This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
1as t = 1 is Problem 4.21 and 0 < t < 1 uses similar ideas. As before, bound the integral defining Z a S ( f ) by J + K; J s c ~ " ~ M ( f ' ) (To x ) estimate . K choose s < p so that t < 6 + ( 1 - 6 ) s and use Holder's inequality to show that K < C Q - ~ ~ / ( ~ - ' ) M ( ~ ) now ( X ) ;minimize.) 4.23 Suppose that f E Lp and let p = l / a > 1. Then there is a constant c (which may be computed explicitly; this is left for the reader) so that for each interval I E T and E > 0 4.22
J, exp(
c
-1
-E
1")
dt < ce1zl.
(Hint: Assume Ilfll, = 1 , estimate II,f(x)l s J + c(In(~I~/2q)'-'~", and minimize.) 4.24 The condition qo f q1 is essential in the interpolation theorem 2.3. (Hint: For f:[ 0 , 1 ] + C consider the mapping
f
=
T f ( x )- F(x) = x-l"
J
f ( t ) dt. [O,Xl
Then T is of weak-type (p, 2) when 1 s p s 2, but is not of strong-type ( p , 2) for any p in that range.) 4.25 For f ' s as above consider the continuity properties of the mappings f ( x ) + T f ( x ) = x" jlo,x) z"f(t) dt, where a, q are real numbers and not necessarily positive. Construct examples of operators of weak-type ( p, q ) but not of type (p, q) for any 1 s p s q < co, and consider whether the interpolation theorem holds for q < p. 4.26 Suppose T is an operator with the following property: for each A > 0, T may be written as TI + T,, where TI maps L p ( x )into L"( Y ) with norm s A / 2 and T2 is of weak-type (p, p) with norm
I,
u
165
4. Notes; Further Results and Problems
of pairwise disjoint intervals such that
and Let now A x ) = Cjfi,xI:(x)+ f ( x ) x T \ u I f ( x ) ,b ( x ) = f ( x ) - A x ) . The estimate for the term involving b is easy; also I{[ Tgl > A}I S c(llgll,/A)qo,which together with g ( x ) =S 2A4'P a.e., llgllp =S 1, and the relations between p and q, gives the desired conclusion. This result is from Baishanski and Coifman's paper [1978].) 4.28 Suppose T is a sublinear operator simultaneously of weak-type (1, q ) and (p, q l ) , with 1 < q, p < q l , q < q l . Then there are constants A, B independent o f f such that 9 T
I Tf(x)I4dx
A + B(
If(x)l(ln'lf(x)()'/'
dx) .
(4.5)
T
(Hint: By (4.16) in Chapter IV, it readily follows that there are constants c, , c,, cj so that for A > 0,
Once we show that
is dominated by the right-hand side of (4.5) we are done, and this is not hard to do. The result is O'Neil's [1966]; however, in the particular case of the fractional integral, it had already been noted by Zygmund.) 4.29 Let 0 s l / q i = pi =S l/pi = ai < 00, i = 0, 1, a. f a l , Po # P I , and let y = E X + y be the equation of the line passing through the points (ai, pi). Assume that the generalized Young's functions A, B are given by A ( u ) = b ( s ) ds, with a and b monotone and further a(s) ds, B ( u ) = assume that, if M = max(qo, 4 , ) and rn = min(qo, q l ) , then B ( u ) / u M decreases and B ( u ) / u " increases and
I
CO?)
( B ( s ) / s " + ' )ds = O ( B ( u ) / u " )
VI. Paley's Theorem and Fractional Integration
166
and
( B ( s ) / s M + 'ds ) = 0(B(u)/uM). Then if B-'( u) = A-'( u E ) u Ythere , is a constant c, independent off, so that J, B(ITf(y)l/c)d v ( y ) s 1 whenever 1 , A ( f[ ( x ) l )d p ( x ) s 1. (Hint: Set the monotone function z - l ( s ) = B-'(A(s)'/').) 4.30 (Young's Convolution Theorem. Lp * L' E Lq, l/q + 1 = l/p + l/r. (Hint: Fix f E Lp(T ) , 1 < p < 00, then convolution with f gives a bounded mapping from L into Lp and from Lp' into L"; now interpolate. Other proofs give a better constant.) 4.31 More generally, wk-LP * L' E Lq, same range of p, q, r's as in 4.30. 4.32 Assume that l/p + l/q > 1, 1 < p, q S 2; then Lp * Lq is not included in U,,,L", l / r + 1 = l / p + l / q . (Hint: For k > 0 put a,, = l/(k + 1)2/p2(k+')/p' for 2k 6 n < 2k+', and extend a, as an even sequence for all n's and similarly for {b,,} with q in place of p. Since 1uPnlnlp-2, 1bzln1q-2 < a there are functions f C u,eim E Lp and g 1b,,eimE L4. However, since ~ ( a n b , , ) S l n ~=S00- Zfor each s > r, f * g cannot be in L". This example is from Quek and Yap's paper [1983].) 4.33 If a > O , O < E < 1, 1 < p < &/a,1 s q < wand f E L" and M E I p E f Lq,then IJ E L' and 11 I, f 11 g cII M E I p11f"I" Ilfll;-"/". (This result is from Adams' work [ 19751.) 4.34 Show that M i = 9Lp, 1 < p G a, i.e. { A j } E Mi if and only if there is a function C#J E Lp(7') so that cj(C#J)= Aj?.allj . (Hint: The sufficiencyis obvious; as for the necessity, if A C Ajevx,then IIA * K,,l[ps C ~ ~ for K , , ~ ~ ~ all n. What does the statement imply concerning A:?) 4.35 The space of multiplier sequences from LP(T) into C(T) is g ~ " , l / p l/p' = 1, 1 s p < 00, and so is M%.What does the statement say about A%?
-
-
+
-
CHAPTER
VII Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
1. ABEL SUMMABILITY, NONTANGENTIAL CONVERGENCE We refer here to yet another classic, and very important, summability method. This method requires the identification of T with eD, the boundary of the unit disk D = { z E C :Iz( < 1) in the complex plane. Given 0 s a < 7 ~ / 2we define the set Cn,(O) with vertex at 1, that is, e”, and opening a as the convex hull of the disk of radius sin a and { 1}\{ l},
u W O )
This set corresponds to the notion of “nontangential” approach to 1. It is readily seen that points z in Cn,(O) satisfy the condition 1 (1- zJ/(1- 121) S 2 max(l/(l - sin a),l/cos a).Thus it is equivalent, and often simpler, to consider instead the “cone”
r,(o) = { z E D : 11
- zl/(i
-
l z l ) c a},
a a 1.
(1.1)
We are now ready for
Definition 1.1. Given a
2
1 and a function f(z) defined in D, we say that 167
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
168 \
f converges (Abel) nontangentially of order lim
Z+
i,zer,(o)
(Y
to L as z + 1 provided that
f(z) = L,
and we denote this by lim,,,f(z) = L ( A , ) . When a = 1 we call the approach “radial,” for then z takes values on the radius joning 0 to 1. Similarly, in the case of series we have Definition 1.2. Let { c i } be a sequence of complex numbers. We say that the m series cj is (Abel) nontangentially convergent of order a ( 2 1) to s, and denote this by CJys0cj = s(A,), provided that for f(z) = cjzJ, limze1f(z) = s(A,). The usual algebraic properties hold in this case as well. For instance, if so and s1 are finite numbers a n d x cj = so(A,),C dj = sl(A,), then also C(cj + d j ) = so + sl(A,).
CJzo
It would be reassuring to know that convergent series also converge nontangentially to the same limit; in fact more is true. Proposition 1.3. Suppose
CJco cj = s(C, 1).
Then also
,:C,
cj = s(A,),
lS(Y
Proof. Let s, and a, denote the partial sums and Ceslro means of order n of { c j } ;our assumption implies that s, = o ( n ) . In the first place, observe that n-I
n
1cjr‘ = ( 1 - 1sir‘ + s,zn. 2)
j=O
j=O
Therefore, if the limit of either side in (1.2) exists as n + CO, then the limit of the other side also exists and they are equal. Moreover, since snzn = o( l), then also m
m
j=O
j=O
1c j 2 = ( 1 - z) 1s j 2
(1.3)
provided either series converges. Summing by parts once again, and since ncr,,_lzn-l = o(1) for z E D as n + co, a similar argument gives m
W
j=O
j=O
1cjzJ = (1 - Z ) ’ C ( j + 1)a;zJ =f(z),
(1.4)
say, again provided either sum converges. Now, it is readily seen that the right-hand side of (1.4) converges absolutely for IzI < 1 with sum s c / ( l - IzI)’, and so the left-hand side is also finite. Next we show that f(z) tends to s nontangentially. In the process we make use of the identity m
1 = (1 - z ) ’ C < j j=O
+ l)zj,
l z ~
(1.5)
169
1. Abel Summability, Nontangential Convergence
More precisely, given E > 0 we show there exists S > 0 so that If(z) - SI S E provided z E r,(O) and 11 - zI s 8. Indeed, combining (1.4) and (1.5), it readily follows that
c m
f(z) - s
+
= (1 - z)' (jro
(j
+ l ) ( q - S ) z i = I + J,
j=N+l)
say. Now, since m
m
j=N+1
j=O
1( j + I)+ s C ( j +I)$ =-( I -1 r)"
if we choose N so that laj - SI s & / 2 a 2for j that for z in ra(0),
3
N
+ 1, then it readily follows
Now that N has been fixed, we note that
j=O
provided S is small enough. We are interested in applying Proposition 1.3 to Fourier series, more specifically to Lebesgue's theorems 4.2 in Chapter I1 and 6.3 in Chapter 111. Since the expression appearing in the Definition 1.2 is one sided, given f E L, f C cjeij*,we introduce the notations
-
C o ( t )= co,
G(t)= c-je-l* + cje'",
j s l
(1.6)
j 2 1.
(1.7)
and eo(t) = 0,
c(t) =
(-i)(-cjeKij'
+ cjeij*),
Proposition 1.3 asserts that actually
j=O
and m
ej(t) = Hf(t)(A,)
almost every t in
T.
( 1 -9)
j=O
We may, and do, assume that (1.8) and (1.9) hold simultaneously. More precisely, if z = rek E ra(0),then for almost every t in T (1.10)
170
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
and (1.11)
We would like to unravel (1.10) and (1.11) and express them in terms of the original cj's. First, since r,(O) is symmeric, that is, z E r,(O) if and only if Z E ro(O), and as is readily seen
then for almost every t in T the following is true: (1.12)
Similarly, by (1.11) now, and for the same t's,
"+" statement
Whence, by subtracting the "-"statement in (1.13) from the in (1.12) and rearranging the expressions involved, we obtain
= f(t )
- iHf( t ) ,
a.e. in
T.
(1.14)
Similarly, by adding the "-"statement in (1.12) and the "+" statement in (1.13) and rearranging the expressions involved, we obtain
=f(t)
+ iHf(t),
a.e. in
T.
(1.15)
We have thus arrived at one of the most interesting and important results in this chapter, namely, Theorem 1.4. Suppose f E L( T ) , f
- C cjeGr.Then for almost every t in T (1.16)
and (1.17)
2. The Poisson and Conjugate Poisson Kernels
171
Prmf. (1.16) follows by adding (1.14), (1.15), and (1.17), by subtracting (1.14) from (1.15), and invoking the symmetry of r,(O) to change -x intox. H
2. THE POISSON AND CONJUGATE POISSON KERNELS Expressions (1.16) and (1.17) in Theorem 1.4 correspond to the convolution off with the functions P ( z) and Q( z) with (absolutely convergent) Fourier series given by m
z = re",
O < r < 1 (2.1)
and W
(-i)(sgn j)cjrlj'evL,
P(z) = Q(Z) =
z
=
reiL,
o
(2.2)
j=-00
respectively; these functions are called the Poisson and conjugate Poisson kernel. When convenient, we view these functions as defined in T and denote them by P r ( t ) and Q r ( t ) ,'i.e., as a family of kernels indexed by r, 0 r < 1. The first task at hand is to obtain an explicit expression for these kernels. By summing the geometric series in (2.1) we get
which easily reduces to
Similarly, by summing (2.2) we see that
which also readily reduces to
172
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
The interaction between P and Q is given by the expression P which on account of (2.3) and (2.5) equals
+ iQ,
This is an analytic function of z in D ; we will have more to say about this later on. By (2.4) we note that Pr(t) is a periodic, positive, even function of t E T, monotone in [0, T),which is dominated either by
1-2 l+r 2 <(l-r)*-l-r 1-r or, on account of estimate (1.16) in Chapter I, by
Also, by (2.1), (2.10) The reader may have noted the similarity of FejCr's kernel K , ( t ) with the Poisson kernel P,( t) for r = 1 - 1/( n + 1); this hints at a similarity of results as well. For instance by (the continuous version of) Proposition 2.3 in Chapter IV there is a constant c, independent off, so that
(2.1 1) But on account of statement (1.16) of Theorem 1.4 we expect a stronger result, of a nontangential nature, to hold. Before considering this point we list some properties of the conjugate Poisson kernel. By (2.6), Q r ( t ) is an odd function and I Qr(t)l is dominated by either
crltl/(l - r)'
or
c/ltl.
(2.12)
Also by (2.5) (2.13) As for 11 Qrlll, it does not remain bounded as r + 1- (cf. 6.4); this is all we need to know about the kernels. 1 6 a < 00. In Now some definitions. Let I',(x) = { z E D : eVkz E ra(0)}, other words T,(xi is the cone r,(O) rotated so that its vertex lies at ek rather than at 1; a similar definition is given for n,(x).
173
2. The Poisson and Conjugate Poisson Kernels
Definition 2.1. Assume f E L and 1 s a < 00. We introduce the nontangential maximal function off * Pr of order a at x by Na(f*p r , x ) = :UP I f * Pr(t)l* (2.14) z = r e .zeT,(x) N , is called the radial maximal function.
We then have Theorem 2.2. Assume that f E L and 1 s a < m. Then there is a constant c,, independent off, such that (2.15)
N ( f *pr, x) s c,Mf(x).
Proof. The radial maximal function was already considered in (2.11), and the nontangential case is a straightforward computation. Indeed, since each z = reir in T , ( x ) is of the form reicx+'),reis E r,(O), it readily follows that
'I
f* P r ( t ) = I = -
2T
T
'I
f(u)P,(x+s-~)du=2T
~(x+u)~~(s-u)~u,
T
and consequently )I1 d
$-(I I +
C-TGO)
.(fI)
+ u)lP,(s - u ) du = J + K ,
(2.16)
[O,.rr)
say. As the estimate for both summands in (2.16) is obtained in a similar way, we only do K . Let F,(u) = F ( u ) = j,o,,,lf(x u)l du; then F is absolutely continuous and F ' ( u ) = If(x u)l a.e. Thus, by integrating by
+
+
parts the integral in K, we note that it equals
F ( u ) P r ( s- u ) ] : -
I
f ( u ) P : ( s - u ) du
=
K1 + K 2 ,
[O,r)
say. K1 offers no difficulty: since F ( 0 ) = 0, F ( T ) s c M f ( x ) and P,(s - T )s c,, we see at once that K1 s c,Mf(x), which is of the right order. Moreover, since for 0 < u < T F( u)/sin( u/2) s c M f ( x ) ,
also K 2 s c(
I[,.,
)
sin( ;)P:(s - u ) du M f ( x ) .
(2.17)
To bound the integral in (2.17) we distinguish two cases, namely, 0 < r =S f, and 4 < r < 1. The latter is pretty easy since then the integral does not exceed
174
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
As for the former we observe that the integral there is dominated by
say. To estimate K4 we note that the integrand uP:(u) is even and, consequently, K4 = -2
J
uP:(u)du
= -~uP,(u)],"
+
[%a)
= -272Pr(
72)
+ 272 s 272.
Finally, to bound K 3 , observe c ( r - 11 cll - re"[; and consequently
+
that
Jro,
a) ~
r ( u du )
flsl s rlsl
(2.18)
clr - reis[s
1 11 - reisl d c + c,. K3
Corollary 2.3. Assume that f E Lp(T ) , 1 C p s 00. Then there is a constant c = c,,~ independent off so that I I N a ( f * Pr)IIp ~ l l f l l p , 1 < P s 00 (2.20)
and
A({Na(f* pr)'
AII s cIIfII1.
Corollary 2.4. Suppose f E Lp(T ) , 1 < p s c = c, independent off so that
X ( f *Qr, and consequently for 1 < p < 00,
(2.21) 00.
Then there is a constant
x) s c W J ) ( x )
(2.22)
I I X ( f * Q J l l P s CllfIlP. (2.23) Proof. Since am(f) * Q r ( x )= &"(f)* P , ( x ) and 1 < p , it follows that also f * Q,(x) = f * P,(x) and the conclusion follows from Theorem 2.2 and Corollary 2.3. As for convergence in Lp we have Proposition 2.5. Assume f E Lp(T ) , 1 s p < a.Then
(i) llf * Prllp s Ilfllp r < 1, (ii) lim,,,Ilf* Pr - f l i p = 0, and (iii) liml=,ix,,,,,r,(0)llf* Pr(x + * ) -flip = 0.
175
2. The Poisson and Conjugate Poisson Kernels
A similar result holds for p
provided that f E C( T).
= 00
Proof. (i) and (ii) have a counterpart, with identical proof, in the case of FejCr's kernel. As for (iii), in case p < 00, the proof is a simple application of Fatou's lemma since, by Theorem 2.2, Pr(x + t ) -f(t>l S c M f ( t ) and, by Theorem 1.4, limz=re~x-tl,zc~,(0)f* Pr(x + t) =f(t) a.e. The case p = 00 also follows easily.
If*
As for the conjugate Poisson Kernel, we have Theorem 2.6. Assume f E L( T), then
(f*Q,(x + I)- H , . J ( t ) )
lim
== re'x-.i,zd-,(o)
=0
a.e.
(2.24)
and there is a constant c = c, independent o f f such that
If*
sup z = relx,zc
Consquently, iff
r, ( 0 ) E
Qr(x + t ) - H , - f ( t ) l s cMf(t) a.e.
(2.25)
Lp(T), 1 < p < 00, then also Qr(x + .) - H l - r f ~ = ~ p0.
/If*
lim
(2.26)
z = retx+ i , z d - , ( 0 )
Proof. (2.24) and (2.25) obtain by arguments similar to those invoked in the case of FejCr's kernel, combined now with the ideas in Theorem 2.2 to incorporate the non-tangential convergence; we sketch the proof of the radial case. First, observe that, since Q1(x) = (2 sin x)/[2(1 - cos x)] = l/tan(x/2), x # 0, we have
f* Qr(t)
- H,-rf(t) =-
2~
1
f(t-x)Qr(x)dx
1xlsl-r
I
+1 2~
= Zl(t)
say. By (2.12) we see that
IIl(t)l s
-1
I-r
f(t - x)(Qr(x) - ~ l ( x )dx )
+ Z*(t),
(2.27)
C
1- r
If(t Ixlrl-r
- x)l dx
and consequently I Z , ( t ) l s cMf(t)and IZl(t)l = o(l), as r + 1-, at each Lebesgue point t of f: Moreover, since Qr(x) - Ql(x) = ((1 - r)/(l + r))Q,(x)P,(x) is an odd and monotone decreasing function in (0, T),and by (2.12), 1-r 1-r 1 ---Q,(X) s --< T, for 0 < x < T, l+r 1 r sin(x/2)
+
VZZ. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
176 then we may estimate IZ2(t)l
c j y t - x)lP,(x) dx
cW(t).
Also an argument similar to Theorem 6.3 in Chapter I11 obtains that 12(t)= o(l), as r + 1-. Corollary 2.7. Suppose f dent off so that
E
L( T ) . Then there is a constant c = c, indepen-
Na(f*Or, t )
c ( J f * f ( t )+ M f ( t ) ) .
(2.28)
3. HARMONIC FUNCTIONS The Laplacian A is the second order partial differential operator given by
A=-1 - + a'- + - -a2 r2 at2 ar2
1 a r ar'
(3.1)
It is readily seen that A( r'j'evt)= 0, all j , and consequently by superposition A ( P r ( t ) )= A ( f * P r ( t ) )= 0, f~ L, re" E D. This operator is also familiar in Cartesian coordinates, i.e., in terms of x = r cos t, y = r sin t, and it is given by A = - a2 + - a' ax2 ay2' In what follows we use (3.1) and (3.2) interchangeably. Functions u which verify Au = 0 (in D) are called harmonic (in D). We begin by showing that in some sense the only harmonic functions are those which arise as Poisson integrals. More precisely, we have
Proposition 3.1. Assume u E C 2 ( D )is harmonic. Then there is a sequence of complex numbers { c j } such that u(re") =
1 cjrljleu*,
reit
E
(3.3)
D.
j=-m
Proof. By assumption the partial derivatives au/dx, au/ay exist and are continuous in D. We construct a function u(x,y ) such that for ( x ,y ) E D (or more precisely x + iy E D ) ,
a
a
-u(x, y ) = --u(x, aY ax
y).
(3.4)
177
3. Harmonic Functions
A pair of functions (u, u ) verifyinng (3.4) is called a Cauchy-Riemann pair and the function o is called a harmonic conjugate, or conjugate, to u ; our claim is that to each harmonic function u in D we may assign a conjugate o. The construction in 0, or any simply connected domain for that matter, is quite easy. Indeed, fix (xo,y o ) in D and note that u is well defined by means of the path integral 4 x 9
Y ) - 4 x 0 , Yo) =
j
(X,Y)
du,
(3.5)
(X0,YO)
where the path in (3.5) is totally contained in 0,provided that du is an exact differential for then the integral in (3.5) is path independent. But if we put
then this occurs since
a "(aY -Gu) a
= - ( - u )a, ax ax
as u is harmonic. Thus (3.5) determines a conjugate u to u and by (3.4) the function f ( z ) = u(z) + iu(z) is analytic in D. Therefore, there is a sequence of complex constants { d j } such that m
f(z)=
Iz( < 1.
djz', j=O
Moreover, since u ( z ) = Ref(z)
=
;(c 1 "
djz'
m
+ @),
it readily follows that with
,
c. = ' J - j ,
j < 0,
co = $ ( d o + do),
and
cj = f d j , j
> 0.
By the way, the proof also shows that u(re") = 1 cirlJ'egr,with c; (-i)(sgnj)cj, j # 0, 4, = ( - i / 2 ) ( d 0 - do).
=
Remark 3.2. If f ( z ) = u ( z ) + i u ( z ) is analytic in a region containing 0, by the results discussed in this chapter it follows that
178
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
where z = reir,0 d r < 1. This formula exhibits the close connection between an analytic function f and its real part u. Next we discuss the analog to Fejir's theorem
Theorem 3.3. Suppose u is harmonic in D and that, in addition, for some 1
Then there is a function f E Lp(T ) , Ilfll, lim
C
A, such that u(re") = f
* Pr(t),
a.e.
u(rei(x+r) ) =f(t)
re"+l,re'xEr,(0)
and lim re'x+l,re'xEr,(o)
11 u(
) - f l p = 0,
1 < p < 00.
(3.6)
Proof. By Theorem 1.4 and Proposition 2.5 it suffices to show that u(reif) = f * P r ( t ) ,f~ L P ( T ) ,Ilfll, S A. By Proposition 3.1 it follows that u(re") = 1 cjrl.ileVr, and we are reduced to showing that the cj's are the Fourier coefficients of an Lp function$ Let a,,(t)denote the Ceskro means of order n of the cj's. By Fejir's theorem 3.3 in Chapter I1 it is enough to prove that ~ ~ as, A, , ~all ~ n. p We write a,,(?) = (a,,(t) - an* P r ( t ) )+ an* P r ( t ) = Z ( t ) + J ( t ) ,
say, and take a closer look at each summand. Observe that
say. Since I , ( t ) is a trigonometric polynomial of degree n, we have that lllllps (1 - r)IIIlllp = o(l),
as r + 1 - .
As for J ( t ) , note that it actually equals u(r-) * 2K,(
IlJllP
S
H~(r*)llpll2K"IIl s A,
I)
(3.7)
and, consequently,
all r, n.
(3.8)
3. Harmonic Functions
179
Thus, by combining (3.7) and (3.8), we get that ~ ~ c T6, A, ~and ~ ~ we have finished. As is usually the case, (3.6) holds forp = 00 providedf E C ( T). As for p = 1 we have Theorem 3.4. Suppose u is harmonic in D and that, in addition,
Then there is a finite Bore1 measure p with total variation 11pl1 6 A, such that u(re") = p * Pr(t).Furthermore, if +(t) =
[
ddx),
t E
T,
then also lim
u(rei(x+r) ) = +'(t)
a.e.
reix+l,re'xEr,(0)
If u( re") 2 0, then there is a positive measure p such that u( reir)= p * Pr(t). Finally if { u ( r e k ) } r < is l Cauchy in L(T) as r -* 1, then there is an integrable function f such that u(re") = f * Pr(t);f satisfies (3.6) with p = 1. P m f . The existence of p and the statement concerning the nontangential convergence follow as in Theorem 3.3. Note that we cannot assert in general that u(re") = +'* Pr(t);the simplest example of this is the Poisson kernel Pr(t)itself which has nontangential limits 0 at every point save 0 and yet corresponds to p = Dirac delta at the origin. Now, if u is a nonnegative harmonic function, u(re") = C cjr'j'egr,then
[;u(reiI)l dt and u(re") = p
=
I,
u(rei1) dt
= 2m,,
< co
* Pr(t). Therefore
u ( r - )* 2K,,(t) = u,,(p)* P r ( t )3 0,
all n, r
and a,,(p, t) =
lim u,,(p)* P J t ) 2 0
r-I
a.e.
(3.9)
By Theorem 3.5 in Chapter 11, (3.9) implies that p is a nonnegative measure. Finally, in case { u( re")} is Cauchy in L(T) as r + 1-, we infer two facts, (r~) = to wit: since L(T) is complete there i s f e Lsuch that l i m r + l - ~ ~ u -fill 0 and by the first part of the theorem there is a measure p so that u( rei') = p * Pr(t). Since for each fixed s, 0 < s < 1, Ps(x - t ) E L"( T), it follows at
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
180
once that limr+l u(r.) * P,(x) = f * Ps(x). On the other hand, since (as is readily seen by direct examination of the Fourier series) Pr * P, = Prs,0 < r, s < 1, we also have that u ( r * )* Ps(x) = p * Prs(x), which tends to p * Ps(x) = u(se") as r + 1-. Thus u(se*) = f * P,(x) and we are done. It is a natural question to consider what integrability properties, if any, are satisfied by the conjugates to harmonic functions verifying the assumptions of Theorem 3.3 or 3.4. The answer is straightforward. Theorem 3.5. Suppose that u is harmonic in D and that, in addition, for somelSp
&
lu( reir)lpdt)
I"
=A
< 00.
T
Let u denote the conjugate to u so that u ( 0 ) = 0. Then there is a constant c= independent of u such that
IT
N,(u, x)" dx s CAP,
1 < p < 00,
(3.10)
and, for all A > 0, Al{N,(u) > A}l
C
cA,
p
=
1.
(3.11)
Proof. Suppose first p > 1; then u(re") = f * Pr(t ) , f E Lp(T), and by inspection of the Fourier series, u(re") = f * Q , ( t ) = Hf* Pr(t). Whence N,(u, x) s N,(Hf*Pryx) 6 cM(Hf)(x) and 1 < P < 00. CIIM(Hf)llp S cllfllp, In case p = 1, we note that f* Qr(t) = (f*Qr(t) - H,-J(t)) + H,-J(t), and consequently by Theorem 2.6 N,(u, x) S c(Mf(x) + H*f(x)). Thus (3.11) also holds and the proof is complete.
I I N Y ( ~ ) l l pS
Two remarks about the above result: the estimate (3.10) points to a satisfactory state of affairs when 1 < p < 00 (a proof of a similar statement which does not rely on the Hilbert transform is sketched in below) and the estimate (3.11) does not. More precisely, if we denote by H P ( D )the Hardy HP space consisting of those harmonic functions u in D such that
I$(:;
IlP
lu(re")Ipdt)
c A < 00,
0
00,
(3.12)
T
and call the infimum over the constants A in (3.12) the HP-norm of u, then for 1 < p < 00 the conjugate u, u ( 0 ) = 0, of a harmonic function u in HP(D ) is also in HP(D) and its norm does not exceed a multiple of the norm of u ; for p = 1 we only have a weak-type result. In particular, if we now denote
4. Further Properties of Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
181
by HP,(D) the analytic Hardy H P space cnsisting of those analytic functions
f such that ~ ~ ( & [ ~ f ( r e i r ) l P d t ) l i p 4 A < mO, < p < a
(3.13)
and call the infimum over the constants A in (3.13) the HP, norm of J; then for 1 < p < 00 each u E H P ( D ) is the real part of an analytic function f~ HP,(D)and the HP, norm off does not exceed c ( H P norm of u ) ; we cannot make a similar assertion for p = 1. Since it is quite an interesting problem to determine under what circumstances a harmonic function is the real part of an analytic function f in H i ( D ) ,or H : ( D ) , 0 < p < 1, for that matter, we develop now some further properties of harmonic functions to address this question. Clearly, this is connected to the question of when Hf E Lp(T ) , 0 < p C 1, the case p = 1 being particularly interesting.
4. FURTHER PROPERTIES OF HARMONIC FUNCTIONS AND SUBHARMONIC FUNCTIONS
We seek now to use to advantage the fact that harmonic functions satisfy Laplace's equation; we begin by showing the mean value property they verify. Proposition 4.1. (Mean Value Property). Let u be harmonic in D and suppose that D ( z o ,r ) = {z E D : Izo- zI < r } is totally contained in D. Then
'I
u(zo)= 2r
u(zo
+ reir)dt.
T
Proof. Assume first zo = 0; then by Proposition 3.1 u(reir)= ~ c j r ' " e V ' and
2r
I
u(re") dt
= c0 =
~(0).
T
If zo # 0, let U ( z )= u ( z + zo); then U is also harmonic in D(0, r), now, and u(zo) = U ( 0 )= ( 1 / 2 ~ ) U(re")dt = (1/2r) u(zo+ reir)dt.
IT
I,
Corollary 4.2. Assume u and D(zo,r ) are as above, then
'I
u(zo) = ITr2
D(zo,r)
u( z) dx dy.
(4.2)
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
182
Prmf. By Proposition 4.1 we get
='I I 2~
T
+ se")s ds dt
u(zo
f0.r)
whence the conclusion follows passing from polar to Cartesian coordinates. rn It is interesting to note that the converse to Proposition 4.1 is also true (cf. 6.19). An important consequence of the mean value property is the distribution of the maximum and minimum values of a harmonic function in a connected domain. Proposition 4.3. Assume that a continuous, real-valued function u verifies the mean value property for each diskD(zo, r ) c 0, and that A = S U P , , ~ U ( Z<) 00. Then either u is identically equal to A in D or else u ( z ) < A for every z in D.
Prmf. Let % = { z E D : u ( z ) = A}; by the continuity of u, % is closed in D; we show now it is also open. By (4.2) it follows that for each zo interior and sufficiently small r, to 0, u ( z ) dxdy
s A.
(4.3)
Therefore, if for some such zo we have that u(zo) = A, then, by (4.3) and the continuity of u, u ( z ) is identically equal to A for z in D(zo, r ) and % is open relative to D. Since D is connected, either % is D or empty. In the former case u is constant and the latter u ( z ) < A for each z in D. A closer look at the above proof shows that the full strength of the mean value property was not invoked to obtain the maximum principle, but rather the fact that the value of a function at a point is dominated by the average of its values near that point. This is an important property which is satisfied, for instance, by u = max( u l , u2),where u1, u2 are harmonic in D (note that u is not necessarily harmonic); it is therefore natural to investigate such functions further.
Definition 4.4. A real valued function s is said to be subharmonic in D if
(i) -00 s s(z) < 00, z E 0, (ii) s is upper semicontinuous, i.e., s(zo) z lim sup s(z), ' 2
zo
zo E 0,
4. Further Properties of Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
183
and (iii) if zo E D and D(zo,r ) = 0,then
‘I
s(z0) s ITr2
s ( z ) dx dy.
(4.4)
D(zo,r)
First, we try to establish sufficient conditions which will assure that a function is subharmonic; an important tool in this endeavour is Green’s theorem. There are some restrictions concerning the domain D in the statement of this theorem, but we shall not be concerned with them since in our applications D is either a disk or a difference of disks. The statement of Green’s theorem is the following: Assume D is a sufficiently smooth domain and u, u are C 2 ( D )functions; then [ i u Au
- u A u ) dxdy
=-
an
(4.5)
where ds denotes the element of arc length along the boundary aD of D and a/an denotes the directional derivative along the inward normal into D. We are then in a condition to prove Proposition 4.5. Assume u only if A u ( z ) 3 0, z E D.
Proof. By setting u W Z O , r) = D
I
=
E
C z ( D ) .Then u is subharmonic in D if and
1 in Green’s theorem ( 4 . 9 , we note that for
(4.6)
D(zo,r)
Let now I ( r ) = ( 1 / 2 ~ r ) u ( z o+ reir)d t ; a simple computation shows that ( r I (r))’ = (1/27r) u’(zo+ reir)eirdt, and, since the inward normal to T at t is ( - e i r ) by (4.6),we see that
I,
I,
I
D(zo,r)
Au(z)dxdy
=
(rI(r))’.
(4.7)
If the Laplacian of u is S O , then by (4.7),r I ( r ) is nondecreasing, and, since its value at 0 is u ( z o ) ,we obtain that
‘I
u(z0) =z2-r
+
u ( z o reir)dt T
and (4.4) follows by integration as in Corollary 4.2. Conversely, suppose there is a point zo in D where Au(zo) < 0. Then by continuity the same
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
184
holds in a small neighborhood D(zo,r) of zo, and, by (4.7), r I ( r ) decreases for small enough r; this implies that for those r’s
& 1,
u(zo
+ re”) dt < u(zo)
which, by integration, contradicts (4.4) at z o . As a first application of this result we have Proposition 4.6. Let f(z) be analytic in D. Then lnlf(z)l is subharmonic there.
Proof. It is a tedious but straightforward computation. Let f ( z ) = u ( z ) + iu(z) and put H ( z ) = ln(u(z)’
+ u(z)’+
T)’/~,
7 > 0.
We show that A H ( z ) 3 0 for z in D. Since u, u are harmonic and (u, u ) is a Cauchy-Riemann pair, a direct computation shows that
Whence for each 77 > 0 and D(zo,r) c D
and the desired conclusion follows by Fatou’s lemma. W Corollary 4.7. Let f(z) be analytic in D. Then If(z)I“is subharmonic there for each E > 0. Proof. Note that Jensen’s inequality, 5.1 in Chapter I, gives at once that if s is subharmonic and 4 convex and increasing and continuous at t = -00, then, also, +(s) is subharmonic; the desired conclusion follows from Proposition 4.6 with 4 ( h ) = eEh,E > 0.
Before we go on we need one more property of subharmonic functions, namely, Proposition 4.8. Suppose s is continuous and suharmonic in D and 0 < r, 7 < 1. Then
s(qrei‘)s ~ ( 7 .* ) pr(t),
rei‘ E D.
(4.8)
Proof. For a fixed 7 < 1 and z = reir, let u ( z ) = s ( 7 * P , ( t ) ; then, by Proposition 2.5, u is harmonic in D and continuous up to the boundary. a )
4. Further Properties of Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
185
In addition s(7.z) - u ( z ) is subharmonic in 0, SO at the boundary, and consequently by the maximum principle also SO throughout D; this gives (4.8) and we have finished. The first application we give of these results is to the identification, among all harmonic functions in 0, of those which are the real part of analytic functions in HP,(D), 0 < p < 00. This result is due to Hardy and Littlewood. We also identify it as half of the Burkholder-Gundy-Silverstein theorem, and it provides the key to the development of a purely real variable theory of Hardy spaces.
Theorem 4.9. Assume f = u + iu E H z ( D ) , 0 < p < 00, HP, norm off < A. Then there is a constant c, independent off such that IINa(u)llp,IINu(u)llp
(4.9)
GA.
Proof. Let s(re") = If(reir)I"p, 0 < 7 < 1; by Corollary 4.7, s is continuous and subharmonic in D. Moreover, sup r
2~
I
s( reir)'/"dt
s AP < 00
(4.10)
T
and {s(rei')}is bounded in L'/"(T); therefore by Proposition 3.2 in Chapter I1 there are a sequence rk + 1- and a function h E L'/"( T ) , Ilhlll/, s Avp, such that
'I
lim k-tm2T
s ( r k e i r ) 4 ( tdt)
'I
=-
T
2T
for 4 E L('/")'(T). Since for each r < 1, P,(x it for 4 in (4.11) and thus obtain lim s ( r k * *) P r ( x ) = h * P r ( x ) ,
h ( t ) + ( t )dt
(4.11)
T
a )
E
L('/")',we may substitute
0 < r < 1,
x E T.
(4.12)
k-ca
Moreover, since, by Proposition 4.8, s( rrkei') S s( rk * ) * P r ( x ) and, by continuity, limk,, s(rrkei') = s(re*), from (4.12) it follows that s(re") s h * P r ( x ) , or If(re")lp s ( h * P,(x))'/",
0 < r < 1, x E T.
(4.13)
Thus, taking sup in (4.13) over reix E r , ( t ) and by Theorem 2.2, we get that Na(lfl,t)" s N , ( ( h * Pr)"", t ) S c,(Mh(t))'/'. Whence ~ ~ N , ( U ) ~ ~ ~ IIN,(u)llp d IIN,(lfl)llps caIIMhll://?ps cA, (4.9) holds and we are done. H This extremely interesting result has many important consequences. We identify a couple of them as they relate to what we can say about those f's for which H ~LE (T).
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
186
Proposition 4.10. Assume f E L( T ) , Hf E L( T). Then N,(f* P,) and Nu(Hf * P,) are integrable and there is a constant c = c, independent off such that
IIX(f*Pr)III, IINa(Hf*Pr)II1s C ( l l f l l l + IIJlflll).
(4.14)
Proof. Let F ( z ) = f * P , ( t ) + iHf* P,(t), z = reir. Then F E H:(D) with norm s (Ilflll + IIHflll). Indeed, since, as is readily seen, Hf * Pr(t ) = f * Q r ( t ) , then (f*P , , f * Q,) is a Cauchy-Riemann pair, F ( z ) = f * P,(t) + iHf*P , ( t ) is analytic, and for r < 1
llflll
+ The conclusion follows now by Theorem 4.9. I I H f l l 1 9
Corollary 4.11. Suppose f z 0 is integrable and H ~LE ( T ) . Then f~ L In L( T). Proof. By Proposition (4.1) N,(f*Pr) is also integrable. Moreover, since by (2.4) P , ( t ) 3 c / ( l - r ) for It1 < 1 - r, then
f ( x - t ) dt s cf* P,(x),
0 < r < 1,
Ibz,,1-r
and M f ( x ) < c N , ( f * Pryx) < cN,(f*Pryx). Thus Mf is also integrable and the desired conclusion follows by Theorem 5.4 in Chapter IV. It is natural to consider whether Theorem 4.9 and Proposition 4.10 admit a converse. More precisely, if a harmonic function u verifies N , ( u ) E Lp(T ) , O < p s l , i s u = R e f ; f ~HP,(T)?Orif N , ( f * P , ) ~ L ( T ) , d o e s i t f o l l o w that Hf E L( T)? We prefer to postpone the discussion of these questions until Chapter XIV where we do the real variable theory of the Hardy spaces. In the meantime, and to provide a glimpse of things to come, we show
Theorem 4.12. Assume u 3 0 is harmonic in D and Nu(u ) E Lp(T ) ,0 < p < 1. Then there is an analytic function f E HP,(D)so that u = Ref and H z norm o f f < cu(0) < c ~ ~ N , ( u ) ~ c~ independent ,,, of u. Proof. Let v be the conjugate to u so that v ( 0 ) = 0; we show that the analytic function f = u + iv verifies all the required conditions. For 77 > 0 put F,(z) = (u(z)’ + v(z)’ + 7’)”’ and G,,(z)= - ( u ( z ) + T ) ~ a; simple computation shows that
AF,, = p ( ( $ u ) ~ + ( $ v ) ’ ) ( u 2
+ v2 +
+ v’) + 277’)
5. Hamack’s and Mean Value Inequalities
187
and
AG,,
+
+ ( ”axv ) ’ ) ( u
= (1 - p ) p ( ( ” uax )’
v)P-’.
Thus there is a constant c = cp = O( 1/ 1 - p ) so that 0 s AF,, s c AG,, and
I,
Oe I D A F , , ( z ) d x d y S c
A G , , ( z ) dx dY.
(4.15)
We may now invoke Green’s theorem on both sides of (4.15) and obtain that
j r $ F q ( r e i r ) dt
S c
I,
-G,,(reil) dt. :r
(4.16)
Whence, by integrating (4.16) with respect to r, it now follows that Ir
I,.,
-F,,( re”) dr dt
=
:r
I,
+
(u(Re”)’+ v(Re”)’+ T ’ ) ~ / ’dt - 2 ~ ( u ( 0 ) ’ T ’ ) ~ / ’
. _
e C 2 T ( u ( 0 ) + 7 ) P - J>u(ReiI)
(
+7
) dt~ .
)
(4.17)
Thus letting 71 + 0 in (4.17) we get
~ ~ f ( R e i tdt) lsp ~ ( 0 ) ~ with c independent of R, and we are done.
5. HARNACK’S AND MEAN VALUE INEQUALITIES Nonnegative harmonic functions satisfy an important inequality which restates the maximum principle in strong terms, namely,
’:r
Theorem 5.1 (Harnack’s Inequality). Let u be a nonnegative harmonic function in D and let D(z,, r ) c D. Then
(:
sup u ( z ) e D(.o,r)
inf u ( z ) . D(z0.r)
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
188
Proof. By the monotonicity of the Poisson kernel in [0, P ) it follows that for 0s t s P I-r 1-r2 l + r ( 1 r)'
+
f'r(t) s
I-r2 =
l+r 7
(5.1)
Furthermore, since by Theorem 3.4 there is a nonnegative measure p such ), ( 5 . 1 ) yields that u(re") = p * P r ( t ) , u ( 0 ) = ( 1 / 2 ~ ) p ( T integrating 1-r
l+r 1
1
- p ( T ) s u(re") s -- d T ) . l + r 2 ~ 1-r21r Thus
+
sup u(re") s -u(o) 1-r
D(z0.r)
4
(i
':r
-
inf u(re"). D(ro,r)
As for harmonic functions of arbitrary sign, in addition to the mean value property, there is a mean value inequality due to Hardy and Littlewood; we begin by proving a version which follows at once from the maximum principle
Proposition 5.2. Assume u is harmonic in D and let D ( z o ,r ) c D(zo,R ) c D. Then there is a constant c independent of r, R and u such that sup 1u1 s
D(zo,r)
c I
( R - r)2
lu(z)l dx dY.
(5.2)
D(zo,R)\D(ro,r/2)
Proof. By the maximum principle the sup on the left-hand side of (5.2) is attained at a point z , with Izl - zol = r, and by Corollary 4.2
'I
=2
=P
,
u ( z ) dxdy,
p < R - r.
(5.3)
D(zI,P)
We distinguish two cases according to the relative sizes of r and R ; if R s t r we put p = R - r in (5.3), and if R > 4r we put p = r / 2 there and note that in either case D ( z , ,p ) E D ( z o ,R)\D(zo, r / 2 ) . W Observe that by Holder's inequality the right-hand side of (5.2) may be whenever 1 < P < a;the replaced by ( c / ( R- r)p-2)IIUI~LP(D(zo,R)\D(zo,r/2)) remarkable fact is that it may also be replaced by a similar expression for 0 < p < 1 as well.
Theorem 5.3. Suppose u is a measurable function defined in D ( z o ,R , ) which verifies
4. Further Properties of Harmonic and S u b h a r m o n i c F u n c t i o n s
189
for all 0 < r < R < R, and some 0 < po < co with c independent of r and R Then there is a constant c = cp so that (5.4) holds for 0 < p < po as well. More precisely, sup IuI s D(z0,r)
cp
(R-
(I
lu(z)lpdxdy)’ip
(5.5)
D(zo,R)\D(zorr/2)
for all 0 < r < R , , with cp independent of r and R.
Prooj. Note that, if 0 < p < R , , it follows by (5.4) that Moreover, since lulpo = ( ~ u ( l - p ~ p ~ ( u ~we p ~ also p o ) phave o
Iu( z ) l p o dx d y D (z o . R )\D ( z o . r / 2 )
S U P ~ ( ~ , ~ ) ~ U
)
Whence combining (5.4) and (5.6) we get
for all 0 < r < R < R , . Fix now r, < Ro < R , ; we will show that (5.5) holds with r = r,, R = R, there. u(z)lpdx d y ) ’ / ” ;then dividing both sides of (5.7) Let = (~D(zo,Ro)\D(zo,r~/2)~ by I we see that for r, s r < R s R,,
since
I
u(z)” dx d y / I p s 1
D(zo,R)\D(zo,r)-
(as Ro* R and r rewritten as
3
ro). With the notation u ( z ) = lu(z)l/I, (5.8) may be
(5.9)
190
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
for ro
r
S
ro=R07,
Ro. Let
T =
ro/ Ro < 1, and consider the sequence
k = 1 , 2 ,....
,
rk=Ro
(5.10)
j=1
Note that { r k } is increasing, rk - rk-] = Ro(l - ~ ) / 2and ~ , lirnk,, rk = Ro. We apply now (5.9) successively with R = rk, r = r k P l ,k 2 1 and obtain sup v = s D(Z0.d
s
C
(Ro(1 - 7)/2>’/””
( sup
v)l-p/po
D(zo,r,)
C
C
(&( 1 - 7)/2)’/’O( (Ro(1 - T)/2’)’/p0
and in general (5.11) where for k = 1,2,. . .
j=O
j=O
This is all we need to complete the proof; indeed, since as is readily seen lim d 4 k ) = Po/P,
lim ICr(k) = (Po/P)’
k-m
k-m
and lim k+m
( sup
(I--P/P0)k
v)
= 1,
D(zo.rk)
by letting k + 00, (5.11) gives at once
-
C
( R-~ro)2/p’
which, on account of the definition of v, is precisely what we wanted to show. Because of its importance, we emphasize Theorem 5.3 in the particular instance of harmonic functions. The reader should also consider the corresponding statement for nonnegative subharmonic functions as well. This is Theorem 5.4 (Hardy-Littlewood). Assume u is harmonic in D and let D ( z o ,r ) c D ( z o ,R ) c D. If 0 < p < 00, then there is a constant c = cp
191
6. Notes; Further Reading and Problems
independent of r, R, and u such that
We will have many an occasion to apply Theorem 5.4. In this section we use it to show that the radial maximal function of a harmonic function controls the nontangential maximal function. Proposition 5.5. Assume u is harmonic in D. Then for each a 0 < 7 ) < 1, we have x E T,
N,(u, X ) s c M ( N , ( u ,*)")(x)"",
where c
=
3
1 and (5.12)
c~,, is independent of u and x. Consequently,
llN*(411ps
Cll~I<~>ll,,
0 < p < m.
(5.13)
Proof. Since (5.13) follows at once from (5.12) (just pickplr] < 1) we only show (5.12). Also by rotation it suffices to do the case x = 0, i.e., eiO= 1. To estimate lu(w)l", w E r,(O),we consider two cases, namely, w far from er near to the boundary; we only discuss the latter here because it is the one which offers some difficulty. Thus assume 11 - wI s 1/2a and note that D(w, (1 - lw1)/2) E D(1, (a++)(1- Iwl)) n D = D , ; to see this let z E D(w, (1 - Iwl)/2)andestimateIl - zI s 11 - wI + Iw + 21 s (a+ f ) ( l - Iwl). Therefore, by Theorem 5.4 with D(w, (1 - lwl)/2), we see that
S [-(l-lwl~,l-lwll
" I
S
(1 - Iwl)
[-~l-lwl~,l-lwll
s
CM"I(U,
*)")(O),
J
N,(u, t)"r dr dt [1-(1-~wl)/2,1)
N l ( u , t)" dt
with c independent of w, and we have finished.
6. NOTES; FURTHER RESULTS AND PROBLEMS
The first sep in solving a steady state heat conduction problem is to find a differential equation which governs the situation; we will do this in the
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
192
disk D. The natural coordinates are polar and the temperature at the point rei' is denoted by u(r, t ) . Consider, then, any section of D given by 0 < ro < r < rl < 1 , O S to < t < tl < 2 ~Since . we are considering a steady state, the rate at which heat flows into this section must be zero for otherwise the average temperature would change with time. Now it is a basic postulate of heat conduction that the rate at which heat crosses a curve C is proportional to the integral along C of the normal derivative au/an, or the derivative of u with respect to arc length along any curve perpendicular to C. When C is the side f = tl we take the perpendicular curves to be given by r = const. Then, since the length of a circular arc is the angle times the radius, in this case we have au/an = r-'(au/at)(r, tl) and the rate at which heat flows into the section along the boundary t = t , is
where k is the conductivity. Adding the expressions corresponding to all the boundaries and setting the net flow equal to zero we get
Upon dividing by (tl - to) and letting tl + to and then dividing by (rl - ro) and letting rl + ro we get that
_1 _a2z u ( r o ,to) +ro at
:r(
r-u r:
)(ro,
to) = 0
for any point roei%in D; this is the polar-coordinate form of Laplace's equation, the main subject of this section. Laplace's influence on mathematics, as well as in our daily affairs (as a member of the Bureau de Consultation des A r t s et MCtiers he was quite influential in the design and adoption of the metric system), is a lasting one. F. Riesz made significant contributions to many fields of mathematics, including the theory of Hardy spaces, but the subject he created and developed is that of subharmonic functions. The proof of Theorem 5.3 given here is based on some idea of Chipot [ 19841. Further Results and Problems
The converse to Proposition 1.3 is not true, namely, that there is a series which converges radially but is not (C, 1) summable. (Hint: For t 6.1
6. Notes; Further Reading and Problems
fixed let c,
=j
f(r)
193
sin jt. Then =
zJzljr'sinjt
r(1 - r') sin t / ( l - 2rcos t + r2)
=
and therefore limr+l-f( r ) exists and equals zero for every real t. If the series in question is (C, 1) summable at t, then limJ+mc , / j = 0, and, consequently, limJ+msin j t = 0; this in turn implies that t = k.rr for some integer k For instance by taking t = .rr/2 we get that 1 + 0 - 3 + 0 + 5 * * is Abel summable to zero but is not (C, 1) convergent.) 6.2 Suppose that C c, = s(A,) and 1 < p ; show that limJ+mc,/js = limJ+msJ/jS = 0. 6.3 (Fatou) If, for some t E T ,+ ' ( t ) exists (in the notation of Theorem 3.4) and is 00, then also limr+l p * P r ( t )= co; the result still holds for nontangential convergence provided the measure p is nonnegative. 6.4 Show that IIQrlll l n ( l / l - r), as r + 1. 6.5 Suppose that f E L In L( T), and let u ( z ) = f * Pr(t ) , z = re"; show that N, ( u ) is integrable. Is the same true for N, ( u ) ? Here u is the conjugate to u with u ( 0 ) = 0. 6.6 Let f be as in 6.5. Show that
-
lim
[If*
r, (0)
z = relX+1,ZE
Pr(x +
a )
-fill
= 0.
Is it also true that lim z = relX+ i,zd-,(o)
[If*
Qr(x
+ - ) - Hflll = O?
(FejCr-F. Riesz) Suppose f~ Lp(T), 1 < p < co, and putF(re") = supp<,lf* Pp(x)I, 0 < r < 1. Show that there exists a constant c = cp independent of f and x E T such that jLo,l) F ( re")p dr s c I,lf( t ) l pdt. Moreover, iff E L In L( T), then F E L([O,1)). (Hint: Note that F(re") s (supr~.p
194
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
6.12 (The Neumann Problem) Given an Lp function g, 1 s p s 00, g ( t ) dt = 0, find a function u in D so that Au = 0 and - ( 3 u / 3 r ) ( r e i r ) converges nontangentially to g a.e. Is there a corresponding statement for g in C ( T)? (Hint: u(z) = 1 cjrlJ'eur, where the cj's are chosen so that the (formally) differentiated series converges nontangentially to -g; note that in the limit we get ( 3 / 3 n ) u ,the directional derivative of u along the inward normal into D.) 6.13 State and solve the Dirichlet and Neumann problems in arbitrary disks D ( z o ,r ) . 6.14 (M. Riesz) Suppose u is harmonic in D and N , ( u ) E L P ( T ) ,1 < p < 00. Then there is a function f E H : ( D ) so that u = Ref and H : norm of f s cIIN,(u)llp, c independent of u. (Hint: The reader may assume u 2 0; the proof of Theorem 4.2 works here with G,(z) = (u(z) + T ) ~ . ) 6.15 Let f be analytic in D ; if R e f 2 0, then f~ H : ( D ) for 0 < p < 1 and its H ; norm s c l f ( 0 ) l p .(Hint: Since Ref = I(. * P, we may invoke Proposition 2.10 in Chapter IV.) 6.16 For each 0 < p < 1 there is a function u E H P ( D )so that its cqnjugate v, v ( 0 ) = 0, is not in H q ( D ) for any q. (Hint: In fact there is an analytic function f(z) = u(z) i u ( t ) such that u E H P ( D ) for all p < 1, yet v H 4 ( D ) any q ; the function f is Cz=l &,z2"/(1- z2"+'),for some choice E, = + l . This example is from Duren's [1970] book.) 6.17 Assume u E C 2 ( D )and D(zo, r ) c D ; then
IT
+
(Hint: Apply Green's theorem to u and v(z) = In(r/Jz - zol) in D(zo,R)\D(zo, E ) ; then let E + 0.) 6.18 Suppose f~ L, f - C cjeiir is such that Il(d/dr)(f* P,)Il,, = 2, 4 E L([O,1)); then Clcjl < 00. (Hint: For 0 ( ( 1 - r)'Ip4(r)), 1
11
-(f* P,) (1/(1 - r))l'pdr,
I[o,l)ll:r
the last step being due to Hausdod-Young. When p of a well-known result due to Bernstein.)
=2
this is a variant
195
6. Notes; Further Reading and Problems
Suppose u satisfies the mean value property (4.1). Then u is a C", harmonic function in D. (Hint: For each z, in D we show that u is C"(D(zo, R ) ) , D(z,, R) c D ; first let r$ be a C", radial function, i.e., r$ ( reir)= 4 ( r ) ,supported in D( z,, (1 - 1z01)/2) = D with 4(z) dx dy = 1 (cf. 4.12 in Chapter I) and note that for R < (1 - 1z01)/2 and w in D(zo, R), 6.19
I ,,
I -( IT
r$( r ) dr
= u( w )
= u( w ) ;
C0,l)
changing variables z + z - w shows that the differentiation can be done on the r$ and consequently u E C"(D). Moreover, since
I
&u(zo
+ reir)dt = a
Tar
u(zo + reir)d t )
ar
a
= -(27ru(z,))
ar
= 0,
by Green's theorem and the Lebesgue differentiation theorem we see that
1 as
Au(z) d x d y r + 0,
+ Au(zo)
everywherein
D.
The idea in the first part of the proof can be used to estimate the growth of the derivatives of u as well.) 6.20 (Weyl's Lemma) Suppose u is a locally integrable function in D whose distributional Laplacian vanishes there. Show that u is a C"(D) function. (Hint: If r$ is a C"(D) function with small support and r$(z) d x d y = 1, it is readily seen that U ( w ) u ( w + z)r$(z) d x d y is harmonic in a disk D ' c D (D' depends on the support of r$), and by U ( w + reir)dt for w in D' and all r Proposition 4.1 U ( w ) = (1/27rr) sufficiently small; but U converges to u uniformly on compact subsets of D: thus u is continuous in D and satisfies the mean value property.) 6.21 Iff E C"(D) and u is a locally integrable function D whose distributional Laplacian equals f in 0, then u is a C"(D) function. 6.22 Suppose u is harmonic in {z = x + iy E D : y > 0)and u ( x ) = 0; show that u can be extended to be harmonic in D by the formula u ( x - iy) = - u ( x + iy), y > 0. (Hint: It is clear that the extension is continuous in D and harmonic, except, perhaps, at y = 0. For x E D then let D ( x , r ) c D and solve the Dirichlet problem A u = 0 in D ( x , r ) , u(z) = u ( z ) for Iz - X I = r; by the explicit expression of u given by 6.13 it follows at once that u = u in D(x,, r ) . )
ID
=ID
I,
196
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
Suppose that u is harmonic in D\{zo} and lu(z)l = O(ln(l/lz - zol)) as z + zo. Show that u can be redefined at so as to be harmonic in D. (Hint: Let D(zo, r ) c D and solve the Dirichlet problem Au = 0 in D(zo, r ) , u(z) = u(z) for Iz - zol = r ; if we can show that u = u in D(zo, r)\{zo} we can remove the singularity by putting u(zo) = u(zo). To dothis,considerthefunction u(z) - u(z) + E lnlz - zol in D(zo, r)\D(z0,6), sufficiently small 6, and invoke the maximum principle.) 6.24 (Harnack) Suppose {u,} is a monotonic increasing sequence of harmonic functions in D ; then either u, (z) diverges to +co everywhere in D or else u,(z) + u(z) uniformly in every compact subset of 0, and u ( z ) is harmonic in D. (Hint: Clearly, u( z) exists everywhere in D as either a finite or infinite limit. Suppose that there is a zo in D so that u(zo) < co. Then for n > rn sufficiently large we have u,(zo) - u,(zo) < E and by (a simple variant of) Harnack’s inequality it follows that 0 < u,(z) - u,(z) < C,E for z in D(zo, r ) c D. Thus u,(z) converges uniformly there to a finite and continuous limit u ( z ) ; similarly, we get that, if u(zo) = co,then u(z) = 00 for z in D( z,, r ) c D. Thus the sets where u ( 2 ) = 00 and u( z) < co are both open in D and one of them must be empty. That u(z) is harmonic follows easily from the Poisson integral representation of each u, which holds in the interior of D). 6.25 (Green’s function) The function G(z, w) is said to be a (classical) Green’s function of z with respect to the domain D and the point w of D if (i) G is harmonic in D\{w}, (ii) G is continuous up to the boundary of D\{w} and assumes the value 0 at the boundary; (iii) G + lnlz - wI is harmonic at z = w and hence everywhere. Show that if a Green’s function exists it is unique. Also show that for disk D the Green’s function is given by G(z, w) = h(lz - w’I lwl/lz - wl), w # 0, G(z,O) = ln(l/lzl), where w’ = w/l WIZ. 6.26 If u is harmonic in 0, then lulk is subharmonic there for k 3 1. If, then (ln’lfl)” is subharmonic in on the other hand f is an analytic in 0, D for k 2 1. 6.27 Assume that u is subharmonic in D and that p is a nonnegative Bore1 measure on a compact subset of K of D ; show that u(z + w) d p ( w ) is subharmonic in D and harmonic in D\K. 6.28 Let u be an upper semicontinuous function in D, then u is subharmonic in D if and only if for every harmonic function u defined in an open subset 6 of D and every w in the boundary of 6, limsup,,,,,o(u(z) u( z)) s 0 implies u( z) - u ( z) s 0 for all z in 0. (Hint: If u is subharmonic, then the condition follows by a maximum principle argument. Conversely let D(zo, r ) c D and note that since u is upper semicontinuous there is a sequence {u,} of continuous functions decreasing to u on aD(zo, I) as n + 00. Let U,(z) denote the harmonic function in D(zo, r ) with boundary
6.23
I,
6. Notes; Further Reading and Problems
197
values u,,(z); V,, is continuous up to the boundary, u(zo)C Un(zo)and u(zo) s lim
'I
-
n - 3 2 - 1 T~
u,(zo + reir)dt =
1
6.29 A subharmonic function s in D is said to have a harmonic majorant if there is a harmonic function u ( z ) such that s ( z ) s u ( z ) throughout D. Show that this occurs in D if and only if sup,,,(l/2~) ITs(reir)dt < co. (Hint: The necessity of the condition follows by Harnack's theorem 6.24; the converse follows by 6.28. What is the least harmonic majorant of s?) 6.30 Suppose u 3 0 is continuous in D, has continuous second order partial derivatives in the subset % = {z E D : u( z ) > 0}, and satisfies Au( z) 3 0 in OU. Show that u is subharmonic in D. (Hint: The proof is a combination of the idea in 6.22 and 6.28; once all is said and done the reader will note that the following more general result has actually been proven: If u 3 0 is continuous in D and subharmonic in %, then u is subharmonic in D.) 6.31 (Littlewood Subordination Theorem) Suppose that s( z ) is subharmonic in D and that f is analytic in D and verifies If(z)l iIzI there. Then r
r
J
s ( f ( r e " ) >dt
=S
J
T
o < r < 1.
s(re") d f , T
+
(Hint: The reader may assume that f(z ) e"z, some real A, for otherwise there is noting to prove; thus If(z)l < r for IzI =S r, and, if u ( z ) denotes the harmonic extension of s to D(0, r ) , it follows that u ( f ( z ) )is harmonic in IzI r and by the mean value property
I I
u ( f ( r e " ) )dt
= 2m(f(O)) = 2m(O) =
T
\
s(re") dt T
by 6.28. Also by 6.28 s ( z ) c u ( z ) for z in D(0, r ) and so
T
s ( f ( r e " ) )dt c
I
u ( f ( r e " )dt
=
T
6.32 Suppose that u E H P ( D )and showthat lu(reir)ls c/(l - r)'Ip, where c depends only on the H P norm of u. (Hint: Use Theorem 5.3.) 6.33 Suppose u 3 0 is a measurable function defined in D(zo,R,) which verifies
for a1 0 < r < R < R1 and some 0 < po < co, with c independent of r and R. Then the same conclusion holds for 0 < p < po in place of po on the left-hand side of the above inequality; the constants c on the right-hand
198
VII. Harmonic and Subharmonic Functions
side will depend only on p. Could we replace the inf in the right-hand side ) dx dy)"9 for q > p o , and an appropriate power of by l / ( j D ( z o , ru(z)" ( R - r ) on the left-hand side? 6.34 Suppose u 3 0 is a measurable function defined in D( zo, R , ) which verifies
for all 0 < r < R < R , and some 0 < po < q < co,with c independent of r and R. Then the same conclusion holds for 0 < p < po in place of po on the right-hand side of the above inequality; the constant c depends solely on p. 6.35 Assume u 3 0 is a measurable function defined in D ( z o ,R , ) which verifies
for some E > 0 and all 0 < r < R < R , , and constants c, a,x independent of r, R Then the same conclusion holds with the expression on the right-hand side replaced by
and a constant c which depends only on p.
CHAPTER
VIII Oscillation of Functions
1. MEAN OSCILLATION OF FUNCTIONS We introduce in this section a maximal function which has become extremely important in various areas of analysis including harmonic analysis, PDEs, and function theory. The spaces generated by this maximal function are also of interest since, in the scale of Lebesgue spaces, they may be considered an appropriate substitute for L“(T) and beyond. Of course the notion of “appropriate” is a matter of personal choice, but from our point of view an appropriate substitute for La(T) is a space which is preserved by a wide class of important operators such as the HardyLittlewood maximal function and the Hilbert transform and which can be used as an end point in interpolating Lp spaces. In this sense the JohnNirenberg class BMO( T ) we consider below fits the bill. We introduce this space as follows: for f E L( T) let
where c above varies over the complex constants and I is an interval containing x, (I) s 27r. This definition can actually be simplified. Suppose that f is real valued. Then so will be the constant c which minimizes the integral in (1.1). By elementary considerations we expect c to be among those values for which
Since the integrand above equals 1 for f ( t) > c and -1 for f ( t) < c we have, in particular, that I{f > c}l = I { f < c}l. This actually means that any 199
VIZZ. Oscillation of Functions
200
such constant c verifies simultaneously I{f > c}l d 111/2 and I{f < c}l s \Z)/2. In other words c = mf(l)is a median value of f over 1. These considerations can be formalized,and extended to the case whenfis complex valued by introducing the median values mr(I) = r n R e f ( I )+ imImr(I)..Is there, however, a simpler way to choose c? The answer is contained in the next result. Proposition 1.1. If constant c
h
denotes the average of f over I, then for any
Proof. Since
If(t) -hl
If(t) - CI + Ic -hl =z If(t) - CI + (l/lZl) M Y ) - CI dY,
the conclusion follows at once upon integrating over I. Corollary 1.2. For f E L( T) and Z
c T we have
If(t) -&I
dt s 2inf c
I,
If(t) - CI dt.
(1.3)
In view of this corollary we may redefine the “sharp” maximal function in (1.1) by the equivalent expression (1.4)
where I is an open interval containing x, 111 c 2 ~ Clearly, . M # f is a measurable, subadditive function. Let now
Ilfll*
=
IIM”fllm
(1.5)
and put BMO( T) = BMO = {f E L( T ) : Ilfll* < 00). This is the John-Nirenberg space of functions with bounded mean oscillation. Endowed with the norm given in (1.5), BMO becomes a Banach space provided we identify functions which differ a.e. by a constant; clearly, llfl1* = 0 for f(t) = c a.e. in T. Bounded functions f are in BMO and Ilfll, =z 2\lfllm; however, observe that ))xI)I* = 4. On the other hand, does BMO contain unbounded functions? The standard example that this is the case is f(t) = lnltl, It1 < T ; we sketch the proof of this fact. Let I = (a,b) c T. We show that for an appropriate choice of c I ,
1. Mean Oscillation of Functions
20 1
-
which in turn implies that lllnl ](I* s 2. To prove (1.6) we consider three cases, namely, (i) 0 < a < b, (ii) -b < a < b, and (iii) the rest. In case (i), we pick Cr = In b and note that jI/lnltl - In bl dt =
I
(In b - In t ) dt
(46)
= (b - a ) - a(ln b -In a). 2
Therefore,
I I I jrllnltl -In
bl dt
=
(In b - In a ) b-a ’
1-a
and (1.6) follows at once since 0 < a < b. In case (ii) we may restrict ourselves to - b < a < 0 < b. Again pick cI = In b and note that ~rllnltl- In bl dt
=
I
llnltl - In bl dt
(a,-a)
+J
(In b - In t ) dt
=J
+ K,
(-a,b)
+
say. The above computation shows that K = ( b a ) + a(ln b - ln(-a)). As for J, since the integrand is an even function, it equals
2 lim E+O+
Thus J
I
(In b -In 1 ) dt
= 2(-a
In b
+ a In(-a)
- a).
(&,-a)
+ K = ( b - a ) + a(ln b - In(-a)) jIlln/tl - In bl dt
=
1 - (-a)
and (In b - In(-a)) (b + a ) b+a (b-a)‘
(1.7)
Since a < 0, the right-hand side in (1.7) is s l , and (1.6) holds in this case as well. The remaining cases can be reduced to either (i) or (ii) since we are dealing with an even function. Now that we know that BMO functions are not necessarily bounded, the question is how large thay can be; we take another look at lnltl. Fix (0, b) = Z c T and consider those t ’ s in Z where lnltl is large, i.e., consider
oA= { t E I: llnltl - c I / > A},
A
> 0,
Cr = (lnl.I)I. We are interested in OA for large values of A. Clearly, OA = {t E I : t > eA+‘1}u { t E I : t < e-”+‘I}. Obviously, the first set in 0, is
where
empty for A large, and for those A’s we get
10Als I{t E I : t < e-”+‘I}I
= epAeCI.
Vlll. Oscillation of Functions
202
I,
By Jensen's inequality, ecr s ( l / l l l ) eln'dt = I4/2 and consequently ISAI c f\I1 e P A . The remarkable fact is that a similar estimate holds for arbitrary f ' s in BMO and I c_ T. More precisely, we have Theorem 1.3 (John-Nirenberg Inequality). Assume that f E BMO and I G T. Then there are constants c , , c2 > 0, independent off and I, so that lit E 1:I f ( t )
-hl >
< cle-cz'/llfll* 1 1 1
(1.8)
for all A > 0.
Proof. By replacing f by (f-h)/llfIl*if necessary, we may assume that = 1; we must then prove that
h = 0 and Ilfll*
lO,l
= I{t E I : I f ( t ) l > A}[
s cle-czAIII.
(1.9)
This is achieved by the use of the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition. First, since ( l / l l l ) Irlf(t)l dt s Ilfll* = 1, we may invoke the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition for f( t ) X r ( t ) at level 2. We thus obtain (a first generation of) open, disjoint subintervals { I ; } of I such that (i) I f ( t)l s 2 a.e. in I\U I,!, (ii) 2 < ( l / I I J ) J , ! l f ( t ) ldt s 4, and (iii) I;II s f l , I f ( t ) I dt = f I U ( l / I 1 I ) I r I f ( t ) I d t ) c f l ~ l .
c
Next we consider each I,! individually. To simplify notations, fix such an interval, call it I', and consider the function (f(t ) - fil)xIl(t ) . Since
we may invoke the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition of (f(t ) - hi(t)xll(t ) at level 2 and obtain (a second generation of) open, disjoint subintervals { I ; } of I' such that (i) I f ( t ) s 2 a.e. in I'\U 13, dt c 4, and (ii) 2 < (l/ll;l) t)(iii) ~11j'ls f~ J , ; ( f ( t )-hi1 dt s fl1'1.
I,?lf(
Moreover, considering all 1 " s now we also have (i') for each I ' , If(t)l 6 I f ( t ) -hi1 + Ifrll (ii') CalljJ1;I s f Call 11JI'I (4)2111-
2.4 a.e. in I'\u I;, and
We continue with this process and obtain at the nth step a family of open, disjoint subintervals { I ; } of In-' such that
If(
t)l
c 4n
a.e. in
I"-'\U 17
(1.10)
203
1. Mean Oscillation of Functions
(1.11) These estimates are all we need. Suppose first that A > 4 and let n 2 1 be the integer so that 4n < A S 4(n 1). By (1.10) it readily follows that 0; E {t E Z:I f(t)l > 4n} E U Zjn and by (1.11) that
+
l'Al
(f)"lrl*
(1.12)
Moreover, since 2-" = e-" ln and A s 8n, we note that 2-" s c2 = (In 2)/8. Thus by (1.12)
eCC2"
loA]s e-czAIZJ
with
(1.13)
in this case. If, on the other hand, 0 < A s 4, then
loA[s IZ)s cle-c2hlzl
(1.14)
provided that cle-c2A2 1 when A S 4; to ensure that this occurs we set 1 -- e4(ln2)/8 = & > 1. By combining (1.13) and (1.14), we have that in all cases I{t E I: If(t)l > A}[ S & e-(1"2/8)A111, as we wanted to show. The converse to the John-Nirenberg inequality also holds, namely,
Proposition 1.4. Assume thatf E L( T) and that there are constants c l , c2 > 0 so that I{t E I: If(t) -hl> A}I S c1e-'2^lI( for Z c T and A > 0. Then for 0 < c < 4, eclf(t)-frl E L( T) and (1.15)
Proof. We note that the left-hand side in (1.15) equals c
I{t E I : If(t) [0,m)
-fll>
A}\ecAdA s ccllZl
J
e-(c2-c)A
dh,
[OF)
and we are done. Corollary 1.5. Suppose that f E L( T). Then f E BMO with norm and only if
Ilfll*
if
Proof. To obtain the necessity of the condition observe that by the JohnNirenberg inequality and Proposition 1.4 we have (1.17)
VIII. Oscillation of Functions
204
where cl, c2 are the constants in Theorem 1.3 and 0 < c < c,. From (1.17) it follows at once that for p 3 1
JI
and we have finished. Conversely, if (1.16) holds for anyp 3 1, it also holds for p = 1 and the desired conclusion follows from the John-Nirenberg inequality. 2. THE MAXIMAL OPERATOR AND BMO
In this section we prove that the Hardy-Littlewood maximal operator is bounded in BMO.
Theorem 2.1 (Bennett-DeVore-Sharpley). Assume f E BMO. Then Mf E BMO and there is a constant c independent off such that IIMfll* cllfll*. (2.1) Proof. Since M f ( x ) = M ( l f l ) ( x ) and 11 Ifl S 2llfll, (cf. 6.12), we may assume that f 3 0. We must then show there is a constant c, independent of the subinterval J E T and f; so that
Fix an interval J and for each x in J divide those intervals I c T containing x into two families according to their relative size with J; more precisely, let $ , ( x ) = {Ic T : x E I and I c 35 n T} and B;*(x) = {Ic T : x E I and I n (T\3J) # 0).If we set now
and
it clearly follows that M f ( x ) = max(Fl(x), F2(x)). Furthermore, since j , ( M f ( x ) - (Mf),) dx = 0, if 6 = { x E J : M f ( x ) > (Mf),}, we readily see that
205
2. The Maximal Operator and BMO
Thus, if we set %, = {x E 6: F , ( x ) s F 2 ( x ) }and 4!L2 = 6\%,,we may rewrite the right-hand side of (2.5) as 2 2 (F~(x - )(MA,) dx = A + B, (F~(x - )(Mf),) d X +-
m I,,
I JI
I,,
say, and (2.2) will hold for J provided we show that that for some absolute constant c, A, B 6 cllfll*. (2.7) We consider A first. Let now I denote the interval 3 3 n T Since h s infxszM f ( x ) s inf,,, M f ( x ) , then clearly fi s (Mf),, and consequently we may invoke the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition of fxz at level (Mf),. We thus obtain a sequence of open, disjoint subintervals ( 4 ) of I verifying
(i) f(t ) s (Mf), a.e. in Z\U 4, (ii) (w3,< (1/141) Iz,f(t)dt c 2(Mf),, all j , (iii) U 4 E I, and there is an additional property we emphasize: If 1; is the “ancestor” interval corresponding to 4, i.e., I; is the dyadic subinterval of Z which when subdivided gave rise to 4, then (iv) IZJ = 2141 and (l/lI;l) j z ; f ( t )dt s (Mf),. We may then consider (a variant of) the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition g + b of fxz obtained by putting and
= C f r ; x r , ( t )+f(t)xr\ur,(t) i
b(t) =
C(f(t)-h;)xz,(t). j
By (i) and (iv) above it follows that g(t)s
(MA,
in contrast to the usual decomposition where g ( t ) s 2(Mf),. Corollary 1.15 and (iii) and (iv)
(2.8) Also by
llfll:.
(2.9) This is all we need. Indeed, by (2.3) we readily see that F , ( x ) s M ( f x z ) ( x )s M g ( x ) M b ( x ) and by (2.8) and (2.9) that ClJl
+
I,,
F l ( x ) dx d
I,,
M g ( x ) dx
+
M~(x dx)
(2.10)
206
VIII. Oscillatiqn of Functions
Thus passing the first summand from the right to the left-hand side in (2.10), we see at once that A S cllfll*, which is the A statement in (2.7). To bound B we actually prove the stronger estimate F2(x) - (Mf3.r S
~llfll*,
x
(2.11)
E q 2 .
Fix x in q2and let Q be any interval in $72(x);clearly IQI 2 IJI. Consider now the subinterval Q u J of T, 1Q u JI S 21Ql. As above we note that fQu J s ( M A and consequently
Taking sup over Q E 9 2 ( x ) we obtain (2.11), which in turn implies the B statement in (2.7), and we have finished.
3. THE CONJUGATE OF BOUNDED AND BMO FUNCTIONS
As we remarked in 2.7 of Chapter V, if f ( x ) = X ~ ~ , ~ ~ then ( X ) ,f This statement holds in general. In other words,
E
BMO.
Theorem 3.1. Supposef E L"( T). Then? E BMO( T) and there is a constant c independent off so that IIjII, S cllfllrn. The proof of this theorem is essentially contained in that of Theorem 3.3, which we do shortly. However, this is an excellent opportunity for the reader to prove this result directly. At any rate, before we consider our next result we need an observation concerning BMO functions. Proposition 3.2. Suppose f E BMO and I E T, then lf2r
-&I
6
2llfll*,
-&I
5
2kIIfII*,
21
T
(3.1)
and M2kr
2 k ~ T.
Proof. Since (3.2) follows from (3.1) on account of the observation k
- f i ~ CISzjr -hj-lrL
~ 2 . r
j=1
(3.2)
207
3. The Conjugate of Bounded and BMO Functions it suffices to prove (3.1). But this is easy since
zs
2
[ 2 r l f ( t )-f211 dt s 2llfll*.
We are now ready to prove Theorem 3.3 (Spanne, Stein). Assume that f E BMO. Then f there is a constant c, independent of f; such that
E
BMO and
Ilfll, s cllfll,.
(3.3) Proof. Given an interval I c T, we show that there is a constant c, = c( I, f ) so that
;IrIf(t)
- CII dt = C l l f l l * ,
(3.4)
where c is independent of I and f;this clearly implies llfII* s 2cJJfJJ,and we have finished. First, since f E BMO, then f E L2 and f is a well defined, L2 function. Fix an interval I and put
f ( t ) = ( f ( t )- h ) ~ 2 r ( t + ) ( f ( t ) -h)~7-\2i(f) +h
= f d t ) + f 2 ( t ) +h, say. Since (h)" = 0, we have f ( t ) = f l ( t ) + f 2 ( t ) , and it suffices to show that (3.4) holds with f replaced by fi and fi,with suitable constants c,,, and q 2 ,respectively. The estimate for fl, with cr,, = 0, is immediate since
say. By Corollary 1.5, A s cllfll*, and, by Proposition 2.2, B
with c independent of I andf; as we wanted to show.
2llfll,. Thus
208
VIII. Oscillation of Functions
To estimate F2(f) let
I,
denote the center of I and put
where the integral is absolutely convergent, since f2 vanishes in a neighborand the notation k( t) = - l / ( 7r2 tan( t/2)), hood of I. With this choice for c I , ~ we have
” ”
The integrand of the innermost integral in (3.6) was denoted k(t, x, t,) in (1.10) of Chapter V and estimated in (1.13) there by c(lIl/lx - t,12). Thus / I and x the right-hand the innermost integral in (3.6) is of order c ~ I ~-~tIl2 side of (3.6) does not exceed a multiple of
I
~ 1 x -1~
1112
I / I X-
trl’) dx.
(3.7)
T\2I
If now denotes the largest integer k so that 2kI G T, the integral in (3.7) is bounded by
k=l
say. We examine each Ak more closely; since
4. Wk-Lp(T) and Kj-. Interpolation
209
Whence replacing the estimate (3.9) in (3.8), by (3.7) we see at once that (3.6) is dominated by
In other words
(3.10) (3.4) follows by adding (3.5) and (3.10), and we have finished. Theorem 3.4. Assume f E BMO.Then there is a constant c, independent of
J; such that IIH*fll* c cllfll*. Proof. By Theorem 2.13 in Chapter V, H * f ( x ) c(Mf(x) + M(Hf)(x)), and the conclusion follows at once from this on account of Theorems 3.3 and 2.1.
4. Wk-LP(T) AND K,. INTERPOLATION
Let Z c T and (f -h) E Lp(Z), 1 s p < 00. If ( 4 ) is a finite collection of open, disjoint subintervals of Z, then by Corollary 1.2 and Jensen’s inequality it readily follows that
The consideration of a converse to (4.1), which also corresponds to taking l p rather than lm norms on the sequences {(l/lrjl)jI,lf(t) -hll d t ) , as was done in the definition of BMO,leads to Theorem 4.1 (John-Nirenberg).
Suppose thatf
E
L ( I ) and that for some
l
(4.2) where the sup is taken over all finite partitions of subintervals Then (f-h) E wk-LP(Z) with norm c c K f , c independent off:
( 4 ) of z.
VZZZ. Oscillation of Functions
210.
hf. By replacing f by (f- f r ) / K f if necessary, we may assume that
fr = 0 and Kf = 1; consequently, the conclusion will follow once we show AplSAl= A P l { t E I : If(t)l > A}[ c c p
(4.3)
with c independent off, A, and Z. The idea of the proof is to set things so that the Calderh-Zygmund decomposition can get the job done. To start out we must have a number p > I f l l ; in our case, since
p 2 l/lZl’’p will do. For such p, invoke the Calderh-Zygmund decomposition at level p and obtain (a first generation of) open, disjoint subintervals Zj of Z such that
s 2p
+ 2p = 22p,
we may invoke the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition of this function at level 2’p. We then get (a second generation of) open, disjoint subintervals {Z;} of Z’ such that (i) If(t) -fill s 2’p a.e. in z’\U I,? dt s 23p, all j (ii) 2*p < (l/lZ;l) j I j f ( t ) ) II;lf(t) -hi1 dt =s (1/2’p) (iii) ClIj’l ( 1 D 2 p .C
jAf(t)
-hi1 dt.
We would like to rewrite (i) and (iii) in terms off taking into consideration all the 1 ” s . It is readily seen that we have (if) If(t)l s I f ( t ) -fill
+
=S 22p
+ 2p s 23p, a.e. in z’\U I,?,
and summing over all j ’ s corresponding to all Z”s also (iii‘)
Callj’slz;l
s (1/22p) C a l l I l . s I I ~ l f ( f )-511 dt.
We take a closer look at the sum on the right-hand side of (iii’). With l/p + l/p’ = 1, we note that it does not exceed
211
4. Wk-Lp(T ) and K,. Interpolation
Thus (iii’) actually states
c IIi’l
all j ’ s
c (1/22P)( ( U P ) j,lf(t)ld t ) l / p ’ .
Clearly, this process may be iterated as we did inthe proof of the JohnNirenberg inequality: in general, and in the kth step we invoke the CalderhZygmund decomposition for the function (f- & k - i ) x , k - i at level 22(k-1)p and we get a collection of open, disjoint subintervals { I ! } of Zk-’ so that
If(
t)l s
22k-1 p
zk-’\UZ!
a.e.in
(4.5)
and
where l / p
+ l/p’ = 1 and
4(p,k) = ( 2 2 ( k - 1 ) p ) ( 2 2 ( k - 2 ) p ) l / ~ ’ ( 2 2 ( k - 3 ) p ) ( 1 / ~ ‘ ) * . . . p ( l / P ‘ ) k - ’ To complete the proof all we need is a good estimate for the right-hand side of (4.6); note that 1 22/~’(1:=li/(P’)’-’) --
4(p,k) - (22(k-1)p)I + l / ~ ’ + ~ ~ ~ + ( l / p ’ ) “ ~
Moreover, since, :,I
(4.7)
j/(p’Y-’ = 1/(1 - l / ~ ‘ =) pz, ~
c MP’Y
c m
00
=P
and
MP’Y = P/(p’)k,
j= k
j=O
the right-hand side of (4.7) can also be written as 2Zpz/p’(22(k-1) p)P/(P‘)’/ (2Zk-1 ) p)P.
(4.8)
Furthermore, since ( k - l ) / ( ~ ‘c) ~cp = c for all k 2 1, the numerator in (4.9) does not exceed ~ p ~ / (and ~ ‘consequently )‘ the right-hand side of (4.6) is bounded by
We pick now p = 2/1Z)1/pand observe that with this choice,
(fI,!
pplp’
-
r)l dt 6 2P/P’K f -= c,
which finally obtains that for this choice of p the right-hand side of (4.6) is bounded by c/(22(k-l)p)P.
(4.10)
212
VIII. Oscillation of Functions
We are now ready to prove (4.3). First assume A > 2p and let k be the largest integer 31 so that 2*&-’p < A. In this case, and on account of (4.5) we have that 0,c U I f , where the union is taken over all j ’ s and k’s. By (4.10) then (4.11)
10Ald ~ / ( 2 ( ’ ~ - ’ )sp c)/~A P ,
which is what we wanted to show. It only remains to consider the case A s 2 p = 4/lI11/p;but now AplOAls APIIl d 4 and we are done. Not only is Theorem 4.1 of interest in itself but it also has important applications. The one we consider here is to interpolate with BMO as an endpoint space. Theorem 4.2 (Stampacchia). Suppose T is a linear operator which is bounded in Lpo(l), 1 d po < 00 and which is of type (00, *) there, i.e., ; T maps L p ( I )into itself, po < p < 03. (1 T ~ ( ( B M o ( ~I()( f ( ( ~ - ( ) , )then Proof. Let (4) be a finite partition of disjoint subintervals of I, and put
We claim that T is a sublinear mapping simultaneously of types ( p o , po) and (a),@) with norm, in each case, bounded independently of the particular partition of I. This is easy to check in the co case since II~fll, s (1 Tfll*s cllflloo (all norms are taken over I) and for po note that since the 4 ’ s are disjoint, by (4.1) we have
c 2( 1, l T f ( t ) - (Tfirlpodt)l’poccllTfllpo+ ~
z
~
1
’
~
Moreover, since IIll/polTflrs (ITfllpb, also I.fl, s cllfllpo,and our claim is verified. By the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem in Chapter IV we obtain that T is bounded on Lp(I),po < p < co,with norm bounded independently of the partition ( 4 ) as this is the case for p = p o , 00. Moreover, since the 4 ’ s are disjoint we readily see that
and consequently for each f in L p ( I ) ,K , s cllfllp, with c independent of JByTheorem4.1, Tf- ( T f r isinwk-LP(I)withnormscllfllpforpo
o
~
~
~
~
5. ,Lipschitz and Morrey Spaces
213
(p, p) for po < p < 03. By the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem, S is actually of type ( p , p) for the same range of p's. Next we show that T is bounded in Lp(I),recall that by assumption T is bounded in Lpo(I).Observe that
s cllf IIP,
and we have finished. H Remark 4.3. A particularly interesting application of Theorem 4.2 is to the conjugate operator as this is a linear operation simultaneously of types (2,2) and (00, *). This proof is not simpler than the one we gave in Chapter V since it relies on Theorem 4.2, which in turn makes use of the CalderbnZygmund decomposition; in other words, both proofs depend on the same basic principle. 5. LIPSCHITZ AND MORREY SPACES
We say that f is Lipschitz of order a in I, 0 < a < 1, and denote this by f E A,(Z) or Lip,(Z) if there is a constant c so that I f ( x ) - f ( y ) l s C I X - yl" for every x, y in I ; the smallest such constant c is called the Lip a norm off and is denoted by l[fllAa. Endowed with this norm Lip,(Z) becomes a Banach space provided we identify functions which differ by a constant (a.e.). Since this norm in some sense measures the oscillation off over I, we are interested in expressing it in an equivalent form that will enable us to apply the techniques developed in this chapter to Lip,(l) as well. We begin by proving Theorem 5.1 (Campanato, Meyers). Suppose that f E L ( I ) and 0 < a < 1. Then the following four statements are equivalent in the sense that each implies the other three and the constants appearing on the right-hand side of each are also equivalent. (i) Ifb)- f ( Y ) l s C l l X - Yl", all x, Y in I, (ii) (1/1J1"") j,lf(t) -&I dt s c,, all J E I, (iii) I f ( x ) -&I s c,lJI", all x E J, J E I, and (iv) ((1/1JI""") j , l f ( t ) -&lpdt)l'p c c,, all J c I, 1 s p
-=
03.
214
VZZZ. Oscillation of Functions
Proof. The equivalence is to be understood to mean that each f which satisfies (ii), (iii) or (iv) can be modified in a set of measure 0 so as to coincide with a continuous function which verifies (i) as well; with this in mind we proceed with the proof. The only implication which is not trivial is (ii) implies (i). So assume x < y are points in I and let J = [x, y ] , (JI = y - x. We then have
-f(v>l =s I f b ) -hl + Ih -f(v)l
A + B, (5.1) say. We only consider A in (5.1), since the estimate for B is identical. We construct a sequence of subinterval {Jk} of J which tends to x as follows: put J1= J, J2 the left half of J1, i.e., the half which contains x, lJ21 = ilJ1l, and so on. Clearly, for k 2 2, If(x)
c I&+, -h"I
=
k-1
A c If(x) --hJ+
= A1 + A2,
(5.2)
n=l
say. Next note that
c 2c2
IJI" c 2("-1)oL O0
= C,C,lJI".
n=l
Thus, substituting this estimate in (5.2) we see that A c If(x) -hJ+ c,c21JIp, all k > 2. (5.3) Now by Theorem 2.2 in Chaper IV, for almost every x in Z we have limn+mlf(x)-hkl= 0 and consequently by (5.3) we readily see that A cc21x - yl" for almost every x in Z. A similar estimate holds for B, provided, of course, that y is also a point where Theorem 2.2 of Chapter IV applies. Therefore by (5.1) we get that If(x) - f ( y ) I
cc21x - yl",
for almost every x, y
in
I.
(5.4)
Since it is evident that f may be redefined so that (5.4) holds everywhere in Z, the proof is complete. An interesting application of the above result is
Theorem 5.2 (Privalov). Assume 0 < a < 1 and f E Lip,( T) = Lip,. Then f E Lip, and there is a constant c, independent of so that
IlfllL
cllfll*,.
(5.5)
215
5. Lipschitz and Morrey Spaces
Proof. The proof is similar to that of Theorem 3.3. In the notation of that theorem, and by (iv) with p = 2 above, we note that
and since I f 2 1 - f l l s 2 ~ ~ 2 ~ 1 1we 1 "get that
Similarly, since
Ak in (3.8) of that theorem is readily estimated as follows: first,
1
I f ( x ) - L k + l I I dx s ~4(2~+'lIl)'+" 2k+lr
and 2k111 IfZk+lr -hl s CC4k2k111'+",
we see at once that Ak S
JJf2Ct)
c4
-
+
C C , ( ~ ~ ( ~ - ' )k2-k)111"-1.Therefore,
- Cr,2I dt
also,
CC41111+ol,
and we have finished.
~ ~ f ~ ~ A a ,
There is yet another important family of spaces defined in terms of oscillations and we will consider it here briefly since, in some sense, it provides a glimpse of what, in addition to Lip,, lies beyond BMO. Given 1 s p < 00 and 0 d 7 < 1 + p let Zp,,,(T ) = ZP,? denote the class of f~ L ( T ) such that j r l f ( t ) - h I p d t s cPIIIv,
all
I E T.
(5.6)
The smallest constant c in (5.6)above is denoted by and is called the Endowed with this norm, SP,? becomes a Banach space norm off in ZP,?. provided we identify functions which differ by a constant. For each fixed p these spaces coincide with familiar ones for some values of 7 ;for instance, if 7 = 0, Zp,,?Lp; if 71 = 1, ZP,?BMO, and if 1 < 7 < 1 + p , then ZP,,, Lip(q-l),p. In the range 0 < 7 < 1 they are called Morrey spaces and it is possible to show that also j r l f ( t ) l p d ts cl1l" for each I c T. Some relations among these spaces, such as ZP,? E Zp,,,,if p 3 p , and (7- l ) / p = ( 71- l ) p l are quite easy to prove. How about interpolation properties and the action of the conjugate operator on these spaces? The reader may think about these questions, or consult Peetre's work [ 19691.
-
-
-
216
VZZZ. Oscillation of Functions 6. NOTES; FURTHER RESULTS AND PROBLEMS
In the early 1960s John and Nirenberg introduced a space, which they called BMO, in order to be able to use the fact that a function which can be approximated in every subcube Z of a cube Zo in the L mean by a constant a, with an error independent of Z differs also in the Lp norm from a, in Z by an error of the same order of magnitude, 1 < p < a;this is of course one of the meanings of the John-Nirenberg inequality. The proof we give here of this result follows ideas of Calder6n (see Neri [1971] and Garnett [1981]). An interesting description of the role of BMO in the theory of elasticity, as well as the introduction of the local sharp maximal function M$ considered in problem 6.1, is in John’s work [1964]. Further Results and Problems 6.1 Given a measurable function f defined in T and x in T we put
M&f(x) = Sup, inf, inf{A 2 0: I{y E Z: If(y) - C J > A}I < sIII}, where Z is an interval containing x and 0 < s s f (this restriction on s is necessary since for s > f, M & f = 0 for any function which assumes only two values); some properties of this function, such as M{,(f+g)(x) s 2(M&f(x) + Mc,/,g(x)) are easy to show. An important relation is the following: if x E Z, then I{y E Z: If(y) - mf(I)l > 4M&f(x)}l < sill; prove it. (Hint: To show the last relation, given E > 0 let c, = a + ib be such that l{y E Z: If(y) - c,l s M&f(x) + E } J 2 (1 - s)lZl; then
KY
E
1:IRef(y) - 4 > MCSf(x)+ &}I < s l I l
and a similar inequality holds for IZ,f(y) - bl as well. Thus a ( M & f ( x ) + E ) S Re(mf(I)) s a + ( M & f ( x ) + E ) and similarly for b and Im(mf(Z)), and Ic, - m,(f)l s Mc,f(x) + E. Let now I, = { y E Z: If(y) - c,I 2 Imr(Z) - c,!}, Z, = Z\Z,; since it is readily seen that l{y E 1,: If(y) - mf(Z)l > 2(M$f(x) + &)}I = 0, the choice E = M&f(x) completes the proof. Clearly an equivalent statement is l{y E I: If(y) mf(Z)l > 4 inf, M&f)l < sill; this result and the next 5 are from Stromberg’s paper [ 1979al.) 6.2 Let f be measurable, 0 < s s f, Z E J, IJI s 2 k l Z ( . Then Imf(Z) - mf(J)I s ck inf, M&f: (Hint: Cf. (3.2).) 6.3 Assumefis measurable Z E T, 0 < s < f,and A, p > 0; then if I mf(Z)I A there is a collection ( 4 ) of disjoint, dyadic subintervals of I such that no interval 4 is totally contained in {y E Z: M c , f ( y ) > P } , A <
217
6. Notes; Further Results and Problems
I mf(4)l s A + cp ( c is an absolute constant s 1 O a ) and If(y)I s A a.e. in I\(u I j u { y E I : M & f ( y ) > p } ) . This statement corresponds to the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition off and is proved similarly. 6.4 Suppose f is measurable, 0 < s 6 and I E T. Then for P, A > 0, I{y E I : I f ( y ) - mf(I)I > PII s cle-CB/*lIl+ I{Y E I: ~ C , f ( y>) AIL where c, c1 are absolute constants. (Hint: This statement corresponds to the John-Nirenberg inequality and is proved in a similar fashion. An interesting variant of this result is the following: for J; /3, A as above, s sufficiently small, and 0 < p < a,I{y E I: If(y) - mf(I)l> P,
M C S f ( Y )6 APII
w-=/* Ilf - mf(I)ll”L(r,/PP,
6.4 corresponds to p = 0. This result is due to Jawerth and Torchinsky [ 19851.) 6.5 Suppose f is measurable, 0 < s s f, and M & f E La( T). Then f E BMO and Ilfll* ~ ~ M & f One ~ ~ mof. the interesting features of this result is that our original assumption only involved the measurability, and not the integrability, of J 6.6 Suppose f~ L, 0 < s < 1. Then M&Hf(x) G (c/s)M#f(x), x E T. (Hint: Fix I and let x E I; then put fl(y) = (f(y) - mf(I))xzr(y) and f 2 ( ~ = ) ( f ( y ) - ~ ~ ( I ) ) x T \ ~ I ( YSince )Hf(x) = Hfi(x) + Hf2(x), we treat each term separately: it is easy to show that for y in I IHf,(y) - 6 c,M#f(x) and by the weak-type (1,l) property of H that Al{y E I: IHfl(y)> l A}[ s cM”f(x)lIl.) 6.7 A subadditive operator T is of weak-type (1,l) and maps L“ into BMO if and only if for every interval I, f E L + L“ and A > 0, I{y E I: I T ~ ( Y ) - mTf(I)l> 1 ,11 s c l e - c A ~ lmin(lI1, l f ~ ~ - ~ ~ f ~ ~ l / A(Hint: ). The proof of the necessity makes use of the variant of the John-Nirenberg inequality given in problem 6.4. This result is from Jawerth-Torchinsky [19851, where also another necessary and sufficient condition is given, namely, I{M;,Tf> A}l 6 cll{Mf> ch}l, cl, c constants which depend on T but not on f and h > 0.) 6.8 Prove that BMO is complete. (Hint: It suffices to show that if N j T f n ( t )dt = 0, n 3 l,andCllf,II, < a,thenlim,,,C,,=,f, existsin BMO; it is not hard to show that the limit in L actually coincides with that in BMO.) 6.9 Show that Ilflll + Ilfll* gives an equialent norm in BMO, where now functions are identified when they coincide a.e. in 6.10 Does there exist a BMO function f so that f E L”( T)? (Hint: If f E L2(T), then = -f c o ( f ) . ) 6.11 Show that llnlxllP& BMO for p > 1; also X ( ~ , ~ , lnlxl ( X ) E! BMO. 6.12 Show that M”(lfl)(x) G 2M#f(x). (Hint: By Proposition 1.1, jrlIf(t)I - Iflrl dt G 2IIIMt)I - IhIl dt 6 2I,If(t) - f i I d t ) . 6.13 Suppose f E BMO and show that If(t)l* also belongs to BMO for 0 < LY 6 1; this is in contrast to Problem 6.4.
-
CI
5
7
+
VZZI. Oscillation of Functions
218
Suppose f is real valued and show that for each real constant c, M#(max(f; c))(x) s ;M#f(x) and M#(min(f; c))(x) s ; M # f ( x ) . (Hint: max(f( t ) , c ) = i(f(t ) c ) + t ) - CI and min(f( t), c ) = t)
6.14
+
- ilfW - Cl.1 6.15 Suppose f E BMO( I), 11f11* CI
;If(
$If(
+
I,
= 1, f(t ) dt = 0; then f can be written as g + h where h ( t ) = C,:, ajxIJ(t),the 4 ’ s are dyadic subintervals of Z, (ail S c, all j , and llgllms c,; c, c, are absolute constants. (Hint: We take a closer look at the John-Nirenberg inequality; with the notation of Theorem 1.3, let fl =fxI\“I,, fi = C ajxJJ,aj = f J J , (aj[s 2. Next apply the CalderbnZygmund decomposition to eachf’ = (f- uj)xJJand obtainf:,fi as before; repeat this process and set g equal to the sum of all the A’s, h equal to the sum of all the A’s. This result is related to some of Varoupoulos [1977].) 6.16 Here is another way to build up BMO functions: given a sequence ( 4 ) of dyadic (not necessarily disjoint) open subintervals of T, we say that a sequence of functions ( a j }is “adapted” to the 4 ’ s provided (i) aj vanishes off 34, (ii) l a j ( x ) - aj(t)l s Ix - ti, all j , (iii) laj(x)l 6 cl, IuJx)l s c2/lIl a.e., all j . If, in addition, Cj. Jll,ls c31ZI, for all Z G T,then for any adapted sequence of functions we ’have IIC ajll* S c(cI + cz)c3. (Hint: Given Z, separate those 4’s so that 31, n Z # 4 into two families, 8, = (1,: 141S 111) and 8, the rest, and put
C
f(t) =
aj(t),
g(t) =
C
aj(t)-
i;JJ €32
J ;1, E JI
Clearly,
To estimate A = (1/1Z1) j , l g ( t )
- c,l
dt, let
and note that each Ek contains at most A
d
f
k=O
j:JjEEk
1’
I
~
1
cubes ~ 3 and bound
l u j ( t ) - aj(xj)ldt,
where xi
E
4.
I
xi
What this means is that we chose C, = aj(xj).The result is due to Garnett and Jones [1982] and it admits a converse.) 6.17 Suppose f E BMO. Then for 1 d p < 00
with c independent of f: Conversely, i f f € L and (6.1) holds for any 1 s p < 00, thenf E BMO. (Hint: The proof of the first statement is similar
219
6. Notes; Further Results and Problems
in spirit to Theorem 3.3. On the other hand, suppose (6.1) holds for p = 1, say; if z = re”, I = interval centered at t with 111 = 27r(l - r) and x E I, then Pr(x- t) 5 c/lIl,and,consequently, (l/lZl) j I l f ( x )-f* P,(t)ldx s c, all Z. Note that if (6.1) holds for p’s < 1, we may also infer that f E BMO by invoking 6.5 above.) 6.18 With the same notation and assumptions as in 7.14 of Chapter I11 and 7.29 of Chapter IV, show that s* E BMO and IIs*ll* s c(C Irk(’)’/’. (Hint: Given I G T, let N be an integer such that 2 7 r / h ~ + < ] 111 s 27r/A~. There are two cases. First, if such an N does not exist, it is because (11> 27r/Ao, and the bound for (l/lIl) I,s * ( t ) dt obtains at once from 7.29 in Chapter IV. If, on the other hand, such an N exists let t be the center of Z and put cz = sup{ls,(t)l,. . . ,IsN(t)l};we claim that in this case
To show (6.2) we make repeated use of the following fact: if u,, u, 3 0 and l u n - unI s 1 7 then IS UP,,^^ u, - supnaou,l s 1. Let then a ( x ) = sup{lsO(t)l, * * * IsN(t)l, ( S N ( f ) + RN+I(X)I, * . * I S N ( t ) + RN+dX)19* . -1 where R,(x) = C;=,rkfk(Ag); by 7.29 in Chapter IV I s k ( x ) - S k ( t ) l s c(~Irkl2)’/’if k s N, x E I, and, by the above remark, I a ( x ) - s*(x)l S c(C(rk(’)’/’ as well. If now p ( x ) = SUP{IRN+I(X)I,. . . ,IRN+k(x)I,.. .}, then I a ( x ) - cI\ s p ( x ) and finally Is*(x) - czI s p ( x ) c(Clrkl’)’/2 where ((1/1Z1) p ’ ( x ) dx)’/’ s c(CIrkl2)*/’;thus (6.2) holds and we are done. The result is Meyer’s.) 6.19 I f f € BMO, then there exists a constant E > 0 such that 9
+
I,
sup (I{x IET
E
Z: I f ( x ) -hl>
A}~/ I ‘ZI)
s e-*/‘,
(6.3)
whenever A > h ( ~ , f )indeed, ; by the John-Nirenberg inequality, we have E = cllfll*, h ( ~ , f= ) clllfll,. Let now ~ ( f =) inf{s > 0: (6.3) holds} and show that
Moreover, also by the John-Nirenberg inequality there is 7 > 0 such that
< 00,
(6.4)
and let ~ ( f =) sup(7 > 0: (6.4) holds}. Show that ~ ( f =) l / ~ ( f ) .These results are from Garnett and Jones’ work.
220
VZZZ. Oscillation of Functions
6.20
Let 4 be a positive, nondecreasing function defined on [ 0 , 2 ~and ] put 1)=
IZl4(lZl)
j p x )
and finally BMO, = {f E L: l[fll*, tially due to Spanne [ 19651.
-hl
dx,
llfll*,,
= SUP 4(J;1) I= T
< 00). The following results are essen-
if Z E J and
If Z(x, r ) = interval centered at x, length 2r, then Ilf -&., CP(A r ) ; If f~ BMO, and TJ(x) =f(x + s), s 3 0, then
,)I(* s
[If- ~ f l l *
=
O(p(s));
If 4( t ) / t is nonincreasing, then f(x) = j(lxl,l,4( t ) / t dt E BMO, (this is in a way the largest function in the space). + ( t ) = t“, 0 < 77 < 1, and suppose that M$f(x) = supxpr4(J;Z) E Lp(T ) , 1 < p < 1/77; then MZZf E L‘( T ) , l / r = l/p - 77 and there is a constant c independent off such that IIM”fll,. s cI(M$fll,. 6.22 Let Z = [0,1]. We say that a function g is a “pointwise multiplier” of BMO,( Z) provided that gf E BMO,( Z) whenever f E BMO,( Z) and there is a constant c independent off such that Ilgfll*., S cllfll*,,. Assume ) / sthen g is that 4 ( r ) / r is nonincreasing and put $ ( r ) = 4 ( r ) / ~ ( , . , l ~ ( sds; a pointwise multiplier of BMO,(Z) if and only if g E BMO,(Z) n L“(Z). (Hint: Since p(J I ) s ~(r)~~f~~*.,, by 6.20 it follows that for any Z with 1Z1 = r < we have 6.21 Assume
1
-f,g,l
r ~)f(x)g(x)go
dx c 4(r)llgll, s
llfll*,9 + lhl
c 4 ( r )llfll*,,(
1
j l g ( x ) - gll dx
llgll* + Ilgll BMO,,).
Conversely, let Z = Z(t, I ) be an interval as above, let f be the function introduced in 6.20 (iv), and put h(x) = max(f(x - t ) , J ( ? . , , 4 ( s ) / s d sthen ); h is continuous and Ilh l*, G cllfll*,,. Since gh E BMO,, a simple computation shows that g is as it should be. For +(t) = 1, the result is due to Stegenga [1976] and for more general 4’s to Janson [1976].) 4 ( s ) / s 2 ds; one easily checks 6.23 Given 4 as in 6.20 let $ ( r ) = r that $ is nondecreasing, $(r ) + 0 as r + 0 , 4 ( 2 r ) < 2$( r ) and $(r ) 3 4 ( r ) . Show that, iff E BMO,, then Hf E BMO4 and there is a constant c independent off such that 11 Hfll *,J s ~ l l f l l * , ~ . (Hint: The result is Peetre’s [ 19661 and the proof is similar to that of Theorem 5.2.)
6. Notes; Further Results and Problems
22 1
Sarason introduced the class VMO(T) of functions of vanishing mean oscillation in T, consisting of those f s in B MO(T ) for which j , l f ( x ) -hl dx = 0. Obviously, VMO contains every conlim~r~+.,,(l/~I~) tinuous function in T, and since, as is easily verified, VMO is a closed subspace of BMO, it also contains the BMO-closure of C ( T); in fact, VMO is precisely that closure and in many ways VMO bears the same relation to BMO as C does to L". There are many reasons to consider VMO. Here is one: we are already aware that the conjugate f o f f € C ( T ) is not necessarily continuous (cf. 5.14 in Chapter V); however, it is in VMO. A quick proof of this result goes as follows. Iff E C ( T), then we can write it as the sum of a trigonometric polynomial and a function of small L" norm; by Theorem 3.1, f is then the sum of a trigonometric polynomial and a function with small BMO-norm. Thus is in the BMO closure of C ( T ) as we wished to show. For further applications the reader should consult Sarason [ 19791. 6.25 Prove that VMO(T) = BMO,( T ) . 6.26 f~ V M O ( T )if and only if lim,,,llf-f* Pr(-)ll*= 0. 6.27 With the notation of 6.18, show that s* E VMO. 6.28 Let f~ VMO. Then M # ~ C E( T ) . (Hint: It suffices to show that for A > 0, { M # f < A} is open; to do this, suppose M # f ( t ) < A and we will show that the same holds in an interval about t. Since f is in VMO, there l / ~-hl I ~ )dJyI) < M # f ( t ) ;now let exists S > 0 such that S u p ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ( (If(y) J be an interval centered at t whose length is very small compared to 6, let x E J, and, finally, let I be an interval containing x. If 111 < 8, then (l/lIl) J I l f ( y )-hi dy S M # f ( x )< A by the choice of 8 ; suppose then that 111 2 6 and let K = I u J. Then K contains t and 6.24
u
Since IJI is very small compared to 111, the intervals K and I are almost the same and M # f ( x ) < A as well. The same proof works for
and this result has an important application, namely, f is an extreme point of the unit ball of VMO normed by 11 Mrfll,, 1 < p < a,if and only if MFf( t ) = 1. These results are from Axler and Shields [19821.) 6.29 BMO is the natural substitute for L" also in the case of fractional integrals. More precisely, if 0 < a < 1 and p = l/a, then I, maps Lp(T)
222
VIII. Oscillation of Functions
into BMO( T) and there is a constant c independent off such that 11 IJII* G cllfll,. (Hint: With the notation of (2.16), we prove that M ( I , f # ( x ) s cMJ(x). Fix I = I ( x , r ) and put f = fxZ1+ fxT\2r = g + h, say. Note that
1
=z c r F
thus I(I,f)rl c M J ( x ) and consequently ! r I L g ( y ) - (I,g)ll du crMJ(x). By the mean value theorem, we get that for t in I, II,h(x) I,h(t)( d cr (T\211y - xl"-'lf(y)l d y d cM,f(x), a.e. in t, and the right estimate for this term follows by integrating over I. In fact the ideas in this proof give a more complete picture of the general situation when f 3 0, for in that case we have that (i) I J E BMO if and only if M J E Lm and (ii) I,J M,f and M ( I J ) # have comparable norms in Lp, 1 < p < 00. These results are discussed in Adams [ 19751.) 6.30 Let f-1cjeiix, f~ Lip,(T), 0 < a < 1, show that cj = O(ljl-u IlfIl,,). This result is sharp, indeed, iff(t) = Cr=l 2-"" cos 29, then f~ Lip,(T), and cj - j - , , j = 2". (Hint: As in 5.16 in Chapter I we consider g ( t ) = CFi, d , , , ~ ( ~ ~ - ~ , , J twhere ), a, = 2?m/lkl, Ikl Z 0, n = 1 , . . . ,Ikl. Use that c k ( g )= 0 and the choice d,, =Aa"-,,a n ) to obtain the first assertion. Next, observe that if I = (a, b) c T, then m
1
f ( t ) -h = n = l 2-n,(cos2"' =
-
(sin 2"b - sin 2"a) 2"(b - a )
1 2-",A(n, t, I ) , n=l
say. Now IA(n,t, Z)I s 2, but we need a better estimate when 111 is small compared with 2". In that case, IA(n, r, I)I S c(2"lZl). This gives If(t) -&I clIl", t E I, and we have finished. Note that, if a = 1, the above estimate becomes If(t) -hl d clIl ln(2m/lIl) instead.) 6.31 LetfE Lip,, 0 < a < 1 and show that s.(X x) - f ( x ) = O ( n 7 In n ) as n + CD, uniformly in x ; this result cannot be improved. 6.32 Let f~ L. Then a,(J x ) - f ( x ) = O ( n - , ) if and only i f f € Lip,, O
6.33 Let 0 < a, p < a + /3 < 1, and consider I, as an operator on Lip,. For what value of y is the result I,: Lip, + Lip, true? 6.34 Let T be a linear operator such that T: LPo+ L5',,,,, and T: Lp*+ 2pl,q,. Then T :Lp + zp,,whenever l / p = (1 - t9)/po + 8 / p , and T = (1 - O)T0 + eT1, 0 s 8 G 1. (Hint: The proof is straightforward once we consider the operator T),f = Tf - (Tf),: the result is Stampacchia's.)
CHAPTER
IX Weights
1. THE HARDY-LI'ITLEWOOD MAXIMAL THEOREM FOR REGULAR MEASURES Let p be a nonnegative Bore1 measure in R", finite on bounded sets. For this measure we pose the question of whether it differentiates p-locally integrable functions f ; in other words, if x E R" and Z is an open cube containing x, does the statement limp(r& 1 / p ( I))j r f ( y ) d p ( y ) = f ( x ) hold p a.e.? Here 111 denotes the measure of I. As in the case of the Lebesgue measure in Chapter IV we opt to approach this question by first considering a weak-type result for the corresponding maximal function. More precisely, if for x E R" and f locally in L,(R") we put
where the I's are open cubes containing x, is the mapping f + MJ of weak-type (1, l ) ? We can go about answering this as follows: let 0, = { M , f > A}; 0, is open since to each x in 0, there corresponds an open cube I, containing x such that
and consequently I, c OA.In fact
0,=
u I,.
(1.3)
xeU*
We want to estimate p ( 0 , ) in terms of the p-measure of the (complicated) set on the right-hand side of (1.3); it is apparent that we need some control 223
ZX. Ap Weights
224
over this set. So, suppose, in addition, that p is regular; in other words, if % is p-measurable, then
If K is a compact subset of OA now, there are finitely many Zx’s,Zx,,. .. ,I ,, say, so that K s U ,; Ixj; in fact, we may avoid unnecessary overlaps by .,. However, even once this discarding any cube Ix, such that Ix, c Uj+kI is done we may still be left with quite a bit of overlap. To handle this we proceed as follows. Since we are dealing with a finite number of cubes, there is one with largest sidelength (if there is more than one just pick any); separate it and rename it Zl.Now, if any of the remaining cubes, say I, intersects I,,since sidelength Z s sidelength of Zl,it follows that I c 311, the cube concentric with Zlwith sidelength three times that of Zl;all these cubes Z can be discarded as well. We are thus left with a finite collection of open cubes, each one disjoint with Il .Repeat for this family the procedure used to select Zl,that is select a cube with largest sidelength, call it I,, and discard all other cubes which intersect it. After a finite number of steps we are left with a collection {II,.. .,zk} of disjoint open cubes so that K E 31,. Thus
u;=,
Under what circumstances can we replace p ( 3 4 ) by p ( 4 ) in (1.5)? This can be done for the so called doubling measures, namely those measures p for which p(21) s cp(Z), all open cubes Z, c independent of I. In case p is doubling then from (1.5) it follows that
where c is the doubling constant of p. But the 4 ’ s are special cubes; in particular they all satisfy (1.2). Whence combining (1.6) and (1.2), and since the 4 ’ s are pairwise disjoint, we get k
Finally, on account of (1.4), (1.7) gives
2. The Hardy- Littlewood Maximal Function and the mapping is of weak-type (1,l) with norm =sc have proved
225 2
. Summing up, we
Theorem 1.1. Let p be a nonnegative Bore1 measure in R" which in addition is finite on bounded sets, doubling, and regular. Then the mapping f + MJ is of weak-type (1, I), with norm
IIqJllL;
CllfIlL;,
1 < P < 03.
=
cp
(1.9)
Proof. M, is of weak-type (1, l), and is bounded in L:. Thus the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem applies. W Corollary1.3. Let p beasintheorem 1.1,andletfbelocallyin L:(R"). Then
Proof. Since p (K) < co for compact sets K , continuous functions are dense in L:(R"); the proof is therefore entirely analogous to Theorem 2.2 in Chapter IV. W
2. Ap WEIGHTS AND THE HARDY-LITILEWOOD MAXIMAL FUNCTION The boundedness of the Hardy-Littlewood maximal function is an essential ingredient in the consideration of the L P ( T )behavior of the various operators we have considered thus far. It is natural, then, to expect that the LP,(R")behavior of the Hardy-Littlewood maximal operator will have important applications in the study of weighted norm inequalities for similar, n-dimensional, operators. We open our discussion with the study of the necessary conditions; more precisely, suppose there is a constant k = k,,, independent off such that for some p, 1 s p < CO, and allf E LP,(R")and A>O h P P ( { M - > A))
kPllfll%;.
(2.1)
What can we, then, say about p ? Simple examples show, for instance, that p cannot have atoms, but in fact much more is true.
IX. Ap Weights
226
Theorem 2.1. Assume p is a nonnegative Bore1 measure, finite on bounded sets and assume that for some 1 S p < co (2.1) holds. Then (i) p is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure, i.e., there is a nonnegative, locally integrable function w such that d p ( x ) = w (x) dx. (ii) for all open cubes I and f E LP,(R”)
where c = cp,k is independent of $ (iii) ( A pcondition) w satisfies Muckenhoupt’s A p ( R ” )= Ap condition, or w E Ap;i.e., there is a constant c = cp,k independent of the open cube I so that
or
I
The infimum over the constants on the right-hand side of (2.3) and (2.4) is called the Ap, or A l , constant of w ; moreover, the Al constant of w is less than or equal to ck and the Ap constant of w is less than or equal to ckP-’, p > 1. A statement which depends on the Ap constant of a weight w rather than on the weight itself is called “independent in Ap.” Theorem 3.1 below is an example of this. (iv) (Strong Doubling) For each open cube I and measurable subset E of I, s c(lll/lEI)PP(E),
where c
=
(2.5)
cp,k is independent of E and I.
Proof. (i) Suppose the Lebesgue measure IE( of E is 0. We show that also p ( E ) = 0. By the regularity of the measures involved we may assume that E is compact and that, given E > 0, there is an open set 0 3 E such that p(0\E) < E. Let f(y) = X B \ ~ ( ~ ) ;then JE LP,(R”) and l l f l l ~ ; = p(O\E) < E. Next observe that M f ( x ) = 1 for x E E : indeed, to each x E E there corresponds an open cube I c 0, x E I, and consequently 1/111 j r f ( y ) dy = I(O\E) n 11/1I1 = 1 since IEl = 0. By (2.1) it then follows that p ( E ) S p ( ( M f 2 f})C 2PkPllfllPL:s CE,which gives the desired result as E is arbitrary.
227
2. l%e Hardy- Littlewood Maximal Function
(ii) Fix an open cube I and consider for f~ LL the quantity which we may assume >O. Since (1/111) jrlf(y)l dy =
If], must be finite for each 1,for otherwise (2.1) cannot hold unless p is the 0 measure. Thus, if we put 0 = { M ( f X r )> lflr/2}, by (2.1) and (2.6) it follows that p ( I ) S p ( 0 ) s k ” ( l / l f l ~ ) ” l l f x ~ lwhich l ~ ~ : , is equivalent to (2.2). (iii) and (iv) Since there is no a priori reason why w cannot vanish on a set of positive measure, we introduce the measure d v ( y ) = d p ( y ) + E dx, E > 0, to avoid unnecessary technical difficulties. Clearly, v is also absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure, d v ( y ) = u ( y ) dy, u > 0, and, more importantly, (2.1) also holds with p replaced by v with constant independent of E. Assume p > 1 first. In order to estimate u(y)-”(”-’) dy we note that it equals Ill/ullpL’, l/p + l/p’ = 1, which by the converse to Holder’s inequality may be estimated by
I,
Now by (ii), which also holds for v, it follows that for such f’s
and consequently
Unraveling (2.7) gives (2.3),that is, the Ap condition for u. Next we show that (2.5) holds for u; indeed, note that
which by (2.7) does not exceed c k v ( E ) ’ / P ( I I I / v ( I ) ’ / PIn) . other words
v(I) s ck”(IZI/IEI)”v(E).
(2.8)
IX. Ap Weights
228
Since the constant in (2.8) is independent of E, we may let E + 0 there and obtain that p ( I ) 6 ckP(III/IEI)Pp(E)as well; i.e., (iv) holds. Moreover, if there is a set E with IEl > 0 so that p ( E ) = 0, then by (2.5) p is the 0 measure since it vanishes on any open cube I containing E. Thus d p ( x ) = w ( x ) dx, w > 0 a.e., and the above argument may be repeated with w in place of u; this completes the proof when p > 1 . The case p = 1 is rather simple since by putting f = xE, IEl > 0, in (ii), we see that (IEl/lIl) d c k ( p ( E ) / p ( I ) )or equivalently
P(O/IIl C k ( P ( E ) / I E l ) , (2.9) which is (iv). Furthermore, by choosing E to be a sequence of open cubes converging to a Lebesgue point x of w so that w ( x ) ess inf, w, (2.9) gives (2.4), and the proof is complete.
-
3. A , WEIGHTS As we have seen, A , is a necessary condition for the Hardy-Littlewood maximal operator M to map L,(R") into wk-L,(R"), but is it also sufficient? Theorem 3.1 (Muckenhoupt). Suppose w E A , . Then M maps L,(R") into wk-L,(R"), with norm independent in A l . Proof. First note that if w E A , , then p is doubling with doubling constant s c ( A , constant of w ) ; indeed, since (1/1211) d p ( y ) C c ess inf, w s c ( l / l I l ) d p ( y ) , it readily follows that p ( 2 I ) c c p ( I ) , c s 2 " ( A , constant of w ) . Moreover, since
I,,
I,
we also have that M f ( x ) C c M J ( x ) , c = A , constant of w. Thus {Mf> A} E {MJ>A/c}, and by Theorem 1.2 Ap({Mf>A})s 3 ( A / C ) P ( { M J > Ale)) =s c IlfllL,. Some observations concerning Al are obvious: for instance, A , is the limiting Ap condition as p + 1+ and an equivalent way of stating Al is M w ( x )s cw(x)
a.e.
(3.1)
3. A, Weights
229
But what are the A, weights? Can we give some examples or even characterize them? As a first step we consider powers of 1x1, i.e., 1x1". When n = 1 and 71 > 0, by letting I = ( 0 , 6 ) we note that (1/6) j(O,b)X" dx = l6"/(7 + 1) + 00 as 6 + 00, whereas inf, x" = 0. Thus positive powers of 1x1 are ruled out, but how about negative powers? We must have -n < 7 C 0 for otherwise 1x1" is not locally integrable, but this is essentially the only restriction. Indeed, we have
Proposition 3.2. Suppose -n < 7 C 0. Then 1x1" E A,; more precisely, there is a constant c independent of I such that
Proof. Fix a cube I and let I, denote the translate of I centered at 0; we consider two mutually exclusive cases, to wit (i) 21, n Z # 0 and (ii) 2 1 0 n I = 0. In case (i) we have that 610 2 I and ( l / ~ I ~ ) ~ , ~ xC ~ " d x ( l / ( I ( )j6r01xI"dx c ~(ll"'", where cis a (dimensional) constant, independent of I; clearly, (3.2) holds in this case. Case (ii) is easier, for then 1x1 lyl for x, y in I; indeed, we have 1x1 c Ix - yl + lyl G clIll'" + IyI clyl, and the opposite inequality follows by exchanging x and y above. Thus IyI" G cinfr)xlg,all y E I, and averaging over y in I, (3.2) holds for case (ii) as well. H Next we consider functions which behave like (XI", -n < 7 S 0, and show that they also are A, weights.
-
Proposition 3.3 (Coifman-Rochberg). Let p be a nonnegative Bore1 measure so that Mp(x) is not identically 00. Then for each 0 s E < 1, Mp(x)" E A,, with A, constant which depends only on E. Proof. Recall that Mp(x) = S u p x E ~ ( l / ~ Z ~ ) For p ( I )a. fixed open cube Z we ,Mp(x)" dx by A" = (inf, M p ) " as follows: for each x in estimate (l/lI() I I we divide those open cubes Q containing x into two families by setting $I = {Q: IQI C I2Zl) and $* = {Q: IQI > 1211). Thus
= A(x)
+ B(x),
say. The estimate for B ( x ) is readily obtained; since for Q 3 Q 2 Z, it follows that
(3.3) E
$2
we have
and B ( x ) 6 CA
(3.4)
IX. Ap Weights
230
with c independent of p. As for A(x),let p , denote the restriction of p to 61, i.e., d p , ( y ) = xsr(y) d p ( y ) , and note that
A ( x )d w h ( x ) .
(3.5)
Thus on account of (3.3), (3.4), and (3.5) we get that
and it suffices to prove the desired estimate with M p replaced by M p l . But by (a simple variant of the Lebesgue measure version of) Theorem 1.1 and 7.5 in Chapter IV, we readily see that [I
1 MP~(X dx) S~ -c(wk-L norm of M p I ) E ( I I 1 - "
with c depending only on
I[I
E,
and we have finished.
The interesting fact is that the converse to Proposition 3.3 also holds, name1y,
Theorem 3.4 (Coifman-Rochberg). Assume w E A,. Then there are functions b and f and 0 d E < 1 so that (i) 0 < A d b ( x ) d B < 00 a.e. (ii) J E L,,,(R"), M ~ ( Xis )finite ~ a.e. and w ( x ) = b(x)Mf(x)'.
The proof of this theorem relies on the so-called "reverse Holder" pr (perty of w ; this property is of independent interest and plays an importaat role in the theory of weights.
Theorem 3.5 (Reverse Holder). Suppose w E A,. Then there is a positive number q so that
where c = c,, is independent in A , and independent of 1,but not, of course, of q ; we abbreviate (3.7) by w E RH,,,,.
3. A, Weights
23 1
Now, suppose that Theorem 3.5 has been proved. Then by (3.7) also E A, ,M ( w'+")(x) s cw(x)'+" a.e. and Theorem 3.4 holds with b(x) = w ( x ) / M (W ' + " ) ( X ) ' ' ( ' + " ) , f(x) = w(x)'+", and E = 1 / ( 1 + q ) . It thus only remains to prove Theorem 3.5, which we do forthwith. In order to assure that the various integral expressions we consider are finite, we introduce the function v ( x ) = min(w(x), N); clearly, v E A,, (A, constant of v ) s ( A , constant of w), independently of N: indeed, for a given I let A = inf, w and consider two cases, namely, (i) A 3 N and (ii) A < N. We then have wl+"
N s inf, v,
in case (i),
w ( y ) dy s c inf, w
s c inf, v, in case (ii),
thus proving the claim. We show (3.7) with w replaced by v first; let q > 0 and observe that
=A+B,
(3.8)
say. Clearly, B
(3.9) which is the right estimate. The bound for A is not so readily obtained, and in the course of the proof we must keep track of the various constants appearing to be sure that they only depend on the A, constant of v, and 77 of course. First observe that with the notation 0,= { y E I: v ( y ) > t } we have A = (1 + q )
j
S V,+"IIl,
t"lo;l dt
Cv1,m)
lSSlds)' dt
IX. Ap Weights
232
which is also of the right order. Next we show that for an appropriate choice of 77, D is dominated by the (finite) quantity (3.12)
which may then be passed to the left-hand side of (3.8) to obtain the desired conclusion. We consider the innermost integral in D first. It equals (3.13)
Now since t > 0 1 , we may invoke the (n-dimensional version of the) Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition of u at level t, thus obtaining a collection of open, disjoint subcubes (4) of I with the following properties (i) v ( y ) s t a.e. in I\U 4 and (ii) t s (1/141) u ( y ) dy < 2"t, all j.
I,
From (i) it is clear that { u > t} c_ does not exceed
u4 and therefore the integral in (3.13) (3.14)
Furthermore, since u E A,,
c inflJu, UIJ
c
since lj is a Calder6n-Zygmund cube.
{29,
Therefore by combining these bounds we get that ulJ=s(c infrJu)'-'(2"t)", all j , O < E < 1. Thus each summand in (3.14) is dominated by ct'lIjl(infIJ v)'-' s ct" jrJ u(y)'-" dy and (3.14) does not exceed (3.15)
We need one last observation: from the left-hand side inequality in (ii) it 4 G {Mu > t}, and, since u E A, and M v ( x ) 6 c v ( x ) a.e., follows that we also have U 4 G { u > t / c } . Consequently, (3.14) is bounded by
u
ct'
I
{V>t/C)
v(y)'-"dy,
0<E <1
4. A, Weights, p > 1
233
and the same is true of (3.13). Whence
(3.16)
First fix 0 < E < 1 and then choose 77 > 0 sufficiently small so that cv(1 + q ) / (+~7 ) < this is clearly possible. Thus D is dominated by (3.12) and (3.7) holds with v in place of w there. This is a minor inconvenience since by Fatou's lemma
t;
'/I+"
6 lim inf N+m
( I,i
'/I+"
v(y)l+? d y )
and the proof is complete. H 4. A,, WEIGHTS, p > 1
As we have seen, Ap is necessary for the Hardy-Littlewood maximal operator M to map LP,(R") into wk-LP,(R") and a simple argument similar to Theorem 3.1 shows it is also sufficient. However, a stronger result holds. Theorem 4.1 (Muckenhoupt). Suppose w E A,, 1 < p < 00. Then M maps LP,(R") continuously into itself, with norm independent in Ap.
Proof. For a nonnegative function f in LP,(R") and an integer -00 < k < 00, put A, = { y E R": 2, < M f ( y ) S 2k+'} and let %k be a compact subset of A,; we estimate Mf(y)'d p ( y ) by cllfll;;:, where c is independent of f and the %k's, and depends only on the Ap constant of w. A simple limiting argument then gives the desired result. To each y E A, we assign an open cube Iy containing y so that
Iuq,
f ( x ) dx
(<2,+').
(4.1)
IX. Ap Weights
234
Since %k E Ak, there are finitely many I , , ’ s , none of which is contained in the union of the others, { 4 , k } y i ? say, so that each cube verifies (4.1) and %k E U y5:) 4.k. Moreover, since
we must estimate the right-hand side of (4.2); a good estimate depends on our ability to avoid unnecessary overlaps of the $,k’s. This is achieved as fOllOwS: put E 1 . k = I 1 . k n % k , E 2 , k = ( I 2 , k \ I l , k ) n % k , and, in general, Ej,k
= (4,k\u
Ii,k)
%k,
i<j
j =
2, - *
* 3
n(k)
(4.3)
For each k the Eik’s are clearly disjoint, and by (4.3) it follows that (4.4)
Therefore, by (4.4) and (4.1) we also have
1
2kpp(E,k)
j,k
(4.5)
Let u ( x ) = W ( X ) - ” ( ~ - ’ ) , d v ( x ) = ~ ( xdx; ) then the right-hand side in (4.5) can be rewritten as
What we are attempting to do here is to bring a combination of the A, condition and Theorem 1.1 into play. Let ‘rn be the measure on Z + x Z given by
With this notation the expression (4.6) becomes I l { a j , k } l l h , where the sequence a j , k = ( I / V ( 4 . k ) ) j I j , k ( f ( x ) / u ( x d) )v ( x ) . Note that this expression also equals
235
4. Ap Weights, p > 1
where O,,= {(j,k ) E Z+x 2 : a j , k > A}. What we need then is a good estimate for m(O,,);we use the notation Z ( A ) = U ( j , k ) E O , Ij&. Observe that for each (j,k) in O,,by the Ap condition we have
(4.10)
Since the E j , k ’ s are pairwise disjoint we may replace the right-hand side of (4.10) by c I ,.M , ( ~ I ~ h ) / ~ ) dp(x) ( ~ ) P and ’ invoke Theorem 1.1 to estimate this quantity by (4.11)
Moreover, since W(X)-”‘dp(x) = w(x)’-”’ dx = dv(x) the expression in (4.11) is c v ( I ( h ) )and m(O,,) s cv(Z(.h)).
(4.12)
Now, the 4 , k ’ S whose union is I ( h ) are special cubes; in particular, by the definition of 4, if ( j , k) E OA, then a j , k > A. In other words, A < ( l / v ( I j , k ) )JIj,k(f(x)/u(x)) dv(x). n u s , each such Ij,k and also, consequently, I ( h ) is contained in { M , , ( f / u )> A} and by (4.12) we see that m(‘A) cv({Mu(f/u) > A}). (4.13) This is all we need to complete the proof. Indeed, on account of (4.8) J S c Ip3,m) v ( { M , , ( f / u > ) A}) dhp, which by Theorem 1.1 is dominated by c ~,~(f(x)/u(x))p dv(x) = c j,.f(x)” dp(x), since u(x)-” dv(x) = dp(x). This completes the proof. W Corollary 4.2. M maps LP,(R”)into itself if and only if M maps LP,(R“) into wk-LP,(R“), 1 < p < CO.
IX. Ap Weights
236
The question once again is, what are the Ap weights? Some properties, such as w E A, if and only if w-''(~-')E Ap,, l/p + l/p'= 1, 1 < p < 00, are readily verified, but we need some examples and if possible a characterization of these weights. Proposition 4.3. Assume w , , w, 00; then w E Ap.
E
A , and let w ( x ) = w l ( x ) w 2 ( x ) ' - p 1, < p <
hf. Holder's inequality. Corollary 4.4. lxlq E A p , 1 < p < 00, if and only if - n < 7 < n ( p - 1). In addition of being Apweights, the w's in Proposition 4.3 actually verify some additional properties. More precisely, Proposition 4.5. Assume w ( x ) = wl(x)wZ(x)'-p, w l , wz E A , , 1 < p < 00. Then
(i) (Open ended property) w E A,-,, some E > 0. (ii) (Reverse Holder) w E R H l + , , some 7 > 0. (iii) (Reverse doubling) There is 6 > 0 such that for all open cubes I and measurable subsets E of I, p ( E ) / p ( I )d c ( ~ E I / I I ~ ) where ', c is independent in A p , also independent of E, I. (iv) JRn(1 + Ixl)-" d p ( x ) c p ( I o ) , where I. denotes the unit cube in R" and c is independent in Ap.
Proof. (i) Since w, E A , , by Theorem 3.5, w, E RH1+,; put now E = (7/(1+7 ) ) ( p- 1)> Oandnotethatp - E - 1 = ( p - 1)/(1+7 ) .Itisthen readily seen that
(4.14) and also
Whence, by multiplying (4.14)and (4.15),it follows that w,w:-" we wanted to show.
E
A,-,, as
5. Factorization of Ap Weights
231
(ii) Since w2 E A, from Holder's inequality (applied to (1/1Z1) w2(y)'/"'/~ ~ ( y ) d' y/) ~it' follows that for some constant c > 0 independent of I
I,
(4.16) Let w1 E RH,,,. Then by (4.16)
as we wished to show. (iii) Let w E RH,,,. Then by Holder's inequality
= c( IEl/lIl) ? / l + ? p ( I ) .
(iv) By (i) and the doubling property (iv) of Theorem 2.1, p(2kZ0) < C 2 n k ( P - - E ) cL(Zo), k 3 1.
(4.17)
Thus
and we have finished.
5. FACTORIZATION OF A,, WEIGHTS This section is devoted to proving a remarkable fact, namely, the converse to Proposition 4.3. Before we proceed with the proof of this factorization result we need some preliminary observations; we start with a definition.
IX. Ap Weights
238
Definition 5.1. We say that an operator T is admissible provided it verifies the following four properties. (i) (ii) (iii) A > 0. (iv)
There exists r, 1 < r < 00, so that T is bounded in L'(R"). T is positive, i.e., T f ( x )2 0 for every f in L'(R"). T is positively homogeneous, i.e., T ( A f ) ( x )= ATf(x) a.e. for each
+
T is subadditive, i.e., T(f+ g ) ( x ) S T f ( x ) T g ( x ) a.e.
Some examples of admissible operators include If(x)l, M f ( x ) , and, more important for our purposes, ( ~ ( ~ f l " / v " ) ( x ) u ( x ) "for ) ' ~appropriate " 1< p < m , o < 7 d 1. We verify this last example and in the process we find the necessary conditions on u for this to hold. First, we must find r, the choice r = p / 7 being a natural one; in this case we have IITfll: = J R m M(lfl"/u")(x)'/"u(x)dx and, if we assume that u E All", then this ) = cllfll: and expression may be estimated by c JRn ( l f ( x ) l " / " / u ( x ) ) u ( xdx (i) holds; the verification of (ii) and (iii) are immediate. Thus it only remains to check (iv). Fix x and let I denote an open cube containing x; then by Minkowski's inequality we readily see that
=G
M(lfl"/u")(x)""+ M ( l g y / u " ) ( x ) ' / q
and since I is arbitrary it follows that M ( l f + glp/u")(x)l'pd M ( l f l p / u " ) ( x ) l /+ p M ( l g l P / u " ) ( x ) l / pand , (iv) follows at once. An important property of admissible mappings T is that they also are cT-subadditive; more precisely, we have
Proposition 5.2. Suppose T is admissible and r is the index in pro ert (i) in the definition of T. If {A},f are L'(R") functions with limN+, =f in L', then T f ( x ) ?s CJ:, TJ(x) a.e.
R Y
hf. Since f = (f -
zJzl&) + xJT,&,from properties (ii) and (iv) it fol-
lows that N
N
j=l
239
5. Factorization of Ap Weights
Moreover, since 11 T(f-CJt,f;)llrG c l l f - C ~ , f i I l + . 0 as N + 00, there is a sequence Nk + 00 such that lirn,,,, T ( f - C z , f i ) ( x ) = 0 a.e. This is the sequence of N's we choose in (5.1), and by letting Nk + 00 there we get Tfi(x) a.e. that T f ( x ) S ZT=, We need one more definition. Definition 5.3. Given an admissible mapping T, we say that a nonnegative function w is in A , ( T ) if T w ( x )s c w ( x )
a.e.
(5.2)
We then have Proposition 5.4. Suppose that Tl and T2 are admissible mappings with the same r in (i). Then there exists a function 4 in L'(R") such that 4 is simultaneously in A,( T I )and A,( T2).
+
Proof. Put T = TI T2( T is also an admissible mapping) and let A 11 7'11, the norm of T i n L'(R"). For an arbitrary, nonnegative function g in L'(R") put 4 ( x ) = T j g ( x ) / A J We . show that this 4 will do. In the first place, 4 E L'(R") sinceCJz,((T'g((,/A's Tll/Ar)llgllr< 00. Moreover, by the a-additivity of TI we see that
(CJzo(II
This proves that 4 is in A,(T,) and a similar argument gives that 4 is in A1(T2)as well. W It is now a simple matter to prove the decomposition theorem for the Ap weights. Theorem 5.5 (Jones). Suppose w E Ap,1 < p < 00. Then there are weights w,,w 2 in A , so that w ( x ) = wl(x)w2(x)'-". Proof. Since w E Ap we also have that w - " ( ~ - ' )E Ap,,l/p + l/p' = 1. Let r = pp' and set T , f ( x )= ( M ( ~ f l p ' / ~ l / P ) ( ~ ) ~ ( ~and ) l / PT J) (l x/ )P=' ( M ( ~ ~ p w ' ~ p ) ( x ) w ( x ) - By l ~ the p ) l remarks ~p. at the beginning of this section it follows that TI and T2 are admissible and by Proposition 5.4 there is a
240
IX. Ap Weights
nonnegative, locally integrable function 4 simultaneously in A, ( TI) and A,( T,). This means that T , ~ ( x s )c ~ ( x ) or , M ( 4 p ’ w - 1 / p ) ( x )S c ~ ” ’ ( xW) ( X ) - ’ / ~
(5.3)
and T,+(x) s c ~ ( x ) or , M(+”w’l”)(x)c c+”(x)w(x)””. (5.4) In other words, c$pwl/pand +p‘w-l/pare A, weights. Put now w1 = 4pw1/p, w, = 4 p ‘ w - 1 / pand note that since p p’( 1 - p ) = 0 we have w1w i P p=
+
4P+P’(l-P)w1/Pw-(l-P)/P
=
Remark 5.6. It goes without saying that by Theorem 5.5, Ap weights satisfy properties (i)-(iv) in Proposition 4.5. 6. Ap AND BMO
As both the Ap condition and the definition of BMO deal with the, averaging of functions it is natural to consider whether there is any connection between these concepts. Proposition 6.1. Assume w is a nonnegative, locally integrable function. Then In w E BMO if and only if there is 7 > 0 such that w ” E A,.
Proof. We show the necessity first; by the John-Nirenberg inequality there are constants 7 ) s k/llln wll* and c, independent of I, such that
By removing the absolute values in (6.1) we also have
Whence multiplying the
+
and - estimates in (6.2) it follows that
that is, w“ is in A*. Conversely, assume such an
7)
exists and note that
6. Ap and BMO
241
say. Since both summands are handled in a similar fashion we only do A. By Jensen's inequality
s (A2
constant of
wq),
and we have finished. H A similar statement applies to Ap, namely, Corollary 6.2. Assume w is a nonnegative, locally integrable function, and for some 7 > 0, w" E Ap, 1 s p < 00. Then In w E BMO, Proof. If p s 2, then also w" E A 2 ,and the conclusion follows by Proposi, < 2, and again tion 6.1. If, on the other hand, p > 2, then w - " ' ( ~ - ' ) E A p rp' by Proposition 6.1 In( w - q ' ( p - l ) ) E BMO.
Proposition 6.3. Assume w is a nonnegative, locally integrable function. Then w E Ap if and only if
with c independent of I. As the proof should be obvious by now we omit it. Note however that by Jensen's inequality each factor in (6.4) is at least 1 and consequently the membership of w in Ap is equivalent to two separate conditions, to wit
and
An interesting application of these results is to evaluating the distance from BMO to L", more precisely, an estimate of the expression infgGL-ll4 gll* ,4 E BMO.What is relevant here is the quantity 7(4) defined as follows. Let 7 > 0, verify
IX. A, Weights
242
and put 7( 4 )= sup{7: (6.5) holds}. Two properties of this quantity are readily verified, namely, by the John-Nirenberg inequality 7( 4 )2 c/ )I4 (I*, c > 0, and ~ ( -4g ) = ~ ( 4for ) each bounded function g. We then have
Theorem 6.4 (Garnett-Jones). stants cl, c2 such that
There are absolute (dimensional) con-
c1/71(4) s infgsd14 - gll,
=Z
c2/7(4).
(6.6)
Proof. The left inequality in (6.6) follows at once from the comments preceding the statement of the theorem and we say no more. Next let 4 E BMO and pick 7 so that 7 ( 4 ) / 2< 7 < ~ ( 4 )by; Proposition 6.1 eT4 E A2 and consequently by Theorem 5.4 there are Al weights wl, w2 such that eT4(y) = wl(y)/ w2(y), or
74b)= In W l b )
- In
W2(Y).
(6.7)
Now since on account of Proposition 3.3 Mw,(x)" E A l , 0 < E < 1, with Al constant independent of wl, by Proposition 6.1 it follows that llln wlII* 6 absolute constant, and similarly for w2. Furthermore, since wl(y) zs Mw,(y) s cwl(y) a.e., the function g,(y) = ln(w,(y)/Mw,(y)) E L", and similarly for g 2 ( y ) = ln(w2(y)/Mw2(y)). Thus rewriting (6.7) as (In Mwdy) - In Mw2(y)) + (ln(w1(y)/Mwdy)) - 1n(w2(y)/Mw2(y)) = b ( y ) + g(y),sayweseeatoncethat4(y) = b ( y ) / +~ g ( ~ ) / r lIlg/71lms , 00, I(4 - g / 7 (I* s absolute const/ 7 s c/ 7(4 ) . Therefore the right inequality in (6.6) also holds and the proof is complete.
7. AN EXTRAPOLATION RESULT
This section is devoted to an important extrapolation property the A, weights verify; first we need some definitions and preliminary results. Definition 7.1. We say that the pair (w, v ) of nonnegative, locally integrable functions w, v satisfies the A, condition, 1 < p < 00, and we write (w,v ) E A,, if for all open cubes I and a constant c independent of I,
The infimum over the c's on the right-hand side of (7.1) is called the A, constant of (w, u ) , and a statement involving the pair (w, v ) is said to be independent in A, if it only depends on the A, constant of the pair, rather
7. An Extrapolation Result
243
than on the particular functions involved. Similarly, we say that ( w , u ) E A , provided that
where c is independent of I; the statement independent in A, has the obvious meaning. An example of a result independent in Ap is the following: let d p ( y ) = - w ( y ) dy, d v ( y ) = ~ ( y ) - ” ( ~ -dy, ’ ) v regular and doubling, then the weak type estimate (7.3) holds provided ( w , u ) E A p ,with the constant c in (7.3) independent in Ap. We do the case p > 1; first observe that, by Holder’s inequality and (7.1), for f b 0 we have
where c is the Ap constant of ( w , u ) . Whence by (7.4) it follows that, if
fi > A, then also L
Let now K be an arbitrary compact subset of { M f > A}, by the estimate (7.9, and as in (1.6) we see that p ( K ) s ch-’ J R n f ( y ) ’ d v ( y )with c independent in A, and we have finished. Another result of interest to us is Proposition 7.2. Suppose 0 < 7 s 1, 1 < p < 00 and w E A p . Let g L”;”(R”) and consider G ( y ) = ( M ( g ’ / ” w ) ( y ) / w ( y ) ) ” .Then
(i) [IGl[L$’”ScIlgllL$/” and, (ii) (gw, G w ) E A”+p(l-”).
E
IX. A,, Weights
244
Furthermore, both the constant c in (i) and the Al)+p(l-l)) constant of the pair (gw, G w ) are independent in A,,. Proof. Statement (i) has essentially been proved in Section 5. As for (ii), let q = 7 +p(1 - 7 ) and note that q - 1 = ( p - 1)(1 - 7 ) 3 0, or q 3 1. If 7 = 1, then also q = 1and since G = M ( g w ) /w we have that (gw, G w ) E A , with A, constant 1. Let then 0 < 7 < 1, on account of (7.1) we must show that
x
(i
~ I ( M ( g ' i n w ) ( y ) / w ( y ) ) - q l o l w ( y ) - ' / qd-y)"' '
s c (7.6)
for a constant c independent of I and independent in Ap.Now, by Holder's ~ its conjugate 1/1 - 7 we see at once that inequality with indices l / and
I,
Also since for each y in I M ( g ' / " w ) ( y )3 (1/1I1) g ( x ) ' / " w ( x )dx and q - 1 = ( p - 1)(1- v), the other integral in (7.6) is dominated by
Whence, by multiplying (7.7) and (7.8), we get that the left-hand side of (7.6) is bounded by
s (Ap constant of w)'-?, thus (ii) holds and we are done.
Remark 7.3. Proposition 7.2 may be restated as follows: assume 1 S po < p and w E Ap; then to each nonnegative function g in L F / P ~ " ( R "there ) corresponds a function G 3 g such that 11 GI1L',pIp~)' s c 11 g I( J ~ ' , / ~ O " and
245
7. An Extrapolation Result
(gw, G w ) E A,, with both c and the A, constant of the pair (gw, G w ) independent in Ap.Actually a stronger result holds, namely, Proposition 7.4. Assume 1 s po < p , w E A,,;then to each nonnegative func) may assign G 2 g such that IIGllLF/po)'d tion g in L ~ / P o " ( R "we c 11 g 11 L:Ipo" and G w E A,, with both c and the A, constant of Gw independent in Ap.
Proof. We proceed by induction. Let go = g and put g , in place of G in Remark 7.3. Here, g , verifies the estimate llg, 11 L$'po" S cllg 11 L$IPo", and by (7.3) the inequality
J
Ape {Mf>A)g o ( y ) w ( y )dv
k J R j f ( y ) l p o g l ( y ) w ( y )dy
holds for each f in Lp/po", A > 0 with constants c, k independent in A p . We can use g1 in place of go and so on; in general, given g,, we obtain gj+, 3 gj such that ~ ~ g , + , ~ ~ Lcllg,IILypo"d yP~)'~ ci+lllgollLypo" and the estimate
J
g j ( y ) w ( y ) dv
{Mf>At
k
J
If(y)lpogj+l(y)w(y)dv
(7.9)
(7.10)
R"
holds for every f in Lp/po",A > 0, with constants c and k independent in A,,. Now put G ( y ) ='C:o ( c + l)-jgj(y), where c is the constant in (7.9); since ( c + l ) - ' ~ ~ g j ~ ~ L $d~(mc /) c' + lyllgllLp'po" the series defining G converges in LjlpIPo)' and we readily see that G 2 g and IIGllLF'po)'d ( c + l ) ~ ~ g ~ ~ LMultiplying ~ ~ p o ) ' . each inequality (7.10) by ( c + l ) - j and summing over j we also get
i.e., the Hardy-Littlewood maximal function maps L2w(R") into wk-L2w(R")with norm independent in Ap. We may then invoke Theorem 2.1 part (iii) to infer that actually G w E A, with A, constant independent in Ap. Proposition 7.4 has a counterpart for the case p < po as well, namely, Proposition 7.5. Assume 1 < p < po and w E A p ;then to each nonnegative we may assign G 3 g such that 11 GI1Lf'po-p' s function g in LP,/'Po-P'(R") c ~ ~ g ~ ~ L $ ( pand o-pG ) - ' w E A,, with both c and the A , constant of G - ' w independent in Ap.
IX. Ap Weights
246
hf. We dualize Proposition 7.4; our assumptions are equivalent to 1 < p6 < p', u = w - ~ ' ( ~ - 'E) Ap,,and Ap.constant of 0 = Ap constant of w. Let d v ( x ) = u ( x ) dx.Then by Proposition 7.4 we conclude that to each nonnegative h in L$"lP;'(R") there corresponds H 2 h such that [ ~ H ~ ~ L s~ p ' ~ p ~ ) ' c ~ ~ h ~ ~ and L ~ Hu ' ~ Ep A:, ~ ) with ' c and the A,; constant of Hu independent in Ap.But (p'/p&)'= (po - l)p/( po - p ) so that h E L?'lp;)' is an equivalent -') Also Hu E Aio if and only if way of saying h P o - l ~ - ( p ~ - P ) l (EPLpVl(po-p). ( Hu )- I / ( P ; - ' ) = ( H P o - l W - ( P o - P ) / ( P - I ) ) - l W A . Thus given a nonnegative function g in L',/(po-P), we put g = hpo-lW-Ppp,-p)/(p-l) with h in L$P'/PO', obtain the corresponding function H from Proposition 7.4 and then define G = HPo-1 w-(Po-P)/(P-I).
We are now ready to prove the extrapolation theorem alluded to at the beginning of this section.
Theorem 7.6 (Rubio de Francia). Assume T is a sublinear operator which verifies the following property: there is a p o , 1 s po < 00, such that for every w E Am, d p ( x ) = w ( x ) dx,
IIrfllL2
cllfII~2,
(7.11)
where c is independent off and independent in Am. Then for every p with 1 < p < 00, and every w in Ap, T also satisfies the inequality
II
m.::
CllfII.:,
(7.12)
where c is independent o f f and independent in Ap. h f . We consider two cases; first suppose 1 s po < p , and let w E Ap and
f~ L',. As is readily seen
where the sup is taken over nonnegative g in L',"po" with IlgllLF'po"S 1. Fix such a function g and assign to it the function G 5 g of Proposition 7.4. Then by (7.11) and the properties of G given in that proposition we see that the integrals in (7.13) involving g are dominated by
where the constant c is independent of g and independent in Ap. Thus (7.12) holds and the discussion of this case is complete. Next suppose that
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
247
1 < p < po and again let w E Ap and f E L:. Put g ( x ) = IlfI14Polf(x)lPo-P where f ( x ) # 0, and g ( x ) = 0 otherwise. Now note that
I
If(x)l”og(x)-’ d P ( X ) = llfll2;
(7.14)
{f+-O)
= 1. We are then in a position to invoke Proposition 7.5 and Ilg(lL;/(po-p) and obtain a function G 2 g with the properties given there. Observe that
where the constant c is independent in Ap.
8. NOTES; FURTHER RESULTS AND PROBLEMS
As expected, weighted inequalities are important in considering weighted mean convergence of orthogonal series, since the error terms can almost always be majorized by some version of the Hardy-Littlewood maximal function. In this context see Rosenblum [ 19621 and Muckenhoupt [ 19721. They are also important in the pointwise convergence of Fourier series as well: let s * ( f ;x ) = sup,Js,,(f; x)l, then Ils*(f)llL;S cllfllL;, 1 < p < 00, provided w E Ap (cf. Hunt and Young [1974]). Ap weights and their basic properties have been studied extensively; for instance, Feff erman and Muckenhoupt [ 19741 showed there are doubling measures which are not Ap weights for any p 3 1, and Stromberg [1979b] constructed examples to show that aside from the obvious implications, conditions such as doubling and reverse Holder as well as others we discuss in this section are independent of each other. The proof of Muckenhoupt’s Theorem 4.1 we present here is essentially due to Sawyer [19821 and Jawerth [ 19841 and it does not rely on the (difficult) implication “Ap implies Ap--.” as did the original proof. Sawyer’s idea is somehow related to the notion of Carleson measure which will be discussed in Chapter XV. The reader will note, however, that once the elements for the proof are set up, it very much looks like a Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition argument, especially relation (4.1). In fact Christ and R. Fefferman [1983] have shown that this is precisely the
ZX. Ap Weights
248
case; we prefer to give the more abstract proof since it applies to the very general context considered by Jawerth. The proof of the Jones Ap decomposition theorem given here is due to Rubio de Francia [1984]and that of Rubio de Francia’s extrapolation theorem is due to Garcia-Cuerva [1983].
Further Results and Problems
8.1 Suppose a nonnegative Borel measure p is doubling. Show that (R”
‘p(y) =
Let p be a regular, nonnegative Borel measure and let f~ L,(R”). Show that for some constant c, independent o f f , and A > 0, A p ( { M J > A}) S ~ j { ~ ~ , ~ J fd(p y( y)) I. (Hint: For a fixed A let 0 = { M J > A} and put f = fxo + f ~ ~ n = , ~f1+ f 2 , say. If we can show that 6 E { MJ1 > A}, then by Theorem 1.1 we are done; but this is easy since to each x in 6 there corresponds an open cube Z containing x such that (l/p(Z))j I l f ( y ) I d p ( y ) > A, which in turn implies that inf, M J > A and f = fl on I.) 8.3 The proof of Theorem 1.1 relied on a careful selection procedure of cubes out of an arbitrary family; results of this type are known as “covering lemmas.” That proof may also be obtained by making use of the following covering lemma, due to Wiener: Let E be a Borel measurable subset of R ” which is covered by the union of a family of open cubes {I,} of bounded sidelength; then from this family we can select a disjoint subsequence { r j } so that p ( E ) d c C p ( r j ) , where c is a constant that depends only on the doubling constant of p. Prove this lemma. (Hint: Choose I1essentially as large as possible, i.e., sidelength ZI2 i sup,(sidelength I,), discard any cube which intersects Zl,and so on.) 8.4 Maximal results, in turn, imply covering results; the following is an example: Assume that for a nonnegative, Borel measure p and some 1 < p < co the mappingf+ MJverifies IIMJllL: s cllfllL;, c independent o f f ; then given any finite collection of open cubes {Z,} it is possible to select a sequence { r j } so that (i) Z,) S c,p(U Zi) (that is the Zi’s cover Z,) and (ii) jR.(C x1,(y))”’d p ( y ) S c 2 p ( u r j ) (that is a good portion of the overlap of the Is’s is small when measured in L$( R ” )norm, l/p + l/p‘ = 1);the constants c l , c, depend only on the norm of the maximal operator and on p. (Hint: Since the Is’sare finitely many they may be ordered and we choose the first cube as I ] . For 1, we choose the first I, among the , n Zl)S $p( Z,). For Z3we choose the first I , remaining cubes so that p ( I among the cubes listed after Z2 so that p(Zp n (IIu I,)) S ip(Z,) and so on. Note that if an Z , was not selected then we have p(Z, n 4)) > ?p(Z,) 8.2
u
p(u
(u
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
249
consequently p(uI s ) S p ( { M p ( x u I j> ) $1)c C ~ ~ I ) X U I ~=I I L ; c , p ( u $ ) and (i) holds. Next observe that if Ek = I k \ U j < k l j , then E L(&) 3
and
&.&(Ik).
We define now a linear operator T: L;(R") + LP,(R")as follows:
Clearly I Tf(x)l e M d ( x ) .Moreover, the adjoint T* :L$( R " ) + L$( R " ) can be explicitly written as
and consequently
and by taking p' norms we get (ii). this technique of proof is known as "linearization" and since at no point did we use the fact that the Is's were cubes the reader is invited to state and prove a general result in this direction. The substitute result for the case when the maximal operator is of weak-type ( 1 , l ) should also be considered. The proof above is from C6rdoba's work [ 19761 and the weak-type result was done independently by C6rdoba [ 19761 and Hayes [1976].) 8.5 Under very general conditions Corollary 1.3 admits the following converse (we only discuss the unweighted version here): a collection B = {B} of open, bounded subsets of R" is said to be a translation invariant Buseman-Feller, or B-F, basis if for each x in R" there is a subfamily B ( x ) of B such that (i) if B E B ( x ) , then x E B, (ii) each B ( x ) contains sets of arbitrarily small diameter; (iii) B ( x ) = x + B(0). Suppose that B differentiates L ( R " ) , that, is limlBI+o, B,sacx,(l/lBI) j B f ( y )dy = f ( x ) a.e.; then the mapping . f ( x ) M a f ( x ) = supBGB(x)(l/lBI)I B l f ( y ) l dy is Of weak-type ( 1 , l ) . (Hint: Suppose not and proceed exactly as in Chapter IV; the result is from de GuzmLn and Welland [1971].) 8.6 Although Ap is both necessary and sufficient for the ( p , p ) type and weak-type of the maximal operator, the same is not true for the restricted d p ( x ) S c p ( E ) ,all A > 0 and measurweak-type: the inequality A P able subsets E c R", is equivalent to the existence of a positive constant K such that for all cubes I and Lebesgue measurable E E I, lEl/lIl c K ( p ( E ) / p ( I ) ) ' / " (Hint: . Since M x E ( x )2 ( ~ E ~ / ~ I ~the ) ~condition ,(x) is necessary. Conversely, we readily see that M x E ( x ) K ( M d E ( x ) ) ' / P and that p is doubling. The result is Kerman's and the proof appears in Kerman and Torchinsky [ 19821.)
I{MxE,A)
IX. Ap Weights
250 8.7
For a nonnegative, locally integrable function w and an open cube = (tlf2)1/2 where tl = sup{t > O:I{x E I : w ( x ) s t}l s 1Z1/2} and tz = inf{t > 0: I{x E I : w ( x ) > t}l s lIl/2}. Show that for any real num. ber a we have m,a(Z) = (mw(Z))"and ( w " ) a~$ ( m w ( Z ) ) aFurthermore, we say that w satisfies condition A if w1 S cmw(Z),for a constant c independent of I. It is clear that, if 0 < a d 1 and w satisfies condition A, then ( w a ) , (m,( I ) ) a ,all I. Moreover, Apweights have the following interpretation in terms of the condition A : w E Ap if and only if w and w - ' / ( ~ - ' ) both satisfy condition A , 1 < p < 00. (Hint: One direction of the last statement is trivial since (m,( Z))-l/(p-l) = mW-m-1)(J). The other follows from the inequalities W r 2 imw(I ) = $(r n , - m - l ) ( and ( W - l ' ( p - l ) ) r 2 $ ( m w ( I ) ) - l / ( p - lThese ). results and those in the next remark are due to Stromberg and appear in Stromberg and Torchinsky [19801; they should be compared with Proposition 6.3.) 8.8 Let 1 < p , r < 00; then w E Ap n R H , if and only if w r and W - I ' ( ~ - ' ) satisfy condition A. (The statement is equivalent to w" satisfies condition A for all - l / ( p - 1) d a < r.) 8.9 Assume that a nonnegative function w verifies l{y E I ; w ( y ) < W r / A k } l s cvklIl,all I, where c is independent of Z and 0 < 7 < 1 < A < 00. Show that there is a p > 1 such that w E Ap. (Hint: Note that
Z put m , ( I )
-
and choose p so large that 7A1'(p-1) < 1.) We say that w verifies Muckenhoupt's A , condition, and write w E A,, if to each 0 < E < 1 there corresponds 0 < S < 1 so that for measur) IEl < 8111. By Proposiable subsets E of I we have p ( E ) < & p ( I whenever tion 4.5(iii) each A, weight is an A, weight. Show that the converse is also true: if w E A , there is 1 < p < 00 so that w E Ap. (Hint: It suffices to show that for appropriate A and 7 the assumptions of 8.9 hold; A = 8 and 7 = (1 - d / 2 ) , where d is the 6 corresponding to E = $ will do in the one dimensional case, the n dimensional case requires minor adjustments. To see this fix Z and k, let E = {x E I : w ( x ) < ~ 1 / 8 ~and } , observe that p ( E ) < P(I)/< ~~ p ( 1 ) / 2 implies [El < (1 - d)lIl. Now since almost every x E E is a Lebesgue point of xE and Lebesgue measure is regular we may assume 8.10
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
251
that E is compact and each point of E is a Lebesgue point of ,yE. To each x in E we may assign an open interval I, centered at x such that 11, n Z n El = (1 - d ) ( I , n ZI (this is possible since for I, large I, contains I and IEl < (1 - d)lIl and for I, small I, c I and 11, n . E ~ / ~+ I , l), ~ I, G cZ, c independent of x and I. Let S = UxGE I,, since E is compact we may assume that S is finite and choose I , as an I, in S of largest length. Then after 11,. . . ,I k have been chosen let s k be the family of the remaining 1,’s so that x fZ 4 and let I k + l be a largest interval in s k . Observe that each y in 4 belongs to, at most, two of the 4 ’ s and put El = Uj(4n I) E Z. Then ~ ( ~ 61 Cj1 d d y ) G 2 C j J E n i j n i d p ( y ) (since IE n IJ n 1 = implies p ( 4 n I ) 6 2 p ( n (I - d)l4 n 1 ~ 4 n I ) ) s 4jEuijuid p ( y ) (since each y belongs to at most two of the 4 ’ s ) “41, d p ( y ) s 4 ~ ( I ) / 8 ~ . How about the Lebesgue measure of El? Well,
u
uj”=l
IIjnr
’
or lE.11,31El/~. Now, if k 3 2, it is possible to start with p ( E , ) < P ( E ) / ~ ~ - ’ and repeat the above argument with E replaced by El. This gives E2 c I, p(E2) 6 and lE21 > IE1/q2; repeating the process k times we are done. This result is Muckenhoupt’s [1974] and insures that P A , = Uisp<mAp.) 8.11 We say that a nonnegative, doubling, Bore1 measure p is comparable to a (similar) measure v if there exist constants E, 6 E ( 0 , l ) such that whenever E is a measurable subset of a cube I, v ( E ) / v ( I )< S implies p ( E ) / p ( I )< E. The following four conditions are equivalent: (i) v ( E ) / v ( I )s c ( p ( E ) / p ( I ) ) ”for all E c I, with c and 7) > 0 independent of E and I, (ii) v is comparable to p, (iii) p is comparable to v, (iv) d v ( x ) = w ( x ) d p ( x ) where w E R H l + ” ( d p ) i.e., ,
for every cube I. Moreover, comparability is an equivalence relation. (The proof uses ideas similar to the ones discussed in this chapter, (iii) implies (iv) is the hardest implication. This observation is from CoifmanFefferman’s work [ 19741.) 8.12 A nonnegative weight w E A, if and only if
IX. A, Weights
252
I,
( ~ i n t : Since limp+m((l/lIl) w(x)-'/(p-')dx)p-' = e(('/lZl)J, In('/w(x)) h) the assertion here is that A, is obtained as the limiting A, condition, as p -* 00, much like A, is obtained as the limiting condition as p + 1. The proof is computational, and the necessity follows at once from 8.11 and Jensen's inequality. As for the sufficiency, let A denote the sup over I of the expression in question, A < 00. Then for each interval I and disjoint subsets of positive measure E, F of I, E u F = I, we have In A 2 In( w , ) ( I E l / l W n W ) E - (IFI/lIl)(ln W ) F , where (In W ) E = (1/lEl) In w ( x ) dx, and similarly for (In w ) ~Since . by Jensen's inequality (In w ) S~In( w E )we also have that
JE
Putting t = IFl/lIl and T = p ( F ) / p ( I ) we finally get 1nA 2 (1 - t ) ln((1 - t)/(l - 7))+ t ln(t/T); elementary considerations obtain now that for a constant c, which depends only on A, T S 1 - e-'/('-'o) = T~ < 1 provided that t < to, in other words w E A,. The proof is from HruSEev's paper [ 19841.) 8.13 There is yet another way of writing the A, condition, namely, the S, condition
Jz
M(Xrw'-P')(X)PW(X)dx s c
J,
w(x)'-"' dx,
all
I,
with c independent of I. (Hint: It is not hard to see that S, implies A,. Conversely, if w E S, and x E I c Io, then by A, we readily see that
=S CM,( X I o w-') (x)"".
Since for each f with s u p p f r I. and x in I. we have M f ( x ) = s ~ P ~ ~ ~ = ~j J~f(( ~ )/dlI ~I itI, follows ) M(XroW'-P')(X)P c ~ , ( x ~ , , ~ - ' ) ( x ) ~ ' , and S, follows from Corollary 1.2. This proof is due to Hunt and Kurtz and Neugebauer [1983]; an indirect proof follows from 8.14.) Assume that 1 < p S 8.14 (Sawyer's Two Weight Maximal Theorem) q < 00, and that u, w are nonnegative, locally integrable functions in R". Then the following two conditions are equivalent: (i) ((,. M f ( x ) % ( x ) dx)'/¶d C ( ~ , . ~ ~ ( X ) ~ ~ dx)'IP, U ( X ) with c independent of J: (ii) I, M ( ~ r u ' - P ' ) ( ~ dx ) 4s ~ ( ~ ) U(X)'-"' d x ) ¶ I P < 00, all I, with c independent of I.
.(Iz
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
253
The proof of this interesting result is due to Sawyer [19821, and it follows along the lines of Theorem 4.1. An identical result holds for M replaced by the maximal function M,,of fractional order introduced in Chapter VI. 8.15 With the same notation and assumptions as in 7.14 of Chapter 111, 7.29 of Chapter IV, and 6.17 of chapter VIII, prove the following: For every real sequence {ik}, -1 < rk < 1, with r; < a,the infinite product (1 + rkfk(nkX)) converges for almost every x to a function w(x) in A, for 1 < p c 00. Moreover, w E Lp(T), p < co as well. (Hint: the convergence of the product is equivalent to that of the sum s(x) = CT='=,rkfk(ng); also for some constant c, Iln w(x) - s(x)l< c. The convergence of s(x) follows by classical arguments. Observe now that for some constants cl, c2 > 0, cles(x)c w(x) < c2es(x).This result is from Meyer's work [1979].) 8.16 Under the hypothesis of 8.15 and if p*(x) = SUPN,O~N(X), pN(x) = n;="=,l+ rkfk(ng)), denotes the maximal Riesz product, then p* E A,. (Hint: First, there is a constant c > 0 so that (1/27r) JTp*(x)dx s c whenever CT=, r i c E 2 (this follows since pN(x) S cesN@)and s* E BMO). Let I c T, if II( > 27r/n0 the estimate holds trivially sincep*(x) 5 1 - ro > 0 and (l/lIl) J r p * ( x )dx s (no/2r) JTp*(x) dx. Suppose next that 27r/nN+, < 111 < 2 r / n N and let x = center of I; then there exists a constant c > 0 such that p j ( t ) c cpj(x), pj(x) c c p j ( t ) , whenever 0 c j S N and t E I. The constant c only depends on 1 r;. To see this we majorize Ilnpj(t) - lnpj(x)l by
n:='=,
i
Iln(1 + rkfk(nkt)- ln(1 + rkfk(n&)l k=O
i
d c
xlrklnzlx - fl
d c.
k=O
put Yk(t) = (1 + rN+lfN+l(nN+lf)+ * ' * + (1 + rN+kfN+k(nN+kt)) and note that p * ( t ) = sup(pl(t), * * ,PN(f), PN(f)Yl(f),. . . PN(t)Yk(f), ' * ') suP(pl(x), * . PN(X), PN(X)Yl(f), . . * , PN(X)'&(t), .) c sup(a, by*( t ) ) , where y*( t ) = SUpkal yk( t ) . Similarly, p*( t ) 3 c1 sup(a, by*( t ) ) 3 c,a. We will be finished once we show that (l/lIl) I, y * ( t ) dt < c, but this is not hard. The result is Meyer's.) 8.17 Assume w is a nonnegative function defined in a cube I. which verifies
-
-
9
3
( jzi
~ ( x ) dx)" "
c c1
-
ijz
W(X)dx
for all subcubes I c I,, some p > 1 and some constant c, independent of I. Show that there is 7 > 0 so that also
IX. A, Weights
254
for p S r < p + q, all I c I, and c2 = c,,,,, but independent of I. (Suppose I = [0,1], w ( x ) , d x = 1 and put EA = { x E I : w ( x ) > A}; the inequality follows at once from the estimate
I,
IEA
w ( x ) " dx d cAP-'
I,
w(x)dx,
A 3 1,
which in turn follows from an argument not unlike that of Theorem 3.5. This result, important both in applications and motivation, is due to Gehring [19731.) 8.18 For a locally integrable function 4 put p ( 4 ) = {infp: e b and e - @ belong to A,}. Note that p ( 4 ) can equal 00; also Holder's inequality . that p ( 4 ) = 00 and shows that ed E Ap whenever p > ~ ( 4 ) Suppose E BMO and p ( 4 ) - 1 = E ( + ) , where E ( + ) = show that inf{s > 0: supr(l/lIl)l{x E I : I+(x) > A}( =s e-"lE} whenever A > A. = AO(&, 4). (Hint: We must have p ( 4 ) =s2 (if p ( 4 ) > 2, then also e f b E A2, and this cannot be); then the A, estimates for e+' yield that
+
which in turn implies ~ ( 4=s ) p ( 4 ) - 1 since q ( 4 )= I/&(+). Conversely, for p - 1 > E ( + ) , again by the fact that q ( 4 )= l/&(+), we have that
and when p - 1 < 1, Holder's inequality shows that both eb and e-' The result is from Garnett-Jones [1978].) 8.19 Verify the following statements.
E A,.
(i) ( w , u ) E Ap if and only if (u'-~',w'-,') A,., 1 < p < 00. (ii) if (w, U ) E A,, O < S < 1 and ( q - l ) / ( p - 1) = S, then ( d ,u s ) E Aq. (iii) If (w, u ) E A,, 0 < S < 1, and d p s ( x ) = w s ( x )dx, d v 6 ( x ) = d ( x ) dx,then IIMfllL;, d ~ l l f l cl = ~ ~C6.p. (Hint: Since ( w ' , u s ) E A, and p > S ( p - 1) + 1 = q, we get that ({Mf > A}) s cllfll t:, and (iii) follows by the Marcinkiewin interpolation theorem. These observations and the next three res-ults are from Neugebauer's work [19831.) 8.20 Assume that
IlM-fIlL:
and IIMfllL!;-p. s CllfllLP;,-p,; then there are nonnegative functions w l , w2 such that w ( x ) l / p M w l ( x ) c l u ( x ) ' / p w l ( x )an ; identical inequality holdsfor w2, and W ( X ) ' / ~ U ( X )=' ~ ~ ' W ~ ( X ) W ~ ( X ) (Hint: ~ - ~ . Cf. Theorem 5.5 and consider T f x ) = w ( x ) ' / p M ( l f l u - ' / p ) ( x ) + u ( x ) ~ " p s M ( ~ f l w ' ~ p s ) (where x ) ' ~ ss = p / p ' . )
ClIflL:
255
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
Let (w, u ) E Ap and 0 < 6 < 1. Then there exists a nonnegative function u = ug such that clw'(x) c u ( x ) s C ~ U ( X ) ~and u E Ap. (Hint: Choose 0 < E, 7) < 1, 6 = ET. From 8.19 (iii) we know that
8.21
~ v where ~ Mwj ~ ~ s c ~' ~ ( u / w ) j" = ' ~1, , 2. Note Thus, by 8.20, ~ ~ /= w,w;-" that uE = wl(u / W ) ' / ~ W ; - ~3 C M W , ( M W ~ )3' - cwI ~ w:-"( u/ w ) ~ ( ~ -=~ C) W' €~ and thus clws c (MW,)"(MW,)""-~'S c2us. Put now u= (Mw,)yMw2)""-p'. 1 8.22 Let ( w , u ) be a pair of nonnegative functions, then there exists u E A, with c1w ( x ) C u ( x )C c2u(x),if and only ifthere is T > 1such that (w', uT) E Ap.(Hint: Since u, u'-~'satisfy a reverse Holder inequality, there is T > 1 such that u' E A, and ( w T ,uT) E Ap. As for the converse, use 8.21 with 6 = l/T.) 8.23 Suppose that w is a nonnegative function and show that ( w , M w ) E Ap, 1 < p < 00. In particular M f ( x ) " w ( x )dx c c I R n l f ( x ) I p M w ( xdx ) in the same range of p's. (Hint: The proof is reminiscent of Proposition 7.2 (ii). If wI = 0 there is nothing to show. Otherwise, note that inf,Mw 5 w I ; thus ( w , M w ) E Ap with Ap constant 1. Consequently, if u ( x ) = M w ( x ) ,the maximal operator maps L: into wk-LP,for 1 < p < 00 and by interpolation also into Lc for the same p's. The result concerning the integral inequality was originally proved by Fefferman and Stein [1971].) 8.24 Given a nonnegative function w and 1 < p < 00, the following conditions are equivalent.
I,.
I,.
(i) There is a nonnegative, finite a.e. function u such that M f ( x ) " w ( x )dx S c J,nlf(x)l"v(x) dx, c independent of J: (ii) J,n w ( x ) / ( l + 1 ~ 1 dx~ <) 00. ~
(Hint: (i) implies (ii) follows by considering f = xA, measurable A. (ii) implies (i) requires a bit of work; by replacing w by max(1, w ) if necessary, we may assume that w 2 1. Let now u ( x ) = (1 + l ~ l " ) ' - ~note , that M ( u w ) ( x )< 00 a.e., and put u ( x ) = M ( u w ) ( x ) / w ( ~ )d~v (, x ) = v ( x ) dx. For k = 0, 1,. . . ,letfk(x) = f ( x ) ~ ( ~ k ~ l ~ l < then ~ k +by~ 8.23 ~ ( xit) follows ; that c
"
IX. Ap Weights
256
For 1x1 2 2k+Z,we have
where the last term can be estimated and summed. The above proof is from Young's paper [ 19821 and the result was obtained independently by Gatto and Gutierrez [1983]. The result followed this observation of Rubio de Francia [ 19811: given a nonnegative function u and 1 < p < 00 the following conditions are equivalent. (i) There is a nonnegative, finite a.e. function w such that
I,. M f ( x ) " w ( x )dx d c ~ R n l f ( x ) l p u (dx,x ) c independent of J: (ii) U ( X ) - ~ ' ( ~ - ' ) is locally integrable and lim S U P ~ + ~ I Qx~ I - ~ ' I, u( x) dx < co, where QR = {x E R": maxlSjSn lxjl 9 R}.) -l/(p-')
We say that a locally integrable function b has bounded lower oscillation, and we write b E BLO, if b, - inf, b s c, all I, where c is independent of I; BLO c BMO. Then b E BLO if and only if eqb E Al for some 7 > 0. (Hint: If eqb E A,, then ( e q b ) ,S c inf, eqb and the conclusion follows by Jensen's inequality. To prove the converse, note that the JohnNirenberg inequality gives ( e q b ) ,s c d q b ) 1 ,for 7 sufficiently small, and the conclusion follows easily from this. This means, in particular, that each b in BLO may be written as 7 l n f + h, where f s 0 is integrable and h is bounded. These results are Coifman and Rochberg's [19801.) 8.27 Theorem 7.6 has a weak-type version. More precisely, if T is a sublinear operator which verifies the following property; there is 1 S po < co, such that for every w E Ah, d p ( x ) = w ( x ) dx, and A > 0, A P o p ( { (TA > A}) s c llfll FLo, where c is independent off and independent in A,; then for every p with 1 < p < 00 and every w E Ap, T also verifies App({ITA> A}) d cllfll;;:, where c is independent o f f and independent in Ap. (Hint: In the first place if po < p , then for A > 0, 8.26
APOP({ITA > A } ) d P= APollX{,TJl>A)llL,/Po =
JR"
x{ITfl>A)(x)g(x) w ( x ) dx,
for some g 3 0 with IlglJLJp/po)s = 1. Associate with g a function G as in Proposition 7.4 and apply the weak-type assumption. If, on the other hand, 1 < p < p o , use Proposition 7.5 instead. The result is Garcia-Cuerva's [ 19831.)
257
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems 8.28
w
E
A nonnegative function w is said to satisfy the AP,¶condition, or AP,¶,if
where c is independent of I. The infimum over the c's above is called the AP,¶constant of w and a statement is said to be independent in AP,¶if it only depends on the Ap,4constant of the weights involved. Show that, if T is a sublinear operator which verifies
for some pair ( p o , qo), 1 < po s qo < 00, and all w E Ah,%, where c is independent in Apo,40, then it also satisfies the same inequality for any other pair ( p , q), 1 < p s q < 00 with l / p - l / q = l/po - l/qo for every w E AP,¶ with norm independent in AP,¶.(The proof, which is similar to that of Theorem 7.6, is in Harboure-Macias-Segovia [ 1984b1). 8.29 Let Mf,(x)
1
= sup -{)f(Y)l I
lIIl-7
dY,
where 0 < 77 < 1,
and the sup is taken over all open cubes I containing x. Then, if 0 < l / q = l / p - 77 < 00 and w E AP,¶,there exists a constant c, independent off and independent in AP,¶,such that
(I,"
M,f(x)'w(x)¶dx)liq
l/P
-
c( j R " I f ~ X ~ l P W ~ X ~ ~ d X )
Is the converse true? (Hint: The proof follows by a combination of the ideas discussed in this chapter; as an illustration we do the (easier) weak-type result. Assume that ~ , n l f ( x ) l p w ( x ) p d=x1 and note that by Holder's inequality and AP,¶we get that
the weak-type estimate follows without much difficulty from this. (Cf. the remarks in 8.14).)
258
IX. Ap Weights
8.30 For 0 < l / q = l / p - (Y < 1 the condition Ap,q is necessary and sufficient for the mapping
to verify
(cf. Muckenhoupt-Wheeden [19741). Welland [19751 observed that one may prove this inequality by using Theorem 2.4 in Chapter VI and 8.29. Results similar to 8.24 in this context have been established by Rubio de Francia [ 19811 and Harboure-Macias-Segovia [ 1984al.) 8.31 Liifstrom [1983] has shown there exist no nontrivial translation invariant operators on LP,(R”),if d p ( x ) = w ( x ) dx and w belongs to a class of rapidly varying weight functions, including for instance w ( x ) = e*lxla, (Y
> 1.
CHAPTER
More about R"
1. DISTRIBUTIONS. FOURIER TRANSFORMS
As we saw in Chapter IX the transition from periodic functions to those defined in R" may be accomplished smoothly. In this chapter we sketch some of the basic properties of distributions, functions, and operators in Euclidean n-dimensional space which will be useful in what follows. Some of the results are straightforward extensions of the corresponding statements in T and some are not; we will be brief in all cases, though. For instance, the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition is available at all levels now (given A > 0, partition R" into a countable grid of cubes I with 111 > r, where l l f l l r < A, and observe that the "old" Calder6n-Zygmund process at level A applies on each cube I since < A ) and the Riesz potential operators ) L ~ ( R "for ) IJ(X) = JRnf(y)/lx- yl"-" dy, o < a < n, map L ~ ( R "into l / q = l / p - a / n (same proof as for periodic case). On the other hand, other results require some adjustment. For instance, to discuss the notion of distribution we introduce the Schwartz class Y'(R") as follows. Given an n-tuple of nonnegative integers a = ( a 1 ,. . . , a,) with length la1 = a , + . - * + a , , and x = (x,,..., xn) in R", we put x a = x;ll - x z m and define the differential operator D" = d"l/dx;ll * . ax>. The space Y ' ( R n ) consists of those C"(R") functions +(x) (i.e., all partial derivatives D " ~ ( xexist ) and are continuous) such that
InI
-
SUPlXP~"4(X)l= c , , p ( 4 ) < 03
(1.1)
X
for all multi-indices a, p. Y ( R " )contains the space C:(R") consisting of those C" functions with compact support, but e-IXl2 E Y(R")\CF(R").We say that a sequence {&} c Y ( R " ) converges to 0 in 9,and we write limk,, & = O(Y)if lirnk+" ca,P(&) = 0 for all multi-indices a, p. A linear 259
X . More about R"
260
operation T is said to be continuous in Y provided that limk+coT(&) = o(9) whenever limk+oo& = o(9). The reader may verify that all usual operations, such as addition, multiplication by a polynomial, and diff erentiation are continuous in 9. An essential operation which we hope to show to, be continuous in Y is the Fourier transformation. The Fourier transform f of an integrable function f is defined by the absolutely convergent integral r
f(t)= J R" f(x)e-"'&dx,
5 E R",
where x * 5 denotes the usual scalar prodyt x l & + * * * + xn&. Somz proper( ~0,) ~ ties of the Fourier transform, such as llfllm s Ilflll and l i m ~ + o o ~ f = are readily verified. Since, by the Lebe;gue dominated co_nvergenceth%orem, and t"f(6) = it follows that for f in Y ( R " ) ,O a f ( [ )= (-i)l"'(x"f) (t), (i)'"'(O"f)A(t), we also see at on2e that the Fourier transformation is continuous in 9.Moreover, since f E LJR") for f in 9,we consider the possibility of expressing f in terms o f f by means of a Fourier inversion formula. In the process of establishing this fomAulawe need to have at hand a specific integrable function 4 so that 4 is also integrable. We construct an example as follows: if n = 1 we put 4(x) = e-lxl and observe that
and
As for arbitrary n note that the Fourier transform of ~ ( x = ) +(xl) * is S ( t ) = 2"/(1+ 6:) * * (1 + 5;) and
*
- 4(x,)
r
(1.5)
We are now in a position to show Proposition 1.1. Suppose f
holds.
E
Y ( R " ) .Then the Fourier inversion formula
26 1
1. Distributions. Fourier Transforms
Proof. For 71 as above, and since all double integrals involved are absolutely convergent, it readily follows that
"
=
Thus,Aby replacing T(E*)
(y) =
R"
(1.7)
f ( x + y ) ; i ( v ) dv.
~ ( by t )T ( E ~ ) ,E > 0,
E-"~(Y/E),
J
J
in (1.7) and observing that from (1.7) it follows at once that
T ( E t ) ~ t ) e i pd*t R"
=
J
R"
f ( x + E y ) ~ ( ydu. )
(1.8)
We now let E + 0 in (1.8) and by the Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem we get
and the proof is complete.
Remark 1.2. A simple variant of t,he proof above shows that, properly interpreted, (1.6) still holds true iff is merely integrable.
+ ( x ) $ ( x ) dx
(4 *
i,hm i ( t > 4 < S ) =
=
(27r)-"
and (4i,hT(t)= (2+"(C$
* i)(S>.
Proof. The immediate verification of these properties is left to the reader. Next we consider tempered distributions.
X . More about R"
262
Definition 1.4. A linear functional F on Y ( R " )is said to be continuous if limk+mF ( + k ) = 0 whenever limk+m4 k = O ( 9 ) . The collection of all continuous linear functionals on Y(R") is called the space Y'(R") of tempered distributions.
As usual L P ( R " c ) Y ' ( R " ) ,1 s p C 00, and the action of the functional f corresponding to the function f in L P ( R " )is given by the absolutely convergent integral f(4)= I , . f ( x ) + ( x ) dx, 4 E Y ( R " ) . Finite Bore1 measures p, as well as functions of tempered growth, i.e., those functions f such that f ( x ) = 0((1 + 1 ~ 1 ) ~ for ) some integer k also generate distributions in the obvious way. Tempered distributions F are also infinitely differentiable in Y",and D"F is defined by D"F(4) = (-l)'"'F(Da4), all 4 in Y ( R " ) Clearly, . differentiation is continuous in Y ' ( R " )(we say that Fk-f O ( Y ) if Fk(4) 0 for each 4 in Y ( R " ) ,differentiation preserves this property). As in Chapter I, we may prove -f
Proposition 1.5. A linear functional L on Y ( R " )is a tempered distribution if and only if there exist a constant c > 0 and integers k, m,which depend only on L, such that IL(4)I C CC,,~c",~(+), /a[ k, IPI m. We also have (cf. Theorem 4.12 in Chapter I) Proposition 1.6. A tempered distribution F is supported at xo E R" if and only if F is a linear combination of the Dirac 6 concentrated at x,, i.e., the distribution 6 ( 4 )= 4(x,,) and a finite number of its derivatives. As -for the Fourier transformation we have Definition 1.7. A tempered distribution F !as a well-defined distributiona! Fourier transform # given by fi(4)= F ( + ) , a! 4 in Y ( R " ) .Moreover, F verifies the following inversion formula: if 4(x) = 4(-x) and F ( 4 ) = 2 F(I$), then F = (2.rr)"fi We also have the following important property Proposition 1.8. Suppose f E L2(R").Then the (distritutional) Fourier transfomf off coincides with an L2(R")function and llfll2 = (2.rr)"/'llfll2. Furthermore, Proposition 1.3 holds for 4, in L2.
+
Proof. By the Detnition 1.7,*HOlder's inequality and Proposition 1.3 y e have If(+)I = It<+>I I I ~ I I ~ I I = ~ I( I2~ . r r ) n / 2 ~ ~ f ~ ~all2 ~4~in4 ~9~. n2 ,u s f E L2(R")_and IIfll2 (2.rr)n'211f((2.Also replacing f by f we see that (2.rr)"llfllz = (2.rr)"llfllz = llZll2 (2.rr)n~211Z112 (2.rr)"llfll2, and the proof is complete. W
2. Translation Invariant Operators. Multipliers
263
Corollary 1.9. Assume f E L P ( R " ) , 1 < p < 2. Then the Fourier t r a y form f of f is in L p ' ( R " ) , l / p + l / p ' = 1, it is given by f = 1imN+? ~lxl,Nf(x) e-&'*dx, where the limit is taken in the LP'(R")norm and Ilfll,, s Ilfl ,. Proposition 1.10. Suppose that the distribution F has compact support. Then ~ ( 5 =) F(e-"'*) is a c"(R") function. Definition 1.11. For F E Y ' ( R " ) , 4 E Y ( R " ) we define the convolution F * 4 at x as the C"(R") function F ( T , ~ )where , T, denotes translation by x in R". By Proposition 1.5, F * 4(x) has tempered growth and its Fourier transform is the distribution $, where the product is understood in 9".A similar definition holds for the convolution of distributions, one of which has compact support. 2. TRANSLATION INVARIANT OPERATORS. MULTIPLIERS A bounded linear operator T from L P ( R " )into L 4 ( R " ) is said to be TTT~ for all x in R". Unlike for the periodic translation invariant if T ~ = case, such operators do not always exist. Proposition 2.1 (Hormander). If T is a bounded, translation invariant operator from L p ( R " )into L 4 ( R " )and q < p < CO, then T = 0. Proof. First note that limlxl+&+ ~ X f l l ,= 21/pIlfllp;the proof of this is not hard once we write f = u + v, where u is compactly supported and llull, is small, and observe that for 1x1 sufficiently large the support of u and that of T,U are disjoint. We show next that the smallest constant c for which 11 TfII, < cllfll, is 0. By the linearity and translation invariance of T we get IITf+ ~,Tf11~ = IIT(f+ ~ ~ f lC 1 c1l ~ l f + ~ , f l l , , and consequently, letting 1x1 + co it follows that 11 Tfll,s 21/p-1/q cllfll,, where the factor 21/p-1'q< 1. By repeating this argument we see that indeed the smallest such constant is 0 and the proof is complete. W
Next we would like to discuss the relation between translation invariant and convolution operators; this requires the following result, which is a variant of the well-known Sobolev lemma. Proposition 2.2. Suppose f E L P ( R " ) 1, s p s CO, and f has distributional derivatives of order S n + 1 which coincide with LP(R")functions. Then f equals a continuous function a.e. and there is a constant c = c,,,, independent off and x such that If(x)l s c Clal,n+lllDafllp, x E R".
X . More about R"
264
Proof. First, note that for 6 in R", (1 + I6l)"+' s c &+n+ll[UI for some constant c independent of 6. Suppose first that p = 1 and observe that
c I(~"f)A(5)1 + /&'""' c 11
Ij.cs>l sz 4 1 + 161)-'"+1'
Irrl<"+l
s c( 1
D"flll.
(2.1)
IcrlS"+l
Since the right-hand side of (2.1) is an integrable function, llfll, < 00. Consequently, by Remark 1.2 f(x) = ( 2 9 ~ J,n~ "f ( t ) e i x . *dt, x a.e. in R", and f may be modified on a set of measure 0 so as to coincide with a continuous function in R", and the conclusion follows in this case. Suppose now p > 1 and choose 4 in C:(R") so that +(x) = 1 if 1x1 s 1 and 0 if 1x1 > 2. Then fi$ verifies our assumptions for p = 1, and by the above proof it coincides a.e. with a continuous function h such that
c , , , ~ , ~ " ~ ~ ( x ) D " ~it ~ ( x ) , Since by Leibnitz's rule D"(f+)(x) = Ca1+a2=o( follows that the right-hand side of (2.2) is bounded by c maxIa2I+III D"24 [IoD ClullSn+l11 DU1fllp,with a constant c which depends only on n and p. Moreover, since 4 = 1 in 1x1 s 1, h actually coincides with f in that neighborhood of the origin, and the same argument applied to f~&, x E R", gives the general result.
We may now prove
Theorem 2.3. Suppose T is a linear, bounded operator from L P ( R " )into L 9 ( R " ) , 1 p G q 00, which commutes with translations. Then there exists a unique tempered distribution F such that Tc#J(x)= F * +(x), for each 4 in Y ( R " ) . Proof. Since T is translation invariant, Tc$(x) has derivatives of all orders which coincide with L 4 ( R " )functions and Da( T 4 ) = T(D"c$),all a;this observation follows at once since the difference quotients of 4 converge to the corresponding partial derivatives of 4 in Lp, and, consequently, T of the quotients converges to T of the derivatives in L9. By Lemma 2.2, it now follows that Tc$ coincides with a continuous function, after correction on a set of measure 0, which verifies IT4(0)l
c
c
(olJ
IlD"4llP.
265
2. Translation Invariant Operators. Multipliers
.
By Proposition 1.5, T4(O) is a tempered distribution, F ( 4 ) say. We claim F is the distribution we are seeking; indeec, if 4 E 9,then by Definition 1.11 we have that F * 4(x) = F ( T , ~ )= F((T-&)-) = F ( T , ~ = ) T(~,4)(0)= T,T~(O)= T+(x), and we have finished. As in Chapters V and VI, we denote by MP,(Rn) the set of Fourier transforms k^ = m of those tempered distributions k which verify 11 k * 4 11, cl1411p, c independent of 4 E 9'.The elements m of MP,(Rn) are called multipliers of type (p, q) and the smallest constant c above is called the norm of m. All the usual properties hold in this setting as well; we show, for instance, that M:(R") = Lm(Rn) and norm of m = Ilmllm for m in M2(Rn).Suppose first that m E M2(Rn).By Proposition 1.8 it follows that m(5)4(5) is a locally integrable function for each 4 in 9, and consequently m itself is locally integrable. Suppose now is real valued, and note that ) )m(5)~-"$((5 )~(Z) - 5 0 ) / ~ )and , for E > 0 and toin Rn, (k * ( ~ ' ~ . Y ~ ( E ~ = lm(&)12G((5d5 s c2I,. 4 ( ~ $6.) ~Thus by consequently E-" letting E + 0 we see that for almost every toin Rn, Im((o)1211+ll$< (norm of m ) 2 ~1:~ and 11 m 1 , S norm of m. The opposite inequality is trivial, and the claim is proved. We make an additional comment due to deLeeuw; in fact, we show that multipliers may be restricted in a naturgl way to lower dimensional Euclidean spaces preserving their basic properties.
4
I,.
-
4
Theorem 2.4. Suppose m(5, q ) E MP(Rn+"). Then, for almost every Rn, m(5, .) E Mp(Rm),with norm not exceeding that of m.
5 in
Proof. Following Jodeit [1971], we assume first that m is continuous everywhere and put 11 m 11 = norm of mi Also for f l y g, in 9'(Rn) and f2, g2 in 9'(Rm) we set M(5) = J R m m(5, q)f2(q)t2(q) dq and observe that
Thus M(5) E Mp(Rn), with norm 11 Mil =Z 11 m 11 Ilfillpllg211pp.Now since IIMIIm s IlMll, we also have m(&,7l)L(r])t2(77) dql s Ilmll Ilfillpllg211p~ and m(5, .) E Mp(Rn)with norm s Ilmll. To show the same conclusion for arbitrary m, assume (5, q ) is a Lebesgue point of m for almost every q in 71, where *,(5, 7 ) = &-("+")xI(5/&,771~) R m and Put m,(5,77) = m * and I is the unit cube in Rn+" centered at the origin. Since m, E Mp(Rn+'") with norm 11 m, 11 s 11 m 11 it readily follows that
II,.
*E(&
X . More about R”
266
and the conclusion follows by the Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem. W
3. THE HILBERT AND RIESZ TRANSFORM
A classical result asserts that, given a continuous, bounded function f in R, there is a function F ( z ) analytic in Im z # 0, such that lim F ( x + iy) - F ( x - iy) = f ( x ) ,
all x in
R.
(3.1)
P O +
In fact it is not hard to see that the Cauchy integral off
+
does the job. Indeed, since for z = x iy we have that l / ( s - z) l / ( s - 5 ) = 2 i y / ( ( s - x ) ~y 2 ) , (3.1) holds provided that for x E R
+
The integral in (3.3) is the convolution f * P y ( x ) , where P ( x ) = ( l / r ) ( l / ( l+ x 2 ) ) and P J x ) = y - ’ P ( x / y ) . Actually, P , ( x ) is the Poisson kernel for R: = { ( x ,y ) E R2:y > 0) and (3.3) holds, as we have seen in Chapter VII, even nontangentially and in L p ( R )when f is in L P ( R ) . It is also of interest to determine the boundary values limy,,+ F ( x + iy) of E Suppose that for almost every x in R lim F ( x + iy) + F ( x - iy) = i g ( x ) .
(3.4)
p0+
Then adding (3.1) and (3.4) we have lirnyeo+ F ( x + iy) = 4 ( f ( x )+ i g ( x ) ) , x a.e. in R. To find the function g ( x ) in (3.4) we observe that for z = x + iy, l / ( s - z) + l / ( s - 2 ) = 2 ( s - x ) / ( ( s- x ) ’ + y 2 ) , and consequently (3.5)
The right-hand side of (3.5) is i f * Q y ( x ) ,where Q ( x ) = ( l / r ) ( x / l + x 2 ) and Q , ( x ) = y - ’ Q ( x / y ) is the conjugate Poisson kernel. Therefore, g ( x ) = p.v.-
J-
r R fx (-tt)
dt = l i m i
€42
I,
f ( t ) dt,
x-t(>EX-
t
(3.6)
in other words g ( x ) is the Hilbert transform H f ( x ) off. The results of Chapter V will hold in this context, with identical proof, provided we show
3. The Hilbert and Riesz Transform
261
that 11 Hf1 ' G cII f 112 with c independent of $ This estimate is equivalent to m(5) = ( ( l / ~ p.v. ) l/x)-([) E L m ( R ) ,which is an easy computation since
The reader will have no difficulty in establishing the corresponding results of Chapter VII as well. Next we consider the n-dimensional setting. There are many possible extensions and we only discuss here the one obtained in the direction of the theory of conjugate harmonic functions. Other results will be covered in the next chapters. Let u be a harmonic function in an open set R of R", i.e., u E C'(R) and ( a ' / a x : ) u ( x ) + * + (d'/ax',)u(x) = 0 for x in R. Motivated by the results in the disk, we consider the gradient Vu(x) = ((a/dx,)u(x), . . . ,(du/ax,)u(x)) = ( u l ( x ) ,. . . , u , ( x ) ) and observe that in R it satisfies the relations
-
a
-ui(x) axj
a
1 zs i, j zs m
= -uj(x), dXi
(3.7)
and
a
/
a
-uu,(x) + . . . + -u,(x) = 0. (3.8) 8x1 ax, In other words, if W(x) is the vector field (u,(x), . . . , u,(x)), then curl W = 0 and div W = 0 in R. Conversely, it is well-known that (3.7) implies (in a simply connected region) that there exists h(x) such that V h = ( ul ,.. .,urn), whereas (3.8) implies that h indeed is harmonic. We adopt these relations as the extension we have in mind; more precisely, we call (3.7) and (3.8) the generalized Cauchy-Riemann equations in the sense of Stein-Weiss and a solution vector field W to the Cauchy-Riemann equations is called a system of conjugate functions (in the sense of M. Riesz). With this definition applied to R:+' = {(x, t ) : x E R", t > 0}, we pass to discuss the generalization of the Hilbert transform to R". First, we find the Poisson kernel P(x, t) in R:+', that is, a function which verifies (i) ( ( $ / a t 2 ) + A)P(x, t ) = 0, (ii) I,. P(x, t ) dx = 1, t > 0, and (iii) lim,,o P ( x , t ) = 6 (in 9'). Taking the FIourier translform in the space x-variables, by (i] we note that (a2/at2)P(5,t ) - ([I'P([, t ) = 0 and by (iii) that limr+oP ( $ t ) = 1. Thus solving the differential equation we have that P ( & t ) = cl(5)e-'lf' + ~ ~ ( 5 ) ewhere " ~ ~by, the tempered nature of P we have c2(() = 0
X . More about R"
268
and by the above observations cl(.$) = 1. In other words, @(&,t ) = e-r'gland c
P(x, t ) = (2T)-"
J
- 451 k . 5 Rn
45.
(3.9)
It is not hard to find the explicit expressions for P(x, t ) . Indeed, by (3.9) we see that it is of the form t - " 4 ( l x l / t ) and from (i) above it follows that 4 satisfies the differential equation
+ s'>c"'(s) + ( 2 ( n + l ) s 2 + ( n - l))+'(s) + sn(n - l ) + ( s ) = 0, s > 0.
s(l
Thus 4 ( s ) = (1 + s2)--("+')/' and P(x, t) = P r ( x )= cnt-"l/(l+ (Ixl/t)2)("+')/2, (x, t ) E R:+', where c, = (27r)-" j R n e-lC1dt. By passing to polar coordinates, i.e., by putting d t = rn-l dr d f , where dt' is the surface area element on I; = (6' E R": 16'1 = l}, we get that c, = (27r)-"(n - 1) ! w,, w, = surface area of X. Polar coordinates also make it possible to compute w,; indeed observe that e-IXl2dx
=
(IR
ePs2ds)' =
I
re-r2
dx' dr
= T.
109)
Thus lXI2
IR"
dx = T n / 2
= w n I [o,m)
-
(">
e - r 2 d r = - r - w,, 2 2
and our computation is complete. Now for f in LP(R"),1 d p < 00, u(x, t ) = f * P ( x ) is the unique harmonic function in R:+' such that lim,,,u(x, t ) =f(x) in Lp and s ~ p , , ~ j ~ ~ It)lp u (dx x ,= < 00. It is natural to consider whether u is a (first) component of a system of conjugate functions R:+'. Disregarding the question of convergence of the integrals involved, we note that
llfllz
and by (3.7) the other (possible) components of the system of conjugate functions satisfy
=
f * Qkb, t),
(3.10)
where Qk(x, t ) = (2T)-"c,,xk/(t2+ IX/~)("+')/~ denote the conjugate Poisson kernels, 1 d k d n. Since as is readily verified ( d / d t ) u + ( d / d x , ) u , + * + (d/dx,)u, = 0, the vector is indeed a system of conjugate functions. What
-
269
3. The Hilbert and Riesz Transform
are the limits of the &(x, t)'s as t + O? From (3.10) it is readily seen that they are the Riesz transforms Rk given by
It is not hard to see that the Riesz operators are bounded in L2(E"),since fromtherelation Qk(x,t ) = (Xk/f)<(X,t ) E L2(R")it followsthat Qk(& t ) = (itk/1&e-"z' and by letting t + 0,R k ( t )= ( i & / ( & E L"(R"). AS for the L~ continuity we may either apply the techniques for the Hilbert transform or the following interesting result of Calder6n-Zygmund.
Theorem 3.1 (Method of Rotations). Suppose k ( x ) = R(x')/lxl",where R is odd, homogeneous of degree 0, and JrlR(x')Idx' < 00. Then the truncated operator K&)
=
I,
f ( x - y ) k ( y ) dY
Yl>.
is bounded in Lp(R " ) ,1 < p < 00, and there is a constant cp = c independent of E and f such that IIKEfllp=scllfll,. Proof. By passing to polar coordinates and on account of the fact that R is odd we write
K.f(x) = =
II
1 f ( x - ry')R(y');r"-' drdy' r [E,m)
I
I,
R(y')
1 f ( x - v')-dr dy' r
For each fixed y' in Z let Y denote the hyperplane orthogonal to y' which passes through the origin and observe that each x in R" can be written uniquely as x = z + sy', where s E R and z E Y. Thus
where the innermost integral in (3.12) is the one-dimensional truncated Hilbert transform H, of the function F ( r, z, y ' ) = f(z v'),where z and
+
X. More about R“
270
y’ are now parameters. Therefore by Minkowski’s integral inequality and
Fubini’s theorem it follows that
and the proof is complete.
4. SOBOLEV AND POINCARE INEQUALITIES
We conclude this chapter with a glimpse at some applications of the results covered thus far; first we need some observations of general interest. In what follows I, denotes a fixed, open cube in R” and I an arbitrary, open subcube of I,. Proposition 4.1. Suppose f is supported in I, and is C’ there. Then there is a constant c such that
c
independent of x.
Proof. Following Stein we observe that for y‘ in 2, ( d / d t ) f ( x - ty’) = - V f ( x - ty’) . y’ and consequently
-
V f ( x - ty’) ty’ t”-’ dt. t”
Whence integrating this expression over Z we see that
and the desired result follows at once from this. Proposition 4.2. Assume f is supported in I, and is C’ there and let I E 1,.
27 1
4. Sobolev and Poincare' Inequalities
Then
where c is a dimensional constant.
Proof. As f ( z ) - f ( x ) = Jco,,, V f ( x + t ( z - x ) ) * z - xdt, we see at once that j , l f ( x ) - f ( z ) ( dz s Jlo,!)I,lVf(x+ t ( z - x))llz - X I dzdt = A, say. To bound A we observe that, since the line segment joining x and z is totally contained in Z, if we put y = x + t ( z - x ) , then also y is in Z, dy = t" dz and iy = tlz - x ( s ctL, where L denotes the sidelength of I and c is a dimensional constant. Then
-XI
A
c IIlVf(Y)I Ix - Yl S [ , x - y , / e L , o o ) t-("+') dt dy s c IIlVf(Y)I Ix
- Yl(L/lX - Yl)" dY
and the conclusion follows at once since L"
= (11.
As it is convenient to restate the estimate (4.1) in terms of maximal functions, we introduce the following definitions: for f supported in Zo and x in I. we consider the expressions sup(l/lll) j , ( f ( y ) -hl dy, where Z c I. and x E I; in order to keep notations simple we still call this expression the local M # f ( x ) ; we do similarly for the local M J ( x ) , 0 s r ] < 1. With this notation we have Corollary 4.3. Let f be as in Proposition 4.2. Then M # f ( x ) s C~I,"
E
10
(4.2)
where both maximal functions are local.
Proof. Fix x in Zo and let Z contain x. Then
and by (4.1) the right-hand side of (4.3) does not exceed
But since as is readily seen
(4.2) holds and we are done.
W
We collect now some facts concerning the local maximal functions which will be useful in the applications.
X. More about R”
272
Theorem 4.4. Let w E A,( lo) and f E L( lo), & = 0. Then there is a constant c = cq, independent of J; such that the local maximal function M # f verifies ~ # f ( x ) q d p ( X ) , 1 < q < 00.
J,if(x)lq+(x) c c
(4.4)
JIo
We prefer to postpone the proof of this result until Chapter XIII, where the good-A inequalities are discussed in detail. The next two facts relate to the continuity properties of the local function M,,: We begin with a simple variant of 8.29 in Chapter IX, namely,
Theorem 4.5. Suppose w, u are nonnegative, integrable functions in Zo, and let d p ( x ) = w ( x ) dx, d v ( x ) = u ( x ) dx. Then for p , q > 1, 0 < 7 < 1, and l / p - 7 s l/q s l / p the local maximal function M,,f verifies A q p ( { x E Zo: M , f ( x ) > A}) i~ ( l l f l l pif) ~and only if
The condition (4.5) is called Ap,q,,,(Zo)and is indicated by (w, u ) E Ap,q,T(Io); the notions of Ap,q,,,(Zo)constant and independent in Ap,q,T(Io)are defined as the reader would expect them to be. Also refemng to 8.14 in Chapter IX we have
Theorem 4.6. Under the assumption of Theorem 4.5 the inequality
holds for the local maximal function M,,f if and only if
The condition (4.6) is called Sp,q,,,(Zo),is indicated by (w, u ) E Sp,q,,,(Zo), and a simple interpolation argument (making use of Kolmogorov’s inequality 7.19 in Chapter IV) gives Proposition 4.7. Suppose (w, u ) E Ap,s,,,(Zo)for some s such that l/p - 7 l / s s l/p. Then for q < s, (w, u ) E Sp,q,,,(Io). We are now in a position to prove
Theorem 4.8 (Sobolev’s embedding theorem). Let l / p - l / n s l / s < l/p, w E Am(Zo)and (w, u ) E Ap,s,l/n(ZO). Then given any p c q < s, and for every f supported on I. and C’ there,
4. Sobolev and Poincare‘Inequalities
273
-
where c p(I0)’, some S > 0, is independent of f and independent in Am(I0) and Ap,s,l/n(ZO)* Proof. First, observe that by 8.10 and Proposition 4.4(ii) in Chapter IX there is r > 1 such that
and consequently (wr,v) E Ap,rs,,(Io), where 7 = l / n + l / s ( l - l/r). That the statement holds for 0 < r < 1 as well is an easy consequence of Holder’s inequality. Let now p s q < s, and let r > 1 be sufficiently close to 1 so that (4.8) holds and the corresponding 7 verifies 7 < 2 / n s 1. By Proposition 4.1 it follows that j,lf(x)lq dp(x) s c ~Io(Il~n(~Vf~)(x))q dp(x) = A, say, and consequently it suffices to estimate A. Since by Theorem 2.4 in Chapter VI we have that I1/,,(lVfl)(x) s C(M,(IV~~)(X)M,,(IV~~)(X))”~ where v1 = l / n - l / s ( l - l/r), and all maximal functions are local on account of the fact that f is supported in Zo, A may be estimated by
Moreover, since (wr,v) E Ap,rs,,(Io), by Theorem 4.5 M,, maps LP,(Io)into wk-L,”(I,) and, similarly, M , maps LP,(I,) into wk-L,”/‘2r-1’(Io).Thus by Kolmogorov’s inequality 7.19 in Chapter IV, and since q < s, these operators actually map L”yIo)into L2(Zo)(with norm s c ( j , w(x)l dx)’-”/”)and into L2/(2r-1)(Io) (with norm s c ( j , w(x)~/(~~-’) dx?-¶”), respectively; the desired inequality follows now at once from (4.9). That the constant is of the right order requires a straightforward computation invoking the fact that w E RHr(Io). H In the same vein we prove Theorem 4.9 (Poincari’s inequality). Let w E Am(Io) and (w,v) E Sp,p,lln(IO) for some 1 < p < 00. Then iff is supported in Zo and is C’ there, there is a constant c independent off independent in A , and Sp,p,l/n(Io) so that n
(4.10)
Proof. Let g = f - fb, gIo= 0. By Theorem 4.4 and Proposition 4.1, which apply for the local maximal functions since f is supported in Io, we get
X . More about R"
274
I,
I,o
that L,lg(x)l"dcc(x) S c M # g ( x ) PdCL(x)zz c MI/n(lvfo(x)pdcc(x) and the conclusion follows at once from Theorem 4.6. W
Corollary 4.10. Assume w, u are as in Theorem 4.8, then (4.10) holds with a constant c kp(Io)s, 6 > 0, k = ks is independent in A,(Io) and Ap,s,I/ n (1 0 ) . We are now in a position to consider some applications of Theorems 4.8 and 4.9; we discuss here Harnack's inequality for divergence equations. More precisely, let R be a bounded domain in R", and consider (possibly degenerate) elliptic operators L given by div(AV) where A ( x ) = ( a v ( x ) )is an n x n real matrix which verifies
-
n
0
C aij(x)ti5j c w(x)ItI' (4.11) 5 = (tl,.. . ,en) in R"\(O). We make the following v(x)ItI' s
<j=1
for all x in R and assumptions on w, u: (i) w E A,(Io), for every I, c R, with A, constant uniform over Io; for some s > 2, on any I, c R, also with constant (ii) ( w , u ) E A2,s,lln(IO) uniform over I,. Item (ii) implies in particular that l / u is locally integrable, and by (4.10) the same is true of l / w . We may then define the Hilbert space H = L:(R, w, v ) as the closure of the C"(fi) functions 4 with respect to the + (jnlV4(x)12u(x)dx)'12 and extend the norm (InI#J(x)12w(x) bilinear form r
r
to H x H. Another important, and useful, property of these spaces is the following: if u E H and q E C ' ( R ) with q' bounded, then q ( u ( x ) )E H and (d/axj).rl(u(x)) = .r)'(u(x))(d/axj)u(x) a.e. in R, 1 S j n (for this and related results the reader may consult Kinderlehrer-Stampacchia [ 19801 and Gilbarg-Trudinger [ 19771). On account of the assumptions (i) and (ii) on the functions u, w, there is a q > 2 for which inequality (4.2) holds with p = 2 there and I, any cube in R; furthermore, by a density argument this inequality can be extended to any f in H with support in Io. Clearly, similar comments apply to PoincarC's inequality. c R is A function u E L:(R', w, u ) for each open domain R' so that said to be a supersolution (resp. a subsolution) to L if 2 ( u , 4 ) 5 0 (resp. S O ) for all #J E H, supp #J = a, and 4 2 0 there. Here, u is a solution to L if it is both a super-and subsolution to L. Our first observation is that nonnegative subsolutions verify a weak form of Harnack's inequality. More precisely, we have
a'
275
4. Sobolev and Poincare' Inequalities
Proposition 4.11. Assume u is a nonnegative subsolution to L. Then there exist constants c, rn > 0, such that if 21 c R, then
sup u s c(&
u ( x ) ' w ( x ) dx)li2.
(4.12)
(112~
(4.13)
Next we note that +v(u) (4.11) and (4.13) we get
E
H, and has support in I. Thus by Theorem 4.8,
Taking limits as M + m in (4.14), we obtain that for any p 3 1 (4.15)
where r=q/2> 1 (cf. 6.33 in Chapter VII). We may iterate (4.15) with p k = r k and 8 k = 1 - 1/2k7and, taking limits as k + m, the desired conclusion follows at once. Next we use the local boundedness of u to estimate up and In u.
X . More about R”
276
Proposition 4.12. Suppose u is a nonnegative solution to L and 2 1 c CR. Then there are constants c, m > 0 such that for any -1 c p s 1, we have X ) provided f S t < T S 1. suptl up C ( c / ( T - t ) l I l l / ” ) m,1 U ( X ) ~ W ( dx Proof. We may suppose inf, u > 0 (the essential inf that is), and put 4 ( x ) = $ ( X ) ’ U ( X ) ~ - ~ , s # 0, 1, where $ E C p ( 2 1 ) . Since by Proposition 4.11, u is also bounded above in 21, 4 E H and consequently 2 ( u , 4) = 0. This gives the inequality
(4.16)
-
as long as s # 0, 1. Given now any pair of values .C t < T c 1 we choose a function 7 E C : ( T I ) such that 7 = 1 on t I , 0 C 77 S 1 and I V v ( x ) l C 2/lZ11/”(T - t ) . Theorem 4.8 applied to ~ ( x ) u ( x ) ’ / ’ and combined with (4.11) and (4.16) gives
(
u (x ) “ ~ ”w ( x ) dx
In other words, if r = 4 / 2 > 1,
)”‘
E
= 11 - l/sl, then for any s # 0 , l we have
277
4. Sobolev and Poincare' Inequalities
The Moser iteration technique calls for repeated use of this inequality for a sequence of values of s, E, t. A choice that works in this case is tk = ;(I + z - ~ ) ,sk = sr k and E& = ill - 1/skl, where in order to avoid sk coming too close to 1 we take s of the form fr"(r + 1) for some integer u. Concerning In u we have
Proposition 4.13. Suppose u is a nonnegative solution to L, 21 c a. Then there is a constant c such that A ~ ( {ExI : Iln u ( x ) - (In u ) [ l > A } ) c cp(1)/111'/''.
(4.18)
Proof. We may assume sup u > 0. Let U = In u, by Chebychev's inequality it suffices to prove that ( , I U ( x ) - UIl d p ( x ) s c p ( I ) / ~ I ~ ' Now ~ " . since U E H we may invoke PoincarC's inequality to get
J I v u( x >~'
s c~(I)
dv(x).
(4.19)
I
To estimate the right-hand side of (4.19), we introduce the function 4 ( x ) = t,b2(x)/u(x),where $ E C;(21), = 1 on I, 0 s t,b s 1, and IVt,b(x)(s c/lZl"". Since (by replacing u by u + 6 if necessary and then letting 6 += 0) we may assume that u ( x ) 3 6 > 0 and by Proposition 4.11 u is bounded on the support of $, the function 4 E H and 2 ( u , 4) = 0. From this one easily gets that ( 4 ( x ) 2 a (U ( x ) , U ( x ) )dx c 4 ( a ( 4 ( x ) , c$(x)) dx and consequently
(4.20)
Whence combining (4.19) and (4.20) our conclusion follows. W We still need one more result essentially due to Moser [1971], the proof of which is also achieved by an iteration technique and is left for the reader to attempt.
Proposition 4.14. Assume {E(t ) } is an increasing family of measurable sets,
f s t c 1. Let g be a nonnegative, bounded function on E ( 1) which satisfies the following conditions.
X . More about R n
278
(i) There exist constants c, rn > 0 such that SUP^(^) gp d : T - I)-"' g ( x ) ' d p ( x ) , holds for 0 < p < 1, f 6 t 6 T s 1. (ii) There is a constant c such that A p ( { x E E(1): In g ( x ) > A}) d c.
IE(=)
Then there exists a constant k, depending only on the constants c, rn of (i) ( ~ k ~ ~ ) and (ii) above such that S U ~ ~g d We are now ready to state and prove Harnack's inequality
Theorem 4.15. Assume u is a nonnegative solution to L. Then for any compact subset K of R there exists a constant c = cK such that sup u s c inf u. K
(4.21)
K
P m f . We may, and do, assume that u ( x ) 2 6 > 0 a.e. in R. Our conclusion will follow once we show that to each x in R there corresponds an open cube I containing x and so that sup u d c inf u, J
(4.22)
J
where the constant c in (4.21) depends only on I. Z in fact is a cube centered at x so that 41 c a, 1211 C 1 and p(21) C 1. Put A = (In U ) 2 J and consider the functions U l ( x )= e - " u ( x ) and U 2 ( x )= e"u(x). We claim both of these functions satisfy (i) and (ii) in Proposition 4.14 for E ( t ) = 2tZ, f s t d 1. Indeed, U, , U2are bounded because u is bounded above and below. Now, according to Proposition 4.12 we have
for 0 < p < 1 and f s t < T s 1 and (i) holds for U,; a similar argument shows it also holds for V 2 . As for condition (ii), we note that since {x E 21: In U l ( x )> s} c {x E 21: Iln u ( x ) - A1 > s}; it holds for U , on account of Proposition 4.13, and similarly for U2.Whence by Proposition 4.14, and with a constant k which may depend on Z but not on u, we get sup U ] , I
sup J
u, d s
(4.23)
and, consequently, since U , ( x )U 2 ( x )= 1, the inequalities in (4.23) can be rewritten as k-' d U , ( x )d k,all x E Z, and sup U, S k2 inf, U,.The desired conclusion follows now by multiplying through by e". It is well known that this result has important consequences, such as the strong maximum principle (a solution to L which attains its maximum or
279
4. Sobolev and Poincare' Inequalities
minimum in
is constant) and local Holder continuity, max u - mjn u s r
1
1,
1/q
u ( x ) ¶d p ( x ) ) ,
where q depends on the Ap condition of w and I is well inside 0;for further details the reader should consult Gilbarg and Trudiner [ 19771. The exposition of the material presented here follows that of Harboure [19841 and is related to previous work of Fabes, Kenig and Serapioni [1982] and Chanillo and Wheeden [ 19851.
CHAPTER
Calderon-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
1. THE BENEDEK-CALDERON-PANZONE PRINCIPLE In this chapter we extend the continuity results we discussed for the Riesz transforms and more general odd kernels in Chapter X to arbitrary Calderbn-Zygmund singular integral kernels. We begin by proving a general principle which summarizes much of what we had to say concerning those kernels.
Theorem 1.1 (Benedek-Calderbn-Panzone). Suppose A is a sublinear R") into measurable functions which satisfies the followoperation from ing two conditions: (i) A is of weak-type (r, r), 1 < r < a.More precisely, for f in L'(R") and A > 0,
Cr(
Arl{lAA
'A l l =sc;llfllL
where c, is independent off and A. (ii) Let f e L ( R " ) , s u p p f ~B ( x o , R ) = { x E R": Ix - xol < R } , je(.+R)f(~)dx = 0. Then there are constants 1 < c,, c3, independent o f f and B ( x o , R) such that
I
R"\B(xo,czR)
IAf(x)l dx
c3llfll1.
Then A also is an operator of weak-type (1,l); in other words, there is a constant c4 = c4( cl, c,, c, ,A), independent off E C;( R") and A > 0, such that Al{lAA
'A l l 280
C4llflll.
28 1
1. The Benedek- Calderbn- Panzone Principle
Proof. For f in C,"(R") and A > 0, let f = g + b denote the CalderbnZygmund decomposition o f f at level A (cf. Theorem 3.1 in Chapter IV). In particular,
Also by 7.2 in Chapter IV, limN,mll~JNlbj - bll' = 0. Now since by the sublinearity of A we have that IAf(x)ls IAg(x)l + IAb(x)l, it easily follows that
l{lAA
'All s l{IAg/> Wl1 + I{IAbl > WlI.
(1.1)
The measure of the set involving g in (2.1) is readily estimated since by c ~ l l g lS l~ Chebychev's inequality we have (A/2)'({lAgl > A/2)1 cc;Ar-'llfll1 and consequently Al(lAg1 > A/2)( S 2'ccillfl11, where c is a dimensional constant. The term involving b is a bit more delicate. First, observe that
IAb(x)l S CIAbj(x)l
a.e.
(1.2)
i
Indeed, on account of tile subadditivity of A we have
N
=
+ CIAbj(x)I,
~ N ( x )
(1.3)
j=1
say. Now since l i m N + m ~-~CJEl b billr = 0 and A is of weak-type (r, r ) , it readily follows that +N + 0 in measure, as N + 00, and consequently there is a subsequence Nk+ 00 so that 4 N k (+~0) a.e. as Nk+ 00. Using this sequence in (1.3) gives (1.2) at once. We need one last observation of a geometric nature before we proceed with the proof. Let Bi denote the ball concentric with 4, with diameter Bj = c2 diameter Zj, and put R, = U Bi. Then lRll G CIBil S c ClfJls (c/A)llfll1, where c is a dimensional constant. With this remark out of the way we return to estimate Al{IAbJ> A/2}1 S AIR1l + A({x E R"\R,: IAb(x)l> A/2}1= I + J, say. We just noted that
282
XI. Caldero'n-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
AIRll S cllflll, and I is of the right order. As for J, observe that by Chebychev's inequality and (1.2). J s2
j
IAb(x)l dx s 2
R"\O,
j c
IAbj(x)l dx
R"\ni j
I,
Moreover, since each bj verifies b ( x ) dx = 0, by (ii) each summand above is bounded by c3 5,.1b(x)1dx 6 cc3 srJlf(x)ldx, and J C C ~ ( ( ~ which ( ( ~ , is also of the right order. Remark 1.2. Clearly, the same proof applies to L:(R"), the space of compactly supported, bounded functions on R".
Before we proceed with the applications, we discuss the case r covered by Theorem 1.1.
= a, not
2. A THEOREM OF ZO
We begin by proving
Proposition 2.1. Suppose A is a sublinear operator which satisfies the following three conditions: (i) A is of type (a,a) More . precisely, IIAfllms clllf)lm, where c1 is independent of J: (ii) Same as condition (ii) in Theorem 1.1. (iii) For every sequence (4) of pairwise disjoint open cubes and every integrable function h supported in 4 and such that I, h ( x ) dx = 0, allj,
u
IA~(x)I
CIA(hXrj)(x)I
ax-
i
Then A is also of weak-type ( 1 , l ) .
Proof. For f in L ( R " ) and A > 0, consider the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition off at level h, f = g + b. Since llgIlm 2"A, \Ag(x)\ c12"h and {IAgl > t } = 0 whenever t 2 c12"A. Therefore, {IAJ > ~ ~ 2 " +E !~ h } { ( A b (> c,2A}, and by (ii) and (iii) the measure of this set is estimated exactly as in Theorem 1.1. An interesting application of this result is to maximal operators of the form
283
2. A Theorem of Zo'
Our assumptions on the k,'s are those which will insure that (i), (ii), and (iii) of Proposition 2.1 hold. For (i) to hold it is readily seen that we must have
y z [R"lka(Y)l
dY s c,
(2.1)
i.e., { k a } a E Ais bounded in L ( R " ) .As for (iii) note that since
then also =0
N+w
for each
a
E
A.
Therefore there is a sequence N , + w such that
and consequently Ih * ka(x)I s CKhXr,) * ka(x)I
a-e.
i
which gives (iii) at once. Finally we consider (ii), this will require a new assumption on the ka's. We must estimate
I=
suplk, xo-xlZ=c2R
* f(x)l dx.
(2.2)
P
Now since jB(xo,R)f(~) dy = 0 we have k, * A x ) = jl.o-ylsR(k(~ -Y )k ( X - XO))f(Y) dv and SUPlk *f(x)l
[
SUPlkU(X- Y ) - kP(X - XO)lIf(Y)I dY.
.x--ylSR
(2.3)
01
Therefore, by Tonelli's theorem, putting (2.3) into (2.2) gives Is
j
Ixo-Y~S R
If(Y)I(
j
(r,-xlac2R
SUPlk,(X
- v) - k ( x - X0)l dx 4Y (2.4)
)
and (ii) will hold provided the innermost integral in (2.4) is finite. More precisely, we have Theorem 2.2
(26). Suppose { k a } a E verifies A the following two conditions
(i) JRnlkol<x>l dx (ii) ~lxlaczl,,l sup,[k,(x - y ) - k,(x)l dx s c3 where 1 < c2, c3 are constants independent of y E R".
XI. Calderbn- Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
284
Then the mapping f ( x )
T f ( x ) = sup,)k, * f ( x ) l is of weak-type (1,l).
Corollary 2.3. Suppose a nonnegative, integrable function 6 verifies IV+(x)l s c / I x l n f ' . Then if k E L ( R " ) and lk(x)I s 4 ( x ) , the mapping f ( x ) + SUP,,^/^^^ t-"k((x - y ) / t ) f ( y )d y ( is of weak-type (1,l).
Proof. Cf. 8.4 below. Corollary 2.4. Let k be as in Corollary 2.3 and suppose f E L ( R " ) . Then
Proof. Cf. Corollary 2.4 in Chapter IV.
3. CONVOLUTION OPERATORS How does Theorem 1.1 apply to convolution operators? Theorem 2.2 hints that the kernel k in question should verify the following conditions:
k
E
L(R")
(3.1)
and
By Young's convolution theorem, condition (3.1) alone implies thatf + k * f is bounded in L P ( R " ) ,1 d p C 00, with norm cllklll. But the kernels of interest to us, such as those corresponding to Riesz transforms, fail to be integrable in a neighborhood of the origin and at infinity. Aside from this they are locally integrable in R"\(O) and they satisfy (3.2), also known as Hormander's condition. Our strategy to deal with this more general situation consists of three steps, to wit: (1) Truncate k both at 0 and 03, obtain an integrable function, tr k say, and observe that the mapping f + tr k *f is well defined in L P ( R " ) , 1dpC0O.
(2)
Estimate Iltr k
*fIIp
s cllfllp, where c is independent of I(tr kill.
1
(3) Take limits, both in Lp and pointwise senses, to pass from tr k to k.
285
4. Cotlar's Lemma
In this section we address Step 2 by means of Theorem 3.1. Assume k satisfies conditions (3.1) and (3.2) and let A f ( x ) = k * f ( x ) . If in addition to A is of weak-type (r, r ) for some 1 < r < a,then it also is of type ( p , p), 1 < p < co, with norm independent of 11 kll
Proof. We fit our setting into the Benedek-Calder6n-Panzone principle. As we saw in the proof of Proposition 2.1, (3.2) implies that hypothesis (ii) of Theorem 1.1 holds, and, consequently, by Remark 1.2, A is of weak-type ( 1 , l ) on LF(R").Thus by the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem A is also of type ( p , p ) , 1 < p < r, with n6rm independent of llkll,. Let now h ( x ) = k(-x) and put A , f ( x ) = h * f ( x ) .By a simple duality argument it readily follows that for l / p + l / q = 1, A is bounded in L P ( R " )if and only if Al is bounded in L 4 ( R " ) ,with the same norm. Thus in our case A , is bounded in L 4 ( R " )for r' < q < co. But since h also satisfies (3.1) and (3.2), Al is also of weak-type ( 1 , l ) on Lp(R") and, by the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem, of type (q, q ) for 1 < q < 00 with norm independent of 11 kll ,; the same is true for A. In order to apply Theorem 3.1 we must have an important bit of information, namely, a value of r so that A is of weak-type (or type) ( r , r ) . The results in Section 2 and 3 in Chapter X are quite useful here, especially for r = 2. Before we proceed with the other steps we briefly digress to show how Hilbert space techniques apply in this respect.
4. COTLAR'S LEMMA Cotlar, in the commutative case, and Cotlar and Stein, in the noncommutative case proved the following important result. Lemma 4.1 (Cotlar's Lemma). Let {T,};, be a sequence of bounded, linear operators from a Hilbert space H into itself which verifies the following "almost orthogonal" property: Suppose there is a positive a ( j ) = A < 00 and sequence { a ( j ) }so that C-:,__,
II T,TEII, II TTGII
=S
a ( j - k)2,
all j , k,
(4.1)
where T* denotes the (Hilbert space) adjoinnt of T and IITII denotes the norm of T as a mapping from H into itself. Then
286
XI. Caldero'n-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
Proof. Suppose T is a bounded, linear operator in H. Then 11 T1I2 = (1 TT*)) = II(TT*)"II'/", all even n 2 1; this is a well known property of continuous operators on H. When applied to the T i ' s it gives
11 Till' = 11 TiTTI)S ~ ( 0 ) ' sA2, all j . (4h T =, :C , Ti. We want to show that 11 TI1 s A, independently of N.
Let now But this is not hard; indeed, first note that
1
(=*)" = TIT: * * * TZn-, Ttn, (4.3) where the sum is extended over all possible indices 1 S 6 S I)r, 1 S j S 2n, and next observe that the norm of each summand in (4.3)may be estimated in one of two ways, that is, either by
I I T , T * , ~ ~ - - - l l ~ ~ ~ s- a,( i~, -~i2)2~ l l ~ ( i ~ ,-, -i2n)2 ~ * *
or else by
II Till II T t T,e
* * *
(4.4)
II TLTz"-,ll1I c 1 .1
s Aa( i2 - i3)2 * a( i2n-2 - i2,-1)2A. (4.5) Thus combining (4.4)and (43,we see that the norm of each summand is bounded by Aa( il - i2)a(i2 - i3) * * - a( i2n-1 - i2") and consequently
AX
- -
I I ( T I " * ) "s I~ a ( i l - i2) . a(iz,-l - i z n ) . (4.6) To estimate the right-hand side of (4.6) we sum first over i2, and then ,.. . , i2 and note that it does not exceed successively over i2n-l
C 1 = A~"N.
~ 2 n - 1
(4.7)
il
Whence 11 ~ 1 = 1I[(ZT*)" ~ Ill/" s A ~ N " ", and, by letting n -* 00, we see that 11 TI1 S A, independently of N, as we wished to show. Cotlar first considered this result to avoid using Fourier transforms in proving the L2 continuity of convolution operators, and it has become an invaluable tool since. 5. CALDERON-ZYGMUNDSINGULAR INTEGRAL OPERATORS We discuss in this section the first step, namely, an appropriate truncation of the kernels. This we achieve for a very general class of kernels introduced by Calderbn-Zygmund [19521,[19561. Definition 5.1. We say that a function k, locally integrable away from the origin, is a Calderbn-Zygmund singular kernel, or plainly a CZ kernel, provided it verifies the following three properties
287
5. Caldero’n- Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
k ( x ) dxl S c l , where c1 is a constant (i) For each 0 < E < N, IjE
Lemma 5.2. Suppose k is a CZ kernel, and for 0 < E < N put k E , d x )= k ( x ) ~ { ~ < l . ~ < ~Then , ( x )kE,N . also is a CZ kernel, with constants uniformly bounded, independently of E and N. Proof. Fix E, N and in order to simplify notations put k E , N ( x= ) h(x). Since conditions (i) and (ii) are readily verified for h, with the same constants as k, it sufficesto check that h verifies Hormander’s condition with a constant independent of E, N. In other words, we must estimate
I,
IW
- Y ) - h(x)l dx,
Y
+ 0.
(5.1)
x1=21yl
We consider two cases, namely, IyI < N and (yl 2 N. The latter case is immediate since then the integrand in (5.1) vanishes identically. As for the former case there are three possibilities, namely: (1) Ix - y ( < E, ( 2 ) E c Ix - y ( S N, and ( 3 ) Ix - y l > N. Since (1) and ( 3 ) are dealt in a similar fashion we only discuss ( 3 ) . We have now 1x1 2 ( x - yl - lyl 3 N - 1x(/2, or N s 31x(/2. Therefore, since h ( x - y ) = 0; the integral in (5.1) is dominated by
I
lh(x)I dx c
2N/3<1xI
I
ZN/3r1x1rN
1 -lxI
Ixl
lk(x>I dx
( 3 / 2 N ) c 2 N= 3c2/2,
(5.2) and this estimate is of the right order. To bound ( 2 ) we find it convenient to break it up into three subcases according to whether 1x1 < E, E c 1x1 c N, or 1x1 > N. Once again, the first and third subcases are dealt in a similar fashion and we do only the first subcase this time. We have now 1x1 < E and the restrictions in the integral in (5.1) are 1x1 > 21yl and Ix - yI > E. This implies in particular that l y l < lx1/2 < ~ / and 2 therefore also Ix - yl C 1x1 + ly( =S 3 ~ / 2Thus . the estimate is reduced to C
XI. Caldero'n-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
288
Only one case remains, but now both h terms appear in (5.1) and they equal the k term. Whence (5.1) is bounded by c, and the proof is complete. H Next we show that the truncated CZ kernels kc,N are kernels of convolution operators, uniformly bounded in Lz(R").
I~rnrna~5.3. Suppose k is a CZ kernel and let kc,N be as in Lemma 5.2. Then lkE,N(()ls c, where c depends only on the CZ constants of k Proof. Fix E, N and put kE,N(x)= h ( x ) . First, observe that h^(,$) = eiYc h ( x - y)e-'"'*dx, y E R". Since eiy5= -1 for y = .rr,$/I,$12, we have that
I,.
fi(5) =
:(Il+ Il
- h ( x - y))e-"'*dx
)(h(x)
=I
+ J,
(5.3)
X1=-21Yl
xI--2Iyl
say. To estimate J is suffices to invoke the Hormander condition which, by Lemma 5.2, h verifies independently of E, N. As for I we rewrite it as IlxlG21yi(e-d.c - 1 M x ) dx +
I,xls,yl
h ( x ) dx
e-*'%(x - y ) dx = I , l ,,,,,,I
+ I2 - 13,
say. The bounds for Il and I2 are pretty straightforward. Indeed
II,l s
I
le-d'*
- l l l h ( x ) l dx
IX1==2IYl
l 5 l l ~ l ldx~ s~ C~l 5~l C 2l l Yl s
c.
Also
Now, I3 requires some work. We rewrite it as
I,x,==21yl
- j ; . l ~ 2 1 y ( e - ~+. c1 ) W x - Y ) dx + say, and note that since le-ixc 11 = le-'X'
+
1L1s
h ( x - y ) dx = 14+ 15,
- e-iYpI s cIx - ylI5l,
Ix-vlIh(x-y)ldx IX1~21Yl
lxllk(x)l dx s c.
s c/51 IX14Yl
then
5. Calderbn- Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
289
Finally to estimate Is we observe that since now Ix - yl
I,
h(x - y ) dx -
I
G
31~1,it equals
h(x - y ) dx = 16 - 1 7 7
Ix-Yl~3lYl
x-Yl4Yl
IXI>2lYl
say. Clearly 1161 G c , . As for Z7 note that since Ix - y ( 3 1x1 - lyl > lyl, then IZ71 s ~ l y l s l x - y l ~ 31y y)Il ~dx h (s~ 3cz. Since we have exhausted all cases the proof is finally complete. We are now in a position to prove
Theorem 5.4 (Calder6n-Zygmund). C,"(R")function f let Tef(x) =
I,
Suppose k is a CZ kernel and for a
k(x - Y M Y ) dY-
x-yl>s
Then there is a constant c = cp, independent off; and
1I TEfllP
E
> 0, so that
CllfIlP.
(5.4)
Moreover, Tf = lime+oTJ exists in L P ( R " ) 1, < p < 00, and it also satisfies the estimate (5.4). Furthermore, TEfand Tf are well defined for arbitrary f in LP(R"),and the norm inequality (5.4) holds for these functions as well. T, and T are called the truncated and the Calder6n-Zygmund singular operator associated to k
Proof. Fix 0 < E < N and forfin C P ( R " )put TF.Nf(x)= h * f ( x ) ,where h = ke.N as usual. By Lemma 5.3, 11 TE,Nfl12 S ~ l l f 1 1 ~ , c independent of E, N and, by Lemma 5.2, h satisfies Hormander's condition also uniformly in E, N. Therefore, by Theorem 3.1, T E , N fL~P ( R " ) ,1 < p < 00, and there is a constant c = cp so that (5.4) holds with Tefreplaced by Te,NJ Now, since T,f(x) = TE,Nf(~)for every x in R" for N 2 No(sUppfl, it readily follows by Fatou's lemma that (5.4) holds. In fact, a simple limiting argument shows that (5.4) holds for arbitrary L P ( R " )functions as well. Next, and to insure that Tf exists, we verify that { T e n is Cauchy in L P ( R " )for each f in CF(R").Let E > q > 0 be given and observe that T a x ) - Tf(x) =
=
I
v
j
W l Y Is6
=Z+J,
k(ylf(x - Y ) dY k(y)(f(x - Y ) - f ( x ) ) dY
(5.5)
XI. Calderbn-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
290
say. Moreover, since in our case [,.lf(x - y ) - f ( x ) l p dx s clyIp, by Minkowski's inequality it readily follows that
ll~ll,s cJ
as
Iyllk(y)I dy s C C ~ E= o(1)
E +
0.
IYlSE
As for the J term, note that by property (i) of CZ kernels lim,+o J,,lyl, 0. Whence
IlJllP
k ( y ) dv exists, and consequently ~imE,,+olJ,,<~y~~, k ( y ) dyl=
s
I
k ( Y ) dY rl'lYl==&
I
IIfll,
=41)
as
779
E
+
0,
and our claim is proved. Let Tf = lim c + o T,f denote the Lp limit whose existence we have just proved; clearly, 11 Tfll, S cllfll, as well. To show that the same holds for an arbitrary L P ( R " )function J; put f = g + h,where g is in C?(R") and llhll, s S is arbitrarily small. Then IIT,f- TEfllpS IIT,(f-g)llp+ IIT,g- Tsgllp+ I I T , ( f - g ) l l p s 2 c ~ + o ( l ) as E , V + O . Since 6 is arbitrary, {TEA is also Cauchy in L P ( R " ) lim,+o , TEf= Tf exists in Lp and it also verifies (5.4). As for p = 1 we have
* Theorem 5.5 (Calder6n-Zygmund). following additional property:
Suppose the CZ kernel k verifies the
(iv) If x l , x,, x 3 , y are such that x1 - x21, Ix, - x31, Ix, - X3I s R/2 and Ixl 1x2 - yl, 1x3 - 3 R, then
YI,
YI
where c4 is independent of the points involved and R. Then the mapping T,. defined in Theorem 5.4 is of weak-type (1, l ) , with norm independent of E, lim,+o TJ = Tf exists in measure and in the pointwise sense a.e. Furthermore, Al{lTeA > A l l s
Cllflll,
(5.7)
AI(1TY-I > A l l s cllfll1,
(5.8)
c independent of A, E,J; and
with c independent of A, f: Proof. Assumption (iv) insures that the proof given in Theorems 1.1 and 2.12 in Chapter V for the Hilbert transform also works in this case with minor adjustments. Another way to go about this is to observe that the
6. Maximal Caldero'n-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
291
estimate (5.6) insures that hypothesis (ii) of Theorem 1.1 holds, and consequently that result also applies. (Also cf. Theorem 3.1 in Chapter XIII.) There still remains the question of the pointwise convergence of the truncated CZ singular integral operators. This requires the simultaneous control of T&,Nf;and is achieved in the next section with the consideration of the maximal singular integral operators. 6. MAXIMAL CALDERON-ZYGMUND SINGULAR INTEGRAL OPERATORS
For a CZ kernel k let
T* is called the maximal CZ singular integral operator (associated to k ) and our aim is to show that under appropriate conditions the statements analogous to Theorems 5.4 and 5.5 hold for T* as well. Lemma 6.1 (Cotlar). Suppose the CZ kernel k verifies properties (i) through (iv) of Definition 5.1 and Theorem 5.5. Then for 0 < 77 < 1 and Tf as in Theorem 5.4,
T*f(x) 4wI~fl")(x)"" + M f ( x ) ) , (6.2) where c = c" is independent off E C r ( R " ) and x. Proof. As indicated above, for compactly supported functions f the limit as N + m of TE,Nfcan be easily handled, so we may just consider Tef: Now given compactly supported functions f; g it is readily seen that there is a sequence cj + 0 so that lim T J w )
&,+O
=
Tf(w)
and
lim T,g(w) = g ( w )
EJ+0
(6.3)
exist simultaneously for almost every w in R". Fix x in R" and E > 0 and for a given f in C r ( R " )let g ( y ) = f ( y ) x e c x , , , ( ybe ) the restriction off to the ball centered at x of radius E. Next observe that TEf(x)=
I,
X-yI>&
( k ( x - u ) - k ( w - Y)lf(Y) dY
XI. Calderbn- Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
292
say. In (6.4) we have chosen w to be a point B(x, ~ / 4 where ) (6.3) holds. Clearly, by (the first limit in) (6.3) lim&J+o K = T f ( w ) .As for the J term, ) sj + 0, upon choosing E~ sufficiently small it follows since w E B ( x , ~ / 4 and = that B( w, E ~=) B(x, E),and, consequently, for those ~j’sf(y)~Rn\B(~&)(y) ~ ( ~ ) x R “ \ B ( ~ , & ) ( Y ) x ~ ( ~ , ~n~ ) u(sY )J. may be rewritten as -Ilw-yI,EJ k(w y ) g ( y )dy and by (the second limit in) (6.3) lim,J+oJ = - T ( ~ x B ( & ~ ) ) ( w ) . Since Z is independent of E ~by , letting E~ + 0 in (6.4), we obtain that for almost every w in B(x, .5/4) T&f(X)=
J;
(k(x - Y ) - k ( w - Y ) ) f ( Y ) dY
X-YI>E
- T ( f X ~ ( x , & ) ) ( wTf(W) ) =I say. Now, by property (iv) of k, it follows that
J
K,
(6.5)
where 4(x) is the radial, decreasing, integrable function (1 + IX~)-(“+~), 4,(x) = E - ” ~ ( x / E )and , by Proposition 2.3 in Chapter IV, (I1 S cMf(x). Whence by (6.5) we see that ~)I (6.6) IT&f(x)) cMf(x) + ) T ( ~ X B ( X , E ) ) (lTf(w)l for almost every w in B ( x , ~ / 4 ) .NOW,if TEf(x) = 0, then clearly (TEf(x)I is bounded by the right-hand side of (6.2). Otherwise, let 0 < A < ITJ(x)l, ) B and introduce El = { w E B: ITf(w)l> A / 3 } , E2 = put B(x, ~ / 4 = { w E B: IT(fxBCq&))(w)l> A / 3 } and E3 = 0 if cMf(x) S A / 3 and = B if cMf(x) > h / 3 ( c is the constant in (6.6)). From (6.6) it is clear that B = El u E2 u E,, and we pass now to estimate the measure of these sets. In the first place by Chebychev’s inequality
Similarly, and invoking Kolmogorov’s inequality 7.19 in Chapter IV and Theorem 5.5, we see that
and since lE21 is finite, we also have
6. Maximal Caldero'n-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
293
As for E,, it either equals B, and in this case M f ( x ) / A > c > 1, or it is empty. In either case, P 3 1 6
lBlMf(x)/A.
Thus combining (6.7), (6.8) and (6.9) it follows that
IBI
=S cA-"
J i T f ( w ) l " d w + cA-'
I
lf(Y)ldY
B(x,E)
which, multiplying through by A / [ BI, in turn gives
+
s c(A'-"M((Tfl")(x) M f ( x ) ) .
(6.10)
+
Now, since from the inequality 0 < A G clA'-" c2 we readily get that A s max((2cl)'/", 2c2) s ( 2 ~ ~ ) "+" 2c2, by (6.10) we obtain A G c ( M ( ) T f ( " ) ( x ) ' / " M f ( x ) ) ,and (6.2) follows at once from this. H
+
Theorem 6.2. Assume the CZ kernel k verifies the assumption of Lemma 6.1. Then IIT*fllP
CllfllP,
1
< 00,
(6.11)
where c = cp is independent off:
Proof. For f in C ; ( R " ) , (6.11) follows at once from Lemma 6.1 and the maximal theorem. A by now well-known density argument gives the same result for arbitrary f in L P ( R " ) ,1 < p < CO. H Theorem 6.3. Assume the CZ kernel k verifies the assumptions of Lemma 6.1. Then Al{T*f> A l l s
cllfll1,
A
> 0,
(6.12)
for a constant c independent of A and f: Proof. One way to prove (6.12) is to repeat the argument of Theorem 2.14 in Chapter V. Another way is to note that on account of Lemma 6.1, it is enough to show that for f in C?(R"), A I ~ A= I AI{M(ITfl")(x)> A'II
cllfIIi,
Now, by 8.2 in Chapter IX, we have that 10Als cA-"
A
> 0.
(6.13)
I, I Tf(x)l"dx <
00,
294
XI. Calderbn-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
and consequently by Kolmogorov's inequality laA[ G cA-'16,['-'(wk-L norm ITfl)" G c A - ' ~ O ~ / ' -and ~ ~we ~ ~are ~ ~done. ~, We are now in a position to prove the existence of the pointwise limit of the truncated Calderbn-Zygmund singular integral operators. Theorem 6.4. Suppose the CZ kernel k verifies the assumptions of Lemma 6.1. Then lim,,, T , f ( x ) exists a.e. for each f in L P ( R " ) ,1 < p < 00, is denoted by p.v. k * f ( x ) , and it coincides with T f ( x ) , the norm limit.
Proof. For real valued k and f let A ( f ) ( x )= lim sup,,, T E f ( x ) lim inf,,, T E f ( x ) 0. Since we can writef = g + h, g E C,"(R")and Ilh [Ip 4 8, S arbitrary, we also have A ( f ) ( X )= A ( h ) ( x ) ,since by (5.5) (and making use of (ii) in Definition (5.1)) it readily follows that A ( g ) ( x )= 0 everywhere. Thus, A ( f ) ( x ) s 2 T * h ( x ) , and, consequently, for each A > 0 / { A ( f )> A}I 9 I{T*h > A / 2 } (s cApS. Since S is arbitrary we immediately get that / { A ( f )> A } / = 0 for each A > 0. Thus A ( f ) ( x )= a.e.; in other words lim sup,,, T E f ( x )= lim inf,,, T E f ( x )a.e. and the limit exists for each f in L p ( R " ) .Furthermore, since it coincides with T f ( x ) for f in C;(R"), a simple argument along the lines of Theorem 2.2 in Chapter IV shows that the same is true for an arbitrary f in L P ( R " )and we have finished. I 7. SINGULAR INTEGRAL OPERATORS IN L"(R")
As in the periodic case the class BMO arises as the image of L" under CZ singular integral operators. Theorem 7.1. Suppose the CZ kernel k verifies the assumptions of Theorem 5.5, let k , ( x ) = k ( x ) if 1x1 > E and 0 otherwise, and for f in L"(R") set
KEf(X) = j
y
x - Y ) - kd-Y)lf(Y) dY.
(7.1)
Then lime,, K E f ( x )exists a.e. in x and is a BMO function; more precisely, there is a constant c independent off such that
IIKfll*
cllfllm(7.2) Proof. Observe first that, on account of property (iv) of CZ kernels, the integral in (7.1)converges absolutely for each E and x ; in fact, it is precisely for this reason that the term - k , ( - y ) was introduced. Also note that iff is compactly supported, then K E f ( x )differs from T , f ( x ) by a constant. Moreover, well-known arguments by now show that limE,, K , f ( x ) exists in the L2 norm on each finite cube as well as pointwise a.e. in R".
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
295
Next consider K , f ( x ) - K N f ( x ) = kc,N* f ( x ) , where by Lemma 5.2 the integrable function kE,Nis a CZ kernel with constants uniformly bounded, independently of E and N. It is not hard to see that IIkc,N*fll* s C I I ~ I \ ~ , with c independent of E, N, and f ; in fact, the proof of this estimate is similar to that of Theorem 3.1 in Chapter VIII and is therefore omitted. Thus there is a constant c, independent of E, N, and f, so that
Next observe that if cN = IRn(kN(-Y) - k , ( - y ) ) f ( y ) dy, then K N f ( x ) C N = I p ( I C N ( x - y ) - k N ( - y ) ) f ( y ) dy tends to 0 uniformly as N + 00. Moreover, since the inequality in (7.3) remains unchanged if we replace K N f by K N f - cN, we get, by first letting N + CO and then E + 0,
8. NOTES; FURTHER RESULTS AND PROBLEMS Because of the many applications to other branches of analysis and PDE’s, the Calder6n-Zygmund theory of singular integral operators plays a basic role in harmonic analysis and lies at the heart of much of the work being done in this area nowadays. Although other mathematicians, most notably Giraud and Mikhlin, obtained n-dimensional results, it was only through the techniques introduced by Calderbn and Zygmund that the complete picture began to emerge. The classic 1952 Actu Mathemuticu and 1956 American Journal of Mathematics papers make inspiring reading and, even though they are quite well understood by now, there is yet much to be learned about the precise meaning of the various conditions discussed there. For instance, only recently Calderbn-Zygmund [19791 showed that in the case of kernels of the form k ( x ) = n(x’)/lxl”,n homogeneous of degree 0, the Hormander condition (iii) *of Definition 5.1 is actually equivalent to the following one: For a proper rotation p of R “ about the origin put /PI = suplx’ - px’l. Then if w , ( t ) = sup^^^^^ I,)k(px’) - k(x’)l dx’, ~ ~ o ,wl( l l t ) / t dt < 00. Also Calder6n and Capri [ 19841 have shown that if T is as in Theorem 5.4 and f and Tf are both integrable, then limE-,ollTJ Tflll = 0. The versatility of the methods discussed in this chapter is apparent in the consideration of the so-called CZ operators, corresponding to “variable”
296
XI. Calderbn- Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
kernels (also cf. Calder6n and Zygmund [ 1978]), and oscillatory singular integrals. Further Results and Problems 8.1 De Guzmin [1981] observed that the method of rotations applies to the Hardy-Littlewood maximal operator as well. In other words, assume that the 1-dimensional maximal operator is bounded in Lp, 1 < p < 00, and prove that the same is true for the n-dimensional maximal operator. What can be said for the case p = l ? 8.2 Suppose k ( x ) = f2(xr)/\xl", homogeneous of degree 0 and I,n ( x ' ) dx' = 0, is a CZ kernel and show that
lnll/cos
$1
T
- i-sgn(cos 4)
2 where $ denotes the angle between [ and x'. (Hint: we have
In polar coordinates
say. I is easily computed; as for R note that
+I
[ E COSl&'l,l)
(cos r - 1) - + dr r
I
[I/=)
dr cos r-, r
and take the limit as E + 0. The fact that jx f2(x') dx' = 0 is crucial.) 8.3 Suppose the kernel k verifies (ii) in Definition 5.1 and the mappings T , f ( x ) = k, * f ( x ) are bounded in some L P ( R " ) 1, < p < 00, uniformly in E. Then for each 0 < E < N, IJE
297
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
In case k ( x ) = R(x')/lxl",this implies that Ij, R ( x ' ) dx'l ln(N/E) is bounded uniformly in E and N and consequently I ,Cn(x') dx' = 0. The last assertion follows upon writing, for f in Cr( R " ) , ,.
c
=
J
(AX E+lSN
- y ) - f ( x ) ) k ( y ) dy
+f(x)
J
k ( y ) dy EGlylGN
=Z+J, say, and noting that Z converges since the integrand there is absolutely summable. Results of this nature, and more general ones, are discussed by Jurkat and Sampson [ 19791.) 8.4 Suppose 4 is integrable and 141s k, where k is integrable and ( V k ( x ) (s c/(x("+'.Then the mapping T f ( x ) = ~ u p ~ , ~ ( q*5f ,( x ) (is of weak+(y) dy)f(x) type ( 1 , l ) and iff is integrable then lim,+m & * f ( x ) = a.e. (Hint: Since 19, * f ( x ) l s k, * f ( x ) , it suffices to show the weak-type estimate for 4 replaced by k By Theorem 2.2 it is enough to verify that
(IRn
This estimate follows at once from the mean value theorem. 26 [1978] extended this result to the setting I+(x)l G kl(lxll)k2((x21),where x = ( x l ,x2) E R", x1 E R"I denote the first n, components of x and x2 E R"2 the last n2 .) 8.5 Assume 4 is integrable in R and 141=sk, where supp k c [0,1], k is nondecreasing and k E Lln+ L[O, 11. Furthermore, let {A,} be a lacunary sequence, and put T f ( x ) = sup,,lkAn* f ( x ) l .Then T is of weak-type ( 1 , l ) and if f is locally integrable it also follows that limn+mkAn* f ( x ) = (jro,l, k(y) d y ) f ( x )a.e. By means of Lemma 6.4 in Chapter IV it is possible to construct a nonlacunary sequence {A,,} which increases to 00 and a locally integrable function f so that for k as above lim sup,,m kAn * f(x ) = +0O a.e. (Hint: To show that T is of weak-type ( 1 , l ) it suffices to verify that assumption (ii) in Theorem 2.2 is satisfied. This result is also from Z6's work [19761.) 8.6 Assume k ( x ) = Cn(x')/Ixl"is an odd, homogeneous CZ kernel of degree -n, so that j,D(x')l dx' < 00, and put h ( x ) = b(lxl)k(x), where b is a Fourier-Stieltjes transform. Let T , f ( x ) = p.v. h * f ( x ) and show that Tl verifies the same Lp continuity properties as T f ( x ) = p.v. k * f ( x ) does. (Hint: Let g( t ) be in LP(R), 1 < p < 00, and E ( S ) be an arbitrary, positive, measurable function in R Then by the results concerning the Hilbert transform in Section 3 of Chapter X, the expression e-irsjls-tl,r(s) e'"g( t ) / ( s - t ) dt represents afunction with Lp norm acllgllp.
298
XI. Calderbn-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
Thus if p ( r ) is a function of bounded variation, from Minkowski's integral inequality it readily follows that the Lp norm of the function (of s) given by eirrg(t ) e-i's d t d p ( r ) s c(variation of p ) ( l g ( l p .
j, J;
S--II>E(S)
(s - t )
Now interchange the order of integration in the expression above and observe that since E ( S ) is arbitrary, we may conclude that, if
then also l\g*11, S cllgll,. To pass to the n-dimensional statement it suffices now to invoke the method of rotations, i.e., to use an argument similar to Theorem 3.1 in Chapter X; this result is from Calder6n-Zygmund's work [1956]. R. Fefferman [1979] observed that even in the case when b is an arbitrary bounded function the following is true: suppose that for each r > 0 we are given a function a, on X in such a way that the family {a,} is uniformly in the Dini class; i.e., if w ( t ) = sup{la,(x') - a,(y')l: Ix' - y'( < t, r > O}, then w( t ) / t dt < a;and also I ,a , ( x ' ) dx' = 0. Let h ( x ) = fllxl(x')/Ixln,then 1lp.v.h *fl12 s ~ l l f l 1 ~ .If in addition the Dini condition is replaced by a Lipschitz condition of some positive order, then also 1k.v. h *f",S cllfllp, 1 < p < a.The case p = 2 amounts to showing that h is bounded, but things get complicated when p # 2 since in general nothing - y ) - h(x)l dx. The proof relies can be said about integrals like ~lxlP21,,llh(~ then on the complex method of interpolation. Namazi [1984] relaxed the Lipschitz condition and characterized those b's for which the corresponding mapping is bounded from L"(R") into BMO(R").Also Shi [1985] proved results for more general CZ operators.) 8.7 Suppose that is a nonnegative function, supp c (1x1 s l}, such ,.+ ( x ) dx = 1. Let E > 0 and put & ( x ) = E - " + ( x / E ) and define that I 6 , ( x ) = T + € ( x )- k E ( x ) ,where k is a CZ singular integral kernel and T is the CZ operator associated to k. Show there exists a constant c > 0 such that 116,ll, s c, uniformly in E. (Hint: Suppose first 1x1 3 2 s and observe that by the Lebesgue dominated convergence theorem T+&) = JlylSE k ( x - Y ) & ( Y ) dy. Consequently, = jl,,lSE(k(x- Y ) k ( x ) ) + , ( y ) d y and the appropriate estimate for j l X 1 2 2 B 1 8 Edx ( ~follows )I from Fubini's theorem and condition (iii) in Definition 5.1. On the other hand
+
I,
X1S2E
18,(X)l dx
+
I,
XIS28
I W € ( X ) I dx +
j
lk<.>I dx
=
I + J,
E
say. To estimate I we invoke the fact that T is bounded in L2,and to bound J we use condition (ii) in Definition 5.1. This represents the first step in showing that, if f; Tf E L ( R " ) ,then lim,,,J~ TJ - Tflll= 0 (cf. Calder6n and Capri [1984]).)
299
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
8.8 There is yet another way to estimate T * f ( x ) under somewhat weaker conditions than those of Lemma 6.1. Rather than assuming condition (iv) of CZ kernels in Theorem 5.5, suppose that k verifies for Ix - y ( > E
where # satisfies the assumptions of Corollary 2.3. Show that under this hypothesis T * f ( x ) s c ( K f ( x ) M(lAr)(x)"rf M ( T f ) ( x ) ) ,where K is a mapping of weak-type (1,l) and type ( p , p) for 1 < p < 00, and 1 < r < 00. (Hint: We proceed as Lemma 6.1 and integrate (6.5) over w in B(x, ~ / 4 ) to obtain
+
I ~ € f ( X )=s l
c(
I,
If(Y)I&-"
X-yl>E
+ E-"
I,
l ~ ( f X B ( d ( W ) ldw
X--WIGE/4
=A
l u x - Y ) - k ( w - Y)I dw dY Ix--w(rs/4
+ E-"
I,
X--WISE/4
lTf(w)ldw)
+ B + C,
say. Clearly, A s supEm* 4 E ( = ~ K) f ( x ) , and by Corollary 2.3, K is as it should be. B is estimated by applying Holder's inequality and Theorem 5.4 and the bound for C is immediately.) 8.9 Let T, be a z-weakly measurable and uniformly bounded family of operators in L2(R"), 11 Tzll s M for all z in a measure space (2, dz). If the inequalities 11 TzT$lI, 11 TTTz.ll d h2(z,z') hold with a function h ( z , z') which is the kernel of a bounded integral operator H in L2(R")with norm A, then the operator T = T, d z is bounded in L2(R " ) with norm 11 TI1 d A. This variant of Cotlar's lemma is crucial in proving the L2 continuity of pseudo-diff erential operators (cf. Calder6n and Vaillancourt [ 19711). 8.10 Cotlar's lemma is quite useful when the Fourier transform is not available. For instance, for x # y in R let the kernel k(x, y) verify the following conditions: (i) D " ( ( x - y ) k ( x , y ) ) + 0 at infinity for each a, (ii) IWx, y)I 1/lx - Y I , (iii) I(a/ax)(k(x,Y)I l / l x - yI2. (iv) k ( r y ) = -k(y, x ) and (v) p.v. ~ l x - - y l s 4 m k(x, y) d y = 0 for each integer , and x E R Then the operator T f ( x ) = lime,,, jlx--yl,a k(x, y ) f ( y ) d y is bounded in L2 ( R ) .(Hint: For each integer j put = characteristic function of (4' s lx - yl d 4'+'}, &(x, y ) = k(x, y ) x j and denote by lj the integral operator corresponding to 4. Since for f E CF( R)IIC,"=-, Zjf - Tfl12-* 0 as N + 00 it suffices to show that C Il ,:-_, Zjll is bounded, uniformly in N. By (a variant of) Cotlar's lemma 4.1, and since on account of (iv) Ti*= -Ti and since the norm of an operator and that of its adjoint coincide, it is enough to verify that for m G j , 11 ljTm11 =s a ( j - m)', where C a ( j ) < 00. To do this we invoke the well-known and readily verified fact that if s(x, y) is locally
I
XI. Calderbn-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
300
integrable in R2 and j R l s ( x ,y)I dy, jRIs(x,y)l dx 1 (a.e.) then the operator with kernel s ( x , y) is bounded in L 2 ( R )with norm ~ 1This . gives at once that 11 TqII = 11 ?[ I 2 s 100. On the other hand, if m <j, then the kernel sj,,,(x, y) of T T , is given by j R 4 ( x , t)k,(y, t ) dt and the following estimates hold:
This allows us to observe that ~ s j , , , ( x , yG) ~uj,,(x - y ) , where a , , ( t ) = 0 if It[ > 4'+' 4"+', a , , ( t ) s 16.4-' if It f 6 4"'+', u , , ( t ) G 4-2J+mif 4' + 4,+' s It I s 4J+' - 4'"+', finally a.(, t ) = 0 if It1 < 4' - 4"+', q mt() s 16.4-J if It + 4'1 s 4"+'. Consequently, f R a',,,( t ) dt s 50.4-'+" = a ( j - m ) , which is precisely what we wanted to show. This result is from David's work
+
[1982].)
8.11 Motivated by 8.10 and the results in this section we propose the following definitions: we say that a possibly complex-valued, continuous function k ( x , y) defined for x # y is a Calderbn-Zygmund kernel provided the following two conditions are satisfied: (i) Ik(x, r)lc CIX - yl-". (ii) The distributional derivatives D"k(x, y ) , IaI = 1, coincide with -n-1 . locally bounded functions in x # y and verify ID"k(x, y)I S Ix - yl Associated to k we define the operator T by means of the formula T f ( x ) = Pev*I R n k ( x 7 y ) . f ( y )dy = lirn~;rOjI~-yI>~ k ( x , y)f(y) d y 7 f E C?(R"), and we say that T is a Calderbn-Zygmund operator provided T admits a continuous k(x, y ) f ( y ) dy extension to L2(R").As expected we denote T , f ( x ) = IIX-yl,E and T * f ( x ) = sup,) T,f(x)l. Prove that Calderbn-Zygmund operators are bounded on L P ( R " )1, < p < 00, and map L ( R " )into wk-L(R"). Also prove that the same result holds for 7'' and T * . (Hint: The proofs in Section 5 apply to this setting as well; the notation, as well as the formulation of the next four results, is due to Coifman and Meyer [1978].) 8.12 Show that the conclusion of 8.11 holds under the following assumptions on k in place of (i) and (ii) there: (iii) there exist a constant c and a number 0 < S c 1, such that, if Iy - yo[c r and ( x - yo/ 2 2r(x, y , yo E R", r > 0) we have Ik(x, y)I s cIx - yl-" and Ik(x, y ) - k ( x , yo)l, Ik(y, x ) k ( y o ,x)l s cr 6 Ix - yol-n-6. In fact, Yabuta [1985] has shown that the k suffices: Ik(x, y ) ( s cIx - yl-" following assumption on and lk(x, y ) - k ( x 7 yO))+)k(y, k(y07 x ) \ C ~ x - ~ o ~ - " w ( ~ ~ - ~ for all x, y, yo with 21y -yo[ < Ix -yo\, where w is a nonnegative, nondecreasing function with j(o,llw( t ) / t dt < a.
~ ~ / ~ x - ~
301
8. Notes; Further Results and Problems
8.13 Suppose T is a Calder6n-Zygmund operator which verifies the assumptions of either 8.11 or 8.12. Then for each function f in L P ( R " ) , 1 < p < CO, lim,,o T , f ( x ) exists and coincides a.e. with T f ( x ) defined as 4 k l l p -,0. follows: Tf = limit in Lp norm of TcPkwhere 4kE C r ( R " ) and 8.14 If T is a Calder6n-Zygmund operator a n d f e C r ( R " ) ,then for each x in R" we have T ' ( x ) ~ c l l T J J M ( l f l ~ ) ( x ) ' where '~, l
[If-
I,.(
suPsuP[l x
,
U l S l
I,
Ik,(X + U, x + y ) - k, (x + V, x + y)I du dV S 4 ( y ) ,
U(G1
where as usual k,(x, y) = v - " k ( x / 7, y / v ) and for IyI 2 N, some large value, 4 ( y ) is a radial, nondecreasing, integrable function. Then if T f ( x )= p.v. k(x, y)f(y) dy is of weak-type (1, l), and a < a,, is sufficiently small, M c , T f ( x )S c M f ( x ) , where c = c,,+ is a constant independent of x and J (Hint: For convenience we assume that all maximal functions are centered, i.e., the sup at x is defined over all open cubes centered at x. Let then I be an open cube centered at x,. For a fixed locally integrable function f we put fl =fxn1/2NI, f 2 = f - f 1 . Since T is of weak-type ( 1 , l ) we have / { Y E I: ITf,(y)l>A}l
I,.
302
XI. Calderc5n-Zygmund Singular Integral Operators
We estimate the innermost integral A in the preceeding inequality. The cube I is obviously contained in a ball with the same center as I and with radius 6 = diam Q/2. Hence by changing variables we see that
Whence the right-hand side in the above inequality is majorized by c ( I (IRn(f2(y)(46(xo- y ) dy/A 9 c(I(Mf(x,)/A, and this estimate is also of the right order provided that A > cMf(xo). Since I is arbitrary our proof 4 ( y ) lnlyl dy < 00 is complete. A similar argument shows that, if IlylSEN instead, then the stronger inequality M & Tf(x) d cM#f(x) holds. These results, as well as related ones, are in Jawerth and Torchinsky's work [19851.) 8.17 Let k E Y ' ( R " ) have compact support and let 0 < 8 < 1 be given. Further, suppose that ,k coincides with a locallyAintegrable function away and from the origin, that k is a function and that Ik(S)l d A(l + 1~$1)-"' / ~ - y ) - k(x)) dx d c for lyl d 1. Then the convolution operator jlxl,21yl~-~,lk(~ T'= p.v. k *J;is bounded in L P ( R " ) ,1 < p < 00, and maps L"(R") into BMO(R"). (Hint: We may assume that k is integrable by replacing, if necessary, k by k * 4€,where 4 is a C,"(R")function with integral 1, and observing that the above conditions are satisfied by k * 4€,uniformly in E. We show first that T maps L" into BMO. Let I be a cube of dianeter 6, which we may assume is centered at the origin. Of the two cases, 6 S 1 or 6 > 1, we only do 6 d 1. Write f =f,+ f 2 , where f,= f in the ball 1x1 d 26'-', f 2 = f -4, and u1 = Tfl, u2 = Tfi. In terms of Fourier transforms n0/2 * GI([) = )5(-"e/2k([)1S1 f,([), where according to our assumptions $(t)I#'e/2 is bounded. Thus, by (the n-dimensional variant of) Theorem 2.1 in Chaptzr VI, u ^ , j s the FouGer transform of an Lp function with norm ~All~(S)~S~"""f1(S)ll2 cllfll12 cllf,l12, with l l p = 1/2 - 8/2. in other words Thus IrIul(x)pdx d cllf,ll; d CllfIlmNow let a, = k(-ylf,(y) dy. Since UZ(X) (l/lIl) f,IU1(X>1dx a, = jRn(k(X- y ) - k ( - y ) ) f , ( y ) dy, if 1x1 d 6 (which is the case if x E I), we get that IuAx) - a,( (Ilyl,21xll-elk(~- v) - k(-y)l dy)llfllm. Clearly T is bounded in Lz, and by Theorem 4.2 in Chapter VIII, T is also continuous in L P ( R " )for 2 < p < 03. The statement for 1 < p < 2 follows by duality. These operators were introduced by Fefferman [19701, who also proved that they are of weak-type ( 1 , l ) . The fact that they map L" continuously into BMO was proved by Fefferman and Stein [1972].)
CHAFTER
XI1 The Littlewood-Paley Theory
1. VECTOR-VALUED INEQUALITIES It is often possible to extend inequalities involving scalar valued functions to functions which take values in a Banach space and thus obtain not only a more general result but also one which can be applied to other situations. The purpose of this chapter is to take systematic advantage of this fact. We begin by giving two important examples, one concerning maximal functions and the other Calder6n-Zygmund singular integral operators. In each case , c: p < Q), and the applications will be discussed the Banach space is l P ( Z ) 1 later on.
Theorem 1.1. (Fefferman-Stein). Let f = (fi,. . . , f k , . . .) be a sequence of functions defined on R " and, corresponding to f, consider the sequence Mf = ( Mfl . . . ,Mfk, . . .) whose kth term is the Hardy-Littlewood maximal function Mfk offk. Then II II~fkIlI'llp CII Ilfkllrdlp7 1 < r7 P < Q), (1.1) where c = c,,, is independent of$ Also, and with a constant c = c,,~independent off,
NlMfkllI' > All cll llfklll,lllY 1 < r < Q). (1.2) Proof. To simplify notations put F ( x ) = Ilfk(x)lllr and m F ( x ) = IIMkf(x)I(,r.We consider separately the cases p < r, p = r, and p > r. When p = r (1.1) follows at once from the maximal theorem since
(1.3)
XII. The Littlewood -Paley Theory
304
where dJ E L'P/"'(R")and has norm S l . To estimate the integral in (1.4) we invoke 8.23 in Chapter IX and note that it is dominated by "
I f k ( x ) l ' ~ 4 ( xdx )
s
~ l l ~ l l ~ l l ~ sl lc~l l Fp l l/ i *r ~ ~
Therefore the right-hand side of (1.4) is bounded by cllFilp, which is precisely what we wanted to show. Finally since the remaining cases of (1.1) follow from (1.2) and the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem, we show (1.2). Consider the Calder6n-Zygmund decomposition of F at level A and in particular consider a family of disjoint, open cubes ( 4 )such that if R = 4, then ~ R ~ S ~ ~ F ~ ~ , / A , F ( x ) 6 A for x in R"\R and ( l / l 4 l ) IrJF ( x ) dx s 2"A, all j . Let now fk = g k + hk, where gk =f xXR" \Cl, hk and put G ( x ) = Ilgk(x)IIIr,rnG(x)= IIkfgk(x)l(lr andsimilarlyfor H and rnH. Since Mfk(x)s Mgk(x) + Mhk(X), all x and k, it suffices to show that rnG and rnH are in wk - L ( R " ) , with norm s c 11 FII 1 . This is immediate for m G since 11 G 11 zs cA 1) FII and by (1.3) ((rnG((, zs cllGllr; whence A'({rnG> All cA'-'llFll~. The estimate for H requires some work. In the first place let f k ( x )= Cj((l/141) j j , f k ( y )dy)xrJ(X)and P(x), rnF(x) as usual. Observe that supp F c a, and for x E 4, by Minkowski's inequality, we, have F ( x ) s (1/I4I) Ir,IIh(~)IIi~d~ = (~/IJI) IjJ F ( Y )d ~ 2 " 5 ~ - Thus IIFII: s CAW s c A ' - ' J J F I J ~ and as above we see that Al{F > A}l 6 cllFII,. Our proof will (2n4), then for all k and thus be complete once we show that, if 6 = with a constant c independent of k,
u
uj
kfhk(x)zs ckffk(x),
a.e. in
~"\6.
(1.5)
To show (1.5) fix a cube Z containing x and note that
where the sum is only extended over J = {those j ' s so that I n 4 # 0).In this case, since x E Z \ 6 c I \ 2 n 4 , by the geometry of the situation, it follows
305
1. Vector-Valued Inequalities that I j G 2nI. Therefore, the right-hand side of (1.6) does not exceed
Since I is arbitrary we conclude that for x E R"\fi, Mh,(x) s cMfk(x)and we are done. A similar result is true for CZ singular integral operators, the key observation being that a statement analogous to 8.23 in Chapter IX holds in this case as well. More precisely, we have
Theorem 1.2 (C6rdoba-Fefferman). Assume k is a CZ kernel which verifies the assumptions of Chapter XI. If T denotes the CZ singular integral operator associated to k and w is a nonnegative function so that w s is locally integrable for some s > 1, then
"I,[ for all f
E
~ f ( X ) l " W ( X ) dx
s c [R"lf(x)lpM(w s ) ( x ) l / dx s
L P ( R " ) 1, < p < co, and a constant c
=
(1.7)
cp,sindependent off:
Proof. We begin by pointing out a variant of Theorem 7.1 in Chapter XI, namely, TfX(x)s c M ( l j y ) ( x ) 1 / q 7 1 < q < co, (1.8) with c = cq independent off: To see this fix a cube I containing x and put f = fx21+ fXRn\2I = fl + f 2 , say. Then Tf = Tfl + Tf2and it suffices to show (1.8) with f l and f 2 in place off in the left-hand side of that inequality. In the first place, by Holder's inequality and Theorem 5.4 in Chapter XI,
and this estimate is of the right order. Also for y in I,
s cM(lj-y)(x)'/",
and consequently the estimate (1.8) holds.
XII. The Littlewood- Paley Theory
306
Now since by Proposition 3.3 in Chapter IX,M ( w S ) ( x ) ’ / ’ E A,, from (a simple variant of) Theorem 4.4 in Chapter X and (1.8) it follows that
.1
I,. == 1.“
I T f ( x ) l ” w ( x ) dx <
I T f ( x ) l ” M ( w ” ) ( x ) ’ / ”dx Tf”Y(x),M( w ’ ) ( x ) l / ’ dx
=z
1..
M ( Iflq)( X ) ” / ~w’)( M (x ) ’ ~ dx. ’
(1.9)
Suppose now that 1 < q < p, then p / q > 1 and by Theorem 4.1 in Chapter IX we see that the righthand side of (1.9) is dominated by c ~ , . ~ f ( x ) ~ p M ( w ” ) ( xdx, ) ‘ ~and ” the proof is complete. 4 We are now in a position to prove Theorem 1.3 (C6rdoba-Fefferman). Let (4)be a sequence of CZ kernels with unformly bounded CZ constants and let {Ti} denote the sequence of CZ singular integral operators which correspond to the 4’s. Then
where c = c,.,
II Il~LllrIl,c cll II.6III~llP9 1 < r,P < 00% is independent off = (fl, . . . ,A,. . .).
(1.10)
Proof. Since a simple duality argument shows that the estimate (1.10) holds with indices p, r if and only if it holds with indices p’, r‘, l/p + l/p’ = l / r + l / r ’ = 1, we may assume that p 3 r. The case p = r is a simple sequence of Theorem 5.4 in Chapter XI.On the other hand, if p > r, then the left-hand side of (1.10) equals
where g E C , “ ( R “ )and ~ ~ g ~ S~ ~1. Now p , r by ~ rTheorem 1.2, and with 1 < s < ( p/ r)’ there,
IlfjIIV l l ~ l l ~ ~ l ~ l s ~ ~ ~ s l l ~ ~ CII II.6IIr 1; llglk,/rY,
sz CII
and we are done. We consider next a general result in the direction of Theorem 1.4 and some of its applications.
2. Vector-Valued Singular Integral Operators
307
2. VECTOR-VALUED SINGULAR INTEGRAL OPERATORS We begin by discussing some preliminary results; we intend to be brief. Given a separable Hilbert space H with inner product (,) and norm lhlH = Ihl = (h, h)"2, we say that a functionfdefined on R" and with values in H is measurable (or weakly measurable) if the scalar function ( f ( x ) ,h ) is Lebesgue measurable for every h in H. The class Lp(R",H ) consists of those measurable f with Ilfll, = ( j , . l f ( x ) l P d ~ ) < " a, ~ 1 p s 00, and similarly ~ ~ =f ess ~ sup,nlfl ~ m denotes the norm in L"(R", H). For a couple of separable Hilbert spaces HI, H2 let B( HI,H2) be the (Banach) space of bounded, linear operators T from HI into H2 endowed with the norm ITIB(H,,H2)= IT1 = ~ ~ ~ h e H , ( l ~ l H ~ / l h l H , ) . We say that a functionfon R" and with values in B( H1,H 2 )is measurable if f ( x ) h is an H2 valued, measurable function or each h in HI. In this case IflB(H,,H,, is also Lebesgue measurable and the spaces LP(R",B ( H , , H 2 ) ) may be defined exactly as above. The usual facts concerning operations of functions hold in this general setting as well. For instance, suppose that a function k defined on R" and with values in B ( H I ,H2) is integrable, and for f in LP(R",H,) put
Then the integral in (2.1), as an element in H 2 , converges weakly in H2 for d ~Furthermore, . almost every x, and l g ( X ) l H , IRntHx- Y)IB(H,,H,J~(Y)IH, llgllp s Il~lllllfll, 1 P Another important property concerns the Fourjer transformation. For f in L(R", H)we define its Fourier transform bzf(5) = jRne - i 2 T x ' v ( xdx. ) In this case is also H valued and clearly IIfllg, s llflll. Futhermore, if f E L(R",H ) n LZ(R",H),by means of an appropriate limiting process as was done in Chapter X, also f E L2(R",H) and Plancherel's identity is valid for these functions. This is readily seen by expressing the elements of the Hilbert space in terms of an orthonormal basis and then proceeding as in the scalar case. To further illustrate the fact that the results we need in this setting are simple extensions of the scalar case we prove the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem. Theorem 2.1. Let A be a sublinear operator defined on LF(R",HI), i.e., compactly supported, bounded H,-valued functions, with values in M(R", H2), i.e., the space of measurable, H2-valued functions. Suppose in Hl)AI{IAflH, > A)I 6 c l ~ ~ fand ~ ~ ArI{IAflH, l, > addition that forfin hm(R", A)[ s c ~ ~where ~ fc1 and ~ ~c, are ~ ,independent of A and f: Then for each
XII. The Littlewood - Paley Theory
308
1 < p < r, we have that Af E LP(Rn,H2) wheneverf E LP(R",H , ) and there is a constant c = cl,,,, independent off such that IIAfII, s cllfll,. Prmf. Let F ( x ) = (If(x)lH,)-'f(x) wheneverf(x) # 0 and 0 otherwise. For a scalar valued function g consider Bg(x) = jA(F(x)g)l,,. Clearly B is a sublinear mapping, simultaneously of weak-types ( 1 , l ) and (r, r), with norm s cl, c,, respectively. By the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem 4.1 in Chapter IV there is a constant c as indicated above so that llBgllpS cJJgJJ,, 1 < p < r. Upon setting g(x) = If(x)lH,our proof is complete. W An important result for our purposes is the following extension of Theorem 1.1 in Chapter XI,
Theorem 2.2. Suppose a linear operator A defined in LT( R", Hl) and with verifies values in M ( R " ,H2)
(9 ~ ' l { I A f l >~ 1 1 C l l l f l l r , some r > 1. (ii) Iff has support in B(x,,, R) and integral 0, then there are constants c2, c3 > 1 independent off so that
I
R " w x O .c2R )
IAf(x)l dx
C3llflll.
Then also Al{lAA > A}[ s cllfll, and by Theorem 2.1 also IIAfll, for 1 < p < r.
cllfll,
Since the proof is identical to that of the cited result, it is omitted. In the same vein we have Theorem 2.3. Let k be a function on R" whose values are bounded linear operators from H , to H,; we assume k to be measurable and integrable on compact sets. For f~ L,"(R", H , ) put
r If for some r > 1 and f in L'( R ",H,)the inequality 11 Tfll and
I
Ik(x - y ) - k(x)l dx
S ~ 2 ,
y
E
llfll ,holds,
c1
R",
lXl*2IYl
then Tf E LP(R",H 2 )for all 1 < p < 00 and 11 Tfll, s cllfll, where c depends on c,, c2 and p but is otherwise independent off:
3. The Littlewood-Paley g Function
309
The proof is identical to that of Theorem 3.1 in Chapter XI and is omitted. As for the vector valued singular integrals we have Definition 2.4. We say that a function k on R" whose values are bounded operators from H1to H2 is a vector-valued Calder6n-Zygmund integral kernel provided that (i) k is measurable and integrable on compact sets not containing the origin. (ii) For 0 < E < N, (jEclxl
The first application we consider is to the Littlewood-Paley theory. For this purpose we let Hl = C, the complex numbers, and H2= L2(R+,d t l t ) , the Hilbert space of square integrable functions on the positive half-line with respect to the measure d t / t , and norm
Definition 3.1. We say that a scalar valued function 6 on R" is a LittlewoodPaley function provided it satisfies
+
E L ( R " ) , ~ ,+ . ( x ) dx = 0. (i) (ii) I+(x)l s c(1 + JX~)-("+O),some a > 0. (iii) f , n l @ ( x + y ) - +(x)l dx d clyl', y in R", some y > 0.
XU. The Littlewood -Paley Theory
310
Clearly any Schwartz function with vanishing integral verifies (i)-(iii). We also have PIoposition3.2. Suppose I)is a Littlewood-Paley function and 5 E R". Then
I$( 81H2s c*
Proof. We begin by showing that
1$(&>1
s c min(l~la'(n+l+a) 121-y), 9
(3.1)
where c is independent of 5. Since by identity (5.3) in Chapter XI $(2) = ~ j , . ( $ ( x )- $ ( x + y))e-"'*dx, y = .rr&/1@, by (iii) above it follows s c1,$1-'. Furthermore, since I) has vanishing immediately that l$(.$)I integral, we also have =I ,.$(x)(e-"'* - 1) dx, and consequently
$(e)
I$(S)l s 2 1,"I$(X)l min(lxl 121,1) dx s 2121
I
IxlI$(x)I dx + 2
IXlS?
I
IXI'?
II)(x)l dx
=I+J, say. Now since I C cl,$clq"+' and J C ccl j l x l > q l ~ I - ( n + adx ) = cq-O1, we obtain at once that I$(.$)I c c(I(lq"+' + q-"), and (3.1) follows upon minimizing with respect to 7. To complete the proof we invoke (3.1) and estimate
~$(.S>I'H, s c
j
min((tltl)a'(n+l+a),
dt ( t l 5 1 ) - " ) 2 y s c.
10.~)
Let now k ( x ) E L(C, L2(R+,d t l t ) ) be given by k ( x ) a = t - " $ ( x / t ) a = $,(x)a, where x E R", a is a complex scalar and $ is a Littlewood-Paley function. Corresponding to k we consider the singular integral operator
= lim E'O
J
- Y M Y ) dy.
(3.2)
Jx-yI>s
We want to show that T falls within the scope of Theorem 2.5 and thus obtain its Lp continuity, 1 < p < 00. To get a feeling for the situation we do the L2 case first.
3. The Littlewood - Paley g Function
311
Proposition 3.3. T is bounded from L2(R") into L2(R", L2(R , ,dt/ t ) ) .
Proof. Observe that for f in Lz(R") and on account of Tonelli's theorem, Plancherel's identity, and Proposition 3.2 we have
In fact a more precise result holds in the particular case $ is radial, namely Proposition 3.4. Suppose $ is a radial Littlewood-Paley function, then
Proof. As above we see that
4
and sinceA is also radial the innermost integral in (3.4) is readily seen to be I[o,co,I+Cl(t)IZ/tdt*rn For the other values of p we have Theorem 3.5. Suppose T is given by (3.2). Then
II Tfll,
cllfllp,
1
<
m 9
whre c = cp is independent of J: Proof. We verify that (i)-(iv) in Definition 2.4 are satisfied. (i) is immediate. As for (ii), observe that since IlxlsR $ ( x ) dx = $ ( x ) dx, by property (ii) of Definition 3.1
-IIxIpR
XII. The Littlewood - Paley Theory
312
and consequently IjlxlsR + t ( x )dxl, d c, which gives (ii). On the other hand, from (ii) of Definition 3.1 it follows that lk(x)l d cIxI-" and (iii) also holds. Finally, to show that Hormander's condition is satisfied let 0 < E < min(cy, y, n) and observe that (XI-(n+f)/2(IXl(n+E)'21k(X
- y ) - k ( x ) l )dx
We want to verify that the integral in (3.5) does not exceed place note that it is bounded by
Moreover, I+((x - y ) / t ) - +(X/t)l d c ( l +(I. =s c ( l
1~1"'~.
In first
- yl/t))-'"+"'+ c ( l + ( I x l / t ) ) - ( " + " )
+ (Ixl/t))-("+")s c(t/lxl)"+'.
Thus the expression in (3.6) is bounded by
= cly1"/2.
rn
Theorem 2.5 in this context is best expressed as follows: For a LittlewoodPaley function andfin L P ( R " )1, < p < co,put F ( x , t ) = f * + t ( x ) and let
+
(3.7) denote the Littlewood-Paley g function of E Then g ( F ) is in L P ( R " )and there is a constant c = cp,, independent off so that IlS(F)llP
CllfIlRL
1
< 00-
(3.8)
It is useful to point out that the inequality opposite to (3.8) also holds. This is easiesi seen for the particular case when is radial, and normalized so that jro,oo)l+(t)12/f dt = ( 2 ~ ) "In. this case by (3.3) we have that llg(F)112= llfllz and consequently by polarization it follows that
+
(fi,f2) = (fl*+,,A* +A
=(
F l y
F2),
(3.9)
3. The Littlewood-Paley g Function
313
where the first inner product in (3.9) is that of L2(R")and the second one that in L2(R",L2(R+,dtlt)). Suppose now thatf, E L 2 ( R " )n L P ( R " ) 1, < p < 00, andf, E C?(R"),llf211D,s 1. Then by (3.9), Holder's inequality and (3.8) it readily follows that
I
[Rnfl(x)z(x) dxl
=Z
[[ R"
IFl(x, t)l IF2(x, t)l
dt t dx
W,m)
I..
g ( 6)( X I g( F 2 ) (x) dx S IIg ( 4)IIp IIg ( F2)IIp'
cllg(~l)IIp.
Whence by the converse to Holder's inequality we immediately see that
Ilflll,
clIg(F1)IIp,
fl E
L 2 ( R " )n L P ( R " ) ,
(3.10)
and the same inequality holds for generalf in L P ( R " )as , a simple limiting argument shows. In particular our results apply to the function )I with Fourier transform $ ( I )= 161e-I*l; this corresponds to the classical Littlewood-Paley function $(x) = c(a/at)( t/( t2 I X ) ~ ) ( " + ~ ) ' ~ ) ] ~ _ obtained , by differentiating the Poisson kernel. It is also important to incorporate into the theory the space of the Poisson kernel. There are derivatives $j(x) = (a/ax,)(l + IXI~)-("+')'~ two djfficulties in proving (3.10) for these functions, i.e., $j is not radial, = c,$e-l*I vanishes identically along ,$ = 0; clearly, there is no and $,(I) problem with (3.8). The way to overcome this is to consider instead the gradient of the Poisson kernel whose Fourier transform is the vector ce-l*lf. Indeed, since jro,m,( t1,$1)2e-2"*'/tdt = 2 it readily follows that for sufficiently smooth functions f , ,f 2
+
X I . The Littlewood- Paley Theory
3 14
4. THE LUSIN AREA FUNCTION AND THE LITTLEWOOD-PALEY g: FUNCTION In order to consider the next application we set H , = C and H2 = {b:lblH2= ( l / u a " ) ~ ~ O , m ) ~ , y lt)12/tdydt)1/2< <,~h(~, a},where a > 0 and u = volume of the unit ball of R". Let now k ( x ) E L(C, H2) be given by k ( x ) a = t-"$(x/t - y ) a , where x E R", ( y , t ) E R:+', a is a complex scalar and $ is a Littlewood-Paley function. Corresponding to k we consider again the singular integral operator
r
= lim E'O
[
$t(x - tY - w ) f ( w )dw.
(4.1)
I.Y- - H .I>F
We then set F ( x , t ) = f * & ( x ) and ITf(x)l = S,(F)(x), the Lusin (or area) function of F (with opening a). If we denote by T,(x) = { ( y , t ) E R:+': Ix - yl < at} the cone with vertex at x and opening a, it follows immediately that
As we did in case of the g function it may be readily seen that llSa(F)[[2 S cllfl12. Indeed, it suffices to observe that if y, denotes the characteristic function of the unit interval then
(4.3)
and the assertion follows at once from Proposition 3.3. In fact the above argument shows that under the normalization of (3.9), also IISJllz = Ilf112. Also an argument quite similar to that of Theorem 3.5 shows that k verifies (i)-(iv) in Definition 2.4 and consequently
IISJll,
ZS
cllfll,
1 < P < a,
(4.4)
4. Lusin Area Function and Littlewood-Paley gf Function
315
where c = cp,, is indepedent off: To prove the inequality opposite to (4.4) we proceed exactly as in Section 3, so we say no more. Returning to the constant in (4.4) it is of interest to consider its dependence on a. It is best to approach this question from a geometric point of view and in order to do this we need the following observation Lemma 4.1. Let 0 be an open set in R" and for a > 1 associate to it % = { x E R " : Mx,(x) > 1/2a"}.
Then if T,(R"\%) T(R"\O), we have
=
UxeRn\, T,(x),
and similarly for T,(R"\O) =
(i) If (y, t ) E T,(R"\%), then IWy, t)l s 21B(y, t ) n (R"\Q)I. (ii) T,(R"\%) s T(R"\O). Proof. If ( y , t ) E T,(R"\%) there is x g % with ly - X I < at, or x E B ( y , a t ) . Thus IB(x t ) n O I I I W y , t)l s a"lB(y, a t ) n Ol/lB(y, at)l s a"Mx