In This Issue
May 2005 In This Issue Click article title to open Reviews
People
Allen & Heath Xone VF1
Business End
Analogue Filter You probably know Allen & Heath as a studio mixer manufacturer, but they also specialise in high-end DJ mixing and processing. Now they have combined their studio and DJ expertise into a multi-mode analogue filter with sophisticated MIDI control.
Reader Tracks Evaluated Listen online to the tracks whilst reading what some Music Producers Guild members think of the latest collection of SOS reader recordings.
Apple Mac Mini Desktop Computer Apple have long been criticised for charging a premium for their products, making the Mac platform a more costly choice than the alternatives. With the newly released Mac Mini, Apple hope to change this perception, but is there enough Mac in the Mac Mini to make it useful for musicians?
ART TCS Dual Compressor Choose from optical and VCA compression, de-essing, noise reduction, and valve voicing within a single processor.
Audio Ease Rocket Science Effects Plug-ins (Mac OS) A new plug-in bundle from Dutch developer Audio Ease brings together three unique sound-shaping tools.
Audix SCX25 Condenser Microphone Large-diaphragm mics don't have to be bulky and unwieldy, as this compact new contender from Audix demonstrates.
Bornemark Broomstick Bass Virtual Bass Player Instrument (Mac/PC) So how is your plug-in band coming on, then? With a combination of Steinberg's Groove Agent and Virtual Guitarist plus Yamaha's Vocaloid, all that is required is a bass player. Enter, stage left, Bornemark's Broomstick Bass...
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss Broad-band Noise-reduction Processor This new slimline rack processor makes CEDAR's latest class-leading audio-restoration algorithms remarkably
Crosstalk: readers' writes Your letters, emails, faxes Replies from the editorial team to more of your valued feedback.
Greg Ladanyi Jackson Browne, Don Henley & The SoCal Sound Greg Ladanyi showed up at the right time in rock history to chair sessions for Jackson Browne, Don Henley, Warren Zevon, Toto, Fleetwood Mac and the Jacksons — but while 50 percent of life may be simply showing up, the other half requires a lot of hard work.
Manny Marroquin Mixing For Kanye West & Alicia Keys You might not know his name, but you've definitely heard his work: Manny Marroquin is the mix engineer of choice for leading artists in both urban and rock music.
Sounding Off Mr X Soon all software could be FREE — like it or not...
Studio SOS East Norfolk Sixth Form College East Norfolk Sixth Form College needed help integrating their hardware multitracker with their computer sequencing system, so the SOS team travelled over to Great Yarmouth to lend a hand.
The Dust Brothers Sampling, Remixing & The Boat Studio The Dust Brothers changed the course of record production with a new approach to sampling. In their first ever in-depth technical interview, John King and Mike Simpson explain their unique way of making records and open the doors of their remarkable LA studio, The Boat.
The World At Your Fingertips Paul White's Leader
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/In%20This%20Issue.htm (1 of 4)9/27/2005 9:21:33 PM
In This Issue
quick and easy to use.
Edirol UA101 USB 2 Audio Interface (PC) Edirol have pioneered USB 2.0 as a format for connecting audio interfaces, and their latest unit offers 10 inputs and outputs at a price that compares well with Firewire alternatives.
Fervent Software Studio To Go Bootable Linux Software Suite for PC If you are attracted by the idea of Linux and open-source music software, but put off by the thought of installing it on your PC, there is another way: a bootable CD-ROM containing both the OS and all the software you need, ready to go.
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312 Active Monitors & Subwoofer JBL's new monitors incorporate Room Mode Correction technology which claims to be able to reduce the bass problems caused by standing waves at the listening position. But does it really work in practice?
Korg Kontrol 49 USB MIDI Controller Keyboard Korg's Microkontrol was a highly versatile, yet compact MIDI controller — but perhaps, with its three octaves of miniature keys, it was too compact. With its four-octave, full-size keyboard, the Kontrol 49 looks set to put that right...
Mindprint Trio Processor & Monitor Controller Mindprint cram mic and line channel strips, monitor control, and talkback into a single desktop unit.
Native Instrument Battery 2 Virtual Drum Module (Mac/PC) Two years on from its original release, Native's virtual drum module gets its first full upgrade. Is it all John Bonham tom mayhem, or is it limper than a Kraftwerk drum solo?
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA Powered Monitors Pioneering digital amplifiers are combined with PMC's proven transmission-line cabinet designs to deliver spectacular monitoring performance at a project-studio price.
Propellerhead Reason v3 Virtual Electronic Studio (Mac OS X/PC) Astonishingly, Reason is now over four years old! Version 3 adds performance-enhancing features and mastering facilities, losing only Mac OS 9 support on the way. We
Last month's column aroused plenty of response so Paul continues his thoughts on whether guitars or keyboards are best-suited to being 'controllers'.
Technique
Digital Performer: EQing Tracks Digital Performer Notes This month, how to tweak your tracks with MOTU's answer to Sony's Oxford EQ and speed up your workflow with the essential DP keyboard shortcut selection!
Pro Tools: latest news Pro Tools Notes Our new-look Pro Tools Notes column brings you all the latest news from the Digidesign universe...
Reason: New Refills & Tips Reason Notes This month: new Refills and tweaking techniques for Reason v3, plus the usual haul of time-saving tips.
Sonar: Studio or Producer? Sonar Notes It's time to address the Studio versus Producer question, as well as looking into a new Sonar remote-control option.
Apple GarageBand 2, PowerBooks & iPods Apple Notes Although intended as an entry-level application to introduce new people to computer-based music making, Apple's GarageBand has received acclaim from beginners and professionals alike. In this special extended Apple Notes we look at version 2, which adds score editing, multitrack audio recording, and more...
Catch and Link modes in Logic Logic Notes Combining Logic's Catch and Link modes can greatly increase the usefulness of multi-window Screensets, but it is not always clear, especially to new users, how the various options work.
CLASSIC TRACKS: The Who 'Who Are You?' Producers: Jon Astley, Glyn Johns The Who's final album with Keith Moon took almost a year to record and pushed the band to the limit. Engineer and producer Jon Astley tells the remarkable story behind Who Are You?'s title track.
Composite Vocal Recording (Using Sonar 4) Masterclass The audio sequencing facilities we have at our disposal these days make it easier than ever before to produce world-class vocal recordings by taking the best parts from a series of takes and producing a composite from them. Here's how to do the job in Sonar 4.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/In%20This%20Issue.htm (2 of 4)9/27/2005 9:21:33 PM
In This Issue
bring you the first UK review of the full release version...
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD A-D/D-A Converter & Digital Format Converter Two new half-rack boxes offer considerable operational flexibility and pristine sound in both the analogue and digital domains.
Roland Fantom Xa Workstation Synth At £1099, the Xa is the most affordable keyboard in the Fantom range. But, inevitably, features have been removed to make it such a bargain. Have Roland thrown out the works from the workstation?
Roland VC1 D50 RAM Card for Roland V-Synth & VariOS Roland's innovative V-Synth can now be reprogrammed with a RAM card, effectively turning it into another instrument. The VC1 card puts the clock back to 1987, perfectly recreating the S&S tones of the Roland D50.
Sample Libraries: On Test Sample Shop Four new Sample Library collections get the aural treatment from the SOS reviewers: Apple Jam Pack 4: Symphony Orchestra **** APPLE LOOPS Sonic Boom Box **** APPLE LOOPS Downbeat & Leftfield **** MULTI-FORMAT Platinum Essentials ***** AUDIO+WAV
Demo Doctor Reader Recordings Analysed Listen to these tracks from SOS readers and see whether you agree with the good Doctor's prognosis...
Maximum RAM PC Notes If you are tempted to approach the dizzy heights of 4GB of RAM in your PC, as supported by most motherboards, there are a few things to bear in mind.
Pop Shields: Why You Need Them Recording Tips Pop shields are essential for most modern studio productions, but what are they and why are they so important?
Troubleshooting Your Pro Tools System Masterclass Whatever computer recording system you use, the chances are it's going to fall over sooner or later, and Pro Tools is no exception. So before you call Digidesign's technical support line, take a look at Sound On Sound's guide to diagnosing and fixing the most common faults.
Using Folder Tracks in Cubase SX Cubase Notes Steinberg originally introduced the concept of Folder tracks in Cubase VST, as a way of organising the track list in the Arrange window. This month we look at how this feature became even more powerful in Cubase SX, and how to make the most of it.
Why & How To Partition Your Music PC Hard Drive
PC Musician Did you know that sensibly partitioning your hard drive or, if Steinberg Groove Agent 2 it's already partitioned, simply swapping the positions of your audio and sample partitions could result in a significant Virtual Drummer Instrument (Mac/PC) improvement in PC audio performance? We explain the whys From the same team that brought you Virtual Guitarist, Groove Agent has had an impressive upgrade, and is now and wherefores. claimed to work better under non-Steinberg hosts. We put Yamaha AW4416 User Tips it through a proper multi-platform test. Masterclass: Part 1 Tascam FW1082 Combining the guts of an 02R mixer with a fully featured multitrack recorder, the AW4416 ended up being a Firewire Audio & MIDI Interface / Control Surface prodigiously complex beast. Our hands-on workshop shows (Mac/PC) Joining the growing market for one-box devices combining you which of those snazzy features work best in practice, and how to use them efficiently. audio and MIDI interfacing with control-surface functionality, Tascam's latest Firewire unit might be all you need for multitrack recording and mixing.
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW Firewire Audio Interface (Mac/PC) Terratec's range of affordable audio interfaces now file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/In%20This%20Issue.htm (3 of 4)9/27/2005 9:21:33 PM
In This Issue
includes two attractive Firewire options: the eight-in/out Phase 88 Rack FW and the two-in/four-out Phase 24 FW.
Ursa Major Space Station Digital Reverb & Effects Processor The original 3U monster that was the SST282 Space Station has been reissued by Seven Woods Audio as this small desktop unit. Not content merely to offer all the classic sounds, though, the new incarnation has a number of fresh tricks up its sleeve?
Yamaha Motif Rack ES Workstation Synth Module Yamaha's original Motif Rack was a fine-sounding, wellspecified synth module, but it suffered from MIDI timing problems when reviewed in SOS. Two years on, we put the follow-up Motif Rack ES to the test... Competition
WIN: Digidesign 002 Digital Audio Workstation Sound Advice
Q Can I use a mono compressor for stereo compression? Q How do I convert a split-stereo file to interleaved stereo? Q How should I sync up my digital inputs? Q Is there any advantage to using two subwoofers? Q Should I buy a vintage analogue synth or a modern modelling synth? Q Will my PC run Garritan Personal Orchestra?
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/In%20This%20Issue.htm (4 of 4)9/27/2005 9:21:33 PM
Allen & Heath Xone VF1
In this article:
Smooth Presentation In The Xone: Studio Listening Tests Comprehensive MIDI Functionality Optional Built-in RIAA Equalisation DJ Dream Machine
Allen & Heath Xone VF1 £398 pros Stereo 12dB/octave or mono 24dB/octave operation. MIDI control of filter type and cutoff. Balanced or unbalanced I/O. Valve overdrive.
Allen & Heath Xone VF1 Analogue Filter Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Effects
You probably know Allen & Heath as a studio mixer manufacturer, but they also specialise in high-end DJ mixing and processing. Now they have combined their studio and DJ expertise into a multi-mode analogue filter with sophisticated MIDI control. Paul Nagle
cons For over 30 years, Cornwall-based Allen & Heath have built a solid reputation for making quality mixers. More recently they have diversified with the Xone range, tailored specifically for the needs of DJs. A logical extension to this range is the new Xone VF1, a compact 1U summary analogue filter capable of 24dB/octave A stereo analogue filter with Photos: Mike Cameron mono or 12dB/octave stereo operation. valve overdrive, a built-in LFO The VF1 is an enhanced design taken and envelope follower, plus from existing mixer circuitry and offers low-pass, band-pass and high-pass MIDI control of important modes which can be selected in any combination. It also features a dual-triode parameters. Other than a slightly awkward method of valve with two separate elements, an LFO, an envelope follower, and MIDI changing MIDI modes, and control. With finishing touches that include balanced or unbalanced I/O, an the rear-panel location of at internal power supply, and stylish clickless switching of functions, you'll probably least one useful switch, the agree that the market can cope with one more analogue filter. VF1 is remarkably Mode changes require powering down, and there's no power switch. Switch for mono/stereo mode mounted on the rear panel. MIDI Implementation could be more extensive.
straightforward and a delight to use.
information VF1, £398.36; VF1R, £416.26. Prices include VAT. Allen & Heath +44 (0) 1326 372070. +44 (0)1326 377097.
Smooth Presentation The matt-grey panel with its black text and Moog-style knobs conveys a tangible air of finesse. Four large switches are provided, which activate the filters and select the three filter modes. These switches are backlit in orange (for filter
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Allen%20&%20Heath%20Xone%20VF1.htm (1 of 7)9/27/2005 9:21:55 PM
Allen & Heath Xone VF1
Click here to email www.allen-heath.com
modes) and blue (for filter switching). With no audio clicks generated when you push them, they are exactly the kind of thing that inspires confidence. Two large chunky knobs control cutoff and resonance. Smaller knobs set the rate and depth of the onboard LFO, and also adjust envelope-follower and overdrive amounts. Add switches for LFO waveform selection, envelope-follower decay, and the routing of envelope follower to overdrive, and you have a simple yet powerful set of options at your fingertips. Where the front panel is a streamlined, ergonomic delight, the rear is as fully populated as Jordan's T-shirt! There are balanced inputs and outputs on both XLRs and TRS jacks, while unbalanced I/O is courtesy of phono sockets, although the TRS jacks happily connect to balanced or unbalanced gear. With the aid of a screwdriver, you can prod a tiny blue recessed button which sums the inverted filter output with the raw input to create cancellation effects. This inverted signal is then sent to the TRS jacks without affecting the signal routed to the XLR outputs. Versatility is the name of the game; accordingly, you can use all outputs at once. When powered on, the orange glow of the valve is clearly visible through a grill on the top of the unit. The manual advises against obstructing this ventilation grill, so a little thought is needed in terms of placement in your rack. Thoughtful placement becomes an even more important issue when you realise that the rear panel has a couple of buttons on it. One of these, the Mono button, transforms the VF1 into a single-channel 24dB/octave filter. In this mode, the right input is ignored and the processed signal is sent to both outputs equally. Switching to a steeper filter slope adds extra depth and resonance — handy qualities for bass or solo instruments. Thus, positioning such a useful button on the back could prove jolly inconvenient on a piece of gear designed to spend its days in a rack or flightcase. The other rear-mounted button is Local Off, which routes the front-panel controls via the MIDI processor. Don't worry that MIDI control involves any sacrifices; you can still use the large, friendly cutoff knob, for example, and the resulting filter sweeps are smooth enough for Local Off to be activated permanently. MIDI In and Out sockets are provided for transmission and reception of MIDI data. Perhaps we can forgive Allen & Heath for the lack of a MIDI Thru because, on such a densely-packed panel, you'd be hard pushed to find room for one! A further audio output — the stereo Monitor Out jack — is provided as a means of previewing the effect of the filter even when it's bypassed — ideal for live mixing situations. The IEC power socket and fuse holder round off this well-provisioned rear.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Allen%20&%20Heath%20Xone%20VF1.htm (2 of 7)9/27/2005 9:21:55 PM
Allen & Heath Xone VF1
In The Xone: Studio Listening Tests Getting up and running is ludicrously easy, in part because the VF1 features no input controls or level indicator. This is a conscious decision on the part of Allen & Heath based on the philosophy that DJs shouldn't have access to level controls! With a unity-gain structure and a healthy +22dB of headroom, interfacing with most equipment should be a doddle. Indeed, I found the VF1 coped with a wide range of signals — keyboards, mixer sends/groups, and entire mixes — without complaint. After making the audio connections and enabling the VF1 with the Filter On button, I set overdrive and modulation to zero, activated low-pass mode and played a chord on one of my digital synths. The filter has a range from 20Hz up to 20kHz, and a full rotation of the cutoff knob resulted in my jotting down terms such as rich, smooth, and sweet as my first impressions. Several weeks of daily use later, I'd classify the VF1 as ideal for enhancing a wide variety of material, never dominating in the manner of, for example, the Sherman Filterbank. Not that comparisons are really appropriate, but I believe the Xone VF1 would slot into a mix far more readily, and thus see more general use, than a filter with more 'attitude'. A built-in Automatic Resonance Control automatically compresses the resonant peaks and reins in the sometimes speaker-shattering effects of high resonance, giving a pleasing sparkle without clipping, whistling, or loss of bass. This should definitely be a comfort when performing live. When the mono switch is activated, the effect of resonance becomes far more This block diagram in the VF1 manual shows pronounced and you can stray into how the different processing elements distortion. Here, the VF1 becomes interact with the controls and I/O. more 'synthy', but remains one of the most predictable filters I've encountered. If this gives the impression of a lack of balls, any such suggestions are dispelled when you reach for the overdrive knob. Valve overdrive with an analogue filter is a marriage made in heaven — well, any heaven that is famous for its pasties anyway! Low levels of overdrive introduce soft clipping, adding a subtle warming effect. At higher levels, hard clipping imposes a cutting distortion perfect for adding bite to solo instruments, basses, percussion... you name it! A make-up gain circuit is used to maintain a relatively constant level as you increase the overdrive amount. For maximum tonal variety, any combination of the filter-mode buttons may be pushed simultaneously. For example, activating low-pass, band-pass, and high-
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Allen%20&%20Heath%20Xone%20VF1.htm (3 of 7)9/27/2005 9:21:55 PM
Allen & Heath Xone VF1
pass produces an 'all-pass' filter that adds a gentle fizziness to any source as you crank up the resonance. low-pass and high-pass in combination create a notch filter, whilst high-pass and band-pass together conjure up a gorgeous, almost icy presence. Having spent some time establishing a feel for the tone of the VF1, I increased the LFO depth, adjusted the modulation speed, and enjoyed some traditional filter warbles. Two LFO waveforms are available: triangle for smooth cutoff changes and square for alternating stepped effects. Modulation rates vary between 0.2Hz and 16Hz. The more experimentally-minded may wish for faster speeds, but in this context I feel the range is judged correctly. The filter can also be modulated using the envelope follower, its amount set using a single knob. The envelope follower sets the response of the filter to input signal level; the higher the depth, the more the input will drive the cutoff frequency. A switch sets whether the envelope follower has a fast or slow decay; for loops or full mixes, a fast decay can give unusual artificial 'pumping' effects, but when used to filter synths, guitars, and so forth, a slow decay can sound more natural. A second switch determines whether the envelope follower will drive the output of the valve distortion. With dynamic sources this is very effective, adding a controlled overdrive effect that is responsive to the source transients.
Comprehensive MIDI Functionality As shipped, the unit responds to MIDI channel 16. To change this, power on whilst holding down the high-pass button and then set the channel using combinations of all four buttons — a chart in the manual shows you how. The VF1 responds to MIDI Continuous Controller (CC) numbers 80-83, which govern the status of the filter mode and bypass buttons. Additionally, MIDI CC74 controls the filter cutoff. By sending these MIDI controllers, you can remotely access or automate key features via your master keyboard or sequencer. Helpfully, the buttons and cutoff knob all transmit as well as receive their respective MIDI controllers, but there is no way to control any other parameter, such as resonance or LFO speed. However, that's not the full story of MIDI control. Additional functionality is available in the form of three additional MIDI input modes and, as when setting the MIDI channel, these modes require powering down to change. To do this, power up holding down the filter on/off switch and set the three available modes using the three filter buttons. When complete, normal operation is resumed by pressing the filter button again. My only significant complaint about the VF1 is that it lacks a power switch, which means that resetting the MIDI input mode requires you to pull out the mains plug — not something I'd consider mid-performance, and I'm sure I'm not alone! The additional modes are useful enough for this to be quite annoying, and Allen & file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Allen%20&%20Heath%20Xone%20VF1.htm (4 of 7)9/27/2005 9:21:55 PM
Allen & Heath Xone VF1
Heath have promised to investigate whether a future update could allow changes to be performed via MIDI. Of the three modes, the first is designed to work in conjunction with the Allen & Heath's own Xone:92 DJ Mixer. I didn't have one of these, but was able to reproduce the MIDI controller messages it sends because the manual helpfully records what they The three filter circuits in the VF1 can be are! In this mode, a single MIDI combined to create a variety of unusual filter controller (CC13) is used to switch shapes, including an intriguing 'all-pass' between filter types, although there are response if all the filters are activated just five possible combinations simultaneously. available: low-pass, low-pass plus band-pass, band-pass, band-pass plus high-pass, and high-pass. This means you can't set low-pass plus high-pass or 'all-pass' using this method, which is a pity. When in this mode, CC12 controls cutoff and CC92 sets the filter on and off. I found the implementation of a single continuous controller very handy for switching filters, even given the restriction that not all combinations were accessible, but it was the other two MIDI input modes that were far more exciting. When the second input mode is enabled, the filter cutoff tracks the pitch of incoming MIDI notes, provided that they are on the VF1's MIDI channel. You can therefore play a synth and process its output whilst using MIDI to track the pitch. Another fun technique is to direct MIDI notes to 'play' the filter whilst you're processing an entire track or mixer subgroup. The last of the MIDI input modes is the 'keyboard mute mode'. This makes the current filter active only as long as an incoming MIDI note is held. As soon as all notes are released, the filter is deselected, resulting in no output. This is superb for gating effects — particularly when you trigger the mute function from devices such as sequencers or drum machines. What's even better is that the MIDI input modes can be used in any combination — for example you could combine keyboard muting with keyboard tracking. In conjunction with your sequencer, this provides an endless source of freaky chopped-up mixes, with filters changing modes faster than your fingers could move. And all without glitches or annoying cracks and pops. One final MIDI facility worth mentioning is that two VF1s can be linked together via MIDI to implement stereo 24dB/octave operation, both units being set to mono. Connect the MIDI Out of your first filter to the MIDI In of the second and the filter switches and cutoff frequency can be controlled remotely from the first. Nifty as this option may be, in most cases I actually found the 12dB/octave mode was just fine for stereo mixes; the 24dB mode seemed best suited to processing individual instruments. file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Allen%20&%20Heath%20Xone%20VF1.htm (5 of 7)9/27/2005 9:21:55 PM
Allen & Heath Xone VF1
Optional Built-in RIAA Equalisation The VF1 is available in two versions, the VF1 reviewed here and the VF1R. This latter version is a little more expensive because it includes a preamp for connecting turntables requiring RIAA equalisation. RIAA equalisation is a specification for vinyl playback established by the Recording Industry Association of America. It was designed to permit longer playback times and improve sound quality, and has been an industry standard since the 1950s. Before then, each record company applied its own equalisation — with over 100 combinations of turnover and roll-off frequencies used, the main ones being AES, LP, NAB, and FFRR.
DJ Dream Machine From the moment I first unpacked the VF1, it screamed 'quality!' at me — and not just in terms of looks. Every sound source I put through it, from virtual analogue pads to drum loops and even full mixes, became more malleable and sonically gratifying. The effects on offer range from subtle and uncoloured to hard and overdriven. Low levels of overdrive add warmth, but at high levels a gritty underbelly of distortion is exposed. Yet even at its extremes the VF1 remains usable and controllable; careful design wards off the harshness and squealing sometimes associated with analogue filters. As the envelope shaper can optionally drive the overdrive effect too, there's plenty of mileage in muckying up loops and samples. In fact, I'd say it's more or less obligatory! Using MIDI control of gating, filter selection, and filter cutoff, there's a wealth of signal-chopping and swooshing activities to indulge in. Although not all parameters are MIDI controllable, the options chosen work well. Indeed, the VF1 has relatively few shortcomings, but its inability to switch freely between MIDI modes without pulling the plug certainly counts as one of them! The keys to the VF1 are its simplicity and versatility — it just insists on being tweaked! To this end, the smooth knobs and soft switches are a delight and every feature seems to have a range of operation yielding only practical results. If you're looking for a stand-alone stereo analogue filter, the Xone VF1 comes highly recommended. Published in SOS May 2005
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Allen%20&%20Heath%20Xone%20VF1.htm (6 of 7)9/27/2005 9:21:55 PM
Allen & Heath Xone VF1
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Allen%20&%20Heath%20Xone%20VF1.htm (7 of 7)9/27/2005 9:21:55 PM
Apple Mac Mini
In this article:
What's In The Tin First Impressions Time For An Upgrade Performance Adding More Memory Build-To-Order Price List
Apple Mac Mini Desktop Computer Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Computer
Apple Mac Mini £399/ £339 pros The smallest, most affordable Mac ever. Doesn't get too hot or produce an unbearable amount of fan noise. Makes an interesting DSP accelerator for Logic Pro users, especially those with Powerbooks.
cons The cost of the Mac Mini can quickly rise once you start adding the build-to-order options. Some users who aren't skilled (or willing) to use a putty knife may be reluctant to perform their own upgrades to the Mac Mini.
summary While the Mac has long been priced above the price range many people consider affordable, the Mac Mini is a perfectly priced model for those wishing to try out the Mac platform for very little money, and isn't so underpowered that musicians and audio engineers couldn't find an interesting use for the device.
information 1.42GHz model £399; 1.25GHz model £339. Prices include VAT. www.apple.com/uk/
Apple have long been criticised for charging a premium for their products, making the Mac platform a more costly choice than the alternatives. With the newly released Mac Mini, Apple hope to change this perception, but is there enough Mac in the Mac Mini to make it useful for musicians? Mark Wherry
As a computer company, Apple seem to be obsessed with size. When they aren't creating the biggest piece of equipment around, as seen with the recently introduced 30-inch Cinema Display, they're busy developing at the titchy end of the scale as well. Having miniaturised the iPod into the iPod Mini, Apple have now miniaturised the Mac into the Mac Mini, originally announced at this year's Macworld show in San Francisco back in January, ending what has been a 20-year wait for a low-cost Macintosh computer. Photos: Mike Cameron
What's In The Tin
With a DVI output and the option of Bluetooth, the Mac Mini is compatible with Apple's Cinema Displays and wireless peripherals, though it comes with no display, keyboard or mouse as standard.
The Mac Mini is available in two configurations: one with a 1.25GHz G4 processor and a 40GB Ultra ATA hard drive for £339 and the other with a 1.42GHz G4 processor and an 80GB Ultra ATA drive for £399. Both models offer a 512k Level2 cache on the processor, a 167MHz system buss, 256MB of PC2700 SDRAM
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Apple%20Mac%20Mini.htm (1 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:00 PM
Apple Mac Mini
Test Spec Apple 1.42GHz Mac Mini running Mac OS 10.3.7. Apple Logic Pro 7.0.1. 1GB memory chip from Crucial (CT431640). Putty knife.
upgradeable to 1GB, an ATI Radeon 9200 graphics processor with AGP 4X and 32MB of dedicated Double Data Rate (DDR) video memory, along with a slotloading Combo drive capable of reading DVDs at 8x and CD media at 24x speed, and writing CD-Rs at 24x and CD-RWs at 16x speed. In terms of connectivity, the Mac Mini offers one Firewire 400 port, two USB 2.0 ports, a headphone output mini-jack, a modem, 10/100 Ethernet, and a DVI port. That the Mac Mini has a DVI port is actually pretty neat, and while Apple supply a DVI-to-VGA adaptor, the Mac Mini is capable of driving LCD monitors with a resolution of up to 1920 x 1200; or, in other words, a 23-inch Apple Cinema Display. For wireless networking, the Mac Mini is compatible with Apple's Airport Extreme cards, and there's also a build-to-order Bluetooth option. It's worth pointing out that another 'feature' that puts the Mini into Mac Mini is the lack of keyboard and mouse. This is obviously a cost-cutting move as well, although because the Mac Mini's target market is partly those Windows users who might just want to add a Mac to their system, Apple justify it by reasoning that those buyers will already have a spare keyboard and mouse sitting around. For the money, the Mac Mini's specifications aren't terrible: the G4 processors used are faster than in the current iBook models, and almost the equal of what you would have found in the Powerbook range until recently. The ATI Radeon 9200 graphics and 32MB video memory will give adequate The inclusion of a Firewire 400 port enables the Mac Mini to be connected to Firewire performance for Aqua (32MB is the audio interfaces, and also to other Macs as a minimum required), and at least the Node in a distributed Logic system. video memory isn't shared with the main memory. And speaking of memory, this is perhaps the biggest issue people will have the Mac Mini's specifications: 256MB really isn't enough to get the most out of Mac OS X. Even if you just use consumer-oriented software, all of the iLife applications (with the possible exception of iTunes) will benefit from more memory. So while the small amount of included memory was probably necessary to keep the cost down, you will almost certainly need to order more memory with your Mac Mini or upgrade soon after the purchase. In addition to the base models described above and on Apple's web site, there are many build-to-order options from the Apple Store, along with a slightly more beefed-up model Apple sell to certain retailers, and this is the area where the Mac Mini has come in for the most criticism. Once you start configuring your dream Mac Mini, complete with 1GB memory, a Superdrive, Airport, Bluetooth and so on (see the Build-To-Order Price List box), it's easy to go over the 1000 figure in any currency, which starts to make the Mac Mini look rather less of a bargain, and probably too expensive for what you end up with. To Apple's credit (and not in the financial sense), though, the company did respond to this issue a few weeks after the Mac Mini's release and lowered the cost of many of the buildto-order options. Arguably, if you want to get a really powerful Mac system, you
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Apple%20Mac%20Mini.htm (2 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:00 PM
Apple Mac Mini
probably shouldn't be looking at a Mac Mini in the first place, since the product is clearly aimed at the lower end of the market.
First Impressions Despite the consumer orientation of the Mac Mini, I couldn't resist buying one and seeing if it actually could be of interest to those who use Macs for music and audio purposes, although this was initially harder than expected. On the day of the Mac Mini's release, I visited my local Apple Store in the US and already the Mac Mini had sold out. The on-line Apple Store, while fulfilling pre-orders, was clearly going to be a bit of wait, but in the end I found another web-based store that was able to supply a basic 1.42GHz Mac Mini a few days after the product's release — interestingly, they sold out completely a couple of days after this. Since there's no keyboard or mouse, the packaging for the Mac Mini is incredibly compact, and once you get the actual computer out of the box it's hard not to be astounded by just how small it really is. As a 6.5-inch square that's just two inches tall, and weighing in at 2.9 pounds (1.32kg), the Mac Mini makes Apple's last attempt at a compact desktop Mac, the G4 Cube, look bulky. And perhaps this comparison isn't unfair: Apple's The Mac Mini is capable of running five eightpublicity shots of the Mac Mini with voice instances of Sculpture in Logic Pro keyboard, mouse and an Apple 7.0.1, as shown here. Cinema Display are strangely reminiscent. But while the G4 Cube failed because it didn't really meet a market demand, the Mac Mini seems not to have that problem; although I always wanted a G4 Cube, I could never justify the cost, but the affordable nature of the Mac Mini removes this issue. One factor that helps keep the Mac Mini small is that the power supply is an external unit, which looks much the same as those used in Apple's current range of Cinema Displays. At first I thought the external power 'brick' might spoil the small aesthetic of the Mac Mini, but the leads are plenty long enough to hide the power supply away from the computer. That the power supply isn't in the computer also helps with cooling, and although I worried that the Mac Mini might suffer from getting rather hot in the same way as Powerbooks, I didn't notice this being an issue in practice. After switching on the Mac Mini and proceeding with the now familiar Mac OS X registration process, the Mac Mini did initially feel a little more sluggish than the more powerful Macs I'm used to using. Even using the Finder made it clear that more memory was definitely going to be necessary. file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Apple%20Mac%20Mini.htm (3 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:00 PM
Apple Mac Mini
Time For An Upgrade At the time of my Mac Mini purchase, it was impossible to order a unit with more than 256MB memory and get it delivered the next day; ordering 512MB or 1GB memory from Apple would have cost £50 or £220 respectively. Instead, I ordered a 1GB memory chip from Crucial for $161.99 (the equivalent cost in the UK from Crucial's UK web site would be £102.21), which obviously worked out a little cheaper. However, there are two things to bear in mind: firstly, the Mac Mini only has one memory slot, so upgrading actually means taking out the current memory chip and putting a completely new one in. And secondly, if you do order the memory chip to put in the Mac Mini yourself, it's not quite the easy upgrade that Power Mac and Powerbook users are used to. In order to perform any kind of upgrade on your Mac Mini, whether you're adding memory or an Airport Extreme card, you have to take the lid off the unit. This doesn't sound difficult, of course, except for the fact it's impossible to do it with just your hands. But the great thing about the now almost cult appeal of the Mac Mini is that a simple Internet search will reveal a vast quantity of information on how to take the unit apart, from those who have found and posted Apple's official service manual for the Mac Mini, a training video for engineers, those who have put a Windows machine inside the Mac Mini, and so much more.
The Mac Mini could make a perfect Logic Node when used with a Powerbook via Firewire TCP/IP networking. This screenshot is taken from a Powerbook G4 running Logic Pro 7.0.1, but with Audio Objects offloaded to a Mac Mini running Logic Node, connected via Firewire.
It turns out that the way to take the Mac Mini apart (which you'll see was achieved quite successfully in the photo on the last page of this article) is to use a putty knife, although it's probably a good idea not to recycle the same tool used to retile your bathroom! A very thin blade can be inserted between the point where the upper case meets the base of the Mac Mini to unlatch the clips so you can slide the top of the computer away from the base. It might take a little courage the first time you try this, and it's still questionable whether doing it yourself voids the warranty, but it's actually fairly simple and takes very little time. Obviously, neither myself or Sound On Sound accept any liability if you try to perform your own Mac Mini upgrades, but I can say that I did do this on my own unit and ran into no problems.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Apple%20Mac%20Mini.htm (4 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:00 PM
Apple Mac Mini
Performance Given the specifications of the Mac Mini, it goes without saying that this isn't going to be the most powerful Mac system on the planet for music and audio purposes. However, given the attractive nature of the machine, both in terms of the aesthetic and cost, just how much can you reasonably expect? To answer this question, I carried the usual array of tests that I've written about in previous Mac reviews and in Apple Notes, using Logic Pro 7.01 and some of the built-in instruments and effects: Platinumverb, Space Designer, EXS24, and, just to spice things up a little, Sculpture. To begin with, I carried out the tests using the base 1.42GHz Mac Mini with just the stock 256MB memory installed. Starting with Platinumverb, along with a single ES P instrument as a test signal, I was able to run 15 stereo instances with 84 percent User CPU indicated in the Activity Monitor utility; adding a 16th instance made the display a little sluggish, and going up to 21 instances made the display totally unusable, with a 95 percent User CPU reading. By way of comparison, a 1.8GHz G5 iMac managed 46 instances, while a 1.5GHz G4 Powerbook managed 20.
The Mac Mini's slot-loading Combo drive offers DVD reading and CD-R and RW reading and writing functions.
Moving onto Space Designer, the 1.42GHz Mac Mini managed four instances comfortably, while a fifth instance caused problems even though the User CPU figure was only at 86 percent. The iMac was able to run 17 instances in this same test, and the Powerbook performed the same as the Mac Mini, also running four instances. Next I tried Logic's EXS24 sampler. Since the 256MB memory of the Mac Mini wasn't enough to load my favoured harp from the Vienna Symphonic Library, I opted for the 30.6MB Stereo Grand instrument from Logic's stock library. With no filter enabled and the standard 16-bit storage mode selected in EXS24's preferences, I was able to play 150 voices across three instances with a 95 percent User CPU reading. With a filter, this value went down to 64 voices from one EXS24 instance, using 85 percent User CPU. Enabling EXS24's 32-bit storage mode, where the Stereo Grand instrument now required 61.3MB memory, it was possible to play 256 voices across four instances with 98 percent User CPU, although the system was admittedly very sluggish at this point. With the filter turned on, the polyphony dropped to 86 voices and 94 percent User CPU. As a comparison, using the VSL harp with 16-bit storage, the 1.5GHz Powerbook G4 played 276 voices with the filter disabled and 84 voices with the filter enabled; with 32-bit floating-point storage used instead, the same Powerbook played 660
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Apple%20Mac%20Mini.htm (5 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:00 PM
Apple Mac Mini
voices with the filter disabled and 106 voices with the filter enabled. Looking at a slightly different Logic instrument as well for a change, namely Sculpture, the Mac Mini was able to cope with five, eight-voice instances with the 'Attack Flute' preset (Logic users will note how dramatically the performance of the instrument can change depending on the patch used) at 90 percent User CPU. The audio still worked if I added a sixth instance, but the user interface ground to a halt.
Adding More Memory Since the performance of Mac OS X benefits from having more memory installed, I repeated the same tests on my Mac Mini after installing a 1GB chip. With Platinumverb I could comfortably run 21 stereo instances with 95 percent User CPU, but with Space Designer I was only able to run the same four instances, this time with 91 percent User CPU. With EXS24 the results in terms of polyphony were identical, and the only real difference was that with Logic taking advantage of more physical memory, its general performance was less sluggish, even with the high polyphony of the EX24 in 32-bit floating-point storage mode with no filters enabled. And using Sculpture I was able to get six eight-voice instances running, with the user interface slightly sluggish, but not completely killing the system, with 96 percent User CPU; five instances used 90 percent. In these tests, somewhat surprisingly, the extra memory made little difference, although it has to be borne in mind that none of them really made intensive use of the extra memory. The only real benefit was that the operating system could use more physical memory, making the whole system far If you're handy with a putty knife, it's possible more responsive. Another important to save money by upgrading your Mac Mini's consideration with these memory memory yourself, rather than choosing one of Apple's buy-to-order options. comparisons, however, is that the test songs were almost empty except for objects required for the test: a 'real' song would actually require more memory. The fact that with a relatively empty song, these tests show little difference between having 256MB or 1GB installed opens up an interesting application for the basic Mac Mini, which is to use it as an alternative to something like TC Electronic's Firewire Powercore for running Logic instruments and effects via Logic Pro 7's distributed audio functionality. Indeed, as covered in last month's Apple Notes, setting up a network via Firewire and getting the Mac Mini to boot automatically into Logic Node is fairly trivial, and the cost of the Mac Mini makes it quite an affordable option for Powerbook users, as an example, who want to run a few more Space Designer or Sculpture instances for around £400 — see screenshots for an example of this in action. And as a bonus, you're actually file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Apple%20Mac%20Mini.htm (6 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:00 PM
Apple Mac Mini
getting another Mac that might have uses beyond simply running Logic Node. Overall, it's hard not to like the Mac Mini. Aesthetically, it's great. Financially, it's great. And for those users just getting started who might want to play around with Logic Express or an M Box, it really is a great product. Even for more demanding users, the Mac Mini can be valuable, for instance as a Logic Node system. Normally the highest compliment a reviewer can pay a product is to say they bought the unit after review; in this case, I bought the unit before writing the review. And while I have to confess to loving new toys, the Mac Mini is a great and fairly affordable toy that has surprising usefulness in the studio.
Build-To-Order Price List 512MB memory: £50.01. 1GB memory: £220.01. 80GB hard drive for 1.25GHz model: £30.01. 4x speed Superdrive: £70.01. Internal Bluetooth module: £35. Airport Extreme card: £49. Bluetooth and Airport Extreme: £69.99. Wired keyboard and mouse: £38. Wireless keyboard and mouse: £69.99. Applecare Protection Plan: £129.
Prices include VAT. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Apple%20Mac%20Mini.htm (7 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:00 PM
ART TCS
In this article:
ART TCS
Technical Specifications Dual Compressor Preset Convenience With Published in SOS May 2005 Manual Control Variable Voicing Print article : Close window In The Studio With The TCS Reviews : Microphone V3 Verdict
ART TCS £305 pros Combines the ease of presets with the flexibility of manual adjustment. Offers true optical and VCA compression. Built-in noise reduction. Valve stage for added warmth. Extremely affordable.
Choose from optical and VCA compression, de-essing, noise reduction, and valve voicing within a single processor. Paul White
cons The manual doesn't make it entirely clear how the controls interact with the presets. No side-chain listen facility.
Photos: Mike Cameron
summary This is a good compressor for beginners, because the presets are so easy to use, but it is also flexible enough to satisfy the needs of the more experienced user.
information £305.49 including VAT. Sonic8 +44 (0)8701 657456. +44 (0)8701 657458. Click here to email www.sonic8.com www.artproaudio.com
ART's new TCS dual compressor offers the benefits of both application-specific 'character' presets and full manual control (including the ability to adjust the presets) when necessary. Unlike other preset-based machines, the presets here are as much about character as about defining exactly how the compressor is set up, so you can use the default settings as a starting point and fine-tune from there. Alternatively, if you're a bit wary of compressors, you can select a suitable preset, then adjust only the Threshold control to achieve the desired amount of gain reduction. Furthermore, because compressors are routinely used to add a musical flavour rather than simply to control levels, the ART TCS includes both optical and VCA (Voltage Controlled Amplifier) gain-control stages to offer the best of both worlds. Traditionally, VCA compression tends to be the most transparent, while optical types that rely on a lamp and a photosensitive device are best known for their vintage character. There's also switchable valve circuitry to provide more choice over tonality by inserting a 12AX7 gain stage into the signal path. Housed in a 1U steel rack case and powered directly from the mains via an IEC connector, the ART TCS offers the user a choice of both balanced XLR and unbalanced jack inputs and outputs operating at +4dBu and -10dBV respectively. There's also a TRS insert jack that can be used to place other processors
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/ART%20TCS.htm (1 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:02 PM
ART TCS
(usually equalisers) in series with the sidechain. The front panel looks quite busy, but is in fact very logically set out. First of all, a Level control adjusts the instrument input into the compressor. Following this are the familiar Threshold, Ratio (adjustable up to hard limiting), Attack, and Release controls for manual operation or preset tweaking. Note that there is no conventional make-up gain knob within the channel control area. Instead there are two knobs at the extreme right of the front panel that operate as stereo level and balance controls in stereo mode or as separate channel output-level controls in split mono mode.
Preset Convenience With Manual Control
Technical Specifications Frequency Response: 10Hz150kHz ±1dB THD: 0.01 percent at 1kHz Maximum Input Level: +20dBu Maximum Output Level: +20dBu Input/Output Connections: balanced XLR and balanced/ unbalanced quarter-inch TRS jack Side-chain Input: quarter-inch TRS (ring send, tip receive) XLR/Jack Input Impedance: 10k(omega) Instrument Input Impedance: 1M(omega)
The input Level control is linked to the highOutput Impedance: 300 impedance front-panel instrument-level input (omega) (balanced) jack, and it has a 0-30dB gain range. Plugging anything into this instrument jack overrides the Dimensions 1.75 x 19.0 x 6.5 inches (hwd) rear-panel input connectors. In addition to the compressor, each channel also features a Weight: 5.5lbs (2.5 kg) noise-reduction section that can be either a gate or an expander depending on which preset mode is chosen. The only way to tell which is active is to observe the NR LED, which will gradually dim when in expander mode and switch off more abruptly in gate mode. The only user controls here are Threshold and Shelf, where the latter controls a side-chain filter — when this is fully anticlockwise it makes the sidechain most sensitive to lower frequencies, whereas the fully clockwise position makes the side-chain sensitive predominantly to high frequencies. A central setting gives a nominally flat response. Gain reduction is monitored by an edgewise moving-coil meter, and though the scale is unreadably small, it gives you a very good idea of what is going on. Directly below this is a set of three buttons, one for bypassing the channel, one for switching the valve circuitry in or out, and one for engaging or bypassing the rear-panel side-chain insert points. This side-chain bypass feature is very useful, as it allows the inserts to be permanently left connected to a patchbay or external processor. To the right of the right-hand channel are two further buttons, one for stereo linking the two channels and one for changing the two high-resolution LED meters between reading the input level and reading the output level. These meters have a peak-hold function and so are very useful for warning of potential clipping problems. When stereo linking is selected, both channels are controlled from the left-hand set of controls and the two side-chains are fed with the same signal to avoid image shifts when compressing asymmetrical mixes.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/ART%20TCS.htm (2 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:02 PM
ART TCS
Variable Voicing I've left the most important control until last, and that is the V3 voicing knob. This operates a rotary switch to give different preset and manual processing modes with either optical or VCA compression. Within the optical compression selection there are settings for Bass, Mixes, Vocals, and Choral, as well as the fully manual setting — the Vocals option includes a built-in de-esser for reducing vocal sibilance, and different noise reduction (gate or expander) is used in each case, as detailed in the manual. Switching to VCA mode reveals presets for Vocals, Mixes, Percussion, and Bass, as well as the manual setting, and the vocal preset includes de-essing again. The remaining V3 knob settings use a combination of optical and VCA gain control. The first combination mode is Stack, which combines both compressor types in such a way that the selected ratio value is effectively doubled — you're really compressing twice. The Sustain preset is designed to do exactly that — add sustain to guitars and other sources — while Nice is a more extreme compressor with character. The Guitar knob position is a guitar-specific patch to add density and to even out the sound.
Here you can see the two gain-control elements used in each channel of the ART TCS: a VCA (voltage-controlled amplifier) on the left and an LED-based optical component on the right.
Finally three OPL presets use the optical circuit for compression, teamed with the VCA circuit rigged as a limiter. This is a nice combination, as you can dial in enough compression to allow the sound to breath, but still catch those high peaks before they cause trouble. The presets on offer are Leveling, Mix, and Vocals.
In The Studio With The TCS The manual doesn't make it entirely clear exactly how the front-panel controls interact with the presets, but looking at the gain-reduction meter, it's obvious that they adjust whatever attack and release times are called up, which seem to differ quite a lot between one preset and another. This is to be expected, as part of the art of using a compressor is selecting the correct attack, release, and ratio settings for specific instrument types. The tonality of the sound remains reasonably consistent between presets, but the character of the compression definitely changes, with the optical modes sounding smoother and more rounded than the VCA alternatives.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/ART%20TCS.htm (3 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:02 PM
ART TCS
Having a vocal de-esser built in is also a nice touch, and though this isn't as effective or transparent as a dedicated de-esser that attenuates only problem frequencies, it is very welcome for the bonus feature that it is. The in-built noise reduction also works smoothly enough and saves having to use a separate gate or expander, though I couldn't find any means of monitoring the noise-reduction side-chain filter or the effects of processors connected into the side-chain insert point. Switching in the valve circuit leaves the top end sounding much the same as before, but there's definitely more weight and warmth at the lower end of the spectrum. This function works equally well on guitar, bass, and vocals, and seems to strike a good balance between being hyped and being too subtle to be significant. On balance, the presets work pretty well for the sources for which they're intended, and having the option to tweak them means you never have to accept something that isn't quite right. I particularly liked the optical compressor character, and the modes that combine this with a VCA limiter are particularly useful, as you get the benefits of both processes in a single preset.
V3 Verdict As stated at the outset, compressors are as much about adding character as they are about controlling levels, and the ART TCS manages to do both jobs in an efficient and straightforward way. As a gain-control device, it works much like any other variable-ratio compressor, but the permutations of optical and VCA voicings mean you can choose what type of character you need for each track or mix you process. Having presets is a great way to get into compression without making too many mistakes, yet you still have the opportunity to make manual adjustments or even set up your compressor parameters from scratch if you feel confident in doing that. No compressor will ever be entirely automatic, as the Threshold level needs to be adjusted to take account of the input level and the input signal dynamics, but with the system adopted here, it's very straightforward to get musically consistent results. Overall I like ART's approach to compression, and though there are more esoteric compressors out there, few offer this amount of flexibility at this UK price and few are easier to use thanks to the wide range of presets and the switchable valve stage. There's even a side-chain filter on the noise gate/expander. You can also use the ART TCS in stereo mode, as two completely independent mono channels, or as an instrument DI with comprehensive compression, so there's no shortage of applications. Given the very attractive price, I've no complaints. Published in SOS May 2005 file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/ART%20TCS.htm (4 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:02 PM
ART TCS
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/ART%20TCS.htm (5 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:02 PM
Audio Ease Rocket Science
In this article:
Roger That Into Orbit Take Me To Your Leader Fly Away
Audio Ease Rocket Science £163
Audio Ease Rocket Science Effects Plug-ins (Mac OS) Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
pros Offers a range of interesting and contemporary-sounding effects that would be difficult to achieve by other means. Available in a wide range of plug-in formats. Easy to use, with great user interfaces. Excellent MIDI control options. Low processor hit. Good manual and tech support.
cons For the money, it might be a touch too quirky and specialised. No parameter automation in Logic except via MIDI.
summary A classy suite of uniquesounding effects. What's not to like?
information £163.33 including VAT. Unity Audio +44 (0)1440 785843. +44 (0)1440 785845. Click here to email www.unityaudio.co.uk www.audioease.com
Test Spec Rocket Science v3.02. Dual 867MHz G4 Power Mac with 1.25GB RAM, running Mac OS 10.3.7.
A new plug-in bundle from Dutch developers Audio Ease brings together three unique sound-shaping tools. Robin Bigwood
There are some plug-ins you just have to have: a neutral and a 'characterful' EQ, a flexible reverb, a handful of compressors, maybe a good delay. After that things get a bit more specialised in the murky world of filters, tone processors and multi-band tools. Go further and you're at the outer reaches, with granular synthesizers and step sequencer-driven curiosities — and it's here that Audio Ease's Rocket Science bundle belongs. This is a collection of three apparently dissimilar plug-ins which can do some interesting things to your tracks that would be difficult to achieve in other ways. Just how useful they are might depend very much on the type of music you make and how willing you are to embrace the unfamiliar in your pursuit of new sonic horizons, but they're certainly an intriguing bunch. Rocket Science is available in HTDM, RTAS, VST, MAS and AU formats for OS X, and in MAS format for OS 9. Installation on my own system was a brief and painless affair, and a decent PDF manual is included — not that you'll need to refer to it very much. Authorising the plug-ins is done via an on-line challenge/ response system, so you can do it immediately, and Audio Ease provide you with a couple of authorisations in case you need to run Rocket Science on your laptop as well as your desktop Mac, for example.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audio%20Ease%20Rocket%20Science.htm (1 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:05 PM
Audio Ease Rocket Science
Tested with MOTU Digital Performer v4.52.
Roger That Roger is a 'Multiple Gender Vowel Bank'. It's not Roger himself who's of multiple gender: the term is explained by the presence of his companions Cindy and Patty. Together they provide filtering effects that make it sound as if your audio is to some extent being 'pronounced' by voices of three different pitches. Taken on their own, the individual vowel sounds on offer just add what sounds like a very specific EQ curve, perhaps with some 'formant' resonance, to whatever audio is passing through the plug-in — a strong effect but not terribly exciting. Roger comes to life, though, through making transitions from one vowel to another, as it's then that the effect becomes really audible. You can choose vowels manually, and if your host sequencer supports it, record the changes as automation data, while Audio Ease also provide Roger with a step sequencer that switches between vowels automatically. As you'd expect, this can be flexibly sync'ed to the host sequencer's tempo, and the resulting rhythmic effects can be enhanced by tweaking the Beat Skips parameter. This causes Roger to not always change vowel on every beat, instead introducing some syncopation and cross-rhythms into the proceedings. The Portamento parameter determines the speed at which one vowel 'morphs' into another. The quality of the vowel sounds themselves is controlled by the Bandwidth parameter. At its maximum value no filtering takes place at all, and when set to its minimum, Roger breaks down into high-resonance ringing nonsense that almost completely obliterates the input signal. Between these two extremes there's plenty of usability. You have to hear the sound to really appreciate it, but it's like a combination of a swept band-pass filter, a phaser and a vocoder, and there's something undeniably charming about it that makes it into somewhat more than purely a novelty effect, though at times it can be downright funny. It works extremely well on pad and sustained sounds but can sound great on whole mixes, on drums, and on vocals, too. Having said that, though, the full vowel effect is only achieved at the expense of most of the high-frequency content of the input signal — it's certainly a plug-in that draws attention to itself. The final trick up Roger's sleeve is MIDI control. As long as your sequencer can send MIDI to plug-ins, you can choose between all 30 vowel types (10 for each character) by playing MIDI notes between C2 and B4, with the Bandwidth and Portamento values being set by key velocity or cc1 (mod wheel). This type of vowel selection, in particular, can make for some rhythmic effects which sound absolutely superb.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audio%20Ease%20Rocket%20Science.htm (2 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:05 PM
Audio Ease Rocket Science
Into Orbit Having vowel-filtered your sound, what better than to hand it over to a psychoacoustic flight-path simulator? Orbit is a processor that combines reverblike early-reflection generation with filtering and Doppler effects to 'localise' the sound it's treating in a virtual room of anything from 8 x 8m to 80 x 80mm — it is, in effect, a sort of 26th-century panner. Your own position in the virtual room is set by dragging an icon showing two speakers either side of what appears to be the planet Saturn (why not?), whilst the audio you're treating is shown as a red ball. This always represents a mono sound source, so if you place Orbit on a stereo track the two channels are summed to mono in order for the location of the red ball to be meaningful. Having set the distance your speakers (or indeed headphone drivers) are apart — which can make quite a difference to the final sound — you can then start experimenting with different room sizes and sound-source placements. Orbit can calculate up to 60 early reflections, which represents the dry signal bouncing off the four virtual walls up to a maximum of five times. To save processor power you can choose to make Orbit calculate fewer reflections, or even none at all, but even with comparatively few reflections the sense of location can be uncanny, responding as it does to your settings. The High Damp parameter makes the walls more or less absorbent, so you can choose a bathroom or airing-cupboard ambience, or anything in between. It is possible to just set your speakers and your sound source's positions and leave it at that, but Orbit goes further, and lives up to its name, by offering some movement paths for the sound source via a colourful pop-up menu. The sound source can move smoothly from one position to another, as determined by your mouse clicks and the Speed parameter, or continuously around the perimeter of an adjustable oval (in either direction). It can also, as the Rocket Science manual wryly observes, 'move randomly about like a drunk' within the oval. Where this all gets interesting is when you put the 'listening position' inside the oval path of the sound source, so the sound source seems to encircle you — that's where the psychoacoustic filtering comes in. It's also possible to place the listening position right on the sound source's path, which can make it sound like the sound is passing right through your head. Additionally, with the right room size and movement speed, Orbit will do a fire-engine-like Doppler effect. Orbit is a very interesting alternative to a conventional panner for mono tracks: even when set to produce no early reflections, it does seem to introduce a 2D
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audio%20Ease%20Rocket%20Science.htm (3 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:05 PM
Audio Ease Rocket Science
element in a way that a conventional panner can never achieve. Linked with a really good reverb, perhaps Audio Ease's own Altiverb, I could see this as being a viable tool for speech recording post-production, for example. It works nicely for instruments, too, creating a tangible sense of separation. The 'moving' modes are impressive but could clearly get tiresome if used for too long.
Take Me To Your Leader Follo, an 'Energy Driven Band Booster', is another filter effect, but it's very different to Roger. It's a resonant band-pass filter whose cutoff frequency is determined by the input level to the plug-in and limited to a frequency range set by a couple of sliders. The sensitivity of the cutoff frequency to input level is set with the Analysis parameter, the overall strength of the effect with the Bandwidth knob, and what can only be described as the 'squelchiness factor' by the Release time. If this doesn't seem terribly complex that's because it's not — Follo is brought to life by the audio it treats, and then it's simply a case of tweaking the relatively few parameters to tease out the effect you want. Audio Ease give two prime examples of Follo's possible applications — as a guitar auto-wah, and as a 'bass generator', presumably for bass drum tracks. There's no doubting this plug-in comes from the planet 'wah' but I did find it could work on a surprisingly wide range of input material, from strings to synths, and it can do some deliciously evil things to individual drums, even to a wide-band drums submix. It's also good combined with other effects — Audio Ease's suggestion of putting it after a delay works very well, especially as the gradual decay causes Follo to respond in a slightly different way for each repeat of the signal. I also tried putting Follo after a reverb which was set up in 'aux' rather than 'insert' fashion — the effect was very nice, and very novel.
Fly Away There's a lot to like about Rocket Science. To some extent the individual plug-ins are one-trick ponies, in the way that some off-the-wall freeware efforts often are. But that's where any comparison with freeware or shareware ends: Roger, Orbit and Follo absolutely ooze quality, as much from their user interfaces as from the often ravishing sounds they conjure up. Just as with Riverrun, a plug-in from Audio Ease's Nautilus bundle which is without doubt one of my 'desert island' effects, Rocket Science might not be what you reach for on every project, day-in, day-out, but it has an uncanny ability to inspire and refresh, and also to create some extremely novel and distinctive sounds. Also, the effects are not so limited in scope that you'd hardly ever use them. I could imagine whipping out Follo and Orbit fairly often, and Roger as often as I could! It helps, too, that the plug-ins run very efficiently, even on my low-end dual G4, so you can experiment with them without feeling they need to be handled with kid gloves.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audio%20Ease%20Rocket%20Science.htm (4 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:05 PM
Audio Ease Rocket Science
Gripes? I don't have any, but it should be pointed out that AU versions of the Rocket Science plug-ins don't support automation via manipulation of their graphic interface controls. This could be a problem for some Logic users, but it's possible to control virtually every parameter and setting with MIDI messages, and the manual contains exhaustive information on this. Perhaps a harder question to answer is whether Rocket Science is worth the £160 asking price. For plug-ins that aren't of the bread-and-butter variety that's quite a lot, and certainly lifts the bundle out of the 'whimware' category. But you are getting the broad plug-in format compatibility as well as quality, and additionally, Audio Ease's customer support is up there with the very best. The bottom line is that Rocket Science won't appeal to everyone, and doesn't try to, but for those creative types who are always on the lookout for something unusual and distinctive it could fit the bill perfectly. It's always a pleasure to work with software of this quality, and Rocket Science is certainly an extremely welcome addition to my own plug-ins folder. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audio%20Ease%20Rocket%20Science.htm (5 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:05 PM
Audix SCX25
In this article:
In-depth Studio Tests Self-noise & Polar Pattern Verdict
Audix SCX25 £595
Audix SCX25 Condenser Microphone Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Microphone
pros Very compact size allows easy placement, especially in pianos. Effective internal shockmount. A slightly lean but natural sound that cuts through a mix.
Large-diaphragm mics don't have to be bulky and unwieldy, as this compact new contender from Audix demonstrates.
cons Subcardioid polar pattern. Restricted SPL capability. No internal pad facility.
Hugh Robjohns
The Audix SCX25 is a large-diaphragm studio condenser mic with a fixed A very compact largediaphragm capacitor mic with cardioid polar pattern, but housed in an a slightly lean sound, boasting unusually small body. While there will a very effective internal always be the need for physically large shockmount. Minimal microphones to help make the vocal proximity effect coupled with a talent feel cherished, large-diaphragm limited bass extension allows mics in compact cases are a lot easier close-miking, and a high presence peak provides a to place, and far more visually discreet. Photo: Mark Ewing sense of air and detail. The SCX25 represents the top of the information company's capacitor mic range, and is produced entirely in America. It is shipped in a smart foam-lined wooden box within a cardboard outer sleeve, and is SCX25, £595; SCX25 matched pair, £1395; D-Clip accompanied with a sheet of generic specs and suggested applications. summary
mounting hardware, £8.49. Prices include VAT. Stirling Audio +44 (0)20 8963 4790. +44 (0)20 8963 4799. Click here to email www.stirlingsyco.com www.audixusa.com
A side-address microphone, it displays more than a passing resemblance to a lollipop — a 50mm disk supported from a 95mm stem. The physical design is claimed to minimise acoustic reflections and diffractions, and enables the capsule head to be positioned with ease even in congested areas. The microphone is mounted to a stand using a simple clip-on bracket (complete with 3/8-inch thread adaptor) which slips onto the slim 20mm-diameter stem. The SCX25 is not supplied with a shockmount adaptor, but Audix claim that it doesn't need one thanks to a patented capsule suspension within the housing disk. The microphone body is made of brass, anodised matt black, with a highly polished frame around the capsule and at the top of the stem body. The solidstate, transformerless impedance-conversion electronics are contained within the stem, which terminates in the usual three-pin male XLR connector. The front of
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audix%20SCX25.htm (1 of 4)9/27/2005 9:22:07 PM
Audix SCX25
the mic is indicated by the Audix name and model number etched into the brass stem just below the capsule. The capsule is hard to see through the dense but slightly flexible wire grilles on either side of the disk, but it is apparently one inch in diameter with a five-micron, gold-sputtered mylar diaphragm. This is a true externally polarised capacitor mic that requires phantom power (quoted as 48-52V, but no figures are given for supply current). The sensitivity is a generous 27mV/Pa, with self-noise of 14dBA, and a maximum SPL of 135dB (for one percent distortion). The frequency response is given on the supplied spec sheet as simply 20Hz-20kHz, but elsewhere I found a rather wide tolerance range of +5/-2.5dB. What you see is what you get with this mic — the polar pattern is fixed, and there are no highpass filter or pad switches. The mic weighs 170g, but much of that weight is in the capsule, making it noticeably top-heavy.
In-depth Studio Tests The obvious starting point in forming an opinion on the SCX25 seemed to be to compare it with the Microtech Gefell M930, since they share similar physical attributes, but I also put it up against my trusted standards: the Neumann TLM103 and the small-diaphragm Sennheiser MKH40. All were hooked up to a GML mic preamp as the front end, and then through a Yamaha DM1000 mixer and on to PMC monitoring. The first thing to test was the internal shockmount. The M930 isn't supplied with a shockmount as standard (although a rubber 'doughnut' stand adaptor is optionally available and works very well), but my TLM103 sits in a full cradle, and the MKH40s have shockmounted clips as standard. I mounted these mics on adjacent stands and, having adjusted input gains appropriately, I was impressed with the isolation from mechanical vibrations achieved by the Audix mic. Far better than the M930, and very similar to the performance of the shockmounted Sennheiser and Neumann mics.
In comparison with many other largediaphragm mics, the SCX25 is remarkably compact, and it's therefore much easier to position in cramped spaces, for example under a piano lid.
Next up was a listening test to male voice — mine, in fact! Working at a distance of about 30cm, the sound came over as clean, slightly lean, and with a hint of added presence or air. It didn't appear to have the bass extension of the M930 or the MKH40, and even the TLM103 sounded warmer. Neither did it sound quite as open at the extreme top end, and file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audix%20SCX25.htm (2 of 4)9/27/2005 9:22:07 PM
Audix SCX25
the overall impression was that it sounded slightly 'smooth' and light — no bad thing in the right circumstances. The microphone exhibits relatively little proximity effect and I found it possible to work far closer with the SCX25 than with other mics before the sound became excessively boomy, something that was particularly noticeable on acoustic guitar. However, recording close vocals with the SCX25 demands the use of a proper pop screen — it is simply not possible to work without one. On a 12-string acoustic I found the SCX25 tended to lose control of the complex harmonics and delivered a slightly confused, almost harsh sound in comparison to the reference mics, but as a percussion overhead it worked well to provide clean, clear detail with crisp transients, without excessive splashiness from cymbal crashes. However, on a couple of occasions there was a hint of transient clipping in this application, which I'm fairly sure can be attributed to the mic rather than the preamp, so this may not be the ideal overhead mic if you are working with a powerful drummer.
Self-noise & Polar Pattern The relatively high (by modern standards) self-noise was evident when compared directly with the TLM103 and the M930, and it was also a brighter hiss. To be fair, in musical applications I doubt the mic's self-noise will ever be an issue, but the SCX25 might not be the best choice for spoken-word applications. The polar pattern was, I found, subcardioid at low and mid-range frequencies, and almost omni at the high end, albeit with a significant flattening of the sides at extreme high frequencies. The latter is to be expected with a large-diaphragm mic, but the poor cardioid shape across the entire range was something of a disappointment, and made the mic much more prone to picking up unwanted spill than my other references. When used for solo vocals, for example, the SCX25 captured noticeably more of the room sound than the M930 or TLM103. The rear null was never particularly deep, reaching maybe 10dB around 1kHz and less everywhere else. However, the off-axis response is quite smooth and reasonably neutral, so at least the spill doesn't sound too coloured or phasey. One of the specialist applications recommended for the SCX25 is that of miking pianos, and in this role the mic's attributes work well in its favour. The slim design allows it to sit above the strings of a grand piano very neatly (or within the body of an upright piano), and with suitable miniature stands the lid can be supported on the short stick or even closed completely. The insignificant proximity effect and the slightly curtailed bass also help to prevent the sound from becoming boomy, and the integral shockmount minimised mechanical damper noise. Of course, close miking of this kind doesn't suit every musical genre, but where a 'pop sound' is appropriate, the Audix mic works very well indeed, producing a detailed but clean and precise result. I used a small table stand sitting on the soundboard to support the mic in a grand piano, but Audix can supply the file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audix%20SCX25.htm (3 of 4)9/27/2005 9:22:07 PM
Audix SCX25
optional D-Clip for the SCX25 which is designed to clamp onto the dividing bars of a grand piano's frame. Finally, I tried the SCX25 as a woodwind mic in a test recording of a school orchestra. Its wide pattern and lean sound worked well, capturing a clean and delicate recording with plenty of character and 'wood'. In fact, I could easily become quite attached to the Audix in this role.
Verdict In conclusion, the SCX25 is an interesting mic with an unusual blend of qualities. Its small size makes placement easy, and the internal shockmount works surprisingly well. It provides a high output level, ideal for preamps with limited gain, and although it's noisier than the best it is quiet enough for all normal musical applications. The lack of proximity effect allows close placement, but I would place a question mark over the maximum SPLs it can handle, and also over it's poor directionality. The tonal quality tends towards the lightweight, with a noticeable, though smooth, high presence peak, but this will often help instruments to cut through in a mix without you having to resort to the EQ. The mic also tends to suit male vocalists with 'deep brown' voices more than female and high male voices, and would make a good alternative for those who find the TLM103 too thick or boomy. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Audix%20SCX25.htm (4 of 4)9/27/2005 9:22:07 PM
Bornemark Broomstick Bass
In this article:
Broomstick Basics Bass Box Touching All The Basses Auto Pilot Manual Control Big Bottom Style File Verdict
Bornemark Broomstick Bass £169 pros Very well designed and easy to use. While Auto mode is the key selling point, Manual mode is also excellent. Good value for money considering the range and quality of the sample library alone.
Bornemark Broomstick Bass Virtual Bass Player Instrument (Mac/PC) Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
So how is your plug-in band coming on, then? With a combination of Steinberg's Groove Agent and Virtual Guitarist plus Yamaha's Vocaloid, all that is required is a bass player. Enter, stage left, Bornemark's Broomstick Bass... John Walden
Given how well received products such as Virtual Guitarist and Groove Agent cons were, it is perhaps surprising that a Relatively modest effects 'virtual bass player' hasn't appeared section. before now. Just like buses, you wait Could benefit from more hipfor ages for one and two arrive hop, R&B or other modern together. Off the mark slightly before styles. Steinberg's own Virtual Bassist is summary Bornemark's Broomstick Bass Bornemark's Broomstick Bass. The Bornemark name might not immediately provides a solid and reliable be familiar to many SOS readers, but virtual bass player. While the auto-accompaniment is Sven Bornemark led the production perhaps the main selling teams for both Groove Agent and point, the quality of the bass Virtual Guitarist, so his pedigree is well sounds, plus their various established. articulations, means that this plug-in also makes an excellent 'manual' samplebased bass instrument.
Broomstick Bass in Auto mode with its namesake instrument selected. The Memory Tab at the top of the window allows 16 snapshots of the plug-in settings to be saved for later recall.
Of course, musical autoaccompaniment is not a new idea, but information the type of 'virtual band member' £169 including VAT. provided by Groove Agent or Virtual MI7 +44 (0)1446 754350. Guitarist has taken the process to a new level by including a high-quality sample +46 40 6992509. collection. Whatever your own personal take on auto-accompaniment in the Click here to email creative process, with virtual guitarists, drummers and singers already available, www.mi7.com bass players were the next obvious target. So is Broomstick Bass a valuable www.bornemark.se 'session musician in a box' or a bunch of 'cheesy keyboard-style' presets? Let's
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Bornemark%20Broomstick%20Bass.htm (1 of 8)9/27/2005 9:22:11 PM
Bornemark Broomstick Bass
Test Spec 3.2GHz Pentium 4 PC with 2GB of RAM running Windows XP Pro (Service Pack 2), with Echo Mia 24, Egosys Wami Rack 24 and Yamaha SW1000XG soundcards. Steinberg Cubase SX v3.0.1. Steinberg Groove Agent 2. Broomstick Bass version reviewed: v1.0.0.
get the lowdown...
Broomstick Basics Broomstick Bass is constructed from four elements. First, a large sample library (just over 800MB) has been built from 21 different bass instruments and is divided into four main types; acoustic, electric, keyboards and pedal basses. Incidentally, the plug-in takes its name from one of these instruments — a homemade 'bass' consisting of a metal bucket, a broomstick and a piece of string (see the screenshot on the left for an image of this). A full list of the instruments is provided in the 'Touching All The Basses' box elsewhere in this article. Second is the auto-accompaniment section. This consists of dozens of individual styles, each grouped into a general musical genre (see the 'Style File' box over the page for details). As described more fully in a moment, each individual style actually consists of eight variations (bass riffs or patterns) and these are adjusted automatically to fit the chords arriving at the MIDI input. The third element is the DSP section. This provides a collection of the more common processing options used with bass sounds and includes a three-band EQ, a pitch-shifter, compressor, chorus and overdrive. Finally, a Manual mode is included where Broomstick Bass can be used as a playable virtual instrument using any of the sampled instruments from the library.
Bass Box Bornemark recommend that Broomstick Bass is run on a minimum 800MHz Pentium III PC under Windows XP, or a 600MHz G3 Mac under Mac OS v10.3, both with at least 512MB of RAM and 850MB of disk space. Both platforms require a DVD drive and a VST- or AU-compatible host sequencer (the latter on the Mac only, obviously). The plug-in itself is provided on a single DVD-ROM (not a CD-ROM) with a slim printed manual. The latter is very well written and covers both the operation and concept/background to the instrument. Installation is simple, and allows user selection of the sample library location. Registration of Broomstick Bass can be completed on-line using the supplied serial number, and this provides access to updates and extras. These already include a 'gift pack' (a 14MB download) containing samples for two additional instruments and a dozen additional styles. Both the manual and the web site suggest that further add-ons will be made available to registered users at no charge — an attractive feature of the product. After installation, the plug-in was recognised without a problem by Cubase SX on my test system.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Bornemark%20Broomstick%20Bass.htm (2 of 8)9/27/2005 9:22:11 PM
Bornemark Broomstick Bass
The main screen of Broomstick Bass is divided into three areas. To the right, the user can select the required instrument and this displays an image of the selected instrument. This section also includes the master volume control, a switch for Poly/ Mono mode and smaller knobs for adjusting Glide, Release and Release Noise. The Release simply changes how long a sample is sustained after a note is released, while for added realism, the Release Noise control attempts to add more (or less) of the finger noise created as a note is released. The bottom section of the window contains In Manual mode, Broomstick Bass a virtual keyboard. This can be used for offers a selection of different triggering patterns or individual notes if an performance articulations. external MIDI keyboard is not available. The shaded area of the keyboard is the 'Control Octave' and this is used to select patterns in Auto mode or articulations in Manual mode. Both of these modes are described more fully below. The left side of the window is somewhat busier. This includes the Auto/Manual switch which flips between the two main modes of operation. At the top of this section is the Style selector used in Auto mode. If the Link button is on, selecting a particular style also loads the appropriate instrument. The Memory tab brings up 16 user slots where you can save the current configuration of Broomstick Bass. You can automate the process of switching between these with MIDI continuous controllers, so the tab provides a simple way to move between different setups mid-song. This can include a change in the instrument used, but this may well cause a slight glitch as it involves loading the sample data on the fly. Running two instances of Broomstick Bass provides a workaround to this problem, as the plug-in only produced a CPU load of three to five percent when running under Cubase SX on my test system. A further useful feature is the Metronome button (with the drum kit icon) and this provides a basic drum file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Bornemark%20Broomstick%20Bass.htm (3 of 8)9/27/2005 9:22:11 PM
Touching All The Basses Aside from the homemade broomstick bass from which the plugin takes its name, Bornemark sampled 20 different bass instruments. These are as follows: KEYBOARD BASSES Fender Rhodes Piano Bass. Minimoog (four different sounds). ARP 2600 (two different sounds). ARP Odyssey (two different sounds). ARP Omni (the bass preset). Yamaha DX7 (preset Bass 1).
ELECTRIC BASSES Fender Precision (picked and fingered, both damped). Fender Jazz (picked and fingered). Gibson Thunderbird (fingered, amped). Rickenbacker 4001 (picked, amped). Hagström H8 (picked and damped). Music Man Sabre (picked and slapped).
Bornemark Broomstick Bass
pattern (in a suitable style) to audition the bass lines against. While it will not replace something like Groove Agent, it is certainly helpful to have.
Chapman Stick (tapped). Ashbory Bass (fingered). Manne Acoustibass fretless (fingered).
ACOUSTIC BASSES Broomstick bass.
Auto Pilot
Double bass (bowed and fingered). Tacoma Thunderchief (picked).
Of course, the most obvious selling PEDAL BASSES point of Broomstick Bass is its ability to Church organ bass pedals. act as a virtual bass player. In use, the Hammond B3 bass pedals. basic operation of Auto mode is very straightforward. Broomstick Bass Moog Taurus (Taurus preset). recognises basic chords fed to it via The first free 'Gift Pack', which can MIDI and, on the basis of the chord be downloaded from the Bornemark type, it will play a suitable bass line web site, includes two new dictated by the selected style. Each instruments; a Hofner 500/1 bass style contains eight variations and, in (made famous by Paul McCartney) and a suitably aggressive Elektron many of the styles, these are based SidStation patch. around a similar riff or pattern, with higher variation numbers containing more complex playing. You can switch between these eight variations via the onscreen display (the green Reference section or the grey Control Octave can be used). More generally, however, this would be done using the Control Octave from an external MIDI keyboard. The 'Stop' and 'Bar 1' options within the Control Octave provide further possibilities. The 'Bar 1' switch forces any of the longer patterns (some run to four bars) to play only bar 1, while holding down the 'A' key stops the auto bass line until another key outside the Control Octave triggers it again. Usefully, while holding down the 'Stop' key, you can play your own bass line (similar to working in Manual mode). The modulation wheel on a MIDI keyboard also provides access to this basic 'manual' mode; pushing the mod wheel towards the top of its travel stops the auto playback and allows you to play the plug-in as a normal bass instrument. Additionally, with the mod wheel set between 10 and 90 percent of its travel, the pattern engine will just play repeated notes (usually the root note of the current chord) and this can be very useful for linking between chords or over rapid chord changes. Bringing the mod wheel back down to below 10 percent of its travel restarts Auto mode. Other useful Auto mode features include the Latch option. With this on, a pattern can be triggered by hitting a chord and, even if that chord is released, the pattern will continue until the next chord is played. The Speed button allows patterns to be played in half-time or double time, while the Shuffle knob can be used to add swing to a straight bass riff (turn the knob clockwise) or to straighten out a bass line that is already swinging (turn the knob anticlockwise). Just as Groove Agent can output its rhythms over MIDI, Auto mode in Broomstick Bass includes the ability to output the bass lines created as a MIDI track. I've always found this
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Bornemark%20Broomstick%20Bass.htm (4 of 8)9/27/2005 9:22:11 PM
Bornemark Broomstick Bass
really useful in Groove Agent, as it allows you to fine-tune the autogenerated parts by, for example, groove quantising. This MIDI output process is well explained in the manual and worked a treat in Cubase SX. The MIDI output function allows the autoThe whole operation of the Auto mode generated bass line to be recorded (the is very well thought-out and, once you lower track) from a sequence of chords (the have a basic chord progression for upper track). This worked flawlessly in your song, creating a suitable bass line Cubase SX. is a breeze — even if you do then decide to edit this further. At first glance, I was only really surprised by one feature of the Auto engine — the rather limited range of chord types that are supported. Essentially, Broomstick Bass will play patterns based on only major, minor and 7th chords and, while a much fuller range of chord types are recognised by the software, they are essentially truncated to one of these three basic types. Even using this fairly narrow chord palette (which, incidentally, is the same as Virtual Guitarist Electric Edition with the exception of sus2), Broomstick Bass is capable of producing solid, credible bass lines. Aside from real jazz aficionados, most users are unlikely to find this a significant restriction.
Manual Control While Auto mode might be the main selling point of Broomstick Bass, the Manual mode is also well featured. In this mode, Broomstick Bass operates as a normal sample-based virtual instrument and, as well as velocity-sensitive sample layers, each of the instruments also contains articulation layers, accessed via the Control Octave. As well as the 'normal' sustained notes, Staccato, Slide Up, Hammer On/Off, Slide Down and Legato articulations are provided. For the acoustic and electric basses, further options of Fret Noise, Ghost Note (a heavily damped note where the pitch is unclear) and Smack sounds can also be added for additional realism. While this type of 'key-switching' system can add great flexibility to a performance, it does require considerable practice to make it work effectively. When playing the same note in quick succession (for example, a simple bass line playing eighth notes on the root of the chord) 'machine-gun' effects can often befall sample-based sounds, as it soon becomes obvious that the same sample is being played repeatedly. Broomstick Bass avoids this problem as the playback engine detects repeated notes. For normal notes, re-pitched adjacent samples will be thrown in to add variety, while for Staccato playing, a random selection of four samples for each note are used. This end result does sound very natural, with enough subtle variation to fool the ears.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Bornemark%20Broomstick%20Bass.htm (5 of 8)9/27/2005 9:22:11 PM
Bornemark Broomstick Bass
Big Bottom So much for the technical details — what do the various instruments sound like? The simple answer is very good indeed. With the exception of the broomstick bass itself (for which I'm not sure I could find a genuine musical application!), all the instruments are eminently usable and appear to have been well recorded and edited. The recording methods obviously varied; while some have been recorded via a mic/amp combination, others seem to have been recorded direct. The manual includes an interesting section that details some of the methods used. For a number of the instruments, several different versions are provided. For example, four versions of the double bass are included, providing fingered and bowed sounds, both with or without vibrato. This variety is useful but also necessary as, despite some relatively minor sound-shaping possibilities described below, there is little that can be done to edit the sounds themselves. That point accepted, there are some absolute gems here. For example, if you want solid and reliable electric The Edit screen provides access to both bass, the Fender Precision and Fender effects and some general settings as well. Jazz basses are pretty much spot on. In contrast, for something a little more aggressive, the Gibson Thunderbird and Rickenbacker 4001 deliver the goods, as both of these have been recorded via an amp. I also liked the very solid sound of the Chapman Stick, while the 'slapped' version of the Music Man Sabre has plenty of character. Of the keyboard and pedal instruments, perhaps my favourite was the wonderful Hammond B3 bass pedals — instant 'Green Onions'. Given how 'playable' the articulations make these instruments, the Broomstick Bass sample set is probably worth the price of entry on its own. The Edit screen provides access to various bass-orientated effects which are both simple and effective in operation. The EQ section permits a reasonable level of tonal control if some minor fine-tuning is required to make the bass sit within a mix. The compressor and overdrive work well enough but don't overcook things, while the chorus sounds really nice and can easily add a little movement and character to any of the sounds. The pitch-shifter, while working well enough with the keyboard-based instruments, did not produce very usable results with the acoustic and electric basses. All these controls can be automated and the MIDI controller numbers are listed in the manual. The Edit screen also includes various settings that control how Broomstick Bass operates. For example, the MIDI Output function can be enabled here. Depending upon the size of your master keyboard, the other useful option provided is the ability to move the position of the Control Octave to any one of four positions. file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Bornemark%20Broomstick%20Bass.htm (6 of 8)9/27/2005 9:22:11 PM
Bornemark Broomstick Bass
Style File There are several dozen individual styles included with Broomstick Bass. These are grouped into a number of broad musical types including jazz, rockabilly, boogie, blues, pop, rock, prog rock, reggae, funk, dance, and fusion. There are also a few stranger headings, such as 'Classic Synth' and 'Odd Meters', and a group named 'Streets Of....' which includes a small selection of bass styles from around the world (eg. Rio, Dublin, Dakar). The blues and rock styles are pretty safe and solid but right on the money, while the funk styles contain some excellent material with plenty of slapping. The classic synth and dance groups include great '70s and '80s moods, particularly the Disco styles. While there is plenty of choice, I wonder whether Bornemark might add some more styles aimed at hip-hop, R&B and other modern styles. These could, of course, be easy targets for future 'Gift Pack' downloads.
Verdict In Broomstick Bass, Bornemark have delivered the kind of characteristics that most band members would think of as ideal in a real bass player; it is solid and dependable, plays in time with the drummer, always uses an appropriate bass sound and is happy to turn down (or off) when asked. I didn't experience a single glitch during the whole of the review period, and this gives plenty of confidence in the programming work done. The user interface is very straightforward, and the large range of styles and the quality of the sounds are commendable. As with any auto-accompaniment function, what you can't really expect is virtuoso playing that, all of a sudden, is going to spring a musical surprise. In Auto mode, what Broomstick Bass does provide is a solid and reliable bass line. If more colour is required, then Manual mode includes enough creative possibilities to get the job done. While I'm sure I will still be turning to my Fender Jazz for many of my own needs, I'm also sure there will be times when Broomstick Bass will do the job just as well and with a minimum of fuss. By the time you read this, Steinberg's Virtual Bassist may also be available and it will be very interesting to see exactly how Virtual Bassist and Broomstick Bass compare — look out for a review of the former in a forthcoming SOS. However, if you are keen to get a virtual bass player on board as soon as possible, then Broomstick Bass is a pleasure to use and comes highly recommended. A 15MB downloadable demo is available from the Bornemark web site for those that wish to try before they buy. Published in SOS May 2005
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Bornemark%20Broomstick%20Bass.htm (7 of 8)9/27/2005 9:22:11 PM
Bornemark Broomstick Bass
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Bornemark%20Broomstick%20Bass.htm (8 of 8)9/27/2005 9:22:11 PM
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss
In this article:
Duo Auto Dehiss Setting Up Action Stations Duo Auto Declickle Performance
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss Broad-band Noise-reduction Processor Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Processor
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss £4113 pros Fast, accurate automatic configuration, with flexible finetuning facilities Options to process channels separately or in Middle & Sides format. Phenomenally effective noise-reduction algorithm. No audible side effects if used sympathetically.
This slimline new rack processor makes CEDAR's latest class-leading audio-restoration algorithms remarkably quick and easy to use. Hugh Robjohns
For anyone involved in the specialised crafts of audio restoration and 'forensic audio', CEDAR Audio will be a familiar name. This Cambridge-based company cons have long been the standard bearer for the kind of highly specialised digital This degree of signal-processing tools required in these professions. In recent years, the sophistication doesn't come advances in computer processor speeds and general DSP functionality have cheap. enabled many manufacturers to develop their own audio-restoration programs, summary and many are very cost effective, but to date no-one has quite managed to match The CEDAR Audio Duo Auto the class-leading functionality and quality of the highly evolved CEDAR Dehiss represents another step forward in the technology algorithms. of hiss-removal tools. Both the hardware and the algorithm have benefited from updating, enabling this new unit to offer even more impressive performance controlled through a remarkably simple but flexible user interface.
information £4112.50 including VAT. CEDAR Audio +44 (0) 1223 881771. +44 (0)1223 881778. Click here to email
Most of CEDAR's restoration tools are available on a variety of software and hardware platforms. The company's flagship software platform is called the CEDAR Cambridge, a PC-based system which can be equipped with a wide range of the latest signal-processing 'modules' to suit a variety of restoration and forensic applications. Many of the same core modules are also available as plugins for DAW platforms including AMS Neve workstations, Merging Technologies Pyramix, Studio Audio & Video SADiE, and Sydec Soundscape. However, this review is of CEDAR's latest generation of hardware, the new Duo series, which effectively supersedes some of the previous Series X rackmount units.
www.cedaraudio.com Photos: Mike Cameron
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/CEDAR%20Audio%20Duo%20Auto%20Dehiss.htm (1 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:15 PM
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss
Duo Auto Dehiss The Series X Dehisser was called the DHX (reviewed in SOS July 2000). It boasted a 50 megaflops DSP engine, with all-digital I/O and three simple rotary controls to adjust the critical dehiss algorithm parameters (level, variance and attenuation). By comparison, the new Duo Auto Dehiss reflects the advancing technology of the last five years very clearly, both in terms of its looks and its specifications. The first impression when unpacking the unit is that the steel case has a very similar design to that of its forebear, with three horizontal engraved lines running across the full width of the matt-black front panel and highlighted with a subtle gloss-black CEDAR logo. The case extends a modest 200mm behind the rack ears according to my ruler (although the handbook claims 240mm), but the new model is almost twice as heavy as the older DHX, tipping the scales at 4kg. As on the DHX, the rear panel carries only a few connectors: a pair of XLRs for stereo AES digits in and out, a pair of phono sockets for S/PDIF in and out, and a trio of MIDI sockets (In, Out, and Thru) for remote control. One new addition is a USB socket (apparently for factory use only), and the IEC mains inlet feeds an internal universal mains power supply accepting voltages from 85V to 260V at 50Hz or 60Hz. Whereas the DHX could only operate at sample rates of 44.1kHz or 48kHz, the Duo accepts any sample rate between 32kHz and 96kHz. The I/O supports 24-bit word lengths (although the internal resolution is 32-bit), and the available DSP power is an impressive eight times greater than on the DHX — a pair of Sharc DSPs providing 400 megaflops of signal-processing power. The front panel also reflects half a decade of technological advances. For a start, the old-fashioned green power LED of the Series-X models has been upgraded to the new millennium's omnipresent blue indicator. In fact, there are two blue LEDs at the right-hand end of the front panel: one marked Power, and the other Standby. As on the DHX, there is no mains isolation switch — the unit is permanently powered as long as it is plugged in — but a front-panel rocker switch enables a power-saving standby mode. Another sign of the times is that, while the operating power consumption of the Duo is the same as that of the DHX at 15W, the standby mode curtails the power consumption to just 1W instead of the 10W of the older DHX. Possibly a slightly less welcome change for the Duo is the replacement of the DHX's three simple physical controls with a blue (what else?) LCD menu screen, six soft keys, and a rotary encoder. The screen is very clear and the menu operation simple and intuitive, thanks in part to the bright/dim illumination of the backlit blue buttons to indicate which functions are available and which are not.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/CEDAR%20Audio%20Duo%20Auto%20Dehiss.htm (2 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:15 PM
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss
Setting Up After you switch the unit on, the LCD screen shows the CEDAR logo and the product serial number for a couple of seconds while the software boots up. After this, the main operating menu is displayed, with the three principal user parameters on the left-hand side, and mode and menu options on the right. The middle right soft key accesses the Menu mode, providing six new options labelled Setup, Audio I/O, Process Mode, Memory, Close, and Status — and I suspect the functions of most of these will be self-evident. The Setup menu allows the screen contrast and MIDI channel number to be changed, as well as displaying the software version and hardware serial numbers. There is also a facility here to clear the user memories and restore the factory defaults. The Audio I/O menu enables the output word length to be selected (16, 18, 20, or 24 bits, with TPDF dithering) and the output gain to be adjusted over ±10dB. There is also a numerical signal-level display with a peak-hold function. Strangely, there is no means of selecting a specific input — the unit apparently selects whichever has a valid signal. So what happens if there is a valid signal on both? The handbook recommends against this to avoid an incorrect automatic selection being made! Both outputs are active at all times, and any status bits present on the active input are mirrored to the outputs. The Status menu indicates the input connection and clock lock status, along with the measured input sample rate and the current state of the two DSP chips (indicated as either OK or Error, the latter with numeric fault codes). The Memory menu provides access to the 99 user memories, with the usual Store, Recall, Rename, and Delete functions, while the final Process Mode menu allows the unit to be configured for manual or automatic operation, and to process stereo signals in either L-R (left-right) or M-S (Middle & Sides) formats. This menu is, however, mostly redundant as these configuration modes can be changed directly from the main operating screen.
Action Stations In the default automatic mode, the screen shows the settings of three adjustable parameters on the left, each accessed by pressing the adjacent soft key and then using the wheel encoder to change the value. I'll return to these user parameters in a moment. The right-hand side of the screen shows the processing mode at the top (L-R or M-S) with underlines to indicate which channel is being processed. Repeated pressing of the adjacent soft key cycles between left, right,
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/CEDAR%20Audio%20Duo%20Auto%20Dehiss.htm (3 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:15 PM
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss
and both (or Middle, Sides, and both), and holding the button down for three seconds changes the mode between L-R and M-S. The middle button always provides access to the configuration menus, as already described, while the bottom button provides a bypass function to switch the processing in and out to check its subjective effect. Holding this button down for three seconds will change the operating mode from automatic to manual, and vice versa. In automatic mode, the software itself identifies the hiss element of the signal and optimises the various program parameters accordingly. The screen displays three adjustable parameters, labelled Bias, LF Bias, and Atten. Normally, the last is the only control that requires setting, as this determines the amount by which the hiss is attenuated. This is a subjective decision and will vary with the material and the desired effect. The Bias and LF Bias controls allow the user to offset the program's automatic hiss detection. Setting a positive Bias effectively instructs the program that there is more hiss present than it has detected, and the output will therefore be processed more heavily. A lower Bias setting does the reverse, which helps to retain more ambience in the signal, although with a greater risk of noise artefacts slipping through. The LF Bias control does exactly the same, but only influences the system for frequencies below 5kHz — low and mid-range frequencies. This allows the hiss reduction to be tailored to suit the spectral character of the medium. An analogue tape, for example, where the hiss is most audible across the higher frequency range, might benefit from less low and mid-range hiss reduction, and the LF Bias control could be reduced accordingly. Adjusting either of the Bias controls normally requires the Atten setting to be tweaked as well, and there is an iterative process of optimising the bias settings and fine-tuning the attenuation to get the best results. However, the effect of each control is quite audible with a little experience, and in practice setting things up is reasonably quick. In manual mode, the menu screen looks much the same. The three right-hand buttons perform the same functions as before: channel selection, menu access, and bypass (with the same 'long press' options working as before). The three lefthand parameters initially look the same too. The Atten and LF Bias controls are exactly as before. However, in place of the Bias control the manual mode provides a Level control. This is used to instruct the software of the absolute level of hiss within the signal, and operates across the entire audio spectrum. In effect, this is the parameter which is set automatically in automatic mode. Clearly, this parameter is critical to the effective operation of the dehiss process, although finding the optimum position is actually quite intuitive. If set too high,
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/CEDAR%20Audio%20Duo%20Auto%20Dehiss.htm (4 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:15 PM
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss
low-level ambience is treated as noise and removed, resulting in an unnatural and muffled sound quality. If set too low, the device will not remove noise effectively at all, and you may start getting noise artefacts. Again, an interactive process is required to finetune the Level, LF Bias, and Atten parameters, but finding the optimal settings doesn't take long.
CEDAR's previous generation of 1U rackmount audio restoration tools were the Series X, reviewed back in SOS July 2000. The march of progress has been swift, though, and the Duo processors now provide eight times the processing horsepower of the Series X units, as well as a more flexible LCD-based control interface.
The facility to process the signal in M-S mode is very useful. In many cases the strong central component of stereo material may mask hiss quite effectively, while at the edges of the image the hiss may be more exposed and obvious. Processing in M-S mode allows the hiss reduction to be tailored accordingly across the stereo image. Likewise, in L-R mode if there is more noticeable hiss on one channel than the other, or if the two channels exhibit different 'colours' of noise, the program can be optimised accordingly.
Duo Auto Declickle The other unit in CEDAR's Duo range is the Auto Declickle, which gets its slightly odd name from the fact that it combines declicking and decrackling processes into a single 1U rack. Apparently, while developing the flagship Cambridge system, CEDAR's researchers found that combining the two processes gave better results. What makes Auto Declickle particularly clever is that it can detect the remains of the original audio signal behind the click or crackle, so it can repair the audio waveform much more sensitively than would a traditional interpolation process. Stay tuned for a review in SOS soon...
Performance The Duo Auto Dehiss is certainly an impressive tool, and the algorithmic improvements over the previous generation are obvious, both when setting it up and when listening to the processed output. This new version seems more assured of what to class as noise within a signal, and the distinct 'twittering' and 'glugging' artefacts incurred while adjusting the Level parameter of the Series X machine have been replaced with a more intuitive noise-pumping effect. No dehiss program will ever be able to remove every trace of noise perfectly file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/CEDAR%20Audio%20Duo%20Auto%20Dehiss.htm (5 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:15 PM
CEDAR Audio Duo Auto Dehiss
while leaving low-level ambience and reverb tails completely intact, but the Duo Auto Dehiss comes very close to that ideal in a fuss-free way. I used the machine to clean up a selection of classic jazz recordings on quarter-inch tape, some dating back nearly forty years. The results were very good indeed, and optimising the settings was always intuitive — although it certainly pays to fine-tune the Bias, LF Bias, and Level controls in a reiterative loop a couple of times, because adjusting one seems to have knock-on effects for the others. The more care and attention paid during setting up, the better the end results, as you might expect. While a lot of the material was mono, I found the M-S mode very useful with some of the stereo tapes, and the ability to bypass the hiss removal processing made it easy to assess the effect on reverb and ambience, as well as making it easier to recognise any low-level artefacts. I suspect longer familiarity with the product would result in very effective 'ear-training' which would allow the optimal settings to be found even more quickly. Like all CEDAR products, the new Duo Auto Dehiss is relatively costly — this kind of R&D is expensive to fund — but it provides a real-time solution to the problem of unwanted hiss. The automatic mode seems to optimise the settings very well, and there are no audible artefacts from the processing if you use it sympathetically. Overall, a very worthwhile improvement over its predecessor. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/CEDAR%20Audio%20Duo%20Auto%20Dehiss.htm (6 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:15 PM
Edirol UA101
In this article:
In The Blue Corner Edirol UA101 Brief Specifications Installation Control Panel Testing Testing Final Thoughts
Edirol UA101 USB 2 Audio Interface (PC) Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Computer Recording System
Edirol UA101 £399 pros Good audio quality in a compact and rugged package. Versatile monitor mixing options. Stereo and multi-channel WDM drivers provided. Built-in analogue limiter.
Edirol have pioneered USB 2.0 as a format for connecting audio interfaces, and their latest unit offers 10 inputs and outputs at a price that compares well with Firewire alternatives. Martin Walker
cons No GSIF driver support. Rear-panel DIP switches for phantom power and +4/10 input switching are fiddly to operate.
summary The UA101 finally provides a cheaper alternative to the UA1000 for anyone who would prefer their audio interface to plug into a USB 2.0 rather than a Firewire port, and its analogue limiter may sway those who don't mind either way.
information £399 including VAT. Edirol Europe +44 (0)20 8747 5949. +44 (0)20 8747 5948. Click here to email www.edirol.co.uk
Test Spec Edirol UA101 Windows XP driver version 1.0.
In 2003, Edirol launched the world's first USB 2.0 audio interface, the UA1000 (reviewed in SOS November 2003: www.soundonsound.com/sos/ nov03/articles/edirolua1000.htm). Since then, however, few USB 2specific music products have been Photos: Mike Cameron forthcoming — largely, I suspect, because USB 2 products can't as yet be used by Mac owners. Firewire audio interfaces, on the other hand, can be used by both PC and Mac owners, so when Edirol subsequently launched their Firewire-based FA101, many people assumed that the UA1000 was a one-off experiment. The UA101 proves them wrong. As its name suggests, it's similar in many ways to the FA101 (reviewed in SOS September 2004: www.soundonsound.com/sos/ sep04/articles/edirolfa101.htm), except that it connects via USB 2.0 rather than Firewire. It's presented in the same half-rack format, and at a similar £399 price. Both devices offer 10 inputs and 10 outputs: of the eight analogue inputs, six operate at line level only, whilst two also boast mic preamps, and one of these can serve as a high-impedance instrument input. There are also eight analogue output channels with a versatile analogue monitoring system, plus S/PDIF optical in/out and MIDI In and Out. Like the FA101, the UA101 supports audio formats up to 24-bit/192kHz, albeit with a reduced number of channels at the highest sample rates.
Intel Pentium 4C 2.8GHz
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Edirol%20UA101.htm (1 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:20 PM
Edirol UA101
processor with Hyperthreading, Asus P4P800 Deluxe motherboard with Intel 865PE chip set running 800MHz front side buss, 1GB DDR400 RAM, running Windows XP with Service Pack 2. Tested with Cakewalk Sonar 4.0, NI Pro 53, Rightmark Audio Analyser 5.4, Steinberg Cubase SX 3.0 and Wavelab 5.00a, Tascam Gigastudio 160 v3.04.
You'd be forgiven for assuming that the FA101 and UA101 were otherwise identical, barring a different colour scheme and the replacement of the pair of rear-panel Firewire sockets by a single USB 2.0 port. However, closer inspection shows that there are plenty of other differences between the two, the most intriguing being a front-panel button labelled Limiter.
In The Blue Corner The two front-panel Neutrik inputs of the UA101 are fed to a pair of 'professional grade' mic preamps identical to those of the FA101, with up to 40dB gain controlled via rotary sensitivity knobs, and optional +48 Volt phantom power. As with the FA101, the button to switch this is on the rear panel — fine for mobile and desktop use, but not very handy if you've bolted the unit into a rack. There's the same optional high-impedance button for input 2 allowing you to use the inner TRS jack socket to plug in an electric guitar. There are also six line-level inputs on the rear panel with balanced/ unbalanced connections on quarterinch jack sockets, but whereas the FA101 offered adjustable sensitivity Each pair of the UA101's inputs can be between -10dBV and +4dBu only on switched between -10 and +4 sensitivity inputs 7/8, here, each pair of line settings using a DIP switch on the rear panel. inputs can be switched between 10dBV and +4dBu operation via tiny rear-panel DIP switches. This is not a job you'd want to do very often in the dark, but is certainly a more versatile approach in the absence of software-switched options. A further DIP switch lets you switch between USB 1.1 and USB 2.0 formats, so you can connect the UA101 to almost any USB-equipped computer, although of course you won't be able to use the full quotient of I/O over USB 1. The rest of the rear panel is straightforward, with 10 TRS-wired output sockets instead of the FA101's eight (the extra two are dedicated stereo Monitor Outs, hard-wired to the monitor mixer outputs along with the headphone output), plus MIDI input and output sockets, a USB connector, and the input for the supplied DC power supply. The left-hand end of the front panel is completed by the aforementioned Limiter switch, which places a limiter with a -4dBFS threshold in the signal path on inputs 1 and 2, plus the Toslink optical input and output sockets. The five-LED meter is another improvement on the four LEDs of the FA101, and can display the peak levels of any input or output. The five LEDs come on at -42, -30, -18, -12 and -6 dBFS, so they provide a useful graph from signal present through to imminent clipping. The black area at the right-hand end of the panel is devoted to digital and monitoring options, looking almost identical to the same area of the FA101, and
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Edirol%20UA101.htm (2 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:20 PM
Edirol UA101
comprises sample-rate selection, Digital In and associated Sync LED for internal/ external clock selection, two buttons and one rotary control for monitoring, which I'll come to in a minute, the rotary level control for the dedicated monitor and phones outputs, the phones socket itself, and power and 'USB active' indicators.
Edirol UA101 Brief Specifications Sample rates: 44.1, 48, 88.2, 96 and 192 kHz from internal clock. Analogue inputs 1/2: Neutrik with outer balanced mic socket, optional global +48V phantom power and analogue limiting, inner TRS quarter-inch jack, high-impedance guitar input option on input 2, plus preamp with 40dB gain range. Analogue inputs 3 to 8: +4/-10 switched line-level sensitivity on quarter-inch TRS balanced/unbalanced jack sockets. Analogue outputs: 10 balanced/unbalanced TRS quarter-inch jack at fixed +4dBu level (two of which carry the dedicated stereo Monitor Mixer outputs), plus stereo headphone output with dedicated level control. Digital I/O: S/PDIF in and out on Toslink optical, two MIDI Ins and Outs. Dynamic range: not stated. Frequency response: 20Hz to 40kHz, +0/-2dB at 96kHz.
Installation I received the final version of the hardware and Windows XP drivers, but a preliminary Control Panel utility and no printed or PDF manual, so this was an ideal opportunity to see just how easy the UA101 was to use. The driver CDROM contained a Setup.exe file, so in keeping with most other USB and Firewire audio interfaces, I ran this before I plugged in the interface, and was pleased to find it provided on-screen instructions on the installation procedure, including when to plug in and power up the UA101 — not everyone reads the manual after all, even when it's supplied! The UA101 can't be powered from the USB buss, so you need to plug in the bundled 9 Volt DC line-lump PSU and switch on the UA101 via the switch associated with the Phones/Monitor output rotary level control before it's detected by Windows. For those interested in mobile recording who have both USB 2.0 and Firewire ports available, this gives the FA101 an advantage over the UA101, since it can be powered from the Firewire buss if your computer is capable of doing so. Like its USB 2.0 stablemate the UA1000, the UA101's drivers only currently support Windows XP, but this is after all what most PC musicians are now using, and I was up and running within a couple of minutes. I was pleased to see that Edirol are bucking the trend by offering multiple stereo WDM drivers in addition to a single multi-channel one, which is very handy for those whose applications only support stereo pairs. The UA101 offers five stereo pairs of driver playback file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Edirol%20UA101.htm (3 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:20 PM
Edirol UA101
options (1/2, 3/4, 5/6, 7/8 and 9/10 digital) in addition to the multi-channnel one, while the recording options add to this list the Monitor output from the UA101's 40-bit internal mixer. However, I was disappointed that Edirol still seem to be ignoring Gigastudio owners, and there's no GSIF driver support at all.
Control Panel I experienced a strong dose of déjà vu when I located the Edirol UA101 software utility among my Windows Control Panel options and launched it: it was identical to the one I last saw when reviewing the UA1000, even down to still having 'Edirol UA1000 Control Panel' displayed in its title bar. The UA101 will ship with a control panel that looks rather more elegant, but its patchbay and monitor mixer functions remain fairly similar, so let's remind ourselves briefly of what's on offer. In essence, you get a patchbay that lets you decide which signals get sent to the five pairs of WAV inputs that appear as recording options in your audio application, chosen from the five pairs of physical input signals, the five pairs of WAV playback signals coming from your audio application, or the combined output of the control panel's monitor mixer. The five pairs of A helpful routing diagram is printed on the physical outputs have similar options: UA101's top panel. the five pairs of WAV playback signals, the five input pairs, or the monitor mixer output. In addition, a second set of output routings is available, and can be selected using the front-panel Soft Ctrl button, so you can set up two different monitoring presets. The main control panel display is devoted to the monitor mixer, with on/off, solo, pan, fader and link controls for each of the Wave Outs and physical inputs, plus a signal 'blinky' for each of these channels and a pair of monitor master level controls. Across the bottom there's a status display of various parameters including current sample rate, internal/external clock, and the direct-monitor Mono and Soft Ctrl buttons. The hardware front panel has the same unusual Mix control as the FA101, with a centre detent marking the default mix, and clockwise movements favouring the Input monitor mix, and anti-clockwise moves the Output monitor mix. There's also a front-panel Mono button that affects the input monitor mix. Overall, the monitoring facilities are comprehensive once you get your head round them.
Testing Testing
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Edirol%20UA101.htm (4 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:20 PM
Edirol UA101
My double-blind listening tests against Emu's 1820M and Echo's Mia proved interesting. Once again I picked out the Emu for its superior imaging and ability to present greater front-to-back positioning during reverb tails, but I couldn't decide which I preferred of the other two. The Mia was warmer and 'cosier', whereas the UA101 gave a slightly more intimate sound, possibly because as I found later it exhibits a slightly boosted playback response above 6kHz, rising to a tiny peak of +0.3dB at 20kHz with a 44.1kHz sample rate. However, these are very subtle differences, and given its similarities with the FA101, I'd agree with the judgements Mike Bryant made in his review of that unit: it has a clean, open sound and good stereo imaging. While recording, the limiter option on inputs 1/2 proved extremely useful in avoiding clipping, and let me achieve significantly higher input levels in a transparent way without worrying about compromising audio quality — only by applying input levels high enough to clip the analogue stages preceding the limiters did I start to experience any distortion. Rightmark's Audio Analyser proved that the UA101 must have almost identical analogue circuitry to the FA101, returning exactly the same dynamic range of 104dBA at 24bit/44.1kHz. Unusually, this stayed almost the same at both 96kHz and 192kHz, even though its frequency response was not capped at the higher The review unit was supplied with a rates (the most common reason for preliminary Control Panel utility: the finished this). The -0.3dB points were at an version will look like this. impressive 8Hz and 21kHz with a 44.1kHz sample rate, extending to about 44kHz with a sample rate of 96kHz, and 57kHz at 192kHz. Like both the UA1000 and FA101, the UA101's sample rate can only be changed from the front-panel switch, and the unit must be rebooted before this takes effect. However, whereas the on/off switch for the FA101 is on the rear panel, making it inaccessible if the unit is bolted into a rack, both UA units have the practical advantage of front-panel on/off switches. The control panel utility provides a handy readout of the unit's current sample rate, but it's up to users to make sure that this is the same as the one set in their audio application — I received no error messages when attempting to play back or record files through the UA101 at one rate when it was set to another, but my RMAA results displayed peculiar frequency responses when I did so. As with the FA101, switching to 24-bit/192kHz reduces the I/O count from 10 channels to six, which is sufficient to play back DVD-Audio discs in 5.1 surround, while anyone who needs to plug into a low-bandwidth USB 1.1 port instead of a Hi-Speed USB 2.0 one will find themselves reduced to using analogue inputs and outputs 1/2 at 44.1 or 48 kHz only.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Edirol%20UA101.htm (5 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:20 PM
Edirol UA101
The slider to adjust the buffer size of the ASIO drivers is simply labelled from Min to Max, rather than stating number of samples or latency in milliseconds, but the default setting equates to an unusual value of 432 samples, resulting in 10ms latency at 44.1kHz. I experienced no glitching with Cubase SX at this setting, and was eventually able to drop the value down to the lowest setting on my system with no problems, giving a 3.3ms latency. The WDM drivers managed an even better 2.0ms with Sonar 4, and the Direct Sound and MME drivers proved to be as good as any I've tried under Windows XP, achieving 30ms and 45ms Play Ahead settings respectively with NI's Pro 53 soft synth.
Final Thoughts Edirol have placed the UA101 into an already congested part of the market, and at a price of around £400 you can also buy various Firewire audio interfaces such as M Audio's Firewire 1814 and Guillemot's Hercules 1612FW. The Firewire 1814 provides the most potential I/O with its eight-in/four-out analogue plus eightchannel ADAT support, and the highest dynamic range at a measured 109dBA. It can be buss-powered, but its analogue inputs aren't balanced, and its outputs don't offer the higher +4dBu levels compatible with more professional gear. For those with more demanding recording requirements, the Hercules 1612FW is another strong contender with its 12-in/eight-out analogue plus co-axial and optical S/PDIF, word clock, and two MIDI Ins and Outs. It has very similar audio performance to the FA/UA101 boxes, but it doesn't support 192kHz at all. Both the 1814 and 1612FW also provide GSIF drivers, though, unlike the Edirol range. However, the UA101's closest competitor is probably its own stablemate, the FA101. If you don't have a Firewire port then you can buy one on a card fairly cheaply, but nearly all modern PCs are already equipped with USB 2.0 ports, so which is the best option? Well, a USB 2 interface might have the advantage where high track counts are required from a Firewire hard drive, since it won't be sharing the same bandwidth. On the other hand, some armchair experts say USB 2 is unsuitable for professional audio, but I've now reviewed both the UA1000 and the UA101, the only available multi-channel USB 2 interfaces, and have had no practical problems with either. Since its launch, moreover, the UA1000 has gone on to win an enviable reputation for its reliability. The strengths of both the UA101 and FA101 are their robust and compact halfrack cases, which make them the smallest of all these units, while their almost identical eight-in/eight-out analogue audio quality is on a par with the Hercules and only slightly behind the Firewire 1814. In its favour, the FA101 can be busspowered, which is handy for mobile recording sessions, but the UA101 provides an additional stereo monitoring output, more flexible -10/+4 input options, and slightly better metering. Its most significant advantage, however, is the stereo limiter — the only other interface I can recall with this feature was the ill-fated Lexicon Core 2, but it remains a powerful incentive for anyone wanting to record anything cleanly when faced with unpredictable levels. For small live sessions, file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Edirol%20UA101.htm (6 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:20 PM
Edirol UA101
this is a big advantage, and should push the UA101 a long way up your shortlist.
Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Edirol%20UA101.htm (7 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:20 PM
Fervent Software Studio To Go
In this article:
On The Go System Requirements Trying It Out ALSA Dancing
Fervent Software Studio To Go £50
Fervent Software Studio To Go Bootable Linux Software Suite for PC Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
pros Easy introduction to Linux audio and music tools. Hardly any configuration or Linux skills required. Cost-effective compared to time spent getting a DIY Linux music system working. Official technical support, rather than community support.
cons
If you're attracted by the idea of Linux and opensource music software, but put off by the thought of installing it on your PC, there's another way: a bootable CD-ROM containing both the OS and all the software you need, ready to go. Daniel James
Only as good as the hardware of the PC you run it on. The suitability of any given PC for real-time audio can be unpredictable. Loading from CD-ROM can be slow on older machines. No support for some audio hardware, including all MOTU and Firewire interfaces.
It's certainly possible to produce and record music on a Linux system, but setting up the machine could be a challenge for many people without experience of the platform. With nearly all of the source code available on various Internet sites, the DIY route is feasible if you have the time to figure out how the pieces fit together. While that's undoubtedly the best way to summary learn about the technology, it could A lot of software for under present a frustrating learning curve for £50, and far more complete than any proprietary bundle. If those musicians who just want to get going. you're interested in using Linux for music but fear the amount of new skills required, this could be the product for you.
On the Studio To Go desktop, Sweep plays a stereo track into the Jamin mastering tool via JACK.
One way of hiding the unfamiliarity of novel software is to put it inside devices that resemble traditional equipment — the Hartmann Neuron resynthesizing keyboard and the Muse Receptor information rackmount VSTi host are both in this class, with Linux systems running inside. £49.99 including VAT. Another approach is to do what Apple have done with OS X: select a particular Fervent Software +44 (0) combination of open-source software, add some user-friendly components on top 7905 932630. and market the result as a single product, along with technical support services. Click here to emailClick here to email www.ferventsoftware. com
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Fervent%20Software%20Studio%20To%20Go.htm (1 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:25 PM
Fervent Software Studio To Go
On The Go
Test Spec Custom audio PC with AMD Opteron 240 and 1GB RAM, with M Audio Audiophile PCI card. Dell Optiplex GX270, P4 2.6GHz, 512MB RAM, Intel onboard sound chip set. Acer Aspire, Athlon XP 2000 +, 256MB RAM, VIA onboard sound chip set.
Fervent Software have done something similar to Apple with Studio To Go, which takes the form of a single, bootable CD-ROM. Linux is available in native versions for just about all processors, including the IBM chips found in the Apple G5 machines, but since most people have PCs, Studio To Go was compiled for the Intel 32-bit architecture, which includes the Pentiums and the Athlons. Because Linux-based systems are licensed in a very different way to proprietary software products, it's quite legitimate to use the same software on any number of machines you have access to. The principle behind these 'live' Linux distributions aimed at musicians — and there are now at least half a dozen available — is that you can have all your music-making tools in one portable package, without needing to carry a laptop around. These distributions load the Linux software into the available RAM and won't touch any software or data already present on the hard disk, unless you want them to. A USB memory stick is a popular complement to live distributions, as it allows you to take personal data and settings around with you. The bootable format has both advantages and disadvantages. On the plus side, the software isn't tied down to any particular machine and there's little risk of damaging the system other than by breaking the CD-ROM itself. On the other hand, loading software from CD-ROM is slower and noisier than loading it from hard disk, and will become tedious if the PC isn't a recent one with plenty of RAM. Most live distributions offer the possibility of a permanent install to hard disk if you're happy to wipe the system or data that's on there already. Fervent Software are the first company to produce a live Linux distribution for musicians in a retail package with a technical help service: buyers of the boxed set can register for 30 days' support by email and in customer forums. The company intend to market this product to both home-studio users and the education sector, the idea being that students will be able to have access to a full suite of music tools which they can take home and use without the fear of a raid from the software police. To this end, Fervent Software intend to offer volume pricing deals to educational institutions.
System Requirements A PC compatible with 32-bit Intel software. 800MHz Pentium minimum; 1.2GHz or faster recommended. 256MB minimum RAM; 512MB or more recommended. Any sound/MIDI chip set with ALSA driver available. CD-ROM drive, the faster the better. 2GB or more hard disk space for optional hard disk install.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Fervent%20Software%20Studio%20To%20Go.htm (2 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:25 PM
Fervent Software Studio To Go
Trying It Out I tried Studio To Go with a 64MB memory stick on generic Dell and Acer PCs, and my own Opteron-based workstation, which was built specifically to run Linux audio software. First, you have to make sure the PC is booting from CD rather than hard disk. Once that's taken care of, there's a whir from the CD-ROM drive and a boot prompt appears. At this stage you can press the Enter key for default settings, or choose from several boot options if automatic configuration has failed on a previous attempt. Assuming everything works on your particular PC, you then see a loading screen followed by the KDE desktop, which should feel familiar to anyone coming from a Windows or Mac background. The Dell machine threw up an immediate problem: the screen resolution was a pitiful 640 x 480 instead of the 1280 x 1024 I would have expected. The autoconfiguration of the display had not worked properly, and a Google search demonstrated that this was a known problem on this specific model — the amount of video memory allocated by the BIOS was only 1MB. Linux can sometimes highlight cases where hardware is buggy, and PC manufacturers bodge a machine to get it working with Windows XP and out of the door as quickly as possible. A flash update with a newer BIOS, available on demand from Dell technical support, is the proper solution in this case. Other than the resolution problem, the Dell machine worked smoothly, with program launching reasonably responsive and the JACK sound server distributing audio between applications without buffer glitches, or xruns as JACK calls them. The same couldn't be said of the bargain-basement Acer PC, which required an increase in the number of periods per buffer to process audio properly, and suffered from serious delays when launching applications. This isn't really the fault of Studio To Go, since there are a lot of PCs out there which just aren't up to the task of working with real-time audio, and JACK, by design, is extremely unforgiving of inadequate machines. The lack of performance on the Acer PC could have been due to low-quality hardware, or perhaps daft interrupt assignment. Disabling ACPI in the BIOS was suggested by Fervent Software as a possible fix; poor implementations of this standard also cause problems with Windows XP on certain PCs.
ALSA Dancing Drivers from the ALSA project are included in a single package, so Studio To Go either will support your sound hardware or it won't — since a live distribution is run from a read-only disc, you can't download drivers to it. To sum up the current status of ALSA driver support: PCI cards and motherboard chip sets tend to work, some PCMCIA interfaces have drivers, USB devices work if they are standards-compliant, and Firewire devices can be assumed not to work. This is not due to a lack of Firewire support under Linux, but because audio interface manufacturers hardly ever stick to the proper Firewire specification, and they file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Fervent%20Software%20Studio%20To%20Go.htm (3 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:25 PM
Fervent Software Studio To Go
won't release the details of their non-standard protocols. This is a particular problem with Mark of the Unicorn equipment, and as a result hardly any MOTU interfaces are supported under Linux. It's something to consider when choosing an interface, as a closed design means you will always be dependent on the manufacturer for continued driver support, regardless of whether you use Linux, Windows or OS X. The converse of this problem is that some sound hardware is supported by ALSA even though it has been discontinued and does not have Windows XP drivers available — an example would be the Midiman DMAN PCI card.
Studio To Go provides access to disk partitions on the host system, as well as a memory stick if you have one.
On my Opteron machine, which has a Matrox dual-head video card, the display was configured perfectly on the first boot without any tweaking required. The M Audio Audiophile PCI card was correctly detected and configured, with JACK starting automatically at a conservative buffer size. A row of icons on the left side of the desktop provided access to disks on the host machine and the USB memory stick, while folders contained tutorials, example files and sample VSTi plug-ins in PC format. Although VST Instruments and effects are rarely open-source or written specifically for Linux, they can be run on Linux systems as long as the binary format matches that of the host CPU. Fervent Software also support the Rosegarden project, so it's no suprise that this MIDI + Audio sequencer, with classical notation support, is at the core of Studio To Go. Audio recording and editing programs include Ardour, Audacity, Sweep and Rezound, providing a choice of both destructive and non-destructive, diskbased and RAM-based editing. A collection of soft synths, including the Hydrogen drum machine and native DSSI plug-in instruments, means that there is plenty of software to make music with, and VSTis can also be loaded from the host machine's hard disk. Utilities such as software mixers for sound interfaces are included, and there is also a collection of general-purpose tools including Konqueror, KDE's combined file manager and web browser. Ultimately, the portability advantages of Studio To Go will be constrained by the quality and Linux-compatibility of the PC hardware that you have access to. The price-to-storage ratio of USB memory sticks tends to make the combination of Studio To Go and one of these more suitable for MIDI work than lengthy multitrack audio sessions, and I suspect most people who want to use the software seriously will take the step of installing it permanently to a hard disk. However, running Studio To Go from the CD-ROM is a quick, easy and reasonably priced way of taking a look at Linux music software, or testing the suitability of your PC for running it. Published in SOS May 2005
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Fervent%20Software%20Studio%20To%20Go.htm (4 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:25 PM
Fervent Software Studio To Go
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Fervent%20Software%20Studio%20To%20Go.htm (5 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:25 PM
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312
In this article:
LSR6328 Active Monitor JBL Transducer Technologies LSR6312 Powered Subwoofer Room Mode Correction Listening Tests The Final Word
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312 £2680/£1545 pros Essentially neutral and detailed character. Powerful and dynamic. Solid construction and ease of portability. Matching optional subwoofer with bass management.
cons Room Mode Correction facility is limited in what it can achieve.
summary A powerful but competent active monitor capable of resolving a lot of detail over a wide bandwidth. It boasts a wide and stable listening area, with good imaging and excellent dynamics. The matching subwoofer extends the bandwidth downwards and the headroom upwards, while also providing simple bass-management facilities. The Room Mode Correction feature works as advertised and will be useful to many, but cannot replace proper acoustic treatment.
information LSR6328 active nearfield monitors, £2680 per pair; LSR6312 subwoofer, £1545 each. Prices include VAT.
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312 Active Monitors & Subwoofer Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Monitors
JBL's new monitors incorporate Room Mode Correction technology which claims to be able to reduce the bass problems caused by standing waves at the listening position. But does it really work in practice? Hugh Robjohns
Under review here are two members of JBL's new LSR6300 series of monitors: the LSR6328, a two-way midfield system, and the LSR6312 subwoofer. Completing the range are the compact two-way nearfield LSR6325, and the three-way LSR6332, either of which can also be used in concert with the aforementioned subwoofer. The LSR6328 is of a size I associate with midfield monitors, but JBL suggest a working range of one to three metres, the short end of this range conforming with nearfield conditions. Nevertheless, I'd recommend placing these monitors on tall stands behind the desk rather than on the meterbridge.
Photos: Mark Ewing
LSR6328 Active Monitor The LSR6328's two-way design has cabinet dimensions of 330 x 406 x 325mm (hwd) and weighs 18kg. It is constructed from 19mm MDF, finished in a darkgrey paint, and has convenient recessed lifting handles built into each side panel.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/JBL%20LSR6328%20&%20LSR6312.htm (1 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:30 PM
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312
Harman Pro UK +44 (0) 1707 668222. +44 (0)1707 668010. Click here to email
The integral amplifier's heat sink is on the rear panel, along with the connections, setup controls and a rear-facing Linear Dynamics Aperture (LDA) port. (For more information on LDA and other proprietary terms, take a look at the 'JBL Transducer Technologies' box elsewhere in this article.)
www.harmanprouk.com www.jblpro.com
The driver complement comprises an eight-inch bass unit with an unusually low 2 (omega) nominal impedance, and a 4(omega) one-inch titanium/composite tweeter mounted in an Elliptical Oblate Spheroidal (EOS) waveguide. An LED between the two drivers illuminates when the system is powered. The amplifier chassis is a two-channel Class-AB design with a 120W monolithic (chip) amplifier for the high-frequency driver and an all-discrete 250W circuit for the lowfrequency driver. The rear control panel is surprisingly complex at first sight, but the handbook provides clear setup instructions and a Room Mode Calibration Kit is supplied to help configure the system (see 'Room Mode Correction' box for more details). The audio input is hooked up via a combi jack/XLR connector with an associated and recessed input-level trim control. Mains is provided via the usual IEC socket with an adjacent power button. A set of eight DIP switches, three recessed rotary switches, a bypass button, and remote control socket complete the configuration facilities. Three of the DIP switches configure the input, enabling the input level trimmer or presetting the input level to +4dBu, +8dBu, or +12dBu sensitivity. The LSR6328's input trimmer is aligned at the factory such that a -10dBV input provides 96dBSPL at one metre (in an anechoic environment). The fourth switch activates low-frequency protection circuitry which replaces the default 24dB/octave highpass filter with a 36dB/octave filter. The next pair of switches adjust the highfrequency level, introducing a subtle shelf to the response above 2kHz, amounting to a very modest 1dB up or down. The final pair provide lowfrequency boundary compensation, with a shelf cut of -1.5dB, -3dB, or -4.5dB below about 250Hz. The specifications claim a nominal response of 50Hz-20kHz (+1/-1.5dB), extending to 46Hz at -3dB and 36Hz at -10dB. For an SPL of 96dB at one metre, distortion is claimed to be better than two percent below 120Hz and 0.6 percent above. Maximum peak SPL is 111dB/1m and self noise is less than 10dBA.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/JBL%20LSR6328%20&%20LSR6312.htm (2 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:30 PM
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312
JBL Transducer Technologies A number of innovative proprietary technologies have been used to improve the performance of the LSR monitors. The first, Differential Drive, is an arrangement of two separate voice coils on the bass driver, providing twice the surface area of conventional speakers and allowing greater heat dissipation. This gives 3dB more power handling with less power compression. The two coils are wound with opposite phase to reduce their mutual inductance, which provides a more consistent impedance relative to frequency and makes the driver an easier amplifier load. Another advantage is that less iron is required in the magnetic path than with most designs, making it lighter. A third, shorted coil within the motor assembly does absolutely nothing most of the time! However, during extreme cone excursions this central coil enters the magnetic fields of the two driving coils and a current is induced within it. This sets up an opposing magnetic force which acts against the motion of the cone, acting as a brake. JBL call this Dynamic Braking and it is a clever protection device. Apparently, the introduction of the third coil into the magnetic gap of the main coils also helps to cancel the inherent distortion which builds as the main voice coils reach the outer edges of their magnetic fields. Reflex cabinet loudspeakers can suffer from turbulence within the port when monitoring at high levels, simply because of the large volume of air moving around. The LSRs use a Linear Dynamics Aperture (LDA) for their ports, which smoothes the contour of the port exit to minimise this turbulence and thus improve low-frequency accuracy at high listening levels. Common to the tweeters of all the LSR range is the use of titanium and composite materials, which are claimed to provide a better transient response with low distortion, and thus reduced 'ear fatigue'. Furthermore, the tweeters a combined with an Elliptical Oblate Spheroidal (EOS) waveguide, which helps to shape the high-frequency dispersion, directing sound across a listening area of ±30 degrees horizontally and ±15 degrees vertically, and maintaining an even frequency response within 1.5dB across the entire zone.
LSR6312 Powered Subwoofer The LSR6312 powered subwoofer measures 394 x 635 x 292mm (hwd) and weighs 23kg. The cabinet features a front-facing port and contains a single 12inch driver powered by a 260W discrete Class-AB amplifier. The frequency response is given as 28-80Hz (-6dB points), and maximum SPL is 112dB/1m. The 6312 incorporates bass management for a three-channel satellite/subwoofer system, as well as RMC facilities. Combi jack/XLR inputs and associated outputs are provided for three channels (left, centre, and right) plus a fourth Sub Direct input (with a 10dB gain-boost button). An eighth XLR socket provides a summed bass output for additional subwoofers. The three-channel input signals are summed together and then low-pass filtered at 80Hz before being combined with the direct input (normally used for a dedicated LFE signal. At the same time the input signals are individually highpass filtered at 80Hz and presented to the corresponding outputs to feed the file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/JBL%20LSR6328%20&%20LSR6312.htm (3 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:30 PM
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312
satellite speakers. An LCR Bypass mode (remote-controlled with a footswitch) disables the high-pass filtering to the outputs, providing a direct loop-through — only the dedicated Sub Direct input feeds the subwoofer, so this essentially bypasses the sub as far as the satellite monitors are concerned. A recessed input trimmer and six DIP switches provide similar input-level options as those on LSR6328 monitor, supplemented with a polarity inversion option, a boundary compensation mode (a -4dB shelf below 50Hz), and an RMC bypass mode. The RMC facilities are the same as before.
Room Mode Correction The LSR-series Room Mode Correction (RMC) is a grand name for what is, at the end of the day, a simple single-band parametric equaliser. This can be used to tame a single low-frequency response peak, typically formed by the interaction of standing waves within an untreated room. It is no substitute for properly designed acoustic treatment with effective bass trapping, but it can help damp the effect of a boomy resonance in a room. If your mixes often come out bass-light (because a boomy room mode fools you into thinking the bass is more prominent than it really is) then this could be a simple, if partial, solution. The RMC controls incorporated into the LSR6328 monitors and the LSR6312 subwoofer all provide a single parametric equaliser, with adjustable frequency, bandwidth, and attenuation. The control ranges are 26-96Hz, Q of 0.5-0.05, and up to 14dB of cut. The difficult thing is to adjust each of these controls appropriately, but that's where the supplied RMC Calibration Kit comes in. A simple sound level meter and dedicated calibration CD, both provided, are used to chart the low-frequency response of your room, and a series of charts in the manual can then be used to reposition speakers as necessary and adjust their rear-panel RMC controls. The system is simple and elegant, if a little timeconsuming — the whole setup process for all three speakers took me about 40 minutes.
Listening Tests The LSR6328 is a powerful nearfield monitor with excellent dynamics and transient handling. Not only can it play very loud indeed, it can do so effortlessly and with 'rifle shot' attacks when called for! The mid-range is very clean and neutral, and reproduced the critical vocal range with commendable clarity and precision. I found it easy to listen into a complex mix, and heavy bass instruments didn't mask the mid-range detail at sensible listening levels. Stereo imaging was portrayed equally well, with a wide and stable sound stage over a relatively large sweet spot. With all the configuration controls in their default positions I found the tonal balance to be a tad on the hard side, but in a more heavily damped control room I suspect it would sound pretty neutral from the off. In my listening room I found setting the high-frequency shelf to the -1dB position was all that was needed to file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/JBL%20LSR6328%20&%20LSR6312.htm (4 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:30 PM
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312
tame the top end — something which I find typical of most monitors tested here. Recording flaws and imperfect mixes are revealed clearly, but, while many monitors with this ability quickly become fatiguing, I found I was happy to listen for extended periods without any problems. The bottom end of the monitor is very well controlled and has a reasonable extension for the size of cabinet. In a modest control room the LSR6328s do not demand the use of a subwoofer on grounds of either extension or headroom — although both obviously improve with the dedicated subwoofer in service. Hooking up the LSR6312 subwoofer is as simple as re-plugging a couple of XLRs. By default the input signals are high-pass filtered at 80Hz for the satellites, and the subwoofer handles everything below 80Hz. The integration with the satellites was excellent, and the greater extension was immediately obvious on suitable material, with the bass becoming more powerful and solid. On bassheavy material the system really came alive, and if you are looking for a system that can really move some air, this combination would be a good place to start your auditioning.
The Final Word As straightforward monitors, with or without the dedicated subwoofer, this new LSR6300-series system performs impressively. When the music calls for it, these monitors will sound smooth, delicate, and very revealing. However, they can also deliver a really solid, weighty, and dynamic wall of sound when asked, with huge sound pressure levels that can be sustained all day if your ears can take it. Spoken voice and classical music are portrayed with neutrality and fidelity, and clearly this speaker is a good all-rounder, equally capable regardless of the source material's genre. The trumpeted Room Mode Correction will be useful in some situations, but I can't help feeling that messing up the speaker's low-frequency response in an effort to correct a physical standing-wave issue is not the right way to go about things! Having said that, the calibration tools are well thought out and easy to use, and when applied carefully they can at least help to tame response peaks at the listening position. Published in SOS May 2005
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/JBL%20LSR6328%20&%20LSR6312.htm (5 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:30 PM
JBL LSR6328 & LSR6312
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/JBL%20LSR6328%20&%20LSR6312.htm (6 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:30 PM
Korg Kontrol 49
In this article:
The 49er USB & Kontrol 49 Summing Up
Korg Kontrol 49 £319
Korg Kontrol 49 USB MIDI Controller Keyboard Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Keyboard
pros Full-sized keys, separate pitch-bend and mod controls, and the Microkontrol's vector joystick. Programming easy via the software interface, with loads of ready-to-use templates. Powered via USB. MIDI interface capability.
cons Functionality over USB limited to users of Mac OS 10.2 and higher, and Windows XP. Similarly, the editing software and presets cannot be used with any other operating system on the host computer.
summary A competitively priced, well thought-through package that's also easy-to-use (especially if you can run the bundled editor/librarian software).
information £319 including VAT. Korg UK Brochure Line +44 (0)1908 857150. +44 (0)1908 857199. Click here to email www.korg.co.uk
Korg's Microkontrol was a highly versatile, yet compact MIDI controller — but perhaps, with its three octaves of miniature keys, it was too compact. With its four-octave, full-size keyboard, the Kontrol 49 looks set to put that right... Nicholas Rowland
These days we are blessed with a wide choice of brilliant, affordable music software whose power and versatility often puts far more creativity at our fingertips than the hardware which inspired it, and so, not surprisingly, most of us are becoming more software-centric in our music-making. Which is why we're seeing a growth industry in hardware control surfaces, Photos: Mike Cameron and particularly those that are easily configurable to work with many different programs, often simultaneously. Korg's new Kontrol 49 is intended as just such a 'universal' device and one particularly suited to the computer-based musician whose wallet and studio space are both relatively modest. Its grand title is 'USB/MIDI Studio Controller': in a nutshell, it's a controller keyboard equipped with a fair amount of knobularity plus a great deal of programmable MIDI intelligence enabling it to interface at the deepest level with any music software (or hardware) you can shake a MIDI parameter at. If you think those sleek silvery looks are Korgishly familiar, then you're right. Look into my eyes, look into my eyes... and cast your mind back to the Korg Microkontrol reviewed by Paul White in SOS March 2004. Those with long memories (or with browsers pointing to www.soundonsound.com/sos/mar04/
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Korg%20Kontrol%A049.htm (1 of 4)9/27/2005 9:22:35 PM
Korg Kontrol 49
articles/korgmicrokontrol.htm) might recall the deal here: a neat velocity-sensitive keyboard married to eight sliders, eight rotary controls and a master control, 16 velocity-sensitive drum machine-like trigger pads (also doubling as data-entry buttons), plus a programmable vector-control joystick to handle such performance features as modulation and pitch-bend. There was also an array of colour-coded, eight-character LCD 'scribble strips' above the faders and rotary controls to display parameter names and also give instant feedback on changes to parameter values. In terms of its flexibility and intuitive handling, the Microkontrol generally earned itself a big thumbs-up from Paul. However, it was precisely in the big thumbs department that it wouldn't score so highly, being equipped with mini keys, and only 37 of them at that. So Korg have administered a portion of Alice's 'Eat Me' cake, and created the more grown-up version you see here, sporting 49 or four octaves of full-size keys (which incidentally, can be transposed up or down to give you a range of C1 to C9).
The 49er The keyboard itself is of the non-weighted variety, and is velocity sensitive with eight programmable velocity curves to suit different styles. However, a true player will bemoan the fact that there's no aftertouch. As on a lot of keyboards/ synths, pressure control has to be applied through either the programmable modulation or pitch-bend wheels — features which were missing on the Microkontrol. A Vector joystick is also present with separate control messages assignable to the X (up/down) and Y (left/right) axes. Compared to the rest of the package, which feels solid and well-built, this control does seem rather flimsy and lightweight to the touch. If my maths is correct (and counting the keyboard as only one) the Kontrol 49 offers a total of around 40 different controllers, each of which is extensively programmable. The shorthand for a complete set of controller assignments is the word Scene, and like the Microkontrol, the Kontrol 49 can store up to 12 Scenes on board with the trigger pads providing the means to switch between them. As it comes out of the box, it's preloaded with a variety of sample Scenes primarily designed to show off its muscles controlling the various demo packages which are included on the installation CD-ROM. However, these are just the tip of the iceberg: the
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Korg%20Kontrol%A049.htm (2 of 4)9/27/2005 9:22:35 PM
The editor/librarian enables you to speedily assemble sets of Scenes and gives you visual access to all the Kontrol 49's various control elements. Double-clicking on any item brings up a smaller menu (shown top right) where you can quickly input values and name names. When you're finished, you can upload the Scenes via USB to the keyboard. Names of parameters appear on the LED scribble strips to give you vital feedback on which slider/rotary control is assigned to
Korg Kontrol 49
what, though the eight-character limit makes CD-ROM has an extensive collection some descriptions rather cryptic. of templates covering all mainstream packages from the major software houses, including Ableton Live, Propellerhead Reason, IK's Sampletank 2, most NI instruments, and the major sequencers.
Korg also include a brilliant scene-management software package (shown below), which in terms of functionality goes well beyond the original librarian software that was included with the Microkontrol. This software offers complete on-screen programming of the all Kontrol 49's assignment and functions, enabling you to very easily modify the presets or create custom Scenes of your own, assemble them into Scene sets and then upload them to the keyboard. Using the editor I was quickly able to assemble the included templates into a custom Scene set, giving me control over my Cubase mixer and EQ screens, Steinberg's A1 software synth, Native Instruments' Battery, which I use as a VST instrument within Cubase, and also a Korg Electribe. Of course, you can also use the Kontrol 49's front panel to edit patches or create your own from scratch, but to be perfectly honest, it really is a lot less hassle and kinder on the tips of your fingers just to fire up the editor and do it all via the big screen. Unfortunately, like the USB drivers, the editor software is only for users of Windows XP and Mac OS 10.2 and above. What's more, 12 scene memories is not that many, and if you need to control lots of different packages (or aspects of packages) then you will probably find yourself swapping between different Scene sets quite regularly.
USB & Kontrol 49 Like the Microkontrol, the Kontrol 49 is designed to interface with your computer through a USB connection, which also provides the necessary power to the keyboard. There's an included 9V wall-wart adaptor if you've got too many devices on your USB connection for this to work. USB drivers are provided for Windows XP and Mac OS X (10.2 or later) and installation on to my shiny new iMac G5 was simple and straightforward. But my laptop runs Windows Professional, to which the Kontrol 49 is only any good as a MIDI keyboard connecting through its five-pin sockets. One thing to get your head around when setting up the Kontrol 49 with your software is that although it is equipped with two physical MIDI Outs and one physical MIDI in, what the computer actually sees are five ports. Two of these are virtual routes through which the Kontrol 49 sends note and controller data to your software, and another is the virtual route by which computer transmits info (typically program dumps) back to the Kontrol 49. This means that you can use the unit both as a USB controller for your software and as a one-in/one-out MIDI interface between your computer and external hardware.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Korg%20Kontrol%A049.htm (3 of 4)9/27/2005 9:22:35 PM
Korg Kontrol 49
Summing Up In both the Microkontrol and the Kontrol 49, Korg have succeeded in producing a cost-effective way of providing flexible and relatively intuitive control over a typical collection of studio software. If you're the kind that knows your NRPNs from your RPNs and devours MIDI implementation charts in the way others do romantic novels, then the level of programmability you can achieve with the Kontrol 49 is impressive. But the good news is that if you're the sort who doesn't particularly want to get down and dirty with arcane MIDI parameters, then the included templates do seem to work straight out of the box. Personally, I think it's actually the combination of the hardware with the editor/ librarian that really makes this an appealing package, which makes the cheese very hard indeed if you're not running the right operating system. The Microkontrol deserved its positive review, and with the benefit of its refined software and its bigger complement of full-sized keys, the Kontrol 49 is a welcome extension (if you'll pardon the pun) of the original offering. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Korg%20Kontrol%A049.htm (4 of 4)9/27/2005 9:22:35 PM
Mindprint Trio
In this article:
Mindprint Trio
Front End For DAW Studios Processor & Monitor Controller Input Conditioning Published in SOS May 2005 Connectivity Working With The Trio Print article : Close window
Mindprint Trio £329
Reviews : Processor
pros Cost effective. Combines a very capable front end with flexible monitoring.
cons DAW connections on unbalanced phonos only. Talkback switch noisy.
Mindprint cram mic and line channel strips, monitor control, and talkback into a single desktop unit. Paul White
summary
Mindprint's Trio is designed to meet the specific needs of the desktop audio market and comprises a very practical combination of a channel strip and a monitor-control section, complete with headphone amp and talkback facilities. Although it doesn't include a computer information audio interface as such, it does have £329 including VAT. optical S/PDIF inputs and outputs, so it Mindprint +49 6851 9050. could be used with the new Apple Mac +49 6851 905 200. G5 computers without the need to buy Click here to email a separate audio interface. The voicechannel part of the package is based Photos: Mark Ewing www.mindprint.com around a very respectable Class-A mic/ instrument preamp with switchable 48V phantom power, compressor, and equaliser, but there's also a separate stereo line input with its own EQ that can be mixed with the mic input, as well as an auxiliary monitor input that could be used as a two-track return. Mindprint have taken part of the Trio's compressor design from their rather more costly DTC dual recording channel, and it provides programme-dependent adjustment of the time constants so that only a single knob is needed to adjust the processing. Furthermore, the mic channel's EQ is tailored specifically to vocals so you get the job done with fewer distracting controls. As an alternative to a separate front end and monitor controller, the Trio provides a solution that is both cost effective and tidy. I was also impressed by the musicality of the compressor.
Front End For DAW Studios Clearly Mindprint have tried to provide all the essential front-end and monitoring file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Mindprint%20Trio.htm (1 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:41 PM
Mindprint Trio
features required for use with a typical desktop recording setup, though they've steered clear of including a USB or Firewire computer interface, as different users will have different requirements in this area. All the analogue inputs may be used at the same time, and there are also two separate headphone amps, each with its own volume control. Latency-free monitoring is catered for by allowing the input signal to be routed directly to the monitoring section during recording, though this obviously means switching off software monitoring in the computer to avoid hearing both the direct and delayed signals. Also included in the monitoring section is talkback functionality; speaker level control with Mono, Dim (20dB attenuation), and Mute buttons; and provision to switch between three pairs of speakers. On a practical level, the unit is compact without being cramped, and its cast-metal case is finished in a pleasant rubbery coating with a very nicely styled red front panel. There are rubber feet on the base, and the unit is surprisingly heavy, so it shouldn't creep around on your desk. All the connections, including the two headphone jacks, are on the rear panel, and the integral talkback mic is just below the centre of the front panel. All the channel-strip controls are located on the left of the unit, and all the monitor control facilities are on the right. Those controls relating to the zero-latency monitoring have their own section at the bottom centre of the panel, where you'll also find the auxiliary input's level control. All the pots have red caps with clear white marker lines, and most of the buttons are chunky rubber affairs with in-built status LEDs. Power comes from the obligatory power adaptor, and there's a ground terminal (of the type used to earth record decks) on the rear panel — this is a useful addition for systems powered entirely from mains adaptors, as you may get a hum if you have no grounds at all. Also on the rear panel are three DIP switches for setting the optical S/PDIF to internal or external sync and for selecting 44.1kHz, 48kHz, 88.2kHz, or 96kHz sample rates.
Input Conditioning The Trio has two input channels that are mixed before being fed to your DAW, the main one being the instrument/mic channel. This features a gain control with switchable 80Hz low-cut filter, a two-band EQ tuned for vocals, and a Fat knob which brings in the compression. Unlike the more general-purpose EQ in the line channel (which features shelving at 120Hz and 9kHz), the mic-channel EQ's shelving frequencies are set to 100Hz and 7.5kHz and have a Chebyshev curve, which simply means there's a bit of a dip before the boost comes in to give it a vintage EQ character. All the EQ bands have a ±12dB range. A round button activates the phantom power, while a further knob sets the output level being mixed with the line channel, the latter accommodating mono or stereo line signals.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Mindprint%20Trio.htm (2 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:41 PM
Mindprint Trio
Mindprint have designed the mic channel's Fat compressor to automatically adjust its gain depending on how much compression is applied, so the level should remain reasonably constant during adjustment. Although there's no gain-reduction meter in the traditional sense, a multi-coloured LED shows green when there's no compression, orange during moderate compression, and red when the signal is really being hammered! This compressor has a soft-knee characteristic and so behaves fairly benignly. Each channel has its own Mute button. The line input incorporates a basic two-band shelving EQ and a level control. A 10segment meter at the centre of the panel can be switched to read the input or the output level but not the compressor gain reduction. When in input mode, the left meter shows the mic-channel level while the right meter shows the summed line-input level.
Unusually for a desktop unit, the underside of the Trio carries important controls. A set of DIP switches assigns the mic and line input channels to the recording and monitoring outputs. At the top of the picture you can also see the pair of trimmer pots which are used to set suitable levels for the rear-panel DAW Interface connectors.
Bottom centre on the front panel are three knobs, two to control the level of mic and line channels to be fed directly to the monitor section for zero-latency monitoring, and there's also a control for the stereo auxiliary input. In the output section are feeds for three sets of monitors, where the first (A) is on jacks and the other two (B & C) are on phonos. A single large level control adjusts the speaker output levels. There is a screwdriver level-trim control on the bottom panel for monitor output B, so active monitors fed from output C need to have their levels matched using their own input trim controls — passive monitors can be adjusted by using their own amplifier gain controls. Two further trims set the main DAW analogue input and output levels. Right next to the speaker outlets are the two independently controllable headphone outputs, leaving just the AC input and power switch at the end of the panel, next to the ground terminal.
Connectivity The mic input is on a balanced XLR, while the mono instrument input and stereo line inputs are on quarter-inch jacks. A pair of quarter-inch jacks provide an insert point that may be used for connecting additional processors between the preamp and the compressor. As separate send and return jacks are provided, the send is always active and can be used as a further output without upsetting the signal flow. The stereo mix of all the possible input sources is fed to the stereo DAW Interface Out which, in this case, is on unbalanced phono connectors, as is the corresponding DAW Interface In.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Mindprint%20Trio.htm (3 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:41 PM
Mindprint Trio
There is, however, a cunning set of DIP switches on the bottom panel which serves two functions: firstly, it allows the routing of the mic and line channels to the DAW Interface Output jacks to be configured; and, secondly, it lets you determine how the channels are monitored, so an overdub can be monitored in the left ear while the original track plays in the right, for example. The default setting is to have all four switches on, which sends both the mic and line signals to both sets of DAW inputs as well as to both channels of the monitoring system. The DAW output, also on phonos, is fed via an internal 24-bit converter to the optical S/PDIF connector. Both optical S/PDIF ports are located at the lower edge of the rear panel along with the DIP switches for setting the sample rate and sync status. Two further Aux In phonos feed the monitor section directly. As mentioned earlier, these could be used as a two-track return, but you could also use them to play a CD, keyboard, or guitar preamp directly into the monitors without the computer being on. The integral talkback mic routes into the headphone outputs. The switch is nonlatching and any other audio being monitored is dimmed when the talkback is active. A Monitor On switch allows the input channels to be routed directly to the monitor section‚ again useful for trying things out without your computer running. Similarly, a DAW On button provides a fast way to feed the outputs from the computer's audio interface to the monitor section. Separate latching buttons are used to switch on the monitors, so all three pairs can be active at once when needed — the Mono and Dim buttons apply to whichever monitors are selected.
Working With The Trio The Trio proved to be very easy to set up and work with, and with very few exceptions it worked impeccably. The mic preamp sounds clean and solid, though a little hiss is evident when you turn up the HF EQ controls, even when using a sensitive capacitor mic close up. This probably wouldn't be noticeable under normal vocal-recording conditions, but could become audible when recording more distant sources or particularly quiet vocalists with less sensitive microphones. The EQ frequencies and curves seem well chosen from a musical standpoint, while the compressor is particularly impressive in thickening up vocals without making them sound excessively processed. Although the general monitoring facilities are comprehensive and the phones feed is both loud and clear, there is quite a loud 'clonk' when you activate the talkback. This is simply the mic picking up the switch operation, but if you have your phones turned up loud, it's rather like having your head in the bucket and somebody tapping on it with a spanner. Looking on the bright side, it certainly gets the attention of your listeners on the other end of the cable! Overall I really like the concept of the Trio, and it delivers a lot of quality and flexibility for the UK price. Its mic amp is at least the equal of what you'd expect to find in a mid-price mixer, and I think the compressor is exceptional for file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Mindprint%20Trio.htm (4 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:41 PM
Mindprint Trio
something you can drive with only one knob. I love the packaging — it's just the right size and it stays put on your desktop, though I'd still have preferred a choice of two-track monitor sources for playing back CDs and so on. You can use the Aux input for this, of course, but on the Mackie Big Knob that I reviewed recently there are three two-track inputs, and I often used these to connect my Roland V-Drums and Line 6 Pod guitar preamp for simply playing through the studio monitors. Having optical S/PDIF I/O is a undeniable bonus, though, and while many pieces of audio equipment use the coaxial rather than optical variant of S/PDIF, it does provide a simple way for users to connect to those computers that have optical S/PDIF I/ O, such as the Apple G5 range.
A further trim pot on the left-hand side of the Trio's underside allows level adjustment of one of the three pairs of speaker outputs. All the trimmers are recessed to avoid accidental misalignment, and are slotted to allow easy adjustment using a flat-blade screwdriver.
Of course you can't provide all the features to satisfy everyone without hiking up the cost to the point where people aren't prepared to pay for it, so a line has to be drawn somewhere. I would have liked balanced I/O for connecting to the DAW, rather than phonos, though this won't be a significant shortcoming in most studio setups. My feeling is that Mindprint have come up with a great product. For those musicians who record only one or two audio parts at a time, it combines all that is essential in a stereo monitor controller with a simple yet very smooth-sounding front end, and it therefore does away with the need for a separate channel strip or mixer. For the desktop studio user who works mainly alone or with one musician at a time, Mindprint's Trio is a very appealing all-in-one product for recording and monitoring. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Mindprint%20Trio.htm (5 of 5)9/27/2005 9:22:41 PM
Native Instrument Battery 2
In this article:
The Master Section Sample Matrix Edit Pane Conclusions
NI Battery 2 £150
Native Instrument Battery 2 Virtual Drum Module (Mac/PC) Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
pros Compatible with a wide range of sample formats. Powerful modulation options. Ability to swap sets of Cells across kits. Inspiring range of dynamic filtering options. Large number of audio outputs.
cons
Two years on from its original release, Native's virtual drum module gets its first full upgrade. Is it all John Bonham tom mayhem, or is it limper than a Kraftwerk drum solo? Paul Ward
Supplied library lacking in variety.
summary If you're messing around with a full-blown hardware or software sampler just to handle your one-shot drum sounds, Battery will be like a breath of fresh air — it's so quick and easy to use. It handles just about any sample material you can get your hands on and the simple editing options allow you to tailor the sounds quickly for use. In short, I can't imagine anyone working with percussion samples that wouldn't benefit from having Battery 2 on their computer.
information £149.99 including VAT. Arbiter Music Technology +44 (0)20 8970 1909. +44 (0)20 8202 7076. Click here to email www.arbitermt.co.uk www.native-instruments. com
I've been an ardent fan of Native Instruments' original Battery samplebased software drum module since it was unveiled back in 2001. It was great for slinging together a 'kit' of drum samples and for coming up with rhythms quickly, and much faster than using my old Akai hardware samplers to do the same thing. But there were a few quirks in its operation, and I found myself hoping that an upgrade would take care of them someday. Now, at last, it's here — does it smooth out the wrinkles of the previous version?
Battery 2 has the same quasi-military look as the original version, as you can see in this shot of the program running under Cubase SX on the review PC. The Master section is the top strip of this window, above the Sample Matrix of grey Cells in the middle, and the Edit Pane is the section at the bottom. The left-hand part of the Edit Pane changes according to the selections made on the tabs at the top left of the pane, as shown in the other screenshots in this article, while the display on the right shows the waveform of the currently selected Cell for editing.
Battery 2 will run as a stand-alone application, or as a plug-in under VSTi-, DXi-, RTAS-, or Audio Unitscompatible hosts. Native Instruments claim that it will run in 256MB of RAM and up to 4GB of disk space under 400MHz Athlon or Pentium 3-based PCs, or a 500MHz G3 Mac, but as usual, they suggest using beefier machines than these for optimum performance; a 1.2GHz Pentium 3/4 or Athlon PC, or a 1GHz G4 Mac, with 512MB of RAM, is recommended. I ran the review
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Native%20Instrument%20Battery%202.htm (1 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:47 PM
Native Instrument Battery 2
Test Spec 3.4GHz Pentium 4 PC with 1GB of RAM running Windows XP (Service Pack 2). Native Instruments Battery 2. Steinberg Cubase SX v3.01.
copy on a 3.4GHz Pentium 4 in 1GB of RAM with no problems, and it demanded little more than 10 percent of my total CPU power in typical use (ie. when using it to handle main rhythm, percussion and tom-fill duties) with the largest of Battery 2's new factory kits loaded. At first I thought that NI had forgotten to include the library disks with Battery 2. The disk insert states that it contains the 'Installation CD' — but it's actually a DVD. Anyone lacking a DVD reader on their PC or Macintosh, take note...! In addition to Battery 2 itself, the DVD contains over 3GB of sampled drums including acoustic, electronic and percussion kits. The kits from Battery 1 are also provided, which is handy, as you can use version 2 in your old songs without having to re-import the v1 sounds. Whatever minor gripes I may have had about the original Battery's user interface (of which more in a moment) I can vouch for the quality and effectiveness of the Battery 1 kits, having used them time and time again. I'm glad to report that the new material is generally of an equally high standard. There's a power and liveliness to the samples that sometimes makes you feel as though there's a real drummer sitting next door surrounded by expensive microphones! I would have preferred rather more variety in the factory sets, however — particularly a few more acoustic kit variants. Some of the acoustic kick drums sounded a little flabby, and I would have liked a few more to choose from. The user interface is similar to that of the original version of Battery, with its rows of 'Cells' containing your samples, but NI have tidied up the main panels and arranged them more logically. The Battery window is conceptually and physically divided into three sections, comprising the Master Section, the Sample Matrix and the Edit Pane (see the large screenshot opposite). The Master section is where drum kits are managed and where the overall volume of Battery is controlled. The Sample Matrix, which dominates the window, maps out the Cells containing the samples into columns and rows, much like a spreadsheet, and gives you an overall view of the current kit. The Edit Pane, in the bottom third of the window, is where you get down to modifying the behaviour of Cells and the samples within those Cells.
The Master Section This section, at the top of the Battery window, contains drop-down menus for File, Edit and View functions and a 'quick-select' drop-down menu for selecting kits stored in the hard drive location specified by Battery 2's sample 'path'. Useful information displayed here includes polyphony/used polyphony, memory requirements for the currently selected kit and the master volume. As with some of their other recent sample-based releases (such as Elektrik Piano), Native Instruments have endowed Battery 2 with 'Direct From Disk' facilities, making it possible to use sample files that would otherwise take up more space than is available in RAM. You do have the option to turn this feature on or off, since the downside of DFD is that it increases disk and processor file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Native%20Instrument%20Battery%202.htm (2 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:47 PM
Native Instrument Battery 2
activity. I felt the original file- and samplehandling system in Battery was somewhat clumsy, and I was pleased to see that this had been streamlined in the new version — I've lost count of the times I've picked the wrong option from Battery's File menu, ending up in the 'Add Cell' dialogue when I really wanted to load a new set of Cells. Mapping samples to a Cell at different Battery 2 treats its files intelligently; so velocities. if you choose a kit, the program now realises that you want to load a kit and performs that function, whereas if you choose a WAV or AIFF file, it loads that sample into a Cell. There's also a list of recently used kits, which is a nice timesaver. The influence of Native Instruments' Kontakt is discernible in the wealth of supported file formats: Kontakt Instruments, Battery v1 kits, Battery 2 kits and/or Cells, Sound Designer II files, WAVs, AIFFs, Soundfonts, and files from the following hardware and software samplers: HALion, Samplecell, LM4, Gigasampler, Recycle, the Akai S1000 and S3000 and MPC-series sequencer/ samplers — and all from eight- to 32-bit resolution. It's an extremely impressive list. A new 'Import' function brings all of the supported file formats together into a browser window, similar to that used in Kontakt. I've never been totally convinced by this browser window, even in Kontakt; I find it a bit pokey and I'd also prefer to have access to some simple file-management functions from here, such as the ability to rename, copy and move samples — the browser format merely hints at such possibilities. I would also like to see the double-pane approach adopted, like the standard Windows Explorer panel, to make the navigation area less restrictive. Choices for saving information have been given some attention too. There's now the option to save pointers to your samples, rather than have them replicated by Battery in its own folders — although you can still choose that method for maximum flexibility. You can save selections of Cells, making it easier to build kits from these collections, rather than having to load them one at a time, or start from another full kit. It's simple to save a Cell collection of your favourite percussion rack and then pop it into any kit. Brilliant! This has the potential to avoid an enormous amount of repetitive work.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Native%20Instrument%20Battery%202.htm (3 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:47 PM
Native Instrument Battery 2
Sample Matrix The spreadsheet-like Sample Matrix displays your currently selected kit. Each Cell represents a sample, or collection of samples assigned to a specific MIDI note number, or range of notes. Up to 128 samples can be held in a Cell and these are layered, or split across velocity ranges (with or without crossfades) as required. The number of Cells is no longer fixed, as it was in the previous version. You can add or delete rows up to a maximum of 72 Cells and view them in rows of six or 12 Cells. Individual Cells may be soloed or muted, or you can select noncontiguous Cells with combinations of modifier keys. Selecting, muting, or soloing rows and columns of Cells is a one-click task, and you can similarly combine the selection of both rows and columns. Personally, I like to separate kicks, snares, cymbals, toms, percussion and loops onto separate rows for selective muting/ soloing. A pair of indicators at Cell, row and column level show whether they are muted or soloed. Just to the right of the mute/solo buttons in each Cell is a field that can display one parameter, such as volume, pan position, filter cutoff, or one of many other values. This parameter can be fixed, or can change depending on the parameter you are currently editing. One feature that I sorely miss from the earlier version of Battery is the ability to see a Cell's full key range in this display field. You can now see either the low or high key value in there, but not both simultaneously. This is no doubt down to screen space restrictions, but it's certainly going to slow me down, and I'll wager I'm not alone. However, it is possible to move, copy and swap Cells, with or without their associated key range. This is the real strength of Battery's ability to organise drum kits quickly and easily.
Edit Pane The Edit Pane is where detailed sample editing takes place. Here, Cells can be treated to an array of editing options and individual samples can be tweaked into shape. And when I say 'tweaked' you can read 'mangled beyond all recognition'! Firstly, setting up sample layers is much easier than it was with the original Battery, and is helped enormously by the user-friendly, Kontakt-like assignment display (shown on page 209). I'd still balk at the thought of mapping 128 velocity layers in a Cell, but if you've got the time, Battery 2 will allow you to do it. The basic editing features are familiar from the original version of Battery, including all the typical features you'd expect, such as volume, pitch, and also amplitude and pitch envelopes. A bit-reduction control has been added, in case you long for the days of the Akai S900, and there's a sample-frequency reduction control if you really want to get back to the days of the Sinclair Spectrum! Gone is the 'Shape' control of Battery 1, but the 'Saturation' knob does a similar job, adding distorted higher harmonics, as its name suggests, and is always worth a turn if you feel that your drums need a little more energy. If there's one feature I always felt was missing from Battery's armoury it was a dynamic filter. I have quite a few old samples that have a great attack phase, but
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Native%20Instrument%20Battery%202.htm (4 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:47 PM
Native Instrument Battery 2
become very noisy once the signal level starts to fall away. In the past I used the old Battery's volume envelope to deal with this, but this inevitably leads to some 'choking' of the sound, and this is particularly unwelcome when the after-ring or ambience forms an important part of the sample. Fortunately, Battery 2 arrives with a freely assignable modulation envelope. I can simply apply an envelope to the The new dynamic filter. filter cutoff frequency and with a little tweaking, that nasty noise is removed while retaining the character of the sample's decay. The filter's pretty flexible, too — there are 15 types, including low-pass, high-pass, band-pass, three-band EQ, phase and vowel variants. Battery 2 also adds a built-in compressor, and this is welcome, removing the need for external processors in many cases. It doesn't have all the control and flexibility of a dedicated dynamics processor, but I believe it would get the job done in all but the most critical cases. More importantly, it can be applied on a Cell-by-Cell basis, rather than across the output of the entire instrument, so it may allow you to avoid having to tie up outputs simply to add compression to one sound. Controls are provided for Threshold, Ratio, Gain, Attack and Decay. If you found Battery a little lacking in modulation features, then Battery 2 should be more to your taste. Up to eight modulation paths can be created, with controls to determine the modulation source, destination and amount in positive or negative values. The list of modulation sources is impressive, including velocity, the mod wheel, mono/poly aftertouch, key position, LFO or any of Battery 2's The built-in compressor can be applied to envelopes (there's even a dedicated individual Cells with different settings. AHDSR modulation envelope). You can also define up to eight global MIDI controllers to act as modulation sources across any of Battery 2's Cells. The modulation destinations are no less impressive, taking in such staples as volume, pan, filter cutoff and resonance, but there are also more esoteric options, such as bit depth, saturation, loop start/length and pitch envelope. Battery 2's LFO is also surprisingly flexible, with controls for waveform (a choice of sine, sawtooth and square), fade-in and pulse width (on the square wave only). The LFO can be made to re-trigger when the Cell is played, and you can also make the LFO speed sync to the host sequencer's tempo. Battery has never been a loop player in the way of tools such as Phatmatik or
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Native%20Instrument%20Battery%202.htm (5 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:47 PM
Native Instrument Battery 2
Intakt, and that hasn't really changed (although there's absolutely no reason why you can't use Battery to trigger loops), but NI have added some simple looping tools. Up to four loops can be created within a sample, with crossfades and variable tuning. Each loop can repeat a fixed number of times, or infinitely. While we're on the subject, I often use Battery to split a single-hit drum sound from a loop by setting the sample start position and using the volume envelope to isolate a particular sound. Using this method means you can keep the loop as a single sample, but use variants across a range of Cells to pick out other drum hits you want to use. Battery 2 makes this very easy. Finally, each Cell now has the choice of being sent to one of up to 16 mono and eight stereo outputs. This number of outputs is a vast improvement over the previous version and wins another big smile from this reviewer.
Conclusions All in all, I'm a big fan of Battery 2 and its many enhancements. I'm still not keen on the Browser window in its current form, and I am going to miss the simultaneous high/low note display in the matrix. If I were to compile a wish list I would suggest the ability to use one or two outputs as aux/effects sends. I'd also like to be able to choose the colour of Cells to assist my brain in finding its way around — no matter how I arrange the matrix, I can't seem to find things quickly enough. A mixer page with faders would assist when balancing kits, perhaps with the ability to choose the parameter (other than simply volume) that the faders are currently controlling — balancing tom tunings, for example, can be a bit longwinded on a Cell-by-Cell basis. The library material, although high on quality, is somewhat lacking in breadth. I would really have liked some Simmons drums, classic analogue drum machines or some more 'produced' acoustic kits. I've often used Battery's simple interface to play bass lines and vocal samples, so some more examples of this nature would be useful to show off Battery's potential. I liked the original Battery so much that I had it plugged into my default song, so that it fired up with Cubase. The best praise I can give to Battery 2 is that it is so good that it makes Battery seem cumbersome and inflexible! Battery 2 is now loading with my default song, and I doubt I'll ever look back. In my opinion, there is simply no easier way to get your drum samples into a host sequencer than by using Battery 2. Published in SOS May 2005
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Native%20Instrument%20Battery%202.htm (6 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:47 PM
Native Instrument Battery 2
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Native%20Instrument%20Battery%202.htm (7 of 7)9/27/2005 9:22:47 PM
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA
In this article:
The Mystery Of Model Names Technical Specifications Flying Mole Amplifier Listening Tests
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA Powered Monitors Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Monitors
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA £1616/£1169 pros Tweeter and crossover upgrades have raised the standards yet again. Uncanny bass extension and power handling from such small boxes. Superb resolution and stereo imaging. The Flying Mole amplification approaches that of the Bryston amps, but without the weight, heat, or cost. The tweeter upgrade and Flying Mole amps are available for older systems.
cons You'll have to take them home once you've auditioned them!
summary PMC's two smallest passive monitors are now available with an integrated Class-D amplifier to form self-powered Activated monitors that deliver class-leading performance in a convenient and costeffective package. The remarkable quality of the Flying Mole amplifiers, coupled with recent upgrades to the DB1 and TB2 monitors, produces stunning sound quality that has to be heard to be believed.
information TB2SA, £1616 per pair; DB1SA, £1169 per pair.
Pioneering digital amplifiers are combined with PMC's proven transmission-line cabinet designs to deliver spectacular monitoring performance at a projectstudio price. Hugh Robjohns
The Professional Monitor Company — now known more simply as just PMC — have built up a phenomenal reputation for their entire range of monitors, from the massive BB5/XBD system down to the tiny DB1. These products can be found in mastering houses, film dubbing suites, recording and broadcast studios, and outside broadcast trucks, and are increasingly making inroads into the homes of wellheeled hi-fi buffs.
Photos: Mark Ewing The TB2SA and DB1SA monitors (outside and inside, respectively), complete with their Flying Mole amplifier packs.
Many of these products have already been reviewed in the pages of Sound On Sound, including the DB1, TB2, FB1, and AML1, and all employ highly sophisticated transmission-line loading principles unique to PMC. The majority of PMC's products are passive, meaning that they employ high-level crossovers constructed from passive components — albeit highly specified components laid out with enormous care on huge and complex circuit boards behind the terminal panels. Only the largest systems — the BB5 and MB2 speakers — and the compact AML1 are available in fully active configurations. PMC have long argued that while the active approach has some significant advantages over a passive design, it is an expensive solution requiring highquality active components — filters and amplifiers. The large active BB5 and MB2 systems, for example, employ specially modified Bryston active crossovers
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/PMC%20TB2SA%20&%20DB1SA.htm (1 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:51 PM
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA
Prices include VAT. PMC +44 (0)870 444 1044. +44 (0)870 444 1045. Click here to email www.pmc loudspeaker.com www.flyingmole.co.jp
and Bryston amplifiers throughout. Even the AML1 employs Bryston circuitry built under licence. Making active speakers to suit the budgets of the home-studio market while still meeting the quality threshold demanded by Peter Thomas, Managing Director and Chief Designer of PMC, has so far proved impossible — not, apparently, through lack of trying! To date, Peter has simply not found a way of incorporating active crossovers and amplifiers of sufficient quality at a low enough price to make this dream a reality, and the company has long recommended instead partnering their passive speakers with a top-quality amplifier to achieve the product's performance potential. To that end, they have long offered the neat solution of the Bryston Powerpac amplifiers — single-channel self-contained units, available in a range of powers from 60W to 240W, which can be bolted to the rear panels of the speakers to produce a convenient 'powered speaker' — an approach PMC like to call Activated. While this solution lacks the 'tweakability' featured in many active designs, and it is relatively expensive, it works very well indeed and the resolution and quality surpasses many similarly priced active designs. Regular Sound On Sound readers will already know that I have used a pair of TB1s, Activated by Bryston Powerpac 120s, for many years with no complaints whatever. The sound quality and resolution are superb given the system's size, although the combination is relatively heavy and quite expensive. However, these criticisms have now been addressed with the launch of the TB2SA and its diminutive brother the DB1SA. Essentially these are standard TB2 and DB1 speakers with re-engineered cabinets to incorporate Flying Mole monobloc digital amplifiers in a very neat package. The amplifier is incredibly lightweight and highly cost-effective, while giving remarkably little away in sound quality terms to the heavy and expensive Bryston. It may sound too good to be true, but the proof is in the listening!
The Mystery Of Model Names First off, it might be useful to explain the logic behind the model names and some of the recent developments, which have left some potential purchasers a little confused. The TB2 is named as the second generation of the 'tiny box' loudspeaker — it's older and discontinued sibling being the TB1. The newer model introduced improvements to the transmission line and crossover, as well as rounded baffle edges to enhance stereo imaging. The 'S' in the model name refers to the Studio version — the most cost-effective model in the range, with a painted black cabinet rather than the more expensive range of real wood veneers favoured by up-market studios and hi-fi types. Finally, the 'A' suffix points to the Activated status of the model, with the incorporated Flying Mole amplifier. Interested parties may become confused by another suffix — the '+' model. Recently, PMC decided that economies of scale would allow the original metalfile:///H|/SOS%2005-05/PMC%20TB2SA%20&%20DB1SA.htm (2 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:51 PM
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA
dome tweeters fitted to several models — including the DB1 and TB2 — to be upgraded to the soft-dome tweeters used across the board in the more expensive models. This upgrade was indicated by the '+' suffix, and the current production models of the passive speakers are marketed as the DB1S+ and TB2S+ (older metal-dome systems can be upgraded — contact your dealer for details). However, in the interests of simplicity, the Activated models, which all employ the same soft-dome tweeter, don't include the '+' suffix.
The Flying Mole's simple controls are provided on the top panel of the amplifier pack for ease of access — this picture was taken from directly above the monitor.
Last but not least, is the 'M' version, which means that the monitor is Magnetically Corrected — this is only available as an option, rather than being built in as standard. Given the almost universal use of LCD computer monitors, and the growing use of LCD and Plasma TV screens, magnetic shielding is far less important than it once was, and hence many will enjoy the reduction in cost that derives from making the shielding an optional extra. Phew! Hope you were paying attention, because I'll be testing you later...
Technical Specifications Supplied for review were pairs of both DB1SA and TB2SA monitors. The TB2S and DB1S have both been reviewed before (in SOS November 2001 and January 2003 respectively), so rather than go over exactly the same ground here, I'll concentrate mainly on the differences. First, though, it might be worth giving the outline specs of each model as a reference point. The TB2 measures 400 x 200 x 350mm (hwd) and weighs just over 9kg. The amplifier is mounted vertically in a cabinet extension from the upper half of the rear of the speaker, and the connection between amp and speaker is courtesy of a right-angled Speakon connector that protrudes from the foam of the transmission-line port at the bottom of the rear panel. It is a very neat solution, and the integration of amp and speaker is elegant and practical. The new rear panel is equipped to accept an Omnimount bracket for wall mounting, if required. PMC claim the usable frequency range for the TB2 to be 40Hz-25kHz, with a peak SPL (at one metre) of 111dB. The bass driver employs a doped-paper cone in a 170mm cast-alloy chassis, coupled at 2kHz to a 27mm fabric soft dome. The DB1 and its amplifier housing are constructed in a very similar way to those of the TB2, but with scaled-down dimensions. Again, the new rear panel is equipped for wall mounting, but rather than a standard Omnimount system PMC supply an optional bespoke wall bracket. This tiny speaker measures 290 x 155 x file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/PMC%20TB2SA%20&%20DB1SA.htm (3 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:51 PM
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA
283mm (hwd) and weighs just 5kg. The soft-dome tweeter and crossover frequency are the same, but the doped-paper bass driver is mounted in a 140mm cast-alloy chassis. As you would expect, the low-frequency extension is not as great, and neither is the power handling, with specifications of 50Hz and 108dBSPL, respectively. The Flying Mole amplifier unit is fitted so that its power switch and volume control are both at the top, while the bottom panel provides an XLR input, IEC mains inlet, and the pre-connected Speakon output. The amplifier power output is quoted as 120W when coupled to the PMC monitors, and the manufacturer claims a power conversion efficiency of over 85 percent — hence a power consumption of just 25W (6W when in standby mode with no input signal) and no heat to worry about!
Flying Mole Amplifier The name Flying Mole seems an odd one for a Japanese amplifier manufacturer. Apparently it derives from the notion that the greatest goal in life for a mole scurrying around underground might be to fly — well, it always has been hard for Westerners to understand the Oriental mind-set! But regardless of the company name, the products are impressive. Digital amplifiers — Class-D amps — are nothing new, and lots of active loudspeakers already use Class-D amplifier designs. However, most leave something to be desired when auditioned; Class-D amps are often harshsounding and lack the resolution and 'inky black' silences that a good analogue amp can deliver. However, the technology has improved significantly in recent years, and Flying Mole's unique Bi-phase Fusion Technology certainly seems to be able to deliver the goods. In some ingenious but secretive way, this technology integrates the amplifier's switched-mode power supply with the switching amplifier circuitry, resulting in unusually high power efficiency and no audible artefacts. Most analogue amps struggle to better 30 percent power efficiency and typical Class-D amps are about 65 percent efficient. The impressive 85 percent performance figure of the Flying Mole amps means that they always run cool and don't require external heat sinks — they're just simple plain boxes the size of paperbacks, but they drive loudspeakers very nicely indeed! Strangely, the distortion figure given in the specifications (0.03 percent at 50W output) appears rather unimpressive, yet auditioning the amp suggests it compares very favourably to a Bryston — which quotes distortion figures with several more zeros before the digit. The logical conclusion is that what we hear and what we measure are not necessarily the same thing! In many ways, the Flying Mole amps can be compared to a really good valve triode design — which would share a similar, yet equally inaudible, distortion figure. The DADM100pro reviewed here is available in three main versions with different input and output connectors. The DADM100pro BI version used with the Activated PMCs features a balanced XLR input and Speakon output, while the BB version retains the XLR input but uses 4mm binding posts for the outputs. The last version is the HT model, which couples an unbalanced phono input socket with 4mm binding posts for the output. The last two models measure 43 x 132 x 238mm (hwd), while the BI model isn't quite as deep (223mm). All weigh a ridiculous
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/PMC%20TB2SA%20&%20DB1SA.htm (4 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:51 PM
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA
650g. In fact, the amplifier is so lightweight that during the review a heavy speaker cable was easily able to pull it off the desk! In addition, there are dual AC/DC versions of each of the above, equipped with a 12V DC power input in addition to the standard IEC mains inlet. The DC input is useful for portable and outside-broadcast applications, and the amp draws a modest 5A of current at full power! There are also various brackets and mounting kits available to fix the amps to the rear of any speaker, to a 1U rackmount shelf, or in a six-pack lump!
Listening Tests I have owned a pair of TB1S speakers for many years and use them when recording on location. Recently they were upgraded to the TB2+ spec with the soft-dome tweeters and crossovers. As already mentioned, Bryston Powerpac 120 amplifiers are bolted to their back panels and provide plenty of clean, articulate 'welly' to allow the monitors to deliver their best. As it happens, I also have a pair of DB1S speakers (with the original metal-dome tweeters) and a pair of stand-alone Flying Mole amplifiers which I use when editing — so all in all, there are sufficient elements to hand to provide valuable references and comparisons. The first thing to mention is the significant improvement wrought by the new tweeter and amended crossovers — to both the TB2 and DB1. The old metaldome tweeter was certainly no slouch, but the soft dome — which is admittedly a much more expensive device — has clear advantages in terms of the precision and naturalness of the high frequencies. The crossover changes that the new tweeter required have improved the mid-range resolution too. If the TB2 speaker rated at an eight out of 10 before, it's the full 10 out of 10 now, and the DB1 has benefited from a similar improvement in resolution. Furthermore, the matching of timbre and imaging is now almost flawless across the entire PMC range. I was able to compare the DB1SA and TB2SA not only with each other, but also directly against the larger LB1 twoway and huge IB1 three-way monitors. Aside from the inherent increases in headroom/SPL and bass extension (and the additional resolution of the three-way design), the sound character barely changed at all — which is a praiseworthy achievement.
The amplifier's audio I/O and mains connectors are on the underside of the amplifier pack, and a sturdy right-angled Speakon connector links the amplifier output with the speaker's crossover.
The Flying Mole amplifiers appear to defy the laws of physics — I can think of no other explanation! I compared the Flying Mole DADM100pro BI monobloc amplifier (see the 'Flying Mole Amplifier' box for more details) directly with the Bryston Powerpac 120 and found it hard to file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/PMC%20TB2SA%20&%20DB1SA.htm (5 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:51 PM
PMC TB2SA & DB1SA
tell the difference! The Bryston is large, heavy, and very expensive, while the Flying Mole is none of those things — and yet they produced near identical sound. Okay, so in the final analysis the Bryston retained the edge, with more headroom, better bass control and sustain, and the ability to convey transients and dynamic changes with an effortless ease that the Flying Mole couldn't quite equal. But without a direct A/B comparison it would be very hard to tell them apart. Not all Class-D designs are equal, and I share the view expressed by Peter Thomas that the Flying Mole amps are in a class of their own — the first switching amp that comes within a whisker of equalling the best analogue designs. Overall, then, the new Activated versions of the DB1 and TB2 are unqualified successes. All of the qualities of the original monitors have been retained — the superb bass extension and control, the consistent sound balance regardless of monitoring level, the vast three-dimensional sound stages, the wide sweet spot, and the neutral presentation with high levels of resolution. The '+' updates with the better tweeter and revised crossovers have improved mid-range and highfrequency resolution and accuracy, and have also made the sound character more consistent across the entire PMC range. The Flying Mole amps are the icing on the cake, matching a powerful, high-performance, high-resolution amplifier to the speaker to form a convenient, effective, and affordable package. The problem with passive speakers as good as PMC's is that they can reveal the failings of inadequate amplifiers just as easily as they can poor mixes or mic placement issues. Unfortunately, the cost of a really good amplifier often matches or exceeds that of the monitors, so the complete package can appear very expensive when compared to some of the active monitors aimed at the home-studio market. The Flying Mole amplifiers, whether in stand-alone form or fitted to the DB1SA and TB2SA, redress that balance very well, and allow the PMC monitors to deliver a superlative performance at a far more reachable price. It is hard to find fault with the combination in any way at all, and if you are in the market for good nearfield studio monitors, these Activated monitors make ideal reference points. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/PMC%20TB2SA%20&%20DB1SA.htm (6 of 6)9/27/2005 9:22:51 PM
Propellerhead Reason v3
In this article:
What's New A Remote Possibility Combinator MClass Mastering Suite Enhanced File Browser Bits & Pieces Conclusions
Propellerhead Reason v3 £299 pros Combinator. Full stop. Excellent mastering processing. Close integration with some hardware control surfaces. Expanded factory Refill collection.
Propellerhead Reason v3 Virtual Electronic Studio (Mac OS X/PC) Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Software
Astonishingly, Reason is now over four years old! Version 3 adds performance-enhancing features and mastering facilities, losing only Mac OS 9 support on the way. We bring you the first UK review of the full release version... Derek Johnson
cons More demanding of host computer. No new sound makers or audio recording. No real moves forward with the linear sequencer.
summary Live or in the studio, Reason remains top software, offering an enviable combination of great sound and value for money. Existing users, upgrade now!
information Reason v3 £299; upgrade from previous versions £69; upgrade from Reason Adapted £199. Prices include VAT. M Audio UK +44 (0)1923 204010. +44 (0)1923 204039. Click here to email www.maudio.co.uk www.propellerheads.se
An incremental software update is a milestone for most software, especially if it's a really popular package. When that software is Propellerhead's Reason — the yardstick by which other virtual studios are measured — there are plenty of users holding their breath. Reason's last update, to v2.5, was free and introduced a host of powerful new devices. The latest release, v3.0, doesn't initially seem to be in quite the same league (and it's not free!), but just a little investigation reveals that Propellerhead have enhanced their flagship package in some unexpected ways.
This overview provides a glimpse of the Reason rack with a modestly equipped Combinator installed — it takes up a lot of room!
If Reason is new to you, a quick recap is in order. Should you require more detail, check out some SOS back issues: Reason was first reviewed in March 2001, v2.0 surfaced in September 2002, and v2.5 made a splash in December 2003. In between, check out a 'Making The Most Of...' two-parter in November and December 2002, and have a gander at SOS's on-going Reason Notes column, which started 11 months ago.
Test Spec file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Propellerhead%20Reason%20v3.htm (1 of 8)9/27/2005 9:23:03 PM
Propellerhead Reason v3
PC REVIEW SYSTEM 3.06GHz Pentium 4 PC with 512MB of RAM running Windows XP. MAC REVIEW SYSTEM 450MHz Apple Mac G4 with 896MB of RAM running Mac OS v10.3.8. Propellerhead Reason version reviewed: v3.0.
For many readers, the ideal hardware electronic studio would be a mix of classic analogue synths, drum machines, step sequencers, samplers, effects units and an audio mixer. In essence, this is what Propellerhead took as their inspiration when developing Reason. Its on-screen representation of these elements houses them in a virtual rack and adds linear sequencing, automation and easily configurable real-time control from hardware control surfaces. It also offers a brilliantly elegant virtual jack-based interconnection system, a lot of knobs and sliders, and instant integration with a wide range of other software via the Rewire protocol. What it has never had is an audio input, either to audio tracks or the samplebased devices. I'll get the bad news over with now: this feature is still lacking in v3.0. Anyone requiring linear audio tracks needs a MIDI + Audio sequencer that supports Rewire to host Reason, and the creation of custom samples for importing into Reason sample players requires separate sample-acquisition and editing software.
What's New There are two major developments in v3.0. First of all, the new Combinator turns Reason into more of a real-time performance instrument than it has been before. Just like the 'performance' level of a workstation synth, this new instrument groups Reason devices into one super-device. You can layer and set up key and velocity splits, but that's just the beginning: unlike most workstation synths, Combinator puts no limits on the number or configuration of devices it holds, save those imposed by the host computer's CPU and RAM. It sits in the rack as one device, addressable from one MIDI sequencer track. In the past, Reason owners have been forced to go to great lengths to repurpose existing Reason devices to recreate the effects of integrated mastering processors. This is no longer necessary, thanks to v3's other major innovation: the new MClass collection offers four dedicated mastering processors, and they're really rather good. Other new features which we'll address shortly include a new, more accessible patch browser (see the box at the end of this article), built-in support for many hardware control surfaces, an enhanced linear sequencer, a neat little line mixer and improved sample handling. file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Propellerhead%20Reason%20v3.htm (2 of 8)9/27/2005 9:23:03 PM
The new Combinator turns Reason v3 into a super performance synth. Any device in the Reason rack can be combined, layered and controlled from one handy window. Here there are three Subtractor modules visible in the Combinator's programmer, with key splits, and three NN19s playing at different
Propellerhead Reason v3
velocity levels. Note the Modulation Routing window to the right.
Sadly, for some of us, there are changes of a less positive kind. Reason is now Mac OS X only — it ran quite well under Mac OS 9 until v2.5. It'll also only run on Windows XP and 2000; 98 and ME are no longer in the picture. Version 3.0 is much more demanding of its host computer, so although Propellerhead claim that the minimum specs are a G3 running Mac OS 10.2 or a 300MHz Pentium III, think of those as absolute minimums. Reason is much happier with faster processors (and tons of RAM). I was a little saddened that I wasn't able to audition demo songs on my aging Mac without crackles and audio dropouts, and even had to tweak the audio system of my 3GHz Pentium 4 laptop.
A Remote Possibility Reason is not known for being buggy — release versions usually work first time. A trawl around the Propellerhead web site, though, does reveal a problem with v3. Basically, the problem is with Keyboard Control (previously known as Keyboard Remote), the system whereby computer keys can be assigned to Reason functions. What has been discovered is that if you set up mappings and then change them, the mappings may change unpredictably and can occasionally cause the software to crash. The big problem is that making changes in a song, saving it, and then reloading it, could crash Reason. Songs with no mappings are problem-free. Propellerhead advise users to not make any Keyboard Control assignments in v3 until the problem has been solved. Visit the site for a full discussion of the issues, a strategy to minimise problems if you have made assignments, and await an update!
Combinator It was always frustrating, in earlier versions of Reason, to be presented with four incoming MIDI control busses (via the fixed 'Hardware Interface') that allowed real-time layering of four devices — there was no way to use these layers in the main sequencer except by a lot of messing around. The new Combinator changes all that, adding many performance-level features. A Combi — the name for the resulting agglomeration of devices — doesn't just layer sound-makers. It allows them to be played in their own key range or velocity-triggered layers, and you can add as many effects as you want, and integrate Matrix step sequencers or Redrum drum machines. Not only can the result be saved as a recallable patch, but all the virtual linkages between devices (audio, gate and virtual 'CV') are saved as part of that patch. As existing Reason users will know, even simple gate/CV links made within a single device cannot be saved, except in a full song. As you might expect, any links from inside a Combi to the rest of the Reason rack will not be saved in a patch. However, Combinator does have its own audio inputs, so if you create effect-only Combis, you'll have one of the most userdefinable multi-effects processors you've ever played with (at least in this price range!).
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Propellerhead%20Reason%20v3.htm (3 of 8)9/27/2005 9:23:03 PM
Propellerhead Reason v3
At its simplest, Combinator is reduced to a single rack strip, like any other Reason device, offering patch selection and name display, plus input and output level metering. Clicking a little arrow causes the Controller panel to fold out. The business end of Combinator, this panel offers four assignable rotary control knobs and four assignable buttons, plus pitch-bend and mod wheels. These controls can be assigned to any parameters in any device in the Combinator, so one knob or button can control one parameter on each of several devices if you wish. Two more buttons let you run all the pattern-based devices in the Combi (ideal for auditioning independently of the host song), and bypass any effects. One of the remaining two buttons folds out the Programmer, which lets you define key and velocity ranges for each sound generator in the Combi. It looks rather like the Remote Programmer on the NNXT sample player, and is logical and straightforward. Key ranges are shown by a tweakable bar under a mini All four MClass mastering processors nestled in their very own Combinator setup. keyboard, with an option to key in Of course, they can be used individually exact values. Velocity ranges are anywhere in the Reason rack. simply keyed in, and I did feel it might have been useful if there had been a more graphical way of showing a velocity-controlled layer than the shading effect applied to the layer's key range bar, though this would have required much more screen space. It would be handy to be able to apply a transposition setting to devices in this display (if you wanted to have key-split instruments playing in specific pitch ranges), and I'd quite like to see some sort of trigger delay option, so that devices play a fixed time value after a note-on. Devices appear in a list to the left of the keymap display, and highlighting a device allows you to access the Modulation Routing section for that device, to the right: the knobs and buttons on the controllers are assigned to device parameters here. The last Controller button — labelled 'Show Devices' — unfolds the Combinator even further, so that it shows all of the devices that have been loaded into it. Adding devices can be done in three ways. First of all, it's possible to highlight a group in the main rack and use the Edit menu's 'Combine' command. A Combi containing those devices is instantly created (Combinators can also be 'uncombined'). Devices can easily be added using the 'Create' menu or contextual menu option. And finally, any device in the rack can simply be dragged into the Combi. You can't drag one Combinator into another, though — doing so simply adds all the modules from the one you're dragging to the other. This is a nifty option, allowing you to combine, say, effects chains and layered synths in a new Combinator. However, the new devices added in this way tend to automatically link to any available inputs on the main Remix in your rack, if you
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Propellerhead%20Reason%20v3.htm (4 of 8)9/27/2005 9:23:03 PM
Propellerhead Reason v3
have one, rather than the mixer in the target Combinator. Each Combinator has a flexible audio routing system, consisting of two pairs of stereo input jacks and two pairs of stereo outs. Devices in a Combi are routed to a stereo pair labelled 'From Devices', and thence to the rack's main mixer from the pair labelled 'Combi Output'. Thus you can see a mixer is needed in most circumstances, to reduce the outputs from all the combined devices to a single stereo stream, whether you're combining synths, samplers and drum machines or the outs from a parallel effects setup. There is one area in which the devices in a Combinator are still dealt with on an individual basis: automation. Try to record a parameter change with your mouse for a device in a Combinator patch and it won't work. The only parameters that can be automated are the knobs, buttons and wheels of the Combinator's controller panel (plus aftertouch, breath control, sustain pedal and expression pedal). To automate the parameters of one of the devices, you have to assign that device to its own sequencer track. Combinator even has a collection of gate and CV connections: the four rotary Controller knobs can be assigned a CV from elsewhere in the Reason rack for programmable modulation, and sequencer control gate and CV inputs mean that a Combinator can be played by a Matrix pattern sequencer. Finally, I note that the rear panel of the Combinator Programmer is amusingly labelled 'TS8450 Touch Sensitive Display Unit. We wish, guys, we wish...
MClass Mastering Suite The four-strong MClass suite offers a mastering EQ, stereo imager, compressor and maximiser. Each is a full-sized device, with a full complement of controls. And to make it even easier for you, Propellerhead have made a Mastering Suite Combi available from the 'Create' menu; it has all four devices in it, and a collection of specific factory patches to start you off (see above). The MClass EQ is actually larger than the remaining three devices, to show off its curve display, a larger version of that used by the original half-rack PEQ2. The MClass EQ is worlds beyond that device, however, offering high and low shelving bands, two parametric bands, plus a 30Hz low-cut switch. The range of the EQ is quite impressive, with the low band operating from 30Hz. Though the high band tops out at 12kHz, both mid bands have a range of 39Hz to 20kHz. I was slightly disappointed to not be able to change EQ response by dragging the curve in the display, but that's just a personal thing! I can't be alone in playing with delays to increase the perceived width of mixes, so the dedicated MClass Stereo Imager is most welcome. Not only does this device control stereo width, but it operates on high and low frequency ranges independently, with user control over the crossover frequency, and offers
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Propellerhead%20Reason%20v3.htm (5 of 8)9/27/2005 9:23:03 PM
Propellerhead Reason v3
independent stereo outputs for each range. Solo controls let you check out the effect on each band.
The Micromix stereo six-channel mixer is a small addition to the Reason rack, but is nonetheless welcome.
It's great to see the MClass Compressor join the Reason family — unlike the original COMP01 device, it offers the facilities of a real compressor, such as standard or soft-knee operation (the more 'musical' compression), plus side-chain access for ducking and frequency-conscious processing (such as deessing). The control set is very traditional, with knobs for Input Gain, Threshold, Ratio (1:1 to Infinity:1), Attack (1 to 100ms) and Release (50 to 600ms), plus Makeup Gain, but there are a couple of surprises — the Release parameter has a programme-dependent option. If you enable this, the release time changes in response to the length of incoming peaks. And the rear panel houses a CV output which transmits a dynamic CV signal derived from the compressor's gain reduction. Lastly, the MClass Maximiser allows you to make your mixes as loud as possible without clipping. There's a large, detailed peak/VU meter display and control over input and output gain, with a three-way switched control over Attack and Release (Release again has an adaptive programme-dependent option, for a more natural-sounding result). A soft clipping control appears after the final gain stage, and enabling the 4ms look-ahead option lets the Maximiser examine audio before it's processed, and limit it if you wish.
Enhanced File Browser New for v3.0 is a reworked file-browser system, letting you more easily navigate your hard drive and any Reason-related files and Refills it might contain. The redesign lets you search for patches by name or type, and the database folders of earlier versions have been replaced by a sub-window called 'Locations' — in fact, the database folders from earlier versions will be placed in the Locations list when you upgrade. You can add any file location to this to make it easily accessible. One great new feature is in-browser auditioning of both samples and patches: as long as your master keyboard is routed to the device patches are being selected for, they can be played in the browser without loading first. A particularly welcome file-browsing option, available from the Create or contextual menu, is 'Create Device by Browsing Patches': you just pick the patch you want, and the device that plays it loads immediately, ready to go. As an extension of that idea, it's also possible to open the browser from one device and look for patches for any other device; select another device's patch, and it will automatically replace the original device.
Bits & Pieces The MClass suite is fab — I've already imported a couple of mixes into NN19, just to process them with these effects — but there is still more. One further file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Propellerhead%20Reason%20v3.htm (6 of 8)9/27/2005 9:23:03 PM
Propellerhead Reason v3
device has been added to the rack: the Micromix stereo line mixer. While it's ideal as a sub-mixer inside Combis, it has, of course, a life elsewhere in the rack. Many of us have been using v2.5's Spider audio device as a simple audio mixer/ combiner, and will welcome the option to add a bit of panning and an effect send for more demanding applications that don't require the facilities or CPU overhead of the full-blown Remix module. Each of Micromix's six channels is equipped with a stereo input jack pair, mute and solo buttons, and level, pan and a single pre/post fader stereo aux send (to suit the stereo input of the RV7000 advanced reverb device). There's even space for a miniature LED bar-graph level meter, scribble strip and (rear-panel) CV control for the pan parameter. Other changes are more subtle. A new Preferences page labelled 'Control Surfaces and Keyboards' helps you select the hardware controllers you The new Preferences window, where MIDI intend to use, and the software control surfaces and your master keyboard are selected and assigned. communicates instantly with many current examples, complete with readymade mappings of controllers to Reason parameters. Multiple controllers can be used if you need to control more than one device at once. There's even a 'MIDI Out' element to the MIDI routing for controllers, but this link is solely for controllers that require bi-directional MIDI connections, like moving-fader surfaces — there's no way to send MIDI note data outside Reason this way. Another MIDI enhancement affects the main linear sequencer: it's possible to record automation to several tracks at once, though you can still only record one note-based MIDI performance at a time. The sequencer itself benefits from a bit of tidying up: it now has sensible Mute and Solo buttons, a much clearer 'MIDI In' indicator column, and record-enable switching. There are no major new editing options, though, and neither is there a tempo track yet, nor a score display. The two supplied Refills (Orkester and the Factory Sound Bank) have been enhanced and enlarged — they both now total 1.22GB in size, and take advantage of new features such as the Combinator and the MClass processors. Some of the stacks and layers sound fabulous! Refill installation now occurs as part of the overall installation, too. The fab Electro Mechanical Refill added some months ago is not part of the Reason v3 package, but is still a free download for registered users. At the other end of the process from installation — bouncing a finished mix to disk — dithering has been added to the audio export options, and sample load times for Redrum, NNXT and NN19 have been sped up. file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Propellerhead%20Reason%20v3.htm (7 of 8)9/27/2005 9:23:03 PM
Propellerhead Reason v3
Conclusions As ever, I had a ball with Reason. It's just so much fun to work with, and the new features enhance that feeling. You'll never want to be without Combinator again, and the mastering suite really is in a (n M) Class of its own. Overall, the software remains the one to beat just for sheer facilities and user-friendliness. To temper this slightly, I'm not so delighted about the way v3 will only run on upto-date operating systems and exhibits sluggishness on older computers, even with simple Songs. Perhaps Propellerhead are readying their software for some as-yet unrevealed features. Furthermore, my own bias is towards sound sources, and there are no new ones in this update (although admittedly Combinator offers a powerful way of applying what's already there). And Reason remains a closed zone to plug-ins, so you can't add any yourself. I also have a soft spot for arpeggiators, and no matter how existing devices can be pulled together to create arpeggiator-like effects, it's not the real thing! Finally, there will always be users who wish audio recording was available, and that goes for me too, if only to see how Propellerhead's engineers would present the feature. But as much as I try to play devil's advocate with Reason, it remains the music software I use most. Whenever I feel nostalgic for all the old synths and effects units my studio no longer has to accommodate, I fire up Reason, and I'm in the future. Now. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Propellerhead%20Reason%20v3.htm (8 of 8)9/27/2005 9:23:03 PM
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD
In this article:
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD
Case & Connections RME ADI4 DD: AES-ADAT A-D/D-A Converter & Digital Published in SOS May 2005 Digital Format Converter Front-panel Controls Print article : Close window Technology & Specifications Reviews : A-D/D-A Converter Audible Benefits
Format Converter
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD £445/£455 pros Flexible analogue operating levels and excellent clocking performance for the ADI2. AES, S/PDIF, and ADAT formats supported. 24-bit capability and elevated sample rates.
Two new half-rack boxes offer considerable operational flexibility and pristine sound in both the analogue and digital domains. Hugh Robjohns
cons
I have reviewed several RME hardware products in the past, and have always been impressed with the summary high audio quality they seem able to The ADI2 is a compact but provide despite their very moderate high-performance twopricing. Recent technological channel A-D and D-A converter with useful I/O developments have made this qualityflexibility. Improved clock Photos: Mark Ewing price ratio even more favourable, with circuitry helps bestow classsome impressive advances in wordleading technical performance clock stability which are claimed to put the latest-generation of RME converters in which belies its modest Apogee territory in this regard — an intriguing thought! pricing. The ADI4 DD offers In-line mains PSU modules.
flexible format-conversion and routing options, and could be the ideal solution for anyone facing format incompatibilities.
information ADI2, £445; ADI4 DD, £455. Prices include VAT. Synthax Audio UK +44 (0)1664 410600. +44 (0)1664 410999. Click here to email www.rme-audio.com
One of the latest RME offerings is the ADI2, a relatively straightforward twochannel A-D/D-A converter housed in a half-width 1U rack case. In essence, it is a development of the previous ADI1 which I reviewed way back in SOS August 1999, sharing a similar (but updated and extended) feature set and mechanical footprint. Technological advances have been incorporated to support 24-bit conversion and all standard sample rates up to 192kHz, with significantly improved jitter rejection.
Case & Connections The case of the ADI2 is constructed from three folded-steel panels to provide a very strong and fully screened enclosure for the internal circuitry. The front panel is made from aluminium sections, using blue-painted panel areas and clear silver
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/RME%20ADI2%20&%20ADI4%20DD.htm (1 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:08 PM
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD
legends to highlight the various controls. The rear panel is painted black with large white legends, and the connections are all very obvious. The analogue linelevel inputs to the A-D are catered for with Neutrik combi jack/XLR sockets, accepting either XLR or TRS connectors. The input circuitry employs clever 'servo amplifiers' that can accommodate balanced or unbalanced signals equally well, automatically compensating for the 6dB lower signal level that can otherwise occur when connecting an unbalanced signal to an electronically balanced input. The unit can be configured from the front panel for one of three operating levels, where 0dBFS (digital peak) equates to +19dBu, +13dBu, or +4dBu. These are designed for compatibility with professional high-level, standard +4dBu, and semiprofessional -10dBV equipment respectively. The first two options effectively just change the available headroom from 15dB to 9dB (relative to +4dBu), while the third reduces the sensitivity to accommodate the lower semi-pro operating levels. In this case, the stated +4dBu peak level equates to +2dBV, thus offering a nominal 12dB of headroom above -10dBV. The A-D's digital output is presented on both a coaxial phono connector and a Toslink optical port, although you can choose different data formats — a frontpanel selector enables the output format to be switched between Consumer (S/ PDIF), Pro (AES), and ADAT. The phono connector is used to output S/PDIF or AES data: changing the format from Consumer to Pro increases the signal level (from 0.8V to 2.3V peak-to-peak) and changes the status flags to comply with the relevant standards. The phono socket is electrically isolated from the chassis and connected via a transformer so that it is fully floating. Thus, a properly balanced AES output can be obtained simply by wiring the tip and sleeve of a phono plug to pins two and three of an XLR plug respectively. Valid audio data appears to be present at this output regardless of whether the optical socket is configured for Pro/Consumer or ADAT operation. All sample rates are catered for up to 192kHz, using the single-wire double- or quad-speed transmission method which is now more or less the standard. The optical output can be switched between S/PDIF or ADAT modes from the front panel, but at standard sample rates only channels one and two carry the data, the other six channels being mute. However, at the doubled sample rates the widely supported SMux data format is used, so that the first two channel pairs are used to convey the AD's stereo signal. Surprisingly, no audio output is provided at all at the quad rates, although a standard-rate embedded word clock is still conveyed in case the ADAT signal is being used for clocking purposes, which is a thoughtful feature. Moving over to the D-A side of things, digital inputs are catered for once again with a phono socket and a Toslink optical input. The data format arriving at each
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/RME%20ADI2%20&%20ADI4%20DD.htm (2 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:08 PM
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD
connector is detected and decoded automatically, but a front-panel selection determines which input is used to feed the D-A (and act as external clock reference, when appropriate). Again, the phono socket is electrically isolated from the chassis and connected via a transformer so that balanced AES signals can be accommodated with a suitable converter lead wired in the same way as described earlier for the AES output. The line-level analogue outputs are provided on both XLRs and TRS sockets, featuring the same kind of servo amplifier idea so that the correct signal level is maintained regardless of whether the output is connected to balanced or unbalanced equipment. As with the input-sensitivity selection, a front-panel control allows the output level to be switched between the same three settings, giving peak signal levels of +19dBu, +13dBu, or +4dBu (+2dBV). The ADI2, like its predecessor, is too compact to allow a mains power supply to be incorporated, so a coaxial power connector is present on the rear panel, complete with a metal hoop through which the power lead can be threaded to prevent it falling out if accidentally tugged. Like many other RME products, this unit is remarkably flexible in its powering options. It can accept DC supplies between 8V and 28V DC (of either polarity), or low-voltage AC supplies between 8V and 20V AC. So battery powering from a range of sources is perfectly viable. A compact third-party mains power unit is also included in the package, and this can accept mains voltages between 100V and 240V AC at 50Hz or 60Hz, to produce a 12V DC output suitable for powering the ADI2.
RME ADI4 DD: AES-ADAT Digital Format Converter The RME ADI4 DD has been designed to translate between arguably the two most common digital interface formats, AES and ADAT; and to do this in both directions with up to 24-bit word lengths and sample rates up to 96kHz. Much of the functionality can be assumed from a glimpse of the rear panel, although there are several hidden features that only become apparent after reading the comprehensive manual (supplied as a PDF file on a CD-ROM). So, first let's look at the rear panel. Two XLRs provide a pair of AES (or S/PDIF) channels in and out, and these are supplemented with a 25-pin D-Sub connector which duplicates that first pair of channels and adds three more pairs. (In other words, there are eight channels in and out altogether.) Each AES input and output is transformer coupled and can operate in single- or dual-wire modes up to 96kHz. There are numerous wiring formats for AES signals on D-Sub connectors — Yamaha, Tascam, Euphonix, and Genex are just four that come immediately to mind. However, the RME designers have been remarkably helpful by allowing the user to re-configure the ADI4 DD to operate correctly with any of the first three listed above. Inside the case a ribbon cable can be plugged into one of three sockets, re-configuring the D-Sub to suit the Tascam, Yamaha, or Euphonix house standards, respectively. For this review, I re-configured the unit from the default Tascam setting to the Yamaha convention, to interface directly with my equipment. Above the D-Sub connector, a BNC socket accepts an external word clock,
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/RME%20ADI2%20&%20ADI4%20DD.htm (3 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:08 PM
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD
complete with a 75(omega) termination switch and LED indicator. A word-clock output BNC is also provided. Power is connected through a coaxial socket with similar AC/DC voltage flexibility as provided on the ADI2, and an in-line switchedmode mains PSU is also provided. Finally, the first of two pairs of Toslink optical connectors supply dedicated ADAT inputs and outputs, with the second pair being switchable between S/PDIF and ADAT formats. There are only four buttons on the front panel, the first of which selects the source for the first pair of AES channels, the options being the XLR, the first two channels of the D-Sub, or the S/PDIF optical connector. The next panel section carries an array of LEDs indicating clock status and audio data — each AES input has its own pair of LEDs, and two more pairs cater for the two optical inputs. Another LED illuminates when double-rate AES inputs are detected. Next up are buttons to select the clock source (external word clock, ADAT, or AES) and to convert SMux ADAT inputs to double-rate AES outputs. Finally, the AES outputs can be configured to operate with professional or consumer (S/PDIF) voltage levels and data flags, and the second Toslink socket switched to provide S/PDIF data. The 'hidden' features provided by the ADI4 DD include the ability to convert four channels between 'double wide' and 'double speed' data formats (in both directions); the facility to split incoming eight-channel AES or ADAT data to both eight-channel ADAT outputs; and the option to function as a 'two input to eight output' AES splitter. This is a very well engineered and flexible little box that may well provide the ideal solution to anyone facing format incompatibilities.
Front-panel Controls Having completed the geek's tour of the connectors, the front panel needs little explanation, as most of the facilities have already been mentioned. There are only five buttons, a rotary control, and a quarter-inch stereo headphone socket to master — although the 31 LEDs make it look a little more complex than it really is! Starting at the left-hand side, the first button cycles through the three inputlevel options, each with a green LED to indicate the current setting. Next up is a vertical bar graph meter with two columns of six LEDs, showing the A-D's digital output level. The bottom four lights are green, followed by a yellow and a red LED, and the ensemble is scaled -60, -30, -12, -6, -3 and 'Over' (although, strictly, this is not an 'over' warning at all since it can only indicate digital signals reaching 0dBFS.) The meter is actually a lot more informative than this description implies, as each LED has several intensities which help to bridge the gaps between adjacent LED levels. AT the bottom end, signals as low as 76dBFS can be identified, while, at the top, peaks of -2dBFS or -1dBFS are easily distinguished. Only signal peaks that actually hit 0dBFS cause the peakhold function to activate, maintaining the red LED's illumination for one second to attract attention. The central section of the front panel is concerned with clock-rate and I/O selections. The first button cycles through the clocking functions, with six LEDs to indicate the status. There are three internal crystal-based sample-rate options — 32kHz, 44.1kHz, and 48kHz — followed by an external sample rate derived from the selected digital input. Further pushes of the button cycle through these four file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/RME%20ADI2%20&%20ADI4%20DD.htm (4 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:08 PM
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD
options again, but with a 'x2' multiplier for the internal rates, and then again with a 'x4' multiplier. So getting to 192kHz is a tedious process, but simple enough and with clear indications along the way. The next two buttons configure the digital I/O, the first selecting the coaxial or optical digital input, and the second configuring the digital outputs for ADAT, Pro, or Consumer formats, as described earlier. Once again, LEDs indicate which input connectors and output modes have been chosen. The last button selects one of three analogue output levels, again with LEDs to show the current status. The final control is a rotary volume knob for the built-in headphone monitor which auditions the output from the D-A converter. The quarter-inch socket sits alongside the control for easy access, and there is sufficient 'oompf' from the amplifier to enable this output to be used to drive unbalanced line inputs, should that ever become necessary.
Technology & Specifications The earlier ADI1 employed 20-bit Crystal and AKM converters and operated at only the standard sample rates — although this was the state of the art for 'budget' converters back then. Such limitations wouldn't be countenanced these days, of course, and it is interesting to see just how far RME have evolved in the intervening six years. The current unit uses the latest high-resolution AKM chips: the 5385 A-D and 4395 D-A converters (the latter with built-in automatic deemphasis facilities in the unlikely event that they are needed). The analogue side of things appears to be handled by the ubiquitous 4580 op amps, in the same circuit topology as used in several other RME products including the previous ADI1 and the flagship ADI8DS (reviewed back in SOS September 2003). All of the unit's control functions, as well as the audio data manipulation and formatting, are handled by a Xilinx Spartan IIE FPGA Three different pin-out configurations for the (Field Programmable Gata Array). ADI4 DD's digital D-Sub connector are Everything has been put together very supported, as used by Tascam, Yamaha, nicely, on one fairly dense printed and Euphonix. You can change the format by circuit board using mainly surfacere-plugging an internal ribbon cable. mount components. The front-panel LEDs and buttons are mounted on a second vertical card, linked via a ribbon cable. All the rear-panel connectors are soldered directly to the main board, but are fixed to the rear panel to help minimise any mechanical strain being conveyed to the PCB connections. The published specs make impressive reading, with an A-D signal-to-noise ratio file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/RME%20ADI2%20&%20ADI4%20DD.htm (5 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:08 PM
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD
of 113dBA and distortion below 0.0003 percent. The D-A boasts a signal-to-noise figure of 119dBA and distortion below 0.0007 percent. Compared to the ADI1, the signal-to-noise ratios are nearly four times better, and the distortion has improved by an order of magnitude! Perhaps even more impressive are the jitter figures, which are roughly half that of any comparable product — less than 0.8ns on the internal crystal and only 1ns when slaved to an external clock reference, with around 30dB of jitter suppression from wobbly external sources! Apparently the Steady Clock technology that provides these impressive results was developed originally to recover stable clocks from the multi-channel version of the AES interface — MADI — which typically suffers a monumental 80ns of jitter!
Audible Benefits The ADI2 is a very straightforward and compact unit, the simplicity (and comparatively low UK price) of which belies its superb quality. This really is a star performer which compared favourably against my trusty Apogee PSX100, as well as the rather nice converters in the Drawmer DC2476 mastering processor. Noise and distortion are completely inaudible, even when working with generous headroom; the audio spectrum is open and airy (especially at the double and quadruple sample rates); and the stereo imaging is three-dimensional and completely stable — always the sign of a good clock — with wide and deep sound stages. The only relevant negative comment I could raise is that the low bass seems a little thin when compared to some more expensive converters — but you have to move a very long way up the price scale before the RME's inevitable shortcomings start to become noticeable at all. Leaving the sonic merits to one side, the ADI2 has some practical limitations compared to many state-of-the-art converters. For example, the A-D and D-A stages can't be used as completely separate units, running at different clock rates; the output cannot be dithered down to lower word lengths to suit CD-R and DAT recorders; there is no external word-clock input (separate from that embedded in the digital inputs); and there is no 'soft-limiting' facility to minimise peak overloads when working with minimal headroom. However, these features are not important — let alone necessary — to the vast majority of semi-pro users in our modern 24-bit world. On the plus side, the I/O flexibility in terms of connections, formats, and operating levels is excellent, the simplicity of configuration a joy, the built-in headphone monitoring a useful facility, and the cost-performance ratio astounding. I'm not a fan of in-line or wall-wart power supplies, but given the sonic and fiscal benefits of this unit, I feel pleasantly disposed to overlook such a minor issue! Published in SOS May 2005
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/RME%20ADI2%20&%20ADI4%20DD.htm (6 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:08 PM
RME ADI2 & ADI4 DD
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/RME%20ADI2%20&%20ADI4%20DD.htm (7 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:08 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
In this article:
Previous SOS Fantom Reviews The Synthesizer Keyboard Fantoms Compared The Sampler The Sequencer In Use The Fantom Editor Conclusions
Roland Fantom Xa Workstation Synth Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Keyboard workstation
At £1099, the Xa is the most affordable keyboard in the Fantom range. But inevitably, features have been Roland Fantom Xa £1099 removed to make it such a bargain. Have Roland pros thrown out the works from the workstation? The cheapest Fantom keyboard to date. Still an extremely powerful synth. Built-in sampler, expandable to 516MB of RAM. Many additional facilities, such as arpeggiators, chord generators, rhythm patterns, and more. Included Editor makes it a pleasure to program. Sounds superb.
Gordon Reid
The Fantom Xa is the eighth model to appear in Roland's Fantom range of workstations and is, with the exception of the Fantom XR rack module, also the cheapest. To achieve this, many of the facilities found on the other Fantoms have been removed. In principle, this makes it immediately cons attractive, but in some ways it's clearly Lower-quality keyboard than less powerful than its forebears. any other Fantom. Much smaller display than on previous Fantoms. Only one SRX expansion slot. Sampler still has limitations of previous models. Non-touch-sensitive sample pads. Outdated effects structure. External power supply.
Photos: Mike Cameron
Most obviously, the 320x240-pixel colour screen of the X-series has gone, to be replaced by a 240x64-pixel greyscale screen. Ironically, given that this is the first Fantom keyboard to sport a small LCD, the soft-keys and the on-screen commands now line up perfectly. There's even a bit of panel artwork to ensure that you notice this (on all previous Fantoms, the buttons and commands were offset from one another). Reducing the screen resolution by 80 percent is a significant change, but, thanks to a cleverly implemented set of zoom pages for graphical displays and grid representations for programming, I was generally able to obtain the results I wanted on the Xa itself.
summary Like its siblings, the Fantom Xa is a well-specified combination of an expanded XV synth engine, an MRC Pro sequencer, and 'groove'-style sampling, with oodles of
Gone too are the likeable semi-weighted keyboards of the Fantom S, X6 and X7. Roland have removed the weights from underneath the keys, which makes the keyboard feel springy and unpleasant, and they've also removed pressure sensitivity. Peculiarly, although the keyboard can't generate aftertouch, the keyboard's real-time controllers can be assigned to do so, and the Xa will both
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (1 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
extras such as userprogrammable arpeggiation, rhythm patterns, and an included software Editor. However, it lacks several of the niceties of previous Fantoms, the removal of which has made it both cheaper but also less usable for some players. I suspect that it will be seen as an good price/performance compromise for cashstrapped, dance-oriented musicians and producers, and that it will be a success.
information £1099 including VAT. Roland UK +44 (0)1792 515020. +44 (0)1792 799644. www.roland.co.uk www.roland.com
transmit and respond to channel aftertouch. Even more peculiarly (and perhaps as a leftover trait from the full X-series workstations), the sequencer can also generate polyphonic aftertouch. This implies that the Xa will respond to polyaftertouch generated internally or received over MIDI, but I can't find any modulation destination that responds to it. In short, Roland have made the Xa unsuitable for piano and, to a lesser extent, orchestral playing. Given that the Xa still costs over a thousand pounds, this is rather disappointing, unless you view a keyboard as a set of buttons for triggering arpeggios and patterns. But perhaps this is in keeping with some of the more Groovebox-like aspects of the Xa. For example, some of the X-series' PCMs appear to have been replaced with drum and percussion samples aimed squarely at dance music production, and then there are the illuminated pads on the right-hand side of the panel, introduced on the Fantom S. The Xa has 10 of these compared to the S- and X-series' 16, but they can still operate as drum pads, as well as triggers for other features such as Real-Time Phrase Sequences, rhythm patterns, and samples. This all seems to be... well, Groovy. In the past, I have complimented Roland on focusing products at their target markets, and in this light, the more 'dancy' sounds make sense — you just need to be aware that if you're after an orchestral or rock & roll synth, the Xa is perhaps less suitable than previous Fantoms. But groove instruments still need to be capable of expression, and the Xa's 10 pads not only lack the poly-aftertouch of the previous incarnations, they are not capable of outputting any aftertouch. Nor are they velocity sensitive; you can set up fixed MIDI velocities for each, or a common velocity for them all. In fact, the pads have been reduced to the role of mere switches, not the sensitive performance controls they were. Further casualties of the transition to the Fantom Xa include expandability and the S and X-series' internal power supplies. The Xa has just a single SRX card expansion slot, and an external 9V AC/DC converter (boo!). Despite all this, though, there's still much to be praised...
Previous SOS Fantom Reviews Much has already been written in Sound On Sound about the Fantom series, so I suggest you take a look back at Nick Magnus's review of the Fantom S and S88 (in Sound On Sound October 2003: see www.soundonsound.com/sos/oct03/ articles/rolandfantoms.htm), and Paul Nagle's review of the 'X' series (in Sound On Sound September 2004: see www.soundonsound.com/sos/sep04/articles/ rolandfantomx.htm) and the original FA76 (SOS February 2002: see www. soundonsound.com/sos/feb02/articles/fantom0202.asp). In many ways, the Xa is identical to these, so if I appear to have skipped over something in these pages, the chances are that it's already been covered in Nick's and Paul's previous articles.
The Synthesizer file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (2 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
As far as the sound engine is concerned, the Xa retains the maximum polyphony of 128 voices and the 16-part multitimbrality of the rest of the 'X' series, but the ROM has shrunk back to the 'S' specification, with 1228 PCM waveforms rather than the full complement of 1480. Lest you think that this is a problem... it isn't. The Fantom S was and remains a phenomenally powerful synth, and I defy anybody to plumb fully the depths of the Xa's ROM, its 10 types of patch structure, its cross-modulation (FM) capabilities, the boosters, the ring modulators, the hugely flexible modulators and modulation matrix, and the many, many ways that patches can be modified with up to six (reasonably) assignable effects units. The number of programmable memories is the same as on other Xs, with 256 patch memories, 32 programmable rhythm sets and 64 Performance memories in addition to the usual bucketful of presets. But the Xa's bucket is smaller than that of the other Xs — there are 768 preset patches rather than 1024, and 36 Unlike on all previous Fantoms, the 'soft' rhythm sets rather than 40. Happily, keys beneath the LCD line up with the onthe number of effects algorithms and screen functions they access! It's a shame that this also happens to be the Fantom with the MFX architecture remain the smallest display, but you can't have unchanged from the rest of the X everything... series. This means that there are 78 algorithms including COSM (Composite Object Sound Modelling) and RSS (Roland Sound Space) effects. Unfortunately, it also means that Roland's aging MFX/chorus/reverb system is retained. Flexible though this is, it's dropping further and further behind the flexible Insert and Master effects structures being used on other companies' workstations, and it's time that it was replaced. Like the 'S' and 'X' series, the Xa also has a three-band compressor/limiter placed across its main outputs, which Roland call the 'Mastering Effect'. Threeband compressors like these are becoming ubiquitous on hard disk editors as well as keyboard workstations, but I think that unless they're used with great care and subtlety, they can do more harm than good — and they're certainly no match for the handiwork of a good mastering engineer. Still, you don't have to use them! Also unchanged from the Fantom S spec, the Xa offers the full complement of rhythm patterns and memories, as well as preset and user-programmable arpeggios. Nevertheless, some functions have been lost, and not just because the hardware has changed. For example, the 'Live Setting' section of the full Xseries instruments is gone (which is strange, given the performance orientation of the Xa) as is the ability to use the pads to jump to favourite edit screens, and the voice monitor that showed how the polyphony was used. But when it comes to the crunch, the patch, performance, and effects structures of the Xa are all but identical to those of a full 'X', so we need say no more about them here.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (3 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
Keyboard Fantoms Compared FA76
S & S88
X SERIES
XA
—
61-note semiweighted (S)
61-note semiweighted (X6)
61-note unweighted
76-note semiweighted
—
76-note semiweighted (X7)
—
—
88-note 88-note — hammer-action hammer-action (S88) (X8)
VELOCITY SENSITIVE?
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
PRESSURE SENSITIVE?
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
DISPLAY
320x240 mono 320x240 mono 320x240 LCD LCD colour LCD
240x64 mono LCD
PADS
None
16
16
10
MAXIMUM POLYPHONY
64
64
128
128
MULTITIMBRALITY
16 parts
16 parts
16 parts
16 parts
ROM SIZE
64MB equivalent
64MB equivalent
128MB equivalent
64MB equivalent
NUMBER OF WAVEFORMS
1083
1228
1480
1228
EXPANSION (SR JV TYPE)
1 slot
None
None
None
EXPANSION (SRX TYPE)
2 slots
4 slots
4 slots (6 slots in XR)
1 slot
PRESET MEMORY
640 Patches
640 Patches
1024 Patches
768 Patches
256 GM2 Patches
256 GM2 Patches
256 GM2 Patches
256 GM2 Patches
KEYBOARD
16 rhythm sets 32 rhythm sets 40 rhythm sets 36 rhythm sets
USER MEMORY
CARD MEMORY
9 GM2 rhythm sets
9 GM2 rhythm sets
9 GM2 rhythm sets
9 GM2 sets
64 Performances
64 Performances
64 Performances
64 Performances
—
8 piano Patches (S88 only)
—
—
128 Patches
256 Patches
256 Patches
256 Patches
16 Rhythm Sets
32 Rhythm Sets
32 Rhythm Sets
32 Rhythm Sets
64 Performances
64 Performances
64 Performances
64 Performances
—
Smart Media slot (up to 128MB)
PC card slot (up to 1GB)
PC card slot (up to 1GB)
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (4 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
EFFECTS
3 MFX slots, 90 types
3 MFX slots: 77 types (78 on S88)
3 MFX slots: 78 types
3 MFX slots: 78 types
Global chorus: Global chorus: Global chorus: Global chorus: 2 types 3 types 3 types 3 types Global reverb: 4 types
Global reverb: 5 types
Global EQ
Input effects: 6 Input effects: 6 Input effects: 6 types types types
—
Mastering effects: compressor
Mastering effects: compressor
Mastering effects: compressor
—
16-bit linear, 44.1kHz
16-bit linear, 44.1kHz
16-bit linear, 44.1kHz
—
File type: WAV File type: WAV File type: WAV & AIFF & AIFF & AIFF
SAMPLE MEMORY
—
32MB 32MB 4MB standard standard (up to standard (up to (up to 516MB) 288MB) 544MB)
SEQUENCER
Tracks: 16
Tracks: 16
Tracks: 16
Tracks: 16
100 patterns
100 patterns
100 patterns
100 patterns
Resolution: 480ppqn
Resolution: 480ppqn
Resolution: 480ppqn
Resolution: 480ppqn
Capacity: 120,000 notes
Capacity: 120,000 notes
Capacity: 400,000 notes
Capacity: 400,000 notes
88 preset, 0 user
128 preset, 128 user
128 preset, 128 user
128 preset, 128 user
RHYTHM PATTERNS 50 preset, 0 user
256 preset, 256 user
256 preset, 256 user
256 preset, 256 user
CHORD MEMORY
64 preset, 64 user
64 preset, 64 user
64 preset, 64 user
SAMPLING
ARPEGGIATOR
—
Global reverb: 5 types
Global reverb: 5 types
The Sampler Apart from the loss of the user interface supported by the large screens of previous models, and the lack of the other Fantom Xs' digital inputs, sampling on the Xa appears to be largely unchanged from the 'S' and 'X' series. The means of accessing it is different (there's no Input Setting button, either), but the basis is the same. You can sample, import WAVs and AIFFs, truncate, loop, normalise, amplify sections, stretch, chop and recombine to your heart's content. I particularly like the Auto Divide function, which breaks samples up at moments of near silence and assigns the next sample number to the ensuing audio. This is an elegant way to sample sources such as drum kits, but I also find it excellent for resampling phrases played on the Xa itself. I am less enamoured of the sampling input effects; I'd rather apply effects after sampling, and thereby use the more sophisticated MFX algorithms. It's nice to see skip-back sampling here, though — once you get used to this, you'll never want to work any other way. Introduced on the Fantom S and retained on the Xa, this feature simply means that the sampler is continually recording whatever you present to its input. If you
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (5 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
like something that you hear, you can save it even though you haven't told the sampler to start sampling. The Xa's sampler lacks a couple of features that I really miss. Alt (bi-directional) looping is one; I use this extensively on my S700-series samplers. It would be simple to implement this on a processor as powerful as the one in the Xa, so why haven't Roland done it? Secondly, the Xa is still unable to import existing multisamples correctly. Overcoming this by converting and loading individual samples, re-looping and then re-allocating them to the keyboard is too longwinded for words. Just as I was finishing this article, Roland resolved this problem for the rest of the Fantom X series, but the fix does not work on the Xa — see the box on page 60.
The Sequencer The Xa's sequencer appears to be identical to that of the other Fantom Xs, with 16 channels, each of which can hold data across all 16 MIDI channels. Song data can be directed to the internal sound engine, to external MIDI products, or to both simultaneously, and live 'mutes' allow you to inspect what's doing what to what. All the expected editing and MIDI data manipulation tools are included, but I won't list them all; if you know the way that Roland write sequencing software, you'll know what's here. Nevertheless, one facility deserves special mention; the provision of 71 templates for quantising and 'shuffling' selected data in various musical styles. That's an excellent touch. You can only edit songs in a 'temporary' area that's lost on powerdown, so you have to save your work at the end of each session. Four formats are supported, these being SVQ (the format used by all of Roland's recent MRC Pro sequencers), the older standard MRC format, and Standard MIDI File (format 0 and format 1). If you save a song in SVQ format, the resulting files can include the performance/setup data as well as any associated samples. The sequencer is powerful, but I feel that this is the area that suffers most from the loss of the larger 'S' and 'X' screens. Real-time recording is a doddle, and the step-time recording and editing is well implemented given the limited amount of screen space available, but much of the operating file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (6 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
There's no digital I/O on the Fantom Xa, but otherwise, there's a fine complement of I/O and facilities, including Expression and Sustain pedal jacks, five-pin MIDI In, Out, and Thru, a Headphones socket, stereo master analogue inputs with an associated input level control, and stereo master analogue outputs on jacks with two further independent outs. Out of shot, to the left of what you can see in this picture, are the power switch and DC In connection to the external PSU, the PC card slot, and the USB socket for connecting a computer and/or the software editor.
Roland Fantom Xa
system is text-based. This won't be a problem if you're used to working with older Roland sequencers, or other keyboard workstations, but if you have always used computer-based sequencers, and you're accustomed to large, graphical representations of controllers and other data, you may find it difficult to come to terms with the Xa's operation. If you're not comfortable using the sequencer in a linear mode, you may enjoy the provision of short sequences called 'phrases' that you allocate to pattern memories and then trigger to build tracks and songs. I'm not a fan of phrase sequencers on 'pro' instruments because the philosophy feels too similar to that of auto-accompaniment keyboards. But if you're tempted by this way of working, the Xa offers everything that you need. You can trigger and loop patterns by pressing a single note or pad, and combine up to eight of them simultaneously to create music that you couldn't play 'live' with just two hands. You can also include the patterns within longer sequences.
In Use Given the clear focus of the Xa on dance music and Roland's proven expertise in this area, it's not surprising that it excels in creating and manipulating all manner of beats and grooves. The step LFOs, arpeggiated patterns and synchronised rhythms make the Xa an instant groovebox — the Xa's sales blurb even speaks of 'instant dancefloor inspiration'. Of course, the danger with these kinds of sounds is that they can quickly become last summer's craze, unless you're prepared to delve deeper than the presets. On the other hand, the list of percussion samples, rhythm sounds and patterns listed at the back of the manual is huge, so there's plenty of scope for you to plough your own furrow. Of course, there is also a superb selection of lead sounds, pads, guitars, organs, and orchestral instruments, so the Xa is capable of acting as a first-class expander. Unfortunately, I found that layering my patches in a Performance led to a great deal of note stealing as the polyphony dropped. This is because, while the Fantom has a maximum polyphony of 128 notes, this is obtainable only if you restrict every sound to a single, monophonic PCM. If you use the full XV-engine capabilities in patch mode, the polyphony drops to just 32 notes. If you then start to layer patches, the polyphony can drop to 16, 10, eight or even fewer notes. So, while you may have 128 individual tones available, it is how you use them that will define the polyphony. Of course, this limitation is not unique to Roland's workstations and, to their credit, they explain it in the manual. Furthermore, to minimise the unpleasant side-effects of note-stealing, they have introduced an innovative note priority mode called 'Loudest'. With this selected, the quietest of the current notes is silenced, rather than the oldest, or the highest, or the lowest. This is an excellent innovation. Whichever types of sounds you use, the Xa provides a great deal of control, both over the patches themselves and the effects that you apply to them. You can file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (7 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
assign MIDI CCs to patch parameters and effects, apply MIDI aftertouch using the knobs or a control pedal (not the same thing, I know), and assign the real-time knobs and the D-Beam to a huge variety of destinations, either directly or via a control matrix. If you're prepared to take the time and trouble, you can create some amazing textures by modulating the initial patch and effects combination. I found Solo Synth less inspiring. It's a dual-oscillator, monophonic sound generator first introduced on the Fantom S that shares its performance philosophy with that of a single-aerial Theremin. In other words, move your hand towards the D-Beam source and the pitch rises; move it away and the pitch drops. But although you can resample its output, you can't store patches, nor can you sequence them. I'm not usually a fan of polyphonic arpeggiators or auto-chord generators, either. But the chord generator can strum up, down, or up and down, and act as the note source for the arpeggiator, both of which can be synchronised with the rhythm unit. With suitable sounds, this can sound excellent, and if it's a bit too sedate for you, you can add a bit of chaos using the Solo Synth as a sort of 21stcentury Theremin. I expected not to like this, but I did. When used to the full, the chord generator, arpeggiator and rhythm patterns provide miniature sequences that you can trigger, transpose and combine into complete musical backings. Neat. On the other hand, if you see a synth primarily as a keyboard instrument, the fact that the Fantom Xa offers many other performance options does not make up for the low-quality keyboard; this makes the Xa far from ideal as a conventional performance synth. This brings me to the subject of the Xa's piano sounds. The grand piano sound of the S88 is not included, but given the price point of the Xa and where it seems to be aimed, that's not surprising. However, that's no reason to make the piano sounds that are included less than overwhelming. To be fair to Roland, I am not greatly enamoured of the pianos provided by anybody's workstations, but I find the Xa's to be particularly lifeless. The best have only four velocity layers, and most of them have only two, quiet and loud. What's more, the velocity splits are obvious, with no attempt to crossfade from one to the next. If you require a realistic piano sound and action, this is not the instrument for you.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (8 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
The Fantom Editor If you want to delve deeper than the preset sounds and groove-style facilities, you're going to need to dig into the Xa's editing system, at which point you'll become inordinately grateful that the Xa is supplied with a computer-based editor/ librarian. This cross-platform application is compatible with a wide range of platforms, from Windows 98, 2000, ME and XP to Mac OS (8.6 to 9.2.2, and 10.2 upwards). Roland recommend that PC-based users run it on a 400MHz Pentium or higher (500MHz for a Pentium III), and that Mac users should consider a 233MHz G3 the minimum spec for OS 8/9 usage, and a 500MHz G3 the minimum for running the editor under OS X. 128MB of RAM is considered the minimum for both PCs and Macs, with 256MB or higher recommended. The editor can communicate with the workstation via MIDI and USB, and although you have to load the appropriate driver for your PC or Mac, you'll find that this is straightforward and that, once it's done, the two devices talk to each other without difficulty. However, while you can use the USB port on the Xa to transfer samples to and from computer, and to communicate with the editor/librarian using MIDI over the USB connection, you cannot do both simultaneously.
The main patch screen from the Mac OS X Editor.
The Editor is a boon, wholly overcoming the limitations imposed by the Xa's reduced screen. Parameters are laid out clearly and — as far as is possible with such a huge sound generator — intuitively, with detailed graphics where required. Once you start to use this, everything drops into place, and XV-style synthesis is no longer daunting, it's a pleasure to use. Unfortunately, the editor only knows about Patches and Performances. The librarian part of the package handles rhythm sets, rhythm patterns, rhythm groups, chords and arpeggios in addition to Patches and Performances, but it can't edit them. This is a great shame. If the package included a sample editor, and the attached PC or Mac could manipulate and control the entire workstation, it would make the Fantom a real contender at the high end of music production. Now, if I were reviewing any other Fantom with an 'X' in its name, this is where I would say, "Ah yes, but..." and go on to discuss the FANX UP1 Fantom X Audio Track Expansion Kit, which was released while I was writing this review. Not only does this add eight stereo audio tracks to the Fantom's sequencer, it includes a sample editor, a multisample editor, and a utility that claims to convert S700series sample libraries for use on the Fantom X. This appears to be dreamland except that... it doesn't run on the Xa!
Conclusions
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (9 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
Much of what made the Fantom X6 good has survived in the Fantom Xa. But nevertheless, the Fantom Xa has left me in a bit of a quandary. You can look at it like this: Roland have taken the rather tasty Fantom X6, and removed all the bits that gave it an edge in a highly competitive marketplace. Gone is the very playable keyboard, to be replaced by something that lacks aftertouch and does not permit the highest standards of keyboard playing. Gone are the touch-sensitive pads, to be replaced by mere switches. Gone is the large, colour LCD that make editing so simple and such fun, to be replaced by a monochrome screen. And gone is the huge ROM that made the other Fantom Xs special, to be replaced with the sound engine of the previous generation of Fantoms. On that basis, who could recommend the Fantom Xa? But you can also look at it like this: Roland have taken the rather tasty but over-specified Fantom X6 and stripped out several expensive and largely unnecessary facilities to create a lower-cost workstation while sacrificing none of its essential features. Gone is an expensive keyboard unnecessary for producing and triggering dance grooves, to be replaced by something that does the job just as well at a fraction of the price. Gone are the unnecessary touch-sensitive pads, to be replaced by cheaper ones that still trigger all your favourite rhythms and samples. Gone is the large and expensive colour LCD, to be replaced by something that still allows you to tweak your sounds. And gone is the overblown ROM full of unnecessary concert piano sounds, to be replaced by an otherwise equally powerful but cheaper sound engine more in tune with current trends. On that basis, who could fail to recommend the Fantom Xa? I would say, though, that since the Xa seems in many ways to be a groovebox at heart, and is aimed squarely at dance music production, it might have been better to strip it out still further; in its current form it may still be too complex (and expensive) for its prospective market. Clearly, the Fantom Xa is not going to appeal to all potential customers, but in many ways it is still a well-crafted instrument that offers astonishing power for a price that (as always) would have been unthinkable a few years ago. Published in SOS May 2005
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (10 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:12 PM
Roland Fantom Xa
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20Fantom%20Xa.htm (11 of 11)9/27/2005 9:23:13 PM
Roland VC1
In this article:
VC1 & VariOS Schizo Synth Patches Virtual Digital? Editor & CD-ROM Conclusions
Roland VC1 D50 RAM Card for Roland V-Synth & VariOS Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Sound/Song Library
Roland VC1 £99 pros Authentic D50 sound — your V-Synth becomes a D50! Offers you a better-sounding D50 (thanks to the V-Synth's more modern audio specifications), one which is fully compatible with existing D50 patches. Fully self-contained — the card stores all settings and user patches.
Roland's innovative V-Synth can now be reprogrammed with a RAM card, effectively turning it into another instrument. The VC1 card puts the clock back to 1987, perfectly recreating the S&S tones of the Roland D50... Paul Nagle
cons
Launched in 1987, the D50 was Roland's answer to a growing perception that analogue Changing between V-Synth and D50 modes requires a was dull and a thing of the past, whilst FM power-off. programming, the bright new concept that had summary dominated synthesis throughout the mid-'80s, could leave permanent furrows in the brow. If you have a V-Synth (or a VariOS module), the VC1 Although Roland chose the acronym LA (Linear card allows you to transform it Arithmetic) to describe its synthesis, the D50 into a D50 for about half of embodied what we now refer to as sample and the second-hand price of the real thing. With an impressive synthesis, or 'S&S', its distinctive short samples storage capacity and a useful (breathy chiffs, percussive plinks and so on) supplied editor, this small supplementing synthesizer waveforms. This card offers a fun diversion for lent the D50 a realism that's easy to overlook in V-Synth owners who can now these days of massive samples. carry two classic Roland keyboards in one flightcase.
information £99 including VAT. Roland UK +44 (0)1792 515020. +44 (0)1792 799644. www.roland.co.uk www.roland.com
Paul Ward's D50 retrospective in July 1997's SOS, (which can be read in full at www.soundonsound.com/sos/1997_articles/jul97/rolandd50.html) offers an evaluation of this ground-breaking synthesizer, so for our purposes it's sufficient to note that a D50 patch consists of two tones known as Upper and Lower. Each tone in turn comprises one or two sound sources (or 'partials' as Roland refer to them) which can either be PCM or 'analogue' waveforms. With enough programming depth to keep the tweakers happy and an effects section supplying a glossy finish, the D50 deservedly did well — at least until the Korg M1 came along the following year...!
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20VC1.htm (1 of 5)9/27/2005 9:23:17 PM
Roland VC1
Fast forward to 2003, when Roland launched a very different flagship, the VSynth. My first encounter with it came at a trade show and by May, when the Sound On Sound review was published (see www.soundonsound.com/sos/ may03/articles/rolandvsynth.asp), I had fallen under its spell. The V-Synth bundles together virtual analogue oscillators, user sampling and COSM processors; it also renders PCM waveforms malleable in ways they usually aren't, by cunning use of Variphrase processing. Add to this a superior user interface and a set of expressive performance controls, and you can see why I was hooked. Naturally, when I heard of a means to transform the V-Synth into a D50 without any kind of invasive surgery, I was intrigued. I also wondered whether the transformation would be of novelty value only, or whether 'digital retro' might truly have something to offer.
VC1 & VariOS I don't have a VariOS module, but according to Roland's documentation, everything stated in this review with regard to using the VC1 with the V-Synth also applies to VariOS, with the obvious exception of the things I've said about the VSynth's physical controls (because the rackmount VariOS doesn't have these). Slot in the VC1, boot VariOS and you have a D50 in a rack. Helpfully, the VC1 manual contains separate sections describing the operation from the perspective of both VariOS and the V-Synth, because the respective user interfaces differ so much. Judging by the VariOS section in the manual, I would recommend using the software editor, which would make everything far easier to operate!
Schizo Synth The PC Card slot at the rear of the V-Synth (and at the front of the VariOS module) is a valuable means of storing data, exchanging files and so on. With appropriate software present, it is also the means by which the V-Synth can boot with an entirely different personality. This was already a familiar concept on the VariOS, but it is rather unusual for a flagship synthesizer to be capable of such a drastic 'brain swap'. The first of the mooted 'alternative identities' to be available for the V-Synth is provided in the form of the VC1 or 'V-Card' (a VC2 Vocal modelling card was announced at this year's Winter NAMM, but was yet to be released when this was written). The VC1 card looks similar to a laptop PCMCIA adaptor, and you insert it into the V-Synth's card slot. Installation is now complete — you simply power on and the V-Synth boots as a D50. In order to achieve this, Roland engineers apparently descended into the vaults to retrieve the original D50 code, which was stored on 5.25-inch disks. Running file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20VC1.htm (2 of 5)9/27/2005 9:23:17 PM
Roland VC1
this code on the V-Synth produced a much cleaner sound than the original D50, because the D-A converters of the V-Synth are better than those of the D50 (not surprising when you consider how technology has marched on since 1987). To get around this, the card offers a 'D50 mode' for those that want it, which restores some of the grunge and aliasing of the original. A system menu offers the choice of the much-improved version or something closer to the sound owners of the original are familiar with. However, even in D50 mode, the VSynth's emulation sounds better to my ears, and the reverbs are more acceptably quiet too. Once you are up and running, you navigate using the V-Synth's touchscreen, make edits with the knobs and have a fair degree of flexibility with respect to assigning the V-Synth's performance controls. However, since this is not a rewrite of the D50's OS — it is the D50's OS — the limitations of that instrument still apply, and you can't create assignments that exceed its original capabilities. Nor can you apply V-Synth capabilities to the VC1's D50 — the V-Synth is either a V-Synth without the VC1 card in the slot, or a D50 with the VC1 installed, but never a mixture of the two. The V-Synth's Time Trip Pad is an intuitive replacement for the D50's joystick and can be used to vary the levels of partials or the balance between Upper and Lower tones. Similarly, you can assign the D-Beam to take on the duties of the mod wheel, aftertouch or pitch-bender, or to act as a volume control or even a hold pedal. The D50 was not blessed with knobs — you had to purchase the PG1000 programmer separately for that kind of real-time control. Even with the programmer, editing wasn't exactly a joy because you had to constantly retrigger notes in order to hear the changes made by the sliders. With the V-Synth's onboard knobs, you can tweak happily with no such restriction. You select a partial or partials for editing by means of the touchscreen or via the V-Synth's Structure buttons, and from then on it's simply a matter of turning knobs. Although these don't map exactly to D50 functions, they are mapped out logically enough and, in conjunction with the screen (because there are far more parameters than V-Synth knobs), editing is way easier than it ever was on the original. Most of the controls can even be remapped. If you select the small controller icon in the bottom left-hand corner of the main Play screen, you can then navigate around the V-Synth panel, plucking any parameters you like from the huge selection available. Provided you ignore the physical labels on the VSynth, you can quickly memorise your way around. The V-Synth has an arpeggiator, but the D50 did not, so nor does the VC1-based version, as you would expect. The V-Synth's Arpeggiator button is therefore used to activate the D50 Chase function, which is like a built-in MIDI-based delay; the V-Synth's Hold button sets portamento on or off and the Arpeggio Speed knob
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20VC1.htm (3 of 5)9/27/2005 9:23:17 PM
Roland VC1
sets the Portamento or Chase (delay) rate.
Patches The VC1 is supplied with all of the D50's original presets, plus the sound libraries for the D50/D550. In addition, 64 new patches are supplied using 28 extra waveforms that were too large to fit into the original synth (these include a passable mellotron string sample, and several electric pianos). There are an impressive 384 presets — but that isn't the end of the story. It's worth repeating that the VC1 is functionally identical to the real thing, meaning you have complete SysEx compatibility with any existing D50 patches. Therefore it's helpful that the card has a RAM area into which you can place up to eight banks of your own D50 sounds — that's another 512 patches on tap! If you don't have enough original creations to populate these banks, a quick Google search on the phrase 'free D50 patches' should yield enough to keep you happily occupied for weeks.
Virtual Digital? Was the D50 the world's first virtual analogue? I occasionally hear people mistakenly suggest that it had true analogue oscillators and filters when, in fact, it was an entirely digital machine. This is a testament to Roland's programmers, who emulated analogue oscillators and filters with uncanny skills. Ironically, in 1987, the synth world was looking to distance itself from analogue; it was another eight years before the circle was complete and the Clavia Nord Lead appeared on the scene.
Editor & CD-ROM The supplied CD-ROM contains a Uniquest editor for both the V-Synth and VariOS. It's compatible with a variety of operating systems, from Windows 98 through to XP and also Mac OS X or OS 9, and is an excellent means of editing patches or managing user banks. As well as graphical editing of parameters, options such as randomise, blend, mix and morph ensure you should never get bored when seeking new patch ideas. I was surprised to be able to throw up plenty that sounded genuinely different using these morphing techniques. I also generated several that were silent or constantly droning, but as you can produce whole banks with indecent haste, this isn't exactly an issue! Logically, since there is only one card slot in the V-Synth, the VC1 has to be a RAM card in order to store user patches and be fully self-contained. But this also means that you might inadvertently delete some of the files needed for the VC1 to operate. For this reason, Roland include on the supplied CD-ROM a copy of the all-important program files and details on how to restore the card, should that
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20VC1.htm (4 of 5)9/27/2005 9:23:17 PM
Roland VC1
ever be necessary.
Conclusions Unlike synthesizers that use modelling technology, the VC1 is an absolutely faithful reproduction of an earlier digital instrument. This means that the V-Synth can import D50 banks, can exchange patches with a D50, and yet sounds cleaner and better than the original. If you turn off its 'D50 mode', you have an even more polished sound — the V-Synth's signal path conveys the D50's personality much better than the original hardware. I'm no purist, though, and personally, I would have been happy if the VC1 had offered you a D50 with the full V-Synth stock of effects and an arpeggiator. And although the Upper and Lower tones can be split, layered or played from separate MIDI channels, the D50 remains a bi-timbral instrument, whereas I'd have loved access to more modern levels of multitimbrality. But as this is not an emulation, you are given exactly the D50's capabilities and sounds, and nothing more (other than an extra 28 waveforms). I don't think for a moment that I'd want a D50 to permanently replace my VSynth, but of course that's not the idea — when you want your V-Synth back again, you simply remove the card and reboot as normal to restore the V-Synth's functions. However, I really enjoyed my refresher course in LA synthesis — there's still plenty of mileage left in it, especially when you delve into the supplied editor. If that isn't enough to convince you, it's worth remembering that strings, brass, and organs were not really the focus of the original V-Synth factory set, and given the abundance of free D50 patches on the Internet, the VC1 is a great way of adding more conventional sounds to the Roland V-Synth. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Roland%20VC1.htm (5 of 5)9/27/2005 9:23:17 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
In this article:
Jam Pack 4: Symphony Orchestra **** Sonic Boom Box **** Downbeat Leftfield **** Platinum Essentials *****
Sample Libraries: On Test Sample Shop Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Sound/Song Library
Star Minerals ***** Cummingtonite **** Khanneshite
Jam Pack 4: Symphony Orchestra ****
*** Dickite
APPLE LOOPS
** Fukalite * Sillimanite
Garage Band may not be considered a serious piece of recording software by some, but in reality it does most of what the majority of us actually need from a sequencer, and Apple Loops, far from being gimmicks, have lots of applications in songwriting and even in the creation of original music. Building whole songs from 'cut and paste' elements may seem a bit of a cop-out, but many pieces of TV music are already made that way and, after hearing this library for myself, I can understand why this is possible — the quality is seriously impressive. Once the installation has been carried out from the two DVDs, containing around 10GB of material, you'll find that you have over 2000 orchestral loop elements that can be used in Garage Band 2, Logic Pro 7, or Logic Express. There are also over 30 sample-based orchestral instruments, which Logic users can load into EXS24 or EXS24P (though some of the clever modwheel/pitch-bend tricks may not come over with the samples). The loops are mainly solo instrument phrases covering a number of classical and film styles, and all the ones I auditioned sounded smooth and lush, with exactly the right character and an appropriate amount of added ambience — I can envisage many of the parts sitting nicely in pop songs or soundtracks. In addition to the vast range of loops, there's also a great selection of sample-based orchestral instruments divided into strings, brass/ woodwind, and keyboards/percussion, again with a suitable ambience added at source. All the main orchestral instruments are represented, and the sounds have a mature, mellow quality which contrasts with some of the strident samples that I've heard from other libraries. The strings are particularly good, though it's hard to fault the wind samples either. There may not be a great depth of multi-velocity sampling going on (usually just two layers), but the sounds just seem to work together, which is really all that matters. Furthermore, the designers have made
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Sample%20Libraries%20%20On%20Test.htm (1 of 6)9/27/2005 9:23:24 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
full use of the modulation and pitch-bend wheels to add expression to specific instruments — for example, the orchestral oboe changes timbre depending on the mod wheel position and eventually produces staccato notes at the extreme mod wheel position. The pitch-bend wheel sets the starting volume, so it can be used to dynamically control notes. I did manage to get some of the loops to click by wiggling the mod wheel excessively during playback, but reloading the instrument seemed to cure this problem. The pianos and harps also sound the part, and while this pack may not give Vienna Symphonic Library a hard time, it's incredible value, both for its loops and its sample-based instruments. Only some audible sample looping (which would probably go unnoticed in a real composition) prevents me giving this the full fivestar treatment. As it is, it's a worthy four. Paul White Apple Loops 2-DVD-ROM set, £65 including VAT. Apple Store +44 (0)800 039 1010. www.apple.com/uk
Sonic Boom Box **** APPLE LOOPS This is a cost-effective Apple Loops product from Ultimate Soundbank which, rather than being too tightly themed, sets out to give the users a broad palette of styles, both in Apple-Loop form and as software instruments that can be used within Apple's Garage Band software. The Apple Loop section, which also works in Final Cut Pro, Logic Pro 7, Logic Express, and Soundtrack, comprises over 4000 loops, both instrumental and percussive, and these are augmented by in excess of 220 software instruments. The collection comes on a single DVD and requires 4GB of hard drive space for installation. Included instrument genres encompass drums, percussion, basses, guitars, and a large number of synths, as well as some more traditional instruments. A lot of the rhythm loops are aimed at contemporary dance and hip-hop styles, but there's also some traditional pop/rock material as well as riffs and phrases played on guitar, bass, wind, strings, and synthesizer/keyboard. The blurb on the back of the box says that 'your composition will sound as good as a professional record in a couple of seconds'. Personally, I'd say this claim errs on the side of exaggeration, but I have to agree that the quality of the material provided here rivals that of far more costly sample CD libraries. While many of the Apple Loops products I've looked at so far concentrate on a specific genre, Sonic Boom Box could be considered the Apple Loops equivalent of a workstation synth, albeit with a dance-music bias, and as such it's a good file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Sample%20Libraries%20%20On%20Test.htm (2 of 6)9/27/2005 9:23:24 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
starting-point for your collection, especially if you work in diverse pop genres. The loop material is nicely produced, rarely needing additional processing to make it sound good, and while the included instruments are pretty simple, they still manage to sound strong and 'right for the job'. I particularly like the quality of the percussion and rhythm loops, though some are a bit too 'off the wall' for my taste — words like 'chemical' and 'acid' come unbidden to mind. In all, there's some great stuff in here and it's certainly easy to get the basis of a groove together to stimulate your creativity, which is where I think these packages score best. If you like variety and have a penchant for loops that are a bit 'out there', Sonic Boom Box is a bargain. Paul White Apple Loops DVD-ROM, £66 including VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.usbsounds.com
Downbeat Leftfield **** MULTI-FORMAT The Loopmasters Origin Series, of which this library forms a part, aims to offer 100-percent copyright-free loops, multisamples, and single sounds in a value-formoney format. All the CDs in the series include WAV loops, REX 2 files for all the loops, and some Propellerhead Reason instrument patches. As suggested by the title of this CD, the collection of samples here were all recorded at lower tempos (100bpm and slower), while the musical content is both dark and somewhat quirky — hence the 'leftfield' tag. The library totals some 700MB of data, with 275 REX 2 loops, 700 WAV files, and samples for 21 different drum kits included. A good chunk of the collection is made up by a mixture of over 100 live and programmed drum loops recorded at 100bpm, 90bpm, and 80bpm. There is some good stuff amongst this lot that would suit anything from hip-hop through to chill-out. The sounds are nicely produced and not over-processed, with some of the percussive elements lending a darker feel to the grooves created. The tone is not lofi gritty, but it does conjure up a 'serious' hiphop mood, so think Nelly or Snoop Dogg rather than Goldie Lookin Chain or The Beastie Boys — although you could get to the latter with suitable extra processing. A separate folder of percussion loops, drum fills, and other drum 'extras' is also included. Aside from the drum loops, the rest of the collection provides a diverse set of file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Sample%20Libraries%20%20On%20Test.htm (3 of 6)9/27/2005 9:23:24 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
instrument loops and sounds. These include a folder of bass loops (plus a small collection of Reason NNXT bass patches) whose moods match the drum loops very well, so there is plenty of scope for mixing and matching between these. A further folder of 'instrument' loops is subdivided into guitar, keyboard, pad/ atmosphere, strings, vocoder, and woodwind (dominated by solo sax lines) groups. This is a pretty mixed bag. For example, the keyboard group includes a good number of chilled Rhodes loops while, in contrast, the pad/atmosphere set provides a mixture of both chill-out and much darker moods. Two further folders complete the collection. Firstly, a sound effects folder contains various bleeps, bloops and other noises — all very disturbing. Secondly, the Vibes & Atmos folder contains a mixture of bed-style pads and sound effects, plus a collection of turntable scratches. In use, there is plenty to get your teeth into in this collection, and the loops from the various groups can easily be mixed together to produce a complete musical arrangement. The single hits, REX 2 loops, and instrument patches (for Reason users) add extra flexibility. For styles moving from Zero-7 chill-out through to darker hip-hop moods, Downbeat & Leftfield has plenty to offer. The only downside is that, while the material is all very useable from a musical perspective, I'm not sure there is anything radically new offered here. That said, the sample set is competitively priced and certainly does offer good value for money. John Walden WAV, REX 2, and Reason CD-ROM, £39.95 including VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.loopmasters.com
Platinum Essentials ***** AUDIO+WAV This title aimed squarely at fans of West-Coast hip-hop has been produced by Keith 'Clizark' Clark, a man who already has 10 million record sales to his name having worked with such names as Snoop Dogg and the Eastsidaz. The single split-format disc acts as both a normal audio CD and a WAV CD-ROM (all samples are duplicated in both formats), and the audio comprises 20 construction kits followed by a small group of additional synth samples. The construction kits cover tempos of 93-103bpm, and each track begins with a mixed track featuring MPC-style sampled drums, bass, synths, and some guitars — this lasts less than a minute. Most of these mixes exude an understated yet powerful menace which would be well complemented by the kind of smoothly murderous rapping that Snoop Dogg has nailed. The rhythm programming is beautifully done, creating that head-nodding momentum that so often seems to separate the hits from the 'B' sides — the fact that Clizark has made this difficult file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Sample%20Libraries%20%20On%20Test.htm (4 of 6)9/27/2005 9:23:24 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
task sound so easy here should leave no-one in any doubt as to his production chops! Although the style of all the tracks is quite sparse, this is definitely part of Clizark's trademark sound, and you'd have no trouble transforming any of these mixes into a finished production with just a bit of editing and the addition of some vocals. The solid basses doubtless account for some of this gravitas, especially as they have been shrewdly chosen to complement the kick drum in each case. However, it's the meaty drum sounds which really carry each track and which are the obvious highlight of Platinum Essentials to my ear: just the right amount of attack to sound punchy, just the right amount of mid-range and sustain to provide body, and just the right amount of low end to anchor everything firmly. You could spend a great deal of time trying to obtain drum sounds as good as on even one of these construction kits, and you get 20 different sets here. If they had Desert Island Discs with sample CDs, including this one would be a no-brainer as far as I'm concerned! Clearly, then, I was delighted to find that all the drum loops and single hits from each full mix were included in each construction kit. However, I wasn't quite as delighted to find that this was pretty much all that was provided in the way of separate elements — none of the guitar licks, synth pads, and other pitched samples which had helped round out the mixed tracks so successfully. Anyone expecting a more traditional construction-kit format would justifiably feel a little cheated. The small selection of synth multisamples at the end of the CD help make up for this a bit by including ten rather nice sets of 'one note per octave' bass-synth samples, which are pretty much to the standard of the drum sounds. However, the other synth sounds are a wash-out, and don't sit well against the rest of the library content. If it weren't for the bargain UK price, I'd be rather in two minds about giving Platinum Essentials as a whole our top star rating. On the one hand there are drum sounds here which would outshine many five-star releases; on the other, the incomplete track breakdowns, measly 32-minute running time, and wafer-thin documentation leave me with a sneaking feeling that someone's having a laugh! The bottom line for me, though, is that the drums and basses are worth the mockery, and at this price that's got to mean five stars. Mike Senior Split-format Audio CD & WAV CD-ROM, £32.95 including VAT. Time + Space +44 (0)1837 55200. +44 (0)1837 55400. Click here to email www.timespace.com www.bigfishaudio.com Published in SOS May 2005
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Sample%20Libraries%20%20On%20Test.htm (5 of 6)9/27/2005 9:23:24 PM
Sample Libraries: On Test
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Sample%20Libraries%20%20On%20Test.htm (6 of 6)9/27/2005 9:23:24 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
In this article:
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
Back To Basics Virtual Drummer Instrument (Mac/PC) Installation Published in SOS May 2005 New Styles New Sounds Print article : Close window Copy Protection Reviews : Software More Control In Use Verdict Using Groove Agent 2 Under Logic From the same team that brought
you Virtual Guitarist, Groove Agent has had an impressive Steinberg Groove Agent upgrade, and is now claimed to work better under 2 £170 non-Steinberg hosts. We put it through a proper multipros platform test. Incredibly easy to use with Cubase SX. Wide range of usable styles. Loads of different, easily tweakable kits.
Martin Walker
From Bornemark, the same Swedish developers that gave us Virtual As our Logic-based tests Guitarist and Broomstick Bass show, users of other hosts may face a frustrating time! (reviewed elsewhere in this issue), Sounds have fewer velocity Groove Agent is essentially an 'instant layers than some competitors. drummer' for those that either can't or don't have the time to program their summary While it doesn't offer the most own drum rhythms, or who want some sophisticated multi-layered kit rhythmic inspiration. Plenty of us fall sounds, Groove Agent 2 is into these categories, yet when I first perfect (at least under a saw version 1 displayed at the Frankfurt Steinberg host) for any Musikmesse in 2003 I was tempted to musician who wants to dismiss it as a gimmick — that is, until I explore a huge range of drumming styles with the was given a proper demonstration of its minimum of fuss and the capabilities. The sounds are all highmaximum of enjoyment. quality 24-bit audio (mostly recorded information onto analogue tape), and although you can use it as a simple drum machine, it £169.99; upgrade from version 1, £55. Prices actually provides far more creative include VAT. possibilities. cons
Arbiter +44 (0)20 8970 1909. +44 (0)20 8202 7076. www.arbitermt.co.uk www.steinberg.net
Version 2 offers many more rhythm style options (81 instead of version 1's 54) including grunge, punk, and triphop, plus nine new kits, and there are
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (1 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
Test Spec PC REVIEW SYSTEM 2.8GHz Intel Pentium 4C PC with 1GB of DDR400 RAM running Windows XP with Service Pack 1, and based on an Asus P4P800 Deluxe motherboard with an Intel 865PE chipset, running an 800MHz Front Side Buss. Steinberg Groove Agent v2.0.
now up to eight stereo outputs available Groove Agent 2 looks very similar to v1 for more refined mixing options. What's apart from the extra Solo buttons for the eight groups. more, you can now bypass the internal sample-playback engine and output MIDI data to trigger your own preferred drum sounds, and you can capture MIDI performances to a MIDI file independent of any host application. Let me fill in the details...
Back To Basics
Steinberg Cubase SX v3.01. Cakewalk Sonar v4.0. Tonewise DirectiXer v2.5. MAC REVIEW SYSTEM Dual 2GHz Apple Mac G5 with 1.5GB of RAM running Mac OS v10.3.8. 1.3GHz Apple G4 Powerbook with 512MB of RAM running Mac OS v10.3.8. Apple Logic Pro v7.01 (both machines). Apple Logic Pro v6.4.3 (both machines).
We reviewed version 1 back in SOS July 2003, but here's a brief recap. Groove Agent can play drums in a variety of styles, arranged chronologically across the upper curving timeline slider, starting in the 1950s with 'Swing' and moving through five decades to the 21st century and 'Mini Club'. Each style has an associated drum/percussion setup, but you can unlink the lower part of the slider to marry any kit with any style. Furthermore, each style provides 25 complexity levels from laid-back to incredibly busy, chosen from the lower slider, each with its own unique 'fill', and once again you can link/unlink the fills from the complexity level. Other refinements include the choice of snare or sidestick, buttons to trigger accents or fills on demand, a half-tempo feel, and a random option that plays slightly varying patterns. A set of rotary knobs down the left-hand side of the window lets you create a triplet shuffle feel, loosen the timing, add simple limiting, and control the Ambience balance by mixing together dry, two-metre, and sevenmetre distant miked versions of the same sounds.
Installation Besides the jump in required hard drive space from 300MB to 450MB, system requirements are much the same as for version 1 (a 1.4GHz PC Pentium or Athlon processor for PC users, or a Power Mac G4 Dual and 1.25GHz), although Windows 2000 and Mac OS 9 support have been quietly dropped. 512MB of RAM is also recommended, but I'd increase this to 1GB for a typical user who's running a host sequencer and other softsynths alongside. Like most dongle-protected software, Groove Agent 2 should be installed without the dongle, to avoid your computer finding this new hardware device before the relevant drivers have been installed. Other than that, I found installation an easy ride, although I'd have liked an option to install the plug-in in my usual 'vstplugins' folder and the 450MB of audio files on another partition — some of us prefer to keep our Windows partitions as small as possible. PC owners get the option to install the DXi and Rewire versions along the way if they need them. Those upgrading from version 1, like me, will be forgiven for initially thinking that file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (2 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
they've been sent the old version by mistake, since until you notice the '2' appended to the Groove Agent logo, there's very little visual difference between the two, and exactly the same list of Styles appears across the top slider. The secret is that many are now displayed in a different colour, and if you right-click on these options, a pull-down menu appears with further related style options (see the 'New Styles' box above for full details).
New Styles Unlike the historical linking of kits and styles to the timeline in version 1, the 27 new styles included in version 2 are somewhat more arbitrary, and are tucked in among the originals as right-click menu options. Here's the complete lowdown in the order in which they appear along the timeline. First up is 'Bop' for jazz standards, then there are two strange ones in 1953 under 'Paint' (presumably a Jackson Pollock reference?). 'Ominous' uses a palette of heartbeats, morse code, and deep mechanical noises for some unsettling soundscapes, while 'Machinery' mixes thuds, rattles, taps, and escaping steam to form relentless, pulsing rhythms ideal for future city soundtracks. Rather more traditional are '6/8' (this handy time signature was missing altogether from version 1), 'Slow Blues' for jam sessions, 'Steady Beat' for straightforward nosurprises drumming, and the latin-influenced 'Mozambique'. Next up are 'Bombay Dance Hall' and 'Roots' (the latter utilising the new 'Noisy' kit), both filed under the 'Reggae' style, but with very different flavours. The Hard Rock section has been fleshed out considerably, with extra entries for 'Grunge', 'Indie Punk', 'Unplugged', and 'Ballad', while 'Basic Hip-Hop' has been supplemented with a simpler 'Live' and a 'Sloppy' version inspired by the Beastie Boys. Meanwhile, analogue drum machine freaks will rejoice that the rather generic 1981 'Elektro' style is now joined by 'Vintage FR3', 'TR7', 'CR8', 'Meek Ballad' (where the 25 complexity levels simply add more and more beats to the same pattern), and the harder sounds of 'Axis Y'. The hard rock 1984 'Arena' style now has 'HM Straight' and 'Triplet' feels for metalheads, the busy eighth-note feel of 'Grind', and the technique and busy fills of 'Progressive'. 'Daft' provides simple rhythms, and 1994's 'Trip-Hop' style is now supplemented by the acoustic sounds of Portishead-inspired 'Bristol Trip'. Finally, 'Kelly' is an additional R&B style that's slow and heavy with double-tempo hi-hats.
New Sounds New Solo buttons feature alongside each instrument, making it far easier to tweak individual sounds in the mix. Version 1 already offered plenty of internal editing possibilities, including velocity response for selecting the softer or harder end of each instrument's sample splits, ±1 octave tuning, decay, individual ambience, volume, and output selection. However, version 2 expands the number of possible stereo outputs from four to eight, so that you can now treat each of the eight 'groups' (kick, snare, toms, hi-hat, ride, crash, percussion 1, and percussion 2) through separate effects if you wish.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (3 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
Because you can choose from one to eight stereo outputs in version 2, the 'Ambience to output 4' option from version 1 (located under the Setup lid at the bottom right of the window) has now become 'Ambience Split', which routes the ambient and reverberated versions of all parts to the highest available audio output (dependent, of course, on how many you've chosen). And the sounds? Version 1 offered '50s jazz, '60s pop, '70s rock, and '80s studio kits, plus various percussion instruments and extras such as brush and mallet kit sounds. Version 2 adds a top-of-the-range Studio kit for clean, modern sounds including three new snares (a Slingerland Radio King, a Slingerland copper, and a model handmade in Prague), and a hard-sounding Heavy Kit designed for metal styles with busy kick-drum patterns, and with ride and crash cymbals specially selected to cut through the sound of multiple distorted guitars. The 'Noisy' Kit uses tiny traditional drums including a 10-inch mini-snare, treated through digital effects to give them a modern and much bigger lo-fi sound, plus a mixture of rare vintage and knackered modern cymbals. There's also a handful of electronic drum sounds including the Simmons SDS9, TR7, and CR8, treated with ambience from a vintage EMT plate reverb, and combined into a versatile selection of electronic kits. This new selection of sounds adds freshness and variety to the new styles, but given that you can bypass any or all of the instruments pre-selected for each kit in favour of any other allocated to the same sound 'group', Groove Agent offers incredibly versatile options — for instance, there's now a total of 36 snares, 25 kick drums, and 28 toms on offer, while the two percussion groups together encompass 76 instruments from tambourine, triangle, and shakers to handclaps, djembe, bottles, and tabla.
Copy Protection Although I'm always loath to devote review space to discussing copy protection, this is the first time I've been sent a product that requires a dongle but doesn't ship with one, so here are the pertinent details. Like the majority of Steinberg's latest applications and software synths, Groove Agent 2 won't run unless you plug in a properly-licensed Syncrosoft USB dongle. Anyone who already has products such as Cubase SX, Nuendo, Hypersonic or Virtual Bassist will already have one or more of these, and thankfully, a single dongle can hold licences for multiple Steinberg software applications, so you won't have to invest in an extra USB hub to plug them all in at once! You can also transfer licences from one dongle to another at any time. However, Steinberg don't include a dongle with Groove Agent 2, so anyone who normally uses other host applications such as Logic or Sonar may have to buy one separately — they cost £20 in the UK. All that is supplied is a 32-digit Activation Code, which you must use with the supplied Syncrosoft Licence Control Center software that is installed along with Groove Agent 2. You run its 'Licence Download' Wizard, enter the supplied code, and must then go on-line so it can interrogate Steinberg's database, declare the code a valid one, and then
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (4 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
download the corresponding licence into the dongle. Once you've done this successfully, Steinberg's on-line database will no longer accept the same code to prevent those with multiple dongles licensing them all, although safeguards are built in to ensure that if for any reason your download fails part of the way through, you can try again. In fairness to this approach, licensing for those whose music computers are without an Internet connection has been improved — you no longer have to install the Syncrosoft software on another computer with Internet access, as I described in PC Notes in February this year. Instead, you can now generate a 'Pending Licence' with an associated Challenge File, copy/paste this document into a computer with Internet access, and then copy/paste the resulting on-line generated Response file back into your music computer and use that to generate the licence. However, I already know of some non-Cubase users who have been extremely disgruntled to find themselves expected to fork out an extra £20 to run the software they have just bought in all good faith. Given that old-timers may now have several redundant dongles lying around, Steinberg perhaps ought to provide a recycling scheme to bring down the cost to new users.
More Control Although you can use Groove Agent as an excellent jamming companion, changing patterns in real-time and adding accents and fills, those writing songs will find the version 2 capture features much more versatile. You can capture your 'performance' as a MIDI part in your host sequencer as before, which as you might expect works fine with Steinberg's own Cubase and Nuendo. However, outputting MIDI data from a VST Instrument is exploring the boundaries of the VST 2.0 protocol, and other hosts including Logic Pro can't cope with it (for more on using Groove Agent 2 with Logic, see the large box over the page by Dave Lockwood). In an attempt to overcome some of these limitations, version 2 provides a 'Live Ð ð File' option under the Setup lid to output the data directly to a MIDI file so that you can later import into any host for further tweaking. If you find a pattern that works well in a particular song apart from one particular group part, you can mute this and play in your own manually from a MIDI keyboard. All the individual drum sounds are available from MIDI keys, as are the pattern selection, stop/run, accent, fill, and various other settings, while MIDI controllers can be used to alter the rotary control settings. If you feed Groove Agent from an even-numbered MIDI channel rather than an odd one, the keys used for selecting pattern complexity instead control the mute buttons for the eight groups. So far this is as it was in version 1, but version 2 adds further muting options — the toggle mutes of version 1 can be velocity switchable (playing the key softly acts as a mute, while hitting it hard unmutes it), or operate 'while held', so that their individual mute status toggles to the opposite as long as you hold down a key. The Stop/Run buttons now also have a new option to pause or stop Groove Agent's output when you stop your sequencer.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (5 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
In Use Cubase SX3 proved to be the perfect host, and I had absolutely no problems running Groove Agent 2 within it, recording its MIDI output directly into a Cubase MIDI track, controlling it remotely from an external MIDI keyboard, or directly automating any of its controls by moving them on the VSTi and recording these moves directly into Cubase in multiple passes. In fact, I found the whole experience a rewarding one, and when I really tried to find limitations, such as some styles with busy ride cymbals or tom rhythms that became a little mechanical, a little automation of the Velocity Offset knob worked wonders in adding a little variation. The Sample Engine bypass is apparently not a new feature, but rather a clever workaround discovered by enthusiastic users and publicised in v2.0. By setting the input of your MIDI track to Groove Agent, so that it receives the drum note and controller data, and the output of that same track to another drum synth or sampler with identical key mapping, you can trigger any combination of sounds from the internal patterns. Again, this worked fine for me in Cubase, but of course it wouldn't from other host applications that can't receive MIDI output from a plug-in.
Here you can see the MIDI loopback option provides by Tonewise's DirectiXer, which makes it much easier to use Groove Agent 2 within Cakewalk's Sonar. The new 'Live < > File' option can also be seen under the Setup lid on the bottom right. This allows you to capture your performances as an external MIDI file, making Groove Agent 2 potentially compatible with a wider range of host applications. It still didn't work reliably under Logic, though!
Using Cakewalk's Sonar as a host proved to be a slightly tougher experience, and it took some headscratching before I worked out how to capture MIDI note performance data to an external file — what you have to do is change the MIDI Output option from 'Live Output To Host' to 'Record to File' before activating the MIDI Output toggle under the Setup lid. This starts the recording process, but you must then stop it manually by returning Groove Agent 2's MIDI Output to Off, whereupon a MIDI file is created and placed on your desktop. I dragged this into the appropriate MIDI track within Sonar with no problems. Automation proved more difficult to master, but during the course of my investigations I discovered such an elegant solution that I abandoned further tests. The answer is to purchase Tonewise's $49 DirectiXer wrapper, which has a MIDI loopback function. Using this with Groove Agent 2 let me record its performance directly into a Sonar track, and record automation, just as in file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (6 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
Cubase. Nevertheless, during my time with Sonar I experienced a few random stops during playback, plus missing initial notes, so I can't claim 100-percent success for this combination.
Verdict I was a fan of Groove Agent, and version 2 has more of everything. Its '1970s hifi' user interface isn't very inspiring, but don't let looks put you off — there's an impressive engine under the bonnet! Audio quality is very good, and the kits range all the way from ultra-traditional through analogue to occasionally weird. I can recommend it unreservedly to Steinberg users, although those running other plug-in hosts may not have as smooth a ride. It's great for any musician who may get called on to explore unfamiliar territory, including those working in film, computer games, and library music, where its extensive range of styles is unlikely to let you down. However, even if you mostly work within a narrower range of tempo and genres, the mix-and-match approach to styles, kits, and instruments means that you can rapidly come up with something new, exciting, and sometimes unexpected — I tried it out on a friend with a string of trance albums to his credit, and he was soon a convert. So what competition is there for Groove Agent 2? Well, it's not a beat-slicer or sample loop player, which makes it rather different from Spectrasonics' Stylus RMX with its 7.4GB library, and the 8GB of Submersible Music's Drumcore, which may both have more initial attitude to jump-start new songs, but might be harder to fit into existing ones (although Groove Agent 2's eight outputs make it easy to apply radical processing to each group separately if you wish).
Groove Agent 2 provides many more kit sounds, as you can see from these lists of Kick and Snare options — the new drums for version 2 are in the bottom section.
FXpansion's BFD is probably a closer competitor with its Groove Librarian and 9GB of authentic acoustic drum kit samples, and since these provide many more velocity layers than Groove Agent 2, they will sound more realistic. Nevertheless, Groove Agent's much smaller 450MB set of sounds means you can switch between kits and create new combinations almost instantly, rather than having to wait several seconds for huge samples to be loaded in before you hear the difference, and there are almost limitless kit combinations available to experiment with, especially once you start exploring the individual tuning, decay, and ambience controls. It also provides dance and analogue kits that BFD doesn't cover. Of course, if you wish, you can use Groove Agent 2's sample-bypass mode to trigger BFD and get the best of both worlds!
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (7 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
For me, Groove Agent 2 excels in its immediacy and in its much larger range of instantly available styles, while its interface makes it incredibly easy to generate and capture your real-time performances. If, like me, you want to be able to work quickly when inspiration strikes, Groove Agent 2 can be up and drumming in no time at all. I loved it!
Using Groove Agent 2 Under Logic Groove Agent 2 is now available in Audio Units format, so there's no more VST wrapper to worry about and no text-file kludge just to allow the program to find its samples, but whilst the program itself has been significantly enhanced, it seems that many of the issues surrounding its operation within non-Steinberg sequencers remain. I like Groove Agent a lot. I like its sounds, I like its immediacy and controllability, and above all I like Manually written automation driving Groove the musicality of the playing — and I Agent 2. guess that's the reason why I persist with trying to use it inside Logic, my sequencer for the last 10 years or so, despite the issues that this brings up. Groove Agent resides at the 'outer limits' of the VST2 instrument specification. As a plug-in, it transmits not only its control data, but also note data, writing its output to a MIDI track within Cubase or Nuendo, as Martin Walker details in the body of this review. This allows you to generate a performance with the 'broad-brush' controls of the GUI, but then edit that performance, right down to individual hit resolution, to achieve something quite specific. You don't have to work that way, though. Within Steinberg hosts, you can choose to simply record the output from the interface as automation data and let the program run in real time. Failing that, you can trigger the Groove Agent plug-in with MIDI note and controller data, and edit the resulting performance at 'control' level, rather than at drum-hit level. Within Logic, however, plug-ins can't transmit note data, so writing directly to a MIDI track within your sequencer is not possible. Unfortunately, Groove Agent's on-screen controls won't send any automation data to Logic either, so you are left with a choice of manually writing automation or note data into Logic or using an external keyboard or control surface. Having exhaustively explored all the options over the last few weeks, I can heartily recommend... well, none of them, actually! Each offers something, and each causes sufficient frustration to have at least one committed Logic user thinking, "Hmm — maybe I will learn Nuendo." The simplest option is to use a MIDI keyboard. You record MIDI note and controller data to a Groove Agent-enabled audio Instrument in Logic, with the notes above B3 each triggering a specific Groove Agent pattern. Fills are triggered either by using the mod wheel or entering a pattern-select note with a velocity of 90 or more. You hear the result in real time and you can subsequently edit the performance, at least to some degree, in that you can go in and change which pattern is playing by altering the MIDI note number, and affect when fills
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (8 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
and other events occur by changing the timing of controller data. Editing can be rendered a lot more intuitive by setting up a Mapped Object in the Environment, which allows you to rename notes with their Groove Agent function, but you can't easily address all of the parameters within Groove Agent using this method alone. At the other extreme, you can choose to abandon any semblance of real-time interraction with Groove Agent and just manually write automation data directly into Logic to control it. When you activate automation on a Groove Agent audio instrument track, all the automatable parameters appear listed in alphabetical order (see right). You just choose what data you want to write, and enter the necessary nodes to create the required data values where you want them to occur. It's far from intuitive, but you can be very precise. Square vector points, for 'clean' transitions between discontiguous values (say, switching from Pattern 5 to 19) can be created by 'rubber-banding' the automation line while holding down the Shift, Activating automation on a track containing Groove Agent 2 brings Alt, and Control keys. This creates a pair of up all of the instrument's nodes, and you can then grab the line in parameters ready for automation. between and move it up or down, which is much quicker than trying to get four nodes in exactly the right place yourself! Curiously, some of Groove Agent's switched (On/ Off) functions seem to need to flip from 0 to 127 rather than just between 'zero and anything above zero', while others seem content with any value above 63. In some instances, I found that any 'above zero' value would be enough to switch Groove Agent's user interface, but that a 127 value was actually required to activate the function. All the parameters are named in their separate automation lanes (as shown in the screenshot on the left) so you can see their potential interactions, such as when fills are triggered with repect to changes in the fill pattern number, and you can easily move their relative positions for working on specific combinations of parameters. Mixing the automation-based and the real-time, keyboard-based working methods described here seems to offer the best combination of flexibility and reliability. It makes sense to use note data for basic pattern selection and fill triggering, to maintain a degree of performance spontaneity, whilst manually written automation takes care of everything else. If you're going to do this, though, it doesn't seem to be a good idea for Logic users to heed the advice in the manual about setting up Groove Agent to follow your sequencer's Start button. Once you've connected the plug-in's Start parameter to Logic's transport, it no longer seems to be solely under the control of the programmed note or automation data, and you will often find that it 'free runs' (albeit in perfect beat sync) when you shuttle back to an earlier point in the track, or even past a programmed Stop instruction. The best way I found to work with notes triggering patterns was to use Force Legato (Select All, then Shift, Tab) combined with Logic's Chase Notes facility (File>Song Settings>MIDI>Chase:Notes). This ensures that Groove Agent receives a Start instruction for the correct pattern wherever you choose to restart the sequencer within the song. Another possible working method would be to use a keyboard or hardware mixing surface mapped to the plug-in's automation parameters, but the Groove Agent/ file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (9 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
Logic combination managed to frustrate most of my best efforts in this area. Assigning external controllers to Groove Agent parameters is easy enough using the automation Learn facility, and elicits the desired response from the instrument's user interface, in that faders will fade and switches will switch. However, it is sometimes possible to modulate on-screen controls without affecting the parameters (ie. producing no audible change) and it seems to be somewhat hit and miss whether automation data will be recorded or not. Occasionally, fader movements were simply not recorded, and in the end, I felt I had to abandon this option as too unreliable for serious work. My next thought was that it might be possible to use Environment objects to send automation data to the sequencer input. You can work out the necessary definitions for the Environment faders by examining the Automation Event list after manually writing some automation moves. If you are not familiar with this Event list (shown above), it is a really useful Event editor dedicated to automation data. Prior to v7 of Logic, it could be accessed by simply holding down the Alt and Logic's Automation Event List. Command/Apple keys and hitting 'E'. It may have lost its default key assignment in the latest version, but the editor is still in there — you just have to set up the key command yourself. Rather as with using a hardware controller, however, I found I could affect on-screen controls, but not record automation data. A quick check with one of Logic's own plug-ins in this configuration established that they don't work that way either, so this one is not actually a Groove Agent problem. It just doesn't feel right to me to conclude that there is no way round Groove Agent's inability to output data within Logic, so I'll go on seeking a reliable solution. In the meantime, if any other Logic-using Groove Agent fans have further suggestions or cunning plans they'd like to share, these would be more than welcome via email or in the SOS Mac forum. The infamous random dropout that was present when running version 1 of Groove Agent under Logic is still evident to some extent. In some songs the audio may simply stop for a bar and then resume, perfectly in sync. Usually, if it has done it once, it will go on doing it at precisely the same place, although sometimes it will stop dropping out in one place and start in another, but never for more than one bar. Sometimes it will stop doing it if you close the song and reopen it, or even simply start playback from a different point. To sidestep this problem, both the manual and the Bornemark web site (www.bornemark.se) suggest that you should open Groove Agent as a multi-channel instrument and always make sure that it is not the active (ie. Thru) track in Logic whilst playing back a Groove Agent track. In my experience, the problem can still occur using this configuration — but it certainly occurs more often if you don't follow that advice. Cycling a section of a Logic arrangement which includes one of these dropout bars will make the problem disappear on all but the first pass and, strangely, delaying the whole Groove Agent instrument track by a few ticks can reduce the length of the dropout, sometimes down to a single beat. Nothing else seems to affect it; not buffer size, other audio activity, nor timing and density of automation data. And it is as likely to happen in the middle of a section where Groove Agent is trundling along repeating a pattern that was triggered 16 bars ago as it is when you hit it file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (10 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
with a fill, a pattern change and an instruction to drop to half time and use the sidestick with a hint of triplet shuffle, all at the same time. Nevertheless, using note-triggering, Force Legato and Chase Notes, combined with Groove Agent running as a multi-channel instrument and deselected as the MIDI Thru instrument, I have gone up to three days without a dropout! I'd hesitate to call it a cure, but it's looking like an acceptable workaround. Version 2 does offer a workaround for Groove Agent's inability to send MIDI note data to a non-Steinberg host in the form of the 'Write to File' facility. As Martin Walker says, if you flip the 'Live < > File' switch under the Setup lid, the plug-in is supposed to generate a MIDI file of its note data that you can import into the song for editing. In practice, I found this to be a rather hit-and-miss affair in Logic. You can't determine where the file goes or what it is called, and sometimes I got one and sometimes I didn't. Sometimes it would only appear when I quit Logic, and other times not at all. Once you've established a working method that suits you, I do recommend making use of Logic's Aux Environment objects to give independent control over Groove Agent's output groups, separating out kick, snare, hi-hat, and perhaps virtual overheads (toms and cymbals) for individual treatment. Logic 7 creates two Aux objects by default, so you will need to create some more (by selecting 'Aux' from the Audio objects list under the 'New' menu in the Environment) and then set Groove Agent's outputs as the Aux objects' input and your audio mix output as their Selecting (right) inputs to Aux objects output (see the screenshots below). from Groove Agent and (far right) Note that Groove Agent numbers its individual outs from Groove Agent to outputs from one to eight (each one a Logic. stereo output), while the Aux objects number them from one to 16. Once you've done that, you can insert individual processing into the different streams, treating the snare and toms to EQ, compression and a reverb, say, while the kick and hi-hat remain dry. You can also send Groove Agent's own ambience to a separate output for even more mixing control. I must also add a caveat for Logic users to Martin's thoughts on Steinberg's new copy protection system (see overleaf). If you save a Logic song with Groove Agent 2 in it and then try to open it without the Steinberg key plugged in, not only will the song not open, but Logic will crash. Hardware key or no, Groove Agent really should fail a little more elegantly than this — if the key isn't present, why can't it simply disable itself within the song like most other plug-ins? One final anomaly; Groove Agent occasionally sounds as though it is gently file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (11 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Steinberg Groove Agent 2
phasing or flanging, almost as if two versions of it are running at the same time, although my Mac's processor metering proves that this cannot be the case. This seems to happen most often during fills (maybe it is just more audible during busier passages), and suggests perhaps that some samples are being triggered twice. 'Suggests'... 'maybe'... 'sometimes'... I accept that that this all sounds somewhat unscientific, but it is almost impossible to be definitive about something as seemingly random as these phenomena. In the end, I just got on with using it and accepted the possibility of having to edit a couple of bars of the final audio to excise any compromised bits and fill in any gaps. On the whole, I still consider the rewards of using Groove Agent to be worth the effort — although I would entirely understand if others didn't, for it manages to be simultaneously the most stimulating and frustrating software tool in my studio. Dave Lockwood Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Steinberg%20Groove%20Agent%202.htm (12 of 12)9/27/2005 9:23:33 PM
Tascam FW1082
In this article:
Installation Front Panel Supported Applications Rear Panel Bundled Software In Use
Tascam FW1082 Firewire Audio & MIDI Interface / Control Surface (Mac/PC) Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Effects
Tascam FW1082 £639 pros Easy installation. High-quality multi-channel audio, plus comprehensive MIDI I/O. Faders are very responsive, and quiet when moving.
Joining the growing market for one-box devices combining audio and MIDI interfacing with controlsurface functionality, Tascam's latest Firewire unit might be all you need for multitrack recording and mixing.
Cubase LE is a bonus.
cons Multi-purpose controls can be a bit confusing to begin with. A more comprehensive list of compatible applications would be useful.
Paul Sellars
The Tascam FW1082 is a combined Firewire audio and MIDI interface and mixer-like control surface for Digital Audio Workstation (DAW) applications summary such as Steinberg's Cubase and The Tascam FW1082 is a MOTU's Digital Performer. According well-built, logically designed to Tascam, it's intended to be 'the device, which provides highquality audio I/O plus effective nerve centre of your digital audio and comfortable hands-on environment', and it certainly looks the control over your DAW. Hard part: a solidly built device, boasting to fault. banks of illuminated buttons, numerous information knobs and nine motorised faders. £639 including VAT. Tascam +44 (0)1923 438880. +44 (0)1923 236290. Click here to email www.tascam.co.uk www.teac.co.jp
Photos: Mike Cameron
The FW1082 is not just a pretty face, however. Its audio facilities support 24-bit recording and playback at sampling rates up to 96kHz, and allow for 10 simultaneous input channels (eight analogue, two digital). In addition it features a 2 x 2 MIDI interface, basic analogue audio mixing, and a versatile programmable control surface. Steinberg's Cubase LE is also included, providing a complete multitrack audio and MIDI recording package (see the 'Bundled Software' box for more details).
Test Spec Tascam FW1082 software version 1.40. Athlon 1.8GHz PC with 512MB RAM, running
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Tascam%20FW1082.htm (1 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:42 PM
Installation
Tascam FW1082
Windows XP Service Pack 2.
Installing the FW1082 is straightforward. The necessary drivers are supplied on a Steinberg Cubase LE version CD-ROM, and after running the installer program it's simply a question of rebooting your machine and attaching the device. Under Windows (2000 or XP) 1.07. the FW1082 supports the ASIO and WDM (MME) standards. Under Mac OS X (10.2.8 or later) Core Audio and Core MIDI are supported. Full marks to Tascam for supplying proper, printed documentation. The user manual and a useful setup guide are both presented on paper, which makes the business of finding your way around a lot easier. Some other useful documents (as well as duplicates of the printed booklets) are supplied as PDF files on the installation CD, but all the most important stuff is covered in print. The FW1082 communicates with the host computer via the IEEE 1394 Firewire protocol. All recent Macs will have suitable connectors already built-in, and PC Firewire support is becoming more universal. It should be pointed that the FW1082's manual specifically warns against connecting the device to the smaller, four-pin variety of IEEE 1394 connectors found on some laptops, recommending that the larger six-pin type be used instead. I experimented very briefly with attaching the FW1082 to my laptop's four-pin connector, and didn't encounter any immediate, obvious problems. Nevertheless, I would be inclined to heed Tascam's warning, and to use a computer with a six-pin connector for all serious work. For the purposes of this review, I installed an inexpensive Belkin PCI IEEE 1394 card in my desktop PC, and it worked without a hitch. Once the drivers are installed, a software control panel is available, from which it's possible to adjust various settings, including ASIO buffer size and sample rate. The control panel can be launched either from within your DAW software, or simply by pressing the Control Panel button on the FW1082's front panel.
Front Panel The FW1082's front panel resembles a conventional mixer in many respects. At the top is the analogue input section, with gain Trim knobs for each of the unit's eight analogue inputs. Each knob is accompanied by a pair of LED indicators. The first of these lights up green to indicate the presence of a signal, while the second lights up red to warn when the input is overloaded (the warning threshold is adjustable). Over in the right-hand corner are three 'mode' keys, which are used to switch the FW1082 between its three different modes of operation. The precise functions of many of the FW1082's other controls depend upon which mode is selected. In Computer Control mode, the FW1082 closely integrates with your computer and DAW software. All fader and knob movements and button presses are transmitted to the computer, and interpreted by the software. Data can be sent back by the computer to adjust fader positions, or illuminate LEDs. Several different control protocols are available — see the 'Supported Applications' box for more details. file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Tascam%20FW1082.htm (2 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:42 PM
Tascam FW1082
In MIDI Control mode, the FW1082's buttons, knobs and faders can be used to control external MIDI devices, and MIDI-capable software applications. The FW1082 has two physical MIDI output sockets, and two 'virtual' output ports which are visible to the host computer. MIDI data is sent to the virtual ports via the Firewire connection. By default, a reasonable set of MIDI controllers is already assigned to the FW1082's controls, but these are all editable via the software control panel.
The FW1082's faders are all touch-sensitive, motorised devices.
In Monitor Mix mode, the FW1082 can be used as a straightforward audio mixer. This allows for easy, zero-latency monitoring of the input signals, and the main audio outputs from the DAW software — ideal for overdubs. You can choose between monitoring only the inputs, only the DAW outputs, or both together. The lower half of the front panel is dominated by the main channel controls. Each of the eight channels has its own fader (a ninth fader controls the master level), illuminated mute and solo buttons, a Select button, and a red LED to indicate recording status. In Computer Control mode, pressing a Select button simply selects the relevant channel in the DAW software. Pressing the red Rec button and the Select button together arms that channel for recording. In Monitor Mix mode, the Select button causes the selected channel's pan position to be indicated by the channel record LEDs: channel 1's LED indicates hard left, channel 8's LED indicates hard right, while channels 4 and 5 illuminated together indicates centre. In MIDI Control mode, each Select button can be programmed to send a control message of your choice. Above and to the right of the channel controls are four encoder knobs, and several associated buttons. In Computer Control mode, these knobs can be used to adjust pan and EQ, and The FW1082 provides eight analogue inputs, four with phantom-powered mic preamps. aux send levels for the selected channel — the exact implementation may vary depending on the DAW software. In MIDI Control mode, they can be programmed to send continuous controller messages, while in Monitor Mix mode, the bottom knob serves as a pan control for the selected channel, and the others do nothing. The FW1082's different modes and multi-function buttons and knobs can be a bit confusing to begin with, but I've probably made them sound more complicated than they are. The front-panel layout is quite logical, and with a little practice it quickly becomes second nature. file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Tascam%20FW1082.htm (3 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:42 PM
Tascam FW1082
Beneath the encoder knobs is a collection of fairly self-explanatory transport controls, which have the same functions in all three modes. There are straightforward rewind, fast-forward, stop, play and record buttons which mirror the DAW software's transport controls, together with a dial for scrubbing backwards or forwards through tracks. There's also a pair of bank selection keys, which can be used to switch the channel controls between banks of eight DAW channels. For instance, if your DAW project has 32 tracks in total, you can use these keys to switch between four groups of eight channels. The motorised faders really come into their own here, swiftly updating their positions to reflect the selected group's settings. Other useful buttons include Locate, Set, In and Out keys, which can be used to move location markers and set punch-in points in DAW software, and four cursor-key buttons for navigating around other on-screen parameters. Finally, there are knobs for setting monitor and headphone levels, plus LEDs to indicate MIDI activity, Firewire connectivity and so on.
Supported Applications A device like the FW1082 is really only useful in conjunction with suitable DAW software, and Tascam have attempted to make it compatible with a variety of different applications. When in Computer Control mode, the FW1082 supports several different control protocols. 'Native Protocol' is the default, and this can be used with Cakewalk's Sonar and MOTU's Digital Performer, via special software plug-ins for each. These plug-ins are included on the installation CD, and in both cases there are detailed PDF installation guides explaining how to get things up and running. 'Mackie Emulation Protocol' allows the FW1082 to imitate the control messages sent by Mackie's Mackie Control device. Theoretically, therefore, any application which supports the Mackie Control should be able to understand the FW1082. In fact, the special 'Cubase LE' protocol built into the FW1082's software control panel appears to be a variant on the Mackie Emulation Protocol, since activating it requires you to add a Mackie Control device in Cubase's preferences. Presumably the same applies to the full Cubase SX, should you have it. 'HUI Emulation Protocol' is much like Mackie Emulation Protocol, except designed with a different Mackie device in mind: the Mackie HUI (Human User Interface). Neither the FW1082 manual nor the Tascam web site makes specific claim to support any other applications apart from Cubase LE, Digital Performer and Sonar, although this may change. Nevertheless, if your preferred application is not one of these, but supports either the Mackie Control or Mackie HUI (or, as in the case of Logic, both), it seems reasonable to assume that it will be possible to get it working with the FW1082. That said, you should certainly ask your local Tascam dealer for a demonstration before parting with any money, just to be sure it works as you want it to.
Rear Panel file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Tascam%20FW1082.htm (4 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:42 PM
Tascam FW1082
The rear panel is where the FW1082's various sockets and connectors can be found, and there's no shortage of these. Two MIDI In and two MIDI Out ports are available, and there are two Firewire ports, although the manual advises against daisy-chaining Firewire devices. Each of the eight input channels has a balanced, line-level quarter-inch jack socket, and channels 1 and 2 also have quarter-inch TRS (tip, ring, sleeve) insert sockets, which can be used to insert an external processor such as a compressor or EQ into the signal path. The input for channel 8 offers switchable impedance suitable for DI'd guitars and basses, while channels 1 to 4 provide XLR connectors and built-in microphone preamps. These sockets can also deliver 48 Volts of phantom power to any mics that require it. The only analogue outputs are a pair of monitor outputs on quarter-inch balanced jacks, and a headphone socket which mirrors these monitor outputs. Digital I/O is provided by a pair of stereo co-axial S/PDIF sockets, on standard RCA connectors. The digital output can be set (via the software control panel) to simply mirror the analogue monitor outputs, or it can be used independently. A further jack socket allows you to use a footswitch to punch in and out of record mode.
Bundled Software Tascam have bundled a couple of useful, mid-range software applications along with the FW1082 hardware: their own Gigastudio 3 LE, and Steinberg's Cubase LE. Gigastudio LE is a 64-voice version of the popular, hard disk streaming software sampler application for Windows XP. It offers many of the same features as the full version including Rewire support and VST plug-in capability, and represents a nice bonus for Windows users. No Mac version is available. Cubase LE, on the other hand, is available for both Windows and Mac OS X. It's a cut-down version of Steinberg's flagship Cubase SX sequencer, and although the bundled version is based on version 1 of SX rather than the current version 3, it's still a powerful audio and MIDI recording, editing and sequencing package in its own right. Up to 48 audio and 64 MIDI tracks are available, and audio tracks can take full advantage of the FW1082's 24-bit, 96kHz capabilities. It also includes Rewire and VST plug-in support, reasonable score editing and printing features, and a very nice time-stretch processor for audio parts. Hardware control surfaces including the FW1082 are, unsurprisingly, supported. An upgrade path to Cubase SX is available, if and when you feel you've outgrown the limitations of Cubase LE.
In Use For all its complexity, the FW1082 is easy to get along with. The analogue signal path is clean and clear, without a hint of noise or interference. The mic preamps sound good, with no obvious coloration. Monitor Mix mode makes zero-latency monitoring easy, but I also found I was able to get sufficiently low latency out of
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Tascam%20FW1082.htm (5 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:42 PM
Tascam FW1082
the FW1082's ASIO drivers that monitoring via software could usually be managed quite comfortably. Integration with Cubase LE is seamless and easy, and recording and playback of fader movements is a no-brainer. The shuttle dial works well, and provides a convenient way to quickly seek back or forwards through a track. (The faders ignore any automation data while the dial is turning, and update themselves when the song position indicator comes to rest, which seems sensible.) A hardware control surface is arguably only as good as its faders, and the FW1082 doesn't disappoint. The eight 60mm channel faders and single master fader are touch-sensitive, allowing the most minute fingertip adjustments to be made, predictably and reliably. No unwanted twitching or sticking here; your virtual faders go where you put them. All nine faders are motorised, well engineered, and very quiet, even when switching banks and sending all eight channels from one The control panel is straightforward, but does extreme to the other. There's a soft everything you need it to. click as the servos activate, before the faders flick up or down to their new positions with barely a sound. On slower automated fades, they're as good as silent. In the past I've worked with cheaper control surfaces, and found myself still habitually reaching for the mouse to make mixer adjustments. Not so here. The FW1082 is very comfortable and responsive, and with judicious use of the various function keys it's possible to get plenty of work done — at least in terms of recording and mixing, if not editing — without touching your computer. Once or twice I found myself wishing that Tascam had fitted independent EQ and aux send knobs for each channel, but to do so would have required a lot more space on the front panel, and doubtless bumped up the manufacturing costs and retail price considerably. MIDI Control mode is a bonus, and some users may seize upon the opportunity to start programming custom controllers for their favourite hardware or software. Many, I suspect, will be more than satisfied with the basic DAW control functions. It's hard to find fault with the FW1082. It's easy to install, quite straightforward to use, and works well. In the course of the couple of weeks I was testing it, it sprung no nasty surprises on me, and gave the impression of being very solidly built and dependable. All in all, it does a convincing job of providing high-quality multi-channel audio, comprehensive MIDI I/O, and a very usable control surface. If you're in the market for a hardware DAW controller, the FW1082 deserves serious consideration. file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Tascam%20FW1082.htm (6 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:42 PM
Tascam FW1082
Published in SOS May 2005
Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Tascam%20FW1082.htm (7 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:42 PM
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW
In this article:
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW
PCI And Firewire Firewire Audio Interface (Mac/PC) Overview Published in SOS May 2005 The Phase 24 Installation Print article : Close window Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW Reviews : Computer Recording System Brief Specifications Summing Up
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW £360 pros Excellent value for money. Individual gain controls on every input. Good subjective audio quality, particularly at 24bit/44.1kHz.
Terratec's range of affordable audio interfaces now includes two attractive Firewire options: the eight-in/ out Phase 88 Rack FW and the two-in/four-out Phase 24 FW. Martin Walker
cons Relatively poor 96kHz performance. Hum on analogue input channel one. Confusing list of differences between the Firewire and PCI versions.
summary While I have a couple of reservations about the audio quality of the Phase 88 Rack FW, it certainly provides excellent value for money, and I suspect it will sell and sell.
information
Terratec's Phase product line aims to offer professional features at bargain prices, and with the introduction of the Phase 88 Rack under review here, it now encompasses PCI, Firewire and USB formats. It offers the popular arrangement of eight analogue inputs and eight analogue outputs, plus a healthy complement of digital I/O, all for a very competitive £360. Although it's based on the Phase 88 card I reviewed in SOS April 2004, this time round the I/O is housed in a very professional-looking rack module rather than a desktop or drive-bay-mounted breakout box, and it also offers new features, such as balanced analogue inputs and outputs, gain controls for all eight inputs, two mic preamps, two MIDI inputs and outputs instead of one, plus the addition of word clock in and out. For just £60 more than the retail price of the Phase 88, this seems excellent value for money — and for those who don't need so much I/O, Terratec also offer the even more affordable Phase 24 FW (see box overleaf).
Phase 88 Rack FW £360; Phase 24 FW £165. Prices include VAT. SCV London +44 (0)20 8418 1470. +44 (0)20 8418 0624. Click here to email www.scvlondon.co.uk www.terratec.com
Photos: Mark Ewing The Phase 88 Rack, in both PCI and Firewire variants, offers eight analogue ins and outs at a highly affordable price.
Test Spec
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Terratec%20Phase%2088%20Rack%20FW.htm (1 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:50 PM
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW Windows XP driver version 1.19. Hardware: Intel Pentium 4C 2.8GHz processor with Hyperthreading, Asus P4P800 Deluxe motherboard with Intel 865PE chip set running 800MHz front side buss, 1GB DDR400 RAM, and Windows XP with Service Pack 2. Tested with Cakewalk Sonar 4.0, NI Pro 53, Rightmark Audio Analyser 5.4, Steinberg Cubase SX 3.0 and Wavelab 5.00a, Tascam Gigastudio 160 v3.04.
PCI And Firewire Hopefully, not too many musicians will get confused between the existing Phase 88 and the new Phase 88 Rack, but things get more complicated: the Phase 88 Rack is itself available in two different models, which outwardly look almost identical. The packaging simply states 'Alternative PCI or Firewire interface', but you don't get both options in the same box — whereas the rack unit of the PCI version has a D-type connector on the back panel and is bundled with the associated Phase 88 PCI card interface, the Phase 88 Rack FW sports two Firewire connectors and a front-panel Firewire logo. If you buy the PCI version you can retrofit Terratec's optional Firewire interface (and vice versa according to the manual), but the box I received showed no indication of which model it contained. There are quite a number of differences between the two, as I'll explain. The PCI version has drivers that With a comprehensive monitor mixer, clear support Windows 98SE, Me, 2000, XP display of clock settings, and software switching of mic/line input sensitivity, the and Mac OS X Core Audio/MIDI, and Terratec Control Panel provides its S/PDIF I/O is provided in co-axial comprehensive control over the Rack FW. format on the PCI card. This card is identical to the one bundled with the original Phase 88 model, which means that you can internally synchronise the Phase 88 Rack PCI with other Terratec products including the Phase 88 and EWS 88MT/D and EWS Mic 2/8, using the on-card Sync In and Out connectors. The PCI drivers support up to four cards, so you can achieve up to 40 simultaneous audio inputs and outputs. However, if you want to switch between word clock or S/PDIF external clock, you have to do it using a jumper on the PCI card — not much fun once it's fitted inside your computer! Meanwhile, the Firewire version only supports Windows XP SP1 and higher or Mac OS 10.3.4 or higher, cannot at present be cascaded to expand the I/O totals, and loses the card's co-axial S/PDIF I/O in favour of a pair of optical Toslink connectors on the rack's rear panel. This time you can freely switch between word clock and S/PDIF clock using the Control Panel utility. Finally, if you power up the unit without a Firewire connection, the Rack FW version can be used as a stand-alone A-D/D-A converter box, and you can even alter its digital mixer settings in real time using MIDI controller data, instead of using the software Control Panel.
Overview
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Terratec%20Phase%2088%20Rack%20FW.htm (2 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:50 PM
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW
We received the Firewire version of the Phase 88 Rack for review, although as I noted, there was nothing on the box to indicate which version was inside. It was bundled with a generous four-metre-long six-pin to six-pin Firewire cable, a fourpin to six-pin adaptor for laptop use, and associated 12V AC wall-wart power supply — like many others, this interface can't be powered from the Firewire buss. The front panel contains a pair of XLR mic input sockets, a pair of five-pin DIN MIDI In and Out sockets, eight input gain controls with associated signal and clipping LEDs, a button providing global 48V phantom power for the mic inputs, and an LED power indicator. The rear panel houses 16 quarter-inch jack sockets for unbalanced/balanced operation of the eight line inputs and outputs, the second MIDI In and Out, S/PDIF optical in and out, a 15-pin connector for the supplied word clock breakout cable which terminates in a pair of BNC sockets, the PSU input socket, and the interface panel, which is different for FW and PCI versions. On the Firewire review model this panel houses an identical pair of Firewire sockets, plus four LEDs to indicate successful IEEE 1394 communication, word clock selected, external clock sync (from S/PDIF or word clock), and valid sync. My only layout quibble is that these indicators would be much better placed on the front panel; thankfully, the software utility displays successful sync each time you change sample rate, which does provide reasonable feedback.
The Phase 24 Along with the Phase 88 Rack FW described in the main text, Terratec also sent their Phase 24 FW, a compact interface with a single pair of balanced analogue inputs and outputs on the back panel, plus S/ PDIF co-axial in and out, single MIDI In and Out, and a further unbalanced stereo output on the front panel with thumbwheel level control, which can either be used for headphones or another stereo line output. It's housed in an attractive and robust metal case and bundled with its own Velcro-sealed carrycase. Unlike its stablemate, the Unlike its larger brother, the Phase 24 FW can be powered from the Firewire buss. Phase 24 FW can be powered from the Firewire buss, but a 9V AC wallwart is also supplied for those whose computers only offer four-pin Firewire ports. Unlike the Phase 88 Rack FW, the 24 FW's converters support sample rates up to 192kHz, and it provides a typical 109dBA signal-to-noise ratio for its A-D converters — 9dB quieter than the Rack — and 111dBA for the D-A converters, again slightly better than its big brother. Its drivers are also totally different,
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Terratec%20Phase%2088%20Rack%20FW.htm (3 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:50 PM
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW
although they too support only Windows XP SP1 or Mac OS 10.3.4 or later. The Control Panel provides a useful relay-switched low/mid/high sensitivity option for the inputs to cope with different signal levels, and a similar range of monitor mixer settings to its bigger brother. I confirmed the 109dBA dynamic range at 44.1kHz sample rate using Rightmark's Audio Analyser, and as expected, this dropped slightly to 103dBA at 96kHz and 101dBA at 192kHz, although the analogue bandwidth didn't extend at all at these higher rates, with a -0.5dB point just above 20kHz in each case. Nevertheless, my usual double-blind listening tests against my own Emu 1820M and Echo Mia soon showed that once again the Emu's low-jitter clock provide the most focused and warm sound, closely followed by the Phase 24 (giving it similar audio quality to the 192kHz-capable converters of both M Audio's Audiophile 192 and ESI's Julia), with the Mia slightly behind with a touch of harshness from its its AK4528 converters. Driver quality seemed good too: as with the Phase 88 Rack FW I managed a 2.2ms ASIO latency in Cubase SX 3, while the GSIF driver once again worked faultlessly, even when I allocated the same pair of outputs to each application. The MME-WDM drivers were again multi-channel, but performed well. Overall, I was impressed with this robust and straightforward interface, which provides excellent audio quality for the price, and as many ins and outs as many musicians will ever need for either a desktop or laptop setup. It looks good, sounds good, and is easy on the pocket — what more could you ask?
Installation As usual, I installed the drivers for Windows XP, and for the first time ever found that the manufacturer had supplied me with a CD-R containing drivers newer than those on the web site. Terratec are unusual in providing their GSIF drivers for Gigastudio owners as a separate install option, but I had no problems getting the MME-WDM, ASIO and GSIF drivers installed, along with the associated Control Panel utility. Although the software installation appeared to be successful, the review unit initially refused to record or play back any audio at all. After much investigation I eventually traced the problem to a bad connection between the circuit boards, which was resolved by re-seating the digital board into the main circuit board. Terratec subsequently confirmed that this was due to a design flaw in early production units, which they have now solved by adding an additional bracket inside the case. If you find that your unit is affected by this problem, contact your country's Terratec distributor and they will replace it with a new one, free of charge. I also encountered some hum on analogue input one — not enough to be audible at normal listening levels, but significantly worse than the other seven inputs. This might have been a fault specific to the review unit, but shouldn't happen. Opening the case did let me confirm that the Phase 88 Rack uses the same AK4524 converters as its EWS88MT and Phase 88 predecessors. The Control Panel of the Phase 88 Rack is likewise almost identical to that of the Phase 88, apart from extra options to switch inputs 7/8 between the rear-panel Line sockets file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Terratec%20Phase%2088%20Rack%20FW.htm (4 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:50 PM
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW
and the front-panel Mic sockets. However, for the Firewire series Terratec have streamlined various features. The largest area is devoted to the Digital Mixer, used for monitoring purposes, with level sliders, mute and stereo link buttons for the eight analogue inputs, the stereo digital input (greyed out until a valid signal is detected), and for any two of the eight analogue or two digital WAV playback channels. These signals are mixed together and then sent to the Master section, which has its own master fader, mute and stereo link buttons, while its routing selector lets you decide where the stereo output of the mixer is routed, chosen from the four stereo pairs of analogue outputs, the stereo digital output, or 'Mixer Off', which leaves all physical outputs routed by default to the appropriate WAV playback channel. The peak-reading level meters of the Phase 88 and Phase 88 Rack PCI are omitted on the Firewire rack version, as are the multi-card selections, both The Phase 88 Rack becomes a Firewire presumably because of bandwidth device thanks to the inclusion of an interface considerations. The Master Clock board with two Firewire sockets and some sync LEDs. section provides a useful extra S/PDIF Detection indicator, but its Internal/ External, sample rate, and external clock rate detection displays are almost identical. Terratec's previous EWS 88MT and Phase 88 have suffered from ground-loop problems in some setups, and one of the benefits of the Phase 88 Rack's fully balanced analogue I/O is that for those with compatible gear, most ground-loop problems disappear. I certainly found it quiet and relatively clean, and despite using exactly the same converters, the Phase 88 Rack FW managed a dynamic range of 100dBA at 24-bit/44.1kHz, exactly in line with the manufacturer's spec, and 4dB better than the Phase 88. At 96kHz both models had slightly worse background noise levels of 99dBA, but the dynamic range of the Rack model dropped to 93dBA due to the presence of a crop of low-level spectral lines above 1kHz. Its 96kHz frequency response was also -0.5dB down at 20kHz compared with the 44kHz of the Phase 88, although at the low end it was more extended, being only -0.2dB down at 4Hz. Stereo crosstalk figures for the Rack model measured about 4dB better, although 50Hz hum levels were about 8dB higher — not that this will usually be audible. So how did it sound in subjective terms? My double-blind listening tests of the Phase 88 Rack FW against my own Emu 1820M and Echo Mia cards produced some interesting findings. I consistently picked out the Phase 88 Rack as having the warmest sound, possibly because its frequency response is the most extended at the low end, albeit by only 0.05dB at 20Hz. I could also pick out the slight harshness of the Mia, and the most natural sound of the Emu. Overall, the Emu came out on top yet again — as you might expect, given its more expensive converters and low-jitter clock — but I preferred the warm yet clear sound of the Phase 88 Rack to the Mia, even though the latter has a significantly better dynamic range. Technical specs don't always provide the final word.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Terratec%20Phase%2088%20Rack%20FW.htm (5 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:50 PM
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW
I had no problems using the mic inputs, although there's a hefty click when you switch between mic/line sensitivity using the Control Panel, so turn your monitors down first. The S/PDIF and MIDI I/O also worked fine. Driver quality seemed good too — I didn't quite achieve the lowest available ASIO latency setting of 2.0ms on my PC when running Cubase SX 3, but did manage a very close 2.2ms, and the GSIF driver also worked faultlessly with Gigastudio, even when I allocated the same pair of outputs to each application. The MME-WDM drivers are multi-channel, like those of many recent interfaces. This makes them more difficult to use with applications that prefer their drivers to show up as multiple stereo pairs, but they managed a very typical 45ms Play Ahead setting in NI's Pro 53, while the Direct Sound drivers achieved a better than average 25ms. Sonar's lowest successful Effective Latency with the WDM drivers proved to be a reasonably good 10.2ms, but in ASIO mode I once again achieved 2.2ms.
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW Brief Specifications Sample rates: 32, 44.1, 48, 88.2 and 96 kHz from internal clock. Analogue inputs: eight, balanced/unbalanced TRS quarter-inch jack, 33dB gain range, inputs 7 and 8 switchable to balanced mic sensitivity on XLR sockets, with optional global +48V phantom power. Analogue outputs: eight, balanced/unbalanced TRS quarter-inch jack. Digital I/O: S/PDIF in and out on Toslink optical (FW model) or phono co-axial (PCI model), word clock in and out, two MIDI Ins and Outs. A-D converters: 24-bit 64x oversampling (part of AK4524 codec chip). Input SNR: 100dBA typical at 48kHz sample rate. D-A converters: 24-bit 128x oversampling (part of AK4524 codec chip). Output SNR: 109dBA typical at 48kHz sample rate. Frequency response: not stated.
Summing Up Terratec always seem to provide great value for money with their products, although sometimes the clever shortcuts they take to keep their prices keen can end up being confusing to the user. I was, for instance, a little puzzled about the differences between the PCI and Firewire variants, and slightly concerned by the problems I had getting the review model to work. Nevertheless, the Phase 88 Rack FW provides good subjective audio quality, even though its AKM 4524 converters are outclassed by many more recent designs (including its cheaper Phase 24 stablemate!), and £360 is an excellent retail price for an eight-in/eightout analogue product.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Terratec%20Phase%2088%20Rack%20FW.htm (6 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:50 PM
Terratec Phase 88 Rack FW
If you're prepared to pay a little more, you could consider the greater number of inputs provided by Guillemot's Hercules 1612 FW or the ADAT expansion potential of M Audio's Firewire 1814, but the closest competitor to the Phase 88 Rack FW must be Edirol's FA101, now selling on the street at around the same price. It also offers fully balanced analogue I/O with two mic input options, but in its favour one of these can be switched to high-impedance instrument mode for use with guitars; it also has an additional headphone output, supports 192kHz sample rate, can be powered from the Firewire buss, and its case is half the size, making it more suitable for location work. On the other hand, the Phase 88 Rack FW offers twice as many MIDI inputs and outputs, handy individual level controls on each analogue input, and it looks more impressive when mounted in a rack! Only you can decide which feature set is more appropriate to your needs — Terratec have just made your final choice just that little bit more difficult. Published in SOS May 2005 Sound On Sound, Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill, Cambridge CB3 8SQ, UK. Email:
[email protected] | Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888 | Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2005. All rights reserved. The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers. Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Terratec%20Phase%2088%20Rack%20FW.htm (7 of 7)9/27/2005 9:23:50 PM
Ursa Major Space Station
In this article:
Connectivity & Internal Processing Control Layout In Use Sounds Of The '70s
Ursa Major Space Station Digital Reverb & Effects Processor Published in SOS May 2005 Print article : Close window
Reviews : Effects
Ursa Major Space Station £899 pros Accurate recreation of the original SST282 algorithms. Vintage sound character and effects. Attractive control surface. Sophisticated new Room program.
The original 3U monster that was the SST282 Space Station has been reissued by Seven Woods Audio as this small desktop unit. Not content merely to offer all the classic sounds, though, the new incarnation has a number of fresh tricks up its sleeve...
cons Only digital I/O. No preset memories. Imposing handbook. No block diagram to explain controls.
summary An accurate recreation of the original Space Station's effects using modern technology in a very compact and elegant package. Supplemented with a brandnew and highly sophisticated Room algorithm, plus updated wide-bandwidth versions of the original SST echo and reverb programs.
information £899 including VAT. DACS Audio +44 (0)191 438 2500. +44 (0)191 438 2511. Click here to email www.dacs-audio.com www.seven woodsaudio.com
Hugh Robjohns
The Ursa Major Space Station — the original SST282 3U rackmounting monster — was launched in 1978 as one of the first generation of digital reverbs, competing directly with the classic EMT 250. The Space Station was a multitap delay-based device providing echo, ambience, and reasonable reverb effects, and it remained on sale for the best part of a decade, until technology advances allowed far more sophisticated products at much lower prices. To remove any confusion, let me just clarify that Ursa Major was the name of the company (based in Belmont, USA) which was set up by Christopher Moore to produce the Space Station. It quickly became a classic reverb — more than a reverb really — and its contribution became an identifiable element of much music of the time, especially as a guitar and vocal effect. In fact, the mystique of the Space Station has remained, and Chris Moore, working with Princeton Digital, has already produced a software replica of the Space Station as a TDM plug-in for the Pro Tools platform. Princeton Digital have been involved in the recreation of several vintage digital products, including the Eventide SP2016 reviewed back in SOS May 2004. The new hardware incarnation of the Space Station has been produced by a company called Seven Woods Audio, again with the direct involvement of the
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Ursa%20Major%20Space%20Station.htm (1 of 6)9/27/2005 9:24:00 PM
Ursa Major Space Station
originator Chris Moore. It has acquired a new model number along the way — SST206 — and has shrunk from a 3U rackmount beast to what initially appears to be a remote control but is, in fact, the entire unit! It has also gained a new state-of-the-art algorithm to supplement the original echo and reverb effects. The handbook includes a note from Chris Moore to explain that the new Room program is the 'best reverb that I know how to create with today's best hardware'.
Connectivity & Internal Processing The heart of the new Space Station is a single 140MHz Motorola DSP chip programmed with faithful recreations of the original Space Station's algorithms, some updated versions, plus the new Room reverb. The unique aspect, though, is that the unit is packaged in a slim panel with wooden side cheeks, which is designed to sit on a desk. It measures just 165 x 127 x 150mm (hwd) and weighs next to nothing, with a four-metre connecting cable which terminates in a pair of XLR connectors and a compact universal mains power supply. The latter accepts the usual IEC mains lead and operates on AC voltages from 90V to 260V, consuming less than one Watt of power. Audio connections are provided only in digital form, with stereo AES input and output provided on flying XLR connectors. The SST206 is a stereo output device, like the original, but where it differs is that it accepts a stereo source where the original was a mono-input device. However, the stereo input is a convenient byproduct of adopting the AES input format, and the stereo input is summed to mono to feed the delay/reverb processor. A dedicated Dry Level control allows a percentage of the stereo source signal to be passed through to the stereo outputs, if required. The unit is optimised for use at a 48kHz sampling rate with 24-bit resolution. It will also operate happily at 44.1kHz and even 32kHz — although the control calibration will be inaccurate at these lower sample rates since the delay and decay times are related to the sampling rate. Similarly, it can also be used at 88.2kHz and 96kHz (but only with the SST Reverb and Echo programs), with proportionally shorter delay and decay times again.
Control Layout The original Space Station (and its TDM plug-in version) was driven via a combination of rotary controls and buttons which configured the delay line's outputs and feedback paths in various ways. The fundamental design involved 24 separate delay-line taps. One was used for the echo effect, feeding back to the input through a decay control. In the reverb mode, the delay time of 15 taps was modulated before being fed back to the input. The last eight taps were called the Audition Delay Taps and were configured in pairs to feed the processor's stereo outputs. The buttons selected from 16 different tap configurations to file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Ursa%20Major%20Space%20Station.htm (2 of 6)9/27/2005 9:24:00 PM
Ursa Major Space Station
provide different effect characters and overall decay times. The new version shares the same delay-line topology, but employs twelve rotary controls to configure the unit: two black, three red, four blue (all with pointers and calibrated from zero to 10), and two without pointers. This last pair select the required program and delay tap pattern, which are indicated with LEDs. There is also a small bar-graph meter to show the summed input level, calibrated for -30, 15, -6 and 0dBFS levels. The controls are all clearly labelled in white against a dark-grey background, making the unit very easy on the eye. The first black control sets the input level, while a blue control underneath sets the level of dry input signal sent to the outputs. The next black control sets the echo delay time (and doubles as the pre-delay time control for the new Room program). The red knobs adjust the overall decay with separate tweaks for the LF and HF decay times. The decay time is essentially a feedback control, passing some of the delay-line's output back to the input to extend the effective decay time. The input to the delay line passes through a simple bass/treble equaliser controlled with the LF and HF decay-time parameters, so these enable the character of the reverb or echoes to be tailored to simulate dark or bright spaces. The last four blue knobs control the eight delay taps which generate the stereo output signal. The actual delay times associated with each pair of delay taps are governed by the Audition Delay Pattern, as set by one of the plain black knobs. The options include echo, two slap effects, two delay cluster settings called 'fatty' and 'cloud', three space repeats, four rooms, and four comb-filter effects.
A multicore cable protruding from the top of the new SST206 Space Station transports power and AES digital audio signals.
The tap outputs are controlled in pairs, with the odd-numbered taps feeding the left channel and the even-numbered taps feeding the right channel. By varying the levels of the different taps, the character of the effect can be changed dramatically, and this is completely independent of the Echo Delay and Decay Time parameters — the virtually unlimited combinations make this a very versatile machine. However, it is worth pointing out that the SST206 has no facility for factory or user presets — you have to create and adjust the desired effect manually each time you use the machine. For some, that will be a creative pleasure, while others will find it an intellectual challenge, depending on their respective points of view! Furthermore, the operation is not particularly intuitive at first sight, and the new model lacks the block-diagram graphic of the original to help explain what each control is doing. However, with a little practice and familiarity it soon becomes easy to adjust the parameters as required, and it is rewarding to create and shape the wanted effect.
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Ursa%20Major%20Space%20Station.htm (3 of 6)9/27/2005 9:24:00 PM
Ursa Major Space Station
The two original progams — the SST Echo and SST Reverb — each have two variations, as mentioned earlier. The accurate original algorithms impose a 7kHz bandwidth to the delayed signal with an 80dB dynamic range (11 bit), indicated with a steady-mode LED. The updated version is indicated with a flashing LED and provides a full 20kHz (or greater) bandwidth with 120dB dynamic range. It also boasts less modulation noise in the reverb mode and an 'infinite delay' in the echo mode. The all-new Room program is a more conventional (in the modern sense) reverb algorithm featuring a true stereo input. When in this mode some of the controls take on new functions — Echo Delay becomes a Pre Delay, and the four output tap controls adjust early-reflection delay time and level, reverb level, and room size. The Delay Pattern control determines the length of the early reflections. This algorithm uses the full power of the Motorola DSP to generate a very sophisticated and natural-sounding reverb, which compares very well indeed to the professional Lexicon and TC effects. However, the mode can only be used at 44.1kHz an 48kHz.
In Use The supplied handbook takes quite a bit of reading, made harder by the dense and uninviting layout. However, there is a lot of helpful information in there on how to get the best from the SST206 — which is needed given the less-thanintuitive controls. It is a great shame that the very clear and simple block diagram that featured so prominently on the original could not be squeezed onto the new control surface, and its ommision from the handbook is inexcusable. They say a picture is worth a thousand words and that was never truer than in this case! Hooking the Space Station up was simple enough. I used it in conjunction with a Yamaha DM1000 console, configuring a pair of AES inputs and outputs from one of the interface cards to act as an aux send and effects return. Since the device is optimised for operation at 48kHz, I performed most tests at that sample rate, although some material required me to use 44.1kHz, and I also ran a brief test at 96kHz. Although the parameters all become 10 percent larger at 44.1kHz, this has little practical effect on the character of the processing. With double-samplerate operation, the new Room reverb mode is unavailable, of course, and all the other parameters have half their original delay lengths — which does have a significant knock-on effect for the sound and character of some effects, especially the longer delays and reverbs, for obvious reasons. It's not impossible to use the SST206 at 88.2kHz or 96kHz, but it becomes a lot less versatile and flexible. As a result, I ended up using the slightly bizarre combination of a D-A/A-D converter combination on the input with a sample-rate converter on the output to allow me to operate the Space Station at 48kHz with 96kHz source material. Given that I wanted to use a particular effect with a 7kHz bandwidth, the lack of 24-bit/96kHz integrity hardly seemed to matter!
file:///H|/SOS%2005-05/Ursa%20Major%20Space%20Station.htm (4 of 6)9/27/2005 9:24:00 PM
Ursa Major Space Station
Sounds Of The '70s The sound of the SST206 is impressive, both in the original 'vintage' mode and with the full bandwidth and dynamic range. There is something special about the way the delay effects are generated and controlled that gives it a unique character — perhaps it is the slightly imperfect and grainy quality. Similarly, the SST Reverb mode has a quality that is identifiably 'vintage' yet eminently usable, especially for ADT and flutter echoes on keyboard and guitar parts, and for applying grungy, analogue-like delay effects to vocals. The original Space Station was designed and used at a time when recording engineers were technically minded and were used to having to configure equipment by hand to create the desired effects. These days, I suspect 80 percent of home-studio users rely entirely on factory presets, particularly in the case of reverb and delay effects — partly through laziness and partly because the sophistication of modern effects processors makes manual adjustment a complex business. However, the new SST206 demands personal creative input to create and shape every single effect. Given the digital technology involved, it does seem strange that factory and user presets are not available, and that favourite settings therefore have to be noted on the supplied control template. A technical understanding of what is going on under the panel is not essential for creating interesting and appropriate effects, but it certainly helps. Having said that, I dare say many will discover suitable effects simply through semi-random knob-twiddling — the range and diversity of sounds available in the SST206 is vast. The new room reverb is a very classy effect, with a very lifelike quality. A good ex