from the Royal Horticulture Society in England, and dreamed of heading a botanical garden. In 1949, he attended University College Dublin on a scholarship, and received a Bachelor in Agricultural Science in 1953 with first class honors. He captained the university field hockey team and was selected for the Irish international university team. Graduating first in his class won him the only graduate scholarship available, and he went on to receive a Masters in Agricultural Science in horticulture in 1954. In that year he obtained a research assistantship at Cornell under the tutelage of Dr. Henry M. Munger in the Department of Plant Breeding and Vegetable Crops and received the Ph.D. degree in 1958. It was there that Dermot discovered the passion for his life’s work. His first job after graduation was with the International Division of the Campbell Soup Co., in Kings Lynn, Norfolk, England, where he was assistant manager of agriculture research from 1958–1960. In late 1960, he returned to the United States, where he accepted a position at the University of Nebraska–Lincoln, in the Department of Horticulture and Forestry. He served as acting head in the Horticulture Department from 1974–1975 and in 1986 was awarded the George Holmes Regents Professorship, which he retained until his retirement in June 2001. He continued to work one-quarter time until his tragic illness. Dermot married Ann Gaffey, who was his beloved wife for nearly 45 years. Ann remains active in social change as professor in the School of Social Work at the University of Nebraska at Omaha. Together they raised six amazing children.
1. DEDICATION: D. P. COYNE
3
RESEARCH ACHIEVEMENT Bean Program Dermot made his first discovery in 1961 when he arrived in Scottsbluff, Nebraska, to observe the fields of great northern bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). He noticed late-maturing rogue plants with resistance to common bacterial blight in the susceptible cultivar Nebraska #1 and used one of the selections, coded as 27, to incorporate bacterial blight resistance into his breeding lines. These lines were used widely in the bean-growing regions of the United States and throughout the Americas as a source of common blight resistance. Originally he and other bean breeders believed the resistance came from the tepary bean (Phaseolus acutifolius) that had been crossed with ‘Montana #5’ (Phaseolus vulgaris) to produce Nebraska #1. In the last few years, the origin of this resistance was in doubt. To address that uncertainty, Dermot was part of a team that used molecular mapping data to demonstrate that the origin of common blight resistance was ‘Montana #5’, not the tepary bean. Dermot’s career studies into the genetics of resistance to bacterial pathogens in common bean culminated in major impacts on bean production in Nebraska as well as Africa and the Americas. At one time, the cultivars he developed occupied 60% of the bean crop area of Nebraska. Dermot was a keen observer and spent an enormous amount of time in his plots. He demonstrated the quantitative inheritance and low heritability of common blight resistance. He found that resistance was associated with late flowering, a problem in temperate regions. These revelations kept many bean breeders on the sideline for incorporating blight resistance into their breeding lines as they concentrated on more highly heritable traits. But Dermot persisted on the problem of improving resistance to blight. He made the crucial discovery that bean pods and leaves react differently to both the common blight and halo blight pathogens, which meant that selection for resistance must be made on both organs. Dermot published pioneering work on the effect of photoperiodism and temperature responses on the reaction to common blight. The late flowering of Nebraska #1 selection 27 was due to photoperiodic response under long days and was influenced by temperature. Genetic control was by major genes. Don Wallace later conducted more detailed analysis on these same photoperiod/temperature responses on bean yields. In collaborative work with scientists at CIAT (Centro Internacional Agricultura Tropical), common blight resistance sources from temperate regions such as Selection 27 were found to be susceptible in the tropics. Dermot showed that daylength affects reaction to common blight with both
4
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
tropical and temperate lines and that resistance that functioned under long days did not function under short days. Dermot had a number of productive collaborations in plant pathology. Working with M. L. Schuster and later A. K. Vidaver, he began combining resistance to four bacterial diseases of bean [common blight (Xanthomonas campestris pv. phaseoli), halo blight (Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola), brown spot (Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae), and wilt (Curtobacterium flaccumfaciens pv. flaccumfaciens)] even though the genetic mechanisms for resistance were complex. Dermot’s first releases in the late 1960s and early 1970s (Table 1.1) had high levels of common blight resistance and high yield potential, but were late. In a Plant Introduction he found resistance to three strains of the bacterial wilt pathogen and through transgressive segregation for earliness and backcrossing with Nebraska #1 selection 27 combined resistance to wilt, common blight, halo blight, and bean common mosaic to produce the great northern cultivar ‘Star’. Dermot also developed the wilt and common blight resistant ‘Emerson’, which is still used for specialty markets desiring a large, bright, white-seeded bean. In the middle phase of his career, Dermot addressed two increasing disease problems on the U.S. high plains: white mold (Sclerotinia scleTable 1.1. Release
Bean releases of Dermot Coyne and cooperators. Year
Attributesz
Dry Beans—Nebraska and Great Plains Great Northern (GN) Tara 1969 First GN with resistance to CBB, HB, BS, BCM GN Jules 1970 Resistant to CBB, HB, BS GN Emerson 1971 Moderate resistance to CBB and BW and large attractive seed GN Valley 1974 Resistant to CBB, HB, BS GN Star 1976 Resistant to CBB, BW, BCM, HB, BS GN Harris (PVP) 1980 Resistant to CBB, BCM Small White Monument 1985 Early, upright plant, resistant to BCM GN Starlight (PVP) 1990 Resistant to CBB, rust and with good avoidance of WM; bright white seed GN BelNeb-1, -2 1989 Released in cooperation with J. R. Stavely (USDA); resistant to CBB, HB, BS, rust (3 genes) and BCM GN-BELMINEB-1, -2 1993 Released in cooperation with J. R. Stavely (USDA); J. Kelly (MI); resistant to rust (2 genes) and BCM Pinto Chase 1993 First pinto with resistance to the bacterial diseases CBB, BS, HB, rust and with good avoidance of WM. Also high yielding. GN Weihing 1998 First GN bean with resistance to CBB, HB, BS, rust (2 genes), and BCM
1. DEDICATION: D. P. COYNE Table 1.1.
5
(continued)
Release
Year
Attributesz
GN BELMINEB-RMR-3
1996
GN BELMINEB-4, -5
1998
Resistant to all rust races and BCM strains in U.S. (released in cooperation with J. R. Stavely, USDA and J. Kelly, MI). Resistant to all rust races (3 genes) and BCM strains in U.S. (released in cooperation with J. R. Stavely, USDA and J. Kelly, MI).
Dry Beans—USAID-Bean/Cowpea CRSPy Arroyo Loro #1 1983 Resistant to rust in DR/PR, white seed PC-50 1987 Resistant to rust (adult plant and specific resistance); red mottled seed Anacaona 1993 Partial resistance to WB and resistance to rust; white seed Negro Sureno 1987 Developed with J. Kelly, MI; DR adapted black seed JB-178 1998 Resistant to some rust races in DR; good yielding; red mottled seed Arroyo Loro Negro 1998 Partial resistance to WB; black seed CIAS-95 1998 Resistant to some rust races in DR; red mottled seed Saladin-97 1998 Resistant to some rust races in DR; red mottled seed Winter Squash Butternut Ponca 1976 Stable fruit shape Butternut Patriot 1976 Stable fruit shape Near-Hubbard Lakota 1992 Novel decorative type Butter Bowl 1997 First novel near-oblate butternut squash for microwaving z CBB = common bacterial blight disease; BW = bacterial wilt; HB = halo blight; BS = brown spot; BCM = bean common mosaic; WB = web blight; WM = white mold y Cooperative releases: Universities of Nebraska & Puerto Rico (PR) and Secretary of Agriculture Dominican Republic (DR)
rotiorum) and rust (Uromyces appendiculatus). A Venezuelan graduate student of Dermot’s wanted to use a local black bean cultivar, ‘Tacaragua’, in his research project. When this cultivar was grown in the Scottsbluff breeding nursery, Dermot noticed that the ‘Tacaragua’ bean had low levels of white mold compared to the local pinto and great northern bean lines and cultivars. He demonstrated that hybrids with great northern and pinto lines resulted in germplasm that avoided severe white mold under conditions that favored the disease. Collaborations with J. R. Steadman and with K. G. Hubbard and a graduate student made it possible to define white mold disease avoidance microclimatology. He established that ‘Tacaragua’ contained a gene for rust resistance that is
6
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
still effective on the high plains and north central U.S. bean-growing areas. As a result of a long-term, non-structured, recurrent-selection program, Dermot accomplished what few, if any, bean breeders had achieved: He combined resistance to six major diseases plus avoidance to another disease, with high yield and high seed quality in pinto and great northern cultivars and lines. He further collaborated with USDA scientists and combined resistance to four diseases and pyramided three separate rust resistance genes in elite great northern germplasm containing high seed quality. Bean seed quality was an issue that attracted Dermot’s interest throughout his career. As he had done while tackling disease resistance, Dermot performed basic genetic research on seed coat color and integrity. Although the black seeded ‘Tacaragua’ provided rust and white mold resistance, it brought undesirable seed coat colors to derived pinto lines. Recently, Dermot was able to break the linkage with seed coat yellowing to produce pinto lines with multiple disease resistance and good seed quality. The Nebraska great northern lines and cultivars that he developed (‘Starlight’, ‘Emerson’, and ‘Weihing’) were renowned for their high seed quality. As breeding and genetics moved to the molecular age, Dermot responded by upgrading his laboratory to incorporate gene mapping and molecular markers. Together with his graduate students and postdoctorals, he developed the first RAPD (random amplified polymorphic DNA) molecular map of bean that included quantitative trait loci for resistance to five bean diseases (Table 1.2). Using these maps, he confirmed the genetic relationships established earlier in his career through traditional crossing and statistical analyses. He also was able to demonstrate that adult plant rust resistance and abaxial leaf pubescence, once thought to be linked, were on different linkage groups. During the last two years in one of his final projects, he tackled a longtime goal to improve levels of common bacterial blight resistance so that seed transmission would be negligible and seed production would be feasible for Nebraska bean growers. With his last graduate student, Dermot used classical backcross breeding and SCAR (sequence characterized amplified region) markers for confirming resistance in the process of pyramiding common blight resistance from different bean sources. In 2002, lines in the field with superior common blight resistance were incorporated in agronomically elite pinto or great northern background, a realization of Dermot’s lifelong dream. Dermot Coyne relished the intellectual side of science, but his bottom line was to have a useful product for the poor and malnourished throughout the world. It was appropriate that Dermot chose to spend
Table 1.2. Mapping of quantitative trait loci and genes for disease resistance with RAPD molecular markers in recombinant inbred lines (RIL) of several bean crosses.
Pathogen
Linkage groups (LGs)
Disease
Cross for RIL
Xanthomonas campestris pv. phaseoli (bacterium) Thanatephorus cucumeris (fungus) Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola (bacterium) Uromyces appendiculatus (fungus)
Common blight
BAC6(R)* HT7719(S)*
B7, B10
Jung et al. 1996
Web blight
Xan-159(R)/PC-50(S)
B6, B8
Jung et al. 1996
Halo blight
Belneb RR-1 (R)/A55 (S)
B2, B3, B4, B5, B9, B10
Ariyarathne et al. 1999
Rust
PC-50 (R)/Xan-159 (S)
Jung et al. 1996
Sclerotinia sclerotiorum (fungus)
White mold
PC-50 (R)/Xan-159 (S)
B9—specific race resistance B2—adult plant resistance B10—abaxial leaf trichomes B4, B7, B8
*R = resistant; S = susceptible
Reference
Park et al. 2001
7
8
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
most of his career working with the common bean, the most important food legume in the world from a production, consumption, nutrition, and socioeconomic standpoint. Because of its dual origins in the Andes of South America and Mexico, the common bean has been a staple in the diets of people in the Americas. Beans are a cash crop for all of the Americas. In the United States, the annual farm gate value of dry beans is $700 million, with a commercial value of $900 million for the canning and freezing sector. R. Perrin, an agricultural economist, published a unique study that estimated $5 million for the value of Dermot’s rust-resistant pinto ‘Chase’ during its five-year commercial life in the United States. Dermot’s work directly impacted bean growers in the Midwest and in the Dominican Republic and his legacy will live on through the germplasm that he created. Squash Program Dermot also had a successful squash breeding program. He produced two butternut types that provided stable fruit shape of a straight neck while retaining desirable horticultural qualities. He recently released a novel round butternut squash that could be cooked in a microwave. Always the observant breeder and history buff, Dermot grew out some ‘Hubbard’ squash seeds he obtained from descendants of pioneers in northwestern Nebraska near Fort Robinson. These seeds, traced to Native Americans nearly 200 years ago, provided soldiers with fruits whose flesh contained a rich source of Vitamin C to prevent scurvy. While the fruits no longer resembled the original descriptions, probably as a result of outcrossing, some of the fruits had decorative markings and through breeding and “reverse” selection, developed and released a one-of-a-kind cultivar with excellent cooking quality and decorative fruit surface features (orange, green, and combinations of both colors), resembling the original type. He also produced a large, elongated squash with unique color markings that is very similar to the squash grown by native Americans. This line should be of interest to the increasingly popular heritage seed industry.
CAREER Dermot’s career combined scientific curiosity and practical breeding that resulted in outstanding contributions to bean production in Nebraska and the world. A prolific writer, he authored or coauthored 160 journal articles, 8 book chapters, 350 abstracts/research notes, and 75
1. DEDICATION: D. P. COYNE
9
other publications. He was a caring nurturer to his graduate students. He believed in the generational connections in science. In his office was a picture of the famous geneticist R. A. Emerson, who happened to be a dry bean breeder at Nebraska from 1899 to 1914. Emerson moved to Cornell University and had among his graduate students Nobel Laureates George Beadle, a Nebraska native, and Barbara McClintock. Emerson’s last graduate student was H. M. Munger, who was Dermot’s mentor during his doctoral studies at Cornell. Dermot felt strongly that the research philosophy that he attempted to pass on to his students had been shaped by Munger and Emerson. Dermot took a great interest in the 43 graduate students he guided during his 42-year career. “There’s a great multiplier effect with graduate students,” he told an interviewer, “and great pleasure in seeing them develop, mature and accomplish great things in their careers.” His students came from Africa, Asia, Europe, the Middle East, and throughout the Americas. Dermot enjoyed learning something of the culture and background of each student. His students won many awards, including the Asgrow and Marion Meadow Publication Awards of the America Society for Horticultural Science (ASHS) and the Sigma Xi Distinguished Graduate Student Award. Many achieved eminence in their own right. In recognition of his dedication and success, Dermot received the ASHS Graduate Educator Award in 1998. Dermot’s commitment to graduate students was also reflected in his long-term membership in and chairing of the Horticulture Department’s Graduate Program Committee and his excellent course in Horticultural Plant Breeding. Dermot took his membership in the academic community seriously and was a quiet intervener. On one of his early committee assignments, he was asked to render a decision on an academic freedom issue resulting from on campus strikes and protests related to the Vietnam War. Although this was a difficult task, he continued to accept similar assignments dealing with academic freedom and citizenship. He was also frequently called upon for inspiration and insight into the future of a department, college, or university. Although these duties were somewhat disruptive to his research, he felt it was an important part of academic citizenship. In fact, he served in such a conscientious, courageous, and committed manner that the University of Nebraska–Lincoln Academic Senate bestowed upon him the James Lake Academic Freedom Award for “acts which support, defend, explain and apply in practice the principles of academic freedom.” Dermot’s citizenship carried over to ASHS, the professional society in which he served as president in 1985. He was president of the Nebraska Chapter of Sigma Xi, president of the Nebraska Chapter of the American
10
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
Association of University Professors (AAUP), and president of the International Bean Improvement Cooperative. Dermot was a believer in the land-grant university system and told his ASHS colleagues in his ASHS Presidential Address that Our U.S. foreign aid and university administrators would do well where they can to propagate the merits of the land-grant system and education for all. The United States rose from an underdeveloped to the most developed country on Earth through this process! The European system of separate higher education, research and extension systems in agriculture, which have been adopted in many developing countries, are not satisfactory organizational models to deal with the current needs for broad-based agricultural improvements.
In an interview given after retiring from full-time to quarter-time status, Dermot noted that university research and public plant breeding face enormous change. With less federal and public funds, scientists increasingly compete for larger basic research grants. “I think we need to maintain a better balance between fundamental science and the type of (applied) research that seeks to enhance rural communities and is compatible with good management of our natural resources,” he said. He told the interviewer he expected future research success to be measured almost exclusively by grants and publications, but cautioned, “There’s much more to being a land-grant scientist than that.” Awards and Honors During his long, productive career, Dermot Coyne received many awards, including Fellow of the American Society of Agronomy, Crop Science Society of America, and ASHS. The outstanding researcher/scientist awards from ASHS, Gamma Sigma Delta, Sigma Xi, the Nebraska Legislature, and the University of Nebraska attest to the impact of his research career. As a result of over 20 years as Principal Investigator of a USAID Bean/Cowpea Collaborative Research Support Program, Dermot was presented with the End of Hunger Award by US Mayors on World Food Day. He was proud of his role in the Dominican Republic’s transformation from a net bean importer to self-sufficiency in bean production in the late 1990s. For this role, he and his colleagues received an award from the Agricultural Producers Association in the Dominican Republic for contributions to the development of agriculture and scientific collaboration contributing to bean production progress. He was the inaugural recipient of the Frazier-Zaumeyer Distinguished Lectureship Award from his bean colleagues.
1. DEDICATION: D. P. COYNE
11
Dermot Coyne was a thoughtful, caring human being with a delightful personality, a charming presence, and a wry sense of humor. His life and career remains an inspiration for plant breeders, horticulturists, pathologists, and crop scientists.
PUBLICATIONS OF DERMOT P. COYNE Journal Articles Coyne, D. P. 1962. Chemical and physiological changes in celery in relation to pithiness. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 8:341–346. Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster and S. Al-Yasiri. 1963. Reaction studies of bean species and varieties to common blight and bacterial wilt. Plant Dis. Rptr. 47:534–537. Coyne, D. P., and J. L. Serrano. 1963. Diurnal variations of soluble solids, carbohydrates and respiration rate of drought tolerant and susceptible bean species and varieties. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 83:453–460. Coyne, D. P. 1964. Species hybridization in Phaseolus. J. Hered. 55:5–6. Al-Yasiri, S., and D. P. Coyne. 1964. Effect of growth regulators in delaying pod abscission and embryo abortion in the interspecific cross Phaseolus vulgaris × P. acutifolius. Crop Sci. 4:433–435. Schuster, M. L., D. P. Coyne, and Kamla Singh. 1964. Population trends and movement of Corynebacterium flaccumfaciens var. aurantiacum in tolerant and susceptible beans. Plant Dis. Rptr. 48:823–827. Coyne, D. P., and R. G. Mattson. 1964. Inheritance of time of flowering and length of blooming period in Phaseolus vulgaris. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 85:366–373. Coyne, D. P. 1965. Component interaction in relation to heterosis for plant height in Phaseolus vulgaris variety crosses. Crop Sci. 5:17–18. Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster, and L. Harris. 1965. Inheritance, heritability and response to selection for common blight tolerance in Phaseolus vulgaris field bean crosses. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 86:373–379. Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster, and J. O. Young. 1965. A genetic study of bacterial wilt (Corynebacterium flaccumfaciens var. aurantiacum) tolerance in Phaseolus vulgaris crosses and the development of tolerance to two bacterial diseases in beans. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 87:279–285. Coyne, D. P. 1965. A genetic study of crippled morphology resembling virus symptoms in Phaseolus vulgaris L. J. Hered. 56:164. Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster, and L. W. Estes. 1966. Effect of maturity and environment on the genetic control of reaction to wilt bacterium in Phaseolus vulgaris L. crosses. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 88:393–399. Al-Yasiri, Salih Aziz, and D. P. Coyne. 1966. Interspecific hybridization in the genus Phaseolus. Crop Sci. 6:59–60. Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster, and Lyle Shaughnessey. 1966. Inheritance of reaction to halo blight and common blight bacteria in a Phaseolus vulgaris variety cross. Plant Dis. Rptr. 50:29–32. Coyne, D. P. 1966. A mutable gene system in Phaseolus vulgaris L. Crop Sci. 6:307–310. Coyne, D. P. 1966. The genetics of photoperiodism and the effect of temperature on the photoperiodic response for time of flowering in Phaseolus vulgaris L. varieties. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 89:350–360.
12
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster, and Robert Fast. 1967. Sources of tolerance and reaction of beans to races and strains of halo blight bacteria. Plant Dis. Rptr. 51:20–24. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1967. A source of tolerance and reaction of tomato species and varieties to bacterial spot pathogen. Plant Dis. Rptr. 51:25–28. Coyne, D. P., and R. Mattson. 1967. Inheritance of pod maturity in a Phaseolus vulgaris L. variety cross. Crop Sci. 7:398–399. Coyne, D. P. 1967. A test to detect a mutator or unstable gene in Phaseolus vulgaris L. J. Hered. 58:146–147. Coyne, D. P. 1967. Some correlation studies in asparagus as related to cumulative season yield. Hort. Res. 7:105–112. Coyne, D. P. 1967. Photoperiodism. Inheritance and linkage studies in Phaseolus vulgaris L. J. Hered. 58:313–314. Coyne, D. P. 1968. Differential effect of soil moisture levels on style elongation in some tomato varieties. HortScience 3:39. Coyne, D. P. 1968. Correlation, heritability and selection of yield components in field beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 93:388–396. Coyne, D. P. 1969. Effect of growth regulators on time of flowering of a photoperiodic sensitive field bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). HortScience 4:100–101. Coyne, D. P. 1969. Breeding behavior and effects of temperature on expression of a variegated rogue in green beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 94:488–491. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1969. Moderate tolerance of bean varieties to brown spot bacterium (Pseudomonas syringae). Plant Dis. Rptr. 53:677–680. Coyne, D. P. 1970. The genetic control of a photoperiod–temperature response for time of flowering in beans. Crop Sci. 10:246–248. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1970. ‘Jules’, a Great Northern dry bean variety tolerant to common blight bacterium (Xanthomonas phaseoli). Plant Dis. Rptr. 54:557–559. Coyne, D. P. 1970. Inheritance of mottle-leaf in Cucurbita moschata Poir. HortScience 5:226–227. Coyne, D. P. 1970. Effect of 2-chlorethylphosphonic acid on sex expression and yield in Butternut squash and its usefulness in producing hybrid squash. HortScience 5:227–228. Arp, Gregory, D. P. Coyne, and M. L. Schuster. 1971. Disease reaction of bean varieties to Xanthomonas phaseoli and Xanthomonas phaseoli var. fuscans using two inoculation methods. Plant Dis. Rptr. 55:577–579. Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster, and Cesar C. Gallegos B. 1971. Inheritance and linkage of the halo blight systemic chlorosis and leaf water-soaked reaction in Phaseolus vulgaris crosses. Plant Dis. Rptr. 55:203–206. Schuster, M. L., and D. P. Coyne. 1971. New virulent strains of Xanthomonas phaseoli. Plant Dis. Rptr. 55:505–506. Coyne, D. P. 1971. A new procedure to develop hybrid Butternut squash relatively stable for fruit shape. Hort. Res. 11:183–187. Hill, K., D. P. Coyne, and M. L. Schuster. 1972. Leaf, pod, and systemic chlorosis reactions in Phaseolus vulgaris to halo blight controlled by different genes. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 97:494–498. Augustin, E., D. P. Coyne, and M. L. Schuster. 1972. Inheritance of resistance in Phaseolus vulgaris to Uromyces phaseoli typica Brazilian rust race B11 and of plant habit. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 96:526–529. Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster, and K. Hill. 1973. Genetic control of reaction to common blight bacterium in bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) as influenced by plant age and bacterial multiplication. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 98:94–99.
1. DEDICATION: D. P. COYNE
13
Schuster, M. L., D. P. Coyne, and B. Hoff. 1973. Comparative virulence of Xanthomonas phaseoli strains from Uganda, Colombia and Nebraska. Plant Dis. Rptr. 57:74–75. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1973. Phaseolus germ plasm tolerant to Xanthomonas phaseoli bacterium. Plant Dis. Rptr. 57:111–114. Ibrahim, A. M., D. P. Coyne, R. C. Lommasson, and E. Davies. 1973. Orientation, anatomical and breeding behavior studies of the Crookneck rogue fruit in Butternut squash. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 98:576–580. Steadman, J. R., D. P. Coyne, and G. E. Cook. 1973. Reduction of severity of white mold disease on Great Northern beans by inter-row spacing and determinate plant growth habit. Plant Dis. Rptr. 57:1070–1071. Schuster, M. L., and D. P. Coyne. 1974. Survival mechanisms of phytopathogenic bacteria. Annu. Rev. Phytopath. 12:199–221. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1974. Breeding and genetic studies of tolerance to several bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) bacterial pathogens. Euphytica 23:651–656. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1974. Inheritance and linkage relations of reaction to Xanthomonas phaseoli (common blight), stage of plant development and plant habit in Phaseolus vulgaris L. Euphytica 23:195–204. Coyne, D. P., M. L. Schuster, and S. Magnuson. 1974. Differential reaction of pods and foliage of beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) to Xanthomonas phaseoli. Plant Dis. Rptr. 58:278–282. Coyne, D. P., J. R. Steadman, and F. N. Anderson. 1974. Effect of modified plant architecture on dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) on white mold severity and yield. Plant Dis. Rptr. 58:379–382. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1974. ‘Great Northern Valley’ dry bean. HortScience 9:482. Anderson, F. M., J. R. Steadman, D. P. Coyne, and H. F. Schwartz. 1974. Tolerance to white mold in Phaseolus vulgaris dry bean edible types. Plant Dis. Rptr. 58:782–784. Schuster, M. L., and D. P. Coyne. 1975. Genetic variation in bean bacterial pathogens. Euphytica 24:143–147. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1975. Genetic and breeding strategy for resistance to rust (Uromyces phaseoli (Reben) Wint) in beans (Phaseolus vulgaris). Euphytica 24:795–803. Ibrahim, A. M., and D. P. Coyne. 1975. Genetics of stigma shape, cotyledon position, and flower color in reciprocal crosses between Phaseolus vulgaris L. and Phaseolus coccineus (Lam.) and implications in breeding. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 100:622–626. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1976. ‘Great Northern Star’ dry bean tolerant to bacterial diseases. HortScience 11:621. Coyne, D. P. 1976. ‘Butternut Ponca’ squash. HortScience 11:617. Coyne, D. P., and Robert M. Hill. 1976. ‘Butternut Patriot’ squash. HortScience 11:617–618. Coyne, D. P., and J. R. Steadman, and H. F. Schwartz. 1977. Reaction of Phaseolus dry bean germ plasm to Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Plant Dis. Rptr. 61:226–230. Coyne, D. P., and J. R. Steadman. 1977. Inheritance and association of some traits in a Phaseolus vulgaris L. cross. J. Hered. 68:60–62. Coyne, D. P., J. R. Steadman, and H. F. Schwartz. 1977. Effect of genetic blends of dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) of different plant architecture on apothecia production of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum and white mold infection. Euphytica 27:225–231. Schwartz, H. F., J. R. Steadman, and D. P. Coyne. 1977. Influence of Phaseolus vulgaris blossoming characteristics and canopy structure upon reaction to Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Phytopathology 68:465–470. Schuster, M. L., and D. P. Coyne. 1977. Supervivencia de patogenos bacterioles de plantas en el tropico con enfasis en frijol (Phaseolus vulgaris). Fitopath. Colombiana 6(2):101–111.
14
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
Schuster, M. L., and D. P. Coyne. 1977. Characterization and variation of Xanthomonas and Corynebacterium incited diseases of beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Fitopath. Brasileira 2:199–209. Schuster, M. L., and D. P. Coyne. 1977. Survival of plant parasitic bacteria of plants grown in the tropics with emphasis on beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Fitopath. Brasileira 2:117–130. Coyne, D. P. 1978. Genetics of flowering in dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 103:606–608. Hulluka, M., M. L. Schuster, J. L. Weihing, and D. P. Coyne. 1978. Population trends of Corynebacterium flaccumfaciens strains in leaves of Phaseolus species. Fitopath. Brasileira 3:13–26. Schuster, M. L., D. P. Coyne, M. Hulluka, Lisa Brezina, and E. D. Kerr. 1978. Characterization of bean bacterial diseases and implications in control by breeding for resistance. Fitopath. Brasileira. III:149–161. Valladares-Sanchez, N. E., D. P. Coyne, and M. L. Schuster. 1979. Differential reaction of leaves and pods of Phaseolus germ plasm to strains of Xanthomonas phaseoli and transgressive segregation for tolerance from crosses of susceptible germ plasm. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 104:648–654. Coyne, D. P. 1979. Plant breeding and the public. Intl. Torch Mag. Spring p. 30–32. Schuster, M. L., D. P. Coyne, D. S. Nuland, and C. Christine Smith. 1980. Transmission of pathogenic Xanthomonas phaseoli in seeds of tolerant bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) cultivars. Plant Dis. Rptr. 63:955–959. Coyne, D. P. 1980. The role of genetics in vegetable improvement. Scientia Hort. 31:74–88. Coyne, D. P. 1980. Modification of plant architecture and crop yield by breeding. HortScience 15:244–247. Coyne, D. P. 1980. Horticulture and interdisciplinary research. HortScience 14:686. Coyne, D. P., David S. Nuland, M. L. Schuster, and F. N. Anderson. 1980. ‘Great Northern Harris’ dry bean. HortScience 15:531. Schuster, M. L., and D. P. Coyne. 1980. Biology, epidemiology, genetics and breeding for bacterial pathogens of Phaseolus vulgaris. Hort. Rev. 3:28–58. Al-Mukhtar, Faisal A., and D. P. Coyne. 1981. Inheritance and association of flower, ovule, seed, pod and maturity characters in dry edible beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 106:713–719. Korban, S. S., D. P. Coyne, and J. L. Weihing. 1981. Evaluation, variation and genetic control of seed-coat whiteness in dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 106:575–579. Korban, S. S., D. P. Coyne, and J. L. Weihing. 1981. Rate of water uptake and sites of water uptake in seeds of different cultivars of dry beans. HortScience 16:545–546. Korban, S. S., D. P. Coyne, J. L. Weihing, and M. A. Hanna. 1981. Testing methods, variation, morphological and genetic studies of seed-coat cracking in dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). J. Am. Soc. Hort Sci. 106:821–828. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1982. Genetics and breeding for resistance to bacterial pathogens in vegetable crops. HortScience 18:30–36. Coyne, D. P., S. S. Korban, D. Knudsen, and R. B. Clark. 1982. Inheritance of iron deficiency in crosses of dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Proc. Intl. Symp. Iron Nutrition and Interactions in Plants 5(4–7):575–585. Adeniji, A. A., and D. P. Coyne. 1982. Inheritance of resistance to trifluralin toxicity in Cucurbita moschata Poir. HortScience 16:774–775. Leyna, H. K., S. Korban, and D. P. Coyne. 1982. Changes in patterns of inheritance of flowering time of dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) in different environments. J. Hered. 73:306–308.
1. DEDICATION: D. P. COYNE
15
Valladares, N. E. Sanchez, D. P. Coyne, and R. F. Mumm. 1983. Inheritance and associations of leaf, external, and internal pod reactions to common blight bacterium in Phaseolus vulgaris L. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 108:272–278. Adeniji, A. A., and D. P. Coyne. 1983. Genetics and nature of resistance to powdery mildew in crosses of Butternut with Calabaza squash and ‘Seminole Pumpkin’. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 108(3):360–368. Schuster, M. L., D. P. Coyne, T. Behre, and H. Leyna. 1983. Sources of Phaseolus species resistance and leaf and pod differential reaction to common blight. HortScience 18:901–903. Zaiter, H. Z., and D. P. Coyne. 1984. Testing inoculation methods and sources of resistance to the halo blight bacteria (Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola) in Phaseolus vulgaris. Euphytica 33:133–141. Fuller, P. A., D. P. Coyne, and J. R. Steadman. 1984. Inter and intra-row inter-genotypic competition influences selection for avoidance to white mold disease in dry edible beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 109:567–572. Fuller, P. A., J. R. Steadman, and D. P. Coyne. 1984. Enhancement of white mold avoidance and yield in dry beans by canopy elevation. HortScience 19:78–79. Fuller, P. A., D. P. Coyne, and J. R. Steadman. 1984. Inheritance of resistance to white mold disease in a diallel cross of dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) in the field and greenhouse. Crop Sci. 24:929–933. Pierson, E. E., R. B. Clark, J. W. Maranville, and D. P. Coyne. 1984. Plant genotype differences to ferrous and total iron in emerging leaves. I. Sorghum and maize. J. Plant Nutr. 7:371–387. Pierson, E. E., R. B. Clark, D. P. Coyne, and J. W. Maranville. 1984. Plant genotype differences to ferrous and total iron in emerging leaves. II. Dry beans and soybeans. J. Plant Nutr. 7:355–369. Coyne, D. P. 1985. Tackling world hunger and malnutrition through horticultural research, graduate education, extension and management in cooperation with U.S. universities. HortScience 20:805–808. Beaver, J., C. Paniagua, D. P. Coyne, and G. Freytag. 1985. Yield stability of dry bean genotypes in the Dominican Republic. Crop Sci. 25:923–926. Zaiter, Haytham, D. P. Coyne, R. Clark, and David Nuland. 1986. Field, nutrient solution and temperature effect upon iron leaf chlorosis of dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris). J. Plant Nutr. 9:397–415. Coyne, D. P., J. R. Steadman, D. S. Nuland, and C. L. Campbell. 1986. ‘Monument’ small white dry bean. HortScience 21:542. Pierson, E. E., R. B. Clark, D. P. Coyne, and J. W. Maranville. 1986. Iron deficiency stress effects on total iron in various leaves and nutrient solution pH in sorghum and beans. J. Plant Nutr. 9:893–907. Finke, M. Luann, D. P. Coyne, and J. R. Steadman. 1986. The inheritance and association of resistance to rust, common bacterial blight, plant habit and foliar abnormalities in Phaseolus vulgaris L. Euphytica 35:969–982. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, and R. B. Clark. 1987. Genetic variation and inheritance of resistance of leaf iron-deficiency chlorosis in dry beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 112:1019– 1022. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, and R. B. Clark. 1987. Temperature, grafting method, and rootstock influence on iron-deficiency chlorosis of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 112:1023–1026. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, and R. B. Clark. 1988. Genetic variation, heritability, and selection response to iron-deficiency chlorosis in dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). J. Plant Nutr. 11:739–746.
16
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
Poe, R. R., D. P. Coyne, B. A. Swisher, and M. D. Clegg. 1988. Differential Cucurbita spp. tolerance to the herbicide trifluralin. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 113:31–35. Jimenez, J., D. P. Coyne, and F. Saladin. 1989. Imbibition, germination and cooking time of seeds of dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) stored in different containers. J. Agr. Univ. Puerto Rico 73:327–338. Jimenez, J., D. P. Coyne, and F. Anderson. 1989. Imbibition of seed of dry beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) stored under high and low temperature and relative humidity conditions. Scientia Hort. 40:91–98. Ahmed, A., and D. P. Coyne. 1989. Heritability, phenotypic correlations and associations of the common blight disease reactions in beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 114:828–833. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, A. K. Vidaver, and J. R. Steadman. 1989. Differential reaction of tepary (Phaseolus acutifolius Gray) bean lines to Xanthomonas campestris pv. phaseoli. HortScience 24:134–137. Stavely, J. R., J. R. Steadman, D. P. Coyne, and D. T. Lindgren. 1989. Belneb rust resistant –1 and –2 Great Northern dry bean germplasm. HortScience 24:400–401. Ahmed, A., D. P. Coyne, A. K. Vidaver, and K. M. Eskridge. 1989. Transmission of the common blight pathogen in bean seed. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 114:1002–1008. A. Aggour, D. P. Coyne, and A. K. Vidaver. 1989. Comparison of leaf and pod disease reactions of beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) inoculated by different methods with strains of Xanthomonas campestris pv. phaseoli (Smith) Dye. Euphytica 43:143–152. Coyne, D. P. 1989. Research and extension’s role in the future of dry bean production. HortScience 24:542–546. Clark, R. B., D. P. Coyne, W. M. Ross, and B. E. Johnson. 1990. Genetic aspects of plant resistance to iron deficiency. Intern. Plant Physiol. Congr. 2:1096–1115. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, and J. R. Steadman. 1990. Rust reaction and pubescence in Alubia beans. HortScience 25:664–665. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, and J. R. Steadman. 1990. Inheritance of abaxial leaf pubescence in beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 115:158–160. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, and J. R. Steadman. 1990. Coinoculation effects of the pathogens causing common bacterial blight, rust and bean common mosaic in Phaseolus vulgaris. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 115:319–323. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, R. B. Clark, and J. R. Steadman. 1991. Medium, pH and leaf nutrient concentration influence on rust pustule diameter on leaves of dry beans. HortScience 26:412–414. Mohamed, M. F., P. E. Read, and D. P. Coyne. 1991. In vitro response of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) cotyledonary explants to benzyladenine in the medium. Quart. Plant Growth Regulator Soc. Am. 19:19–26. Arnaud-Santana, E., E. Pena-Matos, D. P. Coyne, and A. K. Vidaver. 1991. Longevity of Xanthomonas campestris pv. phaseoli in naturally infested dry bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) debris. Plant Dis. 75:952–953. Coyne, D. P., J. R. Steadman, D. T. Lindgren, and D. S. Nuland. 1991. ‘Starlight’ Great Northern dry bean. HortScience 26:441–442. Beaver, J. S., J. R. Steadman, and D. P. Coyne. 1992. Field reaction of landrace components of red mottled beans to common bacterial blight. HortScience 27:50–51. Zaiter, H. Z., D. P. Coyne, R. B. Clark, D. T. Lindgren, D. T. Nordquist, W. W. Stroup, and L. A. Pavlish. 1992. Leaf chlorosis and seed yield of dry beans grown on high-pH calcareous soil following foliar iron sprays. HortScience 27:983–985. Mmbaga, M. T., E. Arnaud-Santana, J. R. Steadman, and D. P. Coyne. 1992. New sources of nonspecific resistance to rust and common bacterial blight in the dry bean landrace Pompadour. Euphytica 61:135–144.
1. DEDICATION: D. P. COYNE
17
Mohamed, M. F., P. E. Read, and D. P. Coyne. 1992. Plant regeneration from in vitro culture of embryonic axis explants in common and tepary beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 117:332–336. Mohamed, M. F., P. E. Read, and D. P. Coyne. 1992. Dark preconditioning, CPPU, and thidiazuron promote shoot organogenesis on seedling node explants of common and faba beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 117:668–672. Beaver, J. S., J. R. Steadman, and D. P. Coyne. 1992. Field reaction of landrace components of red mottled beans to common bacterial blight. HortScience 27:50–51. Arnaud-Santana, E., D. P. Coyne, J. S. Beaver, and H. Z. Zaiter. 1993. Effect of photoperiod and temperature on common blight disease of common beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Euphytica 66:211–216. Arnaud-Santana, E., M. T. Mmbaga, D. P. Coyne, and J. R. Steadman. 1993. Sources of resistance to common bacterial blight and rust in elite Phaseolus vulgaris L. germplasm. HortScience 28:644–646. Mohamed, M. F., E. Arnaud-Santana, and D. P. Coyne. 1993. Rooting of bean leaves and use in germplasm evaluation for common bacterial blight resistance. Euphytica 65:161–166. Mohamed, M. F., D. P. Coyne, and P. E. Read. 1993. Shoot organogenesis in callus induced from pedicel explants of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 118:158–162. Wallace, D. H., J. P. Bandoin, J. Beaver, D. P. Coyne, D. E. Halseth, P. N. Masaya, H. M. Munger, J. R. Myers, M. Silbernagel, K. S. Yourstone, and R. W. Zobel. 1993. Improving efficiency of breeding for higher crop yield. Theor. Appl. Genet. 86:27–40. Arnaud-Santana, E., D. P. Coyne, K. M. Eskridge, and A. K. Vidaver. 1994. Inheritance, low correlations of leaf, pod, and seed reactions to common blight disease in common beans, and implications for selection. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 119:116–121. Coyne, D. P., D. S. Nuland, D. T. Lindgren, and J. R. Steadman. 1994. ‘Chase’ Pinto dry bean. HortScience 29:44–45. Deshpande, R. Y., K. G. Hubbard, D. P. Coyne, J. R. Steadman, and A. M. Parkhurst. 1995. Estimating leaf wetness in dry bean canopies as a prerequisite to evaluating white mold disease. Agron. J. 87:613–619. Mohamed, M. F., and D. P. Coyne. 1995. Photoperiod sometimes influences common bacterial blight disease of common beans. HortScience 30:551–553. Mohamed, M. F., D. P. Coyne, and P. E. Read. 1995. A radiation-induced mutant with resistance to common bacterial blights in common beans. HortScience 30:577–578. Lindgren, D. T., and D. P. Coyne. 1995. Injury and yield of leaf hopper infested dry beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 120:839–842. Coyne, D. P. 1995. Classical and molecular approaches to breeding horticultural plants for disease resistance: Introduction to the Colloquium. HortScience 30:448–449. Coyne, D. P., J. M. Reiser, and L. Sutton. 1995. ‘Lakota’ winter squash, a cultivar derived from Native American sources in Nebraska. HortScience 30:1106–1107. Arnaud-Santana, E., and D. P. Coyne. 1996. Herencia y relacion de la reaccion a la bacteriosis comun y dias a floracion en habichuelas (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). J. Agr. Univ. Puerto Rico 80:95–109. Beaver, J. S., E. Arnaud Santana, and D. P. Coyne. 1996. Yield stability of determinate and indeterminate red mottled beans. J. Agr. Univ. Puerto Rico 80:187–189. Eskridge, K. M., and D. P. Coyne. 1996. Estimating the number of genes affecting a trait using inbred-backcross data and modified minimum chi-square. J. Hered. 87:410–412. Mohamed, F. M., D. P. Coyne, and P. E. Read. 1996. Enhancement effect of CPPU on differentiation of somatic embryoids in callus cultures of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Quart. Plant Growth Regulator Soc. Am. 24:97–103.
18
J. STEADMAN AND J. JANICK
Jung, G., D. P. Coyne, P. W. Skroch, J. Nienhuis, E. Arnaud-Santana, J. Bokosi, H. M. Ariyarathne, J. R. Steadman, J. Beaver, and S. Kaeppler. 1996. Molecular markers associated with plant architecture and resistance to common blight, web blight, and rust in common beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 121:794–803. Zhang, Z., D. P. Coyne, and A. Mitra. 1997. Factors affecting Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of common bean. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 122:300–305. Jung, G., P. W. Skroch, D. P. Coyne, J. Nienhuis, E. Arnaud-Santana, H. M. Ariyarathne, S. M. Kaeppler, and M. J. Bassett. 1997. Molecular marker-based genetic analysis of Tepary bean-derived common bacterial blight resistance in different developmental stages of common bean. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 122:329–337. Park, S. O., D. P. Coyne, A. Dursun, and G. Jung. 1998. Identifying randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers linked to major genes for common bacterial blight resistance in tepary bean. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 123:278–282. Jung, G., D. P. Coyne, J. Bokosi, J. R. Steadman, and J. Nienhuis. 1998. Mapping genes from specific and adult plant resistance to rust and abaxial leaf pubescence and their genetic relationships using randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers in common bean. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 123:859–863. Ariyarathne, H. M., D. P. Coyne, A. K. Vidaver, and K. M. Eskridge. 1998. Selecting for common bacterial blight resistance in common bean: Effects of multiple leaf inoculation and detached pod inoculation test. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 123:864–867. Zhang, Z., D. P. Coyne, A. K. Vidaver, and A. Mitra. 1998. Expression of human lactoferrin cDNA confers resistance to Ralstonia solanacearun in transgenic tobacco plants. Phytopathology 88:730–734. Park, S. O., D. P. Coyne, J. M. Bokosi, and J. R. Steadman. 1999. Molecular markers linked to genes for specific rust resistance and indeterminate growth habit in common bean. Euphytica 105:133–141. Sandlin, C. M., J. R. Steadman, C. M. Araya, and D. P. Coyne. 1999. Isolates of Uromyces appendiculatus with specific virulence to landraces of Phaseolus vulgaris of Andean origin. Plant Dis. 83:108–113. Jung, G., P. W. Skroch, D. P. Coyne, E. Arnaud Santana, and H. M. Ariyarathne. 1999. Confirmation of QTL associated with common bacterial blight resistance in four different genetic backgrounds in common bean. Crop Sci. 39:1448–1455. Ariyarathne, H. M., D. P. Coyne, G. Jung, P. N. Miklas, M. J. Bassett, and P. Skroch. 1999. Molecular mapping of disease resistance genes for halo blight, common bacterial blight, and bean common mosaic virus in a segregating population of common bean. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 124:654–662. Muharrem, E., E. T. Paparozzi, D. P. Coyne, D. Smith, S. Kachman, and D. S. Nuland. 2001. Testing the effects of moisture on seedcoat color of pinto dry beans. HortScience 36:302–304. Fall, A. L., P. F. Byrne, G. Jung, D. P. Coyne, M. A. Brick, and H. F. Schwartz. 2001. Detection and mapping locus for fusarium wilt resistance in common bean. Crop Sci. 41:1494–1498. Park, Soon O., Dermot P. Coyne, James R. Steadman, and Paul W. Skroch. 2001. Mapping of Qtl for resistance to white mold disease in common bean. Crop Sci. 41:1253–1262. Sutton, L. A., and D. P. Coyne. 2002. Bean-dry. Cultivar list. HortScience 37:16–18. Coyne, D. P., J. R. Steadman, G. Godoy-Lutz, R. Gilbertson, E. Arnaud Santana, J. S. Beaver, and J. R. Myers. Contributions of the Bean/Cowpea CRSP to Management of Bean Diseases. Field Crops Res. (In press).
1. DEDICATION: D. P. COYNE
19
Book Chapters Coyne, D. P. 1977. Dry edible beans. p. 70–71. In: Agricultural atlas of Nebraska. Univ. Nebraska Press, Lincoln. Coyne, D. P., and R. B. O’Keefe. 1977. Horticultural crops. p. 73–74. In: Agricultural atlas of Nebraska. Univ. of Nebraska Press, Lincoln. Coyne, D. P., and M. L. Schuster. 1979. Bacterial diseases of legumes: Breeding and resistance. p. 225–233. In: Advances in legume science. HMSO, London. Adams, W., D. P. Coyne, J. H. C. Davis, C. A. Francis, and P. H. Graham. 1985. The common bean. In: R. Summerfield (ed.), Grain legumes. Longman’s, UK. Coyne, D. P. 1989. Introductory essay on J. C. Walker and Rose Bloom’s classical paper “Effect of environmental factors upon the resistance of cabbage to yellows.” J. Agr. Res. 41:1–15 (1930). p. 526–528. In: J. Janick (ed.), Classical papers in horticultural science. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ. Coyne, D. P. 1994. Tackling world hunger and malnutrition through horticultural research, graduate education, extension and management in cooperation with U.S. universities. p. 383–394. In: J. Janick (ed.), Presidential addresses. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci., Alexandria, VA. Wallace, D. H., K. S. Yourstone, J. P. Baudoin, J. Beaver, D. P. Coyne, J. W. White, and R. W. Zobel. 1995. Photoperiod × temperature interaction effects on the days of flowering of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) p. 863–891. In: M. Pessarakli (ed.), Handbook of plant and crop physiology. Marcel Dekker, New York. Jahn, M. J., and D. P. Coyne. 1998. Dedication: Henry M. Munger. Cucurbitaceae. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci., Alexandria, VA.
2 Strategies for Genetic Improvement of Common Bean and Rhizobia Towards Efficient Interactions* Carla Snoeck and Jos Vanderleyden Centre of Microbial and Plant Genetics, Department of Applied Plant Sciences, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Kasteelpark Arenberg 20, B-3001 Heverlee, Belgium Stephen Beebe Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical A.A. 6713, Cali, Colombia
I. RHIZOBIUM-COMMON BEAN SYMBIOSIS II. BEAN BREEDING A. Breeding Strategies B. Phosphorus Efficiency C. Enhanced Nitrogen Fixation III. SELECTION OF OPTIMIZED RHIZOBIUM STRAINS FOR BEAN INOCULATION A. Strains with Enhanced Nitrogen Fixation Capacity B. Nodulation Competitiveness and Persistence in the Soil C. Common Bean Rhizobia Adapted to Different Environmental Factors IV. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE PROSPECTS LITERATURE CITED * The authors thank E. Luyten, J. Michiels, and R. De Mot at CMPG for useful suggestions during the preparation of the manuscript and P. Gepts, E. Martínez-Romero, R. Merckx, and W. Broughton for critically reading the manuscript. Special gratitude goes to P. Gepts for providing the bean linkage map. C. Snoeck acknowledges the receipt of a predoctoral fellowship from the “Vlaams Instituut voor de Bevordering van het Wetenschappelijk Technologisch Onderzoek in de Industrie” and the receipt of a postdoctoral fellowship from the K.U. Leuven Research Council. The authors acknowledge financial support from a VLIR-DGOS grant from the Belgian government and a VIS grant from the K.U. Leuven Research Council. Plant Breeding Reviews, Volume 23, Edited by Jules Janick ISBN 0-471-35421-X © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 21
22
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
I. RHIZOBIUM-COMMON BEAN SYMBIOSIS The wild ancestor of the cultivated common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L., Fabaceae) is a climbing herbaceous annual that grows naturally at mid to high altitudes from Northern Mexico to Northwest Argentina (Gepts and Debouck 1991). Archeological findings indicate that domestication took place in both Mesoamerica and the Andean zone at least 4000 years ago (Kaplan and Lynch 1999). The pre-Colombian tribes domesticated four other Phaseolus species covering distinct ecological niches (Table 2.1): P. lunatus L., P. coccineus L., P. acutifolius A. Gray, and P. polyanthus Greenman (Toro et al. 1990). All of these species are of 2n=22. Nevertheless, common bean gained wider acceptance and was selected more intensively. Four centers of diversity can be distinguished for wild populations of P. vulgaris: the Mesoamerican, the Andean, the Colombian, and Ecuador-Northern Peru (Fig. 2.1) (Tohme et al. 1996). Geographically isolated domestications in the Andean and Mesoamerican gene pools have led to at least two major gene pools of domesticated bean and one minor, incipient gene pool (Gepts et al. 1986; Singh et al. 1991a; Islam et al. 2002). In addition, there are important secondary centers of diversity in Brazil, North America, Europe, the Middle East, and Africa. The world collection of cultivated and wild P. vulgaris is held in the germplasm bank of The International Center of Tropical Agriculture (CIAT) in Cali, Colombia. The large biodiversity of wild Phaseolus species is well recognized. Moreover, the available wild Phaseolus species give access to an excellent source for traits such as resistance/tolerance to biotic and abiotic stress, yield under agronomically relevant conditions, and symbiotic Table 2.1. Ecological and growth characteristics of selected cultivated species of Phaseolus in tropical areas.z
Phaseolus
Altitude (m)
Daytime temperature (°C)
Mean annual precipitation (mm/year)
Growth cycley (days)
Yield potentialx (kg/ha)
coccineus acutifolius lunatus polyanthus vulgaris
1400–2800 50–1900 50–2800 800–2600 50–3000
12–22 20–32 16–26 14–24 14–26
400–2600 200–400 0–2800 1000–2600 400–1600
90–365 60–110 90–365 110–365 70–330
400–4000 400–2000 400–5000 300–3500 400–5000
z
D. G. Debouck (http://www.hort.purdue.edu/newcrop/1492/beans.html) Duration of growth cycle from start to end of harvest x Yield potential in tropical areas y
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
23
A
Colombian Mesoamerican Andean Ecuador Northern Peru
B Guatemala Durango
Jalisco
Mesoamerica
Nueva Granada
?
Peru
Chile
?
?
Wild Middle American
Wild Andean
Wild Ecuador Northern Peru
Fig. 2.1. A. Distribution of wild P. vulgaris L. in Latin America. B. Evolution of P. vulgaris L.: Domestication of the Middle American and the Andean gene pools led to four races in the Middle American gene pool and three races in the Andean pool. Introgression between genotypes of races from different gene pools is shown. Modified from Gepts (1998b) and Beebe et al. (2000).
24
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
interactions with rhizobia and mycorrhizae that occurred because of coevolution under different selection pressures. Wild bean germplasm is also useful as a source of geographic markers in evolutionary studies (Gepts 1998a), allowing a more systematic search for a trait of interest in the cultivated germplasm (Kipe-Nolt et al. 1992). To date, this potential of wild ancestral Phaseolus germplasm has only been exploited for common bean (Debouck 1994). Common bean is the most important food legume for direct human consumption worldwide and especially in Latin America and Africa (Table 2.2). Beans, like other legumes, are superior to cereals as sources of proteins and micronutrients. Total worldwide production of common bean is difficult to quantify (estimates range from 12 to 19 million tonnes). According to the Food and Agricultural Organization, more than 50% of bean is produced in developing countries (FAO 2001). Beans are considered as a relatively profitable crop by local farmers in Latin America (CIAT 2000), and smallholder bean production, on farms ranging from 1 to 10 ha in size, is expanding rapidly. Nevertheless, yield of common bean on these farms is low (600–900 kg/ha) because cultivation is done on sloping land of low fertility. Under fertile conditions, a yield potential of 2500–5000 kg/ha can be obtained (Table 2.1). However, use of chemical fertilizer is difficult to implement because of economic constraints, while inoculation with N2-fixing rhizobia (exploiting the potential of symbiotic N2 fixation of legumes) is presently limited because of the low N2-fixing capacity of the commercial bean genotypes currently in use, combined with unfavorable edaphic constraints. Interest in common bean genetics is increasing with the recent identification of new sources of germplasm and the development of gene mapping techniques (Nodari et al. 1993). The challenge of increasing
Table 2.2.
Bean production in Latin America (CIAT 2000). Area (1000 ha)
Production (1000 tonnes)
Brazil Mexico Central America (Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Panama) Southern cone (Chile, Argentina, Paraguay) Andean zone (Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia) Caribbean (Cuba, Haiti, Dominican Republic)
5 092 2 259
3 055 1 300
526 357
337 398
299 157
265 141
TOTAL
8 690
5 496
Country/Region
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
25
bean yield through selection for disease resistance, improved nodulation following infection by efficient Rhizobium strains with consequently higher N2 fixation levels, and more efficient use of nutrients is high but technically feasible to tackle. Moreover, the selection/construction of superior Rhizobium strains can help to promote the development of low-input cropping systems. Promiscuity of bean as a host plant for rhizobia became obvious when native isolates recovered from bean nodules from different geographical regions (although with emphasis on Mesoamerica) were shown to have considerable genetic diversity (Martínez et al. 1985; Piñero et al. 1988; Laguerre et al. 1993; Eardly et al. 1995; Aguilar et al. 1998; VasquezArroyo et al. 1998; Herrera-Cervera et al. 1999; Rodriguez-Navarro et al. 2000). P. vulgaris is highly promiscuous for both fast-growing and slowgrowing rhizobia, but efficient (N2 fixing) symbiosis is only obtained with fast-growing rhizobia (Michiels et al. 1998a; Bala and Giller 2001). Among the fast-growing rhizobia, R. etli type I strains (formerly R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli) (Segovía et al. 1993; van Berkum et al. 1996) were found to be predominantly present in the nodules of aboriginal wild bean varieties both in Mesoamerica and the Andean region. This led to the speculation that P. vulgaris co-evolved in the symbiosis with compatible Rhizobium spp. (Aguilar et al. 1998; Bernal and Graham 2001). R. tropici type II A and B strains (Martínez-Romero et al. 1991) are particularly associated with bean plants cultivated in South American acid soils. R. tropici, such as CIAT899, seemed a promising source for inoculant strains because of its tolerance to high temperatures and its higher genetic stability—being less subject to genomic rearrangements and plasmid loss—under stress conditions (Martínez-Romero et al. 1991; Michiels et al. 1994a; Soberón-Chavez et al. 1986). Other strains effectively nodulating beans are R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli (Jordan 1984), Rhizobium sp. NGR234 (van Rhijn et al. 1994a), the recently described R. gallicum bv. phaseoli and R. giardinii bv. phaseoli (Amarger et al. 1997), and Sinorhizobium sp. BR816, retained from a Brazilian selection program for tolerance to high temperature (Hungria et al. 1993; Hernández-Lucas et al. 1995b). Former use of inoculant strains for application in Brazilian acid soils with low N content (Cerrados region) has been a discouraging experience, since these strains, none of them phylogenetically classified as R. tropici, had lost their ability to fix N2 in the field. Today, the demand of Brazilian farmers for bean inoculants is increasing. Bean yield is generally increased by inoculation with R. tropici CIAT899 to up to 2500 kg/ha, five times higher than the average Brazilian yield. Since 1998, a new isolate PRF 81 with R. tropici characteristics has been officially recommended for use in Brazilian commercial inoculants together with
26
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
CIAT899 (Hungria and Vargas 2000). PRF 81 is tolerant to high temperatures and acidity in vitro and in vivo, effective in N2 fixation with common bean, and highly competitive against indigenous bean rhizobia (Hungria et al. 2000). In this review, innovative research strategies and current trends to improve bean yield are highlighted. It emphasizes the need of coordinated screening for genes involved in disease resistance, abiotic stress and yield potential, through exploitation of the large genetic potential of available bean germplasm. In this respect, N2 fixation (selection of plant host, preferential nodulation by the host) and efficient P uptake (plant architecture, carbon/nitrogen metabolism, root activity) are indirect traits of high priority to select for higher bean yield and are discussed here. This study also deals with the selection and subsequent inoculation with superior N2-fixing rhizobia that are optimally interacting with bean cultivars, hereby exploiting the potential of symbiotic N2 fixation. An overview of the bacterial determinants involved in the Rhizobium-Phaseolus vulgaris interaction is given. Recent developments in the selection of optimized bean nodulating Rhizobium strains (enhanced N2 fixation capacity, nodulation competitiveness, abiotic stress resistance) through advances in molecular genetics are discussed. For further reading, we refer to a recent book covering various state-ofthe-art aspects and future directions of common bean improvement (Singh 1999a) as well as to a review on inoculant Rhizobium strains (Vlassak and Vanderleyden 1997).
II. BEAN BREEDING Although common bean is a staple food crop in Latin America and the international bean market is still quite small, the onset of globalization will certainly promote bean trade. Not only countries like China and Myanmar, but also the United States, Argentina, and Canada, are major grain legume exporters (FAO 2001). Since common bean consumption in most Latin American countries exceeds local production, there is increasing activity in the international market. Although Latin America has its own typical bean cultivars and undoubtedly cultural aspects are very important in this respect, yield will have to increase to compete on a world scale (CIAT 2000). Clear goals for yield potential must be seen in the context of a given region, production system, and grain type. Associated bean cropping is the most common traditional system in both Latin America (often maizebean association) and Africa (often bean-banana and bean-root crops association) and is focused on low-input farming. Environmental factors
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
27
are frequently far from optimal and soils can be critically limited by abiotic stresses, such as drought, toxicities, and nutrient deficiencies. Thus, breeding for improved productivity within these farming systems is best addressed through a combination of genetic and phytotechnical management solutions that are accessible to poor farmers. Moreover, increased productivity may be emerging from work on edaphic resistance. Lack of money to purchase pesticides and the dangers of pesticide toxicity also make breeding for disease resistance a desirable goal. Improvement of the nutritional quality of beans is another important aspect that would be beneficial for all bean-consuming populations but the subject will not be covered here. A. Breeding Strategies Wild germplasm, weedy forms, and landraces of common bean have been (and still are) the major source of genes for disease resistance, abiotic stress tolerance, and yield potential (Beebe et al. 1997). Recombination between the two major gene pools offers opportunities for bean breeders to broaden the genetic diversity of the cultivated races provided that viable and fertile progeny can be obtained and that appropriate breeding methodology is adopted to capture the complex gene interactions underlying performance (Gepts 1998a; Johnson and Gepts 2002). Most traits are still selected by conventional means in field sites where diseases and edaphic constraints can occur. However, the advent of biotechnology has provided new tools for optimally making use of genetic resources, encouraging integrated and coordinated screening programs. By analyzing patterns of molecular markers such as restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP), random amplification of polymorphic DNA (RAPD), sequence characterized amplified regions (SCAR), amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP), or single sequence repeats (SSR), genetic diversity in germplasm can be evaluated and genetic control of traits elucidated. These polymorphic markers are assembled to construct linkage groups covering the genome. RFLP and SSR have the advantages of being co-dominant and identifying specific sites in the genome and are preferred for developing maps among contrasting parental genotypes that in turn can be compared with the reference map (Freyre et al. 1998). If map saturation with RFLP and SSR is inadequate, AFLP and RAPD can be generated at relatively low cost and can serve to saturate a framework map, especially if the map is based on Recombinant Inbred Lines (RIL), where dominant expression of these markers is not an issue. Wide crosses among gene pools offer a high degree of polymorphism with all types of markers but suffer possible segregation distortion,
28
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
which complicates map development. Furthermore, wide crosses might present certain physiological dysfunctions that make phenotypic analysis doubtful. This is an important consideration for analysis of complex physiological traits. Narrow crosses (for example, within bean races) will likely perform more normally both genetically and physiologically, but close genetic relationship has the disadvantage of low genetic polymorphism, which makes mapping more difficult. Furthermore, these techniques should prove useful for selecting particular traits between different sources, and hopefully, loci affecting quantitatively inherited traits (QTL) can be detected and monitored during introgression. The parameters of QTL detection (necessary population size, desired degree of map saturation) depend on the precision that the researcher seeks for his particular purposes. Precise localization of QTL within one or two mapping units would require a population of several hundred individuals and a highly saturated map. But for practical breeding purposes of identifying markers that can serve to recover important regions of the genome in a breeding program, flanking markers at a distance of 5–10 cM might be adequate. This degree of precision requires rather more modest population sizes, and much can be learned with populations of 80–100 individuals. Furthermore, if QTL are sought for physiological traits, the capacity for detailed and reliable physiological analysis on large populations may be even more limiting than the genetic analysis. For more detailed information, other strategies such as functional genomics that focus on genes of known sequence and function might be a more effective avenue than QTL analysis (for example, to tease out knowledge of multigene families). Another option to obtain molecular markers is to sequence messenger RNAs extracted from tissues of interest. These so-called expressed sequence tags (ESTs) represent sequences of genes that are very useful for positional cloning. High-throughput molecular mapping making use of these ESTs as genetic landmarks will speed up modern plant breeding programs. Markers have been used to position agronomically important genes on the linkage map that several groups have developed for common bean (Vallejos et al. 1992; Nodari et al. 1993; Adam-Blondon et al. 1994; Beebe et al. 1998; Freyre et al. 1998). Markers for disease-resistance genes have been identified, including those for resistance to anthracnose (Adam-Blondon et al. 1994; Alzate-Marin et al. 1997; Melotto et al. 1997; Young and Kelly 1997; Mendoza et al. 2001), rust (Haley et al. 1993; Miklas et al. 1993), bean common mosaic virus (BCMV) (Haley et al. 1994; Johnson et al. 1997; Melotto et al. 1996), bean golden mosaic virus (BGMV) (Miklas et al. 1996; Urrea et al. 1996), common bacterial blight (Vallejos et al. 1992; Nodari et al. 1993; Jung et al. 1996; Miklas et al.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
29
1996; Jung et al. 1997), and ashy stem blight (Olaya 1995). A few genes for physiological traits have also been tagged, including photoperiod sensitivity (Gu et al. 1993; Gu et al. 1994), drought (Schneider et al. 1997), biological N2 fixation (CIAT 1998; Tsai et al. 1998) and root structure affecting P uptake (Beebe et al. 1998), as well as genes for the domestication syndrome (Koinange et al. 1996). A core map version of a linkage map of common bean, consisting of 11 linkage groups, is schematically drawn in Fig. 2.2. The reader is referred to Gepts (1999), Kelly et al. (2002), and references therein for a detailed description. Reliable PCR-based markers of high priority genes allow highthroughput screening to marker-assisted selection (MAS). The application of markers in MAS is most effective if markers are linked in coupling to desirable genes, thus permitting positive selection of the trait, including in the case of dominant markers like RAPD. However, most breeding programs are not in a position to select for more than a few genes, given the cost involved. Thus, for MAS to be cost effective, the genes under selection must have a relatively large effect on the trait of interest. In the case of QTL, these probably need to be what have been referred to as oligogenes. Although the implementation of MAS for QTL is still not common, markers have contributed greatly to understanding the genetics and inheritance of complex traits, such as biological N2 fixation and root structure for nutrient uptake or discovering more precisely physiological relationships. For this, RIL are a useful genetic tool because they are homozygous at most loci, thus permitting observations about cosegregation of traits of interest, and about relationships among those traits, in genotypes with a common genetic background. In addition, they can be used in replicated trials, thus allowing an analysis of traits subject to environmental influence. We are studying a population of 100 RIL derived from a cross of two small seeded genotypes of Central American race Mesoamerica (Singh et al. 1991c), DOR 364 × BAT 477. The latter has presented excellent nitrogen fixation capacity in both optimal and suboptimal conditions with drought and phosphorus stress. The recently formed international consortium PHASEOMICS (March 2001), which represents different bean research centers, conceived the plan to establish the necessary framework of knowledge and materials that will result in disease-resistant, stress-tolerant, high-quality protein, and high-yielding beans, especially for deprived regions in Latin America and Africa, and finally aims at sequencing the genome of Phaseolus vulgaris L. For a detailed description of the objectives of the project “Beans (Phaseolus spp.)—Model Food Legumes” by the Phaseomics consortium, we refer to Broughton et al. (2002). Efforts on EST sequencing and transcriptome analysis will complement current studies on
30
B1 SCN, Co-1, Co-x, Co-w Ur-9 Ppd
Pal-1 fin
B2 ROG19.1490 G19.1500
Bng171a
Q01.650 D1662 D1327 AD17.350 V12.550 R20.1250 T01.300 D1032
NM,DF,DM, PD,HI,SW MG
[I-B] F06.350 T07.550 AG08.700
CBBBA SWBJ NM,DF, DM,NP, WMAG L5
ROD3.930 AN16.700
V12.1050
Co-u, R3
107
St
O12.900 D1287 P07.700
D0166 V12.700 G05.850 G06.1100 U12.500 Bng174 Cel O12.1600 W20.1400 GRP1.8-1 I06.550 AM02.1500 O19.800 Vpe-2 AM10.800 O15.1800
PvPR-2 ChS-2 Pgip
ChS W02.1100 J01.2000 D1595
AN08.800 Q09.1200 R20.400 AD04.1000 AP07.1300 V20.700 AA03.650 D1020 O10.350 HBBA Bng165 F10.900 CBBBJ GRP1.8-2 D08.800 D1009 FRRMF U20.700 AM18.1050 DO,PL Z AM10.525 CBBBH AH05.650 O20.550 Q18.600 SS W06.700 PvPR-1 S08.500 G17.800 I18.1700 Y11.350 CBBPX D1377 X11.1300 WBBH , HTBH Bng12 WMBN Pu-a G03.1150 AO11.1000 2 bc-1 D1151
V10.900 AM07.300 F13.300 AN08.900
DO,SWBJ
CBBBA
175
rk, Ane, Ms-8
[alphaAlArl- Lec]
CBBS95
NN
G
Cab-1 RVI
O20.1000 Bng224 X07.250 Z04.1200 D1325 Rbcs P09.800 G08.1100 X01.950 F08.1600 Bng71 D1298
AM04.950 Co-9, Co-y, - Co-z, D1174 Ur-5, Ur-Dorado, Ur-Ouro Negro Y17.1100
CBBBH NN FRRMF WMBN
132
bc-u
Bng119b
B5 G19.1800
Me
SGou D1132
ROS3.380
B4
D1066-2
W07.1450 Bng122 O13.700 V20.400
B3
B6 CBBBJ
Bng104
D1080 Diap-1 ROD20b F07.1550 SWBJ&PX,WMPX U12.950 D1198 K10.1300 H13.300 Aco-2 S18.500 D1157 Lox-1 D1301 AL08.900 D1251 AH17.500 Bng162
ANTBJ,ASBDX, BGMVDX 95
Hsp70
S18.1500 U10.2000 U19.500 AD09.950
bc-3
Bng94 P2062 ROF7.540
Ur-4 Cdc-2 72
HBBA CBBS95
S18.650 AD09.700
WM HTB60 LDG
D1086 ROD3.560 D03.600 W13.350 T08.500 AD12.350 O10.650 V D0096 U19.350 G05.1150 AM06.1000
SW CBB 113
ChI Bng199 J09.950 Y04.1050 Bng060
Co-v
Phs
P Co-6 Ef
Pal-2 LegH Per Uri-2 Lec-2 Lec-3
y
Bng191
Asp
I16.900
NN, WM AG&PX CBBBJ&BH&DX, BGMVDX ,ASBDX
A10.1100 T08.650
SW BJ&MG&PX
DJ1kscar
Gy [C-R] Co-4
Bip, Ana Y04.1600
CBBXC
GS-c -
109
WMBN
U20.1150 D1468 D1505 Bng205 O16.600 I08.1500 AJ13.1350 E19.1500 I03.1550 H11.400 L04.950 X15.450 W01.650 E19.1200
WMPX
Y08.1350 AA03.1100 AD08.450
AM07.600 Bng73 D1055
WMB60 NM,DF,DM, NP,HI
CBBPX
W02.750 Bng228 Bng102 Cad, Ch G18.400 P07.350 P07.550 AI07.600 D1096-2 2 W13.550 T AM13.1500 O19.750 D1831 Uri-1 D1338-2
D1476 I07.700 AM14.1000 Bng200 AJ14.250 AG18.550 K19.450b U01.700 X11.700 Bng68 D1580
Bng112
L
AL15.1300 Q11.1000 AE07.800 U10.1000 AD12.450 D1308 AD17.950
CBBBH&BA&DX WBBH
L04.500 AN11.300
Ur-BAC6
AN03.350
CBBBJ ROF1.1180
HBBA
105
Bng218
89
CBBXC
D1228
HBBA,FWBA
Vpe-3
Fr
93
133
CBBBA
P06.600
AH05.1000
SW MG
rRNA-1
AO11.1200
PL
H12.1050b
G04.900 U10.900
B11
B10
Gluc
CBBXC
D1861 W20.550 P1090 AM13.450 Z04.600 Bng204 H14.550 D0190 Y04.1300
W16.550 AN03.650 I07.1200 AN08.650 D1107
B9
B8
B7
Ur-12 Hrgp36
Co-2
AJ16.250 G03.850 D1291 Bng145 P2027 W02.950 K10.700 DH20sT D1512 G08.1200
NN
WBBH CBBXC PD CBBBA
100
PL PepC
Ur-11, Ur-3, Ur-Dorado
CBBPX, WMPX
Fig. 2.2. Current core linkage map of common bean (modified from Kelly et al. 2002), representing the distribution of genes with a biochemical function, major genes coding for phenotypic traits, and QTLs. To the left of each linkage group are the framework molecular markers (smaller font), the biochemical genes (larger font), and major genes for phenotypic trait (shaded boxes). To the right are QTLs. For the meaning of the symbols, the reader is referred to Kelly et al. (2002). The stippled boxes surrounding gene symbols are putative disease or pest resistance gene clusters.
31
32
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
other legumes such as Lotus japonicus and Medicago truncatula as well as the EST projects in soybean by providing a framework for comparative genomics between legumes or within Phaseolus species. This will be of particular interest since Phaseolus, in comparison to Glycine max, L. japonicus, and M. truncatula, is a tropical legume species. To date, public databases hold relatively few entries (<500 nuclear-encoded genes) for Phaseolus. Useful data for breeding programs and functional genomics will be made freely accessible on the Phaseomic Information Resource (http://www.phaseolus.net). B. Phosphorus Efficiency Estimates from the CIAT database suggest that over 50% of bean-growing areas in Latin America and 65% to 80% of bean-growing areas in Africa are critically deficient in phosphorus (CIAT 2000). P deficiency is especially a nutritional limiting factor under N2-fixing conditions, as compared to growth in the presence of mineral nitrogen. Nodules are a strong sink for P since they require much ATP for nitrogenase functioning (AlNiemi et al. 1997; Gniazdowska et al. 1998). It is reported that their P concentration is three times higher than that of other organs (Vadez et al. 1997). There is growing interest in developing cultivars of common bean with acceptable yield at low P levels in many tropical systems. Bean plants exhibit numerous physiological and morphological responses to growth at suboptimal phosphorus supply (Lynch and Beebe 1995). These plant responses offer the possibility of studying P availability and have proven to be useful in screening of bean genotypes for low P tolerance. The effectiveness of selection for physiological traits greatly depends on factors such as the genetic variability within populations and specific stage of plant ontogeny (Araujo and Teixeira 2000). Genetic differences in P efficiency exist among common bean genotypes (Araujo et al. 1998; Yan et al. 1995) and seem to be related to geographic origin (Beebe et al. 1997). The amplitude of genotypic variability within wild accessions for certain biochemical traits suggests a genetic diversity superior to cultivated genotypes, although wild accessions did not seem more tolerant to low P conditions (Lynch and Beebe 1995). Variability of P utilization traits such as shoot biomass, shoot P concentration, and nodule dry mass was more expressive at low P levels, confirming the potential for detecting lines with high N2 fixation under low P availability, and is strongly associated with photosynthetic activity. Vadez et al. (1997) also observed genotypic variability in effects of P deficiency on nodule metabolism such as the permeability of nodules to oxygen diffusion and proton efflux, nodule nitrogenase activity, and
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
33
nodule number and mass. Thus, these traits could be a key issue in the selection of symbioses tolerant to low P, at least between genotypes of similar phenology. Low-P adapted root growth and architecture such as a vigorous branched root system (Lynch and Van Beem 1993), reduced gravitropic response of basal roots (Bonser et al. 1996; Liao et al. 2001), and “lowcost” roots of small diameter enable a plant to explore more efficiently the soil in time and space with a lower degree of spatial competition between adjacent roots within a root system (Nielsen et al. 1994). Fractal geometry is a potential new approach for a very sensitive measurement of root branching activity. With this method, differences between highly efficient genotypes and inefficient genotypes could be observed (Nielsen et al. 1999). Caution should be taken with the utility of certain morphological characteristics and evaluation criteria for selection of adapted genotypes, since this depends on other environmental constraints encountered in Phaseolus habitats, such as drought. Interestingly, lines that were selected under moderate aluminum and phosphorus stress are also performing well under optimal soil conditions, yielding as much as 40% more than the standard high yielding controls. It is possible that selection has led to improved root systems that perform well under any conditions (CIAT 2000). A well-recognized symptom of a limiting inorganic phosphate (Pi) concentration in plant tissues is a reduction in shoot growth, while root growth is unaffected or slightly stimulated (Yan et al. 1995). Increase of the root to shoot biomass ratio on the other hand is correlated with a higher carbohydrate concentration in the roots (Rychter and Randall 1994) due to higher translocation of photosynthates to the roots (Ciereszko et al. 1996). Increased sucrose synthase activities are responsible for the enhanced sucrose hydrolysis in the growing parts of roots under phosphorus deprivation (Ciereszko et al. 1998). P deficiency stress in root meristematic tissue also provokes increased size of the vacuolar compartment, ultrastructural changes of mitochondria in cortical cells, and changes in factors controlling respiration rate (Wanke et al. 1998). Carbohydrate mobilization and ultrastructure of bean root cells are traits worth considering in order to elucidate their role in acclimation of plants to P deficiency. Internal and exuded acid phosphatase activity (APA) and release of organic acids are generally believed to be important in the regulation of P nutrition inside the plant (Helal et al. 1990; Tadano et al. 1993; Ryan et al. 2001). However, their role in plant adaptation to low P availability remains controversial and their use as a diagnostic criterion for P deficiency needs to be critically evaluated. A positive relation was reported
34
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
between root APA and phosphorus uptake in bean (Helal et al. 1990). However, results obtained by Yan et al. (2001) do not support a major role for leaf APA induction in regulating common bean adaptation to phosphorus efficiency. On the other hand, Shen et al. (2002) demonstrated that Andean genotypes performed a higher P solubilizing activity than Mesoamerican genotypes, which they attribute to the higher exudation of organic acids, particularly citrate. Genomic research will certainly set the stage for the dissection of the P starvation signal transduction pathway in plants and the identification of key molecular determinants of P efficiency leading to genetically altered plants that are enhanced in acquiring P from the soil (Raghothama 2000). Beans that grow in P-deficient soils can particularly benefit from their association with arbuscular mycorrhizae (AM) through the acquisition of greater amounts of P from the soil. It is interesting to note that both AM and Rhizobium symbioses rely on partially overlapping genetic programs, suggesting a bacterial recognition cascade that is derived from an evolutionary ancient mycorrhizal recognition pathway (Duc et al. 1989; Stracke et al. 2002). Two symbiotic mutants were described for common bean with respectively a Nod+/Fix–/Myc– phenotype and a Nod–/Myc+phenotype (Shirtliffe and Vessey 1996). Given the promiscuous behavior of beans, not only referring to the generally low fungal specificity but also toward rhizobial strains, it will be of particular interest to decipher the unique components of the signaling pathway leading to nodule development and mycorrhizal interaction by using a comparative approach with other model legumes. Besides, understanding the mechanisms of nutrient exchange, such as P, in bean-AM symbiosis is an important future research goal. C. Enhanced Nitrogen Fixation Common bean is often grown on marginal lands limited in available soil N, and with minimal N fertilization. Improving the potential of biological N2 fixation would reduce N depletion in such soils (at least for crops with a small harvest index), improve grain yield, and possibly enhance protein content. The capacity to fix N2 is variable among genotypes of common bean, ranging from 4 to 59% of the required N2 derived from the atmosphere (Hardarson et al. 1993). Genetic improvement of nodulation and N2 fixation in common bean was discussed by Bliss (1985, 1993), emphasizing the evaluation of direct selection traits such as nodule mass, nitrogenase activity, and xylem ureide content in segregating populations grown under low-N soil conditions. Over a period of 13 years, Bliss and his colleagues selected
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
35
a high N2-fixing progeny from crosses of commercial and vigorous high N2-fixing parents under low-N soils (Bliss et al. 1989; Bliss 1993). Recently, Barron et al. (1999) also isolated elite populations with high N2-fixing ability through recurrent selection for high seed and biomass under low-N conditions. A few studies indicate that breeding for preferential infection/ nodulation has potential, and emphasize the genetic contribution of the plant to the nodulation competitiveness phenomenon. Identification of genotypes that do not nodulate with an undesirable strain and then introduce this qualitative trait into other genetic backgrounds is a possible approach, as demonstrated with selected soybean genotypes and isolates of the dominant Bradyrhizobium serogroup 123 (Cregan et al. 1989). With this strategy for a “restricted” symbiosis, the developed cultivars nodulate only with highly effective indigenous or inoculant strains. A converse approach is to breed the host plant for preferential infection/nodulation with one or more desirable, high N2-fixing strains (Rosas et al. 1998). This will provide more insight into the quantitative trait of strain preference. In order to identify germplasm and to follow the preferential nodulation trait in segregating populations, Rosas and coworkers (1998) used a rapid visual screen for plant lines that preferentially nodulate with a desirable strain, R. etli KIM5s, in the presence of indigenous R. etli strains. Consistent with the concept of co-evolution of the Rhizobium and the wild germplasm of beans, the preference for the indigenous R. etli strains appeared to be more common among Mesoamerican accessions, as compared to the Andean accessions. KipeNolt et al. (1992) found a tendency for Middle American bean materials to prefer CIAT632, a R. etli strain isolated from the same geographic region, whereas certain Andean accessions preferred R. tropici CIAT899 from Colombia. Similarly, Montealegre et al. (1995) demonstrated that the bean cultivar RAB39 is preferentially nodulated by R. tropici CIAT899 instead of R. etli strains when applied together, independently of the temperature or pH regime. A more detailed analysis showed that this host preference was extended even when the R. tropici strain was applied with a delay of 8 h compared to the competitor strains of R. etli (Montealegre and Graham 1996). A more straightforward approach will certainly be the dissection of the signal cascade leading to nodule development by determining the molecular basis of mutations in genes, partly based on existing genetic resources coming from other legume genome sequencing initiatives (Endre et al. 2002). Genes that were thought to have unrelated functions could then be seen as part of a complex network of interacting genes and their products, and unveil previously unrecognized relationships.
36
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
It would also be of interest to start breeding programs of beans for enhanced symbiotic N2 fixation in high-N soils, since there is evidence for such a trait in different members of the Phaseoleae tribe (Dakora 1998; Park and Buttery 1988). Soybean mutants resulting in increased nodule number (called hypernodulation or supernodulation) simultaneously led to an alleviation of nitrate inhibition of the symbiosis (Carroll et al. 1985). These mutants [termed nts (nitrate-tolerant symbiotic)] appeared defective in the autoregulation of nodulation, which is controlled by a single recessive gene operating through the shoot (Delves et al. 1986; reviewed in Gresshoff 1993), encoding a receptor-like protein kinase GmNARK (G. max nodule autoregulation recepter kinase) similar to Arabidopsis CLAVATA1 (CLV1) (Searle et al. 2002). GmNARK has a major role in long-distance signaling mechanisms. A characteristic reduction of total plant growth and restricted root growth, eventually resulting in reduced grain yield, was observed for these mutants as compared to their parental genotypes (Day et al. 1986). Similar mutant phenotypes have been generated from a supernodulation mutant of Phaseolus vulgaris (Buttery and Park 1990; Buttery et al. 1990). Field evaluation of supernodulating soybean genotypes revealed that the increase in N2 fixation could not compensate for whole plant yields that were commonly 20–30 % below those of the wild type cultivars (Herridge and Rose 2000). The major advantage of the supernodulators is to provide a source of N for succeeding non-leguminous crops leading to higher yields and to increased soil Rhizobium levels. Characterization and molecular mapping of the genes controlling nitrate tolerance is a potential approach for selection and breeding of beans for enhanced N2 fixation. In this way, breeding is much more focused on increasing the percentage of crop N derived from N2 fixation rather then genetically based improvements in yield. The reader is advised to consult the above mentioned comprehensive review (Herridge and Rose 2000) on the selection and breeding of soybean for enhanced N2 fixation. III. SELECTION OF OPTIMIZED RHIZOBIUM STRAINS FOR BEAN INOCULATION Rhizobia that is to be employed as inoculum must meet important criteria before release into the field (Date 2000). An inoculant strain must be able to form highly effective nodules on the host for which it is recommended, preferably under a wide range of field conditions. Furthermore, successful strains must be competitive in nodule formation and persist in the soil in the presence of the host plant. Nodulation com-
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
37
petitiveness is still poorly understood and a major hurdle in transferring knowledge from the laboratory to the field. In areas where beans have been planted for many years, often only a small percentage of the nodules contain the applied inoculant strain. Consequently, because indigenous saprophytic Rhizobium species are often less effective N2 fixers, significant yield increases were often not attained (Ramos and Boddey 1987; Thies et al. 1991; Wolff et al. 1991). The use of mixed strains rather than single strains of rhizobia is suggested since this strategy helps to overcome the competitiveness of the ineffective indigenous rhizobial strains and achieve good nodule occupancy by the inoculant (Daba and Haile 2002). Moreover, tropical environmental conditions can severely affect inoculant persistence in the soil and rhizosphere of plants as well as efficiency of nodulation. Both indigenous soil bacteria and the inoculant strain are competing for limited carbon sources and are exposed to abiotic stresses such as elevated temperature, acidity, high osmolarity, or oxidative stress. Thus, the success of an inoculant strain depends on its capacity to adapt to adverse conditions. Much effort is being directed toward identifying superior strains occupying bean nodules under geographically different agronomic field conditions. Other criteria include the need for easy growth of the inoculum strains in broth culture, growth and survival in peat culture, and ability to survive on the seed prior to germination (Date 2000). Using peat as a carrier for rhizobial inoculants is known to have an advantage in that it has a very high water holding and buffering capacity that protect rhizobia from unfavorable soil conditions. Products with an extended shelf life are high priority for inoculant manufacturers (Catroux et al. 2001). It has to be mentioned that seed inoculation, which today is still the most common way to introduce effective rhizobia into the soil, often results in a high density of bacteria near the seed, and nodulation that is restricted to the upper taproot (Hardarson et al. 1989). Therefore, proper inoculant placement away from the seed and near the lateral roots is a key factor for good strain performance (Date 2000; Wadisirisuk et al. 1989; Danso and Bowen 1989). Lateral root nodules play an important role in providing fixed nitrogen, especially during later stages of the growing season (Hardarson et al. 1989). Alternative inoculation strategies, aiming at increased movement and contact of the inoculant rhizobia with the legume roots, for post-emergence lateral root application include pivot irrigation delivery of the inoculant, either as a liquid or a peat powder, and post-emergence side-dress banding into the furrow (S. Smith, person. commun.). Based on the diversity of its microsymbionts, bean is an undiscriminating host. Information about infection and nodulation signaling in
38
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
Rhizobium-bean symbiosis was reviewed recently by Laeremans and Vanderleyden (1998). Extensive research on the molecular basis of symbiotic promiscuity, the N2 fixation capacity, and regulatory mechanisms, among other traits, has revealed many molecular determinants needed for an effective and efficient Rhizobium-bean interaction (as summarized in Table 2.3). Recent developments and practical applications regarding the selecting of elite bean-nodulating Rhizobium strains under stress conditions are discussed below. Interestingly, not only α-Proteobacteria but also β-Proteobacteria are now described that are capable of nodulating leguminous plants, for which the genetic control of nodulation also involves nod genes (e.g., the so-called β-rhizobia belonging to the Burkholderia genus) (Moulin et al. 2001). This points to yet unexplored and overlooked classes of rhizobial bacteria that might be encountered in nodules of a wide range of leguminous plants. A. Strains with Enhanced Nitrogen Fixation Capacity During the past two decades, molecular analysis of many genetic loci in Rhizobium that have an effect on bean symbiosis has led to a better understanding of symbiotic N2 fixation (Table 2.3). Genetically engineered Rhizobium strains with high SNF capacity, at least under controlled environmental conditions, were constructed. With few exceptions, genetically modified bean-nodulating rhizobia have yet to result in improved N2 fixation under field conditions. Nevertheless, several approaches are promising. The need for very precise regulation of oxygen concentration during the symbiotic N2 fixation process was taken as a strategy for constructing improved inoculant strains. A genetically engineered R. etli strain expressing the vhb gene, encoding a bacterial hemoglobin from Vitreoscilla sp., shows increased respiratory activity, compared to the wild type strain, probably through a better O2 transporting capacity of leghemoglobin at the bacteroid level. A higher nitrogenase activity provoked a higher total nitrogen content of inoculated bean plants (Ramírez et al. 1999). Nitrogenase activity was strongly enhanced when the fixNOQP genes, encoding the symbiotic high-affinity cbb3 type terminal oxidase, were constitutively expressed from a strong promoter in a R. etli ntrC mutant background (Soberón et al. 1999). Altered bacterial carbon and/or nitrogen metabolism were also shown to be powerful tools for a higher N2 fixation capacity. Lowering the basal nitrogen metabolism in the bacteroids by obstructing the glutamine synthetase-glutamate synthase (GS-GOGAT) pathway positively affected nitrogenase activity in R. etli and increased nitrogen supply to the plant
Table 2.3. Effect of mutated genetic loci of Rhizobium spp. on Phaseolus vulgaris L. symbiosis. Abbreviations used are R. (Rhizobium), R. l. (Rhizobium leguminosarum), S. (Sinorhizobium), LPS (lipopolysaccharides), and EPS (exopolysaccharides).
Similarity Group
Phenotype on Phaseolus vulgarisx
Rhizobial strainz
Function or homologyy
R. tropici CIAT899 S. sp. BR816 S. sp. BR816 S. sp. BR816 S. sp. BR816 R. l. bv. phaseoli 8002 R. l. bv. phaseoli 8002 R. l. bv. phaseoli 8002 R. sp. NGR234 R. etli CNPAF512 R. tropici CIAT899
transcriptional activator transcriptional activator transcriptional activator transcriptional activator transcriptional activator transcriptional activator transcriptional activator transcriptional activator transcriptional activator deacetylase methyltransferase
Nod+/– Nod+ Nod+ Nod+/– Nod+/– Nod+v Nod+v Nod+v Nod– Nod– Nod+/– Fix–u
nodS
Rhizobium sp. NGR234
methyltransferase
Nod+Fix–
nodPQ
R. tropici CIAT899
Nod+
nodPQ
S. sp. BR816
Nod+
Laeremans et al. 1997
nodPQ
R. tropici CFN299
Nod++ or Nod+/–t
Laeremans et al. 1996
nodH nodH nolK nolL
R. tropici CFN299 R. tropici CIAT899 R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CE3
ATP-sulphurylase and APS kinase ATP-sulphurylase and APS kinase ATP-sulphurylase and APS kinase sulphotransferase sulphotransferase fucose synthetase acetyltransferase
van Rhijn et al. 1994a van Rhijn et al. 1994a van Rhijn et al. 1994a van Rhijn et al. 1994a van Rhijn et al. 1994b Davis and Johnston 1990 Davis and Johnston 1990 Davis and Johnston 1990 van Rhijn et al. 1994a Xi et al. 2001 K. Vlassak and J. Vanderleyden, unpublished K. Vlassak and J. Vanderleyden, unpublished Folch-Mallol et al. 1996
Nod++ Nod+ Ndv–fix– Nod+ or Nod+/–t
Laeremans et al. 1996 Folch-Mallol et al. 1996 Xi et al. 2001 Corvera et al. 1999
Genes/orfs
Nodulation genes nodD1w nodD1 nodD2 nodD3 nodD4 nodD1 nodD2 nodD3 nodD1 nodB nodS
Reference
39
(continued)
40
Table 2.3.
Similarity Group
Continued
Genes/orfs
Nodulation genes (cont.) noeJ
Rhizobial strainz
R. etli CNPAF512
noeJs
R. tropici CIAT899
nodIJ nodO
R. etli CE3 R. sp. BR816
Infection genes LPS ABCDEF GHIKLq
Function or homologyy
mannose-1-P-GDPtransferase mannose-1-P-GDPtransferase Nod factor export facilitated Nod factor uptake ??r; altering cation flow through plant membrane
Phenotype on Phaseolus vulgarisx
Reference
Ndv – Inf – Fix–
Xi et al. 2001
Nod – Fix –
Nogales et al. 2002
Nod+/– Nodd
Cárdenas et al. 1995 Vlassak et al. 1998
Noel et al. 1986; Brink et al. 1990; Cava et al. 1990; Noel et al. 1996; Noel and Duelli 2000; Noel et al. 2000; Lerouge et al. 2001 Noel et al. 1996; Noel et al. 2000 Lerouge et al. 2001 Cava et al. 1989; Cava et al. 1990; Garcia de los Santos and Brom 1997 Garcia de los Santos and Brom 1997
R. etli CE3
ND
Ndv – Inf – Fix–
Jq
R. etli CE3
Ndv – Inf+Fix+
wzm/wzt lpsb1
R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3
?? subtle changes in decoration of LPSIr ABC-transporter galacturonic acid transferase
lpsb2
R. etli CE3
glucose epimerase or dehydratase
Ndv – Inf – Fix–
Ndv – Inf – Fix– Ndv – Inf – Fix–
EPS
lps-166
R. etli CFN42
lpcA
R. l. bv. phaseoli
lpcB exoBp orf2
R. l. bv. phaseoli R. etli CE3 R. etli KIM5s
orf3 orf4 lpeA psiAB
R. etli KIM5s R. etli KIM5s R. etli CE3 R. l. bv. phaseoli 8002
pssA
R. l. bv. phaseoli 8002
psrA
R. l. bv. phaseoli 8002
Nitrogen fixation genes iscN nifHan nifHb nifHc nifA nifA
R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3 R. etli CNPAF512 R. l. bv. phaseoli 8002
synthesis of UDPNdv – Inf – Fix – QuiNAc (UDP-GlcNAc→ UDP-QuiNAc) galactosyl transferase ND
Cava et al. 1989; Noel et al. 2000 Poole et al. 1994; Allaway et al. 1996 Allaway et al. 1996 Diebold and Noel 1989 Vinuesa et al. 1999
41
Kdo transferase UDP-glucose 4’ epimerase sugar nucleotide epimerase or dehydratase α-glycosyltransferase β-glycosyltransferase methyltransferase exopolysaccharide production repressor, similar to Rhizobium ExoX similar to Rhizobium ExoY transcriptional repressor
ND ND ND
iron-sulfur cofactor metabolism nitrogenase reductase nitrogenase reductase nitrogenase reductase transcriptional regulator transcriptional regulator
Nod+Fix–o
Dombrecht et al. 2002
Nod+Fix+/–m Nod+Fix+/–m Nod+Fix+/–m Nod+Fix– Nod+Fix–
Romero et al. 1988 Romero et al. 1988 Romero et al. 1988 Michiels et al. 1994b Borthakur et al. 1987; Hawkins and Johnston 1988
Ndv– Fix– ND Ndv+ Fix+ Ndv – Inf – Fix–
Vinuesa et al. 1999 Vinuesa et al. 1999 Duelli et al. 2001 Borthakur et al. 1985; Latchford et al. 1991
Nod+Fix+
Borthakur et al. 1986; Latchford et al. 1991 Borthakur and Johnston 1987; Mimmack et al. 1994
Nod+Fix+
(continued)
42
Table 2.3.
Similarity Group
Continued
Genes/orfs
Rhizobial strainz
Nitrogen fixation genes (cont.) orf180 R. etli CNPAF512 fixLJ R. etli CNPAF512
Function or homologyy
Phenotype on Phaseolus vulgarisx
Reference
Nod+Fix+/– Nod+Fix+/–
Dombrecht 2001 D’Hooghe et al. 1995
Fix–
Xi et al. 2001
Nod+Fix+
Girard et al. 2000
Nod+Fix+
fixB
R. etli CNPAF512
fixL f l
R. etli CE3
fixKd l
R. etli CE3
peroxidase two-component regulatory system electron transfer fixAB complex two-component regulatory system transcriptional activator
fixKf l nifS s
R. etli CE3 R. tropici CIAT899
transcriptional activator cysteine desulfurylase
Nod+Fix+ Nod+/–Fix+/–
Girard et al. 2000; Soberón et al. 1999 Girard et al. 2000 Nogales et al. 2002
R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CNPAF512
calsymin transcriptional repressor LuxI type of autoinducer synthase LuxR type of transcriptional regulator
Nod+Fix+/– Nod+Fix+ Nod+Fix+/–
Xi et al. 2000 Xi et al. 2000 Daniels et al. 2002
Nod+Fix+/–
Daniels et al. 2002
Michiels et al. 1998b; Michiels et al. 1998c Michiels et al. 1998c J. Michiels, unpublished
Bacteroid development casA casR cinI cinR
R. etli CNPAF512
Global regulation rpoN1
R. etli CNPAF512
σ54 factor
Nod+Fix+
rpoN2 fnrN
R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CNPAF512
σ54 factor transcriptional regulator
Nod+Fix–o Nod+Fix+/–k
lrp cyaC Nitrogen regulation ntrBC
R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CE3
global regulator adenylate cyclase
Nod+Fix+ Nod+Fix+
Rosemeyer et al. 1998 Téllez-Sosa et al. 2002
R. etli CE3
two-component regulatory system glutamine synthetase I ammonium transporter glutamate synthase subunit (GOGAT) glutamate synthase subunit (GOGAT) arginine deiminase pathway sensor of two-component regulatory system
Nod+Fix+ Nod+Fix+/– ND j Nod+Fix++
Moreno et al. 1992; Patriarca et al. 1993 Moreno et al. 1991 Taté et al. 1998 Castillo et al. 2000
Nod+/– Fix+/–
Ferraioli et al. 2002
Nod+Fix+/–
D’Hooghe et al. 1997
Nod–Fix–
Nogales et al. 2002
Nod+/– Fix+ Nod+/– Fix+
Pardo et al. 1994; Hernández-Lucas et al. 1995a Pardo et al. 1994
Nod+Fix++
Cevallos et al. 1996
Nod++Fix++i
Marroqui et al. 2001
Inf – Fix–h
Soberón et al. 1993; Tabche et al. 1998
Nod+Fix–
Soberón et al. 1999
glnA amtB gltB
R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3
gltD
R. etli CE3
arcABC
R. etli CNPAF512
ntrYs
R. tropici CIAT899
Carbon regulation ccsA
R. tropici CFN299
pscA
R. tropici CFN299
phaC
R. etli CE3
glgA
R. tropici CIAT899
Respiration complexes cycHJKL
fixNOQPdl
R. etli CE3
R. etli CE3
chromosomal citrate synthase plasmid-encoded citrate synthase poly-β-hydroxybutyrate synthase glycogen synthase
43
subunits of haem lyase enzyme/cytochrome biogenesis synthesis of symbiotic cytochrome terminal oxidase cbb3
(continued)
44
Table 2.3.
Similarity Group
Continued
Genes/orfs
Rhizobial strainz
Respiration complexes (cont.) fixNOQPf l R. etli CE3
Function or homologyy
Phenotype on Phaseolus vulgarisx
Nod+Fix+
Girard et al. 2000
Nod+Fix+
Xi et al. 2001
Nod+Fix+
Xi et al. 2001
ND
Aguilar and Soberón 1996
Nod+/– Fix–
Soberón et al. 1989; Aguilar and Soberón 1996 Soberón et al. 1990; MirandaRíos et al. 1997
fixG
R. etli CNPAF512
fixI
R. etli CNPAF512
ccmA
R. etli CE3
ccmB
R. etli CE3
synthesis of symbiotic cytochrome terminal oxidase cbb3 assembly and/or stability of the cbb3-type heme-copper oxidase assembly and/or stability of the cbb3-type hemecopper oxidase ATP binding protein of ABC type transporter system hydrophobic protein
thiCOGE
R. etli CE3
thiamin synthesis
Nod+Fix++g
R. etli CE3 R. tropici CIAT899 R. tropici CIAT899 R. tropici CFN299 R. etli CNPAF512
transcriptional repressor glutathione synthetase ribose transport proteins ribose transport proteins host-inducible gene S. fredii
Nod+Fix+Cmp– Nod+Fix+Cmp– Nod+Fix+Cmp– Nod+Fix+Cmp+ NoddFix+Cmp–
Nodulation competitivity rosR gshB teu teu orf3
Reference
Bittinger et al. 1997 Riccillo et al. 2000 Rosenblueth et al. 1998 Rosenblueth et al. 1998 Michiels et al. 1995
nfeD
R. etli TAL182
slp
R. etli TAL182
Amino acid auxotrophs cysG metZ
R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3
argC
R. etli CE3
trpB serA hisA
R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3
leuC
R. etli CE3
pheA aroK lysA
R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3 R. etli CE3
Miscellaneous melA melC raiI raiR nadA csaA dnaJ
R. l. bv. phaseoli R. l. bv. phaseoli R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CNPAF512 R. etli CNPAF512 R. l. bv. phaseoli
ornithine cyclodeaminase stomatin-like protein siroheme synthetase O-succinylhomoserine sulfhydrylase N-acetylglutamylphosphate reductase tryptophan synthase L-serine dehydratase phosphoribosylformimino-5 aminoimidazole carboxamide ribotide isomerase isopropylmalate dehydratase chorismate mutase shikimate synthase diaminopimelate decarboxylase
45
tyrosinase similarity to ntrA/rpoN autoinducer synthase transcriptional regulator quinolate synthetase molecular chaperonin heat shock protein; involved in glutamate metabolism
pr. Cmp–
Borthakur and Gao 1996b
Nod+Fix+Cmp–
You et al. 1998
Nod+Fix+ Nod–Fix –
Taté et al. 1997 Taté et al. 1999
Nod–Fix –
Ferraioli et al. 2001
Nod–Fix – Nod+/–Fix+/– Nod+/–Fix+/–
Thorne and Williams 1999 Ferraioli et al. 2002 Ferraioli et al. 2002
Nod+/–Fix+/–
Ferraioli et al. 2002
Nod+/–Fix – Nod+/–Fix – Nod+/–Fix –
Ferraioli et al. 2002 Ferraioli et al. 2002 Ferraioli et al. 2002
Nod+Fix+f Nod+Fix –f Nod++Fix+ Nod++Fix+ Nod+Fix – Nod+Fix –
Hawkins and Johnston 1988 Hawkins et al. 1991 Rosemeyer et al. 1998 Rosemeyer et al. 1998 Xi et al. 2001 Xi et al. 2001
Nod–Fix –
Labidi et al. 2000 (continued)
46 Table 2.3.
Similarity Group
Continued
Genes/orfs
Miscellaneous (cont.) dnaJs
Rhizobial strainz
R. tropici CIAT899
greAs
R. tropici CIAT899
alaSs groESL rmrA
R. tropici CIAT899 S. sp. BR816 R. etli CFN42
rmrB
R. etli CFN42
kdpE
R. tropici CIAT899
kups
R. tropici CIAT899
recA
R. etli CFN42
Function or homologyy
heat shock protein; involved in glutamate metabolism transcriptional elongation factor; stress responsive protein alanyl-tRNA synthetase chaperonin membrane fusion protein major facilitator protein i.p. drug-resistance protein response regulator of two-component regulatory system involved in K+ uptake system recombinase
Phenotype on Phaseolus vulgarisx
Reference
Nod–Fix–
Nogales et al. 2002
Nod+/– Fix+/–
Nogales et al. 2002
Nod+/– Fix+/– Nod+Fix+/– Nod+/– Fix+
Nogales et al. 2002 Luyten 1999 Gonzalez-Pasayo and Martínez-Romero 2000 Gonzalez-Pasayo and Martínez-Romero 2000
Nod+/–Fix+
Cmp+/–e
Botero et al. 2000
Nod+/– Fix+/–
Nogales et al. 2002
NoddFix+
Martínez-Salazar et al. 1991
z Only those rhizobial strains are included that are genetically studied in relation to their symbiotic reaction with P. vulgaris. For a more complete picture of rhizobia nodulating bean, we refer to Michiels et al. (1998a).
y
Functional description was based on sequence similarity as well as in silico analysis and biochemical characterization. Bean phenotype compared to the wild type level of inoculation was scored as follows: enhanced nodulation (Nod++), unaltered nodulation (Nod+), delayed nodulation (NodDd), reduced nodule number (Nod+/–), no nodules formed (Nod–), different nodule development pattern (Ndv–), unaltered infection (Inf+), no infection (Inf –), enhanced N2 fixation (Fix++), unaltered N2 fixation (Fix+), reduced N2 fixation (Fix+/–), no N2 fixation (Fix –), reduced nodulation competitiveness (Cmp–), unaltered nodulation competitiveness (Cmp+) and not determined (ND). w Numbered nodD copies represent multiple alleles. v The authors only mentioned that the formation of nodules was not abolished. u Waelkens et al. (1995) found that these nodS mutants were Nod– on beans. t Increased or decreased nodule numbers were found depending on the inoculated bean cultivar. s Mutation in this gene (or downstream genes) plays a role in adaptation to saline and osmotic stress (Nogales et al. 2002). r ?? = postulated function. q Complementation groups. p The exoB mutant was affected in both LPS and EPS production. o Nitrogenase activity per plant is reduced to 10% of the wild type N2 fixation level. n Numbered nifH copies represent multiple alleles. m Romero et al. (1988) found that the triple nifH mutant is Fix–. l d and f stand for plasmid d and f of the six plasmids present in R. etli. k Nitrogenase activity per plant is reduced to 30% of the wild type level. j Downregulation of the amtB gene is essential for an effective symbiotic interaction. i The authors found that glgA mutants grown in glucose have reduced high-molecular-weight EPS, as well as other pleiotropic effects like increased respiration. h Tabche et al. (1998) report that a mutation in cycH not affecting the downstream genes is Inf+Fix–. g Enhanced N2 fixation is due to mutation in promoter region of this cluster, resulting in constitutive expression of the operon. f No melanin production. e The reduced symbiotic competence is based on initial studies on the symbiotic properties of the kdpE mutant; this gene is involved in the in situ P acquisition of bacteroids from bean nodules. x
47
48
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
(Castillo et al. 2000). Disturbed bacterial carbon metabolism in R. tropici and R. etli mutants, blocked in respectively the synthesis of glycogen and polyhydroxybutyrate, also enhanced symbiotic N2 fixation (Cevallos et al. 1996; Marroqui et al. 2001). B. Nodulation Competitiveness and Persistence in the Soil Studying the genetic basis of Rhizobium nodulation competitiveness is challenging because of the high variability and the fact that it is a quantitative trait. Consequently, so far identified genes affecting competition for nodulation encode a diversity of functions. Various physiological attributes such as bacteriocin and exopolysaccharide production, motility, speed of infection, level of N2 fixation, growth rate, and colonization in the rhizosphere have been shown to be involved in the competitiveness of Rhizobium strains (Triplett and Sadowsky 1992; Vlassak and Vanderleyden 1997). Antimicrobial compounds secreted by rhizobia can detrimentally affect concurrent rhizosphere bacteria. The peptide antibiotic trifolitoxin (TFX), isolated from R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii T24, has been described as a possible means to prevent nodulation by TFX sensitive strains including most Rhizobium spp. but also strains of Agrobacterium and various taxonomically more distant α-proteobacteria (Triplett and Barta 1987). Genetic enhancement of nodulation competitiveness in R. etli expressing the tfx genes was successful both in sterile and non-sterile soil and under field conditions (Robleto et al. 1997; Robleto et al. 1998a). Additionally, Robleto et al. (1998b) clearly demonstrated a reduction in the diversity of α-proteobacteria in the bean rhizosphere after inoculation with the genetically engineered R. etli strain producing TFX as compared to the wild type strain. Rosemeyer et al. (1998) showed that R. etli CNPAF512 produces an autoinducer molecule, which is comparable to a growth inhibiting factor, called small (Schripsema et al. 1996). Small inhibits the growth of closely related strains (Hirsch 1979) and is involved in stationary-phase survival of R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli following nutrient starvation (Thorne and Williams 1999). Although exopolysaccharides (EPS), in contrast to lipopolysaccharides (LPS), do not seem to be essential for Rhizobium invasion in determinate nodules, like those formed on bean plants (Gray and Rolfe 1990), they are indispensable in terms of competitiveness. In R. etli, the transcriptional regulator encoded by rosR was found to be a determinant of nodulation competitiveness (Araujo et al. 1994; Bittinger et al. 1997). Subsequently, Bittinger and Handelsman (2000) demonstrated that a subset of the genes regulated by RosR are involved in cell surface char-
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
49
acteristics as well as nodulation competitivity, strongly suggesting that the altered competitiveness of a rosR mutant is due to dramatic changes in cell surface properties. Also, reduced competitiveness was observed for mutants of R. tropici CIAT899 affected in EPS production (Milner et al. 1992). Rosenblueth et al. (1998) isolated from R. tropici the teu genes (tropici exudate uptake) which are related to sugar transport genes. Interestingly, the inducing compound, though not yet identified, appears to be characteristic for bean and closely related legumes (e.g., Macroptilium) but is not present in soybean, Leucaena, pea, alfalfa, or maize. The bean exudate compound might be advantageous for rhizosphere survival and efficiency of its symbiont. A R. tropici CIAT899 teu mutant strain appeared less competitive than its wild type counterpart. Other approaches to identify genes involved in nodulation competitiveness consisted of transferring a cosmid library of the highly competitive R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli strain KIM5 into the inferior strain R. etli CE3. However, the enhanced competitiveness of the isolated strains was not due to the introduced DNA but probably arose because of spontaneous mutations elsewhere in the genome (Beattie and Handelsman 1993). On the contrary, Borthakur and Gao (1996a) reported the presence of a DNA region on a 150 MDa plasmid (different from the symbiotic plasmid) important for nodulation competitiveness in R. etli strain TAL182 and some other R. etli strains but absent in other Rhizobium spp. One of these genes, slp, encoding a stomatin-like protein, was characterized by You et al. (You et al. 1998). The authors suggest that slp may be of competitive advantage through better ion exchange and nutrient uptake capacity in the infection thread. Increased competitivity was also shown to be plasmid-borne in R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli since four of the six naturally occurring plasmids appear to possess traits for competitiveness (Brom et al. 1992). It was often seen that highly efficient rhizobia introduced in soils with no history of bean production no longer occupy the nodules of their host after 2–3 years of successive bean cropping. Vlassak et al. (1996) could clearly demonstrate in subsequent field trials that R. tropici CIAT899 was the most competitive of the tested inoculant strains after the first year but, in subsequent seasons, planting without reinoculation resulted in a much lower percentage of nodule occupancy by R. tropici CIAT899 (type IIB). Increased bean nodule populations of R. etli (type I) and R. tropici CFN299 (type IIA) were found even in plots that had never been inoculated or in plots only inoculated with type IIB strains. Interestingly, strains isolated from the field with a 3-year bean-planting history were more competitive and totally different compared to the
50
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
population of a plot without bean history (before first planting). This indigenous soil population arose probably from a population present on the seed (Pérez-Ramírez et al. 1998) or from contamination, followed by multiplication. Another possibility is that these indigenous nodulating rhizobia could arise from transfer of symbiotic genes to rhizobia that lack this symbiotic information and by possible genomic rearrangements (Romero et al. 1995). The presence of non-symbiotic strains of R. leguminosarum in the soil has been reported before (Laguerre et al. 1993; Segovía et al. 1993; Soberón-Chavez and Najera 1989). These “new” soil rhizobia are particularly well adapted to the environment and better able to survive and compete than the introduced inoculant strains. In R. etli, symbiotic plasmid transfer is absolutely dependent on the presence of another plasmid (Brom et al. 2000). Interestingly, subsequent multiple plasmid curing of R. etli revealed an accumulating effect of plasmid loss on the nodulation competitiveness of the strain compared to the wild type competition levels. This strongly suggests that Rhizobium plasmids are functionally intimately related. Based on these results, other approaches, directed to the modification of global genomic features through the use of genomic rearrangements such as DNA amplifications, may open other perspectives to understand and manipulate the competitiveness of a given Rhizobium strain (Mavingui et al. 1997). The plant-host genotype is of critical importance for determining the outcome of competition experiments. Strain differences in competitiveness with a single or limited bean cultivar(s) have been welldocumented (Josephson et al. 1991; Vásquez-Arroyo et al. 1998; RodriguezNavarro et al. 2000). Nevertheless, studies in which several host cultivars are utilized to evaluate competitiveness of Rhizobium bacteria are needed to have a better idea of the usefulness of a given strain, since the host genotype strongly influences all of the tested symbiotic characteristics after inoculation with a particular inoculant strain. C. Common Bean Rhizobia Adapted to Different Environmental Factors Soil bacteria are constantly challenged by a variety of stresses in their natural environments. Among these, high temperature and soil acidity are severely affecting all stages of the symbiosis, including the stability of the symbiotic properties of the Rhizobium microsymbiont, and limit Rhizobium growth and survival in tropical soils (Hungria and Vargas 2000). Several studies on the characterization of Rhizobium bean isolates from different soil types clearly revealed that broad-host-range R. tropici-
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
51
type bacteria are predominantly present in acid soils, whereas narrowhost-range R. etli and R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli types predominate in near-neutral soils (Martínez-Romero et al. 1991; Amarger et al. 1994; Anyango et al. 1995; Herrera-Cervera et al. 1999). Both in acid and near neutral soil, characterization of the indigenous isolates revealed a high genetic diversity among these strains. Exploiting this variability to perform screening procedures of large numbers of native strains probably still is the best strategy to overcome environmental factors affecting an optimal symbiotic interaction (Hungria et al. 1993; Hungria et al. 2000; Hungria and Vargas 2000). Therefore, screening programs for competitive and efficient Rhizobium strains performing well in tropical conditions should be encouraged. The analysis of such strains will contribute to unraveling the underlying genetic and biochemical basis of the adaptional ability of a given strain, which in turn can be used to define rational screening procedures. Nevertheless, care should be taken in evaluating strains, since examples of a lack of relationship between ecological origin and in vitro behavior do exist. For example, RodriguezNavarro et al. (2000) found isolates from neutral-alkaline soils showing acidic tolerance in vitro. Wolff et al. (1991) also identified variations in tolerance of the strains to different environmental conditions in vitro that were not related to their relative competitiveness in the field. On the other hand, it is almost impossible to select strains that are resistant to all adverse conditions. The highly competitive strain R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli KIM5 proved to be tolerant to high temperatures and aluminum toxicity but appeared more sensitive than other strains to a low pH and to tannins and phytoalexins, two host defense compounds that inhibit nodulation (Wolff et al. 1993). The broad-host-range type strain R. tropici CIAT899 displays a high intrinsic tolerance to acidity and high temperatures (Martínez-Romero et al. 1991) and has been used for studying the molecular basis of rhizobial responses to survive acid stress and elevated temperatures. The acid pH tolerance of R. tropici does not appear to be an adaptive response, is not plasmid mediated, and the strain shows a limited ability to short-term regulation of cytoplasmic pH (Graham et al. 1994). Recently, Riccillo et al. (2000) characterized a R. tropici CIAT899 Tn5 induced acid-sensitive mutant that was affected in the glutathione synthetase gene gshB. It was demonstrated that glutathione is essential to protect R. tropici CIAT899 against not only environmental stresses such as acidity but also osmotic and oxidative shock, and that the glutathionedeficient mutant strain is affected in its ability to maintain cellular potassium levels. Previous work also led to the observation of higher potassium and glutamate levels in CIAT899 following exposure to low
52
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
pH (Aarons and Graham 1991). Furthermore, bacterial outer membrane composition and structure might play a role in acid tolerance (Graham et al. 1994). The ability of Rhizobium strains to take up glucose has been related to their ability to survive a pH shift (Clarke et al. 1993). Steele et al. (1999) could demonstrate that in R. tropici the glucose uptake mechanism was not sensitive to short- or long-term exposure to acidic conditions, whereas the acid-sensitive R. etli strains tested showed differences in their ability to transport glucose due to short-term and long-term exposure to acidity. Furthermore, the authors showed that under different pH regimes, the susceptibility of the strains to the isoflavone daidzein changes. Daidzein is one of the nod gene-inducing flavonoids in the Phaseolus vulgaris–R. tropici symbiosis (BolanosVásquez and Warner 1997). The idea of implementing a flavonoid nod gene-inducer based strategy for inoculant strains to withstand acid stress conditions is described by Hungria and Stacey (1997). The molecular basis of high temperature tolerance of R. tropici strains is still poorly understood. As R. tropici CIAT899 does not fix atmospheric N2 at elevated temperatures, its symbiotic performance under temperature stress is probably due to its capacity to survive the periods of thermal stress and to recover afterward (Michiels et al. 1994a). The requirement of heat-shock proteins for successful symbiosis was shown in several Rhizobium species (Krishnan and Pueppke 1991; Fischer et al. 1993; Ogawa and Long 1995). The involvement of a 41-kDa heatshock protein encoded by dnaJ in R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli in glutamate metabolism and symbiosis was demonstrated by Labidi et al. (2000). In Sinorhizobium sp. BR816, the chaperonin GroEL was identified as being specifically important for symbiosis with bean but not with Leucaena (Luyten 1999). Stresses in acid soils are not only the direct effect of low pH but also include aluminium and manganese toxicity or deficiency of essential nutrients. Estimates suggest that around 40% of total bean area in Latin America is affected by Al toxicity (CIAT 2000). Aluminium resistance is a trait that varies markedly from strain to strain and does not necessarily correlate with acid tolerance (Wolff et al. 1991). The precise mechanisms involved in tolerance of R. tropici for survival at high aluminium concentrations is still not understood. Although EPS was suggested to play a role in Al protection via binding in several Rhizobium strains, a nonmucoid EPS– mutant of R. tropici CIAT899 was equally as tolerant to aluminium as the parental strains, indicating that EPS does not confer Al resistance in this strain (Kingsley and Bohlool 1992). Furthermore, possible determinants of Al resistance are not located on the pSym plasmid of CIAT899.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
53
Low available P concentrations resulting from complex formation with aluminium could be another cause of the aluminium toxicity observed in acid soils. Understanding the mechanisms by which bacteria acquire phosphorus should contribute in every respect to the identification/construction of strains with an efficient P uptake system at low external P levels. Also, mutants affected in genes for in situ P acquisition of bacteroids will provide useful information concerning phosphorus exchange between the two partners of the symbiosis and should be used in current breeding programs for P efficient crops under N2fixing conditions (see above). Recently, two phosphate (Pi) stressinducible phosphate transport systems were identified in R. tropici CIAT899 differing in their affinities for Pi. A mutant with reduced in situ Pi acquisition by its bacteroids was identified (Botero et al. 2000). Previously, Al-Niemi et al. (1997) showed that under free-living conditions, P transport and phosphatase activity increased in response to P stress in R. tropici CIAT899. Interestingly, high levels of alkaline phosphatase activity were present in bacteroids from nodules of bean plants grown in non-P limiting nutrient solution. The authors suggested that bean plants provide very low levels of Pi to the bacteroids in the nodules under normal growth conditions.
IV. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE PROSPECTS Phaseolus species distinguish themselves from other major grain legume species by their broad genetic base, which holds promises for achieving higher production needs, provided the germplasm is sufficiently evaluated and bred for performance. In spite of this diversity, it is well known that the genetic base of commercial bean cultivars is narrow. Systematic evaluations of wild accessions of common bean and other related species for their responses to diseases, insects, long photoperiod, drought, and low soil fertility are lagging behind as compared to cultivated species. The available genetic resources of Phaseolus should be fully exploited to develop new bean cultivars with enhanced biological N2 fixation, well-protected or adapted to adverse environmental conditions. Inputs of research centers focusing on the molecular aspects of bean and bean interactions with microorganisms should be brought together, whereas future bean breeding strategies should be directly based on integrated approaches proposed by breeders and microbiologists. Future bean breeding and genetic improvement of Rhizobium will benefit from the development of innovative techniques and new biotechnological tools. Molecular marker analysis helped in clarifying genetic
54
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
relationships and levels of genetic diversity in common bean germplasm (Gepts 1998b). This marker technology should be incorporated in bean breeding programs and integrated genetic maps will assist in gene discovery using map-based cloning. As an example, the recent cloning of a Phaseolus resistance gene cluster (R genes) of ancestral origin (comprising both Andean and Mesoamerican resistance specificities) against its fungal pathogen Colletotrichum lindemuthianum has already proven its use in understanding the Phaseolus vulgaris-pathogen coevolution phenomenon at the molecular level in the two independent gene pools (Geffroy et al. 1999). The existence of both major resistance genes and strain-specific QTL against C. lindemuthianum is challenging in terms of defining and selecting an ideotype capable of resisting the complete spectrum of pathogenic diversity (Geffroy et al. 2000). Implementation of a combination of both partial and complete resistance genes to provide durable resistance, especially in developing countries where farmers often cannot afford the purchase of pathogen-free seeds or fungicides, offers new perspectives for improving common bean yield. This strategy has been successfully applied in other crops such as rice (Wang et al. 1994). Although in recent years major progress has been made, a widely applicable transformation and regeneration protocol for Phaseolus is still awaited. Stable and heritable transformation of beans has been successful either via biolistic gene delivery in P. vulgaris (Russell et al. 1993; Aragão et al. 1998) or via Agrobacterium tumefaciens mediated integration in P. acutifolius (Dillen et al. 1997), albeit with a very low frequency of recovery. As the interspecies hybridization among the genus Phaseolus is possible (e.g., P. vulgaris × P. acutifolius) through congruity backcross and using embryo rescue techniques (Mejía-Jiménez et al. 1994), genetic improvement of common bean indirectly is among the possibilities. Good transformation technology will be employed for introducing novel genes to broaden the genetic base of common beans and perform functional analysis of agronomically important genes. The advent of molecular approaches has revolutionized the genetic fingerprinting based on stable (chromosomal) properties (MartínezRomero and Caballero-Mellado 1996; Thies et al. 2001). Phylogenetic studies play an important role in our knowledge of relationships on both sides of the plant-bacteria symbiosis. Multi-locus enzyme electrophoresis, for instance, can be considered as a highly robust tool for deriving estimates of strain relatedness and unraveling potential evolutionary pathways or for assessing bacterial diversity. Ancient lineages of native Rhizobium bacteria seem to have co-evolved with wild Phaseolus species, coinciding with their distribution (Aguilar et al. 1998; Bernal
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
55
and Graham 2001). The resulting broad geographical distribution of Rhizobium species is most probably related to their huge genetic diversity. The mechanisms of generating diversity, influenced by agricultural practices, were recently studied for the traditional mixed cropping of maizebean associations in Mexico, called “milpas” (bean climbing over maize plant) (Gutiérrez-Zamora and Martínez-Romero 2001). Interestingly, a common pool of R. etli strains was found in bean nodules and as naturally occurring maize endophytes. Below, the strategy is given that we are currently following in a program for the implementation of biofertilization in bean cultivation by optimizing the use of Rhizobium-bean symbiosis (Fig. 2.3). Landrace germplasm and new bean lines have been identified at CIAT that produce good yields and are less restricted to phosphate limitation in
Selection criteria for varietal selection based on physiological analysis and molecular markers established Populations developed
Optimization of rhizobial strains and preparation for field release
BNF performance, shoot dry weight, N content at variable N and P levels under greenhouse conditions QTL confirmed in greenhouse
SELECTION
Socio-Economics
Field trials of different Rhizobium-bean combinations Evaluation of yield and competition of rhizobial strains under specific environments (field N, P and climate) QTL confirmed in field over environments
Elucidation of new signals involved
Extrapolation of results obtained in field to other environments
Fig. 2.3. Flow chart of the strategy for integration of biofertilization in bean cultivation by optimizing the use of the Rhizobium-bean symbiosis.
56
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
comparison with the currently available commercial bean lines. From these sources, RIL have been generated for genetic studies and for eventual marking of genes for biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) potential, drought resistance, and low P tolerance with DNA markers. Since N and P are interrelated in plant nutrition, these newly developed lines, which are not commercially available yet, are the best possible starting material to test enhanced BNF under field conditions. Different combinations of selected bean lines and optimized Rhizobium strains will be examined in greenhouse and field trials in Mexico in order to define the optimal environment for selection and the appropriate selection criteria for an efficient bean cultivar and a rhizobial strain in respect to environmental settings. The influence of the applied strain on indigenous bacterial populations will be surveyed, as well as data about survival and competitivity of the inoculum will be obtained, in the long term leading to further elucidation of signals involved and giving input for optimization of inoculant strains. Simultaneously, the value of putative QTL that are potentially of agronomic utility and that have been tentatively identified under controlled conditions will be tested during the field trials to confirm their usefulness in a given set of environments and respective markers are to be converted to suitable PCR-based markers (SCAR or microsatellites). This activity is building up a set of data that will serve to analyze the effect of QTL over sites and therefore determine the range of environments for which the genes can be of use. These activities will lead to the identification of selection criteria for the bean breeding program (either physiological traits or molecular markers) that will permit breeders to recognize and select higher BNF in segregating cultivars and advanced lines. Once QTL are identified, marker assisted backcrossing can be used very effectively to introduce QTL into commercial varieties. In Participatory Breeding Programs, elite genotypes will be backcrossed to local cultivars, such as the small opaque black class, which is the most widely used in Mexico, and in the Flor de Mayo type, which guarantees high prices for farmers, by improving local cultivars such as Negro 8025 and FM Sol. For example, a number of these commercial cultivars from the Mexican plateau could benefit from BNF genes from BAT477, which has proven its potential for BNF in this environment. Geographical Information Systems (GIS) will allow extrapolating data generated during field trials to similar environments that can be expected to give a similar phenotypic response. Recently, a program called “FloraMap” was developed to map environments in which wild ancestors of crop plants can be expected to flourish, through a mathematical comparison of climatic data at known collection sites with that at all other sites (Beebe et al. 1997). Conceptually, it should be possible to perform a similar function with crop plants.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
57
Another important recent development in the field of rhizobia-bean interaction is the genome sequencing of R. etli CFN42 as well as its expression under symbiotic conditions (by transcriptomics and proteomics). So far, the complete nucleotide sequence of the symbiotic plasmid of this strain has been obtained and annotated, and can be consulted at http://www.cifn.unam.mx/retlidb/. Initiatives for comparative genomics with available genome sequencing data of different Rhizobium strains (like Sinorhizobium meliloti and Mesorhizobium loti) are awaited. The bean genome project will undoubtedly speed up integrated research. In Europe, scientific interest in bean breeding for human consumption is also high. A concerted action named PHASELIEU was formed in 1998 by an EU wide network of experts. The group focuses on the elaboration of an integrated model for improvement of Phaseolus production in Europe for human consumption through exchange and dissemination of the knowledge and expertise regarding bean research in Europe. Surprisingly, decisions of policymakers often do not stimulate ongoing bean research despite the current high demand for alternative protein sources in the diet. There is need for a rethinking of current production and consumption processes, moving toward more sustainable processes. Soybean, a major supply of protein in animal feed, is mainly imported in Europe since its production in these countries is limited by climatological factors and international agreements. Another major hurdle can be attributed to the strict EU legislation concerning the use of genetically modified crops in the food chain, which has an important impact on availability and price. Hence, opportunities may be offered for bean cropping for both animal feed as well as human consumption. Research that leads to new bean varieties with higher yields under temperate climate environments and increased nutritional value for potential markets would be valuable. Furthermore, existing molecular markers generated in international research programs can be integrated into European breeding programs. Besides technological factors, the success of bean research relies heavily on socio-economic factors. Yield improvement of sustainable lowinput bean cropping systems will only reach its goal when research centers and farmer unions reflect on the farmers’ needs and their preferences, and specificities of local farming systems. Making beans more competitive on a global scale is an important aspect, but the establishment of regional market niches with its typical, often highly priced bean cultivars adapted to regional environments, with biotic and abiotic constraints, should not be neglected. In addition to the different market classes of dry bean of major economic importance in the world, some dry
58
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
beans that are produced and consumed on a smaller scale are highly valued and appreciated locally (for example, Flor de Mayo and other closely related types or variants, produced under both irrigation and rainfed farming systems in the central highlands of Mexico) because of high yield potential and moderate levels of tolerance to low soil fertility and water stress. Other examples are Bolón Amarillo in Ecuador, the Rosinha type in Brazil, Cargamanto in Colombia, Kablankati type in Tanzania, and the ñuña or popping bean that only grows in the highlands of Peru and Bolivia (Singh 1999b). LITERATURE CITED Aarons, S. R., and P. H. Graham. 1991. Response of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli to acidity. Plant Soil 134:145–151. Adam-Blondon, A. F., M. Sevignac, M. Dron, and H. Bannerot. 1994. A genetic map of common bean to localize specific resistance genes against anthracnose. Genome 37:915–924. Aguilar, G. R., and M. Soberón. 1996. Cloning and sequence analysis of the Rhizobium etli ccmA and ccmB genes involved in c-type cytochrome biogenesis. Gene 182:129–135. Aguilar, O. M., M. V. Lopez, P. M. Riccillo, R. A. Gonzalez, M. Pagano, D. H. Grasso, A. Pühler, and G. Favelukes. 1998. Prevalence of the Rhizobium etli-like allele in genes coding for 16S rRNA among the indigenous rhizobial populations found associated with wild beans from the Southern Andes in Argentina. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64:3520– 3524. Allaway, D., B. Jeyaretnam, R. W. Carlson, and P. S. Poole. 1996. Genetic and chemical characterization of a mutant that disrupts synthesis of the lipopolysaccharide core tetrasaccharide in Rhizobium leguminosarum. J. Bacteriol. 178:6403–6406. Al-Niemi, T. S., M. L. Kahn, and T. R. McDermott. 1997. P metabolism in the bean Rhizobium tropici symbiosis. Plant Physiol. 113:1233–1242. Alzate-Marin, A. L., G. S. Baia, T. J. de Paula, G. A. de Carvalho, E. G. de Barros, and M. A. Moreira. 1997. Inheritance of anthracnose resistance in common bean differential cultivar AB 136. Plant Dis. 81:996–998. Amarger, N., M. Bours, F. Revoy, M. R. Allard, and G. Laguerre. 1994. Rhizobium tropici nodulates field-grown Phaseolus vulgaris in France. Plant Soil 161:147–156. Amarger, N., V. Macheret, and G. Laguerre. 1997. Rhizobium gallicum sp. nov. and Rhizobium giardinii sp. nov., from Phaseolus vulgaris nodules. Intl. J. Syst. Bacteriol. 47: 996–1006. Anyango, B., K. J. Wilson, J. L. Beynon, and K. E. Giller. 1995. Diversity of rhizobia nodulating Phaseolus vulgaris L. in 2 Kenyan soils with contrasting pHs. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61:4016–4021. Aragão, F. J. L., S. G. Ribeiro, L. M. G. Barros, A. C. M. Brasileiro, D. P. Maxwell, E. L. Rech, and J. C. Faria. 1998. Transgenic beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) engineered to express viral antisense RNAs show delayed and attenuated symptoms to bean golden mosaic geminivirus. Mol. Breed. 4:491–499. Araujo, A. P., and M. G. Teixeira. 2000. Ontogenetic variations on absorption and utilization of phosphorus in common bean cultivars under biological nitrogen fixation. Plant Soil 225:1–10.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
59
Araujo, A. P., M. G. Teixeira, and D. L. de Almeida. 1998. Variability of traits associated with phosphorus efficiency in wild and cultivated genotypes of common bean. Plant Soil 203:173–182. Araujo, R. S., E. A. Robleto, and J. Handelsman. 1994. A hydrophobic mutant of Rhizobium etli altered in nodulation competitiveness and growth in the rhizosphere. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 60:1430–1436. Bala, A., and K. E. Giller. 2001. Symbiotic specificity of tropical tree rhizobia for host legumes. New Phytol. 149:495–507. Barron, J. E., R. J. Pasini, D. W. Davis, D. D. Stuthman, and P. H. Graham. 1999. Response to selection for seed yield and nitrogen (N2) fixation in common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Field Crops Res. 62:119–128. Beattie, G. A., and J. Handelsman. 1993. Evaluation of a strategy for identifying nodulation competitiveness genes in Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli. J. Gen. Microbiol. 139:529–538. Beebe, S., J. Lynch, N. Galwey, J. Tohme, and I. Ochoa. 1997. A geographical approach to identify phosphorus-efficient genotypes among landraces and wild ancestors of common bean. Euphytica 95:325–336. Beebe, S., F. Pedraza, M. Rojas, J. Gutierrez, and J. Tohme. 1998. A genetic map of common bean combining RFLP, RAPD, SCAR and AFLP markers. Annu. Rep. Bean. Improv. Coop. 41:95–96. Beebe, S., P. W. Skroch, J. Tohme, M. C. Duque, F. Pedraza, and J. Nienhuis. 2000. Structure of genetic diversity among common bean landraces of Middle American origin based on correspondence analysis of RAPD. Crop Sci. 40:264–273. Bernal, G., and P. H. Graham. 2001. Diversity in the rhizobia associated with Phaseolus vulgaris L. in Ecuador, and comparisons with Mexican bean rhizobia. Can. J. Microbiol. 47:526–534. Bittinger, M. A., and J. Handelsman. 2000. Identification of genes in the RosR regulon of Rhizobium etli. J. Bacteriol. 182:1706–1713. Bittinger, M. A., J. L. Milner, B. J. Saville, and J. Handelsman. 1997. rosR, a determinant of nodulation competitiveness in Rhizobium etli. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 10: 180–186. Bliss, F. A. 1985. Breeding for enhanced dinitrogen fixation potential of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). p. 303–310. In: P. W. Ludden and J. E. Burris (eds.), Nitrogen fixation and CO2 metabolism. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Bliss, F. A. 1993. Breeding common bean for improved biological nitrogen-fixation. Plant Soil 152:71–79. Bliss, F. A., P. A. A. Pereira, R. S. Araujo, R. A. Henson, K. A. Kmiecik, J. R. McFerson, M. G. Teixeira, and C. C. Dasilva. 1989. Registration of 5 high nitrogen-fixing common bean germplasm lines. Crop Sci. 29:240–241. Bolanos-Vásquez, M. C., and D. Warner. 1997. Effects of Rhizobium tropici, R. etli, and R. leguminosarum bv. phaseoli on nod gene-inducing flavonoids in root exudates of Phaseolus vulgaris. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 10:339–346. Bonser, A. M., J. Lynch, and S. Snapp. 1996. Effect of phosphorus deficiency on growth angle of basal roots in Phaseolus vulgaris. New Phytol. 132:281–288. Borthakur, D., and X. Gao. 1996b. The Rhizobium etli nfeD gene is required for nodulation competitiveness in Phaseolus vulgaris L. Genbank Accession #U41754. Borthakur, D., and X. F. Gao. 1996a. A 150-megadalton plasmid in Rhizobium etli strain TAL182 contains genes for nodulation competitiveness on Phaseolus vulgaris L. Can. J. Microbiol. 42:903–910.
60
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
Borthakur, D., and A. W. B. Johnston. 1987. Sequence of psi, a gene on the symbiotic plasmid of Rhizobium phaseoli which inhibits exopolysaccharide synthesis and nodulation and demonstration that its transcription is inhibited by psr, another gene on the symbiotic plasmid. Mol. Gen. Genet. 207:149–154. Borthakur, D., C. E. Barber, J. W. Lamb, M. J. Daniels, J. A. Downie, and A. W. B. Johnston. 1986. A mutation that blocks exopolysaccharide synthesis prevents nodulation of peas by Rhizobium leguminosarum but not of beans by R. phaseoli and is corrected by cloned DNA from Rhizobium or the phytopathogen Xanthomonas. Mol. Gen. Genet. 203:320–323. Borthakur, D., J. A. Downie, A. W. B. Johnston, and J. W. Lamb. 1985. psi, a plasmid-linked Rhizobium phaseoli gene that inhibits exopolysaccharide production and which is required for symbiotic nitrogen-fixation. Mol. Gen. Genet. 200:278–282. Borthakur, D., J. W. Lamb, and A. W. B. Johnston. 1987. Identification of 2 classes of Rhizobium phaseoli genes required for melanin synthesis, one of which is required for nitrogen fixation and activates the transcription of the other. Mol. Gen. Genet. 207:155–160. Botero, L. M., T. S. Al Niemi, and T. R. McDermott. 2000. Characterization of two inducible phosphate transport systems in Rhizobium tropici. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 66:15–22. Brink, B. A., J. Miller, R. W. Carlson, and K. D. Noel. 1990. Expression of Rhizobium leguminosarum CFN42 genes for lipopolysaccharide in strains derived from different R. leguminosarum soil isolates. J. Bacteriol. 172:548–555. Brom, S., A. G. Delossantos, T. Stepkowsky, M. Flores, G. Davila, D. Romero, and R. Palacios. 1992. Different plasmids of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli are required for optimal symbiotic performance. J. Bacteriol. 174:5183–5189. Brom, S., A. Garcia-de los Santos, L. Cervantes, R. Palacios, and D. Romero. 2000. In Rhizobium etli symbiotic plasmid transfer, nodulation competitivity and cellular growth require interaction among different replicons. Plasmid 44:34–43. Broughton, W. J., G. Hernández, M. Blair, S. Beebe, P. Gepts, and J. Vanderleyden. 2002. Beans (Phaseolus spp.)—model food legumes. Plant Soil 252:55–128. Buttery, B. R., and S. J. Park. 1990. Effect of nitrogen, inoculation and grafting on the expression of supernodulation in a mutant of Phaseolus vulgaris L. Can. J. Plant Sci. 70:375–381. Buttery, B. R., S. J. Park, and B. N. Dhauvantari. 1990. Effect of combined nitrogen, Rhizobium strain and substrate on a supernodulation mutant of Phaseolus vulgaris L. Can. J. Plant Sci. 70:935–963. Cárdenas, L., J. Domínguez, O. Santana, and C. Quinto. 1996. The role of the nodI and nodJ genes in the transport of Nod metabolites in Rhizobium etli. Gene 173:183–187. Carroll, B. J., D. L. McNeil, and P. M. Gresshoff. 1985. A supernodulation and nitratetolerant symbiotic (nts) soybean mutant. Plant Physiol. 78:34–40. Castillo, A., H. Taboada, A. Mendoza, B. Valderrama, S. Encarnación, and J. Mora. 2000. Role of GOGAT in carbon and nitrogen partitioning in Rhizobium etli. MicrobiologyUK 146:1627–1637. Catroux, G., A. Hartmann, and C. Revellin. 2001. Trends in rhizobial inoculant production and use. Plant Soil 230:21–30. Cava, J. R., P. M. Elias, D. A. Turowski, and K. D. Noel. 1989. Rhizobium leguminosarum CFN42 genetic regions encoding lipopolysaccharide structures essential for complete nodule development on bean-plants. J. Bacteriol. 171:8–15. Cava, J. R., H. Tao, and K. D. Noel. 1990. Mapping of complementation groups within a Rhizobium leguminosarum CFN42 chromosomal region required for lipopolysaccharide synthesis. Mol. Gen. Genet. 221:125–128. Cevallos, M. A., S. Encarnación, A. Leija, Y. Mora, and J. Mora. 1996. Genetic and physiological characterization of a Rhizobium etli mutant strain unable to synthesize polybeta-hydroxybutyrate. J. Bacteriol. 178:1646–1654.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
61
CIAT (Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical). 1998. Bean Program Annual Report. CIAT, Cali, Colombia. CIAT (Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical). 2000. Bean Program Annual Report. CIAT, Cali, Colombia. Ciereszko, I., A. Gniazdowska, M. Mikulska, and A. M. Rychter. 1996. Assimilate translocation in bean plants (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) during phosphate deficiency. J. Plant Physiol. 149:343–348. Ciereszko, I., A. Zambrzycka, and A. Rychter. 1998. Sucrose hydrolysis in bean roots (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) under phosphate deficiency. Plant Sci. 133:139–144. Clarke, L. M., M. J. Dilworth, and A. R. Glenn. 1993. Survival of Rhizobium meliloti WSM419 in laboratory culture—effect of combined pH shock and carbon substrate stress. Soil Biol. Biochem. 25:1289–1291. Corvera, A., D. Promé, J.-C. Promé, E. Martínez-Romero, and D. Romero. 1999. The nolL gene from Rhizobium etli determines nodulation efficiency by mediating the acetylation of the fucosyl residue in the nodulation factor. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 12:236–246. Cregan, P. B., H. H. Keyser, and M. J. Sadowsky. 1989. Soybean genotype restricting nodulation of a previously unrestricted serocluster-123 Bradyrhizobia. Crop Sci. 29:307–312. D’Hooghe, I., J. Michiels, K. Vlassak, C. Verreth, F. Waelkens, and J. Vanderleyden. 1995. Structural and functional analysis of the fixLJ genes of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli CNPAF512. Mol. Gen. Genet. 249:117–126. D’Hooghe, I., C. VanderWauven, J. Michiels, C. Tricot, P. deWilde, J. Vanderleyden, and V. Stalon. 1997. The arginine deaminase pathway in Rhizobium etli: DNA sequence analysis and functional study of the arcABC genes. J. Bacteriol. 179:7403–7409. Daba, S., and M. Haile. 2002. Effects of rhizobial inoculant and nitrogen fertilizer on yield and nodulation of common bean under intercropped conditions. J. Plant Nutr. 25:1443– 1455. Dakora, F. D. 1998. Nodule function in symbiotic bambara groundnut (Vigna subterranea L.) and Kersting’s bean (Macrotyloma geocarpum L.) is tolerant of nitrate in the root medium. Ann. Bot. 82:687–690. Daniels, R., D. E. De Vos, J. Desair, G. Raedschelders, E. Luyten, V. Rosemeyer, C. Verreth, E. Schoeters, J. Vanderleyden, and J. Michiels. 2002. The cin quorum-sensing locus of Rhizobium etli CNPAF512 affects growth and symbiotic nitrogen fixation. J. Biol. Chem. 277:462–468. Danso, S. K. A., and G. D. Bowen. 1989. Methods of inoculation and how they influence nodulation pattern and nitrogen fixation using 2 contrasting strains of Bradyrhizobium japonicum. Soil Biol. Biochem. 21:1053–1058. Date, R. A. 2000. Inoculated legumes in cropping systems of the tropics. Field Crops Res. 65:123–136. Davis, E. O., and A. W. B. Johnston. 1990. Regulatory functions of the 3 nodD genes of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli. Mol. Microbiol. 4:933–941. Day, D. A., H. Lambers, J. Bateman, B. J. Carroll, and P. M. Gresshoff. 1986. Growth comparisons of a supernodulating soybean (Glycine max) mutant and its wildtype parent. Physiol. Plant. 68:375–382. Debouck D. G. 1994. Beans (Phaseolus spp.). p. 47–62. In: J. E. Hernández Bermejo and J. Léon, Neglected crops: 1492 from a different perspective. FAO, Rome. Delves, A. C., A. Mathews, D. A. Day, A. S. Carter, B. J. Carroll, and P. M. Gresshoff. 1986. Regulation of the soybean-Rhizobium nodule symbiosis by root and shoot factors. Plant Physiol. 82:588–590. Diebold, R., and K. D. Noel. 1989. Rhizobium leguminosarum exopolysaccharide mutants—biochemical and genetic analyses and symbiotic behavior on 3 hosts. J. Bacteriol. 171:4821–4830.
62
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
Dillen, W., J. De Clercq, A. Goossens, M. Van Montagu, and G. Angenon. 1997. Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of Phaseolus acutifolius A. Gray. Theor. Appl. Genet. 94:151–158. Dombrecht, B. 2001. The complex regulation and role of the Rhizobium etli RpoN regulon in the symbiotic interaction with the common bean plant (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Ph.D. thesis, K. U. Leuven, Belgium. Dombrecht, B., M. Z. Tesfay, C. Verreth, C. Heusdens, M. C. Nápoles, J. Vanderleyden, and J. Michiels. 2002. Rhizobium etli iscN is highly expressed in bacteroids and required for nitrogen fixation. Mol. Genet. Genom. 267:820–828. Duc, G., A. Trouvelot, V. Gianinazzi Pearson, and S. Gianinazzi. 1989. First report of nonmycorrhizal plant mutants (Myc–) obtained in pea (Pisum sativum L.) and Faba bean (Vicia faba L.). Plant Sci. 60:215–222. Duelli, D. M., A. Tobin, J. M. Box, V. S. Kolli, R. W. Carlson, and K. D. Noel. 2001. Genetic locus required for antigenic maturation of Rhizobium etli CE3 lipopolysaccharide. J. Bacteriol. 183:6054–6064. Eardly, B. D., F. S. Wang, T. S. Whittam, and R. K. Selander. 1995. Species limits in Rhizobium populations that nodulate the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris). Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61:507–512. Endre, G., A. Kereszt, Z. Kevei, S. Mihacea, P. Kaló, and G. B. Kiss. 2002. A receptor kinase gene regulating symbiotic nodule development. Nature 417:962–966. FAO (Food and Agricultural Organization). 2001. http://apps.fao.org/cgi-bin/nph-db.pl? subset=agriculture. Ferraioli, S., R. Taté, E. Caputo, A. Lamberti, A. Riccio, and E. J. Patriarca. 2001. The Rhizobium etli argC gene is essential for arginine biosynthesis and nodulation of Phaseolus vulgaris. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 14:250–254. Ferraioli, S., R. Taté, M. Cermola, R. Favre, M. Iaccarino, and E. J. Patriarca. 2002. Auxotrophic mutant strains of Rhizobium etli reveal new nodule development phenotypes. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 15:501–510. Fischer, H. M., M. Babst, T. Kaspar, G. Acuna, F. Arigoni, and H. Hennecke. 1993. One member of a groESL-like chaperonin multigene family in Bradyrhizobium japonicum is coregulated with symbiotic nitrogen-fixation genes. EMBO Journal 12:2901–2912. Folch-Mallol, J. L., S. Marroqui, C. Sousa, H. Manyani, I. M. Lopez-Lara, K. M. G. M. vanderDrift, J. Haverkamp, C. Quinto, A. GilSerrano, J. Thomas-Oates, H. P. Spaink, and M. Megias. 1996. Characterization of Rhizobium tropici CIAT899 nodulation factors: the role of nodH and nodPQ genes in their sulfation. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 9:151–163. Freyre, R., P. W. Skroch, V. Geffroy, A. F. Adam-Blondon, A. Shirmohamadali, W. C. Johnson, V. Llaca, R. O. Nodari, P. A. Pereira, S. M. Tsai, J. Tohme, M. Dron, J. Nienhuis, C. E. Vallejos, and P. Gepts. 1998. Towards an integrated linkage map of common bean. 4. Development of a core linkage map and alignment of RFLP maps. Theor. Appl. Genet. 97:847–856. Garcia de los Santos, A., and S. Brom. 1997. Characterization of two plasmid-borne lps beta loci of Rhizobium etli required for lipopolysaccharide synthesis and for optimal interaction with plants. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 10:891–902. Geffroy, V., M. Sévignac, J. C. F. de Oliveira, G. Fouilloux, P. Skroch, P. Thoquet, P. Gepts, T. Langin, and M. Dron. 2000. Inheritance of partial resistance against Colletotrichum lindemuthianum in Phaseolus vulgaris and co-localization of quantitative trait loci with genes involved in specific resistance. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 13:287–296. Geffroy, V., D. Sicard, J. C. F. de Oliveira, M. Sévignac, S. Cohen, P. Gepts, C. Neema, T. Langin, and M. Dron. 1999. Identification of an ancestral resistance gene cluster
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
63
involved in the coevolution process between Phaseolus vulgaris and its fungal pathogen Colletotrichum lindemuthianum. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 12:774–784. Gepts, P. 1998a. Origin and evolution of common bean: past events and recent trends. HortScience 33:1124–1130. Gepts, P. 1998b. What can molecular markers tell us about the process of domestication in common bean? p. 198–209. In: A. Damania et al. (eds.), The origins of agriculture and crop domestication. ICARDA, Aleppo, Syria. Gepts, P. 1999. Development of an integrated linkage map. p. 53–91. In: S. P. Singh (ed.), Common bean improvement in the twenty-first century. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht. Gepts, P., and D. Debouck. 1991. Origin, domestication, and evolution of the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). p. 7–53. In: A. van Schoonhoven and O. Voyest (eds.), Common beans: research for crop improvement. C.A.B. International, Wallingford, UK and CIAT, Colombia. Gepts, P., T. C. Osborn, K. Rashka, and F. A. Bliss. 1986. Phaseolin-protein variability in wild forms and landraces of the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris)—evidence for multiple centers of domestication. Econ. Bot. 40:451–468. Girard, L., S. Brom, A. Davalos, O. Lopez, M. Soberón, and D. Romero. 2000. Differential regulation of fixN-reiterated genes in Rhizobium etli by a novel fixL-fixK-cascade. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 13:1283–1292. Gniazdowska, A., M. Mikulska, and A. M. Rychter. 1998. Growth, nitrate uptake and respiration rate in bean roots under phosphate deficiency. Biologia Plantarum 41:217–226. Gonzalez-Pasayo, R., and E. Martínez-Romero. 2000. Multiresistance genes of Rhizobium etli CFN42. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 13:572–577. Graham, P. H., K. J. Draeger, M. L. Ferrey, M. J. Conroy, B. E. Hammer, E. Martínez, S. R. Aarons, and C. Quinto. 1994. Acid pH tolerance in strains of Rhizobium and Bradyrhizobium, and initial studies on the basis for acid tolerance of Rhizobium tropici UMR1899. Can. J. Microbiol. 40:198–207. Gray, J. X., and B. G. Rolfe. 1990. Exopolysaccharide production in Rhizobium and its role in invasion. Mol. Microbiol. 4:1425–1431. Gresshoff, P. M. 1993. Molecular genetic analysis of nodulation genes in soybean. Plant Breed. Rev. 11:275–319. Gu, W. K., N. F. Weeden, D. H. Wallace, and S. Singh. 1993. A DNA marker for ppd, a gene conferring insensitivity to photoperiod in common bean. Annu. Rep. Bean Improv. Coop. 36:1–2. Gu, W., N. Weeden, J. Zhu, and D. Wallace. 1994. Identification of a DNA marker for hr, a gene that interacts with Ppd to confer extreme photoperiod sensitivity. Annu. Rep. Bean Improv. Coop. 37:125–126. Gutiérrez-Zamora, M. L., and E. Martínez-Romero. 2001. Natural endophytic association between Rhizobium etli and maize (Zea mays L.). J. Biotechnol. 91:117–126. Haley, S. D., L. Afanador, and J. D. Kelly. 1994. Identification and application of a random amplified polymorphic DNA marker for the I gene (potyvirus resistance) in common bean. Phytopathology 84:157–160. Haley, S. D., P. N. Miklas, J. R. Stavely, J. Byrum, and J. D. Kelly. 1993. Identification of RAPD markers linked to a major rust resistance gene block in common bean. Theor. Appl. Genet. 86:505–512. Hardarson, G., M. Golbs, and S. K. A. Danso. 1989. Nitrogen fixation in soybean (Glycine max L. Merrill) as affected by nodulation patterns. Soil Biol. Biochem. 21:783–787. Hardarson, G., F. A. Bliss, M. R. Cigalesrivero, R. A. Henson, J. A. Kipenolt, L. Longeri, A. Manrique, J. J. Penacabriales, P. A. A. Pereira, C. A. Sanabria, and S. M. Tsai. 1993.
64
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
Genotypic variation in biological nitrogen-fixation by common bean. Plant Soil 152: 59–70. Hawkins, F. K. L., and A. W. B. Johnston. 1988. Transcription of a Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli gene needed for melanin synthesis is activated by nifA of Rhizobium and Klebsiella pneumoniae. Mol. Microbiol. 2:331–337. Hawkins, F. K. L., C. Kennedy, and A. W. B. Johnston. 1991. A Rhizobium leguminosarum gene required for symbiotic nitrogen-fixation, melanin synthesis and normal growth on certain growth media. J. Gen. Microbiol. 137:1721–1728. Helal, H. M., H. Arisha, and E. Rietz. 1990. The uptake of trace-elements by spinach and bean varieties of different root parameters. Plant Soil 123:229–232. Hernández-Lucas, I., M. Pardo, L. Segovía, J. Miranda, and E. Martínez-Romero. 1995a. Rhizobium tropici chromosomal citrate synthase gene. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61:3992– 3997. Hernández-Lucas, I., L. Segovía, E. Martínez-Romero, and S. G. Pueppke. 1995b. Phylogenetic relationships and host range of Rhizobium spp. that nodulate Phaseolus vulgaris L. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 61:2775–2779. Herrera-Cervera, J. A., J. Caballero-Mellado, G. Laguerre, H. V. Tichy, N. Requena, N. Amarger, E. Martínez-Romero, J. Olivares, and J. Sanjuan. 1999. At least five rhizobial species nodulate Phaseolus vulgaris in a Spanish soil. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 30:87–97. Herridge, D., and I. Rose. 2000. Breeding for enhanced nitrogen fixation in crop legumes. Field Crops Res. 65:229–248. Hirsch, P. R. 1979. Plasmid-determined bacteriocin production by Rhizobium leguminosarum. J. Gen. Microbiol. 113:219–228. Hungria, M., and G. Stacey. 1997. Molecular signals exchanged between host plants and rhizobia: basic aspects and potential application in agriculture. Soil Biol. Biochem. 29:819–830. Hungria, M., and M. A. T. Vargas. 2000. Environmental factors affecting N2 fixation in grain legumes in the tropics, with an emphasis on Brazil. Field Crops Res. 65:151–164. Hungria, M., D. D. Andrade, L. M. D. Chueire, A. Probanza, F. J. Guttierrez-Manero, and M. Megias. 2000. Isolation and characterization of new efficient and competitive bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) rhizobia from Brazil. Soil Biol. Biochem. 32:1515–1528. Hungria, M., A. A. Franco, and J. I. Sprent. 1993. New sources of high-temperature tolerant rhizobia for Phaseolus vulgaris L. Plant Soil 149:103–109. Islam, F. M. A., K. E. Basford, R. J. Redden, A. V. Gonzalez, P. M. Kroonenberg, and S. Beebe. 2002. Genetic variability in cultivated common bean beyond the two major gene pools. Gen. Res. Crop Evol. 49:271–283. Johnson, W., and P. Gepts. 2002. The role of epistasis in controlling seed yield and other agronomic traits in an Andean × Mesoamerican cross of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Euphytica 125:69–79. Johnson, W. C., P. Guzman, D. Mandala, A. B. C. Mkandawire, S. Temple, R. L. Gilbertson, and P. Gepts. 1997. Molecular tagging of the bc-3 gene for introgression into Andean common bean. Crop Sci. 37:248–254. Jordan, D. C. 1984. Family III: Rhizobiaceae. p. 234–242. In: N. R. Krieg and J. G. Holt (eds.), Bergey’s manual of systematic bacteriology. Williams and Wilkins Co., Baltimore, MD. Josephson, K. L., D. P. Bourque, F. A. Bliss, and I. L. Pepper. 1991. Competitiveness of kim5 and viking-1 bean rhizobia–strain by cultivar interactions. Soil Biol. Biochem. 23:249–253. Jung, G. W., D. P. Coyne, P. W. Skroch, J. Nienhuis, E. Arnaud-Santana, J. Bokosi, H. M. Ariyarathne, J. R. Steadman, J. S. Beaver, and S. M. Kaeppler. 1996. Molecular markers associated with plant architecture and resistance to common blight, web blight, and rust in common beans. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 121:794–803.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
65
Jung, G., P. W. Skroch, D. P. Coyne, J. Nienhuis, E. Arnaud-Santana, H. M. Ariyarathne, S. M. Kaeppler, and M. J. Bassett. 1997. Molecular-marker-based genetic analysis of tepary bean-derived common bacterial blight resistance in different developmental stages of common bean. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 122:329–337. Kaplan, L., and T. Lynch. 1999. Phaseolus (Fabaceae) in archaeology: AMS radiocarbon dates and their significance for pre-Columbian agriculture. Econ. Bot. 53:261–272. Kelly, J., P. Gepts, P. Miklas, and D. Coyne. 2003. Tagging and mapping of genes and QTL and molecular marker-assisted selection for traits of economic importance in bean and cowpea. Field Crops Res. 82:135–154. Kingsley, M. T., and B. Bohlool. 1992. Extracellular polysaccharide is not responsible for aluminium tolerance of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli CIAT899. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 58:1095–1101. Kipe-Nolt, J. A., C. M. Montealegre, and J. Tohme. 1992. Restriction of nodulation by the broad host range Rhizobium tropici strain CIAT899 in wild accessions of Phaseolus vulgaris L. New Phytol. 120:489–494. Koinange, E. M. K., S. P. Singh, and P. Gepts. 1996. Genetic control of the domestication syndrome in common-bean. Crop Sci. 36:1037–1045. Krishnan, H. B., and S. G. Pueppke. 1991. nolC, a Rhizobium fredii gene involved in cultivar-specific nodulation of soybean, shares homology with a heat-shock gene. Mol. Microbiol. 5:737–745. Labidi, M., S. Laberge, L. P. Vezina, and H. Antoun. 2000. The dnaJ (hsp40) locus in Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli is required for the establishment of an effective symbiosis with Phaseolus vulgaris. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 13:1271–1274. Laeremans, T., and J. Vanderleyden. 1998. Infection and nodulation signalling in RhizobiumPhaseolus vulgaris symbiosis. World J. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 14:787–808. Laeremans, T., I. Caluwaerts, C. Verreth, M. A. Rogel, J. Vanderleyden, and E. MartínezRomero. 1996. Isolation and characterization of the Rhizobium tropici Nod factor sulfation genes. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 9:492–500. Laeremans, T., N. Coolsaet, C. Verreth, C. Snoeck, N. Hellings, J. Vanderleyden, and E. Martínez-Romero. 1997. Functional redundancy of genes for sulfate activation enzymes in Rhizobium sp. BR816. Microbiology 143:3933–3942. Laguerre, G., E. Geniaux, S. I. Mazurier, R. R. Casartelli, and N. Amarger. 1993. Conformity and diversity among field isolates of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae, bv. trifolii, and bv. phaseoli revealed by DNA hybridization using chromosome and plasmid probes. Can. J. Microbiol. 39:412–419. Latchford, J. W., D. Borthakur, and A. W. B. Johnston. 1991. The products of Rhizobium genes, psi and pss, which affect exopolysaccharide production, are associated with the bacterial cell surface. Mol. Microbiol. 5:2107–2114. Lerouge, I., T. Laeremans, C. Verreth, J. Vanderleyden, C. Van Soom, A. Tobin, and R. W. Carlson. 2001. Identification of an ATP-binding cassette transporter for export of the O-antigen across the inner membrane in Rhizobium etli based on the genetic, functional, and structural analysis of an lps mutant deficient in O-antigen. J. Biol. Chem. 276:17190–17198. Liao, H., G. Rubio, X. L. Yan, A. Q. Cao, K. M. Brown, and J. P. Lynch. 2001. Effect of phosphorus availability on basal root shallowness in common bean. Plant Soil 232:69–79. Luyten, E. 1999. Analysis of a Rhizobium sp. BR816 megaplasmid region that is involved in host range extension and symbiotic efficiency. Ph.D. thesis, K. U. Leuven, Belgium. Lynch, J. P., and S. E. Beebe. 1995. Adaptation of beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) to low phosphorus availability. HortScience 30:1165–1171. Lynch, J., and J. J. Vanbeem. 1993. Growth and architecture of seedling roots of common bean genotypes. Crop Sci. 33:1253–1257.
66
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
Marroqui, S., A. Zorreguieta, C. Santamaria, F. Temprano, M. Soberón, M. Megias, and J. A. Downie. 2001. Enhanced symbiotic performance by Rhizobium tropici glycogen synthase mutants. J. Bacteriol. 183:854–864. Martínez, E., M. A. Pardo, R. Palacios, and M. A. Cevallos. 1985. Reiteration of nitrogen fixation gene sequences and specificity of Rhizobium in nodulation and nitrogenfixation in Phaseolus vulgaris. J. Gen. Microbiol. 131:1779–1786. Martínez-Romero, E., and J. Caballero-Mellado. 1996. Rhizobium phylogenies and bacterial genetic diversity. Crit. Rev. Plant Sci. 15:113–140. Martínez-Romero, E., L. Segovía, F. M. Mercante, A. A. Franco, P. Graham, and M. A. Pardo. 1991. Rhizobium tropici, a novel species nodulating Phaseolus vulgaris L. beans and Leucaena sp. trees. Intl. J. Syst. Bacteriol. 41:417–426. Martínez-Salazar, J. M., D. Romero, M. D. Girard, and G. Davila. 1991. Molecular cloning and characterization of the recA gene of Rhizobium phaseoli and construction of recA mutants. J. Bacteriol. 173:3035–3040. Mavingui, P., M. Flores, D. Romero, E. Martínez-Romero, and R. Palacios. 1997. Generation of Rhizobium strains with improved symbiotic properties by random DNA amplification (RDA). Nature Biotechnol. 15:564–569. Mejía-Jiménez, A., C. Munoz, H. J. Jacobsen, W. Roca, and S. P. Singh. 1994. Interspecific hybridization between common and tepary beans—increased hybrid embryo growth, fertility and efficiency of hybridization through recurrent and congruity backcrossing. Theor. Appl. Genet. 88:324–331. Melotto, M., L. Afanador, and J. D. Kelly. 1996. Development of a SCAR marker linked to the I gene in common bean. Genome 39:1216–1219. Melotto, M., L. Afanador, and J. Kelly. 1997. SCAR markers linked to major disease resistance genes in common bean. Bean Improv. Coop. Annual Meeting Abstr. Annapolis, MD. November 4–7. Mendoza, A., F. Hernandez, S. Hernandez, D. Ruiz, O. M. de la Vega, G. Mora, J. Acosta, and J. Simpson. 2001. Identification of Co-1 anthracnose resistance and linked molecular markers in common bean line A193. Plant Dis. 85:252–255. Michiels, J., I. Dhooghe, C. Verreth, H. Pelemans, and J. Vanderleyden. 1994b. Characterization of the Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli nifA gene, a positive regulator of nif gene-expression. Arch. Microbiol. 161:404–408. Michiels, J., B. Dombrecht, N. Vermeiren, C. W. Xi, E. Luyten, and J. Vanderleyden. 1998a. Phaseolus vulgaris is a non-selective host for nodulation. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 26:193–205. Michiels, J., M. Moris, B. Dombrecht, C. Verreth, and J. Vanderleyden. 1998c. Differential regulation of Rhizobium etli rpoN2 gene expression during symbiosis and free-living growth. J. Bacteriol. 180:3620–3628. Michiels, J., H. Pelemans, K. Vlassak, C. Verreth, and J. Vanderleyden. 1995. Identification and characterization of a Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli gene that is important for nodulation competitiveness and shows structural homology to a Rhizobium fredii host-inducible gene. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 8:468–472. Michiels, J., T. Van Soom, I. D’Hooghe, B. Dombrecht, T. Benhassine, P. de Wilde, and J. Vanderleyden. 1998b. The Rhizobium etli rpoN locus: DNA sequence analysis and phenotypical characterization of rpoN, ptsN, and ptsA mutants. J. Bacteriol. 180:1729–1740. Michiels, J., C. Verreth, and J. Vanderleyden. 1994a. Effects of temperature stress on beannodulating Rhizobium strains. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 60:1206–1212. Miklas, P. N., E. Johnson, V. Stone, J. S. Beaver, C. Montoya, and M. Zapata. 1996. Selective mapping of QTL conditioning disease resistance in common bean. Crop Sci. 36:1344–1351.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
67
Miklas, P. N., J. R. Stavely, and J. D. Kelly. 1993. Identification and potential use of a molecular marker for rust resistance in common bean. Theor. Appl. Genet. 85:745–749. Milner, J. L., R. S. Araujo, and J. Handelsman. 1992. Molecular and symbiotic characterization of exopolysaccharide-deficient mutants of Rhizobium tropici strain CIAT899. Mol. Microbiol. 6:3137–3147. Mimmack, M. L., D. Borthakur, M. A. Jones, J. A. Downie, and A. W. B. Johnston. 1994. The psi-operon of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli—identification of 2 genes whose products are located at the bacterial cell surface. Microbiology-UK 140:1223– 1229. Miranda-Ríos, J., C. Morera, H. Taboada, A. Davalos, S. Encarnación, J. Mora, and M. Soberón. 1997. Expression of thiamin biosynthetic genes (thiCOGE) and production of symbiotic terminal oxidase cbb3 in Rhizobium etli. J. Bacteriol. 179:6887–6893. Montealegre, C., and P. H. Graham. 1996. Preference in the nodulation of Phaseolus vulgaris cv. RAB39: Effect of delayed inoculation or low cell representation in the inoculant on nodule occupancy by Rhizobium tropici UMR1899. Can. J. Microbiol. 42:844–850. Montealegre, C., P. H. Graham, and J. A. Kipenolt. 1995. Preference in the nodulation of Phaseolus vulgaris cultivar RAB39. Can. J. Microbiol. 41:992–998. Moreno, S., R. Meza, J. Guzman, A. Carabez, and G. Espin. 1991. The glnA gene of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli and its role in symbiosis. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 4:619–622. Moreno, S., E. J. Patriarca, M. Chiurazzi, R. Meza, R. Defez, A. Lamberti, A. Riccio, M. Iaccarino, and G. Espin. 1992. Phenotype of a Rhizobium leguminosarum ntrC mutant. Res. Microbiol. 143:161–171. Moulin, L., A. Munive, B. Dreyfus, and C. Boivin-Masson. 2001. Nodulation of legumes by members of the β-subclass of Proteobacteria. Nature 411:948–950. Nielsen, K. L., J. P. Lynch, A. G. Jablokow, and P. S. Curtis. 1994. Carbon cost of root systems—an architectural approach. Plant Soil 165:161–169. Nielsen, K. L., C. R. Miller, D. Beck, and J. P. Lynch. 1999. Fractal geometry of root systems: field observations of contrasting genotypes of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) grown under different phosphorus regimes. Plant Soil 206:181–190. Nodari, R. O., S. M. Tsai, R. L. Gilbertson, and P. Gepts. 1993. Towards an integrated linkage map of common bean: Development of an RFLP-based linkage map. Theor. Appl. Genet. 85:513–520. Noel, K. D., and D. M. Duelli. 2000. Rhizobium lipopolysaccharide and its role in symbiosis. p. 415–431. In: E. W. Triplett (ed.), Prokaryotic nitrogen fixation: a model system for analysis of a biological process. Horizon Scientific Press, Wymondham, U.K. Noel, K. D., D. M. Duelli, H. Tao, and N. J. Brewin. 1996. Antigenic change in the lipopolysaccharide of Rhizobium etli CFN42 induced by exudates of Phaseolus vulgaris. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 9:180–186. Noel, K. D., L. S. Forsberg, and R. W. Carlson. 2000. Varying the abundance of O-antigen in Rhizobium etli and its effect on symbiosis with Phaseolus vulgaris. J. Bacteriol. 182:5317–5324. Noel, K. D., K. A. Vandenbosch, and B. Kulpaca. 1986. Mutations in Rhizobium phaseoli that lead to arrested development of infection threads. J. Bacteriol. 168:1392–1401. Nogales, J., R. Campos, H. BenAbdelkhalek, J. Olivares, C. Lluch, and J. Sanjuan. 2002. Rhizobium tropici genes involved in free-living salt tolerance are required for the establishment of efficient nitrogen-fixing symbiosis with Phaseolus vulgaris. Mol. PlantMicrobe Interact. 15:225–232. Ogawa, J., and S. R. Long. 1995. The Rhizobium meliloti groELC locus is required for regulation of early nod genes by the transcription activator nodD. Genes Developm. 9:714–729.
68
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
Olaya, G. 1995. Genetics of resistance to Macrophomina phaseolina in beans and influence of water potential on the pathogen and on disease development. Ph.D. thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY. Pardo, M. A., J. Lagunez, J. Miranda, and E. Martínez. 1994. Nodulating ability of Rhizobium tropici is conditioned by a plasmid-encoded citrate synthase. Mol. Microbiol. 11:315–321. Park, S. J., and B. R. Buttery. 1988. Nodulation mutants of white bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) induced by ethyl-methane sulfonate. Can. J. Plant Sci. 68:199–202. Patriarca, E. J., A. Riccio, R. Taté, S. Colonnaromano, M. Iaccarino, and R. Defez. 1993. The ntrBC genes of Rhizobium leguminosarum are part of a complex operon subject to negative regulation. Mol. Microbiol. 9:569–577. Pérez-Ramírez, N. O., M. A. Rogel, E. Wang, J. Z. Castellanos, and E. Martínez-Romero. 1998. Seeds of Phaseolus vulgaris bean carry Rhizobium etli. FEMS Microbiol. Ecol. 26:289–296. Piñero, D., E. Martínez, and R. K. Selander. 1988. Genetic diversity and relationships among isolates of Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54:2825–2832. Poole, P. S., N. A. Schofield, C. J. Reid, E. M. Drew, and D. L. Walshaw. 1994. Identification of chromosomal genes located downstream of dctD that affect the requirement for calcium and the lipopolysaccharide layer of Rhizobium leguminosarum. MicrobiologyUK 140:2797–2809. Raghothama, K. G. 2000. Phosphorus acquisition; plant in the driver’s seat! Trends Plant Sci. 5:412–413. Ramírez, M., B. Valderrama, R. Arredondo-Peter, M. Soberón, J. Mora, and G. Hernandez. 1999. Rhizobium etli genetically engineered for the heterologous expression of Vitreoscilla sp. hemoglobin: effects on free-living and symbiosis. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 12:1008–1015. Ramos, M. L. G., and R. M. Boddey. 1987. Yield and nodulation of Phaseolus vulgaris and the competitivity of an introduced Rhizobium strain—effects of lime, mulch and repeated cropping. Soil Biol. Biochem. 19:171–177. Riccillo, P. M., M. M. Collavino, D. H. Grasso, R. England, F. J. de Bruijn, and O. M. Aguilar. 2000. A guaB mutant strain of Rhizobium tropici CIAT899 pleiotropically defective in thermal tolerance and symbiosis. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 13:1228–1236. Robleto, E. A., K. Kmiecik, E. S. Oplinger, J. Nienhuis, and E. W. Triplett. 1998a. Trifolitoxin production increases nodulation competitiveness of Rhizobium etli CE3 under agricultural conditions. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64:2630–2633. Robleto, E. A., J. Borneman, and E. W. Triplett. 1998b. Effects of bacterial antibiotic production on rhizosphere microbial communities from a culture-independent perspective. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64:5020–5022. Robleto, E. A., A. J. Scupham, and E. W. Triplett. 1997. Trifolitoxin production in Rhizobium etli strain CE3 increases competitiveness for rhizosphere colonization and root nodulation of Phaseolus vulgaris in soil. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 10:228–233. Rodriguez-Navarro, D. N., A. M. Buendia, M. Camacho, M. M. Lucas, and C. Santamaria. 2000. Characterization of Rhizobium spp. bean isolates from South-West Spain. Soil Biol. Biochem. 32:1601–1613. Romero, D., J. Martínez-Salazar, L. Girard, S. Brom, G. Davila, R. Palacios, M. Flores, and C. Rodriguez. 1995. Discrete amplifiable regions (amplicons) in the symbiotic plasmid of Rhizobium etli CFN42. J. Bacteriol. 177:973–980. Romero, D., P. W. Singleton, L. Segovía, E. Morett, B. Bohlool, R. Palacios, and G. Davila. 1988. Effect of naturally-occurring nif reiterations on symbiotic effectiveness in Rhizobium phaseoli. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 54:848–850.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
69
Rosas, J. C., J. A. Castro, E. A. Robleto, and J. Handelsman. 1998. A method for screening Phaseolus vulgaris L. germplasm for preferential nodulation with a selected Rhizobium etli strain. Plant Soil 203:71–78. Rosemeyer, V., J. Michiels, C. Verreth, and J. Vanderleyden. 1998. luxI- and luxRhomologous genes of Rhizobium etli CNPAF512 contribute to synthesis of autoinducer molecules and nodulation of Phaseolus vulgaris. J. Bacteriol. 180:815–821. Rosenblueth, M., M. F. Hynes, and E. Martínez-Romero. 1998. Rhizobium tropici teu genes involved in specific uptake of Phaseolus vulgaris bean exudate compounds. Mol. Gen. Genet. 258:587–598. Russell, D. R., K. M. Wallace, J. H. Bathe, and B. J. Martinell. 1993. Stable transformation of Phaseolus vulgaris via electric-discharge mediated particle acceleration. Plant Cell Rep. 12:165–169. Ryan, P. R., E. Delhaize, and D. L. Jones. 2001. Function and mechanism of organic anion exudation from plant roots. Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. Plant Mol. Biol. 52: 527–560. Rychter, A. M., and D. D. Randall. 1994. The effect of phosphate deficiency on carbohydratemetabolism in bean roots. Physiol. Plant. 91:383–388. Schneider, K. A., M. E. Brothers, and J. D. Kelly. 1997. Marker-assisted selection to improve drought resistance in common bean. Crop Sci. 37:51–60. Schripsema, J., K. E. de Rudder, T. B. van Vliet, P. P. Lankhorst, E. de Vroom, J. W. Kijne, and A. A. van Brussel. 1996. Bacteriocin small of Rhizobium leguminosarum belongs to the class of N-acyl-L-homoserine lactone molecules, known as autoinducers and as quorum sensing co-transcription factors. J. Bacteriol. 178:366–371. Searle, I. R., A. E. Men, T. Laniya, D. M. Buzas, I. Iturbe-Ormaetxe, B. J. Caroll, and P. Gresshoff. 2002. Long-distance signaling in nodulation directed by a CLAVATA1-like receptor kinase. Science (in press). Segovía, L., J. P. Young, and E. Martínez-Romero. 1993. Reclassification of American Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar phaseoli type I strains as Rhizobium etli sp. nov. Intl. J. Syst. Bacteriol. 43:374–377. Shen, H., X. L. Yan, M. Zhao, S. L. Zheng, and X. R. Wang. 2002. Exudation of organic acids in common bean as related to mobilization of aluminum- and iron-bound phosphates. Environ. Expt. Bot. 48:1–9. Shirtliffe, S. J., and J. K. Vessey. 1996. A nodulation (Nod+/Fix–) mutant of Phaseolus vulgaris L. has nodule-like structures lacking peripheral vascular bundles (Pvb–) and is resistant to mycorrhizal infection (Myc–). Plant Sci. 118:209–220. Singh, S. P. 1999a. Common bean improvement in the twenty-first century. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht. Singh, S. P. 1999b. Production and utilization. p. 1–24. In: S. P. Singh (ed.), Common bean improvement in the twenty-first century. Kluwer Academic Publ., Dordrecht. Singh, S. P., J. A. Gutierrez, A. Molina, C. Urrea, and P. Gepts. 1991a. Genetic diversity in cultivated common bean: Marker-based analysis of morphological and agronomic traits. Crop Sci. 31:23–29. Singh, S. P., R. Nodari, and P. Gepts. 1991b. Genetic diversity in cultivated common bean allozymes. Crop Sci. 31:19–23. Singh, S. P., P. Gepts, and D. G. Debouck. 1991c. Races of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris, Fabaceae). Econ. Bot. 45:379–396. Soberón, M., G. R. Aguilar, and F. Sanchez. 1993. Rhizobium phaseoli cytochrome C-deficient mutant induces empty nodules on Phaseolus vulgaris L. Mol. Microbiol. 8:159–166. Soberón, M., O. Lopez, C. Morera, M. L. Girard, M. L. Tabche, and J. Miranda. 1999. Enhanced nitrogen fixation in a Rhizobium etli ntrC mutant that overproduces the
70
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
Bradyrhizobium japonicum symbiotic terminal oxidase cbb3. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 65:2015–2019. Soberón, M., J. Membrillo-Hernandez, G. R. Aguilar, and F. Sanchez. 1990. Isolation of Rhizobium phaseoli Tn5-induced mutants with altered expression of cytochrome terminal oxidases o and aa3. J. Bacteriol. 172:1676–1680. Soberón, M., H. D. Williams, R. K. Poole, and E. Escamilla. 1989. Isolation of a Rhizobium phaseoli cytochrome mutant with enhanced respiration and symbiotic nitrogen fixation. J. Bacteriol. 171:465–472. Soberón-Chavez, G., and R. Najera. 1989. Isolation from soil of Rhizobium leguminosarum lacking symbiotic information. Can. J. Microbiol. 35:464–468. Soberón-Chavez, G., R. Najera, H. Olivera, and L. Segovía. 1986. Genetic rearrangements of a Rhizobium phaseoli symbiotic plasmid. J. Bacteriol. 167:487–491. Steele, H. L., B. Volker, G. F. Fuhrmann, and D. Werner. 1999. Strain specificities in Rhizobium tropici and Rhizobium etli using glucose transport inhibition by acidity and daidzein. Soil Biol. Biochem. 31:1059–1061. Stracke, S., C. Kistner, S. Yoshida, L. Mulder, S. Sato, T. Kaneko, S. Tabata, N. Sandal, J. Stougaard, K. Szczyglowski, and M. Parniske. 2002. A plant-receptor-like kinase required for both bacterial and fungal symbiosis. Nature 417:959–962. Tabche, M. L., E. G. Garcia, J. Miranda, J. E. Escamilla, and M. Soberón. 1998. Rhizobium etli cycHJKL gene locus involved in c-type cytochrome biogenesis: sequence analysis and characterization of two cycH mutants. Gene 208:215–219. Tadano, T., K. Ozawa, H. Sakai, M. Osaki, and H. Matsui. 1993. Secretion of acidphosphatase by the roots of crop plants under phosphorus-deficient conditions and some properties of the enzyme secreted by lupin roots. Plant Soil 156:95–98. Taté, R., A. Riccio, E. Caputo, M. Iaccarino, and E. J. Patriarca. 1999. The Rhizobium etli metZ gene is essential for methionine biosynthesis and nodulation of Phaseolus vulgaris. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 12:24–34. Taté, R., A. Riccio, M. Iaccarino, and E. J. Patriarca. 1997. A cysG mutant strain of Rhizobium etli pleiotropically defective in sulfate and nitrate assimilation. J. Bacteriol. 179:7343–7350. Taté, R., A. Riccio, M. Merrick, and E. J. Patriarca. 1998. The Rhizobium etli amtB gene coding for an NH4+ transporter is down-regulated early during bacteroid differentiation. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 11:188–198. Téllez-Sosa, J., M. Soberón, A. Vega-Segura, M. E. Torres-Marquez, and M. A. Cevallos. 2002. The Rhizobium etli cyaC product: characterization of a novel adenylate cyclase class. J. Bacteriol. 184:3560–3568. Thies, J. E., E. M. Holmes, and A. Vachot. 2001. Application of molecular techniques to studies in Rhizobium ecology: a review. Austral. J. Expt. Agr. 41:299–319. Thies, J. E., P. W. Singleton, and B. Bohlool. 1991. Influence of the size of indigenous rhizobial populations on establishment and symbiotic performance of introduced rhizobia on field-grown legumes. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 57:19–28. Thorne, S. H., and H. D. Williams. 1999. Cell density-dependent starvation survival of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli: identification of the role of an N-acyl homoserine lactone in adaptation to stationary-phase survival. J. Bacteriol. 181:981–990. Tohme, J., D. O. González, S. Beebe, and M. C. Duque. 1996. AFLP analysis of gene pools of a wild bean core collection. Crop Sci. 36:1375–1384. Toro, O., J. Tohme, and D. G. Debouck. 1990. Wild bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.): decription and distribution. International Board for Plant Genetic Resources (IBPGR) and Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT). Cali, Colombia. Triplett, E. W., and T. M. Barta. 1987. Trifolitoxin production and nodulation are necessary for the expression of superior nodulation competitiveness by Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii strain T24 on clover. Plant Physiol. 85:335–342.
2. GENETIC IMPROVEMENT OF COMMON BEAN AND RHIZOBIA
71
Triplett, E. W., and M. J. Sadowsky. 1992. Genetics of competition for nodulation of legumes. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 46:399–428. Tsai, S. M., R. O. Nodari, D. H. Moon, L. E. A. Camargo, R. Vencovsky, and P. Gepts. 1998. QTL mapping for nodule number and common bacterial blight in Phaseolus vulgaris L. Plant Soil 204:135–145. Urrea, C. A., P. N. Miklas, J. S. Beaver, and R. H. Riley. 1996. A codominant randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) marker useful for indirect selection of bean golden mosaic virus resistance in common bean. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 121:1035–1039. Vadez, V., D. P. Beck, J. H. Lasso, and J. J. Drevon. 1997. Utilization of the acetylene reduction assay to screen for tolerance of symbiotic N-2 fixation to limiting P nutrition in common bean. Physiol. Plant. 99:227–232. Vallejos, C. E., N. S. Sakiyama, and C. D. Chase. 1992. A molecular marker-based linkage map of Phaseolus vulgaris L. Genetics 131:733–740. van Berkum, P., D. Beyene, and B. D. Eardly. 1996. Phylogenetic relationships among Rhizobium species nodulating the common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Intl. J. Syst. Bacteriol. 46:240–244. van Rhijn, P., J. Desair, K. Vlassak, and J. Vanderleyden. 1994a. Functional analysis of nodD genes of Rhizobium tropici CIAT899. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 7:666–676. van Rhijn, P., J. Desair, K. Vlassak, and J. Vanderleyden. 1994b. The NodD proteins of Rhizobium sp. strain BR816 differ in their interactions with coinducers and in their activities for nodulation of different host plants. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 60:3615–3623. Vasquez-Arroyo, J., A. Sessitsch, E. Martínez, and J. J. Pena-Cabriales. 1998. Nitrogen fixation and nodule occupancy by native strains of Rhizobium on different cultivars of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Plant Soil 204:147–154. Vinuesa, P., B. L. Reuhs, C. Breton, and D. Werner. 1999. Identification of a plasmid borne locus in Rhizobium etli KIM5s involved in lipopolysaccharide O-chain biosynthesis and nodulation of Phaseolus vulgaris. J. Bacteriol. 181:5606–5614. Vlassak, K. M., E. Luyten, C. Verreth, P. van Rhijn, T. Bisseling, and J. Vanderleyden. 1998. The Rhizobium sp. BR816 nodO gene can function as a determinant for nodulation of Leucaena leucocephala, Phaseolus vulgaris and Trifolium repens by a diversity of Rhizobium spp. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 5:383–392. Vlassak, K. M., and J. Vanderleyden. 1997. Factors influencing nodule occupancy by inoculant rhizobia. Crit. Rev. Plant Sci. 16:163–229. Vlassak, K. M., J. Vanderleyden, and A. Franco. 1996. Competition and persistence of Rhizobium tropici and Rhizobium etli in tropical soil during successive bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L) cultures. Biol. Fert. Soils 21:61–68. Wadisirisuk, P., S. K. A. Danso, G. Hardarson, and G. D. Bowen. 1989. Influence of Bradyrhizobium japonicum location and movement on nodulation and nitrogen fixation in soybeans. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 55:1711–1716. Waelkens, F., T. Voets, K. Vlassak, J. Vanderleyden, and P. van Rhijn. 1995. The nodS gene of Rhizobium tropici strain CIAT899 is necessary for nodulation on Phaseolus vulgaris and on Leucaena leucocephala. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 8:147–154. Wang, G. L, D. J. Mackill, J. M. Bonman, S. R. McCouch, M. C. Champoux, and R. J. Nelson. 1994. RFLP mapping of genes conferring complete or partial resistance to blast in a durably resistant rice cultivar. Genetics. 136:1421–1434. Wanke, M., I. Ciereszko, M. Podbielkowska, and A. M. Rychter. 1998. Response to phosphate deficiency in bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) roots. Respiratory metabolism, sugar localization and changes in ultrastructure of bean root cells. Ann. Bot. 82:809–819. Wolff, A. B., P. W. Singleton, M. Sidirelli, and B. B. Bohlool. 1993. Influence of acid soil on nodulation and interstrain competitiveness in relation to tannin concentrations in seeds and roots of Phaseolus vulgaris. Soil Biol. Biochem. 25:715–721.
72
C. SNOECK, J. VANDERLEYDEN, AND S. BEEBE
Wolff, A. B., W. Streit, J. A. Kipenholt, H. Vargas, and D. Werner. 1991. Competitiveness of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. phaseoli strains in relation to environmental stress and plant defense mechanisms. Biol. Fert. Soils 12:170–176. Xi, C., G. Dirix, J. Hofkens, F. C. De Schryver, J. Vanderleyden, and J. Michiels. 2001. Use of dual marker transposons to identify new symbiosis genes in Rhizobium. Microb. Ecol. 41:325–332. Xi, C., E. Schoeters, J. Vanderleyden, and J. Michiels. 2000. Symbiosis-specific expression of Rhizobium etli casA encoding a secreted calmodulin related protein. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (U.S.A.) 97:11114–11119. Yan, X. L., H. Liao, M. C. Trull, S. E. Beebe, and J. P. Lynch. 2001. Induction of a major leaf acid phosphatase does not confer adaptation to low phosphorus availability in common bean. Plant Physiol. 125:1901–1911. Yan, X. L., J. P. Lynch, and S. E. Beebe. 1995. Genetic variation for phosphorus efficiency of common bean in contrasting soil types: Vegetative response. Crop Sci. 35:1086–1093. You, Z. R., X. F. Gao, M. M. Ho, and D. Borthakur. 1998. A stomatin-like protein encoded by the sip gene of Rhizobium etli is required for nodulation competitiveness on the common bean. Microbiology-UK 144:2619–2627. Young, R. A., and J. D. Kelly. 1997. RAPD markers linked to three major anthracnose resistance genes in common bean. Crop Sci. 37:940–946.
3 Developing Marker-Assisted Selection Strategies for Breeding Hybrid Rice Yunbi Xu* RiceTec, Inc., P.O. Box 1305, Alvin, Texas 77512. Present address: Department of Plant Breeding, Cornell University Ithaca, New York 14853-1901 I. INTRODUCTION II. FEATURES OF HYBRID BREEDING A. Hybrid Prediction B. Selection for Hybrid Performance C. Seed Production and Commercialization D. Grain Production III. COMPONENTS OF MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION A. Genetic Markers and Maps B. Marker Characterization C. Marker-Trait Associations D. Genotyping and High-throughput Genotyping Systems E. Data Management and Delivery IV. GERMPLASM EVALUATION A. Assessing Collection Redundancies and Gaps B. Monitoring Genetic Shifts C. Identifying Unique Germplasm D. Construction of Core Collection E. Germplasm Genotyping Database V. TRAITS REQUIRING TESTCROSSING OR PROGENY TESTING A. Fertility Restoration B. Outcrossing C. Wide Compatibility *The author gratefully acknowledges Drs. Susan R. McCouch, Barry Tillman, Mark Walton, Jules Janick, and three anonymous reviewers for their critical reading and invaluable comments and suggestions on the manuscript, and Dr. Junjian Ni for his help in collecting references. This article is dedicated to Emeritus Professor Zongtan Shen at Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China, for his contributions to agriculture education, rice genetics, and plant breeding. Plant Breeding Reviews, Volume 23, Edited by Jules Janick ISBN 0-471-35421-X © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 73
74
Y. XU
VI. ENVIRONMENT-DEPENDENT TRAITS A. Photoperiod/Temperature Sensitivity B. Environment-induced Genic Male Sterility C. Biotic and Abiotic Stresses VII. QUALITY TRAITS A. Seed Traits B. Hybrid Seed Traits C. Selection of Quality Traits VIII. GENE INTROGRESSION AND WHOLE GENOME SELECTION A. Gene Introgression B. Whole Genome Selection C. Selection for Multiple Genes/Traits D. Integrated Genetic Mapping and MAS E. Response to Selection IX. PREDICTION OF HYBRID PERFORMANCE AND HETEROSIS A. Combining Ability and Heterosis B. Genetic Basis of Heterosis C. Construction of Heterotic Groups D. Hybrid Prediction X. SEED QUALITY ASSURANCE A. Off-type B. False Hybrids XI. GENERAL DISCUSSIONS A. Economic Consideration B. Bioinformatics and Breeding Database C. Opportunities and Challenges LITERATURE CITED
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AFLP ASI BLUP BSSS CHA CMS DH DTF DTH EGMS FNP GCA GD IBPGR IHO
Amplified fragment length polymorphism Anthesis-silking interval Best linear unbiased prediction Iowa (B) Stiff Stalk Synthetic Chemical hybridization agent Cytoplasmic male sterility Doubled haploid Days-to-flowering Days-to-heading Environment-induced genic male sterility Functional nucleotide polymorphism General combining ability Genetic distance International Board for Plant Germplasm Resources Illinois high oil
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
IHP ILO ILP IRMI IRRI LSC MAS MPH NIE NIL NPGS OPC PGMS PIC PTS QTL QTN RAPD RFLP RIL RYD SAF SCA SCAR SNP SSR STS TD TG-BLUP TGMS
75
Illinois high protein Illinois low oil Illinois low protein International Rice Microsatellite Initiative International Rice Research Institute Lancaster Sure Crop Marker-assisted selection Mid-parent heterosis Near iso-environment Near-isogenic line National Plant Germplasm System (USA) Open pollinate cultivar Photoperiod-sensitive genic male sterility Polymorphic information content Photo-thermo sensitivity Quantitative trait locus/loci Quantitative trait nucleotide Random amplified polymorphic DNA Restriction fragment length polymorphism Recombinant inbred line Reid Yellow Dent Shared allele frequency Specific combining ability Sequence characterized amplified region Single nucleotide polymorphism Simple sequence repeat Sequence tagged site Transposon display Trait and gene best linear unbiased prediction Thermo-sensitive genic male sterility
I. INTRODUCTION Exploitation of heterosis or hybrid vigor to increase crop yields started early in the twentieth century with maize. From inbreeding a number of crop plants including maize, George H. Shull developed a perspective on heterosis that he outlined in a 1908 publication entitled “Composition of a Field of Maize.” He argued persuasively that by inbreeding isolated homozygous lines, these lines could be crossed to capitalize on heterosis. East (1908) discussed the danger of inbreeding. Commercially feasible F1 maize hybrids were developed following Jones’s 1918
76
Y. XU
proposition of the doubled cross. Average yields increased twofold after double crosses replaced the open-pollinate cultivars (OPCs) during 1935–1965 and increased another twofold after single crosses replaced the double crosses during 1966–1996 (Hallauer 1999). The T cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) had been used to produce hybrid seeds during 1950–1970. Wide use of this single cytoplasm resource resulted in the epidemic of Southern leaf blight in 1970 caused by a new virulent Race T of Helminthosporium maydis, and an estimated 15% of the maize crop in the United States was destroyed. Hybrid maize is now based on hand detasseling, which avoids the use of CMS female parents. The success of hybrid maize is due to the ability of major seed companies such as Pioneer Hi-Bred International, Inc., to select for yield stability based on extensive testing and the efficiency of seed production that insures profitability. Now over 90% of maize in the United States is hybrid (Duvick 1999). Hybrid rice was first commercialized in the early 1970s in China. Unlike maize, rice is self-pollinated and hermaphroditic. Hybrid rice breeding has been based on using CMS or environment-induced genic male sterility (EGMS). A breeding system using three-lines (CMS line, CMS maintainer, and CMS restorer) was established by using a male sterile plant discovered from a wild rice species (Oryza rufipogon Griff. or O. f. spontanea) in 1970 by Prof. Longping Yuan and his assistant (Li and Yuan 2000). A two-line hybrid rice system using EGMS was established by using a photoperiod-sensitive genic male sterility (PGMS) mutant discovered in 1973 by Mingsong Shi from a japonica cultivar ‘Nongken 58’ (Shi 1981). Now over 50% of rice in China is hybrid (Li and Yuan 2000). Hybrid rice is also commercialized in other Asian countries and hybrid breeding programs have been established in several South American and North American countries. Hybrids provide many advantages in a crop production system. The principal benefit is increased yield. In open-pollinating species, one of the most often overlooked benefits is uniformity, an element which has allowed for the rapid expansion of production in many crop plants such as the vegetables. Additional benefits may include stress tolerance and pest resistance and other performance characteristics. Breeders of hybrid crops can react faster and with more options to meet changing markets, customer needs, and production demands. Other advantages of hybrids include the ability to combine useful dominant genes available in different inbred lines, to optimize the expression of genes in the heterozygous state, and to produce unique traits. Yield increases accounted for about 92% of increased cereal production in the developing world between 1961 and 1990. The yield advantage of hybrids ranged from 15% (maize) to 50% (sunflower), compared
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
77
to non-hybrids (Duvick 1999). However, yield growth rates are stagnating in some areas and, in a few cases, falling. A slowdown in the rate of yield increase of major cereals raises concern because increased yields are expected to be the source of increased food production in the future (Reeves et al. 1999). Utilization of heterosis and the improvement of the efficiency of hybrid breeding is one of the ways by which we can attempt to lift the yield ceiling. Producing F1 hybrids depends on the development of an efficient system for hybridization. There are several approaches to production of hybrids: CMS, EGMS including PGMS and thermo-sensitive genic male sterility (TGMS), protogyny, self incompatibility, chemical hybridization agent (CHA), and hand-emasculation systems. No matter which system is used, the central task is to develop and maintain two parents that have desirable traits. One serves as a pollen receptor and the other as a pollen donor for hybrid seed production. All desirable traits for hybrid seed production and heterosis itself, which are not required in pure line breeding, are difficult to measure, compared to other agronomic traits. Genomics in cereals, especially in rice, has created a substantial information base for their improvement. Marker-assisted selection (MAS), the first benefit that breeders can obtain from genomics, has been receiving a great deal of attention and will play an important role in hybrid breeding. The objective of this paper is to discuss the development of molecular marker strategies in breeding hybrid rice by drawing upon information obtained from maize and other crops. Information on the types of marker systems available and their relative merits is included, as is the use of markers in (1) evaluation and characterization of germplasm resources, (2) selection for different types of traits, (3) gene introgression, (4) prediction of hybrid performance, and (5) monitoring of seed quality in the seed production process. II. FEATURES OF HYBRID BREEDING A. Hybrid Prediction The process of plant breeding has developed through several key phases, including unconscious selection in Neolithic times, empirical art during the development and expansion of agriculture, and a predictive science-based approach practiced today. In general, prediction in plant breeding started from the evaluation of progeny performance. Pedigree methods and use of statistical tools in assessing progeny performance brought about a way for plant breeders to quantitatively separate the heritable portion of variation from the non-heritable and thus make parental choices based on heritability (Goldman 2000). As a result, exploitation
78
Y. XU
of additive genetic variance during the inbreeding process, and dominance variance during the testcrossing phase when assessing performance across multiple testers, has become a standard for cross-pollinated crops. There are several breeding practices that also make plant breeding more predictive. The breeding procedure known as backcrossing makes the progeny highly predictive. Identification of general and specific combining ability in maize helps identify superior inbred lines that can be used more efficiently in breeding new inbreds and hybrids. Wide area testing of hybrids makes it possible to develop widely adapted hybrid maize and improves the efficiency of maize breeding operations. Hybrid rice breeding has a very different story. Breeders of selfpollinating crops have been highly successful in breeding inbred cultivars. Although inbred breeding procedures were established and used for many years, hybrid rice breeding attempted a completely different approach. However, hybrid breeding procedures established for openpollinated crops were unsuitable for rice. Testcrossing and wide area testing, which is not a problem for hybrid maize breeding, has been a bottleneck for hybrid rice. Rice breeders have been searching for more reliable prediction methods in their breeding programs. High performance of hybrid plants results from the complementary action of both parents. Thus, parents with excellent performance per se may not produce desirable hybrids; superior hybrids may come from low-yielding parental lines. The evidence from maize indicates that inbred grain yield is not highly correlated with hybrid grain yield (Hallauer and Miranda 1988). Correlations between midparent values and hybrid means for the 91 crosses studied by Dudley et al. (1992) ranged from 0.46 for ear height to 0.71 for plant height. For grain yield, the correlation was 0.56. These correlations are too small to be of practical use in a breeding program. Despite their low values, the inbred-hybrid yield correlations were positive. They indicated a tendency for high-yielding inbreds to produce high-yielding hybrids. For a specific breeding program, however, the tendency does not make any kind of prediction meaningful. The second reason for the unpredictability is the lack of a full understanding of the genetic basis of heterosis, which affects all aspects of hybrid performance. As noted in the detailed discussion in Section IX, hybrid performance is positively related to the genetic distance between the parental lines when comparison is based on crosses derived from the intra-heterotic group. This “prediction” does not work, however, when comparison is based on the crosses derived from parental lines belonging to different heterotic groups, ecotypes, or subspecies. Although many hypotheses, such as physiological complementary, overdominance, dominance, and partial dominance, have been proposed as the
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
79
genetic explanation of heterosis, “isolated” research conclusions cannot be extended to other populations from the same varietal group, let alone the hybrids derived from very different crosses or species. As a result, limited and less-reliable information often provides contradictory results. As will be discussed later, prediction of hybrid performance depends on a thorough understanding of heterosis from different aspects, including genetics, physiology, and developmental biology. B. Selection for Hybrid Performance Hybrid performance depends on genes, and their interactions and combinations. Selection for hybrid performance in breeding programs is based on testcrossing and progeny testing. That is, we breed hybrids through selection of parental lines with desirable agronomic traits. To associate the parental phenotype with hybrid performance, breeders have to cross their candidate breeding lines with several testers, and from the hybrid progeny, determine if the candidates contain the genes required for hybrids and whether the parental combinations produce useful hybrids. This indirect selection, based on testcrossing and progeny testing, is time-consuming and very expensive. Furthermore, the association between the parental line and hybrid from one cross cannot be used to make a prediction about other associations. A cross of two extremely low-yielding inbreds can give a hybrid with good mid-parent or high-parent heterosis but poor performance, whereas a cross of two high-yielding inbreds might exhibit less mid-parent or high-parent heterosis but nevertheless produce a hybrid with good performance. High-yielding hybrids owe their yield not only to heterosis but also to other heritable factors that are not necessarily influenced by heterosis. For effective selection, one needs to know the relative importance of each genetic contribution—of heterosis and non-heterosis—in individual hybrids (Duvick 1999). Furthermore, when examining yield trends in a time series of successively released hybrids, breeders need to know what portion of the genetic yield gains (if gains are made) is due to increase in heterosis, and what portion to increases in nonheterosis (Duvick 1999). C. Seed Production and Commercialization In cultivar breeding, once an outstanding line is identified to be superior to the commercial control, it can be registered as a new commercial cultivar for production. In hybrid breeding, however, a superior hybrid requires not only a high yield potential and desirable agronomic traits such as disease resistance and good quality, but also an economically
80
Y. XU
viable seed production and maternal production system for each specific hybrid. Simply to exhibit good hybrid performance is insufficient. To be commercially viable, potential lines must produce excellent hybrids and have many traits desirable for seed production, such as high outcrossing rate and good flowering habits. This allows the cost of seed production to be low enough so that the seed producer benefits from the production and sale of hybrid seed. Requirements for activities such as roguing, detasseling/emasculation, pollination assistance, and other special management systems for seed production and parent multiplication can affect the cost and quality of the final product. This is very important to crops such as rice and wheat where reducing seed cost becomes critical for successful commercialization. Thus, a good seed production system will determine the cost of seed production and therefore the final commercialization of the hybrid. D. Grain Production In hybrids, commercial grain is produced from hybrid plants, but hybrid seed is produced from inbred parents. The agronomic practice used for the two production systems could be very different. For example, hybrid rice may have a very different nitrogen response than the parental lines and thus different kinds of nitrogen management are required, depending on the environments in which the hybrid is growing. Low potassium can be a problem for hybrid rice in many areas, although this element may be sufficient enough for inbred lines (Yuan and Chen 1988). Modern maize hybrids differ from open-pollinated and earlier hybrids primarily in their response to stress. New hybrids have improved water stress performance, are much less prone to silk delay, have significantly lower respiration rates during silking, have longer periods of grain fill, and are higher-yielding under both low- and high-input environments (Tomes 1998). Severe droughts in the American Cornbelt during 1934 and 1936 resulted in poor maize crops; however, hybrids often outperformed their open-pollinated counterparts under these conditions (Goldman 1999). This is due to the strong root system and lodging resistance of hybrids. These characteristics helped hybrid maize quickly replace OPCs. Contrary to maize, the first rice hybrids developed in China and the United States were tall and very prone to lodging if the same nitrogen rate as for inbred cultivars was used. As a result, a very different kind of nitrogen management is required for hybrids to maintain a good plant stand. In conclusion, hybrid breeding consists of all the components of inbred line breeding plus the additional complexity of recombining
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
81
inbreds. Plant breeders have continually looked to genetics for assistance (Duvick 1996), including quantitative genetics, cytogenetics, tissue culture, and mutation breeding. While utility has come from all new innovations, practical plant breeding based on hybridization and selection continues with little change in its basic structure. Now, a powerful new plant breeding technique, MAS, has appeared that promises to vastly increase selection efficiency. This review will explore the development and use of this MAS strategy in improving hybrid cereals, with an emphasis on rice.
III. COMPONENTS OF MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION Key components that are required for an efficient MAS system include (1) suitable genetic markers and their characterization, (2) high-density molecular maps, (3) established marker-trait associations for traits of interest, (4) high-throughput genotyping systems, and (5) functional data analysis and delivery systems. A. Genetic Markers and Maps Genetic polymorphism at morphological, cytological, and molecular levels can be used as markers to tag traits, chromosomes, or DNA fragments. Genetic markers have been used for several decades in linkage analysis, gene mapping, gene transfer, and as aids to selection. Many different types of markers have been developed, including morphological variants, protein polymorphisms such as variation at isozyme loci, and DNA polymorphisms. DNA-based markers received the most attention since the first genetic map was established using restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) (Botstein et al. 1980). While DNA markers have many advantages over other types of markers, morphological and protein polymorphisms are still very useful, especially when marker-trait associations have been well established or when desirable agronomic traits are used as markers. There are examples using morphological markers for heterosis-related applications. In this review, the term “markers” includes all types. DNA-based markers reflect genetic polymorphism at the DNA level, which result from any possible differences existing in nucleotides. Compared with other types of genetic markers, DNA markers have almost no practical limitation in numbers, often have no direct phenotypic effect, and are unaffected by environment. DNA markers can be classified into four different types based on the method used for polymorphism detection: (1) DNA-DNA hybridization such as RFLPs; (2) PCR-based markers
82
Y. XU
such as random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) using arbitrary primers, or simple sequence repeat (SSR) and sequence tagged site (STS), both of which use specific primers; (3) combining use of PCR and restriction enzyme technique such as amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) or transposon display (TD); and (4) single nucleotide differences that are referred to as single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). Desirable DNA markers for MAS should meet the following requirements: detection of high frequency of polymorphism, codominance, abundance, whole genome coverage, high duplicability, suitability for high-throughput analysis and multiplexing, technical simplicity, cost effectiveness, requirement of small amount of DNA, and user-friendly (such as suitability for different genotyping systems and facilities). Among all these requirements, codominance is the most important for characterization of F1 hybrids. The two parental inbreds and hybrid combinations can be distinguished unambiguously. For all types of DNA markers mentioned above, SSR satisfies all the requirements. As estimated from a draft rice sequence, the density of SSRs in the genome is approximately one SSR per gene. These markers can be shared internationally through Internet-distributed primer sequences. SSR markers can be genotyped manually using agarose or polyarylamide gels and ethidium bromide or silver staining, or in highly automated facilities using ABI3700 Sequencers. SSR markers can be multiplexed doing PCR and for multiple-sample loading on gels using fluorescent labeling (Coburn et al. 2002). DNA extracted from a small piece of leaf or from single dry seeds will be enough to run several hundreds of markers (Xu et al. 2002). SSR is a more mature technique than SNP, although the latter has great potential for super high-throughput analysis using chip technology. As more and more genes are cloned, it will be possible to develop molecular markers based on sequences with the gene of interest. Intragenic markers provide several advantages over gene-linked markers. First, there is no recombination between the marker and the gene, or intergenic recombination. Second, multiple alleles can be tagged and distinguished. An example in rice is the SSR marker, RM190, derived from a microsatellite sequence with a splice site in the waxy gene, which is responsible for amylose synthesis, an important grain quality trait for hybrid rice. Selection of target chromosomal regions based on associated markers (foreground selection) and selection of genetic background for one of the parental genomes (background selection) may need different markers. Markers for foreground selection must be genetically mapped and associated with agronomic traits. Genetic markers revealing multiple bands or representing multiple loci are usually difficult to trace back to the specific allele/locus known to be associated with the trait, particularly when
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
83
the population used for MAS is different from the mapping population. These types of markers include RAPDs and AFLPs, which as such are not good for foreground selection. To use marker-trait associations based on these markers, it is best to convert them into types of markers that are more locus-specific, such as STS or SSR markers. For background selection, any type of markers that detect a high rate of polymorphism is useful. Background selection does not require the use of mapped markers as long as they can reveal genome-wide polymorphism. The efficiency of MAS largely depends on how well markers are linked to the target trait. Construction of a high-density genetic map using highthroughput molecular markers is the first step to a large-scale MAS program. A reference map is required for each crop based on a permanent segregating population that can be shared internationally such that it has the potential for continuous placement of additional markers by the entire community on the map later on. This map should be constructed using markers that are friendly to users. There are two reasons why we need a high-density molecular map. First, a minimum requirement for MAS based on marker-trait association includes a three-marker system: one marker cosegregating with the trait for foreground selection and the other two in each side of it for background selection. Since the target gene can be located in any region of the genome, a dense map is required for identifying this triplet at any position in the genome. Second, markers identified using mapping populations may not be polymorphic in breeding populations derived from other parental lines. To guarantee that the three-marker system will work for other breeding populations, many markers have to be identified around the target region. To saturate the rice SSR map, an international effort has been initiated through the International Rice Microsatellite Initiative (IRMI) (McCouch et al. 2002), with a goal of characterizing and mapping 2000 microsatellite markers developed from the Monsanto rice sequence database. As a member of the IRMI group, RiceTec, Inc. has undertaken a genetic mapping effort to place IRMI markers onto the existing SSR map, which was constructed using a subset of doubled haploid lines derived from an indica × japonica cross, ‘IR64’/‘Azucena’, and having a framework map consisting of 432 RFLP and SSR markers. A reference genetic map consisting of a thousand SSR markers is now available to rice molecular breeding programs. B. Marker Characterization It is not enough to just have thousands of genetic markers in hand. To use molecular markers efficiently, they have to be characterized for many features, including number of alleles; polymorphic information content
84
Y. XU
(PIC), allele sizes and ranges; allele sizes in standard or control cultivars; signal strength under specific genotyping conditions; background or noise signal; PCR conditions; chromosome location (flanking markers and genetic distances); and information required for multiplexing. Characterization of molecular markers helps to identify markers close to the genes of importance to breeding programs and to evaluate germplasm and breeding materials. A core set of SSR markers evenly distributed on all rice chromosomes and suited for multiplexing has been established at RiceTec, Inc., and is currently used for evaluation of germplasm accessions, construction of heterotic pools, and MAS in hybrid rice breeding. In this section, marker characterization will be illustrated using an example taken from a rice research project at Cornell University (Xu et al. 1997a,b; Xu et al. 2004). A total of 236 cultivars were collected to represent world genetic diversity, which included two subsets, 125 U.S. rice cultivars and 111 collected from 22 other countries. All germplasm accessions were genotyped using 100 RFLP and 60 SSR markers. The results related to marker characterization are summarized below. 1. Allele Number. The number of alleles at a marker locus is related to the genetic diversity that can be revealed by that marker. The more alleles at a locus, the higher the degree of diversity that can be revealed and the more efficiently closely related lines can be distinguished. A total of 274 alleles were detected at the 100 RFLP loci, with an average of 2.7 alleles per locus. SSR markers detected a total of 714 alleles, with an average of 11.9 alleles per locus. The world collection embodied 99.3% of RFLP and 95.8% of SSR alleles, while the U.S. collection embodied 82% of RFLPs and only 56% of SSR alleles. 2. PIC Value. The relative informativeness of each marker can be evaluated based on its PIC value, which reflects the amount of polymorphism and is a function of the number of alleles and allele frequencies at any given locus. The average PIC value was almost twice as high for SSRs (0.66) as for RFLPs (0.36). Average PIC values for the 100 RFLP markers were 0.40 for the world collection, and 0.21 for the U.S. collection. Average PIC values for the 60 SSR markers were 0.74 for the world collection, and 0.50 for the U.S. cultivars. 3. Informative Markers. Based on PIC values and the number of alleles detected, a set of highly informative markers can be selected such that the same amount of genotyping information can be obtained by surveying fewer molecular markers. Selected markers should be evenly distributed throughout the genome. Based on the 236 × 160 rice dataset, a group of 24 RFLP/SSR markers were selected to represent all 12 chromosomes and
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
85
are recommended as a set of highly informative markers for preliminary fingerprinting of rice germplasm and breeding populations. Molecular markers that are suited for MAS in hybrid breeding should have the same requirements as for other breeding projects. In addition to the requirements discussed in Section IIA for a marker system, there are some other requirements for a marker and a core set of markers. A useful marker should have many alleles per locus (>10 for SSRs), high PIC value (>0.8), suitable difference in allele sizes (4 to 10 bp between any two alleles for SSRs), strong signal for detection, less background or noise signal, and high replicability or reliability. A useful set of markers should provide whole genome coverage, even distribution on each chromosome, and high potentiality for multiplexing. C. Marker-Trait Associations Establishment of highly significant marker-trait associations is one of the prerequisites for MAS. Demonstrated linkages between target traits/genes and molecular markers are traditionally based on genetic mapping experiments, and it is important to confirm that these associations are consistent in mapping populations and breeding populations. For efficient MAS, marker(s) should co-segregate or be closely linked with the target trait, with a distance of 2 cM or less. Markers associated with major genes or quantitative trait loci (QTL) in one population may be used directly for MAS in other materials. For genes with relatively small effects, however, cross-population comparison of genes, alleles, and gene effects are required because of multilocus and multiallelic features that characterize most quantitative traits. To find tight marker-trait associations, a two-step process could be involved (especially for quantitative traits). The first step is based on a primary mapping population derived from very diverse parents, often with complicated genetic backgrounds. The second step is based on near isogenic lines that share a common genetic background and differ only at the target locus. There are many factors that are related to the detection of marker-trait associations and the efficiency of MAS. Marker-trait association or trait mapping has been discussed in detail elsewhere (Xu 1992; Tanksley 1993; Xu 1997, 2002; Liu 1998; Lynch and Walsh 1998; Paterson 1998; Flint and Mott 2001). 1. Genetic Backgrounds. Gene mapping requires the ability to extract a genetic signal from background “noise.” Sources of “noise” include variability in the external environments in which plant phenotypes are evaluated and variability due to differences in the internal genetic backgrounds of the individuals in a population. For accurate gene mapping,
86
Y. XU
the “noise” must be minimized or eliminated. “Controlled” environmental and/or genetic backgrounds are created to help filter the “noise.” Creation of homogeneous genetic backgrounds will help define markertrait associations. Xu (2002) described five approaches for creation of homogeneous or isogenic backgrounds: backcross-derived near-isogenic lines (NILs), selfing-derived NILs, whole genome selection of permanent populations, mutation, and chromosome substitution. Genetic materials, such as NILs with homogeneous backgrounds, have been used in many different investigations. If NILs are used, interaction between the target gene and other major genes/QTL can be eliminated and only epistasis between multiple target genetic loci needs to be considered. With removal of noise from heterogeneous backgrounds, the proportion of variance explained by the target loci will increase and minor genes (genes with smaller effects) can be identified. By minimizing the disturbance from the genetic background, multiple loci in a single chromosomal region can be separated and their effect on the phenotype can be partitioned. When all genotypic variation comes from the target loci, environmental effects can be estimated. Heterogeneous genetic backgrounds can also come from populations with different structures, such as F2, doubled haploids (DH), and recombinant inbred lines (RILs), but derived from the same cross, or come from various crosses derived from different cultivars, subspecies, species, and families. Genetic materials with heterogeneous genetic backgrounds can be used to estimate epistasis, detect non-allelic genes, discover multiple alleles, and identify paralogous and orthologous genes. As a contribution to complicated genetic backgrounds, many quantitative traits per se are a complex consisting of several components or subtraits. For example, polygenic sterility in rice can be partitioned into several components, including male and female sterility, or ovary and pollen abortion, so that polygenes can be divided into several components with different functions and, thus, can be handled more easily (Shen and Xu 1992). Genetic backgrounds in a population can also be complicated by the contribution of other related traits. 2. Alleles at Multiple Loci. When multiple loci control a trait, their alleles of positive or negative effect (increasing or decreasing trait value) tend to be dispersed between parents, each with positive alleles at one or some loci but negative alleles at others (Xu and Shen 1992). These dispersed alleles can be cryptic transgressive, which has been found in the parents with similar phenotypes (Xu et al. 1998). In genetic mapping, phenotypic difference between parents is unnecessary for detection of QTL. In many QTL studies, mapping populations were developed without consideration of phenotypic differences between the two parents and
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
87
QTL mapped without a statistical test of the parental difference. In most cases where no parental difference is found, QTL are still detected, which could be due to the complementary distributions of positive and negative allelic effects in the parents. As observed in QTL mapping, on average, about four QTL are identified for each trait in rice (Xu 2002), the same as the average obtained for 176 trial-trait combinations as reviewed by Kearsey and Farquhar (1998). When QTL identified for the same trait are summarized over different projects/populations, this number becomes much larger. For example, plant height has been mapped using 13 populations with 63 QTL reported. Some of the QTL are allelic to each other, that is, they were mapped to the same chromosomal region or intervals of less than 15 cM. After elimination of possible allelic QTL, the total number of QTL for plant height is reduced to 29, with up to five QTL existing on one chromosome (Xu 2002). In contrast, over 50 independent single gene mutations have been identified so far for plant height in rice, as summarized by Kinoshita (1998). Some plant height QTL were co-located with major plant height loci, suggesting that the gene controlling quantitative variation may be the same as those associated with macromutations. This has been demonstrated based on high-resolution mapping and cloning of a QTL for plant height in rice (E. M. Septiningsih and S. R. McCouch at Cornell, pers. commun.). To date, QTL alleles that have been cloned in rice all correspond to previously identified single gene mutants. For example, a photoperiod sensitivity QTL, Hd1, is allelic to the major gene, Se1 (Yano et al. 2000). QTL allelism tests and determination of major-gene and QTL correspondences are facilitated by the availability of high-density molecular maps with a common set of markers shared among researchers. 3. Multiple Alleles at a Locus. Two-parent derived populations in diploid crops have only two alleles segregating at each locus. Identification of multiple alleles requires comparison of populations derived from different crosses. To distinguish alleles identified in one cross from those in another, all alleles must be accurately sized and documented. Rice amylose content, mainly controlled by the wx gene, is a good example for multiple alleles at a locus. A polymorphic microsatellite was identified in the wx gene (Bligh et al. 1995) located 55 bp upstream of the putative 5’-leader intron splice site. A total of 16 wx microsatellite alleles were identified in worldwide rice germplasm (Ayres et al. 1997; Zeng et al. 2000). Now the question is whether the multiple alleles identified at the waxy locus can be associated with specific quantitative effects, including developing an understanding of how each allele interacts with other genes/alleles in the genetic background
88
Y. XU
and in response to environment. Using the best-characterized examples, such as wx, the challenge will be to extend this kind of analysis to other traits or genetic loci. Using gene-based molecular markers that have multiple alleles in gene mapping could help identify multiple alleles at a locus. Genetic mapping studies using different populations have identified some common major genes and QTL. It is necessary, however, to further clarify whether common or different functional alleles were identified at those loci. Reporting the sizes of associated (closely linked) alleles and using allele-rich markers in marker-trait association studies will provide a baseline of information required for this clarification, with the assumption that each marker has a corresponding allele at the trait locus. There are many reasons why close marker-trait associations are required: (1) chromosomal location associated with the trait must be reduced to a manageable piece of DNA if cloning of specific genes is necessary; (2) to identify all the related genes for a specific trait, a highdensity genetic map is required because the fewer markers are used, the smaller proportion of genetic factors contributing to that trait will be sampled; (3) large genetic distances between markers and target traits will contribute to the rapid decrease of MAS efficiency after several successive cycles of selection; and (4) to minimize linkage drag involved in gene introgression, closely linked markers around the target region are needed. QTL mapping presumes accurate phenotypic scoring methods, something that can be difficult to optimize and even more difficult to keep consistent for months or years. Just a few misscored individuals can totally confound QTL discovery and placement (Young 1999). This is also true for fine mapping of major genes for map-based cloning, where misscoring of several plants in a population with thousands of individuals will result in a large error (up to one cM) in estimating genetic distances. High levels of accuracy are required to dissect a chromosomal region associated with a given trait and narrow down the candidate region to a single contig, that is, a set of clones that can be assembled into a linear order. D. Genotyping and High-throughput Genotyping Systems To make marker-based technology practical for breeding applications, an automated genotyping system is required. Such an automated system using SSRs to genotype rice germplasm and breeding populations was developed, through improved DNA extraction and loading with multiple-PCR products. This system brings the cost per data point down to as low as $0.30 with daily data output up to 4608 data points per ABI
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
89
3100 Sequencer (Xu et al. 2002). This level of efficiency makes it possible to genotype thousands of individual plants with a panel of eight SSR markers in a week using two sequencers. SNPs have gained wide acceptance as genetic markers for use in linkage and association studies, especially for human genetics. Highthroughput SNP genotyping has great potential for many applications, including MAS on the basis of whole genome approaches. This has led to a requirement for high-throughput SNP genotyping platforms. Development of such a platform depends on coupling reliable chemical assays with an appropriate detection system to maximize efficiency with respect to accuracy, speed, and cost. Current technology platforms are able to deliver throughputs in excess of 100,000 genotypes per day, with an accuracy of >99%, at a cost of 20–30 cents per genotype (Jenkins and Gibson 2002). In order to meet the demands of the coming years, however, genotyping platforms need to deliver throughputs in the order of one million genotypes per day at a cost of only a few cents per genotype. In addition, DNA template requirements must be minimized such that hundreds of thousands of SNPs can be interrogated using a relatively small amount of genomic DNA. Jenkins and Gibson (2002) predicted that the next generation of high-throughput genotyping platforms would exploit large-scale multiplex reactions and solid phase assay detection systems. Released genomic sequences of rice and Arabidopsis can be used to develop gene-based SNPs for other related species. E. Data Management and Delivery To handle the daily data flow from the lab to the breeder and integrate information from molecular markers, genetic mapping, and phenotyping, many informatics tools are needed. For efficient data management and delivery, it is important for all researchers to follow general rules through all these procedures. A standard reporting system is also critical for comparative genomics, QTL allelism tests, data sharing and mining, and the association between major genes and QTL. As discussed by Xu (2002), a standard system for marker-trait association should include associated alleles and allele characterization such as allele sizes, gene effects, variation explained by each gene or all genes in the model, gene interaction if more than one gene is identified, and genotype × environment interaction if more than one environment is involved. Genetic information should be shared and combined with data generated in plant breeding, for example, germplasm diversity, mapping populations, pedigrees, graphical genotypes, mutants, and other genetic stocks. With several thousand data points flowing out of the laboratory every day, timely scoring and delivery of the results to breeders are basic
90
Y. XU
requirements for a high-efficiency breeding system. Well-trained assistants for genotyping and scoring, coupled with research scientists who can analyze data in meaningful ways, are the key components for a data management and delivery system. A laboratory with well-equipped facilities has to be also well equipped with qualified personnel and software required for data integration, manipulation, analysis, and mining. Timely delivery of data to the breeder is also equally important, because in many cases the time window the breeder can use for selection is very limited. With the high-throughput genotyping and data management systems currently available, it takes about a week to generate and analyze data for a breeding-related population consisting of several hundred individuals. This includes activities ranging from leaf tissue harvesting to DNA extraction, genotyping, data scoring, analyzing, summarizing, and reporting.
IV. GERMPLASM EVALUATION Germplasm resources represent the genetic variability required for continuous improvement of crop plants. The old paradigm for evaluation and utilization of germplasm involves looking for a clearly defined character by screening entries from a genebank. This approach works well when the trait of interest is controlled by one or few genes. For traits such as yield, genetically controlled by many genes, it is impossible to identify all these genes phenotypically because each gene has a relatively small but similar effect. As a result, exotic germplasm, which is perceived to be a poor bet for the improvement of most traits based on phenotypic examination, may contain some favorable genes (alleles) that lie buried amidst the thousands of accessions maintained in genebanks (de Vicente and Tanksley 1993; Tanksley and McCouch 1997; Xiao et al. 1998). The new paradigm involves looking for genes using molecular markers and/or the integrative power of QTL analysis, which can be used to extract superior genes (alleles) from the inferior germplasm accessions. Molecular marker-assisted germplasm evaluation aims to complement phenotypic evaluation by helping define the genetic architecture of germplasm resources and by identifying alleles that are associated with key phenotypic traits. Molecular markers may allow for characterization based on gene, genotype, and genome, which provide more accurate and detailed information than classical phenotypic or passport data. Many features revealed by molecular markers, such as unique alleles, allele frequency, and heterozygosity at marker loci, mirror the genetic loci for heterosis and the traits of agronomic importance. On a more fundamental level, molecular marker information may lead
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
91
to the identification of useful genes contained in collections and transferal of those genes into well-adapted cultivars. Bretting and Widrlechner (1995) comprehensively reviewed genetic markers and their application in plant genetic resource management, including procedures related to acquisition/distribution, maintenance, and utilization. In this section, discussion will be focused on the aspects more related to breeding applications. A. Assessing Collection Redundancies and Gaps With a large number of germplasm accessions available for each cultivated plant, it is likely that many represent duplicate or nearly identical samples of the same cultivar, while others embody rare alleles or highly unusual allele combinations, with many genes or alleles still missing in current collections. According to the International Board for Plant Genetic Resources (IBPGR), over 3.6 million germplasm accessions for different crop species are conserved at international and national genebanks, which include 90,000 for rice, 120,000 for wheat, and 25,000 for maize (Iwanaga 1993). Evaluation of genetic diversity will help in the understanding of genetic structure of existing collections and design acquisition strategies. In particular, calculation of genetic distance (GD) can be used to identify particularly divergent subpopulations that might harbor valuable genetic variation that is underrepresented in current holdings. Redundancy germplasm accessions exist in many germplasm collections because of different names for the same cultivars or duplicate samplings of the same accessions. Pedigree-related cultivars, siblines, and NILs may represent another type of redundancy because they are genotypically duplicated at most of the genetic loci. For example, U.S. rice cultivars ‘M5’, ‘M301’, ‘M103’, ‘S201’, ‘Calrose’, ‘Calrose 76’, ‘CS-M3’, and ‘Calmochi-202’ shared the same panel of alleles at all 100 RFLP loci tested by Xu et al. (2004). All these cultivars can be traced back to a common ancestor, ‘Caloro’. No genetic polymorphism could be detected either at any of the 60 SSR loci between ‘Calrose’ and ‘Calrose 76’ (Xu et al. 2004), because they are isolines, with ‘Calrose 76’ representing a variant derived from ‘Calrose’ via chemical mutagenesis (Rutger et al. 1977). Using 15 SSR markers, Dean et al. (1999) assayed 19 sorghum [Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench] accessions identified as “Orange” presently maintained by the U.S. National Plant Germplasm System (NPGS). They found most accessions are genetically distinct, but two redundant groups were found. The variance analysis also indicated that it should be possible to reduce the number of Orange accessions held by NPGS by almost half without seriously jeopardizing the overall amount
92
Y. XU
of genetic variation contained in these holdings. Chavarriaga-Aquirre et al. (1999) evaluated genetic diversity and redundancy in a cassava core collection. The core collection (630 accessions) was selected from the base collection (over 5500 accessions) on the basis of diversity of origin (country and geographic), morphology, isozyme patterns, and specific agronomic criteria. A small number (1.34%) of potential duplicates were identified from the core collection through isozyme and AFLP profiles. Different germplasm collections can be compared for the frequencies of alleles at all marker loci so that distinctive alleles, allele combinations, and allele frequency patterns can be identified. Chromosomal regions containing loci that show the greatest changes in allele frequency between the collections can be located. The rationale for this analysis is to define the genomic regions where selection under the environment had given rise to allele combinations or allele frequency patterns that distinguished a group of accessions with less diversity from more diverse accession groups. In the rice example (Xu et al. 2004), alleles at two RFLP loci (a 6.5 kb allele at CDO686/HindIII and a 6.0 kb allele at BCD808/XbaI) and alleles at six SSR loci were represented at frequencies of 17.1% to 33.6% in the world collection, but had been completely lost in the U.S. cultivars. When low-frequency or underrepresented alleles are defined as those that occur in four or fewer U.S. cultivars but are very frequent (i.e., >17% for SSR and >30% for RFLP) in the world collection, alleles underrepresented in the U.S. collection were found at 19 RFLP and 18 SSR loci. Three U.S. cultivars, ‘Della’, ‘Rexmont’, and ‘Caloro’, retained 34 of the 37 low-frequency alleles. ‘Della’ alone retained 24 (64.9%) of them, which could be traced back to two of its ancestral cultivars, ‘Rexoro’ and ‘Delitus’. The U.S. rice cultivars that were developed from a small set of germplasm introductions help explain why these cultivars retained an unusually large number of alleles that show a decline in frequency among later developed U.S. cultivars. B. Monitoring Genetic Shifts Maintaining genetic diversity and preventing genetic drifts is one of the most important objectives for germplasm conservation. In openpollinated species, deviations from random mating, primarily in the form of assortative or consanguineous matings, needs to be monitored during germplasm regeneration. In maize, deviations from random mating were widely studied with emphasis on detailed multilocus isozyme analyses of one or two synthetic or open-pollinated maize cultivars (Kahler et al. 1984; Pollak et al. 1984; Bijlsma et al. 1986). In general, levels of selfing did not exceed those expected under random-mating mod-
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
93
els, but significant deviations were caused by temporal variation in the pollen pool or by gametophytic selection. The genetic profiles of germplasm accessions can change during the course of medium- or long-term storage. Storage effects fall into three broad categories: (1) the occurrence of mutations, (2) the occurrence of chromosomal aberrations, and (3) shifts in gene frequencies resulting from differential genotypic viability in heterogeneous populations (Roos 1988). After a comprehensive review of storage effects on seeds, Roos (1988) found little evidence for heritable changes in germplasm attributable to storage-induced chromosomal aberrations, and noted “little need for concern about mutation as a significant factor in altering the composition of germplasm collection.” However, differential seed longevity can markedly reduce genetic variability over time (Bretting and Widrlechner 1995). This is well documented by experiments involving mixtures of eight bean lines (Roos 1984) and four seed storage protein genotypes within a cultivar of wheat (Stoyanova 1991). Genetic shifts can be caused by in vitro culture. The genetic stability of germplasm maintained in tissue culture (in vitro) has generally been monitored with karyotypic markers such as chromosome number and morphology (D’Amato 1975), because cytological variability has been considered a primary cause of somaclonal variation. Lassner and Orton (1983) reported that isozymatically identical in vitro cultures of celery were markedly variable cytologically. This finding should reinforce the concept that the genetic stability of in vitro cultures should be monitored with a battery of different genetic markers, particularly those DNA markers that collectively span the whole genome (Bretting and Widrlechner 1995). A certain level of heterogeneity could exist in germplasm accessions that are mainly self-pollinated, which provides a buffer for maintaining genetic diversity and preventing genetic drifts. Monitoring heterogeneous accessions will help develop strategies for regeneration of germplasm samples without loss of the allelic diversity provided by heterogeneity. In general, traditional cultivars had a higher level of heterozygosity, as reported in rice by Olufowote et al. (1997). Genetic diversity resulting from the heterozygosity was also found within inbred lines from different sources in rice (Olufowote et al. 1997) and maize (Gethi et al. 2002). As reported by Xu et al. (2004), a total of 120 (50.6%) of the 236 rice accessions was found heterozygous at one or more RFLP or SSR loci, and the number of heterozygous loci detected in a single rice accession ranged from 0 to 39 (25.3% of the 160 loci). These heterozygous allele patterns could indicate either seed mixtures or true heterozygosity remaining in these cultivars despite the fact that all accessions had been purified.
94
Y. XU
C. Identifying Unique Germplasm Progress in hybrid breeding is demonstrated by the development of new parental lines and hybrids that are superior for one or more characteristics once a commercialized hybrid system has already been established. Progress depends on (1) discovery and generation of genetic variation for heterosis and agronomic traits and (2) accurate selection of rare genotypes that possess new or improved attributes due to superior combinations of alleles at multiple loci. Over the past century, the development and successful application of modern breeding methodologies has produced the high-yielding cultivars and hybrids on which modern farming is based. As the demand for uniform performance and grain quality has increased, new cultivars and hybrids are increasingly derived from adapted, genetically related, and elite modern cultivars/hybrids, while genetically more variable, but less productive, primitive ancestors are excluded from most breeding programs (Tanksley and McCouch 1997). In a study of pedigree relationships among 140 U.S. rice accessions, Dilday (1990) concluded that all parental germplasm in public cultivars used in the southern United States today could be traced back to 22 plant introductions in the early 1900s, and those used in California could be traced to 23 introductions. The same situation is true for soybean and wheat. Virtually all modern U.S. soybean cultivars can be traced back to a dozen strains from a small area in northeastern China, and the majority of hard red winter wheat cultivars in the United States originated from just two lines imported from Poland and Russia (Tanksley and McCouch 1997). To broaden the genetic base of specific cultivated species, the genetic diversity within collections must be assessed in the context of the total available genetic diversity for each species. With the use of DNA profiles, the genetic uniqueness of each accession in a germplasm collection or in a population can be determined, and the identity and frequency of individual alleles can be clearly described and characterized (Brown and Kresovich 1996; Smith and Helentjaris 1996). The sampling of exotic germplasm should emphasize the genetic composition rather than the appearance of exotic accessions. Accessions with DNA profiles most distinct from that of modern germplasm are likely to contain the greatest number of novel alleles. Assuming that most marker alleles having the same molecular weight are likely to be common by descent in a specific varietal group, we are able to trace alleles that are frequent in one specific collection but existed in low frequency or not at all in the other. Examination of the chromosomal distribution of the loci harboring underrepresented alleles indicated that underrepresented alleles in the U.S. rice cultivars as discussed in previous sections tended to cluster on 11 chromosomal fragments (Xu
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
95
et al. 2004). This raises the question about what genes are located in these regions and whether U.S. breeders have consciously or unconsciously narrowed the range of genetic variation in these regions. It also suggests that molecular marker analysis could be used to identify parents harboring rare or novel alleles in these regions so that the functional significance of the resident genes could be determined using both traditional crossing and sequence-based genomics approaches. Considering the allele frequency profiles across all cultivars will give us some idea of which cultivars may retain or contain the rare genes/alleles and whether these alleles may be important to our future breeding programs. The germplasm that holds unique alleles may contain unique genetic variation required for trait improvement. In the rice example (Xu et al. 2004), 15 (6.4%) of the rice accessions in the 236 × 160 data set had unique alleles for at least one RFLP locus, with a total of 21 unique RFLP alleles were found. Eighty-one (34.3%) rice accessions had unique SSR alleles with a total of 153 unique SSR alleles identified. The germplasm accessions identified with unique alleles have unique geographical origins with high genetic diversity and could have potential use in the exploitation of heterosis. Genetic similarity between any two cultivars can be calculated as the proportion of shared alleles. Theoretically, shared allele frequency (SAF) is positively related to the number of cultivars in the analysis and negatively related to the informativeness of the markers. The most similar accessions should share alleles at almost all marker loci, while the least similar accessions should have none of the alleles in common. When evaluating genetic similarity, SAFs are averaged over all possible pairs of cultivars. A smaller average similarity indicates a greater genetic difference with respect to the rest of the cultivars in the collection. Based on the averaged SAF, the most diverse accessions can be selected to represent cultivars that host the least-frequent alleles and are genotypically most different from other accessions. From 236 rice cultivars, Xu et al. (2004) selected the 16 most diverse accessions (with SAF < 50%) based on RFLP markers and 49 accessions based on SSR markers. Most of these selections, such as ‘Caloro’, ‘Cina’, ‘Badkalamkati’, ‘DGWG’, and ‘TN1’, were ancestral cultivars that had been used as parents in breeding programs over 40 years ago, and none of the selections is from the U.S. collection that has a much narrower genetic basis. D. Construction of Core Collection According to its original definition (Frankel 1984), a core subset of a germplasm collection contains, with minimal redundancy, most of the entire collection’s genetic diversity. Several different methods have
96
Y. XU
been used to construct core collections (Crossa et al. 1995; Hamon et al. 1995; Schoen and Brown 1995; van Hintum 1995). Construction of a core collection has a target of selecting approximately 10% of the germplasm accessions to represent at least 70% of the genetic variability (e.g., Brown 1989a,b). In addition to phenotypic evaluation, molecular marker technology provides us with a new tool to construct a core collection that can represent most of the genetic diversity at molecular level. Combining the use of different types of markers that reveal different levels of genetic diversity will help select a core collection to better represent genome-wide diversity. Shared allele frequency and frequency for hosting rare alleles are two important criteria that can be used to construct the core collection. In the rice example given in Section IIIB, accessions were selected based on the frequency of unique RFLP and SSR alleles and shared allele frequency. Subsets of various sizes were selected (representing 5% to 50% of each of the U.S. and world collections), using random selection as a control. For each sample size, 200 replications were analyzed through a resampling technique and the number of alleles in each subgroup was compared to the total number of alleles identified in the larger collection from which the subsets were sampled. The following conclusions were obtained (Xu et al. 2004): (1) more samples are needed to represent a diverse germplasm collection (the world collection) than a germplasm collection containing more pedigree-related cultivars (the U.S. collection), (2) combining use of shared allele frequency and unique alleles improves representativeness of a core collection, (3) core collections selected on the basis of shared allele frequency require much fewer samples than random selection for the same level of representativeness, and (4) more samples are needed to represent genetic diversity at marker loci that reveal a higher level of polymorphism. A 31-cultivar subset (13% of the entire collection), selected on the basis of both shared allele frequencies and number of unique alleles detected, represented 94.9% of RFLP alleles and 74.4% of SSR alleles. It can be expected that selection criteria based on additional sources of information will further improve the value and representativeness of core collections. When molecular markers are developed from DNA sequences with unknown function, identical marker alleles in two collections may not mean that the two collections share identical genes that are linked to the marker locus. There is a potential risk that genetic variation for important phenotypic traits could be lost if core collections are based only on those markers. As the genome sequence is deciphered and the function of many genes is determined, intragenic markers will become available for many genes. Core collections of germplasm constructed using intra-
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
97
genic markers and functional alleles will represent a “core collection” of genes. As gene structure-function relationships are clarified with greater precision, it will be possible to focus attention on genetic diversity within the active sites of a structural gene or within key promoter regions. This will make it productive to screen large germplasm collections for functional nucleotide polymorphism (FNP), targeting the search for alleles that are likely to be phenotypically relevant at specific loci. From a primary collection, a user who had identified an accession or accessions of interest would move to the next level of information, where clusters of germplasm known to represent a broader spectrum of diversity within a specific gene pool or a specific trait could be defined. The second level of investigation could be conducted using carefully designed sets of molecular markers known to target specific traits or regions of the genome. The construction of core collections may help establish heterotic groups and choose parents for establishing base populations. In the age of genomics, the context of germplasm resources should be expanded to include whole plants, seeds, plant parts, tissue, and clones, from distinct species and synthetic germplasm and all types of mutants. An extreme example is DNA or protein sequence. The ultimate goal of germplasm conservation is to maintain the genes and gene combinations. With a suitable vehicle, germplasm could be maintained in the form of a gene sequence. Genetic manipulation allows gene flow across the reproductive barriers existing among distant species. So germplasm evaluation is not necessarily defined for each species or crop (Xu and Luo 2002). The issues discussed in this section, currently suitable for each crop, can be extended to all vehicles of genetic information such as tissues, clones, genes, and sequences. E. Germplasm Genotyping Database Plant geneticists and breeders may use the data from a germplasm evaluation project as a guide in choosing the most efficient crosses for genetic studies and breeding. For instance, it provides preliminary polymorphism data for many pairwise combinations of parents. Theoretically, the dataset with 236 rice cultivars provides polymorphism surveys for 236 × 235/2 = 27,730 possible cross combinations, including thousands of indica/indica, indica/japonica, and japonica/japonica crosses. With an increasing number of markers surveyed on a variety of germplasm accessions and as more data flows into the database from multiple sources, it is increasingly possible to determine the genetic constitution and genetic relationships among a wide range of parental lines, cultivars,
98
Y. XU
and wild relatives. This also provides the foundation for developing hypotheses based on association genetics to relate agronomically important phenotypes to the presence or absence of specific molecular marker alleles. A comprehensive DNA fingerprinting of crop gene pools, including as many cultivars, hybrid parents, and progeny as possible, is the first step for using MAS in hybrid breeding. These data can be integrated with both phenotypic information and pedigree information. A database of DNA marker alleles for the elite gene pool of a crop provides information on specific DNA polymorphisms that is needed to design, execute, and analyze genetic mapping experiments, targeted at specific traits or specific crosses. The same database serves as a classification tool, describing the overall levels and patterns of variation within the crop gene pool and illustrating subdivisions within a gene pool such as heterotic groups. Such information is useful in making predictions about the performance of new cultivars and hybrids, or selecting parents for crosses that are likely to yield new gene combinations, or afford an optimal degree of heterosis. An efficient approach to the screening of germplasm involves the ability to rapidly create a nested series of core collections, based on information about geographical, phenotypic, and genotypic diversity stored in a database. The construction of such a system would require a largescale effort to provide genotypic information using a standard set of markers that could serve as a reference point. As new markers and marker systems were developed, they could be overlaid onto the essential framework of diversity established previously. An increasingly powerful information system could be developed if data models were made explicit and the data structures were modular so that new types of genetic information could be readily incorporated as they became available. As we have seen from the rice example (Xu et al. 2004), RFLP and SSR markers provide complementary information about overall genetic diversity, but one marker system may have specific advantages that recommend it for a particular type of study. By accumulating historical information in a systematic way, germplasm collections would rapidly gain in value because they could be screened computationally for essential molecular and phenotypic characteristics of interest. Databases for whole genomic sequences for several important species, both dicots and monocots, are available, with more being added, allowing directed discovery of genes in higher plants and classification of alleles present in a wide range of breeding germplasm. As indicated by Sorrells and Wilson (1997), identification of the genes controlling a trait and knowledge of their DNA sequence would facilitate classification of variation in a germplasm pool based on gene fingerprinting or charac-
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
99
terization of variation in key DNA sequences. Classification of sequence variants within genes such as SNPs at a large number of targeted loci would substantially reduce the amount of work required to determine their relative breeding value and lead to the identification of superior alleles.
V. TRAITS REQUIRING TESTCROSSING OR PROGENY TESTING Improvements in inbreds per se will play an increasingly important role in breeding hybrid crops. Bringing dominant genes for non-heterotic traits such as disease resistance into inbreds will enhance the overall performance of hybrids. MAS for non-heterotic traits should be performed the same as those in breeding cultivars. Although there is every reason to believe that plant breeding in the 21st century will still depend, to a great extent, on conventional methods for phenotypic selection, molecular biology could help identify and manipulate favorable alleles and select the traits that are not measurable under normal environments with conventional methods. Using molecular markers in plant breeding has been discussed elsewhere (Beckmann and Soller 1986; Paterson et al. 1991; Dudley 1993; Stuber 1994; Xu 1994; Xu and Zhu 1994; Lee 1995; Paterson 1996; Hospital and Charcosset 1997; Mackill and Ni 2001; Xu 2002). Xu (2002) described six situations that are suitable for MAS with the current knowledge available. These include selection without testcrossing or a progeny test; selection independent of environments; selection without laborious fieldwork or intensive laboratory work; selection at an earlier breeding stage; selection for multiple genes and/or multiple traits; and whole genome selection. Selection for traits requiring testcrossing and/or a progeny test will be discussed in this section. In breeding hybrids, many traits need testcrossing and progeny testing for unambiguous identification. Typical examples for all hybrid crops include testcrossing for screening of heterosis and combining ability. For hybrid crops based on a cytoplasmic male sterility system, malesterility restoration is at the top of the testcross list. For hybrid crops that use distant crosses with hybridization barriers, for example, partial sterility in indica × japonica crosses of rice, a testcross is required to find genes related to the hybridization barrier. In testcrossing, each candidate plant or family will be crossed to testers and then its genotype will be inferred from a progeny test in the next season. Each candidate must be harvested and maintained separately and only the plants/families with the target trait will advance to
100
Y. XU
the next procedure. Testcrossing may continue for several generations until the selected plants reach a certain level of homozygosity. A successful breeding program would take more than 50% of the breeders’ effort for testcrossing and progeny testing. Using MAS, one might reduce or eliminate testcrossing and/or progeny testing for traits controlled by major genes. A. Fertility Restoration Many important crop species, including rice, sorghum, and sunflower, depend on CMS and its fertility restoration for hybrid seed production. As indicated above, a large amount of testcrossing and progeny testing is involved in breeding CMS lines and their restorers. Testcrossing can start as early as with the F2 generation. F2 plants will be selected first for other agronomic traits, and selected plants are testcrossed to maintainer lines for CMS maintaining ability or to restorer lines for restorability. The testcross progeny will be planted the following season for fertility observation. Only the plants with complete sterile testcross progeny (for CMS) or completely fertile testcross progeny (for restorability) will be moved to the next breeding procedure. MAS can be used to replace testcross and progeny testing if markers closely linked to fertility restorability are identified. Table 3.1 lists crops and their restorability genes that have been associated with molecular markers. A total of 12 crop species were reported with molecular markers identified for fertility restoration, including maize, rice, sorghum, wheat, barley, rye, sunflower, oilseed rape, sugar beet, and onion. Genes for fertility restoration in rice have been found each on chromosomes 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5, and two on chromosome 10. Many markers are closely linked with fertility restoration and can be directly used for MAS. In rice, an RFLP marker RG140 with PvuII digestion linked with the Rf3 on chromosome 1 was useful for increasing screening efficiency for restorers (Virmani 2002). Although many genes for fertility restoration have been reported as QTL without genetic distances available, associated markers still provide useful information for MAS. In several cases, RAPD markers have been converted to STS or sequence characterized amplified region (SCAR) markers that are more suitable for MAS. B. Outcrossing Evolutionary change in plant mating systems from outcrossing (crosspollination) to inbreeding (self-pollination) has occurred frequently throughout the history of flowering plants and has been described as the
Table 3.1.
Molecular markers associated with fertility restoration in crops. R gene
Species
CMS
Allium cepa Beta vulgaris
S Owen H
X R1H
Owen Owen Ogu
2QTL QTL Rfo
Ogura
R
pol
Rfp
PET1
Rf1
Brassica napus
Helianthus annuus
Raphanus sativus Oryza sativa
PEF1 PEF1 ogu
101
BT BT HL WA WA WA WA WA WA WA
Rf1 Rf1
Rf3
Marker type RFLP RFLP RAPD, RFLP RFLP RFLP RAPD, RFLP RAPD RAPD, RFLP RAPD RFLP RAPD RAPD, SCAR RFLP SSR SSR RFLP RFLP RFLP RFLP RFLP RFLP RAPD, RFLP
Linked markers AOB210, API65 pKP1238 K11-1000, pKP753
OPC02-1150, OPD02-1000 OPK12-750, F04-500 4ND7b, 5E12b
Chromosome or (linkage group) (B) (3) 4
Distance (cM) 14, 15 9.6 5.2, 1.7
3 4 (DY15)
(18)
King et al. 1998 Pillen et al. 1993 Laporte et al. 1998 Hjerdin-Panagopoulos et al. 2002 Hjerdin-Panagopoulos et al. 2002 Delourme at al. 1994, 1998
1.2, 7.7
Hansen et al. 1997
10.8, 5.4
Jean et al. 1997
OPC07-900, OPD10-750
Ji et al. 1996 (6) (1)
OPH11-410 G2155, C1361 OSRRf RM258 RG69a, RG413 C22, RG4449d RZ404c-RG241B RG69A-RG413 C22-RG449D RG435-RG172A RG532, RG140/RG458
Reference
1.2 10L 10 3 4 2 3 4 5 1
3.5, 3.9 3.7 7.8
1.4, 1.9
Gentzbittel et al. 1995 Quillet et al. 1995 Murayana et al. 1999 Kurata et al. 1994 Akagi et al. 1996 Huang et al. 1999 Li et al. 1996 Li et al. 1996 Zhu et al. 1996 Zhu et al. 1996 Zhu et al. 1996 Zhu et al. 1996 Zhang et al. 1997 (continued)
102
Table 3.1.
Continued R gene
Species
CMS
Oryza sativa (cont.)
WA WA WA WA WA WA WA Ci
Rf4 Rf6(t) Rf5 Fr
Ci
Fr2
Phaseolus vulgaris
Secale cereale
Sorghum bicolor Triticum aestivum Zea mays
Hordeum vulgare
G P P A1
rf1
A3 T T T T T T S C msm1
rf4 Rf3 Rf3 Rf6 Rf1 Rf2 Rf8 Rf3 Rf4 Rfm1
Marker type RFLP RFLP RFLP RFLP SSR SSR RFLP RAPD, RFLP RAPD, RFLP RAPD, RFLP RFLP RFLP AFLP/ SSR ST/CAPS RFLP RFLP RFLP RFLP RFLP AFLP RFLP RFLP RAPD/STS
Linked markers RG532, R173 G403, C234 C1361, S11019 R2309, RG257 RM171, RM228 RM244 RG374, RG394 Bng228, R335F/UBC487 Bng228, Bng102
PSR596-PSR634 PSR899-MWG573 Xtxa2582, Xtxp18, Xtxp250 LW7, LW8 Xabc249, Xcdo442 Xbcd156, Xcdo388 Xksug48 umc97, umc92 umc153, sus1 Arf-8 whp1, bnl17.14 NP1114A OPI-18/900, MWG2218
Chromosome or (linkage group)
Distance (cM)
1 10 10L 10S 10L 10S 1 (K)
4.5, 0
Yao et al. 1997 Tan et al. 1998 Tan et al. 1998 Tan et al. 1998 Jing et al. 2001 Jing et al. 2001 Shen et al. 1998 He et al. 1995
(K)
0, 0.7
Jia et al. 1997
4RL 1RS 4RL (H) (E) 1BS 1BS 6BS 3S 9L 2L 8S 6H
6.0, 18.4 3.3, 19.1
Reference
3.7, 3.4
4.6 5 2.4, 12, 10.8 5.3, 3.2
1.2, 9.5 3.8, 5.8 4.5 4.3, 6.4 1.5 5.2, 5.6
Börner et al. 1998 Miedaner et al. 2000 Miedaner et al. 2000 Klein et al. 2001 Wen et al. 2002 Ma and Sorrells 1995 Kojima et al. 1997 Ma et al. 1995 Wise and Schnable 1994 Wise and Schnable 1994 Wise et al. 1999 Kamps and Chase 1997 Sisco 1991 Matsui et al. 2001
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
103
most common evolutionary trend in angiosperm reproduction (Stebbins 1957, 1970). For example, wild rice is frequently cross-pollinated, while cultivated rice is self-pollinated. Many characters involved in mating system evolution, such as sizes of floral organs or amount of pollen produced, are quantitative in nature. Hybrid seed production depends on the improvement of outcrossing-related traits and for selfpollinated crops, it might involve a reconstruction (or recovery) of the outcrossing mating system. Various techniques to produce hybrids have been developed depending on the crop, including hand emasculation, roguing of staminate plants in dioecious lines, use of gynoecious or highly female lines, CMS and genetic male sterility, protogyny, or self-incompatibility (Janick 1998). The rate of outcrossing is often the limiting factor determining whether a hybrid has potential for commercialization: Seed cost and price are both largely dependent on how easy it is to produce highquality hybrid seed that both seed providers and farmers accept. Maize was particularly suitable for hybrid breeding because of monoecism and the simple emasculation techniques practiced in breeding that allowed for easy inbreeding and outbreeding (Simmonds 1979). The necessity of high seeding rates in highly self-pollinated crops such as rice and wheat introduces an economic problem: Seed production costs must be low enough and yield of hybrids in the farmers’ fields must be high enough that farmers can profit from purchase and use of hybrid seed and companies can profit from their production and sale (Goldman 1999). Demands for low-cost seed dictates that seed yields be increased. As with sorghum and maize, some of the best new parents in sunflower are clearly more vigorous and high yielding than their predecessors. Sunflower is unique among the hybrid crops in that females are single headed but males have multiple heads, a recessive trait. Presence of multiple heads in the male ensures a long period of pollen availability, and better seed yield on the female, but it also hinders visual estimates of yield of the line per se (Duvick 1999). Yield of hybrid seed is determined by many variables, both genetic and environmental. In productive, favorable environments, seed yield from seed set through cross-pollination can approach those of conventional self-pollinated cultivars in wheat (Lucken 1986) or might be up to 80% of inbred lines in rice (Yuan and Chen 1988; Lu et al. 2001). The breeder’s approach to high, stable seed production is, first, to identify those plant and flower features that affect cross-pollination; second, to find variation for these traits; and third, to incorporate genes for favorable expression of traits into parental lines (Lucken 1986). Considering all hybrid cereal crops with the CMS system, measurements for
104
Y. XU
increased outcrossing rate will include choice of favorite climate conditions for seed production; ensuring flowering synchronization of the two parents; providing a suitable pollen source; developing male sterile lines with desirable outcrossing traits; supplementary pollination; and adjustment of flowering habit and stigma characteristics using growth regulators such as gibberellic acid. Many cereals are naturally self-pollinated. Their floral structure is adapted for inbreeding. Breeding parental lines may need to completely convert the floral structure and make them suitable for outcrossing. Outcrossing in rice depends on the capacity of stigmas to receive alien pollen and the capacity of anthers to emit much pollen to pollinate other plants in the proximity (Oka 1988). Genetic variation of floral traits in wild rice provides opportunities to modify floral structure for hybrid rice parents through the breeding process (Xu and Shen 1987, 1988a,c; Xu et al. 1988). For example, a wild rice, Oryza longistaminata, has big and exerted stigmas with a long life for outcrossing, which can be used for improving the female parent. Although genetic difference of stigma exertion between cultivated rice and a wild species is controlled by a major gene (Xu and Shen 1987), traditional breeding using Oryza longistaminata as an exerted stigma source has not been successful. Linkage between long exerted stigma and undesirable agronomic traits in wild rice species is quite strong and needs to be broken to incorporate these traits into selected genotypes. Using the gene eui (elongated upmost internode) to correct the panicle enclosure associated with CMS has been used in China for high-yielding seed production with the minimized gibberellic acid application, but has not been terribly successful. In addition, many cultivation practices have been used to facilitate outcrossing in rice by clipping flagleaf, applying gibberellic acid, supplementary pollination, and adjustment of flowering dates (Yuan and Chen 1988). The situation described for rice is also applicable to wheat and other self-pollinated species, especially those for which hand-emasculation is impractical. Although Wilson (1968) considered that the floral structure of wheat is oriented toward cross-pollination, a close examination of its floral traits clearly indicated that wheat is less suited, in its present form, to cross-pollination than crops such as maize, sorghum, and rye (Wilson and Driscoll 1983). A spike of cereal rye has ten times as many pollen grains as wheat, its flowers open considerably wider, and it has the ability to cross-pollinate under adverse weather conditions (De Vries 1971). While a great deal of variability for floral characteristics exists in wheat, the possibility of introducing additional characters favoring cross-pollination from wheat’s ancestral relatives should be explored.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
105
Miller and Lucken (1976) reported that environmental variation resulted in a sixfold difference in grain yield on a male-sterile wheat line grown at five locations in North Dakota over three years. After review of the status of hybrid wheat, Lucken and Johnson (1988) indicated the need for acquiring more knowledge about genetic variation of floral biology, including (1) spike and flower morphology; (2) pollen dispersal, buoyancy, durability, and vigor; (3) stigma accessibility, receptivity, and durability; and (4) development of selection screens for these traits. Genetic mapping of genes for restoration, pollen shedding, anther extrusion, seed set, female receptivity, combining ability, yield, quality, and disease resistance could revolutionize hybrid wheat breeding (Jordaan et al. 1999). Openness of the wheat flower and longevity of the stamen have been found to be under genetic control and can be improved through selection. Selection for better pollen quality and greater quantities thereof produced by the male will help improve the outcrossing. Technology is also available to transfer these characteristics from rye or even triticale (×Triticosecale) to wheat. Many factors affecting outcrossing provide opportunities for MAS. However, there are very few investigations on genetic mapping of traits related to outcrossing. Grandillo and Tanksley (1996) examined anther length in a backcross between Lycopersicon esculentum and L. pimpinellifolium. They found two QTL affecting this trait, on chromosomes 2 and 7, which accounted for only 24% of the phenotypic variation. Georgiady et al. (2002) investigated traits that distinguish outcrossing and selfpollinating forms of currant tomato, L. pimpinellifolium. Five QTL total were found involving four traits: total anther length, anther sterile length, style length, and flowers per inflorescence. Each of these four traits had a QTL of major (>25%) effect on phenotypic variance. In rice, some genetic mapping projects have been undertaken that target outcrossing. It is anticipated that MAS will provide a powerful tool to help fix the outcrossing-related issues in crops that are naturally selfpollinated but have great potential in hybrid breeding. Linkage drag associated with the introgression of outcrossing-related genes from wild species or distant cultivars may be overcome with marker-assisted background selection. Testcrossing-required traits, such as stigma longevity and receptivity, and labor-intensive traits, such as pollen load, can be selected much more easily through linked markers. C. Wide Compatibility Hybridization barriers exist in distant crosses of many crop species to some extent. Because the parents are not genetically compatible, hybrids
106
Y. XU
derived from intersubspecific crosses such as indica × japonica in rice are partially or completely sterile with seed set less than 30%, in addition to other unfavorable agronomic traits such as tall plant height and long days-to-heading (DTH) (Wang et al. 1991). Some intermediate cultivars have little or no hybrid barrier with either indica or japonica. The “intermediate type” was studied as early as in the 1930s, but Ikehashi (1982) first proposed the “wide compatibility” trait, which can be defined as the ability to make intersubspecific hybrids fertile. Discovery of wide compatibility in rice offers an opportunity for overcoming the reproductive barrier exhibited in hybrids between indica and japonica, and thereby for using the strong heterosis derived from intersubspecific crosses. To identify wide compatibility and transfer the related genes to other genetic backgrounds, testcrossing and progeny testing are required, as for fertility restoration. Several sets of testers were carefully selected for this purpose. IRRI evaluated wide compatibility using ‘Akihikari’, ‘Toyonishki’, and ‘Taichung 65’ as japonica testers, and ‘IR36’, ‘IR50’, and ‘IR64’ as indica testers. The China National Two-line Hybrid Rice Research Cooperative Group selected ‘Youmangzaoshajing’, ‘Banilla’, and ‘Akihikari’ as japonica testers and ‘Nantehao’, ‘Nanjing 11’, and ‘IR36’ as indica testers. Cultivars or individuals in breeding populations are considered wide compatible if the pollen fertility and seed set of the hybrids between them and all six testers are over 70%. A nation-wide effort in China for screening wide compatibility cultivars identified 51 cultivars, 49 of which had an average F1 fertility of over 80% when crossed with the six testers (Gu and Tang 2001). A lot of work is involved in testcrossing and progeny test to find out the cultivars or plants with wide compatibility. Molecular marker-assisted identification of wide compatibility genes will accelerate and facilitate the breeding process by eliminating or minimizing testcrossing and progeny testing. A genetic model was proposed by Ikehashi and Araki (1986) to account for wide compatibility. According this model, there are three alleles at the S5 locus: a neutral allele, S5n, an indica allele, S5i, and a japonica allele, S5j. A zygote from S5n allele with either of the other two alleles, S5nS5i and S5nS5j, would be fully fertile, while a zygote genotypically S5iS5j would be partially sterile. Using morphological markers, S5 was found to be closely linked with genes C (chromogen for apiculus pigmentation) and wx (waxy endosperm) on chromosome 6 (Ikehashi and Araki 1987). This chromosomal location was confirmed in several studies using isozymes (Li et al. 1991) and RFLP markers (Liu et al. 1992; Zheng et al. 1992; Yanagihara et al. 1995). A more precise
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
107
location of the S5 locus was provided by K. Liu et al. (1997), which was about 1 cM from an RFLP marker R2349. Many other wide compatibility cultivars have been identified (Xu et al. 1989; Gu and Tang 2001) and five new loci, S7, S8, S9, S15, and S16, were located on chromosomes 4, 6, 7, 12, and 1, respectively, by Yanagihara et al. (1992) and Wan et al. (1993). Allelic interaction at these loci can cause hybrid sterility, independently of each other, and neutral alleles to overcome this problem have been identified in different rice cultivars (Ikehashi and Wan 1998). These neutral alleles at different loci plus S5n are extremely important for enhancing the level of heterosis in rice. Except for these major genes, wide compatibility can be attributed to multiple loci with small effects (Shen and Xu 1992). QTL analysis of a wide compatibility cultivar ‘Dular’ identified five loci, located on chromosomes 1, 3, 5, 6, and 8, which jointly explained 55% of the variation for fertility (Wang et al. 1998). Wide compatibility has been selected using associated SSR markers in our breeding program.
VI. ENVIRONMENT-DEPENDENT TRAITS Plant populations used for gene analysis can be evaluated in either natural or controlled environments or both. Controlled environments can be compared with each other or with natural environments. If two environments mainly differ in one macro-environmental factor, they are considered contrasting or near iso-environments (NIEs), and the standard plot-to-plot variation and other residual micro-environmental effects can be neglected (Xu 2002). If the two environments are from experiments in different years or locations, it is assumed that location and year effects do not confound the effect of the macro-environmental factor. Some traits need to be measured under NIEs, where plants respond differently. In such cases, one environment imposes much less stress on plants than the other, for example, two environments with normal and high temperatures, respectively. The effect of the stress environment can be measured by comparing it to a much-less-stress or non-stress environment. A relative trait value is then derived from two direct trait values measured in each environment to ascertain the sensitivity of plants to the stress (Ni et al. 1998). If different plants have an identical phenotype under the much-less-stress environment (this is not true for a segregating population in most cases), the direct trait value in the stress environment can be used to measure sensitivity. When both environments impose little stress on plants and the plants respond differently, however, one should use relative trait values.
108
Y. XU
A. Photoperiod/Temperature Sensitivity A typical example for environment-dependent traits is photoperiod sensitivity that can only be measured in NIEs, one with short daylength and the other with long daylength. Plants start to flower when specific photoperiod and/or temperature conditions are met. Because of the complementary action of genes from two parents, hybrids could have very different photoperiod/temperature responses so that it is difficult to predict the flowering date of hybrids from those of their parents without a complete understanding of all related genes in the parents. Flowering synchronization of two parents is one of the factors influencing hybrid seed production and thus the economic advantage over the inbred lines/cultivars. To understand photoperiod and temperature responses, hybrids and their parents must be planted in a variety of environments or NIEs. Genetic study of these responses will finally characterize the parental photoperiod-thermo response pattern and its effect on their hybrids and thus make hybrid photoperiod-thermo response predictive. Once molecular markers have been associated with photoperiodand thermo-sensitivity, MAS will help minimize the requirements for multi-environment/location tests, which will reduce the breeding cost and shorten the breeding cycle. Using a rice DH population between ‘Zhaiyeqing 8’ and ‘Jingxi 17’, DTH and photo-thermo sensitivity (PTS) were investigated in two environments (Beijing and Hangzhou, China) that differ mainly in daylength and temperature (Xu et al. 1997c, Xu 2002). Four chromosomal regions were significantly associated with DTH in either or both locations, whereas a different locus on chromosome 7 (G397A-RM248) was significantly associated with PTS, indicating that the PTS QTL was independent of the QTL for DTH. By evaluating days-to-flowering (DTF) of individual ‘CO39’/ ‘Moroberekan’ RILs under 10 h and 14 h daylengths and greenhouse conditions, Maheswaran et al. (2000) identified 15 QTL for DTF. Only four of them were also identified as influencing response to photoperiod. Different QTL have been identified using direct and relative trait values, and in rice, DTH and photoperiod are often controlled by different QTL. On the other hand, direct and relative traits could share some QTL. That means DTH and photoperiod sensitivity are genetically related to some extent because both traits are related to the basic vegetative growth that rice plants must achieve to flower. There are QTL mapping studies undertaken in NIEs, but QTL were mapped using trait values scored in each environment rather than using relative measures. The traits themselves were mapped rather than the relative response
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
109
measured under the NIEs. In rice, numerous QTL for days to heading or flowering have been mapped using molecular markers but very few of them have been tested under both long- and short-day conditions. Using an F2 between japonica ‘Nipponbare’ and indica ‘Kasalath’, Yano et al. (1997) identified two major and three minor QTL for heading date. Three of them (Hd1, Hd2, and Hd3) were identified later as photoperiod sensitivity genes by test of the QTL-NILs under different daylengths (Lin et al. 2000), and one of them (Hd1) was cloned (Yano et al. 2000). In hybrid breeding, it is very important to understand what genes are involved in each parent for flowering and how they are working together in their hybrids. To synchronize flowering time of both parents for seed production, both parents should have the genes (of the same type) related to heading date and photoperiod and temperature sensitivity. Otherwise, two parents have to be planted separately to make them flower about the same time. Using MAS, days to flowering for the hybrid could be predicted from the parental genotypes and specifically designed from different combinations of parental genes. B. Environment-induced Genic Male Sterility Male sterility can be induced by specific environmental factors. An EGMS was first discovered in rice by Shi (1981) from ‘Nongken 58’, a japonica cultivar. The mutant ‘Nongken 58S’ is sterile when the days are long (>13.5 h) but becomes fertile when days are short (<13.5 h). Thus, fertility conversion is triggered by the length of photoperiod. This EGMS is called PGMS. Investigations on some derivatives from ‘Nongken 58S’ and other EGMS lines indicated that male sterility was affected by both photoperiod and temperature, and some EGMS lines were influenced more by temperature (and thus can be called TGMS), which reverted to partial or full fertility under certain temperature regimes (Zhou et al. 1988; Yang et al. 1989; Wu et al. 1991; Virmani and Voc 1991; Lu et al. 1994). Based on the EGMS system, Yuan (1987) proposed a strategy of hybrid rice breeding that did not involve a maintainer line and hence was called the two-line method. So far, more than ten EGMS lines have been used in China to breed two-line hybrid rice (Chen 2001; Lu et al. 2001; Lu et al. 2002), and over 20 two-line hybrids have been released to farmers; the area of two-line hybrid rice increased to 2.67 million ha in 2001 (Ma and Yuan 2002). EGMS has also been reported in pepper, tomato, wheat, barley, sesame, pea, rape, and soybean (Li and Yuan 2000). Compared with the CMS-based three-line method, the two-line method has several advantages. First, the EGMS parent can be used to produce hybrids with any rice cultivar, which removes the restriction of restorer
110
Y. XU
genes. Second, it is easier to introduce wide compatibility gene(s) into EGMS lines than into CMS lines, which makes intersubspecific hybrid breeding more feasible. Third, negative effects inherited from the male sterile cytoplasm can be overcome. However, the dependency of male sterility on temperature or photoperiod-temperature interaction requires two different environments in the breeding and selection process. Breeding populations have to be planted in one environment where the plants will be sterile to make sure of the presence of sterility genes and in another where the plants will be fertile to confirm the fertility conversion and produce seeds. Using associated molecular markers, confirmation of fertility conversion involving two environments can be avoided. So far three genes, pms1, pms2, and pms3, conferring PGMS in ‘Nongken 58S’ and its derivative ‘32001S’, were associated with RFLP markers on chromosomes 3, 7, and 12, respectively (Table 3.2). Although most associated markers are RFLPs, it is easy to convert them into PCR-based markers. Molecular markers on five chromosomes (2, 6, 7, 8, and 9) were associated with TGMS, most of which were microsatellite markers. A gene for reverse TGMS, which is fertile under high temperature but sterile under low temperature (contrary to the original TGMS), was associated with molecular markers on chromosome 10 (Table 3.2). These studies have laid a foundation for MAS in breeding EGMS lines. To facilitate incorporation of the tms2 gene, a SSR marker, RM11, located on chromosome 7, was identified and found to be useful in identifying heterozygous fertile plants in F2 populations and F3–F4 progenies for selection of progenies in advance (Lu et al. 2002). Lang et al. (1999) reported that PCR-based markers were 85% accurate in identifying tms3 in the juvenile stage. C. Biotic and Abiotic Stresses Breeding of insect and disease resistance and tolerance to abiotic stresses has become a worldwide issue. To identify insect/disease resistance, plants must be inoculated artificially or naturally, or in specific environments where the stress exists. Artificial inoculation is impractical when the insects/diseases are under quarantine control. On the other hand, evaluation of plant response to different insects/diseases or different biotypes/strains/races of the same stress agents is very difficult if not impossible using traditional screening methods. Using molecular markers associated with the stress response will help select for resistance without inoculation or creating or finding specific environments. Plant response to multiple biotic stresses can be screened simultaneously using molecular markers associated with these stresses. In traditional breeding programs, selection for tolerance to abiotic stress such as salinity, drought
Table 3.2. Marker-trait associations identified in rice for photoperiod-sensitive genic male sterility (PGMS), thermo-sensitive genic male sterility (TGMS), and reverse TGMS (RTGMS).
Trait PGMS
TGMS
RTGMS
Gene
Source
pms1
32001S
pms2 pms3
32001S Nongken 58S
tms1 tms2 tms3 tms5 tms-vnl
5460S Lorin PL12 IR32364S Annong S-1 SA2 TGMS-VN1
rtms1
J207S
Chromosome 7 3 12 8 7 6 2 9 2 10
Linked markers
Distance (cM)
Reference
RG477, RG511/RZ272 RG477/R277, R1807 RG191, RG348 RZ261/C751, R2708 RZ261, M36
3.5, 15.0 0.1, 6 7.0, 10.6 5.5, 9.0 1.6, 1.6
Zhang et al. 1994b Liu et al. 2001 Zhang et al. 1994b Mei et al. 1999 X. Li et al. 2001
RZ562, RG978 (R643A, R1440) OPAC3-640, OPAA7-550 RM174, R394 RM257/EAA/MCAG E5/M12-600, E3M16-4003
1.7 7.7, 10.0 0, 2.5 6.2, 5.3 3.3, 28.8
Wang et al. 1995 Yamaguchi et al. 1997 Subudhi et al. 1997 Jia et al. 2000 Reddy et al. 2000 Dong et al. 2000
RM222, RG257
11.8, 4.6
Jia et al. 2001
111
112
Y. XU
and submergence tolerance, and lodging resistance can only be done at specific environments that are either present at specific locations or created at well-controlled environments. Selection for these traits is considered most difficult in breeding programs. To measure responses to agrochemicals, such as herbicides and plant growth regulators, such chemicals must be applied to plants at the right stage under suitable environments. MAS has made it possible to perform indirect selection for all these traits using tightly linked or intragenic markers. There are several successful examples using MAS for biotic stress in rice. Hittalmani et al. (2000) used MAS to combine three rice blast resistance genes (Pi1 on chromosome 11, Piz-5 on chromosome 5, and Pi-ta on chromosome 12) into a single genotype. For Piz-5, a single marker was used, whereas flanking markers were used for the other two. MAS was efficient in developing gene pyramids and the line containing all three resistance genes had a broader resistance spectrum than lines with only one of them. Huang et al. (1997) pyramided four bacterial blight resistance genes, Xa4, xa5, xa13, and Xa21, using PCR-based markers. Sanchez et al. (2000) transferred three bacterial blight resistance genes into susceptible rice lines possessing desirable agronomic characteristics. For efficient MAS, sequences from RFLP or genomic clones, linked to the resistance genes (xa5, xa13, and Xa21), were converted to STS markers. This work showed the effectiveness of using markers linked to recessive genes in a backcrossing program, particularly in the presence of a dominant resistant gene. In an F2 population, selection efficiency was as high as 95% for xa5 and 96% for xa13. Breeding for drought tolerance is becoming a top priority in many countries, as less and less water is available for agriculture. Current knowledge on physiology suggests that drought tolerance in rice depends on one or more of the following components: (1) the ability of roots to exploit deep soil water to provide for evapotranspirational demand, (2) the capacity for osmotic adjustment that allows plants to retain turgor and protect meristems from extreme desiccation, and (3) control over nonstomatal water loss from leaves (Nguyen et al. 1997). These components are generally applicable to other cereal crops. There is a large body of literature published in China indicating that hybrid rice has a strong root system characterized by more and longer roots, with better distribution in the soil as compared to its parents and inbred lines (Yuan and Chen 1988). In 1999, Zhang et al. (1999) summarized the QTL identified for drought-tolerance components in rice. More than 100 QTL had been identified for osmotic adjustment, dehydration tolerance, abscisic acid accumulation, stomatal behavior, root penetration index, root thickness, total root number, root length, total dry root weight, deep root dry weight, and root pulling force.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
113
In maize, grain yield under drought stress is negatively correlated with the anthesis-silking interval (ASI), the difference in days between pollen shedding and silk emergence. A short ASI means rapid silk extrusion because time to anthesis is little affected by drought. Five QTL that were stable over stressed environments were identified under several levels of drought. A backcross MAS scheme to improve the drought tolerance of an elite but drought-susceptible inbred line, CML 247, has been successfully completed, using PCR-based markers as a preselection tool (Ribaut et al. 1999). A second MAS experiment used molecular markers to select changes in the frequency of alleles at loci having a known association with drought tolerance as a result of recurrent selection in an open-pollinated population. Plant selection based on the presence/ absence of those alleles whose frequency changed could give increased drought tolerance in less time than recurrent selection. Ribaut et al. (1999) concluded that new breeding schemes involving optimal combinations of MAS and conventional selection to improve drought tolerance in maize hold considerable promise for the future. In rice, the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) has several drought-tolerance breeding programs using identified QTL and MAS. QTL affecting root parameters were identified using a rice DH population derived from the cross ‘IR64’/‘Azucena’. A marker-assisted backcross program was started to transfer the alleles of ‘Azucena’ (upland rice) at four QTL for deeper roots on chromosomes 1, 2, 7, and 9 from selected DH lines into ‘IR64’ (elite rice cultivar) (Shen et al. 2001). The backcross progeny were selected strictly on the basis of their genotype at the marker loci in the target regions up to the BC3F2, from which BC3F3 near-isogenic lines (NILs) were developed and compared to ‘IR64’ for the target root traits. Of the three tested NILs carrying target 1 (QTL on chromosome 1), one had significantly improved root traits over ‘IR64’. Three of the seven NILs carrying target 7 (QTL on chromosome 7) alone, as well as three of the eight NILs carrying both targets 1 and 7, showed significantly improved root mass. Four of the six NILs carrying target 9 (QTL on chromosome 9) had significantly improved maximum root length. The results indicate that MAS can be used to select the traits requiring specific environments for phenotyping.
VII. QUALITY TRAITS Many important traits in crops are phenotypically invisible or unscorable and must be measured in the laboratory using sophisticated equipment or facilities. Some analyses require a large amount of seeds so that they cannot be measured until late generations when a relatively
114
Y. XU
large amount of seed becomes available for each selection entry. Grain chemical properties such as starch and protein content, and physical properties such as milling quality, are important quality traits for most cereal crops that fall under this category. A. Seed Traits As a major storage organ of cereal seeds such as rice, endosperms provide humans with proteins, essential amino acids, and oils. An understanding of the inheritance of endosperm traits is critical for the improvement of seed quality. Genetic behavior in triploid endosperms is much different from that of the maternal plants that supply assimilates for grain growth and development. Thus, methods suited for genetic analysis of traits in maternal plants (diploids for most cereal crops) cannot directly be used for endosperm traits (Xu 1997). Any genetic analytical method for endosperm traits needs to combine a genetic method developed for diploid maternal plants with a triploid model proposed for conventional genetic analysis. The genetic system controlling endosperm traits may be much more complicated than that controlling traits of the plant per se. Because the plant provides seeds with a portion of their genetic material and almost all the nutrients required for growth and development, seed traits are genetically affected by both the seed nuclear genes and maternal nuclear genes. In addition, cytoplasmic genes may also affect some seed traits through their indirect effects on the biosynthetic processes of chloroplasts and mitochondria. To understand endosperm traits with biological accuracy, one should take into consideration maternal genetic effects and cytoplasmic effects along with the direct genetic effects of seeds. As seeds initiate a new generation that differs from their maternal plants, some seed traits should be considered as one generation advanced over their maternal plants. Genetic analysis of endosperm traits should be based on the DNA extracted from both maternal plants and endosperm tissues in order to understand the relative contribution of the different genetic factors to the variation of endosperm traits (Xu 1997). Currently all endosperm traits have been treated the same as other traits of the plant, with few reports (Tan et al. 1999) that considered the generation advancement issue. B. Hybrid Seed Traits Although F1 plants are uniform, seeds borne on them represent the F2 seed generation and are expected to segregate for some grain characteristics. Major determinants of grain quality in cereal crops are milling;
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
115
grain size, shape and appearance; and cooking and eating characteristics. Some grain tissues are of maternal origin and some result from fertilization and union of genetically diverse gametes. For example, the lemma and palea of the rice hull are maternal tissues. Seed size and shape are determined by the shape and size of hulls and the latter is determined by the genotype of F1 plants. As a result, all F2 seeds borne on F1 plants have nearly identical dimensions even though the parents could have very different seed sizes. Endosperm is triploid tissue resulting from the union of one male nucleus with two female nuclei. If the parents differ in endosperm traits, the F2 grains on F1 plants show clearcut segregation (Kumar and Khush 1986; Tan et al. 1999). Single seed analysis of a hybrid rice, ‘Shanyou 63’, indicated that the amylose content for seeds on a F1 plant could range from 8% to 32% when two parents had 15.8% and 27.2% amylose content, respectively. A similar situation was reported for barley. If the parents differ significantly in malting quality characters, the grain produced by barley hybrids will be heterogeneous and heterozygous for characters critical to the malting process (Ramage 1983). The cooking and eating quality of milled rice is related to starch properties such as amylose content, gelatinization temperature, and gel consistency. These three traits are highly correlated and the latter two are controlled by a locus located in the same chromosomal region as amylose content (Tan et al. 1999). When both parents are non-glutinous but differ widely in amylose content, the raw F2 grains are distinctly classifiable into different amylose categories. But, when cooked in bulk, the grains do not vary in cooking and eating characteristics (Khush et al. 1988). That might explain why the hybrid rice ‘Shangyou 63’, which contains 8% to 32% amylose contents among different grains, has been acceptable for many years in China. Although genetic heterozygosity of hybrids may not impair grain quality in terms of physical and chemical characteristics as long as one of the parents is not glutinous or poor in grain quality (Khush et al. 1988), amylose difference among grains may contribute to unstable milling quality and uneven endosperm traits such as chalk. For hybrid rice breeding programs in countries demanding high-quality standards, both parents should be equally good if hybrids are to meet the standard quality of inbred cultivars. To develop glutinous rice hybrids, both parents must have glutinous grains. To develop hybrid rice possessing premier grain quality like that of basmati, both parents must possess basmati quality (Virmani and Zaman 1998). The same situation may be true for other cereal hybrids. It is strongly suggested that to develop hybrid crops with grain quality as good as the best inbred lines/cultivars, both parents must have the best quality. Use of parental lines with equally good quality will help minimize this effect, but might
116
Y. XU
result in low heterosis because of less genetic diversity for grain traits between the parents. Genetic contribution to quality comes from both parents, but one of them could be more important than another in some specific situations. Endosperm properties might be affected more by female parents due to the maternal effect, or more by male parents due to the xenia effect (Xu and Shen 1988b). The composition and development of the kernels can be changed by the nature of pollen. This was first shown by Kiesselbach (1926) as the change of a sweet corn endosperm into a starchy endosperm after pollination of a sweet corn female by a flint endosperm male. Large xenia effects were observed for sorghum malt quality in the F1 but this was entirely lost in the F2 generation (Wenzel and Pretorius 2000). Curtis et al. (1956) observed that the germ is markedly influenced in weight, oil and protein content by both the seed parent and the pollen parent of corn, with a pronounced maternal effect. C. Selection of Quality Traits Many quality traits are genetically controlled by multigenic loci, or by multiple alleles at a locus because of the triploidy of the endosperm. As a result, the same phenotypes may come from different genetic factors or different alleles from the same locus. Phenotypic selection for the same trait values may not result in the same alleles or genes fixed in parents. MAS will help distinguish different genetic loci that contribute to the same quality traits to avoid the problem that the two parents used for hybrid production have different alleles or alleles from different loci. Almost all quality traits are only measurable at or after the reproductive stage and they are good candidates for MAS. MAS can be made at any stage and in any generation so that breeders do not need to maintain a large number of candidate plants generation after generation. Methods for non-destructive extraction of DNA from single dry seeds provide an opportunity for selection of seed traits so that selection can be processed before planting. Early-stage selection also provides more opportunities for selection of traits with relatively low heritability. MAS could be used for early-stage quality tests or DNA-based quality tests, whereas such tests would be delayed in a conventional breeding program because a relatively large amount of seeds is required. Malt quality traits of barley, which are influenced by many loci, are suitable candidates for MAS. The genetic make-up of modern malting barley cultivars has been achieved by carefully balancing these traits through lengthy breeding processes. In a MAS project conducted among the progeny from the same cross for which the QTL had been mapped,
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
117
Igartua et al. (2000) confirmed the presence of QTL on chromosome 7 affecting all traits. MAS was effective in selecting phenotypically superior lines and the magnitudes of the combined effects for these regions were close to the estimates calculated in the mapping experiment. The use of marker information in the selection did not eliminate the need to gather reliable phenotypic data but it should permit breeders to allocate resources to the evaluation of progeny that are more likely to carry favorable alleles. Rice amylose content, mainly controlled by the wx gene, is a good example of MAS. Ayres et al. (1997) determined the relationship between polymorphism at that locus and variation in amylose content. Eight wx microsatellite alleles were identified from 92 long-, medium-, and shortgrain U.S. rice cultivars. When used as predictors of amylose content, these eight alleles explained an average of 85.9% of the variation. The amplified products ranged from 103 bp to 127 bp in length and contained (CT)n repeats, where n ranged from 8 to 20. Average amylose content in cultivars with different alleles varied from 14.9% to 25.2%. Using more diverse rice germplasm accessions (n=243), Zeng et al. (2000) identified 15 alleles at the wx locus using microsatellite class and G-T polymorphism, resulting in a total of 16 alleles identified so far. Although the mircrosatellite marker was located in the intron of the waxy gene, a complete association between marker alleles and amylose contents still depends on fully understanding other genes involved in the starch synthesis.
VIII. GENE INTROGRESSION AND WHOLE GENOME SELECTION In previous sections, several types of special traits that are important to hybrid breeding and most suitable for MAS were discussed. Except for quality traits discussed in Section VII, there are many other traits that need laborious fieldwork or intensive laboratory work. Xu (2002) fully described all the trait categories most suitable for MAS, and Dekkers and Hospital (2002) also listed the opportunities for the use of molecular data. In this section, some general considerations for all trait categories will be discussed. A. Gene Introgression Emerging MAS technology should provide the vehicles for using markers to expedite the acquisition of important genes from exotic populations or from wild species. Gene introgression involves the introduction
118
Y. XU
of a target gene into a productive, recipient line or cultivar. Gene introgression can be used in both backcrossing and intercrossing programs. By using DNA markers to identify recombinants, introgressed chromosome segments might be “trimmed” to minimal size, reducing the extent to which the recurrent genotype is disrupted by undesirable alleles closely linked to the target trait (Tanksley and Rick 1980). It is critical in plant breeding that allelic substitution be precise so that only the target gene and the shortest possible segment of the linked chromosome are transferred from the donor parent to the recipient parent, the latter of which is usually a cultivar or inbred line with very good combining ability. To reduce false positives in MAS, markers must be tightly linked to the target trait, and flanking markers or multiple markers around the region could be used simultaneously. A three-marker system, with three markers located on a chromosome block of a few (<5 cM), will be desirable in this case (Zhang and Huang 1998). The marker in the middle, preferably intragenic or cosegregating with the gene, will be used to indicate the presence of the target gene in the selection process. The marker on each side will be used to indicate the absence of the chromosome segment from the donor parent (negative selection), that is, selection for recombination between the target gene locus and the marker locus. As more and more genes have been cloned, the marker in the middle could be developed from the cloned gene or gene sequence, as discussed in Section IIIA. This system will be very useful when the target gene is only available in a wild species and linkage drag is proven to be associated with the chromosome segment to be transgressed. In rice, a series of advanced backcrossing populations have been developed through collaborations between Cornell University and breeders around the world to identify and introgress trait-enhancing alleles from wild species into high-yielding elite cultivars. The first such study employed a cross between the wild rice relative Oryza rufipogon and the Chinese indica hybrid ‘V20’/‘Ce64’ (Xiao et al. 1998). Although the O. rufipogon accession was phenotypically inferior for all 12 traits studied, transgressive segregation was observed for all traits, and 51% of the QTL detected had beneficial alleles from O. rifupogon. By MAS and field selection, an excellent CMS restorer line (‘Q661’) carrying one of the QTL for yield components has been developed. Its hybrid, ‘J23A’/‘Q661’, outyielded the check hybrid by 35% in a replicated trial for the second rice crop in 2001 (Yuan 2002). A second QTL study used an advanced backcross population between the same O. rufipogon accession and the upland japonica rice cultivar ‘Caiapo’, and identified beneficial QTL alleles from O. rufipogon for 56% of the traitenhancing QTL detected (Moncada et al. 2001). A third study employed the O. rufipogon in a cross with the long-grain ‘Jefferson’, a U.S. tropi-
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
119
cal japonica cultivar, and the O. rufipogon allele was favorable for 53% of the yield and yield component QTL (Thomson et al. 2003). There are several ongoing projects to introgress these favorable alleles from the O. rufipogon accession into cultivated rice. Information from the mapping studies reported may not be used directly in designing MAS experiments in breeding programs because different genetic backgrounds and environments have been involved. Other than epistasis and G × E interaction, many important questions regarding genetic regions tagged by molecular markers remain unknown. For instance, the number of polymorphic genes and the number of functional alleles at each of these loci in the gene pool are generally unknown for most traits. Cross-population comparison of genetic mapping studies using biparental materials can only provide limited information. As a result, many questions remain to be answered before any MAS experiment for major gene/QTL transfer can be used: (1) information on genetic parameters of a locus such as location, effect, and linked markers; (2) number of loci and number of alleles at each locus and variation explained by each locus and by all loci; (3) background effect on genes and gene interaction; and (4) linkage drag and its genetic basis. A reasonable strategy for molecular breeding is to do simultaneous gene identification and introgression such as advanced backcross QTL analysis as suggested by Tanksley and Nelson (1996). A comprehensive backcrossing breeding program through international breeding activities has been initiated for integration of DNA markers with phenotypic selection (Li 2001), which focuses on improvement of inbred cultivars and the parental lines for hybrid rice. B. Whole Genome Selection MAS can also be practiced at the whole genome level. DNA markerbased whole genome selection or background selection can be used to accelerate recovery of a recurrent genotype in the backcrossing process for breeding parental lines. Compared to a backcross program that usually takes five to seven generations to recover most recurrent parental backgrounds, MAS may save two to four backcross generations in the transfer of a single target allele (Tanksley et al. 1989; Hospital et al. 1992; Fisch et al. 1999). Combined with selection for target traits, whole genome selection allows the breeder to simultaneously transfer multiple traits through backcrossing. When single chromosomes are distinguishable, partial genome selection or whole chromosome selection are alternatives to whole genome selection so that the other chromosomes remain unchanged. MAS could be focused on a chromosomal region/arm if it is separable from the rest
120
Y. XU
of the genome. Genes controlling the same traits or trait category may cluster in some specific chromosomal regions, which are called gene blocks. Regional mapping strategies (Xu 1997; Monna et al. 2002), combined with a high-density genetic map, can help construct high-density regional maps that target gene blocks for separation of closely linked genes. As genetic mapping information accumulates from different mapping populations, it will be possible to establish a complete profile for all the genes associated with a specific trait or trait category. Whole genome selection can be used to select the best trait/gene combinations based on selection for each of the target loci whose position in the genome is known. It is possible to select the best cassette for any traits and/or trait combinations. To transfer the bacterial blight resistance gene Xa21, 128 RFLP markers, evenly distributed on the 12 rice chromosomes, were used to recover the genetic background of ‘Minghui 63’, a widely used parent. Plants containing Xa21 in the BC3F1 generation were screened with markers covering the genome, and those homozygous for ‘Minghui 63’ alleles were saved. The improved version of ‘Minghui 63’ and its hybrid with ‘Zhenshan 97’ showed the same resistance spectrum as the resistant donor. Field examination of a number of agronomic traits showed that the improved ‘Minghui 63’ and its hybrid were identical to the originals except for their resistance to bacterial blight (Chen et al. 2000). MAS was also used by the same group to improve ‘6078’, an elite restorer line with high yield potential, by transferring Xa21 from IRBB21 (Chen et al. 2001). Background selection in this study took place in the BC1F1 and also in the BC2F1 population using AFLP markers with unknown positions. It is not clear exactly how much of the genetic background of the recurrent parent was recovered in the individual obtained in the final selection (because of unknown chromosomal distribution of the 129 polymorphic bands), but the agronomic performance and combining ability of the selected line was very similar to the original. C. Selection for Multiple Genes/Traits MAS provides opportunities for simultaneous selection of multiple traits/genes. In some cases, multiple pathogen races or insect biotypes must be used to identify plants for multiple resistances, but in practice this may be difficult or impossible because different genes may produce similar phenotypes that cannot be distinguished from each other. Marker-trait association can be used to simultaneously select multiple resistances from different disease races and/or insect biotypes, and pyramid them into a single line through MAS as discussed in Section VIC.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
121
To find a CMS restorer in rice through testcrossing and progeny test, a candidate male plant has to be testcrossed with a CMS line to find out if it has fertility restorability based on the fertility of testcross progeny. However, sterility in testcross progeny could result from the absence of either restorability genes or wide compatibility genes or both when an intersubspecific cross is involved. MAS could be used to distinguish the two different types of sterility. Consider phenotypic selection for multiple traits in rice, such as TGMS, amylose, and wide compatibility. Candidate plants must be tested in two different environments where TGMS can be identified. Each plant must be testcrossed with wide compatibility testers, following up with a progeny test in the next season. At the same time, a relatively large amount of seed must be harvested for amylose measurement. While conventional selection methods require a delay until a large number of seeds are available and a reasonable level of homozygosity is reached, in MAS only a leaf harvested at any growth stage in any segregating population is required. Hybrid rice provides an advantage over inbred cultivars because dominant genes and/or QTL with additive effects from both parents can be integrated into one hybrid. An integrated breeding program including MAS was initiated in China to improve an elite hybrid rice, ‘Shanyou 63’, a cross between ‘Zhenshan 97’ and ‘Minghui 63’. Xa21, a widespectrum bacterial blight resistance gene, was introduced into the restorer ‘Minghui 63’ by MAS and a Bt gene that is toxic to stem borer was introduced into ‘Minghui 63’ through transformation. An allele at the Wx locus from ‘Minghui 63’ was transferred by MAS to ‘Zhenshan 97’ to improve cooking and eating quality of the hybrid, resulting in a new version of ‘Zhenshan 97’ with medium amylose content, soft gel consistency, and high gelatinization temperature. The pyramiding of Bt, Xa21, and wx genes created an improved ‘Shanyou 63’ (He et al. 2002). D. Integrated Genetic Mapping and MAS MAS programs involve genetic mapping to identify genes of interest followed by transfer to another genetic background. This procedure was used to enhance ‘B73’ and ‘Mo17’ inbreds in maize (Stuber et al. 1999). The procedure per se is inefficient because it requires identification of the targeted segments (containing the putative genetic loci) prior to transfer to the recipient line. In many cases, genetic mapping results obtained from specific crosses cannot be used for MAS for the same traits in different crosses. There are three reasons for this phenomenon. First, quantitative traits are usually controlled by many genes. Genes are only segregating at the loci where two parents are genetically different and
122
Y. XU
thus can be mapped using the population derived from these two parents. For a randomly selected mapping population, the parents will have a strong chance to share identical alleles at some of the genetic loci. There is a high probability that segregating genes in any breeding population could be different from the genes already mapped. Second, multiple alleles at a locus work in the same way to complicate MAS, because mapping parents could have alleles that are different from those of breeding populations. Interaction among these multiple alleles will modify marker-trait associations when different allele combinations are considered. Third, G × E interaction could make the establishment of marker-trait association depend on specific environments. One of the best ways to avoid these limitations is to integrate genetic mapping with MAS, that is, marker-trait associations identified from a breeding population will be used for MAS of the same population. This is critical for quantitative traits that are genetically controlled by many genes and interact with environments. Advanced backcrossing QTL analysis, proposed by Tanksley and Nelson (1996) to accelerate the process of molecular breeding, is one of the approaches that can be used for this purpose. Stuber et al. (1999) discussed their effort to test a marker-based breeding scheme for systematically generating superior lines without any prior identification of genes in the donor sources. The identification of and mapping of genes in the donor is a bonus obtained when the derived NILs are evaluated. This method is somewhat similar to advanced backcross-QTL analysis. Other approaches include using associations identified in F2 populations to select the subsequent selfpollinated populations. E. Response to Selection MAS for traits controlled by major genes will receive a strong response. However, the response to selection for quantitative traits using associated molecular markers will depend on several factors: linkage between markers and genes, trait heritability, gene effects, gene interactions, population size, the number of plants selected, and the breeding scheme. In this section, response to MAS of QTL will be discussed. An example in Lande and Thompson (1990) demonstrated that on a single trait the potential selection efficiency by using a combination of molecular and phenotypic information, compared to standard methods of phenotypic selection, depends on the heritability of the trait, the proportion of additive genetic variance associated with marker loci, and the selection scheme. The relative efficiency of MAS is greatest for traits with low heritability if a large fraction of the additive genetic variance is associated with marker loci. Limitations that may affect the potential
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
123
utility of MAS in applied breeding programs include (1) the level of linkage disequilibrium in the populations, which affects the number of marker loci needed; (2) sample size needed to detect trait loci with low heritability; and (3) sample errors in the estimation of relative weights in the selection indices. In theory, MAS is proposed to be more efficient than phenotypic selection when the heritability of a trait is low, where there is tight linkage between QTL and DNA markers (Dudley 1993; Knapp 1998), with larger population sizes (Moreau et al. 1998), and in earlier generations of selection before recombinational erosion of marker-trait associations (Lee 1995). Edwards and Page (1994) proposed that the distance between markers and QTL was the factor that most limited gains from MAS. Yousef and Juvik (2001) reported an empirical experiment that provided equivocal results regarding the relative efficiency of MAS and phenotypic selection in enhancing economically important quantitative traits in sweet corn. MAS and phenotypic selection were applied to three F2:3 base populations with either the sugary 1 (su1), sugary enhancer 1 (se1), or shrunken 2 (sh2) endosperm mutations. One cycle of selection was applied to both single and multiple traits such as seedling emergence. Selection efficiencies were evaluated on the basis of gains over one cycle. Among 52 paired comparisons between MAS and phenotypic selection composite populations, MAS resulted in significantly higher gain than phenotypic selection for 38% of the comparisons, while phenotypic selection was significantly greater in only 4% of the cases. The average MAS and phenotypic selection gain, calculated as percent increase or decrease from the randomly selected controls, was 10.9% and 6.1%, respectively. Recognizing that small mapping populations are not adequate for QTL mapping is the first and most important realization needed in the research community (Young 1999). Scientists must understand that simply demonstrating that a complex trait can be dissected into QTL and mapped to approximate genomic regions using DNA markers is not enough. Projects need to utilize better scoring methods, larger population sizes, multiple replications and environments, appropriate quantitative genetic analysis, various genetic backgrounds, and, whenever possible, independent verification through advanced generations or parallel populations. Only then will sufficient experimental evidence be in place for a successful MAS program. “What if we knew all the genes for a quantitative trait in hybrid crops?” This was asked by Bernardo (2001), who has been working on the prediction of hybrid performance through computer simulation. With maize as a model species, he found through trait and gene best linear unbiased prediction (TG-BLUP) that gene information is most useful in selection
124
Y. XU
when few loci (e.g., 10) control the trait. With many loci (50), the least square estimates of gene effects become imprecise. Gene information consequently improves selection efficiency among hybrids by only 10% or less, and actually becomes detrimental to selection, as more loci become known. Bernardo further indicated that increasing the population size and trait heritability to improve the estimates of gene effects also improves phenotypic selection, leaving little room for improvement of selection efficiency via gene information. He thought genomics is of limited value in selection for quantitative traits in hybrid crops. Epistatic interactions, which were assumed absent in his study, would make the estimation of gene effects even more difficult. It is unknown whether methods other than TG-BLUP or multiple regression would substantially enhance the usefulness of gene information in selection. Response to phenotypic selection can be evaluated using molecular markers. The Illinois long-term selection experiment on maize oil and protein contents (Dudley and Lambert 1992; Dudley 2004) and markerassisted evaluation (Goldman et al. 1993) is an example of markerassisted evaluation of the response to selection. This selection experiment was initiated in 1896, and by 1989 had experienced 90 generations of selection, increasing oil content from 4.7% in the original population to 19.3% in the Illinois High Oil (IHO) strains. In contrast, 87 generations of selection for low oil concentration reduced oil content from 4.7% to <1% in the Illinois Low Oil (ILO) strains. Mean protein concentration for 76 generations were 25% for the Illinois High Protein (IHP) strains and 4% for the Illinois Low Protein (ILP) strains (Dudley and Lambert 1992). This long-term divergent selection response can be attributed to the accumulative action of alleles with similar effect that had been dispersed among the individuals of the original population (Xu 1997), although de novo mutations may be an alternative explanation for this divergence, as indicated by selection for bristle number in Drosophila (Mackay 1995). The selection strains offer a unique opportunity to investigate the genetic basis of kernel chemical traits, and have been used to produce maize populations to map the QTL responsible for the selection response (Goldman et al. 1993). By using 90 genomic and cDNA clones distributed throughout the maize genome to detect RFLPs between IHP and ILP strains, 22 loci distributed on 10 chromosome arms were significantly associated with protein concentration, and clusters of three or more significant loci were detected on chromosome arms 3L, 5C, and 7L, suggesting the presence of QTL with large effects at these locations. A multiple linear regression model consisting of six significant loci on different chromosomes explained over 64% of the total variation (Goldman et al. 1993). These significant QTL associations can be used to account for the long-term selection response and the protein
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
125
content difference between the IHP and ILP strains. It can be expected that the longer the selection proceeds, the bigger the difference of protein content will be in the resulting selection strains, and thus the potential to detect additional QTL, as long as the populations continue to respond to selection. This expectation can be tested by QTL mapping using the crosses from the IHP and ILP strains derived from different cycles of selection. We would expect genetic fixation with long-term selection programs. However, selection experiments discussed above for maize for high and low protein or oil and in Drosophila for bristle numbers (Yoo 1980) show no indication of genetic fixation from long-term selection resulting in remarkable changes in phenotype. Frequent identification of large-effect QTL, as reviewed by Tanksley (1993), Kearsey and Farquhar (1998), and Xu (2002), makes steady and sustained selection response puzzling: Alleles of large effects should be fixed rapidly, after which no further response would be seen. Barton and Keightley (2002) named two factors that might explain this apparent paradox. First, QTL-mapping experiments underestimate the number of QTL and overestimate their effects. Second, mutation generates alleles of large effect, which can be picked up quickly enough by selection to sustain a continuing selection response. Several mechanisms have been described that can create de novo variation, including intragenic recombination, unequal crossing over among repeated elements, transposon activity, DNA methylation, and paramutation (R. L. Phillips, pers. commun.). Barton and Keightley (2002) listed several factors that make it difficult to estimate the true numbers and effects of loci influencing a quantitative trait. Hyne and Kearsey (1995) pointed out that in a typical experiment (heritability ~40%, ~300 F2 individuals), no more than ~12 QTL are ever likely to be detected, which is supported by empirical data on the numbers of QTL detected in plants (Tanksley 1993; Kearsey and Farquhar 1998; Xu 2002). Beavis (1994) indicated that unless samples are large (>500, for example), the effects of statistically significant QTL are substantially overestimated. IX. PREDICTION OF HYBRID PERFORMANCE AND HETEROSIS A. Combining Ability and Heterosis There are two types of combining ability, general and specific. General combining ability (GCA) is defined as an attribute of an inbred line and is measured as the average performance of all hybrids made with that inbred line as a parent. The higher the GCA of an inbred, the higher the average performance of its hybrids. Specific combining ability (SCA) is
126
Y. XU
defined for specific combinations of parents and is measured by the deviation of the hybrid performance from the expected performance as estimated from the GCA of the parents. As a result, hybrid performance is determined by its parents’ GCA and the cross’s SCA. The widely grown rice hybrid in China, ‘Shanyou 63’, is an example of this. The female parent (CMS line), ‘Zhenshan 97’, and the male parent, ‘Minghui 63’, have been used to produce many successful hybrids with various fertility restorers and CMS lines. Heterosis is an important cause of the increasingly high yields of rice, maize, grain sorghum, and oil sunflower, although it is not the only cause. Improvements in GCA, in additive genes as well as in dominant, overdominant, or epistatic gene combinations, have been crucial to the improvement of hybrids in all four crops. Heterosis will continue to be a very important cause of hybrid superiority in yield and yield stability. SCA—specific combinations of inbred lines with good GCA—will remain the essential requirement for production of superior new hybrids (Duvick 1999). The use of marker-aided prediction of advanced generation combining ability on the basis of data from early generation testcrossing was evaluated by Johnson and Mumm (1996). Using a total marker score generated from regressing F3 line testcross yield on the corresponding F3 line RFLP genotypes, F5 testcross yields were predicted with more accuracy than they would have been with F3 testcross yields alone as predictors. It was concluded that marker-assisted prediction of advanced generation performance from early generation testcrosses was effective. These results were in agreement with those reported by Eathington et al. (1997). B. Genetic Basis of Heterosis Heterosis is a complex physiological phenomenon affected by many factors. Yield is the most important trait in crop-based heterosis analysis. In many investigations, genes for yield per se and genes for yieldrelated heterosis have been confounded with each other. Several different hypotheses have been proposed for the explanation of heterosis but none of them is widely accepted so far. Among these hypotheses, arguments have focused on the dominance hypothesis (Davenport 1908) and the overdominance hypothesis (East 1908; Shull 1908), both of which are based on describing the genetic effects of single loci. Recent studies, as will be discussed later, have indicated that epistasis plays an important role in genetic control of both quantitative traits and heterosis. The dominance hypothesis proposes that heterosis results from the cancellation of effects from deleterious recessive alleles, contributed by one parent, by dominant alleles contributed by the other parent in the heterozygous F1. This hypothesis emphasizes the contribution of the
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
127
dominance to heterosis. The overdominance hypothesis assumes that a specific heterozygous combination of alleles at a single locus is superior to either of the homozygous combinations of the parental alleles at that locus. Two alleles with different effects are presumed to interact physiologically such that heterozygotes show superiority in viability and adaptability compared to either of the homozygotes, and the degree of superiority increases with the degree of allelic heterozygosity. Supporters of the overdominance hypothesis offer two main objections to the dominance hypothesis. First, it should be possible to accumulate, by selection, all the favorable dominant alleles into one homozygous strain and obtain inbreds that are as vigorous as hybrids. Second, F2 distributions should be skewed because of the 3⁄4 dominants to 1⁄4 recessive segregation (Lamkey and Edwards 1999). But in 1916, Jones noted that with linkage the two hypotheses became indistinguishable and Collins pointed out in 1921 that with a large population size the F2 distribution is essentially symmetrical. From the results of Gardner (1963) and Moll et al. (1963), the clear conclusion was that statistical overdominance in the early generations was a consequence of linkage disequilibrium, that is, favorable dominants linked to deleterious recessives. For selfpollinated species, the genetic basis for heterosis may be different because of purging of deleterious recessive alleles by long-time inbreeding (Crow 1999). As a complex trait, heterosis is likely to be conditioned by numerous genetic factors functioning and responding to a wide variety of interacting situations, and epistasis must also play an important role in the genetic control of heterosis. Crow (1999, 2000) provided a historical review on the dominance and overdominance hypotheses. 1. Evidences from Genetic Mapping Using Molecular Markers. Xiao et al. (1995) investigated the genetic basis of heterosis in rice by backcrossing an indica/japonica RIL population to its two parental cultivars. For 12 agronomic traits, a total of 27 QTL could be detected in either backcross population. At about 82% of these QTL, heterozygotes had higher phenotypic values than their corresponding homozygotes. Ten QTL influencing grain yield components detected in both backcross populations were completely or partially dominant. RILs having phenotypic values superior to the F1 hybrid between the parental lines were found for all traits evaluated. They concluded that dominance complementation is the major genetic basis of heterosis in rice. This conclusion was strengthened by the finding that there was no correlation between most traits and overall genome heterozygosity and that there were some RILs in the F8 population having phenotypic values superior to the F1 for all of the traits evaluated—a result not expected if overdominance were a major contributor to heterosis. Digenic interaction was not evident in this study.
128
Y. XU
Stuber et al. (1992) analyzed the genetic mechanism of heterosis in a maize single-cross hybrid, ‘Mo17’ × ‘B37’, using RFLP markers. They found that most yield-QTL heterozygotes had higher phenotypic values than either homozygote class and they concluded that overdominance was the major genetic basis of heterosis in maize. This overdominance hypothesis was also supported by the results from wheat (Sun et al. 1997), Arabidopsis (Mitchell-Olds 1995), and juvenile aspen (Li and Wu 1996). However, maize researchers were careful to point out that estimates of dominance variance exceeding that for straight dominance could be due to either overdominance or linkage disequilibrium of linkage loci with favorable alleles in repulsion phase (pseudo-overdominance). Subsequently, fine mapping experiments demonstrated that the two major QTL in maize that had been identified with overdominance effects by Stuber et al. (1992) acted in a dominant manner with alleles in repulsion phase linkage by fine mapping (Graham et al. 1997). Thus, the effects at these two QTL strongly support the dominance theory of heterosis in this chromosomal region of maize. Epistasis represents non-allelic interaction, including additive-byadditive interaction, additive-by-dominance interaction, and dominanceby-dominance interaction. Because almost all heterotic traits are genetically controlled by the combined effect of many QTL, epistasis is expected to play an important role in the genetic control of these complex traits, as it does for many other quantitative traits. The first evidence for epistasis in rice is provided by Yu et al. (1997). They located QTL for yield and its components using F3 families derived from a rice hybrid, ‘Shanyou 63’. A total of 32 QTL were detected for four traits; 12 were observed in both years and the remaining 20 were detected in only one year. Overdominance was observed for most of the yield QTL and also for a few yield-component QTL. Correlations between marker heterozygosity and trait expression were low, indicating that the overall heterozygosity made little contribution to heterosis (yield). Digenic interactions, including additive-by-additive, additive-by-dominance, and dominance-by-dominance, were frequent and widespread in this population. The interactions involved large numbers of marker loci, most of which individually were not detectable on a single-locus basis; many interactions among loci were detected in both years. The authors concluded that epistasis plays a major role as the genetic basis of heterosis. The three reports discussed above for dominance, overdominance, and epistasis hypotheses were all based on the use of yield and yield components per se to measure hybrid performance without use of parental lines as a control to derive values for the midparent or betterparent heterosis. The method of measurement will identify genes for yield and yield components rather than genes for heterosis. For open-
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
129
pollinated species like maize, which has severe inbreeding depression, it is very difficult (if not impossible) to do side-by-side comparisons of the F1 hybrids with their parents. But, theoretically, this comparison is absolutely necessary if heterosis rather hybrid performance needs to be measured. Several recent investigations have been reported for genetic analysis of heterosis per se in rice. Zhang et al. (2001) designed a mating scheme that generated a fixed or “immortalized” F2 population, using a population of 240 RILs derived from the ‘Zhenshan 97’/‘Minghui 63’ cross. In this design, crosses were made between the RILs chosen by random permutations of the 240 RILs. In each round of permutation, the 240 RILs were randomly divided into two groups and lines in the two groups were paired at random without replacement to provide parents for 120 crosses. The procedure can be repeated as many times as desired and each round of permutation will pair parents for 120 crosses. This population provides opportunities for genetic mapping of heterosis per se rather than analyses based on measurements of trait performance, as long as the hybrids and the parents for each cross are planted side by side in the field, allowing measurement of heterosis for each cross. Three rounds of such random permutations, including 360 crosses, resulted in two conclusions (Zhang and Li 2002). First, all kinds of genetic effects, including single-locus heterotic effects caused mostly by overdominance, and all three forms of digenic interactions (additive by additive, additive by dominance, and dominance by dominance) appeared to play a role in the genetic basis of heterosis in the “immortalized F2” population. However, the QTL were not fine mapped, leaving open the possibility that, as in maize, the single-locus effects were due to pseudooverdominance, rather than true overdominance. Second, single-locus heterotic effects and dominance-by-dominance interaction could, together, adequately account for the genetic basis of heterosis in the F1 hybrid. Z.-K. Li et al. (2001) investigated the genetic basis of heterosis in rice using 254 RILs derived from a cross between ‘Lemont’ (japonica) and ‘Teqing’ (indica) and two BC and two testcross populations derived from crosses between the RILs and their parents plus two testers (‘Zhong 413’ and ‘IR64’). For both grain yield per plant and biomass per plant, there were significant negative effects associated with homozygous loci detected in the RIL population and a high level of heterosis in each of the BC and testcross hybrid populations. Epistasis was found for a large number of QTL pairs and a few QTL with significant main-effects were identified. Together, these QTL were responsible for over 65% of the phenotypic variation of biomass and grain yield in each of the populations, with epistatic effects explaining a much greater portion of the
130
Y. XU
variation than the main effects. As a result, most QTL associated with decreased grain yield and biomass, or with heterosis in rice appeared to be involved in epistasis, and about 90% of the QTL contributing to heterosis appeared to be overdominant. These results and the results from the genetic analysis of yield components (Luo et al. 2001) indicate that epistasis and overdominance, rather than dominance, were the major genetic basis of heterosis in rice. 2. Conclusions. As a complex character involving yield and yield components, heterosis should be genetically controlled by many genes. Although genetic study of quantitative traits has identified a limited number of QTL, each explaining a relatively large proportion of genetic variation, much more QTL could be found when multiple populations are considered. For example, a total of 63 QTL for plant height have been identified from 13 rice mapping populations and these QTL distributed on 29 chromosomal regions (Xu 2002). For a specific hybrid, heterosis is more likely genetically controlled by a relatively small number of genes; for explanation of heterosis involved in all hybrids derived from a species, a large number of QTL will be needed. Heterozygosity and its related gene interactions are the primary genetic basis for explanation of heterosis because the hybrid is heterozygous across all genetic loci that differ between the parents. Thus, the degree of heterosis depends on which loci are heterozygous and how withinlocus alleles and inter-locus alleles interact with each other. Interaction of within-locus alleles results in dominance, partial dominance, or overdominance, with a theoretical range of dominance degree from zero (no dominance) to larger than 1 (overdominance). Interaction of inter-locus alleles results in epistasis. Genetic mapping results have indicated that most QTL involved in heterosis and other quantitative traits had a dominance effect. As statistical methods that can estimate epistasis more efficiently become available, epistasis has been found more frequently and proven to be a common phenomenon in the genetic control of quantitative traits including heterosis. With so many genetic loci involved, it is unlikely that there is no interaction at all between any pair of them. When a trait is controlled by multiple QTL, their alleles of positive or negative effects (increasing or decreasing trait value) tend to be dispersed among cultivars that are used as parents for developing mapping populations (Xu and Shen 1992). Considering all genetic loci controlling a specific trait, a specific genotype (cultivar) usually has alleles of increasing effect at some loci but alleles of decreasing effect at the others, which is called allele dispersion or repulsion-phase linkage if the related loci link to each other. Identification of numerous QTL from
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
131
crosses derived from two parents with the same phenotype strongly support the hypothesis of allele dispersion. Accumulation of alleles with similar effects from allele-dispersed cultivars will result in transgressive segregation, which has been proven in two rice crosses where transgressive segregation for tiller angle has been fixed in the inbred lines selected for extreme phenotypes (large tiller angle). When similar alleles dispersed in four rice cultivars were accumulated, the fixed transgressive selections showed tiller angle three times larger than that of the original parents (Xu et al. 1998). The accumulation of dispersed alleles should add to the list of the factors that can be used to explain the response of long-term selection for oil and protein contents in maize (Dudley 2004; Walsh 2004). Allele dispersion or repulsive linkage can result in pseudo-overdominance when two such loci closely linked to each other and they are not separable by linked markers. As an example, the overdominance identified in the maize cross Mo17 × B37 by Stuber et al. (1992) has been proven to be pseudo-overdominant later (Graham et al. 1997). As reported by Z.-K. Li et al. (2001), most (~90%) QTL contributing to heterosis in rice appeared to be overdominant. It is very unlikely that each of these overdominant QTL is due to pseudooverdominance from the repulsive linkage of two completely or partially dominant QTL, although the genetic map used for heterosis mapping was less saturated. It can be concluded that two different types of allele interaction, both within-locus and inter-locus, each should play an important role in the genetic control of heterosis. Contribution of a specific locus to heterosis could be due to any single type of these interactions. When multiple loci are involved that were not taken into account in the early 1900s, various combinations of within-locus and inter-locus interactions (especially dominance-by-dominance interaction) could contribute to the genetic control of heterosis. For a specific cross and specific trait, heterosis might be explainable by any single type of these interactions. For different crosses, species, or traits, however, their heterosis has to be explained by the dominance of different degrees in combination with all possible inter-locus interactions, as indicated by Goldman (1999). Currently available information on heterosis has been provided by individual studies using specific crosses, most of which were designed for hybrid performance rather than heterosis per se. As a result, none of the mechanisms discussed above contributing to heterosis can be completely excluded. A full understanding of heterosis will depend on cloning and functional analysis of all genes that are related to heterosis. This process would be very similar to that for understanding disease resistance genes that functionally appear much simpler than heterosis.
132
Y. XU
C. Construction of Heterotic Groups 1. Germplasm Classification. Understanding the genetic structure and diversity in the gene pools with which breeders work is critical for the choice of parents, construction of heterotic groups and, thus, for the development of hybrids. Germplasm accessions can be classified based on morphological traits, geographic distribution, evolutionary and breeding history, pedigree, and/or genotypic diversity at molecular marker loci. Geographic distribution and breeding process are straightforward criteria for germplasm classification. Rice is an example. Cultivated rice, O. sativa, originated in South and Southeast Asia between 10,000 and 15,000 years ago (Chang 1984) and was dispersed throughout the world by human migration and international trade. It is believed that at least two independent domestication events gave rise to the two major subspecies of O. sativa, namely the long-grained, tropical “indica” rice, and the short-grained, temperate “japonica” rice (Oka 1988). In addition, a third group of cultivars is recognized as “tropical japonica” or “javanica” rice, characterized by bold grains, adaptation to dry, or upland, growing conditions in the tropics (Chang 1976). Rice culture was successfully introduced into the United States around 1685, when a tropical japonica cultivar, ‘Carolina Gold’, was carried to Charleston Harbor on a ship that came from Madagascar (Wilson 1979). Tropical japonica rice became the mainstay of rice production along the Atlantic Coast for 200 years and later spread to the tidal wetlands and prairie land along the Gulf Coast (Wilson 1979). The short-grained, temperate japonica types grown in California are derived largely from introductions from Japan, Korea, and China (Wilson 1979; Rutger and Bollich 1991). Germplasm accessions can also be classified based on phenotypic and/or genotypic similarity. There are several genetic distance (GD) or similarity indices that have been used as criteria for classification. A similarity index can be constructed using various types of original data. Both categorical and quantitative data have been used for phenotype-based classification. However, genotype-based classification or clustering is usually based on binary (categorical) data by scoring the presence and absence of molecular marker alleles. This scoring method has two shortcomings. First, the score does not generally reflect differences in allele sizes. For example, a difference of 2 bp and a difference of 200 bp at a SSR locus are reflected simply as a polymorphism, losing all size-related information. Second, the binary scoring method expands the data size by as many times as the number of alleles. When a clustering program has a limitation on the size of the dataset, the data has to be cut to fit the program. A better scoring method retains information about allele sizes, and similarity is then calculated for each pair of samples based on allele
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
133
sizes per se or shared allele frequency. Allele sizes can be easily converted into allele presence-absence, whereas the latter is not convertible. In rice, a genetic similarity index was computed based on SAFs (S) between each pair of rice accessions, and then 1-S was used as the GD to construct the dendrograms depicting genetic relationships among these rice accessions (Y. Xu and S. R. McCouch, Cornell University, unpubl. data). Different types of molecular markers are suited for different levels of classification. RFLP marker-based analysis of the whole collection of 236 rice cultivars identified two major groups corresponding to indica and japonica, respectively, whereas most of the U.S. cultivars belonged to a different group. SSR markers that can distinguish closely related accessions were then used to subgroup the U.S. cultivar collection. Two subgroups were identified, representing two different types of grain shapes, long grain and medium- and short-grain, with average grain lengths 9.7 mm and 8.4 mm, respectively. The major longgrain cultivars released in Texas tended to cluster in the long-grain subgroup while the medium- and short-grain cultivars released in California formed a cluster in the short/medium subgroup. Within each subgroup, some cultivars were closely clustered. They were either closer in pedigree or more similar in morphology. Many rice accessions released in Texas clustered on the top of the long-grain subgroup. There is very limited heterosis in the hybrids derived from cultivars within this subgroup. Southern U.S. cultivars are mostly derived from tropical japonica germplasm that traces its ancestry to Indonesia. This ancestral source, coupled with selection during breeding, makes the U.S. cultivars distinct from other indica or japonica cultivars, though they share many genes from these groups. For example, these U.S. cultivars may have long grains as typical of indica rice, although many have intermediate or short grains. Also akin to the tropical japonica germplasm native to Indonesia, many of these cultivars were found compatible with both typical indica and typical japonica without much hybridization barrier (Xu et al. 1989; Gu and Tang 2001). The intermediate-type cultivars and the cultivars with wide-compatibility genes, as discussed in Section VC, have been frequently used to overcome the indica-japonica crossing barrier, resulting in the diffusion of genes and disappearance of reproductive isolation between the two subspecies. These wide-compatible cultivars belong to the third major group or subspecies of rice cultivars. Representation of this group will greatly affect germplasm classification and heterosis studies. Using male sterility in hybrid seed production provides the opportunity to produce large amounts of seed. Simultaneously, it raises concern that cytoplasm uniformity of CMS lines could result in genetic vulnerability, as happened in maize in 1970 because of the extensive use of
134
Y. XU
T-CMS. In rice, sorghum, and rye, only one or few CMS sources for each crop have been widely used for hybrid breeding. Genetic characterization and classification of alternative CMS sources will help establish diverse CMS pools and avoid CMS uniformity. To facilitate this, marker profiles could be used to classify genotypes. Molecular marker alleles specific to cultivar groups could be identified and then used to classify other germplasm accessions such as those containing different sources of CMS. Marker information could be exploited better for germplasm classification if it were integrated with phenotypic information, including information about CMS. 2. Concept of Heterotic Groups. The concept of heterotic groups or heterotic pools was first developed in maize based on the observation that inbreds selected out of certain populations tended to produce better performing hybrids when crossed to inbreds from other groups (Hallauer et al. 1988). This recognition resulted from the systematic crossing of thousands of inbred lines from different source populations and evaluation of the hybrids (Havey 1998). In the review of capturing heterosis in forage crop cultivar development, Brummer (1999) indicated that the key to successful semihybrid production is to keep heterotic groups separate, only intercrossing them for testing and release. Merging of heterotic groups into a larger breeding population results in the loss of interacting linkats (alleles), limiting potential yield advance. Breeding highly heterotic hybrids largely depends on selection of desirable parents as a prerequisite for most hybrid breeding programs, and thus depends on genetic diversity in the germplasm resources available to plant breeders. For example, commercial maize hybrids are typically made between inbreds from opposite, complementary heterotic groups. Therefore, construction or development of heterotic groups has been one of the key components in hybrid breeding for many crops. Introgressing exotic germplasm is often suggested as an approach to increase genetic differences between opposing heterotic populations, thereby potentially increasing heterotic response. An understanding of heterotic relationship between populations is needed to exploit exotic germplasm intelligently. Melchinger and Gumber (1998) reviewed the development of heterotic groups in five major crops with different pollination systems: allogamous—maize and rye, partially allogamous—faba bean and oilseed rape, and autogamous—rice. In this section, discussion will be devoted to construction of heterotic groups based on both conventional methods and molecular marker information. A possible explanation for heterotic groups is that populations of divergent genetic backgrounds have unique allelic diversity that may have arisen from founder effects, genetic drift, or the accumulation of
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
135
unique allelic diversity by mutation or selection. Significantly greater heterosis could result from this genetic diversity by specific interallelic interactions (overdominance), repulsion-phase linkage among loci showing dominance (pseudo-overdominance) (Havey 1998), and/or inter-locus interaction (epistasis). Apparently, the most obvious potential heterotic groups are either geographically separated populations or separate subspecies and ecotypes. Melchinger and Gumber (1998) recommended the following criteria for the identification of heterotic groups and patterns in descending order of importance: (1) high mean performance and large genetic variance in the hybrid population to ascertain future selection response; (2) high per se performance and good adaptation of both or at least one of the parental heterotic groups; (3) low inbreeding suppression in the source materials for the development of inbreds; and (4) a stable CMS system without deleterious side effects, as well as effective restorers and maintainers, if hybrid breeding is based on CMS. 3. Construction of Heterotic Groups Based on Hybrid Performance. With large numbers of inbred or open-pollinated lines or populations available, it is unfeasible in most crops to make diallel crosses and produce sufficient F1 seed for multi-environment field-testing. Therefore, Melchinger and Gumber (1998) suggested a multi-stage procedure to identify heterotic groups, which consists of the following steps: (1) grouping the germplasm based on genetic similarity; (2) selection of representative genotypes (e.g., two or four lines or one population) from each subgroup for producing diallel crosses; (3) evaluation of diallel crosses among the subgroups together with parents in replicated field trials; and (4) selection of the most promising cross combinations as potential heterotic patterns using the identification criteria. If established heterotic patterns are available, using selected elite genotypes from them as testers for the production and evaluation of the germplasm to be classified is recommended. Based on the testcross performance, populations or lines having similar combining ability and heterotic response could be merged to constitute a new independent heterotic group, if they behave differently from the existing heterotic groups; however, if their behavior is similar to an existing heterotic group, they could be merged with it to enlarge its genetic base. Heterotic patterns in many crop species have been established solely based on the large numbers of testcrosses and breeding experience, without the use of DNA-based markers. Ron Parra and Hallauer (1997) reviewed heterotic patterns used in the major maize production regions of the world. Some patterns have had importance in specific production regions. Others have been exploited on several continents, for example, the heterotic patterns based on ‘Reid Yellow Dent’ (RYD) and ‘Lancaster Sure Crop’ (LSC) from the
136
Y. XU
temperate United States, and ‘Tuxpeño’ and Estación Tulio Ospina’ from tropical Mexico and South America. Two heterotic groups from which inbreds commonly are selected and used to produce superior maize hybrids are Iowa (B) Stiff Stalk Synthetic (BSSS) and derivatives of LSC (Darrah and Zuber 1986; Gerdes and Tracy 1993). Although both populations are primarily comprised of southern dent germplasm, LSC has more northern flint germplasm than BSSS (Smith 1986; Gerdes and Tracy 1993). With genetically balanced sets of crosses, inter-group hybrids outyielded the respective intra-group hybrids by 21% in RYD × LSC crosses (Dudley et al. 1991) and by 16% in Flint × Dent crosses (Dhillon et al. 1993). In both studies, the percentage of increase in heterosis for yield of inter-group over intra-group crosses was about twice as large as for the hybrid yield itself. Intrapopulation maize hybrids have been developed and commercialized in tropical maize. Some of the earlier hybrids were intrapopulation hybrids. The first hybrid (‘Suwan 2301’), developed by Kasetsart University in Thailand, was an intrapopulation interline hybrid derived from ‘Suwan-1’. Data suggested that interpopulation interline hybrids are generally superior (Han et al. 1991). Even when the populations are not heterotic, the interpopulation interline hybrids give superior performance. However, populations such as ‘AED’ × ‘Tuxpeno’ (P44), ‘Tuxpen’ (P21), and ‘La Posta’ (P43) have produced outstanding intrapopulation interline hybrids. It is possible to produce good hybrids from the same population provided it has high per se performance and high general combining ability (Vasal et al. 1999). The systematic search for suitable heterotic patterns by Hepting (1978) laid the foundation for hybrid breeding in rye. Based on the hybrid performance and heterotic derivation in a complete diallel among seven open-pollinated populations, he found that cross combinations involving populations from the two most widely used germplasm groups, Petkus and Carsten, were most promising for grain yield. In fact, all rye hybrids released in Germany since 1985 are based on the Pampa CMS system and are of the Petkus × Carsten type. In oilseed rape, Grant and Beversdorf (1985) evaluated diallel crosses among six OPCs of European and Canadian spring rapeseed and suggested European spring × Canadian spring rapeseed as a promising heterotic pattern. Similarly, Lefrot-Buson et al. (1987) found crosses between winter rapeseed of European × Asian origin to be most productive. The results of diallel crosses among seven spring rapeseed cultivars of European, Canadian, and Asian origin confirmed that crosses between European × Asian and Canadian × Asian spring rapeseed exhibited higher heterosis than crosses between parents originating from the same region (Brandle and McVetty 1990).
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
137
Four distinct heterotic groups within sunflower are now being utilized by breeders throughout the world (Vear and Miller 1993). OPCs developed in Russia are used in deriving female maintainer inbred lines. The U.S. restorer group, derived by crossing wild annual species of sunflower with cultivated lines, is a distinct source of disease resistance and fertility restorer genes. Romanian female lines, along with their South African derivatives, are used throughout the industry. Also used are the Argentinean INTA OPCs for developing female lines (Miller 1999). Rice might be the only crop where hybrids are widely grown but very few studies on heterotic groupings have been reported. Heterosis in rice has been utilized largely through CMS. Fortunately, rice breeders in China identified the restorers for CMS from geographically distant rice cultivars from southeastern Asia and used them in hybrid rice breeding. This resulted in high levels of heterosis among intra subspecies (indica × indica) hybrids. A large-scale screening of diverse CMS maintainers and restorers provided some clue as to heterotic pattern. Three ecotypes from different subspecies, indica, japonica, and javanica, have different morphological and physiological characteristics and ecogeographical distribution and, therefore, serve as a basis for defining distinct heterotic groups. As summarized by Yuan (1992a), heterosis for grain yield in crosses among the three rice ecotypes has the following trend: indica × japonica > indica × javanica > javanica × japonica > indica × indica > japonica × japonica. This mirrors the current situation of heterotic pools in rice. It is well known to hybrid rice breeders that a high level of heterosis results from crosses between CMS lines bred in China and restorer lines derived from southeast Asian indica cultivars, which is the heterotic pattern for indica × indica hybrids. Wheat breeders lag much behind their colleagues in other crops in establishing heterotic pools (Jordaan et al. 1999). Heterotic groups have not been well described in vegetables either. 4. Construction of Heterotic Groups Using Molecular Marker Information. DNA-based markers may be used to classify parental lines into different heterotic groups, each with a high level of similarity in genetic backgrounds. This reveals genetic diversity at the whole genome level, and helps identify effects of selection, genetic drift, and mutation. Molecular markers have been playing an increasingly important role in the construction of heterotic groups since the 1990s. Most reports are focused on maize, wheat, barley, and canola. Because marker-based groupings reflect the genetic differences among parental lines, they can contribute to parental improvement and to effective selection for heterotic hybrids. In general, heterotic groups constructed on the basis of
138
Y. XU
marker information match up very well with pedigrees, but have the advantage that missing historical information, such as the incomplete pedigree information or ambiguous pedigree, will not affect the markerbased method. Using RFLP markers, Meng et al. (1996) grouped 46 cultivars of Brassica napus, originating from China, into six groups, and a very significant difference was found between the cultivars from China and a group of six cultivars from B. napus L. var. oleifera subvar. biennis originating from Europe. They suggested that the latter could be used to broaden the genetic diversity of breeding populations of oilseed rape. In maize, different types of molecular markers have been successfully used to differentiate heterotic groups with results that are consistent with pedigree-based grouping (Mumm and Dudley 1994; X. Liu et al. 1997; Peng et al. 1998; Wu et al. 2000). Based on heterosis and combining ability analyses using cultivars from different heterotic groups, Peng et al. (1998) proposed seven heterotic patterns for the utilization of maize heterosis. Divergence at molecular marker loci has been useful in assigning maize inbreds to known heterotic groups previously established in breeding programs and the molecular information agreed with pedigree information (Lee et al. 1989; Melchinger et al. 1991; Messmer et al. 1993). In rice, Zhang et al. (1992) analyzed 12 indica and 14 japonica cultivars using RFLP markers. The average GD measured by RFLPs between indica lines was three to four times higher than that between japonica, which confirmed the results based on the morphological studies. Using 160 RFLP markers and 21 wide-compatibility cultivars and three indica and three japonica cultivars, Zheng et al. (1994) constructed a dendrogram tree and discussed the potential of wide compatibility in hybrid breeding using indica/japonica crosses. Based on diallel crosses among eight indica lines representing the parents of the best-performing commercial rice hybrids grown in China, Zhang et al. (1995) studied molecular divergence and hybrid performance. Their results suggest the existence of two heterotic groups within indica, one comprised of rice strains from southern China and the other comprised of strains from Southeast Asia. Using two types of molecular markers, RFLPs and AFLPs, Mackill et al. (1996) obtained similar grouping results. Using RAPD and SSR markers, Xiao et al. (1996a) separated the ten parental lines into two major groups that correspond to indica and japonica subspecies. These researches indicated that molecular markers are useful tools in detection of genetic diversity between parental cultivars. The results from barley (Melchinger et al. 1994) and wheat (Sun et al. 1996; Ni et al. 1997) also supported the conclusion that DNA markers are very useful tools for construction of heterotic groups.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
139
5. Future Directions. Heterotic groups are the backbone of successful hybrid breeding. Decisions regarding the definition and utilization of heterotic groups are of fundamental importance and must be made at the beginning of a crop improvement program. In most cases, breeding for heterosis without knowledge of heterotic patterns has proven to be a hitor-miss approach (Jordaan et al. 1999). It is evident from the review of various studies that adapted populations, isolated either by time and/or space, are the most suitable candidates for promising heterotic patterns. Genetic diversity can be related to geographic origin of parental lines. The geographical variation can be related to ecological and environmental variations that, in turn, dictate survival fitness, created by spontaneous and induced genetic variation in natural and directed-selection situations. Consequently, the parental lines derived from different geographic origins are considered to have more genetic diversity than those derived from the same geographic origin. International breeding efforts through various collaborative breeding programs in rice, wheat, and maize have been very successful in breeding both hybrid and non-hybrid cultivars. However, internationalization of plant breeding efforts and massive exchange of unimproved and improved germplasm throughout the world have altered the genetic structure and adaptation of germplasm accessions with which breeders have been working. As a consequence, differences in geographic origin of the parental lines may not always reflect genetic diversity among them. On the other hand, extensive hybridization practiced in several international and national crop breeding programs has created new forms of genetic diversity, and one can expect to find substantial genetic diversity among parents from the same geographical origin (Virmani 1996). The negative effect of using distant crosses is the confusion of heterotic groups existing among cultivars of different geographic origins. For example, breeding wide-compatible inbred cultivars as a bridge for harnessing indica/japonica heterosis in rice has reduced heterosis compared to what would be expected from crosses between typical indica and japonica cultivars. Therefore, it is important to keep in mind that we are not disturbing the current heterotic groups, which have been established either naturally or creatively, when we use distant crosses in hybrid breeding programs. Heterotic groups should not be considered as closed populations, but should be broadened continuously by introgressing unique germplasm to warrant medium- and long-term gains from selection. Heterotic groups consisting of poorly utilized and unadapted germplasm should be enhanced through joint public-private breeding ventures. Different phenotypes may or may not reflect divergent genetic backgrounds.
140
Y. XU
Phenotypically different populations may possess the same genetic background, and divergent phenotypes may be conditioned by allelic differences at relatively few loci (Havey 1998). MAS can be useful in creating, maintaining, and improving heterotic groups. As discussed above, marker-based grouping of germplasm and breeding populations will help establish heterotic groups that hold maximum genetic diversity between groups but minimum diversity within groups. Identification of marker alleles that are specific to each heterotic group will help keep them genotypically separated. MAS can be used to improve the existing heterotic groups through introgressing target genes from one heterotic group or outsource germplasm to another with minimum linkage drag from the donor. As we discussed previously, MAS will help breeders realize their goals without linkage drag and unwanted genetic background. D. Hybrid Prediction 1. Reasons for Hybrid Prediction. Hybrid breeding includes two major procedures: breeding parental lines and selection for the best hybrids from the cross combinations of those parental lines. These procedures involve a large amount of work for field evaluation, testcrossing, and progeny tests. Breeders continually have to decide which experimental single crosses to test, which advanced hybrids to recommend for further testing or commercialization, and which inbred parents to cross to form new base populations for inbred/population development (Bernardo 1999). Suppose a breeder has 100 inbreds from heterotic group 1 and 100 inbreds from heterotic group 2. There are 10,000 possible (group 1 × group 2) single crosses. For developing new hybrids, there are 495,000 possible (group 1 F2 ) × (group 2 tester) combinations, and 495,000 possible (group 1 tester) × (group 2 F2) combinations, if testcrossing starts from the F2. Due to limited resources, breeders are unable to test all combinations in all environments of interest but may test a limited set of single crosses and F2 × tester combinations. Typically, <1% of the maize single crosses tested by a breeder eventually become commercial hybrids (Hallauer 1990). Therefore, predicting hybrid performance has always been a primary objective in all hybrid-breeding programs. Methods for predicting the performance of single crosses would greatly enhance the efficiency of hybrid breeding programs. Development of a reliable method for predicting hybrid performance and/or heterosis without generating and testing hundreds or thousands of single cross combinations has been the goal of numerous studies using marker data and combinations of marker and phenotypic data, particularly in maize and rice. It is reasonably believed that heterosis originates, in some way, from the genetic differences or heterozygosity between the parents. Theoret-
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
141
ically, hybrid performance is equal to the average parental performance plus heterosis. In the past several decades, hybrid prediction has been largely based on the evaluation of genetic diversity among parental lines. It has been expected that understanding the relationship between heterozygosity/parental difference and heterosis would help predict hybrids. The development of molecular marker techniques has provided new tools for hybrid prediction and DNA markers have been used extensively in investigating correlations between parental GD and hybrid performance. 2. Statistical Methods for Hybrid Prediction. The best linear unbiased prediction (BLUP) procedure has been used for decades for evaluating the genetic merit of animals, especially dairy cattle. Intrapopulation, additive genetic models have traditionally been used for BLUP in animal breeding (Henderson 1975). During the last several years, Bernardo has attempted to use BLUP in maize breeding with interpopulation genetic models that involve both GCA and SCA (Bernardo 1994, 1996). Results have indicated that BLUP is useful for routine prediction of single-cross performance. The predicted performance of single crosses may subsequently be used to predict the performance of F2 × tester combinations, three-way crosses, or double crosses. Along with the pedigree relationship, the BLUP method can use trait data, or both trait and marker data, for prediction. 3. Genome-wide Heterozygosity and Hybrid Prediction. In most cases, isozyme-based GD estimates are positively associated with hybrid performance for grain yield (for a review, see Stuber 1994); however, it remained unclear whether the low correlations between both measures observed in most cases were due to poor coverage of the genome or whether other causes were involved. The availability of a large number of DNA-based markers provided the opportunity for genome-wide surveys of heterozygosity and laid the foundation for a better understanding of the relationship between heterozygosity at marker loci and heterosis. The relationship between parental genetic divergence and hybrid performance was first studied in maize. Variability for molecular markers generally agreed with pedigree information and assignment (based on hybrid performance) to known heterotic groups (Smith et al. 1990; Dudley et al. 1991; Melchinger et al. 1991); however, variability at molecular marker loci was ineffective in predicting specific hybrid performance from crosses among maize inbreds (Lee et al. 1989; Melchinger et al. 1992). Some reports indicated high correlation between hybrid performance/heterosis and parental GDs or the degree of heterozygosity (Smith et al. 1990; Lee
142
Y. XU
et al. 1989; Stuber et al. 1992), while others revealed very weak correlations (Godshalk et al. 1990; Dudley et al. 1991). Considering all these and other studies in maize, the correlation depends largely on the plant materials and their origins and suggests that specific loci are involved in heterosis rather than heterozygosity per se. Correlations between single-cross performance and molecular marker diversity for unrelated parental inbreds have been too low to be of any predictive value (Godshalk et al. 1990; Melchinger et al. 1990; Dudley et al. 1991). Molecular-based GD estimates also failed to predict superior hybrid performance in oat (Moser and Lee 1994), soybean (Gizlice et al. 1993), and chickpea (Sant et al. 1999). 4. Hybrids Are More Predictable Within than Between Heterotic Groups. Let us first consider intra-heterotic crosses. Correlations between heterozygosity/GD and hybrid performance/heterosis varied for hybrids between lines that belong to the same heterotic group (within-group hybrids). In maize, correlations of GD with F1 performance and heterosis were significant and positive for all traits of within-group hybrids, flint × flint crosses (Boppenmaier et al. 1993). This was supported by Benchimol et al. (2000) using 18 tropical maize inbred lines where correlations of parental GDs with single crosses and their heterosis for grain yield were higher for line crosses from the same heterotic groups. The same conclusion was reported by Zhao et al. (1999) using diallel crosses derived from 11 elite rice lines where the correlations of marker heterozygosity with hybrid performance and heterosis were high in crosses within subspecies. In other cases, however, weak or no correlation was found for within-group hybrids. Examples include weak or no significant associations of GD with F1 performance and mid-parent heterosis in soybean (Cerna et al. 1997), wheat (Martin et al. 1995), and U.S. longgrain rice cultivars (Saghai Maroof et al. 1997). These results may be due to the low levels of heterosis in these varietal groups. Weak or no correlation was found for hybrids between lines that belong to different heterotic groups (between-group hybrids). In maize, correlations of GD with F1 performance and heterosis were not significant for the subsets of flint × dent and dent × dent crosses (Boppenmaier et al. 1993). Using 18 tropical maize inbred lines, Benchimol et al. (2000) found that correlations of parental GDs with single crosses and their heterosis for grain yield were low for line combinations from different heterotic groups. In rice, Xiao et al. (1996a) reported that yield potential and its heterosis showed significantly positive correlations with GD for indica × indica or japonica × japonica crosses, but the correlations were not significant for indica × japonica crosses. This was confirmed by Zhao et al. (1999) that very little correlation was detected in intersubspecific crosses using diallel crosses derived from 11 elite rice cultivars.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
143
A theoretical study conducted by Charcosset and Essioux (1994) supported the reports discussed above. The correlation between heterozygosity at marker loci and heterosis was investigated for (1) hybrids between lines that belong to the same heterotic group (within-group hybrids); (2) hybrids between lines that belong to different groups (between-group hybrids); and (3) all hybrids, both within- and betweengroups. Within a group, significant correlations may be detected because of linkage disequilibrium generated by drift. At the between-group level, no correlation is expected since linkage disequilibium should differ randomly from one group to another, which is consistent with the results of recent experiments. When all hybrids are considered simultaneously, divergence of allelic frequencies among groups for the markers and the QTL produces a correlation between heterosis and heterozygosity at marker loci. This correlation increases with the number of markers that are considered. Based on results from various studies in maize, Melchinger (1993) summarized the relationship between parental GD and mid-parent heterosis (MPH) in a schematic representation. For crosses among related lines, there exists a tight association between GD and MPH for yield characters because both measures are a linear function of coancestry, f, and, thus, decrease with increasing f. For intra-group crosses, the correlation r (GD,MPH) is generally positive, too. This can be explained by hidden relatedness between some parents considered to be unrelated based on their pedigree, and the presence of the same linkage phase between QTL and marker loci in the maternal and paternal gametic arrays of intra-group hybrids, which results in a positive covariance between GD and MPH (Charcosset et al. 1991). In contrast, no significant association between both measures exists for inter-group hybrids. In this case, the maternal and paternal gametic arrays may differ in the linkage phase for many QTL-marker pairs; as a consequence, positive and negative terms cancel each other in their net contribution to covariance (GD,MPH), resulting in a low or zero correlation (Charcosset and Essioux 1994). High estimates of r (GD,MPH) could be expected if correlations are calculated across different types of crosses due to group effects. This is because both GD and MPH are expected to increase from crosses among related lines to intra-group crosses and further to inter-group crosses (Melchinger 1999). 5. Heterosis-associated Markers and Hybrid Prediction. It has been common practice in most studies to determine GD or heterozygosity estimates from a set of DNA markers chosen for good coverage of the entire genome but not for linkage to genes influencing heterosis of the target trait. Theoretical investigations (Charcosset et al. 1991) and computer
144
Y. XU
modeling (Bernardo 1992) demonstrated that with intra- and inter-group crosses the correlation between GD and MPH is expected to decrease if genes influencing heterosis are not closely linked to markers used for calculation of genetic estimates and vice versa if markers employed for calculation of GDs are not linked to genes controlling the trait. Hence, increasing the marker density alone will not necessarily improve the ability to predict MPH by GD estimates; rather, markers must additionally be selected for tight linkage to genes affecting heterosis of the target trait in the germplasm under study. This is corroborated by comparison of results obtained with 209 AFLPs vs. 135 RFLPs (Ajmone Marsan et al. 1998) and a study by Dudley et al. (1991). Using these associative loci will help establish strong correlations between heterozygosity and heterosis. However, allelic differences at marker loci do not assure allelic differences at linked loci for heterosis. For a limited number of markers to be useful as predictors for hybrid performance, the effects of alleles at the loci linked to specific marker alleles must be ascertained (Stuber et al. 1999). Zhang et al. (1994a) proposed two statistical parameters: general and specific heterozygosity, to measure genotypic heterozygosity. The former is the heterozygosity calculated from the GDs between the parents using all possible markers, and the latter is that from using marker loci that are significantly associated with the traits of interest revealed by single factorial analysis of variance. The results from rice indicated that there was a weak correlation between general heterozygosity and heterosis but a significant correlation between specific heterozygosity and heterosis for yield and biomass. As a result, heterosis could be predictive to some extent (Zhang et al. 1994a, 1995). Joshi et al. (2001) studied the correlations between GD, hybrid performance, and heterosis in rice using the markers associated with grain yield and other traits reported by Xiao et al. (1996b) and McCouch et al. (1997) and 21 F1 hybrids derived from two CMS lines and 14 restorer lines. There was no significant correlation for grain yield. Two factors contributed to this result: loose marker-trait associations and different genetic systems for controlling heterosis and grain yield in the materials used by different researchers. As a result, markers identified for grain yield from one population cannot be used to predict heterosis for another. Successful heterosis prediction based on molecular markers will depend on how many genes have been identified from different genetic backgrounds and how these genes interact with each other to control heterosis. The complexity of these interactions explains why there are no successful examples of heterosis prediction. Attempts to identify QTL-marker associations by use of multiple regression techniques, in which observed phenotypic values for a fixed
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
145
set of hybrids are regressed on their coded marker genotypes, must be regarded with great caution, because the number of variables from which the regressors are selected is usually as large or even greater than the number of phenotypic observations. Moreover, comparison of QTL mapping results from different populations in maize (Stuber 1995; Lübberstedt et al. 1998) and rice (Xu 2002) suggested that QTL regions affecting a given trait are not necessarily consistent across different germplasm accessions. 6. Favorable Allele Combination and Hybrid Prediction. Although the importance of genetic diversity to heterosis has been known for several decades, heterogenic gene combinations may not always lead to heterosis and heterosis is ultimately dependent upon the balance between favorable and unfavorable interactions of genes. It is reasonably inferred that heterosis could be caused by specific gene combinations derived from the two parents. Those genes may simultaneously produce different genetic effects in different genetic backgrounds. So, for parental improvement and hybrid prediction, investigating the specific gene combinations that contribute to heterosis should be more important than studying any single gene or QTL. Using 99 half-diallel rice hybrids derived from nine CMS lines and 11 restorer lines, Liu and Wu (1998) found that four favorable alleles and six favorable heterotic patterns on the parental lines significantly contributed to the heterosis of their hybrids for grain yield, whereas six unfavorable alleles and six unfavorable heterotic patterns significantly reduced heterosis. They suggested that optimal hybrids with superior grain yield could be developed by assembling those favorable alleles into, and removing the unfavorable alleles from, their parental lines. 7. Conclusions. There are several conclusions that can be drawn from the numerous investigations on the relationships between heterozygosity and GD with hybrid performance and heterosis. First, the higher the heterozygosity between the parents, the stronger the heterosis. Second, using more markers alone will not improve the prediction. Third, prediction is possible using markers known to be associated with hybrid performance or heterosis if the association is used to predict performance of a hybrid derived from the same heterotic pattern. Fourth, genetic variation (the presence of heterosis) is a prerequisite for prediction. Fifth, the relationship of heterozygosity with heterosis and with hybrid performance will be different if the two involve different genes. The last conclusion was supported by results of Zhu et al. (2001) that heterosis was highly significant but hybrid performance was not when 57 rice accessions from six ecotypes and their hybrids were genotyped
146
Y. XU
by 48 SSR and 50 RFLP markers. In conclusion, heterozygosity at general marker loci can be used to construct heterotic groups. It is anticipated that prediction could be possible if heterozygosity is derived from specific marker loci that are associated with heterosis and hybrid performance and all possible associated loci have been identified and their effects and interactions clearly defined. Considering the fact that only heterotic crosses are of commercial importance and of interest to the breeder, the practical value of the genetic distance approach for prediction of heterosis and hybrid performance is limited (Vuylsteke et al. 2000). This is true for some crop species like maize. For rice, however, the reproductive barrier between the two subspecies, indica and japonica, has enforced a limitation on the utilization of indica/japonica heterosis, although the use of the widecompatibility gene(s) has had a great impact on the limitation. Hybrid breeding for indica rice has been based on crosses within the indica group. The strong relationship between the heterozygosity at marker loci and heterosis within the indica group as reported before (Xiao et al. 1996a) indicates that GD estimates based on molecular markers could be very useful in assigning indica cultivars into different subgroups for hybrid indica rice development. Screening for heterosis-related molecular markers as suggested by Melchinger et al. (1990), using specific heterozygosity proposed by Zhang et al. (1994a), and identifying favorable combinations of allele and heterotic patterns (Liu and Wu 1998) are among the approaches that could be exploited further to improve the prediction of hybrid performance/heterosis using molecular markers. Understanding genetic variation among cultivars to be tested and identifying markers associated with heterosis and heterosis-related traits are two important components in hybrid prediction. We should keep in mind that markerheterosis associations identified in one cross may not be suitable for selection in others because heterosis could be controlled by many genes and each cross has different genes and gene combinations in action. Despite their low values, the inbred-hybrid yield correlations were positive. They indicated a tendency for high-yielding inbreds to produce high-yielding hybrids. Hybrid breeding is always accompanied by the improvement of parental lines. Modern maize inbreds, grown at today’s high density, can yield nearly as much as hybrids of the 1930s (Duvick 1984; Meghi et al. 1984). Duvick (1999) has suggested that if as much effort had been put into improvement of OPCs as has been devoted to hybrid improvement over the years, the gap between the best hybrids and the best OPCs might be less than what it currently is. Some authors even argue that OPCs might be superior to hybrids (Lewontin and Berlan 1990), but their assumption is not backed up by data. No experiments
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
147
have been reported that test the theory that OPCs could be improved at the same rate as hybrids (or at a higher rate), if equal effort were expended on each kind of breeding (Duvick 1999). This assumption, if true, would greatly support the dominance theory of heterosis. In conclusion, the potential application of DNA markers in hybrid breeding depends very much upon whether divergent heterotic groups have been established or not and upon crop species. If well-established heterotic groups are unavailable, marker-based GD estimates can be used to avoid producing and testing crosses between closely related lines. Furthermore, crosses with inferior MPH could be discarded prior to field-testing based on prediction. Another potential application exists. If new lines of unknown heterotic pattern or inbreds developed from crosses between parents from different heterotic groups (e.g., commercial hybrids) are to be evaluated for testcross performance, GD estimates could assist the breeder in the choice of appropriate testers for evaluating the combining ability of the lines. However, with regard to the typical situation of hybrid breeding, in which crosses are produced between lines from genetically divergent heterotic groups, GD estimates based on an unselected set of DNA markers alone are not promising for predicting hybrid performance or any of its components.
X. SEED QUALITY ASSURANCE Production of high-quality hybrid seed is crucial to the success of a heterosis-breeding program. Two major factors influencing seed quality are purity and viability. Hybrid seed do not show large differences from non-hybrids in viability despite heterosis for some traits such as germinating ability or disadvantages such as short seed life for hybrid rice because of the partially enclosed hull. In this section, only seed purity will be discussed. Two major factors contribute to the purity of hybrid seed: off-types and false hybrids. Off-types includes non-hybrid seed resulting from non-parental plants in parental multiplication and hybrid seed production, and false hybrids includes non-hybrid seed resulting from the selfing of the female parent due to instability of male sterility if a male sterile line is involved in seed production. A. Off-type Off-type in hybrid seed and grain production is a potential quality problem. Traditionally, off-types are defined as individual plants that are phenotypically different from the plants developed by breeders. They may result from mechanical mixtures, outcrossing, mutation, or residual
148
Y. XU
genetic variation. Off-types may be found in a parental line or only visible in the hybrid. The presence of off-type plants will reduce the uniformity of the crop and thus reduce its productivity and quality. Phenotypic off-types can be easily rogued if there are not too many. Besides the offtypes that are visible phenotypically, many off-types are genetically different from the typical plants and they are hard to distinguish visually. Genotypic off-types may impose more severe effect on hybrids, which could be one of the major reasons for reduced performance of hybrid cultivars or inbred lines. They also impose an effect on the parent, which could be exaggerated by multiplication of the parents themselves and their progeny. Molecular marker technology provides a powerful way for distinguishing both the phenotypic and genotypic off-types from hybrid plants and their parents. Marker-trait associations and high-resolution molecular markers such as SSRs could be used to distinguish two plants with very similar genetic backgrounds. With ten or more SSR markers, rice breeders can identify distinct off-types from their breeding populations and hybrid seed bulks and obtain detailed genotypic information such as where the off-type genotypes come from and what the proportion of the off-types is to the typical plants. A selection and purification decision can be made to refine their breeding materials and hybrids. B. False Hybrids False hybrids come from the selfing of the female parent because a male sterile line becomes fertile due to instability of male sterility. This has happened to two-line hybrid rice when the EGMS female parent becomes fertile during seed production. As discussed previously, a TGMS line can serve as a sterile line under one environmental condition and can propagate itself under another. The ability to maintain sterility makes TGMS lines practicable as a female to cross with any other commercial rice cultivars. However, most TGMS lines require a specific temperature to maintain their sterility. Abnormal weather can bring the temperature down below the critical temperature that is required for conversion of TGMS lines from sterility to fertility (or simply called fertility conversion), which makes TGMS lines fertile or partially fertile in locations where they are sterile in normal years. This results in self- or sib-seed contamination, a potential problem for seed production of two-line hybrid rice. The mixture of real hybrids with selfed seeds from the EGMS line cannot be used in rice production, resulting in a great loss to seed producers or rice growers. As a way of insuring the seed production, marking the seeds from EGMS lines using genetic markers can help identify and remove the false hybrids from the mixture.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
149
1. Approaches to Eliminating False Hybrids. To eliminate pseudo hybrids from seed production, three strategies can be used: (1) breeding herbicide mutants and use of the herbicides to kill false hybrids, (2) use of morphological markers (such as purple leaf mutants) to distinguish the false hybrids and remove them by hand, and (3) use of mutants with faded green leaves to get rid of false hybrids. Morphological and chemical markers have been investigated as a way to identify specific seeds/plants from a mixture. In rice, several morphological markers, such as purple leaves (Mou et al. 1995) and pale green leaves (Dong et al. 1995), have been used for marking EGMS lines. These markers can be used to distinguish real F1 hybrids from selfed seeds (false hybrids) at the seedling stage. However, removing the purple false hybrid seedlings must be done by hand, which is laborintensive and there is no assurance that all false hybrids will be completely eliminated. Faded green mutants with chlorophyll deficiency during the seedling stage cannot compete with normal plants and will die in the densely planted seedling nursery but will grow well in a less dense planting. Selective responses of plants to herbicides can be used to identify a specific type of plant from a mixture and the response can be exploited as a “marker.” There are two different types of herbicides that can be used as selective chemicals to remove false hybrids in rice and other crops: herbicides that can selectively kill a crop and ones that are safe to the crop. Prerequisites for use of herbicide mutants in hybrid seed production include availability of herbicides (registered chemicals), low cost of herbicides, response to low concentration of herbicides, long sensitivity duration, minimal effect of environmental factors/weather, and easy identification of the herbicide response. 2. Herbicide Mutants in Rice. In rice, there are several herbicide mutants reported, including IMI mutants such as IMI-Cypress, resistant to imidiazone; Bar (phosphinothrin acetyltransferase), resistant to Basta (Liberty); EPSP synthase, resistant to Roundup; and Norin 8 mutant, recessively sensitive to bentazon at the flowering stage. Zhang et al. (1998) transferred the bar gene into a rice restorer line to make it resistant to the herbicide Basta, which can be used to selectively kill false hybrids. When a herbicide is safe to use with normal rice cultivars, recessive sensitivity to the herbicide can be used to selectively kill the seedlings from the selfed seeds of the female once it possesses the sensitivity. The herbicide-sensitive rice mutant obtained by Mori (1984) through radiation was lethal to bentazon, which was controlled by a recessive gene.
150
Y. XU
To prevent seed production from selfing contamination, Zhang et al. (2002) developed a system to secure seed purity using a herbicide sensitive TGMS mutant, M8077S, obtained by radiation. Genetic analysis using the F1, F2, F3 populations derived from this mutant and other normal cultivars revealed that bentazon lethality/sensitivity was controlled by a single recessive gene, bel. The mutant can be killed at the seedling stage by bentazon at 300 mg/L or higher, a dosage that is safe for its F1 hybrids and all other normal cultivars. This mutant is also sensitive to all the tested sulfonylurea herbicides. The response of segregating plants to these two types of herbicides indicated that the sulfonylurea sensitivity was also controlled by bel. By crossing this mutant with Pei-Ai 64S (a TGMS line), the bel locus was located on chromosome 3 with 7.1 cM from the closest microsatellite marker RM168. Phenotypic analysis indicated that the bel gene had no negative effect on agronomic traits in either homozygous or heterozygous status. Because the M8077S mutant is lethal in the response of bentazon, homozygous plants at the mutated locus will be killed by the herbicide and selection in breeding programs must be made without application of the chemical. Associated microsatellite markers can be used to select these homozygous plants without spraying the herbicide. These markers have also been used to identify heterozygous plants during continuous backcrossing procedures for gene transfer from one genetic background to another. After two cycles of MAS, a new version of PeiAi 64S (a widely used EGMS cultivar) with bentazon sensitivity was obtained and is ready for seed production (Zhang et al. 2002). The Bel gene can also be used to test for purity in seed production. Hybrid rice seeds must be tested for purity before release to rice producers. Traditionally seed samples were planted and evaluated for purity after flowering, when they could be distinguished from the false hybrid plants based on distinct agronomic traits. In order to obtain purity test results before the next planting season, seed samples are usually sent to a location such as Hainan, China, where rice can be planted in the winter. Nevertheless, this is labor-intensive and also very expensive. Using bentazon sensitivity, false hybrids can be detected by spraying at the 2- to 3-leaf stage. A seedling tray in a greenhouse or in a growth chamber will be enough for a purity test required for any sample of hybrid seeds, which functions the same way as molecular markers used to identify off-types and false hybrids. In seed production, sterile plants are currently planted with pollinators in alternative rows. This system requires a great amount of manpower for transplanting and harvesting if planting is not mechanized. It is very difficult to use manpower to produce F1 seeds in countries where labor is limited and/or very expensive. Mixed planting of sterile plants
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
151
with pollinators could make mechanized seed production easier. This could also ensure a higher ratio of seed set on male sterile plants because the average distance between the pollinators and male sterile flowers becomes closer than under the alternative-row planting (Zhang et al. 2002). As discussed by Maruyama et al. (1991), incorporating a herbicidesensitivity gene to a pollinator, that could be killed by spraying a specific herbicide right after pollination, could ensure that all the harvested seeds are F1 hybrids only. Using PGMS and TGMS lines transformed with the herbicide-resistant gene Bar, the seeds of the herbicide resistant PGMS and TGMS lines were mixed with the pollen parent at the ratio of 4:1. The herbicide Basta was sprayed after natural pollination ended. The pollen parent died and the hybrid seeds could be harvested from the herbicide-resistant PGMS and TGMS lines. The natural outcrossing rate without artificial pollination ranged from 10.6% to 24.5% (Suh et al. 2002). Combining the use of a herbicide-sensitive mutant with a herbicideresistant mutant could be helpful not only for mixed plantings in hybrid seed production but also for removal of selfings. When a pollinator has a sensitivity gene to herbicide A and a resistance gene to herbicide B, it can be killed after pollination by spraying the herbicide A, while the plants from false hybrids can be killed by spraying the herbicide B. M8077S reported by Zhang et al. (2002) can be used as a gene donor for breeding herbicide sensitivity, while the bar gene as reported by Zhang et al. (1998) can be used for breeding a herbicide-resistant pollinator. XI. GENERAL DISCUSSIONS A. Economic Consideration The value of MAS depends on several factors. Acceleration of breeding programs and shortening the breeding cycle would be the first advantage of MAS, because the benefits of releasing new hybrids more quickly can be substantial, particularly in competitive markets. The economic merit of MAS could include situations in which molecular costs are more than offset by savings in phenotypic evaluation. If molecular costs are in addition to, not in place of, phenotypic costs, the economic merit of MAS will become questionable and more difficult to evaluate. In other cases, the ability to select early offsets the extra costs that are associated with MAS. The economic story from DNA sequencing may tell us what we can expect in terms of cost reduction in marker genotyping. Sequencing cost per finished base was $10 in 1990, but was reduced to $1 in 1996 and $0.1 in 2002. With further technology development, it is anticipated that the cost will be $0.01 in 2006, which is a thousand times cheaper
152
Y. XU
than in 1990. The cost of genotyping using molecular markers depends on marker type and its capacity in high-throughput analysis. For example, the lowest cost of SNP analysis is now about 20 to 30 cents per genotype, and a cost of only a few cents per genotype is expected in the coming years (Jenkins and Gibson 2002). With well-established marker systems and sequencing facilities, genotyping with SSR markers costs about 30 to 80 cents per data point, depending on marker multiplexing and the number of markers genotyped for each sample (Xu et al. 2002). There are several ways to reduce the MAS cost. First, high-throughput analysis using automated genotyping and data scoring systems will help increase the daily data output. Second, using the same sample for selection of multiple traits will reduce the trait-based cost. Third, selection at an early stage of plant development and an early stage of the breeding process will minimize the number of plants that need to be retained so that the overall breeding cost will come down. Fourth, optimization of MAS systems, including facilities and personnel, will result in less cost per data point. However, there are very few experiments that have been done with the aim of cost reduction. A comparison between MAS and conventional greenhouse screening of common beans for resistance to common bacterial blight showed that the cost of MAS is about onethird less than that of the greenhouse test (Yu et al. 2000). Today, a database literature search from CAB Abstracts for “markerassisted selection” provides about a thousand hits, but, in most cases, MAS is mentioned only as a future perspective. Others have evaluated the potential of MAS using computer simulation. Overall, there are still few reports of successful MAS experiments. Apparently, almost all MAS projects in plant breeding that have been reported received special monies for demonstration of MAS applications rather than for pure breeding. Several private companies have been routinely using MAS in breeding programs, benefiting from their long-term basic research programs and the availability of all the components of MAS, as discussed in Section III. It is certainly a big investment for a breeding company/institution to start from scratch to run a MAS-based breeding program. Further work on the economic evaluation and optimization of strategies for the use of MAS in breeding programs is required. The economically optimal use of MAS will likely necessitate a complete re-designing or at least some modification of breeding schemes (Dekkers and Hospital 2002). B. Bioinformatics and Breeding Database Enabling infrastructure provides the raw materials and the data and the methods for collating and verifying information within the appropriate biological context. The infrastructure typically includes cDNA and
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
153
genomic sequence data, genetic maps of mutants, DNA markers and maps, candidate genes and quantitative trait loci, physical maps based on chromosome breakpoints, and libraries of large inserts of DNA such as bacterial artificial chromosomes and radiation hybrids. Information flow from molecular markers to genetic maps to sequences and to genes has been established. Apparently, however, there is a gap between the sequence-based information and breeding-related information such as germplasm, pedigree, and phenotype. We will depend on phenotyping as the basis for functional analysis of about 40% of genes even though a complete sequence is available. Integration of breeding-related information with a genomics database is required for genomics-based breeding programs. MAS can be considered the first benefit that breeders can obtain now from genomics. The explosion of interest in marker-trait association studies has led to numerous reports in plants, each based on its own experimental population(s). Each experiment is limited in size and usually restricted to a single population or a cross planted in a specific environment. As suggested by Xu (2002), it is important for all researchers to follow general rules for reporting about genes and traits. One direction for the use of this database is to combine information from several studies, for example, by meta-analysis of results of QTL studies (Goffinet and Gerber 2000) or joint analysis of the raw data (Haley 1999). Extension of current databases to include raw data from gene mapping projects will stimulate this effort. On the other hand, many permanent populations have been shared internationally for genetic mapping. The raw data should be shared, too. A rice RFLP map constructed by using IR64/Azucena DHs has been saturated with about a thousand SSR markers (Chen et al. 1997; Temnykh et al. 2000; McCouch et al. 2002; Y. Xu, RiceTec, Inc., unpubl. data). Researchers involved in QTL mapping, however, have been using the first version of the molecular map consisting of only 175 RFLP markers. Sharing marker and phenotype information through a well-established database will make all sources of data more valuable. C. Opportunities and Challenges Genetic improvement through artificial selection has contributed greatly to advances in productivity that have been achieved over the past century in crops. Plant breeding has generally accounted for one-half of the increases in productivity of the major crops and the future will continue to depend on its advances. Most of the traits that are selected are complex quantitative traits. So far, most selection has been on the basis of observable phenotypic variation, which represents the collective effect
154
Y. XU
of all genes and the environment. Advances in genomics and MAS provide breeders both opportunities and challenges for the improvement of crops through manipulation of both qualitative and quantitative traits. Well-established physical maps and the publicly available DNA sequence for a whole genome, as is currently available for rice, will help eliminate the many fine mapping steps that are required now to narrow down the candidate genome region to a kilobase resolution. Once identified, a target region could be associated with a contig that has been well located on the physical map and defined by molecular markers. On the other hand, high-throughput analysis combined with highly informative molecular markers enables us to manage populations with thousands of plants and thousands of markers in fine mapping. Recent advances in genomics have made it possible to map and determine the magnitude of the effect of individual loci controlling both qualitative and quantitative traits. Positional cloning has been successfully used to clone several QTL with relatively large effects (Frary et al. 2000; Fridman et al. 2000; Yano et al. 2000; Takahashi et al. 2001). Since heterosis and other quantitative traits are usually controlled by many genes, each with a relatively small effect, it will be a great challenge for molecular geneticists to verify the effects of minor genes (Xu 1997). If many genes are known, and favorable alleles are present in different lines or cultivars, MAS can be used to design new genotypes that combine favorable alleles at all loci. A large number of molecular polymorphisms such as SSRs or SNPs and small or large insertions/deletions, discovered with genome sequencing, provide an opportunity for identifying the nucleotide change associated with quantitative trait variation. The nucleotide change that contributes to quantitative variation has been referred to as quantitative trait nucleotide (QTN) (Lyman et al. 1999) or FNP. Fine mapping combined with sequence analysis can quickly narrow the chromosomal region associated with quantitative variation (QTL) down to a specific nucleotide change. Rice as a major food source for human beings has been moving ahead of other crop plants in terms of genome sequencing. Any success in this crop will benefit others in certain ways. Rice has become the model species for the cereals; chromosomes of other cereals such as maize, sorghum, sugarcane, millet, oats, wheat, and barley share much similarity to each other and to rice. The complete DNA sequence of rice will allow the tracking of genes/traits from rice to other grass species. It has become apparent that the differences between species of plants appear due to novel allelic specifications and interactions other than novel genes. Can molecular genetics improve our understanding and manipulation of heterosis? Plant complexity and numerous interactions with the envi-
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
155
ronment will make it difficult or impossible for molecular genetics to identify universal aspects of heterosis suitable for alternation. Elements of a crop’s heterotic response are interwoven with many aspects of plant metabolism and development. We may not find a biologically based unifying mechanism or pathway of heterosis. Certainly, molecular genetics alone will not accomplish this, especially if there are not adequate human resources to analyze, explore, and integrate new sources of information while maintaining a highly effective infrastructure of plant breeding (Lee 1999). Without a deeper understanding of the physiological determinants of yield potential, molecular approaches that seek to empirically concentrate “yield genes” or heterosis genes are likely to fail. Instead, molecular geneticists must actively collaborate with crop physiologists, agronomists, and plant breeders so that genetic differences in yield potential and heterotic loci can be properly measured and identified. Additionally, measurement of yield-determining traits should be made on a time-series of hybrids grown at yield-potential levels, to determine if the changes in hybrid characteristics in breeding history have contributed to an increase in yield potential (Duvick and Cassman 1999). As our awareness and sophistication grows, with the new information, it should be possible to develop more rational and informationdriven assessments and strategies. Molecular-marker technology has revolutionized our understanding of quantitative traits in different backgrounds at different levels of genomics. Considering interactions of all types that could happen among numerous genes with minor effects, and interaction with external environments that could change from time to time and from location to location, we need to develop much more efficient systems for separating, pyramiding, and packaging all the genes related to hybrid performance and heterosis and make them functional at full scale in specific environments. These systems would be too complicated to be practical. Increasing efficiency should be a major objective for future generations of geneticists and plant breeders. Highly informative markers, isogenic mutation libraries, high-throughput technology, availability of full sequences from several model plants and genomics software are key tools for genetic manipulation of genes for quantitative traits. With all these developments, MAS could be an important component in plant breeding, especially for heterosis and hybrid performance. The accepted dogma has been that recent advances in molecular genetics promises to revolutionize agricultural practices. However, as Lande and Thompson (1990) point out, there are several reasons why molecular genetics can never replace traditional methods of agricultural improvement, but instead should be integrated to obtain the maximum improvement in the economic value of domesticated populations. The
156
Y. XU
analytical results, as well as the more recent computer simulations and the limited empirical results (Stuber et al. 1999), are encouraging and support the use of genetic markers to achieve a substantial increase in the efficiency of hybrid breeding. LITERATURE CITED Ajmone Marson, P., P. Castiglioni, F. Fusari, M. Kuiper, and M. Motto. 1998. Genetic diversity and its relationship to hybrid performance in maize as revealed by RFLP and AFLP markers. Theor. Appl. Genet. 96:219–227. Akagi, H., Y. Yokozeki, A. Inagaki, A. Nakamura, and T. Fujimura. 1996. A codominant DNA marker closely linked to the rice nuclear restorer gene, Rf-1, identified with interSSR fingerprinting. Genome 39:1205–1209. Ayres, N. M., A. M. McClung, P. D. Larkin, H. F. J. Bligh, C. A. Jones, and W. D. Park. 1997. Microsatellites and a single-nucleotide polymorphism differentiate apparent amylose classes in an extended pedigree of US rice germ plasm. Theor. Appl. Genet. 94:773–781. Barton, N. H., and P. D. Keightley. 2002. Understanding quantitative genetic variation. Nat. Rev. Genet. 3:11–21. Beavis, W. D. 1994. The power and deceit of QTL experiments: lessons from comparative QTL studies. p. 250–266. In: Proceedings of the 49th annual corn and sorghum industry research conference. Am. Seed Trade Assoc., Washington, DC. Beckmann, J. S., and M. Soller. 1986. Restriction fragment length polymorphisms in plant genetic improvement. Oxford Surveys Plant Molec. Cell Biol. 3:196–250. Benchimol, L. L., C. L. de Souza, Jr., A. A. F. Garcia, P. M. S. Kono, C. A. Mangolin, A. M. M. Barbosa, A. S. G. Coelho, and A. P. de Souza. 2000. Genetic diversity in tropical maize inbred lines: heterotic group assignment and hybrid performance determined by RFLP markers. Plant Breed. 119:491–496. Bernardo, R. 1992. Relationship between single-cross performance and molecular marker heterozygosity. Theor. Appl. Genet. 83:628–634. Bernardo, R. 1994. Prediction of maize single-cross performance using RFLPs and information from related hybrids. Crop Sci. 34:20–25. Bernardo, R. 1996. Best linear unbiased prediction of maize single-cross performance. Crop Sci. 36:50–56. Bernardo, R. 1999. Best linear unbiased predictor analysis. p. 269–276. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Bernardo, R. 2001. What if we knew all the genes for a quantitative trait in hybrid crops? Crop Sci. 41:1–4. Bijlsma, R., R. W. Allard, and A. L. Kahler. 1986. Nonrandom mating in an open-pollinated maize population. Genetics 112:669–680. Bingham, E. T. 1998. Role of chromosome blocks in heterosis and estimates of dominance and overdominance. p. 71–87. In: K. R. Lamkey and J. E. Staub (eds.), Concepts and breeding of heterosis in crop plants. CSSA, Madison, WI. Bligh, H. F. J., R. I. Till, and C. A. Jones. 1995. A microsatellite sequence closely linked to the waxy gene of Oryza sativa. Euphytica 86:83–85. Boppenmaier, J., A. E. Melchinger, G. Seitz, H. H. Geiger, and R. G. Herrmann. 1993. Genetic diversity for RFLPs in European maize inbreds. III. Performance of crosses within versus between heterotic groups for grain traits. Plant Breed. 111:217–226.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
157
Börner, A., V. Korzun, A. Polley, S. Malyshev, and G. Melz. 1998. Genetics and molecular mapping of a male fertility restoration locus (Rfg1) in rye (Secale cereale L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 97:99–102. Botstein, D., R. L. White, M. Skolnick, and R. W. Davis. 1980. Construction of a genetic linkage map in man using restriction fragment length polymorphisms. Am. J. Hum. Genet. 32:314–331. Brandle, J. E., and P. B. E. McVetty. 1990. Geographical diversity, parental selection and heterosis in oilseed rape. Can. J. Plant Sci. 70:935–940. Bretting, P. K., and M. P. Widrlechner. 1995. Genetic markers and plant genetic resource management. Plant Breed. Rev. 13:11–86. Brown, A. D. H. 1989a. The case for core collections. p. 136–156. In: A. D. H. Brown, O. H. Frankel, R. D. Marshall, and J. T. Williams (eds.), The use of plant genetic resources. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK. Brown, A. D. H. 1989b. Core collection: A practical approach to genetic resources management. Genome 31:818–824. Brown, S. M., and S. Kresovich. 1996. Molecular characterization for plant genetic resources conservation. p. 85–93. In: A. H. Paterson (ed.), Genome mapping in plants. R. G. Landes Co., Austin, TX. Brummer, E. C. 1999. Capturing heterosis in forage crop cultivar development. Crop Sci. 39:943–954. Cerna, F. J., S. R. Cianzio, A. Rafalski, S. Tingey, and D. Dyer. 1997. Relationship between seed yield heterosis and molecular marker heterozygosity in soybean. Theor. Appl. Genet. 95:460–467. Chambliss, C. E., and J. M. Jenkins. 1923. Some new varieties of rice. USDA Bul. 1127. Chang, T. T. 1976. The origin, evolution, cultivation, dissemination and diversification of Asian and African rices. Euphytica 25:425–441. Chang, T. T. 1984. Conservation of rice genetic resources: luxury or necessity? Science 224: 251–256. Charcosset, A., and L. Essioux. 1994. The effect of population structure on the relationship between heterosis and heterozygosity at marker loci. Theor. Appl. Genet. 89:336–343. Charcosset, A., M. Lefort-Buson, and A. Gallais. 1991. Relationship between heterosis and heterozygosity at marker loci: a theoretical computation. Theor. Appl. Genet. 81:571– 575. Chavarriaga-Aquirre, P., M. M. Maya, J. Tohme, M. C. Duque, C. Iglesias, M. W. Bonierbale, S. Kresovich, and G. Kochert. 1999. Using microsatellites, isozymes and AFLPs to evaluate genetic diversity and redundancy in the cassava core collection and to assess the usefulness of DNA-based markers to maintain germplasm collections. Mol. Breed. 5:263–273. Chen, L. (ed.). 2001. The principles and techniques of two-line hybrid rice. Shanghai Scientific and Technical Publ., Shanghai, China. Chen S., X. H. Lin, C. G. Xu, and Q. Zhang. 2000. Improvement of bacterial blight resistance of ‘Minghui 63’, an elite restorer line of hybrid rice, by molecular marker-assisted selection. Crop Sci. 40:239–244. Chen, S., C. G. Xu, X. H. Lin, and Q. Zhang. 2001. Improving bacterial blight resistance of ‘6078’, an elite restorer line of hybrid rice, by molecular marker-assisted selection. Plant Breed. 120:133–137. Chen, X., S. Temnykh, Y. Xu, Y. G. Cho, and S. R. McCouch. 1997. Development of microsatellite framework map providing genome-wide coverage in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 95:553–567.
158
Y. XU
Coburn, J. R., S. V. Temnykh, E. M. Paul, and S. R. McCouch. 2002. Design and application of microsatellite marker panels for semiautomated genotyping of rice (Oryza sativa L.). Crop Sci. 42:2092–2099. Crossa, J., I. H. DeLacy, and S. Taba. 1995. The use of multivariate methods in developing a core collection. p. 77–92. In: T. Hodgkin, A. H. D. Brown, Th. J. L. van Hintum, and E. A. V. Morales (eds.), Core collections of plant genetic resources. Wiley, West Sussex, England. Crow, J. F. 1999. Dominance and overdominance. p. 49–58. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Crow, J. F. 2000. The rise and fall of overdominance. Plant Breed. Rev. 17:225–257. Curtis, J. J., A. M. Brunson, J. E. Hubbard, and F. R. Earle. 1956. Effect of the parent on oil content of the corn kernel. Agron. J. 48:551–555. D’Amato, F. 1975. The problem of genetic stability in plant tissues and cell cultures. p. 333–348. In: O. Frankel and J. G. Hawkes (eds.), Crop genetic resources for today and tomorrow. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK. Darrah, L. L., and M. S. Zuber. 1986. 1985 United States maize germplasm base and commercial breeding strategy. Crop Sci. 26:1109–1113. Davenport, C. B. 1908. Degeneration, albinism and inbreeding. Science 28:454–455. Dean, R. E., J. A. Dahlberg, M. S. Hopkins, and S. Kresovich. 1999. Genetic redundancy and diversity among ‘Orange’ accessions in the U.S. National sorghum collection as assessed with simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers. Crop Sci. 39:1215–1221. Dekkers, J. C. M., and F. Hospital. 2002. The use of molecular genetics in the improvement of agricultural populations. Nat. Rev. Genet. 3:22–32. Delourme, R., A. Bouchereau, N. Hubert, M. Renard, and B. S. Landry. 1994. Identification of RAPD markers linked to fertility restorer gene for the Ogura radish cytoplasmic male sterility of rapeseed (Brassic napus L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 88:741–748. Delourme, R., N. Foisset, R. Horvais, P. Barret, G. Champagne, W. Y. Cheung, B. S. Landry, and M. Renard. 1998. Characterisation of the radish introgression carrying the Rfo restorer gene for the Ogu-INRA cytoplasmic male sterility in rapeseed (Brassica napus L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 97:129–134. De Vicente, M. C., and S. D. Tanksley. 1993. QTL analysis of transgressive segregation in an interspecific tomato cross. Genetics 134:585–596. De Vries, A. Ph. 1971. Flowering biology of wheat, particularly in view of hybrid seed production: A review. Euphytica 20:152–170. Dhillon, B. S., J. Boppenmaier, W. G. Pollmer, R. G. Hermann, and A. E. Mechinger. 1993. Relationship of restriction fragment length polymorphisms among European maize inbreds with ear dry matter yield of their hybrids. Maydica 38:245–248. Dilday, R. H. 1990. Contribution of ancestral lines in the development of new cultivars of rice. Crop Sci. 30:905–911. Dong, F., X. Zhu, Z. Xiong, S. Cheng, Z. Sun, and S. Min. 1995. Breeding of photoperiodthermo sensitive genic male sterile indica rice with a pale-green-leaf marker. Chinese J. Rice Sci. 9:65–70. Dong, N. V., P. K. Subudhi, P. N. Luong, V. D. Quang, T. D. Quy, H. G. Zheng, B. Wang, and H. T. Nguyen. 2000. Molecular mapping of a rice gene conditioning thermosensitive genic male sterility using AFLP, RFLP and SSR techniques. Theor. Appl. Genet. 100:727–734. Dudley, J. W. 1993. Molecular markers in plant improvement: manipulation of genes affecting quantitative traits. Crop Sci. 33:660–668. Dudley, J. W. 2004. 100 generations of selection for oil and protein in corn. Plant Breed. Rev. 24 (in press).
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
159
Dudley, J. W., and R. J. Lambert. 1992. Ninety generations of selection for oil and protein in maize. Maydica 37:81–87. Dudley, D. N., M. A. Saghai Maroof, and G. K. Rufener. 1991. Molecular markers and grouping of parents in a maize breeding program. Crop Sci. 31:718–723. Dudley, D. N., M. A. Saghai Maroof, and G. K. Rufener. 1992. Molecular marker information and selection of parents in corn breeding program. Crop Sci. 32:301–304. Duvick, D. N. 1984. Genetic contribution to yield grains of U.S. hybrid maize, 1930–1980. p. 15–47. In: W. R. Fehr (ed.), Genetic contributions to yield grains of five major crop plants. CSSA Spec. Publ. 7. CSSA and ASA, Madison, WI. Duvick, D. N. 1996. Plant breeding: an evolutionary concept. Crop Sci. 36:539–549. Duvick, D. N. 1999. Heterosis: feeding people and protecting natural resources. p. 19–29. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASACSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Duvick, D. N., and K. G. Cassman. 1999. Post-green revolution trends in yield potential of temperate maize in the North-Central United States. Crop Sci. 39:1622–1630. East, E. M. 1908. Inbreeding in corn. Rep. Connecticut Expt. Stat. Years 1907–1908. p. 419–428. Eathington, S. R., J. W. Dudley, and G. K. Rufener. 1997. Marker effects estimated from testcrosses of early and late generations of inbreeding in maize. Crop Sci. 37:1679–1685. Edwards, M. D., and N. J. Page. 1994. Evaluation of marker-assisted selection through computer simulation. Theor. Appl. Genet. 88:376–382. Fehr, W. R. (ed.). 1984. Genetic contribution to yield grains of five major crop plants, Special Publ. No. 7. CSSA, Madison, WI. Fisch, M., M. Bohn, and A. E. Melchinger. 1999. Comparison of selection strategies for marker-assisted backcrossing of a gene. Crop Sci. 39:1295–1301. Flint, J., and R. Mott. 2001. Finding the molecular basis of quantitative traits: successes and pitfalls. Nat. Rev. Genet. 2:437–445. Frankel, O. 1984. Genetic perspectives of germplasm conservation. p. 161–170. In: W. Arber, K. Limensee, W. J. Peacock, and P. Starlinger (eds.), Genetic manipulation: impact on man and society. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK. Frary, A., T. C. Nesbitt, A. Frary, S. Grandillo, E. van der Knaap, B. Cong, J. Liu, J. Meller, R. Elber, K. B. Alpert, and S. D. Tanksley. 2000. fw2.2: a quantitative trait locus to the evolution of tomato fruit size. Science 289:85–88. Fridman, E., T. Pleban, and D. Zamir. 2000. A recombination hotspot delimits a wildspecies quantitative trait locus for tomato sugar content to 484 bp within an invertase gene. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA) 97:4718–4723. Gardner, C. O. 1963. Estimates of genetic parameters in cross fertilizing plants and their implications in plant breeding. p. 225–252. In: W. D. Hanson and H. F. Robinson (ed.), Statistical genetics and plant breeding. NAS-NRC, Washington, DC. Gentzbittel, L., F. Vear, Y. X. Zhang, A. Berville, and P. Nicolas. 1995. Development of a consensus linkage RFLP map of cultivated sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 90:1079–1086. Georgiady, M. S., R. W. Whitkus, and E. M. Lord. 2002. Genetic analysis of traits distinguishing outcrossing and self-pollinating forms of currant tomato, Lycopersicon pimpinellifolium (Jusl.) Mill. Genetics 161:333–344. Gerdes, J. T., and W. F. Tracy. 1993. Pedigree diversity within the Lancaster Surecrop heterotic group of maize. Crop Sci. 33:334–337. Gethi, J. G., J. A. Labate, K. R. Lamkey, M. E. Smith, and S. Kresovich. 2002. SSR variation in important U.S. maize inbred lines. Crop Sci. 42:951–957.
160
Y. XU
Gizlice, Z., T. E. Carter, Jr., and J. W. Burton. 1993. Genetic diversity in North American soybean: II. Prediction of heterosis in F2 populations of southern founding stock using genetic similarity measures. Crop Sci. 33:620–626. Godshalk, E. B., M. Lee, and K. R. Lamkey. 1990. Relationship of restriction fragment length polymorphisms to single-cross hybrid performance of maize. Theor. Appl. Genet. 80:273–280. Goffinet, B., and S. Gerber. 2000. Quantitative trait loci: A meta-analysis. Genetics 155:463–473. Goldman, I. L. 1999. Inbreeding and outbreeding in the development of a modern heterosis concept. p. 7–18. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Goldman, I. L. 2000. Prediction in plant breeding. Plant Breed. Rev. 19:15–40. Goldman, I. L., T. R. Rocheford, and J. W. Dudley. 1993. Quantitative trait loci influencing protein and starch concentration in the Illinois long term selection maize strains. Theor. Appl. Genet. 87:217–224. Graham, G. I., D. W. Wolff, and C. W. Stuber. 1997. Characterization of a yield quantitative locus on chromosome five of maize by fine mapping. Crop Sci. 37:1601–1610. Grandillo, S., and S. D. Tanksley. 1996. QTL analysis of horticultural traits differentiating the cultivated tomato from the closely related species Lycopersicon pimpinellifolium. Theor. Appl. Genet. 92:935–951. Grant, I., and W. D. Beversdorf. 1985. Heterosis and combining ability estimates in spring oilseed rape (Brassica napus L.). Can. J. Genet. Cytol. 27:472–478. Gu, M. H., and S. Z. Tang. 2001. Theory and practice of two-line intersubspecific hybrid rice. p. 100–132. In: X. G. Lu, M. H. Gu, and C. Q. Li (eds.), Theory and technology of two-line hybrid rice. China Science Press, Beijing. Haley, C. 1999. Advances in quantitative trait locus mapping. p. 47–59. In: J. C. M. Dekkers, S. J. Lamont, and M. F. Rothschild (eds.), From Jay Lush to genomics: Visions for animal breeding and genetics. Animal Breeding & Genetics Group, Dept. Animal Sci., Iowa State Univ., Ames. Hallauer, A. R. 1990. Methods used in developing maize inbreds. Maydica 35:1–16. Hallauer, A. R. 1999. Temperate maize and heterosis. p. 353–361. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Hallauer, A. R., and J. B. Miranda. 1988. Quantitative genetics and maize breeding. 2nd ed. Iowa State Univ. Press, Ames. Hallauer, A. R., W. A. Russell, and K. R. Lamkey. 1988. Corn breeding. p. 463–564. In: G. F. Sprague and J. W. Dudley (eds.), Corn and corn improvement. 3rd ed. Agron. Monogr. 18. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Hamon, S., M. Noirot, and F. Anthony. 1995. Developing a coffee core collection using the principal components score strategy with quantitative data. p. 117–126. In: T. Hodgkin, A. H. D. Brown, Th. J. L. van Hintum, and E. A. V. Morales (eds.), Core collections of plant genetic resources. Wiley, West Sussex, England. Han, G. C., S. K. Vasal, D. L. Beck, and E. Elias. 1991. Combining ability analysis of inbred lines derived from CIMMYT maize (Zea mays L.) germplasm. Maydica 36:57–64. Hansen, M., C. Halldén, N.-O. Nilsson, and T. Säll. 1997. Marker-assisted selection of restored male-fertile Brassica napus plants using a set of dominant RAPD markers. Mol. Breed. 3:449–456. Havey, M. J. 1998. Molecular analyses and heterosis in the vegetables: can we breed them like maize? p. 109–116. In: K. R. Lamkey and J. E. Staub (eds.), Concepts and breeding of heterosis in crop plants. CSSA, Madison, WI.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
161
He, S., Z.-H. Yu, C. E. Vallejos, and S. A. Mackenzie. 1995. Pollen fertility restoration by nuclear gene Fr in common bean: an Fr linkage map and the mode of Fr action. Theor. Appl. Genet. 90:1056–1062. He, Y., C. Chen, J. Tu, P. Zhou, G. Jiang, Y. Tan, C. Xu, and Q. Zhang. 2002. Improvement of an elite rice hybrid, Shanyou 63, by transformation and marker-assisted selection. p. 43. In: Abstract of the Fourth Intl. Symp. Hybrid Rice, 14–17 May 2002, Hanoi, Vietnam. Henderson, C. R. 1975. Best linear unbiased estimation and prediction under a selection model. Biometrics 31:423–447. Hepting, L. 1978. Analyse eines 7×7—Sortendiallels zur Ermittlung geeigneten Ausgansmaterials für die Hybridzüchtung bei Roggen. Z. Pflanzenzücht. 80:188–197. Hittalmani S., A. Parco, T. V. Mew, R. S. Zeigler, and N. Huang. 2000. Fine mapping and DNA marker-assisted pyramiding of the three major genes for blast resistance in rice. Theor. Appl. Genet. 100:1121–1128. Hjerdin-Panagopoulos, A., T. Kraft, I. M. Rading, S. Tuvesson, and N.-O. Nilsson. 2002. Three QTL regions for restoration of Owen CMS in sugar beet. Crop Sci. 42:540–544. Hospital, F., and A. Charcosset. 1997. Marker-assisted introgression of quantitative trait loci. Genetics 147:1469–1485. Hospital, F., C. Chevalet, and P. Mulsant. 1992. Using markers in gene introgression breeding programs. Genetics 132:1199–1210. Huang, N., E. R. Angeles, J. Domingo, G. Magpantay, S. Singh, G. Zhang, N. Kumaravadivel, J. Bennett, and G. S. Khush. 1997. Pyramiding of bacterial blight resistance genes in rice: marker-assisted selection using RFLP and PCR. Theor. Appl. Genet. 95:313–320. Huang, Q. Y., Y. Q. He, R. C. Jing, R. S. Zhu, and Y. G. Zhu. 1999. Mapping of the nuclear fertility restorer gene for HL cytoplasmic male sterility in rice using microsatellite markers. Chinese Sci. Bul. 45:430–432. Hyne, V., and M. J. Kearsey. 1995. QTL analysis—further uses of marker regression. Theor. Appl. Genet. 91:471–476. Igartua, E., M. Edney, B. G. Rossnagel, D. Spaner, W. G. Legge, G. L. Scoles, P. E. Ecksteins, G. A. Penner, N. A. Tinker, K. G. Briggs, D. E. Falk, and D. E. Mather. 2000. Markerassisted selection of QTL affecting grain and malt quality in two-row barley. Crop Sci. 40:1426–1433. Ikehashi, H. 1982. Prospects for overcoming barriers in the utilization of indica-japonica crosses in rice breeding. Oryza 19:69–77. Ikehashi, H., and H. Araki. 1986. Genetics of F1 sterility in remote crosses of rice. p. 119– 130. In: Rice genetics. Intl. Rice Res. Inst., P. O. Box 933, Manila 1099, Philippines. Ikehashi, H., and H. Araki. 1987. Screening and genetic analysis of wide compatibility in F1 hybrids of distant crosses in rice, Oryza sativa. Tech. Bul. Trop. Agr. Res. Center No. 23. TARC, Japan. Ikehashi, H., and J. Wan. 1998. The wide compatibility system: current knowledge of its genetics and use for enhanced yield heterosis. p. 67–77. In: S. S. Virmani, E. A. Siddiq, and K. Muralidharan (eds.), Advances in hybrid rice technology. Proc. Third Intl. Symp. Hybrid Rice, 14–16 Nov. 1996, Hyderabad, India. Intl. Rice Res. Inst., Manila, Philippines. Iwanaga, M. 1993. Enhancing links between germplasm conservation and use in a changing world. p. 407–413. In: International crop science I. CSSA, Madison, WI. Janick, J. 1998. Hybrids in horticulture crops. p. 45–56. In: K. R. Lamkey and J. E. Staub (eds.), Concepts and breeding of heterosis in crop plants. CSSA, Madison, WI. Jean, M., G. G. Brown, and B. S. Landry. 1997. Genetic mapping of nuclear fertility restorer genes for the ‘Polima’ cytoplasmic male sterility in canola (Brassica napus L.) using DNA markers. Theor. Appl. Genet. 95:321–328.
162
Y. XU
Jenkins, S., and N. Gibson. 2002. High-throughput SNP genotyping. Comp. Funct. Genom. 3:57–66. Ji, Q., G. Wang, E. Belhassen, H. Serieys, and A. Berville. 1996. Molecular markers of nuclear restoration gene Rf1 in sunflower using bulked segregant analysis—RAPD. Science in China (Ser. C) 39:551–560. Jia, J. H., C. Y. Li, X. P. Qu, Q. Wang, Q. Y. Deng, M. L. Weng, and B. Wang. 2000. Construction of genetic linkage map and mapping of thermo-sensitive genic male sterile gene tms5 in rice. p. 37. In: Abstract for Plant Genomics in China I, July 2000, Dalian, China. Jia, J. H., D. S. Zhang, C. Y. Li, X. P. Qu, S. W. Wang, V. Chamarerk, H. T. Nguyen, and B. Wang. 2001. Molecular mapping of the reverse thermo-sensitive genic male sterile gene (rtms1) in rice. Theor. Appl. Genet. 103:607–612. Jia, M. H., S. He, W. Vanhouten, and S. Machenzie. 1997. Nuclear fertility restorer genes map to the same linkage group in cytoplasmic male-sterile bean. Theor. Appl. Genet. 95:205–210. Jing, R., X. Li, P. Yi, and Y. Zhu. 2001. Mapping fertility-restoring genes of rice WA cytoplasmic male sterility using SSLP markers. Bot. Bul. Acad. Sin. 42:167–171. Johnson, G. R., and R. H. Mumm. 1996. Marker-assisted maize breeding. Proc. 51st Annual Corn and Sorghum Industry Research Conf., American Seed Trade Assoc. 51:75–84. Johnston, T. H. 1958. Registration of rice varieties. Agron. J. 50:694–700. Jordaan, J. P., S. A. Engelbrecht, J. H. Malan, and H. A. Knobel. 1999. Wheat and heterosis. p. 411–421. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Joshi, S. P., S. G. Bhave, K. V. Chowdari, G. S. Apte, B. L. Dhonukshe, K. Lalitha, P. K. Rangekar, and V. S. Gupta. 2001. Use of DNA markers in prediction of hybrid performance and heterosis for a three-line hybrid system in rice. Biochem. Genet. 39(5/6):179–200. Kahler, A. L., C. O. Gardner, and R. W. Allard. 1984. Nonrandom mating in experimental populations of maize. Crop Sci. 24:350–354. Kamps, T. L., and C. D. Chase. 1997. RFLP mapping of the maize gametophytic restorerof-fertility locus (rf3) and aberrant pollen transmission of the nonrestoring rf3 allele. Theor. Appl. Genet. 95:525–531. Kearsey, M. J., and A. G. L. Farquhar. 1998. QTL analysis in plants: Where are we now? Heredity 80:137–142. Khush, G. S., I. Kumar, and S. S. Virmani. 1988. Grain quality of hybrid rice. p. 201–215. In: International Rice Research Institute (ed.), Hybrid rice. P.O. Box 933, Manila, Philippines. Kiesselbach, T. A. 1926. The immediate effect of gametic relationship and of parental type upon the kernel weight of corn. Neb. Agr. Expt. Sta. Bul. 33:1–69. King, J. J., J. M. Bradeen, O. Bark, J. A. McCallum, and M. J. Havey. 1998. A low-density genetic map of onion reveals a role for tandem duplication in the evolution of an extremely large diploid genome. Theor. Appl. Genet. 96:52–62. Kinoshita, T. 1998. Linkage mapping using mutant genes in rice. Rice Genet. Newsl. 15:13–74. Klein, R. R., P. E. Klein, A. K. Chhabra, J. Dong, S. Pammi, K. L. Childs, J. E. Mullet, W. L. Rooney, and K. F. Schertz. 2001. Molecular mapping of the rf1 gene for pollen fertility restoration in sorghum (Sorghum bicolor L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 102:1206–1212. Knapp, S. J. 1998. Marker-assisted selection as a strategy for increasing the probability of selecting superior genotypes. Crop Sci. 38:1164–1174. Kojima, T., H. Tsujimoto, and Y. Ogihara. 1997. High-resolution RFLP mapping of the fertility restoration (Rf3) gene against Triticum timopheevi cytoplasm located on chromosome 1BS of common wheat. Genes Genet. Syst. 72:353–359.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
163
Kumar, I., and G. S. Khush. 1986. Genetics of amylose content in rice (Oryza sativa L.). J. Genet. 65:1–11. Kurata, N., Y. Nagamura, K. Yamamoto, Y. Harushima, N. Sue, J. Wu, B. A. Antonio, A. Shomura, T. Shimizu, S. Y. Lin, T. Inoue, A. Fukuda, T. Shimano, Y. Kuboki, T. Toyama, Y. Miyamoto, T. Kirihara, K. Hayasaka, A. Miyao, L. Monna, H. S. Zhong, T. Tamura, Z. X. Wang, T. Momma, Y. Umehara, M. Yano, T. Sasaki, and Y. Minobe. 1994. A 300 kilobase interval genetic map of rice including 883 expressed sequences. Nat. Genet. 8:365–372. Lamkey, K. R., and J. W. Edwards. 1999. Quantitative genetics of heterosis. p. 31–48. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASACSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Lande, R., and R. Thompson. 1990. Efficiency of marker-assisted selection in the improvement of quantitative traits. Genetics 124:743–756. Lang, N. T., P. K. Subudhi, S. S. Virmani, D. S. Brar, G. S. Khush, Z. Li, and N. Huang. 1999. Development of PCR-based markers for thermosensitive genetic male sterility gene tms3(t) in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Hereditas 131:121–127. Laporte, V., D. Merdinoglu, P. Saumitou-Laprade, G. Butterlin, P. Vernet, and J. Cuguen. 1998. Identification and mapping of RAPD and RFLP markers linked to a fertility restorer gene for a new source of cytoplasmic male sterility in Beta vulgaris ssp. maritima. Theor. Appl. Genet. 96:989–996. Lassner, M. W., and T. J. Orton. 1983. Detection of somatic variation. p.209–217. In: S. D. Tanksley and T. J. Orton (eds.), Isozymes in plant genetics and breeding. Vol. 1A. Developments in plant genetics and breeding, 1. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Lee, M. 1995. DNA markers and plant breeding programs. Adv. Agron. 55:265–344. Lee, M. 1999. Towards understanding and manipulating heterosis in crop plants: can molecular genetics help? p. 185–194. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Lee, M., E. B. Godshalk, K. R. Lamkey, and W. L. Woodman. 1989. Association of restriction length polymorphism among maize inbreds with agronomic performance of their crosses. Crop Sci. 29:1067–1071. Lefort-Buson, M., B. Guillot-Lemoine, and Y. Datte. 1987. Heterosis and genetic distance in rape seed (Brassica napus L.): Crosses between European and Asiatic selfed lines. Genome 29:413–418. Lewontin, R. C., and J.-P. Berlan. 1990. The political economy of agricultural research: The case of hybrid corn. p. 613–628. In: C. R. Carroll et al. (eds.), Agroecology. McGraw Hill, New York. Li, B., and R. Wu. 1996. Genetic causes of heterosis in juvenile aspen: a quantitative comparison across intra- and inter-specific hybrids. Theor. Appl. Genet. 93:380–391. Li, H., L. Tang, and J. Zou. 1991. Marker-based analysis of wide compatibility in rice (in Chinese). Hybrid Rice (4):22–24. Li, J., and L. Yuan. 2000. Hybrid rice: Genetics, breeding, and seed production. Plant Breed. Rev. 17:15–158. Li, P., K. D. Zhou, Y. Chen, P. He, R. R. Li, and L. H. Zhu. 1996. Molecular mapping of the restorer genes of wild type cytoplasmic male sterility in rice. Acta Genetica Sinica 23:357–362. Li, X., Q. Lu, F. Wang, C. Xu, and Q. Zhang. 2001. Separation of the two-locus inheritance of photoperiod sensitive genic male sterility in rice and precise mapping the pms3 locus. Euphytica 119:343–348. Li, Z. 2001. QTL mapping in rice. p. 153–171. In: G. S. Khush, D. S. Brar and B. Hardy (eds.), Rice genetics IV. Proc. Fourth Intl. Rice Genetics Symp., 22–27 Oct. 2000. Los
164
Y. XU
Baños, Philippines. Science Publ., Inc., New Delhi, India, and Intl. Rice Res. Inst., Los Baños, Philippines. Li, Z.-K., L. J. Luo, H. W. Mei, D. L. Wang, Q. Y. Shu, R. Tabien, D. B. Zhong, C. S. Ying, J. W. Stansel, G. S. Khush, and A. H. Paterson. 2001. Overdominance epistatic loci are the primary genetic basis of inbreeding depression and heterosis in rice: I. Biomass and grain yield. Genetics 158:1737–1753. Lin, H. X., T. Yamamoto , T. Sasaki, and M. Yano. 2000. Characterization and detection of epistatic interactions of 3 QTLs, Hd1, Hd2, and Hd3, controlling heading date in rice using nearly isogenic lines. Theor. Appl. Genet. 101:1021–1028. Liu, A., Q. Zhang, and H. Li. 1992. Location of a gene for wide-compatibility in the RFLP linkage map. Rice Genet. Newsl. 9:134–136. Liu, B. H. 1998. Statistical genomics: Linkage, mapping, and QTL analysis. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Liu, K., J. Wang, H. B. Li, C. G. Xu, A. M. Li, X. H. Li, and Q. Zhang. 1997. A genome-wide analysis of wide compatibility in rice and the precise location of the S5 locus in the molecular map. Theor. Appl. Genet. 95:809–814. Liu, N., Y. Shan, F. P. Wang, C. G. Xu, K. M. Peng, X. H. Li, and Q. Zhang. 2001. Identification of an 85-kb DNA fragment containing pms1, a locus for photoperiod-sensitive genic male sterility in rice. Mol. Genet. Genomics 266:271–275. Liu, X. Z., Z. B. Peng, J. H. Fu, L. C. Li, and C. L. Huang. 1997. Application of RAPD in group classification studies. Scientia Agr. Sinica 30(3):44–51. Liu, X. C., and J. L. Wu. 1998. SSR heterotic patterns of parents for making and predicting heterosis in rice breeding. Mol. Breed. 4:263–268. Lu, X. G., M. H. Gu, and C. Q. Li (eds.). 2001. Theory and technology of two-line hybrid rice. China Science Press, Beijing. Lu, X. G., T. M. Mou, N. T. Hoan, and S. S. Virmani. 2002. Two-line hybrid rice breeding in and outside of China. p. 6. In: Abstract of the Fourth Intl. Symp. Hybrid Rice, 14–17 May 2002, Hanoi, Vietnam. Lu, X., Z. Zhang, S. S. Virmani, and K. Maruyama. 1994. Current status of two-line method of hybrid rice breeding. Chinese J. Rice Sci. 8:48–54. Lübberstedt, T., A. E. Melchinger, S. Fähr, D. Klein, A. Dally, and P. Westhoff. 1998. QTL mapping in testcrossing of flint lines of maize: II. Comparison across populations for forage traits. Crop Sci. 38:1278–1289. Lucken, K. A. 1986. The breeding and production of hybrid wheat. p. 87–107. In: E. L. Smith (ed.), Genetic improvement in yield of wheat. CSSA and ASA, Madison, WI. Lucken, K. A., and K. D. Johnson. 1988. Hybrid wheat status and outlook. p. 243–255. In: International Rice Research Institute (ed.), Hybrid rice. P.O. Box 933, Manila, Philippines. Luo, L. J., Z.-K. Li, H. W. Mei, Q. Y. Shu, R. Tabien, D. B. Zhong, C. S. Ying, J. W. Stansel, G. S. Khush, and A. H. Paterson. 2001. Overdominant epistatic loci are the primary genetic basis of inbreeding depression and heterosis in rice. II. Grain yield components. Genetics 158:1755–1771. Lyman, R. F., C. Lai, and T. F. Mackay. 1999. Linkage disequilibrium mapping of molecular polymorphisms at the scabrous locus associated with naturally occurring variation in bristle number in Drosophila melanogaster. Genet. Res. 74:303–311. Lynch, M., and B. Walsh. 1998. Genetics and analysis of quantitative traits. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA. Ma, G., and L. P. Yuan. 2002. Achievements and development of hybrid rice in China. p. 22. In: Abstract of the Fourth International Symposium on Hybrid Rice, 14–17 May 2002, Hanoi, Vietnam.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
165
Ma, Z. Q., and M. E. Sorrells. 1995. Genetic analysis of fertility restoration in wheat using restriction fragment length polymorphisms. Crop Sci. 35:1137–1143. Ma, Z. Q., Y. H. Zhao, and M. E. Sorrells. 1995. Inheritance and chromosomal locations of male fertility restoring gene transferred from Aegilops unbellulata Zhuk. to Triticum aestivum L. Mol. Gen. Genet. 247:351–357. Mackay, T. F. C. 1995. The genetic basis of quantitative variation: number of sensory bristles of Drosophila melanogaster as a model system. Trends Genet. 11:464–470. Mackill, D. J., and J. Ni. 2001. Molecular mapping and marker-assisted selection for majorgene traits in rice. p. 137–151. In: G. S. Khush, D. S. Brar, and B. Hardy (eds.), Rice genetics IV, Proc. Fourth Intl. Rice Genetics Symp., 22–27 Oct. 2000, Los Baños, Philippines. Science Publ., Inc., New Delhi, India, and Intl. Rice Res. Inst., Los Baños, Philippines. Mackill, D. J., Z. Zhang, E. D. Redoña, and P. M. Colowit. 1996. Level of polymorphism and genetic mapping of AFLP markers in rice. Genome 39:969–977. Maheswaran, M., N. Huang, S. R. Sreerangasamy, and S. R. McCouch. 2000. Mapping quantitative trait loci associated with days to flowering and photoperiod sensitivity in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Mol. Breed. 6:145–155. Martin, J. M., L. E. Talbert, S. P. Lanning, and N. K. Blake. 1995. Hybrid performance in wheat as related to parental diversity. Crop Sci. 35:104–108. Maruyama, K., H. Kato, and H. Araki. 1991. Mechanized production of F1 seeds in rice by mixed planting. Japan Agr. Res. Quart. 4:243–252. Matsui, K., Y. Mano, S. Taketa, N. Kawada, and T. Komatsuda. 2001. Molecular mapping of a fertility restoration locus (Rfm1) for cytoplasmic male sterility in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 102:477–482. McCouch, S. R., X. Chen, O. Panaud, S. Temnykh, Y. Xu, Y. G. Cho, N. Huang, T. Ishii, and M. Blair. 1997. Microsatellite marker development, mapping and applications in rice genetics and breeding. Plant Mol. Biol. 35:89–99. McCouch, S. R., L. Teytelman, Y. Xu, K. B. Lobos, K. Clare, M. Walton, B. Fu, R. Magnirang, Z. Li, Y. Xing, Q. Zhang, I. Kono, M. Yano, R. Fjellstrom, G. DeClerck, D. Schneider, S. Cartinhour, D. Ware, and L. Stein. 2002. Development of 2240 new SSR markers for rice (Oryza sativa L.) DNA Res. 9:199–207. Meghi, M. R., J. W. Dudley, R. J. Lamkey, and G. F. Sprauge. 1984. Inbreeding depression, inbred and hybrid grain yields, and other traits of maize genotypes representing three eras. Crop Sci. 24:545–549. Mei, M. H., X. K. Da, C. G. Xu, and Q. Zhang. 1999. Mapping and genetic analysis of the genes for photoperiod-sensitive genic male sterility in rice using the original mutant Nongken 58S. Crop Sci. 39:1711–1715. Melchinger, A. E. 1993. Use of RFLP markers for analyses of genetic relationships among breeding materials and prediction of hybrid performance. p. 621–628. In: D. R. Duxton et al. (eds.), International crop science I. CSSA, Madison, WI. Melchinger, A. E. 1999. Genetic diversity and heterosis. p. 99–118. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Melchinger, A. E., and R. K. Gumber. 1998. Overview of heterosis and heterotic groups in agronomic crops. p. 29–44. In: K. R. Lamkey and J. E. Staub (eds.), Concepts and breeding of heterosis in crop plants. CSSA, Madison, WI. Melchinger, A. E., M. Lee, K. R. Lamkey, and W. L. Woodman. 1990. Genetic diversity for restriction fragment length polymorphisms: relation to estimated genetic effects in maize inbreds. Crop Sci. 30:1033–1040.
166
Y. XU
Melchinger, A. E., M. M. Messmer, M. Lee, W. L. Woodman, and K. R. Lamkey. 1991. Diversity and relationships among U.S. maize inbreds revealed by restriction fragment length polymorphism. Crop Sci. 31:669–678. Melchinger, A. E., J. Boppenmaier, B. S. Dhillon, W. G. Pollmer, and R. G. Herrmann. 1992. Genetic diversity for RFLPs in European maize inbreds. II. Relation to performance of hybrids within versus between heterotic groups for forage traits. Theor. Appl. Genet. 84:627–681. Melchinger, A. E., A. Graner, M. Singh, and M. M. Messmer. 1994. Relationships among European germplasm: I. Genetic diversity among winter and spring cultivars revealed by RFLPs. Crop Sci. 34:1191–1199. Meng, J. L., A. Sharpe, C. Bowman, Z. H. Tian, T. D. Fu, X. Z. Qian, and D. Lydiate. 1996. Genetic diversity of Brassica napus revealed by RFLP markers. Acta Genetica Sinica 23:293–306. Messmer, M. M., A. E. Melchinger, R. G. Herrmann, and J. Boppenmaier. 1993. Relationships among early European maize inbreds: II. Comparisons of pedigree and RFLP data. Crop Sci. 33:944–950. Miedaner, T., C. Glass, F. Dreyer, P. Wilde, H. Wortmann, and H. H. Geiger. 2000. Mapping of genes for male-fertility restoration in ‘Pampa’ CMS winter rye (Secale cereale L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 101:1226–1233. Miller, J. F. 1999. Oilseeds and heterosis. p. 399–404. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Miller, J. F., and K. A. Lucken. 1976. Hybrid wheat seed production methods for North Dakota. Crop Sci. 16:217–221. Mitchell-Olds, T. 1995. Interval mapping of viability loci causing heterosis in Arabidopsis. Genetics 140:105–109. Moll, R. H., M. F. Lindsey, and H. F. Robinson. 1963. Estimates of genetic variances and level of dominance in maize. Genetics 49:411–423. Moncada, P., C. P. Martinez, J. Borrero, M. Chatel, H. Gauch, E. Guimaraes, J. Tohme, and S. R. McCouch. 2001. Quantitative trait loci for yield and yield components in an Oryza sativa × Oryza rufipogon BC2F2 population evaluated in an upland environment. Theor. Appl. Genet. 102:41–52. Monna, L., H. X. Lin, S. Kojima, T. Sasaki, and M. Yano. 2002. Genetic dissection of a genomic region for a quantitative trait locus, Hd3, into two loci, Hd3a and Hd3b, controlling heading date in rice. Theor. Appl. Genet. 104:772–778. Moreau, L., A. Charcosset, F. Hospital, and A. Gallais. 1998. Marker-assisted selection efficiency in population of finite size. Genetics 148:1353–1365. Mori, K. 1984. Inheritance of susceptible mutant in rice plant to herbicide bentazon. Japan. J. Breed. 34 (Suppl 1):340–341. Moser, H., and M. Lee. 1994. RFLP variation and genealogical distance, multivariate distance, heterosis, and genetic variance in oats. Theor. Appl. Genet. 87:947–956. Mou, T., C. Li, G. Yang, and X. Lu. 1995. Genetical studies on seedling leaf color in purple rice. Chinese J. Rice Sci. 9:45–48. Mumm, R. H., and J. W. Dudley. 1994. Classification of 148 U.S. maize inbreds. I. Cluster analysis based on RFLPs. Crop Sci. 34:842–851. Murayana, S., H. Yamagishi, and T. Terachi. 1999. Identification of RAPD and SCAR markers linked to a restorer gene for Ogura cytoplasmic male sterility in radish (Raphanus sativus L.) by bulked segregant analysis. Breed. Sci. 49:115–121. Nguyen, H. T., R. Chandra Babu, and A. Blum. 1997. Breeding for drought tolerance in rice: physiology and molecular genetics considerations. Crop Sci. 37:1426–1434.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
167
Ni, J. J., P. Wu, D. Senadhira, and N. Huang. 1998. Mapping QTLs for phosphorus deficiency tolerance in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 97:1361–1369. Ni, Z. F., Q. X. Sun, Z. Y. Liu, and T. C. Huang. 1997. Studies on heterotic grouping in wheat: II. Genetic diversity among common wheat, Tibet semi-wild wheat and spelt wheat. J. Agr. Biotech. (China) 5:103–111. Oka, H. I. 1988. Origin of cultivated rice. Japan Scientific Societies Press, Elsevier, Tokyo. Olufowote, J. O., Y. Xu, X. Chen, W. D. Park, H. M. Beachell, R. H. Dilday, M. Goto, and S. R. McCouch. 1997. Comparative evaluation of within-cultivar variation of rice (Oryza sativa L.) using microsatellite and RFLP markers. Genome 40:370–378. Paterson, A. H. 1996. DNA marker-assisted crop improvement. p. 71–83. In: A. H. Paterson (ed.), Genome mapping in plants. R. G. Landes Company, Austin, TX. Paterson, A. H. 1998. Molecular dissection of complex traits. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Paterson, A. H., S. D. Tanksley, and M. E. Sorrells. 1991. DNA markers in plant improvement. Adv. Agron. 46:39–90. Peng, Z. B., X. Z. Liu, J. H. Fu, L. C. Li, and C. L. Huang. 1998. Preliminary studies on the superior inbred groups and construction of heterosis mode. Acta Agron. Sinica 24:711–717. Pillen, K., G. Steinrucken, R. G. Herrmann, and C. Jung. 1993. An extended linkage map of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris L.) including nine putative lethal genes and the restorer gene X. Plant Breed. 111:265–272. Pollak, L. M., C. O. Gardner, A. L. Kahler, and M. Thomas-Compton. 1984. Further analysis of the mating system in two mass selected populations of maize. Crop Sci. 24:793–796. Quillet, M. C., N. Madjidian, Y. Griveau, H. Serieys, M. Tersac, M. Lorieux, and A. Berville. 1995. Mapping genetic factors controlling pollen viability in an interspecific cross in Helianthus sect. Helianthus. Theor. Appl. Genet. 91:1195–1202. Ramage, R. T. 1983. Heterosis and hybrid seed production in barley. p. 71–93. In: R. Frankel (ed.), Monographs on theoretical and applied genetics, Vol. 6, Heterosis. Springer-Verlag, Berlin and Heidelberg. Reddy, O. U. K., E. A. Siddiq, N. P. Sarma, J. Ali, A. J. Hussain, P. Nimmakayala, P. Ramasamy, S. Pammi, and A. S. Reddy. 2000. Genetic analysis of temperaturesensitive male sterility in rice. Theor. Appl. Genet. 100:794–801. Reeves, T., P. Pinstrup-Anderson, and R. Randya-Lorch. 1999. Food security and role of agricultural research. p. 1–5. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Ribaut, J.-M., G. O. Edmeades, F. J. Betrán, C. Jiang, and M. Bänziger. 1999. Markerassisted selection for improving drought tolerance in tropical maize. p. 193–209. In: O. Ito, J. O’Toole, and B. Hardy (eds.), Genetic improvement of rice for water-limited environments. Intl. Rice Res. Inst., Manila, Philippines. Ron Parra, J., and A. R. Hallauer. 1997. Utilization of exotic maize germplasm. Plant Breed. Rev. 14:165–187. Roos, E. E. 1984. Genetic shifts in mixed bean populations. I. Storage effects. Crop Sci. 24:240–244. Roos, E. E. 1988. Genetic changes in a collection over time. HortScience 23:86–90. Rutger, J. N., and C. N. Bollich. 1991. Use of introduced germplasm in U.S. rice improvement. p. 1–13. In: Use of plant introductions in cultivar development, Part I. CSSA Special Publ. no. 17 Rutger, J. N., M. L. Peterson, and C. H. Hu. 1977. Registration of Calrose 76 rice. Crop Sci. 17:978.
168
Y. XU
Saghai Maroof, M. A., G. P. Yang, Q. Zhang, and K. A. Gravois. 1997. Correlation between molecular marker distance and hybrid performance in US southern long grain rice. Crop Sci. 37:145–150. Sanchez, A. C., D. S. Brar, N. Huang, Z. Li, and G. S. Khush. 2000. Sequence tagged site marker-assisted selection for three bacterial blight resistance genes in rice. Crop Sci. 40:792–797. Sant, V. J., A. G. Patankar, N. D. Sarode, L. B. Mhase, M. N. Sainani, R. B. Deshmukh, P. K. Ranjekar, and V. S. Gupta. 1999. Potential of DNA markers in detecting divergence and in analyzing heterosis in Indian elite chickpea cultivars. Theor. Appl. Genet. 98:1217–1225. Schoen, D. J., and A. H. D. Brown. 1995. Maximising genetic diversity in core collections of wild relatives of crop species. p. 55–76. In: T. Hodgkin, A. H. D. Brown, Th. J. L. van Hintum, and E. A. V. Morales (eds.), Core collections of plant genetic resources. Wiley, West Sussex, England. Shen, L., B. Courtois, K. L. McNally, S. Robin, and Z. Li. 2001. Evaluation of near-isogenic lines of rice introgressed with QTLs for root depth through marker-aided selection. Theor. Appl. Genet. 103:75–83. Shen, Y. W., Z. Q. Guan, J. Lu, J. Y. Zhuang, K. L. Zheng, M. W. Gao, and X. M. Wang. 1998. Linkage analysis of a fertility restoring mutant generated from CMS rice. Theor. Appl. Genet. 97:261–266. Shen, Z., and Y. Xu. 1992. Genetic analysis for hybrid sterility of intersubspecific crosses in rice. Chinese J. Rice Sci. 6:105–112. Shi, M. S. 1981. Preliminary report of later japonica natural 2-lines and applications. Hubei Agr. Sci. (7):1–3. Shull, G. H. 1908. The composition of a field of maize. Am. Breed. Assoc. 4:296–301. Simmonds, N. W. 1979. Principles of crop improvement. Longman, London. Sisco, P. H. 1991. Duplications complicate genetic mapping of Rf4, a restorer gene for cmsC cytoplasmic male sterility in corn. Crop Sci. 31:1261–1266. Smith, J. S. C. 1986. Genetic diversity within the corn belt dent racial complex of maize (Zea mays L.). Maydica 21:349–367. Smith, O. S., J. S. C. Smith, S. L. Bowen, R. A. Tenborg, and S. J. Wall. 1990. Similarities among a group of elite maize inbreds as measured by pedigree, F1 grain yield, grain yield heterosis, and RFLPs. Theor. Appl. Genet. 80:833–840. Smith, S., and T. Helentjaris. 1996. DNA fingerprinting and plant variety protection. p. 95–110. In: A. H. Paterson (ed.), Genome mapping in plants. R. G. Landes Company, Austin, TX. Sorrells, M. E., and W. A. Wilson. 1997. Direct classification and selection of superior alleles for crop improvement. Crop Sci. 37:691–697. Stebbins, G. L. 1957. Self fertilization and population variability in the higher plants. Am. Nat. 91:337–354. Stebbins, G. L. 1970. Adaptive radiation of reproductive characteristics in angiosperms: I. Pollination mechanisms. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 1:307–326. Stoyanova, S. D. 1991. Genetic shifts and variations of gliadins induced by seed aging. Seed Sci. Technol. 19:363–371. Stuber, C. W. 1994. Heterosis in plant breeding. Plant Breed. Rev. 12:227–251. Stuber, C. W. 1995. Mapping and manipulating quantitative traits in maize. Trend. Genet. 11:477–481. Stuber, C. W., S. E. Lincoln, D. W. Wolff, T. Helentjaris, and E. S. Lander. 1992. Identification of genetic factors contributing to heterosis in a hybrid from two elite maize inbred lines using molecular markers. Genetics 132:823–839.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
169
Stuber, C. W., M. Polacco, and M. L. Senior. 1999. Synergy of empirical breeding, markerassisted selection, and genomics to increase crop yield potential. Crop Sci. 39:1571–1583. Subudhi, P. K., R. P. Borkakati, S. S. Virmani, and N. Huang. 1997. Molecular mapping of a thermosensitive genetic male sterility gene in rice using bulked segregant analysis. Genome 40:188–194. Suh, H. S., D. S. Lee, L. Chen, and S. J. Kim. 2002. Hybrid rice seed production using herbicide-resistance GMS lines. p. 48. In: Abstr. Fourth Intl. Symp. Hybrid Rice, 14–17 May 2002, Hanoi, Vietnam. Sun, Q. X., T. C. Huang, Z. F. Ni, and D. J. Procunier. 1996. Studies on heterotic grouping in wheat: I. Genetic diversity between varieties revealed by RAPD. J. Agr. Biotech. (China) 4:103–110. Sun, Q. X., Z. F. Ni, X. Y. Chen, Z. Y. Liu, and T. C. Huang. 1997. Partial genome heterosis in winter wheat. J. China Agr. Univ. 2:64, 116. Takahashi, Y., A. Shomura, T. Sasaki, and M. Yano. 2001. Hd6, a rice quantitative trait locus involved in photoperiod sensitivity, encodes the alpha subunit of protein kinase CK2. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA) 98:7922–7927. Tan, X. L., A. Vanavichit, S. Amornsilpa, and S. Trangoonrung. 1998. Genetic analysis of rice CMS-WA fertility restoration based on QTL mapping. Theor. Appl. Genet. 96:994–999. Tan, Y. F., J. X. Li, S. B. Yu, Y. Z. Xing, C. G. Xu, and Q. Zhang. 1999. The three important traits for cooking and eating quality of rice grain are controlled by a single locus in an elite rice hybrid, Shanyou 63. Theor. Appl. Genet. 99:642–648. Tanksley, S. D. 1993. Mapping polygenes. Annu. Rev. Genet. 27:205–233. Tanksley, S. D., and S. R. McCouch. 1997. Seed banks and molecular maps: unlocking genetic potential from the wild. Science 277:1063–1066. Tanksley, S. D., and J. C. Nelson. 1996. Advanced backcross QTL analysis: a method for the simultaneous discovery and transfer of valuable QTLs from unadapted germplasm into elite breeding lines. Theor. Appl. Genet. 92:191–203. Tanksley, S. D., and C. M. Rick. 1980. Isozyme gene linkage map of the tomato: applications in genetics and breeding. Theor. Appl. Genet. 57:161–170. Tanksley, S. D., N. D. Young, A. H. Paterson, and M. W. Bonierbale. 1989. RFLP mapping in plant breeding: new tools for an old science. Bio/Technology 7:257–263. Temnykh, S., W. D. Park, N. Ayres, S. Cartinhour, N. Hauck, L. Lipovich, Y. G. Cho, T. Ishii, and S. R. McCouch. 2000. Mapping and genome organization of microsatellite sequences in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 100:697–712. Thomson, M. J., T. H. Tai, A. M. McClung, M. E. Hinga, K. B. Lobos, Y. Xu, C. Martinez, and S. R. McCouch. 2003. Mapping quantitative trait loci for yield, yield components, and morphological traits in an advanced backcross population between Oryza rufipogon and the Oryza sativa cultivar Jefferson. Theor. Appl. Genet. (in press). Tomes, D. T. 1998. Heterosis: performance stability, adaptability to changing technology, and the foundation of agriculture as a business. p. 13–27. In: K. R. Lamkey and J. E. Staub (eds.), Concepts and breeding of heterosis in crop plants. CSSA, Madison, WI. Tsaftaris, A. S., M. Kafka, A. Polidoros, and E. Tani. 1999. Epigenetic changes in maize DNA and heterosis. p. 195–203. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. van Hintum, Th. J. L. 1995. Hierarchical approaches to the analysis of genetic diversity in crop plants. p. 23–34. In: T. Hodgkin, A. H. D. Brown, Th. J. L. van Hintum, and E. A. V. Morales (eds.), Core collections of plant genetic resources. Wiley, West Sussex, England.
170
Y. XU
Vasal, S. K., H. Cordova, S. Pandey, and S. Srinivasan. 1999. Tropical maize and heterosis. p. 363–373. In: J. G. Coors and S. Pandey (eds.), Genetics and exploitation of heterosis in crops. ASA-CSSA-SSSA, Madison, WI. Vear, F., and J. F. Miller. 1993. Sunflower. p. 95–111. In: Traditional crop breeding practices: an historical review to serve as a baseline for assessing the role of modern biotechnology. OEDC, Paris, France. Virmani, S. S. 1996. Hybrid rice. Adv. Agron. 57:377–462. Virmani, S. S. 2002. Advances in hybrid rice research and development in the tropics. p. 4. In: Abstr. Fourth Intl. Symp. Hybrid Rice, 14–17 May 2002, Hanoi, Vietnam. Virmani, S. S., and P. C. Voc. 1991. Induction of photo- and thermo-sensitive male sterility in indica rice. Agron. Abst. 119. Virmani, S. S., and F. U. Zaman. 1998. Improving grain quality of hybrid rice: challenges, strategies, and achievements. p. 177–186. In: S. S. Virmani, E. A. Siddiq, and K. Muralidharan (eds.), Advances in hybrid rice technology. Proc. Third Intl. Symp. Hybrid Rice, 14–16 Nov. 1996, Hyderabad, India. International Rice Research Institute, Manila, Philippines. Vuylsteke, M., M. Kuiper, and P. Stam. 2000. Chromosomal regions involved in hybrid performance and heterosis: their AFLP®-based identification and practical uses in prediction models. Heredity 85:208–218. Walsh, B. 2004. Population- and quantitative-genetic models of selection limits. Plant Breed. Rev. 24 (in press). Wan, J. M., S. Yanagihara, H. Kato, and H. Ikehashi. 1993. Multiple alleles at a new locus causing hybrid sterility between Korean indica variety and a javanica variety in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Japan. J. Breed. 43:507–516. Wang, B., W. W. Xu, J. Z. Wang, W. Wu, H. G. Zheng, Z. Y. Yang, J. D. Ray, and H. T. Nguyen. 1995. Tagging and mapping in the thermosensitive genic male sterility gene in rice (Oryza sativa) with molecular markers. Theor. Appl. Genet. 91:1111–1114. Wang, J., Y. Xu, and Z. Shen. 1991. Exploring the major restrains to the utilization of Indica-Japonica hybrids in rice. Scientia Agr. Sinica 24(1):27–33. Wang, J., K. D. Liu, C. G. Xu, X. H. Li, and Q. Zhang. 1998. The high level of widecompatibility of variety ‘Dular’ has a complex genetic basis. Theor. Appl. Genet. 97:407–412. Wen, L., H. V. Tang, W. Chen, R. Chang, D. R. Pring, P. E. Klein, K. L. Childs, and R. R. Klein. 2002. Development and mapping of AFLP markers linked to the sorghum fertility restorer gene rf4. Theor. Appl. Genet. 104:577–585. Wenzel, W. G., and A. J. Pretorius. 2000. Heterosis and xenia in sorghum malt quality. South-African J. Plant Soil 17(2):66–69. Wilson, J. A. 1968. Problems in hybrid wheat breeding. Euphytica 17 (Suppl. 1):13–33. Wilson, J. H. 1979. Rice in California. Butte County Rice Growers Association. Wilson, P., and C. J. Driscoll. 1983. Hybrid wheat. p. 94–123. In: R. Frankel (ed.), Monographs on theoretical and applied genetics, Vol. 6, Heterosis. Springer-Verlag, Berlin and Heidelberg. Wise, R. P., and P. S. Schnable. 1994. Mapping complementary genes in maize: positioning the rf1 and rf2 nuclear-fertility restorer loci of Texas (T) cytoplasm relative to RFLP and visible markers. Theor. Appl. Genet. 88:785–795. Wise, R. P., K. Gobelman-Werner, D. Pei, C. L. Dill, and P. S. Schnable. 1999. Mitochondrial transcript processing and restoration of male fertility in T-cytoplasm maize. J. Hered. 90:380–385. Wu, M. S., S. C. Wang, and J. R. Dai. 2000. Application of AFLP markers to heterotic grouping of elite maize inbred lines. Acta Agron. Sinica 26:9–13.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
171
Wu, X. J., H. Q. Yin, and H. Yin. 1991. Preliminary study of the temperature effect on Annong S-1 and W6154S. Crop Res. (China) 5(2):4–6. Xiao, J., J. Li, L. Yuan, and S. D. Tanksley. 1995. Dominance is the major genetic basis of heterosis in rice as revealed by QTL analysis using molecular markers. Genetics 140:745–754. Xiao, J., J. Li, L. Yuan, S. R. McCouch, and S. D. Tanksley. 1996a. Genetic diversity and its relationship to hybrid performance and heterosis in rice as revealed by PCR-based markers. Theor. Appl. Genet. 92:637–643. Xiao, J., J. Li, L. Yuan, and S. D. Tanksley. 1996b. Identification of QTLs affecting traits of agronomic importance in a recombinant inbred population derived from a subspecific rice cross. Theor. Appl. Genet. 92:230–244. Xiao, J., L. Li, S. Grandillo, L. Yuan, S. D. Tanksley, and S. R. McCouch. 1998. Identification of trait-improving quantitative trait loci alleles from a wild rice relative, Oryza rufipogon. Genetics 150:899–909. Xu, Y. 1992. Molecular markers in quantitative trait locus mapping. Hereditas (Beijing) 14(2):45–48. Xu, Y. 1994. Application of molecular markers in genetic improvement of quantitative traits in plants. p. 38–49. In: Proc. Third Young Scientists Symp. Crop Genetics and Breeding. Publ. House of Agricultural Science and Technology of China, Beijing, China. Xu, Y. 1997. Quantitative trait loci: separating, pyramiding, and cloning. Plant Breed. Rev. 15:85–139. Xu, Y. 2002. Global view of QTL: Rice as a model. p. 109–134. In: M. S. Kang (ed.), Quantitative genetics, genomics and plant breeding. CAB International, Wallingford, UK. Xu, Y., H. M. Beachell, R. Dilday, and S. R. McCouch. 1997a. A genome-wide view of rice germplasm. Plant and Animal Genome V, Poster 62. Xu, Y., H. M. Beachell, and S. R. McCouch. 1997b. Genetic diversity of 256 rice germplasm accessions revealed by microsatellite and RFLP markers. General Meeting Intl. Program on Rice Biotechnol., Sept. 15–19, 1997, Malacca, Malaysia. Xu, Y., H. Beachell, and S. R. McCouch. 2004. A marker-based approach to broadening the genetic base of rice (Oryza sativa L.) in the U.S. Crop Sci. (in press) Xu, Y., K. B. Lobos, and K. M. Clare. 2002. Development of SSR markers for rice molecular breeding. p. 49. In: Proc. Twenty-Ninth Rice Technical Working Group Meeting, February 24–27, 2002. Little Rock, AR. Xu, Y., and L. Luo. 2002. Biotechnology and germplasm resource management in rice. p. 229–250. In: L. Luo, C. Ying, and S. Tang (eds.), Rice germplasm resources. Hubei Sci. Tech. Publisher, Wuhan, China. Xu, Y., S. R. McCouch, and Z. Shen. 1998. Transgressive segregation of tiller angle in rice caused by complementary action of genes. Crop Sci. 38:12–19. Xu, Y., and Z. Shen. 1987. Inheritance of stigma exertion in rice. Rice Genet. Newsl. 4:76–78. Xu, Y., and Z. Shen. 1988a. Receptivity of exerted stigma. Intl. Rice Res. Newsl. 13(3):7–8. Xu, Y., and Z. Shen. 1988b. Maternal effect on chalkiness in rice kernels. Rice Genet. Newsl. 5:111–113. Xu, Y., and Z. Shen. 1988c. Study on improving percentage of cross-pollination in rice. II. Inheritance of stigma exertion and development of exerted stigma in Oryza sativa L. Acta Agr. Univ. Zhejiangensis 14:66–70. Xu, Y., and Z. Shen. 1992. Detection and genetic analyses of the gene dispersed crosses: Some theoretical considerations. Acta Agr. Univ. Zhejiangensis 18:109–117 (in English with Chinese abstr.). Xu, Y., Z. Shen, C. Ying, and Z. Yang. 1988. Variation in stigma exertion in rice. Intl. Rice Res. Newsl. 13(3):6–7.
172
Y. XU
Xu, Y., J. Wang, and Z. Shen. 1989. Screening indica and japonica varieties for wide compatibility. Intl. Rice Res. Newsl. 14(5):6–7. Xu, Y., and L. Zhu. 1994. Molecular quantitative genetics (in Chinese). China Agr. Press, Beijing. Xu, Y., L. Zhu, Y. Chen, C. Lu, L. Shen, P. He, and S. R. McCouch. 1997c. Tagging genes for photo-thermo sensitivity in rice using RFLP and microsatellite markers. Plant and Animal Genome V, Poster 149. Yamaguchi, Y., R. Ikeda, H. Hirasawa, M. Minami, and P. Ujihara. 1997. Linkage analysis of thermosensitive genic male sterility gene, tms-2 in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Breed. Sci. 47:371–373. Yanagihara, S., H. Kato, and H. Ikehashi. 1992. A new locus for multiple alleles causing hybrid sterility between an aus variety and javanica varieties in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Japan. J. Breed. 42:793–801. Yanagihara, S., S. R. McCouch, K. Ishikawa, Y. Ogi , K. Maruyama, and H. Ikehashi. 1995. Molecular analysis of the inheritance of the S-5 locus, conferring wide compatibility in indica/japonica hybrids of rice (Oryza sativa L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 90:182–188. Yang, G. P., M. A. Saghai Maroof, C. G. Xu, Q. Zhang, and R. M. Biyashev. 1994. Comparative analysis of microsatellite DNA polymorphism in landraces and cultivars of rice. Mol. Gen. Genet. 245:187–194. Yang, R. C., W. M. Li, N. Y. Wang, K. J. Liang, and Q. H. Chen. 1989. Discovery and preliminary study on indica photosensitive genic male sterile germplasm 5460s. Chinese J. Rice Sci. 3:47–48. Yano, M., Y. Harushima, Y. Nagamura, N. Kurata, Y. Minobe, and T. Sasaki. 1997. Identification of quantitative trait loci controlling heading date in rice using a high-density linkage map. Theor. Appl. Genet. 95:1025–1032. Yano, M., Y. Katayose, M. Ashikari, U. Yamanouchi, L. Monna, T. Fuse, T. Baba, K. Yamamoto, Y. Umehara, Y. Nagamura, and T. Sasaki. 2000. Hd1, a major photoperiod sensitivity quantitative trait locus in rice, is closely related to the Arabidopsis flowering time gene CONSTANS. Plant Cell 12:2473–2483. Yao, F. Y., C. G. Xu, S. B. Yu, J. X. Li, Y. J. Gao, X. H. Li, and Q. Zhang. 1997. Mapping and genetic analysis of two fertility restorer loci in the wild-abortive cytoplasmic male sterility system of rice (Oryza sativa L.). Euphytica 98:183–187. Yoo, B. H. 1980. Long-term selection for a quantitative character in large replicate populations of Drosophila melanogaster. I. Response to selection. Genet. Res. 35:1–17. Young, N. D. 1999. A cautiously optimistic vision for marker-assisted breeding. Mol. Breed. 5:505–510. Yousef, G. G., and J. A. Juvik. 2001. Comparison of phenotypic and marker-assisted selection for quantitative traits in sweet corn. Crop Sci. 41:645–655. Yu, K., S. J. Park, and V. Poysa. 2000. Marker-assisted selection of common beans for resistance to common bacterial blight. Plant. Breed. 119:411–415. Yu, S. B., J. X. Li, C. G. Xu, Y. F. Tan, Y. J. Gao, X. H. Li, Q. F. Zhang, and M. A. Saghai Maroof. 1997. Importance of epistasis as the genetic basis of heterosis in an elite rice hybrid. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. (USA). 94:9226–9231. Yuan, L. P. 1987. Strategy conception of hybrid rice breeding. Hybrid Rice (1):1–4. Yuan, L. P. 1992a. Development and prospects of hybrid rice breeding. p. 97–105. In: C. B. You and Z. L. Chen (eds.), Agricultural biotechnology. Proc. Asian Pacific Conf. Agric. Biotech., China Agr. Press, Beijing. Yuan, L. P. 1992b. The strategy of breeding rice PGMS and TGMS lines. Hybrid Rice (1):1–4. Yuan, L. P. 2002. Future outlook on hybrid rice research and development. p. 3. In: Abstract of the Fourth International Symposium on Hybrid Rice, 14–17 May 2002, Hanoi, Vietnam.
3. MARKER-ASSISTED SELECTION STRATEGIES FOR BREEDING HYBRID RICE
173
Yuan, L. P., and H. X. Chen (eds.). 1988. Breeding and cultivation of hybrid rice. Hunan Science and Technology Press, Changsha, China. Zeng, R., Z. Zhang, and G. Zhang. 2000. Identification of multiple alleles at the Wx locus in rice using microsatellite class and G-T polymorphism. p. 202–205. In: X. Liu. (ed.) Theory and application of crop research. China Science and Technology Press, Beijing. Zhang, G., T. S. Bharaj, Y. Lu, S. S. Virmani, and N. Huang. 1997. Mapping of the Rf-3 nuclear fertility-restoring gene for WA cytoplasmic male sterility in rice using RAPD and RFLP markers. Theor. Appl. Genet. 94:27–33. Zhang, J., R. Chandra Babu, G. Pantuwan, A. Kamoshita, A. Blum, L. Wade, S. Sarkarung, J. C. O’Toole, and H. T. Nguyen. 1999. Molecular dissection of drought tolerance in rice: from physio-morphological traits to field performance. p. 331–343. In: O. Ito, J. O’Toole, and B. Hardy (eds.), Genetic improvement of rice for water-limited environments. Intl. Rice Res. Inst., Manila, Philippines. Zhang, J., Y. Xu, X. Wu, and L. Zhu. 2002. A bentazon and sulfonylurea sensitive mutant: breeding, genetics and potential application in seed production of hybrid rice. Theor. Appl. Genet. 105:16–22. Zhang, Q., Y. J. Gao, M. A. Saghai Maroof, S. H. Yang, and J. X. Li. 1995. Molecular divergence and hybrid performance in rice. Mol. Breed. 1:133–142. Zhang, Q., Y. J. Gao, S. H. Yang, R. A. Ragab, M. A. Saghai Maroof, and Z. B. Li. 1994a. A diallel analysis of heterosis in elite hybrid rice based on RFLPs and microsatellites. Theor. Appl. Genet. 89:185–192. Zhang, Q., J. Hua, S. Yu, L. Xiong, and C. Xu. 2001. Genetic and molecular basis of heterosis in rice. p. 173–185. In: G. S. Khush, D. S. Brar, and B. Hardy (eds.), Rice genetics IV. Proc. Fourth Intl. Rice Genetics Symp., 22–27 Oct. 2000, Los Baños, Philippines. Science Publishers, Inc., New Delhi, India, and Intl. Rice Res. Inst., Los Baños, Philippines. Zhang, Q., and N. Huang. 1998. Mapping and molecular marker-based genetic analysis for efficient hybrid rice breeding. p. 243–256. In: S. S. Virmani, E. A. Siddiq, and K. Muralidharan (eds.), Advances in hybrid rice technology. Proc. Third Intl. Symp. Hybrid Rice, 14–16 Nov. 1996, Hyderabad, India. Intl. Rice Res. Inst., Manila, Philippines. Zhang, Q., and Z. Li. 2002. Advances in understanding the genetic basis of heterosis in rice. p. 11. In: Abstr. Fourth Intl. Symp. Hybrid Rice, 14–17 May 2002, Hanoi, Vietnam. Zhang, Q., M. A. Saghai Maroof, T. Y. Lu, and B. Z. Shen. 1992. Genetic diversity and differentiation of indica and japonica rice detected by RFLP analysis. Theor. Appl. Genet. 83:495–499. Zhang, Q., B. Z. Shen, X. K. Dai, M. H. Mei, M. A. Saghai Maroof, and Z. B. Li. 1994b. Using bulked extremes and recessive class to map genes for photoperiod-sensitive genic male sterility in rice. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA) 91:8675–8679. Zhang, S. Q., H. H. Tong, R. Xue, Z. H. Hua, X. L. Wang, D. L. Huang, and X. B. Xie. 1998. Tests on improving purity in hybrid rice seed production by introducing bar gene to restorers. Scientia Agr. Sinica 31(6):33–37. Zhao, M. F., X. H. Li, J. B. Yang, C. G. Xu, R. Y. Hu, D. J. Liu, and Q. Zhang. 1999. Relationships between molecular marker heterozygosity and hybrid performance in intraand inter-subspecific crosses of rice. Plant Breed. 118:139–144. Zheng, K., H. Qian, B. Shen, J. Zhuang, H. Liu, and J. Lu. 1994. RFLP-based phylogenetic analysis of wide compatibility varieties in Oryza sativa L. Theor. Appl. Genet. 88:65–69. Zheng, K., P. Shen, H. Qian, and J. Wang. 1992. Tagging genes for wide compatibility in rice via linkage to RFLP markers. Chinese J. Rice Sci. 6:145–150. Zhou, T. B., H. C. Xiao, D. Y. Lei, and Q. X. Duan. 1988. The breeding of indica photosensitive male sterile line. J. Hunan Agr. Sci. (6):16–18. Zhu, L., C. Lu, P. Li, L. Shen, Y. Xu, P. He, and Y. Chen. 1996. Using doubled haploid populations of rice for quantitative trait locus mapping. p. 631–636. In: Rice genetics III.
174
Y. XU
Proc. Third Intl. Rice Genetics Symp., 16–20 Oct. 1995, Manila, Philippines. Intl. Rice Res. Inst., Manila, Philippines. Zhu, Z. F., C. Q. Sun, T. B. Jiang, Q. Fu, and X. K. Wang. 2001. The comparison of genetic divergences and its relationships to heterosis revealed by SSR and RFLP markers in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Acta Genetica Sinica 28:738–745.
4 Significance of Cytoplasmic DNA in Plant Breeding Ursula Frei, Edmundo G. Peiretti, and Gerhard Wenzel Department of Agronomy and Plant Breeding, Center for Life and Food Sciences, Technical University of Munich D-85350 Freising-Weihenstephan, Germany
I. INTRODUCTION II. SOME BASIC INFORMATION ON DNA IN THE CYTOPLASM OF PLANTS III. AGRONOMIC TRAITS INFLUENCED BY CYTOPLASMIC FACTORS A. Cytoplasmic Male Sterility (CMS) B. Yield and Quality Parameters C. Disease Resistance D. Tissue Culture Responses and Regeneration E. Combining Ability IV. BREEDING USING CYTOPLASMIC FACTORS A. Characterization of Plant Material 1. Potato 2. Maize 3. Rice 4. Wheat 5. Amaranth B. Creating New Variability 1. Undirected Processes 2. Directed Alterations by Plasmone Transformations C. Selection 1. Correlation of Phenotype and Cytoplasm 2. Somatic Recombination V. CONCLUSION LITERATURE CITED
Plant Breeding Reviews, Volume 23, Edited by Jules Janick ISBN 0-471-35421-X © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 175
176
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
I. INTRODUCTION Genomics, proteomics, and most recently, metabolomics are fashionable tools in plant genetics. Most of this research concentrates in plant breeding on genetic information of the cell nucleus, the genomic DNA (Lübberstedt et al. 2002). Although the nucleus is the main organelle where genetic information is active, additional DNA is found in the cytoplasm as plasmone. This non-nuclear, plasmone DNA is located as plastome in plastids (ptDNA) and as chondriome in mitochondria (mtDNA). The size of these organelle DNA is small compared to the genomic DNA: only about 200 kb per plastid and up to 2500 kb per mitochondrion. However, the small amount of organelle DNA has to be multiplied by the number of organelles per cell, up to 100 in the case of plastids and several hundred in the case of mitochondria, and thus the non-nuclear DNA cannot be neglected when estimating the inheritance of specific traits. Nevertheless, in plant breeding programs, the importance of genetic information about mitochondria and chloroplasts is often ignored or excluded in studies of DNA polymorphisms and their correlation to phenotypes. Influences of the genetic information of the cytoplasm are normally detected via reciprocal crosses, since, in general, cytoplasmic genes are only inherited maternally. This does not mean, however, that microspores do not contain plastids or mitochondria; the regeneration of functional plants from isolated microspores during androgenetic haploid production proves their presence. Thus, the situation of a uniparental inheritance, which is a strong indication of the presence of plasmone DNA, needs an additional explanation. It is assumed that the plastids and mitochondria are stripped off of the sperm nucleus during the process of fertilization, and consequently they are not transmitted into the zygote (Hagemann 2002). Maternal inheritance was described for variegated leaf color in Pelargonium zonale at the beginning of the last century (Baur 1909). The genetic basis of this phenomenon could not be explained at that time, but today we know that eucaryotic plant cells contain ptDNA and mtDNA that interact with the nuclear genetic information and interact with each other (Hedtke et al. 1999; Comai 2000; Herrmann et al. 2003). They contribute in cell metabolism to photosynthesis and respiration. Furthermore, cytoplasmic genes contribute to the operation of the sexual reproductive systems and to the differentiation and evolution of plant species, including maize and teosinte (Poggio et al. 1997), potato (Hosaka and Hanneman 1988), rubber tree (Luo et al. 1995), soybean (Xu et al. 2002), and wheat (Vedel et al. 1978; Wang et al. 2000). Thus, mitochondria and chloroplasts represent a source of genetic diversity, as they contain DNA and the machinery to express that information as RNA and,
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
177
after RNA editing and tRNA import, by their own translation system, as proteins (Stern et al. 1997; Steinhauser et al. 1999; Yamaguchi and Knoblauch 2000; Bock 2001). The expression of plastid genes may be enhanced under light and may show tissue specificity that leads to increased protein production in chloroplasts of photosynthetically active tissues (Bruik and Mayfield 1999). This review will summarize which agronomic traits are influenced by cytoplasmic factors or nuclear-cytoplasmic and/or organelle interaction and where knowledge about cytoplasmic DNA is ready to be considered in breeding programs. A first area in cytoplasm research was the production and use of alloplasmic lines by combination breeding, where by successive backcrossing of two parents the cytoplasm of one is changed. A second tool was provided by the field of somatic cell fusion, circumventing uniparental inheritance and permitting complete combination of cytoplasms (Hanson and Folkerts 1992; Lössl et al. 1994). The third application is opened up by direct transfer of genes into organelles, resulting in the case of plastids in transplastomic plants. Most present knowledge has been driven by the applied goals of hybrid breeding, and consequently much of the available information is based on trials to understand and subsequently to use the mitochondrial trait of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS). Before discussing applied approaches, some basic information will be summarized. II. SOME BASIC INFORMATION ON DNA IN THE CYTOPLASM OF PLANTS Most basic information on the plasmone structure is published for mitochondria of microorganisms and animals, a substantial part of which can, however, be applied to plant organelles (Scheffler 1999). With the very first analyses of ptDNA, it became evident that plastids and eubacterial genomes are related (Schwarz and Kössel 1979). According to the endosymbiont hypothesis, plastids originated from cyanobacteria, whereas it has been suggested that the ancestors of mitochondria were eubacteria (Gray et al. 1999), and thus research on microorganisms offers a lot of information about higher plant plasmones. Substantial basic plant knowledge has been gained from model plants such as tobacco or Arabidopsis (Abdallah et al. 2000; Barkan and Goldschmidt-Clermont 2000; Lim et al. 2000); and transfer of these findings to crop plants has started. Reviews of the physical structure, information content, RNA editing, and interaction with the nucleus are given for plant mitochondria by Knoop and Brennicke (2002) and for plastids by Bock and Hippler (2002). Using molecular tools, research on non-nuclear DNA of higher plants resulted in sequencing of the DNA from maize mitochondria (Lonsdale
178
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
et al. 1984), from tobacco (Shinozaki et al. 1986), and recently from wheat chloroplasts (Ogihara et al. 2002). A first rather simple and descriptive use of information deduced from organelle sequencing shows the genetic diversity of pt and mtDNA. Polymorphisms of plasmone DNA could be used to elucidate phylogenetic relationships of crops such as Zea (Timothy et al. 1979), Hordeum (Neale et al. 1986), Triticum and Aegilops (Breiman 1987), Theobroma (Laurent et al. 1993), Hevea (Luo et al. 1995), pines (Powell et al. 1995), Coffea (OrozcoCastillo et al. 1996), Allium (Friesen et al. 1999), Solanum (Bryan et al. 1999), rice (Sun et al. 2002), or soybean (Xu et al. 2002). For the breeder, such information about the genetic diversity of the plasmone is a helpful addition to the characterization of nuclear genomes, and thus helps in parent selection. By comparing two fully sequenced ptDNAs, in this particular case Atropa and Nicotiana plastomes, Schmitz-Linneweber et al. (2002) found that promoters and translational and replicational signals are well conserved between the two species. The authors concluded that pt-genes are even more conserved, but RNA editotypes differ between species, which makes RNA editing a major trait in speciation. This may have a substantial effect on plant fitness via protein function. The mtDNA of higher plants has a large coding capacity and encodes, in addition to the standard set, for the five mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes, and for additional proteins like cytochrome c oxidase or the α subunit of ATPase. The model plant Arabidopsis has 57 mtgenes, and the gene number varies between species (Scheffler 1999). Mitochondrial DNA is constantly reorganized, probably by an own recombination system. In order to account for the structural rearrangements, the presence of repeated sequences in direct or inverted orientation has been noted. Since the DNA is circular, two direct repeats at some distance in the master circle will yield two subgenomic circles. Recombination between a subgenomic circle and the master circle can give rise by homologous recombination to larger circles with duplications, permuting the mt-genome without mutating the coding regions and ending up in a wide variability. In contrast to this variability, sequences of individual genes are remarkably constant. The mtDNA has captured genes encoded in the nucleus, suffers mutations that can effect growth and sterility, and yields transcripts that have to be edited, or trans-spliced, but lack a subset of tRNAs that have to be imported from the cytoplasm (Herrmann 1992; Scheffler 1999). The synthesis of mRNA from the ptDNA in tobacco and its in vitro translation provided the final proof for pt-protein synthesis, though one interdependent with the nucleus (Hirose and Sugiura 1997). Since it is possible to transform chloroplasts of higher plants (Svab et al. 1990), the ptDNA can be engineered to permit study of even those steps in gene
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
179
expression for which no in vitro systems are currently available. In addition, plastid transformation technology has allowed the functional characterization of ptDNA-encoded open reading frames (orf) by reverse genetics (Ruf et al. 1997), and by the use of plastome mutants (Bock and Hippler 2002). This research on the pt-genome is still of an experimental nature, mostly done on model plants, but, in the view of the potential environmental concerns of nuclear genetic engineering, pt- or mt-transformation can help to create a strong barrier against undesired vertical gene transfer via pollen (Daniell 2002). Consequently, this research will increasingly be applied to important crop species. Although mitochondria and plastids retain a semiautonomous status, they depend heavily for their biogenesis and function on interaction with the nucleus (Herrmann 1992; Gray et al. 1999). Interaction between the nucleus and the cytoplasm has been well studied in several crops, such as Beta (Samitou-Laparde et al. 1991), Brassica (Gourret et al. 1992), Helianthus (Moneger et al. 1994), Oryza (Ishii et al. 1993), Pennisetum (Virk and Brar 1993), Solanum (Hosaka 1995), Triticum (Terachi and Tsunewaki 1992), and Zea (Rocheford and Pring 1994). Cytoplasms of Triticum species and related genera differ with regard to the effects on the expression and interaction of nuclear genes. The cytoplasmic diversity detected within a series of distantly related varieties seems to correspond to their nuclear divergence. This predicts that nuclear-cytoplasmic interactions should not be neglected when interpreting a phenotypic segregation in a breeding program. The first experiments to test the nuclear-organelle interaction were carried out with microorganisms. In yeast, for example, a large number of nuclear genes have been identified that influence, for example, the respiratory chain or oxidative phosphorylation system of mitochondria (Scheffler 1999). The interaction is either by transcriptional regulation or post-transcriptional and affects mRNA processing and the stability of translation (Grivell 1995). In the meantime, these findings could be verified for higher plants, and it became quite clear that organelles may also control the nuclear gene expression, as shown for chloroplasts by Gray et al. (1999). III. AGRONOMIC TRAITS INFLUENCED BY CYTOPLASMIC FACTORS A principal problem in applied reports of cytoplasmic effects on agronomic traits is that many have been evaluated in populations carrying different sources of cytoplasms, or do not differentiate plastome and chondriome. In addition there is the problem of accurately assessing cytoplasmic variation with respect to quantitative agronomic traits
180
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
(Edwards and Coors 1996). Thus, a comparison of the phenotypes of alloplasmic isonuclear lines with different backgrounds in order to evaluate their use for hybrid breeding programs is difficult. Furthermore, a clear distinction of cytoplasmic effects and nuclear-cytoplasmic interactions is complicated, depending on the nuclear genome that is combined with the cytoplasm under evaluation. The differentiation between cytoplasmic types is primarily based on their sterile phenotype controlled by CMS of the mtDNA and the corresponding nuclear restorer system. Less important and obvious are variations of the ptDNA due to differences in chloroplasts or other plastid types. A. Cytoplasmic Male Sterility (CMS) In higher plants, CMS is a maternally inherited defect in pollen production that is thought to result from the expression of unusual or aberrant mt-genes interacting with the nuclear genome (Kaul 1988; Ducos et al. 2001). Various chimeric mitochondrial genes produced by homologous recombination or via protoplast fusion are believed to disturb the mitochondrial function at a critical stage of tapetum development, thus causing male sterility (Hanson and Folkerts 1992; Dragoeva et al. 2001). Laser and Lersten (1972) reviewed cytoplasmic pollen sterility in more than 140 species of 47 genera and 20 families. Although half of the CMS types described occurred naturally, 20% of them were the result of intraspecific crosses, and the rest originated from interspecific crosses (Levings 1990). Several nuclear genes are known to control this expression of CMS and, thus, different CMS types can be distinguished by the specific nuclear genes (rfs) that restore pollen fertility. This nuclear-cytoplasmic system is extensively used in hybrid breeding programs: Currently, great effort is ongoing with the outbreeders, rye and sunflower; the facultative outbreeder, rapeseed; and in the inbreeders, wheat, rice, triticale, barley, and oats. In maize, a specific S-plasmid of the mitochondria can integrate into the mtDNA and causes CMS (Schardl et al. 1985), while in sunflower the PET1 mitochondrial mutation is associated with premature programmed cell death and cytochrome c release (Balk and Leaver 2001). The threat of a disaster such as occurred in Texas (T) cytoplasm of maize indicated a need to broaden the cytoplasmic base (Levings 1990). If no CMS is available in wild relatives of a cultivar, it may be possible to create CMS via recombination of mtDNA. Besides the production of new nuclear-cytoplasmic interactions resulting from sexual production of alloplasmic lines, this can be achieved via cell fusion. After somatic fusion, recombination of mtDNA may take place, making cell fusion also a promising tool for sexually propagated plants such as in rapeseed (Pelletier et al. 1988) or in Nicotiana cybrids (Atanassov et al. 1998), yielding new CMS lines.
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
181
Since the discovery of an induction of complete male sterility in wheat with the G-type cytoplasm of Triticum timopheevi by Wilson and Ross (1962), G-type cytoplasm has been used as a source of male sterility for developing high-yield hybrid cultivars (Wilson 1967). Murai and Tsunewaki (1993) and Ogihara et al. (1999) reported a new CMS system in wheat, namely, photoperiod-sensitive cytoplasmic male sterility. It is induced by interaction between the nuclear genome of common wheat, Triticum aestivum ‘Norin 26’, and the cytoplasm of Aegilops crassa. The alloplasmic line of ‘Norin 26’ with Ae. crassa cytoplasm shows almost complete male sterility, resulting from the pistillate nature of the stamens that develop under long day conditions (15 hr or more of light), but this line is highly male fertile under short-day conditions (<15 hr of light). Ogihara et al. (1999) described this action as a result of the production of a truncated mtDNA gene product (open reading frame, orf 48) under the influence of the euplasmsic mt gene of Ae. crassa and the rps7 gene of wheat. In hybrid triticale programs it appeared difficult to permanently express CMS irrespective of the wheat cytoplasm used. The molecular investigation of genetically well defined lines revealed a nuclear dependence on gene structures as well as transcriptional and posttranscriptional expression in wheat and triticale. Wheat mtDNA exhibits multiple DNA polymorphisms and rearrangements, creating chimeric or truncated open reading frames leading to novel gene copies, for example, of orf25-gene with altered expression profiles (Kueck et al. 1995). B. Yield and Quality Parameters Agronomic traits influenced by cytoplasmic factors, aside from CMS, are summarized in Table 4.1. In most cases, alloplasmic lines were developed in sexual hybrid breeding programs for the seed (CMS) parent. Ekiz et al. (1998) studied different quality traits in bread wheat (Triticum aestivum). They reported small but significant differences between reciprocal crosses of alloplasmic lines for thousand kernel weight (TKG) and protein percentage. The authors emphasized that the behavior of a given cytoplasm may be different in different years and with different nuclei. It was difficult to find cytoplasms that had stable positive effects with all nuclear genotypes in all locations and years. Symmetric somatic hybrids are available for the vegetatively propagated potato (Wenzel 1994). Clones regenerated after protoplast fusion of two parents may have the same fused nuclear genome but varying cytoplasm compositions. Such hybrids are ideal for studying influences on agronomic traits of a broad range of recombined mitochondrial types with one of the two parental chloroplasts and with the background of an unaltered nuclear DNA genome. The investigations of Lössl et al. (1994) concentrate on yield and quality with a strong emphasis on starch production.
Table 4.1.
Agronomic traits influenced by cytoplasmic factors.
Agronomic trait
Species
Regeneration ability
Helianthus annuus
Protoplast culture Phoma macdonaldii
Helianthus annuus Helianthus annuus
Fusarium culmorum Yield parameters Eating, cooking, processing quality GCA
Hordeum vulgare Oryza sativa Oryza sativa
Grain yield, plant height, days to flower Starch content
Pennisetum glaucum
Ustilago tritici resistance Septoria nodorum resistance Anther culture response Stripe rust resistance Tissue culture response Starch B-granule content Anther culture response Rust resistance
Analyzed in
References
Triticum aestivum Triticum aestivum
Alloplasmic lines (diff. CMS sources) Alloplasmic lines Alloplasmic lines (diff. CMS sources) Alloplasmic lines Alloplasmic lines Incomplete diallel (diff. CMS and restorer lines) Alloplasmic lines (diff. CMS sources) Alloplasmic lines (diff. CMS sources) Intraspecific somatic hybrids Alloplasmic lines Alloplasmic lines
Dhitaphichit et al. 1989 Keane and Jones 1990
Triticum aestivum Triticum aestivum Triticum aestivum Triticum aestivum Triticum aestivum Vicia faba
Alloplasmic lines Alloplasmic lines Alloplasmic lines F1, F2, and BC Tritordeum Diallel of F1 hybrids
Hasan and Konzak 1991; Orlov et al. 1997 Chen and Line 1995 Bebeli 1995 Stoddard 2000 Hernandez et al. 2001 Stoddard and Hearth 2001
Pennisetum typhoides
Solanum tuberosum
Nestares et al. 1998 Bolandi et al. 1999 Rousstaee and Barrault 2000 Adamski et al. 1997 Wang et al. 1998 Bao and Xia 1999 Virk and Brar 1993; Yadav 1994 Yadav 1994 Lössl et al. 2000
182
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
183
C. Disease Resistance Disease and pest resistance is the most important breeding goal, since it stabilizes yield and quality. One example for qualitative cytoplasmic resistance is maize: Hybrids with the Texas male sterile cytoplasm (cmsT) are rendered highly susceptible to leaf blight caused by the T-toxins of Bipolaris maydis and Phyllostica maydis. Intensive research is underway to understand this interaction, which at the same time might help to elucidate host pathogen interaction. Associated with cms-T is the unidentified reading frame, URF13 (Levings 1990). The mitochondrial gene T-urf13 codes for three trans-membrane protein helices acting as receptor for the host specific toxin produced by each of the pathogens. Binding of T-toxin to URF13 leads to the formation of hydrophilic pores that permeabilize the inner mitochondrial membrane (Rhoads et al. 1996). By transfer of urf13 into Escherichia coli, this system could be further elucidated. Several chemicals protect E. coli and cms-T mitochondria from the permeability caused by T-toxin. Also, light reduces the leaking of electrolytes and thus has an influence on the sensitivity of cms-T cytoplasm to T-toxin (Garraway et al. 1998). The increasing but still incomplete knowledge about the interaction of a known gene with a known toxin underlines the complexity of a host pathogene interaction. Further examples of quantitative influences of specific male sterile cytoplasms on resistance responses are given in Table 4.1. Stoddard and Hearth (2001) reported on the selection of Vicia faba beans with increased rust resistance within a complete diallel of F1 hybrids. Highly susceptible cytoplasms could be distinguished from resistant ones by the size of the pustule developing on detached leaves. Chen and Line (1995) suggested that there are maternal or cytoplasmic factors that affect stripe rust resistance in wheat, and Keane and Jones (1990) found an effect of alien cytoplasm substitution on the response of wheat cultivars to Septoria nodorum. In sunflower, alloplasmic lines showed significant cytoplasmic effects for improved partial resistance to Phoma macdonaldii (Rousstaee and Barrault 2000). The alien cytoplasm had a positive effect on the resistance in sunflower, while the substitution of the ‘Chinese Spring’ nucleus into the cytoplasm of Aegilops squarrosa, Ae. variabilis, or Ae. mutica resulted in increased susceptibility to Ustilago tritici (Dhitaphichit et al. 1989). It cannot be ruled out that the different reactions are due to an altered interaction between the new nucleus and the Aegilops cytoplasm. Similarly, the finding of Adamski et al. (1997) that, in barley, resistance against Fusarium culmorum decreased when Hordeum vulgare cytoplasm was replaced by H. bulbosum cytoplasm may be an unspecific effect of the new mixture. Fortunately, for haploid
184
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
induction by the parthenogenetic bulbosum method, where the zygote eliminates the paternal chromosomes and results in maternal haploids (Wenzel and Foroughi-Wehr 1994), the paternal cytoplasm is not transferred. Otherwise, increased susceptibility might accompany parthenogenetic haploid induction. D. Tissue Culture Responses and Regeneration In vitro technologies to increase the efficiency of specific breeding steps include rapid propagation, androgenetic haploid induction, cell fusion, and regeneration of cells after gene transfer (Altman 1998). Even under optimized protocols, differences in the success rate among cultivars are common. Regeneration success in microspore culture of potato was achieved by the selection of clones with a high culture response. Transferring this character to progenies by sexual crosses resulted in an increased tissue culture ability of several of the F1 clones (Wenzel and Uhrig 1981; Sonnino et al. 1989). The Mendelian segregation of this trait implicated nuclear origin, but an additional influence of the plasmone during regeneration processes was apparent. Similarly, Hernandez et al. (2001) report on the beneficial influence of specific Triticum cytoplasms on the anther culture response of tritordeum, and cytoplasms from Triticum dicoccum ssp. pseudomacrotherum, T. monococcum ssp. aegilopoides, T. turgidum v. persicum fuliginosum, T. dicoccum v. khapli, and T. turgidum v. turanicum notabile. This may offer useful cytoplasmic genetic variation for enhancing anther culture response in wheat (Hasan and Konzak 1991). Orlov et al. (1997) reported on the positive effects of an interspecific cytoplasm substitution between the five species T. aestivum, T. turgidum, T. durum, T. dicoccum, and T. aetiopicum on different variables evaluated during anther culture (number of responding anthers, and number of embryoids per 100 anthers, number of green and albino regenerants). The cytoplasms of Aegilops umbellulata, Ae. triuncialis, Ae. columnaris, Ae. kotschyi, and Ae. variabilis were found to induce haploid parthenogenesis in common wheat, ‘Salmon’, at relatively high frequencies (Tsunewaki et al. 1974). Cytoplasms also have an effect on immature embryo culture leading to embryogenic suspension cultures, a prerequisite for in vitro regeneration of cereals. Bebeli (1995) compared 21 alloplasmic lines and one euplasmic line of bread wheat having a common nuclear genotype (‘Chinese Spring’ of T. aestivum) with cytoplasm belonging to different Triticum and Aegilops. In comparison to the euplasmic line, the lowest induction rates were observed in the alloplasmic lines having Ae. speltoides, bicornis, and kotschyi cytoplasms, while the best performances were shown by the triuncialis and umbellulata lines.
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
185
A different way to induce haploidy by using cytoplasmic effects was described by Hsam and Zeller (1993). They developed an alloplasmic haploid-inducer in the durum wheat cultivar ‘Cando’, which possesses the homologous wheat-rye translocation 1BL/1RS from the 6x-wheat ‘Veery’. The nucleus of 4x-‘Cando-Veery 1BL/1RS’ was introduced into Ae. kotschyi cytoplasm, and 6% haploids were produced by crossing the alloplasmic durum line with ‘Cando-Veery 1BL/1RS’. The general regeneration ability of sunflower was analyzed in malesterile and male-fertile forms of inbred lines using explants from cotyledons of mature seeds (Nestares et al. 1998). Significant differences were observed between male-sterile and male-fertile forms, indicative of the universal influence of cytoplasmic genes on the cell metabolism. Furthermore, protoplast regeneration is influenced by the plasmone. Bolandi et al. (1999) evaluated the effect of different sunflower cytoplasms on protoplast culture. The complex interactions between the genotypes tested indicated that protoplast culture responses are affected independently by nuclear-cytoplasm interactions. Some nuclear-cytoplasm combinations improved protoplast culture response. E. Combining Ability High general (GCA) and specific combining abilities (SCA) of parental lines are prerequisite to a successful hybrid breeding program. Alien male-sterile cytoplasm introduced in cultivars for efficient hybrid production can influence combining ability both positively and negatively. Yadav (1994) reported such a positive influence of the A1-cytoplasm, an important source of CMS, in pearl millet hybrid breeding on GCA estimated by plant height and grain yield, and a negative influence on days to flowering. Virk and Brar (1993) studied cytoplasmic differences for several agronomic traits in near-isonuclear male-sterile lines in pearl millet. A differential behavior of cytoplasm, in combination with both a common pollinator and a cross pollinator, was observed for yield, plant height, and ear length. Since most plants contain mitochondrial populations in a heteroplasmic state, sorting is a common phenomenon. An unexpected segregation during a selection may be the result of such a dissorting. Combining ability of cytoplasms is of special importance in somatic hybridization. The fusion process combined cytoplasms as well as different nuclei. The differentiation of cytoplasm types in dihaploid potatoes revealed five distinct mitochondrial types (α, β, γ, δ, ε) associated with three chloroplast types T, W, and S (Fig. 4.1). Analyzing symmetric protoplast fusion experiments performed over several years with dihaploid clones derived by chromosome reduction of tetraploid potato cultivars, Frei et al. (1998) calculated the mean hybrid efficiency
186
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
α 38% γ 8% W 48% δ 2% ε 2%
S 2%
β 50%
T 50%
Fig. 4.1. Distribution of cytoplasm types within a pool of dihaploid breeding clones of potato. Inner circle: chloroplast types nomenclature according to Hosaka (1995). Outer circle: mitochondrial types nomenclature according to Frei et al. (1998).
(percentage of hybrids among regenerates) of different cytoplasm combinations (Fig. 4.2). Clear differences in hybrid recovery were demonstrated for some combinations. Since this may be due to competition among mitochondria, to stoichiometric shifting, or even to a new mixture of mitochondria, the observed variability may not easily be reproduced in different genotypes. Hybrid efficiency (%) 40
30
20
10
0
(16)
(26)
(4)
(7)
(15)
(3)
(1)
(1)
(1)
α (+) α α (+) β α (+) γ β (+) β β (+) γ α (+) δ α (+) ε β (+) ε γ (+) δ Cytoplasmic Composition (mt type)
Fig. 4.2. Mean hybrid efficiency (percentage of hybrids among regenerated plants; total number analyzed in brackets) of fusion combinations with different cytoplasm types of the parental fusion clones (Frei et al. 1998).
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
187
IV. BREEDING USING CYTOPLASMIC FACTORS Cytoplasmic factors are obviously important in qualitative traits such as CMS or disease resistance/susceptibility. However, the contribution of cytoplasmic factors to quantitative agronomic traits is probably of minor significance. Nevertheless, in order to further enhance the performance of cultivars, plant breeders can exploit such minor effects. They should be considered in order (1) to characterize variability, (2) to use or generate variability by recombination, and (3) to select favorable genotypes. The following section emphasizes the degree of integration of cytoplasm research into breeding crop plants. A. Characterization of Plant Material There are several approaches that can be used to understand the role variability in cytoplasmic genomes plays in phylogenetic studies. Misleading results occur when the investigated species is crossed with an unidentified pollen parent, even if only evolutionary pathways derived from the seed parent are analyzed. The molecular basis of the genetic variability of cytoplasms has revealed greater variability of mitochondrial genomes compared to chloroplast genomes, and an interdependence between both organelles (Newton 1988; Samitou-Laparde et al. 1991). In all cases, the specific effects of the independent organelles and nuclei are difficult to estimate due to their interactions. Differentiation of cytoplasmic types, in addition to male sterility influences, is a prerequisite for efficient breeding work. Development of molecular marker techniques based on DNA polymorphisms in the organelle genomes may facilitate parent selection. However, it should always be taken into consideration that the mt-genome is very dynamic and consequently such polymorphisms may not be stable. If a breeding program is initiated with a neglected crop, such as amaranth, reproducible classification of the starting material is essential. This classification should not be restricted to the nuclear genome but include the plasmone, since the additional knowledge will help to optimize breeding strategies. 1. Potato. The origin of the cultivated tetraploid potato was traced via plasmones, predominantly ptDNA, information as well as by genetic relationships among cultivars (Hosaka and Hanneman 1988; Hosaka 1995). Lössl et al. (1999) characterized different mitochondrial types in 100 dihaploid and 144 tetraploid potato clones (Fig. 4.1). Based on reproducible RFLP patterns using 11 homologous mtDNA probes, five distinct classes (α, β, γ, δ, and ε) of mtDNA were separated. A dendrogram showing the relationship of wild potato species and primitive cultivars based on mitochondria descent is shown in Fig. 4.3. This
188
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
Rescaled Distance Cluster Combine CASE
0
5
10
15
20
25
Beta tuberosum berthaulthii poloytrichon verrucosum Gamma
gourlayi traijense stoloniferum Alpha demissum acaule sparsipilum
goniocalix andigena phureja maglia multidissectum curtilobum ajanhuiri chauca Epsilon megistacrolobum
capsibaccatum circaefolium brevidens gibberulosum spegazinii vernei microdontum kutzianum Delta chacoense bulbocastanum Fig. 4.3. Dendrogram with genetic distances between different Solanum mtDNAs (Lössl et al. 1999).
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
189
type of information can be used to select distantly related parents for sexual and somatic combinations. 2. Maize. Molecular probes are increasingly used for characterization of inbred lines of maize. Peiretti (2003) evaluated the plasmone of 30 dent and 32 flint lines using 23 mt-probes, and found clear polymorphisms. A genetic distance analysis revealed three clusters. The majority of lines of one cluster were flint types, and the majority of lines of another were dents. Only a smaller, third cluster, more distant from the other two, contained lines of both. RFLP analysis of nuclear genomes using the same genotypes gave a corresponding classification (Messmer et al. 1992, 1993). Since mt-probes result in simpler restriction patterns, they offer an easier system for the characterization of inbred line diversity for applied use. 3. Rice. Cytoplasmic variability of cultivated rice species, Oryza sativa and O. glaberrima (Ishii et al. 1993) indicates high conservation of pt- and mt-genomes. Lin (1992) performed pedigree analyses to quantify the ancestral contributions to 27 rice cultivars released at IRRI and to estimate the coefficients of parentage among them. One ancestor was the ultimate cytoplasmic parent for 22 of the 27 cultivars. These investigations are particularly helpful in current hybrid breeding programs. 4. Wheat. In wheat and its related genus Aegilops, genetic diversity of cytoplasmic genomes among species has been extensively studied by two different means. One was to compare, by repeated backcrosses, alloplasmic lines with common wheat nuclei and different cytoplasms introduced from numerous Triticum and Aegilops species. The second was restriction endonuclease analyses of mt and ptDNAs (Vedel et al. 1978; Terachi et al. 1984). Based on mitochondrial RFLP analyses with cloned genes as probes, Terachi and Tsunewaki (1992) generated a phylogenetic tree of the mitochondrial genomes of Triticum and Aegilops that differentiated into three major groups: (1) Triticum monococcum, (2) Aegilops speltoides and the polyploid wheats, and (3) all the other species. Today, it is possible to classify the cytoplasm from Triticum and Aegilops as belonging to 10 major plasma types, of which six are further subdivided into minor plasma types. Each plasma type can be characterized by the effects on common wheat (Table 4.2). Investigations of the plasmone of more than 100 genotypes of Triticum, Aegilops, and Agropyron using RFLP mt-probes combined with different restriction enzymes showed in 20% of the combinations
190
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
Table 4.2. Plasmone types of wheat modified from Mukai (1982), Panayotov (1983), Terachi and Tsunewaki (1992), Wang et al. (2000). Group origin
Type
Characteristics in the alloplasmic lines
1. T. monococcum
A
2. Ae. caudata, Ae. triuncialis
C1 C2 Cu1
No winter hardiness, growth inhibition, variegation in winter, CMS CMS, pistilloid, anther malformation
3. Ae. umbellulata, Ae. binuncialis Ae. triaristata Ae. columnaris 4. Ae. tauschii, Ae. cylindrica Ae. ventricosa, Ae juvenalis Ae. crassa, Ae vavilovii 5. Ae. comosa Ae. heldreichii Ae. ovata 6. Ae. uniaristata 7. Ae. mutica 8. T. speltoides, T. turgidum, T. aestivum Ae. bicornis, Ae. kotschyi, Ae. variabilis, Ae. nudiglumis 9. Ae. aucheri, T. timopheevi, T. zhukovskyi 10. Ae. longissima Ae. sharonensis
Growth depression, late heading variegation, partial CMS
Cu2 D1
Anther malformation No remarkable effects
D2 M1 M2 M3 Mu Mt B/S1
Pistilloid Late heading, CMS Late heading, CMS, growth depression Late heading, CMS, tall plant height Growth depression Late heading No remarkable effects
S2
Slightly reduced fertility
G
CMS, anther malformation
S11 S12
Slight reduction of plant vigor Growth depression, partial CMS
polymorphisms indicative of a substantial variability of the mitochondria. A phylogenetic analysis of the cytoplasms on the basis of such genetic distances resulted in a dendrogram differentiating eight clear plasmone types for Triticum and one type for Agropyron trichophorum. Lines clustering closely were homogeneous in the genetic structure of the plasmone and could be assigned to the groups given in Table 4.2. For groups 1, 3, 4, 6, 8, and 9, a precise ordering was possible. Two other groups expressed lower homogeneity but could still be differentiated. In one group the majority of the plasmone corresponded to type S2 but contained in addition S11, C2 Cu2, and D1; and one group showed similar amounts of M3, Mt Mu and S12, implying mt-genome recombination. This may be caused by exchange of nuclear and mitochondrial genetic information; so it is essential to document where the gene is encoded before assaying its expression in different nuclear backgrounds.
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
191
5. Amaranth. Although rather neglected by plant breeders, amaranth has a good potential as a new crop (Peiretti and Gesumaria 1998). Due to the high protein quality of its seeds and flour, it could be valuable in baking bread (Schmidhuber and Zeller 1998). In an analysis of genetic diversity, the plasmone was analyzed using mt-probes in combination with three restriction enzymes in about 50 genotypes of 10 different species of Amaranthus. One third of the combinations revealed polymorphisms. The results clearly demonstrate wide genetic variability of the cytoplasm, which could be classified distinctly into five groups in agreement with the phylogenetic structure. In addition, two small clusters were found, consisting of two genotypes each. Phenotypic resemblances within the respective plasmone groups suggests that recombination did not result in new types. On this basis, Peiretti (2003) formulated five cytoplasmic types: (1) A. cruentus plasma; (2) A. caudatus plasma; (3) A. mantegazzianus with slight addition of A. caudatus plasma; (4) A. hipochondriacus with slight addition of A. hybridus and A. caudatus plasmone similar to A. hipochondriacus (also in the phenotype), producing one small subgroup with A. tricolor and A. quitensis plasma; and (5) A. retroflexus with addition of A. cruentus, A. hypochondriatus, producing one small subgroup with A. dubius plasmone. Based on this classification of the plasmones, the present systematic order of the Amaranthus species might require re-evaluation. Analysis of the plasmone may detect errors in taxonomic classification and can provide information in the direction of subspecies formation. B. Creating New Variability When natural variability is insufficient for direct selection of a desired plasmone, new variability needs to be created via mixing or recombination processes. The classical approaches combine the many genes of two parents that use meiotic recombination. This process works by chance. More precise means are available by gene transfer techniques in which at least the gene structure and function are known. 1. Undirected Processes. Different kinds of variability need to be considered: (1) the generation of new nuclear cytoplasmic combinations, (2) new combinations between unaltered chloroplasts and mitochondria, or (3) the creation of new mitochondrial or plastid genotypes. New Cytoplasmic Nuclear Combinations via Alloplasmic Crossing. Alloplasmic genotypes can be developed via a repeated backcross process,
192
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
always using the seed parent as donor for the cytoplasm and the pistillate parent as the donor for the nuclear information (Tsunewaki et al. 1996). Rare transfer of proplastids and/or mitochondria via the pollen tube may result in mixed zygotes when the parents have different cytoplasms. Since each cell has hundreds of mitochondria, and only a few paternal promitochondria will be transferred, the stabilization of a new cytoplasm takes normally at least six backcrossing generations (Linnert 1997). Alloplasmic effects were predominantly investigated in allopolyploids such as Brassica napus (Hallden et al. 1993), Triticum aestivum (Tsunewaki et al. 1996), or triticale (Geiger et al. 1993). For Triticum and its relatives, alloplasmic lines with substituted cytoplasms could be bred combining good starch (falling number and α-amylase activity) and protein quality (gluten ductility and swelling) with resistance against biotic and abiotic stresses (Busch and Rauch 1994; Öttler and Mares 1994; Ekiz et al. 1998). Wu et al. (1998) found a new range of nucleoplasmic hybrids having Aegilops crassa cytoplasm to be the best under practical field growing conditions. Wang et al. (2000) characterized 46 alloplasmic lines of common wheat carrying plasmones of 33 Triticum and Aegilops species. Using mtDNA probes, they described high mtDNA variability. Using a minimum set of three mtDNA probeenzyme combinations, they identified the plasmone type and screening of new plasmone types became possible. The cytoplasms of Triticum boeoticum, Aegilops umbellulata, Ae. triuncialis, Ae. biuncialis, Ae. columnaris, and Ae. triaristata 6x induce variegation in many common wheats (Mukai 1982). In general, alien cytoplasmic effects are more deleterious in tetraploid Triticum turgidum var. durum than in hexaploid T. aestivum (Sasakuma and Maan 1978). In the allopolyploid Brassica napus, the action of the cytoplasm has became of enormous interest since hybrid cultivars have been successful (in Germany since 1996). By means of restriction enzymes, pt and mtDNAs were characterized for alloplasmic effects (Hallden et al. 1993; Landgren et al. 1996). In B. rapa, Matsuzawa et al. (1999) found CMS in B. napus carrying the Eruca sativa plasmone. Since hybrid breeding is of increasing importance in rice (Virmani and Sharma 1993), the search for CMS has become essential. Cytoplasmic effects of alloplasmic lines varied significantly with the nuclear background. Due to such variation, it should be possible to minimize the present negative cytoplasmic effects so as to obtain improved hybrids by selection of the desired CMS lines (Wang et al. 1998; Li and Yuan 2000). Also, in hybrid breeding of sugar beet, the sexual reproductive system of the gynodioecious and hermaphroditic Beta vulgaris ssp. maritima on cytoplasmic differentiation was evaluated in populations of wild beet
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
193
using chloroplast DNA polymorphism and applied for parent selection (Samitou-Laparde et al. 1991; Forcioli et al. 1998). For hybrid production of Daucus, alloplasmic cultivars are intensively used for the utilization of CMS (Steinborn et al. 1995; Nothnagel et al. 2000). The authors evaluated a collection of alloplasmic carrot lines and found three CMS lines among 100 lines. The genetic analysis revealed that a nuclear-cytoplasmic interaction determined male sterility in these three sources. A clear separation of lines was possible by mtDNA markers. In a similar way, Vivek et al. (1999) proved the maternal inheritance of ptDNA in carrot by markers. New Cytoplasmic-nuclear Combinations in Cybrids. Interspecific and intergeneric protoplast fusions were developed to introduce novel germplasm from sexually incompatible species in order to broaden the genetic base of parents. Besides nuclear incompatibility, Gleba and Sytnik (1984) described the phenomenon of nuclear-cytoplasmic incompatibility. The multifusion of potato (Frei 1994) or wider plant groups can help to understand these phenomena (Binding et al. 1992). In all fusion events, however, organelle segregation and recombination takes place. Fusion provides the opportunity to optimize not only the genetic composition of the nuclear genome but also that of the cytoplasm and the interaction of both. While maternal inheritance operates in sexual recombination, this principle is switched off in somatic cell fusion where both parental cells contribute genomic and cytoplasmic information. The somatic fusion approach for cytoplasmic improvement was attempted for applied breeding. Trials were initiated to exchange cytoplasms completely, leading to alloplasmic lines. Thus, under this aspect, asymmetric hybrids with unequal contributions of the cytoplasmic and nuclear genetic material of each parent were of greater interest than symmetric fusions. Ideally, the asymmetry should go so far that one parent delivered the nucleus only and the other one the cytoplasm only, forming a cybrid. The problem of combining two nuclear genomes with the probability to incorporate undesired genes and the consequence of doubling the ploidy level could be overcome. In the simplest procedure, protoplasts of a donor species (normally a distantly related genotype) are irradiated, destroying the nuclear DNA before fusion with the recipient protoplast (normally a cultivar) in which the metabolism of the cytoplasm is blocked by rhodamin-6-G or iodoacetamide (Sidorov et al. 2000). As a result, the nuclear genome of the cultivar is combined with the plastome of, for example, a distantly related species. Since under these conditions nuclear-cytoplasmic incompatibilities appear, de novo CMS systems can be created. Cybridization can replace the cytoplasm
194
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
of a cultivar in one step, saving lengthy backcrossing programs classically applied for the introduction of alien cytoplasms (Melchers et al. 1992). The most advanced system occurs in the Brassicaceae, in which new vegetables (Earle and Dickson 1995) and rape seed hybrids have been produced. Cybridization provided a way to replace the Raphanus chloroplasts with Brassica ones, while retaining the CMS associated with the Raphanus mitochondria (Pelletier et al. 1988; Gourret et al. 1992). This CMS source was patented as the INRA/Ogura system. Sometimes, along with the desired CMS character undesired chlorosis is also induced. By a subsequent somatic fusion, such mistakes could be corrected (Arumugam et al. 2000). Several such hybrids of rapeseed have reached the market. The cultivar ‘Life’ was still registered in Germany in the year 2001, but due to problems of restoration, it needs a line producing pollen for fertilization. In the meantime, restored hybrids have been developed via classical breeding, resulting in the MSL system, replacing hybrid cultivars with the more complicated INRA/Ogura system (Manthey 2001). Several other cybrids were produced, particularly in tobacco and potato, but since they are not yet advanced enough to make predictions on their practical value, the reader is referred to the review of Johnson and Veilleux (2001). An approach to tackle defined nuclear-cytoplasmic combinations is offered by the microfusion of plasma-free caryoplasts with enucleated cytoplasts (Spangenberg et al. 1991). This process is, however, so laborious and difficult to reproduce that it has not reached the level of practical application. New Cytoplasmic Combinations by Symmetric Fusions. Most of the applied work using asymmetric cell fusion and cybridization has used the donor-recipient principle described above. The selection of desired types of organelles before cell fusion has a number of disadvantages and the effect of metabolic inhibitors is unclear. These inhibitors act differently in different species and probably also in different genotypes. Furthermore, segregation of the chloroplasts cannot be influenced (Walters and Earle 1993). Molecular analysis of somatic hybrids, especially of their cytoplasmic composition, has been performed for various organelles in Brassica. In plants regenerated after fusion between B. oleracea var. italica (broccoli) containing the petaloid B. nigra type of CMS and an atrazine-resistant biotype of B. campestris var. oleifera, plants were regenerated that were CMS and atrazine resistant up to the level of 25 µM (Christey et al. 1991). Molecular analysis showed that they contain chloroplasts from the atrazine-resistant B. campestris parent and mitochondria from the B. nigra parent. In that case, no recombination or rearrangement of the mt-genomes in the fusion products was detected.
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
195
Symmetric fusion may result in CMS, as demonstrated by Bhattacharjee et al. (1999) for rice. Symmetric fusion with a subsequent selection using markers of pt and mtDNA is promising for de novo construction of plasmones by recombination. In potato, Lössl et al. (1994) characterized by RFLP analysis the nuclear and cytoplasmic composition of five different fusion combinations consisting of up to 50 hybrid regenerants each. The same hybrids were evaluated in repeated field experiments for their yield structure and starch content. Complete chloroplast segregation was found with a 1:1 ratio in all but one hybrid. This complete segregation of plastids may be an effect of the recently detected connections between plastids (stromules), highly dynamic structures with continuously and rapidly changing shape. Stromules have been shown to interconnect plastids and permit exchange of proteins between plastids (Gray et al. 2001). The mtDNA shows a much more complex picture; new RFLP bands were indicative of rearrangements in the mt-genome. The assignment of hybrids to the different chloroplast types in potato did not affect yield or starch content. However, mt-types could be distinguished. Their analysis with different probes homologous to coding regions revealed a relationship between the homogeneity of the mtgenome, the yield level, and the starch content of the potato. Further evaluations of the correlation between the cytoplasmic types showed that an interaction existed between starch content and mt-pt combinations. In general, the highest field performances were associated with those cytoplasmic configurations that appeared at a high frequency after completion of the segregation process in vitro. It is assumed that an advantage of clones with an optimized organelle composition exists by such a selection and that they regenerate in vitro preferentially (Lössl et al. 2000). Somatic hybridization is a standard breeding technique in potato for combining nuclear genomes (Hofferbert and Wenzel 1997). Since potato is vegetatively propagated, no meiosis will recombine the heterozygous hybrid structure. Somatic hybridization offers a chance for recombining mt-genomes, resulting in new mtDNA sequences that might be superior for a desired breeding aim. In sexually propagated crops, somatic hybridization is of minor importance, since during meiosis preceding the sexual process, the nicely combined nuclear alleles will recombine and segregate. If the construction of really combined and not just mixed mt or ptDNA can be maintained via meiosis, somatic hybrids are a much more efficient way to use in organelle genetics than the lengthy way of the production of alloplasmic lines via backcrossing. 2. Directed Alterations for Plasmone Transformations. While whole plasmones can be mixed or recombined, plasmone transformation
196
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
allows a more specific technique: adding one or a few genes to a plastome or chondriome, resulting in transgene organelles. Due to their better genetic stability, plastids are the major object in transferring organelle genes. Four discoveries have established them as a feasible platform for genetic modification of plants: (1) the stable transformation of cloned DNA into the Chlamydomonas chloroplasts (Boynton et al. 1988), (2) the successful extension of these approaches to higher plants (Svab et al. 1990), (3) the technical developments in plastid transformation (Heifetz 2000), and (4) advances in the understanding of the rules of plastid gene expression (Maliga 2001). The transformation of pt-genomes (Table 4.3) has a number of advantages compared to the nuclear genome. Plastid transformation usually results in a high level of transgene expression partly attributed to the presence of 50–60 chloroplasts per leaf cell and 60–100 chromosomes per plastid, compared to the usual two copies of each of many chromosomes in the nucleus. The chloroplasts of flowering plants encode 120–150 genes, many of which are grouped in operons. In contrast, the nuclear chromosome contains thousands of genes arranged separately and transcribed individually. As the vast majority of interesting agronomic traits are multigenic, their introduction into the nuclear genome has to be done one gene at a time with unpredictable expression level. The introduction of even short biosynthetic chains is laborious and time consuming. It required a 7-year effort by the group of Ingo Potrykus to induce 3 genes into rice to produce high provitamin A in ‘Golden Rice’ (Ye et al. 2000). The organization of plastid genes in operons allows the introduction of blocks of foreign genes in a single operon under the control of a single promotor. Even the site of insertion can be selected, and the integration via the homologous recombination process facilitates Table 4.3. Summary of plant species where a stable chloroplast transformation has been achieved.
Species
Transformation method
Arabidopsis thalinana Nicotiana plumbaginifolia Potato Tobacco
Biolistic PEG Biolistic Biolistic, protoplast
Tomato Rice
Protoplast Biolistic
References Sikdar et al. 1998 O’Neill et al. 1993 Sidorov et al. 2000 Svab et al. 1990; Golds et al. 1993; McBride et al. 1995; Koop et al. 1996; Guda et al. 2000 Ruf et al. 2001 Khan and Maliga 1999
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
197
targeted gene replacement and precise transgene control. And at the least, because chloroplasts of angiosperms are generally transmitted only by the maternal plant, trans-plastomic plants will not unintentionally release a trait introduced by genetic engineering to wild relatives. The principal methods to introduce DNA into chloroplasts are biolistic bombardment (Svab et al. 1990) and the use of polyethylene glycol (O’Neill et al. 1993; Koop et al. 1996). Alternatively, Knoblauch et al. (1999) have shown that DNA is expressed after its direct injection into individual chloroplasts in photosynthetic leaf cells of tobacco. The final integration of foreign genes into higher plant plastid genomes probably occurs through homologous recombination. Currently the marker genes aadA, codA, and nptII, and the reporter gene ui9dA are used for selection of transformed plastids (Serino and Maliga 1997). In chloroplasts, due to the presence of an Escherichia coli-like system for homologous recombination, transformation is a promising system (Bock and Hagemann 2000). An advantage of transplastomic plants is the accumulation of high levels of alien proteins in the cell organelles, sheltered from proteases of the cytoplasm or enclosed, if biosynthetic products would be harmful to the cell in higher amounts. The introduction of genes coding for insecticidal proteins are currently being investigated. Crops expressing the Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) toxin under the control of the nucleus generally produce it only in sub-optimal amounts. McBride et al. (1995) introduced the Bt gene encoding the protoxin into the chloroplast chromosomes of tobacco. In the resulting plants, this protoxin constituted 2–3% of the total soluble leaf protein. Further efforts have focused on the engineering of herbicide-resistant transplastomic plants by EPSPS transfer (Daniell et al. 1998; Lee et al. 2000). Although transformation of plastids has been achieved for several plant species, homoplasmic fertile plants have been produced only in tobacco and tomato as yet (Ruf et al. 2001). There is great hope regarding the exploitation of the abundant expression capacity of the plastome for plastid mediated molecular farming, leading to the biofabrication of biopolymers and pharmaceutical proteins. A first step can be seen in the work of Staub et al. (2000), engineering tobacco plants able to produce massive amounts of the therapeutic protein, human somatropin, or of insecticidal crystals by over-expressing a Bt operon (De Cosa et al. 2001). Guda et al. (2000) obtained a 100-fold higher yield compared to the transgenes of bioelastic protein-based polymers with transplastomic tobacco plants carrying an artificial gene encoding a repetitive sequence observed in all sequenced mammalian elastin proteins. Mason et al. (2002) have already discussed the usefulness of edible plant vaccines for their application
198
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
in prophylactic and therapeutic molecular medicine. Although there might be still a long way to go, two major modifications of plant metabolism of high importance for agriculture will get renewed consideration: enabling plants to fix N2 and improving the photosynthetic CO2 fixation (Bogard 2000). C. Selection The procedures for directed transformation of ptDNA are not yet precise enough to expect reliable gene expression in any transformed plant. Therefore, powerful selection systems are needed allowing detection of the rather rare event. Molecular techniques allow sensitive differentiation between cytoplasm types. Alcala et al. (1997) succeeded in differentiating the plastomes of CMS onion cultivars from fertile lines using genetic bit analysis. Nevertheless, apart from the information about phylogeny and genetic variability, the molecular characterization of cytoplasms is only of value for breeding approaches if phenotypic traits can be correlated with the markers. When the modifications of the plastome are undirected, as in cell fusion experiments, an additional drawback is the lack of correlation between types of altered cytoplasms and phenotypic changes caused by them. Molecular selection steps may also help to revive the use of somaclonal and protoclonal variation. When it becomes possible to screen for specific mutations that are responsible for a specific step in the biochemical pathway, predictability may replace “luck” in the selection process. 1. Correlation of Phenotype and Cytoplasm. In most cases, the influence of the plasmone on agronomic traits is not distinguished from biparentally inherited traits. To judge the importance of the plasmone, Lössl et al. (2000) combined distinct parental cytoplasms in symmetric tetraploid somatic hybrids in potato. This made it possible, in the presence of nearly isogenic nuclear genomes, to estimate the contribution of mt and ptDNA (Fig. 4.1). The starch content was selected as a phenotypic character. Analysis of mt-pt configurations in a broad gene pool of German potato cultivars, in a reciprocal dihaploid population of 180 clones, in dihaploid fusion parents and in their somatic hybrids emphasized the effects of the plasmone. The results showed that in starch content, the wild type mt-pt cytoplasms have a significant advantage to other combinations of the cytoplasm. An interaction between starch content and different mt-pt combinations was found in hybrids. In general, the highest starch content and yield measured in the field was associated with
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
199
cytoplasmic configurations that appeared in a high frequency within a population after completion of the segregation process. This fact is explained by a selection advantage of clones with optimized organelle segregation during the in vitro phase. 2. Somatic Recombination. Chloroplast segregation has been reported for somatic hybrids by Maliga and Menczel (1986). Chloroplasts normally segregated after a few cell cycles. In potato and Brassica, however, different ratios of parental plastids were observed, perhaps due to different organelle replication rates (Glimelius et al. 1990; Sundberg and Glimelius 1991). When such segregations of hybrids were compared with the field data, no correlation was detectable between the type of plastome and yield characteristics. For potato mitochondria, Xu et al. (1993) reported about 75% recombination of the mtDNA. Such recombinations occur during normal protoclonal variation without any fusion event (Kemble and Shepard 1984). Similar results have been found in the genus Brassica, where Temple et al. (1992) located regeneration breakpoints in the mtDNA, and by Walters and Earle (1993), who found mitochondrial recombination in one third of somatic Brassica hybrids. Lössl et al. (2000) found a correlation between the mitochondrial composition and yield parameters of somatic potato hybrids. Different levels of starch content and tuber yield could be ascribed to different mt-genotypes. Especially for yield, mitochondria from one parent were superior to mitochondria of the other parent. However, most recombinations or new mixtures (new heteroplasmic forms) of mitochondria resulted in a decrease in vigor. It is suggested that plant vigor measured by tuber yield correlates positively with the homogeneity of the mtgenome. The fact that, in sexual hybridizations, only the maternal plasmone is inherited by the next generation suggests a very limited mt-recombination. Evolution resulted in uniform mitochondria with an optimal function for the fitness of the genotype. There is, however, a chance that, by inducing new heteroplasmic mixtures or even mitochondrial recombination, mitochondria can be combined or produced that fit better man’s breeding aims. If so, then protoplast fusion may provide a means for the construction of improved mt-genomes in other crops. As an explanation for the process of recombination among mtDNA resulting in new mtDNA arrangements, Lössl et al. (1999) proposed the following model for potato (Fig. 4.4). In view of the multiple copies and the variability of the wild type mt-genome with master, super, and subcircles coexisting, both fusion parents may contribute to the new mtgenome different mixtures of mtDNA. The sub-circles are the result of
200
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
α cob
β cob
cox I cob rps14 rpl 5
α
cox I
(+)
cob rps14 rpl 5
β
Parents
α cob cox I cob rps14 rpl 5
β
R1 β cob cox I
cob rps14 rpl 5
α
R2
Fig. 4.4. Model of parental mt-genomes and recombinant hybrid mt-genomes R1 and R2. The mt-genome is shown as consisting of a major (master circle) and minor component (sub-circle) for each plant. After protoplast fusion, parts of mt-genome α are replaced by sub-genomes from chondriome type β (Lössl et al. 1999).
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
201
homologous recombination between sequence repeats (Newton 1988). At least during the reorganization of the mt-genome after the fusion process, the sub-genomes seem to be excluded from the master circle so that they can be exchanged independently from the mt main chromosome. The various types of mtDNA within a fusion hybrid population are combined by chance in the somatic hybrids (Fig. 4.4). Such a form of organization could explain the mixtures between different mt-loci found in some hybrids. Somatic fusion should permit the formation of new mixtures of mitochondria that might be stably inherited. The evolution of the mitochondria up to now was little influenced by plant breeding. Now, recombinations after cell fusion open up an opportunity to produce de novo many new mt-genomes, some of which might provide superior traits.
V. CONCLUSION Information on genetic variability and genetic distance is most useful for optimal selection of parents, especially for hybrid breeding. Thus, increasingly molecular markers based on genome polymorphisms are mapped on the chromosomes and used for marker aided selection (MAS) (Wenzel et al. 2001). This nuclear genomic picture should be backed by an understanding of plasmone variability. Different reports on the influence of the plasmone emphasize the importance of the non-nuclear DNA for breeding processes, in particular for hybrid production using CMS, but also, as shown for potato, for yield and/or quality. In contrast to the complex nuclear genome, mt- or pt-probes may allow a simpler but faster classification due to less complex polymorphisms. Most of this research is underway in the major cereals (wheat, rice, and maize) but also in vegetables such as carrot. If their usefulness can be demonstrated, the transfer of these techniques will pay off in speeding up the work with minor crops such as legumes, or neglected crops such as amaranth. The approach to obtain new nuclear-cytoplasmic combinations through sexual combination is reliable but time consuming. The biotechnological (asexual) methods of somatic hybridization and transformation offer faster but laborious alternatives. However, both procedures are not yet efficient enough to be used for plant breeding without proper selection of the superior recombinants. Programmed combination breeding of the nuclear genomes could be successfully speeded up by the extended use of MAS, thanks to extensive efforts to correlate phenotypic and molecular data. Consequently,
202
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
combination and/or recombination should also be a powerful tool in breeding for improved plasmones as soon as the newly obtained cytoplasm types can be correlated with phenotypic variation. This can be achieved, for example, in hybrid regenerants after somatic hybridization. As their nuclear genomes reveal only minor variability, as proven by RFLP analysis, the new phenotypic variation can be ascribed to the cytoplasm and predominantly to the chondriome. This variation, a result of plasmone recombination, allows the characterization and selection of improved mt-genomes. Breeding work using the plasmone thus enhances the opportunity to select improved cultivars. The somatic cell fusion approach will be useful in breeding vegetatively propagated crops. In particular, symmetric protoplast fusion is an elegant method to create new cytoplasms. Cell fusion will also be applicable in sexually propagated crops for the formation of improved mtgenomes. Modifying ptDNA by somatic cell fusion is more difficult since their number per cell is lower and they are separated during the first cell divisions. Chloroplasts have, however, become an object for transformation since under the aspect of safeguarding transgenes, plants carrying the transformation in the pt-genome minimize the ecological risk of vertical and horizontal gene transfer (Bergelson et al. 1998). Integration of foreign genes into the plastid genome appears to occur via homologous recombination, facilitating the targeting of foreign genes to a specific location in the ptDNA (Bock and Hagemann 2000). Consequently, all transformants from the same construct should have the same expression level. Revealing structure-function relationships for pt and mtDNA results in increased understanding of the action of cytoplasmic multiprotein complexes. Such basic knowledge is creating the hope of exploiting the abundant expression capacity of the plastome for plastid-mediated biosynthesis. Molecular farming in cell organelles will lead to the biofabrication of biopolymers and pharmaceutical proteins. In summary, work on the genetic basis of the plasmone is still difficult, but it could have enormous benefits for genetic improvement of feed, food, and non-food crops. The importance of the mtDNA for CMS in hybrid breeding highlights the potential of non-nuclear genes. In addition, there are always new surprises coming from basic research such as the detection of stromules permitting exchange of proteins between plastids (Gray et al. 2001). Chondriomes, perhaps optimized by the use of stromules or transgenic plastomes, may become biotechnological tools with sufficient reproducibility and reliability to achieve known and new breeding goals.
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
203
LITERATURE CITED Abdallah, F., F. Salamini, and D. Leister. 2000. A prediction of the size and evolutionary origin of the proteome of chloroplasts of Arabidopsis. Trends Plant Sci. 5:141–142. Adamski, T., J. Chelkowski, Z. Kaczmarek, M. Surma, and H. Wisniewska. 1997. Evaluation of susceptibility of auto- and alloplasmic barley DH lines to Fusarium seedling blight. Euphytica 93:169–172. Alcala, J., J. J. Giovannoni, L. M. Pike, and A. S. Reddy. 1997. Application of genetic bit analysis for allelic selection in plant breeding. Mol. Breed. 3:495–502. Altman, A. (ed.). 1998. Agricultural biotechnology. Dekker, New York, Basel, Hong Kong. Arumugam, N., A. Mukhopachyay, V. Gupta, Y. S. Sodhi, J. K. Verma, D. Pental, and A. K. Pradhan. 2000. Somatic cell hybridization of oxy CMS Brassica juncea (AABB) with B. oleracea (CC) for correction of chlorosis and transfer of novel organelle combinations to allotetraploid brassicas. Theor. Appl. Genet. 100:1043–1049. Atanassov, I. I., S. A. Atanassova, A. I. Dragoeva, and A. I. Atanassov. 1998. A new CMS source in Nicotiana developed via somatic hybridisation between N. tabacum and N. alata. Theor. Appl. Genet. 97:982–985. Balk, J., and C. J. Leaver. 2001. The PET1-CMS mitochondrial mutation in sunflower is associated with premature programmed cell death and cytochrome release. Plant Cell 13:1803–1818. Bao, J. S., and Y. W. Xia. 1999. Genetic control of paste viscosity characteristics in indica rice (Oryza sativa L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 98:1120–1124. Barkan A., and M. Goldschmidt-Clermont. 2000. Participation of nuclear genes in chloroplast gene expression. Biochimie 82:559–572. Baur, E. 1909. Das Wesen und die Erblichkeitsverhältnisse der “Varietates albomarginatae” hort. von Pelargonium zonale. Z. Ind. Abst. U. Vererbungsl. 1:330–351. Bebeli, P. J. 1995. Cytoplasmic effects on tissue culture response in wheat. J. Genet. Breed. 49:201–208. Bergelson, J., C. B. Purrington, and G. Wichmann. 1998. Promiscuity in transgenic plants. Nature 395:25. Bhattacharjee, B., A. P. Sane, and H. S. Gupta. 1999. Transfer of wild abortive cytoplasmic male sterility through protoplast fusion in rice. Mol. Breed. 5:319–327. Binding, H., L. D. Won, L. H. Qing, G. Buch, G. Tank, J. Rudnick, and W. G. Rong. 1992. Interspecific interactions in the regeneration from protoplasts. p. 27–34. In: K. Oono et al. (eds.), Plant tissue culture and gene manipulation for breeding and formation of phytochemicals. NIAR, Tsukuba. Bock, R. 2001. RNA editing in plant mitochondria and chloroplasts. In: B. L. Bass (ed.), RNA editing. Frontiers in molecular biology. 38–60. Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford. Bock, R., and R. Hagemann. 2000. Extranuclear inheritance: plastid genetics: manipulation of plastid genomes and biotechnological applications. Prog. Bot. 61:76–90. Bock, R., and M. Hippler. 2002. Extranuclear inheritance: Functional genomics in chloroplasts. Prog. Bot. 63:106–131. Bogard, L. 2000. Engineering chloroplasts: an alternative site for foreign genes, proteins, reactions and products. TIBTECH 18:257–263. Bolandi, A. R., M. Branchard, G. Alibert, H. Serieys, and A. Sarrafi. 1999. Cytoplasmicnuclear interaction and medium effect for protoplast culture in sunflower. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Culture 57:189–193. Boynton, J. E., N. W. Gilham, and E. H. Harris. 1988. Chloroplast transformation in Clamydomonas with high velocity microprojectiles. Science 240:1534–1538.
204
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
Breiman, A. 1987. Mitochondrial DNA diversity in the genera of Triticum and Aegilops revealed by Southern-blot hybridisation. Theor. Appl. Genet. 73:563–570. Bruik, R., and S. P. Mayfield. 1999. Light-activated translation of chloroplast mRNAs. Trends Plant Sci. 4:190–194. Bryan, G. J., J. McNicoll, G. Rfamssay, and R. C. Meyer. 1999. Polymorphic simple sequence repeat markers in chloroplast genomes of Solanaceous plants. Theor. Appl. Genet. 99:859–867. Busch, R. H., and T. L. Rauch. 1994. Alien cytoplasmic effects on agronomic performance of two high yielding semidwarf spring wheat cultivars. Crop Sci. 34:389–391. Chen, X., and R. F. Line. 1995. Gene action in wheat cultivars for durable, hightemperature, adult-plant resistance and interaction with race-specific, seedling resistance to Puccinia striiformis. Genetics 85:567–572. Christey, M. C., C. A. Makaroff, and E. D. Earle. 1991. Atrazine-resistant cytoplasmic male-sterile-nigra broccoli obtained by protoplast fusion between cytoplasmic malesterile Brassica oleracea and atrazine-resistant Brassica campestris. Theor. Appl. Genet. 83:201–208. Comai, L. 2000. Genetic and epigenetic interactions in allopoliploid plants. Plant Mol. Biol. 43:387–399. Daniell, H. 2002. Engineering the chloroplast genome to confer stress tolerance and production of pharmaceutical proteins. p. 427–451. In: S. M. Jain et al. (eds.), Molecular techniques in crop improvement. Kluwer Acad. Publ., Dordrecht. Daniell, H., R. Datta, S. Varma, S. Fray, and S. B. Lee. 1998. Containment of herbicide resistance through genetic engineering of the chloroplast genome. Nat. Biotechnol. 16: 345–348. De Cosa, B., W. Moar, S. B. Lee, M. Miller, and H. Daniell. 2001. Overexpression of the Bt cry2Aa2 operon in chloroplasts leads to formation of insecticidal crystals. Nat. Biotechnol. 19:71–74. Dhitaphichit, P., P. Jones, and E. M. Keane. 1989. Nuclear and cytoplasmic gene control of resistance to loose smut (Ustilago titici) in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 78:897–903. Dragoeva, A., I. Atanassov, and A. Atanassov. 2001. CMS due to tapetal failure in cybrids between Nicotiana tabacum and Petunia hybrida. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Culture 55:67–70. Ducos, E., P. Touzet, P. Saumitou-Laprade, P. Vernet, and J. Cuguen. 2001. Nuclear effect on mitochondrial protein expression of the CMS Owsen cytoplasm in sugar beet. Theor. Appl. Genet. 102:1299–1304. Earle, E. D., and M. H. Dickson. 1995. Brassica oleracea cybrids for hybrid vegetable production. p. 171–176. In: M. Terzi et al. (eds.), Current issues in plant molecular and cellular biology. Kluwer, Dordrecht. Edwards, J. W., and J. G. Coors. 1996. Teosinte cytoplasmic genomes: II. Performance of maize hybrids with teosinte cytoplasms. Crop Sci. 36:1092–1098. Ekiz, H., A. S. Kiral, A. Akcin, and L. Simsek. 1998. Cytoplasmic effects on quality traits of bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Euphytica 100:189–196. Forcioli, D., P. Samitou-Laparade, M. Valero, and J. Cuguen. 1998. Distribution of chloroplast DNA diversity within and among populations in gynodioecious Beta vulgaris ssp. marritima (Chenopodiaceae). Mol. Evol. 7:1193–1204. Frei, U. 1994. Multifusions. Potato Res. 37:338. Frei, U., M. Stattmann, A. Lössl, and G. Wenzel. 1998. Aspects of fusion combining ability of dihaploid Solanum tuberosum L.: influence of the cytoplasm. Potato Res. 41:155–162. Friesen, N., S. Pollner, K. Bachmann, and F. R. Blattner. 1999. RAPDs and noncoding chloroplast DNA reveal a single origin of the cultivated Allium fistulosum from A. altaicum (Alliaceae). Am. J. Bot. 86:554–562.
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
205
Garraway, M. O., D. S. Park, and J. D. Beltran. 1998. Role of light and malate in the decreased sensitivity of cms-T cytoplasm maize leaves to Bipolaris maydis race T toxin. Phytopathology 88:556–562. Geiger, H. H., G. Öttler, R. Marker, F. H. Utz, and F. Wehmann. 1993. Evaluating rye inbred lines per se and in euplasmic and alloplasmic crosses for triticale suitability. Crop Sci. 33:725–729. Gleba, Y. Y., and K. M. Sytnik. 1984. Protoplast fusion. Springer Verlag, Berlin. Glimelius, K., J. Fahlesson, M. Landgren, M. Sjödin, and C. Sundberg. 1990. Improvement of the Brassica crops by transfer of genes from alien species via somatic hybridisation. p. 299–312. In: H. Nijkamp et al. (eds.), Progress in plant cell and molecular biology. Kluwer, Dordrecht. Golds, T., P. Maliga, and H. U. Koop. 1993. Stable plastid transformation in PEG-treated protoplasts of Nicotiana tabaccum. Bio/Technology 11:95–97. Gourret, J. P., R. Delourme, and M. Renard. 1992. Expression of Ogu cytoplasmic male sterility in cybrids of Brassica napus. Theor. Appl. Genet. 83:549–556. Gray, J. C., J. A. Sullivan, J. M. Hibberd, and M. R. Hansen. 2001. Stromules: Mobile protrusions and interconnections between plastids. Plant Biol. 3:223–233. Gray, J. C., J. A. Sullivan, and R. Sornarajah. 1999. Chloroplast control of nuclear gene expression. J. Exp. Bot. 50 (Suppl.) 48. Gray, M. W. 1999. Evolution of organellar genomes. Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev. 9:678–687. Grivell, L. A. 1995. Nuclei-mitochondrial interactions in mitochondrial gene expression. Crit. Rev. Biochem. Mol. Biol. 30:121–164. Guda, C., S. B. Lee, and H. Daniell. 2000. Stable expression of a biodegradable proteinbased polymer in tobacco chloroplasts. Plant Cell Rep. 19:257–262. Hagemann, R. 2002. Milestones in plastid genetics of higher plants. Prog. Bot. 63:5–51 Hallden, C., B. Gertsson, T. Sall, and C. Lind-Hallden. 1993. Characterization of organellar DNA in alloplasmic lines of Brassica napus L. Plant Breed. 111:185–191. Hanson, M. R., and O. Folkerts. 1992. Structure and function of higher plant mitochondrial genome. Int. Rev. Cytol. 141:129–172. Hasan, E., and C. F. Konzak. 1991. Nuclear and cytoplasmic control of anther culture response in wheat: I. Analyses of alloplasmic lines. Crop Sci. 31:1421–1427. Hedtke, B., I. Wagner, T. Börner, W. R. Hesws. 1999. Inter-organellar crosstalk in higher plants: impaired chloroplast development affects mitochondrial gene and transcript levels. Plant J. 19:635–643. Heifetz, P. B. 2000. Genetic engineering of the chloroplast. Biochimie 82:655–666. Hernandez, P., P. Barcelo, A. Martin, and A. Cabrera. 2001. The effect of Hordeum chilense and Triticum cytoplasm on anther culture response of tritordeum. Plant Cell Rep. 20:542–546. Herrmann, R. G. 1992. Cell organelles. Springer Verlag, Wien. Herrmann, R. G., R. M. Maier, and C. Schmitz-Linneweber. 2003. Eukaryotic genome evolution: Rearrangement and co-evolution of compartmentalised genetic information. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. (London) (in press). Hirose, T., and M. Sugiura. 1997. Both RNA editing and RNA cleavage are required for translation of tobacco chloroplast psbA mRNAs: development of an in vitro translation system from tobacco chloroplasts. EMBO J 16:6804–6811. Hofferbert, H. R., and G. Wenzel. 1997. Alternative Hybridzüchtung—somatische Hybridisation bei der Kartoffel. Ber. Arbeitstagung Gumpenstein 48:111–114. Hosaka, K. 1995. Successive domestication and evolution of the Andean potatoes as revealed by chloroplast DNA restriction endonuclease analysis. Theor. Appl. Genet. 90:356–363. Hosaka, K., and R. E. Hanneman. 1988. The origin of the cultivated tetraploid potato based on chloroplast DNA. Theor. Appl. Genet. 76:172–176.
206
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
Hsam, S. L. K., and F. J. Zeller. 1993. Haploid production in durum wheat by the interaction of Aegilops kotschyi cytoplasm and 1BL/RS chromosomal interchange. Theor. Appl. Genet. 86:951–954. Ishii, T., T. Terachi, N. Mori, and K. Tsunewaki. 1993. Comparative study on the chloroplast, mitochondrial and nuclear genome differentiation in two cultivated rice species, Oryza sativa and Oryza glaberrima, by RFLP analyses. Theor. Appl. Genet. 86:88–96. Johnson, A. A. T., and R. E. Veilleux. 2001. Somatic hybridization and applications in plant breeding. Plant Breed. Rev. 20:167–225. Kaul, M. L. H. 1988. Male sterility in higher plants. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. Keane, E. M., and P. W. Jones. 1990. Effect of alien cytoplasm substitution on the response of wheat cultivars to Septoria nodorum. Ann. Appl. Biol. 117:299–312. Kemble, R. J., and J. F. Shepard. 1984. Cytoplasmic DNA variation in a potato protoclonal population, Theor. Appl. Genet. 69:211–216. Khan, M. S., and P. Maliga. 1999. Fluorescent antibiotic resistance marker for tracking plastid transformation in higher plants. Nat. Biotechnol. 17:910–915. Knoblauch, M., A. J. E. van Bel, J. M. Hibberd, and J. C. Gray. 1999. Micro-injection and expression of reporter genes in plastids. J. Expt. Bot. 50:48. Knoop, V., and A. Brennicke. 2002. Molecular biology of the plant mitochondrion. Crit. Rev. Plant Sci. 21:111–126. Koop, U., K. Steinmüller, H. Wagner, C. Roessler, C. Eibl, and L. Sacher. 1996. Integration of foreign sequences into the tobacco plastome via polyethylene glycol-mediated protoplast transformation. Planta 199:193–201. Kueck, U., B. Laser, S. Mohr, E. Schulte-Kappert, C. Nowak, G. Öttler, B. Pfeiffer-Schad, C. U. Hesemann, R. Weigel, U. Pfeil, M. Stierle, T. Stösser, H. van der Kuip, M. Wolf, and W. Odenbach. 1995. CMS in wheat and triticale. Fortschritte der Pflanzenzüchtg. 18:19–36. Landgren, M., M. Zetterstrand, E. Sundberg, and K. Glimelius. 1996. Alloplasmic malesterile Brassica lines containing BBB. Tournefortii mitochondria express on ORF 3 of the atp6 gene a 32 Kda protein. Plant Molec Biol. 32:879–890. Laser, K. D., and N. R. Lersten. 1972. Anatomy and cytology of microsporogenesis in cytoplasmic male sterile angiosperms. Bot. Rev. 38:425–454. Laurent, V., A. M. Risterucci, and C. Lanaud. 1993. Chloroplast and mitochondrial DNA diversity in Theobroma cacao. Theor. Appl. Genet. 87:81–88. Lee, H. J., S. B. Lee, J. S. Chung, S. U. Han, J. O. Guh, J. S. Jeon, G. An, and K. Back. 2000. Transgenic rice plants expressing the Bacillus subtilis protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene are resistant to diphenyl ether herbicide oxyfluorfen. Plant Cell Physiol. 41:743–749. Levings, C. S. 1990. The Texas cytoplasm of maize: cytoplasmic male sterility and disease susceptibility. Science 250:942–947. Li, J., and L. Yuan. 2000. Hybrid rice: Genetics, breeding, and seed production. Plant Breed. Rev. 11:15–158. Lim, K. Y., R. Matyasek, C. P. Lichtenstein, and A. R. Leitch. 2000. Molecular cytogenetic analyses and phylogenetic studies in the Nicotiana section Tomentosae. Chromosoma 109:245–258. Lin, M. S. 1992. Ancestral contribution to IRRI rice varieties. Japan. J. Breed. 42:437–442. Linnert, G. 1997. Plasmatische Vererbung. p. 202–210. In: W. Odenbach (ed.), Biologische Grundlagen der Pflanzenzüchtung. Parey, Berlin. Londsdale, D. M., T. P. Hodge, and C. M.-R. Fauron. 1984. The physical map and organisation of the mitochondrial genome from fertile genome of maize. Nuc. Acid. Res. 12:9249–9261. Lössl, A., U. Frei, and G. Wenzel. 1994. Interaction between cytoplasmic composition and yield parameters in somatic hybrids of S. tuberosum L. Theor. Appl. Genet. 89:873–878. Lössl, A., N. Adler, R. Horn, U. Frei, and G. Wenzel. 1999. Chondriome-type characterization of potato: mt α, β, γ, δ, ε and novel plastid-mitochondrial configurations in somatic hybrids. Theor. Appl. Genet. 99:1–10.
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
207
Lössl, A., M. Götz, A. Braun, and G. Wenzel. 2000. Molecular markers for cytoplasm in potato: male sterility and contribution of different plastid-mitochondrial configurations to starch production. Euphytica 116:221–230. Lübberstedt, T., V. Mohler, and G. Wenzel. 2002. Function of genetic material: Genes involved in quantitative and qualitative resistance. Prog. Bot. 63:80–105. Luo, H., B. V. Coppenolle, M. Seguin, and M. Boutry. 1995. Mitochondrial DNA phylogenetic relationships in Hevea brasiliensis. Mol. Breed. 1:51–63. Maliga, P. 2001. Plastid engineering bears fruit. Nat. Biotechnol. 19:826–827. Maliga, P., and L. Menczel. 1986. Chloroplast transfer and recombination through protoplast fusion. p. 601–612. In: I. K. Vasil (ed.), Cell culture and somatic cell genetics. Academic Press, Orlando. Manthey, R. 2001. Stand der in Deutschland zugelassenen Rapssorten. Raps 19:152–155. Mason, H. S., H. Warzecha, T. Mor, and C. J. Arntzen. 2002. Edible plant vaccines: applications for prophylactic and therapeutic molecular medicine. Trends Mol. Med. 8:324–329. Matsuzawa, Y., S. Mekiyanon, Y. Kaneko, S. W. Bang, K. Wakui, and Y. Takahata. 1999. Male sterility in alloplasmic Brassica rapa L. carrying Eruca sativa cytoplasm. Plant Breed. 118:82–84. McBride, K. F., Z. Svab, D. J. Schaaf, P. S. Hogan, and D. M. Stalker. 1995. Amplification of a chimeric Bacillus gene in chloroplasts leads to an extraordinary level of insecticidal protein in tobacco. Bio/Technology 13:362–365. Melchers, G., Y. Mohri, K. Watanabe, S. Wakabayashi, and K. Harada. 1992. One-step generation of cytoplasmic male sterility by fusion of mitochondrial-inactivated tomato protoplasts with nuclear-inactivated Solanum protoplasts. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA) 89:6832–6836. Messmer, M., A. E. Melchinger, J. Boppenmaier, E. Brunklaus, and R. Herrmann. 1992. Relationships among early European maize inbreds: I. Genetic diversity among flint and dent lines revealed by RFLPs. Crop Sci. 32:1301–1309. Messmer, M., A. E. Melchinger, R. Herrmann, and J. Boppenmaier. 1993. Relationships among early European maize inbreds: II. Comparison of pedigree and RFLP data. Crop Sci. 33:944–950. Moneger, F., C. J. Smart, and C. J. Leaver. 1994. Nuclear restoration of male sterility in sunflower is associated with the tissue-specific regulation of a novel mitochondrial gene. EMBO J. 13:8–17. Mukai, Y. 1982. Genetic characterization of the cytoplasms of tetraploid Aegilops species. Memoirs Osaka Univ. Ser. III 31:13–34. Murai, K., and K. Tsunewaki. 1993. Photoperiod-sensitive cytoplasmic male sterility in wheat with Aegilops crassa cytoplasm. Euphytica 67:41–48. Neale, D. B., M. A. Saghi-Maroof, R. W. Allard, Q. Zhang, and R. A. Jorgensen. 1986. Chloroplast DNA diversity in populations of wild and cultivated barley. Genetics 120: 1105–1110. Nestares, G., R. Zorzoli, L. Mroginski, and L. Picardi. 1998. Cytoplasmic effects on the regeneration ability of sunflower. Plant Breed. 117:188–190. Newton, K. J. 1988. Plant mitochondrial genomes: organization, expression and variation. Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol. Plant Mol. Biol. 39:503–532. Nothnagel, T., P. Straka, and B. Linke. 2000. Male sterility in populations of Daucus and the development of alloplasmic male-sterile lines of carrot. Plant Breed. 119: 145–152. O’Neill, C., G. V. Horvath, E. Horvath, P. J. Dix, and P. Medgysey. 1993. Chloroplast transformation in plants: polyethylene glycol (PEG) treatment of protoplasts is an alternative to biolistic delivery systems. Plant J. 3:729–738. Öttler, G., and D. J. Mares. 1994. Falling number and alpha-amylase activity in developing grain of alloplasmic hexaploid wheat. Plant Breed. 112:47–52.
208
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
Ogihara, Y., K. Isono, T. Kato et al. (16 co-authors). 2002. Structural features of a wheat plastome as revealed by complete sequencing of chloroplast DNA. Mol. Gen. Genomics 266:740–746. Ogihara, Y., Y. Kurihara, K. Futami, K. Tsuji, and K. Murai. 1999. Photoperiod-sensitive cytoplasmic male sterility in wheat: Nuclear-mitochondrial incompatibility results in differential processing of the mitochondrial orf25 gene. Current Genet. 36:354–362. Orlov, P. A., E. B. Mavrishcheva, and A. N. Palilova. 1997. Analysis of the effect of nucleus and cytoplasm interactions on the anther culture efficiency in wheat. Cereal Res. Commun. 25:883–890. Orozco-Castillo, C., K. J. Chalmers, W. Powell, and R. Waugh. 1996. RAPD and organelle specific PCR re-affirms taxonomic relationships within the genus Coffea. Plant Cell Rep. 15:337–341. Panayotov, I. 1983. The cytoplasm in triticinae. Proc. 6th Intern. Wheat Gen. Symp., Kyoto, p. 481–497. Peiretti, E. G. 2003. Molekulare Charakterisierung der Cytoplasmen von Amarant, Mais und Weizen. Diss. TU München. Peiretti, E. G., and J. J. Gesumaria. 1998. Influencia de la distancia entre lineas sobre el crecimiento y rendimiento de amaranto granifero (Amaranthus spp.). Invest. Agr. Prod. Prot. Veg. 13:139–151. Pelletier, G., C. Primard, M. Frerault, F. Vedel, P. Chetrit, M. Renard, and R. Delourme. 1988. Use of protoplasts in plant breeding: cytoplasmic aspects. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult. 12:173–180. Poggio, L., M. Rosato, and C. A. Naranjo. 1997. Meiotic behavior and DNA content in alloplasmic lines of maize. Genome 40:723–729. Powell, W., M. Morgante, R. McDevitt, G. G. Vendramin, and J. A. Rafalski. 1995. Polymorphic simple sequence repeat regions in chloroplast genomes: application to the population genetics of pines. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA) 92:7759–7763. Rhoads, D. M., H. C. Griffin, B. B. Neuschwander, C. S. Levings, and J. N. Siedow. 1996. Assays for characterizing URF13, the pathotoxin and methomyl receptor of cms-T maize. Meth. Enzymology 264:566–581. Rocheford, T. R., and D. R. Pring. 1994. Interaction of nuclear and mitochondrial genomes in the alteration of maize mitochondrial transcripts. Theor. Appl. Genet. 89:951–958. Rousstaee, A., and G. Barrault. 2000. Inheritance of partial resistance to black stem (Phoma madonaldii) in sunflower. Plant Pathol. 49:396–401. Ruf, S., H. Kössl, and R. Bock. 1997. Targeted inactivation of a tobacco intron containing open reading frame reveals a novel chloroplast-encoded photosystem I-related gene. J. Cell Biol. 139:95–102. Ruf, S., M. Herrmann, I. J. Berger, H. Carrer, and R. Bock. 2001. Stable genetic transformation of tomato plastids and expression of a foreign protein in fruit. Nat. Biotechnol. 19:870–875. Samitou-Laparde, P., G. Pannenbecker, V. Boutin-Stadler, G. Michaelis, and P. Vernet. 1991. Plastid DNA diversity in natural populations of Beta maritima showing additional variation in sexual phenotype and mitochondrial DNA. Theor. Appl. Genet. 81:533–536. Sasakuma, T., and S. S. Maan. 1978. Male sterility-fertility restoration systems in Triticum durum Desf. Can. J. Genet. Cytol. 20:389–398. Schardl, C. L., D. M. Lonsdale, and D. R. Pring. 1985. Mitochondrial DNA structures in male-sterile maize Zea mays and its fertile revertants. J. Cell Biochem. Suppl. 9C:262. Scheffler, E. 1999. Mitochondria. Wiley-Liss, New York. Schmidhuber, M., and F. J. Zeller. 1998. Amarant: mehr Protein fürs Brot. Back J. 98:65–66. Schmitz-Linneweber, C., R. Regel, T. G. Du, H. Hupfer, R. G. Herrmann, and M. Maier. 2002. The plastid chromosome of Atropa belladonna and its comparison with that of Nicotina tabacum: The role of RNA editing in generating divergences in the process of plant speciation. Mol. Biol. Evol. 19:1602–1612.
4. SIGNIFICANCE OF CYTOPLASMIC DNA IN PLANT BREEDING
209
Schwarz, Z., and H. Kössel. 1979. Sequencing of the 3’-terminal region of a 16 S rRNA gene from Zea mays chloroplasts reveals homology with E. coli 16 S rRNA. Nature 279: 520–522. Serino, G., and P. Maliga. 1997. A negative selection scheme based on the expression of cytosine deaminase in plastids. Plant J. 12:697–701. Shinozaki, K., M. Ohme, M. Tanaka, T. Wakasuki, N. Hayashida, T. Matsubayasha, N. Zaita, J. Chungwongse, J. Obokarta, K. Yamaguchi-Shinozaki, C. Ogto, K. Torazawa, B. Y. Meng, M. Sugita, H. Deno, T. Kamogashira, K. Yamada, J. Kusuda, F. Takaiwa, A. Kata, N. Tohdo, H. Shimada, and M. Sugiura. 1986. The complete nucleotide sequence of the tobacco chloroplast genome: its gene organisation and expression. EMBO J. 5:2043–2049. Sidorov, V. A., D. Kasten, S. Z. Pang, P. Hajdukiewicz, J. M. Staub, and N. S. Nehra. 2000. Stable chloroplast transformation in potato: use of fluorescent protein as a plastid marker. Plant J. 19:209–216. Sikdar, S. R., G. Serino, S. Chaudhun, and P. Maliga. 1998. Plastid transformation in Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Cell Rep. 18:20–24. Sonnino, A., S. Tanaka, M. Iwanaga, and L. Schilde-Rentschler. 1989. Genetic control of embryo formation in anther culture of diploid potatoes. Plant Cell Rep. 8:105–107. Spangenberg, G., E. Freydl, M. Osusky, J. Nagel, and I. Potrykus. 1991. Organelle transfer by microfusion of defined protoplast-cytoplast pairs. Theor. Appl. Genet. 81:477–486. Staub, J. M., B. Garcia, J. Graves, P:T. J. Hajdukiewicz, P. Hunter, N. Nehra, V. Paradkar, M. Schlittler, J. A. Carroll, and L. Spatola. 2000. High-yield production of a human therapeutic protein in tobacco chloroplasts. Nat. Biotechnol. 18:333–338. Steinborn, R., B. Linke, T. Nothnagel, and T. Börner. 1995. Inheritance of chloroplast and mitochondrial DNA in alloplasmic forms of the genus Daucus. Theor. Appl. Genet. 91:632–638. Steinhauser, S., S. Beckert, and I. Capesius. 1999. Plant mitochondrial RNA editing. J. Molec. Evol. 48:303–312. Stern, D. B., D. C. Higgs, and J. Yang. 1997. Transcription and translation in chloroplasts. Trends Plant Sci. 2:308–315. Stoddard, F. L. 2000. Genetics of wheat starch B-granule content. Euphytica 112:23–31. Stoddard, F. L., and I. H. M. H. B. Hearth. 2001. Genetic analysis of partial rust resistance in faba beans. Austral. J. Agr. Res. 52:73–84. Sun, C. Q., X. K. Wang, A. Yoshimura, and K. Doi. 2002. Genetic differentiation for nuclear, mitochondrial and chloroplast genomes in common wild rice (Oryza rufipogon Griff.) and cultivated rice (Oryza sativa L.). Theor. Appl. Genet. 104:1335–1345. Sundberg, E., and K. Glimelius. 1991. Effects of parental ploidy level and genetic divergence on chromosome elimination and chloroplast segregation in somatic hybrids within Brassicaceae. Theor. Appl. Genet. 83:81–88. Svab, Z., P. Hajdukiewicz, and P. Maliga. 1990. Stable transformation of plastids in higher plants. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA) 87:8526–8530. Temple, M., C. A. Makaroff, M. A. Mutschler, and E. D. Earle. 1992. Novel mitochondrial genomes in Brassica napus somatic hybrids. Curr. Genet. 22:243–249. Terachi, T., Y. Ogihara, and K. Tsunewaki. 1984. The molecular basis of genetic diversity among cytoplasms of Triticum and Aegilops. 3. Chloroplast genomes of the M and modified M genome-carrying species. Genetics 108:681–695. Terachi, T., and K. Tsunewaki. 1992. The molecular basis of genetic diversity among cytoplasms of Triticum and Aegilops. VIII. Mitochondrial RFLP analyses using cloned gene probes. Mol. Biol. Evol. 9:917–931. Timothy, D. H., C. S. Levings, D. R. Pring, M. F. Cone, and J. L. Kermicle. 1979. Oranelle DNA variation and systematic relationships in the genus Zea: Teosinte. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA) 76:4220–4224.
210
U. FREI, E. PEIRETTI, AND G. WENZEL
Tsunewaki, K., T. R. Endo, and Y. Mukai. 1974. Further discovery of alien cytoplasms inducing haploids and twins in common wheat. Theor. Appl. Genet. 45:104–109. Tsunewaki, K., G. Z. Wang, and Y. Matsuoka. 1996. Plasmone analysis of Triticum (wheat) and Aegilops. 1. Production of alloplasmic common wheats and their fertilities. Genes Genetic Syst. 71:293–311. Vedel, F., F. Quetier, F. Dosba, and G. Doussinauls. 1978. Study of wheat phylogeny by EcoRI analysis of chloroplastic and mitochondrial DNAs. Plant Sci. Lett. 13:97–102. Virk, D. S., and J. S. Brar. 1993. Assessment of cytoplasmic differences of near-isonuclear male-sterile lines in pearl millet. Theor. Appl. Genet. 87:106–112. Virmani, S. S., and H. L. Sharma. 1993. Manual for hybrid rice seed production. IRRI, Manila. Vivek, B. S., Q. A. Ngo, and P. W. Simon. 1999. Evidence for maternal inheritance of the chloroplast genome in cultivated carrot (Daucus carota L. ssp. sativus). Theor. Appl. Genet. 98:669–672. Walters, T. W., and E. D. Earle. 1993. Organellar segregation, rearrangement and recombination in protoplast fusion derived Brassica oleracea calli. Theor. Appl. Genet. 85:761–769. Wang, C., S. Tang, and Y. Tang. 1998. Effects of male sterile cytoplasm on yield and agronomic characters in Japonica hybrid rice, Oryza sativa L. Breed. Sci. 48:263–271. Wang, G. Z., Y. Matsuoka, and K. Tsunewaki. 2000. Evolutionary features of chondriome divergence in Triticum (wheat) and Aegilops shown by RFLP analysis of mitochondrial DNAs. Theor. Appl. Genet. 100:221–232. Wenzel, G. 1994. Tissue culture. p. 173–195. In: J. E. Bradshaw and G. R. Mackay (eds.), Potato genetics. CAB Intl., Wallingford. Wenzel, G., and B. Foroughi-Wehr. 1994. Production and use of isogenic lines. p. 153–172. In: I. K. Vasil and T. A. Thorpe (eds.), Plant cell and tissue culture. Kluwer, Dordrecht. Wenzel, G., V. Mohler, and F. Thuemmler. 2001. Marker techniques as tools for efficient plant breeding. Proc. Workshop Soybean Biotechnology, Bogor, p. 4–14. Wenzel, G., and H. Uhrig. 1981. Breeding for nematode and virus resistance in potato via anther culture. Theor. Appl. Genet. 80:359–365. Wilson, J. 1967. Problems in hybrid wheat breeding. Euphytica Suppl. Wilson, J. A., and W. M. Ross. 1962. Male sterility interaction of the Triticum aestivum nucleus and Triticum timopheevi cytoplasm. Wheat Inform. Service 14:29–30. Wu, Y., C. Zhang, L. Chunguang, R. Shuxoin, and Z. Yan. 1998. Breeding technology of alloplasmic wheat. Sci. China C 41:449–458. Xu, D. H., J. Abe, J. Y. Gai, and Y. Shimamoto. 2002. Diversity of chloroplast DNA SSRs in wild and cultivated soybeans: evidence for multiple origins of cultivated soybean. Theor. Appl. Genet. 105:645–653. Xu, Y. S., M. S. Clark, and E. Pehu. 1993. Use of RAPD markers to screen somatic hybrids between Solanum tuberosum and S. brevidens. Plant Cell Rep. 12:107–114. Yadav, O. P. 1994. Effect of the cytoplasmic source on the combining ability of agronomic traits in pearl millet. Plant Breed. 113:242–245. Yamaguchi, K., and K. V. Knoblauch. 2000. The plastid ribosomal proteins. Identification of all the proteins in the 30 S subunit of an organelle ribosome (chloroplast). J. Biol. Chem. 275:28455–28465. Ye, X., S. Al-Babili, A. Klöti, J. Zhang, P. Lucca, P. Beyer, and I. Potrykus. 2000. Engineering the provitamin A (β-carotene) biosynthetic pathway into (carotenoid-free) rice endosperm. Science 287:303–305.
5 Flowering, Seed Production, and the Genesis of Garlic Breeding Philipp W. Simon Vegetable Crops Research Unit, United States Department of Agriculture—Agricultural Research Service, Department of Horticulture, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706 Maria M. Jenderek National Arid Land Plant Genetic Resource Unit, United States Department of Agriculture—Agricultural Research Service, San Joaquin Valley Agricultural Science Center, Parlier, CA 93648 I. II. III. IV.
INTRODUCTION GARLIC PRODUCTION TRENDS GARLIC TAXONOMY AND GENETIC VARIATION GARLIC GROWTH AND REPRODUCTIVE BIOLOGY A. Morphology and Growth B. Reproductive Biology V. GARLIC SEED PRODUCTION A. Importance of Garlic Germplasm for Seed Production B. Processes and Procedures for Garlic Seed Production VI. PROGRESS IN GARLIC BREEDING AND FUTURE PROSPECTS A. Selection for Improved Floral Characteristics and Fertility B. Selection for Improved Seed Size and Vigor C. Garlic Breeding Goals D. Garlic Breeding Methods VII. CONCLUSIONS LITERATURE CITED
I. INTRODUCTION Garlic is one of the oldest horticultural crops. There are Egyptian and Indian references to garlic 5000 years ago, clear evidence of Babylonian usage 4500 years ago, and usage in China 2000 years ago, although some Plant Breeding Reviews, Volume 23, Edited by Jules Janick ISBN 0-471-35421-X © 2003 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 211
212
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
writings suggest that it was grown there as long as 4000 years ago (Hahn 1996). In spite of its long history, little is known about early garlic production or plant types used for cultivation. Garlic production today relies completely upon asexual propagation of the crop and, while flowering in garlic has long been known, no record of true seed production in garlic is known before 1950. While domestication implies selection for improved adaptation and production in cultivation by humans, it could be argued that despite its long cultivation, garlic still remains undomesticated. This statement presumes that domestication only proceeds when humans can tap the broad range of heritable variation resulting from sexual reproduction. However, it seems likely that sexual reproduction and selection among products of meiosis and syngamy may have been realized in cultivation from time to time during garlic’s long history. Furthermore, clonal selection has clearly generated new cultivars of non-sexual, clonally propagated crops such as seedless bananas, sweet potatoes, Caladium, Colocasia, potatoes, apples (Sharma 1956), and also garlic (Burba 1997). Nevertheless, flowering and seed production research in garlic over the last 50 years sets the scene for utilizing a system of classical plant breeding in this important crop that has been used as the mainstay of plant breeding today. True seed production in garlic provides a foundation for dramatically changing the production and reproduction technologies used by garlic producers in the future. Etoh (1985) reviewed the early research on garlic sterility and seed production, while Etoh and Simon (2002) recently reviewed garlic diversity, fertility, and seed production. Darlington (1939) maintained that, in nature, asexual reproduction provides only limited genetic options for continued adaptation, saying: “With loss of sexual recombination, the apomict . . . is cut off from ultimate survival. Apomixis is an escape from sterility but it is an escape into a blind alley of evolution.” Human intervention has apparently sustained and even favored asexual reproduction throughout the agricultural history of garlic. The prospects for true seed production in garlic now hold out the possibility of capturing the broader diversity that allogamy and recombination can bring.
II. GARLIC PRODUCTION TRENDS Garlic is widely grown, with current worldwide production at nearly 10 million tonnes on nearly a million hectares, and it is used as a spice, condiment, and vegetable (Table 5.1). China and India are the largest producers of garlic, collectively accounting for 60% of the production area and 69% of the world yield. World garlic production area has more than doubled since 1970, and its availability has almost doubled in that
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
213
Table 5.1. World garlic production and availability, 1961–2000. Source: FAO Yearbook Production Statistics; average of 3 years for 1970, 1980, 1990, and 2000 (i.e., 1970 = average of 1969–1971). Yield (t/ha)
Availability (kg/capita)
1 1 2 3 3
10.5 23.2 16.3 12.7 11.4
0.2 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
1961 1970 1980 1990 2000
86 74 74 77 76
5.7 7.4 7.3 9.0 10.7
2.2 1.2 1.3 1.7 2.2
Europe
1961 1970 1980 1990 2000
8 16 15 13 12
5.2 5.3 5.2 5.4 6.1
0.8 0.8 0.9 1.0 0.7
North and Central America
1961 1970 1980 1990 2000
1 2 2 3 3
4.3 6.8 9.7 13.6 15.2
0.1 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
Oceania
1961 1970 1980 1990 2000
<1 <1 <1 <1 <1
1.0 1.0 7.0 5.9 6.0
<0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1
South America
1961 1970 1980 1990 2000
4 6 6 5 6
3.1 3.7 4.5 5.1 7.4
0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.9
World
1961 1970 1980 1990 2000
771 464 627 771 985
5.6 6.9 7.0 8.4 10.0
1.4 0.9 1.0 1.2 1.6
Continent
Year
Africa
1961 1970 1980 1990 2000
Asia
Area (% world)
period to a current annual consumption of 1.64 kg/capita. Asia is by far the major garlic production region, but increased area and availability have kept up with population in the rest of the world, with especially sharp rises between 1990 and 2000 in the Americas. In spite of the wide geographic range of garlic production today, little is known about the similarities and differences among major
214
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
cultivars grown in different growing regions. In this paper, we use the term “clone” to indicate garlic cultivars, strains, or genotypes that are asexually propagated. The major distinction among garlic clones is the tendency to produce a flower stalk, or not. Those producing a flower stalk are referred to as “bolting,” “stalking,” or “hard neck” types, whereas those without a flower stalk are “non-bolting,” “non-stalking,” or “soft neck.” Sometimes a third category, “incomplete or partial bolting,” is used for clones in which the inflorescence begins to develop but stem elongation is incomplete and mature flowers do not develop (Takagi 1990). There is a presumption that this character is stable across environments but this is unproven. Likewise, it is assumed that, like onion, garlic bulb formation is a response to photoperiod and some reference is made to “shortday” cultivars (which produce bulbs as photoperiods lengthen slightly in the spring in regions near the Equator), and “long-day” cultivars (which produce bulbs as photoperiods lengthen dramatically in the spring in regions farther from the Equator). This has not been substantiated either, although both bolting and non-bolting garlic clones are produced in nearly all production regions. Grower and consumer preferences for garlic vary among different geographic regions and end uses. Intact or processed garlic bulbs constitute the usual form of the crop traded in commerce, but in parts of Asia and North Africa leaves are marketed. Preferred garlic cultivars for fresh bulb sale include those with red or pink cloves surrounded by white bulb scales and those with white cloves and bulb scales. Processors of prepared fresh garlic (e.g., minced, chopped, crushed, or sliced) use both types. Dehydrators require the latter type with little pigment and high dry matter content. The inclination of consumers toward unusual and pigmented vegetables has resulted in specialty markets for novel and colored garlic. The development of garlic for the nutraceutical industry has resulted in another specialty market with high levels of sulfur compounds such as allicin, that are often correlated with strong flavor. True seed production of garlic will likely provide a more diverse array of variation from which users can select. The strictly asexual propagation of garlic brings with it several viruses, nematodes, and other pests, which lower garlic yield. Consequently, an extensive research effort and very significant production resources are dedicated to reducing or eliminating these pathogens from “seed” garlic, plants used for crop production rather than consumption (van Dijk 1994; Verbeek et al. 1995; Salomon 2002). The prospects of true seed production in garlic could dramatically reduce the resources dedicated to this aspect of garlic production, especially if genetic resistance can be identified and incorporated into new cultivars.
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
215
III. GARLIC TAXONOMY AND GENETIC VARIATION Plant systematists have struggled with the taxonomy of garlic, Allium sativum L. It is a diploid species (2n = 2x = 16) in the subgenus Allium of the Alliaceae (formerly in the Liliaeceae, and then the Amaryllidaceae). The other cultivated plants in this subgenus are leek, usually tetraploid, or elephant garlic, usually hexaploid (both A. ampeloprasum L.). Leek and garlic have flat, folded leaves. Elephant garlic and garlic form a bulb, but leek does not. Elephant garlic bulbs consist of 2 to 6 large cloves and several small cloves, while garlic bulbs usually have more cloves of a relatively consistent size, especially for bolting types. Bolting garlic, leek, and elephant garlic all have a solid scape, unlike the hollow scape of the most economically important Allium, onion (A. cepa L.). Garlic flower color ranges from white to pink to purple and inflorescences almost always include not only flowers but also bulbils (small, undivided bulbs occurring in the inflorescence; also referred to as “topsets” or “air bulbs”), whereas A. ampeloprasum inflorescences form bulbils only sporadically. Early classifications considered A. sativum to be a species known only in cultivation, with A. longicuspis Rgl. as a closely related wild relative originating in Central Asia (Vvedensky 1935; Jones and Mann 1963). The diversity of Central Asian garlic supports the idea that this region is the primary center of origin of garlic, although this region was likely much larger in past history (reviewed by Engeland 1991; Etoh and Simon 2002). The distinctiveness of A. longicuspis as a separate species, primarily differing from garlic in having exserted anthers, has been brought into question. Several botanical varieties of garlic are described in the literature, including A. sativum var. sativum L., which rarely or never flowers; A. sativum var. ophioscorodon (Link) Doll (the varietal name meaning “serpent garlic”), which regularly flowers; and A. sativum var. pekinense (Prokh.) Makino, which rarely flowers, like A. sativum var. sativum, but has wider leaves (Helm 1956; Jones and Mann 1963). Several other garlic subspecies names have been used in the literature. For example Kuznetsov (1954) and Kommisarov (1964, 1965) referred to ssp. vulgare and ssp. sagittatum, while Kazakova (1971, 1978) referred to ssp. sativum or mediterraneum and ssp. asia-mediae Kaz., but the contrast of bolting versus non-bolting has been the primary distinction made among subspecies. Most recent considerations of A. sativum taxonomy include either two or three groups. Hanelt (1990) included a “common garlic group” (consisting of A. sativum var. sativum, A. sativum var. typicum Rgl., and A. pekinense Prokh.) and an “ophioscorodon group” (consisting of A. sativum var. ophioscorodon (Link) Doll, A. ophioscorodon Link, and A. sativum var. controversum (Schrad.)
216
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
Moore jr.), while Fritsch and Friesen (2002) added a third “longicuspis group” (consisting of A. longicuspis Rgl.). More recently, A. tuncelianum has been proposed as the wild progenitor of garlic (Mathew 1996). This suggestion has generated discussion (Etoh and Simon 2002; Fritsch and Friesen 2002), including the point that garlic is regarded as a Central Asian species, while A. tuncelianum is currently found in Turkey. A wide range of morphological diversity has been observed in garlic, including flowering ability (and scape length of flowering clones), leaf traits (color and attitude), bulb traits (shape, outer leaf scale color, clove color, number, size, and organization of cloves), plant maturity, bulbing response to temperature and photoperiod, cold-hardiness, bulbil traits (number, size, color, and ease of removal), and flower traits (timing, number, size, color, petal closure, and stigma position) (McCollum 1976; Hwang 1993; Messian et al. 1993; Lallemand et al. 1997; Hong et al. 2000a; Senula and Keller 2000; Jenderek and Hannan 2002). Detailed classification of garlic germplasm collections based solely on morphological diversity has been considered difficult due to the subjective nature of categorization for several of these traits, although Hwang (1993) and Senula and Keller (2000) were able to develop detailed comparisons based upon principal component analysis of 10 traits and cluster analysis of 16 traits. Concomitant with this morphological variation, evaluations of molecular variation have noted significant levels of variation in isozymes, RAPDs, and AFLPs (Etoh and Ogura 1981; Siqueria et al. 1985; Etoh 1985; Tsuneyoshi et al. 1992; Pooler and Simon 1993a; Maaß and Klaas 1995; Bradley et al. 1996; Al-Zahim et al. 1997; Lallemand et al. 1997; Hong et al. 1997; Etoh et al. 2001; Garcia Lampasona et al. 2002; Ipek et al. 2003). In earlier studies utilizing isozymes, relatively few polymorphisms were detected and consequently unique “fingerprints” were unable to be determined for even clearly morphologically different clones, whereas with the utilization of RAPDs, and more recently AFLP molecular markers, hundreds of polymorphic bands can be detected to allow for clear demarcations of differences in diverse garlic germplasm collections. Generally the groupings ascertained by morphological variation are positively correlated with molecular variation, and clustering of clones in the ophioscorodon and “common” (sativum) botanical varieties is evident. Maaß and Klaas (1995) included subtropical and pekinense clones in their study, and suggested that subtropical clones were “clearly separated from all other types,” while the pekinense subgroup was relatively similar to the stalking types. Interestingly, most molecular “fingerprinting” studies which included A. longicuspis clones produced no basis for distinction between A. sativum and A. longicuspis as separate species. Field evaluation of a genetically—and
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
217
geographically—diverse collection of all A. sativum subspecies, A. longicuspis, and A. tuncelianum in very diverse climates, combined with molecular fingerprinting, may help further resolve garlic taxonomy. A combination of field evaluation and molecular fingerprinting will also be helpful in characterizing world garlic cultivars. Cultivars are clones, so any garlic production plot is expected to be genetically invariable. Molecular fingerprinting studies have demonstrated wide DNA variation concomitant with wide phenotypic variation observed among cultivars in a growing area. However, it is not known how cultivars from one region compare to those from another, since cultivar names are rarely constant over diverse growing areas. Knowledge of these relationships may shed light on crop history and adaptation. Variation among chromosomes in the garlic karyotype has also been noted for centromere location, chromosome length, and the number of chromosome satellites (Takenaka 1931; Krivenko 1938; Mensinkai 1939; Battaglia 1963; Gohil and Koul 1971; Konvicka and Levan 1972; Verma and Mittal 1976; Etoh and Ogura 1978; Etoh 1979; Etoh 1983b; Etoh 1985; Hong et al. 2000a). The extensive karyotypic evaluation by Hong et al. (2000a) demonstrated a preponderance of the “basic” karyotype (2 sets of chromosomes) in bolting Central Asian clones proven to produce seed, while a collection of partial-bolting clones from the Iberian Peninsula usually had “non-basic” karyotypes, including heteromorphic pairs and unusual chromosome variation in terms of centromere location and/or satellites. Assessment of morphological variation in garlic can be complicated by what is perceived as a gradual response by garlic to the environment. For example, an accurate assessment of yield, maturity, and even flowering ability for a garlic clone is often reserved until 3–5 years of propagation after arrival at a new location (Engeland 1991; Pooler 1991), especially if large changes in photoperiod or climate are involved. With this, garlic clones adapted to shorter summer photoperiods (i.e., at lower latitudes) will usually grow well the first year or two after being moved to a long summer photoperiod environment, but in subsequent years smaller bulbs are produced and eventually no bulbing occurs before senescence, and the clone is lost. This is thought to be a photoperiod response, but it is unproven. One variable that has a significant negative effect on garlic performance and a confounding effect on germplasm evaluation is virus infection. The potyviruses onion yellow dwarf virus and leek yellow stripe virus are most economically important. Because virus infection is so common in garlic, and resistance has not been identified, there has been extensive research and effort devoted to generating virus-free garlic for production areas around the world (van Dijk 1994; Verbeek et al. 1995;
218
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
Salomon 2002). It is not uncommon for the virus-freeing process to increase garlic yield from 5 to 20% with a delay of plant senescence of up to 5 weeks. IV. GARLIC GROWTH AND REPRODUCTIVE BIOLOGY A. Morphology and Growth Factors influencing garlic morphology and growth have been discussed in many reports, including several comprehensive studies (Mann 1952; Mann and Minges 1958; Takagi 1990). The garlic bulb of commerce typically weighs 60 to 120 g, and consists of cloves surrounded by the dried basal sheaths of the foliage leaves. Bolting garlic bulbs usually consist of 4–12 cloves that tend to be relatively similar in size, while nonbolting garlic usually have more cloves that can vary greatly in size. Cloves are sessile lateral bulbs, that originate from axillary buds of inner (younger) foliage leaves. An outer, thin protective leaf and an inner, thickened, bladeless storage leaf are the most predominant parts of a garlic clove, with the storage leaf accounting for most of the volume and weight of the clove. The storage leaf subtends a central vegetative bud over a flattened basal plate, which is a modified very short stem. The central vegetative bud includes a predominant sprout leaf and several foliage leaf primordia that surround the apical meristem. The growth of a garlic plant typically begins from an individual clove that has been exposed to cool temperatures (15°C or less) and depleted or “broken” dormancy (Rahim and Fordham 1988; Takagi 1990). Depending upon how long the mature bulb was stored, the sprout leaf and foliage leaves may still be contained within the storage leaf, or may have elongated (sprouted) through the top of that leaf to protrude above it. Roots grow quickly around the perimeter of the basal plate and precede further leaf development. Leaves arise in an opposite and alternate orientation. Since a given leaf blade emanates from a broad meristematic arch, the bases of consecutive leaves are extensively overlapped. This overlap of leaf bases results in the production of a “pseudostem” that consists of closely appressed leaf sheaths surrounding young leaves. Above the pseudostem, leaf blades extend without overlap. The root system and flat leaves usually develop before clove initiation (bulbing) ensues from inner (younger) leaf axillary buds. Many variables, including storage, temperature, growing temperature, planting time, and photoperiod, interact with clove size and the genetic predisposition of a garlic clone to determine the number and size of leaves and cloves realized in a production cycle. Plant maturation and senescence usually ensues after garlic bulb production. As the main stem of the bulb dies,
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
219
intact and living basal plates remain on each clove to carry on future growth. Studies investigating broad ranges in photoperiod, air and soil temperature, and light intensity during production, and bulb storage time and temperature have noted relatively small effects on garlic leaf size and number, bulb and clove size, and bulb dormancy, compared to the effects of those environmental variables in other Alliaceae (Takagi 1990; Pooler and Simon 1993b), although extended cold storage increased the incidence of flowering plants for some clones, shading slowed maturity and reduced yield, and “short day” cultivars often produced small, undivided bulbs (“rounds”) in long photoperiods. B. Reproductive Biology Most reports of garlic morphology and growth focus on the plant and bulb, although several include evaluations of floral initiation and development (Vanin 1947; Aoba 1966; Takagi 1990; Pooler and Simon 1993b). Like other alliums, garlic flowers are perfect, with 6 petals, 6 anthers, and 3 locules consisting of 2 ovules each (Fig. 5.1). Garlic flowers are smaller
Fig. 5.1.
Garlic flowers and a bulbil from a male fertile clone.
220
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
than onion. The number of flowers in an umbel varies from less than 10 to over 300, but the typical range is from 150 to 200. The inception of routine seed production in garlic has provided a wealth of information about its reproductive biology (Etoh 1985; Pooler and Simon 1994; Jenderek 1998). Garlic flowers are protandrous with 2 to 4 days between pollen shedding and stigma receptivity. The stigma is receptive for 1 to 2 days and styles are usually longer than petals. Across a garlic inflorescence, anthesis occurs over 5 to 20 days. The opposing petals of most mature garlic flowers form an angle of approximately 45° although some seed-derived plants have nearly closed petals. Petal color in bolting garlic clones is usually light purple, with or without darker coloration of pedicel and petal tip. In seed-derived plants, lilac and white petals also occur. Anthers of typical clonally-propagated garlic are yellow or purple, while in seed-derived plants light gray and lilac anthers also occur. Development of the floral apical meristem in bolting garlic requires exposure to low temperatures (< 5°C) before onset of the primary growth period. The details of garlic vernalization requirements are not well known. Most garlic is fall planted and if winter temperatures are lower than 5°C, the bolting phenotype is presumed to be induced. However, a systematic study of cold-treated non-bolting garlic clones typically grown in warmer climates could reveal bolting clones. A very significant genetic predisposition contributes to flowering in garlic, as some clones almost never flower with inductive conditions (non-bolting clones), while others flower readily (bolting clones) (Takagi 1990; Pooler and Simon 1993b). No treatment to routinely induce flowering in non-bolting garlic has yet been devised. As with other alliums, garlic clones that tend to flower must attain a minimum size or physiological maturity to realize that potential. Therefore, spring planting, which reduces bulb yield and does not allow enough time for plants to reach a certain maturity level, can significantly reduce or eliminate flowering. Low and, especially, high temperatures during inflorescence and scape elongation can also result in incomplete bolting (Takagi 1990). The garlic seed stalk develops from the tip of the main stem, precluding further vegetative growth (Mann 1952). Seed stalk formation represents the only significant internode elongation in the life of a garlic plant. Early scape elongation precedes any visible indication in the apical meristem that floral development is commencing. During scape elongation the meristematic region at its tip begins to differentiate floral initials and subdivides into identifiable flowers interspersed with bulbils (Kothari and Shah 1974a,b; Etoh and Ogura 1977; Etoh 1985; QuYing et al. 1994; Kamenetsky and Rabinowitch 2001, 2002). For incomplete bolting clones, the arrested scape development often results in a very short scape with flower and bulbil formation ranging from
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
221
slightly above the cloves within the bulb, to a more elevated position in the pseudostem, to a short stem protruding slightly above the pseudostem. Complete bolting in garlic involves floral induction, scape elongation, inflorescence development, and floral maturation (Takagi 1990; Kamenetsky and Rabinowitch 2001, 2002). Clove development tends to be initiated somewhat earlier in the development of non-bolting plants than in incomplete or complete bolting plants, suggesting that there is a balance or competition between bulb and inflorescence development, with bulb development taking precedence and floral development being optional. The extent to which a plant initiates floral development is strongly influenced by genotype and contingent upon exposure to low temperatures. During the growth of flowering garlic, there is a balance or competition between storage organs and flowers in terms of relative development and resource allocation (Pooler 1991; Pooler and Simon 1993b, 1994). The interplay between clove development in the bulb (bulb formation) and clove development in the inflorescence (bulbil formation) at the whole plant level seems to have a counterpart in the interplay between flowers and bulbils within the inflorescence. Bulbing without floral initiation and development is common, as seen in non-bolting garlic, but floral development without bulbing is not reported except for rare instances during in vitro cultivation. In most bolting cultivated garlic, bulbil formation takes precedence over floral development, although usually not to the complete exclusion of at least some floral development. Thus we can represent the relative strength of these three competing resource sinks as follows: 1. Bulb development excludes bulbil and flower development in non-bolting or unvernalized bolting plants; 2. Bulb development predominates over bulbil development and flower development in most cultivated bolting garlic plants; or 3. Bulb development, bulbil development, and flower development occur in some bolting cultivars, wild garlic, and some seedlings. Once the environmental conditions to stimulate floral development have been met, the rate and degree of floral and bulbil development varies widely among flowering garlic clones (Fig. 5.2). Without the development of mature flowers, the production of viable gametes and seed is not possible. Garlic fertility is primarily determined by genetic background, and fertile clones usually have numerous healthy flowers and small bulbils. Infertile, barren flowering clones vary widely in floral and bulbil development. Large bulbils usually indicate little potential for seed production. For some barren clones, mature healthy-appearing flowers develop, but many barren clones develop flowers that senesce early in the bud stage before buds even reach meiosis so mature flowers never
222
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
Fig. 5.2. Inflorescences from six garlic clones with bulbils and senesced flowers late in the season.
develop (Weber 1929; Gvaladze 1965; Etoh 1985; Pooler and Simon 1994). The causes of this form of sterility have not been studied. Examination of developing flowers during scape elongation also noted abortion of some flowers in fertile clones (Qu-Ying et al. 1994). Floral development is no guarantee of viable gamete production. Studies of 154 diverse primarily Eastern garlic clones (Etoh 1985) and of 210 Central and Western clones (Pooler and Simon 1994) yielded complete bolting in 46% and 65% of the clones, respectively, but in the latter study about 1/2 to 2/3 of these clones failed to develop fully mature flowers,
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
223
since buds withered and died. This premature senescence takes several forms. In some clones, sporogenous tissue failed to enter meiosis, while in others microsporogenesis was complete, but then microspores degenerated at, or beyond, the tetrad stage. In the former study, one flowering clone developed fertile pollen, while in the latter study 27 male fertile clones were recorded, and in both studies these were Central Asian clones. Numerous other clones from the region of garlic’s center of diversity have also been collected and found to be male fertile (Etoh 1986; Etoh et al. 1992; Pooler and Simon 1994; Hong and Etoh 1996; Hong et al. 2000a). The causes of garlic floral abortion and sterility are not well understood. An accumulation of pathogens, chromosome aberrations, postmeiotic tapetal degeneration, and unsuccessful competition of floral development with bulbils have been implicated as contributing to the failure of flowers to develop (Etoh 1985). Konvicka and co-workers noted leaf necrosis in flowering plants and microscopic inclusions resembling rickettsia-like organisms, both of which became less apparent with antibiotic treatments (tetracycline and tylosine) of cut stems (Konvicka 1973, 1984; Konvicka et al. 1978). Some clones with complete synapsis, bivalent formation, and normal microsporogenesis are male sterile. In these clones, tapetal hypertrophy and other disturbances inhibit further microspore development (Novak 1972; Etoh 1982). These observations were interpreted by Konvicka to support a pathogenic cause of garlic floral abortion and sterility. However, Novak and Havranek (1975) and Pooler (1991) observed ambiguous results with antibiotic treatments, while Etoh (1980) observed phytotoxicity and arrested development of pollen with antibiotic treatment of cut scapes. Furthermore, the extensive production of virus-free garlic has not resulted in increased fertility of bolting clones, although it could be argued that the methods to produce virus-free garlic may not be expected to also remove rickettsia-like organisms. Until further substantiation is provided, a pathogenic basis for floral abortion and male sterility in garlic seems unlikely. While some karyotypic variation was noted in mitosis of diverse garlic clones, evaluations of meiosis indicate an interesting general difference between clones collected in Central Asia (including those from the wild), east of that region, or west of it (which we refer to as Central, Eastern, and Western clones, respectively) that relate to fertility and perhaps floral abortion (Table 5.2). Several authors have observed quadrivalents, hexavalents, octavalents, and decavalents in microsporogenesis of numerous diverse bolting Eastern garlic clones that were all male sterile, while only a small number of Eastern clones, notably those from India, had all bivalents in the first meiotic division. These Eastern clones with bivalents may represent the subtropical group noted by Maaß and Klaas (1995) to differ significantly from other Eastern garlic based on
224 Table 5.2.
Reports of garlic flowering, meiosis, and male fertility. No. clones evaluatedz
Reference
Meioticy configuration
No. clones flowering
Takenaka 1931 Katayama 1936
1E 3E
1 3
Krivenko 1938 Kononkov 1953 Takenaka 1953 Shimada and Shozaki 1954 Gvaladze 1961
1C 1C 1E 1E
No. malefertile clones
1 1 1 1
II and multivalents 8 II (1 clone); 1 VI & 5 II (2 clones) 8 II — IV, VI, VIII + II —
1 1 0 0
1C
1
variable
Partial
Gvaladze 1965
—
—
—
Koul and Gohil 1970 Gohil and Koul 1971 Konvicka and Levan 1972 Konvicka 1972 Novak 1972
3 E? (not specified) 1 E (India)
3
8 II
50–60% fertile pollen; 1–3% normal ovules 0
1
Desynapsis (I)
0
4W
3
0
1W 1W+1 A. longicuspis
1 2
8 II in most meiocytes; IV in one clone 8 II 8 II
Remarks
0 0
0 0
Climate limits seed production Seed produced Better flower retention with bulbil removal Better flower retention with bulbil removal; suggested aposporic origins of seed
Normal meiosis, but microspores degenerate
Post-meiotic tapetal degeneration
Konvicka 1973
14 W
14
8 II predominate
Novak and Havranek 1975
2 W+ 1 A. longicuspis
3
8 II
Konvicka et al. 1978
3W
3
8 II
Etoh and Ogura 1978 Koul et al. 1979
1E
1
5 E (India)
2 or more
VIII + 4 II usually; never 8 II 8 II
Etoh 1979 Cheng 1982 Etoh 1983a
43 (39 E + 4W) 1 28 (25 E + 2 W + 1 C)
43 1 28
Etoh 1983b
153
72
Etoh 1985
154
71 complete 57 partial
VI, VIII, or X + II II 8 II in 2 clones (1 W + 1 C); VI or VIII + II in 25 sterile 8 II in fertile clones; VI, VIII, or X + II in sterile clones 8 II in fertile clones; VI, VIII, or X + II in sterile clones
0 (with no antibiotics) to 14 (with antibiotics) 0
0 (with no antibiotics) to 3 (with antibiotics) 0 0
0 0 1C
1C
1C
Postmeiotic disturbances alleviated with application of tetracycline Binucleate pollen not viable; better flower retention with bulbil removal and cut stems Postmeiotic disturbances; better flower retention with bulbil removal
2, 4 - D and gamma-irradiation do not improve flower retention; better flower retention with bulbil removal Bulbils compete with flowers Male fertile clone from Moscow; fertile flowers have violet anthers Seed produced
Bulbil number correlated with flower number; partial bolting clones failed to retain flowers to meiosis in 50 of 57 clones
225 (continued)
226 Table 5.2.
Continued
Reference
No. clones evaluatedz
Meioticy configuration
No. clones flowering
No. malefertile clones
Etoh 1986
31C
31
8 II
14
Bozzini 1991 Etoh et al. 1992 Pooler and Simon 1994 Hong and Etoh 1996 Hong et al. 2000a
1 several 210 W and C
1
—
137
8 II in 29 examined
1 several 27
42 C
42
8 II in 39/42
31/35
30 W + 30 C
0 W (all partial bolting) + 29 C 38
Not reported
9 (all C)
8 II in 5 of 5
15 (14 C + 1 E)
Etoh et al. 2001 z
38 (33C + 4W + 1 E)
Remarks Fertile flowers have purple anthers; several male sterile, female fertile clones Tetraploid, not garlic?
Fertile flowers have purple anthers
Clones collected in Central Asia (C), East of center (E), and west of center (W). I, II, III, IV, VI, VIII, and X refer to univalents, bivalents, trivalents and associations of 4, 6, 8, and 10 chromosomes at meiosis I, respectively.
y
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
227
molecular “fingerprinting.” The multivalent associations in Eastern garlic north of India indicate a clear basis for their male sterility, since gametes that result will have unbalanced chromosome sets. In contrast, Central and Western garlic clones usually form only bivalents, with multivalents rarely noted, although desynapsis has been noted in some clones. Yet Western garlic clones are almost always male sterile, while Central clones are often fertile. Post-meiotic tapetal degeneration is observed in those Western clones closely analyzed (Novak 1972; Gori and Ferri 1982; Gori 1983), as well as in sterile Eastern clones (Etoh 1982), but the cause of degeneration is not known. Genetic and cytoplasmic male sterility in seed-propagated crops is only beginning to be understood after much effort, and a similar mechanism accounting for male sterility in Western garlic may be uncovered. A fourth contributor to impaired garlic floral development in some studies points to unsuccessful floral competition with bulbils. Katarzhin and Katarzhin (1982) and Etoh (1983b, 1997) produced garlic seed without bulbil removal, but Konvicka (1984), Pooler and Simon (1994), and Jenderek (1998) removed bulbils during floral development to improve development of flowers and seed, although it should be noted that this was only successful for clones with some male fertility without this procedure. It is reasoned that developing flowers are relatively poor competitors with bulbils for photosynthate and, at least in some cases, this competition results in floral abortion. Verification of this hypothesis has not yet been forthcoming. Konvicka (1984) and Pooler and Simon (1994) carried this notion a step further and decapitated garlic plants just above the pseudostem around the time when the scapes were nearly fully elongated. These cut stems were then placed in containers of water (with and without antibiotics, respectively) for pollination and seed development, with good success. The rationale for this treatment is that developing flowers also compete poorly with the developing bulb. Experiments demonstrating a clear, positive effect from this treatment (versus seed production on intact plants) have not been reported. V. GARLIC SEED PRODUCTION A. Importance of Garlic Germplasm for Seed Production One recurring observation made in all recent studies seeking garlic flowering and seed formation is the need to include a diverse range of garlic germplasm with an emphasis on Central Asian cultivated clones and Allium longicuspis (reviewed by Etoh and Simon 2002) (Table 5.3). The
228
Table 5.3.
Reports of garlic seed production. No. Clones
Reference Kononkov 1953 Gvaladze 1961 Katarzhin and Katarzhin 1978 Katarzhin and Katarzhin 1982
Etoh 1983b Konvicka 1984 Etoh 1985 Etoh et al. 1988 Pooler and Simon 1994 Inaba et al. 1995 Hong and Etoh 1996 Etoh 1997 Jenderek 1998 Hong et al. 2000c
No. seeds produced
Germination rate (%)
Evaluated
Flowering
Producing seed
Several Several 120
+ + +
1 1 >1
1 1 —
1 1 —
Several
—
4
—
—
25.90 41.50 36.80
153 7 2
72 7 2
1 7 2
3 to 83 9.60
17 210
17 137
17 11
80 .0
—
—
—
0.01
42
39
17
12.30 0 to 100 up to 93 0.02
17 10.0 421 49 original + 124 previously derived from seed
17 10 — —
17 10 64 —
27 41 200 harvested, 85 mature 22,850 655 52,508 346 3481 (1984) >7000 (1985) >2M >3500
Remarks Bulbil removal Two generations produced in field conditions The first seed generation was without bulbil removal; two generations of seeds were produced Bulbil removal Seed production from cross-pollination
Four cycles of selection, up to 248 seeds/plant All seed from selfpollination Multiple pollination Up to 656 seeds/plant Inclement weather limited seed production
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
229
first three reports of garlic seed production came from research in the Soviet Union apparently using germplasm from Central Asia and neighboring regions (Kononkov 1953; Gvaladze 1961; Katarzhin and Katarzhin 1978, 1982). Etoh and co-workers (Etoh 1983b, 1985, 1997; Etoh et al. 1988; Inaba et al. 1995; Hong and Etoh 1996; Hong et al. 2000c) included Central Asian germplasm in their materials, which resulted in successful production of seed. Konvicka (1984) used a diverse germplasm collection in his successful production of garlic seed. Pooler and Simon (1994) found especially good seed production with recently collected wild garlic from Central Asia. Jenderek (1998) also utilized a very diverse germplasm collection of garlic originating from 41 countries, including many from the former USSR, for highly successful seed production. As Central Asia is the center of garlic germplasm diversity and only area where wild garlic or Allium longicuspis still occurs, it seems likely that the broad genetic variation observed in visible characters as well as molecular assessments likely contributed significantly to successful seed production. In fact, we may infer that sexual reproduction in wild, and perhaps cultivated, Central Asian garlic has served as the reservoir of recombination to generate most of the new genetic diversity of this crop. As migrating hunters and gatherers, and more recently travelers followed major migration and trade routes through Central Asia, it is easy to envision them collecting and carrying wild garlic for cultivation far from that region. This process likely continues today. Based on molecular fingerprinting, it does not appear that newly collected garlic from Central Asia represents a different basic gene pool from clones long propagated in cultivation and collected around the world. Therefore, we may speculate that long-term cultivation and even selection has brought an accumulation of genetic changes that limit the ability of garlic to flower and produce seeds. Long-term asexual propagation is well known to accumulate structural and numerical chromosome aberrations (Sharma 1956), which appears to be the likely mechanism for male sterility in Eastern garlic. But other genomic changes that affect gene expression, such as altered patterns of DNA methylation, may account for male sterility in Western garlic. Experiments comparing clonally propagated garlic with true seedlings may lead to a better understanding of the mechanisms contributing to the success or failure of garlic flowering, fertility, and seed production. B. Processes and Procedures for Garlic Seed Production With the discovery of several sources of male fertile garlic, the prospects for seed production and breeding seemed likely. Yet while the
230
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
development of fertile flowers in garlic is necessary for seed production and breeding, it is not sufficient. Once fertile clones are identified in diverse germplasm, flowers must be pollinated and seed produced; seed must be harvested, stored and germinated; and seedlings must be grown to plants to move forward in a breeding program. The extensive research contributions of T. Etoh in seeking male fertility and successful seed production in garlic are particularly notable in their breadth and depth. 1. Pollination and Seed Production. Optimal plant growth conditions contribute to successful garlic seed production. Fall planting in a climate that induces bolting is essential. Once bolting plants produce mature flowers in the spring or summer, they must be prepared for pollination. In more optimal climates, garlic seed production is most straightforward on plants growing in the field since this is where optimal growth occurs. This requires situating plants at planting time to accommodate pollinating cages, if they will be placed over flowering plants the following spring. Alternatively, in less optimal climates, field-grown plants can be used as a source of cut stems to perform seed production at a different site. This practice allows bulbil removal and pollination to be performed outside the field, for example, in a laboratory or air-conditioned greenhouse. Garlic cut stems are prepared by severing the scape just above the pseudostem when the scape is fully, or almost, straightened and usually after bulbil removal. Cutting the stem too early can impede full development of the inflorescence. Adequate photosynthate is apparently provided by the scape, as seed production capacity does not appear to be limited by this procedure. Production of garlic seed on cut stems is more labor-intensive than seed production on plants in the field, and consequently would not be practical for commercial large-scale production of seed, but the flexibility it provides will likely recommend its continued use in small-scale breeding programs, or in making initial crosses in larger programs. Bulbil removal is very conducive to prevention of early senescence of flowers (Fig. 5.3), but it is not required for all clones, especially in the second and subsequent generations of seed production. Bulbil removal is a time-intensive and tedious exercise that involves opening the spathe of inflorescences while bulbils are no larger than 2 to 5 mm in diameter, followed by extirpation of all visible bulbils. Care is required in finding all bulbils while not damaging the developing flowers, which are smaller than the bulbils and much more fragile. After the initial removal of bulbils, a second removal 3 to 7 days later is useful to extirpate bulbils that typically remain.
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
231
Fig. 5.3. Garlic flower development. Early (a and b) and late (c and d) flowering in the same clone where bulbils have been removed (a and c) or retained (b and d). Fertilized ovules swelling late in the season for clones with few (e) and many (f) flowers.
232
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
The most promising flowers for successful seed production usually have pigmented (purple or red) anthers and are male fertile (Etoh 1983a; Konvicka 1984; Etoh 1986; Etoh et al. 1988; Pooler and Simon 1994; Hong and Etoh 1996), although some male fertile plants with yellow anthers do occur and such plants produce seeds (Pooler and Simon 1994; Jenderek 1998). Furthermore, male sterile plants can still be female fertile and set seed. This fact creates an opportunity to produce F1 hybrid garlic seed by isolating a male sterile/female fertile clone with a fully fertile clone during pollination. Pollen stainability and germination varied widely among those garlic clones first used for seed production. For example, Hong and Etoh (1996) and Jenderek and Hannan (2000) observed pollen stainability from 0% up to 98.3%. Pollen germination rate is generally lower than stainability. Pooler and Simon (1994) found from 0% to 10.5% germination, while 0.7% to 49.7% was reported by Hong and Etoh (1996) and Jenderek and Hannan (2000). Although male fertility is associated mainly with purple anthers, stainable pollen in yellow anthers was as high as 68.6% with pollen germination rates of 30.1% in the latter study. To ensure garlic seed production, several authors have used multiple pollination (repeated hand pollination of the same flowers over several days) (Etoh 1983b; Pooler and Simon 1994; Etoh 1997). It is not clear that this practice always improves the seed set. Several pollination vectors have been used to produce garlic seed. Collection of anthers or pollen with a forceps, on a glass slide, or small brush has been used on a small scale, usually with repeated pollen application to the same flowers over several days. Emasculation has been used to eliminate self-pollination, but it is a tedious exercise. Honey bees (Apis mellifera), houseflies (Musca domestica), leaf cutter bees (Megachile rotundata), and bluebottle flies (Protophormia terraenovae) have been used successfully as pollinators in isolation cages. As the style of garlic flowers is small and delicate (Fig. 5.1), seed production in some clones suffers from rough handling and honeybee pollination. Success with bluebottle fly pollination has been very good, and this is the main pollination vector currently used in much garlic true seed production. Diseases, pests, and weather can take a significant toll on garlic pollination and seed formation. In particular, floral pests such as thrips and mites can quickly decimate recently pollinated flowers and lead to crop failure. Inclement weather such as heavy wind and rain can also interfere with pollination and damage plants in the field (e.g., Etoh et al. 1988). A serious threat to true seed production occurs with hot weather (over 30°C) persisting for several days during anthesis when pollen via-
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
233
bility declines rapidly, flowers wither, and flower stalks senesce rapidly. Heat sensitivity varies widely among diverse clones. 2. Seed Harvest, Storage, and Germination. Garlic seed harvest is similar to onion seed harvest. Dried inflorescences are crushed to release seeds, and seeds are separated from chaff. Small seeds are frequently inviable and often occur with great regularity, especially in early generation materials. All seeds are planted in hopes of germination, but as selection for greater viability and seedling vigor proceeds in advanced generations, procedures such as seed separation in a wind column are used to remove chaff and light seed and leave heavier, more vigorous seed. The number of seeds produced by an inflorescence depends on several variables, including genotype and growing conditions. Clonal planting material produced up to 50 seeds/umbel (Etoh et al. 1988; Jenderek and Hannan 2002), whereas maternal plants derived from true seeds produced 656 seeds/umbel (Etoh et al. 1988; Jenderek 1998). Garlic seeds are approximately half the size of onion seeds, resembling them in shape and color (Fig. 5.4). The size of true seeds in garlic depends
Fig. 5.4.
Garlic (above) and onion seeds. Bar = 1 mm.
234
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
on the genotype of parental lines. Early publications documenting the ability of certain garlic clones to set a limited number of seeds inspired a series of experiments evaluating conditions and treatments that stimulate seed germination, including hormone treatments, stratification, scarification, and moist chilling. Hormone treatments proved ineffective (Etoh 1983b; Etoh et al. 1988; Inaba et al. 1995). In vitro seed germination allows for easy evaluation of germinating seeds, but requires high labor input with no apparent improvement in germination rate (Pooler and Simon 1994). Like many Allium species, garlic has some seed dormancy, which is reduced by cold treatments. Germination rates in clones that had been long propagated asexually ranged from 10% to 35% with some seeds still beginning to germinate 12 months after onset of germination conditions. Breeding efforts have increased germination rates to at least 65%, and up to 100%. 3. Growing Seedlings to Plants. Vigorous growth of garlic seedlings is difficult to achieve in early generations of seed production. Seedling growth is often weak and slow, so optimal growing medium, moisture, and freedom from pests and diseases is essential. Like onion and leek, garlic seed germinates epigeally with the bent cotyledon first to emerge. As with plant development from cloves or bulbils, leaves arise from the apical meristem to generate 5 to 15 leaves, depending on genotype, temperature, and photoperiod. The time from germination to 3 true leaves can take as long as 4 months. Pseudostem development is not very prominent in small seedlings. If seedlings grow large enough, flowering can occur in the first year in optimal growth conditions with the best genetic selections. Usually only one scape and inflorescence forms in flowering garlic, and that in the second year, however 2–3 stalks per plant may develop. A broad range of phenotypic variation is evident in bulbs that develop from true seed (Fig. 5.5). Garlic seedling vigor and consequently survival usually increases with progressing seed cycles. Populations of all early generation seed derived plants carry, to various degrees, unfavorable characteristics, such as stunted or aberrant growth, or chlorophyll deficiencies. In fact, plants in these early generations can manifest unfavorable growth even in more mature plants. These can include deformed leaves, stunted roots, and limited bulb production (although the latter trait could be a photoperiod response). The appearance of these traits is more frequent in progenies derived from self-pollination (Jenderek 2002), but surviving seedlings and subsequent generations are usually more vigorous in growth, and often they surpass the vigor of plants grown from clonal material.
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
Fig. 5.5.
235
Garlic bulbs from true seed.
VI. PROGRESS IN GARLIC BREEDING AND FUTURE PROSPECTS Before the development of techniques to produce garlic seed in relatively large quantities, garlic breeding was not a realistic possibility. In fact, there is no evidence indicating that sexual reproduction and selection were ever utilized by garlic growers throughout history so that, while garlic has been one of the longest cultivated horticultural crops, breeding the crop has just begun. Clonal selection has been successful in altering some traits in garlic such as clove number and earliness (Burba 1997) and routine treatments to reduce or eliminate viruses clearly improve production (van Dijk 1994; Verbeek et al. 1995; Salomon 2002), but without sexual reproduction, desired traits found in different clones cannot be combined. With the possibility of seed production, garlic breeding can commence. Information on the current status of true seed derived plants is scarce, as most of the large-scale seed production has been performed by private industry. The United States Patent and Trade Office lists three seed derived cultivars to be propagated by cloves. The area in cultivation utilizing those cultivars is not reported.
236
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
A. Selection for Improved Floral Characteristics and Fertility Although the asexually propagated bolting garlic clones used worldwide typically produce inflorescences with predominant bulbils and completely or nearly sterile flowers, selection for improved floral characteristics and fertility has generally been successful. Reduced numbers of small, easy-to-remove bulbils is typically very rapid, so that after two or three generations of seed propagation, bulbil removal is not necessary in some breeding stocks, although they usually are still present. It may, in fact, be possible to breed for bulbil-free strains in some genetic backgrounds. Selection progress for improved male fertility is also rapid, with high levels of pollen stainability common in the first generation progeny of sexual reproduction. It is presumed that the cleansing effect of meiosis to generate balanced gametes immediately results in meiotic stability and female fertility, although published data are lacking. There is cytological evidence that demonstrates that translocations and inversions occur in many Eastern garlic clones, so one can speculate that some fertile seed progeny of these clones may harbor homozygous translocations or inversions that have no effect upon selfing or intercrossing with similar strains. However, upon crossing with strains lacking these aberrations, sterile translocation or inversion heterozygotes would result. No observations of this type have been published to date. However, several molecular markers have been identified to assist in selection for male fertility so that fertility may be predicted long before a plant flowers (Etoh 1985; Hong et al. 1997, 2000b). B. Selection for Improved Seed Size and Vigor Selection for improved seed vigor and size can be dramatic after two or three cycles. Sizable variation in seed size has been noted in early generation seed progeny, and breeding efforts to date have succeeded in selecting for seed size ranging from 339 to 496 seeds/gram (Jenderek 1998). After two to three generations of selection for improved seed germination, germination rates of 65% to 93% have been routinely observed (Inaba et al. 1995; Jenderek 1998), a dramatic improvement over the low rates of 10% to 35% observed in first generation seed. Like any plant breeding effort, selection is not successful in all genetic stocks. Selection efforts to date have proved that the yield of true seeds could be improved significantly. The possible number of seeds produced by one inflorescence can be up to 1200 seeds in umbels with 200 flowers, based on the assumption that one flower has a potential of developing six seeds.
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
237
C. Garlic Breeding Goals A very wide range of phenotypic variation has been observed in true garlic seed progenies, including variation in all of the characters discussed above in describing germplasm variation. Perhaps most interesting is the observation of non-bolting seedlings, since both parents were obviously bolting plants. These are unusual and no reports have described these segregants beyond first- and second-year field observations. In fact, general descriptions of genetic segregation for any trait in garlic are lacking. Most of the variation described has been for some of the typical bulb and flower traits, including outer and inner bulb scale color, clove number and color, time of bulb maturity, time of flowering, stalk length, and flower petal color, pedicel color, number, and ovary wall color. Given the range of flowering habits observed among diverse garlic clones, a better understanding of flowering genetics will be of particular interest. Of most interest to garlic growers are yield and bulb storage parameters, but no reports to date have included data detailing these attributes. A search for genetic resistance to viruses and other diseases ranks high among garlic breeding goals. Another very critical trait, likely associated closely with yield, is seedling vigor. This was a crucial variable contributing to the initial successes in obtaining garlic seed, and it will also be critical for success in developing seed-propagated garlic. Since clonally propagated garlic typically develops from a clove several grams in size, and a seedling has a weight equivalent to only a small fraction of a clove, early seedling vigor will be essential for crop propagation from seed. Perhaps other technologies such as transplanting of seedlings, rather than direct seeding, will also be used to make seed-propagated garlic a viable economic possibility, although this would add back another production cost and hence reduce the economic benefits of a seed-propagated crop. Field trails to evaluate the possibilities for direct seeding are underway and they will apply intense selection pressure to test the feasibility of seed-propagated garlic. D. Garlic Breeding Methods Initial efforts to produce garlic seed included only a very few fertile clones that were interpollinated and then progeny were either interpollinated again or self-pollinated. As garlic breeding proceeds, there are two distinct directions that can be taken: development of new clones for asexual propagation, or development of seed-propagated garlic cultivars. The development of new garlic clones for asexual propagation will follow the same process of evaluation and utilization as is currently being
238
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
used to evaluate new asexually propagated clones that have been acquired from abroad and are being tested for performance. In this system, individual seedlings will be selected based upon superior performance to be used as new clonally propagated cultivars using the same production techniques as have been used until now. The process of adequately testing a new seedling will take several years, since the increase of a single plant to produce an adequate supply of bulbs is necessary to perform replicated field trials, storage trials, and evaluation of added-value characteristics such as phytonutrient content or soluble solids. New cultivars developed this way must fit all existing parameters to meet grower and processor needs, but also exhibit enough superior traits or unique new combinations of traits to warrant considering replacing existing cultivars with them. New clonally propagated cultivars have likely been gradually replacing older ones in Central Asia throughout history, although this process has never been documented. An important question, which has not yet been answered, is whether new clones from seedlings can out-compete existing clonally propagated materials. Preliminary observations seem to indicate this will occur, but the superior traits offered by new clones selected from seedlings, and the number of existing cultivars that will be replaced is yet unknown. Likely, the large-scale production and processing industry will utilize new clonally propagated cultivars, but smaller-scale growers can benefit to the same extent in improving their operations. The new complication that garlic clones derived from seedlings bring to growers is a potentially huge influx of new clones to be tested. Increase of materials and proper testing over several years for large numbers of seedlings is a monumental task, so new clones from seedlings will likely require striking improvements over existing cultivars to warrant such an effort. The development of seed-propagated garlic cultivars is only in its very initial stages and no clear indication of its likelihood of success is possible for several years. The possibility that seed-propagated garlic will have low or no virus contamination is a strong incentive for true seed propagation. The combination of tissue culture to remove viruses, plus “seed” garlic field production costs exceed $2500/ha. If the costs of $300/ha for hybrid onion seed are an indication of how expensive garlic seed may someday be, then the economic incentive for true garlic seed is apparent. Inventory management, storage, and transportation costs also favor garlic seed over clonal propagation. Garlic breeding methods to be used include the usual recurrent phenotypic selection from (at least initially) a broad genetic base of materi-
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
239
als. As self-pollination has been demonstrated to be possible and to result in reasonably vigorous and more uniform families, it seems likely that cultivar development strategies for seed-propagated garlic will include an emphasis on inbred development for hybrid cultivars, like onions. Since male sterile/female fertile clones have been well documented, these clones are an obvious choice for seed parents. As for other outcrossing crop species, hybrid cultivars not only can take advantage of hybrid vigor (which has been widely observed in garlic but not reported), but they also encourage growers to return to seed producers for seed in subsequent production years. With the large investment involved in developing seed-propagated garlic, there is little incentive for large-scale seed producers to develop open-pollinated cultivars that could be seed propagated by the grower, although public sector programs may develop open-pollinated seed-propagated garlic cultivars.
VII. CONCLUSIONS Garlic is a widely recognized and appreciated crop with a long history of asexual propagation. Several inherent aspects of garlic growth and development combined with artifacts of its long asexual reproduction have resulted in a crop in which many clones do not flower, those flowering are nearly or completely sterile, bulbils usually suppress flower maturation, and first-generation seedlings are weak with a high incidence of abnormalities limiting normal growth and development. In spite of these facts, observations and experiments of the last 50 years, and especially the efforts of T. Etoh in the last 20 years, made it apparent that the production of true garlic seed is possible. Access to a diverse range of germplasm, particularly that from near its center of origin, combined with careful application of procedures to enhance seed production and growth, such as bulbil removal and careful seedling husbandry, has set the stage for true garlic seed production of the crop. Thus, the advantages that sexual reproduction brings in generating a balanced genome and combining traits from two unrelated parents could be captured. Utilizing these materials, methods, and meiosis, a small level of success in garlic seed production was realized. Taking advantage of the benefits of these breakthrough efforts, millions of garlic seeds have been generated in the last decade, and garlic breeding is underway. The potential for combining traits of diverse materials to develop new genotypes is only in its infancy, but much genetic variation is apparent and field testing of a seed-produced garlic crop is underway.
240
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
LITERATURE CITED Al-Zahim, M., H. J. Newbury, and B. V. Ford-Lloyd. 1997. Classification of genetic variation in garlic (Allium sativum L.) revealed by RAPD. HortScience 32:1102–1104. Aoba, T. 1966. Studies on bulb formation of garlic plants (in Japanese). J. Japan. Soc. Hort. Sci. 35:284. Battaglia, E. 1963. Mutazione cromosomica e cariotipo fondamentale in Allium sativum L. Caryologia 16:1–46. Bozzini, A. 1991. Discovery of an Italian fertile tetraploid line of garlic. Econ. Bot. 45:436–438. Bradley, K. F., M. A. Rieger, and G. G. Collins. 1996. Classification of Australian garlic cultivars by DNA fingerprinting. Austral. J. Expt. Agr. 36:613–618. Burba, J. L. 1997. Obtencion de nuevas culivares de ajo. 50 Temas Sobre Prod. de Ajo 2:49–53. Cheng, S. S. 1982. Sexual process in garlic (Allium sativum L. cv. ‘Chonan’). Proc. Trop. Region Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 25:69–72. Darlington, C. D. 1939. The evolution of genetic systems. Univ. Press, Cambridge. Engeland, R. L. 1991. Growing great garlic. Filaree Productions, Okanogan, WA. Etoh, T. 1979. Variation of chromosome pairings in various clones of garlic, Allium sativum L. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 15:63–72. Etoh, T. 1980. An attempt to obtain binucleate pollen of garlic, Allium sativum L. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 16:65–73. Etoh, T. 1982. Development and degeneration of the tapetum in garlic, Allium sativum L. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 18:75–84. Etoh, T. 1983a. Accomplishment of microsporogenesis in a garlic clone. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 19:55–63. Etoh, T. 1983b. Germination of seeds obtained from a clone of garlic, Allium sativum L. Proc. Japan Acad., ser. B. 59:83–87. Etoh, T. 1985. Studies on the sterility on garlic, Allium sativum L. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 21:77–132. Etoh, T. 1986. Fertility of the garlic clones collected in Soviet Central Asia. J. Japan. Soc. Hort. Sci. 55:312–319. Etoh, T. 1997. True seeds in garlic. Acta Hort. 433:247–255. Etoh, T., J. Johjima, and N. Matsuzoe. 1992. Fertile garlic clones collected in Caucasia. p. 49–54. In: P. Hanelt, K. Hammer, and H. Knupffer (eds.), The genus Allium: Taxonomic problems and genetic resources. JPK, Gatersleben, Germany. Etoh, T., E-R-J. Keller, and A. Senula. 2001. Fertile garlic clones in the Gatersleben collection. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 37:29–35. Etoh, T., Y. Noma, Y. Nishitarumizu, and T. Wakamoto. 1988. Seed productivity and germinability of various garlic clones collected in Soviet Central Asia. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 24:129–139. Etoh, T., and H. Ogura. 1977. A morphological observation on the formation of abnormal flowers in garlic (Allium sativum L.). Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 13:77–88. Etoh, T., and H. Ogura. 1978. Multivalent chromosomes in garlic, Allium sativum L. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 14:53–59. Etoh, T., and H. Ogura. 1981. Peroxidase isozymes in the leaves of various clones of garlic, Allium sativum L. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 17:71–77. Etoh, T., and P. W. Simon. 2002. Diversity, fertility, and seed production of garlic. p. 101–117. In: H. Rabinowitch and L. Currah (eds.), Allium crop science: Recent advances. CABI Publ., New York.
5. FLOWERING, SEED PRODUCTION, AND GENESIS OF GARLIC BREEDING
241
Etoh, T., H. Watanabe, and S. Iwai. 2001. RAPD variation of garlic clones in the center of origin and the westernmost area of distribution. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 37:21–27. FAO Yearbook Prod. Stats. 1961–2001, Rome. Fritsch, R. M., and N. Friesen. 2002. Evolution, domestication, and taxonomy. p. 5–30. In: H. Rabinowitch and L. Currah (eds.), Allium crop science: Recent advances. CABI Publ., New York. Garcia Lampasona, S., L. Martinez, and J. L. Burba. 2002. Genetic diversity among selected garlic clones (Allium sativum L.) using AFLP (Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism). Euphytica accepted for publication. Gohil, R. N., and A. K. Koul. 1971. Desynapsis in some diploid and polydiploid species of Allium. Can. J. Genet. Cytol. 13:723–728. Gori, O. 1983. Ultrastructural changes in the wall of the sporogenous cells in Allium sativum, clone Piemonte during microsporogenesis. Ann. Bot. 51:139–143. Gori, O., and S. Ferri. 1982. Ultrastructural study of the microspore development in Allium sativum clone ‘Piemonte’. J. Ultrastruct. Res. 79:341–349. Gvaladze, G. E. 1961. The embryology of the genus Allium L. (in Russian). Bul. Acad. Sci. Georgian SSR 26:193–200. Gvaladze, G. E. 1965. Vivipary and the capability of generative reproduction in Allium sativum L. Bul. Acad. Sci. Georgian SSR 40:412–427. Hahn, G. 1996. History, folk medicine, and legendary uses of garlic. p. 1–37. In: H. P. Koch and L. D. Lawson (eds.), Garlic: the science and therapeutic application of Allium sativum L. and related species, 2nd ed. Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, MD. Hanelt, P. 1990. Taxonomy, evolution, and history. p. 1–26. In: H. D. Rabinowitch and J. L. Brewster (eds.), Onions and allied crops, I. botany, physiology, and genetics. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Helm, J. 1956. Die zu Wurz- und Speisezwecken kultivierten Arten der Gattung Allium L. Kulturpflanze 4:130–180. Hong, C-J., and T. Etoh. 1996. Fertile clones of garlic (Allium sativum L.) abundant around the Tien Shan mountains. Breed. Sci. 46:349–353. Hong, C-J., T. Etoh, and S. Iwai. 2000c. An attempt of crossbreeding in garlic. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 36:17–28. Hong, C-J., T. Etoh, B. Landry, and N. Matsuzoe. 1997. RAPD markers related to pollen fertility in garlic (Allium sativum L.). Breed. Sci. 47:359–362. Hong, C-J., H. Watanabe, T. Etoh, and S. Iwai. 2000a. Morphological and karyological comparison of garlic clones between the center of origin and westernmost area of distribution. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 36:1–10. Hong, C-J., H. Watanabe, T. Etoh, and S. Iwai. 2000b. A search of pollen fertile clones in Iberian garlic by RAPD markers. Mem. Fac. Agr. Kagoshima Univ. 36:11–16. Hwang, J. M. 1993. Genetic divergence and classification of garlic cultivars by multivariate analysis (in Korean). J. Kor. Soc. Hort. Sci. 34:257–264. Inaba, A., T. Ujiie, and T. Etoh. 1995. Seed productivity and germinability of garlic. Breed. Sci. 45 (Suppl. 2):310. Ipek, I., A. Ipek, and P. W. Simon. 2003. Comparison of AFLPs, RAPDs, and isozymes for diversity assessment of garlic and detection of putative duplicates in germplasm collections. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. (in press). Jenderek, M. M. 1998. Generative reproduction of garlic (Allium sativum) (in Polish). Zeszyty Naukowe Akademii Rolniczej im. H. Kollataja w Krakowie 57:141–145. Jenderek, M. M. 2002. Development of S1 families in garlic. XXVIth Int. Hort. Congr., Toronto, Canada, 433 (Abstr.)
242
P. SIMON AND M. JENDEREK
Jenderek, M. M., and R. M. Hannan. 2000. Seed producing ability of garlic (Allium sativum L.) clones from two public U.S. collections. Proc. Third Int. Symp. on Edible Alliaceae. Athens, GA, p. 73–75. Jenderek, M. M., and R. M. Hannan. 2002. Fertility, reproductive characteristics and true seed production of the USDA garlic germplasm collection. HortScience (in press). Jones, H. A., and L. K. Mann. 1963. Onions and their allies. Leonard Hill Books, London, UK. Kamenetsky, R., and D. H. Rabinowitch. 2001. Floral development in bolting garlic. Sexual Plant Reprod. 13:235–241. Kamenetsky, R., and D. H. Rabinowitch. 2002. Florigenesis. p. 31–57. In: H. Rabinowitch and L. Currah (eds.), Allium crop science: Recent advances. CABI Publ., New York. Katarzhin, M. S., and I. M. Katarzhin. 1978. Experiments on the sexual reproduction of garlic (in Russian). Byulleten’ Vsesoyuznogo Ordena Lenina I Ordena Druzhby Narodov Instituta Rastenievodstva Imeni N. I. Vavilova 80:74–76. Katarzhin, M. S., and I. M. Katarzhin. 1982. On generative reproduction of garlic (in Russian). Trudy po Prikladnoi Botanike, Genetike I Selektsii 72:135–136. Katayama, Y. 1936. Chromosome studies in some Alliums. J. College Agr. Imp. Univ. Tokyo 13:431–441. Kazakova, A. A. 1971. Most common onion species, their origin and intraspecific classification (in Russian). Trudy po Prikladnoi Botanike, Genetike I Selektsii 45:19–41. Kazakova, A. A. 1978. Allium (in Russian). In: D. D. Brezhnev (ed.), Flora of cultivated plants. Vol. 10. Kolos, Leningrad. Komissarov, V. A. 1964. Evolution of the cultivated garlic, A. sativum L. (in Russian). Izvestiya Timirjazevskoi Sel’ slokhozyaistvennoi Akademii 4:70–73. Komissarov, V. A. 1965. Classification of garlic, A. sativum L. (in Russian). Doklady Sel’ skohozyaistvennoi Akademii Timirjazev 108:351–357. Kononkov, P. F. 1953. The question of obtaining garlic seed (in Russian). Sad I Ogorod 8:38–40 Konvicka, O. 1972. Cytotaxonomische studien von vier sterilen Arten der Gattung Allium. Biol. Plant. 14:62–70. Konvicka, O. 1973. Die Ursachen der Sterilitat von Allium sativum L. Biol. Plant. 15:144–149. Konvicka, O. 1984. Generative Reproduktion von Knoblauch (Allium sativum). Allium Newsl. 1:28–37. Konvicka, O., and A. Levan. 1972. Chromosome studies in Allium sativum. Hereditas 72:12–148. Konvicka, O., F. Nienhaus, and G. Fischbeck. 1978. Untersuchungen uber die Ursachen der Pollensterilitat bei Allium sativum L. Z. Pflanzenzucht 80:265–276. Kothari, I. L., and J. J. Shah. 1974a. Structure and organization of shoot apex of Allium sativum L. Israel J. Bot. 23:216–222. Kothari, I. L., and J. J. Shah. 1974b. Histogenesis of seed stalk and inflorescence in garlic. Phytomorphology 24:42–48. Koul, A. K., and R. N. Gohil. 1970. Causes averting sexual reproduction in Allium sativum Linn. Cytologia 35:197–202. Koul, A. K., R. N. Gohil, and A. Langer. 1979. Prospects of breeding improved garlic in the light of its genetic and breeding systems. Euphytica 28:457–464. Krivenko, A. A. 1938. A cytological study of garlic (Allium sativum L.) (in Russian). Biol. Zhurnal 7:47–68. Kuznetsov, A. V. 1954