Whatever the outcome of the current constitutional reforms, the Soviet Union remains a military superpower with global ...
315 downloads
3789 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Whatever the outcome of the current constitutional reforms, the Soviet Union remains a military superpower with global security interests. The doctrines, practices, and capabilities of its still formidable armed forces are shaping world politics just at the time that the future of the country that created them is in doubt. This is the first book to examine the Soviet defense outlook and military forces in the light of these developments. In Soviet strategy and new military thinking, a group of leading strategists and
Sovietologists, writing from within the US national security community, analyzes the unprecedented changes, as well as the troubling continuities, that characterize Soviet military thinking during the 1990s. The authors confront the range of Soviet military strengths, including intercontinental nuclear power, conventional ground forces, and naval capabilities and special operations. They address questions of weapons research and development, military planning and policy-making, and the role of civilian critics on Soviet military objectives. Other chapters explore the Soviet Army's diminished influence on Eastern Europe as well as the lessons of Afghanistan. Based on primary Soviet sources and extensive personal experiences, Soviet strategy and new military thinking is an authoritative and comprehen-
sive evaluation of Soviet military power amid kaleidoscopic political and strategic change. It will guide a wide range of readers through largely unmapped oceans. Soviet strategy will be studied by specialists in international and Soviet affairs (including journalists and both political and military leaders), as well as by businessmen and other concerned citizens whose own well-being may be shaped by the Soviet future.
Soviet strategy and new military thinking
For Nancy Hemingway, Katharine, and their mom, JW: Peace hath her victories no less renowned than war
Soviet strategy and new military thinking Edited by Derek Leebaert and Timothy Dickinson
The right of the University of Cambridge to print and sell all manner of books was granted by Henry VIII in 1534. The University has printed and published continuously since 1584.
Cambridge University Press New York Port Chester Melbourne Sydney
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, Sao Paulo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www. Cambridge. org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521404297 © Cambridge University Press 1992 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 1992 A catalogue recordfor this publication is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data Soviet strategy and new military thinking / edited by Derek Leebaert and Timothy Dickinson. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 0 521 40429 0 (hard). - ISBN 0 521 40769 9 (paper) I. Soviet Union - Military policy. 2. Strategy. I. Leebaert, Derek. II. Dickinson, Timothy, 1943UA770.S669 1991 355'.033547-dc20 90-19959 CIP ISBN 978-0-521-40429-7 hardback ISBN 978-0-521-40769-4 paperback Transferred to digital printing 2008
Contents
Notes on contributors Foreword Acknowledgements 1
The stakes of power DEREK LEEBAERT
Part I
Soviet nuclear strategy and new military thinking COLIN S. GRAY 3 The tightening frame: mutual security and the future of strategic arms limitation RAYMOND L. GARTHOFF
Soviet theater forces on a descending path EDWARD B. ATKESON 5 Protection from one's friends: the disintegration of the Warsaw Pact CHRISTOPHER JONES 6 Red Star of the sea: the Soviet Navy and strategic policy GAEL DONELAN TARLETON
7
29
57
Below the threshold
4
Part III
1
The instruments of power
2
Part II
page ix xii xv
81
100 127
Managing the mission
Counter-insurgency and the lessons of Afghanistan DAVID ISBY 8 New weapons and the attempts at technical change MIKHAIL TSYPKIN
157 187
vn
viii
Contents
9
A generation too late: civilian analysis and Soviet military thinking BENJAMIN S. LAMBETH 10 The other side of the hill: Soviet military foresight and forecasting JACOB W. KIPP Index
217
248
276
Notes on contributors
The Editors DEREK LEEBAERT is a professor of management in Georgetown University's Graduate School of Business Administration. He also works on strategic planning, and on technology issues and applications, for the US Department of Defense and for industry. While a post-doctoral fellow at Harvard University's Center for Science and International Affairs in the 1970s, Professor Leebaert was a founding editor of both International Security and the Journal of Policy Analysis and Management. He was also a founding editor of The International Economy in 1987. He has a DPhil in economics from Oxford University and previously was a Ford Fellow at MIT. graduated from Magdalen College, Oxford, where he studied with A. J. P. Taylor. He has been an editor of Harper's magazine and of the Paris Review, He has taught military strategy at the MidCareer Officer's Program in the US Department of Defense, and he serves as a management consultant in the financial and information technology services sectors.
TIMOTHY DICKINSON
The Authors COLIN GRAY is president of the National Institute for Public Policy. He served on the President's General Advisory Committee on Arms Control and Disarmament from 1982 until 1987, and has also served on advisory panels for Congress' Office of Technology Assessment, the Department of the Army, and the Department of the Air Force. He teaches National Security Studies at Georgetown University. Dr. Gray has been Assistant Director of the International Institute for Strategic Studies (London) and Director of National Security Studies at the Hudson Institute. He has a DPhil from Oxford, and his books include The Geopolitics of Super Power, Strategy for War and Peace, and Nuclear Strategy and National Style. ix
x
Notes on contributors
RAYMOND L. GARTHOFF is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, having retired from the US Foreign Service in which he last served as ambassador to Bulgaria. In the 1970s, he was the Executive Secretary and Senior Advisor on the SALT I delegation, and served as Deputy Director of the State Department's Bureau of Politico-Military Affairs. He has a PhD in political science from Yale and is the author of several landmark books, including Detente and Confrontation, Soviet Military Policy, Soviet Strategy in the Nuclear Age, Soviet Military Doctrine, and Reflections on the Cuban Missile Crisis. EDWARD B. ATKESON is a professor at the Defense Intelligence College in Washington, DC. From 1982-84, he served as the National Intelligence Officer for General Purpose Forces at the CIA, being the principal advisor and assistant to the Director on matters concerning foreign general purpose forces. Previous responsibilities include being Commanding General of the US Army Concepts Analysis Agency, Deputy Chief of Staff for Intelligence, US Army Europe, Director of the Office of Policy and Planning for the Intelligence Community Staff in Washington, and Deputy Director of the US Army War College. General Atkeson's books are Thinking Red in War Games and The Final Argument of Kings: Reflections on the Art of War. He has been a Fellow at the Center for International Affairs and is a graduate of the Advanced Management Program, both at Harvard University. He has a BS from the US Military Academy and an MBA from Syracuse University. CHRISTOPHER JONES is a professor at the Jackson School of International
Studies of the University of Washington. From 1977-81, Dr. Jones was a Fellow at Harvard University's Russian Research Center. He is author of Soviet Influence in Eastern Europe: Political Autonomy and the Warsaw Pact and co-author with Professor Teresa Rakowska Harmstone of The Warsaw Pact: The Question of Cohesion, vols. 1-4. is a policy analyst at Science Applications International Corporation. Until 1991, she served as Chief of the Strategic Analysis Office at the Defense Intelligence Agency, Washington, DC. She has analyzed Soviet strategic issues within the intelligence community for over a decade.
GAEL TARLETON
DAVID ISBY is a Washington, DC attorney and a national security analyst for
unattributable US government agencies. His books include Weapons and Tactics of the Soviet Army and War in a Distant Country: Afghanistan's Invasion and Resistance. He has traveled extensively with the Afghan resistance.
Notes on contributors
xi
MIKHAIL TSYPKIN is Assistant Professor of National Security Affairs, and Coordinator of Soviet and East European Studies, at the Naval Post Graduate School. He consults for the Center for Naval Warfare Studies at the US Naval War College, and for System Planning Corporation in Washington, DC. He has a PhD in Political Science, and an MA in Soviet Studies, from Harvard University. is Senior Social Scientist at The Rand Corporation, where he has served for more than fifteen years, recently as Director, International Security and Defense Policy Program. He has an extensive background in military aeronautics as a pilot and theorist. Dr. Lambeth's latest book is Understanding Soviet Defense Policy. He has a PhD in political science from Harvard and an MA from Georgetown University.
BENJAMIN LAMBETH
JACOB w. KIPP is Senior Analyst at the Soviet Army Studies Office, US Army Combined Arms Center, at Fort Leavenworth, and a professor of history at the University of Kansas. He also serves as the assistant editor of The Journal of Soviet Military Studies, and has held a Fulbright Fellowship in Poland. Dr. Kipp edited the book Soviet Aviation and Airpower. His PhD and MA in history are from Pennsylvania State University. Foreword is a recent Chairman of the Council of the International Institute for Strategic Studies. He is a Deputy Chairman of the Midland Bank, Chairman of Samuel Montagu & Co. Limited, and a director of a number of other companies. He was Permanent Under Secretary of the Foreign Office from 1975-82.
THE RIGHT HON. SIR MICHAEL PALLISER GCMG
Foreword
Into an Unmapped Ocean For over half a century the world has accepted at face value the description of that vast land mass stretching from Eastern Europe to the Far East as "a Union of Soviet Socialist Republics." This has been in spite of the exceptional variety of ethnic, cultural and climatic diversity within that presumed monolith. A unitary view of the Soviet Union has its roots in the long development of Tsarist Russian colonial-style empire followed, after 1917, by its brutal integration and consolidation under Lenin and Stalin and the almost equally brutal extension of that empire into Europe after World War II. Despite the appalling damage the Soviet Union suffered during the war, it emerged as a looming menace and awesome power - one which soon included nuclear power. Its vast resources were coupled with clearly stated malevolence towards the West. We knew Khrushchev was wrong when he proclaimed in 1961 that the Soviet Union would "bury" the West economically. But his arrogant claim had a certain plausibility to the so-called non-aligned world, which itself included countries slowly emerging from the West's own colonial rule. It carried conviction too within the Soviet Union, where claims of that sort were most needed to reassure peoples still forced to accept hopelessly a minimal standard of living. Thirty years ago now seems like ancient history. The emptiness of Khrushchev's boast increasingly became evident to the Soviet citizens themselves and to the world outside. But Moscow continued to govern in a style that discouraged any honest political or economic introspection. Meanwhile, the West saw commitments of Soviet resources to military programs as well as continuing Soviet efforts to destabilize those parts of the world where Western interests were at stake. Recent change in the Soviet Union has been so fundamental in scale and scope - political, military and economic - as to be difficult to comprehend. Perhaps it is even more difficult for Soviet citizens to comprehend - let alone to manage - the change. Political freedom and economic realism are a heady mix for a huge and turbulent country that has never known either. xii
Foreword
xiii
We go further into the 1990s with a singular and disquieting uncertainty about the likely future of the world's second superpower, if indeed it is still possible so to describe it. Nor is it reassuring to observe that no one inside the Soviet Union is much clearer about it than we are. Many in the West have applauded Gorbachev's declared objectives in his own country and would like to help - without knowing precisely what that might imply. Unfortunately, it is unclear whether Gorbachev or any other Soviet leader is carrying the majority of the people with him. What are the implications for "the West" - a term that I believe still has meaning, even if developments in Eastern Europe tend to blur boundaries and widen definitions? We must address two issues - the first primarily politico-military, the second primarily politico-economic. The issues are equally important and are, in essence, two sides of a coin. They involve our mutual security and, as in this book, they need to be addressed simultaneously. We face a politico-military dilemma. It arises out of the justifiable and correct sense among our peoples that, if the cold war is over and the Warsaw Pact dissolved, we should finally be able to beat our swords into plowshares; or most of them. The dilemma is how to respond to that popular expression of good sense, while at the same time insuring militarily against the unpredictable. Clearly, the Soviet future is dangerously unpredictable. And the invasion of Kuwait reminds us of the range of terrifying unpredictabilities elsewhere. So there is a continuing need for a sustained, if modified, Western security policy and defense effort. Above all, there is the need for a continuing alliance - political, military and economic - between North America and Western Europe, and between them and Japan, which, after all is not only Asia's dominant economic force but also the militarily potent eastern neighbor of the Soviet Union and China. Whatever happens, the Soviet Union (or whatever might emerge) will remain huge in resources and in military, nuclear power. We simply cannot tell whether such power will remain quiescent, or for how long. That is why this volume's comprehensive analysis of Soviet force and doctrine in the 1990s is so important. The politico-economic unpredictabilities underlying Soviet strategy are just as evident as the military ones. Comecon has unwound along with the disintegration of the Warsaw Pact. Moreover, the countries of Eastern Europe look to the West for political models and economic support. Moscow itself faces a far more dire economic crisis and more staggering difficulties in trying to meet it, not least because of the social upheavals throughout its vast territories in the aftermath of glasnost. The Western economic model in general, and the striking advances achieved by the European Community in particular, have had a magnetic
xiv
Foreword
effect on the East. It is essential for the West to sustain its economic success. The European Community, in economic partnership with the United States and Japan, is as crucial to the peaceful development of relations with the Soviet Union as a continuing transatlantic alliance is to sustaining the West's essential defense requirements. What, then, is really "essential", both militarily and economically? It is certainly essential to pursue with vigor the various arms control negotiations made possible by changes in Soviet policies. But this must not mean the end of any effective Western defense: the North Atlantic Treaty will remain at the core of collective security. There is also a self-evident need for adapting the Treaty as well as for the European members to play a more effective part in organizing their own security. The twenty-threemember Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe may be an excellent forum for closer cooperation among all parties; and it should include Japan. But CSCE cannot be the instrument for upholding the West's appropriate defense capabilities. Judging from Soviet capabilities, if not intentions, the authors show that there is much to defend against. Siren voices call on the European Community to stop "deepening" its process of politico-economic integration so as to enable the early "broadening" of the Community by including some Eastern Europe's fledgling democracies. This concept is misguided. It both represents a false antithesis and is cruelly misleading to the Eastern countries. "Broadening" of that kind is barely conceivable in the nineties, though "broadening" to include Western countries such as Austria or Norway certainly is. The Community needs throughout this decade to strengthen its own political, economic, monetary and institutional integration, while developing a pattern of economic links with its Eastern neighbors, and an ever more liberal economic relationship with the rest of the world. This is a cornerstone of the Western strategic response to the immense Soviet changes we are witnessing. These are brave words and challenging objectives. It will be difficult and perhaps dangerous to meet them. We face justifiable demands for deep defense spending cuts together with the prospect of slower growth as well as gross uncertainty about the supply and cost of oil. As we approach the end of one of history's bloodiest centuries, the greatest challenge to Western leaders isfinallyto reach the millennium in peace and with wider world prosperity. But it would be premature and reckless not to examine our own defense strategy, let alone that of the Soviet Union - or of whatever succeeds it. We can only hope, if with limited confidence, that our leaders will be equal to the challenge. Sir Michael Palliser
Acknowledgements
Numerous friends encouraged me to keep pursuing this work despite kaleidoscopic change in Soviet life. All of the authors in this collective effort were themselves amid constant editorial revisions and updating. But we believe that we have a book which offers enduring insights about Soviet military thinking in the 1990s. Several US government officials were particularly encouraging, as well as generous in sharing their own perspectives: Bruce Weinrod and Dale Vesser from the US Department of Defense, John Hauge from the US Treasury, Ambassador Jim Woolsey and David Webster from the State Department, David Rivkin from the Department of Energy, and Colonel of Marines Murph McCloy. Academic colleagues who have patiently discussed Soviet affairs with me include Jim Billington, Michael Mandelbaum, Leon Aron, Greg Treverton, Steve Canby and Edward Luttwak, Yves Boyer, and my first professor in Soviet politics, Columbia University's Marshall Shulman as well as my former Harvard colleague Richard Pipes. I'm also grateful to Georgetown University deans John Onto and Ali Fekrat. Several leaders in international finance and technology also served as valuable critics: IBM's Denos Gazis, president of the Advisory Board David G. Bradley, Covington & Burling's Jim Snipes, CBEMA's Anne McCormick, Jeff Bellin, David Bruce, Phil Odeen, as well as both Ed Stephenson and Maurice Zilber. Timothy Dickinson - friend, advisor, and brilliant editor - emphasizes the indispensably creative roles of Alana Boyd, Colin Clark, Naum Jasny, Jack and Barbara Chatfield, Robert H. Mitchell, and of Grenville Leyshon and Elizabeth Dickinson. Robert Ellsworth, the current chairman of the International Institute of Strategic Studies and the former Deputy Secretary of Defense and Ambassador to NATO, has long been a guide for many of us in politics and strategy. Derek Leebaert Summer, 1991 xv
1
The stakes of power Derek Leebaert
A classic mark of a state's greatness is that one fears it when it is strong and weak alike. The disintegration of the Warsaw Pact and the collapse of the Soviet economy have undercut familiar military reckonings of the cold war. But new menaces emerge. The world remains Herman Kahn's "dangerous neighborhood" despite summit declarations of a "qualitatively new relationship" between the superpowers. The US and the Soviet Union are metamorphosing at biological speed rather than at the geological rates of most such political correlations. The US is moving back into the rich, benevolent island far out to sea that it traditionally longed to be. The Soviet Union is becoming an undoubted nuclear stockpile around which people anxiously seek to discern a more or less legitimate government. It is still a formidable military power with global security interests, the more pressing because they are less easy to defend. How does Moscow imagine its strategic capacities amid the clamor about "new phases" in international cooperation? Now that the Chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff describes the Soviet Union as a "business competitor" rather than an enemy, what do the leading US experts on the Soviet military predict? Where are changes in direct relationships and in their fundamental resources - wealth, knowledge, authority, will - taking East/West relations? Such sweeping issues are best organized at the hands of a group of long-time scholars of Soviet strength and vulnerability, each focusing on a central area of military expertise. "There is no such thing as an expert on Russia," observed US Ambassador Charles "Chip" Bohlen, "only various degrees of ignorance." Nothing confirmed his quip more vividly than the West's icy shock of recognition at the "drizzle of empire," to borrow from Churchill, that has masked the Communist landscape since 1988. Cholerton, the Daily Telegraph's Moscow correspondent said of the 1930s purge trials, "In this country you can believe everything except the facts." The degree of articulate anger in the Soviet Union had been seen in the democracies as Turgenevian alienation, not as the spiritual quest of "Birth of Our Power." Strength in 1
2
Derek Leebaert
bitterness is perhaps rightly ominous to decent accommodating constitutional states. Because it is so difficult to foresee even the direction let alone the outcome of these assertions of sovereignty within an empire, it is more than ever important to examine Moscow's philosophy of force. Different experiences and approaches are called for to examine the range of strategic nuclear power, conventional capabilities, and military organization. To this end, we interrogate the operational details within the new strategic environment as we draw tentative conclusions about Soviet strategy and military thinking in the 1990s. The maxim that defense policy must be based on an opponent's capabilities rather than on its intentions is easily forgotten amid excitement about "the end of the cold war." But how is the high level of defense policy in that security-obsessed realm actually changing from argument to doctrine in this kaleidoscope? The better to highlight the new, our authors have developed the most comprehensive recent exposition of earlier Soviet operational deployments and technologies. One great contribution of Marxism is its extension of our sense of the material context of human choice and imagination. Moscow did not just roll over in bed and awake from "the nightmare of history" to try to become a geographically isolated bourgeois democracy. The last great empire of the nineteenth century has thoroughly practical - indeed pressing - reasons to enter the international division of labor. The Soviet autarchy is beset by a cumulating host of economic, political, and military pressures. Only by overcoming them can it hope to see the twenty-first century. Otherwise, this state at least may wither away ahead of schedule. We are dealing not with the bankruptcy of strategy, but with the strategy of bankruptcy. Like any other great intellectual undertaking, strategy dissolves upon inspection into a matrix of component disciplines and passions, resources, circumstances, and desires. Strategy is the shorthand for a state's organized pursuit of its interests once its leaders have concluded that they face inescapable resistance or political threat in the larger world. It also involves the peacetime combination and orchestration of nations. The strategy of one power acts upon the foreign policies of many others as all try to balance commitments and capabilities while holding a surplus of strength in reserve. We emphasize strategy, rather than doctrine only, because questions of military capability are inseparable from geography and politics - at no time more than in the years approaching. Since 1945, strategy in East and West alike has sought nuclear stability and sometimes ascendancy. Deterrence brought some degree of stability as the great powers learned that they dared only to use their might tactically, however far away the theater of conflict.
The stakes of power
3
The elucidations of doctrines of deterrence which have shaped East/West conflict have always been conducted at high levels of abstraction. Commanders on both sides had very similar roles in holding back from escalation to the thermonuclear level. Strategic choices before 1945 were qualified by the "terrible ifs" of war. Thereafter, they were subject to the assumed certainty of virtual ruin. The system must be guarded against its own final logic. The powers and temptations of great nations are rarely symmetrical. Russia has cherished its power for three reasons: first, military power has supported expansion in whatever guise - conquest, Leninist revolution, or a post-Stalin contest for assets and influences; second, military power has been imperative for maintaining order within that land of subjection, so long called "the prison house of nations"; and third, military power is needed for defending the so often invaded and devastated rodina. What main influences are altering Moscow's philosophy of force in the early 1990s? Again, there are three: first, the evaporation of presence abroad, authority at home, and legitimacy everywhere; second, the break-up of the Warsaw Pact which strips the Soviet Union of its massive conventional ascendancy over Western Europe - this reinforced by the relative demographic decline of Great Russia in the union; and, third, the capabilities steadily gained by the Soviet fleet which is the one great success story in the Soviet military establishment in this generation. The strategic kaleidoscope "Cold war" was shorthand for predictably safe main frontiers and seas during conflict both indirect and afar. Such predictability is essential to deterrence. Lines of demarcation must be established in practice and theorized about in public. The fear of what would result from a major trespass led in the late 1940s to the Great Simplification: the two superpower blocs were cemented with certain stabilizing benefits. The cold war could then be defined as an epoch in which peace in the normal sense of the term was impossible while war in the normal sense of the term was improbable. A term coined for the specific victors' quarrel which followed the war, deterrence also cemented the nuclear powers' central interests while opening opportunities for maneuver on the periphery. The Great Simplification was born of at least half a lifetime of international disorder - from 1914 until 1945. Europe was clearly divided, the Soviet Union unable to extend power across the oceans. The Great Simplification was also solidified as Japan began to develop, as the rapid collapse of the Chinese Nationalists mercifully kept the US from trying to "save" Nanking, and as South Korea became a buffer. The main tear in this
4
Derek Leebaert
simple tapestry of stability soon became the Sino-Soviet split. But China was in no position to initiate hostilities against the Soviet Union. Soviet consolidation of Eastern Europe under the Warsaw Pact as well as Communist control of China bracketed the ideological and strategic no-man's-land of the Middle East, Southeast Asia, and Africa - while Latin America eventually yielded its anomalous position as a non-belligerent in the cold war. Soviet power sank as ruined Japan and anarchic China gained. Under every regime, Russia gets the neighbor attitudes that it deserves. The nature of cold war, however, emphasized the limited utility of military confrontation at whatever level of violence. Therefore, the US and the West in general needed to ensure their prosperity. Sound economies both guaranteed resources for distant involvements and could also exert some attraction for developing states. Again, the US needed to exploit the contradictions between communism as an international creed on the one hand and Soviet national aggrandizement on the other. Meanwhile, the founding axiom of Soviet grand strategy - that of a regime created by the attempted suicide of the West in 1914 - anticipated a final crisis for the capitalist world. Mounting internal conflicts with their consequent social catastrophes would inflame and divide the West. When they came, the Soviet Union would be well positioned to exploit them: it was a centralized state resting upon heavy industry, possessed of increasing nuclear and conventional forces, and paradoxically confident in its "scientific world outlook." The Soviets have also had a Russian patience and a Hegelian sense of the spiral nature of dialectical advance. If history in its deepest direction pursues the one certain critical path, what does it matter if it passes through the barracks of right-wing dictatorships as long as it is suitably employed by the enthusiasts of Marxism-Leninism? Ideological detachment was one of the benefits of a Marxist education as both power blocs collected incongruous allies. Moscow has been better able to assume a high degree of diplomatic return upon its politico-military dispositions. The US knew that it confronted a regime that had minimal accountability. Washington was more susceptible to real time pressures, as in arms control negotiations and in Vietnam. The most significant Soviet gains, for example, coincided with the West's tortured introspections of the 1970s.1 Detente was later explained by its architects as an attempt to shore up the fading consensus for containment and to avoid ever repeating the Vietnam war's devastating unanticipated sacrifices, what in the fifties would have been called a "fringe war." "We'll see who can pound longest," said Wellington. The Soviets through the Brezhnev era believed that it would be they who could pound longest: the collapse of socialism showed by the
The stakes of power
5
1990s that it was the West. "Dictatorships are like great trees," said Stanley Baldwin: "all very fine and mighty, and then they blow down - and there's nothing growing underneath." The ordinary great game of nations should not, however, be generalized into so imprecise a term as "cold war." These were years of stark ideological-military-reconstructive conflict which followed the greatest war in history. Several dates can be given for the separation of the cold war's head-to-head antagonism into a more precedented, though uniquely planetary, ballet of rivalries: 1956 when the US remained faithful to Europe's implicit division by abandoning promises to Hungary, or 1965 after which no demarcation lines were altered, with the dubious exception of Vietnam - a national conflict which might have afforded a potential frontier of ideological advance, but which the US held until Southeast Asia stabilized. Afghanistan, in turn, was not a part of the US defense perimeter. The erosion and above all the diffusion of forces which upheld the Great Simplification has led in the early 1990s to what can be called the Great Complication in world affairs. There are new and acute sources of international disorder. The two great Eurasian power systems are each coming under increasing stress: China facing the possibility of descending into warlordism should its army groups again divide between different power centers as in 1989; the Soviet Union, faced by a rabble of internal dangers as diverse as Russian chauvinism and Moslem discontent. The historic Eurasian cauldron of perpetual and perilous rivalries now touches two more foci of intense unpredictable change. Japan, territorially confined, its nationalism strongly reviving, has functionally surpassed the Soviet Union in all spheres but the military. To the West, the Soviet Union sees the likelihood of a German-centered Common Europe with its own foreign policy, and, most disconcerting, its own Ostpolitik. The once confident Soviet state which for a generation pioneered equally the artificial satellite and the Eurodollar meanwhile sinks all the faster into technological and institutional obsolescence. The growing instabilities pushing us into the Great Complication increase as the international roles of both the United States and the Soviet Union diminish. Vietnam and Afghanistan showed each superpower the limits of force against "invertebrate" states. The absence of both powers from the 1980s Iran/Iraq war underscored the hopes in both Washington and Moscow for fewer third-world imbroglios. There are more serious threats to peace in the third world today than forty years ago because there are more resources to reach out with gas, plutonium, or bacteria as some village quarrel is forced upon the whole fabric of nations. The world is moving into an age for which there is no vocabulary. The
6
Derek Leebaert
political euphemisms of the 1990s - the counterparts of such terms as extended deterrence, counter-value, fire-break, half-war, police action, and the like - have yet to be coined. The world remains bipolar only in thermonuclear terms. It is ever less so where it comes to conventional - or biochemical - weapons. A new distribution of power arises because industrial states recognize the limits of force in dealing with invertebrate ones, or those with few hostages to the future. There are now many militarily autonomous areas in the world. For example, the US would not forcefully inject itself between Brazil and Argentina. The further down one goes on the scale of violence, the greater the level of complexity. Enemies will also be harder to discern with more porous borders and with new more portable weapons of mass destruction. War games between immense Red and Blue teams over exhaustively mapped European terrain are anachronistic. Instead, the likelihood remains of an international dimension to convulsion in southern Africa; it is highly unlikely that this generation has seen the last Middle East war; and the demographics of Latin America grow increasingly desperate, at least while its current institutional fabrics are in place. Crises spring up out of the ground, swifter in their coming than in their departure - a sharp contrast of experience with the hopes for peace and demobilization worldwide. During the Great Simplification, the US and Soviet Union at least represented world alternatives in imagination as well as in power. The stark differences between these two models of development and governance are now also eroding. The world is arriving at a time when allegiances change at the pace of technology - that is, faster than ever before - and where strategic surprises may be imminent. It is not just the distribution of power which is changing, but its nature. Alliance commitments, for example, will age faster as the strength and vulnerabilities of the participants rise and fall ever more rapidly. So much that once was reckoned as essentially strategic - resource differentials, geographic distance, structure of rival (and allied) societies - is seen as transient and migrates into the tactical. The Soviet Union faces vital threats as the Great Complication unfolds, in contrast to the relatively simple challenges that Moscow confronted during the cold war. The country is in no position to adjust only at the present rate, let alone to catch its breath. Its imperatives to change whipsaw it between dynamic accommodation and a reaffirmation of fading unity and certainty. Yet the Soviet regime can no longer defend itself at home by appealing to dangers abroad, yet alone uphold the ideology Solzhenitsyn called "the scaffolding of lies." Nor can the Soviet authorities count on having their conventional strength leveraged by Warsaw Pact forces to a point of preponderance that shakes political concessions and economic subsidy from the West. Most of all, the Soviet Union must weigh its
The stakes of power
7
military spending - "the cost of empire" - against its hopes of becoming a power of the third industrial revolution. The US can meet its own domestic problems and pursue a minimalist international role with relative ease. It faces no major threats in its hemisphere, although like the whole humane, socially complex West, it is highly vulnerable to septic small war crises whether from direct terror or from the exigencies of sea lanes and access. By contrast, the Soviet Union is so configured that, excepting only Afghanistan, there are no possibilities of merely small wars on its borders. Conflict with Japan, China, any European country, or Iran would all represent a general security crisis to the West. As NATO and the Warsaw Pact each erode in their different ways, and for different causes, both the US and the Soviet Union will have to rework their strategic positions to compensate for losses in relative military power, geographic facility, and political primacy. So far as can be seen, the "new" Soviet military thinking has been tactical. It is primarily an acceptance, at least for the moment, of such new realities as independence in Eastern Europe: not so much a doctrinal reversal as an acceptance of the "re-correlation of forces" emerging in the mid-1980s - about when Soviet strategic writings ironically began to draw a close connection between theory and concrete international behavior.2 In the 1990s, the West needs not just to adapt to a more chastened Soviet doctrine, but to a different Soviet position in this "correlation of forces" originally, a Soviet concept referring to the dynamic and developing aspects of the international system. The dangers offered by the period from America's bitter revulsion after the fall of Saigon to the acceptance of INF by NATO were induced by the reawakening of a predatory consciousness in power at the center of the international system. One power occupied Eastern Europe, leaned against Western Europe, fomented violence on four continents, and spent treasuries to keep its impoverished people from talking and then more treasuries to find out what they were thinking. But the 1990s and beyond will be more vulnerable to a centerless lack of order - an "international anarchy." The Soviet Union must face a substantially more dangerous and complex world at the same time that the US, Europe, and Japan have to face a more markedly unstable Soviet Union. Soviet military doctrine The military jockeyings of the US and the Soviet Union make no sense without one another, but have never run parallel. Soviet force levels and increases of military spending have gone up for many reasons, but have not gone down when American spending has. Soviet expenditures have been
8
Derek Leebaert
wobbingly one directional: America's have been saw-edged. However, the Soviet force posture has been flexible: when the US invested in bombers, for example, Moscow made PVO-Strany a separate service. The US pattern has been the reverse. US spending varies not merely by Washington's interpretation of Soviet actions, but by its interpretation of Soviet attitude. Each service and each arm of each service receives pretty much the same proportion of spending whatever the absolute magnitude of defense appropriation. America's spending policies sieve through an institutional mesh which includes endless Congressional subcommittees, as well as the Joint Chiefs, veteran organizations, and Rand. No two great military organizations think, remember, or feel alike. History, culture, and geography must all be different. It should be even less surprising that two very different political systems developed great defense establishments of very different patterns. In the early days, a president of the US could manage the cold war with a firm and single hand. But such autonomy was only acceptable to Americans when the going was simultaneously critical and easy. The Soviet Union, in turn, has consciously maintained much more unity between military and political doctrine - a unity which has brought the Soviets rewards abroad and which never could have been obtained through military strength alone. The original US theorists of nuclear war undertook to work out the basic grim common sense of the atomic age. The crystalline principles of deterrence theory could never be coarsened down into empiric geography and politics. Nor could a workable deterrent operate in a world of real catastrophe on any formulations not radically simple in their context. This leads many Western observers to assume that Soviet planners have had to share most of the West's key military beliefs. But instead, the Soviet efforts to penetrate the necessities of war - and to emancipate the optimum principles of force, for itself, here and now - have been woven into an entire science possessing natural laws and an elaborate body of extensive theory seeking to govern all aspects of armed conflict and national mobilization. Objectives are formulated in the light of state and revolution, not just of autonomous military analysis. Even in the 1920s, such studies were designated "war work," voynii trud, to show that they were a proper part of socialist thought. This has but the palest of counterparts in the West. Ideology is no longer the heart of the Soviet system, if it ever was. And glasnost and perestroika - as understood in the West - are incompatible with what has been known of socialism. But Soviet doctrine retains far more consciously a great operationally formulated body of the directives and views of the ruling party on all aspects of preparation and state activity in wartime.
The stakes of power
9
There is not just a constitutional assumption of civil supremacy but a day-to-day invigilation appropriate to an originally intellectual police state's observation of its most powerful institutional arm. No junior civilian defense intellectuals have until very recently injected themselves into high decisions, no patronizing diplomats proffered alternative expertise. And as the armed forces undertake ever more responsibilities for the state, relations between the military and the civilian leadership interpenetrate to the point of unprecedented opacity. State Department appointees can declare that "Gorbachev has the military firmly under control. They are by no means resurgent." 3 But the Soviet military probably has never sought to overshadow civilian preeminence. The harshly anti-Caesarian tone of Russian life - militarized but not ruled by generals - has been too often emphasized in blood. Red Army marshals routinely hold the leadership of the civil department charged with military matters, a position prohibited by statute to even retired general and flag officers in the US. But the Soviet military may find themselves somewhat like the Chinese armed forces during the worst stages of the Cultural Revolution, the receivers in insolvency of their society. The Soviets still regard military doctrine as "the sum total of scientifically based views accepted by the country and its armed forces on the nature of contemporary wars that might be unleashed against the USSR, and the goals and missions of the armed forces in such a war, on the methods of waging it, and also on the demands which flow from such views, for the preparation of the country and the armed forces." Since 1987, however, they have assigned the preeminent place to the prevention of war. 4 Strategy, in turn, is intended to implement doctrine and is the instrument for war plans and the preparation of the country for war. Should war come, doctrine holds that high commands are managers of violence and resources policy. All complex doctrines have their deep ambiguities. Here, distinctions are made between military art (the theory and practice of preparing and conducting military operations) and military science (the system of knowledge about the character and laws of war) which comprises inter alia the strategic, operational, and tactical theory of military art. These distinctions may appear scholastic, but they constantly surface in the most practically oriented Soviet discussions of military decision-making. Western critics offer many explanations for the singularities of Soviet doctrine: bureaucratic inefficiency, the military's chauvinism, ignorance about the implications of new weapons, the nation's confidence in its ability to endure punishment, and the amazing stagnancy of Soviet intellectual life where it is a question of genuinely responding to the "world elsewhere." Officially, Soviet views on war and deterrence derive from constant
10
Derek Leebaert
theoretical refinement in the senior service academies, in the military's main political administrations, and in the operations directorate of the general staff. Views are also shaped by progress and refinements in weapon development as well as by analysis of the conduct of potential enemies. The military-technical side of Soviet doctrine then addresses the methods of waging war, of military organization, and of combat readiness. The Defense Ministry eventually integrates doctrine with deployment and procurement, although now its traditional centrality is waning, and thence to the high Party-formulated doctrines of policy, embracing assertions of comparative economic power and technological development as well as the states of unity (or disunity) in the East and West. Delving into Soviet writings on the significance of these often arcane definitions has long been a substantial part of the stock-in-trade of Western intelligence agencies, defense departments, and scholars. The academic swordplay of marshaling footnotes is particularly fierce. The different levels of authority which are ascribed to these Soviet lucubrations, and the quarrels which result, have been tellingly analogized to the debates among sixteenth-century Western observers of the Muscovite state. 5 Soviet doctrine is certainly specific about geography. For example, a strategic axis (SN) is part of a theater of military action itself encompassing a broad zone of terrain with its adjacent sea and airspace. Along such a strategic axis, operations are to be conducted by military entities large enough to be assigned strategic missions. Such a theater of war (TV), in turn, usually includes several theaters of action (TVD) and embraces up to a continent. The Soviets divide their frontiers into five principal theaters: the Northwestern, Western, and Southwestern - which extends from the Arctic to the Black Sea; the Southern, from the Black Sea to the intersection of the Soviet, Chinese, and Afghan borders; and the Eastern for the rest of the country and Mongolia, including Pacific territorial waters. To each theater, a high command: subordinate headquarters may be established to coordinate the actions within a theater and along a strategic axis, of which there may be more than one within the theater. Forces within these theaters are centrally controlled and coordinated to integrate all elements assigned to a given mission.6 A Table of Organization and Equipment emerges - believable only in a country which for over a generation has not fought a technologically comparable enemy. Any actual combat command structure is likely to be recast fast and agonizingly in the furnace of war. The Soviet high commands in both the revolution and World War II were entirely improvised
The stakes of power
11
- Trotsky racing around in trains, as well as the startled new faces which had to replace those officers slaughtered by Stalin in the 1930s, and indeed after the war had begun. The reverse arrangement entails long, formal service in well-known slots. We can gauge neither the practical implications of this difference nor tell at what point in conflict new leaders and lines of authority would be forced through the smooth face of theory - going by the French experience in 1914 and 1940, it could be within days. Nor do we know the consequences of long peace for the Soviet high command. Behind a cool analytical description of military organization and modernization there is likely to be tension and fury. Time has been unkind to so many early Soviet military anticipations: the capitalists are unlikely to turn on each other over resources; the masses of an invaded country will not rally to their liberators, and so on. Even though the Soviet Union is a state built on theory, little is known about current theoretical debates within the general staff or between the military and political leaderships. The so-called revolution in warfare of the 1980s boils down to an implosion in the time available for decision and response. The Soviet Union has always had months to prepare, even when taken by surprise as in 1941. Where will power ultimately rest to make and act upon tremendously fast decisions forced by future conflict? And how might such conflicts be conducted? The instruments of power The Soviet Union's strategic problems remain those of the Muscovite state writ large - frontiers, development, nationalities. Problems are not likely to be resolved, whether with Germany, the Ukraine, the Baltic republics, or the eastern borders. These problems, all hope, will just grimly be lived through. The Soviet Union has traditionally been forced to contain and suppress its problems. The US, on the contrary, has the offshore power's instinct to avoid pushing events to their final conclusion. The Russian/ Soviet experience is that the state eventually pays a high price for merely alleviating troubles. There comes a point when, if the opportunity arises for an apparently definitive conclusion, events will be pushed to the utmost. These cultural distinctions are apparent in the different ways the two countries think about nuclear war. For the US, doctrines of nuclear deterrence have always been an intellectual construct with origins in psychological or game theory, and formulated by civilians. The Soviets, in their turn, emphasize military science and have been prepared to wage war at all levels: they have had to endure war to the enemy's worst capacities as in 1941-45. Different systems of strategic belief lead to different
12
Derek Leebaert
perspectives on the consequences of central nuclear war, on stability, on the connection between intercontinental and regional strategic security systems, and on the limitation of strategic conflict.7 Geography does not permit a land-bound power such as the Soviet Union more than minimal distinctions between strategic and non-strategic nuclear forces. The Soviets understandably insist that strategic interests start at their frontiers no matter whether they are struck by an ICBM, an intermediate range missile from Europe, or a nuclear bomb from a US carrier, or perhaps fallout from some convulsion across the frontier. All Soviet force elements are therefore treated as parts of a unified strategic purpose. There are no tortured disputes as in the West over the "coupling" of strategic and theater forces. All great Russian triumphs to date have begun with the shattering of the enemy on Russian soil. Apart from the defeat of decaying states such as Turkey and Persia, the enemy was drawn into the bear-hug. World War II is canonized as the Great Patriotic War because in it the Russian people worked their own deliverance, as Stalin quite unideologically put it in the moment of victory. There was no longer any reason for the Soviets to filter their doctrine through analogy with the German War once they attained ICBM capability and all but the most suicidal enemy could be deterred at the frontiers. But equally the question arose of the enemy's ICBMs. Determining whether Moscow imparts any special doctrinal categories either to the waging or the consequences of nuclear war - and whether it thinks there is some rational working out of state interests in the event of such catastrophe - has been the subject of fierce debate in the US. For the Soviets, deterrence may be neither the only nor the last objective of strategy - a possible difference which has also inflamed convoluted discussions about the Soviet philosophy of war. "Of course we talk about 'warwinning,' " Colonel General Milstein told me in 1976 as detente continued to unravel, "What do you expect us to talk about, 'war-losing'?". The Soviets implicitly cling to the axiom of Adam Smith, "There is a lot of ruin in a country." As the levels of internal criticism roared upward a dozen years later, several Soviet commentators acknowledged that Moscow had all along entertained a notion of "victory in nuclear war." 8 Of all the Soviet defense capacities, Moscow's relative strategic nuclear standing has been least affected by the upheavals of these years. Lines of communication have been ruined for Soviet tank armies in Europe, and a failing economy forces the leadership to reassess the consequences of committing 25 percent of GNP to military budgets - mostly spent on inefficient conventional forces. Such pressures will compel Moscow to rely more rather than less on nuclear weapons just as nuclear dangers accelerate toward the periphery as new states and sub-national entities achieve such capabilities.
The stakes of power
13
Colin Gray and Raymond Garthoff show two contrasting interpretations and methods in seeking to explain Soviet thinking on nuclear war. The intellectual underpinnings of Soviet nuclear policy are interesting. But it may be more important to triangulate from the historical patterns of Russian dispositions. It is more difficult to lay out the occasions when military writings have flowered into policy. Even in vastly better documented America, we still cannot establish what the US leadership might actually do when facing nuclear war any more than we could have gauged the administration's stance on October 28, 1962 from that of October 21. Nuclear strategies are surely also a mystery to their own practitioners. "You give battle," said Bonaparte, "and then you work it out." US endeavors to standardize doctrine into procedure by way of escalation ladders and limited nuclear options recall Bismarck's observation that every treaty has written at the bottom in invisible ink "Providing things remain the way they are." No one can imagine a central nuclear war except as a convulsion of nature like a collision with an asteroid. There is a difference between strategic doctrine as an ornamental waterspout and the battle force as it strikes home. Should we assume that there is some esoteric Soviet nuclear strategy awaiting its epiphany? Or is it as likely to be as convoluted, historically conditioned, and contradictory as is nuclear doctrine in the West? Nuclear planners on both sides continue to fumble through a labyrinth of technological fluidity and moral inconceivability. It is unlikely that there is a "smoking bomb" behind the nuclear doctrine of either state. Except for very brief and very quickly abandoned junctures in the past thirty-five years, US nuclear doctrine has not sought "victory" as traditionally understood. Soviet nuclear doctrine has, however, been envisioned as a quest for victory to the extent that threats specifically nuclear have their operational place in Soviet general strategy. The Soviets have always used their nuclear potency as an instrument of political ascendancy. A strategic victory, if achieved, would be a Clausewitzian "continuation of policy." The Russians usually push hard once determined upon a foreign adventure, but will more or less yield and wait when they encounter resistance. Two steps forward, one back. Unlike Americans, they do not regard failure as an existential disaster. No ancient power on a great plain has that luxury. At the same time, the Soviet elites have always made it clear that their people are relatively expendable - much like the nineteenth-century Earl of Erne who warned the Irish nationalists that if they thought to intimidate him by shooting his bailiffs they were much mistaken. Being the survivor in that northern vastness does not come from defensive skills alone. The formulation of nuclear strategy in the American managerial idiom
14
Derek Leebaert
has no place in Soviet vocabulary. Russian great war thinking was chewed into shape by the teeth of the beast in the 1940s. For the Soviets, the elegant politico-military dance for strategic advantage occurs not as the nuclear bases go on special alert but rather on the leisurely, pre-industrial perspective of political conflict, indirection, and ruthless waiting, not at the nuclear planning level but on the pre-conflict political level. For the Americans, the search for doctrinal precision is far more evident in the event that deterrence fails. These comparisons also raise the question of protracted war, or at least of prolonged crisis. Moscow's likely opponents, except for China, are constitutional powers with a relatively low tolerance for strain and dislocation. Is it now any more unthinkable than in the recent past to consider which polity might best endure a six-month nuclear alert? Modern strategy has been recast by nuclear weapons. "The life of the law has not been logic," Justice Holmes taught us, "it has been experience." The possibility that a state can be destroyed in days, or in hours, has changed strategy if only because the control of two societies over several years of war is certain to be very different from controlling them over a few days of immediate destruction. Gray and Garthoff come to contrary conclusions about the key question of US-Soviet nuclear relations: do the opponents envision stalemate as a way of life or envision discontinuity and checkmate when deterrence breaks down and two states still possessing about 50,000 nuclear warheads meet head to head? Below the threshold The Soviet Union has conceded tactical power in Europe. The theater redraws itself as we watch. Soviet troop withdrawals from Eastern Europe mean that military pressure on the West would now have to start at the nuclear threshold. Escalating tensions along an intra-European frontier, with intimidating flights over Denmark and harassments over Berlin, crumbled into the archives once the Soviet Union eschewed the line "from Stettin to Trieste" that Marx had already anticipated for Tsarist Russia in 1853. The arithmetic of conventional forces has become less pressing than has the fate of an evolving cordon sanitaire. No serving US officer has ever seen combat in Europe, nor have more than a handful of Soviet officers - with the exception of having fought brave amateurs in 1956 and fired on a few crowds in 1968. Yet the Soviets rationalized maintaining forces in Eastern Europe decades after Germany's defeat by emphasizing a fictitious NATO doctrine of invasion. In fact, Moscow has long understood the advantage of facing a coalition in which NATO's fear of the great menace did not anaesthetize secondary divisions
The stakes of power
15
of interest. As Clemenceau's respect for Bonaparte diminished once he learned that all of the emperor's victories had been against coalitions, so too must the post-war Red Army marshals have had a certain confidence in "the single, brief, big strike" against NATO's national layer-cake of troops thinly arrayed along the intra-German border. 9 In the early 1980s, Moscow was confident it could just sit back and watch NATO percolate. Paul Nitze, who would soon lead the US intermediate nuclear force negotiations, and David Proektor, the head of European studies at Moscow's Institute for World Economy, each believed that the alliance would "tear itself apart" if the US insisted on deploying its intermediate range nuclear missiles in Western Europe: and both were proved wrong. 10 But Moscow was confident that its "peace offensive," replete with hooks as well as doves, could prevent US weapon deployment while further eroding NATO's public support. This strategy of playing upon foreign opinions was what Le Monde in the late 1940s correctly identified as a new style of conflict, one which could leave the rest of Europe just as vulnerable as it had been against the German blitzkrieg of 1940. The value to Moscow of nuclear weapons targeted on Europe was not to ensure strategic stability amid regional conventional victories. Instead, much as Berlin deployed the idea of the Luftwaffe in 1938, well-publicized Soviet nuclear dispositions were planned to obviate conventional conflict while achieving strategic successes. What the Soviets began calling their new doctrine in the late 1980s has been primarily tactical. Highly maneuverable and offensively-trained Soviet armored divisions depart from the "satellites." The West, in turn, needs to adapt not to a more passive Soviet conventional doctrine but to a different Soviet position of power. Trying to distinguish between "offensive" and "defensive" Soviet operational planning for Europe is difficult: so much of what appears defensive was formulated before the Warsaw Pact fell apart; and what has been called highly offensive can derive from the fact that no country wants to fight on its own soil. The profound change, however, is that the retreat from Eastern Europe dispels by acts not words and for the first time in a generation, Western fears that "the air fleets and tank armies of the Soviet Union [can] throw themselves upon us with a velocity and fury far eclipsing any Blitzkrieg of World War II." 1 1 Gross organizational inefficiencies characterize Soviet society as a whole. To impose any additional demands on the corroding infrastructure would strip more gears than anyone has been able to determine. Specifically, Soviet mobilization planning would likely jam before troops could even arrive at the depot. The Soviets can no longer hope of "winning with the last million men," as Kitchener believed the British Empire's sheer numbers and brute force would do in World War I, and as Russia actually
16
Derek Leebaert
did by throwing numbers of the order of a national migration into the grinders during World War II. The Red Army's problems of mobilization and of geography are now compounded by those of demography: conscripts from the Asian republics compose more than half the army drawn from rising populations long disdained by Great Russia. Even a Mongolfeatured participant in the Potemkin mutiny was promptly furnished with Slav features in the "history" books. Conscription itself is becoming problematic. Another tactical constraint is that Soviet intelligence has lost its reserve army of ideologues, misfits, and fifth columnists. In the past, the Soviet Union had stunning opportunities as its operatives recruited ideologues and fifth columnists in the West. Since it is unlikely that there are many more Philbys and Cambridge Apostles, espionage will now be less dramatic and, for the Soviets, less effective. Atkeson examines the significance of both the types and numbers of forces which Moscow is reducing. But what are the new operational concepts that must accompany these changes? What the Soviets call defensive operations, after all, still involve potent combinations of nuclear and conventional weapons, maneuver, and "a single system" composed of "massed, multi-layered fire from all types of weapons." 12 Whatever "counter-offensive" means today in the current Soviet lexicon, its implications are less threatening for Western Europe than in the past. Determining what the Voroshilov General Staff Academy believes is "offensive" or "defensive" may be little more than a state of mind. Such terminological disagreement has existed ever since Thucydides. The changes in Soviet conventional capabilities, however, may also produce leaner and substantially more formidable forces. There is nothing new in the Soviets emphasizing tactical excellence. The more credible the conventional force, the more distressingly real becomes the contingency that the NATO allies might have to play the ultimate nuclear card. Nor does a restructuring of forces mean that the Soviets are excluding the possibility of nuclear war in Europe. A terrain seared by nuclear fires would be so dreadful that merely to follow up would require conventional forces to be superbly effective. The urgency qualitatively to transform the Soviet fighting instrument was pushed in the mid-1980s by Marshal Nikolai Ogarkov. As in the rest of Soviet life, obsolescent practices had to be dropped. The Soviet military has understood preeminently the need for short-term sacrifices for longterm gain. Russia, after all, has traded numbers for efficiency with increasingly less reward for 200 years. In an idiom that now seems archaic, even so eminent an officer of the general staff as Ogarkov could speak in 1985 of exposing "the historical
The stakes of power
17
futility of the capitalist system because the correlation of forces in the international arena has changed irreversibly." 13 In a finite battleground, or, indeed, planet, qualitative changes in conventional munitions would bring these weapons closer in devastating power to their nuclear sisters, making all combat potentially "strategic." This would alter the nature of war. 14 In new and even ironic circumstances, the Soviet military establishment is urgently pursuing a high technology arsenal. The Red Army is no longer the army of the Great Patriotic War. But it still expects to throw itself on (obrushit' sya na) an opponent through a series of insistent (nastoichivyi), never ceasing (neprekrashchayushchyisya) attacks. The Soviet military can become more formidably professional. It has before it the example of a comic opera Russian navy - disastrous even in home waters which turned itself into a great world-girdling fleet in half a lifetime. Other Soviet writings stress the indivisible link between technology and the battlefield, noting "the leading role computer technology plays in the growing defense of our country" and the fact that technology provides "one of the controllable and economically beneficial paths" in dealing "with the current high cost of weapons." 15 But technology can not be confined to enhancing military efficiency. In fact, technology's permeation had long presaged the collapse of Leninist command economies.16 The vision of social comprehensiveness which was originally undertaken and defended in command terms of war and revolution is instead available in the early 1990s in terms of growth, productivity, and inventiveness. Nearly every objective set by political revolution has been transcended by technological improvement. Computer and communication technologies raise effectiveness by dispersing power as much on the battlefield as in the factory and in the rest of society, with untenable consequences for centralization and hierarchy. It is ironic to recall that in his first speech as General Secretary, Gorbachev pledged to maintain a firm grip on the "socialist camp." But he also acknowledged the prime necessity of greater economic growth. 17 Now Christopher Jones shows how Moscow allowed Eastern Europe to become independent after decades in the coils of the Warsaw Pact and Comecon. Jurists in Eastern Europe inaugurated the 1990s by debating the Pact's legality and the means which dissolved it. Soviet military doctrine had been predicated for forty years on the assumption that most of the client state armies, highly integrated into Soviet command and logistical structures, would be generally reliable in combat. The Soviet Union can not now raise sufficient divisions, no matter how their readiness is defined, to maintain the conventional posture it exploited for forty years. Free elections in Eastern Europe came with the suddenness of earlier metamorphoses. Moscow by the late 1980s understood what it had only
18
Derek Leebaert
glimpsed when it considered using force against Poland in 1981 - that the political, economic, and military consequences of exercising anything like the Brezhnev Doctrine had become insurmountable. In any conflict Westward, Moscow's lines of communication across its old empire through Eastern Europe would be highly vulnerable - at best. Moreover, armies returning from lost frontiers have for centuries been the carriers of disruptive ideas - even the hard-won Russian victory of 1878 shook the land for years. Alexander II paid with his life in part for Russian soldiers discovering that they were worse off than Bulgarian peasants under the hated Turk. Having stunted the societies to its immediate west during the world's greatest half-century of growth, Moscow can be reasonably certain that the West itself will not allow the logical consequences of Soviet conduct to develop in Eastern Europe. For forty years, the US could do little there other than to try to "encourage the union of western Europe to go beyond the moral limits and get themselves buttoned up in a military alliance." 18 Now a diffuse and even contentious Eastern Europe is acceptable to Moscow because the West, through aid and investment, would not let these just decommunized states become dictatorships - not that Moscow at its most hypocritical fears any of them but Germany. NATO, in turn, has become increasingly less central to US strategy. Similarly, it is unlikely that Central Front issues in fact remain central to Soviet calculations. Both superpowers have a wider 'geographic scope. Russia's eclipse as a forward land power, for example, brings seapower into more urgent focus. New Soviet naval capabilities can alter the pace and nature of future confrontation. A prolonged guerre de course at sea, with endless incidents and collisions, could itself obviate any actual clash in Europe as the West's political loyalties were unwound by ratcheting. War at sea can give conflict another dimension: as in the past, it can force the decision to escalate upon the West, recalling Cavour's maneuvering "They cannot get out without firing the cannon." Gael Tarleton studies the fleet's role in Soviet strategy. The capabilities of the Navy (Voyenno-Morskoy Flot) vastly increased during the 1970s and 80s. To what extent should the navy be regarded as "offensive" or "defensive" in the 1990s? Throughout the cold war, the great land power was vulnerable to the great sea power. The Soviet view of seapower has been entirely different from that of the US. The US Navy's emphasis upon the seas as highways was simply more spacious: Russia's historic deployment of fleets was directly upon peripheral land objectives from Navarino through Tsushima. Comparing two superpowers at sea is less a technological discussion than an anthropological one: it is one about two different systems. The last Russian naval victory was in 1853 when a Turkish fleet was destroyed at
The stakes of power
19
Sinop. In World War II, the Soviets had only one effective submarine squadron. The other six would better have been deployed as light infantry. The navy has never contributed to the Russian tradition of winning annihilating battles. And Moscow has never had the island power's view of striking with the needle rather than with the axe. The US-Soviet rivalry at sea has therefore been a vastly magnified version of Sebastopol in 1854: the liberal seapower coming right through by sea to bleed a continental empire. It has also exemplified the pressures that can be imposed by a technologically more advanced, mobile power. The only landlocked country toward which the US has a military commitment is Luxembourg. No accident: seapowers dislike getting too deep inland. American naval power has ensured Japan's independence and would later cover China's autonomy. But the 1962 Missile Crisis was the catalyst for a Soviet blue ocean navy, transcending the cruiser force of the 1950s. The strategic consequences were apparent by the 1970s: in the maintenance of a Cuban army in Angola, in the 1973 maneuvers and signals during the Middle East war, and in the general staff's assertion that "the historic function of the Soviet Armed Forces is not restricted to their function in defending our Motherland" but in opposing "the export of counterrevolution . . . in whatever distant region of our planet it may appear." 19 A relatively weak power at sea goes for disruption rather than counterfleet capabilities. Just so, America employed commerce destroyers to deadly effect in the war of 1812, not dreaming of matching the Royal Navy anywhere. Soviet naval theorists in the 1920s shaped their planning against the greatest of commercial powers, not its proud fleets. They emulated the approach of France's jeune ecole: instead of boldly confronting Britain's preeminence, France had forced the Royal Navy to disperse its resources. Outside of a few bases, the Soviet Navy is homeless beyond its coasts. It has to be self-contained. Unlike the 1970s, its hopes for warm water ports are in abeyance, and the fleet's Marine component, the "white berets," is only of divisional strength. The dislocation of alliances in Europe has much less effect on the Soviet Navy than on the army. With the demise of the Warsaw Pact, however, Moscow may concentrate more heavily on the northern flank, and thus need more protection at sea. An intention to interdict the Baltic and North Atlantic sealanes may be one explanation for the Soviet submarine penetration of Swedish waters while the rest of Europe demobilized.20 Modern Soviet naval doctrine has so far been relatively autonomous. Barely visible to traditionalists it was shaped under Admiral Gorshkov's domination rather than as a facet of high international security policy. Overall, Tarleton addresses the meaning of change in Eastern Europe for
20
Derek Leebaert
the fleet, as well as the implications of recently available Russian naval writings. With the Soviet fleet and air force having attained such prominence, however, can we still assume that the Red Army has the central role in Soviet strategy, or that the presence of a Soviet general as defense minister still unambiguously reflects the hierarchy of military leadership? The command education of this military leadership, as of the US and Soviet armies, has been gained against dispersed, invertebrate, third world opponents, who won. David Isby now uses the Soviet experience in Afghanistan to illuminate the role of Moscow's previously concealed special operations forces. Until perestroika, Moscow insisted that such forces were only to be found among foreign armies. Such secrecy may have been due to the unique offensive role of these outfits, offensive to the point that in the mid-1980s West Germany claimed that commandos regularly penetrated the country to familiarize themselves with strategic targets and that, in a prewar crisis, commandos would be infiltrated in Western uniforms to disrupt NATO's rear by assassinating or kidnapping political leaders. 21 The lessons of Afghanistan go wider than questions of tactics or of power projection. In the aftermath of successful conventional force reductions in Europe, special operations would be far more powerfully levered than would tanks and artillery. Since Soviet troops would no longer be deployed forward, there will also be a premium on forces which can be immediately injected - or which could defend Soviet supply lines from former allies seeking neutrality. Special operations forces are now only projecting their power inward. The elite airborne, air assault, and spetsnaz units are among the rather short list of units reliably available to the Soviet government to support local policy and anti-riot internal troop formations. The Ministry of the Interior, for example, has realized the limitations of its regular troops and has formed its own special operations army. In spring 1989, airborne units were first used to suppress massive demonstrations in Tbilisi and were later used to enforce martial law in Armenia and Azerbaijan. Army patrols were included in early 1991. This may be a sign of renewed strength and wills. Managing the mission Moscow entered the 1990s with its paradox of being a third world economy with first world weapons. Less than a decade earlier, Brezhnev's successors could each assert in the old idiom that the Soviet Union exerted its main influence on the world revolutionary process through its economic policies. In fact, military power has been Moscow's only claim to a global role trying to maintain that power has steadily compromised the economy. So much
The stakes of power
21
for the Leninist maxim that modern war cannot be waged without serious economic preparation. 22 Ironically, it was the US that first dreaded being economically buried by the military technology competition with the Soviet Union. NATO from the beginning felt that Moscow was inducing the allies to spend themselves into inflationary deficits and economic oblivion through unmanageable defense budgets. 23 As the information age approaches the millennium, the West has shown that prosperity and innovation can only come from dispersing initiative through countless decentralized, individual, random decisions. This is compatible only with an open society in contrast to the Soviet system of vertical structures, rigid production schedules, and an inability to measure opportunity. The Soviet Union is in a desperate race between economic disintegration and the creation of a political consensus which can endure the agonies of economic change as bitter as those of a bad frostbite. If the economy collapses and the entities to administer it before legitimate political structures come into place, "this military 'superpower' in possession of over 12,000 nuclear charges, [could] plunge into violent political chaos, a Lebanon-like war of all against all." 24 Wellington noted 175 years ago that "The Russians have no wealth or trade, all they have is 400,000 men about whom they talk all too much." At best, the hopelessness of Soviet economics and development will continue to constrain the potential of Russian force. The Soviet military has so far conceded that short-term sacrifices in its development are necessary for long-term benefits in capability. Mikhail Tsypkin addresses the combined military and economic questions of Soviet weapon development amid these transformations. Soviet scientists draw heavily upon historic precedent when discussing military R&D. 25 The 1930s and World War II, for example, are recalled as times of military innovation under the greatest of stress. Despite a demolished economy, the Soviet Union was able to "independently develop weapons and technologies to surpass and defeat Germany." Can the Soviets achieve new qualitative and even quantitative leaps under current constraints? Tsypkin examines an apparent contradiction: is the Soviet military R&D system being tasked with developing weapons for the twenty-first century while at the same time facing budget cuts and talk of a diminished national role? Russia for 200 years has had a sense of technical inferiority to the West and, more recently, towards Japan. Russians have never been convinced of their old intonement, nashe luchshe, "ours is best," even when it happened to be true. Underestimating Soviet military technical excellence - whether in jet engines, atomic power, rocket technology, or remote guidance - has been a chronic failing in the West's net assessments.
22
Derek Leebaert
The effect of new influences and institutions upon the military is evident in the unprecedented civilian challenge to traditional military responsibilities. Far more is being questioned than problems of weapons development. Gorbachev originally expanded and intellectualized the old procedures. A military monopoly was diluted while criticism arose from civilian research institutions and analysts. This was only possible among much wider social and political changes. Ben Lambeth articulates the unprecedented assertiveness of Soviet defense intellectuals who aspire to a role not dissimilar from their US counterparts. Old inhibitions and hierarchies were removed, and newly emboldened contestants have entered the arena. Tension then mounts. The civilian analysts have an independent expertise not just in arms control and procurement but also in battlefield questions such as force effectiveness. They emphasize quantitative modeling, or systems analysis, and have their own points of contact with Western civilian analysts. They have new access to their own Russian sources upon which the military previously had a proprietary grip. The result is what Lambeth calls a "civilian onslaught." Competition in military analysis also arises from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Meanwhile, the general staff has the deepest foreboding as it tries to protect its pride of place. There are constant reciprocal challenges to competence and credentials. But never before has there been an independent civilian filter between the military and the highest political leadership. New civilian critics have compared their research institutes to Rand and Hudson. These civilian defense analysts were profoundly frustrated until the mid-1980s. Theirs was largely a propaganda role exercising the most minimal influence upon the leadership. When I first encountered them in 1969 in Moscow, they spent much of their time creating psychological profiles of US national security policy-makers as well as many less prominent Americans involved in the contemporary defense debate. Twelve years later, the institutes were still on the fringes of policy as they compiled biographies of the new US appointees whom they denounced as "strategists of empire." By the early 1990s, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs itself joined hands with these increasingly well-prepared non-military defense experts in a contest of influence with the Defense Ministry. Edmund Wilson wrote that "One of the elements of the Russian character to which it is most difficult for the Westerner to adjust himself is the passion for self-immolation." These new civilian defense-policy critics became intertwined with the new regime and were risking their careers, at least, in challenging military competence. International security now embraces all of those influences which have a
The stakes of power
23
direct bearing on the structure of the nation state system, whose members increasingly define their security not only in the conventional modes of military strength, economic vigor, and government stability but also in terms of environment, science and technology, cultural vitality, and natural resources. Such complexity requires more than traditional general staff planning. But Soviet military forecasters are adapting their own methods to new planning techniques. Jacob Kipp expands on the military's anxious role in shaping Soviet strategy "in an era of restructuring," to "survey mankind from China to Peru." Military foresight must range over not just the scientists in weapons development but also the social scientists in the institutes and bureaucracy. Conclusion Soviet strategists have little reason for optimism as they look ahead. Strategy until a quarter century ago was conducted in a world of specific fronts: Europe, China, and the timeless path to warm water ports. From the fall of Japan until the 1970s, the Soviet Union did not face the prospect of a two front war. Now the possibility of China again throwing itself into chaos reminiscent of the Cultural Revolution is by no means unimaginable (although it was during the Cultural Revolution, we should recall, that China combined with the US). The high politics of Central Asia are again in play. And the possibility of a new, authoritarian "government of order" in the Soviet Union is regarded fearfully by everyone, particularly China. The number of unsettling forces and influences - whether economic, demographic, technological, or historic - will increase prodigiously upon the Soviet state (or its successor) irrespective of new borders or forms of government. In fact, the rise of a liberal Indian superstate, with its increasing command of the talents and technologies of the information age, might be a far greater threat to the Soviet future than would be a strengthening of merely contiguous China. Everywhere the familiar lines of demarcation are disappearing. They no longer clearly indicate those areas at the margin where the powers might probe with impunity. The moves of chess are being replaced as the analogy of world conflict by the processes of go.
If the Soviet Union wants to return to anything like its global role over the last forty years, it must rely more on strategic nuclear power. It has conceded its tactical position in Europe, and is finding it increasingly difficult to maintain its conventional forces. The diplomatic dividends of strategic nuclear power would be different depending on whom such power would be used; in Europe, against NATO, which is less likely to dissolve than to become a Hobbesian wraith; in the East, against Japan which is
24
Derek Leebaert
superbly conventionally well-armed; and in the Indian Ocean where a Soviet role is possible given Australia's focus on Southeast Asia and South Africa's internal problems. There is a nest of potential conflicts. Nearly every objective set for political revolution has been transcended by technological improvement. Communism set out to overthrow the separation of the country and the city, as well as of such constraints as class and religion. But this was not enough as people - whole societies - insisted on finding individual goals, defining themselves by their enmities. So Moscow place-names are changed from ideologically charged Karl Marx Prospect to the pastoral Okhotny Ryad ("Hunter's Row") and from Cheka police chief "Dzerzhinsky" square to "Lubyanka." The political economy of the information era is about human possibilities and about ever greater degrees of freedom. Technology diminishes the need for the heroic central decision-maker. The information era which was spawned by war is now transforming the Soviet Union in the 1990s. But there remains a caveat. Soviet strategists may know it best of all. History is not marked by gentleness or persuasion. Seventy years ago, the foreign minister of another doomed empire summed up the departure from the world stage that his order had taken: "It was left to us to choose the manner of our passing; and we chose the most agonizing means of death." Notes 1 Harry Gelman, The Brezhnev Politburo and the Decline of Detente (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1984). 2 V. V. Zagladin, "Correlation of Forces in the International Arena and the Development of International Relations," International Affairs, Moscow, February 1985. 3 The New York Times, May 21, 1990. 4 Soviet Military Dictionary (Moscow: Voyennoye Izdatel'stvo, 1987). 5 Edward L. Keenan, Russian Political Culture, US Department of State, Contract no. 1722-420119, 1976. 6 Soviet Military Power: Prospects for Change (US Government Printing Office, 1989). 7 Fritz W. Ermarth, "Contrasts in Soviet and American Strategic Thought," in Derek Leebaert (ed.), Soviet Military Thinking (Boston: Allen & Unwin, 1981). 8 I. Kulkow, Kommunist, no. 7 (April 1989), 21; V. Zagladin, Pravda, June 13, 1988. 9 Nathan Leites, "The Soviet Style of War," in Leebaert (ed.), Soviet Military Thinking. 10 Author's discussions with D. Proektor, IMEMO, Moscow, April 1981, and with Paul Nitze, CSIA Arms Control Seminar, Harvard University, March 1981. 11 Ma j or General F. W. von Mellinthin, Panzer Battles: A S tudy of the Employment
The stakes of power
12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19
20 21 22
23 24 25
25
of Armor in the Second World War (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1956). G. Ionin, "Foundations of Modern Defensive Battle," Voyennyy Vestnik, March 1988, reported in FBIS-SOV-89-014, July 18, 1989, p. 4. The Times, April 22, 1985. N. V. Ogarkov, History Teaches Vigilance (Moscow: Voyenzadat, 1985), p. 57. Pravda, "Computers and People," February 6, 1985 and Major General M. Yasyukov, "The Military Policy of the CPSU," Kommunist Vooruzhennykh, October 20, 1985. George Paloczi-Horvath, The Facts Rebel (London: Cassell, 1963). Kommunist, no. 5 (1985), 9; FBIS-SU, May 22, 1985. R4. Daily Log Sheet, March 4, 1948, Lovett Papers, New York Historical Society, NY. See "The Fleets in the Local Wars of Imperialism," in S. G. Gorshkov, Sea Power of the State, 2nd edn (Moscow: Military Publishing House, 1979), as well as Marshal Grechko, "The Leading Role of the CPSU in Building the Army of a Developed Socialist Society," Problems of the History of the CPSU, May 1974. Gordon McCormick, Stranger than Fiction: Soviet Submarine Operations in Swedish Waters (Santa Monica, CA: Rand, 1990), R-3776. General Robert Close, Europe Without Defense? (New York: Pergamon Press, 1979). The current economic predicament bears out those Soviet military economists who already two decades ago insisted that there was a "national limit" to military expenditures at the national economic growth rate, and that exceeding this limit would ruin the overall economic base from which military spending is extracted. See "Analytic Notes," AN-0184, October 1984, Russian Studies Center (Bethesda, MD: Booz Allen & Hamilton, 1984). Public Record Office (UK), October 1, 1949, FO 371/71672, N 10581, and Harry S. Truman Library, PSF, Fofrestal to President, November 20, 1948. Leon Aron, "Waiting for Yeltsin," The National Interest, Summer 1990. A. Aleksandrov, interview, Izvestiya, June 10, 1985.
Parti
The instruments of power
2
Soviet nuclear strategy and new military thinking Colin S. Gray
It would be a major error to approach Soviet nuclear strategy as if it were an extant mosaic to be uncovered by the prodigious scholarly efforts of Western archaeologist-strategists. Bearing in mind the fact that the Soviet Government says next to nothing about its current thinking on its contingent nuclear operations, one should approach the subject expecting a quality of evidence more suitable for the securing, by analogy, of conviction in a civil, than in a criminal, case. There is, and is going to be, no "smoking gun," in the form of Soviet public explanation and defense of the equivalent of a NSDM-242, or a PD-59. 1 Many of the people who, understandably, debate Soviet nuclear strategy in a necessarily inexpert manner, often are less than reliably informed about the doctrine which helps shape current US (and NATO) nuclear contingency plans. These plans and related matters are the most closely guarded of state secrets - in the United States as well as in the USSR. There is a night and day difference between the quality and quantity of information officially released by the US and the Soviet governments on current (and past) nuclear doctrine and strategy. None the less, this is a subject that rightly attracts the most strenuous of official discouragement of release of classified data. Whether or not, or to what degree, the deeply classified details of nuclear targeting really matter, has to depend upon the level of questions posed. Fortunately, the more interesting issues of strategy that bear directly upon nuclear contingency planning and force structure planning do not require debate at the level of highly classified detail. The discussion immediately below identifies the diverse sources of evidence for Soviet nuclear strategy. Nine sources are registered, though these are not rigorously exclusive. Tactical capability For reasons of redundant plausible causation, it is not wholly true to claim that policy and strategy can be inferred logically from military programs. However, strategy is a practical art and the realm of tactics - of the actual 29
30
Colin S. Gray
use of armed force of all kinds - determines that which is possible for operational artists and strategists. Good strategy and inspired operational artistry can provide some compensation for tactical deficiencies, but it is a useful general rule that if a military operation does not work tactically then it will be a forlorn hope in strategic terms. The tactical fighting value of Soviet central nuclear forces does not dictate Soviet operational and strategic choice, but it does rule out certain objectives. Save in some exceedingly far fetched scenarios of fine-tuned C3I decapitation attacks, Soviet nuclear-armed forces simply cannot win a classic military victory.2 It is important to know if Soviet nuclear forces are capable of being employed in a highly discriminate mode against, say, hardened or otherwise elusive military targets over a period of days or even weeks. However, to pass judgment on whether or not Soviet forces would be so employed is quite a different matter. The beginning of all wisdom concerning Soviet strategy for central nuclear war is recognition that Soviet nuclear-armed forces cannot function reliably as an instrument of military decision over the United States. Their prospective tactical accomplishments would fall lamentably short of producing the necessary strategic effect for outright victory. Analogically, the great armies of 1914—early Fall 1918, were tactically incapable of delivering what operational and strategic direction asked of them. Recognition in Britain (and belatedly in the United States) in 1942^3 that Anglo-American (and Canadian) landpower and airpower simply were not sufficiently tactically effective to confront with confidence the Germans in the main theater of operations, similarly was an appreciation critical for the design and success of strategy.3 Strategic culture and national style
It is a hypothesis of increasing respectability to suggest that each national security community - Russian in this instance - has a more or less distinctive strategic culture, whence derives a discernible national style. The concepts of strategic culture and national style, as with their close cousins from the realm of geopolitical analysis, do not point to allegedly essential truths which determine thought and behavior. Instead, they indicate non-random preferences and persisting tendencies.4 The most relevant hypothesis is that the Russian/Soviet past has bequeathed to the present modes of thought, sets of attitudes, patterns of behavior, and institutions which express and propagate those learned ideas and procedures. Depending, inter alia> upon its geostrategic character - for example, is it a maritime or a continental community (or does it have an ambivalent status between the two)? - a state will tend to be better at some
Soviet nuclear strategy
31
kinds of national security activity than at others. 5 As the saying goes, "it is no accident" that the Soviet/Russian army has been a more impressive fighting instrument than the navy, or that the British and US navies have been in a different league of excellence than generally have been their armies. There is some general transcultural logic to strategy at a level of arid abstraction. But, as Christopher Donnelly has emphasized, indeed possibly overemphasized, the roots of military thought and behavior are lodged in a particular stream of historical experience and in a unique geographical setting. 6 It would be a mistake to approach Soviet nuclear strategy as a local sub-set of some generic nuclear strategy. Writing of Soviet national security policy, James Sherr has offered the pithy judgment that "in any explanation of Soviet military power and its application, geopolitics may come up trumps." He is probably correct. It is scarcely less plausible to suggest that over many issues of military strategy, Soviet/Russian strategic culture and national style are likely to come up trumps. 7 Of course nuclear weapons are different, even "revolutionary," in their implications for policy, strategy, operations and tactics.8 But, that difference is treated and managed in a Soviet way. A strategic culture and national style shaped and reshaped by a millennium of deeply continentalist experience is not swept away by the advent of new weapon (and other) technologies. The functioning of culture and style is important in any national security community, but Western sensitivity to their operation in the Soviet context is unusually important because of the acute shortage of other more tangible, and reliable, sources of evidence (or just insight) on thought and contingent behavior. History Reference to a state's history as a source of evidence on future thought and behavior really means reference to that "history" as interpreted by favored historians. In Oscar Wilde's apposite words, "[a]ny fool can make history, but it takes a genius to write it." 9 Soviet military professionals are second to none in the respect they accord historical study. Unlike much of their curious passion for a mathematical science of war, 10 their pedagogical utilization of historical experience - particularly of the Great Patriotic War - warrants study in the West. 11 Of outstanding interest for Western defense planners is the unsettled issue of whether Soviet defense professionals truly have a competent grasp of the likely realities of global war against the greatest mixed maritime-continental coalition in history. 12 One need hardly add that coalitions invite enemy grand strategies of divide and conquer. The nominal aggregate strength of the US-led
32
Colin S. Gray
coalition would likely be quite scenario-dependent. The deep, narrow and highly competent analysis of what was a one-front war against a landpower foe whose homeland fortress could be taken by the Soviet/Russian instrument of military excellence, the army, may not provide a very healthy bedrock of history-based learning for a candidate (global) World War III. Continental-minded defense expertise tends to be dismissive of the threat posed by navies, not realizing how superior seapower - broadly understood - can shape the course and structure, and hence the outcome, of (protracted) conflict. All national security communities learn from, and to a degree express, their historical experience. There are clues to current and future Soviet strategic thought and behavior in Soviet understanding o/Soviet history. It is a matter of great importance that the USSR has never waged war against a sea-based enemy whose homeland could not plausibly be reached save by engines of very long-range bombardment. Great institutions have a way of preparing to do that which they know how to do well. If the new "Red God of War," 13 the long range, nuclear-armed missiles of the Strategic Rocket Forces, are denied the license to conduct a classic (preemptive) kontrpodgotovka - a break-up barrage - wherein lies the Soviet theory of victory? Soviet strategists have to cope with a putative enemy whose strategic geography as a coalition and whose strategic preferences (which rest in part upon the very different culture, style, and historical experience of the United States) have a rather different structure from those of Moscow.14 Notwithstanding the universally acknowledged novelty of nuclear weapons, defense planners have a way of learning from history how to win against yesterday's enemy. The USSR believes that it knows how to beat a great continental power. It is less obvious that Soviet defense professionals know how to beat the extra-Eurasian United States (assuming that a SIOPRISOP "exchange" is ultra vires - a subject in need of careful treatment). Weapons and other military equipment The technical detail of Soviet weaponry does not speak eloquently to the realms of policy purpose and strategy design.15 Provided the operational context is specified - variations on the themes of first strike or first use knowledge of Soviet nuclear-armed weapon systems provides the basis for reasonable judgment as to their tactical utility against particular target sets with familiar (if often assumed) characteristics.16 But to know what a weapon system could do is not to know how it would be used. In short, Soviet operational nuclear strategy cannot be read reliably from the details of Soviet force posture - suggestive though those details certainly appear to be.
Soviet nuclear strategy
33
The Soviet strategic forces' posture, considered in the context of what broadly may be called war survival measures, is the posture of a state with a thoroughgoing "war-fighting" approach to deterrence. That Soviet posture implies the beliefs (or working hypotheses) that: large-scale nuclear war could occur; the USSR, by its unilateral efforts, could (or might) enforce a range of different outcomes; and that the differences among those outcomes could matter. One must hasten to add that it is not claimed here that the USSR believes: that nuclear war will occur; that any large-scale East-West war must be a nuclear war; or necessarily that it would secure any reasonable facsimile of victory in a nuclear war. At the level of policy declaration as contrasted somewhat with policy as capability, there is not a great deal to distinguish major aspects of Soviet, from US, nuclear strategy. The USSR has expended vastly greater assets for the physical protection of leadership cadres than has the United States indeed, there is no comparison between the two. The USSR has sought to provide for the survival in nuclear war of all key assets of the state; the United States does not try. 17 But US policy as declaration is scarcely less devoted to the idea of continuity of government than is Soviet policy. Soviet and US military styles in operational nuclear strategy would probably differ markedly. However, what is there about the Soviet nuclear-armed force posture and its support (and other relevant) systems from which the grand design of Soviet nuclear strategy might be deduced? In overall size, at approximately 11,500 plus weapons, Soviet strategic nuclear forces effectively are on a rough numerical par with those of the United States. In diversity, the Soviet triad is unbalanced in favor of its landbased missile leg. However, the US triad is unbalanced in the low warhead allocation to its ICBM force - allowing numerical pride of place to the SLBM force. While the USSR has provided for pre-launch survivability in a probable START era by agility as well as silo hardening for its longest suit, ICBMs, the United States is committed unhealthily to high concentration of SLBM warheads in relatively few Ohio class SSBN hulls. The USSR has dedicated such a wealth of assets to strategic C3I that that area, for all its undoubted significance, may not carry the promise of high reward to US nuclear targeteers. In the 1980s, in particular, the United States committed itself to making a reality of the principle that minimum essential C3I must survive as long as the forces that they serve.18 That worthy ambition is challenged by the fact that the strategic forces are inherently more survivable than is their C 3 I: still, much progress has been made.
34
Colin S. Gray
The USSR has purchased such offensive and defensive counterforce capability as the state of their technical art has permitted. As a matter of strategic objectives, the United States is scarcely less dedicated to the performance of counterforce missions than is the USSR. Those strategic objectives may be inferred from Soviet force acquisitions that make no sense if they are not dedicated to the prosecution of technically stressful counterforce operations. In practice for twenty years the United States has all but eschewed defensive counterforce for central war (though not for regional conflicts). But, with the SDI the United States, if anything, is even more strongly committed (rhetorically, at least) to the idea of defensive counterforce than is the USSR. Whereas policies and strategies usefully can be labelled offensive or defensive, individual weapons have no inherently offensive or defensive, meaning; the context is everything. 19 An MX or an SS-18 mod 5ICBM is as entirely suitable for a variety of operational styles in nuclear strategy, as it is for the support of an offensive or a defensive national security policy. Other military capabilities Nuclear war, nuclear weapons, and nuclear strategy are not subjects isolated from war, weapons, and strategy more generally. The non-nuclear preference which appeared to dominate Soviet strategic thinking - though not planning or posture - in the 1980s, was an expression of new-found, if distinctly fragile, confidence both in conventional options and in nuclear counterdeterrence. 20 From the early 1970s to the early 1980s the Soviet Union sought to acquire the means both to wage and win regional Blitzkrieg campaigns around the Eurasian periphery of its imperium, and to deny the Western Alliance any contingently attractive options for nuclear employment. It is probably true to say that Soviet nuclear weapons in the 1980s were allocated the potentially decisive role of deterring attempts at "decision" via nuclear use by an enemy. One can infer reasonably that Soviet nuclear weapons of all kinds were charged primarily, though certainly not exclusively, with holding the ring square for the achievement and consolidation of regional conventional victories. This is not to evade the question of how the Soviet military establishment would be permitted to wage nuclear conflict in the event. But is is to claim that the event of nuclear conflict has come to be viewed in Moscow as being imbued far more with peril than with opportunity. The unmistakable preference for non-nuclear options in Soviet strategy
Soviet nuclear strategy
35
in the 1980s undoubtedly reflected mature consideration of the associated dangers. However, that preference was encouraged by the contemporary Soviet belief in conventional alternatives for swift success in land warfare. The somewhat exaggerated, at least over-heated, Soviet anxiety over the West's advanced conventional munitions (ACMs), the multiplying geostrategic uncertainties about the shaky terms and vanishing future of the Warsaw Pact and the evolving balance of military force levels, may well induce Soviet reconsideration of the unique merit (as well as demerit) in nuclear ordnance. 21 In the context of CFE I, let alone an ambitiously mooted CFE II, and enormous uncertainties over the future structure of security in Europe, Moscow already has signaled some lessening of enthusiasm for truly thoroughgoing regional nuclear disarmament (for the leading example, the "third zero," for battlefield nuclear-capable weapon systems). A mix of NATO's ACMs (and their improvements), the newly adverse strategic geography of European conflict imposed by the demise of the Warsaw Pact, and the need for domestic economy, may well produce a Soviet Army radically less capable of rapidly overrunning West-Central Europe that has been the case until recently. But, even though such a noteworthy adverse change in the net combat prowess of Soviet landpower could imply a need for new nuclear competence, such competence would be unlikely to be achievable. That which is strategically very desirable, even necessary, is not necessarily tactically or operationally feasible. Intelligence When one considers the totality of the US, and other allies' (and functionally friendly), intelligence effort, the scale, diversity and sheer professionalism of the multi-form effort, it can be difficult to accept the fact of the severe limitations upon what is reliably knowable concerning the subjects of most importance. "Overhead" assets of many kinds can count most installations and pieces of hardware (provided they do not move) though deception remains a severe problem in monitoring things Soviet but those tend not to be the categories of knowledge with history-turning implications. The things that can be imaged one way or another, counted and more or less reliably monitored, indeed the entire world of "indications and warning" ("I and W") activity, can provide invaluable input for strategic and policy judgment, if one knows how to interpret what one sees or hears. Similarly, given the necessary ambiguity of policy intentions, or even over strategic objectives, there is everything to be said in favor of the real-time tactical monitoring of the adversary's behavior. (Even if Soviet policy
36
Colin S. Gray
motives are an enigma, it is essential to know if their Northern and Baltic fleets are surging into the Atlantic and North Seas.) Questions of outstanding interest for this inquiry include the following. Over what issues would the USSR choose to fight; when would it have resort to nuclear weapons; how would it wage nuclear war; how responsive would it be to some de facto guidelines for the practical control of the dangers of nuclear escalation, and so forth? Alas, none of the answers to questions such as these lends itself reliably to discovery by the intelligence community via imaging, listening, counting, and such like. The rounded study of Soviet/Russian phenomena, as well as the achievement of some intellectual grip on the subject of strategy, should educate a person to the point where his or her guesses concerning Soviet operational nuclear strategy ought to command a respectful audience. But, some of the more important issues may well be beyond study, though not beyond educated guesswork. For example, to what extent would the Soviet General Staff be permitted to wage war, nuclear and other, without detailed real-time guidance/interference by political leaders?22 Or, if the United States flexed an "extended (nuclear) deterrent" muscle in a substantial, but still highly constrained manner, how would the USSR respond? Pending the greatly undesired event, there can be no authoritative answer to questions such as these. Exercises Along with recent defectors with military, or other defense related, experience, electronic oversight of various kinds, and the typically ambiguous implications of military posture, military exercises are a prime source of information and disinformation. The dilemma in the design and conduct of exercises is a classic one. Armed forces require realistic preparation for mobilization, for crisis-time deployment, and war. But, the more realistic the exercise scenario and the conduct of training "games," the more an alert putative enemy might learn. Generally, there are important data to be gathered from exercises. There have to be. If exercises are important to the exerciser - as they have to be, else why hold them? - then they have to be a source of important information to interested foreigners. All levels of relevant information may be gathered: technological, tactical, operational, and strategic. Even attempts at deception can be revealing (why are they trying to hide what they appear to be trying to hide?). When, on what scale, and particularly whether, nuclear weapons play an active role in Soviet military exercises, are significant issues well worth watching (as, of course, we do). Both historical experience and common sense suggest that the wise way
Soviet nuclear strategy
37
to use exercises deceptively is not to train forces in wholly fanciful maneuvers, but rather to conceal blueprints for contingent action among a variety of activities. Troops have to be trained realistically, but that training need not be conducted in such a way that its operational, let alone strategic and policy, implications are transparently obvious. It is worth mentioning that an actual intention to attack might be concealed within a large-scale military, naval, and strategic-forces' exercise. As the superpowers thin-out their forces in Central Europe, perhaps even disengage from the erstwhile line of scrimmage, the strategic advantage to be gained by an attack transitioning out of an exercise should be increased, even though it should become geographically more difficult to effect. Soviet military thinking, new or otherwise, does not need education in the value of maskirovka - or surprise and surprise effect overall. Writings and statements Glasnost may well destabilize the Soviet polity and its imperium more thoroughly than perestroika and other efforts at centrally managed, measured reform can possibly handle. To date, notwithstanding the nominal (though far short of actual) 50 percent reductions agreed to for START-accountable warhead totals which could slash the size of strategicforce stockpiles, "new thinking" on nuclear strategy is less than massively apparent in responsible circles. There has been some talk about minimum deterrence at low levels of nuclear weaponry, but nothing with self-evident policy or military-professional authority. Given the predominance of anodyne cliches about being ready to deliver a staggering rebuff to the enemies of the USSR and of peace, the eager Western Soviet-watcher finds little of much interest on Soviet nuclear strategy from the Soviet printed page. In the mid-1970s, and particularly following Leonid Brezhnev's Tula speech of January 1977, much of the color and life went out of Western-accessible Soviet writings on the subject of the utility of nuclear weapons in war. 23 There can be little doubt that Soviet leaders were embarrassed by the propaganda (and US defense budget-support) value of Soviet writings on the prospects for victory in nuclear war. But also it would seem to have been the case that in the USSR, as - somewhat later - in the West, operational military interest in nuclear weapons waned severely. After the mid-1970s the USSR imposed a much stronger discipline on its military writers. While alert to deception campaigns and to the seduction of fashion, still as Peter Vigor points out 24 - rules of scholarship should enable Western Soviet-watchers to make disciplined use of Soviet writings and statements.
38
Colin S. Gray
Because interpretations of the putative Soviet enemy play as a factor in internal US defense and foreign policy debate, all kinds of lawyers' tricks are employed in order to make the particular case desired at the moment. The overwhelming bulk of the inordinately tedious professional Soviet military literature that is available in the West should be taken at face value. That literature is fostered to further the professional education of an intensely professional defense community, not to deceive Western commentators. Such relative, if dated, gems as the Officer's Library series,25 or, more especially, the 1973-75 lectures smuggled out of the Voroshilov Academy (of the General Staff), are entirely credible and somewhat informative.26 However, direct Soviet commentary on the design of Soviet nuclear strategy, or even on the factors which bear on such design, is distinguished by its rarity. Analogically, Western seekers after knowledge of Soviet nuclear strategy have to shift tons of earth or very low grade ore before, if ever, they discover truly precious metal. Common sense and general knowledge
Whether it was the Marquis de Custine in 1839, or Tibor Szamuely in 1974, insightful commentators on matters Russian have a healthy habit of emphasizing the cultural particularity of their subject. Tinted though Soviet military spectacles have been by ideological and Great Russian national cultural perspectives, still the Soviet defense community is immensely respectful of what it understands by objective conditions. In his flawed masterpiece, Strategy: The Logic of Peace and War27 - following some of the major themes introduced by Carl von Clausewitz in On War Edward N. Luttwak posits and explores enduring relations among different levels of analysis and treats a paradoxical, quintessentially strategic, logic at every level (technical, tactical, operational, theater, and grand strategic). There is some value to general knowledge of strategic phenomena - a general knowledge that can be applied to the Soviet case. It should be noted that Soviet foreign policy similarly is all but fully explicable with reference to the general workings of international security politics. There is no such phenomenon as a distinctively socialist (or pseudo-socialist) defense strategy, any more than there is a socialist foreign policy (this is one of Francis Fukuyama's minor errors). It must never be forgotten that Soviet military thinking and planning, in very large part indeed, is the thinking and the planning of the world's greatest continental power, reasoning imperially. But, as this chapter has suggested already, there is much common ground between the current superpowers on matters of nuclear strategy, even if their particular
Soviet nuclear strategy
39
strategic cultures encourage them to seek to plant rather different strategy designs in that ground. For reasons of history, geography, and what may be termed the distinctively Soviet/Russian politics of defense planning and strategymaking, it is probable that Soviet operational responses to some of the major questions posed by nuclear weapons for policy, grand and military strategy, are different from those which comprise orthodox wisdom among the cognoscenti of Washington, DC, and Santa Monica. However, those operational responses certainly are founded upon a rigorous and clear-eyed study of what are believed to be objective conditions, and where different from the gospel according to Thomas Schelling, Glenn Kent, or Albert Wohlstetter, will not be idiosyncratically different.28 Questions that matter and questions that do not Can the USSR compete effectively in strategic nuclear forces? Viewed as two science-based defense industrial systems, the Western World and what tentatively remains of the Soviet empire are an order of magnitude apart in high-technological competence. 29 If the comparison is made much more broadly between "the West" (including both actual and strategically functional allies in East Asia) and the USSR with reference to defense mobilization potential of all kinds, the second-class character of the Soviet competitor is revealed even more starkly. However, notwithstanding the current time of admittedly severe troubles in the East (in the territorial as well as the all but defunct hegemonic empire), several factors have enabled the Soviet Union to play much above her innate scientific-economic strength. Specifically: the Western foe comprises a coalition which generates security at a level far below the sum of its many parts; the superpower competitor is a popular democracy politically unable to sustain a very high level of commitment to military competition; the nuclear thread seems to contradict much of the traditional logic of military competition; the strategic geography of the Soviet imperium provides - or provided - a concentration of threat via a medium (landpower) wherein Soviet competitive disadvantage was minimized; the Soviet command economy can focus its energies effectively, if not efficiently, on matters of high state priority in the security field; and in its several major non-military aspects, Soviet grand strategy can provide some compensation for the weaknesses of Soviet laboratories and factories.30 Provided one important, if arguable, caveat is not forgotten, the answer to the question "can the USSR compete effectively in strategic nuclear forces?" has to be in the affirmative. The caveat pertains to the US ability and willingness to react, indeed overreact, to belatedly determined identifi-
40
Colin S. Gray
cation of threat. Thus far, at least, certainly for a quarter-century, nuclear armaments have not lent themselves to exploitation as an instrument of military decision. The Soviet Union can menace the pre-launch survivability of most US ICBMs in silos, SSBNs in port, and some fraction of the manned bomber force on runways. But, no combination of quantity of nuclear firepower or attainable quality in weapon systems, has carried a plausible promise of classical style victory. The Soviet experience of the 1970s and 1980s was that more or less disputable advantage31 could be secured through prowess in its traditional arm of excellence, very long range artillery (ICBMs). But, the theoretical gain in net hard-target counterforce capability was both swamped by its limited military (and political) significance, and served eventually to trigger potentially very disadvantageous US competitive responses. To date, the Soviet Union knows that it could not design, build and operate a strategic defensive architecture against long-range ballistic missiles which would achieve strategically significant kill ratios. However, Soviet scientists and defense planners appear to have been convinced that the United States - let alone the West (including Japanese, West German, and Israeli hightechnology industries) more generally - just might succeed in constructing an SDI which could fulfill truly ambitious design goals.32 The argument must not be overstated. Soviet political leaders and defense planners seem to have been operating of very recent years upon the basis of the beliefs that they could not build a central Soviet war-winning offense-defense military posture, but that the United States just might be able to do so. Moreover, Moscow also has come to appreciate that the truly dedicated pursuit of military and political advantage over the United States is impracticable, given the current unsatisfactory terms of competition. Furthermore, frantic overt competition is counterproductive in that it prods the Western giant into a quantity and quality of competitive behavior that the USSR cannot possibly match. The much vilified idea attributed to the Reagan Administration in 1981-82 of, in effect, spending the USSR into bankruptcy, no longer looks quite so primitive or foolish. Where else did perestroika and glasnost come from if not from desperate Soviet recognition that, unreformed, they were outclassed in their ability to compete? To provide an intelligent answer to the question, "Can the Soviet Union compete?", it is necessary to ask, "compete to achieve what?" Moscow cannot compete to achieve the ability to wage and win a central nuclear war. But, even the United States would seem to be unable to achieve such a military-technical capability. Victory or defeat in war has rarely been strictly a matter of the economic ability to compete (though 1914-18 was an approximation of such a case). It is possible that the ability to wage central
Soviet nuclear strategy
41
war to a favorable decision will be reacquired at some point in the next century. The Soviet Union knows that it must stay in touch with the highest of high technologies for that reason, if for no others. However, in order to compete satisfactorily in strategic nuclear arms, the Soviet Union does not require that its nuclear-armed forces be able to win a classical victory. Instead, those forces must be able to deny US - or any other country's statecraft and strategy coercive benefit from nuclear threat or actual nuclear use. Ideally, in Moscow's perspective, Soviet nuclear-armed forces would deny foes nuclear compellent options either as an instrument for gain or, more likely, as a tool of controlled escalation intended to thwart Soviet nonnuclear action. 33 Can START help Soviet statecraft and strategy? START, as with CFE, makes sense only within a framework of competition in strategic relations. If political peace truly breaks out, then START and CFE would be irrelevant at best and an actual hindrance to improving relations, at worst. START should be regarded in the West grand-strategically as an element of the arms control instrument of Soviet policy. START is of great importance in Soviet statecraft because: it treats the weapons which have come almost to define superpower status; it addresses the realm of military competition to which Americans are most sensitive; and it speaks to that aspect of the overall strategic rivalry (except for the naval dimension) in which the Soviet Union is most at a structural competitive disadvantage. Above all else, the START process is helpful to Soviet statecraft and strategy as a net dampener of US strategic competitive effort. Soviet leaders, unlike many conservative and liberal commentators in the United States, know that START is insignificant for political issues of peace or war and bears scarcely worth mentioning upon matters of military advantage. Given that the unpredictability of the United States has been a cause of occasional alarm in Moscow, it is important to note the standard claim that arms control benefits stability because it increases the predictability of behavior by the High Contracting Parties. This claim is not a very persuasive one, historically and logically appraised. If the will to compete is still present, then arms control agreements channel competition into areas that remain unlicensed (large cruisers in the 1920s, intermediate-range ballistic missiles in the 1970s). Furthermore, no arms control regime could serve to offset a US unpredictability that reflected genuine security alarm. Moscow may have hopes, but can hardly have expectations, that START would effect the "lulling" of Western foes.34 Rather, START provides
42
Colin S. Gray
some rules for the conduct of the strategic arms competition which, though of little significance for great or less great issues of stability, do themselves, and by the tone they set, help to inhibit Western competitive prowess. In other words, it is not necessarily the Soviet purpose to employ START to set snares and create or feed delusions in the United States. But, along with domestic economic considerations, START could be a significant inhibitor of US military-technical programs. Moscow does not rely upon START to preclude the United States from developing the ability to win a World War III, let alone - through a pattern of cheating and illicit technical acquisition across frontiers - to allow the Soviet Union to acquire the weapons which might deliver a major military advantage. At least until the political melt-down of the structure of Soviet authority in East-Central Europe, Soviet-American military competition was conducted on two very uneven playing fields. Because of the geopolitics of superpower rivalry and the truly coalition character of the West the playing field of West-Central Europe was very uneven in the Soviet favor, while the playing field of the scientific-industrial bases was distinctly uneven to the Soviet disadvantage. START, which many Americans think of as a contribution to a deeply technical idea of strategic stability, instead - in Soviet perspective - is a thoroughly political institution intended by the Soviet Union to encourage the United States to play below its true capabilities. In the context of the Western Alliance, though not vis-a-vis China, Moscow does not appear to believe that nuclear weapons are very useful for any strategic purpose more ambitious than the deterrence of nuclear use by others. However, it remains the Soviet way to seek such military advantage as incompetent foreign negotiators or treaty-terms verifiers, and a slack pace of US force modernization, permit. The on-going and impending changes in the military balance in Europe will need to be considered both in the round, which is to say with respect to developments on both sides, not just to the East, and with reference to Mikhail Gorbachev's range of practicable alternatives. The 1989 admission of felonious conduct with the Krasnoyarsk PAR (phased-array radar) was something less than a resounding change of Soviet heart or policy. Moscow owned up, very belatedly, to the fact that Krasnoyarsk was a massive violation of the ABM treaty of 1972. But, the admission of guilt was forthcoming only when it became apparent that progress in START would be politically impossible in the absence of such a Soviet mea culpa. Notwithstanding occasional rhetorical claims to the contrary, the United States does not conduct defense postural and arms control planning as a
Soviet nuclear strategy
43
single broad enterprise. 35 The result, inevitably, is that military planners have to do the best with the quantitative and qualitative constraints that proved negotiable (or intellectually fashionable). Because of weapon system design from a previous era of assumptions, and because of the politics of defense budgeting in an era of arguable peace, it is a virtual certainty that the START process, as usual with the arms control, will tend to aggravate rather than alleviate existing military-technical problems. Conservatives will claim, with some justice that - for example - START will worsen the high-quality warhead to hard target ratio to the US disadvantage; that a reduced SSBN fleet will have to contend with unconstrained Soviet ASW capability; and that large-scale offensive missile reductions would enhance the strategic value of a Soviet BMD ("Red Shield") break-out from the ABM treaty regime. These claims are not without merit, but they would leave the USSR still so far distant from a reliable war-winning force that they should be discounted heavily as arguments leading Moscow to favor a START treaty. As suggested above, the real strategic value of START to the USSR almost certainly lies in its worth as a net dampener of the pace and the quantity of US competitive performance. How would the Soviet Union attempt to wage a central nuclear war? Western scholars, and most Soviet scholars, do not know the answer to this critically important question. The direct evidence on the basis of which an answer might be constructed ranges from the poor to the very poor (see the quality of evidence provided for the> relevant writings of William T. Lee, Notra Trulock, Edward Warner, Steven Meyer, and Joseph Douglass inter alia).36 The evidence that can be assembled in support of an answer to the question tends to contradict common sense. Rather after the fashion of some historians of early medieval times, Western commentators on Soviet nuclear strategy have no choice other than to exceed the strict bounds of the evidence available. Broadly speaking, there are two schools of Western thought on Soviet nuclear strategy for central war. The first school, led most copiously in terms of publications by Notra Trulock, 37 holds that the Soviet Union probably would attempt to wage what could be called a limited (central) nuclear war. Such a Soviet approach would endeavor to wage as little war as would be compatible with war aims. Moscow, recognizing that it could not win a war if US retaliation was unrestrained, would seek to confine its targeting rigorously to US military assets, and probably would risk paying some military price as an inescapable consequence of an attempt to leave
44
Colin S. Gray
the US national command authorities (NCA) intact. It is readily apparent that this view of central nuclear war, in the absence of direct evidence of Soviet intentions, amounts both to the projection of dominant American ideas on nuclear strategy, escalation control, and war termination, upon the USSR, and to recognition of an ancient maxim that an enemy should be left an alternative to a fight to the death. The second school of thought on Soviet nuclear strategy holds that Soviet strategic culture denies, or at least very strongly encourages the denial of, the possibility of limited central nuclear war. In this view of the Soviet official mind-set, a nuclear assault upon the homeland would be interpreted on the receiving end as a bid for complete victory.38 The context could be all important, but it may be that nuclear assault on the Soviet homeland itself would define the context and the terms of engagement. Politically, too much would be at stake for the superpowers to fight each other at home according to some variant of the caricature of eighteenth-century war doctrine which helped inspire Western limited-war theory in the 1950s. None the less, Soviet military planners and operators would treat nuclear-armed forces as scarce assets to be employed cost-effectively; that is to say efficiently. However, in the view of this second school of thought Soviet strategy would not be concerned to control escalation (save by brute force) or to establish favorable conditions for a negotiated "war termination." Instead, Soviet military power would be applied for the proximate goal of securing a clear, favorable military decision. Common sense suggests that the first school of thought ought to be correct. Is it reasonable to believe that the same Soviet Union which would be very reluctant to have resort to nuclear weapons in a regional conflict,39 and which has claimed authoritatively that it would control such nuclear resort carefully, would wage a central nuclear conflict as if it were an old fashioned war which could be won decisively? Furthermore, even if the military professionals on the General Staff are the sole authors and would be the authoritative executors of the war plans, is it reasonable to believe that political leaders on the wartime Stavka would not intrude themselves into some critical details of nuclear force application?40 Though with generally poor results, Joseph Stalin attempted to play field commander in 1941-42 (and subsequently he certainly monitored very closely the performance of those to whom he had delegated operational command). 41 Is it likely that a future Soviet/Russian president would not endeavor to do likewise, given what would be at stake? Indeed, after 1914 generals lost their licenses to conduct war according to the dictates of military expediency. It is entirely possible, for example, that a US president would find none of the pre-planned SIOP options to be responsive to his policy needs.
Soviet nuclear strategy
45
Four points warrant citation as bearing upon, or answering directly, the question posed about Soviet choice of strategy for the conduct of central Soviet war. First, Soviet military and civilian capabilities for waging and surviving war are inherently ambiguous. Improvements in Soviet strategic C 3 I, in the technical reliability of their weapon systems on alert, in the pre-launch survivability of forces, and in the accuracy with which weapons can be laid down at great distances - are all points which lend themselves to alternative interpretation vis-d-vis Soviet preferences in strategy. Second, it would seem to be sensible, or perhaps just prudent, to take Soviet leaders and commentators at face value when they make the logical, if potentially very dangerous, argument that the conduct of war must be governed by its political purposes. That view is both an unintelligent, even fatalistic, reading of Clausewitz and is historically less than fully persuasive. Clausewitz's "grammar" of war may make no sense without reference to policy, but - as the master noted - war does have a grammar, a nature, of its own which "policy" needs to understand. None the less, Soviet leaders and commentators have offered no encouragement to the idea that a central war could be waged to any conclusion other than the defeat of one side or the other (or both). Defeat, of course, can have different meanings for different polities. Third, as best one can tell from the evidence available, the Soviet approach to war does not include education in the supposedly strategic theories and processes of crisis management, threshold observance for escalation control, and war termination. In practice, of course the Soviet Union manages crises, recognizes the salience of some thresholds for the control of violence, and seeks to terminate conflicts. However, Soviet strategic culture approaches those functions in a distinctly unAmerican manner. As a caveat, one should not lightly project Soviet style in regional crises or conflicts for the shaping of US expectations of Soviet style in the conduct of central nuclear war. Fourth, whether or not the result would be a foredoomed attempt to "conventionalize" that which inherently is not conventional,42 Soviet statements of all kinds are consistent only with the view that should they ever be compelled, very reluctantly, to wage central nuclear war, they would seek, though not confidently expect to achieve, a clear military (and hence political) decision. One cannot and should not predict that the USSR assuredly would seek to win a war which its experts, as well as common sense, would deny could be won. But, the canons of scholarship, and a concern lest national strategic cultural assumptions not mislead, oblige us to behave as if the USSR would seek to win a World War III in a classical military fashion. There are obvious commonsense, practical reasons why
46
Colin S. Gray
Soviet leaders should take a distinctly non-traditional view of central nuclear war (with the West if not with China) - which is to say a view of such a war which eschews interest in seeking military victory (but not in avoiding defeat). Moreover, those are reasons sufficiently powerful for the United States to be motivated to offer at least the possibility of a structure of conflict that need not lead to a general catastrophe. It is one thing to endorse a strategy that could fail deadly; it is quite another to endorse a strategy that, if tested, must fail deadly. This fourth point amounts to the advice: prepare for the worst, but make some intelligent provision to facilitate a less bad sequence of events. Has Soviet nuclear strategy changed? Contingency plans for the application of nuclear firepower are always changing in detail, as the inventory of weapons and the target base evolve. However, given the difficulty described above of understanding Soviet nuclear strategy, there is no evidence of recent years of any noteworthy change in that strategy for the conduct of central nuclear war. Indeed, there is no reason why evidence of such change may be awaiting discovery. Not only is there no evidence of authoritative (as opposed to civilian speculative) new military thinking pertaining to nuclear strategy for central war, in addition it is not obvious that there is room for new thinking. Long before the advent of the much heralded "new thinking," Soviet leaders would seem to have decided that although the USSR should endeavor to secure the best military outcome available in the event of general war, bilateral disaster was the most probable result of such a conflict. Notwithstanding the Soviet effort to secure such advantage as might be secured through vigorous offensive-defensive strategic-forces' competition, the overriding purpose of that competition has been, and remains, the negative one of deterring US (inter alia) initiatives. Should Soviet leaders come to feel an unaccustomed lack of coercive options on the ground as the structure of European security changes, then it is possible that more demanding (i.e. compellent) missions may be asked of their "strategic" (perhaps just nuclear-armed) forces. Lest the thoughts just expressed should seem unduly conservative, readers should consider the major continuities in US central-war strategy and nuclear targeting from the revision of the first SIOP (1960) in 1961 (SIOP-62) until SIOP-6F of 1989.43 Enough has been published about US targeting policy to support the point that even in a country where ideas on central war strategy are debated intensively, and where ideas come and go as fashions, relatively little of major significance has changed over the
Soviet nuclear strategy
47
decades. Weapon systems phase in and are phased out (some come and stay), and the tactical feasibility of particular missions will fluctuate technically, but truly "new thinking" about nuclear strategy is a rarity indeed and there is little in evidence in Moscow today. Undoubtedly there is considerable flux and uncertainty in the militarytechnical dimension of Soviet military doctrine. That uncertainty pertains both to attempts to respond to political insistence upon a less offensive orientation to force posture and plans, and to the proper meaning of the latest technical revolution in military affairs.44 Many Soviet military theorists believe that formerly valid distinctions between offensive and defensive weapons are in the process of definitive erosion. Also, they believe that NATO's (future) arsenal of ACMs, heavily grouped into "strike-reconnaissance complexes," could thwart the operational designs of Soviet ground forces. Overall, pending the need to accommodate new (Soviet) defensive weapons (ground and space-based), and perhaps to plan opportunistically to take advantage of new possibilities for damage limitation granted by unwise (past, present, and future) US decisions on strategic force posture under the influence of START, one should not anticipate important change in Soviet strategy for the conduct of central nuclear war. The realm of sensible choice for the Soviet Union is far less over strategic forces than it is over general purpose forces; an important point, albeit not unique to the Soviet case. After all, what might constitute the strategic-force equivalent of the military evacuation of East-Central Europe? (Possibly the endorsement of some concept of a "minimum deterrent.") But a Soviet Union acutely aware that it was surrendering the strategic leverage of a landpower previously plainly superior in Europe, would not be likely to be a Soviet Union willing to choose to reduce the military rationality of its central-war forces. However, crystal balls quite aside, as of this time of writing there is no authoritative Soviet evidence indicating anything resembling radical "new thinking" on nuclear strategy for central war. The four questions addressed above are all important and merit attention. The three remaining questions are none of them important, because the answers are quite trivially obvious in Soviet perspective. But, so many Western commentators believe that these questions - and the answers - are significant, that it is necessary to treat them here, if only very briefly. First, could a nuclear war be won? Soviet and US leaders recognize that a war in which some nuclear weapons were used could be won. The superpowers, inter alia, could use nuclear weapons and win a war. However, both sides tacitly agree that an attempt to secure a classic military victory with the outright, definitive defeat of the other superpower, is, pro
48
Colin S. Gray
tern, at least, impractical. Soviet leaders give every evidence of believing that nuclear war could occur, that a range of outcomes is possible, that the differences on that range could matter enormously, and that it is the duty of a nuclear-armed state to make militarily intelligent contingency plans for the efficient employment of nuclear weapons. Second, must the USSR compete with the United States? Notwithstanding domestic perestroika and "new thinking" on foreign and military affairs, there is no sign that Mikhail Gorbachev is suffering from galloping naivetethe classic ailment of Western liberals. Security is always relative, and relations of influence and anxiety are ever dynamic. The current upheaval in the Soviet empire would appear to have been caused predominantly by the felt need of the Soviet leadership to improve the competitive trim of their imperial polity. The fact that perestroika has led to the catastrophic demotion of the CPSU was not predictable long in advance; neither was it intended by Gorbachev. Reform and revolution can have a dynamic all their own. In order to effect the necessary reforms (the scope of which has changed over the years), the USSR elected to destabilize its own hegemonic empire in East-Central Europe (which is to say to deny support to non-reformminded leaders), and (hopefully) maintain sufficient geopolitical dominance as to yield her the kind of political influence in Europe that her security requires. Far from constituting evidence of the future irrelevance of superpower competition, Gorbachev's new thinking provides the most convincing proof of Soviet determination so to reform that they will be able to compete effectively in the next century. As Stalin so wisely said, "[t]hose who fall behind get beaten." T h i r d , is there an arms control alternative
to the superpower
military
competition? Soviet strategic culture has its blind spots - as with its often misplaced enthusiasm for a quantifiably "scientific" approach to many matters of defense analysis which transcend the purely tactical (which is quantifiable). However, it is a great strength of Soviet strategic culture that it tends not to confuse the political with the administrative. Soviet leaders have never endorsed or encouraged the very American idea that some of the political duties of the two security communities can be devolved upon technical experts. 45 If anything, traditionally the USSR has overcentralized at the top. Moscow has taken an unreasonably and impractically extensive view of what constitutes properly political, as contrasted with technical administrative, subjects. In Soviet strategic culture the idea is close to absurd that there is, or could be, an arms control process with a distinctive militarytechnical logic of stability, through which the superpowers could channel much of their strategic relationship. There is a logic of power politics and
Soviet nuclear strategy
49
there is an evolving correlation of forces, including a multi-faceted relationship, which must influence policy choice. But, the notion that there is a military-technical theory of strategic stability that can be applied, or, as it were, administered, by experts in an arms control process, is simply unSoviet. It should be recalled that what Soviet authorities refer to as their military doctrine has a military-technical dimension; that dimension is subordinate to high political direction. In Soviet strategic culture and consequently in day-by-day practice, arms control is a valued instrument of grand strategy. Arms control cannot have a strategic logic of its own. Arms control cannot function as an effective substitute for military competition in the way that such competition can substitute for war, because a "process" of arms control engagement has meaning only as an expression of a political urge to compete. If the urge to compete erodes and vanishes, then an arms control nexus becomes irrelevant. Conclusions Seven major points stand out as worth citing as conclusions to this chapter. First, the scope for opinion on Soviet nuclear strategy remains uncomfortably high. Direct evidence on Soviet preferences, let alone clear choices, in nuclear strategy, is all but totally absent. Western governments know a great deal about the capabilities and standard procedures of Soviet nucleararmed forces, and from intelligence data of all kinds they can make some plausible guesses about Soviet crisis-time moves. But, in answer to the question, "how would Moscow choose to fight its nuclear-armed central war forces in face of an enemy endeavoring to wage nuclear war with considerable targeting restraint?" one is in the realm only of guesswork. To date, Soviet defense professionals have not debated Soviet centralwar strategy in public. Large and flexibly capable land forces are to some degree constrained in their operational choices by the demands of terrain and weather. Central-war nuclear forces, with only modest exceptions, are not severely limited by physical geography in the choices they provide to policymakers. 46 Second, the cultural factors which influence perception are disciplined, to the degree that they are not themselves shaped, by objective conditions. Those conditions (the width of the Pacific Ocean, the general level of national technical and managerial competence, and so forth) will both affect what is perceived to be possible and, of course, will influence strongly what is practicably achievable. Soviet military doctrine, and certainly Soviet nuclear strategy, manifestly has been shaped by some highly plausible appreciations, or perceptions, of objective conditions. Objective
50
Colin S. Gray
conditions are dynamic. Net military competence varies from period to period (consider the combat prowess, qualitatively and quantitatively, of the Soviet Army, over the years 1939 - as revealed in Finland - to 1945). Whatever one discovers at the present time about Soviet strategic culture, or about technical developments in Soviet ICBMs, defense radars, and the like, Soviet military doctrine is dominated by the objective condition - and recognition of the same - that nuclear war against the United States cannot reliably be waged to achieve a classic military victory. Nuclear war should function to the net Soviet tactical and operational advantage in most circumstances at sea. But that judgment is overborne in significance by the strong probability that a Western Alliance unable to use its transAtlantic or transpacific sea lines of communication, would have prompt resort to nuclear weapons on land. 47 Third, within the severe constraints imposed by tolerably accurate recognition of objective conditions, the strategic culture that is the product of centuries of more or less unique historical experience works to fashion preferences and actual choices. It is a reality that a full-scale, or even much of, a SIOP-RISOP "exchange," must prove to be mutually self-defeating, but the culturally distinctive superpowers have reacted to that frustrating apparent fact in rather different ways (at least in so far as one can tell from open sources on the US side, and from the highly ambiguous evidence on the Soviet side). The USSR consistently has said that it rejects American strategic ideas on the controlled conduct of limited central war. On the one hand there lurks the probably unrealistic US aspiration for escalation control in a carefully conducted central nuclear war. On the other hand there hovers the Soviet aspiration that somehow, on the night and contrary to analysisbased judgment and common sense, Soviet nuclear arms could enforce a useful level of damage limitation. In practice, neither superpower has a militarily sufficiently useful central nuclear war posture as reliably to be able to coerce, or just bludgeon, its way to victory. Everybody knows this, but responsible defense officials must do their best with the technically, and hence tactically, inadequate military tools extant (and hope for a more counterforce-capable tomorrow). Fourth, although the Soviet Union of the early 1990s appears to be willing, even eager, to reduce nuclear-armed central-war forces by a nominal 50 percent (in START) or more (a START II), the political, strategic, operational, and tactical fundamentals of long-range nuclear forces have yet to be debated publicly. If there is a great Soviet debate underway on the utility or character of the strategic forces, it has yet to be monitored in the West. Already, Soviet postural evolution seems intelligently to have anticipated probable START limits (consider the case of
Soviet nuclear strategy
51
the road-mobile single-warhead SS-25, for example).48 The (new) thinking that really mattered about the strategic utility, and hence policy and strategic purposes of central-war nuclear forces, appears to have been settled as of the close of the 1970s at the latest. If the United States could not be deterred from taking nuclear initiatives, then Soviet nuclear-armed forces would be charged to do their best to achieve the military conditions for an overall political victory. Fifth, a mixture of strategic-cultural preference and recognition of objective conditions renders it unlikely that Soviet nuclear strategy for central war will change radically in the 1990s. The political possibility of a superpower central war may alter, but that is a very different matter. So long as the USSR retains a nuclear arsenal it must enjoy the services of strategy for the contingent employment of that arsenal. Everything in Russian history tells its contemporary legatees to attempt to prepare for war in as militarily rational a manner as possible. Far from seeking to accommodate radical change in their nuclear strategy, Soviet leaders are struggling politically - thus far successfully - to avoid having to adjust precipitately to cumulatively dramatic change in the central-war threat posed by the United States. Specifically, Soviet diplomacy has been waging political warfare against the rather vague US proposal, or threat, to deploy new strategic defenses. Sixth, a possible START treaty regime which might well reduce the US central war arsenal to approximately 9,500 weapons (including nonSTART-accountable warheads) is unlikely to trigger drastic, or even very noticeable, change in Soviet nuclear strategy. It is very probable that the USSR, though economically generally embarrassed, will compete under START more vigorously and less legally than will the United States. Such is the historical pattern of behavior under formal arms control restraint. There is nothing in the structure of the pending START treaty, particularly if treaty adherence is linked more or less formally to continued self-restraint in BMD testing and deployment, which should lend itself to exploitation for the effecting of very important changes in Soviet nuclear strategy. Seventh and finally, the point cannot be overemphasized that the nuclear strategy of the USSR, or of a successor state to the USSR, must be a subject of permanent interest. That superpower, deeply troubled or not, will remain heavily nuclear armed and in need of the services of strategic ideas and plans for the contingent operational direction of its nuclear arsenal. The terms and conditions of the US-Soviet security relationship could range from a freely expressed enmity to entente (or even alliance). However, Soviet nuclear strategy will remain both culturally stamped and responsible to a general logic which binds strategy to policy purpose.
52
Colin S. Gray Notes
1 National Security Decision Memorandum (NSDM)-242 of 1974 and Presidential Directive (PD)-59, and related matters of US strategic nuclear targeting policy, are treated in Desmond Ball and Jeffrey Richelson (eds.), Strategic Nuclear Targeting (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1986). 2 For a detailed examination of this issue, see Colin S. Gray, "ICBM's and Deterrence: The Controversy Over Prompt Launch," The Journal of Strategic Studies, vol. 10, no. 3 (September 1987), 285-309. 3 See Michael Howard, History of the Second World War: Grand Strategy. Vol. iv, August 1942-September 1943 (London: HMSO, 1970). Soviet ground and air forces similarly were unfit in 1941 for trial by battle with the Wehrmacht- but they had no choice. 4 See Yitzhak Klein, "A Theory of Strategic Culture," Comparative Strategy, vol. 10, no. 1 (January-March 1991), 3-23; and Joseph Rothschild, "Culture and War," in Stephanie G. Neuman and Robert E. Harkavy (eds.), The Lessons of Recent Wars in the Third World: Vol. n. Comparative Dimensions (Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1987), pp. 53-72. Also see the collection of essays, Williamson Murray and Alvin H. Bernstein (eds.), The Making of Strategy (Boston: Allen and Unwin, forthcoming). 5 See Colin Gray, War, Peace, and Victory: Strategy and Statecraft for the Next Century (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1990). 6 "Yet just as individuals are conditioned by the environment in which they grow up, so are governments conditioned by the same environment, and reflect, as well as reflect upon, national characteristics. These characteristics are shaped by geography, climate, historical experiences, and religious beliefs, which in turn determine economic circumstances, national prejudices, ideals or ideologies." Christopher N. Donnelly, Red Banner: The Soviet Military System in Peace and War (Coulsdon [UK]: Jane's Information Group, 1988), p. 13. 7 James Sherr, Soviet Power: The Continuing Challenge (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1987), p. 111. 8 Probably the most rigorous and insightful treatment of the "revolutionary" thesis is Robert Jervis, The Meaning of the Nuclear Revolution: Statecraft and the Prospect of Armageddon (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1989). 9 Quoted in Peter P. Witonski (ed.), Gibbon for Moderns: The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, with Lessons for America Today (New Rochelle, NY: Arlington House Publishers, 1974), p. 15. 10 For a good example, see V. V. Druzhinin and D. S. Kontorov, Decision Making and Automation: Concept, Algorithm, Decision (A Soviet View). Soviet Military Thought Series of the US Air Force, no. 6 (Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office, 1975; Moscow, 1972). Note Christopher Donnelly's comments on the Soviet reliance upon mathematical calculation in "The Development of Military Policy Under Gorbachev," in Donnelly (ed.), Gorbachev's Revolution: Economic Pressures and Defence Realities (Coulsdon [UK]: Jane's Information Group, 1989), pp. 124, 136. According to Donnelly, "Military Policy under Gorbachev," this operational-level reliance is "almost total" (p. 136). 11 As John Erickson has noted, Soviet scholars are wont to use the Great Patriotic War "as a vast data base." The Road to Stalingrad: Stalin's War With Germany,
Soviet nuclear strategy
12
13 14
15
16 17
18
19
20
53
Vol. (London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1975), p. viii. For a useful collection of essays by Western scholars, see Jonathan R. Adelman and Christann Lea Gibson (eds.), Contemporary Soviet Military Affairs: The Legacy of World War II (Boston: Unwin Hyman, 1989). Maritime-slanted Western analyses relevant to an attempt to answer this question include Michael McGwire, Military Objectives in Soviet Foreign Policy (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 1987); and Colin S. Gray, Competitive Grand Strategies and The Roles of the Navy (Fairfax, VA: National Security Research, January 1989). See Chris Bellamy, Red God of War: Soviet Artillery and Rocket Forces (London: Brassey's Defence Publishers, 1986). This is not to deny that the vulnerable forward-continentalist perspectives of some European allies, not to mention the enduring continentalist urges of the United States itself, could overcome the global-maritime concepts which might encourage Washington to seek to wage a protracted conflict. American history has taught its policymaking legatees to seek swift solutions to complex problems by means of the shortest route. Anglo-American strategy arguments in 1942-44 reflected the clash between somewhat differing theories of victory, which expressed differences between British and American strategic culture. See Samuel P. Huntington, American Military Strategy, Policy Papers in International Affairs, no. 28 (Berkeley, CA: Institute of International Studies, University of California, Berkeley, 1986); and Colin S. Gray, "Strategy in the Nuclear Age: The United States, 1945-1990," in Murray and Bernstein (eds.), The Making of Strategy. Aside from such standard sources as the annual US official Soviet Military Power (1981-90, to date), and the trade press (Aviation Week and Jane's Defence Weekly, preeminently), readers should consult the excellent source book, Thomas B. Cochrane et al., Nuclear Weapons Databook, Vol. iv: Soviet Nuclear Weapons (New York: Harper and Row, 1989). For plausible estimates of gross stockpile numbers, see "Estimated Soviet Nuclear Stockpile (July 1990)," The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, vol. 46, no. 6 (July/August 1990), 49. Following common usage, a first strike is an attempt to disarm an enemy. First use, in contrast, is an attempt to coerce. See US Department of Defense, Soviet Military Power: An Assessment of the Threat, 1988 (Washington, DC: US Department of Defense, 1988), pp. 59-62; and Soviet Military Power; Prospects for Change, 1989 (Washington, DC: US Department of Defense, 1989), pp. 52-53. See Bruce G. Blair, Strategic Command and Control (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 1985); and the more recent study, Kurt Gottfried and Bruce G. Blair (eds.), Crisis Stability and Nuclear War (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988). Samuel P. Huntington, "US Defense Strategy: The Strategic Innovations of the Reagan Years," in Joseph Kruzel (ed.), American Defense Annual, 1987-1988 (Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1987), pp. 23-43. The relationship between offense and defense is among the least well appreciated conceptual matters with which US defense professionals are obliged to grapple. See N. V. Ogarkov, Always in Readiness to Defend the Homeland, JPRS L/10412 (Washington, DC: FBIS, March 25, 1982); and Makhmut Akhmeto-
54
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Colin S. Gray vich Gareev, M. V. Frunze: Military Theorist (Washington, DC: PergamonBrassey's, 1988; first pub. 1984). These works, let it be noted, were more than just "period pieces." An outstanding Western interpretation of the recent evolution in Soviet military doctrine - reflecting, inter alia, some (not the Warsaw Pact melt down) of the factors cited in the text - is William E. Odom, "Soviet Military Doctrine," Foreign Affairs, vol. 67, no. 2 (Winter 1988/89), 114-134. For speculation on this question see Condolezza Rice, "The Party, the Military, and Decision Authority in the Soviet Union," World Politics, vol. 40, no. 1 (October 1987), 55-81. Also see David Holloway and Condoleezza Rice, "The Evolution of Soviet Forces, Strategy, and Command," in Gottfried and Blair (eds.)j Crisis Stability and Nuclear War, pp. 116-158. In his Tula speech Brezhnev formally disavowed the goal of strategic superiority and argued that nuclear war could not be won. See the analysis in Benjamin S. Lambeth, "Has Soviet Nuclear Strategy Changed?" in Roman Kolkowicz (ed.), The Logic of Nuclear Terror (Boston: Allen and Unwin, 1987), particularly pp. 213-219. Peter Vigor, "Western Perceptions of Soviet Strategic Thought and Doctrine," in Gregory Flynn (ed.), Soviet Military Doctrine and Western Policy (London: Routledge, 1989), pp. 79-105. For a comprehensive listing of the "Officer's Library" series, those available in the West and those not, see Harriet Fast Scott and William F. Scott, Soviet Military Doctrine: Continuity, Formulation, and Dissemination (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1988), "Appendix D: Original Plan of the Officer's Library Series," pp. 275-277. Graham Hall Turbiville, Jr. (ed.), (compiled by Ghulam Dastagar Wardak), The Voroshilov Lectures, Materials from the Soviet General Staff Academy: Vol. i. Issues of Soviet Military Strategy (Washington, DC: National Defense University Press, 1989). Luttwak's Strategy: The Logic of War and Peace (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1987), is flawed by its resolute refusal to provide definitions of key concepts, by its elevation of a powerful insight (that war, really conflict, is pervaded by a paradoxical logic) to a status of theoretical workhorse that exceeds its capacity, and by its lack of a sure intellectual grip of both maritime and nuclear matters. For all that, the book is an outstanding achievement that deservedly will be read long after the critical reviews are forgotten. For example: Thomas C. Schelling, Arms and Influence (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1966); Glenn Kent et al., A Calculus of First-Strike Stability, N-2526-AF (Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation, June 1988); and Albert Wohlstetter, "Between an Unfree World and None," Foreign Affairs, vol. 63, no. 5 (Summer 1985), 962-994. On the military-technological competition, see David Holloway, The Soviet Union and the Arms Race (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1983); and Matthew Evangelista, Innovation and the Arms Race: How the United States and the Soviet Union Develop New Military Technologies (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1988). Edward N. Luttwak, The Grand Strategy of the Soviet Union (London: Weiden-
Soviet nuclear strategy
31
32
33
34
35
36
55
feld and Nicolson, 1983), though seriously dated, is still crammed with valuable insight. For an example of pseudo-measurement, see Dean Wilkening et al., Strategic Defense and Crisis Stability, N-2511-AF (Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation, April 1989). Also see Kent, A Calculus of First-Strike Stability, for a further example from the same intellectual stable. No quality or quantity of fancy graphics can overcome the fact that strategic stability is not measurable period. See Benjamin S. Lambeth and Kevin N. Lewis, The Strategic Defense Initiative in Soviet Planning and Policy, R-355O-AF (Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation, January 1988). Characteristic Soviet blasts against SDI included: "Star Wars": Delusions and Dangers (Moscow: Military Publishing House, 1985); and Evgeni Velikhov et al., (eds.), Weaponry in Space: The Dilemma of Security (Moscow: Mir Publishing, 1987), chapter 4. See the contrasting views in Robert Jervis, The Illogic of American Nuclear Strategy (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1984); and Colin S. Gray, Nuclear Strategy and National Style (Lanham, MD: Hamilton Press, 1986). See Sean M. Lynn-Jones, "Lulling and Stimulating Effects of Arms Control," in Albert Carnesale and Richard N. Haass (eds.), Superpower Arms Control: Setting the Record Straight (Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing Company, 1987), pp. 223-273. By way of quite sharp contrast, Donnelly is right to note, even if he overstates, what he calls "an innate Russian ability to see the 'big picture' to subordinate short-term needs to long-term goals." Red Banner, p. 31. The Soviet strength in holistic approaches, whether or not it is "innately Russian," certainly is encouraged by the dialectical method of inquiry which their now practically defunct, though still (barely) authoritative state religion inherited from Nineteenth Century German philosophers. Turbiville (ed.), The Voroshilov Lectures, Vol. i, provides an excellent example of Soviet holism. "All forms of strategic action are interrelated and are conducted on the basis of a unified plan, under the control of the Supreme High Command, to achieve the general aim of the war." p. 252. William T. Lee, "Soviet Nuclear Targeting Strategy," in Ball and Richelson (eds.), Strategic Nuclear Targeting, pp. 84-108, 326-329; Notra Trulock III, "Soviet Perspectives on Limited Nuclear Warfare," in Fred S. Hoffman, Albert Wohlstetter, and Davis S. Yost (eds.), Swords and Shields: NATO, the USSR and New Choices for Long-Range Offense and Defense (Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1987), pp. 53-85; Edward I. Warner III, Soviet Concepts and Capabilities for Limited Nuclear War: What We Know and How We Know It, N-2769-AF (Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation); Stephen Meyer, "Soviet Nuclear Operations," in Ashton B. Carter, John D. Steinbruner, and Charles A. Zraket (eds.), Managing Nuclear Operations (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 1987), pp. 470-531; and Joseph D. Douglass, Jr., "Nuclear War Termination: Soviet Style," in Cimbala and Douglass (eds.), Ending a Nuclear War, pp. 19-43. Unlike Peter Vigor ("Western Perceptions"), my point at this juncture is not that these people are poor scholars, but rather that what they most seek to know is not knowable by the research means available to them (and they all have access to highly classified information).
56
Colin S. Gray
37 For example, Notra Trulock III, "Emerging Technologies and Future War: A Soviet View," in Commission on Integrated Long-Term Strategy, The Future Security Environment (Washington, DC: US Department of Defense, October, 1988), pp. 97-163. The same view pervades Albert Wohlstetter and Richard Brody, "Continuing Control as a Requirement for Deterring," in Carter, Steinbruner, and Zraket (eds.), Managing Nuclear Operations, pp. 142-196. 38 Meyer, "Soviet Nuclear Operations," p. 514. Benjamin S. Lambeth, "On Thresholds in Soviet Military Thought," The Washington Quarterly, vol. 7, no. 2 (Spring 1984), 69-76, also is highly relevant (and disturbingly plausible). 39 But, see the very careful analysis in Stephen Meyer, Soviet Theater Nuclear Forces, Part i: Development of Doctrine and Objectives, and Part n: Capabilities and Implications, Adelphi Papers nos. 187 and 188 (London: IISS, 1984). 40 See Meyer, "Soviet Nuclear Operations," p. 512. 41 See Seweryn Bialer (ed.), Stalin and His Generals: Soviet Military Memoirs of World War II (New York: Pegasus, 1969); Erickson, The Road to Stalingrad; and Albert Seaton, The Russo-German War, 1941-45 (New York: Praeger Publishers, 1970). 42 Jervis, The Illogic of American Nuclear Strategy, pp. 56-63. 43 See Sagan, Moving Targets, chapter 1; Nolan, Guardians of the Arsenal; and (with some skepticism) Desmond Ball and Robert C. Toth, "Revising the SIOP: Taking War-Fighting to Dangerous Extremes," International Security, vol. 14, no. 4 (Spring 1990), 65-92. 44 See Odom, "Soviet Military Doctrine." 45 For a book length treatment of this point, see Robin Ranger, Arms and Politics, 1958-1978: Arms Control in a Changing Political Context (Toronto: Macmillan of Canada, 1979). 46 But see Desmond Ball, "Modern Technology and Geopolitics," in Ciro E. Zoppo and Charles Zorgbibe (eds.), On Geopolitics: Classical and Nuclear (Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff, 1985), pp. 171-199; and Colin S. Gray, "Geography and Grand Strategy," in John B. Hattendorf and Malcolm H. Murfett (eds.), Limitations of Military Power (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1990). 47 An excellent analysis is Donald C. F. Daniel, "The Soviet Navy and Tactical Nuclear War at Sea," Survival, vol. 29, no. 4 (July/August 1987), 318-335. 48 See Michael Brower, "Targeting Soviet Mobile Missiles: Prospects and Implications," Survival, vol. 31, no. 5 (September/October 1989), 433-445.
3
The tightening frame: mutual security and the future of strategic arms limitation Raymond L. Garthoff
Nearly fifteen years ago I published an essay under a similar title at a time when there remained doubt as to whether the Soviet leadership accepted mutual deterrence and was seriously interested in strategic arms reductions and other limitations.1 There is now less doubt as to Soviet interest in deterrence and arms limitation. Today the real questions are, first, whether Soviet "new thinking" offers a way to go beyond stabilization of mutual deterrence through strategic arms limitations toward mutual security through nuclear disarmament, and second whether the United States is ready to do so. Indeed, if a decade ago it could be asked whether the Soviet Union was prepared to join the United States in arms control, the question now is whether the United States is ready to join the Soviet Union in going beyond mere arms control. This discussion will concentrate on the changes in Soviet political, military and security thinking that now pose the challenge, rather than on the American policy response. The Soviets also see other important ideologically sanctioned uses of military force, but the basic Marxist-Leninist ideological framework predicates a fundamentally deterrent role for Soviet military power.2 The Soviets have, none the less, faced a doctrinal dilemma. While jettisoning Stalinist views on the inevitability of war and the necessary or desirable role of war as a catalyst of socialist advance in the world, as Communists they were predisposed to assume that socialism would be destined to survive and to triumph, even if a world nuclear catastrophe occurs. If they openly discarded that view, they long believed, it could place in question not only their whole world-view but also their basis for legitimacy. Hence from the late 1950s through to the mid-1980s there were occasional reaffirmations of confidence in the ultimate triumph of socialism even if a world nuclear war should, despite Soviet efforts to prevent it, occur. Such confidence was expressed in the Party Program adopted in 1961. The Soviet leaders acknowledged that general nuclear war would threaten the whole existence and future of world civilization and mankind. From the late 1960s they began to draw further conclusions from that fact, deepening Soviet interest in strategic arms limitations and reductions, and in prevention of any 57
58
Raymond L. Garthoff
nuclear war. Ultimately, in the later 1980s, "new thinking" on this matter led to a new conception of requirements for security. Lenin embraced the observation of Clausewitz that "war is a continuation of policy by other means," and this indeed represents a natural Marxist-Leninist conception. Some Soviet writers, mainly but not exclusively civilians, as early as the 1960s were so impressed by the inexpediency and enormous dangers of any nuclear world war (or indeed any war which could escalate into such a war) that they seemed to challenge this view. They, in turn, were sometimes criticized and refuted by other spokesmen, mainly military. Yet the question kept arising. Why? Mainly because the two sides were not engaged in a theoretical disputation, but in a political argument with considerable potential importance for military programs and policy. In fact, both sides accepted the basic premise that war is a matter of policy or political motivation; both sides also have accepted the fact that resort to nuclear war would not be expedient as a matter of policy. The real underlying debate has been over whether war is recognized as so unpromising and dangerous that it can never occur. Such a question has profound implications for military requirements. Is a force dedicated to deterrence enough? Or, if war were to occur, despite Soviet efforts to prevent it, is a war-waging capability needed to seek a Pyrrhic "victory?" Soviet military power, and the constant enhancement of its capability and readiness, has been justified primarily for deterrence, but also to wage a defensive war if one should come despite Soviet efforts to prevent it. This view was consistently held by the Soviet military and political leaders from the mid-1950s to the mid-1980s. It is not accurate, as some Western commentators have done, to counterpose Soviet military interest in a "war-fighting" (and hopefully "war-winning") posture to a "deterrent" one. At least until very recently, the Soviets have seen the former capability as providing the most credible deterrent, as well as serving a contingent resort in the event of war. The emphasis, however, steadily shifted from the mid-1970s to the mid-1980s toward the absolute need to prevent nuclear war, even to the extent of repeated authoritative statements by successive Soviet leaders, and military chiefs, on the unwinnability of nuclear war. It is clear from Soviet military and political discussions that acceptance of the Clausewitzian (and Leninist) conceptions of the nature and role of war is not only compatible with mutual deterrence, but reinforces its paramount feature: recognition of the necessity of avoiding and preventing general nuclear war. The most important aspect of this particular question is the unfounded contention of some prominent Western commentators, such as Professor Richard Pipes, widely cited, that "as long as the Russians persist in adhering to the Clausewitzian maxim on the function of war, mutual deterrence does not really exist." 3 On the contrary, the Soviet
The future of strategic arms limitation
59
professional literature clearly shows that there is no contradiction between being "Clausewitzian" and recognizing the validity of mutual deterrence. Mutual deterrence in Soviet writings has usually been expressed in terms of assured retaliatory capability which would devastate the aggressor, because this formulation (rather than "mutual assured destruction" capability) is more responsive to ideological sensitivity over the idea that the USSR could be considered a potential aggressor and thus needs to be deterred. (Only adversaries - the United States, more broadly the imperialists, and for a time also the Chinese communists - are described as potential aggressors.) In addition, this formulation avoids identification with the specific content of the American concept of "mutual assured destruction," often expressed in terms of a countervalue capability for destroying a specified percentage of the opponent's industry and population. This US interpretation is more limited than the Soviet recognition of mutual deterrence, which rests simply on mutual capability for devastating retaliation unacceptable to a rational potential initiator of war, without calculations of arbitrary industrial and population losses that theoretically would be acceptable costs.4 Some observers have posited a possible Soviet conception of "deterrence by denial," as contrasted with the American conception of "deterrence by punishment." (Neither, of course, is a Soviet, or for that matter an official American, expression.) "Deterrence by denial" is conceived as seeking to deter by maintaining a capability for thwarting and defeating a potential attack; "deterrence by punishment" seeks to deter by relying instead on a capability for devastating punitive retaliation. Soviet force posture and "war-waging" military doctrine have suggested the possible applicability of this idea, but Soviet statements on deterrence have invariably been couched in terms of retaliatory punishment, and there is no indication that such a distinction reflects a Soviet way of thinking. The political leaders in their programmatic statements have endorsed the idea that deterrence requires strong and ready combat capability, but have never gone on to discuss meeting requirements for waging and winning a war. Brezhnev, for example, on a number of occasions stated simply: "Any potential aggressor is well aware that any attempt to launch a nuclear missile attack on our country would be met by devastating retaliation."5 In the Soviet view - shared by military and civilian leaders - just as in the mainstream of thinking in the United States in the 1970s, overall "parity" has existed for twenty years. There have been those - again, both in Moscow and in Washington, especially by the end of the 1970s - who were apprehensive as to whether this parity would be upset by some successful effort of the other side. But successive US secretaries of defense and
60
Raymond L. Garthoff
chairmen of the Joint Chiefs of Staff have agreed, even when sounding such an alarm for the future (fortunately, one that seems each few years to recede to a few years hence), that "at present" there is an overall strategic parity that while each side has certain areas of superiority they balance out to yield overall deterrent parity. Parity was, of course, for the Soviet side a significant advance over the previous US unilateral superiority. Soviet political leaders from the ebullient Khrushchev of the late 1950s on had been prematurely claiming various partial superiorities and overall parity. But only in the early to mid-1970s did the Soviet military leaders admit that an assured retaliatory capability for the USSR had not come about until "the 1960s," or the late 1960s. By the late 1970s and early 1980s commentators began to acknowledge that it was only in the early 1970s that "the USSR achieved nuclear missile parity with the United States." 6 This became the standard view in the 1980s. And the Soviet military have acknowledged that while each side has certain areas of superiority, these balance out to yield an overall parity. Nevertheless, uncertainties remain in the 1990s. Maintaining mutual deterrence The Soviet leadership, like its US counterpart, has always looked in the first instance and in the final account to its own unilateral military strength as the guarantor of deterrence of the other side and, hence, of mutual deterrence. Soviet generals in the 1970s often cited a statement made by General Secretary Brezhnev in 1970: "We have created strategic forces which constitute a reliable means of deterring any aggressor. We shall respond to any and all attempts from any quarter to obtain military superiority over the USSR with a suitable increase in military strength to guarantee our defense. We cannot do otherwise." 7 This, of course, remains a postulate of Soviet defense policy - as, indeed, of parallel US policy. In both the Soviet Union and the United States, elements of the professional military leadership, especially at the outset, were somewhat skeptical of the role that arms control - especially bilateral (or multilateral) negotiated commitments to strategic arms limitations - can play in securing such deterrence. At the same time, there is good evidence that national leaderships, including senior professional military men, came increasingly in the 1970s to accept negotiated strategic arms limitations as a contributing element in providing more stable and less costly deterrent military forces. Let us recall the important discussion by General Zemskov in Military Thought in 1969. He spoke of the particular importance of the possible "disruption" of the nuclear balance in case of "the creation by one of the sides of highly effective means of anti-ballistic missile defense while the
The future of strategic arms limitation
61
other side lags considerably in solution of these tasks" and that it would "increase greatly the danger of a nuclear war" if the West achieved such an advantage. 8 It is clear that this reflected a view held at the highest political and military levels, and the congruence of Soviet and American views and objectives led to the ABM Treaty signed in May 1972. Many Soviet writers have noted the effect of SALT in reflecting and supporting parity and the nuclear balance. Trofimenko expressed with particular precision the effect of the ABM Treaty on mutual deterrence, as seen by the Soviets. He described "a situation of equality of strategic capabilities of the USSR and the United States stemming from the essential equality in the balance of strategic arms (in particular, since each of the sides under any circumstances retains the capability for a retaliatory strike on the vital centers of the other)." While this situation had developed by the late 1960s, and was only implicitly codified in the SALT I agreements in late 1972, Trofimenko spoke of "the equalizing of capabilities of the USSR and the US for a retaliatory strike (in particular as a result of the prohibition on the creation of nation-wide ABM systems through the 1972 Treaty)," 9 and further "By relinquishing deployment of nation-wide ABM systems, the two sides eliminated one of the main motivating stimuli to the further build-up of efforts in the field of offensive systems." 10 This recognition of the key significance of the ABM Treaty in "preventing the emergence of a chain reaction of competition between offensive and defensive arms" was specifically cited by Marshal Grechko, then Minister of Defense, and General of the Army (now Marshal) Kulikov, then Chief of the General Staff, in 1972 in endorsing the treaty when it was formally considered by the Supreme Soviet in the ratification process. 11 Aleksandr Bovin, following the signing of the SALT II treaty in 1979, similarly commented on the contribution of the SALT I ABM treaty. 12 We should recall the second element in General Zemskov's analysis in 1969. In addition to noting the possibility of the disruption of the nuclear balance if one side obtained an effective ABM capability and the other did not, he also had noted such a danger "in case of a further sharp increase of nuclear [strike] potential" by one side. 13 Specifically, the great threat seen in the 1970s was MIRV. General Cherednichenko spelled it out in another article in Military Thought in 1974, referring to the so-called "Schlesinger Doctrine." He stated that while the counterforce conception was not new in American military thinking, in the 1960s a disarming strike had not been a real possibility, but with MIRV a disarming strike could be envisaged. And as he saw it, "the new US nuclear strategy is focused on a preventive preemptive strike. It is of a patently aggressive character and aims at increasing the possibilities for initiating a nuclear world war." 14 This is the
62
Raymond L. Garthoff
danger Soviet military planners have seen in the qualitative and quantitative superiority of the United States in MIRVed systems throughout the 1970s, and in other new offensive systems in the 1980s, especially coupled with prospective new strategic defensive spaced-based systems in the 1990s or beyond. The main concern of the Soviet leadership is US political-military strategic intention. They have also been concerned over growing US counterforce capabilities and parallel US advocacy of counterforce concepts, both because of threatened destabilization of the existing balance and because of what they suspect as to the underlying US intentions. Dr. Trofimenko, for example, concludes that the "genuine parity" reflected and bolstered by the SALT ABM treaty "does not suit American theoreticians." He has argued that: The true nature of American strategic missile targeting is a most important state secret, and the American command can target its missiles in any way it wishes without speaking out publicly about it. Hence the public campaign of the Pentagon connected with the advertised "retargeting" [of the Schlesinger Doctrine] is . . . a conscious effort to put psychological pressure on the other side.15 The reversal of US stated policy on the destabilizing nature of counterforce capabilities and the open pursuit of such capabilities after 1974 considerably raised Soviet suspicions, especially because it initially accompanied the failure in the latter half of the 1970s to reach a SALT agreement based on the Vladivostok accords. In the Soviet perception, the United States continued, notwithstanding SALT and detente, to seek military superiority even in the 1970s, and more openly in the 1980s. Although some highly placed US leaders and others are considered to have "soberly" evaluated the strategic situation and given up pursuit of supremacy in the 1970s, powerful forces are believed to have continued to seek advantage and superiority in order to compel Soviet acquiescence in US policy preferences. Moreover, actual American military policy and programs have been seen as seeking to upset or to circumvent the nuclear mutual deterrence balance. American counterforce capabilities developed and deployed since the mid-1970s constitute a powerful threat to the overall Soviet ICBM force, bomber force and submarine force (particularly since the latter two are not kept on the same degree of airfield alert or deployment at sea as are their US counterparts). While Americans have focused on growing Minuteman vulnerability, the Soviets recognize that ICBMs are less than one fourth of the US strategic force, and it is far more ominous for the Soviet side that its ICBM force has become increasingly vulnerable, because far more Soviet strategic eggs are in the fixed land-based ICBM force basket - nearly
The future of strategic arms limitation
63
70 percent of their total strategic warheads. Also, as noted above, other Soviet intercontinental forces are less numerous, less capable and even more vulnerable. Given the concerns in the United States over the Soviet threat to US ICBMs, it is no wonder that conservative Soviet military planners and responsive political leaders would be concerned over existing and growing US capabilities. From the vantage-point of Moscow, while a general nuclear balance had come into being by the beginning of the 1970s, and parity was recognized in the SALT accords and consolidated by Soviet military modernization programs of the 1970s, major continuing Soviet efforts were needed to keep up the balance. We in the United States are accustomed to regarding the later 1970s as a time of a "relentless Soviet military buildup," and of American relaxation in military programs - in the eyes of the Reagan Administration a decade of neglect and passivity. Yet, in fact, the United States added more strategic warheads to its force during the decade of the 1970s, the decade of detente and SALT, than did the Soviet Union. Moreover, we now know that while catching up with the United States by deploying its own MIRVed missiles the Soviet Union was cutting back in the pace of its overall military procurement. In 1976, the Soviet leadership made a decision of considerable importance: to reduce military spending from an annual rate of increase of four to five percent to about two percent, and to level off the procurement of military weapons and equipment. Paradoxically, just as this policy began to be implemented in 1976-77 the United States began to publicize a campaign decrying a spending gap, and depicting an allegedly undiminished Soviet rate of military spending as evidence of a relentless Soviet military buildup despite detente and SALT. 16 Regrettably, United States intelligence estimators did not detect and establish this Soviet cutback until 1982-83 - but to the Soviets it appeared that the United States was using a false charge of a growing Soviet military buildup that began in the late 1970s and burgeoned in the 1980s.17 The Soviet perspective, while no doubt biased, is more readily understood against this background. It should be emphasized that measuring a military balance and parity is a far more subjective matter than most people realize. Moreover, adversaries are bound not only to see the balance differently, but to resolve uncertainties in favor of the other side in the interests of prudence - and then, often, to use such "worst case" estimates not only for hedging in setting their own military requirements, but also to infer the adversaries' intentions as well as capabilities from such weighted estimates. 18 And Soviet and American military and political leaders have seen the military balance very differently - each side tends to look at the balance as if through the two ends of a telescope, at the adversary's capabilities through a magnifying lens and
64
Raymond L. Garthoff
then at one's own forces through the minifying reverse lens. Moreover, different historical, cultural-ideological, geopolitical and other filters importantly affect judgments. This occurred on both sides in the last half of the 1970s with respect to buildup and capabilities, and in the first half of the 1980s also with respect to intentions. 19 The process of "hedging" on parity by seeking a margin of insurance is occasionally recognized by Soviet commentators, but without much sympathy and without admitting that it affects their own defense programming. Indeed, it is usually dismissed as a US pretext for seeking superiority. 20 But it does tend to influence military force planning in both countries. There is, in addition, a strong temptation more or less consciously to manipulate "the threat" by the other side to justify one's own military programs. This also has been only too evident on both sides in this period, especially in the 1980s. Thus, from their perspective Soviet leaders and military and political commentators since the late 1970s have perceived the leaders of the United States to be following a "course directed at overthrowing the existing approximate balance of forces between the USSR and the United States and at achieving American military superiority." 21 The Central Committee in June 1980 charged that the United States was seeking to upset "the existing strategic balance in the world," and reaffirmed the need for strengthened Soviet defense capability "to defeat imperialist plans to attain military superiority." 22 Many Soviet commentators referred to the alleged US attempt "to destabilize global strategic parity in its own favor," and failure to recognize that "security in the age of nuclear parity is based on stability, and stability is based on the mutual acknowledgement of equality and on abandoning the aspiration for superiority." 23 Beginning in 1980-81, Soviet military men began to become increasingly concerned as the United States buildup became large and sustained. Yet successive Soviet leaderships under Brezhnev, Andropov, Chernenko and Gorbachev, while vowing to maintain parity and continuing Soviet strategic modernization programs, did not accept plans for a comparable Soviet buildup. Military leaders, and other Soviet leaders and commentators, have displayed considerable suspicion of US intentions, and concern not only over growing US capabilities, but also as to why this continued increase in capabilities is sought. To be sure, some of these expressions of concern doubtless serve other purposes, such as argument to support requested Soviet military programs. But many have the ring of sincerity about them and many cite incontrovertible evidence to support their arguments on capabilities, as well as "evidence" which to the Soviets seem to be convincing signs of nefarious US objectives and intentions. 24 During the first Reagan Administration the sustained American military
The future of strategic arms limitation
65
buildup stilled any doubts in Moscow that there was a major United States effort to regain strategic superiority. While seeing the Reagan Administration's military program as essentially continuing and building on those of its predecessor, Soviet observers saw radical change in two other respects, changes that imparted a still more ominous cast to the whole direction of US military strategy. The first significant new departure was the attitude toward strategic arms limitation. The second significant new departure of the Reagan Administration was the president's flamboyant advocacy of a strategic defense initiative (SDI), as it came to be called officially, better known (and termed in most Soviet commentary) as "Star Wars." The Star Wars initiative directly challenged the whole rationale of the ABM Treaty banning a ballistic missile defense of the territories of the two countries. Thus, the real American objective was perceived as a defensive shield to augment a strengthened sword and permit use politically, or even militarily, of a coercive first strike capability.25 This aim seemed strengthened in later months and years as US spokesmen increasingly shied away from the idea that the SDI could replace a nuclear offensive deterrent, as Reagan had suggested, and claimed instead it would supplement offensive forces and strengthen deterrence (interpreted by the Soviets to mean coercion). Space weapons, seen as a principal element in the SDI, have come to be suspected of development also as offensive arms, "space strike weapons." Thus, for example, Marshal Akhromeyev, then first deputy Minister of Defense and Chief of the General Staff, wrote that: "Reagan's so-called 'Strategic Defense Initiative,' which envisages the creation of a large-scale ABM defense system and, most important, the deployment of strike weapons in space, also pursues aggressive aims. The main purpose of this program is perfectly clear: to make possible a sudden nuclear attack on the Soviet Union with minimal risk to the United States." 26 Then Defense Minister Marshal Sergei Sokolov similarly declared in 1985 that "From the military view-point, the American 'Star Wars' plan is an integral part of US nuclear strategy, a.first-strike strategy." 27 The Soviet military, as well as political, leaders see the Star Wars program as a US attempt to capitalize on technological superiorities in seeking a military superiority in order to gain political dominance. Even if doomed to failure (and the Soviets may not be quite so certain of this outcome as they say), it would at least disrupt the offensive - defensive connection stability by the ABM Treaty. Again, Marshal Sokolov stressed that "the creation by one of the sides of a large-scale ABM system will break this interconnection ['that objectively exists between offensive and defensive arms'], will destabilize the strategic situation, and will require the other side to reestablish the situation either by building up its strategic
66
Raymond L. Garthoff
offensive arms, or supplementing them with antiballistic missile systems, or most likely both." 28 The SDI is also seen as both undermining the existing ABM Treaty, and precluding further steps in strategic offensive arms limitations. As General Secretary Mikhail Gorbachev put it: "The creation of space weapons can have only one result: the arms race will become even more intensive and will embrace new spheres." 29 Indeed, Soviet commentators not only see an intensification of the arms race as the inescapable result of the SDI, but also as part of at least its initial purpose: "The real purpose behind Reagan's space fantasies is to pave the way for renouncing existing accords and whipping up the arms race in all kinds of strategic weapons, offensive and defensive." 30 Finally, complementing and supporting both the American abandonment of serious arms control, and the intention to escape the constraints of the ABM Treaty, was an escalation of charges of Soviet noncompliance with the ABM Treaty, SALT II, and other arms control agreements. The Soviet leaders explicitly tied these military developments to the aims of the Reagan Administration to mount a "crusade" against Soviet socialism, and "to destroy socialism as a social-political system." 31 Thus in addition to intensifying military competition, and making arms control impossible, the US Star Wars program has been seen as reflecting and intensifying political confrontation. By coincidence the resumption of arms negotiations occurred just as Gorbachev became the Soviet leader. Initially, for the first year, only minor steps were taken by either side - the United States was not really prepared to negotiate any constraints on strategic defenses and space weapons, and the Soviet Union was not prepared to move on strategic arms reductions in the absence of such constraints. Even the restoration of highest-level contact in the summit meeting of President Reagan and General Secretary Gorbachev at Geneva in November 1985 only produced another papering over of that basic divergence, rather than a step toward its resolution. On January 15,1986, Gorbachev unilaterally proposed a plan for gradual staged elimination of all nuclear weapons in fifteen years, by the end of the century. 32 While widely regarded at the time as primarily a propaganda initiative, it provided a framework for partial agreements, and directly contributed to the later INF Treaty, the proposed 50 percent reduction in strategic arms, and the new readiness for on-site inspection that made that progress possible.33 The Reykjavik summit in October 1986 represented a spectacular failure in an over-ambitious attempt to reach a very far-reaching reduction of nuclear arms, caused by an impasse over the question of strategic defense and space weapons. None the less, there was real progress in negotiation of
The future of strategic arms limitation
67
many elements for a 50 percent strategic arms reduction agreement, and toward the eventual INF Treaty. In December 1987 the INF Treaty was signed, and in May 1988 ratified, while negotiation continued on a 50 percent reduction in strategic arms. Meanwhile, attention increasingly turned toward forthcoming talks on conventional arms in Europe. This was given an impetus by a major unilateral reduction, including six forward-deployed Soviet tank divisions in Central Europe, announced by Gorbachev in a speech to the UN General Assembly in December 1988.34 Arms control and reductions, an uncertain prospect in 1980-81, and indeed until 1986-87, became a growing concern. To be sure, there remains serious technical difficulties over verification of some measures, but not because of political reticence. There also remain important differences over evaluations of requirements for deterrence and stability based on the differing geostrategic perspectives of the two sides. The questions of continued commitment to the ABM Treaty and to the strategic design it embodies remain. But Soviet interest in strategic arms limitations and reductions is not an issue. Mutual deterrence, despite differences over the respective weight to be accorded to unilateral defense or negotiated reduction, is accepted by both sides. There has, however, been an interesting and significant transformation underway on the Soviet side. From mutual deterrence toward mutual security As early as the mid-1970s, arguments began to appear in some Soviet writings on the need to go beyond codification of a nuclear balance on the basis of parity at the very high levels currently existing. A writer in Pravda in 1976 argued: "Trying to justify the arms race, certain political circles in Western countries propagandize some sort of balance of terror which is supposedly necessary to maintain peace and to ensure the security of peoples. But such a balance is an unreliable foundation for security. The real way to achieve security is to observe the principle of the non-use of force."35 These commentators did not oppose a nuclear balance based on parity from the standpoint of seeking superiority, but rather argued for a need to go beyond it to disarmament.36 Soviet objections to the "balance of terror" and indefinite reliance on mutual deterrence extend beyond concerns and continuing risks of possible resort to nuclear warfare or accidental occurrence precipitating nuclear war. "The conception of preserving peace on the basis of an 'equilibrium of fear' or 'balance of terror' occupies an important place in the arsenal of the enemies of disarmament."37 The concept of the "balance of terror" and
68
Raymond L. Garthoff
mutual deterrence is, it is argued, used by Western opponents of detente and disarmament to legitimize the arms race. 38 Nevertheless, Soviet critics note that while the "balance of terror" is an uneasy peace owing to the tension engendered by being under a nuclear sword of Damocles, and much less satisfactory than one marked by trust and disarmament, still "such a balance is peace." 39 Thus, the Soviet position has been to accept that "nuclear missile parity is a condition contributing to the success of a policy of peace," and that detente in the 1970s reflected the strategic nuclear balance of parity, while advocating steps beyond that situation toward greater cooperation and disarmament. 40 By the time of the 26th Party Congress in 1981, Brezhnev declared that "to count on victory in a nuclear war is dangerous madness." 41 A few months later he repeated that statement, and added that "only he who has decided to commit suicide can start a nuclear war in the hope of emerging a victor. No matter what strength an attacker possesses, no matter what method of unleashing war he chooses, he will not attain his aims. Retribution will inevitably ensue." 42 Party leaders Andropov and Chernenko made similar statements in major party pronouncements on Lenin's anniversary, and Chernenko stressed that it would be "criminal" to view nuclear war as a "rational, almost 'legitimate' continuation of policy." 43 At the Geneva Summit meeting of President Reagan and General Secretary Mikhail Gorbachev in 1985, it was reportedly Gorbachev who took the initiative in proposing inclusion in the joint statement that the two sides "agreed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought," as well as reaffirming that they would "not seek to achieve military superiority." 44 By the mid-1980s even Soviet military spokesmen were saying that today "what is at issue is no longer victory or defeat, but annihilation or existence." Lieutenant General Dmitri Volkogonov, then deputy chief of the Main Political Administration and a well-known military theorist, made that statement in 1985 in a major article on "War and Peace in the 'Nuclear Age'" on the seventieth anniversary of Lenin's principal military writing, "Socialism and War." 45 He reaffirmed as valid today Lenin's Clausewitzian definition of war as the continuation of policy by violent means, but went on to stress that "it is becoming increasingly obvious that a nuclear war can no longer be used by an aggressor as a means for resolving political tasks." He cited Brezhnev's 26th Congress statement that "counting on victory in a nuclear war is dangerous madness," and as noted above went beyond to question even the concept of "victory" for anyone. He also repeated the judgment that "The arms buildup above a certain level ceases to play a decisive military role." As he put it, "Indeed, life on earth can be annihilated only once, not twice or three times over." And he cited a
The future of strategic arms limitation
69
statement attributed to Lenin that the militarization of science and technology can undermine "the very conditions of the existence of human society," which he depicted as displaying striking sagacity. No matter how one interprets this or other statements by Lenin, what is significant is the ideological basis being provided to support the current Soviet view and to discourage any challenges to it. Deterrence is the underlying military policy, and "the only objective material basis for deterrence of war today is the capability of socialism to maintain strategic parity in nuclear means." General Volkogonov emphasized, as do all Soviet writers, the existence of a "prevailing approximate parity in strategic nuclear forces" as depriving the imperialists of any realistic hope for achieving victory and thus deterring war and preserving the peace. Far from seeing this as a transient development, he drew from it a far-reaching theoretical proposition: "Essentially, this dialectical interconnection between a balance of strategic forces and attainment of international security emerges as one of the laws governing the preservation of peace in the world." But while deterrence is seen as the necessary bedrock, Volkogonov also stressed that "the dominating imperative of 'the nuclear age' is that real security lies not in the search for ways to achieve victory in war, but in the ability to prevent a nuclear cataclysm." 46 This discussion is indicative of the trend in Soviet military and political thinking by the mid-1980s.47 This general approach had received authoritative advocacy from successive Soviet political leaders. Gorbachev, however, appears to have carried this line of thinking further. Gorbachev and the "new thinking" on security By the time of the 27th Party Congress in 1986, Gorbachev not only spoke of "the complete unacceptability of nuclear war," but also of the insufficiency for security of defense or deterrence in the nuclear age. "The character of contemporary weapons," he said, "does not permit any state hope of defending itself by military-technical means alone, even by creating the most powerful defense." 48 While accepting the reality of mutual deterrence "when the whole world has become a nuclear hostage," he argued that "security cannot indefinitely be built on fear of retaliation, that is on doctrines of 'deterrence' or 'intimidation.'" Moreover, "these doctrines [deterrence] encourage the arms race, which sooner or later can get out of control." Rather, "Ensuring security more and more becomes a political task and can only be solved by political means. Above all, the will is needed to take the path of disarmament." 49 And "it is more than time to begin a practical withdrawal from balancing on the brink of war, from a
70
Raymond L. Garthoff
balance of terror, to normal civilized forms of mutual relations between states of the two systems." 50 By this time the Soviet leadership had established the maintenance of strategic parity with the United States as a foundation for stability, deterrence, arms control, and security, and endorsed all these aims. An article in May 1986 in the authoritative journal Kommunist is worth citing at some length: Life has so developed that both of our countries must proceed from the fact that strategic parity is a natural condition. Without a military-strategic balance the maintenance of international stability is unthinkable. Without it it would hardly have been possible to conclude a number of treaties and agreements on the limitation of the arms race. An approximate equivalence of forces must be accepted as a foundation for international security, as a self-evident imperative. But for this new thinking, it is necessary to understand that for reliable defense today a considerably reduced number of arms is sufficient. Indeed, and this is obvious to everyone, the present level of the balance of nuclear potentials of the two sides is much too high. For the present this ensures both sides with equal danger. But only for the time being. A continuation of the arms race will inevitably increase this equal danger and it could lead to such extremes that even parity would cease to be a military-political deterrent.51 Similarly, the new Party Program adopted at the 27th Party Congress in 1986 described "The establishment of military-strategic parity between the USSR and the United States and the Warsaw Pact and NATO" not only as "a historic achievement of socialism," but also argued that the preservation of parity is "an important factor for safeguarding peace and international security." 52 It is difficult to overstate the importance of strategic parity in Soviet thinking. For example, a leading Soviet academician described as an "epic of the twentieth century," ranking along with the Bolshevik Revolution and the Soviet victory in World War II, "the achievement of militarystrategic parity with the strongest and most mighty capitalist power, the United States, permitting mankind to keep peace on earth and to save civilization from a nuclear missile catastrophe." 53 Yet parity itself, as traditionally conceived, has come under challenge by the new thinking. In delivering the Political Report of the Central Committee to the Party Congress, Gorbachev introduced the concept of "reasonable sufficiency" as a criterion in determining military requirements. 54 He did not spell out how reasonable sufficiency itself would be determined, and encouraged an open discussion of the issue. The military soon began to stress that the foundation for reasonable sufficiency was maintaining strategic parity. 55 General of the Army Dmitri Yazov, minister of defense, emphatically expressed the continuing view that "Military
The future of strategic arms limitation
71
strategic parity remains the decisive factor in preventing war at the present time," that is, serves as the key to deterrence of war. 56 Debate, indirectly expressed, none the less continued on whether "parity" meant quantitative equality in strategic forces, or qualitative equality in the ability to deliver a retaliatory strike - that is, a parity in deterrent capability. While the minority of civilian commentators who came close to espousing a doctrine of minimum deterrence with inferior forces has not prevailed in the debate, the idea of qualitative rather than quantitative parity has. Thus even a relatively conservative military writer by 1989 accepted the idea that the traditional quantitative approach must be replaced by a qualitative one based on "reasonable sufficiency for defense," although "the measure of reasonable sufficiency is defined not only by us but also by the other side's actions." Most important, however, is the recognition that parity is defined in mutual deterrent capabilities. The new approach "requires that parity be regarded as a correlation of the two sides' strategic potential that provides capability to inflict unacceptable damage on the aggressor in a retaliatory strike." 57 This acceptance of a retaliatory deterrent capability as the essence of parity has also been reflected in confidential internal military discussions. For example, in 1988 this approach was made crystal clear in a discussion in the General Staff journal Military Thought: "Military strategic parity between the USSR and the USA, and between the WTO and NATO, has decisive significance for deterrence of aggression and prevention of war. Maintaining military-strategic parity doesn't mean an absolute equality of forces, but requires capabilities for assured dealing of an unstoppable retaliatory strike." 58 The acceptance by the military of mutual assured destruction capability as the foundation for parity and reasonable sufficiency of strategic forces underlies military support for Gorbachev's efforts to reduce strategic nuclear weapons (and indeed all nuclear weapons) on both sides to the fullest extent negotiable. The new thinking also calls for going beyond mutual deterrence to mutual security. Again, the basis for a new approach was provided by Gorbachev's earlier cited declaration at the Party Congress that "security cannot indefinitely be built on . . . doctrines of'deterrence'...," but "more and more becomes a political task," based on recognition that "security can only be mutual" or general. 59 How do the Soviets envisage mutual security serving as a replacement for mutual deterrence? While various Soviet writers have stressed different aspects of this matter, the overall conception that has been emerging has four elements: strategic stability, national interests of the parties, increased reliance on international institutions, and increased trust. These are
72
Raymond L. Garthoff
mutually reinforcing elements, and movement in each can have a synergistic effect on the others. A military balance, and strategic parity in a qualitative deterrent sense, retains an important, and at least initially crucial, role. As Colonel Strebkov has put it, "a qualitative approach to parity requires the creation of an integral system of strategic stability on the basis of military equilibrium." As the military factor diminishes in importance, "as parity falls to lower and lower levels, on the basis of reasonable sufficiency for defense and a balance of interests, there will be a corresponding increase in stability in relations between the USSR and the United States and the Warsaw Pact and NATO as a whole. A policy of strength will give way to political and legal means of settling problems that arise." 60 Stressing the role of reliance on reasonable sufficiency in reducing mutual threat perceptions and thereby lowering tension, Soviet analysts have begun to emphasize the need to accommodate the national interests of the sides. "Reasonable sufficiency," they note, "presupposes that in order to prevent aggression it is necessary not only to balance forces, and to evaluate the hypothetical capabilities of the other side, but above all to restrain its leadership from unleashing war, by taking into account its real intentions, and most important its interests." 61 The combination of reciprocally reducing and restructuring military forces in accordance with reasonable sufficiency, and political measures based on mutual accommodation of national interests, would thus become "the shaping of a new model for ensuring security not by means of mutual deterrence but by the creation of an atmosphere of mutual trust." 62 Finally, as a concomitant to this diminished military capability and diminished perception of a threat, with increased mutual trust and accommodation, the very role of deterrence will be increasingly assumed by the changing world order and "the role of deterrence in the new world order will no doubt have to be played by political and legal instruments. An important role must be played by international law and international institutions." 63 The increased attention being given by the Soviet Union to international institutions, including the resolution of regional conflicts, is relevant in this connection. The role of strategic arms limitations and reductions in helping to secure parity at even lower levels is obvious. As with other aspects of the changing Soviet military doctrine, some things can be done unilaterally but much can only be done reciprocally by tacit agreement or more likely by formal negotiated accords. Gorbachev's dramatic proposal on January 15, 1986, for elimination of all nuclear weapons by the end of this century was perhaps too dramatic, too theatrical. But at Reykjavik in August it became clear that the Soviet Union was prepared to agree on eliminating all nuclear
The future of strategic arms limitation
73
weapons. And as less far-reaching interim steps, the Soviets proposed reductions of 50 percent, and soon thereafter agreed to a separate "zero option" elimination of intermediate and lesser range missiles. Parallel with these developments, General Kozlov, former first deputy chief of the General Staff, wrote in the confidential journal Military Thought, not for a public audience, that both parity and mutual deterrence while necessary for the present were not the Soviet preferred state of affairs. The Soviet Union, he stated, "considers military-strategic parity only as a definite frontier beyond which it is necessary to move to achieve a reduction, and ultimately even a complete elimination, of the threat of nuclear war." "Our country," he continued, "is doing everything possible to get out of the situation of 'mutual assured destruction.5 The aim of the policy of the USSR is to exclude nuclear weapons from the arsenals of states and in the final account their complete elimination." 64 In the meantime, the Soviet Union is also moving to change its military objective not only in terms of parity at reduced levels, a defensive and strategic doctrine, and reducing and restructuring elements of their force posture that appear especially threatening to the West (and to China), but also is designing its strategic concept to facilitate conflict termination, rather than victory, as the operative objective in case hostilities were to occur. That, however, is a subject beyond the scope of this discussion. Conclusion Soviet acceptance of parity and mutual deterrence, renunciation of the goal of superiority, and positive interest in negotiated strategic arms limitations and reductions are now much clearer than they were when SALT began more than twenty years ago. Those American commentators who long argued that the Soviets, and in particular the Soviet military, reject mutual deterrence, and who have therefore questioned the basis for mutually useful strategic arms limitations, were evidently not sufficiently aware of the record. Allegations that Soviet statements on mutual deterrence and the unacceptability of general nuclear war were "for export," and contrasting them with selected Soviet military statements on war-waging doctrine, have been either misconceived or mischievous. Authoritative statements of successive Soviet political leaders on such occasions as Party Congresses, and by Soviet military leaders, and finally the evidence from such sources as the confidential USSR Ministry of Defense organ Military Thought, dispel such erroneous assumptions. The record as well as the rhetoric indicates that the Soviet political and military leadership accepts a strategic nuclear balance and parity between
74
Raymond L. Garthoff
the USSR and the United States not only as a fact, but as the realistic prospect for the foreseeable future, until it can gradually be superseded by an evolving new world order. They are pursuing extensive military programs to ensure that they do not fail to maintain their side of the balance, which they see as in some jeopardy given US programs, especially the SDL But there is reason to credit their statements that they seek to stabilize and to maintain parity and mutual deterrence at the lowest possible level, and that they desire balanced and verified strategic arms reductions. Moreover, the Soviets are now seeking ways to move from reliance on mutual deterrence to greater reliance on mutual security. Recognition by the Gorbachev regime of the economic problems of the country add powerfully to other incentives to reach agreed arms limitations and major reductions. Finally, it is simply not the case that such avowed Soviet objectives are inconsistent with Soviet military doctrine or with communist ideology. In Marxist-Leninist eyes, military power is not and should not be the driving element in world politics. With "imperialist" military power held in check, the decisive social-economic forces of history, they believe, would determine the future of the world. Surely we can be no less confident in letting history decide. Nuclear war is the one threat to any ideological goal. The intensified efforts of both sides in the late 1970s and much of the 1980s to rely more upon unilateral military programs than on negotiated constraints to secure deterrence compounded the difficulty of a serious negotiation of strategic arms limitations and reductions. So does the inexorable march of military technology. None the less, that process is again underway and the INF Treaty is a solid, if modest, step. A START agreement building on the negotiation since Reykjavik would be an appropriate next step. Negotiating agreed constraints, while the best way to support parity and mutual deterrence, is not easy. Still more difficult is a process of building sufficient trust to move gradually toward mutual security based on minimal deterrent capabilities or even supplanting them altogether. Yet that is now the avowed Soviet aim, and one that we too should consider seriously in determining how best our own security can be served. Notes 1 Raymond L. Garthoff, "Mutual Deterrence and Strategic Arms Limitation in Soviet Policy," International Security, vol. 3, no. 1 (Summer 1978), 112-147. 2 In addition to the very summary discussion in these paragraphs, see Raymond L. Garthoff, Soviet Military Policy: A Historical Analysis (New York: Praeger, 1966), chapters 1, 4, 10 and 12.
The future of strategic arms limitation
75
3 Richard Pipes, "Why the Soviet Union Thinks It Could Fight and Win a Nuclear War," Commentary, vol. 72, no. 7 (July 1977), 34. 4 This distinction of the US and Soviet formulations of mutual deterrence was expressed in this way in my earlier article (International Security, Summer 1978, p. 124), with no specific Soviet source references. Five years later, a Soviet analyst used almost exactly the same terms to describe the US and Soviet conceptions: "Then, as now, both sides in the nuclear confrontation possessed an assumed capability to inflict an annihilating retaliatory strike on an aggressor (the Soviet formulation), or to inflict 'unacceptable damage' on the attacker as long as the situation of 'mutual assured destruction' exists (the American formulation)." See G. Gerasimov, "Current Problems of World Politics," Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodnyye otnosheniya [The World Economy and International Relations], no. 7 (July 1983), 99. The parenthetical identifications of Soviet and American formulations are Gerasimov's. Some Soviet accounts in discussing American policy debates endorse "mutual assured destruction" as a "positive, constructive" conception underlying mutual deterrence, and explicitly endorse "the principle of 'the mutual vulnerability of the sides,' which underlies the existing Soviet-American disarmament agreements." See "The Establishment of the Military-Political Strategy of the Reagan Administration," SShA (USA), no. 5 (May 1982), 125, and no. 6 (June 1982), 118-19. 5 L. I. Brezhnev, in Materialy xxiv s'yezda KPSS (Materials of the 24th Congress of the CPSU) (Moscow: Politizdat, 1971), p. 81. 6 See Kortunov, Kommunist, no. 10 (1980), 99. 7 L. I. Brezhnev, Leninskim kursom [A Leninist Course], vol. 3 (Moscow: Politizdat, 1970), p. 541. 8 Zemskov, Voyennaya mysV, no. 5 (1969), 59. 9 Trofimenko, SShA: Politika, voina, ideologiya, pp. 317, 318. 10 Trofimenko, SShA: Politika, voina, ideologiya, pp. 324-25. 11 The quotation is from General of the Army Viktor G. Kulikov, cited in Izvestiya, August 24, 1972; a similar statement by Marshal Andrei A. Grechko appears in Pravda, September 30, 1972. 12 A. Bovin, "Internationalism and Coexistence," Novoye vremya [New Times], no. 30 (July 1973). 13 Zemskov, Voyennaya mysV, no. 5 (1969), 59. 14 Maj. Gen. M. Cherednichenko, "The Evolution of Views on the Content and Functions of Military Strategy," Voyennaya mysV, no. 12 (December 1974), 23-24. 15 Trofimenko, SShA: Politika, voina, ideologiya, p. 319. 16 See Raymond L. Garthoff, Detente and Confrontation, pp. 794-96. 17 Garthoff, Detente and Confrontation, pp. 795 and 800. 18 See Raymond L. Garthoff, "Worst-Case Assumptions: Uses, Abuses and Consequences," in Gwyn Prins (ed.), The Nuclear Crisis Reader (New York, NY: Vintage/Random House, 1984), pp. 98-108. 19 For a more comprehensive discussion of the problem of determining a military strategic balance, and of conflicting Soviet and American viewpoints, see Raymond L. Garthoff, Perspectives on the Strategic Balance (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 1983), and for further discussion of diverging American
76
20 21
22 23 24
25
26 27
28 29 30 31
Raymond L. Garthoff and Soviet military thinking and views of the strategic balance, see Garthoff, Detente and Confrontation, pp. 768-800. V. Nekrasov, "An Absurd but Dangerous Myth," Kommunist, no. 12 (August 1979), 98. Editorial, "On the US President's State of the Union Message," Pravda, January 29, 1980. In this connection it cited the president's statement that the United States should be prepared to pay any price that may be required to remain "the strongest country in the world." Kommunist, no. 10 (July 1980), 8 and 10. Vladimir B. Lomeyko, "International Observers Roundtable," Radio Moscow, Domestic Service, February 10, 1980. For a comprehensive analysis of Soviet perceptions of American military policy and doctrine, see Raymond L. Garthoff, "Soviet Perceptions of Western Strategic Thought and Doctrine," in Soviet Military Doctrine and Western Policy (London and New York: Routledge, 1989), pp. 197-309. The paragraphs following draw upon that analysis. The most authoritative and complete Soviet analysis has been a report prepared by a distinguished group of Soviet scientists led by R. A. Sagdeyev, Director of the Institute of Space Research, and A. A. Kokoshin, a deputy director of the Institute of USA and Canada, under the auspices of the Committee of Soviet Scientists for Defense of Peace and Against Nuclear War. The report is titled: Strategicheskiye i mezhdunarodno-politicheskiye posledstviya sozdaniya kosmicheskoi protivoraketnoi sistemy s ispol'sovaniyam oruzhiya napravlennoi peredachi energii [Strategic and International-Political Consequences of the Creation of a Space-based Antiballistic Missile System Using Directed Energy Weapons] (Moscow: Institute kosmicheskikh issledovanii Akademiya Nauk, 1984, 42 pp.). This interpretation had been given authoritatively by General Secretary Yury Andropov only a few days after the Star Wars speech; see "Replies of Yu. V. Andropov to Questions from a Correspondent of Pravda," Pravda, March 27, 1983. Marshal S. Akhromeyev, "A Great Victory and Its Lessons," Izvestiya, May 7, 1985. "Replies of Marshal of the Soviet Union S. L. Sokolov, Minister of Defense of the USSR to Questions of a TASS Correspondent," Krasnaya zvezda, May 5, 1985. Ibid. "Interview of M. S. Gorbachev with the Editor of Pravda," Pravda, April 8, 1985. A. Bovin, "Fantasies and Reality," Izvestiya, April 21, 1985. See Marshal S. L. Sokolov, "Great Victory: Conclusions and Lessons," Kommunist, no. 6 (April 1985), 64-65; and Marshal S. Akhromeyev, Izvestiya, May 7, 1985. The Star Wars speech of March 1983 had followed closely after the most direct political challenge by Reagan to the legitimacy of Soviet rule, a speech in which he declared the Soviet leaders to be "the focus of evil in the world," and the Soviet Union "an evil empire." And in a third speech a week later, nominally addressed to arms control, the president attacked what he called a "relentless military buildup" by the Soviet Union, and called for "peace through [American
The future of strategic arms limitation
77
military] strength," rather than arms control. See President Reagan, "National Security, Address to the Nation," March 23, 1983, Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents, no. 19 (March 28, 1983), 4 4 2 ^ 8 ; "Remarks at the Annual Convention [of the National Association of Evangelicals] in Orlando, Florida, March 8, 1983," Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents, no. 19 (March 14,1983), 369; and "Remarks to the Los Angeles World Affairs, March 31, 1983, Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents, no. 19 (April 4, 1983), 484. 32 Gorbachev, Pravda, January 16, 1986. 33 See Raymond L. Garthoff, "The Gorbachev Proposal and Prospects for Arms Control," Arms Control Today, vol. 16, no. 1 (January-February 1986), 3-6. 34 Gorbachev, Pravda, December 8, 1988. 35 V. Larin, "A Topical Proposal," Pravda, October 27, 1976; see also A. Bovin, Radio Moscow, June 19, 1979; B. Andrianov and V. Nekrasov, Radio Moscow, June 18, 1979; G. Shakhnazarov, "The Arms Race Is a Danger to the Peoples," Krasnaya zvezda, June 14, 1979; and Dr. [Colonel] V. Kulish, "A Balance of Trust and not a Balance of Terror," Novoye vremya, no. 22 (May 1979), 4—6. 36 Kulish, "A Balance of Trust." 37 N. I. Lebedev and S. V. Kortunov, "The Problem of Disarmament and the Ideological Struggle - A Critique of the Apologists for the Arms Race," Novaya i noveishaya istoriya [Modern and Contemporary History], no. 4 (July-August 1980), 8-9. 38 Lebedev and Kortunov, "Problem of Disarmament"; and see Milovidov and Zhadanov, Voprosyfilosofii,no. 10 (1980), 49. 39 Bovin, Kommunist, no. 10 (1980), 78. 40 Bovin, Kommunist, no. 10 (1980), 78; and see the Resolution of the Central Committee of the CPSU, June 23, 1980, text in Kommunist, no. 10 (July 1980), 8-10. 41 L. Brezhnev, Pravda, February 24, 1981. 42 L. Brezhnev, Pravda, October 21, 1981. 43 K. U. Chernenko, Pravda, April 23, 1981; and see Yu. V. Andropov, Pravda, April 23, 1982. 44 "Joint Statement, Nov. 21, 1985," Department of State Bulletin, vol. 86, no. 2,106 (January 1986), 8. Gorbachev's initiative in seeking inclusion of these statements was disclosed to this writer by a Soviet participant in the delegation and confirmed by an American participant. 45 Lt. Gen. D. Volkogonov, "War and Peace in the 'Nuclear Age,'" Kraznaya zvezda, August 30, 1985. All subsequent quotations in this and the succeeding paragraph are from this article. 46 Volkogonov, "War and Peace." 47 Parity and its implications are also included in public information efforts. For example, a feature documentary set of filmed interviews by Izvestiya political observer Aleksandr Ye. Bovin with a "soldier" (Major General Viktor M. Tatarnikov of the General Staff), a "historian" (Dr. Vitaly V. Zhurkin of the USA Institute), and a "political figure" (Vadim Zagladin, of the Central Committee), on Moscow Television, November 12, 1985. 48 M. S. Gorbachev, Politicheskii doklad tsental'nogo komiteta KPSS xxvn s'yezdu kommunisticheskoi partii Sovetskogo Soyuza [Political Report of the Central
78
49
50 51
52 53
54 55
56 57 58 59 60 61
62
63
64
Raymond L. Garthoff Committee of the CPSU to the 27th Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (Moscow: Politizdat, 1986), pp. 15 and 81. Gorbachev, Politicheskii doklad, pp. 81-82. It is of interest that Gorbachev is aware of the distinction between the two terms used in Russian to represent "deterrence," and intentionally covers both. Gorbachev, Politicheskii doklad, p. 15. L. Tolkunov, "The Dilemma of the Age," Kommunist, no. 7 (May 1986), 85-86. Lev Tolkunov is chairman of one of the houses of the Supreme Soviet, and an influential member of the Party Central Committee. "Program of the CPSU, New Edition, Adopted by the 27th Congress of the CPSU," Pravda, March 7, 1986. S. Tikhvinsky, "Soviet Historical Science at the Threshold of the 27th Party Congress," Kommunist, no. 1 (January 1986), 99. Tikhvinsky is a prominent historian and has been head of the Historical Diplomatic Directorate of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Gorbachev, Politicheskii doklad, p. 85. See the discussion in Raymond L. Garthoff, "New Thinking in Soviet Military Doctrine," Washington Quarterly, vol. 21 (Summer 1988), 136-45. One of the first was Gen. Army Mikhail M. Kozlov, "The Preservation of Military Strategic Parity - A Serious Factor in Assuring Peace and International Security," Voyennaya mysl', no. 12 (December 1986), 3-13. Gen. Army D. T. Yazov, "The Military Doctrine of the Warsaw Pact, a Doctrine of the Defense of Peace and Socialism," Pravda, July 27, 1987. Col. V. Strebkov, "From the Standpoint of the New Thinking: Military Parity Yesterday and Today," Krasnaya zvezda, January 3, 1989. Col. Gen. V. V. Korobushin, "On Raising the Effectiveness of Military Scientific Research," Voyennaya mysV, no. 5 (May 1988), 40. Gorbachev, Politicheskii doklad, pp. 15 and 81-82. Strebkov, Krasnaya zvezda, January 3, 1989. Vitaly Zhurkin, Sergei Karaganov and Andrei Kortunov, "Reasonable Sufficiency, Or How to Break the Vicious Circle," Novoye vremya, no. 40 (October 2, 1987), 13. "Authoritative Opinion: Clear Skies over Europe," Interview of Mikhail P. Shelepin by Yury Popov, Komsomol'akaya Pravda (Komsomol Pravda), December 28, 1988. Deputy Foreign Minister Vladimir F. Petrovsky, in a roundtable discussion on the "International Program" on Moscow Television, March 11, 1989. Petrovsky's career and current responsibilities lead him to stress international institutions, but he has been a leading contributor to the new thinking even before the Gorbachev administration, and has been promoted under it. Kozlov, Voyennaya mysV, December 1986, p. 12.
Part II
Below the threshold
Soviet theater forces on a descending path Edward B. Atkeson
Moscow's decision by Summer 1991 to abide by the terms of an agreement restricting conventional forces in Europe (CFE) caused new thinking among allied governments about the nature of new East-West security arrangements. A year and a half earlier, the former chief of the Soviet General Staff, and presently close advisor to General Secretary Gorbachev, Marshal Sergei F. Akhromeyev, remarked that the new Soviet political thinking and defense doctrine were inseparably connected. The companion foreign policy he described as threefold: demilitarization, democratization, and de-ideologization. The first element, he said, effectively excludes the use of force in relations with other countries. The second establishes the principle of equality in Soviet dealings with other countries, large and small. The third removes the ideological aspect in international relations in favor of greater reliance upon international law.1 The impact of this policy on the Soviet war machine, and, indeed, upon the political structure and forces of the entire Warsaw Pact, has been dramatic. In consequence, as Soviet theater forces enter the final decade of the twentieth century, they find themselves marching to an unfamiliar drummer along a path winding through doctrinal terra incognita. The shell of the Warsaw Pact dissolved, and the myth of socialist solidarity and brothers-in-arms among the troops of the East European states has been shattered. The armies of the USSR's "allies" have undergone steep reductions in practically all dimensions, and the political milieu has changed so precipitously that the remaining forces share little more than the most superficial common grounds for coordinated action with their former masters. If there were no other stimulus for the adoption of a new military doctrine by the Soviets, the virtual evaporation of any hope that their allies' forces might play a significant part in an offensive against NATO would be reason enough to turn to a defensive posture. Soviet theater forces must now turn much of their energy to compliance with directives for internal reorganizations and disassembly of their offensive prowess, so carefully nurtured over the past four and one half decades. The political leadership has made it clear that the forces' 81
82
Edward B.Atkeson
impressive capabilities for intimidation and invasion of neighboring states have become more of a burden than an asset to the nation. However reluctantly, the Soviet military has been obliged first to trim its offensive power unilaterally, and then to submit to international negotiations designed to disassemble much of its apparatus for waging the types of warfare for which it was designed. This chapter examines the new mandate for Soviet theater forces and the developing concept for the posture they are to assume under the new military doctrine. Further, it assesses the feasibility of the doctrine for fulfilling the security needs of the USSR, recognizing the manifold difficulties the country faces in social, economic and technological spheres. The new direction The new direction for the forces was set by the political leadership in 1986 with the promulgation of the concept of "reasonable sufficiency" in meeting military requirements. The following year, on May 29, the Political Consultative Committee of the Warsaw Pact ratified a paper entitled, "On the Military Doctrine of the Warsaw Treaty Member Countries." Of particular note in the paper were these points: - "Never and under no circumstances shall we begin hostilities against any state or any alliance of states unless we ourselves come under attack." - "We have no territorial claims to any state . . . [and] do not look on any state or any people as an enemy." - "[We] do not strive to have more armed forces that necessary for defense. [The Warsaw Pact Powers] will strictly adhere to the principle of sufficiency in protecting their security." 2 Important as the document was for the alliance, it was particularly noteworthy as a formal representation of a new Soviet doctrine. Pact doctrine is an extension of Soviet doctrine, and Soviet military doctrine is the linchpin of the entire theoretical structure of Soviet military science.3 Soviet military doctrine is composed of two principal branches, one political, the other military-technical. The former has traditionally had a defensive bias and has served the declaratory policy of the state. Its principal thrust has been to avoid open conflict with the West while permitting exploitation of promising politico-military opportunities. The latter, which has served as the basic guidance for the development of the forces, has been highly offensive. It has held that in case of conflict, the forces would rapidly seize the initiative and carry the battle forward into the opponent's territory to victory.4 The new doctrine reverses the latter guidance, mandating a defensive posture for the forces. If the Soviet Armed Forces are to fulfill their instructions, changes must be made, not
Soviet theater forces on a descending path
83
only in force structure, but in strategy, operational thinking, plans and practices, some dating back almost half a century. The defense minister, Army General Dmitri T. Yazov, summarized the thrust of the new thinking as the assumption of a posture which would provide the Soviet Union with "the magnitude of armed forces necessary to defend [itself] from attack from the outside." In the future, he wrote, the Soviet aim would be to reduce the forces of the two great alliances facing each other in Central Europe "to such a level where neither of the sides, while insuring its defense, has the forces or means enabling it to mount offensive operations." 5 In addition to the adoption of defensive posture and the reduction of forces, new guidance from the Kremlin includes a novel responsibility for the Armed forces to avoid war. As General Yazov has pointed out, Warsaw Pact military doctrine (and hence, Soviet doctrine) "is subordinated to the task of preventing war." 6 Soviet military leaders have traditionally assumed avoidance of war to be a diplomatic or political function, thus it came as some surprise that they would find it a charge of their own as well. While they may not be completely comfortable with the mission, they have devised a working list of specific measures for the forces to pursue: maintenance of parity with the West in both nuclear and nonnuclear spheres, participation by military officials in the verification of arms control and confidence-building accords, greater military participation in diplomatic meetings and discussions, improved planning for military participation in disaster relief, reorientation of operational and tactical concepts for defensive operations. 7 Many other functional matters, however, remain unclear. The Soviets still have much work to do in theoretical areas to integrate the specific changes they are making in their forces into a coherent whole. As Army General Mikhail A. Moiseyev, Chief of the General Staff, has pointed out: Nearly all the tenets of strategy, operational art, and tactics are undergoing radical changes, under the influence of both military-technical and military-political factors. Basically a new theory of military art is being created.8 It is important to note, however, that the programs for removing military material from the forward area and destroying equipment are not directly linked. Defense Minister Yazov made this clear in a radio phone-in program in February 1990 when he replied to a questioner: As for the reductions and scrapping of military hardware, yes indeed some of the hardware that has seen out its prescribed service life is being destroyed, sent for melting down. But what tanks are these? The T-34, T-54, old models of the T-55,
84
Edward B. Atkeson
T-10. But, all the new hardware will remain. Moreover, any hardware that is still serviceable is not being withdrawn from the Armed Forces. As you recommend, it is being mothballed and, should the need arise, will be used.9 Gorbachev had promised a reorganization of the remaining forces, indicating a likelihood that the remaining tanks would be redistributed. General Yazov explained that the Soviet motorized rifle divisions (MRDs) stationed in East Germany and Czechoslovakia would be stripped of their tank regiments and that the remaining tank divisions (TDs) would each lose one of their three tank regiments. These reductions, he said, would represent a 40 percent decrease in tanks for the MRDs and a 20 percent cut for the TDs. To off-set the loss of tank-killing power in the divisions, they would be allocated additional infantry and anti-tank weapons. Also, he said, their air defense and engineer mining and entrenching capabilities would be enhanced. 10 In addition to these alterations, but without indicating any specific timetable for the change, General Yazov stated that as many as half of the Soviet MRDs would be converted to "machine gun/artillery" divisions for positional and area defense missions. Information from other sources indicates that these units may be located in border districts in the Soviet Union and that they may have no more than a single battalion of tanks, greatly restricting their offensive potential. 11 While the details remain unclear, it is apparent that most - and very likely all - of the Soviet maneuver divisions (MRD and TD) remaining in the forward area in 1992 will possess an additional motorized rifle regiment, equipped with BMP infantry fighting vehicles, to replace the withdrawn tank regiments. The divisions are expected to gain in manpower, BMPs, mortars and some other small weapons as a result of the conversion. The net result will be a loss in some offensive capability, but a considerable increase in defensive staying power, with essentially no change in overall combat capability.12 Soviet operational concepts under a defensive military doctrine As clear as the Soviet retrenchment of forces appears, there is ample evidence that the Soviets have every intention of continuing to meet practical requirements for conducting respectable military operations at tactical (division and below) and operational (army and front) levels. Soviet military leaders believe it essential to maintain an ability to halt and to reverse a foreign attack, and to carry the conflict to a successful conclusion against any invader. As General Yazov has pointed out, "it is impossible to rout an aggressor with defense alone . . . After an attack has been repelled,
Soviet theater forces on a descending path
85
the troops and naval forces must be able to conduct a decisive offensive [emphasis in original]. The switch to an offensive will be in the form of a counteroffensi ve."13 In this connection, a number of Soviet authors have resurrected accounts of battles of the Great Patriotic War to undergird their theses. Army General E. F. Ivanovskii, former Commander-in-Chief of Ground Forces, has cited the Battle of Stalingrad as an example of how victory can be achieved through a massive counteroffensive after the enemy has become bogged down in the defenses.14 Similarly, prominent academics, A. Kokoshin and V. Larionov, have cited the Battle of Kursk as a model of advantageous use of the counteroffensive for decisive defeat of an attacking enemy force.15 The debate over the application of the new doctrine has been lively. Some senior officers, such as Marshal of the Soviet Union Viktor Kulikov, former Commander-in-Chief of the Warsaw Pact, have argued that Soviet doctrine has always been defensive, implying that no changes in operational procedures are necessary. Army General Ivan Tretyak, Commander-inChief of Air Defense Forces (PVO) has written: Any changes in our Army should be considered a thousand times over before they are decided upon. Temporary benefits are a great lure. But I repeat once again - the most important thing is to have a reliable defense. If we were not so strong, imperialism would not hesitate to change the world.16
Others, particularly civilian academics who have gained new influence under the Gorbachev leadership, insist that much restructuring and reduction of forces is necessary and that it would be better done sooner than later. For example, Dr. Lev Semeyko argues: The military might of a state or coalition of states should be maintained at a level that would give no one any reason for fear, even imaginary, for one's security. It is not enough to declare one's doctrine defensive, the way NATO did. One should confirm the defensive orientation of one's doctrine by the size and deployment of one's troops, their structure and armaments and military activities. Without this declarations would be merely declarations.17
It appears that both sides in the debate are realizing some points. Force reductions and restructuring are proceeding apace. On the other hand, the concept of decisive offensive operations, if only in a counteroffensive mode, remains deeply rooted in Soviet military culture and has not been abandoned. The new defensive doctrine also impacts Soviet thinking about the utility of airborne forces, designed as they are for offensive operations. (Western sources claim that the Soviets have some seven airborne divisions; the Soviets counter that they have but five. All are small, elite organizations
86
Edward B. A tkeson
routinely held in high states of readiness.) General Albert Slyusarev, Commandant of the Ryazan Higher Airborne Command School has commented, "We are training officers to be able to carry out offensive operations with a defensive force, ready to respond to attack . . . The aim is still to destroy the enemy, and, like the infantry, our men are still suited to counteroffensive actions." 18 Some insight into the practical impact of the doctrine on the forces was given by Lieutenant General V. Achlov, Commander of Airborne Forces (VDV), during a visit to the United States in 1989. He is reported to have said to an escort officer that one half of the airborne (air assault) units presently deployed in the forward area would be withdrawn, that the remaining units would be withdrawn from control of front and army commanders, and that the maximum doctrinal ranges of airborne operations would be cut in half.19 Soviet airborne forces have never enjoyed a reputation for long strategic reach comparable to that of their Western counterparts. On the other hand, they tend to be far more heavily equipped, more closely resembling Western armored cavalry regiments than airborne infantry, possessing many light armored vehicles, including assault guns. This characteristic has tended to give them high tactical mobility (once on the ground), but at the expense of strategic reach because of their weight. 20 The implications of General Achlov's remarks would seem to be that the Soviets were reducing the scale of their dependence upon airborne forces, not only in expected frequency of commitment, but in depth of operation as well. At the tactical level new Soviet literature is focusing upon activism in defensive operations. Major General I. Vorob'yev, a doctor of military science and prominent writer on operational matters, argues that maneuver is crucial to the success of a defense. It permits, he says, the defender "to evade the blow of the superior enemy forces, to maintain combat capability, and, having won time, to achieve a breakthrough in the course of the battle." 21 General Vorob'yev argues that maneuver and positional defensive tactics are not mutually exclusive, but can be "applied in close coordination." He cites as an example of such coordination in operations a security force forward of a main defensive zone. In the general's view the principal purpose of a maneuver defense is to create "the right conditions" for the main defensive grouping "to subsequently rebuff the enemy's attack." 22 General Vorob'yev believes that maneuver defensive operations are highly complex, and he expresses concern over the adequacy of current training of the officer corps for fulfilling its responsibilities in this area. He concludes his writing with the thought that "if we are seriously thinking of the priority of active tactics in defense," there must be a concerted effort to develop the requisite skills among the officers involved.23
Soviet theater forces on a descending path
87
The feasibility of the new doctrine Intelligence. Soviet foreign intelligence agencies have a time-honored tradition of high quality service to both the Kremlin political and military leadership. There is little reason to believe that the foreign intelligence wings of the KGB and military intelligence (GRU) are unlikely to be undercut by unilateral or negotiated reduction of forces. Withdrawals of troops from the forward area, of course, will reduce the operational base structure of military reconnaissance activities, including ground and airborne signals intelligence collectors, but advances in space-based systems are likely to off-set much of the losses which might otherwise result. Further, proposals for mutual "open sky" overflight rights and on-sight inspections of designated zones in border areas under negotiated confidence building measures may largely obviate the need for continuance of the older practices. With respect to longer range, strategic intelligence, the Chairman of the KGB, Vladimir Kryuchkov, claims to have made an effort to reduce or eliminate much of the former emphasis on domestic intelligence and to shift the focus abroad. He has argued that in today's climate "it is the external aspect [of KGB activities] that largely dominates."24 Whether or not he accurately portrays the current trends on the domestic side is not material here. Certainly, there has been no reduction in KGB efforts abroad. Mobilization for Defense. The Soviets place great emphasis on historical examples for defining the military requirements to deal with threats to their borders. One volume of the official Soviet officer's library series, devoted exclusively to the initial period of WWII, draws eleven of its thirteen chapters from this experience. While the work was published in 1974, it has increased in importance under the new doctrine because of its emphasis on Soviet operations while the country was on the strategic defensive.25 Notable in this regard is a comment in the concluding section of the book that during the period of initial defensive operations "it was possible to weaken a strong enemy's offensive capabilities and ultimately to halt its advance only after the entry into battle of major strategic reserves."26 Accordingly, the Soviets look to the speed of their mobilization and reinforcement of the front by reserve forces to buttress their defense. In the past, Western estimates of Soviet requirements for preparation time for mounting an attack on NATO have included some very short periods, measured in hours, for the highly ready forces stationed in the forward area to cross into West Germany. In 1977 the Supreme Allied Commander Europe (SACEUR) cited forty-eight hours as "rock bottom" for Warsaw Pact preparation. At the same time, a preparation period of 8-14 days was cited as a more likely scenario because in that time the Pact
88
Edward B.Atkeson
might achieve maximum relative strength vis-d-vis NATO. 2 7 In late 1989, however, the US Intelligence Community altered its estimate of the likely minimum warning time to something in excess of one month, possibly 33-44 days. NATO did not officially adopt the American view as it became known, but it is apparent that there is widespread agreement among the NATO partners that the likely warning period is substantially longer than previously considered. 28 Soviet Ground Forces are composed primarily of some 190 tank and motorized rifle divisions. Only about 40 percent of these forces are maintained in ready condition (i.e. having most of their equipment and at least half of their authorized complement of personnel). 29 It is expected that, in time of emergency, the remainder of the units would be filled with reservists, given rudimentary training, and shipped forward to the battle area. As Marshal of the Soviet Union Nikolai V. Ogarkov, former Chief of the General Staff, has written: a high degree of combat readiness of troops and naval forces is inconceivable without well organized mobilization preparation, directed toward ensuring prompt and timely shifting of military forces from a peacetime to a wartime footing.30 The principal reinforcement units for a defense of the western frontier would come from the six western military districts (Leningrad, Baltic, Byelorussian, Carpathian, Kiev and Odessa) and the two districts of the Central Strategic Reserve (Moscow and Volga-Ural). In recent years these eight districts have been estimated to be capable of providing as many as 82 ground maneuver divisions, 5 airborne and 9 artillery divisions.31 However, not all of the divisions would be expected to be employed in Central Europe. Deployments would likely be spread from above the Arctic Circle, in the north, to the Balkans, in the south, with the heaviest concentration in the center in the region designated by the Soviets as the Western Theater of Military Operations (TVD). During the Cold War, the Soviets recognized that a requirement for mobilization could develop quickly, placing enormous strains on the national system for the preparation of the country for war, and upon the transportation system in particular. The shift to a defensive doctrine, and, presumably, to more reactive operational concepts, intensifies the transportation question in some respects. They have devised plans for incremental mobilization for less than maximum threats and for gradual preparation for general mobilization.32 In accordance with the teachings of the Voroshilov General Staff Academy: the most important requirement of the operational deployment of the Armed Forces is that it be done rapidly, secretly, and in a timely manner to establish
Soviet theater forces on a descending path
89
strong groups of forces against attacking enemy in order to repel the attack and inflict decisive losses on his forces.33 Few countries are as dependent upon their railways for moving both passengers and freight as the USSR. The enormous distances, the poor road network, and the dominant north-south orientation of the rivers, coupled with their frequent blockage by ice, oblige the Soviets to look to their railroads as their primary east-west arteries for movement of heavy goods, both civil and military. 34 The demands are so great that most trunk lines run at 95 to 100 percent of capacity.35 Western analysts have traditionally ascribed to the Soviets a capability for moving their high priority military cargo in time of crisis in sufficient quantities such that transportation was not the principal determinant of success or failure of their plans. One reason for this was that the Soviets amassed very large stocks of war supplies in the forward area, especially ammunition and petroleum products. These were estimated to be sufficient for some 60-90 days of wartime requirements. 36 As late as January 1990 there was no indication of Soviet intention to withdraw the supplies as part of the unilateral reduction in force.37 However, it seems reasonable to expect that most will be moved as the troops withdraw, at least to the Western Military Districts. The principal consideration in most transport system assessments has been the quantity of tracked military vehicles (tanks, infantry fighting vehicles, self-propelled artillery, etc.) to be moved. At the peak of the 1989 riots in the T