December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 1 (2002) 1–28 c World Scientific Publishing Company
SEMICLASSICAL MOTION OF DRESSED ELECTRONS
STEFAN TEUFEL∗ and HERBERT SPOHN† Zentrum Mathematik, Technische Universit¨ at M¨ unchen, 80290 M¨ unchen, Germany ∗
[email protected] †
[email protected]
Received 6 February 2001 We consider an electron coupled to the quantized radiation field and subject to a slowly varying electrostatic potential. We establish that over sufficiently long times radiation effects are negligible and the dressed electron is governed by an effective one-particle Hamiltonian. In the proof only a few generic properties of the full Pauli–Fierz Hamiltonian HPF enter. Most importantly, HPF must have an isolated ground state band for |p| < pc ≤ ∞ with p the total momentum and pc indicating that the ground state band may terminate. This structure demands a local approximation theorem, in the sense that the one-particle approximation holds until the semiclassical dynamics violates |p| < pc . Within this framework we prove an abstract Hilbert space theorem which uses no additional information on the Hamiltonian away from the band of interest. Our result is applicable to other time-dependent semiclassical problems. We discuss semiclassical distributions for the effective one-particle dynamics and show how they can be translated to the full dynamics by our results.
1. Introduction Electrons, protons, and other elementary charged particles move in essence along classical orbits provided the external potentials have a slow variation. E.g. in accelerators it is safe to compute the orbits by means of classical mechanics. As a somewhat crude physical picture one imagines that the electron dressed with its photon cloud at any given instant t is in its state of lowest energy consistent with the current total momentum p(t). During the time span δt the external forces change the momentum of the electron followed by a rapid adjustment of the photon cloud resulting in the new total momentum p(t + δt). In this picture two physical mechanisms are interlaced. Since the forces are weak, the acceleration is small and radiative losses can be ignored. The effective dynamics of the dressed electron is conservative within a good approximation. In addition the total momentum p(t) has a slow variation and can be regarded as a semiclassical variable with respect to the effective Hamiltonian of the ground state band (lowest energy shell). The goal of our paper is to establish the validity of the physical picture. To set the scene, let us introduce the quantum Hamiltonian under consideration. In fact, as will be explained below, our technique is fairly general and uses only 1
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
2
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
a few generic properties of the Hamiltonian. Still, it is useful to have a specific example in mind. We consider a free electron coupled to the quantized Maxwell field. The Hilbert space of states for the electron is Hel = L2 (R3 ) and its time 1 ∆. m is the mass of the electron evolution is governed by the Hamiltonian − 2m and we have set ~ = 1. For the photon field we introduce the Fock space Fb = Hf L∞ over the one-particle space L2 (R3 ) ⊗ C2 , i.e. Fb = n=0 Sn (L2 (R3 ) ⊗ C2 )⊗n and Sn the symmetrizer. Thus a state φ ∈ Fb is a sequence of vectors {φ(0) , φ(1) , . . .} P∞ (n) 2 k < ∞. On Fb with φ(n) ∈ Sn (L2 (R3 ) ⊗ C2 )⊗n such that kφk2 = n=0 kφ we define the two component Bose field with annihilation operators a(k, λ), where k ∈ R3 stands for the wave number and λ = 1, 2 for the helicity of the photon. The fields satisfy the canonical commutation relations [a(k, λ), a∗ (k 0 , λ0 )] = δ(k−k 0 )δλλ0 , [a(k, λ), a(k 0 , λ0 )] = 0 = [a∗ (k, λ), a∗ (k 0 , λ0 )]. The Hamiltonian of the free photon field is then given by X Z (1) d3 k ω(k)a∗ (k, λ)a(k, λ) Hf = λ=1,2
with dispersion relation ω(k) = |k|, the velocity of light c = 1. The electron and the photon field are minimally coupled through the transverse vector potential A(x). To assure transversality we introduce an orthonormal basis of the form e1 (k), e2 (k), k/|k|. Then X Z 1 eλ (k)(eik·x a(k, λ) + e−ik·x a∗ (k, λ)) . (2) d3 k p A(x) = (2π)−3/2 2ω(k) λ=1,2 A is an operator valued distribution. To make it an unbounded operator we smoothen over the form factor ρ as Z (3) Aρ (x) = d3 x0 ρ(x − x0 )A(x0 ) and R 3 assume that ρ is radial, smooth, of rapid decrease, and normalized as d x ρ(x) = 1. In the corresponding classical Hamiltonian eρ would be the rigid charge distribution. With all these preparations we can introduce the Pauli–Fierz operator of a free electron as 1 (−i∇ ⊗ 1 − eAρ (x))2 + 1 ⊗ Hf (4) H0 = 2m acting on H = Hel ⊗Hf . e is the charge of the electron. In (4) x denotes the position operator of the electron on L2 (R3 ). H0 is invariant under translations jointly of the electron and the photons. Thus the total momentum X Z (5) d3 k k a∗ (k, λ)a(k, λ) , p = pel ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ pf , pf = λ=1,2
is conserved, [H0 , p] = 0. This can be seen more directly by rewriting (4) in momentum representation as 1 (pel ⊗ 1 − eAρ (i∇pel ))2 + 1 ⊗ Hf (6) H0 = 2m
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
3
and then going to a representation in which p is diagonal. This is achieved through the unitary transformation T defined by ! n X (n) (n) ki , k1 , . . . , kn , p− (7) (T ψ) (p, k1 , . . . , kn ) = ψ i=1
where ψ (n) is the n-particle sector component of ψ in electron momentum representation. The transformed Hamiltonian T −1 H0 T , again denoted by H0 , takes the form 1 (p − pf − eAρ (0))2 + Hf . (8) H0 = 2m We decompose H and H0 on the spectrum of p, Z ⊕ Z ⊕ d3 p Hp , H0 = d3 p H0 (p) . H= R3
(9)
R3
The spaces Hp are isomorphic to Hf in a natural sense and will be identified in the following. H0 (p) is just H0 acting on Hf for a given value of p. Note that with a properly chosen phase H0 (p) is a real operator. Physically one expects to have a dressed electron state for given momentum p, at least if |p| < pc . In our semi-relativistic model states with |p| ≥ pc decay through Cherenkov radiation to lower momentum states. Thus provisionally we assume that there exists a pc such that for every p ∈ Λg = {p : |p| < pc } H0 (p) has a unique ground state with energy E(p), i.e. H0 (p)ψ0 (p) = E(p)ψ0 (p)
(10)
has a solution ψ0 (p) ∈ Hf which is unique up to scalar multiples and E(p) = inf spec(H0 (p)). We will discuss in Sec. 2.3 under which additional conditions on ρ our assumptions can be verified. E(p) R ⊕ is the ground state band energy. The corresponding projection is Pg = Λg d3 p P0 (p) where P0 (p) denotes the orthogonal projection onto the onedimensional subspace spanned by ψ0 (p). The states in Ran Pg are called dressed electron states. More explicitly (Z ) ⊕ 3 2 d p φ(p)ψ0 (p) ∈ H; φ ∈ L (Λg ) . (11) Ran Pg = Λg
On Ran Pg we have e
−iH0 t
Z ψ=
d3 p (e−iE(p)t φ(p))ψ0 (p) .
(12)
Λg
Thus, if initially in Ran Pg , the dressed electron propagates like a single quantum particle with dispersion relation E(p), which is generated through the interaction with the photons. In particular, it stays in the dressed electron subspace for all times.
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
4
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
As already remarked, the motion of an electron is modified through external electromagnetic potentials. In general, they have a slow variation on the scale set by the Compton wave length. Thus we add to H0 the external potential V (εx) (and possibly also an external vector potential Aex (εx)). ε is a small dimensionless parameter which controls the variation of V . The external forces break the translation invariance of H0 and the total momentum is no longer conserved. A state ψ initially in Ran Pg will no longer remain so under the time evolution generated by the full Hamiltonian H, which reflects that an accelerated charge loses energy through radiation. Since the external forces are weak of order ε, we can expect radiation losses to be negligible. More precisely, the acceleration is of order ε and by Larmor’s formula the energy radiated over the time span τ is ε2 τ . Thus the relevant time scale is of order ε−1 . On that time scale the radiation loss is of order ε, whereas the cumulative effect of the forces is of order 1 and the electron moves on the scale set by the potential V . If the initial ψ ∈ Ran Pg , the dressed electron should still be governed by an effective one-particle Hamiltonian, which is obtained from the dispersion relation E(p) through the Peierls substitution H1 = E(p − eAex (εx)) + V (εx) , and e−iHt ψ =
Z
d3 p(e−iH1 t φ(p))ψ0 (p) + O(ε)
(13)
(14)
Λg
for 0 ≤ t ≤ ε−1 T with some suitable macroscopic time T . We will establish (14) under some additional assumptions on H0 and for Aex = 0. In (14) it is crucial to assume that ψ ∈ Ran Pg . For a general ψ ∈ H one expects that, in essence on a time scale of order 1, ψ splits into outgoing radiation and a piece which is approximately in Ran Pg . This second piece is then governed by the approximation (14). To prove that this really happens is a challenging problem of scattering theory for free electrons and outside the scope of our present investigation. There are several difficulties with the picture proposed in (14). Firstly the Pauli– Fierz Hamiltonian is infrared divergent. For p 6= 0, the photon cloud has an infinite number of photons, though of finite total energy. The physical ground state at fixed p 6= 0 does not lie in Fock space. Even if we introduce a suitable infrared cut-off by assuming that ρˆ(k) → 0 as k → 0, with ρˆ the Fourier transform of ρ, E(p) is not separated from the rest of the spectrum of H0 (p). To overcome both difficulties we are forced to give the photons a small mass, which means to set ω(k) = (m2ph + k 2 )1/2 . In a separate study [19] we remove the gap condition using ideas as developed in [1]. As a second difficulty, which has been accounted for already, we observe that E(p) will cease to exist beyond a certain critical value pc , i.e. for |p| ≥ pc . This is most easily understood by considering the uncoupled Hamiltonian H0 (p) at e = 0. It has absolutely continuous spectrum and the only eigenvalue E(p) = 2m1 el p2 .
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
5
This eigenvalue is isolated and below the continuum edge for |p| < mel (mph small) and is embedded in the continuum for |p| > mel . For small coupling the embedded eigenvalue should dissolve and E(p) exists only for |p| < pc ∼ = mel . We could avoid the bounded extension of E(p) through a suitable modification of the boson dispersion ω(k) and/or the electron dispersion p2 /2m, cf. Sec. 2.3. However, the termination of bands is a fairly generic phenomenon. Thus, viewed in a more general setting, we have a classical Hamiltonian Hcl (q, p) = E(p) + V (q)
(15)
corresponding to (13) on phase space Γ = R3 × Λg . The solution flow does not exist globally in time and for given initial conditions (q, p) there is a first time T (including T = ∞) when the solution trajectory hits the boundary of Γ. This means we have to control the approximation (14) up to the time when substantial parts of the wave packet “leave” the allowed phase space. Beyond that time new physical phenomena appear not accounted for by (14). In spirit the approximation (14) is similar to the adiabatic theorem, which states that for a Hamiltonian slowly varying in time, transitions between the timedependent eigenspaces are small. In our problem the slow variation is in space and transitions from and to Ran Pg are small. We borrow some elements from the proof of the time-adiabatic theorem; cf. Sec. 4. It turns out that the validity of (14) relies only on a few rather general facts. Therefore we decided to prove (14) as an abstract operator problem. The basic assumptions are the decomposition (9) and a non-degenerate energy band of possibly finite extension separated by a gap from the rest of the spectrum. We mention three widely studied physical systems which possess this abstract mathematical structure, but are, at first sight, very different from the dressed electron. (i) For an electron moving in a periodic crystal potential, p becomes the quasimomentum and the energy band is one particular Bloch band. Bloch bands are discrete but may cross. The small parameter arises, as for Pauli–Fierz, through a, on the scale of the lattice spacing, slowly varying external potential. In [8] we studied the semiclassical motion in periodic potentials for Bloch bands that are isolated over the whole Brillouin zone. While we used a similar approach, the present paper is a substantial improvement in two respects. The approximation is local, no isolated bands have to be assumed, and we consistently avoid using any information on H(p) away from the band of interest. (ii) Electrons are lighter than nuclei by a factor of 2·103 –5·105, which is the starting point of the Born–Oppenheimer approximation for molecular dynamics. p is ~ the collection of nucleonic coordinates. H(R) ~ is the electron now replaced by R, Hamiltonian for fixed nuclei and the band structure arises from eigenvalues of ~ They may cross or dive into the continuum. If we include the kinetic H(R). energy of the nuclei, the small parameter becomes ε = (mel /mnucleus)1/2 and, ~ the Born–Oppenheimer approximation except for the interchange of p and R,
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
6
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
fits our framework. Since in the following only bounded potentials will be covered — the kinetic energy is p2 and plays the role of the potential — we postpone a discussion of the time-dependent Born–Oppenheimer approximation to a separate paper [18]. For an analysis from the point of view of wave packet dynamics we refer to [6]. (iii) The Dirac equation for a single particle has the electron and the positron band. One studies the motion of an electron, say, under slowly varying external potentials [2, 17]. As novel feature, the bands are doubly degenerate. This would also be the case if we include the electron spin in (8) as H=
1 (σ · (p − pf − eAρ ))2 + Hf , 2m
[7]. In the semiclassical limit the internal degrees of freedom (degeneracy) remain quantum mechanical and one has to approximate by matrix valued classical mechanics. Our paper is organized as follows. The abstract setting will be explained in Sec. 2. In this framework, almost by necessity, the theorems are stated as uniform convergence of certain unitary groups and of the corresponding time dependent semiclassical observables in the Heisenberg picture. The reader may worry, as we did, whether such convergence results imply the semiclassical approximation of quantities of physical interest, like position and momentum distributions. In fact, they do under very mild assumptions on the initial wave function, as discussed in Sec. 6. Our main theorems are stated in Sec. 2 with proofs given in Secs. 3 to 5. 2. General Setting and Main Results 2.1. General setting For better readability we denote “momentum space” by M := Rd , d ∈ N. Let Hf be any separable Hilbert space, although the notation should remind one of the Hilbert space for the Bose field in case of our main application. Let H0 be a self-adjoint operator on D(H0 ) ⊂ H = L2 (M ) ⊗ Hf that can be decomposed on M as Z ⊕ dp H0 (p) , (16) H0 = M
where {H0 (p), p ∈ M } is a family of self-adjoint operators with a common domain D0 ⊂ Hf . We assume that the map p 7→ H0 (p) is differentiable in the sense that for all p ∈ M and j = 1, . . . , d the limit H0 (p + hej ) − H0 (p) (H0 (p) − i)−1 h→0 h
(∂pj H0 (p))(H0 (p) − i)−1 := lim
exists in the norm of bounded operators on Hf . This defines, in particular, (∇p H0 )(p) on D0d .
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
7
For p in some compact and convex Λg ⊆ M with non-empty interior let H0 (p) have an isolated non-degenerate eigenvalue E(p), i.e. H0 (p)ψ0 (p) = E(p)ψ0 (p) with ψ0 (p) ∈ Hf and dist(E(p), σ(H0 (p)) \ E(p)) > 0. We assume that E(·) ∈ C ∞ (Λg , R). As before, P0 (p) denotes the rank-one projection onto ψ0 (p) and Pg is defined as the orthogonal projection on Ran Pg given by (11). The eigenfunctions ψ0 (p), p ∈ Λg , are defined only up to a p-dependent phase factor and the choice of phase is crucial when comparing the full dynamics and the effective one-particle dynamics. We assume that it is possible to choose this phase such that ψ0 (·) ∈ C 2 (Λg , Hf ) and, in order to avoid complications coming from geometric phases, Imhψ0 (p), ∇p ψ0 (p)iHf = 0. This choice is considered fixed from now on. On Λg we require H0 (·) to be twice continuously differentiable in the same sense as above, i.e. for all p ∈ Λg and j, k ∈ 1, . . . , d the limit (∂pj H0 )(p + hek ) − (∂pj H0 )(p) (H0 (p) − i)−1 h→0 h
(∂pk ∂pj H0 (p))(H0 (p) − i)−1 := lim
exists in the norm of bounded operators on Hf and depends continuously on p in the same topology. We remark that the last condition ensures the existence of a C 2 (Λg , Hf ) version of ψ0 (·). If, in addition, H0 (p) is real, i.e. commutes with complex conjugation, then ψ0 (p) can be chosen real-valued in that basis for each p and a real-valued version of ψ0 (·) ∈ C 2 (Λg , Hf ) exists, since Λg is convex and thus contractible. Consequently also Imhψ0 (p), ∇p ψ0 (p)iHf = 0 is satisfied. Hence the assumptions on ψ0 (·) follow from the assumptions on H0 (·) in the case of real H0 (p). R d ik·x ˆ V (k), where R Let nthe potential V : R → R be such that V (x) = dk e dk |k| |Vˆ (k)| < ∞ for all n ∈ N0 . This guarantees, in particular, that V and all its partial derivatives are in C ∞ (Rd ) and vanish at infinity. V ε := V (iε∇p ) is a bounded self-adjoint operator on L2 (M ) and the full Hamiltonian H = H0 + V ε ⊗ 1 H f
(17)
is self-adjoint on D(H0 ). We define the corresponding one-particle Hamiltonian on L2 (M ) by H1 = E(p) + V ε .
(18)
Note that E(p) is a priori only defined for p ∈ Λg . To make things simple, we continue E(p) to a smooth and compactly supported but otherwise arbitrary function on M . Since we will be interested only in the behavior for p ∈ Λg , we use this global function to define H1 . The corresponding unitary groups are denoted by U (t) = e−iHt and U1 (t) = e−iH1 t . Our goal is to show that, in a suitable sense, (U (t/ε) − U1 (t/ε))Pg = O(ε)
(19)
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
8
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
for macroscopic times t < T < ∞, where T depends only on V and the initial momenta. But before we can state the precise result, we have to make sense of H1 acting on Ran Pg . According to (11) we define the map U : RanPg → L2 (M ) U(φψ0 ) = φ ,
i.e. (Uψ)(p) = hψ0 (p), ψ(p)iHf .
Its adjoint U ∗ : L2 (M ) → Ran Pg is given by Z ⊕ ∗ dp 1lΛg (p)φ(p)ψ0 (p) , U φ=
(20)
(21)
where here and in the following 1lA denotes the characteristic function of a set A. Clearly U is an isometry and U ∗ U = 1 on Ran Pg . The effective dynamics cease to make sense, once the momentum of the particle leaves Λg . If that is not excluded by energy conservation, the comparison (19) can hold only up to some finite time, which can be determined from the classical dynamics generated by Hcl (x, p) = E(p) + V (x) on phase space Rd × M . Let Λi ⊂ M , the “set of initial momenta”, and Λm ⊂ M some “maximal set of allowed momenta”, both be compact. For Λ ⊂ M compact and δ ≥ 0 we let Λ + δ := p ∈ M : inf |p − k| ≤ δ k∈Λ
be the corresponding δ-enlarged set, which is again compact. With Φtp : Rd × M → M denoting the momentum component of the classical flow, we define for Λi + δ ⊂ Λm δ d Tm (Λi , Λm ) := sup {t : supp((1lΛi ◦ Φ−s p )(x, ·)) + δ ⊆ Λm ∀ s ∈ [0, t], x ∈ R } t≥0
as the maximal time for which the momentum of any (i.e. with any starting position) classical particle with initial momentum in Λi stays within a δ-margin inside of Λm . The following lemma shows that the classical bound on the momentum is respected also by the quantum dynamics in the limit ε → 0. Let Pi = 1lΛi (p) and Pm = 1lΛm (p). Lemma 2.1. Let Λi , Λm ⊂ M be both compact and Λi + δ ⊂ Λm for some δ > 0. δ (Λi , Λm ) there is a C < ∞ such that for all t ∈ [0, T ] For any T < ∞ with T ≤ Tm
(1 − Pm ) U1 t Pi ≤ Cε2 . (22)
2
ε L(L (M)) For the proof of Lemma 2.1 see Sec. 3.
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
9
2.2. Main results In the following we will always assume that Λi ⊂ Λg and we can therefore identify Pi with U ∗ Pi UPg to keep notation simple. I.e., Pi projects on “dressed electron states” with momenta in Λi . Theorem 2.2. Let Λi be compact with Λi + δ ⊂ Λg for some δ > 0. For any T < ∞ δ (Λi , Λg ) there is a C < ∞ such that for all t ∈ [0, T ] with T ≤ Tm
U t − U ∗ U1 t U Pi ≤ C ε. (23)
ε ε L(H) This means, in the case of our main application, that dressed electron states with initial momenta in Λi evolve according to the effective dynamics without radiation losses for times of order ε−1 as long as the momenta of the corresponding classical δ depends orbits stay inside Λg . Note, in particular, that the macroscopic time Tm only on Λi , but not on ε. The equivalence between the full dynamics and the effective one-particle dynamics on the isolated energy band extends to the level of semiclassical or macroscopic observables. We consider classical symbols a ∈ C ∞ (Rd × M ) such that for all multiindices α, β there exists Cα,β < ∞ with sup |∂xα ∂pβ a(x, p)| ≤ Cα,β . x,p
We use the notation of [3] and denote this set of symbols by S00 (1). For a ∈ S00 (1) Weyl quantization leads to an operator aW,ε ∈ L(L2 (M )) given by Z p+k (24) e−i(p−k)·x φ(k) , (aW,ε φ)(p) = (2π)−d dx dk a εx, 2 with operator norm that is bounded uniformly in ε (cf. Sec. 4 for details). For a ∈ S00 (1) let aε (t) = U (−t/ε) (aW,ε ⊗ 1) U (t/ε)
(25)
aε1 (t) = U1 (−t/ε) aW,ε U1 (t/ε) .
(26)
and
Theorem 2.3. Let Λi be compact with Λi + δ ⊂ Λg for some δ > 0 and a ∈ S00 (1) such that Z a(1) (ξ, p)| < ∞ , dξ sup |ξ| |ˆ p∈M
where b (1) denotes Fourier transformation in the first argument. Then for every δ (Λi , Λg ) there is a constant C < ∞ such that for all t ∈ [0, T ] T < ∞ with T ≤ Tm and ψ ∈ H |hPi ψ, (aε (t) − U ∗ aε1 (t)U) Pi ψi| = |hPi ψ, aε (t) Pi ψi − hφ, aε1 (t) φi| ≤ ε C kPi ψk2H . (27)
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
10
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
Thus one can compute expectations of semiclassical observables in the full system approximately by computing the expectations of the corresponding observable in the effective one-particle theory. The advantage is that powerful methods of semiclassical approximation like the Egorov theorem (cf. Proposition 3.4 in Sec. 3) can be applied to aε1 (t), but not to aε (t). A detailed discussions with important examples is postponed to Sec. 6. 2.3. The massive Nelson and Pauli Fierz model It is of interest to see whether our abstract assumptions are in fact satisfied for physically, at least semi-realistic models. The best studied case is the Nelson model [13], where the coupling is to the position of the particle and the Maxwell field is replaced by a scalar field. Switching immediately to the total momentum representation, cf. (8), the Nelson Hamiltonian reads Z 1 ρˆ(k) (a(k) + a∗ (−k)) , (28) HN (p) = (p − pf )2 + Hf + dk p 2 2ω(k) where instead of (1), (5), a(k), a∗ (k) is a one-component RBose field over Rd . Again, p is the total momentum and regarded as a parameter. If dk |ˆ ρ|2 (ω −3 +ω −1 ) < ∞, then HN (p) is bounded from below and self-adjoint with domain D(Hf ). ρˆ(k) can be made real through an appropriate canonical transformation a(k) → eiθ(k) a(k). With such a choice HN is a real operator. According to a result of Fr¨ohlich [5], if ω(k) = (m2ph + k 2 )1/2 , mph > 0, HN has √ an isolated, nondegenerate ground state band for |p| < pc with pc ≥ 3 − 1. If in (28) one replaces the electron dispersion by E0 (p) = (m2el + p2 )1/2 , mel > 0, still keeping ω(k) = (m2ph + k 2 )1/2 , mph > 0, then at zero coupling the ground state lies strictly below the continuum edge for all p, which means pc = ∞ for ρˆ = 0. As proved in [5] pc = ∞ persists to arbitrary coupling strength. A larger class of bosonic dispersion relations is studied in [16]. For the particular case ω(k) = ω0 > 0 and dimensions d = 1, 2 one has pc = ∞, whereas for d = 3 and small coupling indeed pc < ∞ [12]. 1 For the Pauli–Fierz model (8) with ω(k) = (k 2 + mph ) 2 , mph >√0, the existence of the ground state is proved as in [5] for |p| < pc with pc ≥ 3 − 1. For the uniqueness no general argument is available, in contrast to the Nelson model. One route is to estimate the overlap of any ground state with the Fock vacuum (we are grateful to V. Bach for this remark). Thereby uniqueness is ensured provided Z (29) dk |ˆ ρ(k)|2 ω(k)−1 (E(p − k) − E(p) + ω(k))−2 < 1 . 4E(p) e2 ∆(p) = inf{E(p − k) − E(p) − ω(k), k ∈ Rd } is the gap between E(p) and the continuum edge. Thus ∆(p) > 0 for |p| < pc by definition. The condition (29) can be made more explicit through suitable estimates on E(p). We conclude that all assumptions in Theorem 2.2 are satisfied provided mph > 0 with no further restrictions in the case of the Nelson model and the implicit restriction (29) on the coupling strength e in the case of the Pauli–Fierz model.
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
11
3. Preliminaries from Semiclassical Analysis Although Theorem 2.2 compares a full quantum evolution to an effective quantum evolution independently of any semiclassical behavior of H1 , we need to control the leaking through the boundary of Λg as expressed in Lemma 2.1. To prove Lemma 2.1 we use some tools from semiclassical analysis, which are introduced and applied to the one-particle Hamiltonian H1 in this section. Furthermore, in Sec. 6 we will consider semiclassical distributions based on the notions and results discussed here. Since E and V are both smooth bounded functions, we can apply standard results of semiclassics to the Hamiltonian H1 (p, iε∇p ) = E(p) + V (iε∇p ) acting on L2 (M ), where the roles of momentum and position are exchanged and the role of ~ is taken by ε. In the following we will simply ignore this difference and leave the necessary changes as compared to the standard case to the reader. Note, however, that the change in sign, i∇ instead of −i∇, is canceled by the fact that p0 = q and q 0 = −p is the canonical transformation interchanging q and p. We will consider classical symbols a ∈ S00 (1). As was stated in Sec. 2, Weyl quantization of functions in S00 (1) leads to bounded operators. The following result sharpens this statement. Proposition 3.1 (Calderon Vaillancourt). There is a C < ∞ and a finite n ∈ N such that for all a ∈ S00 (1) and ε ∈ [0, 1] kaW,ε kL(L2 (M)) ≤ C
sup |α|≤n,|β|≤n,(x,p)∈Rd×M
|∂xα ∂pβ a(x, p)| .
(30)
For a proof see, e.g., [3, Theorem 7.11]. The statement there is slightly different, but their proof implies our Proposition 3.1. Note, in particular, that the constants n and C in Proposition 3.1 depend on the dimension d of configuration space. The so called product rule, presented in the following Proposition 3.2, is at the basis of all semiclassical analysis we will apply. For a proof see [3, Proposition 7.7 and Theorem 7.9]. Proposition 3.2 (Product rule). Let a, b ∈ S00 (1). Then for all n ∈ N0 there is a dn < ∞ such that
!W,ε
n X
W,ε W,ε k
a b − ε c ≤ dn εn+1 , (31) k
2
k=0 L(L (M))
with k i ck (x, p) = 2
X |α|+|β|=k
(−1)|β| ((∂xβ ∂pα a)(∂pβ ∂xα b))(x, p) . |α|!|β|!
(32)
We state two simple facts that are immediate consequences of the product rule as
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
12
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
Corollary 3.3. Let a, b ∈ S00 (1). Then (i)
kaW,ε bW,ε − (ab)W,ε kL(L2 (M)) = O(ε) .
(ii) If, in addition, supp(a) ∩ supp(b) = ∅, then for any n ∈ N kaW,ε bW,ε kL(L2 (M)) = O(εn ) . Proof. (i) is just Proposition 3.2 for n = 0. (ii) holds since in this case ck = 0 in (31) for all k ∈ N0 . Here and in the following O(εn ) means that an expression, or its appropriate norm, is bounded by a constant times εn for sufficiently small ε. The crucial ingredient to our semiclassical analysis is the following first-order version of a Theorem going back to Egorov [4] (cf. also [15, Th´eor`eme IV-10], which is also a direct consequence of the product rule. Proposition 3.4 (Egorov’s Theorem). Let a ∈ S00 (1) and 0 ≤ T < ∞. There is a C < ∞ such that for all t ∈ [−T, T ]
U1 − t aW,ε U1 t − a ◦ Φt W,ε ≤ Cε2 .
2
ε ε L(L (M)) Proof. First note that for a ∈ S00 (1) we have that a ◦ Φt ∈ S00 (1) for all finite t, since the Hamiltonian vector field is smooth, uniformly bounded and all its partial derivatives are uniformly bounded. Moreover, a ◦ Φt and all its partial derivatives are each bounded uniformly for t ∈ [−T, T ]. Therefore k(a ◦ Φt )W,ε kL(L2 (M)) is bounded uniformly for t ∈ [−T, T ] by Proposition 3.1. Writing t t W,ε a U1 − (a ◦ Φt )W,ε U1 − ε ε Z t s d s = ds U1 − (a ◦ Φt−s )W,ε U1 , (33) ds ε ε 0 one is led to consider s s d t−s W,ε U1 − (a ◦ Φ ) U1 ds ε ε i W,ε s s t−s W,ε t−s W,ε [Hcl , (a ◦ Φ ) ] − Hcl , (a ◦ Φ ) , U1 = U1 − ε ε ε (34) W,ε . From the where {·, ·} denotes the Poisson bracket and we used that H1 = Hcl product rule one computes that for arbitrary a, b ∈ S00 (1)
i i W,ε W,ε [a , b ] = (aW,ε bW,ε − bW,ε aW,ε ) = {a, b}W,ε + O(ε2 ) , ε ε
(35)
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
13
which implies that (34) is O(ε2 ) for fixed t − s. However, one can easily convince oneself that this bound is uniform for t − s in any bounded interval, since the seminorm used in Proposition 3.1 is bounded uniformly for the c2 -terms appearing in a derivation of (35) using the product rule. To have a natural way for extending functions of x or p alone to functions on phase space, we introduce the projections πx : Rd × M → Rd and πp : Rd × M → M as πx (x, p) = x and πp (x, p) = p. We are now ready to prove Lemma 2.1. Proof of Lemma 2.1. In order to regularize 1lΛ i and 1lΛm we pick some fi ∈ C0∞ (M ) and fm ∈ C ∞ (M ) such that fi Λ = 1, fm M\Λ = 1 and supp(fi ◦ Φ−t p )∩ i
m
δ ]. Egorov’s theorem implies that there is a C < ∞ supp(fm ◦πp ) = ∅ for all t ∈ [0, Tm δ ] such that for t ∈ [0, Tm
2
U1 t (fi ◦ πp )W,ε U1 − t − (fi ◦ Φ−t )W,ε p
2 ≤ Cε .
ε ε L(L ) W,ε (fi ◦ Since, by construction, supp(fi ◦ Φ−t p ) ∩ supp(fm ◦ πp ) = ∅, we have (fm ◦ πp ) W,ε 2 W,ε ) = O(ε ) by Corollary 3.3. This and the fact that P = (f ◦ π ) P Φ−t i i p i and p W,ε implies (22). that (1 − Pm ) = (1 − Pm )(fm ◦ πp )
4. Convergence of the Unitary Groups δ (Λi , Λg ) We prove Theorem 2.2. Let Λi +δ ⊂ Λg . In the following T < ∞ with T ≤ Tm will be fixed once and for all and we will always assume that 0 ≤ t ≤ T . For reasons that will become clear during the proof we have to introduce further sets in momentum space. Let [ supp(1lΛi ◦ Φ−t Λm = p (x, ·)) t∈[0,T ],x∈Rd
be the subset in momentum space that is reached by the classical dynamics starting from Λi in our relevant time span. By construction we have that Λm + δ ⊆ Λg and we define Λm1 := Λm +δ/4, Λm2 := Λm +δ/2 and Λm3 := Λm +3δ/4. The respective projections will be denoted by Pm1 , Pm2 and Pm3 . The following lemma ensures that V ε maps wave functions supported in Λm1 (resp. in Λm2 , Λm3 ) to wave functions supported in Λm2 (resp. in Λm3 , Λg ) up to errors of arbitrary order in ε. We will use this result in the following implicitly many times. R Lemma 4.1. Let Vˆ ∈ L1 (Rd ) such that dk |k|n |Vˆ (k)| < ∞ for all n ∈ N. Then for each compact Λ ⊂ Λg and all m ∈ N and δ > 0 there is a Cδ,m < ∞ and a Cδ < ∞ such that (i)
k(V ε − 1lΛ+δ V ε )PΛ kH ≤ Cδ,m εm and, if Λ + δ ⊂ Λg ,
(ii)
k(V ε − PΛ+δ V ε )PΛ kH ≤ Cδ ε .
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
14
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
Proof. Let ψ ∈ Ran PΛ , i.e. ψ = φψ0 with φ ∈ L2 (M ) and supp φ ⊂ Λ. For (i) it suffices to consider the L2 (M ) part and calculate Z (V ε φ)(p) = dk Vˆ (k)φ(p − εk) Z
Z dk Vˆ (k)φ(p − εk) +
= |k|≤ε−1/2
dk Vˆ (k)φ(p − εk) .
(36)
|k|>ε−1/2
The first term in (36) is supported in Λ + δ for ε sufficiently small. For the second term note that Z Z dk Vˆ (k)φ(p − εk) = dk 0 ε−d Vˆ (k 0 /ε)φ(p − k 0 ) |k|>ε−1/2
|k0 |>ε1/2
amounts to convolution with the function 1l|k0 |>ε1/2 ε−d Vˆ (k 0 /ε) and therefore, by Young’s inequality, the L(L2 )-norm of the corresponding map is bounded by Z Z 0 −d ˆ 0 dk ε |V (k /ε)| = dk |k|−2m |k|2m |Vˆ (k)| ≤ Cm εm . |k0 |>ε1/2
|k|>ε−1/2
This shows (i). Part (ii) follows from the fact that the off diagonal part of V ε is of order ε, as expressed in Lemma 4.4. We turn to the proof of (23). Using Lemma 2.1 together with UU ∗ = Id on Ran Pm2 we get t t − U ∗ U1 U Pi U ε ε Z t ε t = −iU ds U (−s)(HU ∗ − U ∗ H1 )U1 (s)UPi ε 0 Z t ε t = −iU ds U (−s)(H − U ∗ H1 U)Pm2 U ∗ U1 (s)UPi + O(ε) . (37) ε 0 For the last equality note also that a factor of order O(ε2 ) in the otherwise uniformly bounded integrand leads to the integral being O(ε). We would be done by the same argument, if we could show that H − U ∗ H1 U acting on RanPm2 is O(ε2 ). However, the first order term does not vanish, as we will see, and we have to treat the integral more carefully. In order to separate the leading order term we write H − U ∗ H1 U = (H − Hdiag ) + (Hdiag − U ∗ H1 U) , where Hdiag = H0 + Pg V ε Pg + Pg⊥ V ε Pg⊥ and Pg⊥ := 1H − Pg .
(38)
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
15
We will treat the easy part first and show in Lemma 4.2 that the difference Hdiag − U ∗ H1 U vanishes sufficiently fast on Ran Pm2 . Lemma 4.2. For ε sufficiently small there is a C < ∞ such that k(Hdiag − U ∗ H1 U)Pm2 k ≤ Cε2 .
(39)
Proof. By definition we have that Pg⊥ Hdiag Pm2 = Pg⊥ U ∗ H1 UPm2 = 0. Hence it suffices to consider the difference projected onto Ran Pg . On Ran Pm2 we have Pg (Hdiag φψ0 )(p)
Z
= E(p)φ(p)ψ0 (p) + 1lΛg (p)
dk Vˆ (k)φ(p − εk) hψ0 (p), ψ0 (p − εk)iHf ψ0 (p)
and
Z
(U ∗ H1 Uφψ0 )(p) = E(p)φ(p)ψ0 (p) + 1lΛg (p)
dk Vˆ (k)φ(p − εk) ψ0 (p) .
Hence Pg (Hdiag − U ∗ H1 U)(φψ0 )(p) Z dk Vˆ (k)φ(p − εk) (hψ0 (p), ψ0 (p − εk)iHf − 1) ψ0 (p) . = 1lΛg (p)
(40)
We will show that there is a constant C such that |hψ0 (p), ψ0 (p − εk)iHf − 1| ≤ C|k|2 ε2
(41)
for all p ∈ Λg and k with p − εk ∈ Λg . Therefore Z k(Hdiag − U ∗ H1 U)φψ0 kH ≤ Cε2 dk |Vˆ (k)| |k|2 kφ(· − εk)ψ0 (·)kH Z dk |Vˆ (k)| |k|2
≤ Cε kφkL2 (M) 2
Z = Cε kφψ0 kH 2
dk |Vˆ (k)| |k|2 .
To see (41), note that for ψ0 (·) ∈ C 2 (Λg , Hf ) Taylor expansion yields 1 0 ψ0 (p − εk) = ψ0 (p) − εk · ∇p ψ0 (p) + ε2 k · (∇(2) p ψ0 )(p )k , 2 where ∇p ψ0 denotes the Hessian and 12 ε2 k · (∇p ψ0 )(p0 )k is the Lagrangian remainder. In view of Rehψ0 (p), ∇p ψ0 (p)iHf = 0, which follows from differentiating the identity hψ0 (p), ψ0 (p)iHf = 1, and Imhψ0 (p), ∇p ψ0 (p)iHf = 0, which holds by assumption, we obtain (2)
(2)
|hψ0 (p), ψ0 (p − εk)iHf − 1| ≤ C(p)|k|2 ε2 .
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
16
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
Here C(p) = 12 by continuity.
P i,j
|hψ0 (p0 ), ∂pi ∂pj ψ0 (p0 )i|, which is bounded uniformly for p ∈ Λg
With the help of Lemma 4.2 and (37), we have t t − U ∗ U1 U Pi U ε ε Z t ε t = −iU ds U (−s)(H − Hdiag )Pm2 U ∗ U1 (s)U Pi + O(ε) . ε 0
(42)
Since (H − Hdiag )Pm2 is of order ε and not of order ε2 , the last integral needs to be treated more carefully. Modulo technicalities the strategy is as follows. We isolate the first order term and show that H − Hdiag = iε[(∇V )ε · ∇p P0 , P0 ] + O(ε2 ). Then an operator A is constructed such that [(∇V )ε · ∇p P0 , P0 ] = [A, H] + O(ε), i.e. U (−s)[(∇V )ε · ∇p P0 , P0 ]U (s) is the time derivative of the bounded operator U (−s)AU (s) modulo terms of order ε. Then partial integration in (42) shows that not only the integrand but also the integral is of order ε. The strategy just described is clearly related to the proof of the time-adiabatic theorem (cf. [10] and for a recent overview on the extensive literature [1]). In the time-adiabatic case, however, one has H(t) − Hdiag (t) = iε[P˙ (t), P (t)] without error term and also [P˙ (t), P (t)] = [H(t), A(t)] can be solved exactly. Lemma 4.3. P0 (·) ∈ C 2 (Λg , L(Hf )) and for p ∈ Λg one has P0 (p)(∇p P0 )(p)P0 (p) = Q0 (p)(∇p P0 )(p)Q0 (p) = 0 ,
(43)
where Q0 (p) = 1Hf − P0 (p). Proof. P0 (·) ∈ C 2 (Λg , L(Hf )) follows from the standard argument involving the Riesz formula. For p ∈ Λg one can express P0 (p) as a contour integral , I 1 dλ Rλ (H0 (p)) , P0 (p) = − 2πi c(p) where c(p) is a smooth curve in the complex plane circling the isolated eigenvalue E(p) only and Rλ (H0 (p)) = (H0 (p)−λ)−1 . It is easy to see that one can differentiate twice under the integral given our assumptions on H0 (·). (43) follows from ∇p P0 (p) = ∇p (P02 (p)) = P0 (p)(∇p P0 )(p) + (∇p P0 )(p)P0 (p) . Lemma 4.4. (H − Hdiag )Pm2 = −εQg (∇p Pg )Pm3 · F ε Pm2 + O(ε2 ) , R⊕ R⊕ where (∇p Pg ) = Λg dp ∇p P0 (p), Qg = Λg dp Q0 (p) and Z ε (F ψ)(p) := −i dk k Vˆ (k)ψ(p − εk) .
(44)
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
17
Proof. Using Lemma 4.1(i) we obtain (H − Hdiag )Pm2 ψ = Pg⊥ V ε Pm2 ψ Z Z ⊕ dp Q0 (p) dk Vˆ (k)P0 (p − εk)(Pm2 ψ)(p − εk) + O(ε2 ) . = Λm3
Since P0 : Λg → L(Hf ) is twice continuously differentiable, we have that 0 P0 (p − εk) = P0 (p) − εk · (∇p P0 )(p) + ε2 k · (∇(2) p P0 )(p (p, εk)) · k ,
(45)
where the last term is again the Lagrangian remainder. Hence, for p ∈ Λg , Z dk Vˆ (k)P0 (p − εk)(Pm2 ψ)(p − εk) Z dk Vˆ (k)(P0 (p) − εk · (∇p P0 )(p))(Pm2 ψ)(p − εk)
=
Z +ε Since
2
0 dk Vˆ (k) k · (∇(2) p P0 )(p (p, εk)) · k (Pm2 ψ)(p − εk) .
Z
(2) 0 ˆ
1lΛm3 (·) dk V (k) k · (∇p P0 )(p (·, εk)) · k (Pm2 ψ)(· − εk)
Z ≤
(46) (47)
(48)
H
0 dk Vˆ (k) k1lΛm3 (·) k · (∇(2) p P0 )(p (·, εk)) · k (Pm2 ψ)(· − εk) kH
(49)
Z ≤ sup
p∈Λm2
k(∇(2) p P0 )(p)k
dk |Vˆ (k)| |k|2 k1lΛm3 (·) (Pm2 ψ)(· − εk)kH
Z
≤ C kψkH
dk |Vˆ (k)|k 2 ,
(47) is O(ε2 ) in L(Hf ) and multiplying (46) with Q0 (p) from the left establishes (44). Including Lemma 4.4 we are left with t t ∗ − U U1 U Pi U ε ε Z t ε t = iεU ds U (−s)Qg (∇p Pg )Pm3 · F ε Pm2 U ∗ U1 (s)UPi + O(ε) . ε 0 To exploit the time averaging we write, as explained before, Qg (∇p Pg )Pg as a time derivative, at least in approximation. Let B(p) := RE(p) (H0 (p))Q0 (p)(∇p P0 (p))P0 (p) .
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
18
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
Note that RE(p) (H0 (p))Q0 (p) := (H0 (p)−E(p))−1 Q0 (p) is bounded since E(p) is an isolated eigenvalue for all p ∈ Λg and Q0 (p) projects on the orthogonal complement of the corresponding eigenvector. Lemma 4.5. Qg (∇p Pg )Pm3 = [H0 , B]Pm3 = [H, B]Pm3 + O(ε)
(50) (51)
and [H, F ε ]Pm2 = O(ε)
(52)
in L(H). Proof. (50) follows from direct computation: H0 (p)B(p) − B(p)H0 (p) = (H0 (p) − E(p))RE(p) (H0 (p))Q0 (p)(∇p P0 (p))P0 (p) = Q0 (p)(∇p P0 )(p)P0 (p) . For (51) we need to show that [V ε , B]Pm3 = O(ε): [V ε , B]Pm3 = [V ε , RE (H0 )Qg (∇p Pg )Pg ]Pm3 . However, P0 (·), ∇p P0 (·) and RE(·) (H0 (·))Q0 (·) are all in C 1 (Λg , L(Hf )) and thus each of them has a commutator with V ε which is of order ε (cf. proof of Lemma 4.4). Thus we showed (51). For (52) first observe that [F ε , V ε ] = 0. [H0 , F ε ] = O(ε) follows again from smoothness of H0 (p) as a function of p. But since H0 is not bounded we shortly explain the argument. Using (as always) Lemma 4.1(i) we observe that ([H0 , F ε ]Pm3 ψ)(p) = 1lΛg (p)([H0 , F ε ]Pm3 ψ)(p) + O(ε) Z = −i1lΛg (p) dk Vˆ (k) k (H0 (p) − H0 (p − εk))(Pm3 ψ)(p − εk) + O(ε) Z = −iε1lΛg (p)
dk Vˆ (k) k k · (∇p H0 )(p0 (k))(Pm3 ψ)(p − εk) + O(ε)
(53)
where the gradient is evaluated at the appropriate point p0 (k). By assumption we have that (∇p H0 )(p) is bounded uniformly for p ∈ Λg in the graph norm, which is equivalent to the H-norm on span{ψ0 (p), p ∈ Λg }. Thus the above expression is O(ε) as ε → 0 (cf. estimate (48)). Let A = B · Pm3 F ε . Then Lemma 4.5 yields Qg (∇p Pg ) · Pm3 F ε Pm2 = [A, H]Pm2 + O(ε)
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
19
in L(H), where [Pm3 F ε , H]P2 = O(ε) follows immediately from (52). Let A(t) = U (−t)AU (t), then t t − U ∗ U1 ( )U)Pi U ε ε Z t ε t = iεU ds U (−s)[A, H]U (s)U (−s)Pm2 U ∗ U1 (s)UPi + O(ε) ε 0 Z t ε d t A(s) U (−s)Pm2 U ∗ U1 (s)U Pi + O(ε) ds = −εU ε ds 0 t t [A(s)U (−s)Pm2 U ∗ U1 (s)U]0ε Pi + O(ε) = −εU ε Z t ε t d ds A(s) (U (−s)Pm2 U ∗ U1 (s)U)Pi + εU ε ds 0 Z t ε t = iεU ds A(s)U (−s)(HPm2 U ∗ − Pm2 U ∗ H1 )U1 (s)UPi + O(ε) ε 0 Z t ε t ds A(s)U (−s)(H − U ∗ H1 U)Pm1 U ∗ U1 (s)UPi + O(ε) . = iεU ε 0 For the last equality we used again Lemma 2.1 and the fact that Lemma 4.1(i) guarantees Pm2 U ∗ H1 UPm1 = U ∗ H1 UPm1 + O(ε2 ). Finally also the last integral is O(ε), since we showed already that (H − U ∗ H1 U)Pm1 = O(ε) and the proof of Theorem 2.2 is completed. 5. Convergence of the Macroscopic Observables In this section we prove Theorem 2.3. We start by showing Lemma 5.1. Let a ∈ S00 (1) such that Z a(1) (ξ, p)| < ∞ dξ sup |ξ| |ˆ p∈M
and γ > 0. Then there is a constant C < ∞ such that k(aW,ε ⊗ 1 − U ∗ aW,ε U) Pg−γ k ≤ C ε ,
(54)
where Pg−γ projects on dressed electron states supported in Λg − γ := {p ∈ Λg : inf k∈M\Λg |k − p| ≥ γ}. Proof. For φ in a dense subset of L2 (Λg − γ) and p ∈ Λg we have ((aW,ε ⊗ 1)φψ0 )(p) Z p+k e−i(p−k)·x φ(k)ψ0 (k) dk dx a εx, = (2π)−d 2
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
20
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
ε ˜ ik·˜ ˜ ˜ ψ0 (p + εk) ˜ ˜ = (2π) dk d˜ xa x ˜, p + k e x φ(p + εk) 2 Z ε˜ −d (1) ˜ ψ0 (p + εk) ˜ ˜ ˜ dk a ˆ − k, p + k φ(p + εk) = (2π) 2 Z ˜ ψ0 (p) ˜ p + ε k˜ φ(p + εk) dk˜ a ˆ(1) − k, = (2π)−d 2 Z ˜ k˜ · (∇p ψ0 )(f (p, εk)) ˜ ˜ p + ε k˜ φ(p + εk) dk˜ a ˆ(1) − k, + ε (2π)−d 2 −d
Z
= (U ∗ aW,ε U φψ0 )(p) + Rε .
(55)
In the previous computation we substituted x˜ = εx and k˜ = (k − p)/ε. In the second to last equality we used Taylor expansion of ψ0 and the mean value theorem ˜ such that the equality holds. guarantees the existence of a point f (p, εk) From (55) we conclude that k(1lΛg (·) ⊗ 1) (aW,ε ⊗ 1 − U ∗ aW,ε U)Pg−γ k ≤ kRε k .
(56)
Since k(1 − 1lΛg (·) ⊗ 1) (aW,ε ⊗ 1 − U ∗ aW,ε U)Pg−γ k = k(1 − 1lΛg (·) ⊗ 1) (aW,ε ⊗ 1)(1lΛg −γ (·) ⊗ 1)Pg−γ k = O(εn ) for arbitrary n by Corollary 3.3 (ii), Lemma 5.1 follows by showing that Rε is of order ε:
Z
(1) ε˜ ε −d ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜
ˆ dk a − k, · + k φ(· + εk) k · (∇p ψ0 )(f (·, εk)) kR k ≤ ε(2π)
2 H
Z
(1) ε˜ ˜ −d ˜ ˜ ˜
≤ ε(2π) sup k(∇p ψ0 )(p)kHf dk a − k, · + k |k| φ(· + εk) ˆ
2 2 p∈M L (M) Z ˜ |ˆ ˜ p)| ≤ εC kφkL2 (M) a(1) (k, dk˜ sup |k| p∈M
= εC˜ kφψ0 kH . Lemma 5.1 together with Theorem 2.2 and Lemma 2.1 immediately implies Theorem 2.3: |hPi ψ, (aε (t) − U ∗ aε1 (t) U)Pi ψi| =
|hU (t/ε)Pi ψ, (aW,ε ⊗ 1)U (t/ε)Pi ψi − hU1 (t/ε) UPi ψ, aW,ε U1 (t/ε) UPi ψi|
Thm 2.2
=
|hU (t/ε)Pi ψ, (aW,ε ⊗ 1)U (t/ε)Pi ψi − hU (t/ε)Pi ψ, U ∗ aW,ε U U (t/ε)Pi ψi| + O(ε)kPi ψk2
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons Lem 2.1 & Thm 2.2
=
21
|hPm U (t/ε)Pi ψ, (aW,ε ⊗ 1 − U ∗ aW,ε U)Pm U (t/ε)Pi ψi| + O(ε)kPi ψk2
Lem 5.1
=
O(ε)kPi ψk2 ,
where Pm was defined in the previous section and satisfies Pm = Pg−δ Pm .
6. Semiclassical Distributions Theorem 2.2 establishes that, restricted to the ground state band, the full unitary group U (t) and the approximate one-particle unitary U1 (t) are uniformly close to each other and Theorem 2.3 lifts this assertion to semiclassical observables. Experimentally measured are empirical statistics of suitable observables, like position and momentum, and we still have the task to investigate in what sense they are approximated through the time evolution U1 (t) for ε 1. For small ε, H1 itself is a semiclassical Hamiltonian, which means that empirical distributions can be determined through the classical flow Φt generated by H1 . Somewhat crudely the scheme is as follows: one choses an initial wave function φε , which may or may not depend on ε, such that for small ε it determines the measure ρcl (dx dp) on phase space. We evolve φε as φεt = e−iH1 t/ε φε and ρcl (dx dp, t) = (ρcl ◦ Φ−t )(dx dp). Then the empirical distributions computed from φεt agree with those of ρcl (t) up to errors of order ε, i.e. quantum distributions are well approximated by their classical counterpart. In our context the distributions of physical interest are really determined through ψtε = U (t/ε)ψ ε with ψ ε = φε ψ0 and not through U1 (t/ε)φε . Theorem 2.3 asserts that they are still well approximated through the semiclassical evolution corresponding to H1 . There are various “schools” which differ in what initial ψ’s are regarded as physically natural. (i) wave packet dynamics. The initial wave function is well localized in macroscopic position and momentum, i.e. ρcl (dx dp) = δ(x − x0 )δ(p − p0 ) dx dp. Then the wave packet follows the classical orbit , which only reflects that ρcl (dxdp, t) = δ(x − xt )δ(p − pt ) dx dp. (ii) microscopic wave function independent of ε. On the macrscopic scale the position is localized, but there is momentum spread. Therefore ρcl (dx dp) = 2 ˆ dx dp. Such a choice is appropriate immediately after a scattering δ(x)|φ(p)| event. Then φ is still localized at the scatterer but has considerable momentum spread. (iii) WKB. The wave function is taken to be build up from local plane waves, which means it has the form φε (x) = εd/2 f (εx)eiS(εx)/ε on the microscopic scale. φε is spread over macroscopic distance, but at any given point it has a sharp momentum. φε yields the phase space measure ρcl (dx dp) = |f (x)|2 δ(p − ∇S(x)) dx dp.
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
22
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
A general discussion of semiclassical distributions for evolutions of the type U1 , including the three mentioned examples, can be found in [11]. However, since the approximation from U (t/ε) to U1 (t/ε), covered by Theorems 2.2 and 2.3, holds uniform on Pg H, we would like to add uniform results also for the semiclassical analysis of U1 . This shows that the rate at which the distributions become classical is independent of the microscopic details of the initial wave function. On the other hand, the rate does depend on the type of scaling that is used. The results from the following subsections can be immediately translated to the language of Wigner measures. For ψ ∈ L2 (Rd ) ⊗ Hf let the reduced Wigner distribution be defined by Z ε (ψ)(dx dp, t) = dξ ε−d hψˆx∗0 (x/ε − ξ/2, t), ψˆx0 (x/ε + ξ/2, t)iHf eip·ξ dx dp , Wrd where here b stands for Fourier transformation in the first argument, i.e. for F ⊗ 1. Then the results translate into ε ε (ψ)(dx dp, t) = ρcl (dx dp, t) := lim Wrd (ψ)(t = 0) ◦ Φ−t (dx dp) lim Wrd ε→0
ε→0
weakly as measures. But, in addition, we get that the previous limit holds uniformly in ψ if evaluated pointwise on test functions. 6.1. Wave packets following a classical trajectory The conceptually simplest way for a quantum particle to behave classically is to have a well localized wave function that follows a classical trajectory. Hence we consider initial wave functions with sharply peaked momentum and, at the same time, sharply peaked macroscopic position. Let the initial wave function be √ φx0 ,p0 (x) = εd/4 eix·p0 φ( ε(x − x0 /ε)) for some φ ∈ L2 (Rd ), i.e., a wave function that is peaked on the macroscopic scale and centered at x0 , but spread out on the microscopic scale. Its Fourier transform is given by x ·(p−p ) −d/4 −i 0 ε 0 ˆ p − p0 ˆ √ , e φ φx0 ,p0 (p) = ε ε which becomes sharply peaked at p0 for ε small. There is no difficulty to include also asymmetric scaling with weights ε1−α and εα , 0 < α < 1, and the choice α = 1/2 was made to simplify presentation. Under the time evolution generated by H1 = E(−i∇x ) + V (εx) it moves along the corresponding classical trajectory starting at (x0 , p0 ) following the classical flow Φt generated by Hcl = E(p) + V (x) .
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
23
To be consistent with the previous chapters, we continue to work in momentum representation. Proposition 6.1. Let a ∈ S00 (1) and T < ∞. Then there is a C < ∞ such that ˆ |p|φˆ ∈ L1 (Rd ) and t ∈ [0, T ] for φ ∈ L2 (Rd ) with φ, |x|φ, φ, | hφˆx ,p , aε (t) φˆx ,p i − (a ◦ Φt )(x0 , p0 ) | 0
0
1
0
0
√
ˆ L1 + k|x|φkL1 kφk ˆ L1 ) . ≤ C ε (kφkL1 k|p|φk
(57)
Using Theorem 2.3, this translates immediately to the full dynamics. Corollary 6.2. Let the assumptions of Theorem 2.3 be satisfied. Then there is a ˆ |p|φˆ ∈ L1 (Rd ) and C < ∞ such that for ψx0 ,p0 = φx0 ,p0 ψ0 ∈ Ran Pi with φ, |x|φ, φ, t ∈ [0, T ] | hψx0 ,p0 , aε (t) ψx0 ,p0 i − (a ◦ Φt )(x0 , p0 ) | √ ˆ L1 + k|x|φkL1 kφk ˆ L1 + kφk2 2 ) . ≤ C ε (kφkL1 k|p|φk L Hence, when initially, on the macroscopic scale, position and momentum are both sharply defined, the wave packet follows the classical orbit without spreading even for macroscopic times. Such a situation occurs for example in particle accelerators, where one can indeed calculate the particle trajectories based solely on classical dynamics in good approximation. Proof of Proposition 6.1. Referring to Egorov’s theorem we have to compute hφˆx ,p , (a ◦ Φt )W,ε φˆx ,p i . 0
One can replace (a ◦ Φ ) by
t W,ε
0
0
0
by the so called standard quantization of a ◦ Φt defined
ˆ := (2π)−d/2 ((a ◦ Φt )S,ε φ)(p)
Z
dx (a ◦ Φt )(εx, p) e−ip·x φ(x)
(58)
where the error is of order ε uniformly in t ∈ [0, T ] (cf. [3, Chap. 7]). For the standard quantization the result becomes a simple calculation: hφˆx0 ,p0 , (a ◦ Φt )S,ε φˆx0 ,p0 i Z x ·(p−p ) p − p0 −d/2 i 0 ε 0 ˆ∗ √ (a ◦ Φt )(εx, p) e−ip·x eix·p0 φ dx dp e = (2π) ε √ x0 ×φ ε x− ε Z √ p (a ◦ Φt )(εx + x0 , p + p0 ) e−ip·x φ( ε(x)) = (2π)−d/2 dx dp φˆ∗ √ ε Z √ √ p)(a ◦ Φt )( ε¯ x + x0 , ε¯ p + p0 ) e−i¯p·¯x φ(¯ x) x d¯ p φˆ∗ (¯ = (2π)−d/2 d¯ = (a ◦ Φt )(x0 , p0 ) + R ,
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
24
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
where |R| ≤
√ ˆ L1 k∇p (a ◦ Φt )k∞ + k|x|φkL1 kφk ˆ L1 k∇x (a ◦ Φt )k∞ ) . ε(kφkL1 k|p|φk
The last inequality follows from a Taylor expansion of a ◦ Φt around (x0 , p0 ). 6.2. Initial wave function with momentum spread Generally wave functions are not of the special form described in the previous subsection. Typically they arise from microscopic interactions and thus “live” on the microscopic scale and do not depend on ε. But if the shape of the initial wave function does not depend on ε it will effectively look like a delta function on the macroscopic scale at t = 0. More precisely, let φ ∈ L2 (Rd ), then the scaled position distribution is ε−d |φ(x/ε)|2 which converges to δ(x) as a measure. However, the 2 ˆ , since in the quotient x/t the ε’s scaled momentum distribution is still |φ(p)| cancel and thus the initially peaked wave function will spread if evolved to times of order ε−1 . More generally we consider as initial wave function φx0 (x) = φ(x − x0 /ε) , i.e. we move φ to the macroscopic initial position x0 . Then it is natural to choose ρcl (dx dp) = δ(x − x0 )|φˆx0 (p)|2 dx dp as the corresponding classical phase space distribution at t = 0 and evolve it according to the classical flow to ρcl (dx dp, t) = ρ ◦ Φ−t (dx dp) . Let us now, as the simplest example, compare the quantum mechanical position distribution ρε (dx, t) = ε−d |φt (x/ε)|2 dx , with the classical one,
φt = e−iH1 t/ε φx0 ,
Z ρxcl (dx, t)
=
ρcl (dx dp, t) ,
in the limit ε → 0. As a first step we calculate, with f ∈ C0∞ a test function, Z ρε (dx, t) f (x) = hφεt , f φεt i = hφx0 , f (xε (t)) φx0 i = hφˆx0 , (f ◦ Φtx )W,ε φˆx0 i + O(ε2 ) .
(59)
For the last equality we used Egorov’s Theorem. To proceed we need to know how the Weyl quantization of a time evolved classical observable acts on microscopic wave functions. The following proposition follows from a calculation analogous to the one for Proposition 6.1.
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
25
Proposition 6.3. Let a ∈ S00 (1). Then for each T < ∞ there is a C < ∞ such that for φ ∈ L2 (Rd ) with |x|φ, φˆ ∈ L1 (Rd ) and t ∈ [0, T ] Z 2 t ˆ ˆ L1 . (60) hφˆx0 , aε (t) φˆx0 i − dp |φx0 (p)| (a ◦ Φ )(x0 , p) ≤ C ε k|x|φkL1 kφk 1 Thus (59) becomes Z hφˆx0 , (f ◦ Φtx )W,ε φˆx0 i =
dp |φˆx0 (p)|2 (f ◦ Φtx )(x0 , p) + O(ε) .
(61)
However, the right hand side of (61) is exactly what we were aiming for: Z Z 2 t ˆ dp |φx0 (p)| (f ◦ Φx )(x0 , p) = ρcl (dx dp, 0)(f ◦ Φtx )(x, p) Z ρcl (dx dp, t)f (x)
= Z =
ρxcl (dx, t)f (x) .
In summary, one obtains that lim ρε (dx, t) = ρxcl (dx, t)
ε→0
(62)
weakly as measures. Note that this means that the position distribution of the quantum particle converges to the classical one, although the wave function is not following the classical orbit, but spreading. Such a situation occurs for example in a scattering experiment. After the quantum particle is scattered off the target its wave function usually has a large momentum spread and thus it also spreads in position space. However, during the process of detection it is subject to relatively weak potentials and can be treated like a classical particle, at least on the level of statistics. For general observables a ∈ S00 (1) Proposition 6.3 yields Z ε ˆ ˆ (63) hφx0 , a1 (t) φx0 i = ρcl (dx dp, t)a(x, p) + O(ε) . Again, Theorem 2.3 allows us to translate this result to the full quantum dynamics. Corollary 6.4. Let the assumptions of Theorem 2.3 be satisfied. Then there is a C < ∞ such that for ψx0 = φx0 ψ0 ∈ Ran Pi with |x|φ, φˆ ∈ L1 (Rd ) and t ∈ [0, T ] Z ˆ L1 ) . hψx0 , aε (t) ψx0 i − ρcl (dx dp, t)a(x, p) < Cε (kφk2 2 + k|x|φkL1 kφk L
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
26
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
6.3. Initial wave function of WKB form In the previous case of an initially localized wave function the different momentum components travel at different velocities and therefore such a wave function spreads on the macroscopic scale. After some time one expects the wave function to have locally well defined momentum as long as no interference occurs, i.e. it should be of WKB type. On the microscopic scale a WKB wave function has the form φ(x) = εd/2 f (εx)ei
S(εx) ε
,
with f and S real valued. Hence it locally looks like a plane wave with momentum ∇S(εx) and amplitude f (εx). Time-dependent WKB approximation is concerned with showing that the time evolution of such a wave function is in first order given by (e−iH1 t/ε φ)(x) ≈ ft (εx)ei
St (εx) ε
,
where St is the solution of the classical Hamilton–Jacobi equation with initial condition S and ft is the solution of the classical continuity equation ∂t f + div ∇St = 0 . The corresponding classical phase space distribution is therefore ρcl (dx dp) = f 2 (x)δ(p − ∇S(x)) dx dp .
(64)
The main drawback of the WKB approximation is that it works only as long as no caustics are reached, or, put differently, as long as no interference between different parts of the WKB wave function happens. However, if we focus again on distributions of semiclassical observables on phase space no difficulty arises, only ρcl (t) is no longer of the particular form (64). Proposition 6.5. Let f ∈ C ∞ (Rd ) ∩ L1 (Rd ), S ∈ C ∞ (Rd ) and φ(x) = εd/2 f (εx)ei
S(εx) ε
be normalized in L2 (Rd ). Let a ∈ C0∞ (Rd × Rd ) and T < ∞. Then there is a C < ∞ such that for all t ∈ [0, T ] Z √ ˆ − ρcl (dx dp, t)a(x, p) ≤ C ε , ˆ aε (t)φi hφ, (65) 1 where ρcl (dx dp, t) = (ρcl ◦ Φ−t )(dx dp) and ρcl (dx dp) was defined in (64). As in the preceding cases we can again translate Proposition 6.5 to the full dynamics using Theorem 2.3, but we omit the corresponding statement this time. Proof. We apply Egorov and switch to standard quantization: ˆ = hφ, ˆ (a ◦ Φt )W,ε φi ˆ + O(ε) = hφ, ˆ (a ◦ Φt )S,ε φi ˆ + O(ε) . ˆ aε (t)φi hφ, 1
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
00107
Semiclassical Motion of Dressed Electrons
27
We calculate for a ∈ C0∞ Z y \ −d d/2 S,ε ˆ (a φ ) = (2π) ε dx dp a(εx, p)f (εx)e−ip·(x−y/ε) eiS(εx)/ε ε Z −d −d/2 = (2π) ε dx dp a(x, p)f (x)ei(S(x)−p·(x−y))/ε = (2π)−d ε−d/2
Z dz dp a(z + y, p)f (z + y)ei(S(z+y)−p·z)/ε .
Stationary phase method (cf. [9, Theorem 7.7.7] with k = n + 1) yields that Z dz dp a(z + y, p)f (z + y)ei(S(z+y)−p·z)/ε i 1 − (2πε)d a(y, ∇S(y))f (y)e ε S(y) ≤ C εd+ 2 , where the constant is uniform in y and depends on a via a sum of sup-norms of finite many partial derivatives. Hence √ i y \ t S,ε ˆ = εd/2 (a ◦ Φt )(y, ∇S(y))f (y)e ε S(y) + εd/2 O( ε) ((a ◦ Φ ) φ) ε and
Z ˆ = ˆ (a ◦ Φt )S,ε φi hφ,
√ dy(a ◦ Φt )(y, ∇S(y))f 2 (y) + O( ε) ,
where we used that f ∈ L1 (Rd ). References [1] J. E. Avron and A. Elgart, “Adiabatic theorems without a gap condition”, Commun. Math. Phys. 203 (1999) 445–463. [2] J. Bolte and S. Keppeler, “A semiclassical approach to the Dirac equation”, Ann. Phys. 274 (1999) 125–162. [3] M. Dimassi and J. Sj¨ ostrand, Spectral Asymptotics in the Semi-Classical Limit, London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series 268, Cambridge University Press, 1999. [4] Y. V. Egorov, “On canonical transformations of pseudodifferential operators”, Uspehi Math. Nauk 25 (1969) 235–236. [5] J. Fr¨ ohlich, “Existence of dressed one electron states in a class of persistent models”, Fortschritte der Physik 22 (1974) 159–198. [6] G. A. Hagedorn, “A time dependent Born-Oppenheimer approximation”, Commun. Math. Phys. 77 (1980) 1–19. [7] F. Hiroshima and H. Spohn, “Ground state degeneracy for the Pauli–Fierz operator with spin”, in preparation. [8] F. H¨ overmann, H. Spohn and S. Teufel, “Semiclassical limit for the Schr¨ odinger equation with a short scale periodic potential”, Commun. Math. Phys. 215 (2001) 609–629. [9] L. H¨ ormander, The Analysis of Linear Partial Differential Operators I, Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften 256, Springer, 1983.
December 27, 2001 14:41 WSPC/148-RMP
28
00107
S. Teufel & H. Spohn
[10] T. Kato, “On the adiabatic theorem of quantum mechanics”, Phys. Soc. Japan 5 (1958) 435–439. [11] P. L. Lions and T. Paul, “Sur les mesures de Wigner”, Rev. Math. Iberoamericana 9 (1993). [12] R. Minlos, “Lower branch of the spectrum of a fermion interacting with a bosonic gas (polaron)”, Theor. Math. Phys. 92 (1993) 869–877. [13] E. Nelson, “Interaction of nonrelativistic particles with a quantized scalar field”, J. Math. Phys. 5 (1964) 1190–1197. [14] M. Reed and B. Simon, Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics 1, Functional Analysis, Academic Press, San Diego, 1972. [15] D. Robert, Autour de l’Approximation Semi-Classique, Progress in Mathematics, Volume 68, Birkh¨ auser 1987. [16] H. Spohn, “The polaron at large total momentum”, J. Phys. A21 (1987) 1199–1211. [17] H. Spohn, “Semiclassical limit of the Dirac equation and spin precession”, Ann. Phys. 282 (2000) 420–431. [18] H. Spohn and S. Teufel, “Adiabatic decoupling and the time-dependent BornOppenheimer theory”, to appear in Commun. Math. Phys. (2001). [19] S. Teufel, “Adiabatic decoupling for perturbations of fibered Hamiltonians”, in preparation.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 1 (2002) 29–85 c World Scientific Publishing Company
SKYRMIONS, FULLERENES AND RATIONAL MAPS
RICHARD A. BATTYE Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics Centre for Mathematical Sciences, University of Cambridge Wilberforce Road, Cambridge CB3 0WA, U.K.
[email protected] PAUL M. SUTCLIFFE Institute of Mathematics, University of Kent at Canterbury, Canterbury, CT2 7NZ, U.K.
[email protected]
Received 23 December 2000 We apply two very different approaches to calculate Skyrmions with baryon number B ≤ 22. The first employs the rational map ansatz, where approximate charge B Skyrmions are constructed from a degree B rational map between Riemann spheres. We use a simulated annealing algorithm to search for the minimal energy rational map of a given degree B. The second involves the numerical solution of the full non-linear time dependent equations of motion, with initial conditions consisting of a number of well separated Skyrmion clusters. In general, we find a good agreement between the two approaches. For B ≥ 7 almost all the solutions are of fullerene type, that is, the baryon density isosurface consists of twelve pentagons and 2B −14 hexagons arranged in a trivalent polyhedron. There are exceptional cases where this structure is modified, which we discuss in detail. We find that for a given value of B there are often many Skyrmions, with different symmetries, whose energies are very close to the minimal value, some of which we discuss. We present rational maps which are good approximations to these Skyrmions and accurately compute their energy by relaxation using the full non-linear dynamics.
1. Introduction 1.1. Overview The possibility that solitons can be used to represent particles is an attractive one, very much at the heart of current ideas in high energy physics. The first such model, known as the Skyrme model [27], was proposed in 1961 as a theory for the strong interactions of pions. The resulting non-linear field theory admits topological soliton solutions, which became known as Skyrmions. In the context of nuclear physics, the topological charge which stabilizes these solitons was identified with baryon number and hence the solitons themselves were identified with baryons. This model was set aside after the advent of gauge theories and Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) in the late 1960’s, but much later [31] it was shown to be a 29
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
30
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
low-energy effective action for QCD, in the limit of the number of colours (Nc ) being large. Subsequent work has shown the model to be capable of describing at least some aspects of the low-energy behaviour of hadrons. In particular, it was shown that the properties of the proton and neutron could be adequately described using the simple quantization of the solution with a single unit of topological charge [1], and that the other static configurations appeared to be most stable when considering charges corresponding to 4 He and 7 Li [5]. Although understanding the properties of light hadrons is the main motivation for this paper, we shall only comment very briefly at various points in our discussion on the implications of our results for this application. Instead, we will concentrate on the Skyrmions themselves, which are of interest in their own right. As examples of three-dimensional topological solitons, they have been seen to be very similar to BPS monopoles [3, 4, 28]. From a mathematical point of view they can be thought of as maps between 3-spheres and, therefore, the minimum energy configurations which we compute are the minimum energy maps relative to the Skyrme energy functional. Although there are no doubt many other possibilities for an energy functional on the space of maps between 3-spheres, the Skyrme functional is the simplest which supports topological structures and, therefore, it is also interesting to speculate as to their generality in this context. In the following we will present an extensive study of minimum energy solitons using two very different numerical methods.a With a small number of caveats, the two approaches come to the same conclusion: that there is a connection with fullerene cages [21] familiar in carbon chemistry, as conjectured in [5], and that the solutions can be represented in terms of the rational map ansatz [18]. For each topological charge, we will discuss the structure and symmetries of the solution in detail, and present an explicit analytic formula for the approximate solution. In the small number of cases where there is some deviation from the fullerene hypothesis, we will discuss qualitatively, and sometimes quantitatively, possible reasons. Finally, in the context of the two applications mentioned above, nuclear physics and generalized harmonic maps between 3-spheres, we will attempt to provide some heuristic insight into why our conclusions as to the structure of Skyrmions are consistent with the particular application.
1.2. Skyrmions In terms of the algebra valued currents Rµ = (∂µ U )U † of an SU(2) valued field U , the Skyrme Lagrangian density is, 1 1 µ µ ν (1.1) − Tr(Rµ R ) + Tr([Rµ , Rν ][R , R ]) . L= 24π 2 8 a The bare essentials of this work were first reported in [7]. Here, we give a more detailed exposition of our results.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
31
At first sight the domain is R3 and the target space is the group manifold of SU(2), S 3 , but the finite energy boundary condition, U (∞) = I, means that U is in fact a map from compactified R3 ∼ S 3 7→ S 3 . Such mappings have non-trivial homotopy classes characterized by π3 (S 3 ) = Z, which has the explicit representation Z 1 ijk d3 x Tr(Ri Rj Rk ) . (1.2) B=− 24π 2 A more geometrical description of the model can be made in terms of the strain tensor defined at each point x in the domain by 1 Dij = − Tr(Ri Rj ) , 2
(1.3)
which can be thought of as quantifying the deformation induced by the map between 3-spheres. This symmetric, positive definite tensor can be diagonalized with nonnegative eigenvalues λ21 , λ22 , λ23 , and the static energy, E, and baryon number, B, can be computed as integrals over R3 of the corresponding densities E and B given by E=
1 (λ2 + λ22 + λ23 + λ21 λ22 + λ22 λ23 + λ23 λ21 ) , 12π 2 1
B=
1 λ1 λ2 λ3 . 2π 2
(1.4)
A simple manipulation of these expressions allows one to deduce the Faddeev– Bogomolny bound E ≥ |B|, but in contrast to monopoles and vortices this bound cannot be saturated for any non-trivial finite energy configuration. In fact, it can be attained only when all the eigenvalues of the strain tensor are equal to one at all points in space — an isometry — and this is clearly not possible since R3 is not isometric to S 3 . In practice we shall see that minimization of the Skyrme energy functional associated with the Lagrangian density requires that the solution be as close to this bound as possible. The energy minimization can be thought of as finding the map which is as close to an isometry as possible, when averaged over space [22]. The boundary condition breaks the chiral symmetry (SU(2) × SU(2)) of the Skyrme model to an SO(3) isospin symmetry U 7→ OU O† , where O is a constant element of SU(2). When we refer to a spatial symmetry of a Skyrmion, such as spherical symmetry, the fields are not invariant under a spatial rotation, but rather there is an equivariance property that the effect of a spatial rotation can be absorbed into an isospin transformation. This implies that both the energy density, E, and baryon density, B, are strictly invariant under the symmetry. The B = 1 Skyrmion is spherically symmetric [27], the maximally allowed symmetry of the Lagrangian, and its energy is E = 1.232 [1]. In fact, spherically symmetric solutions exist at all charges, but they are not the minimum energy configurations, which are less symmetric. The B = 2 solution is axially symmetric [20, 30] and the higher charge solutions all have point symmetries [8, 5] which are subgroups of O(3). For B = 3, 4, 7 the Skyrmions have the Platonic symmetries of the tetrahedron (Td ), the cube (Oh ) and the dodecahedron (Yh ) respectively, while
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
32
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
for B = 5, 6, 8 the Skyrmions have the dihedral symmetries D2d , D4d and D6d respectively (see the discussion in Sec. 1.5 if you are unfamiliar with these point groups). For B = 9 a tetrahedrally symmetric Skyrmion has been found, but as we shall discuss later this appears not to be the minimum energy configuration, and hence is probably a low-energy saddle point. In all the above cases the baryon density (and also the energy density) is localized around the edges of a polyhedron. From these known results we were able, in a previous paper [5], to formulate some simple geometrical rulesb for the structure of Skyrmions which led us to conjecture that higher charge Skyrmions (B ≥ 7) would resemble trivalent polyhedra formed from 12 pentagons and 2B − 14 hexagons. We will refer to such structures as fullerene-like and to the conjecture as the fullerene hypothesis since precisely the same structures arise in carbon chemistry where carbon atoms sit at the vertices of such polyhedra, known as fullerenes [14]. On the basis of this, it was suggested that the minimum energy Skyrmion of charge B, SB , would have the same symmetry as a fullerene from the family C4(B−2) . For low charges (B = 7, B = 8) this leads to a unique prediction for SB , and indeed this was what we found in our original simulations. But as the charge increases the number of possible structures increases, in particular for B = 9 there are 2 possibilities with D2 and Td symmetries respectively, for B = 10 there are 6, for B = 11 there are 15, with a rapid increase for B > 11. Using this simple analogy, it was possible to predict that there would be an icosahedral configuration with B = 17 corresponding to the famous Buckminsterfullerene structure of C60 , and given its highly symmetric structure we suggested that this would be the minimum energy configuration at that charge. Our original work on computing minimum energy Skyrmions [5] and also that of [8] used the full non-linear field equations, or the full non-linear energy functional; a very resource hungry procedure even in the modern era of parallel supercomputers. It is also likely to be somewhat imprecise since (1) it can be very difficult to identify the particular symmetries of the solution that one computes in this way, even using sophisticated visualization packages, and (2) the choice of initial conditions is somewhat arbitrary: even when they are chosen to have no particular symmetry, it is impossible to guarantee that they will relax to the global minimum. Fortunately, help is at hand in the form of the rational map ansatz [18], which was devised as an approximate representation of the solutions computed in [5]. Although this representation is not exact it reduces the degrees of freedom in the problem to be a finite, manageable number, allowing computations to take place in an acceptable amount of time. Of course, the original approach based on the full non-linear equations still has a role to play in firstly checking and then fully relaxing the approximate solutions computed in the rational map approach. The development of this subject b The
original Geometric Energy Minimization (GEM) rules were that all the solutions computed for B ≤ 9 had the symmetries of almost spherical trivalent polyhedra with 4(B − 2) vertices, 2(B − 1) faces and 6(B − 2) edges.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
33
now treads an interesting interface between numerically generated solutions and this analytic approximation. In this paper we shall first compute what are the minimum energy solutions of the Skyrme model upto B = 22, under the assumption that they can be adequately represented by the rational map ansatz. Then by simulating collisions of well separated Skyrmion clusters using the full non-linear field equations, followed by a numerical relaxation of the resulting coalesced cluster, we shall attempt to verify that these structures are in fact the minimum energy Skyrmions. We find precisely the fullerene structures conjectured in [5] for all but a small number of cases where there are interesting caveats. We also demonstrate that not only are the minimal energy Skyrmions fullerene-like, but that there are also several other fullerene Skyrmions at a given baryon number whose energies are only very slightly higher than the minimal value. Finally, using the full non-linear equations once again, we relax the rational map generated solutions with specified symmetries to compute accurately the energies of the configurations.
1.3. Rational map ansatz The rational map ansatz was introduced in [18], and is a way to construct approximate Skyrmions from rational maps between Riemann spheres. Briefly, we use spherical coordinates in R3 , so that a point x ∈ R3 is given by a pair (r, z), where r = |x| is the distance from the origin, and z is a Riemann sphere coordinate giving the point on the unit two-sphere which intersects the half-line through the origin and the point x. Now, let R(z) be a degree B rational map between Riemann spheres, that is, R = p/q where p and q are polynomials in z such that max[deg(p), deg(q)] = B, and p and q have no common factors. Given such a rational map the ansatz for the Skyrme field is ¯ if (r) 2R 1 − |R|2 , (1.5) U (r, z) = exp 2R |R|2 − 1 1 + |R|2 where f (r) is a real profile function satisfying the boundary conditions f (0) = π and f (∞) = 0, which is determined by minimization of the Skyrme energy of the field (1.5) given a particular rational map R. It can be shown that this Skyrme field has charge B, and for 1 ≤ B ≤ 9 rational maps were presented in [18] which reproduced Skyrmions with the same symmetries as those computed in [5]. Furthermore, they were shown to have energies which are only about one or two percent above the numerically calculated values. Substitution of the rational map ansatz (1.5) into the Skyrme energy functional results in the following expression for the energy Z sin4 f 1 r2 f 02 + 2B(f 02 + 1) sin2 f + I 2 dr , (1.6) E= 3π r
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
34
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
where I denotes the integral 4 Z 1 + |z|2 dR 2i dzd¯ z 1 . I= 4π 1 + |R|2 dz (1 + |z|2 )2
(1.7)
To minimize the energy (1.6), therefore, one first determines the rational map which minimizes I, which may be thought of as an energy functional on the space of rational maps. Then given the minimum value of I it is a simple exercise to find the profile function which minimizes the energy (1.6) using a gradient flow method to solve the appropriate boundary value problem. Thus, within the rational map ansatz, the problem of finding the minimal energy Skyrmion reduces to the simpler problem of calculating the rational map which minimizes the function I. Computing the map which minimizes this set up is the essence of our procedure for finding the minimal energy Skyrmion, and in Sec. 2 we shall describe our numerical techniques used to address this problem. The baryon density is proportional to the derivative of the rational map, and (counting multiplicities) this will have 2B − 2 zeros, giving the points on the Riemann sphere for which the baryon density vanishes along the corresponding halflines through the origin. In terms of a baryon density isosurface plot these correspond to holes in a shell-like structure which resembles a polyhedron and the holes correspond to the face centres. 1.4. Symmetric maps: general discussion Since the maps we shall be dealing with describe symmetric Skyrmions, let us recall what it means for a rational map (and hence the associated Skyrmion) to be symmetric under a group G ⊂ SO(3). Consider a spatial rotation g ∈ 4 SO(3), which acts on the Riemann sphere coordinate z as an SU(2) M¨ obius transformation z 7→ g(z) =
γz + δ ¯ + γ¯ , −δz
where
|γ|2 + |δ|2 = 1 .
(1.8)
Similarly a rotation, D ∈ SO(3), of the target two-sphere (which corresponds to an isospin transformation) will act in the same way ΓR + ∆ where |Γ|2 + |∆|2 = 1 . (1.9) ¯ +Γ ¯, −∆R A map is G-symmetric if, for each g ∈ G, there exists a target space rotation, D, which counteracts the effect of the spatial rotation, that is, R 7→ D(R) =
R(g(z)) = D(R(z)) .
(1.10)
Note that in general the rotations on the domain and target spheres will not be the same, so that (γ, δ) 6= (Γ, ∆). Since we are dealing with SU(2) transformations the set of target space rotations will form a representation of the double group of G, which is the group of order 2|G| ¯ which squares to the identity. obtained from G by the addition of an element E
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
35
The fact that we are dealing with the double group is important since it has representations which are not representations of G. From now on it is to be understood that when we refer to a group G we shall actually mean its double group. To determine the existence and compute particular symmetric rational maps is, therefore, a matter of classical group theory. We are concerned with degree B polynomials which form the carrier space for B + 1, the (B + 1)-dimensional irreducible representation of SU(2). Now, as a representation of SU(2) this is irreducible, but if we only consider the restriction to a subgroup G, B + 1|G , this will in general be reducible. What we are interested in is the irreducible decomposition of this representation and tables of these subductions can be found, for example, in [2]. The simplest case in which a G-symmetric degree B rational map exists is if B + 1|G = E + · · ·
(1.11)
where E denotes a two-dimensional representation. In this case a basis for E consists of two degree B polynomials which can be taken to be the numerator and denominator of the rational map. A subtle point which needs to be addressed is that the two basis polynomials may have a common root, in which case the resulting rational map is degenerate and does not correspond to a genuine degree B map. More complicated situations can arise, for example, if B + 1|G = A1 + A2 + · · ·
(1.12)
where A1 and A2 denote two one-dimensional representations, then a whole oneparameter family of maps can be obtained by taking a constant multiple of the ratio of the two polynomials which are a basis for A1 and A2 respectively. An mparameter family of G-symmetric maps can be constructed if the decomposition contains (m + 1) copies of a two-dimensional representation, that is, B + 1|G = (m + 1)E + · · ·
(1.13)
where the m (complex) parameters correspond to the freedom in the decomposition of (m + 1)E into m + 1 copies of E. Explicit examples corresponding to the above types of decompositions will be constructed in Sec. 1.5. For a detailed explanation of how to calculate these maps by computing appropriate projectors see [18]. 1.5. Symmetric maps: specific examples As we shall discuss in Sec. 2.2 the basic procedure for finding the minimum energy Skyrmion in the rational map ansatz will be to minimize the function I subject to the map having degree B. However, this will find the map in an arbitrary spatial orientation, preventing identification of the symmetry directly from the map. One can always compute the corresponding baryon density isosurface and identify the symmetry by eye, a procedure which is often helpful, but this is also fraught with difficulties, particularly when, for example, the solution only has a small number of
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
36
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
symmetry generators. Therefore, in order to be sure of the symmetry identification we will also search maps which are restricted to have a particular symmetry. Since all the point groups that we shall consider are subgroups of O(3), they must be either cyclic groups, Cn , which involve invariance under rotations by (360/n)◦ about some axis, dihedral groups, Dn , which are obtained from the cyclic group by the addition of a C2 axis which is perpendicular to the main symmetry axis, tetrahedral groups (T ), which are the symmetries associated with the tetrahedron, octahedral groups (O), those associated with the octahedron/cube, or icosahedral groups (Y ), those associated with the icosahedron/dodecahedron. Each of these symmetry groups can be extended by the inclusion of reflections. All the icosahedral maps presented in this paper have already been discussed in [18], while all the octahedral maps used are easily deduced from the tetrahedral maps discussed below, so we shall only concentrate on understanding the details of the dihedral and tetrahedral maps. In terms of the Riemann sphere coordinate z the generators of the dihedral group Dn may be taken to be z 7→ e2πi/n z and z 7→ 1/z. This can be extended by the addition of a reflection symmetry in two ways: by including a reflection in the plane perpendicular to the main Cn axis, which is represented on the Riemann sphere by invariance under z 7→ 1/¯ z, and the group Dnh is obtained. Alternatively, a reflection symmetry may be imposed in a plane which contains the main symmetry axis and bisects the C2 axes obtained by applying the Cn symmetry to the C2 axis. This reflection is represented on the Riemann sphere as invariance under z 7→ eπi/n z¯, and the resulting group is Dnd . To construct Dn symmetric maps does not require any group theory formalism discussed in Sec. 1.4 since it is a simple task to explicitly apply the two generators of Dn to a general degree B rational map to determine a family of symmetric maps. Explicitly, an s-parameter family is given byc , s s X X R(z) = aj z jn+r as−j z jn , (1.14) j=0
j=0
where r = B mod n and s = (B − r)/n. Here as = 1 and a0 , . . . , as−1 are arbitrary complex parameters. Clearly, this map satisfies the conditions for it to be symmetric under Dn , R(e2πi/n z) = e2πir/n R(z) ,
R(1/z) = 1/R(z) ,
(1.15)
and imposing a reflection symmetry constrains the otherwise complex coefficients aj to either be real, or pure imaginary. In the case of Dnh symmetry the condition c There
are other Dn symmetric families of maps in addition to those of the form (1.14), but they will not be needed in this paper.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
37
is that all aj are real, whereas for Dnd symmetry the coefficient aj is either real or purely imaginary depending on whether (s − j) mod 2 is zero or one respectively. The procedure for constructing tetrahedrally symmetric maps is more difficult than for dihedral symmetries and the systematic group theory approach discussed in Sec. 1.4 must be employed. No simple formula such as (1.14) exists, so for later reference we shall, therefore, need to recall the basic facts about the irreducible representations of the tetrahedral group T. T has three one-dimensional representations, which are the trivial representation, A, and two conjugate representations A1 and A2 . There is also a threedimensional representaion, F , which is obtained as 3|T . In addition to these representations there are three two-dimensional representations of the double group of T , which we denote by E 0 , E10 , E20 , where the prime signifies that these are not representations of T , but only of the double group of T. E 0 is obtained as 2|T and E10 and E20 are conjugate representations. 2. Numerical Minimization Algorithms 2.1. Overview Minimization of an energy functional is a classical numerical problem, with no hard and fast optimum method. Methods which are tailored for a particular application can work very badly in others. In this section we will outline the basic features of the numerical methods which we have employed to compute minimum energy Skyrmions with and without using the rational map ansatz. We will attempt to discuss both the advantages and disadvantages of the two methods. Our original approach to this problem was to use the code first used in [4] to evolve the full field equations for well-separated Skyrmions, and this is discussed in Sec. 2.3. It worked well for B < 9 [5] and its results were the main motivation for the rational map ansatz. Its disadvantages are that it is very slow, requiring many hours of CPU time on a parallel computer, and in circumstances where there is the possibility of two or more minima separated by a small energy gap, dependence on the choice of initial conditions is also an issue. It is, however, the only way in which the results of approximate methods, such as the rational map ansatz, can be checked. Creating a particular configuration from many different initial conditions using this method can be thought of as strong evidence for it being the minimum energy solution, irrespective of other considerations. The simulated annealing of rational maps as discussed in Sec. 2.2 is by contrast fast — it only requires a serial processor — by virtue of the fact that the number of degrees of freedom have been substantially reduced, is relatively independent of the initial conditions and much less sensitive to local minima. But, of course, the results are only as good as the rational map approach to describing Skyrmions. Thankfully, as we shall see, the rational map approach in general works very well, allowing us to generate symmetric Skyrmions with large baryon number.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
38
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
2.2. Simulated annealing of rational maps Simulated annealing is a fairly recent numerical method for obtaining the global minimum of an energy function, and is based on the way that a solid cools to form a lattice [29]. Let E(a) be an energy function which depends on a number of parameters a. The idea is that at a given temperature, T , the system is allowed to reach thermal equilibrium, characterized by the probability of being in a state with energy E given by the Boltzmann distribution Pr(E = E) =
1 exp(−E/T ) , Z(T )
(2.1)
where Z(T ) is the partition function. In practice, this is achieved by applying a Metropolis method: starting with a given configuration, a, a small random perturbation δa is made and the energy of the resulting configuration is computed. If the change in energy, δE = E(a + δa)−E(a), is negative then the new configuration is accepted, that is, a is replaced by a + δa. However, if the change results in an increase in energy then the probability of accepting the new configuration is e−δE/T . By performing a large number of such perturbations thermal equilibrium can be achieved at temperature T . The procedure to minimize the energy is to start at a high temperature, bring the system into thermal equilibrium and then lower the temperature before regaining the equilibrium. As the temperature is decreased, the system is more likely to be found in a state with lower energy and in the limit as T → 0 the configuration will move toward a minimum of E. In the limit of infinitesimally slow variations in the temperature this can be shown to be the global minimum. From the above description it is immediately clear that the simulated annealing method has a major advantage over other conventional minimization techniques in that changes which increase the energy are allowed, enabling the algorithm to escape from minima that are not the global minimum. Of course, in practice one is not guaranteed to find the global minimum since the number of iteration loops used to bring the system into thermal equilibrium at a fixed temperature and also the number of times the temperature can be decreased are both restricted by computational resources. However, it does provide the most efficient means for searching for a global minimum and with sufficient computational resources, plus sufficient care in applying them, one can be fairly confident of the final result. For our application to rational maps we obviously take the energy function to be I and the parameters a to be the constants in the rational map. To compute I involves a numerical integration over the sphere, which can be performed with standard methods, and in a typical simulation this needs to be calculated approximately a million times for a full simulated annealing run. In each case we take the initial rational map to be the axially symmetric one R = z B , which for large B has a very high value of I. Note that since we are using the Riemann sphere coordinate z, the two-sphere metric is the Fubini–Study metric in this coordinate system. This means that in
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
39
terms of moving energy around the sphere there is a bias between points near the south pole as compared to those near the north pole, in terms of small variations of the rational map parameters. To counteract this discrepancy we perform a spatial rotation of the configuration, z 7→ 1/z each time the temperature is decreased. To identify the rational map, and more importantly its symmetries, produced by the simulated annealing algorithm is a two stage process. First, we compute the minimum energy map assuming no particular symmetry, that is, we allow a general map of degree B. As already pointed in Sec. 1.5 the end result will be a rational map which is in a random orientation in both the domain and target two-spheres. The target space orientation could easily be fixed (in fact, it is more convenient not to do this, due to the above comments regarding a periodic spatial rotation of the map during the minimization procedure), but there is no simple way to make the spatial orientation such that the symmetry generators of the map are conveniently represented. Once one has the minimizing degree B rational map and the corresponding minimum value of I, the Skyrmion is then constructed and its baryon density is plotted and examined in an attempt to identify its symmetries by eye. This conjectured symmetry is then confirmed by constructing the most general map with this symmetry and minimizing within this constrained symmetric family to check that the same minimum value of I is recovered. As a final check the corresponding Skyrmion is constructed and its baryon density examined to confirm that it is identical to the one obtained previously. For each charge we have also performed several simulated annealing runs within constrained symmetric families, such as D2 , D3 and D4 . Since all the symmetry groups must be subgroups of O(3), the number of possibilities is finite and checking just these three possibilities, allows one to rule out a large fraction of them; the rest often being possible by eye. This not only provides an additional check that the minimizing map was found, but also allows us to obtain other low energy maps, which may be either saddle points or local minima. Finally, it is perhaps worth mentioning that a simulated annealing method has recently been used in a rather different way to study Skyrmions [15]. These authors used a simulated annealing algorithm on a discretized version of the full Skyrme energy, taking the parameters to be the field values at the discretized lattice sites. This is a much more computationally expensive approach than using the rational map ansatz, which is probably the reason these authors only considered Skyrmions upto charge B = 4, where, of course, the results were already known. Nonetheless, it is interesting to know that a simulated annealing approach is viable in this manner and demonstrates yet another application of this versatile technique. 2.3. Full field dynamics 2.3.1. Sigma model formulation In the SU(2) form, the equations of motion are cumbersome to handle numerically, so we convert to the notation of a non-linear sigma model (NLSM), which has
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
40
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
Lagrangian, 1 1 L = ∂µ φ · ∂ µ φ − (∂µ φ · ∂ µ φ)2 + (∂µ φ · ∂ν φ)(∂ µ φ · ∂ ν φ) + λ(φ · φ − 1) , (2.2) 2 2 with the Lagrange multiplier λ introduced to maintain the constraint φ · φ = 1. The Euler–Lagrange equations are given by (1 − ∂µ φ · ∂ µ φ)φ − (∂ ν φ · ∂µ ∂ν φ − ∂µ φ · φ)∂ µ φ + (∂ µ φ · ∂ ν φ)∂µ ∂ν φ − λφ = 0 , (2.3) where the Lagrange multiplier can be calculated by contracting (2.3) with φ and using the second derivative of the constraint, λ = (1 − ∂µ φ · ∂ µ φ)φ · φ + (∂ µ φ · ∂ ν φ)(φ · ∂µ ∂ν φ) = −(∂µ φ · ∂ν φ)(∂ µ φ · ∂ ν φ) − (1 − ∂µ φ · ∂ µ φ)∂ν φ · ∂ ν φ .
(2.4)
Denoting differentiation with respect to time as a dot, these equations can be recast as ˙ ∂i ∂j φ) − λφ = 0 , ˙ ∂i φ, ∂i φ, M φ¨ − α(φ,
(2.5)
where the symmetric matrix M has elements Mab = (1 + ∂j φ · ∂j φ)δab − ∂j φa ∂j φb ,
(2.6)
and α is given by ˙ φ˙ + 2(φ˙ · ∂i φ)∂i φ˙ − (φ˙ · ∂i φ)∂ ˙ i φ − φ˙ 2 ∂i ∂i φ α = (φ˙ · ∂i ∂i φ − ∂i φ · ∂i φ) + (∂i φ · ∂i ∂j φ − ∂j φ · ∂i ∂i φ)∂j φ + (1 + ∂j φ · ∂j φ)∂i ∂i φ − (∂i φ · ∂j φ)∂i ∂j φ . (2.7) Quite clearly these equations of motion are not analytically tractable. In subsequent sections we will discuss our numerical methods for evolving the equations of motion for spatially discretized initial conditions and for obtaining minimal energy static Skyrmions. As we shall see this is still a highly non-trivial task and can only be done for a specialized, but ill-defined, set of initial conditions. 2.3.2. Discretization and boundary conditions There are three aspects common to almost all numerical approaches to solving nonlinear PDE’s. The first is a spatial discretization and an approximation for spatial derivatives. We discretized on a regular, cubic grid with N points in each of the Cartesian directions and the array φi,j,k ≈ φ(i∆x, j∆x, k∆x). The choice of N and ∆x is of critical importance, since the soliton configurations we wish to represent are localized. We found that grids with N = 100 and ∆x = 0.1 were convenient for representing all the configurations which we study in this paper, although larger grid spacings (∆x = 0.2) also give sensible results, and larger grids (N = 200) were used to obtain more accurate calculations of energies.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
41
The spatial derivatives used were fourth order, so as to accurately represent the large spatial gradients of the solitonic configurations. Since the reader may not be totally familiar with this procedure, various expressions for derivatives are presented below: for first order derivatives, −φi+2,j,k + 8φi+1,j,k − 8φi−1,j,k + φi−2,j,k ∂φ = + O(∆x4 ) , (2.8) ∂x 12∆x for second order derivatives, −φi+2,j,k + 16φi+1,j,k − 30φi,j,k + 16φi−1,j,k − φi−2,j,k ∂2φ = + O(∆x4 ) , (2.9) 2 ∂x 12∆x2 and for mixed second order derivatives ∂2φ ∂ 2φ ∂2φ + + 2 = O(∆x4 ) + (−φi+2,j+2,k + 16φi+1,j+1,k − 30φi,j,k ∂x2 ∂x∂y ∂y 2 + 16φi−1,j−1,k − φi−2,j−2,k )/(12∆x2 ) .
(2.10)
The next part of the procedure is a method for time evolution. The equations of motion can be transformed into first order form, (2.11) M ψ˙ − α(ψ, ∂i φ, ∂i ψ, ∂i ∂j φ) − λφ = 0 , ˙ and this can be solved using a leapfrog method. This involves by defining ψ = φ, replacing ψ+ − ψ− φ+ − φ− + O(∆t2 ) , ψ˙ = + O(∆t2 ) , (2.12) φ˙ = 2∆t 2∆t where + and − correspond to the the values of ψ and φ at one step after and one before respectively. In a much simpler case such as the wave equation, this creates a decoupling of the arrays containing the discretized versions φ and ψ. However, the non-linear dependence of the function α on ψ requires the storing of two copies of each array, and hence four in total, requiring 64Mb of core memory for N = 100. The choice of ∆t is also crucial, since it can create numerical instability. The √ standard Courant condition for a linear equation in three dimensions states that 3∆t < ∆x. The non-linear nature of the Skyrme equations leads to a non-trivial modification to this relation, which still stands as the best possible due to reasons of causality. We find, essentially by trial and error, that ∆t ≈ ∆x/10 leads to a stable algorithm. We should note at this stage that there is another, potentially more pathological, instability of the Skyrme model which is discussed in a subsequent section. Finally, one is required to specify boundary conditions for the finite grid employed. Since the fourth order spatial derivatives require a five point wide stencil, one point away from the boundary it is necessary to use second order spatial approximations. But on the boundary itself the spatial derivatives cannot be evaluated, since the second order spatial approximation requires a three point wide stencil. We experimented with various different types of boundary conditions, such as Neumann (zero normal derivative), Dirichlet (fixed) and periodic. The results presented here are for Dirichlet boundary conditions, although we believe that the use of Neumann boundaries would have little effect on the results.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
42
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
2.3.3. Imposing the constraint In the previous section we have discussed all aspects of the numerical solution of the Skyrme equations of motion which are common to the numerical solution of most non-linear PDE’s. There is, however, an added extra which makes life much more difficult in the case of a NLSM. In the previous section we included the Lagrange multiplier λ, assuming that it can be calculated from ψ, φ and their spatial derivatives. In fact, this leads to a numerical scheme which becomes unstable for any choice of ∆t in under ten timesteps. The problem is that we have ignored the reason for its introduction; to maintain the constraint φ · φ = 1, which is manifest in the NLSM. A number of approaches have been developed to deal with such constraints. Firstly, one could modify the numerical scheme to calculate λ so that it explicitly maintains the constraint for the discretized equations of motion. At each step, this is seen to be almost equal to calculating λ from the formula (2.4), but the two differ by numerical discretization effects at a level well below 1%, which nonetheless cause the solution to slip off the unit sphere, if allowed to accumulate. An alternative approach, which was found to work well in simulations of Baby Skyrmions [26], is to simply rescale the field to have unit modulus, that is, to continually make the replacement φ , φ 7→ √ φ·φ
(2.13)
at each point on the discretized grid after each timestep. While appearing ugly from a purist numerical analysis point of view, this technique is effective and does not become unstable except in the most extreme circumstances. One is effectively projecting the field back onto the sphere along the field itself, which has no particular physical motivation, but if the modification is small, which can be arranged by choosing a sufficiently small timestep, then this should be as good as any other arbitrary choice. Another possibility is to require that the derivative of the constraint is zero: the relation φ · φ = 1 not only implies that the solution lies on the unit sphere, but that it cannot come off, that is, all the derivatives of the constraint are also satisfied. This leads to an infinite hierarchy of relations which must hold. Obviously, with a second order time evolution one cannot hope to maintain them all explicitly in the discretized system. However, if one manages to satisfy the first one, it may be possible to construct an effective code. It is possible to impose that φ · ψ = 0 by computing λ in order to satisfy φ+ · ψ + = 0 which requires that, λ=−
ψ − · ψ + φ · M −1 α + 2ψ · M −1 α∆t . φM −1 φ + 2ψ · M −1 φ∆t
(2.14)
Although we should note that this does not implicitly imply the imposition of the constraint on the discretized equations. Largely by trial and error, we find that the best method for our numerical scheme is a hybrid of the last two methods. It just so happens that this is possible within
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
43
our scheme, since there are two discretized grids with essentially their own time evolution. Firstly, we calculate λ to satisfy φ+ · ψ + = 0, followed by the rescaling transformation (2.13) on the field φ+ . We find that this hybrid methods maintains the constraint for many thousands of timesteps. 2.3.4. Non–hyperbolic regions We have already discussed the potential for our numerical scheme to become unstable because of Courant-type instability and also due to the imperfect imposition of the constraint φ · φ = 1. However, there is a much more pathological instability which comes about since the equations of motion are not manifestly hyperbolic and their precise nature, hyperbolic, parabolic or elliptic, depends on the particular configuration being evolved [13]. The problem is that the specific numerical scheme we have designed will work only for the hyperbolic case and we know of no way of treating all configurations within a single numerical scheme. Fortunately, the hyperbolic regime is the only physically meaningful one. One can understand this by thinking of the Skyrme model as a low energy effective action, with higher order terms ignored. At higher energies, where the terms which are ignored would be large, the Skyrme equations of motion become non-hyperbolic. It was suggested in [13] that the equations of motion became non-hyperbolic whenever the kinetic energy is greater than the potential energy. Empirically, we find that this is at least partially true, with an instability associated with a very large kinetic energy density relative to that of potential energy. However, this statement is a little imprecise since we found that sometimes the kinetic energy density rose above the potential locally on the discretized grid without creating instability. Unfortunately, the omplicated nature of the equations of motion makes it almost impossible to say for certain, which configurations will eventually lead to an instability and which will not, although experience has taught us that most of the configurations we wish to evolve for physical applications, such as low energy nuclear physics, are possible. 2.3.5. Locating minima In the preceding sections we have discussed how to construct a numerical scheme which evolves the full non-linear equations of motion for the Skyrme model. This allowed us to simulate the dynamics of Skyrmion collisions in [4]. However, for the purposes of this paper one would also like to create static multi-soliton configurations. We are assisted in this by the observation that when well separated Skyrmions coalesce they seem to create low energy symmetric multi-soliton states. The procedure that we use is to set up initial conditions with the required topological charge involving a collision between one or more Skyrmions of some particular charge, which can be done using the rational map ansatz, described in Sec. 1.3, using charges for which the rational map is already known. We then evolve
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
44
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
the configuration until they visibly coalesce or until the potential energy begins to increase. At this point all the kinetic energy is removed, that is, φ˙ = 0 at all points on the grid, and the evolution is continued until once again the potential energy rises. This procedure is repeated many times until the energy is no longer decreasing. Once the solution is sufficiently relaxed it often pays to just evolve the solution under the full equations of motion without removing kinetic energy since this can prevent the minute oscillations required to achieve the minimum from gaining momentum. Even this procedure can be very slow, but can be speeded up by adding a dissipative term to the equations of motion, ˙ ∂i ∂j φ) − λφ = −φ˙ , ˙ ∂i φ, ∂i φ, M φ¨ − α(φ,
(2.15)
for > 0. Clearly, the static solutions are still the same. However, the dissipation causes the solution to roll down the potential well to the minimum much quicker in certain circumstances, with = 0.5 seeming to work well. We should note that the addition of this dissipation can also effect the Courant instability of the algorithm, and, in particular, very near to the minimum one is plagued by instability. Experience, has shown us that a combination of running with dissipation and then without helps speed up the process. Obviously, one should be concerned that this process might not necessarily lead one to the global minima. One might, for example, relax down to a metastable local minima or the initial conditions may have some symmetry which is maintained by the equations of motion and hence the final solution. We attempt to ensure that we do not encounter the latter possibility by creating initial conditions using the product ansatz, which is manifestly asymmetric (U1 U2 6= U2 U1 ). The possibility of local minima, however, can never be totally excluded, but one can build up confidence in the minima by using different initial configurations. For low charges (B ≤ 4), the attractive channel configurations discussed in [4] are particularly good initial conditions. But for higher charge no such maximally attractive channels exist for B well separated Skyrmions and only a small number of attractive configurations are known. We find that sensible initial conditions can be produced for any charge B > 10 by using two clusters, one with charge B − n and the other with charge n, such that n = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 but no larger. These are Lorentz boosted together with a velocity of v = 0.3 in a collision which has a small but non-zero impact parameter. 3. Skyrmion Identification In this section we will present the results of an extensive set of simulations performed with the intention of identifying the symmetry and associated polyhedron of the minimum energy configurations for B ≤ 22. We should note that making definitive statements as to an identification for a particular charge has, historically, been fraught with difficulties. In particular, the identifications of the B = 5 and B = 6
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
45
solutions in [8] and the B = 9 configuration in [5] were incorrect to varying degrees. Suffice to say when the two numerical methods agree for a wide range of initial conditions and simulation parameters, there is strong grounds to believe that we have created the correct configuration; identifying the symmetry is then the only complication. Conversely, when they disagree, or we know more than one very low energy solution for a particular charge, it is a matter of some debate which is the true minimum energy solution, or whether there is some more complicated symmetry allowing local, or even degenerate minima. We will engage in this debate at various stages, but the reader should make up their own mind as to the strength of our arguments. We have argued strongly in the previous sections on numerical methods that the simulated annealing of rational maps is the simplest and probably cleanest approach to compute low energy Skyrmion configurations. Clearly, its veracity for computing the true minima depends on the viability of the ansatz for describing Skyrmions, and that the energy functional based on I is a good approximation to the true energy, or at least the relative energies of particular configurations. With these caveats in mind, we present our first attempt at identification of the minima as the rational maps which minimize I, before discussing other possibilities. The results of the simulated annealing algorithm applied to a general rational map of degree B(≤ 22) and the symmetry identification procedure discussed in Sec. 1.5 are presented in Table 1. In each case, we tabulate the identified symmetry group G, the minimum value of I, the quantity I/B 2 — which is strikingly uniform at around Sec. 5.1.2 and 5.1.3 — and the value of E/B for a profile function which minimizes the energy functional (1.6) for the particular map. We should first comment that for B ≤ 8 the rational maps which minimize I are exactly those presented in [18] to approximate the results of the full non-linear simulations [5]; thus the simulated annealing algorithm provides a nice numerical check that the same maps are reproduced by searching the full parameter space of rational maps. Also for B ≥ 7 all the symmetry groups with the exception of B = 9, B = 10 and B = 13 are compatible with the fullerene hypothesis: that SB has 4(B − 2) trivalent vertices and is constructed from 2B − 14 hexagons and 12 pentagons. The baryon density isosurfaces for each of the solutions are displayed in Fig. 1 along with a model of the associated polyhedron in Fig. 2, which confirm that for the most part they are indeed of the fullerene type. The symmetry groups of B = 9, B = 10 and B = 13 all contain the cyclic subgroup C4 , which is not compatible with them being of the fullerene type, since the associated polyhedron of such a solution must contain either a four-valent bond, or a square. These are the first Skyrme solutions found which do not comply with the Geometric Energy Minimization (GEM) rules suggested in [5]. We shall discuss these solutions in more detail in the subsequent section, but it is gratifying to note that all the other solutions appear qualitatively to comply with our expectations based on the GEM rules.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
46
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
Table 1. Results from the simulated annealing of rational maps of degree B. For 1 ≤ B ≤ 22 we list the symmetry of the rational map, G, the minimal value of I, its comparison with the bound I/B 2 ≥ 1, and the energy per baryon E/B obtained after computing the profile function which minimizes the Skyrme energy functional. B
G
I
I/B 2
E/B
1.0
1.000
1.232
1
O(3)
2
D∞h
5.8
1.452
1.208
3
Td
13.6
1.509
1.184
4
Oh
20.7
1.291
1.137
5
D2d
35.8
1.430
1.147
6
D4d
50.8
1.410
1.137
7
Yh
60.9
1.242
1.107
8
D6d
85.6
1.338
1.118
9
D4d
109.3
1.349
1.116
10
D4d
132.6
1.326
1.110
11
D3h
161.1
1.331
1.109
12
Td
186.6
1.296
1.102
13
O
216.7
1.282
1.098
14
D2
258.5
1.319
1.103
15
T
296.3
1.317
1.103
16
D3
332.9
1.300
1.098
17
Yh
363.4
1.257
1.092
18
D2
418.7
1.292
1.095
19
D3
467.9
1.296
1.095
20
D6d
519.7
1.299
1.095
21
T
569.9
1.292
1.094
22
D5d
621.6
1.284
1.092
In Table 2, Fig. 3 and Fig. 4, we present the results of our extensive search for the minimum energy maps with particular symmetries, usually dihedral groups or chosen from the extensive tables of fullerenes presented in [14], which lend further weight to our conclusions that those presented in Table 1 are in fact the minima relative to the energy functional I. They do, however, turn up the possibility that in certain cases the minima of I may not necessarily be the minimum of the Skyrme energy, since some of them have values of I very close to the values presented in Table 1. When the values are so close it is difficult to make a guess as to how the relaxation to the true solution might effect their relative positions; an issue to which we shall return in subsequent sections. For the moment we will denote them by ?, and conclude at least that they are not a global minima of I, but are believed to represent other critical points.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
47
Fig. 1. The baryon density isosurfaces of the Skyrmions with B = 1 − 22 which are minimum energy configurations (see Table 1) within the rational map ansatz. Each corresponds to a value of B = 0.035 and are presented to scale.
For 9 ≤ B ≤ 22 we shall now describe in detail the rational maps we have obtained, the structure of the associated Skyrmions and make a comparison with the results from full field simulations. Our study of the rational maps has already turned up a few oddities and we shall attempt to interpret these at the relevant charge. Charges where the fullerene hypothesis appears to break down are B = 9 and B = 13, while the rational map approach to representing the minimum energy Skyrmion appears to need careful consideration for B = 10, B = 14, B = 16 and B = 22.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
48
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
Fig. 2. scale.
The associated polyhedra for the Skyrmions presented in Fig. 1. The models are not to
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
49
Table 2. Same as for Table 2, but for the other critical points of I. Notice that the I values for the B = 10 configurations with D3 and D3d symmetry, the B = 13 with D4d , the B = 16 with D2 and the B = 22 with D3 are extremely close to the corresponding values in Table 1, suggesting the possibility of local minima. B
G
I
I/B 2
E/B
9* 10* 10* 10* 13* 13* 15* 16* 17* 19* 22*
Td D3 D3d D3h D4d Oh Td D2 Oh Th D3
112.8 132.8 133.5 143.2 216.8 265.1 313.7 333.4 367.2 469.8 623.4
1.393 1.328 1.335 1.432 1.283 1.568 1.394 1.302 1.271 1.301 1.288
1.123 1.110 1.111 1.126 1.098 1.140 1.113 1.098 1.093 1.096 1.092
Fig. 3. The baryon density isosurfaces of the Skyrmions we found which are other stationary points of I (see Table 2) within the rational map ansatz. Each corresponds to a value of B = 0.035 and are presented to scale.
3.1. B = 9 In [5] it was suggested that the B = 9 minimum energy configuration had Td symmetry, a symmetric configuration of C28 (it corresponds to configuration 28:2 in [14]). The polyhedron to which it corresponds comprises of 12 pentagons, fuzed into 4 triplets, placed at the vertices of a tetrahedron, with 4 hexagons placed at the vertices of a dual tetrahedron. This, plus the solutions for B = 7 and B = 8, was one of the main motivations of the fullerene hypothesis. Unfortunately, it appears that the original identification of the symmetry was incorrect and further relaxation of this configuration using the full non-linear field equations lead to a somewhat different solution.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
50
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
Fig. 4. The associated polyhedra for the Skyrmions presented in Fig. 3. The models once again are not to scale. Note that we have been unable to make models for the B = 13 solution with Oh symmetry and the B = 15 solution with Td symmetry since they contain a large number of four-valent bonds.
The minimizing map in this case has D4d symmetry and I = 109.3, with the functional form of the map being given by R=
z(a + ibz 4 + z 8 ) , 1 + ibz 4 + az 8
(3.1)
where a = −3.38, b = −11.19. It should be noted that this is slightly lower than the value I = 112.8 of the tetrahedral map [18] √ √ √ √ 5i 3z 6 − 9z 4 + 3i 3z 2 + 1 + az 2 (z 6 − i 3z 4 − z 2 + i 3) √ √ √ √ , (3.2) R= z 3 (−z 6 − 3i 3z 4 + 9z 2 − 5i 3) + az(−i 3z 6 + z 4 + i 3z 2 − 1) where a = −1.98. Amazingly, the solution which was created by the relaxation of initially wellseparated B = 8 and B = 1 configurations (henceforth such initial conditions will
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
51
denoted 8 + 1) using the full non-linear field equations, and confirmed using a number of different initial conditions (for example, 7 + 2 and 6 + 3), is precisely that which corresponds to the rational map (3.1). The associated polyhedron is not a fullerene, since the symmetry group D4d is incompatible with pentagons and hexagons forming a trivalent polyhedron. In fact, it has two four-valent links which occur between four pentagons forming the top and bottom pseudo-facesd of a rather flat polyhedron, linked by a belt of eight alternately up and down pointing pentagons; the top and bottom being rotated relative to each other by 45◦ to give the D4d symmetry. In Sec. 5.2 we will discuss how this solution can be formed by the symmetry enhancement of the other known fullerene corresponding to C28 which has D2 symmetry (this is labelled 28:1 in [14]). On the basis of this we conclude that S9 has D4d symmetry and not Td as previously suggested, but that the known Td symmetric solution is a saddle point. 3.2. B = 10 A glance at Table 1 and Table 2 shows that there are (at least) four maps whose I values are very close together. Minimizing over all maps yields the value I = 132.6 and this can be obtained from a D4d symmetric map of the form R=
z 2 (a + ibz 4 + z 8 ) , 1 + ibz 4 + az 8
(3.3)
where a = −8.67 and b = 14.75. This is not a fullerene Skyrmion, the four-fold symmetry this time manifesting itself in the existence of a square on the top and bottom of the associated polyhedron. There is, however, a fullerene Skyrmion with I = 132.8, very close to that of the minimum, which corresponds to a D3 symmetric map of the form R=
z(1 + az 3 + bz 6 + cz 9 ) , c + bz 3 + az 6 + z 9
(3.4)
where a, b, c are complex parameters. The minimum is obtained for the values a = 4.40 − 1.72i, b = −2.38 + 3.10i, c = −0.12 + 0.19i. The symmetry can be increased to D3d by choosing b to be real and a and c to both be purely imaginary, and within this class the minimum is very slightly higher at I = 133.5, which is attained when a = 20.40i, b = −30.22, c = −4.69i. Finally, if a, b, c are all real then the symmetry is D3h and the minimum in this class has I = 143.2 when a = −5.14, b = −2.20, c = −0.36. The baryon density of the D4d symmetric map is presented in Fig. 1 and for the other three maps, D3 , D3d , D3h , in Fig. 3. The polyhedron associated with the D4d solution can be constructed by taking two squares each surrounded by 4 hexagons, connected via a band of 8 pentagons alternately pointing up and down; the two d We
shall use the term pseudo-face to refer, rather loosely, to a set of connected polygons, which act from the point of view of symmetry of the associated polygon as a single face.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
52
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
squares being rotated relative to each other by 45◦ . Each of the links is trivalent, but instead of comprizing of 12 pentagons and 6 hexagons as would have been suggested by the fullerene hypothesis, it contains 8 pentagons, 8 hexagons and 2 squares, although the number of vertices 32 ≡ 4(B − 2) and faces 18 ≡ 2(B − 1) are still compatible with the GEM rules The other three maps give Skyrmions of fullerene type, with the baryon density isosurface comprising the requisite number of pentagons and hexagons arranged in a trivalent polyhedron. The associated polyhedron for the D3h solution (which corresponds to 32:5 in [14]) comprises of two copies of a hexagonal triple linked by a belt of 12 pentagons which can be thought of as being made of 3 sets of four fused pentagons in a C3 arrangement. The D3 and D3d solutions are very similar: to make each of the associated polyhedra (which correspond to configurations 32:6 and 32:4 in [14] respectively) first start with two pentagon triples. There are six places on each triple to which one can add another polygon, which fall into two types — one can connect to a single pentagon edge, or between two pentagons connecting to an edge of each. To make the two different configurations, one must add three hexagons and three pentagons alternately around each of the triples; the difference being which polygon (pentagon or hexagon) connects to the two different sites. In particular, the D3d configuration has hexagons connected to the single pentagon, and pentagons between the two pentagons; vice versa for the D3 configuration. Once one has added these 6 polygons, the two identical copies are then connected, the two being rotated relative to each other by 60◦ in the D3d configuration, and at no particular fixed angle in the case of D3 . As fullerenes these three structures are tabulated in [14], along with three other possibilities which have less symmetry (2 × C2 and D2 ). Unfortunately, these lower symmetry solutions are impossible to find using the simulated annealing algorithm since their symmetry groups are subgroups of D4d and the minimum energy rational map with this symmetry is already known. In order to try and understand which of the four configurations is the true minimum we have relaxed all the different initial configurations made from two individual Skyrmion clusters whose baryon numbers sum to 10, that is, 9 + 1, 8 + 2, 7 + 3, 6 + 4 and 5 + 5. None of these form the D4d configuration, nor that with D3h , suggesting — but not proving — that neither of them are the minimum energy solution, and are hence likely to be saddle points. However, it appears that it is possible to produce both the D3d and D3 configurations from collisions. In particular, the 7 + 3 relaxation appears to give the more symmetric D3d configuration, while all the others give one which only has D3 symmetry. We have already found solutions which we believe to be saddle points, for example, the B = 9 configuration with Td symmetry, but here we have evidence for a new phenomena — local minima. Given that there is no symmetry which can be invoked to explain why there might be degenerate minima, it seems likely that the energies of the two configurations must differ by a minute amount. As we shall discuss in Sec. 4, given the uncertainties we are unable to ascertain which is the global minimum.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
53
The reason that the rational map ansatz is so successful in describing Skyrmions is that they appear to prefer to be as sphericale as possible. Examination of the models of the associated polyhedra sheds some light on the preference of the rational map ansatz for the D4d and D3 configurations, which are very spherical, as opposed to the more elongated D3d configuration. It might be that this oddity is not reproduced in the full non-linear energy functional, and the configuration with D4d symmetry is impossible to reproduce. The phenomenon of many different configurations at a given baryon number, often with energies very close to the minimal value, is a feature of the fullerene hypothesis which one might have been able to predict since there are many possible polyhedra which contain 12 pentagons and 2B − 14 hexagons for B ≥ 9. The possibility of four-valent vertices and also trivalent configurations containing squares only make things worse. This was the main motivation for the choice of a simulated annealing algorithm as our minimization scheme for rational maps; a choice which appears to have been vindicated. It is also one reason why we have used two very different numerical techniques, the rational map approach and full field simulations, to try and confirm the results we obtain, thereby increasing the confidence that the solutions we construct are the global minima. Unfortunately, in this case we were unable to make a definitive identification of the minimum energy Skyrmion, S10 , but have presented evidence that it is one of two configurations which are almost indistinguishable. 3.3. B = 11 The minimum value at this charge is I = 161.1 and this is obtained from the D3h symmetric map R=
z 2 (1 + az 3 + bz 6 + cz 9 ) , c + bz 3 + az 6 + z 9
(3.5)
where a, b, c are real parameters, taking the values a = −2.47, b = −0.84, c = −0.13 at the minimum. The associated polyhedron (which corresponds to 36:13 in [14]) can be constructed by considering a hexagon to which 3 pentagons and 3 hexagons are connected alternately with a C3 symmetry. Each of the pentagons is part of a set of four fused together, each of which is placed in the C3 arrangement. Each of these is then connected to another hexagon, which is directly below the first one and can be thought of as being equivalent to the original one from the point of view of symmetry. The spaces in between are filled up with hexagons, the whole structure comprizing of 12 pentagons and 8 hexagons. eA
sensible quantification of how spherical a solution is might be to consider the eigenvalues of the moments of the baryon density. A distribution which is isotropic, and hence almost spherical, would have all the eigenvalues approximately equal, whereas a more elongated solution would have one which is substantially different to the other two.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
54
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
The exact same configuration was produced by the collision and then relaxation of two Lorentz-boosted B = 3 Skyrmions and a stationary B = 5 solution in a linear arrangement (3 + 5 + 3). Given that the fullerene hypothesis is clearly not the whole story for B = 9 and B = 10, it is reassuring that things get back on track at B = 11 with what appears to be the unique global minimum, S11 , being a fullerene type solution describable by the rational map ansatz. 3.4. B = 12 Considering all degree 12 maps the minimum is found to be I = 186.6 and this can be reproduced from a Td symmetric map constructed as follows. Decomposing 13 as a representation of T gives 13|T = 2A + A1 + A2 + 3F . Now let p± be the Klein polynomials [19] √ p± = z 4 ± 2 3iz 2 + 1 ,
(3.6)
(3.7)
associated with the vertices and faces of a tetrahedron. On applying the C3 generator contained in the tetrahedral group to these polynomials they acquire the multiplying factors p± 7→ e±2πi/3 p± . Thus, the degree 12 polynomials p3± are strictly invariant, forming a basis for the representation 2A in the above decomposition and the polynomials p2+ p− and p2+ p− are bases for the representations A1 and A2 respectively. Explicitly, the rational map R=
ap3+ + bp3− , p2+ p−
(3.8)
is Td symmetric for all real a and b, with the minimal value I = 186.6 obtained for a = −0.53, b = 0.78. We should note that there are other maps with Td symmetry (the denominator in (3.8) can be replaced by p3+ , for example), but it appears that all these have a larger value for I. As for B = 11, this fullerene-like configuration was reproduced in non-linear field theory simulations, this time from initially well-separated B = 7 and B = 5 solutions (7 + 5), allowing us to conclude that it is the unique S12 . The associated polyhedron (which corresponds to configuration 40:40 in [14]) is in some ways similar to the Td solution at B = 9: there being four pentagon triplets positioned on the vertices of a tetrahedron. Each of these triplets is completely surrounded by hexagons forming a polyhedron well-known in fullerene chemistry [14], where it is one of 40 configurations with 12 pentagons and 10 hexagons which are candidates for a C40 cage. 3.5. B = 13 The minimal map of degree 13, deduced from simulated annealing of general maps, has cubic symmetry, another with four-fold symmetry which is incompatible with
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
55
the fullerene hypothesis. It is interesting to note that the fullerene hypothesis would have predicted a trivalent polyhedron made from 12 pentagons and 12 hexagons. We have not discussed representations of the cubic groupf , O, so we shall describe the group theory of this example by embedding it into the tetrahedral group, whose representations were reviewed earlier. One finds that 14|T = 3E 0 + 2E10 + 2E20 ,
(3.9)
so there is a two parameter family of T maps associated with the first component in (3.9). Setting one of these parameters to zero extends the symmetry to O and results in the one parameter family of maps R=
z(a + (6a − 39)z 4 − (7a + 26)z 8 + z 12 ) , 1 − (7a + 26)z 4 + (6a − 39)z 8 + az 12
(3.10)
whose minimum occurs at a = 0.40 + 5.18i when I = 216.7. The associated polyhedron is in many ways similar to a cube comprizing of six pseudo-faces, each of which are made of four pentagons with a four-valent bond, very similar to those in the B = 9 configuration. Clearly, in order for the them to fit together, with all the other bonds being trivalent, each of these pseudo-faces must be rotated slightly relative to the one diametrically opposite, which removes the possibility of the reflection symmetries of the cube and, hence, the symmetry group Oh . The polyhedron comprises of a total of 24 pentagons, as opposed to the 12 pentagons and 12 hexagons that would have been expected had the fullerene hypothesis been correct for this charge. As we shall discuss in Sec. 5.2, this solution, which is reproduced in relaxation of a range of initially well separated clusters (3 + 7 + 3 and 12 + 1, for example), is rather special; it being obtainable via a multiple symmetry enhancement of a D2 fullerene polyhedron (probably from either configurations 44:75 or 44:89 in [14]). If a is real then the symmetry can be extend to Oh , but the minimum in this class is quite a bit higher at I = 265.1 for a = 7.2. This Skyrmion, which is probably a saddle point, has recently been computed in [24] from the relaxation of a single Skyrmion surrounded by 12 others in an initially face centred cubic array. The polyhedron associated with this configuration is more akin to the octahedron than the cube, comprising of eight triangular pseudo-faces. It contains mainly four-valent bonds; the only trivalent ones being placed in the centre of the pseudo-faces. There is a degree 13 map with D4d symmetry whose I value is extremely close to the minimal one, in fact I = 216.8. This map is R=
z(ia + bz 4 + icz 8 + z 12 ) 1 + icz 4 + bz 8 + iaz 12
(3.11)
where a, b, c are real and take the values a = −5.15, b = −50.46, c = 46.31 at the minimum. This Skyrmion looks similar to the O symmetric minimum, but it only f The
cubic symmetry group O is that of the octahedron/cube, without all the reflection symmetries contained in the full symmetry group Oh .
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
56
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
has two four-valent vertices as opposed to the six in the cubic configuration, and can be thought of as being an extension of the D4d configuration with B = 9. The two four valent bonds are part of two pseudo-faces forming the top and bottom, which are linked by eight copies of a single hexagon connected to a pentagon, alternately arranged pointing up and down, so that four hexagons and four pentagons connect to both the top and bottom pseudo-faces. This configuration contains 8 hexagons and 16 pentagons, breaks the GEM rules since the number of vertices is 42 rather than the predicted number 44 (the number of faces is still 24 ≡ 2(B − 1)) and can be created by a single symmetry enhancement of the same D2 fullerene as the O symmetric configuration (see Sec. 5.2 for details). Given the similarity of this configuration to the minimum, it is no surprise that the values of I are very close. We conclude, therefore, that S13 has O symmetry, can be approximated by the rational map (3.10), and that the GEM rules and the fullerene hypothesis breakdown at this charge as they did for B = 9. 3.6. B = 14 The minimizing map of degree 14 has only a relatively small symmetry, that of D2 . The map can be written in the form , 7 7 X X aj z 2j a7−j z 2j , (3.12) R= j=0
j=0
where a7 = 1 and a0 , . . . , a6 are complex parameters. The minimum is I = 258.5 which occurs when the parameters are those given in Table 3. This configuration has much less symmetry than any of the others previously described and the associated polyhedron is difficult to visualize in detail. It can be constructed by arranging the 12 pentagons in 4 sets of 3. The 4 sets should be split up into two pairs, each of which is connected by three hexagons, one in the gap between two pentagons on each side, and the other two either side of the first. The two pairs should then be connected by a band of a further 8 hexagons, making 14 in total. The configuration is of the fullerene type (it corresponds to configuration 48:144 in [14]) and is one of 192 possibilities containing 12 pentagons and 14 hexagons. Table 3. a0
The coefficients of the minimal D2 map with B = 14. a1
a2
a3
a4
a5
a6
Re(a)
0.8
−5.0
−3.0
−53.4
−15.2
−13.1
0.9
Im(a)
0.3
−13.5
3.7
−59.4
66.2
34.1
−11.6
Attempts to reproduce this solution by the relaxation of well-separated clusters have proved unsuccessful. We have tried initial conditions which comprise of 7 + 7,
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
57
Fig. 5. The baryon density isosurface and associated polyhedron of the B = 14 solution with C2 which is created during the collision of well-separated Skyrmion clusters. We believe this elongated solution to be the minimum energy Skyrmion at this charge.
12 + 2 and 13 + 1 and in each case the same configuration, shown in Fig. 5 was the end-product. This configuration has even less symmetry than the minimum energy rational map; it having just C2 symmetry. The associated polyhedron is almost impossible to describe due to the lack of symmetry suffice to say that it contains 12 pentagons and 14 hexagons, and corresponds to configuration 48:83g in [14]. Note that this Skyrmion is very elongated and so it is not surprising that the rational map approximation does not describe this configuration very well, since it assumes that the baryon density has the same angular distribution on concentric spherical shells. Presumably there is a rational map which describes a distorted, more spherical, version of this Skyrmion, but its I value will be larger than the minimal one. Unfortunately we are unable to find this rational map using simulated annealing since its symmetry group is contained within that of the minimizing map. We believe that S14 is the elongated configuration shown in Fig. 5, based on the fact that it was created easily in the collision of well-separated clusters. It is of the fullerene type, but at this stage we do not have a good description of it in terms of a rational map. In subsequent sections, when we use the rational map ansatz as the starting point for a quantitative investigation of Skyrmion properties we will be forced to use the D2 configuration instead of what we believe to be the minimum. However, this should not lead to substantial errors.
3.7. B = 15 Considering all degree 15 maps the minimum is found to be I = 296.3 which has tetrahedral symmetryh , T . To construct the map the relevant decomposition is 16|T = 2E 0 + 3E10 + 3E20 . g This
(3.13)
was identified by computing the pentagon index for the associated polyhedron and checking it against the Table in [14]. h As for the cubic group O, the group T is that of the tetrahedron, but without the reflection symmetries of Td .
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
58
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
At first sight it may appear that there is a one (complex) parameter family of tetrahedral maps corresponding to the 2E 0 component. However, this is not the case since this family of maps is degenerate, having common factors. From 8|T = 2E 0 + E10 + E20 ,
(3.14)
it follows that there is a one parameter family of degree seven tetrahedral maps (this family is constructed explicitly in [18]). Furthermore, 9|T = A + A1 + A2 + 2F ,
(3.15)
so there is a strictly invariant degree eight tetrahedral polynomial, which is given by p+ p− = 1 + 14z 4 + z 8 and is the vertex polynomial of a cube. A basis for the 2E 0 component of (3.13) is obtained by multiplying each basis polynomial for the 2E 0 component in (3.14) by p+ p− , and hence the corresponding map is degenerate, being only degree seven rather than 15. The 3E10 component in (3.13) does correspond to a genuine two (complex) parameter family of degree 15 tetrahedral maps. Using the methods described in [18] we find that this family of maps is given by R = p/q where √ p = i 3(1 + a − b)z 15 + (77 − 99a − 5b)z 13 √ + i 3(637 + 21a + 35b)z 11 + (1001 + 561a − 65b)z 9 √ + i 3(−429 + 99a + 45b)z 7 + (−1001 − 297a − 127b)z 5 √ − i 3(273 + 185a + 15b)z 3 + (115 + 27a + 5b)z ,
(3.16)
and q(z) = z 15 p(1/z). The value I = 296.3 is obtained when a = 0.16 + 2.06i, b = −4.47 − 8.57i. If a and b are both real then the symmetry extends to Td , but the minimum in this class is higher at I = 313.7, when a = 4.64, b = −20.45. The polyhedron associated with the T symmetric solution is of the fullerene type. It contains 12 pentagons and 16 hexagons which can be thought of as being arranged in 8 pseudo faces: 4 of these comprise of hexagon triples, whereas the other 4 can be made from a hexagon connected to 3 pentagons in a C3 arrangement. The 4 hexagon triples can be thought of as being placed on the vertices of a tetrahedron, and the other 4 pseudo-faces, which are connected to the others, can be thought of as being on the vertices of another tetrahedron which is not dual to the first, removing the possibility of reflection symmetries. There is no fullerene polyhedron with Td symmetry [14], and hence this configuration must contain four-valent bonds. In fact it contains more four valent bonds than trivalent ones, in an essentially similar way to the Oh configuration for B = 13. The T symmetric solution was reproduced in the relaxation of clusters containing 12 + 3 and 13 + 2, initially well separated, and hence we conclude that S15 has T symmetry, is of the fullerene type and can be reproduced by a rational map.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
59
3.8. B = 16 B = 16 is another interesting situation where it appears that the minimum energy rational map may not in fact be the minimum energy Skyrmion. The minimizing map of degree 16 has D3 symmetry which takes the form , 5 5 X X aj z 3j+1 a5−j z 3j , R= (3.17) j=0
j=0
where a5 = 1 and a0 , . . . , a4 are complex parameters. The minimum is I = 332.9 which is attained when the parameters take the values presented in Table 4. The associated polyhedron can be constructed by first taking two sets of 3 hexagons, each of which is almost flat. Now connect a total of 6 pentagons and 3 hexagons, in 3-fold cyclic order around the flat structure, such that each of the gaps between the original hexagons is filled by a pentagon flanked on one side by another pentagon and on the other side by a hexagon. A further 6 pentagons, split into 3 pairs are used to fuse the two halves; each of the pairs connecting sets of 2 pentagons. Within the structure, there are a number of symmetrically placed groupings of polygons which are exactly those which were found to lead to symmetry enhancement as observed for B = 9 and B = 13. However, in this case a close examination of the baryon density isosurface shows that all the bonds remain trivalent and the associated polyhedron is of the fullerene type, containing 12 pentagons and 18 hexagons. Table 4.
The coefficients of the minimal D3 map with B = 16. a0
a1
a2
a3
a4
Re(a)
5.4
−14.6
35.9
−125.2
−5.2
Im(a)
−0.4
−69.3
165.9
77.4
34.2
There exists a family of D2 symmetric rational maps with B = 16 of the form , 8 8 X X aj z 2j a8−j z 2j , (3.18) R= j=0
j=0
where a8 = 1 and a0 , . . . , a7 are complex parameters. The minimum in this class takes place when I = 333.4, very close to that with D3 , and the parameters take the values presented in Table 5. Since the solution has very little symmetry it is difficult to describe the associated polyhedron as for that with B = 14. It is of the fullerene type, comprising of 12 pentagons and 18 hexagons, and can be thought of being formed from two identical half shells, connected together. To construct each of the two shells, start with a hexagon and attach to it, in cyclic order, two pentagons, a hexagon, another two pentagons and another hexagon. Then connect a pentagon, pointing downwards to the edge of the two hexagons, and add three hexagons to each side connecting the two pentagons.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
60
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe Table 5.
The coefficients of the minimal D2 map with B = 16.
a0
a1
a2
Re(a)
0.0
−4.2
6.9
Im(a)
0.5
19.9
4.2
a3
a4
a5
a6
a7
39.8
−76.4
−201.0
−5.9
−9.7
−105.0
64.8
−41.0
27.8
−2.7
Given that there are at least two rational maps with very similar values of I, it is interesting to see if we can create them both via the relaxation of initial wellseparated clusters. To this end we have tried a number of different initial conditions (7 + 9, 12 + 4 and 13 + 3). In contrast to the B = 10 case where we were able to create both the D3 and D3d configurations, in each case the end-product of the relaxation process had D2 symmetry. This strongly suggests, but does not prove, that this is the global minimum energy solution and that the D3 configuration may be a saddle point solution. This is interesting since it suggests that the relative ordering of the D3 and D2 solutions is probably different when considering the full non-linear energy functional and that for the rational map ansatz. 3.9. B = 17 The case of B = 17 is interesting since it was conjectured in [5] on the basis of the fullerene hypothesis that there might exist a Skyrmion configuration of this charge with the same structure as that of Buckminsterfullerene, C60 , which comprises of 20 hexagons and 12 pentagons in an icosahedral configuration. This is well known as the standard design for a football since it is almost spherical, and also in civil engineering where it was championed by Buckminster Fuller as a candidate for a geodesic dome. It is the isolated pentagon structure (each pentagon is isolated by connecting it to 5 hexagons) with the lowest number of vertices, and appears to be the most stable carbon cage; it being the subject of much interest in chemistry in the recent past. An icosahedrally symmetric rational map was found in [18] and this exact same map is reproduced by minimizing over all degree 17 maps. The value I = 363.4 is given by the Yh symmetric buckyball mapi R=
17z 15 − 187z 10 + 119z 5 − 1 . z 2 (z 15 + 119z 10 + 187z 5 + 17)
(3.19)
Further confirmation that this is indeed the minimum energy configuration at this charge comes from non-linear field theory simulations. We have performed relaxations of initial configurations of 12 + 5, 13 + 4 and 5 + 7 + 5 all of which relax very quickly to the buckyball structure. [18] the value of I quoted for the B = 17 buckyball map was the result of a typographical error and should read 363.41, not 367.41.
i In
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
61
In addition to the buckyball map there is also a non-fullerene map which has a low value of I. This map has Oh symmetry, and again we shall describe its group theory construction by embedding it into the tetrahedral group. The tetrahedral decomposition in this case reads 18|T = 3E 0 + 3E10 + 3E20 ,
(3.20)
with the two-parameter family of T maps corresponding to the 3E 0 component, reducing to a one-parameter family of O maps by setting one of the two parameters to zero. If the remaining parameter is real then the symmetry extends to Oh and the map is given by R = p/q where p = (129 + a) + (2380 + 116a)z 4 + (24310 + 286a)z 8 + (6188 − 156a)z 12 + (17 + 9a)z 16 ,
(3.21)
and q(z) = z 17 p(1/z). The minimal Oh map in this class has I = 367.2 when a = 280.9. Given that Buckyball map is the minimum map with B = 17 and it is reproduced in the numerical field theory relaxations, we conclude that the fullerene hypothesis and the conjecture of [5] are spectacularly confirmed at this charge; S17 has Yh symmetry and the associated polyhedron is the buckyball. 3.10. B = 18 After the particularly high symmetry of the B = 17 solution, the minimizing map of degree 18 is relatively unremarkable having only D2 symmetry, and takes the form , 9 9 X X aj z 2j a9−j z 2j , R= (3.22) j=0
j=0
where a9 = 1 and a0 , . . . , a8 are complex parameters. The minimum value is I = 418.7 which is attained when the parameters take the values given in Table 6. The associated polyhedron, which is of fullerene type, but is not an isolated pentagon structurej , is difficult to describe to similar reasons to the B = 14 and B = 16 solutions with D2 symmetry. It contains 12 pentagons and 22 hexagons, and can best be described, as for B = 16, in terms of two half shells which fit together to create the whole polyhedron. Each shell can be created by first taking a hexagon and connecting to it, in cyclic order, two hexagons, a pentagon, two hexagons and another pentagon. Now connect a pentagon, pointing downward to each of the hexagons, then fill in the gaps, of which there are 6, with hexagons. Given the rather low symmetry of the minimum energy rational map, one might think that as, for example, with the cases of B = 14 and B = 16 that there might be some confusion. However, by relaxing initial conditions comprizing of 9 + 9 and j In
fact, no isolated pentagon structures exist with 12 pentagons and 22 hexagons [14].
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
62
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe Table 6. a0
The coefficients of the minimal D2 map with B = 18.
a1
a2
a3
a4
a5
a6
a7
a8
Re(a)
−0.1
−5.6
3.2
51.5
−35.9
−50.9
−168.6
−0.3
−10.8
Im(a)
−0.5
−16.4
−0.8
104.8
−73.2
10.7
51.4
−3.3
1.4
17 + 1 we have reproduced the D2 configuration. Hence, we conclude that S18 is of the fullerene type and can be well approximated by the D2 rational map above.
3.11. B = 19 The minimum value at degree 19 is I = 467.9 and is attained by a D3 symmetric map of the form , 6 6 X X aj z 3j+1 a6−j z 3j , R= j=0
(3.23)
j=0
where a6 = 1 and a0 , . . . , a5 are complex parameters given in Table 7. The associated polyhedron can be constructed by taking two sets of three hexagons which are almost flat. To each, connect a pentagon in the gap connecting two hexagons and another pentagon next to it connected to only one of the hexagons in the triple. These two structures are C3 symmetric and can be thought of as forming the top and bottom of the polyhedron. They are connected together by 9 sets of two hexagons, one which connects to the top and the other which connects to the bottom. This is a fullerene type polyhedron containing 12 pentagons and 24 hexagons. Table 7.
The coefficients of the minimal D3 map with B = 19. a0
a1
a2
a3
a4
Re(a)
5.2
Im(a)
0.9
−0.9
71.4
−325.4
−116.0
73.6
41.8
−96.7
95.9
a5 0.83 −32.5
There is a more symmetric map, with Th symmetry, whose I value is only slightly higher than the minimum at I = 469.8. Computing the relevant decomposition 20|T = 4E 0 + 3E10 + 3E20 ,
(3.24)
shows that there is a three parameter family of tetrahedral maps of degree 19 corresponding to the first component in (3.24). This family of maps is given by R = p/q where
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
63
p = (239 − 9b)z + (503a − 25c)z 3 + (−5508 + 460b)z 5 + (−1300a + 284c)z 7 + (−4862 − 286b)z 9 + (1794a + 210c)z 11 + (9996 − 196b)z 13 + (−484a + 44c)z 15 + (135 + 31b)z 17 + (−a − c)z 19 ,
(3.25)
and q(z) = z 19 p(1/z). The minimum in this family is Th symmetric with a = 5.5, b = 6.3, c = 37.3 and produces the I value given above. The associated polyhedron contains many four valent bonds and is most definitely not of the fullerene type. In fact a cursory glance at the configuration might convince one that the polyhedron has cubic symmetry with there being eight sets of three fused pentagons effectively situated at the corners of a cube. However, the two pentagons which are situated at the centre of each face break the cubic symmetry since they point alternately in different directions. In total the configuration comprizes of a total of 36 pentagons. The D3 configuration was reproduced in the collision and subsequent relaxation of 17 + 2 and therefore we conclude that it corresponds to S19 . It is of the fullerene type and can be approximated using the rational map (3.23). 3.12. B = 20 For B = 20 the minimum value is I = 519.6 and is reproduced by the D6d symmetric map R=
z 2 (ia + bz 6 + icz 12 + z 18 ) , 1 + icz 6 + bz 12 + iaz 18
(3.26)
with a = −16.8, b = −288.3 and c = 215.8. The associated polyhedron can be thought of as being created from two half shells connected together and rotated relative to each other by 30◦ to give D6d symmetry. Each half can be constructed from a single hexagon, surrounded by another six forming an almost flat hexagonal structure, which are then surrounded by 6 hexagons and 6 pentagons. The flat structure has 12 positions for attaching another polygon, 6 places to connect to one hexagon and 6 places to connect to two. The pentagons connect to two and the hexagons connect to one forming a structure which is of the isolated pentagon fullerene type (corresponding to configuration 72:1 in [14]). It contains 12 pentagons and 26 hexagons, was reproduced in the relaxation of 17+3 and, hence, we conclude that it is S20 . 3.13. B = 21 The B = 21 minimizing map is Td symmetric. From the decomposition 22|T = 3E 0 + 4E10 + 4E20
(3.27)
there is a three parameter family of T symmetric maps corresponding to the 4E10 component and this family of maps is given by R = p/q where
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
64
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
√ p = 1025 + 3a + b + c + i(210 + 890a + 74b − 10c) 3z 2 + (5985 + 6327a + 1433b − 75c)z 4 √ + i(54264 − 7752a − 680b + 392c) 3z 6 + (203490 + 5814a − 1598b + 690c)z 8 √ + i(352716 + 16796a + 2652b + 260c) 3z 10 + (293930 − 25194a + 442b + 130c)z 12 √ + i(116280 − 7752a − 1768b − 120c) 3z 14 + (20349 + 14535a + 221b − 243c)z 16 √ + i(1330 − 646a + 234b − 10c) 3z 18 + (21 + 51a + 13b + 9c)z 20 ,
(3.28)
and q(z) = z 21 p(1/z). The minimum of I = 569.9 is obtained when a = 20.8, b = −102.0, and c = 570.1, for which the symmetry extends to Td since a, b, c are all real. The associated polyhedron can be thought of in terms of four copies of two different pseudo faces, one set is placed on the vertices of a tetrahedron and the other on the vertices of a tetrahedron dual to the first. In this respect it is very similar to the Td configuration with B = 9, and different to the T configuration with B = 15. One set of pseudo faces comprise of a hexagon triple, whereas the others consists of a hexagon surrounded alternately by hexagons and pentagons. Note that this map is the latest in an infinite family of tetrahedral maps, corresponding to charges B = 6n + 3, where n = 0, 1, 2, 3, . . .. This is because 6n + 4|T = nE 0 + (n + 1)E10 + (n + 1)E20
(3.29)
so there is an n parameter family of tetrahedral maps corresponding to the middle component in the above. For n = 0, 2, 3 (B = 3, 15, 21) we have seen that this family includes the minimal map, and for n = 1 (B = 9) this family includes a map which is very close to the minimal value. Thus it seems possible that other members of this family will be minimal maps, for example, for B = 27, although this configuration must have only T symmetry if it is to be of the fullerene type and will therefore be similar to that with B = 15. This solution was reproduced in the relaxation of 17 + 4 and 20 + 1, and hence we conclude that it corresponds to S21 . It is of the isolated pentagon fullerene type (corresponding to configuration 76:2 in [14]), comprising of 12 pentagons and 28 hexagons and can be reproduced by the rational map (3.28).
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
65
3.14. B = 22 The minimum value at degree 22 is I = 621.6, obtained from a D5d symmetric map R=
az 2 + ibz 7 + cz 12 + idz 17 + z 22 , 1 + idz 5 + cz 10 + ibz 15 + az 20
(3.30)
where a = 24.8, b = −814.6, c = −2000.3, d = 320.3. The polyhedron associated with this configuration can be constructed in two halves, which fit together as with many of the solutions already described. To construct each half, take a pentagon and surround it by 5 hexagons. There are 10 places to position another polygon, 5 of which connect to two hexagons and 5 which connect to just one. Place 5 pentagons in the gaps connecting to two hexagons and 5 hexagons just connecting to one. Then place a further 5 hexagons, connecting to the pentagons. This configuration, which comprises of 12 pentagons and 30 hexagons, is of the isolated pentagon fullerene type (it corresponds to configuration 80:1 in [14]). For B = 22 we find that there is an interesting phenomenon in that an icosahedrally symmetric fullerene polyhedron exists [14], but no corresponding rational map generated Skyrmion. The Yh symmetric C80 fullerene is constructed in a similar manner to the D5d fullerene described above, except that one interchanges the pentagons and hexagons at the point at which there was a choice in inserting polygons into the 10 positions. It is easy to check that there are no Y symmetric rational maps of degree 22, since 23|Y contains only representations of dimension three and higher. Thus there are symmetric fullerene polyhedra which do not correspond to symmetric rational maps. This apparent puzzle can be understoodk by realizing that there are rational map generated Skyrmions whose baryon (and energy) density has more symmetry than the Skyrme field itself. As mentioned earlier, the baryon density of a Skyrmion is localized around the edges of a polyhedron with the face centres of the polyhedron given by the vanishing of the derivative of the rational map, or more accurately by the zeros of the Wronskian of the numerator and the denominator w(z) = p0 (z)q(z) − q 0 (z)p(z) ,
(3.31)
which is in general a degree 2B − 2 polynomial in z. For B = 22 the Wronskian is, therefore, a degree 42 polynomial, and although there are no Y symmetric degree 22 rational maps there is a Y symmetric degree 42 polynomial, given by the product of the Klein polynomials corresponding to the edges and vertices of an icosahedron [19]. Therefore, it appears that the existence of a symmetric fullerene polyhedron coincides with the existence of a rational map whose Wronskian has this symmetry, but that the existence of such a Wronskian does not imply the existence of a symmetric rational map itself. Fortunately, we have not encountered this situation in our study of minimal energy rational maps and Skyrmions for the other charges k We
thank Conor Houghton for pointing this out to us.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
66
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
we have studied, since it would make the problem of identifying and constructing a particular rational map a much more difficult exercise. There exists a family of D3 symmetric rational maps with B = 22 of the form , 7 7 X X aj z 3j+1 a7−j z 3j , (3.32) R= j=0
j=0
where a7 = 1 and a0 , . . . , a6 are complex parameters. The minimum value of I in this class of maps is I = 623.4, which is very close to that for the D5d . The coefficients at this minimum are presented in Table 8. This configuration, which is also of the the isolated pentagon fullerene type, corresponds to configuration 80:4 in [14]. It can be constructed by first taking two hexagon triples each of which are surrounded by 3 pentagons and 6 hexagons in a C3 arrangement, hexagons filling the gaps which connect to 2 of the hexagons in the original triples. Then connect 3 more pentagons to each ‘half’ in between each of the C3 symmetric hexagon triples. The two ‘halves’ should then be connected by a band of 12 hexagons around the centre, which is split up into 3 lots of 4 by the C3 symmetry. The whole polyhedron contains 12 pentagons and 30 hexagons, as for the D5d configuration. Table 8. a0
The coefficients of the minimal D3 map with B = 22. a1
a2
a3
a4
a5
a6
Re(a)
4.5
−75.4
−393.4
270.5
26.1
123.8
41.5
Im(a)
−3.2
54.9
62.3
391.5
872.7
−177.2
13.8
Relaxation of clusters containing 17 + 5, 20 + 2 and 21 + 1 all lead to the same structure, that with D3 symmetry. Therefore, we conclude that S22 is that approximated by the rational map (3.32). This removes, from the point of view of this paper at least, further motivation for attempting to create the Skyrmion with the Y symmetric baryon density isosurface. 3.15. Summary The main conclusion of this section on Skyrmion identification is that the fullerene hypothesis appears to apply for a wide range of charges, and that the rational map ansatz can be used to make a good approximation to the solutions. In particular, we have concludedl that SB is of the fullerene type for 7 ≤ B ≤ 22, except when B = 9 and B = 13. For these charges the associated polyhedron contains fourvalent bonds, but as we shall discuss in Sec. 5.2, even these solutions can be related to fullerene polyhedra via symmetry enhancement. Clearly, there is a strong correlation between the structure of multi-Skyrmions and that of fullerene polyhedra. l We
should note that we have also confirmed the results of [5, 18] for 1 ≤ B ≤ 8.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
67
For B = 17, B = 20, B = 21 and B = 22 where there are fullerene polyhedra in which all the pentagons are surrounded by just hexagons, this type of configuration is picked out as that with minimum energy. In fullerene chemistry the isolated pentagon isomers are thought to minimize energy by placing the pentagonal defects as far as possible from each other, and it likely that this also taking place here. It is interesting to speculate that these highly spherical, isolated pentagon configurations will be the minima at higher charge in a similar way to our suggestion of the fullerene hypothesis just on the basis of the B = 7, B = 8 minima and the B = 9 saddle point. Although there will no doubt be caveats, as we have reported in this paper for the fullerene hypothesis for B = 9 and 13, we believe they are likely to be the exception rather than the rule. Notwithstanding these successes we have turned up a few oddities. Firstly, we have seen that in the cases of B = 10, B = 14, B = 16 and B = 22, that the minimum energy rational maps might not be SB . For B = 10 the situation is particularly interesting since the minimum energy rational map is not of the fullerene type, yet only fullerenes are produced in the relaxation of initially well-separated clusters. While for B = 14 we have been unable to produce a rational map which accurately reproduces the configuration which is readily produced in the full relaxation, probably since it is elongated and has little symmetry. The cases of B = 16 and B = 22 are probably more mundane since the differences in the I values for the two fullerene-like configurations are very small, and it is not difficult to imagine that using I as the energy functional rather than the true energy manages to swap around the two configurations. These special cases vindicate our approach of using two different methods to make our identifications.
4. Skyrmion Energies It is usual when presenting numerically generated minimum energy Skyrmion configurations to discuss their energy. Before we present what we believe are good representations of the energies, we should just make a point that identifying the symmetry is probably a better way of judging success, rather than just this single number. In particular, making comparisons between different approaches for computing the energy presented in the literature is extremely hazardous, whereas the symmetry identification should be universal. The approach that we shall discuss here is based on using the full non-linear dynamics to relax a solution generated using the rational map ansatz for a given charge and symmetry. We have already seen that the rational map ansatz systematically over estimates the ratio of the energy to baryon number (E/B) for a given configuration and it is clear that the numerical relaxation is likely to reduce this somewhat. Specifically, we have performed relaxations on numerical grids for all the solutions listed in Table 1 and Table 2 with (a) ∆x = 0.02 and N = 100 and (b) ∆x = 0.01 and N = 200, both using Dirichlet (fixed) boundary conditions
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
68
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
Table 9. The results of relaxing the rational map solutions which minimize the function I. The first set correspond to N = 100 and ∆x = 0.02, while the second set have N = 200 and ∆x = 0.01. In both cases the profile function was set to be zero at r∞ = 10. Notice that the E/B values are very close for the two different size grids suggesting that this figure is universal with an error ±0.001. B
G
Edis
Bdis
E/B
Edis
Bdis
E/B
1
O(3)
1.1591
0.9407
1.2322
1.2137
0.9849
1.2322
2
D∞h
2.2335
1.8935
1.1796
2.3260
1.9726
1.1791
3
Td
3.2773
2.8573
1.1470
3.3960
2.9627
1.1462
4
Oh
4.2683
3.8091
1.1205
4.4265
3.9519
1.1201
5
D2d
5.3308
4.7708
1.1174
5.5199
4.9409
1.1172
6
D4d
6.3391
5.7230
1.1077
6.5692
5.9296
1.1079
7
Yh
7.3243
6.6889
1.0950
7.5766
6.9210
1.0947
8
D6d
8.3796
7.6441
1.0962
8.6690
7.9100
1.0960
9
D4d
9.4026
8.5984
1.0936
9.7322
8.8990
1.0936
10
D4d
10.4212
9.5579
1.0903
10.7826
9.8893
1.0903
11
D3h
11.4464
10.5129
1.0888
11.8457
10.8788
1.0889
12
Td
12.4533
11.4721
1.0855
12.8888
11.8723
1.0856 1.0834
13
O
13.4689
12.4304
1.0835
13.9311
12.8585
14
D2
14.5057
13.3819
1.0840
15.0139
13.8480
1.0842
15
T
15.5214
14.3403
1.0824
16.0635
14.8387
1.0825
16
D3
16.5274
15.2969
1.0804
17.0167
15.8283
1.0808
17
Yh
17.5275
16.2677
1.0774
18.1205
16.8185
1.0774
18
D2
18.5677
17.2152
1.0786
19.2134
17.8094
1.0788
19
D3
19.6234
18.1913
1.0787
20.2717
18.7951
1.0786
20
D6d
20.6414
19.1607
1.0773
21.3198
19.7781
1.0779
21
Td
21.7056
20.1351
1.0780
22.3781
20.7580
1.0780
22
D5d
22.7349
21.1146
1.0767
23.4183
21.7525
1.0766
at the edge of the grid. These two discretized grids have exactly the same spatial extent and so when computing the initial profile function for the rational map ansatz we have set the profile function to zero at r∞ = 10. The results of this extensive set of simulations are presented in Table 9 for the solutions which are the minimum energy rational maps with respect to the energy functional I and in Table 10 for the other critical points of I, some of which we have concluded in the previous section are, in fact, the minimum energy Skyrmions. The total simulation time — which is the number of timesteps multiplied by ∆t — for N = 100 is twice that for N = 200, although making an exact comparison can be misleading since the rate at which the relaxation takes place is somewhat arbitrary due to the periodic removal of kinetic energy. Suffice to say, in both cases we believe that we have run the code for long enough for it to settle down to the minimum. The first thing to notice is that the computed values of the baryon number for the discrete grid Bdis are less than the relevant integer; the value for N = 200 being
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps Table 10. B
69
Same as Table 9 but for the other saddle points of I listed in Table 2. G
Edis
Bdis
E/B
Edis
Bdis
E/B
9*
Td
9.4281
8.5935
1.0971
9.7636
8.8975
1.0973
10*
D3
10.4223
9.5592
1.0903
10.7826
9.8891
1.0904
10*
D3d
10.4171
9.5586
1.0898
10.7791
9.8890
1.0900
10*
D3h
10.4623
9.5548
1.0950
10.8308
9.8882
1.0953
13*
D4d
13.4674
12.4295
1.0835
13.9311
12.8585
1.0834
13*
Oh
13.6152
12.4264
1.0957
14.0939
12.8548
1.0964
15*
Td
15.5792
14.3429
1.0862
16.1226
14.8369
1.0867
16*
D2
16.5294
15.2964
1.0806
17.1092
15.8281
1.0809
17*
Oh
17.5351
16.2654
1.0781
18.1389
16.8215
1.0783
19*
Th
19.6461
18.1854
1.0803
20.2996
18.7935
1.0801
22*
D3
22.7455
21.1162
1.0772
23.4175
21.7509
1.0766
closer than that for N = 100. There are two possible sources for this error: the first is numerical discretization error from the computation of the spatial derivatives (and the resulting numerical integration) and the other is that the physical size of the box r∞ is not large enough to encompass the whole solution and we have underestimated the gradient energy. In order to understand which is the dominant effect we have repeated the same relaxations with r∞ = 20 (∆x = 0.02 and N = 200) for B = 1 − 4, 9, 13, 17 and the results are presented in Table 11 for a total simulation time which is exactly the same as that for ∆x = 0.02, N = 100 and r∞ = 10. The values of Bdis agree to the third decimal place for B = 1 − 4 with the agreement being less good for larger values of B. Clearly discretization error is the dominant effect for the small values of B, and the truncation error due to r∞ being finite becomes important as it increases. Remarkably, the value of Edis /Bdis appears to remain constant at the level of around ±0.001 for all the relaxations, irrespective of what is the main source of the Table 11. The results of relaxing the rational map solutions for selected charges using N = 200, ∆x = 0.02 and r∞ = 20. Notice that the numerical values are almost identical to those listed in Table 9 for the same value of ∆x. B
G
Edis
Bdis
E/B
1
O(3)
1.1587
0.9410
1.2314
2
D∞h
2.2324
1.8936
1.1789
3
Td
3.2748
2.8562
1.1466
4
Oh
4.2683
3.8095
1.1204
9
D4d
9.3906
8.5870
1.0936
13
O
13.4572
12.4197
1.0835
17
Yh
17.5511
16.2862
1.0777
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
70
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
error in computing the individual values for the sensible parameters ∆x and N that we have used. Therefore, the main conclusion we will draw from these simulations is the value of Edis /Bdis which we will equate with the true value of E/B. Clearly, knowledge of E/B to a certain level of accuracy allows one to compute the energy of the solution, EB , to the same level of accuracy, and the values of the energies based upon this hypothesis are presented in Table 12 and Table 13 for the minima of I and the other critical points respectively. For the subsequent discussions we will take the value of E/B to be that computed when ∆x = 0.01, N = 200 and r∞ = 10 subject to an assumed error of ±0.001, with the relative difference between adjacent values of B probably being even more accurate. This error budget is used to include the many other possible systematic uncertainties in computing E/B which have not already been discussed and the spread of the values computed.
Table 12. The actual computed energies, EB , of the solutions presented in Table 9 deduced from EB = B ∗ Edis /Bdis . B
G
E/B
EB
E/B
EB
1
O(3)
1.2322
1.2322
1.2322
1.2322
2
D∞h
1.1796
2.3592
1.1791
2.3582
3
Td
1.1470
3.4410
1.1462
3.4386
4
Oh
1.1205
4.4820
1.1201
4.4804
5
D2d
1.1174
5.5870
1.1172
5.5860
6
D4d
1.1077
6.6462
1.1079
6.6474
7
Yh
1.0950
7.6650
1.0947
7.6629
8
D6d
1.0962
8.7696
1.0960
8.7680
9
D4d
1.0936
9.8424
1.0936
9.8424
10
D4d
1.0903
10.9030
1.0903
10.9030
11
D3h
1.0888
11.9768
1.0889
11.9779
12
Td
1.0855
13.0260
1.0856
13.0272
13
O
1.0835
14.0855
1.0834
14.0842
14
D2
1.0840
15.1760
1.0842
15.1788
15
T
1.0824
16.2360
1.0825
16.2375
16
D3
1.0804
17.2864
1.0808
17.2928
17
Yh
1.0774
18.3158
1.0774
18.3158
18
D2
1.0786
19.4148
1.0788
19.4184
19
D3
1.0787
20.4953
1.0786
20.4934
20
D6d
1.0773
21.5460
1.0779
21.5580
21
Td
1.0780
22.6380
1.0780
22.6380
22
D5d
1.0767
23.6874
1.0766
23.6852
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
71
Table 13. The actual computed energies, EB , of the solutions presented in Table 10 deduced from EB = B ∗ Edis /Bdis . B
G
E/B
EB
E/B
EB
9*
Td
1.0971
9.8739
1.0973
9.8757
10*
D3
1.0903
10.9030
1.0904
10.9040
10*
D3d
1.0898
10.8980
1.0900
10.9000
10*
D3h
1.0950
10.9500
1.0953
10.9530
13*
D4d
1.0835
14.0855
1.0834
14.0842
13*
Oh
1.0957
14.2441
1.0964
14.2532
15*
T
1.0862
16.2930
1.0867
16.3005
16*
D2
1.0806
17.2896
1.0809
17.2944
17*
Oh
1.0781
18.3277
1.0783
18.3311
19*
Th
1.0803
20.5257
1.0801
20.5219
22*
D3
1.0772
23.6984
1.0766
23.6852
The precise values of E/B we have computed here differ from the those quoted for B = 1 − 9 in our earlier work [5]m , and for B = 1 − 4 in recent work which used a simulated annealing algorithm on the full field dynamics [15]. By making comparison with [5] at the level of accuracy suggested there (∼ 1%), we see that only the B = 2 and B = 3 are discrepant and then the difference is only of the order of an extra 1%, but that the actual values quoted are very different at the level of 3 decimal places. We believe the earlier method has a tendency to under estimate the true value of E/B since the value of the field at the boundary, which is kept fixed during the relaxation runs, is sensitive to the initial conditions, which are well-separated in contrast to the situation here. This is borne out on inspection of the E/B values computed for the relaxed solutions from well-separated clusters for large B used to identify the minima. The comparison with the results of [15] is less good, their results being systematically about 1% higher than those presented here and 2% higher than those of [5]. Although it is difficult to make strong conclusions, we believe that these higher values could well be a function of using periodic boundary conditions rather than fixed. This assumption was used to make their computed values of B almost exactly an integer, but it is clear that such an assumption will modify the scale of the solution. In particular, their quoted value for the energy of a single Skyrmion is larger than the known value (E = 1.232), and the solution assuming periodic boundary conditions with a domain of finite extent will be somewhat different. We should comment on the computed values of E/B for values of B where we have more than one rational map which is of low energy with respect to I. m Note
that the B = 9 solution of [5] had Td symmetry and so one should be careful to make the correct comparison.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
72
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
Previously in a number of cases (B = 10, 16 and 22) we had concluded that the minimum energy rational map is not necessarily the minimum energy Skyrmion and one might hope that the relaxation process might confirm this with their energies being separated by a significant amount. For B = 9, 15, 17 and 19 its clear that the computed values of E/B are systematically much higher for the solutions which are not minima of the energy functional I and therefore we conclude that these solutions are definitely not the minima of the full Skyrme energy functional (remember that on the basis of relaxation of wellseparated clusters we have concluded that the minima with respect to I are in fact the minima). For B = 13 the solution with D4d symmetry has exactly the same value as that with O, while that with Oh is much higher. It might seem remarkable that the values for the D4d and O symmetric solutions are exactly the same, but one should remember that the two solutions are very similar and can be related by symmetry enhancement (see Sec. 5.2). Since the O solution was produced from the relaxation of clusters and the I values for the two solutions are very close anyway, we conclude that the O solution is probably the minimum. For B = 10, 16 and 22, we are unable to tell the different candidate minima apart based on the computed energies since our quoted error of ±0.001 for each of the values of E/B encompasses the different solutions under consideration. For B = 10 the D3h solution is of higher energy and is clearly not the minima, but the other 3 are well within the range of uncertainty. This is also the case for B = 16 and B = 22, where each of the candidate minima are within the quoted range for E/B. In Table 14 we have summarized the computed values of E/B and EB for the solutions which we have identified as the minima in Sec. 3. Included also are the ionization energy IB = EB−1 + E1 − EB , the energy required to remove a single Skyrmion, and the binding energy per baryon given by ∆E/B = E1 − (E/B), which is the energy required to separate the solution up into single Skyrmions divided by the total baryon number. The accuracy of ∆E/B will be exactly that of the computed value of E/B since the value of E1 we compute by this method appears to be exact within the quoted limits, but the errors in computing IB could theoretically be larger since it is the difference of two energies. For B > 10 the worst case errors in computing IB could be as much as ±0.02 (a significant amount on inspection of the quoted values), but since we have already commented that we believe the difference in energies for adjacent values of B will be even more accurate than the absolute errors in the energy we suspect that things will be much better. We will comment on this in subsequent sections. The values of E/B computed for these relaxed solutions and also for the original rational map are plotted against B in Fig. 6. Both start at approximately the same value for B = 1, and both appear to asymptote for large B, albeit at different values. For the relaxed solutions this appears to be about 6–7% above the Faddeev–Bogomolny bound, which is compatible with that computed for the hexagonal Skyrme lattice [6], which can be thought of as the infinite limit of a shell-like
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
73
Table 14. A summary of the symmetry and energy of the Skyrmion configurations which we have identified as the minima. Included also is the ionization energy (IB ) — that required to remove one Skyrmion — and the binding energy per Skyrmion (∆E/B) — that is the energy required to split the charge B Skyrmion into B with charge one divided by the total number of Skyrmions. (*) These correspond to the minimum energy Skyrme solutions which are not minimum energy solutions within the rational map ansatz. (**) The values quoted for B = 14 are computed using the initial configuration with D2 symmetry since we have been unable to derive the rational map with C2 symmetry. B
G
E/B
EB
IB
∆E/B
1
O(3)
1.2322
1.2322
0.0000
0.0000
2
D∞h
1.1791
2.3582
0.1062
0.0531
3
Td
1.1462
3.4386
0.1518
0.0860
4
Oh
1.1201
4.4804
0.1904
0.1121
5
D2d
1.1172
5.5860
0.1266
0.1150
6
D4d
1.1079
6.6474
0.1708
0.1243
7
Yh
1.0947
7.6629
0.2167
0.1375
8
D6d
1.0960
8.7680
0.1271
0.1362
9
D4d
1.0936
9.8424
0.1578
0.1386
10*
D3
1.0904
10.9040
0.1706
0.1418
11
D3h
1.0889
11.9779
0.1583
0.1433
12
Td
1.0856
13.0272
0.1829
0.1466
13
O
1.0834
14.0842
0.1752
0.1488
14**
C2
1.0842
15.1788
0.1376
0.1480
15
T
1.0825
16.2375
0.1735
0.1497
16*
D2
1.0809
17.2944
0.1753
0.1513
17
Yh
1.0774
18.3158
0.2108
0.1548
18
D2
1.0788
19.4184
0.1296
0.1534
19
D3
1.0786
20.4934
0.1572
0.1536
20
D6d
1.0779
21.5580
0.1676
0.1543
21
Td
1.0780
22.6380
0.1522
0.1542
22*
D3
1.0766
23.6852
0.1850
0.1556
Skyrmion, while the asymptote for the rational map ansatz is higher at around 9%. The curve for the relaxed solutions is smoother than that for the rational maps, which has notable dips associated with the highly symmetric solutions with B = 4, 7, 13 and 17. Although these deviations from what appears to be approximately a smooth curve do not totally disappear after relaxation, one can deduce that the other solutions, not being particularly spherical, do not fit the rational map ansatz as well, but that the relaxation using the full non-linear field dynamics softens these effects. The binding energy per baryon, ∆E/B, is plotted against B in Fig. 7, its shape just being the inversion of Fig. 6. Interestingly, it increases to an asymptote just as
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
74
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe 1.25
1.2
1.15
1.1
1.05 0
5
10
15
20
B
Fig. 6. The computed values of E/B as a function of B for the configurations which we have identified as the minimum energy solutions, that is, those summarized in Table 14. The solid line is that after the process of relaxation, and the dashed line that from before, that is, the value for the appropriate rational map. For B = 14 where we have no rational map to represent the minimum energy solution we have used the values for the solution with D2 symmetry.
one might expect in a simple model of nuclei which excludes the Coulomb interaction within the nucleus. We shall return to this issue in Sec. 5.6. The ionization energy, IB , is plotted against B in Fig. 8. We have already commented that our quoted errors in E/B might lead to substantial errors in computing IB , but that systematic errors in computing the energy of a particular solution are likely to be similar and therefore our computed values for IB could probably be more accurate than one might naively expect. This is borne out by a cursory inspection of Fig. 8: we see that the most stable solutions with respect to the removal of a single Skyrmion are those with the most symmetry B = 4, 7 and 17, while those with the least symmetry B = 5, 8, 14 and 18 are much less stable. This is very much as one might expect.
5. Discussion There are some remarkable aspects of the solutions which we have created. In this section we point out, discuss and attempt to explain some of them.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
75
0.15
0.1
0.05
0 0
5
10
15
20
Fig. 7. As for Fig. 6, but ∆E/B is plotted instead of E/B. For large B the values appear to level out at around 0.15 − 0.16 as one might expect in a simple model of nuclei excluding the effect of the Coulomb interaction.
5.1. Platonic symmetries It had been known for sometime that Skyrmion solutions existed whose associated polyhedra are platonic solids (B = 3, 4 and 7) and it had been conjectured that the minimum energy solution with B = 17 had Yh symmetry. These platonic symmetry groups are the groups with the highest symmetry (most generators) which are discrete subgroups of O(3), the dihedral groups having considerably fewer generators. Here, we have shown that platonic symmetries are even more prevalent in Skyrmion solutions, be they minimum energy solutions B = 12, 13, 15 and 21, or low energy saddle points B = 9, 13, 15, 17 and 19. The existence of these solutions is truly remarkable. This could have been expected within the fullerene hypothesis since the platonic groups T and Y are compatible with the associated polyhedron comprising of pentagons and hexagons. But we have also seen that the existence of a highly symmetric fullerene polyhedron compatible with the fullerene hypothesis at a particular charge does not necessarily imply that it is a minimum energy configuration. In particular, tetrahedral fullerene structures are compatible with B = 13, 16 and 19, and the group theory decomposition is consistent with the existence of appropriate rational maps. However, in each of these cases the minimum energy Skyrmion has much less
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
76
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0 0
5
10
15
20
Fig. 8. As for Fig. 6, but IB is plotted instead of E/B. Notice that the most stable solutions are those with the most symmetry, B = 4, 7 and 17, while the least stable are those with little symmetry B = 5, 8, 14 and 18.
symmetry. Clearly, the solution being highly symmetric is not the sole criterion in minimizing the Skyrme energy functional. We have also encountered one case, icosahedral symmetry for B = 22, in which a platonic fullerene polyhedron exists, but no corresponding platonic rational map (and probably no Skyrmion either). However, it appears that a rational map exists (and hence a corresponding Skyrmion) for which the baryon density surface has more symmetry than the Skyrme field and is icosahedrally symmetric. But again this very symmetric structure appears not to be the minimum energy Skyrmion. For B > 7 the octahedral group is incompatible with the fullerene hypothesis since it requires four-fold symmetry which is impossible in a polyhedron comprising only of pentagons and hexagons. However, the minimum energy Skyrmion with B = 13 has O symmetry and we have also been able to find a Skyrmion with Oh symmetry with B = 17 which is a low-energy saddle point. Many such solutions in which there is a four-valent bond connecting 4 pentagons can be related to a fullerene polyhedron by symmetry enhancement as we shall discuss in the next section. This produces an extra twist to the fullerene hypothesis which allows octahedral Skyrmion solutions.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
77
5.2. Symmetry enhancement We have seen that, in keeping with the fullerene hypothesis and the expectations of [5], most links in the polyhedra associated with Skyrmion solutions are trivalent. In particular, the baryon density isosurface of what we have identified as the minimum energy solutions consist of a trivalent polyhedron for all cases except B = 9 and B = 13. In these two cases the polyhedra contain four-valent vertices which means that they are not fullerene Skyrmions, since by definition all links are trivalent. However, it turns out that these two exceptional cases can be obtained from fullerenes by the application of a simple rule, which we refer to as symmetry enhancement, and shall now explain. Consider part of a fullerene which has the form shown in the first figure in Fig. 9, consisting of two pentagons and two hexagons with a C2 symmetry. The symmetry enhancement operation is to shrink the edge which is common to the two hexagons (the thick line) until it has zero length, which results in the coalescence of two vertices. The final object formed is shown in the second figure in Fig. 9. It has a four-valent vertex connecting four pentagons and the symmetry is enhanced from C2 to C4 . We find, empirically, that symmetry enhancement operations appear to take place in pairs, with a particular operation always being accompanied by the same operation on an opposite face of the associated polyhedron.
Fig. 9. On the left is a configuration comprising of two pentagons separated by two hexagons. Such configurations are prevalent in many fullerene polyhedra. On the right is what can be created by a single symmetry enhancement operation as appears to take place for B = 9 and B = 13. It is usual for such an operation to be accompanied by a similar operation on a diametrically opposite face of the associated polyhedron.
There is a C28 fullerene with D2 symmetry (denoted 28:1 in [14]) that contains two of the structures shown in the first figure in Fig. 9. If the above symmetry enhancement operation is performed on both these structures then the resulting object is precisely the D4d configuration of the B = 9 Skyrmion described earlier. There are also D2 symmetric C44 (denoted 44:75 and 44:89 in [14]) fullerenes to which similar statements apply. In this case, which is B = 13, there are an equal number of pentagons and hexagons (12 of each) and so a very symmetric configuration can be
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
78
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
obtained by applying the symmetry enhancement operation at all possible vertices (in this case 6) which results in the cubic Skyrmion. Selective application of the symmetry enhancement rule to these fullerenes allows one to create the associated polyhedron for the D4d symmetric Skyrmion at this charge, and also that for a D4 symmetric Skyrmion, whose rational map we have been unable to deduce since the minimum energy rational map in this class of maps has D4d symmetry. In the context of fullerenes it is, of course, impossible for vertices to coalesce since they correspond to the positions of the carbon atoms, but for Skyrmions the vertices represent local maxima of the baryon density and so there is no restriction that they be distinct; it just appears that in most cases it is energetically favourable to have distinct vertices. Note that, by an examination of the baryon density isosurface by eye, it can often be difficult to identify whether a given vertex is tri-valent or four-valent, since the edge length required to be zero for symmetry enhancement could be small, but non-zero. 5.3. Vertices, faces and rational maps We will now attempt to explain the various features of the Skyrmions we have created by considering the basic properties of the rational map ansatz. Recall that the baryon density of a Skyrmion is localized around the edges of a polyhedron. The face centres of this polyhedron are given by the zeros of the Wronskian of the numerator and the denominator w(z) = p0 (z)q(z) − q 0 (z)p(z) ,
(5.1)
which is in general a degree 2B − 2 polynomial in z. All the solutions which we have created have the property that all the roots of (5.1) are distinct and hence within the rational map ansatz this is a vindication of one of the GEM rules, in that it explains why the number of faces of the polyhedron is F = 2B − 2. Often (though not always, as we shall discuss further below) the position of the vertices correspond to local maxima of the density which occur in the integrand defining I in equation (1.7). This density depends on the modulus of the rational map and its derivative so in general it is not possible to obtain such a simple characterization of the location of its maxima. However, in particularly symmetric cases they can be identified with the zeros of a polynomial constructed from the Hessian of the Wronskian [17]. Explicitly, the polynomial is H = (2B − 2)w(z)w00 (z) − (2B − 3)w0 (z)2 ,
(5.2)
and has degree 4(B − 2). As an example in which the above formula does work, consider the degree 7 rational map describing the icosahedrally symmetric minimal energy charge 7 Skyrmion [18] R=
z 7 − 7z 5 − 7z 2 − 1 . z 7 + 7z 5 − 7z 2 + 1
(5.3)
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
79
The Wronskian and the Hessian in this case are given by w = 28z(z 10 + 11z 5 − 1),
H = −8624(z 20 − 228z 15 + 494z 10 + 228z 5 + 1) , (5.4)
which are proportional to the Klein polynomials associated with the faces and vertices of a dodecahedron respectively [19]. Note that if the zeros of the Hessian (5.2) could always be identified with the vertices of the polyhedron then this would explain another of the GEM rules, that is, the fact that the number of vertices is equal to V = 4(B − 2). In this case the number of edges E = 6(B − 2) by the Euler formula, and hence E = 3V /2, that is, the polyhedron is trivalent. Unfortunately, this is not true in general, though for the minimal energy maps it may be the case that the zeros of (5.2) give good approximations to the positions of the maxima. We have already discussed explicit cases where the number of vertices and edges is affected by symmetry enhancement, and therefore it comes as no surprize that we cannot make general statements about the E, F and V based solely on the rational map ansatz. Although we do not have a general global characterization of the vertices it is possible, by a local analysis of the rational map, to check whether a given point is a local maximum and to obtain its valency.n By using the freedom to perform rotations of both the domain and target spheres it is always possible to choose the point we are considering to be given by z = 0 and the rational map to have a local expansion about this point of the form R = α(z + βz p+1 + O(z p+2 ))
(5.5)
where α and β are real positive constants. A possible exception to this is if the derivative of the map is zero at the point we are considering, but since such points correspond to face centres they are clearly not maxima and may be ignored for our purposes here. Substituting the expansion (5.5) into the expression for the baryon density one can obtain the following result. If p > 2 then z = 0 is a p-valent vertex if α > 1. If p = 1 then z = 0 is not a vertex. The remaining case of p = 2 is a little more subtle. In many cases there is a one-to-one correspondence between the vertices and the local maxima of the baryon density polyhedron. However, this is not always true and in some cases (the lowest charge example being B = 5) only some of the local maxima are vertices, whilst others correspond to midpoints of an edge. In this situation some of the edges may appear thicker than others, reflecting their local maxima nature. The rational map description of such a bivalent maximum is the final p = 2 case, where a local √ maximum requires the more restrictive condition that α > 1 + 3β. As an example of this analysis, consider the B = 9 map with D4d symmetry given by (3.1). Expanding this map about the point z = 0 gives R = az + ib(1 − a)z 5 + · · · n We
thank Nick Manton for suggesting this possibility.
(5.6)
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
80
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
which can be rotated into the form (5.5) with p = 4, α = −a = 3.38 > 1 and β = −b(1 − a). Thus the point z = 0 is a four-valent vertex, as we have observed from the baryon density plot. The other minimizing map with four-valent vertices (this time six of them) is the B = 13 O map (3.10), which can be checked in a similar way. 5.4. Isomerism — local minima and saddles We have argued strongly that there is an analogy between Skyrmion solutions and polyhedra found in carbon chemistry. Moreover, at some charges we have found more than one solution which has very low energy, and therefore it might seem sensible within the analogy to chemistry to describe these solutions as isomers, whether they be saddle point solutions or local minima.o In most cases, for example, B = 9, 16, 17, 19 and 22 the symmetries and structures of the known isomers are unrelated to those of the minimal energy Skyrmions and in these cases it has been easy to identify the minimum energy configurations using the relaxation of initially well-separated clusters. The cases of B = 10 and 13 are interesting since there are known configurations whose associated polyhedra are related by symmetry enhancement. We have already commented that the polyhedron associated with O symmetry at B = 13 can be created by 6 symmetry enhancement operations from a D2 fullerene polyhedron, and that with D4d symmetry requires just 2. However, we have not discussed the B = 10 solutions in this context. The D4d and D3h solutions do not appear to be related to this concept, but one can understand the D3 and D3d solutions in terms of a more symmetric polyhedron which can be created from either by 3 symmetry enhancement operations. Clearly, this highly symmetric configuration, which is likely to be of higher energy, can be thought of as a saddle point in configuration space, with the two minima on either side. It is interesting to speculate that the true minimum energy Skyrmion is more closely associated with a polyhedron in which partial symmetry enhancement has taken place, that is, the bond lengths have shrunk, but not totally to a four valent bond. This might explain our difficulty in identifying the symmetry of the true minima using our methods. 5.5. Skyrmion architecture One of the most important reasons for performing full field simulations in our study of Skyrmions is to verify that the minimal energy Skyrmion (at least for B ≤ 22) consists of a single shell structure, which is the main assumption in the rational map ansatz. In this section we speculate on the kinds of structures which may form for Skyrmions of higher charge. o The existence of degenerate minima, would probably require some kind of symmetry between the solutions. Although we cannot rule it out, it appears to be very unlikely.
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
81
The lowest known value for the energy per baryon in the Skyrme model arises from an infinite three-dimensional cubic crystal [9], with an energy [6] only 3.6% above the Faddeev–Bogomolny bound. In considering a large single-shell fullerene Skyrmion, where hexagons are dominant, the twelve pentagons may be viewed as defects, inserted into a flat hexagonal structure, in order to generate the required curvature necessary to close the shell. Energetically the optimum structure of this form is an infinite hexagonal lattice and this was constructed in one of our earlier papers [6], and found to have an energy per baryon which is 6.1% above the Faddeev–Bogomolny bound. This is therefore the value to which a bigger and bigger single-shell structure will asymptote. Since this value is higher than for the Skyrme crystal it is reasonable to expect that above some critical charge B ? , the minimal energy Skyrmion will resemble a portion cut from the crystal rather than a single shell. However, it is very difficult to estimate the value of B ? (note that we have seen that at least B ? > 22) since it relies on a delicate comparison of the surface to volume energy of a finite portion of the crystal and this is very sensitive to the way in which the portion of the crystal is smoothed off at the edges. As the crystal is basically composed of stacking B = 4 cubes together then B = 32 is the first charge at which any sizeable chunk of the crystal can emerge, and even then it has a large area to volume ratio, so perhaps the charge will need to be even larger than this before a crystal regime takes over from the shell regime. An intermediate between a single-shell and a crystal is a multi-shell structure and this has recently been studied by Manton and Piette [24]. For the charges they consider (B = 12, 13, 14) the relaxation of an initial multi-shell structure produces a single-shell configuration which has relatively high energy in comparison with the minimal energy single-shell Skyrmions we have found. As a shell may be thought of as a spherical domain wall, connecting the two vacua U = ±1, then all configurations with an odd number of shells have U = −1 at the centre, whereas if there are an even number of shells then U = 1 at the centre. Thus a single shell structure obtained from an initial odd number of shells can relax to one of the configurations we have found. In fact, as we have already mentioned, the B = 13 Skyrmion obtained by Manton and Piette is the Oh symmetric saddle point solution whereas the minimal energy Skyrmion is only O symmetric. In summary, there are a number of alternatives to a single-shell structure for higher charge Skyrmions and what is remarkable is that none of these alternatives appear to arise at least for B ≤ 22. It seems reasonably clear that single-shells can not be the whole story for large enough charge, but whether this charge is so large as to be irrelevant in applications to nuclear physics has yet to be determined.
5.6. Relation to applications In the introduction we commented on two diverse motivations for creating Skyrmion solutions, namely from a purely mathematical point of view, to study an interesting class of maps between 3-spheres which generalize the harmonic map equations,
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
82
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
and from a physical perspective to investigate a phenomenological model of nuclei. Here, we comment briefly on the relevance of our results to these two applications and suggest interesting avenues for future research which we have opened up with this work. We have already noted that the Skyrme model is the simplest model in which one finds stable solitonic solutions which correspond to maps from S 3 to S 3 , and so our solutions may have some generality to other extensions. An interesting feature of the solutions which we have found is that, in some sense, they can be thought of as being close to a conformal map between the two 3-spheres, for which the three eigenvalues of the strain tensor, λ21 , λ22 , λ23 , would all be equal. The rational map ansatz, which we have seen provides a good approximation to the true solutions, has two of these eigenvalues equal and it has been observed [22] that the shape of the profile function appears to be such that the deviation from a conformal map is minimized when averaged over space. For a conformal map which is locally an isometry the values of E and B would be exactly equal and so any deviations from the map being locally isometric can be visualized by plotting E − B. When one does this the relevant isosurface is highly localized around the edges of the associated polyhedron and also in the centre of each face where B is close to zero and E is large in comparison. Such an isosurface is a plot of second order effects due to curvature. The fact that the associated polyhedra are generally of the fullerene type is also interesting because in chemistry such structures arise since they minimize what is called steric strain, the overall strain of the delocalized electron distribution. Using this analogy we suggest that the effects of the strain tensor for maps between 3-spheres can be thought of as being analogous to steric strain in fullerene molecules. Finally, we should note that the existence of a Skyrmion with a particular symmetry, which can be described by a rational map, implies that there also exists an SU(2) BPS monopole with the same symmetry, although, of course, all BPS monopoles of a given charge have the same energy. The fields and Lagrangians of monopoles and Skyrmions are very different but the structures which arise in each case are remarkably similar. This suggests that these types of configurations may be generic as low energy states in a variety of 3-dimensional soliton models and elsewhere. Although the original motivation for studying the Skyrme model was to make quantitative predictions for the properties of nuclei based on a model which is derived in some limit from QCD, this has historically been a tricky business. Our hope, based on the extensive results that we have presented here, is that some progress can be made in this direction. Part of the problem in achieving such a goal is how one should understand the model in the context of nuclei. Based on the idea that it is a low energy effective action for QCD several studies have attempted to quantize Skyrmion solutions as rigidly rotating spinning tops for B = 1, 2 and 3 (see, for example, [1, 10, 11]) quantifying corrections in terms of their position in the 1/Nc expansion. This is not only complicated but probably is also too simplified
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
83
an approach, as demonstrated by the more sophisticated quantization of the B = 2 Skyrmion in [23]. Here we would like to make a few interesting points in terms of thinking of the solitons as a phenomenological model for nuclei which incorporates classical isospin. The first thing that we would like to discuss is the shell structure of the soliton solutions which we have created. Naively, one might think that such a structure is incompatible with the solutions modelling nuclei which are usually assumed to be solid lumps. What one has to appreciate to reconcile this is, that until the solutions are quantized, the charge can be thought of as a fluid. If a nuclei were assumed to be comprised of a simple positively charge fluid then a shell structure would be expected under the action of the strong force since there is a long range, but weak, attraction at long distances, and a short distance repulsion due to nucleon-nucleon repulsion. Therefore, the hollow shell structure of the multi-Skyrmions which we have observed is largely due to the continuum version of nucleon-nucleon repulsion. Following on from this point we should note that some of the features of the classical values of IB , the ionization energy, are very much in line with expectations based on nuclei. Let us focus in detail on the solutions for B = 4 and B = 5. The B = 4 solution is highly symmetric and I4 is relatively large, whereas the B = 5 solution has little symmetry and I5 is much smaller. This is exactly as one might have expected since 4 He is the most stable nucleus whereas there is no naturally occurring stable nucleus with A = 5. Since the packing structure of the solutions is a feature of the symmetry of the solution this suggests that there may be something even more than just a good model of the strong force potential within the Skyrme model. There is also an interesting trend in ∆E/B, the classical binding energy per baryon, which appears to asymptote to a value defined by that of an infinite Skyrmion lattice. We have plotted this compared to the experimentally determined values for nuclei with A = 1 to 22 [12, 16] in Fig. 10 with an arbitrary normalization factor (which amounts to multiplying the curve in Fig. 7 by about 50) accounting for our ability to define the Skyrmion energy units. Although this is crude, it makes the point that the curve has the correct shape. This is very encouraging and is the subject of on-going research. Since the fullerene polyhedra are clearly very important for our understanding of Skyrmions, and as we have just argued there are a number of appealing features of the model for explaining the properties of nuclei, it is tempting to make an analogy between the delocalized electron distributions in fullerenes and nuclear charge distributions. Although the analogy is not exact, it might be possible to relate the Skyrme model to density functional theory methods (see, for example, [25]) used in the study of electron distributions.
6. Conclusion We have performed an exhaustive study of minimal energy Skyrmions for all charges upto B = 22, using a variety of methods and involving a substantial amount of CPU
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
84
00106
R. A. Battye & P. M. Sutcliffe
Fig. 10. The binding energy per baryon number for Skyrmions (solid line) compared, using an arbitrary scaling, to the binding energy per nucleon of real nuclei (dashed line). The main thing that one should note is that the approximate shape, an increase to a plateau, is present in both.
time on a parallel machine. At each charge we have discussed in detail the symmetry, structure and energy of the minimal energy Skyrmion (and often several others) in addition to providing an approximate description by presenting its associated rational map. Supplementary to the detailed investigation at specific charges we have found a number of interesting general phenomena. These include the verification of the fullerene hypothesis, which applies to all except two cases (which can be understood in terms of symmetry enhancement), the discovery that there are often several Skyrmions with very different symmetries from the minimal one but nonetheless have energies which are remarkably close to the minimal value, and finally the confirmation that the shell-like structure of Skyrmions continues to large charges (at least B = 22) with the rational map ansatz providing an effective approximation to the true solution. Hopefully this comprehensive piece of work will provide a useful foundation for further studies on Skyrmions, both mathematical and physical, with the ultimate aim being a comparison with experimental data on nuclei. Acknowledgments Many thanks to Conor Houghton, Nick Manton and Tom Weidig for useful discussions. We thank the EPSRC (PMS) and PPARC (RAB) for Advanced Research
December 27, 2001 15:22 WSPC/148-RMP
00106
Skyrmions, Fullerenes and Rational Maps
85
Fellowships. PMS acknowledges the EPSRC for the grant GR/M57521. The parallel computations were performed on the COSMOS at the National Cosmology Supercomputing Centre in Cambridge. References [1] G. S. Adkins, C. R. Nappi and E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B228 (1983) 552. [2] S. L. Altmann and P. Herzig, Point-Group Theory Tables, Clarendon Press, 1994. [3] M. F. Atiyah and N. J. Hitchin, The Geometry and Dynamics of Magnetic Monopoles, Princeton University Press, 1988. [4] R. A. Battye and P. M. Sutcliffe, Phys. Lett. 391B (1997) 150. [5] R. A. Battye and P. M. Sutcliffe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79 (1997) 363. [6] R. A. Battye and P. M. Sutcliffe, Phys. Lett. 416B (1998) 385. [7] R. A. Battye and P. M. Sutcliffe, “Solitonic fullerenes”, to appear in Phys. Rev. Lett. [8] E. Braaten, S. Townsend and L. Carson, Phys. Lett. 235B (1990) 147. [9] L. Castillejo, P. S. J. Jones, A. D. Jackson, J. J. M. Verbaarschot and A. Jackson, Nucl. Phys. A501 (1989) 801. [10] L. Carson, 66 (1991) 1406. [11] L. Carson, Nucl. Phys. A535 (1991) 479. [12] W. N. Cottingham and D. A. Greenwood, An Introduction to Nuclear Physics, Cambrige University Press, 1986. [13] W. Y. Crutchfield and J. B. Bell, J. Comp. Phys. 110 (1991) 234. [14] P. W. Fowler and D. E. Manolopoulos, An Atlas of Fullerenes, Clarendon Press, 1995. [15] M. Hale, O. Schwindt and T. Weidig, Phys. Rev. E62 (2000) 4333. [16] P. E. Hodgson, E. Gadioli and E. Gadioli-Erba, Introductory Nuclear Physics, Oxford University Press, 1997. [17] C. J. Houghton, private communication. [18] C. J. Houghton, N. S. Manton and P. M. Sutcliffe, Nucl. Phys. B510 (1998) 507. [19] F. Klein, Lectures on the Icosahedron, London, Kegan Paul, 1913. [20] V. B. Kopeliovich and B. E. Stern, JETP Lett. 45 (1987) 203. [21] H. W. Kroto, J. R. Heath, S. C. O’Brien, R. F. Curl and R. E. Smalley, Nature (London) 318 (1985) 354. [22] S. Krusch, Nonlinearity 13 (2000). [23] R. A. Leese, N. S. Manton and B. J. Schroers, Nucl. Phys. B442 (1995) 228. [24] N. S. Manton and B. M. A. G. Piette, hep-th/0008110 (2000). [25] I. Zh. Petkov and M. V. Stoitsov, Nuclear Density Functional Theory, Clarendon Press, 1991. [26] B. M. A. G. Piette and W. J. Zakrzewski, J. Comp. Phys. 145 (1998) 359. [27] T. H. R. Skyrme, Proc. Roy. Soc. A260 (1961) 127. [28] P. M. Sutcliffe, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A12 (1997) 4663. [29] P. J. M. Van Laarhoven and E. H. L. Aarts, Simulated Annealing: Theory and Applications, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1997. [30] J. J. M. Verbaarschot, Phys. Lett. 195B (1987) 235. [31] E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B223 (1983) 422.
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 1 (2002) 87–119 c World Scientific Publishing Company
EDGE CURRENT CHANNELS AND CHERN NUMBERS IN THE INTEGER QUANTUM HALL EFFECT
J. KELLENDONK, T. RICHTER and H. SCHULZ-BALDES∗ Fachbereich Mathematik, Technische Universit¨ at Berlin, Straße des 17. Juni 136, 10623 Berlin, Germany ∗Department
of Mathematics, University of California at Irvine, Irvine, California, 92697, USA
Received 8 December 2000 Revised 22 May 2001 A quantization theorem for the edge currents is proven for discrete magnetic half-plane operators. Hence the edge channel number is a valid concept also in presence of a disordered potential. Under a gap condition on the corresponding planar model, this quantum number is shown to be equal to the quantized Hall conductivity as given by the Kubo–Chern formula. For the proof of this equality, we consider an exact sequence of C∗ -algebras (the Toeplitz extension) linking the half-plane and the planar problem, and use a duality theorem for the pairings of K-groups with cyclic cohomology.
1. Introduction In quantum Hall effect (QHE) experiments, one observes the quantization of the Hall conductance of an effectively two-dimensional semiconductor in units of the universal constant e2 /h [29, 38]. As the Hall conductance is a macroscopic quantity, this effect is of completely different nature than any quantization in atomic physics resulting from Bohr–Sommerfeld rules. Although also a pure quantum effect, the quantum numbers of the QHE rather turn out to be global topological invariants of the underlying magnetic Hamiltonian. These invariants become apparent only in the strong localization regime. For an explanation of the integer QHE, the only situation studied in this work, a one-particle framework is widely excepted to be sufficient. The three main existing theoretical approaches are respectively based on the Laughlin Gedankenexperiment [31], on the edge channel picture introduced by Halperin [26] and B¨ uttiker [15] and on the Kubo–Chern formula for the Hall conductivity first derived by TKN2 [43]. Laughlin’s argument was rigorously analyzed by Avron, Seiler, Simon and Yaffe even for multiparticle Hamiltonians and in presence of a disordered potential [6, 8, 7]. Bellissard [9, 10] and Kunz [30] and others [12, 2] generalized the TKN2 work in order to show quantization of the Hall conductivity also in presence of a disordered potential as long as the Fermi level lies in a region of dynamically 87
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
88
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
localized states. The mathematical connection between these two works is well understood [7, 12, 2]. Although several recent works concern boundary conditions for magnetic half-plane operators [4] as well as spectral questions for these operators [32, 21, 25], there was up to now no microscopic mathematical theory of edge channel conduction, except for the case without disorder, of course. Furthermore, a conceptual understanding of the link of bulk and edge theory was lacking even though the beautiful work of Hatsugai [27, 28] was an important step in this direction. The results of this work, announced in [42], fill these gaps. For a description of our main results in a particular case, let HH : `2 (Z2 ) → 2 ` (Z2 ) denote the Harper Hamiltonian describing the motion of a tight-binding electron in a plane submitted to a constant (but arbitrary) magnetic flux per unit cell (see Sec. 2.1 for its definition). Further let V be an Anderson type disorder potential, then we consider the stochastic Hamiltonian H = HH + V . In presence of an external electric field, all extended states below the Fermi level undergo the b (β, µ) at inverse temperaLorentz drift. The associated (bulk) Hall conductivity σ⊥ ture β and Fermi energy µ is calculated in linear response theory by the Kubo b b (µ) = σ⊥ (∞, µ) is equal to a constant formula. The main result of [12, 2] is that σ⊥ 2 integer multiple of q /h as long as the Fermi level µ varies in a given interval ∆ of dynamically localized states (q is the particle charge and h Planck’s constant). In particular, if ∆ is a gap of the spectrum of H, the conclusion holds. The appearing integer is actually given by the Chern number of the Fermi projection Pµ of H. It is hence a topological invariant of the planar model. In a macroscopic Hall bar, there is now another conduction mechanism by edge currents. For a classical two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG), the cyclotron orbits are intercepted by the boundary and this leads to a net current along the boundary. In order to calculate the corresponding quantum mechanical edge current, ˆ of H to the half-plane Hilbert space `2 (Z × N), we will study the restriction H together with a given boundary condition. All operators on the half-plane will carry ˆ be the electrical current operator a hat throughout this work. Let Jˆx = qı[X, H]/~ along the boundary (here X is the position operator of the direction parallel to the ˆ on an interval ∆ ⊂ R. The edge boundary) and Pˆ∆ the spectral projection of H current carried by the states in ∆ is then given by j e (∆) = Try Tx (Pˆ∆ Jˆx ) ,
(1)
where Tx the disorder averaged trace per unit volume parallel to the boundary and Try the trace in the direction perpendicular to the boundary. Note that the calcultion of edge currents is mere equilibrium quantum mechanics: no electric field, linear approximation or dissipation mechnism is needed. Our main result is then the following: Theorem 1.1. Let ∆ be a gap of the (almost sure) spectrum of H = HH + V in which the integrated density of surface states µ ∈ ∆ 7→ Try Tx (Pˆ[inf(∆),µ] ) is
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
89
continuous. Then, for any interval ∆0 ⊂ ∆, one has almost surely 1 b (µ) |∆0 | , j e (∆0 ) = −σ⊥ q
∀µ ∈ ∆,
where |∆0 | denotes the length of ∆0 . The theorem states that the edge channel number in the sense of [26, 15] of a magnetic Hamiltonian in the half-plane remains a valid concept in presence of a disordered potential, and that this number is moreover equal to the Chern number of the planar Hamiltonian. In the following we will call the limit of the quotient e (µ) at µ. It is well −qj e (∆)/|∆| as ∆ → {µ} also the edge Hall conductivity σ⊥ known [15] that its quantization can only hold for a magnetic operator on a semiinfinite space because for a strip geometry the backscattering, notably tunneling from upper to lower edge, will destroy quantization. For the unperturbed Landau Hamiltonian HL , the continuous analog of the ˆ L has operator H theorem just states that in the nth gap of HL , the half-plane R ˆ ˆ exactly n bands (compare Fig. 1). In fact, if HL = R dkx HL (kx ) is the Bloch decomposition in the x-direction and Ej (kx ) are the corresponding edge channels, then for an interval ∆ in the nth gap, one has Z qX dEj (kx ) q dkx χ(Ej (kx ) ∈ ∆) = − n|∆| , j e (∆) = h dk h x R j≥0
where χ denotes the characteristic function. For the Harper Hamiltonian HH , the theorem asserts that the sum of the Chern numbers of the lowest n bands is equal to the number of edge channels within the nth gap (also Dirichlet bands in [27]) of the half-plane operator multiplied by their orientation. In the commensurate case of rational flux per unit cell, this result is due to Hatsugai [27, 28]. His proof
E
E
kx
−π
kx
+π
ˆ L (solid lines), Fig. 1. l.h.s.: schematic representation of the spectrum of the half-plane operator H ˆ H , the solid lines are the Dirichlet the dashed lines show the Landau bands; r.h.s.: spectrum of H bands and the shaded regions are the Bloch bands (for numerical results, see [27]).
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
90
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
is completely unrelated to ours though and cannot be generalized to a situation with broken translation invariance due to either an irrational magnetic flux or to a disordered potential. Our proof of the above theorem splits into two parts. In the first purely analytic step, we consider only half-plane operators and prove that the edge Hall conductivity is equal to the Fredholm index of a certain unitary operator. This can be viewed at as an odd index theorem resulting from a pairing between an odd cyclic cohomology class with the K1 -class of the above unitary operator. Similarly, the quantized Kubo–Hall conductivity is given by a pairing of a certain even cyclic cohomology class with the K0 -class defined by the Fermi projection. These two pairings are over two different C∗ -algebras which are linked by a short exact sequence called the Toeplitz extension [37]. In the second step, we use the K-theoretic six-term exact sequence of the Toeplitz extension as well as its dual K-homologic counterpart to prove the equality of the pairings. This duality theorem unveals that the equality of edge and bulk Hall conductivities is a consequence of a fundamental topological concept, namely of Bott periodicity. Hence this work fully exploits (and thereby justifies) the use of the non-commutative C∗ -algebraic framework developed by Bellissard [9]. Let us now comment on variations and generalizations of the above theorem. First of all, its continuous counterpart is under preparation. It uses the Wiener–Hopf rather than the Toeplitz extension [17, 14] and the duality theorem corresponding to Connes’ Thom isomorphism [24]. Further we believe the consequences of the theorem to hold under the weaker condition that ∆ is an interval containing only dynamically localized states of H. Under precisely this condition it is possible to prove quantization of the bulk Hall conductivity [12]. The gap condition imposed above only allows to deal with the weak disorder regime (unsufficient in order to ˆ has purely absolutely conexplain the QHE). In this regime the Hamiltonian H tinuous spectrum as show positive commutator estimates for the boundary current operator. In fact, the arguments of [21] directly transpose to our discrete case as long as the edge bands of the free magnetic operator have a definite sign. This also implies continuity of the integrated density of surface states. In the regime of intermediate disorder, the gaps of H fill with dynamically localized states. In presence of a boundary, the tunnel effect to the edge states should turn all these localized states into resonances so that we expect the spectrum to remain absolutely continuous. At the same time, the edge channel number should remain an integer equal to the Chern number of the Fermi projection of the planar model. In the high disorder regime, the system completely localizes [33, 3]; in between there is a cascade of metal-insulator transitions [12]. The article is organized as follows. In Sec. 2, we develop the mathematical framework, then state our main results more precisely in Sec. 3. In Sec. 4 we prove the edge current quantization. Only in Sec. 5 we then use a K-theoretic duality theorem in order to show the equality between edge and bulk Hall conductivities.
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
91
This duality theorem was stated by Nest [34], but his proof is technically complicated and incomplete. Using a result by Pimsner [36], the appendix gives a new and transparent proof in a less general situation than the one considered in [34]. For a discussion of the underlying physics, we refer to [26, 38, 15, 16, 42]. 2. Observable Algebras In this section we explicitly construct the observable algebras as the Toeplitz extension of a twisted crossed product. For further details and for physical motivation of the following definitions and subsequent constructions, we refer to [9, 11, 12, 41, 13]. 2.1. Homogeneous operators and their hull As in [13] we define the (geometric) hull of a tight-binding operator in absense of a magnetic field. This seems more adapted than its definition in [12] because the use of magnetic translations leads to a non-trivial hull even for a free magnetic operator as the Harper Hamiltonian (for the Landau Hamiltonian on continuous physical space this problem does not appear due to its invariance w.r.t. all magnetic translations). Definition 2.1. Let U0 (a), a ∈ Z2 , denote the translations on `2 (Z2 ) defined by U0 (A)ψ(n) = ψ(n − a) for n ∈ Z2 and ψ ∈ `2 (Z2 ). Consider a self-adjoint bounded operator H : `2 (Z2 ) → `2 (Z2 ) of the form X Hn,m |ni hm| , Hn,m ∈ R , H= n,m∈Z2
where hm| and |ni are the usual bra-ket notations for states localized at m ∈ Z2 and n ∈ Z2 . Then H is called homogeneous if the set {U0 (a)HU0 (a)∗ |a ∈ Z2 } has a compact closure Ω in the strong operator topology. By continuity, U0 extends to an action T of Z2 on Ω. The dynamical system (Ω, T, Z2 ) is then called the hull of H. Example 2.2. Let H0 be translation invariant, that is U0 (a)H0 U0 (a) = H0 for all 2 a ∈ Z2 . A typical example is the discrete Laplacian. Let further Ω = [−1, 1]⊗Z be endowed with the Tychonov topology as well as the shift action T of Z2 . Let us denote by Vω : `2 (Z2 ) → `2 (Z2 ) the Anderson-type onsite potential corresponding to the disorder configuration ω ∈ Ω, namely Vω |ni = ωn |ni where ω = (ωn )n∈Z2 . We fix an invariant and ergodic probability measure P on Ω with the property P({ω ∈ Ω|ωn ∈ I}) > 0 for all n ∈ Z2 and all intervals I ⊂ [−1, 1] of non-vanishing length. Then, for P-almost all ω ∈ Ω, the operator Hω = H0 + λVω , λ ∈ R, is homogeneous and its hull is equal to (Ω, T, Z2 ). A proof of this fact can be found in [13]. From a mathematical point of view, this article is about the analysis of certain topological invariants of the dynamical system (Ω, T, Z2 ). Associated to it is the
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
92
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
C∗ -dynamical system (C(Ω), α, Z2 ) where (αa f )(ω) = f (T −a ω) for a continuous functions f ∈ C(Ω). This gives rise to a natural C∗ -algebra, the twisted crossed product [35] with a twisting given by the group cocycle Z2 × Z2 → S 1 : (a, b) 7→ θ a ∧ b mod(2π) where a ∧ b = ax by − ay bx and θ = qB/~ is the magnetic flux per unit cell. This algebra has a natural extension, the Toeplitz extension. If moreover an ergodic probability measure P on Ω is given, we have a W∗ -dynamical system (L∞ (Ω, P), α, Z2 ) with an associated von Neumann crossed product [35]. This also has a Toeplitz extension. These exact sequences describe the link between magnetic operators in the plane and in the half-plane. 2.2. Algebraic twisted crossed product and its Toeplitz extension The magnetic translations in symmetric gauge U (a), a = (ax , ay ) ∈ Z2 , are defined by ı θ a ∧ n ψ(n − a) , n = (nx , ny ) ∈ Z2 , ψ ∈ `2 (Z2 ) , U (a)ψ(n) = exp 2 where a ∧ n = ax ny − ay nx and θ = qB/~ is the flux per unit cell. U is a projective unitary representation of the group Z2 on `2 (Z2 ), namely ı θ a ∧ b U (a)U (b) . U (a + b) = exp 2 We denote by Ux = U (1, 0) and Uy = U (0, 1), then Uy Ux = eıθ Ux Uy . The C∗ -algebra generated by Ux and Uy is called the rotation algebra Aθ . Now we explicitly construct the algebraic twisted crossed product and its Toeplitz extension. The formulas below are chosen such that the magnetic translation U (a) is the representation of the function (ω, n) 7→ δn,−a . Let A0 = Cc (Ω × Z2 ) be the continuous complex valued functions on Ω × Z2 with compact support. With the following definitions, A0 becomes a ∗-algebra (A, B ∈ A0 , ω ∈ Ω, m ∈ Z2 ): P ı θl∧m , AB(ω, m) = l∈Z2 A(ω, l)B(T −l ω, m − l) exp (2) 2 A∗ (ω, m) = A(T −m ω, −m) . Further let E0 = Cc (Ω × Z × N × N) and T (A)0 = E0 ⊕ A0 . As E0 and T (A)0 will describe half-plane operators, their elements will carry a hat. In order to simultaneously define the ∗-algebra structure on E0 and T (A)0 , we identify elements (Aˆ1 , A2 ) ∈ T (A)0 with a function Aˆ ∈ C(Ω × Z × N × N) by means of the formula (mx ∈ Z, ny , my ∈ N): ˆ mx , ny , my ) = Aˆ1 (ω, mx , ny , my ) + A2 (ω, mx , my − ny ) . A(ω,
(3)
ˆ B ˆ ∈ T (A)0 , the product and involution are then defined by For A, X ˆ lx , ny , ly )B(T ˆ (−lx ,ny −ly ) ω, mx − lx , ly , my ) ˆ A(ω, AˆB(ω, m x , n y , my ) = (lx ,ly )∈Z×N
· exp
ı θ(lx (my − ny ) − mx (ly − ny )) , 2
(4)
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
ˆ (−mx ,ny −my ) ω, −mx , my , ny ) . Aˆ∗ (ω, mx , ny , my ) = A(T
93
(5)
ˆ 0) ∈ Let us further introduce the inclusion i : E0 → T (A)0 sending Aˆ ∈ E0 to (A, T (A)0 as well as the projection π : T (A)0 → A0 defined by ˆ mx , k, my + k) , ˆ π(A)(ω, mx , my ) = lim A(ω, k→∞
Aˆ ∈ T (A)0 .
(6)
ˆ = A2 if Aˆ = (Aˆ1 , A2 ) ∈ T (A)0 . One directly verifies π(A) Lemma 2.3. The following sequence of ∗-algebras is exact: 0 → E0 −→ T (A)0 −→ A0 → 0 . i
π
In particular, i and π are ∗-morphisms satisfying Im(i) = Ker(π). We point out that this exact sequence of ∗-algebras is never split exact even though it is split exact as an exact sequence of vector spaces. More precisely, there does not exist a ∗-morphism ρ : A0 → T (A)0 such that ρ ◦ π = 1. Proof of Lemma 2.3. First of all, i : E0 → T (A)0 is clearly a ∗-morphism because the operations (4) and (5) are the same in E0 and T (A)0 and moreover leave E0 invariant in T (A)0 = E0 ⊕ A0 . Let us check that π is also a ∗-morphism (Aˆ = ˆ = (B ˆ1 , B2 ) ∈ T (A)0 ): (Aˆ1 , A2 ), B X X ˆ lx , k, ly ) ˆ A(ω, π(AˆB)(ω, mx , my ) = lim k→∞
lx ∈Z ly ≥0
ˆ −(lx ,ly −k) ω, mx − lx , ly , my + k) · B(T ı θ(lx my − mx (ly − k)) . · exp 2 ˆ1 ∈ E0 have compact support, they will vanish for k suffiNow because both Aˆ1 , B ciently big. Then we make the change of variables ly ↔ ly − k and write out the identification (3): X X ˆ A2 (ω, lx , ly )B2 (T −(lx ,ly ) ω, mx − lx , ly − my ) π(AˆB)(ω, mx , my ) = lim k→∞
lx ∈Z ly ≥−k
· exp
ı θ(lx my − mx ly ) . 2
Now because A2 has compact support, we can replace the summation over ly ≥ −k by that over ly ∈ Z for k sufficiently large. Comparing with (2) we see that ˆ = B2 . The identity π(A) ˆ ∗ = π(Aˆ∗ ) ˆ = π(A)π( ˆ B) ˆ as π(A) ˆ = A2 and π(B) π(AˆB) can be immediately checked. This moreover shows that Im(i) = Ker(π). A0 will be called the bulk algebra, T (A)0 its Toeplitz extension and E0 the edge algebra. The algebra A0 and its various completions will describe operators which are homogeneous in the plane, E0 models operators which are homogeneous along the boundary (x-direction), but compact in the y-direction perpendicular to the
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
94
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
boundary, whereas T (A)0 contains both of these operators, notably homogeneous half-plane operators with compact boundary contributions. By means of the following formulas, we introduce two families of physical repˆω , ω ∈ Ω, of the ∗-algebras A0 and T (A)0 on `2 (Z2 ) and resentations πω and π 2 ` (Z × N) respectively (both n = (nx , ny ) and m = (mx , my ) are in Z2 or Z × N respectively): ı θ n ∧ m , A ∈ A0 , (7) hn|πω (A)|mi = A(T −n ω, m − n) exp 2 and ˆ ˆ −n ω, mx − nx , ny , my ) exp = A(T hn|ˆ πω (A)|mi
ı θn∧m , 2
Aˆ ∈ T (A)0 .
(8)
ˆω are ∗-morphisms from A0 and T (A)0 to It is elementary to verify that πω and π the algebras of bounded operators on `2 (Z2 ) and `2 (Z× N) respectively and further that the following covariance relations hold (a = (ax , ay ) ∈ Z2 ): U (a)πω (A)U (a)∗ = πT a ω (A) ,
ˆ (ax , 0)ˆ ˆU ˆ (ax , 0)∗ = π ˆ U πω (A) ˆT (ax ,0) ω (A)
(9)
ˆ (0, ay ) only ˆ denotes the restriction of U to `2 (Z × N). Covariance under U where U holds for ay ≥ 0; for ay < 0 there are corrections by operators in E0 . 2.3. Exact sequence of C∗ -algebras Using these representations, we can now introduce semi-norms on A0 and T (A)0 (A ∈ A0 and Aˆ ∈ T (A)0 ): kAk = sup kπω (A)k ,
ˆ = sup kˆ ˆ . kAk πω (A)k
ω∈Ω
(10)
ω∈Ω
It is elementary to verify that these are C∗ -norms. The C∗ -algebras A, T (A) and E are defined to be the closure of A0 , T (A)0 and E0 with respect to these norms. Now, because any ∗-morphism between pre-C∗ -algebras can be extended by continuity to ˆω extend to covariant representations their C∗ -closures, the representations πω and π of the C∗ -algebras and furthermore Lemma 2.3 leads to an exact sequence of C∗ algebras: 0 → E −→ T (A) −→ A → 0 . i
π
(11)
We note that A is the twisted crossed product C(Ω) ×T Z2 of the dynamical system (Ω, T, Z2 ) associated with the magnetic twisting introduced above. The structure of this exact sequence will be further analysed in Sec. 2.6. Example 2.4. Let us consider this exact sequence explicitly for the case of the rotation algebra Aθ , namely the C∗ -algebra generated by the unitary operators ˆx and U ˆy which still Ux and Uy . Then the Toeplitz extension is generated by U ıθ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆx remains ˆ satisfy the same commutation relation Uy Ux = e Ux Uy , but while U P ∗ˆ ∗ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ unitary, Uy satisfies Uy Uy = 1 and Uy Uy = 1 − Π0 where Π0 = l∈Z |l, 0i hl, 0|.
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
95
The edge C∗ -algebra is given by the C∗ -tensor product C(S 1 ), notably the C∗ ˆx , with the compact operators K in y-direction (modulo the algebra generated by U ˆx,y ) = gauge transformation discussed in Sec. 2.6). The projection is given by π(U Ux,y . The following proposition shows that the Hamiltonian which we started out with is in the C∗ -algebra A. For its proof we refer the reader to [11, 12]. ˜ is a homogeneous bounded self-adjoint operator on Lemma 2.5. Suppose that H 2 2 ˜ ≤ c|n − m|−2 for ` (Z ) the off-diagonal coefficients of which fall off like |hn|H|mi| 2 some constant c > 0. Let (Ω, T, Z ) be its hull. Then there exists an H ∈ A and a ˜ ω0 ∈ Ω such that πω0 (H) = H. 2.4. Von neumann algebra and its extension Let P be a probability measure on Ω which is invariant and ergodic with respect to both Tx and Ty . We suppose that its topological support is all of Ω. All our results hold for any such measure. We now construct the (twisted) von Neumann crossed product L∞ (A, P) of the W∗ -dynamical system (L∞ (Ω, P), T, Z2 ) by the standard procedure [35, 19] using the direct integral representation: Z ⊕ dP(ω)πω : A → B(L2 (Ω × Z2 , P ⊗ λ)) , πΩ = where λ is the counting measure on Z2 and B(H) denotes the algebra of bounded operators on the Hilbert space H = L2 (Ω× Z2 , P⊗ λ). Then L∞ (A, P) is defined as the weak closure of πΩ (A) in B(H). Elements of L∞ (A, P) are weakly-measurable (in ω) covariant operator families [19, 11] and can hence be described by measurable functions on Ω × Z2 satisfying A(ω, n) → 0 as |n| → ∞. We continue to use the notation πω for the (fiberwise) representation of these functions on `2 (Z2 ). The C∗ -norm on L∞ (A, P) is given by kAk∞ = P-ess sup kπω (A)k . ω∈Ω
∗
Similarly, one can construct the W -crossed product L∞ (C(Ω)×αx Z, P) of the W∗ dynamical system (L∞ (Ω, P), αx , Z) where (αx f )(ω) = f (Tx−1 ω) for f ∈ L∞ (Ω, P). Elements therein can be represented by functions on Ω × Z. Let L∞ (E, P)0 denote the finite dimensional matrices with entries in L∞ (C(Ω)×αx Z, P). We can represent elements of L∞ (E, P)0 as measurable functions on Ω × Z × N × N. Set further L∞ (T (A), P)0 = L∞ (E, P)0 ⊕ L∞ (A, P). Using the identification (3), the formulas (4) and (5) introduce an algebraic structure on L∞ (E, P)0 and L∞ (T (A), P)0 . Using again the fiberwise representations π ˆω identifying the functions on Ω × Z × N × N with operators on B(L2 (Ω × Z × N, P ⊗ λ)), a C∗ -norm on both of these algebras is given by ˆ , ˆ ∞ = P-ess sup kˆ πω (A)k kAk ω∈Ω
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
96
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
and the closure w.r.t. this norm define the C∗ -algebras L∞ (E, P) and L∞ (T (A), P). Finally the inclusion i and projection π on the pre-C∗ algebras L∞ (E, P)0 and L∞ (T (A), P)0 can be defined as in (6) and be extended by continuity to the C∗ -closures, giving rise to another exact sequence of C∗ -algebras. 2.5. Non-commutative analysis tools The algebra L∞ (A, P) admits a differential structure generated by a two-parameter group ρk , k = (kx , ky ) ∈ T 2 = [−π, π)×2 , of ∗-automorphisms (A ∈ L∞ (A, P) and m = (mx , my ) ∈ Z2 ): ρk (A)(ω, m) = exp(ı(kx mx + ky my ))A(ω, m) .
(12)
~ = (∇x , ∇y ) are densely defined and explicitly The associated ∗-derivations ∇ given by ∇x A(ω, m) = ımx A(ω, m) ,
∇y A(ω, m) = ımy A(ω, m) ,
(13)
~ = (X, Y ) denotes the posiwhenever the right hand sides are in L∞ (A, P). If X 2 2 tion operators on ` (Z ), then one can verify for such differentiable operators the identities: ~ ~ . = ı[πω (A), X] πω (∇(A))
(14)
Similarly, there is a two-parameter family of ∗-automorphisms ρˆk on L∞ (T (A), P) given by ˆ mx , ny , my ) = exp(ı(kx mx + ky (my − ny ))A(ω, mx , ny , my ) . ρˆk (A)(ω,
(15)
~ˆ ˆ y ). They satisfy identities ˆ x, ∇ The associated ∗-derivations are denoted ∇ = (∇ n similar to (14). For n ∈ N, we define C (A) to be those elements for which all nth order gradients are in the C∗ -algebra. Given an invariant and ergodic probability measure P with support Ω, a normalized faithful trace T on L∞ (A, P) is defined by [35] Z dP(ω)A(ω, 0) , A ∈ L∞ (A, P) . (16) T (A) = Ω
T is the trace per unit volume [11, 12]. For p ∈ [1, ∞), the Banach space Lp (A, P) is defined as the closure of A0 under the norm kAkp = (T (|A|p ))1/p . If πGNS is the GNS representation of A on L2 (A, T ) associated with the state T , then the von Neumann algebra πGNS (A)00 where 00 is the bicommutant can easily be seen to ˆ = be isomorphic to L∞ (A, P) [19]. A trace Tˆ on L∞ (T (A), P) is given by Tˆ (A) ˆ ˆ T (π(A)). However, T is obviously not faithful. Let now L∞ (T (A), P)+ denote the cone of positive operators in L∞ (T (A), P) and define TˆE : L∞ (T (A), P)+ → [0, ∞] by X Z ˆ = ˆ 0, my , my ) . (17) TˆE (A) dP(ω)A(ω, my ∈N
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
97
Using covariance, one sees that TˆE is the disorder averaged trace per unit volume in the x-direction, followed by the usual trace in the y-direction. Clearly TˆE is a weight, ˆ = TˆE (A) ˆ + λTˆE (B) ˆ for all A, ˆ B ˆ ∈ L∞ (T (A), P)+ and λ ≥ 0. namely TˆE (Aˆ + λB) ∗ ˆ for all Aˆ ∈ L∞ (T (A), P). Moreover one can directly check that TˆE (AˆAˆ ) = TˆE (Aˆ∗ A) Hence TˆE is a trace [22]. In particular, it is unitary invariant, that is for all Aˆ ∈ ˆ ∈ L∞ (T (A), P) one has TˆE (U ˆ AˆU ˆ ∗ ) = TˆE (A). ˆ L∞ (T (A), P)+ and unitary U ∞ ˆ As usual (e.g. [22, 35]), one now says that an operator A ∈ L (T (A), P) is ˆ < ∞. The set of all TˆE -trace-class operators form an ideal TˆE -trace-class if TˆE (|A|) ∞ in L (T (A), P) onto which TˆE can be extended. Further let us define Lp (E, P) ˆ p = (TˆE (|A| ˆ p ))1/p . The ideal of as the closure of E0 with respect to the norm kAk 1 ∞ ˆ TE -trace-class operators is then L (E, P) ∩ L (E, P). It can be directly verified that the traces T and TˆE are invariant under the automorphism groups ρk and ρˆk respectively. Thus for any A ∈ C 1 (A) and any Aˆ ∈ L1 (E, P) ∩ C 1 (E): T (∇x,y A) = 0 ,
ˆ = 0. ˆ x A) TˆE (∇
(18)
2.6. Iterated crossed product and Landau gauge Let C(Ω)×αx Z be the C∗ -crossed product without twisting [35] of the C∗ -dynamical system (C(Ω), αx , Z) where (αx f )(ω) = f (Tx−1 ω) for f ∈ C(Ω). Elements of C(Ω) ×αx Z can be represented by continuous functions on Ω × Z. This C∗ -algebra inherits a dynamics by the action αy defined by (αy f )(ω, mx ) = exp(−ıθmx )f (Ty−1 ω, mx ) ,
f ∈ C(Ω) ×αx Z .
∗
Hence we obtain an iterated crossed product C -algebra C(Ω) ×αx Z ×αy Z. Its elements are given by functions on Ω × Z2 and the multiplication is explicitly given by X A(ω, l)B(T −l ω, m − l) exp(ıθly (lx − mx )) , AB(ω, m) = l∈Z2
mimicking the Landau gauge. The iterated crossed product has a Toeplitz extension w.r.t. the action αy in the sense of Pimsner and Voiculescu [37] and this extension turns out to be isomorphic to the exact sequence (11): ψ
0 → C(Ω) ×αx Z ⊗ K −→ ρ
0 →
↓
κ i
π
−→ C(Ω) ×αx Z ×αy Z → 0
T ↓
η π
−→ T (A) −→
E ∗
↓
A
(19) → 0.
Here ⊗K denotes the C -algebraic tensor product with the compact operators on `2 (N) and ψ, π and T are the mappings and the Toeplitz extension as defined in [37]. In fact, it is elementary to verify that ı ˆ (0,ny ) ω, mx , ny , my ) , ˆ θmx (my + ny ) A(T (20) (ρA)(ω, mx , ny , my ) = exp 2
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
98
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
and
(ηA)(ω, m) = exp
ı − θmx my A(ω, m) , 2
(21)
are (gauge) isomorphisms. As it is not used later on, we do not write out a explicit formula for κ here. 3. Main Results ˆ = (K, ˆ H) ∈ T (A) be some lift of the planar (stochastic) self-adjoint HamilLet H tonian H ∈ A. For the representation corresponding to the disorder configuration ω, this means: ˆ = Ππω (H)Π + π ˆ , ˆω (K) π ˆω (H) ˆ to where Π denotes the projection from `2 (Z2 ) onto `2 (Z × N). We suppose K have non-zero entries only a finite distance from the boundary (see Sec. 4.1 for more precise and general hypothesis). Choosing such a lift means that we fix some boundary condition for the operator on the half-plane which is homogenous in the x-direction. Following the discussions in the introduction, let us now define the edge Hall conductivity as follows: e (µ) = − σ⊥
q2 ~
lim ∆→{µ}
1 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ TE (P∆ ∇x H) . |∆|
(22)
Recall (see e.g. [20]) that the spectrum of πω (H) is P-almost surely independent of ω. Our results below show that, under the two hypothesis that (i) H ∈ C 3 (A) and (ii) ∆ is within gap of the spectrum of H (it is well-known that the spectrum of πω (H) as a set is P-almost surely independent of ω ∈ Ω; this condition is equivalent to ask ∆ to be in a gap of the density of states), the operator Pˆ∆ ∈ L∞ (E, P) is in the ideal of TˆE -trace-class operators. Further we let Πx denote the projection in `2 (Z × N) onto `2 (N × N), namely the subspace spanned by the states |mx , my i with mx ≥ 0. ˆ ∈ Theorem 3.1. Suppose that H ∈ C 3 (A) is a self-adjoint element and H C 3 (T (A)) some self-adjoint lift of it. Let the closed interval ∆ ⊂ R be in a gap of the spectrum of H. Suppose that µ ∈ ∆ 7→ TˆE (Pˆ[inf(∆),µ] is continuous. Set ! ˆ − E0 H ˆ (∆) = exp −2πı Pˆ∆ , E 0 = inf(∆) . (23) U |∆| ˆ (∆))∗ Πx is P-almost surely a Fredholm operator on Then the operator Πx πω (U 2 ` (N × N) and its index is P-almost surely constant. For any µ ∈ ∆, its value is equal to the edge Hall conductivity: e (µ) = σ⊥
q2 ˆ (∆)∗ )Πx |`2 (N×N) ) . Ind(Πx πω (U h
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
99
The second main result of this work concerns the equality of the edge Hall b (µ) at Fermi energy conductivity to the zero-temperature bulk Hall conductiviy σ⊥ µ of a gas of independent fermions described by a one-particle Hamiltonian H ∈ A. Because the Lorentz drift is diffusive and non-dissipative, Kubo’s formula allows to calculate it in the zero-dissipation limit [12]. The following is sufficient for our present purposes: Proposition 3.2 ([12, Corollary 2]). Suppose that H ∈ C 1 (A) and that the Fermi level µ is in a gap of the spectrum of H. Then the bulk Hall conductivity b (µ) at zero temperature and zero dissipation is σ⊥ b (µ) = σ⊥
q2 2πıT (Pµ [∇x Pµ , ∇y Pµ ]) . h
(24)
Theorem 3.3. Under the same hypothesis as in Theorem 3.1, b e (µ) = σ⊥ (µ) , σ⊥
(25)
for any µ ∈ ∆. Their common value is constant in ∆ and equal to an integer multiple of q 2 /h. The Hall conductivity can either be calculated by the index in Theorem 3.1 or by that of reference [12]. Hence this work gives another alternative proof of the quantization of the bulk Hall conductivity, once one accepts (24) as its definition. 4. Edge Current Theory 4.1. Trace-class property near the Fermi surface The following summability result will be used in the next section. It also implies that the edge current is actually a well-defined mathematical quantity under a gap condition on the plane operator. The precise conditions on the boundary condition ˆ = (H, K) ˆ are the following: of H ˆ 2 ∈ C 3 (E) and there is an L < ∞ such that for all ω ∈ Ω: ˆ =K ˆ1 +K Hypothesis: K ˆ 1 )|mx , my i = 0 for ny > L , πω (K hnx , ny |ˆ ˆ 2 )|mx , my i = 0 for my > L . πω (K hnx , ny |ˆ Let further the x-sign operator on `2 (Z × N) be defined by X |mx , my i = sgn(mx )|mx , my i |X| ( mx ≥ 0 , |mx , my i , = mx < 0 , −|mx , my i ,
(mx , my ) ∈ Z × N .
ˆ satisfies the ˆ = (K, ˆ H) ∈ C 3 (T (A)) where K Proposition 4.1. Suppose that H above hypothesis. Let the interval ∆ ⊂ R be contained in a gap of the spectrum of πω (H) for all ω ∈ Ωg where P(Ωg ) = 1. Let f be a real C 4 -function supported
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
100
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
ˆ ∈ C 3 (E) ∩ L1 (E, TˆE ) and moreover the Hilbert–Schmidt norm of in ∆. Then f (H) X ˆ ˆω (f (H))] on `2 (Z × N) is uniformly bounded for all ω ∈ Ωg . the operator [ |X| , π Proof. First recall that every operator A ∈ C γ (A) satisfies |hn|πω (A)|mi| ≤
c , 1 + |n − m|γ
(26)
where we use the notation |n − m|γ = |nx − mx |γ + |ny − my |γ . A similar bound ˆ ∈ C 3 (T (A)) and f is a C 4 -function, we holds for operators in C γ (T (A)). As H 3 ˆ ∈ C (T (A)) (this follows from a straightforward generalization deduce that f (H) ˆ with γ = 3. of [39, Theorem 3.3.7]) so that (26) holds for f (H) 0 Furthermore, given E ∈ ∆, let E 7→ gE (E 0 ) be some C 4 -function equal to (E − E 0 )−1 outside of ∆. By the same argument as above, the operator gE (H) is in C 3 (A) as long as E ∈ ∆. Maximising over E ∈ ∆, we conclude that the bound (26) holds for A = (E − H)−1 for a constant c which can be chosen uniform in ˆ − ΠH) = E ∈ ∆ and ω ∈ Ωg . As last preliminary, let us note that the operator (H 2 2 2 ˆ ˆ K1 + (K2 − ΠH(1 − Π)) from ` (Z ) to ` (Z × N) also satisfies (26) for all ω ∈ Ω and that hn|πω (Kˆ2 − ΠH(1 − Π))|mi = 0
for my > L .
ˆ in which The main idea is now to use these bounds in Stone’s formula for f (H) the resolvent is developed according to the geometric resolvent formula. As all the above bounds hold for all ω ∈ Ωg , we suppress the index ω ∈ Ωg throughout the rest of the proof. We replace the geometric resolvent identity 1 ˆ zΠ − H
=Π
1 1 ˆ − ΠH) 1 + (H ˆ z−H z−H zΠ − H
(27)
ˆ and develop (E ± ı − H)−1 into a power series twice into Stone’s formula for f (H) in . Of this series only the constant term, namely (E − H)−1 , remains after the limit → 0: Z 1 1 ˆ − ΠH) 1 , ˆ = 1 s-lim dE f (E) − (H f (H) ˆ ˆ 2πı →0 ∆ E−H E − ı − H E + ı − H (28) and therefore ˆ |hn|f (H)|mi| ≤c
X
X
l∈Z×N k∈Z2
1 ˆ ˆ |mi . |hn|f (H)|li| |hl|H − ΠH|ki| sup hk| E − H E∈∆ (29)
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
101
ˆ − ΠH is localized near the boundary. We As pointed out above, the operator H ˆ ˆ decompose it into two parts K1 and K2 − ΠH(1 − Π) for which we do the following bounds seperately. The contribution C2 of Kˆ2 − ΠH(1 − Π) can be bounded by X X 1 1 1 C2 ≤ c 3 3 1 + |n − l| 1 + |l − k| 1 + |k − m|3 l∈Z×N kx ∈Z,ky ≤L
≤c
1 1 1 + 1 + |nx − mx |3 + m3y 1 + |nx − mx |2 1 + m2y
,
(30)
(here and below, c denotes different constants), and we have used various elementary estimations such as (η, γ > 1): X 1 1 1 1 −1+1/η −1+1/γ ≤ c |a| + |b| . |a| + |k|η |b| + |k − m|γ |b| + |m|γ |b| + |m|η k∈Z
ˆ can be bounded by the r.h.s. of (30). Similarly, one can bound C1 . Hence hn|f (H)|mi This in particular implies that for all ω ∈ Ωg : c ˆ my i| ≤ . |h0, my |f (H)|0, 1 + m2y ˆ As this holds P-almost surely with a uniform constant, it directly implies that f (H) ˆ is TE -trace-class. Replacing (30) twice into 2 ! X X 2 ˆ ˆ , f (H) (sgn(mx )−sgn(mx +nx ))2 |hn|f (H)|mi| , = Tr`2 (Z×N) |X| n,m∈Z×N
the second assertion follows from a short calculation. Remark 4.2. The above proof can be slightly modified in order to prove that Pˆ∆ ∈ L∞ (E, P) and is TˆE -trace-class under the slightly stronger hypothesis that H ∈ C 4 (A). For that purpose one has to replace f in (28) by the indicator function on ∆ and then bound hn|Pˆ∆ |li in (29) trivially by 1. However, the proof of Theorem 3.1 below shows that the TˆE -trace-class property of Pˆ∆ holds whenever H ∈ C 3 (A). Remark 4.3. One can show that, if Aˆ ∈ E is TˆE -trace-class and an element of X ˆ is a Hilbert–Schmidt operator on `2 (Z × N) for P-almost ,π ˆω (A)] C 2 (E), then [ |X| all ω ∈ Ω. This follows from the remarkable identity 2 ! Z X 1 1 ˆ x A) ˆ , ˆ ˆ ∗∇ ,π ˆω (A) (31) dP(ω) Tr`2 (Z×N) = TˆE ((σ A) 4 |X| ı holding for any Aˆ ∈ E0 where ˆ m x , n y , my ) . ˆ (σ A)(ω, mx , ny , my ) = sgn(mx )A(ω, ˆ ∈ E, the formula (31) can be extended to C 2 (E) ∩ As Aˆ ∈ C 2 (E) implies that (σ A) 1 ˆ L (E, TE ), implying hence the above result. Note that this does not give us a uniform bound in ω though and is thus a weaker result (not sufficient for our purposes below). A proof of (31) can be given along the lines of that of Proposition 4.5.
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
102
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
4.2. 1-cocycles over the edge algebra ˆ B ˆ ∈ E0 : The following expression is well-defined and finite for A, ˆ . ˆ B) ˆ = ı TˆE (Aˆ∇ ˆ x B) ξ1 (A,
(32)
Actually ξ1 can be defined on a much wider class of operators. For the purpose of this work, it is sufficient to consider elements in D = C 2 (E) ∩ L1 (E, TˆE ). Note ˆ x and the ideal property of the TˆE -trace-class operators that the product rule for ∇ imply that D is an algebra. It becomes a normed algebra when endowed with the norm: ˆ + k∇ ˆ 2 Ak ˆ + TˆE (|A|) ˆ + 2k∇ ˆ x Ak ˆ . ˆ D = kAk kAk x Lemma 4.4. ξ1 is a cyclic 1-cocycle on D, notably it is cyclic and closed under the Hochschild boundary operator b : ˆ B) ˆ = −ξ1 (B, ˆ A) ˆ for all A, ˆ B ˆ ∈ D. (i) ξ1 (A, ˆ B, ˆ C) ˆ = ξ1 (AˆB, ˆ C) ˆ − ξ1 (A, ˆ B ˆ C) ˆ + ξ1 (Cˆ A, ˆ B) ˆ for all A, ˆ B, ˆ Cˆ ∈ D. (ii) 0 = bξ1 (A, Proof. Both algebraic identities can be verified using the product rule for the ˆ x. ˆ x and the invariance of the trace TˆE under ∇ derivation ∇ ˜ by setting Next we introduce another 1-cocycle on D Z ˆ B) ˆ = dP(ω)ζ1ω (A, ˆ B) ˆ , A, ˆ B ˆ∈D ˜, ζ1 (A, where ˆ B) ˆ ζ1ω (A,
1 = Tr`2 (Z×N) 4
X X X ˆ ˆ ,π ˆω (A) ,π ˆω (B) . |X| |X| |X|
(33)
According to Remark 4.3 of the last section, this cocycle is actually well-defined and finite on D. Proposition 4.5. On D, we have ζ1 = ξ1 . Proof. It is sufficient to show the equality for the dense subalgebra E0 ⊂ D because both ζ1 and ξ1 are continuous with respect to k · kD . A direct calculation shows ˆ B ˆ ∈ E0 : that for A, Z X X ˆ B) ˆ = − 1 dP(ω) sgn(mx ) ζ1 (A, 4 m∈Z×N l∈Z×N
ˆ ˆ πω (A)|li hl|ˆ πω (B)|mi . · (sgn(mx ) − sgn(lx ))2 hm|ˆ Because Aˆ ∈ E0 , the sum over mx ∈ Z actually only contains a finite number of elements, and can thus be exchanged with the integral over P. Then we make the
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
103
change of variables nx = lx − mx and use the covariance relation (9) in order to obtain: X Z X X ˆ B) ˆ = −1 sgn(mx )(sgn(mx ) − sgn(mx + nx ))2 dP(ω) ζ1 (A, 4 mx ∈N
my ,ly ∈N nx ∈Z
ˆ x , ly i hnx , ly |ˆ ˆ · h0, my |ˆ πT (−mx ,0) ω (A)|n πT (−mx ,0) ω (B)|0, my i . Next, by invariance of the measure P, we can replace T (−mx,0) ω by ω. Then we change the sum over mx and the integral over P again and use the identity X sgn(mx )(sgn(mx ) − sgn(mx + nx ))2 = −4nx . mx ∈N
ˆ x , one therefore has By definition of ∇ Z X ˆ ˆ B) ˆ = ı dP(ω) ˆ πω (∇ ˆ x B)|0, my i , h0, my |ˆ πω (A)ˆ ζ1 (A, my ∈N
ˆ B). ˆ which is precisely ξ1 (A, ˜ using the projection operator Finally let us introduce a further 1-cocyle on D Πx = (1 + X/|X|)/2 on `2 (Z × N): Z ˆ ˆ ˆ B) ˆ , A, ˆ B ˆ ∈D ˜, η1 (A, B) = dP(ω)η1ω (A, where ˆ B) ˆ = Tr`2 (Z×N) (Πx π ˆ πω (A)Π ˆ x − Πx π ˆ xπ ˆ x) ˆω (B)ˆ ˆω (B)Π ˆω (A)Π η1ω (A, ˆ πω (B)Π ˆ x − Πx π ˆ xπ ˆ x) . ˆω (A)ˆ ˆω (A)Π ˆω (B)Π − Tr`2 (Z×N) (Πx π
(34)
The following identity is a special case of Connes’ formulas [19]. ˜ both expressions in (34) are finite and one has η1ω = ζ1ω Proposition 4.6. On D, for all ω ∈ Ω. Proof. Some algebra shows ˆ πω (B)Π ˆ x − Πx π ˆ xπ ˆ x ˆω (A)ˆ ˆω (A)Π ˆω (B)Π Πx π 1 X X ˆ ˆ . ,π ˆω (A) ,π ˆω (B) = − Πx 4 |X| |X|
(35)
X ˆ X ,π ˆ ,π ˆω (A)][ Note that if [ |X| |X| ˆω (B)] is trace-class, so is the left-hand side (this is ˆ ˆ ˜ the case for A, B ∈ D by Remark 4.3). Hence using the same identity with Aˆ and ˆ exchanged, we obtain: B
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
104
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
ˆ B) ˆ η1ω (A,
X X 1 ˆ ˆ ,π ˆω (A) ,π ˆω (B) = Tr`2 (Z×N) Πx 4 |X| |X| X X ˆ ˆ ,π ˆω (B) ,π ˆω (A) − Πx |X| |X| X X X 1 ˆ ˆ ,π ˆω (A) ,π ˆω (B) = Tr`2 (Z×N) 2 |X| |X| |X| X X X ˆ ˆ ,π ˆω (B) ,π ˆω (A) . − |X| |X| |X|
X ˆ and [ X , π ˆ ,π ˆω (A)] Note here that the second equality holds because both [ |X| |X| ˆω (B)] are Hilbert–Schmidt (Remark 4.3). From the above we deduce that
ˆ B) ˆ = 1 (ζ ω (A, ˆ B) ˆ − ζ ω (B, ˆ A)) ˆ , η1ω (A, 1 2 1 and the cyclicity property of ζ1ω allows to conclude. Corollary 4.7. On D, we have ξ1 = ζ1 = η1 . 4.3. Index theorems Below we shall use the following well-known result. Proposition 4.8 (Fedosov’s formula). Let F be a bounded operator on a Hilbert space H. We suppose that (1 − F ∗ F ) and (1 − F F ∗ ) are in the pth Schatten ideal of trace-class operators on H. Then F is a Fredholm operator and for every integer n ≥ p, its index satisfies Ind(F ) = Tr((1 − F ∗ F )n ) − Tr((1 − F F ∗ )n ) . Proposition 4.9. Suppose (only for the purpose of this proposition) that P is ˜ be unitary. Then Πx π ˆ x is Pˆω (A)Π ergodic w.r.t. the Z-action Tx . Let Aˆ ∈ D 2 almost surely a Fredholm operator on ` (N × N) the index of which is P-almost ˆ Aˆ∗ −α ¯ ) whenever surely independent of ω ∈ Ω. Its common value is equal to ξ1 (A−α, ˆ A − α ∈ D, α ∈ C, α 6= 0. ˆ Aˆ∗ ) < ∞ for P-almost ˜ Proposition 4.1 implies that η ω (A, Proof. Because Aˆ ∈ D, 1 all ω ∈ Ω. Thus (34) and the Fedosov formula (we can take p = 1) imply that ˆ x is a Fredholm operator on Πx `2 (Z × N) = `2 (N × N) and that its ˆω (A)Π Πx π ˆ Aˆ∗ ). Because index is equal to η ω (A, 1
ˆ x |`2 (N×N) = Πx π ˆ x + K| ˆ ˆT (a,0) ω (A)Π ˆω (A)Π , Πx π U(a,0)`2 (N×N)∼ =`2 (N×N) where K is a compact operator on `2 (N × N) and the Fredholm index is invariant under compact perturbations, we see that the index is Tx -translation invariant in ω ∈ Ω. Hence it is P-almost surely constant by the ergodicity of P with respect to
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
105
ˆ Aˆ∗ ) = η ω (Aˆ − α, Aˆ∗ − α), Tx . As η1ω (A, ¯ Corollary 4.7 implies that the almost sure 1 ∗ ˆ ˆ ¯ index is equal to ξ1 (A − α, A − α). In our context, the measure P is only ergodic w.r.t. the Z2 -action T . However, ˜ notably this is sufficient to give an almost sure index for certain elements in D, those in the image of the exponential map. ˆ satisfy the hypothesis of Proposition 4.1 and let g Proposition 4.10. Let H 4 be a real C function with values in [0, 1], equal to 0 or 1 outside of ∆. Set ˆ = exp(−2πıg(H)). ˆ ˆ )Πx is P-almost surely a Fredholm operator U Then Πx π ˆω (U 2 on ` (N × N) the index of which is P-almost surely independent of ω ∈ Ω. The ˆ − 1, U ˆ −1 − 1). almost sure value is equal to ξ1 (U ˆ ∈ D. ˜ Thus from the proof of Proposition 4.9 follows Proof. By Proposition 4.1, U ˆ ˆω (U )Πx is P-almost surely a Fredholm operator and that its index is that Πx π Tx -invariant. To conclude, we have to show its Ty -invariance. Herefore, let Q : `2 (Z × N) → `2 (Z × N) denote the projection on the subspace ˆ = (K, ˆ H) ∈ T (A), we can use the equation spanned by {|mx , 0i|mx ∈ Z}. Now, if H ˆ ˆ ˆω (K) and the covariance relation Uy π −1 (H)U ∗ = πω (H) π ˆω (H) = Ππω (H)Π + π Ty ω
y
in order to obtain ˆ =U ˆy π ˆ U ˆy∗ + R ˆω , ˆTy−1 ω (H) π ˆω (H) ˆ ω is an operator family, covariant in the x-direction and compact in the where R y-direction and given by ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆy π ˆ U ˆy∗ . ˆω = π ˆω (H)Q + Qˆ πω (H)(1 − Q) + (1 − Q)ˆ πω (K)(1 − Q) + U ˆTy−1 ω (K) R ˆ is actually an operator satisfying the hypothesis of Sec. 4.1. Hence the Now R ˆ U ˆy∗ + λR ˆ ω is a lift of πω (H) and by Proposition 4.1 ˆy π ˆTy−1 ω (H) operator U ˆy π ˆ U ˆy∗ + λR ˆ ω )) , ˆω (λ) = exp(−2πıf (U ˆTy−1 ω (H) U is P-almost surely a norm-continuous family (in λ) of Fredholm operators. Clearly ˆ ˆ ) and moreover, because U ˆ ∗U ˆ ˆ ˆ −1 (U ˆ )U ˆ ∗. ˆω (1) = π ˆω (U U y y = 1, we have Uω (0) = Uy π y Ty ω Therefore the homotopy invariance of the Fredholm index implies: ˆy π ˆ )Πx ) = Ind(Πx U ˆ )U ˆy∗ Πx ) = Ind(Πx π ˆ )Πx ) , ˆω (U ˆTy−1 ω (U ˆTy−1 ω (U Ind(Πx π which concludes the proof. 4.4. Calculation of the edge current Proof of Theorem 3.1. Let G ∈ C 2 (R) be a positive function supported on an interval ∆0 ⊂ ∆. We set Z E 1 dE 0 G(E 0 ) , g(E) = 1 − R 0 G(E 0 ) dE −∞ R
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
106
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
ˆ = exp(−2πıg(H)). ˆ ˆ ) and and the unitary operator W By Proposition 4.10, π ˆω (W ∗ ˆ π ˆω (W ) are P-almost surely Fredholm operators with a P-almost sure index. Changing ∆0 within ∆ (or changing G) does not change their index by the homotopy invariance of the Fredholm index. Hence their indices are actually associated ∗ ˆ (∆) and U(∆) ˆ with the gap ∆ and can moreover be calculated as the index of U ˆ (∆)∗ by Ind so that respectively. We denote that of U ˆ ). ˆ ∗ − 1)∇ ˆ xW Ind = ı TˆE ((W
(36)
ˆ: ˆ xW Now recall Duhamel’s formula for ∇ Z 1 ˆ = −2πı ˆ x g(H) ˆ xW ˆ 1−s ∇ ˆ W ˆ s, ∇ ds W 0
where the integral is defined as a norm convergent Riemann sum in L∞ (E, TˆE ). We replace this into (36), use the continuity of the map A ∈ A 7→ TˆE ((W ∗ − 1)A) in order to exchange the trace with the integral over s and finally use the unitary invariance of TˆE to deduce ˆ )∇ ˆ x g(H)) ˆ . Ind = 2π TˆE ((1 − W P To calculate this, we develop g(E) = k ck Tk (E) in a series of Tchebychev polynomials over ∆ (slightly enlarged if necessary). Because g ∈ C 3 (R), this series converges absolutely and uniformly on ∆0 ⊂ ∆, so the sum over k can be exchanged ˆ we now apply the gradient and then use the with TˆE . On each polynomial in H ˆ , H] ˆ = 0 in order to regroup all polynomials in H ˆ to cyclicity of the trace and [W R P 0 0 0 ˆ ˆ the left of ∇x H. Because G(E) = − k ck Tk (E) · ( R dE G(E )), we conclude that 2π ˆ . ˆ − 1)G(H) ˆ ∇ ˆ x H) Tˆ ((W 0 G(E 0 ) E dE R
Ind = R
Now let Gj ∈ C 3 (R) be a sequence of positive functions converging (pointwise) from ˆ j denotes the unitary constructed from below to the indicator function onto ∆0 . If W ˆ j − 1) Gj (H) ˆ converges in norm to U ˆ (∆0 ) − 1. Therefore, G = Gj as above, then (W for any ∆0 ⊂ ∆, Ind =
2π ˆ ˆ 0 ˆ . ˆ x H) TE ((U (∆ ) − 1)∇ |∆0 |
For a given k ∈ N, k ≥ 1, we divide ∆ into k intervals ∆j = [Ej−1 , Ej ], j = 1, · · · , k, of equal length |∆|/k. Note that E0 = E 0 = inf(∆). Let us set ! ˆ − Ej H ˆj − 1 = exp −2πı ˆ (∆)k − 1) Pˆ∆j . Pˆ∆j − 1 = (U U |∆j | ˆ (∆)∗ , namely Ind. Hence ˆ ∗ is equal to that of U Now the Fredholm index of each U j it follows that Ind =
k 1 X 2π ˆ ˆ ˆ = 2π TˆE ((U ˆ . ˆ x H) ˆ (∆)k − 1)∇ ˆ x H) TE ((Uj − 1)∇ k j=1 |∆j | |∆|
(37)
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
107
ˆj ’s, it can be verified that (37) Introducing a sign in the above definition of the U also holds for negative integers, so it holds for all k ∈ Z except k = 0. Finally we make a Fourier analysis on the closed interval ∆. Let ∆0 ⊂ ∆ be a closed interval such that min(∆0 ) > E 0 and set ∆00 = ∆ \ ∆0 . The indicator function χ∆00 on ∆00 is given by the following pointwise convergent Fourier series: X 1 2πı 0 k(E − E ) , ak exp − χ∆00 (E) = − χ∂∆0 (E) + 2 |∆| k∈Z
where χ∂∆0 is the characteristic function on the boundary points of ∆0 and Z 2πı dE χ∆00 (E) exp − k(E − E 0 ) . ak = |∆| ∆ |∆| One has: X
ak = 1 ,
a0 =
k∈Z
|∆00 | , |∆|
X
ak =
k6=0
|∆0 | , |∆|
so that: Pˆ∆
X
ˆ (∆)k = ak U
k6=0
|∆0 | ˆ 1 P∆ − Pˆ∆0 − Pˆ∂∆0 . |∆| 2
By hypothesis TˆE (Pˆ∂∆0 ) = 0. Hence, summing (37) one obtains: Ind =
|∆| X 2π ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ x H) ˆ − 2π TˆE (Pˆ∆ ∇ ˆ x H) ˆ TE (P∆ U (∆)k ∇ ak |∆0 | |∆| |∆| k6=0
=−
2π ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ TE (P∆0 ∇x H) . |∆0 |
∆0 being an arbitrary closed interval in ∆, the result is thus proven. 5. Equality between Edge and Bulk Hall Conductivity In this section, we give the proof of Theorem 3.3. It makes use of the results and notations of the Appendix. According to Sec. 4 and Proposition 3.2, the definitions in Sec. A.3 show that edge and bulk Hall conductivity result from the following pairings of cyclic cohomology with K-theory over E and A respectively: e (∆) = − σ⊥
q2 ˆ (∆)]1 , [ξ1 ]i , 2πı h[U h
b σ⊥ (µ) =
q2 2 4π ı h[Pµ ]0 , [ξ2 ]i . h
ˆ (∆) and ξ1 are defined in (23) and (32), Pµ is the Fermi projection of the Here U plane operator on a Fermi level µ ∈ ∆ and ξ2 is the 2-cocylce over A defined by ξ2 (A, B, C) = ı T (A∇x B∇y C − A∇y B∇x C) .
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
108
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
We now use the isomorphisms ρ and η defined in (20) and (21) in order to transform these two pairings to pairings over the algebras C(Ω)×αx Z⊗K and C(Ω)×αx Z×αy Z of the Pimsner–Voiculescu exact sequence (19): e (∆) = − σ⊥
q2 ˆ (∆))]1 , [ρ∗ ξ1 ]i , 2πıh[ρ−1 (U h
b σ⊥ (µ) =
q2 2 4π ıh[η −1 (Pµ )]0 , [η ∗ ξ2 ]i . h
Now we may apply the duality Theorem A.10 for Pimsner–Voiculesu exact sequences by setting B = C(Ω) ×αx Z on which the action is given by α = αy . Hence ˆ (∆))]1 Theorem 3.3 is proven once we have verified that exp([η −1 (Pµ )]0 ) = [ρ−1 (U ∗ ∗ and η ξ2 = #αy ρ ξ1 . Concerning the latter equality one can immediately verify that, if one defines ξ1 and ξ2 by the same formulas on the corresponding algebras of the Pimsner–Voiculescu exact sequence, then η ∗ ξ2 = ξ2 and ρ∗ ξ1 = ξ1 (use herefore that η and ρ are isomorphisms leaving the traces invariant); then going back to the definition of #αy in Sec. A.5.2, the identity ξ2 = #αy ξ1 can be directly checked. ˆ (∆)]1 . For the first equality, it is clearly sufficient to show that exp([Pµ ]0 ) = [U We first note that Pµ is equal to the continuous function of the Hamiltonian g(H) = PE 0 − (H − E 0 )P∆ /|∆| where E 0 = inf(∆). A selfadjoint lift of Pµ is ˆ Now using [PˆE 0 , Pˆ∆ ] = 0 and the fact that exp(2πıPˆ ) = 1 thus given by g(H). for any projection Pˆ , we thus obtain from the definition of the exponential map recalled in the Appendix: ˆ 1 = [U ˆ (∆)]1 . exp([Pµ ]0 ) = [exp(−2πıg(H))] This concludes the proof of Theorem 3.3. Appendix A. Duality of Pairings of K-theory with Cyclic Cohomology In this appendix we prove a duality theorem for pairings over crossed products. This result (Theorem A.10 below) was announced by Nest [34, Proposition 12.6], but the proof given there is incomplete. We close that gap using arguments along the lines of [24]. Using a result of Pimsner [36], we provide in fact a new and conceptually more transparent proof in the situation adequate to our context. A.1. Some help for cooking with K-theory For the convenience of the reader, we give a very brief summary of the main K-theoretic notions used in this work. We refer to [14, 44] for all the details and even for the definition of the groups K0 (B) and K1 (B) of a given involutive Banach algebra B. Roughly, K0 is the Grothendieck group generated by homotopy classes of idempotents in matrix algebras over B, and K1 (B) is formed by homotopy classes of invertibles (or equivalently unitaries) therein. However, great care needs to be taken when B does not have a unit.
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
109
The suspension SB of B is the algebra of continuous functions f : S 1 → B which vanish at a distinguished point that we choose to be 1. This construction provides a link between the K-groups. First, the following map is a group isomorphism: " " !# ! # 1 0 1 0 ∗ − . Wt Θ : K1 (B) → K0 (SB) , [V ]1 7→ Wt 0 0 0 0 0 0 Here V ∈ Mn (B) is an unitary representative and Wt ∈ M2n (B) a homotopy from V 0 0 V ∗ to 1. The blocksize in the matrix is n × n. One of the key properties of K-theory is that β : K0 (B) → K1 (SB) ,
[P ]0 7→ [e2πıtP ]1 = [(e2πıt − 1)P + (1 − P )]1
is also an isomorphism called the Bott map. It shows that K0 (B) ∼ = K0 (SSB), making K-theory a periodic theory. Another crucial property of K-theory is that any short exact sequence of Banach algebras, i
π
0 → J −→ B −→ B/J → 0 , gives rise to a six-term exact sequence of K-groups: K0 (J ) x ind
i
π
π
i
∗ ∗ −→ K0 (B) −→ K0 (B/J ) yexp
∗ ∗ K1 (B/J ) ←− K1 (B) ←− K1 (J ) .
The definition of the push-forward maps i∗ and π∗ is immediate. Let us recall those of the index and exponential map. Given a unitary V ∈ Mn (B/J ) defining a class in K1 (B/J ), let W ∈ M2n (B) be a unitary lift of V0 V0∗ . Then " ! " !# # 1 0 1 0 ∗ W − . ind([V ]1 ) = W 0 0 0 0 0 0 The exponential map is defined by exp := Θ−1 ◦ ind ◦ β. Explicitly, if P ∈ Mn (B/J ) defines a class in K0 (B/J ) and L(P ) ∈ B a self-adjoint lift for it, then exp([P ]0 ) = [exp(−2πıL(P ))]1 . We furthermore recall some facts about the Toeplitz extension (see [37]) of the C∗ -crossed product B ×α Z associated with the C∗ -dynamical system (B, Z, α) (for unital B): ψ
π
0 → B ⊗ K −→ T (B) −→ B ×α Z → 0 .
(A.1)
Here K are the compact operators on `2 (N) generated by the finite rank operators en,m , n, m ∈ N, the matrix units, and ψ is the homorphism defined in [37]. We have met such an extension in Sec. 2.6. The imbedding j : B → B ⊗ K,
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
110
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes j∗
j(b) = b ⊗ e11 induces an isomorphism K(B) ∼ = K(B ⊗ K) and in [37] Pimsner and Voiculescu have shown that K(T (B)) ∼ = K(B) as well. Keeping carefully track of these isomorphisms, they obtained from the six-term exact sequence associated with (A.1) the nowadays called Pimsner–Voiculescu six-term exact sequence: K0 (B) x ind K1 (B ×α Z)
i∗ −α−1 ∗
−→
i
∗ ←−
K0 (B)
K1 (B)
i
∗ −→
i∗ −α−1 ∗
←−
K0 (B ×α Z) yexp K1 (B) .
Strictly speaking the maps ind and exp in this diagram are not the same as the ones in the original sequence, but have to be composed with j∗−1 . We now produce a direct proof of the following result by Elliott and Natsume [23] used in Sec. A.6, which is a discrete (one-way) analog of Connes’ Thom isomorphism [17]. We denote the unitary generator of the action in B ×α Z by U , notably α(A) = U AU ∗ for all A ∈ B. Proposition A.1. Let P ∈ Mn (B) be a projection defining a class in K0 (B) which is in the image of the index map, and let W ∈ Mn (B) be a unitary such that α(P ) = W P W ∗ . Then a preimage of [P ]0 is the class defined by the unitary X = U P + W (1 − P ). Proof. First note that the unitary W exists (possibly after enlarging n) because [P ]0 = [α(P )]0 by the Pimsner–Voiculescu exact sequence. In order to compute 0 ind([X]1 ), we have to find a lift W ∈ M2n (T (B)) of X 0 X ∗ and to compute " !# ! " ! # 1 0 1 0 −1 ∗ − W W . j∗ 0 0 0 0 0 0 ˆ = ˆ ∗U ˆ ∈ T (B) of U with the following properties: U ˆU ˆ ∗ = 1, U There exists a lift U ∗ ˆ ˆ 1 − P0 , where P0 = i(1 ⊗ e11 ) and U AU = α(A) for all A ∈ B. In particular, P commutes with P0 and it is not difficult to verify that ! ˆ P + W (1 − P ) U 0 W = ˆ ∗ + (1 − P )W ∗ PU P P0 0 is a lift of X 0 X ∗ . Furthermore, " !# " # !# " ! 1 0 0 0 1 0 ∗ − = = j∗ ([P ]0 ) . W W 0 0 0 P P 0 0 0 0 0 0 A.2. Definition of cyclic cohomology Given a complex algebra B, let Cλn (B) be the set of n + 1-linear functionals on B which are cyclic in the sense that ϕ(A1 , . . . , An , A0 ) = (−1)n ϕ(A0 , . . . , An ) .
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
111
Definition A.2. The cyclic cohomology HC(B) of B is the cohomology of the complex b
0 → Cλ0 (B) → · · · → Cλn (B) −→ Cλn+1 (B) → · · · with bϕ(A0 , . . . , An+1 ) =
n X
(−1)j ϕ(A0 , . . . , Aj Aj+1 , . . . , An+1 )
j=0
+ (−1)n+1 ϕ(An+1 A0 , . . . , An ) .
(A.2)
An element ϕ ∈ Cλn (B) satisfying bϕ = 0 is called a cyclic n-cocycle. Example A.3. Let ∇j , j = 1, . . . , n be n commuting derivations on B (not necessarily fully defined) and T an invariant trace (T ◦ ∇j = 0), not necessarily finite. Then ξn : A⊗n+1 → C defined by X (−1)sgn(σ) T (A0 ∇σ(1) A1 · · · ∇σ(n) An ) ξn (A0 , . . . , An ) = σ∈Sn
= T (A0 ∇[1 A1 · · · ∇n] An ) , (the second expression is an abbreviation) is an n-cocycle. This will be proved below. The domain of definition of ξn depends on the domains of definition of the derivations and that of T . A.3. Pairing with K-groups Now let B be a Banach algebra. The elements of cyclic cohomology of degree j pair with Kj (B) (j mod 2 in the latter case) in the following way. Let ξ be a 2k-cocycle, [ξ] its class. Then h[P ]0 − [Pm ]0 , [ξ]i = c2k Tr ⊗ ξ(P, . . . , P ) ,
P ∈ Mm+l (B) ,
is a well-defined pairing between K0 (B) and HC ev (B) [19]. If ξ is a 2k + 1-cocycle, then h[V ]1 , [ξ]i = c2k+1 Tr ⊗ ξ(V −1 − 1, V − 1, . . . , V − 1) ,
V ∈ Mm (B) ,
(the entries alternate) is a well-defined pairing between K1 (B) and HC odd (B). Here the normalization constants are (chosen as in [18] and [36], but not as in [19]): c2k =
1 1 , (2πı)k k!
c2k+1 =
1 1 1 . 1 k+1 2k+1 (2πı) 2 k + 2 k − 12 · · · 12
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
112
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
A.4. Cycles There is a convenient reformulation of the description of cyclic cocycles in terms of graded differential algebras (Ω, d) with graded closed traces (we use the widely spread notation Ω here, because misinterpretation as the hull of Sec. 2.1 seems L excluded). A graded algebra is a graded vectorspace Ω = n∈Z Ωn (we denote by ∂A the degree of a homogeneous element A) such that ∂(AB) = ∂(A) + ∂(B) for homogeneous elements. It is called a graded differential algebra if there exists a graded differential d (a derivation whose square vanishes) of degree 1. A graded R R R trace on Ωn isR a linear functional which satisfies w1 w2 = (−1)∂w1 +∂w2 w2 w1 . It is closed if vanishes on d(Ωn−1 ). Definition A.4. A n-dimensional cycle over B is a graded differentialR algebra (Ω, d) of highest non-trivial degree n together with a closed graded trace on Ωn and an algebra homomorphism B → Ω0 . We will assume here that the homomorphism B → Ω0 is injective and hence identify B with a subalgebra of Ω0 . See [19] for the proof of the following result. Proposition A.5. Any cycle of dimension n over B defines a cyclic n-cocycle through what is called its character: Z ξ(A0 , . . . , An ) = A0 dA1 · · · dAn . Example A.6. Consider an action of Rn on the algebra B by commuting derivations ∇j (thus view Rn as Lie algebra) and suppose that T is an invariant trace, i.e. T (exp(t∇j )A) = T (A) for all t. Let Ω be the tensor product B ⊗ ΛCn of B with the Grassmann algebra ΛCn with generators ej , j = 1, . . . , n and define d(A ⊗ v) =
n X
∇j A ⊗ ej v .
j=1
It is straightforward to check that (Ω, d) is a differential algebra. Note that Λn Cn ∼ = · · · e ) = 1 C (as vector spaces) and any isomorphism is a graded trace. Taking ı(e 1 n R as such an isomorphism, we define = T ⊗ ı, that is Z A0 dA1 · · · dAn = T (A0 ∇[1 A1 · · · ∇n] An ) , a cycle of dimension n associated with our second example. Let us prove that this is actually closed and graded. The graded cyclicity follows directly from the graded cyclicity of ı and the cyclicity of T . To prove closedness write T ⊗ ı = ı ◦ (T ⊗ id) on the highest degree. Since d acts trivially on C ⊗ ΛCn , the invariance of T implies (T ⊗ id) ◦ d = 0. This proves the claim.
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
113
A.5. Constructing new cycles from old ones We next extend Example A.6. Suppose we have the same situation as in that example R except that in place of an invariant trace there is an invariant k-cycle (Ω, δ, ). By this we mean that Rn acts R on Ω by derivations such that δ commutes with this action and the graded trace is invariant. The aim is to construct a k +ncycle from these data. Before we do so let us recall that the graded tensor product ˆ of two graded algebras is the graded tensor product of the vector spaces with Ω⊗Λ ˆ 1 )(w2 ⊗v ˆ 2 ) = (−1)∂w2 ∂v1 w1 w2 ⊗v ˆ 1 v2 . In particular, it reduces to the product (w1 ⊗v usual tensor product if one of the algebras is trivially graded. R Proposition A.7. Let (Ω, δ, ) be a k-cycle over the algebra R B with an action n invariant. Taking of R by n derivations ∇i which commute with δ and leave ˆ ΛCn , the graded tensor product, d0 = δ ⊗ ˆ 1 + d with d(w ⊗ ˆ v) = Ω0 = Ω ⊗ R0 R R0 P ∂w 0 0 ˆ ˆ ı one obtains a k + n-cycle (Ω , d , ) over B. = ⊗ (−1) j ∇j w ⊗ ej v, and Proof. Ω0 is naturally bigraded and one defines the total degree to be the sum of the components of the bidegree. A straightforward calculation shows that that δ and d are anti-commuting graded differentials which are of total degree 1. Therefore d0 = d+δ is a differential of total degree one and (Ω0 , d0 ) a graded differential algebra R0 is a closed graded with respect to the totalRdegree. It remains thus to check that 0 is non-zero precisely at the highest non-trivial (total) trace. First note, that degree. Further Z Z 0 ∂w2 ∂v1 ˆ ˆ (w1 ⊗ v1 )(w2 ⊗ v2 ) = (−1) w1 w2 ı(v1 v2 ) Z = (−1)∂w2 ∂v1 +∂w1 ∂w2 +∂v1 ∂v2 Z = (−1)(∂w1 +∂v1 )(∂w2 +∂v2 ) shows that
R0 Z
0
0
w2 w1 ı(v2 v1 )
ˆ v2 )(w1 ⊗ ˆ v1 ) (w2 ⊗
is a graded trace. We have Z Z X ˆ v) = d0 (w ⊗ δw ı(v) + (−1)∂w ∇j w ı(ej v). j
The first R 0 term vanishes due to closedness of is closed. Thus A.5.1. Suspension of cyclic cocycles
R
and the second due to its invariance.
R We now consider a Banach algebra B with an n-cycle (Ω, d, ) and look at C(S 1 , B) the algebra of continuous functions over S 1 = R/2πZ with values in B. S 1 is an abelian Lie group thus acting on itself and we take this action and extend it trivially to C(S 1 , B). Then the Lie algebra R of S 1 acts by differentiation along the
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
114
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
R0 parameter of S 1 which we denote t. We define for C(S 1 , B) anR n-cycle (Ω0 , d0 , ) as 0 we combine follows. Ω0 = C(S 1 , Ω), d is the trivial extension of d and for R 0 R the old R = S 1 dt . n-cycle for B with integration (Lebesgue measure) over S 1 , namely R 00 Now Proposition A.7 provides us with an n + 1-cycle (Ω00 , d00 , ) for C(S 1 , B). Its restriction to the suspension SB, sub-algebra of C(S 1 , B), plays an important role for us. Concretely, for Ai : S → B, we get Z 00 A0 d00 A1 · · · d00 An+1
=
n+1 X
Z
Z
(−1)n+1−j
dt
A0 dA1 · · · dAj−1 A˙ j dAj+1 · · · dAn+1 .
S1
j=1
R s If ξ denotes the character of (Ω, d, ) in this example R 00then we denote by ξ the 00 00 character on the suspension SB obtained from (Ω , d , ) in the above way. Note that this suspension construction differs from Connes’ (double) suspension [18, 19]. Theorem A.8 ([36]). The map HC n (B) → HC n+1 (SB) : [ξ] 7→ [ξ s ] is dual to the Bott map β for even cycles and dual to the suspension map Θ for odd cocyles, i.e. h[P ]0 − [Pm ]0 , [ξ]i = hβ([P ]0 − [Pm ]), [ξ s ]i for even cocycles ξ over B and h[V ]1 , [ξ]i = −hθ([V ]1 ), [ξ s ]i for odd ones. A.5.2. Cyclic cocycles for crossed products
R In the second application, we consider a n-cycle (Ω, d, ) over an algebra B on R which is given a Z-action (such that d commutes with this action and is invariant under it). The aim is to construct a n + 1-cycle over B ×α Z, the algebraic crossed product. To do so we first construct a n-cycle over B ×α Z and then apply R0 Proposition A.7. The n-cycle over B is given by (Ω0 , d0 , ) where Ω0 = Ω ×α Z, extension of d to functions A : Z → Ω, the algebraic crossed product,Rd0 the trivial R 0 0 A = A(0). To show that d0 is a derivation one i.e. (d A)(m) = dA(m), and needs indeed that R 0 it commutes with the Z-action α and the latter is also essential is a graded trace. Now on B and on Ω we have an action of the to show that dual group of Z which is S 1 . Its Lie algebra acts by the derivation ∇A(m) = ımA(m) . R0 invariant, the latter simply because This action commutes with d0 and leaves R 00 ∇A(0) = 0. We thus can apply Proposition A.7 to obtain an n+1-cycle (Ω00 , d00 , ). More explicitly, for A : Z → B we get
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
Z
00
115
A0 d00 A1 · · · d00 An+1
=
n+1 X
Z n+1−j
(−1)
(A0 dA1 · · · dAj−1 ∇Aj dAj+1 · · · dAn+1 )(0) .
j=1
R Now, if ξ is the character of (Ω, d, ), we R 00 denote by #α ξ the character corresponding to the above n + 1-cycle (Ω00 , d00 , ). The proof of the following lemma is a straightforward algebraic calculation. R Lemma A.9. Let B be an algebra furnished with a Z-action α, further let (Ω, d, ) be a α-invariant n-cycle over B and ξ its character. Then #α (ξ s ) = (#α ξ)s . A.6. Duality theorem for crossed products R Theorem A.10. Let (B, Z, α) be a C∗ -dynamical system, (Ω, d, ) be a α-invariant n-cycle over B and ξ its character. The map HC n (B) → HC n+1 (B ×α Z) : [ξ] 7→ [#α ξ] is dual to the connecting map of the Pimsner–Voiculescu exact sequence, i.e. hexp([P ]0 − [Pm ]0 ), [ξ]i = 2πh[P ]0 − [Pm ]0 , [#α ξ]i , for odd n, and hind([V ]1 ), [ξ]i = −2πh[V ]1 , [#α ξ]i , for even n. Proof. We denote the unitary generating the action α in B ×α Z by U , that is α(A) = U AU ∗ for all A ∈ B. Due to the Lemma A.9 and Theorem A.8, it suffices to consider only the case of even n because the crossed product commutes with the suspension, notably SB ×α Z = S(B ×α Z). Now let [P ]0 ∈ K0 (B) be in the image of the index map. From the Pimsner– Voiculescu exact sequence we then deduce that [α(P )]0 = [P ]0 . Thus there exists a unitary W ∈ B which is homotopic to the identity and such that α(P ) = W P W ∗ (if necessary, one passes to matrix algebras over B). According to Proposition A.1 of the Appendix, the preimage of [P ]0 under the index map is then [U P +W (1−P )]1 ∈ K1 (B ×α Z). Therefore the second statement of the theorem is equivalent to h[P ]0 − [Pm ]0 , [ξ]i = −2πh[U P + W (1 − P )]1 , [#α ξ]i , for an n = 2k-cocycle ξ of B. Suppose first that W = 1. Then Z 00 P (U ∗ − 1)d00 ((U − 1)P ) · · · d00 ((U − 1)P ) h[U P + 1 − P ]1 , [#α ξ]i = c2k+1
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
116
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
with the cycle for the character as above. Since the action α commutes with d0 and [U, P ] = 0, we can collect all U ’s to the left. Furthermore, P (d0 P )m P vanishes if m is odd and is equal to P (d0 P )m if m is even. Using this the r.h.s. becomes Z 0 U (U − 1)k (U −1 − 1)k+1 P (d0 P )2k ıc2k+1 (k + 1) = −ıc2k+1 (k + 1)
k X
k
l=0
l
2k + 1
= −ıc2k+1 (k + 1) =−
!
k
k+1
!Z
l+1
P (dP )2k
!Z P (dP )2k
1 h[P ]0 , [ξ]i . 2π
To treat now the case W 6= 1, we use the new action α0 (A) = W ∗ α(A)W and the associated crossed product B ×α0 Z. Further let us introduce an automorphism γ of M2 (B) by ! ! A B α(A) α(B)W . γ = C D W ∗ α(C) W ∗ α(D)W Then there are two embeddings ρ1 : B ×α Z → M2 (B) ×γ Z ,
ρ2 : B ×α0 Z → M2 (B) ×γ Z ,
onto the upper left and lower right corner of the 2 × 2-matrix respectively. Finally we introduce the C ∞ -path AdVt : M2 (B) ×γ Z → M2 (B) ×γ Z, t ∈ [0, 1], where π π t − sin t cos 2 2 Vt = π . π t cos t sin 2 2 As AdV1 interchanges the upper left and lower right corners, we can use the following commutative diagram to define an isomorphism i : B ×α Z → B ×α0 Z: ρ1
B ×α Z −→ M2 (B) ×γ Z yAdV1 iy ρ2
B ×α0 Z −→ M2 (B) ×γ Z . One can now check that i(A) = A for all A ∈ B and i(U ) = W U 0 where U 0 is the generator of the α0 -action in B ×α0 Z. Hence i(U P +W (1−P )) = W (U 0 P +(1−P )). Further one checks that #α ξ = ρ∗1 (#γ (Tr2 ⊗ ξ)) ,
#α0 ξ = ρ∗2 (#γ (Tr2 ⊗ ξ)) .
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
117
To verify that the pairings with [#α ξ]1 and [#α0 ξ]1 coincide, we now use Connes’ homotopy invariance of cyclic cohomology [19] extended to non-unital algebras in [24]. As V0 = 1, it tells us that [#γ (Tr2 ⊗ ξ)]1 = [Ad∗V1 #γ (Tr2 ⊗ ξ)]1 in HC odd (M2 (B) ×γ Z). Therefore we obtain: h[U P + W (1 − P )]1 , [#α ξ]1 i = h[ρ1 (U P + W (1 − P ))]1 , [#γ (Tr2 ⊗ ξ)]i = h[ρ1 (U P + W (1 − P ))]1 , [Ad∗V1 (#γ (Tr2 ⊗ ξ))]i = h[i(U P + W (1 − P ))]1 , [ρ∗2 (#γ (Tr2 ⊗ ξ))]i = h[U 0 P + (1 − P )]1 , [#α0 ξ]i , where in the last step we use [W (U 0 P + (1 − P ))]1 = [U 0 P + (1 − P )]1 because W is homotopic to the identity in B. Now this last pairing is in B ×α0 Z where the above calcuation can be applied in order to conclude. Acknowledgments We would like to express our deep gratitude to our teachers Jean Bellissard and Ruedi Seiler. Their works set the stage for the present article which hereby inherits their spirit. We moreover profited from discussions with many collegues, among them M. Aizenman, Y. Avron, J.-M. Combes, S. DeBievre, G. Elliott, F. Germinet, S. Jitormirskaya, A. Klein and M. Seifert. We acknowledge support of the SFB 288. References [1] M. Aizenman, “Localization at weak disorder: some elementary bounds”, Rev. Math. Phys. 6 (1994) 1163–1182. [2] M. Aizenman and G. Graf, “Localization bounds for an electron gas”, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 31 (1998) 6783–6806. [3] M. Aizenman and S. Molchanov, “Localization at large disorder and at extreme energies: an elementary derivation”, Com. Math. Phys. 157 (1993) 245–278. [4] E. Akkermans, J. E. Avron, R. Narevich and R. Seiler, “Boundary conditions for bulk and edge states in quantum Hall systems”, European Phys. J. B 1 (1998) 117–121. [5] B. W. Alphenaar, P. McEuen, R. Wheeler and R. Sacks, “Selective equilibration among the current-carrying states in the quantum Hall regime”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 64 (1990) 677–680. [6] J. E. Avron and R. Seiler, “Quantization of the Hall conductance for gerneral, multiparticle Schr¨ odinger Hamiltonians”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 54 (1985) 259–262. [7] J. E. Avron, R. Seiler and B. Simon, “Charge Deficiency, Charge Transport and Comparison of Dimensions”, Com. Math. Phys. 159 (1994) 399–422. [8] J. E. Avron, R. Seiler and A. Yaffe, “Adiabatic theorems and applications to the quantum Hall effect”, Com. Math. Phys. 110 (1987) 33–49. [9] J. Bellissard, “K-theory of C∗ -algebras in solid state physics”, pp. 95–156 in Statistical Mechanics and Field Theory: Mathematical Aspects, Lecture Notes in Physics 257, eds. T. Dorlas, M. Hugenholtz and M. Winnink, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1986. [10] J. Bellissard, “Ordinary quantum Hall effect and non-commutative cohomology”, in Proc. of the Bad Schandau Conference on Localization, 1986, eds. Ziesche and Weller, Teubner Texte Phys. 16, Teubner-Verlag, Leipzig, 1988.
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
118
00110
J. Kellendonk, T. Richter & H. Schulz-Baldes
[11] J. Bellissard, “Gap labelling theorems for Schr¨ odinger operators”, pp. 538–630 in From Number Theory to Physics, Springer, Berlin, 1992. [12] J. Bellissard, A. van Elst and H. Schulz-Baldes, “The non-commutative geometry of the quantum Hall effect”, J. Math. Phys. 35 (1994) 5373–5451. [13] J. Bellissard, D. J. Herrmann and M. Zarrouati, “Hull of aperiodic solids and gap labelling theorems”, in Directions in Mathematical Quasicrystals, eds. M. Baake and R. V. Moody, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2000. [14] B. Blackadar, K-Theory for Operator Algebras, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1986. [15] M. B¨ uttiker, “Absence of backscattering in the quantum Hall effect in multiprobe conductors”, Phys. Rev. B 38 (1988) 9375–9389. [16] M. B¨ uttiker, “The quantum Hall effect in open conductors”, pp. 191–277 in Semiconductors and Semimetals Vol. 35, ed. M. Reed, Academic Press, San Diego, 1992. [17] A. Connes, “An analogue of the Thom isomorphism”, Adv. Math. 39 (1981) 31–55. [18] A. Connes, “Non-Commutative Differential Geometry: Part I and II”, Publ. IHES 62 (1985) 41–144. [19] A. Connes, Non-Commutative Geometry, Acad. Press, San Diego, 1994. [20] H. L. Cyon, R. G. Froese, W. Kirsch and B. Simon, Schr¨ odinger Operators, Springer, Berlin, 1987. [21] S. De Bievre and J. V. Pul´e, “Propagating edge states for a magnetic Hamiltonian”, Elect. J. Math. Phys. 5 (1999). [22] J. Dixmier, C ∗ -Algebras, North Holland, Amsterdam, 1977. [23] G. Elliott and T. Natsume, “A Bott periodicity map for crossed products of C∗ -algebras by discrete groups”, K-Theory 1 (1987) 423–435. [24] G. Elliott, T. Natsume and R. Nest, “Cyclic cohomology for one-parameter smooth crossed products”, Acta Math. 160 (1988) 285–305. [25] J. Fr¨ ohlich, G. M. Graf and J. Walcher, “On the extended nature of edge states of quantum Hall Hamiltonians”, Ann. H. Poincar´ e 1 (2000). [26] B. I. Halperin, “Quantized Hall conductance, current-carrying edge states, and the existence of extended states in a two-dimensional disordered potential”, Phys. Rev. B 25 (1982) 2185–2190. [27] Y. Hatsugai, “Edge states in the integer quantum Hall effect and the Riemann surface of the Bloch function”, Phys. Rev. B 48 (1993) 11851–11862. [28] Y. Hatsugai, “The Chern number and edge states in the integer quantum Hall effect”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 (1993) 3697–3700. [29] K. v. Klitzing, G. Dorda and M. Pepper, “New method for high-accuracy determination of the fine-structure constant based on quantized Hall resistance”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 45 (1980) 494–497. [30] H. Kunz, “The quantum Hall effect for electrons in a random potential”, Commun. Math. Phys. 112 (1987) 121–145. [31] R. B. Laughlin, “Quantized Hall conductivity in two dimensions”, Phys. Rev. B 23 (1981) 5632–5633. [32] N. Macris, P. A. Martin and J. V. Pul´e, “On edge states in semi-infinite quantum Hall systems”, J. Phys. A 32 (1999) 1985–1996. [33] S. Nakamura and J. Bellissard, “Low energy bands do not contribute to the quantum Hall effect”, Commun. Math. Phys. 131 (1990) 282–305. [34] R. Nest, “Cyclic cohomology of crossed products with Z”, J. Funct. Anan. 80 (1988) 235–283. [35] G. K. Pedersen, C ∗ -Algebras and Their Automorphism Groups, Academic Press, London, 1979. [36] M. Pimsner, “Ranges of traces on K0 of reduced crossed products by free groups”, pp. 374–408 in Lecture Notes in Mathematics Vol. 1132, Springer, Berlin, 1985.
December 27, 2001 16:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00110
Edge Current Channels and Chern Numbers
119
[37] M. Pimsner and D. Voiculescu, “Exact sequences for K-groups of certain crossproducts of C∗ -algebras”, J. Op. Theory 4 (1980) 93–118. [38] R. Prange and S. Girvin (eds), The Quantum Hall Effect, 2nd Edition, SpringerVerlag, Berlin, 1990. [39] S. Sakai, Operator Algebras in Dynamical Systems, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1991. [40] H. Schulz-Baldes and J. Bellissard, “Anomalous transport: a mathematical framework”, Rev. Math. Phys. 10 (1998) 1–46. [41] H. Schulz-Baldes and J. Bellissard, “A kinetic theory for quantum transport in aperiodic media”, J. Stat. Phys. 91 (1998) 991–1027. [42] H. Schulz-Baldes, J. Kellendonk and T. Richter, “Simultaneous quantization of the edge and bulk Hall conductivity”, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 33 (2000) L27–L32. [43] D. J. Thouless, M. Kohmoto, M. P. Nightingale and M. den Nijs, “Quantized Hall conductance in a two-dimensional periodic potential”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 49 (1982) 405–408. [44] Wegge-Olsen, K-theory and C ∗ -Algebras, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1993.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 2 (2002) 121–171 c World Scientific Publishing Company
LINDSTEDT SERIES FOR PERTURBATIONS OF ISOCHRONOUS SYSTEMS: A REVIEW OF THE GENERAL THEORY
MICHELE BARTUCCELLI Department of Mathematics and Statistics University of Surrey, Guildford, GU2 5XH, UK
[email protected] GUIDO GENTILE Dipartimento di Matematica, Universit` a di Roma Tre Roma, I-00146, Italy
[email protected]
Received 8 December 2000 We give a proof of the persistence of invariant tori for analytic perturbations of isochronous systems by using the Lindstedt series expansion for the solutions of the equations of motion. With respect to the case of anisochronous systems, there is the additional problem of finding the set of allowed rotation vectors, because they cannot be given a priori simply by looking at the unperturbed system. By considering the involved parameters (size of the perturbation, rotation vector and average action of a persisting invariant torus) as independent parameters we can introduce a function which is analytic in such parameters and only when the latter satisfy some constraint it becomes a solution: this can be regarded as a sort of singular implicit function problem. Therefore, although the dependence of the parameters, hence of the solution, upon the size of the perturbation is not smooth, in this way we construct explicitly the solution by using an absolutely convergent power series.
1. Introduction 1.1. Lindstedt series and KAM theorem. The KAM theorem assures the persistence of a large number of invariant tori under perturbations of integrable systems. For analytic Hamiltonians a posteriori one can consider the equations of motion and look directly for analytic quasi-periodic solutions, by writing them as formal power series, Lindstedt series, in the size of the perturbation: when such solutions exist, the series representing them must converge. This is a quite natural approach, and in fact it was the first to be attempted, for instance by Poincar´e [14], who, however, doubted that, in general, the series could converge. The problem was then solved by Kolmogorov [12], and it gave rise to a large amount of literature about what has became known as KAM theory. Exponential bounds on the coefficients of the Lindstedt series are obtained in the proof from the analysis of an implicit function problem, but the mechanism which remained unclear was how 121
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
122
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
the single terms arising in the perturbative expansion of the Lindstedt series and separately growing much faster than exponentially still admit an exponential bound when summed together [13], and the problem was referred to (improperly) as the “problem of a direct proof of KAM theorem”. This was the state of the art until very recently, when the problem was solved by Eliasson [6], for the anisochronous case. In fact in such a case the non-degeneracy condition for the free Hamiltonian allows us to construct for the perturbed system an invariant torus run with a rotation vector chosen among those of the free system: more precisely, if, with obvious notations, {α(t) = ωt, A(t) = A0 } is an orbit on an invariant torus for the integrable anisochronous Hamiltonian H0 (A), one considers the perturbed system H(α, A) = H0 (A) + f (α, A, ε), with f (α, A, ε) = O(ε), and, for |ε| < ε0 , with ε0 small enough, and ω satisfying a Diophantine condition, one looks for a quasiperiodic solution of the equations of motion which has the same rotation vector ω. In the isochronous case an approach of this kind is not so straightforward. In fact for H0 (A) = ω · A all tori have the same rotation vector ω, while for the perturbed system H(α, A) = ω · A + f (α, A, ε), with f (α, A, ε) = O(ε), the KAM theorem states the existence of invariant tori for |ε| < ε0 , with ε0 small enough, but with rotation vectors different from that of the unperturbed system: in addition the latter depend (in general) on ε and the dependence is not a smooth one. So it is not clear at all how to extend the Lindstedt series, mostly because there is no hope to obtain an analytic dependence on ε. Here we address the just described question. We prefer to consider a particular case, rather simplified with respect to the most general one can conceive, but still retaining the most important features of the general case. We consider a twodimensional case, in which the frequency of one harmonic oscillator is fixed once and for all ( i.e. it is simply a clock). We follow the spirit of the approach by Gallavotti [8], where Eliasson’s work was revisited by considering a simplified model (Thirring model), in order to separate the general strategy of the proof from the technical intricacies which would make it less terse. Moreover such a case is already interesting for physical applications [1], for example in the study of the stability of the upside-down pendulum whose point of support is subjected to a fast oscillation in the vertical direction. Extensions to more general systems will be discussed at the end (see also Sec. 1.10 below). ¯ ∈ Rm and for A¯1 ∈ C define the following 1.2. The model. For m ∈ N, for x domains: Σκ = {α ∈ C2 : Re αj ∈ T , x) = {x ∈ C Br (¯
m
|Im αj | < κ, j = 1, 2} ,
¯ | < r} , : |x − x
Aρ (A¯1 ) = {A ∈ C2 : |A1 − A¯1 | < ρ} . Consider the system described by the Hamiltonian
(1.1)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
H = ω · A + f (α, A1 , ε) ,
123
(1.2)
where A = (A1 , A2 ) ∈ R2 and α = (α1 , α2 ) ∈ T2 are conjugate variables, ω = (µ, 1), with µ ∈ (0, 1), · denotes the inner product in R2 and f is a function real analytic in the variables α, A1 and ε, and holomorphic in a complex domain D = Σκ × D × Bε1 (0) ,
(1.3)
with D ⊂ C an open subset, and such that f = 0 for ε = 0; so one can write in (1.3) f (α, A1 , ε) =
∞ X
εk f (k) (α, A1 ) .
(1.4)
k=1
The system (1.2) represents two harmonic oscillators interacting through a potential depending only on the angles and on the action variable A1 . The corresponding equations of motion are α˙ 1 = µ + ∂A1 f , α˙ 2 = 1 , (1.5) A˙ 1 = −∂α1 f , ˙ A2 = −∂α2 f , so that the angle α2 rotates with constant angular velocity, i.e. α2 (t) = t. Here and henceforth ∂x denotes the partial derivative with respect to x: if x = (x1 , x2 ) then ∂x = (∂x1 , ∂x2 ). 1.3. Results. Assume that ω in (1.2) satisfies the Diophantine condition |ω · ν| > C|ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(1.6)
with Diophantine constants C > 0 and τ > 1. We shall prove the following results: (1) if ω0 is a rotation vector close enough to ω and with comparable Diophantine properties (i.e. with Diophantine constants C0 = bC and τ , for some constant ¯ one can fix a value ε b ∈ (0, 1)), then for all A0 close enough to a prefixed A, for which there exists an invariant torus with rotation vector ω 0 and average action A0 for the Hamiltonian with perturbative parameter suitably fixed (close to 0) and depending analytically on A0 ; (2) instead of fixing the average action, we can fix the value of the perturbative parameter ε and look for the invariant tori persisting under perturbation: we have that infinitely many of them persist, with rotation vectors ω 0 close enough to ω and with average actions depending on ω0 . The first result is peculiar to isochronous systems, while the second one is quite analogous to the anischronous KAM theorem and it is the usual form in which it is stated in the literature, up to a quantitative characterization of the “infinitely many tori” and an estimate of the relative measure of the points in phase space
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
124
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
lying on invariant tori. If we allow a much weaker Diophantine condition, that is we let b to be a power of ε, such a measure can be shown to tend to 1 for ε → 0; we shall can back to such a problem in Sec. 6 (see also Sec. 1.10 below). We can state more formally the above results as follows. ¯ = (A¯1 , A¯2 ), with A¯1 ∈ D, and ρ > 0 such that Bρ (A¯1 ) ⊂ D. 1.4. Theorem. Fix A Consider the equations of motions (1.5), corresponding to the Hamiltonian (1.2), with ω = (µ, 1) satisfying the Diophantine condition (1.6), and suppose that Z dα ∂A1 f (1) (α, A1 ) 6= 0 ∀ A1 ∈ Bρ (A¯1 ) . (1.7) T2
There is a universal constant b ∈ (0, 1) and three b-dependent constants a > 0, ρ0 ∈ (0, ρ) and κ0 ∈ (0, κ) such that for all µ0 ∈ (µ − aC, µ + aC), with ω 0 = (µ0 , 1) satisfying the Diophantine condition (1.8) |ω 0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ ∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} , C0 = bC , ¯ and for all A0 ∈ Aρ0 (A1 ), there is a value ε = ε(µ0 , A0 ) ∈ Bε1 (0), depending ¯ ¯ A0 , µ0 ) and H(ψ, A0 , µ0 ), analytically on A0 ∈ Aρ0 (A¯1 ), and two functions h(ψ, ¯ 0 0 analytic in (ψ, A0 ) ∈ Σκ × Aρ (A1 ) and with zero ψ-average, such that ( ¯ 0 t, A0 , µ0 ) , α(t) = ω 0 t + h(ω (1.9) ¯ 0 t, A0 , µ0 ) A(t) = A0 + H(ω is a solution of (1.5). The constant a depends on b, but it is independent of C. 1.5. Remarks. (1) The condition (1.7) is not really needed in order to prove the theorem: it is imposed just for simplicity, but it could be considerably weakened. See also Remark 2.13. (2) Since the function H has zero average, the vector A0 represents the average (over time) of the action variable for the quasi-periodic motion with rotation vector ω 0 : this means that we are looking for an invariant torus whose average action equals that of an unperturbed Diophantine one. ¯ = (A¯1 , A¯2 ), with A¯1 ∈ D. Consider the equations of 1.6. Theorem. Fix A motions (1.5) corresponding to the Hamiltonian (1.2), with ω = (µ, 1) satisfying the Diophantine condition |ω · ν| > C|ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
with Diophantine constants C > 0 and τ > 1, and suppose that Z 2 ¯ 6= 0 . dα ∂A f (1) (α, A) M≡ 1
(1.10)
(1.11)
T2
There is a universal constant b ∈ (0, 1) and two b-dependent constants ε¯ ∈ (0, ε1 ) and κ0 ∈ (0, κ) such that for all ε ∈ Bε¯(0) \ {0} there are a constant a > 0, infinitely many µ0 ∈ (µ − aε, µ + aε) with ω 0 = (µ0 , 1) satisfying the Diophantine condition |ω0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
C0 = bC ,
(1.12)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
125
and pairs of functions h∗ (ψ, ε, µ0 ) and H∗ (ψ, ε, µ0 ), analytic for ψ ∈ Σκ0 and with zero ψ-average, and a vector A∗ (ε, µ0 ) such that ( α(t) = ω 0 t + h∗ (ω 0 t, ε, µ0 ) , (1.13) A(t) = A∗ (ε, µ0 ) + H∗ (ω 0 t, ε, µ0 ) is a solution of (1.5). One has A∗2 (ε, µ0 ) = A¯2 and A∗1 (ε, µ0 ) ∈ D; the constant a depends on b, but it is independent of ε. 1.7. Remark. (1) The condition (1.11) could be considerably weakened. See also Remark 1.5 (1), and Remark 2.15. (2) We are fixing ε and ω0 and we want to detect an invariant torus with rotation vector ω 0 : to achieve such a goal we are forced to change (with respect to the unperturbed system) the average action into a value A∗ (ε, µ0 ): this is the meaning of the vector A∗ (ε, µ0 ) appearing in the statement of Theorem 1.6. 1.8. Idea of the proof. For ε = 0 and for all A0 ∈ R2 there is a solution {α(t) = ωt, A(t) = A0 } ,
(1.14)
lying on an invariant torus. Because of the isochrony of the unperturbed system we are not able to fix a priori the rotation vectors ω 0 of the quasi-periodic solutions for ε 6= 0. So we proceed by adopting the splitting µ0 + η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) = µ ,
(1.15)
where A0 is the same as in (1.14) and, to begin, µ0 is fixed in a rather arbitrary way. The above prescription leads to the system of equations α˙ 1 = µ0 + ∂A1 f + η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) , α˙ 2 = 1 , (1.16) ˙ A1 = −∂α1 f , ˙ A2 = −∂α2 f , hence, by ignoring the constraint given by Eq. (1.15), we look for a quasi-periodic solution of the modified system (1.16), where η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) is to be determined, with rotation vector ω0 , i.e. for a solution of the form ( α(t) = ω0 t + h(ω 0 t, A0 , ε, µ0 ) , (1.17) A(t) = A0 + H(ω0 t, A0 , ε, µ0 ) , where ω 0 = (µ0 , 1). The functions h and H are called the conjugating functions, while h is called the counterterm. If η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) is replaced with 0 in (1.15), so that ω 0 becomes ω, it is well known from KAM theory that there are not (in general) quasi-periodic solutions with rotation vector ω; on the other hand, as it is defined, η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) depends
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
126
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
only on µ0 and it is not obvious how µ0 has to be chosen nor if it can be chosen at all so that (1.15) is satisfied. Note that, if for some µ0 (1.15) is verified, then a solution of the true equations of motions (1.5), quasiperiodic with rotation vector ω 0 = (µ0 , 1), will have been found. We shall show that, by neglecting the constraint (1.15), for fixed µ0 it will be possible to choose in a unique way η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) as an analytic function of ε and of A0 in such a way that there exists a solution of (1.16) the form (1.17) with zero average: this will be the content of Lemma 2.2. We note that as long as the constraint (1.15) is neglected the solutions (1.17) of the equation of motion (and the corresponding counterterm) are analytic in ε as well in A0 : so we shall use the powerful machinery of the Lindstedt series for the analytic KAM theory also in a case in which the solution of the original equations of motion cannot be expected to be analytic. The idea of introducing suitable counterterms in the equations of motion in order to make them soluble is not new, and dates back to [13], where it was successfully used in order to give (among other things) a proof of the KAM theorem. Also in [10] (see also [9]) the existence of whiskers for hyperbolic tori (of codimension one) was proved for a class of almost integrable systems by studying a modified Hamiltonian obtained by introducing suitable counterterms. Of course one had to prove eventually that the original Hamiltonian could be recovered: in [10] the proof of such an assertion was a simple application of the implicit function theorem. Also in the present case, because of the introduction of the counterterm, we study a different system of equations, and, since the counterterm is uniquely determined, in general there is no hope to obtain, for ε, A0 and µ0 arbitrarily chosen, that such a counterterm satisfies (1.15). In our case (1.15) is not quite an implicit function problem, because the dependence of η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) on µ0 is not even smooth (the counterterm is defined on a Cantor-like set, as far as the dependence on µ0 is concerned). Nevertheless (1.15), seen either as an equation for ε for fixed A0 and µ0 or as an equation for A0 for fixed ε and µ0 , can be solved: this will lead to, respectively, Theorem 1.4 and Theorem 1.6 as it will be shown in Sec. 2. This means that we shall look for solutions of the form (1.17) where ε, A0 and µ0 are not independent of each other: we can choose ε as a function of µ0 and A0 , in such a way that the constraint (1.15) is satisfied, so that we can write ¯ h = h(ψ, A0 , µ0 ) = h(ψ, A0 , ε(µ0 , A0 ), µ0 ), and analogous expressions hold for the other quantities H and η. Then, fixed µ0 and A0 , ε is not a free parameter, and in principle we could not study the dependence of h in ε by varying ε without changing µ0 and A0 . Nevertheless, considering ε and (A0 , µ0 ) as independent parameters, then h(ψ, A0 , ε, µ0 ) turns out to be analytic in ε, and we shall see that we can use the analyticity of such a dependence in order to write the solution as a power series in ε. Analogously we can fix ε and µ0 (in an appropriate way) and choose A0 = A∗ (ε, µ0 ) as a function of both parameters, again in such a way that the constraint (1.15) is satisfied, so that we can write the solution as h = h∗ (ψ, ε, µ0 ) =
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
127
h(ψ, A∗ (ε, µ0 ), ε, µ0 ), and the same can be done for H and η. Note that in such a case even if h(ψ, A0 , ε, µ) is analytic in ε, the solution h∗ (ψ, ε, µ0 ) is not, as A∗ (ε, µ0 ) does not depend analytically on ε. 1.9. Comments about the statement of the theorems. Theorem 1.4 deals with the problem of fixing a rotation vector ω 0 = (µ0 , 1), with µ0 close to µ, and looking for a value ε = ε(µ0 , A0 ) such that the Hamiltonian (1.2) admits an invariant torus run with rotation vector ω 0 . Such a problem is of physical relevance, in studying the stability and the persistence of KAM tori near elliptic equilibrium points; applications are discussed in [1]. On the other hand one could also consider the following (different) problem: set Bρ (A0 ) = {A : |A − A0 | < ρ} ⊂ D × C, fix ε small enough and look for values µ0 close to µ and, correspondingly, values A∗ ∈ Bρ (A0 ) such that, for that value of ε, the Hamiltonian (1.2) admits a solution parameterized by the action A∗ ( i.e. such that the average of the action variables is A∗ ) and run with rotation vector ω 0 = (µ0 , 1). Theorem 1.6 deals exactly with such a problem. 1.10. Invariant tori for fixed ε. One can also ask how many tori persist under perturbations, that is, with the same notations as in Sec. 1.9, which fraction of phase space in Bρ (A0 )×T2 , once ε has been fixed to some value (small enough), correspond to invariant tori (run with some rotation vector) persisting under perturbation for that value of ε: the answer is that, if the condition (1.11) of Theorem 1.6 is replaced with a non-degeneracy condition like Z 2 (1) dα ∂A1 f (α, A1 ) > 0 , (1.18) inf A1 ∈D
T2
then the set of initial data (A, α) ∈ Bρ (A0 ) × T2 for trajectories which lie on invariant tori persisting under perturbation form a set of relative measure tending to 1 as ε → 0. This can be proved with standard arguments of KAM theory (see for instance [5] and [15]): it could also be studied by using the same techniques introduced in the present paper; we shall briefly (and informally) discuss such an aspect in Sec. 6 below. 1.11. Comments about the proof of the theorem. In studying the functions h, H, η in which ε and µ0 are seen as independent parameters neither the special form of the interaction nor the fact that the dimension is d = 2 play any rˆ ole. So Lemma 2.2 below can be extended (essentially with no change) to any perturbations of Hamiltonian isochronous systems in any dimensions. The notations we shall use will make such an extension trivial: simply interpret the vectors as vectors in Rd , and note (while reading the proof) that the special form of the interaction is not really used; for this reason we shall write f (α, A) = f (α, A1 ), even if in our case the perturbation does not depend explicitly on A2 ; see also Remark 3.5.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
128
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
On the contrary in order to solve the compatibility condition (1.15), the discussion in Sec. 2 applies only to the Hamiltonians of the special form (1.2). The methods extend to the general situation, but some further arguments become necessary; in Sec. 6 we briefly discuss how such an extension can be carried out. 1.12. Contents of the paper. In Sec. 2 we state the main technical result of the paper (Lemma 2.2), which deals with the modified system (1.6), and we show how it implies Theorems 1.4 and 1.6. The immediately following sections are devoted to the proof of Lemma 2.2: in Sec. 3 we introduce the tree formalism which will be used in Sec. 4 to prove that Eqs. (1.16) are formally soluble, for a suitable choice of the counterterm, and in Sec. 5 to prove that the formal series defining the conjugating functions and the counterterm are converging: in particular this will implies that all quantities are analytic in the perturbative parameter ε (the more technical aspects of the proofs will be relegated into the Appendices). Finally in Sec. 6 we discuss possible extensions and generalizations of the results, particularly those concerning the problem of studying the measure of the persisting invariant tori in phase space. For the proof of Lemma 2.2 we could have relied on the existing literature, as [3] and [11], and simply outlined the main differences with respect to it. However we preferred to give the proof in full details both because the paper is meant as a review of the techniques (hence a selfcontained discussion makes it more readable) and becuase in this way we profit to try to clarify the graphic construction through a number of examples and pictures; furthermore some technical improvements are presented with respect to the quoted papers.
2. Persistence of Invariant Tori 2.1. The modified model. As outlined in Sec. 1.8, for the moment, we study Eqs. (1.16), where µ0 is fixed, and η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) is a function to be determined. Of course this is not the original model, so at the end we shall have the problem to show that the results we find can be fruitfully used in order to draw conclusions also for the model in which the constraint (1.15) is taken into account. We shall prove the following result for the modified model, given by (1.16) without the constraint (1.15). ¯ = (A¯1 , A¯2 ), with A¯1 ∈ D, and ρ > 0 such that Bρ (A¯1 ) ⊂ D. 2.2. Lemma. Fix A Given the equations of motions α˙ 1 = µ0 + ∂A1 f , α˙ 2 = 1 , A˙ 1 = −∂α1 f , ˙ A2 = −∂α2 f ,
(2.1)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
129
with ω 0 = (µ0 , 1) satisfying the Diophantine condition |ω0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(2.2)
with Diophantine constants C0 > 0 and τ > 1, there exist three constants ε0 ∈ (0, ε1 ), ρ0 ∈ (0, ρ) and κ0 ∈ (0, κ), two functions h(ψ, A, ε, µ0 ) and H(ψ, A, ε, µ0 ), analytic in (ψ, A, ε) for ψ ∈ Σκ0 , A ∈ Aρ0 (A01 ) and |ε| < ε0 and with vanishing ψ-average on T2 , and a unique function η(A, ε, µ0 ), analytic in ε for |ε| < ε0 and in A for |A1 − A¯1 | < ρ0 , such that all three functions are vanishing for ε = 0, and, for all A0 ∈ Aρ0 (A¯1 ) and |ε| < ε0 , ( α(t) = ω 0 t + h(ω 0 t, A0 , ε, µ0 ) , (2.3) A(t) = A0 + H(ω 0 t, A0 , ε, µ0 ) is a solution of α˙ 1 = µ0 + ∂A1 f + η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) , α˙ 2 = 1 , A˙ 1 = −∂α1 f , ˙ A2 = −∂α2 f .
(2.4)
Moreover one has ε0 = min{E0 C0 , ε1 } for some constant E0 independent of µ0 . 2.3. Proof of Theorem 1.4. The proof of Lemma 2.2 will be performed in the following Secs. 3–5 (and in the Appendices). Now we come back to the original problem (1.5), and we show how the above lemma can be used in order to prove Theorem 1.4. Lemma 2.2 shows that, for ω 0 satisfying the Diophantine condition |ω0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(2.5)
the series defining the conjugating functions and the counterterm converge and have a radius of convergence in ε bounded from below by ε0 = E0 C0 , for some constant E0 (assume for simplicity E0 C0 ≤ ε1 ). Now we want to use such a property to prove the following result, which immediately yields Theorem 1.4. 2.4. Proposition. Let η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) be given by Lemma 2.2, such that the functions (1.17) solve (1.16), and suppose (see (1.7)) that Z (1) dα∂A1 f (1) (α, A01 ) 6= 0 . (2.6) ∂A1 f0 (A0 ) ≡ T2
Then given µ ∈ (0, 1) such that ω = (µ, 1) satisfies the Diophantine condition |ω · ν| > C|ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(2.7)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
130
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
with Diophantine constants C > 0 and τ > 1, there exists a > 0 such that it is possible to fix µ0 ∈ BaC (µ) such that ω 0 = (µ0 , 1) satisfies the Diophantine condition |ω 0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(2.8)
with C0 = bC, for some positive constant b, and to fix ε ≡ ε(µ0 , A0 ), with |ε| < ε0 , such that µ = µ0 + η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) ,
(2.9)
holds for ε = ε(µ0 ). 2.5. Continued fractions and approximants. We shall prove Proposition 2.4 through a series of (elementary) lemmata. We need some preliminary notations. Given µ ∈ (0, 1) denote by [a0 , a1 , a2 , . . .] its continued fraction expansion and by {pk /qk } its best approximants. Then if ω = (µ, 1) and ν k = (qk , pk ) one has [17], 1 1 > |ω · ν k | > , qk+1 2qk+1
(2.10)
|ω · ν| > |ω · ν k | ∀ ν = (q, p) such that qk < q < qk+1 .
(2.11)
and
Note also that qk < |ν k | < 2qk ,
(2.12)
for all k ∈ N. 2.6. Lemma. If ω = (µ, 1) satisfies the Diophantine condition |ω · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(2.13)
then 2τ qk+1 < , τ qk C0
(2.14)
for any k ∈ N. 2.7. Proof of Lemma 2.6. For any k one has by (2.10) and (2.13) 1 qk+1
> |ω · ν k | > C0 |ν k |−τ ,
(2.15)
so that by (2.12) (2qk )τ > |ν k |τ > C0 qk+1 , and the assertion follows.
(2.16)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
131
2.8. Lemma. If one has 1 qk+1 < , qkτ 2C0
(2.17)
for any k ∈ N, then ω = (µ, 1) satisfies the Diophantine condition (2.13). 2.9. Proof of Lemma 2.8. For ν = ν k one has by (2.10), (2.12) and (2.17) |ω · ν k | >
1 2qk+1
>
C0 C0 > , τ qk |ν k |τ
(2.18)
while for ν 6= ν k one can reason as follows. If ν = (qk , p), with p 6= pk , then |ω · ν| > 1/2 and (2.17) is trivially satisfied. If ν = (q, p), with qk−1 < q < qk , then by (2.10) and (2.11) |ω · ν| > |ω · ν k−1 | >
1 C0 C0 C0 > τ > τ > , 2qk qk−1 q |ν|τ
(2.19)
so that (2.13) follows. 2.10. Lemma. Given a rotation vector ω = (µ, 1), with µ ∈ (0, 1), satisfying the Diophantine condition |ω · ν| > C|ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(2.20)
and fixed any interval I ⊂ R with center in µ, there exist infinitely many µ0 ∈ I ∩ (0, 1) such that ω 0 = (µ0 , 1) satisfies the Diophantine condition |ω 0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(2.21)
with C0 = bC, for some constant positive b. 2.11. Proof of Lemma 2.10. Given µ = [a0 , a1 , a2 , . . .] and any interval I with center in µ define µ0 = [a00 , a01 , a02 , . . .] in the following way: ( 0 ak = ak , if k ≤ k0 , (2.22) a0k ≤ N , if k > k0 , where k0 is so large that µ0 ∈ I and N is an integer. Then qk0 = qk for all k ≤ k0 , so that 0 qk+1 2τ , < qk0τ C
(2.23)
0 0 ≤ N qk0 + qk−1 ≤ 2N qk0 < 2N qk0τ qk0 +1 = a0k qk0 + qk−1
(2.24)
by Lemma 2.6, while
for all k > k0 . Then, by Lemma 2.8, ω 0 = (µ0 , 1) satisfies the Diophantine condition |ω0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
(2.25)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
132
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
with C0 = min{C/2τ +1, 1/4N }. If we set a0k ∈ {1, . . . , N } for all k > k0 , we obtain an infinite set of values satisfying the Diophantine condition (2.25). So, as one has C ≤ µ + 1 ≤ 2, the lemma is proved, with b = min{1/2τ +1, 1/16N }. 2.12. Proof of Proposition 2.4. Lemma 2.2 shows that the function η(A, ε, µ0 ) is analytic in ε, with radius of convergence ε0 = E0 C0 , so that one has η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) = εη (1) (A0 , µ0 ) + O(ε2 ), for |ε| < ε0 small enough. The condition (1.7) assures that (1) one has η (1) (A0 , µ0 ) = −∂A1 f0 (A0 ) 6= 0 (see Remark 4.4): then there exists a positive constant η1 such that |η (1) (A0 , µ0 )| > η1 , for any µ0 ∈ BaC (µ) — in fact η (1) (A0 , µ0 ) ≡ η (1) (A0 ) does not depend on µ0 . Therefore, varying ε in (−ε0 , ε0 ), with ε0 = E0 C0 = E0 bC, the function η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) covers an interval BdC (0), for some positive constant d (depending on b). As |µ − µ0 | is bounded by aC, one can choose a < d so that by moving ε in (−ε0 , ε0 ) there is at least one value ε = ε(µ0 , A0 ) such that η(A0 , ε(µ0 , A0 ), µ0 ) = µ − µ0 . (1)
2.13. Remark. The condition ∂A1 f0 6= 0 imposed on f is not really necessary, and it is simply aimed to assures that the counterterm is not identically vanishing. In fact under such a weaker condition, if η (k0 ) is the first nonvanishing coefficient in the expansion (3.1) for η(A0 , ε, µ0 ), then, at worst, when ε is varied in (−ε0 , ε0 ), the counterterm η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) covers an interval of width at least 2dC k0 , for some d > 0, so that a result analogous to Proposition 2.4 follows, provided the width of the interval I is chosen |I| = 2aC k0 , for some a < d. Note that the condition that the counterterm is not identically vanishing to first order amounts to a genericity condition on the perturbation f . 2.14. Proof of Theorem 1.6. Now suppose that, instead of the condition (1.7), one requires Z (1) ¯ 2 2 dα ∂A f (1) (α, A¯1 ) 6= 0 . (2.26) M ≡ ∂A1 f0 (A) ≡ 1 T2
Then, instead of fixing the action variables and moving ε until the compatibility condition (1.15) is satisfied (as in Sec. 2.12), we can fix ε small enough (say smaller than a value ε¯ to be determined) and slightly change A¯1 into a nearby value A01 such that one still has µ0 + η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) = µ ,
A0 = (A01 , A¯2 ) ,
(2.27)
for some µ0 such that ω0 = (µ0 , 1) satisfies the Diophantine condition |ω 0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
ω0 = (µ0 , 1) ,
(2.28)
with C0 = bC, for some constant b ∈ (0, 1). This can be easily seen by reasoning as follows. Henceforth we denote A = (A1 , A¯2 ), where A¯2 is fixed once and for all. Fix A¯1 ∈ D and ρ such that Bρ (A¯1 ) ⊂ D; let us fix 0 < δ < ρ0 , where ρ0 is (1) 2 f (A)| > M/2: given by Lemma 2.2, such that for all A ∈ Aδ (A¯1 ) one has |∂A 1 0 (1) therefore for A varying in Aδ/2 (A¯1 ) the quantity ε∂A1 f (A) covers an interval 0
J(ε) such that |J(ε)| = O(ε); more precisely one has |J(ε)| > M εδ/4.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
133
Let ε¯ ≤ ε0 be such that for any |ε| < ε¯ the interval µ + J(ε) contains at least one value µ0 , such that ω0 = (µ0 , 1) verifies the the Diophantine condition |ω 0 · ν| > C1 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Z2 \ {0} ,
ω 0 = (µ0 , 1) ,
(2.29)
with C1 = b1 C, for some constant b1 ∈ (0, 1); by reasoning as for proving Lemma 2.10 it is easy to realize that this is possible. By applying once more Lemma 2.10 we can conclude that for all a0 > 0 the interval Ba0 C (µ0 ) contains values µ0 such that ω 0 = (µ0 , 1) satisfies (2.28), for some constant b such that C0 = b2 C1 = b2 b1 C ≡ bC: in particular this yields that J(ε) contains infinitely many such µ0 . Fix ε such that |ε| ≤ ε¯ and choose A00 ∈ Aδ/2 (A¯1 ) such that µ0 = µ − εη (1) (A00 ) ,
η (1) (A00 ) = −∂A1 f (1) (A00 ) ;
(2.30)
we can suppose that A00 is such that η (1) (A00 ) 6= 0 (if not simply choose a nearby value µ0 6= 0 and use the property (2.26)). Then write, for any A ∈ Aδ (A¯1 ), η(A, ε, µ0 ) = ε η (1) (A) + ε2 ξ(A, ε, µ0 ) ,
sup ¯1 ) A∈Aδ (A
|ξ(A, ε, µ0 )| ≤ Ξ ,
(2.31)
with Ξ a suitable constant: this follows again from Lemma 2.2, by taking into account that δ < ρ0 . Then define A0 implicitly as the solution of the equation µ = µ0 − ε∂A1 f (1) (A00 ) = µ0 − ε∂A1 f (1) (A0 ) + ε2 ξ(A0 , ε, µ0 ) ≡ µ0 + η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) :
(2.32)
if such a solution exists with A01 in Bρ0 (A¯1 ), then we have proved (2.27). The solution A0 of (2.32) can be found as a simple consequence of the implicit function theorem. In fact the function F (A01 , ε) ≡ ∂A1 f (1) (A00 ) − ∂A1 f (1) (A0 ) + ε ξ(A0 , ε, µ0 )
(2.33)
is analytic both in A01 and in ε (for A01 ∈ Bρ0 (A¯1 ) and ε ∈ Bε0 (0)). As F (A001 , 0) = 0 ,
2 ∂A01 F (A001 , 0) = −∂A f (1) (A00 ) 6= 0 , 1
(2.34)
there exists a value A01 = A01 (ε) such that F (A01 (ε), ε) = 0 ;
(2.35)
moreover one has M 0 |A − A00 | , (2.36) 2 so that there exists A01 ∈ Bδ (A¯1 ) ⊂ Bρ0 (A¯1 ), provided that ε¯ is so small that one has 4Ξ¯ ε < M δ, and the assertion is proved. |∂A1 f (1) (A0 ) − ∂A1 f (1) (A00 )| >
2.15. Remark. As already noted in Remark 1.7 (1), the condition (1.11) is not really necessary in order to prove Theorem 1.6: what one has to require is that the counterterm is not constant in the action variable A1 , for A1 ∈ D.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
134
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
3. Perturbation Theory 3.1. Lindstedt series. In the following we assume that A0 and µ0 are fixed once and for all, and we shall not write explicitly the dependence on A0 and µ0 : so we shall write η(A0 , ε, µ0 ) = η(ε), and so on. We look for a solution of the form (2.3), with h(ψ, ε) = H(ψ, ε) = η(ε) =
∞ X k=1 ∞ X k=1 ∞ X
X
εk
eiν·ψ h(k) ν ,
ν∈Z2
X
εk
eiν·ψ H(k) ν ,
(3.1)
ν∈Z2
εk η (k) .
k=1
The formal series (3.1) are called the Lindstedt series. Note that writing h = (h1 , h2 ) one has h2 = 0 identically as α2 (t) = t for any ε. More generally, for any function F = F (ψ, A0 , ε) analytic in its arguments and (k) (k) 2π-periodic in ψ, we denote by [F ]ν the coefficient Fν with Fourier label ν and Taylor label k in its expansion F (ψ, A0 , ε) =
∞ X k=1
εk
X
∞ X
eiν·ψ Fν(k) (A0 ) ≡
ν∈Z2
k=1
εk
X
eiν·ψ Fν(k) .
(3.2)
ν∈Z2
If we put (2.3) into (2.4) by using the expansion (3.1) we obtain, for ν 6= 0, (k)
(k)
hν = g(ω0 · ν)[∂A f ]ν , (k)
(3.3)
(k)
Hν = −g(ω0 · ν)[∂α f ]ν , with g(ω 0 · ν) =
1 iω0 · ν
,
(3.4)
provided that, for ν = 0, one has (k)
η (k) + [∂A1 f ]0 = 0 ,
(3.5)
(k)
[∂α f ]0 = 0 . We can write (3.3) as h(k) ν
H(k) ν
∗ X 1 1 = g(ν) p! q! ∗ X 1 1 = −g(ν) p! q!
p Y
! iν 0 ·
(k 0 ) hν pp0
p0 =1 p Y p0 =1
p+q Y
! (k 0 ) Hν qq0
· ∂A ∂A fν(k) (A0 ) , 0
q0 =p+1
! iν 0 ·
(k 0 ) hν pp0
p+q Y
! (k 0 ) Hν qq0
· ∂A (iν 0 )fν(k) (A0 ) , 0
q0 =p+1
(3.6)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
where
P∗
135
is a shorthand for ∗ X
=
∞ X ∞ ∞ X X k0 =1 p=0 q=0
X
X
;
(3.7)
k1 ≥1,...,kp+q ≥1 ν1 ∈Z2 ,...,νp+q ∈Z2 k0 +k1 +···+kp+q =k ν0 +ν1 +···+ν p+q =ν
for k = 1 the formulae in (3.6) have to be interpreted in the appropriate (obvious) (k) way. Note in (3.6) that Hν is given by a sum of contributions which have always (k) (at least) one derivative with respect to α, whereas hν is given by the sum of contributions which have always (at least) one derivative with respect to A. Then (k) we can introduce the following notation: Hν is given by a sum of terms which (k) are of the form H ← h, where H denotes that they contribute to Hν and h that there is always a derivative with respect to the angle variables; in the same way, (k) hν is given by a sum of terms which are of the form h ← H, where h denotes that (k) they contribute to hν and H that there is always a derivative with respect to the action variables. So we have two kinds of problems: first to show the formal solubility of Eqs. (2.4), i.e. to show that to each perturbative order (3.5) are satisfied so that no division by zero is performed; then to show that the formal series (3.1) defining h, H and η converge. 3.2. Notations. We introduce some notations which will be used in the following. Given a set of elements S we denote by |S| the number of elements in S. Recall that ∂x denotes the partial derivative with respect to x. If a function F depends only on one argument, F = F (x), then we shall write sometimes ∂F (x) for ∂x F (x), as no ambiguity can arise in such a case. Given a vector v = (v1 , v2 ) ∈ R2 we set |v| = |v1 | + |v2 |. If v ∈ R2 then for any p ∈ N the quantity vp denotes the tensor with entries vi1 · · · vip , where ij ∈ {1, 2} q will denotes the tensor with entries ∂Ai1 · · · ∂Aiq for all j = 1, . . . , p. Likewise ∂A where ij ∈ {1, 2} for all j = 1, . . . , q. 3.3. Tree expansion. An unlabeled tree θ is a partially ordered set of points and lines connecting the points. The partial ordering relation between the nodes is from right to left and it denoted by . The leftmost point r is called the root of the tree; all the other points are called nodes and are denoted by v. The lines are denoted by `; they carry an arrow oriented towards the root. If a line ` connects a node v2 to a node v1 v2 , we shall say that the line is attached to the nodes v1 and v2 , and write ` = `v2 and v20 = v1 : we say also that the line enters v1 and exits from v2 , and that v1 is the node immediately following v2 . The line ` entering the root is the root line. The node v0 which it exits from is called the last node of the tree: one has `0 = `v0 . See Fig. 1. We shall call V (θ) the set of nodes in θ and Λ(θ) the set of lines in θ; one has |V (θ)| = |Λ(θ)|.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
136
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
%
&
'
(
)
0
!
"
1
,
2
Fig. 1.
*
/
3
-
.
#
4
An unlabeled tree θ with 18 nodes.
Two trees are said to be equivalent if they are obtained from each other by continuously deforming the lines in such a way that the latter do not cross each other: in the following we shall always identify equivalent trees. Given a tree θ and any node v ≺ v0 , the set θ0 of nodes w v and of lines connecting them form with the line `v a tree with root v 0 and root line `v : we say that θ0 is a subtree of θ. We denote by θ \ θ0 the set of nodes in V (θ) \ V (θ0 ) and of lines connecting them; we shall write also V (θ) \ V (θ0 ) = V (θ \ θ0 ). We shall write the perturbation f as f (α, A1 , ε) = f (α, A, ε), even if the dependence is only through the first component A1 of A; see Remark 3.5. Then f can be expanded as f (α, A, ε) =
∞ X
εk f (k) (α, A) =
k=1
∞ X
εk
k=1
X
eiν·α fν(k) (A);
(3.8)
ν∈Z2
note that, by the analyticity assumptions on f , one has k −κ|ν| e , |fν(k) (A)| < F01 F02
F01 =
max
|ε|=ε0 |A1 −A01 |=ρ0
|f (α, A, ε)| ,
F02 = ε0−1 ,
(3.9)
for any 0 < ε0 < ε1 and 0 < ρ0 < ρ. Then to each node v we associate a mode label ν v ∈ Z2 and an order label kv ∈ N. We define the order k of a tree as the sum of the values of the order labels of the nodes: X kv . (3.10) k= v∈V (θ)
Note that if kv = 1 for all v ∈ V (θ) then k = |V (θ)|. Define the momentum flowing through a line `v as X νw . ν `v = wv
(3.11)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
137
To each node v we associate a node factor Fv , which is a function of ν v , while to each line ` we associate a propagator G` , which is a function of ω 0 · ν ` . We distinguish between two kinds of lines, lines h ← H and lines H ← h, and we assign to them and to the nodes they exit from different values for G` and Fv , if ` = `v , in the following way. We associate to each node v three non-negative integer labels pv , qv and mv with the constraint pv + qv = mv : mv is the number of lines entering v, while the labels pv and qv denote, respectively, the number of lines h ← H and H ← h entering it. Given a node v let us denote by ` = `v the line exiting from it. Then the node factor Fv and the propagator G` are defined as h←H
H ←h
1 1 qv +1 (kv ) (iν v )pv ∂A fν v (A0 ) pv ! qv ! g(ω 0 · ν ` )
1 1 qv (kv ) (iν v )pv +1 ∂A fν v (A0 ) , pv ! qv ! −g(ω0 · ν ` ) .
` Fv G`
(3.12)
Note that for f (α, A, ε) = f (α, A1 , ε) the only nonvanishing entry of the tensor (k) q (k) q fν (A0 ) is ∂A fν (A0 ). ∂A 1 If we introduce a label δv such that δv = 1 if `v is a line h ← H and δv = 0 if `v is a line H ← h, then Fv can be written as 1 1 qv +δv (kv ) (iν v )pv +(1−δv ) ∂A fν v (A0 ) (3.13) Fv = pv ! qv ! in both cases. Note that one has 1 q (k) |∂ f (A)| < F1 F2k e−κ|ν| F3q , q! A ν F1 =
max
|ε|=ε0 |A1 −A01 |=ρ0
|f (α, A, ε)| ,
F2 = ε0 − 1 ,
F3 = ρ0−1 ,
(3.14)
by (3.9) and by the assumptions on the dependence on A. We have that X ∈ {h, H} can be written as X (k) Val(θ) , Xν = θ∈Tk, (X)
Val(θ) =
Y v∈V (θ)
Fv
!
Y
! G`
(3.15) ,
`∈Λ(θ)
where Tk,ν (X) is the set of all labeled trees of order k with momentum ν flowing through the root line and such that if X = h then the root line is a line h ← H, while if X = H then the root line is a line H ← h. The proof of (3.15) can be performed by induction on the order k, by using (3.3) and expanding the functions in the square brackets. Define also ! ! Y Y 0 Fv G` , (3.16) Val (θ) = v∈V (θ)
`∈Λ(θ)\`0
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
138
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
where `0 is the root line. If we introduce the vector η = (η, 0), so that η (k) = (η (k) , 0), then also η admits a representation X Val0 (θ) , (3.17) η (k) = − θ∈Tk,0 (h)
where Tk,0 (h) means that the trees over which the sum is performed have the constraint that the root line is a line h ← H; see (5.5). We denote also by Tk,ν the set of all labeled trees of order k and with momentum ν flowing through the root line, with no condition on the kind of root line. 3.4. Formal solubility and solubility. We shall prove first of all that the coefficients defining the formal series (3.1) are finite to each perturbative order, i.e. that (k) one has |hν | < ∞ for all k ∈ N and for all ν ∈ Z2 . Hence we shall deal with the problem to prove the convergence of the series: this will require a more careful analysis of the tree values, inspired to the renormalization group approach in quantum field theory. 3.5. Remark. The tree representation given in this section can be carried out, essentially unchanged, for any analytic perturbation of isochronous systems of any dimension d. This explains why we used the notation (3.8) for the perturbation and the vectorial notation (3.17) for the counterterms: of course in general all the components of the counterterms are not vanishing. 4. Proof of the Formal Solubility of the Equations of Motion 4.1. Formal solubility. To show that there exists a formal solution (2.3) of the equations of motion (2.4) we have to show that for any θ no division by zero occurs in Val(θ) and in Val0 (θ). Recall that, given any tree θ, any line ` ∈ Λ(θ) can be considered as the root line of the subtree formed by the nodes and lines preceding (k) `. So we have to show that the sum of all trees contributing to [∂α f ]0 is vanishing, (k) provided that η (k) is chosen in such a way that η (k) + [∂A f ]0 = 0. Then the formal solubility is implied from the following result. 4.2. Lemma. There is a unique choice for the coefficients η (k) such that, for all (k) (k) k ≥ 1, one has [∂α f ]0 = 0 and η (k) + [∂A f ]0 = 0. Such a choice is given by (3.17). 4.3. Proof of Lemma 4.2. The proof can be done by induction. For k = 1 the assertion is trivially satisfied, as (1) [∂α f ](1) ν = iνfν (A0 ) ,
(4.1)
which is vanishing for ν = 0, while imposing (1)
[∂A1 f ]0 + η (1) = 0 fixes η
(1)
as in (3.17).
(4.2)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
139
If the assertion holds for all k 0 < k then we can show that it holds also for k. By the inductive hypothesis all lines in θ which are not the root line have a nonvanishing momentum (as they are the root lines of subtrees of order strictly less than k), so that Val0 (θ) is well defined. Then consider all contributions arising from the trees θ ∈ Tk,0 (H), hence having as root line a line H ← h: we group together all trees obtained from each other by shifting the root line, i.e. by changing the node which the root line exits and orienting the arrows in such a way that they still point towards the root. We call F (θ) such a class of trees (here θ is any element inside the class). See Fig. 2.
!
"
#
$
Fig. 2.
The family F (θ) = {θ, θ 0 , θ 00 } for a tree θ ∈ T3,0 . The labels are not explicitly shown.
The values Val0 (θ0 ) of such trees θ0 ∈ F (θ) differ as (1) there is a factor iν v depending on the node v which the root line is attached to (see the definition (3.10) of Fv for the lines H ← h), and (2) some arrows change their directions. More precisely, when the root line is detached from the node v0 and reattached to the node v, if P(v0 , v) = {w ∈ V (θ) : v0 w v} denotes the path joining the node v0 to the node v, all the lines h ← H along the path P(v0 , v) become lines H ← h and vice versa. As a consequence the signs of the momenta flowing through them and the factorials of the node factors corresponding to the nodes joined by them can change. The change of the signs of the momenta simply follows from the fact that X νv = 0 , (4.3) v∈V (θ)
as θ ∈ Tk,0 : this means that some propagators G` change from g(ω 0 ·ν ` ) to −g(−ω0 · ν ` ) (compare the definitions of the propagators for lines h ← H and H ← h in (3.10)), but, by the definition of propagator (3.4), one has g(ω 0 ·ν ` ) = −g(−ω0 ·ν ` ). The change of the node factors is due to the fact that for the nodes along the path P(v0 , v), an entering line can become an exiting line and vice versa, so that the labels pv and qv can be transformed into pv ± 1 and qv ± 1, respectively: this does qv +δv (kv ) fν v (A0 ) in (3.13), as one immediately not modify the factor (iν v )pv +(1−δv ) ∂A checks, but it can produce a change of the factorials. If we neglect the change of the factorials, i.e. if we assume that all combinatorial factors are the same, by summing over all possible trees inside the class F (θ) we obtain a common value times i times (4.3), and the sum gives zero. One can easily show that a correct counting of the trees implies that all factorials are in fact equal:
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
140
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
simply reason as in [2, Sec. 3], by using topological trees. Therefore the above argument proves the second equation in (3.5). In order to make soluble the equation for h to order k one has to impose that (k) η deletes the Fourier component with label ν = 0 arising from [∂A1 f ](k) (the one arising from [∂A2 f ](k) is automatically vanishing as f does not depend on A2 ): this gives the condition (3.17). The summation on the trees can be easily performed, as the summability over the Fourier labels is assured by the Diophantine condition (which is not the optimal condition under which the formal solubility can be proved; see also [2] for the case of the maps on the cylinder), while all the other labels can assume only a finite number of values. So the proof of the lemma is concluded. 4.4. Remark. The assumption (1.7) on the perturbation f implies, by (4.2), that one has η (1) 6= 0. 5. Proof of Convergence of the Perturbative Expansion 5.1. Bound on the node factors. To prove the solubility of the equations of motions, i.e. the summability of the Lindstedt series (3.1), we shall prove the bounds 0
k −κ |ν| , |h(k) ν |≤B e
0
k −κ |ν| |H(k) , ν |≤ B e
|η (k) | ≤ B k ,
(5.1)
for suitable constants B > 0 and κ0 ∈ (0, κ). The sum over the labeled trees in Tκ,ν can be written as the sum over all the unlabeled trees and over all the ways to assign the mode and order labels to the nodes of the unlabeled trees with the constraints X X kv = k , νv = ν . (5.2) v∈V (θ)
v∈V (θ)
Define M (θ) =
X
|ν v | .
(5.3)
v∈V (θ)
Of course M (θ) ≥ |ν| for θ ∈ Tk,ν . The number of unlabeled trees with V nodes is bounded by 22V . We can see that, if it was possible to neglect the propagators in the definition of Val(θ) and Val0 (θ), a bound like (5.1) would immediately follow. In fact suppose for the time being to neglect the propagators, i.e. to replace G` with 1 in the definition of Val(θ) and Val(θ0 ) in Sec. 3.3. Then the sum over the labels can be performed as follows: the sum over the mode labels is controlled through Y 1 1 X qv +δv (kv ) |ν v |pv +(1−δv ) |∂A fν v (A0 )| qv ! pv ! P {ν v }v∈V (θ)
≤ e
v∈V (θ)
−κM(θ)
ν v =ν v∈V (θ)
2|V (θ)| |V (θ)| k 2k M (θ) F1 F2 F3
(2|V (θ)|)!
≤e
−κM(θ)
|V (θ)| F1
F2 F32 κ21
k eκ1 M(θ) , (5.4)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
for any κ1 ∈ (0, κ), where we used that X mv = |V (θ)| − 1 , v∈V (θ)
X
pv ≤ |V (θ)| − 1 ,
v∈V (θ)
X
qv ≤ |V (θ)| − 1 ,
141
(5.5)
|V (θ)| ≤ k ,
v∈V (θ)
while the sum over the unlabeled trees and over the contraction of the indices of the node factors gives a constant to the power V , say F4V . So we are left with the sum over the order labels, which is controlled through k X
X
22V F1V F4V ≤ 22k F1k F4k
V =1 k1 +···+kV =k
k X kV ≤ (22 eF1 F4 )k . k!
(5.6)
V =1
Then the bound (5.1) follows with κ0 = κ − κ1 . So we have to handle the propagators. We shall see that not all propagators can give problems; more exactly only the accumulation of propagators with the same momenta can be source of problems, as Lemma 5.4 below shows. 5.2. Multi-scale decomposition and clusters. We introduce a partition of unity through characteristic functions 1=
1 X
χn (ω 0 · ν) ,
(5.7)
n=−∞
where χn (x) has support on |x| ∈ [C0 2n−1 , C0 2n ) for n ≤ 0, while χ1 (x) has support on |x| ∈ [C0 , ∞); note that χn (x) = χ(2−n x) if χ(x) is the characteristic function of the interval [C0 /2, C0 ). For each propagator we write G` =
1 X n` =−∞
1 X
χn` (ω 0 · ν)G` ≡
(n` )
G`
.
(5.8)
n` =−∞ (n )
We say that n` is the scale label of the line ` and G` ` is a propagator on scale n` : note that, given the momentum ν ` flowing through the line `, there is only one scale n such that either C0 2n−1 ≤ |ω 0 · ν ` | < C0 2n ,
n ≤ 0,
(5.9)
or |ω 0 · ν ` | ≥ C0 , so that, even if (5.8) is written as an infinite series, in fact only one term is really nonvanishing. We shall say that the scale n for which (5.9) holds is the scale compatible with the line `. Once the scale labels have been assigned to the lines one has a natural decomposition of the tree into clusters. A cluster T on scale n is a maximal set of nodes and lines connecting them such that all the lines have scales n0 ≥ n and there is at least one line on scale n. The mT ≥ 0 lines entering the cluster T and the (only one or zero) exiting line are called the external lines of the cluster T . Given a cluster T on scale n, we shall denote by nT = n the scale of the cluster. We call T (θ) the
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
142
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
set of all clusters in a tree θ; given a cluster T ∈ T (θ) call V (T ) and Λ(T ) the set of nodes and the set of lines of T , respectively. 5.3. Resonances. We call resonance a cluster T with only one entering line `2T such that X X νv = 0 , |ν v | ≤ (2 2(n+3)/τ )−1 , (5.10) v∈V (T )
v∈V (T )
if n is the scale of the exiting line `1T . Note that the entering line `2T must have, by the first condition in (5.10), the same momentum of the exiting line `1T and, by construction, a scale n`2T = n`1T = n. We say that the line `1T exiting a resonance T is a resonant line. We call nonresonant line a line which is not a resonant line. For any resonance T and any line ` ∈ Λ(T ) one can write, by setting ` = `v , ν ` = ν 0` + σ` ν ,
(5.11)
where X
ν 0` =
νw ,
(5.12)
w∈V (T ) wv
ν ≡ ν `2T is the momentum flowing through the line `2T entering T , and σ` is defined as follows: writing ` ≡ `v then σ` = 1 if `2T enters a node w v and σ` = 0 otherwise. Given a resonance T , define the resonance value as ! ! Y Y (n` ) Fv G` , (5.13) VT (ω 0 · ν) = v∈V (T )
`∈Λ(T )
seen as a function of ω 0 · ν, if ν ≡ ν `2T = ν `1T is the momentum flowing through the external lines of the resonance T . We can have four types of resonances: `1T
`2T
1.
H ←h
h←H,
2.
H ←h
H ← h,
3.
h←H
h←H,
4.
h←H
H ← h.
(5.14)
Given a tree θ, define Nn (θ) = {` ∈ Λ(θ) : n` = n} , pn (θ) = {T ⊂ T (θ) : nT = n} .
(5.15)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
143
Call Nn∗ (θ) the number of nonresonant lines on scale ≤ n and call Rnj (θ) the number of resonant lines on scale ≤ n exiting from resonances of type j. Of course Nn (θ) = Nn∗ (θ) +
4 X
Rnj (θ) .
(5.16)
j=1
In Appendix 1 we prove the following result (note that the bound (5.17) is a version of Siegel–Bryuno lemma). 5.4. Lemma. For any tree θ ∈ Tκ,ν one has Nn∗ (θ) + pn (θ) ≤ c M (θ)2n/τ ,
(5.17)
Rn4 (θ) ≤ c M (θ)2n/τ + Rn1 (θ) ,
(5.18)
and
for some constant c. 5.5. Bound on the nonresonant lines. Define Λ∗ (θ) the set of nonresonant lines in Λ(θ). Then one has Y
(n` )
|G`
∗
| ≤ (2C0−1 )|Λ
`∈Λ∗ (θ)
(θ)|
1 Y
∗
2−nNn (θ) .
(5.19)
n=−∞
Let n0 = n0 (κ) be a negative integer to be fixed later (see (5.21) below). One has in (5.19) 1 Y
∗
2−nNn (θ) ≤ 2−2n0 k
n=−∞
n0 Y
∗
2−nNn (θ) ≤ 2−2n0 k
n=−∞
n0 Y
2−cnM(θ)2
n/τ
,
(5.20)
n=−∞
where (5.17) has been used for the lines on scale ≤ n0 . Choose n0 so that c log 2
∞ X
p2−p/τ ≤ κ2 ,
(5.21)
p=|n0 |
for some κ2 ∈ (0, κ − κ1 ); then (5.19) and (5.20) give Y ∗ (n ) |G` ` | ≤ (2C0−1 )|Λ (θ)| 2−2n0 k eκ2 M(θ) .
(5.22)
`∈Λ∗ (θ)
Together with the bounds (5.4) and (5.6), taking into account the product of the node factors, this shows that, by neglecting the resonances, a bound like (5.1) still holds with κ0 = κ − κ1 − κ2 . So we have to prove that the presence of the resonances does not destroy the results implied by the above discussion. 5.6. Localization and renormalization operators. For any resonance T we define VT (ω 0 · ν) = LVT (ω 0 · ν) + RVT (ω 0 · ν) ,
(5.23)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
144
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
where for resonances of type either 2 or 3 one has LVT (ω 0 · ν) ≡ VT (0) ,
Z
RVT (ω 0 · ν) ≡ (ω 0 · ν)
1
dtT ∂VT (tT ω0 · ν) ,
(5.24)
0
while for resonances of type 1 one has LVT (ω 0 · ν) ≡ VT (0) + (ω0 · ν)∂VT (0) , Z 1 2 dtT (1 − tT )∂ 2 VT (tT ω 0 · ν) , RVT (ω 0 · ν) ≡ (ω 0 · ν)
(5.25)
0
and for resonances of type 4 one has simply LVT (ω 0 · ν) ≡ 0 , RVT (ω 0 · ν) = VT (ω 0 · ν) .
(5.26)
Here ∂VT and ∂ 2 VT denote the first and the second derivatives of VT with respect to its argument (see Sec. 3.2). We shall call L the localization operator and R the renormalization operator : correspondingly LVT (ω 0 · ν) and RVT (ω 0 · ν) are called the localized part and the renormalized part of the resonance value. The quantity VT (0) is obtained from VT (ω 0 · ν) by replacing ν ` with ν 0` in the (n ) argument of each propagator G` ` , while ∂VT (0) is obtained from VT (ω0 · ν) by deriving it with respect to x = ω 0 ·ν, hence replacing ν ` with ν 0` in the argument of (n ) each propagator G` ` . Analogously ∂VT (tT ω0 · ν) and ∂ 2 VT (tT ω 0 · ν) are obtained from VT (ω 0 ·ν) by deriving it with respect to x = ω0 ·ν, once and twice, respectively, (n ) hence replacing ν ` with ν 0` + tT σ` ν in the argument of each propagator G` ` : in such a case we shall write ν ` (tT ) = ν`0 + tT σ` ν ,
(5.27)
where, as usual, we denote ν = ν `2T . The expressions for the renormalized parts of the resonance values are explicitly written in (5.35) and (5.36) below. Note that, given a resonance T , even if the renormalization procedure can change the compatible scales of its external lines, nevertheless the two scales have to remain equal to each other: in fact the momenta flowing through the external lines are still equal as their difference is left zero. 5.7. Remark. Because of the renormalization procedure it is no more true that there can be only one compatible scale per line (such that the corresponding propagator is not vanishing). For instance, if T is a resonance and ν ` is the momentum flowing through a line ` ∈ Λ(T ), let n` be the scale compatible with ` before renormalizing the resonance, i.e. the scale n` such that χn` (ω 0 · ν ` ) 6= 0. In the localized part of the resonance value the momentum ν ` has to be replaced with ν 0` , which is in general different from ν ` . So it can happen that χn` (ω 0 · ν 0` ) = 0, while χn0 (ω 0 · ν 0` ) = 0 for some
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
145
scale n0 6= n` : in such a case the scale label compatible with the line is no more n` but n0 . Moreover in the renormalized part of the resonance value, even if the mode labels are fixed, the arguments of the propagators can change: they can assume any value reachable by varying tT ∈ [0, 1], i.e. one has kω0 · ν 0` | − |ω0 · νk ≤ |ω 0 · ν ` | ≤ |ω0 · ν 0` | + |ω 0 · ν| ,
(5.28)
so that (5.8) are (in principle) really infinite sums. The second condition in (5.10) has been introduced exactly with the aim of preventing the number of compatible scales from being too large: see Sec. 5.10 and Lemma 5.11. 5.8. Resummation families. The reason why to split the resonance values as in (5.21) is given by the fact that the contributions arising from the localized parts of the resonance values, when summed over all trees, give a vanishing contributions. In order to prove such a (remarkable) property, we need to introduce suitable resummation families. Given a tree θ containing a resonance T , we can consider all trees obtained by changing the location of the nodes internal to T which the external lines of T are attached to: we denote by FT (θ) the set of trees so obtained, and call it the resummation family associated to the resonance T . And we shall refer to the operation of detaching and reattaching the external lines, by saying that we are shifting such lines. See Fig. 3.
Fig. 3. The resummation family FT (θ) = {θ, θ1 , θ2 , θ3 } obtained by shifting the external lines of the resonance T . The black balls represent the remaining parts of the trees. The labels are not explicitly shown.
Of course shifting the external lines of a resonance produces a change of the propagators of the trees. In particular as all arrows have to point towards the root, some lines can revert their arrows: correspondingly some lines h ← H become lines H ← h and vice versa. Moreover the momentum can change, as a reversal of the arrow implies a change of the partial ordering of the nodes inside the resonance and a shifting of the entering
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
146
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
line can add or subtract the contribution of the momentum flowing through it. More precisely, if the external lines of a resonance T are detached then reattached to some other nodes in V (T ), the momentum flowing through the line ` ∈ Λ(T ) can be changed into ±ν 0` + σν, with σ ∈ {0, 1}: if we call V1 and V2 the two disjoint sets into which ` divides T , such that the arrow superposed on ` is directed from V2 to V1 (before detaching the external lines), then the sign is + if the exiting line is reattached to a node inside V1 and it is − otherwise, while σ = 1 if the entering line is reattached to a node inside V2 when the sign is + and to a node inside V1 when the sign is −, and σ = 0 otherwise. See Fig. 4.
Fig. 4. The sets V1 and V2 in a resonance T ; note that, even if they are drawn like circles, he sets V1 and V2 are not clusters. One has ν 0` = ν v3 +ν v4 +ν v5 +ν v6 and ν = ν `2 ; of course ν `1 = ν `2 T
T
T
and ν 0` = −(ν v1 + ν v2 ) by definition of resonance. The black balls represent the remaining parts of the trees. The labels are not explicitly shown.
Then the following result follows. The proof is in Appendix 2. 5.9. Lemma. For any resonance T ∈ T (θ) one has X LVT (ω 0 · ν) = 0 ,
(5.29)
θ 0 ∈FT (θ)
where ν = ν `2T and the sum is over the resummation family associated to T. 5.10. Changing the scales. When considering separately the localized parts and the renormalized parts of the resonance values, as we said before in Remark 5.7, the scales are no more uniquely fixed by assigning the mode labels. This means that the sum over the scale labels is no more a fictitious sum as in the case in which no renormalization is performed (in such a case the scale associated to each line is simply determined by the momentum flowing through it by (5.9), so that no sum has to be really done).
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
147
Anyway the number of scale labels compatible with a line is not arbitrarily large, as the following result shows (the proof is in Appendix 3). 5.11. Lemma. When shifting the lines external to the resonances of a tree θ, for any line ` ∈ Λ(θ) the scale compatible with ` can change at most by one unit. 5.12. Renormalization of the maximal resonances. If we have several resonances which are external to each other then we apply Lemma 5.9 to each of them: so for all of them we can replace the resonance values with their renormalized parts. The situation is a little more involved when one has to consider a tree θ in which some resonances are contained inside some other resonances. In such a case we define the depth D(T ) of a resonance T recursively as follows: given a resonance T , we set D(T ) = 1 if there is no resonance containing T , and set D(T ) = D(T 0 )+ 1 if T is contained inside a resonance T 0 and all the other resonances inside T 0 (if there are any) do not contain T . Then consider the maximal resonances, i.e. the resonances T ∈ T (θ) with depth D(T ) = 1. We call T1 (θ) the set of such resonances; likewise we call TD (θ) the set of the resonances with depth D. For each T ∈ T1 (θ) let VT (ω 0 ·ν `2T ) be its resonance value. By Lemma 5.9 we can neglect the localized part LVT (ω 0 · ν `2T ), as it will give a vanishing contributions when the values of all trees are summed together, so that we have to consider only the renormalized value RVT (ω 0 · ν `2T ): we say then that the resonance is a renormalized resonance. Note that the scale compatible with the line `2T has not changed by the renormalization procedure (as the momentum flowing through the line entering the resonance remains the same), so that |ω 0 · ν `T2 | ≤ C0 2n ,
(5.30)
if n = n`2T , while, by shifting `2T , the scales compatible with the lines internal to T can change at most by one unit (by Lemma 5.11). Then for any line ` ∈ Λ(T ) one has, setting n = n`2T = n`1T , and, by the second condition in (5.10), X |ν v | ≤ (2 2(n+3)/τ )−1 , (5.31) |ν 0` | ≤ v∈V (T )
so that |ω 0 · ν 0` | > C0 |ν 0` |−τ ≥ C0 2τ 2n+3 ,
(5.32)
hence, with the notation (5.27), |ω0 · ν ` (tT )| > C0 2τ 2n+3 − C0 2n > C0 2n+3 ,
(5.33)
so that the scales compatible with any line ` ∈ Λ(T ) have to be strictly larger than n: the cluster structure imposed by the presence of the resonance is preserved by
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
148
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
the renormalization procedure (recall that in order to define the resonances, even before stating the conditions (5.10), we have required them to be clusters!). As all the lines internal to the resonances in T1 (θ) have a scale larger than the scales of the lines external to the resonances themselves, we can reason as in [3] (or [4]) and consider all the trees having the same structure as the just considered tree θ, but with different scale labels associated to the lines internal to the resonances in T1 (θ), i.e. the trees obtained by assigning to the lines in Λ(T ), for T ∈ T1 (θ), scale labels n0 ≥ n + 1, if n = n`2T . In particular this means that all the considered tree θ0 have the same sets of maximal resonances T1 (θ0 ). So we have the sum over the scale labels compatible with the resonance structure (see comments about (5.37) below) of renormalized resonance values which (setting ν 2`T = ν) are given by RVT (ω 0 · ν) = VT (ω 0 · ν) , for resonances of type 4, by X Z 1 dtT RVT (ω 0 · ν) = 0
`∈Λ(T )
×
Y
(5.34)
! Fv
v∈V (T )
(n ) ∂G` ` (ω 0
!
Y
· ν ` (tT ))
(n ) G`0 `0 (ω 0
· ν `0 (tT )) ,
(5.35)
`0 ∈Λ(T )\`
for resonances of type 2 and 3, and by X Z 1 dtT (1 − tT ) RVT (ω 0 · `) = 0
`∈Λ(T )
× (∂
2
!
Y
Fv
v∈V (T )
(n ) G` ` (ω 0
Y
· ν ` (tT )))
! (n ) G`0 `0 (ω 0
· ν `0 (tT ))
`0 ∈Λ(T )\`
+
Z
X
dtT (1 − tT )
`6=`0 ∈Λ(T )
0
(n` )
× (∂G` ×
Y
1
! Fv
v∈V (T ) (n )
(ω 0 · ν ` (tT ))∂G`0 `0 (ω 0 · ν `0 (tT ))) ! Y (n`0 ) G`0 (ω 0 · ν `00 (tT )) ,
(5.36)
`00 ∈Λ(T )\{`,`0 }
for resonances of type 1. Here we have explicitly written the argument of the propagators and the symbol ∂ is meant as the partial derivative with respect the argument (see Sec. 3.2). Note that we can write ω0 · ν ` (tT ) = ω 0 · ν 0` + tT σ` ω0 · ν, by (5.27). The sum over the scale labels is such that for each line the characteristic functions χn reconstruct a step function: each line ` ∈ Λ(T ) can have any scale
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
149
n0 ≥ nT ≥ n`2T + 1, and 1 X
χn0 (ω 0 · ν ` (tT )) = ϑ(|ω 0 · ν(tT )| − C0 2n ) ,
n0 =n+1
n = n`2T ,
(5.37)
where ϑ denotes the step function, i.e. ϑ(x) = 1 if x > 0 and ϑ(x) = 0 otherwise. For each summand contributing to the renormalized part of the resonance value there are either zero (see (5.34)) or one (see (5.35)) or two (see (5.36)) derived propagators. 5.13. Remarks. (1) First of all note that for any value of the interpolation parameter tT the arguments of the step functions lay inside the region in which their arguments are positive, so that no contribution of the derivatives arise from them. In fact for any line ` ∈ Λ(T ) one has (5.33), while the discontinuity of the theta function is at C0 2n by (5.37). (2) For any line ` ∈ Λ(T ), if n is the scale compatible with it before renormalizing, i.e. C0 2n−1 < |ω 0 · ν ` | ≤ C0 2n ,
(5.38)
C0 2n−2 < |ω 0 · ν ` (tT )| ≤ C0 2n+1 ,
(5.39)
then one has
by Lemma 5.11. 5.14. Iterative renormalization of the resonances. By using Remark 5.13 (1), we redecompose the step functions, so obtaining again characteristic functions. This means that we have to study expressions like (5.35) and (5.36), in which no derivative can acts on the characteristic functions (by the just given argument). Consider explicitly the case in which only one propagator is derived, i.e. the case (5.35) of resonances of type 2 and 3. Then the derived propagator in (5.35) can correspond to a line ` contained inside some resonance T 0 ⊂ T with depth D(T 0 ) = 2. If this is the case we do not split the resonance value of T 0 into the sum of a localized and a renormalized part: we say then that such a resonance is not renormalized. Let T 00 be the resonance with higher depth containing `. Then we do not renormalize any resonances containing T 00 and contained inside T . Then we pass to consider T 00 and we repeat the above analysis, i.e. we apply once more Lemma 5.9, hence we study the renormalized value as in Sec. 5.12. The reason how we proceed in such a way will become clear later (see Remark 5.16). Otherwise, if the line ` corresponding to the derived propagator is external to any resonances T 0 ∈ T2 (θ) we pass to consider such resonances and we iterate the above argument, i.e. we apply again Lemma 5.9, so getting rid of the localized parts of the resonances values for all resonances T 0 ∈ T2 (θ) such that T 0 ⊂ T (which then become renormalized resonances), then, by summing over the scale labels, we group
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
150
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
together all trees having the same cluster structure imposed by the set T2 (θ), and proceed as above. The only differences with respect with the previous case are that now also the momentum flowing through the line `2T 0 entering T 0 can have been changed into ν `2 0 (tT ), and the momenta flowing through the lines internal to T 0 will depend T in general on two interpolation parameters tT and tT 0 , one for each renormalized resonance. By Remark 5.13 (2) one has that (5.30) has to be replaced with |ω 0 · ν `2 0 (tT )| ≤ C0 2n+1 , T
(5.40)
if n = n`2 0 = n`1 0 (of course here n has a different value with respect to n in (5.30), T T where one had n = n`2T ). Moreover for any line ` ∈ Λ(T 0 ) the momentum flowing through it, setting t ≡ {tT , tT 0 } can be written as ν ` (t) = ν 0` + tT 0 σ` (ν 0`2 0 + tT σ`2 0 ν `2T ) . T
T
(5.41)
Then for any line ` ∈ Λ(T 0 ) one has, setting again n = n`2 0 and using the second T condition in (5.10), |ω 0 · ν ` (tT 0 )| > C0 2τ 2n+3 − C0 2n+1 > C0 2n+3 ,
(5.42)
so that the same conclusions as before can be drawn. Note that with respect to the original tree it can happen that the renormalization procedure, by changing the scales compatible with the lines, make some resonances to disappear, while some new resonances can appear: recall that the definition of resonance depends on the scale of the resonant line. But this is not a problem at all: the bound on the number of nonresonant lines (which is of course equal to the number of resonances) is derived in Appendix 1 by using that if a line has a momentum ν ` (t) and a scale n, then C0 2n−2 < |ω0 · ν ` (t)| ≤ C0 2n+1 ,
(5.43)
and such a bound is satisfied also for the trees with renormalized resonances by Lemma 5.11. One deals in a similar way also with the resonances of type 1: in this case if both lines corresponding to the derived propagators are inside some resonance T 0 ∈ T2 (θ), then the resonance T 0 is not renormalized, if only one line is inside T 0 then T 0 is renormalized to one order less (i.e. to zeroth order if of type 2 or 3 and to first order if of type 1), while if both lines are external to T 0 then T 0 is renormalized to its proper order ( i.e. to first order if of type 2 or 3 and to second order if of type 1). 5.15. Final result of the renormalization procedure. In this way we have obtained a sum of contributions such that for each of them the following situation
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
151
arises for a given tree θ. We do not give the full details, as the analysis can be performed as in [3]. All localized parts of the resonance values cancel out, so that only renormalized parts have to be considered for the resonance values (by Lemma 5.9). As some resonances contained in the tree θ are renormalized (not all, as the discussion in Sec. 5.14), we say then that the tree is a renormalized tree. For each renormalized resonance T we have an interpolation parameter tT . Defining the set interpolation parameters as t = {tT : T is a renormalized resonance in θ} ,
(5.44)
the momenta of the lines ` ∈ Λ(θ) become functions of t, ν ` = ν ` (t). The explicit dependence on such parameters is obtained as follows: if a line ` = `v is contained inside the renormalized resonances T1 ⊂ T2 ⊂ · · · ⊂ Tp and tT1 , . . . , tTp are the corresponding interpolation parameters, then X Y νw tT . (5.45) ν` (t) = T ∈{T1 ,...,Tp }:`w ∈Λ(T )
wv
Of course (5.45) generalizes (5.41) to the case of more than two resonances contained inside each other. See Fig. 5 for an example.
Fig. 5. The momenta as functions of the interpolation parameters in the case of two resonances T 0 ⊂ T . One has ν ` = ν 0` +tT 0 ν 00 +tT 0 tT ν 0 , where ν 0` = ν v1 +ν v2 and ν 00 = ν v3 +ν v4 +ν v5 +ν v6 . The black balls represent the remaining parts of the trees. The labels are not explicitly shown.
Furthermore, by construction, each propagator is derived at most twice, and one has (n` )
∂ p G`
(ω 0 · ν ` (t)) ∼ (−1)p
p! χn (ω 0 · ν ` (t)) (iω 0 · ν ` (t))p+1 `
= (−1)p
p! (n ) G ` (ω 0 · ν ` (t)) , (iω 0 · ν ` (t))p `
(5.46)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
152
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
where ∼ means that the two quantities differ by the derivatives of the characteristic functions, which, however, have to be discarded in the valuation of the value of the renormalized tree (see Remark 5.13 (1)). Note that 1 −1 nT −2 , (5.47) iω0 · ν ` (t) ≤ C0 2 if T is the resonance with highest depth such that ` ∈ Λ(T ), as the compatible scales of ` could have been changed at most by one unit with respect to that associated to ` before the renormalization procedure was applied, again by Lemma 5.11. Then for each renormalized resonance, if ν(t) denotes the momentum flowing through the entering line, we have an extra factor iω0 · ν(t) iω0 · ν(t) , iω0 · ν ` (t) iω0 · ν 0` (t)
(5.48)
(possibly times 2, when arising from a propagator derived twice; see (5.46) with p = 2) if T is of type 1, and an extra factor iω0 · ν(t) , iω0 · ν ` (t)
(5.49)
if T is of type 2 or 3. Here ` and `0 denote the lines corresponding to the propagators which have been derived by renormalizing T . This means that for each resonance of type 2 and 3 one has a factor iω0 · ν(t), which deletes the propagator of the corresponding resonant line. This does not happens for resonances of type 4; on the other hand one has a factor (iω0 · ν(t))2 for resonances of type 1, and we can take advantage of such a fact through (5.18) (see (5.54) below). As for any resonance T and for any line ` ∈ Λ(T ) one has |ω 0 · ν ` (t)| > C0 2nT −2 (see (5.47)) and |ω0 · ν(t)| ≤ C0 2n+1 , if ν(t) = ν `2T (t) and n = n`2T , then (5.48) and (5.49) give a “factor gain” Γ2T or ΓT , where ΓT = O(2n−nT ) .
(5.50)
This is evident for resonances which are renormalized, but it is not difficult to realize that it holds also for nonrenormalized resonances. For simplicity (and for expository clarity) we explicitly discuss only the case in which only resonances of type 2 or 3 are involved, but the argument can be easily extended to cover also the case in which some resonances are of type 1. Suppose that a resonance T1 ∈ TD (θ), for some D ≥ 1, is renormalized and that the derived propagator corresponds to a line ` ∈ Λ(Tp ), with Tp ∈ TD+p (θ) such that Tp is the resonance with highest depth containing `. Call T2 , . . . , Tp−1 the (not renormalized) resonances such that Tp ⊂ Tp−1 ⊂ · · · ⊂ T2 ⊂ T1 . If `2Tj denotes the line entering the resonance Tj , for j = 1, . . . , p, one has ν(t) = ν `2T (t) in (5.49). 1
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
Then
j=1
!
iω0 · ν `2T (t)
p−1 Y
iω 0 · ν(t) = iω 0 · ν ` (t)
iω0 · ν `2T
(t) j+1
iω0 · ν `2T (t) p
j
iω0 · ν ` (t)
,
153
(5.51)
and, as each line `2Tj+1 is a line internal to the cluster Tj , hence on scale ≥ nTj we can bound (5.51) by p Y
O(2nj −nTj ) =
j=1
p Y
ΓTj ,
nj = n`2T ,
(5.52)
j
j=1
which proves the assertion. 5.16. Remark. Finally we have that, by construction, there are at most two derived propagators per cluster. It is exactly with this aim that no remormalization (or a renormalization to one order less) is performed on a cluster T 0 ⊂ T when a derived line obtained by renormalizing T is contained inside T 0 . In fact if all resonances were renormalized we could have some lines derived arbitrarily many times, and this would give dangerous factorials (see 5.46)). 5.17. Bound on the propagators. In conclusion, as the effect of the renormalization procedure, we obtain a sum of terms each of which can be bounded as follows. If Λ1 (θ) and Λ2 (θ) denote the sets of lines corresponding to the propagators which are derived once and twice, respectively, we have that each term is bounded by a constant to the power k times ! ! Y Y −k 2−n` 2−2n` C0 `∈Λ1 (θ)
×
1 Y
`∈Λ2 (θ)
! 2
∗ −nNn (θ)
n=−∞
1 Y
! 2
−nR4n (θ)
n=−∞
1 Y
! 2
nR1n (θ)
where the last two products can be bounded by using (5.18), i.e. ! ! ! 1 1 1 Y Y Y −nR4n (θ) nR1n (θ) −cnM(θ)2(n+3)/τ 2 2 2 ≤ , n=−∞
n=−∞
,
(5.53)
n=−∞
(5.54)
n=−∞
while the product taking into account the nonresonant lines can be bounded as in Sec. 5.5 (by using of course also Lemma 5.11). Finally the first two products can be bounded by ! ! 1 Y Y Y −n` −2n` 2 2 2−2npn (θ) , (5.55) ≤ `∈Λ1 (θ)
`∈Λ2 (θ)
n=−∞
as, as we noted, there are at most two derivatives per cluster.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
154
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
So we are left with the problems of counting how many terms we have to sum over. More precisely we have to sum over the possible choices of the propagators to be derived times a sum over all the possible scale labels compatible with the lines. The first sum is bounded by a constant to the power k as there can be at most two derived propagators per cluster (as already remarked above), while the second sum is bounded by 3|V (θ)| ≤ 3k : once the mode labels have been fixed for each line the scale label can assume only 3 values, by Lemma 5.11. (k) (k) Then the bounds (5.1) are proven for the first two quantities hν and Hν . 5.18. Remark. As a matter of fact there are only 2 compatible scales per line. In fact the change of the momentum ν(t) flowing through a line ` ∈ Λ(T ) is such that at most |ω 0 · ν| ≤ C0 2n+1 , if n = n`2T , while the momentum was originally contained in an interval of width at least C0 2n+3 : this means that ω 0 · ν(t) can fall 0 0 in one of the two contiguous intervals [C0 2n −1 , C0 2n ), with |n0 − n| = 1, but not in both of them. 5.19. Bounds for the counterterms. Repeating the discussion of the previous sections for the counterterms we obtain a bound of the same kind, the only difference being that there is no factor C0−1 associated to the root line (as there is no propagator corresponding to the root line): such a property has been used in Sec. 2.12. So the proof of Lemma 2.2 is complete. 6. Conclusions and Extensions of the Results 6.1. General perturbations and higher dimensions. In this section we briefly review the possible generalizations and extensions of the results discussed in the previous sections. We confine ourselves to give some ideas how the proofs could be carried out, as we think that the main interest of the present paper relies on the techniques described in the previous sections rather than on the results (which are essentially well known from the standard KAM theory). One can consider more general systems described by Hamiltonians of the form H = ω · A + f (α, A, ε) ,
(6.1)
where (α, A) ∈ T × R , with d ≥ 2, are conjugate variables, the rotation vector ω satisfies the Diophantine condition d
d
|ω · ν| > C|ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Zd \ {0} ,
(6.2)
with Diophantine constants C > 0 and τ > d − 1, and f is a real analytic function, (d) (d) holomorphic ic in a domain D = Σκ × D × Bε1 (0), where Σκ = {α ∈ Cd : d Re αj ∈ T, |Im αj | < κ, j = 1, . . . , d} and D ⊂ C is an open subset. With respect to the Hamiltonian (1.2) we allow the perturbation to depend on all the action variables and no restriction is made on the dimension d. Then one can ask if a result analogous to Theorem 1.6 holds for the Hamiltonian (6.1).
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
155
The reason why we considered the condition (2.26) for the Hamiltonian (1.2) is that the argument given in Sec. 2.14 can be repeated also for the Hamiltonian (6.1), with some minor (obvious) changes: this represents the first step in order to study the problem outlined in Sec. 1.10. ¯ ⊂ D. By ¯ ∈ D, let ρ be such that Bρ (A) So, for the Hamiltonian (6.1), given A setting Z 2 (1) ¯ 2 (1) ¯ 6= 0 , f (A) ≡ det dα ∂A f (α, A) (6.3) M ≡ det ∂A T2
then, if one fixes ε small enough (and nonvanishing), one can find infinitely many rotation vectors ω 0 close enough to ω and satisfying the Diophantine condition |ω 0 · ν| > C0 |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Zd \ {0} ,
(6.4)
with C0 = bC, for some constant b, and, for each of them, a value A0 = A0 (ε) ∈ ¯ for a suitable δ < ρ0 < ρ, such that one has solutions of the form Bδ (A), ( α(t) = ω 0 t + h(ω 0 t, A0 (ε), ε, ω 0 ) , (6.5) A(t) = A0 (ε) + H(ω 0 t, A0 (ε), ε, ω0 ) and A0 (ε) verifies the equation ω0 + η(A0 (ε), ε, ω0 ) = ω ,
(6.6)
and the functions h(ψ, A, ε, ω 0 ) and H(ψ, A, ε, ω 0 ) are analytic for (ψ, A, ε) ∈ (d) ¯ × Bε0 (0), with suitbale κ0 < κ, ρ0 < ρ and ε0 < ε1 . (Of course A0 (ε) Σκ0 × Bρ0 (A) will depend also on ω0 , even if we are not explicitly writing such a dependence.) Here η(A0 (ε), ε, ω 0 ) is the counterterm naturally arising when trying to look for solutions of the equations of motion with rotation vector ω0 (see Lemma 2.2 and Remark 3.5). The only difference with respect to the simplified problem studied in Sec. 2.14 is that now one has to prove that, given ω verifying the Diophantine condition (6.2) then there exists ε¯ ∈ Bε1 (0) such that, for all |ε| < ε¯, any neighborhood of radius O(ε) close enough to ω contains infinitely many ω 0 satisfying the Diophantine condition (6.4): this can also be easily proved. Then one can reason as in Sec. 2.14, and a result analogous to Theorem 1.6 holds for the Hamiltonian (6.1). 6.2. Measure of the persisting tori in phase space. Under the condition (1)
2 f0 (A)| > 0 , M ≡ inf |det ∂A A∈D
(6.7)
one can ask how many tori persist for perturbed Hamiltonian systems of the form (6.1). If one wants to use the Lindstedt series instead of the usual KAM techniques (see [5] and [15]), one can reason in the following way. For simplicity let us assume ε > 0 (small enough).
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
156
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
First of all note that it is straightforward to prove that if ω satisfies the Diophantine condition (6.2), then, for any constant a > 0, the Lebesgue measure of the set I(ω) of vectors ω 0 ∈ Baε (ω) satisfying the Diophantine condition |ω 0 · ν| > Cεβ |ν|−τ
∀ ν ∈ Zd \ {0} ,
(6.8)
for some constant β ∈ (0, 1), is given by m(I(ω)) ≥ m(Baε (ω))(1 − cεα ) ,
α=
τ −d+1 +β −1, τ +1
(6.9)
for some constant c, so that m(I(ω))/m(Baε (ω)) → 0 for ε → 0, provided that one has β > d/(τ + 1). The condition β > d/(τ + 1) assures that α in (6.9) is strictly positive, while the condition β < 1 is required as a consequence of the bound on the radius of convergence (see below); we shall see in Sec. 6.4 that in fact such a condition is highly improvable. Then one can prove that, fixed ε small enough, most of invariant tori persist under perturbation, in the sense that the fraction of initial data in phase space for trajectories lying on invariant tori tends to 1 for ε → 0. The discussion proceeds as follows. ¯ ⊂ D. Consider ω 0 ∈ Baε (ω), for some ¯ ∈ D and ρ such that Bρ (A) Fix A constant a independent of ε (to be fixed), such that (6.8) is satisfied for ω0 . Then the radius of convergence (in ε) of the series defining the functions h, H, η is of the form ε0 = E0 C0 εβ (simply use the extension of Lemma 2.2 discussed in Sec. 6.1, with C0 replaced with C0 εβ ). As β < 1, if ε is small enough, one has ε < ε0 , so ¯ for some that the series for h, H, η converge for that value of ε and for A ∈ Bρ0 (A), 0 0 0 0 ρ ∈ (0, ρ); in particular η(A, ε, ω ) depends weakly on ω , provided ω ∈ I(ω). More precisely one can choose ε small enough and δ < ρ0 so that, for all A ∈ ¯ Bδ (A), η(A, ε, ω 0 ) = ε η (1) (A) + ε1+γ ξ(A, ε, ω 0 ) ,
sup
ω0 ∈I
sup ¯ A∈Bδ (A)
|ξ(A, ε, ω 0 )| ≤ Ξ , (6.10)
with γ = 1 − β > 0 and Ξ a suitable constant (we are using that the radius of convergence in ε for the counterterm is O(εβ )). By the analyticity in A of the counterterm, by (6.10) and by the condition (6.7) one has that, for ε small enough, for A, A0 ∈ Bδ (A) and for all ω0 ∈ I, |η(A0 , ε, ω0 ) − η(A, ε, ω 0 )| >
M ε|A0 − A| . 2
(6.11)
¯ define ω0 ≡ ω 0 (A) ≡ ω − ε η (1) (A). By varying A ∈ Bδ/2 (A), ¯ For A ∈ Bδ/2 (A) 0 the corresponding values ω cover a set Ω, whose distance from ω is of order ε: this (1) follows from (6.7), as η (1) (A) = −∂A f0 (A). Then we can suppose that a is such that Ω ⊂ Baε (ω). Call Ω0 ⊂ Ω the set of vectors in Ω satisfying (6.8). By the condition (6.7) and ¯ such that ω0 (A) ∈ Ω0 by the bound (6.9) one has that the set of values A ∈ Bδ/2 (A)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
157
α ¯ has complement with measure bounded by m(Bδ/2 (A))dε , for some constant d. 0 ¯ and A ∈ Bδ (A), ¯ Then one has, for A ∈ Bδ/2 (A)
ω 0 + η(A0 , ε, ω0 ) = ω − ε η (1) (A) + η(A0 , ε, ω0 ) = ω − ε η (1) (A) + η(A, ε, ω 0 ) + η(A0 , ε, ω0 ) − η(A, ε, ω 0 ) = ω + ε1+γ ξ(A, ε, ω 0 ) + η(A0 , ε, ω0 ) − η(A, ε, ω0 ) ,
(6.12)
where ξ(A, ε, ω 0 ) admits the bound in (6.10), while η(A0 , ε, ω0 ) − η(A, ε, ω 0 ) is bounded from below through (6.11). Choose β so that α > γ and a as said above: for ε small enough one has ¯ one δ > 4Ξ εγ /M , so that we conclude that, when varying A0 in Bδ/2 (A) ⊂ Bδ (A), 0 reaches a value A such that ε1+γ ξ(A, ε, ω0 ) + η(A0 , ε, ω0 ) − η(A, ε, ω 0 ) = ε(η (1) (A0 ) − η (1) (A)) + ε1+γ ξ(A0 , ε, ω0 ) = 0
(6.13)
so that (6.12) gives ω 0 + η(A0 , ε, ω0 ) = ω. Of course the value A0 depends on A: we want to prove that if we take two dif˜ 0 , respectively, the corresponding ˜ and we denote by A0 and A ferent values A and A values that one finds by following the above procedure, then one has ˜ 0 = (1 + O(εγ ))(A − A) ˜ + O((A − A) ˜ 2) . A0 − A
(6.14)
To prove the last assertion we shall use that, to each perturbative order k and for all ω 0 , ω 00 ∈ I, if ∂ω η (k) (A, ω 00 ) denotes the formal derivative of η (k) (A, ω) with respect to ω computed in ω00 , then one has η (k) (A, ω 0 ) − η (k) (A, ω 00 ) = ∂ω η(k) (A, ω 00 )(ω 0 − ω00 ) + O(ω 0 − ω 00 )2 ,
(6.15)
¯ This follows from the analysis in [5] (where in fact a uniformly in A ∈ Bρ0 (A). much stronger result is proved, i.e. C ∞ differentiability in the sense of Whitney, [18]), and it can likely be proved also with the techniques used in the present paper; see Sec. 6.3 below. ˜ and call ω0 and ω ˜ 0 the corresponding values Then choose two values A and A, 0 0 (1) (1) ˜ ˜ are both such ˜ = ω − ε η (A): suppose that A and A ω = ω − ε η (A) and ω 0 ˜0 0 0 0 ˜ are defined so that that ω , ω ∈ Ω . The values A and A (η (1) (A0 ) − η (1) (A)) + εγ ξ(A0 , ε, ω0 ) = 0 , ˜ 0 ) − η (1) (A)) ˜ + εγ ξ(A ˜ 0 , ε, ω ˜ 0) = 0 , (η (1) (A
(6.16)
(see (6.13)). The difference between the two equations gives ˜ 0 )) + εγ (ξ(A0 , ε, ω0 ) − ξ(A ˜ 0 , ε, ω ˜ , ˜ 0 )) = (η (1) (A) − η (1) (A)) (η (1) (A0 ) − η (1) (A (6.17)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
158
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
where one can write ˜ 0 ) = ∂A η (1) (A0∗ )(A0 − A ˜ 0) , η (1) (A0 ) − η (1) (A ˜ = ∂A η (1) (A∗ )(A − A) ˜ , η (1) (A) − η (1) (A)
(6.18)
and ˜ 0 , ε, ω ˜ 0 , ε, ω 0 ) + ξ(A ˜ 0 , ε, ω0 ) − ξ(A ˜ 0 , ε, ω ˜ 0 ) = ξ(A0 , ε, ω0 ) − ξ(A ˜ 0) ξ(A0 , ε, ω 0 ) − ξ(A ˜ 0 ) + ∂ω ξ(A ˜ 0 , ε, ω ˜ 0 )(ω 0 − ω ˜ 0) = ∂A ξ(A0• , ε, ω0 )(A0 − A ˜ 0 )2 ) , + O((ω 0 − ω
(6.19)
˜ 0 , and so on); for suitable A0∗ , A∗ , A0• (for instance A0∗ is a value between A0 and A by construction one has ˜ − εη (1) (A) = ε∂A η (1) (A∗ )(A ˜ − A) , ˜ 0 = εη (1) (A) ω0 − ω
(6.20)
˜ 0 , ε, ω ˜ 0 ) is the derivative (in the sense of Whitney) of ξ with respect to and ∂ω ξ(A the third argument, according to (6.15). Therefore (6.17) reads as ˜ 0 ) + εγ ∂A ξ(A0 , ε, ω0 )(A0 − A ˜ 0) ∂A η (1) (A0∗ )(A0 − A • ˜ 0 , ε, ω ˜ − A) + O((A ˜ − A)2 ) ˜ 0 )∂A η (1) (A∗ )(A + ε1+γ ∂ω ξ(A ˜ , = ∂A η (1) (A∗ )(A − A)
(6.21)
˜ − A)2 )) so that we obtain (up to corrections O((A ˜ 0 = (∂A η (1) (A0 ) + εγ ∂A ξ(A0 , ε, ω0 ))−1 (1 + ε1+γ ∂ω ξ(A ˜ 0 , ε, ω ˜ 0 )) A0 − A ∗ • ˜ , × ∂A η (1) (A∗ )(A − A)
(6.22)
which implies (6.14): hence the map A → A0 is differentiable where it is defined (a property which indeed follows by the smoothness in the sense of Whitney). ¯ for which ω0 = ω 0 (A) As we have seen before that the set of values A ∈ Bδ/2 (A) 0 ¯ belongs to Ω has measure bounded from below by m(Bδ (A))(1−dεα ), the condition (6.14) implies that also the set of values A0 representing the average values of the action variables along the tori with rotation vector in Ω0 has measure bounded from ¯ − d0 εα ), for some constant d0 . below by m(Bδ (A))(1 Therefore we can reason asfollows. Fix δ0 = δ¯0 εα , for some constant δ¯0 inde¯ ⊂ D; of ¯ ∈ D such that Bδ+δ (A) pendent of ε, and define A as the set of values A 0 course the complement of the set A has measure bounded by m(D)cεα . For each of ¯ we can repeat the above discussion, by choosing A = A, ¯ so that we obtain such A 0 0 ¯ the following result: the measure of the values A ≡ A which we find by solving ¯ A ¯ 0 — has complement the sequence of Eqs. (6.13) — with A, A0 replaced with A, 0 α (in D) with measure bounded by m(D)c ε , for some constant c0 independent of ε. By using the fact that the solution can be written in the form (6.5) (and recalling that A0 (ε) depends also on ω0 ) we can reasoning as above to prove that, for fixed ε,
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
159
the actions A(t) are differentiable in A0 = A0 (ε) (in the sense of Whitney) and with derivative close to 1, so that also the action variables corresponding to motions on invariant tori fulfill the set D up to a set of measure of order O(εα ). This answers the question we asked above about the measure in phase space of the persisting invariant tori. 6.3. Differentiability in the sense of Whitney. The functions h, H, η are well defined for ω 0 ∈ I and admit bounds which are uniform for such ω 0 ; they are known to be extendible to functions which are C ∞ in the sense of Whitney. In particular they can be extended to continuous functions: this simply means that (6.15) as well as the equivalent expressions for the functions h and H hold for any ω 0 , ω 00 ∈ I. To prove this one has to compare the Lindstedt series expansions for η (k) (A, ω 0 ) and η(k) (A, ω 00 ). Here we simply sketch how the analysis could be performed. One can write both η (k) (A, ω 0 ) and η (k) (A, ω 00 ) as sums over trees (see (3.17)), so that the difference η (k) (A, ω 0 ) − η(k) (A, ω 00 ) can be written as sum of differences of pairs of tree values, computed the first with the rotation vector ω0 and the second with the rotation vector ω 00 . For the trees of each pair there is a difference between the propagators appearing in the corresponding values, while the remaining factors of the tree values are equal to each other. Therefore each difference can be decomposed as sum of values corresponding to trees whose lines ` have all propagators of the form either 1 , (6.23) ω0 · ν ` or 1 , (6.24) ω 00 · ν ` ˜ which has a new propagator given by the difference up to one, say `, 1 1 − . ω 0 · ν `˜ ω00 · ν `˜
(6.25)
Furthermore one can arrange the decomposition in such a way that the set Λ0 of the lines with propagator (6.23) is connected and contains the root line (except when `˜ is the root line: in such case there is no line with propagator of the form (6.23)), while the set Λ00 of the lines with propagator (6.24) is formed by disjoint sets Λ001 , . . . , Λ00N , each of which is connected. In particular this means that, if for j = 1, . . . , N we call θj00 the set of lines in Λ00j and of the nodes connected by such lines, and, analogously, θ0 the set of lines in Λ0 and of the nodes connected by such lines, then each set θj00 is a subtree which has as root either a node of θ0 or the node which `˜ exit from; for each node v in θ0 call θjv1 , . . . , θjvNv the subtrees which have v as root. ˜ If we denote by ν j the momentum For the time being let us neglect the line `. 00 flowing through the root line of θj and by kj its order, we see that when we sum over all the possible subtrees in Tkj ,ν j we obtain a quantity which admits the bound
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
160
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
(2.5), with k = kj and ν j : in fact all the lines of such subtrees have a propagator of the form (6.24), so that the analysis of the previous sections apply. Then we can consider the set θ0 , which can be considered as a tree, provided that to each node v we replace the mode label ν v with ν v + ν jv1 + · · · + ν jvNv . Again if we sum over all the possible trees θ0 , we obtain a bound like (2.5). The newly introduced propagator (6.25) can be written as (ω 0 − ω00 )ν `˜ 1 1 , − = ω0 · ν `˜ ω 00 · ν `˜ (ω 0 · ν `˜)(ω 00 · ν `˜)
(6.26)
when |ν `˜| <
C 2|ω0 − ω 00 |
−1/(τ +1) ,
while it can be only bounded with 1 1 1 1 ≤ + − ω 0 · ν ˜ ω 00 · ν ˜ ω0 · ν ˜ ω 00 · ν ˜ , ` ` ` `
(6.27)
(6.28)
when ν `˜ does not satisfy (6.27). In the first case we can add a line `˜ both to the set Λ0 and to the set Λ00 , and reason as above: simply the bound (5.17) has to be multiplied times a factor 2 as the line `˜ has to be counted twice. In the latter case one can think to use the exponential decay of the Fourier coefficients in order to obtain a bound small in |ω 0 − ω00 |; note that there is only one line with propagator of the form (6.25), so that we can use, say, the square root of the product of the Fourier coefficients of all the nodes preceding the line `˜ in order to create a quantity bounded by exp[−κ|ν `˜|/2]. Of course the above analysis is only heuristic: but we think that it can be made easily rigorous by using the analysis of Sec. 5, with some minor changes. With similar arguments we can prove differentiability to all orders, i.e. that the functions h, H, η are C ∞ in the sense of Whitney. 6.4. Improving the results. In all the paper we assumed ω to be Diophantine. In that case the measure of the complement of the set of vectors ω 0 whose invariant tori persist under the perturbation, for fixed ε is known to be exponentially small. This is obtained in the usual KAM theory by performing suitably many Birkhoff transformations before applying the KAM theorem. To see such a feature with the Lindstedt series one can reason in a way similar to what was done in [9] about the problem of the persistence of KAM tori for three time scale systems. Again we shall proceed at a heuristic level. Suppose for simplicity f to be a trigonometric polynomial in α of order N , so that to order k one has |ν ` | ≤ kN for ˜ with |ω| ˜ < aε, all ` ∈ Λ(θ) and for all trees θ of order k. By setting ω 0 = ω + ω, one has ˜ · ν| ≥ |ω 0 · ν| ≥ |ω · ν| − |ω
C −τ |ν| , 2
(6.29)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
for all ν such that
|ν| ≤ N0 ≡
C 2aε
161
1/(τ +1) ,
(6.30)
So for all k such that k < k0 ≡ N0 /N one has that (6.27) applies in order to bound all propagators, and only to order k = k0 a line ` such that one has to use the bound |ω0 · ν ` | > Cεβ |ν ` |−τ ,
(6.31)
can really appear. To such an order k0 , by summing over all trees θ ∈ Tk0 ,ν , one obtains the bound B k0 C −k0 ε−β ,
(6.32)
for some constant B, and this suggests that to any order k one has the bound (BC −1 ε−βN/N0 )k ,
(6.33)
BC −1 ε−βN/N0 ε < 1 ,
(6.34)
which requires
that is βN/N0 < 1. The proof of (6.33) can be performed by reasoning as in [9]. Therefore we can take 1/(τ +1) 1 N0 =c , (6.35) β ≤ β0 = 2N ε for some constant c. Then, by using the analysis of Sec. 5, the discussion could be extended to analytic perturbations which are not necessarily trigonometric polynomials: it would be interesting to do so, and to compare the results arising by using the Lindstedt series (in particular the exponent 1/(τ + 1)) with the ones known from the usual KAM theory. Appendix 1. Proof of Lemma 5.4 A1.1. Remark. In the following we shall use that if a line ` is on a scale n then C0 2n−2 ≤ |ω 0 · ν ` | ≤ C0 2n+1 .
(A1.1)
Without considering the renormalization procedure then (5.9) holds, and it implies (A1.1). We shall use (A1.1) instead of (5.9), as we have seen that the renormalization procedure can make the number of scales compatible with some lines to increase (see Sec. 5.10), but, by Lemma 5.11, the change of the compatible scales with respect to the scale originally (i.e. before renormalizing) associated to the line, can be at most by one unit, i.e. n` can be changed into n0` = n` ± 1, so that (A1.1) will continue to hold also when the renormalization procedure is applied. This means that all the following analysis will be still valid for renormalized trees (as it has to be).
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
162
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
A1.2. Proof of Lemma 5.4. We prove inductively on the number of nodes of the trees the bounds Nn∗ (θ) ≤ max{0, 2 M (θ)2(n+3)/τ − 1} , pn (θ) ≤ max{0, 2 M (θ)2(n+3)/τ − 1} , Rn4 (θ)
≤ max{0, 2 M (θ)2
(n+3)/τ
−1+
(A1.2) Rn1 (θ)} ,
where M (θ) is defined in (5.3). The proof is inspired by [16] (see also [8]), and gives (5.14) and (5.15) with c = 22+3/τ . First of all note that if M (θ) < 2−(n+3)/τ then Nn (θ) = 0 as in such a case for any line ` ∈ Λ(θ) one has |ω 0 · ν ` | > C0 |ν ` |−τ > C0 M (θ)−τ > C0 2n+3 ,
(A1.3)
by the Diophantine hypothesis (2.2). A1.3. Bound on N ∗n (θ). If θ has only one node the bound is trivially satisfied as, if v is the only node in V (θ), one must have M (θ) = |ν v | ≥ 2−(n+3)/τ in order that the line exiting from v be on scale ≤ n: then 2 M (θ)2(n+3)/τ ≥ 2. If θ is a tree with V > 1 nodes, we assume that the bound holds for all trees having V 0 < V nodes. Define En = (2 2(n+3)/τ )−1 : so we have to prove that Nn∗ (θ) ≤ max{0, M (θ)En−1 − 1}. If the root line ` of θ is either on scale > n or resonant and on scale ≤ n, call θ1 , . . . , θm the m ≥ 1 subtrees entering the last node of θ and with M (θi ) ≥ 2−(n+3)/τ ; see Fig. 6. Then Nn∗ (θ) =
m X
Nn∗ (θi ) ,
(A1.4)
i=1
hence the bound follows by the inductive hypothesis. If the root line ` is nonresonant and on scale ≤ n, call `1 , . . . , `m the m ≥ 0 lines on scale ≤ n which are the nearest to ` (this means that no other line along the paths connecting the lines `1 , . . . , `m to the root line is on scale ≤ n). Note that in such a case `1 , . . . , `m are the entering line of a cluster T on scale > n; see Fig. 7.
Fig. 6. A tree θ consisting of a node v0 and m subtrees θ1 , . . . , θm with M (θi ) ≥ 2−(n+3)/τ entering v0 . The subtrees are represented by black balls. The subtree θ0 has M (θ 0 ) < 2−(n+3)/τ . The labels are not explicitly shown.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
163
Fig. 7. A tree θ consisting of a line (root line) exiting from a cluster T with m entering lines `1 , . . . , `m . Each of such lines is the root line of a subtree which is represented as a black ball. The labels are not explicitly shown.
One has Nn∗ (θ) = 1 +
m X
Nn∗ (θi ) ,
(A1.5)
i=1
so that the bound becomes trivial if either m = 0 or m ≥ 2. If m = 1 then T = θ \ θ1 , ` and `1 are both on scales ≤ n and `1 is not entering a resonance, so that |ω0 · ν ` | ≤ C0 2n+1 ,
|ω 0 · ν `1 | ≤ C0 2n+1 ,
and either ν ` = ν `1 and one has X |ν v | > (2 2(n+3)/τ )−1 = En ,
(A1.6)
(A1.7)
v∈V (T )
or ν ` 6= ν `1 , otherwise T would be a resonance. If ν ` 6= ν `1 , then, by (A1.6) one has |ω 0 · (ν ` − ν `1 )| ≤ C0 2n+2 , which, by the Diophantine condition (2.2), implies |ν ` − ν `1 | > 2−(n+2)/τ , so that again X |ν v | ≥ |ν ` − ν `1 | > 2−(n+2)/τ > (2 2(n+3)/τ )−1 = En , (A1.8) v∈V (T )
as in (A1.7). Therefore in both cases we get X |ν v | > En , M (θ) − M (θ1 ) =
(A1.9)
v∈T
which, inserted into (A1.5) with m = 1, gives, by using the inductive hypothesis, Nn∗ (θ) = 1 + Nn∗ (θ1 ) ≤ 1 + M (θ1 )En−1 − 1 ≤ 1 + (M (θ) − En )En−1 − 1 ≤ M (θ)En−1 − 1 ,
(A1.10)
hence the bound is proved also if the root line is nonresonant and on scale ≤ n.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
164
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
A1.4. Bound on pn (θ). The bound is trivial if M (θ) < 2(n+3)/τ , as Nn (θ) = 0 in such a case. Otherwise one can reason as follows. If the last node v0 of θ is not in a cluster on scale n one has pn (θ) =
m X
pn (θi ) ,
(A1.11)
i=1
if θ1 , . . . , θm are the subtrees entering v0 and with M (θi ) ≥ 2−(n+3)/τ , so that the bound follows from the inductive hypothesis. If the last node v0 of θ is inside a cluster T on scale n one has pn (θ) = 1 +
mT X
pn (θi ) ,
(A1.12)
i=1
where now θ1 , . . . , θmT are the subtrees entering the cluster T . The only nontrivial case if the one with mT = 1: in such a case there is only one line `1 entering the cluster T , and its scale is strictly smaller than n, i.e. n`1 ≤ n − 1. But then one has X |ν v | > 2−(n+3)/τ , (A1.13) v∈V (T )
as we are going to show. First note that T has to contain at least one line on scale n. Call ` such a line: then C0 2n−2 |ω 0 · ν ` | ≤ C0 2n+1 ,
(A1.14)
by (A1.1). We can write ν ` = ν 0` + σ` ν 1 , where ν 0` is the sum of the mode labels of the nodes w inside the resonance such that w v, if ` = `v , and ν 1 is the momentum flowing through `1 (see (5.11) and (5.12)). Therefore if (A1.13) did not hold one would have !−τ X |ν v | > C0 2n+3 , (A1.15) |ω0 · ν 0` | ≥ C0 |ν 0` |−τ ≥ C0 v∈V (T )
and, as |ω 0 · ν 1 | ≤ C0 2n`1 +1 ≤ C0 2n ,
(A1.16)
|ω 0 · ν ` | ≥ |ω 0 · ν 0` | − |ω0 · ν 1 | ≥ C0 2n+3 − C0 2n ≥ C0 2n+2 ,
(A1.17)
one would have
which is not consistent with (A1.14). Then note that (A1.13) implies M (θ1 ) ≤ M (θ) − En , so that the bound follows. A1.5. Bound on R4n (θ). If θ has only one node the bound is trivially satisfied. Let θ be a tree with V > 1 nodes and suppose that the bound on Rn4 (θ) holds for all trees with V 0 < V nodes.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
165
If the root line ` of θ is not the exiting line of a resonance or it is the exiting line of a resonance of type either 1 or 2 or 3, then call θ1 , . . . , θm the m ≥ 1 subtrees entering the last node of θ and with M (θi ) ≥ 2−(n+3)/τ . By the inductive hypothesis one has Rn4 (θi ) ≤ 2 M (θi )2(n+3)/τ − 1 + Rn1 (θi ) ,
(A1.18)
for all i = 1, . . . , m. Moreover Rn1 (θ) =
m X
Rn1 (θi ) ,
(A1.19)
i=1
if the line ` does not exit from a resonance of type 1, while Rn1 (θ) = 1 +
m X
Rn1 (θi )
(A1.20)
i=1
otherwise, so that Rn4 (θ)
=
m X
Rn4 (θi )
≤2
i=1
m X
! M (θi ) 2(n+3)/τ − m + Rn1 (θ)
i=1
≤ 2 M (θ)2(n+3)/τ − 1 + Rn1 (θ) ,
(A1.21)
as m ≥ 1. If the root line ` is the exiting line of a resonance T of type 4, then ` is a line h ← H and there is only one subtree θ0 entering T . One has Rn1 (θ) = Rn1 (θ0 ) , Rn4 (θ) = 1 + Rn4 (θ0 ) ,
(A1.22)
and the root line `0 of θ0 is a line H ← h with momentum ν `0 equal to ν ` and on scale ≤ n (as T is a resonance of type 4). Call `1 , . . . , `m the m ≥ 0 lines on scale ≤ n preceding `0 and which are the nearest to `0 : by construction they enter a cluster T0 having `0 as exiting line; see Fig. 8. If either m = 0 or m ≥ 2 the bound follows easily from the inductive hypothesis. If m = 1, denote by `1 the line entering T0 ; see Fig. 9. If ν `1 = ν `0 and X |ν v | < En , (A1.23) v∈V (T0 )
then T0 is a resonance, and in such a case it is a resonance of type 1 if `1 is a line h ← H and of type 2 if `1 is a line H ← h; otherwise T0 is not a resonance. In the latter case (i.e. if T0 is not a resonance) one has X |ν v | > En , (A1.24) v∈V (T0 )
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
166
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
Fig. 8. A tree θ consisting of a line (root line) exiting from a resonance T of type 4 whose entering line `0 is the exiting line of a cluster T0 with m entering lines `1 , . . . , `m . Each of such lines is the root line of a subtree which is represented as a black ball. The labels are not explicitly shown.
Fig. 9. A tree θ consisting of a line (root line) exiting from a resonance T of type 4 whose entering line `0 is the exiting line of a cluster T0 with only one entering line `1 . The subtree θ1 having `1 as root line is represented as a black ball. The labels are not explicitly shown.
which is obvious if ν `1 = ν `0 (by definition of resonance) and follows from the Diophantine condition if ν `1 6= ν `0 (see (A1.8)); then if T0 is not a resonance one has M (θ) − M (θ1 ) ≥ M (θ0 ) − M (θ1 ) > En .
(A1.25)
Note also that if T0 is not a resonance then Rn1 (θ) = Rn1 (θ0 ) = Rn1 (θ1 ) , Rn4 (θ) = 1 + Rn4 (θ0 ) = 1 + Rn4 (θ1 ) ,
(A1.26)
so that, by the inductive hypothesis (applied to θ1 ) and by (A1.25), one has Rn4 (θ) ≤ 1 + M (θ1 )En−1 − 1 + Rn1 (θ1 ) ≤ 1 + (M (θ) − En )En−1 − 1 + Rn1 (θ) ≤ M (θ)En−1 − 1 + Rn1 (θ) ,
(A1.27)
so that the assertion is proved. If T0 is a resonance of type 1, then Rn1 (θ) = Rn1 (θ0 ) = 1 + Rn1 (θ1 ) , Rn4 (θ) = 1 + Rn4 (θ0 ) = 1 + Rn4 (θ1 ) ,
(A1.28)
so that, by the inductive hypothesis (applied to θ1 ), one has Rn4 (θ) = 1 + Rn4 (θ1 ) ≤ 1 + (2 M (θ1 )2(n+3)/τ − 1 + Rn1 (θ1 )) ≤ 2 M (θ1 )2(n+3)/τ − 1 + Rn1 (θ) ≤ 2 M (θ)2(n+3)/τ − 1 + Rn1 (θ) , and the bound follows.
(A1.29)
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
167
Finally, if T0 is a resonance of type 2, then Rn1 (θ) = Rn1 (θ0 ) = Rn1 (θ1 ) ,
(A1.30)
Rn4 (θ) = 1 + Rn4 (θ0 ) = 1 + Rn4 (θ1 ) ,
and the line `1 entering T0 is again a line H ← h on scale ≤ n, so that one can ole of `0 ) and, if needed, we repeat for θ1 the above argument (simply `1 plays the rˆ iterate further the analysis until one of the two following possibilities arise: either one obtains a case for which the bound follows or one reaches a tree θ˜ having only a node, so not containing any resonances at all (in particular no other resonances of type 1 and 4). Note that if the first possibility never arise, then the second one sooner or later is unavoidable as at each iterative step the number of the nodes is ˜ + 1 = 1 and R1 (θ) = R1 (θ) ˜ = 0, and the decreased. In such a case Rn4 (θ) = Rn4 (θ) n n (n+3)/τ ≥ 1 in order that there be at least one line on scale bound holds as M (θ)2 ≤ n in θ. So at the end the assertion follows in all cases. Appendix 2. Proof of Lemma 5.9 A2.1. Introduction. We consider separately the first three types of resonances (for the type 4 there is nothing to prove). As in Sec. 3 we ignore the problem of the factorials, which, again, is solved by reasoning as in [2]. P A2.2. Resonance of type 1. First we prove that θ0 ∈FT (θ) VT (0) = 0. Given a tree θ consider all trees which can be obtained by shifting the entering line `2T ; see Fig. 10. Note that the trees so obtained are contained in the resummation family FT (θ) introduced in Sec. 5.8.
Fig. 10. The trees obtained by shifting the line entering a two-node resonance. The black balls represent the remaining parts of the trees. The labels are not explicitly shown.
Corresponding to such an operation VT (0) changes by a factor iν v if v is the node which the entering line is attached to, as all node factors and propagators do not change. By (5.10) the sum of all such values is zero. Then consider ∂VT (0). By construction ! ! X Y Y (n` ) (n`0 ) Fv G`0 ∂G` , (A2.1) ∂VT (0) = `∈Λ(T )
v∈V (T )
`0 ∈Λ(T )\`
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
168
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
where all propagators have to be computed for ω 0 · ν = 0, and d (n` ) (n` ) 0 G (ω 0 · ν ` + x) , x = ω0 · ν . ∂G` = dx ` x=0
(A2.2)
The line ` divides V (T ) into two disjoint set of nodes V1 and V2 , such that `1T exits from a node inside V1 and `2T enters a node inside V2 : if ` = `v one has V2 = {w ∈ V (T ) : w v} and V1 = V (T ) \ V2 ; see Fig. 4. By (5.10) if X X νv , ν2 = νv , (A2.3) ν1 = v∈V1
v∈V2
one has ν 1 + ν 2 = 0. Then consider the families F1 (θ) and F2 (θ) of trees obtained as follows: F1 (θ) is obtained from θ by detaching `1T then reattaching to all the nodes w ∈ V1 and by detaching `2T then reattaching to all the nodes w ∈ V2 , while F2 (θ) is obtained from θ by reattaching the line `1T to all the nodes w ∈ V2 and by reattaching the line `2T to all the nodes w ∈ V2 , and, simultaneously, by replacing all lines h ← H with lines H ← h and vice versa; note that F1 (θ) ∪ F2 (θ) ⊂ FT (θ). See Fig. 11 for a simple example.
!
+
,
*
-
"
.
#
&
'
(
$
%
)
/
0
Fig. 11. The two families F1 (θ) = {θ1 , θ10 } and F2 (θ) = {θ2 , θ20 } for a three-node resonance. Here V1 = {v2 , v3 } and V2 = {v1 }. The black balls represent the remaining parts of the trees. The labels are not explicitly shown.
As a consequence of such an operation the arrows of some lines `0 ∈ Λ(θ) \ `0 change their directions: this means that some line h ← H becomes H ← h and vice versa, and, correspondingly, some propagator g(ν) becomes −g(−ν), but g(−ν) = −g(ν), so that no overall change is produced by such factors. On the other hand one has a derived propagator ±g 0 (ν ` ) for the trees in F1 (θ) and a derived propagator ∓g 0 (−ν ` ) for the trees in F2 (θ), and g 0 (ν) = g 0 (−ν). Then by summing over all the possible trees in F1 (θ) we obtain a value i2 ν 1 ν 2 times a common factor, while
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
169
by summing over all the possible trees in F2 (θ) we obtain −i2 ν 1 ν 2 times the same common factor, so that the sum of two sums gives zero. P A2.3. Resonance of type 3. To prove that θ0 ∈FT (θ) VT (0) = 0 simply reason as for VT (0) in the previous case, by using that the entering line is a line h ← H. A2.4. Resonance of type 2. We want to show that also in such a case P θ 0 ∈FT VT (0) = 0. Given a tree θ consider all trees obtained by detaching the exiting line, then reattaching to all the nodes v ∈ V (T ); see Fig. 12. Note again that the trees so obtained are contained in the resummation family FT (θ).
Fig. 12. The trees obtained by shifting the line entering a two-node resonance. The black balls represent the remaining parts of the trees. The labels are not explicitly shown.
In such a case again some propagators can change, i.e. a line h ← H can become H ← h and vice versa but the corresponding propagator does not change (reason as above for resonances of type 1). So at the end we obtain a common factor times iν v , where v is the node which the exiting line is attached to. By (5.10) again we P obtain θ0 ∈FT VT (0) = 0. So the lemma is proved. Appendix 3. Proof of Lemma 5.11 A3.1. Notations. As in Sec. 5.12 we define the depth D(T ) of a resonance T by setting D(T ) = 1 if there is no resonance containing T , and setting D(T ) = D(T 0 ) + 1 if T is contained inside a resonance T 0 and all the other resonances inside T 0 (if there are any) do not contain T . Given a resonance T , we denote here by T0 the set of nodes and lines internal to T0 not contained in any resonance inside T . Given a resonance T and a line ` ∈ T we write ν ` = ν 0` + σ` ν as in (5.27), with ν = ν `2T . By shifting the lines external to the resonances a momentum ν ` can be changed into ±ν 0` + σν (as noted in Sec. 5.8). A3.2. Proof of Lemma 5.11. The proof is by induction of the depth D of the resonances. If T is a resonance with depth D(T ) = 1 and ` ∈ T0 , denoting by n the scale of the line `2T , then one must have nT ≥ n + 3 by definition of resonance, as it can easily proved. Moreover n` ≥ nT for all ` ∈ T , by definition of cluster).
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
170
00112
M. Bartuccelli & G. Gentile
Then, by denoting by ν the momentum of the line entering T , one has C0 2n` ≥ |ω0 · ν ` | > C0 2n` −1 ,
(A3.1)
|ω0 · ν| ≤ C0 2n ≤ C0 2nT −3 ≤ C0 2n` −3 ,
(A3.2)
while
so that |ω0 · ν 0` | ≥ |ω 0 · ν ` | − |ω 0 · ν| ≥ C0 2n` −1 − C0 2n` −3 ≥ C0 2n` −2 , |ω0 · ν 0` | ≤ |ω 0 · ν ` | + |ω 0 · ν| ≤ C0 2n` + C0 2n` −3 ≤ C0 2n` +1 ,
(A3.3)
which proves the assertion for lines in T0 with D(T ) = 1. Fix D > 1. Then suppose that the assertion holds for all resonances of depth D0 < D: we show that then it holds also for resonances of depth D. Let ` be a line in T0 , for some resonance T ∈ T (θ) of depth D(T ) = D. By the inductive hypothesis `2T is contained inside a resonance of depth D − 1, so that its scale can be changed at most by one unit, i.e., if one had n`2T = n before shifting the lines, the scale n`2T has become n0`2 with n`2T −1 ≤ n0`2 ≤ n`2T +1: then n0`2 ≤ nT −2. T T T Therefore one has C0 2n` ≥ |ω0 · ν ` | > C0 2n` −1 ,
(A3.4)
|ω0 · ν| ≤ C0 2n+1 ≤ C0 2nT −2 ≤ C0 2n` −2 ,
(A3.5)
while
so that again |ω0 · ν 0` | ≥ |ω 0 · ν ` | − |ω 0 · ν| ≥ C0 2n` −1 − C0 2n` −2 ≥ C0 2n` −2 , |ω0 · ν 0` | ≤ |ω 0 · ν ` | + |ω 0 · ν| ≤ C0 2n` + C0 2n` −2 ≤ C0 2n` +1 ,
(A3.6)
which proves the assertion for the lines in T0 with D(T ) = 1. Acknowledgments We are indebted to L. Chierchia and especially to G. Gallavotti for many discussions. References [1] M. V. Bartuccelli, K. V. Georgiou and G. Gentile, “KAM theory, Lindstedt Series and the stability of the upside-down pendulum”, to appear in Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. Ser. A. [2] A. Berretti and G. Gentile, “Scaling properties for the radius of convergence of Lindstedt series: generalized standard maps”, J. Math. Pures Appl. (9) 79(7) (2000) 691–713. [3] F. Bonetto, G. Gallavotti, G. Gentile and V. Mastropietro, “Lindstedt series, ultraviolet divergences and Moser’s theorem”, Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 26(3) (1998) 545–593.
February 4, 2002 10:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00112
Lindstedt Series for Perturbations of Isochronous Systems
171
[4] F. Bonetto, G. Gallavotti, G. Gentile and V. Mastropietro, “Quasi linear flows on tori: regularity of their linearization”, Comm. Math. Phys. 192(3) (1998) 707–736. [5] L. Chierchia and G. Gallavotti, “Smooth prime integrals for quasi-integrable Hamiltonian systems”, Nuovo Cimento B 67(2) (1982) 277–295. [6] L. H. Eliasson, “Absolutely convergent series expansions for quasi-periodic motions”, Math. Phys. Electron. J. 2 (1996) 1–33. [7] G. Gallavotti, “Quasi-integrable mechanical systems”, pp. 539–624 in Critical Phenomena, Random Systems, Gauge Theories, Les Houches, Session XLIII (1984), Vol. II, eds. K. Osterwalder and R. Stora, North Holland, Amsterdam, 1986. [8] G. Gallavotti, “Twistless KAM tori”, Comm. Math. Phys. 164(1) (1994) 145–156. [9] G. Gallavotti, G. Gentile and V. Mastropietro, “A field theory approach to Lindstedt series for hyperbolic tori in three time scales problems”, J. Math. Phys. 40(12) (1999) 6430–6472. [10] G. Gentile, “Whiskered tori with prefixed frequencies and Lyapunov spectrum”, Dynamics and Stability of Systems 10(3) (1995) 269–308. [11] G. Gentile and V. Mastropietro, “Methods for the analysis of the Lindstedt series for KAM tori and renormalizability in Classical Mechanics: A review with some applications”, Rev. Math. Phys. 8(3) (1996) 393–444. [12] A. N. Kolmogorov, “On the preservation of conditionally periodic motions”, Dokl. Akad. Nauk 96 (1954) 527–530; English translation in G. Casati and J. Ford, Stochastic behavior in classical and quantum Hamiltonians, Lecture Notes in Physics 93, Springer, Berlin, 1979. [13] J. Moser, “Convergent series expansions for quasi–periodic motions”, Math. Ann. 169 (1967) 136–176. [14] H. Poincar´e, Les m´ethodes nouvelles de la m´ecanique c´eleste, Gauthier-Villars, Paris, Vol. I, 1892, Vol. II, 1893, Vol. III, 1899. ¨ [15] J. P¨ oschel, Uber Invariante Tori in Differenzierbaren Hamiltonschen Systemen, Bonner Mathematische Schriften 120, Universit¨ at Bonn, Mathematisches Institut, Bonn, 1980. “Integrability of Hamiltonian systems on Cantor sets”, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 35(5) (1982) 653–696. [16] J. P¨ oschel, “Invariant manifolds of complex analytic mappings near fixed points”, in Critical Phenomena, Random Systems, Gauge Theories, Les Houches, Session XLIII (1984), Vol. II, eds. K. Osterwalder and R. Stora, North Holland, Amsterdam, 1986. [17] W. M. Schmidt, Diophantine Approximation, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 785, Springer, Berlin, 1980. [18] H. Whitney, “Analytic extensions of differentiable functions defined in closed sets”, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 36(1) (1934) 63–89.
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 2 (2002) 173–198 c World Scientific Publishing Company
GROUND STATE PROPERTIES OF THE NELSON HAMILTONIAN: A GIBBS MEASURE-BASED APPROACH
´ ˝ VOLKER BETZ, FUMIO HIROSHIMA∗ , JOZSEF LORINCZI, ROBERT A. MINLOS† and HERBERT SPOHN Zentrum Mathematik, Technische Universit¨ at M¨ unchen Gabelsbergerstr. 49, 80290 M¨ unchen, Germany ∗Department
of Mathematics and Physics, Setsunan University Osaka 572-8508, Japan †Dobrushin Mathematical Laboratory of the Institute for Information Transmission Problems of the Russian Academy of Sciences Bol’shoy Karetny per. 19, Moscow, 101447, Russia
Received 25 June 2001 The Nelson model describes a quantum particle coupled to a scalar Bose field. We study properties of its ground state through functional integration techniques in case the particle is confined by an external potential. We obtain bounds on the average and the variance of the Bose field both in position and momentum space, on the distribution of the number of bosons, and on the position space distribution of the particle.
1. Introduction Ground states in quantum mechanics can be analysed through two in essence distinct techniques. The obvious choice is the eigenvalue equation, Hψ = Eψ, which after all serves as a definition of the ground state. The second route is more indirect and uses positivity properties of the semigroup e−tH , t ≥ 0, which happen to be valid for many models. Through a Trotter type formula one can then represent ground state expectation values as averages with respect to a certain probability measure on a function space. This measure has the structure of a Gibbs measure and methods from statistical mechanics become available. The standard folklore is that for systems with a few degrees of freedom the eigenvalue equation is the more powerful approach, whereas for quantum fields with an infinite number of degrees of freedom one should employ functional integration. In fact in the latter case, the Hamiltonian H is in general not available as a self-adjoint operator on some Hilbert space, and one uses functional integration techniques to define H in the first place. In this paper we investigate the Nelson model of a quantum particle confined by an external potential and coupled to a scalar Bose field. This is a borderline case: the model has a well-defined Hamiltonian H, cf. Sec. 2 below, as well as a 173
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
174
00111
V. Betz et al.
natural functional measure. There has been growing interest in this model recently in connection with a rigorous control of resonances and radiation damping [2]. Here we take up the technique of functional integration with the goal of establishing bounds on ground state expectations of physical interest. A basic qualitative question is how the coupling to the field modifies the localization of the particle. We will prove a pointwise exponential bound, even a superexponential bound if the potential is sufficiently confining, for the ground state density of the particle. They support the physical picture that coupling enhances localization. For the Bose field we study the fluctuations, which turn out to increase through the presence of the particle, and the average density in position and momentum space. For the latter we prove upper and lower bounds which are sharp enough to pin down the infrared divergent behaviour. Finally we establish superexponential bounds on the distribution of the boson number. The core of our paper is a “dictionary” which translates ground state expectations in Fock space into averages over the Gibbs measure. When this translation is applied to quantities of physical interest, the aforementioned bounds turn out to be a consequence of elementary inequalities. The only extra tool that we need is a diamagnetic type inequality for estimating the position density of the particle. Some of our bounds, possibly in weaker form, have been proved before by other means; we refer to Sec. 6 for a discussion. The Nelson model has the special feature that, as first observed by Feynman [4], one can integrate over the field degrees of freedom resulting in an effective action for the particle. Nelson [16] used this method in a study of the ultraviolet limit, which turned out to be the gateway to his famous work on Markov random fields. Since then the understanding of the probabilistic structure of the functional measure corresponding to Nelson’s model has improved considerably; we use the occasion to provide a concise and self-contained framework in Secs. 3 and 4. The Nelson model with massless bosons is both infrared and ultraviolet divergent. As proved by Nelson [17] through operator techniques, the latter is of a rather mild nature, since only the energy has to be renormalized. In this work we simply assume the appropriate cutoffs at small and large k to hold so that the Hamiltonian H of (2.1) is a self-adjoint operator in Fock space with a unique ground state. The functional integral for the Nelson model with massless bosons in dimension d ≥ 3 is studied in [14]. The construction of the appropriate functional measure relies on a cluster expansion for the effective Gibbs measure on particle trajectories [13]. This model is infrared divergent in d = 3 and convergent for d > 3. Infrared divergence means in the language of functional integration that the time t = 0 path measure is singular with respect to the free t = 0 measure. In fact, this measure is absolutely continuous with respect to an appropriately shifted Gaussian measure, which then leads to a renormalized Hamiltonian Hren in Fock space [15]. Arai [1] studies Hren through operator techniques. We also refer to the monumental work of J. Fr¨ ohlich [5, 6] where ground state properties of the Nelson model with zero external potential are studied, including the removal of ultraviolet and infrared cutoffs.
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
175
2. Representation in Fock Space The Hamiltonian of the model in Fock space is the operator H := Hp ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ Hf + HI
(2.1)
in L2 (Rd ) ⊗ F. We use L2 (Rd ) to denote the set of the square integrable functions with respect to Lebesgue measure on Rd , while we will write L2 (µ) for the square integrable functions with respect to any other measure µ. F denotes the symmetric Fock space over Rd , and 1 Hp = − ∆ + V , 2 Z Hf = ω(k)a∗k ak dk , Z HI =
1 p (ˆ %(k)eikq ak + %ˆ(−k)e−ikq a∗k )dk . 2ω(k)
odinger operator Hp to be of the We require the potential V : Rd → R of the Schr¨ form V + − V − with V + , V − > 0, V − in the Kato class Kd (see [21]) and V + locally in Kd . In particular, V can be the sum of a continuous function that is bounded below and a function having Coulomb singularities. In addition, we assume that V is chosen such that Hp has a unique ground state, i.e. inf spec(Hp ) is an eigenvalue of multiplicity one. As for Hf and HI , we require ω(k) = ω ¯ (k) = ω(−k) ,
%(k) = %¯(k) ,
0 < ω(k) except on a set of Lebesgue measure zero, %ˆ √ ∈ L2 (Rd ) , ω
%ˆ ∈ L2 (Rd ) . ω
(2.2) (2.3) (2.4)
Here and henceforth fˆ denotes Fourier transform, f ∨ will be used for the inverse Fourier transform of f , and f¯ denotes the complex conjugation of f . For the convenience of the reader, we briefly recall the notions concerning symˆ the space of metric Fock space involved in the above formulas. Denote by L2 (Rd )⊗n L2 (Rdn )-functions f that are symmetric in the sense that for each k1 , . . . , kn ∈ Rd and each permutation π of {1, . . . , n}, we have f (k1 , . . . , kn ) = f (kπ(1) , . . . , kπ(n) ). L∞ ˆ The symmetric Fock space F is the set of all F = (f0 , f1 , . . .) ∈ n=0 L2 (Rd )⊗n for which the direct sum norm, kF k2F =
∞ X
kfn k2L2 (Rd )⊗n , ˆ
(2.5)
n=0 ˆ , it follows from the polarisation formula for converges. Putting F (n) = L2 (Rd )⊗n (n) is spanned by linear combinations of functions multilinear maps (see [19]) that F ˆ with f ∈ L2 (Rd ) (where we use the convention f ⊗0 ∈ C). of the form f ⊗n = f ⊗n
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
176
00111
V. Betz et al.
Thus for defining linear operators on F it is sufficient to specify their action on these elements. Given such an f ⊗n ∈ F (n) and g ∈ L2 (Rd ), we define Z √ ∗ ⊗n ∗ ˆ ∈ F (n+1) , ≡ ak g(k)dk f ⊗n = n + 1f ⊗n ⊗g a (g)f a(g)f ⊗n ≡
Z
√ ak g(k)dk f ⊗n = nh¯ g , f iL2 (Rd ) f ⊗(n−1) ∈ F (n−1) for n > 0 ,
ˆ is given by and (a(g))(F (0) ) = 0. Here, f ⊗n ⊗g (f
n+1 1 X ⊗g)(k1 , . . . , kn+1 ) = n + 1 i=1
⊗n ˆ
n+1 Y
! f (kj ) g(ki ) .
j6=i
a∗ is called the Bose creation operator and a the annihilation operator. Both of them P∞ < ∞}. are defined on the common domain {(f0 , f1 , . . .) ∈ F : n=0 nkfn k2L2 (Rd )⊗n ˆ g )F, GiF with F, G in the above domain. Furthermore, hF, Ra(g)GiF = ha∗ (¯ The operator ω(k)a∗k ak dk is the differential second quantisation of the multiplication operator f 7→ ωf in L2 (Rd ). In general, given an operator B in L2 (Rd ), the second quantisation Γ(B) of B is the operator in F with Γ(B)f ⊗n = (Bf )⊗n . If (Bt )t≥0 is a contraction semigroup on L2 (Rd ) with generator A, then it is easy to see that (Γ(Bt ))t≥0 is a contraction semigroup on F . The generator of this semigroup is then called the differential second quantisation of A. Explicitly, dΓ(A)f ⊗n =
n X
ˆ ⊗(n−1) (Af )⊗f
(2.6)
i=1
for all f ∈ D(A). It follows that Z n X ⊗n ∗ ⊗n ˆ ⊗(n−1) . ≡ ω(k)ak ak dk f = (ωf )⊗f dΓ(ω)f
(2.7)
i=1
For a self-adjoint operator A, both Γ(A) and dΓ(A) are self-adjoint. For every ε > 0 there exists b > 0 such that
%ˆ
kHfg k + b √%ˆ kgk kHIg k ≤ ε
ω 2
ω 2 L
(2.8)
L
for all g ∈ D(Hf ). Thus by the Kato–Rellich theorem, conditions (2.4) ensure that H is self-adjoint on D(∆ ⊗ 1) ∩ D(1 ⊗ Hf ) and bounded from below. 3. Representation in Function Space In this section, we develop the Schr¨odinger representation of H, i.e. we find an ˜ which is unitarily equivalent to H and acts in an L2 -space. Moreover, operator H ˜ will be the generator of a Markov process. H
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
177
We begin our construction by applying the so-called ground state transformation to Hp . Let us write ψ0 for the strictly positive, unique ground state of Hp . The operator of multiplication with ψ0 will be denoted by ψ0 as well. ψ0 is a unitary map ˜ p = ψ −1 Hp ψ0 of from L2 (ψ02 dq) to L2 (Rd ), and thus the ground state transform H 0 ˜ p is unitary equivalent to Hp . H ˜ p is the generator of a Hp acts in L2 (ψ02 dq), and H stationary Rd -valued P (φ)1 -process, i.e. the stationary solution of the SDE dqt = (∇(log ψ0 ))(qt )dt + dBt . We will denote the path measure of the P (φ)1 -process by N 0 , and its stationary measure by N0 . Note that dN0 (q) = ψ02 (q)dq. In order to construct an L2 -space for the bosonic field, consider the space S 0 = 0 S (Rd ) of tempered distributions and the space S = S(Rd ) of (real-valued) Schwartz functions. Write G for the Gaussian measure on paths ξ = {ξt : t ∈ R} (ξt ∈ S 0 ) with mean 0 and covariance Z 1 e−ω(k)|t−s| dk g (k) (3.1) G(ξs (f )ξt (g)) = fˆ(k)ˆ 2ω(k) R for all f ∈ S with |fˆ|2 (k)/ω(k)dk < ∞. G is the measure of an S 0 -valued OrnsteinUhlenbeck process, i.e. a stationary Gaussian Markov process with state space contained in S 0 . The stationary measure of G will be denoted by G. It is the Gaussian measure on S 0 with mean 0 and covariance obtained by setting t = s in (3.1). To get some information about support properties and path continuity of G, we define a Hilbert seminorm on S by Z 2 kf kBD = fˆ(k) max{ω(k), 1}D(k, k 0) max{ω(k 0 ), 1}fˆ(k 0 )dk dk 0 , where D(k, k 0 ) is the integral kernel of (−∆ + |k|2 )−(d+1) . The completion of S with respect to k.kBD will be denoted by BD . For G-almost all ξ, the map t 7→ ξt takes its values from BD and is continuous with respect to the topology generated by BD [13]. When working with the measure G it is convenient to introduce the Hilbert space K obtained by completing S with respect to the (complex) scalar product Z 1 dk (f, g ∈ S) . (3.2) g (k) hf, giK = fˆ(k)ˆ 2ω(k) Extending the action of ξ to complex-valued functions by putting ξ(f + ig) = ξ(f ) + iξ(g), we find that Z ξ(f )ξ(g)dG(ξ) = hf, giK for all f, g ∈ K . In particular, the map ξ 7→ ξ(f ) is a well-defined element of L2 (G) for each f ∈ K; we will denote it by ξ(f ).
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
178
00111
V. Betz et al.
The connection between the Fock space F and L2 (G) is given by the Wiener– Itˆo–Segal isomorphism. In order to describe this isomorphism, we need Wick polynomials. The Wick polynomial of order n with respect to G is defined recursively by : ξ(f )0 : = 1 , : ξ(f ) : = ξ(f ) , √ n : ξ(f1 ) · · · ξ(fn ) : = : ξ(f1 ) · · · ξ(fn−1 ) : ξ(fn ) (3.3) Z n−1 n−1 X Y 1 ξ(fi )ξ(fn )dG(ξ) : ξ(fj ) : . −√ n − 1 i=1 j6=i Note √ that this differs from the convention used e.g. in white noise theory by a factor of n! in the nth Wick polynomial. The reason is that there, the Fock space norm is usually defined with an n! in front of the nth term in (2.5), while we use the convention from [17]. The Wiener–Itˆo–Segal isomorphism now is the map θ : F → L2 (G) ,
ˆ · · · ⊗f ˆ n 7→ : f1 ⊗
n Y
√ ξ(( 2ωfi )∨ ) : .
(3.4)
i=1
A carefully done proof of the fact that θ is indeed an isomorphism can be found in [10], although there a different norm convention is used for the Fock space. Remark 3.1. The fact that the Fourier transform is part of our version of the Wiener–Itˆo–Segal isomorphism is somewhat inconvenient and leads to aesthetically slightly unsatisfactory formulas. We could have avoided this by defining the Gaussian process G on distributions that produce real numbers when applied to Fourier transforms of real-valued functions, and omitting the hats in (3.1). However, since this also does not seem to be the most natural thing to do, we decided to stick to the established convention [13, 14]. Let us now describe the images of Hf and HI under θ. From (3.4) and (2.7) it is easy to see that ˜ f : ξ(f1 ) · · · ξ(fn ) : ≡ (θHf θ−1 ) : ξ(f1 ) · · · ξ(fn ) : H =
n X
: ξ((ω fˆi )∨ )
i=1
n Y
ξ(fj ) : .
(3.5)
j6=i
˜ f is the generator of the process G [18]. Note that H On the other hand, the unitary map ψ0 ⊗ 1 commutes with HI . Thus writing Θ = ψ0−1 ⊗ θ, we easily see from (3.3) and (3.4) that for g ∈ L2 (N0 ) and f ∈ K, ˜ I (g⊗ : ξ(f )n :) ≡ (ΘHI Θ−1 )(g⊗ : ξ(f )n :) H = (g⊗ : ξ(f )n :)ξ(%(. − q)) = (g⊗ : ξ(f )n :) · (ξ ∗ %)(q) .
(3.6)
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
179
Of course, ξ(%(. − q)) in the above means the map (ξ, q) 7→ ξ(%(. − q)). Extending ˜ I is the operator of multiplication with (q, ξ) 7→ (3.6) by linearity, we find that H (ξ ∗ %)(q). In sum, we find ˜p ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ H ˜f + H ˜I . ˜ ≡ ΘHΘ−1 = H H
(3.7)
˜ p ⊗1 acting in L2 (N0 ⊗G) = L2 (N0 )⊗L2 (G) is the generator ˜f +H The operator 1⊗ H of a stationary Markov process. We will denote the measure N 0 ⊗ G corresponding to this Markov process by P 0 , and its stationary measure N0 ⊗ G by P0 . ˜ is the sum of the generator of a Markov process and From (3.7) we see that H a multiplication operator. Modulo technical assumptions (see below), this implies Z Rt ˆ hF, e−tH GiL2 (P0 ) = F (q0 , ξ0 )e− 0 (ξs ∗%)(qs )ds G(qt , ξt )dP 0 , (F, G ∈ H) . (3.8) (3.8) is called Feynman–Kac–Nelson formula. Nelson [16] proved it by explicit ˜ I . However, since we have path continuity of P 0 and HI is approximation of H infinitesimally bounded with respect to Hp ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ Hf (see (2.8)), the standard proof using the Trotter formula (see e.g. [20]) also works. 4. Gibbs Measures Rt The factor exp(− 0 ξs ∗ %(qs )ds)dP 0 appearing in (3.8) defines a finite measure on path space C(R, Rd × BD ). Normalizing it results in a probability measure with a Gibbsian structure for finite intervals (or in “finite volume”). We are going to investigate the existence of the infinite volume limit (i.e. t → ∞) of this measure. The method we use here to prove existence relies on the following ˜ has a normalized, positive ground state Ψ ∈ L2 (P). Main assumption: H We will require this assumption to be fulfilled throughout the remainder of the paper. Sufficient conditions for the existence and uniqueness of an L2 -ground state of ˜ are [22] H √ (i) %ˆ/ ω ∈ L2 , %ˆ/ω ∈ L2 , (ii) %ˆ/ω 3/2 ∈ LZ2 , |ˆ %(k)|2 k 2 dk, (iii) Σ − Ep > ω(k)(2ω(k) + k 2 ) where Σ is the infimum of the essential spectrum of Hp , and Ep = inf spec Hp . In [8], more general particle-field couplings are allowed. When specialized to our setting, the assumptions in [8] correspond to Σ = ∞. Let us briefly comment on the above conditions: (i) appears in Sec. 2 as Assumption (2.4) and was needed there to ensure existence and self-adjointness of H. In the context of Gibbs measures (i) is required for
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
180
00111
V. Betz et al.
the existence of the free energy limT →∞ T1 log(ZT ); see below the definition of ZT . (ii) is called the infrared cut-off Under additional assumptions on V and R condition. on the coupling strength |ˆ %|2 /ω dk, (ii) is also necessary for the existence of an L2 ground state [14]. Thus although we will explicitly assume (ii) to hold only after Theorem 4.1, implicitly it plays a role also there. (iii) is needed for currently available proofs. For the Pauli–Fierz model with external potential, Griesemer et al. [9] prove the existence of a ground state without such an extra assumption. Thus one would expect (i) and (ii) to suffice. Note that if lim|q|→∞ V (q) = ∞, then Σ = ∞ and (iii) follows from (i). Let us write X = {Xt : t ∈ R} = {(qt , ξt ) : t ∈ R} for elements of C(R, Rd × BD ), and Z T 1 exp − (ξs ∗ %)(qs )ds dP 0 (X) , (4.1) dPT (X) = ZT −T R RT for the finite volume Gibbs measure. Here ZT = exp(− −T (ξs ∗ %)(qs )ds)dP 0 (X) is the partition function. In order to state our theorem about existence of the T → ∞ limit of PT , we still need some preparations. First let us recall the notion of local weak convergence: For a topological space Y and an interval S ⊂ R, denote by FS the σ-field over C(R, Y ) generated by the point evaluations with points in S. A sequence of probability measures (µn ) on C(R, Y ) is said to converge locally weakly to a measure µ if for each compact interval S ⊂ R and each bounded, FS -measurable function F , limn→∞ µn (F ) = µ(F ). ˜ and put H ¯ =H ˜ − E0 , where E0 = Secondly, let Ψ be the ground state of H, ˜ Denote by P the unique probability inf spec(H) is the ground state energy of H. d measure on C(R, R × BD ) characterized by the conditions Z ¯ ¯ (4.2) F dP = hΨ, f1 e−(t2 −t1 )H f2 · · · e−(tn −tn−1 )H fn ΨiL2 (P0 ) for all F (X) = f1 (Xt1 ) · · · fn (Xtn ) with f1 , . . . , fn ∈ L∞ (Rd × BD ), t1 < · · · < tn . Note that the r.h.s. of (4.2) in fact defines a probability measure because of ¯ e−tH Ψ = Ψ, kΨkL2(P0 ) = 1 and Kolmogorov’s consistency theorem. Theorem 4.1. PT → P in the topology of local weak convergence as T → ∞. Moreover, P fulfills the DLR-equations with respect to the family {PT : T > 0}, ¯ ∈ C(R, Rd × BD ), i.e. for F ∈ F[−T,T ] and P-almost all X ! Z Z T 1 0,T ¯ = F (X) exp − (ξs ∗ %)(qs )ds dPX P(F |F[−T,T ]c )(X) ¯ T (X) , ¯ −T ,X ZT −T (4.3)
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
181
0,T 0 ¯ where PX ¯ −T ,X ¯ T (X) is P conditional on {X±T = X±T }. Hence, P is a Gibbs RT measure with respect to P 0 for the interaction given by −T (ξs ∗ %)(qs )ds.
Proof. Let S > 0 and F ∈ F[−S,S] be bounded. Since ˜
˜
ZT = h1, e−2T H 1iL2 (P0 ) = ke−T H 1k2L2 (P0 ) , by using the Feynman–Kac–formula and the Markov property of P 0 we find that, for T > S, ZZ Z 1 ˜ ˜ (e−(T −S)H 1)(X−S )(e−(T −S)H 1)(XS ) F dPT = ke−T H˜ 1k2L2 (P0 ) Z ×
Z −
exp
S
−S
0,S F (X)dPX (X) −S ,XS
(ξs ∗ %)(qs )ds
× dP0 (X−S )dP0 (XS ) .
(4.4) ¯ −(T −τ )H
1 → hΨ, 1iΨ as T → ∞ in By spectral theory, for any τ ∈ R we have e L2 (P0 ). Ψ is strictly positive, therefore hΨ, 1i > 0 and 1 ke−T H¯ 1k
¯
T →∞
e−(T −τ )H 1 −→ Ψ
in L2 (P0 ) , for every fixed τ ∈ R .
(4.5)
L2 (P0 )
From this it follows that 1 ˜ T →∞ e−(T −τ )H 1 −→ e−τ E0 Ψ in L2 (P0 ) , for every fixed τ ∈ R , (4.6) ¯ −T H ke 1kL2 (P0 ) and thus
Z lim
T →∞
ZZ F dPT =
Ψ(X−S )Ψ(XS )e−2SE0
Z ×
e−
RS −S
(ξs ∗%)(qs )ds
0,S F (X)dPX (X) −S ,XS Z
× dP0 (X−S )dP0 (XS ) =
F dP .
This shows local weak convergence, and (4.2) as well as (4.3) now follow from the last equation by using the Feynman–Kac formula and the Markov property of P 0 . From (4.2) it is immediate that P is the measure of a stationary Markov process and dP = Ψ2 , dP0 where P is the stationary measure of P.
(4.7)
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
182
00111
V. Betz et al.
From now on we assume that Z 0 Z ∞ Z |ˆ %|2 C% = 2 sup ds dt |W (qs − qt , s − t)| = dk < ∞ . 2ω 3 q∈C(R,Rd ) −∞ 0
(4.8)
Note that (4.8) is actually the infrared condition. As discussed above, in general we will not have Ψ ∈ L2 (P0 ) if the infrared condition is violated, and thus it is clear that (4.8) will be essential for the results of Secs. 5 and 6 to hold. Here we use (4.8) to describe some nice additional structure of P. Fix q¯ ∈ C(R, Rd ) and denote by PTq¯ the measure PT conditional on {q = q¯}. Note that the condition q¯ appears as an upper index here, as opposed to the lower indices used in Theorem 4.1. The convention we use throughout is that conditioning on a path is denoted by upper indices, while conditioning on points is denoted by lower ones. PTq¯ is a Gaussian measure on C(R, BD ) with mean Z
Z T ξt (f )dPTq¯ (ξ) = Mt,¯ q (f ) = −
Z
T
ds
dk
−T
fˆ(k)ˆ %(k)eik¯qs −ω(k)|t−s| e 2ω(k)
(f ∈ K, f real-valued, t ∈ R) and covariance equal to that of G. Since Z
T
fˆ(k)ˆ %(k)eik¯qs −ω(k)|t−s| e dk 2ω(k) Z ˆ Z ∞ Z ˆ |f | |ˆ %| |f | |ˆ %|e−ω|t−s| dk = ≤ ds dk 2 2ω ω −∞ Z
ds −T
Z ≤ kf kK
2|ˆ %|2 dk ω3
1/2 < ∞,
(4.9)
T Mt,¯q (f ) = limT →∞ Mt,¯ ¯, t and f . By the convergence theory for q (f ) exists for all q Gaussian measures it follows that P q¯ = limT →∞ PTq¯ exists in the topology of weak convergence, and is a Gaussian measure with mean Mt,¯q and the same covariance as G. Knowing the structure of P q¯ for each q¯, in order to understand P we need only study the distribution N of q¯ under P. This will then give us a convenient representation of P as a mixture of Gaussian measures that R T we will use in the next section. To obtain N , let f ∈ L1 (N 0 ). Then, since ξ 7→ −T (ξs ∗ %)(qs )ds is linear and G is a Gaussian measure, the integration with respect to ξ can be explicitly done and we obtain Z T Z T Z Z RT − −T (ξs ∗%)(qs )ds 0 dP = f (q) exp − W (qs − qt , s − t)ds dt dN 0 f (q)e −T
with 1 W (q, t) = − 2
Z
−T
|ˆ %(k)|2 cos(kq)e−ω(k)|t| dk . 2ω(k)
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
183
From now on we thus look at the Gibbs measure Z T Z T 1 dNT = exp − W (qs − qt , s − t)ds dt dN 0 . ZT −T −T By taking F = f ⊗ 1 in Theorem 4.1 we have the following Corollary 4.2. There exists a probability measure N on C(R, Rd ) such that NT → N in the topology of local weak convergence. N is the measure of a stationary Rd valued process. The stationary measure of N will be denoted by N. We have Z Z f dN = f ⊗ 1 dP , for each f ∈ L1 (N ), and Z Z Z F (q, ξ)dP(q, ξ) = F (q, ξ)dP q (ξ) dN (q)
(4.10)
for each F ∈ L1 (P). Both PT and NT are finite volume Gibbs measures relative to the reference measures P 0 and N 0 , respectively. Checking that N admits a DLR representation (i.e. is a Gibbs measure) is, however, slightly more involved than it was for P because N is no longer the measure of a Markov process. This is due to the long range pair potential W that is picked up by integration over the field. The next theorem states that N does however fulfill the DLR-equations with respect to the family of measures ZZ 1 q¯ W (qs − qt , s − t)ds dt dNT0,¯q (q) , (4.11) dNT (q) = q¯ exp − ZT ΛT where NT0,¯q is the P (φ)1 -measure conditioned on {q(s) = q¯(s) ∀ |s| > T }, and ΛT = ([−T, T ] × R) ∪ (R × [−T, T ]) . Theorem 4.3. N is a Gibbs measure for the family {NTq¯ : T > 0}. The proof of this theorem would interrupt the main line of the paper and is therefore moved to the Appendix. To conclude this section, let us note that if the infrared condition (condition (ii) above) is fulfilled, then the interaction energy between the path on the left and right half-lines is uniformly bounded. Thus [13] we expect N to be unique on the set of paths with at most logarithmic increase in this case. 5. Ground State Expectations as Gibbs Averages We now establish an explicit formula for writing expressions of the form hΨ, BΨiL2 (P0 ) as Gibbs averages with respect to N . Remember that Ψ is the ground
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
184
00111
V. Betz et al.
˜ For stating our results we need Wick exponentials, which for g ∈ K are state of H. given by S 0 3 ξ 7→ : exp(ξ(g)) : =
∞ X 1 √ : ξ(g)n : . n! n=0
(5.1)
The following formulas hold for all f, g ∈ K and all bounded, self-adjoint operators A in L2 (Rd ): 1 2 (5.2) : exp(ξ(g)) : = exp ξ(g) − kgkK , 2 h: exp(ξ(f )) :, : exp(ξ(g)) :iL2 (G) = exp(hf, giK ) , √ 1 ˜ Γ(A) : exp(ξ(g)) : = : exp(ξ(( wA √ gˆ)∨ )) : , w
(5.3) (5.4)
√ 1 ˜ h: exp(ξ(f )) :, dΓ(A) : exp(ξ(g)) :iL2 (G) = hf, ( wA √ gˆ)∨ iK exp(hf, giK ) . (5.5) w ˜ ˜ Here we put Γ(A) = θΓ(A)θ−1 and dΓ(A) = θdΓ(A)θ−1 . Moreover, for each T ∈ d [0, ∞], q ∈ C(R, R ) we define Z T + (k) = − %ˆ(k)eikqs e−ω(k)|s| ds , fˆT,q 0
− (k) = − fˆT,q
Z
0
%ˆ(k)eikqs e−ω(k)|s| ds ,
−T
± (k). Note that and write fq± (k) for f∞,q Z 0 Z hfq− , fq+ iK = −2 ds −∞
and kfq± k2K
∞
dt W (qt − qs , t − s) ,
(5.6)
0
Z
%ˆ(k)2 dk = C% . 2ω(k)3
≤
(5.7)
Theorem 5.1. Let B be a bounded operator on L2 (G). Then Z hΨ, (1 ⊗ B)ΨiL2 (P0 ) = h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, B : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) Z × exp 2
Z
0
∞
ds
−∞
dt W (qt − qs , t − s) dN (q) .
0
Proof. Put ΨT :=
1 ke−T H˜ 1k
˜
e−T H 1 .
(5.8)
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
Then by (3.8), we have in L2 -sense Z T Z ¯ = √1 ΨT (¯ exp − q , ξ) (ξs ∗ %)(qs )ds dPq¯0,ξ¯(q, ξ) , ZT 0
185
(5.9)
where Pq¯0,ξ¯ = Nq¯0 ⊗ Gξ¯ denotes the measure P = N 0 ⊗ G conditional on {q0 = q¯, ¯ G ¯ is a Gaussian measure with mean ξ0 = ξ}. ξ Z ¯ −|t|ω fˆ)∨ ) (t ∈ R, f ∈ S) ξt (f )dGξ¯(ξ) = ξ((e (5.10) Mξ,t ¯ (f ) ≡ and covariance
Z ξt (f )ξs (g)dGξ¯(ξ) − Mξ,t ¯ (f )Mξ,s ¯ (g)
Z ˆ¯ f gˆ −ω|t−s| (e − e−ω(|t|+|s|) )dk , (s, t ∈ R) . (5.11) = 2ω The proof of these formulas can be found in the Appendix. Now the integration with respect to Gξ¯ in (5.9) can be carried out with the result Z T Z T Z Z 1 |ˆ %(k)|2 1 + ¯ ¯ exp(ξ(fT,q )) exp q , ξ) = √ ds dt dk ΨT (¯ 2 0 2ω(k) ZT 0 (5.12) × cos(k(qs − qt ))(e−ω(k)|t−s| − e−ω(k)(t+s) ) dNq¯0 . By (5.2) we have,
Z T Z T Z |ˆ %(k)|2 1 ds dt dk 2 0 2ω(k) 0 × cos(k(qs − qt ))e−ω(k)(t+s) ,
¯ + )) : exp ¯ + )) = : exp(ξ(f exp(ξ(f T,q T,q
and hence ¯ = √1 ΨT (¯ q , ξ) ZT
Z ¯ + )) : exp : exp(ξ(f T,q
Z −
Z
T
ds 0
T
dt W (qs − qt , s − t) dNq¯0 .
0
(5.13) By the time reversibility of Nq¯0 , also Z 0 Z Z 0 ¯ − )) : exp − ¯ = √1 : exp(ξ(f q , ξ) ds dt W (q − q , s − t) dNq¯0 ΨT (¯ s t T,q ZT −T −T (5.14) holds. Now we write (5.14) for the left entry and (5.13) for the right entry of the scalar product hΨT , (1 ⊗ B)ΨT i and use the fact that for F[0,∞[ -measurable f, g ∈ L1 (N 0 ), Z Z Z Z q ) = f (q + )g(q − )dN 0 (q) f dNq¯0 g dNq¯0 dN0 (¯
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
186
00111
V. Betz et al.
(with qs+ = qs and qs− = q−s for s ≥ 0), to write hΨT , (1⊗B)ΨT i as an integral with R0 RT respect to N 0 . Then we add and subtract the term 2 −T ds 0 dt W (qs − qt , s − t) in the exponent and incorporate the term with the minus sign into the measure NT . The result reads Z − + )) :, B : exp(ξ(fT,q )) :iL2 (G) hΨT , (1 ⊗ B)ΨT iL2 (N0 ⊗G) = h: exp(ξ(fT,q Z × exp 2
Z
0
−T
ds
T
dt W (qt − qs , t − s) dNT (q) .
0
(5.15) This is the finite T version of (5.8). It remains to justify the passing to the limit T → ∞. On the left hand side of (5.15), this is immediate since ΨT → Ψ in L2 (N0 ⊗ G) and B is continuous. On the right hand side, we already know that NT → N in the topology of local weak convergence, and thus it only remains to show that the integrand converges uniformly in q ∈ C(R, Rd ). For the second factor of the integrand this is a consequence of (4.8). As for the first factor, we find that for k 6= 0, ± (k)| ≤ |fT,q
|ˆ %(k)| ω(k)
uniformly in T and q ,
and T →∞
± fT,q (k) −→ fq± (k)
uniformly in q .
+ )) : → : exp(ξ(fq+ )) : in L2 (G) Thus : exp(ξ(fq+ )) : is well defined, and : exp(ξ(fT,q and uniformly in q by dominated convergence. Since the same argument applies to − and B is continuous, the claim follows. fT,q
Most operators of physical interest are not bounded. Therefore we need to extend formula (5.8) to unbounded operators. Proposition 5.2. Let B be a self-adjoint operator in L2 (G) with Z kB : exp(ξ(fq± )) : k2L2 (G) dN (q) < ∞ .
(5.16)
Then Ψ ∈ D(1 ⊗ B), and (5.8) holds. Let E be the projection valued measure corresponding to B, and let BN = RProof. N λ dE(λ) for N ∈ N. Then BN is a bounded operator, hence (5.8) holds for BN . −N Using (4.8) and the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality, we have k(1 ⊗ BN )Ψk2L2 (N0 ⊗G) Z R0 R∞ 2 = h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, BN : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) e2 −∞ ds 0 dt W (qt −qs ,t−s) dN (q)
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
Z ≤ eC % Z ≤ eC%
187
kBN : exp(ξ(fq− )) : kL2 (G) kBN : exp(ξ(fq+ )) : kL2 (G) dN (q) kB : exp(ξ(fq− )) : kL2 (G) kB : exp(ξ(fq+ )) : kL2 (G) dN (q) ,
which is finite according to (5.16). This shows that Ψ ∈ D(1 ⊗ B) and (1⊗ BN )Ψ → (1 ⊗ B)Ψ as N → ∞. On the other hand, it follows from (5.16) that : exp(ξ(fq± )) : ∈ D(B) for N -almost all q . From this we conclude h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, BN : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) → h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, B : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) for N almost all q as N → ∞. Since by (5.3) we have h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, BN : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) ≤ k : exp(ξ(fq− )) : kL2 (G) kBN : exp(ξ(fq+ )) : kL2 (G) ≤ e2C% kB : exp(ξ(fq+ )) : kL2 (G) for all q, and the right hand side of the above is N -integrable, the dominated convergence theorem implies Z R0 R∞ h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, BN : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) e2 −∞ ds 0 dt W (qt −qs ,t−s) dN (q) Z →
h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, B : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) e2
R0
−∞
ds
R∞ 0
dt W (qt −qs ,t−s)
dN (q)
as N → ∞. This finishes the proof. We now present one minor extension and two important special cases of (5.8). Corollary 5.3. Let g ∈ L∞ (Rd ), and suppose B satisfies the assumptions of Proposition 5.2. Then Z hΨ, (g ⊗ B)ΨiL2 (P0 ) = h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, B : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) Z × g(q0 ) exp 2
Z
0
−∞
ds
∞
dt W (qt − qs , t − s) dN (q) .
0
Here g is again used to denote the operator of multiplication with g. Note that if BR is chosen to be the identity operator, then we arrive at hΨ, gΨiL2 (P0 ) = g(q0 )dN , a formula that also follows from Corollary 4.2. Corollary 5.4. For β > 0 and g ∈ K, put M (β) = hΨ, eβξ(g) ΨiL2 (P0 ) .
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
188
00111
V. Betz et al.
M is the moment generating function for the random variable ξ 7→ ξ0 (g) under P, and Z M (β) = eβξ0 (g) dP(q, ξ)
Z =
exp
β2 2
Z
|ˆ g |2 dk − β 2ω
Z
Z
∞
ds −∞
%ˆ(k)ˆ g (k)eikqs −ω(k)|s| e dN . (5.17) dk 2ω(k)
By (4.9), M (β) is finite for all β, and hence hΨ, ξ(g)n ΨiL2 (P0 ) =
dn M (β)|β=0 dβ n
for all n ∈ N .
(5.18)
Note that, although (5.17) can in principle be deduced from Proposition 5.2, it can be obtained more easily by using (4.10), i.e. by fixing q ∈ C(R, Rd ) and integrating the function ξ 7→ eξ0 (g) with respect to the corresponding Gaussian measure. The next statement deals with second quantisation and differential second quantisation of operators. Corollary 5.5. Let A be a bounded self-adjoint operator on L2 (Rd ), and write ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ = θdΓ(A)θ−1 . Then Ψ ∈ D(Γ(A)), Ψ ∈ D(dΓ(A)) Γ(A) = θΓ(A)θ−1 and dΓ(A) and ˜ hΨ, Γ(A)Ψi L2 (P0 ) ∨ R Z R∞ 0 √ 1 e2 −∞ ds 0 dt W (qs −qt ,s−t) dN (q) , = exp fq− , wA √ fˆq+ w K ∨ Z √ 1 ˆ+ − ˜ √ 2 0 f = f , wA dN (q) . (5.19) hΨ, dΓ(A)Ψi L (P ) q w q K Proof. First note that by (5.7) and boundedness of A, k(Afˆq± )∨ kK is uniformly bounded in q. On the other hand, ∨ 2
√ 1 ˆ+ ± 2
˜ √ f wA kΓ(A) : exp(ξ(fq )) : kL2 (G) = exp
w q K follows directly from (5.3) and (5.4). Furthermore, ˜ kdΓ(A) : exp(ξ(fq± )) : k2L2 (G) ∨ 2 ∨ 2
√ √ ± 2 1 ˆ± 1 ˆ± ±
√ √ f fq ekfq kK = wA wA , fq
+ w q w K K can be obtained from the definitions of differential second quantisation (2.6), Wick ˜ exponentials (5.1) and of dΓ(A) above. Thus (5.16) is fulfilled, and Proposition 5.2 ˜ ˜ now gives Ψ ∈ D(Γ(A)) and Ψ ∈ D(dΓ(A)). Now that this is established, formulas (5.19) follow directly from (5.8) and (5.3) to (5.5).
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
189
6. Bounds on Ground State Expectations We are now ready to apply the results of the previous section in order to investigate some qualitative properties of the ground state of H. Example 6.1 (Boson number distribution). Let Pn be the projection onto the nth Fock space component (or n-boson sector). Then P˜n = θPn θ−1 is the projection onto the closure of the subspace spanned by {: ξ(f )n :, f ∈ K} ⊂ L2 (G). By (5.1), we have 1 h: exp(ξ(fq− )) :, P˜n : exp(ξ(fq+ )) :iL2 (G) = hfq+ , fq− inK , n! and with (5.6) and Theorem 5.1 we find n Z 0 Z Z ∞ 1 ˜ −2 ds dt W (qs − qt , s − t) pn ≡ hΨ, 1 ⊗ Pn ΨiL2 (P0 ) = n! −∞ 0 Z 0 Z ∞ × exp 2 ds dt W (qs − qt , s − t) dN . −∞
0
˜ Obviously, pn is the probability of finding n bosons in the ground state of H. pn ≤
C%n C% e . n!
(6.1)
Denoting by N = dΓ(1) the number operator, the superexponential bound (6.1) implies hΨ, eαN ΨiL2 (P0 ) < ∞ for each α > 0 and is useful in the context of scattering theory [12]. Let us now assume in addition that W (q, t) < 0 for all q and all t. This is true e.g. for the massive Nelson model √ with mass parameter κ > 0 and ultraviolet cutoff parameter K 1, i.e. ω(k) = k 2 + κ2 , %ˆ(k) = 1{|k|≤K} . Then there exists D ≤ C% with C%n Dn −C% e . ≤ pn ≤ n! n!
(6.2)
The right hand side of (6.2) is again obvious, and the left hand side follows from n Z Z 0 Z ∞ 1 −C% pn ≥ e −2 ds dt W (qs − qt , s − t) dN n! −∞ 0 Z Z 0 n Z ∞ 1 ds dt W (qs − qt , s − t)dN . ≥ e−C% − 2 n! −∞ 0 D is then the expectation of the double integral above. In the next two examples we will look at the mean value and variance of the random variable ξ 7→ ξ0 (g) under P for g ∈ K, using the results of Corollary 5.4.
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
190
00111
V. Betz et al.
Example 6.2 (Average field strength). For n = 1, (5.18) yields Z Z Z ∞ %ˆ(k)ˆ g (k) −ω(k)|s| ikqs e e hΨ, ξ(g)ΨiL2 (P0 ) = − dk ds dN (q) 2ω(k) −∞ Z Z %ˆ(k)ˆ g (k)eikq = − dk dqψ02 (q)λ2 (q) , (6.3) ω(k)2 R where λ2 (q) = Ψ2 (ξ, q)dG(ξ) is the stationary density of N with respect to N0 , and ψ02 is the density of N0 with respect to Lebesgue measure. Writing χ = ψ02 λ2 for the position density of the particle, and taking g to be a delta function in momentum space and in position space, respectively, we find hΨ, ξ(k)ΨiL2 (P0 ) = −
%ˆ(k)χ(k) ˆ (2π)d/2 ω 2 (k)
(k ∈ Rd ) ,
and hΨ, ξ(q)ΨiL2 (P0 ) = (χ ∗ Vω ∗ %)(q)
(q ∈ Rd ) ,
(6.4)
respectively. Here Vω denotes the Fourier transform of −1/ω and is the Coulomb potential for massless bosons, i.e. for ω(k) = |k|. (6.4) is the classical field generated by a particle with position distribution χ(q)dq. Note that equality (6.3) follows also from the equations of motion and the stationarity of Ψ0 . 2
Example 6.3 (Field fluctuations). For n = 2, (5.18) becomes 2 Z Z ∞ Z Z %ˆ(k)ˆ g (k)eikqs −ω(k)|s| |ˆ g (k)|2 2 dk + e hΨ, ξ(g) ΨiL2 (P0 ) = ds dk dN . 2ω(k) 2ω(k) −∞ By using the previous result and the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality, we find that Z Z |ˆ g |2 hΨ, ξ(g)2 ΨiL2 (P0 ) − hΨ, ξ(g)Ψi2L2 (P0 ) ≥ dk = ξ(g)2 dG(ξ) . 2ω The latter term represents the fluctuations of the free field. We thus see that fluctuations increase by coupling the field to the particle. We now consider special cases of Corollary 5.5. Example 6.4 (Average number of bosons at given momentum). For realvalued g ∈ L∞ consider Z a∗k ak g(k)dk = dΓ(g) . ˜ By Corollary 5.5, we have Ψ ∈ D(dΓ(g)). With g chosen to be the indicator function d ˜ 2 0 of some set B ⊂ R , hΨ, dΓ(g)Ψi L (P ) is the expected number of bosons with momentum within B. By (5.19), Z 0 Z Z Z ∞ |ˆ %(k)|2 −ω(k)(t−s) ˜ 2 0 g(k) cos(k(qt − qs ))dN . ds dt e hΨ, dΓ(g)ΨiL (P ) = dk 2ω(k) −∞ 0 (6.5)
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
On the one hand, from cos(kx) ≤ 1 we get Z |ˆ %(k)|2 ˜ hΨ, dΓ(g)ΨiL2 (P0 ) ≤ g(k)dk . 2ω(k)3
191
(6.6)
(6.6) is proven in [2] using the pullthrough formula. On the other hand, from 1 − (k 2 x2 )/2 ≤ cos(kx) we get Z Z k2 (qt2 + qs2 − 2qt qs )dN cos(k(qt − qs ))dN ≥ 1 − 2 Z 2 q 2 ψ02 (q)λ2 (q)dq . ≥ 1−k The last inequality above follows from Z ¯ ¯ qs qt dN = hΨq, e−|t−s|H ΨqiL2 (P0 ) = ke−(|t−s|/2)H qΨk2L2 (P0 ) ≥ 0 . Writing C =
R
q 2 ψ02 (q)λ2 (q)dq, we have for g ≥ 0 that Z |ˆ %(k)|2 ˜ hΨ, dΓ(g)ΨiL2 (P0 ) ≥ (1 − Ck 2 )g(k)dk . 2ω(k)3
The above results can be compactly (and somewhat formally) written as |ˆ %(k)|2 |ˆ %(k)|2 (1 − Ck 2 ) ≤ hΨ, 1 ⊗ a∗k ak ΨiL2 (N0 ⊗G) ≤ . 3 2ω(k) 2ω(k)3
(6.7)
˜ − k)). The quantity in the middle Here, a∗k ak denotes the formal expression dΓ(δ(· of (6.7) is the expected number of bosons with momentum k. In particular, for the massless Nelson model, one can see from the lower bound how the infrared divergence occurs. In this model, ω(k) = |k|, d = 3, and %ˆ(k) = 1{κ<|k|
Z
Z
0
ds −∞ 0
Z
∞
dt 0
Z dk
%ˆ(k)ˆ %(k 0 ) dk 0 p √ 2 w(k) w(k 0 ) 0
× ei(kqs −k qt ) gˆ(k − k 0 )e−ω(k)|s|−ω(k )|t| .
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
192
00111
V. Betz et al.
Thus for g ∈ L1 , we find hΨ, A˜g ΨiL2 (P0 ) Z Z 1 1 |ˆ %(k)| |ˆ %(k 0 )| dk dk 0 g (k − k 0 )| ≤ C C kgkL1 , 3 3 |ˆ d 1 2 d/2 0 2(2π) (2π) 2 2 2ω(k) ω(k ) R %(k)|2 /ω(k)n dk for n = 1, 2. Taking g to be the indicator of some with Cn = |ˆ bounded set B ⊂ Rd , hΨ, A˜g ΨiL2 (P0 ) measures the expected number of bosons with position within B. From the above estimate we see that this number is bounded by a multiple of the volume of B. Moreover, it is interesting to note that this bound is insensitive to formally removing the infrared cutoff. On the other hand, the total number of bosons in the ground state is obtained by taking g = 1 in this or the previous example, and we see from (6.7) that this quantity diverges when the infrared cutoff is formally removed. ≤
Example 6.6 (Localization of the particle). We conclude this section by showing exponential decay of the Lebesgue-density of the stationary measure of N . We ˜ will need the following property of H: Proposition 6.7 (Diamagnetic inequality). For f, g ∈ L2 (P0 ) we have ˜
˜
hf, e−tH giL2 (P0 ) ≤ etVeff hkf kL2 (G) , e−tHp kgkL2 (G) iL2 (N0 ) , where Veff =
1 2
Z
|ˆ %(k)|2 dk < ∞ , ω 2 (k)
˜ p = (1/ψ0 )Hp ψ0 . and H A proof can be found in [11]. The second ingredient we need is a result due to Carmona [3]. For this result to hold, some mild additional restrictions on the single site potential V are needed. We say that V : Rd → R is in the Carmona class if there exists a breakup V = V1 − V2 , such that d/2+
V1 ∈ Lloc
for some > 0, and V1 is bounded below ,
V2 ∈ L for some p > max{1, d/2}, and V2 ≥ 0 . p
Then from the proofs of [3, Lemma 3.1, Propositions 3.1 and 3.2] one can extract the following Lemma 6.8. Let V = V1 − V2 be of the Carmona class, and use Wq¯ to denote the measure of Brownian motion on Rd starting in q¯. (a) Suppose there exist γ > 0, m > 0 such that V1 (q) ≥ γ|q|2m
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
193
outside a compact set. Put t(q) = max{|q|1−m , 1}. Then for each E > 0 there exist D > 0 and δ > 0 such that Z R t(q) ¯ q |m+1 ) . ∀ q¯ ∈ Rd : et(¯q )E e− 0 V (qs )ds dWq¯(q) ≤ D exp(−δ|¯ (b) Put α := lim inf |q|→∞ V (q), t(q) := β|q| with β > 0. Then for each E ∈ R with E < α, there exist D > 0, δ > 0 and β > 0 such that Z R t(q) ¯ d t(¯ q)E e− 0 V (qs )ds dWq¯(q) ≤ D exp(−δ|¯ q |) . ∀ q¯ ∈ R : e Recall that N denotes the stationary measure of N , ψ0 λ equals the square root of the Lebesgue density of N (cf. Example 6.2) and E0 is the ground state energy ˜ Our result now reads: of H. Theorem 6.9. For any V fulfilling the general conditions given in Sec. 2, we have ψ0 λ ∈ L∞ (Rd ). If, in addition, V = V1 −V2 is of the Carmona class, then there exists a version of ψ0 λ (denoted by q 7→ ψ0 (q)λ(q)) for which the following statements hold : (a) If V satisfies the assumptions of Proposition 6.8(a), then there exist D, δ > 0 with ∀ q ∈ Rd : ψ0 (q)λ(q) ≤ D exp(−δ|q|m+1 ) .
(6.8)
(b) Put α := lim inf |q|→∞ V1 (q). If α− (E0 + Veff ) > 0, then there exist D > 0, δ > 0 such that ∀ q ∈ Rd : ψ0 (q)λ(q) ≤ D exp(−δ|q|) .
(6.9)
˜ = E0 Ψ, for h ∈ L∞ (Rd ), h ≥ Proof. We first show that ψ0 λ ∈ L∞ (Rd ). Since HΨ 0, the diamagnetic inequality implies Z ˜ h(q)ψ02 (q)λ2 (q)dq = hhΨ, ΨiL2 (P0 ) = etE0 hhΨ, e−tH ΨiL2 (P0 ) ˜
≤ et(Veff +E0 ) hhλ, e−tHp λiL2 (N0 ) Z ˜ = et(Veff +E0 ) h(q)ψ0 (q)λ(q)(e−tHp λψ0 )(q)dq .
(6.10)
Since we required V to be in the Kato class, e−tHp takes L2 (dq) into L∞ (dq) [21]. Thus we can find C ∈ R with Z Z 2 2 (6.11) h(q)ψ0 (q)λ (q)dq ≤ C h(q)ψ(q)λ(q)dq , which implies ψ0 λ ∈ L∞ . Using this result in (6.10) and the Feynman–Kac formula to express the kernel of e−tHp , we get
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
194
00111
V. Betz et al.
Z
Z h(q)ψ02 (q)λ2 (q)dq ≤ et(Veff +E0 ) Z ×
e−
Rt 0
d¯ q h(¯ q )ψ0 (¯ q )λ(¯ q) V (qs )ds
ψ0 (qt )λ(qt )dWq¯(q)
≤ et(Veff +E0 ) kψ0 λk2L∞ Z Z Rt × d¯ q h(¯ q ) e− 0 V (qs )ds dWq¯(q) .
(6.12)
The version of ψ0 λ mentioned above can now be explicitly defined by Z 2 2 ψ0 (q)λ(q) = lim sup hq,n (x)ψ02 (x)λ2 (x)dx , n→∞
in L1 to a delta peak where hq,n is any fixed sequence of L1 -functions R converging Rt at q. We now use this sequence in (6.12). Since exp( 0 V (qs )ds)dWq¯ is continuous in q¯ and finite for all q¯, the right hand side of (6.12) converges and we have Z Rt q )λ2 (¯ q ) ≤ et(Veff +E0 ) kψ0 λk2L∞ e− 0 V (qs )ds dWq¯(q) . ψ02 (¯ This inequality is valid for each t > 0, and therefore in case V is in the Carmona class, we can use Proposition 6.8 with E replaced by Veff + E0 to conclude the proof. A version of the preceding result already appears in [2]. There it is shown that ψ0 (q)λ(q) exp(αq) ∈ L1 (dq) for some α > 0, while the present results (when applicable) imply ψ0 (q)λ(q) exp(αq) ∈ L∞ (dq) in case of a decaying external potential V and superexponential localization in case of growing potentials. Appendix A A.1. Conditional Gaussian measures In the first part of this Appendix we prove formulas (5.10) and (5.11). In fact, we give a simple and powerful method for explicitly calculating certain conditional Gaussian measures. This method must be known in some form, but we could not find it in the literature. Complete the space S(Rd+1 ) with respect to a Hilbert seminorm k.kK and denote its closure by K. Consider on S 0 (Rd+1 ) the Gaussian measure γ with mean 0 and covariance Z η(f )η(g)dγ(η) = hf, giK (f, g ∈ K) . (A.1) The σ-field for γ is generated by {η 7→ η(f ) : f ∈ K}. Consider now a closed subspace K0 ⊂ K and denote by F0 the σ-field generated by {η 7→ η(f ) : f ∈ K0 }. Moreover, write P0 for the projection onto K0 . By writing f ∈ K as f = P0 f + f ⊥ ,
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
195
we find Eγ (eiη(f ) |F0 )(¯ η ) = Eγ (eiη(P0 f ) eiη(f
⊥
⊥
|F0 )(¯ η ) = ei¯η(P0 f ) Eγ (eiη(f ) |F0 )(¯ η) ⊥ 1 η (P0 f ) − kf ⊥ k2K . (A.2) = ei¯η(P0 f ) Eγ (eiη(f ) ) = exp i¯ 2 )
The equalities above are in L2 (γ), and the third equality is due to the fact that independence with respect to γ is equivalent with orthogonality in L2 (γ). For η¯ ∈ S 0 (Rd+1 ), we denote by γη¯ the Gaussian measure with mean η¯(P0 f ) and covariance (f, g) 7→ hf ⊥ , g ⊥ iK = hf, giK − hP0 f, P0 giK . It follows from (A.2) that the map (S 0 (Rd ), L1 (γ)) → R ,
Z (¯ η , F ) 7→
F (η)γη¯ (η)
is a version of the regular conditional probability Eγ (.|F0 ). To specialize to our context, we take for K the closure of S 0 (Rd+1 ) with respect to the norm associated with the scalar product Z 1 g (k, κ) 2 dk dκ (k ∈ Rd , κ ∈ R) hf, giK = fˆ(k, κ)ˆ ω (k) + κ2 and derive from this the Gaussian measure γ according to (A.1). By performing the corresponding Fourier integration, it can be checked that a distribution of the form f ⊗δt (with f ∈ K, cf. (3.2), and δt denoting the delta-peak at t ∈ R) is an element of K, and that the S 0 (Rd )-valued stochastic process {ξt (f ) = η(f ⊗ δt ), f ∈ K, t ∈ R} coincides in law with the process G. Moreover, by taking K0 to be the closure of the set {f ⊗ δ0 : f ∈ K}, we find that (g ⊗ δt ) = e−tω g\ ⊗ δ0 P0\
for g ∈ K .
This can be used in the above general result to obtain (5.10) and (5.11). A.2. Proof of Theorem 4.3 Before we prove the theorem, by showing compatibility [7] we first make sure that the family of measures {NTq¯ : T > 0} (cf. (4.11)) has a chance to fulfill the DLR equations. Remember that ΛT = ([−T, T ] × R) ∪ (R × [−T, T ]) . Lemma A.1. The family {NTq¯ : T > 0} is compatible. Proof. We have to check that for T > S, measurable A ⊂ C(R, Rd ) and q¯ ∈ C(R, Rd ): Z q¯ • NT (NS (A)) ≡ NSq (A)dNTq¯(q) = NTq¯(A) .
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
196
00111
V. Betz et al.
Here and henceforth we write NTq¯(f ) instead of EN q¯ (f ) in order to avoid too many T subscript levels. By a monotone class argument, we may assume A to be of the form A = A1 ∩ A2 ∩ A3 with A1 ∈ F[−S,S], A2 ∈ F[−T,T ]\[−S,S] and A3 ∈ F[−T,T ]c . Writing TT for FR\[−T,T ] , it is clear from the definition of NT0,¯q that for S < T and f ∈ L1 (NT0,¯q ), NT0,¯q (f |TS ) = NS0,¯q (f ) for NT0,¯q -almost all q¯ ∈ C(R, Rd ) . Plugging
f (q) = NSq (A1 ) exp
(A.3)
W (qs − qt , s − t)ds dt 1A2 (q)
ZZ − ΛT
into this equality, and writing
ZZ
WΛ (q) := −
W (qs − qt , s − t)ds dt Λ
for Λ ⊂ R2 , we find NTq¯(NS• (A1 )1A2 ) = NT0,¯q (f ) = NT0,¯q (NT0,• (f |TS )) = NT0,¯q (NS• (A1 )1A2 eW(ΛT \ΛS ) NS0,• (eWΛS )) 1 1A2 eW(ΛT \ΛS ) NS0,• (eWΛS ) = NT0,¯q NS0,• (1A1 eWΛS ) 0,• W NS (e ΛS ) = NT0,¯q (NT0,• (1A1 eWΛS |TS )1A2 eW(ΛT \ΛS ) ) = NT0,¯q (eWΛS eW(ΛT \ΛS ) 1A1 1A2 ) = NTq¯(1A1 ∩A2 ) . Since furthermore NTq¯(A3 ) = 1A3 (¯ q ), the lemma is proved. Proof Theorem 4.3. Let S < T , put ΛS,T := ([−T, T ] × [−S, S]) ∪ ([−S, S] × [−T, T ]), and define ZZ W (qs − qt , s − t)ds dt , WΛS,T := − ΛS,T q¯ dNS,T (q) :=
1 q¯ ZS,T
exp(−WΛS,T (q))dNS0,¯q .
We claim that q¯ NT (·|TS )(¯ q ) = NS,T
for NT -almost all q¯ .
q ) = NS0,¯q (·) and proceed exactly as in the proof of To see this, note that N 0 (·|TS )(¯ Lemma A.1. As a consequence, if A ∈ FR for some R > 0, we have • NT (A) = NT (NT (A|TS )) = NT (NS,T (A)) .
(A.4)
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
00111
Ground State Properties of the Nelson Hamiltonian
197
As a last ingredient, we have for every q ∈ C(R, Rd ) and T > S Z S Z ∞ Z |ˆ %(k)|2 −ω(k)|t−s| e |WΛS,T (q) − WΛS (q) ≤ 4 ds dt dk 2ω(k) −S T Z |ˆ %(k)|2 T →∞ ≤ 8S e−ω(k)(T −S) 2 dk −→ 0 2ω (k) by dominated convergence and (2.4). Thus, sup q¯∈C(R,Rd )
T →∞
q¯ |NS,T (A) − NSq¯(A)| −→ 0 ,
and by taking T → ∞ on both sides of (A.4), we arrive at N (A) = N (NS• (A)), which is what we wanted to show. Acknowledgments The author, R. A. Minlos, thanks Zentrum Mathematik of Technische Universit¨ at M¨ unchen for warm hospitality and financial support. He also thanks the Russian Fundamental Research Foundation (grants 99-01-00284 and 00-01-00271), CRDF (grant NRM 1-2085) and DFG (grant 436 RUS 113/485/5) for financial support. The author, J. L˝ orinczi thanks Schwerpunktprogramm “Interagierende stochastische Systeme von hoher Komplexit¨ at” (grant SP 181/12). The author, F. Hiroshima thanks Technische Universit¨at M¨ unchen for kind hospitality. This work was partially supported by the Graduiertenkolleg “Mathematik in ihrer Wechselbeziehung zur Physik” of the LMU Munich and Grant-in-Aid 13740106 for Encouragement of Young Scientists from the Japanese Ministry of Education, Science, Sports and Culture. References [1] A. Arai, “Ground state of the massless Nelson model without infrared cutoff in a non-Fock representation”, Rev. Math. Phys. 13 (2001) 1075–1094. [2] V. Bach, J. Fr¨ ohlich and I. M. Sigal, “Quantum electrodynamics of confined nonrelativistic particles”, Adv. Math. 137 (1998) 299–395. [3] R. Carmona, “Pointwise bounds for Schr¨ odinger eigenstates”, Commun. Math. Phys. 62 (1978) 97–106. [4] R. P. Feynman and A. R. Hibbs, Quantum Mechanics and Path Integrals, McGraw Hill, 1965. [5] J. Fr¨ ohlich, “On the infrared problem in a model of scalar electrons and massless scalar bosons”, Ann. Inst. H. Poincar´ e 19 (1973) 1–103. [6] J. Fr¨ ohlich, “Existence of dressed one electron states in a class of persistent models”, Fortschr. Phys. 22 (1974) 159–198. [7] H.-O. Georgii, Gibbs Measures and Phase Transitions, Berlin, New York, de Gruyter, 1988. [8] C. G´erard, “On the existence of ground states for massless Pauli–Fierz Hamiltonians”, Ann. Henri Poincar´e 1 (2000) 443–459.
February 4, 2002 10:52 WSPC/148-RMP
198
00111
V. Betz et al.
[9] M. Griesemer, E. Lieb and M. Loss, “Ground states in non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics”, to appear in Inv. Math. [10] T. Hida, H.-H. Kuo, J. Potthoff and L. Streit, White Noise, Dordrecht, Boston London, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1993. [11] F. Hiroshima, “Diamagnetic inequalities for systems of nonrelativistic particles with a quantized field”, Rev. Math. Phys. 8 (1996) 185–203. [12] M. H¨ ubner and H. Spohn, “Radiative decay: nonperturbative approaches”, Rev. Math. Phys. 7 (1995) 363–387. [13] J. L˝ orinczi and R. A. Minlos, “Gibbs measures for Brownian paths under the effect of an external and a small pair potential”, J. Stat. Phys. 105 (2001) 607–649. [14] J. L˝ orinczi, R. A. Minlos and H. Spohn, “The infrared behaviour in Nelson’s model of a quantum particle coupled to a massless scalar field”, preprint. [15] J. L˝ orinczi, R. A. Minlos and H. Spohn, “Infrared regular representation of the three dimensional massless Nelson model”, preprint. [16] E. Nelson, “Schr¨ odinger particles interacting with a quantized scalar field”, p. 87 in Proceedings of a Conference on Analysis in Function Space, eds. W. T. Martin and I. Segal, MIT Press, Cambridge 1964. [17] E. Nelson, “Interaction of nonrelativistic particles with a quantized scalar field”, J. Math. Phys. 5 (1964) 1990–1997. [18] E. Nelson, “The free Markoff field”, J. Funct. Anal. 12 (1973) 211–227. [19] N. Obata, White Noise Calculus and Fock Space, Berlin, Heidelberg, Springer, 1994. [20] B. Simon, Functional Integration and Quantum Physics, New York, San Francisco, London, Academic Press, 1979. [21] B. Simon, “Schr¨ odinger semigroups”, Bull. Amer. Math.Sec. 7 (1982) 447–526. [22] H. Spohn, “Ground state of a quantum particle coupled to a scalar boson field”, Lett. Math. Phys. 44 (1998) 9–16.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 2 (2002) 199–240 c World Scientific Publishing Company
ON SPECTRAL AND SCATTERING THEORY FOR N -BODY ¨ SCHRODINGER OPERATORS IN A CONSTANT MAGNETIC FIELD
TADAYOSHI ADACHI Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science, Kobe University 1-1, Rokkodai-cho, Nada-ku, Kobe-shi, Hyogo 657-8501, Japan
[email protected]
Received 26 February 2001 We consider an N -body quantum system in a constant magnetic field which consists of just one charged and the other N − 1 neutral particles. We prove the existence of a conjugate operator for the Hamiltonian which governs the system, and show the asymptotic completeness of the system under short-range assumptions on the pair potentials.
1. Introduction The scattering theory for N -body quantum systems in a constant magnetic field has been studied by G´erard–Laba [8, 9, 10]. But they have assumed that all particles in the systems are charged, that is, there is no neutral particle in the systems under consideration, even if the systems consist of only two particles (see also [14, 15]). Under this assumption, if there is no neutral proper subsystem, one has only to observe the behavior of all subsystems parallel to the magnetic field. Skibsted [21, 22] studied the scattering theory for N -body quantum systems in combined constant electric and magnetic fields, but his result needs the asymptotic completeness for the systems in a constant magnetic field. Recently we studied the scattering theory for a two-body quantum system, which consists of one neutral and one charged particles, in a constant magnetic field (see [1]). Showing how to choose a conjugate operator for the Hamiltonian which governs the system was one of the ingredients in [1]. By virtue of this, we obtained the Mourre estimate and used it in order to obtain the so-called minimal velocity estimate which is one of useful propagation estimates. Throughout this paper, we consider an N -body quantum system which has N − 1 neutral particles and just one charged particle in a constant magnetic field. Our goal is to prove the asymptotic completeness of this system under short-range assumptions on the pair potentials. For achieving it, it is useful to obtain the Mourre estimate for the Hamiltonian which governs this system. The Mourre estimate is powerful also in studying spectral properties of the Hamiltonian. 199
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
200
00113
T. Adachi
Finding a conjugate operator for the Hamiltonian is one of the ingredients in this paper. We consider a system of N particles moving in a given constant magnetic field B = (0, 0, B) ∈ R3 , B > 0. For j = 1, . . . , N , let mj > 0, qj ∈ R and xj ∈ R3 be the mass, charge and position vector of the jth particle, respectively. Throughout this paper, we assume that the last particle is charged and the rest are neutral, that is, (1.1) qj = 0 if 1 ≤ j ≤ N − 1 , qN 6= 0 . P In particular, the total charge q = j qj of the system is non-zero in this case. The total Hamiltonian for the system is defined by N −1 X 1 1 ˜ = H Dx j 2 + (DxN − qN A(xN ))2 + V (1.2) 2m 2m j N j=1 acting on L2 (R3×N ), where the potential V is the sum of the pair potentials Vjk (xj − xk ), that is, X Vjk (xj − xk ) , V = 1≤j
Dxj = −i∇xj , j = 1, . . . , N , is the momentum operator of the jth particle, and A(r) is the vector potential. Using the Coulomb gauge, the vector potential A(r) is given by B (−r2 , r1 , 0) , r = (r1 , r2 , r3 ) . (1.3) 2 As is well-known, it is easy to remove the center of mass motion of the system ˜ (see e.g. [3]). In order to achieve it, parallel to the field from the Hamiltonian H we write the position xj of the jth particle for xj = (yj , zj ) with yj ∈ R2 and zj ∈ R. Moreover we identify the vector potential A(xj ) ∈ R3 with A(yj ) ≡ (B/2)(−yj,2 , yj,1 ) ∈ R2 because A(xj ) can be written as (A(yj ), 0). Thus we study the spectral and scattering theory for the following Hamiltonian : ! N −1 X 1 1 1 2 + H= Dy j (DyN − qN A(yN ))2 − ∆zamax + V (1.4) 2m 2m 2 j N j=1 A(r) =
acting on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ), where Z amax is defined by ( ) N X N amax = z = (z1 , . . . , zN ) ∈ R mj z j = 0 Z j=1
which is equipped with the metric hz, z˜i =
N X j=1
mj zj z˜j ,
|z|1 =
p hz, zi
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
201
for z = (z1 , . . . , zN ) ∈ RN and z˜ = (˜ z1 , . . . , z˜N ) ∈ RN , and ∆zamax is the Laplace– Beltrami operator on Z amax . Moreover, introducing the total pseudomomentum ktotal of the system perpendicular to the field B which is defined by ! N −1 X Dyj + (DyN + qN A(yN )) , (1.5) ktotal = j=1
one can remove the dependence on ktotal from the Hamiltonian H: It is well-known that ktotal commutes with H, and that since the total charge q = qN of this system is non-zero, the two components of the total pseudomomentum ktotal cannot commute with each other, but satisfy the Heisenberg commutation relation (see e.g. [3]). Now we introduce the unitary operator U = e−iycm ·qA(ycc ) eiqBycm,1 ycm,2 /2 eiDycm,1 Dycm ,2 /(qB) on L2 (R
2×N
(1.6)
× Z amax ) with ycm =
N 1 X mj y j , M j=1
1X qj yj , q j=1 N
ycc =
(1.7)
P where M = j mj is the total mass of the system. We note that ycc = yN holds in this case. Then we obtain U ∗ ktotal,1 U = Dycm,1 ,
U ∗ ktotal,2 U = qBycm,1 ,
(1.8)
and see that U ∗ HU is independent of (Dycm,1 , qBycm,1 ) (see [8, 9, 10, 21, 22 and 1]). Here the dot · means the usual Euclidean metric, and we wrote ktotal = (ktotal,1 , ktotal,2 ), ycm = (ycm,1 , ycm,2 ) and Dycm = (Dycm ,1 , Dycm ,2 ). Thus one can identify the Hamiltonian U ∗ HU acting on U ∗ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ) with an operator acting on H = L2 (Y amax × Rycm ,2 × Z amax ), where Y amax is defined by N ( ) X 2×N amax = y = (y1 , . . . , yN ) ∈ R mj y j = 0 Y j=1
which is equipped with the metric hy, y˜i =
N X
mj yj · y˜j ,
|y|1 =
p hy, yi
j=1
for y = (y1 , . . . , yN ) ∈ R2×N and y˜ = (˜ y1 , . . . , y˜N ) ∈ R2×N . We denote this reduced ˆ It is a part of our goal to study the spectral theory Hamiltonian acting on H by H. ˆ for H. Now we state the assumptions on the pair potentials Vjk . For r = (r1 , r2 , r3 ) ∈ R3 , we denote (r1 , r2 ) by r⊥ and write ∇r⊥ = ∇⊥ . For any interval I ⊂ R, we denote the characteristic function of I on R by 1I . 3 (V.1) Vjk = Vjk (r) ∈ L2 (R3 ) + L∞ (R ) (1 ≤ j < k ≤ N ) is a real-valued function.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
202
00113
T. Adachi
(V.2) If j and k satisfy that 1 ≤ j < k ≤ N − 1, r · ∇Vjk is −∆-bounded and satisfies
1[1,∞) |r| r · ∇Vjk (−∆ + 1)−1 = O(R−µ ) , R → ∞ ,
R for some µ > 0. Otherwise, that is, if l satisfies that 1 ≤ |∇⊥ VlN |2 and r · ∇VlN are all −∆-bounded, and satisfy
1[1,∞) |r| ∇⊥ VlN (−∆ + 1)−1 = O(R−µ ) ,
R
1[1,∞) |r| |∇⊥ VlN |2 (−∆ + 1)−1 = O(R−µ ) ,
R
1[1,∞) |r| r · ∇VlN (−∆ + 1)−1 = O(R−µ ) ,
R
l ≤ N − 1, ∇⊥ VlN ,
R → ∞, R → ∞, R → ∞,
for some µ > 0. (V.3) If j and k satisfy that 1 ≤ j < k ≤ N − 1, (r · ∇)2 Vjk is −∆-bounded. Otherwise, that is, if l satisfies that 1 ≤ l ≤ N − 1, (∇⊥ )2 VlN , (r · ∇)2 VlN , ∇⊥ (r · ∇VlN ) and r⊥ · ∇⊥ VlN are all −∆-bounded. (SR) Vjk satisfies that ∇Vjk is −∆-bounded and
1[1,∞) |r| Vjk (−∆ + 1)−1 = O(R−µS1 ) ,
R
1[1,∞) |r| ∇Vjk (−∆ + 1)−1 = O(R−1−µS2 )
R as R → ∞, with µS1 > 1 and µS2 > 0. ˆ are self-adjoint. Under these assumptions, the Hamiltonians H and H To formulate the main result in this paper precisely, we introduce some notations in many body scattering theory: A non-empty subset of the set {1, . . . , N } is called S a cluster. Let Cj , 1 ≤ j ≤ j0 , be clusters. If 1≤j≤j0 Cj = {1, . . . , N } and Cj ∩ Ck = ∅ for 1 ≤ j < k ≤ j0 , a = {C1 , . . . , Cj0 } is called a cluster decomposition. We denote by #(a) the number of clusters in a. Let A be the set of all cluster decompositions. Suppose a, b ∈ A. If b is a refinement of a, that is, if each cluster in b is a subset of a certain cluster in a, we say b ⊂ a, and its negation is denoted by b 6⊂ a. Any cluster decomposition a can be regarded as a refinement of itself. If, in particular, b is a strict refinement of a, that is, if b ⊂ a and b 6= a, we denote by b ( a. We identify the pair (j, k) with the (N − 1)-cluster decomposition ˇ . . . , {N }}. We denote by amax and amin the 1- and {{j, k}, {1}, . . . , {ˇj}, . . . , {k}, N -cluster decompositions, respectively. In this paper, we often use the following notation A(amax ) = A \ {amax } .
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
For a ∈ A, the intercluster potential Ia is defined by X Vjk (xj − xk ) , Ia =
203
(1.9)
(j,k)6⊂a
and the cluster Hamiltonian Ha is given by ! N −1 X 1 1 1 2 Dyj + (DyN − qj A(yN ))2 − ∆zamax + V a , Ha = 2m 2m 2 j N j=1 Va =
X
(1.10)
Vjk (xj − xk )
(j,k)⊂a
acting on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ). We also define the innercluster Hamiltonian H Cj on L2 (R2×#(Cj ) ×Z Cj ) for each cluster Cj = {cj (1), . . . , cj (#(Cj ))} in a, where #(Cj ) is the number of the elements in the cluster Cj : ! ! X 1 X 1 2 Cj 2 + Dy (Dyl2 − ql2 A(yl2 )) H = 2ml1 l1 2ml2 n c l1 ∈Cj
V Cj
l2 ∈Cj
1 − ∆zCj + V Cj , 2 X = Vl1 l2 (xl1 − xl2 ) .
(1.11)
{l1 ,l2 }⊂Cj l1
Here Cjn = Cj ∩ {1, . . . , N − 1}, Cjc = Cj ∩ {N }, the configuration space Z Cj is defined by #(Cj ) ( ) X #(Cj ) Cj mcj (l) zcj (l) = 0 , Z = (zcj (1) , . . . , zcj (#(Cj )) ) ∈ R l=1
which is equipped with the metric defined by X
#(Cj )
˜ = hζ, ζi
mcj (l) zcj (l) z˜cj (l) ,
|ζ|1 =
p hζ, ζi
l=1
zcj (1) , . . . , z˜cj (#(Cj )) ) ∈ R#(Cj ) , for ζ = (zcj (1) , . . . , zcj (#(Cj )) ) ∈ R#(Cj ) and ζ˜ = (˜ and ∆zCj is the Laplace–Beltrami operator on Z Cj . We also define two subspaces Z a and Za of Z amax by ( ) X a amax ml zl = 0 for each cluster Cj ∈ a , Za = Z amax Z a . Z = z∈Z l∈Cj
And we denote by ∆za and ∆za the Laplace–Beltrami operators on Z a and Za , respectively. As is well-known, one can identify Z a with Z C1 ⊕ · · · ⊕ Z C#(a) . What
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
204
00113
T. Adachi
we notice here is that the cluster Hamiltonian Ha is decomposed into the sum of all the innercluster Hamiltonians H Cj and −∆za /2: ! #(a) X 1 Cj Id ⊗ · · · ⊗ Id ⊗ H ⊗ Id ⊗ · · · ⊗ Id + Id ⊗ · · · ⊗ Id ⊗ − ∆za Ha = 2 j=1 (1.12) on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ) = L2 (R2×#(C1 ) × Z C1 ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ) ⊗ L2 (Za ). Let a = {C1 , . . . , C#(a) } ∈ A. Choose j1 such that 1 ≤ j1 ≤ #(a) and {N } ⊂ Cj1 . Of course, this j1 associated with a exists uniquely. If necessary, by renumbering the clusters in a, one can put j1 = #(a) without loss of generality. What we should emphasize here is that H C#(a) is just the #(C#(a) )-body Hamiltonian under consideration. We consider the sum of all the innercluster Hamiltonians except H C#(a) X
#(a)−1
K(a) =
Id ⊗ · · · ⊗ Id ⊗ H Cj ⊗ Id · · · ⊗ Id
(1.13)
j=1
on K(a) = L2 (R2×#(C1 ) × Z C1 ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ L2 (R2×#(C#(a)−1 ) × Z C#(a)−1 ). Here we note that if one removes the center of mass motion perpendicular to the field B of this (N − #(C#(a) ))-body system from K(a), the obtained Hamiltonian is an odinger operator without external electromagnetic fields (N − #(C#(a) ))-body Schr¨ in the center of mass frame. Now we equip R2×#(Cj ) , j = 1, . . . , #(a) − 1, with the metric X
#(Cj )
hη, η˜i =
mcj (l) ycj (l) · y˜cj (l) ,
|η|1 =
p hη, ηi
l=1
ycj (1) , . . . , y˜cj (#(Cj )) ) ∈ for η = (ycj (1) , . . . , ycj (#(Cj )) ) ∈ R2×#(Cj ) and η˜ = (˜ R2×#(Cj ) , and define two subspaces Y Cj and YCj of R2×#(Cj ) by #(Cj ) ( ) X 2×#(C ) j mcj (l) ycj (l) = 0 , Y Cj = (ycj (1) , . . . , ycj (#(Cj )) ) ∈ R l=1
YCj = R2×#(Cj ) Y Cj . And we put X Cj = Y Cj × Z Cj and X a,n = X C1 × · · · × X C#(a)−1 , and define two subspaces Y a,n and Ya,n of R2×(N −#(C#(a) )) by Y a,n = Y C1 × · · · × Y C#(a)−1 and Ya,n = R2×(N −#(C#(a) )) Y a,n which are equipped with the metric h , i. Then K(a) can be decomposed into 1 a (1.14) K(a) = K ⊗ Id + Id ⊗ − ∆ya,n 2 on K(a) = L2 (X a,n ) ⊗ L2 (Ya,n ), where ∆ya,n is the Laplace–Beltrami operator on Ya,n . As we mentioned above, this Hamiltonian K a is an (N − #(C#(a) ))-body
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
205
Schr¨ odinger operator without external electromagnetic fields in the center of mass frame. Thus we have Ha = K a ⊗ Id ⊗ Id ⊗ Id + Id ⊗ H C#(a) ⊗ Id ⊗ Id 1 1 + Id ⊗ Id ⊗ − ∆ya,n ⊗ Id + Id ⊗ Id ⊗ Id ⊗ − ∆za 2 2
(1.15)
on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ) = L2 (X a,n ) ⊗ L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ) ⊗ L2 (Ya,n ) ⊗ L2 (Za ). Denoting by P˜ a and Pˆ a the eigenprojections for K a on L2 (X a,n ) and for H C#(a) on L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ), respectively, we put P a = P˜ a ⊗ Pˆ a ⊗ Id ⊗ Id on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ) = L2 (X a,n ) ⊗ L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ) ⊗ L2 (Ya,n ) ⊗ L2 (Za ). Then the usual wave operators Wa± , a ∈ A(amax ), are defined by Wa± = s - lim eitH e−itHa P a . t→±∞
(1.16)
The main result of this paper is the following theorem. Theorem 1.1. Assume that (V.1), (V.2), (V.3) and (SR) are fulfilled. Then the usual wave operators Wa± , a ∈ A(amax ), exist and are asymptotically complete X ⊕ Ran Wa± . L2c (H) = a∈A(amax )
Here L2c (H) is the continuous spectral subspace of the Hamiltonian H. The problem of the asymptotic completeness for N -body quantum systems has been studied by many mathematicians and they have succeeded. For example, for N -body Schr¨ odinger operators without external electromagnetic fields, this problem was first solved by Sigal–Soffer [19] for a large class of short-range potentials, and some alternative proofs appeared (see e.g. Graf [11] and Yafaev [23]). On the other hand, for the long-range case, Derezi´ nski [5] solved this problem with arbitrary N √ −µL ) with some µL > 3 − 1 (see for the class of potentials decaying like O(|xj − xk | also e.g. [6]). As for the results for the systems in external electromagnetic fields, see e.g. the references in [6]. Throughout this paper, we assume that the number of charged particles L in the system under consideration is just one. In fact, we have not solved the problem in the case when L ≥ 2 yet. In the case when L ≥ 2, by virtue of the constant magnetic field, the physical situation in R3 seems quite different from the one in R2 : Imagine N -body quantum scattering pictures both in R3 and in R2 under the influence of a constant magnetic field. Suppose that the last L particles are charged. Put C n = {1, . . . , N − L} and C c = {N − L + 1, . . . , N }, and introduce the set of cluster decompositions B = {a = {C1 , . . . , C#(a) } ∈ A | C c ⊂ C#(a) }
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
206
00113
T. Adachi
with renumbering the clusters in a if necessary. For simplicity of the argument below, we suppose that the pair potentials are “short-range”. As in the case when L = 1, one can also introduce the Hamiltonian H, cluster Hamiltonians Ha and the wave operators Wa± . Then one expects that the statement of the asymptotic completeness says that X ⊕ Ran Wa± L2c (H) = a∈A(amax )
when the space dimension is three. As is well-known, it is equivalent to that the time evolution of any scattering state ψ ∈ L2c (H) is asymptotically represented as X e−itH ψ = e−itHa P a ψa± + o(1) as t → ±∞ (1.17) a∈A(amax )
ψa±
∈ L (R2×N × Z amax ). We note that each summand e−itHa P a ψa± with some describes the motion of the particles in which those in the clusters in a form bound states and the centers of mass of the clusters in a move freely. Since the motion of the particles parallel to the magnetic field B is not influenced by B, we need take a superposition of e−itHa P a ψa± whose index a ranges in the whole of A(amax ) in general, as in the case when H is a usual N -body Schr¨ odinger operators without external electromagnetic fields. On the other hand, when the space dimension is two, the statement of the asymptotic completeness may be X ⊕ Ran Wa± , L2c (H) = 2
a∈B(amax )
where B(amax ) = B \ {amax } ⊂ A(amax ). This says that the time evolution of any scattering state ψ ∈ L2c (H) is asymptotically represented by a superposition of e−itHa P a ψa± , a ∈ B(amax ), which particularly describes the particles in the only charged cluster C#(a) in a ∈ B(amax) form bound states. The reason why we should take this B(amax ) instead of A(amax ) is as follows: All charged particles are bound in the directions perpendicular to the magnetic field B by the influence of B. So one expects that the distance among all charged particles is bounded with respect to time t, and one can suppose that all charged particles belong to one cluster. Hence we need not consider cluster decompositions a ∈ A(amax ) which have at least two charged clusters. Moreover, neutral particles can move freely without being influenced by the magnetic field B even when the space dimension is two. Thus one should study the motion of particles in the directions perpendicular to B more carefully in the case when L ≥ 2. Now what we would like to emphasize here is that our case, that is, the case when L = 1 is the unique one in which B(amax ) = A(amax ) holds, because C c = {N } only when L = 1. In fact, our argument can also be applied to studying the problem in R2 when L = 1, because the motion of the only
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
207
charged particle in the directions perpendicular to B can be controlled by the total pseudomomentum ktotal which does commute with the Hamiltonian H. This fact is a key in order to prove the main result. The plan of this paper is as follows: In Sec. 2, we find a conjugate operator ˆ and prove the Mourre estimate. A conjugate operator for for the Hamiltonian H, ˆ H under consideration was not found before. Recently we found it for the twobody case in [1]. But, since by virtue of the merit of two-body systems, we used the relative coordinates and the center of mass coordinates in its representation, its definition was slightly complicated and unsuitable for finding it for general N even if L = 1. Its definition in this paper may be suggestive in considering general cases. As mentioned above, the Mourre estimate is powerful in studying spectral and scattering theory for the Hamiltonian, and so finding a conjugate operator for the Hamiltonian itself is of interest to us. In Sec. 3, we show some propagation estimates which are useful for proving the asymptotic completeness, which one can utilize even for studying long-range scattering for the system under consideration. One of useful propagation estimates is called the minimal velocity estimate, which can be obtained by virtue of the Mourre estimate in Sec. 2. It seems new to show the way how to analyze the motions of neutral and charged particles in the directions perpendicular to B simultaneously, although we can deal with the case when L = 1 only up to the present. In Sec. 4, we prove the main result Theorem 1.1 of this paper. We give the proofs in the case t → ∞ only. The case t → −∞ can be proved in the same way. 2. The Mourre Estimate ˆ and prove the In this section, we find a conjugate operator for the Hamiltonian H, Mourre estimate. ˆ by induction in the number First we define the set of thresholds Θ for H (or H) of neutral particles in the system. If N = 2, we put Θ = τ2 (see [1]). Here ! ) ( 1 |qN |B (2.1) n+ τN = n ∈ N ∪ {0} . mN 2 Next let N ≥ 3 and suppose that the sets of thresholds are defined for all k-body systems in which the number of charged particles is just one, with 2 ≤ k ≤ N − 1. Let a = {C1 , . . . , C#(a) } ∈ A(amax ) with {N } ⊂ C#(a) . As we emphasized above, H C#(a) is just the #(C#(a) )-body Hamiltonian under consideration. Then one can define the set of thresholds τa,c for H C#(a) by the assumption of induction. Here it seems convenient that in the case when C#(a) = {N } one puts τa,c = ∅. Put σa,c = σpp (H C#(a) ). Next we consider K(a) on K(a). As we noted above, (1.14) odinger operator without exterholds, and K a is an (N − #(C#(a) ))-body Schr¨ nal electromagnetic fields in the center of mass frame. Thus one can define the set of thresholds τa,n for K a as in the usual way. Put σa,n = σpp (K a ). And set τ˜a,n = τa,n ∪ σa,n and τ˜a,c = τa,c ∪ σa,c . Now we define the set of thresholds Θ for
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
208
00113
T. Adachi
ˆ by H (or H) [
Θ=
(˜ τa,n + τ˜a,c ) .
(2.2)
a∈A(amax )
Now we find the origin operator A of a conjugate operator Aˆ for the Hamiltonian ˆ In order to achieve it, we recall the argument in [1] for a two-body system. Begin H. with the following self-adjoint operator A1 on L2 (R2×2 × Z amax ) for H: A1 =
1 {(hz amax , Dzamax i + hDzamax , z amax i) + (y1 · Dy1 + Dy1 · y1 )} . 2
(2.3)
Putting H0 = Hamin , one can obtain the following commutation relation by a straightforward computation: 1 1 (2.4) i[H0 , A1 ] = −∆zamax + Dy1 2 = 2 H0 − (Dy2 − q2 A(y2 ))2 . m1 2m2 As is well-known, the spectrum of the last term consists of the Landau levels τ2 . The commutation relation (2.4) seems nice for studying the spectral theory for the ˆ However, since A1 does not commute with ktotal , U ∗ A1 U reduced Hamiltonian H. cannot be reduced on H. In order to overcome this difficulty, we introduce the self-adjoint operator Aˆ1 on H, which is obtained by removing the dependence on the total pseudomomentum (Dycm,1 , qBycm,1 ) from the operator U ∗ A1 U . This Aˆ1 ˆ In [1], using the relative is a conjugate operator for the reduced Hamiltonian H. coordinates and the center of mass coordinates, we obtained this Aˆ1 , but its representation was slightly complicated and unsuitable for generalizations to N -body systems. Now we review the argument in [1]: We see that the self-adjoint operator U (Aˆ1 ⊗ Id)U ∗ on L2 (R2×2 × Z amax ) = U (H ⊗ L2 (Rycm ,1 )) can be written as 1 U (Aˆ1 ⊗ Id)U ∗ = {(hz amax , Dzamax i + hDzamax , z amax i) + (w1 · Dy1 + Dy1 · w1 )} 2 (2.5) with w1 = y1 + κ0 ,
κ0 =
2 A(ktotal ) , qB 2
(2.6)
where Id is the identity operator on L2 (Rycm,1 ). In this case, one knows that q = q2 , of course. Now we note that ycc + κ0 = y2 + κ0 =
2 A(Dy1 + (Dy2 − q2 A(y2 ))) qB 2
(2.7)
is H-bounded. Since ycc + κ0 commutes with the total pseudomomentum ktotal , ˆ where we regarded U ∗ (ycc + κ0 )U as the reduced one U ∗ (ycc + κ0 )U is H-bounded, acting on H. We notice that one can write i[V12 , Aˆ1 ] = −(x1 − x2 ) · ∇V12 (x1 − x2 ) − (U ∗ (y2 + κ0 )U ) · ∇⊥ V12 (x1 − x2 )
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
209
on H, noting that V12 commutes with ktotal . Under the assumptions (V.1) and (V.2), ˆ H ˆ 0 + 1)−1 is bounded on H, and that for any ε > 0 ˆ 0 + 1)−1 i[V12 , A]( we see that (H ∞ and real-valued f ∈ C0 (R) there exists a compact operator K on H such that ˆ ˆ ˆ 2 ˆ f (H)i[V 12 , A1 ]f (H) ≥ −εf (H) + K ˆ which was mentioned holds. Here we used the fact that U ∗ (ycc +κ0 )U is H-bounded, above. Since both Dy1 and ktotal commute with H0 , it is clear that 1 ∗ 2 ˆ ˆ ˆ (2.8) (Dy2 − q2 A(y2 )) U i[H0 , A1 ] = 2 H0 − U 2m2 ˆ 0 and U ∗ {(1/2m1)(Dy2 − q2 A(y2 ))2 }U are the holds by virtue of (2.4), where H reduced operators acting on H of H0 and (1/2m1 )(Dy2 − q2 A(y2 ))2 , respectively. By virtue of these two estimates, we obtained the desired Mourre estimate in [1] (see also Theorem 2.1 in this section). Now we return to the present problem. We define the origin operator A of a ˆ conjugate operator Aˆ for the reduced Hamiltonian H: ( ) N −1 X 1 amax amax (hz , Dzamax i + hDzamax , z i) + (wj · Dyj + Dyj · wj ) (2.9) A= 2 j=1 with wj = yj + κ0 ,
κ0 =
2 A(ktotal ) , qB 2
j = 1, . . . , N − 1 .
(2.10)
We see that A commutes with the total pseudomomentum ktotal , by taking account of the fact that Dyj and wj , j = 1, . . . , N − 1, commute with ktotal . Here we note that q = qN and ycc = yN in this case, and that ! ! N −1 X 2 A Dyj + (DyN − qN A(yN )) (2.11) ycc + κ0 = qB 2 j=1 ˆ 0 -bounded, since ycc + κ0 is H0 -bounded. We also notice that U ∗ (ycc + κ0 )U is H commutes with ktotal and is H0 -bounded as we mentioned just now, where we regarded U ∗ (ycc +κ0 )U as the reduced one acting on H. Since Dyj , j = 1, . . . , N −1, and ktotal all commute with H0 , it is clear that N −1 X 1 1 2 2 (2.12) Dy = 2 H0 − (DyN − qN A(yN )) i[H0 , A] = −∆zamax + mj j 2mN j=1 ˆ as holds. And we define a conjugate operator Aˆ for the reduced Hamiltonian H the reduced operator on H of A. The Nelson’s commutator theorem guarantees the self-adjointness of A and Aˆ (see e.g. [18]). Moreover, by virtue of the fact that ˆ 0 -bounded, one can check that (H ˆ 0 + 1)−1 i[V, A]( ˆ H ˆ 0 + 1)−1 U ∗ (ycc + κ0 )U is H is bounded on H in the same way as in the two-body case which we mentioned above, under the assumptions (V.1) and (V.2). We have only to keep in mind that wj1 − wj2 = yj1 − yj2 with 1 ≤ j1 , j2 ≤ N − 1.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
210
00113
T. Adachi
Then we have the following main result of this section by virtue of the abstract Mourre theory (see e.g. [16] and [4]) and the HVZ theorem for the reduced Hamilˆ (it is well-known that the HVZ theorem for H cannot hold, since H has tonian H the so-called Landau degeneracy which was proved in [3]): Theorem 2.1. Suppose that the potential V satisfies the conditions (V.1) and (V.2). Put d(λ) = dist(λ, Θ ∩ (−∞, λ]) for λ ≥ inf Θ, where Θ is as in (2.2). Then for any λ ≥ inf Θ and any ε > 0, there exists a δ > 0 such that for any real-valued f ∈ C0∞ (R) supported in the open interval (λ − δ, λ + δ), there exists a compact operator K on H such that ˆ H, ˆ A]f ˆ (H) ˆ ≥ 2(d(λ) − ε)f (H) ˆ 2+K f (H)i[
(2.13)
ˆ can accumulate only at Θ, and Θ ∪ σpp (H) ˆ is a holds. Moreover, eigenvalues of H closed countable set. Proof. We follow the argument of Froese–Herbst [7]. We introduce a partition of unity {ja }a∈A(amax ) of the configuration space amax = Y amax × Z amax : Let ja be a real-valued smooth function on X amax which X are homogeneous of degree 0 outside the unit ball {xamax ∈ X amax |xamax | ≤ 1} amax | holds outside with the properties athat on the support of ja |xj − xk | ≥ C(j,k)a|x amax amax |x max | ≤ 1} for any pair (j, k) 6⊂ a, where x max = (y amax , z amax ), ∈X {x P P and that a∈A(amax ) ja2 ≡ 1. Inserting 1 ≡ a∈A(amax ) ja2 , we have X ˆ H, ˆ A]f ˆ (H) ˆ ≥ ˆ a i[H, ˆ A]j ˆ a f (H) ˆ + K1 f (H)i[ f (H)j (2.14) a∈A(amax )
with some compact operator K1 on H. Here we used the fact that for any function ˆ + i)−1 is compact g(xamax ) such that |g(xamax )| → 0 as |xamax | → ∞, g(xamax )(H on H, which was proved by Avron–Herbst–Simon [3] (see also [8, 9, 10] and [15]). ˆ a )}(H ˆ 0 + 1) is compact on H, which follows ˆ a − ja f (H Next we note that {f (H)j ˆ a − ζ)−1 }(H ˆ 0 + 1), ζ ∈ C \ R is compact on ˆ − ζ)−1 ja − ja (H from the fact that {(H H, which can be shown by the proof in [3] and a standard argument (see e.g. [7]). ˆ a , A]( ˆ H ˆ 0 + 1)−1 is bounded on H, we obtain ˆ 0 + 1)−1 i[H And also noticing that (H X ˆ a )i[H ˆ a , A]f ˆ (H ˆ a )ja − εf (H) ˆ 2 + K2 (2.15) ˆ H, ˆ A]f ˆ (H) ˆ ≥ ja f (H f (H)i[ a∈A(amax )
with some compact operator K2 on H, by virtue of (V.2). Now we claim that for each a ∈ A(amax ), 1 ˆ a )2 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ f (Ha )i[Ha , A]f (Ha ) ≥ 2 d(λ) − ε f (H 2
(2.16)
holds for sufficiently small δ > 0, by virtue of the results for many body Schr¨ odinger operators without external electromagnetic fields (see e.g. [4, 6, 7 and 17]) and in [1]:
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
211
Let a = {C1 , . . . , C#(a) } ∈ A(amax ) with {N } ⊂ C#(a) . By a simple computation, we have ! ! #(a) X X 1 2 Cj − ∆zCj + i[V , A] − ∆za . Dy (2.17) i[Ha , A] = ml l n j=1 l∈Cj
We notice that for 1 ≤ j < k ≤ N − 1, i[Vjk , A] = −(xj − xk ) · (∇Vjk )(xj − xk ) holds, and that for 1 ≤ j ≤ N − 1, i[VjN , A] = −(xj − xN ) · (∇VjN )(xj − xN ) 1 − {(ycc + κ0 ) · (∇⊥ VjN )(xj − xN ) + (∇⊥ Vj N )(xj − xN ) · (ycc + κ0 )} 2 holds. Since Ha and A commute with the total pseudomomentum ktotal , ˆ a , A] ˆ holds. Here we regarded U ∗ i[Ha , A]U as the reduced one U ∗ i[Ha , A]U = i[H ˆ a -boundedness of U ∗ (ycc + κ0 )U , we obtain acting on H. Taking account of the H ! ! #(a) X ∗ ˆ a) ˆ a , A]f ˆ (H ˆ a ) ≥ f (H ˆ a )U ˆ a )i[H Bj − ∆za U f (H (2.18) f (H j=1
with for 1 ≤ j ≤ #(a) − 1, ! X 1 2 − ∆zCj − D Bj = ml y l l∈Cj
X
(xl1 − xl2 ) · (∇Vl1 l2 )(xl1 − xl2 ) ,
{l1 ,l2 }⊂Cj l1
(2.19) and X
B#(a) =
n l∈C#(a)
1 2 D ml y l
− ∆zC#(a) −
!
X
(xl1 − xl2 ) · (∇Vl1 l2 )(xl1 − xl2 )
{l1 ,l2 }⊂C#(a) l1
−
X 1 ε − Cε |(∇⊥ VlN )(xl − xN )|2 , 32 n
(2.20)
l∈C#(a)
where Cε > 0 depends on ε > 0 and λ only as long as δ > 0 runs the interval (0, P#(a) 1]. Here we regard U ∗ (( j=1 Bj ) − ∆za )U as the reduced one acting on H, and notice that Cjn = Cj if 1 ≤ j ≤ #(a) − 1. First we note that X
#(a)−1
j=1
Bj = i[K a , AK a ] − ∆ya,n
(2.21)
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
212
00113
T. Adachi
holds, where AK a is the generator of dilations on L2 (X a,n ), which is one of the conjugate operators for K a . And we also notice that each Bj acts on L2 (R2×#(Cj ) × Z Cj ), and that ∆za , K a and AK a are invariant under the transformation U , that is, U ∗ ∆za U = ∆za , U ∗ K a U = K a and U ∗ AK a U = AK a hold. Though we used both new and old coordinates at the same time here, we think that this does not confuse the reader. And we use the fact that if C#(a) = {N }, we have B#(a) = −ε/32 in the argument below. Taking account of the form of B#(a) , we prove both the statement of the theorem and the following statement by induction with respect to the number N −1 of neutral particles in the systems: For sufficiently small δ > 0, 1 ∗ ˜ ˆ 2 ˆ ˆ (2.22) f (H)U B0 U f (H) ≥ 2 d(λ) − ε f (H) 8 holds, where ( ˜ = d(s)
ˆ dist(s, (−∞, s] ∩ (Θ ∪ σpp (H)))
ˆ if s ≥ inf(Θ ∪ σpp (H))
s+C
ˆ if s < inf(Θ ∪ σpp (H))
ˆ and for some large constant C > 0 such that −C < inf(Θ ∪ σpp (H)), ! N −1 X X 1 B0 = Dyj 2 − ∆zamax − (xl1 − xl2 ) · (∇Vl1 l2 )(xl1 − xl2 ) mj j=1 1≤l1
−
N −1 X 1 ε − C |(∇⊥ VjN )(xj − xN )|2 32 j=1
(2.23)
for some Cε > 0. Here we took account of the fact that B0 commutes with the total pseudomomentum ktotal and regarded U ∗ B0 U as the reduced one acting on H. The theorem for N = 2 was proved in [1]. Then one can also prove the above ˆ 0 + 1) is ˆ − f (H ˆ 0 )}(H estimate (2.22) for N = 2 as follows: When N = 2, {f (H) compact on H by (V.1). By taking account of B0 = i[H0 , A] − (x1 − x2 ) · (∇V12 )(x1 − x2 ) −
1 ε − Cε |(∇⊥ V12 )(x1 − x2 )|2 32
and following the same way as in [1], one can obtain ˆ 2 + K3 ˆ ≥ 2 d(λ) − 1 ε f (H) ˆ ∗ B0 U f (H) f (H)U 16
(2.24)
with some compact operator K3 on H, for sufficiently small δ > 0. Then, by virtue of the theorem for N = 2, we have ˆ 2 ˆ ≥ 2 d˜ λ + 1 ε − 2 × 1 ε − 1 ε f (H) ˆ ∗ B0 U f (H) (2.25) f (H)U 64 64 16
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
213
for sufficiently small δ > 0, by following the idea of Froese–Herbst [7] (see also [4] ˜ + ε/64) ≥ d(λ) ˜ − ε/64, we obtain the estimate (2.22) for N = 2. and [6]). Since d(λ Now let N1 ≥ 3 and assume that the theorem and the above estimate (2.22) holds for any N such that 2 ≤ N ≤ N1 − 1. Then we prove the theorem and the estimate (2.22) for N = N1 . Since (2.21) holds and (2.22) holds for any N such that 2 ≤ N ≤ N1 − 1, by following the argument in [4], one can obtain the estimate (2.16). We sketch the proof of this: Ha is decomposed into 1 Ha = K a ⊗ Id ⊗ Id + Id ⊗ T a ⊗ Id + Id ⊗ Id ⊗ − ∆za 2 on L2 (R2×N1 × Z amax ) = L2 (X a,n ) ⊗ T a ⊗ L2 (Za ), where 1 a T = − ∆ya,n ⊗ Id + Id ⊗ H C#(a) = T1a + T2a 2 acting on T a = L2 (Ya,n ) ⊗ L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ). Here we recall that K a and −∆za /2 are invariant under the transformation U . Introducing the reduced operator Tˆja , j = 1, 2, on H of U ∗ (Id ⊗ Tja ⊗ Id)U and putting Tˆa = Tˆ1a + Tˆ2a , we use ˆ a = K a + Tˆ a + (−∆za /2). In a direct integral a direct integral representation of H decomposition Z ∞Z ⊕ H(t1 , t2 )dµ(t1 )dt2 , H= 0
σ(Tˆ a )
ˆ a is represented by K a + t1 + t2 on each fiber H(t1 , t2 ). Since K a , Tˆa and −∆za /2 H are all bounded from below, f (K a + t1 + t2 ) is nonzero in some compact subset odinger M ⊂ σ(Tˆ a ) × [0, ∞) only. Then by using the results for many body Schr¨ operators without external electromagnetic fields, in particular the result of [7], we see that for sufficiently small δ > 0 f (K a + t1 + t2 )i[K a , AK a ]f (K a + t1 + t2 ) 1 1 ≥ 2 d1 λ + ε − (t1 + t2 ) − 3 × ε f (K a + t1 + t2 )2 64 64 1 3 ≥ 2 d1 (λ − (t1 + t2 )) − ε − ε f (K a + t1 + t2 )2 64 64 holds uniformly in (t1 , t2 ) ∈ M. Here ( dist(s, (−∞, s] ∩ τ˜a,n ) d1 (s) = s+C
(2.26)
if s ≥ inf τ˜a,n if s < inf τ˜a,n
for some large constant C > 0 such that −C < inf τ˜a,n , and we used the fact that d1 (s + ε/64) ≥ d1 (s) − ε/64. Thus we obtain 1 ˆ a )2 ˆ a ) ≥ 2 d1 λ − Tˆ a − 1 ∆za ˆ a )i[K a , AK a ]f (H − ε f (H f (H 2 16
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
214
00113
T. Adachi
1 a ˆ a )2 = 2 d1 (K + (λ − Ha )) − ε f (H 16 1 1 a ˆ a )2 , ≥ 2 d1 (K ) − ε − ε f (H 16 16
(2.27)
where we took δ > 0 as δ < ε/16 and used the fact that d1 (s1 + s2 ) ≥ d1 (s1 ) − |s2 |. Let a ∈ A(amax ) such that {N1 } ( C#(a) . By virtue of (2.22) and the assumption of induction, one can obtain the following estimate similarly : ˆ a )2 , ˆ a ) ≥ 2 d2 (Tˆ a ) − 1 ε f (H ˆ a )U ∗ B#(a) U f (H (2.28) f (H 2 8 where
( d2 (s) =
dist(s, (−∞, s] ∩ τ˜a,c )
if s ≥ inf τ˜a,c
s+C
if s < inf τ˜a,c
for some large constant C > 0 such that −C < inf τ˜a,c . Summing up these two estimates (2.27) and (2.28), and using (2.21), we have 1 1 a a a ˆ a )2 . (2.29) ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ f (Ha )i[Ha , A]f (Ha ) ≥ 2 d1 (K ) + d2 (T2 ) + T1 − ∆za − ε f (H 2 4 Now we show that for λ1 ∈ σ(K a ), λ2 ∈ σ(Tˆ2a ), t1 ∈ σ(Tˆ1a ) = [0, ∞) and t2 ∈ σ(−∆za /2) = [0, ∞), we have d1 (λ1 ) + d2 (λ2 ) + t1 + t2 ≥ d(λ1 + λ2 + t1 + t2 ) .
(2.30)
We note that d1 (λ1 ) = λ1 − θ1 for some θ1 ∈ τ˜a,n ∩ (−∞, λ1 ], and d(λ2 ) = λ2 − θ2 for some θ2 ∈ τ˜a,c ∩ (−∞, λ2 ]. Then the left-hand side is equal to λ1 + λ2 + t1 + ˆ θ 1 + θ2 ∈ t2 − (θ1 + θ2 ). However, by the definition of the set of thresholds of H, Θ ∩ (−∞, λ1 + λ2 + t1 + t2 ] since t1 , t2 ≥ 0. This implies the inequality (2.30) by the definition of d(s). Combining these inequalities (2.29) and (2.30), we have 1 ˆ a )2 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ f (Ha )i[Ha , A]f (Ha ) ≥ 2 d(Ha ) − ε f (H 4 1 ˆ a )2 ˆ = 2 d(λ + (Ha − λ)) − ε f (H 4 1 1 ˆ a )2 . ≥ 2 d(λ) − ε − ε f (H (2.31) 4 16 Therefore we get the estimate (2.16) for a ∈ A(amax ) such that {N1 } ( C#(a) . Let a ∈ A(amax ) such that C#(a) = {N1 }. We first notice that H C#(a) =
1 (DyN1 − qN1 A(yN1 ))2 , 2mN1
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
215
whose spectrum is the set of Landau levels τN1 . Then, by following the same way as above (see also [1]), one can get ˆ a ) = f (H ˆ a )(Tˆa − Tˆa )f (H ˆ a) ˆ a )Tˆ a f (H f (H 1 2 1 a ˆ a )2 ˆ ≥ d3 (T ) − ε f (H 8
(2.32)
for sufficiently small δ > 0 (such that δ < ε/4). Here ( dist(s, (−∞, s] ∩ τN1 ) if s ≥ inf τN1 d3 (s) = s if s < inf τN1 . Summing up the estimates (2.27) and (2.32), we have 1 1 a a ˆ ˆ a )2 ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ f (Ha )i[Ha , A]f (Ha ) ≥ 2 d1 (K ) + d3 (T ) − ∆za − ε f (H 2 4 1 ˆ a )2 ˆ ≥ 2 d(Ha ) − ε f (H 4 1 ˆ a )2 ˆ = 2 d(λ + (Ha − λ)) − ε f (H 4 1 1 ˆ a )2 ≥ 2 d(λ) − ε − ε f (H (2.33) 4 4 in the way quite similar to the one above. Therefore we get the estimate (2.16) for a ∈ A(amax ) such that C#(a) = {N1 }, too. ˆ a − By combining (2.15) with (2.16), and using the fact that {f (H)j ˆ a )}(H ˆ 0 + 1) is compact on H again, we have the Mourre estimate (2.13). ja f (H The other statement in the theorem follows from the Mourre estimate (2.13) and ˆ which the abstract Mourre theory, by taking account of the HVZ theorem for H says that ˆ = inf σess (H)
inf
a∈A(amax )
ˆ a ) = inf Θ . σ(H
(2.34)
After getting the statement of the theorem for N = N1 , one can also prove the estimate (2.22) for N = N1 in the way quite similar to the one in the proof of the Mourre estimate (2.13). Therefore the theorem is proved. Remark 2.2. By regarding the conjugate operator Aˆ as Aˆ = 0 when N − 1 = 0, maybe one can start from N = 1 in the induction argument and the proof may become simpler. However, the situation of systems which have some neutral particles seems different from the one of systems that have no neutral particle. Hence we started from N − 1 = 1 in order to present the difference in the above proof. As one has already seen, the above argument in the proof is valid also for the case when the space dimension is two.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
216
00113
T. Adachi
In order to study the scattering theory for the Hamiltonian H, the following ˆ is the reduced operator corollary seems useful, which follows from the fact that H on H of H and a standard argument immediately (cf. [1]): Corollary 2.3. Suppose that the potential V satisfies the conditions (V.1) and (V.2). Then for any λ ∈ R \ (Θ ∪ σpp (H)), there exist δ > 0 and c > 0 such that for any real-valued f ∈ C0∞ (R) supported in the open interval (λ − δ, λ + δ), f (H)i[H, A]f (H) ≥ cf (H)2
(2.35)
holds. 3. Propagation Estimates In this section, we prove some propagation estimates which are useful for showing the asymptotic completeness for the system under consideration. Throughout this section, we assume that the potential V satisfies the following condition (LR) as well as (V.1), (V.2) and (V.3). (LR) Vjk is decomposed as Vjk = Vjk,S +Vjk,L , where a real-valued Vjk,L ∈ C ∞ (R3 ) such that |∂rα Vjk,L (r)| ≤ Cα hri−|α|−µL with 0 < µL ≤ 1, and a real-valued Vjk,S satisfies that ∇Vjk,S is −∆-bounded and
1[1,∞) |r| Vjk,S (−∆ + 1)−1 = O(R−µS1 ) ,
R
1[1,∞) |r| ∇Vjk,S (−∆ + 1)−1 = O(R−1−µS2 )
R as R → ∞, with µS1 > 1 and µS2 > 0. One can use this condition (LR) in the study of long-range scattering for N body quantum systems in a constant magnetic field under the condition that the number of charged particles in the systems is only one. We note that by putting VL ≡ 0, (LR) implies (SR). Inspired by [1], we first introduce the configuration space X = R2×(N −1) ×Z amax which is equipped with the metric ! N −1 X p ˜ = mj yj · y˜j + hz amax , z˜amax i , |Ξ|1 = hΞ, Ξi hΞ, Ξi j=1
˜ = (˜ for Ξ = (y1 , . . . , yN −1 , z amax ) ∈ X and Ξ y1 , . . . , y˜N −1 , z˜amax ) ∈ X . We denote the velocity operator associated with Ξ by pΞ = −i∇Ξ . Now, for a = {C1 , . . . , C#(a) } ∈ A with {N } ⊂ C#(a) , we introduce two subspaces X a and Xa of X as follows: ( ) X 2×(N −1) a mk yk = 0 for any j = 1, . . . , #(a) − 1 X = (y1 , . . . , yN −1 ) ∈ R k∈Cj
× Za ,
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
217
Xa = {(y1 , . . . , yN −1 ) ∈ R2×(N −1) | yl1 = yl2 if l1 , l2 ∈ Cj , for any j = 1, . . . , #(a) − 1 ; yk = 0 if k ∈ C#(a) } × Za . We see that these two subspaces are mutually orthogonal, and that X a ⊕Xa = X . We denote by π a and πa the orthogonal projections of X onto X a and Xa , respectively. And we write Ξa = π a Ξ and Ξa = πa Ξ. Denoting the velocity operators associated with Ξa and Ξa by pΞa = −i∇Ξa and pΞa = −i∇Ξa , respectively, we see that pΞa = π a pΞ and pΞa = πa pΞ . For a, b ∈ A, we denote the smallest cluster decomposition c ∈ A with a ⊂ c and b ⊂ c by a∪b, whose existence and uniqueness are well-known. Then we note that for a, b ∈ A Xa∪b = Xa ∩ Xb holds, which can be seen easily. For δ > 0, we put Xa (δ) = {Ξ ∈ X ||Ξa |1 < δ} .
(3.1)
Now we would like to introduce the so-called Graf vector field. We recall the way how to construct it in [11] and [5] (see also [6]): Let ρ = {ρa | a ∈ A} be a sequence of non-negative numbers indexed by elements of A such that ρamin = 0. Then we introduce the set Ωa (ρ) 2 2 = {Ξ ∈ X |Ξa |1 + ρa > |Ξb |1 + ρb for any b ∈ A such that b ( a or a ( b} (3.2) for a ∈ A, by combining the idea of Graf [11] with the one of Derezi´ nski [5] (see also [6]). 2 1/2 2 is a norm on X a∪b , we have Since the seminorm (|Ξa |1 + |Ξb |1 2
2
10r × |Ξa∪b |1 ≤ |Ξa |1 + |Ξb |1
2
(3.3)
for all a, b ∈ A with sufficiently small r > 0. We also require r ≤ 1/5. Now we take a sequence ρ such that 1 #(a) r ≤ ρa ≤ r#(a) , 2
a 6= amin .
(3.4)
And, for simplicity of notations, we put r#(amin ) ≡ 0. The following lemma and proposition can be obtained as in [11, 5 and 6], and so we omit the proofs. 2
Lemma 3.1. Let a, b ∈ A. Assume that a 6⊂ b and b 6⊂ a. If |Ξa∪b |1 ≥ r#(a∪b) /2 − 2 r#(a) and |Ξa |1 ≤ 2r#(a) , then one has 2
|Ξb |1 ≥ r#(b) .
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
218
00113
T. Adachi
Proposition 3.2. Let a, b ∈ A. (1) For a 6= b, the intersection Ωa (ρ) ∩ Ωb (ρ) is a set of measure zero. Here Ωa (ρ) and Ωb (ρ) are the closures of the sets Ωa (ρ) and Ωb (ρ), respectively. The family of sets {Ωa (ρ) | a ∈ A} is a family of disjoint open sets in X and one has [ Ωa (ρ) = X . a∈A
(2) For Ξ ∈ Ωa (ρ) and b 6⊂ a, one has 3 #(b) 3 N −1 r r ≥ . 10 10 p Moreover, for δ > 0 such that δ < 3rN −1 /10, [ Ωb (ρ) Xa (δ) ⊂ 2
|Ξb |1 ≥
˜a b∈A
holds with A˜a = {b ∈ A | a ⊂ b}. Such a family of sets {Ωa (ρ) | a ∈ A} should be called a Graf partition of X . Now we put Rρ (Ξ) =
1 2 max(|Ξa |1 + ρa ) , 2 a∈A
(3.5)
a ∈ A,
(3.6)
qa,ρ (Ξ) = 1Ωa (ρ) (Ξ) ,
where 1Ωa (ρ) is the characteristic function of the set Ωa (ρ). The following proposition can be shown as in [5, 6], by virtue of Proposition 3.2. Hence we omit the proof. Proposition 3.3. Rρ (Ξ) is a continuous convex function on X . Moreover, one has the following: X1 qa,ρ (Ξ)(|Ξa |1 2 + ρa ) Rρ (Ξ) = 2 a∈A
holds up to a set of measure zero. (∇Ξ Rρ )(Ξ) =
X
Ξa qa,ρ (Ξ) ,
a∈A
(∇2Ξ Rρ )(Ξ) ≥
X
πa qa,ρ (Ξ) ,
a∈A
hξ, (∇2Ξ Rρ )(Ξ)ξi − hξ, (∇Ξ Rρ )(Ξ)i − h(∇Ξ Rρ )(Ξ) , ξi + 2Rρ (Ξ) X 2 ≥ qa,ρ (Ξ)|ξa − Ξa |1 a∈A
for ξ ∈ X hold as distributions.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
max{|Ξ|21 , C1 } ≤ 2Rρ (Ξ) ≤ |Ξ|21 + C2
219
for some C1 , C2 > 0 ,
and for any a ∈ A, Rρ depends on Ξa only in some neighborhood of Xa . Next we fix a function f0 ∈
C0∞ (×a6=amin [r#(a) /2, r#(a) ])
where dρ =
N a6=amin
Z such that f0 ≥ 0 ,
f0 (ρ)dρ = 1 ,
dρa . Then we define Z R(Ξ) = f0 (ρ)Rρ (Ξ)dρ ,
(3.7)
Z q˜a (Ξ) =
f0 (ρ)qa,ρ (Ξ)dρ ,
qa (Ξ) = pP
q˜a (Ξ) , ˜b 2 (Ξ) b∈A q
a∈A
(3.8)
a ∈ A.
(3.9)
The following proposition can also be shown in the same way as in [5] and [6], by virtue of Proposition 3.3. So we omit the proof. Proposition 3.4. R(Ξ) is a smooth convex function on X . q˜a (Ξ) and qa (Ξ), a ∈ A, are all bounded smooth functions on X with bounded derivatives. Moreover, one has X q˜a (Ξ) ≡ 1 , a∈A
X
qa 2 (Ξ) ≡ 1 ,
a∈A
max{|Ξ|1 2 , C1 } ≤ 2R(Ξ) ≤ |Ξ|1 2 + C2 (∇Ξ R)(Ξ) =
X
for some C1 , C2 > 0 ,
Ξa q˜a (Ξ) ,
a∈A
(∇2Ξ R)(Ξ) ≥
X
πa q˜a (Ξ) ,
a∈A
hξ, (∇2Ξ R)(Ξ)ξi − hξ, (∇Ξ R)(Ξ)i − h(∇Ξ R)(Ξ), ξi + 2R(Ξ) X ≥ q˜a (Ξ)|ξa − Ξa |1 2 , ξ ∈ X , a∈A
and that for any a ∈ A, R depends on Ξa only in some neighborhood of Xa . For any multi-index α, ∂Ξα (2R(Ξ) − |Ξ|1 2 ), ∂Ξα (hΞ, (∇Ξ R)(Ξ)i − |Ξ|1 2 ) and ∂Ξα (hΞ, (∇2Ξ R)(Ξ)Ξi − |Ξ|1 2 ) are all bounded functions on X . The following lemma is also needed for proving some propagation estimates in this section.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
220
00113
T. Adachi
Lemma 3.5. There exists σ0 > 0 such that for any σ ≥ σ0 , one has qa (Ξ) = qa (Ξ)
X
q˜b (σΞ) ,
a ∈ A,
b∈Aa
where Aa = {b ∈ A | b ⊂ a}. Proof. By virtue of Proposition 3.4, it is sufficient to show that there exists σ0 > 0 such that for any σ ≥ σ0 and b 6⊂ a, supp qa (Ξ)∩ supp q˜b (σΞ) = ∅. By the definition of qa (Ξ) and Proposition 3.2, we see that for Ξ ∈ supp qa (Ξ) and b 6⊂ a, |Ξb |12 ≥
3 #(b) r 10
holds. On the other hand, for Ξ ∈ supp q˜b (σΞ), |σΞb |1 2 = |σΞamin |1 2 − |σΞb |1 2 ≤ r#(b) ,
b 6= amin
holds, where we took account of (3.4). Thus taking σ0 > 0 as σ0 > obtain this lemma.
p 10/3, we
Following the argument of [3], we introduce the creation operator β ∗ by using the total pseudomomentum ktotal = (ktotal,1 , ktotal,2 ) as follows (see also [1]): 1 β =√ 2 ∗
1 ktotal,2 − iktotal,1 qB
.
(3.10)
Here we took account of (1.8). In the argument below, we use the localization of the number operator N0 = β ∗ β in addition to the localization of the energy. Now we show the following important propagation estimate, which was due to Graf [11] in the case of N -body Schr¨ odinger operators without external electromagnetic fields (see also [5, 6]). ∞ function such that J = 1 on Theorem 3.6. Let a ∈ A, J ∈ C0 (X ) be a cut-off ∞ {Ξ ∈ X |Ξ|1 ≤ θ} and J ≥ 0, and f, h ∈ C0 (R) be real-valued. Suppose that max{(1 + µS2 )−1 , (1 + µL )−1 } < ν ≤ 1. Then, for sufficiently large θ > 0, there exists a constant C > 0 such that for any ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax )
Z 1
holds.
∞
2
Ξa
Ξ Ξ −itH dt
≤ Ckψk2 ψ
t − pΞa qa tν J t f (H)h(N0 )e t 1
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
221
In order to prove this theorem, we need the following lemma. Lemma 3.7. Let f, h ∈ C0∞ (R) and ν > 0. Then for any ε > 0 and M ∈ N , one has
1[ε,∞) |yN | f (H)h(N0 ) = O(t−Mν )
ν t as t → ∞. Proof. First we recall that |yN |M f (H)h(N0 ), M ∈ N , is bounded on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ), because of the relation N −1 X Dyj − (DyN − qA(yN )) 2qA(yN ) = ktotal − j=1
P −1 and the boundedness of the operators (ktotal )α h(N0 ) and {( N j=1 Dyj ) + (DyN − qA(yN ))}α f (H), α ∈ (N ∪ {0})2 . For u1 ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ), we put u = 1[ε,∞) (|yN |/tν )f (H)h(N0 )u1 . Then we have (εtν )M kuk ≤ k |yN |M uk ≤ Cku1 k with some C > 0 independent of t ≥ 1. This implies the lemma. We also need the following maximal velocity estimate in order to prove Theorem 3.6. Proposition 3.8. For any real-valued f ∈ C0∞ (R) there exists M > 0 such that for any M2 > M1 ≥ M,
2 Z ∞
1[M ,M ] |Ξ|1 f (H)e−itH ψ dt ≤ Ckψk2 1 2
t t 1 for any ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ), with C > 0 independent of ψ. Moreover, for any ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ) such that (1 + |Ξ|1 )1/2 ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ),
2 Z ∞
1[M ,∞) |Ξ|1 f (H)e−itH ψ dt < ∞ 1
t t 1 holds. Proof. The proof is done in the way similar to the one in [20] (see also e.g. [5, 6, 11 and 1]). We sketch the proof. Let G1 be defined by Z s g1 (u)2 du , G1 (s) = −∞
with real-valued g1 ∈ We use
C0∞ (R)
supported in [M0 , ∞) such that g1 = 1 on [M1 , M2 ].
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
222
00113
T. Adachi
Φ1 (t) = −G1
|Ξ|1 t
as a propagation observable. We note that Φ1 (t) is uniformly bounded in t ≥ 1. The Heisenberg derivative DH (Φ1 (t)) = ∂t Φ1 (t) + i[H, Φ1 (t)] of Φ1 (t) is calculated as follows: ( 2 2 |Ξ|1 1 |Ξ|1 |Ξ|1 Ξ g1 − , pΞ DH (Φ1 (t)) = 2 g1 t t 2t t |Ξ|1 2 ) Ξ |Ξ|1 . g1 + pΞ , |Ξ|1 t By virtue of the boundedness of pΞ f (H), which can be seen easily, we have 2 M0 − C |Ξ|1 f (H)g f (H)DH (Φ1 (t))f (H) ≥ f (H) + O(t−2 ) t t for some C > 0 which depends on f . Then if we take M0 > 0 so large that M0 > C, we obtain the first estimate. Next we put Z s g2 (u)2 du G2 (s) = −∞
with g2 ∈ C0∞ (R) which is supported in [M0 , M0 + 1] and satisfies R ∞ real-valued g (u)2 du = 1. We use −∞ 2 |Ξ|1 |Ξ|1 − M0 G2 Φ2 (t) = − t t as a propagation observable. We note that (1 + |Ξ|1 )−1/2 eitH f (H)Φ2 (t) f (H)e−itH (1 + |Ξ|1 )−1/2 is uniformly bounded in t ≥ 1. In the same way as above, we have |Ξ|1 M0 − C1 G2 f (H)DH (Φ2 (t))f (H) ≥ f (H) t t ) 2 C2 |Ξ|1 −2 g2 + O(t ) f (H) . − t t Thus if we take M0 so large that M0 > C1 and the first estimate holds, we obtain the second estimate. Proof of Theorem 3.6. We follow the argument of [11, 5 and 6]. First we take ν1 > 0 such that max{(1 + µS2 )−1 , (µL + 1)−1 } < ν1 < ν ≤ 1. We define 1 Ξ Ξ (∇Ξ R) ν1 , pΞ + pΞ , (∇Ξ R) ν1 Bt = tν1 −1 2 t t Ξ Ξ Ξ Ξ , − t2ν1 −2 R ν1 + ν1 t2ν1 −2 2R ν1 − ν1 , (∇Ξ R) ν1 t t t t
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
223
Ξ Ξ Ξ 2 , (∇Ξ R) ν1 pΞ − ν1 Ct = pΞ − ν1 t t t Ξ Ξ Ξ Ξ ν1 −1 + pΞ − ν1 , (∇Ξ R) ν1 (∇Ξ R) ν1 , pΞ − ν1 − (1 − ν1 )t t t t t Ξ + 2(1 − ν1 )2 t2ν1 −2 R ν1 . t Then, by a straightforward computation, we have Ξ 2ν1 −1 , R ν1 Bt = DH0 t t 1 −2ν1 −1 2 Ξ (∆Ξ R) ν1 DH0 Bt = t Ct − t 4 t Ξ Ξ Ξ . + t2ν1 −3 ν1 (ν1 − 1) 2R ν1 − ν1 , (∇Ξ R) ν1 t t t
(3.11)
−1
(3.12)
One can write Ct as
Ξ 2 τ, (∇Ξ R) ν1 τ Ct = (1 − ν1 ) t t Ξ Ξ Ξ − (∇Ξ R) ν1 , τ + 2R ν1 − τ, (∇Ξ R) ν1 t t t 2 2ν1 −2
with
Ξ . τ = (1 − ν1 )−1 t−ν1 +1 pΞ − ν1 t
Taking account of
we obtain
Ξ Ξ −1 −ν1 +1 , pΞ − τ − ν1 = (1 − ν1 ) t t t
X Ξa Ξa Ξ q˜a ν1 pΞa − p Ξa − Ct ≥ t t t
(3.13)
a∈A
by Proposition 3.4. Now we introduce a propagation observable Ξ Ξ Bt J f (H)h(N0 ) . Φ(t) = h(N0 )f (H)J t t For simplicity of notations, we write Jt = J(Ξ/t). We note that Φ(t) is uniformly bounded in t. We compute the Heisenberg derivative DH Φ(t) of Φ(t): DH Φ(t) = h(N0 )f (H)(DH0 Jt )Bt Jt f (H)h(N0 ) + h(N0 )f (H)Jt Bt (DH0 Jt )f (H)h(N0 )
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
224
00113
T. Adachi
ν1 −1
−t
h(N0 )f (H) ∇Ξ V (x), (∇Ξ R)
Ξ tν1
Jt2 f (H)h(N0 )
+ h(N0 )f (H)Jt (DH0 Bt )Jt f (H)h(N0 ) =: I1 (t) + I2 (t) + I3 (t) + I4 (t) .
(3.14)
We take j ∈ C0∞ (X ) such that j ≥ 0, j = 1 on supp ∇Ξ J and supp j ⊂ {Ξ ∈ X | θ/2 ≤ |Ξ|1 ≤ 2θ}. Since Ξ Ξ −1 B(t)j f (H)h(N0 ) + O(t−2 ) I1 (t) + I2 (t) = t h(N0 )f (H)j t t for some uniformly bounded observable B(t), by using Proposition 3.8, we have for sufficiently large θ > 0 Z ∞ |(e−itH ψ, (I1 (t) + I2 (t))e−itH ψ)| dt ≤ Ckψk2 . (3.15) 1
By Proposition 3.4, one can rewrite I3 (t) as X Ξa Ξ q˜a ν1 Jt2 f (H)h(N0 ) . I3 (t) = − h(N0 )f (H) ∇Ξa Ia (x), t t a∈A
In fact, one can identify R2×N × Z amax with X × R2yN , and then write V (x) as V (Ξ, yN ). Hence we have only to show that for (j, k) ⊂ a, Vjk (xj − xk ) depends on Ξa only for any fixed yN . We write a = {C1 , . . . , C#(a) } with {N } ⊂ C#(a) . We note that X a can be written as X a = Y C1 × · · · × Y C#(a)−1 × R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z a .
(3.16)
When {j, k} ⊂ Cl with l = 1, . . . , #(a)−1, it is well-known that Vjk (xj −xk ) depends odinger operators without external on Ξa only as in the case of many body Schr¨ electromagnetic fields. On the other hand, when {j, k} ⊂ C#(a) , Vjk (xj − xk ) can be written as Vjk (yj − yk , z (j,k) ). So we see that this Vjk (xj − xk ) also depends on Ξa only for any fixed yN , by taking account of (3.16). Thus we obtain h∇Ξ V (x), Ξa i = h∇Ξa V (x), Ξa i = h∇Ξa Ia (x), Ξa i . Next we consider (j, k) 6⊂ a. Taking account of (3.16), when j < k < N ,p we see that |xj − xk | ≥ c holds with some c > 0 on supp q˜a (Ξ), because |Ξ(j,k) |1 ≥ 3rN −1 /10 holds on supp q˜a (Ξ), by the definition of q˜a and Proposition 3.2. Similarly, when j < k = N , we see that |yj | + |z (j,N ) |1 ≥ c1 holds with some c1 > 0 on supp q˜a (Ξ). qa (Ξ)1[0,ε] (|yN |)) for Thus we have |xj − xN | ≥ c holds with some c > 0 on supp(˜ any ε > 0 such that ε < c1 . By virtue of these facts and Lemma 3.7, we obtain Z ∞ |(e−itH ψ, I3 (t)e−itH ψ)| dt ≤ Ckψk2 (3.17) 1
for any ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ), because I3 (t) = O(t−ν1 (1+µS2 ) ) + O(t−ν1 (1+µL ) ) + O(t−ν1 M ) is integrable in t ∈ [1, ∞) for sufficiently large M ∈ N such that
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
225
−ν1 M < −1, by the assumptions on the pair potentials. Here we used the facts that Ξa is bounded on supp J(Ξ), and that −ν1 (1 + µS2 ) < −1 and −ν1 (1 + µL ) < −1. Finally, by (3.12), (3.13) and Proposition 3.4, we see I4 (t) = t−1 h(N0 )f (H)Jt Ct Jt f (H)h(N0 ) + O(t−2ν1 −1 ) + O(t2ν1 −3 ) X Ξb Ξ Ξb −1 − pΞb q˜b ν1 − pΞb Jt f (H)h(N0 ) h(N0 )f (H)Jt ≥t t t t b∈A
+ O(t−2ν1 −1 ) + O(t2ν1 −3 ) .
(3.18)
Here we note that −2ν1 − 1 < −1 and 2ν1 − 3 < −1 because of 0 < ν1 < 1. Taking account of t−ν1 = t−ν × tν−ν1 with ν − ν1 > 0, by virtue of Lemma 3.5 and its proof, we have for a ∈ A and sufficiently large t ≥ 1, X Ξb Ξ Ξb − pΞb q˜b ν1 − pΞb Jt f (H)h(N0 ) h(N0 )f (H)Jt t−1 t t t b∈A
≥ t
X
−1
h(N0 )f (H)Jt
b∈A
× = t−1
Ξb Ξ Ξ 2 − pΞb qa q˜b ν1 t tν t
Ξb − pΞb Jt f (H)h(N0 ) t X Ξb Ξ Ξ − pΞb qa 2 ν q˜b ν1 h(N0 )f (H)Jt t t t
b∈Aa
× ≥ t−1
Ξb − pΞb Jt f (H)h(N0 ) t X Ξa Ξ Ξ 2 − pΞa qa q˜b ν1 h(N0 )f (H)Jt t tν t
b∈Aa
Ξa − pΞa Jt f (H)h(N0 ) × t Ξa Ξ Ξa − pΞa qa 2 ν − pΞa Jt f (H)h(N0 ) = t−1 h(N0 )f (H)Jt t t t 2 Ξ Ξa − pΞa = t−1 h(N0 )f (H)Jt qa ν t t Ξ × qa ν Jt f (H)h(N0 ) + O(t−1−2ν ) , t
where we used the fact that πa ≤ πb for b ⊂ a. Thus, combining (3.14), (3.15), (3.17) and (3.18) with this, we obtain the theorem.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
226
00113
T. Adachi
When we take ν = 1 in Theorem 3.6, one can obtain an improvement of Theorem 3.6 as follows: ∞ Theorem 3.9. Let a ∈ A, J ∈ C0 (X ) be a cut-off∞function such that J = 1 on {Ξ ∈ X |Ξ|1 ≤ θ} and J ≥ 0, and f, h ∈ C0 (R) be real-valued. Then, for sufficiently large θ > 0, there exists a constant C > 0 such that for any ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax )
2 1/2 Z ∞
dt
Ξ Ξ Ξ
a −itH − pΞa J f (H)h(N0 )e ≤ Ckψk2 qa ψ
t t t t 1 1
holds. Proof. Since the proof is quite similar to the one in [11], we sketch it. Put 2 Ξa − pΞa + t−2γ Λa (t) = t 1 with 0 < γ < 1. We compute the Heisenberg derivative of Ξ Ξ Ξ Ξ qa Λa 1/2 (t)qa J f (H)h(N0 ) , h(N0 )f (H)J t t t t which is bounded uniformly in t. For simplicity of notations, we write Jt = J(Ξ/t) and qa,t = qa (Ξ/t). One can first prove that the terms arising from DH Jt are integrable in t ∈ [1, ∞). In fact, taking j as in the proof of Theorem 3.6, as in [11], we have h(N0 )f (H)Jt qa,t Λa 1/2 (t)qa,t (DH Jt )f (H)h(N0 ) Ξ Ξ B(t)j f (H)h(N0 ) + O(t−2+γ ) . = t−1 h(N0 )f (H)j t t Thus, by Proposition 3.8, we obtain Z ∞ |(e−itH ψ, h(N0 )f (H)Jt qa,t Λa 1/2 (t)qa,t (DH Jt )f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψ)| dt 1
≤ Ckψk2 .
(3.19)
Next we consider the terms arising from Ξ i −2 Ξ Ξ −1 , − pΞ − t (∆Ξ qa ) . (∇Ξ qa ) DH qa,t = −t t t 2 t Now we introduce another partition of unity {ˆ qa (Ξ) | a ∈ A} which is defined by the definition of {qa (Ξ) | a ∈ A} with replacing r by a sufficiently small r1 > 0 in its definition. Then, by the proof of Lemma 3.5, we see that if r1 < 3r/10, X qˆb 2 (Ξ) . ∇Ξ qa (Ξ) = ∇Ξ qa (Ξ) b∈Aa
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
227
Moreover we claim the following lemma. The reason why we follow not the argument of [5] and [6] but the idea of Graf [11] in the definition of Ωa (ρ), a ∈ A, is that the definition (3.2) makes the proof of this lemma much simpler. We think that this lemma presents one of the important properties of {qa (Ξ) | a ∈ A} and {ˆ qa (Ξ) | a ∈ A}. qa (Ξ) | a ∈ A} as r1 < Lemma 3.10. If one takes r1 > 0 in the definition of {ˆ 3r/10, one has for b ⊂ a qˆb (Ξ)∇Ξ qa (Ξ) = qˆb (Ξ)∇Ξb qa (Ξ) . Proof. The proof is quite similar to the one in [11]. First we have to prove that qa,ρ (Ξ) depends on Ξb only on supp qˆb (Ξ) with b ⊂ a. In order to achieve it, we have only to show that on supp qˆb (Ξ) with b ⊂ a, qa,ρ (Ξ) = 1Ωa,b (ρ) (Ξ) with
(3.20)
2 2 Ωa,b (ρ) = {Ξ ∈ X |Ξa |1 + ρa > |Ξb1 |1 + ρb1 for any b1 ∈ A such that b ⊂ b1 ( a or a ( b1 } .
One can assume that b 6= amin without loss of generality, because Ωa,amin (ρ) = Ωa (ρ). Put 2 2 ωa,b (ρ) = {Ξ ∈ X |Ξa |1 + ρa > |Ξb |1 + ρb } for a, b ∈ A. Then we see that Y 1ωa,b1 (ρ) (Ξ) , qa,ρ (Ξ) =
A¯a = {b1 ∈ A | b1 ( a or a ( b1 } ,
(3.21)
¯a b1 ∈A
1Ωa,b (ρ) (Ξ) =
Y
1ωa,b1 (ρ) (Ξ) ,
Aa,b = {b1 ∈ A | b ⊂ b1 ( a or a ( b1 } . (3.22)
b1 ∈Aa,b
As for b1 ( a with b 6⊂ b1 and b1 6⊂ b, we have either i) b ∪ b1 = a or ii) b ∪ b1 ( a. On supp qˆb (Ξ), we have in the case i) 1ωa,amin (ρ) (Ξ)1ωa,b1 (ρ) (Ξ) = 1ωa,amin (ρ) (Ξ) ,
(3.23)
while in the case ii) 1ωa,amin (ρ) (Ξ)1ωa,b∪b1 (ρ) (Ξ)1ωa,b1 (ρ) (Ξ) = 1ωa,amin (ρ) (Ξ)1ωa,b∪b1 (ρ) (Ξ) .
(3.24)
Assume that there exists a Ξ ∈ supp qˆb (Ξ) in the support of the right-hand side of one of the above two equalities (3.23) and (3.24), such that |Ξa |1 2 + ρa ≤ |Ξb1 |1 2 + ρb1 . In the case i), this is written as |Ξb∪b1 |1 2 + ρb∪b1 ≤ |Ξb1 |1 2 + ρb1 . In the case ii), we have |Ξb1 |1 2 − |Ξb∪b1 |1 2 = (|Ξb1 |1 2 − |Ξa |1 2 ) − (|Ξb∪b1 |1 2 − |Ξa |1 2 ) > (ρa − ρb1 ) − 2 2 2 (ρa − ρb∪b1 ) = ρb∪b1 − ρb1 . Thus both cases imply |Ξb∪b1 |1 ≥ |Ξb∪b1 |1 − |Ξb1 |1 = 2 2 #(b∪b1 ) #(b1 ) /2 − r . On the other hand, we have |Ξb1 |1 − |Ξb∪b1 |1 ≥ ρb∪b1 − ρb1 ≥ r 2 2 2 2 b1 2 |Ξ |1 = (|Ξa |1 − |Ξb1 |1 ) + (|Ξamin |1 − |Ξa |1 ) < (ρb1 − ρa ) + (ρa − ρamin ) =
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
228
00113
T. Adachi 2
ρb1 ≤ r#(b1 ) . Hence, by Lemma 3.1, we have |Ξb |1 ≥ r#(b) with b 6= amin . This 2 contradicts Ξ ∈ supp qˆb (Ξ), because, for Ξ ∈ supp qˆb (Ξ), |Ξb |1 ≤ r1 #(b) holds with r1 < 3r/10 and b 6= amin . Therefore we have (3.23) and (3.24). As for b1 ( a with b1 ( b, we have on supp qˆb (Ξ) 1ωa,b (ρ) (Ξ)1ωa,b1 (ρ) (Ξ) = 1ωa,b (ρ) (Ξ) . 2
(3.25) 2
2
2
In fact, for Ξ ∈ supp qˆb (Ξ) ∩ ωa,b (ρ), we have |Ξb1 |1 − |Ξa |1 = (|Ξb |1 − |Ξa |1 ) + 2 2 (|Ξb1 |1 − |Ξb |1 ) < (ρa − ρb ) + (r1 #(b) − r1 #(b1 ) /2). If we take r1 > 0 as r1 < 3r/10, we have r1 #(b) − r1 #(b1 ) /2 < r#(b) /2 − r#(b1 ) for any b1 ( b. In fact, we have #(b) r1 (1−r1 #(b1 )−#(b) /2) ≤ r1 #(b) and r#(b) (1/2−r#(b1 )−#(b) ) ≥ 3r#(b) /10 because #(b1 ) − #(b) ≥ 1 and r ≤ 1/5. Thus it is enough to show r1 #(b) < 3r#(b) /10 for 2 2 #(b) = 1, . . . , N −1, which holds if r1 < 3r/10. Therefore we have |Ξb1 |1 −|Ξa |1 < (ρa − ρb ) + (r#(b) /2 − r#(b1 ) ) ≤ (ρa − ρb ) + (ρb − ρb1 ) = ρa − ρb1 by (3.4), which implies (3.25). By using (3.23), (3.24) and (3.25), we obtain (3.20) on supp qˆb (Ξ) with b ⊂ a, taking account of (3.21) and (3.22). Thus we see that q˜a (Ξ) depends on Ξb only on supp qˆb (Ξ) with b ⊂ a. We prove that qa (Ξ) also depends on Ξb only on supp qˆb (Ξ) with b ⊂ a. As in the proof of Lemma 3.5, for Ξ ∈ supp q˜c (Ξ) and b 6⊂ c, 2 2 |Ξb |1 ≥ 3r#(b) /10 holds. On the other hand, for Ξ ∈ supp qˆb (Ξ), |Ξb |1 ≤ r1 #(b) holds. Since r1 < 3r/10, we see that supp q˜c (Ξ) ∩ supp qˆb (Ξ) = ∅ for b 6⊂ c. Thus we have on supp qˆb (Ξ) qa (Ξ) = qP
q˜a (Ξ) ˜c 2 (Ξ) ˜b q c∈A
,
A˜b = {c ∈ A | b ⊂ c} ,
which implies the lemma because q˜c (Ξ), c ∈ A˜b , depends on Ξb only on supp qˆb (Ξ). We continue the proof of Theorem 3.9. Since, by virtue of Lemma 3.10, (DH qa,t )Jt f (H) = −t
−1
X b∈Aa
= −t
−1
X b∈Aa
qˆb
2
Ξb Ξ Ξ (∇Ξb qa ) , − pΞb Jt f (H) + O(t−2 ) t t t
Ξb Ξ Ξ Ξ (∇Ξb qa ) , − pΞb qˆb Jt f (H) + O(t−2 ) , qˆb t t t t
we obtain |(e−itH ψ, h(N0 )f (H)Jt qa,t Λa 1/2 (t)(DH qa,t )Jt f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψ)|
X
Ξb − p kΛa 1/2 (t)qa,t Jt f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψk ≤ Ct−1 Ξ b
t 1 b∈Aa
Ξ −2 2 Jt f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψ × qˆb
+ O(t )kψk . t
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
229
Combining this with Theorem 3.6, we obtain
Z
∞
|(e−itH ψ, h(N0 )f (H)Jt qa,t Λa 1/2 (t)(DH qa,t )Jt f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψ)| dt ≤ Ckψk2 .
1
Now we consider the term arising from DH Λa 1/2 (t) = DHa Λa 1/2 (t) + i[Ia (x), Λa 1/2 (t)] . Taking account of e
itHa
(DHa Λa
1/2
(t))e
−itHa
d d = (eitHa Λa 1/2 (t)e−itHa ) = dt dt
we have DHa Λa
1/2
(t) = −t
−1
= −t
−1
Λa Λa
−1/2
1/2
2
|Ξa |1 + t−2γ t2
!1/2
! 2 Ξa −2γ − pΞa + γt (t) t 1
(t) + (1 − γ)t
−1−2γ
Λa
−1/2
,
(3.26)
(t) .
Because of Λa −1/2 (t) = O(tγ ), we see that the term arising from (1 − γ)t−1−2γ Λa −1/2 (t) is integrable in t ∈ [1, ∞). On the other hand, we claim h(N0 )f (H)Jt qa,t [Ia (x), Λa 1/2 (t)]qa,t Jt f (H)h(N0 ) = O(tmax{−1−µ0 ,−2}+2γ )
(3.27)
with µ0 = min{µS1 , µS2 , µL }. In order to carry it out, we have only to show that h(N0 )(Hamin + 1)−1 Jt qa,t [Ia (x), Λa 1/2 (t)]qa,t Jt (Hamin + 1)−1 h(N0 ) = O(tmax{−1−µ0 ,−2}+2γ ) .
(3.28)
Since [(N0 + 1)−1 (Hamin + 1)−1 Jt qa,t Ia (x)qa,t Jt (Hamin + 1)−1 (N0 + 1)−1 , Λa 1/2 (t)] = (N0 + 1)−1 (Hamin + 1)−1 Jt qa,t [Ia (x), Λa 1/2 (t)] × qa,t Jt (Hamin + 1)−1 (N0 + 1)−1 + [(N0 + 1)−1 (Hamin + 1)−1 Jt qa,t , Λa 1/2 (t)] × Ia (x)qa,t Jt (Hamin + 1)−1 (N0 + 1)−1 + (N0 + 1)−1 (Hamin + 1)−1 × Jt qa,t Ia (x)[qa,t Jt (Hamin + 1)−1 (N0 + 1)−1 , Λa 1/2 (t)] ,
(3.29)
we have only to prove the left-hand side and the last two terms on the right-hand side of (3.29) are O(tmin{−1−µ0 ,−2}+2γ ). By a straightforward computation, we have [(N0 + 1)−1 (Hamin + 1)−1 Jt qa,t , Λa (t)] = O(t−1 ). Moreover, taking account of Ξa Ξa − pΞa , ∇Ξa Ia (x) + ∇Ξa Ia (x), − pΞa , i[Ia (x), Λa (t)] = t t
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
230
00113
T. Adachi
we obtain (N0 + 1)−1 (Hamin + 1)−1 Jt qa,t [Ia (x), Λa (t)]qa,t Jt (Hamin + 1)−1 (N0 + 1)−1 = O(tmax{−1−µS2 ,−1−µL ,−2} ) , as in the proof of Theorem 3.6. Here we used
1[ε,∞) |yN | (Hamin + 1)−1 (N0 + 1)−1 = O(t−2 ) ,
t
t→∞
instead of Lemma 3.7, which can be proved as Lemma 3.7 because |yN |2 (Hamin + 1)−1 (N0 + 1)−1 is bounded on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ). Thus we have [(N0 + 1)−1 (Hamin + 1)−1 Jt qa,t Ia (x)qa,t Jt (Hamin + 1)−1 (N0 + 1)−1 , Λa (t)] = O(tmax{−1−µ0 ,−2} ) by (3.29) with replacing Λa 1/2 (t) by Λa (t). As in [11], one can prove that if [Λa (t), B(t)] is bounded for fixed t, then k[Λa (t)1/2 , B(t)]k ≤ Ct2γ k[Λa (t), B(t)]k . Using this, we have (3.28), which implies (3.27). Taking γ as 2γ < min{µ0 , 1}, we see that the term arising from i[Ia (x), Λa 1/2 (t)] is integrable in t ∈ [1, ∞). By using these facts and taking account of (3.26), we obtain Z ∞ dt (e−itH ψ, h(N0 )f (H)Jt qa,t Λa 1/2 (t)qa,t Jt f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψ) ≤ Ckψk2 . t 1 This implies the theorem. Next we prove the following minimal velocity estimate, which can be shown by virtue of the Mourre estimate in Corollary 2.2. Theorem 3.11. Let λ, δ, c and f be also as in Corollary 2.2. Then for any realvalued h ∈ C0∞ (R), there exists ε0 > 0 such that
2 Z ∞
1[0,ε ] |Ξ|1 f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψ dt ≤ Ckψk2 0
t t 1 for any ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ), with C > 0 independent of ψ. This theorem can be obtained by Proposition 3.12 and Lemma 3.13 below: First we have the following propagation estimate associated with the observable A, which is defined by (2.9), by following a standard argument in the N -body scattering theory originated with the works of Sigal–Soffer (see e.g. [19, 20]). Proposition 3.12. Let λ, δ, c and f be as in Corollary 2.2. Let c0 be such that 0 < c0 < c. Then there exists C > 0 such that
2 Z ∞
1[−c ,c ] A f (H)e−itH ψ dt ≤ Ckψk2 0 0
t t 1 for any ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ).
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
231
Proof. The proof is done in exactly the same way as in [20]. We sketch it (see also e.g. [10] and [1]). Take g ∈ C0∞ (R) such that g is real-valued, g = 1 on [−c0 , c0 ] and supp g ⊂ (−∞, c). Let G be defined by Z s g(u)2 du , G(s) = −∞ 0
so that G (s) = g(s) ∈ 2
C0∞ (R)
with g being real-valued. We use A Φ1 (t) = G t
as a propagation observable. We note that Φ1 (t) is uniformly bounded in t ≥ 1. If we take f1 ∈ C0∞ (R) such that f1 = 1 on the support of f , then f (H)i[H, Φ1 (t)]f (H) = f (H)i[f1 (H)H, Φ1 (t)]f (H) . By using the almost analytic extension method due to Helffer–Sj¨ ostrand [12] in order to calculate several commutators, we have A A A f (H)i H, f (H)g + O(t−2 ) . f (H)i[H, Φ1 (t)]f (H) = g t t t Here we note that [(H + i)−1 , A] and [[(H + i)−1 , A], A] are bounded on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ) by the assumptions on the pair potentials. Hence it follows from the Mourre estimate (2.35) that c A A f (H)2 g + O(t−2 ) f (H)i[H, Φ1 (t)]f (H) ≥ g t t t 2 c A f (H) + O(t−2 ) . ≥ f (H)g t t On the other hand, we have 2 c1 A f (H) f (H)∂t Φ1 (t)f (H) ≥ − f (H)g t t for some c1 such that c0 < c1 < c, which depends on the support of g. Thus we obtain 2 c − c1 A f (H)g f (H) + O(t−2 ) . f (H)DH (Φ1 (t))f (H) ≥ t t This proves the proposition. Lemma 3.13. Let λ, δ, c and f be as in Corollary 2.2. Let c0 be such that 0 < exists ε0 > 0 such that for any c0 < c. Then for any real-valued h ∈ C0∞ (R), there ∞ real-valued F ∈ C0 (X ) supported in {Ξ ∈ X |Ξ|1 ≤ 2ε0 } such that F = 1 on {Ξ ∈ X |Ξ|1 ≤ ε0 }, one has
1[c ,∞) |A| F Ξ f (H)h(N0 ) = O(t−1 )
0
t t as t → ∞.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
232
00113
T. Adachi
Proof. We follow the argument in [1]. First we introduce the operator N −1 X 1 (yj · Dyj + Dyj · yj ) . (3.30) (hz amax , Dzamax i + hDzamax , z amax i) + A˜ = 2 j=1 Then we note that the following equality holds, which can be checked by a straightforward computation: 1 A˜ − A = − 2
N −1 X
(κ0 · Dyj + Dyj · κ0 ) ,
(3.31)
j=1
where κ0 is as in (2.10). Then it is obvious that (A˜ − A)f (H)h(N0 ) is bounded on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ). We take F1 ∈ C ∞ (R) such that F1 ≥ 0, F1 = 1 on [c0 , ∞) and supp F1 ⊂ [c0 /2, ∞), and put FA (t) = F1 (|A|/t). We also put FΞ (t) = F (Ξ/t), where F is as in the statement of the lemma. And for u1 ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ), we put u = FA (t)FΞ (t)f (H)h(N0 )u1 . Since (A˜ − A)f (H)h(N0 ) is bounded on L2 (R2×N × Z amax ), by controlling some commutators, we have ˜ + ku1 k) k |A|uk ≤ C1 (k |A|uk
(3.32)
with some C1 > 0 independent of t ≥ 1. Now we introduce G ∈ C0∞ (X ) such that G = 1 on supp F and supp G ⊂ {Ξ ∈ X |Ξ|1 ≤ 3ε0 } and put GΞ (t) = ˜ controlling some G(Ξ/t). Taking account of the definition (3.30) of the operator A, commutators, and using GΞ (t), we obtain c0 tkFA (t)FΞ (t)f (H)h(N0 )u1 k , 2 ˜ k |A|uk ≤ C2 ε0 tkFA (t)FΞ (t)f (H)h(N0 )u1 k + C3 ku1 k
k |A|uk ≥
with some Cj > 0 (j = 2, 3) independent of t ≥ 1. Hence, combining these inequalities with (3.32), if we take ε0 > 0 so small that C1 C2 ε0 < c0 /2, we obtain the lemma. 4. Proof of Theorem 1.1 Throughout this section, we assume the conditions (V.1), (V.2), (V.3) and (SR). First we prove the existence of the Deift–Simon wave operators ˇ + = s - lim eitHa q˜a Ξ e−itH , a ∈ A . (4.1) W a t→∞ t We note that N0 commutes with H. By a density argument, for ψ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ) such that ψ = f (H)ψ ,
ψ = h(N0 )ψ
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
with f, h ∈ C0∞ (R), we have only to prove the existence of ˇ a+ ψ = lim eitHa q˜a Ξ e−itH ψ , a ∈ A . W t→∞ t
233
(4.2)
In order to carry it out, by taking f1 , h1 ∈ C0∞ (R) such that f1 f = f and h1 h = h, we have only to show the existence of Ξ e−itH ψ , a ∈ A . lim eitHa h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )˜ qa (4.3) t→∞ t Here we note that qa h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )˜
Ξ Ξ − q˜a f1 (H)h1 (N0 ) = O(tmax{−1,−µS1 } ) = O(t−1 ) , t t
which can be proved as in the proof of Theorem 3.6 by virtue of Lemma 3.7. As is well-known, Proposition 3.8 implies Ξ 2 e−itH f (H) = 0 , s - lim 1 − J (4.4) t→∞ t where J ∈ C0∞ (X ) be a cut-off function such that J = 1 on {Ξ ∈ X |Ξ|1 ≤ θ} and J ≥ 0 with sufficiently large θ > 0 (see e.g. [1]). By virtue of (4.4), we have only to show the existence of Ξ −itH Ξ Ξ q˜a J e ψ, a ∈ A. (4.5) lim eitHa h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )J t→∞ t t t Since the proof is quite similar to the one in [11], we sketch it. Putting Ξ Ξ Ξ itHa ˇ q˜a J f (H)h(N0 )e−itH , h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )J Wa (t) = e t t t we compute ˇa dW (t) = eitHa h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )DH (Jt q˜a,t Jt )f (H)h(N0 )e−itH dt − ieitHa h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )Jt q˜a,t Jt Ia (x)f (H)h(N0 )e−itH with Jt = J(Ξ/t) and q˜a,t = q˜a (Ξ/t), where the last term in the right-hand side is integrable in t in the norm sense because of µS1 > 1, by virtue of Lemma 3.7. We used the fact that N0 commutes with Ha , a ∈ A. We have to compute qa,t Jt + Jt q˜a,t (DH Jt ) . DH (Jt q˜a,t Jt ) = Jt (DH q˜a,t )Jt + (DH Jt )˜ As for the terms arising from DH Jt , by taking j ∈ C0∞ (X ) such that j ≥ 0, j = 1 on supp ∇Ξ J and supp j ⊂ {Ξ ∈ X | θ/2 ≤ |Ξ|1 ≤ 2θ}, we have |(Φ, h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )Jt q˜a,t (DH Jt )f (H)h(N0 )ψ)| ≤ Ct−1 kjt f1 (Ha )h1 (N0 )Φkkjt (H + i)f (H)h(N0 )ψk + O(t−2 )kΦk kψk
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
234
00113
T. Adachi
with jt = j(Ξ/t) for any Φ ∈ L2 (R2×N × Z amax ). Thus we have as t1 , t2 → ∞ Z t2 |(Φ, eitHa h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )Jt q˜a,t (DH Jt )f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψ)| dt t1
Z
∞
≤ C
kjt f1 (Ha )h1 (N0 )e−itHa Φk2
1
Z ×
t2
dt t
1/2
kjt (H + i)f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψk2
t1
dt t
1/2 + o(1)kΦk kψk
≤ o(1)kΦk + o(1)kΦk kψk = o(1)kΦk ,
(4.6)
by virtue of Proposition 3.8. Next we consider Ξ Ξ −1 , − pΞ Jt + O(t−2 ) Jt (DH q˜a,t )Jt = −t Jt (∇Ξ q˜a ) t t X Ξb Ξ Ξ 2 −1 (∇Ξb q˜a ) , − pΞb Jt + O(t−2 ) = −t Jt qˆb t t t b∈Aa
= −t−1
X b∈Aa
Jt qˆb
Ξb Ξ Ξ (∇Ξb q˜a ) , − pΞb t t t
Ξ Jt + O(t−2 ) , × qˆb (4.7) t by virtue of the proof of Theorem 3.9, where we used the same notations as in Sec. 3. Since |(Φ, h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )Jt (DH q˜a,t )Jt f (H)h(N0 )ψ)| X ≤ Ct−1 kΛb 1/4 (t)ˆ qb,t Jt f1 (Ha )h1 (N0 )Φk kΛb 1/4 (t)ˆ qb,t Jt f (H)h(N0 )ψk b∈Aa
+ O(t−2 )kΦk kψk with qˆb,t = qˆb (Ξ/t) and the same notations as in Sec. 3, we obtain as t1 , t2 → ∞ Z t2 |(Φ, eitHa h1 (N0 )f1 (Ha )Jt (DH q˜a,t )Jt f (H)h(N0 )e−itH ψ)| dt = o(1)kΦk (4.8) t1
ˇ a (t)ψ | t ≥ 1} by virtue of Theorem 3.9. Combining (4.6) with (4.8), we see that {W is a Cauchy sequence, which implies that (4.5) exists. Therefore we get the existence ˇ a+ , a ∈ A. of the Deift–Simon wave operators W Next we prove the existence of the usual wave operators Wa+ , a ∈ A(amax ), which are defined by (1.16). First we note that in the same argument as the one to ˇ a+ , a ∈ A, there exist the show the existence of the Deift–Simon wave operators W limits Ξ −itHa e s - lim eitH q˜a , a ∈ A. (4.9) t→∞ t
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
235
Next we notice that finite linear combinations of tensor products of eigenstates of K a and H C#(a) are dense in Ran(P˜ a ⊗ Pˆ a ). So it is sufficient to show the existence ˜ a for an eigenstate of Wa+ with assuming that P˜ a ⊗ Pˆ a is the eigenprojection of K ˜ a = K a ⊗ Id + Id ⊗ H C#(a) on ˜ a (P˜ a ⊗ Pˆ a ) = E(P˜ a ⊗ Pˆ a ), where K such that K 2×#(C#(a) ) 2 a,n 2 C#(a) ×Z ). Put L (X ) ⊗ L (R Y Dr = Ran 1ω˜ a,b1 (r) (pΞ ) , A¯a,1 = {b ∈ A | a ( b} ¯a,1 b1 ∈A
with r > 0 and
2 2 ω ˜ a,b1 (r) = {Ξ ∈ X |Ξa |1 + r#(a) /2 ≥ |Ξb1 |1 + r#(b1 ) } .
Then we have only to prove the existence of Wa+ on states in the dense set D = S r>0 Dr . Now we note that we have only to consider sufficiently small r > 0, and we see that Ξ it(∆ya,n +∆za )/2 e 1ω˜ a,b1 (r) (pΞ ) = 0 , a ( b1 , s - lim 1X \˜ωa,b1 (r) t→∞ t Ξ = 0, b ( a s - lim 1X \˜ωa,b (r) t→∞ t as t → ∞, where as for the first limit, see [18] (see also e.g. [11]). Here we used the facts that the definition of ω ˜ a,b1 (r), a ( b1 , is independent of Ξa , and that −(∆ya,n + ∆za ) = hpΞa , pΞa i. Thus, by taking account of (1.15), we have for ψ ∈ Dr with r > 0 ! Y Ξ −itHa a e−itHa P a ψ + o(1) P ψ= 1ω˜ a,b (r) e t ¯ b∈Aa
Ξ −itHa a e = q˜a P ψ + o(1) t as t → ∞, where we used the facts that q˜a (Ξ) = 1 on the set ˜ a (r) = {Ξ ∈ X |Ξa |1 2 + r#(a) /2 ≥ |Ξb |1 2 + r#(b) Ω Q
for any b ∈ A such that b ( a or a ( b} ,
˜ a (r). Thus, by virtue of and b∈A¯a 1ω˜ a,b (r) (Ξ) is the characteristic function of Ω + the existence of (4.9), we see that Wa exists. Now we note that one can prove the closedness of the ranges of Wa+ , a ∈ A(amax ), their mutual orthogonality and X M Ran Wa± ⊂ L2c (H) a∈A(amax )
in the same way as in the case for many body Schr¨ odinger operators without external electromagnetic fields. Finally we prove the asymptotic completeness. We first claim that letting f ∈ C0∞ (R) as in Corollary 2.2, we have for any real-valued h ∈ C0∞ (R) ˇ + f (H)h(N0 ) = 0 W amax
(4.10)
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
236
00113
T. Adachi
with sufficiently small r > 0 in the definition of {˜ qa (Ξ) | a ∈ A}. In fact, by virtue of Theorem 3.11, we have only to take r > 0 so small that r < ε0 2 , where ε0 > 0 is as in Theorem 3.11. Now we prove the asymptotic completeness by induction with respect to N ≥ 2. First we note that in the case when N = 2, the asymptotic completeness was proved in [1]. Assume that the asymptotic completeness holds for M -body systems in which there exists only one charged particle with 2 ≤ M < N . By a density argument, we have only to consider ψ ∈ L2c (H) such that ψ = h(N0 )ψ ,
ψ = f (H)ψ
with h ∈ C0∞ (R) and f ∈ C0∞ (R) as in Corollary 2.2. Here we also notice that Θ ∪ σpp (H) is a closed countable set (see Theorem 2.1). If we take r > 0 so small that r < ε0 2 , we see that X Ξ e−itH ψ q˜a e−itH ψ = t a∈A X ˇ + ψ + o(1) = e−itHa W a (4.11) a∈A(amax )
=
X
X
ˇ +ψ + e−itHa P a W a
a∈A(amax )
ˇ + ψ + o(1) e−itHa (Id − P a )W a
a∈A(amax )
as t → ∞. Here we used Proposition 3.4, the existence of the Deift–Simon wave ˇ + , and (4.10). For any ε > 0, there exist a finite number of ψ˜a ∈ operators W a j L2 (X a,n ), ψˆja ∈ L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ), ψa,j ∈ L2 (Ya,n ) ⊗ L2 (Za ) such that
X O O
ˇ+ (4.12) ψ˜ja ψˆja ψa,j < ε .
Wa ψ −
j:finite
Now one can apply the asymptotic completeness for K a and H C#(a) , where we odinger operator without external recall that K a is an (N − #(C#(a) ))-body Schr¨ electromagnetic fields in the center of mass frame, and H C#(a) is the #(C#(a) )-body Hamiltonian under consideration. We also note that the asymptotic completeness for K a under the condition (SR) was already obtained by several authors (see e.g. [19], [11] and [23]). For any a = {C1 , . . . , C#(a) } ∈ A(amax ) with {N } ⊂ C#(a) , we put an = {C1 , . . . , C#(a)−1 } and ac = {C#(a) }. Let Ana be the set of all cluster decompositions S#(a)−1 Cj such that bn ⊂ an , and Aca be the set of all cluster decompositions bn of j=1 c b of C#(a) such that bc ⊂ ac . Put Ana (an ) = Ana \ {an } and Aca (ac ) = Aca \ {ac }. Taking account of that the asymptotic completeness for H C#(a) , a ∈ A(amax ), holds by the assumption of induction, we have X M ˜ + (K a , K an ) (4.13) Ran (Id − P˜ a ) = Ran W b n bn ∈An a (a )
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
237
with ˜ + (K a , Kban ) = s - lim eitK a e−itKban P˜ban W t→∞
an bn
on L2 (X a,n ), where Kban = K a − I˜ n I˜ban =
with X Vl1 l2 (xl1 − xl2 ) ,
(l1 ,l2 )⊂an (l1 ,l2 )6⊂bn
P˜ban = P˜ban ⊗ Id is the eigenprojection for the subsystem Hamiltonian associated with Kban , as well as X M ˆ + (H C#(a) , H Cc#(a) ) (4.14) Ran (Id − Pˆ a ) = Ran W b bc ∈Aca (ac )
with ˆ + (H C#(a) , H Cc#(a) ) = s - lim eitH W b t→∞
C
C#(a)
C#(a)
e−itHbc
Pˆbac
c
on L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ), where Hbc#(a) = H C#(a) − Iˆbac with X c Vl1 l2 (xl1 − xl2 ) , Iˆbac = (l1 ,l2 )⊂ac (l1 ,l2 )6⊂bc C Pˆbac is the eigenprojection for Hbc#(a) , which is defined in the same way as P a ˜ bn ,j ∈ L2 (X a,n ), bn ∈ An (an ), such that associated with Ha . Thus there exist Φ a X ˜ bn ,j ˜ + (K a , K an )Φ (4.15) W (Id − P˜ a )ψ˜ja = b n bn ∈An a (a )
ˆ bc ,j ∈ L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ), bc ∈ Ac (ac ), such that by (4.13), and there exist Φ a X C ˆ bc ,j ˆ + (H C#(a) , H c#(a) )Φ (4.16) W (Id − Pˆ a )ψˆja = b bc ∈Aca (ac )
by (4.14). Thus, taking account of O O O O O (Id− Pˆ a )+(Id− P˜ a ) Pˆ a + P˜ a Id Id− P˜ a Pˆ a = (Id− P˜ a ) (Id− Pˆ a ) , we have as t → ∞ X ˇ a+ ψ + o(1) + O(ε) e−itH ψ = e−itHa P a W a∈A(amax )
+
X
X
n n n b ∈Aa (a ) a∈A(amax ) j:finite
O
˜ + (K a , Kban )Φ ˜ bn ,j e−itHa (W
bc ∈Aca (ac )
ˆ bc ,j ⊗ ψa,j ) ˆ + (H C#(a) , H Cc#(a) )Φ W b
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
238
00113
T. Adachi
+
X
˜ + (K a , Kban )Φ ˜ bn ,j e−itHa (W
O
Pˆ a ψˆja
O
ψa,j )
n bn ∈An a (a )
+
X
e−itHa (P˜ a ψ˜ja
O
ˆ bc ,j ˆ + (H C#(a) , H Cc#(a) )Φ W b
bc ∈Aca (ac )
O
ψa,j ) . (4.17)
c n n c c c B1 , . . . , B#(b For bn = {B1n , . . . , B#(b n ) } ∈ Aa and b = c ) } ∈ Aa , we write n c c bn + bc = {B1n , . . . , B#(b n ) , B1 , . . . , B#(bc ) } ∈ Aa = {b ∈ A | b ⊂ a} .
We note that, for bn ∈ Ana and bc ∈ Aca , we see that bn + bc , bn + ac , an + bc ∈ A(a) = ˜ + (K a , K an ) {b1 ∈ A | b1 ( a} = Aa \ {a}. Taking account of the definition of W b C ˆ + (H C#(a) , H c#(a) ), and rearranging some terms in (4.17) with respect to and W b b ∈ A(a), we have as t → ∞ X ˇ a+ ψ e−itHa P a W e−itH ψ = a∈A(amax )
+
X
X
e−itHb P b (ψjb
O
ψa,j ) + o(1) + O(ε)
(4.18)
a∈A(amax ) b∈A(a) j:finite
N with some ψjb ∈ L2 (X a,n ) L2 (R2×#(C#(a) ) × Z C#(a) ). Multiplying both sides of (4.18) by eitH and taking t → ∞, we have X X X O ˇ +ψ + Wa+ W Wb+ (ψjb (4.19) ψ= ψa,j ) + O(ε) . a a∈A(amax )
a∈A(amax ) b∈A(a) j:finite
Since one can take ε > 0 arbitrary, this implies X M Ran Wa+ , ψ∈ a∈A(amax )
by virtue of the closedness of the ranges of Wa+ , a ∈ A(amax ). The proof is completed. Remark 4.1. If one follows the argument of [5] and [6], one can first prove the existence of the asymptotic velocity s -C∞ - lim eitH t→∞
Ξ −itH e , t
and after that, one can show the asymptotic completeness for the system under consideration by using this asymptotic velocity. Though we have not used this asymptotic observable here, it seems to be very useful in the study of long-range scattering for the system under consideration.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
00113
Spectral and Scattering Theory
239
Acknowledgments I would like to express my deep gratitude to Professor Christian G´erard for his valuable comments as well as his hospitality, because a part of the contents of this ´ paper was developed during my staying at the Ecole Polytechnique. This work was supported by the Ministry of Education, Science, Sports, and Culture, the Government of Japan. References [1] T. Adachi, “Scattering theory for a two-body quantum system in a constant magnetic field”, J. Math. Sci. Univ. Tokyo 8 (2001) 243–274. [2] J. Avron, I. W. Herbst and B. Simon, “Schr¨ odinger operators with magnetic fields. I. General interactions”, Duke Math. J. 45 (1978) 847–883. [3] J. Avron, I. W. Herbst and B. Simon, “Separation of center of mass in homogeneous magnetic fields”, Ann. Phys. 114 (1978) 431–451. [4] H. Cycon, R. G. Froese, W. Kirsch and B. Simon, Schr¨ odinger Operators with Application to Quantum Mechanics and Global Geometry, Springer-Verlag, 1987. [5] J. Derezi´ nski, “Asymptotic completeness of long-range N -body quantum systems”, Ann. Math. 138 (1993) 427–476. [6] J. Derezi´ nski and C. G´erard, Scattering Theory of Classical and Quantum N -Particle Systems, Springer-Verlag, 1997. [7] R. Froese and I. W. Herbst, “A new proof of the Mourre estimate”, Duke Math. J. 49 (1982) 1075–1085. [8] C. G´erard and I. Laba, “Scattering theory for N -particle systems in constant magnetic fields”, Duke Math. J. 76 (1994) 433–465. [9] C. G´erard and I. Laba, “Scattering theory for N -particle systems in constant magnetic fields, II. Long-range interactions”, Comm. Partial Ditterential Equations 20 (1995) 1791–1830. [10] C. G´erard and I. Laba, “Scattering theory for 3-particle systems in constant magnetic fields: Dispersive case”, Ann. Inst. Fourier, Grenoble 46 (1996) 801–876. [11] G. M. Graf, “Asymptotic completeness for N -body short-range quantum systems: a new proof”, Comm. Math. Phys. 132 (1990) 73–101. [12] B. Helffer and J. Sj¨ ostrand, Equation de Schr¨ odinger avec Champ Magn´etique et ´ Equation de Harper, Lecture Notes in Physics 345, Springer-Verlag 1989, 118–197. [13] A. Jensen and S. Nakamura, “The 2D Schr¨ odinger equation for a neutral pair in a constant magnetic field”, Ann. Inst. Henri Poincar´e — Phys. Th´eor. 67 (1997) 387–410. [14] I. Laba, “Scattering for hydrogen-like systems in a constant magnetic field”, Comm. Partial Ditterential Equations 20 (1995) 741–762. [15] I. Laba, “Multiparticle quantum systems in constant magnetic fields”, pp. 147–215 in Multiparticle Quantum Scattering with Applications to Nuclear, Atomic and Molecular Physics, Minneapolis, MN, 1995, IMA Vol. Math. Appl., 89, Springer-Verlag 1997. [16] E. Mourre, “Absence of singular continuous spectrum for certain self-adjoint operators”, Comm. Math. Phys. 78 (1981) 391–408. [17] P. Perry, I. M. Sigal and B. Simon, “Spectral analysis of N -body Schr¨ odinger operators”, Ann. Math. 114 (1981) 517–567. [18] M. Reed and B. Simon, Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics I–IV, Academic Press.
February 4, 2002 11:31 WSPC/148-RMP
240
00113
T. Adachi
[19] I. M. Sigal and A. Soffer, “The N -particle scattering problem: asymptotic completeness for short-range systems”, Ann. Math. 125 (1987) 35–108. [20] I. M. Sigal and A. Soffer, “Long-range many body scattering: Asymptotic clustering for Coulomb type potentials”, Invent. Math. 99 (1990) 115–143. [21] E. Skibsted, “On the asymptotic completeness for particles in constant electromagnetic fields”, pp. 286–320 in Partial Differential Equations and Mathematical Physics Copenhagen, 1995; Lund, 1995, Progr. Nonlinear Differential Equations Appl., 21, Birkh¨ auser 1996. [22] E. Skibsted, “Asymptotic completeness for particles in combined constant electric and magnetic fields, II”, Duke Math. J. 89 (1997) 307–350. [23] D. Yafaev, “Radiation conditions and scattering theory for N -particle Hamiltonians”, Comm. Math. Phys. 154 (1993) 523–554.
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 3 (2001) 241–272 c World Scientific Publishing Company
QUANTUM STOCHASTIC ANALYSIS VIA WHITE NOISE OPERATORS IN WEIGHTED FOCK SPACE
DONG MYUNG CHUNG∗ Department of Mathematics, Sogang University Seoul, 121-742 Korea UN CIG JI∗ Department of Mathematics, College of Natural Science Chungbuk National University, Cheongju, 361-763 Korea NOBUAKI OBATA† Graduate School of Information Sciences, Tohoku University Sendai, 980-8579 Japan
Received 9 May 2000 Revised 17 August 2001 White noise theory allows to formulate quantum white noises explicitly as elemental quantum stochastic processes. A traditional quantum stochastic differential equation of Itˆ o type is brought into a normal-ordered white noise differential equation driven by lower powers of quantum white noises. The class of normal-ordered white noise differential equations covers quantum stochastic differential equations with highly singular noises such as higher powers or higher order derivatives of quantum white noises, which are far beyond the traditional Itˆ o theory. For a general normal-ordered white noise differential equation unique existence of a solution is proved in the sense of white noise distribution. Its regularity properties are investigated by means of weighted Fock spaces interpolating spaces of white noise distributions and associated characterization theorems for S-transform and for operator symbols. Keywords: White noise theory; Fock space; quantum stochastic differential equation; normal-ordered white noise differential equation; quantum white noise; Wick product. Mathematics Subject Classification 2000: Primary: 60H40; Secondary: 34G10, 46A32, 46F25, 81S25.
Introduction Quantum stochastic differential equations have attracted the interest of both physicists and mathematicians for many years. They serve a useful tool for the study of ∗ Partially
supported by Korea Research Foundation Grant (KRF-2000-015-DP0016). supported by Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (No. 12440036), Ministry of Education, Japan. † Partially
241
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
242
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
noisy quantum systems appearing in many branches of quantum physics, e.g. quantum open systems, quantum measurement theory, quantum optics, quantum information, and so on, see e.g. [1, 9]. The mathematical basis of quantum stochastic differential equations was first given by Hudson and Parthasarathy [16], where the role of Brownian motion in the classical Itˆo theory was played by three quantum stochastic processes (annihilation, creation and number processes) and the concept of quantum stochastic integration of Itˆ o type was established. Since then the Hudson–Parthasarathy approach has developed considerably as a quantum extension of the traditional Itˆ o theory, for a comprehensive account see the books by Meyer [22] and by Parthasarathy [30], see also [29]. Meanwhile, the white noise theory (Hida calculus), originally aiming at extension of Itˆo theory keeping contact with L´evy’s stochastic variational calculus [11], has developed considerably into an infinite dimensional analysis with a wide range of applications [12, 17, 21] and references therein. Among others, the significant feature that the pointwisely defined creation and annihilation operators (quantum white noise process) were formulated as continuous operators on white noise functions sublimated into the white noise operator theory [24] and brought a new approach to quantum stochastic analysis [5, 14, 15, 25, 26]. This approach enables us to discuss very singular (nonlinear) noises involving higher powers or higher order derivatives of quantum white noises and nonlinear extension of stochastic analysis. Moreover, together with the stochastic limit of quantum theory due to Accardi, Lu and Volovich [2], which reveals a mechanism of emerging a quantum stochastic differential equation (in a broad sense) from a standard Hamiltonian model, white noise approach is expected to be a clue to go beyond the traditional Itˆ o theory. In this paper we focus on white noise approach to quantum stochastic analysis. A typical quantum stochastic differential equation (QSDE) of Hudson–Parthasarathy type is of the form: dX = (L1 dAt + L2 dA∗t + L3 dΛt + L4 dt)X ,
X(0) = I ,
(0.1)
where {At }, {A∗t } and {Λt } are respectively the annihilation process, the creation process and the number process. As these processes are originally (unbounded) operators acting in the Fock space Γ(L2 (R)), on a suitably prepared Gelfand triple: W ⊂ Γ(L2 (R)) ⊂ W ∗ , they can be formulated as continuous operators from W into W ∗ , i.e. within the space L(W, W ∗ ). In general, a member of L(W, W ∗ ) is called a white noise operator, which is expected to play a role of a “generalized observable” in Fock space Γ(HC ). This idea shares a common spirit with the so-called rigged Hilbert space formalism for quantum mechanics, see e.g. [4]. It is noteworthy that d At = at , dt
d ∗ A = a∗t , dt t
d Λt = a∗t at , dt
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
243
hold in L(W, W ∗ ), where at and a∗t are the annihilation and creation operators at a point t ∈ R. With these machinery (0.1) is translated into an equation for white noise operators: dX = (L1 at + L2 a∗t + L3 a∗t at + L4 ) X , X(0) = I , dt where stands for the Wick product (normal-ordered product). A significance here is that the stochastic equation (0.1) is equivalent to a simple ordinary differential equation for white noise operators. From the mathematical aspect it is more natural to consider a linear differential equation for white noise operators of the form: dΞ = Lt Ξ , Ξ(0) = I , (0.2) dt where {Lt } is a quantum stochastic process in the sense of white noise operators, i.e. we only assume that t 7→ Lt ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) is a continuous map defined on an interval. An equation of the form (0.2) is called a normal-ordered white noise differential equation (NOWNDE ). We emphasize that the seemingly simple linear equation (0.2) already covers a quantum stochastic differential equation with very singular driving noises that are not handled by the traditional Itˆ o theory. As we have established general existence of a unique solution to (0.2) as white noise operators [6, 27, 28], regularity properties of the solution are to be discussed next. In particular, we need a systematic answer to the question when the “distributionvalued” solution becomes a process with values in operators acting in a certain Hilbert space. In this paper, introducing weighted Fock spaces (a particular class of interacting Fock spaces [2]) interpolating spaces of white noise distributions, we shall discuss regularity properties of a solution and improve preliminary results in [7]. This paper is organized as follows: In Sec. 1 we recall standard notations in white noise distribution theory due to Cochran, Kuo and Sengupta [8]. Moreover, we state, in terms of its S-transform, a sufficient criterion for a white noise distribution to belong to a weighted Fock space. In Sec. 2 we study the white noise operators. A sufficient condition for a general white noise operator to be an operator in a certain weighted Fock space is obtained by refining the famous characterization theorem for operator symbols. In Sec. 3 we introduce the Wick product and explain the relation between quantum stochastic differential equations and normal-ordered white noise differential equations. In Sec. 4 regularity properties of the Wick exponential of a white noise operator are studied in detail. The results are applied to a normalordered white noise differential equation and a proper Hilbert space is specified for the solution. General Notation. For locally convex spaces X, Y let L(X, Y) denote the space of continuous operators from X into Y. It is always assumed that L(X, Y) is equipped with the topology of uniform convergence on every bounded subset. If X is a real space, its complexification is denoted by XC .
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
244
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
1. White Noise Distribution Theory 1.1. Gaussian space and Brownian motion In order to realize a Brownian motion we start with the real Gelfand triple: E = S(R) ⊂ H = L2 (R, dt) ⊂ E ∗ = S 0 (R) ,
(1.1)
where S(R) is the space of rapidly decreasing functions, and S 0 (R) the space of tempered distributions. The canonical bilinear form on E ∗ ×E and the inner product of H are denoted by the common symbol h· , ·i since they are compatible. The norm of H is denoted by | · |0 . We shall introduce the canonical topology of E = S(R) by means of Hilbertian norms. For p ∈ R we put |ξ|p = |Ap ξ|0 ,
ξ ∈H,
A = 1 + t2 −
d2 . dt2
Then, for p ≥ 0 the set Ep = {ξ ∈ H; |ξ|p < ∞} becomes a Hilbert space with norm | · |p . While, E−p denotes the completion of H with respect to the norm | · |−p . Note that Ep and E−p are dual each other. With these notations we have E ∗ = S 0 (R) = ind lim E−p .
E = S(R) = proj lim Ep ,
(1.2)
p→∞
p→∞
There exists an orthonormal basis {ei }∞ i=0 ⊂ E of H such that Aei = (2i + 2)ei , i ≥ 0. The constant numbers ρ = kA−1 kOP =
1 , 2
kA−q k2HS =
∞ X i=0
1 < ∞, (2i + 2)2q
q>
1 , 2
play an important role in norm estimates throughout. It follows from the Bochner–Minlos theorem that there exists a probability measure µ on E ∗ such that Z 2 eihx,ξi µ(dx) , ξ ∈ E . e−|ξ|0 /2 = E∗
This µ is called the standard Gaussian measure and the probability space (E ∗ , µ) the Gaussian space. By the standard L2 -approximation we can define a family of random variables: Bt (x) = hx, 1[0,t] i ,
x ∈ E∗ ,
t ≥ 0.
(1.3)
As is easily verified, {Bt ; t ≥ 0} ⊂ L2 (E ∗ , µ) and B0 (x) = 0 ,
E(Bt ) = 0 ,
E(Bs Bt ) = min{s, t} ,
that is, {Bt } is a (realization of) Brownian motion. The white noise process {Wt } is formally defined as the time derivative of Brownian motion: Wt (x) =
d Bt (x) = hx, δt i . dt
The rigorous meaning of the above expression will be given in Sec. 1.3.
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
245
1.2. Weighted Fock space b be the n-fold symmetric tensor power of H and their norms are For n ≥ 0 let H ⊗n denoted by the common symbol | · |0 . Given a sequence α = {α(n)}∞ n=0 of positive numbers we put ( ) ∞ X b ∞ 2 2 ⊗n n!α(n)kfn |0 < ∞ . Γα (H) = φ = (fn )n=0 ; fn ∈ H , kφ k0,+ ≡ n=0
Then Γα (H) becomes a Hilbert space and is called a weighted Fock space. The (Boson) Fock space is the special case of α(n) ≡ 1 and is denoted by Γ(H). For two sequences of positive numbers α = {α(n)} and β = {β(n)} we write β ≺ α if there exists a positive number C > 0 such that β(n) ≤ Cα(n) for all n ≥ 0. With these notation, we easily see the following Lemma 1.1. Assume that a Hilbert space K2 is imbedded in another Hilbert space K1 and the inclusion map K2 ,→ K1 is a contraction. Let α = {α(n)} and β = {β(n)} be two positive sequences such that β ≺ α. Then we have continuous inclusions with dense images: Γα (K2 ) ,→ Γβ (K2 ) ,→ Γβ (K1 ) . Moreover, the second inclusion is a contraction. 1.3. CKS-space For a positive sequence α = {α(n)} we consider the following four conditions: (A1) α(0) = 1 and inf n≥0 α(n)σ n > 0 for some σ ≥ 1; 1/n = 0; (A2) limn→∞ { α(n) n! } (A3) α is equivalent to a positive sequence γ = {γ(n)} such that {γ(n)/n!} is log-concave; m+n α(m + n) for all (A4) there exists a constant C1α > 0 such that α(m)α(n) ≤ C1α m, n. The generating function of the sequence α = {α(n)} defined by Gα (t) =
∞ X α(n) n t n! n=0
is entire due to condition (A2). Condition (A3) is necessary and sufficient for the power series ∞ X n2n Gα (s) n ˜ α (t) = inf t G n!α(n) s>0 sn n=0 to have a positive radius of convergence Rα > 0. Condition (A4) implies that there exists a constant C3α > 0 such that m α(m) , α(n) ≤ C3α
0 ≤ n ≤ m,
see [3, 19]. The following results are then easily verified.
(1.4)
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
246
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
Proposition 1.2. Let α = {α(n)} be a positive sequence satisfying (A2), and Gα (t) the generating function defined therein. Then, (1) Gα (0) = 1 and Gα (s) ≤ Gα (t) for 0 ≤ s ≤ t; (2) γ[Gα (t) − 1] ≤ Gα (γt) − 1 for any γ ≥ 1 and t ≥ 0. With additional condition (A4), we have (3) es Gα (t) ≤ Gα (C3α (s + t)) for s, t ≥ 0, in particular, et ≤ Gα (C3α t) for t ≥ 0, where the constant C3α is given in (1.4); (4) Gα (s)Gα (t) ≤ Gα (C1α (s + t)) for s, t ≥ 0. From now on we always assume that a weight sequence α = {α(n)} satisfies conditions (A1)–(A3). In fact, conditions (A1)–(A3) are necessary for basic characterization theorems for S-transform and for operator symbols, and condition (A4) for another essential properties of white noise operators. However, those conditions are not yet down to the minimum and an almost ultimate (but somehow implicit) description has been investigated in terms of a function Gα or another function controlling growth rate, see [3, 10]. Now we shall construct the space of white noise distributions. For the Hilbert space Ep defined in Sec. 1.1 consider the weighted Fock space Γα (Ep ) and according to (1.2) define Γα (E) = proj lim Γα (Ep ) . p→∞
It is easily shown that Γα (E) is a nuclear space whose topology is given by the family of norms: kφk2p,+ =
∞ X
n!α(n)|fn |2p ,
φ = (fn ) ,
p ≥ 0.
n=0
By a standard argument we see that Γα (E)∗ ∼ = ind lim Γα−1 (E−p ) , p→∞
where Γα (E)∗ carries the strong dual topology and ∼ = stands for a topological isomorphism. Then, by taking the complexification, we obtain a complex Gelfand triple: Wα ≡ Γα (EC ) ⊂ Γ(HC ) ⊂ Γα (EC )∗ ≡ Wα∗ ,
(1.5)
where the middle space is the usual Fock space over HC . Recall the famous Wiener–Itˆo–Segal isomorphism between Γ(HC ) and 2 L (E ∗ , µ), which is a unitary isomorphism uniquely determined by the correspondence: ξ ⊗n ξ ⊗2 ,..., , . . . ↔ φξ (x) = ehx,ξi−hξ,ξi/2 , ξ ∈ EC . 1, ξ, 2! n!
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
247
The above element is called an exponential vector or a coherent state (though not normalized to have norm one), and is denoted by the common symbol φξ . The Gelfand triple obtained from (1.5) through the Wiener–Itˆ o–Segal isomorphism is denoted also by Wα ⊂ L2 (E ∗ , µ) ⊂ Wα∗ .
(1.6)
In this context, elements of Wα and of Wα∗ are called a white noise test function and a white noise distribution, respectively. The Gelfand triple (1.6) is referred to as the Cochran–Kuo–Sengupta space (or CKS-space for short) with weight sequence α = {α(n)}. When there is no danger of confusion, we write W = Wα for simplicity. The canonical bilinear form on W ∗ × W is denoted by hh· , ·ii. Then hhΦ, φii =
∞ X
n!hFn , fn i ,
Φ = (Fn ) ∈ W ∗ ,
φ = (fn ) ∈ W ,
n=0
and it holds that |hhΦ, φii| ≤ kΦk−p,− kφkp,+ , where kΦk2−p,− =
∞ X n! |Fn |2−p , α(n) n=0
Φ = (Fn ) .
The following result, whose proof is easy, highlights one of the essential features of the space of white noise distributions (1.6). Proposition 1.3. Let {Bt } be the Brownian motion defined in (1.3). Then, for any α satisfying (A1)–(A3), the map t 7→ Bt ∈ Wα∗ is infinitely many times differentiable in Wα∗ . Thus the time derivative of Brownian motion: Wt =
d Bt dt
is defined in Wα∗ and t 7→ Wt ∈ Wα∗ is also infinitely many times differentiable. In that case, {Wt } is called the white noise process. Here are some important examples of CKS-spaces Wα with α satisfying conditions (A1)–(A4). The CKS-space corresponding to α(n) ≡ 1 is called the Hida– Kubo–Takenaka space [20] and is denoted by Wα = (E) ,
α(n) ≡ 1 .
˜ The one corresponding to α(n) = β(n) = (n!)β , 0 ≤ β < 1, is called the Kondratiev– Streit space [18] and is denoted by Wβ˜ = (E)β ,
˜ β(n) = (n!)β ,
0 ≤ β < 1.
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
248
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
Another important examples are constructed from the kth order Bell numbers {Bk (n)} defined by k−times
z }| { ∞ X Bk (n) n exp(exp(· · · (exp t) · · ·)) = t , GBell(k) (t) = exp(exp(· · · (exp 0) · · ·)) n=0 n! for more details see [8]. We here only mention a simple recurrence formula: GBell(k+1) (t) = exp γk {GBell(k) (t) − 1} ,
k ≥ 1;
GBell(1) (t) = et ,
(1.7)
where k ≥ 1;
γk+1 = exp γk ,
γ1 = 1 .
1.4. Weighted Fock spaces interpolating CKS-space In addition to the Gelfand triple (1.1) consider another Hilbert spaces to construct weighted Fock spaces interpolating the CKS-space Wα ⊂ Γ(HC ) ⊂ Wα∗ . Let K ± be Hilbert spaces with norms | · |± and assume that the inclusions E ⊂ K + ⊂ H ⊂ K − ⊂ E∗ are all continuous, the inclusion K + ,→ H is a contraction, and K ± are dual each other with respect to H. For example, K + = Ep has this property for all p ≥ 0. Lemma 1.4. Let β be a positive sequence such that 1 ≺ β ≺ α. Then we have continuous inclusions with dense images: + − ) ⊂ Γ(HC ) ⊂ Γβ −1 (KC ) ⊂ Wα∗ . Wα ⊂ Γβ (KC
(1.8)
+ − ) and Γβ −1 (KC ) are dual each other with respect to Γ(HC ). Moreover, Γβ (KC
Proof. Since E ,→ K + is continuous, there exist C ≥ 0 and p0 ≥ 0 such that 0
|ξ|+ ≤ C|ξ|p0 ≤ Cρp−p |ξ|p ,
ξ ∈E,
p ≥ p0 .
Hence for a sufficiently large p ≥ 0 we have |ξ|+ ≤ |ξ|p , ξ ∈ E; in other words, Ep ,→ K + is a contraction. It then follows from Lemma 1.1 that Γα (Ep ) ,→ Γβ (K + ) + ). Again by Lemma 1.1 we see that is continuous, and hence so is Wα ,→ Γβ (KC + Γβ (KC ) ,→ Γ(HC ) is also continuous for 1 ≺ β. ± For simplicity the norms of Γβ ± (KC ) are denoted by k · k± , namely,
kφk2± =
∞ X n=0
n!β ±1 (n)|fn |2± ,
± φ = (fn ) ∈ Γβ ± (KC ).
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
249
1.5. S-transform For Φ ∈ W ∗ , the S-transform is defined by SΦ(ξ) = hhΦ, φξ ii ,
ξ ∈ EC .
Since the exponential vectors {φξ ; ξ ∈ EC } span a dense subspace of W, each Φ is uniquely specified by the S-transform. Obviously, the S-transform F = SΦ possesses the following properties: (F1) for each ξ, η ∈ EC , the function z 7→ F (zξ + η) is entire holomorphic on C; (F2) there exist C ≥ 0 and p ≥ 0 such that |F (ξ)|2 ≤ CGα (|ξ|2p ) ,
ξ ∈ EC .
In fact, (F2) follows by kφξ k2p,+ = Gα (|ξ|2p ). More important, the converse assertion is also true. This famous characterization theorem for S-transform was first proved for the Hida–Kubo–Takenaka space by Potthoff and Streit [31]. The following result is due to Cochran, Kuo and Sengupta [8]. Theorem 1.5. Let F be a C-valued function on EC . Then F is the S-transform of some Φ ∈ W ∗ if and only if F satisfies conditions (F1) and (F2). In that case, for any q > 1/2 with kA−q k2HS < Rα we have ˜ α (kA−q k2 ) . kΦk2−(p+q),− ≤ C G HS (Such a choice of q is always possible for limq→∞ kA−q kHS = 0.) − ) in (1.8) is characterized. For We then ask how the intermediate space Γβ −1 (KC this question we have only a sufficient condition, which is, however, enough for our discussion later.
Theorem 1.6. Let β = {β(n)} be a positive sequence satisfying conditions (A1)– (A3). Let F : EC → C be a function satisfying (F1) and assume that there exist + with Tr Q < Rβ C ≥ 0 and a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear form Q on KC such that |F (ξ)|2 ≤ CGβ (Q(ξ, ξ)) , Then there exists a unique Φ ∈
− ) Γβ −1 (KC
ξ ∈ EC .
such that F = SΦ. Moreover, in that case,
˜ β (Tr Q) . kΦk2− ≤ C G The proof is a simple modification of that of usual characterization theorems for S-transform [8, 31]. Remark 1.7. In fact, the “if part” of Theorem 1.5 (this is an essential part since the “only if part” is obvious) follows from Theorem 1.6. Fix q > 1/2 and put K + = Ep+q . Let {ei } ⊂ E be a complete orthonormal basis of H such that Aei = (2i + 2)ei . Define an operator Q0 by X hξ, ei i(2i + 2)−2q ei Q0 ξ = i
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
250
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
and a sesquilinear form on Ep+q by Q(ξ, η) = hAp+q Q0 ξ, Ap+q η i . Noting that {(2i + 2)−(p+q) ei } is a complete orthonormal basis of Ep+q , we may show easily that Q(ξ, ξ) = |ξ|2p ,
Tr Q = kA−q k2HS < ∞ ,
q>
1 . 2
Hence condition (F2) is equivalent to |F (ξ)|2 ≤ CGα (Q(ξ, ξ)), and the “if part” of Theorem 1.5 follows immediately from Theorem 1.6. Remark 1.8. As for the Kondratiev–Streit space Wα = (E)β , 0 ≤ β < 1, the function Gα (t) in Theorems 1.5 and 1.6 can be replaced with G(t) = exp t1/(1−β) , see [8]. 2. White Noise Operators A continuous operator Ξ : W → W ∗ is called a white noise operator and the space of such operators is denoted by L(W, W ∗ ). Note that L(W, W) and L(Γ(HC ), Γ(HC )) are subspaces of L(W, W ∗ ). Moreover, L(W ∗ , W ∗ ) is isomorphic to L(W, W) by duality. A general theory for white noise operators has been extensively developed in [5, 24, 26]. In this section we shall focus on regularity properties of a white noise operator in terms of weighted Fock space. 2.1. Quantum white noise process Let at and a∗t be the annihilation and creation operators at a point t ∈ R. For φ ∈ W we have at φ(x) = lim
θ→0
φ(x + θδt ) − φ(x) , θ
where the limit always exists for all t ∈ R and x ∈ E ∗ . It is known that at ∈ L(W, W) and a∗t ∈ L(W ∗ , W ∗ ). Moreover, the maps t 7→ at and t 7→ a∗t are both infinitely many times differentiable. The pair {at , a∗t } is referred to as the quantum white noise process. The annihilation, creation and the number processes are defined by Z t Z t Z t as ds , A∗t = a∗s ds , Λt = a∗s as ds . At = 0
0
0
(A precise definition is due to the argument in Sec. 2.2.) These are white noise operators and d At = at , dt
d ∗ A = a∗t , dt t
d Λt = a∗t at , dt
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
251
hold in L(W, W ∗ ). Moreover, Bt = At + A∗t ,
Wt = at + a∗t ,
where the left hand sides are regarded as multiplication operators from W into W ∗ . Thus, in white noise theory it is reasonable that a continuous map t 7→ Ξt ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) defined on an interval is called a quantum stochastic process. A “classical” stochastic process is then a continuous map t 7→ Φt ∈ W ∗ defined on an interval. In that case, as multiplication operators a classical stochastic process is regarded as a quantum stochastic process, see also Sec. 4.3. The quantum white noise process plays a role of “elemental” quantum stochastic processes, in this connection see [25]. 2.2. Integral kernel operators ⊗(l+m)
)∗ we shall define a white noise operator called an integral kernel For κ ∈ (EC operator with kernel distribution κ: Z κ(s1 , . . . , sl , t1 , . . . , tm )a∗s1 · · · a∗sl at1 · · · atm ds1 · · · dsl dt1 · · · dtm Ξl,m (κ) = Rl+m
though the integral is understood in a formal sense. For the precise definition we ⊗(l+m) ∗ ⊗(n+m) ) and f ∈ EC defined by need the right m-contraction of κ ∈ (EC ! X X hκ, e(j) ⊗ e(i)ihf, e(k) ⊗ e(i)i e(j) ⊗ e(k) , κ ⊗m f = j,k
i
where e(i) = ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ eim , e(j) = ej1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ejl , e(k) = ek1 ⊗ · · ·⊗ekn are respec⊗m ⊗l ⊗n , HC and HC . With these notation tively a complete orthonormal basis of HC we define (n + m)! κ ⊗m fn+m , φ = (fn ) ∈ W . Ξl,m (κ)φ = n! An integral kernel operator is always a white noise operator, that is, Ξl,m (κ) ∈ ⊗(l+m) ∗ ) . Moreover, if the weighted seL(W, W ∗ ) for an arbitrary kernel κ ∈ (EC quence α(n) fulfills conditions (A1)–(A4), then Ξl,m (κ) ∈ L(W, W) if and only if ⊗l ⊗m ∗ ⊗ (EC ) . For the proof of this result, in [5] the authors used the following κ ∈ EC property of the sequence {α(n)}: there exists a constant C2α > 0 such that for all m and n, m+n α(m)α(n) α(m + n) ≤ C2α
which is derived from condition (A3), see [3]. 2.3. Operator symbol The symbol of a white noise operator Ξ ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) is by definition a C-valued function on EC × EC defined by ˆ η) = hhΞφξ , φη ii , Ξ(ξ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
252
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
Every white noise operator is uniquely specified by its symbol. The symbol is related to the S-transform in an obvious manner: ˆ η) = S(Ξφξ )(η) = S(Ξ∗ φη )(ξ) . Ξ(ξ, ˆ of a white noise operator Ξ ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) As is easily verified, the symbol Θ = Ξ possesses the following properties: (O1) for any ξ, ξ1 , η, η1 ∈ EC the function (z, w) 7→ Θ(zξ + ξ1 , wη + η1 ) is entire holomorphic on C × C; (O2) there exist constant numbers C ≥ 0 and p ≥ 0 such that |Θ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ CGα (|ξ|2p )Gα (|η|2p ) ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
As in the case of S-transform, the characterization theorem for symbols, which was first proved in [23] for the Hida–Kubo–Takenaka space, is a significant consequence of white noise theory. The following result was proved in [5]. Theorem 2.1. A function Θ : EC × EC → C is the symbol of a white noise operator Ξ ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) if and only if Θ satisfies conditions (O1) and (O2). In that case ˜ 2α (kA−q k2HS )kφk2p+q,+ , kΞφk2−(p+q),− ≤ C G
φ∈W,
where q > 1/2 is taken as kA−q k2HS < Rα . For regularity properties of a white noise operator we prove the following Theorem 2.2. Let α = {α(n)} and β = {β(n)} be two sequences satisfying conditions (A1)–(A3). Let Θ : EC × EC → C be a function satisfying condition (O1). Assume that there exist C ≥ 0, p ≥ 0 and a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear + with Tr Q < Rβ such that form Q on KC |Θ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ CGα (|ξ|2p )Gβ (Q(η, η)) ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
− ˆ Moreover, in )) such that Θ = Ξ. Then there exists a unique Ξ ∈ L(Wα , Γβ −1 (KC −q 2 that case, for any q > 1/2 with kA kHS < Rα we have
˜ α (kA−q k2 )G ˜ β (Tr Q)kφk2 kΞφk2− ≤ C G HS p+q,+ . Proof. Let η ∈ EC be fixed and define a function Fη : EC → C by Fη (ξ) = Θ(ξ, η), ξ ∈ EC . Then Fη satisfies conditions (F1) and (F2). In fact, for any ξ, η ∈ EC |Fη (ξ)|2 ≤ CGβ (Q(η, η))Gα (|ξp2 ) . Therefore by Theorem 1.5 there exists a unique Φη ∈ Wα∗ such that S(Φη )(ξ) = Fη (ξ) = Θ(ξ, η) .
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
253
Moreover, for each q > 1/2 with kA−q |2HS < Rα we have ˜ α (kA−q k2 )Gβ (Q(η, η)) . kΦη k2−(p+q),− ≤ C G HS Now, fix φ ∈ Wα and define a function Gφ : EC → C by Gφ (η) = hhΦη , φii ,
η ∈ EC .
Then we can easily show that Gφ satisfies (F1) and the assumption in Theorem 1.6. − ) such that Therefore, by Theorem 1.6, there exists a unique Ψφ ∈ Γβ −1 (KC S(Ψφ )(η) = Gφ (η) = hhΦη , φii ,
η ∈ EC .
Moreover, we have ˜ α (kA−q k2HS )G ˜ β (Tr Q)kφk2p+q,+ . kΨφ k2− ≤ C G
(2.1)
− ) by Ξφ = Ψφ , φ ∈ Wα . It then follows Define a linear operator Ξ : Wα → Γβ −1 (KC − by (2.1) that Ξ ∈ L(Wα , Γβ −1 (KC )). That Θ is the symbol of Ξ is clear and we complete the proof.
Remark 2.3. As in the case of S-transform, Theorem 2.1 follows from Theorem 2.2. Moreover, for the Kondratiev–Streit space (E)β with 0 ≤ β < 1 the function Gα (t) in the above theorems can be replaced with exp t1/(1−β) . 3. Normal-Ordered White Noise Equations 3.1. Wick product of white noise operators Lemma 3.1. Assume that the weight sequence α = {α(n)} satisfies (A1)–(A4). For two white noise operators Ξ1 , Ξ2 ∈ L(Wα , Wα∗ ) there exists a unique operator Ξ ∈ L(Wα , Wα∗ ) such that ˆ 2 (ξ, η)e−hξ,ηi , ˆ η) = Ξ ˆ 1 (ξ, η)Ξ Ξ(ξ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
(3.1)
Proof. A simple application of Theorem 2.1. It is sufficient to show that a function Θ defined by ˆ 2 (ξ, η)e−hξ,ηi , ˆ 1 (ξ, η)Ξ Θ(ξ, η) = Ξ
ξ, η ∈ EC ,
satisfies conditions (O1) and (O2). In fact, (O1) being obvious, we shall obtain an estimate of Θ. By assumption there exist Cj ≥ 0 and pj ≥ 0 such that ˆ j (ξ, η)|2 ≤ Cj Gα (|ξ|2p )Gα (|η|2p ) , |Ξ j j
j = 1, 2 .
Since |ξ|p ≤ ρq |ξ|p+q ≤ |ξ|p+q , we have ˆ 2 (ξ, η)|2 ≤ CG2 (|ξ|2 )G2 (|η|2 ) , ˆ 1 (ξ, η)Ξ |Ξ α p α p
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
254
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
where C = C1 C2 and p = max{p1 , p2 }. Moreover, in view of |e−hξ,ηi |2 ≤ e2|ξ|0 |η|0 ≤ |e|ξ0 +|η|0 ≤ e|ξ|p +|η|p , 2
2
2
2
we obtain |Θ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ Ce|ξ|p G2α (|ξ|2p )e|η|p G2α (|η|2p ) . 2
2
By using Proposition 1.2 the above becomes |Θ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ CGα (C3α (2C1α + 1)|ξ|2p )Gα (C3α (2C1α + 1)|η|2p ) .
(3.2)
Choose q ≥ 0 with C3α (2C1α + 1)ρ2q ≤ 1 so that C3α (2C1α + 1)|ξ|2p ≤ C3α (2C1α + 1)ρ2q |ξ|2p+q ≤ |ξ|2p+q . Then (3.2) becomes |Θ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ CGα (|ξ|2p+q )Gα (|η|2p+q ) , which shows that Θ(ξ, η) satisfies condition (O2). The operator Ξ defined in (3.1) is called the Wick product of Ξ1 and Ξ2 , and is denoted by Ξ = Ξ1 Ξ2 . We note some simple properties: (Ξ1 Ξ2 ) Ξ3 = Ξ1 (Ξ2 Ξ3 ) ,
I Ξ = Ξ I = Ξ, ∗
(Ξ1 Ξ2 ) =
Ξ∗2
Ξ∗1
,
Ξ1 Ξ2 = Ξ2 Ξ1 .
Namely, equipped with the Wick product L(W, W ∗ ) becomes a commutative ∗algebra. As for the annihilation and creation operators we have as a∗t = a∗t as ,
a∗s a∗t = a∗s a∗t .
(3.3)
a∗s1 · · · a∗sl Ξat1 · · · atm = Ξ (a∗s1 · · · a∗sl at1 · · · atm ) ,
Ξ ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) .
(3.4)
a s at = as at ,
a∗s at = a∗s at ,
More generally, it holds that In fact, the Wick product is a unique bilinear map from L(W, W ∗ ) × L(W, W ∗ ) into L(W, W ∗ ) which is (i) separately continuous; (ii) associative; and (iii) satisfying (3.3). 3.2. Passage from QSDE to NOWNDE A typical quantum stochastic differential equation of Itˆ o type has the form: dX(t) = (L1 dAt + L2 dA∗t + L3 dΛt + L4 dt)X(t) ,
X(0) = I .
(3.5)
In fact, (3.5) is a short-hand notation for a stochastic integral equation of Itˆ o type and is equivalent to hhX(t)φξ , φη ii = hhφξ , φη ii Z t hh(ξ(s)L1 X(s) + η(s)L2 X(s) + ξ(s)η(s)L3 X(s) + 0
+ L4 X(s))φξ , φη ii ds ,
(3.6)
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
255
where ξ, η run over a certain dense subset of L2 (R). We here suppose that ξ, η ∈ EC . Since at φξ = ξ(t)φξ , the integral in (3.6) becomes Z t hh(L1 X(s)as + a∗s L2 X(s) + a∗s L3 X(s)as + L4 X(s))φξ , φη ii ds . 0
Then by reversing the above argument and by using the smoothness of s 7→ as ∈ L(W, W) we come to the differential equation: dX(t) = L1 X(t)at + L2 a∗t X(t) + L3 a∗t X(t)at + L4 X(t) , dt
X(0) = I .
(3.7)
Note that (3.7) is meaningful whenever t 7→ X(t) ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) is differentiable. Moreover, the right hand side is expressed by means of the Wick product. In fact, in view of (3.4) we see that (3.7) is equivalent to the following ordinary differential equation for white noise operators: dX(t) = (L1 at + L2 a∗t + L3 a∗t at + L4 ) X(t) , dt
X(0) = I .
More generally, it is natural to consider an equation of the form: dΞ = Lt Ξ , dt
Ξ(0) = I ,
(3.8)
where {Lt } is a quantum stochastic process, i.e. t 7→ Lt ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) is continuous. Equation (3.8) is generally called a normal-ordered white noise differential equation (NOWNDE). Consequently, a quantum stochastic differential equation of Itˆ o type (3.5) is brought into a normal-ordered white noise differential equation with coefficients involving only lower powers of quantum white noises. 3.3. Unique existence of a solution as white noise operators Recall that the space L(W, W ∗ ) is closed under the Wick product. Hence, a formal solution to (3.8) is given by the Wick exponential: Z t X n Z t ∞ 1 Ls ds = Ls ds , (3.9) Ξt = wexp n! 0 0 n=0 and our first task is to check its convergence in the sense of white noise operators. Several studies of the convergence of Wick exponential can be found in [28], see also [27]. As a general result, we have the following Theorem 3.2. Let α and ω be two weight sequences satisfying (A1)–(A4) and assume that their generating functions are related in such a way that Gω (t) = exp γ{Gα (t) − 1} ,
(3.10)
where γ > 0 is a certain constant. If t 7→ Lt ∈ L(Wα , Wα∗ ) is continuous, the solution is given by (3.9) and lies in L(Wω , Wω∗ ).
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
256
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
Proof. For each t ≥ 0 we put
Z Mt =
t
Ls ds 0
and consider a C-valued function Θt on EC × EC defined by ˆ t (ξ, η)} , Θt (ξ, η) = ehξ,ηi exp{e−hξ,ηi M
ξ, η ∈ EC .
Then condition (O1) is obviously satisfied. Condition (O2) is verified with a similar (but more tedious) argument as in the proof of Lemma 3.1 together with Proposition 1.2. It then follows from Theorem 2.1 that there exists Yt ∈ L(Wω , Wω∗ ) such that Yˆt = Θt . Finally, Yt = wexp Mt is easily verified. Then the assertion follows immediately. The relation (3.10) is motivated by the Bell numbers, see (1.7). 4. Regularity Properties in Terms of Weighted Fock Spaces 4.1. Main results Given a continuous map t 7→ Lt ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) defined on an interval (i.e. {Lt } is a quantum stochastic process), we shall discuss regularity properties of a solution to the initial value problem dΞ = Lt Ξ , Ξ(0) = I . dt Assume that Lt is a finite or infinite sum of integral kernel operators: X Ξl,m (λl,m (t)) . Lt =
(4.1)
(4.2)
l,m
(Every white noise operator L ∈ L(Wα , Wα∗ ) admits such an expansion if α satisfies ⊗(l+m) ∗ ) (A1)–(A4), for the proof see [5].) In that case, the map t 7→ λl,m (t) ∈ (EC is continuous, and so is Z t ⊗(l+m) ∗ λl,m (s) ds ∈ (EC ) . t 7→ κl,m (t) ≡ 0
Since the (formal) solution of (4.1) is given by X Ξl,m (κl,m (t)) , Ξt = wexp l,m
see (3.9), regularity properties of Ξt is described in terms of κl,m (t) instead of λl,m (t). In order to pick up κl,m (t) from (4.1) the following formula is useful: Z t X ˆ s (ξ, η) ds = L hκl,m (t), η ⊗l ⊗ ξ ⊗m i , (4.3) e−hξ,ηi 0
which is straightforward from (4.2).
l,m
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
257
Theorem 4.1. Assume that Lt is given by Lt =
n 1 X X
Z Ξl,m (λl,m (t)) ,
κl,m (t) ≡ 0
l=0 m=0
t
− ⊗l ⊗m ∗ λl,m (s) ds ∈ (KC ) ⊗ (EC ) .
− )) if 0 ≤ n ≤ 1; and in Then, the unique solution to (4.1) lies in L((E), Γ(KC − L((E)β , Γ(KC )) with β = 1 − 1/n if n ≥ 1. − ⊗l ⊗m ∗ ) ⊗ (EC ) for which there For l, m ≥ 0 let Kl,m be the space of κ ∈ (KC + exist a complete orthonormal basis {ζn } of KC , a non-negative sequence {an } ∈ `1 , and constant numbers C ≥ 0, p ≥ 0 such that
|hκ ⊗m ξ ⊗m , ζi1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ζil i| ≤ Cai1 · · · ail |ξ|m p ,
ξ ∈ EC .
(4.4)
For example, a finite linear combination of elements of the form f1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ fl ⊗ F , − ⊗m ∗ , F ∈ (EC ) , belongs to Kl,m . where f1 , . . . , fl ∈ KC Theorem 4.2. If Lt is of the form: Lt =
n k X X
Z Ξl,m (λl,m (t)) ,
κl,m (t) ≡
t
λl,m (s) ds ∈ Kl,m , 0
l=0 m=0
− )), where 0 ≤ β < 1 is then the unique solution to (4.1) lies in L((E)β , Γβ˜−1 (KC chosen in such a way that max{k + 1, k + n, 2n} = 2/(1 − β).
The proofs of Theorems 4.1 and 4.2 are deferred in Secs. 5.1 and 5.2, respectively. For the case where the coefficient {Lt } is an infinite series of integral kernel operators, we have ∗ ) be a continuous map and assume Theorem 4.3. Let t 7→ Lt ∈ L(WBell(k) , WBell(k) that Z t X − ⊗l ⊗m ∗ Ξl,m (λl,m (t)) , κl,m (t) ≡ λl,m (s) ds ∈ (KC ) ⊗ (EC ) . Lt = l,m
0
+ If there exist C ≥ 0, p ≥ 0 and a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear for Q on KC with Tr Q < RBell(k+1) such that
ˆ t (ξ, η)e−hξ,ηi |2 ≤ CGBell(k) (|ξ|2 )GBell(k) (Q(η, η)) , |L p
ξ, η ∈ EC ,
− )). then the unique solution to (4.1) lies in L(WBell(k+1) , ΓBell(k+1)−1 (KC
The proof is given in Sec. 5.3. There are many cases where similar results are obtained with our method, for some relevant results see the next section.
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
258
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
4.2. Examples Throughout this section formula (4.3) is taken into account. We start with a quantum stochastic differential equation of Hudson–Parthasarathy type (3.5). Proposition 4.4. The initial value problem (4.1) with Lt = L1 a∗t at + L2 at + L3 a∗t + L4 has a unique solution in L((E), Γ(HC )). Proof. For any ξ, η ∈ EC , we have Z t Z t Z t Z t −hξ,ηi ˆ Ls (ξ, η) ds = L1 ξ(s)η(s) ds + L2 ξ(s) ds + L3 η(s) ds + L4 t e 0
0
0
0
= L1 hM[0,t] ξ, ηi + L2 h1[0,t] , ξi + L3 h1[0,t] , ηi + L4 t ≡ hκ1,1 (t), η ⊗ ξi + hκ0,1 (t), ξi + hκ1,0 (t), ηi + κ0,0 (t) , where M[0,t] is the multiplication operator by the indicator function 1[0,t] of [0, t]. ∗ by the kernel theorem, with κ1,1 (t) ∈ Since M[0,t] ∈ L(EC , HC ) ∼ = HC ⊗ EC ∗ ∗ HC ⊗ EC . Obviously, κ0,1 (t) ∈ EC and κ1,0 (t) ∈ HC . Therefore it follows from Theorem 4.1 that the unique solution lies in L((E), Γ(HC )). Proposition 4.5. Let n ≥ 1. The initial value problem (4.1) with Lt =
n X
L0m am t +
m=0
n X
L1m a∗t am t
m=0
has a unique solution in L((E)β , Γ(HC )), where β = 1 − 1/n. Proof. For any ξ, η ∈ EC , we have Z t Z t Z t n n X X −hξ,ηi m ˆ Ls (ξ, η) ds = L0m ξ(s) ds + L1m η(s)ξ(s)m ds e 0
m=0
=
n X
0
m=0
L0m h1[0,t] , ξ m i +
m=0
n X
0
L1m hM[0,t] ξ m , ηi .
m=0
Then the assertion follows by a similar argument as in Proposition 4.4. Proposition 4.6. Let n ≥ 1 and assume that {Lt } involves higher order derivatives of quantum white noises in such a way that Lt =
n X m=0 (m)
m where ∇m t at = (−1) Ξ0,1 (δt
L0m ∇m t at +
n X
L1m a∗t ∇m t at ,
m=0
). Then the unique solution lies in L((E), Γ(HC )).
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
259
Proof. For any ξ, η ∈ EC , we have Z t Z t Z t n n X X ˆ s (ξ, η) ds = L L0m ξ (m) (s) ds + L1m η(s)ξ (m) (s) ds e−hξ,ηi 0
0
m=0
=
n X
0
m=0
L0m h1[0,t] , ξ (m) i +
m=0
n X
L1m hM[0,t] ξ (m) , ηi .
m=0
In view of dm ∈ L(EC , EC ) , dsm
M[0,t] ◦
dm ∈ L(EC , HC ) , dsm
we may derive the assertion by a similar argument as in Proposition 4.4. We now consider the case where {Lt } involves higher powers of quantum white noises in such a way that Lt =
n k X X
m Ll,m a∗l t at .
(4.5)
l=0 m=0
Then, by a similar argument as above we see that Theorem 4.2 with K − = E−p for a suitably chosen p > 0 can be applied. Below we prove a sharper result by a direct application of Theorem 2.2. P For a finite sum of integral kernel operators: Ξ = l,m Ξl,m (κl,m ) we put deg Ξ = max{l + m; Ξl,m (κl,m ) 6= 0} < ∞ . Such a white noise operator belongs to L(Wα , Wα∗ ) for all α satisfying (A1)–(A3). Proposition 4.7. Let {Ξt } be the unique solution to the initial value problem (4.1) with coefficient {Lt } given as in (4.5). Choose 0 ≤ β < 1 such that deg Lt ≤ 2/(1 − β). Then for any T > 0 there exists p > 1/2 such that {Ξt }0≤t≤T ⊂ L((E)β , Γβ˜−1 (E−p )). Proof. For any ξ, η ∈ EC , we have Z t n k X X ˆ s (ξ, η) ds = L Ll,m h1[0,t] ξ m , η l i . e−hξ,ηi 0
l=0 m=0
Since the pointwise multiplication of E = S(R) is continuous, for each l ≥ 1 there exist Cl ≥ 0 and pl ≥ 0 such that |ξ l |0 ≤ Cl |ξ|lpl . Therefore, for any l, m ≥ 1 and 0 > 0 we obtain l+m 0 l+m , |Ll,m h1[0,t] ξ m , η l i| ≤ |Ll,m |Cl Cm |η|lpl |ξ|m pm ≤ |ξ|rm + |η|ql
where we choose rm ≥ pm and ql ≥ pl in such a way that |Ll,m |Cl Cm ρ(rm −pm )m ≤ 1 and ρ(ql −pl )(l+m) ≤ 0 . Similarly, for any l ≥ 1 choose ql0 ≥ pl such that √ |Ll,0 h1[0,t] , η l i| ≤ |Ll,0 | T Cl |η|lpl ≤ 0 |η|lq0 , l
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
260
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
0 and for any m ≥ 1 choose rm ≥ pm such that √ m |L0,m h1[0,t] , ξ m i| ≤ |L0,m | T |Cm ξ|m 0 . pm ≤ |ξ|rm
Hence for any l, m ≥ 0 and 0 > 0 there exist C ≥ 0 and r, q ≥ 0 such that |Ll,m h1[0,t] ξ m , η l i| ≤ C + |ξ|dr + 0 |η|dq , where d = deg Lt and we used the fact that xα ≤ 1 + xβ for x ≥ 0 and 0 < α ≤ β. Now we define a sesquilinear form Q on Es+q,C , s > 1/2, by Q(ξ, η) = (0 (k + 1)(n + 1))2/d hAq ξ, Aq ηi . Then Q is a non-negative sesquilinear form with Tr Q = (0 (k + 1)(n + 1))2/d kA−s k2HS . For a given > 0, by taking 0 > 0 satisfying (0 (k + 1)(n + 1))2/d kA−s k2HS < we obtain Tr Q < and Z n k X X −hξ,ηi t ˆ s (ξ, η) ds ≤ e L |Ll,m h1[0,t] ξ m , η l i| 0
l=0 m=0
≤ C 0 + |ξ|r+r0 + Q(η, η)d/2 , d/2 0
where C 0 ≥ 0 and r0 ≥ 0 with (k + 1)(n + 1)ρr d/2 ≤ 1. The assertion is now immediate from Theorem 2.2. With a similar argument as in Theorem 4.2 we come to the following Proposition 4.8. The unique solution of dΞ = (a2t + a∗2 t ) Ξ, dt
Ξ(0) = I ,
lies in L((E), Γ(E−p )) with p ≥ 2. The last example is the case of deg Lt = ∞. Proposition 4.9. Let {Ξt } be the unique solution to the initial value problem (4.1) with Lt = wexp(a2t + a∗2 t ). Then there exists p > 2 such that {Ξt } ⊂ L(WBell(2) , ΓBell(2)−1 (E−p )). The proof is straightforward with the help of Theorem 2.2. Moreover, it is not difficult to determine p after tedious computation.
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
261
4.3. A classical case In [13] classical stochastic differential equations are extensively studied by means of Wick product and unique existence results are established in a distribution sense. To clarify classical–quantum relationship we introduce a multiplication operator by a white noise distribution. For each Φ ∈ W ∗ we define a multiplication operator MΦ by hhMΦ φ, ψii = hhΦ, φψii ,
φ, ψ ∈ W .
Since pointwise multiplication of test functions is a continuous bilinear map, we see easily that MΦ ∈ L(W, W ∗ ) and the map Φ 7→ MΦ is a continuous injection. Recall that the Wick product of white noise distributions Φ, Ψ ∈ W ∗ is defined by S(Φ Ψ)(ξ) = SΦ(ξ) · SΨ(ξ) ,
ξ ∈ EC .
It then follows by definition that MΦΨ = MΦ MΨ ,
Φ, Ψ ∈ W ∗ .
We now consider a normal-ordered white noise equation for white noise distributions: dXt = Φt X t , X 0 = Ψ , (4.6) dt where {Φt } is a classical stochastic process in a white noise sense, i.e. t 7→ Φt ∈ W ∗ is continuous, and Ψ ∈ W ∗ . An equation of the form (4.6) is studied in [13]. Associated with (4.6) we consider a NOWEDE given by dΞt = MΦt Ξt , dt
Ξ0 = I .
(4.7)
Since hh(MΦt Ξt )φ0 , φξ ii = hhMΦt φ0 , φξ iihhΞt φ0 , φξ ii = hhΦt , φξ iihhΞt φ0 , φξ ii = hhΦt (Ξt φ0 ), φξ ii , we have (MΦt Ξt )φ0 = Φt (Ξt φ0 ) . Therefore if a quantum stochastic process Ξt satisfies (4.7), then the classical process Xt ≡ (Ξt φ0 ) Ψ
(4.8)
satisfies (4.6). Thus our regularity results can be applied to the classical case (4.6) too. It is known [24] that the Fock expansion of a multiplication operator MΦ is given by MΦ =
∞ X (l + m)! Ξl,m (Fl+m ) , l!m!
l,m=0
(4.9)
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
262
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
where Φ = (Fn ) ∈ W ∗ . On the other hand, for each ξ, η ∈ EC ˆ Φ (ξ, η) = hhΦ, φξ φη ii = hhΦ, φξ+η iiehξ,ηi = SΦ(ξ + η)ehξ,ηi . M
(4.10)
With the help of (4.9) and (4.10) our conditions introduced in the previous sections are paraphrased in terms of Φt = (Fn (t)) which is the coefficient of the classical equation (4.6). ∗ is continuous and for For instance, assume that the map t 7→ Φt ∈ WBell(k) each n ≥ 0 Z t − ⊗n Fn (s) ds ∈ (KC ) , Gn (t) ≡ 0
and that there exist C ≥ 0, p ≥ 0 and a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear for Q + with Tr Q < RBell(k+1) such that on KC |SΦt (ξ + η)|2 ≤ CGBell(k) (|ξ|2p )GBell(k) (Q(η, η)) ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
− ). Then regApplying Theorem 4.3, wee see that Ξt φ0 belongs to ΓBell(k+1)−1 (KC ularity of the unique solution to (4.6) given by (4.8) can be specified according to the initial value Ψ. In this way, a classical stochastic differential equation involving singular noises such as quadratic powers of white noise can be discussed within our framework beyond the traditional Itˆ o theory. The solution lies not necessarily in the original Fock space but can be found in a weighted Fock space which is “singular” to the original Fock space.
5. Proofs of Main Theorems 5.1. Proof of Theorem 4.1 ⊗m ∗ ) there exist constant numbers C ≥ 0 Lemma 5.1. Let m ≥ 1. For any κ ∈ (EC and p ≥ 0 such that
|hκ, ξ ⊗m i| ≤ C + |ξ|2m p ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
Proof. Taking p ≥ 0 with |κ|−p < ∞ we see that |hκ, ξ ⊗m i| ≤ |κ|−p |ξpm | ≤ |κ|2−p + |ξ|2m p , as desired. − ⊗m ∗ Lemma 5.2. Let m ≥ 0. For any κ ∈ (KC ) ⊗ (EC ) and > 0, there exist constant numbers C ≥ 0, p ≥ 0, and a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear form Q + with Tr Q < such that on KC
|hκ, η ⊗ ξ ⊗m i| ≤ C + |ξ|2m p + Q(η, η) ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
263
− Proof. We first consider the case of κ ∈ KC . Since η 7→ hκ, ηi is a continuous + + linear form on KC , there exists κ0 ∈ KC such that
hκ, ηi = hη, κ0 i+ ,
+ η ∈ KC ,
+ . Note that |κ0 |+ = where the right hand side is the (hermitian) inner product of KC + |κ|0 . With this κ0 ∈ KC we define
Q0 η = hκ, ηiκ0 = hη, κ0 i+ κ0 ,
+ η ∈ KC .
+ with Tr Q0 = |κ0 |2+ = |κ|2− . Define a Obviously, Q0 is a trace class operator on KC + sesquilinear form Q on KC by
Q(ξ, η) = 1 hξ, Q0 ηi+ ,
+ ξ, η ∈ KC ,
with 1 < /|κ|2− . Then Tr Q = 1 Tr Q0 < and |hκ, ηi| ≤
1 1 + 1 |hκ, ηi|2 = + |Q(η, η) , 1 1
as desired. − ⊗m ∗ ⊗ (EC ) , where m ≥ 1. Let L ∈ We next consider the case of κ ∈ KC ⊗m − L(EC , KC ) be defined by hκ, η ⊗ ξ ⊗m i = hLξ ⊗m , ηi , ξ, η ∈ EC . P Then, inserting ξ = hξ, ei iei , we obtain X hξ, ei1 i · · · hξ, eim ihL(ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ eim ), ηi . hκ, η ⊗ ξ ⊗m i = i1 ,...,im
Hence, for any p ≥ 0 and 1 > 0 it follows from the Schwartz inequality that |hκ, η ⊗ ξ ⊗m i| 1/2 X 2 2p 2 2p |hξ, ei1 i (2i1 + 2) · · · |hξ, eim i| (2im + 2) ≤ i1 ,...,im
×
X
1/2 |hL(ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ eim ), ηi|2 (2i1 + 2)−2p · · · (2im + 2)−2p
i1 ,...,im
≤
X 1 2m |ξ|p + 1 |hL(A−p ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ A−p eim ), ηi|2 . 1 i ,...,i 1
(5.1)
m
+ by Define a non-negative sesquilinear form Q on KC X hL(A−p ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ A−p eim ), ξihL(A−p ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ A−p eim ), ηi . Q(ξ, η) = 1 i1 ,...,im
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
264
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
+ Let {ζj } be a complete orthonormal basis of KC . Then, X X X Q(ζj , ζj ) = 1 |hL(A−p ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ A−p eim ), ζj i|2 Tr Q = j
= 1
j
X X j
i1 ,...,im
|hκ, ζj ⊗ A−p ei1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ A−p eim i|2 = 1 |κ|21,m;−,−p ,
i1 ,...,im
where note that {A−p ei } is a complete orthonormal basis of Ep . By assumption one may choose p ≥ 0 such that |κ|1,m;−,−p < ∞. Moreover, we choose 1 > 0 and q ≥ 0 in such a way that 1 < /|κ|21,m;−,−p and ρ2qm /1 ≤ 1. Then, Tr Q < and (5.1) becomes |hκ, η ⊗ ξ ⊗m i| ≤ |ξ|2m p+q + Q(η, η) , which completes the proof. Lemma 5.3. Let p > r0 + 1/2, where r0 ≥ 0 is chosen in such a way that the inclusion Er0 ,→ K + is a contraction, and define Q(ξ, η) = hA−p ξ, A−p η i . + with Then Q is a sesquilinear form on KC
0 ≤ Tr Q ≤ kA−(p−r0 ) k2HS . Proof. We first note that such a choice of r0 ≥ 0 is always possible under the assumption posed in Sec. 1.4, see also the proof of Lemma 1.4. Then, in view of the chain of Hilbert spaces Ep ,→ Er0 ,→ K + ,→ H ,→ K − ,→ E−r0 ,→ E−p , we see that the natural inclusion map T : K + → E−r0 is a contraction. Moreover, S : Ep → Er0 is of Hilbert–Schmidt type with kSkHS = kA−(p−r0 ) kHS , hence so is + . Then S ∗ : E−r0 → E−p . Let {ζj } be a complete orthonormal basis of KC X X X Q(ζj , ζj ) = |A−p ζj |20 = |ζj |2−p . (5.2) Tr Q = j
j
With the help of |ζj |2−p = |S ∗ T ζj |2−p =
j
X
|hS ∗ T ζj , ei i|2 (2i + 2)−2p
i
=
X
|hζj , T ∗ Sei i|2 (2i + 2)−2p ,
i
we see that (5.2) becomes X XX |hζj , T ∗ Sei i|2 (2i + 2)−2p = |T ∗ Sei |2− (2i + 2)−2p . Tr Q = i
j
i
(5.3)
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
265
Since T ∗ is also a contraction, (5.3) is bounded by X X |Sei |2r0 (2i + 2)−2p = (2i + 2)2r0 (2i + 2)−2p = kA−(p−r0 ) k2HS , ≤ i
i
from which the assertion follows. Proposition 5.4. Let Ξ be a white noise operator of the form: Ξ=
n 1 X X
Ξl,m (κl,m ) ,
− ⊗l ⊗m ∗ κl,m ∈ (KC ) ⊗ (EC ) .
l=0 m=0 − )) for 0 ≤ n ≤ 1; and Then the Wick exponential wexp Ξ belongs to L((E), Γ(KC − )), where β = 1 − 1/n for n ≥ 2. belongs to L((E)β , Γ(KC
Proof. Assume that n ≥ 2. The proof for 0 ≤ n ≤ 1 is similar. The symbol of Ξ is given by ˆ η)} \Ξ(ξ, η) = ehξ,ηi exp{e−hξ,ηi Ξ(ξ, wexp ) ( n 1 X X ⊗l ⊗m hκl,m , η ⊗ ξ i , = exp hξ, ηi +
ξ, η ∈ EC .
l=0 m=0
Taking Theorem 2.2 and Remark 2.3 into account, we need only to derive an estimate of the form: \Ξ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ M exp{|ξ|2/(1−β) + Q(η, η)} , |wexp p
ξ, η ∈ EC ,
(5.4)
where M ≥ 0 and p ≥ 0 are constant numbers, and Q is a non-negative sesquilinear + with an arbitrarily small Tr Q. form on KC Given > 0 arbitrarily small, we take 0 < 1 < /(2n + 4). By Lemma 5.1, for each 0 ≤ m ≤ n there exist C0m ≥ 0 and pm ≥ 0 such that |hκ0,m , ξ ⊗m i| ≤ C0m + |ξ|2m pm ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
Similarly, by Lemma 5.2, there exist C1m ≥ 0, qm ≥ 0 and a bounded, non-negative + with Tr Qm < 1 such that sesquilinear form Qm on KC |hκ1,m , η ⊗ ξ ⊗m i| ≤ C1m + |ξ|2m qm + Qm (η, η) ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
Choose r0 ≥ 0 such that the inclusion Er0 ,→ K + is a contraction and fix q > r0 + 1/2 with kA−(q−r0 ) k2HS < 1 . Define p = max{q, pm , qm ; 0 ≤ m ≤ n}. Note an obvious inequality 2n ≤ |ξ|2m |ξ|2m r p ≤ 1 + |ξ|p ,
0 ≤ r ≤ p,
0 ≤ m ≤ n.
Then, replacing the constant numbers C0m , C1m with a larger C, we obtain |hκ0,m , ξ ⊗m i| ≤ C + |ξ|2n p ,
0 ≤ m ≤ n,
(5.5)
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
266
and |hκ1,m , η ⊗ ξ ⊗m i| ≤ C + |ξ|2n p + Qm (η, η) ,
0 ≤ m ≤ n.
(5.6)
Moreover, note that 2 |hξ, ηi| ≤ |ξ|p |η|−p ≤ |ξ|2p + |η|2−p ≤ 1 + |ξ|2n p + |η|−p .
(5.7)
Thus, combining (5.5)–(5.7), we obtain n 1 X X hκl,m , η ⊗l ⊗ ξ ⊗m i hξ, ηi + l=0 m=0
n X
2 ≤ 1 + 2(n + 1)C + (2n + 3)|ξ|2n p + |η|−p +
Qm (η, η) .
(5.8)
m=0 + by Now we define a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear form Q on KC
Q(ξ, η) = 2
n X
Qm (ξ, η) + 2hA−p ξ, A−p η i ,
+ ξ, η ∈ KC .
m=0
Then with some constant numbers M1 ≥ 0 and r ≥ 0, (5.8) becomes n 1 X X ⊗l ⊗m hκl,m , η ⊗ ξ i ≤ M1 + |ξ|2n 2 hξ, ηi + p+r + Q(η, η) ,
(5.9)
l=0 m=0
where Tr Q ≤ 2
n X
Tr Qm + 2kA−(q−r0 ) k2HS < 2(n + 1)1 + 21 < ,
m=0
which follows from Lemma 5.3. Then (5.4) follows immediately from (5.9). Theorem 4.1 is a direct consequence of Proposition 5.4. 5.2. Proof of Theorem 4.2 − ⊗l ) and > 0, there exist C ≥ 0 Lemma 5.5. Let l ≥ 1. For any κ ∈ Kl,0 ⊂ (KC + with Tr Q < such that and a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear form Q on KC
|hκ, η ⊗l i| ≤ C + Q(η, η)(l+1)/2 ,
η ∈ EC .
+ , a nonProof. By definition we take a complete orthonormal basis {ζn } of KC 1 negative sequence {an } ∈ ` , and constant numbers C ≥ 0 such that
|hκ, ζi1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ζil i| ≤ Cai1 · · · ail .
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
267
P Hence by using η = n hη, ζn i+ ζn , X hκ, ζi1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ζil ihη, ζi1 i+ · · · hη, ζil i+ |hκ, η ⊗l i| = i1 ,...,il ≤C
X
ai1 · · · ail |hη, ζi1 i+ | · · · |hη, ζil i+ | = C
X
i1 ,...,il
≤C
X
!l ai |hη, ζi i+ |
i
!l/2 ai
i
X
!l/2 ai |hη, ζi i+ |
2
.
(5.10)
i
P Put M = i ai < ∞ and suppose we are given an arbitrary 1 > 0 with 1 < /M . With the help of an obvious inequality bl cm ≤ bl+m + cl+m for b, c ≥ 0, (5.10) becomes !l/2 X −l 2 l 1/2 2 ai |hη, ζi i+ | 1 (1 C M ) i
2 l (l+1)/2 ≤ (−l + 1 C M )
1
X
!(l+1)/2 ai |hη, ζi i+ |2
.
(5.11)
i
Define a sesquilinear form by X ai hξ, ζi i+ hζi , ηi+ , Q(ξ, η) = 1
+ ξ, η ∈ KC .
(5.12)
i + with Tr Q = 1 M < . Obviously, Q is a non-negative sesquilinear form on KC Thus (5.10) and (5.11) become 2 l (l+1)/2 + Q(η, η)(l+1)/2 , |hκ, η ⊗l i| ≤ (−l 1 C M )
which completes the proof. − ⊗l ⊗m ∗ Lemma 5.6. Let l ≥ 1 and m ≥ 1. For any κ ∈ Kl,m ⊂ (KC ) ⊗ (EC ) and + > 0, there exist p ≥ 0 and a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear form Q on KC with Tr Q < such that
+ Q(η, η)(l+m)/2 , |hκ, η ⊗l ⊗ ξ ⊗m i| ≤ |ξ|l+m p
ξ, η ∈ E|C .
(5.13)
Proof. With the property stated as in (4.4), the proof is a simple modification of the proof of Lemma 5.5. Proposition 5.7. Assume that k + n ≥ 2 and consider a white noise operator Ξ which is a finite sum of integral kernel operators of the form: Ξ=
n k X X l=0 m=0
Ξl,m (κl,m ) ,
− ⊗l ⊗m ∗ κl,m ∈ Kl,m ⊂ (KC ) ⊗ (EC ) .
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
268
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
− Then the Wick exponential wexp Ξ belongs to L((E)β , Γβ˜−1 (KC )), where 0 ≤ β < 1 is chosen in such a way that max{k + 1, k + n, 2n} = 2/(1 − β).
Proof. The symbol of wexp Ξ is given by \Ξ(ξ, η) = exp hξ, ηi + wexp
n k X X
! hκl,m , η
⊗l
⊗ξ
⊗m
i ,
(5.14)
l=0 m=0
to which we shall apply Theorem 2.2. Suppose > 0 and 1 > 0 are given arbitrarily. By Lemma 5.1, for each m ≥ 0 there exist C0,m ≥ 0 and p0,m ≥ 0 such that |hκ0,m , ξ ⊗m i| ≤ C0,m + |ξ|2m p0,m .
(5.15)
By Lemma 5.5, for each l ≥ 1 there exist Cl ≥ 0 and a bounded, non-negative + with Tr Ql,0 < 1 such that sesquilinear form Ql,0 on KC |hκl,0 , η ⊗l i| ≤ Cl + Ql,0 (η, η)(l+1)/2 .
(5.16)
By Lemma 5.6, for each pair l ≥ 1 and m ≥ 1 there exist pl,m ≥ 0 and a bounded, + with Tr Ql,m < 1 such that non-negative sesquilinear form Ql,m on KC (l+m)/2 , |hκl,m , η ⊗l ⊗ ξ ⊗m i| ≤ |ξ|l+m pl,m + Ql,m (η, η)
ξ, η ∈ EC .
(5.17)
Fix q > r0 + 1/2 with kA−(q−r0 ) k2HS < 1 , where r0 ≥ 0 is chosen in such a way that Er0 ,→ K + is a contraction. We put p = max{q, pl,m ; 0 ≤ l ≤ k, 0 ≤ m ≤ n} and define Q(ξ, η) =
n k X X
Ql,m (ξ, η) + hA−p ξ, A−p ηi ,
ξ, η ∈ EC .
(5.18)
l=1 m=0 + with Then Q becomes a sesquilinear form on KC
Tr Q ≤
n k X X
Tr Ql,m + kA−(p−r0 ) k2HS ≤ k(n + 1)1 + 1 .
l=1 m=0
Thus, given > 0 we may choose 0 < 1 < /(kn + k + 1) to have Tr Q < . Now we estimate (5.14). Put d1 = max{2n, k + n}. By using an obvious inequality xα ≤ 1 + xβ for x ≥ 0 and 0 < α ≤ β, we sum up (5.15)–(5.17) to obtain |hξ, ηi| +
n k X X
|hκl,m , η ⊗l ⊗ ξ ⊗m i|
l=0 m=0
≤ M1 + (1 + n +
kn)|ξ|dp1
+
k X
Ql,0 (η, η)(l+1)/2
l=1
+
k X
n X
l=1 m=1
Ql,m (η, η)(l+m)/2 + |η|2−p ,
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
269
where M1 is a constant. Note an inequality: for x1 , . . . , xn ≥ 0 and α1 , . . . , αn > 0 with α = max{α1 , . . . , αn } ≥ 1 it holds that αn α α α 1 xα 1 + · · · + xn ≤ (1 + x1 ) + · · · + (1 + xn ) ≤ n + (x1 + · · · + xn ) .
Then with d2 = max{k + 1, k + n} and (5.18) we come to k X
Ql,0 (η, η)(l+1)/2 +
n k X X
Ql,m (η, η)(l+m)/2 + |η|2−p
l=1 m=1
l=1
≤ (k + kn + 1) +
n k X X
!d2 /2 Ql,m (η, η) + |η|2−q
l=1 m=0
= (k + kn + 1) + Q(η, η)d2 /2 , Consequently, with some constant numbers M ≥ 0 and r ≥ 0 we have n k X X ⊗l ⊗m 1 hκl,m , η ⊗ ξ i ≤ M + |ξ|dp+r + Q(η, η)d2 /2 . 2 hξ, ηi + l=0 m=0
Finally, taking d = max{d1 , d2 } = max{k + 1, k + n, 2n}, we have \Ξ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ C exp{|ξ|dp+r + Q(η, η)d/2 } , |wexp and the assertion follows by Theorem 2.2 and Remark 2.3. Theorem 4.2 is direct from Proposition 5.7. 5.3. Proof of Theorem 4.3 It is sufficient to prove the following ∗ ) and assume that there exist C ≥ Proposition 5.8. Let Ξ ∈ L(WBell(k) , WBell(k) + with Tr Q < 0, p ≥ 0 and a bounded, non-negative sesquilinear form Q on KC RBell(k+1) such that
ˆ η)e−hξ,ηi |2 ≤ CGBell(k) (|ξ|2 )GBell(k) (Q(η, η)) , |Ξ(ξ, p Then the Wick exponential wexp Ξ belongs to
ξ, η ∈ EC .
(5.19)
− )). L(WBell(k+1) , ΓBell(k+1)−1 (KC
Proof. For simplicity we write Gk = GBell(k) . The symbol of wexp Ξ is given by ˆ η)e−hξ,ηi } . \Ξ(ξ, η) = ehξ,ηi exp{Ξ(ξ, wexp By the Schwartz inequality and (5.19) we see that for any q ≥ 0, √ \Ξ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ e2|hξ,ηi| exp{2 C G1/2 (|ξ|2p )G1/2 (Q(η, η))} |wexp k k ≤ e|ξ|q e|η|−q exp{CGk (|ξ|2p )} exp{Gk (Q(η, η))} . 2
2
(5.20)
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
270
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
We first consider CGk (|ξ|2p ) + |ξ|2q . Without loss of generality we may assume that C ≥ γk , where γk is defined in (1.7). In view of Proposition 1.2 we obtain CGk (|ξ|2p ) + |ξ|2q = C{Gk (|ξ|2p ) − 1} + C + |ξ|2q C 2 ≤ γk Gk |ξ| − 1 + C + |ξ|2q γk p ≤ γk Gk (|ξ|2r ) − γk + C + |ξ|2r ,
(5.21)
where r ≥ max{p, q} is suitably chosen. By means of an obvious inequality s + Gk (t) ≤ Gk (s + t) for s, t ≥ 0, (5.21) becomes 1 2 2 2 CGk (|ξ|p ) + |ξ|q ≤ γk Gk 1+ |ξ|r − γk + C γk ≤ γk {Gk (|ξ|2s ) − 1} + C , where s ≥ r is chosen in such a way that (1 + 1/γk )ρ2(s−r) ≤ 1. Then, exp{CGk (|ξ|2p ) + |ξ|2q } ≤ eC Gk+1 (|ξ|2s ) . On the other hand, we obtain easily Gk (Q(η, η)) + |η|2−q ≤ γk {Gk (Q(η, η) + |η|2−q ) − 1} + γk
(5.22)
and hence, exp{Gk (Q(η, η)) + |η|2−q } ≤ eγk Gk+1 (Q(η, η) + |η|2−q ) .
(5.23)
By combining (5.22) and (5.23), (5.20) is brought into \Ξ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ C4 Gk+1 (|ξ|2s )Gk+1 (Q(η, η) + |η|2−q ) , |wexp
(5.24)
where C4 > 0 is a constant. With a bounded non-negative sesquilinear form Q1 on + defined by KC Q1 (ξ, η) = Q(ξ, η) + hA−q ξ, A−q η i ,
+ ξ, η ∈ KC ,
(5.24) becomes \Ξ(ξ, η)|2 ≤ C3 Gk+1 (|ξ|2s )Gk+1 (Q1 (η, η)) . |wexp Choosing a sufficiently large q ≥ 0 in such a way that Tr Q1 ≤ Tr Q + kA−(q−r0 ) k2HS < RBell(k+1) , where r0 ≥ 0 is chosen as Er0 ,→ K + is a contraction. (This is guaranteed by Lemma 5.3.) The assertion then follows by Theorem 2.2. Acknowledgments This joint work was accomplished during the second named author’s stay at Nagoya University in 1999. He is most grateful to Graduate School of Mathematics, in particular to Professor Nobuaki Obata for their warm hospitality. The authors thank the referee for useful comments that improved this paper.
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
00117
Quantum Stochastic Analysis via White Noise Operators
271
References [1] L. Accardi, “Noise and dissipation in quantum theory”, Rev. Math. Phys. 2 (1990) 127–176. [2] L. Accardi, Y.-G. Lu and I. Volovich, “Non-linear extensions of classical and quantum stochastic calculus and essentially infinite dimensional analysis”, pp. 1–33 in Probability Towards 2000, eds. L. Accardi and C. C. Heyde, Lect. Notes in Stat. 128, Springer-Verlag, 1998. [3] N. Asai, I. Kubo and H.-H. Kuo, “General characterization theorems and intrinsic topologies in white noise analysis”, Hiroshima Math. J. 31 (2001) 299–330. [4] A. Bohm and M. Gadella, Dirac Kets, Gamow Vectors and Gel’fand Triples, Lect. Notes in Phys. 348, Springer-Verlag, 1989. [5] D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji and N. Obata, “Higher powers of quantum white noises in terms of integral kernel operators”, Infinite Dimen. Anal. Quantum Prob. 1 (1998) 533–559. [6] D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji and N. Obata, “Normal-ordered white noise differential equations I: Existence of solutions as Fock space operators”, pp. 115–135 in Trends in Contemporary Infinite Dimensional Analysis and Quantum Probability, eds. L. Accardi et al., Istituto Italiano di Cultura, Kyoto, 2000. [7] D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji and N. Obata, “Normal-ordered white noise differential equations II: Regularity properties of solutions”, pp. 157–174 in Prob. Theory and Math. Stat. eds. B. Grigelionis et al., VSP/TEV Ltd., 1999. [8] W. G. Cochran, H.-H. Kuo and A. Sengupta, “A new class of white noise generalized functions”, Infinite Dimen. Anal. Quantum Prob. 1 (1998) 43–67. [9] C. W. Gardiner, Quantum Noise, Springer-Verlag, 1991. [10] R. Gannoun, R. Hachaichi, H. Ouerdiane and A. Rezgui, “Un th´eoreme de dualit´e entre espaces de fonctions holomorphes ` a croissance exponentielle”, J. Funct. Anal. 171 (2000) 1–14. [11] T. Hida, Analysis of Brownian Functionals, Carleton Math. Lect. Notes 13, Carleton University, Ottawa, 1975. [12] T. Hida, H.-H. Kuo, J. Potthoff and L. Streit, White Noise: An Infinite Dimensional Calculus, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1993. [13] H. Holden, B. Øksendal, J. Ubøe and T. Zhang, Stochastic Partial Differential Equations, Birkh¨ auser, 1996. [14] Z.-Y. Huang, “Quantum white noises — White noise approach to quantum stochastic calculus”, Nagoya Math. J. 129 (1993) 23–42. [15] Z.-Y. Huang and S.-L. Luo, “Wick calculus of generalized operators and its applications to quantum stochastic calculus”, Infinite Dimen. Anal. Quantum Prob. 1 (1998) 455–466. [16] R. L. Hudson and K. R. Parthasarathy, “Quantum Itˆ o’s formula and stochastic evolutions”, Commun. Math. Phys. 93 (1984) 301–323. [17] Yu. G. Kondratiev, P. Leukert and L. Streit, “Wick calculus in Gaussian analysis”, Acta Appl. Math. 44 (1996) 269–294. [18] Yu. G. Kondratiev and L. Streit, “Spaces of white noise distributions: Constructions, descriptions, applications I”, Rep. Math. Phys. 33 (1993) 341–366. [19] I. Kubo, H.-H. Kuo and A. Sengupta, “White noise analysis on a new space of Hida distributions”, Infinite Dimen. Anal. Quantum Prob. 2 (1999) 315–335. [20] I. Kubo and S. Takenaka, “Calculus on Gaussian white noise I”, Proc. Japan Acad. 56A (1980) 376–380. [21] H.-H. Kuo, White Noise Distribution Theory, CRC Press, 1996.
March 19, 2002 11:43 WSPC/148-RMP
272
00117
D. M. Chung, U. C. Ji & N. Obata
[22] P.-A. Meyer, Quantum Probability for Probabilists, Lect. Notes in Math. 1538, Springer-Verlag, 1993. [23] N. Obata, “An analytic characterization of symbols of operators on white noise functionals”, J. Math. Soc. Japan 45 (1993) 421–445. [24] N. Obata, White Noise Calculus and Fock Space, Lect. Notes in Math. 1577, Springer-Verlag, 1994. [25] N. Obata, “Generalized quantum stochastic processes on Fock space”, Publ. RIMS 31 (1995) 667–702. [26] N. Obata, “Integral kernel operators on Fock space — Generalizations and applications to quantum dynamics”, Acta Appl. Math. 47 (1997) 49–77. [27] N. Obata, “Quantum stochastic differential equations in terms of quantum white noise”, Nonlinear Anal. 30 (1997) 279–290. [28] N. Obata, “Wick product of white noise operators and quantum stochastic differential equations”, J. Math. Soc. Japan. 51 (1999) 613–641. [29] K. R. Parthasarathy, “Quantum Ito’s formula”, Rev. Math. Phys. 1 (1989) 89–112. [30] K. R. Parthasarathy, An Introduction to Quantum Stochastic Calculus, Birkh¨ auser, 1992. [31] J. Potthoff and L. Streit, “A characterization of Hida distributions”, J. Funct. Anal. 101 (1991) 212–229.
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 3 (2002) 273–302 c World Scientific Publishing Company
ANDERSON LOCALIZATION FOR A MULTIDIMENSIONAL MODEL INCLUDING LONG RANGE POTENTIALS AND DISPLACEMENTS
HERIBERT ZENK Institut f¨ ur Theoretische Physik der Universit¨ at Wien Boltzmanngasse 5, A-1090; Austria
Received 12 March 2001 Revised 19 November 2001 We give a short summary on how to combine and extend results of Combes and Hislop [2] (short range Anderson model with additional displacements), Kirsch, Stollmann and Stolz [13] and [14] (long range Anderson model without displacements) to get localization in an energy interval above the infimum of the almost sure spectrum for a continuous multidimensional Anderson model including long range potentials and displacements. Keywords: Random Schr¨ odinger Operators; Anderson Localization; Long Range Potentials, Random Displacements. Mathematics Subject Classification 2000: 81Q10, 35J10, 47A10
1. Introduction We treat the multidimensional Anderson model including displacements as in [2], using a long range single site potential ℘ as in [14]. To be more precise, we consider a continuous function ℘ : Rd → R+ and two independent families (λj : (Ω0 , P 0 ) → R)j∈Zd and (ξj : (Ω00 , P 00 ) → Rd )j∈Zd of independent identically distributed random variables satisfying the following conditions: (1) The joint probability distribution F = FP 0 ◦λ−1 : R → [0, 1] j
0
t→P ◦
λ−1 j (]
Z − ∞, t[) =
t
g(x) dx −∞
satisfies F (t) > 0 for t > 0, F has a density g ∈ L∞ (R) with respect to Lebesgue measure µ, and there is a finite interval [0, g0 ] containing the support of g. (2) There is an R ∈]0, 12 [, such that |ξj (ω 00 )| < R, for every j ∈ Zd and ω 00 ∈ Ω00 . Here | · | denotes the maximum norm in Rd . (3) We further assume that there is a c0 > 0 such that c0 101+2R ≤ ℘ holds, where 1xl denotes the characteristic function of the box Λ(x, l) with sidelength l > 0 273
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
274
00119
H. Zenk
centered at a point x ∈ Rd . We consider two conditions for ℘(x), as |x| tends to ∞: (a) the “long range case”: There is a c1 > 0 and ς > 2d such that ℘(x) ≤ c1 hxi−ς := c1 (1 + |x|2 )−ς/2 holds, for every x ∈ Rd . As a special case we consider (b) the “short range case”: ℘ has compact support. Using these properties of ℘, (λj )j∈Zd and (ξj )j∈Zd , we define a bounded potential X λj (ω 0 )℘(x − j − ξj (ω 00 )) V (ω 0 , ω 00 , x) := j∈Zd
and arrive at the selfadjoint random Schr¨ odinger operator H(ω 0 , ω 00 ) := −4 + 0 00 2 d 0 V (ω , ω ) in L (R ) on the domain D(H(ω , ω 00 )) = H 2 (Rd ). Thus the operator H is measurable (a proof can be found in [4, Proposition V.3.1]) in the sense, that ω 7→ hϕ, (H(ω) − z)−1 Ψi is measurable for all ϕ, Ψ ∈ L2 (Rd ) and all z ∈ C\R. If d we denote the path of (λj )j∈Zd as λ• : Ω0 → RZ , we get an equivalent stochastic process ω 0 7→ λ• (ω 0 ) = (λj (ω 0 ))j∈Zd ! d d (1) prj : (RZ , B(RZ ), P 0 ◦ λ−1 • ) → R , (xk )k∈Zd 7→ xj j∈Zd for the family (λj )j∈Zd and another process (prj : ((Rd )Z , P00 ◦ ξ•−1 ) → Rd )j∈Zd equivalent to (ξj )j∈Zd . Using independence and identical distribution one easily d
(2)
⊗Z ⊗Z := (P 0 ◦ λ−1 and P00 ◦ ξ•−1 = P⊗Z := (P 00 ◦ ξ0−1 )⊗Z verifies P0 ◦ λ−1 • = P0 1 0 ) Zd d Zd for all cylinder sets in B(R ) respectively B((R ) ), hence for all elements of d d B(RZ ) respectively B((Rd )Z ). As (λj )j∈Zd and (ξj )j∈Zd are independent families, d
d
d
d
⊗ we construct a new probability space (Ω, B(Ω), P) = (RZ × (Rd )Z , B(Ω), P⊗Z 0 ⊗Zd P1 ), where B(Ω) is the completion of the product-σ-algebra on Ω with respect to the measure P containing all P-zerosets, and an equivalent stochastic process (the canonical representant) ! prj : Ω → R × Rd d
ω = (ωk )k∈Zd 7→ ωj
d
d
j∈Zd
for ((λj , ξj ) : Ω0 × Ω00 → R × Rd )j∈Zd , see e.g. [12] for more details about equivalent stochastic processes. In this way we identify ω = (ωj )j∈Zd = (ωj0 , ωj00 )j∈Zd ≡ (λj (ω 0 ), ξj (ω 00 )) ∈ Ω with (ω 0 , ω 00 ) ∈ Ω0 × Ω00 and thus the random potential reads as X ωj0 ℘(x − j − ωj00 ) . V (ω, x) = j∈Zd
The product structure of Ω also immediately shows limn→∞ P(θj−n A ∩ B) = P(A)P(B) for all j ∈ Zd \{0} and all cylinder sets A, B in B(Ω), where θj : Ω → Ω is the measure preserving transformation defined by θj ((ωk )k∈Zd ) = (ωj+k )k∈Zd .
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
275
This equality extends to all A, B ∈ B(Ω), cf. [23, Theorem 1.17], hence shows the mixing property and especially the ergodicity of the system (Ω, P, (θj )j∈Zd ). As V (θx ω, y) = V (ω, x+y), the existence of subsets Σ, Σc , Σs , Σac , Σsc , Σess , Σpp ⊆ R such that Σ = σ(H(ω)), Σc = σc (H(ω)), etc. holds for P-almost all ω ∈ Ω, is a standard result in the theory of random operators; see e.g. [4, Proposition V.2.4]. Adapting an idea of [13] for the proof of Eq. (1.1) therein, as a warm up in handling displacements, we prove: Lemma 1.1. Under the assumptions specified above, inf Σ = 0. Proof. V (ω) ≥ 0 implies H(ω) ≥ 0 for P-almost all ω ∈ Ω, hence inf Σ ≥ 0 and it is enough to show 0 ∈ Σ. For 0 ∈ σ(−4) choose a singular sequence (φn )n∈N in C0∞ (Rd ), i.e. kφn k = 1 and −4φn → 0, and a sequence (ln )n∈N of odd numbers, n→∞ such that supp φn ⊆ Λ(0, l2n ) and ln −→ 0. The events 1 for each k ∈ Λ(0, ln ) ∩ Zd Ωn := ω ∈ Ω : ωk0 ∈ 0, n S d satisfy P(Ωn ) = P0 ([0, n1 ])ln > 0, so the invariant set An := x∈Zd θx−1 Ωn has full T P measure due to the ergodicity of (θx )x∈Zd with respect to P. Now A := n∈N An satisfies P(A) = 1 and for each ω ∈ A and n ∈ N, there is xn (ω) ∈ Zd with 1 −1 0 d Ω = ω ∈ Ω : ω ∈ 0, (ω), l ) ∩ Z for k ∈ Λ(x ω ∈ θ−x . n n n k n (ω) n As a consequence
X
1 00 ℘(· − j − ω ) kH(ω)φn (· − xn (ω))k ≤ k − 4φn k + j
n
j∈Λ(xn (ω),ln )∩Zd
X
xn (ω) 00
+ g0 1 ln ℘(· − j − ωj )
2 j∈Zd \Λ(xn (ω),ln )
∞
.
(1)
∞
For the estimation of the last two terms, we see that for each x ∈ Rd , j0 , j ∈ Zd , |x − j0 | ≤ 12 and P-almost every ω ∈ Ω, we obtain |j − j0 | ≤ |j0 − x| + |x − ωj00 − j| + |ωj00 | < |x − ωj00 − j| + 1 . As there are (2k + 1)d − (2k − 1)d elements j ∈ Zd satisfying |j0 − j| = k > 0, we may estimate ∞ X X X 00 00 −ς ≤ c ℘(x − ω − j) hx − ω − ji 1 j j j∈Zd k=0 j∈Zd |j−j0 |=k
≤ c 1 + c1
∞ X
[(2k + 1)d − (2k − 1)d ](1 + (k − 1)2 )− 2 < ∞ ς
k=1
(2)
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
276
00119
H. Zenk
as an upper bound for the second norm in (1). If we choose some x ∈ Λ(xn (ω), l2n ) and j ∈ Zd \Λ(xn (ω), ln ) for an estimate of the third term in (1), then the sum in (2) is restricted to k ≥ l4n − 1, hence we get a constant c < ∞ with
X
xn (ω) n→∞ 00
1 l ℘(· − j − ω ) < clnd−ς −→ 0 . j
2n
j∈Zd \Λ(xn (ω),ln ) ∞
So (Φn (· − xn (ω)))n∈N is a singular sequence for 0 ∈ σ(H(ω)) for each ω ∈ A, which yields 0 ∈ Σ. Now we state the main theorem of this paper: Theorem 1.2. Let H(ω) be the random Schr¨ odinger operator specified above. There exists an EX > inf Σ, such that σ(H(ω)) ∩ [inf Σ, EX ] is pure point spectrum for P-almost all ω ∈ Ω. In the short range case the corresponding eigenfunctions are exponentially decaying; in the long range case, the eigenfunctions decay faster than every inverse polynomial. The general scheme for a proof of such a theorem includes a Wegner estimate, multiscale analysis, spectral averaging and a criterion to detect pure point spectrum. The first three techniques originate from papers in the eighties, dealing with ohlich and Spencer proved a discrete model in l2 (Zd ). In the fundamental work [9], Fr¨ exponential decay of the Green’s function for large disorder and fixed energy. Then Fr¨ ohlich, Martinelli, Scoppola and Spencer [10], Delyon, Levy and Souillard [6] and Simon and Wolff [20] gave three independent proofs for the existence of dense pure point spectrum. Later on these methods were extended and simplified, see e.g., in [5] or [4], but these proofs seemed to be restricted to the discrete model. Combes and Hislop extended these ideas to continuous random Schr¨ odinger operators in [2]. They treat the continuous Anderson model with displacements for compact supported single site potential ℘ and in the case ℘(x) ≤ c1 hxi−ς , ς > 92 d. But the proof of this long range case is considered to be “incomplete” by the authors in [3]. Kirsch, Stollmann and Stolz studied a model without random displacements but with an additional periodic potential in [13], discussing effects of the random perturbation on the band structure. In [14] they extended their model to single site potentials ℘ satisfying ς > 2d. In [15] the case ς > 4d is considered; under this stronger requirement on ℘ they proved, that the eigenfunctions are exponentially decaying. A textbook account treating both, discrete and continuous random operators, is [21]. As Theorem 1.2 also covers the long range case, it is an improvement of the results in [2]. In Sec. 2 we start with a proof of the Wegner estimate on the resolvent (HΛ (ω)−E−iε)−1 of operators HΛ (ω), where HΛ (ω) is obtained as the restriction of H(ω) to a bounded open box Λ with Dirichlet boundary conditions. Using the geometric resolvent equation (6), we may view the resolvent of HΛ (ω) as the restriction
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
277
of the resolvent of HΛ0 (ω), with Λ0 ⊇ Λ, to functions with support in Λ modulo a boundary term. So provided we control these boundary terms, the geometric resolvent equation enables us to pass from HΛ (ω) to HΛ0 (ω), i.e. to enlarge the boxes under consideration. The multiscale analysis in Sec. 4 consists of constructing sen→∞ ries (ln )n∈N −→ ∞ of length scales and events (An )n∈N with (1 − P(An ))n∈N ∈ l1 and in finding a lower bound EX > inf Σ, such that we get enough control on all the boundary terms arising from the geometrical resolvent equation, when we pass inductively from the operators (HΛ(z,ln ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 , ω ∈ An , z ∈ Rd , E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ] to those restricted to boxes of the next length scale ln+1 > ln . This result of multiscale analysis allows us to use the Borel–Cantelli lemma, yielding a key step of the proof in Sec. 5: We obtain estimates on the decay of the norm of some localized versions 1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1x and 1x (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ℘(· − z) of the resolvent for P-almost all ω ∈ Ω and for µ-almost all E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ] as ε & 0 and |x| → ∞. Using these estimates we establish the decay properties of Theo1 d rem 1.2 for distributional solutions Ψ ∈ H− ς (R ) of the “perturbed” eigenvalue 4 equation H(ω)Ψ + α℘(· − z)Ψ = EΨ for α 6= 0, P-almost all ω ∈ Ω and µ-almost all E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ]. Due to the fact, that with respect to a spectral measure να,z,ω of H(ω) + α℘(· − z) for almost every E ∈ R such a distributional solution Ψ exists, we get pure point spectrum and the decay properties of the eigenfunctions for those “perturbed” operators H(ω) + α℘(· − z). The proof of Theorem 1.2 follows in Sec. 6.4, where we write “unperturbed” operators H(˜ ω ) for P-almost all ω ˜ ∈ Ω as appropriate “perturbed” operators H(ω)+α℘(·−z), using several relations between sets of P, µ, respectively, να,z,ω measure 0. 2. Spectral Averaging and Wegner Estimate In this section we make use of the product structure of P to estimate expectation values via Fubini’s theorem. We fix j ∈ Zd and perform the integration with respect to ωj0 first by some inequalities from [2] and then integrate the remaining variables. We begin with the following lemma from [2], cf. Lemma 4.1 and Corollary 4.2 there. Lemma 2.1. Let H be a separable Hilbert space and H0 a selfadjoint operator in H. Let B, V ≥ 0 be bounded operators on H, such that there is a constant c2 > 0 satisfying 0 ≤ c2 B 2 ≤ V. For α ∈ R, let πα be the spectral decomposition of the operator H(α) := H0 +αV and fix a bounded function h : R → R of compact support. Then for every measurable set M ⊆ R of finite Lebesgue measure, µ(M ) < ∞, one has: (1) k (2) k
R
1 hu, R 1+tα2
R
R
µ(M)kuk2 , for t > 0 and u c2 µ(M)kuk2 khk∞ , for u ∈ H. c2
Bπα (M )Buidαk ≤
h(α)hu, Bπα (M )Buidαk ≤
∈ H,
Theorem 2.2 (Wegner Estimate). Let Λ ⊆ Rd be an open finite box and let HΛ (ω) := −4+V (ω)|Λ be the restriction of H(ω) to L2 (Λ) with Dirichlet boundary
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
278
00119
H. Zenk
conditions. Then there is a function CW : R → R+ satisfying • for each E0 ∈ R the function CW is bounded on ] − ∞, E0 ], • P{ω ∈ Ω : dist(σ(HΛ (ω)), E0 ) < η} ≤ CW (E0 )ηld holds for every box Λ of sidelength l ≥ 1. Proof. For a box Λ ⊆ Rd we fix J := {j ∈ Zd : Λj := Λ(j, 1) ∩ Λ 6= ∅}. Let χj be L Λ the characteristic function of Λj and define HN,Λ := − j∈J 4Nj ≤ HΛ (ω) as the 2 direct sum of the Laplacians on L (Λj ) with Neumann boundary conditions. Then we use the proof of [4, Proposition 4.5] to get P{dist(σ(HΛ (ω)), E0 ) < η} ≤ eE0 +η E(tr(πΛ (]E0 − η, E0 + η[)e−HN,Λ )) XX kE(χj πΛ (]E0 − η, E0 + η[)χj )ke−En,j ≤ eE0 +η
(3)
n∈N j∈J
where πΛ is the spectral decomposition of HΛ and (En,j )n∈N are the eigenvalues of Λ −4Nj . These eigenvalues are explicitly known (see e.g. [18]), so one gets XX e−En,j ≤ Cld . (4) n∈N j∈J
For a given j ∈ J, we now estimate kE(χj πΛ (]E0 − η, E0 + η[)χj )k. In order to do so, we choose ϕ ∈ L2 (Λ) satisfying kϕk = 1 and decompose (Ω, P) as a product d ˆ = (RZd \{j} × (Rd )Zd , P⊗(Z \{j}) ⊗ P⊗Zd ) and (R, P0 ). Writing ω = (ˆ ˆ j , P) ω , α) of (Ω 0
1
Fubini’s theorem yields hϕ, E(χj πΛ (]E0 − η, E0 + η[)χj )ϕi Z Z ˆ ω) hϕ, χj πΛ (]E0 − η, E0 + η[, (ˆ ω , α))χj ϕi dP0 (α) dP(ˆ = ˆj Ω
Z
R
Z
= ˆj Ω
R
ˆ ω) . g(α)hϕ, χj πΛ (]E0 − η, E0 + η[, (ˆ ω , α))χj ϕi dα dP(ˆ
P ω , x) := i∈Zd ωj0 ℘(x − i − ωi00 ) one gets Defining Vˆj (ˆ i6=j
ω , x) + α℘(x − j − ωj00 ) V (ω, x) = V ((ˆ ω , α), x) = Vˆj (ˆ and ω ))|Λ + α℘(· − j − ωj00 )|Λ . HΛ (ω) = (−4Λ + Vˆj (ˆ As the assumptions on the model imply that g is a bounded function of compact support, ℘(·−j −ωj00 )|Λ ≥ 0, and c0 (χj )2 ≤ ℘(·−j −ωj00)|Λ , we may apply Lemma 2.1
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
279
with h = g, c2 = c0 , H = L2 (Λ), H0 = (−4Λ + Vˆj (ω))|Λ , V = ℘(· − j − ωj00 )|Λ and B = χj . This application yields Z Z ˆ ω) g(α)hϕ, χj πΛ (]E0 − η, E0 + η[, (ˆ ω , α))χj ϕi dα dP(ˆ ˆj Ω
R
≤
Z ˆj Ω
2ηkgk∞ µ(]E0 − η, E0 + η[)kgk∞ ˆ dP(ˆ ω) = . c0 c0
(5)
Combining (3), (4) and (5), we arrive at the desired result. The next result is close to [13, Proposition 4.2]. Proposition 2.3. For any ζ > 0 and b ∈ ]0, 2[ there is a l1∗ = l1∗ (ζ, b), such that for all boxes Λ of sidelength l ≥ l1∗ the following inequality is valid : P{ω ∈ Ω : dist(σ(HΛ (ω)), inf Σ) ≤ lb−2 } ≤ l−ζ . Proof. The proof consists of several steps; in the first step, we give a lower bound for the lowest eigenvalue µ1 (HΛN (ω)) of the operator H(ω) restricted to Λ with Neumann boundary conditions. Fix z ∈ Zd , take an odd number l, so Card(Λ(z, l) ∩ Zd ) = ld and define E := ( ω ˜ j :=
π2 , 8c0 (1 + 4c0 )l2
min{8E, ωj0 }
if j ∈ Λ(z, l) ∩ Zd ,
0
if j ∈ Zd \Λ(z, l) .
Due to our general assumptions c0 101+2R ≤ ℘ and |ωj00 | < R for P-almost all ω ∈ Ω, P ˜ j 1j satisfies V˜ (˜ ω )|Λ(z,l) ≤ V (ω)|Λ(z,l) . Hence the so the potential V˜ (˜ ω ) := c0 j∈Zd ω N ˜ ˜ (˜ (˜ ω )) of −4 + V ω )) restricted to Λ(z, l) with Neumann lowest eigenvalue µ1 (H Λ(z,l) N ˜ N (˜ (ω)). Note, that µ1 (H ω )) boundary conditions is a lower bound for µ1 (H Λ(z,l)
Λ(z,l)
does not depend on the random displacements. In the second step, we have a closer ˜ N (˜ look to the event {µ1 (H Λ(z,l) ω )) < E}. The definition of E ensures, that we may apply Temple’s inequality, see [19, Lemma 4.4], which yields 3 −d ˜ N (˜ l µ1 (H Λ(z,l) ω )) ≥ 4
X
ω ˜j ,
j∈Λ(z,l)∩Zd
d ˜ N (˜ ˜ j < 4E} > hence µ1 (H Λ(z,l) ω )) < E implies that Card{j ∈ Λ(z, l) ∩ Z : ω to N ˜ N (˜ µ1 (H Λ(z,l) ω )) ≤ µ1 (HΛ(z,l) (ω)) ,
ld 2.
Due
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
280
00119
H. Zenk
we obtain the inclusion N (ω)) < 4E} {ω ∈ Ω : µ1 (HΛ(z,l) ld . ⊆ ω ∈ Ω : Card{j ∈ Λ(z, l) ∩ Zd : ωj0 < 4E} > 2
As step three, we apply Cramer’s theorem, see [22, Theorem 1.3.13], which yields d1 ld 4 d 0 ≤ e−l 2 log( 3 ) , P ω ∈ Ω : Card{j ∈ Λ(z, l) ∩ Z : ωj < 4E} > 2 provided 34 < P0 ([4E, ∞[) < 1. Hence, if l is big enough, so that E satisfies this condition, we obtain d1 π2 4 N −2 l ≤ e−l 2 log( 3 ) . P ω ∈ Ω : µ1 (HΛ(z,l) (ω)) < 2c0 (1 + 4c0 ) N (ω), Λ(z, l) ⊆ Λ, is done The last step, the estimation of HΛN (ω) by a sum of HΛ(z,l) as in [13, Proposition 4.2]. One obtains
P{ω ∈ Ω : µ1 (HΛN (ω)) ≤ lb−2 } ≤ l−ζ for all boxes Λ of sidelength l, which has to be large enough. As HΛN (ω) ≤ HΛ (ω) this also proves the proposition. 3. Geometric Resolvent Equation The results of Sec. 2 enable us to control the resolvent for the operator HΛ (ω) restricted to a finite box Λ. We state the geometric resolvent equations and some consequences, which were implicitly stated in [2, 13] and [14]. These observations, which allow us to increase the size of the box Λ, are close to the preparations of multiscale analysis in [7, 8] and [11]. Theorem 3.1. Let ∅ 6= Λ ⊆ Rd be a finite, open box and χ ∈ C0∞ (Λ, R) a smooth function of compact support in Λ, and choose as Λ0 another finite, open box Λ0 ⊇ Λ odinger operators or Λ0 = Rd . For a potential V ∈ L∞ (Rd , R) consider the Schr¨ 0
HΛ0 := −4Λ + V |Λ0
and
HΛ := −4Λ + V |Λ
with Dirichlet boundary conditions for Λ and for Λ0 whenever Λ0 is finite. Suppose 0 0 that WχΛ is the operator in L2 (Λ0 ) with domain D(WχΛ ) = H 1 (Λ0 ) satisfying 0
WχΛ f := −(4χ)f − 2∇χ · ∇f ,
∀ f ∈ H 1 (Λ0 ) .
Then for all z ∈ C\R, the following geometric resolvent equations hold true for all u ∈ L2 (Λ0 ) and v ∈ L2 (Λ): 0
χ(HΛ0 − z)−1 u = (HΛ − z)−1 χu + (HΛ − z)−1 WχΛ (HΛ0 − z)−1 u
(6)
(HΛ0 − z)−1 χv = χ(HΛ − z)−1 v − (HΛ0 − z)−1 WχΛ (HΛ − z)−1 v .
(7)
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model 0
0
0
281
0
Proof. We notice that WχΛ f = −4Λ (χf ) + χ4Λ f for all f ∈ D(4Λ ) and 0 0 −4Λ (χf ) = −4Λ (χf ) for all f ∈ D(−4Λ ) or f ∈ D(−4Λ ). Hence 0
(HΛ − z)(χf ) = χ(HΛ0 − z)f + WχΛ f 0
for all f ∈ D(4Λ ). Taking (HΛ −z)−1 on both sides of this equation and considering f = (HΛ0 − z)−1 u gives (6) and similarly from χ(HΛ − z)f = (HΛ0 − z)(χf ) − WχΛf for f = (HΛ − z)−1 v one gets (7). 0
0
0
Given a sequence (fn )n∈N in D(−4Λ ) then fn → f , −4Λ fn → h and WχΛ fn → g 0 altogether imply WχΛ f = g. So, we can state some properties of the operator WχΛ resulting from the closed graph theorem. Lemma 3.2. The operator WχΛ has the following properties: • WχΛ (HΛ − z)−1 : L2 (Λ) → L2 (Λ) ⊆ L2 (Λ0 ) is bounded for every z ∈ C\R, 0 • (HΛ − z)−1 WχΛ : H 1 (Λ0 ) → L2 (Λ) has a continuous extension on L2 (Λ0 ) with 0 norm k(HΛ − z)−1 WχΛ k = kWχΛ (HΛ − z¯)−1 k. In the multiscale analysis procedure we fix δ > 0 and consider boxes Λ(z, l) centered at z of sidelength l > 3δ. We also use an Urysohn function ϕ for Λ(z, l), which is a function ϕ ∈ C0∞ (Λ(z, l − 23 δ), [0, 1]) with ϕ = 1 on Λ(z, l − 43 δ). In this situation, for every τ ∈ C ∞ (Rd ) satisfying τ (x) = 1, for x ∈ Λ(z, l− 23 δ)\Λ(z, l − 43 δ) 0 0 one has WϕΛ = WϕΛ ◦ τ for all Λ0 ⊇ Λ(z, l). To perform the multiscale analysis we note: Lemma 3.3. Let ϕ be an Urysohn function for Λ = Λ(z, L) and let Λ0 ⊇ Λ be a finite box. Given η > 0 and z ∈ C\R with dist(
˜ = {x ∈ Λ(z, L) : where Λ function c3 is given as:
L 2
3
− δ < |z − x| <
L 2}
is the enlarged δ-edge of Λ and the
r
2 [(1 + 2
c3 (η,
r ·
k4τ1 k∞ + 2
2 [(1 + 2
!
using a function τ1 ∈ C0∞ (Λ(z, L)) with τ1 (x) = 1 for all x ∈ Λ(z, L − 23 δ). Proof. Taking τ1 specified above, we have τ1 1zL = 1zL . Thus applying the geometric 3
3
resolvent equation (6) to τ1 (HΛ0 − z)−1 1zL v and then applying WϕΛ we obtain 3
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
282
00119
H. Zenk
WϕΛ τ1 (HΛ0 − z)−1 1zL v 3
0
= WϕΛ (HΛ − z)−1 1zL v + WϕΛ (HΛ − z)−1 WτΛ1 (HΛ0 − z)−1 1zL v . 3
3
Taking also (4ϕ)τ1 = 4ϕ and ∇ϕ · ∇τ1 = 0 into account, this equation leads to: WϕΛ (HΛ − z)−1 1zL v 3
0
= WϕΛ τ1 (HΛ0 − z)−1 1zL v − WϕΛ (HΛ − z)−1 WτΛ1 (HΛ0 − z)−1 1zL v 3
3
−1 z
= −(4ϕ)(HΛ0 − z) − WϕΛ (HΛ
1 L v − 2(∇ϕ) · ∇((HΛ0 − z)
1 L v)
3
−1
− z)
−1 z
0 WτΛ1 (HΛ0
3
−1 z
− z)
1L v .
(8)
3
0
For χ ∈ C 1 (Λ0 , Rd ), u ∈ D(−4Λ ) and z ∈ C\R, we remark that 1 kχ · grad uk2 + 4ku div χk2 ≥ −2
2 [kχ(HΛ0 − z)uk2 + (1 + 2
k∇(HΛ0 − z)−1 vk2 0
= h(HΛ0 − z)−1 v, (−4Λ )(HΛ0 − z)−1 vi =
1 1 kvk2 + k
Expressing WϕΛ and WτΛ1 in terms of 4ϕ and ∇ϕ · ∇ respectively 4τ1 and ∇τ1 · ∇ in (8) and inserting these estimates, the lemma is proven. 4. Multiscale Analysis In this section we give a slight modification of the multiscale analysis, which has been used in [2, 13] and [14]. We state the results in a different way to the papers mentioned above, stressing the deterministic or probabilistic nature of the statements. In this way, we can take into account the displacements and the long range case for the single site potential more easily. For the multiscale analysis procedure
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
283
we now fix a δ > 0 and further on, we only consider boxes of sidelength l > 3δ. An Urysohn function of such a box is then always chosen with respect to this fixed δ in accordance with the conventions made before Lemma 3.3. Definition 4.1. Given an energy E, a configuration ω ∈ Ω and γ > 0, we call a box Λ = Λ(z, l) a γ-good box (for E and ω), if sup kWϕΛ (HΛ (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zL k ≤ e−γl
(9)
3
ε6=0
holds for an Urysohn function ϕ of Λ. Otherwise Λ is called γ-bad (for E and ω). We remark that with the help of the first resolvent equation we can change supε6=0 in (9) into supε∈Q,ε6=0 . Using measurability of HΛ and the geometric resolvent equation to express WϕΛ (HΛ (ω) − E − iε)−1 in terms of ϕ and HΛ (ω), we get {ω ∈ Ω : Λ is γ good for ω} ∈ B(Ω). The aim of the multiscale analysis is to find sequences (ln )n∈N in R+ and (An )n∈N in B(Ω), such that ln → ∞, Λ(z, ln ) is γ-good for E and ω ∈ An and P(An ) ≥ 1 − ln−ζ for a ζ > 0. In order to perform this “induction process” there are these steps to do: 4.1. Finding γ-good boxes for an initial length scale l0 Lemma 4.2. Let V be a potential on Rd which is locally uniformly in Lp , p = 2 for d ≤ 3 and p > d2 for d ≥ 4. Let Λ be a finite box and HΛ = −4Λ + odinger operator with Dirichlet boundary conditions. Let ]r, s[ be V |Λ be the Schr¨ ˜ ∈ L∞ (Λ) satisfying kχk∞ , kχk ˜ ∞ ≤ 1 and a spectral gap of HΛ and take χ, χ dist(supp χ, ∂Λ), dist(supp χ, ˜ ∂Λ) ≥ δ0 > 0. Then there are positive constants C0 , C1 and C2 only depending on δ0 and supx∈Rd kV kLp (Λ(x,1)) , such that for each E ∈]r, s[, each j ∈ {1, . . . , d}, and η := dist(E, σ(HΛ )) the following estimates hold : 1 η dist(supp χ,supp χ) C2 (C0 + s) − CC+s ˜ e 0 , kχ(H ˜ Λ − E − iε)−1 χk ≤ η kχ∂ ˜ j ((HΛ − E − iε)−1 χ)k ≤
1 C2 (C0 + s) − CC+s ˜ e 0 η dist(supp χ,supp χ) . η
A proof of this lemma can be found in [13, Appendix A]; using this lemma, we prove the “initial length scale estimate”: Theorem 4.3. For ξ ∈]0, 1[ there is a minimal length scale l2∗ = l2∗ (ξ), such that for all l0 > l2∗ there is a γ0 = γ0 (l0 , ξ) > 0 such that for all z ∈ Rd , for all Urysohn l−ξ
functions ϕzl0 of Λ(z, l0 ) with δ ≥ 1 and for all E ∈ I := [inf Σ, inf Σ + 02 ] and all configurations ω ∈ A := {ω ∈ Ω : dist(inf Σ, σ(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω))) ≥ l0−ξ } the box Λ(z, l0 ) is γ0 -good (for E ∈ I and ω ∈ A). and χ = 1zl0 to get dist(supp 1Λ(z,l , supp 1zl0 ) = Proof. We take χ ˜ = 1Λ(z,l ˜ ˜ 0) 0) l0 3
3
3
− δ. If we consider that I ⊆ ρ(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω)) for each ω ∈ A and η =
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
284
00119
H. Zenk l−ξ
dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω))) ≥ 02 for all E ∈ I and ω ∈ A using this spectral gap I, we get from Lemma 4.2: Λ(z,l0 )
kWϕz
l0
(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl0 k 3
≤
(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω) k4ϕzl0 k∞ k1Λ(z,l ˜ 0)
− E − iε)−1 1zl0 k 3
∇((HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl0 )k + 2k∇ϕzl0 k∞ k1Λ(z,l ˜ 0) 3
≤ (k4ϕzl0 k∞ + 2k∇ϕzl0 k∞ )C2 [2l0ξ (C0 + inf Σ) + 1]e
−l−ξ 0
l C1 ( 0 −δ) 3 −ξ l 2(C0 +inf Σ+ 0 ) 2
As the norms k4ϕzl0 k∞ and k∇ϕzl0 k∞ are bounded with respect to l0 , and C0 + inf Σ if l0 is large enough, there are constants C3 , C4 and C5 such that Λ(z,l0 )
kWϕz
l0
≤
.
l−ξ 0 2
≤
(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl0 k 3
−ξ C3 l0ξ e−l0 (C4 l0 −C5 )
=
C4 −ξ C4 −ξ −ξ [C3 l0ξ eC5 l0 e−( 2 l0 )l0 ]e−( 2 l0 )l0 −ξ
C4 −ξ
l →∞
holds, provided l0 is big enough. As C3 l0ξ eC5 l0 e−( 2 l0 )l0 0−→ 0 there is a l2∗ = C4 −ξ −ξ l2∗ (ξ) with C3 l0ξ eC5 l0 e−( 2 l0 )l0 ≤ 1 for l0 ≥ l2∗ . If we take γ0 = γ0 (l0 , ξ) := C24 l0−ξ and choose any l0 ≥ l2∗ (ξ), we get Λ(z,l0 )
kWϕz
l0
(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl0 k ≤ e−γ0 l0 . 3
4.2. Box counting or how to get a bigger good box In this section we are looking for fixed E how to get for some typical realizations ω from a γ-good box Λ(z, l) to a γ 0 -good bigger box Λ(z, l0 ). For fixed z ∈ Rd and l < l0 we consider the lattice Γz, l := {z + 3l y : y ∈ Zd } and the cluster 3 Q(ω, z, γ, l, l0 ) := {x ∈ Γz, l : Λ(x, l) ⊆ Λ(z, l0 ) and Λ(x, l) is γ-bad for ω} of γ-bad 3 boxes centered at a point of Γz, l contained in Λ(z, l0 ). 3
Lemma 4.4. Fix an energy E, let l be big enough, l0 > 13l, β > 0 and choose a configuration ω ∈ Ω satisfying δQ(ω, z, γ, l, 3l0) ≤ 11 3 l for the diameter of the cluster 0 −β of bad boxes, dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω))) ≥ (l ) and dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω))) ≥ (3l0 )−β . If we choose γ 0 := (1 − box for ω and E.
−
13l l0 )(γ
log(3d −1) ) l
−
(2d+2β) log l0 , l0
then Λ(z, l0 ) is a γ 0 -good
Proof. Taking w, z ∈ Λ(z, 3l0 ) with |w − z| ≥ 23 l and using the notation ϕw l for an z w w w 1 = 0 and 1 ϕ = 1 , so Urysohn function of Λ(w, l) we get ϕw l l l l l 3
w
−1 z
3
3
1 l (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)
3
1l Λ(z,3l0 )
= 1wl (HΛ(z,l) (ω) − E − iε)−1 Wϕw 3
3
l
(HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl
3
(10)
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
285
is a special case of the geometric resolvent equation (6). Choosing w ∈ Γz, l ∩Λ(z, 3l0 ) 3 we take the 3d −1 boxes of sidelength 3l centered at γw := (Γz, l ∩Λ(w, l))\{w} to get 3 P 0 ˜ 1wl as an equality in L2 (Λ(w, l)) for every function τ ∈ C0∞ (Λ(w, l)) τ =τ· 0 w ∈γw
3
Λ(z,3l0 )
Λ(z,3l0 )
with τ |Λ(w,l− 23 δ)\Λ(w,l− 43 δ) = 1. As such a function τ satisfies Wϕw l and due to Lemma 3.2 we have Λ(z,3l0 )
k1wl (HΛ(z,l) (ω) − E − iε)−1 Wϕw l
3
Λ(w,l)
k = kWϕw l
= Wϕw l
◦τ
(HΛ(w,l) (ω) − E + iε)−1 1wl k , 3
for w1 ∈ γw with 0
k1wl (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k , k1wl 1 (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k = max 0 w ∈γw
3
3
3
3
we obtain from (10) k1wl (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k 3
3
= k1wl (HΛ(w,l) (ω) − E − 3
Λ(z,3l0 ) iε)−1 Wϕw τ l
X
w 0 ∈γ
0
1wl 3
w
· (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k 3
Λ(w,l)
≤ (3d − 1)kWϕw l
(HΛ(w,l) (ω) − E + iε)−1 1wl k 3
0
k1wl (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k · max 0 w ∈γw
3
3
Λ(w,l)
= (3d − 1)kWϕw l
(HΛ(w,l) (ω) − E + iε)−1 1wl k 3
−1 z
· k1 l (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε) w1 3
1lk. 3
we can iterate this procedure to get a sequence w = w0 , w1 , . . . , wn If |w1 − z| ≥ 0 in Γz, l ∩ Λ(z, 3l ) with |wj − z| ≥ 23 l for j = 0, . . . , n − 1 and 2 3 l,
3
k1wl (HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k 3
3
≤ (3d − 1)n
n−1 Y j=0
kW
Λ(wj ,l) wj
ϕl
(HΛ(wj ,l) (ω) − E + iε)−1 1 l j k w 3
· k1wl n (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k .
(11)
3
3
/ Q(ω, z, γ, l, 3l0), we Restricting our considerations to the case w0 , w1 , . . . , wn−1 ∈ get from (11) k1wl (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k 3
3
≤ (3 − 1) (e d
n
−γl n
) k1 l (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl k . wn 3
3
(12)
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
286
00119
H. Zenk
This procedure which allows us to get further exponential factors e−γl in (12) stops, if either |wn − z| = 3l or Λ(wn+1 , l) * Λ(z, 3l0 ) or wn ∈ Q(ω, z, γ, l, 3l0) is satisfied. Provided we get a pair wi = wj with 0 ≤ i < j the procedure can be iterated as many times we like, by setting wj+1 := wi+1 , “running through this 0 path wi , . . . , wj ” once more. Take x ∈ S1 := {x ∈ Γz, l : Λ(x, 3l ) ∩ Λ(z, l3 ) 6= ∅} and 3 ˜ l0 ) 6= ∅}, then we have |x − y| ≥ l0 −l − δ > 11 l y ∈ S2 := {y ∈ Γ l : Λ(y, l ) ∩ Λ(z, z, 3
3
3
3
and consequently Λ(x, l) or Λ(y, l) is a γ-good box. So we can start the construction above with w = x and z = y whenever Λ(x, l) is γ-good and with w = y, z = x otherwise. In the case where Λ(x, l) and Λ(y, l) are γ-good and we end up with wn ∈ Q(ω, z, γ, l, 3l0), we increase the number of exponential factors e−γl by starting the above construction once again with w = y and z = wn . Now we have to estimate the minimum number of e−γl -factors in terms of |x−y| for each possible combination of these stopping conditions to get k1xl (HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1yl k 3
3
≤e
d 0 −(γ− log(3l −1) )3(|x−y|−max{ 4l 3 ,δQ(ω,z,γ,l,3l )})
k(HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 k (13)
for all lattice sites x ∈ S1 and y ∈ S2 , where δQ(ω, z, γ, l, 3l0) denotes the diameter 0 of the cluster Q(ω, z, γ, l, 3l0). As we have 3|x − y| − max{ 4l 3 , δQ(ω, z, γ, l, 3l )} ≥ 0 l − 13l > 0 and −1 z 1 l0 k k1Λ(z,l 0 ) (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε) ˜ 3
≤ Card S1 Card S2 max k1 l (HΛ(z,3l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1xl k y
x∈S1 y∈S2
3
3
the last task is to count the elements of S1 and S2 and then to combine this with the estimate of Lemma 3.3, using c3 ((l0 )−β , E) ≤ c4 (l0 )β to get a c ≥ 0 with Λ(z,l0 )
kWϕz
l0
(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 1zl0 k
≤ cl−2d e(l
3 0
log(3d −1) −13l)( −γ)+(2d+2β) log l0 l
yielding the proposed γ 0 , provided l is big enough. 4.3. An important probabilistic trick in multiscale analysis for long range single site potentials Taking a finite set ∅ = 6 Υ ⊂ Zd and A ⊆ Ω, we find a set B ⊇ prΥ (A) in the d+1 Υ σ-algebra B(R ) with (P0 ⊗ P1 )⊗Υ (B) = [(P0 ⊗ P1 )⊗Υ ]∗ (prΥ (A)). Consequently d d ∗ B × (Rd+1 )Z \Υ ∈ B(Ω) satisfies B × (Rd+1 )Z \Υ ⊇ pr−1 Υ (prΥ (A)) and P (B × d (Rd+1 )Z \Υ \A) = 0, so due to the completeness of B(Ω) we obtain pr−1 Υ (pr(A)) ∈ B(Ω). Fixing A, B ∈ B(Ω) and finite sets ∅ = 6 Υ1 , Υ2 ⊆ Zd , Υ1 ∩ Υ2 = ∅ then the
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
287
−1 two events pr−1 Υ1 (prΥ1 (A)) and prΥ2 (prΥ2 (B)) are independent. Due to this fact in [14] one finds the following definition.
Definition 4.5. A box Λ(z, l) is called γ-super good for ω and E, if Λ(z, l) is γω ) with Υ(z, 4l) := good for E and for all ω ¯ ∈ Ω satisfying prΥ(z,4l) (ω) = prΥ(z,4l) (¯ Zd ∩ Λ(z, 4l). Using γ-super good boxes instead of γ-good boxes eliminates all the problems, we would have, if we want to estimate for noncompact ℘ the probability P{ω ∈ Ω : Λ(x, l) and Λ(y, l) are not γ-good for E and ω} in terms of P{ω ∈ Ω : Λ(x, l) is not γ-good for E and ω}, even if we assume large |x − y|. In order to proceed, we need some pr−1 Υ prΥ -versions of earlier statements. Lemma 4.6. There is a c5 , such that for L large enough we have the inclusions: pr−1 Υ(z,4L) (prΥ(z,4L) {ω ∈ Ω : dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,L) (ω))) < η}) ⊆ {ω ∈ Ω : dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,L) (ω))) < η + c5 L−(ς−d) } , pr−1 Υ(z,4L) (prΥ(z,4L) {ω ∈ Ω : dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,L) (ω))) > η}) ⊆ {ω ∈ Ω : dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,L) (ω))) > η − c5 L−(ς−d) } . Proof. We take A = {ω ∈ Ω : dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,L) (ω))) < η} for the first inclusion and similarly A = {ω ∈ Ω : dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,L) (ω))) > η} for the second. Then we take ω ¯ ∈ pr−1 Υ(z,4L) (prΥ(z,4L) (A)) and choose ω ∈ A satisfying ω ). As the ωj and ω ¯ j coincide for all sites j ∈ Υ(z, 4L) and prΥ(z,4L) (ω) = prΥ(z,4L) (¯ −ς ω , x)| ≤ c5 L−(ς−d) . ℘ decreases at least polynomial as c1 hxi , one gets |V (ω, x)−V (¯ So the Minimax theorem shows, that the absolute value of the differences of the ω ) is bounded above by c5 L−(ς−d) and nth eigenvalues of HΛ(z,L) (ω) and HΛ(z,4L) (¯ this lemma follows. Lemma 4.7. If l0 > 13l and P{ω ∈ Ω : Λ(x, l) is not γ-super good for ω} ≤ η for each x ∈ S(z, l, l0 ) := {x ∈ Γz, l : Λ(x, l) ⊆ Λ(z, 3l0 )} are satisfied, one gets: 3
0 2d l 11 0 2d l ≤ 9 ) > η2 . pr ω ∈ Ω : δQ(ω, z, γ, l, 3l P pr−1 Υ(z,4l0 ) Υ(z,4l0 ) 3 l Proof. We remark that for finite sets ∅ = 6 Υ1 ⊆ Υ2 ⊂ Zd and every A ⊆ Ω we get −1 the “reversed” pr−1 pr-relation prΥ1 (prΥ1 (A)) ⊇ pr−1 Υ2 (prΥ2 (A)). So 11 0 l ) > pr−1 pr ω ∈ Ω : δQ(ω, z, γ, l, 3l 0 0 Υ(z,4l ) Υ(z,4l ) 3 [ pr−1 = Υ(z,4l0 ) (prΥ(z,4l0 ) {ω ∈ Ω : Λ(x, l) and Λ(y, l) are γ-bad for ω}) x,y∈S(z,l,l0 ) |x−y|> 11 l 3
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
288
00119
H. Zenk
⊆
[
[pr−1 Υ(x,4l) (prΥ(x,4l) {ω ∈ Ω : Λ(x, l) is γ-bad for ω})
x,y∈S(z,l,l0 ) |x−y|> 11 l 3
∩ pr−1 Υ(y,4l) (prΥ(y,4l) {ω ∈ Ω : Λ(y, l) is γ-bad for ω})] and as Υ(x, 4l)∩Υ(y, 4l) = ∅ for all x, y ∈ S(z, l, l0 ) with |x−y| > 11 3 l, we can use the −1 independence of the two events prΥ(x,4l) (prΥ(x,4l) {ω ∈ Ω : Λ(x, l) is γ-bad for ω}) and pr−1 Υ(y,4l) (prΥ(y,4l) {ω ∈ Ω : Λ(y, l) is γ-bad for ω}) to estimate 11 0 l ) > P pr−1 pr ω ∈ Ω : δQ(ω, z, γ, l, 3l 0 Υ(z,4l ) Υ(z,4l0 ) 3 X P({ω ∈ Ω : Λ(x, l) not γ-super good for ω}) ≤ x,y∈S(z,l,l0 ) |x−y|> 11 l 3
· P({ω ∈ Ω : Λ(y, l) not γ-super good for ω}) 0 2d l η2 . ≤ (Card S(z, l, l0 ))2 η 2 ≤ 92d l Theorem 4.8. Let l be big enough and l0 > 13l and suppose that for each x ∈ S(z, l, l0 ) the estimate P{ω ∈ Ω : Λ(x, l) is γ-super good for ω} ≥ 1 − η holds, then there is a c6 , such that P{ω ∈ Ω : Λ(z, l0 ) is γ 0 -super good for ω} ≥ 1 − η 0 , where we can choose γ 0 and η 0 as follows: 13l (2d + 2β) log l0 log(3d − 1) 0 , − γ = 1− 0 γ− l l l0 " # 0 2d l η 2 + (l0 )d−β + (l0 )−(ς−2d) . η 0 = c6 l Proof. We only look for configurations ω ∈ A1 with 11 0 l ) > pr ω ∈ Ω : δQ(ω, z, γ, l, 3l A1 := Ω\ pr−1 0 Υ(z,4l ) Υ(z,4l0 ) 3 0 −β 0 })] ∩ [Ω\ pr−1 Υ(z,4l0 ) (prΥ(z,4l0 ) {ω ∈ Ω : dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,3l ) (ω))) < (3l ) 0 −β 0 })] . ∩ [Ω\ pr−1 Υ(z,4l0 ) (prΥ(z,4l0 ) {ω ∈ Ω : dist(E, σ(HΛ(z,l ) (ω))) < (l )
¯ ∈ Ω with prΥ(z,4l0 ) (ω) = prΥ(z,4l60) (¯ ω ), one easily verifies that Fixing ω ∈ A1 and ω this ω ¯ satisfies the conditions of Lemma 4.4, so one obtains the γ 0 and that Λ(z, l0 ) ¯ . A combination of Lemma 4.6, Theorems 2.2 and 4.7 gives is a γ 0 -good box for ω the estimate P(A1 ) ≥ 1 − η 0 .
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
289
4.4. The induction process Theorem 4.9. There are l∗ , ζ > 0 and EX > inf Σ, such that if we choose l0 > l∗ αn and α ∈]1, 2d+2ζ 2d+ζ [ and define ln := l0 there is a γ > 0, such that P{ω ∈ Ω : Λ(z, ln ) is not γ-super good for ω and E} ≤ ln−ζ
(14)
for each z ∈ Rd and E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ]. −(ς−d)
Proof. Choosing b > 1, we get ξ ∈]2 − b, 1[ such that l0b−2 − c5 l0 is large enough. Now we conclude from Lemma 4.6 that
≥ l0−ξ if l0
b−2 pr−1 Υ(z,4l0 ) (prΥ(z,4l0 ) {ω ∈ Ω : dist(inf Σ, σ(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω))) > l0 }) −(ς−d)
⊆ {ω ∈ Ω : dist(inf Σ, σ(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω))) > l0b−2 − c5 l0
},
so the initial length scale estimate shows that for all l0 > l2∗ (ξ) the box Λ(z, l0 ) is γ0 = γ0 (l0 , ξ) =
C4 −ξ 2 l0
good for all E ∈ [inf Σ −
l−ξ 0 2 , inf
Σ+
l−ξ 0 2 ]
and all
b−2 ω ∈ pr−1 Υ(z,4l0 ) (prΥ(z,4l0 ) {ω ∈ Ω : dist(inf Σ, σ(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω))) > l0 }) .
This implies that for ω ∈ {ω ∈ Ω : dist(inf Σ, σ(HΛ(z,l0 ) (ω))) > l0b−2 } the box Λ(z, l0 ) is γ0 -super good, and so using Proposition 2.3 we get P{ω ∈ Ω : Λ(z, l0 ) is γ0 -super good for ω and E} ≥ 1 − l0−ζ if we choose a suitable lower bound for l0 . Now the induction works; we define 13lk γk+1 (l0 , γ0 , α) = γk+1 := γk 1 − − ck , lk+1 log(3d − 1) 13lk log lk+1 , 1− + (2d + 2β) ck (l0 ) = ck := lk lk+1 lk+1 and use the proof of Lemma A3 in [2] to express γk+1 in terms of lj and cj , Q −(α−1)αj ) satisfying 0 < j = 1, . . . , k to find κ = κ(l0 , α) = j∈N (1 − 13l0 γ0 (l0 ,ξ) κ(l0 , α) 2
≤ γk for all k ∈ N if we choose l0 big enough. In order to check the P-estimate (14), we use the expression for η 0 in Theorem 4.8 and optimize the parameter α, β and ζ as in the proof of [14, Proposition 5.4], which says: We can choose ζ ∈]0, ς − 2d[, then α ∈]1, 2d+2ζ 2d+ζ [ and β > d + ζ such that if we only consider large values of l0 , then for all k ∈ N, we will get the inequalities: 2d 1 −2d 1 −2ζ lk+1 1 −ζ 2d−ς 2d α α ≤ lk+1 , c6 ηk2 ≤ c6 lk+1 lk+1 lk+1 c6 lk+1 3 lk ζ 1 2d(1− α )−2 α
= c6 lk+1
≤
1 −ζ l , 3 k+1
d−β c6 lk+1 ≤
With this choice of l0 and for EX := inf Σ +
l−ζ 0 2
1 −ζ l . 3 k+1
> inf Σ Theorem 4.9 follows.
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
290
00119
H. Zenk
5. From the Resolvent on Finite Boxes to the Localized Resolvent on the Whole Space Theorem 5.1. Let EX be as in Theorem 4.9, then for every E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ] there is a measurable set B1 = B1 (E) with P(B1 ) = 1, such that for every bounded set K ⊆ Rd and each ω ∈ B1 there is r1 (ω, E, K) ∈]0, ∞[ such that sup k(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1K k = sup k1K (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 k ≤ r1 (ω, E, K) . ε6=0
ε6=0
Proof. Setting Λk := Λ(0, lk ), εk := e−γlk and Wk := WϕΛkk for an Urysohn funck tion ϕk of Λk and lk := l0α as in Theorem 4.9, we define ( ) Mk = Mk (E) :=
ω ∈ Ω : sup kWk (HΛk (ω) − E − iε)−1 1 lk k ≤ εk
,
3
ε6=0
Nk = Nk (E) := {ω ∈ Ω : dist(σ(HΛk (ω), E) > εk−1 } . Combining Theorems 4.9 and 2.2 we get (1 − P(Mk ))k∈N ∈ l1
and (1 − P(Nk ))k∈N ∈ l1 .
Hence the Borel–Cantelli lemma implies that B1 := B1 (E) = lim inf k→∞ Mk (E) ∩ Nk (E) has measure 1. For each ω ∈ B1 (E) we have a lower bound k0 (ω), such that ω ∈ Mk (E) ∩ Nk (E) for all k ≥ k0 (ω). For the given bounded set K we choose m with 1K ⊆ Λ(0, lm 3 ) and then we treat indices j ≥ max{k0 (ω), m} =: n. If we take the Urysohn functions ϕk of Λk and use ϕk+1 Wk = Wk , we get for v = 1K v applying the geometric resolvent equation (7) several times (H(ω) − E − iεj )−1 1K v = (H(ω) − E − iεj )−1 ϕn v = ϕn (HΛn (ω) − E − iεj )−1 v − (H(ω) − E − iεj )−1 Wn (HΛn (ω) − E − iεj )−1 v = ϕn (HΛn (ω) − E − iεj )−1 v − ϕn+1 (HΛn+1 (ω) − E − iεj )−1 Wn · (HΛn (ω) − E − iεj )−1 1 ln v + (H(ω) − E − iεj )−1 Wn+1 3
· (HΛn+1 (ω) − E − iεj )−1 Wn (HΛn (ω) − E − iεj )−1 1 ln v 3
= ϕn (HΛn (ω) − E − iεj )−1 v +
j−n−1 X
(−1)s+1 ϕn+s+1
s=0 −1
· (HΛn+s+1 (ω) − E − iεj )
( st=0 Wn+t (HΛn+t (ω)
− E − iεj )−1 1 ln+t )v 3
+ [(−1)n−j+1 (H(ω) − E − iεj )−1 j−n t=0 Wn+t · (HΛn+t (ω) − E − iεj )−1 1 ln+t ]v . 3
(15)
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
As ω ∈ Mk (E) ∩ Nk (E) we estimate k(HΛk (ω) − E − iεj )−1 k ≤ 1 εk−1
−1
and kWk (HΛk (ω) − E − iεj ) −1
k(H(ω) − E − iεj )
1K vk ≤ kvk
1 lk k ≤ εk to get
1 dist(E,σ(HΛk (ω)))
3
1 εn−1
≤ kvk e
+
γln−1
j−n−1 X
1
s=0
εn+s
+
X
s Y
! e
−γlk
291
j−n 1 Y εn+t + εn+t εj t=0 t=0
≤
!
.
k∈N
Using the first resolvent equation we pass from (εj )j∈N to ε 6= 0, if we take P r1 (ω, E, K) := 2(eγln−1 + k∈N e−γlk ). As ϕn |K = 1 the proof is complete. Lemma 5.2. Let EX and γ be given as in Theorem 4.9. (1) Taking a bounded function Q of compact support and an E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ], there is a B2 = B2 (E, Q) ∈ B(Ω) of full measure P(B2 ) = 1 and for each ω ∈ B2 there are constants s2 = s2 (ω, E, Q), s3 = s3 (ω, E, Q) and s4 (ω, E, Q), such that for all x ∈ Rd , |x| ≥ s3 (ω, E, Q) and for all ω ∈ B2 (E, Q) one gets: sup k(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Qk ≤ s2 (ω, E, Q) < ∞ ,
(16)
ε6=0 γ
sup k1x (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Qk ≤ s4 (ω, E, Q)e− 5 |x| .
(17)
ε6=0
(2) Taking d < D < r and an E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ], there is a set B2 = B2 (E, D, r) ∈ B(Ω) with P(B2 (E, D, r)) = 1 and for each ω ∈ B2 (E, D, r) there are t2 = t2 (ω, E, r), t3 = t3 (ω, E, D, r) and t4 = t4 (ω, E, D, r) ∈ R+ , such that for all x ∈ Rd satisfying |x| ≥ t3 (ω, E, D, r) and for all ω ∈ B2 (E, D, r) the following inequalities are valid : sup k(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 h·i−r k ≤ t2 (ω, E, r) < ∞ ,
(18)
ε6=0
sup k1x (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 h·i−r k ≤ t4 (ω, E, D, r)hxiD−r .
(19)
ε6=0
Proof. Let (lk )k∈N be the sequence of length scales from Theorem 4.9 and let ζ(D, r) be the positive solution of X + d − r(X+2d) 2X+2d = D − r. Choose ζ > 0 as ˜ = Q has compact support and choose some ζ ∈]0, ζ(D, r)[, in Theorem 4.9 if Q ˜ = h·i−r . As which fulfills the requirements 0 < ζ < ς − 2d of Theorem 4.9 if Q x+2d x 7→ x + d − r 2x+2d is increasing, we get ζ +d−
ζ + 2d r < ζ +d−r α 2ζ + 2d
≤ ζ(D, r) + d − r
ζ(D, r) + 2d =D−r <0 2ζ(D, r) + 2d
(20)
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
292
00119
H. Zenk
for the choice α ∈ ]1, 2ζ+2d ζ+2d [ in Theorem 4.9. For k ∈ N, E ∈ [0, EX ] define 11 l , 27l ) > pr ω ∈ Ω : δQ(ω, 0, γ, l Mk (E) : = Ω\ pr−1 k−1 k k−1 Υ(0,4lk ) Υ(0,4lk ) 3 and ∩ ω ∈ B1 (E) : sup k(HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 k ≤ζ+d k ε6=0
sup k109lk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) ε6=0
−1
− E − iε)
d WϕR27l k k
≤e
−γlk
,
then the multiscale analysis and the Wegner estimate imply (1−P(Mk (E)))k∈N ∈ l1 . So due to the Borel–Cantelli lemma and Theorem 5.1 the event B2 (E) := B1 (E) ∩ lim inf k→∞ Mk (E) satisfies P(B2 (E)) = 1. For each ω ∈ B2 (E) there is k0 = k0 (ω), such that ω ∈ Mk (E) for k ≥ k0 (ω). As ˜ ≤ sup k(1 − 10 )(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Qk ˜ sup k(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Qk 9lk ε6=0
0
ε6=0
˜ , + sup k109lk (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Qk 0
ε6=0
Theorem 5.1 implies, that it is enough to estimate supε6=0 k(1 − 109lk )(H(ω) − E − 0 ˜ for the proof of (16) and (18). Define Θk := 10 − 10 , then an Urysohn iε)−1 Qk 9lk
9lk−1
function ϕ27lk for Λ(0, 27lk ) satisfies Θk = Θk · ϕ27lk . Choosing τ27lk as described d d after Lemma 3.2, such that WϕR27l ◦ τ27lk = WϕR27l , an application of the geometric k k resolvent equation yields: ˜ 2 k(1 − 109lk0 )(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Quk =
X
˜ 2 kΘk (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Quk
k>k0
≤2
X
˜ 2 (kΘk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕ27lk Quk
k>k0
˜ 2) . + kΘk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 WϕR27l k2 kτ27lk (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Quk d
k
(21) The estimate supε6=0 k109lk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 WϕR27l k ≤ e−γlk is satisfied for d
k
k
ω ∈ Mk (E) and from the construction of lk = l0α we may assume τ27lk = Θk+1 τ27lk . As a consequence of (21) we obtain ˜ 2 (1 − 2e−2γlk0 )k(1 − 109lk )(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Quk ≤2
X k>k0
0
˜ 2 kΘk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕ27lk Quk
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
293
for ω ∈ B2 (E). Inserting 1 = 10lk−1 + (1 − 10lk−1 ), we are lead to an estimate of 3
X
3
−1
kΘk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)
˜ 2 ϕ27lk 10lk−1 Quk 3
k>k0
+
X
˜ 2. kΘk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕ27lk (1 − 10lk−1 )Quk
(22)
3
k>k0
Using δQ(ω, 0, γ, lk−1 , 27lk ) ≤ ω ∈ B2 (E), k ≥ k0 then
11 3 lk−1
and k(HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 k ≤ lkζ+d for
k1ylk−1 (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 10lk−1 k ≤ e
log bd
−(γ− l
k−1
)(3|y|−11lk−1 ) ζ+d lk
(23)
3
3
follows analog to (13) for lk−1 d lk−1 Z : Λ y, ∩ (Λ(0, 9lk )\Λ(0, 9lk−1 )) 6= ∅ . y ∈ Sk := y ∈ 3 3 Counting the elements y ∈ Sk and using 92 lk−1 ≤ |y| ≤ 92 lk + kΘk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 10lk−1 k ≤
lk−1 6 ,
we obtain
9 d(1− 1 ) lk α e− 4 γlk−1
,
3
hence the first sum in (22) is finite. Estimating the second sum of (22), we may ˜ = h·i−r , hence as a result of the Wegner estimate and the decay properties assume Q −r of h·i , X ˜ 2 kΘk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕ27lk (1 − 10lk−1 )Quk 3
k>k0
≤ kuk
2
X
−1 2
k(HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)
k
1+
k>k0
≤ 62r kuk2
X
r 2(ζ+d− α )
lk
lk−1 6
2 !−r
,
k≥k0
which is finite due to (20). l For the proof of (17) and (19), we may assume Λ(x, 1) ⊆ Λ(y, k−1 3 ) ∩ Λ(0, 9lk ) for some k ≥ k0 (ω), ω ∈ B2 (E) and y ∈ Sk . Hence we estimate ˜ Observing 109lk = 109lk ϕ27lk , an application supε6=0 k109lk 1ylk−1 (H(ω)− E − iε)−1 Quk. 3
of the geometric resolvent equation yields: ˜ k109lk 1ylk−1 (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Quk 3 d ˜ ≤ k109lk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 WϕR27l k k(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Quk k
˜ + k1ylk−1 (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕ27lk 10lk−1 Quk 3
3
˜ . + k1 lk−1 (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕ27lk (1 − 10lk−1 )Quk y
3
3
(24)
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
294
00119
H. Zenk
Due to the definition of B2 (E), we have sup k109lk (HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 WϕR27l k ≤ e−γlk , d
k
ε6=0
˜ is finite. and the proof of (16) and (18) shows, that supε6=0 k(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Quk γ From (23) we obtain k1ylk−1 (HΛ(0.27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 10lk−1 k ≤ e− 2 |y| if lk−1 is big 3
3
˜ has compact support, the third term in (24) vanishes for big k, hence enough. If Q ˜ = h·i−r , then due to (20), the definition of B2 (E) and the we obtain (17). If Q decay properties of h·i−r , we obtain ˜ k(HΛ(0,27lk ) (ω) − E − iε)−1 k · k(1 − 10lk−1 )Qk 3
≤ lkζ+d
1+
lk−1 6
2 !− r2 ≤ 6r lkD−r ,
which implies (19). Theorem 5.3. Choosing EX and γ as in Theorem 4.9 there is a Z0 ∈ B(Ω) with P(Z0 ) = 1, such that for each ω ∈ Z0 there is an I(ω) ∈ B([inf Σ, EX ]) with µ(I(ω)) = µ([inf Σ, EX ]), such that the following statements hold : (1) For all y ∈ Qd , ω ∈ Z0 and E ∈ I(ω), there are constants r3 (ω, E, y), r4 (ω, E, y) ∈ R+ , such that for all x ∈ Rd satisfying |x| ≥ r3 (ω, E, y) one gets: γ
sup k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1x k ≤ r4 (ω, E, y)e− 5 |x| . ε6=0
(2) Is ℘ of compact support, then for all ω ∈ Z0 and E ∈ I(ω) there are constants r3 (ω, E, ℘), r4 (ω, E, ℘) such that for all x, z ∈ Rd with |x| ≥ r3 (ω, E, ℘) and |z| < R we have: γ
sup k1x (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ℘(· − z)k ≤ r4 (ω, E, ℘)e− 5 |x| . ε6=0
(3) For n ∈ N, ω ∈ Z0 and E ∈ I(ω) there are r3 (ω, E, ς, n), r4 (ω, E, ς, n) ∈ R+ , such that for all x, z ∈ Rd with |x| ≥ r3 (ω, E, ς, n) and |z| < R the following inequality is valid : sup k1x (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 h· − zi− 2 −n 4 k ≤ r4 (ω, E, ς, n)hxi−n 4 . ς
ς
ς
ε6=0
Proof. Using Q = 1y in Lemma 5.2 we obtain B2 (E, y) ∈ B(Ω) with P(B2 (E, y)) = 1 and r3 (ω, E, y), r4 (ω, E, y) ∈ R+ for each ω ∈ B2 (E, y), such that for |x| ≥ r3 (ω, E, y) we get γ
sup k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1x k ≤ r4 (ω, E, y)e− 5 |y| . ε6=0
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
In the case that ℘ has compact support, we take M := Q := k℘k∞ 1M . Using Lemma 5.2 again we get
S |z|
295
supp(℘(· − z)) and
sup k1x (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ℘(· − z)k ε6=0
= sup k℘(· − z)(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1x k ≤ sup kQ(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1x k ε6=0
ε6=0 γ
= sup k1x (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 Qk ≤ r4 (ω, E, ℘)e− 5 |x| ε6=0
for ω ∈ B2 (E, Q), |x| ≥ r3 (ω, E, ℘) with P(B2 (E, Q)) = 1 and r3 (ω, E, ℘), r4 (ω, E, ℘) ∈ R+ . As 1 + |x − z|2 ≥ 12 (1 + |x|2 ) for |x| ≥ 4R, we estimate h· − zi−r ≤ ch·i−r for all |z| < R. Taking D = 2ς and r = 2ς + n 4ς we get sets B2 (E, 2ς , 2ς + n 4ς ) ∈ B(Ω) with P(B2 (E, 2ς , 2ς + n 4ς )) = 1 and r3 (ω, E, ς, n), r4 (ω, E, ς, n) ∈ R+ such that for |z| < R and |x| ≥ r3 (ω, E, ς, n): sup k1x(H(ω) − E − iε)−1 h· − zi− 2 −n 4 k ς
ς
ε6=0
= sup kh· − zi− 2 −n 4 (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1x k ≤ r4 (ω, E, ς, n)hxi−n 4 . ς
ς
ς
ε6=0
Hence for all E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ] the set B3 (E) :=
\
B2
n∈N
nς ς ς E, , + 2 2 4
! ∩
\
B2 (E, y)
y∈Qd
or \
B3 (E) :=
B2 (E, y) ∩ B2 (E, Q)
y∈Qd
has full measure P(B3 (E)) = 1. So [ B3 (E) × {E} ⊆ Ω × [inf Σ, EX ] Y := E∈[inf Σ,EX ]
has full outer measure (P ⊗ µ)∗ (Y ) = EX − inf Σ, because for all X ∈ B(Ω) ⊗ B([inf Σ, EX ]) with X ⊇ Y every section X(E) := {ω ∈ Ω : (ω, E) ∈ X} contains B3 (E), so Z EX Z EX P(X(E)) dE ≥ P(B3 (E)) dE EX − inf Σ ≥ (P ⊗ µ)(X) = inf Σ
inf Σ
= EX − inf Σ . This calculation provides us with examples of sets X ∈ B(Ω) ⊗ B([inf Σ, EX ]) with X ⊇ Y and (P ⊗ µ)(X) = (P ⊗ µ)∗ (Y ). Fixing such a set X and due to (P ⊗ µ)∗ (X\Y ) = 0, we can choose an N ∈ B(Ω) ⊗ B([inf Σ, EX ]) with N ⊇ X\Y and
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
296
00119
H. Zenk
(P ⊗ µ)(N ) = 0. Defining I := X\N ⊆ Y the sections I(ω) := {E ∈ [inf Σ, EX ] : (ω, E) ∈ I} and the function Ω → R+ ω 7→ µ(I(ω)) are measurable. Due to Fubini’s Theorem we get Z µ(I(ω)) dP(ω) = (P ⊗ µ)(I) = EX − inf Σ , Ω
so P{ω ∈ Ω : µ(I(ω)) < EX − inf Σ} = 0 and Z0 := Ω\{ω ∈ Ω : µ(I(ω)) < EX − inf Σ} ∈ B(Ω) has full P-measure, which completes the proof. 6. Proof of Localization Following the ideas of [13, 14] and [2], we note three results used for the proof of localization, before turning to the proof of our main theorem. 6.1. “ P-almost sure absolute continuity” Theorem 6.1. Let V ∈ L∞ (Rd , R) and Q ∈ L∞ (Rd , R+ ) and suppose that there is a nonempty open set K ⊆ Rd with Q · 1K ≥ 1K . Define H0 := −4 + V and for each α ∈ R take H(α) := H0 + αQ and let πα be the spectral decomposition of H(α). Then for each M ∈ B(R) with µ(M ) = 0 there is an N ∈ B(R) with µ(N ) = 0, such that πα (M ) = 0 for all α ∈ R\N. √ Proof. Choosing V = Q and B = Q in Part 1 of Lemma 2.1 we get Z √ √ 1 hΦ, Q πα (M ) Q Φi dα ≤ µ(M )kΦk2 2 R 1+α for all Φ ∈ L2 (Rd ). As µ(M ) = 0 we get N (M, Φ) ∈ B(R) with µ(N (M, Φ)) = 0 √ √ √ and hΦ, Q πα (M ) Q Φi = kπα (M ) Q Φk2 = 0 for all α ∈ R\N √ (M, Φ). Tak2 d (R ), we have πα(M ) Q Φ = 0 and ing a countable dense subset F ⊆ L √ √ 0 = g(H(α))πα (M ) Q Φ = πα (M )g(H(α)) Q Φ for all Φ ∈ L2 (Rd ),√ α ∈ S R\ φ∈F N (M, φ) and g ∈ L∞ (πα ). As Q·1K ≥ 1K the subspace lin{g(H(α)) QΦ : g ∈ L∞ (πα ), Φ ∈ L2 (Rd )} is dense in L2 (Rd ) due to [2, Proposition A2.2] and Theorem 6.1 is therefore proven. 6.2. Distributional eigenfunctions odinger operator Theorem 6.2. Let s > d2 and V ∈ L∞ (Rd , R). For the Schr¨ H = −4 + V we take a spectral control measure ν. Then for ν-almost every E ∈ R there is a distributional solution Ψ of the eigenvalue equation HΨ = EΨ with 1 (Rd )\{0} = {f : Rd → C : f 6= 0 measurable, h·i−s f ∈ H 1 (Rd )}. Ψ ∈ H−s
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
297
√ Proof. With S = −4 + 1 , T = h·is and γ(α) := (α − z)−m , α ∈ R, for a given z ∈ C\R, m ∈ N, m > 12 + d4 , [16, Theorem 3.6] shows, that the assumptions of [17, Theorems 1 and 2] are satisfied, so this theorem follows. 6.3. Perturbation theory Theorem 6.3. Let Z0 be the set constructed in Theorem 5.3 and for ω ∈ Z0 take E ∈ J(ω) := {E ∈ I(ω) : E is not an eigenvalue of H(ω)}, |z| < R, α ∈ R\{0} and 1 d a distributional solution Ψ ∈ H− ς (R ) of the equation 4
H(ω)Ψ + α℘(· − z)Ψ = EΨ .
(25)
Then Ψ decays as follows: • If ℘ is of compact support and γ as in Theorem 4.9, then there is a C = C(Ψ, α) > 0, such that for all y ∈ Rd one gets: γ
|Ψ(y)| ≤ Ce− 5 |y| . • In the long range case for all t > 0 there is a Ct = Ct (Ψ, α) > 0 such that |Ψ(y)| ≤ Ct hyi−t for all y ∈ Rd . Proof. All potentials are bounded, hence the subsolution estimate (see [1, The1 d orem 2.4]) implies for distributional solutions Ψ ∈ H− ς (R ) of (25), that ψ is a 4 continuous function and there is a constant c independent of y, such that Z |Ψ(x)| dx . |Ψ(y)| ≤ c |y−x|< 12
Application of the H¨ older inequality shows |Ψ(y)| ≤ ck1y ΨkL2 . To estimate y k1 ΨkL2 we note that the spectral calculus implies lim (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 (H(ω) − E)Φ = Φ − π(ω, {E})Φ
ε→0
for all E ∈ R and Φ ∈ D(H(ω)), where π(ω, ·) is the spectral decomposition of H(ω). Next we choose an Urysohn function ϕn of the box Λ(0, 2n + 1) with ϕn |Λ(0,2n−1) = 1 d −ς 2 d 2 d 1. Due to Ψ ∈ H− ς (R ) we get h·i 4 ∂j Ψ ∈ L (R ), hence ∇ϕn · ∇Ψ ∈ L (R ). 4 Inserting the distributional eigenvalue equation −4Ψ = EΨ − V (ω)Ψ − α℘(· − z)Ψ in the Leibniz product rule 4(ϕn Ψ) =
d X
[Ψ(∂k2 ϕn ) + ϕn ∂k2 Ψ + 2∂k ϕn ∂k Ψ]
k=1
= (4ϕn )Ψ + ϕn 4Ψ + 2∇ϕn · ∇Ψ implies ϕn Ψ ∈ D(−4). As E ∈ J(ω) is not an eigenvalue of H(ω), we conclude lim (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 (H(ω) − E)ϕn Ψ = ϕn Ψ .
ε→0
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
298
00119
H. Zenk
Given y ∈ Qd we choose n ∈ N with Λ(y, 1) ⊆ Λ(0, 2n − 1), then inserting (H(ω) − E)ϕn Ψ:
k1y Ψk = k1y ϕn Ψk = 1y lim (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 (H(ω) − E)(ϕn Ψ) ε→0
= 1y lim (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 (−(4ϕn )Ψ − 2∇ϕn · ∇Ψ − α℘(· − z)ϕn Ψ) ε→0
≤ sup k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 (4ϕn )Ψk ε6=0
+ 2 sup k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ∇ϕn · ∇Ψk ε6=0
+ |α| sup k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ℘(· − z)ϕn Ψk .
(26)
ε6=0
As supp ∂ β ϕn ⊆ Λ(0, 2n + 1)\Λ(0, 2n − 1) =: M (n) for all β ∈ Nd0 with |β| ≥ 1 we get k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 4ϕn Ψk X k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1x k k1M(n) Ψk , ≤ k4ϕn k∞ x∈Zd |x|=n
and k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ∇ϕn · ∇Ψk X k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 1x k k1M(n) ∂ k Ψk . ≤ dk∇ϕn k∞ x∈Zd |x|=n ς
As k1M(n) ∂ k Ψk, k1M(n) Ψk ≤ (1 + (n + 12 )2 ) 8 kΨkH 1ς , we obtain a polynom p(n), 4
such that after inserting the estimates of Theorem 5.3 for |x| = n ≥ r3 (ω, E, y) γ
k1y Ψk ≤ p(n)kΨkH 1 ς e− 5 n + |α| sup k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕn ℘(· − z)Ψk . −
4
(27)
ε6=0
Estimating the last term of (27) we consider first the short range case for |y| ≥ r3 (ω, E, ℘) and for n big enough, such that ϕn ℘(· − z) = ℘(· − z) k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕn ℘(· − z)Ψk ≤ k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ℘(· − z)k k1supp ℘(· − z) Ψk γ
≤ r4 (ω, E, ℘)e− 5 |y| k1supp ℘(· − z) Ψk . Combining the results for n → ∞ we get γ
|Ψ(y)| ≤ ck1y Ψk ≤ c|α|r4 (ω, E, ℘)k1supp ℘(· − z) Ψke− 5 |y|
(28)
and this result extends to all y ∈ Rd by continuity of Ψ. In the long range case we ς have to do a sort of induction process. First note that h·−zi− 4 Ψ, ℘(·−z)Ψ ∈ L2 (Rd )
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
299
hence k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕn ℘(· − z)Ψk ≤ k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 (℘(· − z)h· − zi 4 )k kh· − zi− 4 ϕn Ψk ς
ς
≤ c1 kh· − zi− 4 ς (H(ω) − E + iε)−1 1y k kΨkH 1 ς . 3
−
4
Using Theorem 5.3 we estimate sup k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 h· − zi− 4 ς k ≤ r4 (ω, E, ς, 1)hyi− 4 ς
3
ε6=0
for |y| ≥ r3 (ω, E, ς, 1). Thus for n → ∞ Eq. (27) implies |Ψ(y)| ≤ ck1y Ψk ≤ cc1 |α|r4 (ω, E, ς, 1)kΨkH 1 ς hyi− 4 . ς
−
(29)
4
This estimate yields Ψ ∈ L2 (Rd ), so we are able to improve the estimate k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ϕn ℘(· − z)Ψk ≤ k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 ℘(· − z)k kΨk ≤ c1 kh· − zi−ς (H(ω) − E + iε)−1 1y k kΨk = c1 k1y (H(ω) − E − iε)−1 h· − zi−ς k kΨk in order to get |Ψ(y)| ≤ ck1y Ψk ≤ c|α|c1 r4 (ω, E, ς, 2)kΨkhyi−2 4 ς
for |y| ≥ r3 (ω, E, ς, 2). Continuing we end at |Ψ(y)| ≤ c|α|c1 kh·i(n−2) 4 Ψkr4 (ω, E, ς, n)hyi−n 4 ς
ς
for |y| ≥ r3 (ω, E, ς, n) and for n 4ς ≥ t. Choosing ς
Ct (Ψ, α) ≥ c|α|c1 r4 (ω, E, ς, n)kh·i(n−2) 4 Ψk , we get |Ψ(y)| ≤ Ct (Ψ, α)hyi−t for all y ∈ Rd . 6.4. Proof of the main theorem We first gather some facts from the last sections, which imply pure point spectrum for operators “perturbed” at site 0: As it was seen in the construction of Z0 , for each ω ∈ Z0 we have µ([inf Σ, EX ]\J(ω)) = 0. So due to Theorem 6.1 we get S(ω, z) ⊆ R with µ(R\S(ω, z)) = 0 and να,z,ω ([inf Σ, EX ]\J(ω)) = 0 for every ω ∈ Z0 , |z| < R and α ∈ S(ω, z), where να,z,ω is a spectral control measure of the operator H(ω) + α℘(· − z). On the other hand for να,z,ω -almost all E ∈ R there is 1 d a distributional solution Ψ ∈ H− ς (R ) of the eigenvalue equation (H(ω) + α℘(· − 4 z))Ψ = EΨ. Applying Theorem 6.3 for |z| < R and E ∈ J(ω) these distributional eigensolutions are L2 -eigenfunctions, decaying as stated in Theorem 6.3. Hence the interval [inf Σ, EX ] consists να,z,ω -almost sure of eigenvalues of H(ω)+α℘(· −z) and
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
300
00119
H. Zenk
σ(H(ω) + α℘(· − z)) ∩ [inf Σ, EX ] is therefore pure point. In the second step of the proof, we construct a set Z1 of full P-measure, such that for each ω ¯ ∈ Z1 the operator H(¯ ω ) equals such an operator perturbed at site 0 of pure point spectrum as we have just constructed. To do this we consider Ω as a product of the probability spaces ˆ P) ˆ = ((R × Rd )⊗(Zd \{0}) , (P0 ⊗ P1 )⊗(Zd \{0}) ) R = (R, P0 ), Rd = (Rd , P1 ) and (Ω, ˆ For each α ∈ R let ˆ ) ∈ Ω with ω00 ∈ R, ω000 ∈ Rd and ω ˆ ∈ Ω. writing ω = (ω00 , ω000 , ω d ˆ × R : (α, z, ω ˆ ) ∈ Z0 } denote the section through Z0 at α. As M (α) := {(ˆ ω, z) ∈ Ω Z ˆ ⊗ P1 )(M (α)) dP0 (α) , 1 = P(Z0 ) = (P R
ˆ ⊗ P1 )(M (α0 )) = 1. For (ˆ ˆ × Rd respectively ω, z) ∈ Ω we choose α0 ∈ R with (P d ¯ (z) = (¯ ω (z)j )j∈Zd and δ(α, z) = (δ(α, z)j )j∈Zd ∈ Ω taking (ω, z) ∈ Ω × R define ω ( ( (α0 , z) : j = 0 , (α, z) : j = 0 , and δ(α, z)j := (30) ω ¯ (z)j := 0 : j 6= 0 . ωj : j 6= 0 , Then we define ω(z) + δ(α, z)) : ω ¯ (z) ∈ Z0 , |z| < R, α ∈ S(¯ ω (z), z)} ⊆ Ω , Z1 := {(¯ Z2 := {ω ∈ Ω : H(ω) is pure point in [inf Σ, EX ] and the eigenfunctions decay as in Theorem 6.3} ⊆ Ω ˆ |z| < R the section through Z1 at (ˆ ω , z) and for ω ˆ ∈ Ω, ω , z) := {α ∈ R : ω ¯ (z) + δ(α, z) ∈ Z1 } . S1 (ˆ Using the definition of Z1 S1 (ˆ ω , z) = {α ∈ R : (¯ ω (z) + δ(α, z)) ∈ Z1 } ω (z), z)} = {α ∈ R : ω ¯ (z) ∈ Z0 , α ∈ S(¯ ( ∅:ω ¯ (z) ∈ / Z0 = S(¯ ω (z), z) : ω ¯ (z) ∈ Z0 ( ∅ : (ˆ ω, z) ∈ / M (α0 ) , = S(¯ ω (z), z) : (ˆ ω, z) ∈ M (α0 ) , ˆ ω (z)), z)) = 1 for all (ˆ ω , z) ∈ M (α0 ) we compute and as P(M (α0 )) = 1 and P0 (S(¯ Z Z ˆ ω) 1Z1 (α0 + α, z, ω ˆ ) dP0 (α) dP1 (z) dP(ˆ P(Z1 ) = Z
d ˆ Ω×R
R
Z
= Z
M(α0 )
R
Z
= M(α0 )
ˆ ω) 1S1 (ˆω,z) (α) dP0 (α) dP1 (z) dP(ˆ
R
ˆ ω) 1S(¯ω(z),z) (α) dP0 (α) dP1 (z) dP(ˆ
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
00119
Anderson Localization for a Multidimensional Model
301
Z ˆ ω) P0 (S(¯ ω (z), z)) dP1 (z) dP(ˆ
= M(α0 )
Z
ˆ ω ) dP1 (z) = 1 . dP(ˆ
= M(α0 )
In view of H(¯ ω (z)) + α℘(· − z) X ωj0 ℘(· − j − ωj00 ) + (α0 + α)℘(· − z) = H(¯ ω (z) + δ(α, z)) , = −4 + j∈Zd j6=0
we get Z1 ⊆ Z2 and hence the conclusion. Acknowledgments This paper is a summary of my diploma thesis [25] in mathematics and physics at Universit¨at Regensburg. I thank W. Hackenbroch, who initiated the theme; K. Barbey, who spent a lot of time in discussions of the forthcoming mathematical problems which were a great help making some arguments rigorous; U. Krey for having a look at the physical sight of the problem and V. Bach for various suggestions in the preparation of this article. References [1] H. Cycon, R. Froese, W. Kirsch and B. Simon, Schr¨ odinger Operators — with Application to Quantum Mechanics and Global Geometry, Texts and Monographs in Physics, Springer, 1987. [2] J. M. Combes and P. D. Hislop, “Localization for some continuous random Hamiltonians in d-dimensions”, J. Funct. Anal. 124 (1994) 149–180. [3] J. M. Combes and P. D. Hislop, “Landau Hamiltonians with random potentials: localization and the density of states”, Comm. Math. Phys. 177 (1996) 603–629. [4] R. Carmona and J. Lacroix, Spectral Theory of Random Schr¨ odinger Operators, Probability and Its Applications, Birkh¨ auser, 1990. [5] H. von Dreifus and A. Klein, “A new proof of localization in the Anderson tight binding model”, Comm. Math. Phys. 124 (1989) 285–299. [6] F. Delyon, Y. L´evy and B. Souillard, “Anderson localization for multidimensional systems at large disorder or low energy”, Comm. Math. Phys. 100 (1985) 463–470. [7] A. Figotin and A. Klein, “Localization of classical waves I: acoustic waves”, Comm. Math. Phys. 180 (1996) 439–482. [8] W. Fischer, H. Leschke and P. M¨ uller, “Spectral localization by Gaussian random potentials in multi-dimensional continuous space”, J. Statistical Phys. 101(5/6) (2000) 935–985. [9] J. Fr¨ ohlich and T. Spencer, “Absence of diffusion in the Anderson tight binding model for large disorder or low energy”, Comm. Math. Phys. 88 (1983) 151–184. [10] J. Fr¨ ohlich, F. Martinelli, E. Scoppola and T. Spencer, “A constructive proof of localization in Anderson tight binding model”, Comm. Math. Phys. 101 (1985) 21–46.
March 19, 2002 12:4 WSPC/148-RMP
302
00119
H. Zenk
[11] F. Germinet and A. Klein, “Bootstrap multiscale analysis and localization in random Media”, Comm. Math. Phys. 222 (2001) 415–448. [12] W. Hackenbroch and A. Thalmeier, Stochastische Analysis, Teubner 1994 [13] W. Kirsch, P. Stollmann and G. Stolz, “Localization for random perturbations of periodic Schr¨ odinger operators”, to appear in Random Operators and Stochastic Equations. [14] W. Kirsch, P. Stollmann and G. Stolz, “Anderson localization for random Schr¨ odinger operators with long range interactions”, preprint, 1997. [15] W. Kirsch, P. Stollmann and G. Stolz, “Anderson localization for random Schr¨ odinger operators with long range interactions”, Comm. Math. Phys. 195 (1998) 495–507. [16] T. Poerschke and G. Stolz, “On eigenfunction expansions and scattering theory”, Math. Z. 212 (1993) 337–357. [17] T. Poerschke, G. Stolz and J. Weidmann, “Expansions in generalized eigenfunctions of selfadjoint operators”, Math. Z. 202 (1989) 397–408. [18] M. Reed and B. Simon, Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics, IV. Analysis of Operators, Academic Press, New York, 1979. [19] B. Simon, “Lifschitz tails for the Anderson model”, J. Stat. Phys. 38(1/2) (1985) 65–76. [20] B. Simon and T. Wolff, “Singular continuous spectrum under rank one perturbation and localization for random Hamiltonians”, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 39 (1986) 75–90. [21] P. Stollmann, Caught by Disorder, Bound States in Random Media, Birkh¨ auser Boston, 2001. [22] D. W. Stroock, Probability Theory, An Analytic View, Cambridge University Press 1993. [23] P. Walters, An Introduction to Ergodic Theory, Graduate Texts in Mathematics 79, Springer, 1982. [24] J. Weidmann, Linear Operators in Hilbert Spaces, Graduate Texts in Mathematics Vol. 68, Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1980. [25] H. Zenk, Anderson–Lokalisierung bei Random Schr¨ odinger Operatoren in mehreren Dimensionen, Diplomarbeit Regensburg 1997 and Spektraleigenschaften von Schr¨ odingeroperatoren in ungeordneten Systemen untersucht mit Methoden der mathematischen Physik, Diplomarbeit, Regensburg, 1998.
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00118
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 3 (2002) 303–316 c World Scientific Publishing Company
FORMAL AND ANALYTIC DEFORMATIONS FROM WITT TO VIRASORO
L. GUERRINI Universit` a Degli Studi di Bologna Dipartimento di Matematica per le Scienze Economiche e Sociali Viale Filopanti 5, I-40126, Bologna, Italy
[email protected]
Received 2 March 2001 We introduce a new family WF of deformations of the Witt algebra W, F varying in the space of all polynomials with vanishing constant terms, and show the existence of an isomorphism of its formal and analytic completions with those of the Witt algebra. Central extensions of this algebra are considered and the existence of an isomorphism between their formal and analytic completions with those of the Virasoro algebra is proved. Keywords: Deformations; Witt algebra; Virasoro algebra.
1. Introduction Let (G, [· , ·]) be a complex Lie algebra. A formal deformation Gt of G is a formal power series X Fn (g, h)tn [g, h]t = [g, h] + n≥1
with Fn : G × G → G bilinear antisymmetric maps, such that # "∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ X X X X n m gn t , hm t = tj Fi (gn , hm ) n=0
m=0
t
j=0
i+n+m=j
is a Lie algebra structure on G[[t]], the space of formal power series on G in the complex parameter t. In particular the map F1 is a 2-cocycle on G with coefficients in the adjoint representation of G. Two deformations [· , ·]t and [· , ·]0t of G are said to be formally equivalent if there exists a transformation Φt : G → Gt ,
Φt = 1 +
∞ X i=1
303
ti ϕi
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
304
00118
L. Guerrini
with ϕi : G → G linear, such that for each g, h ∈ Gt Φt ([g, h]0t ) = [Φt (g), Φt (h)]t . A formal deformation equivalent to the null deformation is called trivial. One has the obvious notion of a deformation of order k and equivalence simply means that one replaces the formal power series by formal power series truncated at the order k. For k = 1, one speaks of infinitesimal deformations. Since two deformations beginning with [· , ·] + tF1 and [· , ·] + tG1 are equivalent up to order one if and only if F1 − G1 is a coboundary, one has that the second cohomology group H 2 (G, G) classifies equivalence classes of infinitesimal deformations. A Lie algebra is called formally rigid if each of its formal deformations is trivial, that is if there exists a Lie algebra isomorphism Gt ' G[[t]] over C[[t]] . It is a standard result [4] that H 2 (G, G) = 0 implies G is formally rigid. One has an actual deformation of the Lie algebra G if by replacing the parameter t by a number in a formal or order k deformation, one gets a Lie algebra structure on G. A Lie algebra G is called analytically rigid if, for small |t|, one has a Lie algebra isomorphism Gt ' G
over C .
The question whether formal rigidity implies analytic rigidity was investigated in [5–7] for certain special deformations Wf of the Witt algebra W, where the parameter f runs in the space of even polynomials with vanishing constant terms. Since Wf is a deformation of W and H 2 (W, W) = 0 is rigid [2], there should exist, for each f , a formal isomorphism Sf : Wf → W. The construction of this expected isomorphism however showed that one should work with suitable completions (adic and analytic) of the Lie algebras Wf and W. Moreover, it was proved [7] that this map is analytic in f , in the sense that there exists a neighborhood N of 0 in C ∞ (S 1 ) such that if M is any finite dimensional subspace of C ∞ (S 1 ), then, for f ∈ N ∩ M, Sf is holomorphic in f . Motivated by the fact that the Witt algebra W has a one-dimensional central extension, the Virasoro algebra Vir, and [2] H 2 (Vir, Vir) = 0, one could define central extensions of the family Wf and see if it is possible to extend the above results to the case of the centrally extended algebras, that is to construct explicitly the corresponding isomorphisms. In Sec. 2, a new family WF of deformations of the Witt algebra is introduced, the parameter F varying in the space of all polynomials with vanishing constant terms. Adic and analytic completions of this family are studied and it is showed that they are isomorphic to those of the family Wf . In Sec. 3, an isomorphism between the completions of the Lie algebras Wf and WF is shown. The study of central extensions of the family Wf is therefore reduced to those of the family WF .
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00118
Formal and Analytic Deformations
305
In Sec. 4, a one-dimensional central extension VirF of WF is defined and a formal isomorphism between the adic completions of Vir and VirF is explicitly constructed. In Sec. 5, the results of the previous section are extended to the analytic completions of the Lie algebras Vir and VirF . 2. The Algebra WF and Its Formal and Analytic Completions Let X=
M
CLn
n∈Z
be an infinite dimensional vector space over C with basis {Ln }n∈Z . One can make X into a Lie algebra by defining multiplication through [Lm , Ln ] = (n − m)Lm+n for all m, n ∈ Z. This Lie algebra is called the Witt algebra and is denoted by W. This algebra arises naturally when one considers the space of complex vector fields on the unit circle S 1 = {e2πiθ , θ ∈ R}, that is the space of linear operators gd/dθ on the space of complex valued C ∞ -functions on S 1 . W is in fact the subspace of vector fields gd/dθ for which g has a finite Fourier series expansion, the Lie algebra structure given by [gd/dθ, hd/dθ] = (gdh/dθ − hdg/dθ) d/dθ . Let z = e2πiθ , then, through the assignment g(z) → g(z)d/dz, one can identify the Lie algebra W with the space of Laurent polynomials X cm z m (cm ∈ C) g= |m|≤M
with bracket [g, h] = gh0 − g 0 h . A basis for this space is clearly given by ˆln = z n+1 (n ∈ Z). Let P be the space of polynomials with vanishing constant terms and let F ∈ P. Let WF be the Lie algebra whose vector space structure is the same as the algebra W and bracket [g, h]F = (1 + F )[g, h] . ˆ F }F ∈P is a deformation of W with the infinite Since W0 = W, the family {W dimensional parameter space P. ˆ be the adic completion of W, that is one replaces the underlying vector Let W space of Laurent polynomials by the vector space of formal Laurent series X cm z m m≥−M
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
306
00118
L. Guerrini
and bracket structure is the same. Let Pˆ be the space {ˆ u1 z + uˆ2 z 2 + · · · (ˆ uj ∈ C)}. ˆ ˆ The definition of [· , ·]F makes sense also for g, h ∈ W, F ∈ P and [· , ·]F is continuous in the adic topology. ˆ →W ˆ (k ≥ 1) be the continuous linear map Let Tk : W T k g = ak F k g with {ak }k≥1 scalars uniquely determined from the power series identity in z (1 + z)
∞ Y
(1 + ak z k ) = 1 .
k=1
Since [7] ak =
X k d k (−1)k + (−1) d add , k k 1≤d
for all k ≥ 1 ,
d|k
one has
−1 , ak = 1, 0,
if k = 1 , if k = 2r , r > 1 ,
(2.1)
if 1 < k 6= 2 . r
ˆ and W ˆF . The next result shows the existence an isomorphism between W Theorem 2.1. Let SF =:
∞ Y
(1 + Tk ) :
k=1
denote the limit (in the adic topology) lim (1 + T1 )(1 + T2 ) · · · (1 + TN ) .
N →∞
ˆ and W ˆF. Then SF is an isomorphism between W Proof. Same proof as [7, Theorem 14]. ˆ ∞ (respectively W ˆ ∞ ) be the analytic analogue of the Lie algebras W ˆ Let W F ˆ ˆ (respectively WF ), that is the underlying vector space W is replaced by the space ˆ ∞ = C ∞ (S 1 ) . W Let the parameter F ∈ C ∞ (S 1 ). C ∞ (S 1 ) is a Frechet space with topology determined by the norms k · k(m) (m ≥ 1) r X d sup r g(e2πiθ ) kgk(m) = dθ 0≤r≤m
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00118
Formal and Analytic Deformations
307
with k · k(1) ≤ k · k(2) ≤ · · · ≤ k · k(m) ≤ · · · For r = 0, 1, 2, . . . , gn → g if and only if (dr /dθr )gn → (dr /dθr )g uniformly. One speaks of norms k · k(m) instead of seminorms since this is sufficient for the application one has in mind. Let C ∞ (S 1 )(m) be the completion of C ∞ (S 1 ) by k · k(m) . Then C ∞ (S 1 ) ⊂ · · · ⊂ C ∞ (S 1 )(m) ⊂ C ∞ (S 1 )(m−1) ⊂ · · · ⊂ C ∞ (S 1 )(1) and C ∞ (S 1 ) =
∞ \
C ∞ (S 1 )(m) .
m=1
Sobolev’s classical result [1] that says the above can be achieved by another set of norms X X (m) = |n|r |ˆ g (n)| , kgk
0≤r≤m n
g k1 , kgk(0) = kˆ
P with gˆ(n) the Fourier coefficients of g, g(e2πiθ ) = n∈Z gˆ(n)e2πinθ . The l1 -norm will be used since one needs the fact l1 is a Banach algebra. The next result says that under some restrictions on F the formal isomorphism SF of Theorem 2.1 is analytic. Theorem 2.2. If sup |F | < 1 and kF k(0) < 1, then the map SF =:
∞ Y
(1 + Tk )
k=1
ˆ ∞. ˆ ∞ and W is an isomorphism between W F Proof. Same proof as [7, Theorem 25]. Corollary 2.1. Let M = {F ∈ C ∞ (S 1 ) : sup |F | < 1 and ||F ||(0) < 1} and F be any finite dimensional subspace of C ∞ (S 1 ). Then the map F → SF is analytic from M ∩ F into the space of continuous linear maps C ∞ (S 1 ) → C ∞ (S 1 ).
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
308
00118
L. Guerrini
3. Relations Between the Lie Algebras Wf and WF In [7], a family of deformations Wf of the Witt algebra W parametrized by the space E of even polynomials with vanishing constant terms was defined. The vector space structure is the same as W and Lie bracket (g, h odd) [g, h]f = (1 + f )[g, h] , (g, h even) [g, h]f = [g, h] , [g, h]f = (1 + f )[g, h] + 1 f 0 gh , (g even, h odd) 2 where 0 denotes differentiation with respect to z, f ∈ E and g, h ∈ W. Since ˆ 0 = W, the family {W ˆ f }f ∈E is a deformation of W with the infinite dimensional W parameter space E. The relation between the completions of the algebras WF and Wf is as follows. Theorem 3.1. For any f ∈ E and F ∈ P, one has ˆF . ˆf ' W W ˆ ([7]) and W ˆ 'W ˆ F (Theorem 2.1). ˆf ' W Proof. This follows from W Theorem 3.2. If f and F are close to 0 in the C ∞ (S 1 )-topology, then ˆ F∞ . ˆ f∞ ' W W ˆ ([7]) and W ˆ 'W ˆ ∞ (Theorem 2.2). ˆ∞ ' W Proof. This follows from W f F These two theorems in particular say that the study of central extensions of the ˆ ∞ can be done in term of those of W ˆ F and W ˆ ∞. ˆ f and W algebras W f F ˆ F of VirF and the Isomorphism 4. Adic Completions Vir ˆ F ' Vir ˆ Vir Let VirF = WF ⊕ Cλ be the one-dimensional central extension of WF defined for all g, h ∈ W by ˜ h; F )λ , [g, h]F,Vir = (1 + F )[g, h] ⊕ χ(g, [g, λ]F,Vir = 0 , [λ, h]F,Vir = 0 ,
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00118
Formal and Analytic Deformations
with
χ(g, ˜ h; F ) = χ((1 + F )g, (1 + F )h) + Res0
3 2 5 F − F 4 2
309
z −2 [g, h] ,
Res0 the residue in zero and χ the 2-cocycle of the Witt algebra I 13 g 0 h00 dz . χ(g, h) = − 12πi On the basis elements this means 13 0 . χ(ˆlm , ˆln ) = − (m3 − m)δm+n 6 If F = 0, the family VirF reduces to the Virasoro algebra, that is it is a deformation of Vir. Introducing a parameter t, that is replacing F with tF , the central extension can be rewritten as ˜ h; tF ) [g, h]t = (1 + tF )[g, h] ⊕ χ(g, = [g, h]Vir + tC11 (g, h; F ) + t2 C22 (g, h; F ) , that is it can be viewed as a formal deformation of Vir in the parameter t. ˆ Vir ˆ F of the These definitions immediately extend to the adic completions Vir, algebras Vir, VirF . ˆ and Vir ˆ F In order to construct the expected formal isomorphism between Vir one needs first to define some linear maps. ˆ → Vir ˆ (k ≥ 1) be the continuous linear map Let T˜k : Vir ( T˜k (λ) = 0 , T˜k (g) = Tk (g) ⊕ Res0 (Ak F k z −2 g) , where {Ak }k≥1 are the scalars uniquely determined from the following power series identity in z ∞ X 1 3 2 5 Ak z k z z = − . (4.1) k 4 2 (1 + z)2 Y k=1 (1 + ar z r )(1 + z) r=1
Lemma 4.1. Let k ≥ 2. Then s−2 X X 3 13 X i) + k− , (−A (−AN ) + 2 4 4 r=1 2r
if k even ,
if k odd ,
2r+1 |(k−N )
where s denotes the smallest positive integer such that k < 2j for all j > 2.
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
310
00118
L. Guerrini
Proof. By (2.1) one has ∞ X N =1
AN z N N Y
(1 + ar z r )(1 + z)
r=1
=
A1 z + 1 − z2
X N ≥2 N =2i ,i≥1
AN z N + 1 − z 2N
X
AN z N
N ≥3 N 6=2i ,i≥1
N Y
(1 + ar z r )(1 + z)
r=1
=
X AN z N X A1 z + + 2 2N 1−z 1−z i
X
AN z N
r≥1 2r
N =2 i≥1
N Y
(1 + ar z r )(1 + z)
r=1
=
X AN z N X A1 z + + 1 − z2 1 − z 2N i
r≥1 2r
N =2 i≥1
Since
X
3 2 5 z − z 4 2
AN z N . 1 − z 2r+1
∞
X 1 = Ck z k , 2 (1 + z) k=1
where
5 − , 2 3 13 Ck = k− , 4 4 13 − k + 3 , 4 4 then it follows from (4.1) that if k is odd, X X A1 + r≥1
if k = 1 , if k even , k > 2 , if k odd , k > 3 , k ≥ 3, AN = −
2r
3 13 k+ . 4 4
Therefore Ak = −
s−2 X
X
r=1
2r
AN −
13 (k − 1) , 4
with s denoting the smallest positive integer such that k < 2j . If k is even, k ≥ 2, then s−2 X X X 3 13 k− A2i + AN + Ak = 4 4 r+1 i≥1 r=1 r 2i+1 |(k−2i )
2
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00118
Formal and Analytic Deformations
311
and so Ak = −
X i≥1 2i+1 |(k−2i )
A2i −
s−2 X
X
r=1
2r
AN +
3 13 k− . 4 4
with s denoting the smallest positive integer such that k < 2j . Corollary 4.1. (1) If k is odd, k ≥ 3, then Ak = 2M−2 A3 , where M is the smallest positive integer such that k < 2i (i ≥ 1) and A3 = −
13 . 2
In particular, Ai = Aj for all i, j odd such that 2s < i, j < 2s+1 . (2) If k is even, k = 2s , s ≥ 1, then Ak =
13 (k − 1) . 4
(3) If k is even, 2s < k < 2s+1 , then Ak = −Ai for all i, 2s < i < 2s+1 . If k is odd, k ≥ 1, then Ak < 0 and if k is even, k ≥ 2, then Ak > 0. Proof. By the previous lemma using induction and the fact A3 = −(13/2). In particular, for all k ≥ 1 one has |Ak | ≤
13 2 k . 4
Theorem 4.1. Let ψk = 1 + tk T˜k ˆ kF be the Lie algebra structure of Vir ˆ defined inductively in k by and let Vir [g, h]kt = ψk−1 [ψk (g), ψk (h)]k−1 t = [g, h]Vir + tk+1 C1k+1 (g, h; F ) + tk+2 C2k+2 (g, h; F ) + · · · , with C1k+1 (g, h; F ) = ωk+1 (g, h; F ) ⊕ V1k+1 (g, h; F ) ,
(4.2)
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
312
00118
L. Guerrini
and ωk+1 defined by δTk+1 (g, h) = ωk+1 (g, h; F ) , δ the coboundary operator. Then the map T˜k+1 satisfies δ T˜k+1 (g, h) = C1k+1 (g, h; F )
ˆ . (g, h ∈ Vir)
Proof. It is by induction on k. The case k = 1 is straightforward. Suppose the statement is true for r = 2, 3, . . . , k, we prove it is true for k + 1. By the inductive hypothesis and the fact [g, h]kt = ψk−1 [ψk (g), ψk (h)]k−1 t −1 = ψk−1 ψk−1 · · · ψ1−1 [ψ1 · · · ψk−1 ψk (g), ψ1 · · · ψk−1 ψk (h)]t # " k k k Y Y Y r ˜ −1 r˜ r˜ = (1 + t Tr ) (1 + t Tr )g, (1 + t Tr )h r=1
r=1
k Y
k Y
=
(1 + tr T˜r )−1
r=1
r=1
t
(1 + tr T˜r )2 ((1 + tF )[g, h])
r=1 k Y
⊕χ ˜
k Y
(1 + t T˜r )g, r
r=1
!! (1 + t T˜r )h r
r=1
it follows [g, h]kt =
k Y
(1 + ar F r tr )(1 + tF )[g, h]
r=1
⊕χ
k Y
r r
(1 + ar F t )(1 + tF )g,
r=1
k Y
! r r
(1 + ar F t )(1 + tF )h
r=1
k X + Res0 r r=1 Y
−Ar tr F r s
z
s
(1 + as t F )(1 + tF )
−2
[g, h]
s=1
+ Res0
3 2 2 5 t F − tF 4 2
Y k
! (1 + ar F r tr )2 z −2 [g, h] .
r=1
Therefore [g, h]kt = [g, h]Vir + tk+1 C1k+1 (g, h; F ) + tk+2 C2k+2 (g, h; F ) + · · · ,
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00118
Formal and Analytic Deformations
313
where C1k+1 (g, h; F ) = ωk+1 (g, h; F ) ⊕ Res0 (Ak+1 F k+1 z −2 [g, h]) − ak+1 (χ(F k+1 g, h) + χ(g, F k+1 h)) having used Lemma 4.1. It is now immediate that δ T˜k+1 (g, h) = C1k+1 (g, h; F ). The previous theorem essentially says ψ −1
ψ −1
ψ −1
k 1 2 ˆ 1F ' ˆ 2F ' · · · ' ˆ kF . ˆ F ' Vir Vir Vir Vir
ˆ This ˆ F and Vir. As k → ∞ one should expect to get an isomorphism between Vir is in fact what the next result says. Theorem 4.2. Let S˜F =:
∞ Y
(1 + T˜k ) :
k=1
be lim :
N →∞
N Y
(1 + T˜k ) :
k=1
where : : means that the product is taken as (1 + T˜1 )(1 + T˜2 ) · · · (1 + T˜N ) and the limit is in the adic topology. Then S˜F is an isomorphism between the Lie algebras ˆ and Vir ˆ F. Vir Proof. It follows from the definitions and the above as k → ∞ and t = 1. ˆ ∞ and the Isomorphism Vir ˆ ∞ ' Vir ˆ ∞ 5. Analytic Completions Vir F F ∞
ˆ Let Vir be the smooth analogue of the Virasoro algebra, that is the Lie algebra whose vector space structure is C ∞ (S 1 ) ⊕ Cλ, where ( ) X ∞ 1 n −M gn z , |gn | = O(|n| ) for all M > 0 C (S ) = g = n∈Z ∞
ˆ F be the vector space C ∞ (S 1 ) ⊕ Cλ with and bracket [· , ·]Vir . Similarly let Vir ∞ 1 bracket [· , ·]F,Vir . Let F ∈ C (S ). The aim is now to make sense of the map S˜F , defined in Theorem 4.2, as a continuous invertible transformation. Let B [m] be the Banach space C ∞ (S 1 )(m) ⊕ Cλ with norm k · k[m] = k · k(m) + k · kC . Proposition 5.1. Let k ≥ 1, m ≥ 1 and F ∈ C ∞ (S 1 ) be such that sup |F | < 1. Then
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
314
00118
L. Guerrini
(1) the operators T˜k : B [m] → B [m] are continuous; (2) the operators 1 + T˜k : B [m] → B [m] are continuous and invertible. Proof. (1) Let g ⊕ αλ ∈ B [m] . By definition, (2.1) and (4.2) one has kT˜k gk(m) ≤ kF k gk(m) X = kDr (F k g)k(0) 0≤r≤m
(0)
X X r
s k r−s
= (F )D (g) D
s
0≤r≤m 0≤s≤r ≤
X
2r kF k k(r) kgk(r)
0≤r≤m
≤ 2m+1 (m + 1)kF k k(m) kgk(m) , and | Res0 (Ak F k z −2 g)| ≤ 4k 2 (sup |F |)k kgk(m) . Therefore kTek (g ⊕ αλ)k[m] = kTk gk(m) + | Res0 (Ak F k z −2 g)| ≤ (2m+1 (m + 1)kF k k(m) + 4k 2 (sup |F |)k )kg ⊕ αλ)k[m] . (2) The map 1 + T˜k is clearly continuous by (1) and its inverse is −Ak F k −2 1 −1 ˜ g ⊕ Res0 z g , (1 + Tk ) (g ⊕ αλ) = 1 + ak F k 1 + ak F k the element 1 + ak F k being never 0 on S 1 (k ≥ 1) since sup |F | < 1. Proposition 5.2. Let m ≥ 1 and F ∈ C ∞ (S 1 ), sup |F | < 1 and kF k(0) < 1. Then ∞ X
kT˜k k[m] < ∞ .
k=1
Proof. By Proposition 5.1 ∞ X
kT˜k k[m] ≤ 2m+1 (m + 1)
k=1
∞ X
kF k k(m) + 4
k=1
Since sup |F | < 1, by the Ratio test ∞ X k=1
k 2 (sup |F |)k < ∞ .
∞ X k=1
k 2 (sup |F |)k .
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
00118
Formal and Analytic Deformations
315
Since the behavior of a series does not change if one deletes a finite number of its terms, let consider the series ∞ X kF k k(m) . k=m+1
Now one has ∞ X
kF k k(m) =
k=m+1
∞ X
k=m+1
X
kDr (F k )k(0)
0≤r≤m
(0)
X X r!
s1 sk (D F ) · · · (D F ) =
s +···+s =r s1 ! · · · sk ! k=m+1 0≤r≤m 1 k
s ≥0 ∞ X
j
∞ X X ≤ k=m+1
≤
0≤r≤m
∞ X
k=m+1
X
X s1 +···+sk =r sj ≥0
r! (kF k(m) )m (kF k(0) )k−m s1 ! · · · sk !
k m (kF k(m) )m (kF k(0) )k−m
0≤r≤m
≤ (m + 1)(kF k(m) )m
∞ X
k m (kF k(0) )k−m .
k=m+1
So again by the Ratio test, kF k < 1, one has that the series is convergent. The fact k > m is used to say that in each (s1 , . . . , sk ) at least k − m of the sj have to be 0. (0)
Theorem 5.1. Let m ≥ 1 and F ∈ C ∞ (S 1 ), sup |F | < 1 and kF k(0) < 1. Let S˜N = (1 + T˜1 )(1 + T˜2 ) · · · (1 + T˜N ) . Then, as N → ∞, the map S˜N : B [m] → B [m] is convergent in the norm topology to a continuous invertible linear operator S˜F = limN →∞ (1 + T˜1 )(1 + T˜2 ) · · · (1 + T˜N ). Its inverse is given by S˜F−1 = lim (1 + T˜N−1 )(1 + T˜N−1−1 ) · · · (1 + T˜1−1 ) . N →∞
Proof. Same proof as [7, Lemma 20]. Theorem 5.2. Let F ∈ C ∞ (S 1 ) be such that sup |F | < 1 and kF k(0) < 1. Then the operator ∞ Y ˆ ∞ → Vir ˆ ∞ (1 + T˜k ) : Vir S˜F =: F k=1
is an isomorphism.
March 19, 2002 12:11 WSPC/148-RMP
316
00118
L. Guerrini
Proof. Same proof as [7, Lemma 22]. P If F is a Laurent polynomial, that is |n|≤M cn z n , then it is enough to have X |cn | < 1 . kF k(0) = |n|≤M
Corollary 5.1. Let M be a finite subspace of C ∞ (S 1 ) and N = {F ∈ C ∞ (S 1 ) : sup |F | < 1 and kF k(0) < 1} . Let B be the space of all continuous linear operators C ∞ (S 1 )⊕Cλ → C ∞ (S 1 )⊕Cλ. Then the map Ψ : M ∩ N → B, Ψ(F ) = S˜F is an analytic map. Proof. This follows from the previous results and Morera’s theorem. Acknowledgments I would like to thank all those people who helped me in many different ways during the most testing period of my life (1998–2000). References [1] R. A. Adams, Sobolev Spaces, Academic Press, 1975. [2] A. Fialowski, “Deformations of some infinite-dimensional Lie algebras”, J. Math. Phys. 31(6) (1990) 1340–1343. [3] M. Flato and D. Sternheimer, “Deformations of Poisson brackets, separate and joint analyticity in group representations, nonlinear group representations and physical applications”, Harmonic Analysis and Representations of Semisimple Lie Groups, eds. J. A. Wolf, M. Cahen and M. De Wilde, Dordrecht, 1980, Mathematical Physics and Applied Mathematics, Vol. 5, pp. 385–448. [4] M. Gerstenhaber, “On the deformation of rings and algebras”, Ann. Math. 79 (1964) 59–103. [5] L. Guerrini, “Construction and deformation of infinite dimensional Lie algebras, doctoral thesis, University of California, Los Angeles, 1998. [6] L. Guerrini, “Formal and analytic deformations of the Witt algebra”, Lett. Math. Phys. 46 (1998) 121–129. [7] L. Guerrini, “Formal and analytic rigidity of the Witt algebra”, Rev. Math. Phys. 11(3) (1999) 303–320.
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 3 (2002) 317–342 c World Scientific Publishing Company
REPRESENTATIONS OF REFLECTION ALGEBRAS
A. I. MOLEV School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
[email protected] E. RAGOUCY LAPTH, Chemin de Bellevue, BP 110, F-74941 Annecy-le-Vieux cedex, France
[email protected]
Received 30 July 2001 Revised 19 October 2001 We study a class of algebras B(n, l) associated with integrable models with boundaries. These algebras can be identified with coideal subalgebras in the Yangian for gl(n). We construct an analog of the quantum determinant and show that its coefficients generate the center of B(n, l). We develop an analog of Drinfeld’s highest weight theory for these algebras and give a complete description of their finite-dimensional irreducible representations.
1. Introduction A central role in the theory of integrable models in statistical mechanics is played by the Yang–Baxter equation R12 (u − v)R13 (u − w)R23 (v − w) = R23 (v − w)R13 (u − w)R12 (u − v) ;
(1.1)
see Baxter [1]. Here R(u) is a linear operator R(u) : V ⊗ V → V ⊗ V on the tensor square of a vector space depending on the spectral parameter u. Both sides of the Yang–Baxter equation are linear operators on the triple tensor product V ⊗ V ⊗ V and the indices of R(u) indicate the copies of V where R(u) acts; e.g., R12 (u) = R(u) ⊗ 1. A simplest nontrivial solution of the equation is provided by the Yang R-matrix R(u) = 1 − P u−1 ,
(1.2)
where P is the permutation operator P : ξ ⊗ η 7→ η ⊗ ξ in the space C ⊗ Cn . The Yang R-matrix emerges in the XXX or six vertex model [1]. It gives rise to an algebra with the defining relations given by the RTT relation n
R(u − v)T1 (u)T2 (v) = T2 (v)T1 (u)R(u − v)
(1.3)
(we discuss the precise meaning of this relation below in Sec. 2). The algebraic structures associated with the Yang–Baxter equation were studied in the works of 317
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
318
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
Faddeev’s school in the 70-s and 80-s in relation with the quantum inverse scattering method; see e.g. Takhtajan–Faddeev [30], Kulish–Sklyanin [12]. In particular, a central element called the quantum determinant in the algebra defined by (1.3) was introduced by Izergin and Korepin [10] in the case of two dimensions. The basic ideas and formulas associated with the quantum determinant for an arbitrary n are given in the paper Kulish–Sklyanin [12]. Tarasov [31, 32] described irreducible representations (monodromy matrices) in the case n = 2. In was independently realized by Drinfeld and Jimbo around 1985 that the algebraic structures associated with the quantum inverse scattering method are naturally described by the language of Hopf algebras. This marked the beginning of the theory of quantum groups [8] (a historic background of this theory is given in the book by Chari and Pressley [4]). In his paper [7] Drinfeld introduced a remarkable class of quantum groups called the Yangians. For any simple Lie algebra a the Yangian Y(a) is a canonical deformation of the universal enveloping algebra U(a[x]) for the polynomial current Lie algebra a[x]. The Hopf algebra defined by the RT T relation (1.3) with the Yang R-matrix (1.2) is called the Yangian for the general linear Lie algebra gl(n) and denoted Y(gl(n)) or Y(n). The significance of the Yangians was explained by Drinfeld [7] who showed that the rational solutions of the Yang–Baxter equation (1.1) are described by the Yangian representations. The irreducible finite-dimensional representations were classified in his subsequent paper [9]. The results turned out to be parallel to those for the semisimple Lie algebras. Every irreducible finite-dimensional representation of Y(a) is a quotient of the corresponding universal highest weight module where the components of the highest weight satisfy some dominance conditions. Explicit constructions of all such representations for the Yangians Y (sl(2)) and Y (2) are given in Tarasov [31, 32] and Chari–Pressely [3]. However, apart from this case, the explicit structure of the Yangian representations remains unknown even in the case of gl(n) (a description of a class of generic and tame representations is given in [19] and [22] via Gelfand–Tsetlin bases). Sklyanin [29] introduced a class of algebras associated with integrable models with boundaries (we call them the reflection algebras in this paper). His approach was inspired by Cherednik’s scattering theory [6] for factorized particles on the half-line. Instead of the RT T relation the algebras are defined by the reflection equation R(u − v)B1 (u)R(u + v)B2 (v) = B2 (v)R(u + v)B1 (u)R(u − v) .
(1.4)
In [29] commutative subalgebras in the reflection algebras (in the case of two dimensions) were constructed and the algebraic Bethe ansatz was described. Moreover, an analog of the quantum determinant for these algebras was introduced and some properties of the highest weight representations were discussed. Different versions of (1.4) were employed in the works Reshetikhin–SemenovTian-Shansky [28], Olshanski [24] and Noumi [23]. Similar classes of algebras were studied in Kulish–Sklyanin [13], Kuznetsov–Jørgensen–Christiansen [14],
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
319
Koornwinder and Kuznetsov [11, 15]. Recently, algebras of this kind were discussed in the physics literature in connection with the NLS model, they describe the integrals of motion of the model; see Liguori–Mintchev–Zhao [16], Mintchev–Ragoucy– Sorba [17]. In this paper we consider a family of reflection algebras B(n, l). They are defined as associative algebras whose generators satisfy two types of relations: the reflection equation and the unitary condition; see (2.5) and (2.6) below. The unitary condition allows us to identify B(n, l) with a subalgebra in the gl(n)-Yangian Y (n); see Theorem 3.1. This condition was not explicitly used in [29], but it appears e.g. in ˜ l) such that B(n, l) is a quotient of [11]. If we omit it we get a larger algebra B(n, ˜ l) by an ideal generated by some central elements. The consequence of this fact B(n, is that the finite-dimensional irreducible representations of both algebras B(n, l) and ˜ l) are essentially the same. B(n, On the other hand, the subalgebra B(n, l) turns out to be a (left) coideal in the Hopf algebra Y (n); see Proposition 3.3. This allows us to regard the tensor product L ⊗ V of an Y(n)-module L and a B(n, l)-module V as a B(n, l)-module; cf. [29, Proposition 2]. We show that the center of B(n, l) is generated by the coefficients of an analog of the quantum determinant which we call, following [21], the Sklyanin determinant. We derive a formula which expresses the Sklyanin determinant in terms of the quantum determinant for the Yangian Y(n). The aforementioned properties of the algebras B(n, l) exhibit much analogy with the twisted Yangians introduced by Olshanski [24]; see also [21] for a detailed exposition. Moreover, in two dimensions the algebras B(2, 0) and B(2, 1) turn out to be respectively isomorphic to the symplectic and orthogonal twisted Yangians; see Sec. 4.2. This analogy also extends to the representation theory; cf. [20]. We prove here that, as for the twisted Yangians, the Drinfeld highest weight theory [9] is applicable to the algebras B(n, l). Every finite-dimensional irreducible representation of B(n, l) is highest weight, and given an irreducible highest weight module, we produce necessary and sufficient conditions for it to be finite-dimensional. These conditions are expressed in terms of the Drinfeld polynomials in a way similar to [9] and [20] for the Yangians and twisted Yangians. Note, however, an essential difference: here all Drinfeld polynomials must satisfy a symmetry condition; see Theorem 4.6. In particular, all of them have even degree. In conclusion, we would like to emphasize the common feature of the three classes of algebras, the Yangian, twisted Yangians and reflection algebras: the defining relations in all the cases can be presented in a special matrix from. This allows special algebraic techniques (the so-called R-matrix formalism) to be used to describe the algebraic structure and study representations of these algebras. On the other hand, the close relationship of these “quantum” algebras with the matrix Lie algebras leads to applications in the classical representation theory; see e.g. [18] and references therein. The Yangian symmetries have been found in various areas of physics including the theory of integrable models in statistical mechanics, conformal
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
320
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
field theory, quantum gravity. We note a surprising connection of the Yangian and twisted Yangians with the finite W-algebras recently discovered in [26, 27, 25]; see also [2]. 2. Definitions and Preliminaries Recall first the definition of the gl(n)-Yangian Y(n); see e.g. [12, 9]. We follow the notation from [21] where a detailed account of the properties of Y(n) is given. The (1) (2) Yangian Y(n) is the complex associative algebra with the generators tij , tij , . . . , where 1 ≤ i, j ≤ n, and the defining relations [tij (u), trs (v)] =
1 (trj (u)tis (v) − trj (v)tis (u)) , u−v
(2.1)
where tij (u) = δij + tij u−1 + tij u−2 + · · · ∈ Y (n)[[u−1 ]] (1)
(2)
and u is a formal (commutative) variable. Introduce the matrix T (u) =
n X
tij (u) ⊗ Eij ∈ Y(n)[[u−1 ]] ⊗ End Cn ,
(2.2)
i,j=1
where the Eij are the standard matrix units. Then the relations (2.1) are equivalent to the single RT T relation (1.3). Here T1 (u) and T2 (u) are regarded as elements of Y (n)[[u−1 ]] ⊗ End Cn ⊗ End Cn , the subindex of T (u) indicates to which copy of End Cn this matrix corresponds, and R(u) = 1 − P u−1 ,
P =
n X
Eij ⊗ Eji ∈ (End Cn )⊗2 .
i,j=1
Now we introduce the reflection algebras. Fix a decomposition of the parameter n into the sum of two nonnegative integers, n = k + l. Denote by G the diagonal n × n-matrix G = diag(ε1 , . . . , εn )
(2.3)
where εi = 1 for 1 ≤ i ≤ k, and εi = −1 for k + 1 ≤ i ≤ n. The reflection algebra (r) B(n, l) is a unital associative algebra with the generators bij where r runs over positive integers and i and j satisfy 1 ≤ i, j ≤ n. To write down the defining relations introduce formal series ∞ X (r) (0) bij u−r , bij = δij εi (2.4) bij (u) = r=0
and combine them into the matrix n X bij (u) ⊗ Eij ∈ B(n, l)[[u−1 ]] ⊗ End Cn . B(u) = i,j=1
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
321
The defining relations are given by the reflection equation [29] R(u − v)B1 (u)R(u + v)B2 (v) = B2 (v)R(u + v)B1 (u)R(u − v)
(2.5)
together with the unitary condition B(u)B(−u) = 1 ,
(2.6)
where we have used the notation of (1.3). Rewriting (2.5) and (2.6) in terms of the matrix elements we obtain, respectively, [bij (u), brs (v)] =
1 (brj (u)bis (v) − brj (v)bis (u)) u−v 1 + u+v
δrj
n X
bia (u)bas (v) − δis
a=1
1 δij − 2 u − v2
n X
n X
! bra (v)baj (u)
a=1
bra (u)bas (v) −
a=1
n X
!
bra (v)bas (u)
(2.7)
a=1
and n X
bia (u)baj (−u) = δij .
(2.8)
a=1
˜ l) which is defined in the same way as B(n, l) We shall also be using the algebra B(n, but with the unitary condition (2.6) dropped. (This corresponds to Sklyanin’s orig(r) ˜ l). inal definition [29]). We use the same notation bij for the generators of B(n, As we shall see in the following proposition, the algebra B(n, l) is isomorphic to a ˜ l) by an ideal whose generators are central elements; see also [17]. quotient of B(n, ˜ l) the product B(u)B(−u) is a scalar matrix Proposition 2.1. In the algebra B(n, B(u)B(−u) = f (u)1 ,
(2.9)
˜ l). where f (u) is an even series in u−1 whose all coefficients are central in B(n, Proof. Multiply both sides of (2.7) by u2 − v 2 and put v = −u. We obtain ! n n X X bia (u)bas (−u) − δis bra (−u)baj (u) 2u δrj a=1
= δij
a=1 n X a=1
bra (u)bas (−u) −
n X
! bra (−u)bas (u) .
(2.10)
a=1
Choosing appropriate indices i, j, r, s, it is easy to see that B(u)B(−u) = B(−u)B(u) and that this matrix is scalar. Thus, (2.9) holds for an even series
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
322
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
f (u). Now multiply both sides of (2.5) by B2 (−v) from the right: R(u − v)B1 (u)R(u + v)f (v) = B2 (v)R(u + v)B1 (u)R(u − v)B2 (−v) .
(2.11)
Applying (2.5) to the right hand side we write it as B2 (v)R(u + v)B1 (u)R(u − v)B2 (−v) = B2 (v)B2 (−v)R(u − v)B1 (u)R(u + v) = f (v)R(u − v)B1 (u)R(u + v) .
(2.12)
This shows that f (u) is central. We would like to comment on the relevance of the choice of the initial matrix G in the expansion B(u) = G +
∞ X
B (r) u−r ;
(2.13)
r=1
see also [17]. We could take G to be an arbitrary nondegenerate matrix. However, as the proof of Proposition 2.1 shows, the reflection equation implies that G2 is a scalar matrix. Since G is nondegenerate, the scalar is nonzero. On the other hand, as can be easily seen, for any constant c and any nondegenerate matrix A the transformations B(u) 7→ cB(u) and
B(u) 7→ AB(u)A−1
(2.14)
preserve the reflection equation. Accordingly, the matrix G is then transformed as G 7→ cG and G 7→ AGA−1 . Therefore, we may assume that G2 = 1 and using an appropriate matrix A we can bring G to the form (2.3). Note also that both the reflection equation and unitary condition are preserved by the change of sign B(u) 7→ −B(u). This implies that the algebras B(n, l) and B(n, n − l) are isomorphic. In what follows we assume that the parameter l satisfies 0 ≤ l ≤ n/2. ˜ l) that given It is immediate from the definitions of the algebras B(n, l) and B(n, −1 −1 any formal series g(u) ∈ 1 + u C[[u ]] the mapping B(u) 7→ g(u)B(u)
(2.15)
˜ l). If g(u) satisfies g(u)g(−u) = 1 then is an automorphism of the algebra B(n, (2.15) is an automorphism of B(n, l). 3. Algebraic Structure of B(n, l) Here we show that each B(n, l) can be identified with a coideal subalgebra in the Yangian Y(n) and prove an analog of the Poincar´e–Birkhoff–Witt theorem for the algebra B(n, l). Then we describe its center using an analog of the quantum determinant.
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
323
3.1. Embedding B(n, l) ,→ Y (n) Denote by T −1 (u) the inverse matrix for T (u); see (2.2). It can be easily seen that the matrix T −1 (−u) satisfies the RT T relation (1.3). This implies that the mapping T (u) → T −1 (−u) defines an algebra automorphism of the Yangian Y (n); cf. [21]. The following connection between B(n, l) and Y(n) was indicated in [29]. Theorem 3.1. The mapping ϕ : B(u) 7→ T (u)GT −1 (−u)
(3.1)
defines an embedding of the algebra B(n, l) into the Yangian Y(n). Proof. First we verify that ϕ is an algebra homomorphism. Denote the matrix ˜ ˜ B(−u) ˜ We obviously have B(u) = 1 and so (2.6) is T (u)GT −1(−u) by B(u). satisfied. Further, we have ˜2 (v) ˜1 (u)R(u + v)B R(u − v)B = R(u − v)T1 (u)G1 T1−1 (−u)R(u + v)T2 (v)G2 T2−1 (−v) .
(3.2)
We find from the RT T relation (1.3) that T1−1 (−u)R(u + v)T2 (v) = T2 (v)R(u + v)T1−1 (−u) .
(3.3)
Therefore, since Gi commutes with Tj (u) for i 6= j we bring the expression (3.2) to the form R(u − v)T1 (u)T2 (v)G1 R(u + v)G2 T1−1 (−u)T2−1(−v) .
(3.4)
One easily verifies that R(u − v)G1 R(u + v)G2 = G2 R(u + v)G1 R(u − v) .
(3.5)
Applying (1.3) and (3.5) we write (3.4) as T2 (v)T1 (u)G2 R(u + v)G1 T2−1 (−v)T1−1 (−u)R(u − v) ,
(3.6)
˜ 1 (u)R(u − v) due to (3.3). Thus, B(u) ˜ ˜2 (v)R(u + v)B satisfies which coincides with B the reflection Eq. (2.5). We now show that ϕ has trivial kernel. The Yangian Y(n) admits two natural (r) filtrations; see [21]. Here we use the one defined by setting deg1 tij = r. Similarly, (r)
we define the filtration on the algebra B(n, l) by deg1 bij = r. Let us first verify that the homomorphism ϕ is filtration-preserving. By definition, the matrix elements of ˜ B(u) are expressed as ˜bij (u) =
n X a=1
εa tia (u)t0aj (−u) ,
(3.7)
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
324
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
where the t0ij (u) denote the matrix elements of T −1 (u). Inverting the matrix T (u) we come to the following expression for t0ij (u): t0ij (u) = δij +
∞ X
n X
(−1)k
k=1
t◦ia1 (u)t◦a1 a2 (u) · · · t◦ak−1 j (u) ,
(3.8)
a1 ,...,ak−1 =1
where t◦ij (u) = tij (u) − δij . Taking the coefficient at u−r for r ≥ 1 we get 0(r)
tij =
r X
(−1)k
n X
X
(r )
(r )
k 2) tia11 t(r a1 a2 · · · tak−1 j ,
(3.9)
a1 ,...,ak−1 =1 r1 +···+rk =r
k=1
with the last sum taken over positive integers ri . Therefore, we find from (3.7) that (r) the degree of ˜bij does not exceed r. Hence, ϕ is filtration-preserving and it defines a homomorphism of the corresponding graded algebras gr1 B(n, l) → gr1 Y(n) .
(3.10)
(r) (r) Let t¯ij denote the image of tij in the rth component of gr1 Y (n). The algebra gr1 Y (n) is obviously commutative, and it was proved in [21, Theorem 1.22] that (r) the elements t¯ij are its algebraically independent generators. On the other hand, by the defining relations (2.7), the algebra gr1 B(n, l) is also (r) (r) commutative. Denote by ¯bij the image of bij in the rth component of gr1 B(n, l). We find from the unitary condition (2.8) that the elements
¯b(2p−1) , ij
1 ≤ i, j ≤ k
or k + 1 ≤ i, j ≤ n ,
¯b(2p) , ij
1≤i≤k<j≤n
or 1 ≤ j ≤ k < i ≤ n ,
(3.11)
with p running over positive integers, generate the algebra gr1 B(n, l). Now, by (3.7), (r) the image of ¯bij under the homomorphism (3.10) has the form ¯b(r) 7→ (εi (−1)r−1 + εj )t¯(r) + (· · ·) , ij ij
(3.12)
(s) where (· · ·) indicates a linear combination of monomials in the elements t¯ij with s < r. This implies that the elements (3.11) are algebraically independent which completes the proof.
The proposition implies the following analog of the Poincar´e–Birkhoff–Witt theorem for the algebra B(n, l). Corollary 3.2. Given any total ordering on the elements (2p−1)
bij
(2p)
bij
,
,
1 ≤ i, j ≤ k 1≤i≤k<j≤n
or k + 1 ≤ i, j ≤ n , or 1 ≤ j ≤ k < i ≤ n ,
with p = 1, 2, . . . , the ordered monomials in these elements constitute a basis of the algebra B(n, l).
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
325
Due to Proposition 3.1, we may regard B(n, l) as a subalgebra of Y(n) so that the generators bij (u) are identified with the elements ˜bij (u) given by (3.7). Recall that the Yangian Y (n) is a Hopf algebra with the coproduct ∆ : Y(n) → Y (n) ⊗ Y(n) defined by ∆(tij (u)) =
n X
tia (u) ⊗ taj (u) .
(3.13)
a=1
Proposition 3.3. The subalgebra B(n, l) is a left coideal in Y(n): ∆(B(n, l)) ⊆ Y(n) ⊗ B(n, l) .
(3.14)
Proof. It suffices to show that the images of the generators of B(n, l) under the coproduct are contained in Y(n) ⊗ B(n, l). Since ∆ is an algebra homomorphism, the images of the matrix elements t0ij (u) of T −1 (u) are given by ∆(t0ij (u)) =
n X
t0aj (u) ⊗ t0ia (u) .
(3.15)
a=1
Therefore, using (3.7) we calculate that ∆(bij (u)) =
n X
tia (u)t0cj (−u) ⊗ bac (u) ,
(3.16)
a,c=1
completing the proof. 3.2. Sklyanin determinant The quantum determinant qdet T (u) of the matrix T (u) is a formal series in u−1 , qdet T (u) = 1 + d1 u−1 + d2 u−2 + · · · , defined by qdet T (u) =
X
di ∈ Y(n) ,
sgn p · tp(1)1 (u) · · · tp(n)n (u − n + 1) ;
(3.17)
(3.18)
p∈Sn
see Izergin–Korepin [10], Kulish–Sklyanin [12]. The elements d1 , d2 , . . . are algebraically independent generators of the center of the algebra Y(n); see e.g. [21] for the proof. The quantum determinant can be equivalently defined in a R-matrix form [12, 5]; see also [21]. Consider the tensor product Y(n)[[u
−1
]] ⊗ End Cn ⊗ · · · ⊗ End Cn
(3.19)
with n copies of End Cn . For complex parameters u1 , . . . , un set R(u1 , . . . , un ) = (Rn−1,n )(Rn−2,n Rn−2,n−1 ) · · · (R1n · · · R12 ) ,
(3.20)
where we abbreviate Rij = Rij (ui − uj ), and the subindices enumerate the copies of End Cn in (3.19). If we specialize to ui = u − i + 1 ,
i = 1, . . . , n ,
(3.21)
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
326
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
then R(u1 , . . . , un ) becomes the one-dimensional anti-symmetrization operator An in the space (End Cn )⊗n . The quantum determinant qdet T (u) is defined by the relation An T1 (u) · · · Tn (u − n + 1) = An qdet T (u) .
(3.22)
Now, using (2.5) and the relation Rij Rir Rjr = Rjr Rir Rij ,
(3.23)
(the Yang–Baxter equation) we derive the following relation for the B-matrices: ˜ 12 · · · R ˜ 1n B2 (u2 )R ˜ 23 · · · R ˜ 2n B3 (u3 ) · · · R ˜ n−1,n Bn (un ) R(u1 , . . . , un )B1 (u1 )R ˜ n−1,n · · · B3 (u3 )R ˜2n · · · R ˜ 23 B2 (u2 )R ˜ 1n · · · R ˜ 12 B1 (u1 )R(u1 , . . . , un ) , = Bn (un )R (3.24) ˜ ij = Rij (ui + uj ). When we specialize the parameters ui as in (3.21), the where R element (3.24) will be equal to the product of the anti-symmetrizer An and a series in u−1 with coefficients in B(n, l). We call this series the Sklyanin determinant and denote it by sdet B(u). That is, sdet B(u) is defined by ˜ 12 · · · R ˜ 1n B2 (u − 1) · · · R ˜ n−1,n Bn (u − n + 1) = An sdet B(u) . An B1 (u)R
(3.25)
As follows from the definition, the constant term of sdet B(u) is det G = (−1)l , so sdet B(u) = (−1)l + c1 u−1 + c2 u−2 + · · · ,
ci ∈ B(n, l) .
(3.26)
In the next theorem we regard B(n, l) as a subalgebra in Y (n); see Theorem 3.1. Theorem 3.4. We have the identity sdet B(u) = θ(u) qdet T (u)(qdet T (−u + n − 1))−1 ,
(3.27)
where θ(u) = (−1)l
k l n Y Y Y (2u − 2n + 2i) (2u − 2n + 2i) i=1
i=1
1 . 2u − 2n + i + 1 i=1
(3.28)
In particular, all the coefficients of sdet B(u) are central in B(n, l). Moreover, the odd coefficients c1 , c3 , . . . are algebraically independent and generate the center of the algebra B(n, l). Proof. Substitute B(u) = T (u)GT −1 (−u) into (3.25). Applying relation (3.3) repeatedly, we bring the left hand side of (3.25) to the form ˜ 12 · · · R ˜ 1n G2 An T1 (u) · · · Tn (u − n + 1)G1 R ˜ n−1,n Gn T −1 (−u) · · · T −1 (−u + n − 1) . ···R n 1
(3.29)
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
327
Now use (3.22), and then note that ˜ 12 · · · R ˜ 1n G2 · · · R ˜ n−1,n Gn = An θ(u) , An G1 R
(3.30)
for some scalar function θ(u). Indeed, this follows e.g. from (3.24) where we specialize ui as in (3.21) and consider the trivial representation of B(n, l) such that B(u) 7→ G. Furthermore, we have An T1−1 (−u) · · · Tn−1 (−u + n − 1) = An (qdet T (−u + n − 1))−1 .
(3.31)
This follows from (3.22), if we first multiply both sides by Tn−1 (u − n + 1) · · · T1−1 (u) from the right, replace u with −u + n − 1 and then conjugate the left hand side by the permutation of the indices 1, . . . , n which sends i to n − i + 1. To complete the proof of (3.27) we need to calculate θ(u). It suffices to find a diagonal matrix element of the operator on the left hand side of (3.30) corresponding to the vector e1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ en , where the ei denote the canonical basis of Cn . We have (n − 1)!An = An A0n−1 , where A0n−1 is the anti-symmetrizer in the tensor product of the copies of End Cn corresponding to the indices 2, . . . , n. Note that A0n−1 commutes with G1 . Furthermore, we have the identity ˜ 12 · · · R ˜ 1n = R ˜ 1n · · · R ˜ 12 A0 A0n−1 R n−1 ,
(3.32)
which easily follows from (3.23). This allows us to use induction on n to find the matrix element and to perform the calculation of θ(u) which is now straightforward. Using (3.27) we can conclude that all the coefficients of sdet B(u) belong to the center of the Yangian Y (n), and hence to the center of its subalgebra B(n, l). Furthermore, if we put −1 n−1 n−1 , (3.33) θ u+ c(u) = sdet B u + 2 2 then by (3.27) we have the identity c(u) = d(u)d(−u)−1 ,
d(u) = qdet T
u+
n−1 2
.
(3.34)
The coefficients of d(u) are algebraically independent generators of the center of Y(n). Since c(u)c(−u) = 1, repeating the argument of the second part of the proof of Theorem 3.1 for the case of B(1, 0) we find that all the even coefficients of c(u) can be expressed in terms of the odd ones, and the latter are algebraically independent. Since n−1 , (3.35) sdet B(u) = θ(u)c u − 2 the same holds for the coefficients of sdet B(u). Finally, let us show that the center of B(n, l) is generated by the coefficients of (r) sdet B(u). We use another filtration on B(n, l) defined by setting deg2 bij = r − 1. We first verify that the corresponding graded algebra gr2 B(n, l) is isomorphic to the universal enveloping algebra for a twisted polynomial current Lie algebra. Consider
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
328
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
the involution σ of the Lie algebra gl(n) given by σ : Eij 7→ εi εj Eij . Denote by a0 and a1 the eigenspaces of σ corresponding to the eigenvalues 1 and −1, respectively. In particular, a0 is a Lie subalgebra of gl(n) isomorphic to gl(k) ⊕ gl(l). Denote by gl(n)[x]σ the Lie algebra of polynomials in a variable x of the form a0 + a1 x + a2 x2 + · · · + am xm ,
a2i ∈ a0 ,
a2i−1 ∈ a1 .
(3.36)
We claim that the following is an algebra isomorphism: gr2 B(n, l) ' U(gl(n)[x]σ ) .
(3.37)
(r) (r) Indeed, denote by ¯bij the image of bij in the (r − 1)th component of gr2 B(n, l). Then by the unitary condition we have for r ≥ 1 (r) (εi + (−1)r εj )¯bij = 0 ,
(3.38)
while the reflection equation gives (r) (s) (r+s−1) (r+s−1) − δil (εi + εj (−1)r−1 )¯bkj . [¯bij , ¯bkl ] = δkj (εi (−1)r−1 + εj )¯bil
(3.39)
This shows that the mapping ¯b(r) 7→ (εi + (−1)r−1 εj )Eij xr−1 ij
(3.40)
defines an algebra homomorphism gr2 B(n, l) → U(gl(n)[x]σ ). Corollary 3.2 ensures that its kernel is trivial. Further, it is easily deduced from the definition (3.25) of the Sklyanin determinant that the images of c¯2m+1 under the isomorphism (3.37) are given by c¯2m+1 7→ (−1)l 2(E11 + · · · + Enn )x2m ,
m ≥ 0.
(3.41)
The theorem will be proved if we show that the center of U(gl(n)[x]σ ) is generated by the elements (E11 +· · ·+Enn )x2m with m ≥ 0. This is equivalent to the claim that the center of U(sl(n)[x]σ ) is trivial. Here sl(n)[x]σ is the Lie algebra of polynomials of the form (3.36) where now a0 = sl(n) ∩ (gl(k) ⊕ gl(l)). However, this follows from a slight modification of a more general result: see [21, Proposition 4.10]. Namely, if a is any Lie algebra and σ is its involution, we define a[x]σ as the Lie algebra of polynomials of type (3.36). Then an argument similar to [21] proves that if the center of a is trivial, and the a0 -module a1 has no nontrivial invariant elements then the center of U(a[x]σ ) is trivial. Next we give some remarks. (1) The algebra B(n, l) can also be regarded as a deformation of the universal enveloping algebra U(gl(n)[x]σ ). To see this, introduce the deformation parameter h and rewrite the defining relations for B(n, l) in terms of the re-scaled generators 0(r) (r) bij = bij hr−1 . These define a family of algebras B(n, l)h. If h 6= 0 the algebra B(n, l)h is isomorphic to B(n, l) while for h = 0 one obtains the universal enveloping algebra U(gl(n)[x]σ ). (2) It would be interesting to find an explicit formula for sdet B(u) in terms of the generators bij (u).
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
329
Recall that the Yangian Y(sl(n)) for the special linear Lie algebra sl(n) can be defined as the subalgebra of Y(n) which consists of the elements stable under all automorphisms of the form T (u) 7→ h(u)T (u), where h(u) is a series in u−1 with the constant term 1; see [21]. Then one has the tensor product decomposition Y(n) = Z(n) ⊗ Y(sl(n)) ,
(3.42)
where Z(n) is the center of Y(n). Define the special reflection algebra SB(n, l) by SB(n, l) = B(n, l) ∩ Y(sl(n)) .
(3.43)
In other words, SB(n, l) consists of the elements of B(n, l) which are stable under all automorphisms (2.15). It is implied by (3.42) (cf. [21, Proposition 4.14]), that the following decomposition holds B(n, l) = Z(n, l) ⊗ SB(n, l) ,
(3.44)
where Z(n, l) is the center of B(n, l). 4. Representations of B(n, l) Here we show that the Drinfeld highest weight theory [9] applies to the representations of the algebras B(n, l); see also [20] for the case of twisted Yangians. We then give a complete description of the finite-dimensional irreducible representations of B(n, l). 4.1. Highest weight representations Recall first Drinfeld’s classification results for representations of the Yangian Y(n) [9]; see also [20]. A representation L of the Yangian Y(n) is called highest weight if there exists a nonzero vector ξ ∈ L such that L is generated by ξ, tij (u)ξ = 0
for 1 ≤ i < j ≤ n ,
tii (u)ξ = λi (u)ξ
for 1 ≤ i ≤ n ,
(4.1)
for some formal series λi (u) ∈ 1 + u−1 C[[u−1 ]]. The vector ξ is called the highest vector of L and the set λ(u) = (λ1 (u), . . . , λn (u)) is the highest weight of L. Let λ(u) = (λ1 (u), . . . , λn (u)) be an n-tuple of formal series. Then there exists a unique, up to an isomorphism, irreducible highest weight module L(λ(u)) with the highest weight λ(u). Any finite-dimensional irreducible representation of Y(n) is isomorphic to L(λ(u)) for some λ(u). The representation L(λ(u)) is finitedimensional if and only if there exist monic polynomials Q1 (u), . . . , Qn−1 (u) in u such that Qi (u + 1) λi (u) = , i = 1, . . . , n − 1 . (4.2) λi+1 (u) Qi (u) These relations are analogs of the dominance conditions in the representation theory of semisimple Lie algebras. Similar relations involving monic polynomials are
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
330
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
given by Drinfeld [9] to describe finite-dimensional irreducible representations of the Yangian Y(a) for any simple Lie algebra a. The polynomials Qi (u) are called the Drinfeld polynomials (usually denoted by Pi (u)). Let us now turn to the reflection algebras. A representation V of the algebra B(n, l) is called highest weight if there exists a nonzero vector ξ ∈ V such that V is generated by ξ, bij (u)ξ = 0
for 1 ≤ i < j ≤ n ,
bii (u)ξ = µi (u)ξ
for 1 ≤ i ≤ n ,
(4.3)
for some formal series µi (u) ∈ εi + u−1 C[[u−1 ]]. The vector ξ is called the highest vector of V and the set µ(u) = (µ1 (u), . . . , µn (u)) is the highest weight of V . Theorem 4.1. Every finite-dimensional irreducible representation V of the algebra B(n, l) is a highest weight representation. Moreover, V contains a unique (up to a constant factor) highest vector. Proof. Our approach is quite standard; cf. [4, Proposition 12.2.3], [20]. Introduce the subspace of V V 0 = {η ∈ V | bij (u)η = 0 , 1 ≤ i < j ≤ n} .
(4.4)
We show first that V 0 is nonzero. The defining relations (2.7) give (1)
[bij , brs (u)] = (εi + εj )(δrj bis (u) − δis brj (u)) .
(4.5)
This implies that V 0 can be equivalently defined as V 0 = {η ∈ V | bi,i+1 (u)η = 0 , i = 1, . . . , n − 1} .
(4.6)
(1)
The operators εi bii are pairwise commuting and so they have a common eigenvector ζ 6= 0 in V . If we suppose that V 0 = 0 then there exists an infinite sequence of nonzero vectors in V , ζ,
(r )
bi1 ,i1 1 +1 ζ ,
(r )
(r )
bi2 ,i2 2 +1 bi1 ,i1 1 +1 ζ, . . . .
(4.7)
(1)
By (4.5) they all are eigenvectors for the operators εi bii , i = 1, . . . , n of different weights. Thus, they are linearly independent which contradicts to the assumption dim V < ∞. So, V 0 is nontrivial. Next, we show that all the operators brr (u) preserve the subspace V 0 . We use a reverse induction on r. For r = n we see from (2.7) that if i < j < n then bij (u)bnn (v) ≡ 0, where the equivalence is modulo the left ideal in B(n, l) generated by the coefficients of bij (u) with i < j. Similarly, if i < n then the assertion follows from the equivalence bin (u)bnn (v) ≡
1 bin (u)bnn (v) u+v
(4.8)
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
331
which is immediate from (2.7). Now let r < n. Note the following obvious consequence of (2.7): if i < m and i 6= j then bij (u)bjm (v) ≡
n 1 X bia (u)bam (v) . u + v a=m
(4.9)
In particular, the right hand side is independent of j and so, if i < m then for any indices j, j 0 6= i we have bij (u)bjm (v) ≡ bij 0 (u)bj 0 m (v) .
(4.10)
If i + 1 < r then it is immediate from (2.7) that bi,i+1 (u)brr (v) ≡ 0. Further, using (4.9) we derive from (2.7) that br−1,r (u)brr (v) ≡
n−r+1 br−1,r (u)brr (v) , u+v
(4.11)
which gives br−1,r (u)brr (v) ≡ 0. Next, by (2.7), br,r+1 (u)brr (v) ≡
1 (br,r+1 (u)brr (v) − br,r+1 (v)brr (u)) u−v −
n X 1 bra (v)ba,r+1 (u) . u + v a=r+1
(4.12)
n−r br,r+1 (v)br+1,r+1 (u), which is equivalent to By (4.10), the second sum here is − u+v zero by the induction hypothesis. So we get
1 u−v−1 br,r+1 (u)brr (v) + br,r+1 (v)brr (u) ≡ 0 . u−v u−v
(4.13)
Swapping u and v we obtain −
u−v+1 1 br,r+1 (u)brr (v) + br,r+1 (v)brr (u) ≡ 0 . u−v u−v
(4.14)
The system of linear Eqs. (4.13) and (4.14) has only zero solution which proves the assertion in this case. Finally, for i > r we get from (2.7) bi,i+1 (u)brr (v) ≡
1 (br,i+1 (u)bir (v) − br,i+1 (v)bir (u)) , u−v
(4.15)
and br,i+1 (u)bir (v) ≡
1 (bi,i+1 (u)brr (v) − bi,i+1 (v)brr (u)) u−v −
n X 1 bia (v)ba,i+1 (u) . u + v a=i+1
(4.16)
n−i bi,i+1 (v)bi+1,i+1 (u), which By (4.10), the second sum here is equivalent to − u+v is equivalent to zero by the induction hypothesis. Therefore, (4.16) implies that br,i+1 (u)bir (v) is symmetric in u and v which shows that the left hand side of (4.15) is equivalent to 0.
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
332
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
Our next step is to show that all the operators brr (u) on V 0 commute. For any 1 ≤ r ≤ n, the defining relations (2.7) give 1 1 αr (u, v) , (4.17) [brr (u), brr (v)] ≡ 1− u+v u+v where αr (u, v) =
n X
(bra (u)bar (v) − bra (v)bar (u)) .
(4.18)
a=r+1
Using (2.7) again we obtain for a ≥ r + 1 bra (u)bar (v) − bra (v)bar (u) 1 ([brr (u), brr (v)] + [baa (u), baa (v)] + αr (u, v) + αr (u, v)) . u+v Taking the sum over a gives ≡
(4.19)
(u + v − n + r)αr (u, v) ≡ (n − r)[brr (u), brr (v)] +
n X
([baa (u), baa (v)] + αr (u, v)) .
(4.20)
a=r+1
Using (4.17) we easily prove by a reverse induction on r that [brr (u), brr (v)] ≡ 0 and αr (u, v) ≡ 0. Finally, if i < r then by (2.7) 1 ([brr (u), brr (v)] + αr (u, v)) , (4.21) u2 − v 2 which is equivalent to 0 as was shown above. We can now conclude that the subspace V 0 contains a common eigenvector ξ 6= 0 for the operators brr (u), that is, (4.3) holds for some formal series µi (u). Since V is irreducible, the submodule B(n, l)ξ must coincide with V . The uniqueness of ξ now follows from Corollary 3.2. [bii (u), brr (v)] ≡ −
Given any n-tuple µ(u) = (µ1 (u), . . . , µn (u)), where µi (u) ∈ εi + u−1 C[[u−1 ]], we define the Verma module M (µ(u)) as the quotient of B(n, l) by the left ideal generated by all the coefficients of the series bij (u) with 1 ≤ i < j ≤ n, and bii (u) − µi (u) for i = 1, . . . , n. However, contrary to the case of the Yangian Y (n) the module M (µ(u)) can be trivial for some µ(u). If M (µ(u)) is nontrivial we denote by V (µ(u)) its unique irreducible quotient. Any irreducible highest weight module with the highest weight µ(u) is clearly isomorphic to V (µ(u)). Theorem 4.2. The Verma module M (µ(u)) is nontrivial (i.e. V (µ(u)) exists) if and only if µn (u)µn (−u) = 1 ,
(4.22)
and for each i = 1, . . . , n − 1 the following conditions hold µi (−u + n − i) = µ ˜i+1 (u)˜ µi+1 (−u + n − i) , µ ˜i (u)˜
(4.23)
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
333
where µ ˜i (u) = (2u − n + i)µi (u) + µi+1 (u) + · · · + µn (u) .
(4.24)
Proof. Suppose first that V (µ(u)) exists. For each i = 1, . . . , n set βi (u, v) =
n X
bia (u)bai (v) .
(4.25)
a=i
The highest vector of V (µ(u)) is an eigenvector of βn (u, v) with the eigenvalue µn (u)µn (v). Due to the unitary condition (2.8) this eigenvalue must be equal to 1 if v = −u which proves (4.22). Using the notation of the proof of Theorem 4.1, we derive from (2.7) that n X 1 u+v−n+i βi (u, v) ≡ bii (u)bii (v) − βa (v, u) u+v u + v a=i+1 n X 1 (baa (u)bii (v) − baa (v)bii (u)) . + u − v a=i+1
(4.26)
Therefore, n X 1 u+v−n+i (βi (u, v) − βi (v, u)) ≡ (βa (u, v) − βa (v, u)) . u+v u + v a=i+1
(4.27)
Since clearly βn (u, v) ≡ βn (v, u), an easy induction implies that βi (u, v) ≡ βi (v, u) for all i. Now consider (4.26) with i replaced by i + 1 and subtract this from (4.26). This gives u+v−n+i (βi (u, v) − βi+1 (u, v)) u+v ≡ bii (u)bii (v) +
n X 1 (baa (u)bii (v) − baa (v)bii (u)) − bi+1,i+1 (u)bi+1,i+1 (v) u − v a=i+1
n X 1 (baa (u)bi+1,i+1 (v) − baa (v)bi+1,i+1 (u)) . − u − v a=i+2
(4.28)
Apply both sides to the highest vector of V (µ(u)) and put u + v = n − i. We then get the following condition for the components of µ(u), µi (u)µi (v) +
n X 1 (µa (u)µi (v) − µa (v)µi (u)) u − v a=i+1
= µi+1 (u)µi+1 (v) +
n X 1 (µa (u)µi+1 (v) − µa (v)µi+1 (u)) , u − v a=i+2
(4.29)
where v = −u + n − i. It is now a straightforward calculation to verify that this condition is equivalent to (4.23).
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
334
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
Conversely, suppose that the conditions (4.22) and (4.23) hold. We shall demonstrate that there exists a highest weight module L(λ(u)) over the Yangian Y(n) such that B(n, l)-cyclic span of the highest vector is a B(n, l)-module with the highest weight µ(u). This will prove the existence of V (µ(u)). Suppose first that L(λ(u)) is an arbitrary irreducible highest weight module. The quantum comatrix Tˆ (u) = (tˆij (u)) is defined by qdet T (u) = Tˆ(u)T (u − n + 1) .
(4.30)
It can be deduced from (3.22) that the matrix element tˆij (u) equals (−1)i+j times the quantum determinant of the submatrix of T (u) obtained by removing the ith column and jth row. Therefore, the matrix element t0ij (u) of the inverse matrix T −1 (u) can be expressed as t0ij (u) = (qdet T (u + n − 1))−1 tˆij (u + n − 1) .
(4.31)
This implies that the highest vector ξ of the Y (n)-module L(λ(u)) is annihilated by the elements t0ij (u) with i < j, and that ξ is an eigenvector for the tp0ii (u). The corresponding eigenvalues are found from the formula (3.18) and given by t0ii (u)ξ =
λi+1 (u + n − i) · · · λn (u + 1) ξ. λi (u + n − i) · · · λn (u)
The following relations are easily derived from (1.3); see also [21, Sec. 7] ! n n X X 1 0 0 0 δrj tia (u)tas (v) − δis tra (v)taj (u) . [tij (u), trs (v)] = u−v a=1 a=1
(4.32)
(4.33)
Hence modulo the left ideal in Y (n) generated by the elements tij (u) with i < j we can write for a > i tia (u)t0ai (−u)
n n 1 X 1 X 0 0 ≡ tic (u)tci (−u) − t (−u)tca (u) . 2u c=i 2u c=a ac
(4.34)
Due to (3.7) this implies that
! n n n X X X 1 εa tic (u)t0ci (−u) − t0ac (−u)tca (u) . bii (u) ≡ εi tii (u)t0ii (−u) + 2u a=i+1 c=a c=i (4.35)
Now suppose that i ≥ k + 1 and set fii (u) = −
n X
t0ic (−u)tci (u) .
(4.36)
c=i
Then (4.35) can be written as n 1 X 2u − n + i bii (u) ≡ −tii (u)t0ii (−u) − faa (u) . 2u 2u a=i+1
(4.37)
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
335
A similar transformation for fii (u) gives n 1 X 2u − n + i 0 fii (u) ≡ −tii (−u)tii (u) − baa (u) . 2u 2u a=i+1
(4.38)
Since bnn (u) ≡ fnn (u), an easy induction proves that bii (u) ≡ fii (u) for all i = k + 1, . . . , n. By (4.37), we have for those i, n 1 X 2u − n + i bii (u) + baa (u) ≡ −tii (u)t0ii (−u) . 2u 2u a=i+1
(4.39)
In the same way for i = 1, . . . , k we get n X 1 2u − n + i bii (u) + baa (u) ≡ tii (u)t0ii (−u) . 2u − 2l 2u − 2l a=i+1
(4.40)
Now, applying both sides of (4.39) and (4.40) to ξ and using (4.32) we obtain ( λn (u)λn (−u)−1 , if l = 0 , (4.41) µn (u) = −λn (u)λn (−u)−1 , if l > 0 . Moreover, λi (u)λi+1 (−u + n − i) µ ˜i (u) = , µ ˜i+1 (u) λi+1 (u)λi (−u + n − i)
(4.42)
l − u λk (u)λk+1 (−u + l) µ ˜ k (u) = · . µ ˜k+1 (u) u λk+1 (u)λk (−u + l)
(4.43)
if i 6= k; while
The proof of the theorem is now completed as follows. By (4.22) there exists a series λn (u) ∈ 1 + u−1C[[u−1 ]] such that (4.41) holds. Similarly, (4.23) ensures that there exist series λ1 (u), . . . , λn−1 (u) satisfying (4.42) and (4.43). Thus, V (µ(u)) is isomorphic to the irreducible quotient of B(n, l)ξ. 4.2. Representations of B(2, 0) and B(2, 1) The algebras B(2, 0) and B(2, 1) turn out to be isomorphic to the symplectic and orthogonal twisted Yangians Y − (2) and Y+ (2), respectively (see the remark at the end of this section). Thus the representations of B(2, 0) and B(2, 1) can be described by using the results of [20] for the twisted Yangians. In our argument we use the corresponding isomorphisms of the extended algebras (Proposition 4.3). Note also that this similarity between the reflection algebras and the twisted Yangians does not extend to higher dimensions. Recall (see e.g. [21]) that the twisted Yangian Y± (2) is an associative algebra (1) (2) with generators sij , sij , . . . , where i, j ∈ {1, 2}. Introduce the generating series sij (u) = δij + sij u−1 + sij u−2 + · · · (1)
(2)
(4.44)
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
336
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
and combine them into the matrix S(u) = (sij (u)). Then the defining relations have the form of a reflection equation analogous to (2.5), R(u − v)S1 (u)Rt (−u − v)S2 (v) = S2 (v)Rt (−u − v)S1 (u)R(u − v) ,
(4.45)
as well as the symmetry relation S t (−u) = S(u) ±
S(u) − S(−u) . 2u
(4.46)
Here we have used the notation of Sec. 2, and Rt (u) = 1 − Qu−1 ,
Q=
2 X
t Eij ⊗ Eji ∈ (End C2 )⊗2 ,
i,j=1
where the matrix transposition is defined by a22 a12 a22 t t and A = A = a21 a11 −a21
−a12 a11
,
(4.47)
for Y + (2) and Y− (2), respectively. ˜ − (2) is defined in the same way ˜ + (2) and Y Another pair of associative algebras Y as Y± (2), but with the symmetry relation (4.46) dropped. Then the algebra Y± (2) ˜ ± (2) by the ideal generated by all coefficients of is isomorphic to the quotient of Y the series δ(u) defined by the relation 1 (4.48) δ(u)Q = QS1 (u)R(2u)S2−1 (−u) . 1∓ 2u ˜ ± (2); see [21, Theorems 6.3 and Moreover, these coefficients belong to the center of Y 6.4] for the proofs of these assertions. Note also that δ(u) satisfies δ(u)δ(−u) = 1 which is easy to deduce from (4.48). ˜ l) is the algebra with the defining relations (2.5; see Sec. 2. Recall that B(n, Here we let G = diag(1, −1). Proposition 4.3. The mappings 1 and S(u) 7→ B u + 2
1 S(u) 7→ B u + G 2
(4.49)
˜ 0) and Y ˜ 1), respectively. ˜ + (2) → B(2, ˜ − (2) → B(2, define algebra isomorphisms Y Proof. We have to show that the matrix B(u + 12 ) or B(u + 12 )G, respectively, ˜ − (2) the operator P + Q is satisfies the relation (4.45). Note that in the case of Y the identity on (End C2 )⊗2 . This implies that Rt (−u − v) =
u+v+1 R(u + v + 1) u+v
(4.50)
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
337
˜ + (2) both G1 QG1 + P and G2 QG2 + P are proving the assertion. In the case of Y the identity operators which implies that G1 Rt (−u − v)G1 = G2 Rt (−u − v)G2 =
u+v+1 R(u + v + 1) . u+v
(4.51)
It remains to note that G1 G2 commutes with R(u − v). Suppose now that V is an irreducible finite-dimensional representation of the ˜ ± (2) and, by Propotwisted Yangian Y± (2). Then V is naturally extended to Y ˜ 0) or B(2, ˜ 1), respectively. The central element sition 4.3, to the algebra B(2, f (u) defined in (2.9) acts in V as a scalar series. Then there exists a series g(u) ∈ 1 + u−1 C[[u−1 ]] such that g(u)g(−u)f (u) = 1 as an operator in V . This means that the composition of V with the corresponding automorphism (2.15) of ˜ 0) or B(2, ˜ 1) can be regarded as an irreducible representation of the algebra B(2, B(2, 0) or B(2, 1), respectively. Conversely, any irreducible finite-dimensional representation V of B(2, 0) or ˜ 0) or B(2, ˜ 1) and B(2, 1) is naturally extended to the corresponding algebra B(2, ± ˜ hence to Y (2). The composition of V with an appropriate automorphism S(u) 7→ h(u)S(u) can be regarded as an irreducible representation of the twisted Yangian Y± (2). Indeed, the central element δ(u) defined by (4.48) acts as a scalar series on V , and since δ(u)δ(−u) = 1, the series h(u) is found from the relation h(u)h(−u)−1 δ(u) = 1. This argument allows us to carry over the description of representations of Y± (2) to the case of the algebras B(2, 0) or B(2, 1). The following proposition is easily derived from [21, Theorems 5.4 and 6.4]. Suppose that two formal series µ1 (u) and µ2 (u) satisfy the conditions of Theorem 4.2 so that the irreducible highest weight module V (µ(u)) exists. Proposition 4.4. (i) The B(2, 0)-module V (µ(u)) is finite-dimensional if and only if there exists a monic polynomial P (u) in u such that P (−u + 2) = P (u) and P (u + 1) (2u − 1)µ1 (u) + µ2 (u) = . 2uµ2 (u) P (u)
(4.52)
In this case P (u) is unique. (ii) The B(2, 1)-module V (µ(u)) is finite-dimensional if and only if there exist γ ∈ C and a monic polynomial P (u) in u such that P (−u + 2) = P (u), P (γ) 6= 0 and P (u + 1) γ−u (2u − 1)µ1 (u) + µ2 (u) = · . 2uµ2 (u) P (u) γ+u−1
(4.53)
In this case the pair (P (u), γ) is unique. Given α, β ∈ C denote by L(α, β) the irreducible gl(2)-module with the highest weight (α, β). It is well-known that any finite-dimensional irreducible representation
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
338
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
of Y(2) is isomorphic to a tensor product of the form L = L(α1 , β1 ) ⊗ · · · ⊗ L(αk , βk ) ,
(4.54)
up to the twisting by an automorphism T (u) 7→ h(u)T (u) of Y(2), where h(u) is a formal series [32, 3]; see also [20]. The corresponding analogs of this result for the algebras B(2, 0) and B(2, 1) are also immediate from [20] due to the above argument. For any γ ∈ C denote by V (γ) the one-dimensional representation of B(2, 1) such that the generators act by b11 (u) 7→
u+γ , u−γ
b22 (u) 7→ −1 ,
b12 (u) 7→ 0 ,
b21 (u) 7→ 0 .
(4.55)
Representations of this kind were constructed in the pioneering paper [6]. Given any Y (n)-module L and any B(n, l)-module V we shall regard L⊗V as a B(n, l)-module by using Proposition 3.3. Proposition 4.5. Any finite-dimensional irreducible B(2, 0)-module is isomorphic to the restriction of a Y (2)-module of the form (4.54). Any finite-dimensional irreducible B(2, 1)-module is isomorphic to the tensor product L ⊗ V (γ), where L is a Y (2)-module of the form (4.54). We give some remarks here. (1) It is proved in [21, Proposition 4.14] that the twisted Yangian admits the decomposition ± ± ± Y (2) = ZZ ⊗ SY (2) ,
(4.56)
where ZZ± is the center of Y ± (2), and SY± (2) is a subalgebra called the special twisted Yangian. Using the decomposition (3.44) we conclude from Proposition 4.3 that the algebras SY+ (2) and SY− (2) are respectively isomorphic to SB(2, 1) and SB(2, 0). Indeed, each special subalgebra is the quotient of the corresponding alge˜ l) by the ideal of relations sending the generators of the center ˜ ± (2) or B(2, bra Y to zero. On the other hand, both centers ZZ± and ZZ(2, l) are polynomial algebras in countably many variables; see Theorem 3.4 above and [21, Theorem 4.11]. This implies the isomorphisms Y + (2) ∼ = B(2, 1) and Y − (2) ∼ = B(2, 0). (2) Criteria of irreducibility of the modules L and L ⊗ V (γ) (with L given by (4.54)) over the algebras B(2, 0) and B(2, 1), respectively, can also be obtained from the corresponding results in [20]. 4.3. Classification theorem for B(n, l)-modules Theorem 4.1 together with the following result will complete the description of finite-dimensional irreducible representations of B(n, l). Let V (µ(u)) be an irreducible highest weight module over the algebra B(n, l), so that the conditions of Theorem 4.2 for the components µi (u) hold. We shall keep using the notation (4.24).
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
339
Theorem 4.6. (i) The B(n, 0)-module V (µ(u)) is finite-dimensional if and only if there exist monic polynomials P1 (u), . . . , Pn−1 (u) in u such that Pi (−u + n − i + 1) = Pi (u) and Pi (u + 1) µ ˜ i (u) = , µ ˜i+1 (u) Pi (u)
i = 1, . . . , n − 1 .
(4.57)
(ii) The B(n, l)-module V (µ(u)) (with l > 0) is finite-dimensional if and only if there exist an element γ ∈ C and monic polynomials P1 (u), . . . , Pn−1 (u) in u such that Pi (−u + n − i + 1) = Pi (u), Pk (γ) 6= 0 and Pi (u + 1) µ ˜i (u) = , µ ˜i+1 (u) Pi (u)
i = 1, . . . , n − 1 ,
i 6= k ,
(4.58)
while Pk (u + 1) γ−u µ ˜k (u) = · . µ ˜k+1 (u) Pk (u) γ+u−l
(4.59)
Proof. Set V = V (µ(u)) and suppose first that dim V < ∞. We shall use induction on n. In the case n = 2 the result holds by Proposition 4.4. Suppose now that n ≥ 3 and consider the subspace V+ = {η ∈ V | b1i (u)η = 0 for i = 2, . . . , n} .
(4.60)
The calculations similar to those used in the proof of Theorem 4.1 show that V+ is stable under the operators bij (u) with 2 ≤ i, j ≤ n. Moreover, the operators b◦ij (u) = bi+1,j+1 (u) ,
i, j = 1, . . . , n − 1
(4.61)
form a representation of the algebra B(n−1, l) in V+ (recall that by our assumptions, l ≤ n/2). The cyclic span B(n−1, l)ξ of the highest vector ξ ∈ V is a module with the highest weight µ+ (u) = (µ2 (u), . . . , µn (u)). Since this module is finite-dimensional the conditions of the theorem must be satisfied for the components of µ+ (u). Similarly, consider the subspace V− = {η ∈ V | bin (u)η = 0 for i = 1, . . . , n − 1} .
(4.62)
Now the operators bnn (u) and bij (u) with 1 ≤ i, j ≤ n − 1 preserve V− . Moreover, the operators δij 1 1 ◦ · bnn u + + , i, j = 1, . . . , n − 1 (4.63) bij (u) = bij u + 2 2u 2 form a representation of the algebra B(n − 1, 0) or B(n − 1, l − 1) in V− , respectively for l = 0 and l > 0. Again, the cyclic span of ξ is a finite-dimensional module
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
340
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
over B(n − 1, 0) or B(n − 1, l − 1), respectively, with the highest weight µ− (u) = (µ◦1 (u), . . . , µ◦n−1 (u)), where 1 1 1 ◦ · µn u + + . (4.64) µi (u) = µi u + 2 2u 2 By the induction hypothesis, the components of µ− (u) must satisfy the conditions of the theorem. Rewriting them in terms of the components of µ(u) we complete the proof of the “only if” part. Conversely, suppose that the conditions of the theorem hold for the components of the highest weight µ(u). Since Pi (u) = Pi (−u + n − i + 1) for each i, there exist monic polynomials Qi (u) in u such that Pi (u) = (−1)deg Qi Qi (u)Qi (−u + n − i + 1) .
(4.65)
Then there exists a representation L(λ(u)) of the Yangian Y (n) such that the components λi (u) of λ(u) satisfy the conditions (4.2) for the polynomials Qi (u). The argument of the proof of Theorem 4.2 shows that the B(n, 0)-span of the highest vector ξ of L(λ(u)) is a module with the highest weight µ(u) such that the relations (4.42) hold. Since V (µ(u)) is isomorphic to the irreducible quotient of this span we conclude that V (µ(u)) is finite-dimensional. Suppose now that l > 0. It is easy to verify that for any γ ∈ C the assignment bij (u) 7→ δij
u+γ εi u − γ
(4.66)
defines a one-dimensional representation of B(n, l) which we denote by V (γ). Now consider the B(n, l)-module L(λ(u)) ⊗ V (l − γ); see Proposition 3.3. Let η be a basis vector of V (l − γ). Repeating again the calculation of the proof of Theorem 4.2 we find that the B(n, l)-span of the vector ξ ⊗ η is a module with the highest weight µ(u) such that the relations (4.42) hold for i 6= k, while γ−u λk (u)λk+1 (−u + l) µ ˜ k (u) = · . µ ˜k+1 (u) γ + u − l λk+1 (u)λk (−u + l)
(4.67)
This implies that V (µ(u)) is finite-dimensional. Using the decomposition (3.44) we can deduce the following parametrization of the representations of the special reflection algebra SB(n, l). Corollary 4.7. (i) The finite-dimensional irreducible representations of the special reflection algebra SB(n, 0) are in a one-to-one correspondence with the families of monic polynomials (P1 (u), . . . , Pn−1 (u)) such that Pi (−u + n − i + 1) = Pi (u). (ii) The finite-dimensional irreducible representations of the special reflection algebra SB(n, l) with l > 0 are in a one-to-one correspondence with the families (P1 (u), . . . , Pn−1 (u), γ), where γ ∈ C and the Pi (u) are monic polynomials such that Pi (−u + n − i + 1) = Pi (u) and Pk (γ) 6= 0.
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
00115
Representations of Reflection Algebras
341
Acknowledgment This work was done during the first author’s visit to the Laboratoire d’Annecyle-Vieux de Physique Th´eorique, Annecy, France. He would like to thank the Laboratoire for the warm hospitality. References [1] R. J. Baxter, Exactly Solved Models in Statistical Mechanics, Academic Press, New York, 1982. [2] C. Briot and E. Ragoucy, “RTT presentation of finite W-algebras”, J. Phys. A34 (2001) 7287–7310. [3] V. Chari and A. Pressley, “Yangians and R-matrices”, L’Enseign. Math. 36 (1990) 267–302. [4] V. Chari and A. Pressley, A Guide to Quantum Groups, Cambridge University Press, 1994. [5] I. V. Cherednik, “Quantum groups as hidden symmetries of classic representation theory”, pp. 47–54 in Differential Geometric Methods in Physics, ed. A. I. Solomon, World Scientific, Singapore, 1989. [6] I. V. Cherednik, “Factorizing particles on a half line and root systems”, Theoret. Math. Phys. 61 (1984) 977–983. [7] V. G. Drinfeld, “Hopf algebras and the quantum Yang–Baxter equation”, Soviet Math. Dokl. 32 (1985) 254–258. [8] V. G. Drinfeld, “Quantum Groups”, pp. 798–820 in Proc. Int. Congress Math., Berkeley, 1986, AMS, Providence RI, 1987. [9] V. G. Drinfeld, “A new realization of Yangians and quantized affine algebras”, Soviet Math. Dokl. 36 (1988) 212–216. [10] A. G. Izergin and V. E. Korepin, “A lattice model related to the nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equation”, Sov. Phys. Dokl. 26 (1981) 653–654. [11] T. H. Koornwinder and V. B. Kuznetsov, “Gauss hypergeometric function and quadratic R-matrix algebras”, St. Petersburg Math. J. 6 (1994) 161–184. [12] P. P. Kulish and E. K. Sklyanin, “Quantum spectral transform method: recent developments”, pp. 61–119 in Integrable Quantum Field Theories, Lecture Notes in Phys. 151, Springer, Berlin-Heidelberg, 1982. [13] P. P. Kulish and E. K. Sklyanin, “Algebraic structures related to reflection equations”, J. Phys. A25 (1992) 5963–5975 . [14] V. B. Kuznetsov, M. F. Jørgensen and P. L. Christiansen, “New boundary conditions for integrable lattices”, J. Phys. A28 (1995) 4639–4654. [15] V. B. Kuznetsov, “3 F 2 (1) hypergeometric function and quadratic R-matrix algebra”, pp. 185–197 in Symmetries and integrability of difference equations, CRM Proc. Lecture Notes, 9, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1996. [16] A. Liguori, M. Mintchev and L. Zhao, “Boundary exchange algebras and scattering on the half line”, Comm. Math. Phys. 194 (1998) 569–589. [17] M. Mintchev, E. Ragoucy and P. Sorba, “Spontaneous symmetry breaking in the gl(N )-NLS hierarchy on the half line”, to appear in J. Phys. A. [18] A. I. Molev, “Yangians and their applications”, to appear in Handbook of Algebra, Vol. 3, ed. M. Hazewinkel, Elsevier. [19] A. I. Molev, “Gelfand–Tsetlin basis for representations of Yangians”, Lett. Math. Phys. 30 (1994) 53–60.
March 19, 2002 12:23 WSPC/148-RMP
342
00115
A. I. Molev & E. Ragoucy
[20] A. I. Molev, “Finite-dimensional irreducible representations of twisted Yangians”, J. Math. Phys. 39 (1998) 5559–5600. [21] A. Molev, M. Nazarov and G. Olshanski, “Yangians and classical Lie algebras”, Russian Math. Surveys 51(2) (1996) 205–282. [22] M. Nazarov and V. Tarasov, “Representations of Yangians with Gelfand–Zetlin bases”, J. Reine Angew. Math. 496 (1998) 181–212. [23] M. Noumi, “Macdonald’s symmetric polynomials as zonal spherical functions on quantum homogeneous spaces”, Adv. Math. 123 (1996) 16–77. [24] G. Olshanski, “Twisted Yangians and infinite-dimensional classical Lie algebras”, pp. 103–120 in Quantum Groups, ed. P. P. Kulish, Lecture Notes in Math. 1510, Springer, Berlin-Heidelberg, 1992. [25] E. Ragoucy, “Twisted Yangians and folded W-algebras”, Internat. J. Modern Phys. A16 (2001) 2411–2433. [26] E. Ragoucy and P. Sorba, “Yangians and finite W-algebras”, Quantum groups and integrable systems (Prague, 1998). Czechoslovak J. Phys. 48 (1998) 1483–1487. [27] E. Ragoucy and P. Sorba, “Yangian realisations from finite W-algebras”, Comm. Math. Phys. 203 (1999) 551–572. [28] N. Yu. Reshetikhin and M. A. Semenov-Tian-Shansky, “Central extensions of quantum current groups”, Lett. Math. Phys. 19 (1990) 133–142. [29] E. K. Sklyanin, “Boundary conditions for integrable quantum systems”, J. Phys. A21 (1988) 2375–2389. [30] L. A. Takhtajan and L. D. Faddeev, “Quantum inverse scattering method and the Heisenberg XYZ-model”, Russian Math. Surv. 34(5) (1979) 11–68. [31] V. O. Tarasov, “Structure of quantum L-operators for the R-matrix of the XXZmodel”, Theor. Math. Phys. 61 (1984) 1065–1071. [32] V. O. Tarasov, “Irreducible monodromy matrices for the R-matrix of the XXZ-model and lattice local quantum Hamiltonians”, Theor. Math. Phys. 63 (1985) 440–454.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 4 (2002) 343–374 c World Scientific Publishing Company
REFLEXIVE POLYHEDRA, WEIGHTS AND TORIC CALABI YAU FIBRATIONS
MAXIMILIAN KREUZER Institut f¨ ur Theoretische Physik, Technische Universit¨ at Wien Wiedner Hauptstraße 8–10, A-1040 Wien, Austria
[email protected] HARALD SKARKE Mathematical Institute, University of Oxford 24-29 St. Giles’, Oxford OX1 3LB, England
[email protected]
Received 24 April 2001 Revised 19 November 2001 During the last years we have generated a large number of data related to Calabi– Yau hypersurfaces in toric varieties which can be described by reflexive polyhedra. We classified all reflexive polyhedra in three dimensions leading to K3 hypersurfaces and have also completed the four-dimensional case relevant to Calabi–Yau threefolds. In addition, we have analysed for many of the resulting spaces whether they allow fibration structures of the types that are relevant in the context of superstring dualities. In this survey we want to give background information both on how we obtained these data, which can be found at our web site, and on how they may be used. We give a complete exposition of our classification algorithm at a mathematical (rather than algorithmic) level. We also describe how fibration structures manifest themselves in terms of toric diagrams and how we managed to find the respective data. Both for our classification scheme and for simple descriptions of fibration structures the concept of weight systems plays an important role.
1. Introduction A few years after Calabi–Yau manifolds had found their way into physics it was conjectured that they should actually come in pairs with opposite Euler number, since an exchange of complex structure and K¨ ahler moduli in physics corresponds to a change of sign in the definition of the charge, or, equivalently, an exchange of particles and anti-particles [1, 2]. This phenomenon is called mirror symmetry. Although the situation is complicated by the fact that there are rigid Calabi–Yau manifolds whose “mirror string compactifications” do not have a straightforward geometrical interpretation [3, 4], the search for the mirror manifolds proved to be an extremely fruitful enterprise from both the physicists’ and the mathematicians’ perspective [5, 7]. 343
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
344
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
The first systematic constructions of large classes of Calabi–Yau threefolds as complete intersections in products of projective spaces [8] did not seem to support the mirror hypothesis because the resulting manifolds all had negative Euler numbers. But when the attention was extended to weighted projective spaces, it turned out that the blow up parameters of the quotient singularities can provide large positive contributions. The first substantial list of pairs of Hodge numbers resulting from constructions of this type [9] was almost mirror symmetric in the sense that only for a few percent of the Hodge data the respective mirror pair was not in the list. A complete classification [10, 11], however, made the picture worse, and abelian quotients [12], which make a subclass of these spaces perfectly symmetric [13, 14], did not help with this problem either. Batyrev’s construction of toric Calabi–Yau hypersurfaces [15], which is manifestly mirror symmetric while generalising the above results, provided a solution to this puzzle. In this framework the geometrical data is encoded by a reflexive polyhedron,a i.e. a lattice polyhedron whose facets are all at distance 1 from the unique interior point (see below). Toric geometry turned out to provide a very efficient tool for the analysis of many physical aspects of Calabi–Yau compactifications, including the physics of perturbative [16] and non-perturbative [17]–[20] topology changing transitions, as well as fibration structures that are important in string dualities [21, 22]. This made a constructive classification of reflexive polyhedra a useful and interesting enterprise. Our approach to this problem [23] was partly inspired by our experience with the classification of weighted projective spaces that admit transversal quasi-homogeneous polynomials [24]. Indeed, as it turned out, the Newton polyhedra that correspond to polynomials defining CY hypersurfaces in weighted P4 are all reflexive [25, 26] and provide a canonical resolution of the ambient space singularities (this is no longer true in higher dimensions). Actually, regardless of the P transversality condition, a diophantine equation of the form ni ai = d with posP ni , and with the set of solutions restricted to ai ≥ 0 itive coefficients ni , d = gives a simple way to produce lattice polyhedra with at most one interior point (this is a necessary condition for reflexivity): We may regard this as an embedding of the lattice into a higher-dimensional space with the polyhedron being contained in the finite intersection of an affine subspace with the non-negative half-spaces. All lattice points, except for the candidate interior point, whose coordinates are all equal to 1, are located on some coordinate hyperplane ai = 0. We may then ask ourselves if all reflexive polyhedra are contained in polyhedra that can be embedded in this way. In the next section we will show that the answer is assertive provided that we allow for an embedding with higher codimension k −n, i.e. we also consider solutions to more than one equation of the above form, k X i=1 a In
(j)
ai n i
= d(j) ,
d(j) =
k X
(j)
ni ,
j = 1, . . . , k − n ,
i=1
the present context polyhedra are always convex subsets of a real vector space.
(1)
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
345
(j)
but with some of the coefficients ni equal to zero according to a certain pattern. What then makes our construction work is the fact that there is only a finite set of coefficients that lead to lattice polytopes with an interior point. The collections (j) ni of non-negative numbers are called weight systems in the case of a single equation and combined weight systems if k − n > 1. If we shift our coordinates to xi = ai − 1 the resulting polyhedron lies in a linear subspace of the embedding P (j) space determined by i ni xi = 0, is bounded by xi ≥ −1 and has the origin of the embedding space as its interior point. (These linear coordinates are more useful for many general considerations whereas the affine coordinates ai are better suited for quickly finding the lattice points in a given example.) In practice, because of the huge number of solutions, an enumeration of all reflexive polyhedra seems to be possible only in up to 4 dimensions. This leads to a further simplification of the procedure because in up to 4 dimensions all polytopes ∆ that correspond to a minimal combined weight systems are reflexive [26]. It is easy to see that the dual ∆∗ (defined in Eq. (2) below) of a reflexive polytope ∆ is ˆ again a reflexive lattice polytope. Moreover, ∆ is contained in a larger polytope ∆ ˆ ∗ is contained in ∆∗ . Therefore only minimal polytopes for if and only if its dual ∆ which ∆∗ does not contain any reflexive subpolytope are necessary ingredients for our classification scheme. We will show that in 4 dimension there are 308 reflexive polytopes that contain all others as subpolytopes, provided that we also consider sublattices. Finding all relevant lattices is a subtle point and our strategy to solve this problem will be described in the next section. 25 additional maximal reflexive polytopes can be obtained directly from these 308 objects on sublattices. The remaining 7 maximal polytopes could only be found by carrying out the complete classification algorithm. While one of the main insights of the “first superstring revolution” was the fact that Calabi–Yau spaces are crucial for string compactifications, it was found during the “second string revolution” that fibration structures of Calabi–Yau manifolds are essential for understanding various non-perturbative string dualities. In particular, K3 fibrations are required for the duality between heterotic and IIA theories [27, 28] and elliptic fibrations are needed for F -theory compactifications [22, 29, 30]. Again toric geometry provides beautiful tools for studying the respective structures. As we will see, the polytope ∆∗f corresponding to the fiber manifests itself as a subpolytope of ∆∗ with the same interior point, whereas the base space is a toric variety whose fan can be determined by projecting the original fan along the linear subspace spanned by ∆∗f . While we never attempted to give a complete classification of structures of this type, we did create large lists of fibration structures [31, 32]. The geometry of such toric fibrations was analysed in more detail in [33]. Our data are accessible at our web site [34], and we plan to make the source code of our programs available in the near future. Since one of the motivations for writing this contribution was to give useful background material for anyone interested in applying our data, we would like to briefly mention some older results on our web page that will not be discussed in the remainder of this paper. These are mostly related to weighted projective spaces and, in the physical context, to
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
346
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
Landau–Ginzburg models [2, 35]. We classified all 10839 weight systems allowing transversal quasihomogeneous polynomials [24, 10] with singularity index 3, leading to Landau–Ginzburg models with a central charge of c = 9 and computed the corresponding numbers of (anti)chiral states in the superconformal field theories (this includes the 7555 transversal weights for weighted P4 ). Vafa’s formulas for these numbers [35] inspired the definition of what Batyrev et al. call string theoretic Hodge numbers [36]. We also extended these results to arbitrary abelian quotients that leave a transversal polynomial invariant [12] (and included the modifications by discrete torsions [37], which correspond to topologically non-trivial background 2-form fields in the physical context [38]). Since the Newton polyhedra are reflexive also for abelian quotients, the resulting Hodge numbers (without discrete torsion) are all recovered in the toric context. Nevertheless our results might be useful when working in weighted projective spaces, since transversal polynomials in general have larger symmetries than the complete Newton polyhedra. We will not discuss Calabi–Yau data obtained by other groups here. An important class of spaces that we did not consider consists of complete intersection Calabi–Yau varieties. The classification of these objects in products of projective spaces was given in [8], and Klemm has produced a sizeable list of codimension two complete intersections in weighted projective spaces. A number of toric complete intersections [39, 40] was constructed in [41, 42]. All transversal weights for Calabi– Yau 4-folds in weighted P5 were constructed in [43]. Further web pages with relevant information are [44, 45]. In the next section we give a self-contained exposition of our classification algorithm and of the results in 3 and 4 dimensions. In Sec. 3 we discuss the implications of these results for the geometry of toric K3 and Calabi–Yau hypersurfaces. In Sec. 4 we explain the toric realisation of fibrations where both the fibered space and the fiber have vanishing first Chern classes. We discuss how weight systems can be used to encode such fibrations and how this is related to fibrations in weighted projective spaces. We also provide an appendix with several tables that summarise some of our results. 2. Classification of Reflexive Polyhedra In this section we give a self-contained exposition of our methods and results on the classification of reflexive polyhedra, without reference to toric geometry. Nevertheless, as we will see in the next section, some of the concepts used here, in particular the concept of weights, have interpretations in terms of geometry. A polytope in Rn is the convex hull of a finite set of points in Rn , and for our present purposes a polyhedron is the same thing as a polytope (in particular, it is always bounded, which need not be true if a polyhedron is defined as the intersection of a finite number of half spaces). We will be interested in the case where we have a pair of lattices M ' Zn and N = Hom(M, Z) ' Zn and their real extensions MR ' Rn and NR ' Rn . A
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
347
polyhedron ∆ ⊂ MR is called a lattice (or integer) polyhedron if the vertices of ∆ lie in M . Definition 2.1. A polytope ∆ ⊂ Rn has the “interior point property” or “IP property”, if 0 (the origin of Rn ) is in the interior. A simplex with this property is an IP simplex. Definition 2.2. For any set ∆ ⊂ MR the dual (or polar) set ∆∗ ⊂ NR = MR∗ is given by ∆∗ = {y ∈ NR : hy, xi ≥ −1 ∀ x ∈ ∆} ,
(2)
where hy, xi is the duality pairing between y ∈ NR and x ∈ MR . If ∆ is a polytope with the IP property, then ∆∗ is also a polytope with the IP property and (∆∗ )∗ = ∆. Definition 2.3. A lattice polyhedron ∆ ⊂ MR is called reflexive if its dual ∆∗ ⊂ NR is a lattice polyhedron w.r.t. the lattice N dual to M . The main idea of our classification scheme is to construct a set of polyhedra such that every reflexive polyhedron is a subpolyhedron of one of the polyhedra in this set. By duality, every reflexive polyhedron must contain one of the duals of these polyhedra, so we are looking for polyhedra that are minimal in some sense. In the following subsection we will give a definition of minimality that depends only on the way in which a polytope is spanned by its vertices, without reference to a lattice or details of the linear structure. We will see that this allows for a very rough classification with only a few objects in low dimensions. The corresponding characterisation of polyhedra can be refined by specifying explicitly the linear relations between the vertices with the help of weight systems. We will see that these weight systems can be used in a simple way to find the polyhedra dual to the minimal ones and to check whether they can possibly contain reflexive polyhedra; the main criterion here is the existence of a dual pair of lattices such that a minimal polytope is a lattice polyhedron and the convex hull of the lattice points of the dual has the IP property. The classification of the relevant weight systems leads to a finite number of polytopes that contain all reflexive polytopes, with the subtlety that only the linear structure but not the lattice on which some polytope may be reflexive is specified. In the final subsection we solve this problem by showing how to identify all lattices on which a polyhedron given in terms of its linear structure can be reflexive, and present the results of our classification scheme. Let us illustrate with the example in Fig. 1 how we can obtain a weight system for a given reflexive polyhedron ∆ with vertices in some n-dimensional lattice M . Reflexivity implies that the dual (or polar) polytope ∆∗ defined in Eq. (2) has its vertices on the dual lattice N = Hom(M, Z). In our case ∆∗ is already minimal in the sense that we lose the interior point (IP) if we drop any of its vertices and take the convex hull of the remaining vertices. The set of vertices of ∇ = ∆∗
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
348
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
Fig. 1.
A minimal polyhedron ∇ that corresponds to a combined weight system.
can be decomposed into the two triangles (V1 , V2 , V5 ) and (V3 , V4 , V5 ) that both contain the IP in their lower-dimensional interior. As we will show later, similar decompositions are always possible for minimal polyhedra. For both triangles the P barycentric coordinates of the IP are given by q = (1/4, 1/4, 1/2), i.e. qi Vi = 0 P and qi = 1, where the sum is over the indices of the vertices for any of the (j) (j) two triangles. Rescaling the coefficients to integers ni = d(j) qi we arrive at the (1) (2) weight system ni = (1, 1, 0, 0, 2), ni = (0, 0, 1, 1, 2). We will show that weights obtained in this way can always be used to describe the dual polytope ∆ as in Eq. 1. In the present case, this construction leads to x1 + x2
+2x5 = 0 , x3 + x4 + 2x5 = 0 .
(3) (4)
Eliminating, for example, x2 and x4 it is easily checked that we indeed reconstructed ∆ (note that ai = xi + 1 is the lattice distance of a point from the facet dual to Vi ). If we keep all points with xi ≥ −1 then, in our example, ∆∗ is equal to ∇. In general ∆∗ will not be minimal and we first have to drop some vertices of ∆∗ to arrive at a minimal polytope ∇ whose simplex decomposition leads to a weight system. If we drop points from ∆ in such a way that ∆0 ⊂ ∆ is reflexive, then ∆0∗ becomes larger. The vertices of ∇ remain vertices of ∆0∗ ⊃ ∇ as long as the bounding hyperplanes xi = −1, which in our case support all facets of ∆, are affinely spanned by facets of ∆0 . A different way to generate a “smaller” ∆ is to keep the vertices but to go to a coarser M lattice: We may, for example, demand x1 − x3 ∈ 2Z or x1 + x5 ∈ 2Z. Correspondingly, the N lattice becomes finer and is no longer generated by the vertices of ∇. In general there will occur additional lattice points in ∇. The coarsest lattice that keeps all vertices of ∆ and the IP is obtained by imposing x1 − x3 ∈ 4Z and x1 + x5 ∈ 2Z. Actually, in our example, this exchanges ∇ and ∆.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
349
2.1. Minimal polyhedra and their structures We will later give various definitions of minimality, each of which has advantages and disadvantages. Here we define the weakest form of minimality, but the one that is most useful, where we forget for the time being about the lattice structure and concentrate on the vertex structure only. Definition 2.4. A minimal polyhedron ∇ ⊂ Rn is defined by the following properties: (i) ∇ has the IP property. (ii) If we remove one of the vertices of ∇, the convex hull of the remaining vertices of ∇ does not have the IP property. Obviously every polytope ∇ ⊂ Rn with the IP property contains at least one minimal polytope spanned by a subset of the vertices of ∇. Before asking ourselves which minimal polytopes can be subpolytopes of reflexive polyhedra, we will now analyse the possible general structures of minimal polytopes. Lemma 2.1. A minimal polytope ∇ ⊂ Rn with vertices V1 , . . . , Vk is either a simplex or contains an n0 -dimensional minimal polytope ∇0 := ConvexHull{V1 , . . . , Vk0 } and an IP simplex S := ConvexHull(R ∪ {Vk0 +1 , . . . , Vk }) with R ⊂ {V1 , . . . , Vk0 } such that k − k 0 = n − n0 + 1 ≥ 2 and dim S ≤ n0 . Proof. If ∇ is a simplex, there is nothing left to prove. Otherwise, we first note that every vertex V of ∇ must belong to at least one IP simplex: It is always possible to find a triangulation of ∇ such that every n-simplex in this triangulation has V as a vertex (just triangulate the cone whose apex is V and whose one-dimensional rays are V V˜ , where the V˜ are the other vertices of ∇). As 0 must belong to at least one of these simplices, it must lie on some simplicial face which then is an IP simplex. Now consider the set of all IP simplices consisting of vertices of ∇. Any subset of this set will define a lower-dimensional minimal polytope: The fact that 0 is interior to each simplex means that it is a positive linear combination of the vertices of any such simplex, and therefore 0 can also be written as a positive linear combination of all vertices involved. If the corresponding polytope were not minimal, our original ∇ could not be minimal, either. Among all lower-dimensional minimal polytopes, take one (call it ∇0 ) with the maximal dimension n0 smaller than n. Rn factorises 0 0 0 into Rn and Rn /Rn ∼ = Rn−n (equivalence classes in Rn ). The remaining vertices 0 define a polytope ∇n−n0 in Rn /Rn . If ∇n−n0 were not a simplex, it would contain a simplex of dimension smaller than n − n0 which would define, together with the vertices of ∇0 , a minimal polytope of dimension s with n0 < s < n, in contradiction with our assumption. Therefore ∇n−n0 is a simplex. Because of minimality of ∇, each of the n − n0 + 1 vertices of ∇n−n0 can have only one representative in Rn ,
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
350
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
implying k − k 0 = n − n0 + 1. The equivalence class of 0 can be described uniquely as a positive linear combination of these vertices. This linear combination defines 0 a vector in Rn , which can be written as a negative linear combination of ≤ n0 linearly independent vertices of ∇0 . These vertices, together with those of ∇n−n0 , form the simplex S. By the maximality assumption about ∇0 , dim S cannot exceed dim ∇0 . Definition 2.5. For an n-dimensional minimal polytope ∇ with k vertices, an IP simplex structure is a collection of subsets Si , 1 ≤ i ≤ k − n of the set of vertices of ∇, such that: The convex hull of the vertices in each Si is an IP simplex, Sj ∇j = ConvexHull i=1 Si is a lower-dimensional minimal polytope for every j ∈ {1, . . . , k − n}, ∇k−n = ∇ and Sj−1 Sj \ i=1 Si contains at least two vertices. Corollary 2.1. Every minimal polytope allows an IP simplex structure. Proof. If ∇ is a simplex, this is obvious. Otherwise one can choose Sk−n = S and ∇k−n−1 = ∇0 with S and ∇0 as in Lemma 2.1 and proceed inductively. Lemma 2.2. Denote by {Si } an IP simplex structure. Then Si − contains exactly one point.
S j6=i
Sj never
Proof. An IP simplex contains line segments V V 0 with V 0 = −εV , where ε is a positive number. If a simplex S = ConvexHull {V1 , . . . , Vs+1 } has all of its vertices except one (Vs+1 ) in common with other simplices, then all points in the linear span of S are nonnegative linear combinations of the Vj and the −εj Vj with j ≤ s, thus showing that Vs+1 violates the minimality of ∇. The following example shows that an IP simplex structure need not be unique: Example 2.1. n = 5, ∇ = ConvexHull {V1 , . . . , V8 } with V1 = (1, 1, 0, 0, 0), V2 = (1, −1, 0, 0, 0), V3 = (−1, 0, 1, 0, 0), V4 = (−1, 0, −1, 0, 0) , V5 = (−1, 0, 0, 1, 0), V6 = (−1, 0, 0, −1, 0), V7 = (1, 0, 0, 0, 1), V8 = (1, 0, 0, 0, −1) . (5) ∇ contains the IP simplices S1234 = V1 V2 V3 V4 (in the x1 x2 x3 -plane), S1256 (in the x1 x2 x4 -plane), S3478 (in the x1 x3 x5 -plane), S5678 (in the x1 x4 x5 -plane) and the 4dimensional minimal polytopes ∇123456 , ∇123478 , ∇125678 , ∇345678 . Any set of three of the four IP simplices defines an IP simplex structure.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
351
Lemma 2.3. For dimensions n = 1, 2, 3, 4 of Rn precisely the following IP simplex structures of minimal polyhedra are possible: n = 1 : {S1 = V1 V2 } ; n = 2 : {S1 = V1 V2 V3 } , {S1 = V1 V2 , S2 = V10 V20 , } ; n = 3 : {S1 = V1 V2 V3 V4 } , {S1 = V1 V2 V3 , S2 = V10 V20 } , {S1 = V1 V2 V3 , S2 = V1 V20 V30 } , {S1 = V1 V2 , S2 = V10 V20 , S3 = V100 V200 } ; n = 4 : As in the first column of Table 1 in the appendix . Proof. Recursive application of Lemma 2.1 and use of Lemma 2.2 shows that these are the only possible structures. Explicit realisations of these structures will be presented later. 2.2. Weight systems Any IP polytope, and therefore any reflexive polyhedron, must obviously contain one of the minimal polyhedra encountered in the last subsection. The structures found there are rather coarse, so now we have to face the task of suitably refining them in such a way that they become useful for our goal of classifying reflexive polyhedra. In particular, we will find that the linear relations between the vertices of minimal polyhedra can be encoded by sets of real numbers called weight systems, and we will address the question of which weight systems can occur if a minimal polyhedron is a subpolyhedron of some reflexive polytope. The fact that a simplex spanned by vertices Vi contains the origin in its interior is equivalent to the condition that there exist positive real numbers (weights) qi P such that qi Vi = 0. As these numbers are unique up to a common factor, it is P convenient to choose some normalisation such as qi = 1. Definition 2.6. A weight system is a collection of positive real numbers (weights) P qi = 1. A weight system corresponding to an IP simplex with vertices qi with P qi Vi = 0. A combined weight Vi is the normalised set of numbers qi such that system (CWS) corresponding to a minimal polyhedron endowed with an IP simplex (j) structure is the collection of weight systems qi corresponding to the IP simplices (j) Sj occurring there, with qi = 0 if Vi 6∈ Sj . We call a (combined) weight system rational if all of the qi are rational numbers. If a minimal polyhedron ∇ is a lattice polyhedron, a corresponding CWS will always be rational. In this case it is possible to normalise the weights as positive P integers ni with no common divisor; then qi = ni /d with d = ni . We will use both conventions for describing weight systems. By the definition of a lattice polyhedron,
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
352
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
any lattice on which a minimal polyhedron ∇ is integer must contain the lattice Ncoarsest generated by the vertices of ∇. Definition 2.7. Given a minimal polyhedron ∇ ⊂ NR , we define the lattice Ncoarsest as the lattice in NR generated linearly over Z by the vertices of ∇ and the lattice Mfinest ⊂ MR as the lattice dual to Ncoarsest . Lemma 2.4. If ∇ is a minimal polyhedron with vertices Vi and q a CWS corresponding to an IP simplex structure of ∇, then: (a) The map MR → Rk , X → x = (x1 , . . . , xk ) with xi = hVi , Xi defines an P (j) embedding such that the image of MR is the subspace defined by i qi xi = 0 ∀ j. (b) ∇∗ is isomorphic to the polyhedron defined in this subspace by xi ≥ −1 for i = 1, . . . , k. (c) If q is rational, then Mfinest is isomorphic to the sublattice of Zk = P (j) {(x1 , . . . , xk ) integer} ⊂ Rk determined by the equations i qi xi = 0. Proof. P (j) P (j) (a) qi Vi = 0 implies i qi xi = 0. Conversely, the xi determine X because a point in MR is uniquely determined by its duality pairings with a set of generators (here, the Vi ) of the dual space. (b) Follows from the form of the embedding map and the definition of the dual polytope (2). (c) If X belongs to any lattice M such that ∇ is integer on the dual lattice N , the corresponding xi must be integer. If the xi are integer, then X has integer pairings with the generators Vi of Ncoarsest , so X belongs to Mfinest. Corollary 2.2. An IP simplex structure together with the specification of a CWS uniquely determines a minimal polyhedron up to isomorphism. Proof. By Lemma 2.4, ∇∗ and hence ∇ is uniquely determined by the CWS. As our example after Lemma 2.2 shows, an IP simplex structure need not be unique, so it is possible that two different CWS may correspond to the same minimal polytope. In such a situation, the weight systems of one CWS must be linear combinations of those of the other CWS with coefficients that are not all nonnegative. Since all weights must be positive, this can only happen if there is an IP simplex such that all of its vertices also belong to other IP simplices in the same IP simplex structure. This can happen only for n ≥ 5, as one can see by explicitly checking all cases for n ≤ 4. Thus, for n ≥ 5 it might be preferable to work with equivalence classes of CWS leading to the same minimal polytopes instead of using CWS only.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
353
Definition 2.8. If q is a rational CWS corresponding to a minimal polyhedron ∇, we define ∆(q) as the convex hull of ∇∗ ∩ Mfinest . We say that q has the IP property if ∆(q) has the IP property. Corollary 2.3. If a CWS has the IP property, then every single weight system occurring in it also has the IP property. Proof. Without loss of generality we can assume that the single weight system is (1) (1) q(1) with qi > 0 for i ≤ l and qi = 0 for i > l. There is a natural projection π from Zk as in Lemma 2.4 to Zl by restriction to the first l coordinates. Our construction implies that the projection of the lattice polytope in Zk is a subpolytope of the P (1) lattice polytope in Zl determined by i qi xi = 0 and xi ≥ −1. If 0l = π(0k ) were not in the interior of the polytope in Zl , then 0k could not be in the interior of the polytope in Zk . Lemma 2.5. Let l denote the number of weights of a weight system. Then the following statements hold: l = 2: There is a single IP weight system, namely (1, 1). l = 3: There are three IP weight systems, namely (1, 1, 1), (1, 1, 2) and (1, 2, 3). l = 4: There are the 95 IP weight systems shown in Table 3. l = 5: There are 184, 026 IP weight systems which can be found at our web site [34] Proof. The classification of IP weight systems is based on the study of which integer points are allowed by Lemma 2.4. Assume that a weight system q1 , . . . , ql allows a collection of points with coordinates xi ≥ −1 as in Lemma 2.4, including the interior point with xi = 0 ∀ i. If these points fulfill an equation of the type Pl 0 with a 6= q, then the weight system must also allow at least one i=1 ai xi = Pl Pl point with i=1 ai xi > 0 and at least one point with i=1 ai xi < 0 to ensure that 0 is really in the interior. The latter inequality is the one that we actually use for the algorithm: Starting with the point 0, we see that unless our weight system is Pl q = (1/l, . . . , 1/l), there must be at least one point with i=1 xi < 0. For l ≤ 5 there are only a few possibilities, and after choosing some point x1 , we can look for some simple equation fulfilled by 0 and x1 and proceed in the same way. If l = 2, any weight system except (1/2, 1/2) would have to allow an integer point with x1 + x2 < 0, x1 ≥ −1 and x2 ≥ −1. Such a point has no positive coordinate and therefore cannot be allowed by a (positive) weight system. For l = 3 the classification is still easily carried out by hand: Unless q = (1/3, 1/3, 1/3), we need at least one point with x1 + x2 + x3 < 0. As points where no coordinate is greater than 0 would be in conflict with the positivity of the weight system, we need the point (1, −1, −1) (up to a permutation of indices). Now we note that 0 and (1, −1, −1) both fulfill 2x1 + x2 + x3 = 0, so q = (1/2, 1/4, 1/4) or we need a point with 2x1 +x2 +x3 < 0. The only point allowed by this inequality which leads to a sensible weight system is (−1, 2, −1), leading to q = (1/2, 1/3, 1/6).
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
354
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
For l = 4 and l = 5 we have implemented this strategy in a computer program that produced 99 and 200653 candidates for IP weight systems, respectively. Finally, explicit constructions of ∆(q) show that four of the 99 weight systems with l = 4 and 16627 of the 200653 weight systems with l = 5 do not have the IP property, leading to the results given. Remark 2.1. The 95 IP weight systems for l = 4 are precisely the well known 95 weight systems for weighted P4 ’s that have K3 hypersurfaces [46, 47], whereas for l = 5 the 7555 weight systems corresponding to weighted P4 ’s that allow transverse polynomials [11, 10] are just a small subset of the 184026 different IP weight systems. Lemma 2.6. In dimensions n = 1, 2, 3, 4, the CWS with the IP property are the weight systems with l = n + 1 given in the previous lemma and, in addition, the following CWS: n = 2: {(1, 1, 0, 0), (0, 0, 1, 1)} n = 3: The 21 CWS given in Table 2 n = 4: 17320 CWS (cf. the second column of Table 1) Proof. By explicitly combining the structures of Lemma 2.3 with the IP weight systems of Lemma 2.5 and checking for the IP property of ∆(q). 2.3. The classification As we saw in the previous subsections, every reflexive polyhedron must contain at least one minimal polytope corresponding to one of the CWS found there. Thus, by duality, every reflexive polyhedron must be a subpolyhedron of one of the ∆(q) on some suitable sublattice of the finest possible lattice Mfinest . We start this section with analysing the question of which dual pairs of lattices can be chosen such that a dual pair of polyhedra is reflexive on them. Then we give various refinements of our original definition of minimality, and finally we present our results on the classification of reflexive polyhedra. Given a dual pair of polytopes such that ∆ has nV vertices and nF facets (a facet being a codimension 1 face), the dual polytope has nV facets and nF vertices. Definition 2.9. The vertex pairing matrix (VPM) X is the nF × nV matrix whose entries are Xij = hV¯i , Vj i, where V¯i and Vj are the vertices of ∆∗ and ∆, respectively. Xij will be −1 whenever Vj lies on the i’th facet. Note that X is independent of the choice of a dual pair of bases in NR and MR but depends on the orderings of the vertices. If ∆ is reflexive, then its VPM is obviously integer. In this case there are distinguished lattices Mcoarsest and Ncoarsest , generated by the vertices of ∆ and ∆∗ , respectively, and their duals Nfinest and Mfinest . Clearly any lattice M on which ∆ is reflexive must fulfill Mcoarsest ⊆ M ⊆ Mfinest.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
355
Lemma 2.7. If ∆ ⊂ MR ' Rn is a polytope with the IP property such that its VPM X is integer, the following statements hold: ˜ ·D ˜ ·U ˜ = W · D · U, where W ˜ is a GL(nF , Z) X can be decomposed as X = W ˜ ˜ matrix, U is a GL(nV , Z) matrix and D is an nF × nV matrix such that the first n diagonal elements are positive integers whereas all other elements are zero; W, D and U are the obvious nF × n, n × n and n × nV submatrices. The lattices M ⊂ MR on which ∆ is reflexive are in one to one correspondence with decompositions D = T · S, where T and S are upper triangular integer matrices with positive diagonal elements and with 0 ≤ Tji < Tii . Then ∆ as a lattice polyhedron on M is isomorphic to the polytope in Zn whose vertices are given by the columns of S · U and ∆∗ is isomorphic to the polytope in Zn whose vertices are given by the lines of W · T . In particular, ∆ on Mfinest corresponds to D · U, ∆ on Mcoarsest corresponds to U, ∆∗ on Nfinest corresponds to W · D and ∆∗ on Ncoarsest corresponds to W. Proof. By recombining the lines and columns of X in the style of Gauss’s algorithm for solving systems of linear equations, we can turn X into an nF ×nV matrix ˜ with non-vanishing elements only along the diagonal. But recombining lines just D corresponds to left multiplication with some GL(nF , Z) matrix, whereas recombining columns corresponds to right multiplication with some GL(nV , Z) matrix. Keeping track of the inverses of these matrices, we successively create decomposi˜ (n) · U ˜ (n) (with W ˜ (0) = 1, D ˜ (0) = X and U ˜ (0) = 1). We denote ˜ (n) · D tions X = W ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ being regular the matrices resulting from the last step by W , D and U . W and U ˜ has only n non-vanishing matrices and the rank of X being n, it is clear that D elements which can be taken to be the first n diagonal elements. In the same way as we defined an embedding of MR in Rk Lemma 2.4, we now define an embedding in RnF such that Mfinest is isomorphic to the sublattice of ZnF determined by the linear relations among the V¯i . In this context the Xij ˜ effects a are just the embedding coordinates of the Vj . The nF × nF matrix W nF so that ∆ now lies in the lattice spanned by the change of coordinates in Z first d coordinates. Thus we can interpret the columns of D · U as the vertices of ∆ on Mfinest. Similarly, the lines of W · D are coordinates of the vertices of ∆∗ on Nfinest , whereas U and W are the corresponding coordinates on the coarsest possible lattices. ~ i and the generators of Mfinest by ~ei , we Denoting the generators of Mcoarsest by E ~ i = ~ej Dji . An intermediate lattice will have generators E~i = ~ej Tji such that have E ~ i = E~j Sji = ~ek Tkj Sji ~ i can be expressed in terms of the E~j , amounting to E the E with some integer matrix S. This results in the condition Dki = Tkj Sji . In order to get rid of the redundancy coming from the fact that the intermediate lattices can be described by different sets of generators, one may proceed in the following way: E~1 may be chosen as a multiple of ~e1 (i.e., E~1 = ~e1 T11 ). Then we choose E~2 as a vector in the ~e1 -~e2 -plane (i.e., E~1 = ~e1 T12 + ~e2 T22 ) subject to the condition that the lattice generated by E~1 and E~2 should be a sublattice of the one generated
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
356
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
~ 1 and E ~ 2 , which is equivalent to the possibility of solving Tkj Sji = Dki for by E integer matrix elements of S. We may avoid the ambiguity arising by the possibility of adding a multiple of E1 to E2 by demanding 0 ≤ T12 < T11 . We can choose the elements of T column by column (in rising order). For each particular column i we first pick Tii such that it divides Dii ; then Sii = Dii /Tii . Then we pick the Tji with j decreasing from i − 1 to 1. At each step the j’th line of T · S = D, X Tjk Ski + Tjj Sji = 0 , (6) Tji Sii + j
must be solved for the unknown Tji and Sji with the extra condition 0 ≤ Tji < Tii ensuring that we get only one representative of each equivalence class of bases. At this point we have, in principle, all the ingredients that we need for a complete classification of reflexive polyhedra. We simply have to construct all subpolyhedra with integer VPM of all ∆(q) with q being one of our IP CWS, and apply Lemma 2.7. Both for theoretical and for practical reasons, however, it is interesting to reduce the number of polyhedra used as a starting point in our scheme. To this end we will give various refinements of our original definition of minimality, preceded by a useful lemma on the structure of ∆(q). Lemma 2.8. For n ≤ 4, ∆(q) is reflexive whenever it has the IP property. Proof. This fact was proved in [26] and later explicitly confirmed by our computer programs. Definition 2.10. Let ∇ ⊂ NR be a minimal lattice polyhedron such that ∆, the convex hull of ∇∗ ∩ M , also has the IP property. Then we say that ∇ has the span property if the vertices of ∇ are also vertices of ∆∗ ; ∇ is lp-minimal: if we remove one of the vertices of ∇, the convex hull of the remaining set of lattice points of ∇ does not have the IP property; ∇ is very minimal; if we remove one of the vertices of ∇ from the set of lattice points of ∆∗ , the convex hull of the remaining lattice points of ∆∗ does not have the IP property; a CWS q is said to have one of the above properties if the corresponding ∇ on Ncoarsest has it. A reflexive polytope ∆ ⊂ MR is called r-maximal (and its dual ∆∗ ⊂ NR r-minimal) if it is not contained in any other reflexive polytope; a CWS q is called r-minimal if ∆(q) is r-maximal. The name “span property” refers to the fact that our definition is equivalent to the statement that the hyperplanes in MR dual to the vertices of ∇ are spanned by points of ∆. The following lemma clarifies the relations between the various definitions of minimality and the ways in which these definitions can be used to refine our classification scheme. It also answers the question of how many CWS of the various minimality types exist.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
357
Lemma 2.9. (a) For every reflexive polytope ∆ ⊂ MR , there exists at least one CWS q with the span property such that ∆ is a subpolyhedron of the convex hull of ∇∗ ∩ M and M is a sublattice of Mfinest. (b) For every reflexive polytope ∆ ⊂ MR , there exists at least one lp-minimal CWS q such that ∆ is a subpolyhedron of the convex hull of ∇∗ ∩ M and M is a sublattice of Mfinest . (c) If q is very minimal, ∆(q) is not a subpolyhedron of ∆(q0 ) for any q0 corresponding to a minimal polytope different from the one defined by q. (d) A very minimal polytope is lp-minimal and has the span property. (e) For every reflexive polytope ∆ ⊂ MR ' Rn with n ≤ 4, there exists at least one r-minimal CWS q such that ∆ is a subpolyhedron of the convex hull of ∇∗ ∩ M and M is a sublattice of Mfinest . (f) For n ≤ 4, a CWS q is r-minimal if and only if it is very minimal. (g) For n ≤ 3 (but not for n = 4), every lp-minimal CWS has the span property. (h) The very minimal CWS for n = 2 are {(1, 1, 1)}, {(1, 1, 2)} and {(1, 1, 0, 0), (0, 0, 1, 1)}. The remaining IP weight system {(1, 2, 3)} has the span property but is not lp-minimal. (i) For n = 3 the minimality type is indicated in Tables 2 and 3. (j) For n = 4 the numbers of CWS of the different minimality types are given in Table 1. Proof. (a) By dropping vertices from ∆∗ one can always arrive at a minimal polytope ∇ ⊆ ∆∗ and the corresponding CWS. (b) By dropping lattice points from ∆∗ one can always arrive at an lp-minimal (and therefore also minimal) polytope ∇ ⊆ ∆∗ and the corresponding CWS. (c) If ∆(q) were a subpolyhedron of ∆(q0 ) for some q0 other than q, then (∆(q))∗ would contain (but not be equal to) (∆(q0 ))∗ , which is impossible by the definition of q being very minimal. (d) By definition, ∆ ⊆ ∇∗ , implying ∇ ⊆ ∆∗ . Very minimal implies span: If a vertex of ∇ were not a vertex of ∆∗ , it would be in the convex hull of the remaining lattice points of ∆∗ which then would be equal to ∆∗ and hence have the IP property, thus violating the assumption that ∇ is very minimal. The fact that very minimal implies lp-minimal is obvious from comparing the different definitions. (e) With (a), we can find a CWS q(1) such that ∆ is a subpolyhedron of ∆(q(1) ), possibly on a sublattice. By Lemma 2.8, ∆(q(1) ) is reflexive. If q(1) is not rminimal, ∆(q(1) ) is a proper subpolyhedron of some other reflexive polyhedron ∆(1) for which we can find a CWS q(2) as before. As the number of lattice
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
358
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
points of ∆(q(i) ) increases in every step, this process has to terminate; thus q(i) must be r-minimal for some i. (f) Because of (c), every very minimal CWS is r-minimal. The fact that every r-minimal CWS is very minimal was checked explicitly by our computer programs. (g)–(j) By explicit checks, for n ≥ 3 with the help of our computer programs. To end this section, we now give the results of the application of our classification scheme for various dimensions. Proposition 2.1. For n = 2 there are 16 reflexive polyhedra up to linear isomorphisms. All of them are subpolyhedra of ∆(q) where q is one of the three very minimal CWS. Proof. The classification of 2-dimensional reflexive polyhedra has been established for a while (see, e.g., [48, 49]) and is easily reproduced within our scheme. The second fact can be checked explicitly. Proposition 2.2. For n = 3 there are 4319 reflexive polyhedra up to linear isomorphisms. 4318 of them are subpolyhedra of ∆(q) where q is one of the very minimal CWS of Tables 2 and 3. The remaining one is the convex hull of ∇∗ ∩ M, where ∇ is determined by the weight system (1, 1, 1, 1) and M is a Z2 sublattice of Mfinest . Proof. We explicitly constructed all subpolyhedra with integer VPMs of the ∆(q) coming from very minimal CWS with the help of a computer program and checked that polyhedra coming from CWS that are not very minimal are contained in the list of reflexive subpolyhedra of the ∆(q) for very minimal CWS. Application of Lemma 2.7 produced the last polyhedron (see [50]). Proposition 2.3. For n = 4 there are 473, 800, 776 reflexive polyhedra up to linear isomorphisms. In addition to ∆(q) with q one of the 308 r-minimal CWS, there are 32 further r-maximal polyhedra. Proof. Our computer programs produced 473,800,652 different reflexive subpolyhedra of the 308 polytopes we started with, and another 124 that are subpolytopes on sublattices. Among these there are 25 r-maximal polyhedra that were obtained by applying Lemma 2.7 to the original 308 r-maximal polytopes and checking for r-minimality of the duals on the various lattices allowed by Lemma 2.7. Another 7 r-maximal polyhedra showed up on sublattices that were generated either by lattice reductions that were required by reflexivity during the search for subpolytopes or in the final search for all allowed lattices for all VPMs (for details see [51]).
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
359
3. Geometric Interpretation of Our Classification Results We now want to discuss what our results on the classification of reflexive polyhedra imply for Calabi–Yau manifolds that are hypersurfaces in toric varieties. The lattice points of a reflexive polyhedron ∆ encode the monomials occurring in the description of the hypersurface in a variety VΣ whose fan Σ is determined by a triangulation of the dual polyhedron ∆∗ . For details of what a fan is and how it determines a toric variety, it is best to look up a standard textbook [52, 53]. There is one particular approach to the description of toric varieties, however, which cannot be found there. This is the description in terms of homogeneous coordinates [54], which is the one most useful for applications in physics, and which also exhibits in the clearest way the significance of the weight systems that we used in the context of our classification scheme. We will briefly present this approach and show how Calabi–Yau manifolds are constructed in this setup and then we will proceed to explain some of the consequences of our results in terms of geometry. Given a fan Σ in NR , it is possible to assign a global homogeneous coordinate system to VΣ in a way similar to the usual construction of Pn . To this end one assigns a coordinate zk , k = 1, . . . , K to each one-dimensional cone in Σ. If the primitive generators v1 , . . . , vK of these one-dimensional cones span NR , then there P must be K − n independent linear relations of the type k wjk vk = 0. These linear relations are used to define equivalence relations of the type 1
K
(z1 , . . . , zK ) ∼ (λwj z1 , . . . , λwj zK ) ,
j = 1, . . . , K − n
(7)
on the space CK \ ZΣ . The set ZΣ is determined by the fan Σ in the following way: It is the union of spaces {(z1 , . . . , zK ) : zi = 0 ∀ i ∈ I}, where the index sets I are those sets for which {vi : i ∈ I} does not belong to a cone in Σ. Thus (C∗ )K ⊂ CK \ ZΣ ⊂ CK \ {0}. Then VΣ = (CK \ ZΣ )/((C∗ )(K−n) × G), where the K − n copies of C∗ act by the equivalence relations given above and the finite abelian group G is the quotient of the N lattice by the lattice generated by the vk . We will usually consider the case where G is trivial. In this approach the toric divisors Dk are determined by the equations zk = 0. The construction of a Calabi–Yau hypersurface from a reflexive polyhedron proceeds in the following way: We take ∆ to be a reflexive polyhedron in MR , ∆∗ ⊂ NR its dual, and Σ a fan defined by a maximal triangulation of ∆∗ . This means that the integer generators v1 , . . . , vK of the one-dimensional cones are just the integer points (except the origin) of ∆∗ . The polynomial whose vanishing determines the Calabi–Yau hypersurface takes the form X x∈∆∩M
ax
K Y
hvk ,xi+1
zk
.
(8)
k=1
It is easily checked that it is quasihomogeneous with respect to all K − n relations PK of (7) with degrees dj = k=1 wjk , j = 1, . . . , K − n. Note how the reflexivity of the polyhedron ensures that the exponents are nonnegative.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
360
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
By [15], the Hodge numbers h11 and h1,n−2 are known, and in [36] the remaining Hodge numbers of the type h1i were calculated. For a hypersurface of dimension n − 1 ≥ 2 these formulas can be summarised as ! X l∗ (θ∗ ) h1i = δ1i l(∆∗ ) − n − 1 − codimθ ∗ =1
+ δn−2,i l(∆) − n − 1 −
X codimθ=1
! ∗
l (θ)
+
X
l∗ (θ∗ )l∗ (θ)
(9)
codimθ ∗ =i+1
for 1 ≤ i ≤ n − 2, where l denotes the number of integer points of a polyhedron and l∗ denotes the number of interior integer points of a face. These formulas are invariant under the simultaneous exchange of ∆ with ∆∗ and h1i with h1,n−i so that Batyrev’s construction is manifestly mirror symmetric (at least at the level of Hodge numbers). For n ≤ 4, the generic (n − 1)-dimensional Calabi–Yau hypersurface in the family defined by ∆ will be smooth [15] and the meaning of these numbers is unambiguous. For n ≥ 5, the Calabi–Yau variety may have singularities that do not allow a crepant blow-up. In this case we refer the reader to [36] for a discussion of the precise meaning of the Hodge numbers resulting from Eq. (9). In the case of a K3 surface there is only one such number, namely h11 , which is well known always to be equal to 20. Contrary to the case of higher dimensional Calabi–Yau manifolds, this number is not the same as the Picard number, which is given by [15] X X l∗ (θ∗ ) + l∗ (θ∗ )l∗ (θ) . (10) Pic = l(∆∗ ) − 4 − facetsθ ∗ of ∆∗ edgesθ ∗ of ∆∗ Mirror symmetry for K3 surfaces is usually interpreted in terms of families of lattice polarised K3 surfaces (see, e.g., [55] or [56]). In this context the Picard number of a generic element of a family and the Picard number of a generic element of the mirror family add up to 20. The fact that the Picard numbers for toric mirror P families add up to 20 + l∗ (θ∗ )l∗ (θ) indicates that our toric models occupy rather special loci in the total moduli spaces. If a polyhedron ∆1 contains a polyhedron ∆2 , then the definition of duality implies ∆∗1 ⊂ ∆∗2 . Therefore the variety determined by the fan over ∆∗1 may be obtained from the variety determined by the fan over ∆∗2 by blowing down one or several divisors. If we perform this blow-down while keeping the same monomials (those determined by ∆2 ), we obtain a generically singular hypersurface. This hypersurface can be desingularised by varying the complex structure in such a way that we now allow monomials determined by ∆1 . Thus the classes of Calabi–Yau hypersurfaces determined by polyhedra ∆1 and ∆2 , respectively, can be said to be connected whenever ∆1 contains ∆2 or vice versa. More generally, if there is a chain of polyhedra ∆i such that ∆i and ∆i+1 are connected in the sense defined above, we call the hypersurfaces corresponding to any two elements of the chain connected.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
361
We can easily check for connectedness as a by-product of our classification scheme: For each new CWS q we check explicitly that at least one of the subpolyhedra of ∆(q) has been found before. Connectedness of the corresponding list of 4318 polytopes in three dimensions follows from the fact that this is always the case. Connectedness of all 3-d reflexive polyhedra follows from the fact that the last polytope that we only found on a sublattice contains 679 reflexive proper subpolytopes that were found before. In the same way all of the four-dimensional polyhedra that we have found so far form a connected web. As we saw in the previous section, every three-dimensional reflexive polytope ∆∗ ⊂ NR contains one of 16 r-minimal polyhedra as a subpolytope on the same lattice. Therefore, the fan of any toric ambient variety determined by a maximal triangulation of a reflexive polyhedron is a refinement of one of the corresponding 16 fans. In other words, any such toric ambient variety is given by the blow-up of one of the following 16 spaces (cf. Tables 2 and 3 and Proposition 2.2): – – – – – – –
P3 , P3 /Z2 , 8 different weighted projective spaces P2(q1 ,q2 ,q3 ) , P2 × P1 , P2(1,1,2) × P1 , 3 further double weighted spaces, and P1 × P1 × P1 .
Each of the three spaces with ‘overlapping weights’ allows two distinct bundle structures: The first one can be interpreted as a P2 bundle in two distinct ways, the second one as a P2 bundle or a P2(1,1,2) bundle, and the third one can be interpreted as a P2(1,1,2) bundle in two distinct ways. In each case the base space is P1 . Let us end this section with briefly discussing a few of the most interesting objects in our lists. There are precisely two mirror pairs with Picard numbers 1 and 19, respectively. One of them is the quartic hypersurface in P3 with Picard number 1, together with its mirror of Picard number 19, which is also the model whose Newton polytope is the only reflexive polytope with only 5 lattice points. This model corresponds to a blow-up of a Z4 × Z4 orbifold of P3 . The blow-up of six fixed lines zi = zj by three divisors each yields 18 exceptional divisors leading to the total Picard number of 19. The other mirror pair with Picard numbers 1 and 19 consists of the hypersurface in P3(1,1,1,3) of degree 6 and an orbifold of the same model, with Newton polyhedra with 39 and 6 points, respectively. This polyhedron is also one of the two ‘largest’ polyhedra in the sense that there is no reflexive polytope in three dimensions with more than 39 lattice points. The other polyhedron with the maximal number of 39 points is the Newton polytope of the hypersurface of degree 12 in P3(1,1,4,6) . This model leads to the description of elliptically fibered K3 surfaces that is commonly used in F -theory applications [22, 29, 30], with the elliptic fiber embedded in a P2(1,2,3) by a Weierstrass equation. The mirror family of this class of
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
362
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
models can be obtained by forcing two E8 singularities into the Weierstrass model and blowing them up. The resulting hypersurface allows also a different fibration structure which can develop an SO(32) singularity; thereby this model is able to describe the F -theory duals of both the E8 × E8 and the SO(32) heterotic strings with unbroken gauge groups in 8 dimensions [57]. In four dimensions there is a unique ‘largest’ object, determined by the weight system (1, 1, 12, 28, 42)/84. It has the maximum number, namely 680, of lattice points and the corresponding Calabi–Yau threefold has the Hodge numbers h11 = 11 and h12 = 491. The latter is the largest single Hodge number in our list, and the value of |χ| = |2(h11 − h12 )| = 960 is also maximal, the only other object with the same values being the mirror. F -theory compactifications of the latter lead to the theories with the largest known gauge groups in six dimensions [57]. Another interesting object that we encountered is the 24-cell, a self dual polytope with 24 vertices, which leads to a self mirror Calabi–Yau manifold with Hodge numbers (20, 20). It has the maximal symmetry order 1152 = 24 ∗ 48 among all 4 dimensional reflexive polytopes and arises as a subpolytope of the hypercube. It is a Platonic solid that contains the Archimedian cuboctahedron (with symmetry order 48) as a reflexive section through the origin parallel to one of its 24 bounding octahedra. Note that in our context symmetries are realised as lattice isomorphisms, i.e. as subgroups of GL(n, Z), and not as rotations. The polytope with the largest order, namely 128, of Mfinest /Mcoarsest is determined by the weight system (1, 1, 1, 1, 4)/8. For the Newton polytope of the quintic hypersurface in P4 , this order is 125. There is a well known Z5 orbifold of the quintic with Hodge numbers (1, 21) which is quite peculiar from the lattice point of view: Although the N lattice is not the lattice Nfinest generated by the vertices of ∆∗ , the only lattice points of ∆∗ are its vertices and the IP. Thus it provides an example where the N lattice is not even generated by the lattice points of ∆∗ . This can only happen in more than 3 dimensions: As a lattice triangle with 3 lattice points is always regular (i.e. it has the minimal volume 1 in lattice units) and there are no lattice hyperplanes between a facet and the IP because of reflexivity, the vertices of any triangle of a maximal triangulation of a 2-dimensional facet of a 3-dimensional polytope provide a lattice basis.
4. Fibrations In this section we want to discuss fibrations of hypersurfaces of holonomy SU (n−1) in n-dimensional toric varieties where the generic fiber is an (nf − 1)-dimensional variety of holonomy SU (nf − 1). In other words, it will apply to elliptic fibrations of K3 surfaces, CY threefolds, CY fourfolds, etc., to K3 fibrations of CY k-folds with k ≥ 3, to threefold fibrations of fourfolds, and so on. The main message is that the structures occurring in the fibration are reflected in structures in the N lattice: The fiber, being an algebraic subvariety of the whole space, is encoded by a polyhedron ∆∗f which is a subpolyhedron of ∆∗ , whereas the base, which is a
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
363
projection of the fibration along the fiber, can be seen by projecting the N lattice along the linear space spanned by ∆∗f . We will first give a general discussion and then explain how descriptions in terms of CWS may be useful for identifying and/or encoding fibration structures. 4.1. Fibrations and reflexive polyhedra Assume that ∆∗ contains a lower-dimensional reflexive subpolyhedron ∆∗f = (Nf )R ∩ ∆∗ with the same interior point. This allows us to define a dual pair of exact sequences 0 → Nf → N → Nb → 0
(11)
0 → Mb → M → Mf → 0 ,
(12)
and
and corresponding sequences for the underlying real vector spaces. We can convince ourselves that the image of ∆ under MR → (Mf )R is dual to ∆∗f in the following way: We choose a basis ej , j = 1, . . . , n of N such that Nf is generated by the ej with 1 ≤ j ≤ nf and define ei to be the dual basis. Then ∆f = {(x1 , . . . , xnf ) : ∃xnf +1 , . . . , xn with (x1 , . . . , xn ) ∈ ∆)} , (∆∗ )f = {(y1 , . . . , ynf ) : (y1 , . . . , ynf , 0) ∈ ∆∗ } ,
(13) (14)
and the duality of these two polytopes is easily checked. Let us also assume that the image Σb of Σ under π : N → Nb defines a fan in Nb . This is certainly not true for arbitrary triangulations of ∆∗ . Constructing fibrations, one should rather build a fan Σb from the images of the one-dimensional cones in Σ and try to construct a triangulation of Σ and thereby of ∆∗ that is compatible with the projection. It would be interesting to know whether this is always possible whenever the intersection of a reflexive polyhedron with a linear subspace of NR is again reflexive. The set of one-dimensional cones in Σb is the set of images of one-dimensional cones in Σ that do not lie in Nf . The image of a primitive generator vi of a cone in Σ is the origin or a positive integer multiple of a primitive generator v˜j of a onedimensional cone in Σb . Thus we can define a matrix rji , most of whose elements are 0, through πvi = rij v˜j with rij ∈ N if πvi lies in the one-dimensional cone defined by v˜j and rij = 0 otherwise. Our base space is the multiply weighted space determined by 1
˜ K
˜ −n j = 1, . . . , K ˜, (15) P i ˜ji are any integers such that i w ˜j v˜i = 0. The projection where n ˜ = n−nf and the w map from VΣ (and, as we will see, from the Calabi–Yau hypersurface) to the base (˜ z1 , . . . , z˜K˜ ) ∼ (λw˜j z˜1 , . . . , λw˜j z˜K˜ ) ,
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
364
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
is given by z˜i =
Y
ri
zj j .
(16)
j j
j
i
This is well defined: zj → λwk zj leads to z˜i → λwk rj z˜i which is among the good P j i P j wk rj v˜i = 0. equivalence relations because applying π to wk vj = 0 gives A generic point in the base space will have z˜i 6= 0 for all i, implying zi 6= 0 for all vi 6∈ ∆∗f . The choice of a specific point in VΣb and the use of all equivalence relations except for those involving only vi ∈ ∆∗f allows to fix all zi except for those corresponding to vi ∈ ∆∗f . Thus the preimage of a generic point in VΣb is indeed a variety in the moduli space determined by ∆∗f . What we have seen so far is just that VΣ is a fibration over VΣb with generic fiber VΣf (this is actually the statement of an exercise in [52, p. 41] and how this fibration structure manifests itself in terms of homogeneous coordinates. Now we also want to see how this can be extended to hypersurfaces. To this end note that if vk ∈ ∆∗f then hvk , xi only depends on the equivalence class [x] ∈ Mf of x under x∼y
if
Thus we may rewrite Eq. (8) as Y hv ,[x]i+1 X a0[x] zk k p= [x]∈∆f ∩Mf
x − y ∈ Mb .
with
vk ∈∆∗ f
a0[x] =
(17) X x∈[x]
ax
Y
hvk ,xi+1
zk
.
(18)
vk 6∈∆∗ f
In each coordinate patch for VΣb this is just an equation for the fiber with coefficients that are polynomial functions of coordinates of the base space. Whenever a one-dimensional cone (with primitive generator v˜i ) in Σb is the image of more than one one-dimensional cone in Σ, the fiber becomes reducible over the divisor z˜i = 0 determined by vi . Different components of the fiber correspond to different equations zj = 0 with πvj = rji v˜i . The intersection patterns of the different components of the reducible fibers are crucial for understanding enhanced gauge symmetries in type IIA string theory [58, 56] and F -theory [22, 29, 30]. Blowing down the corresponding subvarieties (and hence making the Calabi–Yau space itself singular) leads to the appearance of non-perturbative enhanced gauge groups whose Lie algebras are determined by the intersection patterns of the components of the fibers. In terms of the N lattice, the occurrence of enhanced gauge groups can be easily inferred by studying the preimage of a one-dimensional cone in Σb . In particular, as noted by Candelas and Font [59], under favourable circumstances the Dynkin diagram of the corresponding Lie algebra can be seen directly in the toric diagram in the N lattice. 4.2. Fibrations and weight systems As for polyhedra, weight systems provide a very useful and economic tool for constructing and describing fibrations. We only consider toric CY fibrations which
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
365
require a reflexive section through the origin of ∆∗ ⊂ NR whose dimension is equal to nf for (nf − 1)-dimensional CY-fibers. In the M lattice this corresponds to a projection onto the dual reflexive polyhedron along an (n − nf )-dimensional subspace. Hence, on either side, we need to specify a linear subspace (Nf )R ⊂ NR or (Mb )R ⊂ MR . This can be done, for example, by singling out vectors that span the subspace or by representing the subspace as an intersection of hyperplanes. If the polyhedron is given in terms of some CWS it is natural to try to specify this linear subspace by using some part of the weight information. Note that a (j) lower index i in a CWS ni corresponds to a vertex of the minimal polytope ∇, or, by duality, to a bounding hyperplane in the M lattice (which, if ∆ is embedded into Rk , is the intersection of the coordinate hyperplane ai = 0, or xi = −1, with the affine or linear subspace that supports ∆). An upper index j corresponds to a simplex in the CWS and, hence, to the linear subspace spanned by that simplex. Actually this can be regarded as a special case of the former correspondence, since the subspace that is spanned by a simplex S j is generated by those vectors of ∇ (j) for which ni 6= 0. The simplest case is therefore the situation where a subset of the IP simplex structure of the minimal polytope ∇ provides a weight system for ∆f . In turn, we can engineer fibrations where the fiber corresponds to a certain weight system if we start by generating combined weight systems q with a given subsystem qf . As usual, one has to check that ∆(q) is reflexive, which in up to 4 dimensions is equivalent to the IP property (in the case of Calabi–Yau 4-fold CWS with ∆(q) IP but not reflexive we can proceed with reflexive subpolytopes ∆0 ⊂ ∆(q)). Because of the additional equations that come from the extended CWS q, the set of solutions to Eq. (1) is smaller than those for qf when we disregard the additional coordinates. Hence the intersection of ∆∗ with the subspace spanned by the vertices of ∇f contains ∆(qf )∗ , but may be larger. We therefore obtain a fibration if the resulting nf -dimensional polytope is reflexive.b In the case of elliptic fibrations this is always true: We want to show that ∗ ∆f = ∆∗ ∩ (Nf )R is reflexive. As we saw in Sec. 4.1, ∆f can be identified with the image of ∆ under MR → (Mf )R . As the image of 0M under M → Mf is an IP of ∆f , ∆f has at least one IP. Because of the well known fact that a two-dimensional lattice polytope is reflexive if it has precisely one IP, all that is left to show is that ∆f cannot have more than one IP. As ∆∗f ⊇ ∇f implies ∆f ⊆ ∇∗f and ∇f as a lattice polytope with a single IP is reflexive, ∇∗f and hence ∆f has precisely one IP, i.e. ∆f is indeed reflexive. To obtain elliptic fibrations in Weierstrass form, as they are mostly used in F -theory compactifications [22, 29, 30], we thus only need to take the weight system qf = (1, 2, 3)/6 as the fiber part of a combined weight system and check for reflexivity of ∆(q). b If
this is not the case we could proceed by dropping vertices of ∆ and trying to find a larger reflexive section, but this soon becomes ugly and in view of the abundance of weight systems it is hardly worth the effort.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
366
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
It is no surprise that the situation we described does not cover the general case: Given an IP simplex structure of a minimal polytope ∇f ⊆ ∆∗f it is not always possible to extend it to a simplex structure for a minimal polytope ∇ ⊆ ∆∗ . As a simple example in 4 dimensions we consider the points V1 , . . . , V6 ∈ N with coordinates given by the columns of the matrix
−1
0 (V1 , . . . , V6 ) = 0 0
1
1
−1
−1
1
−1
0
0
0
0
1
−1
0
0
0
1
−1
0 . −1 −1
(19)
The first three points provide a weight system (2, 1, 1) for an elliptic fiber such that ∆∗f is supported by the 1–2 plane. V1 is contained in the convex hull of V2 , . . . , V6 , which is a minimal polytope ∇ as defined in Sec. 2.1. The weight system for ∇ is q = (2, 2, 2, 1, 1)/8 and we cannot use (2, 1, 1)/4 as part of a CWS corresponding to a minimal polyhedron ∇ with an IP simplex structure in the sense of Sec. 2. In this situation it makes sense to use generalised IP simplex structures where the vertices of the IP simplices are lattice points (but not necessarily vertices) of ∆∗ and we do not insist on the non-redundancy implied by our original definition of an IP simplex structure. Having made this point we may use the linear relations among the vertices of the simplices (V1 , V2 , V3 ) and (V2 , V3 , V4 , V5 , V6 ) to arrive at the CWS q(1) = (2, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0)/4 and q(2) = (0, 2, 2, 2, 1, 1)/8. A CWS of this type was not considered in our classification scheme because V1 = (V2 + V3 )/2 is redundant when combined with the vertices that correspond to q(2) . It does, however, lead to a perfectly sensible system of equations (1), the convex hull of whose solutions is ∇∗ (in our example all polytopes are simplices). Actually, for q = (2, 2, 2, 1, 1)/8 we find that (∆(q))∗ has the seven lattice points V2 , . . . , V6 , 0 and (−1, 0, −1, 0)T , but no reflexive subpolytope. The CWS {q(1) , q(2) }, on the other hand, leads to a polytope (∆(q1 , q2 ))∗ with nine lattice points and the reflexive subpolytope that we started with: The addition of V1 refines the lattice generated by the vertices of ∇ in such a way that the convex hull of V2 , . . . , V6 on the finer N lattice now contains the additional lattice points V1 and −V1 . As an aside we thus observe that a CWS corresponding to a generalised IP simplex structure may also be used to encode certain sublattices of Mfinest . Probably most polytopes can be directly specified by using a generalised IP simplex structure and the corresponding CWS. A counterexample is given by the Z5 quotient of the quintic at the end of Sec. 3, where the N lattice is not generated by ∆∗ ∩ N . But in practice such a representation is only useful if the number of equations is small. In any case combined weight systems provide a simple construction for toric fibrations and can always be used to specify reflexive sections.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
367
4.3. Toric fibrations and weighted projective spaces There is a more subtle way in which a fibration structure can be encoded in a weight system. It only works for codimension 1 fibers, but it is quite interesting for historical and practical reasons. When string dualities led to interest in K3 fibrations, the first examples were constructed in the context of weighted projective spaces [60, 61]. It turned out that these examples are indeed special cases of toric fibrations in the sense that they correspond to reflexive projections of Newton polyhedra of transversal hypersurfaces in weighted P3 or P4 . Actually, reflexive objects of codimension 1 were first observed on these Newton polyhedra, either as reflexive facets or as reflexive sections through the IP in the M lattice [59]. Since what we really need for a toric fibration is a reflexive section in NR , the question arises whether there is a reflexive projection of ∆ onto one of its facets. A simple necessary condition for this is provided by the following observations. We work with the embedding space of Lemma 2.4 and do not distinguish between objects in MR and their images under the embedding map. Lemma 4.1. (a) For a polytope ∆ defined by a weight system ni only facets that are supported by a lattice hyperplane xl = −1 can have interior points. (b) If y = (y1 , . . . , yk ) ∈ M has yl = −1, yi ≥ 0 for i 6= l, the map πy : MR → MR , πy x = x + (xl + 1)y has the following properties: It is a projection to the affine subspace xl = −1, i.e. πy2 = πy and πy MR = MR ∩ {xl = −1}. It respects the lattice structure, i.e. if x ∈ M then πy x ∈ M ∩ {xl = −1}, The image of ∆ is the corresponding facet of ∆, i.e. πy ∆ = ∆ ∩ {xl = −1}. (c) There is a one-to-one correspondence between maps π with the same properties as in (b) such that 0 gets mapped to an IP of the facet with xl = −1 and P partitions of the weight nl by the remaining weights, i.e. nl = i6=l yi ni where the yi are nonnegative integers. Proof. (a) If an interior point of a facet is not on some hyperplane xl = −1 all xi must be nonnegative, but this is only possible for the interior point of ∆. (b) The first two statements follow directly from the definition of πy . πy ∆ ⊇ ∆ ∩ {xl = −1} follows from the fact that πy is a projection. For πy ∆ ⊆ ∆ ∩ {xl = −1} we note that ∆ ∩ {xl = −1} is the convex hull of the lattice points in {xl = −1} with xi ≥ −1 and that every vertex of ∆ gets mapped to such a lattice point. (c) If π is such a map, then we choose y to be the IP of the facet to which 0 is mapped (this implies yi ≥ 0 for i 6= l), and the partition of nl follows from the P fact that yi ni = 0. Conversely, if y is defined by such a partition we have to
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
368
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
show that it is interior to the facet. This follows from the facts that 0 is interior to ∆ and y = πy 0. A necessary condition for the existence of a reflexive projection of ∆ onto one of its facets is therefore that one of the weights ni has a unique partition in terms of the other weights. Using this criterion we found all such projections for single weight systems with k ≤ 5 by first searching for weights with unique partitions and then checking reflexivity of the corresponding facets. The results are given in Table 3 for the case of elliptic K3 surfaces and they are available on our web page [34] for K3-fibered Calabi–Yau manifolds (cf. Table 4). We can find a set of generators for (Nf )R by solving the equation hV, yi = 0 for P a general linear combination V = cj Vj of the vertices Vj of ∇. Since hVi , yi = yi we obtain the solutions Vi0 = Vi + yi Vl for i 6= l. The linear relations among the Vi0 are given by the corresponding subset of the original weights. In general they do not provide a weight system for the fiber because the points Vi0 need not belong to ∆∗ . This is easy to see for the class of weights (1, 1, 2n3 , 2n4 , 2n5 ) that was considered by Klemm, Lerche and Mayr [60]. Here V20 = V1 + V2 and hV20 , xi = x1 + x2 for P xi ni = 0 implies that x1 + x2 is even, so x ∈ M with coordinates xi . But V20 is not a primitive lattice vector in N and can be divided by 2, which leads to the weight system (1, n3 , n4 , n5 ) for the K3 fiber. The slightly more complicated example (8, 4, 3, 27, 42)/84 was given by Hosono, Lian and Yau [61]. The first weight has a unique partition with y2 = 2 and y3 = y4 = y5 = 0, so that (Nf )R is spanned by V20 = V2 + 2V1 and Vi with i > 2. This time 8x1 + 4x2 + 3x3 + 27x4 + 42x5 = 0 implies that x2 + 2x1 is a multiple of 3 and the primitive lattice vector V20 /3 ∈ ∆∗ leads to the weight system (4, 1, 9, 14) for the fiber, which agrees with the normalised weights for the fiber given in [61]. If more of the coefficients yi are nonvanishing, it is, of course, still possible to compute a weight system for the fiber, but this gets more tedious and we would also lose the direct connection with the original weights or we would have to introduce many redundant coordinates in a CWS. Another strategy for identifying reflexive projections of ∆(q) that can be used in the codimension 1 case follows from the fact that such a projection either must be along a line parallel to a facet or onto that facet whenever a facet has an interior point. If the number of facets with interior points is large enough this allows us to find all reflexive projections. The result of this analysis is indicated in the next-tolast column of Tables 3 and 4. The K3 surfaces in Table 2 are all elliptic, since their combinded weight systems contain 2 dimensional subsystems. With our strategies to identify reflexive projections (onto facets) we generalised the results of [60, 61] and extended the scope from the transversal case to the complete list of 184026 IP weight systems, where we could identify 124701 fibrations. The efficiency of our approach can be inferred from the fact that we found 5370 fibrations for the 7555 transversal cases, wheras only 628 fibrations yielded to the methods of [61].
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
369
Acknowledgements M.K. is partly supported by the Austrian Research Funds FWF grant Nr. P11582PHY. The research of H.S. is supported by the European Union TMR project ERBFMRX-CT-96-0045. Appendix: Various Tables Table 1. IP simplex structures and numbers of corresponding IP CWS for n = 4 (for n = 3, see Lemma 2.3). IP simplex structure S1 = V1 V2 V3 V4 V5
Total
Span
lp-min.
r-min.
184026
38730
16437
206
16040
6365
143
51
1122
727
40
29
6
6
3
3
36
36
4
4
116
79
19
15
201346
45943
16646
308
S1 = V1 V2 V3 V4 , S2 = V1 V2 V30 V40 S1 = S1 = S1 =
V1 V2 V3 V4 , S2 = V1 V20 V30 V1 V2 V3 , S2 = V10 V20 V30 V1 V2 V3 , S2 = V1 V20 V30 , S3
=
S1 , . . . , Sm−1 as for n = 3, Sm =
V1 V200 V300 (m) (m) V1 V2
Total
Table 2. IP CWS for n = 3. The columns indicate the minimality type (‘s’ for span, ‘l’ for lp-minimality and ‘r’ for r-minimality) and point and vertex numbers for ∆ and ∆∗ . As r-minimality implies lp-minimality and the latter implies the span property for n = 3, we have given only the strongest statement in each case. d n1 n2 n3 n4 n5 3 3
1 1
1 0
1 0
0 1
0 1
3 4 3 4
1 2 1 1
1 0 1 0
1 0 1 0
0 1 0 2
0 1 0 1
3 6
1 3
1 0
1 0
0 2
0 1
3 6 3 6
1 2 1 1
1 0 1 0
1 0 1 0
0 3 0 3
0 1 0 2
4 4 4 4
2 2 2 1
1 0 1 0
1 0 1 0
0 1 0 2
0 1 0 1
P
V
P¯ V¯
d n1 n2 n3 n4 n5 n6
r 30
5
6
4 6
1 2
2 0
1 0
0 3
0 1
1 1 3 3
2 0 2 0
1 0 1 0
0 3 0 2
0 2 0 1
5
r 31
6
7
5
s 23
7
8
6
4 6 6 6
5
6 6
2 2
3 0
1 0
0 3
0 1
6 6 6 6
2 1 1 1
3 0 3 0
1 0 2 0
0 3 0 3
0 2 0 2
3 2 4 2
1 0 2 0
1 0 1 0
1 0 1 0
0 1 0 1
0 1 0 1
s 24
6
9
s 21
5
9
5
s 14
7
11
6
r 35
5
7
5
s 23
6
9
5
P
V
P¯ V¯
s 16
6
14
6
s 12
6
14
6
s 21
5
12
5
s 15
5
15
5
s 10
6
20
6
s
9
5
18
5
r 30
6
6
5
r 27
6
7
5
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
370
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke Table 2.
d n1
(Continued)
n2
n3
n4
n5
P
V
P¯
V¯
d n1
s 27
5
9
5
6 2
s 19
5
9
5
s 18
6
12
5
2 2 2
4 6
2 3
1 0
1 0
0 2
0 1
4 4 4 6
1 1 1 3
2 0 2 0
1 0 1 0
0 2 0 2
0 1 0 1
n2
n3
n4
n5
3 0
2 0
1 0
0 1
0 1
1 0 0
1 0 0
0 1 0
0 1 0
0 0 1
P
V
P¯
V¯
s 21
6
9
5
r 27
8
7
6
n6
0 0 1
Table 3. The 95 K3 weight systems: r, l, s denote the minimality type as in Table 2, Π is the number of reflexive projections (if known) and F denotes the number of reflexive projections onto facets. The corresponding weights with unique partitions are indicated with bold face. d
n1 n2 n3 n4
4 5 6 6 7 8 8 9 9 10 10 10 11 12 12 12 12 12 12 13 14 14 14 15 15 15 15 15 16 16 16
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 2 3 1 1 1
1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 2 3 3 1 2 3 2 3 2 2 3 3 3 3 2 3 4
1 1 1 2 2 2 2 3 3 2 3 3 3 3 4 4 3 4 3 4 4 4 3 5 4 5 5 4 5 4 5
1 2 3 2 3 3 4 3 4 5 4 5 5 6 5 4 4 6 5 5 7 5 7 7 7 6 5 5 8 8 6
r r r r r s r s r s s r l s s s s r s l s s s s s s s s s s s
P
V
P¯ V¯ Π F
d
35 34 39 30 31 24 35 23 33 28 23 36 24 27 24 21 15 39 17 20 27 13 19 26 22 21 14 12 28 24 19
4 6 4 4 7 6 4 6 5 4 7 5 8 4 5 4 4 4 5 7 5 7 5 6 6 5 6 5 5 5 6
5 6 6 6 8 8 7 8 9 8 11 9 13 9 12 9 9 9 11 15 12 16 11 17 17 15 11 12 14 12 17
21 22 22 22 24 24 24 24 24 24 24 24 25 26 26 26 27 27 28 28 28 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 32 32 33
4 5 4 4 6 5 4 5 5 4 6 5 7 4 5 4 4 4 5 7 5 7 5 6 6 5 5 5 5 5 6
0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1
n1 n2 n3 n4 3 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 3 3 3 4 4 1 2 2 2 5 1 3 4 1 1 2 2 3 4 5 2 4 3
5 3 4 4 3 6 3 3 4 4 6 5 5 5 3 5 5 6 4 4 6 4 6 3 6 4 5 6 5 5 5
6 7 6 5 8 8 8 7 5 7 7 6 7 7 8 6 9 7 9 7 7 10 8 10 7 10 6 8 9 7 11
7 11 11 11 12 9 11 12 12 10 8 9 9 13 13 13 11 9 14 14 11 15 15 15 15 13 15 11 16 16 14
– – s – s s – s s s – s – – – – – – – s – s s s – – s – – – –
P V
P¯ V¯ Π F
9 25 22 14 27 18 15 16 12 10 9 8 7 21 16 13 11 6 24 12 7 25 21 18 13 10 10 6 13 9 9
21 20 20 19 15 24 27 20 18 26 21 26 32 24 23 23 32 30 24 18 35 20 24 18 23 35 20 39 29 27 39
5 5 6 5 4 5 4 5 5 5 4 5 5 5 5 5 6 5 4 5 4 5 5 4 4 5 5 4 5 5 4
5 5 6 5 4 5 4 5 5 6 4 6 6 5 5 5 6 6 4 5 4 5 5 4 4 5 5 4 5 5 4
? 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 ? 2 ? ? ? 1 1 2 2 ? 1 2 ? 1 1 1 1 2 ? ? 2 ? 2
1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations Table 3. d
n1 n2 n3 n4
16 17 18 18 18 18 18 18 19 20 20 20 20 20 21 21 21
2 2 1 1 1 2 2 3 3 1 2 2 2 3 1 1 2
3 3 2 3 4 3 3 4 4 4 3 5 4 4 3 5 3
4 5 6 5 6 4 5 5 5 5 5 6 5 5 7 7 7
7 7 9 9 7 9 8 6 7 10 10 7 9 8 10 8 9
s l s s s s s s l s s – – s – – s
(Continued)
P V
P¯ V¯ Π F
d
14 13 30 24 19 16 14 10 9 23 16 11 13 10 24 18 14
18 20 12 15 20 14 20 17 24 13 14 23 23 22 24 24 23
34 34 36 36 36 38 38 40 42 42 42 44 48 50 54 66
6 8 4 5 6 5 6 6 7 4 5 5 4 6 4 5 6
6 8 4 5 6 5 6 6 8 4 5 5 4 6 4 5 6
2 2 1 1 1 2 2 ? ? 1 2 3 1 ? 1 1 2
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 0 1 1 1
371
n1 n2 n3 n4 3 4 1 3 7 3 5 5 1 2 3 4 3 7 4 5
4 6 5 4 8 5 6 7 6 5 4 5 5 8 5 6
10 7 12 11 9 11 8 8 14 14 14 13 16 10 18 22
17 17 18 18 12 19 19 20 21 21 21 22 24 25 27 33
– – – – – – – – s – s – – – – –
P V
P¯ V¯ Π F
11 8 24 12 5 10 7 8 24 15 13 9 12 6 10 9
31 31 24 30 35 35 35 28 24 27 26 39 30 39 35 39
6 5 4 4 4 5 5 4 4 4 5 4 4 4 5 4
6 5 4 4 4 5 5 4 4 4 5 4 4 4 5 4
2 ? 1 2 ? 2 ? ? 1 1 2 2 2 ? 2 2
1 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1
Table 4. Examples from our list of 184026 IP weights [34] with various data including Hodge numbers, point and vertex numbers, and numbers of reflexive projections (onto facets). T indicates transversality and M denotes the minimality type. n3
n4
n5
TM
h11
h12
P
V
P¯
V¯
Π
F
4
5
14
21
−ls
26
39
54
18
35
15
?
0
8 8
10 11
19 26
25 45
−ls −ls
59 63
10 15
16 24
13 15
75 71
21 21
? ?
0 1
d
n1
n2
47
3
69 97
7 7
84
1
1
12
28
42
Tr
11
491
680
5
26
5
1
1
280
7
19
40
87
127
−−
491
11
26
5
680
5
2
1
24 26 33 36
3 3 3 3
4 4 6 6
5 5 6 6
6 7 7 10
6 7 11 11
Ts −ls −− T−
10 22 19 19
34 22 37 49
36 31 34 38
8 13 7 7
12 21 22 22
7 10 6 6
? ? ? ?
0 0 0 0
26 36 39 52
3 5 3 4
4 7 6 6
5 7 9 8
6 8 10 11
8 9 11 23
−s −− Ts T−
14 30 17 29
24 12 41 33
32 19 33 34
14 10 12 9
19 28 22 36
10 9 13 8
? ? ? ?
1 1 1 1
34 44 55 63
3 4 3 7
6 8 10 9
7 9 13 14
8 10 14 15
10 13 15 18
−s −− Ts T−
18 29 28 44
20 17 16 8
27 22 23 15
13 9 12 6
23 31 35 37
12 9 14 6
? ? ? ?
2 2 2 2
5 10
1 1
1 1
1 1
1 3
1 4
Tr −r
1 4
101 126
126 165
5 10
6 9
5 7
0 0
0 0
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
372
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke Table 4.
(Continued) P¯
V¯
Π
F
7 9
15 19
7 7
0 0
0 0
51 50 45 60
10 8 7 7
14 11 25 25
8 6 6 6
1 1 1 1
0 0 0 0
86 108 23 18
105 141 33 25
5 12 11 7
7 11 30 20
5 8 8 7
1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1
11 14 31 26
33 44 31 38
43 56 33 39
14 9 6 7
14 13 29 29
9 7 6 6
2 2 2 2
1 1 1 1
Tr −ls −− T−
5 11 33 26
51 39 21 28
57 51 33 42
10 14 6 7
10 16 25 25
7 9 6 6
2 2 2 2
2 2 2 2
−s Ts −− T−
18 23 28 35
20 23 16 11
27 26 23 19
10 6 7 6
18 16 25 23
8 6 6 6
3 3 3 3
2 2 2 2
d
n1
n2
n3
n4
n5
TM
h11
h12
P
25 26
1 1
5 5
5 5
6 7
8 8
T− −l
17 19
49 49
65 65
20 20 30 36
2 2 2 2
3 3 5 5
4 5 6 6
4 5 6 6
7 5 11 17
−s Ts −− T−
13 6 27 24
45 48 39 54
8 13 35 40
1 1 2 4
1 1 7 5
2 2 8 9
2 4 9 10
2 5 9 12
Tr −r −− T−
2 6 35 22
19 27 36 40
2 2 4 4
3 3 4 4
4 4 6 6
5 9 9 9
5 9 13 17
−ls Ts −− T−
14 19 30 35
2 2 3 3
2 3 5 5
3 3 5 5
3 4 6 6
4 7 11 16
28 36 40 42
4 4 4 6
5 6 7 7
5 8 7 7
6 9 10 10
8 9 12 12
V
References [1] L. Dixon, in Superstrings, Unified Theories, and Cosmology 1987, eds. G. Furlan et al., World Scientific, 1988, p. 67. [2] W. Lerche, C. Vafa and N. Warner, “Chiral rings in N = 2 superconformal theories”, Nucl. Phys. B324 (1989) 427. [3] P. Candelas, E. Derrick and L. Parkes, “Generalized Calabi–Yau manifolds and the mirror of a rigid manifold”, Nucl. Phys. B407 (1993) 115. [4] P. S. Aspinwall and B. R. Greene, “On the geometric interpretation of N = 2 superconformal theories”, Nucl. Phys. B437 (1995) 205. [5] P. Candelas, X. C. De la Ossa, P. S. Green and L. Parkes, “An exactly soluble superconformal theory from a mirror pair of Calabi–Yau manifolds”, Phys. Lett. B258 (1991) 118. [6] P. Candelas, X. C. De la Ossa, P. S. Green and L. Parkes, “A pair of Calabi–Yau manifolds as an exactly soluble superconformal theory”, Nucl. Phys. B359 (1991) 21. [7] A. Strominger, S.-T. Yau and E. Zaslow, “Mirror symmetry is T duality”, Nucl. Phys. B479 (1996) 243. [8] P. Candelas, A. M. Dale, C. A. Lutken and R. Schimmrigk, “Complete intersection Calabi–Yau manifolds”, Nucl. Phys. B298 (1988) 493. [9] P. Candelas, M. Lynker and R. Schimmrigk, “Calabi–Yau manifolds in weighted P4 ”, Nucl. Phys. B341 (1990) 383.
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
00120
Reflexive Polyhedra, Weights and Toric Calabi–Yau Fibrations
373
[10] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “No mirror symmetry in Landau–Ginzburg spectra!”, Nucl. Phys. B388 (1992) 113. [11] A. Klemm and R. Schimmrigk, “Landau–Ginzburg string vacua”, Nucl. Phys. B411 (1994) 559. [12] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “All abelian symmetries of Landau–Ginzburg potentials”, Nucl. Phys. B405 (1993) 305. [13] P. Berglund and T. H¨ ubsch, “A generalized construction of mirror manifolds”, Nucl. Phys. B393 (1993) 377. [14] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “Orbifolds with discrete torsion and mirror symmetry”, Phys. Lett. B357 (1995) 81. [15] V. V. Batyrev, “Dual polyhedra and mirror symmetry for Calabi–Yau hypersurfaces in toric varieties”, J. Alg. Geom. 3 (1994) 493. [16] P. S. Aspinwall, B. R. Greene and D. R. Morrison, “Space-time topology change and stringy geometry”, J. Math. Phys. 35 (1994) 5321. [17] P. Candelas, P. S. Green and T. H¨ ubsch, “Finite distances between distinct Calabi– Yau vacua: (Other worlds are just around the corner)”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62 (1989) 1956. [18] P. Candelas, P. S. Green and T. H¨ ubsch, “Rolling among Calabi–Yau vacua”, Nucl. Phys. B330 (1990) 49. [19] A. Strominger, “Massless black holes and conifolds in string theory”, Nucl. Phys. B451 (1995) 96. [20] B. R. Greene, D. R. Morrison and A. Strominger, “Black hole condensation and the unification of string vacua”, Nucl. Phys. B451 (1995) 109. [21] S. Kachru and C. Vafa, “Exact results for N = 2 compactifications of heterotic strings”, Nucl. Phys. B450 (1995) 69. [22] C. Vafa, “Evidence for F -theory”, Nucl. Phys. B469 (1996) 403. [23] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “On the classification of reflexive polyhedra”, Commun. Math. Phys. 185 (1997) 495. [24] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “On the classification of quasihomogeneous functions”, Commun. Math. Phys. 150 (1992) 137. [25] P. Candelas, X. C. de la Ossa and S. Katz, “Mirror symmetry for Calabi–Yau hypersurfaces in weighted P4 and extensions of Landau–Ginzburg theory”, Nucl. Phys. B450 (1995) 267. [26] H. Skarke, “Weight Systems for toric Calabi–Yau varieties and reflexivity of Newton polyhedra”, Mod. Phys. Lett. A11 (1996) 1637. [27] A. Klemm, W. Lerche and P. Mayr, “K3-fibrations and heterotic-type II string duality”, Phys. Lett. B357 (1995) 313. [28] P. S. Aspinwall and J. Louis, “On the ubiquity of K3 fibrations in string duality”, Phys. Lett. B369 (1996) 233. [29] D. R. Morrison and C. Vafa, “Compactifications of F -theory on Calabi–Yau threefolds – I”, Nucl. Phys. B473 (1996) 74. [30] D. R. Morrison and C. Vafa, “Compactifications of F -theory on Calabi–Yau threefolds – II”, Nucl. Phys. B476 (1996) 437. [31] A. Avram, M. Kreuzer, M. Mandelberg and H. Skarke, “Searching for K3 fibrations”, Nucl. Phys. B494 (1997) 567. [32] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “Calabi–Yau fourfolds and toric fibrations”, J. Geom. Phys. 466 (1997) 1. [33] Y. Hu, C. H. Liu and S. T. Yau, “Toric morphisms and fibrations of toric Calabi–Yau hypersurfaces”, math.AG/0010082. [34] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, http://hep.itp.tuwien.ac.at/ ∼ kreuzer/CY.html
April 25, 2002 17:1 WSPC/148-RMP
374
00120
M. Kreuzer & H. Skarke
[35] C. Vafa, “String vacua and orbifoldized LG models”, Mod. Phys. Lett. 4A (1989) 1169. [36] V. V. Batyrev and D. I. Dais, “Strong McKay correspondence, string-theoretic Hodge numbers and mirror symmetry”, Topology 35 (1996) 901. [37] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “Landau–Ginzburg orbifolds with discrete torsion”, Mod. Phys. Lett. 10 (1995) 1073. [38] C. Vafa, “Modular invariance and discrete torsion on orbifolds”, Nucl. Phys. B273 (1986) 592. [39] V. V. Batyrev and L. A. Borisov, “On Calabi–Yau complete intersections in toric varieties”, in Proceedings of Trento Conference, 1994. [40] V. V. Batyrev and L. A. Borisov, “Mirror duality and string theoretic Hodge numbers”, Invent. Math. 126 (1996) 183. [41] M. Kreuzer, E. Riegler and D. Sahakyan, “Toric complete intersections and weighted projective space”, math.AG/0103214. [42] M. Kreuzer, “Strings on Calabi–Yau spaces and toric geometry”, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 102 (2001) 87. [43] M. Lynker, R. Schimmrigk and A. Wisskirchen, “Landau–Ginzburg vacua of string, M - and F -theory at c = 12”, Nucl. Phys. B550 (1999) 123. [44] R. Schimmrigk, http://thew02.physik.uni-bonn.de/ ∼ netah/cy.html [45] S. Katz, http://www.math.okstate.edu/ ∼ katz/CY/ [46] M. Reid, “Canonical 3-folds”, Proc. Alg. Geom. Anger 1979, Sijthoff and Nordhoff, p. 273. [47] A. R. Fletcher, “Working with complete intersections”, Bonn preprint MPI/89–35, 1989. [48] V. V. Batyrev, “Higher-dimensional toric varieties with ample anticanonical class”, Moscow State Univ., Thesis, 1985. [49] R. J. Koelman, “The number of moduli of families of curves on toric varieties”, Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, Thesis, 1990. [50] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “Classification of reflexive polyhedra in three dimensions”, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2 (1998) 847–864. [51] M. Kreuzer and H. Skarke, “Complete classification of reflexive polyhedra in four dimensions”, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 4 (2000). [52] W. Fulton, “Introduction to toric varieties”, Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton 1993. [53] T. Oda, Convex Bodies and Algebraic Geometry, Springer, Berlin Heidelberg 1988. [54] D. Cox, “The homogeneous coordinate ring of a toric variety”, J. Alg. Geom. 4 (1995) 17. [55] Igor V. Dolgachev, “Mirror symmetry for lattice polarized K3 surfaces”, J. Math. Sci., New York 81 (1996) 2599. [56] P. S. Aspinwall, “K3 surfaces and string duality”, in Differential Geometry Inspired by String Theory. [57] P. Candelas and H. Skarke, “F -theory, SO(32) and toric geometry”, Phys. Lett. B413 (1997) 63. [58] E. Witten, “String theory dynamics in various dimensions”, Nucl. Phys. B443 (1995) 85. [59] P. Candelas and A. Font, “Duality between the webs of heterotic and type II vacua”, Nucl. Phys. B511 (1998) 295. [60] A. Klemm, W. Lerche and P. Mayr, “K3-Fibrations and heterotic-type II string duality”, Phys. Lett. B357 (1995) 313. [61] S. Hosono, B. H. Lian and S.-T. Yau, “Calabi–Yau varieties and pencils of K3 surfaces”.
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 4 (2002) 375–407 c World Scientific Publishing Company
ABSENCE OF TRANSPORT IN ANDERSON LOCALIZATION
FUMIHIKO NAKANO Mathematical Institute, Tohoku University, Sendai, 980-8578, Japan
[email protected]
Received 11 July 2001 We consider the charge transport in the tight-binding Anderson model. Under a mild condition on the Fermi projection, we show that it is zero almost surely. This result has wider applicability than our previous work [12], while the definition of charge transport is slightly different. It also applies to the computation of non-diagonal component of the conductivity tensor which recovers the famous result of quantization of Hall conductivity in quantum Hall systems.
1. Introduction Since the pioneering work of Anderson [5], where he discussed that a certain disorder may cause materials to have insulating property, there have been much development in the theory of Anderson localization. From mathematical point of view, this phenomenon is represented as the exponential decay of Green’s functions which implies the exponential decay of eigenfunctions, and, together with Kubo formula, vanishing of the electrical conductivity (e.g., [1, 3, 9, 16]). On the other hand, Bellissard et al. [8, 13, 14] developed a theory to compute the electrical conductivity by using C ∗ algebraic approach. They used the random kick-rotor term to introduce dissipation mechanism. In this paper, we study essentially the same quantity, which we call charge transport to compare it with that treated in [12]. We do not use dissipation term, which turns out not to be necessary to consider in the study of Anderson localization, and develop the theory by the use of spectral theory and functional analysis. This approach has the advantage of being mathematically simple, while it would not be straightforward to extend to more general systems, without suitable improvements in the analysis. We will show that, when the Fermi energy lies in the “localized states”, then the charge transport is equal to zero almost surely. This fact has a clear physical interpretation: the current vanishes in the localized regime. However, to prove this fact seems not to be trivial as discussed in [12]. Our model is the standard, tight-binding random Hamiltonian on l2 (Zd ): X ϕ(y) + λVω (x)ϕ(x) , ϕ ∈ l2 (Zd ) . (1.1) (Hω ϕ)(x) := |y−x|=1
375
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
376
00121
F. Nakano
λ > 0 is the coupling constant, and {Vω (x)}x∈Zd are independent, identically distributed random variables on a probability space (Ω, B, P). We assume (1) the probability distribution of Vω (0) has the density r(v)dv. supp r is bounded from below, and r ∈ Lp (R) for some 1 < p ≤ ∞. (2) E|Vω (0)|2 < ∞, where E stands for taking expectations. The assumption that supp r is bounded from below is purely technical to use almost analytic continuation (Sec. 2, Proposition 2.8). However, this assumption is satisfied in most situations, and is natural to study the conducting properties. The condition E|Vω (0)|2 < ∞ is assumed in order that the Liouville operator of HE,ω is densely defined. It is known that, the spectrum of Hω is deterministic almost surely, and σ(Hω ) = [−2d, 2d] + supp r, for a.e. ω [10]. Moreover, there appears some region in the spectrum depending on λ where we have pure point spectrum with exponentially decaying eigenfunctions which, as we already mentioned, is a mathematical presentation of Anderson localization (e.g., [1, 3, 9, 16]). In [12], we considered the charge transport caused by the slowly varying potential. We used adiabatic approximation, and proved that this quantity is equal to zero almost surely when λ is sufficiently large (i.e., at high disorder). In this paper, we consider the charge transport caused by the discrete analogue of the constant electric field E(∈ R) Hω,E := Hω + E · x1 ,
(1.2)
where x1 is the first component of x = (x1 , x2 , . . . , xd ) ∈ Z . We define the charge transport by carrying out the following three operations successively: d
(1) take the thermal average of current operator at zero temperature, (2) divide it by E and let E ↓ 0, (3) take the time average. That is, Z T dt 1 lim T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E PF ) , σ1 (ω, F ) := lim T ↑∞ 0 T E↓0 E where T is the trace per volume for an operator A: 1 trace(χΛL A χΛL ) . T (A) := lim L↑∞ |ΛL |
(1.3)
(1.4)
χC is the characteristic funtion of a set C, and ΛL is a finite box in Zd : ΛL := {x ∈ Zd : |xj | ≤ L, j = 1, . . . , d} . e−itHω,E is the unitary propagator of Hω,E , and PF is the Fermi projection operator: χ(−∞,F ] (Hω ), corresponding to the Fermi energy F ∈ R which we fix arbitrary. In the definition of σ1 (ω, F ), it might be more natural if we took limE↓0 E1 after RT taking the time average limT ↑∞ 0 dt T . However, we can only deal with the Abel limit of that, which can be regarded as a sort of approximation. Z 1 ∞ dt δe−tδ T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E PF ) , (1.5) σ2 (ω, F ) := lim lim δ↓0 E↓0 E 0
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
377
Remark 1.1. (1) σ1 (ω, F ) was originally defined in [8]. Instead of studying σ1 (ω, F ), they computed σ2 (ω, F ) by using the relaxation time approximation. (2) We are not able to discuss the deep question that whether the discrete analogue of the constant electric field E · x1 would be appropriate to compute the electrical conductivity [7, 15]. In fact, the spectrum of Hω,E is known to be purely discrete. However, we believe that taking E ↓ 0 limit limE↓0 E1 is not trivial in any case. (3) In non-zero temperature, PF is replaced by fβ,F (Hω ), where fβ,µ (λ) is the Fermi–Dirac distribution function fβ,µ (λ) := (1 + exp[β(λ − µ)])−1 ,
λ ∈ R,
and β > 0 is the inverse temperature. Throughout this paper, we assume the following decaying property of the matrix element of the Fermi projection. Assumption E
X
|x1 |2 |PF (ω ; x, 0)|2 < ∞ ,
(1.6)
x∈Z
PF (ω ; x, y) := hδx , PF δy il2 (Zd ) , where h· , ·il2 (Zd ) is the inner product on l2 (Zd ), and δx (z) = 1, if z = x, and δx (z) = 0, if z 6= x. It is shown that [2], (1.6) follows from the fractional moment bound of the Green’s function E|GF +i (ω ; x, y)|s ≤ Ce−µ|x−y| ,
x, y ∈ Zd ,
(1.7)
for some constants 0 < s < 1, C > 0, µ > 0, uniformly w.r.t. ∈ R. GE (ω ; x, y) := hδx , (Hω − E)−1 δy il2 (Zd ) is the matrix element of Green’s function. (1.7) is one of the key observation of Anderson localization [1, 3], and known to hold if (1) λ > 0 is sufficiently large (high disorder case), or (2) |F | is sufficiently large (extreme energy case), or (3) F is away from the spectrum of free Laplacian for |λ| small (weak disorder case). Under the above Assumption (1.6), we have following results. Theorem 1.1. σ2 (ω, F ) = 0 ,
a.e. ω.
Theorem 1.2. σ1 (ω, F ) = 0 ,
a.e. ω.
Remark 1.2. (1) We can extend Theorem 1.2 to some long-range hopping Hamiltonians. However, it seems not to be a trivial task to extend the resolvent equation (Proposition 3.1.) to those Hamiltonians, which is important to prove Theorem 1.1. (2) It would require further studies to see under which conditions the various limits involved in the definitions of σ1 (ω, F ), σ2 (ω, F ) may be interchanged. HowR∞ ever, in Theorem 1.1, the exchange of two operations, limE↓0 E1 and 0 dt δe−δt is allowed (Remark 4.1) if, in addition, we assume the following dynamical localization estimate E|e−itHω (ω ; x, y)| ≤ Ce−µ|x−y| ,
x, y ∈ Zd ,
(1.8)
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
378
00121
F. Nakano
for some constants C > 0, µ > 0, independent of t ∈ R. (1.8) is known to be true when λ > 0 is sufficiently large (high disorder case [2, 4]). (3) In [12], essentially the same result is proved under more restricted situations (i.e., bounded random potential, bounded electrical potential, and high disorder). However, there are some differences between the definition of σ1 (ω, F ) and the charge transport defined in [12]. For instance, in the definition of σ1 (ω, F ), we take E ↓ 0 limit first and then take the time average, while, in [12], we take these two operations at the same time in a sense. It would not be easy to take these two limits at the same time in the approach of this paper. (4) In [8], they argue that the conductivity is always zero or infinity without taking dissipation mechanism into account. Moreover, they show that the conductivity is always zero if the Hamiltonian is bounded. Our results imply that this is also true in case Anderson localization happens, even when the Hamiltonian is unbounded. On the other hand, in [2], they discuss the derivation of Kubo formula, and obtained the same quantity as what we will have in the proof of above two theorems. Theorems 1.1 and 1.2 are still true when we impose constant magnetic field to Hω . Moreover, the above results have some implications to the theory of integral Hall effect. Let d = 2, and we consider the following Hamiltonian which has constant magnetic flux −B(∈ R) penetrating each plaquettes on Z2 . X hB (x, y)ϕ(y) + λVω (x)ϕ(x) , ϕ ∈ l2 (Z2 ) , (HωB ϕ)(x) := |y−x|=1
where,
( hB (x, y) :=
e
iB 2 hy, x−yiR2
0,
,
if |x − y| = 1 , otherwise ,
x, y ∈ Z2 .
h·, ·iRd is the inner product on Rd . We define the Hall conductivity σ1H (ω, F ), σ2H (ω, F ), by replacing x1 by x2 in the definition of σ1 (ω, F ), σ2 (ω, F ), respectively. We note that dissipation mechanism is not necessary to consider in the definition of the Hall conductivity. Under Assumption (1.6), we have the following result which can be proved by mimicking the proof of Theorems 1.1 and 1.2. Theorem 1.3. (1) σ1 (ω, F ) = σ2 (ω, F ) = 0 , a.e. ω. (2) σ1H (ω, F ) = σ2H (ω, F ) = iT (PF [∂1 PF , ∂2 PF ]PF ) , ∂j PF := [xj , PF ], j = 1, 2.
a.e. ω, where,
The quantity iT (PF [∂1 PF , ∂2 PF ]PF ) is known to have an interpretation as a “topological invariant” ([6, 8] and references therein). Therefore, Theorem 1.3 implies the vanishment of the direct conductivity and the quantization of the Hall conductivity if the Fermi energy lies in the localized regime, which is well-known in the theory of integral quantum Hall effect. The key ingredient of the proof of Theorems 1.1 and 1.2 is the theory developed in [2, 8], namely to consider the Hilbert space (called L2 ) which consists of matrix
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
379
elements of operators, and consider the Liouville operator of Hω . In Sec. 2, we define L2 , and study some basic properties. We provide proofs even for what is elementary, because it would be better to be careful in the treatment of Liouville operators for unbounded Hamiltonians. In Secs. 3 and 4, we prove Theorems 1.1 and 1.2, respectively. The main part of proofs is to study E ↓ 0 limit: limE↓0 E1 . In order for that, we prove resolvent equation (for Theorem 1.1), and Duhamel formula (for Theorem 1.2), respectively. 2. Preliminaries In this section, we define a Hilbert space L2 , study its basic properties, and consider some operators on it. First of all, we notice that, the operator Hω is covariant w.r.t. the translation in the following sense U (a)Hω U (a)∗ = HT a ω ,
a ∈ Zd , ω ∈ Ω ,
(2.1)
where U (a) is the translation operator on l2 (Zd ): (U (a)ϕ)(x) := ϕ(x − a), U (a)∗ is the adjoint operator of U (a), and T a : Ω → Ω is a measure preserving map defined by ω = {Vω (x)}x∈Zd 7→ T a ω = {Vω (x−a)}x∈Zd . It is well-known that T a is ergodic. Because of (2.1), the matrix element of Hω satisfies the following relation H(ω ; x, y) = H(T −a ω ; x − a, y − a) ,
a, x, y ∈ Zd , ω ∈ Ω .
(2.2)
We say that a function H(ω ; x, y) on Ω × Z × Z satisfies (CR) if (2.2) holds. We define L2 as the space of functions on Ω × Zd × Zd which satisfies (CR) and has a certain decaying property. d
d
L2 := {A(ω ; x, y) : function on Ω × Zd × Zd which is finite a.e., (1) A(ω ; x, y) satisfies (CR), Z X dP |A(ω ; x, 0)|2 < ∞} . (2) kAk2L2 := Ω
x∈Zd
˜ ˜ is Remark 2.1. In the above definition, “a.e.” is in the sense of P-a.e., where P d d d the product measure of P and the counting measure on Z × Z . Since Z × Zd is ˜ countable, “A(ω ; x, y) is finite for P-a.e.” is equivalent to the statement that “there exists a subset Ω0 ⊂ Ω with P(Ω0 ) = 1, such that A(ω ; x, y) is finite for ω ∈ Ω0 , x, y ∈ Zd ”. We shall see there are many functions which belong to L2 . For this purpose, we consider a subspace of L2 . A := {{Aω }ω∈Ω : family of bounded operators on l2 (Zd ) , (1) U (a)Aω U (a)∗ = AT a ω , (2) sup kAω kop < ∞} . ω∈Ω
kAkop is the operator norm on l2 (Zd ).
ω ∈ Ω, a ∈ Zd ,
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
380
00121
F. Nakano
Remark 2.2. If Aω ∈ A, then its matrix element A(ω; x, y) belongs to L2 . In fact, since Aω is bounded on l2 (Zd ), A(ω ; x, y) is finite for any (ω, x, y) ∈ Ω × Zd × Zd . The condition (1) in the definition of A implies that A(ω ; x, y) satisfies (CR). To check the condition (2) in the definition of L2 , we write A(ω ; x, 0) = (Aω δ0 )(x), and since Aω is bounded on l2 (Zd ), and kδ0 kl2 (Zd ) = 1 (k · kl2 (Zd ) is l2 (Zd )-norm), X |A(ω ; x, 0)|2 = k(Aω δ0 )(x)k2l2 (Zd ) ≤ kAω k2op . x∈Zd
The condition (2) in the definition of A now implies kAkL2 < ∞, and thus, A(ω ; x, y) ∈ L2 . Therefore, we will sometimes abuse the notation, and regard A as a subspace of L2 , though the former is a space of operators while the latter is that of functions. To introduce a Hilbert space structure on L2 , we consider L˜2 := L2 (Ω × Zd ). Proposition 2.1. We define a map π : L2 → L˜2 by (πA)(ω, x) := A(ω ; x, 0) ,
A ∈ L2 .
Then, π is a bijection, and (π −1 a)(ω ; x, y) = a(T −y ω, x − y) ,
a ∈ L˜2 .
Proof. It is clear that πA ∈ L˜2 for A ∈ L2 . Conversely, let (π −1 a)(ω ; x, y) := a(T −y ω, x − y), a ∈ L˜2 . By Remark 2.1, (π −1 a)(ω ; x, y) is finite a.e. (π −1 a)(T −b ω ; x − b, y − b) = a(T −b T −(y−b) ω, (x − b) − (y − b)) = a(T −y ω, x − y) = (π −1 a)(ω ; x, y) ,
x, y, b ∈ Zd .
Hence (π −1 a)(ω ; x, y) satisfies (CR). kπ −1 akL2 = kakL˜2 < ∞. Therefore, π −1 a ∈ L2 for a ∈ L˜2 . Then, it suffices to show π −1 ◦ π and π ◦ π −1 are equal to identities on L2 and L˜2 respectively, which follows from direct computations. We introduce an inner product on L2 : hA, BiL2 := hπ(A), π(B)iL˜2 L2 becomes a Hilbert space under the above inner product. 2 Remark 2.3. To see L2 is complete, we let {An }∞ n=1 ⊂ L be a Cauchy sequence. ˜ Then π(An )(ω, x) = An (ω ; x, 0) is a Cauchy sequence in L2 , and thus, there exists an element a(ω, x) ∈ L˜2 , such that π(An ) → a in L˜2 as n → ∞. We define A := π −1 (a) ∈ L2 , then we have An → A in L2 as n → ∞. We regard L2 as a complete metric space in this sense.
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
381
For A, B ∈ L2 , we define a product AB which is a function on Ω × Zd × Zd : X A(ω ; x, z)B(ω ; z, y) . (2.3) (AB)(ω ; x, y) := z∈Zd
If a = π(A), b = π(B), it is written as π(AB)(ω, x) = (AB)(ω ; x, 0) X a(T −z ω, x − z)b(ω, z) . =
(2.4)
z∈Zd
Lemma 2.1. The sum in (2.3) absolutely converges for a.e. ω. Moreover, for any fixed (x, y) ∈ Zd × Zd , |A(ω ; x, z)||B(ω ; z, y)| ∈ L1 (Ω× Zd ) as a function of (ω, z) ∈ Ω × Zd , and (AB)(ω ; x, y) ∈ L1 (Ω). Proof. |A(ω ; x, z)||B(ω ; z, y)| ≤
1 (|A(ω ; x, z)|2 + |B(ω ; z, y)|2 ) . 2
(2.5)
On the other hand, Z Z X X dP |A(ω ; x, z)|2 = dP |A(T −z ω ; x − z, 0)|2 Ω
Ω
z∈Zd
z∈Zd
Z =
dP Ω
|A(ω ; x − z, 0)|2
z∈Zd
Z =
X
dP Ω
X
|A(ω ; z, 0)|2 = kAk2L2 .
(2.6)
z∈Zd
We used (CR) property of A and Fubini’s theorem. Similarly, we have R P 2 2 dP together imply the second statez∈Zd |B(ω ; z, y)| = kBkL2 < ∞, which Ω P ment of Lemma 2.1. Moreover, (2.6) implies z∈Zd |A(ω ; x, z)|2 < ∞, and similarly, P 2 z∈Zd |B(ω ; z, y)| < ∞, for a.e. ω. For such ω ∈ Ω, the sum of the RHS of (2.5) w.r.t. z ∈ Zd converges, and X 1 X |A(ω ; x, z)||B(ω ; z, y)| ≤ (|A(ω ; x, z)|2 + |B(ω ; z, y)|2 ) . (2.7) 2 d d z∈Z
z∈Z
The RHS of (2.7) ∈ L (Ω), and thus, (AB)(ω ; x, y) ∈ L1 (Ω). 1
By using Lemma 2.1, we can show that the trace per volume T (AB) exists almost surely if A, B ∈ L2 . Proposition 2.2. (1) If A, B ∈ L2 , Z dP(AB)(ω ; 0, 0) , T (AB) = Ω
In particular, T (AB) exists and finite for a.e. ω. (2) T (AB) = T (BA), for a.e. ω.
f or a.e. ω .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
382
00121
F. Nakano
Proof. (1) By Lemma 2.1, (AB)(ω ; x, y) is finite for a.e. ω. For such ω ∈ Ω, it is clear that trace(χΛL ABχΛL ) makes sense which is simply the usual trace of (2L + 1)d × (2L + 1)d matrix {(AB)(ω ; x, y)}x,y∈ΛL . T (AB) = lim
L↑∞
1 trace(χΛL ABχΛL ) |ΛL |
1 X (AB)(ω ; x, x) . L↑∞ |ΛL |
= lim
(2.8)
x∈ΛL
On the other hand, by using (CR) property of L2 , X A(ω ; x, y)B(ω ; y, x) (AB)(ω ; x, x) = y∈Zd
X
=
A(T −x ω ; 0, y − x)B(T −x ω ; y − x, 0)
y∈Zd
= (AB)(T −x ω ; 0, 0) .
(2.9)
By Lemma 2.1, the RHS of (2.9) ∈ L1 (Ω). Therefore, by Birkhoff’s ergodic theorem, Z dP(AB)(ω ; 0, 0) , for a.e. ω . T (AB) = Ω
(2) For a.e. ω,
Z
T (AB) =
dP(AB)(ω ; 0, 0) Ω
Z
X
dP
= Ω
Z
X
dP
=
A(ω ; 0, y)B(ω ; y, 0)
y∈Zd
Ω
B(T y ω ; 0, y)A(T y ω ; y, 0) .
(2.10)
y∈Zd
By Lemma 2.1, |B(ω ; 0, y)||A(ω ; y, 0)| ∈ L1 (Ω × Zd ), so that we can use Fubini’s theorem. RHS of (2.10) XZ dPB(ω ; 0, y)A(ω ; y, 0) = y∈Zd
Ω
Z dP
= Ω
X
B(ω ; 0, y)A(ω ; y, 0) = T (BA) .
y∈Zd
We have the following fact, which will make it easier to study unbounded operators on L2 . Proposition 2.3. A is dense in L2 .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
383
Proof. Let A ∈ L2 , a := π(A) ∈ L˜2 . Define ( a(ω, x) , (if |x| ≤ n and |a(ω, x)| ≤ n) , an (ω, x) := 0, (otherwise), An := π −1 (an ) . Then an → a, and An → A in L˜2 and L2 respectively as n → ∞. We will show An ∈ A which completes the proof. For ϕ, ψ ∈ l2 (Zd ), we compute, by Schwarz inequality and the definition of π −1 , X |ϕ(x)||An (ω ; x, y)||ψ(y)| |hϕ, An ψil2 (Zd ) | ≤ x,y∈Zd
≤
1/2
X
|ϕ(x)|2 |A(ω ; x, y)|
x,y∈Zd
=
×
1/2 |A(ω ; x, y)||ψ(y)|2
x,y∈Zd
X X x∈Zd
X
1/2 |ϕ(x)|2 |an (T −y ω, x − y)|
y∈Zd
X X
y∈Zd
1/2 |an (T −y ω, x − y)||ψ(y)|2
.
(2.11)
x∈Zd
We notice that, |an (T −y ω, x − y)| ≤ n, and an (T −y ω, x − y) 6= 0 only if |x − y| ≤ n. Therefore, RHS of (2.11) ≤ n(2n + 1)d
X
1/2 |ϕ(x)|2
n(2n + 1)d
x∈Zd
X
1/2 |ψ(y)|2
y∈Zd
= Cn kϕkl2 (Zd ) kψkl2 (Zd ) , where the constant Cn > 0 is independent of ω ∈ Ω. Therefore, An is bounded on l2 (Zd ), and supω∈Ω kAn kop < ∞. Because An = π −1 (an ), An satisfies (CR). Hence An ∈ A. It will be convenient to introduce another subspace of L2 . A0 := {A(ω ; x, y) : function on Ω × Zd × Zd , (1) A satisfies (CR) ,
(2) |A(ω ; x, y)| is bounded,
(3) there exists a constant K > 0 such that A(ω ; x, y) = 0 , if |x − y| > K} . Then the proof of Proposition 2.3 also shows A0 ⊂ A, and A0 is dense in L2 .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
384
00121
F. Nakano
From now on, we consider some operations on L2 . For a function A(ω ; x, y) on Ω × Zd × Zd , we define A∗ (ω ; x, y) by A∗ (ω ; x, y) := A(ω ; y, x) , which corresponds to the matrix element of the adjoint operator if A ∈ A. The corresponding element in L˜2 is a∗ := π(A∗ ) = a(T −x ω, −x) , where a = π(A). Lemma 2.2. If A ∈ L2 , then A∗ ∈ L2 , and kA∗ kL2 = kAkL2 . Proof. It is clear that A∗ (ω ; x, y) is finite a.e. That A∗ (ω ; x, y) satisfies (CR) follows from direct computation. The equality kA∗ kL2 = kAkL2 < ∞ follows from (CR) and Fubini’s theorem, which is the same argument in (2.6) in the proof of Lemma 2.1. Due to Birkhoff’s ergodic theorem, trace per volume is related to the inner product on L2 . Proposition 2.4. Let A, B ∈ L2 . (1) As functions on Ω × Zd × Zd , (BA)∗ (ω ; x, y) = (A∗ B ∗ )(ω ; x, y) ,
for a.e. ω .
∗
(2) T (A B) = hA, BiL2 . Proof. (1) By definition, (BA)∗ (ω ; x, y) = (BA)(ω ; y, x) X B(ω ; y, z) A(ω ; z, x) . = z∈Zd
On the other hand,
X
A∗ B ∗ (ω ; x, y) =
A∗ (ω ; x, z)B ∗ (ω ; z, y)
z∈Zd
X
=
A(ω ; z, x) B(ω ; y, z)
z∈Zd
= (BA)∗ (ω ; x, y) . By Lemma 2.1, the above sums absolutely converge for a.e. ω. (2) By Proposition 2.2, Z X dP A∗ (ω ; 0, x)B(ω ; x, 0) T (A∗ B) = Ω
x∈Zd
Z dP
= Ω
X x∈Zd
A(ω ; x, 0) B(ω ; x, 0) ,
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
385
for a.e. ω. Therefore, since A(ω ; x, 0) = π(A), T (A∗ B) = hπ(A), π(B)iL˜2 . The following ideal property of L2 will be used frequently in this paper. Proposition 2.5. (1) Let A ∈ L2 , B ∈ A. Since B ∈ A ⊂ L2 (Remark 2.2), we can define products BA, AB as functions on Ω × Zd × Zd . Then BA, AB ∈ L2 , and kBAkL2 = kABkL2 ≤ sup kBkop kAkL2 . ω∈Ω
Hence the multiplication operators on L defined by A 7→ BA, A 7→ AB are linear and bounded. (2) The adjoint operators of A 7→ BA, A 7→ AB are A 7→ B ∗ A, and A 7→ AB ∗ respectively. 2
Proof. (1) By Lemma 2.1, (BA)(ω ; x, y) and (AB)(ω ; x, y) are finite a.e. It ; x, y) and (AB)(ω ; x, y) satisfy (CR). Since R is Peasy to see (BA)(ω P 2 2 2 dP |A(ω ; x, 0)| = kAk d x∈Z x∈Zd |A(ω ; x, 0)| < ∞, for a.e. ω, L2 < ∞, Ω 2 d which implies (Aδ0 )(x) = A(ω ; x, 0) ∈ l (Z ) w.r.t. x for a.e. ω. For such ω ∈ Ω, (BA)(ω ; x, 0) = (BAδ0 )(x) ∈ l2 (Zd ), and X |BA(ω ; x, 0)|2 = k(BAδ0 )(x)k2l2 (Zd ) x∈Zd
≤ kBk2op k(Aδ0 )(x)k2l2 (Zd ) X ≤ sup kBk2op |A(ω ; x, 0)|2 . ω∈Ω
(2.12)
x∈Zd
In (2.12), we recall that B = {Bω }ω∈Ω , where Bω is a bounded operator on l2 (Zd ) for any fixed ω ∈ Ω. Since the RHS of (2.12) ∈ L1 (Ω), we have BA ∈ L2 , and kBAkL2 ≤ supω∈Ω kBkop kAkL2 . By Lemma 2.2, A∗ ∈ L2 , and kA∗ kL2 = kAkL2 . Since B ∈ A, B ∗ is the matrix element of the adjoint operator of B, if we regard B as a bounded operator on l2 (Zd ). Moreover, B ∗ ∈ A. By Proposition 2.4, (AB)∗ (ω ; x, y) = B ∗ A∗ (ω ; x, y), as functions on Ω × Zd × Zd . By what we have just shown, B ∗ A∗ ∈ L2 . Therefore, (AB)∗ , and hence, AB ∈ L2 . Since kBkop = kB ∗ kop , and kAkL2 = kA∗ kL2 , we have kABkL2 = k(AB)∗ kL2 = kB ∗ A∗ kL2 ≤ sup kB ∗ kop kA∗ kL2 = sup kBkop kAkL2 . ω∈Ω
ω∈Ω
To prove Proposition 2.5(2), we prepare the following lemma, which is not a priori trivial. Lemma 2.3. Let A, C ∈ L2 , and B ∈ A. Then, as functions on Ω × Zd × Zd , ((AB)C)(ω ; x, y) = (A(BC))(ω ; x, y) ,
a.e. ω .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
386
00121
F. Nakano
Proof. By Proposition 2.3, we can take sequence of bounded operators {An }∞ n=1 , 2 {Cn }∞ ⊂ A which satisfy A → A, C → C in L as n → ∞. Then, by n n n=1 Proposition 2.5(1), An B → AB, BCn → BC, in L2 as n → ∞. Moreover, by Schwarz inequality and (2.6), Z dP|((AB)C)(ω ; x, y)| Ω
Z ≤
dP Ω
≤
X
|(AB)(ω ; x, z)||C(ω ; z, y)|
z∈Zd
Z dP Ω
X
1/2 1/2 Z X |(AB)(ω ; x, z)|2 dP |C(ω ; z, y)|2 Ω
z∈Zd
z∈Zd
= kABkL2 kCkL2 ≤ sup kBkop kAkL2 kCkL2 . ω∈Ω
Therefore, for any fixed (x, y) ∈ Zd × Zd , ((An B)Cn )(ω ; x, y) → ((AB)C)(ω ; x, y) , as n → ∞ in L1 (Ω). Since Zd × Zd is countable, by diagonal trick, we can take a subsequence n0 = n0 (k) such that ((An B)Cn )(ω ; x, y) → ((AB)C)(ω ; x, y) , pointwise for a.e. ω, as k → ∞, for any x, y ∈ Zd . Similarly, by taking a subsequence further: n00 = n00 (n0 (k)), (An (BCn ))(ω ; x, y) → (A(BC))(ω ; x, y) , pointwise for a.e. ω, as k → ∞. Therefore, it is sufficient to show ((An B)Cn )(ω ; x, y) = (An (BCn ))(ω ; x, y) , pointwise, which is clear. In fact, since An , B, Cn are bounded on l2 (Zd ), ((An B)Cn )(ω ; x, y) = hδx , An BCn δy il2 (Zd ) = (An (BCn ))(ω ; x, y) . Proof of Proposition 2.5(2). Let A, C ∈ L2 , and B ∈ A. By Proposition 2.4, hBA, CiL2 = T ((BA)∗ C) = T ((A∗ B ∗ )C) . By Proposition 2.2, and Lemma 2.3, Z ∗ ∗ dP((A∗ B ∗ )C)(ω ; 0, 0) T ((A B )C) = Ω
Z =
dP(A∗ (B ∗ C))(ω ; 0, 0)
Ω
= T (A∗ (B ∗ C)) = hA, B ∗ CiL2 .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
387
Therefore, the adjoint of the linear bounded operator A 7→ BA on L2 is the map A 7→ B ∗ A. The adjoint operator of A 7→ AB can be derived similarly. We are going to study unbounded operators on L2 . The following operator corresponds to taking commutator with x1 . Proposition 2.6. For A ∈ L2 , we define (∂1 A)(ω ; x, y) := (x1 − y1 )A(ω ; x, y) . Then, the operator A 7→ ∂1 A is self-adjoint with domain D(∂1 ) := {A ∈ L2 : ∂1 A ∈ L2 } . Therefore, Assumption (1.6) is equivalent to the statement that PF ∈ D(∂1 ). Proof. Let a := π(A). Then, (π(∂1 A))(ω, x) = x1 a(ω, x). Thus, the operator A 7→ ∂1 A corresponds to the multiplication operator of x1 on L˜2 , which is self-adjoint with domain {a ∈ L˜2 : x1 a ∈ L˜2 }. Next, we consider an operator on L2 which corresponds to taking commutator with Hω,E . The matrix element of Hω,E is given by (if |x − y| = 1) , 1, Hω,E (ω ; x, y) = λVω (x) + Ex1 , (if x = y) , 0, (otherwise). For A ∈ L2 , we define (Hω,E A)(ω ; x, y) and (AHω,E )(ω ; x, y) as (2.3) X A(ω ; z, y) + (λVω (x) + Ex1 )A(ω ; x, y) , (Hω,E A)(ω ; x, y) := |z−x|=1
(AHω,E )(ω ; x, y) :=
X
A(ω ; x, z) + (λVω (y) + Ey1 )A(ω ; x, y) .
|z−y|=1
We define (LHω,E A)(ω ; x, y) := (Hω,E A)(ω ; x, y) − (AHω,E )(ω ; x, y) ,
(2.13)
which makes sense as a function on Ω× Zd × Zd . We note (LHω,E A)(ω ; x, y) satisfies (CR), though (Hω,E A)(ω ; x, y) and (AHω,E )(ω ; x, y) do not. The corresponding element in L˜2 is X a(ω, z) + (λVω (x) + Ex1 )a(ω, x) π(LHω,E A)(ω, x) = |z−x|=1
−
X
|z|=1
a(T −z ω, x − z) + λVω (0)a(ω, x) .
(2.14)
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
388
00121
F. Nakano
Since E|Vω (0)|2 < ∞, LHω,E A ∈ L2 if A ∈ A0 . Hence LHω,E is densely defined on L2 . Proposition 2.7. (1) LHω,E is self-adjoint with domain D(LHω,E ) := {A ∈ L2 : (λ(Vω (x) − Vω (y)) + E(x1 − y1 ))A(ω ; x, y) ∈ L2 } . (2) eitLHω,E A = eitHω,E Ae−itHω,E , A ∈ L2 . Remark 2.4. Hω,E has the following property U (a)Hω,E U (a)∗ = HT a ω,E − Ea1 ,
ω ∈ Ω, a ∈ Zd ,
(2.15)
which implies U (a)eitHω,E U (a)∗ = eitHT a ω,E e−itEa1 .
(2.16)
However, by using (2.16), we can show (eitHω,E Ae−itHω,E )(ω ; x, y) satisfies (CR) (it is straightforward if A ∈ A. For A ∈ L2 , we use Proposition 2.3). By using the argument in the proof of Proposition 2.5, eitHω,E Ae−itHω,E ∈ L2 , for A ∈ L2 . Proof of Proposition 2.7(1). It is easy to see the operators a(ω, x) 7→ P P −z ω, x − z), which appear in (2.14), |z−x|=1 a(ω, z), and a(ω, x) 7→ |z|=1 a(T are bounded on L˜2 . The multiplication operator a(ω, x) 7→ (λ(Vω (x) − Vω (0)) + Ex1 )a(ω, x) is clearly self-adjoint with domain D := {a ∈ L˜2 : (λ(Vω (x) − Vω (0)) + Ex1 )a(ω, x) ∈ L˜2 } . Therefore, LHω,E is self-adjoint with domain π −1 D = D(LHω,E ). To prove Proposition 2.7(2), we prepare the following lemma. Let D(Hω,E ) be the domain of the self-adjoint operator Hω,E on l2 (Zd ) given by D(Hω,E ) := {ϕ ∈ l2 (Zd ) : (λVω (x) + Ex1 )ϕ ∈ l2 (Zd )} . Lemma 2.4. Suppose ϕ ∈ D(Hω,E ) for any ω ∈ Ω, and A ∈ A0 . Then, Aϕ ∈ D(Hω,E ) for any ω ∈ Ω. Proof. We have only to show (λVω (x) + Ex1 )(Aϕ)(x) = (λVω (x) + Ex1 )
X
A(ω ; x, y)ϕ(y) ∈ l2 (Zd ) ,
y∈Zd
for any ω ∈ Ω. Since A ∈ A0 , there exist constants C > 0, K > 0, such that |A(ω ; x, y)| ≤ C, and A(ω ; x, y) = 0 if |x − y| > K. Then, X (λVω (x) + Ex1 ) A(ω ; x, y)ϕ(y) d y∈Z ≤ C|(λVω (x) + Ex1 )|
X |z|≤K
|ϕ(x + z)| .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
389
We will show |(λVω (x) + Ex1 )ϕ(x + z)| ∈ l2 (Zd ), w.r.t. x for any fixed z(|z| ≤ K) which completes the proof. In fact, letting y = x + z, |(λVω (x) + Ex1 )ϕ(x + z)| = |λVT −x+y ω (y) + Ey1 + E(x1 − y1 )||ϕ(x + z)| ≤ |λVT z ω (y) + Ey1 ||ϕ(y)| + |Ez1 ||ϕ(y)| . By assumption, the first term of the RHS in the above expression belongs to l2 (Zd ), for any ω ∈ Ω. Proof of Proposition 2.7(2). Let U (t)A := eitHω,E Ae−itHω,E , A ∈ L2 . By Proposition 2.5 and Remark 2.4, U (t) is uniformly bounded on L2 w.r.t. t ∈ R. Thus, it suffices to show eitLHω,E A = U (t)A, for A ∈ A0 . Let ϕ ∈ D(Hω,E ) for any ω ∈ Ω, and A ∈ A0 . Then, by Lemma 2.4, Z t ds eisHω,E i[Hω,E , A]e−isHω,E ϕ (2.17) U (t)Aϕ − Aϕ = 0
as elements of l (Z ). We let ϕ = δy ∈ D(Hω,E ), and take the l2 (Zd )-inner product of (2.17) with δx (x, y ∈ Zd ). Then, we have Z t ds eisHω,E i[Hω,E , A]e−isHω,E (2.18) U (t)A − A = 2
d
0
as elements of L2 , for LHS of (2.18) belongs to L2 . We will show U (t) is strongly continuous on L2 . Let A ∈ A0 . By (2.18), h(U (t) − I)A, (U (t) − I)AiL2 Z t Z t = ds eisHω,E i[Hω,E , A]e−isHω,E , du eiuHω,E i[Hω,E , A]e−iuHω,E 0
0
Z =
dP Ω
XZ x∈Zd
Z
t
ds
t
du(V (s))(ω ; x, 0)(V (u))(ω ; x, 0) ,
0
L2
(2.19)
0
where (V (s))(ω ; x, y) := (eisHω,E i[Hω,E , A]e−isHω,E )(ω ; x, y) . By Proposition 2.5, V (s) is bounded in L2 uniformly w.r.t. s ∈ R. Thus, we use Fubini’s theorem the RHS of (2.19) Z t Z Z t X ds du dP (V (s))(ω ; x, 0)(V (u))(ω ; x, 0) = 0
Z
Z
t
ds
= 0
Ω
0
0
x∈Zd
t
duhV (s), V (u)iL2 .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
390
00121
F. Nakano
Since A0 is dense in L2 , we conclude that U (t) is strongly continuous on L2 . By (2.18), Z t ds U (s)(i[Hω,E , A]) . U (t)A − A = 0
If A ∈ A0 , then i[Hω,E , A] ∈ L so that the integrand in RHS in the above expression is continuous in L2 w.r.t. s ∈ R. Hence, for A ∈ A0 , U (t)A is differentiable, and we have d U (t)A = U (t)(i[Hω,E , A]) . dt By Lemma 2.4, it is easy to see 2
iLHω,E (U (t)A)(ω ; x, y) = U (t)(i[Hω,E , A])(ω ; x, y) ∈ L2 , for A ∈ A0 , and hence, we have U (t)A ∈ D(LHω,E ), and d U (t)A = iLHω,E (U (t)A) , A ∈ A0 . dt Therefore, by uniqueness of solution of time-independent Schr¨ odinger equation, U (t)A = eitLHω,E A ,
A ∈ A0 ,
as desired. Proposition 2.8. For f (λ) = fβ,µ (λ), or χ(−∞,µ] (λ), T (f (Hω )∂1 Hω ) = 0 ,
a.e. ω .
(2.20)
Proof. We divide the proof into some steps. Step 1. We will show T (e−itHω,E ∂1 Hω ) = 0 ,
a.e. ω .
(2.21)
Let ∇n be a bounded operator on L˜2 defined by ( x1 a(ω, x) , (if |x1 | ≤ n) , (∇n a)(ω, x) := (sgn x1 )n a(ω, x) , (otherwise) . In L2 , ∇n corresponds to the following operator which we also denote by ∇n . ( (x1 − y1 )A(ω ; x, y) , (if |x1 − y1 | ≤ n) , (∇n A)(ω ; x, y) = (sgn(x1 − y1 ))n A(ω ; x, y) , (otherwise) . eisHω ∇n (e−isHω ) ∈ L2 , and (eisHω ∇n (e−isHω ))(ω ; x, y) = hδx , eisHω ∇n (e−isHω )δy il2 (Zd ) . Since ∇n corresponds to a multiplication operator by a bounded function, and δy ∈ D(Hω ), for any ω ∈ Ω, it is easy to show (∇n (e−isHω,E )δy )(x) ∈ D(Hω ), for
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
391
any ω ∈ Ω. Therefore, (eitHω ∇n (e−itHω ))(ω ; x, y) Z t dshδx , eisHω {Hω (∇n (e−isHω )) − ∇n (Hω e−isHω )}δy il2 (Zd ) . =i 0
Because both sides in the above equality belong to l2 (Zd ) w.r.t. x, we have Z t −itHω −itHω )=e ds eisHω {Hω ∇n (e−isHω ) − ∇n (Hω e−isHω )} . (2.22) ∇n (e 0
We take the trace per volume on both sides. By Proposition 2.2, T (∇n (e−itHω )) = 0 ,
a.e. ω .
(2.23)
On the other hand, in the proof of Lemma 3.1 in Sec. 3, we will show that, (1) L2 norm of {Hω ∇n (e−isHω ) − ∇n (Hω e−isHω )} is bounded uniformly in s (3.5). (2) {Hω ∇n (e−isHω ) − ∇n (Hω e−isHω )} → −(∂1 Hω )e−isHω in L2 as n → ∞ (Remark 3.1). By (1), we can use Fubini’s theorem and conclude that Z t −itHω isHω −isHω −isHω ds e {Hω ∇n (e ) − ∇n (Hω e )} T e 0
Z
t
= 0
ds T (e−i(t−s)Hω {Hω ∇n (e−isHω ) − ∇n (Hω e−isHω )})
Z
→−
t
ds T (e−itHω (∂1 Hω )) ,
as n → ∞ .
(2.24)
0
In the last step, we used (2) above, and Proposition 2.2. By (2.22), (2.23), and (2.24), we have (2.21). Step 2. For z ∈ C, Im z 6= 0, we will show T ((Hω − z)−1 ∂1 Hω ) = 0 ,
a.e. ω .
(2.25)
If z = a + iλ, for λ > 0, T ((Hω − a − iλ)−1 ∂1 Hω ) Z XZ ∞ dP dt e−λt eita (e−itHω )(ω ; 0, x)(∂1 Hω )(ω ; x, 0) . (2.26) =i Ω
x∈Zd
0
Since e−itHω ∈ A Rand ∂1 Hω ∈ A0 , we can use Fubini’s theorem to exchange R P ∞ dP x∈Zd with 0 dt. Ω RHS of (2.26) Z ∞ dt e−λt eita T (e−itHω ∂1 Hω ) = 0 . =i 0
The proof of (2.25) for λ < 0 is similar.
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
392
00121
F. Nakano
Step 3. (completion) We use the following formula which is norm convergent. Z 1 (∂z¯f˜β,µ (z))(Hω − z)−1 dzd¯ z, (2.27) fβ,µ (Hω ) = 2πi C where f˜β,µ (z) is the almost analytic continuation of fβ,µ , (∂z¯f )(x + iy) = 12 (∂x f + i∂y f )(x + iy), for z = x + iy ([11]). Then, by (2.25), T (fβ,µ (Hω )∂1 Hω ) = 0 ,
a.e. ω ,
and thus, we have (2.20) for f (λ) = fβ,µ (λ). Since fβ,µ (λ) → χ(−∞,µ] (λ), pointwise if λ 6= µ, as β → ∞, and the integrated density of states is continuous, Z 2 T ((fβ,µ (Hω ) − Pµ ) ) = (fβ,µ (λ) − χ(−∞,µ] (λ))2 dN (λ) → 0 , as β ↑ ∞ , R
where dN (λ) is the density of states measure. By Schwarz inequality, 0 = T (fβ,µ (Hω )∂1 Hω ) → T (Pµ ∂1 Hω ) , as β → ∞, and we obtain (2.20) for χ(−∞,µ] (λ). Remark 2.5. When we impose constant magnetic field, the analysis in this paper goes through with suitable modifications in the definitions of some notations described below. Let B := {Bij }1≤i,j≤d be d × d antisymmetric matrix whose components are given by Bij = −Bij ∈ R, if i < j, and 0 if i = j. Bij corresponds to the magnetic flux penetrating plaquettes in (i, j)-planes. (1) The translation operator U (a) defined after (2.1) should be replaced by the magnetic translation given by (UB (a)ψ)(x) := e 2 ha,BxiRd ψ(x − a) , i
x, a ∈ Zd .
(2) The definition of (CR) in (2.2) should be replaced by H(ω ; x, y) = e 2 ha,B(x−y)iRd H(T −a ω ; x − a, y − a) , i
x, y, a ∈ Zd .
(3) π −1 : L2 → L˜2 in Proposition 2.1, and the product of A, B ∈ L2 represented in L˜2 in (2.4) should be given by the following quantities respectively: (π −1 a)(ω ; x, y) = e 2 hy,BxiRd a(T −y ω ; x − y) , X i e 2 hz,BxiRd a(T −z ω, x − z)b(ω, z) . π(AB)(ω, x) = i
z∈Zd
3. Proof of Theorem 1.1 In this section, we prove Theorem 1.1. The following proposition is important to study E ↓ 0 limit.
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
393
Proposition 3.1. Let A ∈ D(∂1 ), Z X dP |x1 |2 |A(ω ; x, 0)|2 < ∞ . D(∂1 ) := A ∈ L2 : Ω d x∈Z
Then, we have the following resolvent equation. (z − LHω,E )−1 A − (z − LHω )−1 A = (z − LHω,E )−1 E∂1 (z − LHω )−1 A ,
Im z 6= 0 .
(3.1)
Before we prove Proposition 3.1., we prepare the following lemma. Lemma 3.1. (1) Let C ∈ L2 . Then, L2 -norm of [LHω , ∇n ]C which is defined by [LHω , ∇n ]C := [Hω , ∇n C] − ∇n ([Hω , C]) is bounded uniformly w.r.t. n (∇n is defined in the proof of Proposition 2.8). (2) ∂1 (z − LHω )−1 A ∈ L2 , if A ∈ D(∂1 ), Im z 6= 0. Proof. (1) Let c := π(C), h := π(Hω ). Then, h(ω, x) is given by (if |x| = 1) , 1, h(ω, x) = Vω (0) , (if x = 0) , 0, (otherwise) . By (2.4), the product is given by X
hc = π(Hω C) =
h(T −z ω, x − z)c(ω, z) .
z∈Zd
First of all, we compute (h∇n c)(ω, x) − (∇n (hc))(ω, x). By definition of ∇n , we have X h(T −z ω, x − z) z1 c(ω, z) (h∇n c)(ω, x) = z∈Zd ,|z1 |≤n
+
X
h(T −z ω, x − z)(sgn z1 )n c(ω, z) ,
(3.2)
z∈Zd ,|z1 |>n
X x1 h(T −z ω, x − z)c(ω, z) , d z∈Z X (∇n (hc))(ω, x) = h(T −z ω, x − z)c(ω, z) , (sgn x1 )n
(if |x1 | ≤ n) , (if |x1 | > n) .
(3.3)
z∈Zd
h(T −z ω, x − z) 6= 0 only if |x − z| ≤ 1, and thus the sums in (3.2), (3.3) are finite sums and they make sense for each (ω, x) ∈ Ω × Zd . We divide into several cases.
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
394
00121
F. Nakano
Case A (|x1 | ≤ n) In this case, we have (h∇n c)(ω, x) − (∇n (hc))(ω, x) X (z1 − x1 )h(T −z ω, x − z)c(ω, z) = |z1 |≤n
+
X
((sgn z1 )n − x1 )h(T −z ω, x − z)c(ω, z) .
(3.4)
|z1 |>n
The second term of RHS is nonzero only if x1 = n, z1 = n + 1, or x1 = −n, z1 = −(n + 1). In either case, (sgn z1 )n − x1 = 0. Therefore, if |x1 | ≤ n, we have |(h∇n c)(ω, x) − (∇n (hc))(ω, x)| ≤ |c(ω, x + e1 )| + |c(ω, x − e1 )| ,
(3.5)
where e1 := (1, 0, . . . , 0) ∈ Zd . Case B (|x1 | > n) In this case, we have (h∇n c)(ω, x) − (∇n (hc))(ω, x) X (z1 − (sgn x1 )n)h(T −z ω, x − z)c(ω, z) = z∈Zd ,|z1 |≤n
X
+
((sgn z1 ) − (sgn x1 ))n h(T −z ω, x − z)c(ω, z) .
z∈Zd ,|z1 |>n
The first term of RHS in the above expression vanishes by the same reason as in Case A. The second term is nonzero only if |x1 | > n, |z1 | > n, and |x − z| ≤ 1, in which case sgn x1 = sgn z1 . Thus, the second term also vanishes. Next, we compute ((∇n c)h)(ω, x) − (∇n (ch))(ω, x). Each term is given by X
((∇n c)h)(ω, x) =
z∈Zd ,|x
(x1 − z1 )c(T −z ω, x − z)h(ω, z)
1 −z1 |≤n
X
+
n sgn(x1 − z1 )c(T −z ω, x − z)h(ω, z) ,
z∈Zd ,|x1 −z1 |>n
(∇n (ch))(ω, x) =
Case C (|x1 | ≤ n)
X x1 c(T −z ω, x − z)h(ω, z) ,
(if |x1 | ≤ n) ,
(if |x1 | > n) .
z∈Zd
X
z∈Zd
n(sgn x1 )c(T −z ω, x − z)h(ω, z) ,
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
395
In this case, we have ((∇n c)h)(ω, x) − (∇n (ch))(ω, x) X (−z1 )c(T −z ω, x − z)h(ω, z) = z∈Zd ,|x1 −z1 |≤n
X
+
(n sgn(x1 − z1 ) − x1 )c(T −z ω, x − z)h(ω, z) .
z∈Zd ,|x1 −z1 |>n
The second term is nonzero only if x1 = −n, z1 = 1, or x1 = n, z1 = −1. In either case, the second term vanishes. Hence, if |x1 | ≤ n, we have X |c(T −z ω, x − z)| . (3.6) |((∇n c)h)(ω, x) − (∇n (ch))(ω, x)| ≤ |z|=1
Case D (|x1 | > n) In this case, we have ((∇n c)h)(ω, x) − (∇n (ch))(ω, x) X ((x1 − z1 ) − (sgn x1 ) n)c(T −z ω, x − z)h(ω, z) = z∈Zd ,|x1 −z1 |≤n
+
X z∈Zd ,|x
n(sgn(x1 − z1 ) − sgn x1 )c(T −z ω, x − z)h(ω, z) .
1 −z1 |>n
By the similar argument as in Case B, C, we see that the RHS in the above expression vanishes. By (3.5), (3.6), we conclude that [LHω , ∇n ]C is uniformly bounded in L2 w.r.t. n. (2) Let C := (z − LHω )−1 A, for A ∈ D(∂1 ), Im z 6= 0. Then, C ∈ D(LHω ), and as discussed in the proof of Proposition 2.8, ∇n C ∈ D(LHω ). Then, ∇n (z − LHω )−1 A = ∇n C = (z − LHω )−1 (z − LHω )∇n C = (z − LHω )−1 ∇n ((z − LHω )C) + (z − LHω )−1 [(z − LHω ), ∇n ]C = (z − LHω )−1 ∇n A − (z − LHω )−1 [LHω , ∇n ]C . By (1) of Lemma 3.1, the RHS in the above expression is uniformly bounded in L2 w.r.t. n. On the other hand, by monotone convergence theorem, k∂1 Ck2L2 = lim k∇n Ck2L2 < ∞ . n→∞
−1
Therefore, we have k∂1 (z − LHω ) Lemma 3.1 is proved.
AkL2 < ∞, and ∂1 (z − LHω )−1 A ∈ L2 .
Remark 3.1. (3.4) shows h(∇n c) − ∇n (hc) → −(∂1 h) c , in L˜2 as n → ∞, which we needed in the proof of Proposition 2.8.
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
396
00121
F. Nakano
Proof of Proposition 3.1. Let A ∈ D(∂1 ), Im z 6= 0. Then, (z − LHω,E )−1 A − (z − LHω )−1 A = (z − LHω,E )−1 (z − LHω )(z − LHω )−1 A −(z − LHω,E )−1 (z − LHω − E∂1 )(z − LHω )−1 A = (z − LHω,E )−1 E∂1 (z − LHω )−1 A . In the second step, we used Lemma 3.1. From now on, we will carry out each operations in the definition of σ2 (ω, F ). Lemma 3.2. If PF satisfies Assumption (1.6), Z 1 ∞ dt δe−tδ T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E PF ) lim E↓0 E 0 = ih(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω , ∂1 PF iL2 . Proof. By Proposition 2.7, eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E = −eitLHω,E (i∂1 Hω ), and by Proposition 2.5 and the fact that identity operator on l2 (Zd ) belongs to L2 , PF ∈ L2 . Then, Z ∞ dt δe−tδ T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E PF ) 0
Z =− 0
∞
dt δe−tδ heitLHω,E (i∂1 Hω ), PF iL2
= (−δ)h(−iδ − LHω,E )−1 ∂1 Hω , PF iL2 = (−δ)h∂1 Hω , (iδ − LHω,E )−1 PF iL2 . By Assumption (1.6), PF ∈ D(∂1 ). Then, by Proposition 3.1., = (−δ)h∂1 Hω , (iδ − LHω )−1 PF iL2 + (−δ)Eh∂1 Hω , (iδ − LHω,E )−1 ∂1 (iδ − LHω )−1 PF iL2 =: I + II . For bounded Borel measurable function f (λ) on R, by definition, it is easy to see that Hω f (Hω )(ω ; x, y) = f (Hω )Hω (ω ; x, y), and thus LHω f (Hω ) = 0. Hence, PF = (iδ)−1 (iδ − LHω )PF . By Proposition 2.8 and (3.7), I = ih∂1 Hω , PF iL2 = 0 , II = iEh∂1 Hω , (iδ − LHω,E )−1 ∂1 PF iL2 = iEh(−iδ − LHω,E )−1 ∂1 Hω , ∂1 PF iL2 .
(3.7)
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
Therefore, 1 E
Z
∞
397
δe−tδ T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E PF )
0
= ih(−iδ − LHω,E )−1 ∂1 Hω , ∂1 PF iL2 .
(3.8)
Since ∂1 Hω ∈ A0 ⊂ D(∂1 ), we use Proposition 3.1. again. RHS of (3.8) = ih(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω , ∂1 PF iL2 + iEh(−iδ − LHω,E )−1 ∂1 (−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω , ∂1 PF iL2 . For fixed δ > 0, the second term goes to zero as E ↓ 0. Hence, we have Lemma 3.2.
Remark 3.2. The equality I = 0 corresponds to the fact that σ2 (ω, F ) = 0 if E = 0. The following lemma would be useful to study finite temperature properties of charge transport, though we will not use it in the proof of Theorems 1.1 and 1.2. Lemma 3.3. If fβ,F (Hω ) satisfies the following decay estimate E|fβ,F (Hω )(ω ; x, y)| ≤ Chx − yi−γ ,
(3.9)
for some constant C > 0 independent of x, y ∈ Zd , γ > d + 2, and β > 0 (hxi := 1 + |x|), then we have fβ,F (Hω ) → PF , ∂1 fβ,F (Hω ) → ∂1 PF , in L2 , as β → ∞. Proof. Since P{F is the eigenvalue of Hω } = 0, fβ,F (Hω )(ω ; x, y) → PF (ω ; x, y) , as β → ∞, for a.e. ω. Then, by dominated convergence theorem, Z dP|fβ,F (Hω )(ω ; x, 0) − PF (ω ; x, 0)|2 → 0 , Ω
as β → ∞, for any x ∈ Zd . Then, by (3.9) and dominated convergence theorem again, we can easily arrive at the conclusion. To study δ ↓ 0 limit, we prepare a series of lemmas, by borrowing the arguments in [2]. For the sake of simplicity, we write P instead of PF . Lemma 3.4. If P ∈ D(∂1 ), we have ∂1 P = P (∂1 P )Q + Q(∂1 P )P , where Q := 1 − P .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
398
00121
F. Nakano
Proof. Since P 2 = P , we have (∂1 P )(ω ; x, y) =
X
(x1 − z1 )P (ω ; x, z)P (ω ; z, y)
z∈Zd
+
X
(z1 − y1 )P (ω ; x, z)P (ω ; z, y) .
z∈Zd
Since ∂1 P ∈ L2 , the sums in the above expression are absolutely convergent (Lemma 2.1). Hence, as elements of L2 , ∂1 P = (∂1 P )P + P (∂1 P ). Multiplying P and Q from both sides, we have P (∂1 P )P = 0, Q(∂1 P )Q = 0. Therefore, ∂1 P = (P + Q)(∂1 P )(P + Q) = P (∂1 P )Q + Q(∂1 P )P . Lemma 3.5. If A ∈ D(LHω ), then P AQ ∈ D(LHω ), and we have LHω (P AQ) = P LHω (A)Q . Remark 3.3. By Proposition 2.5, P AQ ∈ L2 . LHω (P AQ) is defined as LHω (P AQ) := hδx , [Hω , P AQ]δy il2 (Zd ) . h := π(Hω ) satisfies h(ω, x) = 0, if |x| ≥ 2, and h(ω, x) < ∞. Therefore, hδx , [Hω , P AQ]δy il2 (Zd ) makes sense. We note that A ∈ D(LHω ) is equivalent to the statement that LVω (A)(ω ; x, y) := hδx , [Vω , A]δy il2 (Zd ) ∈ L2 . Proof. Let a := π(A), and define ( a(ω, x) , an (ω, x) := 0,
(if |x| ≤ n, and |a(ω, x)| ≤ n) , (otherwise) .
Then, An := π −1 (an ) → A in L2 . Since LVω (A) ∈ L2 , LVω (An ) → LVω (A) in L2 as n → ∞. We write Hω = H0 + Vω . Since H0 , P , Q, An are all bounded on l2 (Zd ), LH0 (P An Q)(ω ; x, y) = (LH0 (P )An Q)(ω ; x, y) + (P LH0 (An )Q)(ω ; x, y) + (P An LH0 (Q))(ω ; x, y) . On the other hand, LVω (P An Q)(ω ; x, y) =
X
(3.10)
P (ω ; x, z1 )An (ω ; z1 , z2 )Q(ω ; z2 , y)
z1 ,z2 ∈Zd
× (Vω (x) − Vω (z1 ) + Vω (z1 ) − Vω (z2 ) + Vω (z2 ) − Vω (y)) = (LVω (P )An Q)(ω ; x, y) + (P LVω (An )Q)(ω ; x, y) + (P An LVω (Q))(ω ; x, y) .
(3.11)
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
399
Since A, P ∈ D(LHω ), the sums appearing in the above expression absolutely converge. By (3.10), (3.11), and the equality LHω (P ) = LH0 (P ) + LVω (P ) = 0, we have LHω (P An Q) = P LHω (An )Q .
(3.12)
P LHω (An )Q → P LHω (A)Q in L2 (n → ∞), and by taking subsequence, (P LHω (An )Q)(ω ; x, y) → (P LHω (A)Q)(ω ; x, y) ,
(3.13)
as n → ∞ for a.e. ω, and for any x, y ∈ Zd . On the other hand, we have (P An Q)(ω ; x, y) → (P AQ)(ω ; x, y), as n → ∞ for a.e. ω, by the same reason. Since h(ω, x) = 0 if |x| ≥ 2, and |h(ω, x)| < ∞ for a.e. ω, LHω (P An Q)(ω ; x, y) → LHω (P AQ)(ω ; x, y)
(3.14)
for a.e. ω, as n → ∞. By (3.12), (3.13), and (3.14), we arrive at the conclusion. Lemma 3.6. Q{(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω }P = (−iδ − LHω )−1 (Q∂1 Hω P ) ,
(3.15)
P {(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω }Q = (−iδ − LHω )−1 (P ∂1 Hω Q) .
(3.16)
Proof. Let A := Q{(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω }P − (−iδ − LHω )−1 (Q∂1 Hω P ) . The first term of RHS belongs to D(LHω ) by Lemma 3.5. Moreover, (−iδ − LHω )A = Q(∂1 Hω )P − Q(∂1 Hω )P = 0 . Therefore, A = 0. The proof of (3.16) is similar. Lemma 3.7. If P ∈ D(∂1 ), then (Qx1 P )(ω ; x, y) is finite for a.e. ω. Proof. By Schwarz inequality, we have Z dP|(Qx1 P )(ω ; x, y)| Ω
=
XZ z∈Zd
≤
dP|Q(ω ; x, z)||z1 ||P (ω ; z, y)|
Ω
X Z z∈Zd
Ω
1/2 Z 1/2 dP|Q(ω ; x, z)|2 |z1 | dP|P (ω ; z, y)|2 |z1 | . Ω
(3.17)
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
400
00121
F. Nakano
Since P , Q ∈ D(∂1 ), RHS of (3.17) Z 1 X dP|Q(ω ; x, z)|2 (|x1 − z1 | + |x1 |) ≤ 2 Ω d z∈Z
+
Z 1 X dP|P (ω ; z, y)|2 (|z1 − y1 | + |y1 |) 2 Ω d z∈Z
≤ C(k∂1 Qk2L2 + |x1 |kQk2L2 + k∂1 P k2L2 + |y1 |kP k2L2 ) ≤ Cx,y < ∞ , for some constants C, Cx,y depending on x, y ∈ Zd . Lemma 3.8. If P ∈ D(∂1 ), we have LHω (Qx1 P ) = QLHω (x1 )P . In particular, LHω (Qx1 P ) ∈ L2 . Proof. By Lemma 3.7, (Qx1 P )(ω ; x, y) is finite for a.e. ω. Thus, by Remark 3.3, LHω (Qx1 P ) makes sense as a function on Ω × Zd × Zd for a.e. ω. We will show LVω (Qx1 P ) = LVω (Q)x1 P + Qx1 LVω (P ) ,
(3.18)
LH0 (Qx1 P ) = LH0 (Q)x1 P + QLH0 (x1 )P + Qx1 LH0 (P ) ,
(3.19)
as functions on Ω×Zd ×Zd . Then, Lemma 3.8 follows by using LHω (P ) = LHω (Q) = 0. To prove (3.18), we compute (LVω (Qx1 P ))(ω ; x, y) = III + IV , where III :=
X
Q(ω ; x, z)z1 P (ω ; z, y)(Vω (x) − Vω (z)) ,
z∈Zd
IV :=
X
Q(ω ; x, z)z1 P (ω ; z, y)(Vω (z) − Vω (y)) .
z∈Zd
We will show that, III, IV make sense for a.e. ω. In fact, by Schwarz inequality, 1/2 Z Z X dP|III| ≤ dP |Q(ω ; x, z)|2 |Vω (x) − Vω (z)|2 Ω
Ω
×
z∈Zd
Z dP Ω
X z∈Zd
1/2 |z1 |2 |P (ω ; z, y)|2
.
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
401
Since P satisfies Assumption (1.6), Z Z X X 2 2 dP |z1 | |P (ω ; z, y)| ≤ 2 dP |z1 − y1 |2 |P (ω ; z, y)|2 Ω
Ω
z∈Zd
z∈Zd
Z
+ 2|y1 |2
dP Ω
X
|P (ω ; z, y)|2 ≤ Cy < ∞ ,
z∈Zd
for some constant Cy depending only on y ∈ Z . Since Q ∈ D(LHω ), Z X dP |Q(ω ; x, z)|2 |Vω (x) − Vω (z)|2 = kLVω (Q)k2L2 < ∞ . d
Ω
z∈Zd
Therefore, III makes sense for a.e. ω, and so does IV by the same argument. Since III + IV = (LVω (Q)x1 P )(ω ; x, y) + (Qx1 LVω (P ))(ω ; x, y) , we proved (3.18). To prove (3.19), we notice that, by Remark 3.3, (H0 Qx1 P )(ω ; x, y), (QH0 x1 P )(ω ; x, y), (Qx1 H0 P )(ω ; x, y), and (Qx1 P H0 )(ω ; x, y) are all finite for a.e. ω. Then, (LH0 (Qx1 P ))(ω ; x, y) = (H0 Qx1 P )(ω ; x, y) − (Qx1 P H0 )(ω ; x, y) = (H0 Qx1 P )(ω ; x, y) − (QH0 x1 P )(ω ; x, y) + (QH0 x1 P )(ω ; x, y) − (Qx1 H0 P )(ω ; x, y) + (Qx1 H0 P )(ω ; x, y) − (Qx1 P H0 )(ω ; x, y) = (LH0 (Q)x1 P )(ω ; x, y) + (QLH0 (x1 )P )(ω ; x, y) + (Qx1 LH0 (P ))(ω ; x, y) . Thus (3.19) is proved. The following lemma follows by simple argument of functional calculus. Lemma 3.9. lim(−iδ − LHω )−1 LHω A = −A , δ↓0
f or A ∈ (Ker LHω )⊥ .
Lemma 3.10. [[x1 , P ], P ] ∈ (Ker LHω )⊥ . Proof. By Proposition 2.5, hA, [[x1 , P ], P ]iL2 = h[A, P ], [x1 , P ]iL2 .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
402
00121
F. Nakano
Thus, it suffices to show [A, P ] = 0 ,
if A ∈ Ker LHω .
(3.20)
Let An ∈ A0 so that An → A in L2 as n → ∞ (Proposition 2.3). Since An ∈ A0 , (z − Hω )−1 (z − Hω )An = An (Im z 6= 0) makes sense as elements of L2 . Then, [An , (z − Hω )−1 ] = (z − Hω )−1 [An , Hω ](z − Hω )−1 . Since An → A in L2 , and (z − Hω )−1 is bounded on l2 (Zd ), the LHS of the above expression converges to [A, (z − Hω )−1 ] in L2 as n → ∞. On the other hand, trivially, [An , H0 ] → [A, H0 ], and by the construction of An , [An , Vω ] = −LVω (An ) → −LVω (A) = [A, Vω ]. Therefore, [A, (z − Hω )−1 ] = (z − Hω )−1 [A, Hω ](z − Hω )−1 = 0 . By using the almost analytic continuation of fβ,F (λ) (2.27) which is a norm convergent integral, we have [A, fβ,F (Hω )] = 0 . Let B ∈ A0 . By Proposition 2.5, h[A, P ], BiL2 = hA, [B, P ]iL2 . In Step 3 of the proof of Proposition 2.8, we saw fβ,F (Hω ) → P in L2 as β ↑ ∞. Thus hA, [B, P ]iL2 = lim hA, [B, fβ,F (Hω )]iL2 β↑∞
= lim h[A, fβ,F (Hω )], BiL2 = 0 . β↑∞
Therefore, [A, P ] = 0. We are ready to prove Theorem 1.1. Proof of Theorem 1.1. By Lemma 3.2, we have σ2 (ω, F ) = lim ih(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω , ∂1 P iL2 . δ↓0
By Lemma 3.4, Proposition 2.5, and Lemma 3.6, ih(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω , ∂1 P iL2 = ih(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω , P (∂1 P )Q + Q(∂1 P )P iL2 = ihP {(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω }Q + Q{(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω }P, ∂1 P iL2 = ih(−iδ − LHω )−1 (P (∂1 Hω )Q + Q(∂1 Hω )P ), ∂1 P iL2 . As functions on Ω × Zd × Zd , we have (∂1 Hω )(ω ; x, y) = −(LHω (x1 ))(ω ; x, y). Together with Lemma 3.8, ih(−iδ − LHω )−1 (P (∂1 Hω )Q + Q(∂1 Hω )P ), ∂1 P iL2 = (−i)h(−iδ − LHω )−1 LHω (Qx1 P + P x1 Q), ∂1 P iL2 .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
403
By direct computation, [[x1 , P ], P ] ∈ D(LHω ), and Qx1 P + P x1 Q = [[x1 , P ], P ]. By Lemma 3.9 and (3.10), we compute ih(−iδ − LHω )−1 ∂1 Hω , ∂1 P iL2 = (−i)h(−iδ − LHω )−1 LHω ([[x1 , P ], P ]), ∂1 P iL2 → ih[[x1 , P ], P ], ∂1 P iL2 (δ ↓ 0) = ih[∂1 P, P ], ∂1 P iL2 = ih(∂1 P )P, ∂1 P iL2 − ihP (∂1 P ), ∂1 P iL2 . By Propositions 2.2 and 2.4, h(∂1 P )P, ∂1 P iL2 = −T (P (∂1 P )(∂1 P )) = −T ((∂1 P )P (∂1 P )) = hP (∂1 P ), (∂1 P )iL2 . Therefore, we proved σ2 (ω, F ) = 0, for a.e. ω. 4. Proof of Theorem 1.2 The following proposition is important to study E ↓ 0 limit in the proof of Theorem 1.2. Proposition 4.1. If A ∈ L2 satisfies A ∈ D(LHω ) , eitLHω A ∈ D(∂1 ) ,
(4.1) t ∈ R.
(4.2)
itLHω,E
and eitLHω Then, we have the following “Duhamel” formula for e Z t eitLHω,E A − eitLHω A = iE ds ei(t−s)LHω,E [x1 , eisLHω A] . 0
Proof. By (4.1), (4.2), eisLHω A ∈ D(LHω ), eisLHω A ∈ D(∂1 ). Thus eisLHω A ∈ D(LHω,E ), and e−isLHω,E eisLHω A is differentiable w.r.t. s. Z t d −isLHω,E isLHω (e ds e A) e−itLHω,E eitLHω A − A = ds 0 Z t ds e−isLHω,E ∂1 (eisLHω A) . = −iE 0
By multiplying e
itLHω,E
from the right on both sides, we arrive at the conclusion.
Lemma 4.1. (1) ∂1 Hω satisfies (4.1), (4.2), (2) [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )] satisfies (4.1), (4.2). To prove Lemma 4.1, we use the following estimate.
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
404
00121
F. Nakano
Theorem 4.1. ([2], Theorem 1.3) Let F be a function analytic and bounded on a strip Sη := {z ∈ C : |Im z| < η}. Then, √ (4.3) |F (Hω )(ω ; x, y)| ≤ 18 2kF k∞ e−µ|x−y| , P for any µ > 0 such that the inequality |x|=1 (eµ|x| − 1) ≤ η/2 holds, and kF k∞ := supz∈Sη |F (z)|. We will make use of the fact that the bound in (4.3) holds uniformly w.r.t. ω ∈ Ω. Proof of Lemma 4.1. (1) Since ∂1 Hω ∈ A0 , and Hω ∈ L2 , we have LHω (∂1 Hω ) ∈ L2 . Hence ∂1 Hω ∈ D(LHω ). By (4.3), for any fixed η > 0, we have √ (4.4) |eitHω (ω ; x, y)| ≤ 18 2eη|t| e−µ|x−y| , P where µ > 0 is taken such that |x|=1 (eµ|x| − 1) ≤ η2 . By (4.4) and the fact that ∂1 Hω ∈ A0 , we have 0
|eitLHω,E (∂1 Hω )(ω ; x, y)| = |(eitHω (∂1 Hω )e−itHω )(ω ; x, y)| ≤ Ct e−µ |x−y| , (4.5) for some constants Ct > 0, µ0 > 0, uniformly in (ω ; x, y) ∈ Ω × Zd × Zd . Ct is uniformly bounded w.r.t. t, if |t| ≤ T for some T > 0. Thus, [x1 , eitLHω (∂1 Hω )] ∈ A ⊂ L2 , because [x1 , (eitLHω (∂1 Hω ))](ω ; x, y) = (x1 − y1 )(eitLHω (∂1 Hω ))(ω ; x, y) decays exponentially by (4.5). Hence ∂1 Hω satisfies (4.1), (4.2). (2) Because [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )] ∈ A, and Hω ∈ L2 which follows from the assumption that E|Vω (0)|2 < ∞, we have LHω [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )] ∈ L2 , and therefore, [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )] ∈ D(LHω ). By (4.4), (eitHω )(ω ; x, y) decays exponentially as well as [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )](ω ; x, y), and so does (eitLHω [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )])(ω ; x, y). Hence eitLHω ([x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )]) ∈ D(∂1 ). Proof of Theorem 1.2. By the same argument as in the proof of Lemma 3.2, we have T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E P ) = −iheitLHω,E (∂1 Hω ), P iL2 . By Lemma 4.1, ∂1 Hω satisfies the condition to use Proposition 4.1. −iheitLHω,E (∂1 Hω ), P iL2 = −iheitLHω (∂1 Hω ), P iL2 Z t +E dshei(t−s)LHω,E [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )], P iL2 =: V + V I . 0
By Proposition 2.2, 2.4, and 2.8, V = −iheitHω (∂1 Hω )e−itHω , P iL2 = −iT (eitHω (∂1 Hω )e−itHω P ) = −iT ((∂1 Hω )P ) = 0 .
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
405
Therefore, 1 T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E P ) E Z t dshei(t−s)LHω,E [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )], P iL2 . = 0
By Lemma 4.1, we can use Proposition 4.1 for [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )]. Z t dshei(t−s)LHω,E [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )], P iL2 0
Z
t
dshei(t−s)LHω [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )], P iL2
= 0
Z
Z
t
+ iE
t−s
duhei(t−s−u)LHω,E [x1 , eiuLHω [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )]], P iL2 .
ds
0 0 [x1 , eiuHω,E [x1 , eisHω,E (∂1 Hω )]]
is uniformly bounded in L2 for s ∈ [0, t], By (4.4), u ∈ [0, t]. Therefore, for fixed t, the second term of RHS in the above expression goes to zero as E ↓ 0. Then, we compute, by using the fact that eitLHω P = P , and P ∈ D(∂1 ), Z t dshei(t−s)LHω,E [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )], P iL2 lim E↓0
0
Z
t
dshei(t−s)LHω [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )], P iL2
= 0
Z
t
dsh[x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )], P iL2
= 0
Z
t
dsheisLHω (∂1 Hω ), ∂1 P iL2 .
= 0
We proceed as in the proof of Theorem 1.1, using Lemmas 3.4 and 3.8, Z t dsheisLHω (∂1 Hω ), ∂1 P iL2 0
Z
t
dsheisLHω LHω ([[x1 , P ], P ]), ∂1 P iL2
= 0
Z
= −i
t
ds 0
d isLHω he ([[x1 , P ], P ]), ∂1 P iL2 ds
= −iheitLHω ([[x1 , P ], P ]), ∂1 P iL2 + ih[[x1 , P ], P ], ∂1 P iL2 . The second term in the above expression vanishes as we saw in the proof of Theorem 1.1. On the other hand, by spectral theorem, Z 1 T dt eitLHω → P{0} , T 0
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
406
00121
F. Nakano
strongly in L2 as T ↑ ∞, where P{0} is the orthogonal projection onto Ker(LHω ). Thus, by Lemma 3.10, Z 1 T dtheitLHω ([[x1 , P ], P ]), ∂1 P iL2 = 0 , lim T ↑∞ T 0 and we prove σ1 (ω, F ) = 0, for a.e. ω. Remark 4.1. If λ is sufficiently large, we have the following dynamical localization estimate E|eitHω (ω ; x, y)| ≤ Ce−µ|x−y| ,
(4.6)
for some constants C > 0, µ > R0, independent of t ∈ R, x, y ∈ Zd [1, 2, 4]. In ∞ this case, operations limE↓0 and 0 dt e−δt in the definition of σ2 (ω, F ) can be exchanged. In fact, we can show 1 T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E P ) = O(t) , E
(4.7)
as t ↑ ∞, uniformly in E. To show (4.7), we use Proposition 4.1, 1 T (eitHω,E i[Hω , x1 ]e−itHω,E P ) E Z t dshei(t−s)LHω,E [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )], P iL2 . = 0
(4.6) implies that [x1 , e
isLHω
(∂1 Hω )] is uniformly bounded in L2 . In fact,
|eisLHω (∂1 Hω )(ω ; x, y)|2 ≤ 2d|eisLHω (∂1 Hω )(ω ; x, y)| X |eisHω (ω ; x, z1 )||∂1 Hω (ω ; z1 , z2 )||e−isHω (ω ; z2 , y)| . (4.8) ≤ 2d z1 ,z2 ∈Zd
We used |(∂1 Hω )(ω ; x, y)| ≤ k∂1 Hω kop ≤ 2d. We take expectation, and use Schwarz inequality w.r.t. E. E(RHS of (4.8)) X (E|eisHω (ω ; x, z1 )|3 )1/3 ≤ 2d z1 ,z2 ∈Zd
× (E|∂1 Hω (ω ; z1 , z2 )|3 )1/3 (E|e−isHω (ω ; z2 , y)|3 )1/3 . By (4.6) and the fact that |eisHω (ω ; x, y)| ≤ keisHω kop = 1, we have E|eisLHω (∂1 Hω )(ω ; x, y)|2 ≤ Ce−µ|x−y| ,
x, y ∈ Zd ,
for some constants C > 0, µ > 0. Therefore, [x1 , eisLHω (∂1 Hω )] is uniformly bounded in L2 w.r.t. s ∈ R, and we conclude (4.7).
April 25, 2002 17:46 WSPC/148-RMP
00121
Absence of Transport in Anderson Localization
407
References [1] M. Aizenman, “Localization at weak disorder: some elementary bounds”, Rev. Math. Phys. 6 (1994) 1163–1182. [2] M. Aizenman and G. M. Graf, “Localization bounds for an electron gas”, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 31 (1998) 6783–6806. [3] M. Aizenman and S. Molchanov, “Localization at large disorder and at extreme energies: an elementary derivation”, Commun. Math. Phys. 157 (1993) 245–278. [4] M. Aizenman, J. Schenker, R. Friedrich and D. Hundertmark, “Finite-volume fractional moment criteria for Anderson localization”, Commun. Math. Phys. 224 (2001) 219–253. [5] P. W. Anderson, “Absence of diffusion in certain random lattices”, Phys. Rev. 109 (1958) 1492–1505. [6] J. E. Avron, R. Seiler and B. Simon, “Charge deficiency, charge transport and comparison of dimensions”, Commun. Math. Phys. 159 (1994) 399–422. [7] F. Bentosela, R. Carmona, P. Duclos, B. Simon, B. Souillard, and R. Weder, “Schr¨ odinger operators with an electric field and random or deterministic potentials”, Commun. Math. Phys. 88 (1983) 387–397. [8] J. Bellissard, A. van Elst and H. Schultz-Baldes, “The non-commutative geometry of the quantum Hall effect”, J. Math. Phys. 35(10) (1994) 5373–5451. [9] J. Fr¨ ohlich and T. Spencer, “Absence of diffusion in the Anderson tight binding model for large disorder or low energy”, Commun. Math. Phys. 88 (1983) 151–184. [10] H. Kunz and B. Souillard, “Sur le spectre les op´ erateurs aux diff´erences finies al´eatoires”, Commun. Math. Phys. 78 (1980) 201–246. [11] S. Nakamura, Lectures on Schr¨ odinger Operators, Lectures in Mathematical Sciences, University of Tokyo, 1994. [12] F. Nakano and M. Kaminaga, “Absence of transport under a slowly varying potential in disordered systems”, J. Stat. Phys. 97 (1999) 917–940. [13] H. Schultz-Baldes and J. Bellissard, “Anomalous transport: a mathematical framework”, Rev. Math. Phys. 10 (1998) 1–46. [14] H. Schultz-Baldes and J. Bellissard, “A kinetic theory for quantum transport in aperiodic media”, J. Stat. Phys. 91 (1998) 991–1026. [15] B. Simon and T. Spencer, “Trace class perturbations and the absence of absolutely continuous spectra”, Commun. Math. Phys. 125 (1989) 113–125. [16] H. von Dreifus and A. Krein, “A new proof of localization in the Anderson tight binding model”, Commun. Math. Phys. 124 (1989) 285–299.
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
00116
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 4 (2002) 409–420 c World Scientific Publishing Company
SOLITARY WAVES OF THE NONLINEAR KLEIN GORDON EQUATION COUPLED WITH THE MAXWELL EQUATIONS∗
VIERI BENCI Dipartimento di Matematica Applicata, Universit` a degli Studi di Pisa Via Bonanno, 25/b, 50126 PISA, Italy
[email protected] DONATO FORTUNATO Dipartimento Interuniversitario di Matematica, Universit` a degli Studi di Bari Via Orabona, 4, 70125 BARI, Italy
[email protected]
Received 9 February 2001 This paper is divided in two parts. In the first part we construct a model which describes solitary waves of the nonlinear Klein–Gordon equation interacting with the electromagnetic field. In the second part we study the electrostatic case. We prove the existence of infinitely many pairs (ψ, E), where ψ is a solitary wave for the nonlinear Klein–Gordon equation and E is the electric field related to ψ.
1. Introduction The existence of solitary waves for scalar fields in dimension 3 has been extensively studied by many authors (see e.g. [3, 8], and their references). The equation they have considered is a nonlinear perturbation of the Klein– Gordon equation. A typical simple case is the following one ∂2ψ − ∆ψ + m20 ψ − |ψ|p−2 ψ = 0 , ∂t2
(1)
where ψ = ψ(x, t) ∈ C (x ∈ R3 , t ∈ R), m0 is a real constant and p > 2. The solutions of (1) of the type ψ(x, t) = u(x)eiωt ,
u real function ,
ω∈R
(2)
are called standing waves. With this ansatz, Eq. (1) reduces to the following one −∆u + (m20 − ω 2 )u − |u|p−2 u = 0 . ∗ Supported
by M.U.R.S.T. (ex 40% and 60% funds). 409
(3)
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
410
00116
V. Benci & D. Fortunato
This equation is the Euler–Lagrange equation relative to the functional Z Z 1 1 2 2 2 2 [|∇u| + (m0 − ω )u ]dx − |u|p dx . f (u) = 2 p Exploiting the critical point theory for even functionals the following result can be obtained (see [8]). Theorem 1.1. If |ω| < |m0 | and 6 > p > 2, Eq. (3) has infinitely many solutions uk belonging to the Sobolev space H 1 (R3 ). By the Lorentz invariance of (1) the field ψv (x, t) = u(γ(x1 − vt), x2 , x3 )eiωγ(t−vx1 ) with |v| < 1 and γ = (1 − v 2 )− 2 is again a solution of (1) and we obtain a travelling solitary wave. In this paper we want to investigate about the existence of nonlinear Klein– Gordon fields interacting with the electromagnetic field (E, H). Since E, H are not assigned, we have to study a system of equations whose unknowns are the Klein–Gordon field ψ(x, t) and the gauge potentials A = A(x, t), φ = φ(x, t) related to the electromagnetic field. In order to construct such a system we shall describe, as usual, the interaction between ψ and E, H by using the so called gauge covariant derivatives (see Sec. 2). We shall investigate the case in which A and φ do not depend on the time t and ψ(x, t) is a standing wave (see Sec. 2). In this situation we can assume A = 0 and we are reduced to study the following system of equations 1
−∆u + [m20 − (ω + eφ)2 ]u − |u|p−2 u = 0
(4)
−∆φ + e u φ = −eωu
(5)
2 2
2
where e denotes the electric charge (4) and (5) are the Euler–Lagrange equations relative to the functional Z Z 1 1 {|∇u|2 − |∇φ|2 + [m20 − (ω + eφ)2 ]u2 }dx − |u|p dx . F (u, φ) = 2 p This functional is strongly indefinite. This means that it is unbounded both from below and from above and this indefinitess cannot be removed by compact perturbations. The main result of this paper is the following Theorem 1.2. If |ω| < |m0 | and 6 > p > 4, the system of Eqs. (4) and (5) has infinitely many solutions (u, φ)u ∈ H 1 (R3 ), φ ∈ L6 (R3 ) with |∇φ| ∈ L2 (R3 ). We recall that Maxwell equations coupled with Schr¨ odinger or Dirac equations have been studied respectively in [2, 4] and [5]. Moreover topological solitary waves interacting with electromagnetic fields have been studied in [7].
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
00116
Solitary Waves of the Nonlinear Klein–Gordon Equation
411
2. Deduction of the Equations The Lagrangian density relative to (1) is given by " # 2 1 ∂ψ 1 2 2 2 − |∇ψ| − m0 |ψ| + |ψ|p . L0 = 2 ∂t p
(6)
Assume that ψ is a charged field and let e denote the electric charge. By gauge invariance arguments, the interaction between ψ and the electromagnetic field is ∂ , ∇ with usually described (see e.g. [6]) substituting in (6) the usual derivatives ∂t the gauge covariant derivatives ∂ + ieφ , ∇ − ieA . ∂t Here A, φ are the gauge potentials which are related to the electromagnetic field E, H by the equations E = −∇φ − At ,
H = ∇× A.
Then we have the following Lagrangian density: " # 2 1 ∂ψ 1 2 2 2 + ieφψ − |∇ψ − ieAψ| − m0 |ψ| + |ψ|p . L0 = 2 ∂t p
(7)
(8)
If we set ψ(x, t) = u(x, t)eiS(x,t) ,
u, S ∈ R
the Lagrangian density (8) takes the following form: L0 =
1 2 1 {u − |∇u|2 − [|∇S − eA|2 − (St + eφ)2 + m20 ]u2 } + |u|p . 2 t p
(9)
Now we consider the lagrangian density of the electromagnetic field E, H 1 1 1 (|E|2 − |H|2 ) = |At + ∇φ|2 − |∇ × A|2 2 2 2 and so the total action is given by ZZ S= L0 + L1 . L1 =
Making the variation of S with respecto to δu, δS, δφ and δA respectively, we get u + [|∇S − eA|2 − (St + eφ)2 + m20 ]u − |u|p−2 u = 0 ,
(10)
∂ [(St + eφ)u2 ] − ∇ · [(∇S − eA)u2 ] = 0 , ∂t
(11)
∇ · (At + ∇φ) = e(St + eφ)u2 ,
(12)
∇ × (∇ × A) +
∂ (At + ∇φ) = e(∇S − eA)u2 . ∂t
(13)
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
412
00116
V. Benci & D. Fortunato
If we set ρ = e(St + eφ)u2 , j = e(∇S − eA)u2 , Eqs. (11)–(13) take the form ∂ ρ −∇· j = 0, ∂t
(14)
−∇ · E = ρ ,
(15)
∂E = j. ∂t We look for solutions of (10)–(13) of the type ∇×H−
u = u(x) ,
S = ωt ,
A = 0,
(16)
φ = φ(x)
with this ansatz, Eqs. (11) and (13) are identically satisfied, while (10) and (12) become −∆u + [m20 − (ω + eφ)2 ]u − |u|p−2 u = 0 ,
(17)
∆φ = e(ω + eφ)u2 .
(18)
Since e2 = 1, it is easy to see that in (17) and (18) we can take e = 1. So (17) and (18) become −∆u + [m20 − (ω + φ)2 ]u − |u|p−2 u = 0 ,
(19)
∆φ = (ω + φ)u2 .
(20)
3. The Variational Principle Now we want to find solutions u, φ of (19) and (20) with u ∈ H 1 (R3 ) ,
φ ∈ D.
Here H 1 (R3 ) is the usual Sobolev space with norm Z 12 2 2 (u + |∇u| )dx kukH 1 = R3
and D denotes the completion of C0∞ (R3 ) with respect to the inner product Z (∇v | ∇w)dx . (21) (v | w)D = R3
Consider the functional Z Z 1 1 {|∇u|2 − |∇φ|2 + [m20 − (ω + φ)2 ]u2 }dx − |u|p dx . F (u, φ) = 2 p The following proposition holds
(22)
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
00116
Solitary Waves of the Nonlinear Klein–Gordon Equation
413
Proposition 3.1. F is C 1 on H 1 (R3 ) × D and its critical points are the solutions of (19) and (20). Proof. Let Fu0 (u, φ), Fφ0 (u, φ) denote the partial derivatives of F at (u, φ) ∈ H 1 (R3 ) × D, namely for any v ∈ H 1 (R3 ) and w ∈ D Z 0 (23) Fu (u, φ)[v] = {(∇u | ∇v) + [m20 − (ω + φ)2 ]uv − |u|p−2 uv}dx , Fφ0 (u, φ)[w] = −
Z {(∇φ | ∇w) + (ω + φ)u2 w}dx .
(24)
By Sobolev inequalities H 1 (R3 ) and D are continuously embedded into L6 (R3 ), then standard computations show that Fu0 (respectively Fφ0 ) maps continuously H 1 (R3 )× D in H −1 (respectively D0 ). So we conclude that F is C 1 on H 1 (R3 )× D. Moreover Fu0 (u, φ) = 0 ,
Fφ0 (u, φ) = 0
amounts to say that (u, φ) is a weak solution of (19) and (20). The functional F is neither bounded from below nor from above and this indefinitess cannot be removed by a compact perturbation. For this reason the usual tools of the critical point theory cannot be used in a direct way. To avoid this difficulty we reduce the study of (22) to the study of a functional of the only variable u. We need some technical preliminaries. 3
Lemma 3.2. Let g ∈ L 2 (R3 ), g ≥ 0. Then the bilinear form on D defined by Z ag (v, w) = {(∇v | ∇w) + gvw}dx defines an inner product equivalent to the product (21). Proof. D is continuously embedded into L6 (R3 ), then for v, w ∈ D we have Z gvwdx ≤ kgk 32 kvkL6 kwkL6 ≤ ckvkD kwk , L
where c is a positive constant. Then the conclusion easily follows. Lemma 3.3. Let u ∈ H 1 (R3 ), then there exists a unique solution φ ∈ D of (20). Proof. Equation (20) can be written as follows −∆φ + u2 φ = −ωu2 .
(25)
Since H 1 (R3 ) is continuously embedded into L6 (R3 ), then clearly u2 ∈ L1 (R3 ) ∩ L3 (R3 ) ,
(26)
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
414
00116
V. Benci & D. Fortunato
and, by interpolation, we have 3
u2 ∈ L 2 (R3 ) . Then, by Lemma 3.2, we can consider the isomorphism Lu2 between D and D0 defined by Z hLu2 φ, vi = {(∇φ | ∇v) + u2 φv}dx , u, φ ∈ D . On the other hand, using again (26), we have 6
u2 ∈ L 5 (R3 ) Then, since L 5 (R3 ) is continuously embedded into D0 , we have also 6
u2 ∈ D 0 . So there exists a unique φ ∈ D such that Lu2 φ = −ωu2 . This φ clearly solves (25). By Lemma 3.3 we can define the map Φ : H 1 (R3 ) → D
(27)
such that for all u ∈ H 1 (R3 ) Φ(u) = φ is the unique solution of (25) namely 2 Φ(u) = −ωL−1 u2 (u ) .
The following lemma holds Lemma 3.4. The map Φ is C 1 and its graph GΦ is given by GΦ = {(u, φ) ∈ H 1 (R3 ) × D | Fφ0 (u, φ) = 0} . Proof. The proof of the first part can be easily achieved by standard arguments. The second part follows immediately from the definition of Φ. Now for u ∈ H 1 (R3 ) Φ(u) solves (25), then −∆Φ(u) + u2 Φ(u) = −ωu2 , from which, taking the product with Φ(u), we have Z Z Z 2 2 − ωu Φ(u)dx = |∇Φ(u)| dx + u2 Φ(u)2 dx .
(28)
Now we set J(u) = F (u, Φ(u)) . By Lemmas 3.1 and 3.4, J is C 1 .
(29)
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
00116
Solitary Waves of the Nonlinear Klein–Gordon Equation
415
Using (22), we have Z 1 (|∇u|2 − |∇Φ(u)|2 )dx J(u) = 2 Z Z 1 1 [m20 − (ω + Φ(u))2 ]u2 dx − |u|p dx + 2 p Z 1 (|∇u|2 − |∇Φ(u)|2 + (m20 − ω 2 )u2 − u2 Φ(u)2 )dx = 2 Z Z 1 2 |u|p dx . − ωu Φ(u)dx − p Then, inserting (28), we get Z Z 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 (|∇u| + |∇Φ(u)| + u Φ(u) + (m0 − ω )u )dx − |u|p dx . J(u) = 2 p The following proposition holds.
(30)
Proposition 3.5. Let (u, φ) ∈ H 1 (R3 ) × D. Then the following statements are equivalent : (a) (u, φ) is a critical point of F ; (b) u is a critical point of J and φ = Φ(u). Proof. By (29) and Lemma 3.4, clearly we have (b) ⇔ (Fu0 (u, φ) + Fφ0 (u, φ)Φ0 (u) = 0 and φ = Φ(u)) ⇔ (Fu0 (u, φ) = 0 and Fφ0 (u, φ) = 0) ⇔ (a) . 4. Proof of the Main Result Clearly, by Proposition 3.5, Theorem 1.2 is a consequence of the following result. Proposition 4.1. If |ω| < |m0 | and 6 > p > 4, the functional J possesses infinitely many critical points u ∈ H 1 (R3 ). Since J is invariant under the group transformations u(x) → u(x + a)(a ∈ R3 ), there is a clear lack of compactness. To overcome this difficulty we restrict ourselves to radial functions u = u(r), r = |x|. More precisely we shall consider the functional J on the subspace Hr1 = {u ∈ H 1 (R3 ) : u = u(r), r = |x|} . We recall (see [8] or [3]) that, for 6 > p > 2, Hr1 is compactly embedded into Lpr , where Lpr = {u ∈ Lp (R3 ) : u radially symmetric}. As a consequence, the restriction J|Hr1 does not exhibits the strong indefinitess of the functional F . In fact J|Hr1 is bounded from below modulo the compact perturbation Z 1 |u|p dx . u→ p
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
416
00116
V. Benci & D. Fortunato
Moreover, unlike the functional F , J|Hr1 is even, and we shall exploit this symmetry property to obtain the multiplicity result. Now Hr1 is a natural constraint for J, namely the following lemma holds. Lemma 4.2. Any critical point u ∈ Hr1 of J|Hr1 is also a critical point of J. Proof. Consider the O(3) group action Tg on H 1 (R3 ) defined by for g ∈ O(3) ,
u ∈ H 1 (R3 ) : Tg u(x) = u(g(x)) .
Clearly Hr1 is the set of the fixed points for this action namely Hr1 = {u ∈ H 1 (R3 ) | Tg u = u for all g ∈ O(3)} . Then the conclusion can be achieved by usual arguments (see [8]), if we show that J is invariant under the Tg action, namely if for any u ∈ H 1 (R3 ) ,
g ∈ O(3) J(Tg u) = J(u) .
(31)
Now, for u ∈ H (R ), Φ(u) solves the equation 1
3
−∆Φ(u) + u2 Φ(u) = −ωu2 , then, if g ∈ O(3), we have Tg (−∆Φ(u) + u2 Φ(u)) = −ωTg u2 , −∆(Tg Φ(u)) + (Tg u)2 (Tg Φ(u))) = −ω(Tg u)2 . This equality and the definition of Φ imply that Tg Φ(u) = Φ(Tg u) .
(32)
Therefore, using (32) and the Tg invariance of the norms in H 1 (R3 ), D, Lp , we easily deduce (31). In order to prove Proposition 4.1 we need to prove the following compactness result Lemma 4.3. Let the assumptions of Proposition 4.1 be satisfied. Then the functional J|Hr1 satisfies the Palais–Smale condition, i.e. Any sequence {un } ⊂ Hr1 s.t. {J(un )} is bounded and J|0Hr1 (un ) → 0 contains a convergent subsequence .
(33)
Proof. Let {un } ⊂ Hr1 , s.t. J(un ) = Mn bounded , J|0Hr1 (un ) = εn , where εn → 0 in the dual (Hr1 )0 = Hr−1 .
(34) (35)
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
00116
Solitary Waves of the Nonlinear Klein–Gordon Equation
417
Then, if we set φn = Φ(un ), (35) can be written (see Proposition 3.5) as follows Fu0 (un , φn ) + Fφ0 (un , φn )Φ0 (un ) = εn . Since Fφ0 (un , φn ) = 0, we have Fu0 (un , φn ) = εn .
(36)
1 1 0 hF (un , φn ), un i = hεn , un i p u p
(37)
So
where h, i denotes the pairing between Hr1 and its dual. By (5) Fu0 (un , φn ) = −∆un + [m20 − (ω + φn )2 ]un − |un |p−2 un . Using this equality, the left hand side in (37) can be easily calculated. So, subtracting (37) from (34), we get Z 1 (38) (c1 |∇un |2 + c2 |un |2 )dx + An = Mn − hεn , un i , p where c1 = and
Z An =
1 1 − > 0, 2 p 1 |∇φn |2 + 2
m0 − ω 2 m0 − ω 2 − >0 2 p
c2 =
1 1 + 2 p
2 (un φn )2 + ωu2n φn dx . p
(39)
Now (see (20)) φn satisfies the equation ∆φn = (ω + φn )u2n , then
Z h∆φn , φn i =
from which we get Z
(ω + φn )u2 φn dx ,
Z ωu2n φn dx
=−
(|∇φn |2 + (un φn )2 )dx .
(40)
Since p > 4, from (39) and (40) we deduce that there exists a constant c3 > 0, s.t. Z 2 2 (41) An ≥ c3 (|∇φn | + (un φn ) )dx . Finally from (38) and (41) we deduce that {(un , φn )} is bounded in Hr1 × D , then, up to a subsequence,
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
418
00116
V. Benci & D. Fortunato
un * u (weakly in Hr1 ) , φn * φ (weakly in D) . Next we show that un → u (strongly in Hr1 ) .
(42)
First by (36) we have −∆un + (m20 − ω 2 )un = φ2n un + 2ωφn un + |un |p−2 un + εn . Thus, if we denote by L the isomorphysm between Hr1 and its dual defined by Lu = −∆u + (m20 − ω 2 )u , we get un = L−1 (φ2n un + 2ωφn un ) + L−1 (|un |p−2 un ) + L−1 (εn ) .
(43)
Since Hr1 is compactly embedded into Lpr (see [8] or [3]), standard arguments show that L−1 (|un |p−2 un ) strongly converges in Hr1 . Also L−1 (εn ) strongly converges in Hr1 , then (42) will be a consequence of (43) if we show that also L−1 (φ2n un + 2ωφn un ) strongly converges in Hr1 ,
(44) 3
where Hr1 is compactly embedded into L3r . Then, by duality, Lr2 is compactly embedded into (Hr1 )0 . As a consequence, in order to prove (44), it is enough to show that 3
φ2n un and φn un are bounded in Lr2 .
(45)
Since φn is bounded in D and un is bounded in Hr1 , by Sobolev embedding theorems, we deduce that φn is bounded in L6 , and un is bounded in L6 ∩ L2 ⊂ L3 . Moreover, by H¨ older inequalities, we have 3
3
kφ2n un k 2 3 ≤ kφn k3L6 kun kL2 3 , L2
and kφn un k from which we deduce (45).
3
L2
≤ kφn kL6 kun kL2 ,
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
00116
Solitary Waves of the Nonlinear Klein–Gordon Equation
419
Now we are ready to prove Proposition 4.1 By Lemma 4.2 it is enough to show that J|Hr1 has infinitely many critical points. Since J|Hr1 is even, we shall use an equivariant version of the mountain pass theorem (see [1, Theorem 2.13]). Clearly from (30) we have J(u) ≥ c1 kuk2H 1 − c2 kukpLp ,
u ∈ Hr1 .
(46)
Here and in the sequel c1 , c2 , . . . denote positive constants. Since Hr1 is continuously embedded in Lp , we easily deduce from (46) that there exists α, ρ > 0 such that J(u) ≥ α for u ∈ Hr1 ,
kukH 1 = ρ .
(47)
Now let V be an m-dimensional (m positive integer) subspace of Hr1 . We need only to show that J(u) → −∞ as kuk → ∞ ,
u∈V .
(48)
In fact, since J|Hr1 satisfies the Palais–Smale condition (see Lemma 4.3) and the geometrical assumptions (47) and (48), we can use [1, Theorem 2.13] to conclude that there exist at least m distinct pairs of critical points of J|Hr1 . Since m is arbitrary, we obtain the existence of infinitely many pairs of critical points. Therefore we are left to prove (48). Clearly, if we set φ = Φ(u), from (30) we have 1 1 J(u) ≤ c3 kuk2H 1 + (k∇φk2L2 + kuφk2L2 ) − kukpLp , 2 p
u ∈ Hr1 .
(49)
Since φ satisfies (20), we have h∆φ, φi = h(ω + φ)u2 , φi . Then
Z k∇φk2L2
+
kuφk2L2
=−
ωu2 φdx .
By Sobolev and H¨older inequalities we deduce that Z ωu2 φdx ≤ c4 kuk2 12 kφkL6 ≤ c5 kuk2 12 k∇φkL2 . L
L
5
5
(50)
(51)
Then (50) and (51) give k∇φk2L2 + kuφk2L2 ≤ c5 kuk2 12 k∇φkL2 ,
(52)
k∇φkL2 ≤ c5 kuk2 12 .
(53)
L
5
which implies L
5
From (52) and (53), we have k∇φk2L2 + kuφk2L2 ≤ c25 kuk4 12 . L
5
(54)
April 26, 2002 9:13 WSPC/148-RMP
420
00116
V. Benci & D. Fortunato
Finally (54) and (49) imply 1 J(u) ≤ c3 kuk2H 1 + c6 kuk4 12 − kukpLp . L5 p Then, since p > 4 and V is finite dimensional, (48) easily follows. References [1] A. Ambrosetti and P. H. Rabinowitz, “Dual variational methods in critical point theory and applications”, J. Funct. Anal. 14 (1973) 349–381. [2] V. Benci and D. Fortunato, “An eigenvalue problem for the Schroedinger–Maxwell equations”, Topol. Methods Nonlinear Anal. 11 (1998) 283–293. [3] H. Berestycki and P. L. Lions, “Nonlinear scalar field equations I and II”, Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 82 (1983) 313–345 and 347–375. [4] G. M. Coclite, “Metodi Variazionali applicati allo studio delle equazioni di Schr¨ odinger–Maxwell”, Thesis, University of Bari, 1999. [5] M. J. Esteban, V. Georgiev and E. Sere, “Stationary solutions of the Maxwell–Dirac and the Klein–Gordon–Dirac equations”, Calc. Var. 4, 265–281. [6] B. Felsager, Geometry, Particle and fields, Odense University Press, 1981. [7] V. Benci, D. Fortunato, A. Masiello and L. Pisani, “Solitons and electromagnetic field”, Math. Z. 232 (1999) 73–102. [8] W. Strauss, “Existence of solitary waves in higher dimensions”, Comm. Math. Phys. 55 (1977) 149–162.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 5 (2002) 421–467 c World Scientific Publishing Company
¨ SCHRODINGER OPERATORS ON HOMOGENEOUS METRIC TREES: SPECTRUM IN GAPS
ALEXANDER V. SOBOLEV Centre for Mathematical Analysis and Its Applications University of Sussex, Falmer, Brighton BN1 9QH, UK
[email protected] MICHAEL SOLOMYAK Department of Mathematics, Weizmann Institute, Rehovot, Israel
[email protected]
Received 2 August 2001 Revised 5 February 2002 The paper studies the spectral properties of the Schr¨ odinger operator AgV = A0 + gV on a homogeneous rooted metric tree, with a decaying real-valued potential V and a coupling constant g ≥ 0. The spectrum of the free Laplacian A0 = −∆ has a band-gap structure with a single eigenvalue of infinite multiplicity in the middle of each finite gap. The perturbation gV gives rise to extra eigenvalues in the gaps. These eigenvalues are monotone functions of g if the potential V has a fixed sign. Assuming that the latter condition is satisfied and that V is symmetric, i.e. depends on the distance to the root of the tree, we carry out a detailed asymptotic analysis of the counting function of the discrete eigenvalues in the limit g → ∞. Depending on the sign and decay of V , this asymptotics is either of the Weyl type or is completely determined by the behaviour of V at infinity.
1. Introduction Counting the number of eigenvalues of a perturbed operator, appearing in the spectral gaps of the unperturbed one, is a classical problem. It was extensively investigated both in the general operator-theoretic setting [3] and in applications to various specific problems of mathematical physics (the Hill operator, [14, 21]; the Dirac operator, [16, 5]; the periodic Schr¨odinger and magnetic Schr¨ odinger operators, [1, 11]; waveguide-type operators, [10], etc.) In this paper we study a new problem of this type, which only recently attracted the attention of specialists: our unperturbed operator is the Laplacian on a homogeneous rooted metric tree Γ. In general, a metric tree is a tree whose edges are viewed as non-degenerate line segments, rather than pairs of vertices, as in the case of the standard (combinatorial) trees. This difference is reflected in the nature of the corresponding Laplacian. For a combinatorial tree this is the discrete Laplacian, whereas the Laplacian A0 = −∆ 421
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
422
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
on a metric tree is represented by a family of the operators −d2 /dx2 on its edges, complemented by the Kirchhoff matching conditions at the vertices. The Laplacian on the homogeneous metric tree has very specific spectral properties which we describe later on in detail. In particular, the spectrum has the band-gap structure, with a single eigenvalue of infinite multiplicity in each finite gap. For some other operators on a homogeneous tree, having similar nature, the band-gap structure of the spectrum was established earlier by R. Carlson [12]. In the present paper we study the properties of the perturbed operator AgV = A0 + gV where V is a decaying real-valued potential, and g ≥ 0 is a coupling constant. The potential V is assumed to be symmetric, i.e. dependent only on the distance |x| between x ∈ Γ and the root of Γ. This perturbation may produce extra eigenvalues in the gaps of A0 . For an “observation point” λ inside a gap we denote by M (λ; AgV ) the number of the eigenvalues of the operator AαV , crossing λ as α varies from 0 to g. For any two points λ1 , λ2 , λ1 < λ2 lying in the same gap, we denote by N (λ1 , λ2 ; AgV ) the number of eigenvalues of this operator on the interval (λ1 , λ2 ); see Sec. 4 for more precise definitions. We are interested in the limiting behaviour of these quantities as the coupling constant g tends to infinity. Compared with other problems of this type, mentioned in the beginning of the Introduction, this problem has many new important features. The starting point of our investigation is a direct decomposition of the Sobolev space H1,0 (Γ) on the homogeneous tree Γ. This R decomposition is orthogonal with R respect to the inner products Γ u0 v 0 dx and Γ V (x)u¯ v dx for all symmetric weight functions V simultaneously. Therefore, it reduces the Laplacian and any Schr¨odinger operator AV with a symmetric potential V . This decomposition was constructed in the paper [18] and has proved very useful for spectral theory of this class of operators. Later it was re-discovered by R. Carlson [13]. For the spectral analysis of the discrete Laplacian on combinatorial trees a similar decomposition was used before, see e.g. [20, 2] and references therein. The parts of the operator AV in each component of the said orthogonal decomposition turn out to be unitary equivalent to second order differential operators AVk , k = 0, 1, . . . of the Sturm–Liouville type in the space L2 (R+ ). The potentials Vk are obtained from the original potential V by “shifting” the variable: Vk (t) = V (t + k), k = 0, 1, . . . . The operators AVk act as −d2 /dx2 +Vk , but in contrast to the standard Sturm–Liouville problem, the description of the operator domain of AVk involves specific matching conditions at the points tn = n, n = 1, 2 . . . (see Sec. 2). Each component AVk , k ≥ 1, enters AV with the multiplicity n0 = 1 ,
nk = bk − bk−1 ,
k ≥ 1.
Here b ≥ 2 is the integer-valued parameter (the branching number) which characterizes the homogeneous tree completely, see the definition in Sec. 2.1. The above orthogonal decomposition plays a central role in our approach. First of all, it allows us to calculate the spectrum of A0 explicitly (see Theorem 3.3): it
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
423
consists of the bands [(π(l − 1) + θ)2 , (πl − θ)2 ], θ = arccos(2(b1/2 + b−1/2 )−1 ), and the eigenvalues λl = (πl)2 , l ∈ N. Besides, for V = 0 all the components AVk = A0 are identical, so that the spectrum is of infinite multiplicity. For the perturbed operator this decomposition leads to the representation X M (λ; AgV ) = nk M (λ; AgVk ) . (1.1) k≥0
A similar formula also holds for N (λ1 , λ2 ; AgV ). The presence of the exponentially growing factors nk hampers the study of these sums. Remembering that the numbers nk reflect the geometry of the tree, rather than the properties of the potential ˜ and N ˜ ignoring the exponential multiV , we also study the counting functions M plicities nk . Precisely, we introduce X ˜ (λ; AgV ) = M M (λ; AgVk ) , (1.2) k≥0
˜ defined in a similar way. and the quantity N ˜,N ˜ reduces to that of the inClearly, the study of the four functions M, N, M dividual counting functions M (λ; AgVk ), N (λ1 , λ2 ; AgVk ) for the operators AVk . A similar problem for the classical Hill operator was investigated in [14] and, in a more detailed way, in [21]. The general strategy adopted in [21] applies to the operators AgVk with only minor changes. However, here a new problem emerges: in order to obtain the asymptotic formulas for the sums (1.1), (1.2) one needs an asymptotics of M (λ; AgVk ) jointly in two parameters: g and k, with a good control of the remainder estimate. In solving this new problem we see the main technical novelty of the paper. In the paper we obtain several results of rather different type. In this introduction we do not describe them in detail, but concentrate on their principal features. More extended comments are given in the main text. Also, for the sake of discussion ˜ (λ; AgV ) only. we restrict ourselves to the functions M (λ; AV ) and M First of all, as in the case of the “classical” Hill operator problem (see [21]), we ˜ is in general radically different for non-positive observe that the behaviour of M, M and non-negative potentials. More precisely, if V ≤ 0 decays sufficiently quickly at infinity, then the asymptotics is governed by an appropriate Weyl-type formula, and thus it depends on the values of V (t) at all points t ∈ R, and contains no information on the spectrum of the unperturbed operator. On the contrary, for a non-negative V the asymptotics is determined by the fall-off of V at infinity, and as a rule, depends heavily on some spectral characteristic of the operator A0 . For ˜ instance, the behaviour of M(λ) for V ≥ 0 is described by an integral of the density of states for A0 . Similar asymptotics is also observed for the potentials V ≤ 0 whose decay at infinity is slow in some specified sense. In accordance with this general observation our study of the asymptotics is divided in several parts. We begin in Sec. 4 by specifying the conditions on a non-positive symmetric potential V that guarantee the validity of the Weyl-type
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
424
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
asymptotics. Further on, we proceed to the cases when the Weyl formula fails and the asymptotics is determined by the behaviour of V at infinity. Here we investigate two types of potentials: power-like and exponentially decaying. In Sec. 5 we state ˜ , N. ˜ A common feature of the asymptotic formulae the results for the functions M in Sec. 5 is that virtually all of them contain the density of states for the operator A0 . It is also worth pointing out that the power-like potentials induce a power˜ as g → ∞, whereas the exponential potentials give rise to a like growth of M logarithmic growth. The study of the sum (1.1) is postponed until Sec. 9 as it calls for different techniques and is less complete. For the power-like potentials we are able to establish the asymptotics only for the quantity ln M (λ). For the exponential potentials we provide more detailed asymptotic information. This is possible due to the “self-similarity” of the exponential function. This property allows us to rewrite the formula (1.1) for the function M (λ, AgV ) in a form which can be interpreted as a Renewal Equation (see [15, 17]). Then the Renewal theorem ensures a specific asymptotic behaviour of M (λ). Let us briefly outline the contents of the remaining sections. In Sec. 2 we describe the basic orthogonal decomposition of the space H1,0 (Γ) and also the parts of the operator AV in its components. In Sec. 3 we calculate the spectrum of the Laplacian on Γ. Here we also carry out a detailed analysis of the density of states for the ˜ in the operator A0 . This function is involved in the asymptotic formulae for M non-Weyl situation. As was mentioned earlier, the study of the perturbed operator AV starts in Sec. 4 where the Weyl’s asymptotics is established. The main results ˜ and N ˜ are collected in Sec. 5. on the non-Weyl asymptotics for the functions M Their proofs are given in Sec. 8, preceded by necessary technical preliminaries in Secs. 6, 7. The last section, Sec. 9, is devoted to the analysis of the functions M, N. 2. Laplacian on a Homogeneous Tree and Its Decomposition 2.1. Homogeneous trees and Laplacians on them Let Γ be a rooted tree with the root o, the set of vertices V(Γ) and the set of edges E(Γ). We suppose that the length of each edge e is equal to 1. Given two points y, z ∈ Γ, we write y z if y lies on the unique simple path connecting o with z; let |z| stand for the length of this path. We write y ≺ z if y z and y 6= z. The relation ≺ defines on Γ a partial ordering. If y ≺ z, we denote hy, zi := {x ∈ Γ : y x z} . In particular, if e = hv, wi is an edge, we call v its initial point and say that e emanates from v and terminates at w. For any v ∈ V(Γ) the number |v| is a non-negative integer; we call it generation of v and denote Gen(v). For an edge e ∈ E(Γ) Gen(e) is defined as the generation of its initial point.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
425
Let an integer b > 1 be given. We suppose that for each vertex v 6= o there are exactly b edges emanating from v. We denote them e1v , . . . , ebv and write e− v for the edge terminating at v. We call b the branching number of Γ. We always suppose that only one edge emanates from the root o. Thus, the tree Γ is fully determined by the parameter b, and sometimes we use the notation Γb . We call any tree Γb , with an arbitrary b, homogeneous. The metric topology and the Lebesgue measure on Γ are introduced in a natural way. The space L2 (Γ) is understood as L2 with respect to this measure. A function f on Γ belongs to the Sobolev space H1 (Γ) if and only if it is continuous, f e ∈ H1 (e) for each edge e, and Z kf k2H1(Γ) := (|f 0 |2 + |f |2 )dx < ∞ . Γ
As usual, H1,0 (Γ) = {f ∈ H1 (Γ) : f (o) = 0}. We define the Dirichlet Laplacian −∆ Ron Γ as the self-adjoint operator in 2 L (Γ), associated with the quadratic form Γ |f 0 |2 dx considered on the form domain H1,0 (Γ). It is easy to describe the operator domain Dom(∆) and the action of ∆. Evidently f ∈ Dom(∆) ⇒ f e ∈ H2 (e) for each edge e and the Euler–Lagrange equation reduces on e to ∆f = f 00 . In order to describe the matching conditions at a vertex v 6= o, denote by f− the restriction f e− v and by fj , j = 1, . . . , b the restrictions f ejv . The matching conditions at v are f− (v) = f1 (v) = · · · = fb (v) ;
0 f10 (v) + · · · + fb0 (v) = f− (v)
where the derivatives on each edge are taken in the direction consistent with the ordering on Γ. The first matching condition comes from the requirement f ∈ H1 (Γ) which includes the continuity of f , and the second appears as the natural condition in the sense of calculus of variations. At the root o we have the boundary condition f (o) = 0. It is easy to check that the conditions listed are also sufficient for f ∈ Dom(∆). Along with the Laplacian −∆ we shall be interested also in the Schr¨ odinger operators with a real, bounded and symmetric (that is, depending only on |x|) potential V : AV f := −∆f + V (|x|)f ,
f ∈ Dom(∆) .
(2.1)
The operator AV is self-adjoint. Its quadratic form is given by Z aV [f ] = (|f 0 |2 + V (|x|)|f |2 )dx , f ∈ H1,0 (Γ) . Γ
2.2. The orthogonal decomposition of L2 (Γ) Our techniques is based upon the orthogonal decomposition of L2 (Γ) into a family of subspaces associated with a class of subtrees of Γ. Given a subtree T ⊂ Γ, we say that a function f ∈ L2 (Γ) belongs to FT if and only if f = 0 outside T
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
426
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
and f (x) = f (y) if x, y ∈ T
and |x| = |y| .
(2.2)
Evidently FT is a closed subspace of L2 (Γ). It is easy to describe the operator PT of orthoprojection onto FT . To this end, introduce the function bT (t) = #{x ∈ T : |x| = t} . In particular, bΓ (t) = bk It is clear that (PT f )(x) =
for k − 1 ≤ t < k ,
(bΓ (|x|))−1
X
k ∈ N.
f (y)
(2.3)
for x ∈ T ;
y∈T :|y|=|x|
for x ∈ /T.
0
We shall need the subspaces FT , associated with the subtrees of two following types. Given a vertex v, let Tv = {x ∈ Γ : x v} . Given an edge e = hv, wi, let Te = e ∪ Tw . In particular, Te0 = To = Γ. For the sake of brevity, for any v 6= o below we use the notation Fv , Fvj for FTv , FT j . It is clear that the subspaces Fv1 , . . . , Fvb are ev mutually orthogonal and their orthogonal sum F˜v = Fv1 ⊕ · · · ⊕ Fvb contains Fv . Denote by Fv0 = F˜v Fv the orthogonal complement. The next theorem is a direct consequence of [18, Theorem 5.1 and Lemma 5.2], where a more general class of trees was considered. Later the result was re-discovered by R. Carlson [13], in a slightly different setting. A new detailed exposition, most convenient for our purposes, was recently given in [19]. Theorem 2.1. Let Γ = Γb for some b > 1. (i) The subspaces Fv0 , o 6= v ∈ V(Γ) are mutually orthogonal and orthogonal to FΓ . Moreover, X L2 (Γ) = FΓ ⊕ ⊕Fv0 . (2.4) v∈V(Γ)\{o}
(ii) Let V (t) be a real, measurable and bounded function on R+ . Then the decomposition (2.4) reduces the Schr¨ odinger operator (2.1), and in particular the Laplacian −∆ = A0 .
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
427
2.3. Parts of AV in the subspaces FΓ , Fv0 According to Theorem 2.1, the description of the spectrum σ(AV ) reduces to the similar problem for the parts of AV in the components of the decomposition (2.4). Consider at first the part of AV in the subspace FΓ . It is more convenient (and equivalent) to deal with the quadratic form aV . It is natural to identify a function f ∈ FΓ with the function ϕ on R+ , such that ϕ(t) = f (x) for |x| = t. The operator Π : f 7→ ϕ acts as an isometry of FΓ onto the weighted space L2 (R+ , bΓ ) with the norm given by Z 2 kϕkL2 (R+ ,bΓ ) = |ϕ(t)|2 bΓ (t)dt . R+
Then
Z aV [f ] =
R+
(|ϕ0 (t)|2 + V (t)|ϕ(t)|2 )bΓ (t)dt ,
ϕ = Πf .
(2.5)
Its domain is the weighted Sobolev space H1,0 (R+ , bΓ ) whose norm is defined by the quadratic form (2.5) with V ≡ 1. The corresponding operator AV FΓ turns into an operator acting in L2 (R+ , bΓ ). It is not difficult to describe it explicitly, however it is more natural to pass on to the operators acting in the “usual” L2 (R+ ). To this end we make the substitution y(t) = bΓ (t)1/2 ϕ(t) .
(2.6)
Then kyk2L2 (R+ ) = kϕk2L2 (R+ ,bΓ ) . Since bΓ (t) is a step function, we also have Z (|y 0 (t)|2 + V (t)|y(t)|2 )dt . aV [y] := aV [f ] = R+
However, the domain of aV does not coincide with H1,0 (R+ ), since the function y(t) may have jumps at the points n ∈ N. More exactly, it follows from (2.3) and (2.6) that Dom(aV ) consists of functions y ∈ H1 (0, 1) × H1 (1, 2) × · · · × H1 (n − 1, n) × · · ·
(2.7)
such that y(0) = 0 ; and
Z R+
y(n+) = b1/2 y(n−) ,
∀n ∈ N,
(|y 0 (t)|2 + |y(t)|2 )dt < ∞ .
(2.8)
(2.9)
The self-adjoint operator in L2 (R+ ), associated with this quadratic form, on each interval (n − 1, n), n ∈ N acts as AV y = −y 00 + V (t)y .
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
428
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Its domain Dom(AV ) consists of all functions y ∈ H2 (0, 1) × H2 (1, 2) × · · · × H2 (n − 1, n) × · · · satisfying the conditions (2.8) and y 0 (n+) = b−1/2 y 0 (n−) , and also
Z R+
∀n ∈ N,
(2.10)
(|y 00 (t)|2 + |y(t)|2 )dt < ∞ .
(Here and in (2.9) it would be more accurate to write So we have proved the following
P∞ R n n=1 n−1
rather than
R R+
.)
Lemma 2.2. The part of the operator AV in the subspace FΓ is unitarily equivalent to the operator AV in L2 (R+ ). Now we turn to the operators AV Fv0 , v 6= o. It follows from the symmetry properties of the tree Γ and of the potential V (|x|) that all such operators with the same value of Gen(v) = k can be identified with each other. In order to reduce them to the operators in L2 (R+ ), introduce the “shifted” potentials Vk (t) = V (t + k) ,
t > 0,
k = 0, 1, . . . .
(2.11)
In particular, V0 = V . Lemma 2.3. Let Γ = Γb and v ∈ V(Γ), Gen(v) = k > 0. Then the operator AV Fv0 is unitarily equivalent to the orthogonal sum of (b − 1) copies of the operator AVk . For the formal proof, see [19]. On the qualitative level, the result follows from the fact that the restriction of the operator AV to the subspace F˜v reduces to orthogonal sum of b copies of the operator AVk . The passage to the subspace Fv0 corresponds to the withdrawal of one of these copies. 2.4. The orthogonal decomposition of the operators AV Now we are in position to present the final result of this section. Below A[r] stands for the orthogonal sum of r copies of a self-adjoint operator A. Theorem 2.4. Let Γ = Γb and the function V be real, measurable and bounded on R+ . Then the Schr¨ odinger operator (2.1) on Γ is unitarily equivalent to the orthogonal sum of the operators acting in L2 (R+ ): X [bk−1 (b−1)] AV ∼ AV ⊕ ⊕AVk . k∈N
In particular, for the Laplacian −∆ = A0 we get −∆ ∼ A0 [∞] . This theorem is a direct consequence of Theorem 2.1 and Lemmas 2.2, 2.3, if one remembers that the total number of vertices of generation k equals bk−1 .
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
429
3. Spectrum of the Laplacian on Γb 3.1. The operator A on the whole line Along with the operator A0 in L2 (R+ ) defined as A0 y = −y 00 with the boundary and matching conditions (2.8) and (2.10), consider the similar operator, say A, in L2 (R): (Ay)(t) = −y 00 (t) ,
t 6∈ Z ,
on the analogous domain supplied with the matching conditions y(n+) = b1/2 y(n−) ,
y 0 (n+) = b−1/2 y 0 (n−) ,
n ∈ Z.
(3.1)
The spectrum of A can be found by means of the standard Floquet procedure. The related quasi-periodic problem is y 00 + µ2 y = 0 ,
y(1+) = eiξ y(0+) ,
y 0 (1+) = eiξ y 0 (0+) ,
with the parameter (quasi-momentum) ξ ∈ [0, 2π). Taking into account the matching conditions at the point n = 1, we can re-write this as y 00 (t) + µ2 y(t) = 0 , y(1−) = b−1/2 eiξ y(0+) ,
0 < t < 1;
y 0 (1−) = b1/2 eiξ y 0 (0+) .
(3.2)
It is quite straightforward to calculate the eigenvalues of the problem (3.2). Introduce the function cos ξ b1/2 + b−1/2 ϕ(ξ) = arccos , R= > 1. (3.3) R 2 Then the numbers µl (square roots of eigenvalues) are given by ( π(l − 1) + ϕ(ξ) , l is odd , µl (ξ) = l ∈ N. (3.4) πl − ϕ(ξ) , l is even , The function ϕ is one-to-one on the interval [0, π]. Later we shall also need its inverse: ψ(µ) = arccos(R cos µ) ,
µ ∈ [ϕ(0), ϕ(π)] = [θ, π − θ] .
(3.5)
where θ = arccos(1/R) . It follows easily from (3.3) that ψ(µ) = 21/2 (R2 − 1)1/4 (µ − θ)1/2 + O(µ − θ) , ψ(µ) = π − 21/2 (R2 − 1)1/4 (µ − π + θ)1/2 + O(µ − π + θ) , µ → π − θ − . Define the segments (“bands”) [ bl = µ2l (ξ) = [(π(l − 1) + θ)2 , (πl − θ)2 ] , ξ
µ → θ+ , (3.6)
l∈N
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
430
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
and the intervals (“gaps”) ll = ((πl − θ)2 , (πl + θ)2 ) ,
l0 = (−∞, θ2 ) ,
l ∈ N.
(3.7)
The gaps are labelled so that ll separates the bands bl and bl+1 . The following statement is a direct consequence of the Floquet theory. Lemma 3.1. The spectrum of A coincides with the union of the bands bl , l = 1, 2, . . . . On this set the spectrum is of the Lebesgue type and of multiplicity two. We shall need also the spectral decomposition of the operator A. To this end, note that ζl (t, ξ) = cl (ξ)(cos(µl (ξ)(1 − t)) − b1/2 eiξ cos(µl (ξ)t)) , p cl (ξ) = 2(b + 1)−1 | sin µl (ξ)|−1 , 0 < t < 1 , is the normalized in L2 (0, 1) eigenfunction of Eq. (3.2) corresponding to the eigenvalue µ2l (ξ). It follows from (3.4), (3.3) that ζl (t, ξ) is smooth in ξ on each band bl . Let us extend each function ζl (t, ξ) to all t ∈ R in the following way. Let ωl (t, ξ) be the periodic (in t) extension of the function e−itξ ζl (t, ξ) from the interval [0, 1) to R. Then we define ζl (t, ξ) on the whole of R by the equation ζl (t, ξ) = eitξ ωl (t, ξ) ,
t ∈ R.
Let Pl be the spectral projection of A associated with the band bl . The map Z (Ul y)(ξ) = (2π)−1/2 ζl (t, ξ)y(t)dt R
defines the unitary operator from L (R) onto L2 (−π, π) which diagonalizes APl , namely 2
(Ul APl y)(ξ) = λl (ξ)(Ul Pl y)(ξ) ,
λl (ξ) = µ2l (ξ) .
The adjoint operator U ∗ : L2 (−π, π) → L2 (R) is given by Z π Z π ∗ −1/2 −1/2 (Ul z)(t) = (2π) ζl (t, ξ)z(ξ)dξ = (2π) eitξ ωl (t, ξ)z(ξ)dξ . −π
−π
Denoting by [m] the operator of multiplication by a scalar function m, we get the spectral decomposition of A in the form X A= Ul∗ [λl ]Ul Pl . (3.8) l∈N
3.2. Spectrum of the operators A0 and A0 Theorem 3.2. The spectrum of the operator A0 consists of the bands bl , l ∈ N and of the simple eigenvalues λl = (πl)2 , l ∈ N. The corresponding eigenfunctions (normalized in L2 (R+ )) are yl (t) = c(b)b−n/2 sin(πlt) ,
t ∈ (n − 1, n) ,
c(b) = (2(b − 1))−1/2 .
n ∈ N;
(3.9)
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
431
Proof. The operator A0 is non-negative, so its spectrum lies on [0, ∞). 1. Bands. Let D be the operator in L2 (R+ ), defined as follows: its operator domain coincides with the quadratic domain of A0 , i.e. is defined by (2.7)–(2.9), and for y from this domain (Dy)(t) = −iy 0 (t) ,
t∈ / N.
(3.10)
The operator D is closed and its adjoint D∗ acts by the same formula (3.10) on the domain consisting of those functions y from the direct product (2.7) which satisfy (2.9) and the matching conditions similar to the ones in (2.8) but with the factor b1/2 replaced by b−1/2 ; there is no boundary condition at t = 0. It is easy to see that A0 = D∗ D. Along with A0 , consider the operator DD∗ . It acts as (DD∗ y)(t) = −y 00 (t), t 6∈ N, and its domain is described by the boundary condition y 0 (0) = 0 and the matching conditions y(n+) = b−1/2 y(n−) ,
y 0 (n+) = b1/2 y 0 (n−) ,
n ∈ N.
According to the general operator theory, the non-zero spectra of the operators A0 = D∗ D and DD∗ coincide. Now, in the definition of the operator A let us replace the matching condition at t = 0 by the boundary conditions y(0+) = 0 ,
y 0 (0−) = 0 .
The new operator, say A0 , splits into the orthogonal sum, A0 = A0 ⊕ A00 where the operator A00 acts in L2 (R− ). Its description is clear from the construction and it is easy to see that the substitution t 7→ −t reduces A00 to DD∗ . The essential S spectrum of A0 is the same as that of A, i.e. l∈N bl . It also coincides with the union of the essential spectra of the operators A0 and A00 , i.e. with each of them. It follows that the essential spectrum of A0 coincides with the spectrum of A given by Lemma 3.1. 2. Eigenvalues. The fact that each function yl (t), cf. (3.9), is the eigenfunction corresponding to the eigenvalue (πl)2 , can be verified by the direct inspection. Any two solutions satisfying the boundary condition y(0) = 0 are proportional to each other, so that this eigenvalues are simple. The direct inspection shows also that λ = 0 is not an eigenvalue. So it remains to show that any number λ = k 2 > 0 with π −1 k 6∈ N can not be an eigenvalue. For this purpose we use the explicit formulae for the solutions of the equation y 00 (t) + k 2 y(t) = 0 ,
t 6∈ N
(3.11)
under the matching conditions (3.1). Namely, let q1 , q2 be found from the quadratic equation q 2 − 2Rq cos k + 1 = 0
(3.12)
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
432
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
where R is defined in (3.3). Suppose that q1 6= q2 , that is R| cos k| 6= 1. The functions yj (t) = (b1/2 sin k(n − t) + qj sin k(t − n + 1))qjn−1 , n−1 < t < n,
n ∈ N,
(3.13)
j = 1, 2
are solutions of the equation (3.11) under the matching conditions (3.1). Their Wronskian is equal to y1 y20 − y10 y2 = b1/2 (q2 − q1 )k sin k, so that the solutions y1 , y2 are linearly dependent only if π −1 k ∈ N which is the excluded case. Any solution satisfying the condition y(0+) = 0 is proportional to the function y0 (t) =
q n−1 − q1n−1 y2 (t) − y1 (t) = b1/2 2 sin k(n − t) q2 − q1 q2 − q1 +
q2n − q1n sin k(t − n + 1) , q2 − q1 n−1 < t < n,
(3.14)
n ∈ N.
For π−1 k 6∈ N this function does not lie in L2 (R+ ) and hence, is not an eigenfunction. If R| cos k| = 1, then q1 = q2 = ±1 and it is easy to see that there also are no L2 solutions of the problems (3.11) and (3.1), and we are done. The result for the operator A0 , that is for the Laplacian on the tree, immediately follows from Theorem 2.4 and Theorem 3.2. Theorem 3.3. The spectrum of the operator A0 is of infinite multiplicity and consists of the bands bl and the eigenvalues λl = (πl)2 , l ∈ N. We see that the gap l0 of the operator A is also the gap for A0 , and each gap ll of A with l ≥ 1 splits into two gaps when we turn to the operator A0 : ll,− = ((πl − θ)2 , (πl)2 ) ;
ll,+ = ((πl)2 , (πl + θ)2 ) .
3.3. Global quasi-momentum and density of states Define the density of states for the operators A and A0 as the limit ρ(λ) = lim
NP (λ; ∆) , |∆|
|∆| → ∞ .
(3.15)
Here we denote ∆ = (0, L), L ∈ N, and NP (λ) = #{j : µ2l < λ} is the counting function for the operator By = −y 00 which at the points 1, . . . , L − 1 has the same matching conditions as in (3.1), and also satisfies the boundary conditions y(0) = b1/2 y(L) ,
y 0 (0) = b−1/2 y 0 (L) .
The subscript P in the notation for the counting function indicates that the operator B has the boundary conditions of this type. If the limit (3.15) exists for these conditions, then it will also exist for any other conditions, and its value will not depend on them. Later, in order to calculate the density of states we shall use the
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
433
same formula (3.15), but with the counting function of the Dirichlet problem. In this case we do not use any subscripts and simply √ write N (λ). Let us find eigenvalues of B. Denote k = λ, then choose solutions on every interval (n, n + 1) in the form y(t) = αn cos k(t − n) + βn sin k(t − n) . In view of the matching conditions, we come, with the notations c = cos k, s = sin k, to the equalities βn = b−1/2 (−αn−1 s + βn−1 c)
αn = b1/2 (αn−1 c + βn−1 s) ,
(3.16)
for n = 0, . . . , L. Here we have identified the points with n = 0 and n = L, so that α0 = αL and β0 = βL . To solve this system introduce the functions A(z) =
L−1 X
αn z n ,
n=0
B(z) =
L−1 X
βn z n ,
n=0
where z runs over the set of all complex numbers such that z L = 1. Then by (3.16) A(z) = b1/2 z(cA(z) + sB(z)) ,
B(z) = b−1/2 z(−sA(z) + cB(z)) .
This system of two equations has non-trivial solution iff its determinant is identically zero: ! sb1/2 z cb1/2 z − 1 det = c2 z 2 − cb−1/2 z − cb1/2 z + 1 + s2 z 2 −sb−1/2 z cb−1/2 z − 1 = z 2 − 2cRz + 1 = 0 , whence z + z −1 2πn = cos , n = 0, 1, . . . , L − 1 . 2 L It is convenient to write the formulae for the eigenvalues in terms of the function ϕ defined by (3.3), and the formulae for NP (λ) — in terms of the “global quasimomentum” ω(λ) which we now define. Namely, ω(λ) = πl if λ ∈ ll , and for λ ∈ bl √ π(l − 1) + ψ( λ − π(l − 1)) , l is odd , ω(λ) = (3.17) √ πl − ψ(πl − λ) , l is even . R cos k = Rc =
Here ψ is the function inverse to ϕ, cf. (3.5). Evidently p √ c λ − θ2 ≤ ω(λ) ≤ C λ , λ ≥ 0 . The eigenvalues of the operator B are given by the formulae 2πj µl (j) = π(l − 1) + ϕ , l odd ; L 2πj µl (j) = πl − ϕ , l even , L l ∈ N,
j = 0, 1, . . . , L − 1 .
(3.18)
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
434
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
The number NP (λ) depends on the location of λ. For instance, if λ ∈ ll , then N (λ) = lL, so that ρ(λ) =
NP (λ, ∆) 1 = l = ω(λ) , |∆| π
λ ∈ ll .
To cover the case λ ∈ bl we shall √ consider two options: l is odd or l is even. Suppose first that l is odd and denote λ = π(l − 1) + χ. Then NP (λ; ∆) = l − 1 + `1 (χ) , L 1 2πj `1 (χ) = # j ∈ [0, L − 1) : ϕ <χ . L L The term `1 (χ) can be estimated as follows: `1 (χ) − 1 ψ(χ) ≤ 2L−1 . π Hence by (3.17)
NP (λ; ∆) 1 ≤ 2L−1 , ∀ λ > 0. − ω(λ) L π √ Suppose now that l is even. Denote λ = πl − χ. Then
(3.19)
NP (λ; ∆) = l − `2 (χ) , L 1 2πj `2 (χ) = # j ∈ [0, L − 1) : ϕ >χ . L L The term `2 (χ) can be estimated as follows: `2 (χ) + 1 ψ(χ) − 1 ≤ 2L−1 . π Using (3.17) again, we get (3.19). All this results in the formula 1 ω(λ) (3.20) π which is well known for the clasical Hill operator. Relying upon the estimate (3.19) we shall prove a similar estimate for the counting function of the Dirichlet problem on an arbitrary interval (R1 , R2 ), not necessarily with integer R1 , R2 . ρ(λ) =
Theorem 3.4. Let ∆ = (R1 , R2 ), R1 , R2 ∈ R, R1 < R2 . Then the inequality holds: √ N (λ; ∆) 1+ λ (3.21) |∆| − ρ(λ) ≤ C |∆| for all λ > 0, with a universal constant C.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
435
Proof. It is well known that for the Dirichlet realization of the operator −y 00 on ∆ (with √ no matching conditions inside!) the counting function is controlled by C|∆| λ, with a universal constant. Since the number of integer points inside ∆ is not greater than |∆| + 1, it follows from the decoupling principle that √ N (λ; ∆) ≤ C(|∆| λ + |∆| + 1) . (3.22) If the length of ∆ is small, say |∆| ≤ 2, then (3.21) is implied by (3.18) and (3.22). Let now |∆| > 2. Without loss of generality, we may assume 0 ≤ R1 < 1. Define L = [R2 ] (the integer part of R2 ), then L ≥ 2. Let ∆+ and ∆− be the intervals (0, L + 1) and (1, L) respectively. Then, clearly, N (λ; ∆− ) ≤ N (λ; ∆) ≤ N (λ; ∆+ ) , by variation argument. Furthermore, by the decoupling principle, |N (λ; ∆± ) − NP (λ; ∆± )| ≤ 4 , so that NP (λ; ∆− ) 4 N (λ; ∆) NP (λ; ∆+ ) 4 − ≤ ≤ + . |∆| |∆| |∆| |∆| |∆| Therefore
NP (λ; ∆± ) N (λ; ∆) 4 − ρ(λ) + . |∆| − ρ(λ) ≤ max ± |∆| |∆| Let us estimate the r.h.s. with the “−” sign. The modulus equals NP (λ; ∆− ) L − 1 NP (λ; ∆− ) 2NP (λ; ∆− ) − ρ(λ) ≤ − ρ(λ) + . L−1 |∆| L−1 |∆|(L − 1) In view of (3.19), the first term in the r.h.s. is bounded by 2(L − 1)−1 ≤ 3L−1 and in view of (3.22), the second term is bounded by √ √ C((L − 1) λ + L) C( λ + 1) ≤ . |∆|(L − 1) |∆| Repeating the same argument for the “+” sign, we arrive at (3.21). We conclude this section by discussing the H¨older properties of the global quasimomentum ω(λ) and thus, those of the density of states ρ(λ). It is clear from (3.6) that near the edges of the gap ll = (λ− , λ+ ) the function ρ has the following behaviour: √ 2 1 2 (R − 1) 4 1 ρ(λ) = ρ(λ± ) ± (λ − λ± ) 2 + O(λ − λ± ) , λ → λ± + 0 ± . π λ± Together with the formula (3.18) this asymptotics guarantees that 1
|ρ(λ) − ρ(λ± )| ≥ c|λ − λ± | 2 ,
λ ∈ ll ,
(3.23)
with a constant c depending on l. The formula (3.3) also ensures that the function ψ is 1/2-H¨ older continuous, i.e. |ψ(µ2 ) − ψ(µ1 )| ≤ C|µ2 − µ1 |1/2 ,
µ1 , µ2 ∈ [θ, π − θ] .
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
436
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Using (3.18), one can immediately extend this information to the function ω: 1/2
|ω(λ2 ) − ω(λ1 )| ≤ C(|λ2
1/2
1/2
− λ1 |1/2 + |λ2
1/2
− λ1 |) ,
λ1 , λ2 ≥ θ ,
with a constant C independent of λ1 , λ2 . Later we shall use a less precise, but somewhat more compact consequence of this estimate and (3.20): |ρ(λ2 ) − ρ(λ1 )| ≤ C|λ2 − λ1 |1/2 ,
λ1 , λ2 ∈ R ,
(3.24)
with a universal constant C. 4. Operator AV with a Decaying Potential. Eigenvalues in the Gaps 4.1. Functions M (λ) and N (λ1 , λ2 ) Here we turn to the study of the spectrum of the Schr¨odinger operators AV , cf. (2.1), with the real-valued and bounded potential V (|x|) which in an appropriate sense decays as |x| → ∞. The essential spectrum of AV is the same as for the unperturbed operator A0 (i.e. Laplacian) and therefore, is given by Theorem 3.3. The spectrum of AV may include also eigenvalues lying in the gaps of A0 . For their study, the following quantities are standardly used. Let C be a self-adjoint operator in a Hilbert space, and let V be its relatively compact perturbation; we denote CV = C + V . Suppose that the interval (λ− , λ+ ) is a gap in σ(C). Let λ ∈ (λ− , λ+ ). Define the counting function M (λ; CV ) as the number of eigenvalues of CαV crossing the point λ while α varies from 0 to 1. In other words, X M (λ; CV ) = dim ker(C + αV − λ) . 0<α<1
If λ coincides with one of the ends of a gap, the function M (λ; CV ) is defined as the corresponding one-sided limit. If V is a perturbation of fixed sign, that is if V = ±q with a q ≥ 0, then the function M (λ) is increasing (for V = −q) or decreasing (for V = q) in λ ∈ (λ− , λ+ ) and increasing in q. For any subinterval (λ1 , λ2 ) ⊂ (λ− , λ+ ) the function N (λ1 , λ2 ; CV ) is defined as the total multiplicity of eigenvalues of the operator CV , lying in (λ1 , λ2 ). Note that if λ− = −∞ and λ ≤ λ+ , then N (λ; CV ) := N (−∞, λ; CV ) = M (λ; CV ) . According to Theorem 3.3, the following equalities hold: X bk M (λ; AVk ) , M (λ; AV ) = M (λ; AV ) + (1 − b−1 )
(4.1)
k∈N
N (λ1 , λ2 ; AV ) = N (λ1 , λ2 ; AV ) + (1 − b−1 )
X
bk N (λ1 , λ2 ; AVk ) .
(4.2)
k∈N
Recall that the potentials Vk appearing in (4.1), (4.2) were defined in (2.11). These formulae show that the key step to understanding the behaviour of the functions
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
437
M (λ; AV ), N (λ1 , λ2 ; AV ) consists in studying the individual terms of the series (4.1), (4.2). More precisely, we need the detailed information about their behaviour depending on the parameter k. The study of the sums (4.1), (4.2) is hampered by the presence of the exponential factors in their r.h.s. These factors reflect the geometry of the tree rather than the properties of the potential V (t). For this reason, it makes sense to investigate, along with the functions M (λ; AV ), N (λ1 , λ2 ; AV ), also the functions X ˜ (λ; AV ) = M M (λ; AVk ) , (4.3) k≥0
˜ (λ1 , λ2 ; AV ) = N
X
N (λ1 , λ2 ; AVk ) .
(4.4)
k≥0
For technical reasons, we shall need also the functions M , N for the operators on intervals ∆ ⊆ R. Define AV,∆ as the operator in L2 (∆) acting as (AV,∆ y)(t) = −y 00 (t) + V (t)y(t) for t 6∈ Z, under the zero boundary conditions at each finite end of ∆ and the matching conditions (3.1) at the points n ∈ Z ∩ ∆. In particular, AV,R+ = AV . Often we use abbreviated notation for the corresponding functions M , N , such as M (λ, V ; ∆) or even M (λ; ∆) when the potential V is fixed. Note a convenient relation M (λ; AVk , (R1 , R2 )) = M (λ; AV , (R1 + k, R2 + k)) ,
(4.5)
which is valid for any 0 ≤ R1 < R2 ≤ ∞ and integer k’s. This formula is useful when it is more natural to study the dependence of M on the interval ∆ than on the potential. If V is a function of constant sign, then there is a useful relationship between M (λ; AV,∆ ) and the spectrum of the compact operator T (λ) = T (λ, V, ∆) = |V |1/2 (A0,∆ − λI)−1 |V |1/2 ,
λ 6∈ σ(A0,∆ ) .
(4.6)
Namely, if λ is a regular point of A0,∆ , then M (λ; V, ∆) = n+ (1, T (λ, V, ∆)) ,
V ≤ 0;
(4.7)
M (λ; V, ∆) = n− (1, T (λ, V, ∆)) ,
V ≥ 0.
(4.8)
Here n± (·, T ) stands for the counting functions of the positive and negative eigenvalues ±λ± j (T ) of a compact, self-adjoint operator T , that is n± (s, T ) = #{j : λ± j (T ) > s} ,
s > 0.
The equalities (4.7), (4.8) proved very effective in the problems of the type considered, see e.g. [21]. Actually, these are facts of rather general a nature, see e.g. [3, Proposition 1.5]. The following relations have their prototypes in the theory of the perturbed Hill operator, see [21, (2.5)–(2.8)]. For bounded ∆ ( M (λ; V, ∆) = N (λ; V, ∆) − N (λ; 0, ∆) , V ≤ 0, (4.9) M (λ; V, ∆) = N (λ+; 0, ∆) − N (λ+; V, ∆) , V ≥ 0 .
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
438
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Further, for any (bounded or unbounded) ∆ |N (λ1 , λ2 ; V, ∆) − |M (λ2 ; V, ∆) − M (λ1 ; V, ∆)| | ≤ N (λ1 , λ2 ; 0, ∆) + 1 .
(4.10)
One can give a more precise formula: for any two points λ1 , λ2 such that N (λ1 , λ2 ; 0, ∆) = 0, we obtain from (4.9): ( N (λ1 , λ2 ; V, ∆) = M (λ2 ; V, ∆) − M (λ1 +; V, ∆) , (4.11) N (λ1 , λ2 +; V, ∆) = M (λ1 ; V, ∆) − M (λ2 ; V, ∆) . The next two inequalities are usually referred to as the “decoupling principle”. Let ∆1 = (a, d), ∆2 = (d, c), −∞ ≤ a < d < c ≤ ∞, and ∆ = (a, c). Then |N (λ1 , λ2 ; V, ∆) − (N (λ1 , λ2 ; V, ∆1 ) + N (λ1 , λ2 ; V, ∆2 ))| ≤ 2 ,
(4.12)
|M (λ; V, ∆) − (M (λ; V, ∆1 ) + M (λ; V, ∆2 ))| ≤ 2 .
(4.13)
The proofs of the relations (4.9)–(4.13) are either straightforward, or are based upon standard facts from the perturbation theory. Note that the number 1 rather than 2 stands in the r.h.s of the inequalities [21, (2.7) and (2.8)] whose analogs are the above inequalities (4.12), (4.13). This difference appears due to the nature of the matching conditions at the points n ∈ Z. If d 6∈ Z, one can replace 2 by 1 in (4.12) and (4.13). 4.2. Individual Weyl asymptotics The material presented in this subsection, is a minor refinement of [21, Theorems 3.2 and 3.3]. We give it here for the operators we need in this paper (that is, the functions in the domains of the operators considered are subject to the matching conditions (3.1)). However, it is useful to keep in mind that the results of Theorem 4.2(i) and of Theorem 4.3 hold also for the usual Hill operator. For a real-valued function V on R+ , introduce the quantity !1/2 X Z 2n t|V (t)|dt . J(V ) = n∈Z
2n−1
Consider the operator on L2 (R+ ): KV y = −y 00 + V y ,
y ∈ H2 (R+ ) ,
y(0) = 0 .
(4.14)
In contrast to the operator AV , the description of KV involves no matching conditions, and the quadratic domain of KV is H1,0 (R+ ). The following estimate and asymptotics are particular cases of the results of [9, Sec. 6]; see also expositions in [6] and [7]. A close result was obtained earlier in [8, Theorems 4.18 and 4.19]. Proposition 4.1. Let J(V ) < ∞. Then the negative spectrum of the operator KV is finite and there exists an absolute constant C > 0 such that M (0; KV ) ≤ CJ(V− ) .
(4.15)
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
439
Besides, let g > 0 be the large parameter and V− 6≡ 0. The function M (0; KgV ) satisfies Weyl’s asymptotics Z p lim g −1/2 M (0; KgV ) = π −1 V− (t)dt , g → ∞ . (4.16) R+
If |V (t)| monotonically decreases, then by H¨ older’s inequality Z √ √ J(V )/ 6 ≤ |V (t)|1/2 dt ≤ 6J(V ) .
(4.17)
R+
Hence, for monotone |V (t)| the function M (0; KgV ) is controlled by the r.h.s. of its asymptotics given by (4.16). Along with J(V ), introduce the functional !1/2 Z 1 1/2 X Z 2n ∞ ˜ )= J(V |V (t)|dt + t|V (t)|dt . 0
n=1
2n−1
˜ ), therefore in the r.h.s of (4.15) J(V ) can be replaced by Clearly J(V ) ≤ cJ(V ˜ ). Compared with Theorem 4.1, its corollary with J(V ˜ ) in the r.h.s ignores the J(V fact that due to the Dirichlet condition at 0 the potential V need not be integrable at this point. Still, this corollary is quite convenient provided one is dealing with V integrable at 0. Present also an estimate for M (−1; AV ); we need it in the course of the proof of Theorem 4.2 below. 1/2 X Z n M (−1; AV ) ≤ CΘ(V ) := C |V (t)|dt . (4.18) n∈N
n−1
For the proof, one splits R+ into the union of the intervals (n − 1, n] and applies to each interval the well known eigenvalue estimate for the equation −y 00 + y = λV y with the Neumann boundary conditions. This is exactly the way in which the same estimate for M (−1; KV ) was proved in [4]. It follows from H¨older’s inequality that Θ(V ) ≤ J˜(V ). However, the functional Θ(V ) can not be estimated by J(V ). Note that similarly to (4.17), for a decreasing |V | we have Z 1 1/2 √ Z p ˜ J(V ) ≤ |V (t)|dt + 6 |V (t)|dt . (4.19) 0
R+
˜ ) < ∞. Theorem 4.2. Let V be a function with a fixed sign and let J(V (i) Suppose that λ ∈ ll where ll is one of the gaps (see (3.7)). Then, given an interval ∆ ⊆ R, the estimate ˜ ) + 1) M (λ; V, ∆) ≤ C(J(V holds, where the constant C = C(l) does not depend on λ ∈ ¯ll and V.
(4.20)
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
440
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
(ii) Suppose in addition that ∆ = R+ (so that AV,∆ = AV ), and that ( l0 , l = 0, λ ∈ I where I ⊂ is a closed interval. ll \ {λl } , l≥1
(4.21)
Then ˜ ) M (λ; AV ) ≤ C 0 J(V
(4.22)
with a constant C 0 uniform in λ ∈ I. In particular, for V ≤ 0 the estimate (4.22) is uniform in λ ≤ θ2 . Proof. The proof of (i) follows the scheme suggested in [21]. For this reason, we only outline the necessary changes in the argument. To be definite, we suppose that V ≤ 0 and that l (the index of the gap) is even. We start with the spectral decomposition (3.8) of the operator A = A0,R on the whole line. Set
P+
λ(ξ) = λl+1 (ξ) , P = Pl+1 , X = ⊕Pj , Q = P + − P , U = Ul+1 . j>l
As in [21, Sec. 4], the estimating of M (λ; V, ∆) is reduced to the problem of eigenvalue estimates for the operators T1 (λ) = |V |1/2 (A − λI)−1 P |V |1/2 , T2 (λ) = |V |1/2 (A − λI)−1 Q|V |1/2 . Since k(A + I)(A − λI)−1 Qk ≤ Cl (actually, Cl = O(l)), we have n+ (1, T2 (λ)) ≤ n+ (Cl−1 , (|V |1/2 (A + I)−1 |V |1/2 ) = M (−1; A + Cl V ) . To the latter quantity the estimate (4.18) applies, and we obtain n+ (1, T2 (λ)) ≤ C 0 Θ(V ) .
(4.23)
To the operator T1 (λ) the argument of [21] applies without changes. Indeed, the nature of the operator U in our case is the same as in the case of periodicity coming from a potential. This allows to reduce the problem to estimating the counting function N (λ; KV ) for the operator KV defined in (4.14). Then using the bound ˜ ) + 1) which in combination (4.15), we arrive at the inequality n(1, T1 (λ)) ≤ C(J(V with (4.23) leads to (4.20). (ii) Again, for definiteness, we prove the result for the non-positive potentials. Let λ = k 2 ∈ I, k > 0. In the case l ≥ 1 assume temporarily that λ 6= (πl − θ)2 and λ 6= (πl + θ)2 , so that k ∈ (πl − θ, πl) ∪ (πl, πl + θ). In the case l = 0 assume that λ ∈ (0, θ2 ), so that k ∈ (0, θ). The roots q1 , q2 of Eq. (3.12) are real and distinct, and q1 q2 = 1. Let us label them so that |q1 | < 1 < |q2 | and denote |q1 | = e−σ , then σ > 0. Consider the solutions y0
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
441
and y1 (cf. (3.14) and (3.13)) of the equation (3.11) under the matching conditions (3.1) Their Wronskian is W (y0 , y1 ) = y0 y10 − y00 y1 = −b1/2 k sin k 6= 0, so that y0 , y1 are linearly independent. On the interval (n − 1, n) the function y0 (t) satisfies the inequality |y0 (t)| ≤ nb1/2 (q2n−2 + q2n−1 ) ≤ 2nb1/2 eσt , |y0 (t)| ≤ | sin kt| ≤ kt ,
n > 1;
n = 1.
For y1 (t) we have |y1 (t)| ≤ (b1/2 + 1)q1n−1 ≤ q2 (b1/2 + 1)e−σt ,
t > 0.
Note also that |q2 | = R| cos k| + (R2 cos2 k − 1)1/2 ≤ 2R. So we see that the inequalities |y0 (t)| ≤ cteσt ,
|y1 (t)| ≤ ce−σt ,
t>0
(4.24)
hold uniformly in λ ∈ I. The solution y0 satisfies the boundary condition y0 (0+) = 0. Given a function f ∈ L2 (R+ ), the solution of the non-homogeneous equation on R+ : y 00 (t) + k 2 y(t) = −f (t) ,
t 6∈ N ;
y(0+) = 0
satisfying the matching conditions (3.1) for n ∈ N, is given by Z y(t) = K(t, s)f (s)ds R+
where
( W (y0 , y1 )K(t, s) =
y1 (t)y0 (s) ,
s < t,
y1 (s)y0 (t) ,
t < s.
It follows from (4.24) that |K(t, s)| ≤ c2 e−σ|t−s| min(s, t)(b1/2 k| sin k|)−1 √ ≤ C1 st(k| sin k|)−1 , C1 = c2 b−1/2 .
(4.25)
The operator (4.6) (for λ = k 2 and ∆ = R+ ) acts as Z (T (λ)f )(t) = |V (t)|1/2 K(t, s)|V (s)|1/2 f (s)ds . R+
˜ ) < ∞ this operator belongs to the Hilbert–Schmidt Under the assumption J(V class. Indeed, by virtue of (4.25) ZZ 2 (k sin k) |K(t, s)|2 |V (t)| |V (s)|dtds R2+
ZZ ≤ C12
R2+
Z st|V (t)| |V (s)|dtds = C12
!2 t|V (t)|dt
R+
˜ )4 . ≤ C12 J(V
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
442
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Since kT k ≤ kT kHS and n+ (1, T ) = 0 if kT k ≤ 1, the last estimate and (4.7) imply ˜ )2 ≤ C −1 k| sin k|. In its turn, this and the estimate (4.20) that M (λ; AV ) = 0 if J(V 1 yield the inequality (4.22) with C 0 = C(1+(C1−1 k| sin k|)−1/2 ). By continuity, (4.22) extends to the ends of the gap, i.e. to k = πl ± θ (l ≥ 1) or k = θ (l = 0). Since the function M (λ; AV ) is monotone in λ, the result for l = 0 automatically extends to all λ ≤ θ. As in (4.19) one can simplify the estimate (4.20) if one assumes that |V | is decreasing on the interval ∆ = (R1 , R2 ): !1/2 Z R1 +1 √ Z p M (λ; AV , ∆) ≤ C |V (t)|dt + 6 |V (t)|dt + 1 . (4.26) R1
∆
Theorem 4.3. Let the assumptions of Theorem 4.2 be satisfied and V ≤ 0. Then the asymptotics Z p |V (t)|dt , g → ∞ (4.27) lim g −1/2 M (λ; gV, ∆) = π −1 ∆
(cf. (4.16)) holds uniformly in λ ∈ ll . Proof. Like in [21], the problem reduces to the case of a finite interval ∆. In view of (4.9) we need to study only the term depending on g. Removal of the matching conditions inside the interval shifts the function N (λ; gV, ∆) no more than by 2|∆| + 2 and therefore, does not affect its asymptotic behaviour. As a result, we come to the operator of the Dirichlet problem on a finite interval for which the asymptotics (4.27) is well known. ˜ (λ; AgV ) 4.3. Weyl asymptotics for M (λ; AgV ) and M The results of this subsection follow immediately from Theorems 3.2 and 3.3. Theorem 4.4. Let Γ = Γb and let V (t) ≤ 0 be a bounded measurable function on R+ . Let λ satisfy (4.21). Then (i) If
X
bk J˜(Vk ) < ∞ ,
(4.28)
k∈N
then the Weyl asymptotics holds for the function M (λ; AgV ) of the operator (2.1) : Z p 1 −1/2 M (λ; AgV ) = |V (|x|)|dx , g → ∞ . (4.29) lim g π Γ (ii) If
X k∈N
˜ k) < ∞ , J(V
(4.30)
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
then
∞ Z 1 X ∞p ˜ lim g −1/2 M(λ; AgV ) = |V (t)|dt , π k
g → ∞.
443
(4.31)
k=0
The above asymptotic formulae are uniform in λ on any closed interval I from (4.21). Proof. For definiteness, we prove (4.29). The proof of (4.31) is the same. It follows from (4.1) that g −1/2 M (λ; AgV ) = g −1/2 M (λ; AgV ) + (1 − b−1 )
X
bk g −1/2 M (λ; AgVk ) .
k∈N
By Theorem 4.3, for each k ≥ 0 g −1/2 M (λ; AgVk ) → π −1
Z R+
p |Vk (t)|dt ,
g → ∞.
The series (4.28) dominates the series (4.32) and it follows from Lebesgue’s theorem on the dominated convergence that Z p Z p ∞ X −1/2 −1 k πg M (λ; AgV ) → |V (t)|dt + (1 − b ) b |Vk (t)|dt , g → ∞ . R+
k=1
R+
This is equivalent to (4.29). Due to Theorem 4.2 the series (4.28) converges uniformly on I from (4.21), and hence the asymptotics (4.29) is uniform in λ ∈ I. 5. Power-Like and Exponential Potentials 5.1. Weyl asymptotics Here we show how the theorems in the previous section apply to potentials with a specified rate of decay at infinity. To have a clear distinction between the cases of non-positive and non-negative potentials, we slightly change our notation: we denote the potential by V = ±q or V = sq with s = ±1, always assuming that q ≥ 0. We are interested in two types of potentials: power-like and exponential. More precisely, suppose that q(t) ≤ CQ(t) where Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ ,
γ > 0 , or Q(t) = e−2κt ,
κ > 0.
(5.1)
˜ (λ; A−gq ). Let us first establish the Weyl type asymptotics for M (λ; A−gq ) and M Theorem 5.1. Let Condition (4.21) be fulfilled. Suppose that q(t) ≤ CQ(t). (i) If Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ with γ > 2, then the asymptotic formula (4.31) holds for ˜ (λ; A−gq ); M
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
444
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
˜ (λ; A−gq ) (ii) If Q(t) = e−2κt , κ > 0, then the asymptotic formula (4.31) for M holds. If, in addition, κ > ln b, then the asymptotics (4.29) for M (λ; A−gq ) holds as well. These results are uniform in λ ∈ I with a closed interval I from (4.21). The proof of Theorem 5.1 is based on two elementary Lemmas 5.2 and 5.3, which describe individual counting functions. These lemmas will be also useful in ˜ the analysis of the non-Weyl behaviour of the function M. Recall that by qk , k ≥ 0 are denoted the “shifted” potentials qk (t) = q(t + k), t > 0. Remembering the relation (4.5) and a comment after it, we sometimes transfer the dependence on k to the interval ∆. This is why some of the estimates below are stated for intervals ∆ depending on an additional parameter R, which plays the role of k, but is not supposed to be integer. Lemma 5.2 (Power-like potentials). Suppose that q ≤ CQ with Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ , γ > 1. (i) Then for any R ≥ 0 M (λ; ±gq, (R, ∞)) ≤ C(g 1/2 (1 + R)1−γ + 1) ,
∀k ≥ 0,
(5.2)
uniformly in λ ∈ ¯ll and R ≥ 0. (ii) If the condition (4.21) is satisfied, then M (λ; ±gqR ) ≤ Cg 1/2 (1 + R)1−γ ,
∀k ≥ 0,
(5.3)
uniformly in λ ∈ I with a closed interval I from (4.21). Lemma 5.3 (Exponential potentials). Suppose that q ≤ CQ with Q(t) = e−2κt , κ > 0. (i) Then for any R > 0 M (λ; ±gq, (R, ∞)) ≤ C(g 1/2 e−κR + 1) ,
∀k ≥ 0,
(5.4)
uniformly in λ ∈ ¯ll and R ≥ 0. (ii) If the condition (4.21) is satisfied, then M (λ; ±gqR ) ≤ Cg 1/2 e−κR ,
∀R ≥ 0,
(5.5)
uniformly in λ ∈ I with a closed interval I from (4.21). Proofs of Lemmas 5.2 and 5.3. Due to the monotonicity of the function M (λ; ±V ) in V (see Sec. 4.1), it is sufficient to obtain the estimates for the “model” potential Q. For a power-like Q, we have "Z #1/2 Z R+1 ∞ −2γ (1 + t) dt + (1 + t)−γ dt ≤ C(1 + R)1−γ , R
R
which implies (5.2) by virtue of (4.26). Similarly, (4.22) leads to (5.3). The proof of Lemma 5.3 is the same.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
445
Proof of Theorem 5.1. According to (5.3) (respectively (5.5)) the series (4.30) is convergent for γ > 2 (respectively all κ > 0), which ensures the validity of (4.31). In the exponential case, if κ > ln b, then the series (4.28) is also convergent, which leads to the asymptotics (4.29) by Theorem 4.4. 5.2. Non-Weylian asymptotics The rest of the paper is focused on the situations when the Weyl formula fails, and the asymptotics of the counting functions (4.1)–(4.4) depends on the behaviour of the potential at infinity. We concentrate on bounded potentials q behaving like Q (see (5.1)) at infinity. The precise meaning of this phrase will be made clear later. ˜ As in the previous section, the asymptotics of M (λ; A±gq ) and M(λ; A±gq ) will be deduced from the asymptotics of the individual counting functions M (λ; ±gqk ), k ≥ 0 for the operators A±gqk . In the case of the power-like potential q the total number of eigenvalues of Asq in each gap may become infinite. More precisely, if q = (1 + t)−2γ , s = −1 (respectively s = +1) and γ ≤ 1 then the eigenvalues accumulate at the upper (respectively lower) end of the gap ll . In this connection it is convenient to introduce the notion of an admissible point λ ∈ ¯ll . From now on we fix the number l ≥ 0 and denote ll = (λ− , λ+ ). If l = 0, then λ− = −∞ and λ+ = θ2 . If l ≥ 1, then λ± = (πl ±θ)2 . In the definition below, to avoid unnecessary repetitions, by [−∞, λ+ ], [−∞, λ+ ) we understand the intervals (−∞, λ+ ], (−∞, λ+ ). Definition 5.4. Let Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ . Then a point λ ∈ [λ− , λ+ ] is said to be γ0 -admissible, γ0 > 0, if (λ , λ ] , γ ≤ γ0 , s = +1 ; − + λ ∈ [λ− , λ+ ) , γ ≤ γ0 , s = −1 ; [λ− , λ+ ] , γ > γ0 . For Q(t) = e−2κt any point λ ∈ [λ− , λ+ ] is said to be γ0 -admissible with any γ0 > 0. Clearly, for any two positive numbers γ0 , γ1 , γ0 < γ1 , any γ1 -admissible λ is automatically γ0 -admissible. For the model potential Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ the number M (λ; ±gqn ) is finite for all g > 0 if λ is 1-admissible. For the exponential model potential Q(t) = e−2κt the quantity M (λ; ±gqn ) is finite for all λ ∈ [λ− , λ+ ]. ˜ (λ; Asgq ), N ˜ (λ1 , λ2 ; Asgq ) 5.3. Results for the functions M ˜ (λ; A±gq ) and This subsection contains the results on the asymptotics of M ˜ N (λ1 , λ2 ; A±gq ). Their proofs require some technical preparations which we give in Secs. 6, 7. The proofs are completed in Sec. 8. Our results for the functions (4.1), ˜ and (4.2) require different techniques and are much less complete than those for M ˜ ; they are presented in Sec. 9. N Recall that in contrast to the spectrum of the “individual” operator A0 the spectrum of A0 contains eigenvalues λl = (πl)2 of infinite multiplicity. Thus, when
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
446
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
stating the results we assume that λ, λ1 , λ2 satisfy (4.21) and are 2-admissible. The constants in all the estimates below are • uniform in λ, λ1 , λ2 varying within any closed interval I of 2-admissible points, satisfying (4.21), • independent of the coupling constant g. We begin with the power-like potentials. Theorem 5.5. Let q satisfy the condition q(t) = Q(t)(1 + o(1)) ,
t → ∞,
Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ ,
(5.6)
and one of the following two conditions be fulfilled: (1) γ ∈ (0, 2) and s = −1; (2) The exponent γ > 0 is arbitrary and s = +1. Suppose that λ is 2-admissible and satisfies (4.21). Then Z ∞Z ∞ − γ1 ˜ lim g M(λ; A±gq ) = ± [ρ(λ) − ρ(λ ∓ (s + σ)−2γ )]dsdσ , g→∞
0
(5.7)
0
where ρ is the density of states for the operator A0 . Remark 5.6. A simple change of variables leads to another expression for the asymptotic coefficient: Z ∞Z ∞ − γ1 ˜ [ρ(λ) − ρ(λ ∓ s−2γ )]dsdβ . lim g M(λ; A±gq ) = ± 0
β
In Sec. 7 we shall show that the asymptotic coefficients in the r.h.s. of (5.7) and that in Theorem 5.9 below, are finite. Note that in contrast to s = −1, the above formula describes the asymptotics ˜ of M(λ; Asgq ) with s = +1 for all positive γ. If s = −1, then the case γ = 2 is critical in the sense that for γ > 2 the Weyl asymptotics is applicable instead of (5.7) (cf. Lemma 5.2). We point out however that for the individual counting function M (λ; −gqn ) the critical case is γ = 1 (see Theorem 4.3). ˜ in the case γ = 2 we need to introduce more restrictions To find a formula for M on q. Condition 5.7. Let q ∈ C1 (R+ ) be a function such that cQ(t) ≤ q(t) ≤ CQ(t) ,
∀ t ∈ R+ ,
|q 0 (t)| ≤ CQ(t) . Now we are in position to study the critical case: Theorem 5.8. Suppose that q satisfies (5.6) with γ = 2 and Condition 5.7. Let λ be 2-admissible and satisfy (4.21). Then ˜ (λ; A−gq ) = (4π)−1 , lim g −1/2 (ln g)−1 M
g → ∞.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
447
˜ (λ1 , λ2 ): The next theorem gives an asymptotic formula for the number N Theorem 5.9. Suppose that q satisfies (5.6) with some γ > 0, and that in the case s = −1, α ≥ 2, Condition 5.7 is also fulfilled. Let λ1 , λ2 be 2-admissible and satisfy (4.21). Then 1 ˜ (λ1 , λ2 , A±gq ) lim g − γ N Z ∞Z ∞ = [ρ(λ2 ∓ (t + σ)−2γ ) − ρ(λ1 ∓ (t + σ)−2γ )]dtdσ ,
0
(5.8)
0
as g → ∞. ˜ (λ1 , λ2 ) is described by the density of We point out that the asymptotics of N states ρ(λ) for all γ > 0. Under the conditions of Theorem 5.5 the asymptotics (5.8) can be immediately deduced from (5.7) with the help of (4.11). On the contrary, ˜ can not be inferred from the asymptotics for α > 2 and s = −1 the behaviour of N ˜ of M (λ) which is given by the Weyl term, see Lemma 5.2. Let us proceed to the exponential potentials. From Lemma 5.3 we know that for ˜ (λ; Asq ) is described the case q ≤ CQ, Q(t) = e−2κt , s = −1, the asymptotics of M by the Weyl formula (4.31). The next theorem gives an answer in the case s = +1. Below g0 > e is a constant. Theorem 5.10. Suppose that cQ(t) ≤ q(t) ≤ CQ(t) ,
∀ t ≥ R0 ,
(5.9)
−2κt
with Q(t) = e , κ > 0 and some R0 ≥ 0. Let λ, λ1 , λ2 be arbitrary numbers satisfying (4.21). Then ˜ (λ; Agq ) = 1 ρ(λ)(ln g)2 + O(ln g) , M 8κ2
g ≥ g0 ,
(5.10)
and ˜ 1 , λ2 ; Agq ) ≤ C ln g , N(λ
g ≥ g0 .
(5.11)
The next result complements the Weyl formula (4.31) by providing an estimate ˜ (λ1 , λ2 ; A−gq ): for the function N Theorem 5.11. Suppose that q fulfills Condition 5.7 with Q(t) = e−2κt . Let λ1 , λ2 be arbitrary numbers satisfying (4.21). Then ˜ (λ1 , λ2 ; A−gq ) ≤ C(ln g)2 , N
g ≥ g0 .
(5.12)
6. Individual Estimates and Weyl Asymptotics with a Remainder 6.1. Individual estimates Here we obtain further estimates for individual counting functions M (λ; ±gq, ∆). Although our ultimate objective is to establish asymptotic formulae for the counting functions M (λ; ±gqk ) with integer non-negative k’s, most of the results in this
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
448
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
section are uniform with respect to a wide class of potentials, including the shifted potentials qR , R ≥ 0. Unless stated otherwise, in this section we always assume that the points λ, λ1 , λ2 ∈ [λ− , λ+ ] are 1-admissible. The constants in all the estimates obtained below are • uniform in λ, λ1 , λ2 varying within any closed interval I ⊂ [λ− , λ+ ] of 1-admissible points; • independent of the coupling constant g. Whenever possible we treat the power-like and exponential potentials simultaneously. It is convenient to use the notation 1 if Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ ; g 2γ , α= (6.1) 1 ln g , if Q(t) = e−2κt . 2κ We always assume that g ≥ g0 > e, so α ≥ α0 with some α0 > 0 in both cases. The following simple lemma will be repeatedly used: Lemma 6.1. Suppose that q(t) ≤ CQ(t). (i) If Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ , then for all R ≥ 1 |M (λ; ±gq, R+ ) − M (λ; ±gq, (0, Rα))| ≤ C 0 α
(6.2)
with a constant C 0 depending only on C. Moreover, lim sup sup α−1 |M (λ; ±gq, R+ ) − M (λ; ±gq, (0, Rα))| = 0 .
(6.3)
R→∞ g≥g0
(ii) If Q(t) = e−2κt , then |M (λ; ±gq, R+ ) − M (λ; ±gq, (0, Rα))| ≤ C 0 ,
(6.4)
with a constant C 0 depending only on C. Proof. In view of the decoupling principle (4.13) |M (λ; ±gq, R+ ) − M (λ; ±gq, (0, Rα))| ≤ 2 + M (λ; ±qq, (Rα, ∞)) . If Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ and γ > 1, then by (5.2) the last term in the right hand side does not exceed g 1/2 (αR + 1)1−γ + 1 ≤ αR1−γ + 1 . This implies (6.2) and (6.3). If γ ≤ 1, then λ < λ+ (for s = −1) or λ > λ− ( for ˆ so as to ensure that M (λ; ±qq, (Rα, ˆ ∞)) = 0, s = +1). Thus one can choose R
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
449
ˆ −2γ α−2γ = R ˆ −2γ for all t ≥ Rα. ˆ Now (6.3) follows. To show (6.2) since |gq(t)| ≤ g R use the decoupling principle and (4.26) to conclude that ˆ M (λ; ±gq, (Rα, ∞)) ≤ 2 + M (λ; ±gq, (Rα, Rα)) " #1/2 Z R+1 Z −2γ ≤ C α |t| dt +α
ˆ R
|t|−γ dt + 1 + 2
R
R
≤ C(1 + α) . For the case Q(t) = e−2κt , using (5.4) we obtain the estimate: M (λ; ±gq, (Rα, ∞)) ≤ C(g 1/2 e−καR + 1) ≤ C(g 1/2−R/2 + 1) ≤ C for all R ≥ 1, as required. Lemma 6.2. Let q(t) ≤ CQ(t). (i) If Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ , then 1/2 Cg , M (λ; −gq) ≤ Cg 1/2 ln g , Cα ,
γ > 1, (6.5)
γ = 1, γ < 1.
(ii) Let either Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ with arbitrary γ > 0, or Q(t) = e−2κt . Then M (λ; gq) ≤ Cα ,
(6.6)
N (λ1 , λ2 ; gq) ≤ Cα .
(6.7)
and
Proof. (i) The estimate (6.5) for γ > 1 follows from (5.2). If γ ≤ 1, then by (4.26), Z M (λ; −gq, (0, α)) ≤ Cg ( ≤
1/2
1
−2γ
(1 + t)
1/2 Z 1/2 dt + Cg
0
α
t−γ dt + C
0
Cg 1/2 ln α ,
γ = 1,
Cα ,
γ < 1.
By virtue of Lemma 6.1 this leads to (6.5). (ii) It is clear from (4.9) that M (λ; gq, (0, α)) ≤ N (λ; 0, (0, α)) ≤ Cα . Now Lemma 6.1 gives (6.6). The estimate (6.7) follows from (6.6) and (4.10).
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
450
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
From these lemmas we can immediately deduce the asymptotics of M (λ; gq) with an exponential q. Theorem 6.3. Let q be a bounded function satisfying (5.9) with Q(t) = e−2κt . Then |M (λ; gq) − ρ(λ)α| ≤ C ,
∀α ≥ 1,
(6.8)
and N (λ1 , λ2 ; gq) ≤ C ,
∀α ≥ 1.
(6.9)
Proof. The bound for N (λ1 , λ2 ; gq) immediately follows from (6.8) by (4.11), since ρ(λ1 ) = ρ(λ2 ) for λ1 , λ2 ∈ [λ− , λ+ ]. By the decoupling principle (6.4) it suffices to study the counting functions M (λ; gq, ∆) with ∆ = (0, α). The result for the unperturbed function N (λ; 0, ∆) immediately follows from Theorem 3.4: α → ∞.
N (λ; 0, ∆) = ρ(λ)α + O(1) ,
(6.10)
To handle the perturbed function split the interval ∆ as follows: ∆ = ∆0 ∪ ∆1 ∪ ∆2 , ∆0 = (0, R0 ] ,
∆1 = (R0 , R1 α] ,
∆2 = (R1 α, α) ,
where R0 > 0 is defined in (5.9). The number R1 > 0 is found from the requirement gq(t) ≥ λ − λ0 ,
∀ t ∈ (R0 , R1 α] ,
where λ0 = θ2 = inf σ(A0 ). This implies that for R1 we can take R1 = 1 −
C0 , 2κα
(6.11)
with a sufficiently large C 0 = C 0 (λ) > 0. It follows from (6.11) and Theorem 3.4 that N (λ; gq, ∆2 ) ≤ N (λ; 0, ∆2 ) ≤ (1 − R1 )α + C 0 ≤ C 00 ,
∀α ≥ 1.
Since N (λ; gq, ∆0 ) ≤ N (λ; 0, ∆0 ) ≤ C and N (λ; gq, ∆1 ) = 0, by the decoupling principle (4.12) we have N (λ; gq, ∆) ≤ C ,
∀α ≥ 1.
Now it follows from (6.10) and (4.9) that |M (λ; gq, ∆) − ρ(λ)α| ≤ C , which implies (6.8).
α ≥ 1,
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
451
6.2. Individual asymptotics of the Weyl type with a remainder Even if a potential V ≤ 0 satisfies the conditions of Theorem 4.3, the formula (4.27) fails to provide an asymptotics for N (λ1 , λ2 ; V ) as the leading term in (4.27) does not depend on λ. Below we establish, under certain conditions on q, a Weyl-type asymptotics for M (λ; −gq, ∆) with a remainder, which allows us to obtain bounds on the growth of N (λ1 , λ2 ; −gq) as g → ∞. We begin with an asymptotic formula for the Schr¨ odinger operator −d2 /dt2 − q on a bounded interval ∆ ⊂ R+ with the Dirichlet boundary conditions but without any matching conditions. Denote the counting function of this operator by #(λ; −q, ∆). The next theorem is a minor modification of a similar statement from [21]: Theorem 6.4. Let q ∈ C1 ([0, ∞)) be a non-negative function, and let ∆ = (R1 , R2 ) with 0 ≤ R1 ≤ R2 < ∞. Then for any λ ∈ R one has Z p #(λ; −q; ∆) − 1 q(t)dt π ∆
Z ≤ ∆
p 3 |λ| + 1 |q (t)| dt + |∆| + 1 , 4π(q(t) + |λ|) π 0
(6.12)
where the constant C does not depend on ∆, g and is uniform in λ on a compact interval. Proof. Assume without loss of generality that R1 = 0. The idea is to use the fact that the number #(λ) = #(λ; −q, ∆) equals the number of roots of the solution u of the equation −u00 − qu = λu ,
u(0) = 0 ,
u0 (0) = 1 ,
(6.13)
lying strictly inside ∆. To find the number of roots, represent u in the polar form: p u(t) = β(t) sin ξ(t) , u0 (t) = β(t)f (t) cos ξ(t) , f = q + λ0 , (6.14) with a λ0 > 0. Eq. (6.13) and the above equalities define the real-valued amplitude β and the phase ξ uniquely under the assumption that ξ is continuous. Substituting (6.14) in Eq. (6.13), one obtains the following non-linear equation for ξ: f0 λ − λ0 sin(2ξ) + sin2 ξ , 2f f and a linear equation for β: ξ0 = f +
ξ(0) = 0 ,
β β 0 = − ((λ − λ0 ) sin ξ + f 0 cos ξ) cos ξ , f
β(0) =
(6.15)
1 . f (0)
Since β never vanishes, the number of roots of u equals the number of points t ∈ ∆ where ξ(t) = 0(modπ). From (6.15) it is clear that ξ 0 (t) = f (t) > 0 for those t, so that π−1 ξ(R2 ) − 1 ≤ #(λ) ≤ π −1 ξ(R2 ) .
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
452
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Therefore (6.15) implies that Z Z Z |f 0 | |λ − λ0 | #(λ) − 1 f dt ≤ dt + dt + 1 . π ∆ πf ∆ 2πf ∆ √ √ √ √ Since f ≥ λ0 , f 0 = q 0 (2f )−1 , and q + λ0 − q ≤ λ0 , this leads to Z Z Z √ |q 0 | |λ| + 2λ0 #(λ) − 1 √ qdt ≤ dt + dt + 1 . π ∆ ∆ 4π(q + λ0 ) ∆ π λ0 It remains to take λ0 = |λ| + 1. Theorem 6.5. Suppose that q satisfies Condition 5.7 and let ∆ = (R1 , R2 ) with 0 ≤ R1 ≤ R2 < ∞. Then for any λ ∈ R one has √ Z p N (λ; −gq; ∆) − g ≤ C(|∆| + 1) , q(t)dt (6.16) π ∆
for all g ≥ g0 , where the constant C does not depend on ∆, g and is uniform in λ on a compact interval. Proof. Let us split ∆ as follows: ∆=
m [
∆k ,
l = [R1 ] ,
m = [R2 ] ,
k=l
∆l = (R1 , l + 1] , ∆k = (k, k + 1] ,
∆m = (m, R2 ) ,
k = l + 1, . . . , m − 1 .
Then by the decoupling principle X N (λ; ∆k ) ≤ 2(m − l) ≤ 2(|∆| + 2) . N (λ; ∆) − k
To study each ∆k we use Theorem 6.4. Namely, since |q 0 | ≤ Q and q ≥ cQ, the estimate (6.12) yields: √ Z p N (λ; ∆k ) − g ≤C q(t)dt π ∆k with a constant independent of k. Adding up these inequalities over k = l, l + 1, . . . , m, we arrive at (6.16). Let us derive from this theorem the asymptotics for the counting function M (λ; −gq, ∆) with ∆ = (k, ∞), k > 0. Theorem 6.6. Suppose that Condition 5.7 is satisfied and let ∆ = (k, ∞), k ∈ N ∪ {0}. Then √ Z k+α p g q(t)dt ≤ Cα , ∀ g ≥ g0 , (6.17) M (λ; −gq, ∆) − π k
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
453
uniformly in k, and N (λ1 , λ2 ; −gq, ∆) ≤ Cα , −2γ
∀ g ≥ g0 .
(6.18)
−2κt
If Q(t) = (1 + t) , γ > 1 or Q(t) = e , then Z ∞p √ M (λ; −gq, ∆) − g ≤ Cα , q(t)dt π k
∀ g ≥ g0 .
(6.19)
Proof. The estimate (6.18) follows from (6.17) by virtue of (4.10). Let us prove (6.17). Let ∆1 = (k, k + α] and ∆2 = (k + α, ∞). In view of Lemma 6.1 and the relation (4.5) it suffices to show that the distribution function M (λ; −gq, ∆1 ) satisfies (6.17). This is a direct consequence of Theorem 6.5 and the identity (4.9). The formula (6.19) follows from (6.17) in view of the inequality Z ∞ p √ g q(t)dt ≤ Cα . k+α
7. Individual Asymptotics. Power-Like Potentials In this section we study the individual counting function M (λ; sgqk ) for q satisfying (5.6) with Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ , where γ > 0 is arbitrary for both cases s = ±1. In contrast to the previous section here we focus on the asymptotics of this function under the assumption that g and k tend to infinity in a coordinated way (see Lemma 7.3 below). We shall use the following notation: k+1 . (7.1) α Emphasise again that the main difference with the asymptotics obtained in Theorem 4.3 is that now it is determined by the density of states for the unperturbed operator A0 . We begin with the study of asymptotic coefficients. 1
α = g 2γ ,
β = βk (g) =
7.1. Asymptotic coefficients Introduce the asymptotic coefficients for M (λ; ±gqk ): Z ∞ F± (σ, λ) = ± [ρ(λ) − ρ(λ ∓ (s + σ)−2γ )]ds
(7.2)
0
and for N (λ1 , λ2 ; ±gqk ): G± (σ, λ1 , λ2 ) = ±(F± (σ, λ1 ) − F± (σ, λ2 )) Z ∞ = [ρ(λ2 ∓ (s + σ)−2γ ) − ρ(λ1 ∓ (s + σ)−2γ )]ds .
(7.3)
0
It is clear that F± ≥ 0 and G± ≥ 0 if λ1 ≤ λ2 . Some other useful properties of F± , G± are collected in the next lemma:
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
454
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Lemma 7.1. Let λ, λ1 , λ2 ∈ [λ− , λ+ ] be 1-admissible numbers. Then the integral F± (σ, λ) is finite for all σ > 0. Moreover, (i) If γ > 1, then F− (σ, λ) ≤ Cσ1−γ , F+ (σ, λ) ≤ C(1 + σ)1−γ , for all σ > 0. (ii) If γ ≤ 1, then F+ (σ, λ) ≤ C and ( F− (σ, λ) ≤
C, C ln(σ
γ < 1, −1
+ 1) ,
γ = 1.
(iii) If s = +1 and λ > λ− or s = −1 and λ < λ+ , then F± (σ, λ) = 0 for all −
1
σ ≥ σ± (λ) = d± 2γ with d± = |λ − λ∓ |, and 3
F± (σ, λ) ≥ C(σ± − σ) 2 ,
σ ≤ σ± .
(iv) The integral Z F±R (σ, λ) = ±
R
[ρ(λ) − ρ(λ ∓ (s + σ)−2γ )]ds ,
R > 0,
(7.4)
0
tends to F± (σ, λ) as R → ∞ uniformly in σ > 0. (v) For all γ > 0 one has G± (σ, λ1 , λ2 ) ≤ C, ∀ σ > 0. Proof. (i) By (3.24), the integrand in the definition (7.2) does not exceed C(s + σ)−γ for s = −1 and min{ρ(λ), C(s + σ)−γ } for s = +1. The required estimates follow immediately. (ii) Let γ ≤ 1. Let first s = +1, so that λ ∈ (λ− , λ+ ]. Define R > 0 to be the number such that λ − R−2γ = λ− . Consequently, λ − (s + σ)−2γ ≥ λ− for s + σ ≥ R, and hence ρ(λ) − ρ(λ − (s + σ)−2γ ) = 0 , This implies that
Z F+ (σ, λ) ≤
R
∀s : s + σ ≥ R.
ρ(λ)ds = Rρ(λ) ≤ C 0 (λ) .
0
Consider now the case s = −1, so that λ ∈ [λ− , λ+ ). Let R > 0 be the number such that λ + R−2γ = λ+ . Consequently, λ + (s + σ)−2γ ≤ λ+ for s + σ ≥ R, and hence ρ(λ + (s + σ)−2γ ) − ρ(λ) = 0 ,
∀s : s + σ ≥ R.
If σ ≥ R, then F− (σ, λ) = 0. If σ < R, then ( Z R−σ C(R) , (σ + s)−γ ds ≤ F− (σ, λ) ≤ C 0 C(R) ln(σ−1 + 1) ,
γ < 1, γ = 1.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
455
(iii) For brevity consider only the case s = −1, so that λ < λ+ . For s ≥ σ− − σ, σ− = σ− (λ), the integrand in (7.2) equals zero. Besides, as ρ(λ) = ρ(λ+ ), in view of (3.23) we have ρ(λ + (s + σ)−2γ ) − ρ(λ) ≥ c((s + σ)−2γ − d− ) 2 1
≥ c0 (σ− − σ − s) 2 , 1
∀ s ∈ (0, σ− − σ) .
Integrating this inequality in s, we obtain the required lower bound for F− (σ, λ). The analogous bound for F+ (σ, λ) is obtained in the same way. (iv) It suffices to notice that for any 1-admissible λ and any R > 0 one has Z ∞ Z ∞ ± [ρ(λ) − ρ(λ ∓ (σ + s)−2γ )]ds ≤ ± [ρ(λ) − ρ(λ ∓ s−2γ )]ds R
R
for all σ ≥ 0. (v) Arguing as on the previous step, it suffices to prove that the integral of the form (7.3) over a finite interval is bounded uniformly in σ > 0. By (3.24) |ρ(λ2 ∓ (s + σ)−2γ ) − ρ(λ1 ∓ (s + σ)−2γ )| ≤ C|λ1 − λ2 |1/2 , which provides the required boundedness. When studying the sum of the counting functions, we shall need some properties of the sum of asymptotic coefficients F± (βk , λ): Lemma 7.2. (i) Suppose that λ is a 1-admissible number and δ = δ(α) is a bounded function such that δ ≤ 1,
αδ 2γ+1 → ∞ ,
as α → ∞ .
Then for any fixed A ≥ supα δ(α) one has Z A X lim α−1 F± (βk , λ) − F± (σ, λ)dσ = 0 ,
(7.5)
g → ∞.
δ
[δα]≤k≤[Aα]
(ii) If λ, λ1 , λ2 are 2-admissible, then the integrals Z ∞ Z ∞ F+ (σ, λ)dσ , G± (σ, λ1 , λ2 )dσ 0
0
are finite. If in addition γ ∈ (0, 2), then the integral Z ∞ F− (σ, λ)dσ 0
is also finite. Proof. For brevity we omit λ from the notation of F± . (i) Let σ ∈ (k, k + 1] be an arbitrary number, and let λ1 = λ ± (s + βk )−2γ ,
λ2 = λ ± (s + σ/α)−2γ , t > 0 .
(7.6)
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
456
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Observe that |λ1 − λ2 | ≤ 2γδ −2γ−1 α−1 . Now it follows from (3.24) that |ρ(λ1 ) − ρ(λ2 )| ≤ CE1 (α, δ) ,
E1 (α, δ) = α−1/2 δ −γ−1/2 .
Thus, by definition (7.4), for each R > 0 one has Z k+1 R F±R (σ/α)dσ ≤ CRE1 (α, δ) , F± (βk ) − k or, changing the variable under the integral, Z (k+1)/α R F±R (σ)dσ ≤ CRE1 (α, δ) . F± (βk ) − α k/α Therefore Z A X −1 [Aα] R R α F± (βk ) − F± (σ)dσ δ k=[δα] Z ≤ CARE1 (α, δ) +
Z
δ [δα]α−1
F±R (σ)dσ +
([Aα]+1)α−1
A
F±R (σ)dσ .
Clearly, the first term tends to zero under the conditions (7.5). The last two integrals tend to zero as α → ∞ by Lemma 7.1(i), (ii). Consequently, for each R > 0 Z A X −1 [Aα] lim sup α F± (βk ) − F± (σ)dσ δ k=[δα] ≤ A lim sup Z + δ
max
[δα]≤k≤[Aα]
|F±R (βk ) − F± (βk )|
A
|F±R (σ) − F± (σ)|dσ ,
where lim sup is taken under the conditions (7.5). Recall that by Lemma 7.1 F±R (σ) converges to F± (σ) as R → ∞ uniformly in σ > 0. Thus the right hand side of the above inequality vanishes as R → ∞. This proves (7.6). (ii) By Lemma 7.1(i), (v), and also by definition (7.3), the functions F+ and G± are integrable in σ for γ > 2. If γ < 2, then F± , G± have compact support due to Lemma 7.1(iii). They are also integrable near σ = 0 by virtue of Lemma 7.1(i). If γ = 2, then the same applies to F+ and G± again by Lemma 7.1(i), (iii), (v). Lemma 7.2 guarantees that the asymptotic coefficients in Theorems 5.5 and 5.9 are finite.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
457
7.2. Asymptotics of M (λ; ±gqk ) Lemma 7.3. Let q satisfy (5.6), and let λ, λ1 , λ2 ∈ [λ− , λ+ ] be 1-admissible. Then for any function δ = δ(α) satisfying (7.5) and any fixed A > supα δ(α), one has lim max |α−1 M (λ; ±gqk ) − F± (βk (g), λ)| = 0 ,
(7.7)
lim max |α−1 N (λ1 , λ2 ; ±gqk ) − G± (βk (g), λ1 , λ2 )| = 0 ,
(7.8)
δ≤βk ≤A
δ≤βk ≤A
as g → ∞. Proof. Note without further ado, that (7.8) is a direct consequence of (7.7) in view of (4.11). Let us concentrate on the proof of (7.7). By (6.3) it suffices to establish the required asymptotic formula for the counting function M (λ; ±gqk , ∆) with ∆(g) = (0, Rα] and afterwards take R to infinity. The proof of this fact is an adaptation of the corresponding argument from [21]. Suppose first that q(t) = Q(t). Let us split (0, R] into L identical subintervals (sj−1 , sj ], j = 1, 2, . . . , L, so that s0 = 0, sL = R and sj+1 − sj = RL−1 , and denote ∆j = (sj−1 α, sj α] ,
j = 1, 2, . . . , L .
Define step functions qn,1 , qn,2 : qk,1 (t) = qk (sj−1 α) = qk,2 (t) = qk (sj α) =
1 , g(sj−1 + β)2γ 1 , g(sj + β)2γ
t ∈ ∆j , t ∈ ∆j .
Here we have denoted β = βk . Further proof is for the case s = −1 only. The other case is done in the same way. Clearly, qk,2 ≤ qk ≤ qk,1 , and hence the counting function of the operator A0 − gqk with the Dirichlet conditions at the ends of the interval ∆ satisfies the two-sided estimate N (λ; −gqk,2 , ∆) ≤ N (λ; −gqk , ∆) ≤ N (λ; −gqk,1 , ∆) . Let us find the asymptotics of the r.h.s. We are going to use the decoupling principle again: N (λ; −gqk,1 , ∆) ≤
L X
N (λ; −gqk,1 , ∆j ) + 2(L − 1) .
j=1
Now, using Theorem 3.4, we get for each j α−1 N (λ; −gqk,1 , ∆j ) = (sj − sj−1 )|∆j |−1 N (λ + (sj−1 + β)−2γ ; 0, ∆j ) ≤ (sj − sj−1 )ρ(λ + (sj−1 + β)−2γ ) q + C(1 + |λ| + (sj−1 + β)−2γ )α−1 ,
(7.9)
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
458
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
with a universal constant C. Since β ≥ δ, we obtain from (7.9) that X α−1 N (λ; −gqk,1 , ∆) − (sj − sj−1 )ρ(λ + (sj−1 + β)−2γ ) j
≤ (L + C(λ) + Cδ −γ )α−1 . This can be rewritten as α−1 N (λ; −gqk,1 , ∆) −
XZ
ρ(λ + (sj−1 + β)−2γ )ds
∆j
j
≤ (L + C(λ) + Cδ −γ )α−1 .
(7.10)
To replace the sum in the left hand side by the integral, we use the H¨older property (3.24) with λ1 = λ + (sj−1 + β)−2γ ,
λ2 = λ + (t + β)−2γ .
Observe that |λ1 − λ2 | = |(sj−1 + β)−2γ − (t + β)−2γ | ≤ 2γδ −2γ−1 |sj−1 − t| ≤ 2γRδ −2γ−1 L−1 ,
∀ t ∈ ∆j .
Now we infer from (3.24) that ρ(λ + (sj−1 + β)−2γ ) − ρ(λ + (t + β)−2γ ) ≤ Cδ −γ−1/2 R1/2 L−1/2 ,
t ∈ ∆j .
Substituting this estimate into (7.10), we get RR α−1 N (λ; −gqk,1 , ∆) − 0 ρ(λ + (s + β)−2γ )ds ≤ CE(α, δ, L; R) , E(α, δ, L; R) = (L + 1 + δ −γ )α−1 + δ −γ−1/2 R3/2 L−1/2 . Arguing similarly, we arrive at the analogous lower bound for N (λ; −gqk,2 , ∆). Consequently, Z R −1 ρ(λ + (s + β)−2γ )ds ≤ CE(α, δ, L; R) . α N (λ; −gqk , ∆) − 0 In view of Theorem 3.4 we also have Z −1 α N (λ; 0, ∆) −
0
R
ρ(λ)ds ≤ Cα−1 .
By (4.9), in combination with the previous estimate this gives |α−1 M (λ; −gqk , ∆) − F−R (βk , λ)| ≤ CE(α, δ, L; R) . The parameter L can be chosen so as to insure that E → 0 as α → ∞. Indeed, in view of 7.5 αδ 2γ+1 → ∞ as α → ∞. Therefore, defining L = [α1/2 δ −γ−1/2 ] ,
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
459
we guarantee that δ −2γ−1 L−1 ∼ α−1/2 δ −γ−1/2 → 0 ,
Lα−1 ∼ α−1/2 δ −γ−1/2 → 0 ,
α → ∞.
Taking R to infinity and referring to Lemma 7.1(iv), we obtain (7.7), thus completing the proof for q(t) = Q(t). It remains to include the potentials satisfying (5.6). To this end note that under the condition (5.6), for any ε > 0 Qk (t)(1 − ε) ≤ qk (t) ≤ Qk (t)(1 + ε) , if k is sufficiently large. Thus, using the monotonicity of M (λ; V ) in V (see Sec. 4) and the asymptotics (7.7) for q = Q we easily deduce (7.7) for the general case. In conclusion note that we shall not need the asymptotics (7.8) in what follows. ˜ (λ, A±gq ): Proof of Theorems 5.5 and 8. Asymptotics of M 5.8 5.11 Throughout this section we assume that λ, λ1 , λ2 are 2-admissible and satisfy (4.21). 8.1. Proof of Theorems 5.5 and 5.9 Recall that in Theorem 5.5 we assume that either s = −1, γ < 2, or s = +1 and γ > 0 is arbitrary. In Theorem 5.9, γ > 0 is arbitrary, but if s = −1 and γ ≥ 2, then the potential q satisfies Condition 5.7. Step 1. To begin with we show that “small” or “large” values of k do not contribute ˜ and N ˜. to the sums M Suppose that k ≥ Aα with some fixed A > 0. Then for γ ≤ 2 and large A the perturbation gqk ≤ CA−2γ is small and therefore M (λ, ±gqk ) = 0, since λ is strictly inside the gap. For γ > 2, by (5.3) we have X M (λ; ±gqk ) ≤ Cg 1/2 (Aα)2−γ = C 0 A2−γ α2 . k≥Aα
By (4.11) a similar bound holds for the sum of the functions N (λ1 , λ2 ; ±gqk ) for all γ > 0. These calculations again show that k ≥ Aα do not contribute as A grows. Suppose that k ≤ δα. If γ < 2 and s = −1, then the bounds (5.3) (for γ > 1) and (6.5) (for γ ≤ 1) ensure that for δ > 0 2−γ 2 α , 1 < γ < 2; Cδ X M (λ; −gqk ) ≤ Cδα2 ln α , γ = 1 ; (8.1) k≤δα 2 Cδα , γ < 1. This means that the share of this sum becomes small when δ → 0. For γ 6= 1 we can take δ to be arbitrarily small constant, independent of α. With γ = 1 we must
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
460
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
be more careful. Since we want to obtain the asymptotics of order α2 , we should “kill” the “ln” term in the estimate by choosing δ to be dependent on α, but in a very mild way: δ = α−η with a parameter η < (1 + 2γ)−1 , so that the condition (7.5) from Lemma 7.3 is satisfied. For s = +1 the estimate (6.6) yields: X M (λ; gqk ) ≤ Cγ δα2 , ∀ γ > 0 . k≤δα
As in the case s = −1 and γ 6= 1, it is possible to take δ to be an arbitrarily small constant. However, for the sake of uniformity, we take δ = α−η , for both signs s = ±1. Consequently, X M (λ; ±gqk ) = o(α2 ) k≤δα
˜ the estimate (6.7) and the condition (7.5) is satisfied. In the case of the function N guarantees that X N (λ1 , λ2 ; sgqk ) ≤ Cγ δα2 = o(α2 ) , (8.2) k≤δα
for s = +1 and all γ > 0. If s = −1, γ < 2, then the same bound follows from (8.1) and (4.11). In the case s = −1, γ ≥ 2 the estimate (8.2) is a direct consequence of (6.18). Thus, it remains to study the sums (4.3), (4.4) only over the numbers [δα] ≤ k ≤ [Aα] , −η
with δ = α
−1
, η < (1 + 2γ)
, and a fixed A ≥ supα δ.
Step 2. We use the notation (7.1). Estimate using (7.6): Z A X −2 [Aα] lim sup α M (λ; ±gqk ) − F± (σ, λ)dσ δ k=[δα] X
[Aα]
≤ lim sup α−1
|α−1 M (λ; ±gqk ) − F± (βk , λ)|
k=[δα]
≤ A lim sup
max [δα]≤k≤[Aα]
|α−1 M (λ; ±gqk ) − F± (βk , λ)| .
The right hand side tends to zero by Lemma 7.3. Consequently Z A [Aα] X lim α−2 M (λ; ±gqk ) − F± (σ, λ)dσ = 0 , g → ∞ . k=[δα]
δ
By (4.11) and (7.3) this equality implies that Z A [Aα] X lim α−2 N (λ1 , λ2 ; ±gqk ) − G± (σ, λ1 , λ2 )dσ = 0 , k=[δα]
δ
g → ∞.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
461
Referring to Step 1 of the proof and Lemma 7.2(ii), we can now replace the lower and upper limits of summation and integration by 0 and ∞ respectively. This completes the proof of Theorems 5.5 and 5.9. 8.2. Proof of Theorem 5.8 By (5.6), Z
∞
Z p qk (t)dt =
0
∞
0
1 + o(1) 1 + k dt = , 2 (1 + k + t) k+1
where k → 0 as k → ∞. From here we find by virtue of Theorem 6.6 that the function M ((λ) has the following asymptotics: 1/2 M (λ; −gqk ) − g ≤ Cg 1/4 + C 0 g 1/2 k , (8.3) π(k + 1) k+1 uniformly in k ≥ 0. Observe that the components with numbers k ≥ Ag 1/4 do not contribute if A is sufficiently large, since |gqk (t)| ≤ CA−4 . Let us turn to the remaining terms: 1/2 X M ˜ (λ, A−gq ) − g ln g ≤ |M (λ; −gqk ) − g 1/2 (k + 1)−1 π −1 | 4π 1/4 k≤Ag
X + g 1/2 π −1 (1 + k)−1 − ln g/4 . k≤Ag1/4 The second term in the r.h.s. is of order O(g 1/2 ) in view of the known formula for the partial sum of the harmonic series. By (8.3) the first term is bounded by X k CAg 1/2 + C 0 g 1/2 . 1+k 1/4 k≤Ag
Since k → 0 as k → ∞, this quantity is of order o(g 1/2 ln g). 8.3. Proof of Theorems 5.10 and 5.11 ˜ in the form Rewrite the sum M X ˜ (λ, Agq ) = M M (λ; ge−2κk qˆ(k) ) ,
qˆ(k) = e2κk qk .
k
Since qˆ(k) , k ≥ 0, satisfies the bound (5.9) for all t ≥ R0 , from Theorem 6.3 we obtain that |M (λ; ge−2κk qˆ(k) ) − ρ(λ)(α − k)| ≤ C ,
∀k ≤ α− 1.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
462
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Consequently,
X
M (λ; ge−2κk qˆ(k) ) = ρ(λ)
k≤α−1
X
(α − k) + O(α)
k≤α−1
=
1 ρ(λ)α2 + O(α) . 2
On the other hand, by (5.5) M (λ; ±gqk ) ≤ Cg 1/2 e−κk = Ceκ(α−k) , so that
X
M (λ; ±gqk ) ≤ C .
(8.4)
k>α−1
The asymptotics (5.10) follows. The estimates (5.11) and (5.12) are proved in the same way. By (6.9) and (8.4), (4.11) X ˜ (λ1 , λ2 ; Agq ) ≤ C + C 0 ≤ Cα . N k≤α−1 (k)
Furthermore, as qˆ
satisfies Condition 5.7 by (6.18) and (8.4), (4.11) X ˜ 1 , λ2 ; A−gq ) ≤ N(λ N (λ1 , λ2 ; −ge−2κk qˆk ) + C 0 k≤α−1
≤
X
C(α − k) + C 0 ≤ C 00 α2 .
k≤α−1
9. Asymptotics of M (λ, A±gq ) and N (λ, A±gq ) Here we turn to the study of the sums (4.1) and (4.2). As before, to ensure that they are finite we assume that λ, λ1 , λ2 satisfy (4.21) with the same closed interval I. Due to the presence of exponential terms in the sums, their study is more com˜ N ˜ , and hence the asymptotic formulae are less explicit. plicated than that of M, Another feature is that for the exponential and power-like potentials the results are qualitatively different. 9.1. Exponential potentials In this subsection we always (except for Theorem 9.3) assume that q(t) = Q(t) = e−2κt .
(9.1)
This assumption allows one to obtain asymptotic formulae based on the “selfsimilarity” property of the function e−2κt . Introduce the notation ln b = β > 0 . Theorem 9.1. Assume (9.1). Then the following two statements hold:
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
463
(i) Let κ > 0 be arbitrary. Then there exist functions ϕ± that are 2κ-periodic, bounded and separated from zero, such that lim[g − 2κ N (λ1 , λ2 ; A±gq ) − ϕ± (ln g)] = 0 , β
g → ∞.
(9.2)
(ii) Suppose that κ > 0 is arbitrary if s = +1 and κ < β if s = −1. Then there exist two functions ψ± that are 2κ-periodic, bounded and separated from zero, such that lim[g − 2κ M (λ, A±gq ) − ψ± (ln g)] = 0 , β
g → ∞.
(9.3)
We precede the proof with an elementary but convenient lemma: Lemma 9.2. Let n(t), t ∈ R be a bounded function such that ( n(t) = 0 for all t ≤ t0 with some t0 > 0 , β
n(t) ≤ Ct 2κ − , t ≥ t0 ,
(9.4)
for some > 0 .
Then for the function N (g) = n(g) + (1 − b−1 )
X
eβk n(ge−2κk )
(9.5)
k≥1
there exists a function φ which is 2κ-periodic, bounded and separated from zero, such that β
lim[g − 2κ N (g) − φ(ln g)] = 0 ,
g → ∞.
Proof. The sum in the right hand side of (9.5) is finite, since for sufficiently large k we have ge−2κk ≤ t0 . Denote β
ξ(g) = g − 2κ n(g) ,
β
Ξ(g) = g − 2κ N (g) .
Then (9.5) yields Ξ(g) = ξ(g) + (1 − b−1 )
X
ξ(ge−2κk ) ,
k≥1
which in its turn implies that Ξ(g) − Ξ(ge−2κ ) = ξ(g) − b−1 ξ(ge−2κ ) . Using the notation (6.1) and introducing new functions F (α) = Ξ(g), f (α) = ξ(g), we arrive at the equation F (α) − F (α − 1) = f (α) − b−1 f (α − 1) . Since n(t) satisfies (9.4), f (α) = 0 for α ≤ α0 = (2κ)−1 ln t0 , and f (α) ≤ Ce−2κα , α ≥ α0 . Therefore all the conditions of the Renewal theorem are satisfied (see [15, Chapter XI.1], or a modern exposition in [17]), which guarantees the existence of a 1-periodic function φ˜ which is bounded and separated from zero, such that ˜ F (α) = φ(α) + o(1) ,
α → ∞.
˜ which leads to (9.2) after substitution φ(α) = φ(α/(2κ)).
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
464
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Proof of Theorem 9.1. (i) The proof is done simultaneously for both signs s = ±1. We use Lemma 9.2 with n(g) = N (λ1 , λ2 ; ±gq). Since N (λ1 , λ2 ; ±gqk ) = n(ge−2κk ), by (4.2) the function N (g) in the r.h.s. of (9.5) coincides with N (λ1 , λ2 ; A±gq ). By (5.5) and (4.11) n(t) = 0, t ≤ t0 for a sufficiently small t0 > 0. Moreover, by (6.18) or (6.7), the second condition in (9.4) is also fulfilled for any < β(2κ)−1 . Thus the required asymptotics (9.2) follows from Lemma 9.2. (ii) The cases s = +1 and s = −1 are treated separately. Let first s = +1. Denote now n(g) = M (λ; gq). Then, similarly to the first part of the proof, the total counting function (4.1) coincides with (9.5). By (5.5) and (6.6) the function n satisfies (9.4) for any < β(2κ)−1 . Thus Lemma 9.2 guarantees the asymptotics (9.3) for s = +1. In the case s = −1, κ < β, the first condition in (9.4) is satisfied for n(g) = M (λ; −gq) in view of (5.5). Besides, (5.5) ensures also that the second condition is satisfied with = β(2κ)−1 − 1/2 > 0. Again, Lemma 9.2 leads to (9.3) for s = −1. For s = −1 the cases κ < β and κ > β are described by Theorem 9.1 and Lemma 5.3 respectively. Let us handle the critical case β = κ. We emphasise that this is the only asymptotic formula in this subsection which does not require the exact equality q(t) = e−2κt . Theorem 9.3. Suppose that q(t) = Q(t)(1 + o(1)) ,
t → ∞,
Q(t) = e−2κt ,
with κ = β, and that q satisfies Condition 5.7. Then lim
M (λ; A−gq ) 1 − b−1 = , 2πκ2 g 1/2 ln g
g → ∞.
Proof. By (5.5) M (λ; −gqk ) = 0 for all k ≥ α + A with a sufficiently large A, and X X bk M (λ; −gqk ) + bk M (λ; −gqk ) ≤ CAg 1/2 . k≤A
α−A≤k≤α+A
Consequently lim
M (λ; A−gq ) 1 − b−1 = lim 1/2 1/2 g ln g g ln g
X
eκk M (λ; −gqk ) ,
g → ∞,
(9.6)
A
if the limit in the r.h.s. exists. For k ∈ (A, α − A) apply Theorem 6.6 and the relation (4.5) to obtain the asymptotics Z g 1/2 ∞ p M (λ; −gqk ) = q(k + t)dt + O(α) π 0 = g 1/2 e−κk ((πκ)−1 + oA (1)) + O(α) ,
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
465
where oA (1) → 0 as A → ∞ uniformly in k, g. Therefore the sum in the r.h.s. of (9.6) equals X X 1 g 1/2 + g 1/2 αoA (1) + O(α) eκk πκ A
A
g 1/2 α + g 1/2 O(A) + g 1/2 αoA (1) + eκα e−κA O(α) . πκ Since α = ln g/(2κ), now it follows from (9.6) that M (λ; A−gq ) 1 − = oA (1) + O(e−κA ) . lim sup 2πκ2 g 1/2 ln g g→∞ =
Since A is arbitrary, the required result follows. 9.2. Power-like potentials For power-like potentials the asymptotic formulae that we obtain, are less informative since they are established for ln M and ln N . For the sake of illustration we consider here only M (λ; A±gq ). The corresponding asymptotics of N (λ; A±gq ) can be easily derived using the same argument as well. For simplicity we assume that q(t) = Q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ . For more general power-like potentials the results follow by monotonicity of M with respect to the potential. Recall that I denotes −
1
the interval defined in (4.21). We also use the notation d± = |λ − λ∓ |, σ± = d± 2γ introduced in Lemma 7.1(iii). Theorem 9.4. Let I be a closed interval defined in (4.21), which is strictly inside the gap (λ− , λ+ ). Let q(t) = (1 + t)−2γ , γ > 0. Then for any λ ∈ I −
1
lim α−1 ln M (λ; A±gq ) = βd± 2γ ,
g → ∞,
where β = ln b. Proof. Upper bound. A straightforward perturbation argument ensures that M (λ; ±gqk ) = 0 if gqk (t) ≤ d± , ∀ t > 0, i.e. for −
1
k ≥ K1 = K1 (g) = (d−1 g) 2γ = αd± 2γ . 1
It follows from Lemmas 5.2 and 6.2 that M (λ; ±gqk ) ≤ Cg ω with some ω = ω(γ) > 0. Substituting this bound in (4.1) gives X M (λ; A±gq ) = M (λ; ±qq) + (1 − b−1 ) bk M (λ; ±gqk ) k∈N
≤ Cg ω
K1 X
bk ≤ C 0 g ω bK1 ,
k=0 0
with a constant C depending only on b, γ.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
466
00123
A. V. Sobolev & M. Solomyak
Lower bound. For the lower bound we drop all but one term from the sum (4.1): for any ∈ (0, 1) we have M (λ; A±gq ) ≥ (1 − b−1 )bk M (λ; ±gqk ) ,
k = [(1 − )K1 ] .
By Lemmas 7.3 and 7.1(iii), −
1
M (λ; ±gqk ) ≥ cαF± (λ; βk ) ≥ c0 α(d± 2γ − βk ) 2 , 3
for sufficiently large α. Since βk = (k + 1)α−1 , we see that the r.h.s. is bounded from below by c00 α3/2 with a constant depending only on d± . Consequently, 3
M (λ; A±gq ) ≥ c 2 αbK1 (1−) , with a constant depending on b, λ and γ. Since > 0 is arbitrary, in combination with the upper bound, this gives the required asymptotics. Acknowledgments The second author (M.S.) was partly supported by the Minerva center for nonlinear physics and by the Israel Science Fundation, and partly by the EPSRC grant GR/N 37193/01. This paper was essentially completed when M.S. was visiting King’s College, London in April–May 2001. The authors are grateful to Yu. Safarov for valuable discussions. References [1] S. Alama, P. A. Deift and R. Hempel, Eigenvalue branches of the Schr¨ odinger operator H − λW in a gap of σ(H), Comm. Math. Phys. 121 (1989) 291–321. [2] C. Allard and R. Froese, A Mourre estimate for a Schr¨ odinger operator on a binary tree, Rev. Math. Phys. 12(12) (2000) 1655–1667. [3] M. Sh. Birman, Discrete spectrum in the gaps of a continuous one for perturbations with large coupling constant, in Estimates and Asymptotics for Discrete Spectra of Integral and Differential Equations, Leningrad, 1989–90, Adv. Soviet Math., 7, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1991, pp. 57–73. [4] M. Sh. Birman and V. V. Borzov, On the asymptotics of the discrete spectrum for certain singular differential operators, Probl. Mat. Fiz. 5 (1971), 24–38; English transl. in Topics in Math. Phys. 5 (1972). [5] M. Sh. Birman and A. Laptev, Discrete spectrum of the perturbed Dirac operator, Ark. Mat. 32(1) (1994) 13–32. [6] , The negative discrete spectrum of a two-dimensional Schr¨ odinger operator, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 49(9) (1996) 967–997. [7] M. Sh. Birman, A. Laptev and M. Solomyak, On the eigenvalue behaviour for a class of differential operators on semiaxis, Math. Nachr. 195 (1998) 17–46. [8] M. Sh. Birman and M. Solomyak, Quantitative analysis in Sobolev imbedding theorems and applications to spectral theory, in Tenth Mathem. School, Izd. Inst. Mat. Akad. Nauk Ukrain, SSSR, Kiev, 1974 (Russian), pp. 5–189; English translation in Amer. Math. Soc. Translations 114(2) (1980) 1–132.
June 4, 2002 11:0 WSPC/148-RMP
00123
Schr¨ odinger Operators on Homogeneous Metric Trees
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21]
467
, Estimates for the number of negative eigenvalues of the Schr¨ odinger operator and its generalizations, in Estimates and Asymptotics for Discrete Spectra of Integral and Differential Equations, Leningrad, 1989–90, Adv. Soviet Math., 7, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1991, pp. 1–5. , On the negative discrete spectrum of a periodic elliptic operator in a waveguide-type domain, perturbed by a decaying potential, J. d’Anal. Math. 83 (2000) 337–391. M. Sh. Birman and G. D. Raikov, Discrete spectrum in the gaps for perturbations of the magnetic Schr¨ odinger operator, Estimates and Asymptotics for Discrete Spectra of Integral and Differential Equations Leningrad, 1989–90, Adv. Soviet Math., 7, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1991, pp. 75–84. R. Carlson, Hill’s equation for a homogeneous tree, Electron. J. Differen. Equations 1997 (23), 30 pp. (electronic). , Nonclassical Sturm–Liouville problems and Schr¨ odinger operators on radial trees, Electron. J. Differen. Equations 2000 (71), 24 pp. (electronic). P. A. Deift and R. Hempel, On the existence of eigenvalues of the Schr¨ odinger operator H − λW in a gap of σ(H), Comm. Math. Phys. 103 (1986) 461–490. W. Feller, An Introduction to the Probability Theory and Its Applications, Vol. II, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York-London-Sidney-Toronto, 1971. M. Klaus, On the point spectrum of Dirac operators, Helv. Phys. Acta 53 (1980) 453–462. M. Levitin and D. Vassiliev, Spectral asymptotics, renewal theorem, and the Berry conjecture for a class of fractals, Proc. London Math. Soc. 72(3) (1996) 188–214. K. Naimark and M. Solomyak, Eigenvalue estimates for the weighted Laplacian on metric trees, Proc. London Math. Soc. 80(3) (2000) 690–724. , Geometry of the Sobolev spaces on the regular trees and Hardy’s inequalities, Russian J. Math. Physics 8(3) (2001). R. V. Romanov and G. E. Rudin, Scattering on the Bruhat-Tits tree. I, Phys. Lett. A198 (1995) 113–118. A. V. Sobolev, Weyl asymptotics for the discrete spectrum of the perturbed Hill operator, in Estimates and Asymptotics for Discrete Spectra of Integral and Differential Equations, Leningrad, 1989–90, Adv. Soviet Math., 7, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1991, pp. 159–178.
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Reviews in Mathematical Physics, Vol. 14, No. 5 (2002) 469–510 c World Scientific Publishing Company
EVOLUTION OF CENTRAL MOMENTS FOR A GENERAL-RELATIVISTIC BOLTZMANN EQUATION: THE CLOSURE BY ENTROPY MAXIMIZATION
ZBIGNIEW BANACH Centre of Mechanics, Institute of Fundamental Technological Research Department of Fluid Mechanics, Polish Academy of Sciences Swietokrzyska 21, 00-049 Warsaw, Poland
[email protected] WIESLAW LARECKI Institute of Fundamental Technological Research Department of Theory of Continuous Media Polish Academy of Sciences, Swietokrzyska 21, 00-049 Warsaw, Poland
[email protected]
Received 8 August 2001 Revised 28 January 2002
Beginning from the relativistic Boltzmann equation in a curved space-time, and assuming that there exists a fiducial congruence of timelike world lines with four-velocity vector field u, it is the aim of this paper to present a systematic derivation of a hierarchy of closed systems of moment equations. These systems are found by using the closure by entropy maximization. Our concepts are primarily applied to the formalism of central moments because if an alternative and more familiar theory of covariant moments is taken into account, then the method of maximum entropy is ill-defined in a neighborhood of equilibrium states. The central moments are not covariant in the following sense: two observers looking at the same relativistic gas will, in general, extract two different sets of central moments, not related to each other by a tensorial linear transformation. After a brief review of the formalism of trace-free symmetric spacelike tensors, the differential equations for irreducible central moments are obtained and compared with those of Ellis et al. [Ann. Phys. (NY) 150 (1983) 455]. We derive some auxiliary algebraic identities which involve the set of central moments and the corresponding set of Lagrange multipliers; these identities enable us to show that there is an additional balance law interpreted as the equation of balance of entropy. The above results are valid for an arbitrary choice of the Lorentzian metric g and the four-velocity vector field u. Later, the definition of u as in the well-known theory of Arnowitt, Deser, and Misner is proposed in order to construct a hierarchy of symmetric hyperbolic systems of field equations. Also, the Eckart and Landau–Lifshitz definitions of u are discussed. Specifically, it is demonstrated that they lead, in general, to the systems of nonconservative equations. Keywords: General-relativistic kinetic theory; differential equations for central moments; closure by entropy maximization; symmetric hyperbolic systems. PACS Nos.: 04.20.-q, 05.20.Dd, 05.70.Ln, 47.75.+f 469
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
470
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
1. Introduction In general-relativistic kinetic theory of classical and quantum ideal gases [1, 2], a traditional way of defininig the moments of the distribution function is to multiply this function by tensorial powers of the particle four-momentum and then to integrate the resulting products over the future mass-shell [3, 4]. We call these traditional moments the covariant moments, since the calculations leading to them do not require that there exists a 3 + 1 splitting of space-time determined by some chosen four-velocity vector field. On the other hand, if our space-time is supplied with a preferred four-velocity vector field corresponding to a congruence of timelike world lines (world lines of observers), it will also be possible to introduce the so-called central moments of the distribution function. As noted already by van Kampen [5], these central moments are not covariant in the following sense: two observers looking at the same relativistic gas will, in general, extract two different sets of central moments, not related to each other by a tensorial linear transformation. Within the context of general-relativistic radiative transfer, the idea of using such central moments was explained by Anderson and Spiegel [6], and mathematical and physical aspects of their formalism have been developed by Thorne [7]. For particles with both vanishing and nonvanishing proper mass, a very complete elaboration of the formalism, taking account of the most general definition of a central moment, has been given by Ellis et al. [8, 9]. More recently, Struchtrup [10] considered a new central-moment closure of the relaxation-time model equation of Anderson and Witting [11] as opposed to that based on the covariant moments [12, 13]. Finally, we mention that Banach [14] and Banach and Larecki [15] investigated two preferred sets of central moments, the basic role of which is associated with the unique parametrization of the space of distribution functions and the exact decomposition of the Boltzmann entropy (per unit volume) into equilibrium and nonequilibrium parts. In this context, see also our discussion in Sec. 5.1. Beginning from the relativistic Boltzmann equation in a curved or flat spacetime, it is the aim of this paper to present a systematic derivation of two different hierarchies of closed systems of moment equations. These derivations adopt the closure by entropy maximization, and here we note that an analogous method of truncating the nonrelativistic moment equations has been carried out by Dreyer [16] and Levermore [17]. We consider two moment formalisms. The first formalism applies to covariant moments, while the second formalism starts with essentially the same general program but uses the central moments in place of covariant ones. In the case of covariant moments, a major problem confronts the mathematical procedure for deriving evolution equations by means of a maximum entropy principle. Indeed, for any member of a hierarchy of closed systems of moment equations, approaches of this type impose some restrictions on the possible values of moments or other equivalent variables, and it is physically clear that they are not natural unless the Euler system is the theme of interest. The basic conclusion is as follows. In the formalism of covariant moments, the method of maximum entropy is ill-defined in a neighborhood of equilibrium states. A very similar situation exists concerning the
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
471
nonrelativistic gas [17], where only two physically satisfactory members of the hierarchy are possible. The first one is the Euler system, which is based on Maxwellian velocity distributions, while the second is based on the 10 moment, nonisotropic Gaussian closure. Systematically, this closure was first discussed by Banach and Piekarski [18]. Later, it has been used as a starting point for a thermodynamic description of ideal gases under shear [19] and for an analysis of the nature of shock profiles [20]. Since the aforementioned difficulties are unavoidable in the case of covariant moments, this paper is primarily concerned with the general structure of a theory of central moments. Precisely speaking, we find that if the relativistic gas consists of particles with proper mass different from zero, then the method of maximum entropy applied to two suitably chosen sets of central moments automatically leads to a well-defined hierarchy of closed systems of field equations. This result explains, for the first time, the idea of M¨ uller and Ruggeri [13] that the closure by entropy maximization really yields a “theory of theories,” which carries its own proof of validity: as soon as an increase of the number of central moments does not improve a result, we know the the extant number is sufficient. Our constructions are also valid for the case of a gas of massless particles, although a fully satisfactory theory of theories cannot be obtained by exploiting the maximum entropy closure in this case. As to the details, see Secs. 5.1 and 7. Now, in order to prove that each member of the hierarchy is consistent with a supplementary balance law, interpreted as the equation of balance of entropy, we derive some auxiliary algebraic identities which involve the set of central moments and the corresponding set of Lagrange multipliers. These identities and the formulas of Secs. 2–5 can be constructed quite generally in a completely rigorous way for an arbitrary Lorentzian metric g and an arbitrary four-velocity vector field u. However, it is sometimes natural to assume that there exists a “slacing” of the space-time manifold X by spacelike Cauchy surfaces Σt , labeled by the time parameter t. According to the well-known formalism of Arnowitt et al. [21], the Lorentzian metric g is then projected along, and orthogonal to, the hypersurfaces of the foliation to give a canonical picture in which u is the unit (future-directed) normal to Σt . Our reply to the question “why do we define in Secs. 6.1 and 6.2 the four-velocity vector field u in this way?” is that we also want to obtain a hierarchy of symmetric hyperbolic systems of field equations [22], because they ensure well-posedness of local Cauchy problems [23]. Of course, many interesting problems arise when attempting to implement the alternative definitions of u such as, e.g. the Eckart and Landau–Lifshitz options [24, 25]. As we shall see, in discussing these two options, one is led inevitably to the systems of nonconservative equations. Consequently, no immediate proof of symmetric hyperbolicity of the field equations can be provided, except in the cases mentioned in Sec. 6.3. Another remark is simply this. Given a choice of a timelike vector field, Ellis et al. [8, 9] proposed a spherical harmonic analysis of the distribution function f , obtaining differential equations for a set of moments of the spherical harmonic components of f , which are the quantities of physical interest and which they represent
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
472
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
as trace-free symmetric spacelike tensors. However, such irreducible equations can also be extracted directly from the equations for central moments by using the method of Banach and Piekarski [26]. These matters are not altogether trivial or immediate, and thus we hope that the alternative and relatively simple derivation given here will prove to be useful. The layout of this paper is as follows. Section 2 establishes our notation for tensors. Section 3 first defines the relativistic Boltzmann equation in a curved spacetime and then considers the difficulties associated with deriving a hierarchy of closed systems of equations for covariant moments. Sections 4 and 5 develop a theory of central moments, since this theory is superior to the more familiar covariant formalism in that it meshes more naturally with the concept of closure by a maximum entropy principle. Within the framework of a theory of central moments, Sec. 6 discusses the crucial assumptions that enter into the construction of symmetric hyperbolic systems of field equations. Section 7 concludes by summmarizing the principal results and indicating the direction of future research. Some intermediate calculations are put into the Appendix. Our signature convention is (−, +, +, +). Lowercase Latin indices are used for the general basis and uppercase Latin indices for the coordinate basis. If they are taken from the beginning of the alphabet, i.e. (a, b, . . . , h; A, B, . . . , H), their range is {0, 1, 2, 3}, whereas for the middle of the alphabet, i.e. (i, j, . . . , n; I, J, . . . , N ), their range is only {1, 2, 3}. In Sec. 6, we adopt the notation of Thorne [7]: M Ωα := M i1 i2 ···iα ,
(1.1)
where a capital Greek superscript denotes a string of lowercase Latin indices; their number is denoted by a lowercase Greek subscript on the capital superscript (ip = 1, 2, 3; p = 1, 2, . . . , α). The units are such that c, kB , and ~ are equal to 1. 2. Preliminaries 2.1. Basic tensorial definitions For each point of the space-time manifold X, we denote by Tβα (x) the space of tensors of type (α, β) at x ∈ X. Let {ea } be a basis of vectors at x, and suppose that {ea } is a basis dual to {ea }. If we introduce the simple tensors ea1 ···aα := ea1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ eaα
(2.1a)
eb1 ···bβ := eb1 ⊗ · · · ⊗ ebβ ,
(2.1b)
and
then an arbitrary tensor Mβα ∈ Tβα (x) can be expressed in terms of these tensors as Mβα = Mβαa1 ···aα b
1 ···bβ
ea1 ···aα ⊗ eb1 ···bβ ,
(2.2)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
where {Mβαa1 ···aα b
1 ···bβ
473
} are the components of Mβα with respect to the dual bases
{ea } and {ea }. By definition, we say that M α ∈ T0α (x) is a tensor of type α at x. The action of the symmetrizer S on a tensor M α of type α is given by SM α := M α(a1 ···aα ) ea1 ···aα ,
α ≥ 2,
(2.3)
where parentheses enclosing a set of α indices represent symmetrization of these indices, i.e. the sum of M αa1 ···aα over α! permutations of the indices, divided by α!. For M 1 ∈ T01 (x) and M 0 ∈ T00 (x), we set SM 1 := M 1 and SM 0 := M 0 . Now, suppose that M α and M β are the tensors of types α and β, respectively. Then the equality M α ∨ M β := S(M α ⊗ M β ) (α ≥ 1, β ≥ 1)
(2.4)
defines the symmetric tensor product of M α and M β . If α ≥ β = 0, we set M α ⊗ M 0 := M 0 M α , M 0 ⊗ M α := M 0 M α , M α ∨ M 0 := M 0 (SM α ), and M 0 ∨ M α := M 0 (SM α ). Let g = gab ea ⊗ eb be the metric on X. The trace operator with respect to the pair (µ, ν), denoted by Tr(µ,ν) , determines a linear map: Tr(µ,ν) : T0α (x) → T0α−2 (x) ,
α ≥ 2.
(2.5)
Because of this, we only need to consider how it operates on simple tensors: Tr(µ,ν) ea1 ···aα := gaµ aν ea1 ···ˆaµ ···ˆaν ···aα .
(2.6)
Here the hat over aµ and aν tells us that eaµ and eaν do not appear in ea1 ···aµ ···aν ···aα . Clearly, Tr(µ,ν) M α is a tensor of type α − 2 if M α is a tensor of type α. For symmetric tensors M α ∈ T0α (x), α ≥ 2, we abbreviate Tr(µ,ν) M α as Tr M α . In the cases α = 1 and α = 0, it will be convenient to set Tr M 1 := M 1 and Tr M 0 := M 0 . If M α ∈ T0α (x), α ≥ 2, is a symmetric tensor, we define Trβ M α , β ≥ 0, by the following formulas: Trβ M α := Tr(Trβ−1 M α ) ,
(2.7a)
Tr1 M α := Tr M α ,
(2.7b)
Tr0 M α := M α .
Consequently, Trβ M α is the result of the β-fold successive application of the Tr operator to the symmetric tensor M α ∈ T0α (x), α ≥ 2. We extend the above definition of Trβ M α to the cases α = 1 and α = 0 by setting Trβ M 1 := M 1 and Trβ M 0 := M 0 . Let µ := min(α, β). Then the µ-fold contraction of M α ∈ T0α (x) with M β ∈ β T0 (x) will be denoted by M α ◦M β . The tensor M α ◦M β of type α+β −2µ is usually termed the inner tensor product of M α and M β . However, if M α and M β are not totally symmetric tensors, then some convention as to which of the 2µ indices are to be contracted, must be followed when doing the contraction. Since M α ◦ M β is
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
474
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
a bilinear operation on M α and M β , this convention can be read directly from the definition of ea1 ···aα ◦ eb1 ···bβ : ga1 b1 · · · gaβ bβ eaβ+1 ···aα for α > β , (2.8) ea1 ···aα ◦ eb1 ···bβ := ga1 b1 · · · gaβ bβ for α = β , for α < β . ga1 b1 · · · gaα bα ebα+1 ···bβ These constructions, which imply that M α ◦M β = M β ◦M α , are only valid for α ≥ 1 and β ≥ 1. In other cases, i.e. if α ≥ β = 0, we simply write M α ◦ M 0 := M 0 M α and M 0 ◦ M α := M 0 M α . Recalling the definitions of S and Tr(µ,ν) , the action of t on M α ∈ T0α (x) and M β ∈ T0β (x) is characterized by M α t M β := S Tr(1,α+β) (M α ⊗ M β ) ,
α +β ≥ 2.
(2.9)
¯ α are the tensors of type α and α ≥ 2, then the action of on Next, if M α and M α α ¯ M and M is described by ¯ α := M αaa2 ···aα M ¯ αb a2 ···aα ea ⊗ eb , Mα M
(2.10)
¯ αb a2 ···aα := ga2 b2 · · · gaα bα M ¯ αbb2 ···bα . M
(2.11)
where
¯ αbb2 ···bα }, these are the componets of M α and As regards {M αaa2 ···aα } and {M α ¯ ¯ 1 ∈ T 1 (x), the tensor M with respect to the basis {ea }. For M 1 ∈ T01 (x) and M 0 1 1 ¯ is given by M M ¯ 1 := M 1a M ¯ 1b ea ⊗ eb . M1 M
(2.12)
¯ 0 ∈ T 0 (x), it will be natural to identify M 0 M ¯ 0 with For M 0 ∈ T00 (x) and M 0 α ¯ α is an the zero tensor of type 2. From all these definitions we infer that M M element of T02 (x). Consider a space-time in which there exists a fiducial congruence of timelike world lines (world lines of “fiducial observers”) with four-velocity vector field u = ua ea . Using gab and ua := gab ub , we define Iab by Iab := gab + ua ub : I ab := g ab + ua ub
(g ac gcb = δ a b ) ,
(2.13a)
I a b := g a b + ua ub
(g a b = δ a b ) .
(2.13b)
The tensor I a b ea ⊗ eb projects orthogonal to u. For any Mβα ∈ Tβα (x), we can construct (Mβα )⊥ ∈ Tβα (x) in such a way that the components {(Mβα )⊥ a1 ···aα b1 ···bβ } of (Mβα )⊥ with respect to the dual bases {ea } and {ea } are given by (Mβα )⊥
a1 ···aα
b1 ···bβ
:= I a1 c1 · · · I aα cα I d1 b1 · · · I dβ bβ Mβαc1 ···cα d
1 ···dβ
.
(2.14)
A tensor Mβα ∈ Tβα (x) will be referred to as spacelike whenever it is orthogonal to u, i.e. whenever Mβα = (Mβα )⊥ . For M 0 ∈ T00 (x), we put (M 0 )⊥ := M 0 and thus
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
475
say that M 0 is spacelike. This definition of M 0 as a spacelike quantity is valid for all choices of u. Using Eq. (2.13a), we introduce the projection tensor I and its tensorial powers I α: I := I ab ea ⊗ eb ,
(2.15a)
I α := ⊗α I
(2.15b)
(I 0 := 1, I 1 := I) .
If α ≥ 2 and M α ∈ T0α (x) is a symmetric spacelike tensor, the trace-free part of M α will be defined by [26] X
[α/2]
hM α i :=
(−1)β k(α − 1 − β, β)l(α, β)[(Trβ M α ) ∨ I β ] ,
(2.16)
β=0
where [α/2] means the largest integer less than or equal to α/2 and k(α, β) :=
(2α + 1)!! , (2α + 2β + 1)!!
l(α, β) :=
α! , 2β β!(α − 2β)!
(2α + 1)!! := 1 · 3 · 5 · · · (2α + 1) .
(2.17a) (2.17b)
With Eqs. (2.16) and (2.17), elementary inspection shows that TrhM α i = 0, where α ≥ 2 and 0 ∈ T0α−2 (x). For scalars M 0 ∈ T00 (x) and spacelike vectors M 1 ∈ T01 (x), we also define hM 0 i and hM 1 i: hM 0 i := M 0 ,
hM 1 i := M 1 .
(2.18)
Given the spacelike tensors M α ∈ T0α (x), the following notation will be useful [see Eqs. (2.4), (2.9), and (2.16)]: M α ? M β := hM α ∨ M β i ,
(2.19a)
M α u M β := hM α t M β i .
(2.19b)
If these spacelike tensors are such that S M α = M α , then the further useful tensors are defined by ˆ α[β] := Trβ M α , M
ˆ α|β := Trβ M α+2β , M
(2.20a)
ˆ α[β] i , M α[β] := hM
ˆ α|β i . M α|β := hM
(2.20b)
ˆ α|β = M ˆ α+2β[β] and M α|β = M α+2β[β] . Clearly, using these definitions, we have M Here, of course, care has to be taken with the interpretation of M α[β] for β = [α/2]: M 2α[α] := hTrα M 2α i := Trα M 2α ,
(2.21a)
M 2α+1[α] := hTrα M 2α+1 i := Trα M 2α+1 .
(2.21b)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
476
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
Let M α ∈ T0α (x) and (M α )⊥ = M α = SM α . Then there exists the relation [26] X
[α/2]
Mα =
k(α − 2β, β)l(α, β)(M α[β] ∨ I β ) ,
α ≥ 0,
(2.22)
β=0
expressing M α in terms of M α[β] . 2.2. Differential operations on tensor fields Let ∇ be the covariant derivative determined by the metric g. This derivative generates a tensor field of type (α, 1) from a tensor field of type (α, 0): ∇M α := (∇b M αa1 ···aα )ea1 ···aα ⊗ eb .
(2.23)
Note that Eq. (2.23) is valid for the general dual bases {ea } and {ea }. For each ∇M α , we can introduce an associated tensor (∇M α )0 of type (α + 1, 0) by (∇M α )0 := (g ab ∇b M αa1 ···aα )ea1 ···aα ⊗ ea .
(2.24)
Consider also the tensorial objects ∇ · M α and ∇ ∨ M α defined by ∇ · M α := Tr(α,α+1) (∇M α )0
(α ≥ 1)
(2.25a)
and ∇ ∨ M α := S(∇M α )0 .
(2.25b)
According to these definitions, ∇·M is a tensor field of type (α−1, 0) and ∇∨M α is a symmetric tensor field of type (α + 1, 0). Given the four-velocity vector field u, the time derivative of any tensor M α along the fundamental flow lines is α
M˙ α := Tr(1,α+1) [u ⊗ (∇M α )0 ] .
(2.26)
If u˙ does not vanish, then (M˙ α )⊥ is, in general, different from [(M α )⊥ ]· when α > 0. In this paper, we denote u˙ by a [see, e.g. Eq. (3.14)]. In view of these definitions [see also Eq. (2.14)], we are now prepared to construct the following additional operations on M α : ∇⊥ M α := (∇M α )⊥ ,
(2.27a)
(∇⊥ M α )0 := [(∇M α )0 ]⊥ ,
(2.27b)
∇⊥ · M α := Tr(α,α+1) (∇⊥ M α )0 ,
(2.27c)
∇⊥ ∨ M α := S(∇⊥ M α )0 ,
(2.27d)
∇⊥ ? M α := h∇⊥ ∨ M α i .
(2.27e)
In the sequence (2.27), it appears that the operation (2.24) commutes with the taking of the “perp” operation. Using Eqs. (2.25) and (2.27), it is a straightforward matter to verify that ∇⊥ ∨ M α = (∇ ∨ M α )⊥
(2.28a)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
477
and ∇⊥ ? M α = h(∇ ∨ M α )⊥ i .
(2.28b)
However, ∇⊥ · M α cannot be set equal to (∇ · M α )⊥ , except in the case when Tr(1,α+1) (u ⊗ M α ) and a vanish. 3. Structural Features of a Theory with Covariant Moments 3.1. The Boltzmann equation in a curved space-time We restrict ourselves to the situation in which the uncharged (i.e. neutral) particles of the gas all have identical proper mass m so that m2 = −¯ p ◦ p¯, where p¯ is the four-momentum of the particle: p¯ = pa ea = p0 e0 + pi ei .
(3.1)
˜ be We mostly assume m 6= 0, leaving the case m = 0 to be treated as a limit. Let X the one-particle phase-space for particles of arbitrary proper masses. Then m given ˜ which is constant on each phase orbit. The by (−¯ p ◦ p¯)1/2 is a scalar function on X ˜ hypersurface of X defined by m = const is generated by all those phase orbits which ˜ m for it. Clearly, X ˜ m is belong to the assigned mass value; we use the symbol X the phase space for particles of proper mass m, its dimension is 7. A more detailed discussion of these issues is presented in [1, pp. 26–28]. If u is a future directed timelike vector field (u ◦ u = −1), then the future directed particle four-momenta p¯ satisfy the inequality u ◦ p¯ < 0. In Eq. (3.1), the basis {ea } is a general tetrad basis. Clearly, such a basis can be obtained from a coordinate basis {∂A } by determining the functions ea A which are the components of ea with respect to {∂A }: ea = ea A ∂A
(∂A := ∂/∂xA ) .
(3.2)
For the dual basis {ea }, a consequence of this is that ea = ea A dxA ,
(3.3)
where ea A eb A = δ a b ,
ea A ea B = δ A B .
(3.4)
An obvious way of describing the particles in a given region of space-time is to specify a one-particle distribution function f (xA , pi ) which represents the number of particles at event x with four-momentum p¯. For a single particle, the phase space is the seven-dimensional tangent bundle on X, coordinatized by (xA , pi ), with basic metric g: g = gab ea ⊗ eb = gAB dxA ⊗ dxB .
(3.5)
In a curved space-time, the distribution function f satisfies the following Boltzmann equation [8]: pa ∂a f − Γi ab pa pb
∂f = J(f ) , ∂pi
(3.6)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
478
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
where J(f ) is the collision term. As to the meaning of ∂a and Γa bc , these objects are defined by ∂a := ea A ∂A
(∂a = ea )
(3.7a)
and Γa bc := ea A ec B (∂B eb A + ΓA DB eb D ) = ea A ec B ∇B eb A ,
(3.7b)
where ΓA BC are the Christoffel symbols of gAB . In kinetic theory, a knowledge of the distribution function f enables us to determine the entropy four-vector. For each x ∈ X, this entropy four-vector is characterized by Z Ψ := −y p¯H(f¯)πm , (3.8) where f¯ := y −1 f ,
y := w/(2π)3 ,
(3.9a)
¯ ¯ , H(f¯) := f(|η| − 1 + ln f¯) − η(1 + η f¯) ln(1 + η f) p |g| 1 πm := − dp ∧ dp2 ∧ dp3 , p0
(3.9b)
|g| := − det(gab ) .
(3.9d)
p0 := g0a pa ,
(3.9c)
Here the value of η is made to be +1 for bosons, −1 for fermions, and 0 for classical particles. Further, explaining Eqs. (3.9a), the quantity w equals 2¯ s + 1 for particles with spin s¯ and proper mass m different from zero, w = 2 for particles with s¯ > 0 and m = 0, and w = 1 for particles with s¯ = 0 and m = 0. Given a four-velocity vector field u, the specification of Ψ is completely equivalent to specifying Z s := −y (−¯ p ◦ u)H(f¯)πm (3.10a) and
Z Φ := −y
pH(f¯)πm ,
(3.10b)
where p := p¯ + (¯ p ◦ u)u
(u ◦ p = 0) .
(3.11)
For essentially obvious reasons, it will be convenient to call s the entropy per unit volume and Φ the entropy flux vector. Now, we come to the entropy law. Multiplying Eq. (3.6) by −dH/df¯ = |η| ln(1 + η f¯) − ln f¯ and integrating over momentum space yields ∇·Ψ= P
(P ≥ 0) ,
(3.12)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
where
479
Z (dH/df¯)J(f )πm .
P := −
(3.13)
We refer to P as the entropy production. Because of the well-known properties of J(f ), this entropy production is nonnegative. In order to cast Eq. (3.12) into a form consistent with the decomposition Ψ = su + Φ, we first observe that (∇u)0 = (g bc ∇c ua )ea ⊗ eb can be written as 1 (∇u)0 = σ + ω + θI − a ⊗ u , 3
(3.14)
where σ is the shear tensor (Sσ = σ, Tr σ = 0, u ◦ σ = 0), ω is the vorticity tensor (Sω = 0, u ◦ ω = 0), θ is the expansion, and a is the acceleration (u ◦ a = 0). This physical interpretation of (σ, ω, θ, a) primarily applies to the case where u is defined as in the Eckart and Landau–Lifshitz theories [24, 25]. Using the above formula for (∇u)0 then leads us to convert Eq. (3.12) to s˙ + θs + ∇⊥ · Φ + a ◦ Φ = P .
(3.15)
Equation (3.15) is the entropy law in a form convenient for later discussion (see Sec. 5). At this stage, we need to introduce the so-called covariant moments of the distribution function f : Z α f := (⊗α p¯)f πm , α ≥ 0 . (3.16) By means of Eq. (3.6), we obtain at once ∇ · f α+1 = P α , where
(3.17)
Z α
P :=
(⊗α p¯)J(f )πm .
(3.18)
For P 0 and P 1 , we must have P0 = 0,
P1 = 0.
(3.19)
A full derivation of these simple equations may be found in [1]. Notice that since p¯ ◦ p¯ = −m2 , the following identities are satisfied if α ≥ 2: Tr f α = −m2 f α−2 ,
Tr P α = −m2 P α−2 ,
Tr(∇ · f α+1 − P α ) = −m2 (∇ · f α−1 − P α−2 ) .
(3.20a) (3.20b)
Consequently, the trace of Eq. (3.17) reduces to ∇ · f α−1 = P α−2 for α ≥ 2. The basic covariant moments are f 1 and f 2 ; these moments represent the particle number current and the energy-momentum tensor, respectively. However, from the viewpoint of an observer with four-velocity u, the most important fields in many
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
480
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
applications are the number density n, the energy per unit volume , the pressure p, the number flux vector N, the heat flux q, and the stress deviator Π: n := −u ◦ f 1 , p :=
:= (u ⊗ u) ◦ f 2 ,
(3.21a)
N := (f 1 )⊥ ,
(3.21b)
1 Tr(f 2 )⊥ , 3
q := −(u ◦ f 2 )⊥ ,
Π := h(f 2 )⊥ i .
(3.21c)
The above definitions are valid for m 6= 0 and m = 0. 3.2. Maximization of entropy The set consisting of the first k + 1 equations (3.17) is not a determined system since there appear more variables than equations. It can be made so, however, by using the distribution function f that provides a maximum of s, Z (3.22) s = s(f ) := −y (−¯ p ◦ u)H(f¯)πm , under the constraints of fixed values of fuα := −u ◦ f α+1 ,
0 ≤ α ≤ k.
(3.23)
With the Lagrange multipliers Λα , 0 ≤ α ≤ k, we introduce the following functional of f : Z k X α α α Y (f ) := s(f ) + Λ ◦ fu − (−¯ p ◦ u)(⊗ p¯)f πm . (3.24) α=0
The variation of Y (f ) is given by Z δY (f ) = − (−¯ p ◦ u) ln
f¯ + κ δf πm , 1 + η f¯
(3.25)
where κ :=
k X
Λα ◦ (⊗α p¯) .
(3.26)
α=0
The form of f — the one which maximizes s — has to be deduced from the condition δY (f ) = 0. Denoting this form by F or F (κ), we immediately find that y F = F (κ) := κ . (3.27) e −η Because of the dependence of κ on Λ := (Λ0 , Λ1 , . . . , Λk )
(3.28)
and p¯, the natural variables of F are Λ and p¯. Thus we obtain F = F (Λ, p¯) ,
(3.29)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
481
which means that F depends on x ∈ X through Λ: x 7→ Λ(x) := (Λ0 (x), Λ1 (x), . . . , Λk (x)) .
(3.30)
The Lagrange multipliers Λα , 0 ≤ α ≤ k, appearing in the definition of Λ are tensors of type α, i.e. Λα (x) ∈ T0α (x). For 2 ≤ α ≤ k, these tensors may be assumed without any loss of generality to be symmetric and traceless, since S(⊗α p¯) = ⊗α p¯ and p¯ ◦ p¯ = −m2 [see Eqs. (3.26)]. Consequently, we have SΛα = Λα ,
0 ≤ α ≤ k,
(3.31a)
Tr Λα = 0 ,
2 ≤ α ≤ k.
(3.31b)
Here, an important question arises of how to fit Λ to the actual f . Our construction of F implies that fuα = −u ◦ F α+1 (Λ) where
(0 ≤ α ≤ k) ,
(3.32)
Z F α (Λ) :=
(⊗α p¯)F (Λ, p¯)πm
(0 ≤ α < ∞) .
(3.33)
Mathematically, after specifying the metric g and the four-velocity vector field u, conditions (3.32) are a set of equations for the determination of fu := (fu0 , fu1 , . . . , fuk )
(3.34)
as a function of Λ. The inverse problem to that just mentioned is that of recovering the relation Λ = Λ(fu ) if the relation fu = fu (Λ) is given. For m 6= 0 and k ≥ 1, it is impossible to invert Eqs. (3.32) analytically so as to obtain Λ = Λ(fu ); this can only be done for m = 0 and k = 1. However, if we desire to consider fuα (0 ≤ α ≤ k) as fundamental gas-state variables in place of Λα (0 ≤ α ≤ k), we must postulate that Eqs. (3.32) permit us to calculate Λ as a function of fu , at least in principle. A formal aspect of the closure procedure, which is discussed most conveniently in terms of the Lagrange multipliers, may now be stated very neatly. Define PFα (Λ), 0 ≤ α < ∞, by Z α PF (Λ) := (⊗α p¯)J(F (Λ, p¯))πm . (3.35) Next, focus upon the first k +1 equations (3.17). Finally, in these equations, replace f α+1 by F α+1 (Λ) and P α by PFα (Λ). Accepting this closure procedure, we conclude that the system of equations for Λ is given by ∇ · F α+1 (Λ) = PFα (Λ) (0 ≤ α ≤ k) .
(3.36)
On the understanding that k ≥ 1, there are only (k+1)(k+2)(2k+3)/6 independent scalar variables in Λ and the total number of independent scalar equations in the system (3.36) is also (k + 1)(k + 2)(2k + 3)/6 [27]. Thus this system provides a correct number of equations to determine Λ.
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
482
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
As noted already by M¨ uller and Ruggeri in [13, pp. 211 and 212] Eqs. (3.36) have many desirable properties that follow from their so-called potential form, many of which are lacking in traditional closures. First of all, Eqs. (3.36) are consistent with an additional balance law interpreted as the equation of balance of entropy. Another important property of Eqs. (3.36) is that if g is the metric of a curved or flat spacetime and u is defined as in the theory of Arnowitt et al. [21] (see Sec. 6.1), then these equations can be reduced to a symmetric hyperbolic system. Such a system precludes action at a distance and ensures finite speeds. Also, symmetric hyperbolicity is an attractive feature mathematically, because it ensures well-posedness of local Cauchy problems, i.e. existence, uniqueness, and continuous dependence of the solutions on the data. For k = 1, the connection of Eqs. (3.36) with a system of Eulerian equations is obvious. For k > 1, the internal consistency and physical reasonables of the formalism is less obvious. It would seem that we have derived a hierarchy of closed systems of field equations. However, it is important to understand exactly what freedom is available in the choice of k, i.e. to state precisely what conditions on k are necessary and sufficient for the relation fu = fu (Λ) to be mathematically well defined. When a gas departs only slightly from local equilibrium and k > 1, there is considerable awkwardness in attempting to express fu as a function of Λ. The main reason for this awkwardness will be explained in the text below. 3.3. Requirements placed on the Lagrange multipliers In order to determine the relation fu = fu (Λ), the object Λ must be such as to ensure that the function F α (Λ) is calculable from Eq. (3.33) for all values of α. A set of objects of this kind will be denoted by M. It is natural to think of M as being the set in a real vector space E of dimension (k + 1)(k + 2)(2k + 3)/6, endowed with its canonical structure of differentiable manifold [28]. Let M0 be the interior of M, i.e. the largest open subset of M. Clearly, M0 is an open submanifold of E and the dimension of M0 is equal to the dimension of E. Now, our main problem is to know whether or not the equilibrium states, which are elements of M, are also elements of M0 . If they are not, then the relation fu = fu (Λ) is ill-defined in a neighborhood of these equilibrium states. As to the definition of equilibrium states, see our discussion directly before and after Eq. (3.48). First, we introduce the following notation: Λα−β := [Λα ◦ (⊗β u)]⊥ , β
α ≥ β ≥ 0.
(3.37)
Since Tr Λα = 0 for α ≥ 2 [see Eq. (3.31b)], it can be demonstrated that Λα−2β = Trβ Λα 0 , 2β
Λα−2β−1 = Trβ Λα−1 . 1 2β+1
(3.38)
α−1 In accordance with the above formulas, a knowledge of Λα permits us 0 and Λ1 to calculate Λα−β . Mathematically, a more convenient way of evaluating Λα−β is β β
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
483
based on the identities referred to in Sec. 2.1. Indeed, by using Eq. (2.22), Λα 0 and α−β Λα−1 (and hence Λ ) are expressible in terms of 1 β α[β]
Λ0
:= hTrβ Λα 0i
(3.39a)
and α−1[β]
Λ1
:= hTrβ Λα−1 i. 1
(3.39b)
Therefore, given the definition (3.26) of κ, our next task is to relate κ to α−1[β] Λ1 . The essential step in doing this is to observe that α X α (−¯ p ◦ u)β [(⊗β u) ∨ (⊗α−β p)] , ⊗α p¯ = β
α[β] Λ0
and
(3.40)
β=0
where
α! α := . β β!(α − β)!
(3.41)
For computational reasons, we introduce the additional quantities by setting j := p/(−¯ p ◦ u) , Aα := ⊗α j ,
j := (j ◦ j)1/2 ,
C α := hAα i .
(3.42a) (3.42b)
From Eqs. (2.22) and (3.40), together with the definitions (3.37) and the identities (3.38), it will be possible to obtain a desired expression for κ. After some tedious algebra, by invoking the formulas (2.17a) and (3.26), we can prove that κ=
k [α/2] X X
α[β]
(−¯ p ◦ u)α Kβα (Λ0
◦ C α−2β )
α=0 β=0
+
k [(α−1)/2] X X α=1
α−1[β]
(−¯ p ◦ u)α Lα β (Λ1
◦ C α−2β−1 ) ,
(3.43)
β=0
where Kβα :=
β X ν=0
Lα β :=
β X ν=0
α!(2α − 4β + 1)!! j 2ν , − 2β)!(2β − 2ν)!(2α − 4β + 2ν + 1)!!
(3.44a)
α!(2α − 4β − 1)!! j 2ν . − 2β − 1)!(2β + 1 − 2ν)!(2α − 4β + 2ν − 1)!!
(3.44b)
2ν ν!(α
2ν ν!(α
With the abbreviation X
[α/2]
Qα : =
α[β]
Kβα (Λ0
◦ C α−2β )
β=0
X
[(α−1)/2]
+
β=0
α−1[β]
Lα β (Λ1
◦ C α−2β−1 ) ,
(3.45)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
484
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
an alternative expression for κ is κ = Λ0 +
k X
Qα (−¯ p ◦ u)α ,
k ≥ 1.
(3.46)
α=1
This form of κ is just the one required for the discussion of our main problem. The object Λ has (k + 1)(k + 2)(2k + 3)/6 independent components and these α[β] α−1[β] components are represented by Λ0 and Λ1 . From Eq. (3.43) we see that κ is α[β] α−1[β] an explicit function of Λ0 and Λ1 . For large values of p ◦ p, the quantities j and j can be identified with p/(p ◦ p)1/2 and 1, respectively. Moreover, −¯ p◦u = 2 1/2 approaches ∞ as p ◦ p → ∞. Let the coefficient Qk in Eq. (3.46) (m + p ◦ p) satisfy the condition Qk 6= 0. (If k > 1 and Qk = 0, then Qk must be replaced by the highest nonvanishing coefficient of κ.) Evidently, κ tends to Qk (−¯ p ◦ u)k as p ◦ p → ∞ and the existence of the functions F α (Λ) depends on the sign of Qk . It is clear, from the way it occurs in Eq. (3.46), that R Qk is positive if Qk 6= 0 and Λ ∈ M, and for the convergence of the integrals (⊗α p¯)F (κ)πm it should obey the condition Qk ≥ Dk (Λ) ,
(3.47)
where Dk (Λ) is a positive constant; this constant may depend parametrically on Λ. Also, the inequality F > 0 for bosons (η = 1) imposes some restrictions on Λ, but they will not be discussed here [14]. Let k > 1. The important subset ME of M is defined by saying that Λ ∈ E α[β] α−1[β] belongs to ME if and only if Λ belongs to M and Λ0 and Λ1 are zero tensors for 1 < α ≤ k. We denote the elements of ME by ΛE . If Λ = ΛE , Eq. (3.43) becomes κ = κE := Λ0 + Λ1 ◦ p¯
(3.48)
and F (κ) reduces to F (κE ). In relativistic kinetic theory, we regard as being appropriate to local equilibrium any molecular-density function f such as to be left unaltered by collisions [29]: J(f ) = 0 .
(3.49)
If we recall the definition of J(f ) given, e.g. in [30], we conclude that any such f is described by f = F (κE ). In what follows, we refer to F (κE ) as the local Maxwell– J¨ uttner distribution function [29, 31] and to ΛE as the equilibrium state. Note that for f = F (κE ) the productions P α in Eqs. (3.17) vanish and the entropy production P in Eq. (3.12) reaches its minimum value, i.e. zero. For a gas that departs only slightly from local equilibrium, we may choose (independently at each point x) an arbitrary local equilibrium distribution function FE := F (κE ) that is close to the actual distribution function f and set f = FE (1 + ϕ). By linearizing the collision term J(f ) with respect to ϕ, we obtain the linearized Boltzmann equation for ϕ. This equation is inhomogeneous and contains the source term because the local Lagrange multipliers Λ0 (x) and Λ1 (x)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
485
are, in general, arbitrary. However, if equilibrium holds globally in some region, it then follows from Eq. (3.6) that ∇Λ0 = 0 and ∇ ∨ Λ1 = 0. All these problems are carefully discussed by Israel in [29, pp. 205 and 206]. Let ΛE ∈ ME be an arbitrary equilibrium state and let ϑE ⊂ E stand for an arbitrary neighborhood of ΛE ∈ E. Then there exist elements Λ in ϑE such that Λ 6∈ M, i.e. such that the integrals in Eqs. (3.33) are not well defined. These elements are characterized by the conditions h i k κ = κE + (−¯ p ◦ u)k Kk/2 Trk/2 (Λk )⊥ (3.50a) and Trk/2 (Λk )⊥ < 0
(3.50b)
κ = κE + (−¯ p ◦ u)k Lk(k−1)/2 [Tr(k−1)/2 (Λk ◦ u)⊥ ]
(3.51a)
Tr(k−1)/2 (Λk ◦ u)⊥ < 0 ,
(3.51b)
or by the conditions
and
depending on whether k is even or odd. In the case of Eq. (3.50a) where k = 2l 0[0] 1[0] and l ≥ 1, we begin from the general formula (3.43) and postulate that Λ0 , Λ0 , 0[0] k[l] Λ1 , and Λ0 are the only nonvanishing components of Λ. If k = 2l + 1 and l ≥ 1, 0[0] 1[0] 0[0] k−1[l] play the role previously played by the the components Λ0 , Λ0 , Λ1 , Λ1 0[0] 1[0] 0[0] k[l] components Λ0 , Λ0 , Λ1 , Λ0 and Eq. (3.50a) is replaced by Eq. (3.51a). We can now summarize our results. For the system (3.17), we have been attempting to implement the closure by entropy maximization, which involves calculating F (κ) from Eqs. (3.26) and (3.27). This method meets a difficulty in that the intersection of ME ⊂ M and M0 ⊂ M has no elements (ME ∩ M0 = ∅). Since ΛE 6∈ M0 , the relation fu = fu (Λ) is ill-defined in a neighborhood of equilibrium states and we cannot use the system (3.36) with k > 1 to describe a situation around these equilibrium states. In order to do so, we need to show that ME ⊂ M0 . However, it turns out that this is not possible using the formalism of covariant moments, so we will concentrate on the formalism of central moments. In such a case, ME is a proper subset of M0 (see Sec. 5). Another method of overcoming these difficulties is to retain only the term κE in F (κ), while formally expanding F (κ) − F (κE ) in powers of κ − κE . A more detailed explanation as to why the equilibrium state ΛE should be an element of an open set M0 is the following. First, in order to derive an explicit system of partial differential equations for Λ from Eqs. (3.36), we must calculate (in a classical sense) the derivatives of F α+1 (Λ) with respect to Λ. Because of this, the whole procedure leading to such a system is certainly well-defined if Λ ∈ M0 and may be ill-defined if Λ ∈ M and Λ 6∈ M0 . Second, thanks to the concavity of entropy, Eqs. (3.36) obtained through the method of maximum entropy can be written as a symmetric hyperbolic system and the region of hyperbolicity for
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
486
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
Eqs. (3.36) is any open convex subset of M0 . Now, let x 7→ Λ0 (x) be an arbitrarily fixed mapping such that Λ0 is a continuously differentiable function on X and Λ0 (x) is an element of M0 for each x ∈ X. By setting Λ = Λ0 + λ, where λ is a perturbation of Λ0 , it is always possible to linearize Eqs. 3.36) around Λ0 . In this way, we obtain the linear equations for λ, generally with nonvanishing source terms depending on the known function Λ0 , which are symmetric hyperbolic. At first sight, if we are interested in processes not far from an equilibrium state, it seems reasonable to use the mapping x 7→ ΛE (x) in place of the mapping x 7→ Λ0 (x). However, since ΛE (x) 6∈ M0 for each x ∈ X, the linearization procedure based on Λ = ΛE + λ cannot be automatically expected to be capable of yielding the well-defined system of partial differential equations for λ. Also, due to the fact that the matrices of a characteristic equation are ill-defined in a neighborhood of equilibrium states, it is not clear how to interpret the characteristic speeds of disturbances propagating into a region in equilibrium. Thus, we should look for a new formulation of the theory of moments in which the analog of ΛE belongs to the analog of M0 . 4. Description in Terms of Central Moments 4.1. Equations of balance for central moments Using Eqs. (3.11) and (3.42), we define the central moments by Z frα := (−¯ p ◦ u)r Aα f πm ,
(4.1)
where α and r take the values {0, 1, 2, . . .}. Clearly, these moments are symmetric spacelike tensors. It follows from Eqs. (3.16) and (3.40) that the covariant moments f α are related to the central moments fαα−β by α X α α (4.2) f = [(⊗β u) ∨ fαα−β ] . β β=0
We also obtain fαα−β = (−1)β [f α ◦ (⊗β u)]⊥ ,
α ≥β.
(4.3)
Because of these relations, a knowledge of u and frα allows us to calculate f α . However, the converse is not true, i.e. a knowledge of u and f α does not permit us to calculate frα for all values of α and r. The key central moments which uniquely determine the number density n, the energy per unit volume , the pressure p, the number flux vector N, the heat flux q, and the stress deviator Π are f10 , f20 , f11 , f21 , and f22 : n = f10 ,
= f20 ,
N = f11 ,
q = f21 ,
p=
1 Tr f22 , 3
1 Π = f22 − (Tr f22 )I . 3
(4.4a) (4.4b)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
487
Given Eq. (4.1), it is worthwhile observing that if one changes ones’s choice of fiducial congruence, and thus of the fiducial four-velocity vector field u, then one will change the central moments in a very complicated way. Without persuing the details, it is clear that the procedure leading to Eq. (4.1) is not covariant. More explicitly, two observers looking at the same relativistic gas will, in general, extract two different sets of central moments, not related to each other by a tensorial linear transformation. The situation is evidently virtually the same as that in the case of the moment formalism for radiative transfer [7]. Defining i := p/(p ◦ p)1/2
(4.5)
B α := ⊗α i ,
(4.6)
and
we see that a more general class of central moments is given by Z frα,β := (−¯ p ◦ u)r j β B α f πm ,
(4.7)
where α, β, and r take the values {0, 1, 2, . . .}. With Eq. (3.42a) for j, the description of frα in terms of frα,β leads to the formula frα = frα,α . Note that Tr frα,β = frα−2,β for α ≥ 2. Consequently, we may prefer to use Z hfrα,β i = (−¯ p ◦ u)r j β hB α if πm
(4.8)
(4.9)
instead of frα,β . Then Eq. (2.22) gives X
[α/2]
frα,β
=
k(α − 2µ, µ)l(α, µ)[hfrα−2µ,β i ∨ I µ ] .
(4.10)
µ=0
The irreducible moments hfrα,β i were first studied by Ellis et al. [8, 9]. However, in order to derive a system of evolution equations for hfrα,β i, they assumed that r > β ≥ 0. This assumption is not very convenient for investigating the evolution of all fields of physical interest, since there are the following expressions for n, , p, N, q, and Π: n = hf10,0 i = f10,0 , p=
= hf20,0 i = f20,0 ,
1 0,2 1 hf i = f20,2 , 3 2 3
q = hf21,1 i = f21,1 ,
N = hf11,1 i = f11,1 ,
Π = hf22,2 i .
(4.11a) (4.11b) (4.11c)
Fortunately, although the restriction r > β ≥ 0 is given in [8] and [9] for the validity of the evolution equations, they hold for all values of α, β, and r.
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
488
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
Considering the particular central moments frα , a special-relativistic discussion of the equations of balance for frα was proposed by Struchtrup [10]. As an illustration of the method, he specialized his results to the case in which the state of the gas is assumed to be described completely by the usual two conserved variables n and supplemented by p and the eleven components of N, q, and Π. Here, we return to the problem of deriving the equations of balance for frα , but we solve it according to general relativity. The reasons for studying these equations are twofold. First, we hope that our approach will lead to new insights about the irreducible representation of frα based on trace-free symmetric spacelike tensors such as frα[β] := hfˆrα[β] i = hTrβ frα i
(4.12a)
frα|β := hfˆrα|β i = hTrβ frα+2β i .
(4.12b)
and
Concerning the details, see Sec. 4.2. Second, we would like to give a systematic derivation of a hierarchy of closed systems of moment equations. This then brings up the basic question of whether the closure by entropy maximization ensures that every member of the hierarchy is hyperbolic, implies an equation of balance of entropy, and formally recovers the Euler limit (see Secs. 5 and 6). The differential equations satisfied by the central moments frα can be obtained directly by multiplying the Boltzmann equation (3.6) by (−¯ p ◦ u)r−1 Aα and integrating over the future mass-shell. Doing this and using the decomposition (3.14) of (∇u)0 , we find that α α (f˙rα )⊥ + ∇⊥ · frα+1 + αa ∨ frα−1 + 1 + θfr 3 + α(σ − ω) t frα + (r − α)a ◦ frα+1 1 α+2 α+2 + (r − α − 1) σ ◦ fr + θ Tr fr = Prα , 3 where α and r range from 0 to ∞ and Z α Pr := (−¯ p ◦ u)r−1 Aα J(f )πm .
(4.13)
(4.14)
In Eq. (4.13), we set frα−1 := 0 if α = 0. From the relations (3.19) it follows that P10 , P20 , and P21 vanish. At this stage, we leave the fiducial congruence of timelike world lines arbitrary, so that the user of the formalism can specify it for himself. Landau and Lifshitz [25] chose as rest frame the one in which q = f21 = 0. Eckart [24] assumed that the four-velocity vector field u is parallel to the particle number current f 1 , i.e. that N = f11 = 0. The theory of Ruggeri [32] was founded on the postulate that the entropy flux vector Φ vanishes [see Eq. (3.10b)]. This option remains feasible if the covariant moments are taken into account. Of course, in a curved space-time, many other choices are possible. In Sec. 6.1, we choose u as in the well-known theory
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
489
of Arnowitt et al. [21]; thus there we identify u with the so-called normal vector field. Then the closure by entropy maximization leads directly to a hierarchy of symmetric hyperbolic systems of field equations, i.e. the evolution equations (6.34) for ΛΩ which are symmetric hyperbolic at every order of truncation (see Sec. 6.2). 4.2. Equations of balance for irreducible central moments Given a choice of a timelike vector field u, the particle distribution function f can be expressed in terms of spherical harmonics; the Boltzmann equation can then be written as a set of equations relating the consecutive harmonic components of f . Ellis et al. [8, 9] derived this set of equations and the resulting set of equations for the irreducible moments hfrα,β i. Originally, they used a spherical harmonic formalism to prove a number of exact results on the anisotropic solutions of the Einstein– Boltzmann system. Later, their method has been applied to the study of cosmic microwave background temperature anisotropies arising from inhomogeneities in the early universe [33]. Our purpose here is to provide an alternative to the approach of Ellis et al. [8, 9] which avoids a spherical harmonic decomposition of the Boltzmann equation and uses only a finite number of elementary algebraic operations on Eqs. (4.13). For nonrelativistic classical gases, a very similar formulation of the theory was given by Banach and Piekarski [26]. In order to systematically derive the equations of α|β balance for fr , we first observe that α Trβ (a ∨ frα−1 ) = (α − 2β)a ∨ fˆrα−1[β] + 2βa ◦ fˆrα−1[β−1] ,
(4.15a)
α Trβ [(σ − ω) t frα ] = (α − 2β)(σ − ω) t fˆrα[β] + 2βσ ◦ fˆrα[β−1] ,
(4.15b)
Trβ (f˙rα )⊥ = [(fˆrα[β] )· ]⊥ ,
(4.15c)
Trβ (∇⊥ · frα+1 ) = ∇⊥ · fˆrα+1[β] ,
(4.15d)
Trβ (a ◦ frα+1 ) = a ◦ fˆrα+1[β] ,
(4.15e)
Trβ (σ ◦ frα+2 ) = σ ◦ fˆrα+2[β] ,
(4.15f)
where α ≥ 2β and fˆrα[β] := Trβ frα .
(4.16)
Before using the above formulas, we need to give further thought to the meaning of some terms in these formulas. As regards the details, a complete explanation α−1[β] of Eqs. (4.15a) and (4.15b) will be obtained if we set fˆr := 0 for α = 2β α−1[β−1] α[β−1] ˆ ˆ and fr := 0 and fr := 0 for α ≥ 2β = 0. The identities (4.15) follow from the argumentation similar in spirit to the proof of Eqs. (3.9) in [26], and it is not difficult to transpose this proof to the context of the present theory. With Eqs. (4.15), we see that the result of the β-fold successive application of the operator
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
490
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki
Tr to Eq. (4.13) may be written as
α α[β] · α+1[β] ˆ ˆ [(fr ) ]⊥ + ∇⊥ · fr + 1+ θfˆrα[β] 3 + (α − 2β)(a ∨ fˆrα−1[β] + (σ − ω) t fˆrα[β] ) + 2β(a ◦ fˆrα−1[β−1] + σ ◦ fˆrα[β−1] ) + (r − α)a ◦ fˆrα+1[β] 1 + (r − α − 1) σ ◦ fˆrα+2[β] + θfˆrα+2[β+1] = Pˆrα[β] , 3
(4.17)
where (4.18) Pˆrα[β] := Trβ Prα . 0[0] 0[0] 1[0] Clearly, Eqs. (3.19) imply that Pˆ1 = Pˆ2 = 0 and Pˆ2 = 0. α[β] α[β] α[β] is defined by fr := hfˆr i, from Eq. (2.16) we now Remembering that fr derive the following important formulas: h[(fˆrα[β] )· ]⊥ i = (f˙rα[β] )⊥ , α ≥ 2β , (4.19a) hfˆrα+2[β+1] i = frα+2[β+1] ,
α ≥ 2β ,
ha ∨ fˆrα−1[β] i = a ? frα−1[β] , h∇⊥ · fˆrα+1[β] i =
α > 2β ,
α > 2β ,
(4.19d)
α − 2β a ? frα+1[β+1] 2α − 4β + 1 + a ◦ frα+1[β] ,
ha ◦ fˆrα−1[β−1] i =
(4.19c)
α − 2β ∇⊥ ? frα+1[β+1] 2α − 4β + 1 + ∇⊥ · frα+1[β] ,
ha ◦ fˆrα+1[β] i =
(4.19b)
α > 2β ,
(4.19e)
α − 2β a ? frα−1[β] 2α − 4β + 1 + a ◦ frα−1[β−1] ,
α > 2β > 0 ,
(4.19f)
α − 2β − 1 h(σ − ω) t fˆrα[β] i = σ ? frα[β+1] 2α − 4β − 1 + (σ − ω) u frα[β] ,
α > 2β + 1 ,
(4.19g)
hσ ◦ fˆrα[β−1] i = σ ◦ frα[β−1] +
(α − 2β)(α − 2β − 1) σ ? frα[β+1] (2α − 4β − 1)(2α − 4β + 1)
+
2(α − 2β) σ u frα[β] , 2α − 4β + 3
α > 2β + 1 > 1 ,
(4.19h)
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
00122
Evolution of Central Moments
491
hσ ◦ fˆrα+2[β] i = σ ◦ frα+2[β] +
(α − 2β)(α − 2β − 1) σ ? frα+2[β+2] (2α − 4β − 1)(2α − 4β + 1)
+
2(α − 2β) σ u frα+2[β+1] , 2α − 4β + 3
α > 2β + 1 .
(4.19i)
For the proof of these formulas, it is sufficient to use the same reasoning as that used in the proof of [26, Eqs. (3.12)–(3.18)]. Consequently, we will be brief and omit the technical details. In Eq. (2.16), the symbol h i represents a linear operator which acts on M α . Because of the identities just formulated, the action of this operator on Eq. (4.17) is given by α 1 (f˙rα|β )⊥ + ∇⊥ · frα+1|β + ∇⊥ ? frα−1|β+1 + (α + 2β + 3)θ frα|β 2α + 1 3 2α + 4β + 3 +α σ u frα|β − ω u frα|β 2α + 3 + 2β(a ◦ frα+1|β−1 + σ ◦ frα+2|β−1 ) α(2α + 2β + 1) α−1 α−1|β α−2|β+1 + a ? fr + σ ? fr 2α + 1 2α − 1 α α+1|β α−1|β+1 + (r − α − 2β) a ◦ fr + a ? fr 2α + 1 2α + (r − α − 2β − 1) σ ◦ frα+2|β + σ u frα|β+1 2α + 3 α(α − 1) + σ ? frα−2|β+2 + (θ/3)frα|β+1 = Prα|β , (2α − 1)(2α + 1)
(4.20)
where α, β, and r range from 0 to ∞. In arriving at Eq. (4.20), we have employed the transformations α → α + 2β and β → β, which take frα[β] := hfˆrα[β] i = hTrβ frα i
(4.21a)
Prα[β] := hPˆrα[β] i = hTrβ Prα i
(4.21b)
frα|β := hfˆrα+2β[β] i = hTrβ frα+2β i
(4.22a)
Prα|β := hPˆrα+2β[β] i = hTrβ Prα+2β i ,
(4.22b)
and
into
and
June 4, 2002 11:36 WSPC/148-RMP
492
00122
Z. Banach & W. Larecki 0|0
0|0
1|0
respectively. Naturally, we have P1 = P2 = 0 and P2 0 ≤ α < ∞ and 0 ≤ β < ∞, it is understood that
= 0. Moreover, since
frα−2|β+1 := frα−2|β+2 := 0 if α = 0 or α = 1 ,
(4.23a)
frα−1|β := frα−1|β+1 := 0
(4.23b)
if α = 0 ,
frα+1|β−1 := 0
if β = 0 ,
frα+2|β−1 := 0
if β = 0 .
(4.23c) (4.23d) α|β fr .
We refer to Eq. (4.20) as the equation of balance for The evol