QP-PQ: Quantum Probability and White Noise Analysis Managing Editor: W. Freudenberg Advisory Board Members: L. Accardi, T. Hida, R. Hudson and K. R. Parthasarathy QP-PQ: Quantum Probability and White Noise Analysis VOl. 18:
Quantum Probability and Infinite-Dimensional Analysis From Foundations to Applications eds. M. Schurmann and U. Franz
Vol. 17:
Fundamental Aspects of Quantum Physics eds. L. Accardi and S. Tasaki
Vol. 16:
Non-Commutativity, Infinite-Dimensionality, and Probability at the Crossroads eds. N. Obata, T. Matsui and A. Hora
Vol. 15: Quantum Probability and Infinite-Dimensional Analysis ed. W. Freudenberg Vol. 14:
Quantum Interacting Particle Systems eds. L. Accardi and F. Fagnola
Vol. 13:
Foundations of Probability and Physics ed. A. Khrennikov
QP-PQ VOl. 10:
Quantum Probability Communications eds. R. L. Hudson and J. M. Lindsay
VOl. 9:
Quantum Probability and Related Topics ed. L. Accardi
VOl. 8:
Quantum Probability and Related Topics ed. L. Accardi
VOl. 7:
Quantum Probability and Related Topics ed. L. Accardi
Vol. 6:
Quantum Probability and Related Topics ed. L. Accardi
Qp-pQ Quantum Probability and White Noise Analysis Volume XVIII
From Foundations to Applications Krupp-Kolleg Greifswald, Germany
22 - 28 June 2003
Editors
Michael Schurmann Uwe Franz University of Greifswald, Germany
NEW JERSEY
-
EeWorld Scientific LONDON * SINGAPORE
BElJlNG * SHANGHAI * HONG KONG * TAIPEI
*
CHENNAI
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224
USA ofice: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK ofice: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WCZH 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-PublicationData A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
-
QP-PQ: Quantum Probability and White Noise Analysis Vol. XVIII QUANTUM PROBABILITY AND INFINITE-DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS From Foundations to Applications Copyright 0 2005 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof;may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, includingphotocopying,recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permissionfrom the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN 98 1-256-147-1
Printed in Singapore.
INTRODUCTION
In Spring 2003, we organized the Special Semester “Quantum Probability: From Foundations to Applications” in Greifswald, Germany. The main events were 0
0
0
a school “Quantum Independent Increment Processes: Structure and Applications to Physics,” two workshops on “Non-commutative Martingales and Free Probability” and “Dilations, Endomorphism Semigroups, and their Classification by Product Systems,” and a n international conference “Quantum Probability and Infinite Dimensional Analysis.”
Furthermore, in Fall 2003 a workshop on “Quantum Independent Increment Processes” was held in Levico Terme, Italy, as a continuation of the Greifswald School. The goal of this Special Semester was to bring together scientists with different backgrounds who work in quantum probability and related fields, and to stimulate new collaborations. We would like t o thank all participants and lecturers for their hard work and for helping t o create a very stimulating atmosphere. The research papers collected in this volume represent the topics discussed during the Special Semester and reflect the active developments ranging from the foundations of quantum probability to its applications. The lecture notes of the school on “Quantum Independent Increment Processes” will be published in the Springer series Lecture Notes in Mathematics. Many people have been involved in the organization of the Special Semester, it would be impossible to name them all. We are particularly indebted t o the Volkswagen Foundation and the DFG, who supported the school on “Quantum Independent Increment Processes” and the international conference ‘Quantum Probability and Infinite Dimensional Analysis,” and thereby made the Special Semester possible. We also acknowledge the support by the European Community for the Research Training Network
V
vi
“QP-Applications: Quantum Probability with Applications to Physics, Information Theory and Biology” under contract HPRN-CT-2002-00279. Special thanks go to Mrs. Zeidler for taking care of the logistics of the Special Semester and for her help with the editing of these proceedings.
Michael Schiirmann Uwe Franz Greifswald, October 2004
CONTENTS
Introduction
V
Probability Measures in Terms of Creation, Annihilation, and Neutral Operators Luigi Accardi, Hui-Hsiung Kuo and Aurel Stan
1
Semi Groupes Associes B l’operateur de Laplace-Levy Luigi Accardi and Habib Ouerdiane
12
Stochastic Golden Rule for a System Interacting with a Fermi Field Luigi Accardi, R.A. Roschin and I.V. Volovich
28
Generating Function Method for Orthogonal Polynomials and Jacobi-Szego Parameters Nobuhiro Asai, Izumi Kubo and Hui-Hsiung Kuo
42
Low Temperature Superconductivity and the Stochastic Limit Fabio Bagarello Multiquantum Markov Semigroups, Interacting Branching Processes and Nonlinear Kinetic Equations. Finite Dimensional Case V.P. Belavkin and C.R. Williams A Note on Vacuum-Adapted Semimartingales and Monotone Independence Alexander C.R. Belton Quantum Stochastic Processes and Applications Mohamed Ben Chrouda, Mohamed El Oued and Habib Ouerdiane Regular Quantum Stochastic Cocycles have Exponential Product Systems B.V. Rajarama Bhat and J. Martin Lindsay
vii
56
67
105 115
126
viii
Evolution of the Atom-Field System in Interacting Fock Space P.K . Das Quantum Mechanics on the Circle through Hopf q-Deformations of the Kinematical Algebra with Possible Applications to LQvyProcesses V.K. Dobrev, H.-D. Doebner and R. Twarock
141
153
On Algebraic and Quantum Random Walks Demosthenes Ellinas
174
Dual Representations for the Schrodinger Algebra Philip Feinsilver and Rent! Schott
201
Harmonic Analysis on Non- Amenable Coxeter Groups Gero Fendler
216
A Limit Theorem for Conditionally Independent Beam Splittings K.H. Fichtner, Volkmar Liebscher and Masanori Ohya
227
On Factors Associated with Quantum Markov States Corresponding to Nearest Neighbor Models on a Cayley Tree Francesco Fidaleo and Farruh Mukhamedov
237
On Quantum Logical Gates on a General Fock Space Wolfgang Freudenberg, Masanori Ohya and Noburo Watanabe
252
The Chaotic Chameleon Richard D. Gill
269
On an Argument of David Deutsch Richard D. Gill
277
Volterra Representations of Gaussian Processes with an Infinite-Dimensional Orthogonal Complement Yuji Hibino and Hiroshi Muraoka
293
The Method of Double Product Integrals in Quantisation of Lie Bialgebras Robin L. Hudson
303
ix
On Noncommutative Independence Romuald Lenczewski
320
Lkvy Processes and Jacobi Fields Eugene Lytvynov
337
Ic-Decomposabilityof Positive Maps Wtadystaw A. Majewski and Marcin Marciniak
362
An Introduction to LBvy Processes in Lie Groups Ming Liao
375
Duality of W*-Correspondences and Applications Paul S. Muhly and Baruch Solel
396
Extendability of Generalized Quantum Markov States Hiromichi Ohno
415
White Noise Approach to the Low Density Limit Alexander N . Pechen
428
Asymptotics of Large Truncated Haar Unitary Matrices Jlilia Riffy
448
Quantum Optical Scenarios for Stochastic Resonance Vyacheslav Shatokhin, Thomas Wellens and Andreas Buchleitner
457
On a Classical Scheme in a Noncommutative Multiparameter Ergodic Theory Adam G. Skalski
473
LBvy Processes and Tensor Product Systems of Hilbert Modules Michael Skeide
492
Three Ways to Representations of B A ( E ) Michael Skeide
504
The Hamiltonian of a Simple Pure Number Process Wilhelm von Waldenfels
518
On Topological Entropy of Quotients and Extensions Joachim Zacharias
525
This page intentionally left blank
PROBABILITY MEASURES IN TERMS OF CREATION, ANNIHILATION, AND NEUTRAL OPERATORS
LUIGI ACCARDI Centro Vito Volterm Facoltb di Economia Uniuersitd di Roma “Tor Vergata” 00133 Roma, Italy E-mail: accardi0uolterra.mat.uniroma2.it HUI-HSIUNG KUO Department of Mathematics Louisiana State University Baton Rouge, LA 70803, USA E-mail: kuo0math.1su.edu AUREL STAN Department of Mathematics University of Rochester Rochester, N Y 14627, USA E-mail: astan0math.rochester.edu Let p be a probability measure on Rd with finite moments of all orders. Then we can define the creation operator a + ( j ) , the annihilation operator a - ( j ) , and the neutral operator a o ( j )for each coordinate 1 5 j 5 d . We use the neutral operators ao(i) and the commutators [a-( j ) ,a + ( k ) ] to characterize polynomially symmetric, polynomially factorizable, and moment-equal probability measures. We also present some results for probability measures on the real line with finite support, infinite support, and compact support.
1. Creation, annihilation, and neutral operators
Let /A be a probability measure on Rd with finite moments of all orders, namely, for any nonnegative integers i l , i2,. . . ,id,
1
2
where x = (21,x2,.. . ,xd) E Pd.Let Fo = P and for n 2 1let F, be the vector space of all polynomials in x1,22,. . . , z d of degree 5 n. Then we have the inclusion chain
Fo C FI C ... C Fn C ... C L2(p)Next, define Go = R and for n 2 1 define G, to be the orthogonal complement of F,-1 in F,. Then the spaces G,, n 2 0 , are orthogonal. Define a real Hilbert space 3t by 00
3t = @ G,
(orthogonal direct sum).
n=O
For each n 2 0, let P, denote the orthogonal projection of 3t onto G,. Let X j , 1 5 j 5 d, be the multiplication operator by xj. Accardi and Nahni5 have recently observed that for any 1 5 j 5 d and n 2 0
XjG, I G k , Q k f n - l , n , n + l , where G-1 = ( 0 ) by convention. Then they used this fact to obtain the following fundamental recursion equality
XjPa = Pn+lXjPn
+ PnXjPn + Pn-1XjPn,
1 <_ j
5 d, n >_ 0 ,
(1)
where P-1 = 0 by convention. When d = 1, this equality reduces to the well-known recursion formula
xPn(x) = Pa+l(x) + anPn(z)+ wnPn-l(z),
(2)
where P,(z)’s are orthogonal polynomials with respect to p , Pn(x)is a polynomial of degree n with leading coefficient 1, and {an,wn}’S are the Jacobi-Szego parameters of p . Now, for each n 2 0 and 1 5 j 5 d, define three operators by
D i ( j ) = Pn+lXjPn
:
Gn +Gn+lr
D,(j) = Pn-lXjPn : Gn +Gn-1, DO,(j) = P,XjP,
:
G,
+Gn.
Using these operators, we can define for each 1 5 j 5 d three densely defined linear operators a + ( j ) , u - ( j ) , and a o ( j )from 3c into itself by n
2 0,
= D,(j),
n
2 0,
aO(j)lcn= D%),
n
2 0.
a+(j)lc, = DRW, a-(j)Ic,
3
The operators a + ( j ) , u - ( j ) , and u o ( j )are called creation, annihilation, and neutral operators, respectively. It can be checked that u - ( j ) = a+(j)* and u o ( j ) = u o ( j ) * for each 1 5 j 5 d. The collection I1 I j I d )
{X,a+W, a - ( A , &)
is called the interacting Fock space of the probability measure p . For convenience, we will use the term “CAN operators” to call the creation, annihilation, and neutral operators. By using the multiplication and CAN operators, we can rewrite the fundamental recursion equality in Equation (1) as the equality in the next theorem. Theorem 1.1. For each 1 xj
j
5 d , the following equality holds
= u+(j)
+ 2 ( j )+ u - ( j ) .
(3)
We can use the equality in Equation (3) to extend the Accardi-Boiejko unitarity theorem’ to the multi-dimensional case. In this paper we will present some results to answer the following question. Question: What properties of p are determined by the associated CAN operators? 2. Polynomially symmetric measures Definition 2.1. A probability measure p on Rd is said to be polynomially symmetric if
for all nonnegative integers i l , i2,. . .id with il integer.
+ i2 + . . . + id being an odd
Note that if p is a symmetric measure with finite moments of all orders, then it is polynomially symmetric. But the converse is not true. Consider the function e(z) = e - ( ’ n ~ sin(2n )~ In $1,
z
> 0.
(4)
It is well-known that P“
zV(z) dz = 0, 10
V n = 0, 1,2, . . .
(5)
4
Define a function
f ( x )=
{
c8+(x), 0, c8-(-x),
if x > 0, if x = 0, if x
< 0,
where 8+ and 8- are the positive and negative parts of 8, respectively, and the constant c is chosen such that Jw - m f (x)d x = 1. By using Equation (5) one can easily check that the probability measure
dP(Z) = f dx is polynomially symmetric. Obviously, p is not symmetric. The next theorem has been proved in our paper2. Theorem 2.1. A probability measure p o n Rd with finite moments of all orders is polynomially symmetric if and only i f u o ( j ) = 0 f o r all j = 1,2,...,d. 3. Polynomially factorizable measures Definition 3.1. A probability measure p on Rd is said to be polynomially factorizable if
for all nonnegative integers il ,i 2 , . . .id. Obviously, if p is a product measure with finite moments of all orders, then it is polynomially factorizable. However, the converse is not true. Consider two modified functions of the function 8 in Equation (4):
el (x)= e-Qn e2(2) = e-('" ')'
2 ) '
[I
+ sin(2r In x ) ],
x > 0,
[I - sin(2r In x)], x > 0.
Define a function g ( x , y ) on R2 by
(0'
k[el(x)sin2 y
dX,Y) =
+ &(x) cos2y l e - ~ ,
if x
> 0, y > 0 ,
elsewhere,
where the constant k is chosen so that probability measure
d&,
JR2
g(x,y) d x d y = 1. Then the
Y ) = g(x,Y ) dXdY
5 can be shown to be polynomially factorizable, but not a product measure. The next theorem follows from Theorem 4.10 in our paper2. Theorem 3.1. A probability measure p on Rd with finite moments of all orders is polynomially factofizable if and only if for any i # j ,
the operators in {a+(i),a-(i), a o ( i ) } commute with the operators in {.+(A, a - w , a O ( j ) } . 4. Probability measures by means of the CAN operators
Let p be a probability measure on Rd with finite moments of all orders. We have the associated CAN operators a + ( j ) , u - ( j ) , and u o ( j ) . Define a d x 1 matrix A t and a d x d matrix A;>+ by
where [a,b] = ub - ba, the commutator of a and b. Definition 4.1. Two probability measures p and u with finite moments of all orders are said to be moment-equal if
for all monomial functions m ( x ) . The next two theorems have been proved in our paper3. Theorem 4.1. Two probability measures p and u on Rd with finite moments of all orders are moment-equal if and only if A t = A: and A;,+ = & I + .
6
Theorem 4.2. A probability measzlre p o n Rd with finite moments of all orders is the standard Gaussian measure o n Rd i f and only i f A: = Od and A;'+ = I d , namely, ao(i)= 0 f o r all 1 5 i 5 d and [a-(j),a+(k)]= d j , k I f o r all 1 5 j , k 5 d. The above discussion leads to the following problem for specifying a probability measure /I in terms of the matrices A: and A;*+.
Problem: Let V be the vector space of all polynomials on Rd. Let ai and a j , k be linear operators on V for 1 5 i , j , k 5 d. Find conditions on {~i}f and =~ {aj,k};,k=l so that there exists a probability measure p on Rd satisfying ai = ao(i)and a j , k = [ u - ( j ) , a + ( k ) ]for all 1 5 i , j , k 5 d. In the next section we will give some results on the solution to the above problem for the case when d = 1.
5. Probability measures on the real line Let p be a probability measure on R with finite moments of all orders. Let V be the vector space of all polynomials in 2 and let V,, be its subspace consisting of all polynomials of degree 5 n. Let F,, = Vn/-. Here the equivalence relation is given by p-almost everywhere, namely, f g if f = g holds p-a.e.
-
-
Assumption. In this section all linear operators T : V + V are assumed to satisfy the condition that T(V,) C V, for all n 2 0, namely, all subspaces Vn,n 2 0, are invariant under T . 5.1. Probability measures o n R with finite support Observe that if a probability measure p on R is supported by m distinct points, then
Fj=V,,
,...,m - 1 , j = m , m + l , ....
j=O,l,2
Fj =Vm--l,
The following theorem can be easily verified.
Theorem 5.1. Suppose p is a probability measure o n R supported by m distinct points. T h e n the following equalities hold: (1)
D(u:) , I
(2) TI-( [.;,a:]
= TI-(a:
), I
=
lvm-,)
f o r all k 2 m - 1.
o f o r ail k 2 m - 1.
7
Definition 5.1. Two linear operators S and T from V into itself are called trace equivalent on V , denoted by S T on V , if n-(slvb)
=Tr(TIVb))
vk_>o'
They are called trace equivalent on Vn, denoted by S
T on Vn,if
VOIkSn.
n ( s ( V ,= ) n(Tlvb),
The next theorem is from our paper3. It characterizes those measures supported by finitely many points in R in terms of the CAN operators.
Theorem 5.2. Let m 2 1 be afixed integer. Let a' and a-*+ be two linear operators f r o m V,-l into itself. Then there exists a probability measure p t o n R supported by m distinct points such that a' A a t and a-i+ [a;,.:] o n V,-l if and only if the following conditions hold:
-
(1) The spaces v k , 0 5 k
I,) (3) Q(a-*+ IvJ (2) Tr(a-9'-
5 m - 2, are invariant under a' and a->+. > 0 for all 0 5 k 5 m - 2. = 0,
5.2. Probability measums on R with infinite support Let p be a probability measure on R with infinite support, namely, the support of p contains infinitely many points. In this case, we have
Fn =Vn,
Vn_>O.
The next theorem has been proved in our paper3.
Theorem 5.3. Let a0 and a-i+ be two linear operators f r o m V into itself. Then there exists a probability measure p o n R with infinite support such that a' a! and a->+ [ a ; , a i ] o n V i f and only i f the following conditions hold: (1) The spaces Vn,n 2 0, are invariant under a' and a-i+. (2) Tr(a-i+
I,)
> o for all n 2 0.
Let E denote the set of all trace equivalent classes of ordered pairs (ao,a-i+) of linear operators from V into itself satisfying either one of the following conditions (a) and (b): (a) Q( a-$+
l v n)
> 0, V n 2 0.
8
(b) There exists m such that (1) n ( a OIVJ = n ( a Olvm-l), V k
(2)
n(a-,+
(3)
Tr(a-l+
lvk) lvk)
2m-
1,
> 0, vo 5 k 5 m - 2, = 0, V k 2 m - 1.
Theorem 5.4. There is a one-to-one correspondence between the set B and the set of all probability measures o n R with finite moments of all orders. 5.3. Probability measures on R with compact support
The Paley-Wiener type problem is to characterize probability measures with compact support. We have the next theorem from our paper3.
Theorem 5.5. A probability measure p o n R with finite moments of all orders has compact support if and only if the following two sequences of real numbers are bounded: (1) m
(2)
( 4), I
-*(a;
n ( q +I F = ) ,
n> - 1.
F l J7
n 2 1.
6. Classical probability measures on the real line Let p be a probability measure on R with finite moments of all orders. We have the associated orthogonal polynomials { Pn} and the Jacobi-Szego parameters {an,un}as given in Equation (2). The corresponding CAN operators are given by
UEP,
= pn+l,
aGPn = WnPn-1,
U:P~
= CX,P,, n 2 0,
where P-l = 0 by convention. Therefore, the commutator a;'+ is given by
= [a;,
]a :
Consider the following classical probability measures on the real line: 1 (1) Gaussian: dp(x) = -e - S dx, x E R (g > 0). &a
.=
(2) Poisson: p ( { l ~ }= ) e-'-,
Ak
k!
k = 0,1,2,. . . (A > 0).
9
(3) gamma:
Q
> 0. 1
d p ( x ) = -x a - l e -3 d x , x J3a) (4) Pascal: T > 0, 0 < p < 1.
> 0.
1
( 5 ) uniform: dp(x) = - d x , - 1 5 x 5 I. 2 1 1 (6) arcsine: d p ( x ) = - ___ d x , - 1 < x < 1.
di=?
(7) semi-circle: d,u(x) = Z d S d x , lr
(8) beta-type: j? > -1/2,
-1
1x 5 1.
,8 # 0.
For the above probability measures, the Jacobi-Szego parameters are given in the next table. By convention, wo = 1.
measure u Gaussian Poisson
+ n - 1)
Pascal
+ 2n ( 2 - p)n + ~ ( 1 p- ) P
p”
uniform
0
n2 (2n 4-1)(2n- 1)
arcsine
0
semi-circle
0
-
beta-type
0
n(n - 1 28) 4(n P)(n - 1 + P )
gamma
a!
n(Q n(n
+ T - 1)(1 - P)
-
ifn=l
1
4
+
+
10
Furthermore, the operator a: and the commutator a;’+ = [a,, a]: given in the following table.
are
measure p Gaussian
D 2Pn
Poisson gamma
APn (a!
+ 2n)P,
(a!
+ 2n)P,
Pascal uniform ifn=O arcsine
0
--PI,
(0,
semi-circle
0
beta-type
0
if n = 1 ifn>2
It is interesting to compare the above table with Theorems 2.1, 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, and 5.5.
Acknowledgments This research was initiated in May-June 2002 during the visits of H.-H. Kuo and A. Stan to the Centro Vito Volterra (CVV), Universita di Roma “Tor Vergata”. They are grateful to the CVV for financial support and would like to thank Professor L. Accardi and his staff members for the warm hospitality during the visits.
References 1. Accardi, L. and Boiejko, M.: Interacting Fock space and Gaussianization of probability measures; Infinite Dimensional Analysis, Q u a n t u m Probability and Related Topics 1 (1998) 663-670 2. Accardi, L., Kuo, H.-H., and Stan, A.: Characterization of certain probability measures by creation, annihilation, and neutral operators; Infinite Dimensional Analysis, Quantum Probability and Related Topics (to appear) 3. Accardi, L., Kuo, H.-H., and Stan, A.: Moments and commutators of probability measures; Preprint (2003) 4. Accardi, L., Lu, Y. G., and Volovich, I.: The QED Hilbert module and interacting Fock spaces; I I A S Reports No. 1997-008 (1997) International Institute for Advanced Studies, Kyoto 5. Accardi, L. and Nahni, M.: Interacting Fock space and orthogonal polynomials in several variables; Preprint (2002) 6. Chihara, T. S.: A n Introduction t o Orthogonal Polynomials. Gordon and Breach, 1978 7. Kubo, I.: Generating functions of exponential type for orthogonal polynomials; Inifinite Dimensional Analysis, Q u a n t u m Probability and Related Topics 7 (2004) 155-159 8. Szego, M.: Orthogonal Polynomials. Coll. Publ. 23,Amer. Math. SOC.,1975
SEMI GROUPES ASSOCIES A L’OPERATEUR DE LAPLACE-LEVY
LUIGI ACCARDI Centro Vito Volterra Facoltb d i Economia Universitd di Roma “Tor Vergata” 00133 Roma, Italy E-mail:
[email protected] HABIB OUERDIANE Dipartement de Mathimatiques FacultC des sciences de Tunis i060 Tunas, Tunisia
1. Introduction et prkliminaires
Soit H un espace de Hilbert skpkrable rkel et A un opkrateur positif auto adjoint sur H tel que son inverse A-’ soit de type Hilbert-Schmidt. Alors il existe une suite de nombres rkels positifs 0 6 A1 _< A2 5 ... 5 A,. . . et c Dom(A) tel que: une suite de vecteurs
La suite (en)n21 forme une base orthonormke de H . Pour tout rkel p E R posons:
n=l
oh (., -) est le produit scalaire dans H et I. 10 est la norme Hilbertienne sur H . Pour tout pour p 2 0, Ep = {[ E H , [Elp < oo} est un espace de Hilbert
muni de la norme [
D-h 00
npz0Ep car l’opkrateur A est de
type Hilbert-Schmidt. D’oh le triplet de Gelfand nuclkaire suivant:
E
C
H
11
H’ C E*
12
(1)
13
oil E* = Lim ind E-, =
Up>_o E-, est le dual topologique fort de E.
La
P++W
forme bilinkaire canonique sur E* x E est notde par < ., . > . L’ensemble typique de triplet de type (1) qu’on considbre en analyse du Bruit blanc, voir 191, [13] et [14] est le triplet:
E I S(R) c L2(R,dx)c E* = S(R) oh S(R) est l’espace de Schwartz des fonctions
B ddcroissance rapide sur R, L2(R,dx) est l’espace des fonctions de carrk intdgrable par rapport B la mesure de Lebesgue dx sur R et S ( R )l’espace des distributions tempdrkes. Soit l’op6rateur
et (e,),>lune d’HermiG
base orthonorm6e de L2(R,dx) formke par les fondions
Oh
+
est le polyndme d’Hermite de degr6 n. Alors Ae, = 2 ( n l)en, i. e. An = 2 n + 2, n = 0 ’ 1 ’ 2 , . . . sont des valeurs propres de l’opdrateur A et de plus W
1
< 00 si p > 1 / 2
n=O
Pour tout p 1 0, on d6finit lfl, = lAPflo oh de L2(R,dx). Alors l f l p est donnke par:
[.lo
est la norme Hilbrtienne
\n=o
If/,
Soit l’espace de Hilbert S,(R) = {j E L2(R,dx), < co} alors S(R) = nploS,(R) et S(R) est un espace de F’r6chet nucleaire. Soit SL(R) = S-,(R) le dual topologique de S,(R) muni de la norme Hilbertienne Ifl-, = IA-Pflo . On obtient alors les inclusions suivantes
S(R) C S,(R) C L2(R,dx) C S-,(R) C S ( R )= U,?oS-,(R)
14
1.1. Fonctions differentiables
Une fonctions F : E + R (ou C ) est dite de classe C 2 au point [ E E s’il existe un klkment F’([) E E* et PI’(<)E L ( E ,E * ) telle que:
avec
o(trl) = 0. lim t2
t+O
<
Si de plus on suppose que les applications: 3 F’(J)et [ + F”(<) sont continues, alors puisque E est nuclkaire complet voir [19] et [21] on a:
L(E,E * ) fl ( E @ E)* N B ( E ,E ) et donc (F”(<)q,q)= (F”(E),q63 7) = D,D,F(<)= F”([)(q,r))oh D, est la derivke au sens de Frkchet dans la direction de 11, i.e.,
(D,F)([) = lim
w+
X+O
x
-F(I)
Posons
Alors I’action de l’opkrateur de Laplace- Lkvy AL sur toute fonction F de V est dkfinie par .
N
1.2. Fonctions e n t i h s b croissance exponentielle
Soit 8 : R+ 4 R+ une fonction continue, convexe, strictment croissante et v6rifiant les conditions:
e(z) = +oo lim -
n++m
5
et O(O> = o
Une telle fonction 8 s’appelle fonction de Young c’est A, dire la fonction de Young suivante: 8*(2) = sup(t2 - 8 ( t ) ) t 20
.
(6)
Soit 8* la polaire de 8
15
On montre facilement que 8' = 8. En complexifiant le triplet reel (1) on obtient le triplet nuclkaire complexe suivant
E,
c H, IIHA c E,*
+ i E , H , = H + iH et E,* est le dual topologique fort de E,. Soit ( B ,11.11) un espace Banach complexe. Pour toute fonction de Young 8 et m > 0 notons par Ezp(B,e,m) l'ensemble de toutes les fonctions complexes f qui sont entibres sur B telles que oh E, = E
~ l f l l ~=, sup ~ If(<)le-e(mll~ll) < 00 tEB
(7)
Alors l'espace de fonctions entibres sur E,*, d'ordre de croissance 8-exponentiel de type minimal est defini par
.WE,*) =
n
Ezp(E,,-,,e,m)
(8)
p>O,m>O
qu'on munit de sa topologie limite projective. De m&mel'espace
G, (E,):=
(J
EZP(E,,,, 8, m )
(9)
p>O,m>O
muni de sa topologie limite inductive est appeld espace de fonctions entibres sur E, d'ordre de croissace 8-exponentiel de type arbitraire. Par dCfinition f E T,g(EE)et g E Ge(E,) admettent comme developpement en sdrie deTaylor B l'origine
f(z) = C(z"",fn,,z
E E,*
(10)
n>O
n>O
oh (., .) est la forme canonique de dualit4 entre (E,*)Bnx E,On et oii E,On
d4signe le produit tensoriel symbtrique d'ordre n de E,. En vue de caret Gg(E,) en fonction de leurs sdries formelles actkriser les espaces Fg(E,*) de Taylor, on intoduit les espaces de Fock interactifs suivants:
oh pour tout entier n
16
np>O,m>O Fe,m(Ec,p)muni de la topologie limite pro-
Soit alors Fo(E,) = jective. De mGme on pose
Ge(E,*)=
u
Gs,m(Ec,-p)
p>O,m>O
muni de la topologie limite inductive oh pour tout m
Gs,m(E,*,-p)=
{ 6 = (@n)n>o :
@n
> 0 et p > 0
E (Ec,-p)o",l1611e,m,-p < m}
avec n>O
I1 est facile de verifier que Fe(E,) est un espace de F'rCchet nucl6aire et que les espaces Fg(E,) et Ge(E,*)sont en dualit6, auterement dit que le dual fort de Fe(E,) est identifik B l'espace Ge(E,*).La forme de dualit6 entre Gs(E,*)et Fs(E,) est donn6e par m
n=O
L'application Skrie de Taylor 7 (A l'origine) associe B toute fonction entibre f(z) = Cn>o(z@p",fn) E Fe(E,*)ses coefficients de Taylor = (fn)n2~. Il est demo&r6 dans [ll] que l'application 7 Btablit deux isomorphismes topologiques:
f
1.3. Transformation de Laplace Soit FT*, (E:) le dual topologique fort de 3 0 (E,').La dualitk entre FT*, (E,*)et Gp(E,) est d6finie par la forme de dualit6 (11) entre les espaces de sdries formelles associks Fe (E,) et Gs (E:): 00
w E F:(E,*)et
f E F ~ ( E , * )i
((4,f)):= @,fj= C.!(dn,fn) n=O
De la condition
on dkduit que pour tout E E, la fonction exponentielle et : E,' + C , qui A tout z E E,* associe ec(x) = e("iE) est un Clement de Fs(E,*).Donc pour
17
toute fonctionelle
+ E 3:(E,*)sa transformke de Laplace est dkfinie par:
.~(+)(t) =
= (6, e') =
Pn = C(+n, C n!(+n,7) Pn) n.
(15)
On utilisea dans la suite un thkorbme de dualitk obtenu dans [ll]
Theorem 1.1. La transformation de Laplace L e'tablit un isomorphisme topologique
Fi(EE)+ Go* (Ec) 1.4. Reprdsentation intdgmle de distributions positives
Une fonction test cp de Fo(E,*) est dite positive ( et on note cp 10), si pour tout x E E , cp(x io) 1 0 . Une distribution 4 E Fi(E*)est dite positive si pour toute fonction test cp positive de Fo(EE)
+
(4,cp) 1 0 On dksigne dans la suite par Fi(E*)+l'ensemble de toute les distributions positives.
Theorem 1.2. [21] Pour toute distribution 4 E Fi(E,*)+, il existe une unique mesure de Radon p sur l'espace ( E * ,23) muni de sa tribu Borelienne telle que
vf
(4, f ) =
E Fe(E,*)
/
E '
f(x + io)dp(x)
(16)
De plus la transforme'e de Fourier de p est donne'e par:
fi(<) =
/
ei(nsc)dp(x)= ( 4 , e i t )
E'
Une sorte de rkciproque du thkorkme prkckdent est donnke par la caractkrisation de telle mesures:
Theorem 1.3. [24] Soit p une mesure positive et finie sur E* muni de sa tribu Borelienne BE.. Alors la mesure p repre'sente une distributions 4 E Fi(E,*)+ si et seulement si elle ve'rifie Ees deux conditions suivantes: 1) Il existe q > 0 telle que p soit porte'e par l'espace E - q , i.e. P ( E - ~= )1 2)3m > 0 tel que
18
2. Laplacien de LQvyagissant sur les distributions
Dans cette section, on va etudier l’action de I’opCrateur de L6vy A L sur l’espace des fonctions gCnCralis6es 7;(EZ). Notons par TLla rkstriction de I’opCrateur de LCvy d6fini dans (5) B l’espace 0 0 . (Ec).Comme d’aprbs le thCorkme 1 de dualit6 , la transformee de Laplace de toute distribution q5 E 7;(E:) est une fonction de I’espace ( E J , on dCfinit le domaine de l’opdrateur A L :
et oij (en)est une base orthonorm6e de H . Soit a = C,”=, a,e, E E*, alors en posant pour tout entier n, a, = ( a , e , ) , on a:
et cette limite peut 6tre finie ou infinie. On introduit alors l’espace suivant: 2 E E* telle
que lla11i = lim N++w
l
N
N
n=l
- ~ ( x , e , ) existe ’ et soit finie
il est clair que E c H c E i , , c E*, et que ces inclusions sont strictes, voir [7]. Consid6rons maintenant un sous espace vectoriel V de E* verifiant V c ET,,,. Comme pour tout p > 1, V c E-, alors le complet6 ? de V par B rapport B la norme I . I-, est un espace de Hilbert. On notera par la suite cet espace par El. D’oh les inclusions suivantes:
H c 9 = E,* c E-, c E* En tranposant ces injections canoniques on oblient le triplet:
E
c E, c Eo c H
M
H’ v E,* c E-, c E*
Theorem 2.1. [7] Pour tout a € E * , tel que lla11;= limN,, soit finie, on a:
ALea = ( ( u ( ( i e a
(19) I
N
(a,en)’
(20)
Soit E = Vect{ea,a E E*,11~11; < m} l’espace vectoriel engendr6 par ces fonctions exponentielles. I1 est clair E c Be* ( E )et que griice B 1’6galit6 (20)’ l’op6rateur A , est lin6aire continu sur E . On va dans la suite Ctudier
19
l'action de AL sur l'espace de fonctions gheraliskes F;(E,*). En utilisant le le thkorkme 1 on a:
Proposition 2.1. La transformation de Laplace C e'tablit un isomorphisme topologique:
Lemma 2.1. (Convergence des suites de fonctions) Soit (F,), u n e suite de G,+,(Ec).Alors (F,) converge dans G,(E,) si e t seulment s i (F,) est borne'e dans G,+,(Ec) et converge simplement. Proof. La preuve de ce lemme est basde sur la nucl6aritd des espaces F;(E,*) et Gp(E,). Une demonstration similaire de ce lemme a et6 6tablie 0 avec plus de details dans [16] et [24]. Proposition 2.2. P o u r tout
4 de F;(E,*);
est bien defini et est un e'lement de F:(E,*) Proof. Soit 4 E Fo(E,*) alors d'aprks la proposition (5) , sa transformke de Laplace $(<) E GO* (Eo) . En utilisant la densit6 des fonctions exponentielles dans l'espace G p (Eo), il existe une suite (F,), E E = V e c t { e a , a E E,*}telle que limn+oo F, = $ En utilisant d'une part la stabilitk et la continuitd de AL sur l'espace E et d'autre part le crithe de convergence des suites dans 66. ( E o )donn4 dans le lemme 6, on deduit que
,
ALF,+AL$
n++m
ceci pouve que AL$ E G p (Eo)et donc d'aprbs le thdorbme de dualitd ,L-'(AL$)
:= A
L E~F;(E:)
0
Theorem 2.2. L e s e m i groupe Pt associe' d l'ope'rateur de Ldvy-Laplace est Markovien. D e plus pour t o u t 4 de F;(E,*)+
04 d p ( x ) est la mesure qui repre'sente la distribution positive
4.
20 Proof. Soit 4 m e distribution positive (4 E .Ti(E,*)+).Il existe d'aprks le thkorkme 2 une mesure de Radon p sur ( E * ,B):
(4'cp) =
1
cp(Z)dP(Z)
E'
;
Vcp E .Ti(-%)
Or d'aprks la proposition 7,
A L =~L-'(ALJ) Donc on va d'abord calculer
A L ~En . effet on a:
d'ou:
et par conskquent si Pt est le semi groupe associk A AL il vient:
=
S,.
etllz112e(z>t)dp(z)
Pour montrer la convergence de cette dernikre intkgrale on utilise la condition (17) d'integrabilitk verifike par la mesure p associke a la distribution positive 4, i.e., 3 q > 0 , m > 0:
en effet
en posant alors
21
on a
e@”)dv(z)= (,cY)(<)= o(<) En utilisant de nouveau le thkorkme 1 de dualitk prkcedente:
, on dkduit
de l’kgalitk
/ P ( P t J ):= Ptq5 = P ( , C v )= v d’oii = y = etllzll”p(z)
comme p est une mesure positive, alors Ptq5 = v l’est aussi. Pour finir la preuve il est clair d’aprhs (22) que le semi groupe Pt transforme l’identitk en elle m&me,i.e., PtSo = So. 0 Remark 2.1. Pt transforme les distributions positives en des distributions positives. E n particulier les mesures positives en mesures positives. Dans [l]l’espace M i ( E * )des mesures SUL’ E*, invariantes par l’opkrateur (en) schift S dkfini par S(e,) = en+l a 6t6 introduit. Alors une application directe du thkorkme prkckdent permet de retrouver le thkorkme obtenu par Luigi Accardi dans [2] :
Si 4 = p E M i ( E * ) et FO = ji sa transforme‘ de Fourier, alors le problkme de Cauchy suivant:
Theorem 2.3.
admet l'unique solution donne par f
avec
3. Semi groupe de LQvyagissant sur l’espace des fonctions
On a donnk dans le paragraphe pr6ckdent une formule explicite du semigroupe de Lkvy Pt agissant sur les distributions positives (et donc en particulier sur certaines mesures de Radon sur E l ) . Soit ‘p une function de Young donnke. Le but de ce paragraphe est de dkfinir et de donner explicitement le semi- groupe associk au Laplacien de Lkvy defini sur l’espace G,(Eo,~)des fonctions g : + C qui sont entihres sur A croissance
22 9-exponentiel d'ordre quelconque. Comme E o , est ~ le complexifid de Eo, la restriction de tout element g E G,(Eo,~)B EO est definie par:
gIEo := g(Z
+ io), 2 E EO.
Definition 3.1. Soit f : E + C . On dit que f est une fonction cmactdristique si f est continue, ddfinie positive et verifiant f(0)= 1 Posons alors G:(E0) l'ensemble de toute les fonctions g de G,(Eo,~) dont la restriction glEo est une fonction caratdristique.
Proposition 3.1. Soit g un e'lement de G;(Eo). Alors la mesure de probabilite' qua lui est associe'e, pg ve'rijie la conditions d'inte'grabilite' suivante: 3m>0 etpEN*,
I
e'P'(ml"I-P)dpg(Z)
< co
%--P
D e plus la transforme'e de Fourier F ( p g ) de pg est donne'e par: F'(LLg)(t)
= 35) =
J
ei("9%g(z)
i
v t E Eo
EO,-p
Proof. En effet en utilisant le thdorhme de Bochner-Minlos, voir [14], il existe une unique mesure de probabilite pg sur le dual fort de Eo et qui est associke B la fonction caractdristique S I X , . Plus prbcisement, comme g E G,(Eo)alors
Alors on sait qu'il existe un entier q > p tel que I'injection i, : Eo,q + Eo,p est de type Hilbert-Schmidt et , L L ~ ( E O= , - 1. ~ )Pour montrer la condition d'intkgrabilitb vdrifide par la mesure pg on a besoin d'avoir une estimation et n E N des moments de pg. En effet on a V < E
En utilisant maintenant la formule de Cauchy, alors pour tout
,W)
en posant 9 k = infrBo7 , k E N on a:
T
>0:
23 En utilisant maintenant la formule d'identitk de polarisation et l'indgalitd (23) on obtient
1
lzlzqdpu,(z) 5 (11911q,p,mcpzn(2n)!)112( h m l l i q p l l H S ) n , \ ~ EnN
(25)
oh ~ ~ i P est qla ~ norme ~ ~Hilbert-Schmidt s de l'injection i p q .Pour compldter
la preuve de cette proposition on a pour tout t 2 0 et
E
> 0:
D'autre part on peut montrer facilement que 1
\Jt2 0 , e-q(t)tn < -(Pn
D'oh:
En utilisant maintenant l'estimation (24) des moments de la mesure puset le fait que: &12npn
7
\Jn€N:
on a
comme
d'oh en choissant 44mlliq,pllHS
<1
alors la serie (25) converge et on a:
I
EO,
-*
ep*(EIZI-q)dpg(2)<
00
Ceci provient du fait que sup{etElzl-q-q(t) = exp(sup{tElzl-, - cp(t)}= exp cp* ( ~ l z l - ~ ) t>o
t
par ddfinition meme de la fonction polaire cp* associde
cp.
0
24
Theorem 3.1. Le semi-groupe Pt associe‘ d l’ope‘rateur de Le‘vy-Laplace agissant sur l’espace des fonctions G;(Eo)= ( 9 E G,(Eo),glx0 soit definie positive} est Markovien. De plus o n a la formule explicite du semi-groupe
9: V g E G$(Eo) , ( k t g ) ( t )= ( e t A L g ) ( t )=
/
e-tll”lls,i(.~r)dpg(2)
(27)
E,.
04 (mg)(t)
= 9(t)
Proof. Soit g une fonction appartenant ? l’espace i G;(Eo). Alors d’aprb la proposition (12)’ on sait qu’B tout 6lkment g de B: (Eo),il lui est associCe une unique mesure de Radon pg telle que:
d’ob
D’aprCs l’Cgalit6 (20) on dgduit que
d’oh:
Pour montrer enfin la convergence de cette expression on utilise le fait que la mesure p 9 vgrifie d’aprgs la proposition (12) la condition d’intggrabilitk:
3m > 0 e t p > 0,
I
ev*(mlzl-p)dpg(2)< 00
E O F P
On en d6duit alors que: 3 c > 0, m > 0 et p
> 0 tel que
e,*(mlzl-p)dpg(x) < o o , ~ Et
I(Ptg)(t)l< c / E0r-P
EO
25 et c = c(t, E). Finalement pour montrer que le Processus Pt est Markovien, il suffit de montrer que si g = 1, i.e., g(() = 1, VE, alors pg = So. En appliquant la formule explicite (27) du semi-groupe Ft,on a
d’autre part comme pour tout g dans G$(Eo):
En posant dvg(x):= e-tllzlltdpg(x) , i.e., dv9W = e-t11211:
4%(x) oiI
dP&l(X)
est la d6rivde au sens de Radon-Nikodym. Alors on a: ($‘g)(() =
]
ei(”z[)dv(z)= .T(vg)(E)
E,*
qui est par d6finition une fonction caract6ristique’ et donc le semi-groupe Pt transforme les fonctions definies positives en fonctions definies positives, i.e.:
Pt : G p o )
-+ G,+(Eo)
(28)
D’autre part si P t g = P t h alors 7 v g = Fvh, et comme la transformation de Fourier est injective ceci donne: vg = V h et donc e-tIIzI12dpg (x)= e-tIIzII:dph (z)
d’oh p g = p h et par suite F 1 ( p g ) = T-l(ph), donc g = h. Donc l’application ddfinie par (27) est injective. Montrons qu’elle est aussi surjective. En effet d’aprks la proposition prdcddente, pour tout G de G$ (Eo) alors il existe une mesure p telle que 3 ( p ~ =) G. Cherchons alors s’il existe un antbcedent g (3 G$(Eo)de G , i.e.,
P t g = G equivaut B - T ( ~ G=) Ptg = 3 ( u g ) d’oh p~ =
or
dug- - e-tllz112 - dPG dP9
dP9
26
d’oii puse t donc g par Laplace inverse.
0
Corollary 3.1. En combinant les ope‘rateursPt agissant sur Ees distributions positives et agissant sur les fonctions @(Eo) on a Ee diagramme suivant:
m%)+ -5Wa+
T
7-l
oi F est la transformation de Fourier. D’o% la relation :
References 1. L. Accardi, P. Gibilisco and I. V. Volovich: The Ldvy Laplacian and the Yang-Mills equations, Rendiconti dell’Accademia dei Lincei,( 1993). 2. L. Accardi :Yang Mills equations and LCvy-Laplacians, Dirichlet Forms and Stochastics Processes,(l995), 1-23, Eds.: Ma/Roekner/Yan.Walter de Gruyter and Co., New York . 3. L. Accardi and V. I. Bogachev: The Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process associated with the Lkvy Laplacian, and its Direchlet form, Probability and Math. Statistics , Vo1.17, Fasc.1 (1997), 95-114. 4. L. Accardi and 0. G. Smolyanov: On the Laplacians and traces, Rend. Sem. Mat. Bari, Ottobre 1993, Preprint- Volterra. 5. L. Accardi, P. Roselli and O.G. Smolyanov: The Brownian Motion Generated by the Ldvy-Laplacian, Mat.Zamatki, 54 (1993), 144-148 6. L. Accardi and N. Obata: Derivation Property of the Ldvy-Laplacian, White noise analysis and quantum probability, (N. Obata, ed.) RIMS Kokyuroku 874, Publ. Res. Inst. Math. Sci.(1994), 8-19. 7. L. Accardi and H. Ouerdiane: Fonctionelles analytiques assocides B I’opCrateur de LaplaceLdvy, Preprint No. 477 (2001), Centro Vito Volterra. 8. S. Albeverio, Y. L. Daletsky, Y. G. Kondratiev and L. Streit: Non-Gaussian infinite dimensional analysis. Journal of functional analysis 138 (1996), 311-350. 9. D. M. Chung U. C. Ji. and K. SaitB: Cauchy problems associated with the Ldvy Laplacian on white noise analysis. Infinite Dim. Analysis, Quantum Prob. and Related Topics. Vol. 2, No. l(1999). 10. W. G. Cochran., H-H. Kuo and A. Sengupta: A New Class of White noise Generalized Functions. Infinite Dim. Analysis, Quantum Prob. and Related Topics. Vol.1, No. 1(1998), 43-67. 11. R.Gannoun, R. Hachaichi, H. Ouerdiane and A. Rezgui: Un thdorhme de dualitd entre espaces de fonctions holomorphes B croissance exponentielle. J. Funct. Anal., Vo1.171, No.1 (2000), 1-14.
,
27
12. R. Gannoun, R. Hachaichi, P. Kree and H. Ouerdiane: Division dc fonctions holomorphes ti croissance 8- exponentielle. Preprint, BiBos NO : 00-01-04. (2000). 13. I. M. Gel’fand and N. Ya. Vilenkin: Generalized Functions, volume 4, Academic Press. New York and London (1964). 14. T. Hida: Brownian Motion, Springer Verlag, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York, 1980. 15. T. Hida, H- H. Kuo, J. Potthoff and L. Streit: White noise, An infinitedimensional calculus, Kluwer Academic Publishers Group,l993. 16. P. Krbe and H. Ouerdiane: Holomorphy and Gaussian analysis. Prkpublication de 1’Institut de mathkmatique de Jussieu. C.N.R.S. Univ. Paris 6 (1995). 17. H- H. Kuo, N. Obata and K. SaitB: Lkvy Laplacian of generalized functions on a nuclear space, 3. Funct. Anal. 94 (1990) 74-92. 18. P. Lbvy: Leqons d’analyse fonctionnelle, Gauthier-Villars, Paris (1922). 19. N. Obata: White noise calculus and Fock space. L. N. Math. 1577 (1994). 20. H. Ouerdiane: Fonctionnelles analytiques avec conditions de croissance et application B l’analyse gaussienne. Japanese Journal of Math. Vol. 20, No. 1, (1994), 187-198 . 21. H. Ouerdiane: Noyaux et symboles d’opkrateurs sur des fonctionnelles analytiques gaussiennes. Japanese Journal of Math. Vol21. No.1. (1995), 223-234 22. H. Ouerdiane: Alghbre nuclkaires et kquations aux dkriv6es partielles stochastiques. Nagoya Math. Journal Vol. 151 (1998), 107-127. 23. H. Ouerdiane :Distributions gaussiennes et applications aux Bquations aux dkrivkes partielles stochastiques in Proc. International conference on Mathematical Physics and stochastics Analysis ( in honor of L. Streit’s 60 th birthday ) S. Albeverio et al.(eds.) World Scientific (2000). 24. H. Ouerdiane and A. Rezgui: Reprksentations integrales de fonctionnelles analytiques. Stochastic Process, Physic and Geometry : New interplays. A volume in honor of S.Albeverio. Canadian Math. Society. Conference Proceedings Series. Vol. 28 (2000), 283-290. 25. K. Sait6 and A. Tsoi: The Lkvy Laplacian as a self-adjoint operator, Proceeding of the first Int. Conf. Quantum Information. World Scientific (1999). 26. L. Schwartz: Radon measures on arbitrary topological spaces and cylindrical measures, Oxford Univ. Pr.,1973.
STOCHASTIC GOLDEN RULE FOR A SYSTEM INTERACTING WITH A FERMI FIELD
L. ACCARDI Centro Vito Volterra Universitd d i Roma "Tor Vergata" Via Columbia, 2, 00133, Roma, Italy E-mail: accardiQvolterra.mat.uniroma2.it R.A. ROSCHIN Steklov Mathematical Institute Russian Academy of Sciences Gubkin St. 8, 117966, GSP-1, Moscow, Russia E-mail: roschin0mi.ras.ru I.V. VOLOVICH Steklov Mathematical Institute Russian Academy of Sciences Gubkin St. 8, 117966, GSP-1, Moscow, Russia E-mail: volovich0mi.ras.m We consider the (causally) normally ordered form of the quantum white noise equation for a Fermi white noise. We find a new form of the normally ordered equation for some class of Hamiltonians and we obtain the inner Langevin equation for such Hamiltonians.
1. Introduction
The stochastic limit approach is a powerful method that allows to study the quantum dynamics of an open system. This method proved to be very efficient in study of various systems, interacting with Bose fie1ds.l In the present paper we concentrate on the Fermi case. In this case the superselection rules restrict the class of fundamental Fermi Hamiltonians. This restriction is discussed in Sec. 2. The main goal of the stochastic limit approach is to study the quantum dynamics of open systems. Such a dynamics is given by an evolution operator U ( t ) ,which satisfies the evolution equation in the interaction rep28
29
resentation:
& U ( t ) = -iAK,,t(t)U(t), U ( 0 ) = 1
.
(1)
Here x,t(t) is the evolution of the interaction Hamiltonian under the free evolution. However, even in the simplest non-trivial cases, there are no exact solutions of Eq. (1). Therefore, we have to use some approximations. One can express the solution of Eq. (1) using the iterated series and Feynman diagrams. The Feynman diagrams are a graphical representation of the combinatorial procedure, which is called "normal ordering". Usually, only a few terms of these series can be explicitly calculated. The stochastic limit approach provides another, more efficient and elegant way of solving Eq. (1).
Consider the evolution of an open quantum system in the rescaled time: In the stochastic limit approach we are interested in the limits of the rescaled evolution operator and of the rescaled interaction Hamiltoniama
t
+ t/A2.
In many physically important cases, one can prove that Ut satisfy the (Bose) quantum white noise equation:
&Ut = -ihtUt, Uo = 1 ,
(3)
where the limit of the interaction Hamiltonian, hi, can be expressed in terms of (Bose) quantum white noises. Although Eq. (3) seems to be very similar to its predecessor, Eq. (l),it can be explicitly solved. Again, we are going to find the normally ordered form of Eq. (3). It is called causal normal order to emphasize the fact that the commutation relations used to bring to normal order the terms of the iterated series, only have a meaning for time ordered products of creation and annihilation operators. The causally normally ordered form of Eq. (3) can be found explicitly. The technique that allows to find and bring to causal normal order Eq. (3) is called the stochastic golden rule. The aim of the present paper is to develop the stochastic golden rule for the cases when the interaction in (1) is of dipole type (cf. (8) below) and driven by a Fermi field. aThe exact sense of these limits is the subject of Statement 1
30
2. Hamiltonian of the model
Let 31 be a Hilbert space of the form
(4)
?I!=?I!S@%!R
where 7-Is is a finite dimensional Hilbert space, and 3 1 is~ an infinite dimensional Hilbert space. Suppose H is a Hamiltonian of the form
H =Hs @ 1
+ 1 @ HR + XVjnt
7
(5)
where X is a positive real parameter. We denote the first two terms of this Hamiltonian by Ha, and refer HO as ”free Hamiltonian”. Then, the pair (31,H) describes an open quantum system. In other words, an open quantum system is a ”small”, discrete spectrum quantum system, interacting with some infinite dimensional environment, or field. The simplest model that gives the Fermi white noise equation in the stochastic limit is a two-level system, interacting with a Fermi field. Let us introduce this model, using the notation of Eqs. (4,5). Let the Denote the elements of the orthonormal system Hilbert space be 31s = basis for this space by ti), i = 1,2. Let the environment Hilbert space be the Fermi (antisymmetric) Fock space
a?.
M
n=O
Denote the Fermi creation and annihilation operators in this space by ul and U k , k E R3,respectively. They satisfy anticommutation relations:b
{al,uk’) = 6 ( k - k ’ ) , { a k , a k f } = o . Let the free Hamiltonian be:
HO = H s 4-H R = E 11)(11 @ 1 + 1 8
s
w(k)aiuk dk .
(7)
Here E is a positive real number, w ( k ) = k2+m2, m 2 0. Let the interaction Hamiltonian be:
the following, {,} denote anticommutator, {x,y} = xy +yx, and [,] denote commutator, [x,y]= zy - yx.
31
where D is a bounded operator, acting on the system space, and g(k) is a smooth complex function with finite support. In the following, we omit the tensor product in our formulae. The superselection rules (see Ref. 2, require that fundamental Hamiltonians should be even in the Fermi operators.c If the Hamiltonian is even, then D should be odd in the Fermi operators. Hence, D and a,at should anticommute.d We will see that this case leads to a stochastic golden rule similar to the one known in the Bose case. Effective (for example, non-relativistic) Hamiltonians may be odd in Fermi operators, in these cases D and a,at may commute. An example of such Hamiltonian was considered in Ref. 4. If D and a,at commute, then we get the new kind of the stochastic golden rule. We will study both cases; first the ”commutative”, then the ”anticommutative” one. As mentioned in the introduction, there are two main components in the stochastic golden rule: the existence of the limit and the causal normal order form of the white noise equation. The first part, the existence of the limit, is quite similar for Bose and Fermi cases. Both cases were studied in Ref. 1. Here we just formulate the result for Fermi case. Statement 1. The limit (2) of the evolution operator in the model defined by Eqs. (6-8), exists in the sense of correlators. Moreover, the limit of the rescaled evolution operator Ut satisfies the white noise equation atUt = -ihtUt, with the white noise Hamiltonian of the form ht = D’bt
(9)
+ bfD,
where bt, bi are Fermi Fock white noise creation and annihilation operators. This means that they are operator valued distributions, acting on the Fock space r = F ( L 2 ( R ) )and satisfying the following relations:
{ bf, b”’} = y-6+(t
- t’) ; {bt, bt’} = 0 .
(11)
where d+(t) is the causal &function (see Ref. 1) and
‘An operator is called even, if it commutes with the parity operator, and odd, if it anticommutes. The parity operator in this case can be defined as in Sec. 3. dAn obvious generalization of Eqs. (4-8) is needed to include this case.
32 The relation between D and b, bt is the same as the relation between D and a,at: they either commute, or anti-commute.
3. The "Commutative" case The causally normally ordered form of the Fermi white noise equation and the Langevin equation in the "commutative" case are the main results of the present paper. Let us formulate these results as a theorem. First of all, let us give some definitions. Consider a monomial of the form:
bt: biz
. ..bi," ,
were, bii denote either bt, or bj. Denote the vacuum state in I? by 90. There exists a unique operator 0 , called parity operator, such that for any monomial
Ob;ibf,2 ...b:,"Qo = (-l)nb;:b;,2.. Note, that O2= 1, hence 0-l = 0 = O*. I f A is an operator, then the map: A automorphism. We will use the notation:
+
A := O A O .
.b;,"@o.
(13)
C3AO-l = OAO is a
*-
(14)
Theorem 2. Keep the notation and the assumptions of Statement 1. Suppose the operator D is such that
[D,bt]= [D,bl] = 0 . A
h
and define Ut U := OUO. Then, (1) The following relations are satisfied:
(15)
33
(2) The causally normally ordered form of (9) is the system
+ Dbf Ut) - y-DtDUt = i (DtUtbt + D b f c t ) - y - D t D c t
&Ut = -i ( D t ctbt
{
@t
(17)
h
with the initial conditions Ut = Ut = 1. (3) Let X be an operator on the system space. Consider the following matrices:
T:= Then,
(Jij
(;:),
S:=
(:_4)
(19)
( X ) )satisfies the following inner Langevin equation:
at ( ~ ( x=)-7-) ( J ( x D ~ D ) -) 7: ( ~ ( o t ~ x ) ) (7- + y ? ) J i i ( D t x D ) (-7-+ 7 T ) J i 2 ( D t X D ) + ((-7: + y - ) J 2 i ( D t X D ) (7- + f ) J 2 2 ( D t X D ) ) + ibfST ( & ( D X ) ) - ibfT ( J & ( X D ) )S
+iS ( A j ( D t X ) )Tbt - i ( , 7 , j ( X D t ) )TSbt . (20) -
(4) The master equation for the partial expectation (U,*XUt), = X is:
&X
= -y-XDtD - y-DtDX
+ 2 (!J?y-) D t X D .
(21)
The proof of Theorem 2 is given in the next section. Remark. The causally normally ordered form of the Fermi white noise This is the new feature of the equation is a pair of equations for U and Fermi case.
c.
4. Proof of Theorem 2. 4.1. Quasi-commutation mles for bt and U t .
Let us express the evolution operator as Ut = lim U,( N ) , N+a, N
Ir
u:N)= z(-i)" dtl f ' n=O
0
0
dt2.. . fn-' dt,
(fi
0
j=1
(Dtbtj + D b l j ) )
34
The time-consecutive principle (see Ref. 2) states that expanding the product btUr according to (22), any term of the form btb;: b;,2 . . . b::
with t 2 tl 2
t2
,
(23)
2 . . . 2 tn7 ~i E { ,t}, is equal to (-l)nb,E:bL,2.. .bE,"bt
+ { b t , b::} b:,Z . ..biz
,
where the anti-commutation relation for the fields bt is given by (11). Using this, we obtain:
'&-i)n
l' l dtl
tl
d t 2 . ..
Ln-'
dt,(-l)n j=1
n=l
(fi
{ bt, bfl}
+ (-i)(-i)n-lD
(D'bt,
j=2
= 6:N)bt - i D y - ~ [ ~ , ~ l ( t ) U .: ~ - ' ) Here X[,,~I is the characteristic function of the given interval [ O , T ] . In the limit N -+ 00 we obtain Eq. (16.1) A
btUt = Utbt - i r - D U t , For btU,* we obtain:
btUjN)*=
?(i)" n=l
IT Jo" Jd'=-' dtl
dtg
. ..
(h
+ (i)(i)n-l
j=n
(Dtbtj
+ Db!,))
D { bt, bf,}
j=n
and in the limit we get Eq. (16.2):
btU,* = @bt
+ iy-U,*D.
Let A , B be some operators. Since 0' = 1, observe that
P ( A B ) = OABO = OAG2B0 = P ( A ) P ( B ) .
35
and
(PA)* = P ( A * ) . l?rom the general formula (13) we get
(25)
Pbf = -bf .
Pbt = -bt, Let us apply P operator to bt6t and have:
bt6,*,
(26) and use Eqs. (16.1,16.2). We
(-Utbt - ir-DUt)
bt6t = -P (btUt) = -P
= - (-U& - iT-DUt) = Utbt + i y - D 6 t . 6
Hence, we get Eq. (16.3):
btUt = Utbt bt6,* = -P (btU,*)= -P
+ iy-D6t.
(6,*bt + ir-U,*D = - (-U,*bt
1
+ ir-U,*D - 1 = U,*bt- i ~ - 6 , * D
Hence, we get Eq. (16.4): A
btU,* = U,*bt - ir-U,*D. Eqs. (16.1*)-(16.4*) are adjoint of Eqs. (16.1)-(16.4). In Appendix A we prove the relations (16) using the integral form of the evolution equation, as done in Ref. 1 for bosons. 4.2. Normally ordered equation f o r Ut
.
Let us rewrite the evolution equation (9),using (16.1).
atUt = -i (Dtbt
+ Dbf) Ut = -i
(Dt6tbt
+ DbfUt) - T-DtDUt.
Eq. (27) is not close because it involves both Ut and operator to it, and using (24-26), we obtain:
(27)
6t.e Applying the P
&6t = i (DiUtbt + DbtGt) - T - D t D 6 t .
(28)
The system of Eqs. (27,28) is closed and causally normally ordered in the sense that all the bf operators are on the left hand side and all the bt are on the right hand side of the Ut system. eThe operators U and 6 are dependent, hence if one substitutes the definition of 6into (27), then the result will be closed. R.R. is grateful to Prof. Y.G.Lu for pointing this out.
36 4.3. Inner Langevin equation.
The inner Langevin equation is a result of a direct computation. The idea of this computation is to apply Eqs. (27,28) to express &Ut, then to use Eq. (16) to find the causally normally ordered form of the terms. Let us compute a t J l l ( X ) ( t ) :
atgll(x)(t) = at (u,*xut) = atu,*xut + u,*xatvt
+ U,*Dtbt) - f U , * D t D ) XUt + U,*X (-i(Dt6tbt + bfDUt)- r-DtDUt) = (i(bi6,*D
= ibf6,*DXUt +iU,*DtXbtUt - f U , * D t D X U t
- iU,*XDtGtbt - iU,*bfXDUt - r-U,*XDtDUt Using
iU,*DtXbtUt = iU,*DtX6tbt
+ r-U,*DtXDUt
and
-iU,*bfXDUt we obtain:
Let us compute
Using
and
-ibfG,*XDUt
1
(X)(t):
+ rZU,*DtXDUt
37
we obtain:
Let uss compute
(X)(t):
Using
and
W e ob tain :
The computation of (X)(t) is simila and therefore omitted. Combining all terms in the matrix equation, we find:
Using the matrices T and S, defined in (19), one can rewrite the last two terms as (in the notation (18))
+
i b f ( S T J ( D X )- T J ( X D ) S ) i ( S , 7 ( D t X ) T - , 7 ( X D t ) T S ) b t . this can be checked directly by matrix multiplication.
(33)
4.4. Canonical form of the Jangevin equation.
We would like to represent the following inner Langevin equation: at
( & ( X ) ) = -7- (Zj(XDtD)) - 7' ( & ( D t D X ) )
+
(-7-+ 7')&2(DtXD) (-7' + r - ) & @ X D ) (7- + 7')&2(DtXD) + ibfST ( s j ( D X ) )- ibfT ( A j ( X D ) )S is ( z j ( D t X ) )Tbt - i ( z j ( X D t ) )TSbt
(y- 7 ' ) J l , ( D t X D )
)
+
(34)
in the canonical form at
(zj(x))=
(Jkl(@iij(x))
+ blJkl(8Lij(x))+ Jkl(8,,j(X))bt)
*
kl=1,2
(35) Let us find structure maps 8O, 8%. The map Zj is linear, hence 8O, 8% can be obtained by rewriting the matrix multiplications in (34) in the index form: ( a i j ) ( b j l )= (Cjaijbjl). Thus, where
and
where
nij
:=
(0 ) , -1
(nij) = T
s = (Sij) = oz = (::1).
S,
39 4.5. The Master equation.
The master equation is the vacuum expectation of the inner Langevin equation (32). The last two terms, containing bt and b i , vanish. It is enough to take vacuum expectation only for one matrix element. The most interesting is A I ( X ) . Denote by X the vacuum expectation (,711(X))0.We obtain:
8tX = - y - X D t D - y - D t D X + 2 8 y - D t X D .
(36)
5. "Anti-commutative"case Theorem 3. Keep the notation and assumptions of Statement 1. Suppose the operator D is such that
{D,bt} = { D , b i } = O .
(37)
Then, the following relation is satisfied
Proof. Let us express the evolution operator as:
Using the time-consecutive principle (see (23)), we obtain: bt U i N ) =
c(-i)" /' dtl [' N
=
n=l
0
dtg . . .
0
rn-'
(fi
dt,(-1)2n
{b,,bil}
+ b i j D ) ) bt
j=1
0
+ (-l)(-i)(-i)n-lD
(Dtbtj
(fi
(Dtblj
+ bl,D
j=2
= U:N)bt Taking the limit N
+ iDy-~[o,~](t)U$~-l) (39)
-+ oi, of Eq. (39) we obtain: bt Ut = Utbt
which is (38). The theorem is proved.
+ iy- DUt
40
The relation (38) between b and U is similar to the Bose case.’ In the case of Bose quantum white noise, the causally normally ordered form of the white noise equation (3) can be obtained using only the relation between Bose white noise and the evolution operator. Using the proof for the Bose case, one can easily prove that replacing Bose by Fermi quantum white noise operators, the causally normally ordered form of the white noise equations is the same.
6. Conclusions We studied the Fermi quantum white noise equations with a dipole-type interaction Hamiltonian (10). In the ”commutative” case we obtain a new form of causally normally ordered white noise equation (17) and of inner Langevin equation (20). In the ”anti-commutative’’ case we found the commutation relation (38). From Eq. (38) we get that in the ”anticommutative” case the causally normally ordered form of a Fermi white noise equations is the same as in the Bose case.
Acknowledgements This research was carried out while one of the authors (R.R.) was visiting at Centro Vito Volterra. R.R and I.V. were partially supported by the RFFI grant 02-01-01084 and the grant 1542.2003.1 for scientific schools.
Appendix A. Proof of the relations (16) using integral equation The evolution operator Ut satisfies the following integral equation
i?t
Ut = 1- i
I’
dt’(Dbi, + Dtbr)Uti .
Gt = 1+ i
1
dt’(Dbi, + Dtbtl)ctj
satisfies
t
Consider the iterated series U ( N )for the solution of the integral equation with the initial condition u(0)=
and relation
1
41
and the same series for 6 with the initial condition 6p)= 1. The limit of the series (which exists under our assumptions) is the solution of the integral equation
We want to prove that for t 2 T h
btUT = UTbt - ~ ~ - D X [ O , T ] ( ~ ) U T .
(-4.1)
Let us prove the following relation for the iterated series (for t
btU$N)= @"bt
-iy-D~[o,~](t)U$~-~).
This equation clearly holds for N = 1. Suppose it holds for all N Let us proof it for N = M :
btU$M)= bt (1 - i
Jd'
2r):
5M
- 1.
dt'(Dbf, + Dtbtt)U,(,M-')
= bt - i
I'
)
+
dt' bt(Dbf, Dtbtt)U{?-"
- ir-DX[o,T](t)UT (M-1)
= G!M)bt
+ 0 - iy-D~[o,~](t)U$~-~) . (A.2)
The second term is equal to 0, because t 2 r. Taking the limit N -+ 00, we obtain (A.1). Substituting t for T in ( A . l ) , we get (16.1). References 1. L. Accardi, Y.G. Lu and 1.V. Volovich, Quantum Theory and Its Stochastic Limit, Springer-Verlag, 2003. 2. Bogoliubov, N. N., Logunov, A. A., Oksak, A. I., Todorov, 1. T., General Principles of Quantum Field Theory, Kluwer, Dordrecht 1990 3. R.L. Hudson and K.R. Parthasarathy, Unification of boson and f e n i o n stochastic calculus, Commun. Math. Phys., 104, 457-470 (1986). 4. A.F.Andreev, Mesoseopic superconductivity in superspace, JETP Lett. 68, 673 (1998)
GENERATING FUNCTION METHOD FOR ORTHOGONAL POLYNOMIALS AND JACOBI-SZEGO PARAMETERS
NOBUHIRO ASAI Research Institute for Mathematical Sciences Kyoto University Kyoto 606-8502, Japan E-mail: asaiQkurims. kyoto-u. ac.jp IZUMI KUBO Graduate School of Environmental Studies Hiroshima Institute of Technology Hiroshima 731-5193, Japan E-mail: kubo Qcc.it- hiros hima. ac.jp HUI-HSIUNG KUO Department of Mathematics Louisiana State University Baton Rouge, LA 70803, USA E-mail: kuoOmath.1su. edzl Let p be a probability measure on R with finite moments of all orders. Suppose p is not supported by a finite set of points. Then there exists a unique sequence {Pn(z)}rz0 of orthogonal polynomials such that P,(z) is a polynomial of degree n with leading coefficient 1 and the equality ( 2 - an)P,(z)= P,+i(z) +w,P,-i(z) holds. The numbers {anr u,}?=~ are called the Jacobi-Szego parameters of p . The family {Pn(z),an,u,}:=~ determines the interacting Fock space of p . In this paper we use the concept 'of generating function to give several methods for computing the orthogonal polynomials Pn(z)and the Jacobi-Szego parameters a, and wn. We also describe how to identify the orthogonal polynomials in terms of differential or difference operators.
1. Accardi-Boiejko unitary isomorphism
Let p be a probability measure on R with finite moments of all orders. Assume that p is not supported by a finite set of points and that the linear span of the monomials (2";n 2 0 ) is dense in the complex Hilbert space L 2 ( p ) .Then we can apply the Gram-Schmidt orthogonalization procedure
42
43
to the monomials {1,x,x2,.. . , x n,...}, in this order, to get orthogonal polynomials {Po(x),P1(x),. . . ,P,(x), . . .}. Here P,(x) is a polynomial of degree n with leading coefficient 1. It is well-known (see, e.g., the books by Chihara5 and by Szego7) that these orthogonal polynomials satisfy the recursion formula
(x - a n ) P n ( x ) = pn+l(x) + wnPn-l(x),
n >_ 0 ,
(1)
where a, E R, w, > 0 and by convention wo = 1, P-1 = 0. The numbers a, and w, are called the Jacobi-Szego parameters of p. associated with the measure p by Define a sequence A, = wow1 .-.w,,
n 2 0.
(2)
It can be easily checked that A, = JRIPn(x)12dp(z). Assume that the sequence satisfies the condition that infn>O - A" :/ > 0. Define a complex Hilbert space rp by
with norm
I\ . 1) given by
+
Let @, = (0,. . ., O , l , O , . . .) with 1 in the (n 1)st component. Define the creation, annihilation, and neutral operators a+, a-, and ao acting on F p , respectively, by
a+@, =
a-Gn = wn@,-l,
a'@, = anan, n 2 0 ,
where @.-I = 0 by convention and an's and w,'s are the Jacobi-Szego parameters of p. It can be easily shown that the operators a+ and a- are adjoint t o each other. The Hilbert space F p together with the operators {a+, a-, a o } is called the interacting Fock space associated with the measure p. It has been shown by Accardi and Bozejkol that there exists a unitary isomorphism U : F p + L 2 ( p )satisfying the conditions: (1) U@O = 1, ( 2 ) Ua+U*P, = Pn+1, (3) Ua-U*P, = WnPn-1, (4) U(a+ a- a0)u* = X,
+ +
44
where the polynomials Pn(z)’s are given in Equation (1) and X is the multiplication operator by z. Note that the Hilbert space is determined only by the numbers w,’s, while the numbers an’s and the polynomials P,(z)’s are related to the unitary operator U . It is natural to ask the following question: Question: Given a probability measure p on B!, how to compute the associated orthogonal polynomials and the Jacobi-Szego parameters {Pn, *n, wn}?
In Section 2 we will explain the generating function method to derive the orthogonal polynomials. In Section 3 we will describe two ways for the computation of the Jacobi-Szego parameters. In Section 4 we will discuss the computation of the Orthogonal polynomials by differential and difference operators. In Section 5 we will list some important classical examples from the viewpoint of generating functions. 2. Pre-generating and generating functions
Let p be a probability measure on R satisfying the conditions mentioned in Section 1. In a series of papers2>324we have introduced the generating function method to derive the associated orthogonal polynomials {Pn(z)} and the Jacobi-Szego parameters {an,wn). A pre-generating function is a function cp(t,x) which admits a power series expansion in t as follows:
n=O
where gn(z) is a polynomial of degree n and limsup,,, ~ ~ g n <~CCJ. ~ ~ & ~ A generating function for p is a pre-generating function of the form W
n=O
where P,(z)’sare the orthogonal polynomials associated with ,u as given in Equation (1). Note that a generating function for p is not unique because we can always replace t in Equation (3) with ct for a nonzero constant c # 1 to get a different function $ ( t , z ) . However, it is possible to have two essentially different generating functions for the same measure. For
45
example, the following functions
$Nt,x) =
(
2 ( 1 - 2tx
+ t2)(1- tx + J1-
)
2tx + t 2 )
are generating functions for the measure dp(x) = SJ-dx, 1x1 5 1. Suppose p(t,x) is a pre-generating function. Consider its multiplicative renormalization defined by
Theorem 2.1. The multiplicative renormalization $(t,x ) is a generating function for p i f and only if E,[$(t, -)+(s, -)I is a function of ts.
If we can check that E,[@(t,-)$(s, .)I is a function of ts, then by the above theorem $ ( t ,x) is a generating function. We can expand $(t,2) as a power series in t to get
n=O
where Qn(x)is a polynomial of degree n. Let a, be the leading coefficient of Qn(x) and let P,(x) = &,(%)/a,. Then the polynomials {P,(x)}are the orthogonal polynomials satisfying Equation (1) for the measure p. In the papers2i3s4 we have applied the generating function method to pre-generating functions of the form
d t , 2) = h(P(tb)9 where h(x) = ez or h(x) = (1- x)c and p(t) is a function to be derived so that the condition in Theorem 2.1 is satisfied. Case 1:
h ( z ) = ez measure Gaussian Poisson gamma negative binomial
I
polynomials Hermite Charlier Laguerre Meixner
46
Case 2: h ( z )= (1 - z)' measure
polynomials
uniform arcsine semi-circle beta-type
Legendre Chebyshev of 1st kind Chebyshev of 2nd kind Gegenbauer
The above polynomials are derived from the power series expansion of the resulting generating functions. Consequently they are expressed in terms of sums of monomials. In Section 4 we will use differential and difference operators to identify these polynomials. Recently all measures of exponential type have been derived in the paper6. In particular, the probability law of the L h y stochastic area is
in this class.
3. Computation of orthogonal polynomials and Jacobi-Szegii parameters Suppose $(t,z) is a generating function for p. The object is t o compute the orthogonal polynomials {Pn(z)} and the Jacobi-Szego parameters {a,, wn} from $(t,z). Recall that A, = wow1 .w,, n 2 0, as defined by Equation (2). The following theorem has been proved in our paper3.
Theorem 3.1. Let $(t,z) = C,"==, anPn(z)tnbe a generating function for p. Then we have t+O lim
+(t,
f) =
c 00
anzn,
n=O
n=O
n=O
where a-1 = 0 by convention.
Thus once we have found a generating function for p, then we can compute {P,,a,, w,} as follows:
47
Namely, first expand $(t,x) as a power series in t to get a, and P,(x),which is expressed as a sum of monomials. If we are not interested in finding P,, then we do not have to expand $(t,x) as a power series in t. We can simply use Equation (4)to find a,. Then we use Equation (5) to find A,, which can be used in turn to find w, since w, = An/An--l, n 2 1, wg = 1. Finally we can use Equation (6) to derive a,. In our paper3 we have used this method to compute (Pn,a,,w,} for those measures listed in Section 2. However, the computation is somewhat complicated due to the following difficulties:
Difficulties: There are several difficulties in applying Theorem 3.1. (1) It might be difficult to find the series expansion of $ ( t , x ) in t. (2) The computation of E , [ $ ( t , - ) 2 ]in Equation (5) might be very complicated. (3) The computation of E, [x$(t, -)2] in Equation (6) is even more involved. (4) The orthogonal polynomials are expressed as sums of monomials. How to find the close forms for them?
Resolution: Here are some ideas to overcome the above difficulties: (a) Find a computation method without having to use the power series expansion of $(t,x) in t. (b) Find a system of linear equations for the Jacobi-Szego parameters. (c) Determine P,(z) by a differential or difference operator. (d) Find a differential equation satisfied by P,(x). This equation is determined by the measure p. (e) Determine {a,,w,} from the eigenvalues of a differential operator.
We have made some progress regarding to Items (a), (b), and (c). The key idea is to use the series expansions of $ ( t , O ) and &$(t,x)Is=~ in t. Then we can avoid the difficulty (1). So, suppose cp(t,x) is a pre-generating function and assume that its multiplicative renormalization $(t,x) = cp(t,x)/E,cp(t, .) is a generating function for p. Define three functions A ( x ) , B ( t ) , and C ( t ) with their respective power series expansions by
00
B ( t ) = $(t,O) =
b,tn, n=O
The next theorem is from our paper4.
Theorem 3.2. Suppose $(t,x) = p(t,x)/Ep(p(t,.) is a generating function for p . Let a,, b,, c, be the numbers defined in Equations (7)-(9)- Assume that bncn-l # bn-lc,. Then the Jacobi-Szego parameters {an,w,} are the unique solution of the system of the linear equations:
Thus we can compute the Jacobi-Szego parameters as follows:
Now, consider the special case when the pre-generating function V ( t ,z) is of the form
where p ( t ) = C,“==, pntn is an analytic function near z = 0 with p1 # 0 and h(x) = C;=, h,zn is an analytic function near z = 0 with ho = 1, h, # 0 for all n 2 1 and there exists tl > 0 such that p(tz) is analytic in z on the support of p for all It1 < t l , and limsup,,, (1h.I I~PIILZ(~))”~ < 00. In this case the function A ( z ) in Equation (7) is given by
49
Therefore, a, = hnpr and so Equation (10) becomes
In particular, when p is symmetric, we have 01, = 0 for all n. Then Equation (12) yields the values of wn’s as follows:
4. Orthogonal polynomials in terms of differential or difference operators
Suppose $(t,x ) is a generating function for p. Then we can expand $(t,z) as a power series in t
n=O
where Pn(x)’saxe the orthogonal polynomials associated with p . As pointed out in Section 3, these polynomials are expressed as sums of monomials. Since it might be difficult to compute the power series expansion of $(t,z), it is desirable to determine or identify these polynomials in some other ways, namely, we raise the following Question: How to determine or identify the orthogonal polynomials {Pn(x)}without using the power series expansion of $ ( t ,x ) in t?
For absolutely continuous measures we have the next two theorems from our paper4. Recall that A ( z ) = Cr=,anzn from Equation (7) and that An = wow1 * * . w,. Theorem 4.1. Let p be a measure on ( a ,b) with Q smooth density function e(x) and assume that $ ( t , x ) is a generating function for p . Suppose qn(x) is a smooth function satisfying the conditions: 1 (a) -0,” [qn(xP(z)]E L2(p). O(X)
50
(b) 0,k[qn(x)B(x)]= 0 at x = a, b f o r all 0 5 k
< n.
Then the orthogonal polynomial P,(x) associated with p is given by 1 P,(x) = -0," [qn(x)o(x)] knB(x) with some constant k, if and only i f
[ ~ : + ( Xt ,I ] q n ( x ) d ~ x =) dntn with some constant d,. In this case, d, and k, are related by dn = (-l)"X,a,k,. For the special case when cp(t,x) is of the form in Equation (ll),the generating function is given by
In this case, we can make use of the function B ( t ) defined in Equation (8) and take q n ( x ) = e,(x)/e(x) in Theorem 4.1 to get the next theorem. Theorem 4.2. Let p be a measure on (a,b ) with a smooth density function e ( x ) and assume that
is a generating function f o r p . Suppose & ( x ) is a smooth function with support in [a,b] satisfying the conditions:
(b) D,k [&(x)]= 0 at x = a , b for all 0
5 k < n.
T h e n the orthogonal polynomial P n ( x ) associated with p is given by
with some constant k, i f and only i f
with some constant d,. In this case, d , and kn are given
51
For discrete measures on the set & = {0,1,2,. . .,n,. . .} we have the analogous results in the following two theorems from our paper4. Define the right- and left-hand difference operators A,+ and Ax- acting on functions defined on & by = f (x
Ax+f Ax-f
(2)
+ 1) - f (21,
= f (2) - f .( - 11,
where f (-1) = 0 by convention. We have A:+ f (x - n) = A:- f (x). Theorem 4.3. Let p be a measure o n & and let e(x) = p ( { x } ) , x E & . A s s u m e that +(t,x) is a generating function f o r p . Suppose qn(x) is a
function o n & satisfying the conditions:
(b) A!+ [q,(x)e(x)] = 0 at x = 0 , 00 f o r all 0
5 k < n.
T h e n the orthogonal polynomial P,(x)associated with p i s given by
with some constant k, i f and only i f m
2 [ ~ : + + (.)It , x=o
qn(x)e(x) = dntn
with some constant d,. In this case, d , and k, are related by d , = (-l)n Xn ~ n k n . The next theorem is analogous to Theorem 4.2. It is a special case of Theorem 4.3 for the multiplicative renormalization of the pre-generating function cp(t,x) = ep(t)z. Theorem 4.4. Let p be a measure o n & and let e(x) = p ( { x } ) , x E & .
A s s u m e that the multiplicative renormalization
pntn is analytic with i s a generating function f o r p, Here p ( t ) = C,"==, # 0. Suppose &(x) is a probability m a s s function o n & f o r each n satisfying the conditions:
p1
52
(8)
1
e(z)A:-
[en(x)]E L~(P).
(b) A:+ [&(x)]
5
0 at x = 0 , 00 for all 0 5 k < n.
Then the orthogonal polynomial P,(x) associated with p is given b y
with some constant k, if and only if
with some constant do. I n this case, d, and k, are given by dn = $,
kn = (-I),-.
n!
An
5. Classical examples In our paper3 we have used our method to derive generating functions $ ( t , x ) and {P,(z), ali, wn} for those measures listed in Section 2. But some computations, for example in identifying the polynomials P,(x),are rather complicated. In the paper4 the computations are simplified by using Equations (12) and (13) and Theorems 4.2 and 4.4. Recall that wg = 1.
Example 5.1. (Gaussian measure) e(x) = -&e-x2/2"2,
x
E
R
g ( t ,x) = etz--a2t/2, P,(x)= (-02)nez2/2"20," [e-z2/2"2] (Hermite polynomial), n20,
a, = 0 ,
w, =02n, n
2 1.
Example 5.2. (Gamma distribution) a > 0.
e(x) = r(1a7, p - 1 e --I , x > 0. Here
4(t,x) = (1 + t)-ae+z, n Pn(2) = (-1),x -a+l e zD, [ ~ ~ + ~ - - l e (Laguerre -~] polynomial), an = 2 n + a , n 2 0, w, = n(n a - l), n 2 1.
+
53
Example 5.3. (Beta-type distribution)
where the parameter /? > -l/2, 6 ,
# 0.
(Gegenbbauer polynomial),
We have two special cases. When p = 1/2, the measure p is the uniform measure on [-1,1] and Pn(z) is the Legendre polynomial. When ,B = 1, the measure p is the semi-circle distribution on [-l,l] and Pn(z) is the Chebyshev polynomial of the second kind, which can be verified to equal
Pn(z)=
+
1 sin [(n 1) c0s-l x] sin [cos-l , n>0.
4
Note that we have to exclude P = 0 in this example since the function in Equation (14)) is not a generating function when ,B = 0. The next example takes care of this case.
Example 5.4. (Arcsine distribution) e(z) = +-&J,
121
< 1.
(Chebyshev polynomial of the first kind),
w n = { 1 / 2 , if n = 1, 114, if n
> 2.
54
Example 5.5. (Poisson measure) O(x) = e - X s , x E &, X
> 0.
(Charlier polynomial), an=n+X, wn=Xn,
n10, n > 1.
Example 5.6. (Negative binomial measure)
where r
> 0 and 0 < p < 1.
(Meixner polynomial),
Acknowledgments N. Asai gives his deepest appreciation to Professor I. Ojima of RIMS, Kyoto University for challenging discussions and constant encouragement during his stay from April 2002 to March 2004. He is grateful for the postdoctoral fellowship from the program of the 21st century COE Kyoto Mathematics fellowships. H.-H. Kuo is grateful for research support from the Academic F'rontier in Science of Meijo University. He would like to thank Professors T. Hida, K. Nishi, and K. Sait6 for their warm hospitality during his visits in the past years.
55 References 1. Accardi, L. and Bozejko, M.: Interacting Fock space and Gaussianization
2. 3.
4.
5. 6.
7.
of probability measures; Infinite Dimensional Analysis, Quantum Probability and Related Topics 1 (1998) 663-670 Asai, N., Kubo, I., and Kuo, H.-H.: Multiplicative renormalization and generating functions I.; Taiwanese Journal of Mathematics 7 (2003) 89-101 Asai, N., Kubo, I., and Kuo, H.-H.: Multiplicative renormalization and generating functions 11.; Taiwanese Journal of Mathematics 8 no. 4 (2004) Asai, N., Kubo, I., and Kuo, H.-H.: Generating functions of orthogonal polynomials and Szego-Jacobi parameters; Probability and Math. Stat. 23 (2003) 273-291 Chihara, T. S.: A n Introduction to Orthogonal Polynomials. Gordon and Breach, 1978 Kubo, I.: Generating functions of exponential type for orthogonal polynomials; Inifinite Dimensional Analysis, Quantum Probability and Related Topics 7 (2004) 155-159 Szego, M.: Orthogonal Polynomials. Coll. Publ. 23,Amer. Math. SOC.,1975
LOW TEMPERATURE SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND THE STOCHASTIC LIMIT*
F. BAGARELLO Dipartimento d i Matematica ed Applicazioni, Facoltd d i Ingegneria, Universitd d i Palemno, V i d e delle Scienze, I-90128 Palemno, Italy e-mail: 6agarellOunapa.it
In this paper we review some recent results concerning the analysis of the Open BCS model as proposed by Buffet and Martin as well as some generalizations. Our attention is mainly focused on the computation of the critical temperature.
1. Introduction
In this paper we review two recent papers concerning the Open BCS model as first introduced in Ref. 1, 2 and some possible generalizations of this m0de1.~>~ The technique that we have adopted is that of the stochastic limit approach (SLA), whose details are described in the m ~ n o g r a p h .In ~ particular, we will show here that the SLA allows us to compute the same value of the critical temperature T,when we consider the model in Ref. 1 but in a significantly simpler way, and it allows a simple control of T, also for different models, like the ones discussed in Ref. 4. The paper is organized as follows: In the next section we review in some details the model analyzed in Ref. 3. In Section 111, after some physical justification, we discuss the role of a second reservoir in the open BCS model and we show how this reservoir may affect the value of T,,reviewing some of the results contained in Ref. 4. 2. The physicals model and its stochastic limit
Our model consists of two main ingredients, the system, which is described by spin variables, and the reservoir, which is given in terms of bosonic 'This paper is dedicated to my beloved parents, which are always close to me
56
57
operators. It is contained in a box of volume V = L 3 , with N lattice sites. We define, following Ref. 1, 2
where the Pauli matrices satisfy the following commutation rules
bi*
[a;,o-] 3 =&joy,
7
4
- T 2dij0f.
We will use the following realization of these matrices:
If we now define the following bounded operators, -
N
Hps)
can be simply written as = N(ZS& - gRN) and it is easy to check that [S%,RN]= [H P ” , R j v ] = [H$”),S%] = 0, for any given N > 0. It is also worth noticing that the commutators [ S ~ , C $go ] to zero in norm as & when N + 00, for all j , a and p. Our construction of the reservoir follows the same steps as in Ref. 2, but for the commutation rules. In particular, we introduce here as many bosonic modes a3,j as lattice sites are present in V . This means that j = 1,2, ..., N . p’ is the value of the momentum of the j-th boson which, if we impose periodic boundary condition on the wave functions of the bosons, has necessarily the form p’ = %fi, where n’ = (121,122,723) with nj E 2. These operators satisfy the following CCR,
[ap;i,ag,jl = [at. P,%.,at. 923.I = 0, and their free dynamics is given by
[ag,i,at. 4 > .I 3 = dij+g
(4)
N
-a 47r2(4+?4+4) where A N = {p’= %n’, n’ E Z 3 } and €3 = L2m = 2mL2 ‘ The form of the interaction between reservoir and system is assumed to be
N
+
~ $ 1= C ( a j + a j ( f ) h.c.1, j=1
(6)
58
where aj ( f ) = f (p3, f being a given test function which will be asked t o satisfy some extra conditions, see equation (15) below and the related discussion. We would like to stress that, in order to keep the notation simple, we will not use the tensor product symbol along this paper whenever the meaning of the symbols is clear. The finite volume open system is now described by the following Hamiltonian,
H N = H&
+ AH;),
where H L = H P s J
+Hge8)
(7)
and X is the coupling constant. The free evolution of the interaction Hamili H g V " ) t + -iHg'")t i H g e " ) t ( I ) ( t ) = eiHktH$)e-iHkt = EEI ( e tonian, H N e aj e
+
a j(f)e-iHge"'t h.c.), can be easily computed using a semiclassical approximation . Defining
(8)
where w = g,/(So)2 Q = 0 , f, we get
+ 4S+S-,
Y
= 22
+ gSo and va(p3 = v - e,j + o w ,
N j=1 c r = O , f
The next step in the SLA consists in computing the following quantity
and its limit for X going to zero. Here the state wtot is the following product state wtot = wsyswp, where waysis a state of the system, while wp is a KMS state corresponding to an inverse temperature ,b = It is convenient here t o use the so-called canonical representation of thermal state^.^ For that we introduce two sets of mutually commuting bosonic operators {#}, y = a , b, as follows:
&.
a5,j = Jmlj)cgj
+&'j$c~~~+,
(11)
where
mm = 4 a , j , j a ; , j ) = 1-
1 e-pep>
e-pec nm = wp(ap!,ja,j,j)= 1 - e-pep. (12)
59
The operators c $ ! satisfy the following commutation rules rC$,j (a),cLT)t] g,b = 6J.k 6p-q4
(13)
while all the other commutators are trivial. Now, if we introduce the vacuum of the operators c g j , @o, $!Go >J = 0, Vfl E AN, j = 1, ..N, a = a, b, then wg can be represented as a vector state: wp(X,) =< @o,X,@o> for any observable of the reservoir, X,. Finally, if we define fm@J = and fnm = we get
m f m
mfm,
cc N
H$)(t) =
{ph ( c ~ ) ( f m e i t ” -+) c ~ ) ’ ( f n e i t V a )+ ) hx}.
(14)
j=1 a=O,f Finally, if we require that the following integral exists finite:
where f,(jJis fm@J or fn@J and v,@J
is given above, we find that
(16) where the two complex quantities
(17) both exist because of the assumption (15). This suggest to define the following stochastic limit Hamiltonian N
H F ) ( t )=
c {d
(c&)(t)
j=1 a=O,f
+ c a j ( t )) + h.c } ,
(18)
where the operators ch‘j‘(t) are assumed to satisfy the following commutation rule,
[C$)(t),cg)t(tr)l= sj,
6,,6(t
-
t/)rp),
for t
> t’,
since, as it is easily checked, the following quantity
J ( t ) = (-i)2 [ d t l 0
[’ 0
dtzRtot(H~)(tl)H~‘)(t2))
(19)
60
coincides with I ( t ) . Here Otot = wsvsO = wsys < Qo, QO >, where QO is the vacuum of the operators c$)(t): c$)(t)Qo = 0 for all a , j , y and t , cf. Ref. 5 . Following the SLA5 we now use H g ) ( t )to compute the generator of the theory, which is found recalling that Otot(dtjt(X 81I,)) = O t o t ( j t ( L ( X ) ) ) , where j t ( X @ It,) = U j ( X @ Il,)Ut and Ut is the wave operator, which satisfies the following differential equation: at Ut = - i H g ) ( t ) U t . For all self-adjoint observables X we get
L ( X )=
+L2(X),
(20)
where
cf. Ref. 3. As discussed in Ref. 1, 2, we need to find the dynamics of S& and RN to get some insight about the phase structure of the model and, in particular, to compute the value of the critical temperature corresponding to a transition from a normal to a superconducting phase. These intensive operators are both self-adjoint, so that we can use equations (20) and (22). It is now a direct computation to deduce that
where it is necessary to introduce the F - strong topology instead of the uniform t ~ p o l o g y ,and ~ , ~we have defined
while
61
The phase structure of the model is now given by the right-hand sides of Equations (23) and (25),see Ref. 1, 2, and, in particular, from the zeros of the functions
where x = So and y = S+S-. In particular, the existence of a superconducting phase corresponds to the existence of a non trivial zero of fl and f 2 , cf. Ref. 1, 2, that is to a non trivial zero of the function h: h(xO,yo) = 0 with (x,,y,) # (0,O). In order to find such a solution, it is first necessary to obtain an explicit expression for the coefficients Rrp). This is easily done:
lf,rn~~s(~*rn),
Erg) = =
xrf) = r
C IMPI~S(Y*(P~). IXAN
$€AN
(27) It is now almost straightforward to recover the results of Ref. 1,2.Following Buffet and Martin’s original idea, we look for solutions corresponding to Y = 0. This means that x = -2Z/9, v+@j = w - €5, which is zero if and only if w = €5, and v- (p3 = -w - €5, which is never zero. For these reasons we deduce that Rr?) = 0, y = a,b, while the sums in (27) for Rry) are restricted to the smaller set, EN c AN, of those values of $such that, if 4‘ E EN then 6; = w. Therefore, recalling the expression of m(P3 and n(p3 in (12),we find
From Definition (24), finally, we get the following equation
or
which, as we have proven in Ref. 3, is equivalent to the one obtained in Ref. 1, 2, g tanh = w. For this reason, then, we deduce the existence of a critical temperature, T, := &, coinciding with that found by Martin and Buffet, such that, when T < T,, the system is in a superconducting phase. The values of the order parameters also are recovered.
% 0
62
3. Possible generalizations In this section we discuss some possible generalizations of the model which may produce higher values of T,. The idea is very simple and is well emphasized using the SLA: suppose that the free evolution of the annihilation operator of the reservoir, ag,i(t) = ap-, z.e--iept , is replaced, for some reason, which we will investigate later, by ag,i(t) = ag,,ie-iTept, y being some real constant less than one, y < 1. Then we have shown in Ref. 4 that Equation (29) is replaced by following one:
eDw/r = 9 +W 9-W’
which admits a non trivial solution in 10, g [ if gD/y - 2 > 0, that is under a new critical temperature = = which is larger than T, since y is smaller than 1 by construction. Therefore, this very easy mechanism makes the value of the critical temperature to increase. It is worth stressing that a similar conclusion was by no means evident in Ref. 1, 2. The main point, therefore, is to find a mechanism able to change the free evolution of the boson operators, possibly as shown above. For that, a possibility consists in switching on an interaction between the boson reservoir in Ref. 3, which we will call R1 and mother reservoir, Rz,which only communicates with R1 and not with the system S. This will be our point of view: we will discuss now a single model which generalizes the one discussed in Section I1 and the consequences of the presence of this second reservoir on the value of T,. More models are considered in Ref. 4. Let
‘TP)
5,
where H g Y S )is given in (l),H$) in ( 6 ) and
(32) Here both the reservoirs satisfy a bosonic statistic and they are mutually independent:
63
With these definitions it is clear that the free time evolution of H E ) , H g ) ( t ) = e i H g t H g ) e - i H s t ,depends on R2 only through its interaction with R1.We have, using the definitions in (8), e i H ~ t o ~ e - i H= ~ te i H g “ ) t
+e - i H g u ” t -eiutd oj
+ ei(u+w)tpj+ + e i ( u - w ) t
j
P-
>
while
e - i H & t - e i H $ e S ) t a,;ie- i H g e S ) t aP,Z,(t)= eiNa t U 6 , i - e-icpt [a,-,i -
cos(pt) - ib,j,i sin(pt)] ,
as it can be easily derived. If we now introduce the following function:
vapO=v-€$++QIW+Pp, + = O , f ,
P=&,
(34)
we get
+bj(feitva-)
+ h.c),
- bj(feitua+)]
(35) a- . - b - .
Let us now define the operators Ag,j = a5d&bb3j, B s , ~= p ~ l p 3 1 . The only non trivial commutation rules are [ A g , i , A > , . ] = [ B ~ , i , B i = , ~dijdcf, l and we can write H $ ) ( t ) as
which producess, as in the previous section
The only difference is in the coefficients defined as
Here we have introduced
and
which are now
64
and we recall that m ~ = oW A ( A ~ , ~ Am $ ,~~@ ) ,= 3w ~ ( B ~ , ~ B nA(p3 $ , ~=) , W A ( A $ , ~ Aand ~ , ~nB(p3 ) = w ~ ( B $ , ~ B c ,Wj A) . and WB are the KMS-states of respectively the A and the B-operators. The total state is wtot = wsYs @ WA
@WB.
Remark:- For all our results to be meaningful, we have to require that all these integrals exist finite. This gives a condition on f(p3, which extends the analogous one previous given in the previous section, due to the appearance of two different reservoirs. Due to the fact that I ( t ) in (37) coincides formally with the one in (16), it is easy to check that all the previous steps can be repeated and the conclusion is again the same: the system undergoes a phase transition, from a normal to a superconducting phase, if the function h(x,y) defined in analogy with (24) as
has a non trivial zero (20,yo). Find such a zero may be very hard, in general. First we observe that
i
= f &AN = f &AN sry)= ;
c
lf(P3l2(mA@36(Y+-(p3) + mB(p3d(Y++(p3)) lf(P3l2( m A ( p 3 6 ( Y - - ( p 3 ) + mB(p36(Y-+(p3)) > (41) (nA(p36(Y+-(p3) + nB(p36(Y++(p3)) 7
sr- -- 57r Cc,=,nN lf(p3I2 (nA(p36(V--(p3)+ nB(p36(v-+(p3)) (n)
7
which are much more complicated than the expressions in (27). We have discussed in Ref. 4 that choosing Y = 0 does not allow us to find any new result: the value of the critical temperature obtained in Ref. 1, 2 and Ref. 3 is recovered. For this reason we now assume that Y # 0 and, in particular, we look for solutions such that only u+-(PT assume, for some 3, the value 0, while u++(fl,u--(p3 and v+-+(p? are always different from zero. For such a solution t o exists it is enough that the following inequalities are all satisfied: Y
{
+ w + p < 0,
Y -
Y
w-p
< 0,
- w + p < 0,
v+w-p>o.
65
A trivial solution surely exists if we fix Y = p as far as w E ]2p,-2p[. This means, because 0 5 IwI 5 f i g , that the coumust be negative and less than - g g . pling constant p in However, it is not hard to check that with this choice =
%rim)
%r(”) - = 0, while %I$?
= I ~ ( J $ ~ ~ ~ ~ ( J $ ~ ( Y +and - ( J%I??) $) = If(p312n~(p36(~+-(P3). Now, as an easy consequence, we recover the same equation as in the previous section, epAw = g+w which implies 9 --w ?r
that the critical temperature is not affected in this case. More interesting is the situation when the System (42) holds true without having v = p. This is possible: the choice p = -w, v = is an example of this situation. If (42) is satisfied we deduce that
-:
In order t o check whether this equation admits non trivial solutions for some w €10, g[, we consider three different situations: (i) if Y = p then we go back to the usual ~ o n d i t i o n and , ~ to our previous analysis, and we deduce the existence of a critical temperature which coincides with the usual one. (ii) if v > p then the situation is different: since the function F ( w ) := e B A ( w + Y - p ) - @ is such that F ( 0 ) = e P A ( ” - p ) -1 > 0 and lim-w+g-F ( w ) = g--w -00, and since F ( w ) is continuous, then we surely have a solution F(w,-,) = 0 with wg ~]0,g[,for all the values of PA. This suggests the existence of a superconducting phase for all values of the temperature! (iii) if Y < p then F ( 0 ) = e f i A ( V - - I 1 ) - 1 < 0 and we cannot conclude that a non trivial solution of the equation F( w) = 0 does exist even in this case. A deeper investigation need to be carried out in this case but, since, it is not relevant for our present purposes, we will omit it here. The conclusion of this analysis is therefore that, at least for those values for which System (42) holds true (if Y # p), the equation h(z,g) = 0 has always a non trivial solution independently of the temperature. This seems quite promising and we hope to get a deeper understanding of this fact in a close future, since it suggests the possibility of using this model in a first approach to high temperature superconductivity. We also would like t o mention that more models, sharing with the one considered here a sort of control on the critical temperature depending on the value of the parameters, are discussed in Ref. 4. Remark:- As discussed in Ref. 3, the operators of both R1 and R2 are
66
in general unbounded. For this reason a special care is required to make everything rigorous. This can be done using the framework discussed in Ref. 7, but we will not do it here to avoid a useless complication of the procedure. References 1. E. Buffet, P.A. Martin, Dynamics of the Open BCS Model, J. Stat. Phys., 18,NO.6, 585-632, (1978) 2. P.A. Martin, ModBles en MCcanique Statistique des Processus IrrCversibles, Lecture Notes in Physics, 103, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, (1979) 3. F. Bagarello The stochastic limit in the analysis of the open BCS model, J. Phys. A, in press 4. F. Bagarello The role of a second reservoir in the open BCS model, submitted to IDAQP 5. L. Accardi, Y.G. Lu, I. Volovich, Quantum Theory and its Stochastic Limit, Springer (2002) 6. W.Thirring and A.Wehr1, On the Mathematical Structure of the B.C.S.Model, Commun.Math.Phys. 4, 303-314 (1967) 7. F. Bagarello, Applications of Topological *-Algebras of Unbounded Operators, J. Math. Phys., 39,6091-6105, (1998)
MULTIQUANTUM MARKOV SEMIGROUPS, INTERACTING BRANCHING PROCESSES AND NONLINEAR KINETIC EQUATIONS. FINITE DIMENSIONAL CASE.
V.P. BELAVKIN AND C.R. WILLIAMS School of Mathematical Sciences University of Nottingham University Park Nottingham NG?’ 2RD, U.K.
1. Introduction
This paper introduces an algebraic approach to the theory of systems consisting of random numbers of particles of the same type. In this paper we will consider those systems such that each particle is described as a finite dimensional quantum state, with an associated algebra of (finite dimensional) observables. The multi-particle systems are described by a decomposable algebra of observables compatible with the total number operator on Fock space. The equivalence is shown between multi-particle states and complex valued positive definite contractions defined on a unit ball of matrices and analytic within this ball. A similar correspondence is shown for transformations of multi-particle states, by extension to a family of matrix valued functions. We consider semi-groups of operators on an infinite dimensional space, which are represented as an infinite block matrix of transformations between the finite particle states. Such semi-groups are defined by a suitable family of matrix valued analytic functions of the unit ball of single particle observables which we call generating functions for the semi-group. We define a Markovian multi-particle process in a broad sense by introducing conditions on these matrix valued generating functions and determine necessary and sufficient conditions on the infinitesimal generator of these generating functions for the existence of a Markovian multi-particle process. We consider the class of all possible non-interacting systems and a particular class of interacting systems having an overall interaction strength. A family of generating functionals indexed by the positive real line is given 67
68 which describe the evolution of a multi-particle state for non-interacting systems. We introduce a pair of equations called a canonical pair of quantum kinetic equations and give, in the case of interacting systems having an overall interaction strength, a formal asymptotic solution to the family of state generating functionals in the case where the canonical pair have a solution satisfying a mixed boundary value condition, as the interaction strength tends to zero. At least in the case of pairwise interaction it is possible to show that the asymptotic solution tends to an actual solution in such a limit. 2. The algebraic theory of finite dimensional multi-particle
systems Let A be a C*-algebra of finite dimensionality a, which we will call the algebra of observables for a single particle system. For every such algebra there exists a Ic E N and a set
such that A has the structure k
A3A=@Ai i=l
for some collection of matrices Ai E M (nj). We therefore represent A as a *-subalgebra of M ni having the block diagonal form:
&, 0
‘M(n1) 0 * - . 0 M(n2).
0
..
0
, o
0M
(nk)
For each 1 5 i 5 k let {&,k : 1 5 k 5 n f } be an orthonormal basis for M (ni) with respect to the usual matrix inner product:
( A , B )= T r { A * B } For each 1 5 i 5 k and 1 5 k 5 nf let h i & E A be the matrix; k Ei,k
= @6i&,k j=1
(1)
69
and let {Ei : 1 5 i
I a } be the orthonormal basis set for A on M
(with respect to the inner product (1)) given by Uf=:=,{&,k
:1
x:=l 0 5k5 ni
n:}.
k We define by %(’) the Hilbert space @ ( l ) where d(1) = Ci=:=,ni. We define A’ to be the commutant of A, namely the algebra of all matrices in M (EL1 n . which commute with any single particle observable A E A. Specifically A’ is the algebra of diagonal matrices of the form
.)
‘AIInl
0
0 hIn2
.
.. . . ..
0
..
0
.. .
, o
0 L,In,,
where X I , . . .,A,, E C‘ and Inis the identity matrix on M (n). A single particle state is defined as a positive linear functional having norm at most one (we call such a state stable if it has norm one). Note that any linear functional p on A can be represented by a matrix e = : ei E M (ni) in the sense k i= 1
for any A = $f=lAi E A. It immediately follows that p 2 0 if and only if ei 2 0 for every 1 5 i 5 t. Of course the representation e = is not unique amongst all density matrices on M ni) , but it is the unique A valued element in the equivalence classes defined by the relation:
(‘&
el
N
ez iff Tr { A e l } = Tr { A Q ~VA } EA
Z:=l BT A } where { O BT is the transpose of B , which obviously has the same structure as A. Note Let dT be the transposed algebra B E M
ni
:
E
that positivity is invariant under matrix transposition. We define a pairing
( A ,B ) = Tr { A B T } between A and AT, so that any functional p is uniquely associated (via this paring) with an element in AT. We define a norm on dT as;
AT
3Q
I---)
Ilell, = SUP { ( A ,e> : A E A, IlAll I 11
70
where JJAJ1 is the usual operator norm, so that any single particle state is uniquely represented by a positive matrix in AT having trace at most one. We call AT the algebra of single particle states. is The algebra of n particle observables, which we will denote by defined as the symmetrical nthtensor power, defined as the algebra of finite linear combinations of operators;
with X@O = 1 for all X E A. Such an algebra has a representation in the finite dimensional algebra M (EfZl n,)"> with a basis given by the symmetric tensor products:
(
E ~ @ . . . @ E ? :~n -l +...+TI,=n can also be repreHowever, being finite dimensional, the algebra sented as an algebra of block diagonal matrices. Then any A(") E A(") has the form A!") for some Ic (n) E N, Ain) E M (mi"') for some
@z)
mjn) E N and we define d ( n ) = ~ ~ ~ ' r n { " We ) . define to be the Hilbert space of this representation. We denote by A(")' C M (d ( n ) ) the commutant of the algebra represented on C?(n). We define A:) as the transposed algebra to A(").We define n-particle ( states as the positive matrices en E A;) having trace at most one. We use the collection of algebras A(") : n E N to construct, for 6 > 0, (infinite dimensional) algebras .Ct as the Banach spaces of E summable sequences e = [en]:=o with entries en E A$) such that:
n=O
The multi-particle states are defined as those and sub-normalised in the sense that en =
e E ,C1 which are both positive
aand:
M
n=O
M
n=O
If e is normalised, llell = 1, then we say that the system has a random but finite number of particles with a probability distribution given by p , = Tr{en} for the events that the system consists of n particles. Thus a normalised n-particle state en has the physical interpretation of a multiparticle system which contains (with certainty) exactly n particles.
71
The more relaxed condition of sub-normalisation allows for the description of unstable systems having a non-zero probability 1 - llell of existing in a state having an infinite number of particles. The dual to the space C1, denoted by CT, is the space of all multiparticle observables, which are defined as sequences
satisfying the boundedness condition:
For a given e E Lc we can define a generating functional R (similar to those introduced in Ref. 1) on the unit ball Bt = { X E M : 1JXJI5 [} as the absolutely convergent sum:
The generating function R is an analytic function of a variables in The following proposition establishes the converse.
Proposition 2.1. If R : I3c e E Cg such that:
+ C! is analytic
c
Bt.
then there exists a sequence
W
R (X)=
Tr { $x@n}
n=O
Proof. Such maps R can be thought of as analytic functions in a variables. These agree with their Taylor series locally, giving W
nt=l
W
n,=l
where we denote a
i= 1
and:
The set of complex numbers
72
define a linear functional pn on the algebra d(n)via the linear extension of pn
(Epn'@. .@E?"-) = r (721,. . . ,na)
let en E A$) be the implementation of this form in the algebra A:), in the sense:
We note that the sums nl+...+n,z =n
can be written as ( X @ n , ~ ndefining )
R (X)=
C Tr { e:XNn> n=O
where: 00
C
n=O
{en) = R (61) <
0
Obviously if @ E Ct is a multi-particle state then the generating functional (2) is positive definite and R ( I ) 5 1, the following propositions shows that the converse is true. Proposition 2.2. If R : Bt + C is positive definite and analytic throughout BC then it is the generating functional of some positive @ € Cg. If furthermore 6 = 1 and R ( I ) 5 1 then R is the generating functional f o r a multi-particle state.
Proof. The previous proposition proves the existence of some p E Lt such that: M
n=O
Clearly if 6 = 1 and R ( I ) 5 1 then Cauchy integral formula we can write
llelll 5
1. Furthermore, using the
73
where C is any positively oriented simple closed contour around the origin. Hence we may write
Tr { e;xBn}
by approximating the integrals as the limit of summation, the positivity of Tr { e:X(,)} follows from the positive definiteness of the forms X(,) R. The positivity of the matrix e: in N(")follows from the relation
for any f = @f$)fi E following from that of.:Q
such that fi E P i ( nthe ) , positivity of That e = [ ~ n ] r = oE Lc follows from R ((I) <
en
We have shown a one to one correspondence between positive definite analytic functionals of Q variables and multi-particle states generated by the single particle algebra A. The following proposition is the simplest example of a result we will prove in the following section. Proposition 2.3. An analytic functional R : t3c if and only if
R ( X )=
+ C is positive definite
C C A, (i)* XBnAn (i) n=O i=l
for A, (i) : C + a(")satisfying a(") has dimension d (n).
C,"==, Ct)'
A, (i)* A, (i)
<
00
where
Proof. If R : Bc + C is analytic and positive definite then there exist, for each n E N,positive e: E d(,) such that R is the generating functional of Let A, (i) be the function defined by the column the sequence e = [en],"==o.
74 where R{ is the ( i , j ) t h entry in the square root R of
e:.
Since R ( I ) < 00 it follows that: 03
d"
n=O i=I
Furthermore: 00
n=O
n=O i=l
n=O
The converse follows from the equality
for any I
and ssets
3. Transitional transformations
In this section we consider generalised branching transformations of our : .4c)+ ,CE be a bounded linear transformation having algebra. Let components (@T):) : A$?) + A&m',such a transformation is called an n-particle branching transformation if (QT):) # 0 for at least one m # n. The conjugate transformation dn) : ,CT + d(n) are defined, for en E A?)
@g)
and X = [ X ( m )m=O O3 ] E ,CT by
can be used to construct an F(") : Bc 3 given by:
valued (analytic) generating function
m=O
: We define an n-particle branching evolution as any positive C:=, @g)* ( I @ m )5 Ign. The special case where n = 0 correspond to the multi-particle states. Of
A(") -+ L1 satisfying the contraction condition
75
particular interest will be the branching evolutions having components with completely positive conjugates. The following proposition generalises Proposition 2.1 from transitional transformations (which are simply the elements of C,) to general transformations of the described type.
Proposition 3.1. If F(n) : Be : dg) + C, szlch that:
+ d(n)is
analptic then there exists a
03
m=O
Proof. The proof is similar to the proof of Proposition 2.1. The analyticity gives a power series expansion M
nl=l
n.=l
where f (nl,. . . ,n,) E A(") are defined as the mixed derivatives
as before. We now define an A(") valued bounded linear operator @k) on for each m E N,by the continuous linear extension of the algebra d(m),
(Ef+"'@.. .@ E y " ) = f
+ +
. . . ,n,)
(n1,
where n1 . .. n, = m. Clearly F(n) is the generating function corresponding t o the sequence @$"I = ( @ T )( ,n ) ]O0 and ( e n ) E Cc for any
[
m=O
@g)
E dg).
0
@k)
Clearly if each is completely positive it follows that F(n) must be positive definite. The following proposition proves the converse.
Proposition 3.2. If F("): + A(") is positive definite and analytic : d?) + C, throughout t3c then it is the generating function of some having components with completely positive conjugates : d(m) + d(.).
@g)
@k)
Proof. The previous proposition proves the existence of some M(") + Cc such that: M
m=O
:
76
We again use the Cauchy integral formula, this time applying it to the derivatives g F ( n )( t X ) l to conclude that: t=o
Then for all N E N and for all qi, qj E Canand X i m ) ,X j m ) E M(") where 1 5 i,j 5 N we have
Egl
EM XiY""
for some X i E @, Ci = X i q j and = exp { -ie,} Y,. This proves and the complete the positive definiteness of the conjugate elements 0 positivity follows from the linearity of the operators. where Xj"'
=
2=1
. z ~ + ,= ~ exp {nie,} A&.<, and finally &+,L
@k)
We conclude this section by providing a dilation for the generating functions of the transformations d n ) . Proposition 3.3. An analytic function nite if and only i f M
F ( n )( X ) =
cc
F("): Bc
+
is positive defi-
k(") k(m) kjm)kj.")
@
m=O j=1 i=l
for
A:) (i,j , r)*X B m A k ) (i, j , r )
(4)
r(i,j)=l satisfying;
m=Oj=l i=l
,-(i,j)=l
where k:"), ky' E N for j = 1,... ,k(") and i = 1,.. . ,k(") are the dimensionalities of the block matrices in the block diagonal representations of d ( m )and respectively.
77
Proof. Obviously if F ( n )(X) takes the form (4) then it is positive definite, it remains to show the converse. For each rn E N we use the complete positivity of to construct a positive linear form d, on the Hilbert space 31(")* @ 31(") of d (m) x d (n)complex valued matrices such that
(5)
where
for some vectors
(9),xj ( h ) E dj for j = 1, . . . ,k(") and vectors (n)
[j
ai (9),pi( h ) E dl"' for i = 1,.. .,k(") such that g = 1,.. .,M , h = 1,.. . ,N . By linearity the must take the form operator @g)
where (for each i = l,...,k(") and j = 1,.. . ,k(n))cp(i,j) is a matrix whose entries are positive x valued matrices. Then (5) takes the form
Icy) Icy)
&"'
and each summand defines a positive sesquilinear form on Ckim)*8 which is implemented as the trace with respect to a positive matrix over &m)kjn) having square root R (i,j),i.e. (Sj
(9)7 Tr { ai (9)*Pi ( h )cp (4A } xj ( h ) )
78
where:
We define, for T (i,j ) = 1 , . . .,kim)k:n) the operators A k ) (i,j , T ) to be the
kim) x k p ) complex valued matrices;
where R (i, j ) : denotes the entry of R (i, j ) at the p t h row and qth column. It follows that
and hence that ( 5 ) takes the form
giving
for any ai,Pi E C k i m ) That . F ( n )( X ) takes the form 4 follows immediatela Proposition 2.3 is a corollary of Proposition 3.3 which gives a non linear extension of Stinespring's construction,2 in the finite dimensional case.
79
4. Markovian multi-particle processes
In this section we define a special class of generalised branching evolutions which we call Markovian multi-particle processes (in a broad sense as in Ref. 3). Of articular importance is the class of branching evolutions such that @k7 is completely positive. The previous section shows a one to one correspondence between such branching evolutions and the A(") valued positive definite analytic functions of a variables. We exploit this correspondence in the following definition. Definition 4.1. Let IIT ( t ) : t E J.R+ be a semi-group of branching evolutions IIT ( t ) = [IIcn) (t)];==,in the algebra L1 described by the oneparameter family of Ly valued analytic functions defined on the unit ball B1 as:
P (t,X ) =
[m( t , X ) ]
O0
n=O
We say that II (t)is a stationary continuous time Markovian multi-particle process if the following three conditions hold: (1) The transformation P ( t ) is positive definite (2) For all t > 0, P ( t ) is a contraction P ( t , l )5 I@ = (3) P ( t ,X ) + X @ = [x@~];=~ weakly as t + o for all
[I@n]z=O x
E B1.
We interpret such branching transformations as the partial description of a mechanism by which an n-particle component of a multi-particle state evolves in a system where interactions occur which do not necessarily preserve the number of particles. In particular the mechanism describes the averaged evolution of a system undergoing random branching interactions, which is the only possible description of the evolution of a multi-particle system if the individual branching interactions are not observed.
[@g)]
We say that a transformation 9~= O0 where n=O is the generator of a Markovian multi-particle system if:
:
+ L1
In particular we make no assumptions on the boundedness of the sequence 9 and will later see that some natural branching evolutions can only be described with an unbounded generator. Such a generator 9 is described by the unbounded sequence F = [F(n)],",oof A(") valued functions F(") (defined on and analytic within
80
the unit ball 23') which satisfy: d
F(") ( X ) = -P(") ( t , X ) dt Proposition 4.1. If P(")( t ) : B' + A(") is a positive definite function analytic in 23' describing a Markovian multi-particle system and F(") ( X ) is its generator
then F(") ( X ) is conditionally positive definite, satisfying for all M E 1 5 k,Z 5 M , X I E %(") and Xl E 23'
N,
M
k,l=l and F
Furthermore F
Proof. If
then
from which it follows that limt+o (P(") ( t , X ; X l ) - X;@'"X?") is conditionally positive definite. From Proposition 3.3 it follows that P(")( X ) * = P(")( X * ) and hence (P(") ( t , X ) - X@")* = P(") (t,X * ) - X * @ . Since P(")( t , I ) 5 I@" it follows that F(") ( I ) 5 0. 0
If the enerator F(") ( X ) is analytic also, then it determines transforA("),we now show that these must be conditionally mations ak) : positive definite. Proposition 4.2. If F(") ( X ) : B1 + A(") is analytic in B1 and condi: B1 -+ L1 tionally positive definite then there exists a transformation @$"I such that dn) is conditionally positive definite and:
c a): 00
F(") ( X ) =
m=O
(Xmm)
81
If furthemnore F(") ( X ) * = F(n)( X ' ) t h e n dn) (X)*= dn) (X') for any
x E LY. Proof. The existence of d")is guaranteed by Proposition 3.1. It follows immediately from F(") ( X ) * = F ( n )(X*) and the density in Cy of
(cx,xp : N E N,xi E Bl, xi E c i=l
that
for some 1
and
Such that
then
the positivity following from the conditional positive definiteness of Fcnh then a(") is conditionally completely positive throughout CT. Proposition 4.3. F(") (X) : B1 + A(") is analytic in B1 and conditionally ) = F(") (x*) i f and only zf positive definite and ~ ( n(x)*
for
satisfying:
m=Oj=l i=l r ( i , j ) = l
where k!"), k y ) E N for j = 1 , . . . ,k(n) and i = 1 , . . . ,k(") are the dimensionalities of the block matrices in the block diagonal representations of and A(") respectively and B(") E A(n). Proof. It is well known that linear w*-continuous maps A = A* between Von Neumann algebras A and B are conditionally positive definite with respect t o a w*-representation A : A + B if and only if;
A ( A ) = r ( A ) - A ( A )B - B*A( A )
82 for some completely positive I' : A -+ f3 and B E f3. We apply this result to the map conditionally positive definite map dn)satisfying dn) (X)*= dn) (X*) for any X E CT resulting from the previous proposition. The result then follows from Proposition 3.3. 0 The above proposition is a non-linear extension of the Lewis-Evans construction4 to non-linear conditionally completely positive analytic transformations with values in the finite dimensional algebra The Proposition 4.1 gives the necessary conditions for the generator of a Markovian multi-particle system. We now use Propositions 4.2 and 4.3 to show that these conditions are also sufficient. Theorem 4.1. Let F ( n ): B1 + A(")for n E N be a family of conditionally positive definite maps analytic in L?' such that F(n)( I ) 5 0 and F ( n )( X ) * = F(n)( X ) . Then there exists a Markovian multi-particle process described by a family P(n)( t ): B1 -+ A(") such that:
1
d F@)( X ) = -P(") (t,X ) dt t=O Proof. We seek to represent P(n)(t,X ) as the solution to the integral equation
where we use Proposition 4.3 to express:
Ak)
where (i:) 7-6; + '?are I( defined ") by an A g ) ( i , j ,T ) : Ckln)-+ Ckjm) and Cd(n)d m, AL (i)* A?) ( i )5 B(")- B(n)*. z=1 We are required to show that such a solution exists, satisfies P(n)(t,I ) 5 I for all t > 0, is positive definite, and furthermore is the generating function for a semi-group II(n): A(n)+ L1. Using the Du Hammel principle we look
83 for a solution t o the recurrent system
with starting point Po'") (t,X ) = exp { -tB(")*}XBL"exp { -tB(")}. Using the recurrence relation we can define (t,X ) as the summation
{
( t ,X ) = exp -tB(")*}~
8 exp "
{- t ~ ( n ) }
+k /...I g...c 1
d(n)d(ml)
w
mi=O
N=l
exp
{
{
-SIB(")*)
A?;*
exp s1Bcml)}A::
mn=O
(il) exp
(il) exp
{
d(mnr-l)d(mnr)
...
ii=l
C
iN=l
sI~(ml)*)
{-SIB(")}
dsl
. . .dsN
and so the family of approximations P,'") (t,X ) consists of completely positive members which are increasing (in a C.P. sense) with increasing i. We will now show that Pi"' ( t , X ) 5 I@" if t > 0 and X 5 I . First we note that
84
from which follows exp { -tB(n)*}exp { -tB(")} 5 Ian, Let us assume that X 5 I and Pjn)( t , X ) 5 IBn for all 1 5 i 5 j . Then:
p!") ( t , ~5 )e-tB(n)*e -tB(") z+ 1
5 Ian It follows that the increasing sequence must have a limit 0 5 Pg)( t ,X ) 5 Ian given by the infinite series
{
{
P(")(t,X)= exp - t ~ ( n ) * ~} 8 'exp " -t~(n)}
n
which, furthermore must satisfy the integral equation since
(7)
85 and so it follows;
5 P(n)( t ,X ) whence equality. By differentiating (6) it is clear that the constructed solution does indeed satisfy the equation for the generator:
dt
t=O
It remains only to show that the functions II(n)( t )defined by the derivatives
are a ssemi-group. We note that
+g J.. .J g . . . c~ ... c 00
N= 1 O<sl<...<SN
{
exp S I B ( ~ 'Ag! ) } ( i l )exp from which the semi-group property is clear.
mn--l=O
d(n)d(ml)
d(mN-l)d(m)
i1=l
SIB(^)}
dsl
iN=l
. . . dslv 0
The Markovian semi-group II ( t ) = [IIIcn)(t)] defined by the family P(") (t,X ) given by equation (7) gives a weak solution e ( t ) = e o II ( t ) to
86
the Cauchy problem d
-e(t) = @ O @ dt
is the initial state of the system and @ = .Ly + d(n)are transformations determined by:
where
Q
[dn)]r=O where dn) :
m=O
The solution is defined by the analytic generating functionals
n=O
5. Interaction free branching processes In this section we classify the Markovian branching evolutions corresponding to interaction free systems. We will begin by giving the simplest example of a multi-particle evolution, corresponding to a pure birth process of particles from the vacuum. Example 5.1. Let G ( X ) : B1 + C be analytic in the unit ball B1 and positive definite. Let c E iR+ be such that G ( I ) 5 c. We define a semigroup of analytic functions V ( t , X ) : B1 + C as the exponents
v ( t ,X ) = exp {t (G (W - 4) these have the interpretation as the generating functionals of some states u (t)E L1. Furthermore these states must satisfy M
+
from which follows un (t T ) = family of analytic functions;
C:=, um ( t )@un-m ( T ) .
We define a
P(n)(t,X ) = v (t,X ) X B n these have a family of generators F(n)( X ) = (G ( X ) - c ) X@'" which are necessarily conditionally positive definite, and satisfy F(") ( X ) * =
87
F ( n )(X*) , F ( n )(I)5 0. Hence P(n)( t ,X) describes a Markovian multiparticle process ll ( t ) satisfying: m2n l-Ik)*( t )= {ovmPn( t )ifotherwise
This process defines an evolution of the state e ( t )E L1 of a multi-particle system having initial state e E L1 and generating functional R ( t ,X) via the equation
c(en,dn) 03
R (4 X)=
(t,X)} = R (0, X ) V (t,X)
n=O
from which it follows that en (t) = C:=, em @ vn-m (t). Such a system has a clear interpretation as describing a multi-particle system whose dynamics consist of birth of particles from the vacuum. Conversely let us consider a system consisting only of the birth of particles from the vacuum, i.e. a system whose state at time t E IB+ is described by en ( t ) = em @v2),-m ( t )for some initial state e E L1 and where v ( t ) E L1 are, for each t E lit+, the state of birthed particles at time t. If we require our system to be Markovian, then it must be that ll ( t )defined by
c:=,
m=O
be a semi-group. From this it follows that n
n-m
m=O k=O
+
and hence v n (t T ) = vm ( t )@ vn-m ( T ) . Then the family of generating functionals of the state of the birthed particles at times t E IR+ is a positive definite contractive semi-group, hence it has a conditionally positive definite generator H (X) such that H ( I ) 5 0. Hence any Markovian system of birth from the vacuum is of the type described by Example 5.1. The second fundamental type of process without interaction is that involving processes on single particles in the system. This type of interaction will be described in the following example: Example 5.2. Let us define G (X) as a d(') valued positive definite analytic function. Furthermore let us assume that there exist some B E M ( I ) such that G ( I ) 5 B B*. Let the family QT (t,X) E d(') be analytic
+
88
throughout 23' and a solution to the non-linear inverse Heisenberg Kolmogorov equation defined by
d dr
-QT
( t , X ) = Q T (t,X ) B -
. m=O
+ B*Qr (t,X) '
A , (i)* QT (t,X)@'" A , (i)
i=l
for 0 5 r < t with boundary condition Qt ( t , X ) = X and where the matrices A , (i) are determined by the dilation of G in Proposition 3.3. We show that such a solution exists and is analytic for X E B1 using an iterative method on the integral equation
T (t,X ) = exp { -tB*} X exp { -tB*}
+
I,"
exp {-sB*} G (T (t - s,X)) exp (-sB}cls
similarly t o the proof of Theorem 4.1 where T (t - 7, X)= QT (t,X ) . The family T (t,X) necessarily has generator G ( X ) - X B - B*X and satisfies T (t,X ) 5 I for all X E B1. Now consider the family of analytic maps P(n)( t , X ) : 23l + M(") defined by: P(n)( t , X ) = T ( t , X ) @
These have unbounded generator F(")( X ) given by n
X@j-' @ (G (X)- X B - B ' X ) @ X@(n-i)
F(")(X)= j=1
which are obviously conditionally positive definite and satisfy dn) (I)5 0 , F(n)( X ) * = F(n)(X*).Hence P(n) t X ) describe a Markovian multi( t )= 6p and, for n > 1 particle process 'II( t ) which satisfies
(t)]Z0
where [ O k are defined by T (t,X) using Proposition 3.1. This process defines an evolution of the state e ( t )E ,C1 of a multi-particle system having initial state e E L1 and generating functional R (t,X ) via the equation
89
from which it follows that eo ( t )= ~0 and for n
c
> 1:
m
en ( t )=
m=l k l +
...+k,=n
( t )@ * * * @ @k,
(@kl
( t ) )e m
Such a system has a clear interpretation as describing a multi-particle system whose evolution consists of independent branching. We now show that evolutions of the type typified by the above example are the only Markovian multi-particle processes n(t): t 0 which correspond t o single particle independent branching processes. Due to the condition that the multi-particle states have n particle components in the symmetric algebra A(") it must be that any such process is described at time t 2 0 by a multi-particle state e ( t ) of the type eo ( t )= eo
>
m
m=l kl+
where @ k ( t ):
...+k , = n It follows that
-$
c
Ilk)( t )=
@k1
Ilk)= 6r and that;
( t )@ * * ' @ @ k , ( t )
kl+...+k,=m
and P("-)(t,X) = T ( t ,X)@'". By taking n = 1 we see that T ( t ,X ) is positive definite, and that T ( t ,I ) 5 I for t > 0 from which follows T ( t ,X) E B1 for all X E B 1 . The requirement that ( t )be a semi-group means that for all n E Z+ we have;
IIk)
m
n
.
=m k=O k l + . .+k, =k j=1
MI
from which it follows (by taking n = 1) that
and hence that:
T (t
+ T , X ) = T ( t ,T
(T, X
))
90 By considering the case n = 1 we see that ;di i T ( t , X ) l = F ( l ) ( X ) t=o
which is necessarily conditionally positive definite and satisfies F ( l )(X)*= F ( l ) (X*) hence there exist A , (i) and B such that:
c
00
d(m)d(l)
m=O
i=l
F(l)( X ) =
A , (i)* X B m A , (i) - X B - B * X
Hence we see that; d 1 -T (t,X) = lim - (T (st,T (t,X)) - T (0,T (t,X))) dt 6t-0 6t =
C C
A , (i)* T ( t , X ) B ' m A m ( i )
m=O i=l -T (t,X ) B
- B*T(t,X
)
showing that the above example does indeed characterise all Markovian multi-particle systems of independent branching.
Example 5.3. Let G ( X ) : B1 + C and N ( X ) : B1 + d(l)be analytic in the unit ball 23' and positive definite. Let c E I&.+ be such that G ( I ) 5 c , let B E be such that H ( I ) 5 B B*. Let Qr (t,X) : B1 + be analytic throughout B1 and a solution to the non-linear inverse Heisenberg Kolmogorov equation defined by d -Qr ( t , X ) = Qr ( t J ) B + BQr ( t , X ) dr
+
m=O
i=l
for 0 5 r < t with boundary condition Qt ( t , X ) = X and where the matrices A , (i) are determined by the dilation of H in Proposition 3.3. As before we define T (t,X ) to be the analytic map satisfying T (t - r ,X ) = Qr (t,X ) , which necessarily has generator H ( X ) XB B * X and satisfies T ( t ,X) 5 I for all X E 23'. Define V (t,X ) : B1 + U2 as the exponent:
+
+
)
v ( t , X )= e x p ( l G ( T ( s , X ) ) d s - c t Now consider the family of analytic maps P('l)(t,X ) : B1 -+ d('l)defined by:
P(")(t,X ) = T (t,X)@'lV (t,X )
91
These have unbounded generator F(n) ( X ) given by n
F(n)(X) = G (X) - cX
+ C X @ j - l @ ( H (X)- X B - B * X )@ X@("-j) j=1
which are obviously conditionally positive definite and satisfy F ( n )( I ) 5 0 , F(") (X)*= F(n)(X*).Hence P(n)( t , X ) describe a Markovian multiparticle process II (t)which satisfies m.
k=O k l + . . . + k , = k
(t)]EOare
defined by T ( t , X ) using Proposition 3.1 and [Wk This process defines an evolution of the.state @ ( t E) L1 of a multi-particle system having initial state e E Ll and generating functional R ( t ,X ) via the equation
where
[@k
@)IF0.
from which it follows that;
which is well defined as the form generated by the trace of products of the matrix c a n
(in the sense that the functionals coincide on A(")). Such a system has a clear interpretation as describing a multi-particle system whose evolution consists of independent branching and birth from the vacuum. We now consider all the Markovian multi-particle processes II ( t ): t 2 0 which are non-interacting. Due to the condition that the multi-particle states have n particle components in the symmetric algebra A(") it must be that any such process is described at time t 2. 0 by a multi-particle state ~ ( tof)the type
m=O k=O k l + . . .+k,=k
92
[&]Eo
where O k : M(") -+ M ( l ) ,e = E .C1 is some initial particle space and 'uk ( t )describes the state of the birthed particles. It follows that; m k=O k i + . . . + k , = k
and therefore P(") (t,X ) = T (t,X)@n' V (t,X ) . By taking n = 0 we see that V ( t ,X ) is positive definite and satisfies P (t,I) I for t > 0. It then follows that T ( t , I ) I (since otherwise P(") @,I) > I for n 2 N E N). The requirement that IIk) ( t )be a semi-group means that for n = 0 we have;
<
<
m
00
and hence
which gives us that:
+ +
V(t r,X) = V(t,T(r,X))V(r,X) T(t r,X)=T(t,T(r,X)) By considering the case n = 0 we see that
d -v dt
(t,X )
I
= F(O)( X )
t=O
and hence that: d -v dt
(t,X ) = F(O)(T (t,X ) ) v (t,X )
If we further assume that the generator
is conditionally completely positive and satisfies H ( X ) * = H ( X * ) then the multi-particle system is of the type described by the previous example.
93
6. Branching systems with interaction strength In this section we generalise the examples from the previous section to look at a specific class of interacting branching processes for which we can determine asymptotic solutions in the limit as the interaction strength tends to zero and correspondingly the number of particles tends to infinity. In the first example the Markovian multi-particle process was found to have a generator described by;
F(") ( X ) = (G ( X ) - C ) X@'" for a positive definite G (X) satisfying G (I)5 c. In the second example we saw that the generator was of the form n
F(") ( X ) =
C
X@j-l@
( H ( X ) - X B - B * X )Q9 X@('+j)
j=1
+
for some positive definite H ( X ) satisfying H ( I ) 5 B B*. In the third example the generator was the sum of the previous two, namely:
F(")(X) = G ( X ) - C X +
n
C X @ j - l @ ( H ( X ) - X B - B * X )Q9 X@("-j) j=1
In general we can always write the generator of a Markovian multiparticle process in the form
for some conditionally completely positive G("\") ( X ) , which we interpret as describing the rate of interactions involving k particles independently of the rest of the system, given that there are n. particles in total. The third example is a case in point, it describes the birth from the vacuum and single particle branching which is independent of the number of particles, and the state of the other particles. We will generalise the previous section in the following definition. Definition 6.1. The Markovian multi-particle process IIE( t ) is said to be a branching process with interaction strength E > 0 if its generator is described by a family of conditionally positive definite maps FJn) : B1 + which are analytic in the unit ball B1 and satisfy FJn) ( I ) 5 0 , Fin)( X ) * = F:") (X')of the form
94
where G(') ( X ) are analytic conditionally positive definite generating functions which can always be written in the form d(m)d(t)
w
($k)
A($)(i)* X@mA($) (i) - X@kK(k)- K(k)*X@k
( X )= m=O
i=l
for some A:) (i) :?dk) + ?dm)and w
E A('")satisfying:
am+'
m=O i=I
Our first example is the simplest branching process with interaction strength which is interacting. It consists of the independent pairwise branching interactions with a strength E > 0.
Example 6.1. Consider the generator described by the family F(n)( X ) = 0 for 0 5 n 5 1 and for n > 1
where
G ( X )=
w
4m)W
m=O
i=l
C
c
for some Am (i) : 3t(2)
A , (i)* XmmAm(i) - X @ 2 K- K * X B 2
X ( m ) and B
cc 03
E A(2)satisfying:
am+'
A , (i)* A , (i) IK
+ K*
m=O i=l
jFrom Theorem 4.1 such a family determines a Markovian multi-particle process. The equation of motion for the associated state generating functional RE( t ,X ) must satisfy, at least for positive X
where G ( X ) =
xiXiGi ( X ) @ ' . We write this in the form:
95
Let us assume that the initial state of the system is described by a state generating functional of the form
{: 1 {: 1
R, ( 0 , X ) = A ( X )exp - B ( X ) and look for solutions of the form
RE(t,X ) = A ( t ,X ) exp - B ( t ,X )
where B ( X ) is a conditionally positive definite dissipative analytic functional in B1 and A ( X ) is a positive definite contractive analytic functional in Bl. Under these assumptions the equation of motion for the state generating functional can be defined as the solution to;
equating powers of
E
we have:
Hence up to a term of order
E
we find that the state generating function is
96
determined by the solution to the equations
d -B d t ( t 7 X )= 2 ( G ( X ), (A8 (t,x))@ 2 ) with the initial conditions A ( 0 , X ) = A ( X ) , fi ( t , X ) = B ( X ) . These equations are recognised as the transport equation and Hamilton- Jacobi equation for a Hamiltonian system with Hamiltonian 1 2
H ( X ,P ) = -- (G ( X ),P@') where:
a
P ( t , X ) = -B dX
(t,X)
We now assume the existence of solutions Q t , Pt to the Hamiltonian system
satisfying the boundary conditions QO = Y and Po = &B ( Y ) for some Y E B1. Equivalently we assume Q,, P, are the solutions to the equations
97
due to the fact that, for example, for every
eE
We make the further assumption that not only is the Hamiltonian system solvable, but for each fixed t E I&+. and X E 23l there is a unique Y E 23l satisfying X = Qt. In finite dimensions this corresponds to the Jacobian
not vanishing. Due to this assumption we can write the Hamilton Jacobi equation in the form;
ddtB
(t,X )= --B (t,Q t ) dt .. /Qo=Y(t.X) =
((
&t,
a
a h (t,Q t ) Q.=Y(t,X)
the second equality being the explicit form of the total derivative &B (t,Qt). Then:
Likewise for
a (t,X) we have
d d - A (CX) = -A (t,Q t ) / dt dt Q,=Y(t,X)
98
Hence
and we have a solution:
Then subject to the stated assumptions being satisfied, there exists an approximate solution to the family of state generating functional R, (t,X) which describe the state of a multi-particle system undergoing independent pairwise interaction which can be written in the form:
ii, ( t , ~=)A ( t , x ) e x p We now investigate how closely RE(t,X ) approximates the exact solution R, (t,X ) . An exact solution of the form
R, (t,X ) = A (t,X ) exp must satisfy the equation
:
whereas our
=LA(t,X)
f& ( t ,X ) satisfies:
99
We use the Du Hammel principle to write
which can be written in the operator form
-@) 2
A ( X )2 ( t , X ) = ( A ( X ) - E where
@
A (t,X)
is the operation defined by:
Then, provided the right hand side converges, we can write;
(
A ( t , X ) = 1---@) iA;X)
-1
A(t,X)
the right hand side is given by
from which follows the upper bound
showing that the asymptotic solution does indeed converge to the true solution as E + 0. The above example illustrates the method used in the proof of the following theorem
Definition 6.2. We call the following Hamiltonian system a canonical pair
100
of quantum kinetic equations, Qt = X E B1,PO= Y E M ( l )
a ( K ( ~ ) * , ( P ~ Q T )p+ @~)) pr+ca(dPQT T
O0
m=O
Theorem 6.1. If the family
Fin): B1 + M(")describes the generator of
a Markovian multi-particle system with interaction strength E > 0 , and the initial state of the system is described by a generating function of the f o r m R C
c
1
( 0 , X ) = A ( X )e ~ p-B ( X )
where B ( X ) is a conditionally positive definite dissipative analytic functional in B1 and A ( X ) i s a positive definite contractive analytic functional in B', then there exists a solution RE( t , X ) of the state generating function at any t > 0 for which the canonical pair of quantum kinetic equations have solutions QT ( t , X ) : Qt = X , PT ( t , X ) : PO= &B (Y)ly=q,(t,x) f o r any X E B1.These solutions are given formally by the expressions R € ( t , X ) = e x p { f B ( t , X ) } (l--@)1 A (XI where
-1
A(t,X)
101
and 0 is the operation defined by:
Proof. The proof is a generalisation of the method illustrated by the previous example. We look for a solution to the equation of motion
-RE d ( t , X )= 1 dt
&
25(
( t , X ) ,G(") ( X ) )
&RE
m=O
satisfying the required initial condition, by looking for solutions of the form:
{: 1
R E ( t , X )= A ( t , X ) e x p - B ( t , X ) We find that under such an assumption
and throw away the higher coefficients of
and:
E,
looking for solutions to
102
We again associate the above equations with the Hamilton-Jacobi and transport equation for a Hamiltonian system with Hamiltonian
H ( X ,P ) = -
c m! * 1
( G ( m )( X ) ,Porn) m=O with Pt = &B (t,X ) satisfying the boundary conditions A (0, X ) = A ( X ) and B ( 0 , X ) = B ( X ) . The resulting Hamiltonian system can then be written in the form
from which it follows that
gdt B (t,X ) = dt
(t,Qt (t,X ) )
= (Qt(t,W,
a
( t , Q t ( t , X ) ) )- H (Qt ( t , X ),Pt ( t , X ) )
the second equality being the explicit form of the total derivative $ B (t,Qt). Then:
B (t,X ) = B (Qo (t,X I )
Likewise for
( t , X ) we have
103
where the right hand side takes the form:
In this case we know that Qt(t,X ) = and so we have
hence
and therefore:
To complete the proof we note that
c:=, 5 &(G(m)(Qt(t,X ) ) ,P R m )
104
whereas an exact solution for RE(t,X ) of the assumed type must satisfy
the result then follows from the Du Hammel principle as described in the previous example. 0
References 1. V. P. Belavkin, in: Mathematical Models of Statistical Physics [in Russian], Izdat. TGU, Tyumen', 1982: Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 293, 18 (1987) 2. W. F. Stinespring, Proc. Am. Math. SOC. 6, 211 (1995) 3. G. Lindblad, Comm. Math. Phys. 48, 119 (1976) 4. J. T. Lewis and D. E. Evans, Dilations of Irreversible Evolutions in Algebraic Quantum Theories, Comm. Dublin Inst. for Adv. Studies, Ser. A, Vol. 24, 1997
A NOTE O N VACUUM-ADAPTED SEMIMARTINGALES AND MONOTONE INDEPENDENCE
ALEXANDER C. R. BELTON Lady Margaret Hall, Oxford OX2 6QA, United Kingdom E-mail: beltonamaths. ox.ac.uk A class of vacuum-adapted regular quantum semimartingales, with integrands which act as the conditional expectation on Fock space, are proved to possess increments which are monotone independent. The vacuum-adapted analogue of the Poisson process is shown to have increments which are distributed according to the monotonic law of small numbers.
1. Introduction
The vacuum-adapted analogue of Brownian motion (i.e., the solution to the quantum stochastic differential equation Z(0) = E(O), d Z = EdA + E d A f ) has increments which are distributed (in the vacuum state) according to the arcsine law [2, Section 4.41 (the result therein for Z ( t ) generalizes simply t o Z ( t ) - Z(s) for all t 3 s 2 0). The monotone Brownian motion of Muraki also has increments which are distributed according to the arcsine law [5, Section 4.21 and this observation suggests a connexion between monotone and vacuum-adapted processes. In Section 2 it is proved that if M is a regular vacuum-adapted quantum semimartingale, with integrands which act as the conditional expectation on Fock space, then M satisfies the identities
( M ( t )- M(s))’E(t) = ( M ( t )- M(s))’ = E ( t ) ( M ( t )- M(s))’ (an immediate consequence of vacuum-adaptedness) and
IE(s)(M(t)- M ( S ) ) ’ I E ( S ) = (a,( M ( t )- M ( s ) ) ’ W ( s )
<
for all p E N and all s, t E R+ such that s t. It follows that M is a monotone-independent processes in the sense of Muraki [7]. The relationship observed above between monotone and vacuumadapted Brownian motion gives rise to the thought that the 0-Poisson
105
106
process, i.e., the process M such that
M ( 0 ) = IE(0) and
dM =l E( dA
+ dA + dAt + dt),
should have increments distributed according to the monotone Poisson law, i.e., Muraki’s monotone law of small numbers [7, Section 41. This is proved in Section 3 and an explicit formula for the moments of that distribution is given. The presentation in this note follows the elegant approach to multidimensional quantum stochastic calculus due to Lindsay [3] which has evolved in articles by Lindsay and Wills. (Meyer [4, Section V.31 claims that this coordinate-free notation may be traced back to roots in work by Belavkin.) The treatment of [3] is simplified here, as the processes integrated in the sequel are bounded and act on Fock space as the conditional expectation; these integrals may be thought of as a form of vacuum-adapted Wiener integrals. It is straightforward to verify that the approach to multidimensional quantum stochastic integration given in [2, Section 5.41, based on the idea of bounded admissible collections of processes, is equivalent to the “coordinate-free” approach adopted in this note. 1.1. Conventions and Notation
All Hilbert spaces are complex, with inner products that are linear in the second argument and conjugate linear in the first. The Banach algebra of bounded linear operators on a Hilbert space H is denoted by B ( H ) . If E is an orthogonal projection then E’- := I - E is its orthogonal complement; I (or Ix) denotes the identity operator (on X).The restriction of a function f to a set X is denoted by f l x . The indicator function of a set A is denoted by X A , with the domain of X A being clear from the context. The set of natural numbers is denoted by N := { 1 , 2 , 3 , . . .}. Throughout, R is to be pronounced “vacuum”. 2. Preliminaries
Let k be a separable Hilbert space (the multzpplicity space) and let the elements of may be written as column vectors:
(3
E i(
and 2 : =
(:)
(A E C ,
2
E
:= C@k;
k).
R+ := [O,co) is any interval then L 2 ( I ;k) E L 2 ( I )@ k is the If I Hilbert space of k-valued, weakly measurable functions on I which are
107
square integrable. For f : I + k let
f : I + k be defined by
Let 31:= I?+ ( L 2 ( I ;k)) denote Boson Fock space over the Hilbert space L 2 ( I ;k) and define abbreviations
F
:= FR+,
Fs):= F[o,~), Fs,t := F[s,t) and Fp := Fp,..)
<
for all s,t E R+ with s t. Let ~ ( fdenote ) the exponential vector associated with f : recall that the linearly independent set { ~ ( f :)f E L2(Iw;k)} is total in F. There exist isometric isomorphisms k,,t : F F,)@F,,t@Fp which act on exponential vectors so that kS,t&(f)
= a s ) )
@ d f s , t ! @E(f[t)
V f E L2@+;k),
where fs) := f l p s ) , fs,t := fl[s,t) and f p := f([t,m) are the restrictions of the function f to the given interval. Let IE denote the conditional expectation on F,i.e., IE: IFP + B(F)is such that E ( s ) ~ ( f= ) E ( ~ X [ ~ , , ) ) V S E R+, f E L2(R+;k). Note that IE(s)lE(t) = lE(min{s,t}) for all s , t E R+. Throughout this note, a R-process is a weakly measurable function E: W + B(k €3 F)which is R-adapted, i.e.,
E ( s ) = (Ii, €3 IE(s))E(s)(Ii @ IE(s))
V S E R+.
If the function E : + B ( k ) is weakly measurable then E : s e E(s) @ IE(s) is a 0-process, the R-ampliation of E. Let p k and A Pk €3 13 denote the orthogonal projections on k and k €3 F,respectively, with ranges k and k €3 F. Define =’
E,X := A E A , E,X := A E A l , EO, := A l E A and E,O := A l E A l .
(1)
A R-process E is admissible if IIEIIt := IIE,”IIm,t
where
+ IIE,XIIz,t + IIEO,Iln,t+ llE,”lli,t< 00
V t E R+,
(2)
108
(The measurability condition on E is sufficient to ensure that these norms are well defined.) Theorem 2.1. If E is an admissible R-process then there exists a collection J E dA = E d A : t E W ) of bounded linear operators on 3 such that
(s,"
f o r all t E R+ and all f , g E L2(R+;k). firthemnore,
I/
fi
dAll
< IlEllt
V t E @,
where 11 . Ilt is as defined in Eq. (2). Proof. Let I = (1,. ..,dim k} (or I = N if dim k = MI) and let f := (0) U I. Suppose that ( e , : a E I) is an orthonormal basis of k and define operators P o : 3 + k @ z8 H d € 3 8 ,
Pa:F+kGz 8-ea€38
(UEI)
and Pa = Pi for all a E f; a quick calculation shows that Pau@8 = (e,, u)8 for all a E I, u E k and 8 E F and also that CaEn Pap" = A in the sense of strong operator convergence. It is easy t o verify that the column decomposition & = C @ k induces the block decomposition
and that
where
109
and
E; := paEzPb, E," := PaE,XPo and Ef := poE:Pb
V a , b E I.
(As k L @ 3 is naturally identified with 3,the two possible interpretations of E: will cause no confusion.) Since l2(I;7 )E 12(11)@F E k @ 3 , it follows immediately that {FF} is a bounded admissible collection of processes in the sense of [2, Section 5.41. To see that these processes are 0-adapted, note that PaIE = ( I i @ lE)Pa, and
SO
IEP'
= Pa(Ii €3 E),for all a E
%.Furthermore,
A(Ii €3 E) = Pk €3 IE = (Ii €3 lE)A
so A L ( I i €3 lE) = (Ii @ lE)AL;hence EEtIE = waEzPblE = Pa(Ii@ lE)AEA(Ii €3 IE)Pb = p a A ( I i€3 lE)E(Ii €3 E)APb = PaAEAPb = E t for all a, b 6 I. Similar working shows that EEFE = E; for all a,,B E i and the result follows by [2, Proposition 371. The following is the quantum It6 product formula for R-processes. Theorem 2.2. Let E and F be admissible R-processes and let M = S E dA and N = F dA. Then G is an admissible process, where
s
G = (P: €3 M)F + E(P:
@N)
+ EAF,
and M N = S G d A . Proof. This is a rewording of a result given in [2, Section 5.41; the process denoted above by G corresponds to the bounded admissible collection {G;} specified by [2, Equations 68-71].
Corollary 2.1. If M = S E dA then M" = S E(")dA for all n E N,where
E(") =
C
(P:
€3 M)"E(P: €3 M ) B
a+B=n-l
+
C
(P, €3 M ) ~ ( E A ) ~ ~ + ~€3 E M)? (P*
a+B+y=n-2
and the summation is over non-negative integers.
110
Proof. This follows by induction.
0
3. Result
The following are fixed throughout this section: let E: I&+ weakly measurable and such that IIPkEPkllcqt
+ B ( i ) be
+ I I P k E P k l l l 2 , t -k I I P k l E P k l l 2 , t + IIPklEPklII1,t<
00
for all t E W, let E be the R-ampliation of E, let’ M = J EdA and (for brevity) let M,,t := M ( t ) - M ( s ) for all s,t E rW+ with s t.
<
Lemma 3.1. If 6: X I+ (R, XR) is the vector state on B(F)corresponding to the vacuum vector R := e(0) then
IE(O)XIE(O) = +(X)IE(O)
vx E B(F).
Proof. This follows by a simple calculation. Proposition 3.1. If s,t E W are such that s
0
< t then
Proof.
Ssince
Corollary 3.1. If p E N and s , t E IW+ are such that s
M:,JE(t) = M$ = lE(t)M$
< t then
and lE(s)M:,,IE(s) = +(M:,,)lE(s).
111
Proof. The first two identities are immediate consequences of Proposition 3.1 and the fact that
W t ) = Ic,: ( k €3 )
€3 E(0)
1
ks,t.
The final claim follows from Lemma 3.1, Proposition 3.1 and the fact that
E(s) = q;( I F s ) €3 W )I F*,t€3 E(0)I F[*1k
0
t .
The following definition is due to Muraki [7]. Definition 3.1. A family of quantum random variables ( X i ) i E r (where I is a totally ordered set) is monotonically independent with respect to the state # if
for all i
< j, Ic < j
and p E N and
for all i, > ... > il > i, j n > > jl > i a n d p , p l , . . . ,p m,q l,.. . ,qn E N. (The possibilities m = 0 or n = 0 are allowed and are interpreted in the natural manner.) Theorem 3.1. The process M has monotonically independent increments: i f n E N and 0 s1 6 tl . . . 6 s, t , then (Msi,ti)y=l is monotonically
<
<
<
independent with respect to the vacuum state #: X e ( 0 , X n ) . Proof. Let i,j,Ic E ( 1 , . . . , n } be such that i < j and k ti t j - 1 s j , Corollary 3.1 implies that
<
<
Mai,ti
< j and l e t p E N.
Since
Mai,tiE(ti)= Msi,tiJE(ti)E(sj)= MS,,tiIE(sj)
1
and similarly MSk,tk= E ( s j ) M s , , t k .Hence, again by Corollary 3.1, MSi,ti
M:,,tj
MSk,th
= MSi,ti~sj)M,q.,,jIE(sj)MS,,tk
= Msi
,ti
#(MG
,tj
)IE('j l M s k , t b
Thus the first part of Definition 3.1 is satisfied.
= 4(M:j , t j ) M S i , t i
l'Sk
,tk.
112 and
For the second, let
let
Note that,
by Lemma 3.1, Colllary 3.1 and the fact that
et cetera, and so, by Lemma 3.1,
as required.
In principle, the mixed moments of the increments of M can be found by using monotone independence, which reduces the calculation to finding various q5(M:,) (see [6, Section 11 or [7, Section 21 for a nice explanation of how to do this) and these simple moments may be found using Corollary 2.1. In practice, the algebraic complexity may be formidable. 4. Example
s
Let k = CC and E(s) = ( i i ) for all s E E??, so that M := EdA is the R-adapted analogue of the Poisson process. A straightforward calculation, applying Corollary 2.1 to X[s,ml E dA, shows that m p ( t ):= $(M:,s+t) for s , t E W satisfies mo 3 1 , mp(0)= 0 and
s
k=O Hence m l ( t ) = t for all t E R+ and (mp+l - mp)’ = denotes the Laplace transform of mp, P+ 1 hP+l (x) = x-2
Jj=2
and
+ jx-1)
(1
Cp + l ) m p so, if eP
113
Proposition 4.1. If 1
Clp(t,x)
:=
p!
(E) ”--l
then m,(t) = p p ( t ,0) for all p E
(t - log(1 - 2))” (1 - x ) 2
N and t E W .
Proof. Note first that p1 (t,0) = t = ml ( t ) and P P ( t 7 2)
where Gq,&
2) := (d/dz)‘J(t- log(1 - 2))”. Hence,
if
then
But
d
G,+l,& 0) =
(a,)
p(t - log(1-
.))”-I
1-2
= qGq,p(t,O)+ P G q , p - l ( t , O )
(6)
and therefore Rp(t,O)= 0 for all t E R+. Furthermore, a simple inductive argument using Eq. (6) establishes the fact that G,,,(O, 0) = 0 for all p E N and all q E (0,. . . , p - 1). Hence pp(O,0) = 0 and the result follows.
114
Corollary 4.1. The R-Poisson process M is such that, in the vacuum state, Ms,t (0 3 t ) has probability distribution Y, the limit distribution of the monotonic law of small numbers [7, Theorem 4.11 (with parameter x = t - 5).
< <
Acknowledgments This note was inspired by a talk given by Dr Uwe Franz and discussion with Dr Anis Ben Ghorbal. These took place during the Conference on Quantum Probability and Infinite-Dimensional Analysis which was held at the Krupp-Kolleg, Greifswald, Germany, on 23rd-27th June, 2003; the hospitality of the organisers is gratefully acknowledged.
References 1. A. C. R. BELTON,Quantum R-semimartingales and stochastic evolutions, J . Funct. Anal. 187,94-109 (2001). An isomorphism of quantum semimartingale algebras, 2. A. C. R. BELTON, Quart. J . Math. 55, 135-165 (2004). 3. J. M. LINDSAY,Quantum stochastic calculus lecture notes, Preprint-Reihe Mathematik Nr. 8/2003, Ernst-Moritz-Arndt-Universitat Greifswald, 2003. 4. P.-A. MEYER,Quantum probability for probabilists, second edition, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1538, Springer, Berlin, 1995. 5. N. MURAKI,Noncommutative Brownian motion in monotone Fock space, Commun. Math. Phys. 183,557-570 (1997). 6. N. MURAKI,Monotonic convolution and monotonic Lbvy-HinEin formula, preprint, 2000. 7. N. MURAKI,Monotonic independence, monotonic central limit theorem and monotonic law of small numbers, Infin. Dimens. Anal. Quantum Probab. Relat. TOP. 4, 39-58 (2001).
QUANTUM STOCHASTIC PROCESSES AND APPLICATIONS
MOHAMED BEN CHROUDA and MOHAMED EL OUED and HABIB OUERDIANE Dipartement de Mathematiques Faculti des sciences de !Funis 1060 !Funis, iPllnisia We use special chains of test functions and distributions spaces to give an analytic characterization theorem for continuous linear operators on these test spaces in terms of their symbols. Then, we define the notion of convolution of operators and we give explicit solutions of some quantum stochastic differential equations.
1. Introduction and preliminaries
Let X be a real nuclear F'rechet space. Assume that its topology is defined by an increasing family of Hilbertian norms {I. ,I p E N}.Then X can be represented as
where for p E N the space X, is the completion of X with respect to the norm .1, Denote by X-, the dual space of X,, then the dual space X' of X is represented as
X' = u
x-,,
PEN
and it is equipped with the inductive limit topology. Let N (resp. N,) be the complexification of X (resp. X,),i.e. N = X + i X and N, = X, iX,, p E Z. For any n E N we denote by Nhn the n-th symmetric tensor product of N equipped with the 7r-topology and by N$" the n-th symmetric Hilbertian tensor product of N,. We will preserve the notation 1., and I.l-, for the norms on N P and N?; respectively. Let 0 be a Young function on R+, i.e. 0 is continuous, convex, increasing function
+
115
116
and satisfies lim -= +a, see Ref. 7. We define the conjugate function
e* of e by
+w
x
For a such Young function 0 we denote by Gs(N)the space of holomorphic functions on N with exponential growth of order 6 and of arbitrary type, and by .F,(N’)the space of holomorphic functions on N’ with exponential growth of order 0 and of minimal type. For every p E Z and m > 0, we denote by E x p ( N P , 8 , m )the space of entire functions f on the complex Hilbert space N p such that
Then the spaces .Fe(N’) and Gs(N) are represented as
3e(N’) = p o j lim Exp(N-,, 8, m ) PEN m>O
Ge(N) = ind lim Exp(N,, 0, m). PEN m>O
The space .Fe(N’) and its dual F;(N’) equipped with the strong topology are called the test functions space and the distributions space respectively. We denote by << ., . >> the dual pairing between .Fh(N’) and .Fe(N’). It is easy to see that for every 5 E N , the exponential function eg : z I--) e(’*g) , z E N’ where ( , ) denote the dual pairing between N’ and N , belongs to the test space .Fe(N’) for any Young function 0.Then we define the Laplace transform of a distribution q5 E Fh(N’) by
L ($ )(J ):=< 4,eF
>> , J E N .
In Ref. 3, the authors prove the important duality theorem: the Laplace transform realizes a topological isomorphism of .Fh(N’) on (N). In this paper we establish the analytic characterization theorem of continuous linear operators from Fe(N’) into .Fi(N’) in terms of their symbols, and we give a criterion for the convergence of sequence of operators. Finally, as an application, we solve some quantum stochastic differential equations and characterize their solutions. We refer to Ref. 11 in the particular case where B(x) = x k .
117
2. Characterization theorems
2.1. The Operator symbol
In this section we characterize the space of continuous linear operators from .F,e(N’)into .FL(N’) using spaces of holomorphic functions with exponential growth. Let Ce = C(.Fe(N’),.F,L(N’))be the space of .F;(N’)-valued continuous linear operators on .Fe(N’). For p E lN and m > 0 we put
(((EII(e,p,m = SUP{(+C EYJ,$J
1 ; ( I q ( ( e , p , mI 1 and ll$lle,p,m I 1) , E
E
Leo
Then Ce,p,m = { E E Ce , IIIEllle,p,m< +m} becomes a Banach space with norm Ill.llle,p,m and we obtain
In the general t h e ~ r y , * J ~ ~ if ’we ~ ~take ’ ~ two nuclear F’rechet spaces X and V then the canonical correspondence E t)E K given by
( E u , v ) = ( E K , u @ v ) ,u
E
X,VE V ,
yields a topological isomorphism between the spaces C ( X , V ’ ) and (XBD)’. In particular if we take X = 2) = .Fe(N‘) which is a nuclear F’rechet space, then we get
C(.Fe(N’),.F,L(N’)) (.Fe(N’)8 .Fe(N’))‘.
(2)
We define the symbol of an operator E E Ce denoted by ,!? as follows
E(t,r))= << EK,ec Be,, B-,t,r)E N .
(3)
So, the symbol ,!? can be regarded as the Laplace transform of the kernel EK
Moreover, with the help of duality theorem, and equalities (2),(4) we obtain the following theorem Theorem 2.1. T h e symbol application :
Ce E
+ 6s. ( N )@ G e e ( N ) w,!?
realizes a topological isomorphism, i.e. let F be a function o n N x N with values an C, t h e n there exists a n operator E E Ce with F = ,!? if and only if
118
*
(i) f o r any t,t1,r ] , r]l E N , the function ( 2 , w) F ( z t + 51, wr]+ 111) is an entire function on C x C; (ii) there exist constants c > 0,m > 0 and p E JV such that
IF((, r ] ) l 5 c e"(ml~lp)+e'(ml~lp) ,
t,r] E N .
Remark This theorem is a generalization of the characterization theorem of operators given in Refs. 10, 11, 12 in the particular case 6(z) = xk and given in Ref. 1 using C.K.S spaces. 2.2. Convergence of operators
Recall that ( N ) @ 0s. ( N ) equipped with the r-topology is a nuclear F'rechet space, one of the properties of nuclear spaces is that the closed bounded sets are compacts15. Now we describe the convergence in 6s. ( N ) @ Be* ( N ) .
Theorem 2.2. Let ( f n ) be a sequence in G p ( N ) €3 G,g*(N). Then the following assertions are equivalents: (1) (f n ) converges in G e e ( N ) @ Go* ( N ) . ( N ) and is pointwise convergent. (2) (f n ) is bounded in 60. ( N ) @ (3) ( f n ) is bounded in G,g*(N)8 G p ( N ) and it has a unique cluster point in Be* ( N ) @ G,p ( N ) .
Proof ( N ) i.e. there exist p 2 0 Assume that (f n ) converges to f in ( N )@ and m > 0 such that limn++oo 11 f n - f II,g*,p,m = 0. In particular (f n ) is bounded in Ge*(N)@ Ge*(N)and is pointwise convergent. This proves 1) 2). Assume that ( f n ) has two cluster points f and g i e . , there exists two subsequences (f n l ) and (f n 2 ) of (f n ) which converge in Be* ( N ) 8 0s. ( N ) to f and g respectively. In particular the subsequence (f n l ) ( r e s p .f n 2 ) are pointwise convergent t o f (resp.g). Hence the sequence (f n ) does not pointwise convergent which is not true by assumption. This proves 2) 3). Finally, P ut S = {fn, n 2 0 } , S is a bounded set in ( N ) @ Go* ( N ) and ( N ) becomes a compact by consequence the closure 3 of S in ( N )@ set which contains the sequence ( f n ) . It is known15 that if a sequence has a unique cluster point in a compact set, then it converges. This completes the proof. w
*
+
As a consequence of theorem 2.2 we characterize the convergence of operators by the convergence of its symbols.
119
Corollary 2.1. Let (E,),>o be a sequence in Lo. Then ( E n ) converges in Lo if and only if ( 0 1 ) there exist p 2 0 , m > 0 and c 2 0 such that for every n E N Ign(J,q)I 5 c ~ z P ( ~ * ( ~+ oI *[ (Im~~ )q ~ p >E,V ), E N ; (02) f o r every
[, q
E N , limn++, &([, q) exists in C.
This result was proved in Ref- 11 with 8(x) = xk , x 2 0 , k ~ ] l , 2 ] . Remark A similar analytic characterization theorem for operator symbols and convergence of operators can be established if we replace the space Lo by the space Lo,,,, of continuous linear operators from Fe(N’) into FG(N’),where 8 and cp are two Young functions on R+. 3. The Convolution product of operators
If the Young function 8 satisfies limZ.++,
< +co,we get3
Fe(N’) L) L ~ ( x ’ ,L) ~ )F ~ ( N ’ ) ,
(5)
where y is the standard gaussian measure on X’. Consequently, to include the space L(Fe(N’),Fe(N’)) into Le we assume from now on that 8 satis< +co. In this case the function ( J , q ) t--) e-(tsq), J , q E fies lim+, N belongs to Bo*(N)8 Be*(N) N Go+,s*(Nx N ) see Ref. 14. Since Be*(N)8 Ge*(N)equipped with the pointwise multiplication is an algebra, theorem 2.1 shows that for every E1,E2 E Lo there exists E E Lo uniquely determined by g ( [ , q )= e - ~ ( t + q l € + q ) g l ( J , q ) ~ ~ ( sJ ,,qq )E, N .
(6)
The operator E defined in (6) is denoted by El * E2 and is called the convolution product of El and E2. We denote by E*, = E * E * ... * E , n times. Theorem 3.1. Let y be a Young function o n R+ which does not necessarily = +co and let f ( z ) = CnEN fnzn E E z p ( C , y , m ) f o r satisfy lim+, fnE*n E some m > 0. Then V E E Lo, the operator f * ( E ) := CnEN L(roee* )* .
Proof It is easy t o see that f ( k )E BToee*( N ) @ Groee* ( N ) . Then we conclude by theorem 2.1 that f * ( E )E C(,,,e*)*.
120
Corollary 3.1. Let E E Lo, t h e n the convolution exponential of the operator E defined by e*E := C $E*n as a n element of E L(,P)..
Remark 1) If an operator E E Lo is of degree k E N, k 2 2, i.e. e($,q) is a polynomial in t and q of degree k, then e*E E L, with cp(x) = x”-’. This result was proved in Ref. 11 with Wick product. 2) In infinite dimensional complex analysis2, a convolution operator on 3o(N’) is an operator which commutes with translation operators. Let x E N’, we define the translation operator T-, on To(”) by 7-xcp(~ =) cp(x
+Y) , 9 E N’ , cp E -7e(N’).
It was proved in Ref. 4 that T is a convolution operator on Te(N’) if and only if there exists 4 E FA(”) such that
T(cp) =
4 * cp >
vcp E To(”).
(7)
Proposition 3.1. Let E E Lo, we denote by E+ its adjoint operator, then the following assertions are equivalents: ( I ) T * E = T E , V T E L(3;,3;). (2) E+ * S = E+S , V S E L(T,9,3e). (3) E is a convolution operator. Proof The equivalent between 1) and 2) is obvious by duality. 1) j 3) For x E N’ we denote by T, the translation operator on 3,9(N’). Its symbol satisfies
?,(t,q) = a T,e<, e, >> = e(xic) ec,e, >>
- e(X>c)&( c + , , e + r ) ) . For every x E N’ we have
( E * T,)(t,q ) = e - ~ ( ~ + ~ ~ e + q ) ~ x ( t=, eq( )x i~e () E~( ,t ,qq ) ,
(8)
and
( E T x ) ( tq, ) =<<(ET,)ec, e,
>>= e(,%c)<< Eet, e , >>=e(xit),!?([,q ) .
(8) and (9) imply that
E * T, = ET,, V x
E N’.
(9)
121
On the other hand we know by hypothesis that
E*Tx=TxE,Q x E N ‘ . Then for every x E N‘ we get ET, = T,E, i.e. E is a convolution operator. 3) 2) Let E be a convolution operator, then by (7) there exists @ E FL(N’) such that E(cp) = @ * cp, V cp E .FO(N’), and we get
+
Z+(<,q)= << E+ec,e, >> = << ec, @ * e, >> = 3(q)<< ec,e, >>=3(q)ei(c+qzc+,).
Thus
-
(E+T)(<, q) = << E’TeC, e, >> = << Tee,Ee, >>=a Tee,@* e , >> = $(q) << Tec,e, >>=$(q)?(<,q) = e-1 (E+,L+q)?(t, q)$(q)ei(t+,>t+,) = e-+(c+,L+,)S(<, q ) f ( < 17) , =
w+* T)(<,q).
Let X = S ( R ) the space of rapidly decreasing functions. we denote by at and a t the annihilation and the creation operators r e ~ p e c t i v e l y . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ It is clear that for every t E R,at is a convolution operator. Then as a consequence of proposition 3.1 we get the following result
Corollary 3.2. For any T E L(.Fi,.?’i)and S E L(F’e,Fe) we obtain
T a t = T * a t = at * T , azS = a:
* S = S * at
+
.
Moreover, we have
a, * at = asat, a$
* at = a f a t ,
a, * a > = afa,, a: * a $ = a$.?.
3.1. Application to quantum stochastic diflerential equations
A one parameter quantum stochastic process with values in LO is a family of operators { Et, t E [0,TI} C Le such that the map t eEt is continuous. For such a quantum process Et we put
t n-l En= - x E * k=O
nEN*,
t
E
[O,T].
122
Since the process Et is continuous, {& ,s E [O,t]}becomes a compact set, ( N )@Be. ( N ) i.e. there exist p E IN , m > in particular it is bounded in 0 and Ct > 0 such that for every 5,q E N p we have
(t,q)I 5 Ct ee’
(mlclp)+e’
(mlqlp)
,v s E [o, t].
In particular I&(<,q)I <_ tCtee*(mlclp)+e’(m(qlp) V n E I N . In addition it is easy t o see that V C;,q E N , the sequence (&(&q))n converges to S,’.&(<,q)ds. Thus we conclude by corollary 1 that (En) converges in Ce. We denote its limit by
l E 8 d s := n-t+ca lim En in L O . Moreover, we have
/d’E8ds= l k d s , V t E [O,T]. Theorem 3.2. Let Lt and Mt be two continuous quantum stochastic processes in Lo. Then the ordinary differential equation
-dEt dt
E(O)=
+
Lt * Et M t , A E Lo,
has a unique solution E ( t ) E C(,P). given by E ( t ) = e* .f,’
Lads
*
(l
e* .f,’
- L d U
* Mads+ A ) .
(11)
Proof We apply the Laplace transform to equation (10) to get the following equation
Then
Finally we conclude by theorem 3.1 that E ( t )is given by (11)and it belongs to C(,S*)..
123 Example 1 If we take Lt = AG the Gross Laplacian and Mt = 0, then the solution of equation (10) is given by
E ( t ) = A * e*tAG, t > o . Since AG is a convolution operator we conclude by proposition 3.1 that E ( t ) can be also expressed by
E ( t ) = AetAG, t 2 0 . In what follows we consider X = S ( R ) . Example 2 Let L(i) be Lo-quantum stochastic processes for i E {1,2,3,4}, put Lt = a:Li at Li2)at a?Li3) L r ) and Mt = 0. Then equation (10) has a
+
4 +
+
unique solution in .L(,s*)*
given by
E ( t ) = e* So’ Lads * A.
(13)
Definition 3.1. A quantum stochastic process {Lt}tcR is adapted if
[ D,,Lt for any t E
R and y
E N’ with
I = [ q , L t 1 = 0, supp y E [t,+m[. In particular
Ltat = atLt and Ltat = atLt. Let {Lii’} be &-adapted quantum stochastic processes i = 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 and consider the quantum stochastic differential equation of It6 type dE E(0)
=(Lil)dAt +Ly)dAt =A,
t
+ Li3)dAt+ Li4’dt)E,
t
where At = So a f a s d s , At = So a,ds and A: = solution of equation (14) which will be adapted.
6afds.
(14)
We search a
Theorem 3.3. For i = 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 let {Lii’} C Lo be adapted stochastic quantum processes of convolution operators. Then the equation (14) has a unique solution in C(,e*). given by
E ( t ) = A * ezp*(
/ot
+
+
+
( a f L p ) a , L r ) a , aiLL3) Lp))ds)
124
Proof By means of symbols, we transform equation (14) to a usual differential equation
+ M L f 3 ) E t ) ( E , d$- (L14'Et)(Elrl).
(15)
On the other hand we apply the symbol map t o equation (10) discussed in example 2 dE
{ E/t,o dt
=(atLf')at = A E Lo,
+ Lf2)at + arLf3)+ ,514') * E ,
(16)
we obtain
-
then equations (15) and (17) coincide if
(LF'Et)(<,q)= e-(5'"'F)(E,~)~~(<,77)
,
i = 1,2,3,4
or equivalently if
Lfi) o Et = Lfi) * Et
,
i = 1,2,3,4.
Finally we conclude by proposition 3.1 that equation (14) is equivalent to w (16) and E ( t ) given by (13) is the unique solution of (14).
References 1. D.M. Chung,U.C. Ji and N. Obata : Higher powers of quantum white noises an termes of integral kernel operators. Infinite Dimensional Analysis, Quantum probability and Related Topics, V01.1, No.4 (1998) 533-559. 2. D. Dineen : Complex Analysis in locally convex spaces, Mathematical studies 57, North Holland, Amsterdam (1981). 3. R. Gannoun, R. Hachaichi, H. Ouerdiane and A. Rezgui : U n the'orkme de dualite' entre espace de fonctions holomorphes d croissance exponentielle. J . f i n c . Anal, Vol. 171, No. 1 , pp. 1-14, (2000). 4. R. Gannoun, R. Hachaichi, P. Krde et H. Ouerdiane : Division de fonction holomorphe a croissance 8-exponentielle. Preprint, BiBos Nr: E 00-01-04, (2000). 5. T. Hida : , Brownian motion, Danslated from the Japanese by the author and T. P. Speed, Springer- Verlag, New York,1980.
125
6. T. Hida, H-H. Kuo, J. Potthof and L. Streit : White noise, an infinitedimentional calculus, Kluwer Academic Publishers Group, Dordrecht, 1993. 7. M-A. Krasnosel'ski and Ya-B. Ritickili : Convex functions and Orliez spaces. P .Noordhoff. Itd, Groningen, The Netherlands (1961). 8. P. Kr6e and R. Raczka : Kernels and symbols of operators in quantum field theory. Ann. I. H . P. Section A , Vol. 18, No. 1, (1978), p . 41-73. 9. H-H. Kuo : White noise distribution theory, CRC Press,Boca Raton, FL, 1996. 10. N. Obata : White noise calculus and Fock space. L.N.M 1577 (1994). 11. N. Obata : Wick product of white noise operators and quantum stochastic differential equations. J. Math. SOC.Japan Vol. 51, No. 3, (1999), p . 613-641. 12. H. Ouerdiane : Noyaux et symboles d'ope'rateurs sur des fonctionnelles analytiques gaussiennes. Japanese Journal of Math. Vol. 21, No.1, 223-234 (1995). 13. H. Ouerdiane : Alge'bres nucle'aires et e'quations aux dirive'es partielles stochastiques. Nagoya Math. journal, Vol. 151, 107-127, (1998). 14. H. Ouerdiane : Nuclear * algebras of entire functions and applications. BiBos Nr: 00-05-15 Univ. Bielfeld Germany (2000). 15. F. Trhves : Topological vector space, Distributions and kernels. Academic press New York. London (1967)
REGULAR QUANTUM STOCHASTIC COCYCLES HAVE EXPONENTIAL PRODUCT SYSTEMS *
B.V. RAJARAMA BHAT Statistics and Mathematics Unit,
Indian Statistical Institute (Bangalore Centre) R. V. College Post Bangalore 560059 India E-mail: bhatOisibang.ac.in
J. MARTIN LINDSAY School of Mathematical Sciences University of Nottingham University P a r k Nottingham NG7 2RD
U.K. E-mail: jmlOmaths.nott. ac.uk
Normal *-homomorphic quantum stochastic cocycles on a von Neumann algebra determine *-endomorphism semigroups and thereby product systems of Hilbert W*-bimodules. This product system is identified for a wide class of stochastic cocycles including all those whose Markov semigroup is norm continuous. When the stochastic cocycle is viewed as a dilation of its Markov semigroup the dilation is typically not minimal however in many cases it dominates an irreducible quantum stochastic dilation. Moreover when the semigroup is norm continuous it has irreducible stochastic dilations and, if the semigroup is also cosnervative, the product system of any such dilation is the same as that of the minimal dilation.
*Based on a talk given by JML in the Workshop Dilations, E-semigroups and Product Systems, Greifswald, Germany, June 2003. 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 81825, 47A20 Keywords and phrases. Noncommutative probability, stochastic cocycle, Eo-semigroup, product systems, Hilbert modules, quantum stochastic
126
127
Introduction Quantum stochastic cocycles (with respect to a CCR flow) on a von Neumann algebra M , which are *-homomorphic, give rise to E-semigroups on the tensor product of M with the algebra of bounded operators on the symmetric Fock space of the flow ([L]). When M is a full algebra, the noise dimension space is one-dimensional and the cocycle is regular, the associated product system of Hilbert spaces (in the sense of Arveson, see [Arl]) has been shown to be isomorphic to an exponential product system in particular it is Type I ([Bz]). Here we identify the product system of Hilbert W*-modules (in the sense of Bhat and Skeide) for regular stochastic cocycles in the general case. Again we find that the system is isomorphic to an exponential product system - with Hilbert W*-bimodules replacing Hilbert spaces. In the case of full algebras the minimality of the E-semigroup, viewed as a dilation of the associated Markov semigroup, may be tested by an effective criterion - moreover every Markovian semigroup on the algebra (i.e. pointwise ultraweakly continuous semigroup of completely positive normal contractions) which is norm continuous has such a stochastic dilation, which is minimal ([Bl]). By contrast, minimal quantum stochastic dilation is typically not achievable for non-full algebras - at least not with the quantum stochastic calculus in its present form ([Par],[Mey],[L]). We have therefore introduced a notion of irreducibility for quantum stochastic dilations. Each quantum stochastic dilation (of a norm continuous Markovian semigroup on a von Neumann algebra) dominates an irreducibile one and, at least when the semigroup is unital, the product system of the irreducible dilation coincides with that of the minimal dilation. In this note we summarise these results; full proofs will appear elsewhere ([BLI,~]).
Notation. The symbol denotes algebraic tensor product, and 8 is reserved for tensor products of Hilbert spaces, von Neumann algebras and ultraweakly continuous completely bounded linear maps between von Neumann algebras. 1. Product systems of Hilbert W*-modules
Fix a von Neumann algebra ( M , b ) . Let (Et)t>o be a family of Hilbert W*-bimodules ouer M where EO= M ([Skl]). Thus each Et is a Hilbert W*-module over M and is also a bimodule over M which is balanced in the sense that the left and right actions of M commute. Concretely, Et is an ultraweakly closed subspace of B(b;Kt), for a Hilbert space Kt, and
128
there are sesquilinear maps
(t,rl) * (t,rl)
Et x Et + M, denoted satisfying
(5,rla)= (5,rl)a, namely (1,~) = <*Q. In view of the self-duality of Hilbert W*-modules there is a nice block matrix picture of the situation in which Et is realised as a corner of the von Neumann algebra
Here, and below, Ba denotes the von Neumann algebra of adjointable, and thus (completely) bounded, linear maps; IEt) consists of elements
15) : M + Et, a ++
Ea
(t E Et)
and (Etl consists of elements
(tl: E t + M,
17
*(t,~).
The Dirac notation here is in synch with the operator space structure present. For example each embedding Ba(FI;F!)L) CB(F1;Fz)is isometric ([Ble]). The family (Et)t>o - forms a product system of Hilbert W'-bimodules over M ([BhS]) if there is a two-parameter family of identifications (bimodule M-unitary maps):
Es O Et
+)
Es+t,
where O denotes ultraweak interior tensor product, which satisfy consistency conditions which ensure that the following diagram commutes:
J It is worth noting that the ultraweak interior tensor product coincides with the module weak-* Haagerup tensor product ([Ble]), so that the operator space structure is also respected by the above identifications.
129
An isomorphism of two such systems ( E t )and (Ei) over M is a family (At : Et + E;)t>o - of bimodule M-unitary maps satisfying the obvious compatibility conditions, namely that the following diagram commutes:
Es O Et AsaAtl
EL 0El
-
Es+t
E:+,
By M-isometric, (respectively M-unitary), for a linear map C : FI + F2 between Hilbert W*-modules over M we mean a module map (resp. isomorphism) satisfying
(equivalently, by polarisation, (CE,Cq)= (E, q)), similarly we shall say that an element is M-normalised if l l t j l ~= 1 ~ . A unit of a product system is a family (wt)t>o such that
<
wt E Et for each t
2 0 and
ws+t
= w s 0w t ;
it is M-nomnalised if each wt is M-normalised: (ut,Wt) =
1M-
A basic question for a given product system is whether it has ‘sufficiently many’, some or no units. In the case of product systems of Hilbert spaces this trichotomy is stated as follows: the system is either Type I or Type I1 or Type 111. The paradigm Type I product system of Hilbert spaces is the exponential system (Fk,[O,t[)t>O, where Fk,l denotes the symmetric Fock space (or exponential Hilbert space, in another parlance) over L 2 ( I ;k) for a Hilbert space k and subinterval I of !&, with Fk,[O,s+t[
F k , [ O , s [ @ Fk,[s,s+t[
Fk,[O,s[
@ Fk,[O,t[
(1)
giving the requisite identifications. For such systems multiples of certain exponential vectors:
provide suficiently many units in the sense that the following collection of vectors is total in F k := &$+ ([Arl]): & ( d l l [ t o , t l [ ) ~ . . . ~ ~ ( d_l,t,[) ,l[t,
nEN,di,...& E k,O=to 5 . . * i t , .
130
Analogously, an exponentid system of Hilbert W*-bimodules over M , is based on a Hilbert W*-bimodule F over M , and is the family (FF,[o,t[)t>o defined as follows ([BhS]). For each subinterval 1 of R+ and n E Z+define
rI := { a c I : #a < m>and rp) :=
cI:
=n>
so that for n 2 1 there is a natural bijection
rp)
+)
A?) := {s E P
:s1<
. - -< s n > .
Write I'for rl[p+Lebesgue . measure on A p ) thereby induces a measure on I??) and so, by stipulating that 0 is an atom of unit measure, a measure on Un20 I?) = rI. This is the Guichardet measure (called symmetric measure in [Gui]), integration with respect to which is conveniently denoted J . . . do. Now
f i , I:=
FQn@FJn), where FYI := L 2 ( r p ) ) ,
(3)
n20
with the convention Fo0 := M , may be viewed as a subspace of
and thereby inherits pre-Hilbert W*-bimodule structure from the interior tensor products:
.1cI . a2 := Ul$(
$9
:=
/- ($W>
$'(a))do. rr The product structure may be described in two ways, corresponding to the two views (3) and (4). Thus for cp E G,[o,a,[ and $ E PF,[,,,[, cp 0$ should be identified with the element of PF,[o,s+t[ defined by a1
0
*
)a2,
($3
++ cp( (a - t ) fLO, l4)@ $(a f l [O, tr),
where a - t := { s - t : s E a}. Or, in picture (3), for simple tensors x @ f E FonC&;![ and 71 €3 g E. FQm€3 F{$, the product element (x@ f ) 0( q @g) is identified with
(x@ 7)€a ( S t f @ 9 )
r[ti+,r
where St is the second quantised shift: (Stf)(a) = f(a- t ) for a E Notice that time is running to the left. (FF,[o,t[)t>ois a product system Letting FFJ be the completion of PF,I, of Hilbert W*-bimodules, all contained in the Hilbert W*-module FF := FF,w+.We call it the exponential system based o n F ; in [BhS] it is called
131
the time-ordered Fock module - to distinguish it from earlier experiments in module analogues of symmetric Fock space. The basic unit of this system the collection of all units of such a system which is ( d @ ( . ) lE~ Fp,[O,t[)t,O; are norm continuous (& maps JR++ FF)is indexed by M x F as follows. For each continuous unit w there is lc E M and q E F such that
where pt = etk ([LiS]), in clear generalisation of the situation with exponential systems of Hilbert spaces - see (2). By an E-semigroup on a von Neumann algebra ([Arz]) is meant a pointwise weak*-continuous semigroup of normal *-homomorphisms of the algebra (older terminology: eo-semigroup). If each map is also unital then it is called an Eo-semigroup. Following Skeide, who treated the unital (Eo) case ([Skz]), we next describe the product system of an E-semigroup 4 = ( $ t ) t > o on Ba(E) where E is a Hilbert W*-module having an M-normalised eLment:
which we fix. Set
Q = K ( ~ M I [)=( ) < I where
K
:M
: 77
e <(<,d,
+ Ba(E) is the embedding defined by
4.) := I<)a(tl = IEa)(
with a*
4t(Q)v. b := 4 t ( ~ ( a ) ) ~ b ,
defines Hilbert W*-bimodules (Et)t>O contained in E. These form a product system as follows. First, with < t h e fixed element ( 5 ) ,
x @ 4t(Qh * 4t(lX)(Jl)q
(6)
determines a one parameter family of bimodule M-isometric maps Bt : E 0Et + E . In view of the identity
4t ( I 4 s ( Q ) ~ ) ( < l ) q
= 4 s + t ( Q ) 4 t (I~)(
132
and the fact that Bt has range &(idE)E, each Bt restricts/corestricts to isomorphisms B,,t : E, 0 Et + Es+t and these identifications define a product system over E, with the associativity consistency conditions being covered by the identity
Bs+t 0 (idE OB,,t) = Bt 0 ( B , 0idEt). Moreover the E-semigroup is recovered via the identity
4 t ( X ) = B t ( x @ IEt)B;. We denote this product system by (Ef")t>o. Remark. To date there is no converse result to the effect that every product system of Hilbert W*-modules over a von Neumann algebra M is the product system of some E-semigroup 4 on the algebra of adjointable operators on some Hilbert W*-module with M-normalised element 6. Such a result would require the imposition of a measurability condition, as it does in the Hilbert space context ([Arl]). Under the assumption that d t ( I - Q ) 5 I - Q for t 2 0,
(7) the (pointwise weak*-continuous) family of completely positive contractions on M given by
Pt(a) = < 6 , 4 t ( w ) r , comprises a semigroup;
(tt := 4t (QK)t>Odefines a unit of the above product system; and the identity = (&,a *
tt)
holds. The E-semigroup 4 on B,(E) is thereby a dilation of the completely positive contraction semigroup P on M. The isomorphism class of the product system of Hilbert spaces associated with a n E-semigroup on B(H) is a complete invariant for such semigroups up t o cocycle conjugacy ([Arl]). For a Hilbert W*-module E over M, E-semigroups 4 and qS on Ba(E), are called cocycle conjugate if there - in B,(E) satisfying is a family (Wt)t>o
4 : ( q = Wt4t(T)W,'; WtW; = 4 i ( I ) and W:Wt = &(I); WS+t= WS4,(Wt);WO= I and t e Wt is SO-continuous.
(8)
133
Thus W is a strongly continous cocycle with respect to partial isometries in Ba(E) which intertwines 4 and 4’.
4 consisting of
Theorem 1.1. ([Skz]) Let E be a Hilbert W*-bimodule over a von Neum a n n algebra ( M ,I)) and suppose that E has a n M-nownalised element <.
Let
4 and 4‘ be E-semigroups o n Ba(E), with associated product systems
(E$’E)tLoand ( E f l E ) t ? orespectively.
(i) If 4 and 4’ are cocycle conjugate then their associated product systems are isomorphic. (ii) Conversely, if their product systems are isomorphic then the Esemigroups are cocycle conjugate modulo the continuity condition. For (i) (co-)restriction of each Wt gives the component isomorphisms. For (ii) set Wt = Bi(idE @At)&, in the notation (6), where At is the component isomorphism E?*€+ E f ’ E . 2. Quantum stochastic cocycles
By a quantum stochastic cocycie on a von Neumann algebra ( M ,I)) we shall mean a pointwise ultraweakly continuous family of completely bounded normal maps j t : M + M €3 B(&), for some Hilbert space k called the noise dimension space, satisfying .-
js+t
=3s
O
0s O jt
and jt(M)C M €3 B ( F k , [ O , t [ ) €3 I k , [ t , c o [ r
where ( a t ) t >-o is the CCR flow of index k, ampliated to M €3 B(Fk). Here, with Ran o, identified with M €3 B(Fk,[,,,[) and j , viewed as a map M + M €3 B(Fk,[,,W[), is the normal extension of j , to Rano,, so that
F,
RanTs
c M €3B ( F k , [ O , s [ )
€3 B(Fk,[s,w[) = M €3 B(Fk).
jF’rom the cocycle property it follows that Pt:=IEojt
and J t : = S o o t
(9)
form one-parameter semigroups of maps on M and M@B(Fk)respectively, where := 1~ €3 W k , Wk being the vector state given by the vector f l k := (1,0,0,. . .) in &. When j consists of *-homomorphisms J is an E-semigroup on M €3 El(&) = Ba(E) for E = M €3 I.&), which dilates P:
Pt = IE o Jt
o L,
134 L : M + M @ B(Fk) being ampliation. The cocycle is called regular when its associated Markov semigroup P is norm continuous. From the papers of Lindsay and Wills the regular *-homomorphic stochastic cocycles on M are completely characterised by their infinitesimal description.
Theorem 2.1. ([LWI-~])Let ( M ,fj) and k be respectively a won N e u m a n n algebra and separable Hilbert space.
+ B(z)@ M
satisfying
e(a*b) = e(a)*L(b) L(a)*e(b) e(a)*Ae(b),
(10)
If 8 is a linear ultraweakly continuous map M
+
+
where := C @ k, L i s ampliation M + B f i ) @ M and A is the orthogonal projection Pk @ I M , then the quantum stochastic differential equation djt = 50 8 d&;
j,(a) = u @ 1~~
(11)
where 5 = idB(Q €3 j t , has a unique weakly regular weak solution; the solution is strong and it forms a regular *-homomorphic quantum stochastic cocycle on M . Conversely, if j is a regular *-homomorphic quantum stochastic cocycle o n M , with noise dimension space k , then there is a unique linear completely bounded ultraweakly continuous map 8 : M + B(L)@ M such that j satisfies the quantum stochastic differential equation (11); moreower 8 satisfies (10). We refer t o j as the quantum stochastic cocycle generated by 8, and 8 as the stochastic generator of j.
Note. For this paper we are using an ordering convention for some of our tensor products which is different to the usual one - traditionally stochastic generators map M into M @ B f i ) . The present convention has the advantage of avoiding some of the tensor flips in the theory. Viewing B(L) @ M as a subspace of B(fj @ k @ fj), and writing 8 in corresponding block matrix form:
;[ ",I p
being ampliation M + B(k) @ M ) , T E B ( M ) is the generator of the Markov semigroup (Eo j t ) t > o , p : M + B(k)@ M is a *-homomorphism and S : M 3 Ik) @ M is a pderivation, with St defined by St(a) = S(a*)*. (Lk
135
In passing we mention that these stochastic dilations fit into the general picture described earlier, in the following sense. Lemma 2.2. The element [ = 1~ ‘8 I n k ) of the Hilbert W*-module E := M ‘8 I F k ) satisfies assumption (7) above, for the E-semigroup (Jt := 5 o fJt)t 2.0 : Jt(1-
Q) 5 I -Q
for Q = IE)(tI E Consider stochastic generators of the form
for a normal *-homomorphism p : M -+ B(k) €3 M . In case k = C it is well-known ([Hud]) that the stochastic cocycle generated by (13) has the simple form j t = pNt , in the sense that (jt(a)f)(fJ)= P#(‘”[o’tl)(4
(m),
for a E M and f E Ij @ F = L 2 ( r ;Ij). The cocycle continues to have a simple explicit form in the case of multidimensional k as the following result confirms. Proposition 2.3. Let j be the quantum stochastic cocycle o n M with generator (13). Then, under the identifications
b ‘8F
k
= @ (kBn €3
b)
‘8 F:;j[ ‘8 Fk,[t,m[,
n2.0
j is given by
.’?,(a)= @ pn(a) ‘8 I;;;[ €3 I k , [ t , o o [ n>O
where pn : M
+ B(kBn)€3 M
is defined by
with p ( i ) := idB(kB(i-1))@ p
2 1.
This proposition is key; its proof is a simple verification.
136 3. Product system of a stochastic cocycle
The strategy here is to view the stochastic cocycle as a perturbation (in the sense of [EvH] and [GLW]) of the stochastic cocycle generated by the number/exchange component of the cocycle generator, and thereby reduce the problem to pure number/exchange cocycles, by appealing to Theorem 1.l. In turn the explicit form of pure number/exchange cocycles given in the previous section leads us to the product system of such stochastic cocycles. Given a normal *-homomorphism p : M + B(k ) @ M , define a Hilbert W*-bimodule as follows:
Fk>j':= p ( l ) ( l k ) @ M) with a . p ( l ) q . b := p(a)qb, and standard M-valued inner product Now we need two Lemmas.
(t,q )
I+
(15)
("q.
Lemma 3.1. Let F = Fk,p, for a normal *-homomorphism p : M + B(k) @ M . In the notation (14) define Hilbert W*-bimodules FO := M and, for n 2 1,
Fn := p n ( 1 ) ( ( k @ n )@ M ) With u * pn(l)q . b := pn(a)qb. Then (a) The correspondence p n ( 1 ) (1x1 8.. . @ X n ) @ l M )
* p ( 1 ) ( 1 X 1 ) @ 1 M )0.. * @ p ( l )( I Z n ) @ l M )
extends to an M-unitary bimodule map Fn + Fan. (b) Under the resulting identifications, pn(1))(I.
x * Pn+m(l)(lX)@ pm(a)X)
Q a) 0
for x E kBn, a E M and
(16)
x E Fam = F,.
Lemma 3.2. Let k , p and (Fn)>o be as above. Then, with the identifications there, the product structure of the exponential product system for F = F k i pis determined by ( P n ( l ) ( l X ) @ a )@ f ) @ ( P m ( l ) ( I d@ b ) 8
9)
*
for x E kBn, y E kBm, a, b E M , f E F{$[ and g E F[$, where (St)t>o - is the semigroup of right shifts on F.
137
Using these we are able to identify the product systems of quantum stochastic E-semigroups. Proposition 3.3. Let j be a quantum stochastic cocycle on M with generator of the f o r m (13). Then the product system of its associated E-semigroup is (isomorphic t o ) the exponential system for the Halbert W*-bimodule F k @ .
Now consider a *-homomorphic stochastic cocycle j with general (bounded) generator (12). It follows from the Christensen-Evans Theorem ([ChE]) that there is d E Ik) @ M and h = h* E M such that .(a) = d * p ( ~ ) d h{d*d, U }
+ i[h,u ] , and
d(a) = da - p(a)d. Letting j o denote the quantum stochastic cocycle generated by [I p!Lk] i h - i d ' d d' and setting 1 = where p = p(l), the quantum stochastic -pd P~ differential equation
]
[
dWt = (Ic @ Wt)(idBci;,@ j f ) ( l ) d h t ; W O= I has a unique strong solution ([GLW]). Setting q5 = and q5' = J , where J o and J are the E-semigroups on B, ( M @ I&)) = M @ B(&) corresponding to j o and j respectively, it may be shown ([BLl]) that W satisfies (8). This establishes the following result. Proposition 3.4. Let J be the E-semigroup associated with a *homomorphic stochastic cocycle o n M with bounded ultraweakly continuous generator 9 = p-Lk . Then J is cocycle conjugate to the E-semigroup
[.
1
associated with the stochastic cocycle with generator
[I
In view of Theorem 1.1 these two propositions entail the following theorem. Theorem 3.5. The product system of a regular normal *-homomorphic quantum stochastic cocycle on a uon Neumann algebra is exponential. SpecificaEly, i f the cocycle generator is ;;p6_tLk] then the product system
[
is (-TF,[o,~[)~~o where F = Fk%p. 4. Irreducible quantum stochastic dilations
Let P = (Pt)t>o - be a Markov semigroup on M . A *-homomorphic quantum stochastic cocycle j on M , with noise dimension space k, is a dilation of P
138
if its Markov semigroup is P , that is lE& 0 j t = Pt, where & := idM @Uk. If P is norm continuous with generator T then j has bounded generator of the form [i In fact every norm continuous P has such a quantum stochastic dilation ([GoS]), but typically the dilation is not (and cannot be) the minimal dilation of P ([BL2]). This motivates the following definition. A quantum stochastic dilation j of a Markov semigroup P is irreducible when there is no other quantum stochastic dilation j' which is dominated by j in the sense that the corresponding E-semigroups satisfy (Jt - Ji) is
completely positive for all t 2 0.
Then the following results may be proved.
Theorem 4.1. Let P be a n o r m continuous Markov semigroup o n M . Each of its quantum stochastic dilations j dominates an irreducible quantum stochastic dilation. Specifically, i f [i is the stochastic generator of j then there is a projection q E B(k) 8 M such that the stochastic cocyop(p;-ck is t-homomorphic, is dominated by j, and is cle generated by irreducible.
LtLk 1
[
1
For the second result we assume unitality of the Markov semigroup.
Theorem 4.2. Let j be a n irreducible quantum stochastic dilation of a Markov semigroup P o n M . If P is norm continuous and unital then the product system of j coincides with that of the minimal dilation of P . The generic nonminimality of quantum stochastic dilations appears to us t o be a defect of quantum stochastic calculus in its current form. This might be rectified by refounding the calculus on more general Hilbert W*(and C*-)bimodules than the cut-down standard modules p(lM) (I k) @ M ). We view this as a fruitful direction for future research.
Acknowledgements We are grateful to Michael Skeide and to Adam Skalski for their comments on a preliminary draft. BVRB was supported by a fellowship under the Exchange Agreement between the Indian National Science Academy and the Royal Society of London, and by Visiting Fellowship GR/S57099/01 from the U.K. Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council. The EU Research and Training Network Quantum Probability with Applications to Physics, Information Theory and Biology has faciliated useful discussions with fellow researchers.
139 References [Arl]. W. Arveson, Continuous analogues of Fock space, Mem. Amer. Math. SOC. 80 (1989)no.409.
[Arz]. W. Arveson, “Noncommutative Dynamics and E-semigroups,” Springer Monographs in Mathematics, Springer, New York 2003. [Bl]. B.V. Rajarama Bhat, Cocycles of CCR flows. Mem. Amer. Math. SOC.149 (ZOOl), no. 709. [Bz]. B.V. Rajarama Bhat, Product systems of one-dimensional Evans-Hudson flows, in “Quantum Probability Communications X” (eds. R.L. Hudson and J.M. Lindsay) World Scientific, Singapore 1998,pp. 187-194. [BLl]. B.V. Rajarama Bhat and J.M. Lindsay, The product system of a stochastic E-semigroup, in preparation. [BLz]. B.V. Rajarama Bhat and J.M. Lindsay, Irreducibility for quantum stochastic dilations, in preparation. [BhS]. B.V.Rajarama Bhat and M.Skeide, Tensor product systems of Hilbert modules and dilations of completely positive semigroups, Infin. Dimens. Anal. Quantum Probab. Relat. Top 3 (2000)no. 4,519-575. [Ble]. D.P.Blecher, A new approach to Hilbert C*-modules, Math.Ann. 97 (1997),pp. 253-290. [ChE]. E. Christensen and D.E. Evans, Cohomology of operator algebras and quantum dynamical semigroups, J. London Math. SOC.20 (1979) no. 2,
358-368. [EvH]. M.P. Evans and R.L. Hudson, Perturbations of quantum diffusions, J. London Math. SOC.41 (1990)no. 2,373-384. [GLW]. D. Goswami, J.M. Lindsay and S.J. Wills, A stochastic Stinespring theorem, Math. Ann. 319 (2001)no. 4,647-673. [GoS]. D. Goswami and K.B. Sinha, Hilbert modules and stochastic dilation of a quantum dynamical semigroup on a von Neumann algebra, Comm. Math. Phys. 205 (1999)no. 2,377-405. [Gui]. A. Guichardet, “Symmetric Hilbert Spaces and Related Topics,” Lecture Notes in Mathematics 267,Springer, Heidelberg 1970. [Hud]. R.L. Hudson, Quantum diffusions on the algebra of all bounded operators on a Hilbert space, in “Quantum Probability and Applications IV” , (eds. L. Accardi and W. von Waldenfels), Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1396, Springer, Heidelberg 1989,pp. 256-269. [Lan]. E.C. Lance, “Hilbert C*-modules, A toolkit for operator algebraists,” London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series 210,Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1995. [LiS]. V. Liebscher and M. Skeide, Units for the time-ordered Fock module, Infin. Dimens. Anal. Quantum Probab. Relat. Top. 4 (2001)no. 4,545-551. J.M. Lindsay, Quantum stochastic analysis, in “Lectures in the Spring [L]. School on Quantum Independent Increment Processes,” Lecture Notes in Mathematics, Springer, Heidelberg (to appear). [LWl]. J.M. Lindsay and S.J. Wills, Existence, positivity, and contractivity for quantum stochastic flows with infinite dimensional noise, Probab. Theory
140
Related Fields 116 (2000) no. 4, 505-543. [LWz]. J.M. Lindsay and S.J. Wills, Markovian cocycles on operator algebras, adapted to a Fock filtration, J. Funct. Anal. 178 (2000) no. 2, 269-305. (LWs]. J.M. Lindsay and S.J. Wills, Existence of Feller cocycles on a C*-algebra, Bull. London Math. SOC.33 (2001) no. 5, 613-621. [LW4]. J.M. Lindsay and S.J. Wills, Homomorphic Feller cocycles on a C*algebra, J. London Math. SOC.(2) 68 (2003) no. 1, 255-272. [Mey]. P.-A. Meyer, “Quantum Probability for Probabilists,” 2nd Edition, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1538,Springer, Heidelberg 1993. [Par]. K.R. Parthasarathy, “An Introduction to Quantum Stochastic Calculus,” Monographs in Mathematics 85,Birkhauser Verlag, Basel 1992. [Ski]. M.S. Skeide, “Hilhert Modules and Applications in Quantum Probability,” Habilitation Thesis, Cotthus, Germany 2001. [Skz]. M.S. Skeide, Dilations, products systems and weak dilations, Math. Notes 71 (2002) 914-923.
EVOLUTION OF THE ATOM-FIELD SYSTEM IN INTERACTING FOCK SPACE
P.K.DAS Physics and Applied Mathematics Unit Indian Statistical Institute 203,B.T.Road, Kolkata- 700f08, Indaa e-mai1:daspkOisical. ac.in Here we discuss interaction of a single two-level atom with a single mode of interacting electromagnetic field in the Jaynes-Cummings model with the rotating wave approximation.
1. Introduction
Light is absorbed and radiated by atoms and one of the most fundamental problems in quantum optics is the interaction between the quantized electromagnetic field and an atom. But the real atoms being complicated systems it is often desirable to approximate the behaviour of a real atom by that of a much simpler quantum system. Sometimes only two atomic energy levels play a significant role in the interaction with the electromagnetic field and in many theoretical treatments it has become customary to represent the atom by a quantum system with only two energy eigenstates. Jaynes and Cummings considered a system consisting of a nonrelativistic two-level atom coupled to a single quantized mode of the electromagnetic radiation field under the dipole and rotating wave approximation. This simple model in quantum - optics is one of the few exactly solvable quantum mechanical models describing the interaction of matter with an electromagnetic field. The wave length of the field mode is assumed to be so long, compared with the atomic dimension that the dipole approximation can be made. Originally, Jaynes and Cummings wanted to study the QED predictions for an ammonia maser. But they failed to find an exact solution for this application with the help of simplifying assumptions described above. They had to make the additional approximation by removing transitions that correspond to processes which do not conserve energy. This approximation is called
141
142
the rotating wave approximation. In the rotating - wave approximation this model can be solved exactly. Exact solutions describing the dynamical behaviour of expectation values of variables such as the population inversion, the atomic dipole - correlation function and the mean photon number can be obtained in this case in the form of an infinite series. Starting with a cavity field in a coherent state and with the atom in its upper state it was found that repeated decays and revivals of the Rabi oscillations occur and that for certain times the field mode shows squeezing. The predicted collapses and revivals of the inversion oscillations are in agreement with the experiments done with Rydberg atoms in a microwave cavity. In recent years there have been several generalizations of the Jaynes - Cummings Hamiltonian in which the interaction between the atom and the radiation field is no longer linear in the field variables and are only particular cases of JCM in which the creation and annihilation operators of radiation field are replaced by deformed harmonic oscillator operators with the given commutation relations. Since the JCM is one of the basic models in quantum optics, its extensions in different directions are generally very interesting [6].In this paper, we study JCM in which field variables are taken as the actions on an interacting Hilbert space with the specified commutation relation. The work is organized as follows. In section 2, we have given definitions and preliminaries that will be used throughout the paper. In section 3, we discussed the interaction of a single two-level atom with a single mode of interacting field. In section 4, we described the evolution of the atominteracting field system by probability amplitude method. In section 5 , we gave a conclusion. 2. Definitions and Preliminaries
As a vector space one mode interacting Fock space I?(@) is defined by 00
r(@) = @@in >
(1)
n=O
for any n E N where @In> is called the n-particle subspace. The different n-particle subspaces are orthogonal, that is, the sum in (1) is orthogonal. Thenorm of the vector In > is given by
< nln >= An
(2)
{An} 2 0 and if for some n we have (A,} = 0, then A{}, = 0 for all m 2 n. The norm introduced in (2) makes r(@) a Hilbert space. where
143
An arbitrary vector f in r(C) is given by
f
= COlO > +Clll
> +c212 > +... +c,ln > +.. . llfll = (C,"==, < 00.
(3)
for any n with We now consider the following actions on r(C) :
A* is called the creation operator and its adjoint A is called the annihilation operator. To define the annihilation operator we have taken the convention o/o = 0. We observe that An < nln >=< A*(n- l ) ,n >=< (n - l ) ,An >= < n - 1,n - 1 >= . . . A,--1
(5)
and
By (2) we observe from (6) that A. = 1. The commutation relation takes the form AN+1
AN
AN
AN-1
[A,A*]= -- where N is the number operator defined by Nln >= n(n >. In a recent paper [l]we have proved that the set { n = 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , . . .} forms a complete orthonormal set and the solution of the following eigenvalue equation
$$,
Afa = Qfa is given by (9)
T.
= Cr?o where $J(laI2) Now, we observe that
We call
fa
a coherent vector in r(C).
AN+1 AN AA* = , A*A = AN
We further observe that AA*.
(e
- &)
AN-1
commutes with both A*A and
144
3. Interaction of a single two-level atom with a single mode field
The interaction of a interacting single-mode quantized field of frequency Y with a single two level atom is described by the Hamiltonian in the dipole approximation
H = HF
+ H A + gHI
(10)
+
+
where H F = hvA*A and H A = ;twoz with HI = h(a+ a - ) ( A A * ) . Here A , A* are the interacting annihilation and creation operators for the photons at frequency v. The two - level atom is described by the usual spin - operators and the inversion operator az with w as atomic transition frequency. Also g is the coupling constant. The interaction energy HI consists of four terms. We drop the energy nonconserving terms corresponding to the rotating - wave approximation and obtain the simplified Hamiltonian as
H = hvA*A
+ -21h a , + hg(a+A + A*u-).
(11)
At this stage , for simplicity, we take h = 1 and consider the exact resonance case v = w . The resulting simplified Hamiltonian is 1 2
H = v(A*A+ -az) + g(a+A + A*o-).
(12)
H = Ho + H i
(13)
We write
where 1 2
(14)
+ A*o-)
(15)
Ho = Y ( A * A+ - a z ) and Hi = g(a+A
The Hamiltonian, given by equations (13), (14) and (15) describes the atominteracting field interaction in the dipole and rotating-wave approximation. It is convenient t o work in the interaction picture. The Hamiltonian, in the interaction picture, is given by
v = ,iHotHle-iHot
(16)
145
Then
v = ei[vA*A+1/2vuz]t~le-i[vA*A+1/2vur]t
- eivA'At~ei/2vuzt~le-i~A*At~e-i/2vuzt - eivA'At.ei/2vu,tg(a+A + ~ * ~ _ ) ~ - i v A ' A t . ~ - i / 2 v u = t = ge ivA'
At .ei/2vu,ta+Ae-ivA'
+geivA' At .ei/2vu,
- gei/2uuzta+e -i/2vuZt +geivA'AtA*e-ivA'At
Using
we get
At.e-i/2vu,t
tA*O-e-ivA'
At .e-i/2vuz t
eivA'AtAe-ivA'At .ei/2vaz ta-e-i/2vo,
t
(17)
146
ei/2vazto +e-i/2vazt = o+ + i / 2 v t [ o z , o + ] + ~ [ o z , [ o z , o + +... ll = Is+ i / 2 v t ( 2 a + ) -220+ .. . = o+ ivto+ @ g o + . ..
+
+ +
+
+ + = o+[l+ivt+ (zvt)2 2! +...I =o + p
(22)
From (17) we get
v = S[o+eivt e-iv( hx-N + ) t
N--l
A +A*eiv(e-*)to-e-ivt
I
(23)
4. Evolution of the atom-field system
In this section, we present probability amplitude method to solve the evolution of the atom-field system described by the Hamiltonian (23). The Pauli spin operators are:
We may define the following operators: 0-
= 1/2(o,
+ io,)
(::)
and
The o- operator takes an atom in the upper state into the lower state whereas o+ takes an atom in the lower state into the upper state. We begin with the following spin matrices:
o-=
(;;),
(;;),
ff+=
uz=
(
-1 0 l).
They satisfy the following commutation relations: [o+,Is-]=
oz, [o,,o+]= 2o+,
[Isz,o-]
= -%-.
Then we proceed to solve the equation of motion for 111, >, that is,
-i
at
’
= Vl11,>
(25)
147
At any time t , the state vector I+(t)> is a linear combination of the states la, > and Ib, >. Here la, > is the state in which the atom is in photons. A similar description the excited state la > and the field has is given for the state Ib, >. As we are using the interaction picture, , C~b , n . The state we use the slowly varying probability amplitudes c ~and vector is therefore
e
-&
-&
-&
k
Now,
and
Now we observe the following facts:
a+la > = la
>< bla > = 0
o+p > = la >< b[b> = la > a-la
a-lb We see the followings:
> = Ib >< ala > = Ib > > = Ib >< alb > = 0
148
From equations (29), (31), (32), (33) and (34) we observe that
Now comparing equations (26), (28) and (35) we get
149
From (36) we get
Or
Or
with
for
Now we assume a trial solution to get
or
S2 - A S - g2(-)An+l = 0 An whose solutions are
S= In (42) we take
fli
Af
4 A 2 + 4g2( h) An
(42)
2
A2 + 4g2(*)
i A+n t ( 2")
and write the solution as
i A-nn)t ( 2
ca,n(t) = A l e +A2e =A l e F . e W + A
~
~
F
.
~
~
= [ A l e w + Aze--i"]e% -in
t
+ i sin y}+ Az{cos y - i sin ?}ley = [(Ai+ A2) cos y + i(A1 - A2) sin
(43)
= [Al(cos
To find the constants
A1
and A2 we observe that Ca,n(O)
= A1
+ A2
(44)
150
Also we see that
Hence we see that
-ig/?Cb,n+l(O)
= A1 .i/2(A
+ 0,) + A2.i/2(A - Rn)
(46)
On solving (44) and (46) for A1 and A2 we find that
(47) and
(48) and
Subsstituting the values of
and
from above in (43) we find
finally
In a similar manner we find the value of ~ b , ~ + l (tot ) be
151
If initially the atom is in the excited state la > then c ~ , ~ ( O=) cn(0) and = 0. Here cn(0) is the probability amplitude for the field alone. We then obtain qn+1(O)
-
ca,n(t) = cn(o)[cos(?)
sin(F)]ey
(52)
or
Equations (52) and (54) give us all the relevent informations relating to the quantized interacting field and the atom. I ~ . , ~ ( tand ) l ~ I ~ b , ~ ( t are ) l ~ the probabilities that, at time t , the interacting field has n photons present and the atom is in levels la > and Ib > respectively. To obtain the probability p(n)that there are n photons in the interacting field at time t we take the trace over the atomic states: P(n) =IC~,~(+ ~ )I I C ~ ~ , ~ ( ~ ) I ~ 2 n t = I~n(0)l2[COS + (&I2 sin2(*)nI +Icn-1(0)l2
4g2(&)
a:_,
t
2 %-It
sin (7)
(55) The inversion W ( t )is given by
152
5. Conclusion
In conclusion, we have studied the atom-interacting field evolution in the dipole and rotating wave approximation by probability amplitude method and for simplicity we considered only resonance case. References
1. P. K. Das, Coherent states and squeezed states in interacting Fock space, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, vol 41, no. 06, (2002), MR. No. 2003e: 81091 (2003). 2. P. k. Das, Quasiprobability distribution and phase distribution in interacting Fock space, International Journal of Theoretical Physics, vol 41, no. 10, (2002), MR. NO. 2003j: 81098 (2003). 3. J. S. Peng and G. X. Li, Phase fluctuations in the Jaynes-Cummings model with and without the rotating wave approximation, Phys. Rev. A, vol. 45, no. 5, (1992), 3289 - 3293. 4. M. 0. Scully and M. S. Zubairy, Quantum Optics, Cambridge University Press,(1997). 5. Yariv, Amnon. Quantum Electronic, John Wiley and Sons,Inc. NY.(1967) 6. Crnugelj, J., Martinis, M., Mikuta-Martinis, V., Properties of a deformed Jaynes- Cummings model. Phys. Rev. A, vol. 50, no. 2, (1994), 1785-1791.
QUANTUM MECHANICS ON THE CIRCLE THROUGH HOPF Q-DEFORMATIONS OF THE KINEMATICAL ALGEBRA WITH POSSIBLE APPLICATIONS TO LEVY PROCESSES
V.K. DOBREV1t2, H.-D. DOEBNER3, R. TWAROCK4 School of Informatics, University of Northumbria, Newcastle-upon-Tyne N E l 8ST, UK, vladimir. dobrev0unn. ac.uk, Permanent address: Institute of Nuclear Research and Nuclear Energy, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 7.2 Tsarigradsko Chaussee, 1784 Sofia, Bulgaria, dobrev0inrne.bas.bg Department of Physics, Metallurgy and Material Science, Technical University Clausthal 38678 Clausthal-Zellerfeld, Germany
[email protected] Centre f o r Mathematical Science, City University Northampton Square, London EC1 V OHB, UK r.twarockQcity.ac. uk A formulation of quantum mechanics on S' or its N-point discretisation Sh based on different types of q-deformations of subalgebras of the kinematical algebra of the system was discussed ( [l])in the framework of Bore1 quantisation. We review this method and introduce new Hopf q-deformations of the full kinematical algebra, i.e. q-deformations of both the subalgebras of position and of momentum observable. The implications of this deformed approach to the dynamics and the resulting evolution equations is assessed and compared with previous results including the non-deformed case. The presented algebraic method for q-deformations can be translated to LBvy processes on algebraic structures and the related evolutions; possible applications are outlined.
Key words: Hopf q-deformation, kinematical algebra, quantum dynamics,
153
154
Ldvy processes 1. Introduction
The quest for a discrete quantum mechanical theory is of interest both for conceptual and computational reasons, and different arguments in support of this have been discussed in [l]. There are various possibilities to construct discrete analogs to quantum mechanics, which rely on different guiding principles for the replacement of differential operators by suitable difference operators. The method adopted in [l]is of an algebraic nature, and is based on the kinematical algebra that represents position and momentum observables in the framework of Bore1 quantisation [2]. Via a q-deformation of this algebra, expressions of the quantum mechanical position and momentum operators are obtained in terms of q-difference rather than differential operators, i.e. expressions of the form
where e.g. f E C(R). Furthermore, the quantum dynamics based on these operators and a suitable generalisation of the first Ehrenfest theorem is given in terms of qdifference operators and corresponds to a discrete, nonlinear q-Schrodinger equation. The algebraic guiding principle based on q-deformations of the kinematical algebra leads to different discrete quantum mechanical theories for different choices of q-deformations. While a q-deformation of the subalgebra related to the momentum observable is necessary in order to obtain a quantum mechanical theory in terms of difference operators, a deformation of the subalgebra related to the position observable is not necessary for this purpose, which is minimal in the sense that it involves only a deformation of the subalgebra related to the momentum observable [3]. Therefore, initial attempts to construct a discrete quantum mechanical theory based on a q-deformation of the kinematical algebra have focused on a q-deformation of the kinematical algebra. However, from an algebraic point of view, this does not use the full potential of the algebraic guiding principle for the construction of a discrete quantum mechanical theory, and different options for this have been discussed in [l].Among these, an approach based on a Hopf q-deformation of the full kinematical algebra (see also [4])plays a distinguished role. It is the aim of this contribution to consider this case in further detail and to
155
compare the resulting quantum mechanical theory with the results in the minimal approach. We will show that the approach based on a Hopf q-deformation of the full kinematical algebra has interesting implications in the continuous limit. In particular, we discuss the quantum dynamics, which is given as a family of nonlinear q-Schrodinger equations, in greater detail and compare it with the family of Doebner-Goldin type nonlinear Schrodinger equations [5-81 that arise in the continous approach. The interesting feature of the ansatz based on a q-deformation of the full kinematical algebra is that both real part and imaginary part of the nonlinear Schrodinger equation are completely determined. This is in contrast to the situation in the undeformed case, where only the imaginary part of the nonlinearity follows from the Borel quantisation formalism, and the real part is inferred by some additional plausibility arguments related to the shape of the imaginary part of the nonlinearity [9].We show that in the continuous limit of our approach based on a q-deformation of the full kinematical algebra one obtains a nonlinear Schrodinger equation, in which the imaginary part of the nonlinearity coincides with the one in the Doebner-Goldin formalism and the real part falls in one of their proposed classes. In this way, this study may be understood also as a justification for the Doebner-Goldin models. Finally, we outline possible applications of these results to LBvy processes. Their investigation on noncommutative algebraic structures (Lie groups, quantum groups, bialgebras,. ..) is often intricate and involves representation theory, c.f., e.g., [lo-171. In this approach L6vy processes are characterized by their generators. Classifying such generators originating in our algebraic framework would be one of the main challenges. Another reason for the study of L6vy processes on algebraic structures is their relation t o evolution equations, c.f., e.g., [13-151. The paper is organised as follows. After a review of Borel quantisation in section 2, we discuss the Hopf q-deformation of the kinematical algebra and its implications on the quantum kinematics in section 3. In section 4 a corresponding quantum dynamics is derived and compared with the dynamics obtained via the minimal ansatz in [l].In section 5 we outline the possible applications to L6vy processes.
2. Short review of Borel quantisation with application to
S1
We consider (non relativistic, point-like) systems S moving and localized on a smooth manifold M (with measure p ) and specialize later to S1. The
156 exposition follows [l]. 2.1. The kinematics
To model possible localization regions of S on M and possible infinitesimal movements of the regions we choose for the regions Borel sets B from a Borel field B ( M ) and for the movements (smooth, complete) vector fields X E Vecto(M). These two geometrical objects are the building blocks of the kinematics K ( M ) of S:
-
I v
K ( M ) = (f?(M),Vecto(M)).
-
(2)
Borel sets are displaced through X by its flow @: as B' = {m'lm' = aT%),m E B , X E Vecto(M),7 E [0,1)}. For a quantisation of K ( M ) one has to construct a map Q = (Q, P) which maps the blocks in K ( M ) into the set SA(7-l)of self-adjoint operators on a Hilbert space 3t. It is reasonable to interpret the matrix elements of Q ( B ) ,i.e. ($,Q(B)$),$ E 3-1, as the probability t o find the system localized in B in a state $. The properties of B ( M ) and further physical requirements (e.g. no internal degrees of freedom) show that Q ( B )acts on 3-1 as the characteristic function x ( M ) of M , if 3t is realized via square integrable functions over M , i.e. as L 2 ( M ,d p ) . From the spectral theorem and from Q ( B ( M ) )we infer a quantisation map for C" ( M ,IR)
Q : C"(M,R)
-+ SA('W,
Q(fM = f$-
(3)
Hence we can use in the kinematics C"(M,IR) instead of B ( M ) , that is the kinematics can be viewed as an infinite dimensional Lie algebra, more precisely as a semidirect sum of the abelian algebra C" ( M ,IR) and a subalgebra of the Lie algebra of vector fields, and we denote it as K ( M ) (without tilde) in the following:
K ( M ) = C"" ( M ,R)EVecto ( M ).
(4)
To construct the quantisation map P for Vecto(M) we need further assumptions, which we will call P-assumptions following [l]: 0
0
The partial Lie structure (in connection with complete vector fields) of K ( M ) is conserved. The operator P ( X ) are - in analogy to the canonical quantisation in Rn - local differential operators.
157
With these P-assumptions we have the following result [2]: The P(X)are differential operators of order one with respect to a differential structure on the set M x C. We characterize this assumption (up to isomorphism) through Hermitian line bundles L over M with compatible flat connection V. Wave functions are sections ~ ( min )the bundle and L2( M ,p ) can be viewed as a space of square integrable sections. Unitary equivalent irreducible maps Q(..*”) - quantisations - are given by a bijective mapping onto the set
( a , D ) E 7 q M ) x R.
(5)
$ ( M ) denotes the dual of the first fundamental group of M , a topological quantity. D is connected with the algebraic structure of K ( M ) and characteristic for Bore1 quantisation. (a,D) are quantum numbers in the sense of Wigner. Q is labeled by these numbers, i.e. = (Q(a*D),P(criD)) and one has (m E M ) Q(a3D)
Q(”>”)(fb(m)= f(m)~(m)
+
P(*’”)(X)o(m)= (40% (-ii
(6)
+ D )div,g)
o(m),
(7)
which are self-adjoint operators on a common dense set. Here, V% denotes the connection in the line bundle L ( M ) over M and div, denotes divergence. Note that the quantum number D appears as a real factor in front of div,g and that the nontrivial topology yields the a dependence of ‘7%. 2.2. The dynamics
States of S are modeled via density matrices W , i.e. through trace class operators with Tr(W) = 1. We introduce a time dependence for W (in the Schrcdinger picture), which is based on Q(..*”), through a quantum anaof time dependent log to the classical relation between time derivatives functions f ( m ( t ) )and momenta, i.e. for M = R’
6
d
-f(z(t)) dt
-
PVf .
(8)
One can show [6] that (in the Schrijdinger picture) one has the following relation for expectation values (Exp,(A) = T r ( W A ) ) :
d -Tr(W(t)Q(*’”’(f)) = Tr(W(t)P(”’D) (Xgradf)) ,Vf E Cm(M,R) (9) dt
158
This is a restriction for the evolution of W ( t ) . For pure states it implies, under the condition that pure states evolve into pure states [6], the following generalized version of the first Ehrenfest relation
.
.
with a scalar product (., .) in L2( M ,dp). 2.3. The kinematical algebra K(S1) and a family of evolution equations
We consider now an application of Bore1 quantization to the case that the configuration space is S1. S1 is topologically nontrivial with n;(S1) = [0,27r), and we denote elements in 7r;(S1) as a. The flat line bundles over S1 are trivial, the vector fields are X = X(I$)-& E Vecto(S1) and the Hilbert space is L2(S1,dq). In these coordinates K(S1) is given by the generators
Q(UID)(f)$(I$)
= f(dM4)
P'"'D)(X)$(I$)= (-iX(I$)-&
(11)
+ (+
(y) +ax($)) $(I$X12)
+D)
To analyse the structure of K(S1) we use a Fourier transform F with z = &4: m
n=-w
fn
= f-n, X n = X - n . For the F-transformed quantum kinematics we find w
With the operators
Tn = zn
159
(14) can be expressed as
n=-w
c x, 00
P(*ID)(X)=
(LE
+ iDnT,)
(16)
.
,=-w
The generators T, are an Abelian Lie algebra which we denote as T,and for fixed cr E [0,27r) the L, LE fulfill the commutation relations
=
[Tm,T,I = 0
(17)
[L,, Tm] = mTm+n [Lm,Ln3 = ( n - m)Lm+n
and span an inhomogenisation of the Witt algebra W through T . This [18], where we use the index z to gives the algebraic structure of Kz(S1) indicate that it is given in terms of the variable z as opposed to the angle variable 4. We have from (17) (we have dropped the upper index ( a , D ) for convenience)
[Q(f),Q(g)1 = 0,
[P(X), P ( Y ) l = -.1’P([X,YI). Now we introduce the time dependence for pure states $($) E L2(S1,d4) [P(X),Q ( f ) l = -iQ(Xf),
and we evaluate the restriction (10) with
xgradf
= f’(4)”
d4
(I
G A): d4
This implies a generalized continuity equation of Fokker-Planck type for p = $$:
i
p = &j$” - $5))+ Dp” - crp’ = --(jt)’ + Dp”, d
(19)
where
corresponds for vanishing cr to the usual quantum mechanical current density on S1. This can be derived also by other methods based on Q(a*D)[5], [19],[9]. We use this information in (19) for a general ansatz for a Schrodinger equation of the type
i&$
= H$
+ G[$,$I$
160
in which H is a linear operator and G[$,$] can be written (formally) as a nonlinear complex function G[$,$] = GI[$,$] iG2[$,$] depending on $,$, their derivatives and explicitly on 4 and t . Hence G acts as a multiplication operator. This Ansatz leads to a family Fp of Schrbdinger d4) with G2 enforced by (19) equations [3], on L2(S1,
+
The real part G1 cannot be determined by Borel quantization. Hence a set of (natural) assumptions for G1 motivated by the form of the imaginary part Gz,has been introduced [5], [9]: (1) G1 is proportional to D , i. e. vanishing for D = 0. (2) G1 is a rational function with derivatives no higher than second order and occurring in the numerator only. (3) G1 is complex homogeneous of order zero, i. e. Gl[a!$,&$] = GI [$,$1 for all a! E C. These assumptions restrict G1 in the family Fp to the Doebner-Goldin family (DG-family) 3 D G [5] on S':
with free real parameters Dk, k = 1 , . . . ,5.
3. A discrete quantum kinematics based on a Hopf q-deformation of the kinematical algebra In [l]various q-deformations of the kinematical algebra in Borel quantisation have been discussed. As mentioned earlier, our focus in this contribution is on that version among these (see also [20,21]) which involves a q-deformation of the full kinematical algebra and hence exploits the maximal freedom. Since the corresponding operators are difference operators, it is possible to restrict the configuration space to an N-point discretisation of S1,i.e.
161
3.1. A Hopf q-deformation of the kinematical algebra
We discuss q-deformations of the subalgebras of the kinematical algebra related to the position and the momentum observable separately, and then consider the coupling between these two algebras in a next step. The q-deformation leads to a Hopf algebra, and is therefore called a Hopf qdeformation. 3.1.1. The position observables In the undeformed setting, the subalgebra of the kinematical algebra that corresponds to the position observables in the framework of Bore1 quantisation is given by the generators {T,} in (17). In the q-deformed setting, we augment this basis to {Tn,K,"},where the Abelian subalgebra K := {K,"} with s E Z corresponds to q-shift operators, i.e. operators that act by rescaling the arguments of a function f(x) according to
where x,q E S1.They have the property:
[K,",K;,] = 0,
(24)
with limq+l K," = 1. Moreover, the coupling to the generators {T,} is given by
K:T, = qsnTnK,Q
(25)
The q-analog to the generators T, is given via a restriction of the universal enveloping algebra of the algebra generated by the basis {T,, K,"}to monomials of the form T2,5:= T,K,". The generators in the q-deformed setting are hence related to the undeformed generators via the mapping MZ, which restricted to the subalgebra related to the position observables acts as follows:
The generators T& form a non-commutative algebra with the following commutation relations:
162
3.1.2. T h e m o m e n t u m observables The subalgebra of the kinematical algebra related t o the momentum observables is given by the Witt algebra with basis {L,} and commutation relations as in (17). We consider here a q-deformation, where the q-Witt algebra is generated by the basis {C&} with the following commutation relations:
As expected for consistency, these commutation relations reproduce the commutation relations of the Witt algebra in the continuous limit q + 1. The extra parameter j , which has been introduced during the deformation, vanishes in the limit q + 1. The generators in the q-deformed setting are hence related to the undeformed generators via an extension of the mapping M i to the subalgebra related to the momentum observables M i :
M:,i : Lz
Cz,i, (29) where n,j E Z and a E [0, 1). We hence have a mapping Mq = { M i ,MB,j} that acts on the full kinematical algebra. H
3.1.3. Coupling between the subalgebras: the Hopf q-deformation of the kinematical algebra As a first step, we consider the coupling between the q-Witt algebra in (24) and the algebra of shift operators in (28). One obtains a quadratic Lie algebra with basis {Cz,,, K & } ,with
K,QCZli = q""C"n93.Kf
(30)
It is a noncommutative and co-commutative Hopf algebra - Hopf-q-Witt algebra - 3tWq with coproduct A, counit c and antipode y given as follows:
A ( C g , j )= Cg,j 8 K&
+ K& 8 L$,j , A(KZ)= KZ 8 KZ
E ( C ; , ~ )= 0 , e(KZ) = 1 y(Ck,j) = -(K&)-'Ck,j(K&)-' , y(K;) = (KZ)-'
(31)
Further, we should couple the position observables {T,} . The latter have trivial co-algenra structure: A(T,) = T, 8 1 1 8 T, , e(Tn) = 0, y(T,) = -T, . Thus, one obtains the inhomogeneous Hopf-q-Witt algebra
+
163
with basis { L z , k K , L , Tz,,} and co-algebra relations of Tz,, : A(Tz,,)= T$,,@Kj+Kj@Tz,,, €(Ti,,)= 0, ~ ( 7 2 = , ~- ()K j ) - " T & ( K j ) - ' . The q-deformed kinematical algebra is then given in terms of the basis { L z , k , via a restriction of the monomials in the universal enveloping algebra of { K k ,T,} to {Tz,,},and the commutation relations are as follows:
x}
, is quadratic. Hence the deformed algebra with basis { L z , k Tz,,} We note that a restriction to {L&,Tm} would lead to the results discussed in [l],and it is the purpose of this contribution to discuss the changes in the quantum kinematics and quantum dynamics implied by the occurrence of the shift operators K L in the subalgebra related to the position observable. 3 . 2 . The quantum kinematics on S1
In this subsection we discuss possibilities to associate position and momentum operators to the q-deformed kinematical algebra in the previous subsection. Since on S1the position operators Q ( " > D ) (inf )(16) depend on the generators Tn and the momentum operators P("vD)(X)in (16) depend on the generators Tn and LE,j, a q-deformation of the quantum kinematics can be achieved based on the mapping M Q in (26) and (as),because it relates the basis of the kinematical algebra in the undeformed setting with the basis of the q-deformed kinematical algebra. In particular, M8,j induces the following mapping M b K from the undeformed quantum kinematics in (16) to the Hopf q-quantum kinematics induced by the q-deformation of the kinematical algebra.
M ~ : KQ ( f ) ++ 0;C.f)= C:='=_, fnM:(Tn) P ( X ) ++ P i ( X ) = Cz='=_, Xn (M:,j(LE) i w D M p ( T n ) ) .
+
(33)
{ M $ K ( Q ( f ) )M, b K ( P ( X ) ) }will be called the Hopf q-quantum Borel kinematics induced by Mq = { M : , M:,j}. Indeed, the mapping M $ K depends on two further parameters, j , s E Z, and expressions for the position and momentum operators in the Hopf q-quantum Borel kinematics are given by
164
where K,, respectively K,, is short-hand notation for the shift operators K,“ and K;. For each different choice of the deformation parameter q one hence obtains a different quantum kinematics. Of particular interest for applications are the cases where q is a root of unity, because in this case, the Hopf q-quantum Borel kinematics leaves the N-point discretisation Sh of the configuration manifold S1 invariant. In particular, in this discrete setting the parameter j in Lila) and s in K , have the following interpretation: contains - dependent on j - differences between different points of Sh,e.g. between next nearest neighbours for j = 2 or even further points, i.e. it measures how coarse-grained the discretization is. Similarly s is a measure for how coarsegrained the jumps initiated by the shift operators K , are. 4. The quantum dynamics with Hopf q-structure
In this section we derive a quantum dynamics that is compatible with the Hopf q-quantum Borel kinematics in (34). As an important building block in the derivation, an appropriately defined q-version of the first Ehrenfest theorem is necessary. In order to derive it, we introduce a symmetrization of T,K, and K,T, as follows: 1 Sm,s := -(TmK.g 2
+ KsTm).
(35)
It is given in terms of the shift operators K , and leads to the generators T , in the limit q + 1 as expected for consistency. Based on the symmetrised coordinates, we furthermore introduce the following symmetrised scalar product ( @ , S 4 ) s g r n :=
1 z{(@, S4) + ( S @ 4)) ,
7
(36)
where (,) denotes the usual scalar product as in section 2, S denotes a shift operator, S is its complex conjugate. This symmetrisation of the dependence on the shift operator S is sufficient to ensure that the quantum mechanical probability density p = is a real quantity in the deformed setting; without this symmetrisation, this would not be the case. With this definition of a symmetrised scalar product, the Hopf q-version of the first Ehrenfest relation reads:
165
where
Note that the coefficients r and s, that define the shift operators, are independent. 4.1. Derivation of a nonlinear q-Schrodinger equation
In order to derive the Hopf q-quantum dynamics, the left and right hand side of (37) have to be evaluated explicitly. 4.1.1. The right hand side of (37)
With N , as short-hand notation for zdZ,q-shift operators are given as qaNz and act on functions f(z) via
(40) Then the right hand side of (37) can be evaluated to yield an expression of q a N z f ( 4= f(q."z).
the form ( f , B )in the usual scalar product with
166
In order to obtain the last term in (41) we relate K, and K , such that K,Ks = 1. This ensures that the last term is a function of p = In the following we restrict ourselves to the case of a = 0 to keep the argument transparent. Furthermore, the a-dependence is not essential for the derivation of the nonlinear parts, so that it is not crucial for the main result, which is the derivation of possible real parts. In terms of $1 and $2, where $ = $1 i $ ~ , one finds for the part not depending on the parameter D in (38) the following expression:
4$.
+
4.1.2. The left hand side of (37) The left hand side of (37) can be computed with (13) to be of the form
at ($(t,z ) , Qi(f)$(t,z
)
) =~ at~($(t, ~ 21, f (z)Ks$(t,z))sym
~&($,f(~S+ d )((KS$Lf4)1 (fJt;(4FS$) + (KS4M)) =: (f,4 = =
(43)
where the real-valued functions f are time independent and hence are not affected by the operator at. The last line in (43) contains the usual scalar product.
167
In order to determine an expression for the quantity A in (43), one needs an ansatz for a nonlinear q-Schrodinger equation. We use an ansatz with H i linear in $ and Gi[$,$]nonlinear in $, 4:
i(&$)$ = (Hi$)(S$) + (G{[$,$l$)(R$)
(44)
S and R are shift operators like in (40),with parameters a in (40) given as a, and a,, respectively. Such shift operators typically occur in a q-deformed theory. (44) reduces to the corresponding expression for the evolution equation given in section 2 in the limit q + 1, if H! and Gi[$, $1 are such that they give H and G[G,$] in this limit. With (44) we get
4.2. The q-deformed evolution equation
Fulfilling the Hopf q-version of the first Ehrenfest relation (37) means equating the expressions for A and B in (42) and (45). We will consider linear and nonlinear terms independently.
The t e r n s connected with H; Assuming now that the linear operator H i , denoted by H , and the corresponding shift S are real, and using $ = i q ! ~ we ~, obtain that the terms on the right hand side of (45) involving the linear terms H are given by :
+
-(HK,$1 ) ( W 2 ) . (46) Equating this expression with B' in (42), we find uniquely ( H Q 2 )(SKS$JI)+(HK,$J2) (S$l)- (H$1)(SK,$2)
where E = f l . In particular, since K , = q s N z ,the parameter s is fixed in dependence on j . Note that these results differ from the nonHopf case considered in [3]. The formalism to derive a q-Schrodinger
168
equation corresponding to the ansatz (44) hence requires the selection s = Reinserting this into the Hopf q-quantum Bore1 kinematics in (34) means that the freedom in the position and momentum operator is not independent and linked precisely by this condition on s via the dynamics. The resulting part of the q-SchrBdinger equation is hence ( j E 2N) :
%.
(
f (qNz + q - N z ) 4.
(Hi$)(S$) = [ j N z ][ j % ]
(48)
The terms connected with Gi We focus now on the nonlinear terms Gi. In order to derive them, the terms in (45), which contain a dependence on G{[$, $1 := G1+iG2, are collected. The imaginary terms cancel as expected and one obtains with the R = R1 + iR2, $ the following real quantity:
GIhl(d1, $2,
+ G2h2($1, $2 ,R1,R2, Ks)
R1, R2, Ks)
(49)
where h1($1,$2,Rl,Rz,K,)
+ (Ks$2)(R2$2)
= (KS$l)(R2$1)
+(KS$2)(Rl$l)
- (KS$l)(R1$2)
+(41)(R2&$1) + ($2)
+($2 1(R1Ks$1)
(50)
(R2Ks$2)
- ($1 ) (R1Ks$2 )
and h2($1,42,Rl,R2,KS)
= (Ks$l)(Rl$l)
+ (KS$2)(&$2)
+(KS$l)(R2$2) +($l)(R~Ks$l)
+($1
(R2Ks$2
- (KS$2)(R2$1)
+ ($2)(R1Ks42) - ($2
(51)
(R2Ks$l).
It has to be equated with the terms proportional to D in (41). The corresponding identity implicitly contains GI, G2, as well as the shifts R1 and R2. Depending on the shifts R1 and R2, the components of the nonlinearity G1 and G2 can be obtained from the nonlinear terms:
FNL 3 (Gi[$,$]$)(R$)
= ((GI
+ iG2)$)(R1 + iR2)4.
(52)
In particular, the nonlinear q-Schrijdinger equation is then given as ( j E 2N, € 1 , €2 = f l ) :
i(&$)4= (q$)(s4) +FNL
(53)
169
with H{ and S as in (48). It is important to stress that the nonlinear term FNL depends on the choices for R1 and R2, and indeed for different choices of R1 and R2 different types of nonlinear terms are obtained. 4.3. The continuous limit
In this subsection we consider the continuous limit of our family of nonlinear q-Schrodinger equations. As before, linear and nonlinear case are treated separately.
The linear terms in the continuous limit A restriction to the linear terms in the q-evolution equation leads for all j in the limit q + 1 to the Hamiltonian obtained in section 2. It resembles the Hamiltonian obtained with the more restricted deformation in [l] up to a factor q e z j % , which now is compensated by the operator K,. The nonlinear terms an the continuous limit The limit q + 1 of the linear part of the evolution equation (48) has already been discussed above. In order to obtain the nonlinear part in the limit q + 1, it is necessary to expand the functions hl($l, $2 R1 ,R2, K,) and h2 ( $ 1 , $ 2 , R1 ,R2 K,) as well as the nonlinear terms in (42) in leading orders of h, where h is given implicitly by q = eh. For the nonlinear terms in (41) one finds the sum of the following two terms: B(1) = & $ / $ , / / I - $,/$///)h2 + O(h3) (54) B(2)= -Dp” + O(h)
-is
+
+
+
Moreover, using the ansatz R = R1 iR2 = (aqQNz bqBNz) i (cqTNZ dqdNZ)( a , b, c , d, a , ,f?, y, S real constants), one derives the expression
+
hi ($1
,$2, Ri, R2, Ks)= 2(c + d)($
+ $2) + 2h
((c + dk2; f CY +a) ($l$i + $ 2 4 ) +(aa f W ) ( $ 2 $ , ; - $I$;) + O ( h 2 ) . (55) A similar expression for h2 ( $ 1 , $ 2 , R1, Rz, K,) follows from (55) using hz ($19 $2, Ri ,Rz, Ks) = hi ($1, $ 2 , R2, Ri ,Ks). Based on these expansions one finds that in the limit q + 1 one always obtains the same imaginary part for the nonlinear functional.
170
It coincides with the expression that has been derived without qdeformation in the framework of Bore1 quantisation. In addition, one obtains results on the real part of the nonlinear functional. For nontrivial shift operators R, that is in the case R # 1, the following class of real parts occurs: Dp" 2P . Otherwise, if R = 1 is the trivial shift operator, the real part remains undetermined like in the undeformed setting as expected for consistency. 4.4. Comparison with previous results
The results derived for the real part of the nonlinear functional in the limit q + 1 is sensitive to the choice of shift operators in the q-deformed setting. In particular, q-deformations of the momentum subalgebra of the kinematical algebra as considered in [l]lead to results different from the ones that arise under a Hopf q-deformation of the full kinematical algebra and a related symmetrisation of the first Ehrenfest relation. The reason for this discrepancy lies in the fact that here one has obtained nonlinear terms in leading orders of h2 in (54), whereas the counterpart to this formula in [l]is given in leading orders of h, which have cancelled each other here due to the contributions from the symmetrisation. In this way, the formalism presented here contains more information and leads to more specific results. It is interesting to note that the real part derived here lies in the DG-class of real parts introduced in section 2. In contrast to this, there are two nontrivial classes of real parts for the non-Hopf q-deformation in [l],one of which coincides with the class derived here, and another one which does not fall into the DG-classes. The Hopf q-deformation of the full kinematical algebra together with a related symmetrisation of the first Ehrenfest theorem has, on the contrary, led to a specification of only one type of real part for the nonlinear functional which coincides with one of the classes in the DG-family of nonlinear Schriidinger equations. Moreover, it has led to the fact that the coordinates, that is the operators pn,are no longer commutative, and the Hopf q-deformation has hence resulted in a noncommutative theory. A method to derive the quantum kinematics on Sy through difference operators which is based on spectral triples is given in [22].
171
A further interesting feature of an approach related to a Hopf qdeformation of the full kinematical algebra is the fact that the q-SchrBdinger difference equations (53) adopt a more symmetric form due to the symmetrisation procedure. In particular, one obtains the following family of difference equations in dependence of j :
For comparison with the results related to a q-deformation of the momentum subalgebra of the kinematical algebra, see (96) in [l]. 5. Applications to LQvy processes Here we outline how to apply our formalism to Levy processes. Our starting point is the relation between the algebraic structures of the formalism developed here and results on Levy processes on compact and noncompact quantum groups obtained in [16,17]. First we note that in both formalisms there are Abelian subalgebras. In our case this is the infinitely generated Abelian Hopf algebra K . This could be related to the Cartan subalgebras K of quantum groups generated by group-like elements Ici, ki', (i = 1 , . . . ,n ) , in the formalism of Jimbo [23]. Since Cartan subalgebras are sub-Hopf-algebras of quantum groups G, the restriction of a Ldvy process on 6 to K is still a Ldvy process. We further restrict t o any of the group-like elements and relate the resulting Lkvy process with the subalgebra generated by any of our generators K j . For group-like elements one can use [12] to get explicit expressions without having t o solve any quantum stochastic differential equations, cf. [16]. Ldvy Processes on V,(G) have been considered for G = d ( 2 ) [16] and this may be applied to the subalgebra of (17) generated by L1,L-1,L0, which is isomorphic to the algebra sZ(2). Furthermore, there should be some relation between the real forms of sZ(2) and their quantum group deformations with real forms and deformations of subalgebras of the Witt algebra. Acknowledgments
V.K.D. and R.T. would like to thank the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation for financial support in the framework of the Clauthal-Leipzig-Sofia
172
Cooperation. V.K.D. was also supported in part by the Bulgarian National Council for Scientific Research grant F-1205/02 and R.T. by an EPSRC Advanced Research Fellowship.
References 1. V.K. Dobrev, H.-D. Doebner and R. Twarock, “Quantum Mechanics with Difference Operators” , Rep. Math. Phys. 50, 409-431 (2002). 2. B. Angermann, H.-D. Doebner and J. Tolar, , “Quantum Kinematics on
3.
4.
5. 6.
7.
8. 9.
10. 11.
12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
17.
Smooth Manifolds”, in: Lect. Not. Math. vol. 1037 (Springer, 1983) pp. 171208. V.K. Dobrev, H.-D. Doebner and R. Twarock, “A discrete, nonlinear qSchrodinger equation via Bore1 quantization and q-deformation of the Witt algebra”, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 38,1161-1182 (1997). R. Twarock, “A q-Schrodinger equation based on a q-Hopf deformation of the Witt algebra”, J . Phys. A: Math. Gen. 32,4971-4981 (1999). H.-D. Doebner and G.A. Goldin, “On a general nonlinear Schrodinger equation admitting diffusion currents” , Phys. Lett. A162, 397-401 (1992). H.-D. Doebner and J.D. Hennig, “A quantum mechanical evolution equation for mixed states from symmetry and kinematics”, in: Symmetries in Science VIII, eds B Gruber (Plenum Publ., New York, 1995) pp. 85-90. H.-D. Doebner and P. Nattermann, ,“Bore1 quantization: Kinematics and dynamics”, Acta Phys. Pol. B27, 2327-2339 (1996). P. Nattermann, W. Scherer and A.G. Ushveridze, “Exact solutions of the general Doebner-Goldin equation”, Phys. Lett. A184, 234-240 (1994). H.-D. Doebner and G.A. Goldin, “Properties of nonlinear Schrodinger equations associated with diffeomorphism group representations ” , J . Phys. A : Math. Gen. 27, 1771-1780 (1994). L. Accardi, M. Schiirmann and W.V. Waldenfels, Quantum independent increment processes on superalgebras, Math. 2. 198,451-477, 1988. M. Schiirmann, “A class of representations of involutive bialgebras”, Math. Proc. Camb. Philos. SOC.107,149-175 (1990). M. Schiirmann, White Noise on Bialgebras, Lecture Notes in Math. Vol. 1544 (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1993). U. F’ranz and R. Schott, “Diffusions on braided spaces”, J. Math. Phys. 39, 2 7 4 ~ ~ (1998). 6 2 U.Franz and R. Schott, “Evolution equations and Lkvy processes on quantum groups”, J . Phys. A: Math. and Gen. 31, 1395-1404 (1998). U. Franz and R. Schott, Stochastic Processes and Operator Calculus on Quantum Groups. (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht , 1999). V.K. Dobrev, H.-D. Doebner, U. Franz and R. Schott, “Lkvy processes on U,(g) as infinitely divisible representations”, in: Probability on Algebraic Structures, eds. G. Budzban, Ph. Feinsilver and A. Mukherjea, Contemp. Math. vol. 261 (American Math. Society, 2000) pp. 181-192; [math.PR/9907016]. V.K. Dobrev, H.-D. Doebner, U. Franz and R. Schott, “Lkvy Processes on
173
U,(G)”, in: Proceedings of the International Workshop ”Lie Theory and Its 18.
19.
20. 21.
22.
23.
Applications i n Physics 111, (Clausthal, 1999); eds. H.-D. Doebner et all (World Scientific, Singapore, 2000; ISBN 981-02-4421-5), pp. 280-292. H.-D. Doebner and J. Tolar, “Infinitedimensional symmetries” , A n n , Phys. (Leipzig) 47, 116-122 (1990). H.-D. Doebner and G. Goldin, in: Proceedings of the First Geman-Polish Symposium on Particles and Fields, (World Scientific, Singapore, 1999) p.115. H. Hiro-Oka, 0. Matsui, T. Naito and S. Saito, “On the q-deformation of the Virasoro algebra”, TMUP-HEL-9004, (1990). S. Saito, “q-Virasoro and q-strings in: Quarks, Symmetries and Strings, eds. M. Kaku, A. Jevicki and K. Kikkawa (World Scientific, Singapore, 1991), pp. 231-240. H.-D. Doebner and R. Matthes, “Remarks on Spectral Triples Related to Difference Operators” in: Proceedings of the Fifth International Workshop Lie Theory and its Applications in Physics V, eds. H.-D. Doebner and V. K. Dobrev (World Scientific, Singapore, 2004), to appear. M. Jimbo, “A q-difference analogue of U ( g ) and the Yang-Baxter equation” Lett. Math. Phys. 10,63-69 (1985). ” )
ON ALGEBRAIC AND QUANTUM RANDOM WALKS *
DEMOSTHENES ELLINAS Technical University of Crete Department of Sciences, Division of Mathematics, GR-731 00 Chania Crete Greece E-mail: ellinasOscience.tuc.gr
Algebraic random walks (ARW) and quantum mechanical random walks (QRW) are investigated and related. Based on minimal data provided by the underlying bialgebras of functions defined on e. g the real line R, the abelian finite group Z N , and the canonical Heisenberg-Weyl algebra hw, and by introducing appropriate functionals on those algebras, examples of ARWs are constructed. These walks involve short and long range transition probabilities as in the case of R walk, bistochastic matrices as for the case of Z N walk, or coherent state vectors as in the case of hw walk. The increase of classical entropy due to majorization order of those ARWs is shown, and further their corresponding evolution equations are obtained. Especially for the case of hw ARW, the diffusion limit of evolution equation leads to a quantum master equation for the density matrix of a boson system interacting with a bath of quantum oscillators prepared in squeezed vacuum state. A number of generalizations to other types of ARWs and some open problems are also stated. Next, QRWs are briefly presented together with some of their distinctive properties, such as their enhanced diffusion rates, and their behavior in respect to the relation of majorization to quantum entropy. Finally, the relation of ARWs to QRWs is investigated in terms of the theorem of unitary extension of completely positive trace preserving (CPTP) evolution maps by means of auxiliary vector spaces. It is applied to extend the CPTP step evolution map of a ARW for a quantum walker system into a unitary step evolution map for an associated QRW of a walker+quantum coin system. Examples and extensions are provided.
1. Introduction
Random walks formulated in an algebraic f r a r n e ~ o r of k ~finite ~ ~ groups, ~~~~ bialgebras and operator algebras as well as in the framework of Quantum Mechanics,5~6~7i8~g~10i11~12~13 and references therein), are investigated. Min'Based on talk given in: Volterra-CIRM-Grefswald International Conference on Classical and Quantum Levy Processes: Theory and Applications, Trento Italy 27 Sept. - 3 Oct. 2003.
174
175
imal data for such constructions consist of a bialgebra14 and an integral (functional) defined on it, or alternatively of some Lie algebra, and two quantum systems modelling the walker and the coin system, together with a map modelling the coin tossing, that decides probabilistically the stepping of the walker. Examples of ARWs treated in the following subsections are walks on algebras of functions on R, on ZN, and on the canonical algebra HeisenbergWeyl hw15(section 2). For those walks we show how to define the entropy functional of their respective integral and/or Markov transition operator, and how to deduce that these are entropy increasing random walks by using arguments based on the interrelations relations between majorization bistochastic matrices and e n t r ~ p y . ' ~Moreover, ~ ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~theoretic dea number composing of ARW on ZN is analysed, that is called prime decomposition,20 and refers to its factorization into products of similar smaller ZN-walks. Mathematically this decomposition is based on the Chinese Remainder Theorem and the co-associativity property. Also for the ARWs on R, in addition to the usual case of short range walk with nearest neighbor (NN) transitions (Polya walk),21 we discuss in our algebraic framework the cases of i) the NN centrally biased random walk (Gillis walk)22 and the case of symmetric random walk with exponentially distributed steps (LinderbergShu1er:LS walk).23 Finally, for the h w ARW, where its functional is constructed by means of the eigenstates of the annihilation operator of that algebra i.e the family of coherent state v e c t ~ r s ,the ~ ~continuous ,~~ time, or diffusion like limit, is obtained.15 This limit results into a trace preserving quantum master e q ~ a t i o n ~ for~ the 3 ~ density ~ matrix of a quantum boson system, which physically is identified with the evolution equation of an open quantum boson system interacting coherently with a classical electric field and incoherently (dissipative interaction) with a bath of quantum oscillators rigged initially into a squeezed vacuum state (squeezed white noise) .28,29,30 Section 3, gives a concise prescription of the concept of QRW, using the example of QRW on integers as paradigm.13 It briefly explains the notion of quantum coin system and the coin tossing map, and summarizes two emblematic properties of that walk, namely the quadratic enhancement of its diffusion rate due to quantum entanglement between the walker and coin systems, and the entropy increase without majorization effect of its probability distributions (pd). This section ends with a group theoretical scheme of classification of various known QRWs. In section 4, a relation connecting ARW and QRW is put forward. The
176
connection is grounded on the theorem due to Naimark that asserts the possibility of implementing in a unitary way a CPTP map operating on e.g the density operator of a quantum system.31 This unitary extension is realized in the original vector space of the density operator augmented by an auxiliary vector space, the ancilla space in the terminology of Quantum Information theory.32 Applied in the context of CPTP of a ARW,the ancilla space is identified with the quantum coin state space of a QRW.The Kraus generators determining the CPTP map of a ARW serve to built, albeit in non unique way, the unitary evolution operator of the associated QRW. This section concludes with the example of an explicit construction of a Q R W associated to the h w ARW,of section 2. Finally, section 4, summarized some of the results and gives some prospected applications of the ARW-QRW concepts and formalism.
2. Algebraic Random Walks
2.1. The case of R
=
Proposition 1. Let the bialgebra of real formal power series H Fun(R) generated by the coordinate function X , and let the positive definite functional 4 : H + R, defined as q5 = CiEZ pi&, with 0 5 pi 5 1, CiEZ p; = 1, where q5ad(f(x)) = f(cq), the functional that evaluates any function f E H , at the point cui = icu, defined for some step cu E R+, for i E 2. The n-step convoluted functional becomes
iEZ
where p(") = Dn-'p('), with the stochastic column vectors p ( k ) = (pi ( k )) i E ~ , = k 1 , 2 , 3,... and initially p ( l ) p = ( p i ) i E z . Also D = ( D i j ) = ( p ; - j ) , i,j E 2 a bistochastic infinite matrix (delta matrix), and 4 = ( 4 , ; ) i ~azcolumn vector. Majorization ordering among pd's is valid at each step i.e p("+l) 4 p("),and consequently the ARW is entropy increasing, namely, S(C$*"+') 2 S(q5*"), S(Tt+') 2 S(T;), where S($*") S(T;) S@")), with S(z) any Shur-convex function e.g the classical entropy i.e S(z) = 2i log 2;. Proof: Operating with convoluted functionals on some function f E
-
=
xi
177
H
yields
By induction we obtain the aimed relation $*" = $Tp(") = $*D"-lp('). Two important properties of the delta matrix are: i) bistochasticity, i.e the column and row sums is one, which is expressed by means of the column vector of units e = (. . . , 1 , 1 , 1 , . . .), that is left and right eigenvector of D, i.e De = e, eT = eTD, and ii) the shift property i.e D i j = pi-j = pi+l-(j+l) = Di+l,j+l. This property in the case of ARW in 2 governed by a pd with finite support, or in the case of a N C 2 finite dimensional walk (see remark below), amounts to a bistochastic matrix D. The functional of the walk at each time step c#P = CiEZpin)$ai, is characterized by the pd p(") = (pin))iEz, which in turn is determined by the bistochastic matrix D i.e p(") = Dp("-l) = D"-'p('). Let us assume that the pd's are of finite support (but see remark below), then by invocation of the theorem stating that two discrete pd's x = ( z ~ ) ~ , y = ( Y k ) k , that are connected by a bistochastic matrix D i.e x = Dy, are ordered by majorization i.e x 4 y, we conclude that the sequence of pd's { ~ ( ' ) , p ( ~ ) , .p. (.}~ ,) ,of site occupation probabilities resulting at each time step during the evolution of the walk is partially ordered by majorization i. e p(") 4 p(n-11, n = 1 , 2 , 3 , . . . . Let us adopt now the definition of the entropy of a functional to be the entropy of the pd that determines that functional i.e we set S($*") z S(T$) S(p(")),or more generally we do so for any convex function S : R + R of the type of the so called Shur-convex functions e.g the classical Shannon entropy S(p) = x i p i l o g p i , or the functions F ( p ) = x i p t , for any constant k 5 1, or F ( p ) = - nipi.17 By virtue of the theorem stating that x 4 y implies F(x) < F(y) , where F ( x) = x i f ( x i ) , for any convex function f : R + R, or otherwise said that the convex functions isotonic to maj~rization,~' we conclude that for the pd resulting from the random walk the majorization ordering is valid at each step i.e. p(") 4 p("-'), n = 1 , 2 , 3 , . . . , and this implies ordering for e.g their entropies i.e. ,903") > S(p"-l), and similarly for their functionals and transition operators. As majorization order implies entropy increase, it is considered as a measure of disorder, and this allow us to con16917318119
=
178
clude the ARW are getting more disordered in the course of time with respect to their site-visiting pd’s, which are getting more entropic, approaching, if left uninterrupted, to the uniform distribution of maximal entropy.
Remarks: 1) The assumption in the previous proof about the support of the pd’s been finite is not actually necessary. In fact in the proof given by Hardy et. a141 is stated that given p 4 q for finite sequence of q , p pd’s, use of Muirhead’s algorithm leads to a bistochastic matrix A , such that q = Ap, and then the proposition: H ( A p ) 2 H ( p ) for H information/entropy or more generally a Shur convex function, is applied. This proof is constructive and builds A in a number of steps not greater than the lengths of p , q , therefore for infinite pd’s a theorem not using bistochastic operators for the characterization of majorization is needed. Such a theorem is provided in Ref. 42. 2 ) For the above proposition the corresponding Markov transition operator defined as T+= (4 @id) o A, is equal to T4 = C i E Z p i e a i A For . the simplest case of p* = ( p , 1 - p ) , a&= f a , and all other p’s and a’ s been zero, the continues limit limn--too = (T4)n T r has been obtained that leads to a diffusion equation.33s334s15 3) The above general algebraic setting implies that the stepping probability matrix D = ( D i j ) = (pi-j), i , j E Z, would be expanded in the enveloping algebra U ( e ( 2 ) ) of the Euclidean Lie algebra e ( 2 ) M is0(2), spanned by monomials of its generators { E+,E- ,L } , that satisfy the defining commutation relations43
An irreducible matrix representation of those generators in the Hilbert space 31 Zz(Z) spanned by the eigenvectors of the ”distance operator’’ L, is useful in expressing the D matrix for various random walks, and look for solutions by means of e.g the Fourier method. This irrep in the canonical basis of 31, and using the same symbol for abstract generators and their matrices reads:
=
mEZ
mEZ
Next we present three different random walks in R, that can be used as show cases of the scheme of ARW presented here. In these concrete examples the defining the walk transition probability matrix D ,is written as an element of the U ( e ( 2 ) ) algebra. No attempt will be made t o give an
179
algebraic solution for the problem of finding the n th-step site occupancy probability distribution, as this can be solved by other means. The examples include: i) the simplest case of symmetric nearestneighbor (NN) random walk (Polya-walk2’); one of its deformations, ii) the NN centrally (site n = 0) biased random walk (Gillis-walk22), which refers t o a solvable case of a walk with no translational invariance, and stepping probabilities with a bias which has power law decay, or more specifically which decays in proportion from the origin of coordinates. The &-deformation parameter is chosen so that when E > 0, the walk is biased to enhance returns to the origin, while if E < 0, escape from the origin is enhanced, and iii) a symmetric random walk with non- nearest-neighbor transitions with transition step length decaying according to an exponential law ( L S - ~ a l k ~Explicitly ~). we have: 1 ) Polya-walk: symmetric nearest-neighbor ( N N ) random walk with Markov transition operator 1
D p = -(E2
+ E+)
(5)
with matrix elements the inter-site transition probabilities 1 1 DP(l,l ) = p l J I - 1
1
+ 24,,I+l.
(6)
2 ) Gillis-walk: nearest-neighbor centrally (site n = 0) biased random walk with Markov transition operator 1 D G = D G ( E )= -2( E - + E + ) + ( E - - E + ) z N E p , ,l -1<&<1(7)
where PO = eoei, P,,-’- = 1 - PO,the projection operators in the vector eo, and its orthogonal subspace respectively in 12 (Z), and with matrix elements the inter-site transition probabilities
3 ) LS-walk: symmetric random walk with exponentially distributed steps with Markov transition operator
180
with matrix elements the inter-site transition probabilities
= 0,
1=
i.
Use of the eigenvector equations E*e = e, et = etE*, leads to the conclusion that the transition matrices of the Polya, and LS random walks i.e the matrices D p , DR, and DLS respectively are bistochastic, while that of the Gillis walk DG, is column stochastic. Also from the definitions the following two limits are deduced: lim,,o D G ( E )= limE-.,m D L S ( E )= D P . Generalizations: The 2D generalized Gillis random walk with entanglement. This model describes a 2D NN random walk with a biased towards a point placed at (ml,m2) coordinates on the plane. The bias is an attractive or repelling one depending on the sign of two parameters (€1, ~ 2 )in reference t o the motion along z,y axes respectively, and its strength decays following an inverse power law with characteristic exponents ( a l ,a2) correspondingly. This is summarized by writing explicitly all parameters in the Markov transition operator DgD(&l, ml, U I ; E Z , m2,u2), and their , j , u j } E { (-1, l ) , Z, Z+}, j = 1,2. The transition domain of values { ~ j m matrix along each axis is
1 D ~ ( ~ j , m j ,=~ -(Ej) 2
+ E+) + (E- - E+) 2 ( N - j E
mjl)aj
P;,
j=1,2
(12) where Pj = eje;, Pk = 1 - Pj, the projection operators in the vector ej, and its orthogonal subspace respectively in /2(Z). The 2D transition operator consists of an entangled32 convex combination of two factorizable 1D transition operators with the parameters of position of bias site, characteristic decay exponent, and decay strength c.f { m j , a j , ~ j , }j, = 1 , 2 interchanged, it reads (0 5 Q 5 1)
with matrix elements the inter-site transition probabilities
181
(14)
(Zi,Zi)
(Zi,Zi)# (mz,ml),for
with # (ml,m2), for the q component and the (1 - q) component of the convex combination. Also
1 1 D&D(Z1,2; = m1,2;21,1; = m2,i) = q(5&l,ml-i + 2&1,ml+i)
the matrix elements with (Z;,li) = (ml,mz), for the q component and (Z1,Z;) = (mz,ml), for the (1- q ) component of the convex combination. The role of bias and that of the entanglement of the two 1D walks, can be investigated in a n algebraic manner in terms of tensor product representations of the iso(2) algebra, and it will be given elsewhere.44 2.2. The case of ZN
In this section we give a brief study of algebraic random walks on abelian groups ZN,3 using their underlying bialgebra structure, and further investigate possible forms of their decomposition into simpler and dimensionally lower ARWs, based on number theoretic properties of N . Proposition 2. Let the multiplicative abelian group ZN = {e,g,g2,. . . ,gN-'} and the bialgebra H C(Z,) F u ~ ( Z N )= C N-1 span({gi}i=o ), with dual algebra H* C Z N Fun(Z&), with pairing given by evaluation. Let the positive definite functional (state) of a ZN random walk I$ = &o,N-llpigZ, identified as weighted sum of elements of H , with 0 I pi I 1, &O,N--ll pi = 1. By means of the column vectors p = ( p i ) i ~ [ o , ~ - l ] ,= G (gi)iEIO,N-l],we write it as I$ = GTP,where T denotes transpose. Then the n-th step convolution becomes I$*n = GTDn-l p, where D = (Dij) = ( ' p i - j l m o d ~ ) , i, j E [0, N - 11 a circulant bistochastic matrix, to be called delta matrix.
=
Proof: Straightforward (c.f. Ref. 3).
=
=
182
Remarks: 0) The delta matrix is more precisely a circulant bistochastic matrix,45 that can be treated as an element of finite Heisenberg groupHN, 2o and this leads to an explicit solution for the dynamics of ZN walk. 1) Recall the following version of the Chinese Remainder Theorem (CRT)46: let N = N1N2, the decomposition of positive integer N , into product of coprimes N1, N2, then working with the abelian additive groups of numbers Z N ~ ,mod ~ , N1,2 respectively, we can introduce the unique bijection
6 : ZN
+ ZN, x
ZN,,
6 ( ~=) (x - p N 1 , ~ aNz),
(16)
p , a E 2, that maps the numbers of Z N , into the ordered pair of its
remainders after division by N1, N2. Its dual map is the inverse p 6-’ = ZN, x ZN, + ZN,which constructs the unique number x from its remainders a,b), with respect to the divisors N1,N2, as p ( a , b ) = aNT(N1)+ bNT N z ) = x , where cp(c) = # Ic 2 m E Z+; GCD(m,c ) = 11, the Euler function of given integer c, that equals the number of co-primes
r
less or equal t o c. 2) The same factorization is valid for abelian multiplicative groups i.e ZN ”= Z N ~@ Z N ~ if, N = NlN2, and N1, N2, are relative primes. 3) Let for later use introduce now the map 6 + Va, that uniquely determines from the CRT bijection 6, with 6 ( i ) = ( i l , i 2 ) , the isometric matrix & : C N + C N @ ~ C N ~written , in the canonical basis as20
and its inverse
for which we have
and
Notation: in the sequel and in order to distinguish the space dimensionality N , referring to certain e.g functional, operator, probability vector, co-multiplication etc, we will denote it by $“I, T“],and P [ N ] respectively. We can now state two necessary and sufficient conditions, in order to obtain an isomorphic prime decomposition of a ZN ARW governed by a pd +I, into a product of two others ARWs Z N ~ Z, N ~ with , respective pd’s q N ] = qNl] 8 q N z ] . The first condition is number theoretic and is about
183
the compositeness of the dimension number N of the probability distribution P [ N ] that generates the ARW on Z N , while the second condition is about its factorization into a tensor product of two pd's of appropriate dimensions. Proposition 3. a) Let N = N1 N2 be the prime factorization of a positive integer N , then if in addition to the isomorphism of abelian groups of ZN M Z N , @ ZN,, we consider a probability distribution (pd) q N ] factorizable into a product Of two others pd's q ~ ,P][ N , ~namely ], such that V ~ ~= N 4 I~ ~ q N 2 ] , or p!"] = p ~ ~ ] then p ~ the ~ ]functional , of a ZN algebraic random walk $"I = &zNp\N1gjNl, with 0 5 ptN1 5 1,EiEZN pi"' = 1, factorizes for every step n, namely $fG1 M $iGll @ $;G2],and similar factorization is valid for the transition operator i.e T b ! M ThI1 @ ii) Let Nl, N2 and N3, be the co-prime factors of some positive integer N , then the decomposition ZN M ZN, @ Z N ~ @ ZN, x Z N , N ~@ Z N ~M Z N ~@ Z N , N ~ is , co-assosiativel* as indicated in the last, two equations, and if a pd q N ] is considered for which the finest decomposition V 6 P [ N ]= P",] @ q N 2 1 @ P [ N ~ in]terms , of three others pd's is true, then the associated Z N ARW is also decomposed at any step n, namely for its functional and transition operator respectively, the following co-associative factorizations are valid
Th2].
4[14"11
proof:
2)
@
@ 4[N3]
$[NlNz] @ 4[N3]
$[N1]@ $[NzN3],
(19)
The N = N1 N2 case: By means of the factorization property
of the pd viz.
we deduce that
i,jEZN
and therefore &DblV'
%
D b l l@
for the delta matrix. This yields
18
the factorization of the functional $[N] =
G ~ ] P [ N= ] G~]V~;:VP[N]
and similarly for the transition operator (with T(X@ y ) = y TIN]= (id @ 7 @ id) 0 ( 4 1 ~@ 1 id[^])
" (41~x1@
0
@ x)
A[N]
"
@ $[Nz] @ id[N~]) O ( A [ ~ l@ ] A [ N ~ ] ) T [ N ~@] T
[~~]. (23) ii) The N = NlN2N3 case: Applying the CRT to N, in two different ways yields for the abelian group ZN two factorizations i.e ZN FZ ZNl @ ZNz @ ZN3 .ZN~N @ ~Z N ~ M ZN1 @ ZNZN3. This can equivalently be expressed by means of the bijection 6, as id[~l]
( b [ ~ l , ~@zid) ] 6 [ ~N1Z , N ~= ] (id @ d[N2,~3]) O ~ [ N I , N z N ~ ] .(24) Performing the factorization of the pd PIN], as before twice we have (v~[N1 ,N,, which implies that
@
1 ) V J [ ~ 1 ~'IN] Z , ~=3'[~ NI]
@ I'N
21
@ '[Ns]
(25)
(&[Nl,Nz]@ 1)~[NlN2,N3] Db]((fi[N1,NZJ @ 1)h[N1N2,N~] It
"D k l ] @ D b Z l
(26) D$h]. This factorization of the delta matrix leads to an equivalent factorizations of the functional at each time step of the ZN walk, i.e @
$:El " 4iElNzl @ 4:E3] " $;Ell @
" 4igll@ $iE2]@ 4iE3]
(27) Similar decompositions can be obtained for Markov transition operators. #!i:2N3]
Remark: Interpretation of this result implies that the original random walk ZN, is isomorphically decomposed into the product of : i) three similar walks ZN E ZNl @ ZNz @ ZN3, ii) or into the product of two walks of dimensions N1N2 and N3 i.e ZNINz@ ZN3 and iii) or into the product of two walks of dimensions Nl and NzN3 i.e ZN, @ ZNZN3.AS an example we take the Z6 random walk on the vertices of a canonical hexagon the statistics of which is determined by a 6-dimension pd vector Pp1. If this pd has been chosen so that there are two other pd's one that generates a Z3 ARW on the vertices of a canoni3-dimensional P13] cal triangle, and one 2-dimensional PI2] that generates a Z2 walk on two @ PlzI,then we can decompose the ARW points, such that PI6]= PI3]
185
on the canonical hexagon as a product of two walks one on the triangle times one on the two-point set. Similar interpretations can be given to the prime decomposition of an A R W on a canonical polygon. E. O 2 3 @ Z4 @ 2 5 E Z12 @ 2 5 2 3 @ 220~'. g the decomposition Z ~ 2 Problem: Let N = N1NZ be the prime factorization of a positive integer N, for which the isomorphism ZN M ZN, @ Z N ~is, valid, let US consider an ZN A R W generated as previously by a pd q N ] . It this pd is not factorizable into a product of two others pd's as in the remark above, but instead there are two pairs of pd's qN1], PArl,and q N z ] , PAzl,such that the original pd is a convex combination of them i. e (0 5 4 5 l),
In the terminology of quantum i n f ~ r m a t i o n , we ~ ~ have here two
ARWs Z N ~Z, N ~ that , are classically correlated (cc) and form a probabilistic decomposition of the A R W in ZN, and write symbolically ZN qzN, @ + (1- q)zhl@ zh2.A number of interesting problems arise in this context: the total dynamics and reduced dynamics of the components of the ZN walk; the problem of construction of measures of correlations among the components of ZN walk; the problem of information(majorizati0n) dynamics and information exchange among the pd's components of the ZN walk; the problem of asymptotics of the ZN walk. 2.3. The case of hw-Algebra
A bialgebra14 A
= d ( p ,q,A, E ) over a field k is a vector space equipped with an algebra structure with homomorphic associative product map p : AxA A, and a homomorphic unit map q : k + A, that are related by p o (q @ id) = id = p o (id @ q), together with a coalgebra structure
+
A I8 A and a with a homomorphic coassociative coproduct map A : A homomorphic counit map e : A + k, that are related between them by (E I8 id) o A = id = (id I8 E) o A. Both products satisfy the compatibility condition of bialgebra i.e ( p @ p ) o (id I8 T @ id) o (A A) = A o p, where T ( Z I8 y) = y @ z stands for the twist map. If q or E is not defined in A we speak about non unital or non counital Hopf algebra. Suppose we have a functional 4 : A + C , defined on A, let us define the operator T4 : A + A as T+= (4 @ id) o A, then E o T4 = 4, namely the counit aids to pass from the operator to its associated functional. From this relation we can define the convolution product .1c, * 4, between functionals
186
as follows 33: ($J@id) o A o ( 4 @id) o A = ( 4 @ $J) 0 (id@ id@ E ) 0 (id@ A) 0 A
E 0 T$T$ = E 0
= ( d @ $ J ) o A= 4
*$,
(29)
and in general E o T; = E o T p = 4*". These last relations imply that the transition operators form a discrete semigroup with respect t o their composition with identity element T, = i d (due to the axioms of bialgebra) and generator T$,while the functionals form a dual semigroup with respect to the convolution with identity element e and generator 4, and that these two semigroups are homomorphic to each other. We recall now the Heisenberg- Weyl algebra hw and its structural maps: this is the algebra of the quantum mechanical oscillator and is generated by the creation, annihilation and the unit operator {at, a, 1) respectively which satisfy the commutation relation (Lie bracket) [a,at] = 1, while 1 commutes with the other elements. This algebra possesses a non counital bialgebra structure, cf. Ref. 3, chapt. 3, with comultiplication defined as
~ ( n - l ) a= n - + ( u @ ... @ 1 + 1 @ a8 . - .@ 1 + 1 @ ... B U ) , ~ ( n - l ) a t= n - i ( u t 8 . . . @ 1 + 1 8 . .. @ 1 + 1 @ . . . @ a t ), A1 = 1 @ 1 ,
(30)
where as indicated above the maps the creation/annihilation operators into the n t h fold tensor product of the algebra and adds appropriate factors (also c.f. Ref. 47). Let us also define the number operator N = at u with the following commutation relations with the generators of hw: [ N ,at] = at , [ N ,a] = -a. The module which carries the unique irreducible and infinite dimensional representation of the oscillator algebra is the Hilbert-Fock space 3 1 which ~ is generated by a lowest (or "vacuum" ) state vector 10) E 3 1 and ~ is given as 3 1 =~ {In)= 10) ,nE Z+}. The functionals we intend t o use will be defined by means of the canonical coherent state vectors of the hw algebra so in the sequel we give a brief introduction to the concept of coherent state vectors (CSV) on Lie groups: consider a Lie group (7, with a unitary irreducible representation T ( g ) ,g E 8, in a Hilbert space 31. We select a reference vector I+o) E 31, t o be called the "vacuum" state vector, and let 80 C 8 be its isotropy subgroup, i.e for h E Go, T ( h ) = eip(h)IQo). The map from the factor group M = 8/80t o the Hilbert space 31, introduced in the form of an orbit of the vacuum state under a factor group element, defines a CSV
I+o)
187
) .1
= T(Q/Qo) IQo) labelled by points z E M of the coherent state manifold. Coherent states form an (over)complete set of states, since by means of the Haar invariant measure of the group Q viz. d p ( z ) , z E M , they provide a resolution of unity, 1 = d p ( z ) I.)( 21. As a consequence, any vector JQ) E % is analyzed in the CS basis, I*) = dp(z)!I!(z)Iz), with coefficients !I!(x)= (z1Q). We should note here that the square integrability of the vectors !I! will impose some limits on the growth parameters of the functions @(z)at the boundary of manifold M (cf. Refs. 24, 25 and references therein). The hw-CS is defined by the relation
sM
sM
It is an (over)complete set of normalized states with respect to the measure &(a) = ie-la12&a for the non-normalized CS, and a E M = HW/U(l) M C is the CS manifold. Since a)1.1 = a la), M is the flat canonical phase plane with the standard line element ds2 = dad&. Also the symplectic 2-form w = ida A d& is associated to the canonical Poisson bracket { f,g} =
i(a,pg - &a:).
The density operator (state) p which would be used to determine functionals of some operator bialgebras A, is defined generally as follows : Let a Hilbert vector space 31 that carries a unitary irreducible representation of A of finite or infinite dimension. The set of density operators
S = { p E End(%) : p 2 O,pt
= p , t r p = l}
,
(32)
namely the set of non-negative, Hermitian, trace-one operators acting on
3t form a convex subspace of End(%), which is the convex hull of the set Sp = { p E S,p2 = p }
%/U(l) ,
(33)
namely of the set of pure density operators (states), that are in one-to-one correspondence with the state vectors of %. The density operator to be used in the case of h w walk uses the pure density operators Ifa)( k a1 E Sp and is a convex combination belonging to the convex hull of Sp i.e 0 <_ p 5 1,
P = P b ) ( a l + (1 -PI
I-a)( -
4
f
(34)
Let 4(.) = T r p ( . ) G < p , . >, a functional defined on the enveloping Heisenberg-Weyl algebra U ( h w ) ,where p = p la)(a1 (1 - p ) l-a)( - 011, i.e the p density operator is given as a convex sum of pure state density
+
188
operators. The action of the transition operator T4 = (4 c3 id) o A on the generating monomials of U ( h w ) (where we ignore the numerical factors in the comultiplication of eq.(30)) reads,
T4((at)"a") = (4 8 id) 0 A((U~)"U") =
it:9 (y ) (7)
[pa*%$+ (1 - p)(-CY)i(-CY)j](at)"-ian-j
i=o j=o
= p(at
+ CY*)"(a + a)" + (1- p ) @
- a*)"(a - a)"
.
(35)
For a general element f ( a , a t ) E U ( h w ) that is normally ordered, namely the annihilation operator a is placed to the right of the creation operator at, denoted by f ( a , a t ) = Cm,n20cmn(at)"an,the action of the linear operator T4 becomes
T4(f(a, at)) = p f ( a + CY, at + a * )+ (1 - p)f(a - CY, at - a*)
(36)
By means of the CS eigenvector property and the normal ordering of the f element we also compute the value of functional viz.
4(f(a,at)) = Pf(Q1,a*)+ (1 - P)f(--(y, -a*>.
(37)
Let us consider the displacement operator D , = east-,*' = - eA, with A = crat - Za which acts with the group adjoint action on any element f of the U ( h w ) algebra v ~ z . ~ ~ = ead(,at-,*a) (f)= eadA= D , f D L ,
~ d ~ , (=j, , ,)a t - a * a ( f )
(38)
where ad(X)f= [X, f] and ad(X)ad(X)f = [X, [X, f]]and similarly for higher powers, stands for the Lie algebra adjoint action that is defined in terms of the Lie commutator. Similarly the group adjoint action in terms of the displacement operator on the generators of U ( h w ) reads AdD*,(a) = a CY and AdD*, ( a t ) = at F a*.By means of these expressions we rewrite the action of the transition operator as
+ (1 - p)AdD,If(a,at) + (1 - p ) e a d A ] f ( aat). ,
T4(f(a, at)) = b 4 d D - a =
(39)
Next we compute the limiting transition operator
Tt
T4, n+m
lim T$ =
n+cc
t t + -y(adat)' + -y(~da)~n n t
- IyI (ada a h t
n
+ a h t adat)]".
(40)
189
In the last expression we have introduced the parameters of continuous time t E R and the drift and diffusion terms respectively c,y E C by means of the relations
and have performed the limits a + 0, n + 00, with t, c, y been fixed. We have also been used the limit limn+m(l f ) = e z , to obtain the continuous time Markov transition operator Tt = etL, with its L generators as it is obviously identified in the equation below
+
Tt = etL E expt [ 1 + a d h + y(adat)’
+
- IyJ(adu a h t
+ adut adut)]
(42) By construction Tt is the time evolution operator for any element f of U ( h w )i.e f t = Tt(f) and forms a continuous semigroup TtTtl = Tt+t,under composition. This yields the diffusion equation obeyed by ft, which will be taken to be normally ordered hereafter. By time derivation of the equation + t ( f ) =< p , f t
>=< p , etadcf >=< e-tadct P , f >=< p t , f >
7
(43)
we obtain the diffusion equation -$f t = L f t , as well as the dual one satisfied by the p density operator viz. -$pt = Ltpt. Explicitly the quantum master evolution equation for the density matrix reads d -p(t) = [cat - Za, p ] y(at2p pat - Patpat) y(a2p pa2 - 2apa) dt - JyI( ( 2 N + 1) p p(2N 1) - 2atpa - 2 4 ) . (44)
+
+
+ +
+
+
The obtained equation is similar to the quantum master equation that describes the trace preserving dynamics of the reduced density matrix operator of single mode of the electromagnetic field interacting coherently with classical electric filed while it is immersed in a bath of quantum oscillators.28 The decay of the field mode is influenced by the kind of initial condition the reservoir oscillators are put in. To analyze the physical content of that equation we rewrite it below by separating its right hand side into three lines i.e d -p(t) = [cat - a, p] dt - IyI (atup pat, - 2apat aatp paat - 2atpa)
+
+ + + y ( d 2 p+ pat - 2atpat) + Y(a2p + pa2 - 2apa).
(45)
190
The first line gives the coherent interaction of the mode with the classical electric filed of intensity c, as described by the commutator of density operator with the Hamiltonian term. It is neglected for balanced walk. The second line is a typical part of a master equation describing mode decaying for reservoir oscillators in thermal e q ~ i l i b r i u m .The ~ ~ last line is related to the case where the reservoir is prepared in a squeezed vacuum state.28 Closing we should notice that the above quantum master equation can be transformed into a Fokker-Planck partial differential equation for some quasi-probability function e.g P, Q, or Wigner function associated with the density operator e.g 28.
3. Quantum Random Walks 3.1. The case of 2
In a quantum random walk there are two dynamically coupled systems: the walker systems described by a Hilbert space H,, and the coin system also described by a 2D Hilbert space H , M C2 =span( I >, I - >). Let the uni-
+
7
tary matrix U operating in H,, e.g UH = 1 Jz ( l1 - 1 , or Uq = QUH, the Hadamard (Fourier) transform and the - rotation matrix respectively. If we denote by Pk = >< -f, the projection of an orthogonal partition of H,, and by S,, two step operators in the walker’s space H , (explicit examples determined below), we introduce the unitary one-step evolution operator acting in the space H , @ Hw in the combined coin+walker system:
4
In the equation above the upper/lower signs correspond to the choices
U H ,U s , respectively. If initially the two systems are decoupled, their density matrices are factorized i.e pc @. @, Then if we assume that pc = I f >< @I, is a projective density matrix with If >= a ] + > +bl- >, a normalized coin state vector, then the 1-time step of the QRW is considered as a completely positive trace (CPTP) map E,,, operating on the walkers’ density operator, obtained by partially tracing out (“forgetting”) the coin system i.e
191
Unitarity of V, implies that the two probabilities p+ = TrP*Up,UtP* = f 2Reub 2 0, p+ p- = 1, are determined by the coin system state vector variables and in turn they determine the Kraus generator,31 ( G S + ,,/jjZS-), of CPTP evolution map. Four sources of choices are implicit in the above prescription of QRW: the choice of the initial coin+walker state vectors, the choice of unitary U, the choice of definition of time step in terms of the tracing of the coin system (to be investigated in detail below), and finally the choice of step operators Sr in the walker's space, that determines the king of the QRW under investigation. Next we choose to turn to a Hadamard random walk on integers with dynamical algebra the Euclidean algebra e(2) = is0(2), with step operators (fiS+, 5%) = (&jE+, d m E - ) , and third element the "distance" operator L. The latter is the interesting quantum observable the quantum moments of which are used to compare classical and quantum walks. We examine three possible tracing schemes: i) the classical scheme that promptly traces the coin system after each V action, leading to the CRW
+
E V ( P $ ) ) = Trc(Vpc 8 p$-"Vt)
= pE+@,,, (n-l)E+ +
+ (1-p)E-@$-l)Et, (48)
which produces the diagonal sequence of density matrices
with diagonal elements the probabilities of site occupancy, given by the ( p , 1 - p ) classical Pascal triangle, ii) the scheme that traces the coin system by increasing delays i.e after an increasing number of actions of V operator, leading t o a walk designated by QRWl EVN
(&I)= Trc(VNpc8 p$"VtN) =
C Sm e, (O)S(N)t, (N)
(50)
m=f
which produces the sequence of density matrices (51) iii) and the scheme of delaying the trace of coin system by exactly one action of V operator, leading to a walk designated by QRW2
192
which produces the sequence of density matrices
{P P ,
EV2 (PL?), 4
2
(Pi?) ,4
2
( P P ) ,4 7 2 ( P 9 ,...} .
(53)
Next proposition deals with the time evolution of the pd (Pi"),
=
(ml Im) , made of the diagonal elements of the density matrices in the course of the walk QRWl and QRW2.13 Remarks: 1)From the above treatment can been shown that the QRWl reproduces along the diagonal elements of the sequence of evolving density matrices of the walker system the pd of the 1D Hadamard random walk and its diffusion rate13 2) by expressing the evolution unitary operator V , as the exponential of a hermitian operator H i.e V = eiH, which describes an interaction between coin and walker quantum systems, the various schemes of partial tracing can be physically implemented by choosing the length of interaction time e.g the QRW2 scheme requires an interaction time t = 2 for the evolution operator vt = exp (itH).44 Proposition 4. There exists bistochastic matrices A, = SO030 S 1 o s 1 , and A, = BOo&+B1 OBI,which determine the pd drawn from the diagonal elements of the evolving density matrices of the walks QRWl, and QRW2 respectively, by means of the respective equations
+
P:n+l) = A,P:")
+ (E+- E-)M(")P,(O),
p:("+l)= A 9 p(n), 9
(54) (55)
where
and
Above the element by element or Hadamard product A = A o B , defined between matrices A , B of the same size by ( A o B)ij = AijBij, has been used." The study of the pd obtained from the previous proposition reveals two novel aspects of the models QRWl and QRW2. First the aspect of breaking the condition majorization-implies- entropy increase, and that of enhanced diffusion rates. Before closing this section we give a brief demonstration of the latter one (detail investigation together with relevant references can be found in Ref. 13).
193
Enhanced Diffusion Rates:Let us consider the mth order statistical moment of the distance operator < Lm > n = Tr(p?)Lm) , at the nth step. Assume we have a symmetric walk with < L > n = 0, so that the standard deviation at nth step is on = d m . For the CRW we have that 0,"= &, and from the pd's taken by the previous proposition we obtain the respective standard deviation for the walks QRWI and QRW2, expressed in terms of their classical counterparts, for the first five steps:{ayRW' = QRWi - C QRWI = 0F,04QRWi = &j/20,C,0,&RWi = - 0 2 703
OF, 0 2
1,
QRW2
and {q
=
c
QRWz
01 9 0 2
= r
o
512
c 0QRW3
=
&g,02 A%?!
=2@}. From that we deduce that there is a quadratic speed up of the spreading rate in the case of QRWl with respect to CRW,and that rate is even bigger for the case of QRW2.Finally the asymptotic (n >> l ) , growth values are m a 4c >ff5 QRW2
turn out to be
-d
w
0,".
4. Relation of Algebraic and Quantum Random Walks
This section will put forward a relation between the two types of random walks under investigation so far i.e the ARQ and QRW.The relevant theory here is Naimark's extension theorem that allows to express in a non unique manner a positive trace preserving map, operating by means of its Kraus generators on a density matrix describing the state of some quantum system in a certain Hilbert space, by a unitary operator acting on a extension of the original space. Stated in the language of random walks the extension theorem assumes a ARW described by a CPTP map E(e,,,) = Cm=fPmSme,,,SA, operating on the density matrix of walker system with its Kraus generators (&S+, S S - ) , defined to act on Hilbert space H,. It is further assumed as usually for ARWs,that the step generators S* are related to and algebra of operators that needs to be specified. Then a unitary operator V is considered acting on H , @ H,,, i.e an extension of the original space by an extra or ancilla space H , M C2 =span(l+ >, 1- >), which in the context of QRW stands for the coin system. Let a pure density matrix in the coin system pc = I@ >< @I. Then the extension theorem provides a unitary representation of the CPTP i.e Ev(ew) =
C PmSmezus;
= Trc(V@c8 e w v + ) .
(58)
m=f
The unitary operator provides the Kraus generators as G S , = (ml V I@), up to a local unitary operator W, i.e the transformation V -+
194
W €3 1, V,provides the same generators. For the case of ARQs the unitary operator V is specifically expressed by means of the coin states projections
P&,and the unitary matrix U(p*) =
Em=*
6 6 of the coin space, as (6-6)
V = PmU €3 Sm.In particular the step operators are unitary and inverse to each other i.e S+ = (S-)t.This unitary representation can be extended t o products of CPTM maps by first defining the unitaries
C
v@'
PmU
QD PnU QD SmSn.
(59)
m,n=&
Then we obtain
&(ew)
=
C
PmPn
SmSnew(SmSn)t= TTcQDTTc(V~Vec~ecQDewVt€3Vt),
m,n=f
(60) This unitary extension of E', requires a double ancilla space or two coin quantum systems coupled, so the total space is Hc 63Hc @ H w .In the general case the kth power of the CPTP map of an ARW can be implemented unitarily by extending the original walker space by k anchillary coin systems, so the total space becomes HFk QD H,, and the total unitary operator is
v@L"
C
PmlU
€3
... B PmkU
QD Sml...Smk
...,mk=f
ml,
(61)
with unitarity condition V@'"VBkt = lyk€3 1,. Then we obtain for the kth step of the QRW as described by k successive actions of its CPTP map, a unitary realization which involves tensoring of quantum walker t o k quantum coin systems, followed by a coupling of them by a unitary evolution operator on the space of coins+walker composite system, and finally a decoupling of coins from the walker system, taken by partially tracing with respect t o the coin Hilbert spaces. The partial tracing corresponds to coin tossing in an ordinary random walk, and results into a density matrix for the quantum system of the walker, which further may provide statistics of various quantum observables of the walk. Explicitly the unitarization of ARW reads Et(ew)
=
C
pml...pmkSm,...Smkew(Sm,...Smk) t
...,mk=f
ml,
= TrFk((V@"~Fk @ e,V@'"'),
and can be identified with a QRW.
(62)
195
Let us remark at this point that an equivalent decomposition of the unitary Vmkwould be
n k
VB'" =
~
i
where ,
~i
= ( P + u )@ ~(s+)k+l+ ( P - u ) ~ @(s-)k+1,
i=l
and the subindex denotes the position of the embedding of the respective operator into the k-fold tensor product. In fact each of these operators Wi E End(Hpk @ H w ) , provide a new decomposition of the C P T P map i.e ~k = E W ~ W ~ . . . ,Wwhich ~ is equivalent to a nonstationary QRW with k different unitary evolution operators empoyed in order to construct the k - t h step. As a matter of fact this new decomposition helps to account for the type of quantum entanglement involved between coin and walker systems. Let us take the simplest k = 2 case, where Vm2= WlW2, with
Wl = (P+ @ 1, @ s++ P-
@ 1, @ s-) u @ 1, @ 1, ,
W2= ( ~ c @ ~ + @ s + + l c @ P - @ s - ) l c @ u @ l w . The action of these operators on the product density matrices pc @ pc @ pw is akin t o theaction of some control-control-S* type of non-local operator, which uses the two coin states as control spaces and the walker state as the target space, preceded by the local unitary operator U which acts on the control spaces and creates appropriate superposition of coin states. These actions generate quantum entanglement and can be described by the quantum circuit of Fig.1.c below. For purpose of comparison in Fig.l.a, we have included the corresponding circuit that generates the four entangled bipartite Bell states upon action of the composite operator UCNH @ 1 on the four orthogonal product qubit states, and on Fig. l b the circuit that corresponds to the unitary V = (P+@ S+ P- @ S-)U @ 1, of the EV map.
+
Though the topic of the entanglement in the QRWs will not be investigated further here, it should be obvious from the above analysis that the CPTP map that implements some discrete time-step of a QRW,also generates quantum entanglement that can be studied by appropriate circuits and evaluated by effective measures, as usually is done in other cases of coupled quantum systems. Although quantum correlations have been generally accepted to be the common cause of all novel effects in the QRW performance, the exact evaluation of the entanglement resources needed in the course of a QRW is still an open problem.
196
Fig.1 .a
Fig. I .b
Fig. 1.c Figure 1. Fig.1 (a) Circuit generating entangled Bell states from product states using local Hadamard and non-local control-not gate; (b) Circuit generating the unitary evolution of the 1-step map E V ; (c) Circuit generating entangled coin-walker states from corresponding factorized ones using local unitary (e.g Hadamard gate in the case of the homonymous QRW), and non-local control-control-& gates, that form the map of the 2-step QRW E $ = E W ~wZ.
To establish further the connection among ARQs and QRWs we give four particular examples: a) the Euclidean QRW13 [iso(2)-QRW]: with the distance operator L Im) = m Im) , with its eigenspace HE =span{ Im) ,m E Z}, and its dual phase operator @ Icp) = cp 19) , with its eigenspace H,” =span{Icp) ,cp E [0,27r); related by a Fourier transform with H i . Two ARWs and its associated QRWs (modulo local unitary operators in coin spaces, as explained above), can be constructed: the distance random walk on Z, with C P T P map constructed with Kraus generators been the step operators in the distance operator eigenstates i.e S& Im) E& Im) = e f i 6 Im) = Im f 1), and the phase random walk on the circle S, with CPTP map constructed with Kraus generator been the step operators in the phase operator eigenstates
g},
=
197
i.e S* 19) e f i L 19 f I) ; ii) the Canonical Algebra QRW [ hw-QRW]: with the position operator Q Iq) = q Iq) , with its eigenspace H,& =span{ Iq) ,q E R; dq}, and its dual m o m e n t u m operator P Ip) = p Ip) , with its eigenspace H,' =span{ Ip) , p E R;d p } , related by a Fourier transform with H,&. Two ARWs and its associated QRWs (modulo local unitary operators in coin spaces, as explained above), can be constructed: the position random walk on R, with CPTP map constructed with Kraus generators been the step operators in the position operator eigenstates i.e Sk Iq) e f i P lq) = Iq f 1), and the m o m e n t u m random walk on R, with CPTP map constructed with Kraus generator been the step operators in the momentum operator eigenstates i.e Sk lp) ehiQ lP) = IP f 1); iii) the M - dimensional Discrete Heisenberg Group QRW [~M-QRW]: with the action operator N In) = n In) , with its eigenspace H," =span{ In > , n E ZM}, and its dual angle operator 0 IS,) = 29, IS,) , with its eigenspace H," =span{lS,), 19, E &ZM}, related by a finite Fourier transform with H,". Two ARWs and its associated QRWs (modulo local unitary operators in coin spaces, as explained above), can be constructed: the action random walk on ZM, with C P T P map constructed with Kraus generators been the step operators in the action operator eigenstates i.e S* In) K e *ie In) = h*l In) = In f 1), and the angle random walk on & Z M , with CPTP map constructed with Kraus generator been the step operators in the momentum operator eigenstates i.e S* 18), gfl = e * w IS,) = IS,*,) ; iv) the Coherent State QRW15[ CS-QRW]: with the annihilation operator a la) = a la) , with its eigenspace H: =span{la) ,a E C; %}.Two ARWs and its associated QRWs (modulo local unitary operators in coin spaces, as explained above), can be constructed: the annihilation random walk on C, with CPTP map constructed with Kraus generators been the step operators in the annihilation operator eigenstates i.e Sh la) = eJ(*') la) = D A la) ~ = la f 1).The step operators here identified as special case of the canonical coherent state displacement operator D*g = e*DatFBa = eJ(*g), have based the indicated step property on the following operator identity D,Dg = e-iaxfiDa+g, applied for the case of co-linear a,,B vector on complex plane. To give an explicit identification of the ARW based on the hw algebra constructed in Ref. 15, as a quantum random walk, and in particular as a CS-QRW, we make the following choices: the transition probabilities are p+ = p , p - = 1 - p , the coin state is pc = 10 >< 01, the U operator is U ( p , l - p ) , and the step operators are CS displacement operators with
=
IS,)
198
steps k/3 E C. Then the total 1-step evolution operator in the coin+walker system is V = PU , 18 S, = fiD+P c p D + f i ) , a n d t h e G D - P -@-s reduced walker evolves in 1-step by the CPTP &v(e,,,) = p D + g ~ ~ D i ~
Em=*
(
+
(1 - P)D-aeWD!P = T T c ( V Q c 63 e w v ' ) . For n steps the evolution of the walker has been chosen in Ref. 15 to be +((e,,,). It is important to notice that this is a choice based on the ARW construction methodology, and that our present treatment of the same walk as a QRW, sees the $(e,,,) type of evolution to result from a partial tracing of the coin system at every step. Our previous discussion of other types of tracing schemes motivates the study of CS-QRWs with delayed tracing, in order t o investigate phenomena such as enhanced or anomalous diffusion in ARWs. This problem will be taken up elsewhere. 5 . Discussion
We have outlined a mathematical framework where the conception of random walk and its associated statistical notions, and equations of motion, can both be studied in an algebraic and quantum mechanical manner. ARWs and QRWs appear to be two aspects of the same mathematical device, so their interconnection serves to conceptually clarify the common ground between them and to enrich the heuristics of formulating new problems and methodically searching for their solutions. Quantum random walks are important both as quantum algorithms to experimentally be realized and as modules in a general quantum computing algorithm-devise that could outperform some classical rival. The connection ARW-QRW could serve to generalize, unify and compare such algorithms. Also Quantum Information Processing concepts and tools, could be developed for ARW-QRWs. The step taken here is only a preliminary one towards developing such a theory. Finally, ARW-QRWs come with lots of free choices for its constituting parameters. To mention only one expected application in the field of Open Quantum Systems, we should emphasize the importance of choosing the functional in e.g the hw ARW. Various choices of functionals in terms of types of coherent state vectors, combined together with various choices of ordering the operator basis in the enveloping algebra U(hw), i.e normal, antinormal, symmetric etc, could serve as a guiding rule for constructing quantum master equations for open boson systems interacting with various types of quantum mechanical baths.
199
6. Acknowledgments
I wish t o thank the organizers of the Volterra-CIRM-Grefswald Conference for the opportunity to give a talk. Discussions with L. Accardi, U. F’ranz, R. Hudson, M. Schurmann, and with my collaborators A. Bracken and I. Tsohantjis, are gratefully acknowledged. I am also grateful to the anonymous referee for suggesting eq.(63). References 1. P. A. Meyer, Quantum Probability for Probabilists (Lect. Notes Math. 1538), (Springer, Berlin 1993). 2. M. Schiirmann, White Noise on Bialgebras (Lect. Notes Math. 1544), (Springer, Berlin 1993). 3. S. Majid, Foundations of Quantum Groups Theory (Cambridge Univ. Press, 1955), ff. chapter 5. 4. U. Franz andR. Schott, Stochastic Processes and Operator Calculus on Quantum Groups, (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dodrecht 1999). 5. A. Ambainis, E. Bach, A. Nayak, A. Vishwanath and J. Watrous, Proc. 33rd Annual Symp. Theory Computing (ACM Press, New York, 2001), p.37. 6. D. Aharonov, A. Ambainis, J. Kempe and U. Vasirani, Proc. 33rd Annual Symp. Theory Computing (ACM Press, New York, 2001), p.50. 7. A. Nayak and A. Vishwanath, arXive eprint quant-ph/0010117. 8. J. Kempe, Proc. 7th Int. Workshop, RANDOM’OJ, p.354 (2003). 9. A. M. Childs, E. Farhi and S. Gutmann, Quantum Information Processing 1,35 (2002). 10. B. C. Travaglione and G. J. Milburn, Phys. Rev. A 65, 032310 (2002). 11. B. C. Sanders, S. D. Bartlett, B. Tregenna and P. L. Knight, Phys. Rev. A 67,042305(2003). 12. J. Kempe, Contemp. Phys. 44, 307 (2003). 13. A. J. Bracken, D. Ellinas and I. Tsohantjis, J. Phys. A : Math. Gen. 37, L91(2004). 14. E. Abe, Hopf Algebras (CUP Cambridge 1997). 15. D. Ellinas, J. Comp. Appl. Math.133, 341 (2001). 16. A. W. Marshall and I. Olkin, Inequalities: Theory of Majorization and its Applications (Academic Press, New York, 1979). 17. R. Bhatia, Matrix Analysis (Spinger-Verlag, New York , 1997). 18. P. M. Alberti and A. Uhlmann, Stochasticity and Partial Order: Double Stochastic Maps and Unitary Mixing (Dordecht, Boston, 1982). 19. M. A. Nielsen, An Introduction to Majorization and its Applications to Quantum Mechanics (unpublished notes). 20. D. Ellinas and E. Floratos, J . Phys. A : Math. Gen. 32,L63 (1999). 21. B. D. Hughes, Random Walks and Random Environments Vol. I, (Clarendon Press, Oxford 1995) 22. J. Gillis, Quarterly J. Math., (Oxford, 2nd series)7, 144 (1956). 23. K. Lakatos-Lindenberg and K. E. Shuler, J. Math. Phys. 12,633 (1971).
200 24. J. R. Klauder and B.-S. Skagerstam, Coherent States (World Scientific, Singapore (1986) 25. A. Perelomov, Generalized Coherent States and their Applications, (Springer - Verlag, Berlin 1986). 26. E. D. Davies, Quantum Theory of Open System, (Academic, New York, 1973). 27. G. Lindblad, Non-Equilibrium Entropy and Irreuersibility, (Reidel, Dordrecht 1983). 28. M. 0. Scully and M. S. Zubairy, Quantum Optics, (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1997), p. 255, 448, 453. 29. S. Stenholm, Phys. Scripta T12(1986). 30. J. Gea-Bauacloche, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59,543 (1987). 31. K. Kraus, States, effects and operations (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1983). 32. M. A. Nielsen and 1. L. Chuamg, Quantum Computation and Quantum Information, (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 2000). 33. S. Majid, Int. J . Mod. Phys. 8 , 4521-4545 (1993). 34. S. Majid, M. J. Rodriguez-Plaza, J . Math. Phys. 33,3753-3760 (1994). 35. P. Feinsilver and R. Schott, J. Theor. Prob. 5,251 (1992). 36. P. Feinsilver, U. F’ranz and R. Schott, J . Theor. Prob. 10, 797 (1997). 37. U . Franz and R. Schott, J . Phys. A: Gen . Math. 31 , 1395 (1998); 38. U. Franz and R. Schott, J. Math. Phys. 39, 2748 (1998). 39. D. Ellinas and I. Tsohantjis, J . Non-Lin. Math. Phys.8Suppl. 93(2001). 40. D. Ellinas and I. Tsohantjis,Inf. Dim. Anal.- Quant. Prob. 611 (2003). 41. G. H. Hardy, J. E. Littlewood and G. Polya, Messenger Math. 58, 145 (1929). 42. H. Sikic and M. V. Wickerhauser, Appl. Comp. Harm. Anal. 11, 147 (2001). 43. R. Gilmore, Lie Groups, Lie Algebras and Some of Their Applications, (Wiley, New York 1974). 44. D. Ellinas, et. al, work in progress. 45. P. J . Davis, Czrculant Matrices, (Wiley, New York 1979). 46. M. R. Schroeder, Number Theory in Science and Communication, (Springer, Berlin 1997). 47. C. D. Cushen and R. L. Hudson, J . Appl. Prob. 8, 454 (1972). 48. This second line of the equation has the form a Lindblad type master equation taken in the large temperature limit, where for the average number of thermal photons we have A NN A + 1 = (yI,c.f. Ref. 28. 49. H. Risken, The Fokker-Planck Equation, (Springer, Berlin 1996). 83 (1990).
DUAL REPRESENTATIONS FOR THE SCHRODINGER ALGEBRA
PHILIP FEINSILVER Department of Mathematics Southern Illinois University Carbondale, IL. 62901, U . S . A . RENE SCHOTT IECN and LORIA UniversitC Henri PoincarC-Nancy 1, BP 239, 54506 Vandoeuvre-lks-Nancy, fiance. Starting from the multiplication table for a basis of a Lie algebra, we show how to find a realization as vector fields in the case there is a Lie flag. Then we show how this is connected to finding coordinates of the second kind. We find the explicit form for coordinates of the second kind for the Schrodinger algebra in a particularly useful basis. These coordinates are related to dual vector fields that form an abelian Lie algebra generating an associated family of polynomials. Families of polynomials in quantum variables arise by specialization of the parameters of the first kind corresponding to quantum observables.
201
202
1. Introduction
The Schrodinger Lie algebra plays an important role in mathematical physics and its applications. It has been introduced and investigated as the algebra of symmetries of the free Schrodinger e q ~ a t i o n . The ~~~ re-J sulting structure of the semidirect product of the Heisenberg algebra and sl(2) was investigated in Ref. 11. Recently this algebra has appeared in the context of the square of white noise.’ And G. Pap is using it to compute the Fourier transform of Brownian motion on Heisenberg groups.15 This article is composed of two parts. In Part I, we present the calculation of dual representations of a Lie algebra using Lie flags and illustrate its application to the Schrodinger algebra. In Part 11, we recall the Splitting Lemma for coordinates of the second kind. For the Schrodinger algebra, these coordinates are found in two steps. First using a basis that reflects the semidirect product structure of the algebra the appropriate equations are solved. Since the “standard basis” is a permutation of that first basis, the coordinates of the second kind for the standard basis can be found using group theory. These coordinates are an essential part of a generating function for a family of polynomials giving a representation of a n interesting associated abelian Lie algebra. 2. Dual representations
First, dual representations, particular realizations of a Lie algebra in terms of vector fields, are defined along with the corresponding .rr-matrices. Then we recall the definition of Lie Aag and how it is used to find a dual representation. This approach is carried out for the Schrodinger algebra. The main advantage is that the coefficient matrices of the vector fields can be computed directly in terms of “partial adjoint matrices” which allow for fast symbolic calculations. 2.1. Dual representations and r-matrices
For a given Lie algebra 8, with basis {[I,. . . ,&}, we have the corresponding PBW-basis for the universal enveloping algebra, namely ordered monomials <,”l . . .tyd, with ni 1 0, 1 5 i 5 d. The generating function of this basis
g(A;<) = exp(A1J1) exp(A2J2) . . * exP(AdSd)
203
are local group elements, i.e., they give a representation of the Lie group near the identity, equivalently, for ( A l , . . . ,Ad) near the origin in Cn.The local coordinates (Al, . . . ,Ad) are coordinates of the second kind. Now, left multiplication by a basis element, dualizes to an action on g as some type of generalized differential operator. However, by Lie’s theorems, we know that in fact it acts as a vector field, a first-order partial differential Thus, there is a matrix of coefficients r t ( A ) such that operator,
[it.
Similarly, multiplying from the right we have vector fields C and r-matrix
r * ( A )such that
We call these the left and right dual representations, respectively, of Q. We will see how to compute these quickly if the Lie algebra has a special structure. 2 . 2 . Commutation relations: Kirillov matriz, adjoint
representation Once a basis has been chosen, the Lie algebra is defined by commutation relations. In other words, in terms of structure constants, c $ , determined by k
It is convenient t o summarize the commutation relations in the form of a matrix, K, the Kirillov matrix. The commutation relations, Eq. (l),yield matrix entries k
linear forms in the variables {zk}. (Warning: these are purely formal and have nothing to do with the zvariables used below for representations on functions.)
204
It is usual t o interpret Eq. (1) as giving the action of a linear map ad(&) on &, i.e., k
The matrices, ti, of the linear maps ad(&), 1 5 i . representation of 6. Thus, (&)jk =
dk
2.3.
5 d , are the adjoint
Lie flags
Definition 2.1. A Lie algebra 6 has the flag property if there is an increasing chain of subalgebras .Ci
{o}
c LCt c ,& c ' . c L d
=6
(2) each of codimension one in the next. Such a flag is an increasing Lie flag. '
Note that this is a flag in the usual sense of D as a vector space, but is rather stringent as each Li must be closed under Lie brackets. Suppose that {&, . . . ,&} is a corresponding adapted basis for (2), i.e., for 1 5 i 5 d , {&, . . . ,ti} is a basis for Ci. Then, reversing the order of the basis gives a decreasing Lie flag. Every solvable, in particular every nilpotent, algebra has an increasing Lie flag. The Lie-Engel Theorem guarantees even more, namely, the existence of a flag of ideals. (See Humphreys l 3 for background and proofs.) There are Lie algebras that are not solvable yet which have the flag property. For example, s1(2), with basis { E - , E+, H } and commutation relations [E-,E+] = H , [H,E*] = fE* admits the Lie flag with adapted basis { E + , H ,E-}. Direct sums of sl(2) thus have the flag property. The main example of this paper, the Schrodinger algebra, is another example of this phenomenon. 2.4. Dual representations and flags
iz
Given an increasing flag, with adapted basis {[I,. . . ,&}, denote by the transpose of the matrix of & in the adjoint representation restricted to the subalgebra Li. I.e., columns i 1 through d of are zero'd out and then the matrix is transposed. In terms of the structure constants the entries of are
+
ti
205 with the condition that j , k 5 i, otherwise null. Dually, for a decreasing flag, we denote by the transposed matrix of the restriction of the adjoint action of & to the subalgebra Cf = span{&, . . . ,Jd}, i.e., the first i columns are ctj as are zero’d out, then the matrix transposed. So the entries of in equation (3) except with the condition j , k 2 i otherwise null.
(it
(!
We recall the main theorem from Ref. 9, p. 33 :
Theorem 2.1. For the dual representations we have: (1) Given a n increasing flag, the pi-matrix f o r the right dual is given by
(2) Given a decreasing Jag, the pi-matrix f o r the left dual is given by r t ( A ) = exp(-Al[f) exp(-A2&) ... exp(-Ad(fi)
Remark 2.1. This approach, along with a MAPLE implementation, is presented in Ref. 10. 2.5. Dual representations for the Schrodinger algebra
Order the basis as follows: cl=M,
&=K,
&=G,
&=D,
[.5=Pz,
&=Pt
We call this the standard basis for the Schrodinger algebra. With rows and columns labelled by the corresponding operators, we have the following multiplication table
Notice that this is a variant of the kirillov matrix using the original elements rather than x-variables.
206
Observe that the basis is adapted to an increasing Lie flag. To use Theorem 2.1 we need the transposed partial adjoint matrices. For example, for (4 the adjoint matrix and the transposed partial adjoint matrix are
i4
=
0000 0 0 0200 0 0 0010 0 0 0000 0 0 0000-1 0 0 0 0 0 0-2
000000 020000 .$ = 0 0 1 0 0 0 000000 000000 000000
and
It is not hard t o see that ll = $3 and & = ( 5 while (,*= (; = 0. Of course $1 = 0 as is central. Exponentiating and multiplying according t o Theorem 2.1 yields the matrix T*,coefficients of the vector fields of the right dual representation: . 1
0
0
0
0
0
1 2 As2 e(2A4)A5 eA4 A6 As A5 As2
A5 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
eA4 0 0 1 0 0 0 0
A6 A5 1 0
0 2A6 0 1
In other words, we have the realization as vector fields given by
M * = al K* =
+ e2A4a2+ A5eA4d3+ -4684 + &A585 + eA4d3+ A685 D* = 8 4 + A5d5 + 2A6b6
+A:&
G* = A5dl
P; = a, P; = a, with
a,
denoting
a -.aAi
Of particular interest here is the fact that the
“physical realization” of the Lie algebra, in space-time variables, comes naturally from the right dual representation as follows. Make the correspondences A5 + 2 and A6 + t. Then acting on functions of the form enAle-dA4f(A5, A6) we recover the form given in Ref. 6, for example. Note that the variables A2 and AJ are ignored. We do not know if they carry any physical meaning. 6112114
207 2.6. Double dual
Another way to get a representation of the Lie algebra is to use the double dual. Observe that the action on the enveloping algebra from the left is a Lie anti-homomorphism. So we dualize the vector fields by exchanging Ai H a;, in other words, by taking the algebraic version of Fourier transform.
If r* is known, then rt can be found via the exponentiated adjoint representation % ( A )= g(A;t ) ,the group element formed using the adjoint matrices. In fact, denoting transpose by T, we have the relation (%)T = r* (rt)-l (Ref. 9, p. 37). Thus we find for the Schrodinger algebra in the standard basis the left dual pi-matrix 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 2A2 A3 A3 0 A2
f A:
0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 eA4
0 0 0 0 0
A: A2A3 A2 A3eA4e2A4
For clarity in the double dual, we can use x’s as Fourier-transformed variables taking A;
a + a;, & + xi. In the resulting expressions, ai denotes -.dX;
Then we will have a representation in terms of dual vector fields in the variables {xi}. So, in rt, we replace each A; by &, then formally multiply the resulting matrix with a column vector of the variables xi, and finally, put all partials to the right, “Wick ordering”, to arrive at:
This realization has special features:
208 (1) There is an associated family of polynomials that provide a representation of the boson commutation relations, BCR. By this approach, to a given Lie algebra there is associated an abelian Lie algebra in a natural way, so that the corresponding group elements act the same on the constant function 1. This is explained in Sec. 3.3. (2) The double dual generally is suitable for constructing induced representations of the Lie algebra. See Ref. 9, pp. 40-41.
3. Splitting formula for the SchrSdinger group Now we will find the coordinates of the second kind for the standard basis. The idea is that in semidirect product form the equations for the coordinates of the second kind can be readily solved. Then those for the standard basis can be found using group theory.
3.1. Splitting lemma As a vector space with basis ((1, . . . ,&}, a typical element of G has the form X = ai&. Thus exp(X) is a group element in a neighborhood of the identity. The ai are coordinates of the first kind.
xi
If we write the group element in terms of coordinates of the second kind, we have effectively factorized or split the exponential into a product of oneparameter subgroups. Thus the lemma relating the two types of coordinates is called the splitting lemma. This means finding the change-of-coordinates mapping a + A ( a ) , with a = ( ~ 1 , .. . ,ad). For X = a&, A ( a ) is the map of coordinates determined by
xi
exp(X) = g(A;I ) = eAl(a)tl . . . eAd(a)td
Remark 3.1. This factorization is the principal object of the Wei-Norman theory. l6l1’ Let 0 denote the group law:
The “flow of the group law” z ( t ) = A ( t a ) 0 A , satisfies the equations x j = Z k( Y k x l j ( z ) ,with initial condition z(0) = A . Thus we formulate the
209 Lemma 3.1. Splitting Lemma For X = ai&, consider the factorization
Ci
exp(X) = g(A; <) = eAl(a)
Let rt denote the coeficient matrix (pi-matrix) of the left dual representation. To find the coordinate map a! -+ (Al(a!), . . . ,Ad(a!)), solve the diferential equations
with the initial conditions x l ( 0 ) = ... = ~ ( 0 =) 0 . Then Ai(a) = zi(l), for 1 5 i 5 d. As well, we can use the right dual, 7 r * ( x ) ,in the above system of differential equations. This gives the flow of the group law composing on the right, which with zero initial conditions again gives the coordinate mapping A(a) at t = 1. 3.2. Coodinates of the second kind found
For the basis { & } i = ~. .,. , 6 we have the differential equations for the coordinates of the second kind Ai
Note that even though the equations for A2, A4, A6 may be solved independently, there is still coupling with the other three variables. If instead we use the basis {qi}i=1,,.,,6with
which corresponds to the semidirect product structure, then we have the
210
system of equations for the coordinates of the second kind Bi 1 1 = a1 a3 B2 - - 0 4 B32 + - B22 2 2
+
&=&z-a4B3+&jB2
B 4 =a4+2(115B4f(Y6B42
B5
= a5
+ a6B4
& = a6 e2B5 so now the two groups of variables are completely decoupled. (We thank G. Pap for this observation.) The equations for B4, B5, B6 are for coordinates of the second kind for sl(2) which, e.g., have been computed previously (cf. Ref. 8, p. 32). And the equations for B1, B2, B3 cam be resolved without too much difficulty, noting that those for B2 and B3 are linear. Let us set d2 = Pt - P 4 P 6 , r = (tanhS)/b, and B1
= P1+
sinh 6 - 6 0 P2 263
P2 P3 P 4 P5
CT
= (1 - sech6)/J2. Then
1
+ 2 B2B3
P3 P5 P 6
Now to fin the splitting formula for the
we equae
21 1
In other words,
For the group element, we have the ordered products
Basically, we want to shift P, to the right, from position 3 to position 5. From the adjoint action espm Ke-8Px = K sG (s2/2)M we have
+ +
,sP, et K = et K estG
es2tM/2,spa
D] = Pz,we have the dilation effect And from [Pz, esPaetD = etD exp (set P,) The following relations result:
So substituting and some rearrangements yields Theorem 3.1. Let 62 = as - ~ 2 ~ 1 6T , = (tanh6)/6, and LT = (1 - sech 6)/62. For the basis (1 = M , (2 = K , (3 = G , t 4 = D , (5 =
212
P, , & = Pi, the coordinates of the second kind have the form
3.3. Basic polynomials and quantum observables Taking the results of the above theorem, we can form the generating function
with multi-indices n = (nl,.. . ,n6) in the expansion. The quantities y,(x) are “basic polynomials” or “canonical basis polynomials” since they yield a representation of the Heisenberg algebra, or BCR, boson commutation relations (Ref. 9, pp. 19-20. See also Ref. 5 for various points of view). The formalism goes like this. We have variables {xi} and their correspondd Acting on smooth functions, ing partial derivative operators Di = -. axi they satisfy the BCR: [ D j , X i ]= 6ijI [Dj, Di] = 0, [ X j , X i ] = 0, where Xi denotes the operator of multiplication by xir and I is the identity operator. Write z = (21,.. . zd) and D = (01,. .. ,Dd). Now, for any function V = (Vl(z),.. . ,Vd(z))holomorphic in a neighborhood of the origin in C d , we have a representation of the BCR by setting Vj = V , ( D ) and U, = C k x k W k i ( D ) where W is the inverse Jacobian, satisfying
213
C
av, wkj = 6ij.
They satisfy the BCR
k
[vj,K] = SijI,
[vj,K] = 0,
[ y j , y z ]= 0
Of importance is that the variables Y , commute - they form a n abelian Lie algebra - and satisfy
i
k
where U is the inverse of V in the sense of functional composition: V ( V ( z )= ) z in a neighborhood of the origin. Now we use Theorem 3.4 of Ref. 7 to the effect that the exponential of the double dual acting on the constant function 1 is e x p (C i ziAi). That is,
i
k
If we interpret A(a) as V(w), we see that the yn are the basis for a representation of the BCR with raising operators Y , and lowering operators vj according t o the correspondences z with A and V with a. Note that the yi can be found explicitly from the inverse Jacobian of the map A + a, equivalently from the Jacobian of the map a + A expressed in terms of the variables A.
+ +
+
As observed in Ref. 11, the elements XI = P t D K and X2 = G P, commute and, in fact, a Hilbert space can be constructed on which they act as selfadjoint operators. In other words, they provide quantum observables. Thus, let us specialize the coefficients accordingly: a1 = 0,122 = a4 = a6 = z1 and a3 = a5 = 2 2 . For the double dual representation, we thus have
To use Theorem 3.1, note that 6 = 0. Thus, T reduces to 1 and We get
0
to 1/2.
214
These yield
(Compare this with Ref. 11, Appendix, Eq. A.2 .) The point is that now we have the whole context available. We remark two features: (1) The symmetry properties of the special polynomials, mixed Hermite and Laguerre polynomials in this case, are apparent from the contextual Lie apparatus. (2) The basis states for the observables, the special polynomials noted in #1, are seen indeed as specializations of general basis states, “basic polynomials”, of all six variables corresponding to the basis of the Lie algebra.
The above properties hold in general for any Lie algebra and, particularly, for observables built by specialization from basis elements of a Lie algebra (e.g., Ref. 4). This turns out to explain the results in Ref. 8 where orthogonal polynomials for the classical “Bernoulli-type” probability distributions are constructed as basis states for Lie algebras s1(2), Heisenberg algebra, and the oscillator algebra. The present theory thus gives a setting for general Lie algebras.
215
References 1. L. Accardi, U. Franz and M. Skeide, Renormalized squares of white noise and non-gaussian noises as LBvy processes on real Lie algebras, Comm. Math. Phys. 228, no. 1, 123-150 (2002). 2. A.O. Barut and R. Qczka, Theory of group representations and applications, 2nd ed., PWN, Warszawa, 1980. 3. A.O. Barut A 0 and B.-W. Xu, Conformal covariance and the probability interpretation of wave equations, Phys. Lett. 82A,5, 218-220 (1981). 4. S. Berceanu and A. Gheorghe, On equations of motion on compact Hermitian symmetric spaces J. Math Phys. 33,3, 998-1007 (1992). 5. A. Di Bucchianico, Probabilistic and analytical aspects of the umbra1 calculus, CWI tract, 119, Amsterdam, 1997. 6. V.K. Dobrev, H.D. Doebner and Ch. Mrugalla, Lowest weight representations
7.
8. 9.
10.
of the Schrodinger algebra and generalized heat/Schrodinger equations, Rep. Math. Phys. 39,2, 201-218 (1997). Ph. Feinsilver and R. Schott, Vector fields and their duals, Adv. in Math. 149,2, 182-192 (2000). Ph. Feinsilver and R. Schott, Algebraic structures and operator calculus, v. 1, Representations and probability theory, Kluwer Academic Press, 1993. Ph. Feinsilver and R. Schott, Algebraic structures and operator calculus, v. 3, Representations of Lie groups, Kluwer Academic Press, 1996. Ph. Feinsilver and R. Schott, Symbolic computation of Appell systems on the Schrodinger algebra, Proceedings of RIMS Symposium on Algebraic Systems, Languages and Computation, Kyoto 2000, Ed. M. It8, RIMS 1166, 59-66
(2000). 11. Ph. Feinsilver, J. Kocik and R. Schott, Berezin quantization of the Schrodinger algebra, IDAQP 6,1, 57-71 (2003). 12. C.R. Hagen, Scale and conformal transformations in Galilean-covariant field theory, Phys. Rev. D5,2, 377-388 (1972). 13. J. Humphreys, Introduction to Lie algebras and representation theory, Graduate Texts in Mathematics 9, Springer-Verlag, 1980. 14. U. Niederer, The maximal kinematical invariance group of the free Schrodinger equation, Helv. Phys. Acta 45,802-810 (1972/73). 15. G. Pap, Fourier transform of symmetric Gauss measures on the Heisenberg group. Semigroup Fomm 64,130-158 (2002). 16. J. Wei and E. Norman, On global representation of the solutions of linear differential equations as a product of exponentials, Proc. A.M.S. 15, 327334 (1964). 17. J. Wei and E. Norman, Lie algebraic solution of linear differential equations, J. Math. Phys. 4, 575-581 (1963).
HARMONIC ANALYSIS ON NON-AMENABLE COXETER GROUPS
GEROFENDLER Gero Fendler Finstertal 16 0-69514 Laudenbach Germany
1. Introduction In this note we present certain geometric aspects of Coxeter groups, which lead to results on the regular representation of Coxeter groups. We are merely interested in non-amenable Coxeter groups and shall briefly discuss: (1) weak amenability of the Coxeter group (2) a Haagerup inequality, (3) simplicity of the regular C*-algebra.
This note is a short report on results obtained in Refs. 7 and 8 and for complete proofs we refer to these papers. 2. Coxeter groups
A Coxeter group (G,S) is a group G with a set of generators S and a presentation: s2=e,
(st)m(8gt) =e,
SES s , t E S, s
#t
where m(s,t) E { 2,3 ,4 ,. . .,oo} is symmetric: m ( s , t ) = m ( t ,s),
Examples
216
s,t E S.
217
(1) Reflection Groups Assume that V is a finite dimensional real vector space endowed with a scalar product (., .) : V x V R. For a E V \ (0) denote s, : V 3 V the reflection defined by:
+
It stabilises pointwise the hyperplane H , = {r) E V : (a,?) = 0) and inverts a: s,(a) = -a. A finite group generated by reflections is known to be a Coxeter group. (2) Dihedral Groups Now let V = R2 be the usual euclidian plane, 0 = 2,where m E {2,3,4,. . .}.
For m as above the reflections s, and sp generate a finite group of order 2m. If 0 is not a rational multiple of T , then s, and sp generate the infinite dihedral group.
Ha
(3) Symmetric Groups On V = R" the symmetric group S, acts by permuting the coordinates. It is generated by the transpositions Ti=(iri+1)
,
l
Denoting €1,. . . ,en the standard basis Ti(Ei
- E i + l ) = E i + l - ei
defines a reflection which stabilises Hi = {C; : [ I ( e i - ei+l)} pointwise. 3. Geometric Representation
Let (G,S) be a Coxeter group. We assume #S < 00 and on the finite dimensional real vector space V = @,gsRaswith basis {a,: s E S } we
218
define a bilinear form B : V x V
B (as,at)=
{
+ R by 1 if s = t
if s # t , m(s,t ) < 00 -1 if m(s,t)= 00.
- cos
(1)
For each s E S we define a reflection on V by
a,< = t - 2 B ( a s , J ) a s
,
< E v.
(2)
Then there hold true: 0
0
0
V = Ra, @ H,, where H , = { q E V : B(a,,q) = 0) is stabilised pointwise by us and usas= -as. s I+ (T, extends multiplicatively to a representation u : G + Gl(V) of the Coxeter group. This representation is faithful and its image is a discrete subgroup of Gl(V).
Remarks: B is strictly positive definite if and only if G is finite. B is positive semidefinite, with non-trivial kernel, if and only if G is a semi-direct product of an additive group of translations and a finite Coxeter group acting on the former.The group is called an affine Coxeter group in this case. B is strictly indefinite if and only if G is of exponential growth (equivalently: non-amenable) . 4. Adjoint Representation We dualise the representation
and shall merely work with Let for each s E S:
(T
:G
+ Gl(V) as usual by
IT* instead
2, = {f E
of
(T,
v* : f ( a , ) = O),
A, = {f E V* : f(cr,)
> 0).
Denote
C = ngEG gA, - the fundamental chamber D=C\{O}and U =U
g E g ~D -
the Tit’s cone :
219 o
C is a simplicia1 cone, its faces are the sets 2, n D.
o
U is a convex cone, D is a fundamental domain for the action of G on it.
o
We define a family of hyperplanes in V * :
31 = UgEG gZ8. Then, o a closed line segment [u,c]
cU
between points u , c E U meets only
finitely many members of 3c. o Moreover, for any c E C: where l(g) = inf{k : g = s1 . . . sk, si E S} denotes the usual length with respect t o the generating set S. For the readers convenience we state and give a proof of the following theorem due to Bozejko6.
Theorem 4.1. For each 0 5 r 5 1 the f i n c t i o n g I+ nite.
is positive defi-
Proof: One can write
ZEN
where c E C is arbitrary and
Xh
is the characteristic function of
N~ = { Z E 31 : [ h c , ~n]z # S}. Hence 1(.) is a negative definite and, by a theorem of Schoenberg, rl(.)a positive definite function (for 0 5 r 5 1).
5. A Product of Trees Now, by o*,the Coxeter group G may be considered as a discrete subgroup of Gl(V), where dim(V) = #S < 00. Hence there exists, e.g. by Selberg's Lemma, a torsion free normal subgroup J? of finite index in G. Next we apply a lemma due to Jaffe and Millson13.
Lemma 5.1. For g,g' E
r
and Z E 3c either g Z U g'Z = 0 or g Z = g'Z.
220
We may decompose %! into different r-orbits
where Xi = {yZi : y E Zi} for some Zi E 74. For each i E { 1, . .,A} we define a graph 71 with vertices the connected components of U \ UzExiZ and edges the hyperplanes Z E Xi. An edge -Z E E(7;) connects the vertices CO, C1 E V ( 5 )if, as subsets of U ,ConC1 C 2. The Lemma of Jaffe and Millson shows that each X, i E (1,. . ., A } is a tree. Moreover I' acts on each tree by simplicia1 automorphisms and freely on the product
.
6 = 71 x . . . x rn. A tree may be seen as a chamber system Edges
t)Chambers
Vertices c--)Facets. The above product of chamber systems is a building of type A1 x . . . x 21. Its chambers are A-tuples of edges: ( e l , . . , e n ) , ei E E(X) the facets of the above chamber are ( e l , . .. , e j - I , u j , e j + l , . . . ,e n ) , wj E V ( X ) ,j = 1 , . .., A . We obtain an embedding of the Coxeter group into the building:
.
Vl
i ' L g'---,gc
:
VEV(6).
L/' VA
This is even a metric embedding of the Cayley-graph into the 1-skeleton of the building, where the metric on 6 is obtained from the natural metrics on the trees:
+...+ dn(un,~n),
d(u,v) = & ( w , v I )
where v = (211,. . . ,vA), u = ( ~ 1 ., .., U A )E V ( 6 ) . Remark: i) r acts freely on the vertices of 9. ii) No non-trivial subgroup of r has a bounded orbit.
22 1
6. Weak Amenability
For functions f , h : G
+ C their convolution is defined by: f *MY) =
c
f(z)h(z-ly).
ZEG
For summable f : G -b C we denote X ( f ) : Z2(G) + Z2(G) the associated convolution operator X ( f ) h = f * h. The regular (or reduced) C*-algebra C,*(G) is the just the operator norm closure of { X ( f ) : f E Z1(G)}. Its second commutant, the regular von Neumann algebra VN,(G), has a predual identified with the Fourier algebra A(G) = {cp = k * h : k , h E Z2(G)}. The duality is given by
< X(f), cp >=< X ( f ) h ,k >=
c
f(z)cp(z).
ZEG
With respect to pointwise multiplication of functions A(G) is a Banach algebra. A bounded function m E Z"(G), which with respect to pointwise multiplication multiplies A(G) into itself, is called a multiplier of the Fourier algebra. If the operator, dual to this multiplication, acts completely bounded on the regular von Neumann algebra, then the function m is called a completely bounded multiplier of A(G). By 11 m llcb we denote its completely bounded norm.
Definition 6.1. The group G is called weakly amenable if there exist, a constant c > 0 and a net ( m i ) i G lc A(G) such that micp
+ cp
Vcp E A(G) and IImi llcb I c V i E I.
Remarks: i) Any amenable group is weakly amenable, since for an amenable group A(G) has a bounded approximate identity. ii) The free group on two generators is weakly amenable. iii) In C*-algebraic terms there are the following equivalences respectively implications:
A discrete group G is amenable if and only if C,*(G)is nuclear. The group G is weakly amenable if and only if C,*(G) has the completely bounded approximation property.
If G is weakly amenable then C,*(G) is exact. Theorem 6.1. A finitely generated Coxeter group is weakly amenable.
222
We shall only sketch the proof of the theorem and refer the reader to7 for details. is positive definite. Hence there For 0 < T < 1 the function cpr(g) = exists a unitary representation r,.of G on a Hilbert space H , such that: V r ( g ) =< r r ( g ) t , t
>
for Some
E Hr.
Hence the functions cp, are completely bounded multipliers of A(G) with IIcp, llca = cpr(e) = 1. For T -+ 1 we have that p,t+!J-+ t+!J for all $J E A(G) but for T close to 1 the functions do not belong to A(G). The point of the proof is to cut them off in a proper way to control the complete bounded norm of the cut offs. From these one can then select a net in A(G) which fulfils the conditions of the definition. For z E C with ( z ( < 1 define pz(g) = ~ ' ( 9 ) . As a consequence of the tree structure of the graphs 7; the representations r, can be modified to yield non-unitary but uniformly bounded representations rz on H,, where T = Rez is the real part of z , with
For N E N let FN(eit) = C l k l l N ( l- &)eikt define t+!JN,r=
1
2a
denote the Fejer kernel and
FN(eit)cpreit dt
E A(G).
It is not hard to see that from these functions the net required in the definition of weak amenability can be chosen. 7. Haagerup Inequality In 1979 Haagerupg proved for the free group on two generators remarkable inequality:
II f * h 112 I (n+ 1111f llzll h 112,
IF2
the
h E Z2(F2),
whenever suppf c {u : l(u) = n}. Since then, inequalities of this kind have been proved for Gromov hyperbolic groups by Jolissaint12and de la Harpell. Their stability under free products and group extensions have been studied by Jolissaint. Let (G, S) be a group with a finite set of generators and associated lengthfunction 10.
223
Definition 7.1. We say that (G, S) satisfies a a Haagerup inequality whenever there exist C > 0, IC > 0 such that for all f with supp f c {u : 1(u) = n}:
I1 f * h 112 < C ( n+ 1)“11f llzll h 112,
h E Z2(G).
(3)
There are equivalent: o G satisfies a Haagerup inequality o There exist CI> O , I C ~> 0 such that for all finitely supported
f :G +
C:
>0
, >~ 0 such that for all finitely supported nonnegative symmetric f : G + R+:
o There exist C2
Here f (2k) denotes the 2k-th convolution power of f ,further one may suppose in the last statement that 11 f 111 1. That is, f is a symmetric probability measure on G and f(2k)(e)is the probability that the random walk with transition probabilities p(g, h) = f(g-lh), starting at e, will return to the identity in 2k steps.
<
Theorem 7.1. A Coxeter group satisfies a Haagerup inequality. About the proof: Generalising a theorem of Rammage, Robertson and Stegerl6 , a finitely generated group acting freely on an A, x . . . x A,building satisfies a Haagerup inequality. Since G / r in the extension 1 + l? + G + G/I’ + 1 is finite, a result of Jolissaint12 implies the assertion. Remark: Taking #S = 4 and m(s,s’) = 3 if s # s’, we obtain an example, which, by computations of Bestvina4 has virtual cohomological dimension two. Hence, here I? can not act freely on a single tree. This group is not Gromov hyperbolic either. Conjecture: The best possible value of the constant IC in (3) is qvcd(G). 8. Simplicity of the regular C*-algebra
If G is a discrete group then C:(G), the operator norm closure of {X(f) : f E Z1(G)}, is a C*- algebra with a canonical trace
224 TG : c,*(G)
+ c,
given by T G ( ~ = ) 0 if y # e and TG(e) = 1. If G is amenable, or more generally contains an amenable Go a G, Go # {e}, then trivG 4 XG, resp. Ind(trivG,) 4 XG, and the kernel of those representations is a non-trivial ideal. In contrast to this, a C*-algebra is called simple if it contains no non-trivial two-sided ideal. Examples of groups with simple reduced C*-algebra are necessarily non-amenable: (1) free group on TI 2 2 generators - Powers15, (2) appropriate free products - Paschke, Salinas14, (3) fichsian groups - Akemad , (4) torsion-free Gromov hyperbolic - Gromov, de la Harpel', ( 5 ) Zariski-dense subgroups of connected real semisimple Lie groups without compact factors - Bekka, Cowling, de la Harpe2.
Now consider conjugacy classes of elements:
C(Y) = {gw-l
:9
E GI.
Then, Gf = {y : #C(y) < 0 0 ) a G is amenable, hence for the simplicity of C,*(G) it is necessary that G is icc, i.e. #C(y) = 00 if y # e . Clearly, if G is a finite or S n e Coxeter group then G is amenable, hence C;(G) not simple. Hence we shall assume that the canonical bilinear form B defined in (1) is indefinite, furthermore we assume that it is non-degenerate. To deal with the non reducible case we suppose that the Coxeter group (G,S) is indecomposable. i.e. for all S1,S2 C S there are s1 E S1 and s2 E S 2 such that s1, s2 do not commute. De la HarpelO has shown that under these conditions the restriction of the canonical representation olr : r + Gl(V) remains irreducible whenever I'c G is a subgroup of finite index. It can be shown then, that this is true also for the complexification o @ Id : G + Gl(V @ C). Theorem 8.1. With the above conditions G is an icc-group.
VN,(G) a factor.
Proof: Let e # w E G and 2, be its centraliser. Then
#C(w) < co
* (G : 2,) < * o(w)= Id by irreducibility of olz, * w = e by faithfulness of o. 00
Hence
225
Now G is icc, then a theorem of Bekka and de la Harpe3 shows that CJ(G) is simple, with unique trace if and only if this holds true for C,*(I'),where I' is a torsion free, normal, finite index subgroup as in section 5. We shall concentrate on I?. Taking the trees . . , 7 as ~in that section we consider the action of I' on each of the trees. Bass-Serre theory shows:
x,.
Lemma 8.1. I' contains solvable subgroups if one of the trees has only vertices of degree at most two. On the other hand the theorem of Lie-Kolcbin allows to prove:
Lemma 8.2. rcontains n o non-trivial solvable subgroup. Hence all trees have vertices of degree at least three. A discussion of the action of r on the boundary of the trees yields:
Lemma 8.3. Assume h E I' and let F c C(h) be finite then there is v E I? such that < k,v >= Z * Z for all k E F . Then it is known, see Ref. 2, that there exists a C k E F: j
> 0 such that
for all
j
The above arguments show that I? is an ultraweak Powers group as considered by Boca and Nitica5. As a consequence C* (I?) is a simple C*-algebra, and as already mentioned we infer:
Theorem 8.2. Let (G,S) be a indecomposable Coxeter group, such that the canonical bilinear form is indefinite but non-degenerate, then C,*(G)is simple with unique trace. References 1. C. Akemann. Operator algebras associated to Fuchsian groups. Houston J. Math., 7:295-301, 1981. 2. M. Bekka, M. Cowling, and P. de la Harpe. Some groups whose reduced C*-algebra is simple. Publ. Math., Inst. Hautes Etud. Sci.,80:117-134, 1995. 3. M. B. Bekka and P. de la Harpe. Groups with simple reduced C*-algebras. EXP.Math., 18:215-230, 2000. 4. M. Bestvina. The virtual cohonolocical dimension of Coxeter groups. In Geometric Group Theory I, Cambridge, 1993. Cambridge Univ. Press. 5. F. Boca and V. Nitica. Combinatorial properties of groups and simple C*algebras with a unique trace. J. Operator theory, 20:183-196, 1988.
226 6. M. Bozejko. Positive and negative definite kernels on groups. Lectures at the University of Heidelberg, 1987. 7. G. Fender. Weak amenability of Coxeter groups. arXiv:math.GR/0203052, 2000. 8. G. Fender. Simplicity of the reduced C*-algebra of certain Coxeter groups. Ill. J. Math., 47(3), 2003. 9. U. Haagerup. An example of a non-nuclear C*-algebra which has the metric approximation property. Invent. Math., 50279-293, 1979. 10. P. d. 1. Harpe. Groupes de Coxeter infinis non atFines. Exp. Math., 5:91-96, 1987. 11. P. d. 1. Harpe. Sur les alghbres d’un groupe hyperbolique. C. R. Acad. Sci. (Paris) Serie I, 307:771- -774, 1988. 12. P. Jolissaint. Rapidly decreasing functions in reduced C*-algebras. !?+am. Amer. Math. SOC.,317:145-157, 1990. 13. J . J. Millson. On the first Betti number of a constant negatively curved manifold. Ann. of Math., 104235-247, 1976. 14. W. Paschke and N. Salinas. C*-algebras associated with free products of groups. Pacific J . Math., 82:211-221, 1979. 15. Powers, R. T. Simplicity of the C*-algebra associated with the free group on two generators. Duke Math. J., 42:151-156, 1975. 16. J. Ramagge, G. Robertson, and T. Steger. A Haagerup inequality for A1 xA1 and A2 buldings. Geometric And finctional Analysis, 8:702-731, 1998.
A LIMIT THEOREM FOR CONDITIONALLY INDEPENDENT BEAM SPLITTINGS
K.H. FICHTNERYOLKMAR LIEBSCHER~MASANORI OHYA
1. Introduction
Consider a Boson Fock space r ( L 2 ( G p, ) ) . Then the coherent state $f to a wave function f describes a system of particles in the same one-particle state f/ llfll in the space G. For testing whether two coherent states 4f and $f‘ with l l f l l = Ilf’ll (i.e., the mean number of particles is equal) belong to the same one-particle state or f If’, one could use the following procedure. One applies a conventional beam splitter which transforms the state $f @ $f‘ into $(f-f’)/JZ @ $(f+f‘)/J;i. If f = f ‘ the state 4(f-f’)/JZ is the vacuum $O. Thus measurement using the projection onto the vacuum function in Fock space yields a distribution concentrated on 61. If f I f’,the same measurement has under the state $(f-f’)lJZ the distribution e-llf1126, (1 - e - ~ ~ f ~ ~ 2For ) 6 high ~ . numbers of particles, i.e. llf1I2 = llf’1I2 >> 1, we can therefore distinguish between the two situations with high confidence. The basic idea of this procedure was applied to quantum teleportation [11,12] as well as in the modelling of brain recognition processes, see [lo]. But, especially in the latter case, the condition l l f l l = Ilfll‘ is not realistic because the density of the state representing the input-information differs from the individual density of excited neurons in the brain. Therefore there is need for a preprocessing step which makes the mean number of particle of both states equal to each other. Standard quasifree transition operators
+
* Friedrich-Schiller-Universitat, fakultat fur mathematik und informatik, institut fur angewandte mathematik, D-07743 Jena (Germany) t GSF -National research centre for environment and health, institute for biomathematics and biometry, ingolstadter landstr. 1, D-85758 Neuherberg, Germany, emai1:liebscherQgsf.de *department of information sciences, science university of Tokyo, Noda city, Chiba 2788510, Japan. e-mail: ohyaQis.noda.sut .ac. j p
227
228
are not sufficient for this purpose since then Q(q5f) = q5Tf+h for a linear operator T and some h. In the present paper, we present a limiting procedure based on conditionally independent beam splittings [8],which is a weak generalisation of conventinal beam splittings which achieves the goal of transforming all high mean intensity f to the same lower intensity f' for wave functions f which are constant. The consideration of locally normal states ensures that the mean particle number may be 00 as a prerequisite for limit theorems. A generalisation of the limit theorem to non-constant f is straight forward but tedious and left for the future. 2. Basics
First we introduce Boson Fock spaces in the language of counting measures. This seems to be a convenient description of these spaces as far as particle exchange mechanisms, like introduced in [8] and used for the main result of this paper, are concerned. For details on this representation of Fock spaces we refer t o [6,7,13],see also [18,19,20,21,22]. Let G be an arbitrary complete separable metric space and 6 its aalgebra of Bore1 sets. Further, let p be a locally finite diffuse measure on [G,631,i.e. p ( K ) < 00 for bounded K E 6 and ~((2))= 0 for all singletons x E G. Especially we can apply our results in the standard setting G = Rd and p = Cd is Lebesgue measure. By M we denote the set of all finite integer-valued measures on [G,651, i.e. M is the set of finite counting measures. Since each cp E M can be . - . 6,, for some n E N and xj E G written in the form cp = 6,, (where 6, is the Dirac measure in x) the elements of M code the finite point configurations in G. We equip M with its canonical a-field !TI - the smallest a-field containing all sets of the form {'p E M : cp(K) = n},K E 6 , n E N. On [ M ,!TI] we introduce the exponential measure F" [2] by setting
+
+
Hereby, o is the empty configuration in M , i.e. o(G) = 0. We call M := L 2 ( M ,9X,FP) symmetric Fock space over G, a similar definition of the Fock space one can find e.g. in [Zl]. For a function g : G C we introduce the exponential vector qg : M C through
-
-
229
If G is not bounded one can introduce a quasilocal algebra which allows to model infinite Boson systems. For any measurable K E 6 there is the Hilbert space M K = L 2 ( M ~ , M n M K , F ~ ~ M where K ) MK = {'p E M : p(Kc) = O}. It is well-known that M 2 M K 8 MKc such that $g 2 $gx, 8 qgXKc. This factorisation allows t o define local algebras dK C ( M K )8 1 [ ~ ,for~ bounded K as well as the quasilocal C*-algebra A as the uniform closure of the union of all local algebras. In this work, we are only interested in special states on A, the coherent ones. The space Lt,(G, p ) of locally square integrable functions consists of all p-equivalence classes of measurable functions g such that lK /gI2dp < 00 for bounded K. For g E L t c ( G , p ) the coherent state $9 is the locally normal state given by
$ g ( A )= e-11g112 ($g,A$g),
( A E dK,K E 6, bounded ).
(3) The coherent state $ = 4° is the vacuum state. Note that the so-called position distribution Q,pwill be a Poisson point process, see [5].
-
We follow [8] for the definition of exchange operators. For a map C we define an operator Uv by
Y
:
M4
uv$('pl, V2) =
v(7l
A 'p1771 A q 2 7 7 2 A ( P I 7 7 2 A (P2)$(71 9 7 2 ) (4)
7 1 +72=991+(P2
using the natural lattice structure of M related to the ordering 'p1 5 'p2 ++ 'pl(B) 5 p2(B)VB E f3. Especially, we are interested in conditionally independent beam splitting derived as & from kernels b
-
b ( p l , p27 9 3 , (P4) = ~bl(.,(~)((Pl)~b,(.,~)((P2)~b~(.,~)((P3)$b~(~,(~)((P4)
+ +
(5)
where we use the convention cp = cp1+ p2 cp3 cp4 and bi : G x M C, i = 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 . Conventional beam splittings correspond to bi depending on the first argument only or, typically, even constant bi [S]. We want to apply such operators for various regions A. So suppose we have functions Pi : [0,00) HC such that
From [8] we derive easily
Lemma 2.1.
is unitary if
fulfuil
230 Therefore, we can use U ~ to A transform states (on d A @ d A ) if (7) is fulfilled. Convergence of states we understand as convergence of the local states in norm, i.e. w, t-+ w iff n+w
II(wn)K
- WKII
( K E 6,bounded ).
,two,
This topology is metrizable if we restrict to so-called locally normal states like the coherent ones [l]. A + G denotes the limit over the net of bounded Bore1 sets, i.e. convergence for each monotously increasing sequence (An)nENsuch that for all bounded K E 6 there is n E N with A, 2 K . 3. The Results
We define for all bounded A E 6 a channel (conditionally independent exchange) Q ~ , Aon C(M @ M ) by ) Q~,A(AA@AAc) = (U~AAAU*A)@AAC,( AA E C ( M A @ M A ) , A AECC(MAC@MAC)
where bA is given through ( 6 ) and Pi fulfils (7). For z E C , denote the coherent state @Xc briefly by qY.
Theorem 3.1. Suppose Pi, i = 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 fulfil(7) and z E C is such that all Pi are continuously differentiable in a neighbourhood of 1 ~ 1 ' . Then
with
d
m
Example 3.1. If P1(r) = for some a > 0, we find that the first component of all states limb+G Qi,A(qY @ $'), 1z1' > a, is a coherent state with fixed mean intensity Ic11' = a. If further PZ = this holds for the second component as well. This is the result of interest mentioned in the introduction. Clearly, we can apply the above theorem with this P unless 1z1' = a. The next results study the limiting behaviour of the left hand side in (8) for this and similar situations. First, we weaken the continuity condition and get a mixing effect.
d
m
,
Theorem 3.2. Suppose z E R and 6 > 0 are such that all Pi have left and right limits as r --+ 1z1' and
231 0
in the internal (1zI2- 6, 1zI2],the functions Pt,
0
are continuously differentiable. in the interval [ ! . I 2 , 1zI2 6 ) , the functions P;,
+
are continuously differentiable. Then
with
czf. = P2(1.I2 f0 ) z This is still not sufficient for Pl(r) = d m , as /32 is not differentiable at points r where IP1 ( r )I = 1 and P1 is differentiable with ( r f 0) In these points I/32(r = O(&). Thus we need also the following
+I)&
# 0.
Theorem 3.3. Let z E R and /3 be such that
IPl(IZl",l
O
=1
/3 is continuous in a neighbourhood of (tl2 is differentiable in a left and a right neighbourhood (with limits of the derivative in lz12) and 8 z ( 1 4 2 + E ) has left and right limits in 0. E H 6
Then, with <1,2 given by (9), lim Q ; , ~ ( @8 4') =
A+CC
@ q+.
4. Proofs
Proof. (of Lemma 2.1) In [8] it was proven that if b is given by (5) and all bi are bounded then Ub is unitary if and only if for F-a.a. 'p E M for all x E SUPPCP
232 The
2.f
part of this result translates directly into (7) if (6) is applied.
Proof. (of Theorem 3.1) Let K be fixed, then A -, G shows that A 3 K eventually and C(A\K) -+ 00. We will set to = C(K)and t = C(A\K) 4 00. We have t o compute the kernel of Q Z , , ( V @ + ' ) K U K . First we determine the kernel p of Q>,,(@ @ ~ O ) A , A . By definition, for any f E L2(G, v),
W$f c2 $O)((Pl,
c
-
(P2)
$01 ( 7 1 A ( P l ) $ b (71 A (P2)$03 ( 7 2 A (Pl)$fk(72 A (P2)$f(71)$0(72)
71+72=v1+v2
- $01 (v1+v2) ((P1)%2(v1+p2) ((P2)$f((P1 - ~01(v1+vz)f((P1)~02(vpl+vz)f((P2).
+ Cp2)
This yields p ( ' ~ 1 (, ~ 2( , ~ 3( , ~ 4 = ) e-llzxAAlla$p(
vi+v2)zxA((~1)$ba(vi+vz)zxA((~2)
$b: (v3++'4)zXA ((P3)$bt(p3+v4)zX~ (p4)
where XA denotes the indicator function of the set A. We find that the state G&(V @ + O ) K has again property ( 7 1 ) [17,15],i.e. its kernel po depends only on particle numbers: pO((p1, ( ~ 2( ,p 3 , p 4 )
c
=
e-lz12totk+k'z'+l' ck,kt,Z,l' t
k,k',l ,I'EN
(l(Pll)X{k'})( ~ ' P 2 ~ ) x { Z } ) ( I ~ 3 ~ (1941) )x{l~}) where [(PI = ( P ( K )We . find from (for a precise definition of this formula in the general case see 114,161) x{k})
po((Pli(P2,(P3,(P4)
= 1~~\,(d[@l,d2])p((P1+dl,lpz+d2,(P3+@1,(P~+@2)
that (denoting @(k) = & ( k / C ( A ) ) ) t
Ck,kr,l,l'
=
-1zIZt
Fi\K(d[+l,@21) k+lGlI
+ 1+11+
1@21)
P,^@ + k'
k'+ Ik2 I
+ 1@11+ 1@21) + k' + l@l)+ J @ 2 J ) Z + v 3 ; ( 1 + 1' + 1@11 + 1@21)"+Id1 1 I421@1+82I
P:'@ + k' P:'(k
1
Now is it enough t o prove convergence of ck,k!,l,l, as t + 00 to a suitable limit. The reason is the following lemma which can be found in [3]. Lemma 4.1. If w,, w are normal states on B(3-1) such that for a total set
T23-1 wn(P+,+)n~mw(P+,+~)i ( 1cI,1cI' E T )
(10)
233
then ( w , ) , ~ ~ converges an n o r m t o w . We apply this lemma with the total set consisting of vector being in the span of {&xK : z E C} resp. orthogonal to it. For the orthogonal ones, on both sides (10) there is zero, for the others we use convergence of c : , k , , l , / , We find from definition of F and Pi for k,k‘, 1,l‘
We see for random variables X t , X t ck,k’,l,ll
~
1
~
that 1 2
~
~
=
(P(
+ty;xt
) , P ( l +l’+X,))X’
t
+ to
Additionally, we know X t / t +%(zI2. Upto here only the distribution t-w matters, but we can assume for convenience (due to the Skorohod r e p resentation Theorem, cf. e.g. [4]), that the convergence is actually almost surely on some artificial probability space. Due to (7) we find pz(r)pz(r’)( 5 1, such that we can apply the dominated convergence theorem. We want to find the limit by Taylor expansion. First, let p be one of Pi and apply the expansion
I~/?I(T’) +
P(2
+
E)
= P(2)
+
EP‘(Z)
+
O(E)
(11)
234 in an interval around \z(’ leading to
-
!l?Zpi(r)p:(r)= 0. This leads
Differentiating the first line in (7) yields to
k + k’ + X ” , $ ( P ( t+to
=1
+ 1’ + X t ) ) t
+to
+ o(t-1)
and thus
k+k’+Xt l+l’+Xt )) (@( t to ),p( t +to
+
xt =1
+ o ( X t / t ) = 1 + o(1).
This Shows
Since the left hand side gives the correct matrix element for (q5f11(lz12)z q5flz(lz12)z) K this completes the proof.
@
Proof. (of Theorem 3.2) We apply the same method, but derive the limit of c ; , ~ , , ~differently. ,~, It holds by the central limit theorem even
for some random variable Y and again we assume almost sure convergence on some artificial probability space. Rewriting
xt = ( Z l 2 t + (21JiY + o ( J i ) ,
(t
--+
00
)
we derive that
P ( X t / t > 1z12 eventually ) = 1/2 = lim P ( X t / t < 1z12 eventually t+m
1.
On both sets we may apply the above scheme to derive the result. Proof. (of Theorem 3.3) Here it is crucial to estimate for some 0 E C P2(12I2
+ E ) = m +4&)
(12)
235 what leads to (separately on {Y
since consideration of leads to
> 0)
and {Y
< 0))
1 for small
References 1. 0. Bratteli and D. Robinson Operator Algebras and Quantum Statistical Mechanics I 2nd edition Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York 1987 2. D. Carter and P. Prenter Exponential spaces and counting processes Z. Wahrscheinlichkeitstheor. Verw. Geb. 21:l-19 1972 3. E. Davies Quantum Theory of Open Systems Academic Press New York 1976 4. S. N. Ethier and T. G. Kurtz Markov processes. Characterization and convergence. Wiley Series in Probability and Mathematical Statistics John Wiley & Sons New York etc. 1986 5. K.-H. Fichtner and W. Freudenberg Point processes and the position distribution of infinite boson systems J . Stat. Phys. 47:959-978 1987 6. K.-H. Fichtner and W. Freudenberg Characterization of states of infinite boson systems I. On the construction of states of boson systems Commun. Math. Phys. 137:315 - 357 1991 7. K.-H. Fichtner and W. Freudenberg Remarks on stochastic calculus on the Fock space In L. Accardi, editor, Quantum Probability and Related Topics VII World Scientific Publishing Co. Singapore, New Jersey, London, Hong Kong 1991 pages 305 - 323 8. K.-H. Fichtner, W. Freudenberg, and V. Liebscher On Exchange Mechanisms for Bosons submitted 1998 9. K.-H. Fichtner, W. Freudenberg, and V. Liebscher Time Evolution and Invariance of Boson Systems Given by Beam Splittings Infinite Dimensional Analysis, Quantum Probability and Related Topics 1(4):511-531 1998 10. K.-H. Fichtner, W. Freudenberg, and M. Ohya Recognition and teleportation pages 85-107 11. K. Fichtner and M. Ohya Quantum teleportation with entangled states given by beam splittings Commun. Math. Phys. 222(2):229-247 2001 12. K. Fichtner and M. Ohya Quantum teleportation and beam splitting Commun. Math. Phys. 225(1):67-89 2002 13. W. Freudenberg On a Class of Quantum Markov Chains on the Fock
14.
15. 16.
17. 18. 19.
20. 21.
22.
Space In L. Accardi, editor, Quantum Probability & Related Topics IX World Scientific Publishing Co. Singapore 1994 pages 215 - 237 V. Liebscher Diagonal Integration and Diagonalized Versions Forschungsergebnisse der Fakultat fiir Mathematik und Informatik Jena Math/Inf/96/38 1996 V. Liebscher Beam Splittings, Coherent States and Quantum Stochastic Differential Equations Habilschrift FSU Jena 1998 V. Liebscher Diagonal Versions and Quantum Stochastic Integrals on the Symmetric Fock Space with Nonadapted Integrands Prob.Th.Rel.Fields 112:255-295 1998 V. Liebscher Using weights for the description of states of boson systems in preparation 2001 J. Lindsay Quantum and Noncausal Stochastic Calculus Prob. Th. Re1. Fields 97:65-80 1993 J. Lindsay and H. Maassen An integral kernel approach to noise In L. Accardi and W. uon Waldenfels, editors, Quantum Probability and Applications I11 volume 1303 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics Springer-Verlag Heidelberg 1988 pages 192 -208 J. Lindsay and H. Maassen The stochastic calculus of Bose noise Preprint 1988 H. Maassen Quantum Markov processes on Fock space described by integral kernels In L. Accardi and W. von Waldenfels, editors, Quantum Probability and Applications I1 volume 1136 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics Springer Berlin, Heidelberg, New York 1985 pages 361 - 374 P. Meyer Quantum Probability for Probabilists volume 1538 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York 1993
ON FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH QUANTUM MARKOV STATES CORRESPONDING TO NEAREST NEIGHBOR MODELS ON A CAYLEY TREE
FRANCESCO FIDALEO Dipartimento di Matematica Universitd di Roma “Tor Vergata” Via della Ricerca Scientifica, 00133 Roma, Italy, E-mail: fidaleoOOmat.uniroma2.it FARRUH MUKHAMEDOV Department of Mechanics and Mathematics National University of Uzbekistan Vuzgorodok, 700095, Tashkent, Uzbekistan, E-mail: far75mOOyandex.r~ In this paper we consider nearest neighbour models where the spin takes values in the set @ = {q1,v2,.,.,qq} and is assigned to the vertices of the Cayley tree .?I The Hamiltonian is defined by some given A-function. We find a condition for the function A to determine the type of the von Neumann algebra generated by the GNS - construction associated with the quantum Markov state corresponding t o the unordered phase of the A-model. Also we give some physical applications of the obtained result. 2000 Mathematical Subject Classification: 47A67, 47L90, 47N55, 82B20. Keywords: von Neumann algebra, quantum Markov state, A- model, Cayley tree, unordered phase, Gibbs measure, GNS - construction.
1. Introduction It is known that in the quantum statistical mechanics concrete systems are identified with states on corresponding algebras. In many cases the algebra can be chosen to be a quasi-local algebra of observables. The states on this algebra satisfying the KMS condition, describe equilibrium states of the quantum system. Basically, limiting Gibbs measures of classical systems with the finite radius of interactions are Markov random fields (see e.g. Ref. 8, 22). In connection with this, there arises a problem to construct analogues of non-commutative Markov chains. In Ref. 1 Accardi explored
237
238 this problem, he introduced and studied noncommutative Markov states on the algebra of quasi-local observables which agreed with the classical Markov chains. In Ref. 3, 15,2, modular properties of the non-commutative Markov states were studied. In Ref. 10 Fannes, Nachtergale and Werner showed that ground states of the valence- bond- solid modles on a Cayley tree were quantum Markov chains on the quasi-local algebra. In the present paper we will consider Markov states associated with nearest neighbour models on a Cayley tree. Note the investigation of the type of quasi-free factors (i.e. factors generated by quasi-free representations) has been an interesting problem since the appearance of the pioneering work of Araki and Wyss5. In Ref. 21 a family of representations of uniformly hyperfinite algebras was constructed, which can be treated as a free quantum lattice system. In that case factors corresponding to those representations are of type I&, X E (0,l). More general constructions of product states were considered in Ref. 4. Observe that the product states can be viewed as the Gibbs states of Hamiltonian system in which interactions between particles of the system are absent, i.e. the system is a free lattice quantum spin system. So it is interesting to consider quantum lattice systems with non-trivial interactions, which leads us, as mentioned above, to consider the Markov states. Simple examples of such systems are the Ising and Potts models, which have been studied in many papers (see, for example, Ref. 24). We note that all Gibbs states corresponding to these models are Markov random fields. The full analysis of the type of von Neumann algebras associated with the quantum Markov states is still an open problem. Some particular cases of the Markov states were considered in Ref. 11,14,17,18,19. The present paper is devoted t o the type analysis of some class of diagonal quantum Markov states, which correspond to a X-model on the Cayley tree, in which spin variables take their values in a set @ = {ql, ..., q q } ,where r]k E k = 1,.. . ,q. Observe that the considered model generalizes a notion of X-model introduced in Ref. 23, where the spin variables take their values f l .
2. Definitions and preliminary results
The Cayley tree rk of order k 2 1 is an infinite tree, i.e., a graph without cycles, such that each vertex of which lies on k 1 edges. Let I? = (V,A), where V is the set of vertices of rk,A is the set of edges of I?. The vertices x and y are called nearest neighbor, which is denoted by I =< x , y > if
+
239 there exists an edge connecting them. A collection of the pairs < z, z1>, . . . ,
is called path from the point z to the point y. The distance d(z,y), z, y E V, on the Cayley tree, is the length of the shortest path from z to y. We set Wn = {Z E v J ~ ( x2'), = TI},
Ln = ( 1
=< Z , Y >E L ~ z , YE Vn},
for an arbitrary point xo E V. Denote 1x1 = d(x,xo), x E V. Denote S(Z) = {y E Wn+l :d ( ~ , y = ) I}, x E Wn. This set is made of the direct successors of x. Observe that any vertex x # xo has k direct successors and xo has k + 1. Theorem 2.1. There exists a one-to-one correspondence between the set V of vertices of the Cayley tree of order k 2 1 and the group Gk+l of the free products of k 1 cyclic groups of the second order with generators
+
al,a2,.**,ak+l.
Consider a left (resp. right) transformation shift on follows. For go E Gk+l we put
T g o h= goh (resp. T g o h= hgo,), h E
Gk+l
defined as
Gk+l.
It is easy to see that the set of d l left (resp. right) shifts on Gk+l is isomorphic t o the group Gk+l. Let @ = { q l , q 2 ,...,qQ}, where ql,q2,..., qq are vectors in RqP1, such that
We consider models where the spin takes values in the set @ = { q l , q 2 , ...,q q } and is assigned to the vertices of the tree. A configuration o on V is then defined as a function x E V + o(x) E @; the set of all configurations coincides with R = &. The Hamiltonian is of an A-model form : HA(0)
=
c
<X,Y>
A(+),
4Y); J ) ,
(2)
240
where J E Iwn is a coupling constant and the sum is taken over all pairs of neighboring vertices < z,y >, a E R. Here and below A : @ x @ x Rn 3 R is some given function. We note that A-model of this type can be considered as a generalization of the Ising model. The Ising model corresponds to the case q = 2 and X(Z, y; J) = -J X Y . We consider a standard a-algebra 3 of subsets of R generated by cylinder subsets, all probability measures are considered on (0,3).A probability measure p is called a Gibbs measure (with Hamiltonian H A )if it satisfies the DLR equation: for n = 1,2, ... and a, E GVn:
where
Y $ ~ ~ + , is
the conditional probability
(0,) YWIW,+l vn
= 2-l (w IWn+l) e ~ ( - P ~ ( IaIwsIwn+1)1.
where /3 > 0. Here snlvn and WI W , + ~ denote the restriction of a,w E R to V, and Wn+l respectively. Next, a, : 2 E V, 3 a,(z) is a configuration in V, and H(a,,llwl~,,+,)is defined as the sum H(o,) +U(~,,WIW,,+~) where
c
H(an) =
<X,Y>€L,
U(an,WIwn+l) =
A ( ~ n ( ~ ) , % b J), );
c
A(aTa(z),w(y); 4.
<x,y>:X€Vn,yEWn+l
Finally, Z ( w l ~ , + ~stands ) for the partition function in V, with the boundary condition w I : Z(wlwn+l) =
C
e~(-PH(~~IIwIwn+A. cnEOVn Since we consider nearest neighbour interactions, the Gibbs measures of the A-model possess a Markov property: given a configuration w, on W,, random configurations in V,-l and in V \ Vn+l are conditionally independent. It is known (see Ref. 26) that for any sequence dn) E R, any is a Gibbs measure. Here limiting point of measures
52,,)
IWn+l
is a measure on fl such that Vn’
0,
otherwise.
> n:
52 ,wn+l n,
24 1
We now recall some basic facts from the theory of von Neumann algebras. Let B ( H ) be the algebra of all bounded linear operators on the Hilbert space H ( over the field of complex numbers C). A weak (operator) closed *-subalgebra N in B ( H ) is called von Neumann algebra if it contains the identity operator 1. By Proj(N) we denote the set of all projections in N . A von Neumann algebra is a factor if its center
Z(N := {x E N : xy = yx,
Vy
EN}
is trivial, i.e., Z ( N )= { A 1 : X E C}. The von Neumann algebras are direct sum of the classes I (In,n < 00, Im), I1 (IIl,II,) and 111. Further, a factor is of only one type among these listed above, see e.g. Ref. 30. An element x E N is called positive if there is an element y E N such that x = y*y. A linear functional w on N is called a state if w(x*x) 2 0 for all x E N and w(1) = 1. A state w is said to be normal if ~ ( s u p x , ) = supw(x,) for any a
a
bounded increasing net {xa} of positive elements of N . A state w is called trace (resp. faithful) if the condition w(xy) = w(yx) holds for all x,y E N (resp. if the equality w(x*x) = 0 implies x = 0). Let N be a factor, w be a faithful normal state on N and aW , be the modular group associated with w (see Definition 2.5.15 in Ref. 6). We let I?(&) denote the Connes spectrum of the modular group a; (see Definition 2.2.1 in Ref. 6). For the type I11 factors, there is a finer classification. Definition (Ref. 9). The type I11 factor N is of type (i) 1111,if r(aw) = (ii) IIIx, if r(aw) = {nlogX,n E Z}, X E (0,l); (iii) I&, if r(aw) = (0); see, e.g. Ref. 6, 28 for details of von Neumann algebras and the modular theory of operator algebras.) 3. Construction of Gibbs states for the A-model
In this section we give a construction of a special class of limiting Gibbs measures for the A-model on the Cayley tree. Let h : x + h, = (hl,,, h2,z, ...,hq-l,z) E be a real vector-valued function of x E V . Given n = 1 , 2 , ... consider the probability measure ~ ( on aVndefined by /Jn)(an)= Z,-l exp{-PH(an)
+
c
XEW,
hzo(x)}
7
(3)
~
1
242
Here, as before, a, : x E V, partition function:
+ on(x) and
2, is the corresponding
X€W,
e n EQv,
The consistency conditions for p(,)(o,), n 2 1 are ~ p ( ~ ) ( a , - l , a ( n=) p(n-l)(a,-l), )
(4)
a(")
where a(n) = { a ( x ) , xE Wn}. Let V1 c V2 c ... Ur?, V, = V and p 1 , p 2 , ...be a sequence of probability measures on aV1, Ovz, ... satisfying the consistency condition (4). Then, according to the Kolmogorov theorem (see, e.g. Ref. 25), there exists a unique limit Gibbs measure jJh on R such that for every n = 1,2, ... and on E aVnthe equality holds
0
P {alv, = an}
= P(%,).
(5)
Further we set the basis in RQ-l to be ql, 72,..., qq-l. The following statement describes conditions on h, guaranteeing the consistency condition of measures p(,) (a,). Theorem 3.1. The measures ,u(,)(a,), n = 1,2, ... s a t i s b the consistency condition (4) if and only if f o r any x E V the following equation holds:
h', =
c
F(h',,X) >
(6)
l/ES(X)
Here, and below ha stands f o r the vector *hx and F : RQ-' function is F(h;X)= (Fl(h;X),..., Fq-l(h;X)),with
+ RQ-' (7)
Fi(h,,h2,...,hq-,;X)
i = 1,2, ...,Q - 1, h = ( h l ,...,hq-1). The proof uses the same argument as in Ref. 18,19. Denote
V = { h = (h, E EXq-'
:x E
F(h,,X), V X E V } .
V ) : h, = l/ES(X)
According to Theorem 3.1 for any h = ( h x , x E V ) E V there exists a which satisfies the equality (5). unique Gibbs measure
243
If the vector-valued function ho = (h, = (0, ...,0 ) , x 6 V)is a solution, i.e. ho E 2) then the corresponding Gibbs measure p p ) is called the unordered phase of the X-model. Since we deal with this unordered phase, we have to make an assumption which guarantees us the existence of the unordered phase. Assumption A. For the considered model the vector-valued function ho = (h, = (O,O, ...,0 ) , x E V) belongs to 2). This means that the equation (6) has a solution h, = ho = 0,x E V. According to Theorem 2.1 any transformation S of the group Gk+l induces an automorphism ,$ on V. By &+I we denote the left group of shifts of Gk+l. Any T E G k + l induces a shift automorphism 5! : + by (Fa)(h)= a ( T h ) , h E Gk+i, 0 E R . It is easy to see that p e l o = p o('1 for every 5! E G k + l . AS mentioned above, the measure p c ) has a Markov property (see, Ref. 27). Assumption B. We suppose that the measure p p ) enables a mixing property, i.e. for any A, B E 3 the following holds
Note that the last condition is satisfied, for example, if the phase transition does not occur for the model under consideration.
4. Diagonal states and corresponding von Neumann algebras
Consider C*-algebra A = @lykMq(c),where Mq(C!)is the algebra of q x q matrices over the field C! of complex numbers. By e i j , i , j E {1,2, ...,q} we denote the basis matrices of the algebra M q ( C ) . We let CM,(@)denote the commutative subalgebra of Adq(@)generated by the elements eii i = {1,2, ...,q } . We set CA = @ykCMq(C). Elements of commutative algebra CA are functions on the space R = { e l l , ..., eqq}". Fix a measure p on the measurable space (0,B ) , where B is the 0-algebra generated by cylindrical subsets of R. We construct a state w p on A as follows. Let P : A + CA be the conditional expectation, then the state w p is be defined by wp(x) = p ( P ( z ) ) ,x E A, here p(P(x)) means an integral of a function P ( z ) under measure p, i.e. p(P(x)) = J, P(x)(s)dp(s) (see Ref. 29). The state is called diagonal.
244
By w c ) we denote the diagonal state generated by the unordered phase pt;"). The Markov property implies that the state up)is a quantum Markov state (see 3). On a finite dimensional C*-subalgebra Avn = @vnMq(C) c A
we rewrite the state
up) as follows
where tr is the canonical trace on Av,. The term X(a(x)o(y);J) in (4) is given by a diagonal element of Mq(C) @ Mq(C) in the standard basis as follows B(1) 0 . . .
P X o ( x ) ,4 4 ) ;
4=
(10)
. .. Here, B ( k )= ( b i j , k ) : , j = l , k = l,dots,q are q x q matrices, and
Consequently, using (9) and from (10),(11) (cp. Ref. 26, Ch.1, $1)the form of Hamiltonian fi(Vn) in the standard basis of Av, (i.e. under the basis matrices) is regarded as
0 Denote M = 7r (X)(A)",where T WO
(A)
WO
. ... . . . .B('3)
0
is the GNS - representation asso-
ciated with the state w c ) (see Definition 2.3.18 in Ref. 6). Our goal in this section is to determine a type of M . Remark. In Ref. 29 general properties of a representation associated with diagonal state were studied, but there concrete constructions of states were not considered. In Ref. 20 a deep classification of types of factors generated by quasi-free states has been obtained. For translation-invariant Markov states the corresponding type analysis has been made in Ref. 13.
245
The investigation of the type of factor arising from translation invariant or periodic quantum Markov states on the one dimensional chains is contained in Ref. 11. Now we define translations of the C*-algebra A . Every T E !&+I induces a translation automorphism rT : A + A defined by
Z€V"
XEV,
Since measure 111"' satisfies a mixing property (see (8)), then we can easily obtain that w?) also satisfies the mixing property under the translations { T T } T ~ B ~,+ i.e. , for all a, b E A the equality holds
According to Theorem 2.6.10 in Ref. 6, the algebra M is a factor. We note that the modular group of M associated with is defined by
up)
(A) CTYO
(2)=
where R(A) =
lim exp{itfi(A)}zexp{-itl?(A)},
Atrb
C
x
EM
,
(12)
It is well know that the last limit exists
<x,y>EA
if a suitable norm of the potential l? is finite (see Theorem 6.2.4. in Ref. 7). First of all, we recall the definition of the norm of a potential Q = CxCrb Q(W
where d > 0. Here @(X)E Ax = @ x M q ( C ) . NOW we compute 1lRlld:
m~ w,k 1 lOgpij,kI < co .
Hence the norm of l? is finite, therefore the limit in (12) exists. By M u one denotes the centralizer of w:'), which is defined as (A)
M" = {z E M
:
op
(z) = 2,
t E R} .
Since up)is Gibbs state, according to Proposition 5.3.28 in Ref. 7, the centralizer M u coincides with the set M ( A ) = {z E M : w F ) ( z y ) = ~ F ) ( y z ) y, E M } , (13) wo
246
where we denote by w r ) also the normal extension of the state under consideration t o all of M . By II[n]we denote the group of all permutations y of the set V, such that $22)
= 2, 2 E
w,
Every y E D[n] defines an automorphism ar : M
.rcn,”,,
a,) =
+M
by
n,,, 8
Mp(@) = id,
where id is the identity mapping. Denote
so = UIarIY E II[nl}. Simply repeating the proof of a proposition in Ref. 16, we can prove the following Lemma 4.1. T h e group
Go = {a E SOI wr’(a(x))= w p ) ( x ) ,
acts ergodically o n M , i.e. the equality a(.)
2
EM},
= x, a E Go implies x = 8 i ,
e E c. Lemma 4.2. T h e centralizer M u i s a factor of type IIl.
Proof. From the definition of the automorphism a7 (see (14)), it is easy to see that every automorphism a E Go is inner, i.e. there exists a unitary u, E M such that a(.) = u,xuL,x E M . From the condition up)o a = we find
up)
It follows from (13) that u, E M ( A ) . According to Lemma 4.1 the group *O Go acts ergodically, this means that the equality u,x = xu, for every a E Go implies x = 81,B E C. Hence, we obtain {u,la E Go}’ = Cl. Since Mu’ c {u,}’ we then get
M‘‘nM=ci. In particular Mu’ n M u = @I.This means that M“ is a factor.
I7
247
NOW we are able to prove main result of the paper (compare with the analogous result in Ref. 11). Theorem 4.1.
(i) If the fraction
is rational f o r every i, j , m, 2, k , p , u , v E 1,2, ...,q, whenever the denominator is different f r o m 0, then the von Neumann algebra M associated with the quantum Markov state corresponding t o the unordered phase of A-model (2) o n a Cayley tree is a factor of type IIIe . (ii) If M is a type of 1111factor, then all the fraction cannot be rational. Proof. It is known (see Proposition 2.2.2 in Ref. 9) that Connes' spectrum r(a)of group of automorphisms Q: = { Q : ~ } ~of~von G Neumann algebra M has the following form
r(Q)= n { S p ( a e ) l e E P r o j ( Z ( M " ) ) , e # O},
(15)
where a e ( z )= Q:(eze),z E e M e and Z ( M " ) is the center of subalgebra
M" = {z E M : a g ( z )= z,
9 E G}.
Here, Sp(a) be the Arveson's spectrum of group of automorphisms a: (see for more details Ref. 9,28). By virtue of Lemma 4.2 we have Z ( M " ) = Cl. The equality (15) (a) implies r(&))= sp(ow0 1. We now consider the operator H(V,) = C CP,,. We let ELn
Sp(fi(Vn)) denote the spectrum of the operator R(Vn).Setting (A)
oyo 'n(z) = exp{itfi(V,)}a:exp{-itfi(V,)},
a: E M
,
we obtain S p ( a W ~ ' l= n )Sp(fi(V,))-Sp(fi(Vn)) = {A-p : A,p E Sp(fi(V,))}. (16)
It is clear that ,BA(qi, q k ; J ) E Sp(&(Vn)),V i , k E 1 , . . .,q. Formula (16) then implies that Sp(oWr)9")is generated by elements of the form A ( r l ~ , ~ ~ ; J ) - A ( r l r C , r l ~ ; iJ,)j , k , Z E l , . . . q *
248
Since XX ((V9 ~b~,Tp;J)-X('lu 9j'J)-~(Vm~91'J) is a rational number, then there is a number t9u ; J ) y E (0,l) and integers mi,j,k,l E 2, (i,j,k,1 E {1,2, ...,a}) such that X(77i,qj;J) - X(77k,77l3 J ) = mi,j,k,llOgy*
(17)
Hence we find that an increasing sequence { E ( n ) }of subsets Z such that E(-n) = -E(n) and Sp(H(V,)) = {mlogy}mEE(n)is valid. It follows that Sp(o"b*)) c (nlog7)nEz. Hence there exists a positive integer d E Z such that we have (A)
qawo
) = { n log y d } n G z .
This means that M is a factor of type 1110, 8 = rd.
0
5. Applications and examples 5.1. Potts model
We consider the Potts model on the Cayley tree regarded as
rk whose Hamiltonian is
where J E R is a coupling constant, as usual < 2, y > stands for the nearest neighbor vertices and as before a ( . ) E @ = (71,q 2 , ...,qP}. Here 6 is the Kronecker symbol. Equality (1) implies that
for all z,y E V. The Hamiltonian H ( a ) is therefore
H ( a )= -
c
J'a(z)a(?/) ,
(18)
EL
where J' = q-lJ. 9 Hence the A-model is a generalization of the Potts model, that is in this case the function X : @ x @ x R + R is defined by A(z, y; J ' ) = -J'(z,y). Here, z, y E Rq-' and (2, y) stands for the scalar product in Rq-'. From (1)it is easy to see that
249
From (19) and (6) we can check that the assumption A (see section 3) is valid for the Potts model. So there exists the unordered phase. From (19) we can find that the fraction A(qi ,qj ;J’)- Vqrn,qi; J’) takes values A ( q k , q p ; J ’ ) - A(qzt,%J; J’Y k l and 0. So by Theorem 4.1 a von Neumann algebra M is a I&-factor.
{(if?)}.
From (17) we may obtain that I#J = exp -
Hence we obtain the
following
Theorem 5.1. The von Neumann algebra M corresponding t o the unordered phase of the Potts model (18) o n a Cayley tree is a factor of type III@h,f o r some k E Z, k
> 0, where
# IJ
= exp
Remark. If 4 = 2 the considered Potts model reduces to the Ising model, for this model analogous results were obtained in Ref. 17. For a class of inhomogeneous Potts model similar result has been also obtained in Ref. 18. 5.2. Markov random fields
In this subsection we consider a case when A ( x , y) function is not symmetric and the corresponding Gibbs measure is a Markov random field (see Ref. 27). Let P = ( ~ i j ) & =be ~ a stochastic matrix such that p i j > 0 for all i,j E 1,d. Define a function A ( x , y ) as follows: m i , q j ) = - 10gpij 7
(20)
for all i, j E { 1,.. . ,d } . From now on, we will consider the case /3 = 1 and 4 = d. It is easy to verify that Assumptions A and B, for the defined function A, are satisfied. By p we denote the corresponding unordered phase of the A-model. Observe that if the order of the Cayley tree is k = 1 then the measure p is a Markov measure, associated with the stochastic matrix P (see Ref. 27). By w,, one denotes the diagonal state corresponding to the measure p on C*-algebra A = @ , r b n / i d ( c ) .
Theorem 5.2. Let P = (pij)&=l be a stochastic matrix such that pij > 0 for all i, j = 1,. . .d and at least one element of this matrix is different from 112, and w,, be the corresponding Markov state. If there exist integers rnij i, j E (1,. . . ,d } , and some number 01 E (0,l) such that
250 then T,,,,(A)” , is a factor of tppe 1110 for some 6 E (0’1).
In order t o prove this theorem it should be used the rationality condition of Theorem 4.1. Namely, if the condition (21) is satisfied then using (20) one can see that the rationality condition holds, so we get the assertion. Remark. If all elements of the stochastic matrix P equal to 1/2 then the corresponding Markov state up is a trace and consequently T+ (A)” is the unique hyperfinite factor of type 111. Remark.