studies in physical and theoretical chemistry 83
STRUCTURE, FLUCTUATION, AND RELAXATION IN SOLUTIONS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
studies in physical and theoretical chemistry 83
STRUCTURE, FLUCTUATION, AND RELAXATION IN SOLUTIONS Proceedings of t h e Y a m a d a C o n f e r e n c e X X X X l l , held at N a g o y a , J a p a n , 11 - 15 D e c e m b e r 1994
Edited by HIROYASU NOMURA
and F U M I O K A W A I Z U M I
Department of Chemical Engineering, School of Engineering, Nagoya University, Nagoya 464-01, Japan and JACK YARWOOD
Materials Research Institute, Sheffield Hal/am University, Pond Street, Sheffield $1 1WB, United Kingdom Reprinted from the Journal of Molocular Liquids, Volumes 65 and 66
A m s t e r d a m - L a u s a n n e - N e w York - O x f o r d
ELSEVIER - S h a n n o n - T o k y o 1995
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN 0-444-82384-0 9Elsevier Science Publicatiosl and Yamada Science Foundation, 1995. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without the prior written permission from the publisher. Published by Elsevier Science B.V., Sara Burgerhartstraat 25, P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A.- This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers MA 01923. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the copyright owners, Elsevier Science B.V. and Yamada Science Fondation, unless otherwise specified. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
studies in physical and theoretical chemistry Recent titles in this series
50 Photoelectrochemical Solar Cells edited by K.S.V. Santhanam and M. Sharon 51 Graph Theory and Topology in Chemistry edited by R.B. King and D.H. Rouvray 52 Intermolecular Complexes by P. Hobza and R. Zahradnik 53 Potential Energy Hypersurfaces by P.G. Mezey 54 Math/Chem/Comp 1987 edited by R.C. Lacher 55 Semiconductor Electrodes edited by H.O. Finklea 56 Computational Chemistry by M.D. Johnston, Jr. 57 Positron and Positronium Chemistry edited by D.M. Schrader and Y.C. Jean 58 Ab Initio Calculation of the Structures and Properties of Molecules by C.E. Dykstra 59 Physical Adsorption on Heterogeneous Solids by M. Jaroniec and R. Madey 60 Ignition of Solids by V.N. Vilyunov and V.E. Zarko 61 Nuclear Measurements in Industry by S. Rozsa 62 Quantum Chemistry: Basic Aspects, Actual Trends edited by R. Carb6 63 Math/Chem/Comp 1988 edited by A. Graovac 64 Valence Bond Theory and Chemical Structure edited by D.J. Klein and N. Trinajsti~ 65 Structure and Reactivity in Reverse Micelles edited by M.P. Pileni 66 Applications of Time-Resolved Optical Spectroscopy by V. BrLJckner, K.-H. Feller and U.-W. Grummt 67 Magnetic Resonance and Related Phenomena edited by J. Stankowski, N. Pilewski, S.K. Hoffmann and S. Idziak 68 Atomic and Molecular Clusters edited by E.R. Bernstein 69 Structure and Properties of Molecular Crystals edited by M. Pierrot 70 Self-consistent Field: Theory and Applications edited by R. Carb6 and M. Klobukowski 71 Modelling of Molecular Structures and Properties edited by J.-L. Rivail 72 Nuclear Magnetic Resonance: Principles and Theory by R. Kitamaru 73 Artificial Intelligence in Chemistry: Structure Elucidation and Simulation of Organic Reactions by Z. Hippe 74 Spectroscopy and Relaxation of Molecular Liquids edited by D. Steele and J. Yarwood 75 Molecular Design: Chemical Structure Generation from the Properties of Pure Organic Compounds by A.L. Horvath 76 Coordination and Transport Properties of Macrocyclic Compounds in Solution by B.G. Cox and H. Schneider 77 Computational Chemistry: Structure, Interactions and Reactivity. Part A edited by S. Fraga Computational Chemistry: Structure, Interactions and Reactivity. Part B edited by S. Fraga 78 Electron and Proton Transfer in Chemistry and Biology edited by A. ML~ller, H. Ratajczak, W. Junge and E. Diemann 79 Structure and Dynamics of Solutions edited by H. Ohtaki and H. Yamatera 80 Theoretical Treatment of Liquids and Liquid Mixtures by C. Hoheisel 81 M6ssbauer Studies of Surface Layers by G.N. Belozerski 82 Dynamics of Excited Molocules edited bij Kozo Kuchitsu
vi
z <
<
rj
z;
z
E
7
F~
Z o
o
z
<
YAMADA CONFERENCE XXXXII ON STRUCTURE, FLUCTUATION, AND RELAXATION IN SOLUTIONS, 11-15 December 1994
vii PREFACE
The 4 2 n d Yamada Conference on "Structure, Fluctuation, and Relaxation in Solution" was held at Nagoya Trade and I n d u s t r y Center (Fukiage Hall), Nagoya, Japan from December 11 to December 15, 1994. The meeting was attended by more than 110 scientists from nine countries.
During last four years(1990-1993) the special research project "Molecular Approaches to Non-equilibrium Process in Solutions" was carried out in Japan u n d e r the financial support of the Ministry of Education of Science and Culture. After the successful ending of this research project we have recognized that it is now our d u t y to tackle the problems emerged form these resent results. These are summarized as follows: (1) solvation dynamics, (2) Relaxation, fluctuation, and reaction dynamics, and (3) dynamic structure and reaction mechanisms in solutions. These topics are the main concern of this conference.
In planning this conference with m y colleagues of the organizing committee, we have hoped that this conference be an opportunity to find out a break-through in theories and experimental techniques of the solution chemistry for the coming century. On this intention the organizing committee has arranged the p r o g r a m to be composed of as wide fields as possible. In addition, the general discussion session was set after several presentations of the related subjects.
viii
In this publication the order of the papers follows the p r o g r a m of the Conference.
This is because we would like the readers of this
Proceedings to understand our above-mentioned intention to open this conference at this time as well as to feel the a t m o s p h e r e of the Conference.
This Conference could only be possible with the support of Yamada Science Foundation in financial and moral aspects. His support has led us to the success of this international meeting.
All
the participants will never forget the generosity of Yamada Science Foundation.
Finally, I would like to express m y sincere thanks to all invited speakers who gave excellent lectures, those who presented v e r y interesting posters, chairpersons and discussion leaders who conducted the general discussion section in marvelous fashion, and those who contributed to the vigorous discussion in the Conference. I must add also my deep appreciation to the cooperation of all the participants not only in the running of the Conference itself b u t also in submitting and revising their manuscript for this Proceedings in due time as requested by the organizing committee in spite of their very heavy schedule.
The Organizing Committee of the 42nd Yamada Conference Syflz6 SEKl(Advisory), Hitoshi OHTAKI(Advisory) Hiroyasu NOMURA (Chairman), Fumio KAWAIZUMI (Secretary) Shinobu KODA, Fumio HIRATA, Masaharu NAKAHARA, Tadashi OKADA Kiyoshi SAWADA, Toshio YAMAGUCHI LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Barnes, A. C. Barthel, Josef Buchner, Michael Burger, K~lm~in Button, Joanne Chong, Song-Ho Dore, John Elich, Karsten Espenson, James H. Fujimura, Yuichi Fujita, Yoshitaka Fushiki, Makoto Harada, Makoto Haymet, A.D.J. Heinzinger, Karl Hiram, Fumio Hiram, Yoshinori Hirota, Noboru Hiwatari, Yasuaki Ibuki, Kazuyasu Iida, Masayasu Ikawa, Shunichi Ikeuchi, Haruko Irisa, Masayuki Itoh, Sumiko Iwadate, Yasuhiko Iwata, Koichi Kai, Yasunobu Kameda, Yasuo Kaneko, Yutaka
University of Bristol University of Regensburg University of Bielefeld A.Jozsef University Kyoto University Kyoto University University of Kent at Canterbury Osaka University Iowa State University Tohoku University National Research Laboratory of Metrology National Institute of Materials and Chemical Research Osaka University University of Sydney Max-Planck Institute for Chemistry Kyoto University Osaka University Kyoto University Kanazawa University Doshisya University Nara Women's University Hokkaido University Sophia University ERATO JRDC Cavendish Laboratory Chiba University Kanagawa Academy of Science and Technology Osaka University Yamagata University Kyoto University
Kanekubo, Mitsuhiro Kaneto, Hirotaka KatS, Minoru Kato, Satoko Kawaizumi, Fumio Kimum, Yoshifumi Kinoshita, Shuichi Kinugawa, Kenichi Kitazawa, Minoru Koda, Shinobu Komatsuzaki, Tamiki Ma, Jangseok Maeda, Hiroshi Maroncelli, Mark Masuda, Akiko Masuda, Yuichi Mataga, Noboru Matsumoto, Mitsuru Matsuoka, Tatsuro Matsuura, Hiroatsu Miyasaka, Hiroshi Morita, Akio Munakata, Toyonori Murakami, Masataka Muranaka, Tadasi Nagaoka, Masataka Nakaham, Masaru Nakai, Takehiro Nakanishi, Koichiro Nakashima, Satoru Nomura, Hiroyasu Ohtaki, Hitoshi Okada, Isao Okada, Tadashi Okazaki, Susumu Okuyama, Naoto Olsson, Lars-Fride Ozutsumi, Kazuhiko
Sophia University Kyoto Institute of Technology Ritsumeikan University Seibo Jogakuin Jr. College Nagoya University Kyoto University Osaka University University of Osaka Prefecture Osaka University Nagoya University Institute for Fundamental Chemistry University of South Carolina Kyushu University University of Pennsylvania Tokyo Institute of Technology Ochanomizu Women's University Insitute for Laser Technology Nagoya University Nagoya University Hiroshima University Kyoto Institute of Technology University of Tokyo Kyoto University Natinal Institute for Physiological Science Aichi Institute of Technology Institute for Fundamental Chemistry Kyoto University Ritsumeikan University Kyoto University Osaka University Nagoya University Ritsumeikan University Tokyo Insitute of Technology Osaka University Tokyo Insitute of Technology Dicel Chemicals Gambro AB University of Tsukuba
Radnai, Tamas Raineri, Fernando O. Rick, Steven Rossky, Peter J. Sfmcez, Francisco Sasaki, Yoichi Sato, Gen Sawada, Kiyoshi Seki, Kazuhiko Seki, Syflz6 Sex), Yoshiteru Shushin, Anatoli I. Suga, Hiroshi Sumi, Hitoshi Suzuki, Satoshi Swaddle, Thomas W. Tabata, Masaaki Takagi, Hideo Takasu, Masako Tanaka, Hideki Tanaka, Motoharu Tanida, Hajime Taniguchi, Yoshihiro Tarumi, Toshiyasu Terazima, Masahide
Hungarian Academy of Science State University of New York Columbia University University of Texas at Austin Seville University Hokkaido University Sophia University Niigata University National Institute of Materials and Chemical Research The Japan Academy Natinal Institute for Physiological Scicnce Kyoto University Kinki University University of Tsukuba University of Tokyo University of Calgary Saga University Nagoya University Kanazawa University Kyoto University Nagoya University Osaka University Ritsumeikan University Nagoya University
Tominaga, Keisuke Tominaga, Toshihiro Tominaga, Yasunori Tran-Cong, Qui Troe, Jurgen Tsukahara, Keiichi Verrall, Ronaid E.
Kyoto University Institute for Molecular Science Okayama University of Science Ochanomizu Women's University Kyoto Institute of Technology University of Gt)ttingen Nara Women's University University of Saskatoon
Watanabe, Iwao
Osaka University
Weing~rtner, Hermann Yamabe, Tokio Yamada, Shinkichi Yamaguchi, Toshio Yamatera, Hideo
University of Karlsruhe Kyoto University Shizuoka University Fukuoka University Daido Institute of Technology
xii Y ano, Y os hi ko
Tokyo National College of Technology
Yasuoka, Kenji
Nagoya University
Yokoyama, Haruhiko Yoshida, Naoto
Yokohama City University Institute for Fundamental Chemistry
Yoshiham, Keitaro
Institute for Molecular Science
Yoshimori, Akim
Nagoya University
xiii Welcome Address December 14,1994
Good Evening, Ladies and Gentlemen!
It is my great honor and pleasure to extend the most cordial welcome address to all the participants of this meeting, the 42nd Yamada Conference on "Structure, Fluctuation and Relaxation in Solutions". In particular my special gratitude must go to those who traveled long distances to here from overseas; Australia, Canada, Germany, Hungary, Russia, Spain, Sweden, United Kingdom and United States of America. On behalf of Yamada Science Foundation we are very happy and privileged to sponsor the present Conference.
Yamada Science Foundation was established in
1977 as a result of the donation of the private holding of the late Kiro Yamada who was the former President of Rhoto Pharmaceutical Company in Osaka. Mr. Yamada recognized that creative basic research in Natural Science is indispensable for the welfare and prosperity of mankind.
Hence, the Foundation has been supporting
innovative research project in physics, chemistry and biology, assisting the international exchange of scientists and also the international conference called Yamada Conference with full financial support, two times every year recently. We are convinced that all the past conferences have been rewarding, stimulating and successful. Unfortunately I could not give a welcome address at the opening session, the day before yesterday, clue to inevitable circumstances.
This evening, however, I am
very happy to be here with all the participants. Incidentally, I had been an experimental physical chemist in the field of structural chemical thermodynamics and working, for a long time on phase transitions in the solid by main use of calorimetry. Although I am not the specialist in the field of Solution Chemistry discussed in the present conference, I am very much convinced that the selected subjects of "Structure, Fluctuation and Relaxation
xiv
in Solutions" are one of the most fundamental, fascinating and frontier topics for the essential progress of liquid and solution science which is associated with physics, chemistry and also biology interdisciprinarily. This is just in accordance with the original aim of Yamada Conference. I hear from Professor Ohtaki and Professor Nomura that the Conference is going in quite an active and marvelous fashion up to now.
I do hope such a
wonderful situation will continue and that aH the participants will enjoy a friendly and free contact to cherish mutual friendship with each other and have successful final results for the conference. Last but not least, I would like to express my thanks to the member of the organizing committee, particularly to Professor Nomura, who have made excellent arrangements for the success of the Conference. Thank you for your attention.
~
~
Syuzo Seki Director General of Yamada Science Foundation
xv
YAMADA S C I E N C E F O U N D A T I O N AND T H E S C O P E OF Y A M A D A C O N F E R E N C E Yamada Science Foundation was established in February 1977 in Osaka through the generosity of Mr. Kiro Yamada. Mr. Yamada was President of Rohto Pharmaceutical Company, Limited, a well-known manufacturer of medicines in Japan. He recognized that creative, unconstrained, basic research is indispensable for the future welfare and spenty of mankind and he has been deeply concerned with its promotion. erefore, funds for this Foundation were donated from his private holdings.
p~
The principal activity of the Yamada Science Foundation is to offer financial assistance to creative research in the basic natural sciences, particularly in !nterdisciplinary domains that brid e established fields. Projects which promote... international cooperation are also ~avored. By assisting the exchange of vmmng scientists and encouraging international meetings, this Foundation intends to greatly further the progress of science in the global environment. In this context, Yamada Science Foundation sponsors international Yamada Conferences once or twice a year in Japan. Subjects to be selected by the Foundation should be most timely and stimulating. These conferences are expected to be of the highest international standard so as to significantly foster advances in their respective fields.
xvi Executive M e m b e r s of F o u n d a t i o n
Officers: Board of Directors
Leo ESAKi Kenichi FUKUI Osamu HAYAISHI Junjiro KANAMORI Kiyoshi SF-GAMt
Standing Director
SyOz6 SEKI
Director General
metuo SHIBA
Tomoji SUZUKI Ikuo TAKEUCHi
Yasusada YAMADA Auditors Seturo EBASH!
Hisaya NARA
Advisors:
Nobur6 KAMIYA Takeo NAGAMIYA Shuntaro OGAWA
xvii
Contents
Special Issue: Structure, Fluctuation, and Relaxation in Solutions m Proceedings of the Yamada Conference XXXXII, Nagoya, Japan, 11-15 December 1994 Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii Organizing Committee and List of Participants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix Welcome Address . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xiii Yamada Science Foundation and the Scope of Yamada Conference . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xv Executive Members of Foundation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xvi Papers not included in this special issue . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xxi Perspective of solution chemistry of Japan. The historical background and recent trends H. Ohtaki (Shiga, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Molecular theory of solvation processes in dipolar and non-dipolar solvents H.L. Friedman, F.O. Raineri, B.-C. Perng (Stony Brook, NY, USA) and M.D. Newton (Upton, NY, USA) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 An interaction-site representation of the dynamic structure factor of liquid and the solvation dynamics F. Hirata, T. Munakata (Kyoto, Japan), F. Raineri and H.L. Friedman (Stony Brook, NY, USA) . 15 The interplay of dielectric and mechanical relaxation in solvation dynamics B.J. Schwartz and P.J. Rossky (Austin, TX, USA) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Fluctuating charge force fields for aqueous solutions S.W. Rick, S.J. Stuart, J.S. Bader and B.J. Berne (New York, NY, USA) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 Solvation dynamics of dye molecules in polar solvents studied by time resolved hole burning spectroscopy K. Nishiyama, Y. Asano, N. Hashimoto and T. Okada (Osaka, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 Ultrafast measurements of the dynamics of soivation in polar and non-dipolar solvents J. Gardecki, M.L. Horng, A. Papazyan and M. Maroncelli (University Park, PA, USA) ............ 49 Solvent and nuclear dynamic effects on intermolecular electron transfer K. Yoshihara, Y. Nagasawa, A. Yartsev, A.E. Johnson and K. Tominaga (Okazaki, Japan) ..... 59 Theory on rates of solution reactions influenced by slow fluctuations in viscous solvents, and its experimental confirmation H. Sumi (lbaraki, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Dynamics of Brownian motion under a potential and theory on the rate of chemical reactions A. Morita (Tokyo, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 75 Structural characteristics of hydrogen-bonded networks in water and ice systems J.C. Dore and D.M. Blakey (Canterbury, UK) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 85 Structure and dynamics of supercooled and glassy aqueous ionic solutions T. Yamaguchi, M. Yamagami, H. Wakita (Fukuoka, Japan) and A.K. Soper (Didcot, UK) ........ 91 The structure and dynamics of aqueous solutions containing complex molecules A.C. Barnes, G.W. Neilson and J.E. Enderby (Bristol, UK) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 Liquid-liquid phase separations and critical behavior of electrolyte solutions driven by long-range and short-range interactions H. Weing&rtner (Karlsruhe, Germany) and W. Schr6er (Bremen, Germany) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 Slow relaxation in pure and binary frozen-in systems H. Suga (Higashi-Osaka, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 115
... XVlII
Slow dynamics in supercooled fluids Y. Hiwatari, J. Matsui (Kanazawa, Japan), T. Muranaka (Toyota, Japan) and T. Odagaki (Fukuoka, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Density functional theory of solution dynamics T. Munakata (Kyoto, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dissociation and solvation in water and aqueous solutions A.D.J. Haymet (Sydney, N.S.W., Australia) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Effect of solvent, temperature, and pressure on hydrogen bonding and reorientation of water molecules M. Nakahara and C. Wakai (Kyoto, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Collective vibrational dynamics of simple liquids M. Buchner and T. DorfmQIler (Bielefeld, Germany) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mechanisms of dephasing in femtosecond time-resolved coherent Raman scattering from molecules in liquids Y. Fujimura (Sendal, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ion solvation and ion association studied by infrared and microwave methods J. Barthel (Regensburg, Germany) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dynamical aspects of water by low-frequency Raman scattering Y. Tominaga, Y. Wang, A. Fujiwara (Tokyo, Japan) and K. Mizoguchi (Osaka, Japan) .......... Ultrasonic relaxation study of fast exchange processes in mixed micelle systems of alcoholdecyltrimethylammonium bromide-water R.E. Verrall (Saskatoon, Sask., Canada), D.J. Jobe (Pinawa, Man., Canada) and E. Aicart (Madrid, Spain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Organometallic free radicals in solution J.H. Espenson (Ames, IA, USA) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The structure of metal complexes of small models of glycoproteins in aqueous solution K. Burger, L. Nagy and B. Gyuresik (Szeged, Hungary) ............................................. Kinetic evidence for short-lived intermediates in metalloporphyrin formation M. Tabata (Saga, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Structure and dynamics of solvated ions: new tendencies of research T. Radnai (Pusztaszeriut, Hungary) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The role of solvent in inorganic reaction mechanisms, as elucidated by high pressure studies T.W. Swaddle (Calgary, Aita., Canada) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . EXAFS of bromide ion in solvents and at air/solution interface I. Watanabe (Osaka, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Redox properties of oxo-bridged di- and tri-nuclear complexes of heavy transition elements: stability of mixed-valence state Y. Sasaki (Sapporo, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Study of the reduction of Co(NH3)4(pzCO2)2§ by Fe(CN)6'- in binary aqueous mixtures: an interpretation of solvent effects based on spectroscopic data P. Perez-Tejeda (Sevilla, Spain), J. Benko (Bratislava, Slovak Republic), M.L. Moya and F. Sanchez (Seviila, Spain) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ion pair of tetraalkylammonium picrates K. Sawada and F. Chigira (Niigata, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ion-pairing effects on the SgCoelectric field gradients in the NMR relaxations of tripositive cobalt(Ill) complex ions M. lida, T. Nakamori, Y. Mizuno (Nara, Japan) and Y. Masuda (Tokyo, Japan) ................... Concentration dependence of S"Co relaxation rates of tris(acetylacetonatao)-cobalt(ill)in some organic solvents M. Kanakubo, H. Ikeuchi and G.P. Sat6 (Tokyo, Japan) ............................................. Mechanistic study of oxidation reactions of hydroquinone, catechol, and L-ascorbic acid by dicyanobis(1,10-phenanthroline) iron(Ill) in dimethyl sulfoxide H.D. Takagi, N. Kagayama, M. Matsumoto, T. Tarumi and S. Funahashi (Nagoya, Japan) ......
123 131 139 149 157 169 177 187
195 205 213 221 229 237 245 253
261 265 269 273 277
xix Molecular orientation in fluids near solid-liquid interface as studied by the density functional method Y. Teramoto and K. Nakanishi (Kyoto, Japan) ........................................................ The stability and dynamics of clathrate hydrates H. Tanaka (Kyoto, Japan) ............................................................................... Deviation of the TST rate constant through the nonlinear couplings M. Nagaoka (Kyoto, Japan), N. Yoshida (Hyogo, Japan) and T. Yamabe (Kyoto, Japan) ........ Spatial correlations in reaction-diffusion systems in nonequilibrium conditions K. Seki (Ibaraki, Japan) and K. Kitahara (Tokyo, Japan) ............................................. Nonlinear effects of solvation dynamics A. Yoshimori (Nagoya, Japan) .......................................................................... Solvation dynamics studied by ultrafast transient hole burning J. Ma, D.V. Bout and M. Berg (Columbia, SC, USA) ................................................. Hydrogen-bonded structure in aqueous sulfuric acid solutions Y. Kameda, K. Hosoya, S. Sakamoto, H. Suzuki, T. Usuki and O. Uemura (Yamagata, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Raman spectroscopic study of rotational and vibrational relaxation of CF3H in the supercritical site S. Okazaki, N. Terauchi and I. Okada (Yokohama, Japan) .......................................... Anomalous conformational behavior of short poly(oxyethylene) chains in water: an FT-IR spectroscopic study H. Matsuura and T. Sagawa (Higashi-Hiroshima, Japan) ........................................... Time-resolved resonance Raman study of the recombination dynamics photodissociated carbon monoxide to sperm whale myoglobin and its mutants S. Nakashima (Toyonaka, Japan), T. Kitagawa (Okazaki, Japan) and J.S. Olson (Houston, TX, USA) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Solvent viscosity dependence of bimolecular reaction rate constant of the excited 9cyanoanthracene quenched by 1,3-cyctohexadiene M.Kitazawa, T. Yabe, Y. Hirata and T. Okada (Osaka, Japan) ...................................... Extremely slow reorientation dynamics of molecular tracers in glassy polymers Q. Tran-Cong, H. Kanato and S. Chikaki (Kyoto, Japan) ............................................ Dynamics near a liquid surface: mechanisms of evaporation and condensation K. Yasuoka, M. Matsumoto (Nagoya, Japan) and Y. Kataoka (Koganei, Japan) .................. The effect of ionic atmosphere on the tracer diffusion of micelles T. Tominaga and M. Nishinaka (Okayama, Japan) ................................................... Effect of addition of surfactant on the micelle-monomer exchange process T. Matsuoka, T. Shibata, S. Koda and H. Nomura (Nagoya, Japan) ................................ Dissipative structure in aqueous polymer solutions H. Maeda, S. Sasaki, T. Mashita, K. Nakamura, H. Ojima, T. Gotoh, T. Fukuda and M. Yamanaka (Fukuoka, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Non-linear effects in the free energy.profile of electron transfer reaction: an integral equation approach S.-H. Chong and F. Hirata (Kyoto, Japan) ............................................................. Induction time of precipitation of calcium carbonate L.-F. Olsson (Lund, Sweden) ........................................................................... Photophysical properties of viologen-linked N-alkylporphyrins and their zinc(ll) complexes in solutions K. Tsukahara, N. Sawai, S. Hamada, T. Nakazawa (Nara, Japan) and R. Nakagaki (Ishikawa, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conductometric study of hydrophobic properties of tris(1,10-phenanthroline) and tris(2,2'bipyridine complexes H. Yokoyama, K. Shinozaki, S. Hattori, F. Miyazaki and M. Goto (Yokohama, Japan) ........... Structure of the monohalogenocadmium(ll)complexes in N,N-dimethylformamide K. Ozutsumi (Tsukuba, Japan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
281 285 289 293 297 301 305 309 313
317 321 325 329 333 337 341 345 349
353 357 361
xx Effect of pressure on the viscosity of aqueous cesium chloride solution at 25~ T. Nakai, S. Sawamura and Y. Taniguchi (Shiga, Japan) ............................................ Melting behaviour in hexagonal CeCI3 and monoclinic ErCI3 crystals Y. Iwadate, N. Okako, Y. Koyama, H. Kubo and K. Fukushima (Chiba, Japan) ................... Polarization effect on the static and dynamic properties of molten lithium iodide S itoh (Cambridge, UK) and P.A. Madden (Oxford, UK) ............................................ Evsluation of thermodynamic quantities of fluid mixtures by the PY equation F. Kawaizumi, Y. Amakasu, M. Ohba and H. Nomura (Nagoya, Japan) ........................... $olvation free energy of protein reproduced by the combination of the extended scaled particle theory and the Poisson-Boltzmann equation M. Irisa (Osaka, Japan), T. Takahashi (Tsukuba, Japan), F. Hirata (Kyoto, Japan) and T. Yanagida (Osaka, Japan) ............................................................................... Transport properties of a spherical molecule in solvent with position-dependent viscosity K. Ibuki and M. Ueno (Kyoto, Japan) ................................................................... Liquid dynamics studied by higher order non-linear optical spectroscopy K. Tominaga, G.P. Keogh and K. Yoshihara (Okazaki, Japan) ..................................... Temperature dependence of singlet excitation energy migration in liquid benzene as revealed by picosecond laser photolysis H. Miyasaka (Kyoto, Japan) and N. Mataga (Osaka, Japan) ........................................ Solvent effect on ultra-fast electron transfer in mixed-valence biferrocene monocation A. Masuda, Y. Masuda and Y. Fukuda (Tokyo, Japan) .............................................. Translational diffusion of transient radicals studied by the transient grating method M. Terazima, K. Okamoto and N. Hirota (Kyoto, Japan) ............................................. Intra and intermolecular energy transfer in thermal dissociation in the gas and liquid N20, T. Kato (Kyoto, Japan), S. Hayashi (Kyoto-fu, Japan) and K. Machida (Kyoto, Japan) ........... Photoelectron emission spectroscopy applied to bromide ion in solvents H. Tanida and I. Watanabe (Osaka, Japan) ........................................................... Direct comparison between femtosecond optical Kerr effect and high-resolution light scattering measurements Y. Kai, S. Kinoshita (Osaka, Japan), M. Yamaguchi and T. Yagi (Sapporo, Japan) .............. Vibrational cooling process in solution probed by picosecond time-resolved Raman spectroscopy. Analysis of the cooling kinetics Ko Iwata and H. Hamaguchi (Kawasaki, Japan) ...................................................... Rotational relaxation of rod like molecules: diphenylacetylene in various solvents Y. Hirata, Y. Kanemoto, T. Okada (Toyonaka, Japan) and T. Nomoto (Mie, Japan) .............. Ground state recovery of phenol blue in fluids near the gas-liquid critical density Y. Kimura and N. Hirota (Kyoto, Japan) ............................................................... Dynamics of two-component liquids near the glass transition Y. Kaneko (Kyoto, Japan) and J. Bosse (Berlin, Germany) .......................................... Relaxation characteristics of intracellular (Na § as measured by double quantum filtered (DQf) NMR Y. Seo and M. Murakami (Okazaki, Japan) ...........................................................
365 369 373 377
381 385 389 393 397 401 405 409 413 417 421 425 429 433
Author Index ..................................................................................................
437
Subject Index .................................................................................................
441
Following papers were presented in the Conference. However, these hhhpapers are not included in this special issue.
0-9
Collisional Energy Transfer of Vibrationally Highly Excited Molecules from Gaseous to Liquid Environments J.Troe (Universit~it GiSttingen, Germany)
A-13 High-Pressure FIR and Molecular Dynamics Study of Collision-induced Absorption of Non-dipolar Liquids Y.Fujita, and S.Ikawa (Hokkaido University) B-9
Calculation of Solvation Effect on the Ionization Potential Using Continuum Dielectric Model M.Harada, and K.Sakai, and l.Watanabe (Osaka University)
B-23 Solvent Effects on the Molecular Conformational Equilibrium of Chloroacetone M.Kato, Y.Nanba, and Y.Taniguchi (Ritsumeikan University)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
journal of
MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molccular Liquids, 65/66 ~1995) I-6
Perspective of Solution Chemistry of Japan. - The Historical B a c k g r o u n d and Recent Trends Hitoshi Ohtaki Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science and Engineering, Ritsumeikan University, 1916 Noji-cho, Kusatsu, Shiga 525, Japan
Abstract The development of solution chemistry in Japan is reviewed in connection with the history of solution chemistry in Europe and in the United States. Studies on solution chemistry from molecular aspects, as well as those by means of thermodynamics and statistical thermodynamics, axe discussed from experimental and theoretical sides. Recent trends in solution chemistry, especially those in Japan, are overviewed from static and dynamic points of view. 1. Introduction Solution chemistry in Japan has a relatively long history from the beginning of the 20th century. After a rapid development of physical chemistry, inorganic chemistry and organic chemistry around the turn of the century to the 20th, the term "solution chemistry" is occasionally used among physical and coordination chemists who are interested in properties of electrolyte and non-electrolyte solutions in the 1950's. In fact, most of works by van't Hoff, Kohlrausch, Arrhenius and Ostwald, should be included in solution chemistry in the present sense. Classical analytical chemistry and electrochemistry represented by the works of Noyes, Treadwell, Heyrovsky and Kolthoff may also be considered as applied fields of solution chemistry. Marine chemistry and geochemistry are acceptable as fields closely related to solution chemistry. Even environmental chemistry in recent years should be considered to be an interdisciplinary area of solution chemistry and environmental science.
2. Streams of Solution Chemistry Solution chemistry has, from the origin of the traditional studies of modern chemistry, two main streams: one is concerned with physicochemical studies of solutions, and the other includes studies on chemical reactions in solution. The former has been investigated mainly by physical chemists, and the latter is closely related to coordination chemistry. New techniques such as laser Raman spectrophotometry, NMR spectroscopy and X-ray and neutron diffraction methods, as well as EXAFS and XANES spectroscopy, provide us tools to observe solution phenomena from the microscopic point of view on the bases of structural chemistry and reaction dynamics. Thus, structural and dynamic studies of solutions have been developed as new streams of solution chemistry. 3. Studies of Solution Chemistry in Europe and in the United States One might say that electrochemical studies achieved by Michael Faraday around the 1830's is the starting point of modern solution chemistry. If we focus our attention on basic solution chemistry, the work by Arrhenius (1886) 1 can be said as the most remarkable landmark of solution 0167-7322/95/$09.50 ,~ 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. SSDI 0167-7322 (95) 00838-!
chemistry. Studies carried out by van't Hoff, Ostwald and Kohlrausch at almost the same period as Arrhenius' work, established an equation, "physical chemistry = thermodynamics = solution chemistry", in the early 1900's. This period may be classified to be the first golden period of solution chemistry, although the word "solution chemistry" has not yet been created as a scientific terminology. The second golden time of solution chemistry started by the work of Debye and Hiickel in 19232, which was based on statistical thermodynamics, one step further advanced from thermodynamics. This work was immediately followed by N. Bjerrum 3, whose idea of ion-pair formation was induced by the Debye-Hiickel theory. In these treatments they accepted the existence of ions and molecules with finite sizes as solutes, but solvent was regarded as a homogeneous continuum, and no molecular aspect was introduced in their concept. In this respect the second period can be said as the dawn of the molecular solution chemistry developed in the late 20th century. In this section, we have to mention the work by Bernal and Fowler (1933) 4, which will be referred to again later. In 1960's the molecular aspect was well introduced to solvents, as well as to solutes, and solution chemistry entered the third period. This period was sometimes called "Renaissance of Solution Chemistry". The structure of water and other liquids was discussed in various ways, and such theoretical considerations were highly supported by the development of high-speed computers. Computer simulation studies appeared as a new way of studying structure and dynamics of solutions. Besides the physicochemical studies on solution chemistry, investigations for chemical reactions in solution were extensively developed in the latter half of the 20th century. Studies on chemical reactions in solution were, in principle, closely related to Werner's synthetic works of coordination compounds, and thus, these studies were carried out mostly by coordination chemists rather than physical chemists. Accumulation of knowledge on chemical reactions through studies on synthetic and decomposition reactions led to construction of more reasonable scheme for chemical reactions in solution. Spectrophotometric and optical rotatory dispersive methods, which had been employed in the structural investigations for inert complexes in solution, became important techniques in studies of solution chemistry including reactions of labile complexes. An epoch-making event in solution chemistry happened in 1957. Frank and Wen5 from USA and Samoilov 6 from Russia presented their papers concerning ionic hydration in the journal, "Discussion of Faraday Society". A new concept on the structure and dynamics of ionic hydration was established in this year, although their models were rather primitive according to the present understanding. Nevertheless, their models are still well accepted by many solution chemists as simple but reasonable ones. Interestingly the two important papers on ionic hydration were reported in an English journal by an American and a Russian chemists in the period of the cold war. In the scientific community we have neither border nor war. Studies on ionic hydration and complex formation reactions in solution in the 1960's quite actively proceeded in Europe, especially in northern Europe. J. Bjerrum 7, a son of N. Bjerrum in Denmark, established a method for determination of stepwise formation constants of complexes with simple monodentate ligands in solution by the spectrophotometric method, which was soon modified to the method by potentiometry. Sillen in Sweden extended the method to polynuclear complex formation reactions and Schwartzenbach in Switzerland, who is a pioneer of chelate chemistry, applied this method to multidentate ligand complexes Studies on reactions in solution expanded from equilibrium to non-equilibrium state, and the most remarkable study done in this period was that by Eigen 8 in Germany. Thus, the northern Europe has a tradition for electrolyte solution chemistry since Arrhenius. In USA at the same time, Taube9 introduced a new concept of inner- and outer-sphere reaction mechanisms. Solution chemistry in USA yielded many interesting works,especially in thermodynamic and
statistical thermodynamic studies. The names of Lewis the the very early 1900's, and then, Pitzer, Guggenheim, Hildebrand, and Onsager (although he was originally Norwegian) easily came up to our mind. Coordination solution chemistry was also developed in USA since the 1930's under the leadership by J. Bailer, Jr. In a period when all scientists in Europe and Asia had a hard time during and after the War II, US chemists established the Renaissance of Coordination Chemistry. In the field of solution chemistry a number of names can be picked up from the literature in US in this period,e.g., Basolo, Calvin, and Taube. Statistical thermodynamics was thoroughly investigated in this period and the results were conveyed to the late 20th century. Landmark works by, e.g., Lennard-Jones-Devonshire, Eyring, Yvon-Born-Green, and Kirkwood were connected to the creation of the Ornstein-Zernike, Hypernetted-chain, and Percus-Yevick equations, and new theories such as Scaled Particle and Perturbation Theories were presented. In these theories particles are usually noncharged and longrange ion-ion and dipole-dipole electrostatic interactions are cut off by the introduction of a shielding function in order to eliminate complicated long-range electrostatic interactions. These theories depicted a system in terms of particles of the solute and solvent, and thus, the picture is essentially different from that of the Debye-H iJckel theory. These statistical mechanical theories established in the middle 1900's are especially powerful for systems constructed by non-charged particles with a spherical shape. The development of high-speed computers helps the utilities of the theories by solving equations by means of numerical calculations, which were not soluble until the middle 1900's in mathematical ways. Development of high-speed computers provided a new field of solution chemistry. Molecular mechanics, Monte-Carlo, inverse Monte Carlo, molecular dynamics simulations are those typical approaches in this area. These methods have never been thought in the past until a numerous iterative calculations can be done by computers. Imagine that a radial distribution function of a system containing non-charged spherical particles was simulated by black and white agar-agar balls in a glass vessel and by taking a number of photographs to calculate baU-ball distances by Hildebrand. Since computer simulations reproduce not only experimental results but also reveal unknown facts not accessible by any kind of presently available experimental techniques This is why studies by means of Monte Carlo and molecular dynamics simulations became so fashionable especially for young scientists. The multibody and polarization problems have not been well introduced in these calculations yet, and thus, the simulations are still far from ideal for the elucidation of solution phenomena. These difficulties should be overcome by the effort of physicochemical solution chemists in the 21 st century.
4. Studies of Solution Chemistry in Japan How did solution chemistry in Japan develop? It is said that the Japanese scientist who was first interested in solution chemistry in the present sense was Joji Sakurai (1858-1936). It seemed quite natural that Sakurai, a leading scientist in Japan, was attracted to this field, because he was a physical chemist and the equation "physical chemistry = thermodynamics = solution chemistry" holds rather strictly in this period due to the works by Arrhenius, Ostwald, van't Hoff, and others in Europe. Furthermore, Kikunae Ikeda (1864-1935), who discovered sodium glutamate ("Aji-nomoto") and then changed his interest from physical chemistry to organic chemistry, Yukichi Ohsaka (1867-1950), both of them studied physical chemistry in the laboratory of Ostwald in Germany, and Masao Katayama (1877-1961) significantly contributed to the development of solution chemistry of Japan from the stand-point of thermodynamics and thermochemistry. Although Sakurai's and Ikeda's interests were directed later to fields other than solution chemistry, solution chemistry was one of the most fashionable chemistry and an active branch of
physical chemistry in Japan in the early 20th century, and solution chemistry has been an important subject of research in some imperial universities in the 1930's. Thus, studies on solution chemistry were started rather early in Japan only a little later than Europe. However, originality of chemical researches in Japan was not highly evaluated, because they were mostly studies imitated solution chemistry in Europe. Accompanying the development of chemistry in other fields, researches unique to Japanese solution chemistry were grown. Investigations on properties of solutions by thermodynamics and statistical thermodynamics, chemical equilibria and reaction kinetics became to be the main fields of physical and inorganic solution chemistry in Japan. Even after a break of scientific investigations due to the War II we still had difficulties to communicate with scientists outside Japan. Not only solution chemists but also scientists in other fields in Japan had to tread a thorny path for several years in the 1940's-1950's. Experimental works which do not need expensive equipments could compete with works in the world rather early compared with other fields of solution chemistry. Complex formation studies by the pH-metry using glass electrodes, studies on weak ion-ion interactions by the conductometry, investigations of properties and structures of solutions by the UV-visible and IR spectrophotometry, and oxidation-reduction studies on ionic species by using polarography are typical examples in solution chemistry studies in Japan in the early stage after the second world war. Polarography created by Heyrovsky in 1929 was introduced to Japan by Masuzo Shikata, a coworker of Heyrovsky, and this technique quickly attracted interest of analytical chemists and electrochemists in Japan. N. Tanaka and his coworker R. Tamamushi made a remarkable achievement in the field of oxidation-reduction reactions of metal complexes in solution by polarography. Studies on ion-pair formation initiated by N. Bjerrum were extended theoretically by Onsager and Fuoss, and the theory of ion-pair formation almost completed in the 1960's. Since they were in USA, the studies on ion-pair formation were more actively carried out in USA than other parts of the world. Since the study does not need expensive tools, the work could be done in Japan by using the Onsager-Fuoss theory. Spectrophotometric studies in Japan has a long tradition since Yuji Shibata, a coworker of A. Werner, came back from Switzerland in 1913. The spectroscopic method for the determination of the composition of complexes formed in solution, which is now referred to as Job's method, was really reported by Shibata much earlier than Job. Studies on the spectrophotometric series (1938-1939) by Tuchida is one of the most important achievement in spectroscopic studies made in Japan in this period. Complex formation has also been studied in Japan from view-points of chemical equilibria, reaction kinetics and structures of complexes in solution. Works influenced by J. Bjerrum, Sillen and Schwarzenbach and others in North Europe formed an important stream in equilibrium studies in solution. Reaction kinetics were investigated on the basis of the absolute reaction rate developed by Eyring and fast reactions were analyzed by the method established by Eigen. Many young Japanese scientists went to Europe, USA and Canada to accept new ideas and to learn new methods of investigation there. Structural chemistry of solutions started in Japan rather late compared with other studies of solutions, although crystallographic investigations were very highly developed and actively investigated in Japan. This fact may be due to lack of the concept of structure of liquids in most Japanese physical chemists. The concept of "structure" was soundly applied to solids and molecules in the gas phase, but not to liquids and solutions. X-Ray diffraction studies on liquids and amorphous substances were already examined in 1916 by Debye and S herrer 10, immediately after the first work of Debye for the X-ray diffraction. Studies on liquid metals and molten salts by using X-
ray and neutron diffraction methods were examined by some workers in Japan, but this technique was quite unfamiliar to most Japanese and it had applied neither to water and aqueous solutions nor nonaqueous solutions until Ohtaki applied the solution X-ray diffraction method to cadmium iodide and copper perchlorate solutions in 197411. Combination of a diffraction experiment with molecular dynamics simulation was fin'st made in Japan in 198212, and this combination is now well accepted as one of the most general ways of studies on solution structures. Bioinorganic chemistry was extended in Japan by amalgamating solution chemistry, coordination chemistry and biochemistry. From such a historical background, biochemistry in Japan has still a strong interrelationship with solution chemistry. Everybody recognizes a high activity of bioinorganic chemistry in Japan. Organic chemists are interesting in reactions in solutions, but most of them pay much more attention to the play of solutes than the role of solvents in reactions. The society of solution chemistry in Japan is mostly supported by physical chemists, inorganic chemists and analytical chemists. In 1978 the National Symposium on Solution Chemistry in Japan has started and the meeting has been organized every year at various places in Japan since then. With the background of the activity of Japanese solution chemists, the Association of Japanese Solution Chemists has been established in 1983. The activity of the association increased year by year, and the number of participants of the national meeting on solution chemistry steadily increased We had about 250 participants at the 17th symposium in Okayama held in November, 1994. In this decade we had two big three-year projects concerning solution chemistry under the sponsorship of the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture of Japan. One is the project entitled "Microscopic and Dynamic Aspects of Solute-Solvent Interactions", headed by H. Yamatera and H. Ohtaki was the secretary, which run from 1985 to 1987 fiscal years. The other is "Molecular Approaches to Nonequilibrium Processes in Solutions", which was performed from April, 1990 to March, 1993. The project leader and the subleader were H. Ohtaki and H. Nomura, respectively. Japanese solution chemists have been highly encouraged by these projects. The results of the former project has been published from Elsevier Science Publishers 13. 5. Molecular Aspects and the Perspective of Solution Chemistry As mentioned above, solution chemistry was born at the end of the 19th century and developed on the basis of thermodynamics and statistical thermodynamics. Main fields supporting the solution chemistry were physical chemistry and coordination chemistry, which also absorbed some other parts of chemistry in order to establish an interdisciplinary field of chemistry in 19501960. Even in this period, however, solvent, e.g, water, was recognized as a continuum in most studies except for some works on ionic hydration, and thus, molecular picture of water was not clearly recognized. In modern solution chemistry, ion-solvent and ion-ion interactions should be depicted more clearly at the molecular level. The first molecular picture of water was drawn by Bernal and Fowler in 19334. Their work was based on X-ray diffraction data of water reported by Meyer 14, Steward 15, and Amidi 16. Therefore, we can say that the molecular aspect of water and solution was already established in 1930's, but proposition of the concept of component molecules by Bernal and Fowler is no doubt the most important historical event in structural solution chemistry. Statistical thermodynamics is also changing in recent years. Newly developed RISM (Reference Interactions Site Model) theory has no restriction on the shape of solute species, in contrast to old theories in which spherical species are usually assumed. Ab initio calculations are being combined with molecular dynamic simulations. This combination becomes possible because of the improvement of high-speed computers. The polarization effect and multibody problem will be
adequately introduced in MD calculations in the not too distant future. Dynamic properties of solvent and solute molecules in the condensed phase will be better represented by theories and experiments in the nano second or even shorter time scale in the near future. Structures of short-lived reaction intermediates and even activated complexes will be directly determined by experiments, although indirect observations are sometimes possible even now. Solution chemistry should be further developed by concurrent studies of thermodynamics-statistical thermodynamics, solution reaction studies, structural studies on liquids and solutions, and studies on solution dynamics. At the beginning of the 21st century we shall enjoy fruits grown in the field of solution chemistry irrigated by these four disciplines. References 1 S. Arrhenius, Z. phys. Chem., 1~ 631 (1887). 2 P. Debye and E. HiJckel, Phys. Z., 24, 185 (1923). 3 N. Bjerrum, Kungl. Danske Videnskab. Selskab. Math.-fys., Medd., 7_, 1 (1926). 4 J.D. Bernal and R. H. Fowler, J. Chem. Phys., 1_, 515 (1933). 5 H.S. Frank and W.-Y. Wen, Disc. Faraday Soc., 24, 133 (1957). 6 0 . Ya. Samoilov, Disc. Faraday Soc., 24, 141 (1957). 7 J. Bjerrum, Kungl. Danske Videnskab. Selskab. Math.-fys., Medd., 11, 1 (1931). 8 M. Eigen and K. Tamm, Z. Electrochem., 66, 107 (1962) and others. 9 H. Taube and H. Meyers, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 76, 2103 (1955). 10 P. Debye and P. Sherrer, Nachr. Ges. Wiss. G~ttingen, 1, (1916). 11 a) H. Ohtaki, M. Maeda and S. Ito, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 47, 2217 (1974); b) H. Ohtaki and M. Maeda, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 47, 2197 (1974). 12 I. Okada, Y. Kitsuno, H.-G. Lee, and H. Ohtaki, "Application of Molecular Dynamics Simulation to the Structural Analysis of X-Ray Diffraction Data on a Concentrated LiCI Aqueous Solution" in "Ions and Molecules in Solution" eds. N. Tanaka, H. Ohtaki, and R. Tamamushi, Elsevier, Amsterdam, p. 81 (1983). 13 H. Ohtaki and H. Yamatera, eds., "Structure and Dynamics of Solutions" Elsevier, (1992). 14 A. W. Meyer, Ann. Phys., 5, 701 (1930). 15 G. W. Steward, Phys. Rev., 35, 1462 (1930); 37, 9 (1931). 16 E. Amidi, Phys. Z., 32, 914 (1931).
journal of MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS Journ',dof Molecularliquids. 65/66(1995)7-14
ELSEVIER
MOLECULAR THEORY OF SOLVATION PROCESSES IN D I P O L A R A N D N O N - D I P O L A R S O L V E N T S H a r o l d L. F r i e d m a n , F e r n a n d o O. Raineri, B a w - C h i n g P e r n g
Department of Chemistry, State University of New York at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, New York 11794-3400, USA and M a r s h a l l D. N e w t o n
Chemistry Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory Upton, New York 11973, USA Abstract
We describe a molecular theory of solvation dynamics which provides a detailed description of the mechanism of solvent response following a sudden change in the charge distribution of a solute molecule. The theory is based on a new renormalized linear response development which incorporates nonlinear aspects of equilibrium solvation. The solute-solvent coupling is formulated in terms of intermolecular interactions, without recourse to macroscopic cavity concepts. Both the solute and solvent are represented by interaction site models, while the dynamical aspects are treated with our previously developed Reference Memory Function Approximation. The results for solvation dynamics in water and acetonitrile compare very favourably with MD simulation results for the same model systems. The same renormalized dynamical theory of solvation provides a very useful framework for estimating free energy profiles and associated parameters (average vertical energy gap, reorganization energy, change in solvation free energy) for electron transfer reactions. The new results demonstrate that a reasonably detailed molecular theory that deals with models incorporating the charge distribution of the molecules explains the solvation properties relevant to the theory of electron transfer reactions in both dipolar and non-dipolar (polar) solvents. I. I n t r o d u c t i o n In view of the great importance of chemical reactions in solution, it is not surprising that basic aspects (structure, energetics, and dynamics) of elementary solvation processes continue to motivate both experimental and theoretical investigations. Thus, there is growing interest in the dynamical participation of the solvent in the events following a sudden redistribution of the charges of a solute molecule. 1 These phenomena control photoionization in both pure liquids and solutions, the solvation of electrons in polar liquids, the time-dependent fluorescence Stokes shift, and the contribution of the solvent polarization fluctuations to the rates of electron transfer in oxidation-reduction reactions in solution. We describe a classical statistical mechanical theory of solvation dynamics, formulated for general molecular interaction site models (ISM) of the solute and solvent species. 2 Ba0167-7322/95/509.50
9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
SSD!0167-7322(95)00839-X
sed on a surrogate Hamiltonian model, the theory gives an approximate nonequilibrium distribution function that describes the state of the solvent as it adapts to a change in the distribution of charges on the solute molecule. The surrogate Hamiltonian is expressed in terms of renormalized solute-solvent interactions, a feature that leads to a simple and natural linear response description of the solvent dynamics in the vicinity of the solute. In addition to the measurable solvation time correlation function (tcf), we can also calculate observables needed to elucidate the detailed mechanism of solvation response, such as the evolution of the solvent polarization charge density around the solute. The dynamical theory also provides a framework for the study of the diabatic free energy profiles as functions of the reaction coordinate required in the theory of nonadiabatic electron transfer reactions. We illustrate this new applicatiort by calculating the free energy profiles in solvents coveting a wide range of polarity. II. Basic H a m i l t o n i a n M o d e l a n d S u r r o g a t e D e s c r i p t i o n We consider a genetic donor-acceptor complex solute at infinite dilution in a polyatomic solvent. Both the solute and solvent molecules are represented by rigid and nonpolarizable ISM models. In the ISM models the potential energy of interaction between two molecules is a sum of pairwise-additive site-site terms, including Coulombic interactions between partial charges located at the molecular sites. Throughout the paper the subscript A refers to interaction sites of the solute, while the subscript aj refers to interaction site j of solvent molecule a. The solute has two electronic states, the "precursor" (P) and "successor" (S) states, with different charge distributions characterized as sets of partial charges {QP} and {Qs} at the interaction sites. We regard the solute as the source of an "external" field which is fixed in space, and we concentrate on the solvent dynamics driven by this field. When the solute is in state D the Hamiltonian 7/D of this system (solute plus solvent) is 7"lD = E D + H D = E D + Hw + ~tD , D = P,S , (1) where E D is the energy of the solute electronic state D in vacuum and H D is the Hamiltonian of the solvent in the field of the fixed solute. The second equality expresses H D in terms of Hw, the Hamiltonian of the pure solvent, and the solute-solvent potential energy of interaction ~tD = ~_,,~ ~ a j u~(rA,aj), where the (solute site .\)-(solvent site 3) interaction potential
~ JD( ~ , o : )
= ~ : ( ~9 , ~ : )
~_ QD q1 r~,aj
,
O = P, S
(2)
comprises both a short range (non-Coulombic) part u*~j(r), and a long range (Coulombic) part. The dependence of the latter on the solute electronic state is explicit in Eq. (2). Furthermore, rA,a3 is the distance between solute site A and site j of solvent molecule a, while qj is the partial charge at an interaction site of type j in the solvent molecules. We now introduce a dynamical variable that is central in this work: the solvent
contribution to the vertical energy gap l~ -= H S -
HP = ~S _ ~P __ ~
AQ~ r~,aJqJ ,
~ aj
(3)
where AQ), - Q s _ QP. Thus, for a given configuration of the solvent around the solute. the energy difference between the S and P states of the system is 7-/S - ~ P = A E + ~, where A E is the energy difference between the two electronic states in vacuum. Unfortunately, theories starting from the basic (or factual 2) Hamiltonian, Eq. (1), unavoidably lead (without further approximation) to expressions for the dynamic solvation properties that require the knowledge of two-time many-point correlation functions. 2 To avoid this difficulty we turn to an alternative description of the system, in terms of the surrogate (subscript X') Hamiltonians 2 7"lD - E D + Y D = E D + Y w + ~D
,
D=P,S.
(4)
The difference between ~/D and 7"~D is that the former is defined in terms of renormalized solute-solvent interactions ~D, which need to be specified. While there is no unique criterion for choosing ~D, the selection must lead to an accurate theory of solvation dynamics without invoking two-time many-point correlation functions. We have found that this goal can be achieved with a new theory for the nonequilibrium distribution function in which the renormalized solute-solvent interactions enter linearly. 2 In this theory ~ and ~S are chosen such that the renormalized linear response theory accurately describes the essential solute-solvent static correlations that rule the equilibrium solvation both at t = 0 (when solvent is in equilibrium with the initial charge distribution of the solute) and at t = oc (whcn the solvent has reached equilibrium with the new solute charge distribution). 2 In this work we discuss a Renormalized Dielectric Theory (RDT), that is obtained with the choice 2 ~D = ~ / d3r pA,~(r)~D,A(r) , (5) A where ~A,~(r) is the microscopic solvent polarization charge density at position r relative to site A of the solute. For the expression for 15A,~,(r) the reader is referred to our previous reports. 2 D In Eq. (5) ~2:,A(r) represents the renormalized electrostatic potential at point r relative to the solute site A. It is defined in terms of the equilibrium RISM solute-solvent D ) when the solute is in the electronic state D site-site direct correlation functions cAj(r (RISM refers to the Reference Interaction Site Method of Chandler and Andersen 3) D D ~E,~(k) = ~E,~(k) = -kBT ~ 9j(k)c~(k) , J
(6)
where c~j(k) and ~D,x(k) are, respectively, the spatial Fourier transforms of c ~ ( r ) and D ~Z,~(r). Furthermore, kB is the Boltzmann constant and T is the temperature. The
charge number factors Oj(k) only depend on the average structure of the homogeneous solvent. 2 Notice that in Eqs. (5) and (6) the solute-solvent coupling is formulated in terms of intermolecular interactions, without recourse to macroscopic cavity concepts. III. S o l v a t i o n D y n a m i c s For the discussion of solvation dynamics we identify the electronic states P and S with, respectively, the ground state and an excited electronic state of the solute. In the solvation dynamics experiment the solute undergoes a P ---, S Franck-Condon transition produced by photoexcitation. We assume that the solute in the S state returns to the P state by fluorescence on a time scale that is comparable with the structural relaxation rate of the solvent around the solute. At any instant the fluorescence frequency v(t) is given by the relation by(t) = AE + ((~:; t)), where ((~:; t)) is the nonequilibrium average (under the surrogat~ estimate of the solvent nonequilibrium distribution function) of the surrogate solvent contribution to the vertical energy gap ~ = ~ - ~'P [compare with Eq. (3)]. The solvation time correlation function, which monitors the solvation response to the sudden (at t = 0) P - . S transition, is given by
~,(t) - ~,(oo) z(t)
=
~,(o) - ~,(oo) =
((~; t/) - ((~; oo)) ((t; 0)) - ((t; ~ ) )
(7)
The RDT estimate of the solvation tcf is found to be z~(t)
=
f
a:3k c~,(k,t)BE(k) .t a3k S,,(k) 8z(k) '
(S)
C~,(k, t) is the time correlation function of the solvent polarization charge density, 2 S~,(k) "- C~,(k, t= 0), and where we define
where
Bz(k)
= ~
,.,~,~,(k)a~:,~(k) a,~z,~,(k).
(9)
Here w;~;v(k) is the Fourier transform of the solute intramolecular correlation function, 3 S P and AqoE,,~(k) = qaE,,~(k ) - qav,,~(k) According to Eq. (7), it is the dielectric dynamics of the homogeneous solvent, as expressed in Cu(k, t), that is the source of the time dependence of the estimate Z~(t) of the solvation tcf. In the RDT approximation the effect of the solute-solvent interactions is carried by the static coupling function BE(k). This "factorization" (to a function of the homogeneous solvent dynamics times a function of the static solute-solvent structure) is a characteristic feature of the RDT theory. The renormalized character of the coupling function allows us to bypass the two-time many-point correlation functions that would necessarily appear in a dynamical theory that explicitly addressed the inhomogeneity of the solvent in the neighborhood of the solute particle. As an application, in Figure 1 we compare the prediction Z~(t) of the surrogate theory and the result of nonequilibrium MD simulation. The solute is a spherical particle with Lennard-Jones (L J) parameters E/kB =2668 K, a -6.975/It, which undergoes ionization from QP = 0 to Q s = 1 e (where e is the proton charge). The simulation results are
taken from the nonequilibrium Molecular Dynamics (NEMD) study by Maroncelli and Fleming. 4 The dielectric tcf C ~ ( k , t ) was calculated with the Reference Memory Function Approximation. 2,s The required solute-solute and solute-solvent site-site correlation functions were calculated under the RISM-HNC approximation. 2 As the figure shows, Z ~ ( t ) agrees very well with the nonequilibrium MD response. z h ( t ) displays (i) a very fast initial decay (~ 60% of the total decay within 20-30 fs), (ii) a strong oscillatory feature due to the collective librational motion (optical mode 5) of water, and (iii) a final slower relaxation of diffusive character. 1.0
,
,
1
, W A T E R
Z (f)
- - - NEMD
o
RDT
o
s~ 0
I
!
o
l
"
tO s)
,1
~
t'
"
0.5
Figure 1" Solvation tcf of an ion in water. See the text for details. The RDT theory of solvation dynamics is capable of describing the solvation tcf as well as the evolution of various ancillary observables. 2 IV. Free E n e r g y Profiles The diabatic free energy profile for the electronic state D is defined by the equation -fiFO(r1) -- In
1/ / 9
dr2
dFe-
6(71 - U)
}
,
D = P,S ,
(10)
where "HD is the basic Hamiltonian introduced in Eq. (1). f2 represents the set of Euler angles that specify the solute orientation, fl = ( k B T ) -1 , and 9 is a parameter (with dimensions of energy) independent of the electronic state D. 6 The Dirac delta function in Eq. (10) selects those configurations for which the solvent contribution to the vertical energy gap/d has the numerical value rl (the reaction coordinate). We apply the RDT theory to calculate an estimate FD(rl) of the free energy profile. The central quantity in this analysis is a generalized characteristic function g D ( z ) = ((exp(iz~))) D of complex argument z. Here ((--"/)D indicates an average over the surrogate solvent equilibrium distribution function [defined in terms of the surrogate Hamiltonian
7"/D, cf. Eq. (4)] when the solute is in state D. Both FD(r]) and the surrogate estimate A A ~ - A~ - A P of the equilibrium Helmholtz free energy difference can be expressed in terms of gD(z). Evaluating gP(z) and gS(z) with the RDT theory leads to parabolic precursor and successor free energy profiles
F~:(V) = --U ~E ( ~ - v~ )2 FS(r/) = A F ~ + T~E (77 - r / ~ )2 ,
(11~) (llb)
where A F E = A E + AAE. These equations correspond to a particular choice for the dimensional parameter 0. Both profiles have the same curvature ~E which, in view of the effective linearity of the theory, is related as ~ z = (2AE) -1 to the surrogate estimate A,F of the solvent contribution to the reorganization energy. The theory gives detailed expressions for AA,F and AE in terms of solute-solvent and solvent-solvent sitesite correlation functions that can be calculated under the RISM-HNC approximation. 2 To illustrate this theory we calculate the diabatic free energy profiles FP(rl) and F~(r/) of a complex donor-acceptor solute in two solvents of different polarity. We also examine the dependence on the charge distribution of the S state. The aniline-like solute molecule comprises seven interaction sites, which are labeled as in the scheme below.
All seven sites have the same LJ parameters: a =3.75/~ and e/kB =55.36K, while all of the bond lengths are 1.4/~,. The interaction site 1 and the 6-membered ring are, respectively, the donor and acceptor groups. In the P state the partial charge at the donor site is QP = - 0 . 2 e , while the acceptor charge is locMized at the interaction site 2, Q2P = 0.2e; the charges at the remaining acceptor sites are zero. We consider two electronic transitions that differ in the succesor states, S~ and SH, reached. The two transitions are generated by transfer of charge from the donor to the acceptor sites. The transferred charge is distributed among the acceptor sites according to the unoccupied molecular orbitals e2ul (state S~) and e2u2 (state Su) of benzene. Thus in S~ the donor charge is Q] = 0.5 e, while the charges at the acceptor sites are Q~ = Q~ = 0, and Q~ = Q~I = Q~ = Q~r = - Q ~ / 4 . In state S,, Q~ = 0.5 e, while the acceptor charges are Q~m = Q~ = -V]~/3, and Q"=3 (~1i = Q~ = Qp = -Q~'/12. In Figure 2 we show the P and S free energy profiles for the transitions P ~ S~ and P ~ S~x in acetonitrile. Figure 3 shows the corresponding results in benzene. The ISM models of Edwards et al.7 and Jorgensen and Severance 8 were used to represent the
solvents. The necessary corrections for electronic polarizability of the solvent are also taken into account. 6 Also we have taken A E - 0, so that the vacuum contribution still needs to be added to the profiles in the figures. 10
l
'
i
,, \
\
1'//
_
FEP
-2 -4
m
t
-6 -30
-20
~
-10
i
J
0
10
r/
29
Figure 2: Free energy profiles [Eqs. (11)] in acetonitrile as functions of the reaction coordinate. Solid lines: P --. S~ transition; dashed lines: P ---. S~ transition. FD(r/) and 7/ are in units of kcal mo1-1 . Both figures illustrate the difference between the free energy profiles of the P - . S~ and P ~ Sx~ transitions, signaling the dependence of AA L, and of the reorganization energy ~ v (different curvature) on the P and S charge distributions of the solute molecule. This sensitivity of ,kZ' with the solute charge distribution is only rarely invoked in the analysis of experimental results. Another point of interest is the location of the minimum of the F~(r/) profiles in the two solvents, connected with the different solvatochromic shift of the P --, S transitions in acetonitrile and benzene, s Also of special relevance is the finite curvature of the free energy profiles in benzene (Figure 3), which indicates, in line with experiment, that the solvent reorganization energy is sizeable in this solvent. This is in marked contrast with the conclusion from the naive application of the conventional dielectric cavity theory (based on local electrostatics), that predicts negligible solvent reorganization energy in benzene. We conclude noting that by representing the solute and solvent with ISM models, the RDT theory and its extensions s appear capable of describing the equilibrium and nonequilibrium solvation effects in charge transfer reactions in solvents covering a wide range of polarity, including non-dipolar ("multipolar") solvents comprising molecules without permanent dipole moment. A more complete report on the solvent effects on the energetics of non-adiabatic electron transfer reactions will be presented elsewhere. 6
14
-~ \
\
_l,
l
I
,, ', i
~l
\l
f
\, V,I
/
:
I:
:: !
FS V~,
i i
............... \ - " , .................... " W .
-1 -2
""-',.2---_=/ -8
J
-6
I
1
i
1
-4
-2
0
2 77 4
Figure 3: Same as Figure 2, but in benzene. Acknowledgment. F. O. R. gratefully acknowledges a fellowship from the Consejo Nacional de InvestigacionesCientfficasy Tdcnicas (CONICET) de la Repdblica Argentina. This work was made possible by the support provided by the National Science Foundation of the U.S. under Grant No. CHE-9321963 (Stony Brook) and by the Division of Chemical Sciences, Officeof Basic Energy Sciences of the U.S. Department of Energy under contract DE-ACO2-76CH00016 (Brookhaven Natl. Lab.) References
1. a) B. Bagchi, Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 40, 115 (1989); b) P. F. Barbara and W. Jarzeba, Adv. Photochem. 15, 1 (1990); c) M. Maroncelli, J. Mol. Liquids, 57, 1 (1993); d) S. Roy and B. Bagchi, J. Chem. Phys. 101, 4150 (1994); e) N. Nandi, S. Roy, and B. Bagchi, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 1390 (1995). 2. a) F. O. Rained, H. Resat, B.-C. Perng, F. Hirata, and H. L. Friedman, J. Chem. Phys. 100, 1477 (1994); b) F. O. Raineri, B.-C. Perng, and H. L. Friedman, Chem. Phys. 183, 187 (1994); c) H. L. Friedman, B.-C. Perng, H. Resat, and F. O. Ra~neri, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 6, A131 (1994); d) H. Resat, F. O. Rained, B.-C. Perng and H. L. Friedman, in Hydrogen-Bond Networks, edited by M.-C. Bellissent-Funeland J. C. Dore; NATO-ARW series, (Kluwer, Dordretch, 1994); e) H. L. Friedman, F. O. Raineri, F. Hirata, and B.-C. Perng, J. Statistical Phys. 78, 239 (1995). 3. D. Chandler and H. C. Andersen, J. Chem. Phys. 57, 1930 (1972). 4. M. Maroncelli and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 89, 5044 (1988). 5. H. Resat, F. O. Ra.~neri, and H. L. Friedman, J. Chem. Phys. 98, 7277 (1993). 6. B.-C. Perng, M. D. Newton, F. O. Raineri, and H. L. Friedman, to be submitted. 7. D. M. F. Edwards, P. A. Madden, and I. R. McDonald, Mol. Phys. 51, 1151 (1984). 8. W. L. Jorgensen and D. L. Severance, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 112, 4768 (1990).
journal of
MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of MolecularLiquids,65166(1995) 15-22
An Interaction-Site Representation of the Dynamic Structure Factor of Liquid and the Solvation Dynamics Fumio Hiratal), T. Munakata2), F. Raineri3), and H.L. Friedman 3) 1) Detmrtment of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Kyoto University, Kyoto 606, Japan 2) Department of Applied Mathematics and Physics, Faculty of Engineering, Kyoto University, Kyoto 606, Japan 3) Department of Chemistry, State University of New York at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, New York 11794-3400 Abstract A recent development in the theory for the dynamics structure factor of molecular liquids, which employs the interaction-site model, is outlined. The theory is applied for a description of the solvation dynamics associated with a p h o ~ x c i t a t i o n of a molecule in polar liquid. Preliminary results of the solvation time correlation functions for an atomic molecule in a variety of solvents are presented.
L Introduction The space-time density fluctuations in polar liquid and their coupling with a variety of chemical processes have attracted much attention in recent years. The photo-induced electronic excitation of a solute and the thermal electron transfer reaction are among most well studied examples in such chemical processes. 1 In this brief note, we report our recent effort to build theoretical tools for investigating such phenomena based on the integral equation method in the statistical mechanics of liquids.2-5 For a microscopic description of solvent dynamics, it is necessary to specify a model of solvent molecules. The traditional model for such description is the electric multipoles located at center of a hard-sphere. Such model leads to a rot-translational description of a rigid body typically represented by a Debye-Fick type diffusion equation. Another representation for a solvent molecule is the interaction site model (ISM) which leads to a correlated atomic diffusion model. In that model, the solvent dynamics is described as a correlated translational diffusion of each atom: correlated in terms of not only intermolecular force but also intra-molecular constraints. We have been developing an interaction-site representation for the solvent dynamics based on the generalized Langevin equation (GLE) 6 combined with the RISM equation which describes the static structure of molecular liquids in terms of the positional correlation between a pair of interaction sites. 7,s The GLE theory provides a systematic way of projecting degrees of freedom which are less interesting onto few dynamic variables of interest. It is therefore essential for the theory to choose proper dynamic variables on which other degrees of freedom are projected. Two different choices for the collective variables have been examined: the polarization charge density and the site-number density. The p o l ~ o n charge density representation naUuaHy leads to a dielectric description of the liquids, while the site-number density representation gives a description for the atomic diffusion. It is worthwhile to persue the site-number density representation since it has prospect for developing the desoiption of the solvent dynamics from more fundamental level including translational motion. The relation between the two representations has been clarified in the earlier work. 5 Here, we just concentrate on the sitenumber density formalism. The paper is organized as follows. In the following section, the site-site Smoluchowsky -Vlasov equation for the solvent dynamics is briefly discussed. In section HI, a preliminary results for the solvation dynamics of an ion in a variety of solvent is presented. II. Dynamics of Solvent - Site-Site Smoluchowsky-Vlasov (SSSV) Equation .3 We chose the local density (~SPcx)and the momentum density (Aa) of atoms as the dynamic variables: 0167-7322/95/$09.50 ~" 1995 ElsevierScience B.V. All rights reserved. SSD! 0167-7322(95) 00840-3
Aa(r,t)= ~p~(r-
r~)
(2)
where a and M specify atoms and molecules, respectively. Then the standard treatment by GLE leads to a continuity equation and an equation of motion for atoms: ~p(r,t) = -m _tV -A(r,t) (3)
OA(r,t) Ot
Ot
t
kBTVOf O(rr
o
- r ) * A(r)dr + m-~F(t)
(4)
where ~(r,r') is the inverse density correlation matrix defined by ~(r,r')=~Sp(r)~p(r')> -1, K(t) and F(0 are the friction kernel and the random force, respectively. In the derivation, the equal time correlations of momentum between intra-molecular atom pairs are neglected. The inverse density correlation matrix can be calculated in terms of the RISM theory of liquid, r [~0(k)! -l -c(k) (5) where t0(k) and c(k) are the Fourier transforms of the intra-molecular and direct correlation matrices, respectively. Neglecting the inertia term and solving Eqs. (3) and (4) for ~0, we get a diffusion equation in the Markov limit, which we call 'site-site Smoluchowsky-Vlasov equation,' since it is a Smoluchowsky-type diffusion equation for atoms (sites) with a Vlasovtype mean field term expressed by the RISM direct correlation matrix.
c~p(kd) Ot
_k2/](k) O(i~k)~p(k ,t),
(6)
where D(k) is the diffusion constant matrix. The Smoluchowsky-Vlasov type equation for molecular liquids can be derived9 also by combining the dynamic density fimctional theory developed for multicomponent simple liquids 10 with the flee-energy density-functional for molecular liquids developed by Chandler and coworkers, l I The derivation begins with the two hydrodynmnic equations similar to Eqs. (3) and (4) but with a genemliz~ force field - p(r,t) VSF/~p(r,t) in place of the first term in Eq. (4), where FIp(r)] is a density functional of an atom (or a site) and ~/~P signifies the functional derivative with respect to the density field. Up to the first order in the Taylor expansion with respect to the density field, the free energy functional for the ISM liquid can be written as, F[O]- Z f d r p ~ ( r ) { l n o ~ ( r ) - l } __1 Zfdrfdr,~o~(r)C~u~,.(~r_rl)~Ovu(e)
2 a,v where CaMvM'(Ir-fl) is the direct correlation function defined by -I
I
Cojlvu.(r)-c~.(r)+?~uuO~ {/-to(r)- }
(7) (8)
It can be easily shown that the functional derivative 8F/Spa leads to the first term in Eq. (4). Dynamic Structure F a c t o r T h e (intermediate) dynamic structure factor (DSF) is defined by F(k,0= <Sp(-k,0)Sp(k,0>/N, which describes the time evolution of the spacial correlation of an atom (self) and a pair of atoms (distinct). Multiplying F-~I.(6) by ~p(-k,0) and taking ensemble average, we have the diffusion equation for F(k,t), -
0F(k,t) = _ k 2 D(k) pdp(k)F(k,t) (9) (gt Taking the Fourier-Laplace transform of Eq. (9), the dynamic structure factor can be obtained
as, S(k,s) =[st+ kZD(k){co(k) -l - oc(k) } ~ ~F(k,t =0)
(10)
where I denotes the n-by-n unit matrix. Eq. (1 0) can be inversely transformed to give, F(k,t) ffi L(k,t)F(k, tffiO) where L(k,0 is defined by, 1
"
L( k,t) ffi - ~ t _ ~ .
+ A(k) l-i e*'ds
(11) (12)
and A(k) is defined as, A(k)--- k 2D(k)[to(k) -' - pc(k)]. The integral in Eq. (12) can be performed to lead for the (a,l~)-element of the matrix L, ~j (-1)p+a A ~ (sj)e*/ L~ = .
H,i.j)(s~ = s , )
(13) '
where {si} are the eigen values of the matrix sI+A, and A(xl3denotes the minor of the (a,l~)element of the determinant IIsI+AII.It is worthwhile to note that Fcttl(k,t) is a superposition of a number of exponentials with different time constants. In the following section, we will observe some interesting consequence of the multiexponential behavior of solvent dynamics, which is manifested in the solvation dynamics of ions. 1 0"9l~
0.8 ~ 0.7 ~i\ 0.6i ~ o.4i
Co)
o.~ ~
",,.',, <'-,,
0.5 1~ ~
....... ~
..................................................................
(c) 0.5 1 ~
"
~
......... ~ ' ~ " : ......... ; ......... : " ' " - = .........
~s
Fig. 2. 7-(0 for Cl ~:)r process. Solvents:H20 (~); MeOH (~); MeCl (...); MeCN(-.-)
(d) 0..5 ~ ~ . . . . .
..........
|
o
0,
. . . . . . .
~
~
-21 -4!
(e) -8! ~c.w ...................... ,. . . . . . . . . .
~"~= -10: -12 -14
00 0.5
1 1.5 2 2.5......5" 3:5 - 7{ 4.-5" " t
Fig. 1 Intermediate Structure Factor for the hydrogen atompair of water. Circles, MD simulation; solid lines, SSSV. (a) k=0.3374, (b) k=0.7545, (c) k=1.0670, (d) k=1.3913, (e) k=1.8171, (f) k=2.33860.
-16 -18 -2C
f0 t's 20 2'5 3'0 3'5 4'0 4's t/ps
Fig. 3. lnZ(t) for CI ~>CI- process. Solvents:H20 (--); MeOH (~); MeCI (...); MeCN(-.-)
As an example of the solvent dynamics calculated from SSSV, F(k,t) for the SPC model of water is shown in Fig. l, compared with the simulation results. Only those for the H-H pair are shown for the different values of k. The simulation results were obtained from the 200 ps trajectory for a system of 216 water molecules by directly taking the average, 12
where the subscripts M,M' label molecules in the system. Due to the finite box size used in the simulation, the least value of k is 0.3374 A -l. The diffusion constant from the MD simulation, D1~3.9"10 -5 cm2/sec, is used as an input parameter for D(k)(=6apDr) in Eq.(9), which the single particle Ix~slational motion of water. III. Soivation Dynamics -site n u m b e r density representation- 5 Here, we give a brief review of a method presented in the earlier paper to describe the solvation dynamics associated with the photo excitation of a molecule in polar liquids, which can be p r o l ~ by the time resolved Stokes shifts. 5 The quantity which relates the dynamics theory with the experiment is the solvation time correlation function (STCF) defined by,
~(t)- ~(oo) z(t) = r~(0)- ~(oo)
(~5)
where ~(t)=~(t)-<4E> is the solvation energy change at time t after the photo-excitation. By virtue of the fluctuation dissipation theorem, Eq. (15) can be written as,
z(t)- c l t ) , g~(t~(0))
(16)
c(0) g~(0)~(0))'
where the canonical ensemble average <---> is taken over the equilibrium solvent configurations. The solvation energy fluctuation ~(t) can be represented in terms of the solvent site-density fluctuation 5pT,j(k,t) as follows, 1
dk
with ~4~,j(k)=d~7,j(k)-4~,j(k), where ~, and j Slx~fy solute and solvent sites, respectively, and 4~u),j(k) and 4~7,j(k) denote a solute-solvent coupling in equilibrium before and after the photo excitation.
r
(21 ,I,n,f~ ~.(~,jfk.t,~.r(W))S4~,(-k)A,~.r(-g,.
(18)
The final equation for Z(t) can be obtained from F_qs. (16)-(18) after average over the solute orientation in <--->,
f dkk2~ JJFj:(k't)BjI(k ) Z(t) - f dld~jjSjj (k)Bjf(k) '
(19)
nj:(k) = ~ ~o~.(k)~j(k)~.j.(k)
(20)
where Fjj(k,t) is the dynamic structure factor of the homogeneous solvent, and Bjj(k) and Sjj,(k) are defined by following equations,
Sjz(k). Fg(k,t = 0) (21) The Sjj(k) can be calculated from the RISM equation and Fjj(k,t) from the SSSV equations descnl~ed in the previous section. The solute-solvent coupling ~D?,j(k) (D: p or s) which was left unspecified in Eq. (17) can be identified as the solute-solvent direct correlation functions from the requirement such that
the solvent density response to the perturbation at t--0 and t=oo should satisfy the corresponding RISM equation in the equilibrium, namely, t~(k) = -kT%(k) . (22) In another word, the solute-solvent coupling so defined satisfies proper boundary conditions at the initial and final equilibrium states. -solvation dynamics of an ionIn the previous paper, 5 we have given just a formalism of STCF for the site number density representation, which has been outlined above. In what follows, a very preliminary numerical results of STC~ for a CI~>CI- process is presented based on the theories described in the previous sections. The calculation has been carried out for a variety of polar liquid as solvent including methyl chloride (MeCI), acetonitdle 0VIeCN), methanol 0VleOI-I) and water. Methyl chloride and acetonitrile represent a class of simple aprotic dipolar liquids while water does those liquids which feature the extensive hydrogen-bond network. The alcohol shows characteristics in between those two classes of fiquids. The caladafion is performed at the room temperature (298 K) for all solvents except MeCl. For MeCl, its liquid temperature (249 K: 1 arm) is chosen. The Edward-McDonald (EM), SPC and TIPS models are chosen for MeCN, water and MeOH, respectively, 13-15 while the parmneters determined by Jorgensen et. al. is employed for MeCI. 16 Those models use the same functional form for the intermolecular sitesite interaction, namely
U~(r) = Z[4~
-
+ q"qa r
(23)
with the standard combining rules, where a and [~ denote sites on either solute or solvent molecules and e, a, q have usual meanings. We use a single parameter, a (translational) diffusion constant DT of an atom, in order to characteriz~ the solvent dynamics in the long time limit. We assign the same value, 3.9* l0 -5 cm2/sec, 3 to D r for all solvents examined. This is partly because the diffusion constants of those solvent are not largely different from each other and also because our main focus in the present study is on the effect of liquid structure on the solvation dynamics. The solvation time correlation functions defined by Eq. (15) and its logarithm are plotted in Figs. 2 and 3, respectively. As seen in the figures, all solvents examined show a multi-exponential decay. Methyl chloride and acetoniU'ile as well as water show esseatially a biexponential decay while methanol clearly exhibits a tri-exlxmential decay. The time constants of the decay can be obtained from the slope of straight lines which gives a best fit with the linear portion of In Z(t) curves. Those are listed in Table 1. Since we have employed the same value for the translational diffusion constant for solvent atoms, the large difference in the behavior of STCF among the solvents should have come thoroughly from the discrepancy in the solvent structure. Especially, the difference between the simple polar liquids and the hydrogen bonded liquids is striking. The results seem qualitatively in accord with the simulation result obtained by Maroncelli et. al., 17,1s in which acetonitrile shows a much slower decay compared to water in the solvation time correlation function. In what follows, we give brief discussions of the results for each solvent, although they are still very preliminary in quantitative sense. Simple Polar Liquid: Methyl Chloride and AcetonitrUe Acetonitrile shows a hiexponential decay. The first decay which is characterized with the time constant 0.15 ps can be attributed to the rot-translational relaxation of solvent molecules in the first solvation shelL The second decay with the time constant 34.6 ps corresponds to the structural reorganization beyond the first cxx~dination shell, which brings the solvation structure to the new equilibrium. There has been a simulation study carried out for acetonitrile by Maroncelli. The result exhibits a decay with a dual character:, a rapid initial decay with oscillations, which is characterized by ~ 1 ps decay time. The first quick component has been assigned by the author to the inertial decay which involves mostly the solvent molecules in the first coordination shell around the solute molecule. Although the present theory does not reproduce the Gaussian character of the
20 initial decay as well as the oscillation, it gives the similar time constant for the relaxation. This is because the initial part of the relaxation is dominated by the intermolecular interactions between solute and solvent as well as those among solvent molecules, which are taken into account in the present theory through the effective local field represented in terms of the direct correlation functions. The theory does not reproduce the Gaussian character and the oscillation, because the SSSV equation neglects the inertial term as well as the memory in the friction kernel. As to the second component of the decay, it is important to point out that Maroncelli's results show different behavior for the second part between the charging process ( S 0 - > S +) and the opposite process (S + >SO).While the second component begins after about 1/4 of the energy is relaxed in the S~ + process, it begins after almost 100 percent of the energy is relaxed in the S + E > S 0 process. Our current theory does not distinguish the two process due to the symmetric ~ of Eq. (19). Also noteworthy in the simulation result is that the nonequilibrium results in short time resemble the linear response results averaged over the equilibrium ensemble at the initial state, while those in later time come close to the linear response results at the final state. Our result shows closer resemblance to the linear response results sampled from the equilibrium ensemble prepared with SOthe neutral solute, which turns out to be similar to the non-equilibrium result for the S+E>SO process in overall behavior. This can be understood by considering the fact that our treatment uses the pure solvent dynamics at equilibrium although the solute pemtrbation is taken into aca~unt at the initial and the final states. The equilibrium ensemble prepared at the S O state has less perturbation to the solvent, and thereby it is closer to our theoretical model. Although the time constant for the second component of the S+-->S 0 process is not explicitly given in the literature, it would be much longer than - 1 ps, and would be closer to our result. Methyl chloride shows a similar hiexponential decay with acetonitrile with time constants, 0.21 and 82 ps. Methyl chloride shows the slower initial decay than acetonitrile despite of its less bulky strucUtre. This may be because the temperature of MeCI is significantly lower. Nonetheless, the general feature of the relaxation behavior for both solutes is almost identical in harmony with the simulation re$ults. 18 Water STCF for water features a bi-exponential behavior with very fast initial decay characteriz~ by the time constant 0.01 ps and a slow decay of time constant 36 ps. The fast decay can be assigned to the rotational relaxation of water molecules in the first coordination shell from their initial orientation to the final state in which the hydrogen atom points toward the chloride ion. The following slow decay can be attributed to the reorganization of water molecules in the second and further shells in order to adapt the new situation. A similar behavior in the initial decay has been found in the simulation study by Maroncelli and Flemingl7 except for the pronounced oscillation observed in the simulation. The oscillation is caused by a combination of the two factors, the inertial motion and restoring force due to the hydrogen-bonded structure. The theory does not reproduce the oscillation because it does not include the inertia term although it does take account for the hydrogen-bonded structure. 3 2.5
/
S 1.5
5 4
31 0..5
I
2
//'i
21 11
r
~
~
Fig.4(a) Solvent-sitedistributionaround CIwithout charge.CI-O (~); CI-Me (...);CI-H (--)
o.L
1
3
4
~
6
r
Fig.4(b) Solvent-site distribution around CI- ion. CI-O (--); CI-Me(...); CI-H (--)
Of more interest is the much faster decay compared to acetonitrile. A possible explanation for the phenomena is that water molecules are spherical in shape and thereby the friction due to collision is very small for the rotational motion. Recently, Nakahara and coworkers have measured the rotational diffusion rate of a single water molecule in a variety of solvent based on NMR relaxation time and have observed no-correlation between the rate and the viscosity of solvent. 19 Instead they have found a quite good correlation between the rate a n d the interaction between the solute (water) and solven~ The observation implies that as long as the rotational motion of water molecules is concerned friction due to the collision is less important. Methanol STCF for methanol is characterizedby a tri-exponential decay. Although fu~her study including the molecular dynamics simulation is required in order to clarify the detailed mechanism of each decay, we give here a speculative interpretation regarding a possible mechanism which gives rise to the tri-exponential decay. In Fig. 4, the radial distributions of atoms around chloride ion in equilibrium before and after the abrupt production of the charge on the solute are shown. Before the change, the solute is primarily coordinated either by the methyl group or by the oxygen site. After the change, the solute is predominantly coordinated by the hydrogen site. The first decay c h a r a c ~ by the time constant 0.03 ps is attributed to the initial rotation which brings the methyl group in the first coordination shell, which has a positive partial charge, into the intermediate position to form a weak Coulombic bond with C1-. This tm3cess will be quick because the solute was already well coordinated by the methyl group before the change. The solvent molecules in the first coordination shell further rotate to brmg the hydrogen atom into the final equilibrium position in which the hydrogen atom and the ion are 'bonded' by the strong electrostatic interaction. This process gives the second decay with the time constant 1.69 ps in the lnZ(t) plot- After the solvent molecules in the first coordination shell settled down in the final orientation, the molecules in the second and timber shells must be reorganized cooperatively to adapt themselves in the new equilibrium state. The prtx3ess will be very slow since it involves the relaxation of many molecules. The third decay characterized by the time constant 61.2 ps is assigned to that reorganization process. If the mechanism stated above is correct, the behavior should be different when the solute is a cation instead of an anion, because in that case, the primarily coordination site of the solvent after the abrupt change in charge state of the solute, is the oxygen atom. There is no such intermediate coordination structure as in the case of CI-. The behavior of lnZ(t) for Na + in fact shows essentially biexponential decay as shown in Fig.5. The different behavior in lnZ(t) between the CI-->CI- and Nam>Na + suggests that the multi-exponential behavior is caused not only by the solvent dynamics itself (Fjj'(k,t)) but also by the solute-solvent coupling represented by Bjj'(k) in Eq. (20). O
o%'I 0.15 T1
MeCI
MeCN MeOH Water
.
0.03 0.01
T2
T3
.0
34.6 1.69 36.3
.
.
.
,-6 ""
61.2
.
2
Table 1. Relaxation Times.
~= -10 - -12 ! -14~
.............
-16 -18
-2
~
lb 1'5 2'o 23 3'o 3'5 ~ 4'5 t/ps Fig. 5 in Z(t) for Na -->Na + and Clm>Clprocesses in MeOH; Cl, (m); Na, (--). Concluding R e m a r k s We have presented a method of describing the dynamics of liquids and the solvation dynamics based on the interaction-site model. The method has exhibited its ability to account for the diversity in the relaxation behavior of solvent, such as the multi-exvonential decay.
22 observed in the polar and hydrogen-bonded solvents. An important implication of the results is that the detailed microscopic description of solvent structure and the solute-solvent coupling is essential for studying the solvation dynamics. The results presented here are still preliminary in quantitative sense. The problem which can be easily recognized is the much faster initial decay in every case than what is observed in the experiments (or simulations). Two remedies for the problem are under investigation: (1) replacing the translational diffusion constant by more elaborated model for the single particle dynamics which explicitly includes the rigid body rotation, and (2) inclusion of the nonlinearity in the density field in the SSSV equation.
Acknowledgment Authors ate gateful to the refen~es for invaluable comments on the manuscript.
References 1. Dynamics and Mechanics of Photoinduced Electron Transfer and Related Phenomena, Proceedings of Yamada Conference XXIX, N. Mataga, eds., Elsevier Science Publication and Yamada Science Foundation, 1992. 2. F. O. Raineri, Y. Zhou, H. L. Friedman, Chem. Phys., 152, 201 (1991). 3. F. tFuma, J. Chem. Phys., 96, 4619 (1992). 4. F. O. Raineri, H. Resat, B-C Perng, F. Hirata and H. L. Friedman, J. Chem. Phys. 100. 1477-1491(1994). 5. H. L. Friedman, F. O. Raineri, F. Hirata and B-C Pemg, J. Star. Mech., 78, No 1/2, 239 (1995). 6. H. Mori, Prog. Theor. Phys., 33, 423 (1965). 7. D. Chandler and H. C. Andersen, J. Chem. Phys., 57, 1930 (1972). 8. F. Hirata and P. J. Rossky, Chem. Phys. Leg., 83, 329 (1981); F. Hirata, P. J. Rossky, and B. M. Pettitt, J. Chem. Phys., 78, 4133 (1983). 9. F. Hiram and T. Munakata, in preparation. 10. T. Munakata, J. Phys. Soc. Jptt, 58, 2434 (1989). 11. D. Chandler, J.D. McCoy and SJ. Singer, J. Chem. Phys., 85, 5971(1986); 85, 5977(1986). 12. S. Okazaki, Y. Miyamoto, and I. Okada, Phys. Rev., 1145, 2055 (1992). 13. B. Bigot, B. J. Costa-Cabral and J. L. Riv'~l, J. Chem. Phys., 83,3083 (1985). 14. D. M. Edwards, P. A. Madden, and I. R. McDonald, Mol. Phys., 1141 (1984). 15. H. J. C. Berendsen, J.P.M. Postma, W.F. van Gunsteren, and J. Hermans, in Intermolecular Forces, ed. B. Pullman (Reidel, Dordrecht, 1981). 16. W. L. Jorgensen, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 103, 335 (1981); J. Chandrasekhar, D. C. Sellmeyer, W. L. Jorgensen, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 106, 903 (1984). 17. M. MaronceUi and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys., 89, 5044 (1988). 18. M. Maroncelli, J. Chem. Phys., 94, 2084 (1991). 19. M. Nakahara and C. Wakai, Chem. Left., 809 (1992); J. Chem. Phys., 97,4413 (1992).
journal of
~IOLECULAR
LIQUIDS Journal of Molecular Liquids, 65/66 (1995) 23-30
ELSEVIER
The Interplay of Dielectric and Mechanical Relaxation in Soivation Dynamics Benjamin J. Schwartz and Peter J. Rossky Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry University of Texas at Austin Austin, TX 78712-1167 USA Abstract Quantum molecular dynamics simulations are used to explore the possible coupling between dielectric solvation, the response of the solvent to a change in charge distribution of the solute, and mechanical solvation, the response of the solvent to a change in solute size or shape. The hydrated electron is chosen as a solvation probe, due to its large increase in spatial extent upon photoexcitation and significant contraction in size upon non-adiabatic relaxation. The strong displacement of translational solvent modes upon excitation hampers the effectiveness of individual solvent molecule rotations in providing relaxation, decreasing the relative amplitude of the inertial response. Following non-adiabatic relaxation, solvent molecules can freely translate and reorient, leading to rapid, effective initial solvation. These results suggest that in many situations where solutes undergo changes in both charge distribution and size, solvation can become rate-limited by the relatively slow viscoelastic solvent response.
I. Introduction Whenever the electronic states of a solute are coupled strongly to the surrounding environment, the dynamics of the solvent can play a critical role in determining the fate of condensed phase chemical species. Indeed, solvent fluctuations define the reaction coordinate for electron transfer and many other types of chemical reactions, l This has prompted an explosion of recent interest in solvation dynamics: the study of the relaxation of the solvent following a sudden perturbation due to a change in the solute. 2 At the heart of the issue are the specific solvent motions that lead to relaxation. When the solvent rearranges to accommodate the change in the solute, are the motions of individual solvent molecules important or should the response be viewed as inherently collective? In polar solutions, are reorientational or translational motions of the solvent molecules more effective in lowering the energy of the perturbed solute? Are there different types of solvent responses to changes in solute charge distribution versus changes in solute size and shape? A great deal of progress has been made recently in answering these questions for dielectric relaxation, that is, the response of the solvent accompanying a change in charge distribution of the solute. 2 Theory predicts that the earliest time motions of the solvent relaxing th e perturbed solute are inertial in character. 3 This inertial relaxation has now been observed in many simulations and by experiment, which are approaching generally good agreement. 4 Simulations have established that this early time relaxation can be ascribed to individual molecular behavior, 5 and theoretical developments have linked these motions to an instantaneous normal mode description of the solvent. 6 Less well examined, however, are the molecular details for the solvent mechanical response, that is, 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. SSDi 0167-7322 (95) 00841-1
24 the relaxation of the solvent accompanying a change in solute size and/or shape. Transient hole-burning experiments using non-polar solutes have established that the mechanical relaxation of the solvent behaves in a manner qualitatively similar to the dielectric response. 7 Molecular dynamics simulations changing the dispersion interaction between the solute and the solvent also show similar behavior. 8 Since real chemical solutes undergo changes in both size and shape and charge distribution upon photoexcitation or chemical relaxation, it is imperative to study the potential interplay between these mechanical and dielectric solvent responses. In this paper, we present the results of quantum molecular dynamics simulations aimed at a preliminary exploration of the coupling between mechanical and dielectric solvation dynamics. We have chosen the hydrated electron as our solute probe, since the hydrated electron is known to undergo large changes in both size and shape and charge distribution upon photoexcitation, and since experimental results are available for direct comparison. We find that translational motions of the solvent are of key importance in accommodating the change in size of the solute, and that relaxation by solvent rotational motions may in fact be significantly altered by coupling to the mechanically-induced solvent translations. II. Methodology The non-adiabatic quantum simulation procedures 9 we employ have been well described previously in the literature, 10 so we describe them only briefly here. The model system consists of 200 classical SPC flexible water molecules, II and one quantum mechanical electron interacting with the water molecules via a pseudopotential. 12 The equations of motion were integrated using the Verlet algorithm with a 1 fs time step in the microcanonical ensemble, and the adiabatic eigenstates at each time step were calculated with an iterative and block Lanczos scheme. 9 Periodic boundary conditions were employed using a cubic simulation box of side 18.17/~ (water density 0.997 g/ml). Twenty configurations from a 35 ps ground state adiabatic trajectory, chosen to be on resonance with the laser bandwidth corresponding to the experiments, were selected as the starting points for non-adiabatic excited state trajectories, lo A corresponding set of trajectories was run in D20, with a model identical in all respects to the work described previously except that the mass of the H atom was changed from 1 to 2 amu, and preliminary results of the behavior in D20 are included here. III. Results Figure 1 presents the dynamical history of the 2 lowest adiabatic eigenstates of the hydrated electron for a typical trajectory. At times before t=0, the electron resides in its nearly spherical s-like ground state, with the first p-like excited state lying -2.2 eV to higher energies. Solvent fluctuations modulate the energies of these states, and the strength of the coupling is readily manifest in the large changes in energy (nearly an eV on time scales of tens of femtoseconds). Previous work has established that size and shape fluctuations of the solvent environment have different effects on the quantum energy levels. 13,14 Upon promotion to the first excited state, the electron grows in size by a factor o f - 2 along the axial lobes of the p-like wavefunction, but remains unchanged in diameter in the other two dimensions, l0 The surrounding solvent cavity takes on a peanut shape to accommodate this change, and the net result is that the energy of the unoccupied nodeless ground state is raised while the energy of the occupied p-like state remains mostly unchanged. The electron eventually makes a non-adiabatic transition back to the ground state (which happens near t=200 fs for the trajectory shown, before the excited state equilibrium is attained). After the transition, the eigenenergy of the s-like state rapidly drops so the ground state equilibrium energy gap is quickly recovered, and
0-
'
~-l~
-100
0
100
Time
200
300
400
(fs)
Figure 1. Adiabaticeigenstatesof the hydrated electron for a typical trajectory. Solid and dashed lines denote the ground and first excited states, respectively. Diamondsmark the occupied state. the electronic density quickly becomes localized in one half of the peanut shaped cavity, creating a void in the solvent. As discussed elsewhere, 10 the behavior of the quantum energy levels upon excitation is in good agreement with previous simulations using a different model of the hydrated electron, 15 and the rapid re-establishment of equilibrium following radiationless relaxation is consistent with older, adiabatic calculations. 14 Since the hydrated electron experiences a substantial change in charge distribution upon quantum transition, undergoes a large increase in spatial extent upon photoexcitation, and experiences a corresponding collapse in size upon non-adiabatic relaxation, it serves as an outstanding quantum mechanical probe of the coupling between the mechanical and dielectric solvent responses. To better understand the behavior of the quantum eigenstates following photoexcitation and non-adiabatic relaxation, we have computed non-equilibrium ensemble averages of the quantum energy levels, shown in Figure 2. The left panel shows the response of the adiabatic eigenstates following photoexcitation (the "up" ensemble average); it is an ensemble average that only includes configurations in which the electron still occupies the excited state. Thus, the data at early times contain contributions from all 20 trajectories, but the statistics get poorer at later times as electrons make the radiationless transition to the ground state and are removed from the ensemble. The data clearly show that following photoexcitation, the excited state energy remains essentially unchanged while the ground state energy is raised on two time scales: a rapid increase which takes place in the first 30 fs, and a slower response which takes several hundred femtoseconds. At equilibrium, it is apparent that the gap has decreased from its initial value o f - 2 . 2 eV to 0.5-0.6 eV. The fight-hand portion of Figure 2 shows the change in the quantum energy levels following the non-adiabatic transition (the "down" ensemble average); in constructing this average, we have defined t=0 to be the point at which the non-adiabatic transition occurs for each trajectory. This is a fairly unusual kind of ensemble average: many of the initial configurations start after radiationless transition from the equilibrated excited state, but some initial configurations result from excited state trajectories in which the solvation response is not yet complete (such as the -200 fs point shown in Figure 1). Since all the excited trajectories undergo non-adiabatic relaxation at some point, the traces presented here are averaged over all twenty runs, resulting in good statistics over the entire time period displayed. After radiationless decay over an average gap size of -0.6 eV, solvent relaxation rapidly lowers the energy of the occupied ground state, with most of the response completed within 25 fs. There is evidence for slower relaxation of the ground state on longer time scales, but any slower component of the response plays a much smaller role than that following photoexcitation. Like the upwards transition, the first electronic excited state undergoes little change in energy in response to non-adiabatic
26
.
>
@
@
m
-2
0
I t I I I 300 600 900 1200 0 50 100 150 200 250 Time After Ph0toexcitation (fs) Time After Non-Adiabatic Transition (fs)
Figure 2. Non-equilibriumensemble averages of the lowest 2 adiabatic eigenstates of the hydrated electron. Solid line denotes the ground state, dashed line the first excited state. The left panel shows the response of the energy levels following promotion via photoexcitation; the right panel shows the response following the radiationless transition to the ground state. See text for details. relaxation. Within a few hundred fs of the non-adiabatic transition, the equilibrium structure of the hydrated electron is already re-established, with the gap enlarging to its original value o f - 2 . 2 eV. This rapid evolution to equilibrium once the ground state becomes occupied is in agreement with both the results of previous calculations 15 and the observed dependence of the different elements of the calculated ultrafast transient spectroscopy compared to experiment. 16 One interesting feature of the downwards ensemble average lies in the smoothness of the traces present in the right-hand plot of Figure 2. The energy levels of the individual trajectories (cf. Fig. 1) fluctuate by - 1 eV on a rapid time scale due to coupling with various modes of the solvent. The fact that these large fluctuations are washed out in the ensemble average following relaxation to the ground state indicates that there is no preferred phase of a particular solvent motion that drives the non-adiabatic transition. If, for example, particular configurations of water molecules characterized by being at the turning point of a collective librational mode were more favorable for non-adiabatic relaxation, then some of the oscillations observed in the individual trajectories would add coherently and hence be enhanced in the ensemble average. The lack of large amplitude oscillations in the average indicate that no special water configurations are responsible for driving the non-adiabatic dynamics. It is also interesting to note the small recurrence in dae response between 25 and 30 fs after the downward transition. This oscillation is most likely due to an underdamped librational mode of the solvent, and has been observed in previous aqueous molecular dynamics simulations. 17 IV. D i s c u s s i o n
The effects of mechanical and dielectric solvent fluctuations on the quantum energy gap of a solute are described by the equilibrium solvent response function: C(t) = (~SU(0) 8U(t))/((~SU) 2 ) where U(t) is the value of the quantum gap at time t and 5U(t) = U ( t ) - (U) represents the deviation of the gap from its average value. For small
27 perturbations, the regression of fluctuations due to a non-equilibrium perturbation should decay in the same manner as those present in equilibrium. Thus, in the limit of linear response, the non-equilibrium correlation function S(t) = (U(t) - U(oo))/(U(O) - O(oo)) (1) where the overbar denotes a non-equilibrium average quantity, should be identical to the equilibrium response, C(t). We note that the typical time-dependent Stokes shift experiment which investigates the solvent dielectric response or the transient holeburning experiment used to explore mechanical solvation measure the non-equilibrium solvent response function S(t). Figure 3 presents a comparison of the non-equilibrium solvent response functions, Eq (I), for both the photoexcitation ("up") and non-adiabatic ("down") transitions (cf. Fig. 2). The two traces are markedly different: the inertial component for the downwards transition is faster and accounts for a much larger total percentage of the total solvation response than that following photoexcitation. The solvent molecular motions underlying the upwards dynamics have been explored in detail in previous work, where it was also determined that the solvent response falls within the linear regime, i~ Unfortunately, the relatively small amount of time the electron spends in the excited state prevents the calculation of the equilibrium excited state solvent response function due to poor statistics, leaving the matter of linear response for the downwards S(t) unresolved. Whether the radiationless transition obeys linear response or not, it is clear that the upward and downwards solvation response behave very differently, due in part to the very different equilibrium solvation structures of the ground and excited state species. Interestingly, the downwards S(t), with its much larger inertial component, resembles the aqueous solvation response computed in other simulation studies, 17 and bears a striking similarity to that recently determined in experimental work based on a combination of depolarized Raman and optical Kerr effect data. 18 While the difference in the upwards and downwards solvent responses presented in Figure 3 is striking, this is not the first time that variations in solvation dynamics for the same solvent have been observed. Experimental studies have shown differences in solvation response for different probe molecules in the same solvent.2 This is a direct indication that probe molecules which have different excited state charge distributions and different mechanical interactions with the solvent produce differing relaxation dynamics. Computersimulations have also observed differing solvation dynamics for the forward and reverse transitions of the sudden appearance of charge, indicative of a solutedependent solvent response.17 Moreover, theoretical work has shown that dielectric solvation dynamics is sensitive to the shape of a solute,19 and that solute size is intimately connected to viscoelastic relaxation.2~ It is these effects which are manifest in the
\
0
- - -
100 Time (fs)
Down
200
Figure 3. Photoexcitation (up) and non-adiabatic relaxation (down) solvent responses (Eq. 1)
28 difference between the upwards and downwards solvent responses for the hydrated electron. The size, shape and charge distribution of the electron change continuously (on the time scale of the solvent response) following photoexcitation, creating a situation where the solvent dynamics polarize the solute which then alters the solvent dynamics. The solvent response is determined by both the dynamically changing charge distribution and the mechanical forces of the growing electron pushing on the first solvent shell during its initial expansion. Upon the non-adiabatic relaxation, the electronic density quickly localizes to a shape about that of the final equilibrium ground state. The solvent response to this rapid change in charge distribution is also affected mechanically by the presence of the large void recently occupied by one lobe of the excited state electron. These microscopic differences in the upwards and downwards transitions have profound implications for the coupling of viscoelastic and dielectric solvation dynamics and the nature of the solvent response. Previous work examining dielectric solvation has ascribed the initial relaxation to rotational motions of individual solvent molecules (i.e., polar solvent molecules inertially reorient to create a more favorable dipole interaction with the new charge distribution of the solute). 4,5 The rapid expansion of the hydrated electron upon photoexcitation, however, displaces predominantly translational modes of the solvent. Water molecules in the first solvation shell are simply pushed back by the Pauli repulsion (mechanical) forces as the electron expands. Thus, much of the initial relaxation of the solvent is the launching of an acoustic wave following this sudden expansion of the solute: the relaxation is predominantly viscoelastic in character. There are three major pieces of evidence pointing towards the strong translational nature of the initial response. First, time-dependent pair distribution functions show large solvent molecule displacements relative to the solute center of mass on the inertial time scale. 10 Second, computed ultrafast transient spectroscopic traces show ringing at frequencies corresponding to intermolecular H-bond stretching and bending motions. 16 Finally, deuteration changes the time scale of the initial relaxation by < 10%, a value in accord with motion involving translation of an entire water molecule whose mass has increased from 18 to 20 amu (the corresponding change in moment of inertia if the initial dynamics were predominantly rotational in nature would be 2 !/2, resulting in a --40% increase in the inertial time scale). This isotope effect is illustrated in Figure 4. This idea of predominantly displacing translational solvent modes upon excitation leads to an appealing microscopic picture for the coupling of the mechanical and dielectric solvent response. Upon photoexcitation, the free energy will be lowered by both solvent molecule translations, accommodating the new solute size and shape, and solvent molecule rotations, creating favorable electrostatic interactions with the new
08 ~
1_ ~ x
H20
0.6
0.4? 0.2 0
I ~,, 50 100 T i m e (fs)
150
Figure 4. Solvent response following hydrated electron photoexcitation (Eq. 1) for H20 and I)20
29 solute charge distribution. With a continuously expanding solute like the newly excited hydrated electron, the effectiveness of rotational motions of solvent molecules in the first shell will be hindered due to the overwhelming Pauli repulsion forces driving these molecules translationally. This leads to a kind of "dielectric frustration", where the electrostatic relaxation accomplished through solvent rotations is rate-limited by the overall translational rearrangement which accompanies the viscoelastic relaxation. This idea has support in recent experimental work examining the solvent response of the polar solvent propylene carbonate to photoexcitation of a completely non-polar solute, stetrazine. 21 In this work, the solvent response function near room temperature, which is well fit by a simple analytic theory incorporating only viscoelastic relaxation, 20 is virtually identical to that observed using the polar dye molecule coumarin 152 as a probe. 22 This opens up the possibility that in the latter work, the dye molecule undergoes a change in size and shape as well as dipole moment, and that the observed dielectric solvent response is actually rate-limited by the mechanical relaxation, producing the remarkable agreement between the two very different experiments. The relatively small amplitude of the inertial component of the upwards solvent response may also be the result of this mechanical-dielectric solvation coupling. While the motion of the first shell molecules is inertial in the sense that the solvent-solvent forces play little role in the dynamics, the pressure on these molecules due to the expanding solute hinders their rotational motion. Thus, the decreased effectiveness of these initial ballistic motions can also explain the differences in inertial component amplitude observed in Figure 3 (40%) and in previous aqueous simulation work 17 (8090%) where only the charge but not the size of the solute was varied. The downward solvent response for the hydrated electron also fits nicely into this picture. The effective size of the ground state electron in one lobe of the excited state peanut-shaped cavity does not significantly change upon non-adiabatic collapse. Molecules in the first solvation shell along the lobe into which the electron localizes do not need to significantly translate to accommodate the newly formed ground state electron. Molecules along the newly vacant lobe can freely translate into the void unhindered, providing rapid solvation. This picture is in accord with the agreement between the downward S(t) and that determined experimentally from the Raman-OKE data; the Raman-OKE experiments are not sensitive to relaxation by solvent translations, and show this same type of dominant rapid inertial response. 18 V. Conclusions In summary, we have used quantum molecular dynamics simulations of the hydrated electron to investigate the coupling between the mechanical and dielectric solvent responses. The solvation dynamics following photoexcitation shows a strong degree of translational character, because the increase in size of the hydrated electron provides mechanical pressure on the first solvation shell. This mechanical displacement hampers the effectiveness of solvent molecule rotations in providing relaxation, and results in a smaller amplitude of the inertial response. Following non-adiabatic relaxation, molecules in the first solvation shell are either displaced very little, or can freely translate through the newly created void in the solvent, providing for rapid and highly effective solvation. These results suggest that there is strong interplay between the dielectric and mechanical solvent responses, and that in certain cases, "dielectric frustration" can occur in which dielectric relaxation may be altered or even rate-limited by the viscoelastic response of the solvent.
Acknowledgments This work was supported by the National Science Foundation. BJS thanks Dave Vanden Bout for many stimulating discussions. BJS gratefully acknowledges the support of a National Science Foundation Postdoctoral Fellowship in Chemistry, and the allocation of computational resources from the San Diego Supercomputing Center.
References 1. see, e . g . J . T . Hynes in Ultrafast Dynamics of Chemical Systems, edited by J. D. Simon, p. 345 (Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1994). 2. M. Maroncelli, J. Mol. Liq. 57, 1 (1993). 3. M. Maroncelli, P. V. Kumar, A. Papazyan, M. L. Horng, S. J. Rosenthal and G. R. Fleming, in Ultrafast Reaction Dynamics and Solvent Effects, edited by Y. Gauduel and P. J. Rossky, AIP Conf. Proc. 298, p. 310 (AIP Press, New York, 1994); E. A. Carter and J. T. Hynes, J. Chem. Phys. 94, 5961 (1991). 4. S.J. Rosenthal, X. Xie, M Du and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 95, 4715 (1991); R. Jimenez, G. R. Fleming, P. V. Kumar and M. Maroncelli, Nature, 369, 471 (1994). 5. see, e . g . M . Maroncelli, J. Chem. Phys. 94, 2084 (1991); L. Perera and M. L. Berkowitz, J. Chem. Phys. 96, 3092 (1992); Ibid. 97, 5253 (1992). 6. R.M. Stratt and M. Cho, J. Chem. Phys. 100, 6700 (1994). 7. J.T. Fourkas and M. Berg, J. Chem. Phys. 98, 7773 (1993); J. T. Fourkas, A. Benigno and M. Berg, J. Chem. Phys. 99, 8852 (1993). 8. J.G. Saven andJ. L. Skinner, J. Chem. Phys. 99, 4391 (1993). 9. F. A. Webster, P. J. Rossky and R. A. Friesner, Comput. Phys. Commun. 63, 494 (1991); F. A. Webster, E. T. Wang, P. J. Rossky and R. A. Friesner, J. Chem. Phys. 100, 4835 (1994). 10. B.J. Schwartz and P. J. Rossky, J. Chem. Phys. 101, 6902 (1994); Ibid., p. 6917. 11. K. Toukan and A. Rahman, Phys. Rev. B 31, 2643 (1985). 12. J. Schnitker and P. J. Rossky, J. Chem. Phys. 86, 3462 (1987). 13. B.J. Schwartz and P. J. Rossky, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 3282 (1994). 14 J. Schnitker and P. J. Rossky, J. Phys. Chem. 92, 4277 (1988). 15. R.B. Barnett, U. Landman and A. Nitzan, J. Chem. Phys. 90, 4413 (1989). 16. B. J. Schwartz and P. J. Rossky, J. Phys. Chem. 98, 4489 (1994); Y. Kimuar, J. C. Alfano, P. K. Walhout and P. F. Barbara, J. Phys. Chem. 98, 3450 (1994). 17. see, e.g., M. Maroncelli and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 89, 5044 (1988). 18. E. W. Castner Jr., Y. J. Chang, Y. C. Chu and G. E. Walrafen, J. Chem. Phys., in press; Y. J. Chang and E. W. Castner Jr., J. Chem. Phys. 99, 7289 (1993). 19. see, e.g.E.W. Castner Jr., G. R. Fleming and B. Bacghi, Chem. Phys. Lett. 143, 270 (1988). 20. M. Berg, Chem. Phys. Lett. 228, 317 (1994); B. Bagchi, J. Chem. Phys. 100, 6658 (1994). 21. J. Ma, D. Vanden Bout and M. Berg, private communication. 22. M. A. Kahlow, W. Jarzeba, T. J. Kang and P. F. Barbara, J. Chem. Phys. 90, 151 (1989).
journal o f
~IOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journ',d of Molecular Liquids, 65/66 (1995) 3 I--40
Fluctuating Charge Force Fields for Aqueous Solutions Steven W. Rick, Steven J. Stuart, Joel S. Bader, and B.J. B e r n e D e p a r t m e n t of C h e m i s t r y and Center for Biomolecular Simulation C o l u m b i a University, NY 10027
Abstract
A new molecular dynamics model in which the point charges on atomic sites are allowed to fluctuate in response to the environment has been developed in a previous work (J. Chem. Phys., 101:6151 (1994)). The model and its application to liquid water are briefly reviewed. Various properties of the model are calculated, with emphasis on the bonding characteristics. The water model is also used to investigate the aqueous solvation of formaldehyde.
1
Introduction
In simple molecular force fields the intramolecular electronic structure is often modeled by point charges fixed on well-defined sites in the molecular frame. The charges are constant and thus cannot respond to changing electrostatic fields which arise from movement of the atoms during the simulation. In reality, molecular electronic structure can be strongly influenced by the external environment. Charge induction effects are not pair-wise additive and improved models must go beyond pair potentials. A new simulation method in which the charges are responsive to environmental changes, presented in a recent paper[l], combines the electronegativity equalization (EE) method for determining atomic charges[2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7] and the extended Lagrangian method for treating fictitious degrees of freedom as dynamical variables [8, 9, 10, 11]. This approach treats charges on the molecular sites as dynamical variables by introducing fictitious kinetic energy terms and selfenergy terms for these charges into the Lagrangian for the system, along with Lagrange constraints ensuring electroneutrality. In this extended Lagrangian approach the charges are propagated according to Newtonian mechanics in a similar way to the atomic degrees of freedom. An application of this model to liquid water and comparisons to wen-known water potentials are given in P~ef. [1]. In this paper we briefly review the fluctuating charge method, and describe its application to both liquid water and a dilute aqueous solution of formaldehyde.
2
Dynamical Fluctuating Charge Models
In an isolated atom the energy of creating a partial charge, QA, can be expanded to second order
E(QA) = ~~
lr0
,a2
+ -~AA~A,
0167-7322/95/$09.50 r 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. SSDi 0167-7322 (95) 00842-X
(2.1)
32 where )~4 and J~4A are parameters dependent on the atom type. The parameter ~ is the Mulliken electronegativity of the isolated atom (per electronic charge lel) and J~4A is twice the atom's hardness. For a molecule, the polarization energy to create a set of partial charges is a sum of these atomic self-energies and intramolecular Coulomb interactions, Job(r), or E p~
1
Y~fr176 + "~Y~ Y]~ Qi~Qi/3Ja~(rio,iz)- E~p, cr
a
(2.2)
/3
rio,iZ is Iria - ri/31 and E~ p is the gas-phase energy of molecule i. The total energy for Nmoler molecules includes this polarization energy plus the usual Lennard-Jones and intermolecular
where
Coulomb terms,
The electronegativity per unit charge of atom A is given by XA = (OU/OQA). The charges, by the EE principle, are those for which the electronegativities are equal. This is equivalent to minimizing the energy subject to a charge neutrality constraint. Since the potential is quadratic in the charges, the minimization will lead to a set of coupled linear equations for the charge. The charges are not independent variables since there is a charge conservation constraint. In the following we constrain each molecule to be neutral, ~ a Qia = O. We treat the charges as independent and use the method of undetermined multipliers to enforce the constraint. T h e Lagrangian is then Nmolec N . . . .
Nmolec Natom
lrno§ + E i=1
c):l
E
i--1
Nmolec
1M'"O.~ - U({Q}, {r}) - E
~:1
i=1
Na.tom
~' E
Qi~,
(2.4)
o--1
where mo is the mass of atom c~ and Mio is a fictitious charge "mass", with units of energy • time 2/charge 2, and the ,~i are Lagrange multipliers. The nuclear degrees of freedom evolve according to Newton's equation and the set of charges evolve in time according to Mi.Qi,~
= _OU({Q}, {r}) _ )~i = -;~i,~ - ~ . OQi.
(2.5)
If the total charge of molecule i is a constant of the motion, then it can be shown that )q is the negative of the average electronegativity on molecule i. The force on the charge is simply the difference between the average electronegativity and the instantaneous electronegativity at that site. The charge mass, Mia, a fictitious quantity, should be chosen to be small enough to guarantee that the charges readjust very rapidly to changes in the nuclear degrees of freedom[l]. The Coulomb interaction, Ji/(r), for intramolecular pairs is taken to be the Coulomb overlap integral between Slater orbitals centered on each atomic site, with each orbital characterized by a principal quantum number, ni, and an exponent (i[6].
Table 1: Properties for potentials with the TIP4P geometry: the fixed-charge TIP4P and the flexible charge TIP4P-FQ models. Properties listed are the the gas-phase dipole moment, the dipole polarizabilities, c~ii (the y and z directions lie in the plane of the molecule, with the z-axis along the C2 axis), the energy of the dimer in its minimum energy configuration, the distance between oxygen atoms for the minimum dimer configuration, and properties of the liquid as indicated.
Gas-phase dipole moment (Debye)
~zz (h3) %~ (A 3) ~ (h 3)
TIP4P ~ 2.18
TIP4P- FQ 1.85
0 0 o
0.82
2.55 o
experimental 1.85c 1.468+0.003 d 1.5284-0.013 a 1.4154-0.013 d -5.44-0.7 9 2.98 e
Dimer energy (kcal/mole) -6.3 -4.5 Dimer O-O length (~) 2.75 2.92 Liquid state properties (7'=298 K, p=l.0 g/cm a) Energy (kcal/mole) -10.1 a -9.9 -9.9 a 0.0 b -0.16-1-0.03 0.0 Pressure (kbar) Dipole moment (Debye) 2.18 2.62 53+21 79-1-8 78~ ~0 1 1.5925=0.003 1.79g Diffusion constant(10 -9 m2/s) ' 3.6+0.2 ~ 1.9+0.1 2.30 h 1.44-0.2b 2.1-t-0.1 2.1 / r#M. (ps) 74-2b 84-2 8.274-0.02J To (ps)
a) Ref. [13], b) Ref. [14], c) Ref. [15], d) Ref. [16], e) Ref. [17], f) Ref. [181, g) Ref. [19], h)
l~ef. [20],i)Ref. [21],j)Ref. [22]
3
Results
P u r e w a t e r . The fluctuating-charge method (fluc-q) has been applied to two commonly used models of water[l], the simple point charge model (SPC)[12] and the 4-point transferable intermolecular potential model (TIP4P)[13]. Here we focus on the fluc-q version of the T I P 4 P model ( T I P 4 P - F Q ) . Systems of 256 TIP4P-FQ or TIP4P water molecules have been simulated in the NVE ensemble at an average temperature of 298 K and a density of 1 g/cm 3, using Ewald summation for the long-ranged interactions. For more detailed discussion of the model parametrization and simulation methodology, the reader is referred to our previous work[l]. The properties of the TIP4P and T I P 4 P - F Q models for the water monomer, water dimer, and liquid water are listed in Table 1. The T I P 4 P - F Q electrostatic parameters are chosen to give the correct gas phase dipole moment for the monomer. The dimer properties listed in Table 1 are the energy of the minimum energy configuration and the oxygen-oxygen distance of this configuration. Pair potentials, such as SPC and TIP4P, are parametrized to give the experimental liquid state energies and radial distribution functions and tend to overestimate the gas phase water dimer energy. The fluctuating charge potentials predict an oxygen-oxygen separation closer to the experimental value but underestimate the dimer energy.
34 We have calculated both static and dynamical properties of liquid water at a temperature 298 K and a density of 1 g/cm 3. The parameters for both fluc-q models are chosen to give a binding energy of-9.9 kcal/mol. This energy includes the self polarization energy, which is the difference between the self-energy in the liquid phase and the gas phase (see Eq. 2.2). The average self-polarization energy is 5.7 kcal/mol, which represents a large contribution to the total energy. Pair correlation functions give detailed information about the structure of the liquid. The TIP4P-FQ model gives pair correlation functions that are in good agreement with the neutron diffraction results of Soper and Phillips[23]. For details see Ref. [1]. The static dielectric constant, e0, is calculated from the fluctuations in M , the total dipole of the central simulation box, by (4~p~ eo = %0 + \ 3kT ]
( M ~ -- (___M)2] Nmolec J "
(3.1)
For the TIP4P-FQ model, a 1 ns simulation gave e0 = 79-/-8, in good agreement with experiment. This is consistent with earlier findings that models with a dipole moment of 2.6 D have a dielectric constant near 80[24, 14, 25]. The value obtained for the optical dielectric constant, coo, is 1.59, close to the experimental value of 1.79119], and is underestimated because the perpendicular polarizability, axx, is zero. The frequency dependent dielectric constant, e(w), for the TIP4P-FQ model is shown in Figure 1. The agreement with the experimental results[22, 26, 27] is very good. The close agreement in the low-frequency microwave range is due to the accurate T I P 4 P - F Q values of ~0 and the Debye relaxation time, rD (the exponential decay constant for the autocorrelation function of the total system dipole, M ) . The features at frequencies higher than 300 ps -1 are due to bond stretches and bends absent in the rigid geometry models used here. The highest frequency feature given by the TIP4P-FQ model is the librational mode, which shows a peak in e" at 130 ps -1. The experimental peak is at 90 ps-1127]. The feature at 25 ps -1 has been interpreted as a translational vibration of a water molecule in its cage of nearest neighbors[28], and is not present in the spectrum for non-polarizable water models such as TIP4P[18] or Matsuoka-Clementi-Yoshimine (MCY)[29]. As argued by Neumann, this translational motion will not change the system's dipole moment much for non-polarizable models, but for polarizable models, the translational motion will induce a change in the dipole moment[18]. Therefore this feature only exists in polarizable models. We have investigated the differences in bonding between the fluc-q and fixed-charge models by examining the distributions of pair energies, solvation energies, and residence times. In a molecular model with fixed charges, the pair energy Eij is easily defined as the sum of all pairwise interactions between molecules i and j. For many-body potentials, however, there is no unique definition of a pair energy; the sum of the pair energies Etj does not add up to the total system energy because the self-polarization energy is not included. There are several reasonable ways to distribute a molecule's polarization energy among the pairwise interactions in which it participates, each leading to a different definition of the pair energy. We have defined a normalized pair energy /~ij by including a portion of each participating molecule's polarization energy proportional to the strength of the pair energy,
E'i = E'.i +
Eij E~j AEyOl+ AZpOi. ~ k # i Eik ~kCj Ekj
(3.2)
This weighting reflects that the polarization energy varies as the magnitude of the induced dipole, and that large dipoles will be induced in pairs with strong interactions.
35 A distribution of pair energies is shown in Figure 2 for both TIP4P-FQ and TIP4P. The large peak centered near zero consists of the many distant, weakly interacting pairs in the liquid. The much smaller peak at low energies represents the strongly-bound close neighbors. A convenient definition of a hydrogen bond is any pair bound more strongly than the minimum in this distribution (-2.7 kcal/mol for TIP4P,-2.6 kcal/mol for TIP4P-FQ). Integrating up to this threshold gives 3.1 hydrogen bonds for both models. (Other authors have reported larger hydrogen bonding numbers, but used a different cutoff for the hydrogen bond energy[13].) The longer tail on the T I P 4 P - F Q distribution demonstrates the ability of fluc-q methods to allow for cooperativity in bonding; TIP4P water has a fixed lower limit of-6.2 kcal/mol on any pair interaction, while T I P 4 P - F Q waters have
100
10
~g'
1
t:
0.1
ir, il 0.01 0.01
-------L----
0.1
1
10
100
1000
w/ps -1 Figure 1: Real(top) and imaginary (bottom) parts of the frequency dependent dielectric constant for the TIP4P-FQ model (solid lines), compared to experiment (dotted lines).
36 no such restriction and can form much stronger bonds when other neighbors are oriented favorably. The average strength of a hydrogen bond for TIP4P-FQ waters is 4.38 kcal/mol, compared to 4.32 kcal/mol for TIP4P. Cooperativity can also hinder bonding, and will generally serve to broaden the bonding distribution. Although the high-energy (weakly bound) tail of the H-bond distribution is lost in the zero-energy peak, the broadening can also be seen in the total bonding energy between one molecule and the rest of the simulation cell (obtained by summing Eq. 3.2 over a single index). The distribution of these values is centered at -20 kcal/mot for both models (twice the solvation energy per molecule) but the widths differ. The full width at half-maximum is 8.2 kcal/mol for TIP4P, and 10.1 kcal/mol for TIP4P-FQ. Another way of examining the hydrogen bonding character of the liquid is to determine the first passage time of neighbors out of the first coordination shell, a sphere of radius equal to the first minimum in the oxygen-oxygen pair correlation function (3.3/~ for both T I P 4 P and TIP4P-FQ). A distribution of first-crossing times shows that the TIP4P-FQ molecules are more labile than TIP4P waters at times shorter than 0.3 ps, with a probability of escaping from the first shell increased by 8% over TIP4P waters. But at times between 0.5 and 4 ps, the TIP4P waters leave more readily, with an 18% higher escape probability. This suggests that the fluc-q waters are more fickle in forming hydrogen bonds, breaking away from unfavorable interactions more easily. But once a bond has been formed, it tends to last longer. After 4 ps, the number of molecules who have not left the first solvation shell decays exponentially, with the same decay constant for both models. A survival probability can also be defined by allowing for multiple recrossings[30], but this obscures the short-time behavior which illustrates an important difference between the two models.
i
I
!
i
1.4 1.2
if j
/
]
11
",,
,
',,
!
0.8
/ ',, 9 "", ....
II
I
I
iI ,,/
N(E)
0.6 0.4 0.2 J
0
-8
/I I
-6
!
-4
,
I
1
-2
0
2
4
E (kcal/mol)
Figure 2: Pair energy distributions for TIP4P (dashed line) and TIP4P-FQ (solid line).
37 In general, however, the flexible charge models have slower translational and rotational timescales than the fixed-charge models, primarily due to the stronger electrostatic interactions from the higher charges. The self-diffusion constant, D, is smaller than the fixed-charge models and closer to the experimental value (see Table 1). Rotational time constants for both molecular and system dipole reorientation (rNMR and rD) are also slower and in good agreement with experiment. F o r m a l d e h y d e . Fluctuating charge models for water can also provide insight regarding the structuraJ, energetic, and dynamic aspects of hydrogen bond formation between a water molecule and a solute. One expects that polarizable water molecules next to a solute molecule more polar than bulk water will have a dipole moment enhanced over the bulk value. We have studied the enhancement of the induced dipole on water molecules around a polar solute. As we will show below, the magnitude of the induced dipole on a water molecule next to a solute is strongly correlated with certain aspects of the solvation structure. The system we studied consisted of 209 TIP4P-FQ water molecules and one formaldehyde molecule in a cubic box 18.6/~ on a side. The formaldehyde solute was based on a model of Levy and coworkers [31, 32]. The rigid, planar formaldehyde molecule has a CO bond length of 1.184/~, a CH bond length of 1.093 ~, and an OCtt angle of 122.3 ~ The charges on 0, C, and tt are -0.577, 0.331, and 0.123 lel respectively; the Lennard-Jones a parameters are 2.85, 3.296, and 2.744 ~'; and the Lennard-Jones e parameters are 0.20, 0.12, and 0.01 kcal/mol. Standard combining rules were used to obtain the Lennard-Jones parameters for the interactions between formaldehyde sites and the oxygen site of TIP4P-FQ water. This model for formaldehyde yields a dipole moment of 3.9 D, which is 50% larger than the mean dipole moment of a TIP4P-FQ water molecule in bulk water. The results we present in Figure 3 are from a 20 ps run in the NVE ensemble with an average temperature of 300 K. In the top panel of Figure 3, the mean dipole moment of a water molecule is shown as a function of the distance between the water oxygen and the formaldehyde oxygen. Waters closer than 3 are seen to have a dipole moment enhanced over the bulk dipole moment by as much as 0.3 D. Past 4 ~, the water dipoles rapidly approach the value of 2.62 D characteristic of the bulk liquid. It is interesting to note the dip in the dipole moment of water molecules about 3/~ away from the formaldehyde molecule. Waters in this region are caught between the first and second solvation shell. These water molecules presumably lack the opportunity to form a strong hydrogen bond with either the formaldehyde or a neighboring water molecule. Consequently a smaller dipole moment is induced on these water molecules than the mean dipole induced on bulk water. The bottom panel of Figure 3 shows the strong angular correlations exhibited by water molecules between the first and second solvation shells. The cosine of the OHO angle formed by the formaldehyde oxygen and the H O of a water molecule is nearly 1 for water molecules closer than 3 /?k, indicative of a strong linear hydrogen bond. There is a precipitous drop at 3 /~, signaling the breaking of the hydrogen bond as the water molecule leaves the first solvation shell. Other angular correlations do not show nearly as sharp a jump between the first and second solvation shells. The dashed line, for instance, depicts the cosine of the angle made by the formaldehyde CO and a water oxygen. This angle tends to be more linear for waters closer to the formaldehyde, and angular correlation is lost slowly as the water moves away. The cosine of the angle between the symmetry axes of formaldehyde and water is shown in the dotted line. This angular correlation is also weak compared with the dramatic behavior of the OHO angle.
38
2.9
(,.,o>
I
I
I
I
I
2.8
(Debye) 2.7 2.6 2.5
2
0.75
0.5
(cos(0)) 0.25
i
i
i
i
i
i
i
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
5.5
I
I
I
I
I
I
~ "'""......
~
9
~
f
~
.'-..
QIIO '..'"'"....-......." - - . 7 - " = (
-0.25
f
~...
6
-
,, -.-.~.<---~ ......-. . . . . . . . " s"--,.s" " ~ ......
"
"'"
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
5
5.5
6
R (~,1 Figure 3: Dipole moments of TIP4P-FQ water molecules are shown with angular correlations with a formaldehyde solute. Top panel: The average dipole moment (p) of fluctuating charge water molecules is shown as a function of Roo, the distance from the water oxygen to the formaldehyde oxygen. B o t t o m panel: (cos(0)) for three different angles made between CH~O and H20 as a function of Roo. Solid line: O = O - HO angle for the H on 1~I20 closer to the O on CH70; Dashed line: 8 = CO - O angle; Dotted line: O = the angle between the C2v axes of CH~O (taken from C to O) and H20 (taken from the HH midpoint to O).
4
Conclusion
The fluctuating charge model, as applied to liquid water, was shown to be an effective method for treating polarization effects. The fluc-q method introduces no intermolecular interactions beyond those already present in fixed-charge models, and the propagation of the charges using extended Lagrangian methods increases the computational cost by only a modest amount (about 10%). In contrast, other methods which include polarizability to dipolar order introduce an additional interaction (the dipole-dipole interaction) which, together with solving for the induced dipole moments,
39 increases the CPU time by about a factor of 2 over fixed charge models[33, 34]. The electronic properties of the fluc-q water model are such that in the gas phase it gives the correct dipole moment and in the liquid phase the dielectric properties are well reproduced for a range of frequencies (see Figure 1). In addition, the fluc-q model gives good estimates for the liquid-state radial distribution functions and dynamical properties such as the diffusion constant and "rNMR (see Table 1). In comparison to fixed-charge models, average bonding properties appear to be no different under the fluctuating-charge model, but the charge flexibility and many-body character of the potential both help to broaden the distribution of bonding energies and encourage cooperative bonding behavior. In studies of formaldehyde solvation, we detect a strong correlation between the dipole induced on a water molecule and the presence of a linear hydrogen bond between the water and the solute. We are conducting ongoing studies of solvation dynamics to further characterize the relationship between electronic polarization, solvation structure, and solvation energetics. Other current work includes studies of the solvation of ions, using a Drude dispersion oscillator to model the ion polarizability, and of small organic molecules, examining the coupling of the molecular charge distribution to torsional bond rotation, to functional group substitution, and to the aqueous environment.
Acknowledgements This work was funded by a grant from the National Institutes of Health (GM 43340) and was done on the Thinking Machines CM-5 in the NIH Biotechnology Resource Center at Columbia University. SJS was supported by a National Defense Science and Engineering Graduate Fellowship (DAAL 03-91-G-0277).
References [1] S.W. Rick, S.J. Stuart, and B.J. Berne. J. Chem. Phys., 101:6141, (1994). [2] R.G. Parr and W. Yang. Density-Functional Theory o/Atoms and Molecules. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1989. [3] L. Do~en-Mi~ovid, D. Jeremid, and N.L. Allinger. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 105:1716, (1983). [4] W.J. Mortier, K. Van Genechten, and J. Gasteiger. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 107:829, (1985). [5] K.T. No, J.A. Grant, and H.A. Scheraga. J. Phys. Chem., 94:4732, (1990). [6] A.K.R.app~ and W.A. Goddard. J. Phys. Chem., 95:3358, (1991). [7] C.A. Reynolds, J.W. Essex, and W. G. Richards. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114:9075, (1993). [8] H.C. Andersen. J. Chem. Phys., 72:2384, (1980). [9] M. Parrinello and A. Rahman. Phys. Rev. Lett., 45:1196, (1980). [10] R. Car and M. Parrinello. Phys. Rev. Lett., 55:2471, (1985). [11] S. Nos6. Mol. Phys., 52:255, (1984). [12] H.J.C. Berendsen, J.P.M. Postma, W.F. von Gunsteren, and J. ttermans. Forces, page 331. edited by B. Pullman (/teidel, Dordrecht, Holland), 1981.
Interrnolecular
40 [13] W.L. Jorgensen, J. Chandrasekhar, J.D. Madura, R..W. Impey, and M.L. Klein. J. Chem. Phys., 79:926, 1983. [14] K. Watanabe and M.L. Klein. Chem. Phys., 131:157, (1989). [15] A.C. Shepard, Y. Beers, G.P. Klein, and L.S. Rothman. J. Chem. Phys., 59:2254, (1973). [16] W.F. Murphy. J. Phys. Chem., 67:5877, (1977). [17] J.A. Odutola and T.R. Dyke. J. Chem. Phys., 72:5062, (1980). [lS] M. Neumann. J. Chem. Phys., 85:1567, (1986). [19] A.D. Buckingham. Proc. R. Soc., 238:235, (1956). [20] K. Krynicki, C.D. Green and D,W. Sawyer. Discuss. Faraday Sot., 66:199, (1978). [21] J. Jonas, T. DeFries, and D.J. Wilber. J. Chem. Phys., 65:582, (1976). [22] U. Kaatze and V. Uhlendorf. Z. Phys. Chem. N.F., 126:151, (1981). [23] A.K. Soper and M.G. Phillips. Chem. Phys., 107:47, (1986). [24] S.L. Carnie and G.N. Patey. Mol. Phys., 47:1129, (1982). [25] M. Sprik. J. Chem. Phys., 95:6762, (1991). [26] M.N. Afsar and J.B. Hasted. J. Opt. Soc. Am., 67:902, (1977). [27] A.N. Rusk, D. Williams, and M.R.. Querry. J. Opt. Soc. Am., 61:895, (1971). [28] G.E. WaJrafen. Water-A Comprehensive Treatise, page Vol. 1. edited by F. Franks (Plenum, New York), 1972. [29] M. Neumann. J. Chem. Phys., 82:5663, (1985). [30] R. W. Impey, P.A. Madden, and I.R. McDonald. J. Chem. Phys., 87:5071, (1983). [31] J. T. Blair, K. Krogh-Jespersen, and R. M. Levy. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 111:6948, 1989. [32] R. M. Levy, D. B. Kitchen, J. T. Blair, and K. Krogh-Jespersen. J. Phys. Chem., 94:4470, 1990. [33] A. Wallqvist and B.J. Berne. J. Phys. Chem., 97:13841, (1993). [34] D. van Belle, M.P.G. Lippens, and S.J. Wodak. Mol. Phys., 77:239, (1992).
journal of
MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of MolecularLiquids, 65/66 (1995) 41-48
Soivation Dynamics of Dye Molecules in Polar Solvents Studied by Time Resolved Hole Burning Spectroscopy Katsura Nishiyama, Yasuaki Asano, Nobuhisa Hashimoto, and Tadashi Okada
Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Engineering Science and Research Center for Extreme Materials, Osaka University, Toyonaka, Osaka 560, Japan Abstract Tune resolved ground state hole spectra of cresyl violet in acetonitrile, methanol, and ethanol at room temperature have been measured in subpicosecond to picosecond time region. The time correlation function of the solvent relaxation expressed by the hole width was obtained. The main part of the correlation function decayed much slower compared with that of the reported correlation function observed in time dependent fluorescence Stokes shift. Some possible mechanisms are proposed for understanding of the time depencences of the spectral broadening under the condition with the distribution of the relaxation times in fluid solution based on the entropy term in the solvent orientation as well as the site dependent response of the solvent.
Introduction Absorption and fluorescence spectra of molecules in solution are broadened, in general, compared with those in gas phase because the energy of the molecule dissolved in solvent is fluctuating due to the orientational fluctuation of the surrounding solvent molecules. The fluctuational motion of the solvent plays an important role in chemical reactions in solution phase such as an electron transfer reaction, for example, where the energy fluctuation of the reactants caused by the solvent fluctuation is considered to be essential to realize the transition state of the reaction. In order to understand the dynamics of the solvent fluctuation, many experimental as well as theoretical efforts have been made intensively in the last decade. One of the most convenient methods to observe solvent reorganization relaxation processes within the excited state molecule is time resolved fluorescence spectroscopy. By using time resolved techniques a time dependent fluorescence peak shift, so called dynamic Stokes shift, has been dete~ed in nanosecond 1,2, picosecond3,4, and femtosecond5,6 time regions. Another method to observe solvent relaxation processes is time resolved absorption spectroscopy. This method is suitable for the observation of the ground state recovery of the solvent orientational distribution surrounding a solute molecule. We have performed picosecond time resolved absorption spectroscopy for organic dyes in alcoholic solution 7 and have shown the following results. The spectral shape of the difference spectrum before and after the excitation is expressed as the superposition of the absorption and fluorescence spectra detected under steady state condition when the solvent relaxation time is sufficiently short compared with the time resolution of the experimental equipment and the excited state lifetime. On the other hand, the spectrum in the viscous solvent at low temperature shows slightly sharp in initial and broadens its shape with time. Tune evolution of the ground state hole as well as fluorescence spectra initiated by a short pulse laser irradiation in solution has been conventionally explained in terms of the twodimensional configuration coordinate model by Kinoshita8. According to his theory, two adiabatic potential curves corresponding to the ground and excited states are assumed to have the same curvature but have the different potential minimum in the configuration coordinate, 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995 ElsevierScience B.V. All rights reserved. SSDI0167-7322 (95) 00843-8
42
mg(Q,q)
- a Q 2 + bq 2,
to(Q,q) - a(Q
(1)
- 00) 2 4- b(q
- q0) 2 + e',
(2) where Q and q are the coordinates which give the slow and fast relaxation processes, respectively. Qo and q, denote the positions of their energy minima, a and b are the curvatures of the two adiabatic potential curves. In this model, three relaxation processes are taken into account: the relaxation in the ground and excited states, nonadiabatic one between the two states, and time evolutions of their populations are treated as stochastic processes along their potential surfaces. Tinae resolved hole burning spectra (transient absorption spectra) are thus expressed as
lv.s(w,,w2,t) ~162 -{[AI+[BI+[C]I+[DI
(3)
with
[A] - f d ~ ( o ~ ) ~ - ' ( a '
- o '4p . 2--1/2 ) exp[-Am 2 / G 2 ] e x p [ - { A O O e - 0 , : p = A o ) / G 2 } 2 / { G 2
-- (:Ts4p.2 / O'2}], [B ] .. e - r,f d tog( to ),r - , ( 0, 4 _ o,p,,, _ 4 _ 2.-,,2 ) exp[-Ato z/0,2]exp[-{At02 + 2bq 2
+2aQo2 (l - P . ) -
[C1-
0,s2p.Ao3 / cr2}2 /{ G2 - 0.4_ s P . 2 /o"2}],
-(1/Z'o)flodVfdeog(eo)x-'(a'o':p.2) -112 exp[-A(,02 / 0,2 ]exP[-{A~02 -
-u~p. A~ / a~} ~/{o ~ - ~'p
~/ a~}]cxp[-t/~o
+ 2a02(p.1 - Pro)
],
where g(~o) is a normalized spectral function of the exciting fight pulse centered at an angular frequency of a~1, and oJ2 is that of the probe light. A ~ o - o J - e , AoJ2 - ~ 0 2 - e , E " E'+ a Qo2 + bq 2, 0,2 w 0,2s +0,f2 with 0,2.4aQ2okT and 0,f-4bq2okT where k Boltzmann constant and T absolute temperature, z"0 is a population decay time from the excited state to the ground state. /9=-" p,,(t) is a normalized correlation function of the fluctuation and p,,,l = p,, (t - z). Here the same fluctuations are assumed for the ground and excited states. The terms [A] and [B] come from a hole created in the ground state population and the population created in the excited state by the light irradiation, respectively. In this expression the time resolved fluorescence spectrum can be expressed as only the term [B]. The term [C] corresponds to the additional population created by the nonadiabatic decay from the excited state to the ground state, i.e., hole filling effect. For an early time after the excitation, the term [C] does not contribute to the hole spectrum, because the amount of the relaxed population from the excited state is small. The term [C] is important only when the solvent relaxation time is comparable to the excited state lifetime. In addition to the three terms described above, the absorption spectra from the lowest excited state to the higher excited states (Sn*-'S1 spectra) are overlapped as the term [D] in eq (3). When the solvent relaxation is fast enough compared with the time resolution of the experimental equipment and the excited state lifetime, by putting p,, ( t ) - 0 for t > 0, the spectral shapes given by the terms [A]+[C] and [B] are reduced to
[A]+[C]-exp[-t/Vo]~r-eexp[-Aoge/0,e]exp[-Ao92/2 0,2 ], [ B ] - e x p [ - t / v 0 ] 0 , -2 exp[-Aw 2/G2]exp[-(Ao92 + 2aQ 2 + 2 b q 2 ) 2 / G 2 ] ,
(4) (5)
apart from the unimportant factor. The spectral shapes corresponding to the term [A]+[C] and [B] are coincident with those of the stationary absorption and fluorescence spectra, respectively. Then the hole spectrum is expected to be expressed by the sum of the steady state
43 absorption and fluorescence spectra. Under this condition, we can obtain the term [D] in eq (3), the Sn~--S1 absorption spectrum of the solute molecule, subtracting [A]+[C] and [B] from the hole spectrum. According to eq (3) the time dependences of the hole spectrum on the excitation energy are as follows. When we excite the dye solution at the center of the absorption band, a hole is created around the peak of the ground state population, while an excited state population created by the light irradiation shows a considerable deviation from the energy minimum of the adiabatic potential curve. The subsequent relaxation process causes a time dependent shift in position for the excited state population, while the ground state hole only broadens with time. Consequently, the fluorescence spectrum shows a time shift. The transient absorption spectrum also shifts toward the low energy side with broadening. However, this shift is caused mainly by the time dependent shift of the excited state population. Contrary to this, the case where the excitation is chosen at the tail of the low energy side of the absorption band is completely different. In this case, a hole is created at the tail of the ground state population and then shifts gradually to the peak of the initial population, while in the excited state the population is created almost at the bottom of the potential curve and hence does not show the time dependent shift. Therefore, the shift of the hole spectrum is caused mainly by the time dependent shift in the ground state population, and the shift in this case occurs toward the higher energy side. It is well known that the fluctuational behavior of the solvent molecules is characterized by the normalized time correlation function of the fluctuation, p,, (t), which is expressed as a following equation using observed time resolved fluorescence spectra,
p.(t)- v[(t)- ~1(oo), ~ (0) - r (~)
(6)
where ~;r(0), vr(t), and ~;i(o0) denote the peak energy of the fluorescence spectrum at t
=
0,
t, and oo, respectively. Fluorescence Stokes shift, i.e., ~5.(0)- vi(t), is usually explained as the dielectric dispersion of the surrounding medium and interaction of the solute dipole with the reaction field, in which the energy shift in the fluorescence spectrum is proportional to the square of the difference of the dipole moments between the ground and excited states of the solute molecule. On the other hand, the spectral width is linearly related with the difference of the dipole moment under the assumption included in eqs (1) and (2). Then p,, (t) is expressed using spectral widths as,
[,~(t)'- _,~(o~),~1~9m (t) ~ , V ' ~ 2
--. C~'(00) 2
(7)
where &(t) is the half width of the spectrum at time t. In this paper we investigate the time dependent ground state hole spectrum of cresyl violet in polar solvents by means of subpicosecond transient absorption spectroscopy. The time correlation function expressed by eq (7) showed large difference in time profiles compared with the reported one expressed by eq (6). Possible mechanisms will be discussed.
Experimental Time resolved hole burning spectra were measured by means of a femtosecond transient absorption spectrometer system. A second harmonics of a mode locked cw Nd 3+:YAG laser (Quantronix, 82MHz) was used for a pumping source. A synchronously pumped rhodamine 6G dye laser with a saturable absorber dye jet (DODCI/DQOCI) and dispersion compensating prisms in the cavity was used. The output of the dye laser (100fs fwhm, 600pJ/pulse) was
44 amplified up to ca. 400 p J/pulse by 4-stage dye amplifier excited by a regenerative YAG amplifier (Continuum) with 50Hz. The optical arrangement of the spectrometer is illustrated in Fig. 1. The amplified laser pulse was divided into two by a beam splitter; one was used as a pump pulse collimated to a 2mm sample cell, the other was focused into a quartz cell containing I)20 to produce a continuum probe pulse which was used for the absorption measurement employing the combination of a spectrograph and a multichannel photodiode array. A small part of the probe pulse was used as a reference employing another spectrograph/detector combination. The time resolution of this system was about 150fs. Dispersion effect of the probe pulse was corrected automatically using calibration table obtained from the measurements of a cross-correlation between pump pulse and continuum probe pulse or of a rise curve at each wavelength of a broad band Sn*--S 1 absorption spectrum such as chrysene and porphyrins. Cresyl violet (Exiton) was used as received. Spectrograde acetonitrile, methanol and ethanol were used without further purification. Two or three samples of each solvent with different dye concentration in the order of 10-5M were used for the measurements. No concentration effect on the time correlation function was observed. ,,
I
I~
H2
0
H2
cresyl violet
CPU
PC
^i.,
V, ~ j L P ~ ' f
s,.a.
\
M aS
M
I" O C ~ (DO)
]
"~:.-,.S..
,a f .......
~,
L .......
"
(c)
i
~'--'
E~L 7L
fromDyek'~. FIG. 1. The optical arrangement of the spectrometer. L:lens, BS:beam splitter, M:mirror, D:depolarizer, F:filter, PC:spectrograph, S:shutter, MCPD:multichannel photodiode array detector, CPU: computer,
Results
4OO
~) 6O0 wavelengthInm
700
FIG. 2. Steady state absoption and stimulated fluorescence spectra of cresyl violet in acetonitrile (a), methanol (b), and ethanol (c) at room temperature. Exciting wavelength is indicated by the arrow.
and Discussion
Normalized steady state absorption and stimulated fluorescence spectra of cresyl violet in polar solvents are shown in Fig. 2. Stimulated spectra were calculated from the fluorescence spectra divided by the square of the wavenumber. Exciting wavelengths in each solvent used for the measurements are also indicated in the figure by arrows. Mirror image relation between
45 absorption and fluorescence specWa was observed in each solvent and the amounts of Stokes shift were about 800em "1 in acetonitrile and methanol, and 700crn -1 in ethanol, indicating that the difference of the dipole moment of cresyl violet between the ground and fluorescent states is rather small, and that the equal curvature of their potential curves assumed in the model discussed in the previous chapter may be acceptable in this system. The exciting wavelengths used here correspond to the 0-0 transition of the molecule according to the literature9.
9
9
9
9
9
9
",...
(2 4ee
,~e
9 see
sse
~/
9 .;
O#
4) 6ee
6~
"tee
Toe
~e
o
0
.....
5
. . . .
,
10'
'
t i m e / ps
wavelength / rn
FIG. 3. Estimation of the Sn<--S1 absorption spectrum of cresyl violet in ethanol. 1: observed spectnnn at 166ps, 2: steady state absorption spectrum; 3: stimulated fluorescence spectrum; 4: superposition of absorption and stimulated fluorescence spectra; 5: the Sn<--S1 absorption spectrum.
FIG. 4. Time dependence of the absorbance of the Sn<-- S1 absorption at 500nm in methanol.
To obtain the Sn*--S1 absorption spectrum, the transient absorption spectrum (the difference of the absorbance with and without the excitation) detected at sufficiently long delay time after the excitation, when the solvent reorientation is considered to reach thermal equilibrium, was used. In Fig. 3, Sn*--S1 absorption spectra of cresyl violet in ethanol is indicated by a solid line (5) together with the transient spectra detected at 166ps after the laser excitation (curve 1), terms [A] and [B] in eq (3) at the steady states (curves 2 and 3, respectively), and [A]+[B] (curve 4). The contribution from the term [C] is negligible in this case, because the fluorescence life time of cresyl violet is in nanosecond time domain. The obtained absorbance of the Sn*--$1 spectrum rises with the response function of the detecting system and then decays with the fluorescence life time as indicated in Fig. 4. Transient absorption spectra in acetonitrile and ethanol are shown in Fig. 5. The spectra observed at shorter delay time than 100fs after the excitation are omitted here due to the contribution of the coherent coupling of the excitation and the probe light pulses. The spectra obtained in methanol were similar to those detected in ethanol. The peak shift of the spectra in acetonitrile could not be detected after the delay time longer than 100fs, while in the case of ethanol solution the red shift of a few nm in hundreds of femtosecond time region was observed, which was ascribed to fluorescence Stokes shift due to the excitation at the peak position of the absorption band as described previously. It should be noted here that the spectral broadening was observed until much longer time after the peak shift, although the time dependence of the spectral broadening and the peak shift should be consistent with each other under the assumption in eq (3). The ground state hole spectrum, the term [A] in eq (3), was obtained by subtracting the contributions from the term [B] and the Sn*'-S1 spectrum from the observed time resolved spectra shown in Fig. 5. The contribution from the Sn*---S1 absorption spectrum at each time
46 was corrected using the time dependence of its absorbance in each solvent. It was difficult in our present system to measure the time dependent fluorescence spectra with same time and energy resolutions as the transient absorption spectra. Therefore, we adopted the half width at the half maximum (hwhm) at the shorter wavelengths side of the spectrum without correction of the term [B] as a ground state hole width. The estimated error under this approximation was less than 8%.
(1)
(2)
O.2ps ._>.
0.4ps
0.2ps ~"
0.4ps
0 0 tin L_ 0 m ..I:3 m
I
400
I
I
I
500 600 700 w a v e l e n g t h / nm
I
800
( 400
I
I
I
500 600 700 w a v e l e n g t h / nm
I
800
FIG. 5. Time resolved hole burning spectra in acetonitrile (1) and ethanol (2) at room temperature. The time evolutions of the ground state hole widths in acetonitrile (1) and methanol (2) solutions are plotted in Fig. 6. The hole widths broadened up to 200-300cm "1 in the instrumental response time of the system in the all solvents used here. The band width of the fluorescence spectrum of cresyl violet in methanol/ethanol mixed glass solvent at 77K was also observed as about 300cm -1 hwhm. The rapid relaxation within the response time observed in the hole spectrum as well as the relaxation m 77K glass may correspond to the relaxation due to the librational or inertial component of the solvent which was reported in the studies of dynamic Stokes shift in femtosecond region 5,6. Fig. 7 shows the time correlation functions of solvent fluctuation in accordance with eq (7) using the values plotted in Fig. 6. In this calculation we used o,(0)=30cm -1 as the spectral width of the exciting laser pulse and 1430cm -1, 1360crn "1 and 1250crn -1 for ~oo) in acetonitrile, methanol, and ethanol, respectively. In Fig. 7 the reported correlation functions obtained by the dynamic Stokes shift measurements of LDS750 in acetonitrile5 and 1aminonaphthalene in methanol 6 in accordance with eq (6) are also plotted by dashed lines. According to the literatures 5,6, the correlation function decayed more than 80% in acetonitrile in the first 200fs and about 60% in methanol in the first 500fs. The peak shift of the absorption spectra in the present work was completed in the fin'st lps in methanol and ethanol solutions as indicated in Fig. 5 (2). However, the peak shift in acetonitrile solution could not be observed in the time resolution of our system. It is obvious from above results that the major part of the energy relaxation due to the fast response of the solvent dynamics is taken place in a few
47
hundreds of femtosecond in acetonitrile and lps in methanol. The spectral band shape, however, seems to be controlled by much slower solvent dynamics as indicated in Fig. 7. 9
I
'
i
1.5 ..(1) ,r", |
E
0
,
i
I
==_11= . . . . = _ = . = . . : ~(oo'
..............
,
(2)9 ===
"7,
E
1
i
!
,
i
9
i
9 ,,
_
- ..............................
1
-f
9
=_..: ~(=)
|
03
Q
03
o 'N"
""
%,
0.5
0.5
/ ,
-, 0-:ill 1 ~.,..
9
/
i
i
0
0
I
,
0
I
i
i
20 time / ps
t i m e / ps
'
410
'
FIG. 6. Hole widths of cresyl violet as a function of time in acetonitrile (1) and in methanol (2). 1
, ~ 0
~
"
!
9
o
.
1
.,
mOO0 .
.
.
~
(1)
~"
.
~'
(2)
% ~
r 0.5
o o
",..
"'-..,.
o
o
o
0
"-.
0
"""-.
0 0
o
"' 0
o
o
\
0
. . . . .
Ooo o
', ;
...
.
o
o
t
.
o ". . . . . . . .1. . . time / ps
.. 2
c
~
. . . .
~
,f
. . . . o.
2~
10
30
s0
time / ps
FIG. 7. Normalized correlation functions obtained from the analysis of the hole width in acetonitrile (1) and methanol (2). Dashed curves are reported P,, (t) of LDS750 in acetonitrile 5 and 1-aminonaphtalene in methanol 6, see text. In the previous paper 7 we have observed both the ground state hole shift and the hole broadening of rhodamine 640 in subnanosecond to nanosecond region in methanol/ethanol mixed solvent at 170K. It is also reported that the time constant of dynamic Stokes shift agreed with that of the broadening of the fluorescence band width in nanosecond time region in the systems of laser dyes in the low temperature viscous alcoholic solvent z. Therefore the two dimensional configuration coordinate model seems to work well in viscous alcoholic solvent at low temperature. In the fluid solvent at room temperature, however, the situation seems to be different. In the fluid solvents the fast and slow components are considered to be distributed in the same orders of magnitude in time scale, that is, the rotational relaxation times of the solvent molecule may distribute in tens of femtosecond (rotation of OH for example) to picoseconds
48 (molecular rotation) and the times of translational motions may distribute in subpicosecond to tens of picosecond. In the course of the energy relaxation mainly due to the fast component of the solvent response, some slower rotational and translational motions (corrective motion) surrounding the solute molecule may bring about the disturbance of the configulation which was distributed in the thermal equilibrium one before the laser excitation. This entropy term in the free energy of the system including the solvent orientational distribution may be considered to be a possible mechanism to explain the discrepancy between the energy and the spectral shape relaxation times observed in this work. It is also important to take into consideration the effect of the site dependent relaxation time. When a solute molecule of a larger size is dissolved into solvent molecules of a smaller size, the relaxation time around each atom of the solute molecule which has the different charge density, in general, may differ from each other due to the different solvent response to the local charge. The solvation dynamics depending on the solute charge as well as solvent has been studied by computer simulations of molecular dynamics6 and of the theory based on the site-site Smoluchowski-Vlasov equation]~ The results show remarkable specificity depending on the solvent and the local charge especially in the picosecond time region. In the case considered the site dependent correlation function, the total correlation functions in eqs (6) and (7) may be 1/2, respectively, where a, and b, approximated as Pm(t)- 2 a , p, and Pm(t)- {2 b~pj2} denote the factor of the contribution from the local correlation function, p~, around the atom i of the solute molecule. The contribution of this type of the site dependent relaxation times may be another possibility to explain the results in the present system. Acknowled2ments The authors are grateful to Prof. F. Hirata of Kyoto University, Prof. S. Kinoshita of Osaka University, and Dr. A. Yoshimori of Nagoya University for fruitful discussion on the relaxation processes of solution. The present work was partly supported by a Grant-in-Aid (06NP301 and 06239240) to T.O. from the Ministry of Education, Science, and Culture of Japan. References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. J. 7. 8. 9. 10.
N.G. Bakshiev, Y. T. Mazurenko, and I. V. Piterskaya, Opt. Spectrosc. 21,550 (1966). (a) S. Kinoshita, N. Nishi, and T. Kushida, Chem. Phys. Lett. 134,605 (1987). (b) S. Kinoshita and N. Nishi, J. Chem. Phys. 89, 6612 (1988) and references therein. V. Nagarajan, A. M. Brearley, T. -J. Kang, and P. F. Barbara, J. Chem. Phys. 86, 3183 (1987). E.W. Castner. Jr., M. Maroncelli, and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 86, 1090 (1987); M. Maroncelli and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 86, 6221 (1987). (a) S. J. Rosenthal, X. Xie, M. Du, G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 95, 4715 (1991). (b) M. Cho, S. J. Rosenthal, N. F. Schemer, L. D. Ziegler, and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 96, 5033 (1992). M. Maroncelli, P. U. Kumar, A. Papazyan, M. L. Hong, S. J. Rosenthal, and G. R. Fleming, in "Ultrafast Reaction Dynamics and Solvent Effects," Eds. Y. Gauduel and P. Rossky, AlP Conference Proceedings, AlP Press, New York, 1994, 298, p. 310. (a) S. Kinoshita, H. ltoh, H. Murakami, H. Miyasaka, T. Okada, and N. Mataga, Chem. Phys. Lett. 166, 123 (1990). (b) H. Murakami, S. Kinoshita, Y. Hirata, T. Okada, and N. Mataga, J. Chem. Phys. 97, 7881 (1992). S. Kinoshita, J. Chem. Phys. 91, 5175 (1989). C . H . B . Cruz, R. L. Fork, W. H. Knox, and C. V. Shank, Chem. Phys. Lett. 132, 341(1986). F. Hirata, T. Munakata, F. Rained, and H. L. Friedman, in this proceedings.
journal of
~OLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of MolecularLiquids.65/66 ( !995) 49-57
Uitrafast Measurements of the Dynamics of Soivation in Polar and Non-Dipolar Solvents J. Gardecki, M. L. Horng, A. Papazyan, and M. Maroncelli Department of Chemistry The Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA 16802 ABSTRACT The dynamics of solvation of the probe solute coumarin 153 has been measured with -100 fs time resolution using the fluorescence upconversion technique. A wide variety of solvents, including polar aprotic solvents, hydrogen bonding solvents, and non-dipolar solvents have been examined. For all solvents of even moderate polarity (e0>5), the solvation dyna~cs observed follows the predictions simple models based on the solvent's bulk dielectric response. For a number of "non-dipolar" solvents such as dioxane and benzene, for which e o <5, we observe surprisingly large time-dependent shifts, which seem to reflect the solute interacting with the large quadrupole (and higher multipole) moments of the solvent molecules. These dynamics represent a solvation distinct from the dipolar solvation dynamics previously studied and they cannot be modeled in terms of any currently available theory.
INTRODUCTION An understanding of the time-dependence of solvation is a key ingredient in modern theories of chemical reaction in solution [1]. For this reason there has been a great deal of research focused on measuring and building predictive theories of this dynamics [2,3]. The main concern to date has been on polar solvation dynamics, where the interactions are strongest and are predicted to have large effects on electron and other charge-transfer reactions [1]. A few recent studies also begun to consider the dynamics of solvation in nonpolar solvents [4-6]. In either case, the phenomenon of interest is the time-dependent relaxation of the solvation energy subsequent to some step-function change in the solute's electronic structure. This dynamics is most often measured by monitoring the fluorescence of an appropriately chosen solute upon electronic excitation. (Other, less direct methods, are also under current development [7].)
0
Coumarin 153 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995ElsevierScienceB.V. All rights reserved. SSD10167-7322 (95) 00844-6
50 In the present report we describe new time-resolved measurements of solvation dynmnics using the probe molecule coumarin 153 (hereafter referred to as C153) [8]. This weft-known solvation probe has been thoroughly characterized in a number of past studies [2,9]. Its main attribute which makes it an excellent solvation probe is that upon electronic excitation its dipole moment changes from a ground state value of - 6 D to a value of--15 D in S1 [10]. Furthermore, its $1 state is well separated from other excited singlet states and there is no indication of the occurrence of any excited-state reaction in most solvents [8,9]. Although the solvation dynamics of this molecule have been measured in a number of solvents previously [2,9], we have undertaken an extensive series of new measurements on more than 24 solvents. Motivation for this study comes from indications by computer simulation and theoretical considerations that earlier studies might have missed an important part of the dynamics due to limited time resolution [ 11]. Computer simulations first pointed to the presence of a prominent ultrafast component of the dynamics in small, highly polar solvents such as water [12], acetonitrile [13], and "methyl chloride" [14]. Recent experiments have confinmd the existence of this "inertial" component of the dynamics in a few important cases [ 15,16]. The present work reflects our attempts to more completely characterize such ultrafast dynamics in a broad range of solvents. Compared to earlier studies, we are aided in this pursuit by greatly improved temporal resolution (~ 100 fs FWHM instrument response), as well as having a method of accurately determining the position of the emission spectrum prior to solvent relaxation [ 17]. These two improvements allow us to make what we believe to be highly reliable measurements of the solvation dynamics of C153 in a range of solvents.
METHODS Emission decays were obtained from a fs Ti:sapphire laser/fluorescence upconversion spectrometer whose construction is reported elsewhere [8]. Here we only note that the overall temporal response used in these studies was between 112-125 fs as measured by the FWHM of the cross correlation between the pump and gate pulses. Decays (0-200 ps with a variable step size) were collected at a series of ten emission wavelengths (8 nm ban@ass) which were then used to reconstruct time-evolving emission spectra in the manner described in Refs. 8 and 9. From these spectra the solvation dynamics was extracted in the form of the spectral response function, s~(t)-
v(t)-v(oo) , v(0)-v(--)
(1)
where v(t) denotes the frequency of the peak of the emission specmun at time t (see Refs. 8 and 9 for details). All dynamics were measmed at room temperature, 23:1:2 C. DYNAMICS IN P O L A R SOLVENTS Figure 1 illustrates typical time-resolved emission spectra of C153 observed in the solvents acetonitrile, chloroform, and 1-pentanol. Also shown (dashed curves) arc the steady-state emission spectra (equal to the time infinity spectra in most cases) and the estimated time-zero spectra, the spectra expected prior to any solvent relaxation. (The latter were obtained through comparison of steady-state spectra in the solvent of interest and in a non-polar reference solvent as described in Ref. 17.) A few features of these spectra are noteworthy.
First, with the current time resolution, we are able to capture the full spectral evolution. That is, in nearly every solvent studied, the observed spectrum at t=0 agrees, to within roughly the accuracy of the time-zero method (--200 cm -i for C153), with the predicted time-zero specmml. Second, the time-evolution observed in all of the solvents studied involves a simple time-dependent shift with little change in shape or width. This behavior is indicative that we are indeed observing a continuous solvation process without interference from other excited state processes. The extent of the observed shift depends on solvent polarity. It ranges from --700 for weakly polar solvents such as chloroform to slightly over 2000 for strongly polar solvents such as acetonitrile. The magnitudes of these shifts can be reasonably correlated to the usual reaction field factors expected on the basis of dielectric continuum models [8]. Fmally, as illustrated by the three solvents portrayed in Fig. 1, the rate at which the emission specmun shifts with time varies over an impressive range as a function of solvent.
cm-i
cm-i
.8
,o~176
"
0
/// \\\ .i 16.
18. ~,
20.
~ "........
.2
ooo I
,ooo/ 22.
( 1 0 3 c m -1 )
24.
F'gure 1. Time-resolved spectra of C153 in acetonitfile, chloroform, and l-pentanol (connected points). Times in ps are indicated on the figure: the spectra evolve toward lower frequency with increasing time. The dashed curves are the steadystate emission spectra (red curve) and the spectrum expected prior to any solvent relaxation (blue curve: see Ref. 17).
0 I .05
"..........
1
-PeOH
""'-....
"~
M !':"::
.5
5.
50.
Time
")
\'\
500.
(ps)
F'~gure 2. Soivation response functions observed (solid curves) and calculated using the DMSAi theory (dashed curves; see text) for the solvents acetonitrile, methanol, chloroform, and 1-pentanol.
52 Figure 2 shows the spectral response functions (Sv (t), Eq. 1) derived from the spectra of Fig. 1. In order to adequately display data for these varied solvents, whose dynamics occur on very different time scales, we employ a logarithmic time axis. Such a representation is also useful because a number of solvents, especially the alcohols, show highly dispersive response functions. For example, one observes in methanol significant relaxation taking place over 3-4 decades in time. (Multiexponential fits to the methanol data yield roughly equal contributions from components with time constants of 0.2, 2, and 12 ps). Even in simple, non-associated solvents such as acetonitrile, one seldom observes Sv(t) functions that decay exponentially in time. Most often, biexponential fits are required to describe the observed relaxation. This biexponential behavior does not reflect any clear separation between fast inertial dynamics and slower diffusive dynamics in most solvents. Rather, the observed spectral shift usually appears to simply be a continuous non-exponential process. That is not to say that ultrafast inertial relaxation does not occur in many solvents, just that there is no clear time scale separation observed. Of the 18 polar solvents observed to date, a number of them do show prominent fast components that are probably inertial in origin. For example, in the solvents water [16], formamide, acetonitrile, acetone, dimethylformamide, dimethylsulfoxide, and nitromethane [8], we find that more than half of the solvation response involves components with time constants of <~00 fs. The dynamics observed in polar solvents can be readily modeled in terms of simple theories based on the bulk dielectric response (~(o~)) of the solvent. Although there are now a variety of more sophisticated theories currently available [3], we will only consider the "simple continuum" (SC) [18] and the dynamical MSA (DMSA) models [19]. The simple continuum theory assumes that the solute is a spherical cavity containing a point charge or point dipole. It interacts with the solvent only through the latter's bulk dielectric dispersion ~(r which is assumed to be known empirically. This limiting theory, which should be exact in the absence of specific interactions and in the limit of a solute of macroscopic size, forms the benchmark to which all other theories are compared. Previous studies have shown that predictions of the SC theory provide a useful guide to the dynamics observed in many real molecular systems [2,3]. However, the fact that the solvent is not a continuum fluid, but is in r e ~ t y composed of discrete molecules comparable in size to the solute, should cause deviations from the SC predictions. The DMSA theory corrects for some of the deficiencies of a continuum description by explicitly accounting for the fact that the electrical field generated by a molecular solute changes significantly on a length scale comparable to solvent molecule dimensions. This finite size effect causes a slowing of the solvation response compared to simple continuum predictions to an extent which depends on the solute/solvent size ratio [ 19]. The slow-down is much greater when one considers the response to a change in the solute's dipole moment compared to a change in its net charge (because of the difference in range of the electrical fields involved).
53
Figure 3. Solvation functions in dimethylsulfoxide. ,\
.8
"'-,\
9
9 "'\
b,
\N~x
~..6
--.
,
"':'~
"'b,
neglecting the unobserved uitrafust part of e(o~) (see tex0.
"',
"\
\
2 .82 2.0 MSi
3 3.~ 4.9 MSd
',,
'\, ,,
4 2.5 3.8 SC*
(ion), 3--DMSA(dipole),
El3.4 "\
The solid
curve ("0") is the obsen~ ~ and the dashed curves 1-4 are calculations using various models described in the text. The number of short dashes in the line pattern ctmeslxmd to the numbers wovided on inset tabulation of the characteristic times of these mslxmse functions: 1--SC (ion), 2ffiDMSA
0 .65 1 . 6 0 b s 1 .27 .80 SCi
" ',,
and 4ffiSC(ion)
.2 0
~
.05
,
,...~,- ~ . ~
.5 Time
5.
50.
(ps)
Figure 3 compares the experimentally observed solvation response of C153 in dimethylsulfoxide (#0, solid curve) to the predictions made by simple continuum and DMSA theories. The inset to the figure tabulates the 1/e times (t,,) and the average or integral correlation times (< %>) of the various response functions. These data show that the SC prediction for the response to a charge perturbation (#1) is too fast compared to the observed dynamics by a factor of approximately two. (The SC prediction for a dipole jump is sinfilar to that for a charge jump.) The DMSA prediction for a charge jump (#2; "DMSAi") is very close to the observed dynamics whereas the DMSA prediction for a change in solute dipole CDMSAd") is more than two-fold slower than the observed response. These observations concerning the performance of the various theories are quite general, as we will show presently. However, before doing so, we must make an important point regarding the use of dielectric data in such comparisons. The solvent response measured in time-resolved emission studies involves all solvent motion occurring on time scales slower than that of the electronic transition itself, i.e. slower than optical frequencies. Dielectric data, even those from recent experiments that, as in the case of DMSO [20], extend to the 100 GHz range, do not include all relevant nuclear motions of the solvent. For example, the dielectric data for DMSO used in Fig. 3 was reported to follow a Davidson-Cole distribution with parameters ao--46.40 ande..--4.16. The fact that some of the nuclear polarizability of the solvent is missed by this parameterization is indicated by the fact that at optical frequencies eop,--nv2=2.19. The difference e . . - nv2=1.97 reflects the contributions of nuclear responses in the FIR CPoley absorption") and IR regions (intramolecular vibrations) not captured in the dielectric data. Although this neglected part may seem small compared to the total polarizability of E0--46.40, the effect of these contributions on the computed solvation dynamics can be considerable, as illustrated by curve #4 in Fig. 3. This curve is a SC (ion) calculation which ignores such
54 contributions. The t~, and < ~ > times are slower than the same SC calculations that include these effects by factors of 9 and 5 respectively[ Although DMSO is an extreme example (in most solvents e . - no 2 is smaller than in DMSO), the difference is an important one, and proper comparisons must include the fast part of the nuclear response not directly observed in dielectric measurements. In the calculations described here we have treated this contribution as if it were a single relaxation m r m with a longitudinal time constant of 0.1 ps. This particular form of the time-dependence is arbitrary and is certainly an over simplification of the real dynamics. Luckily however, as long as the term describing the unobserved part of s is assumed reasonably rapid, its particular form and time scale do not appreciably affect the calculated values of t~, and < 1:>.
m 102
te
Figure 4. Comparison of ob~rv~ solvation times to predictions of the SC and DMSA theorics. The points show the comparison between the DMSA theory for an ionic solute with polar aprotic solvents denoted by circles and associated solvents by squares. For clarity,
j " ~ - - " .....--'" ........Q ...-'" .......
101 ._E~v i 0 ~ ~
. ~
..
the SC and DMSAd comparisons are only shown
E--
-o
I03
"~
I0 2 101
.j~ ~ '
I
t~'
L~ i 0 o
lO-t 10-1
10 ~
Observed
101 Time
102
103
as the linear fits to the log-log data with the SC predictions being the lower dashed line and the DMSAd the uPl~ dashed line. The solvents represented here are, in order of ~ i n g tie: acetonitrile, acetone, tetmhydrofuran, dimethylformamide, dimethylsulfoxide, propylene carbonate, dimethyl carbonate, chloroform, and benzonitrile (circles) and water [16], formamide, methanol, ethylene glycol, ethanol, l-prolmnol, l-peatanol, and l-decanol (squares).
(ps)
Figure 4 compares the characteristic times observed with C153 in a wide range of polar solvents to the predictions of the diele,ctric theories just described. As in Fig. 3, one finds good agreement between the times predicted by the DMSA theory for the response to a charge jump CDMSAi") and the observed dynamics. In contrast, the predictions of the simple continuum (ion) and DMSA calculations for a dipole change in the solute CDMSAd ~176 are r c s ~ v e l y too fast and too slow compared to experiment. The agreement between the observed dynamics and the DMSAi predictions also extends to the shapes of the response functions, as illustrated in the comparisons provided in Figs. 2 and 3. This is rather remarkable agreement, given that it extends over a wide variety of polar solvents, both associawxi and non-associated, whose solvation times span more than 3 orders of magnitude. It demonstrates the basic soundness of theories that link polar solvation dynamics to the solvent's dielectric response. However, it must be recognized that the DMSA theow is not a complete theory for the observed dynamics. If it were, one would expect to find agreement with predictions of the DMSA theory meant to model dipole jumps CDMSAd') rather than
55 with the ion version CDMSAi"), since the lowest-order multipole of the solute that changes upon electronic excitation is its dipole moment, not its charge. Indeed, calculations show that charge distributions of polyatomic molecules such as C153 and their change upon excitation are likely to be more quadrupolar in nature than dipolar [21]. Thus, one would expect that the observed dynamics should be even slower than that predicted by the DMSAd theory. The fact that the observed dynamics is in actuality faster is an indication that some aspect of the real system's dynamics is not properly captured by the DMSA theory. Simulations of lattice solvents [22] demonstrate that the DMSA theory does accurately predict the dynanfics of both charge and dipole jumps when (as assumed by the theory) the solvent dynamics involves only rotational motion of point dipole particles. What is neglected in the DMSA theory is: i) that solvent molecules translate in addition to rotate and ii) that the solute does not really see a nearby solvent molecule as a point dipole but rather as an extended charge distribution. The effect of translational motions, which contribute an additional relaxation channel for solvation via "polarization diffusion" [2,23] is clearly to speed up the response relative to the DMSA predictions. The effect of the extended charge distribution of solvent molecules is more subtle to gauge but, at least in some cases, this difference has also been shown to hasten the response [24]. We can summarize these results in the following way. The SC model provides useful first estimates for the solvation dynamics observed with a polar solute such as C153. However, due to its complete neglect of molecular aspects of solvation, it predicts response times that are uniformly too rapid. The DMSA approach, when properly applied (i.e. the DMSAd model), predicts too slow a solvation response. This latter model includes some important effects of solvent molecularity which serve to increase the response time compared to the SC predictions, while it neglects certain others that happen to act in the opposite direction. Thus, the agreement between the dynamics observed with the solute C153 and those pwxiicted by the "inappropriate" DMSAi theory should be regarded as partly fortuitous. Nevertheless, the surprising accuracy of the DMSAi predictions makes this simple model of considerable practical value. DYNAMICS IN NON-DIPOLAR SOLVENTS The success of dielectric models in describing the solvation of C153 in polar solvents is quite remarkable. Although, as just discussed, certain aspects of the dynamics are still not quantitatively described by theory, it is fair to say that the basic features of solvation dynamics in polar solvents are well understood. We would like to conclude by observing that the same cannot be claimed for the dynamics in non-dipolar solvents. Figure 5 shows that in the nominally "nonpolar" solvents dioxane and benzene, C153 undergoes time-dependent shifts that are in all respects analogous to the dynamics observed in weakly polar solvents such as chloroform [8]. However, theories of the sort described above, relying as they do on e(co), are inadequate to describe apparently similar solvation dynamics taking place in these latter solvents. Because they lack significant dipole moments, the solvation response predicted on the basis of their dielectric properties (i.e. by e0) is very small [6]. The fact that these and similar non-dipolar solvents we have examined do solvate C153 strongly is a consequence of the large quadrupole and higher-order electrostatic moments these molecules possess. At the short ranges relevant for molecular solvation, these higher moments (or alternatively the
56 charged groups or dipolar bonds) of the solvent molecules are as effective in solvating C153 as are the dipoles of weakly polar solvents. But the long-range dipolar correlations measured by the bulk property E(ca) are virtually absent in these solvents. Thus, to describe the dynamics observed in such solvents one does not have empirical information of the sort contained in e(o~) or an equivalent of the benchmark SC approach available for dipolar solvents. Furthermore, since the range of the interactions between the solvent and solute is shorter in such solvents, one expects that the details of the solvation structure and the effects of wanslational motion should be of much greater importance to the dynamics than in the dipolar solvent case. Thus, we anticipate that these types of solvents should provide a challenging testing ground for the future development of molecular models of solvation and solvation dynamics. l~gare5. Trine-resolvedspeclra of C153 in dioxane and benzene (connected points). The times shown are 0, 0.1, 0.5, 1, 2, and 10 ps from right to left. The dashed curves are the steady-state emission (red curve) and the speclrum expected prior to any solvent relaxation (blue curve; see Ref. 17).
i
3
0 16.
18.
Frequency
20.
22.
24.
(10 3 c m -I )
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This research was supported by funds from the Office of Basic Energy Sciences of the US Department of Energy and by the Office of Naval Research. REFERENCES 1. See the reviews: J. T. Hynes, in Ultrafast Dynamics of Chemical Systems, I. D. Simon, Ed. (Klewer, Dordrecht, 1994), pp. 345-381; H. Heitele, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 32, 359 (1993). 2. Reviews of the experimental literature are provided in: M. Maroncelli, J. Mol. Liq. 57, 1 (1993); and P. F. Barbara and W. Jarzeba, Adv. Photochem. 15, 1 (1990); W. Jarzcba, G. C. Walker, A. E. Johnson, P. F. Barbara, Chem. Phys. 152, 57 (1991). 3. Reviews of theoretical and simulation studies can be found in Ref. 1 and B. Bagchi and A. Chandra, Adv. Chem. Phys. 80, 1 (1991); and F. O. Raineri, Y. Zhou, H. L. Friedman, Chem. Phys. 152, 201 (1991). Some of the most recent theoretical developments are described in: F. O. Raineri, H. Resat, B.-C. Perng, F. Hirata~ H. L. Friedman, J. Chem. Phys. 100, 1477 (1994); and B. M. Ladanyi and R. M. Stratt, J. Chem. Phys. (1995).
4. B. Bagchi, J. Chem. Phys. I00, 6658 (1994); Svaen and J. L. Skinner, J. Chem. Phys. 99, 4391 (1993) and luther work in progress. 5. M. Berg, "Comparison of a ViscoelasticTheory of Solvation Dynamics to Tune-Resolved Experiments in a Nonpolar Solution," Chem. Phys. Lett.,in press. 6 J.T. Fourkas, A. Benigno, M. Berg, J. Chem. Phys. 99, 8552 (1993); J. T. Fourkas and M. Berg, J. Chem. Phys. 98, 7773 (1993). 7. See, for example, E. T. J. Nibbering, D. A. Wiersma, K. Duppen, J. Chem. Phys. 183, 167 (1994); S. Y. Goldberg, E. Bart, A. Meltsin, B. D. Fainberg, D. Huppert, J. Chem. Phys. 183, 217 (1994); T. Joo, Y. Jia, G. R. Fleming, "Ultrafast Liquid Dynamics Studied by Thrid and Fifth Order Three Pulse Photon Echoes," preprint (1995). 8. A more complete account of these studies is cunently in preparation. (M. L. Homg, J. Gardecki, and M. Maroncelli, "Sub-Picosecond Measurements of the Solvation Dynmrdcs of Coumain 153," to be submitted to J. Chem. Phys.) 9. M. Maroncelli and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 86, 6221 (1987); M. Maroncelli and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 86, 3251 (1990). 10. P. K. McCarthy and G. J. Blanchard, J. Phys. Chem. 97, 12205 (1993); W. Baumann and Z. Nagy, Pure Appl. Chem. 65, 1729 (1993). 11. M. Maroncelli, P. V. Kumar, A. Papazyan, M. L. Homg, S. J. Rosenthal, G. R. Fleming, in Ultrafast Reaction Dynamics and Solvent Effects, Y. Gauduel and P. J. Rossky, Eds. (American Institute of Physics, New York, 1994), pp. 310-333. 12. M. Maroncelli and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 89, 5044 (1988); J. S. Bader and D. Chandler, Chem. Phys. Lett 157, 501 (1989). 13. M. Maroncelli, J. Chem. Phys. 94, 2084 (1991). 14. A. E. Carter and J. T. Hynes, J. Chem. Phys. 94, 5961 (1991). 15. S. J. Rosenthal, X. Xie, M. Du, G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 95, 4715 (1991); S. J. Rosenthal, R. Jimenez, G. R. Fleming, P. V. Kumar, M. Maroncelli, J. Mol. Liq. 60, 25 (1994). 16. R. Jimenez, G. R. Fleming, P. V. Kumar, M. Maroncelli, Nature 369, 471 (1994). 17. R. S. Fee and M. Maroncelli, Chem. Phys. 183, 235 (1994). 18. B. Bagchi, D. W. Oxtoby, G. R. Fleming, Chem. Phys. 86, 257 (1984); G. van der Zwan and J. T. Hynes, J. Phys. Chem. 89, 4181 (1985). 19. I. Rips, J. Klafter, J. Jormer, J. Chem. Phys. 88, 3246 (1988); I. Rips, J. Klafter, J. Jormer, J. Chem. Phys. 89, 4288 (1988); A. L. Nichols HI and D. F. Calef, J. Chem. Phys. 89, 3783 (1988); see also M. Maroncelli and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 89, 875 (1988). 20. J. Barthel, IC Bachhuber, R. Buchner, J. B. Gill, and M. Kleebauer, Chem. Phys. Lett. 167, 62 (1990). 21. C. F. Chapman, R. S. Fee, and M. Maroncelli, "Measurements of the Solute Dependence of Solvation Dynamics in 1-Propanol: The Role of Specific Hydrogen Bonding Interactions," submitted to Chem. Phys. Lett. 22. H. X. Zhou, B. Bagchi, A. Papazyan, M. Maronceili, J. Chem. Phys. 97, 9311 (1992); A. Papazyan and M. Maroncelli, "Rotational Dielectric Friction and Dipole Solvation: Tests of Theory Based on Simulations of Simple Model Solutions," J. Chem. Phys., in press. 23. G. van der Zwan and J. T. Hynes, Physica 121A, 227 (1983). 24. F. O. Rained, Y. Zhou, H. L. Friedman, Chem. Phys. 152, 201 (1991).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
journal of
~IOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of MolecularLiquids,65/66 (1995) 59-64
Solvent and Nuclear Dynamic Effects on Intermolecular Electron Transfer Keitaro Yoshihara, 1, 2 Yutaka Nagasawa, 2 Arkadiy Yartsev, 1, + Alan E. Johnson,l,$ and Keisuke Tominaga 1 llnstitute for Molecular Science, Myodaiji, Okazaki 444, Japan 2The Graduate University for Advanced Studies, Myodaiji, Okazaki 444, Japan
Abstract An ultra_fast intermolecular electron transfer (ET) from electron donating solvent to an excited dye molecule was found. A temperature-dependent non-exponential time dependence was observed in aniline, and a temperature-independent single exponential process for Nile blue (160 fs) and oxazine 1 (260 fs) was observed in N,N-dimethylaniline. The solvation times of solvent anilines were obtained by dynamic Stokes shift measurements. The rate of ET in some systems was observed to be much greater than the solvation time of anilines. The dynamic behavior was simulated by the 2-dimensional potential energy surface for reaction, taking into account of the effects of both solvent reorientation and nuclear motion of reactants.
I. Introduction The universality of intermolecular electron transfer (ET) makes the mechanism one of the central questions to be solved in chemistry and biology. ET is strongly influenced by the nature of solvent and its dynamics in solution. Dynamical solvent effects on the course of reaction have recently studied both theoretically [1-5] and experimentally [6-15]. For ET with a rate comparable to the solvent fluctuation rate, the motion and structure of the solvent can determine the rate of ET and it becomes the "solvent-controlled" reaction [2,3, 6-9]. Most recently we have investigated ultrafast ET (as fast as ca. 1013 s-1) between excited dye and weakly polar electron-donating solvent molecules [10-14]. These systems have several interesting features. (1) The electron donor and acceptor are in contact and there is no translational diffusion to induce ET. (2) Non-equilibrium reaction caused by solvent dynamics can be observed. (3) Some systems have a rate of ET much faster than that of solvent relaxation. In this case the reaction is mainly due to the nuclear dynamics and is independent of solvent dynamics. (4) A clear substituent effect of electron acceptor molecules on the rates of ET is observed. The time scale of ET observed in these systems falls into the time scale of solvent relaxation and of nuclear motions and the reaction will be severely influenced by these dynamics. It is also the aim of the present study to investigate the role of intermolecular interaction, namely, solvent effects to the reaction as well as the effects of inter- and intramolecular dynamics. The oxazine dyes are Nile blue A perchlorate (NB) and oxazine 1 perchlorate (OX1), which are ionic dyes, and coumarin 102 is chosen as a fluorescent probe molecule in the dynamic Stokes shift measurements. The electron donating solvents are aniline (AN) and N,N-dimethylaniline (DMA).
II. Experimental Ultrafast fluorescence quenching dynamics were studied by the fluorescence-upconversion method with femtosecond mode-locked laser systems. For the studies of oxazine dyes, a synchronously pumped hybrid mode-locked dye laser with group velocity 0167-7322/95/509.50
91995 ElsevierScience B.V. All rights reserved.
SSDI 0167-7322 (95) 00910-8
60 compensation prisms was made to generate optical pulses at different wavelengths at 76 MHz. Using a combination of Rh-6G and DODCI/DQOCI and spatial filters between the second prism and end mirror, 70 fs pulses were generated at 615 nm. With a combination of sulforhodamine 101 and DQTCI generation of 50 fs pulses at 675 nm was achieved. For the studies of fluorescence dynamics of coumarins, we used the second-harmonic of a modelocked Ti: sapphire laser, at 395nm, to excite the sample. The remaining fundamental at 790nm was used to up-convert the fluorescence from the sample.
IH. Results and Discussion A. Solvent relaxation times of electron donating solvents W e observed ultrafastE T in the subpicosecond timescale which was thought to be much faster than the diffusive solvent relaxation process [I]. To confirm this the measurement of solvent relaxation time is carried out. The dynamic fluorescence Stokes shift is used to determine solvent relaxation times of the donor solvents ( D M A and AN). W h e n a probe dye molecule is photo-excited, the dipole moment increases instantaneously. The polarization of the surrounding solvent molecule responds to this change and startsto reorganize. Therefore, the energy relaxation process, caused by the solvent reorganization, shiftsthe fluorescence spectrum to longer wavelengths. To extract dynamical information of solvent relaxation process, the normalized spectral shiftcorrelation function C(O is measured [16],
C(t) = v(t)- v(..)
v(O)- v(..)
(1)
where v(t), v(,,), and v(O) are the fluorescence peak frequencies at times, t, ,0, and 0, respectively. For this method, a probe molecule which undergoes a large instantaneous change of dipole moment upon photo-excitation has to be chosen. Coumarin dyes are often used as probe molecules for this type of experiment [17-19]. Coumarin 102 (C102), which has a lifetime of 2.8 ns in DMA and 1.4 ns in AN, is the choice for this experiment. Figure 1 shows fluorescence decays of C102 observed at different wavelengths. At shorter wavelengths there is a fast decay and at longer wavelengths there is a concurrent rise. This implies that the fluorescence spectrum of C102 is shifting towards red with time. Time-resolved fluorescence spectra would illustrate this red shift. We have used the spectral reconstruction method to obtain a time-resolved fluorescence spectrum [13] When the fluorescence up-conversion method is used, the relative intensity between each wavelength becomes uncertain because the angle of the nonlinear crystal has to be tuned at each wavelength of observation. However, the intensity of the fluorescence l(/q,, t), at a given time t and wavelength ;I,, can be obtained from the normalized fitted decay series D(t ,;t) and intensity of the steady-state fluorescence 10()0;
l(/q;, t) = D(t,~) Io(~)
D(t, ~) dt
(2)
Figure 2 shows the reconstructed spectrum. The symbols correspond to the intensities of the fluorescence at the measured wavelength at a given time t. The lines are the least-square-fits to the points using a log-normal function. The log-normal function describes an asymmetric line shape and is often used to fit broad featureless absorption or fluorescence spectra. As expected from examinations of the individual fluorescence transients, the peak of the reconstructed spectrum shifts to red with time. In Figure 3, the spectral shift correlation functions C(t) are shown with the results of bi-exponential fitting. The observed solvent relaxation times are 7.9 ps (19 %) and 18.7 ps (81%) for DMA and 6.7 ps (81%) and 13.3 ps (19 %) for AN. These are much longer than the fluorescence lifetimes of NB, i.e., 0.1 ps
61
I (a)
497 nm
20 ps
Idl/// ~ll
(a)
I 16p~
Izr
;1111 o
'
(b)
~'
'~
. . . . .. . .
'
_ . ~ . , ~ ' ~ " *~ ~'~'~
~
.
.
~
.
~
a;
-
y
~o
.....
Time / ps
;o
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
!
500
....
16 ps
484 nm
9
o . . . . .
450
/ ' ~
....
497 nm ~
,,i .
400
~,
Figure 1. Fluorescence decays of C 102 (a) in DMA and (b) in AN, measured at various wavelengths.
/,P//
4~1
_'t,W/o~
1 ...... 500
5~}
I
6OO
Wavelength / n m
Figure 2. Reconstructed time-resolved fluorescence spectra of C 102 in (a) DMA and (b) AN. The dots are the data experimentally obtained, and the curves are the log-normal fits to the dots.
(95 %) and 2.5 ps (5 %) in DMA, and 0.4 ps (56 %) and 2.5 ps (44 %) in AN. Therefore, our previous prediction is confirmed; the ET occurs much faster than the diffusive solvation process. B. Temperature dependence of electron transfer The fluorescence of OX 1 in anilines is severely (ca. 103 times) quenched by ET, and, therefore, its dynamics reveal the ET dynamics. The temperature dependence of fluorescence decays of OX1 in anilines is shown in Figure 4. The ultrafast single exponential decay (280 fs) of OXI in DMA does not show any temperature dependence from 280 K (7 ~ to 373 K (100 ~ In AN, however, a clear temperature dependence was observed in its non-exponential decay. As the temperature increases from 283 K (10 ~ to 353 K (80 ~ the decay becomes faster. A tri-exponential fitting is performed at different temperatures. The first component (-430 fs) does not show temperature dependence, but the second component shows dependence which gives an activation energy of 1.0 kcal/mol. C. Effect of solvent dynamics on electron transfer and Sumi-Marcus two-dimensional model It is clear in the present system that ET occurs much faster than the diffusive solvation process. To explain exponential and non-exponential kinetics of ET, the idea of Sumi-Marcus two-dimensional reaction coordinate is used. In this treatment, instead of the usual one dimensional reaction coordinate (solvent coordinate), two coordinates are used, i.e., the solvent coordinate and the vibrational nuclear coordinate. A free energy surface is drawn in a two-dimensional plane spanned by the solvent coordinate, X, and the nuclear coordinate, q.
62 The Sumi-Marcus model treats both the solvent and intramolecular mode classically. However, the actual system should have not only the classical modes but also quantum mechanical high-frequency modes. Jortner and Bixon have developed an ET model which introduces the effect of the quantum mechanical high-frequency modes [4]. In this model, the reactant surface crosses not only with the vibrational ground state of the product but also with vibrationally excited states of the product. The reaction of oxazines in DMA is activationless, which means that the reaction is not in the inverted region but very close to it. We use a hybrid model of Sumi-Marcus and Jortner-Bixon developed by Walker et al. [15]. In this model, the intramolecular vibration is separated into the quantum mechanical highfrequency mode and classical low-frequency mode;
~p(X, t) = D ~ (9 + 1 dV(X) ] p(X, t)- ~, k(n, X) p(X, t) n ~t ~ [ 3t kBT dX
(3)
where p(X, t) is the population of the reactant at X and t, and k(n, X) is the reaction rate between the vibrational ground state of the reactant and vibrational state n of the product. The non-adiabatic formula is used for k(n, X) 9
(4)
k(n, X) =~ V~l2 (4ZCXlkBT)I/2exp( - AG*(n,X) ) kBT
,t
~
-:os
=o<
4
g
~
~ o., c
5
2
oo, 9
o.o-
,'o
_
20 '
6.7
30 '
,s(a
%1
40 '
I
~ - O.5
~'.s
'!I
o.o,, 6
o'.o
o'.s
/~
!,!,
,.o
,.s
2S3K
,,
(b)
'
i
1
0
2
Jo,,l ~
,
.i
I
6
Time / ps
oo-
~
i0
~
20
30
40
Time / ps
F i g u r e 3. The normalized spectral shift correlation function C(t) of C102 in (a) D M A and (b) AN. Results of bi-exponential fitting are also shown.
Figure 4. Temperature dependence of fluorescence decays of OXI (a) in DMA and (b) in AN.
63 where ,;Ll is the reorganization energy for the classical low-frequency mode. V'el is the electronic matrix element concerning the effect of Franck-Condon factor which can be written as
Ve~
= Sn
n!
(5)
exp(-S)Ve~
where the electron-vibrational coupling strength is S = Zh2/2. Zh is the reorganization energy for the high-frequency mode. AG*(n, X) is the activation energy which depends on the quantum number of the vibrational state n and the solvation coordinate X;
zlG*(n, X) = (As + AG - 2X;s + nhVh + ,~,/)2 / 4&t
(6)
For D, the time dependent diffusion coefficient D(t) is used [ 13];
D ( t ) = kBT
1
2A,s A(t)
dA(t)
(7)
dt
where
(8)
A(t) = al exp(- t / rl) + a2 exp(- t / z2) lr1, is the first and T2 is the second solvation time, and al + a2 = 1. This model contains m a n y parameters, some of them are difficult to obtain experimentally. But we try to fit the experimental data using as realistic parameters as possible. Firstly we estimate that the minima of the SO and S I free energy surfaces of OXI are located at the same point. This means that the electric dipole moment of OX1 does not change drastically upon photo-excitation. This approximation makes the initial distribution produced by the excitation an equilibrium one. The Stokes shift of OX 1 is very small, therefore, this approximation seems quite reasonable. Secondly, it is assumed that the reaction occurs only from the lowest vibrational state of the reactant. This approximation seems quite reasonable, since there is no excitation wavelength dependence. We used 0.13 eV for the solvent reorganization energy Zs, and 0.37 eV for the reorganization energy of the classical low-frequency mode ;tl. Solvation times of 7 ps (50%) and 15 ps (50%) which are close to the observed solvation times for AN and DMA are used. 0.13 eV and 1400 cm-1 are used for the reorganization energy 2h and the frequency Vh of the highfrequency mode, respectively.
1!~
(a)
II. 2
0.01
0
1
,:
6:
(b)
2.
.. O.lg z.
o..
6.(,
:
~
0.018-
5
Time I ps
Figure 5. Results of simulation using Sumi-Marcus Jortner-Bixon hybrid model. (a) AGo = -0.50 eV. (b) AGo = -0.33 eV, T = 273,293, 313, 333, 353, and 373 K.
64 The results of the simulations are shown in Figure 5. The normalized population of the reactant P(t) is plotted against time (ps) on a logarithmic scale. The energy gaps -AGo are 0.50 eV for Figure 5 (a) and 0.33 eV for (b). Temperature is changed in each set, from 273 K to 373 K The fluoresc6n6e decay of C102 in AN does not show any temperature dependence. Figure 5 (a) corresponds to the ET of OX1 in DMA, where there is no activation barrier. The free energy surface for the lowest vibrational state of the product crosses the bottom of the reactant surface. Such a situation occurs when -AGo = ,~l + 2s = 0.50 eV. The simulated reaction shown in Figure 5 (a) is almost exponential, which coincides with the experimental result of OX1 in DMA. In Figure 5 (b), -AGo is 0.17 eV smaller than that in (a). This difference corresponds to the difference in ionization potential between DMA and AN in condensed phase. The reaction becomes faster as the temperature increases and the change is rather large at the slower part of the reaction than the fast part.
Acknowledgment This work was supported in part by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research on New Program (06NP0301) by the Ministry of Education, Science, and Culture of Japan.
References +Permanent address: Institute of Spectroscopy, Russian Academy of Science, 142092 Troitzk, Moscow Region, Russian Federation. $ Present address: Department of Chemistry, University of Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627, U.S.A. [1] [2]
[3] [4] [5] [6]
[7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14]
[151 [16]
[17] [18] [19]
[20]
H.A. Kramers, Physica (Utrecht) 7, 284(1940). L.D. Zusmann, Chem. Phys. 49, 295(1980). I. Rips, J. Klafter, and J. Jortner, J. Chem. Phys. 94,8557(1990). J. Jortner and M. Bixon, J. Chem. Phys. 87, 167(1988). H. Sumi and R.A. Marcus, J. Chem. Phys. 84,4894(1986). E. M. Kosower and D. Huppert, Chem. Phys. Lett. 96,433(1983). M. A. Kalow, T. J. Kang, and P. F. Barbara, J. Phys. Chem. 91, 6452(1987). J. D. Simon and S.-G. Su, J. Phys. Chem. 92, 2395(1998). R. M. Neison, G. E. McManis, M. N. Golovin, and M. J. Weaver, J. Phys. Chem. 92, 3441(1998). T. Kobayashi, Y. Takagi, H. Kandori, K. Kemnitz and K. Yoshihara, Chem. Phys. Lett. 180,416(1991). H. Kandori, K. Kemnitz, and K. Yoshihara, J. Chem. Phys. 96, 8042(1992). A. Yartsev, Y. Nagasawa, A. Douhal, and K. Yoshihara, Chem. Phys. Lett. 207, 546(1993). Y. Nagasawa, A.P. Yartsev, K. Tominaga, A.E. Johnson, and K. Yoshihara, J. Chem. Phys. 101, 5717(1994). Y. Nagasawa, A. P. Yartsev, K. Tominaga, P. B. Bisht, A. E. Johnson, and K. Yoshihara, J. Phys. Chem., in press. G. C. Walker, E. Akesson, A. E. Johnson, N. E. Levinger, and P. F. Barbara, J. Phys. Chem. 96, 3728(1992). B. Bagchi, D. W. Oxtoby, and G. R. Fleming, Chem. Phys. 86, 257(1984). M. Maroncelli and G. R. Fleming, J. Chem. Phys. 86, 6221 (1987). M. A. Kahlow, T. J. Kang, and P. F. Barbara, J. Chem. Phys. 88, 2372(1988). M. A. Kahlow, W. Jarzeba, T. J. Kang, and P. F. Barbara, J. Chem. Phys. 90, 151(1989). R. A. Marcus, Discuss. Faraday Soc. 29, 21(1960).
journal of
~IOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of MolecularLiquids, 65/66 (1995) 65-73
Theory on Rates of Solution Reactions Influenced by Slow Fluctuations in Viscous Solvents, and its Experimental Confirmation Hitoshi Sumi Institute of Materials Science, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305, Japan Abstract Recently much attention has been aroused on solution reactions whose rates decrease as the viscosity r / o f solvents increases. These reactions cannot be rationalized in the framework of the transition state theory. To describe them, two currents of theories have been developed by extending the Kramers theory. One was initiated by Grote and Hynes, while the other by Sumi and Marcus. Recent data on thermal Z/E isomerization of substituted azobenzenes and N-benzylideneanilines confirms the applicability of the latter for r/variation over 104 times under pressure.
I.
Introduction
The most traditional theory for chemical reaction rates is the transition state theory (TST) established in 1940's. It has recently been disclosed, however, that the TST cannot be applied to varieties of solution reactions. Examples can be found in biological enzymatic reactions ~, electron or proton transfer reactions2, atom-group transfer reactions 3, and isomerization reactions4. Study of solution reactions is one of the most traditionalas well as the most fundamental subjects in chemistry. The situation mentioned above means, nevertheless, that we have not yet established a general expression on rates of solution reactions. Accordingly, many discussions have been stimulated for investigating the unknown general expression. 5 In the TST, it is assumed a priori that fluctuations in the reactant state are so fast that the distribution of populations in the reactant state is always maintained in thermal equilibrium in the course of the reaction. Then, also the population of reactants in the transition state is always maintained in thermal equilibrium with those in the reactant state, and the rate constant can be calculated from the population at the transition state, which is determined only by the shape of the free-energy surface, without knowledge on dynamics of fluctuations for realizing the transition state. In this assumption, therefore, the rate constant should not depend on how fast fluctuations are in the reactant state. Molecular arrangements of the solute-solvent system in solution can take various conformations. They fluctuate from time to time due to shaking and/or damping by microscopic motions of solvent molecules. Since the speed of these conformational fluctuations decreases as the viscosity r / o f solvents increases, r/-' can be regarded as a measure of the speed. In the solution reactions mentioned earlier, the rate constant observed decreases as r/increases, that is, as r/-l decreases. This means that the rate constant of these solution reactions depends on the speed of conformational fluctuations in the solute-solvent system, and hence that these reactions are nonthermalized reactions located outside the framework of the TST. To be more exact, these reactions are controlled by slow speeds of these fluctuations. The first theory giving the 0-induced decrease of the rate constant is the Kramers theory6 presented as early as in 1940. He explicitly treated dynamical processes of fluctuations in the reactant state, not assuming a priori the thermal equilibrium distribution therein. His reaction scheme can be understood in Fig. 1 which shows, along a reaction coordinate X, a double-well potential W(X) composed of a reactant and a product well with a transition-state barrier between them. Reaction takes place as a result of diffusive Brownian motions of reactants surmounting 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995 ElsevierScience B.V. All rights reserved. SSD! 0167-7322 (95) 00903-5
66
Figure 1. Potential curve W(X) for reaction in the Kramers scheme along the reaction coordinate X, and an example of reactive trajectories there. over the transition-statebarrier,as shown by a zigzag trajectory in Fig. I. In this situation, when the reactant population found in the interval from X to X 4 4 X at time t is written as P(X;t)dX, the distribution function P(X;O satisfiesthe Smoluchowski equation describing diffusion of reactants under the influence of a potential fielddue to W(X), as -~
t~X - ~ + ~ ksT
--
P( X ;t) ,
(1)
where D represents the diffusion constant and T the temperature. The diffusion constant D describes frictional effects arising from shaking and/or damping by microscopic motions of solvent molecules, and can be regarded as inversely proportional to the viscosity 7/of solvents, obeying the hydrodynamic Stokes-Einstein relation. When r/and hence D -I are sufficiently small in his theory, rapid diffusive motions make populations in the reactant well to be quickly recovered and maintained in the thermal-equilibrium form in the course of reaction, and the rate constant reduces to that expected from the TST. As 77 and hence D -t increase, however, the diffusive motions become slow, and the reaction becomes limited by their slow speed. In this non-TST regime, the rate constant given by his theory decreases in proportion to r/"t. Concerning the 7/dependence of the rate constant of solution reactions, most often investigated experimentally is photoinduccd E/Z (trans/cis)isomcrization of stilbencs.4 The isomcrization takes place by surmounting over a transition-statebarrier on the excited-state potential surface. The reaction is very fastwith a rate constant on the order of I010 s-' due to a small height (of about 15 kJ/mol) of the barrier.The rate constant observed in solvents kob s decreases as 7/increases. To be more exact, however, kob s often decreases more slowly than
r/-t,describable by a fractional-power dependence on 77-i as /Cobs o~ rl-a with 0 < o~ < I. Therefore, the 7/dependence of/Cot,s deviates from that expected from the Kramers theory. To understand the slow r/dependence of kob s, approximately two currents of theories have been developed by extending the Kramers theory. One was initiatedby Grote and Hynes 7 in 1980. They considered that frictionfeltby reactants should decrease when they surmount over the transition-statebarrier with a high speed. In thiscase, the rate constant in the non-TST regime should not be as small as expected from the Kramers theory, and hence its r/dependence should be milder than 7/"~expected from the Kramcrs theory. This idea of frequency (that is,s ~ ) dependent frictioncan be formulated by the generalized Langevin equation describing time (t) dependent stochastic motions of the position X(t) of a reactant along the reaction coordinate X in the field of the double-well potential W(X), as
d2X(t__._.___2)dW[X(t)] dt 2
=-
t ~ ( t - t' ) dX(t') d t ' + R(t) _ L** dX(t--------~ dr '
(2)
67
where R(t) represents random forces and ~ ( t - t ' ) (>0) represents the frictional memory function. The second term on the right-hand side of eq.(2) describes frictional forces whose strength at time t comes also from the magnitude of the reactant velocity dX(t)ldt' in the past at time t' (< t) through a nonvanishing tail of the frictional memory function ((z') at z= t - t' (> 0). Both R(t) and ((t) arise from a single origin of microscopic motions of solvent molecules interacting with reactants. Then, they must be related to each other. This relation is known as the fluctuation-dissipation theorem, and is written as
( R(t) R(t' )) = kBr ~(t - t' ) ,
(3)
where ( . - . ) represents the thermal average over microscopic motions of solvent molecules. Actual fitting of rate constants observed for stilbenes to that given by the Grote-Hynes theory was performed by several authors s. They all pointed out coincidentally that the fitting could be made only by adopting an unphysically small value for the downward curvature (the square of a frequency written as cot, later) of the potential W(X) at the top of the transition-state barrier. The Kramers theory corresponds to a limit of eq.(2) that the correlation time.between t and t' in eq.(3) is so short that ~ ( t - t' ) can be regarded as proportional to a delta function tJ(t- t3. In this case, the second term on the right-hand side of eq.(2) becomes proportional to dX(t)/dt, losing frictional memory effects, and the generalized Langevin equation (3) reduces to the Langevin equation, from which the Smoluchowski equation (1) can be derived. 9 The other current of theories for understanding the observed slow 7/dependence of the rate constant was initiated by Sumi and Marcus l~ in 1986. It corresponds to an extension of a theory by Agmon and Hopfield II for understanding rebinding kinetics of O 2 or CO molecules in hemoglobin. In this model, conformational fluctuations of intermolecular arrangement in the solute-solvent system take a reactant only midway to the transition-state barrier along the coordinate X, and final surmounting over the barrier is accomplished with the aid of much faster intramolecular vibrational fluctuations in the solute molecule, possible at each value of the coordinate X. Therefore, the reaction takes place as a result of sequential two steps which can be described in a two-dimensional potential surface shown in Fig.2. This surface is spanned by the coordinate X for conformational fluctuations in the solute-solvent system on the abscissa and by the other coordinate q for intramolecular vibrations in the solute molecule on the ordinate. Potential energies are shown by equi-energy contours in Fig.2. The part below the line C represents the reactant-state surface while the part above it represents the product-state surface. These two parts meet at the line C with the same energies, and hence the line C can be called the transition-state line. Energies on this line becomes minimum at the point S, which therefore represents the location of the transition state. Intramolecular vibrational fluctuations along the coordinate q on the ordinate are much faster than diffusive Brownian fluctuations of intermolecular arlatoa,ra surfotm
Reoztant tutfoce
Figure 2. Two-dimensional potential surface for reaction in the Sumi-Marcus scheme along the coordinate X for diffusive Brownian motions and the coordinate q for much faster intramolecular vibrational motions, and an example of reactive trajectories there.
68 rangements along the coordinate X. Then, the surmount over the transition-state barrier is possible with the aid of fast intramolecular vibrations at each fixed value of the slow coordinate X over the transition-state line C determined at this value of X. An example of reactive trajectories is shown in Fig.2. This shows that when the coordinate X fluctuating diffusively along the abscissa in the reactant surface gets an appreciable amplitude as described by a zigzag trajectory, fast intramolecular vibrational fluctuations along the ordinate let the reactant surmount over the transition-state line C as described by a vertical straight trajectory. After that, the system relaxes on the product surface, again by diffusive motions along the abscissa described by a zigzag trajectory there. Since the surmount over the transition-state line C takes place most favorably at X values around that of the transition-state point S, it is not necessary for the reactant to surmount over the barrier only by diffusive Brownian motions, at the point Xc in Fig.2 along the abscissa for q = 0. In the situation mentioned above, we can define a rate constant k(X) determined at each value of X for the surmount over the transition-state line C vertically along the coordinate q at this fixed value of X. Then, the distribution function P(X;t) for reactants with an intermolecular arrangement described by a coordinate value X at time t obeys, instead of the diffusion equation (1), a diffusion-reaction equation in the potential along the abscissa for q = 0, written as V(X), as
-0
Ot
P(X;t)
:oAFA
+ I c)X L ~)X k n T
dv(x)] P ( X ; t ) dX
k(x)P(X;t) .
(4)
The essential difference between eqs. (1) and (4) is the presence of the last term on the righthand side of eq.(4), and it describes loss of reactants by reactions during diffusion along X. The diffusion constant D is regarded as inversely proportional to the solvent viscosity r/as before, while k(X) is independent of r/, determined by intramolecular vibrational motions. It was shown by the present authod 2 that this Sumi-Marcus model gives as a rate constant k=l/(krsr -l+kf -l),
with
kf>O,
(5)
where kTSTrepresents the TST-expected rate constant independent of D (*~ r/-t), while kf(> 0) represents a part influenced by the speed of conformational fluctuations which become slower and slower as the solvent viscosity 7/increases. To be more exact, kf decreases with 7/as
kf ~ r / - a ,
with
0
(6)
This fractional-power dependence of kf on 7/"l can be obtained in the natural situation that k(X) has a nonvanishing width in X. When krs r << k / i n the low viscosity region, eq. (5) reduces to k = krs r, recovering the result of the TST. When kf << krs r in the high viscosity region, on the other hand, eq.(5) reduces to k = ky *~ r/-a, and the rate constant decreases more slowly than r/-l, as observed in photoisomerization of stilbenes in solvents 4. The rate constant of photoinduced isomerization of stilbenes in solvents, however, always decreases as r/increases. This seems to mean that the rate constant is so large because of a low height of the transition-state barrier that the reaction has already been controlled in solvents by a slow speed of conformational fluctuations in the solute-solvent system. This situation itself is very interesting, but is not most convenient from the standpoint of investigating the general expression for the rate constant of solution reactions. More adequate is a situation that the rate constant can be described by the TST in the small r/region, but decreases with r/in the large r/region, entering the non-TST regime. Such a situation was recently reported by Asano and his collaborators 13 with the pressure dependence of rate constants of thermal Z/E isomerization of substituted azobenzenes and N-benzylideneanilines. Their data enables us to determine which current of theories initiated by Grote and Hynes or by Sumi and Marcus is more appropriate.
69
Experimental Check of Theories by Thermal Isomerization in Solvents Although substituted azobenzenes and N-benzylideneanilines are similar in structure to stilbenes, the reaction investigated with these molecules was the recovering of the E form from the Z form obtained after the photoinduced E/Z isomerization, which was investigated for stilbenes. Differently from the E/Z photoisomerization of stilbenes, the Z/E reaction takes place slowly with a rate constant smaller than about 103 s -~ by surmounting over a high transition-state barrier (with height of about 50 kJ/mol) on the ground-state potential surface. 13The solvent viscosity 77 was changed over about 108 times by pressures. In the low-pressure region, the rate constant of this reaction showed a pressure dependence understandable in the framework of the TST. In the high-pressure region, on the other hand, it steeply decreased as the pressure increased, to be more exact, as 77 increased with the pressure. In this non-TST regime, the observed rate constant kobs showed a fractional-power dependence on 77"l, as observed for stilbenes in solvents. It was shown by a joint work of Asano and Sumi 14that the pressure (or, viscosity) dependence of kobs mentioned above could nicely be fitted to eqs.(5) and (6) derived from the SumiMarcus model. As concrete examples in molecules investigated experimentally in refs. 13 and 14, we take 4-(dimethylamino)-4'-nitroazobenzene (DNAB) and N-[4-(dimethylamino)benzylidene]4-nitroaniline (DBNA), since these molecules showed widest ranges of rate-constant variation with pressure. Solvents used were glycerol triacetate (GTA) which is polar, and Traction Fluid B (TFB) which is essentially nonpolar, being a commercial product composed mainly of 2,4dicyclohexyl-2-methylpentane. The structure of DNAB and DBNA is shown in Fig.3 together with the schematic profile of the ground (So)- and the excited (S 1)-state potential surfaces. The photoinduced reaction cycle of these molecules proceeds on these potential surfaces as follows: In the photoinduced E/Z isomerization process, denoted by 1 in Fig.3, a molecule with the stable form E on the S O potential surface is photoexcited to the S 1 surface, from which, surmounting over a small potential barrier, the molecule drops to an intermediate state at the lowest point of the S 1 surface. Then, the molecule makes a transition to the top of the S O surface, from which, along the S O surface, about half of it relax to the Z form and the remaining half relax to the original E form. In this process 1, surmounting over the potential barrier on the S 1 surface is rate limiting. Then, measuring a rise of population in the Z form, we can determine the rate constant of the barrier surmounting, as performed for stilbenes. Since the Z form is metastable on the S O surface, higher than the E form, it gradually transforms itself to the E form, surmounting over a potential barrier with height ,4 shown in Fig.3. This process is denoted by 2. Process 1 is very fast because of a low barrier on the S 1 surface. In stilbenes, the barrier height is about 15 kJ/mol and this process takes about 100 ps after photoexcitation, 4 as mentioned in Section 1. Process 2 is, on the other hand, slow because of a high barrier on the S O II.
S1
X- CH:DBNA~ X=N:DNAB
1
~O2 2
NMe2
. . . . .
Z
E
NO2
X=N NMo2
Figure 3. Molecular structure of DBNA and DNAB, and their photocycle composed of E/Z isomerization (process 1) and ZIE isomerization on the ground (So)- and the excited (S 1)-state potential surfaces.
70
surface. In both DNAB and DBNA, the barrier height is about 50 kJ/mol and this process takes at least about 1 ms at room temperature for DBNA. It is about 103 times slower for DNAB where polarity increase occurs at the transition state due to a reconstruction of electronic structures 15.t6 that NMe2 and NO2 in Fig.3 are converted into NMe2 + and NO2 in association with conversion of the X-N double bond into a single bond around which DNAB twists for reaction. Such an increase in polarity does not occur in isomerization of DNBA which proceeds via an inversion transition state, t5.16 Anyhow, in measurements with time resolution longer than I ns, we observe as if process 1 took place simultaneously after photoexcitation, followed slowly by process 2. In order for the reaction to take place with the mechanism in the Grote-Hynes theory as well as in the Kramers theory, the reactant must surmount over the transition-state barrier only by diffusional Brownian motions regulated by solvent fluctuations. In the two-step mechanism of the Sumi-Marcus model, on the other hand, surmounting over the transition-state barrier is accomplished as a result of sequential two steps. That is, the barrier is climbed ftrst by diffusional Brownian motions only up to intermediate heights, from which much faster intramolecular vibrational motions take the reactant to the transition state located at the top of the barrier. It is apparent, therefore, that differences between these two mechanisms manifest themselves most drastically when the transition-state barrier is much higher than the thermal energy kBT which is about 2.5 kJ/mol for T = 300 K. In this res~e~_t, isomerization of substituted azobenzenes and N-benzylideneanilines with a barrier height t3.t of about 50 kJ/mol on the S O surface is more interesting than photoisomerization of stilbenes with a barrier height 4 of only about 15 kJ/mol on the S 1 surface, if we can cast the former into solvent-fluctuation controlled under pressure. The observed pressure dependence of the rate constant kobs for thermal isomerization of DBNA in TFB and DNAB in GTA is shown respectively in parts (a) and (b) of Fig.4. Detailed experimental setup for the measurement was described in Refs. 13 and 14. The viscosity 77 of these solvents was determined also in Refs. 13 and 14 by best fitting of 77 values measured at several pressures P with a formula of log r/*, P since they met this formula in the whole P region used. The solvents remained transparent in this region without any indication of phase change. In Fig.4(a) for DBNA in TFB, ko/. is nearly independent of pressure when P < 100 MPa (= 1000 bar). This behavior can well be understood in the framework of the TST as a situation =5 that the volume of the reactant is almost unchanged between the reactant and the transition states. In Fig.4(b) for DNAB in GTA, on the other hand, kobs increases as P increases when P < 250 MPa (= 2500 bar). This behavior can also be understood with the TST as a situation of a negative activation volume 16that the transition state has a volume smaller than the reactant state. This difference between DBNA in TFB and DNAB in GTA in the activation volume in the TST regime arises 1000
AAAAAAAAAAAAAA
9
100-
A
A
A
A
&
&
0
0
0
000000
~176176176176176
A
4-
A
2-
*
A
10
9 278 K O 288K & 298 K 9 308K
I
(a)
I 0
50
10-.
A
6 0 9
o O 9
& o
4-" = 2-
o 0
kob=
DNAB in GTA
0
1
9 9
(sec")
20.1-
DBNA in TFB I
I
I
I
150
200
250
Pressure (MPa)
O
A O
& A
0 0
O
I-
4
300
0 (b)
0 9
4 9
100
&
9 A
kob,
9
9
A
A
A
A
0
0
0
0
9
9
(sec")
9
A
9
9
9
A A
0 9
A &
*
9 278 K O 288K A 298K 9 313 K i
i
I
200
400
600
I
8O0
Pressure (MPa)
Figure 4. Pressure dependence of the rate constant kobs of thermal Z/E isomerization of DBNA in TFB [part (a)] and DNAB in GTA [part (b)] at temperatures around 300 K.
71 1000=
§
2100~
§
h
4
2-
+
k~
o O 8 ~ o
+
o
4
0
DBNA I 50
in TFB
i 100
(El)
I 150
at
I 300
Pressure (MPa)
9
6
0
4)
DNAB in GTA at 2 9 8 K I 200
0.1 0
Co)
9
+
0
2-
I 250
9
1 ' e" 4-"
278 K i 200
kT~
o
0
0
S.1 4". 2-
os~
2-
h +
2-
ooooooe8~o o;tooooooo ~ ~ +
I0=
1
+
4"
0
s-I
§
100 7 .
+
4
i 400
i 600
I"' 800
Pressure (MPa)
Figure 5. Decomposition of kobs into kTS T and k./for DBNA at 278 K and DNAB at 298 K. from the difference in the static solute-solvent interaction, mentioned earlier, that the polarity at the transition state increases in a polar solvent in the latter, causing electrostriction there, while does not in a nonpolar solvent in the former. Fitting of the pressure dependence of kobs by the TST with an appropriate activation volume in the low pressure region was performed in Refs. 13 and 14. Then, analytically extrapolating the pressure dependence to the high-pressure region, we can obtain the TST-expected rate constant kTST in the entire pressure region. It is shown in Fig.5. In the low-pressure region, kobs is the same as kTST, but in the high-pressure region, kob s deviates downward from kTS T. This means that kob s can be expressed in the form of eq.(5). The kf derived by expressing kobs in the form of eq.(5) is also shown in Fig.5 together with kob s. The. pressure dependence of kf obtained above was converted to its dependence on the solvent viscosity 77 determined at each pressure. It is shown in Fig.6. We see therein that kf has indeed the 77 dependence of eq.(6) and it is satisfied for 77 variation extending over 104 times. We see thus that thermal isomerization of substituted azobenzenes and N-benzylideneanilines in solvents has rate constants which can well be rationalized in the framework of the Sumi-Marcus model which gives eqs.(5) and (6). More detailed discussions can be found in Ref. 14. Next, let us discuss whether the Grote-Hynes theory can be fitted to the rate constants kob s. In this thoery, kobslkTs T is related to the frequency (that is, the speed)/,t with which the reactant passes, by diffusive Brownian motions, through the transition-state-barrier region in Fig. 1, as
~oo~.
1000-
,-
4-
2:
2-
100-...
lO~
s.1 4! 2. 10-
s.1
,!
2:
1
(a)
103
1s" 4"
DBNA in TFB at 278 K ' ' '"'"1
10 4
'
,
,,
" ....I ' ' " ....I 10 s 10 6 10 7 Viscosity 11 (Pa s)
' '"'"1
' '
' '
'""1 10 a
4.. 2-
(b)
102
DNAB in GTA at 298 K '
' ' '""1
10 3
'
' " '""1
'
' ' '""1
10 4 10 s Viscosity 11 (Pa s)
'
' ' '""1
10 8
Figure 6. Viscosity dependence of kffor DBNA in TFB at 278 K and DNAB in GTA at 298 K.
72
kob,lkrsr
= l~lcob ,
and
/~lCOb = COb/[l~ +
g'(/~)],
(7)
where rob represents the imaginary frequency at the top of the barrier proportional to the square root of the downward curvature there and ~'(,u) represents the frequency dependent friction defined by the Fourier transform of the frictional memory function ~(t) in eq.(2), as
r
= SO ~(t)e-#tdt
We can derive the correlation time
(8)
"
~;sc of random forces in eq.(2) from (R(t)R(O))/(R(O) 2) by
~sc = ~o (R(t)R(O))/(R(O) 2) at .
(9)
Then the correlation function can be regarded as a function f(x) of a scaled variable x = t/'csc,as
/(tl~,~) = (R(t)R(O))I(R(O)2) = ~(t)/~(0),
with
/(0) = ~
(~0)
where the second equality is obtained from eq.(3). Equation (9) ensures ~o f(x)dx = I. W h e n
the Laplace transform of f(x) atthe Laplace variable 21,is written as F(/I,),eqs.(8)- (I0) give
F(/a~sc) - ~of(X)e-~'cXdx = ~(#)/~'(0).
(ll)
From Fig.5, we can get kobs/kTsT as a function of pressure. If it is describable by the Grote-Hynes theory, eq.(7) enables us to determine both # and ~'(#) at each kobs/kTsT and hence at each pressure P or viscosity r/, where rob should have a magnitude on the order of 10 B st
in eq.(7),s In eq.( l l) the zero-frequency friction ~'(0)can reasonably be regarded as given by the hydrodynamic Stokes-Einstein relation,proportional to 77.sThen we can determine F(l.t"rsc) at each 77 from eq.( I l). It is smaller than 10 "s at any 7"/orP where kobs/kTsT was determined from Fig.5, as explicitly shown in Ref. 17. The firstequality in eq.( l l) ensures that F(/I,)<< l can be obtained only for A >> I, and in this case F(;t) is nearly equal to I/:t. Since F(g "rsc)< I0 -s as mentioned above, we get F(l.t"rsc)= (Iz ~sc)l, and the second equality in eq.(l I) gives
~'sc= g-l ~'(0)/~'(g). Since all of/z, ((,u) and ~'(0) have been determined at each 77 or P, we can determine a ~:~cvalue which is required in order to describe the experimental data in Fig.4 by the Grote-Hynes theory. As explicitly shown in Ref. 17, ~:semust be as large as about 50 ns at 17 = 100 Pa. s at 308 K and about 5 ms at 77 = 5 x 107 Pa. s at 278 K for D B N A in ITB, and about 10 ns at 77 = 20 Pa. s at 313 K and about I ms at r/= 107 Pa. s at 278 K for D N A B in GTA. These requirements cannot be satisfiedin real systems, since "cscshould be at most on the order of I ps, as explained below: The average decay rate, l/ "csc,of the correlation function of eq.(3) should be on the order of the width of frequency distributionof solvent microscopic motions interacting with the reaction coordinate,isW a v e lengths of these motions must be at most on the order of the dimension, of several angstroms, of isomerizing moieties. It has been shown by inelastic neutron scattering of molecular liquidsI~ that even for a fixed value of wave length of this order, their frequencies have a width on the order of I T H z = I/(l ps). W e see thus that the experimental data in Fig.4 cannot be described by the Grote-Hynes theory. Discrepancies between the required and the reasonable values of "rscare so huge that the conclusion obtained above is unaltered
73 even if the Stokes-Einstein relation giving ~'(0) *~ 7/was violated so much, as shown in Ref. 17. The temperature dependence of kobs in the non-TST regime deserves also mentioning in relation to differences between the Grote-Hynes model and the Sumi-Marcus model. In the latter it corresponds to that of k f in the limit of this regime where kobs = ky in eq.(5). The thermal activation energy of kobs = kTST in the TST regime is given by the height of the lowest point S on the transition-state line C in Fig.2, while under the isoviscosity condition that of kf is given approximately by the height of the point on the abscissa with the same X value as point S. Then, in the Sumi-Marcus model the thermal activation energy of kobs under the isoviscosity condition should be considerably smaller in the non-TST regime than in the TST regime. In the Grote-Hynes model, on the other hand, it should be unchanged in both the TST and the non-TST regimes, since the reactant must surmount over a same barrier in any situation in Fig. 1. The r/dependence of k f was shown in Fig.6 only at 278 K for D B N A in TFB and at 298 K for DNAB in GTA. Points of k f vs. 71 at other temperatures were observed to line up approximately along the same straight line in Fig.6 or its extension for both DBNA in TFB and DNAB in GTA. ~4This fact means that the cr value in eq.(6) is nearly independent of temperature, and also that the isoviscosity activation energy of k f is nearly vanishing. In general, that of kot,s was considerably smaller in the nonTST regime at high viscosities than in the TST regime at low viscosities. This is another reason why thermal isomerization of these molecules cannot be described by the Grote-Hynes theory. The rate constant with the form of eq.(5) can be obtained only when reaction takes place as a result of sequential two (or more) steps. It is easy 14 to prove eq.(5) for a single intermediate state M, but in this case the o~ value in eq.(6) reduces to unity. It is when M is continuously distributed [described by a continuous variable X in eq.(4)] that a becomes smaller than unity. ~2 This form of eq.(5) has been used also by Troe 2~ for describing the pressure dependence of photoisomerization rates of stilbenes in solvents, without specifying sequential two steps underlying it.
Acknowledgments: This work was accomplished in collaboration with Professor T. Asano of Oita university. He is sincerely acknowledged for valuable discussions in preparing this paper. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
For example, N.G. Goguadze, J.M. Hammerstad-Pedersen, D.E. Khoshtariya and J. Ulstrup, Eur. J. Biochem. 200, 423 (1991). As a review, M.J. Weaver and G.E. McManis HI, Acc. Chem. Res. 23, 294 (1990). For example, P.J. Steinbach et al., Biochem. 30, 3988 (1991). As a review, D.H. Waldeck, Chem. Res. 91, 415 (1991). For example, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 95, no.3 (1991), Rate Processes in Dissipative Systems. H.A. Kramers, Physica 7, 284 (1940). R.F. Grote and J.T. Hynes, J. Chem. Phys. 73, 2715 (1980), and 74, 4465 (1981). B. Bagchi and D.W. Oxtoby, J. Chem. Phys. 78, 2735 (1983); G. Rothenberger, D.K. Negus and R.M. Hochstrasser, J. Chem. Phys. 79, 5360 (1983); S.K. Kim and G.R. Fleming, J. Phys. Chem. 92, 2168 (1988); & N. Sivakumar, E.A. Hoburg and D.H. Waldeck, J. Chem. Phys. 90, 2305 (1989); see also, as a review article, B. Bagchi, Internat. Rev. Phys. Chem. 6, 1 (1987). N.G. van Kampen, Stochastic Processes in Physics and Chemistry (North-Holland: Amsterdam, 1992). H. Sumi and R.A. Marcus, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 4894 (1986). N. Agmon and J.J. Hopfield, J. Chem. Phys. 78, 6947 (1983). H. Sumi, J. Phys. Chem. 95, 3334 (1991). K. Cosstick, T. Asano and N. Ohno, High Pressure Res. 11, 37 (1992). T. Anaso, H. Furuta and H. Sumi, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116, 5545 (1994). T. Asano et al., J. Org. Chem. 58, 4418 (1993), and earlier papers cited therein. T. Asano and T. Okada, J. Org. Chem. 51, 4454 (1986), and earlier papers cited therein. H. Sumi and T. Asano, Chem. Phys. Lett. (1995), and J. Chem. Phys. 102, no.24 (1995), in press. R. Zwanzig, J. Stat. Phys. 9, 215 (1973); E. Cortes, B.J. West and K. Lindenberg, J. Chem. Phys. 82, 2708 (1985); & B.J. Gertner, K.R. Wilson and J.T. Hynes, J. Chem. Phys. 90, 3537 (1989). F.J. Bermejo, F. Batallan, J.L. Martinez, M. Garcia-Hemandez and E. Enciso, J. Phys. Condens. Matter 2, 6659 (1990), & E.G.D. Cohen, P. Westerhuijs and I.M. de Schepper, Phys. Rev. Lett. 59, 2872 (1987). J. Troe, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 95, 228 (1991), and earlier papers cited therein.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
journal of MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molecular Liquids. 65/66 (1995) 75-83
D y n a m i c s of Brownian motion under a potential and theory on the rate of chemical reactions A k i o Morita
D e p a r t m e n t of Chemistry, College of Arts and Sciences, University of T o k y o , K o m a b a , M e g u r o - k u , T o k y o 153, J a p a n
Abstract We have introduced a two square-well potential system, solved the Smoluchowski equation, calculated exactly the concentration of the reactant, compared it to that resulting from the phenomenological rate equations and finally obtained expressions for rate constants for a first-order reversible reaction. It is found that the pre-exponential factors for both constants are just the diffusion coefficients divided by the square of the widths of potential wells. Our expressions for rate constants satisfy a relation between standard free energy and the equilibrium constant arising from chemical thermodynamics. We have also developed a general theory on the relaxation processes of approachment of a system to the equilib~Sum Boltzmann for an arbitrary potential with sufficiently deep well and the escape rate from the well for an asymptotically long time limit of the reaction, which enables us to calculate the rate constants for given potentials. Furthermore, we obtained the rate constant for a dissociation reaction of an ion-pair interacting through the Coulomb potential and found a maximum as the sum of the radii of the ion-pair increases.
I.
Introduction
In formulating the rate constant based a dynamical equation such as the Fokker-Planck-Kramers equation, the Smoluchowski equation and etc., we usually use the assumption of stationary state [1, 2, 3]. However, it is sometimes the case where dynamical information is suppressed by the assumption that the flux of Brownian particles must be uniform in space. It is thus sensible to calculate the rate constant by taking the dynamics explicitly. To this end, we must bear in our mind time scales of the dynamics. Imagine the diffusion of solute particles in solvent by regarding the position of a particle x as a reaction coordinate. When it diffuses on a fiat potential, the time scale we must be concerned with is of course that of diffusion, which is much longer than collision time between the solvent and solute molecules. Now, suppose it moves under a square-wen potential and its height is infinitively high, the main time scale will be roughly a relaxation time of the order of the square of the width of the potential bottom divided by the diffusion constant, which determines time approaching to an equilibrium state after colliding with the potential walls several times before settling into it. However, as lowering the potential height slightly, we see that the particles can now escape from the well after colliding with the potential walls much more times, which makes the time scale much longer to settle the motion. This is precisely why the exponential factor comes into play. The time scale in this region may be called a reaction time which is determined from the diffusion at potential bottom and the barrier height leading to the pre-exponential and exponential factors, respectively. We will be interested in tiffs long reaction time so that time scales representing molecular motion in small changes are trivial. In tiffs paper, we will devote ourselves to finding this reaction time based on the recent development on investigation of the dynamics of Brownian motion under a square-well potential [4]. Furthennore, we will develope a general theory for an arbitrary potential to obtain the reaction time. With this 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. SSD! 0167-7322 (95) 0(0)003
76
new method, we will be able to calculate the rate constants for given potentials. Also, this general theory enables us to estimate how fast a system approaches to the Boltzmann distribution in the reaction time-scale. We shall apply the theory to single minimum with a single maximum, double wells and the Coulomb potentials. Our aim of this study also includes how a potential without the curvatures affects the rate of reaction by remembering that they axe essential in Kramers' theory [1].
II.
Theory and discussion
r(x)
-------
We begin with the following Smoluchowski equation describing the Brownian motion under a potential V(x) for the probability density p(x, t):
L
c3p(x,t) Ot
0 [O,,p(x,t) = o--~ l
1
dV(x)
]
Ox " + kB----T d-----x---p(x't)
J
(1) which may be written after taking the Laplace transform with respect to t
dg(x,A) dx Figure 1" Parameters for the two square-weU potential where Ai = a i / k B T ,
dJ(x,A) dx
---- -eV(x)/kBT J(x, A)
(2)
= _A2e_V(x)/ksTg(x,A ) -t-~(x--xo)
(3)
where g(X,A) -- eV(z)/kaTp(x,A) and J(x, t) is the flux defined by
J(x,t)
-
1 dV(x) ] - [Op(x,t) l Ox + kB'--T d ~ p(x't)
Unless otherwise stated, we denote f(x,A) -"
f(x,t)e-~tdt
~0~176
with s = A2
that is, f(x,A) is the Laplace transform of f ( x , t ) with respect to t. Before treating a general case for an arbitrary potential V(x), we shall consider a specific and simple nmdel of a two square-well potential and obtain an exact solution to show how the reaction time may be found so that our approach will be clarified. It should be emphasized that in treating the Brownian motion with a discontinuous V(x) such as the two-square-well potential sketched in Figure 1., we must use Eqs. (2) and (3), otherwise we do not recover the Boltzmann distribution in the hmit of t ~ ~ . It follows immediately from Fig. 1 that the equihbrium Boltzmann distribution function, peq(X) is given by
peq(X) = [ H ( x ) - H ( x - L1)]e A' + [H(x - Ll) - H ( x - L2)] + [H(x - L2) - H ( x L(e Al + l + e A3)
L3)]e A3
77
where H ( x ) is the Heaviside step function, i. e. H ( x ) = 0 for x < 0 and H ( x ) = 1 for x > 0. Eqs. (2) and (3) readily leads to the following solution for a flat potential V ( x ) = - A k B T X(x,~)
(4)
= A ( x - a , A ) X ( a ) 4- H ( x - x o ) A ( x - x o , ~ ) B
where X ( x , )~) ---
g(x,~) J(x, )~)
'
A(x,)~) -
cosh()~x)
--)~eAsinh()~x)
'
B =
1
We can use this result for obtaining the solution for the present potential in Fig. 1 by introducing the boundary conditions JI(0,)Q = 0,
JI(LI,)~)=J2(L1,)Q,
J3(La,)Q = 0
J2(L2,)Q=J3(L2,)~),
(5)
and e-A1pl(L1,A)
= p2(L1,A),
p2(L2, A) = e - A s p 3 ( L 2 , ~ )
(6)
which enable us to write X l ( x , A) = A(x, A)X(0, ~) + H ( x - xo)A(x - zo, A)B
(0 < x <_ L1)
X2(x,)~) -- A ( x - L1,)t)X(L1,)~)
(L1 < x _< L2)
X3(x,)~) = A ( x -
(L2 < x <_ La)
L2,)QX(L2,)t)
where we have divided X(x,A) into three regions according to the divisions of potential in Fig. 1. Note in Eqs. (5) and (6) that although the fluxes are continuous, the densities are not just like the potential. Number of particles in the region 0 < x g L, N1 (t) can be obtained from
N~(~) = - ~ 1 {cosh[)~(L - xo)l - 1} + (1 + e A a ) c o s h ( $ L ) s i n h ( $ L ) s i n h [ A ( L -
xo)] + e A~ cosh[)~(x- xo)][cosh2(AL) + e As sinh2()~L)]
~2 [eA,+As sinh2()~L) + (1 + e A~ + eA3)cosh2($L)]
(7) The inverse Laplace transform of the above expression can be found by noting that there are simple poles at 1 s , = An2 = - ~-ff(n~r :t: sin-lq) 2 ( n = 0,1,2 .... ) (8) where i q=
14. e A~ 4- e Aa e A~+Aa 4. 1 4. e A~ 4- e As
We are particularly interested in so 1 so = -~--ff(sin -1 q)2 We see that A1 = A2 - 0 leads to q = vf3/2, which is equivalent to sin-lq = r / 3 that corresponds to the maximum value, and by increasing both A1 and A3, sin-lq approaches to zero asymptotically. When these are very large, it follows that sO ; - - -q2 ~
whereas
1 n27r2 sn = - L2
( n -- 1, 2, 3 .... )
78
Since the contribution from s, makes the relaxation much faster than that from so, for the large time scale the time-dependent behaviour of N1 (t) is mostly governed by two poles of s = 0 and s = so which are quite close together but not quite the same leading to e -As
1 k
Note that Nl(S) now is independent of the initial position of xo, which directly suggests that in this long time-limit the particles must hit the walls many times before escaping the wells, keeping almost quasi-equilibrium within the wells, thus forgetting the initial position. It is seen that since the small value of s corresponds to the long time behaviour, the direct substitution of s ~ 0 in Eq. (7) also leads to the same result in Eq. (9). This will become a useful point when we treat the general case. On using the phenomenological rate equation for the first-order reaction of the type A ~ B, that leads to the following concentration of A, x(s) z(s)
s+ k~ s(s 4- k 4- k')
=
and comparing it to the result in Eq.(9), we finally find k =
De-A~ L2
k t --
De-As L2
(10)
where k and k' are the rate constants for the forward and backward reactions, respectively. It explicitly shows that the pre-exponential factors are governed by diffusion processes in the potential wells and the exponential factors come into play due to rebouncing motion at the wells, viz the higher the barrier is, the more rebouncing is needed to escape from the wells. Furthermore, our expression in Eq.(10) satisfies the relation from chemical thermodynamics that is AG "9 = - R T log K where K = k / k ' is the equilibrium constant and G e is the standard free energy for tile reaction. This shows the difference in A s - A 1 determines the equilibrium state, whereas the barrier heights A 1 and As govern the dynamics of reaction. In conclusion, the dynamics of the square-well models can indeed take into account the phenomenological rate equations satisfactorily, which means we in fact have a rather microscopic dynamic model that goes quite well along the phenomenological blackbox relations. We will consider the irreversible first-order reaction with the square-well potential elsewhere [5], that also supports the same conclusion. Our method is different from that of the previous studies [6, 7, 8] investigating by means of the eigen-value problem. Now, we extend the above treatments to consider generally what is the reaction time after-all and to work out a method to obtain the reation times from arbitrary shapes of potentials. We write Eqs. (2) and (3) in the forms of the following integral equations: g(x,A) = g(a,A) - J(a,X)
e x p [ V ( x l ) / k B T ] d x l - H ( x - xo)
exp[V(xl)/kBT]dxl o
+ s
~X~X1exp
J(x,A) =-sg(a,A)
{[Y('xl)
-
(11)
V ( x 2 ) ] / k B T } g(x2, A)dxldx2
exp[-V(xl)/kBT]dxl
+ J(a,A) + H(x-
xo)
79
+ s
exp { [ - V ( x l ) +
V(x2)]/kBT} J(x2,)~)dxldx2
(12)
whose solutions can be expressed by g(x,A)
=
(l+sll-2>+s2ll-2+3-4>+...)g(a,A)-(ll>+sll-2+3> +s211 - 2 + 3 - 4 + 5 > + . . . ) J ( a , A) -
H(x - xo)(ll>o + sll - 2 + 3>0
+8211 -- 2 + 3 - - 4 + 5 > 0 + ...)
J(x,~)
=
-s(]-l>+s]-l+2-3>+s
(13)
2]-l+2-3+4-5>+...)g(a,A)+(l+s]-l+2>
+s2l - 1 + 2 - 3 + 4 > +...)J(a,)Q +
H(x - xo)(1 + s I - 1 + 2>0
+s2l - 1 + 2 - 3 + 4>0 + ...)
(14)
where we have employed bra ket notation through the following definition: [1 - 2 + 3... > .
.
.
JO"
J~
.
exp {[V(xl) - V(x2) + V(x3) - . . . ] / k B T }
dxldx2dx3...
(15)
and I...>o stands for the above integral on replacing the lower limit, a by x0. We are interested in the domain of reaction time, that is the barrier heights are sufficiently high in comparison with the thermal energy and the long time-behaviour of the dynamics. As a first general example, we shall consider the case where the potential heights at x = ul and x = u2 are infinitively high so t h a t
J(ul, A) =0
J(u~, )~) =0
These boundary conditions together with Eqs. (11) and (12) lead after taking the limit of s --, 0 to the following expression valid for the long time:
p(x,t.) _.exp[-V(x)/kBT]<_l> [ 1 - e x p ( - < _ l + 2 _ 3 >-<1 >
DE)]
(16)
where < ... > represents the integral in Eq.(15) with the upper and lower limits of us and ul, respectively. This shows explicitly the long time dynamical processes reaching the final Boltzmann equilibrium distribution. By separating the reaction coordinate into ul <_ x < u and u < x <_ u2 corresponding to the reactant and product regions, respectively, we find the rate constants, k =
D E~ exp[-V(x)/kBT]dx < -1+2-3
>
k ' - D f,~2 exp[-V(x)/kBT]dx
(17)
(18)
<-1+2-3> Whereas if we assume that the potential at ul is infinitively lfigh and that at u2 is infinitively low we can impose the conditions, J(ul,A) = 0 g(u2, A) = 0 which lead to
p(x,t) - exp[-V(x)/kBT] [< 1 > o - H ( x - xo)[l>o] exp [ - < 1 - 2 > D r ]
(19)
80
It is important to realize that p(x, t) takes the Boltzmann factor for x < x0 and does not lead to Boltzmann for x > xo before vanishing. However, when the initial position is near the potential minimum like the system we are concerned with, the pre-exponential factor in Eq. (19) hardly depends on x0 as far as the batTier is sufficiently high. If we apply Eq. (19) to an irreversible reaction, we find D <1-2>
k =
(20)
This expression is different from that of Kramers [1] in that we have taken into account the dynamics explicitly whereas Kramers assumed the stationary condition where the process is time-independent and obtained the following expression: D kc(~ <1> For three-dimensional motion under a central potential V(r) where r is the radial distance, the Smoluchowski equation corresponding to Eq. (1) can be expressed by
Op(r,t) 1~_.~ [OP~rt) 10V(r), ] Ot = "~ r2 + kBT -~r .p(r,t)
(21)
By defining functions, 1
P(r,t) -- eV(r)/ksTp(r,t) .8
Q(r,t) -- r2j(r,t)
.6
and taking the Laplace transform with respect to t, we can reduce Eq. (21) to
dP(r,s) dr
.4
dQ(r,s) dr
.2
e v(r)/keT ~Q(r,s) r2
--
(22)
-sr2e-V(r)/ksT p(r,s) -t- ~f(r -- r0)(23)
where 0 0
20
40
t
~0
Figure 2: Numerical solution of Eq. (1) with potential A (full curves) and theoretical results (marked curves) from Eq. (26)
j(r,t)
0p(r,t)
~
Or
-4
10V(r) p(r,t) kBT Or
It is extremely important to note here that we can easily shift from the one dimensional to three just by regarding
p(x,t) --. r2p(r,t),
J(x,t) --, r2j(r,t)
(24)
and
V(x) ~ V'(r) -'- V ( r ) - 2kBTln r
(25)
This states that we obtain the complete picture of the three-dimensional Brownian motion with the central potential from the one-dimensional one just on replacing V(x) by V*(r), i.e., for the
former motion, the extra potential -2kBTln r arising from an orientational Brownian motion nmst be considered. This is very much similar to the case where the apparent ove~-all potential for two or three dimensional motion in mechanics with a central force consists of the centrifugal mad the mechanical potentials. Now, we shall apply the above general formalism to three specific potentials, A. a system with single minimum and single maximum, B. double minimum system and C. the Coulomb attractive potential, given by the following expressions:
V(z) = b (x2 - 2x 3) V ( x ) = Vl x 4 + v 2 x 3 - 2Vl x 2
(A) 3v2x
-
(B)
V(r) = ---
(C)
r
respectively. Potential A has been set with the minimum at x -- 0 and with the maximum at x - 1. The potential barrier vo is given by 3b = kBTVo. Whereas, potential B has been set with the minima at x = - 1 and x - 1 and the differences in the minima, in the minimum at x -- - 1 and the maximum at xmax = -3v2/4Vl, and in the minimum at x = 1 and the maximum are Av = 4v2, AVl = Vl -- 2v2 + ?3max and Av2 = vl + 2v2 + vrna=, respectively, where ?3m~x= V(xmaz). 1
The number of the particles, N (t) for x <_ 0 as a function of time t has been calculated for potential A based on Eq. (19). Although the present theory cannot describe the accurate behavior of N(t) in the short time regime, on taking into account the rate constant in Eq. (20), we set N(t)=exp[
<1-2>t]
.8
.6
.4
(26)
with D = 1. The Smoluchowski equation with potential A has also been solved numerically and N(t) obtained from Eq.(26) and the numerical analyses o are shown in Fig. 2 where the full curves from o 20 40 60 the upper to the bottom are obtained numerit cally for V0=5, 4, 3, and 1, respectively, and the marked curves are from Eq. (26). It is seen that the agreement is remarkable especially for sys- Figure 3: Numerical solution of Eq. (1) with terns with high barrier tops. The pre-exponential potential A (full curves) and theoretical results factor in Eq. (19) has been also calculated nu- (marked curves) from Eq. (27) merically and compared with theoretical one. We confirmed the good agreement between them for relatively long time. Similar treatments have done for potential B that is a model for reversible first-order. The number of particles in the left well, N1 (t) is set gl(t) =
k' k k+k' +~exp
[
<-l>t] < -1 +2-
3>
(27)
82
with k and k ~in Eqs. (17) and (18), respectively. Nl(t) from Eq. (27) and the numerical calculation (full curves} are shown in Fig. 3 where the filled circles, open circles, and crosses are obtained from Eq. (27) for A v / k B T = 1, 2 and 3 with the fixed value of (Art + Av2 -- 2 v , n a z ) / k s T = 8 and open squares and triangles are ( A v l q- Av2 -- 2 v , , a ~ ) / k B T = l O and 6, for the fixed values of A v / k B T = 2 . Again, we see the agreement is excellent. Because we are now confident on the agreement of the dynamics between the present results and numerical ones, we re-consider the rate constant due to the Coulomb potential C. We see from Eq. (26) and potential C that there exists a maximum for V*(r) at r = rm~z = w / 2 k a T = rc/2 in which rc is the Onsager radius and an highly attractive region at a < r < rmaz. Because of the existence of this region, an ion pair produced at t - 0 is easily recombined. We seek the escaping rate of an ionized particle over the potential top analytically as tt functions of a and rmaz from Eq. (20). To this end, we have to calculate
-rc
4
< 1- 2 > =
~12drl
r22e'2dr2
(28)
where rc = w / k B T and R is a parameter finally to be put oo. On integrating the right hand side in Eq. (28) by parts and expressing the result in terms of a confluent hypergeometric function, we finally find the following approximate expression: D r c 2 =r.f..
k - ---~e
~
( f o r small a and R ---, cc)(29)
We have plotted this k as a function of a in Fig. 4 and it is interesting to note a maximum. Just for the sake of illustration, we show k including unrealistic values near a = 1 where obviously 0 .2 .4 .6 .8 1 Gr the present expression does not cover. When a is small, the potential is so deep that the main contribution to k arises from the usual exponenFigure 4: A theoretical prediction of k for po- tial factor in Eq. (29) which indicates the larger tential C with the initial position of an ion-pair a is, the faster the reaction proceeds. However. near a from Eq. (29) the barrier becomes shallow, the pre-exponential factor starts dominating the rate, where we note - 2 r c / a 3 is the second derivative of V(r) at r = a that leads to a frequency of an oscillator near at r = a. This frequency becomes small, when a is large, which results in the decrease in k. This is why k has a peak before reaching the potential maximum at r~a~. Euation (10) also indicates the pre-exponential factors are governed by tlus kind of frequency. It should be emphasized that in treating the Coulomb potential, our model in deriving Eq. (28) is different from that of Hong and Noolandi [7] who considered Brownian motion in a >_ r >_ oc from the beginning whereas we have introduced the absorbing boundary first at an finite distance, r = R and let it go to infinity in finding Eq. (29), because we know the integral in Eq. (28) does not differ considerably from that in large finite value of R. In other words, we were concerned with Brownian motion in confined space while Hong and Noolandi treated that in unconfined infinite space whose physics must be different. This is the very reason why the dyna~nics of our model has been expressed by a function of s only, whereas that of the latter needed v/~ in addition to s. For example, our case of p(r,t) decays exponentially as expressed by Eq. (19) whereas that of Hong and Noolandi decreases with e x p ( r c / ( r ~ ) .
83
I would like to record that results on irreversible and reversible reactions under square-well potentials are partly due to Mr. Satoshi Suzuki. References [I] H. A. Kramers, Physica 7, 284 (1940) [2] N. G. van Kampen, Stochastic Processes in Physics and Chemistry, North-Holland, Amsterdam (1992) [3] S. A. Rice, Di1~usion-Limited Reactions, Elsevier, Amsterdam (1985) [4] A. Morita,Phys. Rev. E, 4 9 , 3 6 9 7 (1994) [5] S. Suzuki and A. Morita to be published [6] E. Wong, Proc. Syrup. Appl. Math. 16, 264 (1964) [7] K. M. Hong and J. Noolandi, J. Chem. Phys.,68, 5163 (1978) [8] H. Risken, The Fokker-Planck Equation, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1984)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
journal of
MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molecular Liquids, 65/66 (1995) 85-90
STRUCTURAL CHARACTERISTICS OF HYDROGEN-BONDED N E T W O R K S IN WATER AND ICE SYSTEMS
J C Dore and D M Blakey s
Laboratory, University of Kent, Canterbury, Kent, ~
7 N , UK.)
Abstract The molecular configurations of water molecules in the disordered condensed state are investigated by neutron diffraction. The results provide evidence for the interplay of hydrogen-bond goemetry with thermal disorder, leading to a sensitive response to external variables and local influences.
1)
Introduction
R is well known that liquid water exhibits a number of properties that are distinct from those of other molecular liquids.These characteristics are attributed specifically to the effects of a strong hydrogen-bonding interaction which leads to stmcaual ordering on a molecular scale. The tetrahedral nature of the interaction tends towards the creation of a space-filling network but the thermal disorder causes the static geometrical features to be modified. As a result, the water structure is extremely sensitive to the influence of thermophysical variables such as temperature and pressure and also to the presence of other molecules and ions, either in the form of solute entities in solution or due to the effects of a neighbouring interface. The importance of water in physical, chemical and biological sciences provides a compelling reason to study the microstrucmral and dynamical features in some detail. However, it becomes clear that the characteristics are rather subtle and although considerable advances have been made, particularly in the last decade, there are many fundamental questions that remain, at best, partially answered. The present paper provides a short critical review of current issues on the structural properties of pure water in the normal and under-cooled phases as studied by neutron diffraction incorporating information from studies of amorphous ice.
2)
Neutron diffraction techniques
a)
Structural characteristics at room temperature
Neutron diffraction measurements yield the liquid strucan~ factor Sin(Q) which contains information on the spatial correlations at an atomic scale. In the ease of water where the molecules comprise two atomic species, three independent measurements on H20/D20 mixtures of varying composition are required to determine the three pair correlation functions, goo(r), goD(r) and gDD(r) based on the assumption that hydrogen and deuterium occupy equivalent sites. The most frequently quoted results of Soper and Phillips [ 1] were based on reactor measurements with three sample compositions. Similar measurements for a different composition range have also been made by Garawi, Dote and Bellissent-Funel [2]but a detailed report has not been made of these datase~ as the five independent measurements revealed the possibility of minor differences in the hydrogen and deuterium characteristics. However, the data can be used to derive two of the partial functions and Fig 1 shows a comparison between the results of the two experiments. The consistency in the overall features is encouraging as the measurements are technically demanding but the shift in the peak position at low-r may have some significance in terms of detailed interpretation of the results. 0167-7322/95/509.50 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All fights reserved. SSDi 0167-7322 (95) 00845-4
86
1.6
goo(r)
...
0.6
0.~
-0.2
1
2
3
4
S
(I
1
8
--0.~
1
2
3
4
5
6
r/A Fig 1: A comparison of gOD(0 and gDD(r) for water at 20oC from data of Garawi et al [2], (solid line) and Soper and Phillips [ 1] (dashed line). A full analysis of the systematic behaviour for the five d a t a s ~ has been delayed (by manpower resources) but seems to suggest that there may be small variations in the distribution of H and D atoms in the various mixtures. A further factor was also app.arent in the behaviour of the goo(r) curve where it was clear that the first peak at 2.8A was over-estimated in the Soper and Phillips data. The d~_a displayed in Fig 1 can be readily understood in terms of the local configurations of water molecules since the peak position are simply related to the distances of a hydrogen-bonded pair as shown in the insets. Most molecular dynamics studies using a range of interaction potentials are able to reproduce these featmes quite well on a qualitative basis. More recently, Soper and Finney [3] have used pulsed neutron techniques and obtained similar data for the goD(r) and gDD(r) functions but now have a goo(r) curve with a smaller peak height that is in beaer agreement with the results obtained from X-ray diffraction studies. The present situation is much beue~ than a decade ago when several groups had widely differing results [4] but a detailed examination of the s y s ~ c errors in the data treatment and a critical comparison of the various measurements has not yet been made. It therefore a p ~ that a definitive set of partial pair correlation functions has not yet been achieved for liquid water at room temperature. Although the present information is sufficiently accurate to give a clear indication of the inter-molecular features, it does not provide a sufficiently precise distribution to discriminate between the various forms proposed for the interaction potential. More recent approaches to the interpretation of either simulation or experimental results have now begun to emphasise the orientational characteristics rather than the site-site correlation [5]. Fig 2 shows a contour plot of the oxygen distribution function around a fixed water molecule by Svischev [6] using a SPC potential, and Soper has obtained a similar representation in a spherical harmonic (SHARM) analysis of neutron datao This relatively new approach should provide a greater insight into the way the basic tetrahedral order is disrupted by the thermal motion at 300 K.
7
r/,~
87
Fig 2: The orientational correlation of oxygen atoms around a water molecule shown as a contour plot from computer calculations of Svishev [6]. b)
Temperature variation studies
Temperature variation studies are based on a fast order difference technique, such that ADm(Q,AT) = Sm(Q,T2) - Sm(Q,T1) defines the change in the diffraction pattern for a temperature change AT = T2 - TI. Due to the density maximum (1 loc in D20), it is possible to choose pairs of temperatures either side of the maximum where the density is constant. This method defines the isochoric temperature derivative [7] which can be transformed to give the real-space function AdL(r,AT) where oo
AdL(r~T) = 41rrpA~(r) = 2 IQ ADm(Q,AT) sin Qr dQ 7r6 The results for two pairs of temperatures are shown in Fig 3 and reveal several interesting features. The two curves are in remarkable quantative agreement except at the low-r peak position corresponding the OD hydrogen-bond distance. It therefore seems that the local variation in the molecular correlations changes systematically across the density maximum. Furthermore, the re-arrangement is not restricted to the fast neighbour but extends to 8A, involving second and third-neighbour molecules. This result emphasises that the important characteristics of the structure are not simply dependent on adjacent molecules but are influenced by longer range effects arising from ring closure within the local network Of H-bonds. The significance of this observation becomes clearer at lower temperatures.
88
0.008
AT
0
----
-0.008
-
4
-
8
2 / 2 4 *C -o
e
se
*c
1;,
r/J, Fig 3: The isochoric temperature derivative for liquid water from Sufl et al [7] showing systematic variation over the density maximum. c)
The under-cooled liquid and amorphous ice
The structural correlations are strongly enhanced in the under-cooled state as the temperature is reduced towards the metastable limit of -40~ (for D20) and various thermophysical properties exhibit diverged behaviour [81. The exact nature of this anomaly is still the subject of some controversy. However, the diffraction pattern indicates that the structure is evolving towards that of amorphous ice which is characterised as a continuous random network of tetrahedral hydrogen-bonds [9]. Recent neutron measurements on amorphous ice [ 10] have re-inforced the earlier conjectures and shown that the structure is similar to that of hyper-quenehed glassy water produced by rapid cooling of micron-sized water droplets. It can now be realised that the CRN model for the disordered phase of ice is effectively the limiting structure of water at low temperatures. i
I
i
i
ii
i
i
]
2
4
6
8 r/A
10
12
14
16
Fig 4: The spatial function d(r) for a single single molecule form-factor fit and after removal of the cluster contribution for a-ice. The latest data has been analysed by a novel use of a cluster form-factor to fit the data in the high-Q region. The inter-molecular correlations within the tetrahedral network are evaluated up to a range of second nearest neighbour molecules. The transformation to a real-space representation in Fig 4, shows how well the local structure is represented by this approach and conf'ums that the four-bonded network gives excellent results.
89
d)
Argon/a-ice co-deposits
The presence of apolar solute molecules in liquid water is know to affect the local hydrogen-bond geometry and leads to the hydrophobic interaction. Isotopic techniques using natAr/36Ar difference measurements are feasible but difficult due to the low solubility of argon in water. Neutron results for this case have recently been given by Broadbent et al[ 111 using a pressure cell. d ~
i
,
,
,
|
i
!
2
4
6
8
10
|
,
12
14
I
g
2000
m
i
0
91A '
1.2
I
I
I
I
I
I
0.6
i5
......
o
-0.6
,
0
I
I
I
I
I
!
2
4
6
8 dA
10
12
,
I
14
16
Fig 5: a) Diffraction measurements for argon/a-ice co-deposit using Ar isotopes. b) The partial pair correlation function, dAr(r) obtained from the difference technique. An altemative approach to this question is to investigate the effect in the disordered solid phase where the spatial correlations are more pronounced and higher argon concentrations can be achieved. Fig 5a shows the two curves for a sample of codeposited amorphous ice with 8 atomic per cent of argon. A difference analysis yields a composite pair correlation function in the form 0.259gAro(r) + 0.595 gArD (r) + 0.146 gArAr(r)
90
which is shown in Fig 5b. The highly-structured curve shows that there is a wellformed cage of water molecules around the argon atoms which is very similar to the computer predictions for the liquid phase made by Guillot et al [12]. The plane of the water molecules is approximately tangentialto the Ar-O vector so that a localised clathrateg c o m c ~ is created. A doaflcd analysisof thisgeometry has yet to be made but further work is in progress. This type of measurement opens up many possibilities for further studies and is complementary to work currently being pursued by Soper, Finney and collaborators [ 131. 3)
Conclusions
The present work has shown that neutron diffractionhas an important role to play in the study of water structurein the normal and super-cooled liquid phases and also through the investigation of amorphous ice systems. The high sensitivity to minor permd3ations is seen to be due to the specificbchaviour of the hydrogen-bond geometry either through temperature change or proximity of solute particles. In the former case there is a systematic change resultingfrom a delicatebalance between the ordering effectsof the H-bond geometry and the disordering effectsof thermal motion. In the second case, the presence of the argon atoms effectivelycreates void volumes within the material and resultsin network modification such thatthe hydrogen-bond connectivity is preserved by forming cage-like structuresaround the apolar region.
The basic principles seem to be well established for the low t e m ~ regime although a full quantitative description has yet to be developed. The increased spatial correlations are important in providing clear indications of local structure but it remains to be seem whether this information can be extrapolated to predict the behaviour of water systems at ambient conditions. 4)
Acknowledgements
We would like to acknowledge many people who have contributed to this work over the last decade and would particularly like to mention Pierre Chieux (ILL) and Marie-Oaire Bellissent-Funel (LLB). It is also a great pleasure for one of us (JCD) to achknowledge the Yamada Foundation and the conference organisers for the invitation to the meeting and an enjoyable fast visit to Japan. References
1) 2) 3)
4)
5) 6) 7)
8) 9) lO) 11) 12) 13)
A K Soper and M G Phillips, Chem Phys 107, 47 (1985) M S Garawi, Thesis, University of Kent, (1987); M Garawi, J C Dore and M C Bellissent-Funel, in preparation. A K Soper and J L Finney, private communication J C Dore, p3 in Water Science Reviews' Vol 1, F Franks (ed), Cambridge (pub) 1985. 1994 A K Soper p97 in 'Hydrogen Bond Networks', NATO ASI Series Vo1435, I M Svischev and P G Kusalik, J Chem Phys 99, 3049 (1994). P A Egelstaff et al, Phys Rev Lett 47, 1722 (1981), M A M Sufi, Thesis, University of Kent, 1986; M A M Sufi and J C Bore, in preparation. A Angeil, Chap 1 in 'Water : a comprehensive treatise', Vol 7, F Franks (ed), Plenum (pub), 1982. (1984) M R Chowdhury, J C Dore and J T W enzel, J Non Cryst Solids, 53, 247 D M Blakey, p381 in 'Hydrogen Bond Networks', NATO ASI Series Vo1435, M C Bellissent-Funel and J C Dore (eds), Kluwer (pub), 1994. R D Broadbent and G W Neilson, J Chem Phys 100, 5743 (1994). B Guillot et al, J Chem Phys 95, 3643 (1991 ) A K Soper and J L Finney, Phys Rev Letts, 71, 4346 (1993).
journal of
MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molecular Liquids, 65166 (1995) 91-98
S t r u c t u r e and D y n a m i c s of S u p e r c o o l e d and Glassy A q u e o u s I o n i c S o l u t i o n s Toshio Y a m a g u c h i , ~'* M o t o y u k i Y a m a g a m i , ~ H i s a n o b u W a k i t a , ~ a n d Alan K. Soper b ~ D e p a r t m e n t of C h e m i s t r y , Faculty of Science, F u k u o k a University, F u k u o k a 814-80, J a p a n bISIS Facility, R u t h e r f o r d A p p l e t o n L a b o r a t o r y , D i d c o t , Oxon, O X l l 0QX, U.K.
Abstract X-ray diffraction, neutron diffraction isotopic substitution(NDIS), and quasi-elastic neutron scattering(QENS) measurements have been made on concentrated aqueous solutions of lithium halides LiX (X=C1, Br, and I) in a temperature range covering the room-temperature liquid, the supercooled liquid, and the glassy state. X-ray radial distribution functions have revealed that the hydration shell of the halide ions is gradually structured with lowering temperature. Another interesting feature is the evolution of water-water interactions centered at 4.3 and 6.9 ~ independent of the halide ions, due probably to reinforced hydrogen bonds at low temperatures. The NDIS radial distribution functions related to Li + and C1- have demonstrated that the orientational correlation of bound water molecules for C1- is more strongly temperature-dependent than that for Li +. At low temperature the formation of a second hydration shell of Li + and C1- has been established. The QENS data have shown that the translational motion of water molecules in the LiC1 solution is more hindered with lowering temperature. The structural and dynamic characteristics of the supercooled and glassy solutions are discussed in connection with nucleation of ice, isotropic reorientational motion of water, and the partial recovery of hydrogen bonds in these solutions. I. I n t r o d u c t i o n The microscopic structure and dynamic properties of supercooled aqueous solutions have recently attracted much attention in various aspects such as nucleation of ice, crystallization of solutions, glass transition, hydrogen-bonded specificity, and ionic hydration. Lithium halides are very hygroscopic, and their concentrated solutions easily form glassy solutions at low temperatures. The physico-chemical properties of supercooled and glassy aqueous lithium halide solutions have been measured by various techniques such as thermal analysis (DTA and DSC), Rayleigh, Brillouin, and Raman scatterings) ,2 All of these data are, however, limited to qualitative features of the supercooled and glassy solutions. The structural information at an atomic level is essential for understanding the various properties of supercooled and glassy solutions. X-ray and neutron diffraction enables us to obtain direct structure information (bond distance and coordination number) of ionic solutions in terms of the radial distribution function. In the case of aqueous lithium halide solutions, X-ray diffraction data are dominated by halide-oxygen, halideoxygen, and oxygen-oxygen interactions. On the contrary, neutron isotopic substitution
0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995ElsevierScience B.V. All rightsreserved. 0167-7322(95)00896-9
SSDi
92
data with respect of Li and C1 give us the information related mostly to Li-O, Li-D, C1-O, and C1-D interactions. In addition to the static structure of the ionic solutions, their dynamic properties are also needed to explain various phenomena of the supercooled and glassy solutions. One of the available methods for this purpose is the quasi-elastic neutron scattering technique. In the present study, we have made X-ray diffraction, neutron diffraction with isotopic substitution, and quasi-elastic neutron scattering measurements on highly concentrated aqueous solutions of lithium halides in a wide temperature range from room temperature to below glass transition temperature, from which the microscopic behaviors of the static structure and dynamic properties of the solutions are revealed with lowering temperature. The results obtained are discussed in connection with ice nucleation, anisotropic motion of water, crystallization, and the partial recovery of hydrogen bonds. II. E x p e r i m e n t a l X - r a y Diffraction The sample solutions were prepared by dissolving anhydrous lithium halides into distilled water to the [H20]/[LiX] molar ratios of 5.22 (10.6 m, m=mol kg -1) and 12.1 (4.60 m, LiC1), 4.98 (11.2 m, LiSr), and 5.00 (11.1 m, LiI). X-ray scattering data were collected in reflection geometry with a 0 - 0 diffractometer (RIGAKU), except for the 5.22 m aqueous solution where a rapid liquid X-ray diffractometer with an imaging plate (Mac Science) was used in transmission geometry. Mo Ka radiation (A=0.7107 A), monochromatized by a LiF crystal for the former diffractometer and by a graphite crystal for the latter, was used for the measurements. For low temperature measurements, a cryostat described in ref. 3 was used for the 0 - 0 diffractometer, whereas cold N2 gas was used for the imaging-plate diffractometer. The scattering angle (20) covered for both diffractometer is 0,,,140 ~ corresponding to the scattering vector q=4rA -1 sin 0 of 0~16.8 A -1. The details of the X-ray measurements and the diffractometers have been described elsewhere. 4'5 The X-ray diffraction data were corrected for background, polarization, absorption, multiple scattering, and incoherent scattering with the usual procedures. 4'5 The structure functions i(q) were obtained by I(q)- Ex,f~(q) where I(q)is the observed X-ray intensities, xi and fi(q) are the mole fraction and the form factor of species i. The X-ray radial distribution function was obtained from eq. (1).
D(r) = 47rr2po+ (2r/r) f qi(q)M(q)sin(rq)dq
(I)
where p0(= [Zx,fi(O)]2/V) denotes the average scattering density of water and V is the stoichiometric volume (/~3) per halide ion. A modification function M(q) of the form [Y]xif2(O)/~xif2(q)] exp(-O.Olq 2) was used. Neutron Diffraction Sample solutions were prepared by dissolving into D20 ~ (a null mixture of 6Li and ZLi) and ZLi~tC1 for Li-enriched solutions, and ZLi3SC1 and ZLi3ZCl for C1enriched solutions. The sample solution was sealed into a Ti-Zr null alloy cell with inner diameter of 8 mm. Pulsed neutron diffraction measurements were made with HIT at KENS, Japan, and with SANDALS at ISIS, UK. Neutron scattering measurements were also made for background, an empty can, and a vanadium rod. The observed neutron
93 data were corrected for absorption, multiple scattering, and incoherent scattering, and scaled to absolute units by using the vanadium data as have previously been described. 6 The first-order difference function A.(q) between the two total structure factors for isotopic ions a and c~' is given by A,~(q) = A s . o ( q ) + Bs~D(q) + C s . ~ ( q ) + D s . , , ( q ) + E A = 2cacobo(b. - bt,,), B = 2C•CDbD(b. -- b~,) C = 2cac~b~(ba - b~,), D = %2(b~ - b~,),E = - ( A + B + C + D)
(2)
where sii(q) is the partial structure factor of atom pair i - j, c~ is the atomic fraction of atom i, and bi is its scattering length. The important parameter values are given in Table 1. The A a ( q ) is Fourier transformed to give the radial distribution function G~(r) represented by Ga(r) = Agao(r) + BgaD(r) + C g ~ ( r ) + Dg=~(r) + E
(3)
Table 1. Experimental data for the sample solutions" scattering lengths b (10 -12 cm), concentrations m (mol kg-Z), molar ratios R ( - [D20]/[LiC1]), densities p (g cm -a) at 298 K, and coefficients A , B , C and D (10 -27 cm -2) in Eq. (2) in the text. Solution ~ 7Lin~tC1 0Lir~tc1 7Linatc1 7Li35C1 'Li37C1
bLi -0.009 -0.222 0.011 -0.222 -0.222 -0.222
ba 0.958 0.958 0.958 0.958 1.163 0.345
m 4.96 4.98 9.32 9.41 9.61 9.42
R 10.0 10.0 5.36 5.30 5.20 5.30
p 1.20 1.20 1.27 1.27 1.27 1.28
A 2.40
B C D 5 . 5 1 0.'40 -0.05
4.41
1 0 . 1 1.36
-0.15
15.8
36.0
3.92
-1.15
Quasi-Elastic N e u t r o n S c a t t e r i n g The aqueous LiC1 solution with the composition of LiC1.6.0H20 was prepared in the same way as described for the X-ray samples. In the aqueous solution the proton (ZH) has a very large incoherent scattering cross section; the observed differential scattering cross section can be approximated to the incoherent dynamic structure factor through (d2aldFLdw) = (k/ko)[< b2 > - < b >2]Si"C(q,w)
(4)
Since water molecules are involved in translational, rotational, and vibrational motions, the incoherent dynamical structure factor may be described as a convolution of the three terms as
s~"~
~) = S'(q,~)
9S'(q,~)
9S~(q,~)
(5)
Here, the scattering law for the translational motion is expressed by the Lorentzian function as S t ( q , w ) = ( 1 / r ) [ D s q 2 / ( D ~ q 4 + w2)] (6) where DH is the translational diffusion coefficient of the proton.
The neutron quasi-elastic scattering measurements have been made from room temperature to glassy transition temperature on LAM-40 spectrometer at KENS. The details of the spectrometer and the data analysis have been described elsewhere/ III. R e s u l t s and D i s c u s s i o n
X - r a y Diffraction Figure l(a), (b), and (c) show the X-ray radial distribution functions (RDF) for the 10.6 m LiC1, 11.2 m LiBr, and 11.1 rn LiI aqueous solutions, respectively, at the various temperatures. The first prominent peak observed at 3.1 - 3.6 ~ in the RDFs corresponds mainly to the halide-water interactions due to the halide hydration. The contribution of the water-water interactions within the primary hydration shell of Li + also falls within this range. A characteristic feature of the RDFs with temperature is an appearance of a new peak centered at 4.3 /~. The position of the peak does not depend on the halide ions; the peak is gradually enhanced with lowering temperature. We have previously assigned this peak mainly to water-water interactions for the 11 m aqueous LiC1 solution, s The quantitative analysis has been made by a least-squares fitting procedure, and the important structural parameter values finally obtained are summarized in Table 2. The evolution of the 4.3 A peak with lowering temperature is clearly seen in Fig. 6
_
|
|
i
,
|
,
|
|
0
!
=,98 K
.k
:< s
4,
29.:
~
2.~
0
~'1
S
0 -61-
41 . . . . . . . . .
.'<
,
,
2
.
.
4
.
.
r/A
.
6
.
.
8
-I
10
-4F
~ ealc. ,
o
,
2
,
~
oh=.
~'~'~'~o r/A
--
0
!
i
2
i
!
4
i
i
6
!
|
8
10
r/A
Fig. 1. The X-ray radial distribution functions for the 11 m aqueous solutions of LiC1 (a), LiSr (b), and LiI (c) at the various temperatures. 2 (a) and (b) for the 5 m aqueous LiC1 solution. As is seen in Fig. 2(a) the solutions at 233 and 223 K contain hexagonal ice, together with supercooled liquid. The RDF at 223 K is dominated by the hexagonal ice, in which the peak appears at 2.8, 4.3, and 6.8 A, corresponding the tetrahedral network of ice. The continuous evolution of the 4.3 A peak from the supercooled to the ice-formed liquids suggests that at the low temperature the water molecules around C1- will be incorporated into the locally ice-like network locally involved in the solution. As seen in Fig. 2, this tendency is promoted in the solutions containing larger halide ions, probably because the surrounding water molecules are loosely bound to the large halide ion.
95
Table 2. Important structural parameter values obtained by least-squares fits for the aqueous lithium halide solutions at the various temperatures. T, r, b, and n axe the temperature, the interatomic distance, the temperature factor, and the number of interactions, respectively. The values in parentheses are their estimated errors. X - H20
T/K
r/h
LiCI
298 243 193
3.13(1) 3.13(1) 3.13(1)
LiBr
298
13s 3.13(~)
LiI
3.31(1)
26s
3.30(~)
243 298 268 243
3.31(1) 3.53(1)
3.54(1)
3.54(I) *Fixed.
b/lO-ah ~
10.2(5) ~'.S(3) 5.9(4) 5.8(4) 22.5(4) 20.0(4) 16.0(3) 20.0(3) 17.0(4) 17.0(3)
H20--.H20
n
r/h
6.1(5) 4.32(9) 6.4(5) 4.35(1) 6.5(5)4.30(1) 6.6(5)4.28(1) 5.7(5)4.35(3) 5.8(5)4.32(3) 5.6(5)4.33(3) 5.5(5)4.38(2) 5.6(5)4.40(5) 5.6(5) 4.42(5)
b/lO-ah 2
30* 30" 30* 30* 30* 30" 30* 30* 30* 30"
n
0.5(1) 4.0(2) 10.2(3) 10.2(3) 9.1(1) 10.4(1) 12.9(1) 11.5(2) 20.0(2) 22.0(3)
Neutron Diffraction with Isotopic Substitution Figure 3 shows the Li-related radial distribution functions GLi(r) for the 5 m and 9 m LiC1 solutions in D20 at the various temperatures. In the GLi(r) the predominant peaks observed at 2.0 and 2.6 /~, characterize the primary hydration shell of Li+; the former and latter peaks are ascribed respectively to the Li-O and Li-D interactions in the hydration shell. An interesting feature in GLi(r) is an appearance of the new peak centered at 4.2 /~ at 173 K for the 9 m solution and at 240 K for the 5 m solution. This peak should arise from the second hydration shell of Li +. This finding suggests that structure ordering is enhanced at such a low temperature probably through strengthened hydrogen bonds. 4 This conclusion is supported by the fact that the 4.2/~ peak appears at higher temperature for the water-rich solution. The interatomic distances and the hydration number of Li + were determined by a least-squares fitting procedure applied to the r2-weighed GLi(r). Characteristic Li-O and Li-D distances are 2.024-0.05/~ and 2.614-0.05/~ respectively, independent of temperature. The number of water molecules coordinated to Li + is 44-1 at the temperatures down to 213 K, but decreases to 34-1 at 173 K when the second hydration shell is established. The practical independence of Li-O and Li-D distances with temperature shows the strong orientational correlation of water molecules around Li+; it is most likely that an average orientation of the coordinated water molecules is such that the four atoms in a Li+-D20 unit is pyramidal. The strong orientational correlation of the bound water molecules rationalizes the anisotropic reorientational motion of the water molecules in the hydration shell found by nuclear magnetic relaxation data of supercooled LiC1 solutions. The evolution of the secondary hydration shell of Li + may be a hint of nucleation of ice, glass transition, and partial recovery of hydrogen bonds in the supercooled state. Figure 4 shows the Cl-related radial distribution functions Gel(r) for the 9 m LiC1 solution in D20 at the various temperatures. Since the glass transition temperature of the present solution is around 135 K, the values at 94 K corresponds to the glassy solution.
96
298 K
273 K
A
263 K ]
a
~3KI
A
243 K
]
8
10
263 K
~~" o
253 K
A
243 K
0
3
6
12
9
0
15
A
2
4
6 r/A
q / h -I
Fig. 2. The intensity curves (a) and the X-ray radial distribution functions (b) for the 5 m aqueous LiC1 solution at the various temperatures.
0.1
o.o3
-
'!
I
i
!
i
!
!
i
!
1
0
.~
o J
o J
E
-0.03 L0
i
I
2
I
I
4
I
i
6
i
i
8
I
10
-~
0
. . . . . . . . . 2
4
6
8
1
10
r/ ;~ Fig. 3. The Gu(r) function obtained for the 5 and 9 m aqueous solutions of LiCI in D20 at the various temperatures.
Fig. 4. The Gcl(r) function obtained for the 9 m aqueous solution of LiCl in D20 at the various temperatures.
97 The first peak at 2.29/~ is ascribed to the nearest neighbor C1-D interactions due to C1hydration. The second peak at 3.2/~, clearly defined at low temperatures, corresponds to the sum of C1-O and C1-D interactions within the hydration shell of C1-. A characteristic change in Gel(r) is that the first and second distinct peaks are gradually broadened with increasing temperature; this demonstrates a weakening orientational correlation of hydrogen bonds between C1- and the surrounding water molecules, probably due to large thermal motion of water molecules at high temperatures. From the least-squares fitting procedure applied to the 2.29 /~ peak, it has been found that the C1-D distances and the hydration number are 2.26:t=0.01 /~ and 5.8:t=0.1, respectively, at the temperatures investigated.
Quasi-Elastic Neutron Scattering Figure 5 shows the neutron quasi-elastic scattering spectra at q = 1.76/~-1 for the aqueous LiC1 solution at different temperatures. As is seen in Fig. 5, the peak width decreases with lowering temperature, indicating that the motion of water molecules in the solutions is gradually retarded with temperature. The spectra have been analysed by a curve fitting method using the following model function, S(q,~) = C[(A,,/~){F,,/(~ 2 +
r~)} +
(Ab/~){rb/(,., 2 +
r~)}]
(7)
where C is a constant, F~ (i=n and b) is the half-width at half-maximum (HWHM) of the narrow and broad Lorentzian components, respectively, and Ai is the fraction of each component. The HWHM values of the narrow component (b) are plotted against q2 in Fig. 6. The F,, values were analysed on the basis of a jump diffusion model:
Fn = DHq2/[1 + DHq2To]
(8)
where DH is the proton self-diffusion coefficient, and r0 is the life time of the proton oscillatory motion. The self-diffusion coefficient DH can be expressed by the mean jump length of proton L and r0 as D~ = < L ~ >/(6~o) (9) The obtained parameter values are summarized in Table 3. The self-diffusion coefficient of the proton decreases with lowering temperature, suggesting that the translational motion of water molecules is restricted at the low temperatures. This is probably because of the water-water interaction will be enhanced with decreasing temperature. The self-diffusion coefficients obtained from QENS are less than those determined by the 1H-NMR pulsedfield gradient method. A probable reason for the difference in DH is ascribed to different time scales observed by both methods (,-~200 #eV for LAM40).
Table 3. Parameter values for the jump diffusion model for the aqueous solution of LiC1.6.0H20 at various temperatures.
T/K LiCl 295 267
ro/ps L/A 7.1 17
DH/10-1~ I.I0 2.60 1.16 1.33
-1
D~_IMR/10-10m2s-] 5.35 (298 K) 1.74 (263 K)
98
o,
:7'
9
I/
""""
0.0/ -4.0-2.0
0.0
2:0
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 206 K 4:0 6.0 8.0 16.0 ImeV
Fig. 5. The QENS spectra for the aqueous solution of LiCI.6.0H20 at different temperatures. The dots axe experimental values and the solid lines the fitted values by eq.(7).
0
I
o
5
o
3
0 4
5
0 206 K 6 7
a' I A"
Fig. 6. The Q2-dependenceof HWttM of the component r , for the solution of LiCI.6.0H20. The solid fines are the values calculated by the Fick law using the NMIt data in Table 3.
This work is partially supported by the Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (No.06453029) from the Ministry of Education, Science, and Culture of Japan. References 1 A. Elarby-Aouizerat, J.F. Jal, P. Chieux, J.M. Letoffe, P. Claudy, and J. Dupuy, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 104, 203 (1988). 2 H. Kanno and J. Hiraishi, J. Phys. Chem., 87, 3664 (1983). 3 T. Takamuku, T. Yamaguchi, and H. Wakita, J. Phys. Chem., 95, 10098 (1991). 4 T. Yamaguchi, G. Johansson, B. Holmberg, M. Maeda, and H. Ohtaki, Acta Chem. Scand., A38, 437 (1984). 5 M. Ihara, T. Yaznaguchi, and H. Wakita, Adv. X-ray Anal., 25, 49 (1994). 6 M. Yamagami, T. Yamaguchi, and H. Wakita, J. Chem. Phys., 100, 3122 (1994). 7 K. Inoue, Y. Ishikawa, N. Watanabe, K. Kaji, Y. Kiyanagi, H. Iwasa, and M. Kohgi, Nucl. Instrum. Methods, A238, 401 (1984). 8 K. Yamanaka, M. Yamagami, T. Takamuku, T. Yamaguchi, and H. Wakita, J. Phys. Chem., 97, 10835 (1993).
journal of MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molecular Liquids. 65/66 (1995) 75-83
D y n a m i c s of Brownian motion under a potential and theory on the rate of chemical reactions A k i o Morita
D e p a r t m e n t of Chemistry, College of Arts and Sciences, University of T o k y o , K o m a b a , M e g u r o - k u , T o k y o 153, J a p a n
Abstract We have introduced a two square-well potential system, solved the Smoluchowski equation, calculated exactly the concentration of the reactant, compared it to t h a t resulting from the phenomenological rate equations and finally obtained expressions for rate constants for a first-order reversible reaction. It is found that the pre-exponential factors for both constants are just the diffusion coefficients divided by the square of the widths of potential wells. Our expressions for rate constants satisfy a relation between standard free energy and the equilibrium constant arising from chemical thermodynamics. We have also developed a general theory on the relaxation processes of approachment of a system to the equilib~Sum Boltzmann for an arbitrary potential with sufficiently deep well and the escape rate from the well for an asymptotically long time limit of the reaction, which enables us to calculate the rate constants for given potentials. Furthermore, we obtained the rate constant for a dissociation reaction of an ion-pair interacting through the Coulomb potential and found a maximum as the sum of the radii of the ion-pair increases.
I.
Introduction
In formulating the rate constant based a dynamical equation such as the Fokker-Planck-Kramers equation, the Smoluchowski equation and etc., we usually use the assumption of stationary state [1, 2, 3]. However, it is sometimes the case where dynamical information is suppressed by the assumption that the flux of Brownian particles must be uniform in space. It is thus sensible to calculate the rate constant by taking the dynamics explicitly. To this end, we must bear in our mind time scales of the dynamics. Imagine the diffusion of solute particles in solvent by regarding the position of a particle x as a reaction coordinate. When it diffuses on a fiat potential, the time scale we must be concerned with is of course that of diffusion, which is much longer than collision time between the solvent and solute molecules. Now, suppose it moves under a square-wen potential and its height is infinitively high, the main time scale will be roughly a relaxation time of the order of the square of the width of the potential bottom divided by the diffusion constant, which determines time approaching to an equilibrium state after colliding with the potential walls several times before settling into it. However, as lowering the potential height slightly, we see that the particles can now escape from the well after colliding with the potential walls much more times, which makes the time scale much longer to settle the motion. This is precisely why the exponential factor comes into play. The time scale in this region may be called a reaction time which is determined from the diffusion at potential bottom and the barrier height leading to the pre-exponential and exponential factors, respectively. We will be interested in tiffs long reaction time so that time scales representing molecular motion in small changes are trivial. In tiffs paper, we will devote ourselves to finding this reaction time based on the recent development on investigation of the dynamics of Brownian motion under a square-well potential [4]. Furthennore, we will develope a general theory for an arbitrary potential to obtain the reaction time. With this 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. SSD! 0167-7322 (95) 0(0)003
1t3o
there is little knowledge of the way in which they work at the microscopic level. For example, even the long known phenomenon of salting out in polymer solutions is far from being understood at the microscopic level. Of possibly even more importance are aqueous solutions of biological molecules. The majority of biochemical reactions take place in the aqueous phase and the conformation of the molecules, how they hydrate, and how their hydration is affected by the presence of salts or other molecules, is important in understanding basic biological functions. To date, the structure and behaviour of these molecules is generally inferred from the molecular structures of these molecules in the solid (crystal) phase, or indirectly through spectroscopic techniques (NMR, IR and UV etc.). Neutron techniques are now beginning to offer the possibilities of exploring these structures directly and unambiguously. In this paper we wish to consider how neutron scattering techniques can be used to study aqueous solutions containing large polymeric molecules. 2, Ext~erimental techniaues. _
NDIS techniques have been used for many years in the study of aqueous electrolyte solutions. Diffraction measurements for two liquids which differ only in the isotopic composition of one of the components reduce the total number of correlations observed in the data from N(N+I)/2 in the pure liquid to N (corresponding to correlations to the substituted atom) in the first order difference function. By careful analysis of the first order difference function details of the geometric arrangement of molecules around the substituted atom can be established. The supplementary technique of QENS allows a more detailed knowledge of the exchange times of the water in the hydration shells of these ions to be established. 3. Results and discussion. 3.1 Aqueous polyethylene oxide solutions.
Polyethylene oxide (PEO) is an uncharged polymer that has a high solubility in water, especially when compared to its analogues polymethylene oxide (PMO) and polypropylene oxide (PPO) which are essentially insoluble in water. PEO solutions
101
also show characteristic 'clouding' as the temperature is raised due to the formation of large micelles ha solution. The origins of the high PEO solubility and this behaviour have long been of interest to polymer chemists. It is generally believed that its high solubility is due a polymer structure that is commensurate with the underlying water structure, so that the ethereal oxygens on the polymer backbone are hydrogen bonded to the water molecules and the hydrophobic ethyl groups are essentially sitting in a water cage, without heavily perturbing the overall water structure. For the case of PMO and PPO the ethereal oxygens are too close or too distant to fit neatly into the water structure making it energetically untavourable for the polymer to dissolve. Despite this appealing idea no work has been carried out to investigate the water structure around PEO in solution. Figure 1 shows the AI(Q) obtained for the correlations around the (inexchangeable) hydrogen atoms on PEO using llH/21H substitution 9. . . . . .
l
- ~ ~"
iit i!t 0
./~--
I Figure 1. The first order difference I function AH(r) obtained for 1.88 I monomolal PEO ha 21H20. The , bottom (full line) is the uncorrected I difference f u n c t i o n . The top (full fine) is the difference after correction for the difference ha inelastic i scattering between 1l H and 2ill !(dashed line). I
.5 ;/
r
,
-
,
2
4
6
8
10
Q (A ~)
The corresponding AG(r) is shown ha figure 2. A clear peak is observed at 1.1 /~. which corresponds to the characteristic C-H bond distance and coordination number ha the polymer. It is clear that there is no strong structure at larger distances ha the first order difference. This is largely due to the fact that the polymeric hydrogen is not at any particular centre of symmetry ha relation to the hydrating water. However it is possible to reveal more of the hydration structure after the (known) intermolecular structure of the PEO molecule is subtracted from the difference function. A detailed analysis of the result after this subtraction,
1o2
shows that models in which the PEO is modelled into an unperturbed water lattice are not consistent w:,th the data. Further analysis shows that each monomer is hydrated by six waters; a result consistent with the hydration number deduced from cavity surface calculations performed on the polymer. Figure 2. The normalised AGH(r ) for 1.88 monomolal PEO in ZlH20. 2.S0 I
-~o
~.oo t
's~/ oo.[
o.so o.oo ~-~
~ I
.~ 2
J" 3
, 4
~ S
~ J)
QENS measurements have also been carried out on deuterated PEO solutions (2 molal) in ttH20 using the IN10 high energy resolution spectrometer at the ILL. The QENS spectrum is dominated by the translational motion of the protons in the water. After correction for multiple scattering and absorption the data was fitted to a single Lorentzian scattering law obeying Ficks diffusion law (WHM proportional to Q2) as observed for pure I~H20. This fit is clearly inadequate and demonstrates that the polymer is severely perturbing the dynamical behaviour of the water. An attempt to fit a double Lorentzian scattering law similar to the case for ionic solutions in slow exchange is also unsuccessful and indicates that either the hydrating water is exchanging on the timescale of 1 ns (the so caUed intermediate scattering regime) or the scattering law for the hydrating water is considerably more complex than the simple Lorentzian shape obtained from a free diffusion law and more like that of the scattering law of the polymer itself 10.
103 3.2 Aaueous oolvelectrolvte solutions and t~olvmer/ionic solutions, There are many interesting problems concerning the effects of polyelectrolytes and polymers in aqueous ionic solutions. For example, the microscopic origin of the behaviour of certain salts (in accordance with the Hofmeister series) in reducing the cloud point temperature of aqueous PEO is not understood. Originally, there was some speculation that the polymer was binding to the anions ( chlorine is the most effective anion) in these solutions and this was the origin of the salting out effect. An NDIS experiment 11 conclusively demonstrated that there was no modification of the CI- hydration sphere indicating that the origin of this phenomenon was more subtle than supposed. Recently studies of this type have been extended to other systems especially to questions concerning the binding of polymer to cations in solution. Figure 3 shows the first order difference functions for two systems, Ni-PSS 12 and Ca-Dextran 13 in which the hydration structure of a cation has been studied and compared with the corresponding structure in the pure salt solution. It is apparent that in these cases the Q- space data shows remarkably little change from the pure salt solutions for medium to large Q (2 < Q < ~20]k -1) ranges. However, small deviations (notably an enhanced scattering) are observed over the smaller Q region (0.3 < Q < ~2/~- 1) in these materials. This indicates that the close hydration structure of the ions in these solutions is not radically affected. The variations at small Q indicate a significant ordering on the medium range scale (310/~) suggesting that the polymer is binding to the ions over these length scales. The real space first order difference functions (AG(r)) of these solutions and that of Nickel adenosine 5' triphosphate (ATP) solution are shown in figure 4. The diagrams also show the AG(r)'s obtained from the pure aqueous solutions at the nearest available concentration (These have been renormalised to give the correct normalisation where appropriate). In all of these cases several points can be noted: i) The first peak in AG(r) corresponding to the coordination of oxygen around the ion remains unchanged.
1134
,io' o.:
,o,~.-
. . . . . . ,j ~-~,,.,~... " .
.
.
1 J~ . # . . . . . .
7.
q,
-
b
'Jr
~" . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Ji
!J
o..
.
i
............
t
,
.r
'\
~tbdl
,2a'::.,i ,
,I
;,
I '"
'l.
'"
~"
6
"
Im
io
i
~z
i 0
Figure 3. The first order difference function for a) 2~Ca(Q) fro pure 1.35 molal CaC12 solution, b) ACa(Q) for 1 molal CaC12 in 1 molal dextran solution, c) ANi(Q) for 2 molal NiC12 solution, d) ANi(Q) for 1.8 molal NiPSS..
Z
§
6
~
Figure 4. a ) A G c a ( r ) f o r the CaC12 solution (broken line) and CaCl2/Dextran solution (full line), b) A GNi(r) tbrthe NiC12 solution(broken line) and Ni-PSS solution (full line), c) AGNi(r) for 0.5 molal Ni-ATP solution (full line) and 0.4 molal NiC12 solution (dotted line).
105
ii) The second peak ( corresponding to the 21H peak in the pure aqueous solution) is reduced in intensity. iii) An extra peak ( or small shoulder in the case of Ni-PSS) appears in the region between the first and second hydration shell of the pure solutions. This is generally a relatively small feature and it is difficult to confirm that it is not an artefact of the Fourier transform. Such a strong peak has never been observed in any of the pure aqueous solution experiments. From these observations it is possible to conclude that the ion, in all cases, remains bound to the same number of oxygens as the pure solution. The reduced intensity of the second (2~H) peak is strong evidence that some water has been displaced from the hydration sphere and has been replaced by the polymer/polyelectrolyte directly binding to the ion. In all cases this leads to the reduction in the Z~H peak and predicts additional correlations further out due to the internal structure of the polymer/polyelectrolyte, for example, Ni-O-P correlations in Ni-ATP, Ni-O-S correlations in Ni-PSS and Ca-O-C correlations in Ca-dextran solutions. These correlations would all be consistent with the third observation above. Ctm'ently it is difficult to obtain quanttafive information concerning the precise nature of the eftect of the polymer on the ion hydration (especially in the important area of the second hydration sphere). In future, the higher neutron fluxes available and the use of selective hydrogen isotope substitution will lead to clearer information on the structure of these complexes. For example, using zero scattering water for the first order difference measurements will eliminate all the water contributions in the second peak of the difference function. This should lead to unmistakable evidence of the polymer binding to the ion and the ability to determine the conformation, and coordination number of the coordinating group. Selective labelling of the isotopes on the polymer chain should increase this precision even further.
1o6
Conclusions. The results presented here show that neutron scattering is an invaluable tool for studying the important area of ions binding to aqueous polymer solutions. Neutron difference methods allow direct evidence polymer-ion binding to be observed. Further developments in neutron scattering techniques and instrumentation will lead to increased precision in the future. Quantitative neutron quasielastic measurements provide an additional useful tool allowing studies of the modifications of the water dynamics to be studied. Acknowledgements. The authors would like to acknowledge the help and collaboration of the Leiden group, particularly T. Bieze, H. Tromp and J. Leyte. We would also like to thank the EPSRC for financial support. References 1. Enderby, J.E. and Neilson, G.W. (1981) Rep. Prog. Phys. 44, 593-653 2. Neilson, G.W. and Enderby,J.E. (1983) Proc. Roy. Soc. A. 390, 353-371 3. Turner,J., Soper, A.K. and Finney,J.L. (1992) Mol. Phys. 77, 411-429 4. Soper,A.K., Turner,J and Finney,J.L. (1992) Mol. Phys. 77, 431-437 5. PoweU,D.H. and Neilson,G.W. (1990) J. Phys. Condens. Matter 2, 5867-5876 6. Okan,S.E. and Salmon,P.S. (1994) J. Phys. Condens. Matter 6,3839-3848 7. Hewish, N.A., Enderby,J.E. and Howells,W.S. (1983) J. Phys.C: Solid State Phys. 16.1777,1791 8. Salmon,P.S. [ 1987) J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 20,1573-1587 9. Bieze,T.W.N., Barnes,A.C. ,Huige,C.J.M., Enderby,J.E. and Leyte,J.C. (1994) J. Phys.Chem. 98,6568-6576 10. Barnes,A.C., Bieze,T.W.N. Enderby,J.E. and Leyte,J.C.(1994) J. Phys. Chem. in press 11. Barnes,A.C., Enderby,J.E., Breen,J. and Leyte,J.C. (1987) Chem. Phys. Letts. 142,405-408 12. Tromp,R.H. and Neilson,G.W. (1994) J. Phys. Chem. in press 13. Vennix,A. and Barnes,A.C. to be published.
journal of
MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molecular Liquids, 65/66 (1995) 107-114
Liquid-Liquid Phase Separations and Critical Behavior of Electrolyte Solutions Driven by Long-Range and Short-Range Interactions Hermann Weingiirtner Institut fiir Physikalische Chemie und Elektrochemie der Universitiit Karisruhe, D-76128 Karlsruhe, Germany and Woiffram Schriier, Institut t'fir Anorganische und Physikalische Chemie der Universitiit Bremen, D-28334 Bremen, Germany
Abstract The discovery of liquid-liquid phase separations in electrolyte solutions with critical points near room temperature enables the systematic study of the critical behavior of ionic fluids. Depending on the details of the molecular interactions mean-field-like criticality, Ising criticality or crossover from mean-field to Ising criticality is observed. Mean-field behavior occurs in systems which in the framework of a simple corresponding states model are fairly close to the theoretical critical point of the "restricted primitive model (RPM)" of equally-sized charged spheres in a dielectric continuum (so-called Coulombic phase separations). In these cases the phase transition is driven by the long-range Coulombic forces and may be modeled by a Bjerrum-type theory for ion pair association plus an additional term for the interaction between the ion pairs and free ions. The presence of additional short-range interactions shifts the phase transitions towards higher reduced temperatures and/or densities in the corresponding states plot. Two major examples are solvophobic unmixings in aqueous solutions of tetraalkylammonium salts and unmixings of salts with hydrogen-bonds between cations and anions (sticky ion pairs). Such systems exhibit Ising-like criticality. In the intermediate range crossover is observed. Possible scenarios for explaining the mean-field-Ising dichotomy are discussed, indicating a major role of the dielectric constant of the solvent in determining critical behavior.
Introduction Electrolyte solutions are of long-standing interest, and in many respects our understanding of their thermodynamics is in a mature state. The discovery of liquid-liquid phase equilibria in such systems has, however, introduced new features. ~3 Although already reported in 1903,4 and studied in more detail in 1963, 5 such phenomena have remained almost unnoticed. New impetus in the this field has now come from interest in the critical properties of ionic fluids. Experiments at high temperatures have indicated that, at least on a first study, ionic fluids appear to exhibit classical critical behavior, as opposed to the Ising-like criticality of uncharged fluids. 2 Recent experiments using liquid-liquid immiscibilities with critical points 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995 ElsevierScience B.V. All rights reserved. SSDi 0167-7322 (95) 00898-5
108
(CPs) near room temperature have subsequently confirmed this behavior. ~-8 These form a major challenge to experiment and theory. 9 Of course, an ultimate way to treat this problem theoretically would lie in a renormalization group analysis, but successful analyses of this type have ever rested on crucial physical insights into the character of the phase transition. A general physico-chemical characterization of the systems and an understanding of the molecular forces driving the phase separation seems to be indispensable. The focus of our work is therefore on an understanding of the critical phenomena in relation to the molecular processes that control the phase separation.
Coulombic Phase Separations The simplest model for discussing electrolyte thermodynamics is the "restricted primitive model" (RPM) which describes the fluid as equally-sized, charged hard spheres of diameter a in a dielectric continuum with dielectric constant D. If we express the properties in terms of reduced variables, the basic energy scale is set by the binding energy ~ = q,qj/Da of an ion pair, where the qo. are the ionic charges. The length scale is given by the hard sphere diameter. Then, the reduced temperature and density scales are s 7" = k T/6 = kTDa/q,qj
and
C" = C d
(1)
where k is the Boltzmann constant and C the total number density of ions. This model possesses an instability regime with an upper CP near T" = 0.05 and 6" = 0.03, 2"9 substantially displaced from the CP of the Lennard-Jones (LJ) fluid (see Fig. 1).
T
"
210 , 5 --
solvophobic
0 . 2 --
0.1
- -
I
RPM sticky ions
0.01 7 0
I 0.1
! 0.2
oi,
oi,
01,
oi, C*
Fig. 1 Coexistence curves of the RPM and LJ fluids compared with experimental CPs of real systems. Systems according to Table 1" IV (e); V ( 9); VI (V); VII (A); VIII ( !"1 ). The circle A represents the regime of solvophobic unmixings. ( ~ ) denotes KI + SO2 not considered in Table 2.
io9
Via the law of corresponding states, the this coexistence curve is expected to match the general phase behavior of ionic fluids. ~'zl~ We are here interested in the case that a solvent forms a dielectric background with D > 1. In this case one expects the RPM coexistence curve to correspond to liquid-liquid immiscibilities of l:l-electrolytes in solvents of low dielectric constant (D < 8) and of higher valency types in water at high temperatures, where D is low. Owing to the low critical density, all phase separations should occur in the solvent-rich regime. Experimentally it turns out that, normally, at these conditions electrolytes are insoluble. A key step in searching for liquid-liquid phase equilibria has therefore been the use of low-melting salts to suppress crystallization. ~.3We have generally used alkylammonium salts which are chemically fairly stable and usually melt below 200 ~ If one mixes such electrolytes with low-D solvents one readily detects liquid-liquid phase separations. We denote these immiscibilities as Coulombic immiscibilities. Some representative systems are compiled in Table 1. Fig. 1 shows the location of the critical points in the corresponding-states plot.
T a b l e 1: Liquid-liquid immmiscibilities and critical behavior of electrolyte solutions
salt I
Pe4N Br
solvent water
type of unmixing
D at Tc
exponents effective criticality Ising
ref. 16
solvophobic
~50
13
~50
13,y,v
Ising
3
13
Ising
23
II
PrBu 3NI
water
solvophobic
III
Pe4N I
glycerol
solvophobic
IV
EtH3N NO 3 octanol
sticky ions
8.4
~/,v
Ising
24
V
EtMe3N I
chloroform
Coulombic
4.7
y,v
Ising
11
VI
22
BuaN Pie
dodecanol
Coulombic
4.6
y
crossover
VII Bu4N Pie
tridecanol
Coulombic
4.4
y,v
crossover ?
VIII HexEt3N HexEt3B
diphenylether Coulombic
3.7
~/
mean-field
7 6,8
As a typical example we show in Fig. 2 the coexistence curve of the system tetrabutylammonium picrate + tridecanol with an upper CP. ~The upper CP of the RPM does however not necessarily conform to an upper CP of real fluids. If D is a strong function of T, the coexistence curve inverts. Examples are found for 2:2-electrolytes and higher valency types like UO:SO4 or Na.~IPO 3 in water at high temperatures. ~ The system KI + SO: investigated in 1903 by Walden shows a lower CP as well. 4 We have recently reported on another system with a lower CP near room temperature, trimethyl-ethylammonium bromide dissolved in chloroform. ~ The coexistence curve is shown in Fig. 3. For the primary data and error estimates for these and all subsequently reported coexistence curves we refer to the original papers. Commercial chloroform contains ethanol for stabilization, and we have performed experiments under controlled ethanol content. Therefore, in principle, the system is a ternary one, and the minimum of the coexistence curve does not necessarily coincide with the CP. This is just what is seen from Fig. 3, where the CP determined by light scattering is displaced from the minimum of the coexistence curve.
I10
80-
T [oe)
35-
70-
T [ ~c]
Pic
6030-
504030-
25-
20100 0
I
0,2
I
I
0,4
0,6
I
0,8
I
1
20
0,02
, 0,04
, 0,06
, 0,1 x 1
Xl
Fig. 2: Coexistence curves of the systems tetrabutylammonium picrate + tridecanol and ethylammonium nitrate + oetanol, x ! is the mole fraction of the salt.
, 0,08
Fig.3: Coexistence curve of the system trimethyl-ethylammonium bromide + chloroform in the presence of 1% ethanol. The arrow indicates the CP.
Driving Forces for Coulombic Phase Separations Monte-Carlo calculations have established the approximate location o f the CP, but have provided little insight into the character o f these phase transitions. There seems however to be a simple, semi-quantitative way to account for these Coulombic phase separations. 9 For illustration we show in Fig. 4 the equivalent conductance A of the system tetrabutylammonium picrate + tridecanol as a function of the molar concentration C along an isotherm about 6 K above T c. A s2-
10.5-
0
0.2" 0.1" 0.05 0.02
0.0~
1r
i
i
C
Fig. 4: Equivalent conductance A (in S cm 2 mol~) of tetrabutylammonium picrate + tridecanol as a function of salt concentration C (in mol dm 3) about 6 K above Tc. The arrow indicates the CP.
111
The major feature is a rapid decrease of A at low salt concentrations, followed by a minimum and pronounced increase. At the CP there is a substantial conductance. To interpret this behavior, we first note that the Debye- Htickel (DH) theory itself predicts an instability regime at low T', but if compared with experiment C ~ is far too low. Taking account for ion association considerably improves thew results. In the presence of ion association, a higher salt concentration is needed to achieve the concentration of free ions to drive phase separation, i.e. C ~ is shifted to higher values. In particular, the Bjerrum model for ion pair association yields9 T~ = 1/16,
C* = 0.0452...,
K:ca = 1
(2)
in agreement with experiment, r is the usual Debye-HOckel parameter. This is just the picture resulting from the low-concentration branch of the conductance curve in Fig. 4, which yields an association constant K(Tc)= 3 x 109 dm3 mol! in agreement with the Bjerrum-prediction. 1 On the other hand, as indicated in Fig. 4, the CP is located in a regime of increasing conductances far above the minimum. Hence, another process will take part, which is associated with the coupling of these ion pairs with the remainder of the solution. 9 Traditionally, this coupling has been modeled by assuming ion triplets or higher associates which enforce the conductance to increase. More generally, the major effect may result from the coupling of ion pairs with the remainder of the screening free ions, regardless whether distinct species are formed or not. At this level, several scenarios have been discussed 9.1z~3and there exists a comparatively simple theory by Fisher and Levin ~3which matches the major features of the coexistence curve. "Sticky Ions" with Specific Interionic Interactions If in addition to the electrostatic interaction an additional "sticky" interionic interaction stabilizes the ion pair, C ~ is shifted towards higher values. The rationale is that the additional interaction gives rise to an increase of the association constant, so that again a higher overall salt concentration is needed to achieve the critical concentration of free ions. One illustrative example investigated by us is ethylammonium nitrate (EtNH3NO3) in o c t a n o l . 14 There is a comparatively strong hydrogen-bond between the cation and anion which shit, s the critical density towards a high value (Fig. 1) and results in a miscibility gap in the salt-rich regime. In fact, the association constant resulting from conductance measurements in this system is by more than one order of magnitude higher than predicted by the Bjerrum theory. We have recently extended the Fisher-Levin theory of ion-pair - ion coupling ~3 to include angular-averaged dipolar interactions between ion pairs, 15 which enables to describe a continuous transition from the ionic to the dipolar fluid. We obtain in the limit of complete association C~ = 0.13 and T~ = 0.167 which reflects this higher critical concentration.
Solvophobie Unmixings Another important class of liquid-liquid unmixings occur in aqueous solutions of higher homologues of the teraalkylammonium salts with large anions. 1'3'~6 Such miscibility gaps are found with many commonly used salts like tetrabutylammonium iodide at temperatures slightly above room temperature. These are generally closed gaps, the lower parts usually being suppressed by crystallization. ~Fig. 5 shows a particularly interesting example (propyl-tributyl-
112
ammonium iodide, PrBthNI), where a small closed gap is directly observed. 3 In a corresponding states diagram the CP is largely displaced from those of Coulombic immiscibilities (see Fig. 1). We have performed elsewhere a detailed analysis of these miscibility gaps in relation to the thermodynamic properties, m'~7'~8The latter exhibit the characteristic features known from aqueous solutions of hydrophobic molecules and attributed to hydrophobic cation-cation interactions. In addition, specific cation-anion pairing seems to play a role as well. It is known that pair association constants are comparatively small (typically 10 dm 3 mol") and increase with increasing cation and anion size, as opposed to expectations from electrostatic arguments. For anions one finds K to increase with the "lyotropic series" F < CI < B r < NO 3 < I < SCN < CIO; < picrate. This is just the series in which miscibility gaps increase. ~A simple picture is ~9that it is comparatively easy to desolvate a large anion which is the then stabilized in the low-D environment of between the alkyl groups of the cations. The interpretation is confirmed by HNC calculations of model systems characterized by Friedman-Gurney-type potentials. ~9We note that similar immiscibilities have been observed in other solvents of high cohesive energy density like ehtylene glycol, glycerol or formamide. ~ One may call this type of phase separation "hydrophobic u n m i x i n ~ 'i9 or "solvophobic unmixing". ! T~I
7!
65"
60"
-••.0.331
s5
wt. -9 0.446
T
i
0 35
!
0,40
0,48
i
i
0,50
0,55
Wl
Fig. 5: Upper and lower parts of the closed miscibility gap of propyl-tributylammonium iodide in water as an example for hydrophobie unmixing, wl is the weight fraction of the salt.
5.
Critical Behavior
The prime question is, how these various long-range Coulombic and short-range specific interactions affect the critical behavior. In general, liquid-gas and liquid-liquid coexistence curves in the asymptotic regime near the CP can be described by a power law of the form 2~ Ax
=
XI--X2
-"
B t 13 + . . .
(3)
where xl.2 characterizes the compositions of the coexisting phases (e.g. in mole fractions), B is a substance-specific amplitude and t - (7"- T ) / T c . In non-ionic fluids a "universal" critical exponent 13 = 0.325 is found, which corresponds to the figure predicted from the three-
ID
dimensional Ising model. Mean-field (or classical or van-der-Waals) theory predicts 13 = 1/2. However, often static or dynamic light scattering experiments are the method of choice for investigating critical phenomena. These yield the osmotic susceptibility Zr (e.g. derived from static scattering or turbidity measurements) which asymptotically diverges as ~ T = Xot -~
(4)
and the correlation length of the critical fluctuations (e.g. derived from dynamic scattering) which asymptotically diverges as ~ = ~ot -~
(5)
,/= 2v = 1 exactly in the mean-field model and 7 ----2v =__1.24 in the Ising model at the level of accuracy used here. Accurate work performed since the pioneering study of Sing and Pitzer 6 published in 1989 is summarized in Table 1, which lists the exponents investigated (13 via the shape of the coexistence curve, y via static light scattering or turbidity measurements and v via dynamic light scattering) and the universality class found. It is seen that three types of behavior are observable, i.e. sharp Ising behavior, sharp mean-field behavior and crossover from effective mean-field behavior far from Tc to asymptotic Ising behavior (although not complete in the cases under investigation). Such a crossover is expected on theoretical grounds, as far from T~ mean-field behavior should become accurate. The transition is characterized by the so-called Ginzburg-temperature to. 2~ In simple non-charged fluids to is obviously so large that meanfield exponents are never seen. Any observation of mean-field exponents may therefore either imply that criticality is truly mean-field, or that the asymptotic range is not reached in the experiments. General D i s c u s s i o n There are essentially two ways of looking at the data in Table 1. One is associated with the presence of short-range specific interactions in addition to the long-range Coulombic interactions. In these cases sharp Ising behavior is found. Two mechanisms have been detected until now: The dominance of solvophobic interactions shifts an apparent mean-field criticality to an Ising criticality. Similarly an enhancement of pair association by some stickiness between the ions leads to Ising behavior. Using the extension of the Fisher-Levin model to include dipolar interactions between ion pairs, we have found that in the limit of a completely dipolar fluid, t G is two orders of magnitude larger than in the free ion limit, so that an increasing Ising region is expected with increasing association. ~5 However, one may note that at least one observation does not fit to this simple picture: There is no reason for postulating any marked specific interactions in the system trimethyl-ethyl ammonium bromide + chloroform, and in fact, Fig. 1 shows that the RPM matches the experimental CP of this system surprisingly well. Nevertheless, we observe sharp Ising behavior. ~ One may however look at the data in Table 1 from a different point of view (see also ref. 22). It is seen that a transition from Ising to mean-field behavior is observed, if the dielectric constant decreases, the transition regime occuring somewhere near D = 4.5. Could the dielectric constant be the major parameter controlling criticality? In the latter case specific interactions play an indirect role: They shift Tc and Cc thus enabling phase separations to occur
114
at higher dielectric constants thus enabling phase separations under dielectric conditions which favor Ising-like criticality, but are otherwise incidental to the universality class. Recent experiments of Pitzer and Narayanan 22 give support to such an interpretation: In the system Bu4N Pic + dodecanol crossover from asymptotic Ising behavior to mean-field behavior is seen. If D of the solvent is increased by adding a second neutral substance, the Ising range increases. In fact, the role of dielectric phenomena in determining phase transitions and criticality of ionic fluids are widely recognized and subject to current investigations. 9"~2The relation between the dielectric constant and the crossover temperature needs to be investigated in the future. Acknowledgment: K.S. Pitzer and T. Narayanan are thanked for comments and sharing prepublication results.
References
.
10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24.
H. Weing~xtner, T. Merkel, U. Maurer, J.-P. Conzen, H. Glasbrenner and S. K~hammer, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 95, 1579 (1991). see e.g.K.S. Pitzer, Acc. Chem. Res., 23, 333 (1990). H. Weing~.rtner, M. Kleemeier, S. Wiegand and W. Schr6er, J. Stat. Phys., 78, 169 (1995). P. Walden and M. Centnerschwer, Z. Phys. Chem., 42, 432 (1903). H.L. Friedman, J. Phys. Chem., 66, 1595 (1963). R.R. Singh and K.S. Pitzer, J. Chem. Phys., 92, 6775 (1990). H. Weingiirtner, S. Wiegand and W. Schr6er, J. Chem. Phys., 96, 848 (1992). K.C. Zhang, M.E. Briggs, R.W. Gammon and J.M.H. Levelt Sengers, J. Chem. Phys., 97, 9692 (1992). see e.g.M. Fisher, J. Stat. Phys., 75, 1 (1994). H.L. Friedman and B. Larsen, J. Chem. Phys., 70, 92 (1979). S. Wiegand, M. Kleemeier, J.-M. SchrOder, W. Schr0er and H. Weingiirtner, Int. J. Thermophys., 15, 1045 (1994). G. Stell, J. Stat. Phys., in press. M.E. Fisher and Y. Levin, Phys. Rev. Lett., 71, 3826 (1993). H. Weingiirtner, T. Merkel, S. K~hammer, W. SchrOer and S. Wiegand, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 97 970 (1993). W. SchrOer, to be published. M.L. Japas and J.M.H. Levelt Sengers, J. Phys. Chem., 94, 5361 (1990). H. Weing~'tner, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 93, 1058 (1989). H. Weing~irtner and E. Steimle, J. Phys. Chem., 96, 2407 (1992). H. Xu, H.L. Friedman and F.O. Raineri, J. Solution Chem., 20, 739 (1990). see e.g.J.V. Sengers and J.M.H. Levelt Sengers, in "Progress in Liquid Physics", Chap. 4, ed. A Croxton, Wiley, New York, 1978. V.L. Ginzburg, Sov. Phys. Solid, 2, 1824 (1962). T. Narayanan and K.S. Pitzer, Phys. Rev. Lett., in press. T. Merkel and H. Weing~irtner, unpublished data. W. Schr6er, S. Wiegand and H. Weing~irtner, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 97, 975 (1993).
journal of ~IOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of MolecularLiquids,65/66(1995) I 15-!22
Slow Relaxation in Pure and Binary Frozen-in Systems Hiroshi Suga Research Institute for Science and Technology, Kinki University, Kowakae, Higashi-osaka 577, Japan Abstract The glass transition phenomena that have been considered as one characteristic property of liquids are shown to be just one example of freezing transitions which must be of wide occurrence in condensed matters associated with freezing of any degrees of freedom in a system. Freezing transitions observed in some orientationally disordered crystals as revealed by their thermodynamic properties are reviewed. Adiabatic calorimeter used as an ultra-low frequency spectrometer has proven its usefulness in quantifying the relaxation rate and in determining the glass transition and residual entropy of non-crystalline solid as indicative of its non-ergodicity. Nature of relaxation processes observed in exotic non-crystalline solids produced by non-traditional methods is compared with those observed in liquid-quenched glasses. Similarity and dissimilarity in the relaxational processes between them are discussed.
I. Introduction All the classical liquids are believed in principle to realize their glassy states if their crystallizations are avoided in any ways. 1 The formation of glass is kinetic in origin and depends on the persistence of the metastable phase during a quenching process. This requires rapid passage of the crystallization regime in undercooled liquid to reach the low temperature domain where the driving force for the transformation is counterbalanced by the decreased molecular mobility. Similar situation is found in some of the orientationaUy disordered crystal when the transformation into a low-temperature ordered phase is bypassed. 2 The glass transition and residual entropy arising from freezing of the orientational degree of freedom of molecules are observed as in the case of the glass-forming liquids. Thus the glass transition is shown to be of wide occurrence in condensed matters irrespective of the three dimensional periodicity in spatial arrangements of the constituent molecules. The frozen-in disordered crystals were designated as "glassy crystals" There are many ways in producing non-crystalline solids other than the traditional liquid cooling. 3 Vapor deposition is particularly useful in the formation of non-crystalline solid from the most disordered state of aggregation of molecules onto a cold substrate. The process does not require any passage of sample through the "crystallization-dangerous region" in undercooled liquid. Kinetic energies of molecules in the vapor are extracted efficiently if the temperature of substrate is low enough and the condensation rate is sufficiently low. Novel exotic methods have been developed for the formation of non-crystalline solids. In these methods, the starting materials are crystalline solids? An excess amount of energy is impregnated into crystal and freeze it in an energized non-crystalline state. Obviously the method is just opposite from the traditional method in which the energies associated with disorder are removed rapidly. The excitation of energy is carried out either by bombardment of high-energy particles or by mechanical grinding. However, characterizations of these exotic non-crystalline solids are not sufficient compared to those of traditional glasses. It is the purpose of this article to examine similar and dissimilar nature of relaxational processes between the exotic and traditional non-crystalline solids as studied by calorimetric methods. 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995ElsevierScienceB.V. All rightsreserved. SSD10167-7322 (95)(10846-2
116
II. Experimental Experimental methods for the study of non-crystalline solids are similar to those used for the study of phase transitions. 5 They are mainly aimed at resolving the dynamics of the freezing process. Dynamic nature is obtained from dielectric or elastic susceptibility measured over a wide range of frequency. These methods are supplemented by nuclear magnetic resonance technique, which provides information of local properties. Dynamic picture of motion in the time domain of 1 ms-.,10 s is obtained by these techniques. Adiabatic calorimeter can be used as an ultra-low frequency spectrometer owing to its high thermal stability and temperature resolution. It measures the enthalpy of a system as a function of temperature as well as time. Thus the method enables us to follow the enthalpy relaxation which may be exhibited by any frozen-in disordered systems. The time domain that can be covered by this method is in the range 100 s-1 Ms, depending on the quality of the calorimeter and patience of experimenter. The method is complementary with the dielectric spectroscopy. The principle of an adiabatic calorimeter as a relaxational spectrometer is simple. 6 If the temperature of a sample cell is constant with time under an adiabatic condition, the sample is in thermal equilibrium. If the temperature changes with time, the variation is due to irreversible process from a non-equilibrium to the equilibrium state. This can happen when a sample in frozen-in disordered state approaches the glass transition temperature Tg during warming from a low temperature. The non-equilibrium state has an excess amount of enthalpy referred to as the configurational enthalpy and tends to release the excess part when the relaxation time for the structural change crosses the experimental time scale. All the released energy is used to raise the sample temperature if the adiabatic condition is satisfied all the times. Therefore, the temperature versus time curve along the heat capacity data allows to calculate the rate of relaxation for the configurational enthalpy. Amount of correction for a natural heat leakage depends on the quality of the adiabatic control of the calorimeter. The temperature change due to the residual heat leakage is of the order of several mK h -1 in most of the temperature region. Integration of the temperature drift rate with respect to time gives rise to the total excess configurational enthalpy the frozen sample possessed initially. An adiabatic low-temperature calorimeter designed specifically for a vapor-deposited sample is depicted in Fig. 1. This calorimeter equips with a built-in cryorefrigerator which enables to keep the calorimetric cell at cryogenic temperatures for a long time.
Ill. Results and Discussion [1]
Relaxations in Crystalline Solids
One of the features observed in many glass-forming liquids is the non-linear nature of any relaxation processes that occur around and below Tg. The relaxation rate is found to depend on the sign of initial departure of actual sample from the equilibrium state. The relaxation rate is described well by the Kohlrausch-Williams-Watts' (KWW) empirical equation. 7 H(T) = H(O) exp[(-t/z)~],
(1)
where H(t) and H(0) are the enthalpy function at time t=t and t=0, respectively, t the relaxation time and 13 the fractional exponent. Obviously 13=1 corresponds to exponential decay. Generally the value 13is in the range 0.5-0.8 in most of the glass-forming liquids around Tg. One explanation for the deviation of 13from 1 is given by the distribution of the relaxation times. The wider the relaxation times, the smaller the 13value. This kind of non-exponential enthalpy relaxation can be found likely in some of the orientationally disordered crystals in their undercooled states, as exemplified typically by isocyanocyclohexane, s In the room temperature phase, each isocyanocyclohexane molecule reorients rapidly along several unique axes in an fcc unit cell, resulting in time- and spaceaveraged spherical symmetry of the molecule. The cubic phase is easily undercooled by avoiding the transformation into a low-temperature ordered phase. Finally the orientational
117
---A
V5
t
W
V3
~
"
II ,l'--i
I/
D
T4
G
~T3 AT2 ~TI
j K L
coldtrap
~
N
Figure 1 An adiabatic calorimeter for vapor-deposited sample. degree of freedom looses its mobility through a "glass transition" region. The heat capacity decreases discontinuously over a narrow temperature range and a finite amount of entropy remains down to the lowest temperature. The calorimetric results are summarized in Fig. 2. Since isocyanocyclohexane molecule has a large dipole moment, the relaxation rate can be observed dielectrically as well as calorimetrically. A special calorimetric cell with built-in alternately-arranged electrodes was developed in order to compare the relaxation times for the enthalpy and polarization relaxation around the main glass transition region Tg2. The results arc summarized in Table 1. Obviously the relaxations of both quantifies proceed faster at higher temperatures, as expected for a thermally activated process. It is interesting to note that the dielectric polarization relaxes faster than the enthalpy and the non-exponential parameter 13for the polarization is smaller than that for the enthalpy. It is clear that the polarization relaxation concerns only with the recovery of dipolar orientation toward the equilibrium state, while the enthalpy relaxation involves all the processes which accompany any enthalpy change of the crystal as a whole.
Z
isocyar,ocyclohexane
o
20O
,5o,
1
,~
~
Tfus "
!00
50
25o 0
KI
150
IOO
5o
~
5b
1,3o
1;o T
/
26o
2;0
K
Figure 2 Molar heat capacity and entropy of isocyanocyclohexane.
300
118
Table 1 The KWW parameters 13and x for the enthalpy (H) and polarization (P) relaxation in isocyanocyclohexane. T
TH
K
ks
123.04 125.37 126.01 126.82 126.84 127.66
/~H
71 8.3 7.5 4.7 4.6 2.5
fie
0.53 0.70 0.73 0.75 0.75 0.80
4.3 0.62 0.63 0.30 0.35 0.28
0.49 0.42 0.45 0.45 0.46 0.57
Clathrate hydrates 9 provide an interesting example of binary systems with two kinds of disorder. The host water lattice forms various kinds of Archimedes' polyhedra through the hydrogen bonding similar to many ice polymorphs, and the guest molecules are enclathrated in the polyhedral cages. The unit cell of the type II hydrates is composed of 16 pentagonal dodecahedral and 8 hexakaidecahedral cages formed by 136 water molecules. Most of the guest molecules in the type II hydrates are encaged only in the larger cages, so that the ideal stoichiometric composition of a guest molecule G is G-17H20. Both of the host and guest molecules have orientational disorder, being dynamic at high temperatures. For the clathrate hydrates encaging polar molecule like tetrahydrofuran (THF), there exist two kinds of dielectric relaxation. The high temperature one is similar in nature to that of ice and is ascribed to the freezing out of the water reorientational motion. The other occurs at cryogenic temperatures as low as 25 K at 1 ld-Iz and is due to freezing out of the THF reorientational motion inside the almost spherical cavity. The heat capacity of THF. 17H20 exhibits a glass transition at around 85 K which is similar to that of ice Ih observed around 100 K. Analysis of spontaneous temperature change of the sample due to the enthalpy relaxation observed around Tg gives characteristic time for the relaxation process as a function of temperature. The enthalpy relaxation times thus derived can be well correlated with the dielectric relaxation times in an Arrhenius plot. This justifies the assumption that the glass transition is associated with the freezing of the polarization of water dipole. Doping of a minute amount of KOH (1.8x10 -3 in water mole fraction) was found to accelerate the water reorientational motion and induced a first-order phase transition at 62 K T/K ~00
200
150
120
!
!
|
100
90
80
70
40
| ~
""
40
A
ut
v Ot
Pure
! BO.5 K
"-.
,"
0
2
41
6
9
1'2
0
-,
"'-..
50
"'--...
100
150
C'
T -t / k K-I
Figure 3 (Left) Calorimetric and dielectric relaxation time of pure and KOH-doped "ITqF hydrate crystal. (Right) A Cole-Cole plot of KOH-doped THF hydrate crystal.
119
The situation is quite similar to that of ice. ~~ A dielectric measurement on a KOH-doped THF showed that the relaxation time x for the reorientational motion was dramatically shortened by the dopant, possibly by creating a pair of the orientational defects proposed by Bjerrum. Not only the absolute value of x but also the activation energy for the process decreased by the dopant, as shown in Fig. 3. The value of x at 70 K is 10-8 times smaller than that for pure (undoped) sample. This is the reason why the ordering transition has escaped from observation for a pure sample by a kinetic reason appeared now at 62 K in the doped sample by a catalytic action of the dopant within a reasonable time. Also given in the figure is a Cole-Cole plot of the dielectric permittivity of the KOH-doped THF hydrate. The distribution of dielectric relaxation times is much wider in the doped sample than in the pure sample. [2] Relaxation in Non-crystalline Solids As has been described in the introduction, there are many ways in producing noncrystalline solids. These are summarized in Fig. 4. Chemical reaction sometimes produce
Vapor
Liquid i
I
I
Deposition
Rapid ~ooling
Non-crystalline Solids
[~ 1~"
ChemicalI reaction[
Grin~ding Low-temperature melting Bombardment of high-energy particles ,,w
[
Crystal Figure 4 Various methods for preparation of non-crystalline solids. amorphous solid. For example, it has been known that As 3+ ions in aqueous solution react with H2S gas to produce non-crystalline precipitates As2S3. In 1968, we have shown by thermoanalytical method that the precipitates exhibit a glass transition which is essentially the same as that of liquid quenched sample of orpiment (naturally occurred As2S3). 2 Likely, amorphous magnesium acetate Mg(CH3CO2)2 produced by dehydration of its tetrahydrate crystal exhibited a glass transition at around 470 K. Vapor deposited non-crystalline solids were characterized by a special thermal analysis apparatus to exhibit their glass transition phenomena. These observations are, however, merely of qualitative nature. Quantitative study by use of calorimetric method should be necessary for deeper understanding of these noncrystalline solids. A newly developed adiabatic calorimeter ~ for vapor-deposited sample was applied to several samples possessing good glass-forming ability in order to compare the relaxational behavior between the vapor-deposited and liquid-quenched non-crystalline solids. Since the condensation heat exceeds far the heat capacity of any sample, an extremely slow condensation rate is necessary for removal of the heat from the surface of the sample. Generally a non-crystalline sample of 1 g was produced during more than 30 hours' vapor deposition. One of the features shown by vapor-quenched (VQ) non-crystalline solids is their high configurational enthalpies compared to those of liquid-quenched (LQ) solids. ~2 Figure 5 draws
120
100
,
l
80
,
m
~
(//A
/" k
I
.t.~
,/,., 88
4o
. .I
I----I
I
J
I
I
I
I
1.4
YQ2
1.0
~
9
~: 0.6
"
0.4 20
I"
]'
-
0.2
o 00
50
TIK
100
150
50
GO
70
80 TIK
90
100
10
Figure 5 (Left) Molar heat capacity and (fight) configurational enthalpy of butyronitrile prepared by vapor-quenching (VQ) and liquid-quenching (LQ). the heat capacity and configumtional enthalpy of butyronitrile for its VQ and LQ samples. The heat capacity of crystalline phase is also included. Although the values of heat capacity and Tg coincide to each other, there is a large difference in the configurational enthalpy each noncrystalline solid possessed initially. The heat capacity was determined by extrapolating the spontaneously changing temperatures of the calorimetric cell to the mid-point of energizing period and thus correspond to iso-configurational heat capacity; i.e., vibrational heat capacity of the system that can responds rapidly to an energy input. Two kinds of the VQ samples were prepared. The one (VQ1) was deposited at 67 K, and the other (VQ2) at 40 K. It is clear that the lower the substrate temperature, the higher the configurational enthalpy. Here, the configurational enthalpy was referred operationally to that at Tg, at which the spontaneous temperature drifts change from being positive to being negative on warming. For the VQ2 sample, the excess frozen enthalpy amounts to 1.33 kJ mo1-1, compared with 0.08 kJ mo1-1 for the LQ sample, indicating the formation of a non-crystalline solid with extremely high fictive temperature. The enthalpy started to relax at much lower temperatures for the VQ samples than for the LQ sample. The rate of enthalpy relaxation observed for the VQ sample at three different temperatures showed highly non-exponential behavior. Still, the relaxation rate could be described well by the KWW equation. Thus the empirical equation turned out to be valid for non-crystalline solids not only near to but also far from the equilibrium state. The mechanical grinding is a novel technique for solid-state amorphization starting from crystalline sample and is quite popular in recent years in producing amorphous alloys of binary and ternary ~3 systems. The method is generally referred to as mechanical alloying and the grinding procedure is done either by ball-milling or rod-milling. The same thing can happen in non-metallic system. For example, tri-O-methyl-l]-cyclodextrin (permethylated-13-cyclodextrin) can be vitrified by a rod-milling. ~+ During the milling process, a pan of sample was taken out from a pot and examined by X-ray powder diffraction and differential scanning calorimeter. The temperatures of glass transition, crystallization and subsequent fusion were studied as a function of the grinding time. The Tg value decreased at the initial stage of grinding, then increased gradually and finally approached asymptotically the value for the LQ sample. For a fully amorphized sample, the heat capacity ~5 was measured as a function of temperature. Exothermic followed by endothermic spontaneous temperature changes associated with the enthalpy relaxation were observed around Tg. The results are summarized in Fig. 6, along with
121
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
2.5
i
i
,
,
,
Equilibrium
2.5
'
Liquid
2.0 4 o
/
/ !
t.5
]
E 1.5
"~
,..-,
"~ L.0
t.o
0.5
0.5
0
50
0
10
T/K
20
30
40
50
-0.5310
~
310
3~0
3~0
3;0
TIK
Figure 6 (Left) Molar heat capacity and (fight) configurational enthalpy of TMCD prepared by liquid-quenching (LQG) and grinding of crystal (GAS). those for a crystalline sample. Again, the vibrational part of the heat capacity and the Tg value coincided to each other for the ground amorphous solid (GAS) and liquid quenched glass (LQG) samples. However, the amount of configurational enthalpy obtained by integrating the spontaneous temperature drift rates with respect to time differed between the two kinds of noncrystalline solids. The enthalpy relaxation of the GAS sample likely started to occur at lower temperatures compared to the LQG sample. The molecule TMCD has a doughnut-like shape and is known to act as host molecules of the clathrate or inclusion compounds 19 to accommodate various guest molecules in the inner space. Benzoic acid (BA) is one of the guest species. Generally, the preparation of inclusion compound is carried out in solution. In this case, however, solid-state formation of the inclusion compound was found 20 to occur by shaking an equimolar physical mixture of TMCD and BA. About 75 % of the inclusion compound was formed by shaking of the mixture for about 180 min. The inclusion reaction was completed by grinding for additional 3 min with a vibrating mill. Further grinding of the mixture induced again the solid-state amorphization of the inclusion compound. X-ray diffraction pattern of a fully amorphized sample was similar to that of a liquid-quenched inclusion compound. A glass transition was observed for both noncrystalline solids in the temperature range between 331 and 337 K. The grinding-time dependence of the Tg value was about the same as that of pure TMCD. The non-crystalline inclusion compound crystallized into the stable phase via a metastable phase and fused at 447 K. A calorimetric study of the relaxational nature in the non-crystalline TMCD-BA inclusion compound is planning.
IV. Concluding Remarks 1) The observation of glass transition phenomena in some crystals requires a renewal of the concept of glass transition. 16 The glassy crystals are promizing aggregation of state of molecules in the sense that they simplifies the complex nature of non-crystalline solids arising from a coupling between the positional and orientational degrees of freedom of molecules. 2) The cases of ice and clathrate hydrates are particularly interest. 17 The hypothetical ordering transitions that have been concealed so far for a kinetic reason was induced by a minute amount of special dopant which relaxed severe constraints called "ice rules ''is imposed to the highly cooperative reorientational motion of water molecules in their hydrogen-bonded
122 networks. The dramatic acceleration effect of the dopant on the molecular mobility as a whole revealed a facet that a frozen-in disordered system would exhibit under the condition of thermal equilibrium. 3) The configurational enthalpy and its relaxation process in non-equilibrium solids depend strongly on the manner by which the solids were prepared. The amount of excess enthalpy can be changed continuously by modifying slightly the experimental conditions. The continuous hieralchical nature in energy of non-crystalline solids is in good contrast to the discontinuous hieralchy in energy of various modifications (polymorphs) of crystalline solids. 4) Among various techniques in producing non-crystalline solids, the vapor condensation is the most powerful method in extracting rapidly the energies of disordered system to form non-crystalline solids with extremely high fictive temperatures. The enthalpy relaxation starts to occur at temperatures far below Tg. The relaxation rate can be described likely by the KWW empirical equation, as in the cases of many liquids with moderate departure from the equilibrium state. The experimental works described here were carried out at Osaka University when the author had been in active service. The author would like to express his sincere thanks to Professor Emeritus Seki for his continuous encouragement, to many colleagues and students for their enthusiastic collaborations.
References 1 R. Zallen, The Physics of Amorphous Solids (Wiley Interscience, New York, 1983). 2 H. Suga and S. Seki, J. Non-cryst. Solids, 16, 1171(1974) : Faraday Discussion, No. 69 p 221 (Roy. Chem. Sot., 1980). 3 D.R. Secrist and J. D. Mackenzie, Modern Aspects of Vitreous State, edited by J. D. Mackenzie, Vol III, p 149 (Butterworths, London, 1960). 4 R.B. Schwarz and C. C. Koch, Appl. Phys. Lett., 12 146 (1986). 5 N.G. Parsonage and L. A. K. Staveley, Disorder in Solids (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1978) 6 H. Suga and T. Matsuo, Pure & Appl. Chem., 61 1123 (1989). 7 S.A. Brawer, Relaxation in Viscous Liquids and Glasses (Am. Ceram. Soc., New York, 1985). 8 I. Kishimoto, J.-J. Pinvidic, T. Matsuo and H. Suga, Proc. Jpn. Acad., 67B 66 (1981). 9 H. Suga, T. Matsuo and O. Yamamuro, Supramolecular Chem., 1 221 (1993). 10 Y. Tajima, T. Matsuo and H. Suga, Nature, 297 810 (1982). 11 H. Hikawa, M. Oguni and H. Suga, J. Non-cryst. Solids, 101 90 (1988). 12 M. Oguni, H. Hikawa and H. Suga, Thermochim. Acta, 158 1143 (1990). 13 K.-J. Kim, K. Sumiyama and K. Suzuki, J. Non-cryst. Solids, 155 165 (1993). 14 I. Tsukushi, O. Yamamuro and H. Suga, J. Therm. Anal., 37 1359 (1991). 15 I. Tsukushi, O. Yamamuro and H. Suga, To be published. 16 H. Suga, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci., 484 248 (1986). 17 H. Suga, T. Matsuo and O. Yamamuro, Pure & Appl. Chem., 64 17 (1992). 18 J.D. Bernal and R. H. Fowler, J. Chem. Phys., 1 515 (1933). 19 J.L. Atwood, J. E. Davies and D. D, MacNicol (Eds), Inclusion Compounds, Vol III (Academic Press, London, 1984). 20 I. Tsukushi, O. Yamamuro and H. Suga, The rmoc him. Acta., 200, 711 (1992).
journal or
I~OLE~ULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molecular Liquids, 65/66 (1995) 123-130
Slow Dynamics in Supercooled Fluids Y. Hiwatari, J. Matsui, T. Muranaka*, and T. Odagaki** Department of Physics, Kanazawa University, Kanazawa 920-11, Japan "General Education, Aichi Institute of Technology, Toyota 470-03, Japan "*Department of Physics, Kyushu University, Fukuoka 812, Japan Abstract Molecular dynamics simulation is a useful tool in general to investigate dynamical properties of condensed matters from a microscopic point of view. This is the case for highly supercooled liquids and the liquid-glass transition as well. However, we have to pay special attentions to the length of time as well as the time-mesh size and the system size of the simulations for the study of slow dymamics which governs the relaxation of such particular systems. In this paper, we study the slow dynamics of a highly supercooled fluid by calculating the general susceptibility x(q,w) with both two- and three-dimensional binary soft-sphere models and super-long-time molecular dynamics simulations. It is found that the Cole-Cole analysis clearly distinguishes between the a and fl relaxations of supercooled fluid states. A spurious sound-mode peak appearing in x"(q,w) (imaginary part of the general susceptibility) turns out to be located at oJ inversely proportional to the length of the simulation cell size and seems to be physically meaningless. This peak may be caused by the periodic boundary conditions used in the present simulation.
I. Introduction It is known that the density autocorrelation function or the intermediate scattering function F(q, w) in the supercooled fluid phase can well be described by a stretched exponential function of the form F(q,w) ~_ Aexp[-(t/to) ~] with positive constants A, to and fl(< 1) in a time region available in experiments and computer simulations. This particular relaxation is called a relaxation, and such a characteristic decay manifests itself in a slower decay of the dynamical structure factor S(q, w) ~_ w -~-1 and of the a peak of the general susceptibility X"(q,w) ~- w-n, as acompared to the usual Debye forms S(q,w) ~ w -2 and X"(q,w) ~- w -1. It has recently been reported from light scattering experiments that there are two distinct slow relaxations, a and ~ relaxations, in the supercooled fluid states of CKN. Similar slow relaxations have been observed in various systems. In our previous papers 1,2, we have shown that collective jump motions of atoms take place in highly supercooled fluid states, mainly contributing to the a relaxation, and therefore represents the molecular-level mechanisms. The main purpose of this paper is to study both a and fl relaxations from S(q,w) and X"(q,w) in a supercooled fluid by a super-long-time molecular dynamics (MD) simulation for a model fluid of binary soft-sphere mixtures. In particular, we focus on studying the type of each relaxation (Debye or non-Debye ?) and the molecular-level processes for the fl relaxation. In order to find chracteristic motions of atoms at a microscopic level and to reveal the 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. SSD! 0167-7322 (95) 00899-3
124 nature of dynamics most relevant to these relaxations, we have also carried out MD simulations for a 2-dimensional (2-d) soft-sphere model as well as for a 3-d model. In general, 2-d simulations are more advantageous to visualize the correlations of motions of atoms than 3-d simulations, and can remarkably help us find molecular-level solutions of the dynamics of our interest.
II. S o f t - s p h e r e m o d e l As a simple model for binary fluids, we consider in our MD simulation soft-sphere mixtures composed of N1 atoms of mass ml and diameter al and N2 atoms of mass m2 and diameter a2 in a volume V for a 3-d system or in an area S for a 2-d system; the atoms interact through the purely repulsive soft-sphere potentials: v,~a = e
,
(1)
where a, fl denote species indices, and e the energy unit. Here, we assume that a~a = (a,~ + h a ) / 2 . Using the notation of the effective one-component approximation, we introduce the effective coupling constant Felt, i.e., for the 3-d system r e ff - - n . ( T * ) - l / 4
(~ 3' \cr 1 /
3 _. ~a~,BXaXj30.3j3, Creff
(2)
and for the 2-d system
F~fr -" n ' ( T ' ) -1/6 (a~fr~ 2 \ (71 /
'
2
O'ef t ~--
E~
2 ~XaX~(Ta~.
(3)
Here, n" = N a 3 / V for the 3-d system and N a 2 / S for the 2-d system, denoting the reduced number density with the total number of atoms N(= N1 + N2). The reduced temperature T" equals k s T / e , and x l ( = N1/N) and z2(= 1 - z l ) are concentrations. Note that F4~ for the 3-d system and F~fr for the 2-d system are inversely proportional to T'; thus larger Feff'S corresponding to lower temperatures. In the present work we study binary soft-sphere mixtures with a core-size ratio a2/al 1.2 for the 3-d system and a2/al -- 1.4 for the 2-d system, respectively, a mass ratio m2/ml = 2.0 and an equimolar concentration (xl = 0.5) for both 3-d and 2-d systems. Using a constant-temperature MD technique and the peiodic boundary conditions, we have carried out MD simulations for the models. The pair potential, Eq. (1), was cut off over the distance r / a ~ - 3.5 and the number density was kept constant, i.e. n" = 0.8; the temperature was varied to achieve a desired Feff. The microscopic time scale was chosen to be =
E
,
(4)
which is nearly in the same order of magnitude as the Einstein period rE, namely the period of oscillations of atoms in an equivalent solid. This time scale T is of the order of 10 -13 sec, when we use the potential parameters suitable for argon liquid in Eq. (4). The equations of motion were solved numerically with a time mesh of the order of 100th of T, which precisely depends on the temperature of the system.
III. 3 - d i m e n s i o n a l results
1:2.~
We have carried out MD simulations for the 3-d binary soft-sphere model with N - 5 0 0 atoms in a cubic cell. First, we have simulated a liquid equilibrium at Fefr = 0.8; then with using the configuration at the final step of this run, the system was quenched down to Fefr = 1.50 (quenching process) followed by annealing MD simulation at this F~fr over ten million time steps. This ['eft is still lower than Fg (=1.58, the glass transition), but slightly higher than Fc (=1.45, kinetic transition) in the supercooled fluid phase. The Fourier and Laplace transformations, S(q,w) and G(q,w), of the intermediate scattering function F(q, t) are defined as:
S(q,w)
= ~1 f_~ F(q, t)ei~t dt,
(5)
oo
a(q,~o)
where
=
F(q,t) = (E i
/5
(6)
F ( q , t ) ~ - ~ ' at,
e iq'[ri(t+t~
-
ri(t0)]~
.
(7)
li,to
The averages are taken over the configuration of atoms {ri} and the initial time to. It is known that the general susceptibility x(q,w) is related to G(q,w) and S(q,w) as follows:
x'(q,w) x"(q,w)
= 1 + wa"(q,w), wG'(q,w), = ~ S ( q , ~),
(8) (9)
=
(~0)
where x(q,w) = x'(q,w) + iX"(q,w) and G(q,w) = G'(q,w) + iG"(q,w); prime means the real part, and double primes the imaginary part. In the present MD simulation, G(q,w) was calculated with the following equation: 3
G(q,w) = -~ Ej
dto eiq'r'(t~176
dt e -iq'ri(t)+iwt
,
(11)
i where < ... > means an average over the configuration of atoms (ri}, and T is the total time step of the simulation. x~(q,w) obtained from Eq. (11) is shown in Fig. 1. Here, the subscript s stands for the self part of the function, i.e. in the summation ~ j of Eq. (11) only the term j = i is taken into consideartion. The following two remarks should be noted. First the a (left) peak in x"(q,w) depends on T (the upper limit of the integration). Since the a relaxation involves the slowest relaxation process of the density fluctuations in the supercooled fluid, the value of the integration Eq. (11) in the low frequency region seems to depend significantly on the value of T. By careful considerations of x"(q,w) obtained by the present MD simulation (see Fig. 1), the c~ peak is clearly observed around log w = -3.2. We consider that the data below log w = -3.8, in particular the peak around log w -- -4.0, are not valid due to the finite T and do not have any physical meaning. Second, in Fig. 1, we observe the/3 peak around log w = 0.6 in the high frequency region. This peak is much clearer than the c~ peak. We note that the data in the high frequency region (log w > 1.2) monotonously increase as a function of log w resulting from the finite time increment (time mesh) used in the MD simulation and are therefore not correct. Figure 2 shows the Cole-Cole plots of xs(q,w). In this figure, as the frequency becomes higher, X's(q,w) moves from the right- to the left-hand side. As shown in Fig. 1, only the data without ! are reliable; the data marked by I are artificial caused by the finite T or the
126
finite time increment dt in the integration (11). From Fig. 2 we can conclude that the highfrequency data follows a half circle with a center on the abscissa, while the low-frequency data seem not to be fitted by a reasonable half circle with a center on the abscissa. This clearly indicates that the fl relaxation is regarded as being of a simple Debye type. This conclusion is consistent ~ith the decrement of x'(q,w) above the fl peak following w -1 (see Fig. 1 ).
0.0
9
-
9
1.0
,
-
f
-
.
f
3
A
tl v
!
f
3
f
"ID"
-1.0
v -=,
s o -2.0
-4.0
-2.0
Iog~o ~
0.0
2.0
0.0
.... o:o '
'
'
~'(q ,to)
1.o
(left) Fig. 1. The imaginary part of the general susceptibility (self part) , ~ ( q , ~ ) vs. w. The reduced wave number q'(= qL/27r) equals 8.0, where L is the side length of the cubic simulation cell. The circles represent the results of the numerical integration of Eq. (11); the solid symbols are for the lighter species, and the open symbols are for the heavier species. Unreliable data due to the finite numerical integration are marked by [ on their data points. The two peaks around log w ~ - 3 . 2 and 0.6 are the a- and ~-peaks, respectively. The solid lines indicate two power-law behaviors around the ~ minimum, represented by ,~(q,w) " w -0"47 and x~(q,w) " w 0"74 by the least-square fit. The dashed // line, x~(q, w) ~ w- 1 . 0 , is compatible to a typical Debye type. (right) Fig. 2. Cole-Cole plots of x,(q,w), i.e., X.;'(q,w) vs. ,~:',(q, w). The symbols are the same as in Fig. 1. At least two distinct relaxation modes are seen: the semi circle near the origin represents the fl relaxation, while that in the left-hand side represents the c~ relaxation. The latter seems to differ from a semi circle.
IV. 2-dimensional results Annealing MD simulation for the 2-d soft-sphere model with N=10000 atoms has been carried out over the time steps of 10007- at Fefr= 1.4 in the glass phase; the glass transition for the 2-d system is estimated to be between F g = l . 2 and 1.3. Figure 3 shows the displacements of a group of atoms in a portion of the whole system during the period of 47- in the annealed MD simulation. It is observed that the displacements of atoms are shorter than al, but substantially larger than the amplitude of thermal
127
vibrations, their directions being highly (nearly linearly) correlated with each other. In order to measure the degree of such a correlation between a referred atom (i-th atom) and the surrounding atoms within a cut-off distance r~, we introduce the correlated-motion coefficient CMi(r~, t): 4 N~
CMi(rc, t) = ~
A r i ( t ) . Arj(t)/Ar2(t)N~,
(12)
rij <~rc
where Ari(t) displacement from the i-th the i-th atom
is the displacement vector of the i-th atom and Ar2(t) the mean square for an elapsed time t, and Ni is the number of atoms within the distance rc atom at t = 0. The summation j is taken over the near-neighbor atoms of within the cut-off distance re, i.e., rij < re.
(Or)
0 position(5.59,16.77)
+5.0
Z~
=~ ~
: ~
~ ~
.
....
~-~
Y 0.0 ....
......... 4
......
.... ~
........
~,
,
..... ~ - - ~
.....
.......... ~ - ............ - ~ . . . . ~
.............
,
-5.0 -5.0
0.0
x
in of in of
+5.0
(o,)
Fig. 3. Movements of atoms around the position (5.59, 16.77), the center of this figure the present simulation cell with a side length of 111.80 in units of al during the period 47-. The circles represent the initial positions of atoms, and triangles the final positions the period of 47-. Both X- and Y-coordinates are the relative distances from the center this figure..
128 Figure 4 shows the space distribution of such correlations. It is clearly seen that there are large clusters of the dark points marked by the highest graduation in this figure, connected to each other in almost the whole simulation cell. For a shorter elapsed time, we have obtained a similar result, but dark and white points are almost randomly distributed. Note that the time scale used in Fig. 4 is about one order of magnitude longer than that of thermal vibrations. It will be shown below that such a time scale corresponds to the relaxation.
(o,) 50.0
9
Y 0.0
-50.0
-50.0
0.0
x
50.0
(o,)
Fig. 4. Spacial distributions of the strength of the correlations as calculated by the correlated motion coefficient C Mi(2.0, 5.0) for all atoms. The circle at the right-hand side of the figure denotes the size of the cut-off radius re, which is chosen here to be 2.0 al. All circles in different graduation and in different size represent the initial positions of all atoms of the simulation cell. The graduation is made according to the values of CM~, divided into five classes; the darker the graduation is, the larger the value of CMi is obtained. Both Xand Y-coordinates are in units of al.
129
The imaginary part of the generalied susceptibility (self part only) for the 2-d binary soft-sphere model at ['eft = 1.4 is shown in Fig. 5. The peak around co "-" 3 . 1 0 (in units of r -1) corresponds to the thermal vibrations (highest-frequency mode). The peak around co = 2 is the fl peak. This frequency is consistent with the time scale of the collective motions mentioned above. Therefore, these collective motions can be an origin of the /3 peak of x~(q,w). Analyzing the temperature dependence of CM~, we have found that the size of correlated domains becomes significantly larger as the temperature is lowered. In Fig. 5, there also appear largely scattered data in the lower-frequenc side of the/3 peak. Though physical meanings of these data have not yet been well understood, we think they are perhaps artificials. The reasons are followings: It has been found that the maximum among the data depends strongly on the system size of simulations and that the frequency of the maximum is inversely proportional to the length of the simulation cell and nearly equals the inverse of the time for the sound wave to propagate from one side to another of the simulation cell. This suggests that the maximum and the near-by data are seriously influenced by the periodic boundary conditions used in the simulations.
1 0.90.80.70.6-
........
!
........
'
''
.... I
I
|
I
II
o 0
)
0 0 4 0 ~
r~
o o
0.2-
0
0
0
oO00
|
00
~
Oo
|
~
0
0
o
0.1 -2
'
D
~ 0 , 5 -
3 EO.4=-_.. ~0.3-
I-
o 0
0
i , , .i|[
-1
0
i
i
i
i i,,,i
,
0 log,0( aJ )
,
s
, .,.,|
I
,
,
,
.
(1/~')
Fig. 5. Imaginary part of the generalized susceptibility (self part), xJ(q, co), for the lighter species at Fefr = 1.4 in 2-d system. The wave number is q = 27r in units of al, and in abscissa is in units of 7 -1 .
130 V. Conclusions
Main results of the present work are summarized as follows: (1) The a peak as well as the ~ peak in X"(q,w) spectrum was obtained. This is the first case to confirm the existence of of the a peak by MD simulation. (2) We have found that the fl relaxation is essentially of a Debye type. (3) We have obtained spacially collective motions in the time scale of the relaxation; the collective motions therefore are regarded as an origin of the ~ relaxation. (4) We have remarked that the periodic boundary conditions used in the simulations may cause an artificial peak in x"(q,w) and one therefore must be very careful. Finally, we comment on the difference between the self part and the full density autocorrelation function. The full density autocorreration function and the dynamical structure factor are experimentally measured, while in the present MD simulation only the self part was studied. However, the difference between both correlation functions (dynamical structure factors) is considered to be rather small except that additional modes associated with sound modes appear in the full density autocorrelation. We have previously computed the full density autocorrelation via MD simulations for the same model as the present one, and found that the general behavior of the a relaxation was little changed. General trends of the relaxation are nearly the same for both full correlation and self part. In addition, from a point of numerical calculations, the self part is more easily obtained than the full autocorrelation; the statistics of the data obtained from MD simulatons is much higher for the self part than for the full autocorrelation.
References
1 Y. Hiwatari, H. Miyagawa and T. Odagaki, Solid State Ionics, 47, 179 (1991) 2 Y. Hiwatari, J. Matsui, K. Uehara, T. Muranaka, H. Miyagawa, M. Takasu and T. Odagaki, P hysica A 204, 306 (1994). 3 J. Matsui, T. Odagaki and Y. Hiwatari, Phys. Rev. Letters, 73, 2452 (1994). 4 T. Muranaka and Y. Hiwatari, Phys. Rev. submitted.
joumaJ of"
MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molecular Liquids, 65/66 (1995) 131-138
Density Functional Theory of Solution Dynamics Toyonori M u n a k a t a
Department of Applied Mathematics and Physics, K y o t o University, K y o t o 606 J a p a n
Abstract The density functional theory for classical(equilibrium) statistical mechanics is generalized to deal with various dynamical processes associated with density fluctuations in liquids and solutions. This is effected by deriving a Langevin-diffusion equation for the density field. As applications of our theory we consider density fluctuations in both supercooled liquids and molecular liquids and transport coefficients.
I. Introduction The density functional theory(DFT) 1-4 has become a useful method to study freezing transition from a quantitative standpoint.
The DFT is now generalized to deal with complex systems such as
molecular liquids s and liquid crystals 4. It is to be noted that the DFT is basically concerned with the (quasi)equilibrium density profile neq(r) and the corresponding free-energy Feq --- F[neq(r)], where
F[n(r)] denotes the free-energy functional of the system and plays the central role in the DFT. If we could introduce dynamics to the DFT and follow time evolution of the density field n(r,t), this might enable us to study some dynamic processes such as density fluctuations and transport coefficients. In this paper we present a time-dependent(TD) DFT together with some (preliminary) applications of the TD-DFT. In Section 2 the DFT is briefly reviewed and in Section 3 a Langevin-diffusion(L-D) equation for the density field n(r,t) is presented. In Section 4 we consider, as applications of the TD-DFT, (A) density fluctuations in liquids and solutions and (B)mass flow around a fixed particle to calculate transport coefficients of liquids. Section 5 contains some remarks and summary of this paper.
II. D e n s i t y F u n c t i o n a l T h e o r y ( D F T )
First let us consider a one-component liquid, whose density profile is denoted as n(r).
0167-7322J95/$09.50 9 1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. SSD/0167-7322 (95) 00847-0
From a
132 variational principle 2,3, we obtain an equation to determine the equilibrium density profile
$f[n]/6n(r)- p + r
neq(r) :
= 0,
(1)
where Celt(r) is the external field and p is the chemical potential. We may say that all the difficulties of a many-body problem are embedded in the free-energy functional methods heretofore 3. All the approaches divide (excess) part - ~ [ n ] , with
Fid exactly
F[n] into
F[n] and
with h the thermal wavelength [h 2/2rmkBT]
1/2. Standard
Taylor expansion around the uniform liquid state n(r) = =
Fid[n], and
an interaction
given by
Fid[n] = kBT f drn(r)[ln(n(n)h a) -
.[n]
there have been proposed many
an ideal gas part
(2)
1],
perturbational approaches employ a functional
nL, a
constant,
E(1/rn[)fdrl.-.fdrm6m~/6n(rl)...6n(rrn)lnL(n(rl)--nL)...(n(rm)--nL)
=_ (kBT)E(1/m!) f dr,.../drm
era(r1,'" ,rm)(n(rl)
which is usually truncated after m = 2. e In this case
F[n]'~Fid[n] -
Fin] takes
-
I'lL)...(n(bmirm)
-
I'lL) ,
(3)
the form
(kBT f dvlc,[n(v,)-nL]
+ (kBT/2)fdrlfdr2e2([r2--r~l)[n(rl)--nLl[n(r2)--nL]},
(4)
where use is made of the fact that for a uniform system cl is a constant and c2 is a function of Iv2 - r l I. It is not difficult to derive the relation between c2 and the radial distribution function g(r) =
h(r)+ 1, 2,3 (5)
h(r) = c2(r) + nL f dr'h(r')c~(Ir - r'l).
Equation (5) is the familiar Ornstein-Zernike relation and hereafter we denote the direct correlation function c2(r) as
c(r). Based on (1) and
(4) with (2), one can discuss freezing transition of one-component
liquids. 1-3 For an S-component mixture, which is specified by S density fields,
nj(r)(j = 1,... ,S),
we
have, instead of (4),
Fin] ~_ F~jFid[nj]- {kBtEif arlcl,j
[ n i ( r ) l - nj,L]
+ (kBT/2,Eij fdrl/dr2ci.j(lr2--rl,[ni(rl)--ni.L][nj(r2)--nj,L]},
(6,
where c i j ( r ) denotes the direct correlation function between the species i and j.7 For molecular liquids, the DFT is more complicated due to the constraints imposed by the fixed bond length. 5
III. Time-Dependent
Density Functional Theory (TD-DFT)
We now present a Langevin-diffusion(L-D) equation for the density field n ( r , t ) and the corresponding
133
Fokker-Planck(F-P) equation for the distribution functional f[n(r),t] and discuss general properties of
the TD-DFT. s,9 By combining a number-conservation law, the D F T and theory of Brownian motion, we
derived the following equations for the density n(r,t) and the m o m e n t u m density g(r,t) : cg(r,t)/Ot = - V . g ( r , t ) / m , cgg(r,t)/~ = - n ( r , t ) V 6 F / 6 n ( r , t ) -
(7)
r 0 g ( r , t) + y ( r , t ) .
(8)
where - V 6 F / 6 n ( r ; t ) represents a generalized force on a particle at r x~ and the random force f ( v , t ) satisfies the fluctuation-disspation (FD) theorem of the form
< f i ( r , t ) f j ( r ' , t ' ) > = 2 m k B T r o n ( r , t ) ~ ( r - r')6(t - t')6i~,
(9)
with i and j denoting the Cartesian components. Since we are interested in long time behavior, we employ an adiabatic approximation for (8), yielding g(r,t) = {-n(r,t)V6F/6n(r,t) + y(r,t)}/r0.
(10)
From (7) and (10) we finally obtain the L-D equation,
cgn(r,t)/Ot = - V . { - n ( r , t ) V 6 F / 6 n ( r , t ) + f ( r , t ) } / ( m r 0 ) = - 1 7 . { i s + J R } ,
(11)
with the FD theorem (9). Js and JR in (11) denote the systematic and the random current ,respectively. From the FD theorem (9) it is seen that the random current j a ( r ; t ) = f ( r ; t ) / r n r o is a multiplicative noise it and one must specify how one interprets the noise. Here for our purpose it is to be treated as an Ito type. Following a routine procedure n to derive a F-P equation from a Langevin equation, we see that the distribution functional f[n(r),t] evolves in time, with D - k B T / ( m r o ) , according to
Of~at= -/dr6n~J(f
),
J ( f ) = D { f l f V . n ( r ) V 6 F / 6 n ( r ) + V . n(r)V6 f /6n(r)} . When f is proportional to exp(-flF[n]), V . n ( r ) V 6 f / 6 n ( r ) =
V. n ( r ) { - f l f V 6 F / 6 n ( r ) }
(12) (13) =-/3fVn(r)V
6F/6n(r) and we confirm that the stationary solution is given by e x p ( - f l F ) . In other words, the L-D equation (11) actually samples,in a steady state, the density field n(r) according to the weight exp(-/~F). The multiplicativeness of the noise f ( r , t) can be interpreted based on a simple hopping diffusion model and can be related to the internal noise proposed by Mikhailov. t2 General properties of the T D - D F T are most concisely represented by the following two H-theorems the proofs of which are given elsewhere. 9 First we neglect the random current JR and consider the diffusion equation
On(r,t)/Ot = ~ D V . n(r,t)X76F/6n(r,t) = - V . ] s ( r , t ) .
(14)
First H-theorem : When the density field n ( r , t ) evolves in time according to (14), F[n] decreases in time according to dF/dt = - 0 3 D ) - t f dr { j s ( r , t ) } ~ / n ( r , t ) < 0 until ] s ( r , t ) vanishes and it holds that
6F/6n(r) = p, representing the variational condition (1) in the D F T to determine the equilibrium density
134
field for the case ~,=t(r) = 0. N o w we turn to the full L-D equation (I I).
Second H-theorem : W h e n the distribution functional fin,t]evolves in time according to the F-P equation (12) the generalized free-energy functional Fa[f] defined by
Fat/] = / DnFtnlf[n;t] + kBT / Dnftn]ln(ftn]),
(15)
decreases in time monotonically according to
dFa/dt =
-
/ Dn / dr {(kBT//Dn(v))x/2:is(r) - (DkBTn(r)//)l/2v(6//6n(r))} 2 < 0
(16)
until f[n, t] takes the form
/,,In] = const, exp[-F[nl/kBT].
(17)
We note that f Dn denotes the integration over the function space of n(v). When the integrand of (16) is zero, we have (17). Comparing the two theorems it is seen that the noise JR prevents the density field
n(r,t) from b~eing trapped in one of the local minima of the functional Fin]. la The results obtained above is readily generalized to mixtures.
V. A p p l i c a t i o n s of T D - D F T
In this section we apply T D - D F T developed in the previous section to study dynamic density fluctuations (A) and transport coefficients(B). In these studies the approximation (4) or (6) for the free-energy functional is employed since we have no reliable information on higher-order direct correlation functions cn(n > 3).
(A) Density fluctuations in liquids and solutions
Inserting (6) with (2) into (11) we obtain the following L-D equation :
cOn(r,t)/Ot = nV2n - DV. n(r,t)V f dr~c([r - r~l)[n(r',t) - nL]- V . JR
(18)
We note that the second term on the rhs of (18) describes a diffusion process, which is induced by the Vlasov field VF -
-kBTfdr'c(Ir-
r'[)[n(r',t)- nL]. Equation(18) with or without the random
current T M together with its generalization to two-component system 15 and to polar liquids 16'17 have been playing important roles and now generally called a Smoluchowski-Vlasov equation. As an application of the L-D equation (18) with the F-D theorem (9), we calculated the dynamic structure factor r of a simple liquid
G(q,t) = < n(q,t)n(-q,O) > / < n(q)n(-q) > .
(19)
135
with n(q,t)=_ f dr { n ( r , t ) - nL } e x p ( - - i q - r ) / N 1/2. Fourier-transformation of (18) and the FD theorem (9) yield
On(q, t)/Ot = -7(q)n(q,t) + Ek V(q, k)n(k,t)n(q - k,t) + r
(20)
> = - 2 D q . q'6(t - t') {6q+q,,0 + n(q + q',t)/NX/2},
(21)
where 7(q) = Dq2/s(q), with s(q) denoting the static structure factor, c(q) = 1 - 1/s(q), and V(q,k) =
Dc(k)q. k / N ~/2. If we neglect effects of both nonlinearity in(20) and the multiplicativeness of the noise, n(q,t) becomes a simple Ornstein -Uhlenbeck process ~1 and G(q,t) and the dynamic structure factor G"(q,w) = (1/2) f dtG(q,t)exp(iwt) are given by Go(q,t) = exp(-v(q)t) and Gg(q, w) = 7(q)/[v(q) 2 + w2],
(22)
respectively, where the subscript 0 on G means that we regard it as the zeroth aproximation to G.
In
calculating G(q,t) based on (20) and (21) we follow a nonlinear theory of fluctuations by Mori and Fujisaka. xr
Numerical calculation is performed for a hard sphere system characterized by a packing
fraction p = r~3nL/6, is Percus-Yevick approximation is used to supply the structural information. As p becomes large we observe narrowing of the central peak, reflecting slowing down of the density fluctuations due to nonlinear coupling in (20). At p = 0.53 a dynamic 'instability' occured where an effective diffusion constant crosses zero. As is well known the hard sphere system freezes at p ~_ 0.5 and the D F T in its various version has been applied to study the transition. 19 It is interesting to note that the interaction part of the free-energy(4) gives rise to the equilibrium transition on the one hand and it also gives rise to the instability through the nonlinear coupling in the L-D equation (20). Before leaving this section it is noted that if we take the free-energy functional (6) for an S-component mixture we have a set of L-D equations for S density fields ni(r,t)(i = 1,... ,S), which lead to
On,(r,t)/Ot=D, [ V 2 n , ( r , t ) - V
.n,(v,t)V { E j / d , ' c , ~ ( l r -
r'l)6nj(r', t)}]-
V . in,,
(23)
Furthermore if we take the free-energy functional as given by Chandler et hi. 5 for molecular(polyatomic) liquids, we obtain from (11) a L-D equation for each of the atomic species constituting the molecules, which is very similar to (20). After liniarization as done in (22), we obtain a linear diffusion equation, which was used by Hirata lr to investigate the dynamic structure factors of water.
(B) Some Transport Coefficients In this subsection we put a particle at an origin in a velocity field u ( r ) and study effects of flow on a stationary density profile n,t(r). When there is no flow u(r) = o, n,t(r) is obviously given by nLg(r), with g(r) a radial distribution function. Due to the flow u(r), this equilibrium distribution is distorted and from the distortion we can calculate some transport coefficients, like viscosity 7] and friction constant ~, as we show below. We consider a one-component system and neglect random current JR in (18) to obtain
8n(r,t)lbt = - V - j , ( r , t ) ,
(24)
136
j,(v,t) = DVn - a D ~ V t f dr'v~]] (Jr - r ' l ) , ( r ' , t ) + r where v,/l(r ) = -kBTc(r) and r
+ nu,
(25)
two-body interaction, represents effects of the particle fixed at
r = o. The last term on the rhs of (25) represents particle flow due to the velocity field, u ( r ) . We are interested in a stationary density profile n , t ( r ) around the fixed particle. First we consider the equilibrium solution n , q ( r ) when u = 0. In this case the particle flow j0 = o and from (25) we readily obtain ln[gCr)] __
ln[-,,C.)/-L] = -~ f dr'v,ss(l~ -
v'l)nL[g(r')
-
1] -- flr
(26)
where the boundary condition n,q(r) --* nL as r ---,oo is taken into account. From the relation (5) between h and c, we observe immediately that (26) is equivalent to the H N C equation to determine g(r). Thus our theory, when applied to anequilibrium situation, g!ves the H N C
result for g(r).z
Now let us turn to effects of the flow field u(r) on nat(r). We consider, to be concrete, shear flow
u(r) = 7yeffi where ez denotes a unit vector in the x-direction. In this case we assume a solution of the form n , i ( r ) - nLg(r)[1 4- w(r)7/D -t- o(7)]
(27)
where o(7)/~ --+ 0 as 7 ~ 0. Inserting (27) into (24) with i)n/Ot - O, we obtain
gV2w--nLgV2 i dr'c(Ir-r'l)g(r')w(r')+Vg.Vw-nLVg.V
i dr'c(Ir-r'l)g(r')w(,')
zyg'(r)/7. (28)
with use of Fourier transformation it is seen that (28) has a solution of the form w(r) = z y a ( r )
(29)
and a(r) satisfies a complicated integro-differential equation, which we do not write down here. The final step to obtain shear viscosity 71 is to calculate the xy component of the stress tensor axy, which is expressed, on the one hand, in terms of ,7 and 7 as =! =
'7")'
(30)
and also microscopically as T
ffxy = where r
(nLI2) ] drno,(r)xyr
(31)
- de~dr and we have neglected the kinetic contribution, which is very small at a liquid
density. Use of the solution (29) together with (30) and (31) gives
r] = (n2L/2D) / dr(xy)~ g(r)r
(32)
If we fix a particle in a uniform flow u ( r ) = uoe~, we can calculate the friction constant ( from a stationary force on a fixed particle by following similar lines of reasoning as above. Our preliminary results for shear viscosity r / o f a soft-core system with r
= e ( a / r ) 12 shows that
main contributions in the integrand in (32) come from the region r ~_ (V/N) ~/a (of course in the highdensity state) and that r/increases sharply as a function of p. =_ (elkBT)I/4(Nvra/V). Although detailed
137
analysis of 77 and ~ based on our TD-DFT needs some time to be completed, it seems that our approach is promising in view of the fact that we have at the moment nearly no (microscopic) theory for r/and (, especially for dense complex systems like water.
V. S o m e R e m a r k s a n d S u m m a r y
In this paper we gave a dynamic extension of the DFT, by deriving a L-D equation (11) with the /
fluctuation-dissipation theorem (9). We showed that the stochastic equation correctly samples the density field according to the probability exp {-/~F[n]},(17), based on the second H-theorem (16). At this point we note however that our TD-DFT is phenomenological and it is desirable to have a first-principle dynamics generalization of DFT. As applications of TD-DFT, we considered density fluctuations in liquids and transport coefficients. We are currently trying to solve the L-D equation in a real space-time to study slow dynamics in supercooled liquids. This study may be considered to be a dynamic counterpart of the work by Dasgupta and Ramaswamy is and as a similar attempt we mention the work by Lust and Valls 2~ We expect that our L-D equation has many fields of application. One example is dynamics in molecular liquids, as noted at the end of subsection IV(A), which is a very important field in connection with chemical reactions in solutions but, at the same time, is very complex to deal with from first principles.
References 1 R.Evans, Adv.Phys. 28 143(1979). 2 A.D.J.Haymet, Ann.Rev.Phys.Chem. 38 89(1987). 3 D.W.Oxtoby, In 'Liquid, Freezing, and the Glass Transition', (Eds. J.P.Hansen,D.Levesque and J.Zinn-Justin) (Elsevier:New York,1990) 4 Y.Singh, Phys.Rep. 207 351(1991). 5 D.Chandler, J.D.McCoy, and S.J.Singer, J.Chem.Phys. 85 5971;5977(1986). 6 T.V.Ramakrishnan, and M.Yussouff, Phys.Rev. B19 2775(1979). 7 J.P.Hansen, and I.R.McDonald.' Theory of Simple Liquid s'(Academic, New York, 1986). 8 T.Munakata, J.Phys.Soc.Jpn. 58 2434(1989). 9 T.Munakata, Phys.Rev.E(1994) to appear 10 T.R.Kirkpatrick and P.G.Wolynes, Phys.Rev. A35 3072(1987). 11 C.W.Gardiner ' Handbook od Stochastic Methods' (Springer, Berlin,1982) 12 A.S.Mikhailov, Phys.Rep. 84 307(1989).
13 C.Dasgupta and S.C.Ramaswamy, Physica A186 314(1992). 14 T.Munakata, J.Phys.Soc.Jpn. 43 1723(1977). 15 B.Bagchi, Physica 145 A 273(1987). 16 D.F.Calefand P.G.Wolynes, J.Chem.Phys. 78 4145(1983).
17 F.Hirata, J.Chem.Phys. 96 4619(1992). 18 H.Mori and H.Fujisaka, Prog.Theor.Phys. 49 764(1973). 19 T.Munakata, J.Phys.Soc.Jpn. 59 1299(1990). 20 A.D.J.ttaymet and D.W.Oxtoby, J.Chem.Phys. 84 1769(1986). 21 L.M.Lust and V.Valls, Phys.Rev.E 48 1787(1993).
journal of
~IOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of Molecular Liquids, 65/66 (1995) 139-147
Dissociation and Solvation in W a t e r and A q u e o u s Solutions A.D.J. H a y m e t School of Chemistry, University of Sydney, N S W 2006 Australia Abstract Recently the properties of both charged and un-charged solutes in aqueous solution have been elucidated by computer simulations and approximate integral equation theories. While answering some questions, others are raised. In particular the structure of water next to a charged surface (or a very large charged solute) is a challenge. Approximate integral equation theories can address this challenge.
I.
Introduction
Water plays an important role in the chemistry and physics of bulk solutions and interfaces, including electrochemistry and macromolecules in solution. Usually the water is treated as a structureless, dielectric continuum, such as in the Debye-Hiickle approximation 1 for electrolytes, the Gouy-Chapman-Stern 2-4 (GCS) approximation for the electrical 'double layer' and the DLVO 5'6 approximation for colloids. Properties sensitive to the molecular nature of water cannot be determined by these theories. Recently we have published integral equation predictions for a flexible model of water next to a planar interface. T Experimental motivation for this work includes electrochemical experiments on ultra-pure (O2-free) water, s'9 surface EXAFS studies of the oxygenmetal distance for water at an electrode, 1~ and the tunnel junction device measurements of Porter and Zinn. 11 Vossen and Forstmann ~2 have published a related calculation using a different model of water and a different approximation for the bulk water bridge functions. Below we compare the input to the two calculations. First we review some results in bulk water and solutions of non-polar solutes.
II.
A m o d e l of water
We have studied via molecular dynamics computer simulation a number of properties of so-called CF1 central force model of water, 13'14 although our methods may be applied to any model of water with a unified Hamiltonian for intra- and inter-molecular degrees of freedom. The CF1 model is a slight variant of the central force (CF) model of Stillinger and Rahman, is which allows the water molecules to vibrate and even dissociate. 13,~6 Central force models view water as a 'molten salt' of two fractionally charged species, hydrogen and oxygen. MD simulations show that the static dielectric constant and pH of the CF1 model at 25~ and 1.000 g cm -a are in good agreement with experiment. Such properties 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. SSD! 0167-7322 (95) 00848-9
140
are important for models of water which are to be used in electrolyte theory and other solution phase studies. We have also determined a number of physical properties of the CF1 model using integral equation methods. We conclude from these studies that the CF1 model is a valuable addition to the family of classical models of water. The output from this calculation is used in theories of inhomogeneous solutions. 7 The revised central force (CF) potentials of Stillinger and Rahman 15 are defined by
uoo(r)
=
144.538 { 26758.2C1 - 0 . 2 5 e -4(r-3"4)2 - 0 25e -1"5(r-4"5)2 r
7.8.8591
UHH(r) -- 36.1345 ~18 r 1 + e 4~176 72.269 UOH(7")
:
r
,
"
'
-- 17e-762177('-1"45251)2
6.23403
10
r 9"19912
1 -l- e 4 0 ( r - I ' 0 5 )
4 -
I
-I- e 5"49305(r-2"2)
'
(:)
where the values of the constants are C1 = C2 = 1. The distances are measured i n / ~ and energies in kcal tool -1. At the temperature 25~ and a mass density of 1.000 g cm -3, this model predicts a pressure of 3.54 kbar, thousands of times greater than atmospheric pressure of approximately 1 bar. 1T'ls By changing the constants slightly to C1 - 0.9 and C2 - 1/1.025, it was found that the pressure could be reduced to a more acceptable value of 120 bar. 13 We call this model of water the CF1 model. For both CF1 and CF water, each hydrogen species is assigned a partial charge of qH -- 0.32998e where e is the proton charge, while the oxygen species each carry a charge of qo - -2qH to ensure electroneutrality of individual H20 molecules. This fractional charge should not be regarded as a defect of the model, 19 but instead as arising from the 'screening' induced by integration over polarisation terms, three- and higher-body potentials, etc., to obtain the effective pairwise additive potential energies displayed in Equation (1). III.
Hydrophobicity
In 1993 Blokzijl and Engberts 2~ published an important review article on hydrophobic effects. In 1992, Smith, Zhang and Haymet 21'22 showed that hydrophobic association of uncharged solutes in water is almost entirely an entropy effect. Haymet 2a went on to point out that experimental data show that methane "likes" water about as well as it "likes" any other solvent from the point of view of enthalpy. This view is underlined by the experimentally high solubility of water in cryogenic solvents such as liquid methane. Hydrophobicity in fact arises from the entropy penalty incurred by the water. The methane is not hydrophobic: the water is 'methophobic'. Very recently Guillot 24 has performed a beautiful series of simulations using faithful models of rare gases and water, and determined solubilities along the liquid-gas coexistence line. These new contributions revise substantially the traditional view of hydrophobicity.
141
IV.
Ionic
Association
and
Dissociation
The potential of mean force (PMF) for sodium chloride in water has been simulated by numerous investigators for many different models. Smith and Haymet is noted that to dissociate a model sodium ion and chloride ion at room temperature and pressure, two free energy barriers appear to have to be surmounted. The first barrier is associated with the formation of a 'shared' layer of water molecules between the ions, now constituting a so-called 'solvent separated ion pair', and the second barrier associated with the final unlinking of the solvations shells of the two ions. Very recently, Cui and Harris 25 have evaluated the P MF for sodium ion and chloride ion in a model of supercritical water. They decompose the PMF into enthalpy and entropy contributions, as did Smith and Haymet for uncharged solutes, 21 and find that, at least in supercritical water, the entropy effect is dominant, just as for uncharged solutes at room temperature and pressure. The dissociation of a single water molecule has been studied, for the CF1 model, by our group, la'14 By calculating the PMF for separating a single water molecule into two ionic fragments, an upper bound to the pH of the CF1 model was predicted to be 8.4. Future work will involve calculating the relative concentration of H(aq) , + H30~-a.~,( ~, ..., HgO+(aq) and related OH~-,q) species. V.
Properties
of bulk
water
from
an integral
equation
The results summarised here are for pure water at the temperature 25~ and the density 1.000 g cm -3, and are obtained by solving numerically the Ornstein-Zernike (OZ) equation for the pair correlation functions, using a closure that supplements the hypernetted chain (HNC) approximation with a bridge function. The bridge function is determined from computer simulations as described below. The numerical method for solving the OZ equation is described by Ichiye and Haymet 26'27 and by Duh and Haymet. 2s For a liquid mixture of u species at temperature T and volume V. The potential energy Uab(rl:) between particles of species a and b, separated by a distance rl: - Irl - r21, is spherically symmetric and pairwise additive. The (iirect correlation function C~b(r12) is defined by the OZ equation:
hab(r12) -- Cab(r12) + ~-~.ps /v dra cas(rla)hsb(r32) ,
(2)
s--1
where hab(rl2) = gab(rl2)- 1 is the total correlation function and ps is the density of species s. The pair potential is separated into short- and long-range contributions: U~b = u~b + l which leads to a decomposition of the direct and total correlation functions into Uab, ._. 8 8 Cab Cab ~ (~ab and 'hab = hab + qab, where the long range parts of Cab and hab a r e defined to be r = --~U~b and q~b = &~b + ~ = 1 P~ ( ~ * %b, where ~-1 = k T , k is the Boltzmann constant, and 9denotes the convolution integral as in Equation (2). The long-range part of the potential is chosen to be the Coulombic interaction and Cab(r) = --/3q~qb/47r~o~r, where q, is the charge on species a. We retain the symbol e to display the formal similarity
142
with standard theories of electrolytes. Of course, for the present case of CF1 water, E = 1. The function qab is the (negative, dimensionless) Debye-Hiickel (DH) potential of mean force, qab(r) = --~qaq_______~bexp (--~r)
(3)
4~rEo~r
where a is the Debye inverse length defined by ~2 = f l ( e o e ) - i ~ a paq~. For the CF1 model at 25~ and 1.000 g cm -a, a-1 _ 12.402/1,, so this is a DH "strongly interacting" case. To solve the OZ equation, we use the exact closure which may be derived directly from the partition function: hab -I- 1 = exp(--flUab + hab -- Cab ~- Bab) ,
(4)
where Bab is the bridge function. 29 In the HNC approximation, Bab = 0 for all distances. The bridge functions used in this work are discussed below. The above equation becomes C~b -- exp(--~U~b + Tab + qab + Sab) -- 1 -- Tab - qab ,
(5)
where Tab = h~b -- C~b, which is the renormalized closure. The OZ equation and equation 3
g~
2
1 0 2
go.
1 0
i_.
4 3
gHH
2 1 0
0
2
4
6
r/A
Figure 1" Pair correlation functions gab(r) from experimental data of Soper31(thick solid line), and for CF1 water (solid line) and the VF model (dashed line). (5) are solved iteratively to obtain Tab and C~b. Since (I)ab and qab are determined once the potential has been separated into short- and long-range contributions, Cab and hab may be calculated from their definitions. Further details of the integral equation method may be found in the references. 2a-2s For central force models of water, the bridge function is essential for accurate solutions of the integral equations. Thuraisingham and Friedman 3~ found that at room temperature the HNC [Bab(r) -- 0] approximation for the CF model was in very poor agreement with
143
$
COO
-50 -100
,
i
,
i
,
CSoH -50
s
CHH
......i.......i........i....... -50 8
Figure 2: Short-range direct correlation functions c~b for CF1 water (solid line) and the VF model (dashed line). "exact" results from computer simulations. In 1988 Ichiye and Haymet ~~ showed that hard sphere bridge functions can be used to improve the quality of the solutions. We have determined these bridge functions by a numerical method. 16 The pair correlation function gab(r) obtained by solving the OZ equation with these bridge functions is shown in Figure 1, together with the experimental data for water by Soper. al Our integral equation calculation agrees to within the thinkness of the line with MD simulation of the same Hamiltonian. Also shown are the pair correlation functions for bulk water predicted by Vossen and Forstmann12(VF). They use the original CF model of water, together with a bridge function based on the original hard sphere bridge functions of Ichiye and Haymet, 26 augmented with an empirical hydrogen-hydrogen bridge function. The agreement between experiment and the VF calculation is not as good as our calculation, due in part to the CF model of water, and in part to the much more approximate bridge function. The pressure of the bulk VF water, calculated from these pair correlation functions, is approximately -48,000 bar. A full range of properties (including the dielectric constant) arising from our calculation are available. 16 The dielectric constant of CF1 water has been determined by molecular dynamics simulation to be 69 • 11.13 These calculations can also be compared with the perturbation calculations on CF water by Holovko and collaborators, a2 The difference between the two calculation is displayed more dramatically in Figure 2, where the short-range direct correlation functions arising from the two calculations are plotted. They differ markedly. As show below, a convenient theory of the wall - solution interface uses moments of these functions as input into the calculation of the structure and properties of the inhomogeneous system. Not shown in Figures 1 and 2 are the predictions of the well-known HNC approximation, which yields unacceptable CF1 pair correlation functions.
14,4,
VI.
Theory
for the
Interface
To predict the normalized probability g~i(z) for finding an oxygen (i = O) or hydrogen (i = H) atom of a water molecule at a distance z perpendicular to the planar interface ('wall'), we use the 'singlet' theory version of the Ornstein-Zernike equation due to Henderson, Abraham and Barker a3-3S and Percus. 36 We have also used this level of theory to study soft-core primitive model electrolytes next to charged interfaces. 3r The input to the calculation is: (i) the structure of the bulk model water, obtained above, contained in the direct correlation functions cij(r) for all distinct pairs of species, ij = OO, OH and HH, separated by a distance r; (ii) the bulk water density pB and temperature T; (iii) the short-range potential energy between the wall and the oxygen and hydrogen atoms, r i = O, H; and (iv) the surface potential r The normalized density profile g~i(z) is related to the absolute density profile p~i(z) via pwi(z)/p~ - g~i(z) - [ 1 + h~i(z)] , (6) where h~i(z) is the total wall-species correlation function. At fixed surface potential r the total correlation function and the surface charge density a are obtained from the equations ln[1 + h~i(z)] = - f ~ r
+ 2r ~_, pj
~qir
and
j=O,H
zfO)(z) - f(i])(z)
Loo
o
=
E qJp~ dthw,(t),
-
(8)
j=O,H
where e - 4tee0, e0 is the permittivity of free space, and e = 1 is the 'relative permittivity'. The bulk quantities f[~')(z) - f ~ drr"ci~(r ) are the moments of the short-ranged bulk direct correlation functions, c~j(r) = cij(r) + ~qiqj/(er). The mean electrostatic potential, experienced by a test charge at a distance z from the surface, is obtained from r
= (4r/e) ~
j=O,H
qj p3B
L dt(z-t)hwj(t).
(9)
Differentiating ~p(z) with respect to z, and using the charge neutrality constraint of Equation (8), yields at z = 0 de(z)
dz
I
z=o
_
4__~_~~
e j=O,H
qJ pB
/o=
dt t hwj (t) _
4na ~
(10)
Thus the surface charge density is proportional to the negative slope of the mean electrostatic potential at z - 0. In fact, the initial shape of the mean electrostatic potential is necessarily linear with slope - 4 r a / e .
145
The potential energy between the charged, planar wall and the oxygen and hydrogen species may be divided into two parts: a short-range contribution r due to any specific interactions between the oxygen and hydrogen species with the interface (including softbetween the charged wall and core repulsions); and the Coulombic interactions r the partially charged oxygen and hydrogen species. The total potential energy u~i(z) , may be expressed as a sum of these two contributions u~i(z) = r + r where (I)~i(z) = - q i E z and E = 4 r a / e is the electric field strength at the wall. The Coulombic interactions are specified implicitly in Equation (7) through the value of the surface potential. The properties of our charged, planar interface are determined solely by the short-range potentials r and r and the surface potential Co. For our choice of the short-range interactions, at zero surface potential, by construction the wall shows no preference for either oxygen or hydrogen. The oxygen and hydrogen atoms of the water molecules may approach the interface equally. We observe that hydrogen prefers to be slightly closer to the wall than oxygen. Thus water molecules in the contact layer are oriented predominantly with both hydrogens directed towards the interface. The effect of the inhomogeneity created by the wall extends approximately 15/~ into the bulk of the liquid, equivalent to about four layers of water molecules, after which the water attains it bulk properties, as the normalized profiles approach unity asymptotically. An interesting feature of the normalized wall-oxygen profile is that in the region between approximately 2.4 and 3.7/~ from the wall there is very low probability for finding an oxygen atom. Similar behavior is not observed in gwn(Z). Therefore it is unlikely to find another oxygen atom near that of the one in the contact layer of water, due to both the favorable electrostatic interaction between hydrogen and oxygen and the unfavorable oxygen-oxygen interaction. Thus oxygen is largely excluded from this region. Outside the contact layer some structure continues in both profiles, but it is less well defined. The decaying oscillations in the oxygen and hydrogen profiles are approximately in phase outside the region within 5/~ from the wall. A useful way to see this fact is to plot the charge profile q(z) -- --qOP~[gwg(Z) -- gwO(Z)] shown in Figure 3. For this choice of wall-water potentials, the oxygen centres of the water molecules sit in layers at approximately 1.6 /~ and 4.3 /~ from the wall, with high probability of hydrogen species located at certain distances. As the surface charge on the wall is made increasingly negative, the positive end of the water molecule- the hydrogen - is attracted to the wall, and the oxygen end is repelled, as expected. The calculations performed to date suggest that (i) the details of the short-range wall-water potentials dominate the average orientation of the contact layer of water (in combination with the strong water-water and charged wall-water interactions); and (ii) beyond the first layer the structure is insensitive to these details. The layered solvent structure extends approximately 15/~ into the bulk of the liquid, representing about 4 layers of water molecules, a distance remarkably similar to that found in earlier simulations of an ice / water interface. 3s The potential of zero charge is calculated 7 to be -32 inV. The differential capacitance can be calculated, as discussed by Booth et al. 7 Our calculations are being extended to to incorporate the 'pair' theory. 34'39 Higher order correlation functions, such as the inhomogeneous pair correlation function g~ij(R; zl, z2)
146
q(z)
s
-10 -15
2
,
6_ Z
8
,0
/A
Figure 3" For the case of a wall with surface potentials: -1000,-750, -500, -250, 0, 250, 500, 600. 750 and 1000 mV the charge profile q(z) = --qOP~[g~g(Z) -- gwo(Z)] in units of 109 C cm -3 as a function of distance z from the wall. which appear in the pair theory, should provide a more detailed description of this region, particularly in terms of additional information on orientational correlations. Ions will be added to the water to yield a fully molecular description of the 'double layer:. A c k n o w l e d g e m e n t s : This research is supported by the Australian Research Council (ARC) (Grant No. A29530010). I thank Dr. D.-M. Duh, M. Booth and A. Eaton.
References 1p. Debye and E. Hfickel, Phys. Z. 24, 305 (1923). 2G. Gouy, J. Phys. (Paris) 9, 457 (1910). aD. L. Chapman, Phil. Mag. 25, 475 (1913). 40. Stern, Z. Elektro. Chem. 30, 508 (1924). 5B. Derjaguin and L. Landau, Acta Physiochem. 14, 633 (1941). 6E. J. W. Verwey and J. T. G. Overbeek, Theory of the Stability of L yophobic Colloids (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1948). 7M. J. Booth. D.-M. Duh. and A. D. J. Havmer, J. Chem. Phys. 101. 7925 (1994). 8M. Heyrovsk~ and S. Vavricka, J. Electroanal. Chem. 353, 335 (1993). ~M. Hevrovsk~ and F. Pllcciarelli, J. Heyrovsk~ Memorial Congress on Polarography II. 65 (I 980). tow. Schmickler, D. Henderson, and O. R. Melroy, Chem. Phys. Letts. 216, 424 (1993). 11j. D. Porter and A. S. Zinn, J. "Phys. Chem. 97, 1190 (1993).
147
I2M. Vossen and F. Forstmann, Journal of Chemical Physics 101, 2379 (1994). I3A. Nyberg, D. Smith, L. Zhang, and A. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. (1994), submitted. I4A. Nyberg and A. D. J. Haymet, in Structure and Reactivity in Aqueous Solution, edited by D. Trular and C. Kramer (American Chemical Society, New York, 1994). 15F. H. Stillinger and A. Rahman, J. Chem. Phys. 68(2), 666 (1978). 16D.-M. Duh, D. N. Perera, and A. D. J. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 3736 (1995). IVT. A. Andrea, W. C. Swope, and H. C. Andersen, J. Chem. Phys. 79, 4576 (1983). ISD. E. Smith and A. D. J. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. 96, 8450 (1992). tgj. W. Halley, J. R. Rustad, and A. Rahman, J. Chem. Phys 98, 4110 (1993). soW. Blokzijl and J. B. F. N. Engberts, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 32, 154 (1993). 21D. Smith, L. Zhang, and A. Haymet, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 114, 5875 (1992). 22D. Smith and A. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. 98, 6445 (1993). 23A. Haymet, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 715, 146 (1994). 24B. Guillot, 12th International Conference on the properties of Water and Steam (1995). 25S. Cui and J. G. Harris, 12th International Conference on the properties of Water and Steam in press (1995). 26T. Ichiye and A. D. J. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. 89, 4315 (1988). 27T. Ichiye and A. D. J. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. 93, 8954 (1990). 2SD.-M. Duh and A. D. J. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. 97, 7716 (1992). 29R. O. Watts, Statistical Mechanics (The Chemical Society, London, 1973), Vol. 1. 3~ A. Thuraisingham and H. L. Friedman, J. Chem. Phys. 78, 5772 (1983). 31A. K. Soper, Chem. Phys. 107, 61 (1986). 32A. D. Trokhymchuk, M. F. Holovko, E. Spohr, and K. Heinzinger, Mol. Phys 77, 903 (1992). 33D. Henderson, F. F. Abraham, and J. A. Barker, Mol. Phys. 31, 1291 (1976).
34D. Henderson and M. Plischke, J. Phys. Chem. 92, 7177 (1988). 35j. Quintana, D. Henderson, and A. D. J. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. 98, 1486 (1993). 36j. K. Percus, J. Stat. Phys. 15, 1772 (1976). 37M. J. Booth, A. Eaton, and A. D. J. Haymet, J. Chem. Phys. 103(1), in press (1995). 38B. B. Laird and A. D. J. Haymet, Chemical Reviews 92, 1819 (1992). 39R. Kjellander and S. Mar~elja, Chem. Phys. Lett. 127, 402 (1986).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
journal o f
~OLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of MolecularLiquids,65166(1995) 149-155
Effect of Solvent, Temperature, and Pressure on Hydrogen Bonding and Reorientation of Water Molecules Masaru Nakahara and Chihiro Wakai Institute for Chemical Research, Kyoto University, Uji-city, Kyoto 611, Japan Abstract On the basis of the study of the solvent, temperature, and pressure effects, we show how the NMR rotational correlation times %21~for a heavy water molecule in neat liquid and organic solvents arc correlated with the strength of solute-solvent interactions, in particular, H bonds. At room temperature (30 "C), the correlation time is 2.1 ps in the random H-bond network in heavy water, whereas it is as small as 0.1 ps in such an apolar, hydrophobic solvent as carbon tetrachloride because of the absence of the H bonds between water molecules. Pressure distorts H bonds and accelerates the orientational motion of water molecules in neat liquid. Firm evidence is collected for the limitations of the Stokes-Einstein-Debye (SED) law in solution. I. I N T R O D U C T I O N Water is one of the most important H-bonding substances for the living. For a better understanding of reaction dynamics in aqueous systems, it becomes more important to investigate how the water dynamics are controlled by intermolecular interactions (density) as well as kinetic energies (temperature). Anomalous properties of water originate from attractive anisotropic interactions called H bonds, in sharp contrast to simple liquids whose equilibrium structure and transport properties are considered to be dominated by repulsive interactions; recall the van der Waals picture and the SED continuum model or its modifications through boundary conditions. There remains unsolved a nontrivial problem as to how the dynamics of water is controlled by the fluctuating H bonding structures. Here, we examine how the rotational correlation times for a water molecule in neat liquid and solutions are influenced by the H bonding between water molecules and between a solute water and organic solvent molecules. It is interesting to see how water responds to perturbations provided more or less selectively by the potential and momentum terms in the Hamiltonian through pressure, temperature, and solvent. In view of the anisotropic nature of H bonds, the rotational properties are of greater interest than those dominated by the radial distribution function. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has become one of the most powerful tools for studying the rotational dynamics as well as structure of water and aqueous solution under such extreme conditions as high and low temperatures and high pressures, t,2 Our newly developed multi-purpose NMR spectrometer has been successfully applied to the dynamical study of solutions under such extreme conditions as low and high temperatures, 3-5 high pressures, 6 and low concentration. 3-5,7 We have examined the role of H bonds in determining single-body water rotation dynamics in water and aqueous solution by changing or breaking H bonds through temperattm~, pressure, and organic solvents. II. E X P E R I M E N T A L 0167-7322/95/$09.50 91995ElsevierScienceB.V.All rightsreserved. SSDi 0167-7322(95) 0(}849-7
15o
To carry out high temperature experiment on water with a commercially available standard NMR probe (JEOL), we need to use a capillary in a normal glass sample tube (Wilmad) of 5-10 mm diameter. When a long glass sample tube with a normal size is used, the sample liquid contained vaporizes from a heated portion of liquid, condenses near the top of the tube, and falls down to the original liquid. The circulation prevents the efficient and homogeneous heating of the whole sample. A short capillary immersed in a temperature-transmitting medium (Demnum S-65, Daikin) can be employed at high (superheating) and low (supercooling) temperatures. In the case of dilute aqueous solution, the integrated capillary method5 is useful for avoiding the reduction of the signal intensity due to a low concentration. Glass capillaries can stand relatively high pressures; Yamada's method.l The high resolution can be attained by the capillary method at the expense of the sensitivity. We employed the high-sensitivity, high-resolution, high pressure NMR probe where a sample tube of 8 mm diameter can be introduced into a high pressure vessel made of a titanium alloy.2,6 The spin-lattice relaxation times T1 arc measured by the inversion-recovery method. By the capillary method, we have measured the spin-lattice relaxation times T 1 for heavy water (D20) over a wide range of temperature. The results are in good agreement with those given by Hindman and co-workers s,9 within the experimental uncertainties; our and their uncertainties arc +1% and +7%, r e s t i v e l y . The uncertainty of temperature is i-0.1 "C in the present work. IlL REDUCTION OF Tl TO ~2R The spin-lattice relaxation times T 1 due to the quadrupole interaction mechanism can be convened to the rotational correlation times X2R in a simple manner. In the extreme narrowing limit attained by rapid molecular rotational motions, the spin-lattice relaxation rate 1/T t for the 2I-1nucleus with the spin I--1 is expressed by T1-
2
1 +
X2R,
(1)
where e2qQ~ is the quadrupole coupling constant (QCC), ~ is the asymmetric factor for the electric field gradient, and x2a is the correlation time (the area of the time integral) of the time autocorrelation function of the second-order rotation of a bond or principal axis specified by q.6 In the application of Eq. (1) to water, assumptions are required for evaluating ~, QCC, and x2R. Now we can take QCC as 256 kHz and neglect the small ~ value according to a recent quantum mechanical and molecular dynamic study on liquid heavy water between 260 and 359 K. 10 In organic solvents, a gas-phase value of 308 kHz is used because of very weak H bonds between a water molecule and solvent molecules.4 Furthermore, we assume isotropic rotation Table 1. The rotational correlation times X2Rfor pure 1:)20 (99.8% D) T('C) -24 -22 -20 -18 -16 - 14 -12 -10 -5 0
x~8 (ps) 23.7 19.9 16.9 14.5 12.7 11.2 9.91 8.79 6.84 5.43
T('C) 1 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
X~l~(ps) 5.26 4.49 3.76 3.20 2.78 2.37 2.08 1.86 1.66 1.47
T('C) 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 100 105 110
x~8 (ps) 1.34 1.23 1.10 1.02 0.944 0.881 0.802 0.606 0.566 0.539
T('C) 115 120 125 130 135 140 145 150 155 160
x~8 (ps) 0.507 0.483 0.456 0.433 0.416 0.393 0.377 0.360 0.344 0.329
151
of a water molecule in the neat liquid and solution for the reasons described elsewhere. 6 In this case, the water rotational relaxation is described in terms of a single correlation time x2s. The value of ~2Rfor pure D20 has been determined over a wider temperature range than before, and the results are summarized in Table 1. IV. T E M P E R A T U R E EFFECT ON 't2R FOR
D20
The water molecule is characterized by the extremely small moments of inertia, the relatively small mass, and the large charge separation causing H bonds. The moments of inertia are so small that equilibrium angular velocities of water molecules distribute over a wide range according to the Maxwell-Boltzmann law. To what extent are the molecular characteristics reflected on the rotational correlation time? Is the H bonding between water molecules more impcmant than these molecular characteristics? To answer these questions, we plot the logarithmic values of x2s for pure D20 in Table 1 and those in the previous world on solutions in various organic solvents against inverse temperature in Figure 1. First, compare the X2Rvalues at 30 "C to see how the correlation time depends on the I
,,,
I
,,
I
,,,,
I
,,,
,
I m
l
41~ (CH3)2CO
j 2-1
A = ClIa
/
x C6H6 N
. f ~
. . P
cc14
1
Jo
~
,
-1
-2 I
I
2.5
3.0
i
3.5 1/T (10 -3 K -1)
Figure 1. Plots of In ~2R against 1/T for D20 in various solvents.
I
I
4.0
4.5
152
molecular environments of a water molecule. This is in the sequence, CC14 (0.10, 0.85) < C6I-I6 (0.22, 0.56) < CHC13 (0.23, 0.51) <
(2)
CH3CN (0.63, 0.32) < (CH3)2CO (0.83, 0.29) < D20 (2.1, 0.97),
where the x and y values in (x, y) denote the rotational correlation time (ps) and the solvent bulk viscosity (cP), respectively. The value of x2R (D20/D20) is much larger than that expected for the small-size molecule due to the presence of strong H (D) bonds. The very small value of 0.097 ps for D20/CC14 is attributed to the breakdown of the H bonds between water molecules due to the mixing with the hydrophobic solvent. Though the rotational correlation time for a solitary water molecule in the hydrophobic environment is small, it cannot be described by a free rotor: In fact, it has a small but non-zero activation energy barrier (--9 kJ mol-l). The rotational correlation time o f - 1 0 0 fs can be regarded as a lower limit in solution at room temperature in view of the exceptionally small moments of inertia for the water molecule. So far, we don't know whether the single-molecule orientation dynamics of water in the hydrophobic environment, which can exist locally as an active lubricating ~ i e s in membranes and protein solutions,3 is affected by quantum effect or not. The correlation time i n ~ s with increasing solute-solvent interactions but not with increasing solvent viscosity. Surprisingly, thus, the classical hydrodynamic concept is invalid. In fact, a linear relationship has been found between the correlation times and D or H chemical shifts which can be taken as a measure of the strength of the H-bonding interaction between water and solvent. In the solvent- and pressure-variable studies (see below), the SED model fails in predicting the rotational correlation time sequence. When we attempt to modify the hydrodynamic law by using a fractional power 0t and a constant A as
z2R = A(WT) cz,
(3)
the exponent becomes negative. This is a clear indication of the limitations of the continuum hydrodynamic model or its modified version which neglects the details of solute-solvent interactions in the short range. Second, note marked differences in the slope between the plots in Figure 1. The Arrhenius plots are linear for a solitary water molecule in the organic solvents, whereas the plot for neat liquid water is nonlinear as known for other dynamical properties in water. The Arrhenius activation energies at room temperature are in the sequence, CC14 (8.6) < C6H6 (9.8) _--CHCI3 (9.3) < CH3CN (10) < (CH3)2CO (11) < D20 (19), (4) where the values in the parentheses are the activation energies in kJ mo1-1 at room temperature. The sequence (2) agrees with the sequence (4), which indicates the important role of the solutesolvent interaction potential energies. V. PRESSURE EFFECT ON ~2R FOR
D20
Table 2. Pressure dependence of the rotational correlation time x2n for pure D 2 0 at different temperatm~es p(MPa) 0.1 I00 200 300
10 "C ~2R (ps) 11 (cP) 3.76 1.67 3.06 1.57 2.79 1.61 2.78 1.70
~2R (ps) 2.08 1.87 1.79 1.73
30 "C 11 (cP) 0.973 0.974 1.01 1.07
50
~2R (ps) i.34 1.24 1.19 1.17
"C 11 (cP) 0.652 0.676 0.710 0.753
153
As shown in Table 2, the rotational correlation time 't:2Rfor a heavy water in neat liquid decreases with increasing pressure in the pressure range studied at all temperatures. 6 This has been found by Jonas and co-workers. 11 At pressures lower than 100 MPa, the pressure effect on z2R and 11 (viscosity) are in parallel with a negative pressure coefficient, whereas at higher pressures, the correlation time continues to decrease despite the increase in viscosity with increasing pressure. It is to be noted that the rotational correlation time is much more sensitive to the H bonding state than the hydrodynamic property (11). The anomalous negative pressure coefficients for these dynamical properties are explained in terms of the pressure-induced bending or weakening of H bonds. The modified hydrodynamic expression, Eq. (3) accidentally appears to be valid at lower pressures with a positive value of ~ whereas it needs a negative value at higher pressures. The limitation of the continuum model is disclosed by the isothermal compression not at lower pressures but at higher pressures. The limitation of the
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
m
m
Q
I
in bulk in (0H3)200 in CHzCN in CHCI3
Z
inC6H 6
t,i
in CCI 4
& m
m
.,..,
..,.,
r~
& e,i m
m
0
=m,
m
I
0
I
1
I
2
i
3
I
4
I
5
I
6
I
7
n / T (10 .5 P/K) Figure 2. Plots of %2R for a heavy water molecule in different solvents against WT.
154
simple hydrodynamic model is unveiled by the mechanical rather than thermal response of the dynamical quantity; this is because the compression effect is associated exclusively with the intermolecular interaction potential effect in contrast to the thermal effect. Thus, pressure is unique and indispensable for testing the reliability of theoretical models or approximations. Recently, we have observed a similar inapplicability of the SED law to a much larger molecule (benzene) in water in a high pressure NMR relaxation measurement.l~ The initial compression does not decrease but increases the rotational correlation time for a benzene molecule in water at 30 "C. In other words, the viscosity exponent defined by Eq. (3) is negative at lower pressures. The exponent is turned over to a large positive at higher pressures. VL DEPENDENCE OF x2R ON TI/T
To test the reliability of the hydrodynamic variable W'I', we plots the rotational correlation times for a heavy water molecule in various solvents4 against ~/T over a wide range of temperature in Figure 2. The plots are approximately linear and expressed by ~
= ~2Ro + B(T~r),
(5)
where '~2R0 is the value in the limit of ~/T -+ 0. What is the most important is the splitting of the straight lines. The simple SED law predicts that the intercept ~2R0 is zero and that the slope value B, which is associated with the molecular volume characteristic of the solute, is independent of solvent (polarity). Neither of these are satisfied. The modified SED law, Eq. (5), is somewhat meaningful only in the sense that the slope is almost correctly in the sequence CCLs (0.022) < Cd-16 (0.11) = CHCI3 (0.12) < CH3CN (0.65) < D20 (0.66) < (CH3)2CO (1.2),
(6)
where the parenthesized values are the slopes in 10-1 ps p-I K. This corresponds to Eq. (4) except for water and acetone. Thus we can regard the slope B in Eq. (S) as an approximate measure of the strength of dynamical solute-solvent interactions. However, this modification of the SED law still causes such a problem that the intercept introduced for a fixed solute (water) is not common in the family of solvents studied. This indicates the limitations of the simple hydrodynamic scaling law despite the constancy of the slope; the constancy tells us that we are not allowed to change boundary conditions over the range of temperature studied here. The SED law has been modified into the two forms, and they are popular in the pressure- and temperature-variable studies, respectively, as mentioned in a previous paper. 6 Our recent pressure and temperature studyl3 on the rotational correlation time of a heavy water molecule in the organic solvents studied here indicates a serious shortcoming of Eq. (3). No molecular kinetic effect is taken into account in the hydrodynamic approach mentioned above, and one may expect that the kinetic collision effect plays a key role in controlling molecular rotational frictions under consideration. The Dcbye small-step diffusion model has been extended by Gordon 13 and developed later by others. 14.15 The rotational correlation times for infinitely dilute solutions of water in organic solvents have been calculated as a function of the collision frequency j3 using M- and J-diffusion models. 13 The predicted and observed values are summarized for comparison in Table 3. The extended diffusion models give considerably smaller values at atmospheric and high pressures. The pressure effect on the water rotational correlation times is not explained by the random isolated binary collision models; the predicted pressure effect is smaller, in particular in the apolar solvent. Thus, the extended diffusion theory, which originates from the isolated binary collision model in the gas phase, is inapplicable to the condensed phase because of the neglect of the intermolecular potential energy effect in the short range. For an interpretation of molecular rotations in
155
Table 3. Comparison of '~2R values calculated using extended-diffusion models (J- and Mdiffusion) with the values measured for D20 molecules in CH3CN, CHCI 3, and C6H6 at atmospheric (0.1 MPa) and high (300 MPa) pressures. II
Solvent CH3CN
CHC13
C6H6
II
p (MPa) 0.1 300
[~ (ps-1). 14.0 24.8
'172R(M) (fs) 90 133 (1.48) a
"I72R(J) (fs) 63 72 (1.13) a
"U2R(obs) (fs) 599 973 (1.62) j
0.1 300
9.2 13.1
73 88
62 63
227 324
(1.20) a
(1.02) a
(1.43) a
71 79
62 62
(1.11) a
(1.01) a
184 220 (1.20) a
0.1 90
8.7 10.7
aparenthesized values are the ratios of the ~
values to the atmospheric ones.
solutions in terms of attractive solute-solvent interactions, we hope molecular theories are developed. References
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
J. Jonas, Ed., High Pressure NMR (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1991). M. Nakahara, Rev. High Presure. Sci. Teehnol. (in Japanese) 1, 195 (1992). M. Nakahara and C. Wakai, Chem. Lett., 809 (1992). M. Nakahara and C. Wakai, J. Chem. Phys., 97, 4413 (1992). M. Nakahara, C. Wakai, and N. Matubayasi, J. Phys. Chem., 99 1377 (1995). C. Wakai and M. Nakahara, J. Chem. Phys., 100, 8347 (1994). M. Nakahara and K. Emi, J. Chem. Phys., 99, 5418 (1993). J.C. Hindman, A. J. Zielen, A. Svirmickas, and M. Wood, J. Chem. Phys., 54, 621 (1972). J.C. Hindman and A. Svirmickas, J. Phys. Chem., 77, 2487 (1973). R. Eggenberger, S. Gerber, H. Huber, D. Searles, and M. Welker, J. Chem. Phys., 97, 5898 (1992). J. Jonas, T. DeFries, and D. J. Wilbur, J. Chem. Phys., 65, 582 (1976). C. Wakai and M. Nakahara, in preparation. C. Wakai and M. Nakahara, J. Chem. Phys., (1995), in press. R.G. Gordon, J. Chem. Phys., 44, 1830 (1966). (a)R. E. D. McClung, J. Chem. Phys. 51, 3842 (1969); (b)R. E. D. McClung, ibid. 54, 3248 (1971); (c)R. E. D. McClung, ibid. 55, 3459 (1971); (d)R. E. D. McClung, ibid. 57, 5478 (1972). W.A. Steele, Adv. Chem. Phys. 34, 1 (1976).
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
journal of
MOLECULAR
LIQUIDS ELSEVIER
Journal of MolecularLiquids,65/66 (1995) 157-168
Collective V i b r a t i o n a l D y n a m i c s of Simple Liquids Michael B u c h n e r a n d T h o m a s Dorfm/iller D e p a r t m e n t of C h e m i s t r y , U n i v e r s i t y of Bielefeld, 33615 Bielefeld, G e r m a n y Abstract
Instantaneous normal mode investigations of molecular liquids are presented for coupled translational and rotational coordinates as well as for vibrational coordinates. Illustrative examples are chosen so as to demonstrate the influence of structural and dynamical properties on the normal mode behaviour. It is demonstrated that among the structural properties characterising a liquid system the normal mode spectrum is uniquely well suited for being related to the dynamics. The theoretical derivation of the normal mode spectrum for molecular systems starting from configurational distributions is shown to be an ill-behaving problem. Normal mode spectral shapes for strongly infrared active vibrational modes are presented and correlated with transition dipole moment and liquid structure. Finally a perturbational procedure is proposed to quantify the motional narrowing effect of molecular dynamics on inhomogeneously broadened vibrational bands. I.
Introduction
Normal mode approaches enjoy growing interest for describing dynamical properties of liquids. 1'2 Many of their applications are found in numerical experiments where the eigenequation V(R) U(R)
=
U(R) A(R)
(1)
involving the matrix of second derivatives of potential energy V(R) is set up and solved for the set of eigenvalues As and eigenvectors IJ~. V(R) depends on the system configuration R and implicitly on time. Consequently in liquids the modes are momentary variables. These instantaneous normal modes show a number of useful properties. 9They provide a correct short-time description of dynamical processes. They therefore contrast to expansions around inherent structures 3 which are the configurations corresponding to local potential minima obtained by quenching instantaneous system configurations. The results of these two approaches show marked differences as has been demonstrated for the case of low frequency Raman spectra of water. 4's 0167-7322/95/$09.50
91995ElsevierScienceB.V.All fightsreserved.
SSDI 0167-7322(95)00905-!
158
9They can be used to model the long-time behaviour of a dynamical system. This can be done either by approximating the relevant correlation functions using only the stable portion of the frequency spectrum 6'7 or by using the unstable lobe of the spectrum for drawing (empirical) relationships to the diffusion constant, s-l~ 9They are collective coordinates and, therefore, provide a way to describe phenomena which may show high collectivity like solvation 11 or vibrational relaxation 12 processes. Collective velocity correlation functions, e.g., have been discussed as indicators for the onset of glass formation. 13'14 9For some simple systems normal mode spectra have been calculated theoretically by exploiting the isomorphism to a random walk 15 or by applying liquid state theory. 16 They may be regarded as a stepping stone between (structural) theory and experiment. 9Techniques of crystallography can be used to analyse and characterise the modes in terms of their wave vector lr and their spatial extension. 9In a wider perspective analogies have been pointed out with respect to the calculation of quantum time correlation functions, is In this contribution the concept of instantaneous normal modes is applied to three molecular liquid systems, carbon monoxide at 80 K and carbon disulphide at ambient temperature and two different densities. The systems were chosen in this way because pairs of them show similarities either in structural or in dynamical properties. The systems and their simulation are described in the following section. Subsequently two different types of molecular coordinates are used as input to normal mode calculations, external, i.e. translational and rotational coordinates, and internal, i.e. vibrational coordinates of strongly infrared active modes, respectively. The normal mode spectra are related quantitatively to molecular properties and to those of liquid structure and dynamics. Finally a synthesis of both calculations is attempted on qualitative grounds aiming at the treatment of vibrational dephasing effects. II.
S i m u l a t i o n a n d c h a r a c t e r i s a t i o n of t h e s y s t e m s i n v e s t i g a t e d
The configurations needed as input for the normal mode calculations were obtained by molecular dynamics simulation. For the purpose of the present investigation the simulation of rigid molecular models would be sufficient because only translational and rotational coordinates enter the normal mode analysis and the molecular vibrations are treated perturbationally within a frozen field approach. Nevertheless fully flexible molecules were assumed and a specialised algorithm for handling their high frequency motion was employed 1~ which allows time steps of 2 and 1 fs for CO and CS2, respectively. Comparing the results of vibrational normal mode analysis with the spectra obtained by molecular dynamics simulation allows assessing the effects of motional narrowing and anharmonicity. The anharmonic intramolecular 20 ' 21 as well as the intermolecular potentials for both CO and CS2 were taken from literature. The intermolecular interactions of CO are modelled by seven sites interacting isotropically. 22 Among the intermolecular potentials available for CS2 one including electrostatic interactions via partial chargc