WIDE BANDGAP SEMICONDUCTORS
This page intentionally left blank
WIDE BANDGAP SEMICONDUCTORS Growth, Processing and Applications
Edited by
Stephen J. Pearton University of Florida Gainesville, Florida
NOYES PUBLICATIONS Park Ridge, New Jersey, U.S.A. WILLIAM ANDREW PUBLISHING, LLC Norwich, New York, U.S.A.
Copyright 9 2000 by Noyes Publications No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the Publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: ISBN: 0-8155-1439-5 Printed in the United States Published in the United States of America by Noyes Publications / William Andrew Publishing, LLC Norwich, New York, U.S.A. 1098765432
1
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Pearton, S. J. Processing of wide bandgap semiconductors / by Stephen J. Pearton. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 0-8155-1439-5 1. Semiconductors--Design and construction. 2. Wide gap semiconductors. Compound semiconductors. I. Title. TK7871.85.P395 621.3815'2--dc21
2000 00-027325 CIP
MATERIALS SCIENCE AND PROCESS TECHNOLOGY SERIES
Editors Rointan F. Bunshah, University of California, Los Angeles (Series Editor) Gary E. McGuire, Microelectronics Center of North Carolina (Series Editor) Stephen M. Rossnagel, IBM Thomas J. Watson Research Center (Consulting Editor)
Electronic Materials and Process Technology CHARACTERIZATION OF SEMICONDUCTOR MATERIALS, Volume 1: edited by Gary E. McGuire CHEMICAL VAPOR DEPOSITION FOR MICROELECTRONICS: by Arthur Sherman CHEMICALVAPOR DEPOSITION OF TUNGSTEN ANDTUNGSTEN SlLICIDES: by John E. J. Schmitz CHEMISTRY OF SUPERCONDUCTOR MATERIALS: edited by Terrell A. Vanderah CONTACTS TO SEMICONDUCTORS: edited by Leonard J. Brillson DIAMOND CHEMICAL VAPOR DEPOSITION: by Huimin Liu and David S. Dandy DIAMOND FILMS AND COATINGS: edited by Robert F. Davis DIFFUSlON PHENOMENA IN THIN FILMSAND MICROELECTRONIC MATERIALS: edited by Devendra Gupta and Paul S. Ho ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF SEMICONDUCTORS AND ELECTRONICS: edited by John McHardy and Frank Ludwig ELECTRODEPOSlTION: by Jack W. Dini HANDBOOK OF CARBON, GRAPHITE, DIAMONDS AND FULLERENES: by Hugh O. Pierson HANDBOOK OF CHEMICAL VAPOR DEPOSITION, Second Edition: by Hugh O. Pierson HANDBOOK OF COMPOUND SEMICONDUCTORS: edited by Paul H. Holloway and Gary E. McGuire HANDBOOK OF CONTAMINATION CONTROL IN MICROELECTRONICS:edited by Donald L. Tolliver HANDBOOK OF DEPOSITION TECHNOLOGIES FOR FILMS AND COATINGS, Second Edition: edited by Rointan F. Bunshah HANDBOOK OF ION BEAM PROCESSING TECHNOLOGY: edited by Jerome J. Cuomo, Stephen M. Rossnagel, and Harold R. Kaufman HANDBOOK OF MAGNETO-OPTICAL DATA RECORDING: edited by Terry McDaniel and Randall H. Victora HANDBOOK OF MULTILEVEL METALLIZATION FOR INTEGRATED CIRCUITS: edited by Syd R. Wilson, Clarence J. Tracy, and John L. Freeman, Jr. HANDBOOK OF PLASMA PROCESSING TECHNOLOGY: edited by Stephen M. Rossnagel, Jerome J. Cuomo, and William D. Westwood HANDBOOK OF POLYMER COATINGS FOR ELECTRONICS, 2nd Edition: by James Licari and Laura A. Hughes HANDBOOK OF REFRACTORY CARBIDES AND NITRIDES: by Hugh O. Pierson HANDBOOK OF SEMICONDUCTOR SILICON TECHNOLOGY: edited by William C. O'Mara, Robert B. Herring, and Lee P. Hunt
vi
Series
HANDBOOKOF SEMICONDUCTORWAFER CLEANINGTECHNOLOGY:edited byWemer Kem HANDBOOK OF SPUTTER DEPOSITION TECHNOLOGY: by Kiyotaka Wasa and Shigeru Hayakawa HANDBOOK OF THIN FILM DEPOSITION PROCESSESAND TECHNIQUES: edited by Klaus K. Schuegraf HANDBOOK OF VACUUM ARC SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY: edited by Raymond L. Boxman, Philip J. Martin, and David M. Sanders HANDBOOK OF VLSl MICROLITHOGRAPHY: edited by William B. Glendinning and John N. Helbert HIGH DENSITY PLASMA SOURCES: edited by Oleg A. Popov HYBRID MICROCIRCUITTECHNOLOGY HANDBOOK, Second Edition: by James J. Licari and Leonard R. Enlow IONIZED-CLUSTER BEAM DEPOSITION AND EPITAXY: by Toshinori Takagi MOLECULAR BEAM EPITAXY: edited by Robin F. C. Farrow SEMICONDUCTOR MATERIALS AND PROCESS TECHNOLOGY HANDBOOK: edited by Gary E. McGuire ULTRA-FINE PARTICLES: edited by Chikara Hayashi, R. Ueda and A. Tasaki
Ceramic and Other Materials--Processing and Technology ADVANCED CERAMIC PROCESSINGAND TECHNOLOGY,Volume 1:edited by Jon G. P. Binner CEMENTED TUNGSTEN CARBIDES: by Gopal S. Upadhyaya CERAMIC CUTTING TOOLS: edited by E. Dow Whitney CERAMIC FILMS AND COATINGS: edited by John B. Wachtman and Richard A. Haber CORROSION OF GLASS, CERAMICS AND CERAMIC SUPERCONDUCTORS: edited by David E. Clark and Bruce K. Zoitos FIBER REINFORCED CERAMIC COMPOSITES: edited by K. S. Mazdiyasni FRICTION AND WEAR TRANSITIONS OF MATERIALS: by Peter J. Blau HANDBOOK OF CERAMIC GRINDING AND POLISHING: edited by loan D. Mavinescu, Hans K. Tonshoff, and Ichiro Inasaki HANDBOOK OF INDUSTRIAL REFRACTORIES TECHNOLOGY: by Stephen C. Carniglia and Gordon L. Barna SHOCK WAVES FOR INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS: edited by Lawrence E. Murr SOL-GEL TECHNOLOGY FOR THIN FILMS, FIBERS, PREFORMS, ELECTRONICS AND SPECIALTY SHAPES: edited by Lisa C. Klein SOL-GEL SILICA: by Larry L. Hench SPECIAL MELTING AND PROCESSING TECHNOLOGIES: edited by G. K. Bhat SUPERCRITICAL FLUID CLEANING: edited by John McHardy and Samuel P. Sawan
Other Related Titles HANDBOOK OF PHYSICAL VAPOR DEPOSITION (PVD) PROCESSING: by Donald M. Mattox
Preface
There has been a resurgence of interest in wide bandgap semiconductors in recent times, for two important classes of applications, namely blue/green light emitters and high power/high temperature electronics. For the first set of applications, ZnSe and GaN are leading the race, due to their direct bandgaps which give them a huge advantage over the indirect gap SiC. Nichia Chemical Industries of Japan, led by the efforts of Shuji Nakamura, announced its first blue GaN light-emitting diode product in 1993, followed by quantum well blue and green devices in 1995/1996. Currently, more than 10 million blue LEDs are sold per month. Attention has turned to work on high brightness (15 lumens per watt) white LEDs using a blue LED to excite a yttrium aluminum garnet phosphor. These may have applications in whitelighting situations, with the advantage ofmuch longer lifetimes than incandescent bulbs. Nichia has also demonstrated continuous-wave blue-violet laser diodes with room-temperature lifetimes acceptable for commercial applications. The active layer in these devices is InGaN with A1GaN cladding layers. The LEDs are useful for full-color displays, whereas the main commercial laser application is high density optical storage on CD-ROMs. A notable feature of current GaN light-emitter technology is the fact that all devices are currently grown heteroepitaxially on A1203, SiC, or magnesium aluminate substrates. The resulting high defect density (109-10 ~~cm 2) does not appear to affect the light output of LEDs, but can
io
VII
viii
Preface
cause problems in laser diodes through the migration of the p-contact metal along dislocations which may short-out the p-n junction. For this reason, there have appeared some novel lateral overgrowth techniques on SiO 2 patterned GaN templates that produce defect-flee regions above the masked areas. The active regions of the laser diodes are then processed in these areas, with the result that their lifetimes under high current operation are much longer than in devices grown in a blanket (non-patterned) fashion. While II-VI based laser diodes were the first to be demonstrated, their lifetimes are currently in the several hundred hours range and are limited by the ease of defect generation and migration in these soft materials. A typical laser diode structure consists of ZnSe/ZnMgSSe/ZnSSe/ZnCdSe/ ZnMgSSe/ZnSe layers grown on GaAs substrates by Molecular Beam Epitaxy. In this materials system, Metal Organic Chemical Vapor Deposition lags somewhat, due to poorer control over precursor purity and in-situ thickness control. This is in contrast to the GaN system, where MOCVD seems to have an advantage over MBE for photonic devices because of higher quality material due to the higher growth temperature. For the second major class of applications, high power electronics, SiC is by far the most mature, with diamond and GaN as other candidates. Diamond actually has the most appropriate material parameters, but problems with producing large single crystals and lack ofn-type dopability have retarded its progress. GaN has the advantage of the availability of heterostructures and excellent transport properties, but has relatively poor thermal conductivity. SiC has excellent thermal conductivity, demonstrated breakdown voltages of several kV and more well-developed substrates and device processing techniques. To date, the highest rfpower (850 W per mm at 850 MHz CW) was demonstrated by a 4H-SiC MESFET, and the highest total power (450 W pulsed at 600 MHz) produced by a SiC static induction transistor. A SiC power module containing four SITs has demonstrated a 1 kW capability at 600 MHz. The basic driving force is the requirement for electronics in adtomobiles, aircraft, and ships that can function directly on engines to lower the weight and cost of control functions. As an example, it is estimated that approximately 800 pounds could be eliminated on an F16 fighter jet if current mechanical, hydraulic, and pneumatic systems were replaced with advanced power electronics. Si-based electronics is limited to -- 100~ for reliability reasons, requiring active cooling systems. NASA and other agencies have needs for advanced electronics capable of operation at 600~ for temperatures <300~ it is likely that Silicon-on-Insulator technol-
Preface
ix
ogy will prevail. SiC has advantages over Si for power devices because of reduced parasitics, faster switching speed, and reduced thermal management. A key requirement is for SiC substrate micropipe and dislocation densities to be reduced from current levels. Several groups have demonstrated a positive temperature coefficient breakdown behavior in SiC, an important proof that SiC can have acceptable reliability. SiC has a thermal conductivity exceeding that of Cu, and is inert in virtually all chemicals. It is also radiation-hard with high saturation drift velocity. Initial technology insertions include HDTV receivers, power conditioning, and high power microwave applications operating at room temperature atmospheric ambients with high internal junction temperatures. SiC exists in many different polytypes, named according to the stacking sequence of Si and C atoms. For example, 6H material has a hexagonal lattice with an arrangement of six different Si and C layers before the pattern repeats itself. More than 200 different polytypes of SiC exist, and the exact physical properties depend on the crystal structure. The most common polytypes are 6H, 4H, and 3C. Initial work focused on 3C material because of its excellent transport properties. Emphasis is now being placed on the 4H and 6H polytypes. For these latter materials, single crystal substrates are commercially available (up to 3"~ currently). Additionally, the use of vanadium compensation produces semiinsulating substrates which are of interest for microwave power devices. 4H-SiC has a substantially higher carrier mobility than 6H-SiC (800 to 370 cmVV.s). In the latter polytype, there is an inherent mobility anisotropy that degrades conduction parallel to the crystallographic c-axis. Moreover, highly conductive 4H substrates are available for vertical power devices. There is also excellent progress on heteroepitaxy of 3C-SiC on both low-tilt-angle 6H substrates and on Si. In this volume, we have brought together experts in the fields of growth, processing, and characterization of wide bandgap semiconductors. The coverage includes growth and contacts oflI-VI compounds, processing techniques for SiC, GaN and diamond, and materials analysis of all wide gap semiconductors. We believe this is a very useful volume, as a valuable reference tool, both for people just entering this field, and for established researchers. Gamesville, Florida January, 2000
Stephen J. Pearton
NOTICE To the best of our knowledge the information in this publication is accurate; however the Publisher does not assume any responsibility or liability for the accuracy or completeness of, or consequences arising from, such information. This book is intended for informational purposes only. Mention of trade names or commercial products does not constitute endorsement or recommendation for use bythe Publisher. Final determination of the suitability of any information or product for use contemplated by any user, and the manner of that use, is the sole responsibility of the user. We recommend that anyone intending to rely on any recommendation of materials or procedures mentioned in this publication should satisfy himself as to such suitability, and that he can meet all applicable safety and health standards.
Contributors
Jeffrey B. Casady
Berthold Hahn
Mississippi State University Mississippi State, Mississippi
University of Regensburg Regensburg, Germany
Wolfgang Faschinger
Paul H. Holioway
University of Wurzburg Wurzburg, Germany
University of Florida Gainesville, Florida
Joseph R. Flemish
Tae-Jie Kim
Anadigics Warren, New Jersey
University of Florida Gamesville, Florida
Wolfgang Gebhardt
Jewor W. Lee
University of Regensburg Regensburg, Germany
University of Florida Gamesville,Florida
Donald R. Gilbert
Stephen J. Pearton
University of Florida Gainesville, Florida
University of Florida Gainesville, Florida
xi
xii
Contributors
Randy J. Shul Sandia National Laboratories Alburquerque, New Mexico Rajiv K. Singh University of Florida Gainesville, Florida Robert G. Wilson Hughes Research Laboratories Malibu, California
John M. Zavada US Army Research Office Research Triangle Park, North Carolina John C. Zolper Sandia National Laboratories Albuquerque, New Mexico
Contents
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering in Wide Gap IIVI Compounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
WolfgangFaschinger 1.0
I N T R O D U C T I O N .............................................................................. 1
2.0
A B I N I T I O C A L C U L A T I O N S OF D O P I N G L I M I T A T I O N S ................................................................................... 6
3.0
THE 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5
4.0
D O P I N G A N D B A N D S T R U C T U R E E N G I N E E R I N G .................. 23 4.1 Surface S e g r e g a t i o n ................................................................. 23 4.2 Superlattices ............................................................................. 25
5.0
O H M I C C O N T A C T T O p - Z n S e ...................................................... 29
6.0
C O N C L U S I O N S .............................................................................. 37
F E R M I L E V E L P I N N I N G M O D E L ......................................... 8 General C o n c e p t ........................................................................ 8 n - T y p e D o p i n g ......................................................................... 10 C o m p a r i s o n to G a A s and A I G a N ............................................ 15 p - T y p e D o p i n g ......................................................................... 17 C o m p e t i n g D o p i n g Limitation M e c h a n i s m s ............................ 22
R E F E R E N C E S .......................................................................................... 37 xm
xiv
Contents Epitaxial Growth of II-VI C o m p o u n d s by M O V P E ......... 42
Wolfgang Gebhardt and Berthold Hahn 1.0
I N T R O D U C T I O N ............................................................................ 42
2.0
B I N A R Y C O M P O U N D S ................................................................. 45 Z n T e ........................................................................................ 45 2.1 Z n S e ........................................................................................ 50 2.2 ZnS .......................................................................................... 57 2.3 2.4 Z n O ......................................................................................... 59 2.5 C d S e ........................................................................................ 60 2.6 CdS .......................................................................................... 61
3.0
T E R N A R Y A N D Q U A T E R N A R Y C O M P O U N D S ........................ 3.1 T h e r m o d y n a m i c s of Binary C o m p o u n d s ................................ 3.2 T h e r m o d y n a m i c s of Ternary C o m p o u n d s .............................. Z n T e S e .................................................................................... 3.3 3.4 Z n S S e ...................................................................................... 3.5 ZnxCd~.xSe ............................................................................... Z n C d S ..................................................................................... 3.6 Z n M g S e S ................................................................................ 3.7
4.0
61 62 63 65 66 68 71 71
C O N C L U D I N G R E M A R K S ............................................................ 72
R E F E R E N C E S .......................................................................................... 73
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V C o m p o u n d Semiconductors ..................................................................... 80
Tae-Jie Kim and Paul H. Hollowqy 1.0
I N T R O D U C T I O N ............................................................................ 80 1.1 E n e r g y Barrier and Current Transport M e c h a n i s m s ............... 82 1.2 Surface States and F e r m i L e v e l Pinning ................................. 89
2.0
O H M I C C O N T A C T S TO G a A s ....................................................... 98 2.1 In Situ Contact Scheme ........................................................... 98 2.2 Ex Situ Contact Schemes ...................................................... 102 2.3 Reliability o f and T h e r m a l l y Stable Contact Metallizations ........................................................................ 122 2.4 S u m m a r y ............................................................................... 125
3.0
O H M I C C O N T A C T S TO InP ........................................................ 3.1 Single Element/InP Metallizations ........................................ 3.2 Multi-element/InP Metallizations ......................................... 3.3 M e c h a n i s m s for F o r m a t i o n o f Ohmic Contacts ....................
126 126 128 129
Contents
xv
4.0
O H M I C C O N T A C T S TO G a N ...................................................... 130
5.0
O H M I C C O N T A C T S TO Z n S e ..................................................... 134
6.0
C O N C L U S I O N S ............................................................................ 137
A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T ....................................................................... 138 R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................ 138
Dry Etching of SiC .............................
151
Joseph R. Flemish 1.0
I N T R O D U C T I O N .......................................................................... 151
2.0
R E Q U I R E M E N T S OF D R Y E T C H I N G IN SiC D E V I C E F A B R I C A T I O N .............................................................. 152
3.0
C H E M I S T R Y OF SiC D R Y E T C H I N G ......................................... 154
4.0
METHODS FOR PLASMA-ASSISTED E T C H I N G OF SiC .......................................................................... 4.1 Plasma Etching ...................................................................... 4.2 Reactive Ion Etching ............................................................. 4.3 M a g n e t r o n Ion Etching o f SiC .............................................. 4.4 Electron Cyclotron R e s o n a n c e Plasmas ................................
156 156
158 163 165
5.0
PROFILE AND MORPHOLOGY CONTROL WITH E C R E T C H I N G .............................................................................. 168
6.0
S U M M A R Y .................................................................................... 174
A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T S ..................................................................... 175 R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................ 176
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits .. 178
Jeffrey B. Casady 1.0
B A C K G R O U N D ............................................................................ 178 1.1 Historical D e v e l o p m e n t o f Silicon Carbide .......................... 180 1.2 Material Properties o f Silicon Carbide .................................. 182
xvi
Contents 2.0
S I L I C O N C A R B I D E D E V I C E P R O C E S S I N G .............................. 2.1 B u l k SiC G r o w t h ................................................................... 2.2 D o p i n g o f Silicon Carbide .................................................... Etching o f Silicon Carbide .................................................... 2.3 2.4 Oxidation and Passivation o f SiC ......................................... O h m i c Contacts to Silicon Carbide ....................................... 2.5 Schottky Contacts ................................................................. 2.6
189 190 194 201 206 212 215
3.0
S U R V E Y OF SiC D E V I C E S .......................................................... 3.1 L o w P o w e r SiC Devices ....................................................... 3.2 SiC M E S F E T s ....................................................................... 3.3 SiC P o w e r Devices ................................................................ 3.4 SiC Static Induction Transistor .............................................
218 220 221 222 227
4.0
SiC C I R C U I T S A N D S E N S O R S ................................................... 4.1 Operational Amplifiers ......................................................... 4.2 Digital Circuits ...................................................................... 4.3 Sensors ..................................................................................
229 229 229 229
5.0
C O N C L U S I O N S ............................................................................ 231
R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................ 233
Plasma Etching of III-V Nitrides
.......... 250
Randy J. Shul 1.0
I N T R O D U C T I O N .......................................................................... 250
2.0.
E T C H T E C H N I Q U E S .................................................................... 2.1 W e t Chemical Etching .......................................................... 2.2 RIE Etching ........................................................................... 2.3 H i g h - D e n s i t y Plasma Etching ............................................... 2.4 Additional Plasma Etch Platforms ........................................
3.0
P L A S M A C H E M I S T R Y ................................................................ 260 3.1 Gas Mixtures ......................................................................... 262 3.2 H y d r o g e n .............................................................................. 263 3.3 Sulfur Hexafluoride .............................................................. 265 3.4 N i t r o g e n ................................................................................ 267 3.5 A r g o n .................................................................................... 269 3.6 Additional Halogens ............................................................. 270 3.7 H y d r o c a r b o n s ........................................................................ 270
251 251 254 257 259
Contents xvii 4.0
P R E S S U R E .....................................................................................
273
5.0
I O N E N E R G Y A N D P L A S M A D E N S I T Y .................................... 273
6.0
T E M P E R A T U R E D E P E N D E N C E ................................................ 276
7.0
G R O W T H T E C H N I Q U E ............................................................... 279
8.0
E T C H P R O F I L E , M O R P H O L O G Y , A N D S T O I C H I O M E T R Y ... 280
9.0
P L A S M A I N D U C E D D A M A G E ................................................... 284
10.0 P L A S M A E T C H A P P L I C A T I O N S ................................................ 289 11.0 C O N C L U S I O N S ............................................................................ 292 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
....................................................................... 294
R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................
294
Ion Implantation in Wide Bandgap Semiconductors ...... 300
John C. Zolper 1.0 2.0
I N T R O D U C T I O N .......................................................................... 300 I M P L A N T A T I O N I S O L A T I O N .................................................... 301 2.1
3.0
4.0
5.0
G r o u p III Nitrides ................................................................. 302
I M P L A N T A T I O N D O P I N G .......................................................... 309 3.1
Carrier I o n i z a t i o n in W i d e B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s .......... 309
3.2
I m p l a n t a t i o n A c t i v a t i o n T e m p e r a t u r e ................................... 312
3.3
G a N .......................................................................................
313
3.4
SiC ........................................................................................
319
3.5
D i a m o n d ............................................................................... 322
I M P U R I T Y R E D I S T R I B U T I O N ................................................... 325 4.1 4.2
G a N ....................................................................................... 325 SiC ........................................................................................ 331
4.3
D i a m o n d ............................................................................... 332
IMPLANTATION DAMAGE: CREATION AND R E M O V A L ..................................................................................... 5.1
333
G a N ....................................................................................... 333
xviii Contents
6.0
5.2
S i C ........................................................................................334
5.3
D i a m o n d ............................................................................... 338
DEVICE DEMONSTRATIONS 6.1
7.0
.................................................... 338
G a N ....................................................................................... 339
6.2
SiC ........................................................................................ 341
6.3
D i a m o n d ............................................................................... 343
F U T U R E W O R K A N D C O N C L U S I O N S ...................................... 346
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
.......................................................................... 347
R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................347
Rare Earth Impurities in Wide Gap Semiconductors ..... 354
John M. Zavada ABSTRACT
............................................................................................ 354
1.0
INTRODUCTION
2.0
B A S I C C O N C E P T S ....................................................................... 356
3.0
.......................................................................... 355
2.1
R a r e Ea r t h E l e m e n t s ............................................................. 356
2.2
W i d e G a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s ................................................... 359
I N C O R P O R A T I O N OF RE A T O M S IN W I D E G A P SEMICONDUCTORS
.................................................................... 362
4.0
R E 3+ P H O T O L U M I N E S C E N C E
5.0
E L E C T R I C A L A C T I V A T I O N O F R E 3+ I O N S .............................. 383
6.0
S U M M A R Y .................................................................................... 388
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
.................................................... 367
.......................................................................... 389
R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................ 389
SIMS Analysis of Wide Bandgap Semiconductors .......... 393
Robert G. Wilson 1.0
INTRODUCTION
.......................................................................... 393
Contents
xix
2.0
W I D E B A N D G A P M A T E R I A L S D I S C U S S E D H E R E ................ 394
3.0
S E C O N D A R Y ION M A S S S P E C T R O M E T R Y ( S I M S ) ............... 394
4.0
S I M S I S S U E S ................................................................................. 395
5.0
Q U A N T I F I C A T I O N ...................................................................... 397
6.0
D I A M O N D ..................................................................................... 397
7.0
SiC .................................................................................................. 405
8.0
Z n S e ................................................................................................ 410
9.0
L i N b O 3 ( A N D LiTaO3) ................................................................... 412 9.1 H y d r o g e n in L i N b O 3 .......................................................................................................... 413 9.2 Rare Earths in L i N b O 3 and LiTaO 3 ....................................................................416
10.0 G R O U P I I I - N I T R I D E S .................................................................. 417 11.0 A C K N O W L E D G M E N T S
.............................................................. 424
R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................ 427
10 Hydrogen in Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
429
Stephen J. Pearton and Jewor W. Lee 1.0
I N T R O D U C T I O N ................................................................................
2.0
H Y D R O G E N I N C O R P O R A T I O N IN W I D E B A N D G A P S E M I C O N D U C T O R S .................................................................... 430 2.1 H y d r o g e n Plasma E x p o s u r e .................................................. 430 2.2 H y d r o g e n I m p l a n t a t i o n ......................................................... 434 2.3 Survey o f the Configurations o f H y d r o g e n in S e m i c o n d u c t o r s ..................................................................... 437
3.0
H Y D R O G E N IN G a N .................................................................... 445 M O C V D G r o w t h .................................................................. 447 3.1 Passivation o f Other A c c e p t o r Dopants ................................ 454 3.2 Diffusion o f H y d r o g e n in the Nitrides .................................. 459 3.3 Passivation in T e r n a r y Nitrides ............................................. 466 3.4 H y d r o g e n Incorporation During Processing ......................... 471 3.5 H in G a N / I n G a N Device Structures ...................................... 477 3.6 H in Cubic G a N .................................................................... 481 3.7
xx
Contents 4.0
H Y D R O G E N I N SiC ...................................................................... 482 4.1
T h e r m a l Stability o f D e u t e r i u m in 3 C - S i C ........................... 4 8 9
4.2
D i f f u s i o n o f H y d r o g e n in 6 H - S i C ......................................... 493
5.0
D I A M O N D ..................................................................................... 494
6.0
I I - V I C O M P O U N D S ...................................................................... 495
C O N C L U S I O N S ..................................................................................... 495 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
....................................................................... 495
R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................ 496
11 D i a m o n d Deposition and Characterization
506
Donald R. Gilbert and Rajiv If. Singh 1.0
I N T R O D U C T I O N .......................................................................... 506
2.0
P R O P E R T I E S ................................................................................. 506
3.0
F A B R I C A T I O N ..............................................................................
4.0
5.0
6.0
509
3.1
H i g h T e m p e r a t u r e , H i g h Pressure ......................................... 509
3.2
C h e m i c a l V a p o r D e p o s i t i o n .................................................. 510
M O D I F I C A T I O N ........................................................................... 521 4.1
Structural M o d i f i c a t i o n ......................................................... 522
4.2
Electrical M o d i f i c a t i o n ......................................................... 525
C H A R A C T E R I Z A T I O N ................................................................ 525 5.1
M i c r o s c o p y ........................................................................... 527
5.2
S p e c t r o s c o p y ......................................................................... 528
A P P L I C A T I O N S ............................................................................ 532 6.1
T h e r m a l M a n a g e m e n t ........................................................... 532
6.2
Optics .................................................................................... 533
6.3
E l e c t r o n E m i s s i o n ................................................................. 534
6.4
M i c r o e l e c t r o n i c s ................................................................... 534
R E F E R E N C E S ........................................................................................
Index .............................................................................
536
543
1 D o p i n g L i m i t s and B a n d g a p E n g i n e e r i n g in Wide Gap ll-Vl Compounds WolfgangFaschinger
1.0
INTRODUCTION
Figure 1 shows the energy gap of wide gap II-VI compounds as a function of the cubic lattice constant. In addition to the "classical" II-VI compounds ZnS, ZnSe, ZnTe, CdS, CdSe, and CdTe, the range of available materials has been considerably enlarged in the last few years by the introduction of new compounds that form a metastable zincblende modification. The first metastable materials reported were manganese eompounds,[ 1] which were soon followed by the introduction of magnesium compounds with similar lattice constants and energy gaps.[ 2] All of these compounds crystallize naturally in a hexagonal or NaCl-structure and are insulators. Only when they are grown epitaxially on substrates with a zincblende structure do they form semieonducting zincblende modification. In addition, the wide gap II-VI spectrum has recently been further extended by the epitaxial realization of beryllium compounds.P] In contrast to the Mn- and Mg-compounds, these materials crystallized in the
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors zincblende structure even as bulk materials, but were only recently intensely investigated, partly due to their high toxicity. -I
"
-
'
"
4,5
I ....
''
I
'
'
4,0 >
'
I
'
'
I
"
"
I
'
~t, MgS Se MgTe
MnS II
3,5
aTe o. 3,0
I~r BeTe
~
2,5
=
2,0
ZnTe
CdSe
1,5 1 ~ 0
I
'
5,4
'
I
5,6
'
i
"
I
"
CdTe 'I
5,8 6,0 6,2 Lattice Parameter [/~ ]
~'
I'
6,4
'
6,6
Figure 1. Energy gap of wide gap II-VI compounds as a function of their lattice constant.
Altogether, wide gap II-VI materials cover a considerable part of the light speemma; from near infrared (CdTe) into the ultraviolet region (MgS, BeSe). One advantage is that nearly the entire range of compounds with different energy gaps exists at a given lattice constant, a necessary condition for the fabrication of heterojunction devices. These properties make II-VI materials very interesting for applications as light emitters and detectors in the blue and ultraviolet range. However, the application of these interesting properties has long been hindered by the limited dopability of these materials. Until 1990, CdTe (with an energy gap close to that of GaAs) was the only material that could be doped n- and p-type, while compounds with a larger gap could only be doped either n-type (e.g., ZnSe and ZnS) or p-type (e.g., ZnTe). All attempts to dope the other way led to strong compensation, so that no devices could be realized, although the material could be fabricated in outstanding crystalline quality. This picture changed drastically in 1990 when nitrogen plasma was introduced as a p-dopant which allowed p-doping levels around 1018cm -3
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
3
for ZnSe. [4115]Suddenly, blue emitting devices came into reach and within a few months the first blue ZnSe based laser was reported.[ 6] This device operated only at liquid nitrogen temperature and with a very high threshold voltage. Soon the introduction of graded ZnSe/ZnTe contacts[7][ 8] and ZnMgSSe cladding layers for waveguiding[ 9] led to low threshold voltages and operation at room temperature. Room temperature cw operation for more than 100 hours has also been achieved.[ l~ A typical device structure is given in Fig. 2. The entire device, except the active zone, is lattice matched to the GaAs substrate. The active zone consists of CdZnSe, which is surrounded by ZnSSe waveguide- and ZnMgSSe cladding-layers. A typical emission spectrum of a diode fabricated in our lab is shown in Fig. 3, while the LI-characteristics are depicted in Fig. 4. As can be seen, threshold current densities as low as 340 A/cm 2 are obtainable even for simple gain guided structures without facet coating,[ 11]while the lowest reported value for index guided structures with facet coating is 240 A/cm2.[ 12] Threshold voltages well below 5 V have been obtained.[ TMThese devices are already nearly comparable to III-V lasers from an optical and electrical point of view. Therefore, the main issue for device optimization is, at the moment, the increase of the device lifetime, which seems to be limited primarily by stacking faults originating at the GaAs-ZnSe-interface.[ 14] Despite these impressive successes, one should note that the device structure given in Fig. 2 is a compromise governed by the obtainable doping. The use of CdZnSe as the active zone implies a number of disadvantages. In principle, it would be desirable to use ZnSe as the active zone. Its energy gap is really in the blue; it is a binary material with much narrower spontaneous emission linewidth;[ 15]and it is nearly lattice matched to GaAs, so that the width of the active zone could be optimized without limits imposed by the critical thickness. However, the maximum doping level in the ZnMgSSe cladding decreases strongly with an increasing energy gap, [16] limiting the energy gap of the cladding to values below about 2.9 eV at room temperature. For room temperature operation with low threshold currents, an energy difference of about 400 meV is needed between the cladding and the active zone to prevent carrier overflow and to allow reasonable light guiding.[ 17] As a consequence, the emission energy of the device is around 2.5 eV, which is more in the green than in the blue range of the spectrum. This energy corresponds to a Cd content in the active zone of about 25%. Since the lattice constant of CdSe is considerably larger than that of ZnSe, this high Cd content, in turn, seriously limits the thickness of the active zone to values below 5 nm.
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
' ..... " "
i
.:
Gold I sulator ZnSe/ZnTe Graded Contact
'~
"
"
ZnMgSSe:N (p-Cladding)
~///~///////~//////~//~~ ~ / ~ Z ~ , . . ~ ..............
Zn S S e: N (p-Wave g u ide ) CdZnSe Quantum Well ZnSSe:CI (n-Waveguide) ZnMgSSe:C1 (n-Cladding) ~--
GaAs:Si Substrate
.J Figure 2. Layer sequence of a ZnSe based blue-green laser structure.
"
'
I
I
'"
'I
'
I
"
I
'
"
o..-I r~
.r I..--4
.... . . _ J I
525
,
~I
526
,
I
527
,
I
528
~.
I
529
Wavelength ( n m )
Figure 3. Stimulated emission spectrum of a blue green laser.
a
I
530
9
531
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
I
'
'
'
I'
'
I
Pulsed Operation
~3
E 2
f~
9 "" f~
I
9
0
| I
0
9
I
,
200
i
,
_
9
9
J,h 400
9
|
600
Current Density ( A/cm 2 )
Figure 4.
Light output of a blue-green laser as a function of current density.
As a consequence, in spite of the use of nitrogen plasma, the device potential of II-VI compounds is still seriously restricted by compensation phenomena. An understanding of the processes leading to compensation is therefore of major importance. In the following, we will give a review on ab initio attempts to understand and describe compensation in widegap II-VI materials, and then describe, in more detail, a phenomenologieal model that is able to account for most of the experimentally observed doping limitations. This model will be further extended to give some insight into microscopic mechanisms leading to compensation during nitrogen doping, and will be used to explain important properties of contacts to p-ZnSe.
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors 2.0
AB I N I T I O C A L C U L A T I O N S O F D O P I N G LIMITATIONS
In a first approximation, a tendency to compensation is an intrinsic phenomenon of wide gap materials, since the energy gained by the formation of a compensating defect is on the order of the energy gap. As the energy gap increases, compensation becomes energetically more and more favorable. However, this simple analysis does not really explain the doping behaviour of II-VI materials, where materials with comparable energy gaps may differ dramatically in their dopability: CdS and ZnTe, for example, are comparable in their energy gaps (CdS can only be doped ntype, whereas ZnTe is only p-dopable). Therefore, a theoretical approach to the doping problem is more difficult. The major part of recent theoretical works in the field relies on ab initio calculations. Such calculations are usually based on the density functionals approach in the local density approximation, which allows the determination of the minimum energy configuration of a crystal containing dopants and other defects, without any experimental parameters. The starting point is an assumption of the charge distribution in the crystal (e.g., a superposition of atomic charge distributions) from which the potential distribution and the total energy of the crystal is calculated. This charge distribution is then varied in a self consistent way until a minimum of the total energy is reached. In this manner, Laks, Van de Walle, and coworkers calculated the total energy of all current intrinsic defects in ZnSe,[ 181 as well as different arrangements of important extrinsic pdopants in ZnSe,[ 19] and ZnTe.[ 2~ The resulting formation enthalpies for different defects were used to determine the concentrations of these defects as a function of temperature and chemical potentials. The chemical potentials are a measure for the stoichiometry of the host crystal as well as for the concentrations of extrinsic defects. The allowed range of chemical potentials is limited by the boundary condition that they must be smaller than the chemical potentials that would lead to the formation of competing compounds. From this boundary condition, the maximum solubility of the dopants is calculated. Some essential results of these works are: (i) the concentration of all intrinsic defects considered is too low to play a significant role in the compensation of extrinsic acceptors; (ii) Li as a small ion tends to be incorporated at interstitial rather than substitutional positions; and (iii) the decisive limiting factor for the pdoping with Na, Li, and N is not compensation but the solubility of these dopants.
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
7
These statements are only partly in agreement with experimental results (SIMS data on ZnSe and ZnTe doped with radio frequency [RF] nitrogen plasma[ 21] support the last statement). The nitrogen concentration in ZnTe is one order of magnitude higher than in ZnSe, and in both cases, it is comparable to the free carrier concentration. On the other hand, this is not true for ZnMgSSe, where the free carrier concentration decreases several orders of magnitude with increasing energy gap, although the concentration of incorporated nitrogen stays approximately constant.[ 16] Additionally, the prediction of low concentrations for intrinsic defects is not supported by the evaluation of point defect concentration measurements, which conclude that high vacancy concentrations are present in these materials.[ 22] A similar formalism has been used by Chadi to calculate the stability of different defect configurations in ZnSe, ZnTe, MgSe, and MgTe.[ 23] This work focuses on the n-dopants A1, Ga, and C1 and concludes that the total energy of A1 and Ga in tellurides is considerably lowered by a relaxation in (111) direction (in analogy to DX centers in A1GaAs), so that these ions should not be suitable as n-dopants. In selenides, such DX-like centers are energetically unfavourable. A good n-dopability of MgSe is expected. C1 does not form DX-like centers, but is nevertheless a strongly localized defect in ZnTe. This fact is used to explain why the n-dopability of ZnTe is much lower than that of ZnSe; although for alloying of ZnSe with low Te mole fractions, even an improvement of the n-dopability is predicted. As in the case of p-doping, these conclusions only partly agree with available experimental data. Indeed, there is experimental evidence for the formation of DX-like centers in some tellurides,[24]-[ 26] and recent experiments support the existence of AX-like centers in nitrogen doped ZnMgSSe.[ 27] On the other hand, newer works demonstrate that n-doping of ZnTe can be achieved with CI[28] as well as with AI.[29] In contrast to predictions, the carrier concentrations in A1- doped ZnTe (1-4.1017cm 3) are even higher than in the case of C1 doping (3.1016cm-3). An alloying of Te to ZnSe does not lead to the predicted increase, but to a strong decrease in the free carrier concentration.[ 3~ Additionally, the free carrier concentration of ZnMgSe doped with C1 decreases strongly with increasing Mg content, and pure MgSe cannot be doped n-type.[ 31] Considering these facts, DX centers seem to limit the dopability of wide gap II-VI compounds only in some selected cases. Using the same approach, interesting results on nitrogen doping of ZnSe have been obtained by Garcia et al. who investigated the stability of
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors complexes involving charged native defects.[ 321 Their results reproduced the saturation in free hole concentration observed in nitrogen doped ZnSe for high total nitrogen contents (see Fig. 13), as long as the calculation is carried out for Zn-rich conditions. This is in partial agreement with experimental results showing that the maximum free carrier concentration in ZnSe:N is obtained for nearly stoichiometrir growth conditions and decreases only slowly with increasing the Zn to Se ratio.[ 33] However, the prediction that a more Se rich growth should lead to a higher doping level is in direct contradiction to experimental results which show a strong decrease in free carrier concentration even for a slight shift from stiochimetric towards Se rich growth conditions.[ 33]
3.0
THE FERMI LEVEL PINNING MODEL
3.1
General Concept
A more phenomenologieal treatment of doping limitations starts from the observation that for many semiconductors, the maximum dopability is in some way connected to the energetic position of the band edges. This is relatively well understood for III-V materials and has been described in detail by Walukiewiez.[ 341-[361He showed that the energetic position of deep levels induced by heavy irradiation with neutral ions is practically independent of the host lattice, but is fixed with respect to the vacuum level.[ 341One obvious reason for this behavior is that the dangling bonds at vacancies, which are strongly localized defects, do not "know" which atom is missing (e.g., for an As dangling bond in A1GaAs, an A1and a Ga-vaeaney are identical). This is also true for compensating defects which contain vacancies in the form of complexes. If one tries to introduce donors and to raise the Fermi energy above the energetic position of this compensating center, it becomes energetically favorable for the crystal to form the localized compensating center instead of adding the electron to the Fermi surface. This leads to a pinning of the Fermi level at the energetic position of the compensating center. In III-V materials, the nature of the compensating defects is known, and their energetic position can be calculated from their formation enthalpy. The maximum dopability of a compound can then be determined from the relative position of the band edges with
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
9
respect to the Fermi energy. The calculated values are in agreement with experimental data. Several years ago, it was recognized that, at least qualitatively, a similar correlation exists also in II-VI compounds.[ 37][38]Attempts to dope the newly discovered cubic Mg compounds MgSe, MgTe, and BeTe made this still more obvious, as demonstrated in Fig. 5. The figure shows the relative band edge position of many II-VI materials plotted together with their dopability. Compounds with very high conduction bands (like MgSe and MgTe) cannot be doped n-type, while the sulphides with their very low valence band edges are not p-dopable.[ 39]
Vacuum Level i
2 1
["] not n-dopable I I not p-dopable n/p-dopable * extra ~olated = -
>
0
i
r I
1
I
!
I
EF, n
J
o/)
BeTe
Mg,S CdSelZnTe VlgTe
I-q
<
9
x
x
~
~x-x~A
-2 I
'
EF, p
-3 -4 Figure 5. Relative band edge positions of various II-VI compounds. The experimentally
obtained doping is indicated by different shadings.
However, a quantitative treatment analogous to III-V compounds is difficult, since the nature as well as the formation enthalpies of the compensating centers in II-VI's is a matter of controversy. There exist a number of models that all include the participation of vacancies. Marfaing proposed compensation reactions for both n-type[4~ and p-type material[ 41] and concluded that the free hole concentration in ZnSe should not increase
10
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
above 10 TM cm -3. This study is in agreement with experimental data. [421 Hauksson et al. proposed a microscopic model of a deep donor complex acting as a compensating center for nitrogen in ZnSe, but made no conclusions on the maximum dopability.[ 43] The following shows that, in a semi-empirical approach, a quantitative description of the doping behaviour of most II-VI materials can be gained on the basis of the fermi level pinning model without an exact knowledge of the nature of compensating defects. Compared to Walukiewicz and Marfaing, this approach is reversed: instead of calculating absolute values for the maximum dopability from a microscopic model of the compensation process, the relative change in the dopability of mixed crystals is considered. The Fermi level pinning position is treated as a parameter (which influences the absolute values obtained and can therefore be used to adjust the calculation to experimental values), while the calculated relative change in dopability is uniquely determined by the change in the position of the mixed crystal band edges as a function of composition.
3.2 n-Type Doping To illustrate this approach, chlorine doping of ZnMgSe is described as an example. As a first step for a quantitative description, information on the variation of the band edge positions with composition must be obtained. For the given example, this determination has been done by the photolumineseenee experiment depicted in Fig. 6.[44] The ZnSe/ZnTe heterojunetion forms a staggered type II configuration. The prominent photoluminescenee signal in such a structure is given by a transition from the ZnSe conduction band to the ZnTe valence band[ 451 (upper insert in Fig. 6). An addition of Mg only to the ZnSe part of such a structure will induce changes in the position of the conduction and valence band of the ZnMgSe, but not of the ZnTe. Since the end point of the luminescence transition is unchanged, the change in the luminescence signal will only reflect the change of the ZnMgSe conduction band. Eventually, if the Mg concentration is high enough, the ZnMgSe conduction band will raise above the ZnTe conduction band, and the heterojunetion will become a type I structure with a ZnTe quantum well within ZnMgSe barriers (lower insert in Fig. 6). Provided the ZnTe quantum well is thick enough to prevent a significant confinement effect, the luminescence energy will then correspond to the ZnTe energy gap and will not be influenced by a further increase of the Mg content.
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
11
w~w~'|lwwwwwww~l~ww~w~www|w~'wwwwwvw|www"~www"tw
ZnMgSe
3,4 3,2 3,0 > 2,8 .
~2,6
.
.
.
.
II
, -
~D
ZnMgSe/ZnTe MQW
CD
! '~
~ 2,4
"r" 'r
t
2,2-
1
~
~1~
~
2,0
~ ....
, ..........
0
N
......... 20 40 60 80 Mg Content ( % ) , . . . . . . . . .
, . . . . . . . . .
'
Figure 6. Photoluminescence signal of ZnMgSe/ZnTe double heterostructures as a function of the Mg content. Upper part: Near bandedge luminescence of the ZnMgSe. Lower part." Transition from the ZnMgSe conduction band to the ZnTe valence band. Figure 6 shows the energetic positions of the luminescence signals for a number of double heterostructure samples as a function of the Mg content. In the upper part of the figure, the luminescence from the band edge luminescence of the ZnMgSe is shown, while the energetic position of the transition from the ZnMgSe conduction band to the ZnTe valence band is drawn in the lower part. Since all structures were grown on GaAs substrates, and are therefore fully relaxed, the relatively poor crystalline quality of the samples leads to a broad luminescence signal and a relatively large error in the luminescence energy.
12
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Nevertheless, Fig. 6 allows some interesting conclusions. First, for high Mg content, the luminescence energy indeed saturates at 2.3 eV, which is the energy gap of ZnTe. This is in striking coincidence with the prediction given above and confirms the proposed interpretation. The saturation starts at a Mg content of 60%, which is the crossover point between the type II- and the type I-structure. This leads to the conclusion that the conduction band of Zn0.4Mg0.6Se and ZnTe are at the same energetic position. Second, the slope of the ZnMgSe band edge and the type II signal are identical within the experimental error. This can only be the ease if the increase of the energy gap is synchronized with an accompanying increase of the ZnMgSe conduction band edge position. Therefore, the conclusion from the figure is that Mg has a big influence on the position of the ZnMgSe conduction band, while the influence on valence band position is small (below 10%). Given this information on the conduction band position, the next step is a determination of the maximum doping level of ZnMgSe as a function of the Mg content. This has to be done carefully, since the obtained doping level is a strong function of the dopant flux. This behaviour is illustrated in Fig. 7, where the free electron concentration in ZnSe and Zn0.64Mg0.36Seis plotted as a function of the ZnC12 source temperature. As expected, the doping level increases exponentially with the source temperature for low temperatures, reflecting the nearly exponential temperature dependence of the ZnC12 flux. However, for a further increase of the source temperature, the free electron concentration does not saturate, but decreases rapidly for higher temperatures. This is a compensation phenomenon often encountered in II-VI doping which has nothing to do with a change of the band edge with respect to the position of the Fermi level as in the model described here. We will come back to this phenomenon in the case of nitrogen doping of ZnSe, where a similar behaviour is encountered. However, in our present context, the decisive point is that the maximum electron concentration is obtained at different ZnC12 source temperatures for different Mg contents. This fact must be taken into account, and the optimum source temperature has to be determined for each Mg content. The data obtained from such a procedure are shown in Fig. 8, where the maximum doping concentration is plotted as a function of the Mg content.J311 The doping level decreases nearly exponentially with increasing Mg content. To describe this behaviour in the framework of our model, we assume that the Fermi level is pinned at a constant energetic position,
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
13
while the conduction band is shifted upwards in the way determined from Fig. 6. The relative change in the free electron concentration is then uniquely determined by the energy difference between the constant Fermi level position and the conduction band. From this difference, the corresponding free carrier concentration can be easily determined. Since the formation of compensating defects occurs at growth temperature, the calculation should be performed at growth temperature. We now treat the Fermi level position as a parameter to fit the experimental data. The result is shown as a solid line in Fig. 8 for a Fermi level position 130 meV above the ZnSe conduction band. The coincidence between experiment and calculation is striking. The firing parameter does not influence the slope, but only the absolute position of the calculated curve, with the exception of the saturation of the carrier density for low Mg contents, a consequence of degeneracy when the Fermi level comes close to the conduction band. Figure 9 shows that the limits for n-doping of other wide gap II-VI compounds can be explained by the same value of the pinning level.
r162
'~ 1El9 L) O 4.a I-(
1El8
o
L) 1El7 o ,I=,=)
II
ZnSe
9
ZnMg0.36Se
F==,-(
1El6 110
120
130
140 .150
160
170
180
Chlorine Source Temperature [ ~ ] Figure 7. Free electron concentration of ZnSe.CI and ZnMgSe.CIlayers as a function of the ZnCI2 source temperature. The solid lines are guides for the eye.
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
.14
1E20
,
...
,
.
,
.
,
..
,
I
r162 !
o
1El9
~
1El8
-
.
,
ZnMgSe:CI
-
~
o
rj
1El7
o
1El6
' 0,0
'
' 0,1
.... ' 0,2
Mg
'
'
'
0,3
Content
in
'
'
0,4
'
0,5
ZnMgSe
Figure 8. Maximum free electron concentration in ZnMgSe as a function of the Mg content.
1E20
I
'
I
'
I
'
! ZnMgSe:CI 17 CdMgTe:I ZnTe:Cl ulation
!
0
'
1El9
o
o~==1
=
~D
1El8
O = o
1El7
1El6
I
0,0
O,2
0,4
0,6
ECB - ECB ZnSe ( eV ) Figure 9. Maximum free electron concentration in various II-VI compounds as a function of their conduction band edge position. Arbitrary zero of the energy scale is the ZnSe conduction band edge.
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering 3.3
15
Comparison to GaAs and AIGaN
Moreover, it is interesting to compare the n-doping behaviour of II-VI materials with that of III-V compounds, where similar limitations have been observed. GaAs, for example, has a relatively high conduction band edge compared to InP, and, correspondingly, a maximum reported n-doping of about 2.1019 cm -3 for GaAs[ 5~ is lower than the value of 1020 cm -3 obtained for InP.[5~ The limitation for GaAs corresponds to a position of the Fermi level of about 320 meV above the conduction band edge at a typical GaAs growth temperature of 600~ The band alignment between III-V and II-VI materials is much more uncertain than between different II-VI compounds, and it has been shown that the valence band offset of GaAs-ZnSe-heterostructures can be shifted by nearly 1 eV by varying the ZnSe growth parameters at the interface.[ 51]However, if one accepts older measurements that ZnSe and GaAs have typically a conduction band offset as low as 200 meV,[ 52] this would mean that the Fermi level pinning o c c u r s at a similar energy position even for III-V compounds. Limitations for n-type doping therefore seem to follow a kind of"universal" law in the sense that they are independent of host lattice, dopant, and even the class of material. The model can also be applied to A1GaN, although very few systematic data are available on n-type doping of this compound, and the uncertainty in the evaluation of the data is much larger. To illustrate this point, Fig. 10 shows the n-doping level for unintentionally doped MOVPE grown A1GaN.[ 53] Since highly resistive GaN layers have been obtained in the meantime by a better purification of the source gases,[ 54] it can be concluded that the unintentional doping is of an extrinsic nature. Although the doping is unintentional, the fact that very high doping levels are obtained for pure GaNjustifies the assumption that an excess of the dopant is offered for all compositions. The solid line represents results for the dopability based on the Fermi level pinning model, calculated for a growth temperature of 800~ and a conduction band offset of 75% of the energy gap difference between A1GaN and GaN.[ 55] As a consequence of the high growth temperature, which leads to a much higher carrier concentration for a given position of the Fermi level with respect to the conduction band, the slope of this curve is much smaller than in the case of II-VI materials (the calculated difference in the dopability due to the increased temperature is more pronounced at low doping levels and can be as high as four orders of magnitude for A10.4Ga0.6N). Although the scatter in the data is considerable, it is evident that the pinning model adequately
16
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
describes the behaviour in the range of low A1 content, suggesting that the general concept of Fermi level pinning applies also to nitrides. The much stronger decrease of the carrier concentration at high A1 contents is understandable in analogy to the case of ZnMgSe described above. The maximum doping level is not simply obtained by offering as much of the dopant as possible, but by carefully reducing the dopant flux to an optimum value (compare with Fig. 7). If, in Fig. 8, the obtained doping level for a constant dopant flux is plotted instead of the maximum doping level, the decrease in the free electron concentration as a function of Mg content would be much stronger than predicted by the model. Since in the case of A1GaN the doping is unintentional, the dopant flux is assumed to be approximately constant, and a comparison to the calculation only makes sense in the range of relatively high carrier concentrations.
10 2! II 0~ 10 20 o o
=9
II 019
o o
II
0
~ 1018
at
0 o ~ 17 o10 o
III
1016 0
10 20 30 A1 Content in AIGaN ( % )
40
Figure 10. Free electron concentration in unintentionally doped MOCVD-grown AIGaN as a function of the AI content (after Ref. 53).
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
17
3.4 p-Type Doping Since the Fermi level pinning model is very successful in the description of n-doping limitations, it is easy to apply the same model to pdoping data. The procedure is completely identical to that described above for n-doping. No assumption is made on the microscopic nature of the compensation mechanism, and the pinning position is determined by adjusting the calculation to available data for mixed crystals with varying composition. The results are summarized in Fig. 11, where experimentally obtained maximum p-doping levels for ZnSe,[421ZnMgSSe, [161and ZnSe/ ZnTe short period superlattices[ 3~ are plotted versus the energetic position of their valence band maximum. In contrast to the first three material systems, which have been doped with an RF plasma source, the ZnSe/ ZnTe samples were fabricated using a DC plasma, a difference which will be of importance for the following discussion. Arbitrary zero point on the energy scale is the ZnSe valence band. The valence band positions for ZnSSe and ZnMgSSe have been calculated under the assumption that the offset between ZnSe and ZnSSe is purely in the valence band[ 48] and the addition of Mg mainly influences the conduction band position (see See. 3.4 and Ref. 44). In the case of ZnSe/ZnTe, the valence band position has been determined by a Kronig-Penney calculation of the minibands. We will first concentrate on the data obtained with RF plasma. These data can be well described in the framework of the Fermi level pinning model under the assumption that the Fermi level gets pinned at an energy 120 meV above the ZnSe valence band maximum (left solid line). It is worth noting that this calculation has first been done purely on the basis of the ZnSe and ZnSSe data and predicted the doping behaviour of ZnMgSSe claddings that was later experimentally observed.[ 16] The technological implication of the Fermi level pinning interpretation is that the reason for the abrupt decrease of the doping level in ZnMgSSe claddings with increasing energy gap is the lowering of the valence band position of this compound that is caused by the increasing sulphur content. Therefore, a practical realization of deep blue lasers with ZnSe quantum wells as an active zone implies the development of cladding materials with a higher valence band position, but a comparable energy gap as ZnMgSSe. Proposals for the practical realization of such claddings will be given in Ch. 4.
18
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
ZnSe/ZnTe----~
"~--ZnMgSSe
1020 '
10
QO
19
o
= O
1018
~, 10 17 o =
O
L) N O
101
6 Calculatioq Q ZnSe/ZnT~ ! ZnMgSSe|
1015 1014
-0,4
-0,2
0,0
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
EVB - EVB ZnSe ( e V ) Figure 11. Maximum free hole concentration in various II-VI compounds as a function of their valence band edge position. Arbitrary zero of the energy scale is the ZnSe valence band edge.
The free hole concentrations obtained with DC plasma doping are several orders of magnitude lower than those for RF doping, and doping levels obtained with this source for ZnSe are as low as 1014cm -3. Nevertheless, it is remarkable that the slope of the de plasma data is identical to that of the RF data. Consequently, these data can also be well described by a Fermi level pinning mechanism, with the only difference that the pinning position determined from the data is 460 meV higher, at 580 meV above the ZnSe valence band. According to the model, the pinning position depends on the nature of the compensation mechanism (see 3.1). The interpretation of this striking difference is that there must exist two different compensation paths for nitrogen in II-VI materials.
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
19
It is obvious that such a difference in the compensation mechanism must be correlated to the nature of the plasma used. This becomes still more plausible if one takes a look at plasma emission spectra, which contain information on plasma composition. Emission spectra of RF plasma under two different operation conditions are shown in Fig. 12.[56] The upper part of the figure corresponds to the emission of the RF plasma in the so-called "high brightness mode," which is used to obtain high doping levels. The spectrum is composed of broad bands associated with excited nitrogen molecules, together with sharp features that can be ascribed to atomic nitrogen (marked with arrows in Fig. 12). The spectrum in the lower part of the figure is taken from a "low brightness mode" plasma, which is obtained if the plasma power is reduced. In this spectrum, the features of atomic nitrogen have nearly (but not completely) disappeared. In parallel, doping of ZnSe with this low brightness plasma leads to free hole concentrations in the 1015 to 1016 cm -3 range,[561 which is already close to what is achieved with the DC plasma. Obviously, effective p-doping of ZnSe is correlated to the presence of atomic nitrogen in the plasma, and a reduction of the atomic nitrogen content leads to a drastic decrease in the obtained doping.
I
'
I
'
I
~
I
'
'
I
w
t
I
9
I
2nd pos. series N2": C31-1u-> B311 g
atomic transitions
'
1st neg. series N2,: B2T_.u* -> X2T_.g
.
.
.
t
t
.
ff Plasma". Ha mode: ~4NI 110 W~ 7-10 -7 torr
~1
1st pos. series
300
400
500
600
I
700
800
900
IIl~
1000
1100
wavelength [nm]
Figure 12. Emission spectra of radio-frequency nitrogen plasma in the high brightness mode (upper part) and the low brightness mode (lowerpart) (from Ref. 56).
20
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Although no comparable emission spectrum of the DC plasma is available, the fact that this plasma source is operated at much lower power than an RF source (15 W compared to 150-300 W for an RF source) makes it reasonable to assume that the DC plasma does not contain any atomic nitrogen, and the much lower doping levels are a result of doping with excited nitrogen molecules. Two properties of RF plasma doped layers give additional insight in the processes occurring during compensation. First, p-ZnSe doped with RF plasma is rather unstable against annealing, and even anneals below growth temperature lead to a considerable increase in resistance,[ 57] approaching that of layers doped with DC plasma. Thus, it seems that the highly conductive "RF" state can be converted into the resistive "DC" state by a diffusion process. Second, the free carrier concentration in RF plasma doped layers decreases drastically if the atomic nitrogen flux is increased. This behaviour can be seen in Fig. 13, where the p-doping levels obtained by different groups[56][58] (solid symbols) are plotted as a function of the total nitrogen content incorporated in the layer. The variation of the atomic nitrogen flux was obtained by an increase of the RF plasma power used. For low nitrogen incorporation, the nitrogen was nearly completely electrically activated. When the total amount of nitrogen was increased, the free hole concentration first saturates and then drops abruptly for very high nitrogen content. In analogy to annealing, an excess of atomic nitrogen was another possibility to induce a transition from a highly conductive to a resistive state. All these experimental findings can be understood in a model that assumes the existence of two nitrogen complexes which contain one or two nitrogen atoms, respectively.[ 59] Many microscopic models of such centers have been proposed in the literature.[56116~-[62]We assume that the second one is energetically more stable and is formed automatically when nitrogen molecules are the doping species. However, its formation is kinetically limited as soon as atomic nitrogen is offered, since the nitrogen atoms first have to find each other by diffusion. It is now plausible that annealing has such a drastic effect on conductivity, and also helps to interpret the data shown in Fig. 13. As soon as too much atomic nitrogen is offered, the probability for the formation of nitrogen pairs increases. To quantify this latter point, the data in Fig. 13 have been modelled by a Monte Carlo simulation of the nitrogen pair formation process via diffusion (open symbols in Fig. 13, the solid line is a guide for the eye). This simulation assumes a nitrogen sublattice with fixed lattice points, and an average lattice constant determined by the absolute nitrogen content. One incoming nitrogen atom is then moved randomly for a fixed number of
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
21
steps, and the probability of meeting another nitrogen atom is determined by averaging over 100 diffusing atoms at each given composition. This probability is then translated into a free carrier concentration by the assumption that for each nitrogen pair, two acceptors are lost, and a double donor is formed. The number of diffusion steps is calibrated by the condition that an absolute nitrogen concentration of 1018 cm "3 should correspond to a free hole concentration of 3.1017 cm "3 (an experimental finding of much of the research,[421156][58])and is then kept constant for all other concentrations. Under these assumptions, the experimental features, and especially the abrupt drop at high nitrogen content, can be exactly reproduced.
1018 . "J
}
-!
~1017. tO
i,
~
.
~1016O
r,.) ~1015
Q
Kurtzetal.
II
Ohkawa et al.
121
Monte Carlo
1014 .
t
1016
1017
1018
1019
Nitrogen Concentration ( cm -3 ) Figure 13. Free hole concentration in ZnSe doped with RF nitrogen plasma as a function of the total nitrogen concentration (solid symbols, Refs. 56 and 58) together with results of a Monte Carlo simulation (open symbols). The solid line is a guide for the eye.
22
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
These ideas can be taken together with the Fermi level pinning model to explain the different behaviour for doping with RF and DC plasma, as shown in Fig. 11. As long as atomic nitrogen in a moderate concentration is offered, the compensating defect is the complex involving one nitrogen atom, which pins the Fermi level at a value of 120 meV above the ZnSe valence band edge. This pinning is responsible for the decreasing doping levels in ZnMgSSe claddings. If activated nitrogen molecules are offered, the energetically more favorable complex involving two nitrogen atoms becomes dominant and pins the Fermi level 580 meV above the ZnSe valence band edge. As in the case of n-doping, it is again of interest to compare these pinning positions with those occurring in III-V compounds. From the limited obtainable p-doping in InP with its relatively low valence band edge, one can estimate a pinning position about 500 meV below the GaAs valence band edge in these materials.[ 34] Under the assumption of 1.1 eV for GaAs/ZnSe[ 52] (as in the case of n-doping), this would correspond to a position about 600 meV above the ZnSe valence band edge. This is much higher than for RF plasma doping in II-VI compounds. From this, it may be concluded that the compensation mechanisms are very different in nature between III-V's and RF plasma doped II-VI's. This is not too astonishing if one considers the very special compensation situation which is encountered in nitrogen doping of II-VI compounds, as it has been described above. However, the value for the pinning level is close to what is observed for DC plasma doped II-VI compounds, suggesting that the compensation mechanism occurring in this case is closer to what is observed in III-V' s. As an important consequence, the compensation picture given here implies that the complex formed during RF plasma doping is metastable and can be converted into the stable configuration formed during DC doping by an annealing process. While this metastability does not seem to be a significant problem for the conductivity of the p-layers in a laser structure during operation, it has important consequences on the formation of Ohmic contacts to ZnSe, a point to which we will return in Ch. 5.
3.5
Competing Doping Limitation Mechanisms
Obviously, there exist upper doping limits which are determined exclusively by the positions of the band edges. However, this should not be misinterpreted in a way that Fermi level pinning is the only limiting
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
23
mechanism. One obvious example of a competing mechanism is limited solubility of the dopant. This is the reason for the saturation observed in the n-doping level of CdMgTe:I visible in Fig. 8, as well as an analogous saturation in the p-doping level of ZnSeTe seen in Fig. 12. A similar mechanism is the formation of stable competing phases of the dopant with one of the constituents of the host. An example of this is the strong decrease in free hole concentration if Mg is added to ZnTe, which cannot be due to Fermi level pinning, since both ZnTe and MgTe have very high valence band edges. This behaviour has been explained with the formation energy of magnesium nitride, which is much higher than that of MgTe[ 63] and favors the formation of the nitride instead of the substitutional incorporation. Such a mechanism may also be present in selenides, where it has been shown that an addition of Mg to ZnSSe led to a slight decrease in the p-doping level[ 64] (although this may also be att~buted to an increase in the S sticking coefficient due to the presence of Mg and the resulting lowering of the valence bond edge). An analogous explanation has been given also for the relatively poor free hole concentrations in nitrogen doped CdTe.[ 63] The size of the dopant with respect to the host lattice may also be of importance in some cases. The high n-doping of CdMgTe plotted in Fig. 9, for example, is only obtained with the large halogen Iodine, which fits relatively well to the large CdMgTe lattice. If the halogens bromine or chlorine are used, the resulting doping levels are much lower, the lowest values resulting for the small chlorine ion.[47] Such effects may well be due to the formation of DX-like lattice deformations,[231which are more likely for small dopants. In a real crystal, the pinning mechanism competes with all these other limitations. In this context, the main value of the pinning model is that it allows a prediction of the maximum obtainable doping level if all competing mechanisms can be overcome.
4.0
D O P I N G AND BAND S T R U C T U R E E N G I N E E R I N G
4.1
Surface Segregation
It is evident from Fig. 11 that the key factor for the improvement of p-doping levels is to raise the position of the valence band edge. Since, in an MBE process, the incorporation of a dopant occurs at the surface of the growing crystal, the formation of compensating centers should rather be
24
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
determined by the conditions at the surface than by those in the bulk. Consequently, it could be sufficient to increase the valence band edge at the surface in order to obtain a low degree of compensation. One possible way to do this is to take advantage of surface segregation. Segregation usually occurs if atoms of very different size are offered simultaneously, so that it becomes energetically favorable for the larger atom to occupy surface sites where more space is available than in the bulk. In the case of ZnSeTe, this effect is so strong that nearly no tellurium is incorporated during MBE growth. [65] In analogy, strong segregation can be expected if sulfur, as a very small atom, is offered together with the much larger tellurium. In the ease of ZnSTe (or ZnMgSTe) this combination offers, in addition, the possibility to be lattice matched to GaAs. In Fig. 14, the free hole concentration of MBE grown ZnSTe layers determined by CV profiling is plotted versus the bulk Te content of the layers (solid symbols).[ 66] The layers were grown using elementary Zn, S, and Te sources. The obtained carrier concentration is nearly independent of the bulk Te content, whereas the Fermi level pinning model would predict a very strong dependence on Te content (solid line, with a large error in Te content, since the dependence of the valence band on the Te content can only be estimated). This picture changes if one does not plot the bulk Te content, which is determined by x-ray diffraction, but the surface Te content, measured by x-ray photoemission spectroscopy for some selected layers (open symbols, the arrows connect identical samples). This surface Te content is always much higher than the bulk content and is above 20% even for layers with a bulk Te content as low as 5%. It must be noted that this strong segregation effect does not occur if a ZnS source is used instead of the elementary S source. As a consequence, the surface data points now lie close to the calculation, except for high Te content, where they are considerably lower. Since, in this range, the carrier concentration is already close to the 1019 em -3 range, this is probably an effect of limited solubility, in analogy to the ease of ZnSe/ZnTe superlattiees (see Fig. 11). Thus, surface segregation and the shift of the surface valence band edge associated to it allow an increase of the doping level. Unfortunately, there is only a limited potential for applications of this effect due to two negative by-products of the segregation. First, it causes a vertical gradient in composition which can be observed as a strong broadening of x-ray reflexes. Second, the large potential fluctuations associated with these inhomogeneities seem to have a tendency to trap carriers, so that transport finally occurs only via hopping.[ 66] Nevertheless, the conductivity of material with a carrier concentration close to 1019 em -3 is high enough to be useful for p-contacts, as will be shown in Ch. 5.
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
25
10 20
10 = o
19
l
1018
l
l
i
.p,,~
t-d
10
17
o
~
Calculation I"! Volume Te Content (x-ray) I Surface Te Content (XPS)
10 z6
o
10~5 0
10
20 30 Te Content in ZnSTe
40
Figure 14. Free hole concentration of RF-plasma doped ZnSTe as a function of the bulk Te content (solid symbols) and the surface Te content (open symbols). The solid line is a calculation based on the Fermi level pinning model.
4.2
Superlattices
A second attractive possibility to influence the valence band position is the use of superlattices instead of mixed crystals. In that case, the positions of the first conduction and valence minibands that determine the superlattice energy gap can be shifted up and down by simply changing the superlattice period. Since the effective hole masses are much larger than those of electrons, confinement effects are much more pronounced in the conduction than in the valence band, a situation that is in favor of a higher valence band edge as compared to a mixed crystal with a comparable energy gap. That this really affects the doping properties is demonstrated in Fig. 15, where the free hole concentration of ZnSe/ZnTe superlattices doped with DC nitrogen plasma is plotted versus the superlattice period.[ 3~ The average Te content is 15% for all samples. An increase of the period from 2.4 to 5 nm leads to a strong increase of the hole concentration from 2.1016cm -3 to 3.1019cm"3. The solid line is the
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
26
calculated carrier concentration according to our model for miniband positions determined from a Kronig Penney calculation of ideally abrupt superlattices, with heavy hole masses of 0.78 for ZnSe and 0.6 for ZnTe. In fact, this simple model reproduces the large increase in carrier concentration, except for very small periods, where, due to interdiffusion, the dopability approaches that of a mixed crystal of the same composition.
10 20
r
'~ 10
ZnTe Layer Thickness (ML) 1,5 2,0 2,5
1,0
19
1
3,0
Calculation Data
o 18 "'~ 10 I
o 017 =O 1 r,.)
l--
--
I
/
I
Mixed
O
~
10 ~6 2
3 4 5 ZnSe/ZnTe SL Period ( nm )
6
Figure 15. Free hole concentration ofZnSe/ZnTe superlattices with an average Te content of 15% as a function of the superlattice period. The solid line is the result of a model r the dashed line indicates the doping level obtained for a ZnSeTe mixed crystal with 15% Te.
Figure 16 gives the results of an analogous calculation for two examples of RF plasma doped superlattices, namely (MgS)n/(ZnSe)n and (Zn0.sMg0.sS)3J(ZnTe)n, two combinations that are reasonably well lattice matched to GaAs. The former has the advantage that it uses the same components as the quaternary ZnMgSSe, the latter contains ZnTe with its very high valence band edge (which in turn leads to a high heavy hole superlattice miniband). For comparison, the calculation and the data[ 16]for ZnMgSSe mixed crystals are also given in Fig. 16. The dotted part of the curve for (Zno.sMg0.sS)an/(ZnTe)n represents the region where the ZnTe
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
27
thickness is lower than 2 ML, and the calculation is expected to be inaccurate due to interdiffusion.
I
g"" 10 Is
"
o
!
!
!
'
.... ZnMgSfZnTe . . . . . . MgS/ZnSe ZnMgSSe 9 ZnMgSSedata
\
o 9~
o 017 "~1
O
9
"
9 %~
% 9
"%
o
9 %
o 1016
9
9 %
9
9,
O O
% 9
1015
,
9 %
%
9149
.. 9
218
'
I
'
I
3.'0 3.2 3.4 Energy Gap ( eV )
'
I
3.6
Figure 16. Calculatedfreehole concentrationfor (MgS)n/(ZnSe)nand(Zno.sMgo.sS)3n/(ZnTe)n superlattices as a function of their energy gap. For comparison,calculated and experimental values for ZnMgSSe mixed crystals (Ref. 16) are also shown.
For MgS/ZnSe an increase of the hole concentration by a factor of five to ten compared to ZnMgSSe is expected. For cladding layers with an energy gap of 2.95 eV, as they are currently used in blue-green lasers, this would represent an increase of the hole concentration from 1 to 5.1017cm -3, which could help improve device performance. The predicted behavior of the Zn0.sMg0.sS/ZnTe superlattices is still more promising. Even combinations with an energy gap up to 3.2 eV are predicted to exhibit hole concentrations above 1017cm -3. For such a cladding material, the use of a ZnSe quantum well would no longer be unrealistic. Nevertheless, it has to be considered that the improvement in vertical transport, which is decisive for a laser device, will be somewhat smaller than the predicted increase in dopability. The carriers will have to tunnel through the barriers introduced by the superlattice structure. In addition, the conduction band edge of such a cladding layer would be
28
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
already so high that the n-dopability is expected to be very bad. As a consequence, for a deep blue room temperature laser, we propose to use an asymmetric device design with a ZnMgSSe cladding on the n-side, and a Zn0.sMg0.sS/ZnTe cladding on the p-side. The schematic energy band diagram of such a proposed device is shown in Fig. 17. Since the dopability is directly connected to the band edge positions, the dopability scale given at the fight y-axis is directly related to the energy scale. As an additional feature, the use of ZnSTe, which should also allow high p-doping levels, is proposed as a lattice matched p-contact. Such asymmetric devices have already been realized, in principle, for the example ofZnMgSe/ZnSeTe LEDs. [67][68] n
...:. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
=
..........................
1014
........................................................................................................................... ..............................................................................................................................
10, r~
oo
oo
o
~2 >
c5
=1
0
N
c5
N
~
~._
N
i iiiii iiiiiiiiiiiiiii;iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii'~ ".............................................................................................................................. 1 0 1 4
p
Figure 17. Schematic energy band diagram under fiat band conditions for a proposed asymmetric blue laser diode with a ZnMgS/ZnTe superlattice cladding and a ZnSe active zone.
Interesting new possibilities may arise from the use of the highly pdopable compound BeTe, which is nearly lattice matched to GaAs.[ 3] Superlattices between BeTe and ZnSe have already been produced in high quality. However, these superlattices are of the staggered type with an overlap of the two energy gaps of only about 1.9 eV.[ 3] They cannot be used as
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
29
cladding layers in a laser. For this purpose, BeTe should be combined with a material with a much larger energy gap than ZnSe. The best candidate from a confinement and lattice match point of view is cubic MgS.[ 2] In fact, miniband calculations for such superlattiees reveal that they would be potential candidates for highly p-doped cladding layers with energy gaps in excess of 3.2 eV. However, the combination BeTe/MgS is somewhat exotic and may be difficult to realize. A more convenient altemative could be a ZnBeSe/ZnBeTe superlattice. The addition of Be to ZnSe reduces the lattice constant, while the addition of Zn to BeTe enlarges it, so that a combination of a selenide and a telluride with constant Zn to Be ratio, and equal thicknesses, is approximately stain balanced on GaAs. A Be content of about 50% is estimated to lead to approximately zero conduction band offset between the two materials, whereas the valence band of ZnBeSe is much lower than that of ZnBeTe. According to the miniband calculation, short period superlattices of this type can have energy gaps as large as 3.15 eV, if they can be fabricated without significant interdiffusion. At the same time, the valence band of these superlattices is more than 300 meV above that of ZnSe. The obtainable p-doping levels should consequently be limited only by solubility, and no longer by Fermi level pinning. Since it can expected that such a highly doped superlattice may be directly contacted with a metal, the valence band grading in this structure is not at the contact, but between the p-cladding and the p-waveguide.
5.0
OHMIC CONTACT TO
p-ZnSe
Soon after the introduction of nitrogen doping, it became evident that it was difficult to obtain good ohmic contacts to p-ZnSe. The reason for this was that the valence band of ZnSe is very low compared to the work function of even noble metals as Au or Pt. Consequently, a large Schottky barrier was formed between ZnSe and these metals. Additionally, the obtained doping levels in p-ZnSe remained limited to about 1018 cm "3, so that no effective tunneling through that barrier can lower the high contact resistance. Both problems are much less severe for ZnTe, which exhibits a higher valence band edge and much higher p-doping levels. As a result, several groups developed p-contacts to ZnSe that involve ZnTe. In order to reduce the problem of the large valence band offset between ZnTe and ZnSe, which acts as an additional barrier for holes, two
30
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
strategies were followed. Fan et al. introduced a ZnSe/ZnTe superlattice with a quasi continuously varied Te content between the ZnSe and the ZnTe;[ 7] whereas Ishibashi et al. designed a series of ZnTe quantum wells in ZnSe which should allow sequential resonant tunneling of holes from the ZnTe through the quantum wells to the ZnSe.[ 81The decisive element for a good contact is believed to be an optimized grading in the first case and a precise design of the resonant tunneling structure in the second case. Finally, both approaches led to the development of ohmic contacts and allowed a reduction of the laser threshold voltage at room temperature to values well below 5 V[ 13] so that the p-contact problem for blue ZnSelasers seemed to be solved. New results, however, show that the contact properties are mainly governed by a diffusion process. This is demonstrated in Fig. 18, where IV characteristics of several ZnSe diodes are compared.[ 69] The contact used is a multi-quantum well structure similar to the one published in Ref. 8, followed by a ZnTe cap layer of 20 nm thickness. Based on the observation ofTaike et al., doping of the entire contact structure resulted in nonohmic contacts.[ 7~ The ZnTe quantum wells in the structure and the first 15 nm ofthe ZnTe cap were not doped. Only the topmost 5 nm of the ZnTe were heavily doped with nitrogen under the same plasma conditions as used for the p-ZnSe. This highly doped ZnTe layer was then contacted with gold which was evaporated, without breaking the vacuum, in a metallization chamber coupled to the MBE system. The only difference between the diodes was the substrate temperature at which the contact was grown; the temperature for the growth of the diode itself was 280~ for all samples. The solid curves in Fig. 18 represent diodes where the temperature for contact growth was set to 250, 230, and 200~ respectively. It was evident that a reduction of the growth temperature leads to a drastic improvement of the IV curve. This was a strong indication that the contact resistance was dominantly determined by a diffusion process and not, as commonly believed, by the exact design of the quantum wells in the grading or the resonant tunneling structure. A further reduction of the growth temperature to 160~ resulted in the deposition of polycrystalline ZnTe and a deterioration of the contact (see thin solid line in Fig. 18). The importance of diffusion is additionally underlined by the IV characteristics shown in Fig. 19. In this sample series, the growth temperature for all contacts was 200~ Only the thickness of the ZnTe cap was reduced from 10 to 5 nm until finally the cap was completely omitted. In
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
31
order to guarantee a highly doped layer below the gold in these very thin contacts, in contrast to the samples shown in Fig. 19, the entire contact was doped with nitrogen. It can also be seen that the thickness of the ZnTe strongly affects the IV characteristics. For the contact where the ZnTe cap was completely omitted, the voltage which must be applied to obtain a current density of 600 A/cm 2 (a typical threshold current density for a ZnSe-based laser) was as low as 4 V, which was even lower than the best value reported for a similar contact structure.[ 13] This result can be also understood in terms of diffusion, if one assumes that the ZnTe cap acts either as a source or a sink for the diffusing species. A reduction of the ZnTe thickness limits the diffusion process by either reducing the amount of the species available for diffusion or the reservoir to which the diffusing species can migrate.
10,
,
'
" '
"'
'
'
~ZnTe
'!
'
I'
200 ~ ,
'
'
I'
160~
'
'
I'
230~
'
250~
8
"
n-ZnSe
4
Ii I ' : , 1
2
I! I ,I/j
0 I
-15
,
I
-10
.
I
-5
,
I
0
,
I
5
,
/I
i1
I
l
10
l
15
,,'1 i
I
20
i
I
25
.
l
30
Voltage ( V )
Figure 18. Current-density vs voltage for four ZnSe diodes with a ZnSe/ZnTe multiquantum well contact at the p-side. The structure of all diodes is identical, but the substrate temperature during the growth of the multi-quantum well contact was varied between 160 and 250~ The dotted lines represent results of a simulation.
32
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
10 ,~
8
4
0 -2
0
2
4 6 Voltage ( V )
8
10
12
Figure 19. Current-density vs voltage for four ZnSe diodes with a ZnSe/ZnTe multiquantum well contact at the p-side. All contacts were grown at a substrate temperature of
200~ but the thickness of the overlyingZnTe cap layerwas varied between 0 and 10 nm. An additional experiment demonstrates that the diffusion induced deterioration of the contacts does not occur in the graded multi-quantum well itself, but rather in the underlying p-ZnSe. A diode was grown by MBE in which the p-ZnSe was replaced by p-ZnSTe, a mixed crystal which can by grown lattice matched on ZnSe for a Te concentration of 35% and doped p-type with nitrogen plasma.[661 This layer was followed by a ZnSTe stepgraded layer, consisting of five layers of 4 nm thickness for which the Te content was adjusted to 45%, 55%, 65%, 75%, and 85% by reducing the sulphur flux from the valved cracker sulphur source. This step-graded layer replaced the ZnSe/ZnTe multi-quantum wells used in the previous samples. The structure was terminated with a 20 nm ZnTe cap. The sample structure is shown as an insert at the left side of Fig. 20. Since high quality ZnSTe can only be grown at high substrate temperatures, the entire diode, as well as the contact, was grown at 280~ The IV characteristics of this sample are shown as a solid line in Fig. 20 Although it was grown at a high substrate temperature and with a relatively thick ZnTe cap, the IV curve is similar to the one of the best ZnSe diode. This diode was produced at a much lower substrate temperature and without a ZnTe cap to minimize
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
33
diffusion. In the n-ZnSe/p-ZnSTe diode, the diffusion process observed in the pure ZnSe diodes was obviously absent or at least greatly reduced. To make sure that this improvement is not due to the replacement of the ZnSe/ ZnTe multi-quantum well by the ZnSTe grading layer, a second, nearly identical, sample was grown. As the only change, an additional p-ZnSe layer was introduced between the n-ZnSe and the p-ZnSTe. The sample structure is depicted as the right insert in Fig. 20. In contrast to the previous sample, the IV characteristics of this sample (dashed line in Fig. 20) was much worse (although still much better than for a pure ZnSe diode with a contact grown at such a high temperature), which means that interdiffusion is again important, in this case. From this we conclude that interdiffusion causes a deterioration of the p-ZnSe. On the other hand, if one succeeds in suppressing interdiffusion, the detailed design of the grading itself seems to be of minor importance, as can be seen from the fact that comparably good contacts can be achieved for gradings as different as a ZnSe/ZnTe multi-quantum well or a step-graded ZnSTe layer.
10 -
.
I
8
6 !
~
~[
I
n-ZnSe _ n-~~.~~~
/
I [ [
[.... p-ZnTe -1
/
iznsTe gradin~ i p,ZnS0.65Teo.351
; ,.
2 L)
0 ,
-2
I
0
,
I
2
,
I
,
I
4 6 Voltage ( V )
,
I
8
,
I
10
,
12
Figure 20. Current-density vs voltage for two diodes containing p-ZnSTe layers. The detailed structures are given in the inserts. The only difference between the two diodes is that the p-ZnSe layer was omitted in one case.
34
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
The microscopic nature of the interdiffusion process that affects the p-ZnSe cannot be deduced directly from these experiments. However, additional insight can be gained by analyzing the IV characteristics in more detail. The low current for the contacts grown at 230 and 250~ can only be understood as a result of a tunneling process. In fact, a reasonable description of the IV curves can be obtained with a model for tunneling through a triangular barrier introduced by a highly resistive ZnSe layer of a given thickness. Although this model does not give a perfect fit of the observed IV curves, it describes at least qualitatively the observed shift of the experimental IV curves to higher voltages with increasing contact growth temperature (Fig. 18). Best fits are shown as dashed lines in Fig. 18. Although they are not unambiguous in the sense that both a variation of the barrier height and the free carrier density have a similar influence, one can nevertheless see clear trends. For a fixed barrier height of 0.5 eV (which is lower than that for gold on ZnSe,[ 71] but high enough to prevent significant thermionic emission), the thickness of the resistive layer used for the fit decreases from 145 nm for a substrate temperature of 250 ~ to 42 nm for a temperature of 200 ~ A change of the barrier height results in slight variations of these values, but the relative thickness change of the resistive layer remains constant. In Fig. 21, the thickness of the resistive layer obtained in this way is plotted as a function of temperature. These values are compared to a calculation giving the relative change of the diffusion length as a function of the temperature. For diffusion from a finite as well as for an infinite source, the diffusion length is proportional to the square root of the diffusion constant times the diffusion time [72] (which is approximately constant for all structures presented here). The diffusion constant D itself depends on temperature according to an Arrhenius law of the form: Eq. (1)
D = exp(-E a/kT)
where E a is the activation energy of the diffusion process and k the Boltzmann constant.[ 72] The relative change of the diffusion length obtained in this manner is plotted as solid lines in Fig. 21 with E a as a parameter. The comparison to the experimental values shows that the observed behavior can be understood for activation energies on the order Of 1 eV. This value is too low for diffusion via regular lattice sites, and corresponds rather to values observed for diffusion via interstitial sites or along dislocations.[ 72]
Dop&g Limits and Bandgap Engineering
35
160 140
1,o
~ 120
0,8
100 N
r~ ~,,J~
0,6
>
80
9 v,,,~
~
60
~
40
~
20
t~
~
0
*~,,I
o
0,4
o,2
0
190
200
210
220
230
240
250
0,0
Contact Growth Temperature ( ~ )
Figure 21. Thickness of a resistive layer, as obtained from a fit to the IV curves shown in Fig. 18, as a function of the temperature at which the contact was grown. The solid lines are calculated relative changes of the diffusion length with the activation energy E a as a parameter.
Based on these observations, our suggestion is that nitrogen diffuses along dislocations from the ZnTe cap and the grading into the p-ZnSe. The observation of such diffusion by secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) has indeed been reported in the literature[ 7~ and could be driven by the different solubility of nitrogen in ZnSe and ZnTe.[ 2]] The free hole concentration in p-ZnSe would then be drastically reduced by the formation of nitrogen-nitrogen pairs (see See. 3.4 and Fig. 13) so that the diffusing nitrogen could lead to overcompensation in the p-ZnSe. These results can shed light on a few additional features of ZnSe/ ZnTe contacts. First, these contacts, and especially the resonant tunneling variant, seem not to be very reproducible. As an example, the device with a record lifetime of 101 hours reported by Ishibashi et al. needed a threshold voltage of 11 V[ 1~ (a value much larger than the lowest voltage of 4.7 V reported by the same group for a diode with a nominally identical
36
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
contact).[ 13] This irreproducibility was still stronger when the results of different groups were compared. Several workers did not obtain ohmic contacts at all, although the same contact design and equivalent equipment was used.[ 7~ If the properties of the contact are determined by tunneling through a barrier created by nitrogen diffusion, even a slight variation of this barrier will have a strong influence on the IV characteristics, since the properties of the barrier appear exponentially in the tunneling probability. Thus, minor changes in growth conditions or composition of the plasma can lead to strong effects in IV characteristics. Second, aging experiments on laser diodes show that the threshold voltage tends to increase during operation.[ 73] This indicates that a contact degradation takes place during heavy duty operation. In the picture given here, this is an indication of nitrogen diffusion during device operation. Following the argument given above, even minor diffusion effects may be seen drastically in the IV curve. Although this diffusion during operation did not seem to be a factor that limited device lifetime, as long as the density of extended defects was high, it could become important for the structurally more perfect devices that are now available. Based on these observations, one can give some ideas how pcontacts to ZnSe can be further improved. A reduction of the dislocation density in the contact may help to suppress diffusion or at least to increase the activation energy of the diffusion process. In fact, the IV curve of the diode with a lattice mached ZnSTe spacer between the p-ZnSe and the graded contact (which is shown at the right side of Fig. 20) is better than that of a pure ZnSe diode grown at the same conditions. This indicates that the lattice matched spacer reduces interdiffusion. In that sense, the use of nearly lattice matched BeTe instead of ZnTe in contacts[ 3] may be an advantage. Completely avoiding nitrogen as a dopant in the contact region is still more promising. A first step towards this direction has been done by the use of p-Ge as a contact material.[ TM] An extension of this concept to graded ZnSe/Ge structures might even allow the realization of a lattice matched, nitrogen free contact, although significant difficulties for the epitaxy of ZnSe on Ge may be encountered in the practical realization of such a structure.
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering 6.0
37
CONCLUSIONS
Most experimental results on the maximum doping levels obtained in wide gap II-VI materials can be explained by a model that assumes a pinning of the Fermi level at a fixed position with respect to the vacuum level. In the case of n-type doping, this position is about 130 meV above the ZnSe conduction band edge for nearly all II-VI compounds. For pdoping, two different values (namely 120 meV and 580 meV above the ZnSe valence band edge) are obtained for doping with radio frequency and DC nitrogen plasma, respectively. This discrepancy can be understood by assuming the formation of complexes related to nitrogen-nitrogen pairs as the most stable compensating center, an assumption which also is able to describe the abrupt drop in the free hole concentration of RF plasma doped ZnSe if too much nitrogen is offered. In agreement with the model, an upward shift of the valence band edge through surface segregation, or the use of carefully designed superlattices, has the effect of increasing the obtained p-doping level. This fact can be used to gain more flexibility in the design of optoelectronic devices emitting in the blue spectral region. Finally, the formation of ohmic contacts to p-ZnSe is a process governed by diffusion. The results presented can be understood under the assumption that nitrogen diffuses along dislocations from the ZnTe cap into the underlying ZnSe. The excess of nitrogen leads to a highly resistive zone that must be overcome by a tunneling process and thus increases the operation voltages of ZnSe based diodes. This phenomenon may be reduced by the use of lattice matched contacts or contacts that do not involve nitrogen.
REFERENCES 1. Gunshor, R. L., Kobayashi, M., Kolodziejski, L. A., Otsuka, N., and Nurmikko, A. V., J. Crystal Growth, 99:390 (1990) 2. Okuyama, H., Nakano, K., Miyajima, T., and Akimoto, K., Jpn. J. Appl. Physics, 30:L1620 (1991) 3. Landwehr,G., and Waag, A., Proc. Int. Syrup. on Blue Lasers and LEDs, p. 17, Chiba (1996)
38
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
4. Park, R. M., Troffer, M. B., Rouleau, C. M., DePuydt, J. M., and Haase, M. A., Appl. Phys. Lett. 57:2127 (1990) 5. Ohkawa, K., Karasawa, T., and Mitsuyu, T., J. Crystal Growth, 111:797 (1991) 6. Haase, M., Qui, J., DePuydt, J., and Cheng, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59" 1272 (1991) 7. Fan, Y., Han, J., He, L., Saraie, J., Gunshor, R. L., Hua, G. C., and Otsuka, N., Appl. Phys. Lett., 61:3160 (1992) 8. Ishibashi, A., and Mori, Y., J. Crystal Growth, 138:677 (1994) 9. Okuyama, H., Miyajima, T., Morinaga, Y., Hiei, F., Ozawa, M., and Akimoto, K., Electron. Lett., 28:1798 (1992) 10. Taniguchi, S., Hino, T., Itoh, S., Nakano, K., Nakayama, N., Ishibashi, A., and Ikeda, M., Electronics Letters, 32:552 (1996) 11. Albert, D., Olszowi, B., Spahn, W., Niimberger, J., Kom, M., Hock, V., Ehinger, M., Faschinger, W., Landwehr, G., J. Crystal Growth, 184/ 185:571(1998) 12. Kawasumi, T., Okuyama, H., Nakayama, N., Ishibashi, A., and Mori, Y., Electron. Lett., 31:1667 (1995) 13. Itoh, S., Nakayama, N., Matsumoto, S., Nagai, M., Nakano, K., Ozawa, M., Okuyama, H., Tomiya, S., Ohata, T., Ikeda, M., Ishibashi, A., and Mori, Y., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys, 33:L938 (1994) 14. Hua, G. C., Otsuka, N., Grillo, D. C., Fan, F., Han, J., Ringle, M. D., Gunshot, R. L., Hovinen, M., and Nurmikko, A. V., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65:1331 (1994) 15. Nurmikko, A. V., Jeon, H., Gunshor, R. L., and Han, J., J. Crystal Growth, 159:644 (1996) 16. Okuyama, H., Kishita, Y., Miyajima, T., and Ishibashi, A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:904 (1994) 17. Ishibashi, A., IEEE J. on Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, 1:741 (1995) 18. Laks, D. B., Van de Walle, C. G., Neumark, G. F., and Pantelides, S. T., Phys. Rev. Lett., 66:648 (1991) 19. Van de Valle, C. G., Laks, D. B., Neumark, G. F., and Pantelides, S. T., Phys. Rev. B, 47:9425 (1993) 20. Van de Valle, C. G., Laks, D. B., Neumark, G. F., and Pantelides, S. T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:1375 (1993) 21. Fan. Y., Han. J., Gunshor. R. L., Brandt, M. S., Walker, J., Johnson, N. M., and Nurmikko, A. V., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65:1001 (1994) 22. Prior, K., Materials Science Forum, 182-184:11 (Trans Tech Publications), (1995)
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
39
23. Chadi, D. J., Phys. Rev. Lett., 72:534 (1994) 24. Burkey, B. C., Khosla, R. P., Fischer, J. R., and Losee, D. L., J. Appl. Phys., 47:1095(1976) 25. Kachaturyan, K., Kaminska, M., Waber, E. R., Becla, P., and Street, R. A., Phys. Rev. B, 40:6304 (1989) 26. Terry, I., Penney, T., Molnar, S., Rigotty, J. M., and Becla, P., Solid State Commun., 84:235 (1992) 27. Han, J., Ringle, M. D., Fan, Y., Gunshor, R. L., and Nurmikko, A. V., AppL Phys. Lett., 65:3230 (1994) 28. Tao, I. W., Jurkowic, M., and Wang, W. I., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:1848 (1994) 29. Ogawa, H., Irfan, G., Nakayama, H., Nishio, M., and Yoshida, A., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 33:L980 (1994) 30. Faschinger, W., Ferreira S., and Sitter, H., ,4ppl. Phys. Lett., 64:2682 (1994) 31. Ferreira, S., Sitter, H., and Faschinger, W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:1518 (1995) 32. Garcia, A., and Northrup, J., Phys. Rev. Lett., 74:1131 (1995) 33. Kurtz, E., PhD thesis, Univ. Wiirzburg, p. 32 (1996) 34. Walukiewicz, W., Materials Science Forum, 143-147:519 (1994) 35. Walukiewicz, W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 54:2094 (1989) 36. Walukiewicz, W.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 6:1257 (1988) 37. Ren, S. Y., Dow, J. D., and Shen, J., Phys. Rev. B, 38"10677 (1988) 38. Dow, J. D., Hong, R. D., Klemm, S., Ren, S. Y., Tsai, M. H., Sankey, O. F., and Kasowski, R. V., Phys. Rev. B., 43:4396 (1991) 39. Faschinger, W., Ferreira, S., Sitter, H., Krump, R., and Brunthaler, G., Materials Science Forum, 182-184:29, Trans Tech Publications, Switzerland (1995) 40. Marfaing, Y.,J. Vac. ScL Technol. B, 10:1444 (1992) 41. Marfaing, Y,J. Crystal Growth, 138, 305 (1994) 42. Qiu, J, DePuydt, J. M., Cheng, H., and Haase, M. A., ,4ppl. Phys. Lett., 59:2992 (1991) 43. Hauksson, S., Simpson, J., Wang, S. Y., Prior, K. A., and Cavenett, B. C., Appl. Phys. Lett., 61:2208 (1992) 44. Ferreira, S., Sitter, H., Faschinger, W., Krump, R., and Brunthaler, G., J. Crystal Growth, 146:418 (1994) 45. Rajakarunanayake, Y., Miles, R. H., Yu, G. Y., and McGill, T. C., Phys.Rev. B, 37:10212 (1988) 46. Langer, J. M., and Heinrich, H., Phys. Rev. Lett., 55:1414 (1985)
40
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
47. Fischer, F., Waag, A., Bilger, G., Litz, T., SchoU, S., Schmitt, M., and Landwehr, G., J. Crystal Growth, 141:93 (1994) 48. Parbrook, P. J., and O'Donnel, K. P., Optical Properties of Wide Bandgap II-VI Superlattices, in: II-VI Semiconductor Compounds, (M. Jain, ed.), World Scientific, Singapore (1993) 49. Faschinger, W., Ferreira, S., Sitter, H., Krump, R., and Brunthaler, G., Materials Science Forum, 182-184:407, Trans Tech Publications, Switzerland (1995) 50. Tokumitsu, E., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 29:L698 (1990) 51. Nicolini, R., Vanzetti, L., Mula, G., Bratina, G., Sorba, L., Franciosi, A., Peressi, M., Baroni, S., Resta, R., Baldereschi, A., Angelo, J., and Geberich, W., Phys. Rev. Lett., 72:294 (1994) 52. Kowalczyc, S. P., Kraut, A., Waldrop, J., and Grant, R., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 21:482 (1982) 53. Yoshida, S., Misawa, S., and Gonda, S., J. Appl. Phys., 53:6844, (1982) 54. Nakamura, S., Harada, Y., and Seno, M.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 58:2021 (1991) 55. Martin, G., Botchkarev, A., Rockett, A., and Morkoc, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68:2541 (1996) 56. Kurtz, E., Albert, D., Kraus, J., Hommel, D., and Landwehr, G., Proc. Int. Symp. on Blue Lasers and LEDs, Chiba, p. 429 (1996) 57. Einfeldt, S., Heinke, H., Behringer, M., Becker, C., Kurtz, E., Hommel, D., and Landwehr, G., J. Crystal Growth, 134:471 (1994) 58. Ohkawa, K., Tsujimura, A., Hayashi, S., Yoshii, Y., and Mitsuyu, T., Extended Abstracts of the Int. Conf. on Solid State Devices and Materials, Tsukuba, p. 330 (1992) 59. Faschinger, W., J. Crystal Growth, 197:557 (1999) 60. Kimura, K., Miwa, S., Yasuda, T., Kuo, L., Wang, T., Jin, C., Tanaka, K., and Yao, T., Proc. Int. Symp. on Blue Lasers and LEDs, Chiba, p. 167 (1996) 61. Hauksson, I, Simpson, J., Wang, S. Y., Prior, K. A., and Cavenett, B. C., Appl. Phys. Lett., 61:2208 (1991) 62. Zhu, Z., Brownlie, G., Horsburgh, G., Thompson, P. J., Wang, S. Y., Prior, K. A., and Cavenett, B. C.,J. Crystal Growth, 159:248 (1996) 63. Baron, T., Saminadayar, K., and Magnea, N., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67:2972 (1995) 64. Jobst, B., Strauf, S., B~iume, P., Kurtz, E., Schenk, H., Gutowski, J., Hommel, D., and Landwehr, G., Proc. Int. Symp. on Blue Lasers and LEDs, Chiba, p. 409 (1996)
Doping Limits and Bandgap Engineering
41
65. Turco-Sandroff, F. S., Nahory, R. E., Brasil, M. J. S. P., Martin, R. J., Besermann, R., Farrow, L. A., Worlock, J. M., and Weaver, A. L., jr. Crystal Growth, 111:762 (1991) 66. Kom, M., Niimberger, J., Faschinger, W., Spahn, W., Ehinger, M., and Landwehr, G., Proc.of the 23rd Int. Conf. on the Physics in Semiconductors, (M. Scheffler and R. Zimmermann, eds.), World Scientific, Singapore, p. 1023 (1996) 67. Faschinger, W., Krump, R., Brunthaler, G., Ferreira, S., and Sitter, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65:3215 (1994) 68. Krump, R., Brunthaler, G., Faschinger, W., Ferreira, S., and Sitter, H., Mater Sci. Forum, 182-184:349 (1995) 69. Niimberger, J., Faschinger, W., Schmitt, R., Kom, M., Ehinger, M., and Landwehr, G., AppL Phys. Lett., 70:1281 (1997) 70. Taike, A., Momose, M., Kawata, M., Gotoh, J., and Mochizuki, K., J. Crystal Growth, 159:714 (1996) 71. Suemune, I., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:2612 (1993) 72. Schumicki, G., and Seegbrecht, P., Prozefltechnologie, Springer, p. 262ff (1991) 73. Ishibashi, A., IEEE J. Quantum Electronics, 1:741 (1995) 74. Ohki, A., Ohno, T., and Matsuoka, T., Proc. Int. Symp. on Blue Lasers and LEDs, Chiba, p. 252 (1996)
2 Epitaxial Growth of I I - V I C o m p o u n d s by MOVPE Wolfgang Gebhardt and Berthold Hahn
1.0
INTRODUCTION
This article reviews the present state of metal organic vapor phase epitaxy (MOVPE) of wide gap II-VI semiconductors, a class of materials, which is typically represented by ZnSe and related ternary and quaternary compounds. Epitaxial growth of large gap II-VI compounds has attracted a renewed interest, in the last years, since the successful operation of blue diodes and injection lasers based on ZnSe related material. Although MOVPE of II-VI compounds has not yet reached the same maturity as MBE growth, important progress has been made in the last years. Furthermore, we are convinced that there is no intrinsic problem connected with MOVPE which might hamper a successful production of II-VI devices. Both methods of epitaxy, MBE and MOVPE, still suffer from the lack of appropriate II-VI substrates, hence, (001)-GaAs wafers are widely used. The purity of MOVPE precursor compounds was, with exception of the hydrides, a severe problem in the past, but has now been solved for most of the precursor molecules given in Table 1.
42
Epitaxial Growth of ll-Vl Compounds by MOVPE
43
Table 1. Thermodynamic Data MOVPE Precursor Frequently Used for Growth and Doping of II-VI-Compounds[ 1]
Compound
t-(C4Hlo)OH
Shortnotation in MOVPE TBOH
82.2 (MP 25.5~
Vapor Pressure at 20~ (Pa) 5600(25~
-60.7
H2S t-(C4HIo)SH
Boiling Point (~ at Normal Pressure
TBSH
63
16 646
-41.5
H2Se
2926
(C2Hs)2Se
DESe
t-(C4Hio)2Se
DTBSe
122
580*
i-(C3Hs)ETe
DIPTe
49 at 18.12 Pa
282
(C2H5)2Zn
DEZn
118
1395
(CH3)2Zn-(C2H5)3N
DMZn-TEN
95
1733
(CH3)2Zn
DMZn
46
16 277 at 0~
(CH3-CsH4)2Mg
(M-CP)2Mg
C2H5I
El
72.3
13300
n-(C4Hlo)C1
n-BCI
78
11 000
(C2Ha)3Ga
TEGa
143
490
t-(C4HIo)PH2
TBP
54
216.9
t-(C4Hlo)AsH2
TBAs
66
19710
t-(C4HIo)NH2
TBN
46
33 701
21 at 40~
*This vapor pressure was derived from consumption measurements in the authors' group.
By far, most of the results presented in this article were obtained with a horizontal laminar flow reactor used in many commercial growth facilities. In our laboratory, an Aixtron MOVPE system AIX200 is used. These kind of reactor cells are operated between atmospheric and low pressure (1000 hPa-0.1 hPa). Their hydrodynamic properties, with
44
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
respect to II-VI epitaxy, have been investigated[ 2] and reviewed by W. Kuhn. [3] There is a well known inhomogeneity of temperature and growth rate in cells along the reactor axis. The growth rate (GR) has a maximum at the gas inlet, which has to be taken into account when results of different groups are to be compared. The inhomogeneity in the used reactor is, at atmospheric pressure, about 10% over a 2" wafer and can be greatly reduced either by low pressure MOVPE or by installation of a rotating susceptor. In a typical MOVPE system three growth regimes may be distinguished (see Fig. 1): 9 A kinetic limited region at low temperatures where the rate of the surface reactions limits the GR 9A flat region which is defined by diffusion or transport
limited growth 9 A high temperature region in which surface desorption and thermal activation of further chemical reactions suppress growth increasingly Growth optimization should be performed (varying mass flow and temperature) within the diffusion limited regime where the GR is practically independent of temperature.
I
(9
I
I
transport
I I
(b) i
2 t--
kinetics (a)
'!' I
I I
0 o) o) o L_
..,.,.
I
I
I i
i
I i
ill.,
,,.,
1/T 0
Figure 1. Three regions of MOVPE growth.
i.
||
Epitaxial Growth o f l I - V l Compounds by M O V P E
2.0
BINARY COMPOUNDS
2.1
ZnTe
45
This substance grows easily on (001)-GaAs using DIPTe and DEZn, or DMZn-TEN as metal organics. The last mentioned adduct, first introduced by Jones, has been proved to be a very useful Zn-compound.[ 4] It is less volatile than DMZn, prevents prereactions in the gas phase, and leads to layers with a smooth surface and less deep center luminescence. The growth in our laboratory was usually performed with DIPTe and DEZn, or DIPTe and DMZn-TEN, at a substrate temperature of Ts = 340~ and a carrier gas flow of 5 stdl/min at atmospheric pressure. Typical input precursor flow rates are found in Fig. 2 which presents a typical plot of GR versus inverse temperature. The kinetic region in Fig. 2 fits a straight line which yields an activation energy (E~) and a prefactor of the surface reactions E r = 102 + 12 kJ/mol and A r = 6.108 pm/h for DIPTe + DEZn and E~ = 96 • 20 kJ/mol and Ar = 2" 108 ~tm/h for DIPTe + DMZn-TEN.
Growth Temperature [~ 400 '
I
380 '
360
I
'
:340
I
'
320
I
'
300
I
'
I
'
DIPTe+DEZn DIPTe+DMZn-TEN
s"A %
_
l.,-=..e C"
-1 ~IL%
s
%
s
E "--i
O---
~3'
t J
=__.J
s $
,,N=,
s
9
$ s s
r
~
J
J
o L_
0
[DEZn] =17.5 pmol/min [DMZn-TEN]=23.0 pmol/min [DI PTe]=34.1 pmol/min 0.1
0,1 ,
I
1.50
,
I
1.55
.,
l
1.60
,
i
1.65
~
i
1.70
,
.I
1.75
1000/TG[1/K] Figure 2. Growth rate of ZnTe versus 1/T for two different Zn precursors.P]
46
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Kuhn et al. investigated the co-pyrolysis DIPTe and DEZn in an isothermal quartz tube under H2-flow (see Fig. 3). They found the respective activation energies of 71 and 74 kJ/mol. The molar ratio of DIPTe and DEZn in this experiment ensured that the walls of the tube were homogeneously covered by ZnTe. As in pyrolysis of the separate metalorganics propene, propane, 2,3-dimethylbutane from DIPTe and ethene, ethane and n-butane from DEZn appear. Additionally, 2-methylbutane has been detected in significant concentrations which is diminished when He is used as carrier gas. Alkenes as reaction products give evidence for fl-elimination. Eq. (1)
(C2Hs)2Zn -~ C2H4 + C2H 6 + Zn
and Eq. (2)
(C3H7)2Te ~ C3H 6 + C3H s + Te
The production gain ofalkenes is reduced when He is the carrier gas, indicating that the carder H 2 also participates. Eq. (3)
(C2H5)2Zn + H 2 --~ C2H 6 + C2H5ZnH
and Eq. (4)
C2HsZnH ~ C2H 6 + Zn ..........................
r ...........................
I ......................
v ..........................
I .................
'
. . . . . . .
I ......................
100
' ......................
! .......................
..
:DPT:
80 a===
09 f-
.~ f-
60-
, . J
03
:~
40-
o
20-
e-
200
'
'
350
400
Temperature[~ Figure 3. Copyrolysis of DEZn and DIPTe.[S]
Epitaxial Growth of ll- VI Compounds by MO VPE
47
There is also a reaction of radicals which yields butane and substituted butanes. When DMZn is used, t-substitution is not possible. Pyrolysis experiments show a clear evidence for a contribution of H2-carrier gas.[ 6] Eq. (5)
(CH3)2Zn --~ CH 3. + - Z n CH 3
Eq. (6)
CH 3" + H 2 --~ CH 4 + H.
The additional effect of (C2H5)3N in the adduct compound DMZnTEN will be discussed with the growth of ZnSe. Before layer quality is discussed, we will consider the substrate preparation which was applied by us and by W. Kuhn in nearly all growth experiments of ZnTe. The polished surface of the GaAs wafers (not epiready) is degreased in propanol, then etched for 60 sec in HzSO4:HzO2:H20 in the proportion 4:1:1 at 40~ Immediately after this wet etching step, the substrate is rinsed in 18 Mr2 water. After drying by spinning, an in-situ deoxidation is followed by an annealing procedure of 15 min at 350~ in streaming Hz-gas. This process was later changed into a 15 min annealing step at 500~ ZnTe layers grown on GaAs suffer from a large lattice mismatch: Eq. (7)
f = as - at a t
which is -7.5% between 300~ and 400~ Here a s is the lattice constant of the substrate and a t that of the layer material under relaxed conditions. After the growth of a few monolayers, the strain is already largely relaxed by the formation of Lomer- and 60~ (see Fig. 4). This dislocation array yields a strain relaxation: Eq. (8)
6=
b.e(llO)
where the scalar product b'e(110) of the Burgers vector, and the unit vector along (110) is just the component ofb in this direction and d is the averaged distance between two misfit dislocations. The remaining unrelaxed strain at the interface ~1is given by the difference: Eq. (9)
~]1= 6 - f
48
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
which is about -0.5%. When layers of various thicknesses are investigated (see Fig. 4), one finds a saturation of the relaxation at a thickness of about 0.8 ~tm. A very small residual compressive strain of about -0.05 % remains, even in thick layers, but is completely compensated for and even converted into tensile strain when cooled down to liquid Helium temperature for measurements. The dislocation density at the interface evaluated from high resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) images is about 6.10 ~2 cm -2, whereas, in a 3 ~tm thick layer, only about l0 s cm -2 can be determined by the broadening of x-ray rocking curve.
................... ' ............
I ...........
' ............
I ............
r .......
I . . . . .
' ........
I .........
'
.......
I
.......
r .............. [ ................
~ .............
e=,=~
c
0.0
o=,..
f.3
ffl &
II1 ---
9
/.D
9
-0.1
11.
-0.2 o
9 ion channeling DIPTe+DMZn-TEN 9 reflectance DIPTe+DEZn reflectance DIPTe+DMZn-TEN
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . j . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ! .................... ,. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
0.5
1.0
I .............
1.5
J .............
1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , ................... !
2.0
.................. ~ .................... i . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2.5
~-. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3.0
Thickness [IJm] Figure 4. Parallel surface strain of ZnTe layersgrown on GaAs(100) as a function of layer thickness.[7H9]
Our laboratory has made some attempts to study the growth of cubic ZnTe on GaAs(111 A) 2 ~ off. The growth under standard conditions (DIPTe + DMZn-TEN, Ts = 340~ yielded layers which were nearly defect free. HRTEM images show a dark interface zone which extends about 10 nm into the ZnTe layer (see Fig. 5). The misfit dislocations have Burgers vectors parallel to the (111)-planes. Since these planes are glide planes of the zincblende structure, the dislocations are confined within these planes parallel to the interface. The FWHM of the x-ray (111)-reflection was 82 arc sec and, thus, close to the theoretical value of 72 arc sec for ZnTe-layers of 200 nm thickness.
Epitaxial Growth o f l l - V l Compounds by M O V P E
" .- -~,~~.,~- .
49
: ,~ ~ ,'.vr. . '~ : ~.
e. ~!
FWHM 24aw.sec GaAs( 14.1!
8Znre 2 (111) ~f cl~c
i O0 nm
4~
Omegaldegl
Figure 5. Cross section view of the ZnTe/GaAs (111) interface region together with the rocking curve of the (111 ) reflex.[ !~
Doping of ZnTe has been attempted with a variety of elements, however only p-doping has been achieved. The dopants used in our laboratory were: TBAs, TBP, TMBi [(CH3)3Bi ], EI, TEGa, EDMIn [(C2Hs)(CH3)2In ]. A successful doping up to p ~ 1018 cm -3 was obtained only with TBAs and TBP. Typical results from Hall measurements are given for three samples in Table 2 (see also Ref. 11).
Table 2. Acceptor Binding Energy AEA, Hole Concentration NA and the Compensation ND/NA in Three Samples Doped with TBP and TBAs
ZnTe:As- 12
Sample No.
ZnTe:P- 125
ZnTe:P- 124
AEA [meV]
46
35
58
NA [cm -s]
1.6.1017
7.8.1017
4.1.1016
N D [cm "3]
3.1.1016
1.6.1017
1.9.1016
No/NA
0.2
0.2
0.45
50
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
The electron mobilities (~t) thus obtained are quite satisfactory. An example of ~t(T) is given together with a theoretical curve in Fig. 6.
10,8
1000
10"
10'e
750
E 10" ~'
~" "E
t
tO
'!ii I1'
[P]/Ere]: [P].~./Fe~
L
o
250
~ 10'2
10" 101o
5
10 15 20 1000/T [l/K]
25
00 1 ~50' 100....150' " " 200 ' ....250' ....300 Temperature [K]
Figure 6. Carrier concentrationand Hall mobilityof ZnTe:P.
2.2
ZnSe
The growth of ZnSe is usually performed with the same Zn sources as are commonly used for ZnTe. The usual Se sources are H2Se, DMSe, and DTBSe.[ 12] H2Se has the advantage of being readily available in relatively high purity. Disadvantages include its high toxicity and its tendency to prereact in the gas phase with the Zn-eompounds. Therefore, many laboratories have replaced H2Se by less hazardous compounds. Some have already been listed in Table 1. Heuken et al.[ 131have published a comparative study of ZnSe growth rates using various substituted selenium compounds (see Fig. 7), from which DTBSe allows by far the lowest growth temperatures (320~ < Ts). Further advantages of DTBSe are an exceptional broad region of diffusion limited growth (320~ < Ts < 360~ no detectable carbon incorporation, and no prereactions. High quality
Epitaxial Growth o f l l - V l Compounds by MOVPE
51
layers are thus grown at a relatively low selenium to zinc ratio (Se/Zn _=_ 2, compared to 18 necessary when H2Se is used).
550
500
450
400
350
300
o.1 f
......&
I t
--e-- DE_zn*DIPSe --"-- DEZn+DASe -+- DMZn+DESe
1.2
DEZn+DTBSe
1.3
_
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1/TG [1 O00/K] Figure 7. ZnSe growth rates with DMZn and various Se-precursors.[ l 1][13]-[16]
Substrate Preparation. In the authors' laboratory, the standard procedure to grow ZnSe layers is the following: 9 The polished surface of the GaAs wafers (not epiready) is degreased in boiling propanol then rinsed in 18 MC~ water 9 A 60 see. etch at r.t. with H 2 S O 4 : H 2 0 in the proportion 4:1 9 Immediately after this wet etching step, the substrate is again rinsed in 18 M ~ water and dried by spinning 9 Lastly, an in-situ, 20 min desoxidation in flowing hydrogen at 500~ A slightly different procedure is applied to epi-ready GaAs substrates which, after wet etching, are only shortly in-situ annealed at 360~ G r o w t h Conditions with DTBSe. DMZn-TEN and DTBSe are used at Ts = 340~ with Hz-earrier gas flow of 5000 scem/min, Zn = 29 ~tmol/min, Se = 87 ~tmol/min, Se/Zn = 2-3. The pyrolysis of DMZn-TEN has been investigated in a clean growth reactor by recording the mass
52
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
spectra between room temperature and 400~ The difference spectra reveal, as decomposition products, mainly ammonia, ethylene, and methane. The latter stems from DMZn in H 2, whereas NH 3 and C2H4 are products of the TEN pyrolysis. The amine is always adsorbed at the Se- or Sell-determined surface, a conclusion which was reached by in-situ experiments with a reflection difference spectrometer.[ 25] The complete decomposition of the amine on the surface leaves a Se-Zn-bond and releases NH 3, C2H4, C3H6, and C3Hs. Propene and iso-propane stem from the decomposition of DTBSe. Thus, the amine inhibits a quick reaction of Zn and Se on the surface. A model of the possible steps of this reaction has been suggested in Ref. 17. It is important to notice that H2-carrier gas does not participate in the thermal decomposition of DTBSe which disintegrates by ~-elimination. Therefore, H 2 may be safely replaced by an inert carrier gas like N 2 or He.[is] PL spectra may be used as a sensitive tool for the detection of point defects in the layers. As shown in Fig. 8, there is no deep luminescence in layers grown with DTBSe under the above mentioned conditions. Free and donor bound excitons dominate the near band gap luminescence. The donors are presumably chlorine atoms, impurities which are likely to originate in DTBSe. Although the purity of DTBSe has continuously improved, there is still much to be done to reduce background donor concentration. The density of line defects, such as dislocations and stacking faults, is another problem and is the principal source of degradation in II-VI LEDs and laser diodes. In order to reduce the number of ingrown dislocations, a 2-dimensional growth mode should be achieved as is commonly used in MBE. This is difficult to control in MOVPE, since all the powerful surface analytical methods, which need ultra high vacuum, cannot be used. In spite of this difficulty, MOVPE-growth was controlled by RHEED. For this purpose, growth was interrupted and the sample was cooled down to room temperature in flowing nitrogen. The sample was quickly transferred to a MBE-chamber. The RHEED pattern of samples grown under standard conditions (see above) showed a 3D-characteristic and [ 110]-oriented facets. When growth is continued in the MBE-chamber, a 2D-growth mode reconstitutes after a few monolayers. This procedure can be repeated several times with equal results. The results were independent of substrate preparation which was always the same. In Succeeding work, we were able to show that TEN in the adduct compound played a crucial role in the promotion of a 3D-growth mode during MOVPE. When DMZn was used, a 2D-growth mode could be achieved, although at relatively low temperatures.
Epitaxial Growth o f l I - V I Compounds by MOVPE
2.8
Energy [eV] 2.4
2.6
I
'
' I
'
""
2.2
I
"
'I
'
'
'
hh
.
,-.,
53
9
PL ZnSe 2K
"~
12
I,o
Z t"t
'
I
I
"
4380'
I
4 00
,
'
I
,
,
5000 Wavelength [A]
4400
.... 4 J l 2 0 -
i
"
'
.... 4~1.40 .... 4J160
.
.
.
.
.
5500
Figure 8. PL spectra of a 200 nm ZnSe layer at 2 K.
Growth Conditions with Other Se-Precursors. A comparative study of growth rates using DASe, DIPSe, DESe, and DTBSe together with DEZn at various VI/II ratios, has been carried out by Heuken et al.[ 13] In Fig. 7, the results are plotted versus 1/T. Data of another study using DEZn + DMSe and DEZN + MSeH are taken from Refs. 13, 16, and 15. In Refs. 14-16, there was broad experience with DMSe and DESe at growth temperatures above 400~ including photoassisted growth as low as 350~ This growth, however, needs H 2 as reactand (see below). In practice, it sometimes may be useful to choose an appropriate precursor in order to cover a convenient temperature range for growth. However, before planning the respective experiments, one should always ask if the chosen precursors arc available in the required purity. Photoassisted Growth. The lowest growth temperatures under standard conditions using alkyl selenides have been achieved, as shown above, with DMZn + DTBSe or TBSeH.[ 19l If necessary, the growth temperature Ts can be further reduced when the sample is irradiated with
54
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
above bandgap light. In our laboratory, we have used a 150 W xenon lamp, which gives an intensity up to 45 mW/cm 2 at the sample surface. It was found that the diffusion limited region extended now to about 300~ when DMZn-TEN was used. In general, photoassisted growth facilitates doping but can also lead to an increase in the impurity background. Respective results have been published for DMSe and DESe by Fujita et al.[ 2~ and for DTBSe by Hahn et al.[211(See Fig. 9.) In general, the region of diffusion limited growth is shifted to lower temperatures and the reaction limited growth is governed by a lower activation energy.[ 171In the case of DTBSe + DMZn or DMZn-TEN, this yields, at 300~ a growth enhancement factor of 2.1 or 3.4 respectively. Fujita and Fujita summarized the known experimental facts and proposed the following model. The above band gap photons produce electron hole pairs with a quantum yield up to 10%. The holes accumulate at the ZnSe surface due to band bending.[ 221This effect changes the redox potential at the surface. Surprisingly, adsorption and decomposition of the Zn-precursor play important roles and determine the rate limiting step in photoassisted MOVPE (PA-MOVPE). The evidence was found by mass spectrometry [23] and surface sensitive experiments like RDS [24][25] and was also supported by ab-initio calculations.[ 26] When DMZn or DEZn molecules reach the positively charged surface, they bend and act as electron donors which react with the holes. Before a simple reaction scheme is formulated, the role of hydrogen should be emphasized. A Sedetermined surface grown by MBE shows reconstruction since the dangling bonds form dimers. However, if the surface is grown by MOVPE, all dangling bonds are occupied by hydrogen. Therefore, the reaction scheme may be written: Eq. (10)
(Se)surf-H + CH 3 Zn CH 3 ~ (Se)surf-Zn- CH 3 + CH 4 and
Eq. (11)
(Se)surf-Zn- CH 3 + CH 3 Se CH 3 --+ SeZn-(Se)surf CH 3 + C2H6
Here, (Se)sur f symbolizes a Se-atom at a normal lattice site but in surface position bound to two Zn-atoms in the lower lying layer. It is an essential aspect of this model, supported by all experimental results, that PA-MOVPE is a photocatalytic surface reaction. Furthermore, atomic hydrogen plays an important role, it covers the surface, is highly mobile, and reactive.
Epitaxial Growth of lI-VI Compounds by 510VPE
500
450
,
I
,-.,1
"
,,
I
,,
To [*C] 400
"
I
350
"
300
!
0 .......... 0 ~ ~ 0 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
55
"
0"~
'
t.-
i
E "1 ,,._...=
L_ r
0.1"
Growth enhancement by illumination
--o-- DMZn+DESe ~ --..-- DMZn-TEN+DTBSe ~ I
1.3
'"
"
I
'
"
1.4
I
9
"
li~
1.5
1.6
"
"
'1
'
'
1.7
'"
'
!
1.8
1000/TG [l/K]
Figure 9. Growth enhancementunder irradiation with above band gap light; open symbols depict samples grown in photoassisted mode.[2~l[151
n-Doping. A variety of group-Ill-cations and group-VII-anions have been used, more or less successfully, as n-dopants of ZnSe.[ 27] The highest donor concentrations, well in the region of degeneracy, were obtained with C1 and I. Deep donor centers are not formed before very high concentrations (C1 and I > 1019 cm -3) are reached.[ 28] In Table 3, precursor molecules, doping results, and references are summarized.
Table 3. N-Type Doping of ZnSe with Group III and Group VII Elements
Dopant Atom
Precursor
I
C2H5I
Cl
n-C4HI0
Results
29, 30 n > 101Scm-3
27,31 27,32
AI Ga
Ref. #
(CH3)3Ga
n --__10Is cm"3, but forms deep centers
33, 34
56
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
p-Doping. The p-doping of ZnSe and ZnS have a common problem believed to be due to the tendency in these compounds to have the Fermi level pinned in the upper region of the energy gap. This leads to donor states even with most of the group I and group V elements.[35][ 36] Only Li and N were found to be effective dopants yielding p > 1017 cm -3. However, lithium has been rejected because of its fast diffusion which occurs at moderate temperatures. This knowledge has led to numerous doping procedures in order to incorporate N-atoms into the lattice by MOVPE. They are summarized as follows" 9 Plasma doping with low pressure MOVPE[ 13] 9 MOVPE and PA-MOVPE with ammonia and substituted ammonia (organic amines)[37][38] 9 MOVPE with metal organic compounds with a direct nitrogen bond[ 39] 9 MOVPE and PA-MOVPE with azides or hydrazines[ 21][32][401141] The authors of this article have investigated a number of amines and found that, only those which have the structure R.NH 2, where R is an alkane or alkene radical, are effective p-dopants. The problem with most of these compounds, especially NH3, is the strength of the C-N bond which needs relatively high temperatures to dissociate. However, in order to achieve a sufficiently high doping concentration and to avoid interdiffusion in heterostructures, the growth temperature should be low. This is feasible when t-C4H10NH 2 (short notation TBN) is used. TBN has a weak C-N bond and already dissociates above 380~ The growth temperature can be further reduced by illumination. A standard procedure was described by Fujita et a1.[381[42] who used PA-MOVPE (1 > 300nm) with DEZn (6 ~mol/liter) + DMSe (12 ~mol/liter) at 200 Torr and 350~ The flow rate of TBN was varied between 6 and 12 I~mol/liter. A 30 minute post growth annealing in the reactor in flowing N 2 between 500 and 600~ was necessary to activate the nitrogen acceptors. Subsequent C-V-measurements revealed a hole concentration of up to 3.1017 cm -3. An extremely high purity of all precursors, especially with respect to halogen contamination, is an essential prerequisite of successful p-doping. The work cited above led to the suggestion that nitrogen is only incorporated if NH2-radicals reach the surface. On the other hand, hydrogen plays an important role and inactivates nitrogen acceptors. Therefore, it may be possible that at least one hydrogen atom stays either in the neighborhood of, or forms a bond with, the N-atom which occupies a Se-site.
Epitaxial Growth o f ll- VI Compounds by MO VPE
57
Therefore, compounds have been proposed which have a direct metal-nitrogen bond or which lack a NH-bond. Several compounds with direct metalnitrogen bonds have been synthesized and tested. However, no p-type conductivity has been found. [39][43] A member of the second group of compounds is ethylazide (C2HsN3) which easily decomposes into N 2 and N'. Although Nincorporation was achieved, [44]--[46] the layers showed high resistivity. The same is true for the application of substituted hydrazines, for which di-methyl- and phenyl-hydrazine (PhHz) have been used. The latter has also been applied by the present authors. Together with DTBSe + DMZn-TEN, very small molar concentrations of PhHz are sufficient to obtain samples in which nitrogen can be detected by SIMS. Under illumination with above band gap light, the optimum growth temperature is 300~ The N2-plasma treatment is a method borrowed from MBE where it has been quite successfully applied and leads to acceptor concentrations up to 4.1017 cm -3. In MOVPE growth and doping experiments, nitrogen incorporation has again been shown. However, p-conduction was not yet demonstrated.[ 13] For completeness, it should be mentioned, that p-ZnSe has been obtained by solid state diffusion using Li3N.[47]
2.3
ZnS
In early growth experiments, ZnS [48]-[50] (and ZnSSe) was grown with DMZn + H2S (+ H2Se) mostly between 3 50 and 400~ and often at a low pressure to avoid prereactions. Briot et al.[51] used DMZn-TEN + H2S and grew ZnS at 300~ with a reactor pressure of 40 Torr. The VI/II ratio was 5. The excellent optical properties of these layers were demonstrated by reflectivity and PL measurements.[ 52] Fujita et al.[ 53] replaced H2S by methylmercaptane (MSH) and grew ZnS between 400 and 500~ (see Fig. 10). In recent years, tertiary-butyl-mercaptane (TBSH) has become available.[ 54] Optimum growth conditions were found with DMZn-TEN +TBSH at a substrate temperature of Ts = 350~ and a reactor pressure ofP = 300 hPa.[ 55] Absorption measurements in the excitonic region of the material thus obtained have recently been published.[ 56] Low growth temperatures have also been reached with DMZn-TEN + DTBS. [57] (See Fig. 10.) Photoassisted growth allows lower growth temperatures as was explained for ZnSe. Fujita described the growth of ZnS from DMZn + DES under illumination with a xenon or Hg-lamp at temperatures between 100 and 150~ TMHowever, fragments of precursor molecules were incorporated leading to poor morphology of the ZnS-layers. The situation improved
58
Wide Ba n d g a p Semiconductors
when a ArF-Laser was additionally installed, leading to photodissociation of the MO-molecules and fairly good layers. In most practical applications, however, growth mastery should be attempted with as few external parameters as possible and the use ofDMZn-TEN +TBSH at Ts = 350~ may be preferred.
Ta[~ 700
600
500 450
400
350
300
250
t"
E ,,,n i.-...._a
0
-,--'
1
r
o 13 DMZn:TEN+TBSH
(.9
.
0.1
1.0
A
DMZn+DES
O
DMZn+MSH
[]
DEZn+DTBS
9
9 DMZn-TEN+DTBS .
I
1.1
.
,
J
.
1.2
,
I.
I
1.3
1.4
.
.
..
I
I
1.5
1.6
,
I
1.7
,
!
=
1.8
.I
1.9
=
2.0
1000/Ta[K] Figure 10. Growth rates of ZnS obtained with various precursors.[S3l[s4ltSTltSS]
Early doping experiments have been successfully performed with TMA1, HCI,[ 59] and EI.[ 6~ In the last mentioned reference, DMZn and HzS were used for growth which allowed growth temperatures as low as 260~ where the carrier concentration reached a maximum of about n = 2.1018 cm -3. In our laboratory, n-type ZnS was grown with DMZn-TEN + TBSH and n-BC1 as dopant at 330~ Degenerate carrier densities up to n < 5.10 TMcm -3 were easily reached.[ 611 Electroluminescence was another important field for industrial use of ZnS and especially of ZnS:Mn. For a description of the deposition of ZnS:Mn-layers by MOVPE, see Ref. 62.
Epitaxial Growth of ll- Vl Compounds by MO VPE 2.4
59
ZnO
ZnO has proven to be an excellent material for windows, antireflection coating, piezoelectric effects, and even for substrates on which to grow GaN. For this latter purpose, one needs single crystalline epitaxial layers grown on (0001)A1203 .[63] Conducting windows and antirefleetion coatings for solar cells [64]are deposited as polyerystalline layers on glass, CIS, [65] CdTe, and Si [66] from the gas phase where the crystallites are usually oriented with the e-axis normal to the substrate surface. Because of its large energy gap, the layers are transparent in visible light (~. > 380 nm). The transmission cutoff in the near IR is given by the plasma frequency and depends on donor concentration as well as on mobility (i.e., the carrier lifetime).[ 67] MOVPE of ZnO is usually performed with DEZn or DMZn and an oxidizing agent. Sometimes, the adduet DMZn:THF is used[ 68] where tetrahydrofurane (THF) may itself act as an oxidizer.[ 65] The substrate temperature ranges between 100 and 500~ Direct use ofO 2 or H20 in air, or a carrier gas such as N 2 or At', leads to prereaetions which may be partly avoided at reduced pressure. In the ease of CO 2, NO 2, and N20, however, the growth rate is rather small. Improvements were achieved by photoassisted MOVPE [67][69][70] and by using alcohols like t-BOH.[ 711 A comparative study of growth with H20 , CzH5OH , and t-BOH revealed superior properties oft-BOH, yielding defect free and highly oriented ZnO-films (see Fig. 11). [72] Kaufmann, et al. [71] investigated the precursor combinations tBOH, DMZn:THF, and DEZn:THF. They determined the activation energy in the kinetic region to be about 40 kJ/mol. There seems to be a diffusion limited region above 350~ for DMZn:THF where the growth rate reaches 0.45 ~tm/h. In all growth experiments, grain size grows with film thickness and is smaller, but of the same order of magnitude as the thickness. Films with good uniformity have been obtained. Analysis of the surface by REM shows erystallites with tetrapodlike morphology.[ TMSome solid Zn-preeursors have been considered, namely zinc-acetate, Zn(CH3COO)2174]; basic zinc-acetate, Zn4(CH3COO)6175]; and zinc-2-ethylhexanoate, Zn(C2HsCsHllCOO)2 .[76] These compounds, which are very cheap compared to DEZn, sublime at moderate temperatures and are used with a transport gas [74][76] or under vacuum conditions. [75] The oxygen is delivered by the acid radical. At 210~ a deposition rate of 5.4 ~tm/h was observed.[ TM]When this rate is plotted versus 1/T, an activation energy of 21 kJ/mole is obtained.
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
60
T=[*C] 400 350
300
250
200
150
e-
E "-, 2 t_ .C:
o (.9
I
/"
_._ H,O
- - = - - t-C4H10OH
1
- - , - - CH3OH --v .... C=HsOH
[DEZn]=l.2sccm ,
9
I
1.6
,
I
1.8
,
I
2.0
,
I
,
2.2
I
I
1000/'1"=[1/K] Figure
11. The growth rates of ZnO films for varios oxidizing agents of DEZn.[723
In order to deposit stoichiometric material, it is advantageous to have independent control of the oxygen carrier. In some cases, a high ratio O/Zn 15 is used. Most as grown films are n-conducting (see Ref. 70). Oxygen vacancies probably act as donors. Intentional n-doping has been achieved with chlorine, when POC13 was used,[ 64] or with borane (B2H6) diluted with H2,[67] or even more efficiently with (CH3)3A1. Film resistivities as low as 0.008 W cm have been reported.[ 77] 2.5
CdSe
CdSe has been grown between 300 and 500~ on (111) GaAs in hexagonal, and on (001) GaAs in cubic, structure using the adduct DMCd.(C4HsS)2 and H2Se.[7s][791The VI/II ratio was about 3. The hexagonal layers showed better optical properties. The decomposition of DMCd starts at relatively low temperatures leading to prereactions especially with H2Se. This tendency is slightly inhibited when the thiophene adduct DMCd.(CiHsS)2 is used.[ 8~
Epitaxial Growth of ll-Vl Compounds by MOVPE
61
Parbrook et al. have grown cubic CdSe and Znl.xCdxSe (see also below) on (001) GaAs at 300~ under normal pressure using DMCd and DMSe. Limited diffusion growth is possible between 380 and 500~ with a VI/II ratio of 2.1 and a DMCd flow of 18 ~tmol/min. Although there is no evidence for hexagonal overgrowth, the layers have a high density of dislocations (Lomer and 60~ due to the 7% misfit between layer and substrate. The present authors used DTBSe + DMCd to obtain cubic CdSe layers on (001) GaAs at an optimum temperature near 360~ The VI/II ratio was 2. The layers were much less perfect than those of ZnTe on (001) GaAs which had about the same lattice misfit. This was probably due to the metastability of the cubic phase at growth temperatures. This conclusion was also drawn by Parbrook et al. since MBE samples showed the same width of x-ray rocking curves. No improvement of layer quality was observed when the adduct DMCd.(C4HsS)2 was used instead of DMCd. 2.6
CdS
Halsall et al.[81] found that CdS grows purely hexagonally only on the (111)A face of GaAs. A mixture of hexagonal and cubic phases was found when CdS was deposited on (001), (110), and (111)B faces. The precursor molecules were DMCd and HES, and the optimum growth temperature was 350~ Some growth improvement has been reported with DMCd-(C4H8S)2.[79] CdS on GaAs(111)A shows arrays of misfit dislocations confined near the interface. The relaxed epitaxial layers have mainly threading dislocations, but are of sufficiently high quality to allow a subsequent growth of wurtzite structure CdS/CdSe superlattiees.[821[831 MOVPE growth of purely cubic CdS has not yet been reported. However, mixed crystals of cubic ZnxCdl.xS were successfully grown on (001) GaAs at 400~ using DEZn, DMCd, and TBSH with x as low as 0.4 [84] (see also Sect. 3.6).
3.0
T E R N A R Y AND Q U A T E R N A R Y C O M P O U N D S
Ternary and quaternary solid solutions of II-VI compounds have been prepared and investigated in order to vary gap energies and lattice constants. The MOVPE technique makes the composition control especially easy, since the concentration of the constituents at the growing
62
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
surface is regulated by the input partial pressure of the precursor compounds. Even a continuous grading of the energy bands can readily be achieved by MOVPE. If a ternary system mixed in the cation or anion sublattiee (A1.xBxC o r ACl.yDy) is t o be grown, it is necessary to allow an adequate overlap of the regions of optimal growth of the binaries AC and BC, or AC and AD. In general, the composition depends nonlinearly on the input partial pressures of the components. A quantitative description is given below.
3.1
Thermodynamics of Binary Compounds Under the conditions of thermodynamic equilibrium the binary reaction:
Eq. (12)
A + C 4-~ AC
is controlled by the reaction constant Kil_viwhieh is the ratio of the reaction rates defined by: Eq. (13)
Kii_w : = k ~ / k ~
The growth is completely determined by the chemical potential difference (A#) between the gas phase in the reactor and the solid interface. If we neglect the effect of a boundary layer, which may be correct in the ease of diffusion controlled growth, then we may write: Eq. (14)
A/t = R T ln(aK)
R is the universal gas constant and a the activity which replaces the concentration in non ideal solutions. Optimal growth conditions are usually found when the VI/II ratio R vI_II , given by the partial pressure in the gas phase, exceeds 2: Eq. (15)
R VI-lI P~176 =
>2
In this case, there is a depletion of cations at the semiconductor surface and the partial pressure ratio at the interface can be given by: Eq. (16)
P vl /P ll = (P~ v~)ZKll_ Vz/ a iz_vl
Note the quadratic dependence of the anionic partial pressure.
Epitaxial Growth of lI-Vl Compounds by MOVPE 3.2
63
Thermodynamics of Ternary Compounds
Given the ratio P v i / P m one would like to know the composition x of the growing layer. This is possible if the solid-vapor distribution function (SVDF) is known. Expressions for the SVDFs are given in Ref. 85. These authors use a model for regular solutions in which the interaction energy (f2) between neighboring atoms and the influence of the lattice distortion is taken into account.j86][87]The chemical activity is then given by: Eq. (17)
a i = x exp{(1-x)2f2/RT}
with the interaction constant if2 and
Tc = ~/R
given in Table 4.
Table 4. Interaction Constant (f2) and Critical Temperature (T~) for Three Ternary Systems
Compound
f2 (J/mol)
L (K)
Zn(SeTe)
14350
863
Zn(SSe)
6670
401
11300
680
(CdZn)Se
The equilibrium constant has to be determined from the well known relation: Eq. (18)
Ki=
exp{- AGi~
where the Gibb's free energy is given by: Eq. (19)
AGi 0 = Ani 0 + TAS i
using ASi extrapolated from 298K to the growth temperature T with:
64
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors T
Eq. (20)
AS = r! C--eTdT
with Cp(T)= a + bT + c7 2 The relevant values are given in Table 5. Table 5. Thermodynamic Data to Calculate the Free Energy of Formation
AS0298K J/mol
a
kJ/molk ZnS
-205
57.7
12.6
1.24
ZnSe
-160
70.3
11.99
1.38
ZnTe
-120
77.8
2.61
CdSe
-145
83.4
11.95
A n ~ 298K
-1.36
1.5
A solid-vapor distribution function (SVDF) can be derived which forms a unique relation between the ratio of the initial partial pressure F = p~176 +pOs) and the composition~. - -. [85]The following two equations for the SVDF are obtained when cationic mixed systems AxBl.xC are considered: Eq. (21)
F= x (1 - fu) +fn(1 + KAca.4c/KsAasA) "l
Eq. (22)
RvI_I](1-fvi) = 1 - ~ i
with the VI/II ratio: Eq. (23)
Rgl_ll= p~176
+ pOB)
The quantitiesfu andfv1are defined as the ratios of vapor pressure at the crystal surface Pk to input partial pressure pk~ of the component k:
Epitaxial Growth of ll-Vl Compounds by MOVPE
65
and ~
and describe the incorporated fraction of constituents. The SVDF for anionic mixed systems ACI_xDx obey similar equations: Eq. (24)
F = x (1 -fzI) +fvz( 1 + [K,4caAc/KBAaB,4]2) "1
Eq. (25)
Rv1-1il( 1 -~I) = 1-frz
Under the conditions of diffusion limited growth and choosing R vi_iz>2, the cationic component determines the growth rate and fn << 1. Then F can be obtained directly from: Eq. (26)
F
= X'Rvl_if
1
+ (1 - RzH[1)( 1 + [K,4caAc/Ks,4as,4] 2 )-1
For choosing Rvz_zz< 1 (surplus of the group VI component), the anionic component determines the growth and fvI << 1. In this ease, Eq. (24) simplifies to: Eq. (27)
F =x
An example is given in Fig. 12, where the SVDF of ZnSSe is plotted versus composition x for various values of R as the parameter. Near R = 1, the curves approach a straight line.
3.3
ZnTeSe
Layers of ZnTexSel. x have been grown at 340~ in an atmospheric pressure MOVPE process using DMZn-TEN, DIPTe, and DTBSe, and a ratio of VI/II = 3.[1~ as] Figure 13 shows a plot of the ratio of the input partial pressures versus the composition x. The full line was calculated from Eq. 26 with the respective parameters taken from Tables 6 and 7 with the exception of.(2 for which a much smaller value had to be chosen. The results of a former growth experiment with di-allylselenide (DASe) are also plotted and are seen to fit the calculated curve as well (i.e., the solid-vapor distribution function (SVDF) is the same for both Selenium compounds and depends only on the ratio VI/II as was expected from Sect. 3.1). The
66
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
experiments with DASe were stopped when SIMS data revealed a considerable concentration of incorporated carbon. This effect might be reduced at higher growth temperatures. The layers have good optical quality. The PL spectra at x < 0.1 show a sharp excitonic structure. At higher Teconcentration (x > 0.1), the PL spectra broaden and shift to lower energies due to compositional disorder and exciton localization.[ 8s]
0.8 03
.(~4539 kJ/mol Kzns,/Kznse--9 T=340~
u.. 0.6 4-
=1
O)
u.. 0.4 v
1=2.1
O9 v LL
1=3
0.2
0.2
0.4 0.6 Composition x
0.8
Figure 12. Solid vapor distribution function (SVDF) of ZnSel.xS x using DMZn-TEN, DTBSe, and TBSH at Ts = 340~
3.4
ZnSSe
Good quality ZnSxSel. x layers (x < 0.15) grown by MOVPE were already reported in 1988.[89][9~ The atmospheric pressure growth was performed with DMZn, DMSe, and DMSH, a precursor combination which needs high growth temperatures (470-500~ Even successful ndoping was achieved with TEGa.[ 33] The same group was also able to reduce the growth temperature substantially (Ts > 270~ and to change x by PA-MOVPE.[ 91] Other high temperature growth was reported using DEZn, DESe, and DES at 515~ 92] In this reference, the high quality of the ZnSe/ZnSSe interface is demonstrated by measuring Brewster angle reflection spectra.
Epitaxial Growth o f lI- VI Compounds by MO VPE
67
1.0
$
Kz,,To/Kz,,~= 0.5 .0.=4490 kJ/mol
0.8
O
cO em
TDTBSe 0.6
o DASe
co r O CI.
0.4
E o
L)
0.2
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 [Se]/[Se+Te]
0.8
Figure 13. Composition x of ZnTexSel_x versus the ratio of input concentrations given by input partial pressures.
The p r e s e n t authors p e r f o r m e d the g r o w t h on G a A s ( 0 0 1 ) at
Ts = 340~ using DTBSe, TBSH, and DMZnoTEN at arbitrary compositions x. Figure 12[93] shows a plot of the partial pressure ratio versus composition. The full line was calculated with Eq. 26 and the parameters from Tables 6 and 7. The bowing is obviously due to the excess of group VI elements. Heuken et al. observed a linear dependence which is expected when VI/II = 1.[94] As shown in Fig. 14, the FWHM of the x-ray rocking curves has a minimum at about 7% when the lattice constants of ZnSSe and GaAs match.[ 93] These results suggest that the broadening at large x may be the result of two effects: 1) misfit dislocations which are generated when the thickness exceeds a critical value dc; and 2) alloy broadening due to concentration fluctuations. The growth of a thin ZnSe buffer layer seems to be always necessary in order to reduce the density of dislocations. This is especially true near x = 0.07, when the lattice parameters match (see Fig. 15 and Ref. 93). Obviously, sulfur reacts with the GaAs surface to form an interface of Ga2S3. n-Doping can be achieved in the same way as in ZnSe, e.g., with nBC1. Figure 16 (a) and (b) show Hall-data from three samples grown in our
68
Wide B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s
laboratory with different compositions X. [96] In these experiments, the partial pressure of C1 was always kept constant. However, the incorporation increases with composition x. Successful p-doping of ZnSxSel. x by MOVPE has not yet been reported.
1500
.
.
.
.
f
'
"
'
'"'
I
""
'
'
'
I
"
'"'"
"
I
.
.
.
.
X 1250
o 1000
r"
c) c)
[]
I~!
,,,,
"1
-DMZn-TEN -DTBSe -TBSH
a n,' 750 X n,' "r" 500
TG=340~
O
"!"
250
1.1_
0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 C o m p o s i t i o n x: ZnS,Se~.,
Figure 14. FWHM of the x-ray rocking curve versus composition X. [931
3.5
ZnxCdl.xSe
ZnxCdl.xSe quantum wells are the active layers in ZnSe-based bluegreen lasers. Therefore some effort has been put into realization and optimization of the ZnxCdl.xSe growth. The problems which inhibited a quick improvement are: 1) low decomposition temperature of DMCd, which is the only appropriate precursor available; 2) the tendency of ZnxCdl.xSe to form microscopic inhomogeneities; and 3) quick diffusion of Cd even at moderate growth temperatures. The present authors used DMZn:TEN, DMCd, and DTBSe and found an optimum growth temperature of Ts = 340~ at a ratio VI/II = 3 and atmospheric pressure. The insert
Epitaxial Growth of lI-Vl Compounds by MOVPE
69
of Fig. 17 shows the full SVDP. The structural and optical quality of the layers with x < 0.1 is excellent, but at larger Cd-content, the FWHM of the x-ray diffraction increases dramatically, a tendency which is also observed in MBE-grown samples. The large FWHM is not only due to misfit dislocations but to microclustering, which limits the x-ray coherence and seems to be an intrinsic property of this system rather than an effect of the MOVPE-process. Some groups tried to improve the properties of Cdprecursor by using an adduct of DMCd with tetrahydrothiophen. They claimed some improvement which other researchers (including the present authors) denied.
,,.
(a)
O ~
~,~
..
,
"., ,~..
..~ ., .~
,~" . ,',,
~
'~
9
,
,, ,
... ~ "
"
" :.~ , ~
(b)
Figure 15. (a) and (b) show plan-view TEM images of ZnS0.15Se0.75 layers on GaAs(001). The thickness is 200 nm. The lattice misfit with GaAs is +0.3%. In (b) a 20nm ZnSe buffer has been grown between GaAs and ZnS0.1sSe0.75. Note the different scale of (a) and (b). The dislocation density in (a) is an order of magnitude larger than in (b).[95]
Alternative growth conditions have been published (DMZn, DMCd, and DMSe, normal pressure, Ts = 300-550~ 97] Since ZnxCdl.xSe is always used as well material for electron confinement, there was probably little motivation for doping experiments and therefore nothing about doping has been published. The problem of quick Cd diffusion in ZnSe/ ZnxCdl.xSe quantum wells has been investigated by HRTEM and optical methods. [98][99] The prefactor of the diffusion constant depends on the constraints of the experiment. For a free surface, this factor is more than two orders of magnitude larger than for a capped s u r f a c e , [99] whereas, the activation energy of diffusion is unaffected and about 2 eV.
70
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
10"," " -
,
9 ,
-
,
-
,
-
l
-
,
-
-
9
10" lira. 1 9 ~'~'~8 ~ i l l ~ --i....1" i
9 "-----
&__&
--.~__&_
.
.
,
600
~
8oo
r
.
.
.
.
,
.
.
.
.
,
.
.
.
.
.
,,.
. . . .
,
.
.
.
.
ZnS.Se,. :[CI]/[VI]=O.06
~_
9 x=o.o6
-
9
0"
[c~l~q]=o.oe
' " ' - , - . ....,..
9
.~
=
10"
x=O.06 -'x=0.11 ...." - x=0.48 . l . ,
s
"11.
.... ,... -" 21111
.
A
,o
.
,5
i
,
~
Irr[1ooo~
i
,
i
.
=
2~
loo
1
35
. . . . -
5O
100
-...-L
=
. -
150 ~ m p e r a t u m [Ki
(a)
200
'.~ 250
(b)
Figure 16. (a) Carrier concentration n and (b) Hall mobility # of ZnSxSel.x :CI for various compositions x at a constant doping level.
2000 +
oO
.o
MBE 9 MOVPE
.-
1500
,
,
.!I-
(0 9
q-
LL
1000
~
0.8 -
---=~ A
DMCd DMCd-THT
0.6
A
r~ n, ,
oo 0 . 4 ~
_ ~ . / /
+
T0=340"C
q-
500
I
1
molar input flow ratio [Znj/[Zn+Cd]
o.,
,
I
0,2
,
o:,
I
0,4
,
-
L.
,
0,6
I
,.
I
0,8
c o m p o s i t i o n x ZnxCd,.~Se Figure 17. HRXRD FWHM of ZnxCdl_,,Se alloys grown by MOVPE and MBE. The insert depicts the composition of ZnxCdi.xSe versus ratio of input concentration.tZ~
Epitaxial Growth of l I - V l Compounds by MO VPE 3.6
71
ZnCdS
The growth of cubic Znl.xCdxS was first reported in 1989.[l~176 It covers a large range of gap energies and, at x = 0.57, the lattice matches with that of GaAs. The growth was performed with DEZn, DMCd, and DMSe. The growth temperature (Ts = 420~ had to be chosen high enough in order to obtain an acceptable growth rate and low enough to suppress the growth of a hexagonal phase. At Villi = 7, and a moderate x, the solid vapor distribution function (x versus Cd/Cd + Zn) is a straight line. The lattice matching shows up in a minimum of FWHM (~ 70 arc see) of the x-ray rocking curves.J1~ The same group successfully achieved the growth of the quaternary system Znl.xCdxSl.ySey[l~ with methylmercaptane (MSH) as sulphur precursor. In a subsequent paper, it was shown that photoirradiation (100 mW/cm 2 at ~, < 300 nm) not only increases the growth rate of most binaries, but can also change the composition of ternary compounds when the ratio of the initial partial pressures Cd/Cd + Zn is kept constant.[l~ TM] This method was recently used to grow the barriers of ZnxCdl.xS quantum wells by increasing the Znconcentration under illumination.[ 1~ An attempt to incorporate nitrogen using BNH 2 and photoirradiation was probably successful. However, low resistivity has not been achieved.[ 1~
3.7
ZnMgSeS
The system, Znl.xMgxSel.ySy, is used for cladding layers in bluegreen lasers and was first grown by MBE. However, the MOVPE-technique seems to be suitable to control the volatile elements Se and S very well, and is expected to give good reproducibility even for quaternary systems. Successful growth experiments have already been reported.[1~ 1~ et al. used an atmospheric pressure MOVPE system at a growth temperature of 480~ The precursors were DMZn, DMSe, DES, and bismethyl-cyclopentadienyl-magnesium, with the common short notation (MeCp)2Mg. The layers with compositions x,y = 0.1 have a specular reflecting surface, a small FWHM of the near-band-edge PL, and a FWHM of the x-ray rocking curve of about 170 arc see. Alternative precursors were used by the second group:[ 1~ DMZn:TEN, DTBSe, TBSH, and biscyclopentadienyl-magnesium (CP2Mg) at a growth
72
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
temperature of T~ = 330~ and a reduced reactor pressure of 400 hPa. Prereaction between TBSH and CP2Mg led to white precipitates of MgS in the reactor.[ 1~ In a later paper,[ll~ the authors kept the low growth temperature of 330~ but replaced TBSH by (t-CaH10)2S (shortnotation DTBS), and CP2Mg, which is a solid, by (MeCP)2Mg, which is a liquid above 40~ The authors claim that this choice resulted in a reduction of inhomogeneities and a suppression of prereactions, which led to less structural defects in the layers. A systematic study of concentration fluctuations and inhomogeneities has not yet been published, however it was shown[ 1~ that those samples considered as "good" from their FWHM of PL had an estimated deviation from the average composition of about 1%. Recently, the successful operation of a MOVPE-grown blue-green laser diode with a ZnMgSeS cladding layer has been reported.[ ill]
4.0
CONCLUDING REMARKS
High quality material of most of the large gap II-VI-compounds have now been grown by MOVPE from commercially available precursors. The precursor purity has been continuously improved over the last years. Ternary and quaternary systems have been grown and their composition is easily controlled. A convenient method to grow p-ZnSe still remains a challenge. A few years ago, a breakthrough was expected from MO-MBE. As a combination of MBE and MOVPE, it should presumably have all the advantages of both epitaxial methods. However, the success of MO-MBE was, and is still, rather marginal. In our opinion, the reason is that its application severely underestimates the role of surface chemical reactions. As we have pointed out in this article, MOVPE needs specially designed molecules. Their architecture and their weak and strong bonds play an important role in the solid/gas-phase reactions in which, in some cases, even the carrier gas is involved. Furthermore, since MOVPE works at a finite pressure, the molecules have the chance to undergo many collisions; volatile products, especially hydrocarbons, are quickly released from the solid surface into the gas phase. However, in MO-MBE, the precursor molecule is, in most cases, at first destroyed in the cracker cell. Then the fragments, which contain C, CH, C2, and HE, reach the solid surface. Those parts which do not quickly leave by desorption have a good
Epitaxial Growth o f l l - V l Compounds by M O VPE
73
chance to be incorporated, and lead to unacceptable large carbon and hydrogen incorporation. Therefore, in most applications of MO-MBE, those advantages of MOVPE connected with solid/gas reactions and with the architecture of the molecules are lost, and only the easy flow control of volatile elements remains. Finally, we would like to emphasize the importance of new optical methods for in-situ growth control. A number of laboratories, including our own, already make use of ellipsometry or reflectance difference spectroscopy to monitor growth processes or to investigate layer by layer growth.[251[112]-[1161With these methods, very recently applied to surface analysis, most of the in-situ uncontrollability of MOVPE growth is eliminated. There is still pioneering work to be done in order to improve the somewhat difficult interpretation of the results. Another equally important development is the application of elaborate computer simulations of molecular dynamics in order to model chemical reaction pathways; an approach which is especially important for surface reactions which are not directly observable. This effort will greatly extend our knowledge of epitaxial processes on an atomic scale.
REFERENCES 1. CVD Metalorganics for Vapor Phase Epitaxy, Morton International, Advanced Materials, Danvers, MA (1992) 2. Sarkvan, W. G. J. H. M., Janssen, G., Croon de, M. H. J. M., and Gilling, L. J., Semicond. Sci. Technol., 5:16-35 (1990) 3. Kuhn, W. S., Qu'Hen, B., Gorochov, O., Triboulet, R., and Gebhardt, Prog. Crystal Growth and Charact., 31:45-117 (1995) 4. Jones, A. C., Wright, P. J., and Cockayne, B., dr. Crystal Growth, 107:297-308 (1991) 5. Kuhn, W. S., Qu'Hen, B., and Gorochov, O., Prog. Crystal Growth and Charact., 31:1-44 (1995) 6. Nhishio, M., Ogawa, H.,Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 29:145 (1990) 7. Leiderer, H., Jahn, G., Silberbauer, M., Kuhn, W., Wagner, H. P., Limmer, W., and Gebhardt, W., J. Appl. Phys., 70:398 (1991) 8. Lovergine, N., Cingolani, R., Lee, G., Mancini, A. M., Vasanelli, L., Romanato, F., Drigo, A. V. and Matter, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:3452 (1993)
74
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
9. Kuhn, W. S., Lusson, A., Qu'Hen, B., Grattepain, C., Dumont, H., Gorochov, O., Bauer, S., Wolf, K., Wijrz, M., Reisinger, T., Rosenauer, A., Wagner, H. P., Stanzl, H., and Gebhardt, W., Prog. Crystal Growth and Charact., 31:119-177(1995) 10. Stanzl,H., Rosenauer, A., Wolf, K., Kastner, M., Hahn, B., and Gebhardt, W., Epitaxial Growth Processes, SPIE 2140:138 (1994) 11. Wolf, K., Stanzl, H., Naumov, A., Wagner, H. P., Kuhn, W., Hahn, B., Gebhardt, W., J. Crystal Growth, 138:412-417 (1994) 12. Kuhn, W., Naumov, A., Stanzl, H., Bauer, S., Wolf, K., Wagner, H. P., Gebhardt, W., Pohl, U., Krost, A., Richter, W., Diimichen, U., Thiele, K. H., d. Crystal Growth, 123:605-610 (1992) 13. Taudt, W., Wachtendorf, B., Beccard, R., Wahid, A., Heuken, M., Gurskii, A. L., Vakarelska, K., J. Crystal Growth, 145:582-588 (1994) 14. Fujita, S., Takeuchi, F. Y., and Fujita, S., Jpn. d. Appl. Phys., 27(11):L2019-L2021(1988) 15. Fujita, S., Tanabe, A., Sakamoto, T., Isemura, M., and Fujita, S., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 26(12):L2000-L2002 (1987) 16. Hirata, S., Fujita, S., Fujita, S., and Isemura M., J. Crystal Growth, 104:521-526 (1990) 17. Hahn, B., Preis, H., Schindler, M., Reisinger, T., and Gebhardt, W., J. Crystal Growth,179:415-422 (1997) 18. Taudt, W., Hardt, A., Lampe, S., Hamadeh, H, and Keuken, M., J. Crystal Growth, 170:491-496 (1997) 19. Nishimura, K., Nagao, Y., and Sakai, K., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 32" 1,428-1, 430(1993) 20. Fujita, S., and Fujita, S., J. Crystal Growth, 117:67-74 (1992) 21. Hahn, B., Deufel, M., Meier, M., Kastner, M. J., Blumberg, R., and Gebhardt, W., J. Crystal Growth, 170:472-475(1997) 22. Yoshikawa, A., and Okamoto, T., J. Crystal Growth, 117:107-110(1992) 23. Fujita, S., Hirata, S., and Fujita, S., J. Crystal Growth, 115:269-273 (1991) 24. Yoshikawa, A., Kobayashi, M., and Tokita, S., Phys. Stat. Sol., 187(b):315 (1995) 25. Kastner, M. J., Hahn, B., Blumberg, R., Sossna, E., Duschl, R., Gebhardt, W., J. Crystal Growth, 170:188-192 (1997) 26. Nakano, T., and Hirano, T.,J. Appl. Phys., 78(1):251 (1995) 27. Kamata, A., Uemoto, T., Okajima, M., Hirahara, K., Kawachi, M., and Beppu, T., J. Crystal Growth, 86:285-289 (1988) 28. Pereira, E., Vilao, Seitz R., Time-resolved luminescence of deep levels in ZnSe samples,,/. Crystal Growth, 189/190:546-550 (1998)
Epitaxial Growth o f l l - V l Compounds by M O V P E
75
29. Fujimoto, M., Suemune, I., Osaka, H., and Fujii, Y., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 32:L524--L527 (1993) 30. Yoshikawa, A., Nomura, H., Yamaga, S., and Kasai, H., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 27:L1948-51 (1988) 31. Stanzl, H., Wolf, K., Hahn, B., and Gebhardt, W., J. Crystal Growth,
145:918-923(1994) 32. Kukimoto, H.,J. Crystal Growth, 101:953-957 (1990) 33. Fujita, S., Terada, K., Sakamoto, T., and Fujita, S., J. Crystal Growth, 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43.
44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50.
94:102-108 (1989) Fujita, S., Asano, T., Maehara, K., and Fujita, S., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 32:L1153-L1156 (1993) Walukiewicz, W.,J. Crystal Growth, 159:244-247 (1996) Faschinger, W., J. Crystal Growth, 159:221-228 (1996) Taskar, N. R., Khan, B. A., Dorman, D. R., and Shahzad, K., Appl. Phys. Lett., 62(3):270 (1993) Ogata, K., Kawaguchi, D., Kera, T., Fujita, S., and Fujita, S., J. Crystal Growth, 159:312 (1996) Pohl, U. W., Freitag, S., Gottfriedsen, J., Richter, W., and Schumann, H., J. Crystal Growth, 170:144-148 (1997) Akram, S., and Bhat, I.,J. Crystal Growth, 138:105-109 (1994) Yoshikawa, A., Matsumoto, S., Yamaga, S., and Kasai, H., J. Crystal Growth, 101:305-3 10 (1990) Fujita, S., Tojyo, T., Yoshizawa, T., and Fujita, S.,J. Electr. Mat., 24(3):137 (1995) Rees, W. S., Jr., Green, D. M., Anderson, T. J., and Bretschneider, E., Wide Band Gap Semiconductors Symposium, (T. D. Moustakas, J. L. Pankove, Y. Hamakawa, eds.), pp. 281-286, Pittsburgh, PA, Mater. Res. Sec, (1992) Inoue, K., Yanashima, K., Takahashi, T. Hwang, J. S., Hara, K., Munekata, H. and Kukimoto, H.,J. Crystal Growth, 159:130-133 (1996) Hayashi, K., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65(16):2084 (1994) Kamata, A.,J. Crystal Growth, 145:557-561 (1994) Honda, T, Lim, S. W., Inoue, K., Hara, K., Munekata, H., Kukimoto, H., Koyama, F., and Iga, K., d. Crystal Growth, 170:503-506 (1997) Cockayne, B., and Wright, P. J.,J. Crystal Growth, 68:223-230 (1984) Fujita, S., Matsuda, Y., and Sasaki, A., d. Crystal Growth, 68:231-236 (1984) Yoshikawa, A., Yamaga, S., Tanaka, K., and Kasai, H., d. Crystal Growth, 72:13-16(1985)
76
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
51. Briot, O., Briot, N., Abounadi, A., Gil, B., Cloitre, T., and Aulombard, R. L., Semicond. Sci. Technol., 9:207-209 (1994) 52. Abounadi, A., Di Blasio, M., Bouchara, D., Calas, J., Averous, M., Briot, O., Briot, N., Cloitre, T., Aulombard, R. L., and Gil, B., Phys. Rev. B, 50(16):11677 (1994) 53. Fujita., S., and Fujita, S., J. Crystal Growth, 117:67-74 (1992) 54. Armitage, D. N., Yates, H. M., Williams, J. O., Cole-Hamilton, D. J., and Patterson, L. P., J. Crystal Growth, 117:1082 (1992) 55. Lovergine, N., Longo, M., Gerardi, C., Manno, D., Mancini, A. M., and Vasanelli, L., J. Crystal Growth, 156:45-51 (1995) 56. Fem~indez,M., Prete, P., Lovergine, N., Mancini, A. M., and Cingolani, R., Phys. Rev. B, 55:7660-7666 (1997) 57. Obinata, T., Uesugi, K., Sate, G., and Suemune, I., Jpn. J." Appl. Phys., 34:4143-7 (1995) 58. Fujita,Y., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. Lett., 35(7B):L919-22 (1996) 59. Yamaga, S., Yoshikawa, A., and Kasai, H., J. Crystal Growth, 86:252-256 (1988) 60. Yamaga, S., Yoshikawa, A., and Kasi, H., J. Crystal Growth, 106:683-689 (1990) 61. K. Ehrmann, Diploma Thesis, University Regensburg (1996) 62. Zhao, L., Zhong, G., Yang, B., and Fan, X., Inorganic and Organic Electroluminescence, (R. H. Mauch and H. E. Gumlich, eds.), p. 165, W&T, Berlin (1996) 63. Detchprohm, T., Hiramatsu, K., Sawaki, N., and Akasaki, I., J. Crystal Growth, 145:192-196 (1994) 64. Takato, H., Yamanaka, M., Hayashi, Y., Shimokawa, R., Hide, I., Gohda, S., Nagamine, F., and Tsuboi, H., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 31 :L1665-L 1667 (1992) 65. Olsen, L. C., Addis, F. W., Greer, D., Lei, W., and Abulfotah, F., Conference Record of the Twenty Fourth IEEE Photovoltaic Specialists Conference 1994, New York, NY, IEEE, 1:194-7 (1994) 66. Smith, F. T. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 43(12):1108 (1983) 67. Yamada, A., Wenas, W. W., Yoshino, M., Konagai, M., and Takahashi, K., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 30:L1152-L1154 (1991) 68. Kaufmann, T., Fuchs, G., and Webert, M., Cryst. Res. Technol., 23:635-639 (1988) 69. Shimizu, M., Katayama, T., Shiosaki, T., and Kawabata, A., J. Crystal Growth, 99:399-402 (1990) 70. Shimizu, M., Katayama, T., Tanaka, Y., Shiosaki, T., and Kawabata, A., J. Crystal Growth, 101:171-175 (1990)
Epitaxial Growth o f l l - V l Compounds by M O V P E
77
71. Kaufmarm, T., Fuchs, Fuchs, G., Webert, M., Frieske, S., and G~ickle, M., Cryst. Res. Technol., 24:269-274 (1989) 72. Oda, S., Tokunaga, H., Kitajima, N., Hanna, J., Shimizu, I., and Kokado, H., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 24:1607-1610 (1985) 73. Yoshino, M., Wenas, W. W., Yamada, A., Konagai, M., and Takahashi, K., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 32:726-730 (1993) 74. Maruyama, T., and Shionoya, J.,J. Mat. Sc. Lett., 11:170-172 (1992) 75. Gyani, A. K., Khan, O. F. Z., O'Brien, P., and Urch, D. S., Thin Solid Films,
182:L1-L3(1989) 76. Kumar, N. D., Kamalasanan, M. N., and Chandra, S., ,4ppl. Phys. Lett., 65( 11): 1373(1994) 77. Sang, B., and Konagai, M., Jpn. J." ,4ppl. Phys., 35 :L602-L605 (1996) 78. Wright, P. J., and Cockayne, B., J. Crystal Growth, 94:97-101 (1989) 79. Jones, A. C., Rushworth, S. A., Wright, P. J., Cockayne, B., O'Brien, P., and Walsh, J. R., J. Crystal Growth, 97:537-541 (1989) 80. Jones, A. C., Semiconductor Science and Technology, 6:A36--40 (1991) 81. Halsall, M. P., Davies, J. J., Nicholls, J. E., Cockayne, B., Wright, P. J., and Russell, G. J., J. Crystal Growth, 91:135-140 (1988) 82. CuUis,A. G., Williams, G. M., Cockayne, B., Wright, P. J., and Smith, P. W., Microscopy of Semiconducting Materials, (A. G. Cullis, J. L. Hutchinson, eds.) pp. 217-22, Proceedings of the Royal Microscopical Society Conference, Bristol, UK, IOP (1989) 83. Bradley, L. V., Creasey, J. P., O'Donnell, K. P., Wright, P. J., and Cockayne, B., J. Crystal Growth, 159:551-554 (1996) 84. Dumont, H., Fujita, S., and Fujita, S., Appl. Surface Sci., 86:442-446 (1995) 85. Kisker, D. W., and Zawadzki, A. G., J. Crystal Growth,, 89:378-390 (1988) 86. Stringfellow, G. B., and Greene P. E., J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 30:1779-1791 (1969) 87. Stringfellow, G. B.,J. Crystal Growth,, 27:21-34 (1974) 88. Naumov, A., Stanzl, H., Wolf, K., Rosenauer, A., Lankes, S., and Gebhardt, W.,J. Crystal Growth, 138:595-600 (1994) 89. Tonami, Y., Nishino, T., Hamakawa, Y., Sakamoto, T., and Fujita, S., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 27(4):L506-L508 (1988) 90. Fujita, S., Isemura, M., Sakamoto, T., and Yoshimura, N., J. Crystal Growth, 86:263-267 (1988) 91. Fujita, S., Tanabe, A., Sakamoto, T., Isemura, M., and Fujita, S., J. Crystal Growth, 93:259-264 (1988)
78
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
92. Inoue, K., Kuroda, T., Yoshida, K., and Suemune, I., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65(22):2830 (1994) 93. Gebhardt, W., Stanzl, H., Reisinger, T., Schiitz, G., and Kasmer, M., Materials Sci. Forum, 182-184:105-110 (1995) 94. SiSllner, J., Schmoranzer, J., Woitok, J., Hamadeh, Y., and Heuken, M., Materials Sci. Forum, 182-184:419-422 (1995) 95. Kastner, M. J., Leo, G., Brunhuber, D., Rosenauer, A., Preis, H., Hahn, B., Deufel, M., and Gebhardt, W., J. Crystal Growth, 172:64-74 (1997) 96. Gebhardt, W., Hahn, B., Stanzl, H., and Deufel, M., J. Crystal Growth,
159:238-243(1996) 97. Parbrook, P. J., Kamata, A., and Uemoto, T., J. Crystal Growth, 128:639-645 (1993) 98. Rosenauer, A., Reisinger, T., Steinkirchner, E., Zweck, J., Gebhardt, W., J. Crystal Growth, 152:42-50 (1995) 99. Chai, M. K., Wee, S. F., Homewood, K. P., Gillin, W. P., Cloitre, T., and Aulombard, R. L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69(11): 1579 (1996) 100. Fujita, S., Funato, M., Hayashi, S., and Fujita, S., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 28(6):L898-L900 (1989) 101. Fujita, S., Hayashi, S., Funato, M., and Fujita, S., J. Crystal Growth, 99:437-440(1990) 102. Fujita, S., Hayashi, S., Funato, M., Yoshie, T., and Fujita, S., J. Crystal Growth, 107:674-678 (1991) 103. Fujita, S., Matsumoto, S., and Fujita, S., J. Electronic Mat., 22(5):521 (1993) 104. Dumont, H., Fujita, S., and Fujita, S., Mat. Res. Sec. Syrup. Proc., 340:509 (1994) 105. Dumont, H., Kawakami, Y., Fujita, S., and Fujita, S., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 34:L1336-L1339 (1995) 106. Dumont, H., Fujita, S., andFujita, S.,J. Crystal Growth, 145:570--575(1994) 107. Toda, A., Asano, T., Funato, K., Nakamura, F., and Mori, Y., J. Crystal Growth, 145:537-540 (1994) 108. Hamadeh, H., S611ner, J., Schmoranzer, J., and Heuken, M., J. Crystal Growth, 158:89-96 (1996) 109. Hamadeh, H., S/511ner, J., Hermans, J., Kiister, U., Woitok, J., Geurts, J., Bollig, B., and Heuken, M., J. Crystal Growth, 159:21-25 (1996) 110. Heuken, M., S611ner, J., Taudt, W., Lampe, S., J. Crystal Growth, 170:30-38 (1997) 111. Toda, A., Nakamura, F., Yanashima, K., and Ishibashi, A., J. Crystal Growth, 170:461-466 (1997)
Epitaxial Growth of lI-Vl Compounds by MO VPE
79
112. Razeghi, M., The MOCVD Challenge, Vol. 2, Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol (1995) 113. Yoshikawa, A., Kobayashi, M., and Tokita, S., Phys. Stat. Sol., 187:315 (1995) 114. Stafford, A., Irvine, S., and Griffiths, C., J. Crystal Growth, 170:182-187 (1997) 115. Patrikarakos,D., Shukla, N., and Pemble, M.,J. Crystal Growth, 170:215-218 (1997) 116. Kobayashi, N., Kobayashi, Y., Uwai, K., J. Crystal Growth, 170:225-229 (1997)
3 O h m i c C o n t a c t s to I I - V I and III-V Compound Semiconductors Tae-Jie Kim Paul H. HoUoway
1.0
INTRODUCTION
New generations of high speed transistors, such as High Electron Mobility (HEMTs) and Heterojunction Bipolar Transistors (HBTs), have been developed from the superior transport properties of III-V semiconductors. Epitaxial growth techniques, such as MBE and CVD, on an atomic scale, enabled such development of heterojunction devices with different compositions of ternary or quaternary compounds (e.g., A1GaAs/GaAs and GalnP/InP) Therefore, bandgaps offer higher frequency and power characteristics unattainable in Si-based devices.[1]-[3] In addition to the superior transport properties, III-V and II-VI semiconductors have direct bandgaps, enabling quantum well heterostructures for optoelectronic applications such as light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and diode lasers (DLs).[ l] Monolithic integration of a photo diode and a Field Effect Transistor (FET) is possible because of the direct band gap of these compound semiconductors.[ 4] Voltage and current signals must be brought into, and taken out of, the semiconductors through electrical contacts, regardless of the applications. Ohmic contacts play a critical role by allowing current signals to 80
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
81
exhibit a linear relation with respect to applied voltage, or to have a low enough contact resistance not to hinder performance of the devices, especially at high frequency and high power where parasitic contact resistance will limit both the frequency and power handling capabilities.[5][ 6] High specific contact resistance (>10 -3 f2-cm2) will limit the maximum frequency and cause excessive Joule heating and failure of the devices.J7][8] Ideally, an ohmic contact could be formed by selecting metal work functions depending on the type of semiconductors. Practically, formation of ohmic contacts is a complicated and challenging issue due to mismatch of levels at the interface, or due to a phenomenon called Fermi level pinning which involves surface states. A critical parameter in the formation of metal/semiconductors (M/S) contacts is the condition of the surface and particularly whether or not the Fermi energy level, E F, is pinned. Comprehensive surface science studies oflII-V surface and interfaces, for several decades, have shown that Fermi level pinning affects the formation of both Schottky and ohmic contacts, as will be reviewed below. It has been generally demonstrated that pinning of E F is consistent with the characteristic of the bonding in the semiconductor; with covalently bonded semiconductors most often exhibiting pinned surfaces. On the other hand, ionically bonded semiconductors normally exhibit unpinned surfaces. The type of bonding also correlates well with the electronegativity difference between the elements in a compound semiconductor.[ 9] For the semiconductors to be discussed in this chapter, the character of the bonding varies considerably. The III-V semiconductors tend to exhibit more covalent bonding with lower electronegativity differences (Ax) than do the II-VI semiconductors. Therefore, we would expect the former to exhibit pinned surfaces more than the latter. For example, GaAs bonding is only 32% ionic, A~ between Ga and As is only ~0.4, and E F is pinned in nearly all conditions. For InP, bonding is 44% ionic with A;~ ~0.6 and E F is partially pinned. In the AlxlnyGal_x_yN system, GaN bonding is 70% ionic, A)r is ~1.4 and E F does not exhibit pinning. In the II-VI system, ZnSe bonding is 63% ionic, A~ is ~0.8 and this semiconductor also does not exhibit E F pinning. The consequence of these systematic trends will become evident when we discuss the formation of ohmic contacts to these different semiconductors. Covalent bonding and low A)r for the III-V compound semiconductors leads to Fermi level pinning. Therefore, practical ohmic contacts to GaAs and InP devices are predominantly produced by controlling the barrier width rather than the barrier height. The barrier width is controlled
82
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
by incorporating dopants into the interface region of semiconductors. Annealing of ex situ (i.e., post-growth) metallizations is the practical method to cause the incorporation of dopant through metallurgical reactions. When the interface regions of semiconductors are heavily doped by the metallurgical reactions, current transport across the metal/semiconductor contact is dominated by Field Emission (FE) or Thermionic Field Emission (TFE). In this respect, our primary interest is to understand the details of metallizations used for ohmic contacts. Generally, ohmic contacts to compound semiconductors are formed by a lift-off process using multiple (two or more) element metallization, such as AuGeNi (developed in 1967 for n-type GaAs).[ l~ This same metallization is often used for n-InP. While it has long been used and often studied, AuGeNi metallization exhibits problems which include irregular morphology,[11][ 12]poor thermal stability, [13][14] and interdiffusion.[ 15] Tremendous efforts have been made not only to solve the practical problems of the AuGeNi system, but also to understand the mechanism of AuGeNi contacts.[16]-[ TM]Non-alloyed and Au-free contact schemes have been demonstrated for n-GaAs and InP. [19]'[21] Not withstanding all of the studies, the technology of ohmic contacts is much more advanced than the basis for the understanding which is largely empirical. A more fundamental understanding is essential because electrical contacts are critical to both proper performance of a device as well as its lifetime. A great deal of effort has been focused recently on better understanding of both Schottky and ohmic contacts. Brillson has edited a general review of these subjects.[ 22] In the present review, the focus will be only on ohmic contacts to GaAs, InP, GaN, and ZnSe rather than their ternary or quaternary variants. The purpose of this review is to clarify the current understanding of the effects of interracial reactions occurring during formation of ohmic contacts, rather than to compile various recipes for their formation. As will be shown, new information on the metallurgical reactions taking place at the M/S interface will allow us to better understand when to expect ohmic behavior.
I.I
Energy Barrier and Current Transport Mechanisms
An enormous difference in the electrical properties between metal and semiconductor usually results in the formation of a rectifying barrier at the metal/semiconductor interface. In the case of GaAs and InP, rectifying barriers are formed during processing creating an ohmic contact because of Fermi level pinning.[ 231 Therefore, the interface between the metal and
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
83
semiconductor always has a barrier to transport of charge. To make a good ohmic contact, this barrier must be negated. Ideally, either rectifying (Sehottky) or ohmic contacts may form as a result of charge transfer between metal and semiconductor to align the Fermi level across the interface when a metal is brought into electrical contact with a semiconductor. Figure 1 illustrates the idealized formation of a contact. Figure 1a shows the energy band diagram of a metal and a n-semiconductor before contact (unless otherwise specified, all discussion refers to n-type semiconductors), where ~m and ~ are the work functions for the metal and the semiconductor, EF~ and EF~ are the equilibrium Fermi energy levels of electrons in the metal and the n-type semiconductor, and ~ is electron affinity of the semiconductor. The values E c and E v are the energies of the bottom of the conduction and top of the valence bands in the semiconductor. No surface states exist within bandgap, thus E~ and E v are flat up to the surface before contact. Due to the potential difference (~m--f~Is) when the metal and semiconductor are joined, electrons in the conduction band of the semiconductor flow into the metal to occupy lower energy states. This results in a negative charge on the metal and a positive charge on the semiconductor. Since there are a large number of nearly-flee electrons in the metal, the charge distributes uniformly. However, the limited charge in the semiconductor causes the development of an electric field which bends the bands near the surface out to a distance over which majority carriers are depleted (by donation to the metal). The band alignment and bending shown in Fig. l b is observed. The length of the charge depleted region in the semiconductor (W) is called the depletion length (Fig. lb). In GaAs, W ranges from 20 nm to 1000 nm depending on the doping concentration at room temperature.[Z41 The resulting band bending due to the space charge region in the semiconductor is described by the spatial variation of electrostatic potential, V(x): Eq. (1)
V(x) = (1/q).[Evb-Ev(x) ] = (1/q).[Ec6-Ec(x)]
where the subscript b refers to bulk (i.e., x = 89 and subscripts V and C refer to the valence and conduction bands. With the assumptions of semiinfinite boundary conditions and no interface states, the potential as a function of x can be described by Poisson's equation: Eq. (2)
d2 V(x)/dx 2 = -p(x)/~es
where es is the dielectric constant of the semiconductor and p ( x ) is the spatial distribution of charge. Provided that there are no free carriers in the
84
Wide B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s
depletion region of n-type semiconductor and complete ionization, i.e., p(x) = N o, (No = donor concentration) solving Poisson's equation yields:
Eq. (3)
V(x) = VS + Em(x - x2/2 W)
where E m is the electric field at x = 0 given by (qNoW)/6 s, W is the depletion length given by (2SSVbi/qND) 1/2, and Vbi is the built-in potential defined by Ecb-Ecs(= Om-Os)" Here, Vs is the surface band bending at x = 0. Equation (3) shows that the band edge is a parabolic function of x from x = 0 to x = IT"(Fig. l b). The effect of image charge on the band bending was not considered.
Vacuum level
-
IZI i(i) ~,Vacuum s level
_ _
~ - _ ~_ _ Efs
Ec
Eft-Ev n-Semiconductor
Metal
(a) Before contact
I Efm
Os
b l _~~_ ' . .
_E_c- Ets
,.F x -0
~x
(b) At equilibrium Figure 1. Formationof energybarrierand band bendingin electricaland thermal equilibrium.
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
85
The energy barrier, ~0b, is defined as the energy distance between the Fermi level and the edge of the majority-carrier band (Ec). The rPb of an ideal M/S junction is shown (Fig. 1 b) to be equal to" Eq. (4)
9
=
+
= a
,.-Zs
where Zs is the electron affinity of semiconductor as defined in Fig. 1a. Eq. (4) is the Schottky-Mott rule or the Schottky Barrier Height (SBH). The first term, (q),n-q)~), represents the built-in potential and the second term (q)~-Z), is the potential difference between the conduction band edge and the Fermi level in the semiconductor. There are three transport mechanisms for electrons (major carriers) to cross such an energy barrier.[251[261Thermionic Emission (TE) transport occurs by thermal activation of electrons over the energy barrier from the conduction band of the semiconductor into the metal (Fig. 2a). TE is normally dominant when the semiconductor is low doped up to 1016cm-3 at room temperature. The second current transport mechanism is Field Emission (FE), which is a quantum mechanical effect whereby electrons penetrate through the M/S energy barrier at the Fermi level under the influence of an electric field (Fig. 2b). For FE to be predominant, high doping above 1019 cm 3 at room temperature is necessary. Thermionic Field Emission (TFE) is a combination of the TE and FE mechanisms (Fig. 2c) in which the carriers are thermally activated above Fermi level to a region where they can tunnel efficiently through a narrower portion of the barrier. By assuming that only electrons traversing from the semiconductor to the metal with sufficient energies to overcome the energy barrier can contribute to transport, the current density from the semiconductor to the metal is given by: Eq. (5)
Js-~m =.,4*"T2"exp(-q cl)b/k T).exp( q Va/kT) = JrH.exp(-q cI)a/kT)'exp( q Va/kT)
where Va is the applied bias, Tis the absolute temperature, and gYbis the M/ S barrier height. A* is known as Richardson's constant and given by (4rutm*k2/h 3) where m* is the effective mass of electrons in the semiconductor, k is Boltzmann's constant, and h is Planck's constant. For free electrons, A ~ is 120 m/cm2/K 2. Jrtt (known as the thermionic current coefficient) and defined by: Eq. (6)
J'm = A*.T2
- 120(m*/m)T2[A/em 2] - 10.8(m*/m)(T/300) 2 [MA/cm 2]
86
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
where m is the mass of a free electron. For free electrons at room temperature (T = 300K), Ja'rt is 10.8 Million Amperes (MA)/cm 2. By considering din__,,s, the net current across the M/S contact is given by: Eq. (7)
gaet = gm~s + Jm.s = JTa.exp(-q ~b/kT)'exp(q Va/kT)-JTH'exp(-q~b/kT) = JTH'exp(-q ~b/kT).[exp(q Va/kT ) - 1] - J
.[exp(q Z a / k r ) - 1]
where .Is is saturation eurrent and defined by: Eq. (8)
Js = A*'T2"exp(-q~b/kT) = 120(m*/m)'T2exp(-q~b/kT) [A/cm2]
Metal
n-Semiconductor
r ~x'~ e"
Ef
E-c- Ef
(a) Thermionic Emission
Ef . . . . .
EcEf
(b) Field Emission
Ef
C
E-c- Ef
(c) Thermionic-Field Emission Figure 2. Current transport mechanisms across metal/semiconductor interfaces.
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
87
For a large forward bias V~ >> kT/q, Eq. (7) is reduced to "/net = Js.exp(q V~/kT). Equation 7 determines the current-voltage (I-V) characteristics of M/S junctions in low doped semiconductors, which is the most frequently used method to determine the barrier height. Saturation current (J~) is obtained by extrapolating./net at zero Va from a plot ofln(J,,et ) versus forward bias Va. Then the barrier height ~ob can be determined from Eq. (8). At a large reverse bias voltage, V~ << -kT/q, exp(-qVa/kT) is negligibly small compared to 1. Then J,,et ~ -J~, which indicates a constant saturation current independent of applied voltage. Tunneling of electrons was described to explain current transport under an electric field which was independent of temperature, first in metal[271 and in semiconductors.J28] Tunneling as a transport mechanism across the M/S junction was first suggested to describe the formation of ohmic contact in metal/CdS contacts.[ 29] Basically, tunneling currents are determined by the number of electrons impinging upon the junction and the probability of electron transmission through the potential barrier at the M/S junction: Eq. (9)
Jtunneling = q'n'v.P( ~b)
where q is the charge of an electron, n is the number of electrons impinging on the M/S junction, v is the thermal velocity of electrons, and P(qSb) is the tunneling probability. P(qSb) is obtained by solving Sehrodinger equations with appropriate boundary conditions typically in parabolic potential distribution such as Eq. (3). Since P(~b) is a very complicated function of the detailed band structure and doping concentration of the semiconductor,[3~ 31] approximations were used to calculate the tunneling probability.[8][3111321 Tunneling currents through a barrier of height q)b without applied bias is generally expressed as:[23][33] Eq. (10)
J oc exp (q~b/E00)
where Eoo = (h/4n').(ND/m *es)1/2. Typically, field strengths of 107-108 V/cm are needed to cause significant tunneling current.[ 3~ In semiconductors, such high field strengths are established in the heavily doped surface region near the M/S contacts. Once tunneling currents begin to dominate transport across the M/S junction, tunneling can provide higher current densities than thermionic emission. This is why n + or p+ doped surfaces frequently result in good ohmic contacts.
88
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Frequently, thermionic, field, and thermionic-field emissions are described in terms of specific contact resistance by differentiating Eqs. (7) and (10) with respects to Va. The specific contact resistance is defined by: Eq. (11)
pc = (dJ/dVa) l at Va = 0
where Va is the voltage applied across the contact. For thermionic emission over the Schottky barrier, the solution for Pc is given by: Eq. (12)
Pc = (k/qA*T).exp( ~b/kT)
From Eq. (12), the contact resistance for thermionic emission is independent of the doping concentration; the barrier height determines contact resistance. In the case of tunneling, the contact resistance is approximated by: Eq. (13)
pc oc exp( ~t,/Eoo )
where E00 = (h/4zc).(No/m *es) 1/2. The contact resistance is lower when N o (doping concentration in semiconductor) is large and thus the depletion distance (W) is reduced. For TFE, transport results from both tunneling and thermionic emission and contact resistance is given by: Eq. (14)
pc oc exp(~b/Eoo)/eoth(Eoo/kT )
where the temperature dependence is contained in the coth(E00/kT) term. Because coth(z) approaches unity for large z, Eq. (14) has been used to predict that TFE junctions behave: Eq. (15a)
Eoo/kT>>l
~
eoth(E00/kT) ~ 1
Ohmic by tunneling
Eq. (15b)
Eoo/kT = 1
~
coth(E00/kT) _> 1
Non-linear
Eq. (15c)
Eoo/kT<
~
coth(E0o/kT) >>1
Non-ohmic
For z = 2.7, the error in setting coth(z) = 1 is less than 1%. Therefore, it is possible to predict the doping concentration required to form a tunneling contact by setting Eoo/kT > 2.7. Eq. (16)
E00= 18.5 x lO'12.(ND/mroer)l/2> 2.7"kTeV
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
89
where m r = m * / m , e~ = 6s/so and N D is the carrier concentration (cm-3). For n-type GaAs at 300K, m r --0.067, 6r -13, and Eq. (16) predicts ohmic behavior for N D > 1.2 x 1019 em-3.[s] The figure of merit for the formation of an ohmic contact is the specific contact resistance defined by Eq. (11). It is the contact resistance of an unit area for current flow perpendicular to the contact. Thus it has units of s z. Cox and Straek developed a bulk technique to measure contact resistance using different size circular dots defined on an epilayer.[ 341 This method is simple, but is only applicable to bulk structures (e.g., an epilayer on a conducting substrate), and its practical limit is ~ 10-5 ~-cm 2. The Transmission Line Method (TLM) is most frequently used to measure contact resistance in FET structures where current is confined in a highdoped conducting channel on a semi-insulating substrate.E3Sl Typically, the accuracy of TLM measurement is of the order of 10.6 ~-cm 2. For resistances of 10 -7 f~-cm 2, Kelvin Cross Bridge Resistor measurements are used, which require a relatively complicated geometry of the contact pads.j361 There are many other methods and variations to measure specific contact resistance.[371-[391 A particalar method should be selected depending on the type of application and required accuracy. In addition to the performance of ohmic contacts, the lifetime of ohmic contacts is often estimated by monitoring the variation of specific contact resistance over a period of time often versus temperature (to be discussed in Sec. 2.3 below). It should be noted that contact resistance measurements represent averaged electrical property of M/S contacts. This is because the dimensions of contact pads (dimension d in Fig. 3) typically range from-~ 10 (smallest) up to ~1000 gm, while the microstructure of the M/S contact is only homogeneous on the order of~l gm. In Fig. 3, current flow is not exactly perpendicular to the contact. The morphology of the contact is not ideal planar as depicted due to complicated metallurgical reactions, as discussed below.
1.2
Surface States and Fermi Level Pinning
In the development of Eq. (4), it is assumed that the M/S interface is free of structural defects and foreign atoms and is abrupt on the atomic scale (i.e., it is structurally ideal). In this case, the ideal barrier height (Oh) is determined by the work function of metal versus the electron affinity of the semiconductor. Experimentally measured barrier heights for many
90
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
semiconductors, especially GaAs, show a very weak dependence on the metal work function.J4~ 42]
Metallized contact pad M/S~contact ~
~ / , ' /~
~
Semi-insulaing substrate conduction channel Figure 3. A schematicof Transmission Line Method (TLM)for measurementof specific contact resistance.
This deviation from ideal Schottky behavior was first attributed to the existence of surface states (intrinsic or extrinsic) by Bardeen in 1947.[4~ When surface states are present within the bandgap of semiconductors, they are occupied by electrons prior to contact formation with metals. Occupation is controlled by the Fermi level which is constant throughout the crystal. Consequently, these surface states pin the Fermi level resulting in band bending as shown in Fig. 4. As a result, the barrier height (Oh) is not given by Eq. (4) but must be modified by the details of Ess, the energy levels of the surface states. In Fig. 4, the barrier height can be described as Ob = Eg- Ess.[4~ As shown, the barrier height is nearly independent of the metal work function due to the Fermi level pinning. Fermi level pinning may be described by introducing extra charge (Qi), trapped in the surface states between E v to Ess, as shown in Fig. 4. Now charge neutrality is determined by: Eq. (17)
Qm + Qi + Qs = 0
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
91
as contrasted to Qm + Qs = 0 in an ideal M/S interface. The potential variation (A), in Fig. 4 is due to Oi trapped at the surface states. The surface states may be a source of leakage current in M/S contacts and result in deviation from the ideal current-voltage characteristics predicted by Eq. (7), particularly in the low-voltage region.
Metal
n-Semi con ductor
Vacuum level A s
Om,T Erm _ __*_ _v_
Vacuum level ..
s Ec . . . . . Em
-I ss
~ I ' ,
Ev
Figure 4. Energy band diagram for a Schottky barrier formed by a metal and a semiconductor with surface states. Essis the surface state energy levels within the bandgap.
I n t r i n s i c State. Kurtin et al. proposed several intrinsic mechanisms as plausible causes of surface states, and suggested a correlation between a tendency to form surface states and the type of chemical bonding in the bulk. Based on measurements of the barrier heights of various metals on Si, GaSe, and SiO 2, versus electronegativities of the metals, it was suggested that the termination of periodic atomic arrangement at the surface of covalently bonded semiconductors is likely to give rise to surface states. [43] In Fig. 5, the S parameter (defined by S =/9~b//~, n where ~m is the electronegativity of the metal) is plotted as function of AZ, to show the general tendency of Fermi level pinning. As shown in Fig. 5, Si, Ge, GaAs, and InP belong to the group of semiconductors which exhibit Fermi level pinning (i.e., S - 0 . 1 ) . As a word of caution, Fig. 5 contains data which may
92
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
be influenced by several effects in addition to Fermi level pinning. [44] To illustrate this, it has been shown experimentally[45]-[ 47] and theoretically[ as] that intrinsic states in the bandgap for the (110) surface of GaAs may play a minor or no role in Fermi-level pinning. Nevertheless, the use ofionicity of semiconductor bonding is still predictive for pinning of the Fermi level as mentioned in the introduction.[ 22]
AIN 9
eZnS
1.0
aS
SrTiO3 KTo03
AI zO3 9 9 9 SnOz ZnO SiOz Go20~
.8
/TO .,...
Lm_ 0 -1X bJ r-~ uJ z (~ o.
-6
,.'F
Si/eZnSe
_
(/) n,-.4 LIJ I--
eGoTeI
_z
cdSe
.2
Ge
GoAs/
~Si InSb~ ] I'n/ P 1
I
A 1
1
1
1
1
!
1
1
I
AX: ELECTRONEGATIVITYDIFFERENCE BETWEEN CONSTITUENTS OF SEMICONDUCTORS Figure 5. Generaltrendof Fermi level pinning in various semiconductors(from Ref. 43).
Unified Defect Model. To explain Fermi-level pinning, a large body of experimental data was analyzed and the result called the Unified Defect Model. Spicer et al. discovered that clean, cleaved (110) surfaces of III-V compounds, except for GaP, did not exhibit intrinsic states, but the surfaces were strongly perturbed by metal coverages ofa monolayer or less, resulting in Fermi-level pinning. [42][49] Figure 6 shows the pinned Fermi level of GaAs, GaSh, and InP versus several metals, and they are essentially independent of
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
93
the metal. Spicer et al. proposed that pinning resulted from defects created by the interactions between the adatoms (metals and oxygen) and semiconductors. Unique to the UDM is that Fermi level pinning is a consequence of extrinsic effects, not intrinsic properties of the semiconductors.
FERMI LEVEL PINNING
evf l
/
/,/"
//
1 2~r-1 0.8~I
on ~p
/ / . / / /
ICB.M.
Go As (1101 .... o
~____a
........ o
o
0.4~-
Eg
o
i,-'A:S/:At
.... Go ",o " A:u. " 0 , /
vBM
i >LO
ev! / ,,I2: 0.6 ...... " 0.4
....
-
.-
."
_ "
,lCBM
LU Z ILl
0.2
o I," , - C s /
Go ....."
.Sb."Au,,0,y
.IVBM
,,.,"
,/
ev 1.2
In P (110 )
CBM
o A
O
0.8 0.4
--
A
Eg
l
VBM OVERLAYER PRODUCING PINNING ( S u b - M o n o l a y e r ) .
Figure 6. Fermi level pinningposition for n- or p-type (a) GaAs,(b) GaSb, or (c) lnP versus the overlayer adatom (from Ref. 49).
94
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Metal Induced Gap States. The Metal Induced Gap (MIG) model has been developed as an extension of the UDM.[5~ In the MIG model, surface states are postulated to be an intrinsic property of the semiconductor, and they exist over a continuum between the Valence Band Maximum (VBM) and the Fermi level. This is in direct contradiction to the discrete levels assumed in the UDM. The MIG states (surface states) are formed in the semiconductor at the initial interface, due to intimate contact with electrons from the metals. The tails of the metallic wave functions decay into the semiconductor and result in the interface states within the bandgap. Heine first pointed out that tails of the metal wavefunctions are derived from the Virtual Gap States (ViGS) of the complex band structure of the semiconduetor.[S~ In the MIG model, the character of the surface states changes across the bandgap from more acceptor-like, close to the Conduction Band Minimum (CBM), to more donor-like, close to the VBM. The energy at which the contributions from both bands are equal is called the branch point, and is located at mid-bandgap when the effective mass of electrons and holes are of equal value.[ 51] The Charge-Neutrality Level (CNL) is defined as the energy where the Fermi level coincides with the branch point. This determines the Schottky barrier heights. According to the MIG model combined with electronegativity concept, charge transfer occurs across the interface depending on the electronegativity difference between metals and semiconductors, and determines the final position of the Fermi level within the bandgap. For example, when the electronegativity of a metal is the same as the semiconductor, the final Fermi level pinning is located at the branch point of the semiconductor and there is no charge transfer. The final pinning position of the Fermi level should be above or below the branch point of the semiconductor when the metal exhibits a smaller or a larger eletronegativity than the semiconductor. With the Fermi level above or below the CNL, the net charge in the wavefunction tails of the metals has a negative and a positive sign, respectively, as a result of charge transfer between the metal and semiconductor. The Schottky barrier height of the M/S contact would be lowered with the Fermi level above the CNL, and increased with the Fermi level below the CNL, for n-type. The precise position of the Fermi level within the bandgap and corresponding barrier height depends on the occupation of the continuum of the MIG states, and the trend of occupation can be predicted from the electronegativites of metals and semiconductors:[ sll[s2] Eq. (18)
Ohmic Contacts to I I - V I and I I I - V Compounds
95
where tY~cnI is the CNL, Sx is a slope parameter defined as ~b/c m, and ~m and Zs are the eleetronegativities of metal and semiconductor, respectively. The slope parameter S x, (this is the same as S in Fig. 5) was related with the optical dielectric constant, Co, of the semiconductor, while (Y~cnl w a s theoretically predicted. Using Eq. (18), t~b -~ 0.7 eV above the VBM is predicted for Au/GaAs contact. In a recent refinement of the MIG model,[ 52] it was shown from experimental data[ 53] that the position of Fermi level pinning was a function of metal layer coverage. The Fermi level approached its final position as the surface was saturated from submonolayer coverage (isolated adatoms) to a continuous metallic film. The dependence of the Fermi level upon metal coverage (e.g., Fig. 7b), which can't be explained by the UDM, was explained in the MIG model by using the idea of metal-induced surface states at submonolayer coverage and by the continuum of metal-induced gap states at several monolayer coverage. At high coverage, only one Fermi level was determined, regardless of n- or p-type semiconductor. Chemical Reaction Models. Chemical reactivity between semiconductors and metals have been correlated to explain the deviation from the ideal Sehottky barrier; it was rationalized that chemical reactions would affect interfaeial electrical properties. The heat of phase formation was found to exhibit a linear relationship with the barrier heights (~b) between transition metals and Si.[ 54] Later, Freeouf proposed that ~b was determined by ~Siliciae (work function of silieides).[ 55J Even though this idea was developed to describe metal/Si contacts, it was later applied to various compound semiconductors and developed as the Effective Work Function (EWF) Model.E56] In the EWF model, ~b is given by: Eq. (19)
~b = ~eff-- Z instead of Ob =
(I)metal-
Z
where Z is the electron affinity of the semiconductor. r mainly due to the work function of the anion, ~Anion" The EWF model suggests that the Fermi level at the surface (or interface) is related to the work functions of microelusters of one or more interface phases resulting from either oxygen contamination (oxidation) or metal-semiconductor reactions with the metallization. Another chemical argument proposed is that chemical reactions at the interface on a microscopic scale modify the ideal Sehottky barrier via local charge transfer and creation of extrinsic interface states as a result of the interfaeial reaetion.[571[58] In this argument, discrete levels of defects, native or extrinsic, were used to account for the deviation from the ideal Sehottky behavior with chemical reactivity.
96
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Amphoteric Defect Model. Walukiewicz has attributed Fermi level pinning to amphoteric native defects in semiconductors.[59]-[ 61]This model relates the Fermi level pinning to the thermodynamic properties of the entire system of defects. A remarkable similarity was found between the semiconductor Fermi level (EFs) at the M/S interface and the Fermi level (EFI) in heavily irradiated III-V compound and column IV semiconductors (see Fig. 7). As shown in Fig. 7, the Fermi levels for n and p-type semiconductors merged into one level as the irradiating electron dose increased to greater than about 1017cm-2.[6~ Also note, there is a similarity between the convergence level in Fig. 7 and the pinned level shown in Fig. 6.
-/• 1.4-
>
I
C
t.u
%
1.0-
(a) _
9n - T y p e o p-Type ~ Semi-insul.
\eN
0.8~
_
" ~ - ' Z ~ . - - e._e_ ~ - e - & ,
0.6-
/
. . -
/
~_E 0 . 4 u_
I
GaAs
9 12 >, O}
1
1
N
0
0.2[ 1017
1 16
0
L 1018
1019
10 20
Electron Dose (cm -2) _A
>(1)
rw
1 29
0.8
~c-
~S
~9 0.4 LL
(b) -
,~
/.~
0 LAo V
~'-~-
..o- - z-o~-t== ~ , Ti/GaAs "'~
,,n-Type o p-Type , ,
1022
10 -1
1
10
102
Metal Coverage (~) Figure 7. Comparison of the Fermi level behavior (a) in electron irradiated GaAs and (b) for a submonolayer coverage of Ti (from Ref. 60).
Ohmic Contacts to 11-111and III-V Compounds
97
Table 1 lists the range of Fermi levei pinning positions deduced from the Schottky barrier heights for M/S contacts (Eps) and the Fermi level stabilization energy in heavily irradiated III-V compounds and column IV elemental semiconductors (EFt), plus the CNL predicted from the MIGS model (EcNL). Note that the Epi correlates better with the interface state pinning levels (E~s) than do the CNL values.
Table 1. Fermi Level Stabilization Energy in Irradiated Semiconductors (EFI) and at Metal-Semiconductor Interfaces (EFs)
Si InP GaAs
EEl (eV)
EFS (eV)
EClVL(eV)
0.4 1.0 0.5-0.7
0.3-0.4 0.8-1.1 0.5-0.7
0.36 0.76 0.5
Eclvl"represents Charge-NeutralityLevel from MIG model. All energies are with respect to the valence-band edges (from Ref. 60 and references therein).
According to this model, there is a Fermi-level stabilization energy (EFI) in covalent or weakly ionic semiconductors such as GaAs and InP, which is independent of the type of doping and the doping level. Therefore, this property is regarded as an intrinsic property of the semiconductors. As a consequence of this intrinsic property, native defects such as vacancies or substitutional dopants exhibit an amphoteric character depending on their energy level relative to the Fermi-level stabilization energy. For example, a Ga vacancy is a stable aceeptor in n-type GaAs, but it transforms to a donor complex (Asca + VAs) in p-type materials. This behavior results from a large electronic contribution to the total defect formation energy. Specifically, the formation energy of a Ga vacancy is lowered from --4eV to --0.2eV as the Fermi level varies from the VBM to the CBM under As-rich condition.[ 62] The defect formation energy varies until the Fermi level reaches the stabilized position (EF/), after which continued introduction of electrically active species does not affect the stabilized Fermi level. In the case of GaAs, the stabilized Fermi-level is located between E v +0.5 eV to E v +0.7 as can be seen in Table 1. In the amphoteric native defects model,
98
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
the behavior of native defects is responsible for the Fermi level pinning, which appears to be similar to the UDM model. However, the behavior of defects is controlled by the stabilized Fermi level EFI, which is an intrinsic property of semiconductors similar to the MIGS model. Summary. For many years, all the models mentioned above were examined and compared. Nonetheless, the main idea of whether intrinsic or extrinsic effects play a primary role in Fermi level pinning still remains controversial.j63]-[ 66] It is now generally accepted that a single theory cannot explain Fermi level pinning. In the case of GaAs, it is readily and clearly seen that there is a range of-~0.3 eV in Fermi-level pinning (0.5-0.8 eV above the VBM) by reviewing the extensive experimental data collected to date. This variation implies that several mechanisms are simultaneously playing roles and even interacting with each other in the determination of SBH.
2.0
O H M I C C O N T A C T S T O GaAs
GaAs is the most widely used III-V semiconductor and as a result, ohmic contacts to it have been extensively studied. A few techniques have been developed to prepare an ohmic contact with no or little heat treatment after growth ofGaAs epitaxial layers. However, these in situ approaches to ohmic contact formation have not proven to be very practical. Therefore, the majority of this review will focus on contact schemes using deposition of metallization after the growth process has been completed and the sample removed from the MBE or MOCVD systems and stored in laboratory ambient for significant lengths of time. These techniques invariably required heating after deposition of the metallization, and they are called ex situ contact schemes.
2.1
In Situ Contact Scheme
In situ ohmic contact schemes do not utilize heat treatment to produce complicated alloying or metallurgical reactions for incorporation of doping elements into the surface of the GaAs substrate. Instead, very heavy doping is accomplished in situ during the growth of GaAs, or heterojunctions are formed to lower the barrier height between the contact metals and GaAs. In principle, heterojunctions may be either gradual or abrupt junctions, and both have been used for GaAs contacts. A gradual
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
99
junction is one in which two bulk crystals are joined by a continuously varying composition (e.g., GaxInl_xAs/GaAs where x can vary from 0 to 1). An abrupt junction is a sharply defined interface between two homogeneous semiconductors (e.g., Ge/GaAs). For either doping or heterojunction formation, in situ contacts are nonalloyed because they are formed without post-deposition heat treatment. Nonalloyed contacts were developed to reduce some drawbacks of conventional metallization schemes, such as poor morphology, poor reproducibility, deep interdiffusion (deep junction), and poor thermal stability. They succeeded in minimizing some of these effects, but the penalty in product throughput was too great to be practical. Molecular beam epitaxy is frequently used to grow heavily doped n+-GaAs where n + can be as high as the mid-1019 cm -3 (i.e., above the critical carrier concentration calculated from Eq. 16 as being required to ensure TFE or FE transport across the M/S interface). The carrier concentrations produced by MBE are often as much as an order of magnitude above the values achieved in bulk crystal growth. MBE can produce such high carrier concentration because it is a non-equilibrium growth technique. Dopant incorporation may be controlled by surface kinetics rather than thermodynamic equilibrium conditions. Tin dopant has been studied because it is known to be less amphoteric as compared to Si or Ge. A free electron concentration as high as 6 • 1019 em -3 was achieved with Sn, resulting in specific contact resistance as low as 2 x 10 -6 ~_cm 2 simply by depositing metals without heat treatment.[ 67] Even though it tends to be amphoteric, Kirchner et al. reported--1 x 102~cm -3 Si doping which yielded contact resistances of ~1.3 x 10-6 ~_cm 2 with in situ metallization.[ 6s] As reported above, in situ formation of heterojunctions have been studied to form ohmic contacts. For example, Fig. 8 (a) and (b) show the band alignment between metal/GaAs and metal/n+-Ge/n+-GaAs, respectively. Because of Fermi level pinning, the Cb for metal/GaAs is 0.7-0.8 eV above the VBM as discussed already. The localized potential barriers of --0.45 eV at the metal/Ge interface and 0.06 eV at the Ge/GaAs heterojunction are much more favorable for ohmic behavior at room temperature .[691[7~ The dominant resistance will occur at the metal/Ge contact, but the Ge layer can easily be doped up to--102o cm -3, resulting in specific contact resistances of--10-6-10 -7 ~-cm 2 with smooth interfacial morphology.[69][ 71] The Ge/GaAs heterojunction is lattice matched (within 0.5%), and has compatible crystal structure. The thermal expansion coefficient of Ge (6.6 x 106/~ matches well with that of GaAs (6.0 x 10-6/~
100
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Metal
(a)
n+-GaAs
% Ec Ef
Ev
J Ec . . . .
Ef
(b)
I
Metal
!
,n§
,
n§
n-GaAs
Figure 8. Energy band diagram for metal contacts to GaAs showing the band alignment and bending for (a) a degenerately doped n-GaAs, and (b) the same GaAs with epitaxed Ge at the interface with a metal (from Ref. 7 l).
Another heterojunction scheme is to terminate the GaAs surface with Gal_xInxAS, in which the Fermi level is pinned in or near the conduction band as shown in Fig. 9.[72] Because there is a conduction band discontinuity between InAs and GaAs as shown in Fig. 9(e), a non-abrupt heterojunetion is necessary as shown in Fig. 9(d). In this contact scheme, tunneling is not required and low resistance contacts can be made for a wide range of doping without the need of alloying to form n + surface layers. InAs and Gal_xInxAs layers grown in situ by MBE produced contact resistances o f - 1 0 "7 f2-em2.[17][731However, this contact scheme is not generally practical because of MBE production throughput and
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
101
inability to complete processing the device structure requires "dry" techniques in the MBE UHV environment.
Ec o)~////////////~
'
~,~M ! ETAL2//"
~
'
EF
n- GoAs
Ec b) ~
..
~..-~---~
. . .
EF
Ev ~,,~.__
n-InAs I.
c)-: MET.,;..,
.
.
.
.
.
'
. ,.~/,:.
Ec EF
s
ABRUPT NTERFAC :
:...,;;.::~;, I/,'.,
",9 , , . / / 3 " / . ,
NON ABRUPT INTERFACE
r
\
I
'
...........
.............; - ~ ~ ~ , - ~ Go i_x Inx As
Figure 9. Band diagram showing band b~nding and alignment for a metal conlact to (a) nGaAs, (b) n-InAs, (c) n-GaAs with a thin epitaxially abrupt layer ofn-InAs, and (d) n+-InAs layer on a graded n+-InxGal.xAS layer on n-GaAs (from Ref. 72).
102
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Fischer et al. [741175] have reported that sulfur passivation of the GaAs surface can at least partially remove surface pinning and result in ohmic contact formation. In their studies, solutions of P2Ss/Sx/NH4S were used to remove the native oxide on the GaAs surface and replace it with S bonding to the Ga and perhaps As. Samples of Si doped GaAs were then placed in a vacuum, S desorbed by heating to about 500~ and films of Au deposited in situ. Upon removal from the vacuum and without heat treatment, the contacts showed a linear I-V dependence demonstrating formation of an ohmic contact. Surface passivation with S, plus the H20/light treatment of GaAs surfaces reported by Woodall et al., [76]are the only known methods to at least partially unpin the GaAs surface for contact formation.
2.2
Ex Situ Contact Schemes Ex situ contact schemes are those using single or multilayer metal
thin films deposited in a separate chamber from that used in epilayer growth. Thermal annealing is generally required to form the ohmic contact. Single layer metallizations will be reviewed first, followed by a review of bilayer and multilayer metallizations. Single Metal/GaAs Contacts. While single metals on GaAs do not yield technologically feasible ohmic contacts, a review is worthwhile to learn about their interfacial reactions. Special attention has been given to several frequently used metals such as (Au, Ni, Pd, or Ge)/GaAs. It will become obvious that interfacial reactions between metals and GaAs play a critical role in the ex situ formation of ohmic contacts. It will also become obvious that equilibrium thermodynamics can be used to predict GaAs interfacial reactions, although non-equilibrium intermediate phases may also be encountered which may affect the contact properties. A u / G a A s Metallization. Au is frequently used as a contact metal for GaAs and other semiconductors because of its ease of deposition and etching, high conductivity which results in lower resistance interconnects, high ductility for bonding, and lack of oxide formation which results in good bonding and high reliability. Au begins to react with As depleted or near stoichiometric GaAs at ~250~ with rapid reaction at ---400~ resulting in large changes from the as deposited Schottky barrier heights.[771 Typically, Au/GaAs diodes exhibit a barrier height of--0.9 eV as deposited and low barrier Schottky or ohmic behavior after heat treatment.[ 781-[8~ The interfacial reaction between Au and GaAs upon annealing begins with the formation of a Au-Ga-As solid solution with very low As concentrations.[ 811
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
103
The solubility of As in Au-Ga-As is so low that the reaction between Au and GaAs is commonly written: Eq. (20)
Au + GaAs ~ Au-Ga + As x (gas)
which represents the formation ofAu-rieh Au-Ga solid solutions with As x sublimation in the case of an open system (i.e., with a possible loss of Asx). In the ease of a closed system (i.e., no loss of As x possible), As forms precipitates because of the very low solubility of As in Au. [81]-[83]A sharp evaporation peak for As x has been observed by mass spectroscopy, suggesting rapid onset of a metallurgical reaction such as Au-Ga formation. Surface morphological changes have sometimes been interpreted to indicate formation of a liquid phase of Au-Ga alloys at the temperature ranges.[78][821184][85] However, in other cases, these morphology changes have been attributed to solid state transport without formation of a liquid phase.[ 81] While the bulk equilibrium phase diagram shows that a number of intermetallic phases are possible (Au7Ga 2, Au3Ga, Au2Ga, AuGa, or AuGa2), they have only been observed after cooling.j85] -[89] In contrast to the surface capillarity driven surface morphology mentioned above, solid state reactions between Au and GaAs often result in formation of elongated pyramidal pits (see Fig. 10a) bounded by {111 } planes and aligned in the [ 110] directions of GaAs after annealing above -3 50~ [90]-[92] Figure 10b is the corresponding schematic of Fig. 10a, and Fig. 10c is a bright field image of a {110} fractured cross section though a single pyramidal pit. Solid solutions of Au-Ga were found in the pyramidal pits. These solutions were sometimes separated from the GaAs substrate by an intermediate layer of Au-Ga compounds which probably formed upon cooling (i.e., they represent a divorced eutectic decomposition). The reactions pits form through solid-state dissolution of GaAs up to 450~ although a liquid reaction apparently increases their size and governs overall morphology above the melting temperature (--500~ of the Aurich solid solutions. The crystallographic orientation between the reaction products and the parent Au and GaAs has been attributed to the degree of misfit at the interface.j88][ 91] Others have suggested that the crystallographic dependence of GaAs dissociation kinetics may also influence their geometry.[ 92] In any case, formation of the pits on a GaAs surface during interaction with Au represents a very inhomogeneous reaction. The inhomogeneity of the interfacial reaction has also been attributed to the presence of native oxide which limits the ability of Au to react with the substrate.
104
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
(a)
{111)As
[011"-] [o11 (b)
BaAs (100~
{ 111}Ga
(c)
Figure 10. Reaction "pits" from Au on GaAs after the Au has been chemically stripped. (a) Scanning electron micrograph of a pit. (b) Schematic representation of the crystallographic orientation of the pits. (c) Scanning electron micrograph of a fracture cross section through a pit (from Ref. 92).
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
105
Upon reaction of Au with GaAs, the electrical characteristics of the interface have been observed to switch from Schottky to ohmic.[ 8~ To determine if this resulted from interfacial compound formation, Leung et al. [791and Lince et al.[941deposited Au-Ga phases (e.g., AuGa2) on GaAs. In general, these compounds did not result in ohmic contact formation because the surface of the GaAs remained pinned. In addition, the lack of or the limited interfacial reactions that were produced did not significantly modify the interfacial doping concentration, and Schottky contact behavior was maintained, although the quality of the Schottky contact (and barrier height) often was degraded. The chemical reactions between Au/GaAs were studied in detail by Mueller et al. to understand their effects upon the electrical properties of the Au/GaAs system.[8~ 811 It was shown that the Au/GaAs interfacial reactions were dependent upon the conditions of the initial interface. Surprisingly, an interface with a native oxide exhibited the most pronounced formation of reaction pits, consistent with the calculations of Mueller and Holloway showing that the phase stability of Au/GaAs is critically dependent upon the surface stoichiometry. Li and Holloway[771 showed that the Au/GaAs reactions could be modified extensively by supplying a flux of As to the surface during heat treatment. Liu and Holloway[ 921showed that the interfacial reactions pits underwent Ostwald ripening with time at temperature (i.e., some pits disappear while others grow during isothermal annealing). Appearance of the reactions pits results from dissolution of GaAs. Therefore, their disappearance indicates regrowth of GaAs, apparently from Ga and As in Au-Ga-As solid solutions. The reaction of Au with GaAs correlated with the electrical properties switch from rectifying to ohmic. The explanation for forming ohmic contacts was uncertain since the Fermi level was believed to remain pinned, and no dopant was added to the pure Au layer which could be incorporated during regrowth. The only possible dopant to be concentrated was the Si originally in the bulk GaAs. Segregation in the reactions pits of this Si dopant was detected by SIMS (see Fig. 11). Figure 11 is a SIMS image of m/e = 28 from a Si-doped GaAs after reaction with Au film at 450~ for 15 rain followed by chemical stripping of the Au film. Thus, the ohmic contact resulted from Si segregation in the pits causing a local n+region and TFE transport for ohmic behavior. Regrowth of the GaAs occurred as a result of the interfacial reaction, but did not play a role in the ohmic behavior. Ni/GoAs Metallization. Ni reacts uniformly with GaAs except where the native oxide-hydrocarbon interfacial contamination layer affects
106
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
diffusion and compound formation.[95][96] Solid-state reactions between Ni and GaAs produced a hexagonal ternary phase after annealing at 100400~ for times of 5 min to 5 hours: Eq. (21)
xNi + GaAs = NixGaAs
g.
t Figure 11. SIMS imagefromm/e = 28 (i.e., Si§ showing segregation of Si in the reaction pits producedby Au on n-GaAs(fromRef. 93).
Diffraction analysis with TEM and XRD showed that NixGaAs could exhibit twinning and several epitaxial orientations with respect to the GaAs substrate. [97]-[106]The composition x was reported to vary between 2 and 4 without a change in crystal structure. Quantification of AES data yielded Ni2GaAs [96][97][99]while EDS and/or TEM measurement suggested NiaGaAs.[l~176176 1~ High spatial resolution EDS studies yielded NiE.4GaAs, as shown in Fig. 12.[1~ It is noted that compositions ranging from 2 to 4 were observed with the same NiAs-type hexagonal structure with varying Co/ao ratios.[a8][ 109] Studies of bulk material showed that the Ni-Ga-As ternary phase diagram exhibited five ternary phases with broad homogeneity ranges extending toward the binary phases.[ 1~ They all exhibited the hexagonal NiAs symmetry and were unstable in contact with GaAs.
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
107
Figure 12. TEM micrograph of as-deposited GaAs/Ni2.4GaAs/Ge. Bright-field image of cross sectional view to show sharp interface between GaAs/NiE.4GaAs (from Ref. 108). While NixGaAs has often been observed in thin film reaction, it may not be an equilibrium phase. It was reported that NiaGaAs adopts a B8 structure with lattice parameters intermediate between those ofNi3.55Ga2.0 and NiAs B8 structures.[ 95][100]-[104] The hexagonal unit cell of NixGaAs has lattice parameters of ao~4A, co-~5A, similar to the Ni-As and Ni-Ga systems (NiAs:ao = 3.619/1,, %= 5.034A and Ni3Ga2:ao = 4.0A, %= 4.983A).E100]--[105] It has been speculated that NixGaAs is observed even though it may be metastable because of the epitaxial relationship with GaAs which would lower its nucleation barrier below that ofNiAs x and NiGay. [99]In addition, Ni is the mobile species at temperatures below-~300~ where Ga and As are relatively immobile, allowing formation of Ni~GaAs while avoiding separation of Ga and As.[1~176 1111Figure 12 shows an interfaeial morphology of a NiE.4GaAs/GaAs contact, which is rectifying with a barrier height of 0.9 eV.[ 1~ It should be noted that the interface is uniform in contrast to Au/GaAs as shown in Fig. 10e. While the NixGaAs phase is commonly observed in thin film systems at low temperatures, Ogawa showed that NiEGaAs decomposed into binary NiGa and NiAs upon annealing at 500~ for 5 min.[ 971Decomposition proceeded through NiAs precipitation in a matrix of Ni2GaAs at temperatures higher than 350~ After annealing at 500~ for 5 min, NiAs or As-rich phases were found near the GaAs and [3-NiGa near the surface. [97] However, Laval et al. and Guivareh et al. reported that Ni2GaAs epitaxed to (111) GaAs was more stable than on (100) and was still observed after annealing up to 600~ [99][106]On bulk GaAs at 600~ after 1 hour, NixGaAs decomposed into NiGa and NiAs.[ 1~ After the 600~
108
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
anneal, [3-NiGa epitaxed to the GaAs substrate. Randomly oriented NiAs grains, about 0.7 mm in diameter, were observed.[ 99][1~ Sand et al. reported epitaxy for both NiAs and NiGa after annealing at 600~ for 1 hour.[ 11~ While the exact phases at the interface varied in all cases, Ni greatly improved the tmiformity of the reactions, presumably at least in part, because it forms both Ni-Ga and Ni-As compounds. With respect to electrical properties, Ni alone did not result in formation of ohmic contacts. The Schottky barrier height increased slightly (0.76 eV to 0.83 eV) upon formation of Ni2GaAs, then decreased upon decomposition into the binary phases.[ 99] Pd,/GaAs Metallization. Similar to Ni, Pd reacts with GaAs and rapidly and more uniformly penetrates the interracial native oxide, resulting in higher reactivity with GaAs. TEM micrograph images showed the formation of a PdxGaAs phase below the native oxide, where x is typically 2. [21][104][112]-[114] The exact stoichiometry of this reaction product varied, as did its crystallographic orientation with GaAs.[ 1121-[115]Below 300~ annealing partially decomposed the PdxGaAs into Pd-Ga and Pd-As binary phases, which caused the metal/GaAs interfacial morphology to become nonuniform.[ 116] Vacuum annealing above 450~ caused the loss of the Pd-As phases, presumably due to arsenic evaporation. Lin et al. reported that bulk diffusion couples of Pd (~0.6 mm thick)/GaAs showed three stable ternary phases at 600~ 116]They were characterized by broad homogeneity ranges, similar to Ni/GaAs. The thermodynamically stable phases with GaAs at 600~ were PdGa and PdAs 2. However, loss of As in an open system was expected to result in a PdGa/GaAs structure. Ge/GaAs Metallization. To demonstrate that regrowth of GaAs in the presence of Ge could lead to ohmic contacts, Li and Holloway[77][ 117] deposited layers of Ga, As, and Ge on GaAs and annealed the samples up to 500~ This resulted in the formation ofepitaxial GaAs doped with Ge and the formation of ohmic contacts, clearly demonstrating the feasibility of the solid phase epitaxial method of forming ohmic contacts to GaAs. In addition, they demonstrated that a flux of As onto the surface could stabilize GaAs against dissolution by Au, and could be used to regrow GaAs with dopant from a surface covered by Ge and Ga films. Refractory Metals/Go.As MetaUizations. High melting temperature metal elements such as Pt, Ti, and W are frequently used and studied for thermally stable contacts because the processing temperature can be as high as 800~ to anneal out damage by ion implantation.[ 1181Pt/GaAs produces Pt-Ga, Pt-As binaries upon annealing 400-500~ Similarly, a
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
109
Ti/GaAs reaction produces Ti-As and Ti-Ga above 400~ [1191The melting temperatures of those reaction products are typically above 1000~ 12~ Electrically, these reaction products exhibit rectifying contacts. As a result, refractory metals (elements or compound) are more commonly used as constituents in multielement contact metallizations.[~2 ~1 More details will be presented below (in See. 2.3) in a review of the thermal stability and reliability of ohmic contacts. Multi-element/GaAs Contacts. Practical ohmic contact metallizations contain more than two elements. However, the prior knowledge obtained in single element/GaAs rnetallizations is useful in understanding complicated reactions between multielements and GaAs. Au/Ge/GaAs Metallization. The reactions and electrical properties of Au/Ge/GaAs contacts are quite different from the Au/GaAs system described above. An eutectic forms at 88-12 wt% Au-Ge with a melting temperature of 363~ However, even small concentrations of Ge (-~0.6 wt.%) drastically changed the morphology of Au-Ga intermetallic phases (e.g., Au7Ga2, Au3Ga ) and they form at progressively lower temperatures with increasing Ge concentration.[ ~22]In addition, a Au-Ge-As phase was observed to cover the contact after annealing at ~400~ with decreasing coverage at higher temperatures. Epitaxial regrowth of GaAs was reported after cooling to room temperature from higher temperatures. Longer time anneals caused the Au-Ge-As phase to disappear, perhaps from local melting, followed by solidification upon cooling.[ sS] For annealing above -~400~ a molten Au-Ge eutectic phase was detected followed by formation of Au-Ga compounds. These reactions resulted in an ohmic contact with a specific contact resistance of~l 0-5 ~-cm 2. Formation of ohmic contacts was attributed to incorporation of Ge during solidification of GaAs, leading to the formation of a heavily doped n + GaAs layer.liE3][TM]This is consistent with the observation ofepitaxially regrown GaAs after cooling to room temperature. The liquid phase could accelerate formation ofn + epitaxial GaAs, and Ge was responsible for both the low eutectic temperature as well as acting as the n-type dopant. While in-diffusion of Ge into GaAs was suggested, the n + layer was probably formed during cooling. Reduction in the barrier height from 0.77 eV to ~0.4 eV was also reported after annealing below the Au-Ge eutectic temperature, but this again probably resulted from surface doping by Ge. [1231[125] There were no reports of epitaxially regrown Ge films at the interface, therefore the reduced barriers did not result from formation of Ge at the interface (depicted in Fig. 8). Instead, regrowth of GaAs at the interface, doped with Ge, was responsible for the reduced barrier heights
110
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
and ohmic properties. The reaction morphology was similar to Au/GaAs as shown in Fig. 10, even to the formation of pyramidal reaction pits, and even to lack of a uniform morphology. Ni/Ge, Pd/Ge, and Pd/Si/GaAs Metallizations. As shown by the above reviewed data, Au has only limited power to dissociate the lattice. Nickel and Pd are much more efficient at dissociating GaAs and bonding to both the Ga and the As to hold them in the thin film. As also pointed out, contacts containing Au show marginal thermal stability, irregular morphology, and degradation of contact resistance with time. The properties of Au-free metallizations were studied to determine if removal of Au would eliminate the problems. Bielement metallizations such as Pd/Si,[ 126] Pd/Ge, [127] and Ni/Ge[ TMwere tested. Without Ni or Pd, very little Ge was incorporated into GaAs after sintering at 450~ for 30 min.[128]-[13~ With a Ni overlayer on Ge to cause dissociation of GaAs, greatly enhanced incorporation of Ge resulted in ohmic contacts.[ 1281The Ge profile after annealing always followed the Ni distribution, suggesting a correlation between these elements during regrowth of GaAs.[ 13~ Marshall et al. showed that Ge/Pd/GaAs structures resulted in Pd dissociating the GaAs to form a ternary Pd2GaAs phase. This was followed by the formation ofa PdGe x intermetallic compound causing the release of Ga and As and regrowth of GaAs.[ 21][131][132]When regrowth occurs in the presence of a dopant (e.g., Ge), the dopant will be incorporated into the regrown layer and may result in ohmic contact formation. The concept of the regrowth mechanism was applied to explain ohmic behavior for Ni/Ge/GaAs metallizations.[ 21] In this model, Ni was postulated to react with GaAs to form NixGaAs, then decomposition of the ternary phase was driven by the lower free energy of formation of NiGe to result in: Eq. (22)
NixGaAs + xGe ~ xNiGe + GaAs(Ge)
where Ge incorporation is believed to result in n+-GaAs. Typically, the Ni and Pd germanides are formed by annealing above 400~ and they have a very smooth surface morphology and good thermal stability (up to 500~ due to their high melting temperature.[ 127]A minimum thickness ratio of Ni to Ge (29-3 8 at.%) was necessary to form ohmic contacts. Regrown GaAs was distinguishable from the single crystal wafer by a high density of stacking faults, microtwins, and precipitates.J21][ l~ The regrown GaAs was postulated to contain a high concentration of dopant (e.g., Ge with a concentration of ~ 1019 cm3). However, limited experimental data was presented to support the incorporation of Ge to form n+-GaAs.
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
111
When the Pd/Ge layering sequence was reversed and samples of Pd/ Ge/GaAs were reacted below 400~ only a rectifying contact was observed. AES depth profiles showed that Pd-Ga and Pd-As phases were formed while Ge segregated near the surface to form PdGe and Pd2Ge.[ 129] The interfaeial barrier height was increased from -~0.7 eV to --0.8 eV by these phases. Reactions at 400-500~ were necessary to form ohmic contacts, and the Ge SIMS profile into GaAs correlated with the reacted layer.[ 13~ To explain these results, it was commonly postulated that Pd created Ga vacancies, which accelerated the diffusion of Ge into the nearinterface region to form n+-GaAs. The premise that diffusion of Ge caused formation of an n + layer was not directly supported by experimental data. Instead, incorporation of Ge during regrowth of GaAs was postulated by Marshall et al., without the need for solid state diffusion. As illustrated in Fig. 8, epitaxial Ge will potentially form nonalloyed contacts to n-GaAs. This was studied using Ge/Pd/GaAs metallization.[131 ][1321Upon annealing, Pd and Ge reacted to form PdGe while excess Ge was transported through the Pd layer to grow epitaxially on the GaAs substrate. To clarify the mechanism for ohmic transport, SIMS analysis was performed by removal of the vast majority of the GaAs substrate through etching of a parting A1GaAs layer. The concentration of Ge incorporated into the GaAs near-surface region was measured. [134] Concentrations ofGe of-~l x 1019cm-3 were correlated with the onset of ohmic behavior. Thus, epitaxial Ge was not the origin of the ohmic contacts; instead creation of an n § layer in regrown GaAs was concluded to have resulted in ohmic contact behavior. The characteristics of Si/Pd/GaAs were investigated and compared to those of Ge/Pd/GaAs. Again it was shown that an epitaxial Ge layer with a resultant low barrier heterojunction was not responsible for ohmic behavior.[ 126] Instead, a regrowth mechanism was suggested with excess Si reacting with PdaGaAs to produce the following: Eq. (23)
2Si + Pd4GaAs(Si ) ~ 2Pd2Si + GaAs(Si)
The critical product from this reaction is regrown GaAs doped with Si. This same mechanism was also tested in Ni/Si/GaAs which clearly showed that regrowth took place.[1351 Binary metallization of Au/Ni/GaAs is not discussed since this only results in formation of Schottky contacts. Without the presence of Ge, low resistance ohmic contacts cannot be formed.
112
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
AuGeNi/GaAs-Diffusion Doping Model. AuGeNi contacts are the most heavily studied system for GaAs, partly because it is the oldest contact system. It was first introduced in 1967 by Braslau et al. to form ohmic contacts to GaAs-based microwave devices.[ 1~ The postulated mechanism of ohmic contact formation has undergone considerable evolution. The initial postulate was that a Au-Ge liquid eutectic formed and dissolved some GaAs which caused Ge to "diffuse" into the near surface region. Diffusion was possible because dissolution of Ga in Au would create a counter flux of Ga vacancies, which increased the transport of Ge by orders of magnitude.[ 1361The Ge created an n + layer and an ohmic contact. The role of Ni in this process was simply to prevent the AuGe melt from "bailing up" due to surface tension. Therefore, the three elements were evaporated to form a bilayer/substrate structure of Ni/AuGe/GaAs. Several investigators showed that with sufficiently high temperatures and long times, the sequence of the layers did not affect the final metallurgical or electrical properties.[ 137][138]A modified postulate was that Ni improved the surface morphology by improving the wetting of liquid Au-Ge to GaAs. It was observed that Ni and Ge accumulated at the interface with GaAs near the AuGe eutectic temperature, while Ga accumulated near the surface. [139]The evolution of the contact modeled continued when it was realized that the Au-Ge eutectic was not necessary and did not play a major role since Ge was gettered by Ni via a solid-state reaction.J14~ TM]The model evolved by recognition that Ni was correlated with the dissociation of GaAs, and the following reaction was suggested:[ 142] Eq. (24)
Au + Ni + GaAs --~ Au-Ga + Ni-As
Formation of nickel arsenides occurred at the GaAs interface and improved the surface morphology as illustrated in Fig. 13. [143]As shown in Fig. 13, without the first Ni layer on GaAs, Au/GaAs interfacial reaction dominated the interfacial morphology, which was not uniform as discussed above. However the reaction in Eq. 24 did not necessarily lead to formation of ohmic contacts; the barrier height, ~t~ increased from--,0.7 eV to ~0.9 eV as Ni accumulated at short times at the interface.j99][ 139]At longer annealing times, when ohmic behavior was observed, the surface morphology and contact resistance were both directly affected by the Ni to Ge ratio. Higher Ni concentrations led to better surface uniformity, while higher Ge concentrations led to lower contact resistance.[ 1441-[1471 The effect of Gewas still the creation of an n § surface layer by diffusion along a Ga vacancy flux.
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
BE FORE ALLOYING
DURING HEATING ( BELOW 420*C)
i AutG,)'
Au
Ni
AF TER ALLOYING AT 440*C FOR 2~n
,
t
k'//
I
Au-Ge
SAMPLE A
GoAt
GoAt
"
~ A.(G',)
Au
N,
IJ-A. o , / / ' / A
Au (Ge,Go) ,,,m..
,,,.,Ira,.
(WITHOUT Ni FIRST LAYER)
113
4
Ni~Ge
i
Au- Ge
SAMPLE B
4' I AulGt,Go',
=Ni
/- ~" r .
(WITH 5nm Ni F I RST LAYER)
a,,,mm,
NixGoA$ NiAslGe) GoAs
GoAt
GoAs
Figure 13. Schematicillustration of the evolution of phases produced by the reaction of Au/ Ni/Ge layers on GaAs. Note that the first Ni layer on GaAs generally results in planar interface morphology. Generally,for a five elements system,the interface between reacted layers will not be planar (from Ref. 143).
An improved description of the evolution of the contact was suggested by the observation that Ni was always found to diffuse toward the interface and to react with GaAs. The Ge followed the Ni distribution. The Au was normally combined in Au-Ga compounds upon cooling. [85][138][139][141][142][148]-[150] Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) studies showed that annealing above 400~ for a few minutes followed by cooling to room temperature produced NiGe containing small concentrations of Ga and As, NiAs with Ge and Ga, and AuGa.[143][l 5~ The NiAs phase was in direct contact with GaAs resulting in a smooth interracial morphology (Fig. 13). A good ohmic contact with low contact resistance was attributed to a Ni2GeAs phase being in contact with n+-GaAs which resulted from diffusion of Ge from NiGe.[ 15~ In addition, the reaction was assumed to unpin E F, and the NiAs phases were suggested to be low barrier ohmic tunneling contacts where the contact resistance was a function of the NiAs(Ge) coverage at the interface. [23][143] At higher annealing temperatures, more NiAs phase with a highly oriented epitaxial
114
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
relation was found at the interface.[ 85] The epitaxy was suggested to result from a close lattice matching between NiAs and GaAs. But even with NiAs at the interface, Ge diffusion to form n§ was necessary to explain ohmic behavior. Even though the Ga vacancy diffusion model for ohmic contacts was widely accepted, the activation energy for formation of contacts did not agree with the expected value for bulk diffusion. Therefore, Gupta and Kokle postulated that grain-boundary diffusion in the Au film was responsible for generation of Ga vacancies.[ 136] A Ga vacancy mechanism was also postulated to explain ohmic contact formation with Pd.[ 13~ Gupta and Kokle justified their grain boundary diffusion model based on the fact that contact resistance was high after either low or high temperature annealing, but low for intermediate temperatures.[ 136]This observation is generally true for any metallization leading to ohmic contacts on GaAs. Thus the "diffusion doping model" evolved to one in which it was presupposed that Ni dissociated the GaAs lattice and bonded to the As holding it at the interface. The Ga from this dissociation reacted with Au and formed Au-Ga solid solutions. Formation of AuGa x intermetallic phases was also believed to occur, especially during cooling after annealing. The formation of an n § surface region due to Ge diffusing along a counter flux of Ga vacancies was widely accepted as the mechanism of doping. Backside SIMS measurements in an alloyed AuGeNi system were used to demonstrate Ge doping of the near surface region,[ 152][153]but the profiles could not be analyzed in terms of a diffusion profile. In addition, the contact resistance correlated poorly with the detected Ge concentrations. Cross-sectional TEM showed that NiAs was in contact with the substrate. Based on these results, Bruce et al. suggested that n§ level was less important to contact resistance than the formation of the NiAs phase.[ 152]Further refinement of the model was clearly necessary. AuGeNi/GaAs-Solid Phase Regrowth Model. Because E F is pinned in GaAs (near mid bandgap at the surface), n § doping is critical to formation of an ohmic contact. The studies of interfacial reactions have been focused on the mechanism by which Ge occupies the Ga site to form n § GaAs. As pointed out above, while Au-Ga and Pd-Ga reactions have long been postulated to create Ga vacancies in GaAs, the data do not support this mechanism for Ge incorporation and doping. Therefore, the model of ohmic contacts formation in GaAs has evolved to the one of solid-phase regrowth, as discussed for Ni/Ge and Pd/ Ge metallization. Figure 14 is a simplified schematic to illustrate the evolution of phases in this model of ohmic contact formation with Au/Ge/
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
115
Ni metallization. Between 100 and 300~ Ni reacts with GaAs to produce interfacial NixGaAs with low concentrations of Ge. Above this temperature range, the reaction normally results in "binary" phases consisting of NiGa x and NiAsy, both of which contain small concentrations of Ge. Simultaneous with Ni reacting with GaAs, Ni reacts with Ge to form NiGe, and Ge diffuses into Au. At longer times (Fig. 14b), the NixGaAs or NiGa and NiAs phases will be decomposed by formation of NiGe, whose free energy of formation is lower than that of either the ternary or the binary phases. The Ga and As released by this decomposition will lead to solid phase epitaxial regrowth of GaAs. Incorporation of Ge will cause the electrical properties to switch from rectifying to ohmic.
Ohmic contacts Au Ge Ni
GaAs
Au-Ge {de
Au-Ga
Ni-Ge
Ni-Ge
Ni-Ga-As-Ge
GaAs
(a) Interfacial reaction
GaAs
(b) Regrowth
Regrown GaAs (Ge) n+-GaAs
Figure 14. Idealized schematic of the evolution of phases during formation of an ohmic contact to n-GaAs using Au/Ge/Ni metallization. Even though planar interfaces are shown, non-planar reaction fronts are expected in five component systems.
Several key issues about the solid-phase regrowth model still need to be clarified to validate it. First, the evolution of phases at the interface needs to be clarified, and, since Ge is known to be an amphoteric dopant in GaAs, the mechanism(s) controlling selection of the Ga or As site in the GaAs matrix should be explained. A series of studies have been carried out
116
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
in our laboratory to investigate the evolution of interfacial phases and their effect(s) on the formation of ohmic contacts. [74][75][77][93][108][118][154]-[157] Particular attention has been given to the reaction of Ni with GaAs and the evolution of the ternary hexagonal NixGaAs, since previous studies/21][135] showed that the contact properties were dependent on how this ternary phase evolved (see discussion of Ni/GaAs above). In previous experiments which demonstrated solid-phase regrowth, the entire layered structure was first deposited then annealed in one or two steps (e.g., first at 200-250~ prior to the final high temperature anneal).[ 135]As discussed above, multiple reactions occur simultaneously during this processing and it is unclear as to which reaction results in n§ doping. To better understand the reactions, Kim et al. deposited 650 A Ni films on GaAs and in situ annealed them at 300~ to form ~ 1300 A films of Ni2.4GaAs.[ 1~ This anneal was followed by in situ deposition of Ge and Ti films with various thicknesses, and evolution of the interfacial phases upon final annealing at 500~ was studied. Figure 15 is a schematic diagram of the experimental procedure. Ti rather than Au was used in the metallization to determine if the reaction sequence discussed above for the regrowth model (i.e., Ni dissociation of GaAs to form Ni-Ga-As-Ge phases which decompose to Ni-Ge and Ni-Ti plus epitaxial regrowth of Ge doped GaAs) was general. The general sequence of reactions was found for Ti/Ge/Ni metallization, supporting its general validity. In addition, the thickness of the Ge layer was varied from 300 A (thinner than the original 650 A Ni layer) to 750 A to control the degree of reduction of the Ni2.aGaAs phase to the NiGe phase, and thereby control the extent of GaAs regrowth. Ti was expected to assist the evolution of the interfacial phases at 500~ since Ni-Ti intermetallic compounds are formed with large, negative free energies of formation. By pre-reacting the Ni, the NiGe formed directly from Ni2.aGaAs + Ge, while the NiTi reaction occurred later after Ge had reacted with the Ni2.4GaAs layer. Separation of the reactions using this procedure was necessary since the overall metallurgical reactions at temperatures of -~500~ proceed rapidly over times of a few seconds.[23][148] In situ annealing to form Ni2.aGaAs allowed Kim to show that its evolution upon reactions with Ge and Ti proceeded along a route involving both transformation and decomposition.[ 1~ A flow chart showing the critical phases is shown in Fig. 16. In situ annealing at 300~ for 15 min produced Ni2.aGaAs, where the stoichiometry was determined using energy dispersive x-ray analysis (EDX) on a high resolution field emission STEM.[ lsS] After deposition of the Ge and Ti films on the Ni2.aGaAs and
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
117
annealing at 500~ for 5 min, Ni2.4GaAs was decomposed to directly form NiTi and NiGe plus epitaxial doped GaAs as indicated by the dashed line, or decomposed into NiAs + Ni3Ga 2. This was followed by evolution into NiAs plus NiGeGa, and finally into TiNi + NiGe + GaAs(Ge), indicated by the solid line in Fig. 16.
Ge & Ti evaporation
Ni
I650A
Ni2.4GaAs
T-1300~
Ti Ge
Ni2.4GaAs
GaAs
Vacuum
I~ a t
nu = 2 910JScm4
GaAs
GaAs
annealing 500~
5rain
In situ annealing at 300~
Figure 15. Schematic of experimental procedure to investigate evolution of Ni2.4GaAs. See text for detailed explanation (from Ref. 108). GaAs + Ni
1
In situ annealed at 300"C, 15 minutes
Ni2.4GaAs /
/
/
Deposite Ge and Ti annealed at 500"C, 5minutes
~
!
I
NiAs + NisGa 2
I I ! ! I !, I
NiGeGa
! ! I
'
"
/
1
TixNi + NiGey + G a A s (Ge) Figure 16. Schematic of the evolution of phases on GaAs from an in situ anneal of Ni on GaAs at 300~ for 15 min followed by deposition of Ge and Ti and a subsequent anneal at 500~ for 5 min. See text for explanation (from Ref. 108).
118
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
A representative set of data for the transformation and decomposition of Ni2.4GaAs phase are presented in Figs. 17-19. Figure 17 shows SIMS depth profiles of Ti/Ge/Ni2.4GaAs/GaAs. In Fig. 17a, the Ni, Ga and As signal are stable in the Ni2.4GaAs region, and the Ge and Ti layers are distinguishable at the surface. After annealing at 500~ for 5 min, the Ni and Ti signals are found together in the surface region, indicating formation ofNiTi x. The Ni2.4GaAs layer has been partially decomposed, but the Ge layer (250 A) was too thin to completely decompose this ternary film. The bilayer structure indicated by the SIMS data is shown by the cross section TEM mierograph in Fig. 18. The solid line in Fig. 18 indicates the location of the original interface between -~1300 A Ni2.4GaAs/GaAs. This interface obviously has moved towards the surface, indicating epitaxial regrowth of GaAs. In Fig. 18, a small arrow indicates trace of the decomposition of a Ni-As grain, resulting in the epitaxial regrowth of GaAs. Thus the area marked R in the figure is regrown GaAs. High spatial resolution EDX data shown in Figs. 19a and 19b were measured across an interface between regrown GaAs and a Ni-As (e.g., line scan 2 in Fig. 18) or Ni-Ga phase (e.g., line scan 1 in Fig. 18), respectively. These EDS results show that the Ni2.4GaAs transformed into Ni-As and Ni-Ga binaries. Since Ge is present in the Ni2.4GaAs and/or binary phases (4-12 at.% as shown in Fig. 19), it incorporated into the regrown GaAs to about 1020 cm-3.[ 158]This is sufficient to meet the requirements of TFE, as reported above, and therefore to achieve an ohmic contact. Electron diffraction analysis (e.g., from the structure shown in Fig. 18) showed several intermediate compositions for NiAs x and NiGay phases, most of which had crystal structures of the NiAs hexagonal type. They are believed to be intermediate phases along the reaction pathway followed to reach the equilibrium NiAs and Ni3Ga 2 phases.[l~ 159] Both NiAs• and NiGay phases must decompose to allow regrowth of Ge doped GaAs for ohmic contacts, and the decomposition products also depended critically upon the amount of starting elements. For example, in those samples where the amount of Ni was greater than the amount of Ge, the reaction to decompose Ni2.4GaAs or the binary phases did not go to completion. At times, this prevented the formation of an ohmic contact. When the ternary phase decomposed into the binary NiAs and Ni3Ga 2 phases, careful analysis with EDX and electron diffraction on the TEM Showed that Ge was incorporated predominantly at those regions where the binary phases decomposed and caused regrowth of GaAs. Figure 20 is a schematic summary highlighting the key information presented in
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
119
Figs. 17-19 (i.e., the transformation of Ni2.4GaAs into NiAs x and NiGay binaries, and the decomposition of the binaries). The arrows in Fig. 20 indicate Ge indiffusion through the ternary/binary phases resulting in Gedoped regrown GaAs. Under some conditions, regrowth of GaAs occurred predominantly from decomposition adjacent to a NiGay binary phase at the interface, and ohmic characteristics were not observed for I-V data from these samples. In other cases, regrowth predominantly from a NiAs phase led to linear I-V data. Apparently, ohmic behavior was not uniform across the interface. The majority of the current was conducted across regions where the NiAs phase existed at the interface, consistent with the literature reporting a lower specific contact resistance as the percent of the interface covered by NiAs increased.[ 23][143]
(a) As-deposited le+5 ?
:' .....
I
GaAs
u~-a'--
"''"~'.,.'~""
"f
le+4
<_Xs-
G~
~1e+3 "
Ni2_AGaAs
Ti i Gel
le+2 le+1
!,,,
le+0
5
10 15 20 Sputter time (min)
25
30
Ga
|
-
1
{b) 5000C. 5 minutes
le+5 ..._1i
,.,.,..
le+4
~,~ le+3
FA.2 ~:t~x".N~ '1 C'-',. ,,,,/, ~.,..............,....,\
._zffl
~" le+2
...... ' ' "
t" ,==.
.......
-
....
I~lleII
le+1 le+0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Sputter time (min)
Figure 17. SIMS depth profile for GaAs/Ni2.4GaAs/250A Ge/300A Ti; (a) as deposited, (b) annealed at 500~ for 5 minutes (from Ref. 108). See text for explanation.
120
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Figure 18. TEM micrograph from GaAs/Ni2.4GaAs/250A Ge/300A Ti annealed at 500~ for 5 rain. This microstructure corresponds to the SIMS depth profile shown in Fig. 17 (b) (from Ref. 108). See text for explanation.
Not only was the regrown GaAs doped with about 1020 cm -3 Ge, but it contained-~2 at.% of Ni as well. Incorporation of this element should be expected although it had not previously been measured.[15s] Ni is a deep acceptor with a solubility limit of 1017-10 is cm "3 in n-type GaAs,[ 16~ and it would be expected to compensate some of the donor Ge. However, the Ge concentration of-~l x 102~ -3 should not be affected too dramatically. Li and Holloway also measured a free carrier concentration of about this magnitude in regrown GaAs.[ 77] The level of incorporation of Ge into regrown GaAs and into Ga sites are presumably controlled by the amphoteric doping model of Walukiewicz.[59]-[61][164] HyBrid Contact Metallizations. As already discussed, an in situ contact scheme such as In/GaAs can be grown by MBE to form ohmic contacts through InCraAs heterojunctions.[16s][166]Indium films of 50-200 A thickness were added to study the formation of graded GaxInl.xAS heterostructure in addition to the formation of n+-GaAs. [167] TEM images showed that the metal/GaAs interface was covered by regrown GaAs and GaxInl.• Compared to Ni/Ge bimetallization, the contact resistance was reduced from ~1.2 ~ m m to ~0.3 ~mm. These attempts at improvement have resulted in only marginal effects. Wang et al. suggested that for PdInGe/GaAs metallization, either heterojunctions or formation of n+-GaAs was dominant depending on the temperature.[ 16s] In this study, specific contact resistances of~2 x 10-7 ~-cm "3 was measured.
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds 121
(a) Regrown GaAs
,
60 It..
. . . . . . .
I
'
Ni
I
"~.
50
.....
-. . . . . . . . - I - _ _ t t ~
I ~' ........ s,
40 0
Nii.3As
|
I !
3o
^.
......... .,'x~
\,
ii/ /:, \ ". /I
10
/i
/
'iGa
-'-:,,-
I
. , j l ........... , i t . - - -9. d l -
0
§
....
-
-300
.... ~
-
-200
T .... ~
"
t
.
-100
.
.
0
.
...............
.................... .
, ........
.
100
200
300
Distance (~) (b) Regrown GaAs 60
,-
...........................
Ni:.lGa
~
.......
l
i
. . . . . . . .... . O" .... ....... "---~
50
9"
'
\\
// /
I
Ni
r o
..............................
..... 9
I
\\
........ Q
\ \\
'.
40
/
I
/
I
/
\\ i / - |~
-|p\ -
O 9 w,,,i
30
I
\
,,? -\ -t
Ga
/ r/
20
// /
10
/ /
..__-.---~ 0
I
:
ii l
-v- . .. .. .. . .
-300
" ~ v' "
. " " . "." .
-200
I/
_ ~- r " . . . .. . . ~(" . .
-100
'.,
Ge
'i
"
I ,
/~
~: ,i,- - - - . - - , ~
l./
............
9 ....
. . r! '
|I" ' , "
~ s ................................... ,"
9
0
,
i"'".
100
9
,
,"'
|
200
,
9 "'~ " , '
300
Distance (A,) Figure 19. High resolution EDS analysis across the interface (b) regrown GaAs/Ni2.1Ga (from Ref. 108).
(a) regrown GaAs/Nil.3As,
122
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
(a) as-deposited
(b) SOOOC, 5 minutes
I
Ge
I
GaAs
I
Overall reaetioa:Ni,,GaAs +Ge +Ti = R-GaAs(Ge) +NiGa,+ NiAs, + NiTi,+ N i c e
Figure 20. Schematic of the evolution of Ni,,GaAs layer via formation of NiAs,, NiGa, and decomposition of the binaries after annealing at 500°C for 5 minutes. The arrows indicates direction of in-diffusion of Ge during the metallurgical reactions resulting in Gedoped regrown GaAs.
2.3 Reliability of and Thermally Stable Contact Metallizations As an aside, variants to AuGeNi systems have been studied in attempts to improve the thermal stability and surface morphology of nGaAs ohmic contacts. For high-temperature and high power devices, Interdifhreliable operations for long times at T > 300°C is sion and phase instabilities resulting in unnecessary reactions are of particular importance for shallow junctions. The reliability of contacts is a common and serious problem for any semiconductor. It is frequently found that the data of specific contact resistance versus annealing temperature exhibit a U-shaped curve (see Fig. 21), and the temperatures of the lowest resistance typically range from 450-550°C for GaAs and 300-400"C for InP. The specific contact resistance increases below and above this temperature range as shown in Fig. 2 1 for (a) Au-Ge films[80]and (b) for Ni/Ge films.[21]In a study of Au-containing
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
123
metallizations by Kuan et al., contact resistance was reported to be -~1 x 10-6 f2-cm 2 after annealing Au~i/AuGe/GaAs at 410~ for 5 min. Excessive annealing at 450~ for 200 see resulted in an increased resistance to ---5 x 10-6 ~-cm 2 which was attributed to growth of a beta Au-Ga phase at the expense of the NiAs/GaAs coverage.[15~ Shih et al. correlated higher contact resistance to dilution of Ge in overgrown NiAs annealed at 600~ for 5 min. [143] Overgrowth of NiAs was correlated to non-ohmic behavior in W/Ni/Si/Ni/GaAs.[ 17~ Isothermal annealing at 400~ of Ni/Ge/Ni/ GaAs for 10 hours after contact formation caused a rise in contact resistance.[ 21] In the case of addition of Au to Ni/Ge/GaAs, Au indiffusion towards GaAs was suggested as the cause of increase of contact resistance after isothermal annealing at 400~ for 10 hours.[ TM] For In Au/Ge/Pd/InP contacts, annealing at 400-450~ resulted in Schottky contact, while 325350~ resulted in ohmic contacts. Protrusions of Au-In phases into InP with irregular interfacial morphology was suggested to be the cause of non-ohmic behavior.[ 172]Thus, Au diffusion and continued phase evolution in contact metallizations results in a long term thermal instability of low contact resistance. While this has been most often studied for Au in contacts to GaAs, it is a potential problem in any metallization where the phases formed by the metallurgical reactions are not allowed to go to completion for forming the equilibrium phases. This is normally the case since the GaAs wafer is so large compared to the metal thin films, that equilibrium is so far towards the Ga and As-rich end of the complex phase diagrams, that equilibrium is seldom achieved. In addition, the diffusion coefficient of Au is large and therefore the resistance instability is more dramatic than for other metals. Diffusion coefficients are large and interdiffusion rapid for metallization on InP devices. To improve thermal stability, W60N40has been added to the AuGeNi system to prevent the reaction between Au and GaAs while allowing the solid-phase reaction between the Ni and Ge layers to form the ohmic contact.[173] Both a W S i 2 and a Cr layer have also been inserted between the Au and Ge to prevent the formation of the Au-Ge eutectic.[ 13][174]These metallizations formed stable ohmic contacts with contact resistances of 105-10 -6 f2-cm 2, and exhibited smooth morphology above --600~ A Ta-Si-N barrier layer inserted between Au and AuGePt layers was reported to result in stable, smooth interface morphology.[ 122] For better stability in high temperature contacts, Zuleeg et al. replaced the Au in Au/Ge/Ni contacts with A1 (i.e., A1/Ge/Ni contacts). [175] They reported that a thermally stable specific contact resistance of ~ 10-6 f2-cm 2 could be achieved with very smooth surface morphology up to about 400~ Lampert et al. subsequently showed that the formation of ohmic contacts in this system depended critically upon the sequence of thin film deposition,
124
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
with the A1/Ge/Ni/GaAs contacts becoming ohmic much more quickly than AI/Ni/Ge/GaAs contacts.[ 1~]-[156] They interpreted these observations in terms of Ni dissociation of GaAs and epitaxial regrowth of Ge doped GaAs due to formation of NiGe and AlxNiy intermetallic phases.[ 154]-[156][176][177]
1.0
!
!
? ,,_.,
> [-.. o~
10-2
< O u t.)
104
L) o~
104
1
I
I ..
6~
L
800
4O0
200
ANNEALING
TEMPERATURE
(~
(a) E E
I
I
I
SAMPLE-3
6 v u.I
o
l-. l.u
fls h0 < Z 0 0
0 500
.I 550
l
I
600
650
ANNEAL 1NG TEMPERATURE
700 ('C)
(b) Figure 21. (a) Specific contact resistance for conventional Au-Ge film (filled circle) or Gedoped isothermally regrown GaAs (from Ref. 80), (b) contact resistance from Ge/Ni/GaAs after annealing at various temperature for 5 minutes (from Ref. 21). Note U-shaped behavior of specific contact resistance with respect to annealing temperature.
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds 125
2.4
Summary
The formation of ohmic contacts to GaAs has been often studied and the model of their formation has undergone considerable evolution. Beginning with the empirical observation that Au-Ge/Ni formed a good ohmic contact to n-GaAs for Gunn diodes, the mechanism to explain this contact has evolved from one of surface tension and Au reaction, to one postulating doping due to a vacancy flux, to one of epitaxial regrowth after dissociation of the GaAs wafer. Each of the constituents of the contact, chosen empirically, contributes critically to the development of low resistance contacts. The role of Ni is to dissociate the GaAs lattice and to bond with both the Ga and As, often as a ternary phase, te keep them at the interface. Shortly after dissociation of the lattice, Ge reacts with the Ni bonded to Ga and/or As and forms NiGe, causing release of the Ga and As with Ge present to force regrowth of doped GaAs. Au helps drive the reaction towards completion by forming Au-Ga solid solutions. Based on this sequence of events, it is possible to develop rules for the formation of ohmic contacts to those semiconductors requiting heavy surface doping (e.g., when their Fermi level is pinned). The rules may be stated as follows: 1. The initial reaction between the semiconductor and metallization should dissociate the compound semiconductor. 2. The metallization should react with all elements in the compound semiconductor and hold them near the interface. 3. The metallization should have a subsequent reaction which leads to regrowth of the compound semiconductor. 4. A dopant or dopants should be present in the metallization. 5. The metallization should control the Fermi level during regrowth to ensure that dopant is incorporated on the proper lattice sites to result in a free carder density sufficient to yield low resistance ohmic contacts by tunneling or thermionie field emission transport. By following these rules, ohmic contacts should be possible for a large number of compound semiconductors.
126 3.0
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors O H M I C C O N T A C T S T O InP
InP has higher peak and saturation velocities of electrons than GaAs, rendering InP a potentially better material for high-speed and microwave devices.[ 178][179] However, InP is significantly more difficult to process since it decomposes at ~550~ versus GaAs at-650~ Due to the lower melting temperature of InP, metal/InP reactions are more rapid and morphology control can be more difficult. Since contact schemes for InP are similar to those being used for GaAs, it is worthwhile to review the interfacial and metallurgical characteristics and their effects on InP contacts. Katz [is0] reviewed the formation of ohmic contacts on InP based materials.
3.1
Single Element/InP Metallizations
Au/lnP Metallizations. Au is extensively used as a contact metal for InP, just as it is for GaAs devices. Upon annealing from just above room temperature to 400~ Au reacts with InP by In diffusing into Au to form Au-In solid solutions.[181]-[ 188] For example: Eq. (25)
Au + InP = Au-In + P
When the amount of indium in the Au films exceeds the solubility limits for solid solutions, a Au-In phase (Au3In) was formed.[ 182][1841[1851[187][189][19~ Eq. (26)
5Au + 3InP = Au3In + Au2P 3
It was suggested that phosphorus atoms either could leave the system or occupy nonlattice sites near the metal/InP interface.[ 185] It should be noted that Au did not react with As in Au/GaAs but that there was an extremely limited solubility of As in Au-Ga. The same may be true for P in Au-In. Annealing at 400~ for a few minutes changed the electrical property of the contact from non-ohmic to ohmic with-~l 0-4-10 "6~'~-cm2, which was attributed to formation of AuzP3 .[188][191] The surface morphology became rough when Au-In and AuzP 3 phases were formed.J182][ 185]Similar to Au/GaAs, the interface morphology was nonuniform due to formation of rectangular shaped reaction pits bounded by (111) planes.[185][Iss][ 1891The reaction pits were filled with Au-In.[ 1871Longer annealing times showed that Au-In solid solutions formed AuaIn upon cooling, and they were converted to Au9In4 as lateral spreading of the reaction zone took place.J188][19~
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds
127
At temperatures above -450~ Au2P 3 is dissociated and phosphorus evaporates as detected by a sharp evaporation peak at temperatures dependent upon the thickness of the Au film and independent of whether the substrate was n- or p-type.[ 184][187] Melting of the metallic layer was observed concurrent with the evaporation peak of phosphorus. For anneals above 450~ contact resistance increased by up to two order of magnitudes (to ~10 -4 ~-cm 2) upon dissociation of the Au2P3 phase.[191] Thus, the Au/InP and Au/GaAs interracial reactions are very similar to each other except that Au can form AUEP3 which decomposes above --450~ Ni/InP Metallizations. As deposited Ni/InP contacts exhibited rectifying behavior. The interfacial reaction in Ni/InP occurred upon deposition or after annealing below 250~ by Ni, producing amorphous NixInP, NiEP or NiaP.[192]-[196]Note that a rectifying ternary phase was formed near 250-300~ for Ni/GaAs, but it was crystalline. Annealing at higher temperatures above-300~ caused the amorphous phase to crystallize into a hexagonal NixInP (x-- 2.7), [192] monoclinic Ni2InP, and/or NiEP. [194][196]A low contact resistance (~10 -6 ~ - c m 2) was obtained with crystalline Ni2InP or Ni2P phases after annealing at 350~ and they were stable with time and temperature.[ 194][195][197][198]At 470 or 600~ for Ni-In-P, monoclinic Ni2InP was reported to be in equilibrium with InP at ~450~ after 3 month annealing.[ 1951This phase disappeared at 600~ At both temperatures, Ni2P, NisP 4, and NiP 2 were also in equilibrium with InP, but no Ni-In phases were found. [197] Ni2InP and InP had an epitaxial relationship with poor mismatch, and was suggested to be the cause of deviations from ideal I-V behavior after annealing at 5 0 0 ~ [199] It was suggested that the Ni/InP reaction proceeded from amorphization to segregation into Ni-P and Ni-In binary phases, and eventually recombination into the ternary phase.[ 1951With the Ni-P binary phases in contact with InP, contact resistances of 10-4-10 -6 f~-cm2 were measured. [~91 ][193][198] Pd/InP Metallizations. Pd/InP contacts were rectifying as deposited and an amorphous PdxlnP (x-- 3--4) ternary phase was reported. The PdxlnP remained amorphous but grew thicker at 175-225~176176176 Crys tallization into epitaxed cubic Pd2InP was observed upon annealing at 250~176176176 TM] Further annealing at 400~ caused decomposition of Pd2InP into Pdln and PdP 2. These two binary phases were stable after annealing at 500~ for 350 hours, but loss of P was detected when exposed to air or annealed at 650~ for 30 min. Thus Pdln and PdP 2 were reported to be the thermodynamic equilibrium phases with InP in a closed system at higher temperatures. The absence of a Pd-P phase was attributed to the
128
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
sublimation of P due to its high vapor pressure.[2~1762~ Other bulk experiments to determine the Pd-In-P phase diagram identified several ternary phases, for example, Pd5InP, Pd3.sInP , and Pd5InEP2 (suggested to be PdEInP in the report by Ivey et al.). However, at 600~ Pd-P and Pd-In binary phases were found to be in equilibrium with InP. [203] It was noted that an important difference between Pd/InP reaction and Pd/GaAs reaction was that the initial PdxInP ternary phases produced by annealing at 300~ or below were amorphous, while PdxGaAs was hexagonal crystalline. Both systems have the same characteristics; the high temperature equilibrium phases in an open system are binary compounds, although the Pd-P and Pd-As phases are difficult to maintain because of evaporation. Ohmic behavior for Pd/InP was observed after annealing at ~300~ and was attributed to the presence of the PdIn phase.[ 2~ Particularly, PdIn/InP was ohmic as deposited with a contact resistance of 6 x 10.5 ~-cm2. [204]
3.2
Multi-element/lnP Metallizations
Pd/Ge/InP and Au/Pd/Ge/InP Metallizations. The use of Ge/Pd and Ge/Pd/Au for contact to InP followed the results for GaAs contacts. PdGe formed ohmic contacts to n-GaAs with an abrupt interracial morphology due to regrown GaAs.[ TM] The solid phase regrowth model has also been demonstrated for Ge/Pd/n-lnP,[ 2~ and was tested for the Ge/Pd/Z~ Pd/p-InP system.[ 2~ Regrown InP and PdGe and ohmic behavior were found after annealing above 400~ suggesting the following reaction:[ 2~ Eq. (27)
PdxInP(Ge, Zn) + Ge ~ InP(Ge, Zn) + PdGe
For Pd/Ge contacts, the relative amounts of Ge to Pd was a critical factor to lower contact resistance. When thin Ge layers were used (e.g., Pd/ Ge ratio > 2), the dominant metall~gical reaction products were PdP 2 and PdIn, and the contact resistance was -~10-5 ~-cm2.[ 2~ With Pd/Ge < 1, a contact resistance of--4 x 10-6 fl-cm 2 was obtained for annealing at 400450~ with only PdGe in contact with InP. Adding Au to Pd/Ge/InP alters the metallurgical reactions to form Au-In compounds at the metal/InP interface. Spatially, Au~0In3 was in contact with InP with an irregular interracial morphology. Aut0In 3, PdGe, and GeP were the reaction products after annealing at 325-450~ [207]Contact resistances of 2-4 x 10.6 ff)-cm2 was obtained at ~350~ The formation of GeP is different from GaAs since a GeAs phase was not reported.
Ohmic Contacts to 11-I/I and III-V Compounds
129
Au/Ni/InP and Au/Ge/Ni/lnP Metallizations. TEM images of Au/ Ni/InP after annealing at 250-400~ for 15 seconds revealed a layered structure of Aualn/NiP-NiP2/Au3In/InP.[ 2~ This indicates that Au diffused through the Ni layer and reacted preferentially with In, while Ni reacts with phosphorus at temperatures as low as 250~ (which is consistent with AES depth profiles). [2~ Gas mass spectrometry showed that the phosphorus loss was negligibly small, as compared to that from the Au/InP reaction metallurgical reactions near 400~ indicating that Ni captured P by forming Ni-P compounds.[ 21~ It was reported that these reactions resulted in ohmic contacts to n-type (doped to -- 1018 cm-3) without Ge[1991[21l] but non-ohmic contacts on p-InP.[ 2~ Presumably the ohmic contacts without Ge on n-InP results from dopant segregation to the interface during reactions, similar to Au/GaAs reactions.[ 93] Adding Ge to Au/Ni to form ohmic contacts to InP leads to the identical recipe of AuGeNi for n-GaAs contacts. With respect to the metallurgical reactions which lead to the ohmic contacts, below 250~ the formation of amorphous NixlnP and indiffusion of Au towards InP and outdiffusion of In toward the free surface are all observed.[ 212]Annealing at 250-350~ causes Ge to migrate into the Ni layer while Ni accumulates at the metal/InP interface, presumably dissociating the InP lattice to form amorphous NixlnP. Diffusion of Au and In through the intervening layers was also noticeable. [179][191][212][213]The contact resistance was reduced from 10-2 to 10-4-10-s f2-cm 2 during this reaction stage. [179][191][212] At 350~ 450~ where the lowest contact resistances were frequently measured, metallurgical reactions were more pronounced. Nickel accumulated at the InP interface as Ni2P, Ge reacted with Ni to form NiGe, and Au reacted to form Au-In compounds,[ 212][2141all of which are similar to the characteristics for AuGeNi/GaAs reactions.[179][2~ Spatially, the phases in contact with InP are Ni-P and Au-In, with Au-In and indium oxide phases at the metal/ambient interface. The Au-In phase at the InP interface causes irregular interfacial morphology. Elemental Ge coexisted with Au-In alloys at the metal/ambient interface rather than segregating at the metal/InP interface, again similar to GaAs with excess Ge.[ 212] 3.3
Mechanisms for Formation of Ohmic Contacts
As to the mechanism for ohmic contacts, the similarity to GaAs suggests strongly that the solid phase regrowth model should be applicable. In this model, again Ni dissociates the InP lattice and bonds to the P.
130
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
A ternary phase may form at the interface, however, in the case of ternary decomposition to binary alloys, Au or a similar element may be necessary to hold the In at the interface. Formation of Au-Ni or NiGe then would cause regrowth of InP with incorporation of a dopant (Ge or Zn reported above). A significant difference between the two systems is that extremely low contact resistance (10 -7-10 -8~-em 2) was reported without using Ge,[ 215] particularly when Ni-P phases were formed at the interface with n-InP. The use of Ge is essential to formation of low resistance ohmic contacts to nGaAs. This difference with InP might result from stronger segregation of the dopant during metallurgical reactions, or since the Fermi level is only partially pinned for InP, formation of Ni-P may unpin the Fermi level and thereby significantly lower the barrier height. Thus, barrier lowering effects from unpinned Fermi levels may be an important factor in the formation of ohmic contact to InP.
4.0
O H M I C C O N T A C T S T O GaN
The situation for forming ohmic contacts to GaN is quite different from that for GaAs or InP in that Fermi level pinning does not occur. GaN devices are similar in this respect to the situation for ZnSe-based devices, as discussed below. Since the Fermi level is unpinned, formation of ohmic contacts can be predicted by the simple rule (Eq. 4) of the metal work function being less than the electron affinity of the semiconductor (~m < Xs) for an ohmic contact to n-GaN. [216][217] Since ~ G a N -- 4.14 eV, Foresi and Moustakis[ 218] showed that A1 (~gl - 4.08 eV) on n-GaN resulted in an ohmic contact, while Au contacts (~gu = 5.1 eV) were rectifying. Miller and Holloway also reported that Au formed rectifying contacts to nGaN.[216] Miller and Holloway studied Ag ( ( I ) g g = 4.3 eV) single component metallizations on n-GaN which resulted in weakly rectifying contacts in the as-deposited or heated to 500~ conditions. No interface reactions nor phase formation have been observed for either Au or Ag metallization on GaN epitaxial layers. However, Guo et al. showed that the Schottky barrier height for Pt and Pd varied with work function indicating a partially pinned surface level.[ 219] Wang et al. reported for the same system that the Schottky barrier height was the same for Pt and Pd.[ 220]These conflicting results clearly show that cleaning of the GaN surfaces is critical to successful and reproducible formation of ohmic contacts, as suggested by Murakami
Ohmic Contacts to 11-111and I I I - V Compounds
131
et al.[221]Thus, E r of GaN is regarded as unpinned, while partially pinned E F have been attributed to interfacial contamination. The characteristics ofmulticomponent contacts incorporating Ti are consistent with the conclusion of unpinned EF.[216][217][222]-[224]For pure Ti with a ~Ti - 4.3 eV, a weakly rectifying contact would be predicted. However, Ti will react with GaN to form TiN. With a theoretically predicted work function for TixN of 3.74 eV and reasonable electrical conductivities, this material should make a good ohmic contact to n-GaN. At the interface between a single or multicomponent metallization (e.g., Ti versus Ti/Pt/Au or Ti/A1/Ni/Au), TixN can be grown by interracial reactions during heating to temperatures ranging from 250~ (furnace anneal) to 900~ (rapid thermal anneal). The TiN interface phase is so thin that it is difficult to measure using the conventional thin film profiling techniques, such as AES, XPS, or SIMS. This interracial reaction product has only been suggested by limited depth profiling data and by ohmic electrical behavior after annealing. Very low specific contact resistances (~10-5-10 "7 f2-cm2) have been reported.j222][223]Ping et al. showed that A1 adjacent to n-GaN with a top Pd layer would also form an ohmic contact with a low specific contact resistance (10 -5 ~-cm 2) after heating to 650~ for 30 sec.[ 225] Even when the work function of the metallization is not appropriate, increased surface doping of n-GaN can be used to achieve ohmic contact. Miller and Holloway showed that incorporation of Si into a Au/Si/Ni metallization improved the performance.[ 2161Since the work function of both Au and Ni (5.2 eV) are greater than the electron affinity of GaN, neither should make an ohmic contact to n-type material. However, Si apparently helps create an n § surface layer which allows tunneling transport to result in an ohmic behavior. Another way to increase doping at the surface of n-GaN is to heat treat at high temperatures, resulting in the loss of nitrogen and formation of a shallow donor. As a result, Zolper et al. showed that high temperature heat treatment without a capping layer improved the properties of an A1/Ti ohmic contact, while it degraded the performance of a A u n t Schottky contact on n-GaN.[ 227] If the GaN surface was capped with an A1N layer before annealing, loss of N was prevented, the ohmic contact was worse, and the Schottky contact was constant. Lester et al.,[ 228] Cole et al.,[ 2291 Binari et al.,[ 23~ Lin et al.,[223] Revimov et al.,[ TM] and Smith et al.[232] all reported that formation of N vacancies during heat treatment or by interfacial phases increased the free electron concentration near the n-GaN interface and assisted in formation of ohmic contacts. Finally, Ingerly et al. heated Ptln 2
132
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
surface layers on GaN and reported that decomposition of the surface layer resulted in formation of InGaN narrower bandgap material. A specific contact resistance of < 10-3 f2-cm 2 was reported.[ 233] In contact studies to n-GaN, thermal stability of the contacts has only been tested in a cursory fashion. Dt~bha et al. studied the contact resistance, topography, and composition profiles for Ti/Pt/Au, Au/Ge/Ni, A u ~ e and WSi x on GaN or In0.sGa0.sN thin films.[ 217] The WSi x contacts were found to exhibit excellent thermal stability (smooth surface morphology, no interdiffusion, and low contact resistance) even for heat treatments up to 800~ The minimum, specific contact resistance on In0.5Ga0.sN was 1.5 x 10-5 f~-cm 2. The Ti/Pt/Au, Au/Ge/Ni, and A u ~ e contacts showed much lower thermal stabilities, with Au/Be being unstable at temperatures as low as 400~ The instabilities were largely evident from changes in the surface morphologies resulting from voids or islands of metallization (from surface capillarity forces). There was no evidence for formation ofinterfacial phases, even though the interface width measured from AES depth profiles became broader, presumably due to roughening of the interface. In contrast to n-GaN, a metal or compound with a very large work function would be required to make an ohmic contact with p-GaN (electron affinity plus bandgap of 4.1 eV + 3.4 eV = 7.5 eV) as discussed above. Consistent with expectation, studies of the Schottky barrier height for Pt, Ni, Au, and Ti to p-GaN[ 214] showed that all contacts were rectifying and the barrier height decreased with increasing work function. In addition, Ishikawa et al. showed that the interfacial barrier height for contacts of Pt, Ni, Pd, Au, Cr, Ti, A1, and Ta also decreased as the work function increased. [221] Both studies are consistent with unpinned E F or only partially pinned E F. Since there are no metals with a work function >7.5 eV, ohmic contacts to p-GaN must be formed by either a compound with a very large work function/electron affinity, by doping the surface region to p++ with a lowered surface barrier, or by a graded surface barrier normally created during the last phases ofMBE, MOMBE, or MOCVD growth of the GaN epilayer. Nakamura et al. used Au or Au/Ni contacts to p-GaN for a demonstration of LEDs and electrically injected LDs based on GaN. [234][235] Khan et al. also reported using Au/Ni contacts on p-GaN. Other contacts metallizations to p-GaN include Ni by Sakai et al., [236] Au/Zn by Kuga et al.,[ 237] and Ti/Mo/Au by Goldenberg et al. [238] Trexler et al. studied the interracial reactions between Au, Au/Ni, Au/C/Ni, and Au/Cr metallizations on GaN doped with Mg (free hole density of 5 x 1016 to 2 x 1017cm 3)
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds 133 at temperatures up to 900~ [239] The Au contacts were rectifying and remained so even after heat treatment to temperatures up to 600~ There was very little interaction between the Au and GaN and no evidence for formation of an interfacial reaction phase or for diffusion of Au into the epilayer. For Au/Ni and Au/C/Ni metallizations, Ni dissociated the GaN lattice and led to a lower barrier height at the interface.[ 24~ After heat treatment at 600~ the Au and Ni had interdiffused and the width of the Ni/GaN interface had increased significantly, indicating dissociation of the GaN lattice. The reaction products of this dissociation are uncertain since there is low solubility of N in Ni, even though Ni will combine with Ga to form a solid solution and several binary intermetallic solid phases. While the Au/Ni contacts never achieved linear I-V ohmic behavior, the reverse bias breakdown voltage dropped from near 3 V to less than 0.5 V. Trexler et al. speculated that interracial carbon from contamination acted as a dopant and was incorporated into the lattice during this interfacial reaction.[ 24~ Abemathy et al. showed that C can act as an acceptor in GaN, thus it is reasonable to speculate that interfacial contamination detected by both AES and SIMS could lead to a higher free hole concentration at the interface.[ TM] Therefore, the contact structure of Au/C/Ni, where 10 nm of C was evaporated between deposition of Au and Ni, was tested to determine if increased doping and better ohmic contacts would be observed. As shown in Fig. 22, the current-voltage data for this contact scheme exhibited a higher resistance than did the AtffNi scheme. Obviously an evaporated film of C at the metal/semiconductor interface did not improve the ohmic behavior. This could result from a number of factors, including the fact that a monolayer interfacial C contamination layer should be sufficient to saturate the doping effects. In addition, interfacial contamination C is largely "adventitious" organic and hydrocarbon molecules which are similar to the C source used by Abemathy et al. to demonstrate p-doping of GaN. The C present from evaporation of a thin film is bound primarily as C sp 2 in a ring structure, which is notoriously poor as a doping source during thin film growth. Trexler et al. also studied the formation of Au/Cr contacts to p-GaN and found better linear I-V data than for Au/Ni or Au/C/Ni. Contacts were rectifying as deposited with a reverse bias breakdown voltage of ~1.5 V.[239] Upon annealing at 200~ or 400~ for 5 min, there was a slight decrease in conductivity across the contacts and samples. However after an RTA at 900~ for 15 sec., the I-V data were very linear with large current flow across the interfaces. Auger analysis showed very little reaction between
134
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
the Cr and GaN at 200~ or 400~ but extensive dissociation of the GaN lattice and formation of a Cr-N-Ga ternary phase at the interface after the 900~ 15 see. RTA. Thus, Au/Cr appears to be a better contact metallization than does Au/Ni for p-GaN. While the specific contact resistance was not measured, it is expected to be very high compared to the values for ZnSe or GaAs (i.e., much higher than ~10 -5 f)-cm2). 2e-4
2e-4
le-4
<
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
9. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5e-5
! i
C . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
!. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
9
- 5 e - 5 -~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . : 9 Ni/C/~Au as-de;~:slted i : ! { 9 NilC/~Au 200*C,i 5 n~n -le-4
.~ .................
o ..................
~ ......
9
......
9 Ni/C/..Au 400"C, i 5 rain
O
Ni/A~
as-depos./ted
.: ....................
-2e-4
. . . . . .
i
:
O
Ni/A% 400~
5i re,in
-2e-4 -6
-4
-2
0
Voltage
2
4
6
(V)
Figure 22. Current versus voltage for A u ~ i and Au/C/Ni contacts deposited on p-GaN and heated for the temperatures and times shown. While the reverse bias breakdown voltages for the contacts are reduced by heat treatment, the contacts remain rectifying. See text for explanation (from Ref. 240).
5.0
OHMIC CONTACTS TO ZnSe
As discussed in the introduction, the largely ionic bonding and large AX for ZnSe based systems result in an unpinned E F .[242][243][244] Consequently, formation of ohmic contacts to ZnSe can be predicted by the simple rules discussed in the introduction, based on the value of the
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
135
metallization work function versus the semiconductor electron affinity. Formation of an ohmic contact to n-ZnSe is relatively easy since the electron affinity is 4.09 eV, and n-ZnSe can be doped to free electron densities > 1019 em -3. Therefore it is easy to select a metal with a work function less than or nearly equal to 4.09 eV and achieve an ohmic contact, which can be improved by high surface doping (i.e., creation of an n + surface layer). For example, ohmic contacts to n-ZnSe with In (~In = 4.2 eV) and In-Sn alloys plus with Ti/Pt/Au alloys (r = 4.3 eV) have been demonstrated.[245][246][247] Even with an unpinned E F, heating of a deposited metal layer is normally required before ohmic behavior is observed.[ TM] Heating presumably assists an interfaeial reaction whose purpose is to eliminate or penetrate any interfaeial contamination layer which may be present. Liu et al. have discussed the surface preparation methods for ZnSe to minimize this eontamination.[ 248] Even with good cleaning, diffusion to eliminate or negate such an interfacial dielectric layer is commonly required because as-deposited contacts of In or Ti/Pt/Au on n-ZnSe were rectifying. After heat treatments at T > 200~ the contacts commonly switched from rectifying to ohmic. SIMS profiles of the In showed that the interface between the In and ZnSe was now very diffuse. This would be consistent with interdiffusion of In and/or roughening of the metallization thickness due to capillarity forces or displacement of the native ZnO or Zn(OH)2 present on the etched ZnSe wafer.[ 248] An upper limit to the specific contact resistance of In on n-ZnSe was reported by Wang and Holloway to be 10-3 g~-em2. They also reported that contacts heated to T > 350~ showed increased resistance.[ 247] In the ease of ohmic contacts to p-ZnSe, the situation is completely different, even though the Fermi level still appears to be unpinned. [245][246] In this ease, the sum of the electron affinity (4.09 eV) and the bandgap (2.67 eV) is so large (6.76 eV) that it is impossible to find a metal with a sufficiently large work function to create an ohmic contact, exactly analogous to p-GaN. As a result, all studies which have attempted to use simple metals or multiple layer metallization schemes have failed. For example, Fijol et al. showed that Au and Ag exhibited Schottky barrier contacts with minimum breakdown voltages of 3.0 and 2.3 eV, respeetively.[2491[25~ Oxygen helped lower the breakdown voltage, especially for Ag, and Akimoto et al. used an oxygen plasma to achieve a psuedo-ohmic contact using Au metallization.[ TM] Chen et al. only achieved a reduced breakdown voltage by placing Se monolayers at the Au/p-ZnSe interface.[ 243]
136
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Simple metallization schemes should, in principle, still be able to yield an ohmic contact, even with the mismatch between work function and electron affinity plus bandgap, if they could be used to create a p++ doped surface layer. However the maximum free hole concentrations achieved to date in ZnSe have been only at the mid 1017 em -3 level,[ 252] which is not sufficient to allow conversion of the interface transport from thermionie to thermionic field, or simple field emission. In addition, p-type conversion has only regularly and reliably been achieved during molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) growth of ZnSe. No dopant or regrowth scheme has been found which will force increased surface doping during contact formation due to interfacial reactions. Because of solubility limits and self compensation mechanisms for the common p-type dopants in ZnSe, it seems unlikely that such reaction/regrowth/doping systems can be found for p-ZnSe. The most successful ohmic contacts to p-ZnSe have been formations of multi-quantum well structures of p+-ZnTe/p-ZnSe.[253]-[255] The II-VI semiconductor p-ZnTe was used in these quantum well contacts because it can be doped to very high free hole densities during growth, and the band edges of ZnTe and ZnSe align properly for formation of resonant tunneling bandgap states. Therefore, formation of an ohmic contact to p-ZnTe is required to complete the ohmic contact to p-ZnSe. Trexler and Holloway showed that Au could be used to make good ohmic contacts to p-ZnTe with free hole concentrations of 3 x 1018 em-3.[256][257] As deposited, the Au formed a rectifying contact, but heat treatment at 200~ led to an ohmic contact due to disruption of the ZnTe interfacial contamination layer plus Au indiffusion without formation of an interface phase. For heat treatment above 250~ the contact resistance increased and an interface phase was detected by Auger and SIMS depth profiles. The quality of the ohmic contact was improved eonsiderabiy ifbilayer (Au~d), trilayer ( A u ~ t ~ d , Au~t/Ti, or Au/Mo/Pd), or quaternary layer (Au/Pt/Ti~i) metallization schemes were used on p-ZnTe, as shown by Kim et a1.,[258][259] Moehizuki et al.,[ 260] Ohtsuka et al.,[ 261] and by Ozawa et al. [262]Using two and three layer metallizations, specific contact resistances as low as 6 x 10-6 f2-em 2 were reported due to both increased surface doping ofp-ZnTe and reduced Sehottky barrier heights.[ 258] In an attempt to bypass the requirement of high surface doping on pZnSe, Lansari et al. used HgSe layers grown by MBE on p-ZnSexTe~_x layers to form low barrier contacts which were sometimes labeled "ohmic. ''[263][264]Films of HgSe form low barrier contacts to p-ZnSexTel, x because it is a semimetal with an electron affinity of about 6.1 eV. The
Ohmic Contacts to II-VI and III-V Compounds 137 predicted interfacial barrier for this film on p-ZnSe was 0.6 eV, and Fijol et al.[265]measured the barrier to be 0.5 5 eV. By addition of Te (ZnSel.xTex where x = 0.2) to the top-most epilayer, Lansari reduced the interfacial barrier to about 0.4 eV. This still leads to large contact resistances which result in high operating voltages and high junction temperatures for ZnSebased LEDs and diode lasers.[245][246][266] In addition, formation of the contact during MBE growth required deposition of rig in the system. Fijol et al. demonstrated an ex situ method for forming HgSe contacts to p-ZnSe using MBE grown p-ZnSe capped with a thick amorphous Se layer. [265] However the interfacial barrier is still too high to consider this an ohmic contact. Such an in situ capping procedure followed by the ex situ growth of the semiconductor contacting layers is a general scheme for ohmic contacts. For example, Ge-doped n§ for ohmic contacts was grown at the interface of As, or Ga capped GaAs, under a Ga or As flux, respectively, as reported by Li and Holloway.[ 77][118]In general, it is possible to use capped epitaxial layers and in situ or ex situ growth/regrowth to form either doped regions for ohmic contacts, or to form layers (both epitaxial and non-epitaxial) which do not exhibit interfacial contamination and therefore lead to ohmic contacts with low specific contact resistance.
6.0
CONCLUSIONS
Procedures to form ohmic contacts to GaAs, InP, GaN, and ZnSe were reviewed. For GaAs and InP, where Fermi level pinning has a significant effect on ohmic contacts, incorporation of dopants upon epitaxial regrowth of the semiconductor is the dominant method of forming ohmic contacts. The epitaxial regrowth of doped GaAs or InP is achieved by interfacial reactions which dissociate the semiconductor lattice. Subsequent reactions decomposed the phases bonded to the semiconductor elements and allow them to epitaxially regrow in the solid phase. General guidelines for the use of this technique for solid phase regrowth were given and are expected to be applicable to many semiconductor systems. These guidelines are as follows: 1. The initial reaction between the semiconductor and metallization should dissociate the compound semiconductor.
138
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors 2. The metallization should react with all elements in the compound semiconductor and hold them near the interface. 3. The metallization should have a subsequent reaction which leads to regrowth of the compound semiconductor. 4. A dopant or dopants should be present in the metallization. 5. The metallization should control the Fermi level during regrowth to ensure that the dopant is incorporated on the proper lattice sites to result in a free carrier density sufficient to yield low resistance ohmic contacts by tunneling or thermionic field emission transport.
For GaN and ZnSe, the Fermi level is not completely pinned and therefore it should be easier to form ohmic contacts. This is true for n-type materials where metals with work functions less than the electron affinities result in ohmic contacts, often after heat treatment to penetrate interracial contamination layers. However, formation of ohmic contacts to unpinned p-type surfaces is difficult, since the sum of the semiconductor work function and electron affinity is larger than the work function of any known metal. In this case, graded bandgaps or multi-quantum well contacts have proven best for ZnSe. Contacts to p-GaN are still being developed.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT This work was supported by ONR Grant N00014-92-J-1895 and AFOSR Grant F49620-96-1-0026.
REFERENCES 1. Haigh, D. and Everad, J., GaAs Technology and Its impact on Circuits and Systems, Peter Peregrinus Ltd., London, UK (1989) 2. Ali, F., and Gupta, A., HEMTs and HBTs: Devices, Fabrication, and Circuits, Artec House, Massachusetts (1990) 3. Feng, M. S., Hsin, Y. M., and Wu, C. H., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp.Proc., 300:61 (1993) 4. Tell, B., Andrew S. H., Liao, K. F., and Bridges T. J., IEEE Trans on Elec. Dev., ED-32:2319-2321 (1985)
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
139
5. Heime, K., InGaAs Field-Effect Transistors, Research Studies Press LTD, England (1989) 6. Christianson, K. A., Moglestue, C., and Anderson, W. T., Solid-State Elec., 38:1623 (1995) 7. Anderson, W. T., and Christou, A., Semiconductor Device Reliablity, p. 423, Kluwer, Boston (1990) 8. Barnes, A., SPIE Journal, 1632:98 (1992) 9. Wolfe, C. N., Holonyak, N., and Stillman, G. E., Physical Properties of Semiconductors, p. 59, Prentise-Hall, NY (1989) 10. Braslau, N, Gunn, J. B., and Staples, J. L., Solid-State Elec., 10:381(1967) 11. Gupta, R., Khokle, W. S, Wuerfl, J., and Hartnagel, H. L, J. Electrochem. Soc., 137:631 (1990) 12. Ball, R. K., Thin Solid Films, 176:55 (1989) 13. Wilier, J., Ristow, D., Kellner, W., and Oppolzer, H., d. Electrochem. Soc., 135:179 (1988) 14. Hugon, M. C, Agius, B., and Vamiere, F., J. Appl. Phys., 72:3570 (1992) 15. Kolqwa, E., Nieh, C. W., Flick, W., Molarius, J., and Nicolet, M.-A., Mat. Res. Soc. Proc., 126:289 (1988) 16. Rideout, V. L., Solid-State Elec., 18:541 (1975) 17. Piotrowska, A., Guivarc'h, A., and Pelous, G., Solid-State Elec., 26:179 (1983) 18. Shen, T. C., Gao, G. B., and Morkoc, H., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 10:2113 (1992) 19. Mehdi, I., Reddy, U. K., Oh, J., East, J. R., and Haddad, G. I., d. Appl. Phys., 65:868 (1989) 20. Murakami, M., Price, W. H., Greiner, J. H., and Feder, J. D., J. Appl. Phys., 65:3546 (1989) 21. Tanahashi, K., Takata, J. J, Otuki, A., and Murakami, M., J. Appl. Phys., 71:4183 (1992) 22. Brillson, L. J., Contacts to Semiconductors:Fundamentals and Technology, Noyes Publ., Park Ridge, NJ (1993) 23. Marshall, E. D., and Murakami, M., Contacts to Semiconductor: Fundamentals and Technology, Ch. 1, (L. J. Brillson, ed), Noyes Publ., Park Ridge, NJ (1993) 24. Sze, S. M., Physics of Semiconductor Devices, p. 78, Jon Wiley & Sons Inc., New York (1981) 25. Sze, S. M., Physics of Semiconductor Devices, p. 254, Jon Wiley & Sons Inc., New York (1981) 26. Sah, C.-T., Fundamentals of Solid State Electronics, p. 488, World Scientific Publishing Co., River Edge, NJ (1991)
140
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors 27. Flower, R. H., and Nordheim, L., Pro. Roy. Soc., A, 119:173 (1928) 28. 29. 30. 31.
Stratton, R., Proc. Roy. Sot., B, 68:746 (1955) Kroger, F. A., Dimer, G., and Klasens, H. A, Phy. Rev., 103:279 (1956) Stratton, R., Phys. Rev., 125:67 (1962) Conley, J. W., Duke, C. B., Mahan, G. D., and Tiemann, J. J., Phys. Rev., 150:466 (1966) 32. Chang, C. Y., Fang, Y. K., and Szc, S. M., Solid-State Elec., 14:541 (1971) 33. 34. 35. 36.
Padovani, F. A., and Stratton, R., Solid-State Elec., 9:695 (1966) Cox, R. H., and Strack, H., Solid-State Elec., 10:1213-1218 (1967) Bergcr, H. H., Solid-State Elec., 15:145-158 (1972) Proctor, S. J., and Linholm, C. W., IEEE Elec. Dev. Lett., EDL-3:67 (1982) 37. Henry, H. G., IEEE Trans. Elec.Dev., 36:1390-1393 (1989) 38. Harrison, H. B., and Reeves, G. K., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 260:31-41 (1992) 39. Kovacs, B. and Mojzes, I., IEEE Trans. Elec. Dev., ED-33:1401-1403 (1996) 40. Bardeen, J., Phy. Rev., 71:717 (1947) 41. Cowley, A. M., and Sze, S. M.,J. Appl. Phys., 36:3212 (1965) 42. Spicer, W. E., Chye, P. W., Skeath, P. R., Su, C. Y., and Lindau, I., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 16:1422 (1979) 43. Kurtin, S., McGill, T. C., and Mead, C. A., Phys. Rev. Lett., 22:1433 (1969) 44. Schluter, M., Phy. Rev. B, 17:5044-5047 (1978) 45. Gudat ,W., and Eastmen, D. E.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 13:769 (1976) 46. Spicer, W. E., Lindau, I., Gregory, P. E., Garner, C. M., Pianetta, P., and Chye, P., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 13:780 (1976) 47. Tang, S. Y., Mei, W. N., and Xu, G.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 2:393 (1984) 48. Schilfgaarde, M. V., and Newman, N., Phys. Rev. Lett., 65:2728 (1990) 49. Spiccr, W. E., Lindau, I., Skeath, P., and Su, C. Y., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 17:1019(1980) 50. Heine, V., Phys. Rev. A, 138:1689 (1965) 51. Monch, W., Semiconductor Surface and Interfaces, Ch. 6, SpringerVerlag, Berlin (1993) 52. Monch, W., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 6:1270 (1988) 53. Cao, R., Miyano, K., Kendelewicz, T., Lindau, I., and Spicer, W. E., Phy. Rev. B, 39:12655 (1989)
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75.
76. 77.
141
Andrews, J. M. and Phillips, J. C., Phys. Rev. Lett., 56:35 (1975) Freeouf, J. L., Solid-State Comm., 33:1059 (1980) Freeouf, J. L., and Woodall, J. M.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 39:727 (1981) Brillson, L. J.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 15:1378 (1978) Brillson, L. J., Chang, S., Shaw, J., and Viturro, R. E., Vacuum, 41:1016 (1990) Walukiewicz, W., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 5:1062 (1987) Walukiewicz, W., Phy. Rev. B., 37:4760 (1988) Walukiewicz, W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 54:2094 (1989) Zhang, S. B., and Northrup, J. E., Phy. Rev. Lett., 67:2339 (1991) Sankey, F., Allen, R. E., Ren, S.-F., and Dow, J. D., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 3:1162 (1985) Spicer, W. E., Newman, N., Kendelewicz, T., Petro, W. G, Williams, M. D., McCants, C. E., and Lindau, I., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 3:1178 (1985) Tersoff, J., Metallization and Metal-Semiconductor Interfaces, (I. P. Batra, ed.), Plenum Press, New York (1988) Spicer, W. E., and Green, A. M.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 11:1347 (1993) Barnes, P. A. and Cho, A. Y.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 33:651 (1978) Kirchner, P. D., Jackson, T. N., Dpettit, G., and Woodall, J. M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 47:26 (1985) Stall, R. A., Wood, C. E. C, Board, K., Dandekar, N., Eastman, L. F., and Devlin, J.,J. Appl. Phy., 52:4062 (1981) Ballmgall, J. M., Wood, C. E. C., and Eastman, L. F., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 1:675-681 (1983) Devlin, W. J., Wood, C. E. C., Stall, R., and Eastman, L. F., Solid-State Elec., 23:823 (1980) Woodall, J. M., Freeouf, J. L., Pettit, G. D., Jackson, T., and Kirchner, P., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 19:626 (1981) Kumar, N. S., Chyi, J.-I., Peng, C. K., and Morkoc, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 55:775 (1989) Fisher, V., Holloway, P. H., Ristolainen, E., and Schoenfeld, D., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 12:1419 (1994) Fisher, V., Viljoen, P. E., Ristolainen, E., Hollway, P. H., Lampert, W. V., Haas, T. W., and Woodall, J. M., Advanced Metallizations for Devices and Circuits-Science, Technology and Manufacturability, (S. P. Muraka, A. Katz, K. N. Tu, and K. Maex, eds.), Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 337:413, Pittsburgh, PA (1994) Woodal, J. M., Metal Contacts to III-VSemiconductors, p. 223 (1986) Li, B., and Holloway, P. H.,J. Appl. Phys., 71:4385 (1992)
142
Wide B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s
78. Gyulai, J., Mayer, J. W., Rodriguez, V., Yu, Y. C., and Gopen, H. J., J. Appl. Phys., 42:3578 (1971). 79. Leung, S., Yoshiie, T., Bauer, C. L., and Milnes, A. G., J. Electrochem. Soc., 132:898 (1985) 80. Holloway, P. H., and Mueller, C. H., Thin Solid Films, 221:254 (1992) 81. Mueller, C. H., Hollway, P. H., and Connell, R. G., Advanced Metallizations and Processing for Semiconductor Devices and Circuits II, (A. Katz, S. P. Muraka, Y. I. Nissim, and J. M. Harper, ed.) p. 481, MRS Pittsburgh, PA (1993) 82. Kinsbron, E., Gallagher, P. K., and English, A. T., Solid-State Elec., 22:517-524 (1979) 83. Weizer, V. G., and Fatemi, N. S., J. Appl. Phys., 64:4618-4623 (1988) 84. Mojes, I, and Veresegyhazy, R., Thin Solid Films, 144:29 (1986) 85. Kim, T., and Chung, D. D. L., Phil Mag. A, 62:283 (1990) 86. Kumar, K., Jpn. J. AppL Phys., 18:713 (1976) 87. Vandenberg, J. M., and Kinsbron, E., Thin Solid Films, 65:259 (1980) 88. Yoshiie, T., and Bauer, C. L.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 1:554 (1983) 89. Kumar, K., Jpn. J. ,4ppl. Phys., 18:713-716 (1976) 90. Pecz, B., Jaroli, E., Radnoczi, G., Veresegyhazy, R., and Mojzers, I., Phys. Stat. Sol., 94:507 (1986) 91. Bauer, C. L., Surface Sci., 168:395 (1986) 92. Liu, L.-M., and Holloway, P. H., Mat. Res. Soc. Proc., 142:607 (1992) 93. Holloway, P. H., Yeh, L. L-M., Powell, D. H., and Brown, A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59:947 (1991) 94. Lince, J. R., Thomas, C., and Willimas, R. S., J. Mater. Res., 1:537 (1986) 95. Sand, T., Keramidas, V. G., Yu, A. J., Yu, K-M., Gronsky, R., and Washburn, J., J. Mater. Res., 2:262 (1987) 96. Solomon, J. S., and Smith, S. R., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 5:1809 (1987) 97. Ogawa, M., Thin Solid Films, 70:181 (1980) 98. Chen, L. J., and Hsieh, Y. F., Proceedings of the 41st Meeting of the Electron Microscopy Society of America, p. 234, San Francisco (1983) 99. Lahav, A., Eizenberg, M., and Komem, Y., J. Appl. Phys., 60:991 (1986) 100. Sands, T., Keramidas, V. G., Washburn, J., and Gronsky, R., Appl. Phys. Lett., 48:402 (1986) 101. Sands, T., Chang, C. C., Kaplan, A. S., Keramidas, V. G., Krishnan, K. M., and Washburn, J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 50:1346-1348 (1986) 102. Sands, T., and Keramida, V. G., Thin Solid Films, 136:105-122 (1986)
Ohmic Contacts to II-I/I and III-V Compounds
143
103. Sands, T., Chang, C. C., Kaplan, A. S., Keramidas, V. G., Krishnan, K. M., and Washburn, J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 50:1346-1348 (1986) 104. Sands, T., Keramidas, V. G., Washbum, J., and Gronsky, R., Appl. Phys. Lett., 48:402 (1986) 105. Chen, S. H., Carter, C. B., and Palmstrom, C. J., J. Mater. Res., 3:1385 (1988) 106. Guivarc'h, A., Guerin, R., Caulet, J., Poudoulec, A., and Fontenille, J., J. Appl. Phys., 66:2129 (1989) 107. Lin, J.-C, Zheng, X.-Y., Hsieh, K.-C., and Chang, Y. A., Mat. Res. Symp. Proc., 102:233 (1988) 108. Kim, T.-J., Evolution of lnterfacial Phases and Their Effects on Ohmic Contacts to n-GaAs in Ni-Ge-Ti Metallizations, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Florida (1996) 109. Guerin, R., and Guivarc'h, A., J. Appl. Phys., 66:2122 (1989) 110. Sand, T., Keramidas, V. G., Yu, K. M., Washburn, J., and Krishnan, K., J. Appl. Phys., 62:2070(1987) 111. Lin, J.-C., Zheng, X.-Y., Hsieh, K.-C., and Chang, Y. A., Mat. Res. Soc, Symp. Proc., 102:233-236 (1988) 112. Zhao, Y. C., Wu, Z. Q., and Zhang, S. Y., Philosophical Magazine A., 60:63-81 (1989) 113. Kuan, T. S., Freeouf, J. L., Batson, P. E., and Wilkie, E. L., Jr. Appl.Phys., 58:1519-1526 (1985) 114. Cole, M. W., Han, W. Y., Casas, L. M., and Jones, K .A., J. Appl. Phys., 77:5225-5230 (1995) 115. Sands, T., and Keramida, V. G., Thin SoBd Films, 136:105-122 (1986) 116. Lin, J.-C., Hsieh, K.-C., Schulz, K. J., and Chang, Y. A., J. Mater. Res., 3:148-163 (1988) 117. Li, B., and Holloway, P. H., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 9:944-948 (1991) 118. Zheng, X.-Y., Schulz, K. J., Lin, J.-C., and Chang, Y. A., J. the LessCommon Metals, 146:233-239 (1989) 119. Kim, K.-B., and Sinclair, R., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 148:21-27 (1989) 120. Ko, D.-H., and Sinclair, R., J. Appl.Phys., 72:2036-2042 (1992) 121. Che, J. S., Kolawa, E., Nicolet, M.-A., and Ruiz, R. P., J. Appl. Phys., 75:7373-7381 (1994) 122. Kim, T., and Chung, D. D. L., dr. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 4:762 (1986) 123. Iliadis, A., and Singer, K. E., Solid-State Elec., 26:7 (1983) 124. Kulkarni, A. K. and Lukowski, J. T., J. Appl. Phys., 59:2901 (1986) 125. Ilieadis, A.,J. Var Sci. Technol. B, 5:1340 (1987) 126. Wang, L. C., Zhang, B., Gang, F., Marshall, E. D., Lau, S. S., Sands, T., and Kuech, T. F.,J. Mater. Res., 3:922 (1988)
144
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
127. Tsuchimoto, J., Shikata, S., and Hayashi, H., J. Appl. Phys., 69:6556 (1991) 128. Anderson, W. T., Jr., Christou, A,. and Davey, J. E., J. Appl. Phys., 49:2998 (1978) 129. Grinolds, H. R., and Robinson, G. Y., Solid-State Elec., 23:973-985 (1980) 130. Chen, C. L., HoUis, M. A., Mahoney, L. J., Goodhue, W. D., Manfra, M. J., and Murphy, R. A., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 5:902-907 (1987) 131. Marshall, E. D., Chen, W. X., Wu, C. S., Lau, S. S., and Kuech, T. F., Appl. Phys. Lett., 47:298-300 (1985) 132. Marshall, E. D., Zhang, B., Wang, L. C., Jiao, P. F., Chen, W. X., Sawada, T., Lau, S. S., Kavanagh, K. L., and Kuech, T. F., J. Appl. Phys., 62:942 (1987) 133. Kim, T.-J., and Holloway, P. H., unpublished. 134. Palmstrom, C. J., Schwarz, S. A., Yablonovitch, E., Harbison, J. P., Schwartz, C. L., Florez, L. T., Gmitter, T. J., Marshall, E. D., and Lau, S. S., J. Appl. Phys., 67:334 (1990) 135. Sands, T., Marshall, E. D., and Wang, L. C.,J. Mater. Res., 3:914 (1988) 136. Gupta, R. P., and Khokle, S., Solid-State Elec., 28:823 (1985) 137. Christou, A., Solid-State Elec., 22:141 (1979) 138. Marlow, G. S., Das, M. B., and Tongson, L., Solid-State Elec., 26:259 (1983) 139. Robinson, G. Y., Solid-State Elec., 18:331 (1975) 140. Iliadis, A., and Singer, K. E., Solid-State Comm., 49:99 (1984) 141. Relling, E., and Botha, A. P.,Appl. Surf. Sci., 35:380 (1989) 142. Ogawa, M., J. Appl. Phys., 51:406 (1980) 143. Shih, Y.-C., Murakami, M., Wilkie, E. L., and CaUegari, A. C., J. Appl. Phys., 62:582 (1987) 144. Patrick, W., Mackie, W. S., Beaumont, S. P., and Wilkinson, C. D. W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 48:986 (1986) 145. Kovacs, B., Mojes, I., Veresegyhazy, R., Nemeth-Sally, M., and Pecz, B., Vacuum, 40:129 (1990) 146. Buhlmann, H. J., and Llegems, M., J. Electrochem. Soc., 138:2795 (1991) 147. Chua, S.-J., and Lee, S.-H.,Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 33:66 (1994) 148. Wittmer, M., Pretorius, R., Mayer, J. W., and Nicolet, M.-A., Solid-State Elec., 20:433 (1977) 149. Heiblum, M., Nathan, M. I., and Chang, C. A., Solid-State Elec. 25:185 (1982)
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
145
150. Kuan, T. S., Batson, P. E., Jackson, T. N., Rupprecht, H., and Wilkie, E. L., J. Appl. Phys., 54:6952 (1983) 151. Han, W. Y., Lu, Y., Lee, H. S., Cole, M. W., Casas, L. M., DeAnni, A., Jones, K. A., and Yang, L. W., J.Appl.Phys., 74:754-756 (1993) 152. Bruce, R. A., Moore, W. T., Lester, T., Clark, D. A., and Springthorpe, A. J., Paper presented at Microscopy of Semiconducting Materials Conf., p. 671, Oxford (1989) 153. Schilfgaarde, M. V., and Newman, N., Phys. Rev. Lett., 65:2728 (1990) 154. Lampert, W. V, Haas, T. W., and Holloway, P. H., AdvancedMetallization and ProcessingofSemiconductor Devices, p. 941, (A. Katz, Y. I. Nissim, S. P. Murarka, and J. M. E. Harper, eds.) MRS, Pittsburgh, PA (1992) 155. Lampert, W. V., A Study of Aluminum-Germanium-Nickel Ohmic Contact Metallurgical Effects at the Gallium Arsenide Interface, Ph.D dissertation, University of Florida (1992) 156. Lampert, W. V., Haas, T. W., Lambers, E. S., and Holloway, P. H., Semiconductor Heterostructuresfor Photonic and Electronic Applications, pp. 695-700, (D. C. Houghton, C. W. Tu, and R. T. Tung, eds.), MRS Proc., Pittsburgh, PA (1993) 157. Fischer, S., Wetzel, C., Hailer, E. E., and Meyer, B. K., Appl. Phys.Lett., 67:1298-1300 (1995) 158. Kim, T.-J., Holloway, P. H., and Kenik, E. A.,AppL Phys.Lett., submitted. 159. Kim, T-J., and Holloway, P. H., unpublished. 160. Matard, A., Defect electronics in Semiconductor, Ch. 3, Wiley, New York (1971) 161. Ennen, H, Kaufmann, U., and Schneider, J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 38:355 (1981) 162. Hizem, N., Bremond, G., Mayet, L., Gavand, M., Gregoire, J., Guilot, G., and Ulrici, W.,Appl. Surf. Sci., 50:490 (1991) 163. Chang, J. C. P., Otsuka, N., Harmon, E. S., Melloch, M. R., and Woodall, J. M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65:2801 (1994) 164. Walukiewicz, W., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 300:421, San Francisco (1993) 165. Otsuki, T., Aoki, H., and Kano, G., J.,4ppl.Phys., 63:2011-2014 (1988) 166. Jan, C.-H., Swenson, D., and Chang, Y. A., J.Appl.Phys., 68:6458-6462 (1990) 167. Oku, T., Wakimot, H., Otsuki, A., and Murakami, M., J. Appl. Phys., 75:2522(1994) 168. Wang, L. C., Wang, X. Z., Hsu, S. N., Lau, S. S., Lin, P. S. D., Sand, T., Schwarz, A. Z., Plumton, D. L., and Kuech, T. F., dr. Appl. Phys., 69:4364-4372 (1991) 169. Wilson, C., O'Neil, A., Baier, S., and Nohava, J., Mat. Sci. & Eng. B, 29:54 (1995)
146
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
170. Takata, H. J., Tanahashi, K., Otuski, A., Inui, H., and Murakami, M., J. Appl. Phys., 72:4191-4196 (1992) 171. Kawata, H. R., Oku, T., Otsuki, A., and Murakami, M., ,/. Appl. Phys., 75:2530-2537 (1994) 172. Jian, P., Ivey, D. G., Bruce, R., and Knight, G., J. Electro. Mad., 23:953-962 (1994) 173. Kolqwa, E., Nieh, C.-W., Flick, W., Molarius, J., and Nicolet, M-A., Mat. Res. Soc. Proc., 126:289 (1988) 174. Gupta, R., Khokle, W. S., Wuerfl, J., and Hartnagel, H. L., J. Electrochem. Soc., 137:631 (1990) 175. Zuleeg, R., Friebertshauser, P. E., Stephens, J. M., and Watenabe, S. H., IEEE Electron Device Lett., EDL-7:603 (1986) 176. Lin, X. W., Lampert, W. V., Swider, W., Haas, T. W., Holloway, P. H., Washbum, J., and Liliental-Weber, Z., Thin Solid Films, 253:490 (1994) 177. Lin, X., Lampert, W. V., Haas, T. W., Holloway, P. H., Liliental-Weber, Z., Swider, W., and Washburn, J., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 13:2081 (1995) 178. Itho, H., and Ohata, K., IEEE Trans. Elec. Dev., ED-30;811-815 (1983) 179. Del Alamo, J. A., and Mizutani, T., Solid-State Elec., 31:1635-1639 (1988) 180. Katz, A., Handbook of Compound Semiconductors." Growth Processing Characterization and Devices, (P. H. Holloway, and G. E. McGuire, eds.), Noyes Publ., Park Ridge, NJ (1995) 181. Hiraki, A., Shuto, K., Kim, S., Kammura, W., and Iwami, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 31:611 (1977) 182. Piotrowska, A., Auvray, P., Guivarc'h, A., Pelous, G., and Henoc, P., J. Appl. Phys., 52:5112 (1981) 183. Camlibel, I., Chin, A. K., Ermanis, F., DiGiuseppe, M. A., Lourence, J. A., and Bonner, W. A., J. Electrochem. Soc., 129:2585-2590 (1982) 184. Mojzes, I., and Veresegyhazy, R., Thin Solid Films, 144:29 (1986) 185. Fatemi, N. S., and Weizer, V. G., J. Appl. Phys., 65:2111-2115(1989) 186. Fatemi, N. S., and Weizer, V. G., J. Appl. Phys., 67:1934 (1990) 187. Veresegyhazy, R., Pecz, B., Mojzes, I., and Gombos, G., Vacuum, 40:189 (1990) 188. Weizer, V. G. and Fatemi, N. S., J. Appl. Phys., 68:2275-2284 (1990) 189. Wada, O.,J. Appl. Phys., 57:1901 (1985) 190. Barnard, W. O., Malherbe, J. B., Auret, F. D., and Myburg, G., Thin Solid Films, 215:42-49 (1992) 191. Erickson, L. P., Waseem, A., and Robison, G. Y., Thin Solid Films, 64:421-426 (1979)
Ohmic Contacts to II- VI and III- V Compounds
14 7
192. Sands, T., Chang, C. C., Kaplan, A. S., and Keramidas, V. G., Appl. Phys. Lett., 50:1346-1348 (1987) 193. Appelbaum, A, Robbins, M., and Schrey, F., IEEE Trans. Elect. Dev., ED-34:1926-1031 (1987) 194. Stremsdoerfer, G., Wang, Y., Nguyen, D., Clechet, P., and Martin, J. R., J. Electrochem. Soc., 140:2022-2028 (1993) 195. Mohney, S. E., and Chang, Y. A.,J. Appl. Phys., 78:1343 (1995) 196. Persson, L, Bouanani, M. E., Hult, M., Whitlow, H. J, Andersson, M., Bubb, I. F, Johnston, P. N., Walker, S. R., Cohen, D. D., Dytlewski, N., Zaring, C., and Ostling, M., J. Appl. Phys., 80:3346-3354 (1996) 197. Mohney, S. E., and Chang, Y. A.,J. Mater. Res., 7:955-960 (1992) 198. Fatemi, N. S., and Weizer, V. G., J. Appl. Phys., 73:289-295 (1993) 199. Clausen, T., and Leistiko, O., Physica Scripta, T54:68-70 (1994) 200. Caron-Popowich, R., Washburn, J., Sands, T., and Kaplan, A. S., J. Appl. Phys., 64:4909 (1988) 201. Ivey, D. G, Jian, P., and Bruce, R., J. Electro. Matl., 21:831-839 (1992) 202. Stremsdoerfer, G., Calais, C., Martin, J. R., and Clechet, P., J. Electrochem. Sot., 137:835-838 (1990) 203. Suznne, E. M., and Chang, Y. A., Mat. Res. Syrup. Proc., 260:519-524 (1992) 204. Kuphal, E., Solid-State Elec., 24:69-78 (1981) 205. Schwarz, S. A., Palmstrom, C. J., Schwartz, C. L., Sands, T., Shantharama, L. G., Harbison, J. P., Florez, L. T., Marshall, E. D., Han, C. C., Lau, S. S, Allen, L .H., and Mayer, J. W., J. Var Sr Technol. A, 8:2079 (1990) 206. Park, M.-H., Wang, L. C., and Hwang, D. M., J. Electro. Matl., 25:721-725 (1996) 207. Jian, P., Ivey, D. G., Bruce, R., and Knight, G., J. Electro. Matl., 23:953-962 (1994) 208. Ivey, D. G., Bruce, R., and Piercy, G. R., J. Electro. Matl., 17:373-380 (1988) 209. Clausen, T., Leistiko, O., Chorkendorff, I., and Larsen, J. Appl. Surf Sr 74:287-295 (1994) 210. Mojes, I., Veresegyhazy, R., Kovacs, B., and Pecz, B., Thin Solid Films, 164:1-4(1988) 211. Fatemi, N. S., and Weizer, V. G.,Mat. Res. Sor Symp. Proc., 318:171-176 (1994) 212. Ivey, D. G., Wang, D, Yang, D., Bruce, R., and Knight, G., J. Electro. Matl., 23:441-446 (1994)
148
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
213. Bahir, G., Merz, J. L., Abelson, J. R., and Sigmon, T. W., J. Electro. Mad., 16:257-262 (1987) 214. Morais, J., Fazan, T. A., Landers, R., and Sato, E. A. S., J. Appl. Phys., 79:7058-7061 (1996) 215. Fatemi, N. S., and Weizer, V. G., Mat. Res. Soc. Syrup. Proc., 260:537-542 (1992) 216. Miller, S., and Holloway, P. H., J. Elect. Mad., in press (1996) 217. Durbha, A., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Lee, J. W., and Holloway, P. H., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 14:2582 (1996) 218. Foresi, J. S., and Moustakas, T. D., Appl. Phys. Lett., 62:2859-2861 (1993) 219. Guo, J. D., Feng, M. S., Guo, R. J., Pan, F. M., and Chang, C. Y., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67:2657 (1995) 220. Wang, L., Nathan, M. I., Lam, T. H., Khan, M. A., and Chen, Q., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68:1267 (1996) 221. Ishikawa, H., Kobayashi, S., Koide, Y., Yamasaki, S., Nagai, S., Umezaki, J., Koike, M., and Murakami, M., J. Appl. Phys., 81" 1315-1322 (1997) 222. Fan, Z., Mohammad, S. N., Kim, W., Aktas, O., Botchkarev, A. E., and Morkoc, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68" 1672-1674 (1996) 223. Lin, M. E., Ma, Z., Huang, F. Y., Fan, Z. F., Allen, L. H., and Morkoc, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:1003-1005 (1994) 224. Luther, B. P., Mohney, S. E., Jackson, T. N., Khan, M. A., Chen, Q., and Yang, J. W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 15"57 (1997) 225. Ping, A. T., Khan, M. A., and Adesida, I., J. Electro. Mad., 25:819 (1996) 226. Jenkins, D. W. and Dow, J. D., Phys. Rev. B, 39:3317 (1989) 227. Zopler, J. C., Rieger, D. J., Baca, A. G., Pearton, S. J., Lee, J. W., and Stall, R. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:538 (1996) 228. Lester, L. F., Brown, J. M., Ramer, J. C., Zhang, L., Hersee, S. D., and Zolper, J. C., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68:539 (1996) 229. Cole, M. W., Eckart, D. W., Han, W. Y., Pfeffer, R. L., Monahan, T., Ren, F., Yuan, C., Stall, R. A., Pearton, S. J., Li, Y., and Lu, Y., J. Appl. Phys., 80:278 (1996) 230. Rinari, S. C., Rowland, L. B., Kruppa, W., Kelner, G., Doverspike, K., and Gaskill, D. K., Electron. Lett., 30:1248 (1994) 231. Ruvimov, S., Liliental-Weber, Z., Washburn, J., Duxstad, K. J., Haller, E. E., Fan, Z.-F., Moharmned, S. N., Kim, W., Botchkarev, A. E., and Morkoc, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69" 1556 (1996)
Ohmic Contacts to II- I/I and III- V C o m p o u n d s
149
232. Smith, L. L., Bremser, M. D., Carlson, E. P., Weeks, T. W., Huang, Y., Kim, M. J., Carpenter, R. W., and Davis, R. W., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 395:861 (1996) 233. Ingerly, D. B., Chang, Y. A., Perkins, N. R., and Kuech, T. F., Appl. Phys. Lett., 70:108 (1997) 234. Nakamura, S., Mukai, T., and Seno, M., Jpn. 3. Appl. Phys., 30:L1998 (1991) 235. Nakamura, S., Mokia, T., and Seno, M.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 62:1786 (1996) 236. Sakai, H., Koide, T., Suzaki, H., Yamaguchi, M., Yamasaki, S., Koike, M., Amano, H., and Aksaki, I., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 34:L1429 (1995) 237. Kuga, Y., Shirai, T., Haruyama, M., Kawanishi, H., and Suematsu, Y., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 34:4085 (1995) 238. Golderberg, B., Zook, J. D., and Ulmer, R. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 62:381 (1993) 239. Trexler, J. T., Electrical Contacts to p-Type Zinc Telluride and Gallium Nitride, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Florida (1997) 240. Trexler, J. T., Miller, S. J., Holloway, P. H., and Khan, M. A., GaN and Related Materials, (R. D. Dupuis, J. A. Edmond, F. A. Ponce, and S. Nakamura, eds.) 395:819, MRS, Pittsburgh (1996) 241. Abernathy, C. R., MacKenzie, J. D., Pearton, S. J., and Hobson, W. S., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:1969 (1995) 242. Xu, F., Vos, M., Waver, H., and Cheng, H., Phys. Rev. B, 38:13418 (1988) 243. Chen, W., Khan, A., Soukiassian, P., Mangat, P. S., Gaines, J., Ponzon, C., and Olego, D.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 12:2639 (1994) 244. Holloway, P. H., Kim, T.-J., Trexler, J. T., Miller, S., Fijol, J. J., Lampert, W. V., and Haas, T. W.,Appl. Surf. Sci., 117/118:362 (1997) 245. Fijol, J. J., and Holloway, P. H., Crit. Rev. Sol. St. Matl. Sci., 21:77 (1996) 246. Holloway, P. H., Fijol, J. J., Park, R. M., Calhoun, L. C., Jones, K. S., Simmons, J. H., Zory, P., and Anderson, T. J., Proc. Twenty First Stateof-the-Art Prog. Compound Semiconductors (SOTAPOCS XXI), 94-34:2 (S. N. G. Chu, F. Ren, V. Malhotra, and D. P. Van, eds.), The Electrochemical Society, Pennington, NJ (1995) 247. Wang, Y.-X., and Holloway, P. H., Vacuum, 43:1149 (1992) 248. Liu, L.-M., Lindauer, G., Alexander, W. B., and Holloway, P. H., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 13:2238 (1995) 249. Fijol, J. J., Calhoun, L. C., Park, R. M., and Holloway, P. H., Jr. Electron. Matl., 24:143 (1995)
150
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
250. Fijol, J. J., Trexler, J. T., Calhoun, L., Park, R. M., and Holloway, P. H., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 14:159 (1996) 251. Akimoto, K., Miyajima, T., and Mori, u J. Crystal Growth, 115:683 (1991) 252. Park, R. M., and Calhoun, L., Phys. Today, (1996) 253. Fan, Y., Han, J., He, L., Saraie, J., Gunshor, R., Hagerott, M., Jeon, J., Nurmikko, A., Hua, G., and Otsuka, N., Appl. Phys. Lett., 61:360 (1992) 254. Fan, T., Han, J., He, L., Saraie, J., Gunshor, R., Hagerott, M., Jeon, H., Nurmikko, A., Hua, G., and Otsuka, N., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 11:1748 (1993) 255. Hiei, F., Ikeda, M., Ozawa, M., Miyajima, T., Ishibashi, A., and Akimoto, K., Electro. Lett., 29:878 (1993) 256. Trexler, J. T., Fijol, J. J, Calhoun, L. C., Park, R. M., and Holloway, P. H., J. Cryst. Growth, 159:723 (1996) 257. Trexler, J. T., Fijol, J. J, Calhoun, L. C., Park, R. M., and Holloway, P. H., J. Electron. Matl., 25:1474 (1996) 258. Kim, D.-W., Kwak, J. S., Park, H.-S., Kim, H. N., Lee, S.-M., Sim, C.-S., Noh, S.-K., and Baik, H. K., J. Electron. Matl., 26:83 (1997) 259. Kim, D.-W., Kim, H.-S., Kwak, J. S., and Baik, H. K., unpublished (1997) 260. Mochizuki, K., Jerano, A., Momose, M., Taike, A., Kawata, M., Gotoh, J., and Nakatsuka, S., J. Appl. Phys., 78:3216 (1995) 261. Ohtsuka, T., Yoshimura, M., Morita, K., Koyama, M., and Yao, T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67:1277 (1995) 262. Ozawa, M., Hiei, F., Takasu, M., Isibashi, A., and Akimoto, K., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:1120 (1994) 263. Lansari, Y., Ren, J., Sneed, B., Bowers, K., Cook, J., and Schetzina, J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 61:2554 (1992) 264. Lansari, Y., Cook, J., and Schetzina, J., J. Elect. Matl., 22:809 (1993) 265. Fijol, J. J., Trexler, J. T., Calhoun, L., Park, R. M., and Holloway, P. H., J. Vac. Sci. Technol., 14:159 (1996) 266. Kim, J. R., and Jones, K. S., Crit. Rev. Sol. St. Matl. Sci., 21:1 (1996)
4 D r y E t c h i n g of SiC Joseph R. Flemish
1.0
INTRODUCTION
As the quality of semiconducting silicon carbide improves, there have been continued efforts toward developing commercially viable electronic components from this wide-bandgap semiconductor with a particular focus on high-temperature power-switching applications. The two SiC polytypes which have received the greatest attention for power devices are 6H and 4H. Much of the work in SiC devices in the late 1980's and early 1990' s employed the 6H polytype owing to the development and commercial availability of single-crystal wafers of sizes greater than one inch in diameter. More recently, the 4H polytype has displaced 6H for electronic device fabrication due to its superior electron mobility combined with advances in 4H-SiC boule and epilayer growth. Realization of advanced device structures fabricated from SiC require the ability to etch this material smoothly, controllably, and with a minimal amount of damage to the underlying material. Methods for dry etching SiC are necessitated by the lack of wet etching techniques which are compatible with SiC device fabrication schemes. The majority of reports on SiC etching have utilized traditional reactive ion etch (RIE) reactors in conjunction with fluorinated gas mixtures. Compared to other plasma etching methods, RIE exploits the dc self-bias which 151
152
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
develops on the substrate to assist in the sputter removal of volatile etch products. However, high levels of bias lead to a greater degree of etch damage caused by energetic ion bombardment. For a given plasma density, the ion bombardment energy can be reduced in several ways. For example, plasmas in RIE reactors can be magnetically enhanced so that the process can be run at a lower pressure with high etch rates and with lower self-bias developing on the substrate, resulting in less ion-damage. Alternative reactor configurations which de-couple the sample bias from the plasma power have attracted attention in recent years for both etching and deposition processes. Examples of these methods include the use of electron cyclotron resonance (ECR) and inductively-coupled plasmas. This chapter discusses the applications of etching in SiC device fabrication, the chemistry of plasma-assisted SiC etching, and presents most of the published results to date on dry etching of SiC.
2.0
R E Q U I R E M E N T S O F D R Y E T C H I N G IN SiC DEVICE FABRICATION
The difficulty associated with selective-area doping of SiC has forced many device fabrication schemes to rely on the blanket epitaxial growth of doped layers and their selective removal by dry etching methods. As a result, some common needs for dry etching during SiC device fabrication include: mesa isolation, gate recess etching for planar FETs, channel etching for vertical FETs, and making ohmic contacts to buried layers. To illustrate these applications, Fig. 1 shows cross sectional schematics of several types of SiC power switches and amplifiers which have either been fabricated or proposed. For high voltage applications (>1 kV), bipolar devices such as thyristors have much lower on resistances than unipolar devices. Thyristors with structures as shown in Fig. 1a have been fabricated from both 6H and 4H SiC.Ill[2] In order to achieve low onresistances, the most successful devices have utilized heavily doped n-type substrates with a stack of n-p-n-p+ epitaxial layers. In the o f f state, the voltage blocking capability of the device depends largely on the quality, thickness, and doping density of the middle epilayers. In order to switch the device to its on state, current must be injected through an ohmic contact into one of the buried layers. Therefore, fabrication of a SiC thyristor requires two etching steps which must be carefully controlled: a deep (> 5-10 micron)
Dry Etching of SiC 153 etch for electrically isolating the device; and a shallow etch for recessing down to contact the buried n-type layer. The demands placed on the two etching steps are different. The first requires a rapid process with high etch selectivity for SiC relative to the masking material. The second requires that the etch rate be controllable so that the resulting surface is smooth and free of residues.
OHMIC GATE
OHMIC GATE
t ~
,,c,=r "c" I. METSA f
ANODE ~
/ SOURCE
l
n
lyl:~
SCHOTTKY GATE
DRAIN
I
n" channel p " buffer
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
n - SiC substrate
CATHODE
(a) Thyristor
(b) MESFET
SOURCE i
SCHOTrKY
l:.:.-.-:.----:.:--:.:-.:--' ........... ~ ......... ~ SGHOTTKY --:-:-:-:-:.:.:.:-,
....
o.
/GATE
n" drift ration ff
SOURCE
~
SiC subslrato
SOURCE
i~ r
Jl n"
n+
MOS GATE
+-++
J-Pi-- i._. '
drift region
n+ SiC substrato
I:-:_-.:_--'._=."..=:: '_::::-_-" . _ : : - ~ : ~ ~..'_;:(:_=:- ~."_-:;_ :-~.._:.'-:_::!
DRAIN
(c) Static Induction Transistor
DRAIN (d) UMOSFET
Figure 1. Schematics of SiC power switching devices (a) thyristor, (b) MESFET, (c) static induction transistor, and (d) UMOSFET.
154
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
High frequency unipolar devices which have been fabricated from SiC include planar MESFETs and vertical static induction transistors.[ 3]In the fabrication of both of these devices, a Schottky contact is formed on a buried n-type layer which is exposed by dry etching through an upper n § source/drain layer. In this case, the ideal etch process must impart minimal damage to the underlying material so that a high quality Schottky barrier can be formed. Another advanced structure which places perhaps the highest demands on the dry etching process is vertical MOSFET devices (UMOSFETs) which have been demonstrated.[ 11 In these devices, the active channel of the MOSFET is formed on the sidewall of an etched trench so that the requirement of smooth, damage-free, residue-free etching is again particularly critical. Additionally, sharp comers at the base of sidewall features, which can result from anisotropic etching, must be minimized in order to avoid premature gate breakdown. This breakdown can occur due to the electric field enhancement which arises at sharp edges. Therefore, for trench-based MOS devices, an ideal etch would also yield a tapered transition between the etch sidewall and trench bottom. Future SiC power devices which are envisioned include MOS-controlled thyristors and insulated gate bipolar transistors (IGBTs), which are analogous to their Si-based counterparts.[ 4] Most of the viable options for these devices will require the integration of vertical UMOSFET switching elements with thyristor-type structures. In order to realize these next-generation devices, very high demands will be placed on the dry etching processes used in their fabrication.
3.0
CHEMISTRY OF SiC DRY ETCHING
Glow discharges or plasma have been used extensively over the last several decades to promote chemical reactions between gas-phase species and solid-phase materials. Most dry etch processes employ halogenated gas mixtures in order to form volatile products upon reaction with the material being etched. Fluorinated gas mixtures have been found to be quite effective for etching SiC, as they also have for etching Si, SiO 2, SiN x, and silicides of Ta, Ti, and W. Common commercially available gaseous or liquefied sources for fluorine include CHF3, CF4, C2F6, SF6, and NF 3. Most of these sources are nonflammable and relatively harmless; with the exception of NF3, which although highly toxic is often employed due to its efficiency in generating highly reactive species. The chemistry of etching
Dry Etching of SiC 155 Si, SiO2, and SiN x in fluorinated plasmas has been extensively studied and modeled with perhaps the greatest emphasis on CF4/O 2 mixtures. Consequently, much insight can be gained into the chemistry of SiC etching from these results.J5]-[ 14]However, the study of plasma chemistry can be complicated by the presence of many short-lived radical and other excited species which can rapidly react or recombine. For example, when silicon is etched in a fluorine plasma, the only downstream product which can be detected is SiF 4. However, spectroscopic results and thermodynamic arguments suggest that F atoms are the primary reactant and that SiF2 is the initial reaction product. Studies using optical emission spectroscopy have shown that the radicals CF3, CF2, CF, and F all exist in CF 4 plasmas. Various gas additives can have profound effects on etch behavior. The addition of oxygen to a C F 4 plasma reduces the concentration of CF and CF 2 (due to their reactions with oxygen to form CO and CO2).[15][161 Oxidation ofCF x radicals prevents their recombination with F radicals and, consequently, the F-atom concentration increases along with the rate of etching for silicon compounds. As more O 2 is subsequently added, the etch rate eventually reaches a maximum and then decreases, due to the eventual dilution of F by 0 2 and also to strong competition for adsorption sites on the surface from O-atoms. As a consequence of such site-competition among adsorbates, the maximum in the etch rates for Si and SiO 2 films does not always correspond to a maximum in the F-atom concentration. In contrast, the addition of H 2 to the gas mixture can have an effect opposite to that of 0 2. In this case, H radicals can combine with atomic F to form HF. This addition will lower the etch rate of Si, and has been used successfully to increase the selectivity of etching SiO 2 o v e r Si. [17] The etching characteristics of silicon carbide follow trends similar to those of Si, as both CF x and SiF x products can form by reaction ofF with SiC. This reaction can proceed without bias applied to the substrate indicating that SiC is etched chemically by F radicals and does not require the assistance of energetic ions. However, application of a negative bias to the substrate dramatically increases the etching rate as ion bombardment enhances the reaction and subsequent removal of volatile products. Gas additives can also have important effects. For example, the addition of O 2 can enhance the etch rate of SiC just as it does for other Si-containing materials. In this case, 0 2 not only enhances the atomic fluorine concentration but can also participate directly in the etching by reacting with carbon to form volatile CO and CO 2. In some cases, the addition of O 2 can have deleterious effects for SiC etching. It has been known most notoriously to
156
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
enhance micromasking effects.[ is] These effects arise because most commercial plasma chambers use electrodes and other chamber components made of aluminum which can sputter and redeposit on the SiC surface. Oxidation of these A1 deposits decreases their volatility and results in dispersed microscopic regions of contaminants which unevenly mask the underlying SiC. Conversely, the addition of H 2 to the gas mixture can suppress micromasking effects as will be discussed in See. 4.2. Chlorine-containing gas mixtures can also be used for effectively etching many silicon compounds. However, their use for SiC compounds has not been extensively reported. Recently, McDaniel et al.[191 compared etching of SiC using C12, IBr, SF6, and NF 3 with additions ofAr, H2, o r 0 2. In contrast to employing F-containing gas mixtures, the use of C12 or IBr exhibits a threshold level of de self-bias on the substrate, below which no etching occurs. In this case, the reaction and removal of etch products needs to be induced by ion-bombardment because of the lower volatility of the heavier halides of silicon and carbon. Nevertheless, high etch rates with smooth resulting surfaces have been obtained from C12 and IBr chemistries.
4.0
METHODS FOR PLASMA-ASSISTED E T C H I N G O F SiC
4.1
Plasma Etching
The term "plasma etching" most often refers to plasma-assisted etching which occurs at relatively high pressures (e.g., > 10-1 torr) with the sample sitting on the grounded electrode of a parallel plate reactor of the type depicted in Fig. 2. [16] This type of reactor is most common among commercially available systems owing to its success in silicon device processing. Alternatively, plasma etching may also be performed in a barrel reactor or downstream from a plasma source where the plasma is generated inductively using rfpower or in a microwave cavity. Typically, in the case of plasma etching, only a small sheath potential (10-20 eV) develops on the sample and thus the energy of bombarding ions is relatively low. Therefore, plasma etching processes of this type can be relatively gentle to the underlying semiconductor and tend to be largely isotropic in nature.
Dry Etching of SiC 157
(
o.
TUN.NONE WO.K I
GROUND
........
JL ?:"......... "!"::..................... :::":........... :~:i i r
_~
PLASMA
....... [i,
7
!i . . . ~
ISUBSTRATE I
lil !
TO
Ill........... PUMPS
uB r.AT
I li] //
RF1
oR " - ~ , , ~
GROUND
~
I
TUNINGNETWORK
..
I
I
Figure 2. Schematic of rf powered parallel plate reactor for use in plasma etching or RIE.
Early studies showed that sputter-deposited amorphous SiC films could be etched at reasonable rates in plasmas using fluorine-containing gas mixtures; and that A1 or Cr films could be used as masking materials with a high degree of selectivity.[ TMIn 1985, Dohmae et al.[21] reported plasma etching of ~SiC using C F 4 and 0 2 at pressures of 0.2 to 2.0 torr. The samples were placed on the grounded electrode in a parallel plate reactor powered at 13.56 MHz. These studies, performed at a pressure of 0.6 torr and rfpower density of 0.50 W/cm 2, showed that a gas composition of 70% 0 2 yielded the highest etching rate (17 nm/min). Moreover, the etch rate was found to be proportional to the power density and to decrease sharply with increasing pressure. The morphologies of the etched surfaces were not reported by these authors. In 1987, Kelner et al.,[ 12]using a similar configuration, reported etch rates of 24 nm/min for ~SiC using SF 6 at 0.2 torr and a power density of0.18 W/cm 2 (indicating that SF 6 was more effective than CF 4 alone for etching SIC). In this study, the etching rate also increased linearly with power density. However, extremely rough surface morphologies resulted from these conditions due to micro-masking effects. In a similar study in 1986, Palmour et al.[ 231 used C F 4 and 0 2 at pressures ranging from 0.5 to 2.0 torr with an rf power density at 30 kHz ranging from 0.081 to 0.326 W/cm 2. They reported that etch rates were in the range of 1-55 nm/min, but that the rates were inconsistent and dark surface layers
158
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
of 20-150 nm thick formed on the SiC surface. Little other work on traditional plasma etching has been reported for SiC. In a less traditional manner, plasma etching of 6H-SiC was reported by Luther et al.[ 24] using remote microwave (2.54 GHz) plasma. In their remote-plasma arrangement, the SiC was placed in a resistance heated furnace, downstream from the microwave cavity. The plasma was generated at a power of 400 W and pressure of 1 torr from a mixture containing 95% Ar with various ratios of NF 3 and 0 2. The etching was described as being smooth and nearly isotropic with sloping sidewalls extending deep underneath the A1 masking layer. The etch rate was found to have a strong dependence on both temperature and the ratio of NF 3 to 0 2, being a maximum of 220 nm/min in a 82% O2/NF3 mixture and a temperature of 325-330~ This rate was approximately ten times greater than those that had been previously reported for rf-plasmas.
4.2
Reactive Ion Etching
The vast majority of reports on SiC etching have utilized the conventional RIE method using rf (13.56 MHz) power in a parallel-plate reactor of the type shown previously in Fig. 2. In contrast to plasma etching, in an RIE process, the electrode on which the substrate is placed is not grounded, but instead is used to supply the rfpower to the plasma. In this case, a large negative dc self-bias develops on the sample. This de bias attracts ions from the plasma which assist the etching process through enhanced formation and sputter-removal of volatile products. This process is sometimes descriptively referred to as "reactive sputter etching" in some of the older literature. Self-bias potentials of hundreds of volts, potentially damaging to the underlying material, are typical for RIE processes. RIE of [3-SIC using CF4/O 2 mixtures was reported by Palmour et. al.[ TMThe etch rate was found to be a maximum of approximately 20-24 nm/min in the pressure range of 20-50 mtorr and at a power density of 0.55 W/cm 2. At pressures above this range, the rate decreased sharply due in part to a reduction in the dc self-bias. At pressures below this range, the rate decreased sharply due to the decrease in the density of reactive species in the plasma. In contrast to previous studies, the etch rate was not significantly affected by the addition of up to 50% 02 to the gas mixture. However, similarly to previous studies, extremely rough surfaces resulted with features described as "sharp columns" and "spikes."
Dry Etching of SiC 159 In 1990, Pan and Steckl[ 2s] compared the etching behavior of SiO2, Si, and polycrystalline I3-SiC in SF6/O2, CHF3/O2, and CBrF3/O2 plasmas at a power density of 0.46 W/cm 2, pressure of 20 mtorr, and gas-flow of 20 seem. Using optical emission spectroscopy, they measured the relative concentrations o f F and O radicals as a function of oxygen addition and detected both CF x and CO x products as shown in Fig. 3. It was found that the de selfbias increased from-285V to -400V as 0 2 was added, and that the highest etch rate of 53.3 nm/min occurred using SF 6 with 35% 0 2. The maximum rate corresponded to the F radical concentration reaching a maximum value. The etched profiles were found to be more tapered using CBrF3/O 2 and to be more anisotropic using either SF6/O 2 or CHF3/O 2. In this study, rough etched surfaces were also observed. Under most of their conditions, etching of SiO 2 was slightly faster than SiC, although a slight selectivity of 3:2 for SiC o v e r SiO 2 could be obtained using the CBrF3/O 2 mixture.
50
500
.....a,_,
_
[F]
.._
:~ m
4o
>~" 400
n0
300
-~m" un I n " "
m
,-O 200
(3' o"O" I
20
--"O
.. ,,..~~ -
[o]
30
%" m~
20
go
10
I
I
I
40
60
80
0
m
z
Co -4
-<
PERCENTAGE OF 0 2 Figure 3. Change in dc self-bias and relative concentrations of F and O with oxygen addition.t2s] A comparison of the RIE etch rates of amorphous, polycrystalline 13SiC, and single-crystal (100) 13-SICin CF4/O 2 has been reported by Padiyath et al.[ 261and is shown in Fig. 4. The etch rate ofpolycrystalline material was found to be much higher than for single-crystal films. This effect was attributed to the large number of high-energy sites associated with dangling
160
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
bonds at grain boundaries. Moreover, amorphous films which are known to contain significant amounts of hydrogen etched far more rapidly than the crystalline films. This study illustrated the dependence of the etch rate on the degree of crystallinity, but left unanswered the question of whether the etching behavior is different for different polytypes of SiC or for different crystallographic faces of a given polytype. Although no micrographs of the etched materials were presented, the investigators reported that the microroughness of the etched films decreased with increasing crystallinity.
"E" 120 / "~~~ a-SiC'H E E (-. 80 _ poly 13-SiC U.I I-CE -r- 40 g..-o -si -o-o..o\ O I--uJ i
. ,,...
0
\
I
I
I
I
20
40
60
80
"o
PERCENTAGE OF 0 2 Figure 4. Etch rate comparison of amorphous SiC, poly 13-SICand single-crystal ~-SiC. [26]
Significantly, in 1992 Steckl and Yih [18] reported that the micromasking effect which led to rough etched surfaces could be eliminated by adding H 2 to the gas mixture (for RIE processes using CHF3/O2 chemistry). This effect (produced using 18% 0 2 in CF4) is illustrated in Fig. 5 which shows the resulting surfaces without H 2 and with the addition of 17% H2.[27] Using Auger electron spectroscopy, A1 was detected on the rough surfaces which had been etched without the H 2 additive, and was not detected on the smooth surfaces etched in the presence of H 2. This study ascertained that A1 can be sputtered from the rf electrode and redeposited on the SiC surfaces. These A1 residues then coalesce and form micro-clusters
Dry Etching of SiC 161 which mask the subsequent etching of the underlying SiC. The mieromasking effects of A1 are made worse when 0 2 is added to the gas mixture, owing to the strong tendency of A1 for oxidation and the extremely non-volatile nature of aluminum oxide. Unfortunately, many commercial RIE systems utilize electrodes which are constructed of A1 and the addition of H 2 dramatically reduces the etch rate. Moreover, it has been shown that the atomic H generated in H 2 plasmas can significantly passivate the aceeptors in p-type SIC.[ 19]
[ J
Figure 5. Etching of 6H-SiC by RIE with CF4/I 8% 0 2 (a) without H2, and (b) with H2.[27|
162
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
In subsequent papers, Yih and Steckl evaluated a variety of gas mixtures for etching (001) [3-SIC and compared the etching behavior and the tendency of residue formation.[28]-[ 29] They later extended this study to include single-crystal (0001) 6H-SiC.[ 3~ Upon the addition of H 2, A1Hx species were detected in the plasma by optical emission spectroscopy, leading to the speculation that the redeposition of sputtered A1 was thus prevented by the formation of volatile A1 compounds. The data of Yih and Steckl on 6H-SiC are shown in Fig. 6 for cases of no H 2 added and with the minimum amount needed to suppress residue formation. Here, the relative reactivity of these gases and the degree to which 0 2 and H 2 addition affects the etch rates are illustrated. Without either additive, the reactivity of the gases varied as NF 3 > SF 6 > CF 4 > CHF 3. When the minimal amount ofH 2 was added, the reactivity of the two fluorocarbon gases became comparable, as did the reactivities of the SF 6 and NF 3 plasmas. Moreover, when H 2 was added, the maxima in the etch rates corresponded to mixtures containing approximately 10% 0 2 in each case. It was also reported that the micro-masking effect can be eliminated with the use of a graphite sheet covering the powered electrode.[ 3~ However, side effects which have been reported include polymeric deposition and flaking within the reactor, contamination of the pumping equipment, and mass-loading effects. Casady et al. [31l showed that RIE using N F 3 at the relatively higher pressure of 150-350 mtorr can result in high etch rates and residue-free surfaces without the use ofH 2 or O 2 additives. They reported etch rates of approximately 150 nm/min at an rfpower density of 1.7 W/cm 2 and a pressure of 225 mtorr. At these higher pressures, the corresponding de biases were reported to be in the range of only -25 t o - 5 0 V, suggesting that these conditions may be advantageous for recessing down to active regions of SiC devices. When comparing studies reported in the literature, it appears that, under most conditions, [3-SIC films etched approximately 20-50% faster than 6H-SiC, although accurate experimental comparisons have not been made. It could be speculated that the differences in the etch rates are due more to differences in the dangling bond densities and the corresponding reactivities of the crystal faces, than to the different crystal structures. For example, each atom on a cubic (001) face has two dangling bonds; whereas only one dangling bond exists on a (111) face or similarly on the (0001) face of hexagonal SiC. RIE of (111) I3-SiC films has been reported by Wu et al.,[ 32] albeit under conditions where a direct comparison with reports on (001) oriented films cannot be readily made.
Dry Etching of SiC 163
60
'
_'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
0
'
.
.
.
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
50~ E 40,
"'.~
3o
""
'E
..'.<
...........
i '"
cF,,
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
H2 ADDED
_
.....
-
40 ..............
......
....
30 20
-r 20 O !-. m 10
0' 0
'
- :
....
10 "'~CHE ............A..... """ ~,~ 100 20 40 60 80 PERCENT OXYGEN ADDED
0
,
0
(a)
.
,
I
20
=
.
,
I
,
,
40
.
I
60
,
=
,
I
,
.
80
_
.
100
PERCENT OXYGEN ADDED
(b)
Figure 6. 6H-SiC etch rates using (a) various fluorine-containing mixtures and (b) mixtures with the minimum amount of H E needed to suppress micromasking.[ 3~
4.3
Magnetron Ion Etching of SiC
In a RIE reactor, the plasma density can be enhanced and the corresponding dc self-bias reduced with the proper application of magnetic fields (as illustrated in Fig. 7). This method is oiten termed magnetron ion etching (MIE) or magnetic field-enhanced RIE (MERIE). In this configuration, the permanent magnets confine the electrons in the plasma, thereby increasing the ionization cross section.[331The MIE system can then sustain relatively denser discharges with lower ion energies (dc self-bias), and do so at pressures down to approximately 1 mtorr. Importantly, lower ion energy leads to a correspondingly lower degree of damage induced by ion bombardment. The MIE technique has been used to etch single-crystal (0001) 4H-SiC, u s i n g S F 6 both with and without the addition of 0 2 and H2 .[34] In these experiments, when the samples were mounted on an A1203-coated, rfpowered (13.56 MHz) electrode, problematic A1 micro-masking effects occurred (despite the addition of H 2 to the gas mixture). This effect was eliminated by covering the electrode with a Si wafer coated with indiumtin oxide (ITO). Figure 8a shows the MIE etch rate and dc self-bias as a function of rf power density at a pressure of 2 mtorr and flow of 5 sccm SF 6. Significantly, for a given power density, the etching rate was more
164
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
than an order of magnitude greater than for the corresponding RIE process, and the dc self-bias was nearly four times lower. At the moderate power density of 0.5 W/cm 2 and self-bias of- 100 V, the observed etch rate of 450 nm/ min was among the highest reported to date. The rate was found to be relatively independent of the addition of oxygen up to 20% 0 2, but decreased sharply with further additions (as shown in Fig. 8b). The rate was fastest at pressures in the range of 2-4 mtorr (Fig 8c). In this case, the dc self-bias was not significantly affected by variations in pressure, and ranged from 75-80 V. The etch rate increased slightly with a gas flow rate of up to 10 sccm, indicating that the supply of SF 6 can be rate-limiting. The anisotropic nature of this process is illustrated in Fig. 8d which shows deep (2 I~m) trenches etched using a sputtered ITO mask.
QUADRUPOLE MAGNET CONFIGURATION
9
: . . .
.
.
. .
.
.
.
.
.
..
(,( (,Elk.,, CHAMBER ToP
i')))
,,._
~
i ~
~ ~
: ,i.l.l,l,.
iq.l.l.i
ii.1.1,,
i,.i.i~
.l.l.m-
..1=1.~
,.11.1,,~ , l . l . l . l l
,ll, l,l.
,i.1.1,i. ,i=1.1~
~.1,,~
~.ii.i
1,,i.i~
:1 MAGNETIC FIELD LINES
~.I.I=t-
INTERNAL MAGNETS , .,~.,~
,,~.w.~
~.m.,.
,,,.,,,~...i.~.
p~.~
,.,'I"M
~,,'~
~'.'~"P
RF TO CATHODE
"
,,-~.~
.,-~"~
,~.!,.~
POLE PIECES
Figure 7. Arrangement of magnets and cathode in MIE reactor.
Dry Etching of SiC 165
500 ._r
9' '
"I"
'"'I"
"'
"
I
'
/
'
''
'
120
350
tO0
400
E
8O
"~ 3oo C LU ,< 200 n-r" O 100 I--iii
40
m
300 E ~250
~,,
iii I-< rr 200
03
"1-
C3 0
20-.~ i &, ii,
0
i i . I ....
0
I,,,,l,,,,l
0.2
....
0.4
LU
'' ''
I''''1'
I,1,,I
....
....
0
10
P O W E R D E N S I T Y ( W / c m 2)
(a) 450
r.... i ....
,'•,, ,, . . . .
"''1
'''
"i''''1"'
"
150 100
0.6
I''''
I.,,11.,,,1,,,,1,,1,
20 30 40 50 60 PERCENT 0 2 ADDED
70
(b) ,"" ' ', ' "-"
E:
rE
400
E
ua :350 F-
< n-
-r 300
O I-u.l
250
J i l . l / i | * l ,
0
1
,1
, l , l , | i l l . ' l l '
2 3 PRESSURE
4 5 (mTORR)
'|
6
(c) Figure 8. M I E etch rate as a function of (a) power density and (d) micrograph of trenched etched in 4 H - S i C .
4.4
(d) (b) oxygen addition (c) pressure
Electron Cyclotron Resonance Plasmas
An excellent review of the principles of ECR and various reactor configurations has been presented by Asmussen.[ 351 Important advantages of ECR relative to RIE are: the sample can be biased independent of the plasma power by applying rf power to the substrate holder; and a high density discharge can be generated at lower pressures and done so in an electrode-less manner. Plasma etching of SiC in an ECR reactor has been shown to result in smoothly etched surfaces without the formation of micro-masking residues.[361 These studies employed a reactor which used a multipolar ECR source consisting of six permanent magnets surrounding a six inch diameter microwave (2.45 GHz) cavity constructed of an aluminum
166
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
alloy (shown schematically in Fig. 9). The sample sat approximately 8 cm below the bottom of the ECR source on an electrode which could be rfpowered (13.56 Mz) to provide a desired value of dc bias. A 50 sccm 18% O2/CF 4 mixture at 1-2 mtorr was used to investigate the etching behavior of (0001) Si-face, 6H-and 4H-SiC. It was found that for ECR etching, ITO masks endured far better, offered greater selectivity, and adhered better to the SiC than A1, Ni, or Cr masks. As shown in Fig. 10a, the etch rate increased linearly with microwave power and nearly so with applied substrate bias (Fig. 10b). Increasing pressure had a strong effect on decreasing the rate, (Fig. 10c) due to the reduced efficiency of the ECR coupling and the reduced gas-phase mean-free-path. The rate of etching was also affected by the proximity of the sample to the plasma source, increasing by a factor of three as the distance decreased from 8 to 1 cm (Fig. 10d). No significant differences in ECR etch rates had been found for 6H versus 4H polytypes or for different doping types.
TUNERS.---.~
p-wave 2.54 GHz GAS IN
:
QUARTZ WINDOW
CAVITY SAMPLE LOAD LOCK TO TURBO PUMP
" RF POWERED ELECTRODE (13.56 MHz)
Figure 9. Schematic of microwave ECR plasma reactor with rf biasing capability.
ECR etching was also investigated by Ren et al. [37] who found that using NF 3 led to higher etching rates than SF 6, although SF 6 resulted in
much smoother etched surfaces. Reports by McDaniel et al.[ 19]showed that NF 3 resulted in higher etch rates than SF 6 only at lower pressures. When
using NF 3, they found a decreasing etch rate as pressure increased, analogous
Dry Etching of SiC 167 to previous reports which employed CF4/O 2. However, when using SF 6 they found that the etch rate increased with pressure, in the range of 1-10 mtorr.
9
80 e~
/
,
,i,
80 e~
i
-IOOV~
6o
-
o,'
60
.,4r
/ e,-
/
m
I--
40
0 / /
f
20
I-"
/
-20V
/ /
~ 2o
kill
500 W
/ /
<1: I:1=
/
-r O
/
/
40
/ /
I--
w
0
0
' 260 '4()0 '600 " 800 I~-WAVE POWER (W)
's6 '75 BIAS
(a) 100 -
"i00
(-V)
(b) 4O
t'~
r
75
30
o t,-
C
..
u.I 5 0 I,,==: nt"r9 2 5 0I-I,M O - -
-lOOV "o. 5 0 0 W
~.. 2 0
~, - 2 0 V " "800 W
--.. ,.4;
600 W zero bias
.
I--.
Ill
"
3 ' 6 PRESSURE
(c)
' 9 " (mTorr)
12
0 DIST.
" 2 FROM
' z~ ' Ei " 8 ECR CAVITY (cm)
(d)
F i g u r e 10. Etch rate variation o f 6 H - S i C in CF4/18%O 2 plasmas with (a) m i c r o w a v e power, (b) applied bias, (c) pressure and (d) sample proximity to E C R source.
A comparison of ECR etching and RIE was performed to assess the degree of etch-induced damage and the tendency for residue formation characteristic with each process.[ 27][38]In these experiments, samples of ntype 6H-SiC having epilayers with n = 5 x 1015/cm 3 were first subjected to a standard peroxide-based Si cleaning procedure. ECR etching was performed at 600W and 2 mtorr with an imposed de bias o f - 2 0 V . The RIE was performed at an rfpower density of 0.59 W/cm 2 at 25 mtorr. The same gas flow of 50 seem of a mixture of 18% 02/CF 4 was used for each case, but, in the case ofRIE, 10 seem ofH 2 was added to prevent the occurrence of micro-masking. Auger electron spectra showed that the ECR etched
168
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
surfaces and sidewalls were free of any detectable residues containing A1, F, or O. In contrast, the RIE surface composition showed approximately 9% A1 and 6% O. Moreover, larger amounts of A1 and O were detected on the RIE sidewall along with trace amounts of F. The reverse-bias I-V characteristics of Pd Schottky diodes fabricated on the etched surfaces showed that leakage currents were 1000 times greater on RIE samples. Furthermore, C-V measurements showed a 40% reduction in the donor concentration up to a depth of 0.6 ~tm in the RIE samples indicative of ioninduced damage. No reduction in donor concentration was measured for the ECR samples, although the reverse bias leakage currents were 100 times higher than for unetched control samples. The thermal stability of dry etch damage created in n-type SiC was investigated by Pearton et al., [39] who identified threshold energies for ion-damage in both RIE and ECR Ar plasmas. They showed that annealing of ion-damage does not occur until temperatures of greater than 700~ and that some remnant disorder remains even after annealing at 1050~ Due to the relative stability of damage in SiC, it can be concluded that any etching process for SiC device fabrication should be designed to operate below the damage threshold.
5.0
PROFILE AND M O R P H O L O G Y C O N T R O L W I T H ECR E T C H I N G
In the fabrication of advanced devices from SiC, the profile of the etched sidewall, the morphologies of the etched surfaces, and the degree of damage to the underlying SiC are all issues of high concern. For example, fabricating a vertical power-MOSFET, where the FET channel is fabricated on the sidewall of an etched trench, requires not only smooth surfaces with low damage, but also a tapered transition from the sidewall to the trench bottom. This minimizes electric field enhancement that would otherwise occur at the sharp edges of the gate contact. In SiC etching experiments using ECR plasmas, the level of imposed bias was found to have a strong effect on both the profile and surface morphology.[ 4~ Figure 1 l a shows the comer of mesa features etched at a high bias of-100 V, and Fig. 1 lb shows a low bias of approximately-8 V. The ITO masking films were retained on these samples so that the degree of undercutting could be observed. The surface features that resulted under high bias conditions were found to be relatively smooth both on etched sidewalls and on horizontal surfaces. On the other hand, the high bias
Dry Etching of SiC 169 consequently led to undesirably enhanced etching at the base of the sidewalls. This effect, referred to as trenching, results from the deflection of energetic ions at glancing angles off the sidewalls, thus enhancing the sputtering component of the etching mechanism in the affected regions.[ 16] Therefore, the degree of trenching becomes increasingly more pronounced as the etching proceeds deeper. This effect is also prevalent in RIE and can be observed in the micrographs of etched SiC presented in much of the literature. From an applications perspective, a profile of this nature is illsuited for device fabrication (if an active element of the device, such as the gate of a FET, is to be fabricated in or on the etched feature). In contrast, etching, with low bias applied to the substrate, avoided the trenching effect and led to a more tapered transition from the sidewall to the bottom surface. However, the resulting surface morphology tended to be textured and the sidewalls possessed many jagged edges originating from rough features initially present on the mask edges. The consistent appearance of rough features on samples etched at low bias and smooth features on samples etched at high bias suggests that the ITO mask edges can be effectively smoothed by ion-bombardment during the etching process. In light of this speculation, experiments were performed where the samples were subjected initially to a brief high-bias step, prior to prolonged etching at lower bias. Figure 1 lc shows smoother features which resulted when the sample was etched for 2 min at-100 V prior to prolonged etching at-8 V. Therefore, a two-step bias process can result in a morphology which is far more suited to the fabrication of a trench device element than are the morphologies which result when a constant level of bias is applied throughout the process. The proximity of the sample to the ECR source has been found to strongly affect both the anisotropy and rate of etching. Figure 12 shows the etched profiles as viewed from the comers of adjacent square mesa features with the masking ITO layers still remaining on the structures. In both cases, no bias was applied to the substrate. By measuring the vertical etch depth (d) and the lateral etch depth (/), the anisotropy can be quantified as A = (d- l)/d. The anisotropy of etching was approximately 0.8 when the sample was 8 cm from the bottom of the ECR cavity (Fig. 12a). The anisotropy value decreased to 0.5 when the substrate was elevated to within 1.5 cm of the ECR source (Fig. 12b). The rate of etching also increased with the proximity of the sample to the plasma source. Three important consequences of increased proximity are: the sample is bombarded by a higher density of reactive species; there is likely a significant degree of sample heating from the plasma and from microwave absorption; and the reactive species bombard the sample with a wider angular distribution.
170
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Figure 11. (a) Morphology of ECR etched samples with (a)-100 V shows smooth surfaces and sidewalls with trenching effect; (b) -8 V shows rougher surfaces without trenching; (c) two-step bias process to obtain smooth features without trenching.
Dry Etching of SiC 1 71
Figure 11.
(Cont 'd.)
Figure 12. Profiles of 6H-SiC ECR etched with no applied bias have anisotropy of A=0.8 with sample 8 cm from ECR source. (b) A=0.5 with sample 1 cm from source.
(a)
172
Wide B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s
Figure 12. (Cont'd.)
The profile of the etched SiC sidewall can be alternatively controlled by using a thick masking layer of a material which can be eroded gradually at the mask edges.J41][42] One approach is illustrated in Fig. 13 where the sloping edges of a mask can be translated to the etched SiC profile. The resulting sidewall angle is determined by both the initial slope of the mask edge (0m) and the selectivity of etching. Assuming that the etching process is anisotropie, the angle resulting after etching to depths d s and d m in the SiC and mask, respectively, will be given by: Eq. (1)
tan (0~)= d~ tan (Ore)
dm
where (d/dm) is the selectivity of etching SiC relative to the mask and ~ is the sidewall angle of the etched SiC relative to the horizontal surface. It is known that SiO 2 films chemically etched in buffered HF solutions will develop an edge taper of approximately 30 ~. Therefore, by controlling the selectivity of the dry etching process, this method can be applied to SiC using SiO 2 masks. In this case, a variation in selectivity from 0.5 to 3.0 will result in a variation in the SiC sidewall from 16~ to 60 ~
Dry Etching of SiC 1 73
TAPERED MASK
SUBSTRATE
ANISOTROPIC ETCH
SUBSTRATE
(a)
(b)
Figure 13. Diagram of how angled sidewalls are obtained by using tapered mask and varying the etch selectivity.
In a demonstration of this method, a 0.7 ~m layer of SiO 2 was deposited by plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition onto a 4H-SiC substrate to serve as the masking layer.[ 41] The PECVD film was then densified by annealing at 1100~ in O 2 to improve the film durability. Figure 14 shows the etching rates of SiC and SiO 2 as a function of the amount of N20 added to 10 seem of a gas mixture of 18% O 2 in CF 4 for conditions of 650 W power, 2 mtorr, and applied biases of zero and-50 V. The gas composition and sample bias were both found to affect the etching selectivity. Without N20 the etch rate ofSiO 2 was nearly twice that of SiC. However, as N20 was added, the etching became selective in favor of SiC, with the maxima for different bias values occurring at greatly different gas ratios. Interestingly, at low ratios of O/F, an increase in bias favors etching of SiO2, whereas, at high ratios of O/F, an increase in bias appears to favor etching of SiC. To exploit the etch selectivity for the purpose of controlling the profile angle, test patterns were defined photolithographically on the SiO2/SiC samples. Using the photoresist as a mask, the SiO 2 was removed in the exposed regions with a buffered HF solution. The chemical etch resulted in a 30 ~ slope to the SiO 2 mask edge as shown in Fig. 15a. After removing the resist, the sample was etched under conditions of no bias and an O/F ratio of 0.26 (predicted to yield a selectivity of approximately 1.5 in favor of SIC). The resulting SiC profile corresponding to a 0.6 ~m deep etch is shown in Fig. 15b after removal of the remaining SiO 2 film. The measured sidewall angle was 48 ~ corresponding to an actual selectivity of 1.7. Lanois et al. [42]demonstrated considerably better control using SF6/O 2 mixtures with ECR plasmas where the selectivity of SiC/SiO 2 could be
1 74
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
varied from 1 to 6 by varying the amount of 0 2 in the gas mixture. In this ease, the sidewall angles could be tailored from 35 ~ to 80 ~ This technique may eventually prove valuable for fabrication oftreneh-MOS devices and for edge termination in high voltage devices.
O/F INPUT RATIO 700 0.10 I ' I'
0.22 I
I
I
'
'
I
0.46 ' ' '
c-
0.58 '
''
I
0.70 '
'
I
o SiC
E 500
A SiO 2
u.I 400 I-,< n" 300 -r O 200 LU
I
10sccm CF4/18%0 2
600 ~
0.34 '
Vdc
= -50V
100 i
0
5
10
I
I
15
I
t
2O
ADDED N20 FLOW (sccm) Figure 14. ECR etch rates of SiC and SiO2 in CF4/18%02 plasma with addition of N20.
6.0
SUMMARY
Realization of advanced device structures fabricated from semiconducting SiC requires the ability to etch this material smoothly, controllably, and with a minimal amount of damage to the underlying material. In this chapter many of the published results on dry etching of silicon carbide using various techniques have been reviewed and compared. The vast majority of reports on SiC etching have utilized traditional reactive ion etch (RIE) reactors in conjunction with fluorinated gas mixtures. These processes have typically been plagued by the formation of mieromasking residues. These residues can be minimized or eliminated by the addition of H 2 to the gas mixture at the expense of lower etch rates and the potential passivation of aceeptors. While RIE etch rates are enhanced by the dc
Dry Etching of SiC 175 self-bias which develops on the substrate, these high levels of bias lead to a greater degree of etch damage. Recently, alternative methods ofmagnetron enhanced RIE (MIE) and electron cyclotron resonance (ECR) plasma etching have been demonstrated. MIE has resulted in extremely high etch rates and ECR etching has resulted in smooth, residue-free surfaces with an ability to control the etched profiles.
9
)~.~
,":..'~.~
..~-:.:!
,
.~..
Figure 15. Profiles of (a) SiO 2 chemically etched in BHF using photoresist mask and (b) SiC with angled sidewall etched using tapered SiO 2 mask.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I gratefully acknowledge the help and support of my former colleagues at Army Research Laboratory, Ft. Monmouth with whom I have collaborated in the research and development of SiC devices. The contributions of Dr. Kezhou Xie and Dr. Walter Buchwald are especially appreciated.
176
Wide B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s
REFERENCES 1. Weitzel, C. E., Palmour, J. W., Carter, C. H., Jr., Moore, K., Nordquist, K. J., Allen, S., Thero, C., and Bhatnagar, M., IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., 43(10):1732 (1996) 2. Xie, K. Z., Zhao, J. H., Flemish, J. R., Burke, T., Buchwald, W. R., Lorenzo, G., and Singh, H., IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., 17(3):142 (1996) 3. Siergiej, R. R., Clarke, R. C., Agarwal, A. K., Brandt, C. D., Burk, A. A., Jr., Smith, T. J., and Orphanos, P. A., IEDM Tech. Digest, p. 353 (1995) 4. Baliga, B. J., IEEE Trans. Electron Dev., 43(10):1717 (1996) 5. Flanun, D. L., and Donnelly, V. M., Plasma Chem. & Plasma Process., 1:317 (1981) 6. Dalvie, M., and Jensen, K. F., J. Electrochem. Soc., 137(4): 1062 (1990) 7. Field, D., Klemperer, D. F., and Wade, I. T., J. Vac. Sci. Tech. B, 6(2):551 (1988) 8. Dalvie, M., and Jensen, K. F.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 8(3):1648 (1990) 9. Blom, H.-O., Berg, S., Nender, C., and Norstrom, H., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 7(6):1321 (1989) 10. Field, D., Klemperer, D. F., and Wade, I. T.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 6(2):551 (1988) 11. Clarke, P. E., Field, D., Hydes, A. J., Klemperer, D. F., and Seakins, M. J., J. Vac Sci. Technol. B, 3(6): 1614 (1985) 12. Kuo, Y.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. ,4, 8(3):1702(1990) 13. Venkatesan, S. P., Trachtenberg, I., and Edgar, T. F., J. Electrochem. Soc., 137(7):2280 (1990) 14. Schoenbom, P. R., Patrick, R., and Baltes, H. P., J. Electrochem. Soc., 136(1):199(1989) 15. Mogab, C. J., Adams, A. C., and Flamm, D. L., J. Appl. Phys., 49:3769 (1978) 16. Mogab, C. J., VLSI Technology, (S.M. Sze, ed.), pp. 303-345, McGrawHill, New York (1983) 17. Ephrath, L. M.,J. Electrochem Soc., 126:1419 (1979) 18. Steckl, A. J., and Yih, P. H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 60:1966 (1992) 19. McDaniel, G., Lee, J. W., Lambers, E. S., Pearton, S. J., Holloway, P. H., Ren, F., Grow, J. M., Bhaskaran, M., and Wilson, R. G., J. Vac Sci. Technol. A, 14:826 (1997) 20. Chang, C. Y., Fang, Y. K., Huang, C. F., and Wu, B. S., J. Electrochem. Soc., 132(2):418 (1985)
Dry E t c h i n g
of SiC
177
21. Dohmae, S., Shibahara, K., Nishino, S., and Matsunami, H., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 24 :L873 (1985) 22. Kelner, G., Binari, S. C., and Klein, P. H., J. Electrochem. Sot., 134(1):253 (1987) 23. Palmour, J. W., Davis, R. F., Wallett, T. M., and Bhasin, K. B., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 4:590 (1986) 24. Luther, B. P., Ruzyllo, J., and Miller, D. L.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 63" 171 (1993) 25. Pan, W. S., and Steckl, A. J., J. Electrochem. Soc., 137(1):212 (1990) 26. Padiyath, R., Wright, R. L., Chaudhry, M. I., and Babu, S. V., Appl. Phys. Lett., 58:1053 (1991) 27. Flemish, J. R., Xie, K., Buchwald, W., Casas, L., Zhao, J. H., McLane, G., and Dubey, M., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 339:145 (1994) 28. Yih, P. H., and Steckl, A. J.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 140:1813 (1993) 29. Yih, P. H., and Steckl, A. J.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 142:2853 (1995) 30. Yih, P. H., and Steckl, A. J.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 142:312 (1995) 31. Casady, J. B., Luckowski, E. D., Bozack, M., Sheridan, D., Johnson, R. W., and Williams, J. R., J. Electrochem. Soc., 143(5):1750 (1996) 32. Wu, J., Parsons, J. D., and Evans, D. R., J. Electrochem. Soc., 142(2):669 (1995) 33. Rossnagel, S. M., Thin Film Processes II, (J. L. Vossen, and W. Kern, eds.), Academic, San Diego, pp. 11-77 (1991) 34. McLane, G. F., and Flemish, J. R., Appl. Phys. Lett, 66(26):3755 (1996) 35. Asmussen, J.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 7(3):883 (1989) 36. Flemish, J. R., Xie, K., and Zhao, J. H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:2315 (1994) 37. Ren, F., Grow, J. M., Bhaskaran, M., Lee, J. W., Vatuli, C. B., Lothian, J. R., and Flemish, J. R., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 421:251 (1996) 38. Xie, K., Flemish, J. R., Zhao, J. H., Buchwald, W. R., and Casas, L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67:386 (1995) 39. Pearton, S. J., Lee, J. W., Grow, J. M., Bhaskaran, M., and Ren, F., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68(21):2987 (1996) 40. Flemish, J. R., and Xie, K., J. Electrochem. Soc., 143(8):2620 (1996) 41. Flemish, J. R., Xie, K., and McLane, G. F., Mat Res. Soc. Proc., p. 421 (1996) 42. Lanois, F., Lassagne, P., Locatelli, M. L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:36 (1996)
5 Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits Jeffrey B. Cas ady
1.0
BACKGROUND
Most traditional integrated circuit technologies using silicon devices are not able to operate at temperatures above 250~ especially when high operating temperatures are combined with high-power, high-frequency, and high-radiation environments. Much attention has been given to SiC, currently the most mature of the wide-bandgap (2.0 eV < Eg< 7.0 eV) semiconductors, as a material well-suited for high-temperature and efficient high-power operation. High-temperature circuit operation from 350~ to 500~ is desired for use in aerospace applications (turbine engines and the more electric aircraft initiative), nuclear power instrumentation, satellites, space exploration, and geothermal wells.[ 11-[61 As an example of one such application, the more electric aircraft concept offers substantial system-level benefits which are similar to the more electric tank, more electric ship, and more electric automobile concepts. By replacing bulky hydraulic-driven flight control actuators and engine-gearbox driven fuel pumps with power electronics capable of high efficiency and high operating temperatures, tremendous weight savings can be induced. Currently, hydraulic-based systems also provide cooling to aircraft electronics, so the removal of the hydraulic systems will increase 178
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
179
the operating temperature for on-board electronics. Thus, a distributed flight control system which would allow the elimination of cooling systems is envisioned using wide-bandgap devices.[ 2]Over 90% of closed loop environmental control system cooling requirements on modem fighter aircraft are utilized for the cooling of electronics (including radar electronics). Reducing or eliminating this need for cooling would reduce aircraft weight, maintenance support, down time, and ground supplies, while increasing the aircraft' s performance, flying range, efficiency, and reliability. Other advantages of distributed flight control include elimination of long and heavy wiring/shielding runs to actuators and sensors, reduction of the number of unreliable connector pins between control electronics and sensors/actuators, and a decreased chance of catastrophic failure since the control electronics would be located in multiple positions as compared to one centralized location.[2]A pictorial summary of the more electric aircratt concept is shown in Fig. 1.
Integrated Power Unit
Internal Engine Electric Starter/Generator
Solid-State Remote Terminals
Electric-Driven Flight Actuators
Fault-tolerant, solid-state electrical distribution Electric Anti-lcing Electric-Actuated Brakes
Figure 1. Conceptual summary of the more electric aircraft concepts applied to a currentgeneration fighter aircraft.
In addition to these applications, SiC has potential for use in numerous other high-power, high-frequency, and radiation-resistant applications.[ 7]--[9] Silicon carbide (SIC), aluminum nitride (A1N), gallium nitride (GaN), boron nitride (BN), diamond, and zinc selenide (ZnSe) are the primary widebandgap semiconductors now being developed for use in the aforementioned
180
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
applications. Of these, SiC presently has several advantages including commercial availability of substrates since -~1991 (see Refs. 10 and 11), known device processing techniques, and the ability to grow a thermal oxide for use as masks in processing, device passivation layers, and gate dielectrics. In addition, SiC's high thermal conductivity (about 3.3 times that of Si at 300 K for 6HSIC), high electric field breakdown strength (about 10 times that of Si for 6HSIC), and wide bandgap (about 3 times that of Si for 4H-SiC and 6H-SiC) make it a material ideally suited for high-temperature, high-power, highfrequency, and high-radiation environments. The first polytypes of SiC to appear in bulk wafer form[l~ 11]were 6HSiC and 4H-SiC, which has helped SiC to emerge as one of the relatively mature wide-bandgap semiconductor technologies. A complete list of known SiC vendors in 1997 is shown in Table 1 for reference, although the list is certain to expand. Lattice mismatches of only 1% for A1N,[121 and 3% for GaN,[ 131114]exist when these materials are grown on 6H-SiC substrates. Thus, SiC processing is otten intimately linked with A1N and GaN electronic and optical device fabrication as well. For example, commercially available GaN blue (peak wavelength of 430 nm) LED's manufactured on 6H-SiC substrates were released in 1995.[1~ By 1998, this GaN on SiC blue LED represented the highest volume blue LED sold. The small lattice mismatches with AIN and GaN, as well as the abundance of polytypes in SiC, combine to make SiC a material with an immense potential for use in heterostructure electronic devices which take advantage of the differing bandgaps, carrier mobility's, etc.
1.1
Historical Development of Silicon Carbide
With all the recent attention given to SiC, an often surprising fact is that growth of SiC crystals by the Acheson technique dates back to 1893. Discovery and identification of a SiC Light Emitting Diode (LED) occurred in 1907 when H. J. Round published a short article entitled "A Note on Carborundum. ''[15] Semiconductor pioneer W. Shockley, inventor of the bipolar junction transistor in 1947, recognized the potential of SiC in his now prophetic, introductory remarks at the First International Conference on Silicon Carbide in April 1959, as illustrated by the following quote: "Today, in the electronics .field there are probably two areas of special interest. One of these is miniaturization, the process of maldng devices small complicated and fast; the other has to do with problems of new environment, such as higher temperatures and radiation resistance ....
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
181
Now, the big question is this: How is theproblem of high temperature going to be solved? What are the horses to put one's money on?... One approach is the logical sequence we see here: Ge, Si, SiC, C in that sequence .... The SiC situation suffers from the very same thing that makes it so good. The bond is very strong and so all processes go on at very high temperature .... Another aspect of the silicon carbide situation is similar to past situations in the semiconductor field. The lesson is that one should not give up too soon and one should not always look for gold at the ends of new rainbows .... The situation may be similar with silicon carbide. The material problem will have to be extensively worked on. Perhaps one day.., large single crystals o f silicon carbide will be grown easily .... These are difficult questions."[ 16]
Table 1. List of Known SiC Vendors (1997)
Supplier Epitronics, an ATMI company Cree Research, Inc.
Location 7 Commerce Drive Danbury, CT 06810 USA
30 mm 4H and 6H-SiC bulk
2810 Meridian Parkway
50 mm 4H and 6H-SiC bulk/epi
Durham, NC 27713 USA FTTIKS Enterprise
Comments
3-4-13 Nihonbashi Chuo-ku, Tokyo, Japan
6H-SiC bulk and 4H-SiC epi on 6H-SiC
HOYA Corporation
3-3-1 Musashino, Akishima Tokyo 196, Japan
3C-SiCon Si
Sterling Semiconductor
Sterling, VA
50mm 4H-SiC bulk/epi
Nippon Steel Advanced Technology Research Laboratories
5-10-1 Fuchinobe Sagamihara Kanagawa 220 Japan
6H-SiC and 4H-SiC 25 mm wafers available (1995)
182 1.2
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors Material Properties of Silicon Carbide
SiC is part of a family of materials which exhibit a one-dimensional polymorphism called polytypism. An almost infinite number of SiC polytypes are possible, and approximately 200 polytypes have already been discovered.[ 17] A listing of some of the more common polytypes include 3C, 2H, 4H, 6H, 8H, 9R, 10H, 14H, 15R, 19R, 20H, 21H, 24R, and others (see Table 2). SiC polytypes are differentiated by the stacking sequence of each tetrahedrally bonded Si-C bi-layer. With the exception of 2H and 3C, all of the polytypes form 1-D superlattice structures.[ 181Even though individual bond lengths are nearly identical, as shown in Table 2, the crystal symmetry is determined by the stacking periodicity. The polytypes are divided into three basic crystallographic categories: cubic (C), hexagonal (H), and rhombohedral (R). Table 2. Lattice Structure Properties of Selected SiC Polytypes
Polytype
Lattice Structure
Lattice constant a (A)
Lattice constant c (A)
, , .
3C-SiC
face-centered cubic
4.3590
2H-SiC
hexagonal
3.0817
4H-SiC
hexagonal
3.079
6H-SiC
hexagonal
3.0817
15.1183
8H-SiC
hexagonal
3.079
20.146
15R-SiC
rhombohedral
3.079
37.78
21R-SiC
rhombohedral
3.079
52.88 67.995
5.0394 10.254
27R-SiC
rhombohedral
3.079
33R-SiC
rhombohedral
3.079
83.10
51R-SiC
rhombohedral
3.079
128.434
75R-SiC
rhombohedral
3.079
188.867
84R-SiC
rhombohedral
3.079
211.539
87R-SiC
rhombohedral
3.079
219.094
Cubic Silicon Carbide. Cubic SiC has only one possible polytype, and is referred to as 3C-SiC or J3-SiC. Each SiC bi-layer can be oriented into only three possible positions with respect to the lattice, while the tetrahedral bonding is maintained. If these three layers are arbitrarily
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
183
denoted A, B, and C, and the stacking sequence is ABCABC..., then the crystallographic structure is cubic zincblende. This arrangement is known as 3C-SiC or 13-SIC. The number 3 refers to the number of layers needed for periodicity. The smallest bandgap (---2.4 eV)[ 19] and one of the largest electron mobilities (~800 cm2/V.s in low-doped material)[2~ of all the known SiC polytypes is possessed by 3C-SiC. It is not currently available in bulk form, despite bulk growth of 3C-SiC having been demonstrated in a research environment.[ all Cubic SiC has been grown on Si with limited success and incorporated into heterostructure devices, despite the nearly 20% lattice mismatch between 13-SIC and Si. Recent advances in heteroepitaxial growth of I3-SiC include low temperature (750~ CVD of [3-SIC on silicon achieved by researchers at AlliedSignal,[ a2] and the growth of 3C-SiC on 6H-SiC substrates.[23][TM Hexagonal and Rhombohedral Silicon Carbide. If the stacking of the bi-layers is ABAB..., then the symmetry is hexagonal and referred to as 2H-SiC. All of the other SiC polytypes excluding 2H and 3C are a mixture ofzincblende (cubic) and wurtzite (hexagonal) bonding. An equal number of cubic and hexagonal bonds make up 4H-SiC, while 6H-SiC is composed of two-thirds cubic bonds and one-third hexagonal bonds. The overall symmetry is hexagonal for both polytypes, despite the cubic bonds which are present in each. The hexagonal structures are collectively grouped as o~-SiC.The only SiC polytypes currently available in bulk wafer form are 6H-SiC and 4H-SiC. Polytypes with rhombohedral symmetry have also been found and are denoted by the letter R. Advanced Technology Materials, Inc. (ATMI) have also grown 15R-SiC substrates.[ 251 Electrical Properties and Impurity Centers in 3C, 6H, and 4H Polytypes. Basic electrical properties obtained from the literature for the 3C, 6H, and 4H polytypes of SiC are shown in Table 3. The data cited are dependent upon the temperature, test methods used, and quality of the material, as well as dopant concentrations and species. Accuracy of these material properties is extremely important for device modeling, yet material properties are often cited erroneously or improperly in the literature. To fully analyze the data provided in Table 3, one should carefully examine the given references. The properties for Si[TM are also shown for reference. Three key categories where SiC enjoys inherent advantages over Si and GaAs for high-temperature, high-power, and high-frequency operation are thermal conductivity, electric field breakdown strength, and bandgap. SiC also has a much higher thermal conductivity (| than GaAs at 300 K, (8 to 10 times), [a6] a bandgap of approximately twice the bandgap of GaAs, while still possessing a peak saturation velocity (v~at)of 2 x 107 cm/s, just as in
184
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
GaAs. As a partial result of the saturation velocity overshoot phenomenon in GaAs, SiC's Vsat at high electric fields is superior to that of GaAs. The electron velocity of silicon, silicon carbide, and GaAs are compared in Fig. 2a where SiC's superiority at high electric field (>300 kV/cm) can be observed.
Table 3. Silicon Carbide Material Properties QUANTITY
3C-SiC
4H-SiC
6H-SiC
Sil281
Eg (eV) at T < 5 K
2.40 [19]
3.26 [27]
3.02 [27]
1.12
Ecdt(MWcm)
2.12 [29]
2.2 [29]
2.5 [29]
0.25
Eerit ('ND) (kV/cm)
10.64.ND 0.142
O K (W/cm'K) at 300 K*
3.2 [32]
3.71321
4.9[ 33]
1.5
n i (cm "3) at 300 K ~
1.5 x 10 "1
5 x 10 -9
1.6 x 10 -6
1.0 • 1050
v~t (cm/s)
2.0 x 107 [lo]
2.0 x 107 [30]
1.0 x 107
[parallel to c-axis]
10001351
4001351
1400
0 . 7 - 0 . 8 3 [ 34]
6[35]
1 15 [40]
101 [40]
800 [20]
/'/e (cm2/Vs)
m_L/mjj at 300
K
~h (cm2/Vs)
40 [39]
2" (eV) at 300 K refractive index (n)
2.7
es
9.72[ 42]
471
2.70 [4]
2.95[ 4]
3.15
2.712
2.7
3.5
9.661421
11.7
*doped at -~1017 cm "3 **Nc, Nv ~ 1019 cm -3
All of the quantities shown in Table 3 are temperature dependent to differing extents. Electron mobility (ge) and hole mobility (Ph) are carrier velocity per unit drift field, and are critically important device parameters, affecting the microwave performance, transconductance ( g ~ , output gain of FET' s, on-resistance of power FET's (Ro~), and other parameters. The low, anisotropic electron mobility in 6H-SiC is one of the primary reasons for the popularity of 4H-SiC for electronic applications, which has a higher and much less anisotropic electron mobility. In fact, (P-t)/(P II) is about 0.70.83 at 300K in 4H-SIC,[34][35] while the same ratio is about 6 in 6H-SiC.[ 35] Of course, mobility is also strongly dependent upon temperature and doping density. In Fig. 2b, the room temperature mobilities of Si, 4H-SiC, and 6HSiC are compared as a function of total doping density. The mobility values
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
185
for 4H and 6H-SiC were least squared fits (of experimental data taken in the basal plane) to an empirical relation for mobility in silicon.P 5]For reference, the mobility values for n and p-type silicon at room temperature are also shown.[ 28] The superiority of 4H-SiC over 6H-SiC with respect to mobility values can clearly be seen from this figure, especially when considering the severe anisotropic nature of mobility in 6H-SiC as discussed earlier.
10 7
108
103
104
105
106
107
Electric Field Intensity, vlcm (a)
14007= .............................
'~
1
4H-SiC (N)
................................. =........................~ - - i
10001
,., 4 H - S i C
................................................................ : --.
>
~
" ................................................................. ................
800
-
~
-
t
i
1200 .-.
y. . . .
(AI)
6H-SiC
(N)
-..
6H-SiC
(^i)
+
Si (Phos)
+
Si (Boron)
400- ~ "" i
1E+15
'
"'-,~i
i
i
1E+16
1E+17
1E+18
1E+19
1E+20
Total Impurity Concentration (crn -3)
Co) Figure 2. (a) Electron velocity vs. electric field in SiC. Higher saturated electron velocity and breakdown field of SiC result in 4 times higher power density than silicon or GaAs. Taken from Ref. 4.(b)Electron and hole mobility's in silicon and silicon carbide at room temperature as functions of total dopant concentration. Mobility's for SiC are for the basal plane. Silicon data from Ref. 28 and silicon carbide data from Ref. 35.
,186
Wide Bandgap
Semiconductors
The intrinsic carrier concentration (ni), defined by Eq. (1), is directly proportional to N c and N v, which are the conduction band and valence band density of states, respectively. N c and N v have an empirical temperature (T3/2) dependence. However, as a result of the fundamental change in energy between the electron states, n i has an exponential dependence upon temperature, as well as Eg. [37] In Fig. 3a, n i as a function of reciprocal temperature is shown for 4H-SiC, illustrating that device operation in excess of 1500~ is theoretically possible. Intrinsic carrier concentration (ni) is important in high-temperature device applications (pn junction leakage currents in devices are normally proportional to n i or ni 2) when diffusion currents dominate the total leakage current. It should be noted that in wide bandgap semiconductors, the generation current resulting from electron hole pairs thermally generated in the depletion region can actually dominate the total leakage current. Electron effective masses (m• = 0.42 m o and mll - 0.29 m o in 4H-SiC)[ 34] which are also a function of the band curvature have not been analyzed as a function of temperature, and work remains in that area. Eq. (1)
n~ =x[Nc.Nvexp (-e~/~-~r) n,., = n~ exp (~/~r) T (~ -" 73
227
1727 liaJa
~!!!~i ! nl
l x l O + 1 6 c m "3
I
I
I
,
i
ii!i
i !
i
ili
i
~
4.-s,c 11 (a)
71i:Oi
1x10 +lOcm -3 : ,,;:~_.,.~ .~ , /
/
._iiii! -
l x 1 0 +02 c m "3
l~gliil i'i
i
i ,
'
[
i
!~
I ~ ! i : i i i In I~ ~ ~ ~ Ii
9 ~-~i'! EG,,3,24oV
|
~ili
~ i ~
l x 1 0 " 1 0 c m "3
!/
i/
~ ! :
n p~i.
I""" 10
::ilUl
! ! ::! U
JRI
L~i'i''
N C ,, 1.25x10 TMx (T/3IX)) I"s cm "3 !
!
~;~i~ . . .!. i ~:~ p
J
/
ill
!
I I
~iliJl i i
n !
'
~
!ii!li
o
, I
'
iili~i
1
i
i
0.1
1000/T (K "1) Figure 3. (a) Intrinsic carrier concentration as a function of reciprocal temperature ( 1 0 0 0 / T ) in units of inverse Kelvin for 4H-SiC. (b) Temperature-dependent bandgap values for different polytypes of SiC. Taken from Ref. 38.
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
(4.2K) I~X
(RT) ~,
187
(RT)
, ....-' 1 '. ~
r
~-'
"---.... S i C
,o.
&.l~& 300
(4H) s.au 2H 9 ~',.
"~r "
-,x2a5
~,
3.,127
a.a~
3.20
IIIH) . 3.00-2.995 ,2.972 ,,z957
115fl1,,--
3.022 2.999 2.964
2.9o
121 R) z.au, ~1" t~
($H) z.m i
2.80"2.02 ~.77
(24R1 t ~
~1~1%~'~
2.70,2.71
" 2.4,R,'-,, "~ (3C) ~ . ~
2.827 2.80
\
2.7, ;LeO 2.40
F-......
,~1.360
2.387
3s _l
I[_ l__l Ti~l~lUm
Ibwgy ( ; a ~ . Exawn S ~
F i g u r e 3.
- 2.30 %% % X, 9 o 2=O I l I l {Ki - ~
EG(ov) = EGx(eV). ( B E ) x EneflW, ( B E ) x = 0.027 ev
(Cont 'd.)
Typical bandgap values are obtained from photoluminescence studies performed at liquid He temperatures (~4.2 K) under very low pressures (--~10-II T). [17][19][27] Energy bandgap as a function of temperature for polytypes 2H, 4H, 6H, 15R, 21R, 8H, and 3C of SiC have been reported, with the temperature dependencies shown by Fig. 3b.[TMHigh doping levels lead to band gap narrowing (BGN) effects in semiconductors, but have not been extensively studied in SiC. Therefore, the effective intrinsic carrier concentration (hie) relationship with doping has not been firmly established. Arrangement of next neighbors in the lattice is the same for all SiC polytypes, but crystallographically inequivalent lattice sites exist in different
188
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
polytypes. Thus, electronic properties, such as effective mass, carrier mobility, and bandgap, vary widely between different polytypes of SiC, as shown in Table 3. Measurement of all material properties shown in Table 3 should be investigated carefully since varying material quality (mixed polytype material can easily be obtained) can drastically affect measured parameters. An example of variability in reported material constants is the range in thermal conductivity reported for SiC as shown in Fig. 4.
~'~12
g,07 "
E
'
.>
-
"r0
-
96H-SiC . 4H-SiC
~ 6-3
,L 3C-SiC
uo 4 -
= 2j,
m ~
~
.
,, p-
A 9
14
19
24
29
34
39
44
Temperature (K)
(a) I~ Low
I~ Median
4"2
"
~---
"~2-
8 t-I--
D High
6H
4H SiC Pol~ype
3C
(b) Figure 4. Reported values from literature of thermal conductivity for SiC at (a) low temperature and (b) room temperature. Range of room temperature data is reported as high, median, or low. Taken from compiled data in Ref. 95.
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
189
Electrically active impurities in semiconductors are normally substitutional dopants occupying vacant lattice sites. Dopants for SiC include N, P and As (n-type), and A1, B, Be, Ga, O, and Sc (p-type), with A1 being the most common p-type dopant because it has the shallowest acceptor level.[ 17] Undoped SiC is typically n-type from residual nitrogen, and has a slight green tint in color for 6H-SiC. Color of the material depends upon the specific polytype, however. Donor activation energies are often found to vary over a wide range, depending upon measurement technique, material quality, polytype and dopant concentrations. Activation energies also vary depending upon the substitutional site occupied in the lattice (cubic or hexagonal). For n-type 3C, Hall measurements have yielded nitrogen activation energies from 18-48 meV. In 6H-SiC, two donor levels have been found depending upon the occupancy site. Site 1 (hexagonal site) is from 84-100 meV, and site 2 (cubic site) is from 125-150 meV.[ 17]In 4H-SiC, donor levels are 45 meV, and 100 meV for site 1 and site 2, respectively.[ 17] The fact that most dopant levels are deeper than those found comparably in silicon explains the partial carrier freeze-out found in SiC at room temperature, since the thermal energy (kT/q) is only---25.9 meV at 300 K. Since carriers are ionized by electric fields in many devices (most notably field effect transistors), lower temperature operation is also feasible. For example, SiC Junction Field Effect Transistors (JFET's) have been operated to temperatures as low as 77 K, because of field ionization of dopants.[ 41] For p-type A1 doped SiC, an average acceptor energy level of approximately 200 meV is found for all pol3~,pes. [17]Other p-type dopants such as boron have deeper acceptor levels (ranging from approximately 320 meV to 735 meV), and are not as commonly used because of increased concerns regarding carrier freeze-out. Boron's most common use has been in work involving deeper (>0.8 ~tm) p-type implants where boron is preferred over aluminum because of its lighter mass.
2.0
SILICON CARBIDE DEVICE PROCESSING
Now that a brief description of SiC material properties has been given, examining processing issues of the semiconductor for combined high-temperature, high-power, and high-frequency applications is now appropriate. SiC device processing has rapidly evolved since the commercial availability of SiC substrates in 1991. In this section, the major aspects of SiC device processing are discussed, beginning with bulk material growth.
190 2.1
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors Bulk SiC Growth
Historically, bulk growth of SiC has been perhaps the most significant problem limiting the usefulness of SiC in electronic applications. [43}-[59]Singlecrystal wafers of 6H-SiC have been available commercially only since 1991 (from Cree Research, Inc. )[101 and 4H-SiC wafers have only been available since 1994 (from Cree in 1994 and ATMI in 1995).[1~ 11] Research environments, but not commercial ones, have produced 3C-SiC wafers[ 211and 15R-SiC[ 1l] wafers. An excellent review of commercial SiC boule growth by seeded sublimation is given by V. F. Tsvetkov et al.[431 Single crystal boules grown from either a melt or solution would require excessive temperatures (>3200~ and very high pressures (> 100,000 atm) which precludes this growth method from being utilized. Thus, in the absence of other viable melt-growth techniques, physical vapor deposition via seeded sublimation is the most commonly used approach. The vapor phase of SiC (typically Si, Si2C, SIC2) is deposited upon a SiC seed crystal at high temperatures (>2000~ Examples of a 4H-SiC boule grown via the sublimation process is shown in Fig. 5 and example wafers shown after slicing and polishing are shown in Fig. 6. Typical wafer diameters are 3 5 mm, although Cree Research is currently offering the sale of 2 inch (~50 mm) diameter wafers beginning in 1997. One major problem with the sublimation growth technique has been the formation of mieropipe defects. Although defects such as mieropipes are not found in Lely platelets of SiC, this type of growth results in irregular shaped SiC substrates which are unsuitable for commercial SiC device produetion.[5~ 551Mieropipes are bulk defects (voids) which propagate the length of the boule from the seed crystal, and are also found to propagate through subsequent epitaxially grown SiC layers. Mieropipes have hexagonal cross-sections with diameters from about 0.1 ~tm to 5 ~tm. [43][46] Mechanisms causing the mieropipes have not been clearly identified in the literature, but 13 possible thermodynamic, kinetic, and technological mechanisms have been identified.[ 43] A good discussion of various defects (hexagonal pits, mieropipes, screw dislocations, hillocks, etc.) and possible causes is found in Ref. 56. In physical vapor transport grown 6H-SiC substrates, all mieropipe defects were positioned along the lines of super screw dislocations with Burgers vectors of at least four times that of the eaxis lattice constant.[ 461Mieropipe defect densities (MDD), found in densities of 1000/em 2 in the early 1990's, were reported as reduced to 3.5/em 2 at the research level on a 30 mm (1.18 inch) 4H-SiC wafer in 1995.[43]Typical commercial wafers in 1997 possess mieropipe defects densities ranging
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
191
from 50-200/cm 2. One fact often overlooked by device engineers is that the mieropipe defect density is non-uniform and often locally clustered on the wafer. The non-uniform density is a real benefit to device engineers seeking large-area regions for power devices or complex circuits since 1 cm 2 areas on wafers have often been found with zero micropipes. [44]Figure 7 illustrates an example of the non-uniform micropipe defect density found on a typical 4H-SiC substrate, similar to that reported in the literature.[ 441 While some areas are virtually defect-free, other areas have a large density ofmicropipe defects on the same wafer. Thus, quotes of average micropipe defect density across a wafer may not give a true representation of the substrate quality. Elimination of the micropipes found in bulk SiC is a critical issue for development of SiC power devices and larger-area integrated circuits[ 45] and is expected to happen by the year 2000.
Figure 5. Polished 38 mm diameter, <0001>-oriented 4H-SiC boule grown via seeded sublimation technology shown prior to slicing. Photo courtesy of Northrop Grumman.
192
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Figure 6. Examples of sliced and polished SiC substrates. Note that SiC is optically transparent and that substrate color is dependent upon doping type, concentration, and material polytype. Photo courtesy of Northrop Grumman. It should be noted that at least three different corporations in the United States (Northrop Grumman, Cree Research, and ATMI/Sterling Semi.) are currently producing SiC wafers via seeded sublimation, with other companies in Russia, Japan, and Europe also producing wafers (see Table 1). A brief, non-inclusive listing of other outstanding references to bulk growth of SiC are listed for the interested reader.[21][25][43t-[59]Work by H. M. Hobgood et al., [47] D. L. Barrett et a1.,[521[551 and G. Augustine et al. [44] provide superb discussions of SiC bulk growth using a sublimation-source
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
193
physical vapor transport system at Northrop Grumman, with results comparable to that of Cree's. Notable achievements include production of 6HSiC boules up to 60 mm (2.36") in diameter. It is estimated that 100 mm, high-quality wafers of reasonable cost will be required for high-power commercial SiC device production, while 50-75 mm wafers should suffice for low-power commercial products. [43]Growth was done at ~2300~ while the oriented SiC seed crystal was held at a lower temperature (~2200~ The major crystalline defects reported in the 4H-SiC substrates grown by physical vapor transport were micropipes (10 cm -2 on best wafers) and dislocations (104 cm -2 range). Room-temperature electrical conductivity of the substrates could be varied from less than 1 x 10 -2 f~-cm, n-type, to insulating (> 1015 ~-cm).
Figure 7. Example of the non-uniform micropipe defect density on a typical 4H-SiC substrate. Photo courtesy of Northrop Grumman.
194
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Other recent research has focused upon the use of tantalum coated crucibles and containers for sublimation growth in place of the traditional graphite crucibles. For example, growth rates of 1.5 mm/h have been achieved using Ta container material, with growth temperatures ranging from 1600-2100~ When comparing Ta and graphite crucibles for growth (using polycrystalline SiC source material and (0001) 6H-SiC Lely grown platelets as seed), it was found that at low temperature gradients (<30 K/cm), the growth rate of material in Ta containers exceeded that of material grown in graphite containers. The development of semi-insulating SiC substrates is of extreme importance for microwave applications.[ 58][591 Single crystal 6H-SiC substrates grown by PVT have demonstrated high resistivity (1-30 l~.cm), semi-insulating (> 100 k~.cm), and even insulating (1011-1012 k~.cm) type behavior. Achieving semi-insulating 6H-SiC has been accomplished by using undoped and vanadium-compensated substrates. The resistivity of the undoped 6H-SiC semi-insulating substrates has a strong temperature dependence dominated by a single activation (ionization) energy of-~0.3 5 eV identified as the B acceptor level.[59]The temperature dependence of the vanadium-compensated 6H-SiC material is also strong but more complex, with at least three activation energies identified resulting from residual boron and the complex behavior of vanadium. Vanadium has been proposed as both a donor (ED =1.35 eV) and an acceptor (EA= 0.8 eV). These temperature dependencies should obviously be taken into account when examining limits to high temperature operation of high frequency SiC devices fabricated on semi-insulating SiC substrates.
2.2
Doping of Silicon Carbide
Epitaxial Growth of SiC. Doping in SiC for device fabrication is accomplished via epitaxially controlled doping and hot ion implantation. Temperatures required for diffusion are too high (greater than 1800~ for standard device processing because of the very high bond strength possessed by SiC. The two most common dopants used in SiC are nitrogen (n-type) and aluminum (p-type), as discussed previously, although boron is sometimes used for p-type implants. In the absence of diffusion, epitaxial and ionimplanted control of dopants are critical for the development of devices and IC's. Numerous high-quality publications on epitaxial growth processes exist (see for example, Refs. 22-23, 40, and 60-75). Silane and propane are typical source gases of Si and C, respectively. Typical growth rates for 6H-SiC homoepitaxy layers on Si-face n-type substrates are--3 ~tm/hour. For
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
195
example, a prototype horizontal flow epitaxial growth reactor used at Northrop Grumman Science and Technology Center for homoepitaxial 4H-SiC and 6H-SiC growth is shown in Fig. 8. Increasing the growth rate while maintaining polytype control, good surface morphology, uniform thickness, and accurate control of dopant levels is critical in producing thick (50-100 ~tm) blocking layers necessary for high-voltage (>5 kV) power devices. Growth rates of up to 6 ~tm/h have been demonstrated in vertical low pressure CVD systems manufactured by EMCORE, Inc.[TMIn this system, high speed rotation of the wafer carrier was employed to stabilize the gas flow in the reactor at a growth temperature of-1500~ The resulting epitaxial layers were characterized to have breakdown strengths of 2 MV/cm, electron mobility of 700 cm2/V.s in lightly doped 4H-SiC epitaxy, and a background concentration of approximately 2 x 1014 cm-3 (boron). Doping levels were controlled over a magnitude order range of three. Other work using hot-wall CVD reactors has produced impressive results, with 45 ~rn thick epitaxial layers grown and used in 100 ~tm diameter 4.5 kV diodes. [74]
Figure 8. A horizontal Vapor Phase Epitaxy (VPE) growth system used to grow SiC epitaxy at rates of~3 mm/h at temperatures of 1500-1600~ Photo courtesy of Northrop Grumman.
For homoepitaxial growth of 6H-SiC, the substrates used are normally silicon-face, 3.5 degree off-axis, while for homoepitaxial growth of 4H-SiC, silicon-face 8 degree off-axis substrates are generally used. The reason for the difference in off-axis angle for the different polytypes is based upon the greater step height in 4H-SiC. Using on-axis or non-optimized
196
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
off-axis wafers or non-optimized growth conditions for growth of epitaxy results in the formation of triangular morphological defects, caused by inclusions of 3C-SiC which interrupt the step flow mode of growth. These defects have been shown to cause high leakage currents in diodes. These and other surface morphology defects such as Si-droplet formation, faceting, and hillocks are reported in greater depth elsewhere.[43][73] Nitrogen and aluminum doping have been investigated for many years; however, residual doping levels were too high for many devices. The discovery of the site-competition effect[ 611for Si-face SiC epitaxy enabled the reduction of residual doping levels to 1014c m "3 and intentional incorporation over the entire range of possible concentrations. An example of controlling the nitrogen doping of SiC via gas Si/C gas ratio during growth is seen in Fig. 9,[75] for the same reactor as pictured in Fig. 8. This discovery has opened the way for much of the device results shown in subsequent sections. The site-competition effect works by adjusting the Si/C source gas ratio in the growth reactor to control the amount of dopant incorporated into substitutional SiC crystal lattice sites.[63] The model is based upon N and C competition for C sites, with AI and Si competition for Si sites in the SiC lattice. This effect has also been observed for boron and phosphorous doping of SiC.[61]Growth on Cface substrates has behaved quite differently, and more work is still needed to fully understand all growth mechanisms[ 611and tie together behavior on both faces. Numerous industrial and university laboratories now produce homoepitaxial, device-quality growth of SiC.
~I - - - l x 1 0 ]u
E t-
.s ~ c-
o
o
lx10
18
I xlO 11
1• lx10
L,.
]~ 15 ,
,--,_ 9,9 lx1014 o
J
,h.
[] i
, / / ' 6 "~'-
lx10
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
h pu t SJ IC Ratio
Figure9. Controlof doping demonstratedby varyingthe Si/Cgas ratio. TakenfromRef. 75.
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
197
Ion Implantation. Ion implantation is also proving to be a vital component of device processing in the absence of a usable diffusion process. Ion implantation has several critical roles in device fabrication. First, high-dose, shallow depth implants are often used in order to reduce the contact resistance to SiC. This type of implant is of particular importance when forming a contact to a lightly doped layer. A common example would be to use implantation to form n § drain and source regions in an n-channel SiC MOSFET. Nitrogen implants are typically used to form n § regions while aluminum implants are normally done to form p+ regions. A second use for ion implantation would be to form the p-wells in CMOS and planar power MOSFET's. Obtaining a deep implant into SiC is particularly difficult. Typical implant systems have energy limits of around 400 keV, which is insufficient for implants of >0.8 ~tm depth. Higher energy implants using MeV range energies offer the promise of deeper implants, but the amount of crystal damage may be very high, and impossible to remove. Numerous papers may be found in the literature regarding dopant ion implantation into SIC.[ 76]-[94]Finding the optimum high-temperature implant (eg., 500~ to 1000~ and subsequent high-temperature anneal (eg., 500~ to 1700~ which will fully activate the dopants, prevent amorphization of SiC, and not cause damage to SiC epitaxial layers (remembering that SiC epitaxial layers are typically grown at temperatures <1700~ has proven challenging. A summary of the best reported sheet resistivity values for post-implanted n-type and p-type SiC surfaces is shown in Figs. 10 and 11, respectively. Two typical examples of recent work which contain information on nitrogen, boron, and aluminum implants are found in Refs. 77 and 88, although several other comparable papers exist. Of particular concern has been the p-type implant. Boron has proven easier to implant for deeper implants ( >0.5 Ixm) than A1 because A1 has greater atomic mass than B and causes much more lattice damage. High-temperature ion implantation is preferred, since room temperature ion implantation results in amorphized material, while high-temperature implants do not. In Ref. 87, A1 and N implants were performed at 850~ and 700~ respectively, into Si-face, (100) 6H-SiC, followed by a 10-45 minute anneal at 1100~ to 1650~ in Argon. All implants were single energy implants ranging from 50 keV to 3 MeV. SIMS (secondary ion mass spectroscopy) analysis revealed no N redistribution after anneal, although a slight out-diffusion of A1 was reported. Also, due to its higher atomic mass, A1 implants caused more lattice damage than N implants as confirmed from RBS (Rutherford backscattering) data. Aluminum, because of its deep acceptor level and large mass, was not fully activated at anneal temperatures less than 1500~ indicating
198
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
that higher anneal temperatures are necessary for A1. Si and C co-implantations were also performed in attempts to increase A1 activation, but C had no effect and Si co-implantation decreased dopant activation.[S7H ss]
101 '
al.
' J . Gar(Iha', et
' ...... w
.......
J. Bec. Ma1:.,25,885[1996) im plant t mz p. = 700 *(2 adnneed temp. = 161)0 *C anneal l i m e : 15 rain. 9 j \ j i i
-
C
i '5
io o
T. Kimot o, etal. j . R ec. M~., ~ , 2 3 ~ 1995) implant t r a p . = 23 *C ormeed temp. = 1500 anneal t i m e - 3Omin.
3
!
.- ........................... , ........................... .~. ...... ~ ...... . ................
_
mm
4-1 m
-
i
-
.
:
.
~
:
lib
41o
*
mi
N. mnoue,:~t d .
-'
m
.
er~
I
Inst. Phys. C m f . S
3
"
No. H2, 525 (199q implant tem p = 5 0 0 - 860 "C anneed tmzp = 1500 anneal tim e = 30 rain. , , , , ,,,I
1 0 "i
!
1 0 is
l
I
l
I
I Ill
l
I
l
1014 Implant
I
i
I Ill
1 0 ts Dose
I
1 0 le
l
I
l
l
l
Ill
1017
(cm -z)
Figure 10. Best reported sheet resistivity in n-type SiC as a function of implant dose. Implant and anneal temperatures (including references) are given. Figure courtesy of J. Cooper, Purdue University.
The effect of implant temperature is still not fully understood, but studies investigating it have revealed some key information. In one such study, [89] N implants at various temperatures into 4H-SiC and 6H-SiC ptype epi layers were examined. When the total dose exceeded 4 x 10 ]5 cm2, room temperature implants resulted in the creation of a totally amorphous layer, which remained heavily damaged even after high-temperature (1500~ anneals. Under the same high-dose conditions, the damaged regions could be annealed back to almost perfect crystallinity if a hightemperature implant was used. However, to achieve full activation of
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
199
implanted N, annealing temperatures in excess of 1500~ should be used. When comparing high-temperature implants from 500-950~ it was also found that the surface of the 950~ implanted material was Si depleted; graphitic C-C bonds were observed, while the 800~ implanted material retained the stoichiometric composition as verified by XPS (x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy). This is consistent with earlier research which has found that the surface of SiC at high-temperatures undergoes a preferential desorption of Si atoms resulting in graphitic layers formed on the surface. Thus, after ion implant and/or anneal temperatures which exceed-~950~ a sacrificial oxidation is normally performed to consume the (often conductive) graphitic surface. Another method to prevent loss of Si and maintain surface morphology has been to anneal in a silane (silicon) ambient. This has been demonstrated using an epitaxy reactor by ABB, Cree Research, and Mississippi State University with extremely promising results, as shown in Fig. 12.
1 0s
'
'
'
'
'
''''I
'
.
,
,
,
If,,|
.
,
.
,
li,,]
,
i
i
,
,,ij.
-"
." 9
T. K i ~ t o , ~ al.
-
~
J. Elec. Mat..25.879(1996) -
-
!
.=
!
i 1 i
C
1 0a
.............................
implant temp. = 23 ~ anneal tonnp. = 1500 ~
~ ............. .ann~..I
:
...
i i i
i9
:.
9 ...
:9 i
i :
:9
'5 m m
.m
o,m
~
: : i
i
.m
t ~ e = 30 min.
O
m .
"
:"9
-
O
101
!. . . . . . . . . .i.. .. .. . . . . . .j........ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .!. . . . . . . . . .
3
.=
.."
9 9
10 0 1 0 ~s
, i ,,,,,,I
I , ,,,,,,I
1014
101~
Impl an t D o s e
I
I
I
I
IIIII
1016
I
I
I
I
IIII
1017
(cm- z )
Figure 11. Best reported sheet resistivity in p-type SiC as a function of implant dose. Implant and anneal temperatures (including references) are given. Figure courtesy of J. Cooper, Purdue University.
200
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
N, c m "3
10 ~8
:....
N, cm "3
.:..
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
:-..-..
::: : . . : .
-..::
9::..
:
.... ::
.:.....-.
10'*
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
10 '7 10 ~T I 0 ~6
10 ~=
t4
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
Depth, l~m
10 0.25
i
0.30
0,35
0.40
Depth, I~m
Figure 12. Implant activation of Al-implanted (p-type) SiC is demonstrated by CV extracted dopant density before and after anneal. Anneal was performed at 1600~ in an epitaxy reactor with silane overpressure. (Figure courtesy of Dr. S. Saddow, Mississippi State University.)
Other work has looked at implantation of hydrogen and boron into SiC. Hydrogen is important to study because it is present in high concentrations during the epitaxial growth process, and because it also plays a significant role in affecting the SiC/SiO 2 interface. In Ref. 94, boron was implanted at 700~ 350 keV and a dose of 1014 cm "2, and then activated by a 1700~ anneal in a SiC container with an argon atmosphere. The resulting junction depth (at-1018 cm -3) was 0.6 ~tm. Unlike N implantation, the activation anneal can result in appreciable diffusion of the boron implant species. Implanting hydrogen at the same dose (T = 80 K, energy of 80 keV) yielded a concentration of 5 x 1018cm -3 at the same junction depth, and subsequent low temperature photoluminescence has indicated the presence of defects incorporating implanted boron. Little has been reported on the use of MeV implants for the formation of p-type wells in planar CMOS and power device structures. However, the issue ofrecrystallization in MeV implanted 6H-SiC has been examined experimentally in Ref. 93. Wafers of 6H-SiC (0001) were implanted using a tandem accelerator at 160~ with 8 MeV Si 3+ ions (dose = 1 x 1016 c m "2) at a 7 ~ tilt from the [0001 ] direction to prevent channeling. The goal of this implant was to obtain a 1 ~tm deep amorphous SiC layer, and the implant was followed by a 30 minute, 1000~ implant anneal in nitrogen for recrystallization. Cross-sectional TEM micrographs revealed amorphous layers
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
201
between 2.6 and 3.4 ~tm from the substrate surface before anneal. Surprisingly, from diffraction pattems, the amorphous layer was completely recrystallized after the anneal, indicating a much lower temperature anneal is required than for keV implants which typically require anneals in excess of 1450~ Also noted was the presence of 3C-SiC material in the midst ofthe recrystallized 6H-SiC, which apparently grows epitaxially in the recrystallized region. Finally, while layer-by-layer growth of 6H-SiC occurred initially during the recrystallization, columnar growth of 6H-SiC followed along with epitaxial growth of 3C-SiC during the recrystallization process. The resulting mismatch between layer by layer growth and columnar growth resulted in stacking fault formation in the columnar 6H-SiC. To summarize SiC doping techniques, both ion implantation and epitaxial controlled doping should both prove vital processes for SiC device fabrication. Ion implantation has the advantage of selective doping, which is important for complementary logic structures, power device termination, and isolation. Ion implantation also results in a more planar device topology as compared to strict epitaxially controlled doping techniques, which have benefits in terms of photolithographic resolution, uniform final passivation coverage, and similar issues. Epitaxial doping has the advantage of not inducing lattice damage which eliminates the need for a high~ temperature anneal and the requisite creation of defects. Also, micropipe defects may affect ion implanted doping profiles by channeling the implanted species deeper into the SiC. Epitaxial regrowth after ion implantation, or annealing in a silane ambient to protect surface morphology, shows the vital link between implant and epitaxy required for advanced device fabrication. Al-implanted 4H-SiC in an epitaxy reactor with silane overpressure is shown in Fig. 12.
2.3
Etching of Silicon Carbide
Wet etching of SiC has not proven to be feasible from a practical device processing standpoint, as it requires molten salts (for example, NaOH-KOH at 350~ to be used at high temperatures. The difficulty encountered in etching SiC results from the high bond strength, a property which makes SiC useful for high-temperature operation, but a hindrance in fabrication. Nonetheless, numerous dry etches (primarily focused on Reactive Ion Etching processes) have been developed for the various polytypes of SiC. [96]-[120] Electron Cyclotron Resonance (ECR) etching has also been employed. [1111-[1141Most published RIE etches all make use of fluorinated gases (typically SF6, CHF3, CBrF3, CF4, NF3) to etch SiC, although etch rates
202
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
of 1900 A/minute have been obtained in 6H-SiC using a chloride-based (C12/SIC14/O2) etch with SiO2 mask.J1~ RIE etch rates of 6H-SiC and 4H-SiC are typically slow in comparison to Si (300 A/minute to 2000 A/minute), with residue-formation problems commonly found, although not prevalent in all etches. A good overview of SiC etching is also found in the text, Properties of Silicon Carbide. [95] Etching of silicon in fluorinated gas has been found to occur by the reaction mechanism below: Eq. (2)
Si + 4F ---~SiF4
The removal of C has been debated in the literature, with some works indicating that addition of oxygen removes the C, as illustrated by Eqs. 3 and 4. Others claim that the C removal is via physical bombardment (see Eq. 5) or reactive chemistry between the fluorine and carbon. Depending upon the etch chemistry and process parameters (RF power, chamber pressure, electrode area and spacing, etc.), any one of the three mechanisms may actually dominate. Three of the most common fluorinated RIE mechanisms for removal of C proposed in the literature are listed below in Eqs. 3-5: Eq. (3)
C + xO -->CO o r
Eq. (4)
C + xF --~CF4 or CF 2
Eq. (5)
Physical (Ionic) Bombardment
CO 2
Several examples of residue-free RIE of 6H- and 4H-SiC can found in the literature.[96]-[99][l~176176176 For RIE with high etch rates and low surface damage, using high pressure (in comparison to the normal 10 to 100 mT pressures used in RIE) etch recipes seems to be prevalent. For example, in Ref. 97, high etch rates (-~1500 A/minute) were obtained using only NF 3 in a high-pressure (225 mT) RIE recipe. Using a commercial DryTek Quad 400 system, the RF power was 275 W, and the self-induced bias was only 25-50 V. A SEM of a typical sample after RIE is shown in Fig. 13.[97] Another group, using a Plasmatherm Series 790, experimented with 190 mT etch recipes using SF 6 or CF4, and N 2 and 0 2 additives in etching 6H-SiC.[ 1181The peak etch rate was found to be ---2600 A/minute for the following parameters: pressure: 190 mT; SF6 gas flow: 40 seem; 02 gas flow: 10.6 seem; and power: 300 W. Additionally, from atomic force microscopy, a 150 s etch was sufficient to actually remove residual damage leR from the as polished surface. Others have also reported high etch rates of up to 2200 A/minute at 82%O2/18~ r e m o t e plasmas at 330~ [1~176 This etch
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
203
produced minimal surface damage since the SiC sample was etched downstream (about 50 cm) from the microwave generated (400 W @ 2.45 GHz) plasma and the pressure was nearly 1 T. This particular etch was performed on the carbon face of 6H-SiC using an evaporated 500 nm thick aluminum mask. When performing the same etch on silicon-face 6H-SiC, higher percentages of 0 2 (~80%) were required to achieve the same high etch rates.
,i
t (a)
(b)
Figure 13. Scanning Electron Microscope(SEM) photographwith (a) 18.1 kX magnification of a 4H-SiC sample, and (b) 3 kX magnification of an etched profile for a 6H-SiC sample. Taken from Ref. 97.
Obtaining a very low etch rate is also important in many device fabrication unit steps. For example, in the fabrication of a bipolar transistor, when making contact to the very thin base region (as thin as 10 nm), it is critical to have a very slow and well-controlled etch recipe. Several etch recipes utilizing R/E at lower pressures (--10-100 mT) and high selfinduced bias (>300 V) can also be found in the literature.[961199]These etch processes often produce more surface damage,Ilia] but are critically needed in some processes. Perhaps because of the high self-induced bias, aluminum micromasking, which may be a result of aluminum being etched from the powered electrode or the mask material, is more common in these etch recipes. Covering the electrode with graphite and/or adding hydrogen to the fluorinated gas chemistry has been shown effective in preventing residue formation.[961[1~176
204
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
While higher pressure etches have been used to obtain low surface damage, residue-free etching, and high etch rates, other approaches have also been utilized towards those goals. ECR etching has been shown to produce very smooth etched surfaces, and the degree of etch anisotropity can be controlled by the substrate bias.[ 113]ECR etching has the advantages of higher density plasma and independent control of the substrate bias in comparison to RIE etching. When comparing similar RIE and ECR processes using a CF4/O 2 mixture, it was found that the RIE process significantly damaged the SiC surface and also left A1, F, and O impurities on the sidewalls. The ECR process did not.[ 114]The surface damage was measured by comparing the Schottky barrier height of Pd Schottky diodes on ECR etched, RIE etched, and unetched SiC surfaces. However, this particular RIE process has a very high self-induced bias (500 V) in comparison to other SiC RIE processes;[99][ 118]this comparison may vary for different RIE processes. The ECR etching of single crystalline 4H-SiC cantilever structures using a combination of high and low substrate bias has been demonstrated.[ 113]Using a sputtered indium-tin oxide mask, results of ECR etching of 4H-SiC and 6H-SiC in a 1 mT, 17%O2/83%CF 4 plasma indicated a strong dependence of etch rate and etching isotropy on the position of the sample relative to the ECR plasma and the substrate bias. High substrate bias (100 V) produced smoother surfaces and higher etch rates (700 A/minute), but also exhibited trenching (deep trenches at the bottom comers of the etched patterns). Another form of etching has also recently been reported for SiC utilizing Inductively Coupled Plasma (ICP) etching. ICP creates a much denser plasma than traditional RIE by using two RF power supplies instead of one. ICP etching has shown to offer low surface damage, residue-free etching, and fairly high etch rates. Plasma densities in the 1 x 1011 to 1 • 10 ~2ions cm -3 range can be obtained, with the incident ion energy controlled independently by decoupling plasma generation power and bias power. Preliminary ICP etching of 6H-SiC in CF 4 and 0 2 has been investigated using a commercial PlasmaTherm ICP etching system.[ 1191 Using ITO masks, peak etch rates of 1500 A/minute were obtained at 900 W. Sample bias was varied from 10-60 V, with higher etch rates obtained for higher bias values. Using Schottky diodes, the ideality factor (1.1) was the same for both ICP etched and non-etched 6H-SiC. Additionally, the leakage currents of both sets of diodes was similar, indicating that the surface damage was minimal. A cross-sectional SEM of trenches etched into SiC using ICP etching is shown in Fig. 14.
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
205
Figure 14: SEM of SiC trenches etched using an Inductively Coupled Plasma (ICP) etch process. Photo courtesy of J. Zhao, Rutgers University. Photoelectrochemical etching (PEC) of SiC has produced very high etch rates. Several examples can be found on PEC as well, but ICP, RIE, and ECR etching currently appear more compatible with small-feature device processing (for example see Ref. 117). However, etch rates of up to 25 lam/min, for n-type 6H and 3C-SiC have been reported with dopantselective etch stops possible,[ 12~ which may be of use in deep trench or via etching. The dopant-selective etch stop could also be of great importance when etching back to make contact to very thin epitaxial layers of SiC, such as the base layer of a SiC bipolar junction transistor. The etch process is briefly described as a hole-catalyzed surface dissolution, with the holes supplied from bulk p-type SiC or from I_W photogeneration in n or p-type SiC. The transfer of holes into the electrolyte promote oxidation of the surface. The oxide is removed with the HF acid contained in the electrolyte.
206
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
2.4
Oxidation and Passivation of SiC
The ability of SiC to oxidize and form SiO 2 has allowed compatibility with standard silicon-based fabrication. Obtaining a high-quality oxide with low interface state and oxide trap densities has proven to be challenging because of the carbon on the surface, as well as off-axis epitaxial layers which often have rough surface morphologies. Thermal oxidation rates are considerably slower than that of silicon, so typical oxidation temperatures for SiC are often higher than those ofSi (-~1050-1200~ Growth rates of SiO 2 on p-type 6H-SiC are shown in Fig. 15 [124] for both wet and dry oxidation, as well as silicon-face and carbon-face material. Growth on carbon-face SiC is much higher (-5 X) than the growth on silicon-face SiC. The slower oxide growth on Si-face material has been attributed to an interracial oxide layer (Si4C4.xO2 with X -2), identified by angle resolved xray photoelectron spectroscopic analysis, which forms on the Si-face 6HSiC surface and retards the oxidation rate.[1221[142]6H-SiC was polished and cleaned by HF and R/E, and then oxidized for 15 min. at 1100~ in dry O 2. The interracial layer, which has a thickness of about 1 nm situated between SiC and SiO2, is believed to be a reaction product of molecular oxygen bonded peroxidically to a SiC double layer. This interfacial layer can react with oxygen to form Si4C404, SiO2, and CO.[ 122]No interracial layer was found on the carbon-face material, but both silicon-face and carbon-face material had layers of graphite, CxHyOz, and Si4C404 formed on the surface of the oxide. The above discussion of oxide growth and quality is true for oxides grown on standard silicon-face (0001) and carbon-face (000]-) surfaces. The oxide growth rate and quality also varies considerably for other crystal orientations such as (1120) and (1]-00) a-axis orientations.[ 123]Generally, the growth rate on a-axis orientations is 3-5 times higher than that of the silicon-face c-axis SiC material, and the interface state densities are 4-10 times higher as well. This has important ramifications for UMOSFETs, VMOSFETs, and other trench gate MOSFETs in SiC. As an example, a cross-sectional SEM from a 4H-SiC UMOSFET is shown in Fig. 16. The thin white line along the edge of the U trench is SiO2, and as can be seen, this oxide is thicker along the sidewalls than on the bottom of the trench. The higher sidewall Dit also is detrimental to device performance by limiting channel mobility and thus increasing the on-resistance of the device. The high fields present in the device often cause breakdown of the gate oxide via field crowding at the comers of the UMOS trench. The vertical
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
207
sidewalls problems relating to variation of oxide growth and quality are also well documented elsewhere.[127][133][16~
2,5 1126 "C
1200 9
E =l. 2,0 c
1090 ~
1,5
Jg .o_
1050 ~
.~_ 1,0
1125 "C
X 0
1090 ~
0,5 1050 "C 0'00
100
200
300
400
oxidation time [hi
! O~ E ~2
Q
i' 0
l I ...
0
1125 "C ~ - - f ~ .
20
40
1090 '~:
1060"C
.....
4 ....
60
80
,c
100
120
oxidation time [hi
Figure 15. Oxidation rates in dry (upper) and wet (lower) 0 2 environments for p-type 6HSiC. Open symbols are for C-face and solid symbols are for Si-face. Taken from Ref. 124.
208
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Figure 16. Cross-sectional SEM of a completed 4H-SiC UMOSFET.The thin white region is identified as the gate oxide, with a thicker polysilicon layerdeposited over the gate oxide.
Photo courtesy of Northrop Grumman.
Numerous studies have been published about cleaning and oxidation procedures.[ 121]-[160]The goal of low (comparable with silicon) interface state densities is close to fulfillment. One cause attributed to high interface state density of oxides on SiC is that of C. The problem of C at the SiC-SiO 2 interface is compounded by the high temperatures required for reasonable oxidation rates. When exposed to these high temperatures, the surface of SiC often undergoes a preferential loss of Si, resulting in a graphitic surface layer increasing the carbon concentration.[ 155] Three distinct temperature regimes have been identified for 6H and 15R-SiC. Below 900 K (627~ no graphitization of the SiC surface is observed. Between 900 K (627~ and 1300 K (1027~ both Si-face (0001) and C-face (000T) SiC surfaces are terminated in a surface graphite layer. Above 1300 K (1027~ the C-face SiC graphitizes at a rate higher than the Si-face SiC. Both surfaces exhibit massive graphitization above 1027~ as a result of Si sublimation from the SiC surfaces.[ 155] Because of this problem, SiC wafers are otten loaded into oxidation fumaces at lower temperatures (<950~ in an oxidizing environment, then ramped to a higher temperature (1100-1200~ to obtain the desired oxide thickness. Finally, they are ramped back down to a lower temperature in an oxidizing environment for annealing and/or unloading of the
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
209
wafers. This technique has proven effective in lowering the interface trap density on Si-face 6H-SiC to near 1 x 1011per (cm2/eV).[121][13~ In SiC, unlike Si, it is important that C-V measurements be performed at high temperatures (>300~ in order to see the response time of interface states lying deep (>0.6 eV) in the bandgap of SiC. Standard roomtemperature C-V analysis will not reveal the true interface state density. Care must also be exercised because of the large surface potential fluctuations present in SiC C-V measurements.[ 138]J. N. Shenoy et al.[ TM]reported interface state densities (Dit) near the 1 x 1011 per (cm2/eV) order of magnitude, and fixed oxide charge (Qox)of 1 x 1012 (C/cm 2) in thermally grown SiO 2 on 6H-SiC. Another method of reducing Bit and Qo, has been to perform post oxidation anneals in oxidizing environments.[ 156]On p-type (Al-doped) silicon-face 6H-SiC epitaxial layers,Dit of 1 x 1011 cm 2/eV and Qox of 1.0 x 1012 cm-2 was measured on the best oxide, which used a 1050~ oxidation (25 h) and a 3 h post-oxidation anneal in 0 2 at 950~ The interface trap density was extracted using the conductance technique, with measurements taken at 250~ Post-oxidation anneals in oxygen may have a secondary benefit, which would be densification of the SiO 2 to increase oxide reliability and strength. This is evidenced by the high breakdown strength of these oxides (up to 11.5 MV/cm). Time-dependent dielectric breakdown results on these oxides indicated lifetimes of 700 years at 2 MV/cm and 350~ when testing under a negative bias on p-type 6HSiC.[ 158]However, under positive bias on n-type 6H-SiC, the lifetime was significantly less, although no specific numbers were reported. Positive bias stressing was not performed on oxides grown on p-type 6H-SiC, due to the difficulty in forming inversion. The apparent unreliability of oxides under positive bias can also be supported by the finding of hole traps in oxides on SiC (which were not treated to the same annealing conditions).[157] The hole traps (in oxides grown at 1120~ in dry 0 2 with standard 1 h Ar anneal) were found to be related to oxygen vacancies in the oxide, and no direct contribution of impurities such as A1 or C to the trapping was observed. Additionally, thermally unstable interface states were generated during hole injection at the SiC/SiO 2 interface, similar to that of SiO 2 on Si. All of the reliability issues are further supported by the evidence of Fowler-Nordheim tunneling across oxides grown o n SiC. [133][160] That FN injection is more severe for the SiC MOS system is not surprising considering the wide bandgap and reduced transport barrier of the SiC MOS system as compared to silicon. For example, Fig. 17 compares the bandgap, electron affinity, and subsequent barrier for tunneling of silicon, 6H-SiC, and 4HSiC MOS systems via an energy band diagram. In 4H-SiC, the barrier for
210
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
electrons in the conduction band is only 2.70 eV as compared to 3.15 eV in Si. Thus, the Fowler-Nordheim tunneling probability (exponentially dependent upon the electron barrier height) is much higher for SiC, especially at elevated temperature and bias where SiC has many targeted applications. In fact, for a 4H-SiC n-channel power MOSFET, it has been recommended that the maximum positive applied bias be limited to 1.5 MV/cm at room temperature[1601 which in tum limits the maximum gate bias applied under the on-condition as well as placing constraints on the doping of the p-type channel. Type 6H-SiC is also preferred for MOSFET devices since 4H-SiC has a higher Dit at the conduction band edge.
Z l
3.15
1.1,Si
2.95
T
2.70eV
,,. ~ - E o
? 2.85
3.25
'
,
,
i
3.2
3.05
6H-SiC 4H-SiCI 9.0 eV s!c2
4.75
Figure 17. The energy band offsets of 6H-SiC and 4H-SiC with respect to SiO 2. The barrier for electron injection from 4H-SiC into SiO 2 conduction band is significantly lower than silicon. Taken from Ref.4.
Other high-temperature, high-power operation and reliability issues remain to be addressed. Alternative insulators (such as nitrides and oxynitrides) are also being pursued for high-temperature device applications, just as in the silicon industry. One example involves thermal oxidation of SiC in N 2 0 . [152] Diffusion of CO through the oxynitride was attributed to be the limiting factor in oxidation, and Qoxwas reported to be on the order of 1 x 1012C/cm2. The oxidation rate was found to be initially parabolic with time, eventually switching to linear after some
211
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
time, just as the case for Si. It is believed that the introduction of nitrogen into the oxide (or oxynitride) should reduce the Dit, although no specific numbers were mentioned in this work. Other work involving the annealing of oxides with N20 has not proven successful initially, although anneals in NO have shown promise for improvement of oxides on p-type SiC. [159] A quantitative and practical assessment of using thermally grown gate oxides in SiC devices has also been done by researchers at General Electric. [154]Because doping of SiC devices is via implantation or epitaxial growth, most MOSFET devices are fabricated using a non self-aligned process. In fact, the drain/source implantation' s are normally done prior to gate oxide growth. Since the structure is non self-aligned, the gate oxide will partially overlap the implanted drain/source regions. However, thermally grown SiO 2 on implanted regions of SiC has a breakdown strength of only 1-6 MV/cm as compared to 10 MV/cm on non-implanted regions. Premature breakdown of SiO 2 grown on implanted 6H-SiC is shown graphically by Fig. 18. Premature breakdown of the gate oxide in SiC MOSFETs fabricated using this type of process is thus to be expected.
dlO
T = 380~ C 30
1
20
10
0
1
2
3
4
8
8
T
tl
g
10
S (My/era)
(a) Figure 18. (a) BreakdownofSiO2on implantedSiC surfaces.ReproducedfromRef.154. (b) Breakdown of S i O 2 o n non-implantedSiC surfaces. Reproducedfrom Ref.154.
212
4~
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
--
T m 3110"C
w
~0"
i.i 10
0 0
1
2
$
4
5
8
?
II
I)
E (UV/~)
(b) Figure 18. (Cont'd.)
2.5
Ohmic Contacts to Silicon Carbide
Low resistivity ohmic contacts are essential for high-frequency operation. Additionally, high-temperature and high-power requirements maintain that the contacts must be reliable under extreme conditions. Once seen as one of the primary impediments to SiC technological development, the ohmic contact area has now matured rapidly.[161]-[189] An area still requiring extensive work, however, is that of ohmic contacts to p-type SiC. The p-type contact to SiC is made difficult because ofthe wide bandgap of SiC. As illustrated in Fig. 19 bythe thermal equilibrium metal-semiconductor band diagram (q~M < q~sic), the Schottky barrier (OB) to majority carrier transport must be reduced as much as possible in order to provide for an ohmic contact. Since the bandgap and electron affinity (c) of SiC are fixed, the remaining options for reducing the ~B are to choose a metal with a large work function (OM), and also to dope the ptype SiC as heavily as possible. P-type ohmic contacts to SiC often use some variation of A1/Ti alloys. A contact with specific contact resistance measured at 1.5 x 10-5 f~.cm 2 on Al-doped samples (NA = 2 x 1019 cm -3)
Processing of Silicon Carbidefor Devices and Circuits
213
has been reported by J. Crofton et al.[161]using an A1/Ti alloy. The specific contact resistance is a strong function of doping (seen clearly by Fig. 20, where the specific contact resistance is plotted as a function of doping for the A1/Ti alloy contact). Although A1 melts at ~660~ a 90:10 AI:Ti alloy (by weight) is a mixture of solid and liquid phase at temperatures of 9501150~ which are typical anneal temperatures used in the formation of ohmic contacts to SIC.[161]-[163] More recent experiments using a 90:10 AI:Ti alloy has yielded specific contact resistance ranging from 5 x 10 -6 to 3 x 10 "5 f2ocm 2 on p-type 6H-SiC doped at 1.3 x 1019 cm -3. On the same material, pure Ti (with a 1 minute, 800~ anneal) was also used to form ohmic contacts with specific contact resistance ranging from 2-4 x 10-5 f2.cm 2. Etching off the metals after annealing revealed that the Al-based contact spiked into the SiC, evidenced by pits in the SiC surface up to 2600 A deep, while the Ti contact exhibited little interfacial reaction. Thus, although Al-based contacts can yield exceptionally low specific contact resistances, the contact can suffer from poor reproducibility and aluminum oxidation during annealing (A1203). [164]
Eo
metal
~
p-type 4H-SiC '! Z = 2.70 eVNo
....... l !l
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
E F
Figure 19. Band diagram of metal and p-type 4H-SiC before and after making contact ignoring any effects of Fermi-level surfacepruning.
214
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
10 -1
...... ' "
'--"
""-"1
9 '"-'~;;:"~
0 I
.....
w
. . . . .
"I
~ ..... " = " - ' ~ " ' ~
ClUW p - t l r p o 6 H - S t C
A
Net
.... "'"';""
H
10 - t
'
o.av ev
Zb -
e o 9
~,o
10
-3
0
p.
IIle ~ aIp
10
9 ,~
...-4
m
'~
O-S
0 0
10 "e 10 is
9
a A 9149
.... J_
10 is
__J__ 9
~__
9
10 ~7 doptnft
9A s---J
9
9~ . 9
10 TM lout 3
101o
9 A ,L . * * -
10 zo
)
Figure 20. Specific contact resistance as a function of doping on p-type 6H-SiC using an AI/ Ti alloy for ohmic contact. Taken from Ref. 161.
Because A1 is easily oxidized, other contacts such as boron carbide (for example, B4C), Ta, Ti, cobalt silicides[ 162]and Mo may prove to be superior for high-temperature ohmic p-type contact. As an example, refractory metal boride ohmic contacts to p-type 6H-SiC (doped at 1.3 x 1019 cm -3 with A1) have recently been reported.[ 1651Short anneals (2-10 min.) at 1100~ in vacuum (5 x 10-7 torr) yielded specific contact resistance of 8.2 x 10-5 f2.cm 2 for CrB 2 and 5.8 x 10-5 f2.cm 2 for W2B. Experiments with TiB 2 were also performed, but with varying results. Longer anneals lowered the specific contact resistance values further. Recent studies have indicated that formation of cobalt silicide (CoSi2) may prove to be a thermally stable, low-resistance ohmic contact with a specific contact resistance of <4 x 10-6 f2.cm 2 reported on very heavily doped (2.0 x 1019 cm -3) p-type 6H-SiC.[ ]62] This particular contact was formed by depositing
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
215
sequential layers of Co (50 nm) and Si (160 nm) followed by a two-step anneal at 500~ for 5 h then 900~ for 2 h. N-type contacts have been formed from a variety of silicides and carbides (such as Ni2Si and CoSi2). To our knowledge, the n-type contact based on nickel silicide (Ni2Si)[167]currently has been reported to have the lowest specific contact resistance (<5 x 10-6 f2.cm2 on 6H-SiC doped 7-9 x 1018cm-3), and has actually been reported to have lower contact resistance at 500~ than at room temperature. Other ohmic contacts using TiC to n-type 6H-SiC have also shown promise, but with somewhat higher contact resistances.[ 168]Numerous other metal contacts to n-type SiC have been tried, including Re, Pt, Ta, and titanium nitride.[174][181]Reliability studies are only now taking place.[ 169]Although preliminary results are encouraging, the best ohmic contact for high-temperature operation is still in question. Packaging issues and composite contact delamination at high temperatures must still be addressed. N-type ohmic contacts using NiCr may prove advantageous from contact delamination, reliability, and wirebonding issues.[ 182]Other work which may be advantageous from the point of postoxidation device processing includes research on low-temperature annealing cycles, or even ohmic contacts which are ohmic as deposited.[ 17~ High-temperature anneals (for instance of 1000~ [167] could degrade the interface quality and reliability of thermally grown oxides.[13~ Thus, slowly ramped anneals held to lower temperatures for longer time periods are sometimes preferred for annealing devices with MOS structures.
2.6
Schottky Contacts
Increasing the Schottky barrier height is extremely important for elevating the maximum operating temperature for Metal Semiconductor Field Effect Transistors (MESFETs) and Schottky rectifiers. While MESFET's are discussed below, some recent work on Schottky diodes[189][207]is quite worthy of further review. One of the primary uses of Schottky contacts on SiC, other than that of a gate metal in MESFETs, is for use in efficient, solid state, high-voltage switching applications,[ 1971which could prove to be an important market for SiC electronics. Taking advantage of SiC's high critical electric field for breakdown, it is projected that SiC Schottky diodes will have specific on-resistances much (up to 200 times) lower than that of Si. Metals used for Schottky contacts to SiC include Ni, NiCr, Au, Pt, Ti, Mg, Co, A1, and Pd. Actual Schottky barrier heights (SBHs) depend upon the surface quality of material, metal deposition process, polytype, conductivity
216
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
(n-type or p-type), and whether the surface is Si-face or C-face. In addition, the measured SBH also depends upon the measurement technique (with CV measurements often yielding higher numbers than I-V measurements). Since C-V and I-V measurements often depend upon several factors, the actual SBH may lie somewhere between these measured values. Internal photoemission spectroscopy has also been used since this method is not dependent upon leakage current, series resistance, and variable ideality factors.[ 19~ On Si-face, 6H-SiC, Au and Ni possess two of the highest Schottky barriers of ~1.47 eV and 1.27 eV, respectively.[ 195] Tabulated values of SBH for Ti, Ni, and Au on 4H-SiC (both C-face and Si-face) measured by C-V, I-V, and internal photoemission spectroscopy are shown in Table 4 (reproduced from Ref. 190). Table 4. Schottky Barrier Heights of Au, Ni, and Ti on N-type 4H-SiC
Metal
Au Ni Ti
Surface
q)BI-V
~OBC-V
q)BIPE
Polarity
(v)
CO
6O
C
1.80
2.10
2.07
1.20
Si
1.73
1.85
1.81
1.08
C
1.60
1.90
1.87
1.08
Si
1.62
1.75
1.69
1.02
C
1.16
1.30
1.25
1.04
Si
0.95
1.17
1.09
1.03
IPE:intemal photoemission
As mentioned above, high SBH is desirable for high-temperature device operation because it has an exponential effect on the reverse bias current density. This can be seen from the thermionic emission expression for current density (J) as a function of applied bias shown below in Eq. 6, which assumes no series resistance: Eq. (6)
ex(q 1 where ,Is = A * T "2 exp(-q~s/kT)
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
217
The saturation current (Js), in addition to its strong dependence upon temperature (T), is exponentially dependent upon the SBH. The ideality factor (n) is normally measured to determine the quality of the Schottky diode. Effective Richardson constant (A*) has been defined as 72 A/ cm2K2 in alpha SiC. [166] Although this expression predicts the reverse leakage current for Schottky diodes to be constant (-10 -14 A/cm 2 for a SBH of 1 eV), actual leakage currents in SiC Schottky diodes have been much higher (indicating the presence of other leakage mechanisms). In fact, high reverse leakage currents prior to breakdown in SiC Schottky diodes are a result of mechanisms such as thermionic field emission and field emission.[ 1921 Since these are distinct mechanisms, the tunneling probability as a function of energy through a reverse biased Schottky diode has been approximated and compared to experimental data. The image force lowering of the barrier height was also taken into account. This is extremely important for high-voltage SiC Schottky diodes since the image force lowering of the barrier height is proportional to Emax~ (where Em~ is the maximum electric field at the metal-SiC interface).[ 192] From these calculations, for a SBH of 1.0 eV on 6H-SiC doped at 1 x 1017 cm -3, increasing the temperature from room temperature to 300~ resulted in a projected increase in leakage current by five orders of magnitude; an explanation for the very high observed leakage current in many highvoltage Schottky diodes. A variety of Schottky diodes have been fabricated on SiC. One of the more impressive results to date has been the 1750 V blocking voltage obtained with a Ti Schottky diode on C-face (5 ~ off-axis) n-type 4HSiC.[ TM] The SBH was approximately 1.17 eV for this diode, with an ideality factor of 1.03. The use of C-face material is sometimes desired since for Ni, Ti, and Au, the SBH has been found to be 0.2-0.3 eV higher for C-face than for Si-face material[ 19~ (as shown in Table 4). Ten ~tm thick n-type drift layers were grown via step-controlled epitaxy earned out in Sill 4 (0.30 seem), C3H8 (0.22 seem), and H 2 (3.0 slm) using an atmospheric chemical vapor deposition system at 1560~ 191]Doping density obtained from C-V measurements ranged from 7.0 x 101s cm-3 to ---2.0 x 1016 cm -3. Boron implantation performed at room temperature (energy~ 30 keV, d o s e ~ l . 0 x 1016 cm-2) and annealed at 1050~ was used for edge termination. The Schottky contact physically overlapped the boron implanted layer by about 15 ~tm. Although leaky, (these devices were unpassivated so surface leakage may have been a problem) the devices with boron edge termination exhibited blocking voltages up to 1750 V at room temperature; whereas those devices without edge termination broke down at 760 V.
218
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Many metals such as Ni and Ti, can form both ohmic and Schottky contacts,[167][189][2~ with short-term, high-temperature anneals (900~ converting the Schottky contact to ohmic contact. Since Ni and Ti are commonly projected for use in MESFETs, SITs, and Schottky diodes at high temperatures up to 300~ concerns over reliability of these Schottky contacts are well founded. Reliability data are just now beginning to surface, but Ni Schottky diodes on n-type 6H and 4H-SiC have been tested (unbiased) for 9000 hours at 300~ [193]In general, the SBH decreased (by about 0.2 eV) in all samples after 9000 hours, and the ideality factor increased in the majority of cases. This finding is of particular importance since high temperature annealing of Ni to form nickel silicide is the basis for ohmic contact formation on n-type SiC. Additionally, Rutherford backscattering spectroscopy analysis revealed no discernible silicide formation for Ni Schottky contacts after 4000 hours at 300~ Increased leakage currents were also observed after thermal aging, but argon implantation of the surface reversed this trend More work is necessary to understand the mechanism(s) behind this.
3.0
S U R V E Y OF SiC DEVICES
A wide array of devices in 3C, 6H, and 4H SiC have been demonstrated, including: the Bipolar Junction Transistor (BJT) [2081-[212][227], Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor (IGBT),[ 213] MESFET,[214]-[223] the JFET, [7][41][223]-[232]the Metal Oxide Semiconductor Field Effect Transistor (MOSFET)[233]-[239] (which has been operated up to 923 K), [239] the Static Induction Transistor (SIT),[218][240][241] power MOSFETs,[ 242]-[248] thyristors,[221][2481-[252] Gate Turn-Off thyristors (GTO' s),[41[252] pn-junction diodes, [237][253]-[257] and Schottky diodes. [191][194][197][203][205][258][274] Additionally, heterojunction devices such as the Heterojunction FET (HFET) and Heterojunction Bipolar Transistors (HBTs) have been proposed and fabricated. Examples include: 3C-SiC/Si HBTs, [259]-[261] a 6H-SiC/3CSiC HBT,[ 2~ and a GaN/6H-SiC HBT.[ z62]A snapshot summary of fabricated SiC devices along with the highest recorded temperature of operation and comments are summarized in Table 5. While impractical to discuss each of the above mentioned devices in depth, a cursory treatment of selected devices will now be covered. As the technology matures (both from a materials and processing standpoint), SiC device performance records have been changing dramaticallyover a short time frame. No doubt, this
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
219
trend will continue; nonetheless the material presented in Table 5 and following is relevant to discuss early SiC device development as well as provide a snapshot in time of SiC device maturity. While no clear subdivisions of SiC devices are defined, low power SiC devices, high frequency and high power SiC MESFETs, SiC power devices, and the SiC static induction transistor will all be discussed as separate categories.
Table 5. Silicon Carbide Device Performance Snapshot (May 1997) Device
! Tmax(*C ) ,
DMOS (4H)
300
Ref. #
Comments
244
900 V, 5 mA devices
243
760 V, 5 mA devices; geffup to 26 cma/Vs; Ro, , = 66 mf)ocm2
252
700 V blocking
MESFET (4H)
222
65.7 % peak PAE; 3.3 W/mm at 850 MHz
MESFET (4H)
217-218
fmax = 42 Ghz; 5.1 dB gain at 20 Ghz; 3.125 W/mm at 10 GHz
PN Diode (6H)
256
4500 V blocking
Schottky Diode
202
1750 V blocking; Ti on C-face 4H-SiC
DMOS (6H)
GTO
[4H]
400
SIT
200
218,241
120 W at 2.7 Ghz (1 cm periphery)
Thyristor (6H)
300
251
5200 A/cm2 pulse switched current density and < 100 ns fall time
Thyristor (4H)
500
248
700 V, 6 A and 900 V, 2 A devices
UMOS (4H)
300
248
260 V, Ron = 18 m ~ ' c m 2 175 V, 2 A devices; (2.65 V forward drop)
UMOS (4H)
300
244
1100 V, Ro, , = 74 mF2.cm2 at 100 ~
220 3.1
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors Low Power SiC Devices
MOSFETs have been fabricated in 3C, 6H, and 4H-SiC with hightemperature operation demonstrated up to 650~ Aside from MOS reliability issues discussed earlier in the chapter, obtaining theoretical mobility values in the channel has proven difficult. Extracted mobility (/aeff) in the channel of a 6H-SiC depletion-mode MOSFET is shown versus temperature in Fig. 21 .[235] Channel mobility is lower than bulk mobility, and the difference is attributed to interface states between the oxide and semiconductor, material defects, mobility anisotropy, and other factors. Enhancement-mode SiC MOSFETs have had much lower effective channel mobility, presumably a result of deep-level interface traps near the oxide-SiC interface. The low room-temperature mobility of vertical SiC power MOSFETs with positive threshold voltages has been a problem of extreme importance as discussed previously and elsewhere. [242]-[248]Channel mobility in 4H-SiC JFETs with 9 ~tm gate length have been reported at 340 cm2/ V.s at 300K, [226] with a maximum transconductance (gin) of 15 mS/mm. Enhancement-mode JFETs have also been fabricated,[ 228] opening up the possibility of complementary JFET-based logic in SiC, possibly reducing the need for a high-quality gate oxide which can withstand high-temperature, and possibly high-power and high-radiation environments. In the enhancement-mode JFET, the pn junction space charge region at zero gate bias fully depleted the drain-source channel, causing the device to be normally off. The extrapolated threshold voltage (VrH) was measured to be 0.81 V at 300 K, with g~ of 1.5 mS/mm for a device with a gate length of 5 ~tm.[22s] The maximum gate voltage, before forward biasing the gate pn junction diode, fell from---2.5 V at 300 K, to ~1.9 V at 723 K. A good discussion of los s versus temperature can be found in the literature as well.[22s11229]Highvoltage JFETs have also been fabricated, with 6H-SiC JFET's capable of 450 V forward blocking voltage, although pinchoff-voltage was -400 V.[TM] Ro~ was found to vary from 20 mW.cm2 to 80 mW.cm2. BJTs in SiC typically have low DC current gain (-~5-15) in the common emitter configuration, primarily as a result of minority carrier base recombination in npn structures.[2~ Bandgap narrowing with very heavily doped emitters could also play an extremely important role in degrading the DC current gain. Heterostructure devices using wide bandgap emitters or narrow bandgap bases of different SiC polytypes or III-V nitrides will probably be needed to increase DC gain and improve the high-frequency response of the devices.
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
221
"%, Comparable Si MOSIO'I~
200 ~ t
""'....(Thmrea~) - T"~'s .
%%%,1 1~/
~'15oi- W/L= lOOjm#4j.tm ";.. .~ i vmfo.1 v; vssfO.OV "'--.. 9
|
..............
275
iC MOS~
It ............................
375
il
. . . . . . .
475
Tempenmre (K)
t
575
.............
.I
675
Figure 21. Effective channel mobility (meff)versus temperature for a 6H-SiC depletionmode MOSFETcomparedto a similar, theoretical device in silicon. Taken from Ref. 235.
3.2
SiC MESFETs
The use of SiC MESFETs for high-power, high-frequency applications has been the focal point for investigation because of the possibility of power densities in excess of four times that of silicon and gallium arsenide. The small-signal RF performance of SiC MESFETs fabricated by Northrop Grumman has been found to have 5.1 dB gain at 20 Ghz, with extrapolation of Mason's unilateral gain at 6 dB/octave resulting in afmaxvalue of 42 Ghz.[217] Impressive high power operation of X-band 4H-SiC MESFETs has been demonstrated as we11,[2181with power outputs of 6 W at 10 Ghz obtained from devices of 1.92 mm periphery and 0.5 ~tm gate length. The results were obtained under class AB conditions with gate biased at 10% loss. Even higher power output (6.3 5 W or 3.3 W/mm) was obtained at a higher input drive level, VD = 45 V, under 10% duty cycle of 100 ~ts width. Gate-todrain breakdown was approximately 100 V for these devices. Impressive SiC MESFET performance has also been demonstrated by a Motorola/Cree team with 65.7% peak power added efficiency and an extremely high power density of 3.3 W/mm at 850 MHz.I252]
222 3.3
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors SiC Power Devices
Power MOSFET's with 260 V blocking capability and Ro, of 18 mf2.cm2 have been obtained [248] for vertical 4H-SiC UMOSFETs. Also, larger area devices, such as 175 V MOSFETs with a rated current of 2 A (J= 200 A/cm 2) at a forward drop of 2.65 V, were also demonstrated. Operation of similar devices had previously been demonstrated at temperatures up to 300~ with short lifetimes because of gate oxide failure, but no high-temperature data was reported for these later developments.[ 248] Because of SiC's superior electric field strength, Ro, has been affected by channel resistance, and not simply by the resistance of the lightly-doped drain-drift region, which is much thinner than that of comparable Si power MOSFETs. Improvement of channel mobility to lower Ronis critical. Poor channel mobility in SiC Power MOSFETs (eg.,--13 cm2/V.s in 4H-SiC UMOSFET)[ 248] has thus far been generally attributed to poor interface quality between oxide and SiC in the channel region. Additionally, long-term stability of the insulator has been shown to be the limiting factor in SiC power UMOSFET structures. Use of a p+ polysilicon gate reduces Fowler-Nordheim injection from the gate electrode, thereby increasing breakdown voltage. For an excellent discussion of these issues, see Ref. 246. In an attempt to increase the channel mobility as well as blocking voltage, the first Double Implanted MOS (DIMOS or DMOS) FET fabricated in 6H-SiC was reported by a group at Purdue University.[ 243]Blocking voltage operation up to 760 V was demonstrated with 10 ~tm blocking layers doped at n-type at 1.7 x 1016 and 6.5 x 1015 cm-3. A peak inversion layer channel mobility of 26 cm2/V.s was obtained, showing some improvement over the UMOSFETs. Later, 4H-SiC UMOSFETs were fabricated by Northrop Grumman with a 12 ~tm thick drain-drift layer (ND --2 x 1015 cm -3) and a 90 nm gate oxide. The gate oxide consisted of a thin layer of thermally grown SiO 2 followed by a thicker layer of deposited and densified SiO 2 to ensure a more uniform gate oxide across the trench. [244]Nickel was used for drain/ source metals, with TLM measurements yielding a specific contact resistance of 5-7 x 10-6 f2.cm 2. Channel length was 4 ~tm. Blocking voltages of 1.0-1.2 kV were measured at room temperature by probing bare die under Fluorinert TM. In Fig. 22, the blocking voltage for a typical device is shown. Under a moderate gate bias of 32 V (3.55 MV/cm) at room temperature, the effective channel mobility (/Xeffl was only 1.5 cm2/V.s, while increasing the temperature to 100~ increased kteffto 7 cm2/V's, at a gate bias of only 26 V (2.9 MV/cm). Specific on-resistance was 74 mf).cm 2 at 100~ Increasing channel mobility with temperature may be explained by deep
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
223
level interface traps located at the SiC-oxide interface which are thermally ionized at higher temperatures, resulting in increased conduction for a given bias. This explanation would account for the typically observed increase in IDS with temperature which opposes the expected T -3/2temperature dependence of ~teffresulting from increased acoustic phonon scattering. 4H-SiC DMOS structures were also reported on in the same time frame[2441 using a lightly doped 10 ~m thick drain-drift layer and a 50 nm thick oxide/nitride gate dielectric. Multiple ion implants (high-dose nitrogen and aluminum implants for source/body contact regions, and highenergy aluminum or boron implants for formation of the p-wells) were used to fabricate a planar power MOSFET in SiC. Initial findings have resulted in 900 V devices being demonstrated (also see Fig. 22), although the Pegstill shows the s a m e temperature effects of interface traps as was found for the UMOSFET case. 2.0x10-3 .
VG=20V VG = 10 V
1.5x103"~
DMOS 01 W A F E R 3 P3B OR THO 20
T=IO0~
1.0x10-3"~. ,=
03 =,-E3
t(
5.0x10 -~-
0.0xl0~
VG=5V
C
VG=OV ,
''''I''''I''''I''''I''''
-5.0x10 .4
200
400
,
600
800
1000
VDs (v)
5x10 -3 . . 4x10-3-~ (V G = 60 V
3x10 -3t'
o~ 2X10 "3 E3
--
1x10_3-
4H-SiC UMOS
P 13 ORTHO 20 VG = 5 5 V
VG =50V
VG =0V
,,,
0xl0~ .lx10-3 "1 ' ' ' 0
I'' 200
'I ''' I'' 400 600
'I' '' I '' i 800 1000 1200
VD s (V) Figure 22. Output characteristics for a 4H-SiC Double implanted MOSFET (DMOS) exhibiting 900 V blocking voltage at 100~ (above) and similar characteristics for a I 100 V 4HSiC UMOSFET at room temperature (below). Taken from Ref. 244.
224
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Other high-temperature, high-power devices, such as thyristors have been demonstrated to 500~ [248] At room temperature, this same device had a blocking voltage of 600 V with a 1.8 A forward current at a voltage drop of 3.7 V. A 10 A, 200 V thyristor with a forward voltage drop of-3.6 V, current density of 620 A/cm 2, and Ro, of 1.2 m~.cm 2 was also demonstrated.[ 248] Other thyristors with 100 V blocking voltage, pulse switched current density of 5200 A/cm 2 (1.8 A) have also been fabricated.[ TM] The turn-on rise time was 43 ns and a fall time of less than 100 ns was measured. Silicon carbide (4H-SiC), asymmetrical Gate Turn-Off thyristors (GTOs) have also been fabricated and tested with respect to forward voltage drop (VF), forward blocking voltage, and turn-off characteristics. [252] The GTO structure (shown in Fig. 23) has advantages over the conventional thyristor in that it can be turned offwith a gate pulse, allowing it to be used in DC power switching since it does not require the negative AC cycle for turn-off. The asymmetrical GTO structure also has the advantage of easier turn-off in comparison to symmetrical devices. Additionally, the asymmetrical GTO structure is less susceptible to open base transistor breakdown which generally determines the breakdown voltage in conventional thyristors. Devices were tested from room temperature to 350~ in the DC mode. Forward blocking voltages ranged from 600-800 V at room temperature for the devices tested. VF of a typical device at 350~ was 4.8 V ata current density of 500 A/cm 2. Turn-off time was less than 1 ~ts. Although no beveling or advanced edge termination techniques were used, the blocking voltage represented approximately 50% of the theoretical value when tested in an air ambient. Also, four GTO cells were connected in parallel to demonstrate 600 V, 1.4 A performance. Anode
Anode
~rJ///J.//./l
l.,'~JJJ././././A Vjf/ff/~rjfA
P
N .
e
P + Buffer Layer N Buffer Layer 4H- N SiC Substrate Cathode
Figure 23. Cross-sectionof a 4H-SiCasymmetricalGTO. Reproducedfrom Ref. 4.
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
225
The p-type buffer layer shown in Fig. 23 was epitaxially deposited in order to form a punch-through structure and to allow easier turn-off of the device by reducing the injection efficiency of the bottom npn bipolar transistor. The blocking voltage is supported across a lightly doped (~5 x 10:4 cm -3) 6.0 ~tm thick p-type base layer. Finally, n-type gate and p-type anode epitaxial layers were grown. Interdigitated anode and gate fingers were of equal lengths and widths for these non-optimized, first-generation devices. Typical finger lengths and widths were 250 ~tm and 15 ~tm, respectively. The top view of one of these devices is shown in Fig. 24, and typical I-V characteristics obtained using a curve tracer in the pnp mode is shown in Fig. 24, as well.
Figure 24. (a) Top-view of a 4H-SiC GTO with interdigitatedgate and anode fingers. The cathode (backside) is not shown. Photo courtesy of Northrop Grumman. (b) Typical I-V characteristics of same device showing off-state blocking,turn-on, and forward conducting states. Courtesy of Northrop Grumman.
226
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
.4
'r, r ~i
':
f
~~
Figure 24. (Cont 'd.)
This blocking voltage corresponded to a maximum electric field
(Era)of approximately 1.2 MV/cm across the blocking layer for a nominal 700 V blocking device when assuming negligible voltage drop across the anode, substrate, contacts, and buffer layers. This value ofE mis about 50% of the theoretical critical electric field possible in 4H-SiC. Emissions of light at the periphery of the device structure in breakdown were observed under high-power (50X) magnification in the dark, consistent with edgebreakdown. Further improvements in edge termination should improve the breakdown characteristics of the devices. For comparison purposes, it is notable that for punch-through structures in silicon such as a p-i-n diode, a 45 ~tm thick blocking layer of equal doping would be necessary to achieve the same 600 V blocking as with the 6 ~tm SiC blocking layer used here. The dramatic reduction in the required blocking layer thickness for this device structure utilizing SiC's high electric breakdown strength should allow for much faster power switching than conventional silicon devices.
Processing o f Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits 3.4
227
SiC Static Induction T r a n s i s t o r
A promising device in SiC for use in a combination of high-power, high-frequency, and high-temperature applications is the SIT. The device cross-section is shown in Fig. 25. A 225 W UHF 4H-SiC SIT was reported,[ 24~ with the maximum output power of 225 W at 600 MHz, and a power added efficiency (PALE) of 47% and a gain of 8.7 dB for the packaged device. The maximum blocking voltage was 200 V, and maximum channel current density was 1 A/cm of source periphery. Maximum transconductance was 75 mS/mm, and afro~ of 4 GHz was measured on these devices.
Source
Source
~ ~ '
]" 4 um
1
i ur.
urn-.,-2
N Epi
urn
ND=I(}6 "3cm
N + 4H-SiC
Drain Figure25. Schematic cross-section of a SiC Static Induction Transistor. Taken from Ref. 4. A SEM of the completed SIT devices is shown in Fig. 26, as taken from. Ref. 240. Aside from the impressive performance, also noteworthy was that 1.5 cm periphery devices are practical despite the micropipes present in the material, and that eleven good devices with output power of 225 W were obtained on the die shown in Fig. 26. For digital TV transmission, SITs have been used in 2 kW peak power 850 MHz (UHF) modules. The component transistors in this module were UHF SiC SITs, with the
228
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
power output density of the parallel cells at 165 kW/cm 2. The projected peak power density of SiC MESFETs/SITs is approximately four times that possible in silicon or gallium arsenide.[ 218]The SiC SIT device was the primary active device component in a 400 W UHF TV transmitter module used for the first live HDTV television broadcast in April 1996, at the National Association of Broadcasters conference in Las Vegas, NV. Later developments on the SIT have included demonstrated operation from UHF to S-band (3.0 Ghz). [241]Mixed-mode SITs have been developed for use at high frequency. Mixed-mode operation refers to the MESFET/SIT modes of operation used to optimize maximum gain and power density. Packaged (3 cm periphery) mixed-mode SITs have delivered 38 W of output power at 3.0 Ghz with 9.5 dB gain and 43% power added efficiency. Packaged SITs capable of delivering 20 W of power at 2.7 Ghz (1 cm periphery) have also been demonstrated.[218] Development of the SiC static induction transistor has been advanced to the point of pilot production within the Northrop Grumman Corporation.[ 218]
Figure 26. Microphotograph(top-view) of completed 1.5 cm periphery SiC Static Induction Transistors (SITs). Gate and source bonding tabs can be seen. Taken from Ref. 240.
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits 4.0
SiC C I R C U I T S AND S E N S O R S
4.1
Operational Amplifiers
229
The first SiC-based operational amplifier was assembled as a hybrid circuit on an alumina ceramic substrate, using thick-film resistors, gold conductor traces, and die containing 6H-SiC depletion-mode MESFET pairs.[263][264] The packaged circuit was demonstrated in 1992, with measured gain greater than 60 dB from 25~ to 350~ and a gain bandwidth of 1.08 MHz at 25~ and 0.91 MHz at 350~ The first monolithic op-amp was reported in 1994[265]by researchers at General Electric making use of depletion-mode, n-channel, 6H-SiC MOSFET technology. The conservatively designed, packaged op-amp had a gain of 49 dB at room temperature, and a gain bandwidth of 724 kHz at 25~ falling to 269 kHz at 350~ An enhancement-mode NMOS op-amp, with 12 V power supply, an input offset of 56 mV and open loop gain of 103 (40.3 dB) has also been fabricated,[2661 and was operated successfully to 350~ Monolithic SiC CMOS op-amps have been recently reported with a room-temperature open loop voltage gain of 10,000, [267] and hybrid, 4H-SiC JFET op-amps are currently under development.[268]
4.2
Digital Circuits
Another focus of SiC electronics research is to develop a hightemperature, high-speed logic family. Researchers at Purdue University were the first to demonstrate these capabilities,[269]demonstrating fabrication and operation ofinverters, NAND, NOR, and XNOR gates, D-latches, RS flip-flops, binary counters, and half-adders with successful operation from room temperature to over 300~ Seventeen-stage ring oscillators have also been fabricated, with 40% yield for NMOS circuits on 30 mm (1.182 inch), p-type 6H-SiC substrates, and 25% yield for PMOS circuits on 35 mm (1.379 inch), n-type 6H-SiC substrates. [266]
4.3
Sensors
A 6H-SiC, hybrid temperature sensor was designed, fabricated, and tested from -150~ to 500~ at Auburn University, utilizing two 6H-SiC
23.0 Wide Bandgap Semiconductors JFETs configured in a series-series feedback network, and a 6H-SiC diode formed using the gate-to-source junction in a third JFET.[ 27~ Linear output with respect to temperature was measured from 500~ to about -50~ where carrier-freezeout in the diode began to affect performance. The completed assembled hybrid temperature sensor is shown prior to final wirebonding in Fig. 27. The SiC JFETs are mounted on an alumina ceramic substrate with thick film gold conductor traces and thick film resistors fired from commercially available pastes. Other temperature sensing applications have also been envisioned.[ TM ] A SiC thermistor was demonstrated as early as 1973,[ 272] with sustained operation at 1050~ (1323 K) for over 2500 hours. The thermistors were packaged in stainless steel housings, with logarithmic temperature response to temperature from -200~ to 700~
Figure 27. Photograph of a 6H-SiC, hybrid temperature sensorwhich operated from 500~ to approximately -150~ Three 6H-SiC JFET's (one used as a diode) shown brazed on a thick-film gold paste with thick-film screen-printed resistors. Photo was taken prior to wirebonding. Taken from Ref. 270.
SiC UV photodiodes have also been demonstrated. [1][273][274] SiC UV detectors have the advantages of operation in hostile environments, insensitivity to longer wavelengths, and very small dark currents leading to
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
231
a sensitivity four orders of magnitude greater than that of Si detectors.[ 2271 Flame-indication sensors utilizing 6H-SiC transistors[ 111275]have been fabricated and tested at temperatures over 500~ A flame indication sensor with an integral amplifier was earlier operated for over 600 hours in simulated engine environments with no degradation. Flame indication sensors designed for production were then built, qualified, and field tested before being installed in gas turbine power plants. This work represented the first commercialized turbine control application to use SiC electronic devices.[ 275] Other applications for LW detectors include satellite-based missile plume detection, gas sensing (automobile exhaust systems, etc.), and UV dosimetry. SiC hydrocarbon sensors have been pursued as well, with a potentially large market in the automotive industry. [276][277]SiC MOS oxygen sensors, also with a potential large market development, have been developed with promising results.[ 278] A 3C-SiC accelerometer[ 2791fabricated via micromachining of3C-SiC membranes on a silicon substrate has been demonstrated by Daimler-Benz. Free-standing 3C-SiC membranes were obtained by anisotropic etching of the Si wafer. The 3C-SiC membranes were able to withstand much higher temperature and pressure, as well as more corrosive environments than comparable Si membranes, indicating a much more robust accelerometer could be fabricated. Although not a high-temperature application, high-speed Non-Volatile Random Access Memory (NVRAM) in SiC[28~ is worth mentioning, because SiC's wide bandgap and subsequent long charge storage times (> 10 min. at 623 K and projected to be over a million years at 300 K) may give rise to room-temperature memory chips which need no refreshing, thus eliminating hard drives in computers. This could open the commercial personal computer market to SiC, allowing economies of scale to occur and allow the cost of SiC to fall rapidly.
5.0
CONCLUSIONS
The interested reader should look to other reviews found in press and in the literature. In addition, proceedings of past conferences relating to SiC research will also prove helpful.[17][95][281]-[3~176 A brief overview of the electronic properties of SiC as relating to high-temperature electronics, as well as significant achievements involving high-temperature SiC electronics prior to 1996 has been given.
232
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
A broad overview of some of the high-temperature applications using SiC electronics has also been discussed. Excellent progress has been demonstrated by SiC devices and circuits to date. Still, despite impressive individual device performances, some key barriers remain. First, insulators capable of reliable high-temperature operation with high breakdown field strength and low interface trap densities need further development. Of particular concern is the uniform growth/deposition of insulators on the different surfaces of SiC exposed in a typical vertical power UMOSFET configuration. Second, material defects (in particular, micropipes) and material cost must be decreased, while wafer-size must be increased substantially in order to facilitate commercial production of SiC based electronics. Much progress has been made towards these goals, as evidenced by Fig. 28,[ 1~] and should continue, making SiC an attractive semiconductor choice in the high-temperature electronics marketplace. Devices such as high-frequency MESFET's, which do not rely on large area or a high-quality dielectric may be the first SiC electronic devices (excluding optical devices) to reach the commercial market. In 1997, SiC static induction transistors have reached the stage pilot production, a tremendous advancement considering that less than 10 years earlier SiC substrates were not commercially available.[ 2181Also, in 1996, the first reported use of SiC devices in commercial turbine control systems was announced, which was another indication of a rapidly maturing technology.
/
-...
i~.4Cod per em2 s . 4 ldlcroPJpes per c ms
" ,9, . %%
400
"on,,,,
' MJ~terlxl C a s t
sad Mlcroplpe
A~d~ds ~ ' , , , ~ ~o,,, J ~ , O
UllU
1991
lUUl
"
l
u
1992
- j'
l
1993
A
u
i,,~ . •
i...
1994
~
, _
9 n
1995
"-
~---
1996
Yqmul"
Figure 28. Micropipe defect density and cost in U.S. dollars per cm 2 as a function of time since the first commercial introduction of bulk SiC substrates. Taken from Ref. 300.
P r o c e s s i n g o f Silicon Carbide f o r Devices a n d Circuits
233
REFERENCES 1. Oasack,D. E., Glasheen, W. M., and Steglich, H. R., Trans. of 2ndInternational High Temperature Electronics Conference (HiTEC), Charlotte, N.C., USA, Session III, pp. 17-22 (June 5-10, 1994) 2. Reinhardt, K. C., and Marciniak, M. A., Trans. of 3rd International High Temperature Electronics Conference (HiTEC), Session I, pp. 9-15 (June 914,1996) 3. Dreike, P. L., Fleetwood, D. M., King, D. B., Sprauer, D. C., and Zipperian, T. E., IEEE Trans. on Comp., Hybrids, Man. Tech. -A, 17(4):594-609 (Dec., 1994) 4. Agarwal, A. K., Augustine, G., Balakrishna, V., Bran&, C. D., Burke, A. A., Chen, L. S., Clarke, R. C., Esker, P. M., Hobgood, H. M., Hopkins, R. H., Morse, A. W., Rowland, L. B., Seshadri, S., Siergiej, R. R., Smith, T. J., Jr., and Sriram, S., Tech. Dig. Int'l. Elect. Dev. Meeting, pp. 9.1.1-9.1.6 (Dec., 1996) 5. Tajima, M., Trans. of 2"d International High Temperature Electronics Conference (HiTEC), Charlotte, N.C., USA, Session I, pp. 29-34 (June 5-10, 1994) 6. Fleetwood, D. M., IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., Vol. N S-35, pp. 1099-1112 (1988) 7. Palmour, J. W., and Carter, C. H., Jr., Proceedings of 1993 International Semiconductor Device Research Symposium, Omni Charlottesville Hotel, pp. 695-696 (Dec. 1-3, 1993) 8. Trew, R. J., Yan, J. B., and Mock, P. M., Proceedings ofthe IEEE, 79:598-620 (May, 1991) 9. McGarrity, J. M., McLean, F. B., DeLancey, W. M., Palmour, J. W., Carter, C. H., Jr., and Edmond, J. A., IEEE Trans. on Nuclear Science, 39(6): 1974-1981 (1992) 10. Cree Research, Inc., Durham, NC 27713 11. Advanced Technology Materials, Inc., 7 Commerce Drive, Danbury, CT 06810-4169, and Sterling Semiconductor 12. George, T., Pike, W. T., Khan, M. A., Kuznia, J. N., and Chang-Chien, P., J. of Electronic Materials, 24(4):241-247 (Apr., 1995) 13. Yim, W. M., Stofko, E. J., Zanzucchi, P. J., Pankove, J. I., Ettenberg, E., and Gilbert, S. L., J. Appl. Phys., 44(1):292-296 (Jan. 1, 1973) 14. Edmond, J., Kong, H., Dmitriev, V., Bulman, G., and Carter, C., Jr., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 515-518, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 15. Round, H. J., Electrical World, 49:309 (1907) 16. Shockley, W., Proceedings of the First International Conference on Silicon Carbide, Boston, MA, 1959, (J. R. O'Connor and J. Smiltens, eds.), Pergamon, New York (1960)
234
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
17. Pensl, G., and Choyke, W. J., Physica B, 185:264-283 (1993) 18. Dubrovskii, G. B., Soviet Phys. Solid State, 13:2107-109 (1972) 19. Humphreys, R. G., Bimberg, D., and Choyke, W. J., Solid State Comm., 39:163-167(1981) 20. Tachibana, T., Kong, H. S., Wang, Y. C., and Davis, R. F., J. Appl. Phys., 67:6375-6381 (1990) 21. Shields, V., Fekade, K., and Spencer, M. G., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 21-24, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 22. Golecki, I., Reidinger, F., and Marti, J., Workshop on High Temperature Power Electronics for Vehicles, Fort Monmouth, N. J., USA (April 26-27, 1995) 23. Anthony Powell, J., and Larkin, D. J., NASA Tech. Briefs, pp. 58-59 (May, 1995) 24. Kong, H. S., Glass, J. T., and Davis, R. F.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 49:1047 (1986) 25. Tischler,M. A, Hamaguchi, N., Choi, S., Powell, A., and Dobrilla, P., Workshop on High Temperature Power Electronics for Vehicles, Fort Monmouth, N.J. (April 26-27,1995) 26. Madelung, O., Data in Science and Technology: Semiconductors Group IV Elements and Ill- V Compounds, p. 101, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1991) 27. Gaberstroh, C., Helbig, R., and Stein, R. A., J. of Appl. Phys., 76:509-513, (July, 1994) 28. Muller, R. S., and Kamins, T. I., Device Electronics for Integrated Circuits, Second Edition, Wiley, p. 54 (1986) 29. Muench, W. V., and Pfaffeneder, I., J. Appl. Phys., 48:4831-4833 (1977) 30. Muench, W. V., and Petterpaul, E., ~ Appl. Phys., 48(11):4823-4825 (Nov., 1977) 31. Baliga, B. J., Springer Proceedings in Physics, 71:305-313 (1992) 32. Morelli, D., Hermans, J., Becto, C., Woo, W. S., Harris, G. L., Taylor, C., Inst. Phys. Conf. Set. No. 137, p. 313-5, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 33. Slack, G. A., J. Appl. Phys., 35:3460-6 (1964) 34. Son, N. T., Chen, W. M., Kordina, O., Konstantinov, A. O., Monemar, B., Janzen, E., Hofman, D. M., Volm, D., Drechsler, M., and Meyer, B. K., Applied Physics Letters, 66(9): 1074-1076 (Feb. 27, 1995) 35. Schaffer, W. J., Negley, G. H., Irvin, K. G., and Palmour, J. W., MRS Symposium Proceedings, 339:595-600, MRS, Pittsburgh, PA (1994) 36. Jacob, C., Nishino, S., Mehregany, M., Polk, J. A., and Pirouz, P., Inst. of Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 247-250, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994)
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
235
37. Yoshida, S., Properties of Silicon Carbide, (G.L. Harris, ed.), p. 74, INSPEC, London, UK (1995) 38. Materials for High-Temperature Semiconductor Devices, p. 19, National Academy Press, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC (1995) 39. Yamanaka, M., Daiman, H., Sakuma, E., Misawa, S., Yoshida, S., J. Appl. Phys., 61(2):599-603 (Jan. 15,1987) 40. Larkin, D. J., Neudeck, P. G., Powell, J. A., and Matus, L. G., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, p. 51-54, lOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 41. Flatresse, P., and Ouisse, T., Solid-St. Electron., 38(5):971-975 (1995) 42. Patrick, L., and Choyke, W. J., Physical Review B, 2(6):2255-2256 (15 Sept., 1970) 43. Tsvetkov, V. F., Allen, S. T., Kong, H. S., and Carter, C. H., Jr., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 17-22, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 44. Augustine, G., Hobgood, H. M., Balakrishna, V., Dunne, G., and Hopkins, R. H., Phys. Stat. Solidi (submitted Sept., 1997) 45. Neudeck, P. G., andPowell, J. A., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 15:63-5 (Feb., 1994) 46. Giocondi, J., Rohrer, G. S., Skowronski, M., Balakrishna, V., Augustine, G., Hobgood, H. M., and Hopkins, R. H., MRS Symposium Proc., 423:539-544 (1996) 47. Hobgood, H. M., Barrett, D. L., McHugh, J. P., Clarke, R. C., Sriram, S., Burke, A. A., Greggi, J., Brandt, C. D., Hopkins, R. H., and Choyke, W. J., J. Crystal Growth, 137:181-186 (1994) 48. Udding, A., Mitsushashi, H., and Uemoto, T., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 33:L908-L911 (1994) 49. Tairov, Y. M., and Tsvetkov, V. F., J. Cryst. Growth, 43:209-212 (1978) 50. Tairov, Y. M., and Tsvetkov, V. F., J. Cryst. Growth, 52:146-150 (1981) 51. Ziegler, G., Lanig, P., Theis, D., and Weyrich, C., IEEE Trans. Elect. Dev., vol. ED-30, pp. 277-281 (1983) 52. Barrett, D. L., Seidensticker, R. G., Gaida, W., Hopkins, R. H., Choyke, W. J., J. Cryst. Growth, 109:17-23 (1991) 53. Davis, R. F., Carter, C. H., Jr., Hunter, C. E., U.S. Patent No. 4,866,0005 (Sept. 12, 1989) 54. Nakata, T., Koga, K., Matsushita, Y., Ueda, Y., Niina, T., Proc. of 2 ndInt'l. Conf. on Amorphous and Crystalline Silicon Carbide H & Related Mat., Santa Clara, CA, Dec. 15-16, 1988, Springer Proc. Phys., 43:26-34 (1989) 55. Barrett, D. L., McHugh, J. P., Hobgood, H. M., Hopkins, R. H., McMullin, P. G., Clarke, R. C., and Choyke, W. J., J. Cryst. Growth, 128:358-362 (1993)
236
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
56. Takahashi, F., Kanaya, M., and Fujiwara, Y., J. Cryst. Growth, 135:61-70
(1994) 57. Hofinann, D., Karpov, S. Y., Makarov, Y. N., Mokhov, E. N., Ramm, M. G., Ramm, M. S., Roenkov, A. D., and Vodakov, Y. A., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 29-32, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 58. Hobgood, H. M., Glass, R. C., Augustine, G., Hopkins, R. H., Jenny, J., Skowronski, M., Mitchel, W. C., and Roth, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66(11):1364-1366 (Mar. 13, 1995) 59. Gradinaru, G., Sudarshan, T. S., Gradinaru, S. A., Mitchell, W., and Hobgood, H. M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 70(6):735-737 (Feb. 10, 1997) 60. Wang, Y. C., Davis, R. F., and Edmond, J. A., Journal of Electronic Materials, 20:289-294 (Apr., 1991) 61. Larkin, D. J., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 23-28, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 62. Larkin, D. J., Sridhara, S. G., and Devaty, R. P., Journal of Electronic Materials, 24:289-294 (Apr., 1995) 63. Larkin, D. J., Neudeck, P. G., Powell, J. A., and Matus, L. G., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65:1659 (1994) 64. Burke, A. A., Jr., Rowland, L. B., Agarwal, A. K., Sriram, S., Glass, R. C., and Brandt, C. D., Inst. Phys. Conf. Set. No. 142, pp. 201-204, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 65. Kimoto, T., Matsunami, H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Set. No. 137, p. 55-58, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 66. Kim, H. J., and Davis, R. F., J. Electrochem. Soc., 133:2350-2357 (Nov., 1986) 67. Ikeda, M., Matsunami, H., and Tanaka, T., Phys. Rev. B, 22(6):2842-2845 (Sept. 15, 1980) 68. Kordina, O., Henry, A., Bergman, J. P., Son, N. T., Chen, W. M., Hallin, C., and Janzen, E., Applied Phys. Lett., 66(11):1373-1375 (Mar. 13, 1995) 69. Hoh, A., Akita, H., Kimoto, T., and Matsunami, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65(11):1400-1402 (Sept. 12, 1994) 70. Kong, H. S., Glass, J. T., and Davis, R. F., d. Appl. Physics, 64(5):26722679 (Sept. 1, 1988) 71. Davis, R. F.,J. Cryst. Growth, 137:161-169 (1994) 72. Rupp, R., Lanig, P., V'lkl, J., and Stephani, D., Mat. Res. Soc. Syrup. Proc., 423:253-263(1996) 73. Burke, A. A., Jr., Rowland, L. B., Augustine, G., Hobgood, H. M., and Hopkins, R. H., Mat. Res. Soc. Syrup. Proc., 423:275-280 (1996)
Processing o f Silicon Carbide f o r Devices and Circuits
237
74. Janzen, E., and Kordina, O., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 653-658, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 75. Rowland, L. B., Burke, A. A., Jr., Clarke, R. C., Siergiej, R. R., Sriram, S., Augustine, G., Hobgood, H. M., and Driver, M. C., Proc. IEEE/Cornell Conf. Advanced Concepts in High Speed Semiconductor Devices and Circuits (Aug. 7-9, 1995) 76. Rao, M. V., Griffiths, P., Holland, O. W., Kelnar. G., Freitas, J. A., Jr., Simons, P. S., and Ghezzo, M., dr.Applied Physics, 77(6):2479-2485 (15 Mar., 1995) 77. Kimoto, T., Itoh, A., Matsunami, H., Nakata, T., and Watanabe, M., dr. Electronic Mat., 24(4):235-240 (1995) 78. Heft, A., Wendler, E., Bachmann, T., Glaser, E., and Wesch, W., Materials Science & Engineering B, 29:142-146 (1995) 79. Ahmed, S., Barbero, C. J., and Sigmon, T. W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66(6):712-714 (Feb. 6, 1995) 80. Ahmed, S., Barbero, C. J., Sigmon, T. W., and Erickson, J. W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65(1):1-3 (July 4, 1994) 81. Wesch, W., Heft, A., Wendler, E., Bachmann, T., and Glaser, E., Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research B, 96:335-338 (1995) 82. Ghezzo, M., Brown, D. M., Downey, E., Kretchmer, J., and Kopanski, J. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63(9):1206-1208 (Aug. 30, 1993) 83. Ghezzo, M., Brown, D. M., Downey, E., Kretchmer, J., Hennessy, W., Polla, D. L., and Bakru, H., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 13(12):639-641 (Dec., 1992) 84. Du, H., Libera, M., Yang, Z., Lai, P. J., Jacobson, D. C., Wang, Yu. C., and Davis, R. F., Appl. Phys. Lett., 62(4):423-425 (Jan. 25, 1993) 85. Edmond, J. A., Withrow, S. P., Wadlin, W., and Davis, R. F., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 77:193-198 (1987) 86. Edmond, J. A., Kim, H. J., and Davis, R. F., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 52:157-164 (1986) 87. Dalibor, T., Peppermiiller, C., Pensl, G., Sridhara, S., Devaty, R. P., Choyke, W. J., Itoh, A., Kimoto, T., Matsunami, H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 517-520, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 88. Rao, M. V., Gardner, J., Griffiths, P., Holland, O. W., Kelner, G., Ghezzo, M., Simons, D. S., and Chi, P. H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 521524, lOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 89. Inoue, N., Itoh, A., Kimoto, T., Matsunami, H., Nakata, T., and Watanabe, M., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 525-528, lOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 90. Freitas, J. A., Jr., Griffiths, P., Gardner, J., and Rao, M. V., Inst. Phys. Conf. Set. No. 142, pp. 529-532, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996)
238
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
91. Kawase, D., Ohno, T., Iwasaki, T., and Yatsuo, T., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 513-516, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 92. Heera, V., Pezoldt, J., Ning, X. J., and Pirouz, P., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 509-512, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 93. Harada, S., Ishimaru, M., Motooka, T., Nakata, T., Yoneda, T., and Inoue, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:3534-3536(2 Dec., 1996) 94. Peppermiiller, C., Helbig, R., Rottner, K., and Sch6ner, A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 70(8): 1014-1016 (Feb. 24,1997) 95. Harris, G. L., Properties of Silicon Carbide, pp. 131-149 INSPEC, London, UK(1995) 96. Yih, P. H., and Steckl, A. J., J. Electrochem. Soc., 142:2853-2860 (Aug., 1995) 97. Casady, J. B., Luckowski, E. D., Bozack, M., Sheridan, D., Johnson, R. W., and Williams, J. R.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 143(5): 1750-1753 (May, 1996) 98. Casady, J. B., Luckowski, E. D., Bozack, M., Sheridan, D., Johnson, R. W., and Williams, J. R., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 625-628, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 99. Yih, P. H. and Steckl, A. J.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 142:312-319 (Jan., 1995) 100. Luther, B. P., Ruzyllo, J., and Miller, D. L.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:171-173 (1993) 101. Yih, P. H., and Steckl, A. J., J. Electrochem. Soc., 140:1813-1824 (June, 1993) 102. Steckl, A. J., and Yih, P. H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 60:1966-1968 (Apr. 20, 1992) 103. Pan, W. -S., and Steckl, A. J., J. Electrochem. Soc., 137:212-220 (Jan., 1990) 104. Sugiura, J., Lu, W. -J., Cadien, K. C., and Steckl, A. J., ,I. Vac. Sci. Tech. B, 4:349-354 (Jan./Feb., 1986) 105. Yih, P. H., and Steckl, A. J., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp.317-320, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 106. Palmour, J. W., Davis, R. F., Astell-Burt, P., and Blackborow, P., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 76:185-190 (1987) 107. Kelner, G., Binari, S. C., and Klein, P. H., J. Electrochem. Soc., 134:253-254 (Jan., 1987) 108. Niemann, E., Boos, A., and Leidich, D., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp.695-698, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 109. Palmour, J. W., Williams, B. E., Astell-Burt, P., and Davis, R. F., J. Electrochem. Soc., 136(2):491-495 (Feb., 1989)
P r o c e s s i n g o f Silicon Carbide f o r Devices a n d Circuits
239
110. Palmour, J. W., Davis, R. F., Astell-Burt, P., and Blackborow, P., Ceramic Transactions, 2:491-500 (1989) 111. Flemish, J., Xie, K., and Zhao, J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:2315-2317 (1994) 112. Flemish, J., Xie, K., Buchwald, W., Casas, L., Zhao, J. H., McLane, G., and Dubey, M., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 339:145-150, MRS, Pittsburgh, PA (1994) 113. Flemish, J. R., and Xie, K., J. Electrochem. Soc., 143(8):2620-2623 (Aug., 1996) 114. Xie, K., Flemish, J. R., Zhao, J. H., Buchwald, W. R., and Casas, L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67(3):368-370 (July 17, 1995) 115. Shor, J. S., Zhang, X. G., Kurtz, A. D., and Osgood, R. M., Proc. 4th Int'l. Conf. on SiC and Related Mat., Santa Clara, CA, pp. 355-361 (Oct. 9-11, 1991) 116. Collins, D. M., Harris, G. L., Wongchotigul, K., Zhang, D., Chen, N., and Taylor, C., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 617-620, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 117. Saxena, V., Steckl, A. J., and Bordonaro, G., Electrochemical Soc. Proceedings, 95-21:247-249 (1995) 118. Wolf, R., andHelbig, R.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 143(3):1037-1042 (Mar., 1996) 119. Cao, L., and Zhao, J. H., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett. (submitted, 1997) 120. Shor, J. S., Kurtz, A. D., Grimberg, I., Weiss, B. Z., and Osgood, R. M., J. Appl. Phys., 81(3):1546-1551 (1 Feb., 1997) 121. Shenoy, J. N., Chindalore, G. L., Melloch, M. R., and Cooper, J. A., Jr., J. Elect. Mat., 24(4):303-309 (1995) 122. Hometz, B., Michel, H. -J., and Halbritter, J., d. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 13(3):767-771 (May/June 1995) 123. Shenoy, J. N., Das, M. K., Cooper, J. A., Jr., Melloch, M. R., and Palmour, J. W., g. Appl. Phys., 79(6):3042-3045 (Mar. 15, 1996) 124. G61z,A., Horstmann, G., Stein von Kamienski, E., and Kurz, H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 633-636, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 125. Akita, H., Kimoto, T., Inoue, N., and Matsunami, H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 725-728, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 126. Tokura, N., Hara, K., Takeuchi, Y., Miyajima, T., and Hara, K., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 637-640, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 127. Bano, E., Ouisse, T., Lassagne, P., Billon, T., and Jaussaud, C., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 729-733, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 128. Stein von Kamienski, E., Portheine, F., G/51z,A., and Kurz, H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 64 1-644, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996)
240
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
129. Sridevan, S., Misra, V., McLarty, P. K., Baliga, B. J., and Wortman, J. J., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 645-648, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 130. Shenoy, J. N., Chindalore, G. L., Das, M. K., Cooper, J. A., Jr., MeUoch, M. R., Palmour, J. W., and K.G. Irvine, Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 745-748, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 131. Ramberg, C. E., Spear, K. E., Tressler, R. E., and Chinone, Y., J. Electrochem. Soc., 142(11):L214-L216 (Nov., 1995) 132. Zetterling, C. M., Harris, C. I., t3stling, M., Afanasev, V. V., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 605-608, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 133. Bano, E., Ouisse, T., Lassagne, P., Billon, T., and Jaussaud, C., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 733-736, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 134. Pan, J. N., Cooper, J. A., Jr., and Melloch, M. R., J. Appl. Phys., 78:572-574 (July 1, 1995) 135. Karlsteen, M., Baranzahi, A., Spetz, A. L., Willander, M., and Lundstr/Sm, I., J. Elect. Mat., 24(7):853-861 (July, 1995) 136. Brown, D. M., Ghezzo, M., Kretchmer, J., Downey, E., Pimbley, J., and Palmour, J., IEEE Trans. Elect. Dev., 41 (4):618-620 (Apr., 1994) 137. Neudeck, P., Kang, S., Petit, J., and Tabib-Azar, M.,J. Appl. Phys., 75(12): 7949-7953 (June 15, 1994) 138. Bano, E., Ouisse, T., DiCioccio, L., and Karmann, S., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65 (21):2723-2724 (Nov. 21, 1994) 139. Friedrichs, P., Burte, E. P., and Sch/Srner, R., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65(13): 1665-1667 (Sept. 26, 1994) 140. Alok, D., Baliga, B. J., and McLarty, P. K., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 15(10):424-426 (Oct., 1994) 141. Alok, D., McLarty, P. K., and Baliga, B. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65(17):2177-2178 (Oct. 24, 1994) 142. Hometz, B., Michel, H. -J., and Halbritter, J.,J. Mater. Res., 9(12):30883094 (Dec., 1994) 143. Raynaud, C., Autran, J. -L., Balland, B., GuiUot, G., Jaussaud, C., and Billon, T., J. Appl. Phys., 76(2):993-997 (July 15, 1994) 144. Schmitt, J., and Helbig, R., 3'. Electrochem. Soc., 141(8):2262-2265 (Aug., 1994) 145. Tyagi, R., Ghezzo, M., Chow, T. P., and Norton, J. F., J. Electrochem. Soc., 141(8):2188-2191 (Aug., 1994)
P r o c e s s i n g o f Silicon Carbide f o r Devices a n d Circuits
241
146. Powell, J. A., Petit, J. B., Edgar, J. H., Jenkins, I. G., Matus, L. G., Choyke, W. J., Clemen, L., Yoganathan, M., Yang, J. W., and Pirouz, P., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59(2):183-185 (July, 1991) 147. Shinohara, M., Yamanaka, M., Misawa, S., Okumura, H., and Yoshida, S., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 30(2):240-243 (Feb., 1991) 148. Zheng, Z., Tressler, R. E., and Spear, K. E., J. Electrochem. Soc., 137(3):854-858 (Mar., 1990) 149. Zheng, Z., Tressler, R. E., and Spear, K. E., J. Electrochem. Soc., 137(9):2812-2816 (Sept., 1990) 150. Zaima, S., Onoda, K., Koide, Y., and Yasuda, Y., J. Appl. Phys., 68(12):6304-6308 (Dec. 15, 1990) 151. Tang, S. M., Berry, W. B., Kwor, R., Zeller M. V., and Matus, L. G., J. Electrochem. Soc., 137(1):221-225 (Jan., 1990) 152. DeMeo, R. C., Wang, T. K., Chow, T. P., Brown, D. M. and Matus, L. G., J. Electrochem. Soc., 141 ( 11):L 150-L 152 (Nov., 1994) 153. Petit, J. B., Edgar, J. H., Jenkins, I. G., Matus, L. G., Choyke, W. J., Clemen, L., Yoganathan, M., Yang, J. W., and Pirouz, P., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59(2):183-185 (July, 1991) 154. Brown, D. M., Downey, E., Ghezzo, M., Kretchmer, J., Krishnamurthy, V., Hennessy, W., and Michon, G., Solid-State Electronics, 39( 11): 1531-1542 (Nov., 1996) 155. Muehloff, L., Choyke, W. J., Bozac, M. J., and Yates, J. T., Jr.,,/. Appl. Phys., 60(8):2842-2853 (15 Oct., 1986) 156. Lipkin, L. A., and Palmour, J. W., J. Electronic Materials, 25(5):909-915 (1996) 157. Afanas' ev, V. V., and Stesmans, A.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 69(15):2252-2254 (Oct. 7,1996) 158. Lipkin, L. A., Palmour, J. W., and Suehle, J. S., Proc. of3rd lnt'l. Conf. on High Temp. Elect. (HiTEC), 2:XIV-21-28 (June 9-14, 1996) 159. Dimitrijev, S., Li, H., Harrison, H. B., and Sweatman, D., IEEE Electron Device Lett., 18(5):175-177 (May, 1997) 160. Agarwal, A. K., Siergiej, R. R., Seshadri, S., White, M. H., McMullm, P. G., Burke, A. A., Rowland, L. B., Brandt, C. D., and Hopkins, R. H., Proc. oflnt'l. Symp. on Power Semiconductor Devices and ICs, pp. 119-122 (May 20-23, 1996) 161. Crofton, J., Barnes, P. A., Williams, J. R., and Edmond, J. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 62(4):384-386 (Jan. 25, 1993)
242
Wide B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s
162. Lundberg, N., and Ostling, M., Solid-St. Elect., 39(11):1559-1565 (Nov., 1996) 163. Crofton, J., Beyer, L., Williams, J. R., Luckowski, E. D., Mohney, S. E., and DeLucca, J. M., submitted to Solid-St. Elect. (1997) 164. Porter, L. M., and Davis, R. F., Trans. 3ra Int'l. High Temp. Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Session VII, pp. 3-8 (June 9-14, 1996) 165. Oder, T. N., Williams, J. R., Mohney, S. E., and Crofton, J., submitted to J. Elect. Mat. (1997) 166. Petit, J. B., Neudeck, P. G., Salupo, C. S., Larkin, D. J., and Powell, J. A., Proc. of 5thInt 'l. Conf. on SiC and Related Mater., pp. 679, IOP Publishing (1994) 167. Crofton, J., McMullin, P. G., Williams, J. R., and M.J. Bozack, J. Appl. Phys., 77:1317-1319 (Feb. 1, 1995) 168. Chaddha, A. K., Parsons, J. D., and Kruaval, G. B., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:760-762 (Feb. 6, 1995) 169. Liu, S., Severt, C., Reinhardt, K., and Scofield, J., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 589-592, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 170. Teraji, T., Hara, S., Okushi, H., and Kajimura, K., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 593-596, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 171. Baud, L., Jaussaud, C., Madar, R., Chen, J. S., and Nicolet, M. A., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 597-600, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 172. Parsons, J. D., Kruaval, G. B., and Chaddha, A. K., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65(16):2075-2077 (Oct. 17, 1994) 173. Shor, J. S., Weber, R. A., Provost, L. G., Goldstein, D., and Kurtz, A. D., J. Electrochem. Soc., 141(2):479-481 (Feb., 1994) 174. Chen, J. S., B~ichli,A., Nicolet, M. -A., Baud, L., Jaussaud, C., and Madar, R., Materials Science and Engineering, B29:185-189 (1995) 175. Alok, D., Baliga, B. J., and McLarty, P. K., IEDM, pp. 691-694 (Dec., 1993) 176. Chen, J. S., Bachli, A., Nicolet, M. -A., Ruiz, R. P., Baud, L., Jaussaud, C., and Madar, R.,J. Appl. Phys., 76(4):2169-2175 (Aug. 15, 1994) 177. Chen, J. S., B~ichli, A., and Nicolet, M. -A., Trans. 2nd Int'l. High Temp. Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Charlotte, N.C., pp. 203-208 (June 5-10, 1994) 178. Chen, J. S., Kolawa, E., Nicolet, M. -A., Ruiz, R. P., Baud, L., Jaussaud, C., and Madar, R.,J. Mater Res., 9(3):648--657 (Mar., 1994) 179. Chen, J. S., Kolawa, E., Nicolet, M. -A., Baud, L., Jaussaud, C., Madar, R., and C. Bernard, J. Appl. Phys., 75(2):897-901 (Jan. 25, 1993) 180. Dmitriev, V. A., Irvine, K., Spencer, M., and Kelner, G., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64(3):318-320 (Jan. 17, 1994)
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
243
181. Glass, R. C., Spellman, L. M., and Davis, R. F., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59(22):2868-2870 (Nov. 25, 1991) 182. Luckowski, E. D., Williams, J. R., Bozack, M. J., Isaacs-Smith, T., and Crofton, J., Material Res. Soc. Syrup. Proc., 423:119-124 (1996) 183. Grimberg, I., Weiss, B. -Z., Eizenberg, M., and Levit, M., Material Res. Society Spring Meeting, Symposium E, San Francisco, CA (April 8-12, 1996) 184. DeLucca, J. M., and Mohney, S. E., MaterialRes. Soc. Symp. Proc., Vol. 423 (1996) 185. Geib, K. M., Wilson, C., Long, R. G., and Wilmsen, C. W., J. Appl. Phys., 68(6):2796-2800 (Sept. 15,1990) 186. Liu, S., Smith, S. R., Adams, S., Severt, C., Leonard, J., Trans. 2~eInt 7. High Temp. Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Charlotte, NC, Session XIII, pp. 9-14 (June 510,1994) 187. Porter, L. M., Davis, R. F., Bow, J. S., Kim, M. J., Carpenter, R. W., Trans. 2nd Int'l. High Temp. Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Charlotte, NC, Session XIII, pp. 3-8 (June 5-10,1994) 188. Lundberg, N., and Ostling, M., S o l i d - S t a t e 38(121):2023-2028 (1995)
Electronics,
189. Goesmann, F., and Fetzer, R. S., Semicond. Sci. Technol., 10:1652-1658 (1995) 190. Itoh, A., O. Takemura, Kimoto, T., and Matsunami, H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 685-688, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 191. Itoh, A., Kimoto, T. and Matsunami, H., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 17(3):139-141 (Mar., 1996) 192. Crofton, J., and Sriram, S., IEEE Trans. on Electron Dev., 43(12):2305-2307 (Dec., 1996) 193. Luckowski, E. D., Isaacs-Smith, T., and Williams, J. R., 1997 Space Technology and Applications Int'l. Forum, AlP Conf., Proc. 387, p. 851 (1997) 194. Bhatnagar, M., Nakanishi, H., McLarty, P. K., Baliga, B. J., Patnaik, B., and Parikh, N., 1EDM Tech. Dig., pp. 789-792 (1992) 195. Waldrop, J. R.,J. Appl. Phys., 75(9):4548-4550 (1 May, 1994) 196. M6nch, W., Control of Semiconductor Interfaces, (I. Ohdomari, M. Oshima, and A. Hiraki, eds.) (1994) 197. Raghunathan, R., Alok, D., and Baliga, B. J., IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., 16(6):226-227 (June, 1995) 198. M6nch, W., Surface Science, 299/300:928-944 (1994)
244
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
199. Waldrop, J. R., and Grant, R. W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 62:2685-2687 (May 24,1993) 200. Waldrop, J. R., Grant, R. W., Wang, Y. C., and Davis, R. F., J. Appl. Phys., 72(10):4757-4760 (Nov, 1992) 201. Lundberg, L., and 0stling, M., Appl. Phys. Leg., 63(22):3069-3071 (Nov., 1993) 202. Waldrop, J. R., and Grant, R. W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 56:557-559 (Feb 5., 1990) 203. Su, J. N., and Steckl, A. J., lnst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 697-700, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 204. Shenoy, P., Moki, A., Baliga, B. J., Alok, D., Wongchotigul, K., and Spencer, M., Int 'l. Electron Dev. Meet. (IEDM) Tech. Digest, pp. 411-4 14 (Dec. 1114, 1994) 205. Urushidani, T., Kimoto, T., and Matsunami, H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 471-474, IOP Publishing Ltd. (1994) 206. Porter, L. M., Davis, R. F., Bow, J. S., Kim, M. J., and Carpenter, R. W., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 581-584, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 207. Syrkin, A. L., Andreev, A. N., Lebedex, A. A.,J. Appl. Phys., 78:5511-5514 (Nov. 1, 1995) 208. Ruff, M., Mitlehner, H., and Helbig, R., IEEE Trans. Elect. Dev., 41(6):1040-1054 (June, 1994) 209. Wang, Y., Xie, W., Cooper, J. A., Jr., Melloch, M. R., and Palmour, J. W., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 809-812, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 210. Von Muench, W., and Pfaffeneder, I., Int'l. Electron Dev. Meet. (IEDM) Tech. Digest, pp. 337-339 (1977) 211. Chelnokov, V. E., Materials Science and Engineering, B 11:103-111 (1992) 212. Liou, J. J., and Kager, A., lEE Proceedings, 140(4):289-293 (Aug., 1993) 213. Chow, T. P., and Ghezzo, M., Mat. Res. Soc. Syrup. Proc. 423:9-21 (1996) 214. Weitzel, C. E., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 765-768, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 215. Siergiej, R. R., Sriram, S., Clarke, R. C., Agarwal, A. K., Brandt, C. D., Burke, A. A., Jr., Morse, A., and Orphanos, P. A., Inst. Phys. Conf. Set. No. 142, pp. 769-772, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 216. Sriram, S., Clarke, R. C., Burke, A. A., Jr., Hobgood, H. M., McMullin, P. G., Orphanos, P. A., Siergiej, R. R., Smith, T. J., Brandt, C. D., Driver, M. C., and Hopkins, R. H., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 15(11):458-459 (Nov., 1994) 217. Sriram, S., Augustine, G., Burke, A. A., Jr., Glass, R. C., Hobgood, H. M., Orphanos, P. A., Rowland, L. B., Smith, T. J., Bran&, C. D., Driver, M. C., and Hopkins, R. H., IEEEElect. Dev. Leg., 17(7):369-371 (July, 1996)
P r o c e s s i n g o f Silicon Carbide f o r Devices a n d Circuits
245
218. Morse, A. W., Esker, P. M., Sriram, S., Hawkins, J. J., Chen, L. S., Ostop, J. A., Smith, T. J., Davis, C. D., Barton, R. R., Clarke, R. C., Siergiej, R. R., and Brandt, C. D., IEEE MTT-S (Int'l. Microwave Symp.), Denver, CO (June 8-13, 1997) 219. Weitzel, C. E., Palmour, J. W., Carter, C. H., Jr., and Nordquist, K. J., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 15(10):406-408 (Oct., 1994) 220. Tsap, B., Solid-State Electronics, 38(6):1215-1219 (June, 1995) 221. Palmour, J. W., Carter, C. H., Jr., Weitzel, C. E., and Nordquist, K. J., Diamond, SiC and Nitride Wide Bandgap Semi. Mat. Res. Soc. Syrup. Proc., Vol. 339, MRS, Pittsburgh, PA, USA, pp. 133-134 (1994) 222. Moore, K. E., Weitzel, C. E., Nordquist, K. J., Pond, L. L., III, Palmour, J. W., Allen, S., and Carter, C. H., Jr., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 18(2):69-70 (Feb., 1997) 223. Palmour, J. W., H.-S. Kong, and Carter, C. H., Jr., Int'l. Semi. Device Research Symp., pp. 491-4, Charlottesville, VA USA (Dec. 4-6, 1991) 224. Neudeck, P. G., Petit, J. B., and Salupo, C. S., Trans. 2nd Int'l. High Temp. Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Charlotte, NC, Session X, pp. 23-28 (June 5-10, 1994) 225. Dohnke, K. O., Peters, D., Rupp, R., Volkl, J., and Stephani, D., Supplemental Trans. 2nd Int '1. High Temp. Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Charlotte, NC (June 5-10, 1994) 226. Ivanov, P. A., Savkina, N. -S., Samsonova, T. P., Panteleev, V. N., and Chelnokov, V. E., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 593-595, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 227. Palmour, J. W., Edmond, J. A., Kong, H. S., and Carter, C. H., Jr., Physica B, 185:461-465 (1993) 228. Rupp, R., Dohnke, K., V61kl, J. and Stephani, D., Inst. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 503-6, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 229. McLean, F. B., Tipton, C. W., and McGarrity, J. M., Inst. Conf. Ser. No. 13 7, pp. 507-510, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 230. Dohnke, K., Rupp, R., Peters, D., V61kland, J. and Stephani, D., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 625-627, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 231. Alok, D., and Baliga, B. J., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 749-752, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 232. Casady, J. B., Sheridan, D. C., DiUard, W. C., and Johnson, R. W., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 423:105-110 (1996) 233. Krishnamurthy, V., Brown, D. M., Ghezzo, M., Kretchmer, J., Hennessy, W., Downey, E., and Michon, G., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 483-486, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994)
246
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
234. Sheppard, S. T., Melloch, M. R., and Cooper, J. A., IEEE Trans. on Elect. Dev., 41:1257-1264 (July, 1994) 235. Casady, J. B., Cressler, J. D., Dillard, W. C., Johnson, R. W., Agarwal, A. K., and Siergiej, R. R., Solid-State Electronics, 39(6):777-784 (June, 1996) 236. Kong, H. S., Edmond, J. A., Palmour, J. W., Glass, J. T., and Davis, R. F., Springer Proc. Phys., Vol. 34, Springer-Verlag (1989) 237. Palmour, J. W., Kong, H. S., and Davis, R. F.,J. Appl. Phys., 64(4):2168-2177 (1988) 238. Palmour, J. W., Kong, H. S., and Davis, R. F., Appl. Phys. Lett., 51(24):2028-2030 (1987) 239. Palmour, J. W., Kong, H. S., and Waltz, D. G., Edmond, J. A., and Carter, C. H., Jr., Trans., 1st Int'l. High Temperature Electronics Conf. (HiTEC), Albuquerque, NM USA, pp. 229-236 (June 16-20, 1991) 240. Siergiej, R. R., Clarke, R. C., Agarwal, A. K., Brandt, C. D., Burke, A. A., Jr., Morse, A., and Orphanos, P. A., Tech. Digest, Int'l. Elect. Dev. Meeting (IEDM), pp. 353-356 (Dec., 1995) 241. Siergiej, R. R., Morse, A. W., Esker, P. M., Smith, T. J., Bojko, R. J., Rowland, L. B., and Clarke, R. C., IEEE 55 th Annual Device Research Conference (June 23-25, 1997) 242. Bhatnagar, M., Alok, D., and Baliga, B. J., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 703-6, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 243. Shenoy, J. N., Cooper, J. A., Jr., and Melloch, M. R., IEEE Electron Dev. Leg., 18(3):93-95 (Mar., 1997) 244. Casady, J. B., Agarwal, A. K., Rowland, L. B., Valek, W. F., and Brandt, C. D., IEEE 55 th Annual Device Research Conference (June 23-25, 1997) 245. Bhatnagar, M., and Baliga, B. J., IEEE Trans. on Elect. Dev., 40(3):645-655 (Mar., 1993) 246. Agarwal, A. K., Siergiej, R. R., White, M. H., McMullin, P. G., Burke, A. A., Rowland, L. B., Brandt, C. D., and Hopkins, R. H., Mat. Res. Soc. Syrup. Proc., 423:87-92(1996) 247. Palmour, J. W., Edmond, J. A., Kong, H. S., and Carter, C. H., Jr., Proc.28th Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conf., American Chemical Society, pp. 1.249-1.254 (Aug., 1993) 248. Palmour, J. W., Allen, S. T., Singh, R., Lipkin, L. A., and Waltz, D. G., Inst. Phys. Conf. Set. No. 142, pp. 813-816, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 249. Xie, K., Buchwald, W. R., Zhao, J. H., Flemish, J. R., Burke, T., Kingsley, L., Weiner, M., and Singh, H., Int'l. Electron Dev. Meet. Tech. Digest, pp. 415-418 (Dec. 11-14, 1994)
P r o c e s s i n g o f Silicon Carbide f o r Devices a n d Circuits
247
250. Xie, C. K., Flemish, J. R., Burke, T., Buchwald, W. R., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., Vol. 423 (1996) 251. Xie,K., Zhao, J. H., Flemish, J. R., Burke, T., Buchwald, W. 1L, Lorenzo, G., and Singh, H., IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., 17(3): 142-144 (Mar., 1996) 252. Agarwal, A. K., Casady, J. B., Rowland, L. B., Seshadri, S., Valek, W. F., and Brandt, C. D., IEEEElectron Dev.Lett. (submitted Feb. 11, 1997) 253. Pelaz, L., Orantes, J. L., Vincente, J., Bailon, L. A., and Barbolla, J., IEEE Trans. on Elect. Dev., 41 (4):587-590 (Apr., 1994) 254. Edmond, J. A., Das, K., and Davis, R. F., J. Appl. Phys., 63:922-929 (Feb., 1988) 255. Neudeck, P. G., Larkin, D. J., Salupo, C. S., Powell, J. A., and Matus, L. G., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, pp. 475-478, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 256. K/Srdina, O., Bergman, J. P., Henry, A., Janzen, E., Savage, S., Andre, J., Ramberg, L. P., Lindefelt, U., Hermansson, W., and Bergman, K., Appl. Phys. Leg., 67:1561-1563 (1995) 257. Neudeck, P. G., and Fazi, C., IEEE Electron Dev. Lett., 18(3):96-98 (Mar., 1997) 258. Bhatnagar, M., McLarty, P. K., and Baliga, B. J., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 13(10):501-503 (Oct., 1992) 259. Emons, C. H. H., Koster, R., Paxman, D., and Theunissen, M. J. J., Proc. of lEEE Bipolar/BiCMOS Circuits & Technology Meeting (BCTM), pp. 72-75 (Dec., 1994) 260. Sugii, T., Yamazaki, T., and Ito, T., IEEE Trans. Elect. Dev., 37(11):2331-2335 (Nov., 1990) 261. Shaft, Z. A., Post, I. R. C., Whitehurst, J., Wensley, P., Ashburn, P., Moynagh, P. B., and Booker, G. R., Proc. of IEEE Bipolar/BiCMOS Circuits & Technology Meeting (BCTM), pp. 67-70 (1991) 262. Chang, S. S., Pankove, J., Leksono, M., and VanZeghbroeck, B., 53ra Dev. Research Conf. Digest, pp. 106-107 (June 19-21, 1995) 263. Tomano, M., Johnson, R. W., Jaeger, R. C., and DiUard, W. C., IEEE Trans. Comp. Hybrids, andMan. Tech., 16(5):536-542 (Aug., 1993) 264. Tomano, M., Johnson, R. W., Jaeger, R. C., and Palmour, J. W., Proc. of the 42nd Elect. Comp. and Tech. Conf., pp. 157-161 (May 18-20, 1992) 265. Brown, D. M., Ghezzo, M., Kretchmer, J., Krishnamurthy, V., Michon, G., Gati, G., Trans. 2nd lnt'l. High Temp. Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Charlotte, N.C., Session XI, pp. 17-22 (June 5-10, 1994) 266. Slater, D. B., Jr., Lipkin, L. A., Johnson, G. M., Suvorov, A. V., and Palmour, J. W., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 805-808, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996)
248
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
267. Palmour, J. W., private communication (Feb. 21, 1996) 268. Dillard, W. C., Casady, J. B., Jaeger, R. C., Sheridan, D. C., and Johnson, R. W., Trans. 3ra Int'l. High Temp. Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Albuquerque, NM, Session VIII, pp. 15-20 (June 9-14, 1996) 269. Xie, W., Cooper, J. A., Jr., and Melloch, M. R., IEEE Elect. Dev. Lett., 15(1):455-457 (Nov., 1994) 270. Casady, J. B., Dillard, W. C., Johnson, R. W., and Rao, U., IEEE Trans. Comp., Pack., andMan. Tech.-A, 19(3):416-422 (Sept., 1996) 271. Dezauzier, C., Becourt, N., Amaud, G., Contreras, S., Ponthenier, J. L., Camassel, J., Robert, J. L., Pascual, J., Jaussaud, C., Sensors and Actuators, A: Physical, 46:71-75 (Jan.-Feb., 1995) 272. Campbell, R. B., Silicon Carbide-1973, (R. C. Marshall, J. W. Faust, Jr., and C. E. Ryan, eds.), pp. 611-617, Univ. of South Carolina Press, Columbia, SC (1974) 273. Brown, D. M., IEEE Trans. Elect. Devices, 40:325-333 (1993) 274. Edmond, J. A., Kong, H. S., and Carter, C. H., Jr., Physica B, 185.453-460 (1993) 275. Brown, D. M., Downey, E., Kretchmer, J., Michon, G., Shu, E., and Schneider, D., Trans. 3rd Int'l. High Temperature Elect. Conf. (HiTEC), Volume 1, Session X, pp. 23-28 (June, 1996) 276. Shields, V. B., Ryan, M. A., and Williams, R. M., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 1067-1070, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 277. Hunter, G. W., Neudeck, P. G., Knight, D., Liu, C. C., and Wu, Q. H., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 817-820, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 278. Arbab, A., Spetz, A., ul Wahab, Q., Willander M., and Lundstrom, I., Sensors and Materials, Vol. 4, (MYU, Tokyo), pp. 173-185 (1993) 279. Kr6tz,G., Wagner, C., Legner, W., Sormtag,H., M611er,H., and MOiler, G., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, pp. 829-832, lOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 280. Cooper, J. A., Jr., MeUoch, M. R., Xie, W., Palmour, J. W., and Carter, C. H., Jr., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser., No. 137, pp. 711-714, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 281. Morkoc, H., Strite, S., Gao, G. B., Lin, M. E., Sverdlov, B., and Bums, M., J. Appl. Phys., 76(3):1363-1398 (Aug 1., 1994) 282. Davis, R. F., Physica B, 185:1-15 (1993) 283. Neudeck, P. G., J. Elect. Mat., 24(4):283-288 (1995) 284. Perkins, J. F., Hopkins, R. H., Brandt, C. D., Agarwal, A. K., Seshadri, S. and Siergiej, R. R., ASME Meeting-Turbo Expo, Bkmingham, UK (July, 1996)
Processing of Silicon Carbide for Devices and Circuits
249
285. Semler, C. E., and Cawley, J. D., Ceramic Transactions Silicon Carbide '87, The American Ceramic Society, Inc. (1989) 286. Marshall, R. C., Faust, J. W., Jr., Ryan, C. E., Silicon Carbide-1973, Proc. of 3rd Int'l. Conf. on Silicon Carbide, Miami Beach, FL, Univ. of South Carolina Press (1974) 287. Harris, G. L., Yang, C. Y.-W., Proc. ofthe 1st Int'l. Conf., Washington, DC, Dec. 10-11, 1987, Springer-Verlag,Berlin (1989) 288. Rahman, M. M., Yang, C. Y., and Harris, G. L., Proc. of the 2nd Int'l. Conf., Santa Clara, CA, Dec. 15-16, 1988, Springer-Verlag,Berlin (1989) 289. Harris, G. L., Spencer, M. G. and C.Y.-W. Yang, Proc. of the 3rd lnt'l. Conf., Howard Univ., Washington, D.C., April 11-13, 1990, SpringerVerlag, Berlin (1992) 290. Yang, C. Y., Rahman, M. M., and Harris, G. L., Proc. of the 4th lnt 7. Conf., Santa Clara, CA, Oct. 9-11, 1991, Springer-Vedag, Berlin (1992) 291. Spencer, M. G., Devaty, R. P., Edmond, J. A., Khan, M. A., Kaplan, R., and Rahman, M. M., Proc. of the 5th Conf., Nov. 1-3, 1993, Washington, D.C., Inst. of Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 137, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1994) 292. Nakashima, S., Matsunami, H., Yoshida, S., and Harima, H., Proc. of the 6th Conf., Sept. 18-21, 1995, Kyoto, Japan, Inst. of Phys. Conf. Ser. No. 142, IOP Publishing, Ltd. (1996) 293. O'Connor, J. R., and Smiltens, J., Proceedings of the Conference on Silicon Carbide, Boston, MA, USA, April 2-3, 1959, Pergamon Press, New York (1960) 294. Silicon Carbide-1968, Proc. of the International Conf., University Park, Penn. State University, PA, USA, Oct. 20-23, 1968, Pergamon Press, New York(1969)
295. Diamond, Silicon Carbide and Related Wide Bandgap Semiconductors, MRS Symposium, Nov. 27-Dec. 1, 1989, Boston, MA, MRS Proc. Vol. 162, Pittsburgh, PA (1990) 296. Diamond, Silicon Carbide and Nitride Wide Bandgap Semiconductors, MRS Symposium, April 4-8, 1994, San Francisco, CA, MRS Symp. Proc. Vol. 339, Pittsburgh, PA (1994) 297. llI-Nitride, SiC, and Diamond Materials For Electronic Devices, April 8-12, 1996, San Francisco, CA, MRS Symp. Proc. Vol. 423, Pittsburgh, PA (1996)
298. 38 th Electronic Materials Conference, Univ. of California at Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara, CA, USA (June 26-28, 1996) 299. International Conference on SiC, III-Nitrides, and Related Materials, Stockholm, Sweden, Aug. 31-Sept. 5 (1997)
300. Casady, J. B., and Johnson, R. W., Solid-State Electronics, 39(10):14091422 (Oct., 1996)
6 Plasma Etching of III-V Nitrides Randy J. Shul
1.0
INTRODUCTION
Interest in GaN and related III-V nitride materials continues to grow as demonstrations of blue, green, and ultraviolet (UV) light emitting diodes (LEDs), blue lasers, and high temperature transistors are reported.[l]-[221 Many of these advances may be attributed to the recent progress in material growth technology. Although further improvements in material properties can be expected, enhanced device performance will also require improved process capabilities, including plasma etching. Laser facet fabrication is especially dependent upon plasma etch pattern transfer, since the majority of epitaxially grown III-V nitrides are on sapphire substrates which inhibit cleaving the sample with reasonable yield. Plasma etching has had a significant impact on the fabrication of several photonic and electronic devices to improve critical dimension control, reproducibility, and anisotropy over wet chemical etching. Although many advances in plasma etch technology have transpired, the rapid development of state-of-the-art devices, sub-0.5 gm features, and complex material structures (including the III-V nitrides), has increased the requirements for etch processes. Plasma etch processes often demand highly anisotropic profiles, high etch rates, smooth morphologies, and low-damage. Etching III-V nitrides is further complicated due to their inert chemical nature 250
Plasma Etching of lll- V Nitrides 251 and their strong bond energies, as compared to other compound semiconductors. GaN has a bond energy of 8.92 eV/atom, InN, 7.72 eV/atom, and A1N, 11.52 eV/atom as compared to GaAs which has a bond energy of 6.52 eV/atom. Due to high bond energies and inert chemical behavior, the III-V nitrides resist etching in standard, room temperature wet chemical etchants. Therefore, essentially all device patterning has been accomplished using plasma etching technology. For example, commercially available LEDs from Nichia are fabricated using a C12-based RIE to expose the n-layer of the heterostructure.[1][2][5]The first GaN-based laser diode was also fabricated using RIE to form the laser facets.[71 The etched sidewalls were somewhat rough and may have contributed to scattering loss and a high lasing threshold, thus demonstrating the need for improved plasma etch capability. Perhaps the most significant advancement in plasma etching of the III-V nitrides has been the utilization of high-density plasmas. High-density plasma etch systems typically yield higher etch rates with less damage than more conventional reactive ion etch (RIE) systems. This is due to plasma densities which are 2 to 4 orders of magnitude greater and the ability to effectively decouple ion energies and plasma density. Etch profiles also tend to be more anisotropic due to lower process pressures which result in less collisional scattering of the plasma species. Plasma etching of GaN has been reported using several techniques including: RIE, electron cyclotron resonance (ECR), inductively coupled plasma (ICP), magnetron reactive ion etch (MIE) systems, and chemically assisted ion beam etching (CAIBE). This chapter examines the advances made in patterning III-V nitrides. Etch data are reviewed for wet chemical etching, RIE, ion beam etching, and high-density etch systems. Etch rates, profiles, plasma-induced-damage, near-surface stoiehiometry, and surface and sidewall morphology will be discussed. Several excellent reference sourees[Z3H251 are available to provide a thorough background of plasma science.
2.0. E T C H TECHNIQUES
2.1
Wet Chemical Etching
Wet chemical etching with acid or base solutions is often used to transfer patterns into compound semiconductors. The process involves
252
Wide B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s
either the oxidation or reduction of the semiconductor surface followed by removal of the soluble reaction product. For a diffusion-limited reaction, rates are limited by either the diffusion of reactive species to the surface or diffusion of the soluble reaction products from the surface. Diffusionlimited reactions are often difficult to control due to the flow dynamics involved. Alternatively, for a reaction-limited etch, chemical reaction at the substrate surface is the rate-limiting-step. These processes are much easier to control and are highly temperature dependent as shown in the equation: Eq. (1)
Etch rate = Ke'ea/kr
where K is the temperature dependent constant, E a is the activation energy, k is the Boltzmann constant, and T is the temperature of the solution. Wet etching is typically highly selective with virtually no damage to the material. The etch is often crystallographic or isotropic, difficult to control, and has poor resolution, thereby limiting the critical dimension of the etched features. Due to their inert chemical nature and high bond strengths, the III-V nitrides resist etching in common compound semiconductor wet chemical etchants at room temperature. Very slow etching of GaN has been reported in hot alkalis or electrolitically in NaOH.[26][27] InN etch rates of 300-600 A/min have been reported in aqueous KOH and NaOH at 60~ 29] For amorphous or polycrystalline A1N, wet chemical etching has been reported in several different solutions including H3PO4, HF/H20, HNO3/HF, and dilute NaOH at relatively low rates (<500 A/min).[3~ 36] Mileham et al. compiled etch results for binary III-V nitrides in a series of wet chemical etchants.[ 3711381GaN and InN did not etch in either acid or base solutions below--80~ However, single crystal A1N etched in strong KOH- and NaOH-based solutions at room temperature. Figure 1 shows etch rates as a function of solution temperature for three different A1N samples in a KOHbased photoresist developer solution (AZ400K). The etch was strongly dependent upon etchant concentration and temperature, but was not responsive to agitation. This implies a reaction-limited etch regime. The data are also displayed as an Arrhenius plot in Fig. 2. The data designated by triangles represent the polycrystalline A1N grown on GaAs, while the two other samples are single-crystal A1N grown on A120 3. The polycrystalline sample etches much faster than the single-crystal sample as can be seen in Figs. 1 and 2. The data designated by circles has a double crystal x-ray diffraction peak width of 400 arc sec while the data designated by squares
Plasma Etching of lll- VNitrides 253 have a peak width of--200 arc see. Higher etch rates for lower crystalline quality material may be attributed to more defects or dangling bonds with which OH- ions in the etch solution can interact. The etching process has an activation energy of-15.45 kCal/mol. A1N etch rates are well controlled, highly selective to GaN and InN, isotropic, temperature dependent, and strongly dependent on material quality.
12,000
I'"
I
!
- - ~ Al203HiQu' gh ,dityIklNon I
lO,O00
-(~ -/kiNon AI203 - -~-- AINon GaAs
~
9 -2
!
I
8000
i
iiiii
o
6000
=9 u.l
4000
i
,
A
I
2000
A~ !
!
0
20
(3"" |
~
40
60
I
I
(3
.80
100
Temperature (~ Figure 1. A1Netch rates for threedifferentqualitysamplesversussolutiontemperaturefor a KOH-basedphotoresistdeveloper(AZ400K).
Photoenhanced wet chemical etching has recently been reported for GaN.[39][4~ Photoenhanced wet chemical etching incorporates the photogeneration of electrons and holes in the material to enhance chemical etching. Minsky et al. reported etch rates for unintentionally doped n-type GaN, ranging from a few 100 A/rnin in HC1 solutions to several 1000 A/ rain in KOH solutions using a He-Cd laser.[39] Youtsey et al. recently reported photoenhanced etching of GaN at rates of-200 A/rain in KOH using broad-area Hg lamp illumination.[4~ Etching was observed for both n+ and unintentionally doped GaN while no etching was observed for p-GaN.
254
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
I
104
I
I
_ AIN
1000
I
I
~AIN on GaAs
_
on(~)Al203
HighQ u a l i t y ~
-- ~
"
m
100 2.6
,
%
2.8
3
3.2
3.4
3.6
3.8
1000/T (K) Figure 2. Arrenhius plot of AIN etch rate for three different samples etched in AZ400K developer solution. The activation energy (Ea) is 15.45 + 0.44 kCal/mol.
2.2
RIE Etching
High quality plasma etching of the III-V nitrides has been developed due, in part, to the shortcomings of wet chemical etching. In general, plasma etching involves two general mechanisms: (i) a chemical based mechanism where reactive species formed in the plasma interact with the substrate and (/0 a physical based mechanism where energetic ions formed in the plasma sputter the substrate surface. The plasma etch process consists of the following series of steps: (a) Production of reactants in the plasma (b) Transport of reactants to the substrate surface (e) Adsorption of reactants onto the substrate surface (d) Chemical reaction (e) Desorption of the etch products from the surface Etch processes dominated by chemical mechanisms tend to be isotropic with virtually no physical ion bombardment of the substrate surface, thus minimizing plasma-induced-damage. However, this can lead to a loss of critical dimensions, thereby reducing the utility of the process for device fabrication. Alternatively, physically dominated etch mechanisms initiate sputter desorption of the substrate and/or etch products formed on
Plasma Etching of llI-V Nitrides 255 the surface by high energy ions (> 100 eV). The etch is characteristically anisotropic but can result in significant damage, rough surface morphology, and a non-stoichiometrie surface (thus minimizing device performance). A well-designed etch process can balance the chemical and physical components of the etch mechanism to yield high resolution features with minimal damage. The purely physical component of an etch mechanism is exhibited by ion milling. Pearton et al.[411reported ion milling rates for GaN, InN, A1N, and InGaN using 100-500 eV Ar + ions. The ion milling rates were approximately a factor of 2 less than that for GaAs or InP due to stronger bond energies of the III-V nitrides. The milled surfaces were quite smooth with virtually no change in the near-surface stoichiometry. RIE utilizes both chemical and physical components of an etch mechanism. The plasma is typically generated at a radio frequency (rf) of 13.56 MHz between two parallel electrodes in a reactive gas (see Fig. 3). The substrate is placed on the powered electrode and is etched by chemical and physical interactions between the reactive and ionized species formed in the plasma and the substrate surface. The etch is enhanced by sputtering of the surface by impinging ions which typically have energies of a few hundred volts. Ion bombardment energies are defined as the energy with which ions cross the plasma sheath formed just above the substrate. This physical component of the etch mechanism enhances the anisotropy of the etch, independent of the crystallographic orientation of the substrate. RIE typically runs at relatively low pressures ranging from a few mtorr up to 200 mtorr, further enhancing the anisotropy of the etch by minimizing collisional scattering of the ions. Several reports of RIE etching of the III-V nitrides show that it has been quite successful with GaN etching in chlorine-[421[43] and bromine-[441 based plasma chemistries. The first RIE etching of GaN was reported by Adesida and co-workers in SIC14, SiC14/Ar, and SiC14/SiF4 plasmas.[421Etch rates increased monotonically with increasing de-bias, exceeding 500 A/min at -400 V. Etch rate was independent of pressure (20 to 80 mtorr) and plasma chemistry. Etches were smooth with an overcut profile due to the physical component of the etch mechanism. Lin et al. reported similar results in BC13 and SiC14 plasmas with increasing GaN etch rates as the rfpower was increased.[43]Etch rates as high as 1050 A/min were reported in the BC13 plasma, while etch rates in SiC14 were slower. Ping et al. reported GaN etch rates in HBr, HBr/Ar, and HBr/H 2 exceeding 600 A/min at -400 V de-bias.[44]The addition of either Ar or H Eto the HBr plasma lowered the
256
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
etch rates under all plasma conditions studied. GaN etching was also reported in CHF3/Ar and C2C1Fs/Ar RIE plasmas with rates ranging from 60-470 A/min.[ 45] Etch rates increased with rf-power and decreased with pressure. For R/E, the best GaN etch results were obtained under high ion energy conditions where the GaN bonds could be more easily broken and the sputter desorption mechanism was more efficient.
Showerhead Gas D i s t f i r'--'-.-" ~'
b
."r': "-''~~' T I ' :
u
~
..... ~ . ' - ' ~ " ' - : ~ 7 1
Powered .................. ~ Electrode- ~ . ~ _ . . . _ ~ .~.
! ...
-- q ~ m n l a
. . . . . r,--,
13.56 _-MHz To Pumping System Figure 3.
Schematic diagram of a reactive ion etch (RIE) system.
Improved etch rates and anisotropic profiles achieved with RIE, as compared to wet chemical etching, may be partially attributed to the acceleration of energetic ions from the plasma to the wafer. However, this energetic ion bombardment of the surface can damage the sample and degrade both electrical and optical device performance. Attempts to minimize such damage by reducing the ion energy or increasing the chemical activity in the plasma often results in a loss of etch rate or anisotropy. This significantly limits critical dimensions and reduces the utility of the process for device applications requiting vertical etch profiles. Therefore, it is necessary to develop plasma etch processes which yield anisotropic profiles, high etch rates, and low-damage for optimum device performance.
Plasma Etching of lll-VNitrides 257
2.3
High-Density Plasma Etching
Low-damage, high-density plasmas including ECR, ICP, and MIE, have shown improved etch results for the III-V nitrides as compared to R/E. Ion densities often exceeding 5 x 1011 cm -3 are produced in the highdensity systems, which increases the potential etch rate due to higher ion and neutral reactant flux. A schematic diagram of a typical low profile ECR system is shown in Fig. 4. [46]-[48] Due to the magnetic confinement of electrons within the microwave source (2.45 GHz), high-density plasmas are formed at low pressures with low plasma potentials and ion energies. The sample is located downstream from the microwave source to minimize exposure to the intense discharge and to reduce the physical ion bombardment component of the etch. Therefore, less damage than that produced by RIE has been observed during ECR etching of III-V materials.[ 49]-[53] Highly anisotropic etching can be achieved by superimposing an if-bias (13.56 MHz) on the sample and employing low pressure conditions (< 5 mtorr), minimizing ion scattering and lateral etching. With rf-biasing, energetic ions are accelerated from the plasma to the sample with the potential for kinetic damage to the surface. This is differentiated from RIE in that the incident ion energy is decoupled from the ion current density or plasma power.
2.45 GHz Microwave
~
Upper Magnets
[
.!Plasma i ,'~. '7 9
..... : .....
.
...
.
j,
Load Lock
, 9 .. 9
Sample ~-
:
. . .
~ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ ~
/
Collimating Magnets
13.56 MHz
]_--
Figure 4. Schematic diagram of an electron cyclotron resonance (ECR) etch system.
258
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
The first ECR etching of GaN, InN, and A1N, was reported by Pearton and co-workers using low pressure CH4/H2/Ar , BCI3/Ar, C12, and C12/H2 plasmas.[ 54] The etch rates for all three materials increased with increasing de-bias. As H 2 was added to the C12 plasma, etch rates also increased and the surface morphology became smoother, implying equirate removal of the group-III and N etch products. The etch rates ranged from 100-400 A/min at 1 mtorr and - 150 V de-bias for C12/H2 plasmas. Slower rates (typically < 100 A/min) were observed in CH4/H2/Ar plasmas. Higher de-biases were necessary to initiate etching. Etch rates were fiarther improved as the plasma density or ECR source power was increased.[ 551Etch rates of 1100 A/min for A1N and 700 A/min for GaN at -150 V de-bias in a C12/H2 plasma and 3 50 A/min for InN in a CH4/H2/Ar plasma at -250 V debias were reported. The etched surfaces remained stoichiometric and profiles were anisotropic over a wide range of plasma conditions. Several additional reports have been published for ECR etching of GaN with etch rates as high as 1.3 ~tm/min at <-275 V de-bias. [56]-[64] ICP offers an alternative high-density plasma technique where plasmas are formed in a dielectric vessel encircled by an inductive coil into which rf-power is applied,[47][48] as shown in Fig. 5. The electric field produced by the coils in the horizontal plane induces a strong magnetic field in the vertical plane, trapping electrons in the center of the chamber and generating a high-density plasma. At low pressures (< 20 mtorr), the plasma diffuses from the generation region and drifts to the substrate at relatively low ion energy. Thus, ICP etching is also expected to produce low damage with high etch rates. As with ECR etching, anisotropic profiles are obtained by superimposing a rf-bias on the sample to independently control ion energy. The general belief is that ICP sources are easier to scale-up than ECR sources and are more economical in terms of cost and power requirements. ICP does not require the electromagnets or waveguiding technology necessary in ECR. Additionally, automatic tuning technology is much more advanced for rf-plasmas than for microwave discharges. The first ICP etch results for GaN were reported in a C12/H2/Ar ICP-generated plasma with etch rates as high as 6875 7k/min.[65][66]Etch rates increased with increasing de-bias and etch profiles were highly anisotropic with smooth etch morphologies. MIE is similar to RIE with the addition of a magnetic field which confines the plasma electrons close to the powered electrode, and therefore to the sample.[67][ 68] Under these conditions, electron wall loss is minimized and ionization efficiency, generation of reactive species, and etch
Plasma Etching of lll-VNitrides
259
rates are increased. Higher plasma densities can be sustained at much lower and more controlled de-biases as compared to RIE. Therefore, ion bombardment energies and plasma-induced-damage are lower while etch rates remain high. Etch rates of 3500 A/min were achieved in MIE using BCI 3 plasmas at de-biases less than -100 V and 5 mtorr pressure.[ 69] The etch was fairly smooth, with anisotropic profiles. Auger electron spectroscopy (AES) showed etched surfaces with lower Ga:N ratios up to a depth of-100 A.
Showerhead Gas Distribution..~, iiilili
J
1
I i 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Alumina 0 Chamber,,,,,,~[i i
- i-
rf Power Supply
i:
iPlasma I
O!. L o ad L ock
"........ ~ ; . ~ ; L Z S ; ; ; ; . . , ~ - ~
~,\\\\\\\\\\\\\\~~\\\\\\\\\~%~"~
Sample
J l l l l l l l ' l , ~ l l l l l t l l l l l l l ~ Ill
Powered Electrode
9 =" MHz
Figure 5. Schematic diagram of an inductively coupled plasma (ICP) etch system.
2.4
Additional Plasma Etch Platforms
Ion beam techniques, such as chemically assisted ion beam etching (CAIBE) and reactive ion beam etching (R/BE), typically use ECR or ICP sources to generate high-density plasmas. Samples are separated from the ion source by one or more grids which are used to accelerate ions to the surface at highly controlled energies. Ion energies are ordinarily higher (300-2000 eV) than those generated in RIE, ECR, or ICP. Due to the acceleration of the ions and the low process pressures used (< 5 mtorr), etch profiles are highly anisotropic, however the potential for plasmainduced-damage exists. In CAIBE, reactive gases are added to the plasma
260
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
downstream of the acceleration grids to enhance the chemical component of the etch mechanism; whereas in RIBE, reactive gases are introduced in the ion source. Using CAIBE, GaN etch rates as high as 2100 A/rain were reported with a 500 eV Ar + ion beam directed onto the sample in either a C12 or HC1 arnbient.[7~ 71] Etch rates increased with beam current, reactive gas flow rate, and substrate temperature. Anisotropic profiles with smooth etch morphologies were observed. An alternate, low-damage etch technology which has recently stimulated interest is low energy electron enhanced etching (LE4).[ 72]-[751Electrons at low energies (- 15 eV) arrive at the semiconductor surface with reactive species at thermal velocity. The electrons have virtually no momenturn and therefore do not induce damage to the semiconductor as observed by other plasma etch techniques. The electrons appear to enhance reactions between the reactive gas and the semiconductor yielding highly anisotropic profiles. LE4 etching of GaN in pure H 2 showed a strong temperature dependence with etch rates ranging from ~70 A/min at 50~ to ~500 A/min at 250~ [74][75]In a pure C12 LE4 plasma, GaN etch rates of 2500 A/min were reported at 100~ Etch profiles were highly anisotropic with smooth morphologies and stoichiometric surfaces. Photoassisted dry etching of GaN has been reported in HC1 using 193 nm ArF excimer laser for illumination.[ 76] At temperatures between 200 and 400~ the GaN etch was smooth with distinct sidewalls and etch rates < 80 A/min. Laser interactions with the GaN and the HC1 resulted in vibrational and electronic excitation which led to bond breaking and desorption of reactant products.[ 77] The laser energy enhanced the reaction between HC1 and GaN, yielding GaC1x products which thermally desorb while N is removed as either molecular N 2 or NH x.
3.0
PLASMA CHEMISTRY
Several different plasma chemistries have been used to etch compound semiconductor materials, including halogen- and hydrocarbon-based plasmas. Review articles are available Which summarize etch results for GaAs and InP under a variety of plasma conditions.[781[79] Table 1 shows the boiling points of several possible etch products formed when compound semiconductor materials are exposed to halogen- or hydrocarbonbased plasmas. For halogen-based plasmas, compound semiconductor etch
Plasma Etching of lll-VNitrides 261 rates are typically limited by the volatility of the group-III halogen etch product. Therefore, chlorine-based chemistries are preferred to etch Gacontaining materials due to the high volatility of GaC13 as compared to fluoride-based etch products. In a chlorine-based plasma, GaAs etch rates are typically fast (> 2 ~tm/min), well controlled, anisotropie, and smooth. The etch rates tend to be faster in pure C12 due to the strong chemical component of the etch mechanism and the high concentration of reactive C1 available in the plasma. However, the surface morphology can be rough. The addition of BC13 to the plasma chemistry reduces the etch rate due to less available reactive C1, but the etch tends to be smoother and more anisotropie (due to a higher physical component of the etch mechanism). Smooth anisotropie profiles have also been obtained for Ga-eontaining compound semiconductors etched in CH4/Hz-based plasma chemistries at much slower rates as compared to Cl-based plasmas. This is unexpected based on the information in Table 1 (the volatility of the Ga(CH3) 3 etch product is much higher than that for GaC13 and demonstrates the complexity of the etch process where redeposition, polymer formation, and gasphase kinetics can influence the etch rates). Etch rates for In-containing species in a RIE-generated C12 plasma at room temperature tend to range from a few hundred to-1000 A/min. The surfaces are typically rough with an overcut profile due to the low volatility of the InC13 etch products and preferential loss of the group-V species. However, at elevated temperatures (>130~ the volatility of InC13 etch product increases and the etch rates and surface morphology improve.[8~ 831 Recently, high rate InP etching (1.0 to 3.8 ~tm/min) has been reported in C12/Ar ECR-generated plasmas at 25~ [84][85]These results suggest that using a high-density plasma etch platform enables sufficient sputter desorption of the low volatility InC13 etch products before the surface is passivated. However, for room temperature etching of In-containing films, CHa/H2-based plasmas have often been preferred due to the formation of volatile (CH3)3In etch products.[ 55][86]-[89]InP etch rates obtained in RIEand ECR-generated CHa/H2 plasmas range from--500 to 1000 A/min with anisotropic profiles and smooth etch surfaces. GaN typically etches at much slower rates than GaAs. The high volatilities of the Ga- and the nitrogen-based etch products shown in Table 1 implies that the etch rates are not limited by desorption of the etch products. However, due to the strong bond energies of the III-V nitrides, the initial breaking of the group-III-N bond, which must precede the etch product formation, may be the rate limiting step.[ 9~ This topic will be discussed in more detail later in this chapter.
262
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
T a b l e 1. Boiling Points for Possible Etch Products o f C o m p o u n d S e m i c o n ductor M a t e r i a l s E t c h e d in H a l o g e n - or CHa/H2-based P l a s m a s
Etch Products
3.1
Boiling Points (~
AICI3
183
AIF3
na
AII3
360
A1Br3
263
(CH3)3AI
126
GaCI 3
201
GaF 3
1000
GaI 3
sublimes 345
GaBr3
279
(CH3)3Ga InCl 3
55.7 600
InF 3
>1200
InI 3
na
InBr3
sublimes
(CH3)3In
134
PC13
76
PF 3
-101
PI 3
decomposes
PBr 3
173
PH 3
-88
AsC13
130
AsF 3
-63
AsI 3
403
AsBr3
221
AsH 3
-55
Gas Mixtures A l t h o u g h fast G a N etch rates h a v e b e e n observed in c h l o r i n e - b a s e d
plasmas, the source o f reactive C1 as well as the use o f additive gases h a v e not been discussed. V e r y often gas m i x t u r e s are used in a p l a s m a to increase etch rate, i m p r o v e anisotropy, increase selectivity, or p r o d u c e
Plasma Etching of lll-V Nitrides 263 smoother etch morphologies by adjusting the chemical:physical ratio of the etch mechanism. For example; 02, H 2, or N 2 have been added to halogenbased plasmas to modify the concentration of reactive species in the plasma or initiate the formation of sidewall polymers to enhance anisotropy. Additionally, inert gases such as Ar or He are often used to stabilize or dilute the plasma. Fluorine-containing gases are often added to improve etch selectivity of GaAs films over A1GaAs films due to the formation of non-volatile A1F3 etch products. The use of gas mixtures to etch the UI-V nitrides in high-density plasma reactors has had varying success and is summarized below.
3.2
Hydrogen
The addition ofH 2 to chlorine-based plasmas typically results in slower etch rates for GaAs and GaP since H 2 acts as a scavenger of reactive C1 and forms HC1. In Fig. 6, GaN etch rates are plotted as a function of %H 2 concentration for ECR- and ICP-generated C12/H2/Ar plasmas. ECR etch conditions were: 1 mtorr, 850 W ECR source power, 150 W rf-cathodepower with a corresponding de-bias of-190 + 20 V, 25 sccm C12/H2, and 5 sccm Ar. ICP etch conditions were: 2 mtorr, 500 W ICP source power, 95115 W rf-cathode-power with a constant dc-bias of-250 + 10 V, 25 sccm C12/H2, and 5 sccm Ar. Samples etched in the ECR were grown by metalorganic molecular beam epitaxy (MO-MBE), whereas samples etched in the ICP were grown by metal-organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD). GaN etch rates in the ECR and ICP increased slightly as H 2 was initially added to the C12/Ar plasma (10% H2). Using quadrupole mass spectrometry (QMS) in the ECR discharge, the C1 concentration (indicated by m / e = 35 peak intensity) remained relatively constant at 10% H 2. As the H 2 concentration was increased further, the C1 concentration decreased and the HC1 concentration increased as the GaN etch rates decreased in both plasmas, presumably due to the consumption of reactive C1 by hydrogen. GaN etch profiles showed a strong dependence on the %H 2 in the C12/H2/Ar ECR plasma (Figs. 7a-c). The etched surface was quite rough (Fig. 7a) in the C12/Ar plasma, possibly due to preferential removal of the GaC13 etch products or micromasking of the surface. The foot observed at the edge of the etched feature may be attributed to mask-edge erosion due to the aggressive attack ofphotoresist by reactive C1. As the H 2 concentration was increased to 20%, the etch became smooth and very anisotropic (Fig. 7b). At 60% H 2, the etch remained smooth and anisotropic with a slight foot at the base of the feature (Fig. 7c). For GaN samples etched in
264
Wide Bandgap Semiconducwrs
the C12/H2/ArICP-generated plasma (Figs. 7d-0, the features were anisotropic and smooth, independent of%H 2.
5000
4OOO
ICP
3000
2000
ECR
I000
0
t
i 0
i 20
i 40
! 60
~
i 80
i 100
% H 2 Concentration in CI2/H 2 Plasma
Figure 6. GaN etch rates as a function of%H 2 for ECR- and ICP-generated CI2/H2/Arplasmas.
I
ttt~/
ECR
(a)
(b)
(c)
|CP
(d)
(e)
(f)
Figure 7. SEM micrographs of GaN samples etched in either an ECR or ICP CI2/H2/Arplasma (a, d) 0 % HE, (b, e) 2 0 % HE, and (c, f) 6 0 % H E. T h e photoresist m a s k has b e e n r e m o v e d .
at
Plasma Etching of lll-VNitrides 265 In Fig. 8, BCI 3 was substituted for C12 and was used to etch GaN in both the ECR and ICP reactors. The increase in etch rate observed at 10% H 2 concentration in the ECR-generated BC13 plasma correlated with an increase in the reactive C1 concentration as observed by QMS. As the H 2 concentration was increased further, the C1 concentration decreased, the HC1 concentration increased, and the GaN etch rates decreased due to the consumption of reactive C1 by hydrogen. In the ICP reactor, GaN etch rates were quite slow and decreased as H 2 was added to the plasma, up to 80% where a slight increase was observed. The GaN etch rates were consistently faster in the C12-based plasmas as compared to BC13, due to the generation of higher concentrations of reactive C1.
2000
.=. E -2
i
i
i
1500 ECR 1000
Z
ICP
500
0 !
I
I
I
I
I
I
0
20
40
60
80
100
% H 2 Concentration in BCI3/H 2 P l a s m a
Figure 8. GaN
3.3
etch rates as a function o f % H 2 for ECR- and ICP-generated BCI3/H2/Ar plasmas.
Sulfur Hexafluoride
In Figs. 9 and 10, GaN etch rates are shown for ECR- and ICPgenerated C12/SF6/Ar and BC13/SF6/Ar plasmas as a function of %SF 6. ECR plasma conditions were: 1 mtorr, 850 W ECR source power, 150 W rf-cathode-power with a corresponding dc-bias o f - 190 + 20 V, 25 sccm C12/SF 6 or BC13/SF 6, and 5 seem Ar. ICP plasma conditions were: 2 mtorr, 500 W ICP source power, 95-115 W rf-cathode-power with a constant debias of-250 • 10 V, 25 seem C12/SF 6 or BC13/SF 6, and 5 seem Ar. (The pressure was increased to-~3 mtorr in the ICP reactor at > 60% SF6). With
266
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
the substitution of SF 6 for H 2 in the C12-based plasma, the GaN etch rates were typically slower, by a factor of 2. In general, as the concentration of SF 6 was increased, the etch rates decreased independent of etch technique. As the %SF 6 was increased from 0 to 20 in the ECR, the C1 concentration (m/e = 35) decreased but remained significant; faster GaN etching at 20% SF 6 might be expected, based on the C1 concentration alone. However, formation of SC1 (m/e = 67) was observed at 20% SF6 which may be responsible for the reduced GaN etch rate due to consumption of the reactive C1 by S. At 30 and 40% SF6, the C1 concentration was greatly reduced and slow GaN etch rates resulted.
5000
,, I
I
I
,
,
I ~
~ECR 4000
ICP
....,
E 3000
2000 t.t.l t,.3
I000
-
,_, I
0
. /
.
20
I
I
40
60
0
% S F 6 C o n c e n t r a t i o n in CI2/SF6Plasm,'~
Figure 9. GaN etch rates as a function of %SF 6 for ECR- and ICP-generated CI2/SFe/Ar plasmas.
In Fig. 10, the opposite trend was observed for BC13, where the GaN etch rates were typically greater when SF 6 was substituted for H 2 in both the ECR and ICP. The GaN etch rate increased up to 20% SF 6 in the ICP and 30% SF 6 in the ECR, and then decreased sharply. In the ECR, the C1 concentration (m/e = 35) increased as the SF 6 increased to 30% and then decreased at 40%. This implies that at low SF 6 concentrations, the SF 6 enhanced the dissociation of BC13 resulting in higher concentrations of reactive C1 and faster etch rates. However, above --30% SF6, the sulfur appeared to consume reactive chlorine as the SC1 concentration increased and the etch rate decreased.
Plasma Etching of lll- V Nitrides 267
5000
,
l
i
"'C
i ~
4000 E
-2
,,...,
3000
2000
t.rd
1000
0
1
1
1
I
0
20
40
6()
_
i
~0
% SF Concentration ill BCIJSF Plasnia 6
Figure 10. GaN etch rates as a function o f % S F 6 for ECR- and ICP-generated BC13/SF6/Ar plasmas.
3.4
Nitrogen
GaN etch rates were also obtained for C12/N2/Ar and BC13/N2/Ar plasmas under the following ECR and ICP conditions: 2 mtorr, 850 W ECR source power or 500 W ICP source power, 110 to 170 W rf-cathode-power with a constant de-bias of-200 + 10 V, 25 seem C12/N2 or BC13/N2, and 5 seem Ar. Figure 11 shows GaN etch rates as a function of %N 2 concentration in both ECR and ICP C12 plasmas. As the %N 2 increased in the C12 plasma, the GaN etch rates decreased due to less available reactive C1. However, as shown in Fig. 12, GaN etch rates increased significantly as N 2 was added to the ECR- and ICP-generated BC13 plasma. Etch rates increased up to 40% N 2 and then decreased at higher N 2 concentrations. This trend was similar to that observed in ECR and ICP etching of GaAs, GaP, and !n-containing materials.[ 91]-[93]Ren et al. observed peak etch rates for In-containing materials in an ECR plasma at 75% BC13- 25% N 2. As N 2 was added to the BC13 plasma, Ren observed maximum emission intensity for atomic and molecular C1 at 75% BC13 using optical emission spectroscopy (OES). Correspondingly, the BC13 intensity decreased and a BN emission line appeared. It was suggested that at 75% BC13, N 2 enhanced the dissociation of BC13 resulting in higher concentrations of reactive C1 and C1 ions and higher etch rates. This may explain faster GaN etch rates observed as N 2 was added to the BC13/Ar plasmas. In this study, however,
268
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
higher concentrations of reactive C1 and BN emission were not observed using OES in the ICP.
7000
I
I
I
I
I
-~
6ooo
ECR [
" - ~ ICP I "~
5000 4OOO
.~
3O00
2ooo r~ 1000 I
I
I
I
I
0
20
40
60
80
I
100
% N 2 Concentration in Cl2/N2Plasma Figure 11. GaN etch rates as a function of %N 2 for ECR- and ICP-generated CI2/N2/Ar plasmas.
4000
I~.~ i
ECR
3500
ICP
3000 *~
2500 2000 1500
z
r~
lO~ 500 "
I
I
I
I
I
I
0
20
40
60
80
100
-
% N 2 Concentration in BCl3/N2Plasma Figure 12. GaN etch rates as a function of %N 2 for ECR- and ICP-generated BC13/N2/Ar plasmas.
Plasma Etching of lll-VNitrides 3.5
269
Argon
Small amounts of Ar are often added to halogen-based plasmas to stabilize the plasma or to improve the sputter desorption efficiency of etch products from the substrate surface (thus increasing etch rate and anisotropy). [93]-[95] GaN etch rates are shown in Figs. 13 and 14 as a function of %Ar in ICP- and ECR-generated C12 and BC13 plasmas. The plasma etch conditions were: 2 mtorr chamber pressure, 30 sccm total flow rate,-~-250 V dc-bias, 25~ substrate temperature, and 500 W ICP source power or 850 W ECR source power. As Ar was added to either ICP or ECR C12 discharges, GaN etch rates decreased due to less available reactive C1 in the plasma. When BC13 was substituted for C12, etch rates were as much as 6 times slower than those obtained in the C12/Ar plasma due to lower concentrations of reactive C1 (see Fig. 14).
7000
i
t
I
!
t'
I -El- ~c~ I 6000 "~
5000 4000
t~ .m
3000
m Z
2000 IOO0
-
I
I
I
I
I
0
20
40
60
80
t
=
100
% Ar Concentration in Cl2/ArPlasma Figure 13. GaN etch rates as a function of%Ar for ECR-and ICP-generatedCI2/Arplasmas.
Based on the preceding observations, GaN etch rates as a function of plasma chemistry can be summarized as follows: (a) comparable in ECR and ICP reactors; (b) faster in C12-based plasmas as compared to BC13based plasmas; (c) sensitive to the gas mixtures and gas ratios; and (d) highly dependent upon the concentration of reactive C1 in the plasma.
270
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors 2000
I
I
I
I
L~
15oo
/
ICP
E ~
1000
Z
500
I
r~
I
0
I
I
I
I
20
40
60
80
II 100
% Ar Concentration in BCI3/Ar Plasma
Figure 14. GaN etch rates as a functionof%Ar for ECR-and ICP-generatedBCI3/Arplasmas.
3.6
Additional Halogens
Additional halogen-containing plasmas have been used to etch GaN including IC1/Ar and IBr/Ar. In Fig. 15, GaN etch rates are shown as a function of if-cathode-power in ECR-generated IC1 and IBr plasmas. Etch conditions were: 1.5 mtorr pressure, 1000 W ECR source power, 4 seem IC1 or IBr, and 4 seem Ar. The GaN etch rates increased with increasing if-cathodepower at similar rates up to 150 W. However, at 250 W if-cathode-power, the GaN etch rate in ICI/Ar increased to > 1.3 ~tm/min whereas the IBr etch rate decreased slightly. This is the fastest etch rate reported to date for GaN. Near-surface AES showed no loss of N in the Ga:N ratio at low rfcathode-powers. The high volatility of the GaI 3 etch products may have increased the chemical etch mechanism of the Ga and thereby minimized preferential loss of the lighter N atoms and maintained the stoichiometry of the as-grown film. [58][96][97]
3.7
Hydrocarbons
Pearton and coworkers were the first to etch GaN, A1N, and InN in ECR-generated CH4/H2/Ar plasmas.[ 55] Etch rates were < 400 A/min at 1 mtorr pressure, 1000 W ECR source power, and ~ -250 V de-bias. As stated earlier, CH4/H 2 plasmas have been used to etch compound semiconductor materials at etch rates much slower than those obtained for C1based plasmas. In Fig. 16, GaN etch rates are plotted as a function of rf-
Plasma Etching of l l l - V Nitrides 271 cathode-power for C12/Ar and CH4[H2/Ar ECR- and RIE-generated plasmas. These experiments were performed in the same chamber with either 1000 or 0 W of applied ECR source power. The pressure was held constant at 1.5 mtorr and the plasma chemistry was 5 seem C12 and 10 sccm Ar or 5 seem CH4, 15 seem H 2, and 10 sccm Ar. GaN etch rates were significantly faster in C12/Ar, independent of etch technique, possibly due to more efficient formation and sputter desorption of the GaC13 etch products as compared to Ga(CH3) 3. Redeposition or polymer formation on the etched surfaces may also be initiated by CHa/H 2 plasmas, thereby reducing the etch rates. Faster GaN etch rates in the high-density ECR were attributed to higher plasma densities, which enhanced the GaN bond breaking and sputter desorption of the etch products.
14,ooo 12,ooo
I
I
i
I
I
--~ -~cll
10,000 ~
8000
-~
6000
z
4ooo
r~
2000
0
I
I
I
I
I
50
100
150
200
250
300
if-cathode-power (W) Figure 15. GaN etch rate as a function of if-cathode-power for ECR-generated ICI/Ar and IBr/Ar plasmas.
In Fig. 17, InN etch rates are plotted as a function of if-cathodepower for C12/Ar and CH4/H2/Ar ECR- and RIE-generated plasmas. These experiments were performed under the same conditions discussed above. InN etch rates obtained in the ECR were fast (independent of plasma chemistry) and increased with if-cathode-power, due to more efficient bond breaking and/or sputter desorption of the etch products at high de-bias. In RIE, the etch rates were quite low and comparably independent of plasma
272
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
chemistry. GaN etched much faster than InN in the RIE-generated C12/Ar plasma due to lower volatility oflnC13 as compared to GaC13.
7000 - - ~ - RIE Clz/Ar ECR CI21Ar ""A" "RIECH4/H2/Ar - ~ ECR CH4/I-12/Ar
6000 o,,.~
E
5000
i
4000 .=
;~
3000
S
..Q
.(3 s
2ooo
.
..~
..... ,., O..., .,, ........~jC. .....
1000 .z~ -<
0
A
~
.
-
-
.-A ......
4
....
-& . . . . . .
i
i
I
!
1~
2~
3~
400
A
5~
if-cathode-power (W) Figure 16. GaN etch rates as a function of rf-cathode-power for ECR- and RIE-generated Cl2/Ar and CH4/H2/Ar plasmas.
I
8000 .,.q
6000 .m
Z
m
I
I
_ ~ R I E Clz/Ar ECR Cl2/Ar " "&- - RIE CH4/H2/Ar ECR CH4/Hz/Ar
4000
.... 4 , 2o00
-0- ....., 0
100
.-..-..-~-.--,, .--Jr. . . ., 200
300
400
O 500
if-cathode-power (W) Figure 17. InN etch rates as a function of rf-cathode-power for ECR- and RIE-generated C12/Ar and CH4/HE/Ar plasmas.
Plasma Etching of l l l - V Nitrides 273 4.0
PRESSURE
Plasma conditions change quite dramatically as a function of pressure; in particular the mean free path decreases and the eollisional frequency increases as the pressure is increased. This results in changes in both ion energy and plasma density which strongly influence etch properties. Etching GaN in a Cl2-based plasma ordinarily results in faster etch rates as pressure is increased, suggesting a reactant limited regime at lower pressures. However, as pressure is increased further, etch rates often decrease due to higher ion energies, lower plasma densities, redeposition, or polymer formation on the substrate surface. Additionally, at higher pressures, the etch frequently becomes more isotropie and rougher due to lateral etching of the sidewall. In Fig. 18, GaN etch rates are shown as a function of pressure for ECR and ICP plasmas. ECR plasma conditions were: 10 seem C12, 15 seem H2, 3 seem CH4, 10 seem Ar, 850 W ECR source power, and 170~ electrode temperature. ICP plasma conditions were: 22.5 seem C12, 2.5 seem H2, 5 seem Ar, 500 W ICP source power, and 25~ electrode temperature. During these runs, the rf-eathode-power was held constant at 150 W, which resulted in an increase in de-bias (-190 to -450 V for the ECR and -180 to -375 V for the ICP) as the pressure was increased (1 to 10 mtorr). Higher de-biases at higher pressures were attributed to increased eollisional recombination which decreased the plasma density at higher pressures. Despite the differences in plasma conditions, the etch rate trends were similar. Etch rates increased for GaN as the pressure was increased from 1-2 mtorr for the ECR and from 1-5 mtorr for the ICP suggesting a reactant limited regime at low pressure. As the pressure was increased (> 2 mtorr for ECR and > 5 mtorr for ICP), GaN etch rates decreased due either to higher ion energies, lower plasma densities, redeposition, or polymer formation on the substrate surface.
5.0
I O N E N E R G Y AND P L A S M A D E N S I T Y
Etch characteristics show a strong dependence on ion energy and plasma density. Ion energies influence the physical component of the etch, whereas plasma density can effect both the physical and chemical components. In general, etch rates increase as the ion energy increases due to improved sputter desorption of etch products from the surface as well as
274
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
more efficient breaking of the group-III-N bonds. Anisotropy also typically improves due to the perpendicular ion energy which maintains straight wall profiles. Etch rates may decrease under high dc-bias conditions due to sputter desorption of reactive species from the surface before reaction occurs indicating an adsorption limited etch regime. As a function of increasing plasma density or source power, etch rates typically increase due to: (1) higher concentrations of reactive species which increase the chemical component of the etch mechanism, and/or (2) higher ion flux which increases the sputter desorption component of the etch mechanism. However, trends have been observed where etch rates stabilize or decrease at high plasma densities due either to saturation of reactive species at the surface or creation of an adsorption limited regime. The effects of ion energies and plasma densities are more obvious for high-density plasma systems, since ion energies and plasma densities can be more effectively decoupled as compared to RIE.
8000 7000
E
6000
o
~
4000
~
3000
~ r~
2~
_]+
ICP
i'
1000 0
0
I
I
I
I
I
2
4
6
8
10
Pressure (mTorr) F i g u r e 18. GaN etch rates as a function o f pressure in an ICP-generated C12/H2/Ar plasma at 25~ and in an ECR- generated C12/HE/CH4/Ar plasma at 170~
The III-V nitrides typically etch at much slower rates than more conventional compound semiconductors films, including GaAs and InP. As stated earlier, due to the high volatility of etch products formed in Cl-based plasmas and the strong bond energies of the III-V nitrides, the GaN bond breaking may be the rate limiting step of the etch.[ 9~ These tendencies may
Plasma Etching of l l l - V Nitrides 2 75 be observed in Fig. 19 where GaN etch rates are plotted as a function ofrfcathode-power for ECR, ICP, and RIE discharges. Plasma etch conditions were: 1 mtorr pressure, 10 seem C12, 15 seem H 2, 3 sccm CH4, 10 seem Ar, 1000 W ECR source power, and 500 W ICP source power. For ECR and ICP, the rf-cathode-power ranged from 1-450 W with corresponding dc-biases o f - 1 0 to -400 + 25 V. RIE rf-powers ranged from 50-450 W with corresponding de-biases of-270 to -950 + 50 V. Independent of etch technique, the GaN etch rate increased as the rf-cathode-power or ion energy increased, due to more efficient bond breaking of the GaN and/or more efficient sputter desorption of the etch products. GaN rates were-- 5 to 10 times faster in the high-density ECR and ICP etch systems as compared to R/E, due to a two step process directly related to the plasma flux. Initially, the high-density plasmas increase the bond breaking mechanism allowing the etch products to form and then produce efficient sputter desorption of the etch products. The etched surface morphology or rootmean-square (rms) surface roughness was evaluated and quantified using atomic force microscopy (AFM) as a function of plasma etch technique. It remained relatively constant and smooth (< ---3 nm), independent of ion energy and etch platform.
7000
I
I
--~
I
- ECR
6OOO .N
E
5ooo
.
- -A,- - ICP
/
v
4OOO
-~
3OOO
Zea
2OOO
J
.§
/
o 9 f
o~ .f
1000 0 I
I
I
I
0
1~
2~
3~
I
4~
5~
if-cathode-power (W) Figure 19. GaN etch rates as a function of rf-cathode-power as etched in ECR-, ICP-, and RIE-generated CI2/H2/CH4/Arplasmas.
276
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
In Fig. 20, GaN etch rates and rms roughness are shown as a function of ICP-source power. During these runs, the if-cathode-power was held constant at 150 W, resulting in a decrease in de-bias (-285 to - 130 V) as the ICP source power was increased (250 to 1000 W). Lower debiases were attributed to increased plasma density and lower mean free path at higher ICP source powers. GaN etch rates increased as the ICP source power was increased from 250-500 W, due to higher concentrations of reactive species in the plasma or higher plasma flux which resulted in more efficient bond breaking and sputter desorption of the etch products. As the ICP source power was increased further, the GaN etch rates decreased, due either to lower ion energies or sputter desorption of the reactants at the surface prior to reaction. The rms roughness increased to greater than 65 nm at 750 W ICP source power (---150 V dc-bias), possibly due to preferential sputtering of N at higher plasma densities.
7000
I
I
I
I
70
I
m / 6000
60
/ /
E
5000
~
4000
-~
3000
so
I -
2ooo
40
30 ~ 0
m
z
~"
-
20 ~
/
r~
I
rrns
10
I
1000 I
I
I
I
I
200
400
600
800
1000
ICP Power (W) Figure 20. GaN etch rates and rms-roughness as a function o f l C P source power in an ICPgenerated CI2/H2/Ar plasma.
6.0
TEMPERATURE DEPENDENCE
As stated earlier, etch rates and profiles can be influenced by the volatility or desorption rate of etch products. Using a variety of clamping techniques along with backside heating or cooling procedures, the
Plasma Etching of llI-VNitrides 277 temperature at which the sample is maintained during the etch can be controlled. The substrate temperature can effect the desorption rate of etch products, the gas-surface reaction kinetics, and the surface mobility of reactants which earl influence etch results. Several reports are available which present temperature dependent etching of GaAs and InP. [80]-[82][9811991 GaAs etch rates generally increase at substrate temperatures above -~150~ due to one of the mechanisms stated above; high temperature etching of Incontaining species has been quite successful using C12-based chemistries, due to the higher volatilities of In-chlorides at temperatures above--130~ Etch rates for GaN and A1N are shown in Fig. 21 as a function of temperature. The GaN samples were etched in C12/I-I2/CH4/Arand C12/H2/ Ar plasmas while the A1N samples were etched only in C12/HJCH4/Ar plasmas. The etch rates for A1N showed a monotonic decrease of a factor of--2 as the temperature was increased from 30-170~ The GaN etch rate in the CI2/Hz/CH4/Ar plasma was relatively constant up to ~125~ and then increased slightly as the temperature was increased to 170~ When CH 4 was removed from the plasma chemistry, the rates decreased by---2040% and showed a monotonic increase as a function of temperature. Faster GaN etch rates at 170~ may be attributed to either higher volatility and desorption rates of etch products, or changes in the gas-surface reaction kinetics. In Fig. 22, the InN etch rates are shown as a function of temperature for the same plasma chemistries. The InN etch rate decreased by > 60% as the temperature was increased to 150~ for CI2]Hz/CH4/Ar plasma chemistry, however, the etch rate increased rapidly above 150~ A similar trend was observed in the CI2/H2/Ar plasma chemistry, with etch rates 20-50% slower than those obtained with CH 4 in the plasma chemistry. Faster GaN and InN etch rates observed with CH 4 present in the plasma chemistry, may be attributed to the formation of the group III-methyl etch product. The initial InN etch rate decrease observed in the C12]I-I2/CH4/Ar plasma chemistry may be due to competitive reactions to form either InC13 or (CH3)3In. As the temperature was increased above 150~ either the volatility or desorption rate of one of the etch products increased or the reaction kinetics became dominated by one of the surface reaction mechanisms. Figure 23 shows characteristic Auger spectra for GaN samples before and after ECR etching at 30 and 170~ in a C12/H2/CH4/Ar plasma. Prior to exposure of the GaN to the plasma, the Auger spectrum showed normal amounts of carbon and native oxide on the GaN surface. Following exposure to the plasma, within experimental error, there was no change in the stoichiometry of the GaN surface, with some residual atomic C1 present. Similar results were observed for the InN and AIN samples.
278
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
2500
i
i
GaN with CH4
2000
-~N--~ rrl,
1500 GaN without CH 4 1000
-
-|
......... |
AIN with CH 4 500
-.|
-
0 0
I
I
I
50
100
150
200
Temperature (~ Figure 21. Etch rates of GaN and AIN as a function of temperature for ECR-generated C12/ H2/CH4/Ar or CI2/HE/Ar plasmas.
2500
i
i
i
InN
?
2000
-2 1500
t~ 9 ut _CH 4
1000
500 0
I
I
I
50
100
150
Temperature
200
(~
Figure 22. Etch rates of InN as a function of temperature for ECR-generated CI2/H2/CH4/ Ar or C12/HE/Ar plasmas.
Plasma Etching of llI-VNitrides 279
GaN
I
N
O
I
.... GaI
C
(b) 30~ Etch
I
i
Ud
1
Ga
c (c) 170~ Etch
J
CI
I C
I 200
N
I Ga
I
I
400
600
I 800
I 1000
I 1200
Electron Energy (eV) Figure 23. AES surface scans ofGaN (a) before exposure to the plasma, (b) at 30~ at 170~ in an ECR-generated CI2/H2/CHa/Ar plasma.
7.0
GROWTH
and (c)
TECHNIQUE
Since several GaN samples discussed in this chapter were grown by different techniques, it is important to identify any etch dependence on growth technique. In Fig. 24, GaN ECR etch rates are shown as a function of rf-cathode-power for samples grown by MO-MBE, rf-MBE, and MOCVD. The ECR plasma conditions were: 2 mtorr pressure, 22.5 sccm C12, 2.5 sccm H2, 5 sccm Ar, 30~ electrode temperature, 1000 W microwave power, and rf-cathode-powers ranging from 1-450 W with corresponding dc-biases of-25 to -275 + 25 V. GaN samples were etched simultaneously. As the rf-cathode-power and ion energies increased, the
280
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
GaN etch rates increased (due to more efficient bond breaking of the GaN and/or more efficient sputter desorption of the etch products), independent of growth technique. Etch rates approaching 9000 A/min were obtained for the MO-MBE and rf-MBE GaN samples at 450 W rf-cathode-power (--275 V de-bias). A trend where the MO-MBE GaN etched faster than the rf-MBE GaN (which was faster than the MOCVD GaN) was observed. Faster etch rates correlated with higher rms-roughness for the as-grown GaN samples. The rms-roughness for the as-grown GaN samples were: 19.38 + 0.44 nm for MO-MBE, 3.12 + 0.84 nm for rf-MBE, and 1.76 + 0.29 nm for MOCVD.
10,ooo -~
--
I
I
I
I'
""
I
8000
o,,.
E ~"
6000 oO
J
e-_
2
4(~o
z
~
2000
0
IO0
200
300
400
500
rf-cathode-power (W) F i g u r e 24. GaN etch rates as a function o f if-cathode-power for M O - M B E , M O C V D , and If-MBE grown GaN in a CI2/H2/Ar ECR-generated plasma.
8.0
E T C H P R O F I L E , M O R P H O L O G Y , AND STOICHIOMETRY
Three of the more critical parameters used to evaluate the value of an etch process are etch profile, surface morphology, and the chemical composition of the etched surface. Maintaining surface stoichiometry and smoothness are critical for subsequent process steps including the formation of metal contacts, deposition ofinterlevel dielectric films, passivation, or regrowth. Maintaining etch profile is essential for dimensional control and reliability of metal step coverage.
Plasma Etching of l l l - V Nitrides 281 Figure 25 shows SEM micrographs of GaN and InN samples etched in an ECR-generated C12/H2/CHa/Ar, at 850 W of ECR source power, 1 mtorr, 170~ and 150 W rf-cathode-power. The GaN etch was approximately 5800 A deep and was anisotropic with reasonably smooth sidewalls and surfaces. The high anisotropy of the etch may be attributed to the possible formation of a sidewall polymer involving the methane, as previously reported by Constantine et al. with this plasma chemistry.[ 8~ A trench was observed at the base of the GaN feature which may have occurred due to the Si3N4 mask-edge erosion. The InN etch was somewhat rough with a sloped sidewall, also due to erosion of the mask-edge. The InN was etched approximately 1.12 lam deep, which was approximately 1000 A into the GaAs substrate. The surface roughness may have been due to etching GaAs under high temperature C12 plasma conditions or to preferential etching of the InN.
GaN I LIIII
....
InN LIIIi
(a)
(b)
Figure 25. SEM micrographsof (a) GaN and (b) InN etchedat 150 W rf-cathode-powerin an ECR-generatedC12/H2/CH4/Arplasma. Highly anisotropic, smooth GaN etching has been achieved in a C12/ H2/Ar ICP-generated plasma as shown in Fig. 26. The GaN, which was grown by MOCVD, was overetched by approximately 15%. The plasma conditions were: 5 mtorr pressure, 500 W ICP source power, 22.5 seem C12, 2.5 seem H 2, 5 seem Ar, 25~ electrode temperature, and 150 W
282
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
if-cathode-power with a corresponding dc-bias of-280 • 10 V. Under these conditions, the GaN etch rate was -~6880 A/min with highly anisotropic, smooth sidewalls. The vertical striations observed in the sidewall were due to striations in the photoresist mask which were transferred into the GaN feature during the etch. The sapphire substrate was exposed during the overetch period and showed significant pitting possibly due to defects in the substrate or growth process. With optimization of the masking process, these etch parameters may yield profiles and sidewall smoothness which improve etched facet laser performance.
Figure 26. SEM mierograph ofMOCVD GaN etched in an ICP-generated CI2/H2/Arplasma.
As discussed earlier, surface roughness can be quantified using AFM. The rms roughness and AFM images for GaN and InN etched in an ECR-generated C12/H2/CH4/Ar plasma are shown in Figs. 27 and 28, respectively, as a function of if-cathode-power. The GaN rms roughness remained relatively constant as the if-cathode-power was increased from 0-150 W; however, as the if-cathode-power was increased further to 275 W, the rms roughness increased to ~85 nm. The data suggest that at high if-cathode-power preferential sputtering or micro-masking occurred which roughened the surface. The rms roughness for InN was greatest at 65 W if-cathode-power. This implies that the ion-bombardment energy was critical to balance the chemical and sputtering effect of this plasma chemistry in order to maintain smooth surfaces and reasonable etch rates. In general, III-V nitride rms-roughness was smooth over a wide range of etch parameters, but appeared to be very sensitive to high-density plasma conditions and high ion energies.
Plasma Etching of lll-V Nitrides 283
100
I
I
I
| I I I
80 E
~ ~:~
60
I
InN/~
///
40
0
1,-,
~
2o
!
!
i
0
100
200
300
if-cathode-power (W) Figure 27. RMS roughness for GaN and InN as a function of rf-cathode-power in an ECRgenerated CI2/H2/CH4/Ar plasma.
In many cases, preferential etching of the substrate can cause significant variations in the stoichiometry of the material (which in tum can effect device performance or post-etch process steps). Plasma species may also be adsorbed or implanted into the substrate, which can also reduce device performance. In Fig. 29, Auger spectra were taken to evaluate the near-surface stoichiometry of GaN samples (a) before and after ECR etching at 850 W applied microwave power and rf-cathodepowers of (b) 65 W, and (c) 275 W. Prior to exposure of the GaN to the plasma, the Auger spectrum showed a Ga:N ratio of 1.5 with normal amounts of adventitious carbon and native oxide on the GaN surface. Following exposure to the plasma, a general tendency for the Ga:N ratio to increase with rf-cathode-power was observed. The Ga:N ratio increased from 1.8 to 2.3 as the rf-cathode-power was increased from 65-275 W at a microwave power of 850 W. Additionally, the Ga:N ratio also increased as a function of ECR microwave power. Within experimental error, these trends imply that the GaN film was being depleted of N, perhaps due to preferential etching or sputtering of the lighter N-atoms due to higher ionbombardment energy and higher ion density. Auger spectra were also taken to determine the near-surface stoichiometry of GaN as a function of plasma chemistry following exposure to ECR-generated C12/H2/Ar, C12/
284
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
SF6/Ar , BC13/H2/Ar , and BC13/SF6/Ar plasmas. In general, the Ga:N ratio increased as the %H 2 or %SF 6 concentration increased in either BC13 or C12. These trends imply that the GaN films were depleted of N perhaps due to preferential chemical etching of the N atoms with the addition ofH 2 or SF 6 to the plasma.
GaN
InN
a)
As-grown
3.2u,,, gm
lain
~.3Ilnl
b) rf=65
9.5r,,,,
W
lain
Jam
-~ t m'rl
c)
rf = 2 7 5 W
85nm
~m
.m
39nm
Figure 28. AFM micrographs for (a) GaN and InN as-grown, (b) GaN and InN etched at a if-cathode-power of 65W, and (c) GaN and InN etched at a if-cathode-power of 275 W in an ECR-generated C12/H2/CH4/Ar plasma. The Z-scale is 100 nm/division.
9.0
PLASMA INDUCED DAMAGE
As stated in earlier sections, the fabrication of high-density integrated circuits and optoeleetronie devices often requires pattern transfer with
Plasma Etching of lll- V Nitrides 285 highly anisotropic profiles and smooth surface and sidewall morphologies. These requirements are often achieved using plasma etch techniques where energetic ions are accelerated from the plasma to the wafer. However, when these energetic ions strike the sample, surface damage as deep as 1000 A can occur (100), causing degradation of electrical and optical properties of the device. Plasma-induced-damage can include defects or dislocations in the lattice, formation of dangling bonds on the surface, implanted etch ions, or deposition of material on the sample. Attempts to minimize the damage by reducing the ion energy below the damage threshold for compound semiconductors (< 40 eV) [49] or by increasing the chemical component of the etch often results in more isotropic profiles, significantly limits minimum dimensions, and reduces the etch rate.
As-grown
100 :
(a)
--
.
,
~.0
100
Si
65 W if-cathode-power
~
.
-
200 I
(b)
O v
C,:N-1.8__,!.]j
.
.
.
.
.
0
Si
O
IGa m
w
I-
-
200 275 W 200
-
if-cathode-power -
I-- . . . . .
-
-
I
__'
o
(c)
Ga:N =2.3
I|
o .,',4
t
Si
il
O II 500
I
"'' ,
I
Ga
I--I
1000
Kinetic Energy (eV) Figure 29. AES surface scans ofGaN (a) before exposure to the plasma, (b) at 65 W, and (c) 275 W rf-cathode-power, 1 mtorr, 170~ and 850 W microwave power in an ECRgenerated CI2/H2/CH4/Ar plasma.
286
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Since GaN is more chemically inert than GaAs and has higher bonding energies, higher ion energies may be used during the etch process with potentially less damage to the material. However, reports of plasmainduced-damage of the III-V nitrides have been limited. Pearton and coworkers have reported plasma-induced-damage results for InN, InGaN, and InA1N in an ECR-generated plasma (the damage increased as a function of ion flux and ion energy).[l~ In the following section, ICP and ECR plasma-induced-damage of GaN is evaluated using photoluminescence (PL) measurements as a function of rf-cathode-power and source power. Pure Ar plasmas were used to simulate the ion bombardment conditions created during plasma etching of the III-V nitrides. It is important to realize that the use of a pure Ar plasma creates a worse case scenario for plasma-induced-damage due to the lack of chemical interactions. With the introduction of reactive gases to the plasma for a given plasma power and density, the damage will be reduced when compared to a sputter mechanism, since damaged material is typically being removed at a higher rate, leaving a shallower damage depth. Prior to the plasma exposure, a 2 inch GaN wafer (grown by MOCVD) was mapped out to examine the uniformity of the PL emission. In Fig. 30, the PL spectrum at the center of the wafer taken with the low resolution grating is shown. The spectrum consisted of two distinct features. The dominant near band-edge resonance was seen at 3.472 eV. Emission resonances in this spectral region have been identified with recombination of a neutral-donor-bound exciton.[l~ 1~ The free exciton resonance, expected at an energy of~3.485 eV (102), was not clearly resolved. The broad spectral feature centered at approximately 2.21 eV was associated with emission from deep level impurities. In Fig. 31, the peak intensity of the near band-edge emission is plotted as a function of radial position on the two inch GaN wafer. The intensity dropped by --15% at a radial position of 0.5 inches and ---30% at a radial position of 0.8 inches. Toward the edge of the wafer, the intensity drop was significantly more rapid. The samples that were used in the etch studies were taken from the center of the wafer. The PL spectra were taken before and after etching for each sample. In Fig. 32, the % change in the peak PL intensity versus rf-cathodepower is plotted for both ECR and ICP etching. GaN samples were exposed to ICP- and ECR-generated Ar plasmas for 1 minute under identical plasma conditions while the rf-cathode-power was increased. The de-bias was --10 to 65% higher in the ECR under comparable conditions. For the ICP case, at relatively low rf-cathode-powers (1 and 50 W), the PL intensity slightly degraded, and as the rf-cathode-power was increased up to 250 W, increasing degradation in PL intensity was seen. Depth profiling
Plasma Etching of l l l - V Nitrides 28 7 of similar films at a rf-cathode-power of 1 W (-~ - 10 V de-bias) revealed no detectable removal of GaN; whereas, at 250 W etch (-300 V de-bias)-~770 A of GaN was lost during a 1 minute exposure. Distinctly different results were obtained for etching in the ECR plasma system. Etching with very low rf-cathode-power (1 W) resulted in > 80% increase in the PL intensity and virtually no sputter loss of GaN. Etching at higher rf-cathode-powers also improved the PL intensity, but to a lesser degree as the rf-cathodepower was increased. The highest rf-cathode-power (150 W) etch resulted in a very slight decrease in PL intensity and a GaN sputter rate of--820 A/min.
9
!
,
0
,
,
!
,
,
9
,
,
..,d
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
Energy (eV) Figure 30. PL spectrum from the GaN film at T=10 K. The effect of plasma density on the peak near band-edge PL intensity was also studied. GaN samples were exposed to ICP- and ECRgenerated Ar plasmas for 1 minute while the de-bias was held at -~ -65 V. The data were more scattered than the rf-cathode-power data for both ICP and ECR conditions. The ICP showed virtually no change in PL intensity at 250 W source power and then decreased by 30% as the ICP source power was increased to 750 W. The PL intensity decreased by only 10% at 1000 W ICP source power, which was an improvement of almost 20% over 750 W. In the ECR, an increase of--115% in PL intensity at 250 W ECR source power was observed. Similar to the trend observed as a function of rf-cathode-power, the PL intensity also improved at higher ECR source powers but at a lower rate. Sputter rates for GaN were <10 A/min at 250 W source power and--225 A/min at 1000 W.
288
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
2000 "
i . ~
I
~
'
.
I
i
,
,
!
.
,
..
l
,
|
,
!
9
,
.
.
,
!
.
,
,
I
t
|
r
.,,,q
1500
"~ 1000
..~
500
e~
0
9
,
i
0
0.2
I
0.4
,
0.6
0.8
Radial Position on Wafer (inches) Figure 31. Variation of peak PL intensity as a function of radial position on the two inch wafer.
100
50
=
.,..~
0
ECR
cD
(-; -50 ICP - l O 0
I
0
.
.
.
.
I
50
i
.
,
,
I
,
100
,
t
,
I
.
150
.
.
.
I
.
200
.
.
.
I
250
.
,
.
i
~00
rf-cathode-power (W) Figure 32. Percent change in the peak PL intensity as a function of if-cathode-power for both ECR and ICP Ar plasmas.
The PL emission e f f i c i e n c y o f other III-V bulk semiconductors (e.g., GaAs) has been shown to be strongly dependent on surface c o n d i t i o n s
Plasma Etching of l l l - V Nitrides 289 (specifically the presence of a native oxide), the surface recombination velocity, as well as band bending at the surface.[ 1~176 While the exact nature of surface oxides and surface states in GaN are not well understood, the data show that the PL efficiency can be strongly affected by exposure to an Ar plasma and are highly sensitive to plasma conditions. A common result for both plasma environments was the decrease in PL intensity with increasing rf-cathode-power (suggesting that plasma-induced-damage can occur in GaN films under moderate ion energies). The data suggest that GaN surfaces are considerably more sensitive to process-induced changes than is widely recognized. Brief low bias exposures to ECR discharges almost doubled the band-edge PL, suggesting that native oxide has a strong effect on the surface recombination velocity.
10.0 P L A S M A E T C H A P P L I C A T I O N S The principal criteria for any plasma etch process is its utility in the fabrication of a device. The two most obvious applications of plasma etching oflII-V nitride devices have been the fabrication of blue LEDs and laser diodes, as shown by Nakamura.[ 1][2][5]-[7] In Fig. 33, the laser diode structure used by Nakamura is shown schematically.[ 7] A C12 RIE plasma was used to etch down into the n-GaN layer. The roughness of the facet surface was -500/1, and required a highly reflective coating to reduce the threshold current. The laser showed a relatively high threshold voltage and some light scattering, which may be attributed to the roughness of the etch. As plasma etch and masking technologies are refined, improved laser performance is expected. Alternative optical devices may also have applications in future photonic or optoelectronic circuits, including the whispering-gallery-mode microdisk laser.[1~ 1~ In Fig. 34, a schematic diagram of the fabrication process for a microdisk GaN-based laser is shown. A GaN/InGaN quantum well was grown on an A1N buffer by MO-MBE. Circular posts were patterned using a Si3N4 mask. Plasma etching was performed in an ECR C12/H2/CH4/Ar plasma at 1 mtorr, 170~ 850 W ECR source power, and 150 W rf-cathode-power with a corresponding de-bias of ~-175V. The etch was anisotropic and smooth with rates of-2200 A/min for GaN and -1000 A/min for A1N. The A1N was then selectively etched in a KOHbased etchant for--30 min at 85~ There was no measurable etching of the GaN or InGaN. A SEM micrograph showing the dry and wet etch steps is displayed in Fig. 35. Approximately 500 A of the sapphire substrate was etched in the ECR plasma.
290
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
p-GaN p-AIGaN p-GaN
p-AIGaN
I
InGaN MQW
~-~--------n-GaN n-AIGaN n-InGaN
(a)
n-GaN
sapphire substrate
Ni/Au ,
i
(b) Ti/AI ~'
.
v
I
sapphire substrate
Figure 33. Schematic diagram ofa III-V nitride laser diode (Nakamura, Ref. 5) showing the (a) growth structure and (b) the device after RIE etch and metallization.
Plasma etching has also been prominent in the fabrication of III-V nitride based electronic devices. This is especially critical for devices where active channels are close to the etch region, thus requiring well controlled, low-damage conditions. In Fig. 36, the process sequence for a GaNjunction field-effect transistor (JFET) [22]is shown schematically. The process required the following steps: (a) selective area implant of the n-channel and p-gate (b) refractory metal gate deposition, gate definition, and selective area implant of the source and drain (c) a timed plasma etch to remove the p-GaN in the source and drain regions (d) formation of ohmic source and drain contacts
Plasma Etching of lll-V Nitrides 291
InGaN
(a) Mask
~////////'//>/;~/>,/'///~/;~/',/'/,//J ~
sapphire
GaN Bu ffer
]
Mask InGaN ~
b.\\\\\\\\\\\
Co)
- GaN AIN
///.////.//,/////////////~
~
G aN Buffer
ECR Etch sapphire
InGaN ~
K\\\\\\\\\\"~I "~,.,.. GaN
~,,~,,,~.~,~,4,,...
(c) GaN Buffer
Wet Etch
sapphire
Figure 34. Schematic diagram of the process steps for the fabrication o f a GaN microdisk laser showing (a) the epitaxial growth structure, (b) ECR plasma etch, and (c) selective wet etch of the AIN.
The following ECR conditions were incorporated to remove-500 to 1000 A of the p-GaN: 1.0 mtorr pressure, 850 W ECR source power, 150 W if-cathode-power with a corresponding de-bias of~- - 185 V, 15 seem BC13, 20 seem H 2, and 5 seem Ar. The etch process must be well controlled and repeatable with smooth etch morphology and minimal damage for subsequent metallization of the source and drain ohmic contacts.
292
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
a)
/
GaN/InGaN A1N
GaN/InGaN b)
A1N
Figure 35. SEM micrograph of the microdisk laser showing (a) the non-selective ECR plasma etch and (b) the selective wet etch of A1N.
11.0 C O N C L U S I O N S In summary, the utilization of high-density ECR and ICP chlorinebased plasmas has resulted in high rate (> 1 ~m/min), smooth, anisotropie etching of the III-V nitrides. The source of reactive C1 (C12, BC13, IC1, etc.) and the use of additive gases (Ar, H2, N2, and SF6)have several effects on the etch characteristics of III-V nitride films. Using Cl2-based plasmas typically results in high concentrations of reactive C1 which increases the chemical component of the etch mechanism and the GaN etch rate. The addition of H 2, N 2, or SF 6 to C12- or BC13-based plasmas appears to effect the chemical removal of the N atoms from the GaN as well as the concentration of reactive C1 in the plasma (which directly correlates to etch rate). Very smooth pattern transfer has been obtained for a wide range of plasma chemistries and conditions. The bond breaking mechanism for the
Plasma Etching of l l l - V Nitrides 293 III-V nitride bonds appears to be critical and perhaps the rate limiting step in the etch mechanism. The use of high-density plasmas results in improved etch results possibly due to a two step process directly related to the plasma flux. Initially the high-density plasmas increase the bond breaking mechanism allowing the etch products to form and then produce efficient sputter desorption of the etch products. ICP etching of the III-V nitrides in C12/H2 plasmas yields etch profiles and sidewall morphologies which may improve the yield and performance of etched facet lasers. Although work has been significant in this area over the past few years, identifying plasma conditions which maintain the stoichiometry of the as-grown films and minimize plasma-induced-damage are critical to the fabrication of high performance III-V nitride devices and must be further developed and better understood.
GateImplant
photoresist (a)
"~ISI_GaN ~ ~ ~ ~ photoresist
Ohmic Implant
Co)
Gatecontact ~
Gatecontact "Dryetch of p-GaN"
(c)
Ti/AIohmiccontacts
~txxXxXxl
LX%XXXX~I
(d)
I'
'1
Figure 36. Schematic diagram of the process steps for the fabrication of a GaN JFET (Zolper, Ref. 20) showing (a) selective area implant of the n-channel and p-gate, (b) refractory metal gate deposition, gate definition, and selective area implant of the source and drain, (c) a timed plasma etch to remove the p-GaN in the source and drain regions, and (d) formation of ohmic source and drain contacts.
294
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author would like to acknowledge S. J. Pearton, C. R. Abemathy, J. C. Zolper, M. Hagerott Crawford, R. D. Briggs, C. B. Vartuli, R. F. Karlicek, Jr., C. Tran, M. Schurman, C. Constantine, C. Barratt, K. P. Killeen, J. Han, R. J. Hickman, and P. A. Barnes for their collaboration on this work. The author would like to also thank P. L. Glarborg, A. T. Ongstad, and L. Griego for their technical support. This work was supported by the United States Department of Energy under contract DEAC04-94AL85000. Sandia is a multiprogram laboratory operated by Sandia Corporation, a Lockheed Martin Company, for the United States Department of Energy.
REFERENCES 1. Nakamura, S., Mukai, T., and Senoh, M., Jpn. J. AppL Phys., 30: L 1998 (1991) 2. Nakamura, S., Mukai, T., Senoh, M., and Iwasa, N., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 31:L139(1992) 3. Foresi, J. S., and Moustakas, T. D.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 62:2859 (1993) 4. Binari, S. C., Rowland, L. B., Kruppa, W., Kelner, G., Doverspike, K., and Gaskill, D. K., Electron. Lett., 30:1248 (1994) 5. Nakamura, S., Mukai, T., and Senoh, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:1687 (1994) 6. Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Iwasa, N., and Nagahama, S., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 34:L797(1995) 7. Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahama, S., Iwasa, N., Yamada, T., Matsushito, T., Kiyoku, H., and Sugimoto, U., Jpn.. J. Appl. Phys., 35 :L74 (1996) 8. Matsuoka, T., Sasaki, T., and Katsui, A., Optoelectronic Devic'es and Technologies, 5:53 (1990) 9. Amano, H., Kito, M., Hiramatsu, K., and Akasuki, I., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 28:L2112 (1989) 10. Strite, S., andMorkoc, H.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 10:1237 (1992) 11. Kahn, M. A., Kuznia, J. N., Van Hove, J. M., Olson, D. T., Krishnankutty, S., and Kolbas, R. M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 58:526 (1991) 12. Tansley, T. L., and Egan, R. J., Phys. Rev. B, 45" 1094 (1993) 13. Khan, M. A., Bhattarai, A. R., Kuznia, J. N., and Olson, D. T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:1214(1993) 14. Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Wisk, P., Hobson, W. S., and Ren, F., Appl. Phys. Leg., 63:1143 (1993)
P l a s m a E t c h i n g o f l l l - V Nitrides 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 3.
24. 25.
26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40.
295
Davis, R. F., Proc. IEEE 79:702 (1991) Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., and Mukai, T., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 30:L 1708 (1991) Akasaki, I., Amano, H., Kito, M., and Kiramatsu, K., Lumin., 48/49:666 (1991) Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., and Mukai, T.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 62:2390 (1993) Khan, M. A., Chen, Q., Shur, M. S., Dermott, B. T., Higgins, J. A., Burm, J., Schaff, W., and Eastman, L. F., Electron. Lett., 32:257 (1996) Khan, M. A., J. N. Kuznia, Bhattarai, A. R., and Olson, D. T., Appl. Phys. Leg., 62:1248 (1993) Khan, M. A., Shur, M. S., and Chen, Q., Electron. Lett., 31:2130 (1995) Zolper, J. C., Shul, R. J, Baca, A. G., Wilson, R. G., Pearton, S. J., and Stall, R. A.,Appl. Phys. Leg., 68:2273 (1996) Manos, D. M., and Flamm, D. L., Plasma Etching, Academic Press, San Diego (1989) Chapman, B., Glow Discharge Processes, Academic Press, New York (1980) Dautremont-Smith, W. C., Gottscho, R. A., and Schultz, R. J., Semiconductor Materials and Processing Technology Handbook, (G. E. McGuire, ed.), pp. 191, Noyes, Park Ridge, NJ (1988) Chu, T. L., J. Electrochem. Soc., 119:1200 (1971) Pankove, J. I.,J. Electrochem, Soc., 119:1118 (1972) Guo, Q. X., Kato, O., and Yoshida, A.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 139:2008 (1992) Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. 1L, Ren, F., Lothian, J. R., Wisk, P. W., and Katz, A., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 11:1772 (1993) Sheng, T. Y., Yu, Z. Q., and Collins, G. J.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 52:576 (1988) Pauleau, T.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 129:1045 (1982) Taylor, K. M., and Lenie, C.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 107:308 (1960) Long, G., and Fuster, L. M.,J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 42:53 (1959) Barrett, N. J., Grange, J. D., Sealy, B. J., and Stephens, K. G., J. Appl. Phys., 57:5470(1985) Aita, C. R., and Gawlak, C. J., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 1:403 (1983) Kline, G. R., and Lakin, K. M.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 43:750(1983) Mileham, J. R., Pearton, S. J., Abernathy, C. 1L, MacKenzie, J. D., Shul, R. J., and Kilcoyne, S.P.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 14:836(1996) Mileharn, J. IL, Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., MacKenzie, J. D., Shul, IL J., and Kilcoyne, S. P., Appl. Phys. Lea., 67:1119 (1995). Minsky, M. S., White, M., and Hu, E. L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68" 1531 (1996) Youstey, C., Adesida, I., and Bulman, G., Electron. Letts., 33:245 (1997)
296
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
41. Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Ren, F., and Lothian, J. R., J. Appl. Phys.,
76:1210,(1994) 2, Adesida, I., Mahajan, A., Andideh, E., Asif Khan, M., Olsen, D. T., and 3, 4. 5.
46. 47. 48.
49. 50. 51.
52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 0.
61.
Kuznia, J. N., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:2777 (1993) Lin, M. E., Zan, Z. F., Ma., Z., Allen, L. H., and Morko~, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:887 (1994) Ping, A. T., Adesida, I., Asif Khan, M., and Kuznia, J. N., Electron. Lett., 30:1895 (1994) Lee, H., Oberman, D. B., and Harris, J. S., Jr., Appl. Phys, Lett., 67:1754 (1995) Asmussen, J.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 5:328 (1987) Popov, O. A., High-density Plasma Sources, Noyes Publications, Park Ridge, NJ (1996) Lieberonan, M. A. ,and Gottscho, R. A., "Plasma Sources for Thin Film Deposition and Etching," (M. H. Francombe, and J. L. Vossen, eds.), Physics of Thin Films, Vol. 18, Academic Press, San Diego (1994) Constantine, C., Johnson, D., Pearton, S. J., Chakrabarti, U. K., Emerson, A. B., Hobson, W. S., and Kinsella, A. P.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 8:596 (1990) Pearton, S. J., Chakrabarti, U. K., Kinsella, A. P., Johnson, D., and Constantine, C., Appl. Phys. Lett. 56:1424 (1990) Murrell, A. J., Grimwood, R. C., O'Sullivan, P., Gilbert, M., Vanner, K., Ruddell, F., Davies, I., Hilton, K., Bland, S., and Spear, D., Technical Digest, Proc. 1992 GaAs IC Symposium, pp. 173 Cheung, R., Lee, Y. H., Lee, K. Y., Smith, T. P., III, Kern, D. P., Beaumont, S. P., and Wilkinson, C.D.W.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 7:1462 (1989) Ko, K. K., and Pang, S. W.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 141:250(1994) Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Ren, F., Lothian, J. R., Wisk, P. W., Katz, A., and Constantine, C., Semicond. Sci. Technol., 8:310 (1993) Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., and Ren, F., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:2294 (1994) Zhang, L., Ramer, J., Zheng, K., Lester, L. F., and Hersee, S. D., Mat. Res. Soc. Proc., 395:763 (1996) Humphreys, B., and Govett, M., MIJNSR 1 (1996) Vartuli, C. B., Pearton, S. J., Lee, J. W., Hong, J., MacKenzie, J. D., Abemathy, C. R., and Shul, R. J.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:1426 (1996) Vartuli, C. B., MacKenzie, J. D., Lee, J. W., Abemathy, C. R., Pearton, S. J., and Shul, R. J., J. Appl. Phys., 80:3705 (1996) Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., and Ren, F., Appl. Phys. Lett. 64:3643 (1994) Shul, R. J., Kilcoyne, S. P., Hagerott Crawford, M., Parmeter, J. E., Vartuli, C. B., Abemathy, C. R., and Pearton, S. J.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:1761 (1995)
Plasma Etching of llI-VNitrides
297
62. Shul, R. J., Howard, A. J., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Vartuli, C. B., Barnes, P. A., and Bozack, M. J., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 13:2016 (1995) 63. Vartuli, C. B., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Shul, R. J., Howard, A. J., Kilcoyne, S. P., Parmeter, J. E., and Hagerott Crawford, M., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 14:1011 (1996) 64. Shul, R. J., Ashby, C. I. H., Rieger, D. J., Howard, A. J., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Vartuli, C. B., and Barnes, P. A., Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 395:751 (1996) 65. Shul,R. J., McClellan, G. B., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Constantine, C., and C. Barratt, Electron. Lett., 32:1408 (1996). 66. Shul, R. J., McClellan, G. B., Casalnuovo, S. A., Rieger, D. J., Pearton, S. J., Constantine, C., Barratt, C., Karlicek, R. F., Jr., Tran, C., and Schurman, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:1119 (1996) 67. McLane, G. F., Meyyappan, M., Cole, M. W., and Wrenn, C., J. Appl. Phys., 69:695 (1991) 68. Meyyappan, M., McLane, G. F., Lee, H. S., Eckart, E., Namaroff, M., and Sasserath, J.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 10:1215 (1992) 69. McLane, G. F., Casas, L., Pearton, S. J., and Abemathy, C. R., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:3328 (1995) 70. Adesida, I., Ping, A. T., Youtsey, C., Sow, T., Asif Khan, M., Olson, D. T., and Kuznia, J. N., Appl. Phys. Lett., 65:889 (1994) 71. Ping, A. T., Adesida, I., and AsifKhan, M.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 67:1250 (1995) 72. Gillis, H. P., Choutov, D. A., Martin, K. P., and Song, L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68:2255(1996) 73. Gillis, H. P., Choutov, D. A., Steiner, P. A., Piper, J. D., Crouch, J. H., Dove, P. M., and Martin, K. P., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:2475 (1995) 74. Gillis, H. P., Choutov, D. A., and Martin, K. P., JOM, 50 (1996) 75. Gillis, H. P., Choutov, D. A., Martin, K. P., Pearton, S. J., and Abemathy, C. R., d. Electrochem. Soc., in oress. 76. Leonard, R. T., and Bedair, S. M., AppL Phys. Lett., 68:794 (1996) 77. Chuang, T. J., Laser Microfabrication: Thin Film Processes and Lithography, (D. J. Ehrlich and J. Y. Tsa, eds.), p. 87, Academic, San Diego (1989) 78. Ashby, C. I. H., Properties ofGaAs, 2nd edition INSPEC, London, Ch. 20, 653-682 (1990) 79. Hayes, T. R., Indium Phosphide and Related Materials: Processing, Technology, and Devices, (A. Katz, ed.), Artech House, Boston, Ch. 8, 277-306(1992) 80. Constantine, C., Barratt, C., Pearton, S. J., Pen, F., and Lothian, J. R., Appl. Phys. Lett. 61:2899 (1992)
298
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
81. Constantine, C., Barratt, C., Pearton, S. J., Ren, F., and Lothian, J. R., Electron. Lett. 28:1749 (1992) 2, Lishan, D. G., and Hu, E. L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 56, 1667 (1990) 83. Donnelly, V. M., Flamm, D. L., Tu, C. W., and Ibbotson, E., J. Electrochem. Soc., 129:2533 (1982) 4,, Thomas, S., III, Ko, K. K., Pang, S.W.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 13:894 (1995) 85. Lee, J. W., Hong, J., and Pearton, S. J.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 68:847 (1996) 86. Niggebrugge, U., Klug, M., and Garus, G., Inst. Phys. Conf. Ser., 79:367 (1985) 87. Keskinen, J., Nappi, J., Asonen, H., and Pessa, M., Electron. Lett., 26:1371 (1990) 88. Hayes, T. R., Dreisbach, M. A., Thomas, P. M., Dautremont-Smith, W. C., and Heimbrook, L. A., dr. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 7:1130 (1989) 89. Cheung, R., Thoms, S., Beaumont, S. P., Doughty, G., V. Law, and Wilkinson, C. D. W.,Electron. Lett., 23:857 (1987) 0. Pearton, S. J., and Shul, R. J., III-Nitrides, Academic Press, in press. 91. Ren, F., Lothian, J. R., Kuo, J. M., Hobson, W. S., Lopata, J., Caballero, J. A., Pearton, S. J., and Cole, M. W., Jr. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 14:1 (1995) 2. Ren, F., Hobson, W. S., Lothian, J. R., Lopata, J., Caballero, J. A., Pearton, S. J., and Cole, M. W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67:2497 (1995) 3. Shul, R. J., McClellan, G. B., Briggs, R. D., Rieger, D. J., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Lee, J. W., Constantine, C., and Barratt, C., J. Vac. Sci. and Technol. A, in press (1996) 94. Shul, R. J., Howard, A. J., Vartuli, C. B., Barnes, P. A., and Seng, W., J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, 14:1102 (1996) 5. Shul, R. J., Baca, A. G., Rieger, D. J., Hou, H., Pearton, S. J., and Ren, F., Mat. Res. Soc. Syrup. Proc., 421:245 (1996) 6. Vartuli, C. B., Pearton, S. J., Lee, J. W., MacKenzie, J. D., Abemathy, C. R., and Shul, R. J., J. Vac. Sci. and Technol B, 15:98 (1997) 7. Vartuli, C. B., Pearton, S. J., MacKenzie, J. D., Abemathy, C. R., and Shul, R. J.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 143:L246 (1996) 98. Contolini, R. J.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 135:929 (1988) 99. Pearton, S. J., and Hobson, W. S.,J. Appl. Phys., 66:5018 (1989) 100. Pang, S. W.,J. Electrochem. Soc., 133:784 (1986) 101. Pearton, S. J., Lee, J. W., MacKenzie, J. D., Abernathy, C. R., and Shul, R. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67, 2329 (1995) 102. Shan, W., Schmidt, T. J., Yang, X. H., Hwang, J., Song, J. J., and Goldenberg, B., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:985 (1995)
P l a s m a E t c h i n g o f l l I - V Nitrides
299
103. Chen, G. D., Smith, M., Lin, J. Y., Jiang, H. X., AsifKhan, M. and Sun, C. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67:1653 (1995) 104. Gottscho, R. A., Preppemau, B. L., Pearton, S. J., Emerson, A. B., and Giapis, K. P.,J. Appl. Phys., 68:440 (1990) 105. Aydil, E. S., and Gottscho, R. A., Mat. Sci. For., 148/149:159 (1994) 106. McCall, S. L., Levi, A. F. J., Slusher, R. E., Pearton, S. J., and Logan, R. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 60:289 (1992) 107. Abemathy, C. R., Pearton, S. J., MacKenzie, J. D., Mileham, J. R., Bharatan, S. R., Krishnamoorthy, V., Jones, K. S., Hagerott Crawford, M., Shul, R. J., Kilcoyne, S. P., Zavada, J. M., Zhang, D., and Kolbas, R. M., Solid-State Electron., 39:311 (1996) 108. Lee, J. W., Vartuli, C. B., Abemathy, C. R., MacKenzie, J. D., Mileham, J. R., Pearton, S. J., Shul, R. J., Zolper, J. C., Hagerott Crawford, M., Zavada, J. M., Wilson, R. G., and Schwartz, R.N.,J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 10:3637 (1996)
7 Ion Implantation Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
in
John C. Zolper
1.0
INTRODUCTION
,\
The wide bandgap semiconductors, group-Ill Nitrides (INN, GaN, and A1N), SiC, and diamond have long been recognized as being ideal materials for short wavelength light emitters or detectors and for highpower, high-temperature electronics.[1]-[ 3] The group III nitride material system has generated considerable excitement in the semiconductor research community with the success in fabricating high performance light emitting diodes (LEDs), lasers, and transistors.J4] -[12] The interest in SiC has mostly been fueled by its potential in the electronics arena duc to its high breakdown field and high thermal conductivity making it useful for high-power or high-temperature operation.[13]-[ 16] Diamond also is expected to bc most applicable to electronic applications (transistors or detectors) due to its predicted excellent transport and thermal properties which arc superior to the group-HI Nitridcs and SIC.[1Ill7] Details of the attractive properties of these materials arc described in other chapters of this book. The wide bandgap II-VI semiconductors (e.g., ZnSe, ZnS, etc.) are not included in this chapter since their low melting point (-300~ makes them unattractive for electronic device applications where implantation is expected to have the most impact. Their low melting point will also make 300
lonlmplantation 301 it difficult to perform the required thermal annealing to activate implanted dopants in the II-VI materials. For this reason, little work has been reported on implantation in the wide bandgap II-VI semiconductors.[ 18] In this chapter, the status of ion implantation doping and isolation in group-III Nitride, SiC, and diamond semiconductors is presented. Ion implantation is a process whereby doping or compensating impurities are injected into a semiconductor by a high energy accelerator.[ 19]Implantation has come to be the dominant doping technology in silicon and gallium arsenide microelectronics, although there was significant technological development required to achieve this success. This success was due to the ability to precisely control the doping concentration and profile as well as the ability to minimize the processing thermal budget. Therefore, with improved wide bandgap semiconductor starting materials and improved understanding of the ion implantation process, this technology can be expected to play a critical enabling role in the maturation of these promising materials into sophisticated, manufacturable devices. In the following sections, the material and process technologies related to ion implantation in wide bandgap semiconductors are presented. First, the use of implantation to produce high resistivity, isolating regions is discussed. Second, ion implantation doping to achieve n- and p-type material is described. Third, results are given for the redistribution or diffusion of implanted impurities that occurs during the high temperature implantation activation annealing process. Fourth, a review is given of implantation-induced crystal defects and the removal of implant damage by thermal annealing. Fifth, examples are presented of devices in each material system that have employed implantation isolation or doping. Finally, areas for future work are outlined and conclusions are drawn. In each of the sections, a discussion is given for the three materials considered in the chapter: group-III nitrides, SiC, and diamond.
2.0
IMPLANTATION ISOLATION
Implant isolation has been widely used in compound semiconductor devices for inter-device isolation (as in transistor circuits) or to produce current channeling in lasers.[2~ 22] The implantation process can compensate the semiconductor layer either by a damage or a chemical mechanism. For damage compensation, the resistance typically goes through a maximum
302
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
with increasing post-implantation annealing temperature as the damage is annealed out and hopping conduction is reduced. At higher temperatures, the defect density is further reduced below that required to compensate the material, and the resistivity decreases. For chemical compensation, the post-implantation resistance again increases with annealing temperature, showing a reduction in hopping conduction; but it then stabilizes at higher temperatures as a thermally stable compensating deep level is formed. Typically, there is a minimum dose (dependent on the doping level of the sample) required for the chemically active isolation species to achieve thermally stable compensation.[ 23] Thermally stable implant isolation has been reported for O-implanted n- and p-type A1GaAs, where an A1-O complex is thought to form. A C-N complex is postulated for N-implanted C-doped GaAs and A1GaAs.[23]-[25] With this background, implant isolation properties of wide bandgap semiconductors are reviewed.
2.1
Group IIl Nitrides
GaN. The first report of the use of implantation to reduce the free carrier concentration in GaN was by Khan, et al. Their work involved Be and N implants in GaN and A1GaN to achieve compensation of native donor defects to enhance Schottky barrier formation.j26][ 27] It was shown that shallow implants into samples with a high concentration of native donors reduces the donor concentration and allows the formation of improved Schottky contacts. Since the samples were annealed at 1100~ after implantation, the compensation was most likely due to activated acceptors in the case of Be and perhaps due to a reduction in the concentration of N-vacancies that acted as donors (in the case of N-implantation). A study on the thermal characteristics of compensation via Nimplantation in n- and p-type GaN was first reported by Pearton.[ 28] As shown in Fig. 1, N-implantation effectively compensates both p- and n-type GaN when implanted to achieve an implanted N density of-4 x 10 TMcm -3. For both doping types, the resistance first increased with annealing temperature, then reached a maximum before demonstrating a significant reduction in resistance (after a 850~ anneal for n-type and a 950~ anneal for p-type GaN). This behavior is typical of implant-damage compensation. The defect levels estimated from Arrhenius plots of the resistance/temperature product are 0.83 eV for initially n-type and 0.90 eV for initially p-type GaN.[ 28] These levels are not at midgap, but are sufficiently deep to realize a sheet resistance > 109 ~/EI. The implantation has also been reported to
Ion Implantation 303 effectively isolate n-type GaN, with the material remaining compensated to over 850~ 29] Interestingly, H-implant compensation of n-type GaN was reported to anneal out a t - 4 0 0 ~ with an anomalous dependence on implant energy.[ 291The reason for this is presently not known. In light of this result, however, H-implantation in GaN will require further study since H is often the ion of choice for photonie device isolation applications that require deep isolation schemes. Moreover, both He- and N-implant isolation appear to rely solely on implantation damage without any chemical compensation effects analogous to those in the O/A1GaAs case.J2~ 24] However, the implantation-induced defects in GaN are more thermally stable than other III-V semiconductor materials, such as GaAs or InP, where damage levels begin to anneal out below 700~ 2~ This may be a result of the higher bandgap of GaN or the more polar nature of the lattice causing more stable defects. Furthermore, recent results for very low dose (10 l~ to 1011 cm -2) N-implantation in lightly n-type GaN (as-grown ---5 x 1016 em-3) suggest that, for low doses, N-implantation may actually increase the free electron concentration by increasing the number of N-vacancies or interstitials.[ 3~ Clearly, further work is required to fully understand the nature of implantation damage in GaN.
1010 - I F p-type 109
n-type
10 8 107 10 6 105 , ~ , , , ~ 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 annealing temperature (~ Figure 1. Sheet resistance versus annealing temperature for N-implanted initially n- and ptype GaN. The N was implanted at multiple energies to give an approximatelyuniform ion
concentration of 4 x 10Is cm-3 across ~500 nm (after Ref. 27).
304
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
InGaN. Implant isolation of the In-containing nitrides (INN, InGaN, and InA1N) was first reported using F-implantation.[ 31] That work showed that InN did not demonstrate significant compensation while the temaries (InGaN and InA1N) increased in sheet resistance by roughly an order-ofmagnitude after a 500~ anneal, Data from a more extensive study of InxGal.xN implant isolation for varying In-composition using N- and Fimplantation is summarized in Fig. 2.[ 32] The InGaN temaries only realize a maximum of a 100 fold increase in sheet resistance independent of ion species after a 500~ anneal. Pure InN shows a higher increase of 3 ordersof-magnitude, but still only achieves a maximum sheet resistance of 104 f2/EI. This may be high enough for some photonic device current-guiding applications, but is not sufficient for inter-device isolation in electronic circuits. The damage levels created by N-implantation are estimated from an Arrhenius plot of the resistance/temperature product to be a maximum of 390 meV below the conduction band.J32] The defect level is high in the energy gap, not near midgap as is ideal for implant compensation. The position of the damage level is analogous to the defect position reported for implant compensated n-type InP and InGaAs, but different from the damageassociated, midgap states created in GaAs and A1GaAs.[23][24][33]
108 , , , , , . , , . , . , . , . , , , , 107 106
91
105
D
104 r
Q.
103
102 l 01 10~
--0- as-grown - t ~ F-isolation N-isolation ,
,
I
20
,
,
,
I
,
,
,
I
t
40 60 percent In
i
,
i
80
,
,
,
i
100
Figure 2. Maximum sheet resistance versus percent In for InGaN either as-grown or implanted with F or N and annealed at the temperature for maximum compensation for each composition (ion concentration - 5 x 1019cm-3) (after Ref. 34).
lonlmplantation 305 InAIN. As shown in Fig. 3, In0.75A10.25N, in contrast to InGaN, can be highly compensated with N- or O-implantation with over a three orderof-magnitude increase in sheet resistance after a 600 to 700~ anneal while F-implantation produces only one order-of-magnitude increase in sheet resistance.[a1][34][35] The compensating level in InA1N is also high in the bandgap (with the deepest level estimated from Arrhenius plots as being 580 meV below the conduction band edge in high dose N-isolated material). However, it is sufficiently deep to achieve highly compensated material.[34][35] The enhanced compensation for N- and O-implantation in InA1N suggests some chemical component to the compensation process (as compared to F-implantation). For N-implantation, a reduction in N-vacancies (thought to play a role in the as-grown n-type conduction), may explain the enhanced compensation. For O-implantation, the enhanced compensation may be the result of the formation of an O-A1 complex as is thought to occur in O-implanted A1GaAs.[23][24]
10 lo 10 9 10 8 [Z]
ck
10 7 10 6
105 10 4 103 200
I
I
400
!
I
600
I
I
I
800
.
1000
annealing temperature (~
Figure3. Sheet resistance versus annealing temperature for O-, N-, or F-implanted Ino.7sAlo.25N (ion concentration- 5 x 10 ts cm "3) (after Ref. 34).
306
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Figure 4 schematically summarizes the present knowledge of the position in the bandgap of the compensating implanted defect levels in group-III nitride materials and compares these to those in GaAs and InP. Although the levels are not at midgap, as is ideal for optimum compensation as occurs in GaAs and p-type InP, the levels are sufficiently deep to produce high resistivity material (with the exception of InGaN).
n,p GaN n-InGaN (47% InN)
n-InAIN (75% InN) n: 830 meV (He 760 meV)
n&p-GaAs
n&p_InP
~-390meV
~~580meV
EC
l p: 900 meV EV Eg =
1.42 eV
1.35 eV
-2.5 eV
-2.5 eV
3.39 eV
Figure 4. Schematic representation of the position in the energy gap of compensating defect levels from implant isolation in GaAs, InP, Ino.47Gao.53N,Ino.7sAlo.25N,and GaN.
SiC. Implant isolation of SiC layers is also of technological importance to allow the fabrication of planar electronic devices and circuits (limited work has been reported in this area). Nadella reported on the properties of H-implanted, n-type 4H-SiC and achieved resistivities as high as 2 x 106 ~_cm.[ 36] The H-implanted samples demonstrated a temperature activated conduction with characteristic energy of 0.41 eV suggesting that the compensating defect is in the upper half of the bandgap. This may limit this approach for devices that need to operate at elevated temperatures since carriers will be thermally activated out of the levels. Chemical compensation has been achieved in SiC by doping with vanadium either during epitaxy or by implantation. [371-[39]Vanadium was shown to act as a deep donor 1.35 eV below the conduction band edge that effectively compensated residual boron in bulk SiC.[38]V-implantation into
Ion Implantation 307 initially p-type (boron doped) SiC achieved resistivities as high as 1012 ~')cm after annealing up to 1500~ For N-doped, n-type SiC, the same Vimplantation scheme resulted in resistivities of 106 ~-cm that, although lower than the p-type starting material, is still sufficiently high for most device applications. In contrast to the trend for the resistivities, the activation energy for conduction was estimated to be 0.76 eV for the n-type starting material, and 0.1 eV for the p-type starting material. The lower activation energy for the p-type material was not consistent with a 1.35 eV V-donor level and was attributed to alternative leakage paths, such as on the mesa edge.[ 39]This may indeed be the case since V-implantation is now being applied to electronic devices as discussed in Sec. 6.2.[ 4~ Diamond. To date, the primary challenge for diamond devices has been realizing n- and p-type doping. Therefore, little work has been done on implantation isolation in this material. One study by Kalish and coworkers examined the compensation properties of He- and H-implants on p-type diamond.[41] Type IIa diamond films were doped with boron with a multiple energy implantation scheme followed by a two step anneal at 1050~ and 1350~ 42] The films were then implanted with He at an energy of 320 keV or H at an energy of either 30 or 320 keV. Figure 5 shows the effect on resistance versus implanted dose for the three implantation schemes. All three approaches effectively compensated the film for a sufficiently high dose. The dose dependence is explained by the difference in defect profile generation for the different ions and energies. Figure 6 shows resistance versus damage density for the different implants and demonstrates that complete compensation occurs at roughly the same damage level (within a factor of two for all three approaches). This is evidence that damage profile is the key element in compensation and not a chemical compensation by H or He. The damage could be annealed out, and the initial conductivity restored, by annealing the samples at 1350~ but not at lower temperatures (600~ This work also suggests that p-type diamond may be susceptible to radiation damage that will alter the electrical properties of active devices.[ 41]
308
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
10 TM
~ 101o
o~ Z
109
VHe
ni
u') rY
I0 e
H
107 ,
101~
10"
10 '2
DOSE
10 I~
,
, IA,,~
10"
10 '5
(ions/cm2)
Figure 5. Resistance of B-doped diamond layers under irradiation with 320 keV He, 320 keV H, or 30 keV H. The resistance of a undoped layer measured under the same conditions is shown for comparison (after Ref. 41).
1012
" "Tl'"al" ' ' 'i .... I
' ' '1 .... I
' ''i""l
' '~i .... I
1011
E o
10 l~
Ld 0 z
109
Unirradioted
j
U3 m 10e
9320keY 9320
He
"
keY H
0 undoped
9 30
10 7 101~ DAMAGE
101.
1015
DENSITY
1016
keY H 1017
1010
( v a c a n c i e s / c m 3)
Figure 6. The data of Fig. 5 replotted after converting the dose into damage density expressed as vacancies/cm 3. The damage density required to completely remove the conductivity due to the B dopant is about 5 x 1016/cm3, which is comparable to the concentration of acceptors in the B-doped layer (after Ref. 41).
lonlmplantation 309 3.0
IMPLANTATION DOPING
3.1
Carrier Ionization in Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Before reviewing the work on implantation doping in GaN, SiC, and diamond, it is constructive to review the physics of free carrier ionization. The assumption often taken in silicon and GaAs, where ionization energies are typically < 20 meV, of compete carrier ionization at room temperature does not apply for wide bandgap semiconductors due to the high ionization energies. Table 1 contains the accepted values for ionization energies for the most commonly used dopants in GaN, SiC, and diamond. The relationship between these ionization energies and the free carrier concentration is reviewed in the following section.
Table 1. Summary of Ionization Energies of the Most Common Dopants in GaN, SiC, and Diamond
GaN a
3C-SiC b
4H-SiC b
6H-SiC b
Diamond c
donors
Si (25), 0(29)
N(28)
N (45, 100)
N (80, 130)
N (1700)
acceptors
Ca (169), Mg (170), Zn (230)
B (350), Ai (200)
B(350), Al (200)
B (350), Al (200)
B (370)
a j. C. Zolper, et al., J. Electron. Mat., 25:839 (1996); J. C. Zolper, et al.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 68:1945 (1996); S. Strite and H. Morkoc, J. Vac. Sci. Tech. B, 10:1237 (1992) b G. Pensl and W. J. Choyke, Physica B, 185:264 (1993) c R. J. Farrer, Solid State Corn, 7:685 (169); A. T. Collins and A. W. Willimas, J. Phys. C.
Solid St. Phys., 4:1789 (1971)
310
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors The free electron density (n) can be expressed as: [43]
n=N ex~_(E _Ef)]kT
Eq. (1)
and the free hole density (p) can be expressed as:
Eq. (2)
p= N ex~-(Ekf E)]
Ec(v)
where is the conduction (valence) band minimum (maximum) energy. For n-type material, the position of the Fermi level can be solved for from the following expression for the density of ionized donors:
(Ef)
N~d -Nd 1-
Eq. (3)
1
1 (E~.Z.~" ~
l + -geXp~
kT )
while for p-type material the density of ionized aceeptors is:
Eq. (4)
N~=N
1 1+ g e x p ( E :
f,]
and the conduction (valance) band density-of-states, No(v),is defined as" 3/2
Eq. (5)
Mc
Nc(~)-212zcmhz(h)kT ) M~
where is the number of equivalent minima in the conduction band and mde is the density-of-states effective mass. The electron or hole ground
Ion Implantation 311 state degeneracy is expressed by g. The donor (acceptor) ionization energy (Ed(a)) is listed in Table I. Other terms in Eqs. 3-5 have their usual meaning. To simplify the discussion, we assume that the material does not contain significant compensating impurities. The key observation from the above equations is that the free electron and hole concentrations are exponentially dependent on the carrier ionization energy as it determines the position of the Fermi level. To illustrate this point, a simple exponential dependence or Boltzmann statistics of free carrier concentration (n,p .~ N d , a exp (Ed,a/kT)) at room temperature (23~ and 300~ versus carrier ionization energy is shown in Fig. 7. Nd, a w a s set to 100 meV for Fig. 7 so that the result can be displayed as percent ionized. For an ionization energy of 170 meV, as is reported for Mg acceptors in GaN, only---0.14% of the substitutional Mg will yield free holes at room temperature.[ 4][35] This increases to -~3% at 300~ This relationship should be kept in mind when considering the effectiveness of implantation doping in these materials since proper lattice occupation of the dopant (i.e., substitutionality) alone does not control the measured free carrier concentration.
100
i
I
\-.
o~
i
1
-
I L
~23
v
--
10
~
"300 ~
,irN ,,==,,
o o,=,~ r ro
%
L_
Q.
0.1
%
0.01
,
0
i
,
50
100
,.l
~i
150 200 250 300 350 400
ionization energy (meV)
F i g u r e 7. Percent of ionized carriers versus ionization energy at 23 or 300~ simplified exponential or Boltzmann statistics; n , p - Nd, a exp (Ed, a/kT).
based on a
312
3.2
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Implantation Activation Temperature
Selective area ion implantation doping can be used to form highly doped contact regions in lasers and FETs or to create precisely doped transistor channels. The ability to precisely control the doping level and spatial location enables many high-performance device designs. To achieve activated implanted dopants, the ability of the material to withstand the required annealing process must be accessed. Table 2 compares the melting point of wide bandgap semiconductors with more mature semiconductors (Si and GaAs), to the temperatures commonly reported for achieving activation of implanted dopants in these materials.[ 44]For Si and GaAs, the activation temperature is roughly two-thirds of the melting temperature. However, for the higher melting point materials (SiC and GaN), this temperature is closer to 50% of the melting point. The temperature reported for dopant activation in diamond is at an even lower fraction of the melting point (--0.4). While this may suggest that SiC and GaN are actually more stable at the activation temperature, this is not the case since both materials sublime well below their melting point. In the following sections, the status of activating implanted dopants in the wide bandgap semiconductors is reviewed. Details of various annealing schemes are also presented.
Table 2. Comparison of Semiconductor Melting Points (Tmp) to the Temperature Required to Activate Implanted Dopants (Tact) (after Ref 44)
T,.p(~ GaSb InP GaAs Si SiC c GaN c diamond
707 a 1057 a 1237 a 1410 a 2797 a 2518 b 4000
T,a (~ 500--600 700-750 750-900 950-1050 1300-1600 --1100 .-1300 c
rac~/Tmp 0.71-0.85 0.66-0.71 0.61-0.73 0.67-0.74 0.46-0.57 0.44 0.33
a Robert C. Weast, Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, p. E92-93 (1983) b j. A. Van Vechten, Phys. Rev B, 7:1479 (1973) r May include defect and impurity conduction[ TM
Ion Implantation 313 3.3
GaN
In the early 1970's, Pankove and co-workers used ion implantation to characterize the photoluminescence spectra from an array of dopant species in GaN.[ 45] In this work, the energy levels of the common III-V semiconductor acceptors (C, Be, Mg, Zn, and Cd) were first determined, as summarized in Table 3. Magnesium was reported as having the shallowest acceptor level (-~240 meV), while Zn (with an energy level of~580 meV) had the strongest luminescence intensity.[46] To remove the implantation damage, these samples were annealed for 1 hr in flowing NH 3. No electrical properties of the implanted species were reported. These layers were most likely compensated by H that was generated from the decomposition of the NH 3 present during growth and during the annealing process. As discussed later, annealing in a non-hydrogen containing ambient is required to achieve electrical activity of acceptors on GaN.
Table 3. Photoluminescence Peak Position, Distance from the Conduction Band Edge, and the Rank Order of Luminescence Intensity for GaN Implanted with the Species Listed and Annealed in NH 3 at 1050~ for lh. (Data after Pankove in Ref. 45.)
Species
Peak Position
Bandedge-Peak
(eV)
(meV)
3.21
240
B
3.2
250
P
2.88
570
Zn
2.87
580
Cd
2.70
800
As
2.58
920
Ca
2.50
1000
ng
2.43
1070
C
2.17
1280
Be
2.16
1290
Mg
Rank Order of PL Intensity
314
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Figure 8 shows the evolution of sheet resistance versus annealing temperature for Si-implanted (200 keV, 5 x 10 TM c m -2) and unimplanted GaN.[ 28] The samples were annealed for 10 s in flowing N 2 in a SiC coated graphite susceptor. It is critical to use a hydrogen free ambient to avoid hydrogen passivation of the dopants and thus to achieve electrical activity. This discovery is in contrast to earlier annealing studies that used an NH 3 ambient to stabilize the GaN surface but allowed the generation of atomic hydrogen to passivate dopant species. [45][46] As seen in Fig. 8, electrical activity starts to occur at 1050~ as evident by the drop in sheet resistance, and further increases at 1100~ The ionization levels of implanted Si have been estimated from Arrhenius plots of either the sheet resistance or the carrier density to be 25 and 62 meV, respectively.[ 35] These values are in the range reported for epitaxiai doping of GaN with Si. [47]
10 6
105
D t~
a.
104 unimplanted --tl- Si-implanted
103 600
I
700
I
800
I
900
I
I
1000 1100 1200
annealing temperature (~ Figure 8. Sheet resistance versus annealing temperature for GaN either unimplanted or implanted with 28Si (200 keV, 5 x 1014cm-2). The implanted sample demonstrates enhanced ntype conduction after a 1050~ anneal with further improvements at 1100~ (aider Ref. 27).
Figure 9 shows an Arrhenius plot of the sheet electron concentration versus annealing temperature for Si-implanted GaN (200 keV, 5 x 1014 cm2).
lon lmplantation 315 A carrier activation energy (not to be confused with the ionization energy) can be estimated as 6.7 eV from the region of increasing electron concentration by examining Fig. 9.[35]This high activation energy is not consistent with a simple hopping process whereby the Si atoms occupy the nearest Ga vacancies to become electrically active. Such a hopping process is thought to occur during GaAs and InP implantation activation with activation energies in the range of 0.4 to 1.9 eV. [48] The high activation energy for Siimplantation in GaN can be explained in terms of a substitutional diffusion process. In this case, the implanted Si would occupy substitutional Ga-sites at relatively low temperatures, but remain electrically inactive (compensated) by implantation induced point defects. The Si would then become electrically activated only when these defects diffuse away and re-occupy an appropriate lattice site. An example of such a defect reaction is given in Eq. 6: Sio a _ N +Oa ]0 ~ Sioa + NON + Ga 0Ga
Eq. (6)
1014 r J
o I::I O
9 i,,,,,i
1013 a
= 6.7 eV
o I::I
1012 m I
lO 11 . . . . 0.7
~ .... 0.8
I I
0.9
1
,
1.1
1000/T (K l ) Figure 9. Arrhenius plot of the sheet electron concentration for Si-implanted (200 keV, 5 x 10TM cm-2) GaN versus annealing temperature. The extracted activation energy for donor formation is 6.7 meV which is consistent with an inter-diffusion process (after Ref. 34).
316
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Therefore, the activation energy corresponds to the inter-diffusion coefficients of Ga and N in GaN, not the energy for Si to become substitutional. The energy of 6.7 eV, estimated from Fig. 9, is in the range reported for Ga and As inter-diffusion in GaAs and, therefore, is consistent with an inter-diffusion process.[ 49] Ion implantation has also been used to estimate the ionization energy of O in GaN.[ 5~ Determining the electrical nature of O-impurities in GaN is of interest, since O has long been suspected as playing a contributing role in the background n-type conductivity of GaN.[51][52] Figure 10 shows an Arrhenius plot of the resistance/temperature product for unimplanted and O-implanted (70 keV, 5 x 1014cm -2) GaN after annealing. The O-sample is n-type and displays an estimated ionization energy of-~28 meV while the unimplanted sample remains highly resistive with an effective ionization energy of 335 meV.
1013
, '
'
'
!
'
'
'
i
'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
I
'
'
unimplanted, 1100 ~ - I - O-implanted, 1050 ~
1012
= 335 meV
O4
~:
'
lO ll
v
~.~
1010
Q.
109 I
108
J
2
,
i
I
4
i
i
i
i
6
,
,
,
I
8
,
,
,
I
,
10
,
,
I
,
12
,
,
t4
1000/T ( K ~) Figure 10. Arrhenius plot of the resistance/temperature product for unimplanted, annealed (1100~ and O-implanted (70 keV, 5 x 10TM cm-2), annealed (1050~ GaN. The extracted ionization level for O is 28 meV while that for the unimplanted sample is 335 meV (after Ref. 47).
Figure 11 shows the evolution of sheet resistance versus annealing temperature for Mg (180 keV, 5 x 1014cm-2), Mg+P (180/250 keV, both
_Ion Implantation 317 5 x 1014cnl2), and unimplanted GaN.[ 28] The Mg-only samples remained n-type up to 1100~ while the Mg samples co-implanted with P converted from n-top type after a 1050~ anneal. The effect of the P co-implantation may be explained by a reduction of N-vacancies, or an increase in Ga-vacancies, leading to a higher probability of Mg occupying a Ga-site. Co-implantation of P has also been shown to be effective in enhancing activation and reducing diffusion for p-type implantation in GaAs. [53][54][55]The ionization levels of implanted Mg has also been determined, from an Arrhenius plot of carrier density, to be 171 meV and is consistent with the value reported for epitaxial Mg-doped GaN.[35][4]
10 7
106
D
a- ~
10 5
104 600
unimplanted ~Mg "-II-- Mg+P(n) Mg+P(p) I
700
I
800
I
900
I
1000 1100 1200
annealing temperature (~ Figure 11. Sheet resistance versus annealing temperature for GaN either unimplanted or implanted with 24Mg (180 keV, 5 x 10TM cm-2) or 24Mg+alp (180 keV/250 keV, both 5 • 1014 cm2). The Mg+P implanted sample converts from n-to-p type after a 1050~ anneal while the Mg-only sample remains n-type even after a 1100~ anneal (after Ref. 27).
Since the ionization level of Mg in GaN is much greater than kT, less than 1% of the Mg-aeeeptors will be ionized at room temperature as described in Sect. 3.1. Therefore, it would be desirable to identify an aeceptor species with a smaller ionization energy. Since Ca has been
318
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
theoretically, suggested to be a shallow acceptor in GaN, ion implantation was used to determine the ionization energy of Ca in GaN.[5~ Figure 12 shows the evolution of sheet resistance versus the annealing temperature of Ca (180 keV, 5 x 1014 cm-2), Ca+P (180/130 keV, both 5 • 1014 cm-2), and unimplanted GaN. Both the Ca-only and the Ca+P samples converted from n-to-p type after a 1100~ anneal with a further increase in p-type conduction after a 1150~ anneal. The fact that P co-implantation is not required to achieve p-type conductivity with Ca can be understood based on the higher mass of the Ca-ion, as compared to Mg, generating more implantation damage and therefore more Ga-vacancies. This explanation is supported by the higher activation temperature required for conversion from n-to-p type for the Ca-implanted samples compared to the Mg+P implanted samples (1100 versus 1050~ The ionization level of Ca was estimated (from the Arrhenius plot shown in Fig. 13) to be 169 meV, which is equivalent to that of Mg.[ 5~ Although the ionization level of Ca is not smaller than that of Mg, Ca may be preferred for forming shallow implanted p-regions in GaN due to its heavier mass and resulting smaller projected range and straggle than Mg for a given energy.
107 _ ,
..... , . . . . .
, ....
, ....
, ....
10 6 n-to-p
V1 105 unimplanted ---{S}-Ca: n-type Ca+P: n-type Ca: p-type Ca+P: p-type
104
103 950 .
.
.
.
1
.
1000
,
,
~
I
.
1050
.
.
.
I
.
1100
.
.
.
I
.
1150
.
.
.
1200
annealing temperature (~
Figure 12.
Sheet resistance versus annealing temperature for GaN either unimplanted or implanted with 4~ (180 keV, 5 x 10 TMcm -2) or 4~ (180 keV/130 keV, both 5 x 10 TMcm2). The implanted samples convert from n-to-p type after a 1100~ anneal (after Ref. 47).
lonlmplantation 319
1013
'
.,
'
'
I
'
'
"
i
'
'
'
i
'
'
+--
0
o
1012 E = 169 meV
0
""'~
a
o O a= o o r ~lU
II
, , ,
2.8
I
3
,
,
,
I
,
,
,
3.2
,
. . . .
3.4
3.6
1000/T (K 1) Figure 13. Arrheniusplot of the sheet hole concentration for Ca-implanted(180 keV, 5 x 1014cm-2)GaN annealedat 1150~ The extractedionization level for Ca is 169 meV (after Ref. 47).
3.4
SiC
Although reports of implantation doping of SiC date back at least to 1969,[57]-[59] significant advances in understanding of implantation damage accumulation and dopant activation occurred with work by Edmond (circa 1988)on the use of elevated temperature implantation.[6~ The key result of Edmond's research was that elevated temperature implantation markedly enhanced activation of implanted dopants by limiting the buildup of implantation damage via in-situ annealing. This has led to elevated temperature implantation being widely employed for doping of SiC, as discussed in this section. Implantation of the most common donor species in SiC, N, will be presented first, followed by discussion of the most widely used p-type dopants, B and A1. Hiranoet al. reported on the activation of implanted N in 3C-SiC layers as a function of implant temperature and N-dose.[ 62]As seen in Fig. 14, for a sample annealed at 1200~ for 20 min (furnace anneal, FA), the electron concentration was significantly enhanced for N-implantation (N2 at 30 keV and a dose of 3 x 1015 cm -2) by implanting at 400~ as compared to 200~
320
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
(or at room temperature, RT). This effect was ascribed to less damage accumulation, which is supported by damage measurements by Rutherford Backscattering (RBS) discussed later in this chapter. Hirano also showed that there is a dose saturation level for activation near 3 x 1015cm -2 for their implantation conditions. For their conditions, they achieved an electron concentration near 5 x 1019 cm -3 as determined by C-V measurements. For room temperature (RT) N-implants Kimoto reported a minimum sheet resistance of 770 DJr'l (that corresponded with a saturation in N-donors) at a dose of 8 x 1014 c m -2 for furnace annealing at 1500~ 631Hirano also reported using 10 s, 1100~ rapid thermal annealing for both RT and 400~ implants. He reported an order-of-magnitude (to 1 x 1020 cm-3) increase in the electron concentration for the elevated temperature implant, as determined from C-V measurements.[ 62] Significantly, the RTA sample had a higher electron concentration than the 1200~ FA-sample implanted under the same conditions. The high concentration achieved for the RTA sample was reported to be near the highest n-type doping reported for implanted or epitaxial SiC at the time. The success using RTA processing and the resulting high doping level suggests this will be an effective process technology for device applications. 2
10
I
I I M P L A N T S "3.0 x 1015/cm 2 400~ O 9 ~ 200~ ~ 9 ~ 0 0 ~ 20min
f ~,
.
u
n 0~176176 o 0o00 o
r~
0 (:~
,
\ _ i 03,~
o
Z 101 " o a O
~SIMS
a
aa
"
A
,.-A
o
Oo0
A A
.o
%
0
:~
~"
.
U
9
.-
-
" -
-
g
1
~
-
"I
0
-
17 10 0
I 500 DEPTH
I 1000 (,~)
101 1500
Figure 14. Carrier concentration and mobility profiles for n-type layers formed in 3C-SiC by implanting 30 keV N 2 ions to a total dose of 3.0 x l 015 cm -2 at 200~ (triangles) and 400~ (circles) and by subsequent annealing at 1200~ for 20 min (after Ref. 62).
lon Implantation 321 J. N. Pan et al. also studied elevated temperature N-implantation in SiC and, in particular, the details of the annealing process.[641 As shown in Fig. 15, for implants performed at 650~ the optimum time for the anneal is a strong function of the anneal temperature. The minimum anneal time used in this study was 5 min and was limited by the furnace annealing apparatus. It is interesting to note, however, that the sheet resistance appears to have not yet reached a minimum value at 5 min for the 1200~ samples. This also suggests that a rapid thermal anneal (t < 60 s), as reported by Hirano, may be effective to activate these types of implants.
4000 ....... i ..... 0"
,
......
,._iii
_i.ii.i.
3000
........
C v >.,
.....
2000
]
[
a
o m
n" ,-.9 r O3
1000 900 800 700 ....................................................
60O
500
|
I
,
,
, ,
|l|'
io
,
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
]
ioo
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Iooo
.
.
.
.
Ioooo
Anneal Time (minutes)
Figure 15. Sheet resistivity as a function of anneal time for 900, 1050, and 1200~ anneal temperatures for N-implanted (3.8 x 1015cm-2at 30 keV plus 7.1 x 1015cm-2at 70 keV) 6HSiC (after Ref. 61). P-type implantation doping of SiC has been achieved with both B and A1. One of the early reports was for Al-implantation in n-type SiC by Gudkov.[ 65] Gudkov reported difficulty in maintaining the surface stoichiometry during the activation anneal, limiting the ability to quantify the acceptor activity. Rao made a significant contribution in this area by studying both A1 and B-implantation in 6H- and 3C-SiC. [66] Rao showed the importance of using elevated temperature implantation as developed by
322
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Edmond to achieve p-type activation. In this case, A1 was implanted at 850~ and annealed at 1400~ to produce p-type conductivity as determined by Hall and C-V measurements. These layers had--1% of the implanted Al-dose produce ionized acceptors at room temperature, due to the high ionization energy of A1 as discussed in See. 3.1. This means that 100% of the implanted A1 impurities occupied substitutional lattice sites. In this same study, p-type conductivity was not reported for B-implanted SiC. The lack of hole conduction for B was attributed to the still larger ionization energy of B in SiC, compared to A1, or a lack of suitable vacancies being formed during the implantation process for the B to occupy substitutional sites.[66] The difficulty in achieving p-type SiC by B-implantation was also reported by Kimoto, where B-implantation resulted in a highly resistive layer with an indeterminate carrier type. [67] In that same study, Kimoto was successful in producing p-type SiC with room temperature Al-implantation and annealing in an rf-induction furnace at 1500~ The apparent contradiction between Rao's report for the requirement for elevated temperature and that ofKimoto' s room temperature Al-implantation was postulated to be due to differences in the annealing dynamics between Rao's fiwnace anneal and Kimoto' s more rapid annealing scheme.[ 67] Finally, Rao has studied the effect of co-implantation of Si and C on the activation properties of Al-implanted 6H-SiC.[ 68]Co-implantation is often used in compound semiconductors to maintain the local crystal stoichiometry and promote the preferred site occupation of the implanted dopant.J53]-[55]In this case, the co-implantation of either Si or C did not enhance the formation of Al-acceptors. In fact, Si co-implantation resulted in highly resistive layers, either due to compensation by resulting carbon vacancies or other impurity/ defect complexes.[ 68]This area of co-implantation may warrant further study since there is often a dose dependence between the dopant and co-implantation species to achieve optimum electrical results.
3.5
Diamond
Diamond has long been identified as a promising semiconductor. However, its use has been limited by the inability to grow semiconductor grade synthetic diamond and by the difficulty in doping this very stable material. Ion implantation has been one of the most successful approaches to doping diamond due to the ability to create non-equilibrium defects during the bombardment process.j69][7~ A process described as cold-implantation-rapid annealing (CIRA) has been developed and applied to p-type,
Ion Implantation 323 boron doping. This involves implanting the sample at low temperature, typically liquid nitrogen temperature (77 K), to "freeze in" point defects that can then interact with dopant species during subsequent annealing. The annealing is done with a two step process, with a first anneal at ~1000~ and a second at ~1300~ 71] This approach has been successful in achieving p-type doping with a maximum hole mobility of 385 em2/Vs.[ 72] Successful boron doping has also been realized by combining the CIRA (77 K implantation and 1373 K rapid thermal annealing) process with carbon co-implantation.[73] In this study, the B-dose was varied between 1 and 10 x 1014c m "2 while the C-dose ranged from 3 to 20 x 1014 e m "2. The co-implanted sample with the optimum annealing sequence achieved a resistivity of 100 ~-cm with an estimated activation energy of conduction for boron of 0.1 eV. Optical data also support a high fraction of the boron being substitutional acceptors.[ 73] A second co-implantation approach to controlling the vacancy distribution and enhancing dopant activation is the use of a low dose preimplantation scheme that has been named "Low-Damage-Drive-In" Implantation (LODDI). In this approach, the non-dopant or co-implantation species creates the required defect distribution for the dopant atom. Although the annealing sequence depends on the dopant species employed, the key aspect in the process is the low dose required of the pre-implant. By combining He pre-implantation and various annealing steps with B-implantation, this approach produced a hole concentration of 4.0 x 1013 c m 2 and a low field mobility of 1953 c m E / V s . [69] Figure 16 shows results for a Hedamage implant (5 x 1010 cm -2) followed by a 600~ anneal, then an elevated temperature (400~ doping B-implant. During the B-implant, the B is thought to diffuse interstitially into the undamaged, underlying diamond layer. Finally, a carbon amorphizing implant is performed to allow a subsequent etch removal of the amorphous damaged region that is above the interstitially B-doped diamond. At this point, the diamond was subjected to a series of anneals at 1550~ Hall characterization of this sample gave a hole concentration of 4.0 x 1013 c m -3 with a low field mobility of 1953 cmE/Vs.[69] A similar approach for P-implantation in diamond using C as the damage implant species compared it to an Ar-implanted sample that should have the same damage profile. The results, shown in Fig. 17, demonstrated a lower resistivity for the P-implanted samples as compared to the Ar-sample, with the highest dose P-sample having the lowest resistivity. [69] The P-samples were implanted at 100 and 400~ at doses of 5 or 50 x 1016 cm -2 at each
324
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
temperature. The Ar-implant was implanted at the sample temperatures and a dose of 4.2 x 1016 cm -2 (the same damage profile as the lower dose P-sample should be evident).[ 69]The temperature variation of the resistance for these Pimplanted samples was indicative of a highly compensated, low density of dopant. The activation energy for conduction was estimated at 0.3 eV for a P-dose of 1 x 1016 cm -2 and 0.25 eV for a dose of 1 x 1017 cm -2 suggesting that the P ionization energy is not more than 0.25 eV below the conduction band.[ 69] Although this P-implantation doping result is encouraging, significantly more work is needed to understand the actual doping and conduction mechanisms resulting from this process.
6.5 o o
ffl
o
E
o
cO
o o
W
0 0
Z < I--
0
m_ 5.5
0 0
0
UJ
0 0 o
holes=4.0x1013
0 o
UJ LIJ 7"
cm-3
0
/
O0 ~
mobility = 1953 cm 2 N - s
o _J
4.5
9
1.6
I
2
I
2.4
I ,
2.8
!
3.2
INVERSE T E M P E R A T U R E (I 000/3)
Figure 16. Sheet resistance of a diamond layer doped by B ion implantation using the LODDI process. This layer had a room temperature Hall mobility of 1953 cm2/Vs (after Ref. 66).
Ion Implantation 325
15
A
o"
E tO
Argon ions "
o Z <: I-(/3
o
o
I'I!1
w
o
o
o
o
o
o
09 Ill
-r0o
O
13
Ill
O
O
O
0 O 0 0
oo
/
11
0
o
0
o
O
0
On no ++++
+
0
+ 4-
4-
+ +
m~ _ ~ + + + + + +C!1:11:3+ + +
OOO O 0
..J
P'\ Phosphorus ions
.
1.6
.
.
.
i
2
.
.
.
.
.
i
2.4
.
.
.
i
2.8
.
.
.
.
i
3.2
INVERSE TEMPERATURE (1000/T) Figure 17. Sheet resistance of diamond layers implanted with P or Ar using the LODDI process. The P-samples had two different doses (5 or 50 x 1016 cm -2) implanted at 100 and 400~ with the Ar-sample used as a control sample to compare conduction due to implantation damage to conduction due to P-doping (after Ref. 66).
4.0
IMPURITY REDISTRIBUTION
4.1
GaN
When applying ion implantation doping to device structures, it is important to know how the impurities redistribute during the activation anneal. Initial studies by Wilson and coworkers on the redistribution of implanted impurities in GaN was limited to temperatures up to "--800~ [74][75] That work showed negligible redistribution of all elements studied with the exception of S which had appreciable diffusion even at 600~ (see Fig. 18). When it became apparent, however, that temperatures of 1100~ or higher are required to achieve activated dopants in GaN, the question of redistribution
326
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
was revisited.[ 76] Figure 19 shows the Secondary Ion Mass Spectroscopy (SIMS) profile for 28Si in GaN as-implanted and annealed (1050~ Despite the interference in the mass 28 SIMS signal from 2SN2, the annealed Si profile demonstrates no measurable redistribution. Using a conservative estimate of 20 nm for the resolution of the SIMS measurement, an upper limit of 2.7 x 10 "13 cm/s can be set on the diffusivity of Si in GaN at 1050~ The redistribution of O has also been studied, as shown in Fig. 20. Here again, no measurable redistribution is seen and an upper limit of 2.7 x 10 -13 cm/s can be set on the diffusivity of O in GaN at 1125~
1020
,,
-
9425-26OO6
,
I
I
I
.
-
S in G a N 200 keV 1.0 x 10 TM cm -2 10 TM
A
?
E (.1
>. i-. z 1018
600~
UJ
t2
NO A N N E A L
=i
O
i.=
<
1017
10 TM 0.0
I
I
i
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
DEPTH (l~m)
Figure 18. SIMS profile of S-implanted (1 x 1014c m
after a 600~ anneal (after Ref. 71).
"2
at 200 keV) GaN as implanted and
lonlmplantation 327
1020 i
,
,
,
!
,
,
as implanted
,
- - "1050 ~ 019
~
10 Is
01: rr = lli 1017
"~ ~~' IIir
1016[i................... 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
depth (~tm) Figure 19. SIMS profile of 2gSi-implanted (100 keV, 5 x 1014 cm -2) GaN as-implanted and annealed at 1050~ for 15 s. No measurable redistribution is seen at the peak of the annealed sample (after Ref. 73).
1 0 20
~ . , , ..... /t~
9
~
,
.
!
,
,
,
|
9
,
,
as-implanted
. . . . . 1125 o ~ '1=
1019
0
~
10 Is
o 0
9
1017
1016 0
................... 0.2 0.4
0.6
0.8
depth (lain) Figure 20. SIMS profile of 180-implanted (70 keV, 5 x 10 TM cm "2) GaN as-implanted and annealed at 1125~ for 15 s. No measurable redistribution is seen at the peak of the annealed sample (after Ref. 47).
328
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
The lack of Si-redistribution at the implant activation temperature is consistent with the behavior of Si in other compound semiconductors; however, acceptor species are generally more susceptible to diffusion at high temperatures.[ 77] Figure 21 shows the SIMS profiles for Mg, asimplanted and after a 1150~ 15 s anneal. After annealing, the Mg-profile shows a slight movement towards the surface that is estimated to be 50 nm near the peak of the profile. Based on a 50 nm diffusion length and a 15 s anneal, an upper limit of 6.7 x 10-13 cm/s can be set on the diffusivity of Mg in GaN at 1150~ Profiles for Mg co-implanted with P demonstrated a similar amount of redistribution that is somewhat in contrast to the need for co-implantation to achieve acceptor activity. The Mg-only sample should have more Mg in non-active, interstitial sites that should act as fast diffusers as they do in other compound semiconductors.[ 54]This potential conflict has not yet been resolved, however, similar diffusion results have been reported for Mg co-implanted with P by Edwards, confirming the initial result.[ 78]
102 0
9 9 9, . . . . . . . . ,.7/~
~,
0 ~9
[ ~
9 9 . ,
9 , .'
as-implanted
[ ..... l lsO~
1 o
10Is ~D 0 O r ca
1017
1016
.................... 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
I
depth (l.tm)
Figure 21. SIMS profileof24Mg-implanted (100 keV, 5 x 1014 cm -2)G a N as-implanted and annealed at 1150~ for 15 s.The profilepeak shows an approximately 50 n m shifttowards the surface a1~erthe anneal (afterRef. 73).
Figures 22 and 23 show the SIMS profiles for as-implanted and annealed Be and Zn, respectively.[ 79]Zn has played a role as a color center in GaN LEDs, while Be may be of interest as an alternative acceptor
Ion Implantation 329 species.[5][8~ 831Neither Be nor Zn shows measurable redistribution after annealing, which suggests an upper limit of 2.7 x 10-13 cm/s for the diffusivity of Be and Zn in GaN at 1125~ Finally, as shown in Fig. 24, implanted Ca also shows no measurable redistribution even after a 1125 ~ anneal.[ 5~ This Ca result was confirmed by Edwards. [78] The lack of significant redistribution of all the acceptor and donor species studied suggests that ion implantation will be a viable technology for controllable doping of GaN. Furthermore, due to the lack of diffusion, external source diffusion appears not to be practical in GaN. It should also be noted that, with the exception of Be and to a lesser extent O, none of the as-implanted profiles had significant tailing due to channeling. Therefore, implantation of Si, Mg, Ca, and Zn in GaN can be used to define shallow, abrupt doping profiles. This is particularly important when these implants are applied to FET structures such as JFETs or MESFETs.[ 54][84]
10 20 . . . . . . .
, 9 9 9, . . . . . . as-implanted
1019 r o
~ 1018 t.J
o
~
101~
1016
9
0
.
.
!
0.2
,
.
,
i
0.4
.
,
,
|
,
.
0.6
.
|
0.8
9
9
9
1
depth (~tm)
Figure 22.
SIMS profile o f 9Be-implanted (45 keV, 5 x 10 TMcm -2) GaN as-implanted and annealed at 1125~ for 15 s. No measurable redistribution is seen at the peak of the annealed sample (after Ref. 79).
330
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
1020
9
,
9
i
,
,
+ 'N
9
I
9
9
9
i
,
9
9
i
,
,
[ __-~_..as-implantedl 125 ~
1019
o
~
1018
u Q
~
N
m
1017
|!
i
,, i
1016 0
................... 0.2 0.4
0.6
0.8
depth (~tm) Figure 23. SIMS profile of 64Zn-implanted (260 keV, 5 x 1014cm -2) GaN as-implanted and annealed at 1125~ for 15 s. No measurable redistribution is seen at the peak of the annealed sample (after Ref. 79).
1 0 20
9
,
, - T
- - , - - =
|
,
-.....
9
9
!
9
9
9
I
9
as-implanted 25 ~
o
1019 o
o
o o o
1018
1017 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 0.2 0.4 0.6
0.8
depth (j.tm) Figure 24. SIMS profile of 4~ (180 keV, 5 x 1014cm -2) GaN as-implanted and annealed at 1125~ for 15 s. The slight shift of the profile into the bulk for the annealed sample is within the resolution of the SIMS measurement and probably results from experimental variation in measuring the sputtered depth (after Ref. 47).
lon Implantation 331 4.2
SiC
Redistribution of implanted dopants in SiC has also been studied. Kimato reported SIMS profiles as shown in Figs. 25 and 26 for multiple energy A1 or B implants in 6H-SiC either as-implanted or annealed (1500~ 30 min).[ 67] This work supports the results of others that A1 and B display limited redistribution at 1500~ 681 Implanted N in SiC has also been shown to not significantly diffuse, up to 1500~ [63][85] However, in an earlier work, Ryu reported that both B and N started to diffuse towards the surface at 1600~ and diffused completely out of the sample during annealing at 1800~ 86]Ryu' s results were reported at a time (circa 1989) when the SiC material had large micropipe (vertical defects with hollow cores) densities that may have contributed to enhance diffusion. However, that work suggests that as implantation activation temperatures are pushed higher, impurity redistribution may become more significant.
""/U22E
1
1
I
I i
1 I
J I
I
1
!
AI + -~ 6 H - S i C 180keY, 2.7x1015cm -2 --= lOOkeV, 1.4x1015cm -2 = 50keV, 9.0x1014cm -2 -
1 0 21 _ r I
E 0 Z
020 ~ , , ~ ' ~ ..v
0
~
1019_ Z
I-Z LU
o10
18
Z
0 ~0._1017 <
"
annealed 9 (1500%) 1016..
0
Figure 25.
I
I
I
! I I l,. I I i 0.2 0.4 DEPTH (# m)
I
-
I.. I0.6
SIMS profiles for Al-implanted 6H-SiC at the conditions shown either asimplanted or after a 1500~ 30 s anneal (after Ref. 63).
332
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
10 ~
10 21 I
~ ' , ,
E
B + --* 6H-SiC 100keV, 2.8x1015e~n-2 -_ 60keV, 1.4x1015cm -2 30keV, 8.0• -2 "
o,~ 1020 z
0
e
1019 " I-Z LU 1018 = Z 0 0 1017: rn
1016~ 0
..-~ .=
...........
as-implanted 9
~
annealed (1500"C)
" 0.2
DEPTH
0.4
-
0.6
(/z m)
Figure 26. SIMS profiles for B-implanted 6H-SiC at the conditions shown either as
implanted or after a 1500~ 30 s anneal (after Ref. 63).
4.3
Diamond
Comprehensive results for the depth distribution and range parameters for a large number of elements implanted into single-crystal diamonds and chemically vapor-deposited polycrystalline diamond films have been reported.[ 87] No results were identified, however, for the redistribution of these impurities during annealing. Based on the nature of impurity redistribution in the other wide bandgap semiconductors discussed in this chapter which also have high bond energies, redistribution of impurities in diamond can be expected to be very low. This is supported by the lack of success in external source diffusion in diamond.[ 69][7~
lon Implantation 333 5.0
I M P L A N T A T I O N D A M A G E : C R E A T I O N AND REMOVAL
During the ion implantation process, damage is introduced into the semiconductor crystal via electronic and nuclear interactions. Typically, this damage is largely removed during the implant activation annealing process. However, if the amount of damage is sufficient to amorphize the semiconductor, complete recovery of the crystal lattice is often not possible. This is particularly true for compound semiconductors such as GaAs and InP where amorphization must be avoided if electrical activity of implanted dopants is desired.[ 88]Therefore, it is important to determine the implantation conditions that amorphize the wide bandgap semiconductors.
5.1
GaN
The first work on implantation induced damage in GaN was reported by Tan and eoworkers for 90 keV Si-implantation at 77 K.[89]Implantation at low temperatures limits the dynamic annealing that can occur and tends to produce amorphization at a lower dose than if the sample was at room temperature. That is, from an amorphization perspective, low temperature implantation represents a worst ease scenario. As shown in Fig. 27, Tan and coworkers demonstrated that at 77 K, even for a high dose of 7.2 • 1015 cm -2, the GaN sample was not amorphized while a GaAs sample, also implanted at 77 K, was amorphized at a dose two orders-of-magnitude lower (8 x 1013cm-2).[9~ This result suggests that ion implantation can be used to achieve very high Sidoping levels in GaN, since this dose corresponds to an estimated peak Si concentration of--5 x 1020em -3 without the sample being amorphized. Such high doping levels can be expected since epitaxial Si-doping of GaN has achieved donor concentrations in excess of 1020 cm-3.[47][91]In fact, recent results for high-dose (1 x 1016 cm -2) Si-implantation in GaN have demonstrated that such high donor levels are achievable with implantation.j92][ 93J While the high amorphization level of GaN is encouraging, the study of damage removal during annealing must also be addressed. Figure 28 shows RBS spectra for Si-implanted GaN, now implanted at room temperature, either as-implanted or after a 1100~ 30 s anneal. Although there is a reduction in the backseattering yield after annealing that might be construed as a reduction in the damage created by the implantation, when changes in surface dechanneling are accounted for, no measurable
334
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
decrease in the buried damage level occurred due to the anneal.[ 94] This suggests that higher annealing temperatures may be needed to optimize the electrical transport in the implanted layer.[ 95]However, it has also been shown that complete removal of the implant damage in GaN is not a requirement for successful activation of the implanted dopants, although further damage reduction may be needed to optimize the transport properties of the implanted layer.[ 95]This is in contrast to other compound semiconductors where damage removal and dopant activation are serial processes.[ 96]
60
1
-
50 "0 I,,,=,,I o
40
"0 o N
30
ot,~l
E ~O
~_, ~(,4k,=
I
unimplanted
I
-" 7.2x10 ~s cm "a
[~ 8.4xl 014 cm-2 ~ 2.4xl 018 cm-2 ] --~--2.2x1015 cm "2 --xT-- rand~
20 10
0.5
1
1.5
2
energy (MeV)
Figure 27. Ion channeling spectra (2 meV He+ ions) illustrating the build up of disorder in 90 keV Si-implanted GaN at 77 K. The dose for each spectra is shown in the legend (after Ref. 90).
5.2
SiC
Significant work has been done on implantation-induced damage in SiC. Some of the early work focused on how implantation could be used to alter the mechanical properties ofSiC.[97][98] Willams showed that SiC was amorphized by a Cr-implant dose of 2.9 x 1014 cm -2 at 260 keV, while lighter N-ions required a dose of 2.7 x 1015 cm-2 at 62 keV to achieve a similar damage level.[ 97] In that work, it was also reported that SiC swells when amorphized with step heights on-the-order-of 50 nm for a N-dose of
Ion Implantation 335 --2 x 1016 c m -2. Interestingly, the step height was not linear with dose but displayed a dramatic step near the crystalline-to-amorphous dose regime. The authors attributed these results to in-situ annealing during the implant, making the damage unstable during bombardment until the amorphous zone was formed. Dose levels for amorphization were also established for 100 keV Ar (4 x 1014 c m -2) and Xe (~8 x 1013 c m -2) implants and are consistent with the Cr and N results based on the atomic mass of these ions. [99]
60
.
.
.
.
I
~i~
'
'
'
i
'
'
'
I
.
.
.
.
~ unimplanted --'~-- 6x 10 ~5 cm2: as implanted _-l~6x 1015 cm2:1100 ~ 30 s
50 40 N
30
@
20
9 !,,,~
10 0
_
,m
t
0
0.5
1
1.5
energy (MeV) Figure 28. Channeling Rutherford Backseattering (C-RBS) spectra for as-grown (random and aligned, unimplanted) and Si-implanted (90 keV, 6 x 10 Is cm -2) GaN (as-implanted and after a 1100~ 30 s anneal). The implants were performed at room temperature (after Ref. 92).
More recent work examined the damage build-up during the implantation of dopant species in SiC. Chechenin and coworkers reported RBS spectra for room temperature Al-implanted SiC versus dose at 40 keV.[ 1~176 They found the formation of an amorphous region for a dose of 1 x 1015cm-2 (as shown in Fig. 29) with damage below the amorphous regime being effectively removed by annealing at-1800~ for 5 s at 5 atm of Ar. Kimoto et al. reported room temperature implants of A1 and B into 6H-SiC with amorphization levels of 1 and 5 x 1015 cm -2, respectively, for multiple implant energies from 30-180 keV.[ 67]P-type conductivity was measured
336
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
for the Al-implanted material with a resistivity of 22 kDJ while B-implanted materials had high resistivity that made carrier type identification difficult. The difficulties with B may be due to its high ionization energy as discussed in Sects. 3.1 and 3.4.
321 '
1
I
1
2~
!
AI
R7 R6 j
o
"-9 16 I--
0
~
(
~,5
o
i..l,a
A/+
0 50
100
150
200
250
CHANNEL NUMBER Figure 29. The aligned (A1-A6) and random (R6,R7) C-RBS spectra of unimplanted (A1, R7) and 90 keV Al-implanted SiC with doses of 3 x l013 (A2), 1 x 1014 (A3), 3 x 1014(A4), 1 x 1015 (A5), and 3 x l016 (A6, R6) cm-2 (after Ref. 100).
Although there has been success using room temperature implantation and very high annealing temperatures, significant efforts have focused on the use of elevated temperature implants in SiC to limit the damage accumulation and promote impurity activation. Some of the first work in this area was reported by Edmond, as discussed previously in the doping Sect. 3.4, and been further developed by Rao .[6~ Figure 30 shows RBS spectra from Rao for Al-implanted (200 keV, 8 x 1014 cm -2) SiC done at 850~
Ion Implantation 337 as-implanted and after annealing at 1100 or 1400~ [66]Samples implanted at the same dose and energy, but at room temperature, were amorphous and did not recover their initial crystallinity after annealing at 1400~ However, as seen in Fig. 30, the elevated temperature sample was not amorphizcd for this dose and approached the virgin channeling yield after annealing at 1400~ In this study, p-type conductivity was only achieved for the elevated temperature implanted A1 sample and not for those implanted at room temperature. The lack of p-type conductivity in the room temperature samples was attributed to residual implantation damage compensating the Al-acceptors.[ 66]
DEPTH (microns) 1.25
10 a
1.00
0.75
0.50
AI+(200 keV, 8xl0Zac'm-Z, 850~
0.25
0.00
SiC b u l k RANDOM
m
v
102
6 +..
',
10 l
++ 4~" 9
~ +
l 10 o
L
AS-IMPIANTED ANNEALED ! 400oc
* ANNEALED ll00~ i
0.4
I
I
0.6
I
|
I
I
0.B
1.0
1.2
SCATTERED ENERGY (MeV) Figure 30. C-RBS spectra for Al-implanted (200 keV, 8 x 1014cm "2) 6H-SiC performed at
850~ before and after annealing at the temperatures shown (after Ref. 66).
338 5.3
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors Diamond
Ion-beam-induced amorphization of diamond, followed by annealing, has been shown to form a graphite region.[ 1~ Although the amorphous layer can be used as a preferential etching layer (the amorphous layer etches more rapidly than the crystalline diamond), when implantation doping is desirable, amorphization should be avoided. Several reports exist on the dose and energy threshold for amorphization as summarized in Table 4.[101 ]-[105]T h e authors pointed out that the amorphization level depends on the nuclear stopping (S~); and that the product of the critical dose and the nuclear stopping was roughly constant between -~2 and 4 eV i o r g ~ 3 . [101]
Table 4. List of Critical Doses to Amorphize Diamond (after Ref. 101).
Ion
Energy (keV)
Critical Dose, ( D o) (ion/cm 2)
Nuclear energy loss,
Electronic energy loss,
(ev/A)
(s~ (ev/A)
DcSn
Reference
76.7
2.0
98
100
2.5 x 1015
Ar
40
3.7 x 1014
117.1
63.6
4.3
99
Sb
340
1.0 x 10 TM
341.2
135.8
3.41
100
Xe
320
2.0 x 1014
132
370
2.64
101
C
6.0
8.1
DEVICE D E M O N S T R A T I O N S
With the advances in the science and technology of ion implantation in the wide bandgap semiconductors discussed in the previous sections, implantation is now finding application in electronic devices. In this section, key device demonstrations in each material system that employ ion implantation are presented. These results demonstrate the true utility of implantation but are by no means to be considered exhaustive in their scope. Future devices will most likely make even more use of implantation doping to realize more advanced device structures.
lon Implantation 339 6.1
GaN
The first GaN-based devices to use ion implantation were transistors that incorporated implant isolation. This was first done with H-implantation and later with He.[9][29] Such implant isolation allows planar device topologies which facilitates device interconnection and circuit fabrication. More advanced implanted devices have also been demonstrated, with all doping done by implantation in a GaN junction field effect transistor (JFET).[ 111Figure 31 shows a schematic representation of the process flow used to fabricate the GaN JFET in semi-insulating GaN grown by metal organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD) on (1000) A1203 .[1~ The key processing steps are as follows: 1. Selective area ion implantation of the n-channel (28Si: 100 keV, 2 x 1014cm-2) and p-gate 4~ (40 keV, 5 x 1014cm-2) 2. Sputter deposition of 300 nm of W gate contact metal 3. Reactive ion etching (RIE) gate contact patteming using an SF 6/Ar plasma 4. Selective area, non-self-aligned 28Si ion implantation of the source and drain regions 5. A 1150~ 15 s rapid thermal anneal to activate the implanted dopants 6. Electron cyclotron resonant (ECR)-plasma etching of ~50 nm of p-GaN from the source and drain regions using a BC13/H2/Ar chemistry [1~ 7. Deposition of Ti/A1 (20 nm/200 nm) ohmic metal 8. 500~
15 s ohmic alloy
This structure minimizes the gate capacitances often associated with JFETs by self-aligning the p-type gate to the gate contact metal.[ 1~ In addition, since the doping was done in selective areas, device isolation was realized via the semi-insulating properties of the GaN substrate. That is, no implant isolation or mesa etch isolation was required to isolate these devices. Figure 32 shows the Ios versus Vos curves for varied gate biases for a ~1.7 ktm x 50 ~tm CmN JFET with a 4 ~tm source-to-&ain spacing. The JFEF demonstrates good modulation characteristics with nearly complete pinch-off at a threshold voltage of approximately -6 V for Vos=--7V. For Vos= 25 V, a maximum transconductance of 7 mS/mm was measured at Vcs = -2.0 V with a saturation current of 33 mA/mm at VGS= 0 V. Four-probe measurements of
340
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
the source resistance gave R s ~ 500 f~. Although this value o f R s is extremely large, it only accounts for a 20% reduction in the external transconductance with respect to a corrected internal transconductance of 8.5 mS/mm. This high resistance is attributed to the region between the ohmic contact and the channel. Transmission line method (TLM) test structures using the same source and drain implants on C_mNwitness pieces gave a value of the specific contact resistance of -~1 x 10.5 f~-cm2 (-~1 ~')-mm). [77]This access resistance can be substantially reduced by optimizing the source and drain implant and anneal conditions as well as by self-aligning these implants to the gate contact metal. A second possible cause of the low transconductance is low electron mobility in the implanted channel region. If this is the case, optimization of the implant activation process should lead to improved mobilities. In addition, optimization of the epitaxial GaN layers for maximum electron mobility, as has been done for epitaxial FETs, should result in improved JFET performance.[ 1~ This device demonstrated a unity current gain cutoff frequency 0rt) of 2.7 GHz and a maximum oscillation frequency (fm~) of 9.4 GHz. These frequency metrics are comparable to similar gate length epitaxial GaN transistors.[~ ~0] photoresist (a)
n-channeland
28Si + 40Ca
~//~/~ I I.I, I~_.///'~ undoped GaN
(b)
28Si
gate contactdepostionand~_~ definition, ~ source and drain implants, and RTA
n-type
P"~Ype 28Si ~$
~.~ n+ source or drain n-type channel
gate contact (c) plasma etch of p-type GaN from source and drain regions
~ ~ N ~ \ \ \ \p'typr \~
n+ source or drain
n-type channel gate contact \ p-type (d) T~;A! % . 7 Ti/gi ohmic contact deposition ~ ~ , ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ (e.g. Ti/AI) and alloy ~
r--
",,,---
n+ source
ordrain
n-type channel
Figure 31. Schematic representation of the processing steps for fabricating an all ion implanted GaN .fF'ET(after Ref. 44).
lon Implantation 341
30
............................................................................................................................. i................................... i i ~ i
~
!
i
:.
15 10
..........
i
~
j
i
.
~. . . . . . .
i ................
t .....................................
!..............................
.
5 0
0
5
10
15
20
25
VDS (V) Figure 32. Ios versus Vos for a - - 1 . 7 lxm x 50 ~tm G a N JFET. Gate bias starts at 0 V with - 1 V steps (after Ref. 11).
6.2
SiC
Significant progress has been made in the use of implantation in SiC devices. First among these are implanted diodes which were reported by Marsh and Dunlap in 1970.[ 58] Marsh implanted N into Al-doped bulk crystal and achieved rectifying characteristics after annealing at 1100~ that were consistent with a p-i-n structure. The diode behavior was enhanced by higher temperature annealing (up to 1500~ with the reduction of the thickness of the intrinsic layer. Vodakov et al. were also successful in diode fabrication by implanting A1 at room temperature into unintentionally doped n-type SiC and realized mesa diodes with breakdown voltages (defined a t / = 1 ~tA) up to 280 V.[ 111] Edmond reported the use of elevated temperature (600~ implants of A1 into n-type 3C-SiC and N into p-type SiC to achieve diodes with capacitance/voltage characteristics indicative of abrupt junctions.[ 112]The samples were annealed at 1200~ for 30 min. The diodes maintained rectifying properties to 400~ but showed evidence of trap assisted conduction. Improved implanted diode behavior was reported by Ghezzo for both polarities (N-implanted into p-SiC and B-implanted into n-SiC).[ 113][114]
342
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
For N-implanted diodes, a minimum sheet resistance was achieved for an implantation temperature of 1000~ and an anneal temperature of 1300~ The diodes had leakage currents < 100 nA/cm 2 and room temperature reverse breakdown voltages of 95 V.[ zz3] The 1000~ B-implanted diodes were annealed at 1200~ for 5 hrs and had very low leakage currents (4 nA/cm 2) with a reverse breakdown voltage of 650 V at 10 mA for a 2x2 mm 2 diode. A schematic of an implanted SiC MESFET fabricated by Lam is shown in Fig. 33.[ 4o] This device makes use of elevated temperature (650~ N-implantation to form n+-source and drain regions. Vanadium, which acts as a compensating deep level in SiC, was also implanted to form high resistivity regions outside the active transistor area. The transistor DC characteristics are shown in Fig.. 34 for a 5 pm x 150 pm device. The low knee voltage in Fig. 34 is largely the result of the high source and drain doping achieved with the N-implantation. This work is an extension of earlier work by this group on implanted SiC nMOS devices.[ 115]The diode and transistor results just discussed, clearly demonstrate the utility of implantation doping in SiC and should lead to more advanced device structures (such as thyristors) being realized with implanted dopants. Ni interconnect VG
VS
Ni Schottky VG
b,\\'q
~
K'~ _ k\\\X\\'q
doped
(a)
N+
N-
Ni ohmic VD
N
V
P SiC (5xlO15cm"3)
Ni Schottky Gate
lx\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'~\\\\\\'q
.. (b)
)v
P SiC (5x1015cm "3) P+ SiC (1.7xl01ecm "3)
AI ohmic
Figure 33. Cross-section along the channel length (a) and along the channel width (b) of a SiC MESFET that employed N-implantation for source and drain formation and Vimplantation for isolation (after Ref 40).
Ion Implantation
250 2 2~
343
Vo.~
W=12011m, L=51~m
"-'200
150
100
a
50 ~ 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
p1.0V 70
80
Drain Voltage (V)
Figure34. los versus lidsfor a 5 ~tmx 120 ~tmSiC MESFET shown schematicallyin Fig 33. Gate bias starts at 1.0 V with -0.5 V steps (after Ref. 40).
6.3
Diamond
Although there remain many issues in material quality and controllable doping of diamond, some preliminary devices have been demonstrated using ion implantation. Figure 35 shows the current/voltage characteristics of a diamond diode formed by ion implanting carbon to form a n-type damage layer in naturally p-type diamond.[7~ 1161The data shown in Fig. 35 show results for two different implantation processes. Diode 1 was implanted with a target temperature of 300~ while diode 2 was formed using the CIRA process (77 K implant followed by a 1200~ anneal) outlined previously in Sect. 3.5. Diode 2 demonstrated a significant decrease in the forward on resistance with a voltage drop of only 4 V for a forward current of 1.5 mA as opposed to ~9 V for the same current in diode 1. Diode 2 also had a reduced reverse current that is ascribed to an improved defect structure resulting from the CIRA process. Furthermore, diode 2 also demonstrated stronger luminescence in the blue region of the spectrum than diode 1, as shown in Fig. 36.[7~ 116]Blue emission from a diode in a semiconductor with a bandgap of 5.45 eV is most likely due to a donor/acceptor recombination process or other defect mitigated recombination. A diamond bipolar transistor was demonstrated for the first time in 1982 and used C-implantation at 320~ to form the emitter and collector in p-type type IIb diamond.[ 1171Transistor action was achieved as shown in
344
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
Fig. 37. The high collector/emitter turn-on voltage of~l 0 V required to reach the linear portion of the transistor's curves was attributed to high contact resistance.j70][116] Significant improvements in device operation were predicted if the advanced implanted schemes described in this chapter are employed along with improved ohmic contacts on a more optimum device design.
1.5'
< E
1.0
Z UJ n" rr
iiiIII 0.5
,'k / DIODE 1
ii I _
-8
-4
0
4
8
POTENTIAL (VOLT)
Figure 35. Current versus voltagefor diodes in type IIb diamond formed by implantation at 300~ (diode 1) and with the CIRA process (diode 2) (afterRefi 116).
The first diamond field effect transistor to employ ion implantation was reported in 1991 by Zeisse and coworkers.[ lls] This device used multiple energy B-implantation at 80 K into natural type IIa diamond to form the channel and contact regions. The implants were annealed at 1263 K. A SiO 2 gate insulator was deposited by indirect plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition upon which a Ti/Au gate electrode was defined by liftoff. The transistor was configured in a concentric ring geometry (a gate ring between the source and drain rings) so that no lateral isolation was required. Saturation and pinchoff were observed with a transconductance of 3.9 ~S/mm. These diamond device results are encouraging with improved device performance expected as further advances in implantation and material technology occur.
lon Implantation 345
lODE 2
m
03
Z iii
I-Z
1
iii
III
217
2.3
3'.1
3.s
PHOTON ENERGY (eV)
Figure 36. Photoluminescence spectra from the same diodes as in Fig. 35. Diode 1 was pulsed at a forward bias of 80 V while diode 2 was operated under a constant bias of 20 V (after Ref. 116).
0.6
IB=5mA
< E z uJ nIT" 0 nO F0 UJ -J .J
~
IB=4mA
0.4
~
IB=3mA IB=2mA
0.2 _
~
IB--lmA
0 o
IB=0mA 20
40
60
80
COLLECTOR-EMITTER- POTENTIAL.(Volt) Figure 37. Collector current (lc) versus collector-emitter voltage (Vce,) for the base current (I~ levels shown for a lateral n-p-n transistor in type lib diamond fabricated with carbonion implantation (after Ref. 117).
346 7.0
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors F U T U R E W O R K AND C O N C L U S I O N S
Although significant progress has been reported for ion implantation doping and isolation of wide bandgap semiconductors, there are still many areas for further research. Areas of interest for implantation doping in GaN include determining the maximum attainable doping levels for various elements, optimizing the activation annealing process to maximize dopant activation and minimize surface degradation, and understanding of the dynamics of the defect generation and removal process. Areas of interest for implant isolation in GaN include the demonstration of truly thermally stable isolation, understanding the nature of hydrogen implant isolation, determination of the behavior of deep levels such as Cr and Fe, and the effect of implant isolation on the properties of waveguide losses. For SiC implantation, continued work is needed to better understand the trade-off between implantation temperature and the activation annealing process. The maximum doping levels should also be more clearly defined and alternative dopants, particularly for acceptors, should be considered. More work is need to optimize implantation isolation in SiC either with a deep impurity such as vanadium or with a damage related energy level. Diamond implantation has the farthest to come of these wide bandgap semiconductors. This is largely due to the metastable nature of the diamond/graphite phases which can be created by the implantation and annealing process. Continued studies of the implantation induced defects in diamond are important, along with exploring novel co-implantation or predamage techniques. While implantation in the wide bandgap semiconductors is far from a mature technology, it also may be the only way to achieve external doping (either of a blanket or selective area nature), due to the low diffusivities of impurities in these materials. Moreover, if the success of implantation in silicon and gallium arsenide technologies is any guide, the possibilities are extensive for the application of ion implantation to devices in the wide bandgap materials. Therefore, continued development of this technology can be expected to yield significant device improvements.
Ionlmplantation
347
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The author would like to thank his collaborators on various aspects of this work, including: C. R. Abemathy, J. Avery, A. G. Baca, M. Hagerott Crawford, J. Escobedo, G. Lopez, S. J. Pearton, R. J. Shul, R. A. Stall, H. H. Tan, J. S. Williams, and R. G. Wilson. Additional thanks is due to colleagues who supplied reprints and figures including: R. F. Davis, M. Melloch, J. F. Prins, M. V. Rao, and R. G. Wilson. Sandia is a multiprogram laboratory operated by Sandia Corporation, a Lockheed Martin Company, for the United States Department of Energy under contract #DE-ACO4-94AL85000.
REFERENCES 1. Yoder, M. N., IEEE Trans. Elec. Dev., 43:1633 (1996) 2. Davis, R. F., Special Issue on Large Bandgap Electronic Materials and Components, Proceed. IEEE, vol. 79 (1991) 3. Morkoc, H., Strite, S., Gao, G. B., Lin, M. E., Sverdlov, B., and Bums, M., J. Appl. Phys., 76:1363 (1994) 4. Akasaki, I., Amano, H., Kito, M., and Hiramatsu, K., J. Lumin., 48/49:666 (1991) 5. Nakamura, S., Mukai, T., and Senoh, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 64:1687 (1994) 6. Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahama, S., Yamada, T., Matsushita, T., Kiyoku, H., and Sugimoto, Y., Jap. ,I. Appl. Phys., 35 :L74 (1996) 7. Nakamura, S., Senoh, M., Nagahama, S., Iwasa, N., Yamada, T., Matsushita, T., Sugimoto, Y., and Kiyoku, H.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:1477 (1996) 8. Nakamura, S., MRS Bulletin, 22:29 (1997) 9. Khan, M. A., Bhattarai, A., Kuznia, J. N., and Olson, D. T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:1214 (1993) 10. Binari, S. C., Rowland, L. B., Kruppa, W., Kelner, G., Doverspike, K., and Gaskill, D. K., Elect. Lett., 30:1248 (1994) 11. Zolper, J. C., Shul, R. J., Baca, A. G., Wilson, R. G., Pearton, S. J., and Stall, R. A., Appl. Phys. Letts., 68:2273 (1996) 12. Shur, M. S., and Khan, M. A., MRS Bulletin, 22:44 (1997) 13. Weitzel, C. E., Palmour, J. W., Carter, C. H., Jr., Moore, K., Nordquist, K. J., Allen, S., Thero, C., and Bhatnagar, M., IEEE Trans. Elec. Dev., 43:1732 (1996) 14. Neudeck, P. H., J. Electron. Mater., 24:283 (1995)
348
WideBandgap Semiconductors
15. Casady, J. B., and Johnson, R.. W., Solid-State Electronics, 39:1409 (1996) 16. Capano, M.A., andTrew, R. J.,MRS Bulletin, 22:19 (1997) 17. Trew, R. J., Yan, J. B, and Mock, P. M.,Proceed. IEEE, 79:598 (1991) 18. Some examples of implantation in wide bandgap II-VI semiconductors can be found in: Wilson, R. G., Solid-State Electronics, 39:1113 (1996); Sigmon, T. W., Nucl. Instr. Meth. Phys. Res. B, 7/8:402 (1985); Khalal, K., Chami, A. C., Ligeon, E., Fontenille, J., Hamoudi, A., Berard, G., and Cibert, J., 3`. Appl. Phys., 78:37096 (1995) 19. See for example: Ziegler, J. F., Handbook of Ion Implantation Technology, Elsevier Science Publishers, The Netherlands, pp. 271-362 (1992); Ghandhi, S. K., VLSI Fabrication Principles: Silicon and Gallium Arsenide, Ch. 6, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY, (1983) 20. Pearton, S. J., Mat. Sci. Rep., 4:313 (1991) 21. Orenstein, M., Stoffel, N. G., Von Lehmen, A. C., Harbiunson, J. P., and Florez, L. T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59:31 (1991) 22. Lear, K. L., Schneider, R. P., Choquette, K. D., Kilcoyne, S. P., Figiel, J. J., and Zolper, J. C., IEEE Photonic Tech. Lett., 6:1053 (1994) 23. Zolper, J. C., Baca, A. G., and Chalmers, S. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 62:2536 (1993) 24. Pearton, S. J., Iannuzzi, M. P., Reynolds, C. L., Jr., and Peticolas, L, Appl. Phys. Lett., 52:395 (1988) 25. Zolper, J. C., Sherwin, M. E., Baca, A. G., and Schneider, R. P., Jr., J. Elec. Mat., 24:21 (1995) 26. Khan, M. A., Skogman, R. A., Schulze, R. G., and Gershenzon, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 42:430 (1983) 27. Khan, M. A., Skogman, R. A., Schulze, R. G., and Gershenzon, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 43:492 (1983). 28. Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Vartuli, C. B., Zolper, J. C., Yuan, C., and Stall, R. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 67:1435 (1995) 29. Binari, S. C., Dietrich, H. B., Kelner, G., Rowland, L. B., Doverspike, K., and Wickenden, D. K., J. Appl. Phys., 78:3008 (1995) 30. Haase, D., Schmid, M., Kurner, W., Dornen, A., Harle, V., Scholz, F., Burkard, M., and Schweizer, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:2525 (1996) 31. Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Wisk, P. W., Hobson, W. S., and Ren, F., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:1143 (1993) 32. Zolper, J. C., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., and Vartuli, C. B., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:3042 (1995) 33. Pearton, S. J., Abernathy, C. R., Panish, M. B., Hamm, R. A., and Lunardi, L. M., 3". Appl. Phys., 66:656 (1989)
Ion Implantation 349 34. Zolper, J. C., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., and Vartuli, C. B., Conf. Proc. MRS Spring Meeting 1995, Symposium B, p. 485, Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA, (1995) 35. Zolper, J. C., Crawford, M. H., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Vartuli, C. B., Yuan, C., and Stall, R. A., J. Electron. Mat., 25:839 (1996) 36. Nadella, R. V., and Capano, M. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 70:886 (1997) 37. Hobgood, H. M., Glass, R. C., Augustine, G., Hopkins, R. H., Jenny, J. R., Skowronski, M., Mitchel, W. C., and Roth, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:1364 (1995) 38. Jenny, J. R., Skowronski, M., Mitchel, W. C., Hobgood, H. M., Glass, R. C., Augustine, G., and Hopkins, R. H., J. Appl. Phys., 78:3839 (1995) 39. Kimoto, T., Naklima, T., Matsunami, H., Nakata, T., and Inoue, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:1113 (1996) 40. Lam, M. P., Komegay, K. T., Cooper, J. A., Jr., and Melloch, M. R., IEEE Trans. Elec. Dev., 44:907 (1997) 41. Kalish, R., Uzan-Sagay, C., Philosoph, B., Richter, V., and Prawer, S., Appl. Phys. Lett., 70:999 (1997) 42. Prins, J. F., Phys. Rev. B, 44:2470 (1991) 43. Sze, S. M., Physics of Semiconductor Devices, 2nd Ed., pp. 17-24, John Wiley, New York, NY, (1981) 44. Zolper, J. C., and Shul, R. J., MRS Bulletin, 22:36 (1997) 45. Pankove, J. I., and Hutchby, J. A., J. Appl. Phys., 47:5387 (1976) 46. Pankove, J. I., and Hutchby, J. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 24:281 (1974) 47. Kim, J. G., Frenkel, A. C., Liu, H., and Park, R. M.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 65:91 (1994) 48. Cummings, K. D., Pearton, S. J., and Vella-Coleiro, G. P., J. Appl. Phys., 60:166 (1986); Hiramoto, T., Saito, T., and Ikoma, T., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 24:193 (1985); Barrett, N. J., Grange, J. D., Sealy, B. J., and Stephens, K. G., J. Appl., Phys., 56:3503 (1984); Kular, S. S., Sealy, B. J., Ono, Y., and Stephens, K. G., Solid-State Elec., 27:83 (1984); Pearton, S. J., Williams, J. S., Short, K. T., Johnson, S. T., Jacobsen, D. C., Poate, J. M., Gibson, J. M., and Boerma, D. 0., J. Appl. Phys., 65:1089 (1989) 49. Tan, T. Y., and Gosele, U.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 52"1240 (1988) 50. Zolper, J. C., Wilson, R. G., Pearton, S. J., and Stall, R. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68:1945 (1996) 51. Chung, B.C., and Gershenzon, M., J. Appl. Phys., 72:651 (1992) 52. Sato, H., Minami, T., Yamada, E., Ishii, M., and Takata, S., J. Appl. Phys., 75:1405 (1994) 53. Patel, K. K., and Sealy, B. J. Appl. Phys. Lett., 48:1467 (1986)
350
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
54. Sherwin, M. E., Zolper, J. C., Baca, A. G., Drummond, T. J., Shul, R. J., Howard, A. J., Rieger, D. J., Schneider, R. P., and Klem, J. F., J. Elec. Mater., 15:809 (1994) 55. Zolper, J. C., Baca, A. G., Sherwin, M. E., and Shul, R. J., Electron. Letts., 31:923 (1995) 56. 57. 58. 59.
60.
61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69.
70. 71. 72. 73.
Strite, S.,Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 33:L699 (1994) Dunlap, H. L., and Marsch, O. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 15:311 (1969) Marsh, O. J., and Dunlap, H. L., Rad. Effects, 6:301 (1970) Marsh, O. J.,Silicon Carbide 1973, p. 471, (R. C Marschall, J. W. Faust, Jr., and C. E. Ryans, eds.), University of South Carolina Press, Columbia, SC (1974) Edmond, J. A., Withrow, S. P., Wadlin, W., and Davis, R. F., Conf. Proc. Mater. Res. Soc., 77:193, (J. Dow, T. K. Schuller, and J. Hillard, eds.), Material Research Society, Pittsburgh PA (1987) Edmond, J. A., Davis, R. F., and Withrow, S. P., Ceramic Transactions, 2:479 (1989) Hirano, Y., and Inada, T., J. Appl. Phys., 77:1020 (1995) Kimoto, T., Itoh, A., Matsunami, H., Nakata, T., and Watanabe, M., J. Electron. Mat., 24:235 (1995) Pan, J. N., Cooper, J. A., Jr., and Melloch, M. R., J. Electron. Mat., 26:208 (1997) Gudkov, V. A., Krysov, G. A., and Makarov, V. V., Soy. Phys. Semicond., 20:105 (1986) Rao, M. V., Griffiths, P., Holland, O. W., Kelner, G., Freitas, J. A., Jr., Simons, D. S., and Chi, P. H., J. Appl. Phys., 77:2479 (1995) Kimoto, T., Itoh, A., Matsunami, H., Nakata, T., and Watanabe, M., J. Electron. Mat., 25:879 (1996) Rao, M. V., Griffiths, P., Gardner, J., Holland, O. W., Ghezzo, M., Kretchmer, J., Kelner, G., and Freitas, J. A., Jr, J. Electron. Mat., 25:75 (1996) Prins, J. F., "Application of Diamond Films in Electronics," in: "The Physics of Diamond," Proceedings of the International School of Physics, Enrico Fermi, Varenna, 1996, Course CXXXV, IOS Press, Amsterdam (1997) Prins, J. F., Mat. Sci. Rep., 7:271 (1992) Prins, J. F., Phys. Rev. B, 38:5576 (1998) Fontaine, F., Uzan-Saguy, C., Philosoph, B., and Kalish, R., Appl. Phys. Lett., 68:2264 (1996) Sandhu, G. S., Swanson, M. L., and Chu, W. K., Appl. Phys. Lett., 55" 1397 (1989)
Ionlmplantation
351
74. Wilson, R. G., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., and Zavada, J. M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:2238 (1995) 75. Wilson, R. G., Vartuli, C. B., Abemathy, C. R., Pearton, S. J., and Zavada, J. M., Solid-State Elec., 38:1329 (1995) 76. Zolper, J. C., Hagerott Crawford, M., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Vartuli, C. B., Ramer, J., Hersee, S. D., Yuan, C., and Stall, R. A., Conf. Proc. Material Research Society, Fall 1995, 395:801, (F. A. Ponce, R. D. Dupuis, Nakamura, S., and J. A. Edmond, eds.), Material Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA (1996) 77. See for example: Naik, I. K., J. Electrochem. Soc., 134:1270 (1987); Humer-Hager T., and Zwicknagl, P., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 27:428 (1988) 78. Edwards, A., Rao, M. V., Molnar, B., Wickenden, A. E., Halland, O. W., and Chi, P. H., J. Electron. Mat., 26:334 (1997) 79. Zolper, J. C, GaN and Related Materials, Ch. 12, (S. J. Pearton, ed.), Gordon and Breach, New York, NY (1997) 80. Maruska, H. P., private communication. 81. Orton, J. W., Semicond. Sci. Technol., 10:101 (1994) 82. Brandt, O., Yang, H., Kostial, H., and Ploog, K. H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:2707 (1996) 83. Salvador, A., Kim, W., Aktas, O., Botchkarev, A., Fan, Z., and Morkoc, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 69:2692 (1960) 84. Rosenblatt, D. H., Hitchens, W. R., Anholt, R. A., and Sigmon, T. A., IEEE Elec. Dev. Lett., 9:139 (1988) 85. Gardner, J., Rao, M. V., Halland, O. W., Kellner, G., Simons, D. S., Chi, P. H., Andrews, J. M., Kretchmer, J., and Ghezzo, M., J. Electron. Mat., 25:885 (1996) 86. Ryu, J., Kim, H. J., Glass, J. T., and Davis, R. F., J. Electron. Mat., 18:157 (1989) 87. Wilson, R. G., Surface and Coatings Technology, 47:559 (1991) 88. Pearton, S. J., s Mod. Phys., 7:4687 (1993) 89. Tan, H. H., Williams, J. S., Yuan, C., and Pearton, S. J., Conf. Proc. Material Research Society, Fall 1995, 395:807, (F. A. Ponce, R. D. Dupuis, S. Nakamura, and J. A. Edmond, eds.), Material Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA (1996) 90. Tan, H. H., Jagadish, C., Williams, J. S., Zoa, J., Cockayne, D. J. H., and Sikorski, A., s Appl. Phys., 77:87 (1995) 91. Rowland, L. B., Doverspike, K., and Gaskill, D. K., Appl. Phys. Lett., 66:1495 (1995)
352
Wide B a n d g a p S e m i c o n d u c t o r s
92. Zolper, J. C., Crawford, M. H., Tan, H. H., Williams, J. S., Zhou, J., Cockayne, D. J. H., Pearton, S. J., and Karlicek, R. F., Jr., Appl. Phys. Lett., 70, May 15, 1997, 70:2729 (1997) 93. Zolper, J. C., Crawford, M. H., Williams, J. S., Tan, H. H., and Stall, R. A., Nuclear Inst. and Methods in Phys. Res. B, 127/128:467 (1997) 94. Tan, H. H., Williams, J. S., Zou, J., Cockayne, D. J. H., Pearton, S. J., and Yuan, C., Proc. 1st Symp. on III-V Nitride Materials and Processes, 96( 11): 142, Electrochemical Society (1996) 95. Zolper, J. C., Han, J., Biefeld, R. M., Van Deusen, S. B., Wampler, W. R., Pearton, S. J., Williams, J. S., Tan, H. H., Karlicek, R. J., and Stall, R. A., Conf. Proc. Material Research Society, Spring 1997, Vol. 468, (C. R.Abemathy, H. Amano, and J. C. Zolper, eds.), Material Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA, in press 1997 96. Williams, J. S., and Poate, J. M. Ion Implantation and Beam Processing, Academic Press, Sydney (1984) 97. Williams, J. M., McHargue, C. J., and Appleton, B. R., Nucl. Instr. and Meth., 209/210:317 (1983) 98. Spitznagel, J. A., Wood, S., Choyke, W. J., Doyle, N. J., Bradshaw, J., and Fishman, S. G., Nucl. Instr. Meth. Phys. Res. B, 16:237 (1986) 99. Fohl, A., Emrick, R. M., and Carstanjen, H. D., Nucl. Instr. Meth. Phys. Res. B, 65:335 (1992) 100. Chechenin, N. G., Bourdelle, K. K., Suvorov, A. V., and Kastilio-Vitloch, A. X., Nucl. Instr. Meth. Phys. Res. B, 65:341 (1992) 101. Avashi, D. K., Vacuum, 47:1249 (1996) 102. Kalish, R., Reznik, A., Nugent, K. W., Prawer, S., Nucl. Instr. and Meth. in Phys. Res. B, 148:626 (1999) 103. Sato, S., and Iwaki, M., Nucl. Instr. Meth, B, 32:145 (1988) 104. Kalish, R., Bemstein, T., Shapira, B., and Talmi, A., Radiat. Eft., 52:153 (1980) 105. Prawer, S., Hoffman, A., and Kalish, R.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 75:2187 (1990) 106. Yuan, C., Salagaj, T., Gurary, A., Zawadzki, P., Chern, C. S., Kroll, W., Stall, R. A., Li, Y., Schurman, M., Hwang, C.Y., Mayo, W. E., Lu, Y., Pearton, S. J., Krishnankutty, S., and Kolbas, R. M., J. Electrochem. Soc., 142:L163 (1995) 107. Shul, R. J., Howard, A. J., Pearton, S. J., Abemathy, C. R., Vartuli, C. B., Barnes, P. A., and Davies, P., Conf. Proc. Material Research Society, Fall 1995, 395:751, (F. A. Ponce, R. D. Dupuis, S. Nakamura, and J. A. Edmond, eds.), Material Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA (1996) 108. Zolper, J. C., Baca, A. G., Shul, R. J., Howard, A. J., Rieger, D. J., Sherwin, M. E., Lovejoy, M. L., Hjalmarson, H. P., Draper, B. L., Klem, J. F., and Hietala, V. M., IEEE Trans. Elec. Dev., 41:1078 (1994)
lon lmplantation
353
109. Doverspike, K., Wickenden, A. E., Binari, S. C., Gaskill, D. K., and Frietas, J. A., Conf. Proc. Material Research Society, Fall 1995, 395:897, (F. A. Ponce, R. D. Dupuis, S. Nakamura, and J. A. Edmond, eds.), Material Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA (1996) 110. Binari, S. C., Proc. Sym. on Wide Bandgap Semiconductors and Devices, Fall ECS meeting, 1995, p. 136, The Electrochemical Society, Pennington, NJ (1995) 111. Vodakov, Y. A., Demakov, K. D., Kalinina, E. V., Mokhov, E. N., Ramm, M. G., and Kholuyanov, G. F., Sov. Phys. Semicond., 21" 1017 (1987) 112. Edmond, J. A., Das, K., and Davis, R. F.,J. Appl. Phys., 63:922 (1988) 113. Ghezzo, M., Brown, D. M., Downey, E., Kretchmer, J., Hennessy, W., Polla, D. L., and Bakhru, H., IEEE Elec. Dev. Letts., 13:639 (1992) 114. Ghezzo, M., Brown, D. M., Downey, E., Kretchmer, and J., Kopanski, J. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 63:1206 (1993) 115. Xie, W., Cooper, J. A., Jr., and Melloch, M. R., IEEE Elec. Dev. Lett., 15:455 (1994) 116. Prins, J. F., US patent # US5385762 117. Prins, J. F., AppL Phys. Letts., 41:950 (1982) 118. Zeisse, C. R., Hewett, C. A., Nguyen, R., Zeidler, J. R., and Wilson, R. G., IEEE Elec. Dev. Lett., 12:602, (1991)
8 R a r e E a r t h I m p u r i t i e s in Wide Gap Semiconductors John M. Zavada
ABSTRACT In recent years, optoelectronic materials, both insulators and semiconductors, doped with rare earth atoms have received widespread attention due to their impact on optical communication systems operating at 1.54 gm and 1.3 gin. Optical amplifiers based on Er-doped fibers have demonstrated major improvements in link distance, data rates, and reduced needs for signal regeneration. The intra-subshell transitions of4felectrons in rare earth ions lead to narrow absorption peaks in the ultra-violet, visible, and near-infrared regions of the electromagnetic spectrum. Since it appears that the intensity of the room temperature light emission of these ions depends upon the energy bandgap of the host material, wide gap semiconductors may prove to be the best materials for optoelectronic device applications. Semiconductors doped with rare earth ions offer the prospect of very stable, temperature-insensitive, optical amplifiers, and light emitting diodes operating at wavelengths from the ultra-violet to the near infrared. This paper presents a review of the lurninescence characteristics of wide gap compound semiconductors doped with rare earth atoms. In particular, aspects of rare earth atom incorporation in the semiconductor crystal, photoluminescence properties, and prototype electrolurninescent devices are addressed. 354
Rare Earth Impurities 355 1.0
INTRODUCTION
Crystalline Si has emerged as the primary semiconductor material for modem micro-electronics, largely due to an effective native oxide. With the development of fiber optic communications, the natural choice would have been to use Si as the basic material for optical transmitters and detectors. However, Si is an indirect bandgap material. Consequently, even with the advent of porous Si, efficient light emission has not been possible.[ ~]/2] Therefore, direct bandgap III-V compound semiconductor materials have been synthesized and used effectively for optoelectronic sources and detectors.[3] Materials such as AIGaAs and InGaAIP have been epitaxially grown with great success to form light emitters and detectors operating at the major wavelengths (0.82 lam, 1.3 lam, and 1.5 lam) used for optical fiber communications. Long distance optical communication systems also require amplifiers to boost the transmitted signal and, initially, this amplification was done at repeater stations. At these stations, the optical signal was converted into an electrical signal, amplified, and then optically regenerated. Recently, erbium doped fiber amplifiers (EDFA) have been used to perform this amplification while keeping the signal in the optical domain. This has resulted in a large improvement in the capacity of optical fiber communication systems.[4]-[6] However, there are certain disadvantages to the use of semiconductor lasers and Er doped silica fibers. While semiconductor quantum well lasers have high gain and high quantum efficiency, the lasing wavelength is strongly dependent upon the operating temperature. This is especially true for narrow bandgap InP-based devices. EDFAs, which are based on the 4fintra-subshell transitions of the Er ions, require elaborate optical pumping arrangments.[7][8] If rare earth (RE) atoms can be introduced into an appropriate semiconductor material and effectively activated by electrical means, then it might be possible to achieve nearly ideal, optical emission and amplification at the desired wavelengths for optical communication and display systems. Charge carriers would be electrically injected into a RE-doped semiconductor, exciting the RE ions, and inducing 4fintra-subshell optical transitions. Since the trivalent erbium ion (Er 3§ emits mainly around 1.54 ~tm, which is in the range of minimum loss in silica fibers, Er-doped semiconductors may be ideal source and amplifier materials for modem optical fiber communication systems. There are several excellent summaries of the properties of RE doped semiconductors.J9][ 1~ In this chapter, recent developments concerning the
356
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
luminescence characteristics of wide gap semiconductors doped with rare earth atoms are reviewed. In See. 2, the basic properties of the rare earth elements and the wide gap semiconductors are discussed. Section 3 is devoted to the different methods that have been used to dope wide gap semiconductors with RE atoms. In See. 4, photoluminescence spectra from RE 3+ ions incorporated in different wide gap semiconductor host materials, mainly the III-V nitrides and SiC, are presented. The dependence of the emission intensity of the RE ions on the bandgap of the host semiconductor and on the material temperature is discussed. Characteristics of prototype electroluminescent devices based on RE-doped wide gap semiconductors are presented in See. 5.
2.0
BASIC CONCEPTS
2.1
Rare Earth Elements
The lanthanide or "rare earth" elements denote the metallic elements having atomic numbers 57 to 71. These elements are designated "rare earths" due to the difficulty in extracting them from materials known as "earths" (e.g., lime and alumina). Actually, rare earth elements constitute about one-fourth of the known metals and are more abundant than gold or silver. The electronic structure of each trivalent rare earth ion (RE 3+) consists of a partially filled 4f subshell, and completely filled, outer 5s 2 and 5p 6 shells. With increasing nuclear charge, electrons enter into the underlying 4fsubshell rather than the external 5d shell[ 11] (see Table 1). The energy states of the RE 3+ are represented as mLj, where L is the total orbital angular momentum, J i s the total angular momentum, and m is the multiplicity of terms in the atomic configuration. Since the filled 5s 2 and 5p 6 subshells screen the 4felectrons, the rare earth elements have very similar chemical properties and are highly reactive with many other elements forming a variety of organic complexes. The screening of the partially filled 4f subshells also gives rise to sharp emission spectra approximately independent of the host material. The intrasubshell transitions of 4felectrons lead to narrow emission peaks in the ultraviolet, visible, and near-infrared regions of the spectra. For example, the Er 3§ exhibits well defined emission lines near 1.54 ~tm, and the trivalent praesodymium ion (Pr 3§ yields emission lines near 1.30 ~tm. In the free (isolated) RE 3+ state, these electric dipole transitions are forbidden to first
Rare Earth lmpurities 357 order because of parity conservation. However, when a rare earth ion is embedded in a host material, such as a glass or a crystal semiconductor, the local electric fields produce a splitting of the energy levels and certain electric dipole transitions are permitted. In Fig. 1, the spin-orbit splitting of the energy levels of Er 3+under different symmetry conditions is illustrated.[ ill Transitions of 4felectrons between these split levels lead to the observed emission spectra. In particular, the transitions between the first excited manifold of levels (4113/2) and the ground level manifold (4115/2) give rise to the emission lines near 1.54 ~tm.
Table 1. Some of the Basic Properties of the Lathanide Rare Earth Elements
Atomic Number
Element
57
Lanthanum
58
Cerium
59
Praseodymium
60
Neodymium
61
Promethium
62
Samarium
63
Europium
64
Gadolinium
65
Terbium
66
Dysprosium
67
Holmium
68
Erbium
69
Thulium
70
Ytterbium
71
Lutetium
RE 3+ Electron Configuration
4f~ 6 4f15s25p 6 4f25s25p 6 4f35s25p 6 4ff5s25p 6 4f55s25p 6 4f65s25p 6 4fTs25p 6 4fS5s25p 6 4f95s25p 6 4flO5s25p6 4fl15s25p6 4f125s25p6 4f135s25p6 4f145s25p6
R E 3+ Ground State
RE 3+ Ionic Radius (,~)
~So
1.061
2F5/2 3H 4
1.034
419/2 5I 4
0.995
6H5/2
0.964
7Fo
0.950
857/2 7F 6
0.938 0.923
6HI5/2
0.908
1.013 0.979
5I 8
0.894
4II5/2 3H 6
0.881
2F7/2
0.858
IS o
0.848
0.869
The optical properties of RE ions in insulating materials have been extensively studied for applications in solid state lasers and optical fiber amplifiers.Jail 12] Solid state lasers, such as Nd3+:YAG, are based on the 4f
358
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
intra-subshell transitions of Nd 3+ ions, and exhibit a very stable lasing wavelength and minimum temperature dependence. Because of these characteristics, such lasers have found widespread applications in laboratory and military systems. Furthermore, Er-doped silica fibers are being used for amplification of optical communication systems operating at 1.54 ~tm, and Prdoped fibers are being developed for use at 1.3 ~tm. However, these optical components, lasers and amplifiers, have a relatively low cavity gain.
Spin orbital interaction free Er 3"~on
eV 3
ZHe/z
II il II II il
2.5. __.~
1.5
-
3.04
4Fa/z
2.781
4F$/z
2.737
4F7~
2.533
4Hll ~
.
4S3/z 4Fs,, z
2.388 2.276
9
1.890
419/Z
1.533
41111Z
1.255
4113/Z
Er 3~in cubic symmetry (Td) crystal field
.803
~'
Fa~ } lOmeV rs
r6 ) 2o mev
rsra ]~ 42mev
0.5, I I
4115/Z
0.0
~ } '.~rs
74meV
Figure 1. Schematicdiagramof the energylevelsof a free Er3+ion and the splittingof the 4f
subshell levelsin a field of Tdcubic symmetry. [11]
In semiconductor materials, it is only within the past decade that the optical properties of RE ions have been studied in depth. Beginning with the
Rare Earth lmpurities 359 work of Ennen et al.,[ 13] the luminescence of RE ions in III-V compound semiconductors received considerable attention.[ 14]Investigations of RE ions in a variety of different semiconductors were conducted.[9][l~ This includes the III-V, the II-VI, and the IV-IV compounds as well as porous Si. The goal of this work was to develop electrically pumped optical sources for use in optical communications and in full color displays. Due to the importance of the 1.54 ~tm emission for optical communications, Er has been the main RE element to be studied in these semiconductors.
2.2
Wide Gap Semiconductors
Wide gap semiconductors are usually defined as those semiconductor materials having an energy gap (E~ in the visible or UV region (see Fig. 2.)[ 15] While these materials have been studied for many years, only within the last decade have they been under intense scrutiny for electronic and optoelectronic applications. In the electronics area, SiC has been the major wide gap semiconductor. There were a number of impressive demonstrations reported for SiC electronics, including high power metal-oxide semiconductor field effect transistors, microwave devices and high temperature junction field effect transistors.[ 16]In addition, until a few years ago, the only commercially available blue light emitting diodes (LED) were fabricated from SiC wafers. However, as with Si, this material is an indirect bandgap semiconductor. The external quantum efficiency of the blue LEDs was not very high. In the optoelectronics area wide gap II-VI and III-V semiconductors have been the dominant materials. Using ZnSe compounds, Haase et al. were the first group to successfully demonstrate a blue laser diode at room temperature.[ 17] Subsequently, Eason et al. demonstrated both blue and green light emitting diodes based on these wide gap II-VI semiconductors.[ 18]These impressive results caused a dramatic increase in the research activity in wide gap II-VI semiconductors. In 1994, Nakamura et al. demonstrated a high brightness blue LED based on III-V nitride semiconductors.[ 19]Both blue and green LEDs based on single quantum well InGaN structures are now commercially available. The high brightness and long operational lifetime of the InGaN diodes led to their widespread acceptance for use in full-color displays and traffic lights. Nakamura et al. were also the first to demonstrate a blue laser diode based on the GaN material system.[ 2~ Presently, several groups in Japan and the U.S. have reported on room temperature blue laser diodes using InGaN quantum wells. These developments have attracted intense interest for the III-V nitride
360
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
semiconductors.[ 21] There is also a potential for nitrides to be used in high frequency electronic power devices and in high temperature electronics. --r-m-r-T-r-T--r-t-.t--r- r-, T-'T] m
r
r-1
i-r,
'-'-I"
'- '--r-i-r- j-~ -'-V T - ' - r ,--
AIN O|
I ll,,-v,
~9
iGaO2 5 J-
9 ..-.
l-
Mgb
('~ E
LU 4
Z
L'
Cubic
nO
LLI
Ga:/ii~
t:L
36 ' \ \ H' )~ , . _ SiC( ~ i n N
Gat',l
9 III-V 9 Nmides
/
(~ Others -
L ..........
ZnS
gSe
III ZnSelll CdS 9
GaPII,,,, 9
AlAsT
~2 Z
"~ m
I j
.,~
Basal Plane 1 - Lattice Constants ......
2.5
ZnTe-
--- I~-
GaAsO Si Q
9 CdSe InP -,.
L . . . . . . . . . . . k . . . . . . . . _1............. t . . . . . . . . . . J_. . . . . . . . . . .L~_.,G.._~_ t . . . . . . . .
3.0
3.5
4.0
LATTICE
4.5
5.0
CONSTANT
5.5
6.0
6.5
(A)
Figure 2. Bandgap energies and lattice constants of the principal wide gap compound semiconductors as well as other important optoelectronic materials.[~5]
Other wide gap III-V semiconductors include GaP and AlAs, both of which are indirect materials. GaP doped with N has been extensively used in green LEDs.[::] However, the purity and the brightness of the emission cannot compete with the newer InGaN based green LEDs. The A1GaAs material system has been thoroughly investigated for electronic and optical applications. With low concentrations orAl, the alloy A1GaAs is not a wide gap material. At high A1 concentrations, the alloy does have a wide, indirect bandgap. However, ambient oxidation and deep level defects restrict the use of this material. Porous Si is somewhat of an anomaly. It is formed from Si material, which is an indirect, non-wide gap semiconductor. However, after electrochemical processing, porous Si exhibits room temperature luminescence from the visible to the near infrared, depending upon the processing conditions.[ 2] It has been conjectured that, after processing, direct bandgap quantum wires or quantum dots are formed, resulting in a wide gap semiconductor material. One of the main reasons for studying RE impurities in wide gap semiconductors stems from the work ofFavennec et al.[23]They reported a
Rare Earth Impurities
361
strong dependence of the emission intensity of the E r 3+ ions on the bandgap of the host semiconductor and on the ambient material temperature. Several different semiconductors were implanted with Er § ions and the photoluminescence (PL) emission spectrum was subsequently measured. It was found that the PL intensity decreased at higher temperatures. The results of these experiments are shown in Fig. 3. Each material was implanted with Er § ions to a dose ofl013 cm "2 atan energy of 330 keV. The thermal quenching ofthe emission intensity was more severe for the smaller bandgap materials, such as Si and GaAs. The wide bandgap compounds, such as ZnTe and CdTe, exhibited the least temperature dependence.
ut
IoOL
-
.,.
,. ,,,,, m
..,,
-... ~
,,,.
,
,
c I,,.
,ID L_
~ 10"1 m
0
~ D
m
E §
,.,W'-1 O-Z 0
100 200 temperature. K
300 I e~.o~21
Figure 3. Emission intensity of Er3+ions in various semiconductorhost materials as a function of temperature. The semiconductor materials are: (a) Ino.16Gao.ssAso.s4Po.16;(b) Si; (c) InP; (d) GaAs; (e) Alo.17Gao.s3As;09 ZnTe; (g) CdS. Each material was implanted with Er+ ions to a dose of l013 cm-2 at an energy of 330 keV.[TM
Neuhalfen et al. observed a similar temperature dependence of the intensity of the Er 3+ emission for different composition In ]_xGaxP epilayers
362
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
grown by MOCVD. [24]Based on their data, they proposed a model to explain the thermal quenching as a function ofbandgap energy. In this model, the Er a+ ions act as radiative recombination centers. With increased temperatures, the electrons become delocalized from these centers into the conduction band and recombine via non-radiative channels. Another explanation for the decrease of thermal quenching with wider band gap semiconductor materials was given by Takahei et al.[25] They argued that with wider gap materials, energy backtransfer was less likely to occur because the energy needed to form the bound exciton, which subsequently recombines without Er a+ excitation, is larger. In general, optical emission in the semiconductors appears not as efficient as in the dielectric materials. It may be that ionic bonds found in dielectrics may be better for forming the required energy levels than the covalent bonds present in most semiconductors. Co-doping the host semiconductor with impurity elements, such as O or F, seems to enhance optical emission. This may be due to the impurity atoms forming ligands with the RE atoms and converting the local bonds into a more ionic state. Favennec et al. [26] and Michel et al. [27] observed a significant enhancement of the E r 3+ emission in Si due to the presence of O impurities. These results suggest that O assists in the optical activation of the Er 3+ ions. In similar experiments, Colon et al.[TMshowed that the addition of O significantly enhances the Er 3+ emission from Er-implanted A1GaAs. There are considerable materials issues associated with each of these wide gap semiconductors. Improved bulk and epitaxial growth methods need to be developed. Ohmic contacts, processing steps (such as wet and dry etching), and doping/isolation procedures need further research to fully exploit these promising material systems for electronic as well as optical applications.
3.0
I N C O R P O R A T I O N O F R E A T O M S IN W I D E G A P SEMICONDUCTORS
A number of different methods have been used for incorporating RE atoms into semiconductor materials. These methods include: epitaxial growth, ion implantation, e-beam sputtering, laser ablation, electrolysis, and diffusion.J9][ l~ There does not seem to be any report of RE atoms incorporated into
Rare Earth lmpurities 363 semiconductor materials during bulk growth. The principal methods developed so far are: ion implantation and doping during epitaxy. Ion implantation has received considerable attention as a method for doping materials, due to its widespread use in processing integrated circuits and optoeleetronies devices.[ 29] Because this method is a non-equilibrium process, introduction of dopants is limited neither by solubility constraints nor by surface chemistry. However, implantation produces crystal damage, especially with high mass atoms such as the RE elements. The damage leads to electronic traps and non-radiative recombination centers in the host material. Consequently, some form of post-implantation annealing is necessary. Ion implantation has been used extensively to dope semiconductors with RE atoms.[g][l~ However, annealing still needs to be performed and higher concentrations of RE atoms will lead to clustering effects and reduced optical activity. Using ion implantation, Wilson et al. showed that it was possible to dope GaN films with a sufficiently high concentration of Er to observe light emission at 1.54 ~tm.[3~ The GaN specimens were implanted with Er + ions at room temperature in the (100) random orientation. Implantation energy was 300 keV and the fluenee was 2 x 1014 cm -2. Figure 4 shows the result of a secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) measurement of the Er depth profile in a typical ion implanted GaN film.J31][32]Under these conditions, the peak Er concentration reached a level of approximately 1019 cm -3 and the projected range Rp was about 0.1 m. The GaN films were also implanted with O + ions at an energy of 180 keV and a fluenee of 10 is cm -2. The ion energies were chosen to make the projected ranges of the two elements coincide. After implantation, the GaN films were furnace annealed at 650-700~ No change in the Er or O depth profile was observed under such annealing. Several types ofepitaxial growth have been successful for doping the III-V semiconductors with RE atoms: liquid phase epitaxy (LPE), molecular beam epitaxy (MBE), metal-organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD), and metal-organic molecular beam epitaxy (MOMBE).[9][ 1~ Using LPE, reproducible epilayers have been obtained only for Er doping of In-based compounds.[ 33]This difficulty was attributed to the high chemical reactivity of Er and the tendency of these atoms to form oxides. The epilayers were found to consist of Er precipitates and microparticles.[ 34] With MBE, which is an ultra-high vacuum technique, precise control ofepilayer composition, thickness, and doping profile is possible. However, even with this technique, there have been difficulties incorporating the RE atoms into the epilayers. The solubility limit of RE atoms in these epilayers has been on the order of 1019
364
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
cm "3 and the occurrence of precipitates and microparticles has also been noted. Nevertheless, high quality GaAs epilayers doped with Er ions have been achieved using MBE. Distinct lines in the emission spectra at 1.54 ~tm have been observed.[35][36]Using MOCVD, high quality, Er doped GaAs and GaP epilayers have been produced with very good luminescence characteristics. [37][38] MOMBE is a combination of the MBE and MOCVD methods. It is a high vacuum technique which uses gaseous as well as solid sources. This method has been especially successful for C doping of GaAs epilayers. Recently, Er-doped III-V nitride films have been successfully grown using MOMBE and MBE.
1020
-
I
I
I
-
"~
1019 in GaNISapphire 300 keY 2X1014 cm "2
-
i e 1018
1017
":
1016
1015
I
0.0
I 0.2
I 0.4
I 0.6
,
"
0.8
DEPTH (jam)
Figure 4. Atomic depth distribution measured by SIMS of Er implanted at room temperature into GaN/sapphire in the (100) random orientation. Implantation energy was 300 keV and the fluence was 2 x 1014 cm-2.[3~
Rare Earth Impurities 365 MacKenzie et al. were the first to show that AIN films could be doped with Er during epitaxial growth. [39] Using MOMBE techniques, controlled Er densities in the 1019to 1020cm -3range were achieved. The Er densities were confirmed using SIMS analysis that was quantified using Er implanted standards. In Fig. 5, the result of a SIMS measurement of the Er depth profile in a GaN film grown by MOMBE is shown.[4~ In this figure, high concentrations of O also appear in the A1N films. What is not known is whether the presence of O enhances the luminescence of the Er ions. In order to achieve significantly higher Er concentrations in the films, effusion cell temperatures greater than 1000~ were required for the solid Er source.The results of the effusion cell temperature on the Er concentration in the film are shown in Fig. 6.[ 39]
,,
t.
|
A~N ~
1
10 7
1
E r - D O P E D AIN/SAPPHIRE BY M O M B E 0
s
10;12
(n i-. 10 s z o o z
I?
uE1021
.9.o
m
(n z uJ D
10 4
7 0 W
Er
glOa)
_" 10 3
10111 10 2
i
i
i
, , , I,
i
.
, , t ,,,
1~
10 w 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
12.
1.4
DEPTH (lun)
Figure 5. Atomic depth distribution measured by SIMS of Er and O incorporated in an A1N film during MOMBE growth.t4Ol
366
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
1022
,-
.
9 _ , ....
.-
-
|
"
.
'_
i
IS
I0 2t A
'G lo
g~ @ ~m
a
1019
Q0
r gg O
to l_
10 is
1
6.0x10"4 " 6.5x10"4
A
7.(NIO"4
,
L,,
7.5x10
9
"4
I
8.0x10
.
.,
"4
8.5x10
"4
I/T 1s"I
Figure 6. Er concentration in A1N films as a function of cell temperature during MOMBE growth.[
39]
Diffusion of RE atoms into the semiconductor materials has had very limited use. The low diffusivity of the large RE atoms, the relatively low decomposition temperatures of typical semiconductor materials, and solubility constraints have been major obstacles hindering the use of diffusion. However, Horiguchi et al. showed the diffusion process can be used to dope Si with Er atoms. [41] There does not seem to be a fundamental reason preventing this method from being used for wide gap materials. Diffusion has been successfully used to introduce RE atoms into various dielectric crystals, such as LiNbO 3, which have a lower melting temperature than several wide gap semiconductors.[ 42] Not a great deal is known concerning the exact locations of the RE atoms in the semiconductor lattice. Basic questions remain whether interstitial or substitutional sites are the preferred locations. Rutherford backscattering analysis (RBS) has been useful in obtaining some understanding concerning these locations. Kozanecki et al. studied (100) GaAs wafers implanted with Er. [43] and concluded that the optical activity of the Er 3§ ions disappears once the ions are located on substitutional lattice sites.
Rare Earth lmpurities 367 A similar study was conducted by Tang et al. using Si wafers implanted with Er. [44] Their RBS data also indicated that the lattice positions of the Er atoms depend upon the annealing conditions. After implantation, the Er atoms occupy random sites in the lattice. With annealing, the Er atoms move to substitutional lattice sites. However, even when the Er atoms are on substitutional lattice sites, there is optical activity and distinct luminescence lines near 1.54 lam can be detected. These results are consistent with data obtained by Nakata et al. on Erdoped GaAs epilayers grown by M O C V D . [37]The peak of RBS data in the <110> channeling direction supported their conclusion that the Er ions occupy a displaced tetrahedral interstitial site. Photoluminescence measurements at 4 K on these samples displayed a complex spectrum indicating the presence of at least three kinds of active Er 3+centers. In dielectric matrials, it was established that the RE ions occupy a variety of sites. Witte et al. showed that Er ions occupy at least 4 different sites in LiNbO 3 after diffusion.[ 45] Typically, separation of the optical activity from these different sites was a difficult task. After implantation, the RE atoms are probably in interstitial locations. Following annealing, some of the RE ions are probably on lattice sites. With the A1N samples doped with Er, the RE atoms are likely to be on the group III sub-lattice. Kim et al. have studied the location of Er 3+ ions in GaN by siteselective photoluminescence excitation (PLE) spectroscopy.[ 46] The GaN epilayers were grown on sapphire substrates using MOCVD and implanted with Er + and O+ ions. The PLE spectra displayed several broad, below bandgap, absorption bands which in turn could excite distinct Er3+site-selective PL spectra. Three different Er3+sites were identified. Excitation of two of the bands involved optical absorption by defects, and impurities with subsequent energy transfer to Er 3+centers. Excitation of the third band appeared to involve a bound exciton at an Er-related trap center. Further studies are needed to determine the precise locations of the RE ions and the associated optical properties.
4.0
R E 3+ P H O T O L U M I N E S C E N C E
Photoluminescence spectroscopy has been the principal technique used to characterize the optical emission of the RE ions. This technique involves excitation of the RE ions by means of a laser and measurement of the spectnma of the resulting light emission as a function of intensity and energy. While the exact mechanisms are not fully understood, it appears that in a
368
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
semiconductor doped with RE ions, the ions may be optically excited either indirectly or directly. In the first case, laser radiation, at an energy level above bandgap energy, leads to the creation of electron-hole pairs which in turn recombine near a RE center. The energy from the electronhole pair is transferred to the RE ion, exciting it to one of its higher energy states. Upon relaxation, the RE ion emits the optical radiation. Defects and other impurities in the material serve as non-radiative recombination centers that can alter the light emission properties. Most of the PL measurements of RE-doped semiconductors involve the use of a pump laser operating at an energy level above bandgap energy. However, with the wide gap semiconductors, use of a blue or UV laser is required. In the second case, the RE ions in the semiconductor may be excited directly by the laser pump radiation provided that the energy of the laser coincides with one of the excited energy levels of the RE ion. Wu et al. have shown that in defected A1N layers, a carrier-mediated process can also be used to excite the RE ions, even when the laser radiation has an energy below that of the bandgap.[ 47] Carrier lifetime of electron-hole pairs in an undoped semiconductor is determined by the band structure and the defect density of the material. Typically, in direct bandgap material, this lifetime is on the order of a few ns. The intra- sub shell 4ftransitions of RE 3+ ions in a semiconductor exhibit a much longer lifetime, on the order of a few ms. Using PL techniques, Klein and Pomerenke measured the time decay of 1.54 ~tm emission of Er 3§ ions in several different semiconductors and showed that the emission decay for GaAs, GaP, InP, and Si is on the order of 1 ms.[ 48] Wilson et al. reported the first observation of light emission of Er 3+ ions incorporated in III-V nitride semiconductors (in particular, GaN and A1N films).[ 3~ The films, which were grown on either GaAs or sapphire substrates, were co-implanted with Er § and O § ions and then annealed at 650~700~ The Er-O doped GaN films, which were grown on sapphire substrates, were optically excited using an Ar + laser at a wavelength of 457.9 nm which corresponds to an energy below the bandgap ofGaN (Eg.~ 3.4 eV). Infrared PL spectra were measured at 6, 77, and 300 K. As shown in Fig. 7, the spectra were centered at 1.54 ~tm and displayed many of the allowed tmnsitiom between the 4113/2 and the 4115/2 manifolds typical of the Er 3§ configuration. In addition, the luminescence intensity was more than half as intense at room temperature as at 77 K. This result provided further evidence that wide bandgap materials, such as ClaN, tend to suppress the temperature d ~ d e n c e of the Er3+luminescence. Since the laser excitation energy was below the GaN bandgap, it was uncertain whether the observed luminescence of
Rare Earth Impurities 369 Er 3+ was due to direct optical excitation o f the Er § ions or some carriermediated process.
300 K
77K
6K
1500
1520
1540
1560
1580
1600
1620
1640
1660
WAVELENGTH (nm)
Figure 7. Photoluminescence spectra of Er3+ions implanted into a GaN/sapphire host as a function of measurement temperature. The sample film was co-implanted with O+ ions and annealed at 700~176
The A1N films, which were grown on GaAs substrates, were coimplanted with Er § and O § ions and then annealed at 650~ Similarly, an Ar + laser at a wavelength o f 457.9 n m was used to optically excite the Er 3§ ions. No PL spectra could be observed at 77 and 300 K. Only at 6 K could a PL spectrum be measured, as shown in Fig. 8. The spectrum was centered at
370
Wide Bandgap Semiconductors
1.54 ~tm, but did not display many of the allowed transitions between the 4113/ 2 and the 4115/2 manifolds that were found in the Er-doped GaN samples.
I
9,1211-a~.o~
ttJ tLI
I 1500
1520
1540 1560 WAVELENGTH (nm)
1580
1600
Figure 8. Photoluminescencespectrum, measured at 6 K, of Er3+ions implanted into A1N/
GaAs sample. The film was co-implantedwith O+ions and annealed at 650 89 3~
Torvik et al. performed a systematic study of GaN films co-implanted with Er § and O § ions and subsequently annealed. [49]The films were grown by chemical vapor deposition on R-plane sapphire. Different combinations of fluences for the implants and annealing temperatures were examined. After each annealing stage, the samples were examined for Er 3+ luminescence using a laser at a wavelength of 980 nm. Figure 9 shows a typical PL spectrum of one of their sample films measured at 77 K. The inset shows the three level excitation process leading to an emission of around 1.54 ~tm. In their experiments, the samples with the highest Er fluence (1015 Er 2+ cm -2) yielded the strongest PL intensity. Silkowski et al. examined the luminescence of Er and Nd implanted into GaN films which were grown by MOCVD on sapphire substrates.[ 5~ The ion implanted films were annealed and then excited using an Ar + laser operating at 514.5 nm. No co-implantation with O was made. Since the films were prepared by MOCVD, it is posible that high levels of O were already present. The Er-implanted samples showed the 4113/2 ~ 4115/2 transitions around 1.54 ~tm and the 4Ill/2 ~ 4115/2 transitions near 1.0 ~tm. Based on these data, it appeared that multiple Er 3§ radiative centers were present in the samples. The Nd implanted samples showed three well resolved manifolds of 4flines near
Rare Earth Impurities 3 71 0.98, 1.14, and 1.46 lam. PL spectra, measured at 2 and 300 K, of Nd 3+ ions (5x1013 cm -2) implanted into GaN are shown in Fig. 10. The narrow lines nearly correspond to transitions from the 4F3/2 ~ 4I 11/2manifolds. __
.......
4111/241
~. 0.8
13/2
-
A
4Itm
0.69
0.4
c
0.2
-
0
I " 0 v--
0 04
0 eO tO
0 ~" tO
I
,.t
I
-I