SURFACE ENGINEERING FOR CORROSION AND WEAR RESISTANCE
Edited by J.R. Davis Davis & Associates
I O M
heatio M iaclse I...
731 downloads
2246 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
SURFACE ENGINEERING FOR CORROSION AND WEAR RESISTANCE
Edited by J.R. Davis Davis & Associates
I O M
heatio M iaclse InfoTrm nate Sro i ty Materials Park, OH 44073-0002 www. asminternational. org
Communications
IOM Communications is a wholly owned subsidiary of the Institute of Materials IOM Book No. B751
Copyright © 2001 by ASM International® All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the written permission of the copyright owner. First printing, March 2001
Great care is taken in the compilation and production of this Volume, but it should be made clear that NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, ARE GIVEN IN CONNECTION WITH THIS PUBLICATION. Although this information is believed to be accurate by ASM, ASM cannot guarantee that favorable results will be obtained from the use of this publication alone. This publication is intended for use by persons having technical skill, at their sole discretion and risk. Since the conditions of product or material use are outside of ASM's control, ASM assumes no liability or obligation in connection with any use of this information. No claim of any kind, whether as to products or information in this publication, and whether or not based on negligence, shall be greater in amount than the purchase price of this product or publication in respect of which damages are claimed. THE REMEDY HEREBY PROVIDED SHALL BE THE EXCLUSIVE AND SOLE REMEDY OF BUYER, AND IN NO EVENT SHALL EITHER PARTY BE LIABLE FOR SPECIAL, INDIRECT OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES WHETHER OR NOT CAUSED BY OR RESULTING FROM THE NEGLIGENCE OF SUCH PARTY. As with any material, evaluation of the material under end-use conditions prior to specification is essential. Therefore, specific testing under actual conditions is recommended. Nothing contained in this book shall be construed as a grant of any right of manufacture, sale, use, or reproduction, in connection with any method, process, apparatus, product, composition, or system, whether or not covered by letters patent, copyright, or trademark, and nothing contained in this book shall be construed as a defense against any alleged infringement of letters patent, copyright, or trademark, or as a defense against liability for such infringement. Comments, criticisms, and suggestions are invited, and should be forwarded to ASM International. ASM International staff who worked on this project include Scott Henry, Assistant Director of Reference Publications; Bonnie Sanders, Manager of Production; Nancy Hrivnak, Copy Editor; and Kathy Dragolich, Production Supervisor. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Surface engineering for corrosion and wear resistance / edited by J.R. Davis p. cm. Includes index. 1. Corrosion and anti-corrosives. 2. Mechanical wear. 3. Surfaces (Technology) I. Davis, J.R. (Joseph R.) TA462.S789 2001 620.1'1233—dc21 00-048537 ISBN: 0-87170-700-4 ASM International® Materials Park, OH 44073-0002 www. asminternational. org Printed in the United States of America
P r e f a c e
Corrosion, wear, or the combined effects of these destructive failure modes cost industrial economies hundreds of billions of dollars each year. One of the more effective means of mitigating damage due to corrosion and wear is to treat, or "engineer," the surface so that it can perform functions that are distinct from those functions required from the bulk of the material. For example, a gear must be tough and fatigue resistant yet have a surface that resists wear. For applications requiring only a moderate degree of impact strength, fatigue resistance, and wear resistance, a higher carbon through-hardening steel may be sufficient. For more severe conditions, however, a surface hardened steel may have to be used. What are the options? Should the gear be flame or induction hardened, carburized or nitrided, or would high-energy processes such as laser- or electron-beam hardening be more appropriate? As a second example, consider the use of steels for various outdoor structural applications. Steel is popular because it is inexpensive, strong, and easily fabricated. Unfortunately steel is highly susceptible to severe corrosion in many environments and must be coated to achieve a satisfactory service life. Once again there are a variety of options. Should the component be painted, hot dip galvanized or aluminized, electroplated, thermally sprayed, or clad with a more corrosion resistant material? For large steel components, such as bridge members, size, weight, and handling problems may limit the type of surface treatment considered. Finally, take into consideration parts that require wearresistant, thin-film coatings. Can more conventional chromium or hard nickel electroplating be used, or will harder coatings deposited by vapor deposition techniques or ion implantation be required? Will processing time or temperature be a factor in coating selection? From the above discussion, it is apparent that engineers are faced with a bewildering number of choices when selecting the appropriate surface engineering treatment for a specific corrosion and/or wear application. But where does one start? Where can a design engineer find practical guidelines to aid in the selection process? The answers to these questions
lie within Surface Engineering for Corrosion and Wear Resistance. In addition to devoting an entire chapter to process comparisons (see Chapter 7), this book contains dozens of useful tables and figures that compare surface treatment thickness and hardness ranges; abrasion and corrosion resistance; processing time, temperature, and pressure; costs; distortion tendencies; and other surface treatment characteristics that must be considered when choosing the right coating for the job. The starting point for this publication was an excellent overview published by the Institute of Materials (IOM) entitled "Surface Engineering to Combat Wear and Corrosion: A Design Guide," which was written by Keith Stevens (A.T. Poeton Ltd.). Assisting IOM in the project was AEA Technology pic. and their National Centre of Tribology located in Risley, United Kingdom. The IOM booklet presents a concise methodology for understanding corrosion and wear problems and the many factors that must be considered before selecting a surface treatment. Material from the IOM design guide can be found primarily in Chapter 7, "Process Comparisons," and Chapter 8, "Practical Design Guidelines for Surface Engineering." Special thanks are due to Stephen Harmer, the editor of the IOM "Design Guide" series, who also reviewed several key chapters, and Bill Jackson, Head of Publishing for IOM, who worked out the copublishing agreement with Scott Henry, Assistant Director of Reference Publications for ASM International. Other key contributions for this book originated from Volumes 4, Heat Treating, 5, Surface Engineering, 13, Corrosion, 18, Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology, and 20, Materials Selection and Design, of the ASM Handbook series and from the Metals Handbook Desk Edition, Second Edition. Of particular note are articles authored by Arnold R. Marder (Lehigh University) and Eric W. Brooman (Concurrent Technologies Corporation) originally published in Volume 20 of the ASM Handbook. These are acknowledged at the conclusions of Chapters 4, 5, 6, and 8. Tabular data comparing various surface engineering processes were also adapted from the ASM Materials Engineering Institute course "Surface Engineering Processes for Wear and Corrosion" developed by Ralph B. Alexander (R.B. Alexander & Associates). Joseph R. Davis Davis & Associates Chagrin Falls, Ohio
Contents
Preface .......................................................................................................
vii
1. Introduction to Surface Engineering for Corrosion and Wear Resistance ...........................................................................................
1
Surface Engineering to Combat Corrosion and Wear ........................................
3
2. Principles of Corrosion ......................................................................
11
Electrochemical Corrosion Basics .......................................................................
11
Corrosive Conditions ...........................................................................................
13
Forms of Corrosion ..............................................................................................
15
Uniform Corrosion ..................................................................................
15
Galvanic Corrosion .................................................................................
16
Pitting .....................................................................................................
19
Crevice Corrosion ..................................................................................
21
Erosion-corrosion ...................................................................................
22
Cavitation ...............................................................................................
23
Fretting Corrosion ..................................................................................
24
Intergranular Corrosion ..........................................................................
25
Exfoliation ..............................................................................................
26
Dealloying Corrosion ..............................................................................
26
Stress-corrosion Cracking ......................................................................
27
Corrosion Fatigue ...................................................................................
29
Hydrogen Damage .................................................................................
30
Coatings and Corrosion Prevention ....................................................................
31
Corrosion Testing .................................................................................................
35
Field Tests .............................................................................................
36
Simulated Service Tests .........................................................................
36
Salt Spray Tests .....................................................................................
38
Humidity Cabinet Tests ..........................................................................
39
Electrochemical Tests ............................................................................
39
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
iii
iv
Contents
3. Principles of Friction and Wear .........................................................
43
Friction .................................................................................................................
43
Wear .....................................................................................................................
54
Classification of Wear .............................................................................
54
Abrasive Wear ........................................................................................
56
Solid Particle Erosion .............................................................................
61
Liquid Erosion ........................................................................................
68
Slurry Erosion .........................................................................................
69
Adhesive Wear .......................................................................................
72
Galling ....................................................................................................
75
Fretting ...................................................................................................
76
Rolling-contact Wear ..............................................................................
77
Lubrication ............................................................................................................
77
Modes of Lubrication ..............................................................................
78
Lubricants ..............................................................................................
78
Wear Testing ........................................................................................................
81
Test Methods .........................................................................................
81
4. Surface Engineering to Change the Surface Metallurgy .................
87
Selective Surface Hardening ...............................................................................
87
Flame Hardening ....................................................................................
87
Induction Hardening ...............................................................................
88
High-energy Beam Hardening ................................................................
90
Laser Melting .......................................................................................................
91
Shot Peening .......................................................................................................
93
5. Surface Engineering to Change the Surface Chemistry ..................
95
Phosphate Chemical Conversion Coatings ........................................................
95
Types of Phosphate Coatings ................................................................
96
Applications ............................................................................................
98
Chromate Chemical Conversion Coatings .......................................................... 100 Aluminum Anodizing ............................................................................................ 102 Chromic Anodizing ................................................................................. 102 Sulfuric Anodizing .................................................................................. 103 Hardcoat Anodizing ................................................................................ 104 This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
Contents
v
Sealing of Anodized Coatings ................................................................ 105 Corrosion Resistance of Anodized Aluminum ......................................... 106 Oxidation Treatments .......................................................................................... 108 Diffusion Heat Treatment Coatings ..................................................................... 110 Carburizing ............................................................................................. 112 Nitriding .................................................................................................. 113 Carbonitriding and Ferritic Nitrocarburizing ............................................ 115 Pack-cementation Diffusion Coatings ................................................................. 116 Ion Implantation ................................................................................................... 120 Laser Alloying ...................................................................................................... 122
6. Surface Engineering to Add a Surface Layer or Coating ................ 125 Organic Coatings ................................................................................................. 127 Paints ..................................................................................................... 128 Ceramic Coatings and Linings ............................................................................. 132 Glass Linings .......................................................................................... 132 Porcelain Enamels ................................................................................. 133 Concrete and Cementatious Coatings and Linings ................................. 134 High-performance Ceramic Coatings and Linings .................................. 136 Hot Dip Coatings .................................................................................................. 138 Batch and Continuous Processing .......................................................... 138 Coating Microstructure ........................................................................... 138 Galvanized Coatings .............................................................................. 139 Galvanneal Coatings .............................................................................. 142 Zinc-aluminum Coatings ......................................................................... 142 Aluminum Coatings ................................................................................ 143 Terne Coatings ....................................................................................... 144 Electrochemical Deposition ................................................................................. 145 Aqueous Solution Electroplating ............................................................. 145 Continuous Electrodeposition ................................................................. 147 Fused-salt Electroplating ........................................................................ 148 Precious Metal Plating ............................................................................ 149 Electroless Plating .................................................................................. 150 Composite Coatings ............................................................................... 151 Weld-overlay Coatings ......................................................................................... 153 This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
vi
Contents Thermal Spray Coatings ...................................................................................... 160 Cladding ............................................................................................................... 166 Corrosion Control through Cladding ....................................................... 166 Chemical Vapor Deposition ................................................................................. 168 Physical Vapor Deposition Processes ................................................................ 172 Thermoreactive Deposition/Diffusion Process .................................................... 176
7. Process Comparisons ........................................................................ 183 Process Availability .............................................................................................. 184 Corrosion Resistance .......................................................................................... 185 Wear Resistance .................................................................................................. 186 Cost of Surface Treatments ................................................................................. 190 Distortion or Size Change Tendencies ................................................................ 191 Coating Thickness Attainable .............................................................................. 192
8. Practical Design Guidelines for Surface Engineering ..................... 195 Surface-engineering Solutions for Specific Problems ......................................... 196 Structural Parts in Corrosive Environments ........................................................ 197 Base Material ......................................................................................... 197 Neutral Environments ............................................................................. 197 Specific Corrosive Environments ............................................................ 197 Parts in Static Contact with Vibration (Fretting) .................................................. 199 Base Material ......................................................................................... 199 Contact Conditions ................................................................................. 199 Fretting Fatigue ...................................................................................... 200 Oxidative Wear ....................................................................................... 200 Parts in Static Contact with a Product ................................................................. 200 Base Material ......................................................................................... 200 Specific Applications .............................................................................. 201 Parts in Sliding or Rolling Contact with Another Surface .................................... 201 Base Material ......................................................................................... 202 General Contact Conditions ................................................................... 202 Surface-engineering Options .................................................................. 203 Specific Contact Conditions .................................................................... 205
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
Contents
vii
Parts in Low-load Sliding Contact with an Abrasive Product .............................. 206 Base Material ......................................................................................... 206 Specific Applications .............................................................................. 207 Parts in High-load Sliding or Erosion with an Abrasive Product ......................... 208 Base Material ......................................................................................... 208 Surface-engineering Options .................................................................. 208 Parts in Contact with Another Engineering Component in the Presence of an Abrasive and Corrosion Product or Environment .................................... 208 Base Material ......................................................................................... 209 Surface-engineering Options .................................................................. 209 Preprocessing and Postprocessing Heat Treatment .......................................... 209 Coating Thickness, Case Depth, and Component Distortion Considerations ............................................................................................... 210 Surface Roughness and Finishing ...................................................................... 213 General Design Principles Related to Surface Engineering ............................... 213 Design Guidelines for Surface Preparation Processes ....................................... 218 Design Guidelines for Organic Coating Processes ............................................. 219 Design Guidelines for Inorganic Coating Processes ........................................... 222 Other Important Considerations for the Design Engineer ................................... 226
Glossary .................................................................................................... 231 Index .......................................................................................................... 257
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
CHAPTER
I
I n t r o d u c t i o n
t o
E n g i n e e r i n g C o r r o s i o n
a n d
S u r f a c e f o r W
e
a
r
R e s i s t a n c e
SURFACE ENGINEERING is a multidisciplinary activity intended to tailor the properties of the surfaces of engineering components so that their function and serviceability can be improved. The ASM Handbook defines surface engineering as "treatment of the surface and near-surface regions of a material to allow the surface to perform functions that are distinct from those functions demanded from the bulk of the material" (Ref 1). The desired properties or characteristics of surface-engineered components include: Improved corrosion resistance through barrier or sacrificial protection Improved oxidation and/or sulfidation resistance Improved wear resistance Reduced frictional energy losses Improved mechanical properties, for example, enhanced fatigue or toughness Improved electronic or electrical properties Improved thermal insulation Improved aesthetic appearance As indicated in Table 1, these properties can be enhanced metallurgically, mechanically, chemically, or by adding a coating. The bulk of the material or substrate cannot be considered totally independent of the surface treatment. Most surface processes are not limited to the immediate region of the surface, but can involve the substrate by
Table 1
Surface engineering options and property benefits
Surface treatment/coating type
Primary property benefits
Changing the surface metallurgy Localized surface hardening (flame, induction, laser, and electron-beam hardening) Laser melting Shot peening
Improved wear resistance through the development of a hard martensitic surface Improved wear resistance through grain refinement and the formation of fine dispersions of precipitates Improved fatigue strength due to compressive stresses induced on the exposed surface, also relieves tensile stresses that contribute to stress-corrosion cracking
Changing the surface chemistry Phosphate chemical conversion coatings Chromate chemical conversion coatings Black oxide chemical conversion coatings Anodizing (electrochemical conversion coating)
Steam treating Carburizing Nitriding Carbonitriding Ferritic nitrocarburizing Diffusion (pack cementation) chromizing Diffusion (pack cementation) aluminizing Diffusion (pack cementation) siliconizing Boronizing (bonding) Ion implantation Laser alloying
Used primarily on steels for enhanced corrosion resistance, increased plating or paint adhesion, and for lubricity (e.g., to increase the formability of sheet metals) Enhanced bare or painted corrosion resistance, improved adhesion of paint or other organic finishes, and provides the metallic surface with a decorative finish Used for decorative applications, e.g., the "bluing" on steel gun barrels Used primarily for aluminum for increased corrosion resistance, improved decorative appearance, increased abrasion resistance (hard anodizing), improved paint adhesion, and improved adhesive bonding (higher bond strength and durability) Used on ferrous powder metallurgy parts to increase wear resistance and transverse rupture strength Used primarily for steels for increased resistance to wear, bending fatigue, and rolling-contact fatigue Used primarily for steels for improved wear resistance, increased fatigue resistance, and improved corrosion resistance (except stainless steels) Used primarily for steels for improved wear resistance Improved antiscuffing characteristics of ferrous alloys Improved molten-salt hot corrosion Improved oxidation resistance, sulfidation resistance, and carburization resistance Improved oxidation resistance Improved wear resistance, oxidative wear, and surface fatigue Improved friction and wear resistance for a variety of substrates Improved wear resistance
Adding a surface layer or coating Organic coatings (paints and polymeric or elastomeric coatings and linings) Ceramic coatings (glass linings, cement linings, and porcelain enamels) Slip/sinter ceramic coatings Hot-dip galvanizing (zinc coatings) Hot-dip aluminizing Hot-dip lead-tin alloy-coatings (terne coatings) Tin plate (continuous electrodeposition) Zinc-nickel alloy plate (continuous electrodeposition) Electroplating
Electroless plating Mechanical plating Weld overlays Thermal spraying
Cladding (roll bonding, explosive bonding, hot isostatic pressing, etc.) Laser cladding Carbide (salt bath) diffusion Chemical vapor deposition (CVD) Physical vapor deposition (PVD)
Improved corrosion resistance, wear resistance, and aesthetic appearance Improved corrosion resistance Improved wear resistance and heat resistance Improved corrosion resistance via sacrificial protection of steel substrate Improved corrosion and oxidation resistance of steel substrate Improved corrosion resistance of steel substrate Improved corrosion resistance of steel substrate Improved corrosion resistance of steel substrate Depending on the metal or metals being electrodeposited, improved corrosion resistance (e.g., nickel-chromium multilayer coatings, and cadmium and zinc sacrificial coatings), wear resistance (e.g., hard chromium coatings), electrical properties (e.g., copper and silver), and aesthetic appearance (e.g., bright nickel or decorative chromium plating) Improved corrosion resistance (nickel-phosphorus) and wear resistance (nickel-phosphorus and nickel-boron) Improved corrosion resistance Improved wear resistance (hardfacing alloys) and corrosion resistance (stainless steel or nickel-base overlays) and dimensional restoration (buildup alloys) Primarily used for improved wear resistance (many coating systems including ceramics and cermets), but also used for improved corrosion resistance (aluminum, zinc, and their alloys) and oxidation resistance (e.g., MCrAlY), thermal barrier protection (partially stabilized zirconia), electrically conductive coatings (e.g., copper and silver), and dimensional restoration Improved corrosion resistance Improved wear resistance Used primarily for steels for improved wear resistance in tooling applications Improved wear (e.g., tools and dies), erosion, and corrosion resistance; also used for epitaxial growth of semiconductors Improved wear (e.g., tools and dies) and corrosion resistance, improved optical and electronic properties, and decorative applications
exposure to either a thermal cycle or a mechanical stress. For example, diffusion heat treatment coatings (e.g., carburizing/nitriding) often have high-temperature thermal cycles that may subject the substrate to temperatures that cause phase transformations and thus property changes, or shot-peening treatments that deliberately strain the substrate surface to induce improved fatigue properties. It is the purpose of this book, and in particular Chapters 4 to 6, to review information on surface treatments that improve service performance so that metallurgists, chemists, mechanical engineers, and design engineers may consider surface-engineered components as an alternative to more costly materials. Surface Engineering to C o m b a t Corrosion and W e a r The Economic Effects of Corrosion and Wear. The progressive deterioration, due to corrosion and wear, of metallic surfaces in use in major industrial plants ultimately leads to loss of plant efficiency and at worst a shutdown. Corrosion and wear damage to materials, both directly and indirectly, costs the United States hundreds of billions of dollars annually. For example, corrosion of metals costs the U.S. economy almost $300 billion per year at current prices. This amounts to about 4.2% of the gross national product. However, about 40% of the total cost could be avoided by proper corrosion prevention methods. Table 2 provides a breakdown of the cost of metallic corrosion in the United States. Similar studies on wear failures have shown that the wear of materials costs the U.S. economy about $20 billion per year (in 1978 dollars) compared to about $80 billion annually (see Table 2) for corrosion during the same period. Table 3 illustrates the extent of wear failures by various operations within specific industrial segments. Highway vehicles alone use annually 14,600 X 1012 Btu/ton of energy represented in lost weight of steel and 18.6% of this energy could be saved through effective wear-control measures. Table 2 Cost of metallic corrosion in the United States Billions of U.S. dollars Industry
All industries Total Avoidable Motor vehicles Total Avoidable Aircraft Total Avoidable Other industries Total Avoidable Source: Ref 2
1975
1995
82.0 33.0
296.0 104.0
31.4 23.1
94.0 65.0
3.0 0.6
13.0 3.0
47.6 9.3
189.0 36.0
Table 3 Industrial operations with significant annual wear economic consequences Industry
Utilities (28% total U.S. consumption)
Transportation (26% total U.S. consumption)
Mining
Agriculture
Primary metals
Operation
Loss mass (a), 10 12 Btu
Seate Accessories Bearings Reliability Total Brakes Valve trains Piston ring assemblies Transmission Bearings Gears Total Ore processing Surface mining Shaft mining Drilling Total Tillage Planting Total Hot rolling Cold rolling Total
185 120 55 145 505 (b) (b) (b) (b) (b) (b) (b) 22.80 13.26 10.70 5.58 52.34 16.85 2.47 19.32 14.30 0.14 14.44
(a) Assumes 19.2 X 106 Btu per ton of energy represented in lost weight of steel. (b) Lost mass not estimated. Source: Ref 3
Corrosive Wear. Complicating matters is the fact that the combined effects of wear and corrosion can result in total material losses that are much greater than the additive effects of each process taken alone, which indicates a synergism between the two processes. Although corrosion can often occur in the absence of mechanical wear, the opposite is rarely true. Corrosion accompanies the wear process to some extent in all environments, except in vacuum and inert atmospheres. Corrosion and wear often combine to cause aggressive damage in a number of industries, such as mining, mineral processing, chemical processing, pulp and paper production, and energy production. Corrosion and wear processes involve many mechanisms, the combined actions of which lead to the mutual reinforcement of their effectiveness. As listed in Table 4, 17 synergistic relationships among abrasion, impact, and corrosion that could significantly increase material degradation in wet and aqueous environments have been identified. The combined effects of corrosion and wear can also lead to galvanic corrosion in some applications, such as crushing and grinding (comminution) of mineral ores. Wear debris and corrosion products that are formed during comminution affect product quality and can adversely affect subsequent benefication by altering the chemical and electrochemical properties of the mineral system (Ref 5-8). Electrochemical interactions between minerals and grinding media can occur, causing galvanic coupling that leads to increased corrosion wear. More detailed information on galvanic corrosion can be found in Chapter 2.
Methods to Control Corrosion. Owing to its many favorable characteristics, steel is well suited and widely used for a broad range of engineering applications and is referenced here to demonstrate the various corrosion-control steps that can be considered. Steel has a variety of excellent mechanical properties, such as strength, toughness, ductility, and dent resistance. Steel also offers good manufacturability, including formability, weldability, and paintability. Other positive factors include its availability, ferromagnetic properties, recyclability, and cost. Because steel is susceptible to corrosion in the presence of moisture, and to oxidation at elevated temperatures, successful use of these favorable characteristics generally requires some form of protection. Methods of corrosion protection employed to protect steel include: Altering the metal by alloying, that is, using a more highly alloyed and expensive stainless steel rather than a plain carbon or low-alloy steel Changing the environment by desiccation or the use of inhibitors Controlling the electrochemical potential by the application of cathodic or anodic currents, that is, cathodic and anodic protection Applying organic, metallic, or inorganic (glasses and ceramics) coatings Application of corrosion-resistant coatings is one of the most widely used means of protecting steel. As shown in Table 1, there are a wide variety of coatings to choose from, and proper selection is based on the component size and accessibility, the corrosive environment, the anticipated
Table 4 Synergistic relationships between wear and corrosion mechanisms Abrasion Removes protective oxidized metal and polarized coatings to expose unoxidized metal, in addition to removing metal particles. Forms microscopic grooves and dents for concentration cell corrosion. Increases microscopic surface area exposed to corrosion. Removes strain-hardened surface layers. Cracks brittle metal constituents forming sites for impact hydraulic splitting. Plastic deformation by high-stress metal-mineral contact causes strain hardening and susceptibility to chemical attack. Corrosion Produces pits that induce microcracking. Microcracks at pits invite hydraulic splitting during impact. Roughens surface, reducing energy needed to abrade away metal. May produce hydrogen with subsequent absorption and cracking in steel. Selectively attacks grain boundaries and less noble phases of multiphase microstructures, weakening adjacent metal. Impact Plastic deformation makes some constituents more susceptible to corrosion. Cracks brittle constituents, tears apart ductile constituents to form sites for crevice corrosion, hydraulic splitting. Supplies kinetic energy to drive abrasion mechanism. Pressurizes mill water to cause splitting, cavitation, and jet erosion of metal and protective oxidized material. Pressurizes mill water and gases to produce unknown temperatures, phase changes, and decomposition or reaction products from ore and water constituents. Heats ball metal, ore, fluids to increase corrosive effects. Source: Ref 4
Weld overlay Friction surfacing Thermal spraying Carburizing Carbonitriding Nitrocarburizing Nitriding Mechanical working Electrochemical plate + diffusion Transformation hardening Surface alloying—lasers Hot dipping (galvanizing and aluminum) Mechanical plating Electroless plating Electrolytic plating Chemical vapor deposition Physical vapor deposition Resin or laquer"bonding Ion implantation Thickness, mm Fig. 1 Approximate thickness of various surface engineering treatments
temperatures, component distortion, the coating thickness attainable (Fig. 1), and costs. Many of these selection criteria are addressed in Chapters 6 to 8 in this book. Painting is probably the most widely used engineering coating used to protect steel from corrosion. There are a wide variety of coating formulations that have been developed for outdoor exposure, marine atmospheres, water immersion, chemical fumes, extreme sunlight, high humidity, and moderately high temperatures (less than about 200 0 C, or 400 0 F). The most widely used corrosion-resistant metallic coatings are hotdipped zinc, zinc-aluminum, and aluminum coatings. These coatings exhibit excellent resistance to atmospheric corrosion and are widely used in the construction, automobile, utility, and appliance industries. Other important coating processes for steels include electroplating, electroless plating, thermal spraying, pack cementation aluminizing (for high-temperature oxidation resistance), and cladding (including weld cladding and roll-bonded claddings). Applications and corrosion performance of these coatings are described in Chapter 6 in this book. Methods to Control Wear. As is described in Chapter 3 in this book, there are many types of wear, but there are only four main types of wear systems (tribosystems) that produce wear and six basic wear control steps (Ref 9). The four basic tribosystems are:
Relatively smooth solids sliding on other smooth solids Hard, sharp substances sliding on softer surfaces Fatigue of surfaces by repeated stressing (usually compressive) Fluids with or without suspended solids in motion with respect to a solid surface As shown in Fig. 2, the wear that occurs in these tribosystems can be addressed by coatings or by modifications to the substrate metallurgy or chemistry. The six traditional techniques applied to materials to deal with wear produced in the preceding tribosystems include: Separate conforming surfaces with a lubricating film (see Chapter 3 in this book). Make the wearing surface hard through the use of hardfacing, diffusion heat treatments, hard chromium plating, or more recently developed vapor deposition techniques or high-energy processes (e.g., ion implantation). Make the wearing surface resistant to fracture. Many wear processes involve fracture of material from a surface; thus toughness and fracture resistance play a significant role in wear-resistant surfaces. The use of very hard materials such as ceramics, cemented carbides, and hard chromium can lead to fracture problems that nullify the benefits of the hard surface. Make the eroding surface resistant to corrosion. Examples include the use of cobalt-base hardfacing alloys to resist liquid erosion, cavitation, and slurry erosion; aluminum bronze hardfacing alloys to prevent cavitation damage on marine propellers or to repair props that have Wear-causing effects Coatings to reduce wear Polymers/elastomers Electrochemical (plating, etc.) Chemical (CVD, electroless plating) Thermal spraying Fusion welding Thin films (PVD, sputtering, ion plating) Wear tiles Cladding (cast, explosion, hot rolling) Lubricants
Substrate treatments to reduce wear Through hardening Surface hardening (flame, induction, EB, laser) Diffusion of a hardening species (carburizing, nitriding, etc.) Laser/EB alloying Ion implantation Work hardening
Tribosystem
Surface wear
FlC. 2 Surface engineering processes used to prevent wear. CVD, chemical vapor deposition; PVD, " physical vapor deposition; EB, electron beam
suffered cavitation damage; nickel-base hardfacing alloys to resist chemical attack; and epoxy-filled rebuilding cements used to resist slurry erosion in pumps. Choose material couples that are resistant to interaction in sliding (metal-to-metal wear resistance). Hardfacing alloys such as cobaltbase and nickel-chromium-boron alloys have been used for many years for applications involving metal-to-metal wear. Other surfaceengineering options include through-hardened tool steels, diffusion (case)-hardened surfaces, selective surface-hardened alloy steels, and some platings. Make the wearing surface fatigue resistant. Rolling-element bearings, gears, cams, and similar power-transmission devices often wear by a mechanism of surface fatigue. Repeated point or line contact stresses can lead to subsurface cracks that eventually grow to produce surface pits and eventual failure of the device. Prevention is possible through the use of through-hardened steels, heavy casehardened steels, and flame-, induction-, electron beam-, or laserhardened steels. More details on these surface-engineering techniques can be found in Chapters 5 through 8 in this book. Material/Process Selection (Ref 10). Faced with the wide range of possibilities indicated in Table 1 and the discussions on "Methods to Control Corrosion" and "Methods to Control Wear," selection of surface engiPredict working environment from consideration of design Proceed with one-piece construction (see note below)
Yes
Identify material requirements for structure and surface Consider one-piece construction
Analyze service failures to assist selection of better materials No
Select substrate material to suit strength, heat, and corrosion needs
Note: One-piece construction is often least Select surfacing material expensive for small parts as some surfacing alloys to suit requirements are available as castings machined to finished size or as powder metallurgical parts. Select from surfacing processes suitable for chosen material and job, Reconsider (must satisfy needs for coating density, materials thickness, dilution, etc.) Decide if chosen process suits substrate material Yes None and design (adhesion, Reconsider process HAZ, access, distortion, and/or material etc.) No Decide manufacturing Yes details, procedures, Identify quality assurance Finalize choice of health and safety and control needs materials and process requirements, etc. Fig, 3 Checklist for surface engineering material/process selection. HAZ, heat-affected zone
neering material and process may seem difficult, but it is normally straightforward. Often there are constraints placed on the choice because of availability (e.g., laser melting and/or alloying are not widely used, and these processes can only be obtained by a special arrangement with laser job shops). In many cases there is a precedent, but when considering a new problem it helps to follow a checklist of the type shown in Fig. 3. The sequence of decisions to be made covers several fundamental points. The first is the need to be clear about service conditions, based on experience or plant data. This is the key to material selection. The second decision is the choice of application process for the material. This involves the question of compatibility with the coating material; that is, not all materials can be applied by all processes. A further question of compatibility arises between both material and process with the substrate, for example, whether distortion from high-temperature processes be tolerated. All these issues are covered in subsequent chapters in this book (see, in particular, Chapters 7 and 8).
References 1. CM. Cotell and J.A. Sprague, Preface, Surface Engineering, VoI 5, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1994, p v 2. Economic Effects of Metallic Corrosion in the United States, Battelle Columbus Laboratories and the National Institute of Standards and Technology, 1978 and Battelle updates in 1995 3. "Tribological Sinks in Six Major Industries," Report Number PNL5535, Sept 1985, Pacific Northwest Laboratory, Richland, WA, operated for the U.S. Department of Energy by Battelle Memorial Institute (NTIS No. DE86000841) 4. DJ. Dunn. Metal Removal Mechanisms Comprising Wear in Mineral Processing, Wear of Materials, K.C. Ludema, Ed., American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 1985, p 501-508 5. R.L. Pozzo and I. Iwasaki, Pyrite-Pyrrhotite Grinding Media Interactions and Their Effects on Media Wear and Flotation, /. Electrochem. Soc, VoI 136 (No. 6), 1989, p 1734-1740 6. R.L. Pozzo and I. Iwasaki, Effect of Pyrite and Pyrrhotite on the Corrosive Wear of Grinding Media, Miner. Metall. Process., Aug 1987, p 166-171 7. K.A Natarajan, S.C. Riemer, and I. Iwasaki, Influence of Pyrrhotite on the Corrosive Wear of Grinding Balls in Magnetite Ore Grinding, Int. J. Miner. Process., VoI 13 1984, p 73-81 8. R.L. Pozzo and I. Iwasaki, An Electro-chemical Study of PyrrhotiteGrinding Media Interaction Under Abrasive Conditions, Corrosion, VoI 43 (No. 3), 1987, p 159-169
9. K.G. Budinski, Surface Engineering for Wear Resistance, PrenticeHall, Inc., 1988, p 6-10 10. Engineering Coatings—Design and Application, 2nd ed., S. Grainger and J. Blunt, Ed., Woodhead Publishing Ltd., 1999, p 7
CHAPTER
Mm
P r i n c i p l e s
o f
C o r r o s i o n
CORROSION of metal is a chemical or electrochemical process in which surface atoms of a solid metal react with a substance in contact with the exposed surface. Usually the corroding medium is a liquid substance, but gases and even solids can also act as corroding media. In some instances, the corrodent is a bulk fluid; in others, it is a film, droplets, or a substance adsorbed on or absorbed in another substance. All structural metals corrode to some extent in natural environments (e.g., the atmosphere, soil, or waters). Bronze, brass, most stainless steels, zinc, and pure aluminum corrode so slowly in service conditions that long service life is expected without protective coatings. Corrosion of structural grades of cast iron and steel, the 400 series stainless steels, and some aluminum alloys, however, proceeds rapidly unless the metal is protected against corrosion. As described in Chapter 1, corrosion of metals is of particular concern because annual losses in the United States attributed to corrosion amount to hundreds of billions of dollars. Although emphasis in this Chapter has been placed on irons and steels, the electrochemical corrosion basics and the forms of corrosion described are applicable to all metallic materials. For more detailed information on the corrosion resistance of various metals and their alloys, the reader should consult the selected references listed at the conclusion of this Chapter, as well as Corrosion, VoI 13, of the ASM Handbook or Corrosion: Understanding the Basics, published by ASM International in 2000.
Electrochemical Corrosion Basics Electrochemical corrosion in metals in a natural environment, whether atmosphere, in water, or underground, is caused by a flow of electricity from one metal to another, or from one part of a metal surface to another part of the same surface where conditions permit the flow of electricity.
Current flow in conductor Metal anode
Metallic conductor between the anode and the cathode Metal cathode Oxygen or other depolarizer in electrolyte
Oxidation reaction occurs at anode
Electrolyte, water containing conductive salts Reduction reaction occurs at cathode
Current flow through the electrolyte Fig. 1 Simple electrochemical cell showing the components necessary for corrosion
For the flow of energy to take place, either a moist conductor or an electrolyte must be present. An electrolyte is an electricity-conducting solution containing ions, which are atomic particles or radicals bearing an electrical charge. Charged ions are present in solutions of acids, alkalis, and salts. The presence of an electrolyte is necessary for corrosion to occur. Water, especially salt water, is an excellent electrolyte. Electricity passes from a negative area to a positive area through the electrolyte. For corrosion to occur in metals, one must have (a) an electrolyte, (b) an area or region on a metallic surface with a negative charge, (c) a second area with a positive charge, and (d) an electrically conductive path between (b) and (c). These components are arranged to form a closed electrical circuit. In the simplest case, the anode would be one metal, such as iron, the cathode another, perhaps copper, and the electrolyte might or might not have the same composition at both anode and cathode. The anode and cathode could be of the same metal under conditions described later in this article. The cell shown in Fig. 1 illustrates the corrosion process in its simplest form. This cell includes the following essential components: (a) a metal anode, (b) a metal cathode, (c) a metallic conductor between the anode and the cathode, and (d) an electrolyte in contact with the anode and the cathode. If the cell were constructed and allowed to function, an electrical current would flow through the metallic conductor and the electrolyte, and if the conductor were replaced by a voltmeter, a potential difference between the anode and the cathode could be measured. The anode would corrode. Chemically, this is an oxidation reaction. The formation of hydrated red iron rust by electrochemical reactions may be expressed as follows:
(EqI)
(Eq 2) During metallic corrosion, the rate of oxidation equals the rate of reduction. Thus, a nondestructive chemical reaction, reduction, would proceed simultaneously at the cathode. In most cases, hydrogen gas is produced on the cathode. When the gas layer insulates the cathode from the electrolyte, current flow stops, and the cell is polarized. However, oxygen or some other depolarizing agent is usually present to react with the hydrogen, which reduces this effect and allows the cell to continue to function. Contact between dissimilar metallic conductors or differences in the concentration of the solution cause the difference in potential that results in electrical current. Any lack of homogeneity on the metal surface or its environment may initiate attack by causing a difference in potential, and this results in localized corrosion. The metal undergoing electrochemical corrosion need not be immersed in a liquid but may be in contact with moist soil or may have moist areas on the metal surface.
Corrosive Conditions If oxygen and water are both present, corrosion will normally occur on iron and steel. Rapid corrosion may take place in water, the rate of corrosion being accelerated by several factors such as: (a) the velocity or the acidity of the water, (b) the motion of the metal, (c) an increase in temperature or aeration, and (d) the presence of certain bacteria. Corrosion can be retarded by protective layers or films consisting of corrosion products or adsorbed oxygen. High alkalinity of the water also retards the rate of corrosion on steel surfaces. Water and oxygen remain the essential factors, however, and the amount of corrosion is generally controlled by one or the other. For example, corrosion of steel does not occur in dry air and is negligible when the relative humidity of the air is below 30% at normal or lower temperatures. This is the basis for prevention of corrosion by dehumidification. Water can readily dissolve a small amount of oxygen from the atmosphere, thus becoming highly corrosive. When the free oxygen dissolved in water is removed, the water becomes practically noncorrosive unless it becomes acidic or anaerobic bacteria incite corrosion. If oxygen-free water is maintained at a neutral pH or at slight alkalinity, it is practically
noncorrosive to structural steel. Steam boilers and water supply systems are effectively protected by deaerating the water. Additional information on corrosion in water can be found in Ref 1. Soils. Dispersed metallic particles or bacteria pockets can provide a natural electrical pathway for buried metal. If an electrolyte is present and the soil has a negative charge in relation to the metal, an electrical path from the metal to the soil will occur, resulting in corrosion. Differences in soil conditions, such as moisture content and resistivity, are commonly responsible for creating anodic and cathodic areas (Fig. 2). Where a difference exists in the concentration of oxygen in the water or in moist soils in contact with metal at different areas, cathodes develop at points of relatively high-oxygen concentrations and anodes at points of low concentration. Further information on corrosion in soils is available in Ref 2. Chemicals. In an acid environment, even without the presence of oxygen, the metal at the anode is attacked at a rapid rate. At the cathode, atomic hydrogen is released continuously, to become hydrogen gas. Corrosion by an acid can result in the formation of a salt, which slows the reaction because the salt formation on the surface is then attacked. Corrosion by direct chemical attack is the single most destructive force against steel surfaces. Substances having chlorine or other halogens in their composition are particularly aggressive. Galvanized roofing has been known to corrode completely within six months of construction, the building being downwind of an aluminum ingot plant where fluorides were always present in the atmosphere. Consequently, galvanized steel should not have been specified. Selection of materials and evaluation of service conditions are extremely important in combating corrosion. The response of various materials to chemical environments is addressed in Ref 3 and 4. Atmospheric corrosion differs from the corrosion action that occurs in water or underground, because sufficient oxygen is always present. In at-
Cathodic area (steel at top of pipe) Buried pipe
Oxygen diffusing into earth from ground surface Electrolyte 1 (soil with ground water high in oxygen content) •Current flow
Anodic area (steel at bottom of pipe)
• Electrolyte 2 (soil with ground water deficient in oxygen content)
Fe2+ (rust) pjo 2 A metal pipe buried in moist soil forming a corrosion cell. A difference ^* in oxygen content at different levels in the electrolyte will produce a difference of potential. Anodic and cathodic areas will develop, and a corrosion cell, called a concentration cell, will form.
mospheric corrosion, the formation of insoluble films and the presence of moisture and deposits from the atmosphere control the rate of corrosion. Contaminants such as sulfur compounds and salt particles can accelerate the corrosion rate. Nevertheless, atmospheric corrosion occurs primarily through electrochemical means and is not directly caused by chemical attack. The anodic and cathodic areas are usually quite small and close together so that corrosion appears uniform, rather than in the form of severe pitting, which can occur in water or soil. A more detailed discussion on atmospheric corrosion can be found in Ref 5. Forms of Corrosion The differing forms of corrosion can be divided into the following eight categories based on the appearance of the corrosion damage or the mechanism of attack: Uniform or general corrosion Galvanic corrosion Pitting corrosion Crevice corrosion, including corrosion under tubercles or deposits, filiform corrosion, and poultice corrosion Erosion-corrosion, including cavitation erosion and fretting corrosion Intergranular corrosion, including sensitization and exfoliation Dealloying Environmentally assisted cracking, including stress-corrosion cracking (SCC), corrosion fatigue, and hydrogen damage (including hydrogen embrittlement, hydrogen-induced blistering, high-temperature hydrogen attack, and hydride formation) Figure 3 illustrates schematically some of the most common forms of corrosion. More detailed information pertaining to recognition and prevention of these forms of corrosion can be found in Ref 6 and 7. Uniform Corrosion General Description. Uniform or general corrosion, as the name implies, results in a fairly uniform penetration (or thinning) over the entire exposed metal surface. The general attack results from local corrosion-cell action; that is, multiple anodes and cathodes are operating on the metal surface at any given time. The location of the anodic and cathodic areas continues to move about on the surface, resulting in uniform corrosion. Uniform corrosion often results from atmospheric exposure (especially polluted industrial environments); exposure in fresh, brackish, and salt waters; or exposure in soils and chemicals.
More noble metal
No corrosion
Pitting
Uniform
Exfoliation
Galvanic
Dealloying
Flowing corrodent
Erosion
lntergranular
Cyclic movement
Metal or nonmetal
Fretting
Crevice
Tensile stress
Cyclic stress
Stress-corrosion cracking
Corrosion fatigue
Flg. 3 Schematics of the common forms of corrosion
Metals Affected. All metals are affected by uniform corrosion, although materials that form passive films, such as stainless steels or nickelchromium alloys, are normally subjected to localized forms of attack. The rusting of steel, the green patina formation on copper, and the tarnishing of silver are typical examples of uniform corrosion. In some metals, such as steel, uniform corrosion produces a somewhat rough surface by removing a substantial amount of metal, which either dissolves in the environment or reacts with it to produce a loosely adherent, porous coating of corrosion products. In such reactions as in the tarnishing of silver in air, the oxidation of aluminum in air, or attack on lead in sulfate-containing environments, thin, tightly adherent protective films are produced, and the metal surface remains smooth. Prevention. Uniform corrosion can be prevented or reduced by proper materials selection, the use of coatings or inhibitors, or cathodic protection. These corrosion prevention methods can be used individually or in combination. Galvanic Corrosion General Description. The potential available to promote the electrochemical corrosion reaction between dissimilar metals is suggested by the galvanic series, which lists a number of common metals and alloys arranged according to their tendency to corrode when in galvanic contact (Table 1). Metals close to one another on the table generally do not have a strong effect on each other, but the farther apart any two metals are separated, the stronger the corroding effect on the one higher in the list. It is possible for certain metals to reverse their positions in some environments, but the order given in Table 1 is maintained in natural waters and the atmosphere. The galvanic series should not be confused with the sim-
Table 1
Galvanic series in seawater at 25 0C (77 0F)
Corroded end (anodic, or least noble) Magnesium Magnesium alloys Zinc Galvanized steel or galvanized wrought iron Aluminum alloys 5052, 3004, 3003, 1100, 6053, in this order Cadmium Aluminum alloys 2117, 2017, 2024, in this order Low-carbon steel Wrought iron Cast iron Ni-Resist (high-nickel cast iron) Type 410 stainless steel (active) 50-50 lead-tin solder Type 304 stainless steel (active) Type 316 stainless steel (active) Lead Tin Copper alloy C28000 (Muntz metal, 60% Cu) Copper alloy C67500 (manganese bronze A) Copper alloys C46400, C46500, C46600, C46700 (naval brass) Nickel 200 (active) Inconel alloy 600 (active) Hastelloy alloy B Chlorimet 2 Copper alloy C27000 (yellow brass, 65% Cu) Copper alloys C44300, C44400, C44500 (admiralty brass) Copper albys C60800, C61400 (aluminum bronze) Copper alloy C23000 (red brass, 85% Cu) Copper C! 1000 (ETP copper) Copper alloys C65100, C65500 (silicon bronze) Copper alloy C71500 (copper nickel, 30% Ni) Copper alloy C92300, cast (leaded tin bronze G) Copper alloy C92200, cast (leaded tin bronze M) Nickel 200 (passive) Inconel alloy 600 (passive) Monel alloy 400 Type 410 stainless steel (passive) Type 304 stainless steel (passive) Type 316 stainless steel (passive) Incoloy alloy 825 Inconel alloy 625 Hastelloy alloy C Chlorimet 3 Silver Titanium Graphite Gold Platinum Protected end (cathodic, or most noble)
ilar electromotive force series, which shows exact potentials based on highly standardized conditions that rarely exist in nature. The three-layer iron oxide scale formed on steel during rolling varies with the operation performed and the rolling temperature. The dissimilarity of the metal and the scale can cause corrosion to occur, with the steel acting as the anode in this instance. Unfortunately, mill scale is cathodic to steel, and an electric current can easily be produced between the steel and the mill scale. This electrochemical action will corrode the steel without affecting the mill scale (Fig. 4). A galvanic couple may be the cause of premature failure in metal components of water-related structures or may be advantageously exploited.
Electrolyte (water) (rust)
Current flow
Cathode (broken mil scale)
Anode (steel) Fig, 4 Mill scale forming a corrosion cell on steel
Galvanizing iron sheet is an example of useful application of galvanic action or cathodic protection. Iron is the cathode and is protected against corrosion at the expense of the sacrificial zinc anode. Alternatively, a zinc or magnesium anode may be located in the electrolyte close to the structure and may be connected electrically to the iron or steel. This method is referred to as cathodic protection of the structure. Iron or steel can become the anode when in contact with copper, brass, or bronze; however, iron or steel corrode rapidly while protecting the latter metals. Also, weld metal may be anodic to the basis metal, creating a corrosion cell when immersed (Fig. 5). While the galvanic series (Table 1) represents the potential available to promote a corrosive reaction, the actual corrosion is difficult to predict. Electrolytes may be poor conductors, or long distances may introduce large resistance into the corrosion cell circuit. More frequently, scale formation forms a partially insulating layer over the anode. A cathode having a layer of adsorbed gas bubbles, as a consequence of the corrosion cell reaction, is polarized. The effect of such conditions is to reduce the theoretical consumption of metal by corrosion. The area relationship between the anode and cathode may also strongly affect the corrosion rate; a high ratio of cathode area to anode area produces more rapid corrosion. In the reverse case, the cathode polarizes, and the corrosion rate soon drops to a negligible level. The passivity of stainless steels is attributed to either the presence of a corrosion-resistant oxide film or an oxygen-caused polarizing effect,
Electrolyte (water)
(rust) Current flow Cathode (steel) Anode (weld metal) \
FlC, 5 Weld metal forming a corrosion cell on steel. Weld metal may be an^* odic to steel, creating a corrosion cell when immersed.
durable only as long as there is sufficient oxygen to maintain the effect, over the surfaces. In most natural environments, stainless steels will remain in a passive state and thus tend to be cathodic to ordinary iron and steel. Change to an active state usually occurs only where chloride concentrations are high, as in seawater or reducing solutions. Oxygen starvation also produces a change to an active state. This occurs where the oxygen supply is limited, as in crevices and beneath contamination on partially fouled surfaces. Prevention. Galvanic corrosion can be prevented or reduced by proper materials selection (i.e., select combinations of metals as close together as possible in the galvanic series), insulating dissimilar metals, applying a barrier coating to both the anodic (less noble) and cathodic (noble) metal, applying a sacrificial coating (aluminum, zinc, or cadmium) to the cathodic part, applying nonmetallic films (e.g., anodizing aluminum alloys), and by providing cathodic protection.
Pitting General Description. Pitting is a type of localized cell corrosion. It is predominantly responsible for the functional failure of iron and steel water-related installations. Pitting may result in the perforation of water pipe, rendering it unserviceable, even though less than 5% of the total metal has been lost through rusting. Where confinement of water is not a factor, pitting causes structural failure from localized weakening while considerable sound metal still remains. Pitting develops when the anodic or corroding area is small in relation to the cathodic or protected area. For example, pitting can occur where large areas of the surface are covered by mill scale, applied coatings, or deposits of various kinds and where breaks exist in the continuity of the protective coating. Pitting may also develop on bare, clean metal surfaces because of irregularities in the physical or chemical structure of the metal. Localized, dissimilar soil conditions at the surface of steel can also create conditions that promote pitting. Electrical contact between dissimilar materials or concentration cells (areas of the same metal where oxygen or conductive salt concentrations in water differ) accelerates the rate of pitting. In closed-vessel structures, these couples cause a difference of potential that results in an electric current flowing through the water or across the moist steel from the metallic anode to a nearby cathode. The cathode may be copper, brass, mill scale, or any portion of a metal surface that is cathodic to the more active metal areas. In practice, mill scale is cathodic to steel and is found to be a common cause of pitting. The difference of potential generated between steel and mill scale often amounts to 0.2 to 0.3 V. This couple is nearly as powerful a generator of corrosion currents as is the copper-steel couple. However, when the anodic area is relatively large compared with the
cathodic area, the damage is spread out and usually negligible, but when the anode is relatively small, the metal loss is concentrated and may be very serious. On surfaces having some mill scale, the total metal loss is nearly constant as the anode is decreased, but the degree of penetration increases. Figure 4 shows how a pit forms where a break occurs in mill scale. When contact between dissimilar materials is unavoidable and the surface is painted, it is preferred to paint both materials. If only one surface is painted, it should be the cathode. If only the anode is coated, any weak points such as pinholes or holidays in the coating will probably result in intense pitting. As a pit, perhaps at a break in mill scale, becomes deeper, an oxygen concentration cell is started by depletion of oxygen in the pit. The rate of penetration by such pits is accelerated proportionately as the bottom of the pit becomes more anodic. Fabrication operations may crack mill scale and result in accelerated corrosion. Metals Affected. Pitting occurs in most commonly used metals and alloys. Iron buried in the soil corrodes with the formation of shallow pits, but carbon steels in contact with hydrochloric acid or stainless steels immersed in seawater characteristically corrode with the formation of deep pits. Aluminum tends to pit in waters containing chloride ions (for example, at stagnant areas), and aluminum brasses are subject to pitting in polluted waters. Despite their good resistance to general corrosion, stainless steels are more susceptible to pitting than many other metals. High-alloy stainless steels containing chromium, nickel, and molybdenum are also more resistant to pitting but are not immune under all service conditions. Pitting failures of corrosion-resistant alloys, such as Hastelloy C, Hastelloy G, and Incoloy 825, are relatively uncommon in solutions that do not contain halides, although any mechanism that permits the establishment of an electrolytic cell in which a small anode is in contact with a large cathodic area offers the opportunity for pitting attack. Prevention. Typical approaches to alleviating or minimizing pitting corrosion include the following: Use defect-free barrier coatings Reduce the aggressiveness of the environment, for example, chloride ion concentrations, temperature, acidity, and oxidizing agents Upgrade the materials of construction, for example, use molybdenumcontaining (4 to 6% Mo) stainless steels, molybdenum + tungsten nickel-base alloys, overalloy welds, and use corrosion-resistant alloy linings Modify the design of the system, for example, avoid crevices and the formation of deposits, circulate/stir to eliminate stagnant solutions, and ensure proper drainage
Crevice
Corrosion
General Description. Crevice corrosion is a form of localized attack that occurs at narrow openings or spaces (gaps) between metal-to-metal or nonmetal-to-metal components. This type of attack results from a concentration cell formed between the electrolyte within the crevice, which is oxygen starved, and the electrolyte outside the crevice, where oxygen is more plentiful. The material within the crevice acts as the anode, and the exterior material becomes the cathode. Crevices may be produced by design or accident. Crevices caused by design occur at gaskets, flanges, rubber O-rings, washers, bolt holes, rolled tube ends, threaded joints, riveted seams, overlapping screen wires, lap joints, beneath coatings (filiform corrosion) or insulation (poultice corrosion), and anywhere close-fitting surfaces are present. Figure 6 shows crevice corrosion in a riveted assembly caused by concentration cells. Occluded regions are also formed under tubercles (tuberculation), deposits (deposit corrosion), and below accumulations or biological materials (biologically influenced corrosion). Similarly, unintentional crevices such as cracks, seams, and other metallurgical defects could serve as sites for corrosion. Metals Affected. Resistance to crevice corrosion can vary from one alloy-environment system to another. Although crevice corrosion affects both active and passive metals, the attack is often more severe for passive alloys, particularly those in the stainless steel group. Breakdown of the passive film within a restricted geometry leads to rapid metal loss and penetration of the metal in that area.
Low metal ion concentration
Metal ion concentration cell
High metal ion concentration High oxygen concentration Oxygen concentration cell
Low oxygen concentration Fig. 6 Corrosion caused at crevices by concentration cells. Both types of concentration cells shown sometimes occur simultaneously as in a reentry angle in a riveted seam.
Prevention. Crevice corrosion can be prevented or reduced through improved design to avoid crevices, regular cleaning to remove deposits, by selecting a more corrosion-resistant material, and by coating carbon steel or cast iron components with epoxy or other field-applied or factoryapplied organic coatings. Erosion-Corrosion General Description. Erosion-corrosion is the acceleration or increase in the rate of deterioration or attack on a metal because of mechanical wear or abrasive contributions in combination with corrosion. The combination of wear or abrasion and corrosion results in more severe attack than would be realized with either mechanical or chemical corrosive action alone. Metal is removed from the surface as dissolved ions, as particles of solid corrosion products, or as elemental metal. The spectrum of erosioncorrosion ranges from primarily erosive attack, such as sandblasting, filing, or grinding of a metal surface, to primarily corrosion failures, where the contribution of mechanical action is quite small. All types of corrosive media generally can cause erosion-corrosion, including gases, aqueous solutions, organic systems, and liquid metals. For example, hot gases may oxidize a metal then at high velocity blow off an otherwise protective scale. Solids in suspension in liquids (slurries) are particularly destructive from the standpoint of erosion-corrosion. Erosion-corrosion is characterized in appearance by grooves, waves, rounded holes, and/or horseshoe-shaped grooves. Analysis of these marks can help determine the direction of flow. Affected areas are usually free of deposits and corrosion products, although corrosion products can sometimes be found if erosion-corrosion occurs intermittently and/or the liquid flow rate is relatively low. Metals Affected. Most metals are susceptible to erosion-corrosion under specific conditions. Metals that depend on a relatively thick protective coating of corrosion product for corrosion resistance are frequently subject to erosion-corrosion. This is due to the poor adhesion of these coatings relative to the thin films formed by the classical passive metals, such as stainless steels and titanium. Both stainless steels and titanium are relatively immune to erosion-corrosion in many environments. Metals that
Corrosion film
Water flow Impingement corrosion pits
Original metal surface
Metal tube wall Fig, 7 Schematic of erosion-corrosion of a condenser tube
are soft and readily damaged or worn mechanically, such as copper and lead, are quite susceptible to erosion-corrosion. Even the noble or precious metals, such silver, gold, and platinum, are subject to erosion-corrosion. Figure 7 shows a schematic of erosion-corrosion of a condenser tube wall. The direction of flow and the resulting attack where the protective film on the tube has broken down are indicated. Prevention. Erosion-corrosion can be prevented or reduced through improved design (e.g., increase pipe diameter and/or streamline bends to reduce impingement effects), by altering the environment (e.g., deaeration and the addition of inhibitors), and by applying hard, tough protective coatings. Cavitation General Description. Cavitation is a form of erosion-corrosion that is caused by the formation and collapse of vapor bubbles in a liquid against a metal surface. Cavitation occurs in hydraulic turbines, on pump impellers, on ship propellers, and on many surfaces in contact with high-velocity liquids subject to changes in pressure. The appearance of cavitation is similar to pitting except that surfaces in the pits are usually much rougher. The affected region is free of deposits and accumulated corrosion products if cavitation has been recent. Figure 8 is a simplified representation of the cavitation process. Figure 8(a) shows a vessel containing a liquid. The vessel is closed by an airtight plunger. When the plunger is withdrawn (Fig. 8b), a partial vacuum is created above the liquid, causing vapor bubbles to form and grow within Partial vacuum
Pressurized
Metal (a) Rest Quiescent liquid at standard temperature and pressure
(b) Expansion Liquid boiling at room temperature
(c) Compression Collapse of vapor bubbles
Metal oxide (d)
Approaching microjet torpedo
Destruction of metal oxide on impact
Repair of metal oxide at expense of metal
P J o - 8 Schematic representation of cavitation showing a cross section through a vessel and plunger enclosing a fluid. " (a) Plunger stationary, liquid at standard temperature and pressure, (b) Plunger withdrawn, liquid boils at room temperature, (c) Plunger advanced, bubbles collapse, (d) Disintegration of protective corrosion product by impacting microjet "torpedo." Source: Ref 8
the liquid. In essence, the liquid boils without a temperature increase. If the plunger is then driven toward the surface of the liquid (Fig. 8c), the pressure in the liquid increases, and the bubbles condense and collapse (implode). In a cavitating liquid, these three steps occur in a matter of milliseconds. As shown in Fig. 8(d), implosion of a vapor bubble creates a microscopic "torpedo" of water that is ejected from the collapsing bubble at velocities that may range from 100 to 500 m/s (330 to 1650 ft/s). When the torpedo impacts the metal surface, it dislodges protective surface films and/or locally deforms the metal itself. Thus, fresh surfaces are exposed to corrosion and the reformation of protective films, which is followed by more cavitation, and so on. Damage occurs when the cycle is allowed to repeat over and over again. Prevention. Cavitation can be controlled or minimized by improving design to minimize hydrodynamic pressure differences, employing stronger (harder) and more corrosion-resistant materials, specifying a smooth finish on all critical metal surfaces, and coating with resilient materials such as rubber and some plastics. Fretting Corrosion General Description. Fretting corrosion is a combined wear and corrosion process in which material is removed from contacting surfaces when motion between the surfaces is restricted to very small amplitude oscillations (often, the relative movement is barely discernible). Usually, the condition exists in machine components that are considered fixed and not expected to wear. Pressed-on wheels can often fret at the shaft/wheel hole interface. Oxidation is the most common element in the fretting process. In oxidizing systems, fine metal particles removed by adhesive wear are oxidized and trapped between the fretting surfaces (Fig. 9). The oxides act like an abrasive (such as lapping rouge) and increase the rate of material removal. This type of fretting in ferrous alloys is easily recognized by the red material oozing from between the contacting surfaces. Fretting corrosion takes the form of local surface dislocations and deep pits. These occur in regions where slight relative movements have occurred between mating, highly loaded surfaces.
Surface Oxide Bare Metal Metal and Oxide Debris Fig, 9 Schematic of the fretting process
Prevention. Fretting corrosion can be controlled by lubricating (e.g., low-viscosity oils) the faying surfaces, restricting the degree of movement, shot peening (rough surfaces are less prone to fretting damage), surface hardening (e.g., carburizing and nitriding), anodizing of aluminum alloys, phosphate conversion coating of steels, and by applying protective coatings by electrodeposition (e.g., gold or silver plating), plasma spraying, or vapor deposition (Ref 9). lntergranular Corrosion General Description. lntergranular corrosion is defined as the selective dissolution of grain boundaries, or closely adjacent regions, without appreciable attack of the grains themselves. This dissolution is caused by potential differences between the grain-boundary region and any precipitates, intermetallic phases, or impurities that form at the grain boundaries. The actual mechanism differs with each alloy system. Although a wide variety of alloy systems are susceptible to intergranular corrosion under very specific conditions, the majority of case histories reported in the literature have involved austenitic stainless steels and aluminum alloys and, to a lesser degree, some ferritic stainless steels and nickel-base alloys. Precipitates that form as a result of the exposure of metals at elevated temperatures (for example, during production, fabrication, and welding) often nucleate and grow preferentially at grain boundaries. If these precipitates are rich in alloying elements that are essential for corrosion resistance, the regions adjacent to the grain boundary are depleted of these elements. The metal is thus sensitized and is susceptible to intergranular attack in a corrosive environment. For example, in austenitic stainless steels such as AISI type 304, the cause of intergranular attack is the precipitation of chromium-rich carbides ((Cr5Fe)23C6) at grain boundaries. These chromium-rich precipitates are surrounded by metal that is depleted in chromium; therefore, they are more rapidly attacked at these zones than on undepleted metal surfaces. Impurities that segregate at grain boundaries may promote galvanic action in a corrosive environment by serving as anodic or cathodic sites. Therefore, this would affect the rate of the dissolution of the alloy matrix in the vicinity of the grain boundary. An example of this is found in aluminum alloys that contain intermetallic compounds, such as Mg5Al8 and CuAl2, at the grain boundaries. During exposures to chloride solutions, the galvanic couples formed between these precipitates and the alloy matrix can lead to severe intergranular attack. Susceptibility to intergranular attack depends on the corrosive solution and on the extent of intergranular precipitation, which is a function of alloy composition, fabrication, and heat treatment parameters. Prevention. Susceptibility to intergranular corrosion in austenitic stainless steels can be avoided by controlling their carbon contents or by
adding elements (titanium and niobium) whose carbides are more stable than those of chromium. For most austenitic stainless steels, restricting their carbon contents to 0.03% or less will prevent sensitization during welding and most heat treatment. Intergranular corrosion in aluminum alloys is controlled by material selection (e.g., the high-strength Ixxx and Ixxx alloys are the most susceptible) and by proper selection of thermal (tempering) treatments that can effect the amount, size, and distribution of second-phase intermetallic precipitates. Resistance to intergranular corrosion is obtained by the use of heat treatments that cause precipitation to be more general throughout the grain structure (Ref 10). Exfoliation General Description. Exfoliation is a form of macroscopic intergranular corrosion that primarily affects aluminum alloys in industrial or marine environments. Corrosion proceeds laterally from initiation sites on the surface and generally proceeds intergranularly along planes parallel to the surface. The corrosion products that form in the grain boundaries force metal away from the underlying base material, resulting in a layered or flakelike appearance (see, for example, the schematic shown in Fig. 3). Prevention. Resistance to exfoliation corrosion is attained through proper alloy and temper selection. The most susceptible alloys are the high-strength heat-treatable Ixxx and Ixxx alloys. Exfoliation corrosion in these alloys is usually confined to relatively thin sections of highly worked products. Guidelines for selecting proper heat treatment for these alloys can be found in Ref 10. Dealloying Corrosion General Description. Dealloying, also referred to as selective leaching or parting corrosion, is a corrosion process in which the more active metal is selectively removed from an alloy, leaving behind a porous weak deposit of the more noble metal. Specific categories of dealloying often carry the name of the dissolved element. For example, the preferential leaching of zinc from brass is called dezincification. If aluminum is removed, the process is called dealuminification, and so forth. In the case of gray iron, dealloying is called graphitic corrosion. In the dealloying process, typically one of two mechanisms occurs: alloy dissolution and replating of the cathodic element or selective dissolution of an anodic alloy constituent. In either case, the metal is left spongy and porous and loses much of its strength, hardness, and ductility. Table 2 lists some of the alloy-environment combinations for which dealloying has been reported. By far the two most common forms of dealloying are dezincification and graphitic corrosion. Copper-zinc alloys containing more than 15% zinc are susceptible to dezincification. In the dezincification of brass, selective removal of zinc
leaves a relatively porous and weak layer of copper and copper oxide. Corrosion of a similar nature continues beneath the primary corrosion layer, resulting in gradual replacement of sound brass by weak, porous copper. Graphitic corrosion is observed in gray cast irons in relatively mild environments in which selective leaching of iron leaves a graphite network. Selective leaching of the iron takes place because the graphite is cathodic to iron, and the gray iron structure establishes an excellent galvanic cell. Prevention. Dezincification can be prevented by alloy substitution. Brasses with copper contents of 85% or more resist dezincification. Some alloying elements also inhibit dezincification (e.g., brasses containing 1% tin). Where dezincification is a problem, red brass, commercial bronze, inhibited admiralty metal, and inhibited brass can be successfully used. Attack by graphitic corrosion is reduced by alloy substitution (e.g., use of a ductile or alloyed iron rather than gray iron), altering the environment (raise the water pH to neutral or slightly alkaline levels), the use of inhibitors, and avoiding stagnant water conditions. Stress-Corrosion Cracking General Description. Stress-corrosion cracking (SCC) is a cracking phenomenon that occurs in susceptible alloys and is caused by the conjoint action of a surface tensile stress and the presence of a specific corrosive environment. For SCC to occur on an engineering structure, three conditions must be met simultaneously, namely, a specific crack-promoting environment must be present, the metallurgy of the material must be susceptible to SCC, and the tensile stresses must be above some threshold value. Stresses required to cause SCC are small, usually below the macroscopic yield stress. The stresses can be externally applied, but residual stresses often cause SCC failures. This cracking phenomenon is of particular importance to users of potentially susceptible structural alloys because SCC occurs under service conditions that can result, often with no warning, in catastrophic failure. Failed specimens exhibit highly branched Table 2 Combinations of alloys and environments subject to dealloying and elements preferentially removed Alloy
Brasses Gray iron Aluminum bronzes Silicon bronzes Tin bronzes Copper-gold single crystals Monels Gold alloys with copper or silver Tungsten carbide-cobalt High-nickel alloys Medium- and high-carbon steels Iron-chromium alloys Nickel-molybdenum alloys
Environment
Element removed
Many waters, especially under stagnant conditions Soils, many waters Hydrofluoric acid, acids containing chloride ions High-temperature steam and acidic species Hot brine or steam Ferric chloride Hydrofluoric and other acids Sulfide solutions, human saliva Deionized water Molten salts Oxidizing atmospheres, hydrogen at high temperatures High-temperature oxidizing atmospheres Oxygen at high temperature
Zinc (dezincification) Iron (graphitic corrosion) Aluminum (dealuminification) Silicon (desiliconification) Tin (destannification) Copper Copper in some acids, and nickel in others Copper, silver Cobalt Chromium, iron, molybdenum, and tungsten Carbon (decarburization) Chromium, which forms a protective film Molybdenum
Table 3
Some environment-alloy combinations known to result in stress-corrosion cracking (SCC) Alloy system Aluminum alloys
Environment
Carbon steels
Copper alloys
Nickel alloys
Austenitic
Stainless Steels Duplex Martensitic
Titanium alloys
Zirconium alloys
Amines, aqueous Ammonia, anhydrous Ammonia, aqueous Bromine Carbonates, aqueous Carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, water mixture Chlorides, aqueous Chlorides, concentrated, boiling Chlorides, dry, hot Chlorinated solvents Cyanides, aqueous, acidified Fluorides, aqueous Hydrochloric acid Hydrofluoric acid Hydroxides, aqueous Hydroxides, concentrated, hot Methanol plus halides Nitrates, aqueous Nitric acid, concentrated Nitric acid, fuming Nitrites, aqueous Nitrogen tetroxide Polythionic acids Steam Sulfides plus chlorides, aqueous Sulfurous acid Water, high-purity, hot X, known to result in SCC
Stress-corrosion cracking control
Mechanical
Metallurgical
Environmental
Change alloy composition
Modify environment
Relieve fabrication stresses
Change alloy structure
Apply anodic or cathodic protection
Introduce surface compressfve stresses
Use metallic or conversion coating
Add inhibrtor
Avoid stress concentrators
Reduce operating stresses
Use organic coating
Nondestructive testing implications for design
Modify temperature
Fig. 1 0
M e t hods used to control SCC. Source: Ket I I
cracks (see Fig. 3) that propagate intergranularly and/or transgranularly, depending on the metal-environment combination. Table 3 lists some of the alloy-environment combinations that result in SCC. This table, as well as others published in the literature, should be used only as a guide for screening candidate materials prior to further indepth investigation, testing, and evaluation. Prevention. Figure 10 summarizes the various approaches to controlling SCC. Surface engineering treatments like shot peening, metallic coatings, and organic coatings play a key role in controlling SCC.
Corrosion Fatigue General Description. Corrosion fatigue is a term that is used to describe the phenomenon of cracking, including both initiation and propagation, in materials under the combined actions of a fluctuating or cyclic stress and a corrosive environment. Corrosion fatigue depends strongly on the interactions among the mechanical (loading), metallurgical, and environmental variables listed in Table 4. Corrosion fatigue produces fine-to-broad cracks with little or no branching (see Fig. 3); thus, they differ from SCC, which often exhibits considerable branching. They are typically filled with dense corrosion product. The cracks may occur singly but commonly appear as families or parallel cracks. They are frequently associated with pits, grooves, or some other form of stress concentrator. Transgranular fracture paths are more common than intergranular fractures.
Table 4 Mechanical, metallurgical, and environmental variables that influence corrosion fatigue behavior Variable Mechanical
Metallurgical
Environmental
Type Maximum stress or stress-intensity factor, a max or Kmax Cyclic stress or stress-intensity range, ACT or AK Stress ratio, R Cyclic loading frequency Cyclic load waveform (constant-amplitude loading) Load interactions in variable-amplitude loading State of stress Residual stress Crack size and shape, and their relation to component size and geometry Alloy composition Distribution of alloying elements and impurities Microstructure and crystal structure Heat treatment Mechanical working Preferred orientation of grains and grain boundaries (texture) Mechanical properties (strength, fracture toughness, etc.) Temperature Types of environments: gaseous, liquid, liquid metal, etc. Partial pressure of damaging species in gaseous environments Concentration of damaging species in aqueous or other liquid environments Electrical potential pH Viscosity of the environment Coatings, inhibitors, etc.
Prevention. All metals and alloys are susceptible to corrosion fatigue. Even some alloys that are immune to SCC, for example, ferritic stainless steels, are subject to failure by corrosion fatigue. Both temporary and permanent solutions for corrosion involve reducing or eliminating cyclic stresses, selecting a material or heat treatment with higher corrosion fatigue strengths, reducing or eliminating corrosion, or a combination of these procedures. These objectives are accomplished by changes in material, design, or environment and by the application of surface treatments. Shot peening, nitriding of steels, and organic coatings can successfully impede corrosion fatigue. Noble metal coatings (e.g., nickel) can be effective, but only if they remain unbroken and are of sufficient density and thickness. The relatively low corrosion-fatigue strength of carbon steel is reduced still further when local breaks in a coating occur. Hydrogen Damage General Description. The term hydrogen damage has been used to designate a number of processes in metals by which the load-carrying capacity of the metal is reduced due to the presence of hydrogen, often in combination with residual or applied tensile stresses. Although it occurs most frequently in carbon and low-alloy steels, many metals and alloys are susceptible to hydrogen damage. Hydrogen damage in one form or another can severely restrict the use of certain materials. Because hydrogen is one of the most abundant elements and is readily available during the production, processing, and service of metals, hydrogen damage can develop in a wide variety of environments and circumstances. The interaction between hydrogen and metals can result in the formation of solid solutions of hydrogen in metals, molecular hydrogen, gaseous products that are formed by reactions between hydrogen and elements constituting the alloy, and hydrides. Depending on the type of hydrogen/metal interaction, hydrogen damage of metal manifests itself in one of several ways. Specific types of hydrogen damage, some of which occur only in specific alloys under specific conditions include: Hydrogen embrittlement: Occurs most often in high-strength steels, primarily quenched-and-tempered and precipitation-hardened steels, with tensile strengths greater than about 1034 MPa (150 ksi). Hydrogen sulfide is the chief embrittling environment. Hydrogen-induced blistering: Also commonly referred to as hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC), it occurs in lower-strength (unhardened) steels, typically with tensile strengths less than about 550 MPa (80 ksi). Line pipe steels used in sour gas environments are susceptible to HIC.
Cracking from precipitation of internal hydrogen: Examples include shatter cracks, flakes, and fish eyes found in steel forgings, weldments, and castings. During cooling from the melt, hydrogen diffuses and precipitates in voids and discontinuities. Hydrogen attack: A high-pressure, high-temperature form of hydrogen damage. Commonly experienced in steels used in petrochemical plant equipment that often handles hydrogen and hydrogen-hydrocarbon streams at pressures as high as 21 MPa (3 ksi) and temperatures up to 540 0C (1000 0F) Hydride formation: Occurs when excess hydrogen is picked up during melting or welding of titanium, tantalum, zirconium, uranium, and thorium. Hydride particles cause significant loss in strength and large losses in ductility and toughness. Prevention. The primary factors controlling hydrogen damage are material, stress, and environment. Hydrogen damage can often be prevented by using more resistant material, changing the manufacturing processes, modifying the design to lower stresses, or changing the environment. Inhibitors and post-processing bake-out treatments can also be used. Baking of electroplated high-strength steel parts reduces the possibility of hydrogen embrittlement (see Chapter 8 for additional information).
Coatings and Corrosion Prevention As described in the previous section, surface treatments, and in particular protective coatings, are widely used to control corrosion in its varying forms. The problems of corrosion should be approached in the design stage, and the selection of a protective coating is important. Paint systems and lining materials exist that slow the corrosion rate of carbon steel surfaces. High-performance organic coatings such as epoxy, polyesters, polyurethanes, vinyl, or chlorinated rubber help to satisfy the need for corrosion prevention. Special primers are used to provide passivation, galvanic protection, corrosion inhibition, or mechanical or electrical barriers to corrosive action. Corrosion Inhibitors. A water-soluble corrosion inhibitor reduces galvanic action by making the metal passive or by providing an insulating film on the anode, the cathode, or both. A very small amount of chromate, polyphosphate, or silicate added to water creates a water-soluble inhibitor. A slightly soluble inhibitor incorporated into the prime coat of paint may also have a considerable protective influence. Inhibitive pigments in paint primers are successful inhibitors except when they dissolve sufficiently to leave holes in the paint film. Most paint primers contain a partially soluble inhibitive pigment such as zinc chromate, which reacts with the steel
substrate to form the iron salt. The presence of these salts slows corrosion of steel. Chromates, phosphates, molybdates, borates, silicates, and plumbates are commonly used for this purpose. Some pigments add alkalinity, slowing chemical attack on steel. Alkaline pigments, such as metaborates, cement, lime, or red lead, are effective, provided that the environment is not too aggressive. In addition, many new pigments have been introduced to the paint industry such as zinc phosphosilicate and zinc flake. Barrier coatings are used to prevent the electrolyte from reaching the component surface. Examples of barrier coatings include painted steel structures, steels lined with thick acid-proof brick, steels lined with rubberlike materials, or steels electroplated with a noble (see Table 1) metal (e.g., chromium, copper, or nickel). Protection is effective until the coating is penetrated, either by a pit, pore, crack, or by damage or wear. The substrate will then corrode preferentially to the coating (since it is anodic to the coating material), and corrosion products will lift off the coating and allow further attack (Fig. 11). Generally, electroplated coatings that are completely free of pores and other discontinuities are not commercially feasible. Pits eventually form at coating flaws, and the coating is penetrated. The resulting corrosion cell is shown in Fig. 12. The substrate exposed at the bottom of the resulting pit corrodes rapidly. A crater forms in the substrate, and because of the
Rust Paint Steel (a)
(b) p jo "I \ Illustration of the mechanism of corrosion for painted steel, (a) A void " in the paint results in rusting of the steel, which undercuts the paint coating and results in further coating degradation, (b) Photograph showing blistering and/or peeling (undercutting) of paint where exposed steel is rusting.
Moist air
Noble metal coating (cathode)
Steel substrate (anode) f\a 1 2 Crater formation in a steel substrate beneath a void in a noble metal " coating, for example, passive chromium or copper. Corrosion proceeds under the noble metal, the edges of which collapse into the corrosion pit. Water drop
Substrate (M3)
Coating (M1)
Coating (M2)
FlC, 1 3 Corrosion pit formation in a substrate beneath a void in a duplex ^* noble metal coating. The top coating layer (M1) is cathodic to the coating underlayer (M2), which is in turn cathodic to the substrate (M3). As in Fig. 12, the coating tends to collapse into the pit.
large area ratio between the more noble coating and the anodic crater, the crater becomes anodic, and high corrosion current density results. Electrons flow from the substrate to the coating as the steel dissolves. Hydrogen ions (H + ) in the moisture accept the electron and, with dissolved oxygen, form water at the noble metal surface near the void. Use of an intermediate coating that is less noble than a surface coating but more noble than the base metal can result in the mode of corrosion shown in Fig. 13. This would be typical of a costume jewelry item with a brass substrate, an intermediate nickel coating, and a tarnish-resistant gold top coat. It is also exemplified by nickel-chromium coating systems. Sacrificial coatings, which corrode preferentially to the substrate, include zinc, aluminum, cadmium, and zinc-rich paints. Initially these sacrificial coatings will corrode, but their corrosion products are protective and the coating acts as a barrier layer. If the coating is damaged or defective, it remains protective as it is the coating that suffers attack and not the substrate. Figure 14 shows the sacrificial (galvanic) protection offered by a zinc coating to a steel substrate. Cathodic protection involves the reversal of electric current flow within the corrosion cell. Cathodic protection can reduce or eliminate corrosion by connecting a more active metal to a metal that must be
Water drop
Zinc coating (anode)
steel substrate (cathode) FlC. 14 Principles and mechanism of galvanic protection of a substrate by a ^* coating. Galvanic protection of a steel substrate at a void in a zinc coating. Corrosion of the substrate is light and occurs at some distance from the zinc.
protected. The use of cathodic protection to reduce or eliminate corrosion is a successful technique of long-standing use in marine structures, pipelines, bridge decks, sheet piling, and equipment and tankage of all types, particularly below water or underground. Typically, zinc or magnesium anodes are used to protect steel in marine environments, and the anodes are replaced after they are consumed. Cathodic protection uses an impressed direct current (dc) supplied by any low output voltage source and a relatively inert anode. As is the case in all forms of cathodic activity, an electrolyte is needed for current flow. Cathodic protection and the use of protective coatings are most often employed jointly, especially in marine applications and on board ships where impressed current inputs do not usually exceed 1 V. Beyond 1 V, many coating systems tend to disbond. Current source for cathodic protection in soils is usually 1.5 to 2 V. Choice of anodes for buried steel pipe depends on soil conditions. Magnesium is most commonly used for galvanic anodes; however, zinc can also be used. Galvanic anodes are seldom used when the resistivity of the soil is over 30 fl • m (3000 ft • cm); impressed current is normally used for these conditions. Graphite, high-silicon cast iron, scrap iron, aluminum, and platinum are used as anodes with impressed current. The availability of low-cost power is often the deciding factor in choosing between galvanic or impressed current cathodic protection. Figure 15 illustrates both types of galvanic protection systems. Protective coatings are normally used in conjunction with cathodic protection and should not be disregarded where cathodic protection is contemplated in new construction. Because the cathodic protection current must protect only the bare or poorly insulated areas of the surface, coatings that are highly insulating, very durable, and free of discontinuities lower the current requirements and system costs. A good coating also enables a single-impressed current installation to protect many miles of piping. Coal-tar enamel, epoxy powder coatings, and vinyl resin are exam-
ac line Insulated copper wire
Rectifier. Insulated copper wire Soil
Soil Active metal anode
Pipeline
Pipeline
Current
Current
Backfill (a)
Anode
Backfil
(b)
Fig, 1 5 Cathodic protection for underground pipe, (a) Sacrificial or galvanic anode, (b) Impressed-cur^* rent anode, ac, alternating current
pies of coatings that are most suitable for use with cathodic protection. Certain other coatings may be incompatible, such as phenolic coatings, which may deteriorate rapidly in the alkaline environment created by the cathodic protection currents. Although cement mortar initially conducts the electrical current freely, polarization, the formation of an insulating film on the surface as a result of the protective current, is believed to reduce the current requirement moderately. Cathodic protection is used increasingly to protect buried or submerged metal structures in the oil, gas, and waterworks industries and can be used in specialized applications, such as for the interiors of water storage tanks. Pipelines are routinely designed to ensure the electrical continuity necessary for effective functioning of the cathodic protection system. Thus, electrical connections or bonds are required between pipe sections in lines using mechanically coupled joints, and insulating couplings may be employed at intervals to isolate some parts of the line electrically from other parts. Leads may be attached during construction to facilitate the cathodic protection installation when needed.
Corrosion Testing Many tests exist for establishing the reliability of protective coatings on metal substrates. Existing tests and standards are under continuous development, and new tests are being designed. Organizations active in the development and standardization of corrosion tests for coatings include ASTM, NACE International, the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE), the National Coil Coaters Association (NCCA), the International Standards Organization (ISO), international systems (e.g., DIN), and commercial (e.g., automotive, architectural, electronics), proprietary, and
military organizations. This section provides a brief review of the most widely used test methods including: Field tests Simulated service tests Laboratory (accelerated) tests (e.g., salt spray tests, humidity tests, and electrochemical tests) Table 5 lists selected tests used for determining the effectiveness of protective coatings in corrosive environments. More detailed information on testing of coated specimens can be found in several excellent sources. Gaynes (Ref 13) and Munger (Ref 14) give descriptions and the framework for effective use of tests and standards. Gaynes provides detailed descriptions including photographs, cross-listing ASTM to federal tests and a broader perspective encompassing the federal standard, miscellaneous tests, and some caveats of traditional testing. Munger offers practical material directed toward large structures and provides a listing based on ASTM standards. Altmayer (Ref 15) compiled a table of 13 applicable corrosion tests for 30 metallic, inorganic, and organic coating/substrate combinations. Other useful sources of information can be found in review articles by Simpson and Townsend (Ref 16) and Granata (Ref 12), which describe tests for metallic coatings and nonmetallic coatings, respectively.
Field Tests The most reliable performance data are obtained by field tests/surveys. One example would be to monitor and test the corrosion of autobody panels that sit in junkyards. Another example of in-service testing would be to monitor the behavior of the materials in a fleet of captive vehicles. This enables better control and recording of the exposure and driving conditions. The use of fleet vehicles also makes it possible to test coupons representing a larger database of materials.
Simulated Service Tests The most widely used simulated service test for static atmospheric testing is described in ASTM G 50, "Practice for Conducting Atmospheric Corrosion Tests on Metals." It is used to test coated sheet steels for a variety of outdoor applications. Test materials, which are in the form of flat test panels mounted in a test rack (Fig. 16), are subjected to the cyclic effects of the weather, geographical influences, and bacteriological factors that cannot be realistically duplicated in the laboratory. Test durations can last from several months up to many years. Some zinc-coated steel specimens have undergone testing for more than 30 years.
Table 5
Widely used tests for determining the corrosion resistance of protective coatings
Test Salt spray (ASTM B 117)
100% relative humidity (ASTM D 2247) Acetic acid-salt spray ASTM G 85, Al (formerly ASTM B 287) Sulfur dioxide-salt spray (ASTM G 85, A 4) Copper-accelerated salt spray, or CASS (ASTM B 368) FACT (formerly ASTM B 538) Accelerated weathering
Lactic acid
Acidified synthetic seawater testing or SWAAT (ASTM G 85, A3; formerly ASTM G 43)
Electrographic and chemical porosity tests
Adhesion (ASTM D 3359-90)
T-bend adhesion (ASTM D 4145)
Scab test Exterior exposure (ASTM D 1014) Service test data
Description and remarks
Most widely specified test. Atomized 5% sodium chloride (NaCl), neutral pH, 35°C (95 0F) (a), follow details of ASTM B 117, Appendix Xl. Emphasizes wet surfaces (nondrying), high oxygen availability, neutral pH, and warm conditions. Control of comparative specimens should be run simultaneously. Corrosivity consistency should be checked as described in ASTM B 117, Appendix X3. Notes: May be the most widely misused test. Requires correlation to service tests for useful results. Do not assume correlation exists. Widely used test. Condensing humidity, 100% RH, 38 0 C (100 0 F). Emphasizes sensitivity to water exposure Widely used test. Atomized 5% NaCl, pH 3.2 using acetic acid, 35 0C (95 0 F). More severe than ASTM B 117. The lower pH and the presence of acetate affect the solubility of corrosion products on and under the protective coatings. Atomized 5% NaCl, collected solution pH = 2.5-3.2, 35 0 C (95 0 F), SO2 metered (60 min • 35 cm3/min per m 3 cabinet volume) 4 times per day Atomized 5% NaCl, pH 3.2 with acetic acid, 0.025% cupric chloride-dihydrate, 35 0C (95°F). Galvanic coupling due to copper salt reduction to copper metal. More severe than ASTM B 117 Testing anodized aluminum specimens. Electrolyte as in salt spray or CASS test. Specimen is made the cathode to generate high pH at defects. Exposure of coated specimens to effects of ultraviolet radiation experienced in outdoor sunlight conditions, which may be combined with other exposures such as moisture and erosion. Exposure cabinets use carbon arc (ASTM D 822), xenon lamp (ASTM G 26), or fluorescent lamp (ASTM G 53). On substrates of brass and copper alloys, determines coatings porosity and resistance to handling (perspiration). Consists of immersion in 85% lactic acid solution, drying, and incubating above acetic acid vapors for 20 h to reveal discoloration spots at failure points or delaminations Atomized synthetic seawater (ASTM D 1141) with 10 mL glacial acetic acid per L of solution, pH 2.8 to 3.0, 35 0 C (95 0 F). More severe than ASTM B 117. The lower pH and the presence of acetate affect the solubility of corrosion products on and under the protective coatings. Pores and active defects in nonmetallic coatings can be revealed by color indication or deposit formation. On nickel substrates, dimethylglyoxime, or steel, potassium ferricyanide (ferroxyl test) indicator can be applied to surface on filter paper while substrate is made the anode. Alternatively, a substrate immersed in acidic copper sulfate can be made the cathode to form copper nodules at conductive coatings defects. Knife and fingernail test consists of cutting through the coating with knife or awl and dislodging coating with thumbnail or fingernail (pass/fail). The ASTM D 3359 test consists of "X" scribes or parallel cross-hatches followed by adhesive tape stripping of loosened coating. Combined flexibility and adhesion test consists of clamping end of coated flat metal panel in vise or similar tool bending (convex) through 90°, reclamping to bend through 180° to give "071" bend (where T is panel thickness and the numeral (0, 1, 2,...) is the number of panel thicknesses). Rebending over the 180° bend gives a IT bend. Adhesive tape is pressed down along edge of bend and any loose coating stripped off.
Cyclic testing consisting of short salt exposure, short drying period, and long period of high humidity. Undercutting from scribe is measured. Method for conducting exterior exposure tests of paints on steel. Well-defined exposure setup, not necessarily equivalent to service tests Performance data of coatings systems under use conditions. Slowest evaluation method; provides tangible results
FACT, Ford anodized aluminum corrosion test, (a) Note that dissolved CO 2 concentration at 0 0C (32 0F) is three times that of concentration at 35 0 C (95 0F) and can affect corrosion. Source: Ref 12
Flg. 1 6 Atmospheric corrosion test rack Salt Spray Tests
As indicated in Table 6, salt spray testing is the most popular form of testing for protective coatings. These tests have been used for more than 90 years as accelerated tests in order to determine the degree of protection afforded by both inorganic and organic coatings on a metallic base. Table 5 lists several widely used salt spray tests. The neutral salt-spray (fog) test (ASTM B 117—Method 811.1 of Federal Test Method 151b) is perhaps the most commonly used salt spray test in existence for testing inorganic and organic coatings, especially where such tests are used for material or product specifications. The duration of this test can range from 8 to 3000 h, depending on the product type of coating. A 5% sodium chloride (NaCl) solution that does not contain more than 200 ppm total solids and with a pH range of 6.5 to 7.2 when atomized is used. The temperature of the salt spray cabinet is controlled to maintain 35 + 1.1 or -1.7 0C (95 + 2 or - 3 0F) within the exposure zone of the closed cabinet. The acetic acid-salt spray (fog) test (ASTM G 85, Annex Al; Former Method B 287) is also used for testing inorganic and organic coatings but is particularly applicable to the study or testing of decorative chromium Table 6 Results of a survey to determine the most widely used tests for protective coatings Test Salt spray Immersion Outdoor Ultraviolet/condensation Accelerated/weathering Humidity/condensation Cathodic disbondment Adhesion Atlas cell test (NACE TMO174) Other physical tests Other chemical tests Flexibility
% respondents(a) 52 24 22 20 14 10 7 7 4 4 3 2
(a) Multiple tests used (total greater than 100%). Source: Ref 12
plate (nickel-chromium or copper-nickel-chromium) plating and cadmium plating on steel or zinc die castings and for the evaluation of the quality of a product. This test can be as brief as 16 h, although it normally ranges from 144 to 240 h or more. As in the neutral salt spray test, a 5% NaCl solution is used, but the solution is adjusted to a pH range of 3.1 to 3.3 by the addition of acetic acid, and again, the temperature of the salt spray cabinet is controlled to maintain 35 + 1.1 or -1.7 0C (95 + 2 or - 3 0F) within the exposure zone of the closed cabinet. The copper-accelerated acetic acid-salt spray (fog) test (CASS test), which is covered in ASTM B 368, is primarily used for the rapid testing of decorative copper-nickel-chromium or nickel-chromium plating on steel and zinc die castings. It is also useful in the testing of anodized, chromated, or phosphated aluminum. The duration of this test ranges from 6 to 720 h. A 5% NaCl solution is used, with 1 g of copper II chloride (CuCl2-2H2O) added to each 3.8 L of salt solution. The solution is then adjusted to a pH range of 3.1 to 3.3 by adding acetic acid. The temperature of the CASS cabinet is controlled to maintain 4 9 + 1 . 1 or —1.7 0C (120 + 2 or —3 0F) within the exposure zone of the closed cabinet. Humidity Cabinet Tests In a humidity cabinet the humidity is raised to a value chosen as appropriate to the material under test. The temperature is generally cycled, so that the specimen is exposed to alternating humid air and condensation. The apparatus is automated to ensure that conditions are controlled within narrow limits. Other corrodent materials, such as sulfur dioxide, may also be introduced. Examples of humidity cabinet tests include ASTM D 2247 and ASTM G 85 listed in Table 5. Electrochemical Tests Corrosion of metallic substances is an electrochemical process. An alternate approach to field or other accelerated tests in understanding and predicting metallic corrosion is the use of electrochemical parameters/ tests. Electrochemical tests often complement other test methods by providing kinetic and mechanistic data that would be otherwise difficult to obtain. Electrochemical tests are typically grouped as direct current (dc) or alternating current (ac) methods based on the type of perturbation signal that is applied in making the measurements. A number of investigators have used dc and ac electrochemical methods to study the performance and the quality of protective coatings, including passive films on metallic substrates, and to evaluate the effectiveness of various surface pretreatments. Several are discussed below.
Anodized Aluminum Corrosion Test. One such method is the Ford anodized aluminum corrosion test (FACT) listed in Table 5. This test involves the cathodic polarization of the anodized aluminum surface by using a small cylindrical glass clamp-on cell and a special 5% NaCl solution containing cupric chloride (CuCl2) acidified with acetic acid. A large voltage is applied across the cell by using a platinum auxiliary electrode. The alkaline conditions created by the cathodic polarization promote dissolution at small defects in the anodized aluminum. The coating resistance is decreased, more current begins to flow, and the voltage decreases. The cell voltage (auxiliary electrode to test specimen voltage) is monitored for 3 min, and the parameter cell voltage multiplied by time is recorded. A similar test, known as the cathodic breakdown test, involves cathodic polarization to -1.6 V (versus saturated calomel electrode, SCE) for a period of 3 min in acidified NaCl. Again, the test was designed for anodized aluminum alloys because the alkali created at the large applied currents will promote the formation of corroded spots at defects in the anodized film. The electrolytic corrosion test was designed for electrodeposits of principally nickel and chromium on less noble metals, such as zinc or steel. Special solutions are used, and the metal is polarized to +0.3 V versus the SCE. The metal is taken through cycles of 1 min anodically polarized and 2 min unpolarized. An indicator solution is then used to detect the presence of pits that penetrate to the substrate. Each exposure cycle simulates 1 year of exposure under atmospheric-corrosion conditions. The ASTM standard B 627 describes the method in greater detail. The paint adhesion on a scribed surface (PASS) test involves the cathodic polarization of a small portion of painted metal. The area exposed contains a scribed line that exposes a line of underlying bare metal. The sample is cathodically polarized for 15 min in 5% NaCl. At the end of this period, the amount of delaminated coating is determined from an adhesive tape pulling procedure. The impedance test for anodized aluminum (ASTM B 457) is used to study the seal performance of anodized aluminum. In this sense, the test is similar to the FACT test, except that this method uses a 1 V root mean square 1 kHz signal source from an impedance bridge to determine the sealed anodized aluminum impedance. The test area is again defined with a portable cell, and a platinum or stainless steel auxiliary electrode is typically used. The sample is immersed in 3.5% NaCl. The impedance is determined in ohms X 103. In contrast to the methods discussed previously, this test is essentially nondestructive and does not accelerate the corrosion process. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) offers an advanced method of evaluating the performance of metallic coatings (passive film forming or otherwise) and organic barrier coatings. The method does not accelerate the corrosion reaction and is nondestructive. The technique is
quite sensitive to changes in the resistive-capacitive nature of coatings. The technique has been used to evaluate phosphate coverage/stability on galvanneal, painted cold-rolled steel, electrogalvanized steel, and electrogal vannealed steel (Ref 16). It is also possible to monitor the corrosion rate with this technique. In this respect, the electrochemical impedance technique offers several advantages over dc electrochemical techniques in that the polarization resistance related to the corrosion rate can be separated from the high dc resistance of the dielectric coating. This is not possible with the dc methods.
References 1. Corrosion of Steels in Waters, ASM Specialty Handbook: Carbon and Alloys Steels, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 1996, p 408-429 2. Corrosion of Steels in Soils, ASM Specialty Handbook: Carbon and Alloys Steels, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 1996, p 430-438 3. Corrosion of Steels in Chemical Environments, ASM Specialty Handbook: Carbon and Alloys Steels, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 1996, p 439-151 4. Types of Corrosive Environments, Corrosion: Understanding the Basics, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 2000, p 193-236 5. Atmospheric Corrosion of Steels, ASM Specialty Handbook: Carbon and Alloys Steels, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 1996, p 393^07 6. Forms of Corrosion: Recognition and Prevention, Corrosion: Understanding the Basics, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 2000, p 99-192 7. Corrosion Control by Proper Design, Corrosion: Understanding the Basics, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 2000, p 301-362 8. H.M. Herro and R.D. Port, Cavitation Damage, The Nalco Guide to Cooling Water System Failure Analysis, McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1993, p 270-271 9. R.B. Waterhouse, Fretting Wear, Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology, VoI 18, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1992, p 242-256 10. Intergranular and Exfoliation Corrosion, Corrosion of Aluminum and Aluminum Alloys, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 1999, p 63-74 11. R.N. Parkins, An Overview—Prevention and Control of StressCorrosion Cracking, Mater. Perform., VoI 24, 1995, p 9-20 12. R.D. Granata, Nonmetallic Coatings, Corrosion Tests and Standards: Application and Interpretation, R. Baboian, Ed., ASTM, 1995, p 525-530 13. N.I. Gaynes, Testing of Organic Coatings, Noyes Data Corp., 1977
14. CG. Munger, Corrosion Prevention by Protective Coatings, National Association of Corrosion Engineers, 1984, Chapter 12 15. F. Altmayer, "Choosing an Accelerated Corrosion Test," Met. Finish., 61st Guidebook and Directory Issue, VoI 91 (No. IA), Jan 1993, p 483 16. T.C. Simpson and H.E. Townsend, Metallic Coatings, Corrosion Tests and Standards: Application and Interpretation, R. Baboian, Ed., ASTM, 1995, p 513-524 Selected References Corrosion, VoI 13, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1987 Corrosion Basics—An Introduction, L.S. Van Delinder, Ed., NACE International, 1984 Corrosion: Understanding the Basics, J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 2000 M.G. Fontana, Corrosion Engineering, 3rd ed., McGraw-Hill, 1986 H.H. Uhlig and R.W. Revie, Corrosion and Corrosion Control, 3rd ed., John Wiley & Sons, 1985
CHAPTER
4 J
P r i n c i p l e s a n d
o f W
F r i c t i o n e
a
r
FRICTION, WEAR, AND LUBRICATION are complex, interwoven subjects that may all affect the service life of a component or the efficient operation of a machine. While all three are important factors, the major emphasis in this Chapter will be on wear and the various methods used to reduce or prevent it, including the application of surface engineering treatments. More detailed information on the science and technology of friction, wear, and lubrication—known as tribology—can be found in Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology, Volume 18 of the ASM Handbook Friction Friction is the resistance to motion when two bodies in contact are forced to move relative to each other. It is closely associated with any wear mechanisms that may be operating and with any lubricant and/or surface films that may be present, as well as the surface topographies. The heat generated as a result of the dissipation of frictional interaction may affect the performance of lubricants, may change the properties of the contacting materials and/or their surface films, and, in some cases, may change the properties of the product being processed. Any of these results of frictional heating can cause severe safety problems because of the danger of mechanical failure of components due to structural weakening, severe wear (for example, seizure), or fire and explosion. In moving machinery, friction is responsible for dissipation and loss of much energy. It has been estimated, for example, that 10% of oil consumption in the United States is used simply to overcome friction. The energy lost to friction is an energy input that must continually be provided in order to maintain the sliding motion. This energy is dissipated in the
system, primarily as heat—which may have to be removed by cooling to avoid damage and may limit the conditions under which the machinery can be operated. Some of the energy is dissipated in various deformation processes, which result in wear of the sliding surfaces and their eventual degradation to the point where replacement of whole components becomes necessary. Wear of sliding surfaces adds another, very large component to the economic importance of friction, because without sliding friction, these surfaces would not wear. The need to control friction is the driving force behind its study. In many cases low friction is desired (bearings, gears, materials processing operations), and sometimes, high friction is the goal (brakes, clutches, screw threads, road surfaces). In all of these cases, constant, reproducible, and predictable friction values are necessary for the design of components and machines that will function efficiently and reliably. Important Terms and Concepts. It is useful to clearly separate the various terms and concepts associated with friction, such as "friction force," "friction coefficient," "frictional energy," and "frictional heating." These terms are defined subsequently in the context of solid friction, which can be defined as "the resistance to movement of one solid body over another." The movement may be by sliding or by rolling. The friction force is the tangential force that must be overcome in order for one solid contacting body to slide over another. It acts in the plane of the surfaces and is usually proportional to the force normal to the surfaces, N, or: (EqI) The proportionality constant is generally designated |JL or/and is termed the friction coefficient; which is the ratio between the friction force, F, and the load, N: (Eq 2) The friction coefficient typically ranges from 0.03 for a very well lubricated bearing, to 0.5 to 0.7 for dry sliding, and even >5 for clean metal surfaces in a vacuum. A JUL-value of 0.2 to 0.3 allows for comfortable walking; however, walking on ice is very difficult because the JUL-value for the ice/shoe pair may be <0.05, and a slippery floor may have a jx-value of 0.15. Nature has provided highly efficient lubrication to another component of walking, the knee joint which has a |ji-value of 0.02. In most cases, a greater force is needed to set a resting body in motion than to sustain the motion; in other words, the static coefficient of friction, juLs, is usually somewhat greater than the dynamic or kinetic coefficient of friction, juik.
A body of weight W on a flat surface will begin to move when the surface is tilted to a certain angle termed the friction angle, 6, as defined in Fig. 1. The static friction coefficient is given by: (Eq 3) This represents a simple way to measure |xs, but force measurements are more generally used to measure both the static and the dynamic, or kinetic, coefficients of friction. The results obtained from these measurements do, however, depend on the nature and cleanliness of the surfaces and also to some extent on the various characteristics of the measuring system. This dependence underscores the basic fact that the friction coefficient is not a unique, clearly defined materials property, as may become evident from the following discussion on "Basic Mechanisms of Friction." To overcome friction, the tangential force must be applied over the entire sliding distance; the product of the two is friction work. The resulting energy is lost to heat in the form of frictional heating and to other general increases in the entropy of the system, as represented, for example, in the permanent deformation of the surface material. Thus, friction is clearly a process of energy dissipation. Basic Mechanisms of Friction. Surfaces are not completely flat at the microscopic level. At high magnification, even the best polished surface will show ridges and valleys, asperities, and depressions. When two surfaces are brought together, they touch intimately only at the tips of a few asperities. At these points, the contact pressure may be close to the hardness of the softer material; plastic deformation takes place on a very local scale. Cold welding may form strongly bonded junctions between the two materials. When sliding begins, these junctions have to be broken by the friction force, and this provides the adhesive component of the friction. Some asperities may plow across the surface of the mating material, and
Body
(b) (a) FlC. 1 Incl|ned plane used to determine coefficient of static friction, (JLS. (a) Tilting flat surface ^* through smallest angle, 0, needed to initiate movement of the body down the plane. (b) Relation of the friction angle to the principal applied forces
the resulting plastic deformation or elastic hysteresis contributes to the friction force. Additional contributions may be due to wear by debris particles that become trapped between the sliding surfaces. Because so many mechanisms are involved in generating the friction force, it is clear that friction is not a unique materials property, but instead depends to some extent on the measuring conditions, on the surface roughness, on the presence or absence of oxides or adsorbed films, and so on. In spite of this complexity, the values of JUL obtained by different methods and by different laboratories tend to fall into ranges that are representative of the material pair in question under reasonably similar conditions; that is, values obtained by different laboratories tend to fall within —20 to 30% of each other if the testing conditions are generally similar. It is important, however, to understand that the values of JUL listed in this Chapter are intended only to provide rough guidelines and that more exact values, if needed, must be obtained from direct measurements on the system in question under its typical operating conditions. The deformation at asperities and junctions is extremely localized, and very high temperatures may therefore be generated over very short periods of time. At these local hot spots, rapid oxidation, plastic flow, or interdiffusion can take place, and these all affect the wear process. In some cases, sparks may even form. The temperatures obtained depend on how fast heat is generated (that is, on the operating conditions of load and velocity) and on how fast heat is removed (that is, on the thermal properties of the sliding surfaces). These temperatures can be calculated with some degree of certainty, as shown in Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology, Volume 18 of the ASM Handbook (see pages 39 to 44). Friction Coefficients for Selected Materials. The friction coefficient between solids sliding, or about to slide, over one another under the influence of a nonzero normal force is a function of several factors whose relative contributions vary on a case-by-case basis: Composition of the materials Surface finish of each solid Nature of the surrounding environment Force holding the solids in contact (load) Velocity of relative motion Nature of the relative motion (for example, unidirectional, back and forth, steady, variable, and so on) Nature of the contact (conforming versus nonconforming surfaces) Temperature of the interfacial region Prior sliding history of the surfaces Characteristics of the machine and fixtures in which the materials are affixed No single source has generated a comprehensive list of friction coefficients for materials under identical testing conditions; therefore, nearly all
existing handbooks rely on compilations of data produced under a variety of testing conditions. Readers should he aware of this shortcoming and use the values only as very approximate guides, unless their applications are exactly the same as those methods used in generating the data. The five tables of friction coefficient values in this Chapter contain both static and kinetic friction coefficients. They are arranged by material type as follows: Table 1: metals on metals Table 2: ceramics on various materials Table 3: polymers on various materials Table 4: coatings on various materials Table 5: miscellaneous materials Table 1 Friction coefficient data for metals sliding on metals and corresponding references and test conditions Metals tested in air at room temperature Material Fixed specimen Ag
Al Al, alloy 6061-T6
Au Brass, 60Cu-40Zn Cd Co Cr Cu
Cu, OFHC Fe
In Mg Mo
Friction coefficient
Moving specimen
Test geometry(a)
Ag Au Cu Fe Al Ti Al, alloy 6061-T6 Cu Steel, 1032 Ti-6A1-4V Ag Au Steel, tool Cd Fe Co Cr Co Cr Co Cr Cu Fe Ni Zn Steel, 4619 Co Cr Fe
IS IS IS IS IS IS FOF FOF FOF FOF IS IS POR IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS BOR IS IS IS
0.50 0.53 0.48 0.49 0.57 0.54 0.42 0.28 0.35 0.34 0.53 0.49
Mg Mo Ti W Zn In Mg Fe Mo
IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS
0.51 0.46 0.49 0.47 0.55 1.46 0.69 0.46 0.44
Static
0.79 0.52 0.56 0.41 0.41 0.46 0.44 0.46 0.55 0.50 0.49 0.56
Kinetic
0.34 0.23 0.25 0.29
0.24
0.41 0.48 0.51
0.82
Ref 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
(continued) (a) Test geometry codes: BOR, flat block pressed against the cylindrical surface of a rotating ring; FOF, flat surface sliding on another flat surface; IS, sliding down an inclined surface; POR, pin sliding against the cylindrical surface of a rotating ring; RSOF, reciprocating, spherically ended pin on a flat surface; SPOF, spherically ended pin on a flat coupon
Table 1
(continued) Material
Fixed specimen Nb Ni
Pb
Pt Sn Steel Steel, 1020 Steel, 1032
Steel, 52100
Steel, mild Steel, M50 tool Steel, stainless Steel, stainless 304 Stellite Ti
Ti-6A1-4V
W
Zn
Zr
Moving specimen
Test geometry(a)
Nb Cr Ni Pt Ag Au Co Cr Fe Pb Steel Ni Pt Fe Sn Cu Pb Steel, 4619 Al, alloy 6061-T6 Cu Steel, 1032 Ti-6A1-4V Ni3Al, alloy IC-396M Ni3Al, alloy IC-50 Steel, 1015 annealed Steel, dual-phase DP-80 Steel, O2 tool Steel, mild Ni3Al, alloy IC-50 Steel, tool Cu Steel, tool Al Steel, 17-4 stainless Ti Ti Ti-6A1-4V Al, alloy 6061-T6 Cu-Al (bronze) Nitronic 60 Steel, 17-4 stainless Steel, Type 440C stainless Stellite 12 Stellite 6 Ta Ti-6A1-4V Ti-6A1-4V Cu Fe W Cu Fe Zn Zr
IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS IS SPOF IS IS IS IS SPOF SPOF BOR FOF FOF FOF FOF RSOF RSOF BOR BOR BOR BOR RSOF POR FOF POR IS POF POF FOF POF FOF POF POF POF POF POF POF POF FOF POF IS IS IS IS IS IS IS
Reference
Friction coefficient Static
Kinetic
Ref
0.46 0.59 0.50 0.64 0.73 0.61 0.55 0.53 0.54 0.90 0.80 0.64 0.55 0.55 0.74
0.47 0.32 0.31 0.36
0.23 0.54 0.48 0.47 0.55 0.43 0.41 0.36 0.38 0.36 0.44 0.35 0.45 0.53 0.36 0.36 0.41 0.47 0.51 0.56 0.55 0.75 0.63
0.80 1.40 0.54 0.38 0.25 0.23 0.32 1.08 0.70 0.74 0.55 0.49 0.62 0.68 0.53 0.21 0.60 0.48 0.40 0.36 0.38 0.27 0.31 0.31 0.37 0.29 0.36 0.53 0.30 0.31
1 1 5 5 4 2 2 2 2 6 6 7 7 7 3 6 3 2 3 1 8 8 1 8 2 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 2 8 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Test condition
1. E. Rabinowicz, ASLE Trans., VoI 14, 1971, p 198 2. "Friction Data Guide," General Magnaplate Corporation, 1988
Plate sliding on plate at 50% relative humidity TMI Model 98-5 slip and friction tester, 1.96 N (0.200 kgf) load, ground specimens, 54% relative humidity, average of five tests 3. J.F. Archard, ASME Wear Control Handbook, M.B. Peterson and W.O. Pin-on-rotating ring, 3.9 N (0.40 kgf) load, 1.8 m/s (350 ft/min) velocity Winer, Ed., American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 1980, p 38 4. A. W. Ruff, L.K. Ives, and W. A. Glaeser, Fundamentals of Friction Flat block-on-rotating 35 mm (1 3/8 in.) diameter ring, ION (1.02 kgf) and Wear of Materials, ASM International, 1981, p 235 load, 0.2 m/s (40 ft/min) velocity 5. F.P. Bowden and D. Tabor, The Friction and Lubrication of Solids, Sphere-on-flat, unspecified load and velocity Oxford Press, 1986, p 127 6. RJ. Blau and CE. DeVore, Tribol, Int., VoI 23 (No. 4), 1990, p 226 Reciprocating ball-on-flat, 10 Hz, 25 N (2.6 kgf) load, 10 mm stroke 7. RJ. Blau, J. Tribology, VoI 107, 1985, p 483 Flat block-on-rotating 35 mm (1 3/s in.) diameter ring, 133 N (13.6 kgf) load, 5.0 cm/s (2.0 in./s) velocity 8. K.G. Budinski, Proceedings of Wear of Materials, American Society Modified ASTM G 98 galling test procedure of Mechanical Engineers, 1991, p 289 (a) Test geometry codes: BOR, flat block pressed against the cylindrical surface of a rotating ring; FOF, flat surface sliding on another flat surface; IS, sliding down an inclined surface; POR, pin sliding against the cylindrical surface of a rotating ring; RSOF, reciprocating, spherically ended pin on a flat surface; SPOF, spherically ended pin on a flat coupon
It should be emphasized that the data in the tables are for unlubricated solids at room temperature and in ambient air. The references provided with each table list both the sources of the data for the table and a brief description of the testing conditions used to generate these data, if such information was available in the reference. If accurate friction information is required for a specific application, the use of carefully simulated Table 2 Friction coefficient data for ceramics sliding on various materials and corresponding references and test conditions Specm i ens tested in air at room temperature Material Fixed specimen
Ag Al Alumina
Boron carbide Cr Cu Fe Glass, tempered
Silicon carbide
Silicon nitride
Steel, M50 tool
Ti Tungsten carbide
Moving specimen
Test geometry(a)
Alumina Zirconia Alumina Zirconia Alumina Alumina Alumina WRA(b) WRZTA(c) ZTA(d) Boron carbide Alumina Zirconia Alumina Zirconia Alumina Zirconia Al, alloy 6061-T6 Steel, 1032 Teflon(e) Silicon carbide Silicon nitride Silicon nitride Silicon nitride Silicon carbide Silicon carbide Silicon carbide Silicon nitride Boron carbide Silicon carbide Silicon nitride Tungsten carbide Alumina Zirconia Tungsten carbide
RPOF RPOF RPOF RPOF SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD POD RPOF RPOF RPOF RPOF RPOF RPOF FOF FOF FOF SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD POD POD POD POD RPOF RPOF POD
Reference
1. K. Demizu, R. Wadabayashim, and H. Ishigaki, Tribol. Trans., VoI 33 (No. 4), 1990, p 505 2. PJ. Blau, Oak Ridge National Laboratory 3. RJ. Blau, Oak Ridge National Laboratory 4. RJ. Blau, Oak Ridge National Laboratory 5. C S . Yust, Tribology of Composite Materials, RK. Rohatgi, PJ. Blau, and CS. Yust, Ed., ASM International, 1990, p 27 6. B. Bhushan and B.K. Gupta, table in Handbook of Tribology, McGraw-Hill, 1991 7. "Friction Data Guide," General Magnaplate Corporation, 1988
Friction coefficient Static
0.17 0.13 0.10
Kinetic
Ref
0.37 0.39 0.75 0.63 0.50 0.52 0.33 0.53 0.50 0.56 0.53 0.50 0.61 0.43 0.40 0.45 0.35 0.14 0.12 0.10 0.52 0.53 0.71 0.63 0.54 0.67 0.84 0.17 0.29 0.29 0.15 0.19 0.42 0.27 0.34
1 1 1 1 2 3 4 5 5 5 6
7 7 7 6 4 2 3 4 2 3 6 6 6 6 6 1 1 6
Test condition 1.5 mm (0.06 in.) radius pin reciprocating on a flat, 4 N (0.4 kgf) load, 0.17 mm/s (0.0067 in./s) velocity, 50% relative humidity 1.0 N (0.10 kgf) load and 0.1 m/s (20 ft/min) velocity 10 N (1.0 kgf) load and 0.1 m/s (20 ft/min) velocity 9.5 mm (3/8 in.) diameter sphere-on-disk, 2 to 9 N (0.2 to 0.9 kgf) load, 0.3 m/s (60 ft/min) velocity 20 N (2.0 kgf), 3 mm/s (0.12 in./s) velocity TMI Model 98-5 slip and friction tester, 1.96 N (0.200 kgf) load, ground specimens, 54% relative humidity, average of five tests
(a) Test geometry codes: FOF, flat surface sliding on another flat surface; POD, pin-on-disk (pin-tip geometry not given); RPOF, reciprocating pin-on-flat; SPOD, spherically ended pin-on-flat disk; SPOF, spherically ended pin on a flat coupon, (b) WRA, silicon carbide whisker-reinforced alumina, (c) WRZTA, silicon carbide whisker-reinforced, zirconia-toughened alumina, (d) ZTA, zirconia-toughened alumina, (e) Teflon, polytetrafluoroethylene
Table 3 Friction coefficient data for polymers sliding on various materials and corresponding references and test conditions Specimens tested in air at room temperature Material(a) Fixed specimen
Friction coefficient Moving specimen
Test geometry(b)
Static
Kinetic
Ref
0.06 0.06 0.80 0.17 0.50 0.20 0.04 0.08
0.07 0.07
1 1 2 1 2 2 2 3
Polymers sliding on polymers Acetal Nylon 6/6 PMMA Polyester PBT Polystyrene Polyethylene Teflon
TW TW NSp TW NSp NSp NSp FOF
Acetal Nylon 6/6 PMMA Polyester PBT Polystyrene Polyethylene Teflon Teflon
0.07
Dissimilar pairs with the polymer as the fixed specimen Nylon 6 (cast) (extruded) Nylon 6/6 Nylon 6/6 (+ PTFE) PA 66 PA 66 (+ 15% PTFE) PA 66 (PTFE/glass) PEEK PEEK (+ 15% PTFE) PEEK (PTFE/glass) PEI PEI (+ 15% PTFE) PEI (PTFE/glass) PETP PETP (+ 15% PTFE) PETP (PTFE/glass) Polyurethane(c) Polyurethane(d) POM POM (+ 15% PTFE) POM (PTFE/glass) PPS PPS (+ 15% PTFE) PPS (PTFE/glass) Teflon
UHMWPE
0.24
Steel, mild Steel, mild Polycarbonate Steel, mild Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, mild Steel, mild Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Steel, 52100 Al, alloy 6061-T6 Cr plate Cu Ni (0.001 P) Steel, 1032 Ti-6A1-4V TiN (Magnagold) Steel, mild
TPOD TPOD TW TPOD BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR TPOD TPOD BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR BOR FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF TOPD
0.25
0.24 0.09 0.13 0.15 0.27 0.17 0.15
0.35 0.37 0.04 0.35 0.57 0.13 0.31 0.49 0.18 0.20 0.43 0.21 0.21 0.68 0.14 0.18 0.51 0.35 0.45 0.21 0.23 0.70 0.30 0.39 0.19 0.08 0.11 0.12 0.27 0.14 0.12 0.14
4 4 1 4 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 4 4 5 5 5 5 5 5 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 4
0.27 0.35 0.16 0.21 0.31 0.25 0.23 0.28 0.60 0.32 0.37 0.26 0.38 0.28 0.38 0.31
6 1 1 1 7 7 6 6 7 1 6 1 6 1 6 1
Dissimilar pairs with the polymer as the moving specimen Steel, carbon Steel, mild
Steel, 52100 Steel, carbon Steel, 52100 Steel, mild Steel, carbon Steel, mild Steel, carbon Steel, mild Steel, carbon Steel, mild
POF TW TW TW POD POD POF POF POD TW POF TW POF TW POF TW
ABS resin ABS ABS + 15% PTFE Acetal Acetal HDPE HDPE LDPE Lexan 101 Nylon (amorphous) Nylon 6 Nylon 6 Nylon 6/6 Nylon 6/6 Nylon 6/10 Nylon 6/10
0.40 0.30 0.13 0.14
0.36 0.48 0.23 0.54 0.22 0.53 0.20 0.53 0.23
(continued) (a) ABS, acrylonitrile butadiene styrene; HDPE, high-density polyethylene; LPDE, low-density polyethylene; Lexan, trademark of the General Electric Co. (polycarbonate); nylon, one of a group of polyamide resins (see also PA); PA, polyamide; PBT, polybutylene terephthalate; PEEK, polyetheretherketone; PEI, polyetherimide; PETP, polyethylene terephthalate; PMMA, polymethylmethacrylate; POM, polyoxymethylene; PPS, polyphenylene sulphide; PTFE, polytetrafluoroethylene; PVC, polyvinyl chloride; UHMWPE, ultra high molecular weight polyethylene; Magnagold, product of General Magnaplate, Inc.; Teflon, trademark of E.I. Du Pont de Nemours & Co., Inc. (PTFE). (b) Test geometry codes: BOR, flat block-on-rotating ring; FOF, flat surface sliding on another flat surface; NSp, not specified; POD, pin-on-disk; POF, pin-on-flat; TPOD, triple pin-on-disk; TW, thrust washer test, (c) Green polyurethane. (d) Cream-colored polyurethane
Table 3
(continued) Friction coefficient
Material(a) Fixed specimen
Steel, Steel, Steel, Steel,
Moving specimen
Test geometry(b)
Nylon 6/12 PEEK (Victrex) Phenol formaldehyde PMMA PMMA Polycarbonate Polyesther PBT Polyethylene Polyimide Polyoxylmethylene Polypropylene Polypropylene Polystyrene Polystyrene Polysulfone PVC PTFE Teflon Teflon Teflon Teflon Teflon Teflon Teflon
carbon 52100 carbon mild
Steel, carbon Steel, mild Steel, carbon Steel, mild Steel, carbon Al, alloy 6061-T6 Cr plate Glass, tempered Ni (0.001 P) Steel, 1032 Ti-6A1-4V TiN (Magnagold)
TW TW POF POD POF TW TW TW POF POF POF TW POF TW TW POF POF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF
Static
Kinetic
Ref
0.24 0.20 0.51
0.31 0.25 0.44 0.68 0.50 0.38 0.25 0.13 0.34 0.17 0.26 0.11 0.37 0.32 0.37 0.38 0.09 0.18 0.19 0.10 0.19 0.16 0.21 0.11
1 1 6 7 6
0.64 0.31 0.19 0.09 0.46 0.30 0.36 0.08 0.43 0.28 0.29 0.53 0.37 0.19 0.21 0.10 0.22 0.18 0.23 0.16
1 1 6 6 6 1 6 1 1 6 6 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Test condition
Reference 1. "Lubricomp Internally-Lubricated Reinforced Thermoplastics and Fluoropolymer Composites," Bulletin 254-688, ICI Advanced Materials 2. RP. Bowden and D. Tabor, Appendix IV, The Friction and Lubrication of Solids, Oxford Press, 1986 3. "Friction Data Guide," General Magnaplate Corporation, 1988 4. J.M. Thorp, Tribol Int., VoI 15 (No. 2), 1982, p 69 5. J.W.M. Mens and A.W.J. de Gee, Wear, VoI 149, 1991, p 255 6. R.P. Steijn, Metall Eng. Quart, VoI 7, 1967, p 9 7. N.P. Suh, Tribophysics, Prentice-Hall, 1986, p 226
Thrust washer apparatus, 0.28 MPa (40 psi), 0.25 m/s (50 ft/min), after running-in for one full rotation Unspecified testing conditions TMI Model 98-5 slip and friction tester, 1.96 N (0.200 kgf) load, ground specimens, 54% relative humidty, average of five tests Three pin-on-rotating disk apparatus, 0.1 m/s (20 ft/min) Flat block-on-rotating ring, 1.5 MPa (0.22 ksi) pressure, 150 N (15 kgf) load, 0.1 m/s (20 ft/min) velocity 12.7 mm (0.500 in.) diameter ball-on-flat, 9.8 N (1.0 kgf) load, 0.01 mm/s (4 X 10"4 in./s) velocity Pin-on-disk, 4.4 N (0.45 kgf) load, 3.3 cm/s (1.3 in./s) velocity, 65% relative humidity
(a) ABS, acrylonitrile butadiene styrene; HDPE, high-density polyethylene; LPDE, low-density polyethylene; Lexan, trademark of the General Electric Co. (polycarbonate); nylon, one of a group of polyamide resins (see also PA); PA, polyamide; PBT, polybutylene terephthalate; PEEK, polyetheretherketone; PEI, polyetherimide; PETP, polyethylene terephthalate; PMMA, polymethylmethacrylate; POM, polyoxymethylene; PPS, polyphenylene sulphide; PTFE, polytetrafluoroethylene; PVC, polyvinyl chloride; UHMWPE, ultra high molecular weight polyethylene; Magnagold, product of General Magnaplate, Inc.; Teflon, trademark of E.I. Du Pont de Nemours & Co., Inc. (PTFE). (b) Test geometry codes: BOR, flat block-on-rotating ring; FOF, flat surface sliding on another flat surface; NSp, not specified; POD, pin-on-disk; POF, pin-on-flat; TPOD, triple pin-on-disk; TW, thrust washer test, (c) Green polyurethane. (d) Cream-colored polyurethane
Table 4
Friction coefficient data for coatings sliding on various materials
Specimens tested in air at room temperature Material
Fixed specimen Al, alloy 6061-T6
Au, electroplate
Friction coefficient Moving specimen
Test geometry(a)
Cr plate Ni (0.001 P) plate TiN (Magnagold)(c) 60Pd-40Ag, plate 60Pd-40Au, plate 70Au-30Ag, plate
FOF FOF FOF POF POF POF
Static
Kinetic
Ref
0.27 0.33 0.25
0.22 0.25 0.22 2.40 0.30 3.00
1 1 2 2 2
(continued) (a) Ams, Amsler circumferential, rotating disk-on-disk machine; FOF, flat surface sliding on another flat surface; POD, pin-on-disk; POF, pin-on-flat; SPOD, spherically ended pin-on-flat disk, (b) Teflon is a registered trademark of E.I. Du Pont de Nemours & Co., Inc. (polytetrafluoroethylene). (c) Magnagold is a product of General Magnaplate, Inc. (d) CVD, chemical vapor deposition
Table 4 (continued) Material Fixed specimen
Au, electroplate (continued)
Cr plate
Niobium carbide, coating Ni (0.001 P) plate
Steel
Steel, 1032
Steel, type 440C stainless Steel, bearing
Steel, stainless
Teflon(b)
TiC on type 44OC stainless steel
TiN on type 440C stainless steel
TiN (Magnagold)(c)
Friction coefficient Moving specimen
80Pd-20Au, plate 99Au-I Co, plate Au plate Au-0.6 Co, plate Pd plate Al, alloy 6061-T6 Ni (0.001 P) plate Steel, 1032 Teflon(b) Ti-6A1-4V Niobium carbide, coating Al, alloy 6061-T6 Cr plate Ni (0.001 P) plate Steel, 1032 Steel, D2 tool Teflon(b) TiN (Magnagold)(c) Cu film on steel In film on Ag In film on steel Pb film on Cu Cr plate Ni (0.001 P) plate TiN (MagnagoldXc) TiC on type 304 stainless TiN on type 304 stainless Chrome carbide SiC(CVD)(d) TiC(CVD)(d) TiN(CVD)(d) Al2O3, plasma-sprayed Cr plate Cr2O3, plasma-sprayed TiO2, plasma-sprayed WC-12 Co, plasma-sprayed Cr plate Ni (0.001 P) plate TiN (Magnagold)(c) Al Ti TiC on type 440C stainless steel TiN on type 440C stainless steel Al Steel, type 304 stainless Ti TiC on type 440C stainless steel TiN on type 440C stainless steel Al, alloy 6061-T6 Steel, 1032 Teflon(b) Ti-6A1-4V TiN (MagnagoldXc)
Reference 1. "Friction Data Guide," General Magnaplate Corporation, 1988 2. M. Antler and E.T. Ratcliff, Proceedings of the Holm Conference on Electrical Contacts, 1982, p 19 3. MJ. Manjoine, Bearing and Seal Design in Nuclear Power Machinery, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 1967 4. FP. Bowden and D. Tabor, The Friction and Lubrication of Solids, Oxford Press, 1986, p 127 5. B. Bhushan and B.K. Gupta, Handbook ofTribology, McGrawHill, 1991, Table 14.16a 6. B. Bhushan and B.K. Gupta, Handbook ofTribology, McGrawHill, 1991, Table 14.65 7. B. Bhushan and B.K. Gupta, Handbook ofTribology, McGrawHill, 1991, Table 14.12
Test geometry(a)
Static
Kinetic
Ref
POF POF POF POF POF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF SPOD SPOD SPOD SPOD FOF FOF FOF POD POD POD POD POD POD Ams Ams Ams Ams Ams FOF FOF FOF POD POD POD POD POD POD POD POD POD FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF
... ... ... ... ... 0.20 0.19 0.20 0.21 0.38 0.19 0.26 0.41 0.32 0.35 0.43 0.22 0.33 0.30 0.10 0.08 0.18 0.25 0.37 0.31 0.12 0.50 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 0.09 0.15 0.15 0.50 0.65 0.22 0.25 0.27 0.29 0.50 0.05 0.65 0.30 0.38 0.16 0.26 0.25
1.80 2.40 2.80 0.40 0.60 0.19 0.17 0.17 0.19 0.33 0.13 0.23 0.36 0.28 0.31 0.33 0.19 0.26 ... ... ... ... 0.21 0.30 0.28 0.17 0.75 0.79 0.23 0.25 0.49 0.13-0.30 0.30-0.38 0.14-0.15 0.10-0.15 0.11-0.13 0.08 0.12 0.12 0.85 0.80 0.20 0.20 0.40 0.41 0.76 0.06 0.45 0.26 0.31 0.11 0.23 0.21
2 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 4 4 4 1 1 1 5 5 6 6 6 6 7 7 7 7 7 1 1 1 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 1 1 1 1 1
Test condition TMI Model 98-5 slip and friction tester, 1.96 N (0.200 kgf) load, ground specimens, 54% relative humidity, average of five tests Sphere-on-reciprocating flat, 0.49 N (0.050 kgf) load, 1.0 mm/s (0.039 in./s) velocity Flat plate-on-flat plate, 28 MPa (4.1 ksi) contact pressure, 0.25 mm/s (0.010 in./s) velocity Sphere-on-flat, low-speed sliding, 39.2 N (4 kgf) load Pin-on-disk, 12 N (1.2 kgf) load, 14 to 16 cm/s (0.55 to 0.63 in./s) velocity Pin-on-disk, 5 N (0.5 kgf) load, 1.0 cm/s (0.39 in./s) velocity, 50% relative humidity Amsler disk machine, 400 rev/min, 250 N (26 kgf) load
(a) Ams, Amsler circumferential, rotating disk-on-disk machine; FOF, flat surface sliding on another flat surface; POD, pin-on-disk; POF, pin-on-flat; SPOD, spherically ended pin-on-flat disk, (b) Teflon is a registered trademark of E.I. Du Pont de Nemours & Co., Inc. (polytetrafluoroethylene). (c) Magnagold is a product of General Magnaplate, Inc. (d) CVD, chemical vapor deposition
Table 5
Friction coefficient data for miscellaneous materials
Specimens tested in air at room temperature Friction coefficient
Material Fixed specimen
Brick Cotton thread Diamond Explosives(b) HMX(c) PETN(d) RDX(e) Lead azide [Pb(N3)2] Silver azide (AgN3) Glass, tempered
Glass, thin fiber
Glass, clean Graphite, molded
Graphite (clean) Graphite (outgassed) Hickory wood, waxed Ice
Leather Metal Mica (cleaved) Mica (contaminated) Nylon fibers Paper, copier Sapphire Silk fibers Steel (clean) Wood (clean)
Test geometry(a)
Static
Wood Cotton thread Diamond
UnSp UnSp UnSp
0.6 0.3 0.1
Glass Glass Glass Glass Glass Al, alloy 6061-T6 Steel, 1032 Teflon(f) Brass Graphite Porcelain Steel, stainless Teflon(f) Glass (clean) Al, alloy 2024 Al, alloy 2219 Graphite, extruded Graphite, molded Inconel X-750(g) Steel, type 304 stainless Steel, type 347 stainless Graphite (clean) Graphite (outgassed) Snow Bronze Ebonite Ice Ice Ice Metal (clean) Glass (clean) Mica (cleaved) Mica (contaminated) Nylon fibers Paper, copier Sapphire Silk fibers Graphite Metals Wood (clean)
RPOF RPOF RPOF RPOF RPOF FOF FOF FOF StOD StOD StOD StOD StOD UnSp FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF FOF UnSp UnSp UnSp UnSp UnSp UnSp UnSp FOF UnSp UnSp UnSp UnSp UnSp FOF UnSp UnSp UnSp UnSp UnSp
Moving specimen
Reference
1. RP. Bowden and D. Tabor, Appendix IV, The Friction and Lubrication of Solids, Oxford Press, 1986 2. J.K.A. Amuzu, BJ. Briscoe, and M.M. Chaudhri, /. Phys. D, Appl. Phys., VoI 9, 1976, p 133 3. "Friction Data Guide," General Magnaplate Corporation, 1988 4. P.K. Gupta, /. Am. Ceram. Soc, VoI 74 (No. 7), 1991, p 1692 5. MJ. Manjoine, Bearing and Seal Design in Nuclear Power Machinery, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 1967 6. F.P. Bowden and D. Tabor, The Friction and Lubrication of Solids, Oxford Press, 1986
0.17 0.13 0.10
0.9-1.0 0.16 0.22 0.20 0.18 0.16 0.18 0.19 0.10 0.5-0.8
Kinetic
1 1 1 0.55 0.40 0.35 0.28 0.40 0.14 0.12 0.10 0.16-0.26 0.15 0.36 0.31 0.10
0.17 0.14
0.14 0.02 0.02 0.05-0.15 >0.01 0.6 0.5-0.7 1.0 0.2-0.4 0.15-0.25 0.28 0.2 0.2-0.3 0.1 0.2-0.6 0.25-0.5
Ref
0.02 >0.01
2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 4 1 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 1 1 6 6 6 6 6 3
0.26
1 1 1
Test condition
Method unspecified Reciprocating, single-crystal flat sliding on smooth fired glass surfaces, range 5 to 20 gf (0.049 to 0.1962 N load), 0.20 mm/s (0.008 in./s) velocity TMI Model 98-5 slip and friction tester, 1.96 N (0.200 kgf) load, ground specimens, 54% relative humidity, average of five tests Strand lying on a rotating drum, 1.96 N (0.200 kgf) load, 8.5 mm/s (0.33 in./s) velocity Flat plate-on-flat plate, 28 MPa (4.1 ksi) contact pressure, 0.25 mm/s (0.010 in./s) velocity Unspecified method, 4.0 m/s (790 ft/min) at 0 0 C
(a) FOF, flat surface sliding on another flat surface; RPOF, reciprocating pin-on-flat; StOD, strand wrapped over a drum; UnSp, unspecified method, (b) Explosives reported here were tested as reciprocating, single-crystal, flat-ended pin-on-moving flat, (c) HMX, cyclotetramethylene tetranitramine. (d) PETN, pentaerithritol tetranitrate. (e) RDX, cyclotrimethylene trinitramine. (f) Teflon is a registered trademark of E.I. Du Pont de Nemours & Co., Inc. (g) Inconel is a product of INCO, Inc.
conditions or instrumentation of the actual machine should be conducted in lieu of using tabulated values, because even a small change in contact conditions (for example, sliding speed or relative humidity for some materials) can result in a marked change in the measured or apparent friction coefficient. More detailed information on friction measurement techniques can be found in the article "Laboratory Testing Methods for Solid Friction" in Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology, Volume 18 in the ASM Handbook.
Wear In general, wear may be defined as damage to a solid surface caused by the removal or displacement of material by the mechanical action of a contacting solid, liquid, or gas. Gradual deterioration is often implied, and the effects are for the most part surface-related phenomena; but these restrictions should not be rigorously applied when analyzing wear problems or failures. Neither should the assumption that wear is entirely mechanical be accepted, because chemical corrosion may combine with other wear factors. Classification of Wear Wear has been classified in various ways. One of the simplest classifications of wear is based on the presence or absence of effective lubricants— namely lubricated or nonlubricated wear. (The various types of lubrication/lubricants are described later in this Chapter.) Another possibility is to classify wear on the basis of the fundamental mechanism that is operating. Unfortunately, this approach is complicated by the fact that more than one mechanism may be operating at the same time and by the fact that those developing wear classification schemes have come from different backgrounds and experiences with wear. As a result, different classification schemes based on wear mechanisms have been developed and no one scheme is universally accepted, although most of them have reasonably similar features. Figures 2 and 3 show two wear classifications based on the work of Blau (Ref 1) and Budinski (Ref 2). Blau places wear processes into three categories based on the type of motion encountered, that is, sliding, impact, and rolling contact (Fig. 2). Budinski reduces wear processes into four categories, that is, abrasion, erosion, adhesion, and surface fatigue (Fig. 3). Although both of the wear classifications schemes shown in Fig. 2 and 3 have merit, they also point out the difficulties inherent in classifying wear processes based on the commonality of mechanism. A third approach to wear classification emphasizes the nature of the contacting materials and the experimental conditions, using descriptive terms that are widely understood and accepted. The following is an example of this type of classification:
Metal against nonmetallic abrasive High-stress gouging or grinding: Wet, as in ball and rod mills Dry, as in jaw-type or roll-type ore crushers Low-stress scratching or sliding: Wet, such as conveyor screws for wet sand Dry, as against plows or earthmoving devices operating in dry soil Impact of loose abrasive (erosion): Wet, as against impellers in slurry pumps Dry, as in sandblasting Metal against metal Sliding: Lubricated, such as engine crosshead or shaft in a bearing Nonlubricated, such as fasteners, nuts, and bolts Rolling: Lubricated, such as roller bearings and gears Nonlubricated, such as wheels on tracks Liquid or vapor impingement on metals Wet steam, such as turbines Combustion gases, such as gas turbines Water, such as pump impellers Cavitations, as in turbulent, high-velocity flowing liquids
Frequently, these conditions are combined in service so an application that was originally metal against metal may evolve into metal against nonmetal wear, such as the generation of oxide wear debris and the introduction of nonmetallic particles through imperfect seals. Other combinations include rolling with sliding and lubricated-nonlubricated situations.
Wear Sliding wear
Impact wear
Roling contact wear
Abrasive (cutting) wear 2-body Multibody (3-body)
2-body impact wear
Pure rolling contact
Adhesive wear Fatigue wear Delamination Fretting wear Polishing wear (chemo-mechanical abrasion)
Multibody impact wear Erosion Solids Liquids Gases Slurries Electric sparks Cavitation Bubbles Gets)
Rolling/sliding contact Sliding Impact
Roling
pjo 2 Major categories of wear classified by the type of relative motion encountered (sliding, impact, ^* and rolling contact). Using this classification system, galling, scuffing, and scoring are not strictly considered forms of wear because material is not necessarily removed (it may instead be displaced to one side). Rather, these latter phenomena are referred to as "surface damage/' Source: Ref 1
Wear
Abrasion
Erosion
Adhesion
Surface fatigue
Low sress
Solid impingement
Fretting
Pitting
High stress
Fluid impingement
Adhesive
Spalling
Gouging
Cavitation
Seizure
Impact
Polishing
Slurry erosion
Galling
Brinelling
Require hard, sharp surfaces imposed on softer surfaces
Require fluid action
Oxidative wear Require interaction between conforming surfaces
Require repetitive compressive stresses
FlC. 3 Major categories of wear based on abrasion, erosion, adhesion, and " surface fatigue. Source: Ref 2
Abrasive Wear
General Description. Abrasive wear is defined as wear due to hard particles or hard protuberances forced against and moving along a solid surface. This form of wear in metals is most frequently caused by nonmetallic materials, but metallic particles can also cause abrasion. Generally, a material is seriously abraded or scratched only by a particle harder than itself. Figure 4 shows the damage caused on the surface of a soft copper substrate abraded by a hard ceramic particle. The cost of abrasion is high and has been estimated as ranging from 1 to 4% of the gross national product of an industrialized nation. The effect of abrasion is particularly evident in the industrial areas of agriculture, mining, mineral processing, earth moving, and essentially wherever dirt, rock, and minerals are handled. Examples include plows, ore loading/ moving buckets, crushers, and dump truck beds. When two surfaces contact, wear occurs on both surfaces. Individuals and industry tend to focus on the wearing surface that has the greatest potential for their own economic loss, and consider the other surface to be the abrasive. For example, an individual walking up the stairs of a building would
Fig. 4 Scanning electron micrograph showing surface damage by chip for" mation, plastic deformation, and pickup of fragments of a ceramic particle abrading a copper surface
be more likely to think that his shoes, rather than the stairs, were experiencing abrasive wear, whereas the maintenance staff would have the opposite opinion. In actuality, both surfaces are being subjected to abrasive wear. The rate at which the surfaces abrade depends on the characteristics of each surface, the presence of abrasives between the first and second surfaces, the speed of contact, and other environmental conditions. In short, loss rates are not inherent to a material. With reference to the above example, changing the material of either the shoes or the steps could, and often would, change the wear on the opposite counterface. The addition of an abrasive, such as a layer of sand, on the steps would further change the situation, in that the sand would be the second surface that contacts both the shoes and the steps. Abrasive Wear Categories. Abrasion is typically categorized according to types of contact, as well as contact environment. Types of contact include two-body and three-body wear. The former occurs when an abrasive slides along a surface, and the latter, when an abrasive is caught between one surface and another. Two-body systems typically experience from 10 to 1000 times as much loss as three-body systems for a given load and path length of wear. Contact environments (Fig. 5) are classified as either open (free) or closed (constrained). Tests have shown that for a given load and path length of wear, the wear rate is about the same for both open and closed systems. However, measurements of the loss in closed systems will often appear higher than the loss in open systems. This probably occurs because most closed systems experience higher loads. As shown in Fig. 3, abrasion is often further categorized as being lowstress abrasion, high-stress abrasion, gouging abrasion, and polishing
Machining
Free-flow ore (b) (a)
Plow penetrating sandy soil
Jaw crusher
(O (d) Fig, 5 Types of contact during abrasive wear, (a) Open two-body, (b) Closed two-body. ^* (c) Open three-body, (d) Closed three-body
abrasion. As described in the following paragraphs, each of these forms of abrasion is characterized by varying amounts of surface or subsurface damage. Low-stress abrasion (scratching) is defined as wear that occurs clue to relatively light rubbing contact of abrasive particles with the metal. The criteria established for low-stress abrasion is that the forces must be low enough to prevent crushing of the abradant. Wear scars usually show scratches, and the amount of subsurface deformation is minimal. Consequently, the surface does not work harden appreciably. Parts such as screens, chute liners, blades, and belts that are exposed to sand slurries or abrasive atmospheres could experience low-stress abrasion. Many machine components such as bushings, seals, and chains that operate in dust will wear by low-stress abrasion. Figure 6(a) shows a surface that was subjected to low-stress abrasion. High-stress abrasion is wear under a level of stress that is high enough to crush the abrasive. Considerably more strain hardening of the metal surface occurs. The abrasion of ore grinding balls is an example of highstress abrasion in the mining industry. Other examples include abrasion experienced by rolling-contact bearings, gears, cams, and pivots. Figure 6(b) illustrates this form of wear.
(a)
(b)
(C)
(d)
Fig. 6 Schematics illustrating the four types of abrasive wear, (a) Low-stress abrasion where material " is removed by hard, sharp particles or other hard, sharp surfaces plowing material out in furrows, (b) High-stress abrasion characterized by scratching, plastic deformation of surfaces, and pitting from impressed particles. Damage is almost always more severe than low-stress abrasion, (c) Gouging abrasion where material removal is caused by the action of repetitive compressive loading of hard materials such as rocks against a softer surface, usually a metal, (d) Polishing wear where material is removed from the surface by the action of rubbing from other solids under such conditions that material is removed without visible scratching, fracture, or plastic deformation. The example shown is polishing metal removal with a buffing wheel. Source: Ref 2
Gouging Abrasion. The term gouging abrasion is used to describe the high-stress abrasion that results in sizable grooves or gouges on the worn surface (Fig. 6c). It occurs on parts such as crusher liners, impact hammers in pulverizers, and dipper teeth handling large rocks. Strain hardening and plastic deformation are the dominant factors. Polishing wear is an extremely mild form of wear for which the mechanism has not been clearly identified, but that may involve extremely finescale abrasion, plastic smearing of microasperities, and/or chemical corrosion (Fig. 6d). Surfaces that have been subjected to polishing wear are usually smoothed and brightened, but this smoothing or brightening requires material removal. It can cause loss of serviceability in some instances, for example, worn and slippery stair treads. Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain how material is removed from a surface during abrasion. These mechanisms include fracture, fatigue, and melting. Because of the complexity of abrasion, no one mechanism completely accounts for all the loss. Figure 7 depicts some of the processes that are possible when a single abrasive tip traverses a surface. They include plowing, wedge formation, cutting, microfatigue, and microcracking.
Plowing
Microfatigue
Wedge
Microcracking
Cutting Fig, 7 Five mechanisms of abrasive wear
Plowing is the process of displacing material from a groove to the sides. This occurs under light loads and does not result in any real material loss. Damage occurs to the near surface of the material in the form of a buildup of dislocations through cold work. If later scratches occur on this cold-worked surface, then the additional work could result in loss through microfatigue. When the ratio of shear strength of the contact interface relative to the shear strength of the bulk rises to a high enough level (from 0.5 to 1.0), it has been found that a wedge can develop on the front of an abrasive tip. In this case, the total amount of material displaced from the groove is greater than the material displaced to the sides. This wedge formation is still a fairly mild form of abrasive wear. The most severe form of wear for ductile material is cutting. During the cutting process, the abrasive tip removes a chip, much like a machine tool does. This results in removed material, but very little displaced material relative to the size of the groove. For a sharp abrasive particle, a critical angle exists for which there is a transition from plowing to cutting. This angle depends on the material being abraded. Examples of critical angles range from 45° for copper to 85° for aluminum (Ref 3,4). Brittle materials have an additional mode of abrasive wear, namely, microcracking or microfracture. This occurs when forces applied by the abrasive grain exceed the fracture toughness of the material. This is often the predominant mode of severe wear for ceramic materials, and is active in materials such as white cast irons.
Effects of Material Properties on Abrasive Wear. Although hardness is the most important factor in the resistance to abrasion, other properties such as elastic modulus, yield strength, fracture toughness, microstructure, and composition also play an important role. For example, the abrasion resistance of ferrous metals is highly dependent on three metallurgical variables: microstructure, hardness, and carbon content. The inherently hard martensitic structure is preferable to the softer ferritic and austenitic structures. This is especially significant in low-stress abrasion, where little subsurface deformation occurs. When high-stress abrasion is encountered, alloys with high work-hardened hardness values have improved wear resistance when compared with alloys with low work-hardened hardness values. Figure 8 compares the hardness of ferrous alloy constituents with that of various minerals. Prevention of abrasive wear is possible through proper material selection and the use of surface engineering treatments. A number of material families have demonstrated good resistance to abrasive wear. They are typically hard materials that resist scratching, and include ceramics, carbide materials, alloyed white cast irons containing hard chromium carbides (see Fig. 8), and hardened alloy steels. Applicable surface treatments include: Weld hardfacing coatings, for example, high-carbon iron-chromium alloys, tool steels, nickel-chromium-boron alloys, cobalt-base alloys, and austenitic manganese steels Ceramic or cermet thermal spray materials deposited by plasma spraying, detonation gun (D-gun), or high-velocity oxyfuel processes Hard chromium plating Case hardening treatments Selective hardening treatments, for example, flame hardening Wear plates, for example, white cast iron or manganese steels Hard coatings produced by vapor deposition, for example, TiN Solid Particle Erosion General Description. Solid particle erosion (SPE) is the loss of surface material that results from repeated impacts of small, solid particles. In some cases SPE is a useful phenomenon, as in sandblasting and highspeed abrasive waterjet cutting, but it is a serious problem in many engineering systems, including steam and jet turbines, pipelines and valves carrying particulate matter, and fluidized bed combustion systems. Solid particle erosion is to be expected whenever hard particles are entrained in a gas or liquid medium impinging on a solid at any significant velocity (greater than 1 m/s, or 3.3 ft/s). Manifestations of SPE in service usually include thinning of components, a macroscopic scooping appearance following the gas/particle flow field, surface roughening (ranging
from polishing to severe roughening, depending on particle size and velocity), lack of the directional grooving characteristic of abrasion, and, in some but not all cases, the formation of ripple patterns on metals. Solid particle erosion can occur in a gaseous or liquid medium containing solid particles. In both cases, particles can be accelerated or decelerated, and their directions of motion can be changed by the fluid. This is more significant in liquid media, and slurry erosion is generally treated as Microconstituent
Mineral
Hardness Knoop Mohs Diamond
Vanadium carbide (VC) Titanium carbide (TiC)
Silicon carbide (SiC) Tungsten carbide (WC) Chromium carbide [(M^r)7C3] Cementite (Fe3C) Martensite
Corundum Topaz Quartz Feldspar
Austen ite
Apatite Pearlite
Silica sand Olivene Taconite, Glass Leucite, lmenite Limonite
Flint, garnet Iron pyrite Magnetite Hematite
Ferrite
Fluorite Calcite
Gypsum
Siderite Dolomite Bauxite Biotite mica
Kaolin Anthracite Bituminous coal Plastics
Talc
Fifi. 8 ^*
Hardness of some carbides, minerals, and alloy microconstituents. In general, the harder the material or constituent, the higher the abrasion resistance
a different, though related, subject. In gaseous media, at least for particles larger than about 50 jxm, deflection of the particles by the gas stream can often be ignored in erosion tests. However, it should be borne in mind that in an engineering application, such effects can be quite important—as, for example, the spatial distribution and severity of erosion damage within turbines and the effects of particle size and the change of direction and speed when particles rebound from surfaces. Erosion versus Abrasion. The distinction between erosion and abrasion should be clarified, because the term erosion has often been used in connection with situations that might be better classed as abrasion. Solid particle erosion refers to a series of particles striking and rebounding from the surface, while abrasion results from the sliding of abrasive particles across a surface under the action of an externally applied force. The clearest distinction is that, in erosion, the force exerted by the particles on the material is due to their deceleration, while in abrasion it is externally applied and approximately constant. This serves as a good working definition of the difference between the two phenomena. A clear-cut distinction between erosion and abrasion is difficult in some cases, particularly for very dense particle distributions in liquid or gas media, in which a "pack" of particles can develop and slide across the surface, which would be classed as abrasion. Variables Influencing Erosion. In practice, erosion rarely takes place in inert atmosphere or vacuum, but at room temperature the effect of oxidation can generally be ignored. Erosion can be thought of as "pure," that is, there are no synergistic interactions between erosion and corrosion (erosion-corrosion phenomenon are described in Chapter 2). Variables affecting pure erosion can be broadly separated into three types: impingement variables describing the particle flow, particle variables, and material variables. The primary impingement variables are particle velocity (v), angle of incidence (a), and flux (particle concentration), a is defined here and throughout virtually all erosion literature as the angle between the incident particle direction and the particle surface. Particle rotational speed is an additional impingement variable; it is difficult to measure and has not been studied in much detail. Particle variables include particle shape, size, hardness, and friability (ease of fracture). Material variables include all the material properties, such as hardness, work hardening behavior, and microstructure. In the erosion literature, materials are broadly classified as ductile or brittle, based on the dependence of their erosion rate on a. Ductile materials, such as pure metals, have a maximum erosion rate, E, at low angles of incidence (typically 15 to 30°), while for brittle materials, such as ceramics, the maximum is at or near 90°. These two classical extremes are illustrated in Fig. 9. A variety of curves intermediate between these classical extremes exist and in some cases the same material exhibits behavior that shifts from one extreme to the other, depending on erosion conditions.
The erosion rate, E, is commonly given in terms of mass or volume of material removed per unit mass of erodent impacted, volume being preferred because it permits thickness loss comparisons between materials of different density. Implicit is the assumption that the dimensions of the eroded area and the particle concentration are unimportant, which is a good approximation for dilute flows. Metals and ceramics differ in the dependence of E on a, as mentioned above, and also in their response to velocity and particle size and shape. E generally shows a power-law velocity dependence: (Eq 4)
AI2O3 erosion rate, (g/g) x 10"3
Al M00-O erosion rate, (g/g) x 10"4
where k is a constant and n is a velocity exponent that generally depends on material and erosion conditions. The value of n usually falls in the range of 2 to 2.5 for metals and 2.5 to 3 for ceramics, although observations exist outside these ranges. Material removal in ductile materials involves considerable plastic flow, while in brittle materials, fracture is of primary importance, at least for higher angles of incidence. Theories predict that E should be inversely proportional to hardness for metals, while for ceramics there should be a much weaker dependence on hardness, but fracture toughness should be important. Most theories further predict no effect of particle size for metals, although it is often observed that E increases strongly with particle size, at least up to about 100 fxm. For ceramics, a particle size exponent is predicted and observed. Hansen (Ref 5) compared the erosion rates of a large number of alloys, ceramics, and cermets. Although limited to a particular set of conditions, Hansen's study provides the practicing engineer with a good comparison of erosion rates for a very broad range of materials under the same condi-
Angle of impingement, a Fig. 9 Erosion of 1100-O aluminum relative to Al2O3 when both are eroded *** by 127 mm SiC particles impinging at a velocity of 152 m/s (499 ft/s)
tions. Estimation of the effects of variables such as velocity on the erosion rates of different classes of materials can be made from the remainder of this article. It should be noted that the order of material rankings would change with any change of variables such as velocity, particle type or size, and angle of incidence. The erosion tests were performed using 27 |xm Al2O3 particles at normal incidence and 170 m/s (560 ft/s) at 20 and 700 0C (68 and 1300 0F) in nitrogen. As in most other studies, the tests were conducted with a gas-jet erosion apparatus in which particles are fed from a hopper into a nozzle, where they mix with and are accelerated by a flowing gas stream (ASTM G 76 as described later in this Chapter). Hansen (Ref 5) normalized the erosion rates by defining the relative erosion factor (REF) as specimen volume loss divided by that of a standard material, Stellite 6B (Table 6). Figures 10 and 11 show this data for
Table 6 Erosion test results for selected metals and ceramics evaluated at room temperature and at elevated temperature Test parameters: 90° impingement; 27 mm Al2O3 particles; 5 g/min (0.18 oz/min) particle flow; 170 m/s (560 ft/s) particle velocity; 3 test duration; N2 atmosphere Relative erosion factor (REF)(O Material
20 0 C (70 0F)
700 0 C (1290 0F)
0.54 1.00 1.16 1.06 1.61 1.00 0.73 0.56 0.83 0.85 0.62 0.78 0.61 0.79 0.54 0.57 0.57 0.80 0.62
(GE)
1.26 1.25 1.19 1.08 1.04 1.00 1.00 0.99 0.97 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.91 0.91 0.90 0.83 0.80 0.77 0.76 0.52 0.48
ZrB2-SiC-graphite (N) (UCAR) SiC-Si3N4 bond (Carbor) Recrystallized SiC (N) SiC-ceramic bond (Carbor) Recrystallized SiC (N) (N) B4C (N) 2MgO-25TiB2-3.5WC-bal Al 2 O 3 (OGC)
6.36 2.44 0.91 0.80 0.49 0.40 0.40 0.38 0.37
>5.00 3.43 1.15 0.32 1.38 0.38 0.12 0.21 0.36
Manufacturing method(a)
Composition (manufacturer)(b)
Metals Ti-6A1-4V Haynes 93 25Cr iron Stellite 6K Stellite 3 Stellite 6B Type 304 stainless steel Type 316 stainless steel Haynes 188 Haynes 25 Type 430 stainless steel HK-40 Inconel 600 RA 330 Incoloy 800H Beta III Ti Incoloy 800 RA 333 Inconel 671 Mild steel Molybdenum Tungsten
W C C W C W W W W W W C W W W W W W W W W W
17Cr-16Mo-6.3Co-3C-bal Fe (Stellite) 25Cr-2Ni-2Mn-0.5Si-3.5C-bal Fe (OGC) 30Cr-4.5W-1.5Mo-1.7C-bal Co (Stellite) 31Cr-12.5W-2.4C-balCo 30Cr-4.5W-1.5Mo-1.2C-bal Co (Stellite) 17Cr-9Ni-2Mn-lSi-balFe 17Cr-12Ni-2Mn-lSi-2.5Mo-bal Fe 22Cr-14.5W-22Ni-0.15C-bal Co (Stellite) 22Cr-15W-10Ni-1.5Mn-0.15C-bal Co (Stellite) 17Cr-lMn-lSi-0.1C-balFe 26Cr-20Ni-0.4C-bal Fe 76Ni-15.5Cr-8Fe (HA) 19Cr-35Ni-1.5Mn-1.3Si-bal Fe (RA) 32.5Ni-21Cr-0.07C-46Fe (HA) 11.5Mo-6Zr-4.5Sn-balTi 32.5Ni-46Fe-21Cr (HA) 25Cr-1.5Mn-1.3Si-3Co-3Mo-3W-18Fe-bal Ni (RA) 50Ni-48Cr-0.4Ti (HA) 0.15C-balFe
0.17
Ceramics ZRBSC-M Chromite Refrax20C HD 435 Carbofrax D HD 430 Si3N4 Norbide BT-9
HP PS PS PS HP HP PS
(continued) (a) W, wrought; C, cast; HP, hot pressed; PS, pressed and sintered, (b) Manufacturer: BW, Babcock and Wilcox; Carbor, Carborundum Co.; GE, General Electric Co.; HA, Huntington Alloy Products; N, Norton Co.; OGC, Oregon Graduate Center; RA, Rolled Alloys Corp.; Stellite, Stellite Div., Cabot Corp.; UCAR, Union Carbide Corp. (c) REF = Volume loss material/volume loss Stellite 6B
Table 6
(continued) Relative erosion factor (REF)(c)
Material BT-12 BT-Il ZRBSC-D BT-24 BT-IO Noroc 33 TiC-Al2O3 SiC CBN GE diamond
Manufacturing method(a) PS PS HP PS PS HP PS HP
Composition (manufacturer)(b) 1.5MgO-49TiB2-3.5WC-bal Al 2 O 3 (OGC) 1.7MgO-38TiB2-3.5WC-bal Al 2 O 3 (OGC) ZrB2-SiC (N) 2MgO-30TiB2-3.5WC-bal Al 2 O 3 (OGC) 2MgO-30TiB2-3.5WC-bal Al 2 O 3 (OGC) Si3N4-SiC (N) (BW) (N) (GE) (GE)
20 0 C (700F)
700 0 C (1290 0F)
0.35 0.33 0.32 0.32 0.30 0.20 0.19 0.12 0 0
0.16 0.26 0.07 0.20 0.25 0.42 0.30 0.02 0 0
(a) W, wrought; C, cast; HP, hot pressed; PS, pressed and sintered, (b) Manufacturer: BW, Babcock and Wilcox; Carbor, Carborundum Co.; GE, General Electric Co.; HA, Huntington Alloy Products; N, Norton Co.; OGC, Oregon Graduate Center; RA, Rolled Alloys Corp.; Stellite, Stellite Div., Cabot Corp.; UCAR, Union Carbide Corp. (c) REF = Volume loss material/volume loss Stellite 6B
metals and ceramics, respectively. Tungsten carbide-cobalt (WC-Co) cermets gave REFs from about 0.1 to 1.6, and REF was found to increase with binder content. The REFs of most metals were similar at 20 and 700 0 C (68 and 1300 0 F), typically within about 20% of unity (Fig. 10). The three lowest room-temperature REFs for metals were for tungsten (0.48), molybdenum (0.52), and 1015 steel (0.76), and the highest was for Ti6A1-4V (1.26). The 700 0C (1300 0F) erosion rate of the standard (Stellite 6B) was 20% higher than the room-temperature value, so that 7000 C (1300 0F) REF values greater than 0.8 represent increases of erosion rate with temperature for a given material. These results illustrate the unfortunate fact that alloy-strengthening mechanisms such as solution or precipitation hardening that increase hardness do not significantly improve erosion resistance. According to Hansen (Ref 5), if service experience reveals an erosion problem for a metallic component, substitution of another metallic alloy will generally provide little improvement. Most ceramics tested had REF values in the range 0.3 to 0.6, although a few were much higher, and a few were nearly zero. It is important to note here (as discussed later) that for erodent particles of lower hardness than Al 2 O 3 (used in Hansen's study), significant improvements of erosion resistance can be obtained when the ratio of particle to target hardness, HJHV is less than 1. Prevention. Various design solutions have been developed in which high erosion rates are avoided by reconfiguring the system—such as the blocked tee configuration, in which a tee joint with one end closed is used in place of a gradual bend in a pipeline to prevent low-angle impingement. A good example of the variety of engineering solutions to SPE is provided by the case of power-generating steam turbines, in which exfoliation of iron oxide scale formed on steel heater tubes generates large pieces of scale that are fragmented into approximately 100 |xm particles, causing erosion of turbine blades, shrouds, valves, rivets, and other components. Liquid droplet erosion is also present. Solid particle erosion solutions include minimizing of scale formation by using austenitic steels or chromiz-
Ti-6AI-4V Haynes 93 25Cr iron HaynesStellite6K Haynes Stellite 3 Haynes Stellite 6B Type 304 stainless steel Type 316 stainless steel Haynes 188 Haynes 25 Type 430 stainless steel HK-40
Fiff. 1 0 R e ' a t ' v e erosion factors for *** selected commercially available metals at an impingement angle of 90°. Stellite 6B cobalt-base alloy was used as the reference material. Source: Ref5
lnconel 600 RA-330 lncoloy 800H BetaHTi lncoloy 800 RA 333 lnconel 671 Mild steel Molybdenum Tungsten
ZRBSC-M
Specimen perforated
Chromite Refrax20C HD 435 Carbofrax D HD 430 Si3N4 Norbide BT-9
p j a -| I Relative erosion factors for ^* selected ceramics at an impingement angle of 90°. Ratings based on using Stellite 6B cobalt-base alloy as the reference material. Source: Ref 5
BT-12 BT-11 ZRBSC-D BT-24 BT-10 Noroc 33 TiC-AI2O3 SiC Cubic boron nitride Diamond Relative erosion factor (REF)
ing treatments, particle removal with cyclones or screens, application of plasma-sprayed or diffusion coatings to blades, and redesign of turbine configurations. Liquid Erosion General Description. Erosion of a solid surface can take place in a liquid medium even without the presence of solid abrasive particles in that medium. Cavitation, one mechanism of liquid erosion, involves the formation and subsequent collapse of bubbles within the liquid. The process by which material is removed from a surface is called cavitation erosion, and the resulting damage is termed cavitation damage. The collision at high speed of liquid droplets with a solid surface results in a form of liquid erosion called: liquid impingement erosion. Cavitation damage has been observed on ship propellers and hydrofoils; on dams, spillways, gates, tunnels, and other hydraulic structures; and in hydraulic pumps and turbines. High-speed flow of liquid in these devices causes local hydrodynamic pressures to vary widely and rapidly. In mechanical devices, severe restrictions in fluid passages have produced cavitation damage downstream of orifices and in valves, seals, bearings, heatexchanger tubes, and Venturis. Cavitation erosion has also damaged water-cooled diesel-engine cylinder liners. Liquid impingement erosion has been observed on many components exposed to high-velocity steam containing moisture droplets, such as blades in the low-pressure end of large steam turbines. Rain erosion, one form of liquid-impingement erosion, frequently damages the aerodynamic surfaces of aircraft and missiles when they fly through rainstorms at high subsonic or supersonic speeds. Liquid impingement and cavitation erosion are of concern in nuclear power systems, which operate at lower steam quality than conventional steam systems, and in systems using liquid metals as the working fluid, where the corrosiveness of the liquid metal can promote rapid erosion of components. Basic Mechanisms. Liquid erosion involves the progressive removal of material from a surface by repeated impulse loading at microscopically small areas. Liquid dynamics is of major importance in producing damage, although corrosion also plays a role in the damage process, at least with certain fluid-material combinations. The process of liquid erosion is not as well understood as most other wear processes. It is difficult to define the hydrodynamic conditions that produce erosion and the metallurgical processes by which particles are detached from the surface. Evidently, both cavitation and liquid impingement exert similar hydrodynamic forces on a solid surface. In any event, the appearance of damaged surfaces (Fig. 12) and the relative resistance of materials to damage are similar for both liquid impingement and cavitation erosion. Additional information on the mechanism of material removal during cavitation can be found in Chapter 2, "Principles of Corrosion."
pja 1 2 A cast steel feedwater-pump impeller severely damaged by cavitation. Note how ^" damage is confined to the outer edges of the impeller where vane speed was maximum.
Prevention. Damage from liquid erosion can be prevented or minimized by reducing the intensity of cavitation or liquid impingement through design, using erosion-resistant materials, for example, cobaltbase alloys and tool steels including weld overlays of these materials, or, under certain conditions, using elastomeric coatings. Slurry Erosion General Description. Slurry erosion is progressive loss of material from a solid surface by the action of a mixture of solid particles in a liquid (slurry) in motion with respect to the solid surface. If the solid surface is capable of corroding in the fluid portion of the slurry, the slurry erosion will contain a corrosion component. Figure 13 shows an example of slurry erosion. A slurry by definition is a physical mixture of solid particles and a liquid (usually water) of such a consistency that it can be pumped. The particles must be in suspension in the liquid, and most pumpable slurries contain at least 10% solids. Apparent Abrasivity. Typical pumpable slurries possess inherent "apparent abrasivity," which must be determined by testing to enable cost predictions for pump replacement parts or other equipment used for slurries. Apparent abrasivity, without inhibition, is the complex synergistic reaction of many factors (Fig. 14). This reaction, known as the MorrisonMiller effect (Ref 6), is such that the wear response of a given material in
Fig. 1 3 Schematic of slurry erosion.
Resistance of protective film of corrosion products to abrasivity of slurry
Corrosive liquid
Dissolved air (oxygen or environment)
Specimen
Liquid
Lap
Galvanic corrosion (if two metals involved)
Released corrosive connate water from ore particles
True abrasivity of solids (particle hardness, size, shape, and concentration)
Soluble elements in solids forming corrosive solution
Fig. 1 4 Synergistic effects of seven factors in slurry abrasivity
a certain slurry does not indicate how that material would respond to another slurry. Similarly, the effect of a certain slurry on one material does not indicate how it would affect another material. Other modes of wear are also encountered when handling slurries. As shown in Fig. 15, these include abrasion-corrosion (the most severe wear mode), scouring wear, abrasive metal-to-metal wear (crushing and grinding), high-velocity erosion, low-velocity erosion, saltation wear (rapid wear caused when particles are moved forward in a series of short intermittent bounces from a bottom surface), and cavitation.
Polymer with embedded abrasive particles
(b)
(a)
Velocity profile
(O
Pipe wall (e)
(d) Pipe wall
Collapsing vapor bubbles
Large tumbling rocks U)
(g)
Fig. 1 5 blurry erosion wear modes, (a) Abrasion-corrosion, (b) Scouring wear, with wear areas equal (left) and unequal (center and right), (c) Crushing and grinding, (d) High-velocity erosion. (e) Low-velocity erosion, (f) Saltation erosion, (g) Cavitation
Miller numbers are used to determine the abrasivity of slurries, based on the rate of metal loss from a standard 27% chrome-iron wear block that reciprocates through any slurry, on a rubber lap, with an imposed load of 22.2 N (5 lbf) placed on the wearing block. The higher the number, the greater the aggressive effect of the slurry on part life. The additional effect of corrosion (usually present in liquid slurries, even those mixed with distilled water) was slow to be recognized. This was because such chrome-iron is rather corrosion resistant and the original test actually fulfilled its objective to reveal the "true abrasivity" of the dry particles. The effects of both abrasion and corrosion must be recognized in the operation of any slurry-handling system. Table 7 lists typical Miller numbers for selected slurry materials. The wide variation in Miller numbers for some materials is due to the inclusion of varying amounts of "tramp" materials that usually occur with the basic mineral. Information about the factors that contribute to Miller number abrasivity can be found in the ASTM G 75 standard. Prevention of slurry erosion is accomplished through design changes, for example, lessening the severity of pipe bends or using replaceable
Table 7
Typical Miller numbers for selected slurry materials
Material
Alundum (400 mesh) Alundum (200 mesh) Aragonite Ash Ash, fly Bauxite Calcium carbonate Carbon Carborundum (220 mesh) Clay Coal Copper concentrate Detergent Dust, blast furnace Gilsonite Gypsum Iron ore (or concentrate) Kaolin Lignite Limestone Limonite Magnesium hydrate Magnetite Microsphorite Mud, drilling Nickel Phosphate Potash Pyrite Quartzite Rutile Salt brine Sand and sand fill Sea bottom Shale Serpentine Sewage, digested Sewage, raw Sodium sulfate Soda ash tailings Sulfur Tailings (all types) Tar sand Waste, nickel Waste, coal
Miller number(s)
241 1058 7 127 83, 14 9, 33, 50, 76, 134 14 14, 16 1284 34,36 6,10,21,28,47,57 19, 37, 58, 68, 111, 128 6,8 57 10 41 28, 37, 64, 79, 122, 157, 234 7,30 14 22, 30, 39, 43, 46 113 4 64, 71, 134 76 10 31 68, 74, 84, 134 1,2 194 99 10 11 51, 68, 85, 116, 138, 149, 246 11 53,59 134 15 25 4 27 1 24, 61, 91, 159, 217, 480, 644 70 53 22, 28
wear backs on 90° elbows in high-velocity slurry pipelines and protective coatings. These include hardfacing alloys (e.g., cobalt alloys), plasmasprayed ceramics and cermets, hard platings, ceramic and carbide wear tiles, ceramic-filled repair cements, chromized steels, cast cylinder liners, plastic-lined pipe, and basalt-lined pipe (Ref 2). Adhesive Wear General Description. Adhesive wear is defined as wear by transference of material from one surface to another during relative motion under load due to a process of solid-state welding (Fig. 16); particles that are removed from one surface are either permanently or temporarily attached to the other surface. Adhesive wear may be between metallic materials, ceramics, or polymers, or combinations of these. It is dependent on adhesion between the
material, and that, in turn, depends on surface films like oxides or lubricants, as well as the mutual affinity of one material for another. If loads are light and the natural spontaneous oxidation of a metal can keep up with the rate of its removal by wear, then that wear rate will be relatively low (the oxide acting as a lubricant). This is called mild wear. If loads are high and the protective oxide is continually disrupted to allow intimate metal to metal contact and adhesion, then the wear rate will be high. This is called severe wear. Theory. Solid surfaces are almost never perfectly smooth but rather consist of microscopic or macroscopic asperities of various shapes. When two such surfaces are brought into contact under a load normal to the general planes of the surfaces, the asperities come into contact and elastically or plastically deform until the real area of contact is sufficient to carry the load. A bond may then occur between the two surfaces that is stronger than the intrinsic strength of the weaker of the two materials in contact. When relative motion between the two surfaces occurs, the weaker of the two materials fails, and material is transferred to the contacting surface. In subsequent interactions, this transferred material may be retransferred to the original surface (probably at a different location) or may become totally separated as a wear debris particle of an irregular morphology (Ref 7). Formulas that have been proposed (Ref 8, 9), to describe this phenomenon are of the form: (Eq 5) where Vis the wear scar volume, S is the distance of sliding, L is the load, H is the indentation yield strength (hardness) of the softer surface, and k is a probability factor that a given area contact will fracture within the weaker material rather than at the original interface. Formulations similar to Eq 5 have been shown to describe adhesive wear over fairly wide ranges of sliding distances, under a variety of conditions, over limited ranges of load, and over limited ranges of hardness when the same classes of material were compared (Ref 10, 11). While initial theoretical considerations assumed bare metal-to-metal contact, later Load Bodyl
Motion
Flg. 1 6 Schematic of adhesive wear
work assumed that oxide films, adsorbed films, and/or lubricant effects could be accounted for by changing k or by using more complex formulations (Ref 12). It has also been proposed that true metal-to-metal adhesive wear occurs at some time after motion is initiated when surface films or contaminants are worn away. Presumably, therefore, more than one adhesive wear mechanism could be operating at any given time, depending upon the presence or absence of various surface films in local areas. Changes in the apparent value of k or klH as a function of load may be the result of penetration of such films at sufficiently high load or the generation of new films as a result of frictional heating. The wear coefficient, k, has been determined experimentally for a large number of materials couples under various test conditions and geometries. The values found range from about 10~3 to 10~8 (Ref 7). For example, representative values of k for the end of a cylinder sliding against the flat surface of a ring at 1.8 m/s (6 ft/s) under a 400 g load are given for various combinations of cylinder and ring materials in Table 8. In many laboratory experiments, a stationary specimen with a small surface area rubs against a moving specimen with a large area. This frequently leads to a much higher wear rate on the smaller specimen than on the larger because of the constant contact and associated heating of the smaller specimen. This relative area effect may influence the wear mechanisms operating and may not be representative of field use. For most practical applications, volume loss, as predicted by Eq 5, must be converted to a linear value representing penetration or decrease in length, for example, increase in diameter of a journal bearing bushing, reduction in shaft diameter, or reduction in the length of brush in an electric motor. Primary Material Parameters. Materials selection for adhesion resistance requires careful consideration of the operating environment of the workpiece in addition to the total functional performance required of the workpiece itself. Wear properties of the steels vary widely with processing and heat treatment. Polymers are selected for sliding contact applications because of inherent properties such as inertness to many chemicals, relatively low galling tendency, and self-lubricating properties. Ceramics Table 8 Wear coefficients for various combinations of materials under conditions of dry sliding Sliding combination Cylinder material
Ring material
Low-carbon steel 60-40 brass PTFE Bakelite Beryllium copper Tool steel Stellite Tungsten carbide Tungsten carbide
Low-carbon steel Hardened steel Hardened steel Hardened steel Hardened steel Hardened steel Hardened steel Low-carbon steel Tungsten carbide
Wear coefficient, k 7.0 6.0 2.5 7.5 3.7 1.3 5.5 4.0 1.0
X X X X X X X X X
10~ 3 10~ 4 10~ 5 10~ 6 10~ 5 10~ 4 10~ 5 10~ 6 10" 6
Hardness of softer member, 106 g/cm2
18.6 9.5 0.5 2.5 21.0 85.0 69.0 18.6 130.0
Wear coefficients given are for the end of a cylinder sliding against the flat surface of a ring at 1.8 m/s (6 ft/s) under a 400 g load.
are used where extreme resistance to high-temperature oxidation or resistance to highly corrosive materials or gases is required. Prevention. The following guidelines are recommendations to prevent adhesive wear in metals, polymers, and ceramics: Avoid sliding similar materials together, particularly metals. If fatigue due to repeated high-contact pressure is not likely to be a problem, then high hardness is a desired property. However, avoid sliding hard metals against hard metals in lubricated systems to avoid scuffing and to accommodate debris. Consider the effect of relative hardness of phases in materials. For example, a high-chromium cast iron may have a hardness of 400 HB, which is moderate. However, that cast iron may contain Cr7C3, which has a hardness of about four times that of 400 HB and will damage the countersurface considerably. The same applies to polymers, which seem rather soft relative to metals. However, wear-resisting polymers often contain glass or some other hard filler that wears metal counterfaces rather severely. Hard phases in one body may fragment and become embedded in the counterface, which causes abrasion if the fragments extend above the surface. Even if done inadequately, lubrication will reduce wear. Some lubrication can be applied by providing an atmosphere that is corrosive in order to form surface films, many of which produce lower friction than if that film were not present.
Galling General Description. Galling can be considered a severe form of adhesive wear. With high loads and poor lubrication, surface damage can occur on sliding metal components. The damage is characterized by localized macroscopic material transfer, that is, large fragments or surface protrusions that are easily visible on either or both surfaces. This gross damage is usually referred to as galling, and it can occur after just a few cycles of movement between the mating surfaces. Severe galling can result in seizure of the metal surfaces. The terms scuffing and scoring are also used to describe similar surface damage under lubricated conditions. Scuffing is the preferred term when the damage occurs at lubricated surfaces, such as the piston ring-cylinder wall contact. Scoring typically describes damage that takes the form of relatively long grooves. Primary Material Parameters. Materials that have limited ductility are less prone to galling, because under high loads surface asperities will tend to fracture when interlocked. Small fragments of material may be lost, but the resultant damage will be more similar to scoring than to galling. For highly ductile materials, asperities tend to plastically
deform, thereby increasing the contact area of mated surfaces; eventually, galling occurs. Another key material behavior during plastic deformation is the ease with which dislocations cross slip over more than one plane. In face centered cubic (fee) dislocations easily cross slip. The rate of cross slip for a given alloy or element is usually indicated by its stacking-fault energy. Dislocation cross slip is hindered by the presence of stacking faults, and a high stacking-fault energy indicates a low number of impeding stacking faults and an increased tendency to cross slip and, hence, gall. Table 9 lists the stacking-fault energies of four fee elements. Nickel and aluminum have poor galling resistance, whereas gold and copper have good galling resistance. Materials that have a hexagonal close-packed (hep) structure with a high cla ratio have a low dislocation cross slip rate and are less prone to galling. This explains why cobalt-base alloys and cadmium-plated alloys resist galling while titanium alloys tend to gall. Prevention of galling is accomplished through proper design, for example, parts should have sufficient clearance, because tightly fitted parts are more prone to galling. Adequate lubrication and various hard surface coatings also can help prevent galling. Control of surface roughness is another important factor. Highly polished surfaces (<0.25 (xm, or 10 ixin.) or very rough finishes (>1.5 |ixm, or 60 |min.) increase the tendency for wear and galling. It is theorized that very smooth surfaces lack the ability to store wear debris because of the absence of valleys between asperities, which means the asperities will have greater interaction. Also, lubricants will tend to wipe off the smoother surface. Too rough a finish results in interlocking asperities, which promote severe tearing and galling.
Fretting General Description. Fretting is a wear phenomenon that occurs between two mating surfaces; initially, it is adhesive in nature, and vibration or small-amplitude oscillation is an essential causative factor. Fretting is frequently accompanied by corrosion. In general, fretting occurs between two tight-fitting surfaces that are subjected to a cyclic, relative motion of extremely small amplitude. Fretting generally occurs at contacting surfaces that are intended to be fixed in relation to each other but that actually undergo minute alternating Table 9 Metals Gold Copper Nickel Aluminum Source: Ref 13
Stacking-fault energies of some common metals Stacking-fault energy, eVgs/cm2
30 40 80 200
Next Page
relative motion that is usually produced by vibration. The relative displacements between bodies are quite small (<50 to 150 jjim). Fretting further differs from ordinary wear in that the bulk of the debris produced is retained at the site of fretting. In ferrous materials, the fretting process creates a mass of reddish oxide particles. Fretting also occurs in nonoxidizing materials, such as gold, platinum, and cupric oxide. Common sites for fretting are in joints that are bolted, keyed, pinned, press fitted, or riveted; in oscillating bearings, splines, couplings, clutches, spindles, and seals; in press fits on shafts; and in universal joints, baseplates, shackles, and orthopedic implants. One additional problem with fretting is that it may initiate fatigue cracks, which, in highly stressed components, often result in fatigue fracture. Prevention. Fretting, because of the significant role of oxidation, is best combatted by oxidation-resistant coatings, for example, electroless nickel or softer self-lubricating coatings like silver or indium. Solid-film lubricants are also successfully employed. Additional information on prevention of fretting corrosion can be found in Chapter 2, "Principles of Corrosion."
Rolling-Contact Wear General Description. The rolling of one body over another, as in a rolling-element bearing, can result in repeated stressing of the subsurface material, the nucleation of microcracks, and the eventual production of pits and spalls. Because rolling-contact wear is generally produced by repetitive mechanical stressing, it is often associated with, or even referred to as, rolling-contact fatigue. Analysis of bearings and gears indicates that some degree of slip occurs in many rolling-contact situations, such as in the cam and roller assembly in an automobile valve train and in the engagement of gear teeth. Thus, it is common to observe sliding wear (e.g., scuffing or polished-looking areas) on components that are ordinarily considered to be in "rolling contact." Prevention of rolling-contact fatigue is accomplished through proper design and load ratings, lubrication, and the use of through-hardened or case-hardened premium quality (clean) alloy steels.
Lubrication One important means of reducing wear (as well as friction) is lubrication. Lubrication not only reduces the power consumption needed to overcome friction but also protects rolling and sliding contact surfaces from excessive wear. Even with lubrication, however, wear still occurs.
Previous Page
relative motion that is usually produced by vibration. The relative displacements between bodies are quite small (<50 to 150 jjim). Fretting further differs from ordinary wear in that the bulk of the debris produced is retained at the site of fretting. In ferrous materials, the fretting process creates a mass of reddish oxide particles. Fretting also occurs in nonoxidizing materials, such as gold, platinum, and cupric oxide. Common sites for fretting are in joints that are bolted, keyed, pinned, press fitted, or riveted; in oscillating bearings, splines, couplings, clutches, spindles, and seals; in press fits on shafts; and in universal joints, baseplates, shackles, and orthopedic implants. One additional problem with fretting is that it may initiate fatigue cracks, which, in highly stressed components, often result in fatigue fracture. Prevention. Fretting, because of the significant role of oxidation, is best combatted by oxidation-resistant coatings, for example, electroless nickel or softer self-lubricating coatings like silver or indium. Solid-film lubricants are also successfully employed. Additional information on prevention of fretting corrosion can be found in Chapter 2, "Principles of Corrosion."
Rolling-Contact Wear General Description. The rolling of one body over another, as in a rolling-element bearing, can result in repeated stressing of the subsurface material, the nucleation of microcracks, and the eventual production of pits and spalls. Because rolling-contact wear is generally produced by repetitive mechanical stressing, it is often associated with, or even referred to as, rolling-contact fatigue. Analysis of bearings and gears indicates that some degree of slip occurs in many rolling-contact situations, such as in the cam and roller assembly in an automobile valve train and in the engagement of gear teeth. Thus, it is common to observe sliding wear (e.g., scuffing or polished-looking areas) on components that are ordinarily considered to be in "rolling contact." Prevention of rolling-contact fatigue is accomplished through proper design and load ratings, lubrication, and the use of through-hardened or case-hardened premium quality (clean) alloy steels.
Lubrication One important means of reducing wear (as well as friction) is lubrication. Lubrication not only reduces the power consumption needed to overcome friction but also protects rolling and sliding contact surfaces from excessive wear. Even with lubrication, however, wear still occurs.
On lubricated surfaces, the wear process is usually mild and generates fine debris of a particle size as small as 1 or 2 jxm. Abrasive wear or delamination wear predominates under lubricated conditions. Electron microscope examination of worn surfaces from lubricated assemblies frequently reveals a multitude of fine scratches oriented in the direction of relative motion. The fine debris generated by abrasion becomes suspended in the oil or grease. In devices using circulating-oil lubrication, advantage has been taken of the fact that wear debris can be analyzed by spectroscopy and that deterioration of the device by wear can be diagnosed from these results. This technique is used to monitor the condition of vital components in aircraft and locomotive engines. Modes of Lubrication There are several basic modes of lubrication. In all modes, contact surfaces are separated by a lubricating medium, which may be a solid, a semisolid, or a pressurized liquid or gaseous film. Hydrodynamic lubrication is a system in which the shape and relative motion of the sliding surfaces cause the formation of a fluid film having sufficient pressure to separate the surfaces. Hydrostatic lubrication is a system in which the lubricant is supplied under sufficient external pressure to separate the opposing surfaces by a fluid film. Elastohydrodynamic lubrication is a system in which the friction and film thickness between the two bodies in relative motion are determined by the elastic properties of the bodies in combination with the viscous properties of the lubricant at the prevailing pressure, temperature, and rate of shear. Dry-film (solid-film) lubrication is a system in which a coating of solid lubricant separates the opposing surfaces and the lubricant itself wears away. Boundary lubrication and thin-film lubrication are two modes in which friction and wear are affected by properties of the contacting surfaces as well as by the properties of the lubricant. In boundary lubrication, each surface is covered by a chemically bonded fluid or semisolid film, which may or may not separate opposing surfaces, and viscosity of the lubricant is not a factor affecting friction and wear. In thin-film lubrication, the lubricant usually is not bonded to the surfaces and it does not separate opposing surfaces. Lubricant viscosity affects friction and wear. Lubricants Almost any surface film can act as a lubricant, preventing cold welding of asperities on opposing surfaces or allowing opposing surfaces to slide across one another at a lower frictional force than would prevail if the film were not present. Lubricants may be either liquid or solid (in some cases, gas films may act as lubricants). One of the functions of a lubricant is to carry away heat generated by two surfaces sliding under contact pressure.
Liquid lubricants can dissipate heat better than solid or semifluid lubricants, but in all types, the shear properties of the lubricant are critical to its performance. Properties. Liquid lubricants maintain separation or opposing surfaces by pressure within the film, which opposes the contact force. This pressure may be generated within the film, usually as a result of the shape of the opposing surfaces, or the liquid may be forced between the opposing surfaces by pressure from an external source. Regardless of the means of creating pressure within the film, the opposing surfaces slide on a film of liquid. Friction and wear are directly influenced by the thickness and shear properties (viscosity) of the liquid. Where appropriate, the use of a high-viscosity lubricant usually results in a relatively thick film and a low wear rate. However, high sliding speeds cannot be accommodated by a viscous film, because excessive heat generated within the film causes it to become less viscous and to decompose chemically. Full-film (thick-film) lubrication, such as occurs under hydrostatic or hydrodynamic conditions, effectively separates asperities on opposing surfaces, whereas thin-film and boundary lubrication allow asperity contact. The differences among these three conditions of liquid lubrication are illustrated schematically in Fig. 17. Some special types of boundary lubricants, most notably the extreme pressure (EP) lubricants, react with a metallic surface, often at high temperatures, to produce a monomolecular film on the surface. This very thin film contaminates the mating surfaces and prevents metal-to-metal contact or adhesion. Extreme-pressure lubricants often contain extremely reactive constituents that re-form the film instantly if it is scraped off one of the surfaces. Film formation of this type is, in effect, corrosion; when it is uncontrolled or when the film is repeatedly scraped off and re-formed, deterioration of the surface can result. Solid-film lubricants must be adherent to be effective, or they allow metal-to-metal contact or introduce unwanted particles that roll and slide
Fluid film
Full-film lubrication
Fluid film
Thin-film lubrication
Boundary films
Boundary lubrication
PJa- \ 7 Schematic showing the relation of surface roughness to film thickness. Shown are conditions of full-film, thin-film, and boundary lubrication.
within the joint. When they can be kept within the joint, graphite and molybdenum disulfide make good lubricants because they shear easily in certain crystallographic directions. Hard, adherent oxide films, such as Fe3O4 on steel or anodized Al 2 O 3 on aluminum, withstand wear because they resist penetration and do not bond with most mating surfaces. Lubricating oils are relatively free-flowing organic substances that are used to lower the coefficient of friction in mechanical devices. They are available in a broad range of viscosities, and many are blended or contain additives to make them suitable for specific uses. In general, lubricating substances that are fluid at 20 0C (70 0F) are termed oils; lubricating substances that are solid or semifluid at 20 0C (70 0F) are termed greases or fats. Oils are derived from petroleum (mineral oils) or from plants or animals (fixed oils). Mineral oils are classified according to source (type of crude), refining process (distillate or residual), and commercial use. The commercial mineral oil base products consist mainly of saturated hydrocarbons (even though naphthene-base crudes are predominantly unsaturated) in the form of chain or ring molecules that are chemically inactive and do not have polar heads. These commercial products may or may not contain waxes, volatile compounds, fixed oils, and special-purpose additives. Fixed oils and fats differ from mineral oils in that they consist of an alcohol radical and a fatty-acid radical, can be reacted with an alkali (sodium hydroxide or potassium hydroxide, for example) to form glycerin or soap, cannot be distilled without decomposing, and contain 9 to 12.5% oxygen. All fixed oils are insoluble in water and, except for castor oil, are insoluble in alcohol at room temperature. Fixed oils are generally considered to have greater oiliness than mineral oils. Oiliness is a term that describes the relative ability of any lubricant to act as a boundary lubricant. Lubricating grease, as defined by ASTM, is a solid to semifluid product consisting of a dispersion of a thickening agent in a liquid lubricant. In more practical terms, most greases are stabilized mixtures of mineral oil and metallic soap. The soap is usually a calcium, sodium, or lithium compound and is present in the form of fibers whose size and configuration are characteristic of the metallip radical in the soap compound. Solid lubricants, which are solids with lubricating properties, can be maintained between two moving surfaces to reduce friction and wear. Numerous solid inorganic and organic compounds, as well as certain metals and composite materials, may be classified as solid lubricants. Molybdenum disulfide (MoS2), graphite, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), and graphite fluoride (CFx) are the solid lubricants most commonly used. Several hundred different compounds and mixtures have been described as potential solid lubricants. Increasingly, solid lubricants are being vapor deposited for use in harsh environments in which liquids would evaporate or congeal.
Wear Testing (Ref 1) Because different types of wear occur in machinery, many different types of wear tests have been developed to evaluate effects of wear on materials and surface treatments. Consequently, the selection of the right type of wear test for each investigation is important in order to achieve useful and meaningful engineering data. More than one type of wear can attack the same part, such as sliding wear and impact wear in printing presses, or erosive wear and abrasive wear on extrusion machine screws for plastics. Sometimes wear can operate in the presence of corrosive or chemically active environments, and synergistic chemomechanical effects are possible. Selection of appropriate wear test methods begins with an assessment of the type of wear involved in each problem area. Wear testing is performed for one or more of the following reasons: to screen materials, surface treatments, or lubricants for a certain application; to help develop new, wear-resistant materials, surface treatments, or lubricants; to establish the relationship between the manufacturing, processing, or finishing methods applied to a certain machine part and its wear performance; or to better understand and model the fundamental nature of a certain type of wear. Surprising to some, the wear resistance of a given material is not a basic material property, like elastic modulus or yield strength. Rather, the wear behavior of a material depends on the conditions of its use. Therefore, the first step in wear testing is to recognize how the results of the work will be used. Only then can the appropriate test method(s), testing parameters, and a useful format for reporting the results be selected. Test Methods Standardized Wear Testing Methods. A list of ASTM standardized wear test methods, organized by type of wear or surface damage, is given in Table 10. This is by no means a complete list of all available test methods; many nonstandardized tests developed by individual companies or research organizations are also frequently used. Oftentimes if a suitable standard test method does not exist for a specific type of wear problem, an organization may decide to develop its own internal wear-testing standards best suited to its purposes. Variables to be Controlled in Wear Testing. Each wear mode is influenced by a different set of physical variables. Therefore, it is important to recognize what factors must be controlled, or at least monitored, in the design of wear testing procedures. Table 11 lists the major experimental variables that are controlled in conducting wear tests of various types. Environmental and other factors, which should he considered in interpreting the results of the wear tests, are also listed. Sometimes these secondary factors must be controlled in order to simulate a given application, but
Table 10
ASTM wear test methods grouped by wear type illustrated in Fig. 2
Form of wear
Abrasive wear, 2-body
Designation
G 56 G 132 G 119
Abrasive wear, 3-body
G 65 G 81 G 105
Erosive wear, cavitating fluid Erosive wear, liquid droplets Erosive wear, slurry
G 32
Erosive wear, solid particles Fretting wear
G 76 D 4170
Sliding wear
D 2266
G 73 G 75
D 2670 D 2882
D 2981 D 3702 D 3704
D 4172 D 5001
G 77 G 99 G 119 G 133 G 137
Surface damage, galling
G 98
Surface damage, scoring
D 2782
Title
Test Method for Abrasiveness of Ink-Impregnated Fabric Printer Ribbon Test Method for Pin Abrasion Testing Guide for Determining Synergism between Wear and Corrosion Test Method for Measuring Abrasion Using the Dry Sand/Rubber Wheel Apparatus Practice for Jaw Crusher Gouging Abrasion Test Test Method for Conducting Wet Sand/Rubber Wheel Abrasion Tests Test Method for Cavitation Erosion Using Vibratory Apparatus Practice for Liquid Impingement Erosion Testing Test Method for Determination of Slurry Abrasivity (Miller Number) and Slurry Abrasion Resistance Response of Materials (SAR Number) Test Method for Conducting Erosion Tests by Solid Particle Impingement Using Gas Jets Test Method for Fretting Wear Protection of Lubricating Greases Test Method for Wear Preventative Characteristics of Lubricating Grease (Four-Ball Method) Test Method for Measuring Wear Properties of Fluid Lubricants (Falex Pin and Vee Block Method) Test Method for Indicating Wear Characteristics of Petroleum and Non-Petroleum Hydraulic Fluids in a Constant Volume Vane Pump Test Method for Wear Life of Solid Lubricants in Oscillating Motion Test Method for Wear Rate of Materials in Self-Lubricated Rubbing Contact Using a Thrust Washer Testing Machine Test Method for Wear Preventative Properties of Lubricating Greases Using the (Falex) Block on Ring Test Machine in Oscillating Motion Test Method for Wear Preventative Characteristics of Lubricating Fluid (Four-Ball Method) Test Method for Measurement of Lubricity of Aviation Turbine Fuels by the Ball-on-Cylinder Lubricity Evaluator (BOCLE) Test Method for Ranking Resistance of Materials to Sliding Wear Using Block on Ring Wear Test Test Method for Wear Testing with a Pin-on-Disk Apparatus Guide for Determining Synergism between Wear and Corrosion Test Method for Linearly Reciprocating Ball-on-Flat Sliding Wear Test Method for Ranking Resistance of Plastic Materials to Sliding Wear Using a Block-on-Ring Configuration Test Method for Galling Resistance of Materials Test Method for Extreme-Pressure Properties of Lubricating Fluids
Means of wear measurement
Surface profiling or other method Mass loss Mass loss and corrosion-related measurements Mass loss Mass loss ratio Mass loss, normalized by wheel dimensions Mass loss Mass loss Mass loss
Mass loss Mass loss ratio Wear scar diameter "Teeth wear" apparatus-specific measurement of wear Mass loss
Number of revolutions to failure, as indicated by friction Thickness change
Wear scar width
Wear scar diameter Wear scar diameter
Wear scar width Ball: wear scar diameter, disk: profile Mass loss and corrosion-related measurements Ball: wear scar diameter, flat: profile Mass loss
Visual inspection, critical load for galling "OK" value of for load just below critical scoring condition
usually it is sufficient just to measure and document them as an aid to interpreting the data. Wear Testing Devices: Commercially Manufactured and Custom Made. Table 12 exemplifies the types of simple testing geometries common to evaluating the various forms of wear. While simple geometries, such as those in Table 12, represent one approach to testing, some wear
Table 11 types
Parameters that are commonly controlled and reported when conducting wear tests of various
Category
Subcategory
Sliding
Abrasive wear, 2-body
Abrasive wear, 3-body
"Adhesive"
Fretting wear
Polishing wear
Impact
2-body
Impingement, liquid and solid
Cavitation erosion
Rolling
Rolling contact fatigue Rolling with slip
Supplementary characterizations or variables(a)
Typical variables
Load (contact pressure), abrasive type, binder type, backing body, whether repeated contact or sliding against fresh abrasive lubricant or coolant, surface speed, temperature, duration of contact Load (contact pressure), abrasive type, concentration, hardness of counterbody(b), coolant or lubricant, whether repeated contact or continual motion against fresh abrasive surface, surface speed, temperature, duration of contact Load (contact pressure or stress), relative velocity, contact geometry, type of motion (unidirectional or oscillating), duration, sliding distance, or time of sliding, temperature Load (contact stress), contact geometry, amplitude of oscillation, frequency of oscillation, number of cycles or time, choice of lubricant Size of polishing medium, concentration of medium, liquid used for suspension, normal pressure, type of motion bodies (platten and specimen), time of exposure, temperature, substrate (pad type) Force of impact, speed of impact, geometry of contact, angle of impact, repetition rate, duration/number of impacts, temperature Average impact velocity, particle stream shape (by nozzle design), impingement angle of the stream to the surface, duration of exposure, temperature of the specimen and/or jet Test geometry, frequency of moving body oscillation, temperature of the fluid, fluid type, duration of exposure Load (elastic contact stress), rpm of roller(s), test duration, temperature Load (elastic contact stress), rpm of roller(s), % slip, test duration, temperature
Method of surface preparation, material characterization
Method of surface preparation, material characterization
Method of surface preparation, cleaning, surface finish of bodies, type of material/lubricant, method of supplying the lubricant, relative humidity Surface finish, relative humidity, debris characteristics Particle composition and geometric description, method of medium introduction, initial surface finish of specimen Material characterization, environment and relative humidity, surface finish of bodies Particle velocity or flux distribution, density of particles, particle shape description, particle size distribution, particle composition Material characterization
Lubricant/material characterization, surface finish of rollers Lubricant/material type, surface finish of rollers
(a) These quantities are often used to characterize the testing conditions or materials even though they may not be directly controlled in an experiment. In certain cases, they could be treated as variables themselves, (b) In certain types of 3-body abrasive wear tests, notably the dry sand-rubber wheel test, the hardness of the material that is pressing the loose abrasive particles against the test specimen can have a significant effect on the results.
machines are either one-of-a-kind or highly specialized for simulating a particular application. Commercially manufactured sliding and rollingcontact wear testing machines are available in a number of contact geometries. Abrasion and erosion testing machines are also commercially available. Some testers, called "universal" or "multimode" testers, are configured to permit the user to change the contact geometry from, for example, block-on-ring to pin-on-disk, using accessory fixtures and drive mechanisms. Several manufacturers or retail sellers of wear testing machines advertise on the Internet and can be found through key-word searches. As indicated earlier, wear and chemical attack can have synergistic effects. Special procedures have been developed to study these phenomena (ASTM G 119). Specialized commercial testing machines have also been developed to study such effects, like machines that simulate the movements of surgical knee and hip replacement components in bodylike fluids.
Table 12 Category
Sliding
Typical testing geometries for wear tests of various types Subcategory
Abrasive wear, 2-body
Abrasive wear, 3-body
"Adhesive"
Fretting wear Polishing wear Impact
2-body Impingement, liquid and solid
Cavitation erosion
Rolling
Rolling contact fatigue Rolling with slip
Testing geometry
Flat pin-on-rotating abrasive drum (spiral path), reciprocating pin-on-abrasive flat, flat pin-on-moving abrasive belt, traversing pin-on-abrasive disk (spiral path), twin rotating abrasive wheels Dry sand fed between a rotating rubber wheel and a flat coupon, reciprocating flat pin-on-a plate in a slurry bath, block-onrotating ring in a slurry bath, ball mill, or tumbling wear test Block-on-ring (flat or conformal face), pin-on-disk, double rubshoe on rotating disk, reciprocating pin-on-flat, flat-on-flat (thrust washer), pin clamped between V-blocks, ball spinning on three flats (120° apart) Oscillating pin-on-flat, pivoting ball-in-socket, clamped specimen on the sides of a tensile coupon Flat specimen-on-vibrating lap, flat specimens in an orbital polishing or lapping machine Repetitive "hammer"-on-flat Liquid jet aimed at the specimen, gas jet with entrained particles, spinning specimens through a gravity-fed stream of particles, centrifugal particle "slinger" apparatus Oscillatory "horn" suspended above the specimen in a fluid, flowing fluid through a submerged nozzle aimed at the specimen Disk-on-disk rolling contact (equal circumferential speed), rod spinning between three captive balls Disk-on-disk rolling contact (unequal circumferential speed)
As with mechanical testing in general, commercial wear testing machines are being computer automated. While automation has definite advantages, it also drives up the price of these machines. Testers with infrequent wear problems who do not want to make a significant capital investment in wear testing may be faced with the decision as to whether to construct their own machine, purchase a commercial machine, have a custom machine built, or obtain the services of a fee-testing laboratory. Published surveys, conducted years ago by organizations such as the American Society of Lubrication Engineers (now called the Society of Tribologists and Lubrication Engineers) and the European Space Agency, have revealed the existence of hundreds of different wear testing devices. Some of these devices have similar geometries and operational features; however, even relatively similar-looking machines can produce different wear results due to subtle differences in construction features (fixture stiffness, method of specimen mounting, mechanical damping capacity, natural frequencies, heat flow, etc.). The number of custom-designed wear testing devices probably exceeds the number of commercially produced machines. Unfortunately, people who decide to build their own wear testing machines may not be aware of certain subtleties in wear tester design and, thus, may ultimately generate questionable results or results that cannot be reproduced elsewhere. There is still a great deal of applied research needed to better understand differences in wear results arising from different machine designs and measurement techniques.
References
1. PJ. Blau, Wear Testing, Metals Handbook Desk Edition, 2nd ed., J.R. Davis, Ed., ASM International, 1998, p 1342-1347 2. K.G. Budinski, Wear Modes, Surface Engineering for Wear Resistance, Prentice Hall, 1988, p 15-43 3. AJ. Sedriks and T.O. Mulhearn, The Effect of Work-Hardening on the Mechanics of Cutting in Simulated Abrasive Processes, Wear, VoI 7, 1964, p 451 4. T. Sasaki and K. Okamura, The Cutting Mechanism of Abrasive Grain, Bull Jpn. Soc. Mech. Eng., VoI 12, 1960, p 547 5. J.S. Hansen, Relative Erosion Resistance of Several Metals, Erosion: Prevention and Useful Applications, STP 664, ASTM, 1979, p 148-162 6. R.A. Corbett, "A Modified G-75 Abrasion Test for Corrosive Environments," Corrosion Testing Laboratories, Inc., Newark, DE 7. L.E. Samuels et al., Sliding Wear Mechanisms, Fundamentals of Friction and Wear of Materials, D. A. Rigney, Ed., American Society for Metals, 1981, p 1 3 ^ 2 8. KP Bowden and D. Tabor, The Friction and Lubrication of Solids, VoI 1 and 2, Clarendon Press, 1950 and 1966 9. J.F. Archard, Contact and Rubbing of Flat Surfaces, /. Appl. Phys., VoI 24, 1953, p 981-988 10. M.M. Kruschov, Resistance of Metals to Wear by Abrasion; Related to Hardness, Institute of Mechanical Engineers Conference: Lubrication and Wear, 1975, p 655-659 11. R.C. Tucker, Jr., Plasma and Detonation Gun Deposition Techniques, Deposition Technologies for Films and Coatings, R.F. Bunshah et al., Ed., Noyes Publications, 1982, p 454^189 12. CN. Rowe, Some Aspects of the Heat of Absorption in the Function of a Boundary Lubricant, Trans. ASLE, VoI 9, 1966 13. L.K. Ives, M.B. Peterson, and E.P. Whitenton, "Galling: Mechanism and Measurement," National Bureau of Standards Report, p 33-40
Selected References Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology, VoI 18, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1992 M.B. Peterson and W.O. Winer, Ed., Wear Control Handbook, American Society for Mechanical Engineers, 1980 D.A. Rigney, Ed., Fundamentals of Friction and Wear of Metals, American Society for Metals, 1981
J.A. Schey, Tribology in Metalworking: Friction, Lubrication, and Wean American Society for Metals, 1983 A.Z. Szeri, Tribology: Friction, Lubrication, and Wear, McGraw-Hill, 1980
CHAPTER
T f
S u r f a c e C
h
a
n
g
E n g i n e e r i n g e
t h e
t o
S u r f a c e
M e t a l l u r g y
THE SURFACE-ENGINEERING TREATMENTS described in this Chapter include selective surface hardening by flame, induction, or highenergy beam heating, laser melting and quenching, and shot peening. None of these processes change the surface chemistry, but rather they improve properties such as wear and fatigue by altering the surface metallurgy. Selective Surface H a r d e n i n g Surface hardening in a general sense involves many processes that improve the wear resistance of parts while utilizing the tough interior properties of the steel or cast iron component. In this section, surface hardening is limited to localized heat treating processes that produce a hard quenched surface without introducing additional alloying species. This approach consists of hardening the surface by flame, induction, laserbeam, or electron-beam heating. More detailed information on surface hardening of steels can be found in Heat Treating, Volume 4 of the ASM Handbook. Flame Hardening Flame hardening consists of austenitizing the surface of steel by heating with an oxyacetylene or oxyhydrogen torch and immediately quenching with water. After quenching, the microstructure of the surface layer consists of hard martensite over a lower-strength interior core of other steel morphologies such as ferrite and pearlite. A prerequisite for proper flame
hardening is that the steel must have adequate carbon and other alloy additions to produce the desired hardness, because there is no change in composition. Flame-hardening equipment utilizes direct impingement of a high-temperature flame or high-velocity combustion product gases to austenitize the component surface and quickly cool the surface faster than the critical cooling rate to produce martensite in the steel. This is necessary because the hardenability of the component is fixed by the original composition of the steel. Thus, equipment design is critical to success of the operation. Flame-heating equipment may be a single torch with a specially designed head or an elaborate apparatus that automatically indexes, heats, and quenches parts. With improvements in gas-mixing equipment, infrared temperature measurement and control, and burner rig design, flame hardening has been accepted as a reliable heat treating process that is adaptable to general or localized surface hardening for small or medium-to-high production requirements. The flame-hardening process is used for a wide variety of applications. These include (1) parts that are so large that conventional furnace treatments are impractical or uneconomical, (2) prevention of detrimental treatment of the entire component when only small segments of the part require heat treatment, and (3) use of less costly material to obtain the desired surface properties where alloyed steels would be normally applied. Flame hardening is limited to hardenable steels (wrought or cast) and cast iron. Typical hardnesses obtained for the flame-hardened grades depend on the quench media (Table 1). The practical level of minimum surface hardness attainable with water quenching for various carbon contents is shown in Fig. 1. Induction Hardening
Hardness, HRC
Induction hardening is a versatile heating method that involves placing a steel part in the magnetic field generated by high-frequency alternating
Carbon, % Fig. 1 Relationship of carbon content to minimum surface hardness attain^* able by flame or induction heating and water quenching. Practical minimum carbon content can be determined from this curve. Source: Ref 1
Table 1
Response of steels and cast irons to flame hardening Typical hardness, HRC, as affected by quenchant
Material
Water(b)
Air(a)
Oil(b)
50-60 55-62
52-58 58-62 58-62
45-55 50-55
52-57(c) 55-60
33-50 55-60 60-63 62-65 45-55 55-62 58-64
50-60 50-60
58-62 60-63
62-65 62-65
45-55 50-60 55-60 55-60
52-57(c) 55-60 58-62 61-63 50-55 52-56 58-62 53-57 56-60 52-56 55-60 52-60 52-57 55-63
55-62 60-64 63-65 63-65 55-60 55-60 62-65 60-63 62-65 60-63 62-64 55-60 58-62 62-64
58-62 62-65 58-62
63-65 64-66 62-65
Plain-carbon steels 1025-1035 1040-1050 1055-1075 1080-1095 1125-1137 1138-1144 1146-1151
Carburized grades of plain-carbon steels(d) 1010-1020 1108-1120 Alloy steels 1340-1345 3140-3145 3350 4063 4130-4135 4140-4145 4147^150 4337^340 4347 4640 52100 6150 8630-8640 8642-8660
52-56 58-62 53-57 56-60 52-56 55-60 48-53 55-63
Carburized grades of alloy steels(d) 3310 4615-4620 8615-8620
55-60 58-62
Martensitic stainless steels 410,416 414, 431 420 440 (typical)
A2-A1 49-56 55-59
41^4 42-47 49-56 55-59
52-56
49-48 48-52 35^3 52-56 56-59
Cast irons (ASTM classes) Class 30 Class 40 Class 45010 50007, 53004, 60003 Class 80002 Class 60-45-15 Class 80-60-03
52-56
43^8 48-52 35^5 55-60 56-61 35-45 55-60
(a) To obtain the hardness results indicated, those areas not directly heated must be kept relatively cool during the heating process, (b) Thin sections are susceptible to cracking when quenched with oil or water, (c) Hardness is slightly lower for material heated by spinning or combination progressive-spinning methods than it is for material heated by progressive or stationary methods, (d) Hardness values of carburized cases containing 0.90-1.10% C. Source: Ref 1
current passing through an inductor, usually a water-cooled copper coil. The depth of hardening increases as the frequency of the alternating current decreases. Other variables important to the process include the coil current, heating time, and the coil design (Ref 2). The specific ferrous alloys that are commonly used in induction surface hardening are the same as those used in flame hardening (Table 1). The minimum carbon contents to obtain specific surface hardness are also shown in Fig. 1. Electrical
Table 2
Comparison of flame- and induction-hardening processes
Characteristic Equipment Applicable material Speed of heating Depth of hardening Processing Part size Tempering Can be automated Operator skills Control of process Operator comfort Cost Equipment Per piece
Flame
Induction
Oxyfuel torch, special head quench system Ferrous alloys, carbon steels, alloy steels, cast irons Few seconds to few minutes 1.2-6.2 mm (0.050-0.250 in.)
Power supply, inductor, quench system Same
One part at a time No limit Required Yes Significant skill required Attention required Hot, eye protection required
1-10 s 0.4-1.5 mm (0.015-0.060 in.); 0.1 mm (0.004 in.) for impulse Same Must fit in coil Same Yes Little skill required after setup Very precise Can be done in suit
Low Best for large work
High Best for small work
Source: Ref 2
properties of the alloy are an important consideration when selecting induction treatment as a surface-hardening technique. In induction hardening, the electrical resistivity and magnetic properties of the alloy can produce significant differences in heating characteristics. Thus, different steels require differing induction-heating parameters. Table 2 compares the flame- and induction-hardening processes. High-Energy Beam Hardening Electron- and laser-beam methods use high-energy beams to heat treat the surface of hardenable steel. The electron-beam (EB) heat treating process uses a concentrated beam of high-velocity electrons as an energy source to heat selected parts of the steel component. In laser heat treatment, a laser beam is used to harden localized areas of ferrous parts. These processes are similar to flame and induction hardening, except that the need for quenchants is eliminated as long as a sufficient size workpiece is being used. Electron-Beam Hardening. In EB hardening, the surface of the hardenable steel is heated rapidly to the austenitizing temperature, usually with a defocused electron beam to prevent melting. The mass of the workpiece conducts the heat away from the treated surface at a rate that is rapid enough to produce hardening. Materials for application of EB hardening must contain sufficient carbon and alloy content to produce martensite. With the rapid heating associated with this process, the carbon and alloy content should be in a form that will quickly allow complete solid solution in the austenite at the temperatures produced by the electron beam. In addition, the mass of the workpiece should be sufficient to allow proper quenching; for example, the part thickness must be at least ten times the depth of hardening, and hardened areas must be properly spaced to prevent tempering of previously hardened areas. The most suitable materials for EB hardening are the same steels used in flame hardening (Ref 2):
1045 to 1080 carbon steels Medium- to high-carbon alloy steels (4140, 4340, 8645, 52100, etc.) Pearlitic matrix cast irons Wl, W2, Ol, O2, L2, L6, Sl, S2 tool steels There are two basic types of EB systems: stationary or movable. In the movable process, the workpiece is fixed and the gun is moved to produce heating for the hardening. Stationary guns require manipulation of the workpiece under the beam. However, in both cases the area to be hardened on the workpiece must be in a line of sight with the beam. Gun movement or workpiece manipulation is accomplished by computer control to produce any desired pattern, and the beam can be oscillated or pulsed by standard controls. To produce an electron beam, a high vacuum of 10~5 torr (10~3 Pa) is required in the region where the electrons are emitted and accelerated. This vacuum environment protects the emitter from oxidizing and avoids scattering of the electrons while they are still traveling at a relatively low velocity. Electron-beam hardening in hard vacuum units requires that the part be placed in a chamber that is sufficiently large to manipulate the gun or the workpiece. Out-of-vacuum units usually involve shrouding the workpiece; a partial vacuum (IO"2 torr, or 13 Pa) is obtained in the work area by mechanical pumps. Laser-Beam Hardening. Lasers can be used to perform selective hardening with hardening depths and material constraints similar to those of EB hardening. Laser transformation hardening produces thin surface zones, which are heated and cooled rapidly, resulting in very fine martensitic microstructures, even in steels with relatively low hardenability. This process produces typical case depths for steel ranging from 0.75 to 1.3 mm (0.030-0.050 in.) depending on the laser power range, and hardness values as high as 60 HRC. Laser processing has advantages over EB hardening in that laser hardening does not require a vacuum, wider hardening profiles are possible, and there can be greater accessibility to hard-to-get areas with the flexibility of optical manipulation of light energy. A major disadvantage of lasers is the need to use surface treatments to prevent reflectivity of the laser beam.
Laser Melting (Ref 3) Processing. Laser melting requires higher power densities than the levels used for laser transformation hardening. The workpiece is often made absorptive either by using coatings similar to those used for laser heating or by increasing surface roughness, for example, by sand blasting. Laser melting can harden alloys that cannot be hardened by laser transformation hardening. In ferritic malleable gray iron, melting enhances the diffusion of carbon, and the ensuing rapid quench produces a hardened region.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 2 Cross sections of laser-melted cast iron surfaces, (a) Gray iron, (b) Ductile iron. Source: Ref 3
Weight loss (mg/mm2)
Metallurgical changes with laser melting are in the forms of grain refinement, solid solutions, and fine dispersions of precipitates. All of these can contribute to the hardening and strengthening of the surface. Lasermelted surfaces of cast irons appear dendritic, as shown in Fig. 2(a) for gray iron and in Fig. 2(b) for ductile iron. Below the melt zone is the heataffected zone, which appears in lighter contrast in Fig. 2. In the solidified melt in cast irons, a ledeburite (mixture of austenite and cementite) structure generally forms. Hardening is caused by graphite dissolution for form cementite and austenite transformation to martensite. Wear Behavior of Laser-Melted Surfaces. Figure 3 shows that significant improvements in erosion behavior of gray and ductile iron are possible with laser melting. Improved wear resistance can also be obtained with laser-melted tool steels.
Ductile iron, as-received Gray iron, as-received Ductile iron, laser melted Gray iron, laser melted erosion
Test time (hours) PJa- 3 Erosive wear behavior of as-received and laser-melted gray and ductile "* irons. Source: Ref 3
Stress, % of tensile strength
Peened Stressed in bending
Peened
Not peened
Stressed in torsion Not peened Number of cycles to failure Fig. 4 Fatigue curves for peened and unpeened steel spring wires Shot Peening
Shot peening is a method of cold working in which compressive stresses are induced in the exposed surface layers of metallic parts by the impingement of a stream of shot, directed at the metal surface at high velocity under controlled conditions. It differs from blast cleaning in primary purpose and in the extent to which it is controlled to yield accurate and reproducible results. Although shot peening cleans the surface being peened, this function is incidental. The major purpose of shot peening is to increase fatigue strength (Fig. 4). The process has other useful applications, such as relieving tensile stresses that contribute to stress-corrosion cracking, forming and straightening of metal parts, and testing the adhesion of silver-plate on steel. More detailed information on shot peening can be found in Ref 4. References 1. T. Ruglic, Flame Hardening, Heat Treating, VoI 4, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1991, p 260-267 2. K.G. Budinski, Surface Hardening by Flame and Induction, Chapter 5, Surface Engineering for Wear Resistance, Prentice Hall, 1988,
p 120-137
3. K.P. Cooper, Laser Surface Processing, Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology, VoI 18, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1992, p 861-872 4. T. Kostilnik, Shot Peening, Surface Engineering, VoI 5, ASM Handbook, ASM International, 1994, p 126-135
CHAPTER
kJ
S u r f a c e C
h
a
n
g
E n g i n e e r i n g e
t h e
t o
S u r f a c e
C h e m i s t r y
SURFACE TREATMENTS that change the surface chemistry of a metal or alloy, but that do not involve intentional buildup or increase in part dimension, include: Chemical or electrochemical conversion treatments that produce complex phosphates, chromates, or oxides on the metal surface Thermochemical diffusion heat treatments that involve the introduction of interstitial elements, such as carbon, nitrogen, or boron, into a ferrous alloy surface at elevated temperatures Pack cementation diffusion treatments that involve the introduction of aluminum, chromium, or silicon into an alloy surface Surface modification by ion implantation, which involves the introduction of ionized species (virtually any element) into the substrate using a beam of high-velocity ions Surface modification by a combination of laser-beam melting and alloying
Phosphate Chemical Conversion Coatings
Phosphate coating is the treatment of iron, steel, galvanized steel, or aluminum with a dilute solution of phosphoric acid and other chemicals in which the surface of the metal, reacting chemically with the phosphoric acid media, is converted to an integral, mildly protective layer of
insoluble crystalline phosphate. The weight and crystalline structure of the coating and the extent of penetration of the coating into the base metal can be controlled by (Ref 1): Method of cleaning before treatment Use of activating rinses containing titanium and other metals of compounds Method of applying the solution Temperature, concentration, and duration of treatment Modification of the chemical composition of phosphating solution The method of applying phosphate coatings is usually determined by the size and shape of the article to be coated. Small items, such as nuts, bolts, screws, and stampings, are coated in tumbling barrels immersed in phosphating solution. Large fabricated articles, such as refrigerator cabinets, are spray coated with solution while on conveyors. Automobile bodies are sprayed with or immersed in phosphating solution. Steel sheet and strip can be passed continuously through the phosphating solution or can be sprayed. Phosphate coatings range in thickness from less than 3 to 50 |xm (0.12 mils). Coating weight (grams per square meter of coated area), rather than coating thickness, has been adopted as the basis for expressing the amount of coating deposited.
Types of Phosphate Coatings Three principal types of phosphate coatings are in general use: zinc, iron, and manganese. Zinc phosphate coatings encompass a wide range of weights and crystal characteristics, ranging from heavy films with coarse crystals to ultrathin microcrystalline deposits. Zinc phosphate coatings vary from light to dark gray in color. Coatings are darker as the carbon content of the underlying steel increases, as the ferrous content of the coating increases, as heavy metal ions are incorporated into the phosphating solution, or as the substrate metal is acid pickled prior to phosphating. Zinc phosphating solutions containing active oxidizers usually produce lighter-colored coatings than do solutions using milder accelerators. Zinc phosphate coatings can be applied by spray, immersion, or a combination of the two. Coatings can be used for any of the following applications of phosphating: base for paint or oil; aid to cold forming, tube drawing, and wire drawing; increasing wear resistance; or rustproofing. Spray coatings on steel surfaces range in weight from 1.08 to 10.8 g/m2 (3.5 X 10~3 to 3.5 X 10" 2 oz/ft2); immersion coatings, from 1.61 to 43.0 g/m2 (5.28 X 10~3 to 1.41 oz/ft2). Iron phosphate coatings were the first to be used commercially. Early iron phosphating solutions consisted of ferrous phosphate/phosphoric acid
used at temperatures near boiling and produced dark gray coatings with coarse crystals. The term iron phosphate coatings refers to coatings resulting from alkali-metal phosphate solutions operated at pH in the range of 4.0 to 5.0, which produce exceedingly fine crystals. The solutions produce an amorphous coating consisting primarily of iron oxides and having an interference color range of iridescent blue to reddish-blue color. A typical formulation for an iron phosphate bath is: Component Phosphate salts Phosphoric acid Molybdate accelerator Detergents (anionic/nonionic)
Composition, % 12-15 3-4 0.25-0.50 8-10
Basically, then, iron phosphate formulations consist of primary phosphate salts and accelerators dissolved in a phosphoric acid solution. It is the acid that initiates the formation of a coating on a metal surface. When acid attacks the metal and begins to be consumed, solution pH at the metal surface rises slightly. This is what causes the primary phosphate salts to drop out of solution and react with the metal surface, forming a crystalline coating. Although iron phosphate coatings are applied to steel to provide a receptive surface for the bonding of fabric, wood, and other materials, their chief application is as a base for subsequent films of paint. Processes that produce iron phosphate coatings are also available for treatment of galvanized and aluminum surfaces. Iron phosphate coatings have excellent adherence and provide good resistance to flaking from impact or flexing when painted. Corrosion resistance, either through film or scribe undercut, is usually less than that attained with zinc phosphate. However, a good iron phosphate coating often outperforms a poor zinc phosphate coating. Spray application of iron phosphate coatings is most frequently used, although immersion application also is practical. The accepted range of coating weights is 0.21 to 0.86 g/m2 (6.9 X 10" 4 to 0.26 oz/ft2). Little benefit is derived from exceeding this range, and coatings of less than 0.21 g/m2 (6.9 X 10~4 oz/ft2) are likely to be nonuniform or discontinuous. Quality iron phosphate coatings are routinely deposited at temperatures from 25 to 65 0C (80-150 0F) by either spray or immersion methods. Manganese phosphate coatings are applied to ferrous parts (bearings, gears, and internal combustion engine parts, for example) for break-in and to prevent galling. These coatings are usually dark gray. However, because almost all manganese phosphate coatings are used as an oil base and the oil intensifies the coloring, manganese phosphate coatings are usually black in appearance. In some instances, a calcium-modified zinc phosphate coating can be substituted for manganese phosphate to impart break-in and antigalling properties.
Manganese phosphate coatings are applied only by immersion, requiring times ranging from 5 to 30 min. Coating weights normally vary from 5.4 to 32.3 g/m2 (1.8 X 10~2 to 9.83 oz/ft2), but can be greater if required. The manganese phosphate coating usually preferred is tight and finegrain, rather than loose and coarse-grain. However, desired crystal size varies with service requirements. In many instances, the crystal is refined as the result of some pretreatment (certain types or cleaners and/or conditioning agents based on manganese phosphate) of the metal surface. Manganese-iron phosphate coatings are usually formed from high-temperature baths from 90 to 95 0C (190-200 0 F).
Applications On the basis of pounds of chemicals consumed or tons of steel treated, the greatest use of phosphate coatings is as a base for paint. Phosphate coatings are also used to provide: A base for oil or other rust-preventive material Lubricity and resistance to wear, galling, or scoring of parts moving in contact, with or without oil A surface that facilitates cold forming Temporary or short-time resistance to mild corrosion A base for adhesives in plastic-metal laminations or rubber-to-metal applications Corrosion Protection. Conversion of a metal surface to an insoluble phosphate coating provides a metal with a physical barrier against moisture. The degree of corrosion protection that phosphate coatings impart to surfaces of ferrous metals depends on uniformity of coating coverage, coating thickness, density, and crystal size, and the type of final seal employed. Coatings can be produced with a wide range of thicknesses, depending on the method of cleaning before treatment, composition of the phosphating solution, temperature, and duration of treatment. In phosphating, no electric current is used, and formation of the coating depends primarily on contact between the phosphating solution and the metal surface and on the temperature of the solution. Consequently, uniform coatings are produced on irregularly shaped articles, in recessed areas, and on threaded and flat surfaces, because of the chemical nature of the coating process. The affinity of heavy phosphate coatings for oil or wax is used to increase the corrosion resistance of these coatings. Frequently, phosphatecoated articles are finished by a dip in nondrying or drying oils that contain corrosion inhibitors. The articles are then drained or centrifuged to remove the excess oil. Medium to heavy zinc phosphate coatings, and occasionally, heavy manganese phosphate coatings are used for corrosion resistance when
supplemented by an oil or wax coating. Zinc phosphate plus oil or wax is usually used to treat cast, forged, and hot-rolled steel nuts, bolts, screws, cartridge clips, and many similar items. Manganese phosphate plus oil or wax is also used on cast iron and steel parts. Phosphate Coating as an Aid in Forming Steel. The contact pressure used in deep-drawing operations sets up a great amount of friction between the steel surface and the die. The phosphate coating of steel as a metalforming lubricant, before it is drawn: Reduces friction Increases speed of the drawing operations Reduces consumption of power Increases the life of tools and dies Wear Resistance. Phosphating is a widely used method of reducing wear on machine elements. The ability of phosphate coating to reduce wear depends on uniformity of the phosphate coating, penetration of the coating in to metal, and affinity of the coating for oil. A phosphate coating permits new parts to be broken in rapidly by permitting retention of an adequate film of oil on surfaces at that critical time. In addition, the phosphate coating itself functions as a lubricant during the high stress of break-in. Heavy manganese phosphate coatings (10.8 to 43.0 g/m2, or 3.5 X 10~2 to 0.14 oz/ft2), supplemented with proper lubrication, are used for wearresistance applications. Parts that are manganese phosphate coated for wear resistance are listed in Table 1. When two parts, manganese phosphated to reduce friction by providing lubricity, are put into service in contact with each other, the manganese coating is smeared between the parts. The coating acts as a buffer to prevent galling or, on heavily loaded gears, welding. The phosphate coating need not stand up for an extended length of time, because it is in initial movements that parts can be damaged and require lubricity. For example, scoring of the mating surfaces of gears usually takes place in the first few revolutions. During this time, the phosphate coating prevents close contact of the faces. As the coating is broken down in operation, some of it is packed into pits or small cavities formed in gear surfaces by the etching action of the acid during phosphating. Table 1 Parts immersion coated with manganese phosphate for wear resistance Part(a)
Components for small arms, threaded fasteners(b) Bearing races Valve tappets, camshafts Piston rings Gears(c)
Material
Coating time, min
Supplementary coatings
Cast iron or steel; forged steel
15-30
Oils, waxes
High-alloy steel forgings or bar stock Low-alloy steel forgings or bar stock Forged steel, cast iron Forged steel, cast iron
7-15 7-15 15-30 15-30
Oils, colloidal graphite Oils, colloidal graphite Oils Oils
(a) Coating weights range from 10.8 to 43.0 g/m2 (3.5 X 10~2 to 0.14 oz/ft2). (b) Coating may be applied by barrel tumbling, (c) Coating weights range from 5.4 to 43.0 g/m2 (1.8 X 10" 2 to 0.14 oz/ft2).
Long after break-in, the material packed into the pits or coating that was originally formed in the pits prevents direct contact of mating surfaces of gear teeth. In addition, it acts as a minute reservoir for oil, providing continuing lubrication. As work hardening of the gear surfaces takes place, the coating and the etched area may disappear completely, but by this time scoring is unlikely to occur.
Chromate Chemical Conversion Coatings Chromate conversion coatings are formed by a chemical or an electrochemical treatment of metals or metallic coatings in solutions containing hexavalent chromium (Cr 6+ ) and, usually, other components. The process results in the formation of an amorphous protective coating composed of the substrate, complex chromium compounds, and other components of the processing bath. Chromate conversion coatings are applied primarily to enhance bare or painted corrosion resistance, to improve the adhesion of paint or other organic finishes, and to provide the metallic surface with a decorative finish. Chromating processes are widely used to finish aluminum, zinc, steel, magnesium, cadmium, copper, tin, nickel, silver, and other substrates. Chromate conversion coatings are most frequently applied by immersion or spraying, but other methods of application, such as brushing, roll coating, dip and squeegee, electrostatic spraying, or anodic deposition, are used in special cases. Processing Steps. Chromate coatings are applied by contacting the processed surfaces with a sequence of processing solutions. The processing baths are arranged in a series of tanks, and the surfaces to processed are transferred through the sequence of stages by using manual, semiautomatic, or automatic control. The chromate coatings are usually applied to metal parts or to a continuous metal strip running at speeds to 5 m/s (lOOOft/min). The basic processing sequence consists of the following six steps: cleaning, rinsing, conversion coating rinsing, posttreatment rinsing or decorative color rinsing, and drying. In many applications, this sequence is expanded to accommodate pickling, deoxidizing, dyeing, brightening, and other rinsing stages, or the sequence can be shortened when cleaning or posttreatment rinsing is not necessary. More detailed information on key processing steps can be found in Ref 2. Corrosion Protection. Chromate conversion coatings provide excellent bare or painted corrosion protection to the metal. The level of protection depends on the substrate metal, the type of chromate coating used, and the chromium coating weight. In unpainted applications, corrosion protection for the different conversion coatings generally increases with
coating weight, and the upper limit of the coating weight is determined by the process limitations or by the color requirement. Table 2 lists typical corrosion data measured by the ASTM B 117 method. In painted applications, the conversion coating must improve corrosion resistance and provide for good paint adhesion. The upper limit of the coating weight for the painted surfaces is normally defined by the onset of weaker paint adhesion or of corrosion problems related to paint delamination. Opinions differ widely regarding the mechanism of corrosion protection provided by the chromate coatings. The most widely advanced concepts suggest that the chromate coatings provide a barrier insulation from the environment and inhibit the cathodic corrosion reactions. Hardness and Abrasion Resistance. The hardness of chromate coatings depends strongly on the temperature during chromating and drying. Freshly made wet films are very soft and can be easily damaged by abrasion. After drying, the films develop good hardness, which allows for safe handling. However, even the dry films are susceptible to severe scratching or abrasion. Health and Safety Considerations. The disposal of spent solutions and rinse waters requires waste treatment. Hexavalent chromium must be reduced to Cr 3+ before neutralizing and precipitation. Sodium pyrosulfite (Na2S2O5) is usually used as the reducing agent in smaller operations, while for larger plants, sulfur dioxide (SO2) is preferred for economic reasons. Wastewater treatment sludges from chromating operations are considered hazardous waste. As a result, the use and disposal of chromium and chromium compounds have received much regulatory attention because of the toxicity of chromium and indications that it is a cancer-causing agent. Due to worker health and safety concerns, alternatives to chromate conversion coatings are being sought. Unfortunately, there are currently no drop-in substitutes to chromate conversion coatings that adequately match their corrosion resistance, paint adhesion, and so forth. Possible elimination of chromate conversion coatings due to regulatory restrictions is particularly troublesome for the aircraft industry. In applying the coating to the entire aircraft aluminum structure, the subsequent Table 2 Typical salt-spray data for chromate coatings on zinc and aluminum Substrate Electroplated zinc
Hot-dip zinc Aluminum alloy 3003
Type of chromate coating
Time to corrosion stain, h
Untreated Clear Iridescent Olive drab Electrolytic Untreated Clear passivate Untreated Clear Yellow-brown
<4 24-48 100-200 100-400 1000 <4 24-100 <24 60-120 250-800
rinse process can generate large quantities of chromium-containing wastes. The challenges of adequately maintaining aging aircraft will help drive the search for effective chromate substitutes. A l u m i n u m Anodizing Aluminum anodizing is an electrochemical method of converting aluminum into aluminum oxide (Al2O3) at the surface of the item being coated. It is accomplished by making the workpiece the anode while suspended in a suitable electrolytic cell. Although several metals can be anodized, including aluminum, titanium, and magnesium, only aluminum anodizing has found widespread use in industry. A more detailed discussion on anodizing can be found in Ref 3. Because a wide variety of coating properties can be produced through variations in the process, anodizing is used in almost every industry in which aluminum can be used. The broadest classification of types of anodize is according to the acid electrolyte used. Various acids have been used to produce anodic coatings, but the most common ones in current use are sulfuric (H2SO4) and chromic (CrO3) acids. There are two types of H2SO4 anodizing. The first is a room-temperature H 2 SO 4 process termed conventional anodizing, and the second is a low-temperature H 2 SO 4 process termed hardcoat anodizing. In addition to CrO3, conventional, and hardcoat anodizing, a process known as sealing can be used to enhance certain characteristics. The three common types of anodize described above are usually controlled and described through the use of military specification MIL-A8625 (Table 3). It has become standard in the industry to describe anodic coatings with the type and class nomenclature outlined in this specification.
Chromic Anodizing The CrO3 anodizing process produces a coating that is nominally 2 |xm (0.08 mil) thick. It is relatively soft and susceptible to damage through abrasion or handling. The color of the class 1 coating ranges from clear to Table 3 Classification of anodizing processes according to MIL-A-8625 Thickness Type
I II III
Class
Description
Dye
Seal
fxm
mils
1 2 1 2 1 2
CrO3 anodize CrO3 anodize, dyed H 2 SO 4 anodize H 2 SO 4 anodize, dyed Hardcoat anodize Hardcoat anodize, dyed
No Yes No Yes No Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes
1.3-2.5 1.3-2.5 7.5-15 7.5-15 46-56 46-56
0.05-0.1 0.05-0.1 0.3-0.6 0.3-0.6 1.8-2.2 1.8-2.2
gray, depending on whether the coating is sealed and on the alloy coated. The coating can be dyed to produce a class 2 coating; however, this is not generally done, because the coating is thin and does not retain the dye color well. About two-thirds of the coating thickness penetrates the base metal; one-third of the coating builds above the original base metal dimension. Thus, for a coating thickness of 2 juim (0.08 mil) per side, the dimensional change of the workpiece would be 0.7 \xm (0.028 mil) per side. Although the industry has adopted the penetration/buildup terminology, the terms are somewhat misleading. Actually, when the aluminum is converted to Al 2 O 3 it takes up more space—approximately 133% of the space previously occupied by the aluminum converted. The penetration/buildup terms are used only as a convenience in predicting dimensional change in a coated article. The corrosion resistance of this coating is very good. The coating will pass in excess of 336 h in 5% salt (NaCl) spray per ASTM B 117. Advantages and Uses. Although CrO3 anodizing is the least used of the three types of anodize, it has several advantages that make its use desirable. First, because CrO3 is much less aggressive toward aluminum than H2SO4, it should be used whenever part design is such that rinsing is difficult. Difficult rinsing designs would include welded assemblies, riveted assemblies, and porous castings. Second, a typical CrO3 anodize buildup is 0.7 |xm (0.028 mil) per side with good repeatability. Therefore, it is a very good coating to use when it is necessary to coat a precise dimension to size. Third, because CrO3 anodize produces the least reduction in fatigue strength of the three coatings, it should be used where fatigue strength is a critical factor. Fourth, the color of CrO3 anodize will change with different alloy compositions and the heat treat conditions; this makes it useful as a test of the homogeneity of structural components. Lastly, when properly applied, CrO3 anodize can be used as a mask for subsequent hardcoat anodize operations. Suitable Alloys. Most alloys can be successfully coated by the CrO3 process. Exceptions are high-silicon die-cast alloys and high-copper alloys. The rule for suitability is that any alloy containing more than 5% Cu, 7% Si, or total alloying elements of 7.5% should not be coated by this process. Relative Costs. Chromic anodize costs more than H 2 SO 4 but less than hardcoat anodize. SuIfuric Anodizing The H2SO4 process produces a coating that is normally 8 jmm (0.31 mil) in minimum thickness. Although harder than type 1 coatings, H2SO4 anodize may still be damaged by moderate handling or abrasion. The color of the class 1 coating is yellow-green because of the preferred sealing method of immersion in sodium dichromate (Na2Cr2O7). Clear coatings can also be produced by sealing in hot water. Clear coatings should be
specified by the notation "class 1, clear." This coating can also be dyed to produce a class 2 coating. This type of anodize produces the most pleasing colors of the three anodizing methods. Dyed H 2 SO 4 anodize coatings have deep colors with good repeatability. Like CrO3 anodize, H 2 SO 4 anodize coatings penetrate the base metal for two-thirds of their thickness and build above the original base metal dimension for one-third the total thickness. As with all types of anodize, the corrosion resistance of H 2 SO 4 anodize is very good; it has an ASTM B 117 salt-spray resistance of at least 336 h. Advantages and Uses. Sulfuric anodize is the most widely used type of anodize and has many desirable benefits. First, because it has a fairly hard surface, it can be used in situations that require light to moderate wear resistance. Applications include lubricated sliding assemblies and items subject to handling wear, such as front panels. Second, because it is the most aesthetically pleasing type of anodize, it should be used where final appearance is important. It can be dyed almost any color and produces deep, rich shades that make the item appear to be made of a material bearing a color throughout, rather than an applied coating. Lastly, because corrosion resistance is good, it should be used whenever corrosion resistance is needed and the specialized benefits of the other two anodize types are not required. Suitable Alloys. With the exception of high-silicon die-cast alloys, all alloys can be successfully coated with H 2 SO 4 anodize. Clarity and depth of color of the anodize increase with the purity of the alloy. Therefore, alloys should be chosen for maximum purity consistent with the physical requirements needed in the item. Relative Costs. Sulfuric anodize is the least costly and most widely available type of anodize. Hardcoat Anodizing The hardcoat anodize process produces a coating that is normally 50 |xm (2 mils) thick, although other thicknesses can be specified. The coating is extremely hard. It is described as file hard (equal to about 60-70 HRC). The color of the class 1 coating ranges from gray to bronze to almost black, depending on the alloy coated, the coating thickness, and the electrolyte temperature. The coating can be dyed to produce a class 2 coating. Because thick coatings are naturally very dark, only colors darker than natural are possible. Generally, this limits the dying of hardcoat to black in common processes. If a more extensive color choice is required, there are several proprietary hardcoat processes available to accomplish this. Hardcoat penetrates the base metal for one-half of its thickness and builds above the original base metal dimension for one-half of its thickness. Thus, for a thickness of 50 |xm (2 mils) per side, the dimensional change of the workpiece would be 25 |jim (1 mil) per side. Commercially available coating thickness tolerances are the greater of ±5 |mm or ± 10%
of the total targeted thickness. The corrosion resistance of the unsealed class 1 coating is very good and comparable to the other types of anodize. When the hardcoat anodize is sealed, as in a class 2 coating, it becomes the most corrosion-resistant type of anodize. Advantages and Uses. Hardcoat anodize, because of its variety of desirable properties, has found widespread use in manufactured products. First, because of it extreme hardness, it is used in situations in which wear resistance is required. Applications include valve/piston assemblies, drive belt pulleys, tool holders and fixtures, and many other items requiring wear resistance. Second, because of its excellent resistance to corrosion, hardcoat is used on aluminum components in harsh environments. These include outside exposure in salt air, marine components, automobile wash equipment, components for the aircraft and aerospace industries, and food preparation machines. Third, because hardcoat is an excellent electrical resistor, it can be used to insulate heat sinks for direct mounting of electrical or electronic equipment. Also, it is used in welding fixtures where some areas may need to be insulated from work. Fourth, because hardcoat is a naturally porous substance, it is used in many areas in which the bonding or impregnation of other materials to aluminum is needed. This coating bonds very well with paints and adhesives. Also, it can be impregnated with teflon (polytetrafluoroethylene, or PTFE) and many dry film lubricants to impart lubricating properties to the coating. Lastly, because of its desirable properties and also because it produces a buildup of coating, it is widely accepted as a salvage coating to restore worn or improperly machined parts to usable dimensions. Coating thicknesses in excess of 250 \xm (10 mils) per side are possible on some alloys with certain proprietary hardcoat processes. Suitable Alloys. Although almost all alloys can be coated, the 6000-series aluminum alloys produce the best hardcoat properties. As with the other anodize types, high-silicon die castings produce the lowest-quality coatings. Also, because the hardcoat process is sensitive to copper, alloys in the 2000 series should be avoided if possible. Alloys containing copper can be hardcoated, but only a relatively few commercial sources have the ability to coat these alloys with reliability. Relative Costs. Hardcoat anodize is the most expensive type of anodize. It is generally twice the cost of H2SO4 anodize and 50% more than CrO3 anodize. Sealing ofAnodized Coatings Because all of the anodic processes produce porous Al 2 O 3 coatings, it is often desirable to seal the coating to close these pores and to eliminate the path between the aluminum and the environment. Sealing involves immersing the coating in hot water; this hydrates the Al 2 O 3
and causes the coating to swell in order to close the pores. Conventional sealing is generally done at a minimum temperature of 95 0 C (200 0F) for not less than 15 min. There are also several proprietary nickel-base sealing agents available that area said to produce sealing at low temperature through catalytic action. Chromic and sulfuric anodizes are almost always sealed. However, because sealing softens the coating somewhat, hardcoat anodize is usually not sealed unless criteria other than hardness have the maximum importance in the finished coating. Corrosion Resistance of Anodized Aluminum In general, corrosion resistance of anodic coatings is greatest in approximately neutral solutions, but such coatings are usually serviceable and protective if the pH is between 4 and 8.5. More acidic and more alkaline solutions attack anodic coatings. Under atmospheric weathering, the number of pits developed in the base metal decreases exponentially with increasing coating thickness (Fig. 1). The pits may form at minute discontinuities or voids in the coating, some of which result from large second-phase particles in the microstructure. The pit density was determined by dissolving the anodic coating in a stripping solution that does not attack the metal substrate. After the 8V2year exposure, the pits were of pinpoint size and had penetrated less than 50 |xm (2.0 mils). Specimens with coatings at least 22 jxm (0.9 mil) thick were practically free of pitting. Weathering of anodic coatings involves relatively uniform erosion of the
Number of pits per square meter
Original anodic coating thickness, mils Panels exposed 8V2 years Industrial environments
Highly aggressive environments Less aggressive nonindustrial environments
Original anodic coating thickness, p.m Fifi. & 1 Number of corrosion pits in anodized aluminum 1100 as a function of * coating thickness. Source: Ref 4
Average erosion rate Alloy type
Exposure time, years
Remaining coating thickness, mils
Remaining coating thickness, jim
coating by windborne solid particles, rainfall, and some chemical reaction with pollutants. The available information indicates that such erosion occurs at a reasonably constant rate, which averaged 0.33 jxm/yr (0.013 mil/yr) for several alloys exposed to an industrial atmosphere for 18 years (Fig. 2). A three-year seacoast exposure of specimens of several alloys with 23 jmm (0.9 mil) thick sulfuric acid coatings caused no visible pitting except in several alloys of the Ixxx series and in a 2xxx alloy (Table 4). Alloys that exhibited pitting were not protected any more effectively by 50 |xm (2 mils) thick coatings. This confirms a general observation that optimal protection against atmospheric corrosion is achieved in the coating thickness range of 18 to 30 |xm (0.7-1.2 mils) and that thicker coatings provide little additional protection.
Fig. 2 Weathering data for anodically coated aluminum in an industrial at^* mosphere
Table 4 Results of three-year seacoast exposure testing of anodized aluminum alloys Alloy and temper
Results
Sheet 1100 2024-T3, alclad 5456-H343 5086-H34 6061-T6 7039-T6 7075-T6 7075-F, alclad 7079-T6
No visible pitting Edge pitting only No visible pitting No visible pitting No visible pitting No visible pitting Edge pitting only Edge pitting only Edge pitting only
Extrusions 6351-T6 6061-T6 6063-T5 6070-T6 7039-T6
No visible pitting No visible pitting No visible pitting No visible pitting Scattered small pits
H 2 SO 4 anodic coatings 23 ixm (0.9 mil) thick, sealed in boiling water on test panels 100 X 150 mm ( 4 X 6 in.) cut from sheet and extrusions
Oxidation Treatments Tool Steels. Oxidation is a well-established process used for high-speed steel cutting tools. Increases in tool life of up to 100% are achieved, mostly due to a decrease in friction, because of the hard oxide coating and the ability of the porous oxide to entrap lubricant and draw it to the tool/workpiece interface. Steam oxidation of a finished tool is accomplished either by exposing it to steam at a temperature of about 565 0C (1050 0F) or by treating it in liquid sodium hydroxide and sodium nitrate salts at approximately 140 0C (285 0F) for 5 to 20 min. These treatments result in a black oxidized layer that is less than 5 |xm (0.2 mil) thick and will not peel, chip, or crack, even when the tool is bent or cut. Tool life improvements due to steam oxidation are listed in Table 5. Steam Treating of Powder Metallurgy (P/M) Steels. Many P/M parts have traditionally been steam treated for improved wear resistance, corrosion resistance, and sealing capacity. In this process, P/M parts are heated in a specific manner under a steam atmosphere at temperatures between 510 and 570 0C (950 and 1060 0F) to form a layer of black iron oxide, identified as magnetite, in the surface porosity. Magnetite has a hardness equivalent to 50 HRC. Spalling or flaking of the surface oxide layer can occur if the process temperature exceeds 570 0 C (1060 0F) and process times exceed 4 h. The maximum thickness of the surface oxide layer should not exceed 7 juim (0.28 mil). Beyond this thickness, flaking can occur due to an increase in surface tensile stress. Sintered density is an important consideration when applying steam treating for improved strength and hardness. Its ability to increase the wear resistance of the substrate material depends on the available porosity for oxidation. As density is increased, the amount of oxide formed is Table 5 Machining tool life improvements due to steam oxidation Tool life Tool
M2 broaches M2 drills
M7 end mill tools A6 hobs M2 milling cutters M2 saw blades M2 taps Source: Ref 5
Application
Cutting AISI 1010 latch Drilling Bakelite plastic insulating blocks Phenolic terminal plates Drilling AISI4030 steel, 25 mm (1 in.) thick Cutting 8740 steel forgings Cutting teeth on AISI 3140 forged gear Two slots in 1020 steel Slotting 1020 steel bars Cutting 75 mm (3 in.) rods, austenitic steel Cutting SAE 52100 steel
Before steam treating
After steam treating
20 h per grind 10 holes
70 h per grind 25 holes
1700 holes per grind 17 holes
8500 holes per grind 81 holes
30 pieces 62.2% increased life
200 pieces 62.2% increased life
150 cuts per grind 2000 per grind 100% endurance at 0.52 m/s (102 sfm) 1800 pieces
306 cuts per grind 7000 per grind 120% endurance at 0.57 m/s(112sfm) 3000 pieces
Density, Ib/in.3
Apparent hardness, HRB
steam-treated
steam-treated as-sintered
as-sintered
Density, g/cm3 Fig, 3 Effect of steam treating on the hardness of sintered P/M carbon steels. Source: Ref 6
decreased, which minimizes the improvement in apparent hardness attributed to steam treating. This is shown in Fig. 3 for sintered steel. The increase in density and apparent hardness produced by steam treating is illustrated in the micrograph of a sintered steel (Fig. 4). By filling
Fig. 4 Micrograph of steam-treated structure of a P/M steel. Unetched. 200X
the porosity with a hard second phase, the P/M steel offers a better support to the indentation hardness tester. Figure 5 illustrates that the transverse rupture strength is increased significantly by steam treatment for low-carbon P/M steels, but only modestly for high-carbon (0.8% C) P/M steels. Diffusion H e a t Treatment Coatings The diffusion coatings described in this section involve heat treating processes that cause carbon, nitrogen, or a combination of the two to diffuse into the surface of a ferrous part to alter the surface chemistry/properties. As listed in Table 6, these processes include carburizing, nitriding, and carbonitriding. Each of these depends on the concentration gradient of the diffusing species, the diffusivity of the atomic species in the host material, and the time and temperature at which the process takes place. All carburizing and nitriding processes increase the surface carbon or nitrogen content of the alloy to allow the surface to respond to quench hardening. The heat treater usually relies on empirical data to determine how long to expose the part to achieve the desired carbon or nitrogen diffusion. The term used for the entire field of surface-hardening processes is case hardening, and the case indicates the depth of hardening below the surface. Although
Density, Ib/in.3
as-sintered steam-treated
as-sintered
Transverse rupture strength, ksi
Transverse rupture strength, MPa
steam-treated
Density, g/cm3 Fig. 5
E ect 0 steam
^ ^ treating on transverse rupture strength of sintered P/M carbon steels. Source: Ref 6
the depth of hardening decreases gradually because the diffused species does not stop abruptly, the effective case depth is considered to be the depth at which the hardness falls below 50 HRC. More detailed information on the case-hardening procedures described in this section can be found in Heat Treating, Volume 4 of ASM Handbook.
Table 6
Typical characteristics of carburizing, nitriding, and carbonitriding diffusion treatments
Process
Name of case
Process temperature oC
(op)
Case hardness, typical case depth
Hardness, HRC
Typical base metals
Low-carbon steels, low-carbon alloy steels Low-carbon steels, low-carbon alloy steels
Process characteristics
Carburizing Pack
Diffused carbon
815-1090 (1500-2000)
125 fim-1.5 mm (5-60 mils)
50-63(a)
Gas
Diffused carbon
815-980 (1500-1800)
75 jjim-1.5 mm (3-60 mils)
50-63(a)
Liquid
Diffused carbon and possibly nitrogen
815-980 (1500-1800)
50 jxm-1.5 mm (2-60 mils)
50-65(a)
Low-carbon steels, low-carbon alloy steels
Vacuum
Diffused carbon
815-1090 (1500-2000)
75 |xm-1.5 mm (3-60 mils)
50-63(a)
Low-carbon steels, low-carbon alloy steels
Gas
Diffused nitrogen, nitrogen compounds
480-590 (900-1100)
125 fjim-0.75 mm (5-30 mils)
50-70
Alloy steels, nitriding steels, stainless steels
Salt
Diffused nitrogen, nitrogen, compounds
510-565 (950-1050)
2.5 jjim-0.75 mm (0.1-30 mils)
50-70
Most ferrous metals including cast iron
Ion
Diffused nitrogen nitrogen compounds
340-565 (650-1050)
75 |xm-0.75 mm (3-30 mils)
50-70
Alloy steels, nitriding steels, stainless steels
Gas
Diffused carbon and nitrogen
760-870 (1400-1600)
75 (xm-0.75 mm (3-30 mils)
50-65(a)
Low-carbon steels, low-carbon alloy steels, stainless steels
Liquid (cyaniding)
Diffused carbon and nitrogen
760-870 (1400-1600)
2.5-125 |i,m (0.1-5 mils)
50-65(a)
Low-carbon steels
Ferritic nitrocarburizing
Diffused carbon and nitrogen
480-590 (900-1090)
2.5-25 |xm (0.1-1 mil)
40-60(a)
Low-carbon steels
Low equipment costs, difficult to control case depth accurately Good control of case depth, suitable for continuous operation, good gas controls required, can be dangerous Faster than pack and gas processes, can pose salt disposal problem, salt baths require frequent maintenance Excellent process control, bright parts, faster than gas carburizing, high equipment costs
Nitriding Hardest cases from nitriding steels, quenching not required, low distortion, process is low, is usually a batch process Usually used for thin hard cases <25 jxm (<1 mil), no white layer, most are proprietary processes Faster than gas nitriding, no white layer, high equipment costs, close case control
Carbonitriding
(a) Requires quench from austenitizing temperature. Source: Ref 7
Lower temperature than carburizing (less distortion), slightly harder case than carburizing, gas control critical Good for thin cases on noncritical parts, batch process, salt disposal problems Low-distortion process for thin case on lowcarbon steel, most processes are proprietary
Carburizing Carburizing is the addition of carbon to the surface of low-carbon steels at temperatures (generally between 850 and 950 0 C, or 1560 and 1740 0F) at which austenite, with its high solubility for carbon, is the stable crystal structure. Hardening of the component