Texture in food Volume 2: Solid foods
Related titles from Woodhead’s food science, technology and nutrition list: Texture in food Volume 1: Semi-solid foods (ISBN 1 85573 673 X) Understanding and controlling the texture of semi-solid foods such as yoghurt and ice cream is a complex process. With a distinguished international team of contributors, this important collection summarises some of the most significant research in this area. The first part of the book looks at the behaviour of gels and emulsions, how they can be measured and their textural properties improved. The second part of the collection discusses the control of texture in particular foods such as yoghurt, ice cream, spreads and sauces. Understanding and measuring the shelf-life of food (ISBN 1 85573 732 9) The shelf-life of a product is critical in determining both its quality and profitability. This important collection reviews the key factors in determining shelf-life and how they can be measured. Taints and off-flavours in foods (ISBN 1 85573 449 4) Taints and off-flavours are a major problem for the food industry. The first part of this important collection reviews the major causes of taints and off-flavours, from oxidative rancidity and microbiologically-derived off-flavours, to packaging materials as a source of taints. The second part of the book discusses the range of techniques for detecting taints and off-flavours, from sensory analysis to instrumental techniques, including the development of new rapid, on-line sensors. Details of these books and a complete list of Woodhead’s food science, technology and nutrition titles can be obtained by: • visiting our web site at www.woodhead-publishing.com • contacting Customer services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 893694; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 891358 ext.30; address: Woodhead Publishing Ltd, Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge CB1 6AH, England) Selected food science and technology titles are also available in electronic form. Visit our web site (www.woodhead-publishing.com) to find out more. If you would like to receive information on forthcoming titles in this area, please send your address details to: Francis Dodds (address, tel. and fax as above; e-mail:
[email protected]). Please confirm which subject areas you are interested in.
Texture in food Volume 2: Solid foods Edited by David Kilcast
CRC Press Boca Raton Boston New York Washington, DC
WOODHEAD
PUBLISHING LIMITED Cambridge England
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Abington Cambridge CB1 6AH, England www.woodhead-publishing.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 2000 Corporate Blvd, NW Boca Raton FL 33431, USA First published 2004, Woodhead Publishing Ltd and CRC Press LLC © 2004, Woodhead Publishing Ltd The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. The consent of Woodhead Publishing and CRC Press does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing or CRC Press for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN 1 85573 724 8 (book) 1 85573 836 8 (e-book) CRC Press ISBN 0-8493-2537-4 CRC Press order number: WP2537 The publisher’s policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which have been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publisher ensures that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by Replika Press Pvt Ltd, India. Printed by TJ International Ltd, Padstow, Cornwall, England.
Contents
Contributor contact details ................................................................... List of abbreviations ..............................................................................
xiii xix
Consumers, texture and food quality ..................................
1
Part I
1 Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview .......................................................................................... D. Kilcast, Leatherhead Food International, UK 1.1 Introduction: texture and food quality ................................. 1.2 Perception and sensory assessment of food texture .................................................................................... 1.3 Tests and test procedures ...................................................... 1.4 Instrumental measurement of texture .................................. 1.5 In vivo texture measurement ................................................ 1.6 Future developments ............................................................. 1.7 Conclusions ........................................................................... 1.8 References ............................................................................. 2 Consumers and texture: understanding their perceptions and preferences .............................................................................. J-F. Meullenet, University of Arkansas, USA 2.1 Introduction: problems with consumer descriptions of texture .................................................................................... 2.2 Investigating consumer descriptions of texture ................... 2.3 Tests and test procedures ...................................................... 2.4 Understanding consumer preferences .................................. 2.5 Challenges to understanding consumer preferences ............................................................................ 2.6 Future trends ......................................................................... 2.7 Conclusions ........................................................................... 2.8 References .............................................................................
3 3 6 8 13 20 23 26 28
33
33 34 36 39 44 48 50 51
vi
Contents
3 Texture and mastication ............................................................... A. C. Smith, Institute of Food Research, UK 3.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 3.2 The mastication process ....................................................... 3.3 Measuring mastication .......................................................... 3.4 Chewing, swallowing, salivation and bolus formation ....... 3.5 Future trends ......................................................................... 3.6 Mastication and particular foods .......................................... 3.7 Reviews ................................................................................. 3.8 Acknowledgement ................................................................ 3.9 References .............................................................................
53 53 55 56 66 71 75 76 76 77
4 Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness ..................................................................................... P. Mallikarjunan, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, USA 4.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 4.2 Characterization and determination of crispness ................ 4.3 Methods of data correlation, evaluation and analysis ......... 4.4 Case-study: breaded chicken nuggets .................................. 4.5 Future trends ......................................................................... 4.6 References .............................................................................
82 85 91 94 103 103
Instrumental techniques for analysing texture ................
107
5 Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture .............. R. Lu and J. A. Abbott, USDA Agricultural Research Service, USA 5.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 5.2 Mechanical characterization of solid foods ......................... 5.3 Destructive measurements .................................................... 5.4 Non-destructive measurements ............................................ 5.5 Conclusions ........................................................................... 5.6 References .............................................................................
109
6 Sound input techniques for measuring texture ......................... L. M. Duizer, Massey University, New Zealand 6.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 6.2 Sound and its detection: what is sound? ............................. 6.3 Destructive testing ................................................................ 6.4 Non-destructive testing ......................................................... 6.5 Application of sound measurement techniques ................... 6.6 Future trends ......................................................................... 6.7 Sources of further information and advice .......................... 6.8 References .............................................................................
146
Part II
82
109 110 118 128 138 139
146 147 148 155 158 162 162 163
Contents vii
7 Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement .................................................................................. S. Millar, Campden and Chorleywood Food Research Association, UK 7.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 7.2 Application of NIR to cereals and their products ............... 7.3 Application of NIR to fruit and vegetables ......................... 7.4 Application of NIR to meat ................................................. 7.5 Application of NIR to other foods ....................................... 7.6 Conclusions and future trends .............................................. 7.7 Sources of further information ............................................. 7.8 References ............................................................................. 8 Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in texture measurement .................. A. K. Thybo, A. H. Karlsson, H. C. Bertram and H. J. Andersen, Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences, P. M. Szczypinski, Technical University of Lodz, Poland and S. Donstrup, Aarhus University Hospital, Denmark 8.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 8.2 Methods and analysis ........................................................... 8.3 Application of NMR: texture determination of solid foods ...................................................................................... 8.4 Application of MRI: texture determination of solid foods ...................................................................................... 8.5 Future trends ......................................................................... 8.6 References ............................................................................. 9 Modelling food texture ................................................................. L. M. M. Tijskens and H. Luyten, Wageningen University and Research Centre, The Netherlands 9.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 9.2 Factors affecting texture ....................................................... 9.3 Effects of enzymes on texture .............................................. 9.4 Applying models to predict texture ..................................... 9.5 Future trends ......................................................................... 9.6 Notation ................................................................................. 9.7 References ............................................................................. Part III Understanding and improving the texture of particular foods .................................................................................... 10 Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture ........................ K. W. Waldron, Institute of Food Research, UK 10.1 Introduction ...........................................................................
167
167 170 173 176 178 179 180 180
184
184 187 189 195 199 200 205
205 211 218 222 233 234 235
239 241 241
viii Contents
10.2 Measurement of texture ........................................................ 10.3 Plant structure ....................................................................... 10.4 Cellular basis of crispness, juiciness and mealiness in fruit tissue ............................................................................. 10.5 Cellular stability during processing ..................................... 10.6 Improving cell adhesion ....................................................... 10.7 Future trends ......................................................................... 10.8 Acknowledgements ............................................................... 10.9 References ............................................................................. 11 Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear .............. T. Kojima, S. Fujita and M. Tanaka, Saga University, Japan and P. Sirisomboon, King Mongkut’s Institute of Technology Ladkrabang, Thailand 11.1 Introduction: variations in pear texture ............................... 11.2 Measuring and modelling fruit firmness ............................. 11.3 Chemical compounds affecting firmness: the example of Japanese pear .................................................................... 11.4 The effect of constituents on fruit texture .................................................................................... 11.5 Use of near infrared spectroscopy (NIR) to evaluate textural properties ................................................................. 11.6 Future trends ......................................................................... 11.7 Sources of further information and advice .......................... 11.8 Acknowledgement ................................................................ 11.9 References ............................................................................. 12 Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables: the role of oxidising enzymes ..................................................................... H. J. Wichers and C. Boeriu, Agrotechnology and Food Innovations, The Netherlands 12.1 Introduction: distribution of polyphenoloxidases (PPOs) and peroxidases (PODs) in plants and plant cells .............................................................................. 12.2 Biochemical and physiological role of PPOs and PODs ..................................................................................... 12.3 PPOs and PODs: structure and mechanisms of action ..................................................................................... 12.4 PPOs, PODs and texture development ................................ 12.5 Controlling PPO and POD activity ...................................... 12.6 PPOs and PODs: implications for food texture .................. 12.7 Future trends ......................................................................... 12.8 Sources of further information ............................................. 12.9 References .............................................................................
242 244 244 249 251 254 255 255 259
259 262 270 275 279 283 288 289 290
295
295 296 300 304 307 311 311 312 312
Contents
13 Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation ............................................................................... G. Tucker, University of Nottingham, UK 13.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 13.2 Tools of genetic modification .............................................. 13.3 Approaches to the manipulation of texture: the tomato .................................................................................... 13.4 Other approaches to the manipulation of texture ................ 13.5 Future trends ......................................................................... 13.6 References ............................................................................. 14 Raw materials quality and the texture of processed vegetables ........................................................................................ J. B. Adams, formerly of CCFRA, UK 14.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 14.2 Vegetable texture determined by starch ............................... 14.3 Vegetable texture determined by cell wall polysaccharides ..................................................................... 14.4 Vegetable texture affected by phenolic reactions ................ 14.5 Future trends ......................................................................... 14.6 Sources of further information and advice .......................... 14.7 References ............................................................................. 15 Improving the texture of processed vegetables by vacuum infusion ............................................................................ R. Saurel, University of Lyon, France 15.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 15.2 Vacuum infusion technology ................................................ 15.3 Applications to improve texture ........................................... 15.4 Future trends ......................................................................... 15.5 Sources of further information and advice .......................... 15.6 References ............................................................................. 16 Improving the texture of frozen fruit: the case of berries ............................................................................................. M. Suutarinen and K. Autio, VTT Biotechnology, Finland 16.1 Introduction: the effects of freezing and thawing on berry texture .................................................................... 16.2 Maintaining texture: conventional pre-freezing treatments .............................................................................. 16.3 Maintaining texture: alternative pre-freezing treatments .............................................................................. 16.4 Application: frozen berries and jams ................................... 16.5 Future trends ......................................................................... 16.6 References .............................................................................
ix
321 321 323 327 333 335 336
342 342 342 349 354 358 359 360
364 364 365 373 383 383 384
388
388 390 393 400 405 405
x Contents
17 Improving the texture of processed fruit: the case of olives ........................................................................................... I. Mafra, University of Porto and M. A. Coimbra, University of Aveiro, Portugal 17.1 Introduction: the texture of table olives............................... 17.2 Factors affecting the texture quality of raw olives .............. 17.3 Influence of processing on table olives ............................... 17.4 Improving texture .................................................................. 17.5 Future trends ......................................................................... 17.6 Sources of further information and advice .......................... 17.7 References .............................................................................
410
410 412 418 425 426 428 430
18 Improving the texture of bread ................................................... S. P. Cauvain, CCFRA, UK 18.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 18.2 Textural characteristics of bread and other cereal-based foods ................................................................ 18.3 Definitions of texture ........................................................... 18.4 Measuring texture ................................................................. 18.5 Influence of processing and storage .................................... 18.6 Improving texture .................................................................. 18.7 Future trends ......................................................................... 18.8 Sources of further information and advice .......................... 18.9 References .............................................................................
432
19 Analysing and improving the texture of cooked rice ............... S. K. Kim, Dankook University and C. O. Rhee, Chonnam National University, Korea 19.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 19.2 Criteria for evaluating rice quality ....................................... 19.3 Hydration of rice ................................................................... 19.4 Factors affecting cooking quality ......................................... 19.5 Testing texture quality .......................................................... 19.6 Problems and challenges ...................................................... 19.7 Sources of further information and advice .......................... 19.8 References .............................................................................
451
20 Improving the texture of pasta .................................................... B. A. Marchylo and J. E. Dexter, Canadian Grain Commission and L. J. Malcolmson, Canadian International Grains Institute 20.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 20.2 Measuring the texture of cooked pasta ................................ 20.3 Influence of raw materials .................................................... 20.4 Influence of processing ........................................................ 20.5 Trends in consumer preference ............................................ 20.6 References .............................................................................
475
432 434 436 437 442 445 447 448 449
451 452 455 459 464 469 470 470
475 478 484 490 492 494
Contents
xi
21 Improving the texture of fried food ............................................ C-J. Shieh and C-Y. Chang, Da-Yeh University and C-S. Chen, Chao-Yang University of Technology, Taiwan 21.1 Introduction ........................................................................... 21.2 Measuring texture ................................................................. 21.3 Factors influencing texture ................................................... 21.4 The use of response surface methodology (RSM) .............. 21.5 A case study: fried gluten balls ........................................... 21.6 Conclusions ........................................................................... 21.7 References .............................................................................
501
Index ................................................................................................
525
501 501 504 508 514 521 522
This page intentionally left blank
Contributor contact details
(* = main point of contact)
Chapter 1
Chapter 3
Dr D. Kilcast Leatherhead Food International Randalls Road Leatherhead Surrey KT22 7RY UK
Dr A. C. Smith Food Quality & Materials Science Division Institute of Food Research Norwich Research Park, Colney Norwich NR4 7UA UK
Tel: +44 (0) 1372 822321 Fax: +44 (0) 1372 386228 E-mail:
[email protected]
Tel: +44 (0) 1603 255286 Fax: +44 (0) 1603 507723 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 2
Chapter 4
Professor J-F. Meullenet Department of Food Science University of Arkansas 2650 N. Young Avenue Fayetteville, AR 72704 USA
Dr P. Mallikarjunan Biological Systems Engineering Department 312 Seitz Hall Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University Blacksburg VA 24060 USA
Tel: +1 (479) 236 1926 Fax: +1 (479) 575 6936 E-mail:
[email protected]
Tel: +1 (540) 231 7937 Fax: +1 (540) 231 3199 E-mail:
[email protected]
xiv Contributor contact details
Chapter 5 Dr Renfu Lu* USDA ARS Sugarbeet and Bean Research Unit 224 Farrall Hall Michigan State University East Lansing, MI 48824 USA Tel: +1 (517) 432-8062 Fax: +1 (517) 337-6782 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Judith A. Abbot USDA ARS Produce Quality & Safety Laboratory Building 002, BARC-W 10300 Baltimore Avenue Beltsville, MD 20705-2350 USA Tel: +1 (301) 504 6128 Fax: +1 (301) 504 5107 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 6 Dr L. M. Duizer Institute of Food, Nutrition and Human Health Massey University Private Bag 102 904 NSMC Albany, Auckland New Zealand Tel: +64 09 443 9753 Fax: +64 09 443 9640 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 7 Dr S. Millar
Baking and Cereals Processing Department Campden & Chorleywood Food Research Association Chipping Campden Gloucestershire GL55 6LD UK Tel: +44 (0) 1386 842157 Fax: +44 (0) 1386 842150 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 8 Dr A. K. Thybo* Department of Food Science Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences DK-5792 Aarslev Denmark Tel: +045 63 90 43 05 Fax: +045 63 90 43 95 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr A. H. Karlsson, Dr H. C. Bertram and Dr H. J. Andersen Department of Food Science Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences DK-8830 Tjele Denmark Tel: +045 89 99 19 00 Fax: +045 89 99 15 64 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr S. Donstrup Aarhus University Hospital Department of Biomedical Engineering DK-8200 Aarhus N Denmark
Contributor contact details
Dr P. M. Szczypinski Institute of Electronics Technical University of Lodz 90-924 Lodz Poland Tel: +48 42 636 2238 Fax: +48 42 631 2638 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 9 L. M. M. Tijskens* and Dr H. Luyten Wageningen University and Research Centre Agrotechnology & Food Innovations PO Box 17 6700 AA Wageningen The Netherlands Tel: +31 317 475 303 Fax: +31 317 475 347 E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected]
Chapter 10 Dr K. W. Waldron Institute of Food Research Norwich Research Park Colney Norwich NR4 7UA UK Tel: +44 1603 255385 Fax: +44 1603 507723 E-mail:
[email protected]
xv
Chapter 11 Dr T. Kojima, Dr S. Fujita and Dr M. Tanaka Saga University Japan 840-8502 Tel: +81 952 288 750 Fax: +81 952 288 768 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr P. Sirisomboon* Department of Agricultural Engineering Faculty of Engineering King Mongkut’s Institute of Technology Ladkrabang Bangkok 10520 Thailand Tel: +66 2737 300 ext 5120 Fax: +66 2326 4178 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 12 Dr H. J. Wichers and Dr C. Boeriu Agrotechnology & Food Innovations Bornsesteeg 59 6708 PD Wageningen The Netherlands Tel: +31 317 475228 Fax: +31 317 475347 E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected]
Chapter 13 Professor G. Tucker University of Nottingham School of Biosciences
xvi Contributor contact details
Sutton Bonington Campus Loughborough Leicestershire LE12 5RD UK Tel: +44 (0) 1159 516 126 Fax: +44 (0) 1159 516 122 E-mail:
[email protected]
Tel: +358 9 4565175 Fax: +358 9 4552103 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 17 Professor M. A. Coimbra* Department of Chemistry University of Aveiro PT 3810-193 Aveiro Portugal
Chapter 14 Dr J. B. Adams 5 Orchard View Draycott Moreton-in-Marsh Gloucestershire GL56 9LW UK Tel: +44 (01386) 700374 E-mail:
[email protected]
Tel: +1 351 234 370 706 Fax: +1 351 234 370 084 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr I. Mafra REQUIMTE Laboratory of Bromatology Faculty of Pharmacy University of Porto R Anibal Cunha, 164 PT 4050-047 Porto Portugal
Chapter 15 Dr R. Saurel University of Lyon Rue Henri de Boissieu 01 060 Bourg-en-Bresse Cedex 09 France
Tel: +351 22 2078902 Fax: +351 22 2003977 E-mail:
[email protected]
Tel: +33 (0)4 74 45 52 52 Fax: +33 (0)4 74 45 52 53 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 16
Dr S. P. Cauvain Campden & Chorleywood Food Research Association Chipping Campden Gloucestershire GL55 6LD UK
Dr M. Suutarinen and Dr K. Autio* VTT Biotechnology PO Box 1500, 02044 VTT Finland
Tel: +44 (0) 1386 842 000 Fax: +44 (0) 1386 842 150 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 18
Contributor contact details
Chapter 19 Dr S. K. Kim* Dankook University Korea Tel: +82 2 709 2426 Fax: +82 2 790 2447 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr C. O. Rhee Chonnam National University Korea
xvii
Dr L. J. Malcolmson Canadian International Grains Institute 1000-303 Main Strect Winnipeg MB R3C 3G7 Canada Tel: +1 (204) 983 8584 Fax: +1 (204) 983 2642 E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 21
Tel: +82 62 530 2142 Fax: +82 530 2149 E-mail:
[email protected]
Dr C-J. Shieh and Dr C-Y. Chang Department of Food Engineering Da-Yeh University Cheng-Hwa Taiwan 515
Chapter 20
E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected]
Dr B. A. Marchylo* and Dr J. E. Dexter Grain Research Laboratory Canadian Grain Commission 1404-303 Main Street Winnipeg MB R3C 3G8 Canada Tel: +1 (204) 983 3320 Fax: +1 (204) 983 0724 E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected]
Dr C-S. Chen* Department of Applied Chemistry Chao-Yang University of Technology 168 Gifeng E. Rd, Wufeng Taichung County Taiwan Fax: +886 4 2374 2341 E-mail:
[email protected]
This page intentionally left blank
Abbreviations
AACC ADC AF AFC AIS AMG AOAC APX ASAE
American Association of Cereal Chemists Analogue to digital converter aqueous freezant alternative forced choice alcohol insoluble solids acoustic myography Association of Analytical Communities ascorbate peroxidase American Society of Agricultural Engineers
bpm
beats per minute
CA CCFRA CcP CDTA CVA CWC
controlled atmosphere Campden and Chorleywood Food Research Assn cytochrome C peroxidase 1,2-cyclohexanediaminetetraacetic acid canonical variate analysis Chinese water chestnut
DAC DATI DFD DHF DIS DMTA DOPA DP DSP
dynamic axial compression dual-attribute time-intensity dark, firm, dry dihydroxyfumaric acid dewatering impregnation soaking dynamic mechanical thermal analysis dihydroxyphenylananine degree of polymerisation deformation at skin puncture
E EMC
enzyme equilibrium moisture content
xx Abbreviations
EMG Endo-PG EPG Eth
electromyography endo-polygalacturonase electropalatography ethylene
FA F/D FES FFT FITC FMBRA FT-NIR FW
ferulic acid force/deformation functional electrical stimulation fast Fourier transform fluorescein isothiocyanate Flour Milling and Baking Research Association Fourier transform NIR fresh weight
GF GPIB GRL GS
general foods general purpose interface board Grain Research Laboratory glutein subunits
HDM HM HPLC HRP HT HTC HVK
hydrodynamic mechanism high methylated high performance liquid chromatography horseradish peroxidase high temperature hard-to-cook hard vitreous kernel
IAA ICF IDT IFR IQF ISO
indole-3-acetic acid immersion chilling and freezing iso-dityrosine impact force response individually quick frozen International Standards Organisation
KI
kinesiograph
LAM LiP LM LMW LT LVDT
labelled affective magnitude lignin peroxidase low methylated low molecular weight low temperature linear voltage displacement transducer
MA MARS
modified atmosphere multivariate adaptive regression splines
Abbreviations
MassL, MassR MLR MRI MT
masseter left, right multiple linear regression magnetic resonance imaging Magness-Taylor
NIR NIRS NMR NSP
near-infrared near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy nuclear magnetic resonance non-soluble pectin
OD OLS ORF OSP
osmotic dehydration ordinary least squares open reading frame oxalate soluble pectin
P PCA PEL PG PIHMI PLS PME POD POM PPO PSE PSP PVOD
product principal component analysis pectate lyase polygalacturonas paired increasing-height multiple-impacting partial least squares pectin methylesterase peroxidase proportional odds modelling polyphenoloxidase pale, soft, exudative polysterene pack pulsed vacuum osmotic dehydration
QC QDA QTL
quality control quantitatived descriptive analysis quantitative trait loci
Re RH RMS RMSEP RSM RSREG RVA
respiration relative humidity root-mean-square root mean square error of prediction response surface methodology response surface regression rapid visco analyser
S SAS SDP SE
substrate statistical analysis system symmetrised dot pattern softness equivalent
xxi
xxii
Abbreviations
SEM SEP SS
scanning electron microscope standard error of prediction soluble solids
TEM TempL, TempR T-I TOF TOM TP TPA
transmission electron microscopy temporalis left, temporalis right time-intensity time-of-flight total organic matter total pectin texture profile analysis
UHT UV
ultra high temperature ultraviolet
VI VMG VOD
vacuum infusion vibromyography vacuum osmotic dehydration
WB WSP WVP
Warner-Bratzler water-soluble pectin water vapour permeability
XET
xyloglucan endotransglycosylase
Part I Consumers, texture and food quality
This page intentionally left blank
1 Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview D. Kilcast, Leatherhead Food International, UK
1.1
Introduction: texture and food quality
In prosperous societies, we have available an enormous and ever-increasing range of foods, and manufacturers find themselves in an intensely competitive situation. In less well-developed societies, hunger will be the constant driving force, and our diet will be determined by availability of any food that satisfies our basic nutritional needs. It is increasingly clear that if we are to understand what drives consumers’ choice of food, no single factor can be considered in isolation from others. For some years, psychology researchers have been developing models to understand consumer behaviour (e.g. Shepherd and Sparks, 1994). Although there are many possible circumstances under which non-sensory factors such as price and nutritional image can have dominant effects, the sensory characteristics of foods are central to their continued purchase. The importance of a holistic approach is also becoming more clear when the components of sensory perception are considered. During the sequences of actions that constitute food consumption, we perceive a whole range of different characteristics relating to the appearance, flavour and texture of the food. Numerous tools are available for investigating the sensory properties of foods, and the information required must be carefully defined if appropriate tools are to be selected. Systematic development of new products will inevitably depend on the use of different tools at different stages of the development cycle. 1.1.1 The human senses It is generally accepted that human beings have five senses in operation, namely sight, smell, taste, touch and hearing, although warmth, cold, movement
4 Texture in food
and pain may also be considered as senses of importance in a food context (Fig. 1.1). Foods are complex mixtures of chemical compounds, arranged into structural units. The perception of the sensory characteristics of foods results from the stimulation of all our senses to some extent by the physicochemical properties of the foods. The sensory characteristics of food are generally grouped into three categories, namely appearance, flavour and texture. These categories are, however, not independent of one another. For example, colour, which is obviously an important appearance characteristic, can be shown to have an influence on flavour perception; consumers will assign higher scores for flavour intensity to darker foods than to lighter foods. The interaction between appearance and flavour is referred to as ‘visual flavour’. Similarly, textural characteristics such as viscosity can influence the perception of flavour, and some flavour characteristics, e.g. acidity, can affect textural characteristics. One means of defining flavour, texture and appearance is by taking into account the fact that each can be attributed to the stimulation of one or possibly two of the senses. On this basis the International Standards Organisation (ISO, 1992) has proposed working definitions for flavour, texture and appearance, as given below. • Appearance: sensory characteristics of foods perceived largely by way of the visual sense. Input from other senses, especially smell, may contribute. • Flavour: the combination of taste and odour. Pain, heat, cold, tactile and visual sensations may also contribute. • Texture: sensory characteristics perceived largely by way of the senses of movement and touch. Input from other senses, especially vision and taste, may sometimes contribute. The above definitions give little information on how the senses are used in the perception of quality attributes. Appearance is sometimes, mistakenly, equated only with colour, and yet many other visual aspects of form, shape, translucency, etc., may influence our use of the visual senses. Taste (gustation)
Vision
Gustation
Olfaction
Trigeminal
Taste
Odour
Irritant
Touch
Hearing
FLAVOUR SOUND
APPEARANCE
TEXTURE
Fig. 1.1 Schematic diagram of the human senses and their operation in the perception of food quality.
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
5
is strictly defined as the response by the tongue to soluble, involatile materials. These have classically been defined as four primary basic taste sensations: salt, sweet, sour and bitter, although umami, the sensation associated with monosodium glutamate, is now widely recognised as a basic taste. This list is frequently extended further to include sensations such as metallic and astringency. The taste receptors are organised groups of cells, known as taste buds, located within specialised structures called papillae. These are located mainly on the tip, sides and rear upper surface of the tongue. Taste stimuli are characterised by the relatively narrow range between the weakest and the strongest stimulants (ca 104), and are strongly influenced by factors such as temperature and pH (Meilgaard et al., 1999). The odour response is much more complex, and odours are detected as volatiles entering the nasal passage, either directly via the nose or indirectly through the retronasal path via the mouth. The odorants are sensed by the olfactory epithelium, which is located in the roof of the nasal cavity. Some 150–200 odour qualities have been recognised, and there is a very wide range (ca 1012) between the weakest and the strongest stimulants (Meilgaard et al., 1999). The odour receptors are easily saturated, and specific anosmia (blindness to specific odours) is common. It is thought that the wide range of possible odour responses contributes to variety in flavour perception. Both taste and odour stimuli can be detected only if they are released effectively from the food matrix during the course of mastication. The chemical sense corresponds to a pain response through stimulation of the trigeminal nerve. This is produced by chemical irritants such as ginger and capsaicin (from chilli), both of which give a heat response, and chemicals such as menthol and sorbitol, which give a cooling response. With the exception of capsaicin, these stimulants are characterised by high thresholds. The combined effect of the taste, odour and chemical responses gives rise to the sensation generally perceived as flavour, although these terms are often used loosely. Texture is perceived by the sense of touch, and comprises two components: somesthesis, a tactile, surface response from skin, and kinesthesis (or proprioception), which is a deep response from muscles and tendons. For many foods, visual stimuli will generate an expectation of textural properties. The touch stimuli themselves can arise from tactile manipulation of the food with the hands and fingers, either directly or through the intermediary of utensils such as a knife or spoon. Oral contact with food can occur through the lips, tongue, palate and teeth, all of which provide textural information.
1.1.2 Texture and food enjoyment Most studies which have investigated the importance of different sensory modalities on consumer acceptability conclude that flavour is the most important modality, followed by texture and then appearance (e.g. Moskowitz and Krieger, 1995). Such conclusions do not reflect the enormous efforts
6 Texture in food
that the food industry devotes to designing appealing textural characteristics, and to maintaining those characteristics to long-term production. Research with consumers in the USA carried out by Szczesniak and Kahn (1971) showed that awareness of texture lies at a subconscious level, and that textural properties are taken for granted. If the expectations of texture are violated, however, awareness of textural defects is accentuated, and texture becomes a focal point for criticism and rejection of the food. Expectations are being increasingly recognised as important factors in food choice by consumers (e.g. Vickers, 1991; Cardello, 1994).
1.1.3 The interactive role of texture In addition to its direct contribution to consumer acceptance, texture has a vitally important secondary effect, through modulation of flavour release. If flavour components are to be perceived, they must be released from the food matrix in order to reach the appropriate receptors. This release of flavour is intimately related to the way in which the food structure breaks down in the mouth, and consequently to both the initial texture of the food and the change in texture throughout mastication (Section 1.2). In addition, the structural factors that deliver a specific texture can also influence appearance characteristics, for example the glossy surface of chocolate confectionery.
1.1.4 Texture and product design Texture and food structure are inextricably linked; the micro- and macrostructural composition of foods will determine the sensory perception, and any change in structure carries the risk of changing perceived texture and violating consumer expectations. Industry therefore needs to take great care to ensure that products with key textural characteristics, such as snack foods and confectionery products, are manufactured to consistently high quality. This can present an enormous challenge for foods relying on primary components such as meat and vegetables that are naturally subject to high variability, and for any processed food manufactured on high-volume production lines. Product modifications, for example to produce low-fat variants, can introduce structural changes that can generate substantial textural modifications. Industry therefore needs methods to measure textural characteristics. However, designing suitable measurement systems requires an understanding of the mechanisms by which texture is perceived.
1.2 Perception and sensory assessment of food texture 1.2.1 Oral breakdown processes The importance of the interaction between the texture of foods and their perceived flavour can be clearly seen if the sequence of events during food
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
7
consumption is considered. A strong expectation of the flavour and texture characteristics can be generated before the food is introduced into the mouth. As food enters the mouth, and is either bitten or manipulated between tongue and palate, catastrophic changes occur to the structure of the food that strongly influence the way in which tastants and odorants are released from it. Of particular importance are temperature increase (cold foods) or decrease (hot foods) and dilution by saliva. Salivary introduction also serves to lubricate the food bolus. The factors that influence such release are under active study (e.g. Overbosch et al., 1991), and include: • • • • •
rate and mode of production of new surface rate of production of saliva dissolution and dispersion of the food release of involatile tastants and volatile odorants transport of volatiles to the nasal cavity
1.2.2 Oral food management Even the complex picture of food breakdown described previously is an over-simplification of actual oral processes (Heath and Prinz, 1999), which show substantial differences for different foods and between individuals. The first bite by the incisors is an important stage which generates an early textural response that can influence subsequent chewing actions. The food is then transported between the cheek teeth, the jaw closes and main-sequence mastication starts. Hard foods are comminuted into particles, which are then formed into a soft bolus with saliva. Before this bolus is swallowed, the tongue is used to clear any remaining particles. Hutchings and Lillford (1988) have described two thresholds that need to be satisfied before swallowing is initiated: a food particle size threshold and a lubrication threshold. Finally, debris can be left in the mouth after swallowing, and further clearance and swallows may be necessary. 1.2.3 Mechanisms of texture perception Either of the two mechanisms described in Section 1.1.1 (proprioception and somesthesis) can operate during the mastication process, depending on the nature and texture of the food. The texture of solid foods is perceived primarily through proprioception, as the food is chopped by the incisors and ground by the molars. As the physical state of the food changes dramatically during mastication, both mechanisms can be operative. In particular, during the mastication of solid foods somesthesis becomes important as the bolus is formed and manipulated. However, even at the early stages of mastication (and prior to mastication, through use of fingers and lips), somesthesis can give important textural sensations. The texture of semi-solid and liquid foods is perceived primarily through somesthesis, from the action of the tongue and the soft palate, and is usually expressed by the term mouthfeel.
8 Texture in food
1.2.4 Sensory assessment of texture A sensory stimulus to a human subject produces a set of physiological sensations that are interpreted by the brain as perceptions. The sensations will vary considerably between subjects, reflecting the natural physiological differences in the population, and the interpretation by the brain will be modified by psychological differences. Perceptions are recorded as actions by the subject, or as verbal responses. This may be the selection of a certain sample from a group (as in a difference test), words to describe the nature of a perception, and numbers to measure the size of a perception. To ensure that the subjects’ responses relate as closely to their perception as possible, it is necessary to use carefully controlled environmental conditions and test procedures to carry out experiments. In particular, it is important to minimise the many sources of psychological bias that can produce unwanted influences on responses, and it is frequently necessary to minimise the spread of physiological responses characteristic of biological systems through careful panel selection and training procedures.
1.3 Tests and test procedures 1.3.1 Procedures A basic classification of the main sensory test procedures is shown in Fig. 1.2. The primary classification is into analytical tests and hedonic tests. Analytical tests use trained panels as a form of analytical instrument to generate information on the sensory properties of the food, whereas hedonic tests measure the response of untrained consumers to the sensory properties in terms of liking or acceptability. Different psychological procedures form
Sensory test methods
Analytical Difference tests
Descriptive tests
Paired comparison
Qualitative
Duo-trio
Profile
Hedonic Preference tests Paired preference
Acceptability tests Acceptability scaling
Triangle
Instrumental measures of perceived quality
Response of consumers to perceived quality
Fig. 1.2 Classification of the main sensory testing procedures.
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
9
the basis for this test distinction, and the information produced is distinct but complementary. Discrimination tests are commonly used to establish, for example, if a formulation modification has changed the sensory quality. Although the tests can be a sensitive measure of change, and more recently have been generalised from their traditional use as difference tests to permit testing for similarity (Meilgaard et al., 1999), they generate relatively little information. The most informative analytical procedures identify the sensory properties that are characteristic of that food, and quantify the individual characteristics; these are termed sensory profile methods. Numerous sensory profile methods have been developed for foods, but the most important in practical use are the Texture Profile Method, Quantitative Descriptive Analysis and the Spectrum Method (reviewed in Kilcast, 1999).
1.3.2 Difference tests Paired comparison test In the most common form of the test, two coded samples are presented either sequentially or simultaneously in a balanced presentation order (i.e. AB and BA). There are two variations on the test. In the directional difference variant, the panellists are asked to choose the sample with the greater or lesser amount of a specified characteristic. The panellists are usually instructed to make a choice (forced-choice procedure), even if they have to guess, or they may be allowed to record a ‘no-difference’ response. Duo-trio test In the most common variant of the duo-trio test, the panellists are presented with a sample that is identified as a reference, followed by two coded samples, one of which is the same as the reference and the other different. These coded samples are presented in a balanced presentation order, i.e. A (reference) A (reference)
A B
B A
The panellists are asked to identify which sample is the same as the reference. The duo-trio test is particularly useful when testing foods that are difficult to prepare in identical portions. Testing such heterogeneous foods using the triangle test, which relies on identical portions, can give rise to practical difficulties, but in the duo-trio test there are no major difficulties in asking the question: Which sample is most similar to the reference? Triangle test Three coded samples are presented to the panellists, two of which are identical, using all possible sample permutations, i.e.
10 Texture in food
ABB BAB BBA
AAB ABA BAA
The panellists are asked to select the odd sample in a fixed-choice procedure. The increased number of samples compared with a paired comparison test can result in problems with flavour carry-over when using strongly flavoured samples, making identification of the odd sample more difficult. Difficulties can also be encountered in ensuring presentation of identical samples of some foods (see above). 3-AFC (Alternative Forced Choice) test This less common procedure uses one-half of the same sample permutations from the triangle test in a triad format, but either the difference of interest between the samples is revealed to the panellists in advance, or the panellists identify the nature of any difference in advance. In the test itself, the panellists are then asked to identify the sample (or samples) with the specified characteristic. For example, a typical instruction might be: One of these samples is more bitter than the others; please identify this sample. O’Mahony (1995) has identified the reasons why this test can be more sensitive than the triangle test, but the test suffers from the need to identify the nature of the difference positively in advance. R-index test This short-cut signal-detection method (O’Mahony, 1979; 1986) is less well used but has found applications in industry. The test samples are compared against a previously presented standard, and rated in one of four categories. For difference testing, these categories are standard, perhaps standard, perhaps not standard and not standard. The test can also be carried out as a recognition test, in which case the categories are standard recognised, perhaps standard recognised, perhaps standard not recognised and standard not recognised. The results are expressed in terms of R-indices, which represent probability values of correct discrimination or correct identification. The method is claimed to give some quantification of magnitude of difference, but its use has not been widely reported in the literature. One important limitation is that a relatively high number of judgements is needed in this form of test, leading to the risk of severe panellist fatigue. Difference from control test The test is of particular value when a control is available; the panellists are presented with an identified control and a range of test samples. They are asked to rate the samples on suitable scales anchored by the points ‘not different from control’ to ‘very different from control’. The test results are usually analysed as scaled data.
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
11
1.3.3 Quantitative descriptive tests The Texture Profile Method The Texture Profile Method was developed by the General Foods Company specifically to define and measure the textural parameters of foods. Panellists are selected on the basis of ability to discriminate known textural differences in the specific product application for which the panel is to be trained (solid foods, beverages, semi-solid foods, skin care products, fabrics and paper goods). Panellists selected for training are exposed to a wide range of products from the category under investigation, to provide a wide frame of references. The characteristics of the product, the order of appearance and the degree to which each is present are determined. Attributes are usually evaluated in the following order: 1 2 3 4
surface characteristics (can be visual); initial compression (perceived on first bite); masticatory phase (perceived during chewing); residual phase (changes made during mastication and often perceived after swallowing).
In addition to the mechanical (e.g. firmness, adhesiveness, viscosity, springiness, cohesiveness) and geometrical (e.g. flakiness, grittiness, beady, crystalline) characteristics evaluated during the initial compression and masticatory stages, auditory characteristics such as crunchiness, crackliness or crispness might be evaluated. The panel verdicts are derived by group consensus or by statistical analysis of the data. Results are displayed in tabular or graphic form. Quantitative Descriptive Analysis (QDA) QDA is a total system covering sample selection, panellist screening, vocabulary development, testing and data analysis (Meilgaard et al., 1999). Variants of the original QDA procedures are probably used more than any other profiling procedure. The QDA technique uses small numbers of highly trained panellists. Typically, 6 to 12 people are screened for sensory acuity and trained to perform the descriptive task to evaluate the product. Three major steps are required: development of a standardised vocabulary, quantification of selected sensory characteristics and analysis of the results using parametric statistics. Development of the vocabulary is a group process for creating a complete list of descriptors for the products under study. Panellists freely describe the flavour, appearance, odour, mouthfeel, texture and aftertaste characteristics of different samples. No hedonic (good or balanced ), general (full or typical ) or intensity-based (strong or weak) terms are permitted. Terminology should be consistent from product to product and tied to reference materials. The references decrease panellist variability, reduce the amount of time necessary to train sensory panellists, and allow calibration of the panel in the use of intensity scales. References should be simple, reproducible and clear to the
12 Texture in food
panellists, and illustrate only a single sensory descriptor. They can be single chemical substances or finished products, and are made available during both the training and the testing phase, at various concentrations or intensity. The attributes are collected and compiled into a master list. This individual preliminary evaluation of the samples may be revised during an open discussion to eliminate any redundant or synonymous descriptors. New terms might be added and physical references proposed. The panel leader condenses and formats the information into a proposal for standardised vocabulary. This vocabulary is then modified and improved in several interactive sessions. Multivariate statistical methods (e.g. factor analysis) are sometimes used to reduce the number of descriptors. Finally, definitions for the attributes are agreed. When the panellists have agreed a vocabulary, further training is performed. The number of training sessions is dependent on the subject’s performance, product and attribute difficulties and the time allowed for QDA testing. Panel training increases panellist sensitivity and memory and helps panellists to make valid, reliable judgements independent of personal preferences. Once the training sessions have established satisfactory panel performance, and after removal of ambiguities and misunderstandings, the test samples can be evaluated. This is usually carried out in replicated (commonly three) sessions, using experimental designs that minimise biases. In each session, the mean is calculated for group and individual judgements of each attribute. The results are then subjected to univariate statistics (e.g. analysis of variance) or multivariate statistics (e.g. principal component analysis). Test results may also be visualised via bar charts or line graphs. The Spectrum Method This more recent method provides a tool with which to design a descriptive procedure for a given product category. The method resembles QDA in many respects; for example, the panel must be trained to fully define all product sensory attributes, to rate the intensity of each and to include other relevant characterising aspects such as change over time, difference in the order of appearance of attributes, and integrated total aroma and/or flavour impact. Panellists develop their lists of descriptors by first evaluating a broad array of products that define the product category. The process includes using references to determine the best choice of term and to best define that term so that it is understood in the same way by all panellists. Words such as vanilla, chocolate or orange must describe an authentic vanilla, chocolate and orange character, for which clear references are supplied. All terms from all panellists are then compiled into a list that is comprehensive but not overlapping. The Spectrum Method is based on an extensive use of reference points. The choice of scaling technique may depend on the available facilities for
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
13
computer manipulation of data and on the need for sophisticated data analysis. Whatever the scale chosen, it must have at least two, preferably three or five, reference points distributed across the range.
1.3.4 Time-intensity methods Sensory attributes are not perceived instantaneously and can change in intensity with time in the mouth. Time-intensity methods are used to measure intensity of a specific attribute as a function of time in the mouth. They have been used to investigate the temporal behaviour of tastants, such as sweet and bitter molecules, and to investigate the release of volatile flavour materials from foods (Overbosch et al., 1991; Shamil et al., 1992) during mastication. Such studies are particularly important in the reformulation of foods that results in structural modifications, and in changes that can occur on storage. These structural modifications are often accompanied by textural changes, and these often result in complex perceptual phenomena that are direct consequences of the changes in texture with time producing different flavour release phenomena. The use of time-intensity for flavour measurement is well established, and there have also been studies to measure textural changes using the method (Burger, 1992; Duizer et al., 1993). A major limitation of time-intensity methods is that only a single attribute can be tracked with time, and, if a number of important attributes are thought to be time-dependent, separate sessions are needed for each attribute. Difficulties encountered in time-intensity profiling prompted the development of a hybrid technique, progressive profiling (Jack et al., 1994). In this technique, assessors carried out a profile on a set of texture descriptors at each chew stroke over the mastication period. Such a method has a number of potential advantages: several attributes can be assessed in one session; scaling is reduced to a unidimensional process; and the most important aspects of the shape of a time-intensity curve are retained.
1.4 Instrumental measurement of texture Sensory methods are, for the foreseeable future, the primary means of measuring the range of textural characteristics of food that are important to consumer acceptance. The highly labour-intensive nature of sensory analysis has inevitably led to the development of instrumental methods designed to measure food properties that relate to relevant sensory characteristics. These methods have been classified in various ways, according to the type of measurement and the type of food.
14 Texture in food
1.4.1 Empirical, imitative and fundamental measurement Instrumental methods have been classified into three main categories: empirical, imitative and fundamental. Empirical methods Empirical tests often measure ill-defined variables that are indicated by practical experience to be related to some aspect of textural quality. Devices have been developed within different sectors of the industry that are appropriate to specific product types. Even for the same product type, different food manufacturers have developed their own in-house devices. Fuller details of the devices described in this section are given in Bourne (2002). • Puncture or penetration devices measure either the force needed to push a probe into the food to a specified depth or the penetration distance achieved by application of a specified force. Examples include MagnessTaylor testers (for fruit), the Bloom Gelometer and the FIRA Jelly Tester (for gels), the cone penetrometer (for fats) and the Christel Texture Meter (for peas). • Shearing devices measure the force needed for one or more blades to shear through the food. The maximum force is often assumed to measure toughness, firmness or fibrousness. Instruments include the Warner-Bratzler Shear (for meat), the Kramer Shear Cell (general-purpose) and the FMC Pea Tenderometer. • Compression devices measure the force needed to achieve a given compression or the compression achieved at a given force. Examples include the Baker Compressimeter (for bread) and the ball indenter (for fats). In extrusion tests, the food is forced through one or more orifices and the maximum force, average force or work done over a specified period is measured. The measured values are assumed to relate to firmness, toughness, consistency or spreadability. Examples include the FIRA-NIRD Extruder (for fats) and various cells used in conjunction with generalpurpose instruments. • Cutting devices use wires or blades (sometimes rotating) to cut through the food and measure the maximum force developed or the time needed to cut through a standard size of sample. Measurements are assumed to relate to fibrousness, firmness or hardness. The FMBRA Biscuit Texture Meter is a rotating blade device used to measure biscuit hardness. • Flow and mixing devices are used to give a measure of viscosity or consistency of liquid and semi-liquid foods. They often measure the extent to which samples flow or spread under specific geometric conditions, e.g. the Bostwick Consistometer and the Lyons Gel Flow Meter. Although such empirical devices are often simple, inexpensive and portable, precision and reproducibility are generally poor, and the measured parameters are poor measures of perceived texture. Extensive use is still made of them in industry, however, mainly for quality control purposes.
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
15
Imitative methods Imitative methods of measurement mimic the conditions to which the material is subjected in practice during eating. The Volodkevich bite tenderometer attempted to mimic the action of teeth on food. It recorded the force of biting on a piece of food as a function of the deformation incurred. Two wedges with rounded points were substituted for teeth, the lower being fixed to a frame. The upper wedge moved with a linear motion through the arc of a circle by a lever, squeezing a sample between the wedges. A device using human dentures served as the prototype for the General Foods (GF) Texturometer (Friedman et al., 1963), in which the dentures are replaced by a plunger. The location of the sensing element was moved from the articular arm to the sample area to eliminate gravity forces, and the oscilloscope was replaced by a chart recorder, enabling easy and permanent recording of any chosen number of consecutive chews. In this device, the driving mechanism no longer imparts a combined lateral and forward motion to the lower jaw, although it still drives the plunger through the arc of a circle. Although the GF Texturometer remains in use to a small extent in North America and in Japan, the general-purpose testing machines designed for use with foods, exemplified by those made by Stable Micro Systems, Stevens, Lloyd and Instron, are commonly used in the food industry in most countries. The instruments differ in their mechanical construction and in their data acquisition and data analysis capabilities, but they have a number of important features in common. All have a crosshead containing a load cell, which is driven vertically at a range of constant speeds, and which can cycle over a fixed distance or load range. Probes can be attached to the crosshead for penetrating, shearing or crushing food, which can be held in a variety of cells. The load is recorded relative to time or to penetration/deformation distance, and displayed on a suitable recorder. Computer control of the instrument and sophisticated and rapid computer analysis of the data are increasingly common. A major advantage of such instruments is that flexibility of design allows them to be used for a wide range of foods. This is particularly useful for companies that are handling or manufacturing a varied product range. Load cells can be changed to give a high level of accuracy for relatively soft foods through to very hard foods. Probes and sample holders can easily be changed to accommodate measurements on different product types. An additional advantage is that such instruments can often be adapted for fundamental texture measurement. Fundamental methods Fundamental methods involve measuring well-defined physical properties of food, which, if measured properly, are independent of the method of measurement. The most common fundamental parameters are Young’s modulus, shear modulus, bulk modulus and Poisson’s ratio (for solids) and viscosity
16 Texture in food
(for liquids). Fundamental parameters for solids can be measured on generalpurpose testing machines, but such measurements require a carefully designed experimental set-up and are consequently slow. In addition, foods are generally heterogeneous and do not exhibit simple elastic behaviour. Fundamental parameters can be measured on liquids using suitable instrumentation, for example the Weissenberg Rheogoniometer and the Carri-Med Rheometer. Again, however, liquid foods rarely exhibit simple viscosity behaviour. Such fundamental measurements are valuable in investigating the physical properties of food, but are too complex for routine use and, in common with other instrumental measurements, rarely correlate well with perceived texture. Some reasons for this can be identified on examining some of the physiological factors associated with chewing.
1.4.2 Application to solid foods Development of measurement methods For most solid foods, key sensory attributes can be defined that are known to be highly important in defining consumer acceptability, for example crispness in salad vegetables and snack foods, tenderness in meat, and snap in chocolate. The evolution of measurement methods has followed the need both to control these attributes in routine production and to understand how they can be designed into new products. The computerised modern instruments that utilise force-deformation principles are used almost universally in research functions and, with particular success, in quality control (QC) functions. A good example of this is the use by the French company Isigny Sainte-Mère of Stable Micro Systems TAXT2 Texture Analysers for on-line measurement of the firmness of Camembert cheeses to sort for different maturing conditions (Toursel, 1996). The reason for the successful applications in QC is easy to see. In such applications, it is more important to be able to detect changes in measurable parameters than to measure precisely specific textural parameters. A change in any measured parameter outside set control limits can act as a signal that some aspect of the food production cycle has drifted. Of course, this introduces the risk that actions could be taken on the basis of changes in parameters that have little importance to consumer acceptability, but the measurements would normally trigger sensory tests that would minimise any production holds. A more serious risk is that the measurement system would not identify textural changes that were unmeasurable by that system, and, unless routine sensory tests were also carried out, defective material could be supplied to consumers. For example, a standard texture instrument capable of measuring the characteristic snap of chocolate might not detect the dryness that characterises stale chocolate. The deficiencies of texture measurement instruments become particularly apparent when they are used for R&D purposes. One practical problem is that no single instrument is likely to be able to measure the food properties
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
17
that are detected by both the tactile and the deep senses. One route to address this problem is to investigate more closely those physical processes that give rise to the texture sensations. In a study of stickiness in confectionery products, Kilcast and Roberts (1998) explained the need to understand both the meaning of the word ‘stickiness’ by consumers, and in what context the phenomenon is perceived, as well as the physical processes that contribute to the various phenomena commonly described as stickiness. They showed that the perception of stickiness can occur through combinations of both adhesive and cohesive failure (Fig. 1.3). Most industrial problems are associated with cohesive failure, which leaves unwanted material behind on surfaces. Both product rheology and the surface energy of the surfaces can contribute to the observed sticking phenomena, and under critical conditions it is possible to minimise sticking by either changing the surfaces involved or changing product composition or operating conditions. The research led to a test procedure adapted from that developed by Chen and Hoseney (1995) for measuring the stickiness of dough that can be used to study the stickiness of caramels over a wide range of conditions. Figure 1.4 shows the cell, which consists of a Probe movement
Probe movement
Adhesive failure
Cohesive failure a2
a1
start
c1
c2
Fig. 1.3 Adhesive and cohesive failure mechanisms during the force–deformation testing of food. The sequence to the left (start, a1, a2) illustrates adhesive failure; the sequence to the right (start, c1, c2) illustrates cohesive failure. Grid
Perforated cap
Sample reservoir
Water jacket
Piston
Fig. 1.4 Modified Chen-Hoseney cell for measuring the stickiness of caramel.
18 Texture in food
water-jacketed cylinder holding the caramel sample at the required temperature. The screw piston is used to extrude the caramel through a perforated stainless steel cap to give a fresh surface. The instrumental measurements are carried out by lowering a cylindrical probe onto the caramel surface, and then withdrawing it and measuring the force-deformation characteristics. For solid foods giving the proprioceptive (deep) response, the principles of fracture mechanics have been applied widely, and are outlined in the following section. Fracture mechanics in food texture measurements The science of fracture mechanics was originally developed to explain the fracture of brittle materials such as glass. The breakage of a material is influenced by the relationship between the applied force and the bond holding the material together. Bonds will break more readily under the high local stress concentration around the tip of a sharp blade, for example. The basic premise underlying fracture mechanics is that all solids contain inhomogeneities, which exist in the form of flaws, or cracks. The magnitude and distribution of these defects govern the strength of the material. Fracture occurs when these defects grow and traverse the solid, creating new fracture surfaces. Early studies showed the potential of wedge fracture testing to brittle and semi-brittle foods such as apples and cheeses (Vincent et al., 1991). One difficulty in applying the principles of fracture mechanics to food lies in the great complexity of food structure, and in the complex viscoelastic behaviour of most foods, although recent research has demonstrated the feasibility of these techniques (Dolores Alvarez et al., 2000). However, deformation tests applied to carefully prepared food samples have been shown to give improved correlations between instrumentally measured properties and sensory measures. The principles of fracture mechanics have been extended to the measurement of fracture toughness of complex foods, such as the pastry casing of spring rolls (Sim et al., 1993). Lillford (2001) has reviewed the work relating to fracture mechanisms in food, and Lucas et al., (2002) have proposed physiological models relating to the fragmentation and swallowing of food particles.
1.4.3 Analysis and validation of instrumental measurements Statistical methods A physical measurement of textural characteristics can be of practical value only if it is shown to relate to some relevant sensory texture measure. The relationship should take the form of a statistic that represents the fit between the instrumental measurement and the sensory attribute, or an equation that relates the instrumental measure (or set of measures) to the required sensory attribute. Two basic procedures are used.
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
19
• Pearson product moment correlation coefficients (r), where a perfect positive correlation gives r = +1, a perfect negative correlation gives r = –1, and no correlation gives r = 0. The square of the correlation coefficient (r2) gives a measure of the data variance accounted for by the linear correlation, and is a measure of the value of the correlation. • Multiple linear regression (MLR), in which the variable of interest (e.g. sensory attribute) is expressed as a linear combination of other variables (e.g. instrumental parameters). The variable combination is usually found using stepwise selection procedures. The method is of greatest value when the number of data points exceeds the number of attributes of interest. The complexity of both instrumental and sensory data, however, increasingly demands the use of multivariate statistical procedures. Many techniques are available, but, when examining for structure and relationships in data sets, the most common technique is principal component analysis (PCA). PCA is a data reduction technique that replaces a large number of original variables by a smaller number of linear combinations, whilst still explaining a substantial proportion of the original variation in the data. Essentially, PCA projects an n-dimensional space onto a 2-dimensional plot. Other multivariate analyses, such as partial least squares (PLS) analysis are increasingly being used for combined data sets. For example, in a study of the sensory and instrumental characteristics of Reggiano grating cheeses, PLS was used to show that sensory texture correlated best with strain at breaking point (Hough et al., 1996). Novel methods for analysing force–deformation data Analytical software included in the modern force-deformation test systems is capable of parameterising the curve shapes generated by many foods. The most extreme deviation from the idealised force–deformation curves is commonly found in testing brittle foods, which are characterised by very jagged curves. In a series of papers (e.g. Barrett et al., 1992), Peleg and coworkers have described different mathematical approaches to analysing these highly irregular curve shapes, which can give rise to difficulties in parameterisation. One approach has been to carry out a Fast Fourier Transform on the force–deformation curve, giving a power spectrum of underlying frequencies. This procedure gives a qualitative representation of the jaggedness of the original curve, but cannot give a quantitative representation. Such quantification can be carried out through fractal analysis. The fractal concept is based on the geometry of self-similar objects expressed in terms of noninteger dimensions. The fractal dimension is determined from the slope, in logarithmic co-ordinates between the length of the force–deformation contour and the corresponding measurement scale. The latter measurement was found to be convenient in giving a measure of overall jaggedness in terms of a single number, but the power spectrum gave more information on the location of the fracture, and its shape could be related more directly to structure and
20 Texture in food
texture. The use of the power spectrum was subsequently described in relation to the measurement of crunchiness in friable baked products (Rohde et al., 1993). A further innovative attempt to analyse jagged force–deformation curves has been to use a technique used in speech analysis and medical diagnosis, symmetrised dot-pattern (SDP) displays (Peleg and Normand, 1992). This concept is based on the premise that, whereas humans find it difficult to analyse the visual appearance of highly irregular shapes, they are highly sensitive to changes in symmetric patterns. In the method, the recorded data are transformed into several symmetrically arranged sets of points, each reflected by a mirror plane, in an analogous way to the production of symmetric visual images by a kaleidoscope. The technique was used in the hope that the displays could be used to identify crunchiness in the same way that they can be used to identify vowels, but, in practice, the SDP displays were so sensitive to minor details that every signature appeared unique (Peleg, 1998).
1.5 In vivo texture measurement The limitations in trying to mimic the events occurring during mastication using relatively simple instruments have long been appreciated. An alternative approach that has gained credence in recent years has been to attempt to record signals generated by or within the human subject that may relate to the texture of the food being masticated. 1.5.1 Electromyography (EMG) and associated techniques EMG involves the use of a polygraph to measure electrical signals generated in muscles that are active during mastication. For certain muscles that lie close to the surface of the skin, for example the masseter muscle, which is active during the chewing of solid foods, this activity can be related to a specific muscle. Other oral activity, for example tongue movement, is controlled by groups of muscles that are deeper-lying. Monitoring of signals from this latter type of musculature ideally requires implanted electrodes, whereas signals from the masseter muscle can be readily recorded using surface electrodes. Early attempts to use EMG in the study of food texture were limited by difficulty in interpreting the complex data patterns produced. In the absence of suitable computerised acquisition and analysis equipment, visual inspection of the raw data was carried out. For example, motor pauses (or silent periods) were more frequent with hard foods than with soft foods (Boyar and Kilcast, 1986). The development of more sophisticated EMG equipment and computer systems, however, has permitted much deeper analysis of EMG data and their relationship to food texture. An added potential advantage of this technique is studying changes in food texture in the mouth throughout the whole chewing
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
21
cycle. Research projects carried out at the Leatherhead Food Research Association (e.g. Eves, 1990; Kilcast and Eves, 1991) were carried out to investigate the potential use for EMG as a means of characterising food texture, and the way in which texture changes during mastication. Following this work, a number of papers have appeared in the literature in which EMG has been used to investigate food texture. Further studies on the use of EMG in the confectionery sector were reported by Smalls (1992), and indicated good correlations between EMG and Instron measurements. Applications to cheese texture were described by Jack et al. (1993). In this work, EMG was used in conjunction with sensory and instrumental measurements of the texture of a range of Cheddar cheeses, but inconsistency between subjects resulted in difficulties in correlating EMG and Instron measurements. In a review of texture measurements for use in product development, Jack et al. (1995) described the use of EMG in conjunction with other methods. Duizer et al. (1996) used a combination of EMG, timeintensity measurement and instrumental measurement to investigate beef tenderness. The results indicated that the effects of early mastication should be compared with the effects of late mastication. More fundamental aspects of the use of EMG in understanding the oral breakdown process have been reported by Brown and co-workers (e.g. Brown et al., 1994; Brown, 1995; Brown et al., 1998). These studies focused primarily on understanding the chewing behaviour of consumers rather than on texture measurement. EMG was used either as the sole technique, or in combination with synchronous measurement of jaw movement (kinesthesiology) by a set of transducers mounted on a head-frame to track the movement of a small magnet attached to the lower front incisors. Several oral techniques, including EMG, have also been used by Mioche and co-workers to study the mastication process (e.g. Mathevon et al., 1995; Peyron et al., 1996; Mioche and Martin, 1998). A more recent study within the EU HealthSense project has seen the use of EMG to investigate differences in chewing patterns between young and elderly populations (Kohyama et al., 2002). An unusual related technique for studying mastication behaviour has been reported by Jack and Gibbon (1995). The technique, electropalatography (EPG), is used to measure tongue movement during eating and swallowing, and comprises an artificial plate, moulded to the individual’s hard palate, embedded in which are 62 electrodes covering the entire palate surface. Tongue contact with the electrodes generates a signal that can be used to monitor the movement of the tongue. Experiments were carried out with liquid, semi-solid and gelled foods. The authors concluded that the technique could be used for liquid and semi-solid foods, but that bulky or sticky foods prevented the tongue making contact with the palate. 1.5.2 Sound emission Early studies on food-crushing sounds (Drake, 1963) showed that sounds from crisp foods differed from those of non-crisp foods, primarily in terms
22 Texture in food
of amplitude. Frequency and duration played a less important role. A subsequent paper (Vickers and Bourne, 1976) presented studies of the acoustical properties of tape-recorded biting sounds of wet and dry crisp foods. Amplitude–time plots indicated that both sound amplitude and the number of sounds produced in a given bite distance discriminated between different levels of crispness. A series of papers on crispness appeared subsequently (reviewed in Vickers, 1988). In one of this series (Vickers, 1985), it was shown that pitch was a useful parameter in distinguishing between crispness and crunchiness; crisp sounds tended to be higher in pitch than crunchy sounds. These extensive studies gave considerable improvements to the understanding of crispness, and associated work has continued in other laboratories. Dacremont et al. (1992) investigated the contribution of both air-transmitted and bone-conducted sound to the perception of crispness, crackliness and crunchiness in foods. In a further paper, Dacremont and Colas (1993) investigated whether a person’s perception of duration, loudness and pitch of biting sounds might be biased by the sight of food samples. The results suggest that the visual perception of foods has no influence on the loudness or pitch judgement; however, it does influence the judgement of sound duration during eating. This paper pointed out that sound propagation in air is different between an incisor bite, with lips open, and a molar chew, with lips closed. The contact area between food and teeth is different, and the amount of vibration through the bones is different. Although the bite sounds are different for the three textural types, the differences are not sufficient to distinguish them clearly. Roudaut et al. (1998) used acoustic emission in conjunction with sensory analysis, compression tests and Dynamic Mechanical Thermal Analysis (DMTA) to investigate the effect of water on the texture of crispy breads. One difficulty in appraising the practical relevance of the research into sound emission and the texture of foods lies in the difficulty in the use of descriptive terminology. The words crispy and crunchy are, in particular, commonly used without agreed definitions. Work carried out at Leatherhead Food International on the measurement of the texture of fruit and vegetables has taken a consumer-led approach, and has investigated the understanding of textural terms by consumers. Repertory Grid interviewing methods were used to elicit textural descriptions of fruit and vegetables by consumers, and to relate them to attributes developed by trained sensory panels (Kilcast and Fillion, 2001). The trained panel developed a sensory profile that included different attributes associated with the sounds emitted during mastication. Table 1.1 shows a comparison of term usage between consumers and panellists. Of the ten consumers interviewed, nine used the term ‘crunchy’ to describe the texture of the products, but only five mentioned the term ‘crispy’, while one did not mention ‘crispy’ or ‘crunchy’ at all. Those who mentioned both ‘crispy’ and ‘crunchy’ were always using the two terms with different meanings and usually found it easier to describe one against the other. There was generally a good agreement on the meaning of the term ‘crunchy’, with
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
23
Table 1.1 Definitions of crispy and crunchy attributes from consumer and panellist interviews
Number of subjects mentioning the attribute Assessment on front teeth only Assessment on back teeth only Number of times a descriptor was given: Hard, dense Sound Loud Low pitch High pitch Repetition of sound Brittle Snap, clean break Light Fresh Moist
Consumers*
Panellists**
Crunchy
Crispy
Crunchy
Crispy
9
5 1
11
10 6 2
1 8 8 2
6 3
8 10 4 8
9 4 8
1 3 2 3 1
5 3 8 6 1
* n = 11 ** n = 10
most definitions mentioning hardness and sound. Definitions for the ‘crispy’ attributes were more diverse, and were a combination of a snap clean break, a light texture and a sound, and were also associated with freshness, moistness and brittleness for some consumers. These studies have assisted in developing improved methods for texture measurement. Measurement of sound can be used to show the close relationship between the release of sound energy and failure events that result in detectable changes in force. Figure 1.5 shows a comparison of force–deformation and emitted sounds for celery subjected to an incisor probe test in a Stable Micro Systems TA-HD instrument (Kilcast, 2001). The upper curve shows the sound emitted during the test, and the lower curve shows the differential of the force curve, measured from the signal taken directly from the load cell; the close correspondence is clear. However, substantial practical difficulties remain in the measurement of sound during the test, primarily from interferences by the noise emitted from the motor drive of the test machine, and noise from extraneous sources.
1.6 Future developments Although it is increasingly being recognised that only sensory methods can give a complete picture of food texture, many needs can be identified for the
24 Texture in food
Sound level
Differential of the force curve
Fig. 1.5 Comparison of the emitted sound level with the differential of the force changes from cutting celery using an incisor probe.
instrumental measurement of key textural characteristics, and considerable research is being carried out to find new methods. There is particular interest in finding and validating non-destructive methods that can be used for quality control purposes, and for portable instruments that can be used directly in the field.
1.6.1 Selection procedures for sensory panellists Methods for the selection of panellists to ensure that they are capable of carrying out the required sensory tests are described in an ISO Standard (ISO, 1993). This recommends tests for acuity of visual perception, taste and odour perception, but not tests for texture perception ability, other than the generation of verbal descriptions. As part of a European Union-funded project on Healthy Eating for the Elderly, Fillion and Kilcast (2001) have developed tests designed to investigate texture perception and oral dexterity in the elderly. These tests are potentially of great value in screening panellists for use in food texture assessment, and are currently being adapted for this purpose.
1.6.2 Dynamic force/deformation methods The most common material parameters linked to firmness are the elastic properties of the product: hard materials have high values of the elastic modulus, while soft materials have lower values (Pitts et al., 1994). Abbott and Massie (1995) believed that approximate values of the elastic properties of produce were adequate for sorting, and that a dynamic force/deformation (F/D) test might be relatively simple to implement on a kiwifruit packing line. They compared various parameters from a low-frequency F/D test with
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
25
data from the Magness-Taylor puncture test, and found that a relatively simple firmness tester could be devised on the basis of 60-Hz vibrations. 1.6.3 Sound input methods Sonic resonance testing is a potential method for non-destructive measurement of firmness. Resonant frequencies of intact fruits and vegetables decrease with ripening and are directly related to their rigidity, firmness and ripeness (Abbott et al., 1968). Abbott et al. (1995) showed that sonic stiffness coefficients were satisfactory predictors of the firmness of Golden Delicious apples, when compared with the maximum force in compression or puncture tests. Mealiness in apples has been studied using acoustic impulse methods (Tu and de Baerdemaeker, 1996). Chen et al. (1996) and Armstrong et al. (1997) also used the resonant frequency of the vibrational modes to evaluate firmness of melons and peaches, respectively. Muramatsu et al. (1997) used pulsed sound transmission to measure the firmness of kiwifruit during ripening, and found good correlations with penetration testing. Low-frequency ultrasonics have been used (Nielsen and Martens, 1997) to evaluate the texture of carrots during cooking. Ultrasonic methods have also been used in the study of the texture of beef (Park et al., 1994), wafers (Juodeikiene et al., 1990) and crackers (Juodeikiene et al., 1994). 1.6.4 Spectroscopic and related methods A number of both direct and indirect methods for assessing texture have been reported. Near-infrared spectroscopy was investigated as a method for the quality control of asparagus (Garrido Varo et al., 2000). Laser scattering properties of apples were investigated as a means of measuring firmness (Cho and Han, 1999). Scatter parameters showed good correlations with compression testing, but strong varietal differences were found. Laser Doppler techniques have been used to measure firmness of fruit and to detect fruit disorders (Muramatsu et al., 1999). The Doppler method gave good correlations with conventional instrumental testing on peaches, pears and citrus fruit, and is claimed to have potential as a remote-sensing device. Textural investigations using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) have also been reported. Schmidt (1999) has reviewed general uses of NMR methods, and Kim et al. (1998) have studied possible uses of both NMR and MRI for textural investigations. 1.6.5 Image analysis Image analysis techniques have been reported for measuring different aspects of food texture (Affeldt et al., 1994). The paper reviews methods for the measurement of surface texture, dimension and shape and surface cracks. Coles and Wang (1997), described the use of a Bread Quality Imaging System to measure the fineness of bread texture by detecting bubbles above a minimum
26 Texture in food
size. Measurement of the texture of corn puffs by image analysis has been described (Gao et al., 1999). Visually determined sensory scores were effectively predicted by the intensity band image features. A further aspect of visualisation was demonstrated by Kilcast et al. (1984) and Boyar et al. (1984), in which the photoelastic properties of gelatin were used to visualise stress distributions in gelatin during the course of penetration testing. Figure 1.6 shows an example of the interference fringes produced on testing a gelatin gel with a hemispherically ended probe viewed under sodium light between crossed polarisers. Whilst such imaging is restricted to a small number of transparent gels, computation techniques are now available to calculate stress distributions in such systems, but they do not appear to have been used in this context.
1.7 Conclusions Given the complex nature of food texture, developments in measurement techniques are likely to be evolutionary rather than revolutionary. Can the ideal instrumental test, that incorporates the essential elements of fundamental tests, imitative tests and empirical tests, be devised? Table 1.2 summarises
Fig. 1.6 Interference fringes produced on testing a gelatin gel with a hemispherically-ended probe, and viewed under sodium light between crossed polarisers.
Table 1.2 Summary of the main classes of texture measurement Food types
Initial costs
Running costs
Operating environment
Development status
Consumer relevance6
Sensory1
All
High
Moderate/high
Laboratory/QC/ production
Mature/ continuing
High
Empirical2
All
Low
Low
QC/production
Mature/ continuing
Low
Imitative3
Solids
Moderate
Low
Laboratory/QC
Continuing
Low/moderate
Fundamental4
All
High
Low
Laboratory
Mature
Low
Sound emission
Brittle solids
Moderate/high
Low/moderate
Laboratory
Continuing
Moderate/high
Sound input
Solids
Moderate/high
Low
Laboratory
Continuing
Low/moderate
Physiological5
Mainly solids
High/moderate
Moderate
Laboratory
Continuing
Moderate/high
Spectroscopic
Mainly solids
High
Moderate/high
Laboratory
Continuing
Moderate
1
Trained profile panels e.g. hand-held penetrometers 3 e.g. instrumental test rigs, General Foods Texturometer 4 Force–deformation devices under strictly defined operational conditions 5 Including EMG 6 Consumer relevance depends on ability to correlate test with subjective textural responses 2
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
Class
27
28 Texture in food
the status of texture measurement methods at the time of writing. In recent years, an increasing number of novel techniques have been investigated, and more are being used in production/QC environments. A number of factors have contributed to this situation. Firstly, conventional force–deformation instruments have undergone considerable enhancement through the extensive use of computerised data acquisition and analysis software, and through the availability of a wider range of test rigs for specific purposes. Secondly, the increased interest in the mechanics of mastication has enhanced our understanding of oral processes and of their relationship to texture perception. Thirdly, the importance of texture as an important attribute driving consumer acceptance has stimulated further research, particularly in the search for smaller but reliable measuring devices that can be used outside the QC laboratory. However, in recognition of the importance of texture to the consumer, and in keeping with a food characteristic that is defined by the human senses, texture assessment is increasingly being carried out using trained sensory panels alongside the assessment of other organoleptic characteristics such as appearance, odour and taste.
1.8 References ABBOTT J A and MASSIE D R
(1995) Nondestructive dynamic force/deformation measurement of kiwifruit firmness (Actinidia deliciosa), Transactions of the ASAE, 38(6), 1809– 1812. ABBOTT J A, BACHMAN G S, CHILDERS N F, FITZGERALD J V and MATUSIK F J (1968) Sonic techniques for measuring texture of fruits and vegetables, Food Technology, 22(5), 101–12. ABBOTT J A, MASSIE D R, UPCHURCH B L and HRUSCHKA W R (1995) Nondestructive sonic firmness measurement of apples, Transactions of the ASAE, 38(5), 1461–6. AFFELDT H A, BROWN G K, BRUSEWITZ G H, DELWICHE M J, HETZRONI A, KRANZLER G A, PELEG K, SEARCY S W and SISTLER F E (1994) Dimension, shape and surface texture measurement on agricultural commodities. In Nondestructive technologies for quality evaluation of fruits and vegetables: proceedings of the international workshop, Spokane, Washington, June 1993. Michigan, ASAE, 50–62. ARMSTRONG P R, STONE M L and BRUSEWITZ G H (1997) Peach firmness determination using two different nondestructive vibrational sensing instruments, Transactions of the ASAE, 40(3), 699–703. BARRETT A M, NORMAND M D, PELEG M and ROSS E (1992) Characterization of the jagged stress-strain relationships of puffed extrudates using the Fast Fourier Transform and Fractal analysis. Journal of Food Science, 57(1), 227–32+235. BOURNE M C (2002) Food Texture and Viscosity, Concept and Measurement (Second Edition). New York, Academic Press. BOYAR M M and KILCAST D (1986) Food texture and dental science, Journal of Texture Studies, 17, 221–52. BOYAR M M, KILCAST D and FRY J C (1984) Use of gel-based model food systems in texture measurement. In Gums and stabilisers for the food industry 2: Application of hydrocolloids. Ed. G O Phillips, Oxford, Pergamon Press, 465–73. BROWN W E (1995) The use of mastication analysis to examine the dynamics of oral breakdown of food contributing to perceived texture. In Characterization of Food: Emerging Methods. Ed. A G Gaonkar, Amsterdam, Elsevier, 309–27.
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview BROWN W E, LANGLEY K R, MARTIN A
29
and MACFIE H J M (1994) Characterisation of patterns of chewing behaviour in human subjects and their influence on texture perception, Journal of Texture Studies, 25(4), 455–68. BROWN W E, EVES D, ELLISON M and BRAXTON D (1998) Use of combined electromyography and kinesthesiology during mastication to chart the oral breakdown of foodstuffs: relevance to measurement of food texture, Journal of Texture Studies, 29(2), 145–67. BURGER J (1992) Sensory evaluation techniques for chocolate with different types of cocoa butter products, Manufacturing Confectioner, 72(10), 56–60. CARDELLO A V (1994) Consumer expectations and their role in food acceptance. In Measurement of Food Preferences. Eds H J H MacFie and D M H Thomson, London, Blackie, 253–97. CHEN H, DE BAERDEMAEKER J and BELLON V (1996) Finite element study of the melon for nondestructive sensing of firmness, Transactions of the ASAE, 39(3), 1057–65. CHEN W Z and HOSENEY R C (1995) Development of an objective method for dough stickiness, Lebensmittel Wissenscaft und Technologie. 28(5), 467–73. CHO Y L and HAN Y J (1999) Nondestructive characterization of apple firmness by quantitation of laser scatter, Journal of Texture Studies, 30(6), 625–38. COLES G D and WANG J (1997) Objective determination of bread crumb visual texture by image analysis. In Proceedings of the International Wheat Quality Conference, Manhattan, May 1997. Eds J L Steele and O K Chung, Manhattan Grain Industry Alliance, 153–9. DACREMONT C and COLAS B (1993) Effect of visual clues on evaluation of bite sounds in foodstuffs, Sciences des Aliments, 13(4), 603–10. DACREMONT C, COLAS B and SAUVAGEOT F (1992) Contribution of air- and bone-conduction to the creation of sounds perceived during sensory evaluation of foods, Journal of Texture Studies, 22(4), 443–56. DOLOREZ ALVAREZ M, SAUNDERS D E J , VINCENT J F V and JERONIMIDIS G, (2000) An engineering method to evaluate the crisp texture of fruit and vegetables, Journal of Texture Studies, 31(4), 457–73. DRAKE B K (1963) Food crushing sounds: an introductory study, Journal of Food Science, 28, 233–41. DUIZER L M, GULLETT E A and FINDLAY C J (1993) Time-intensity methodology for beef tenderness perception, Journal of Food Science, 58(5), 943–47. DUIZER L M, GULLETT E A and FINDLAY C J (1996) The relationship between sensory timeintensity, physiological electromyography and instrumental texture profile analysis measurements of beef tenderness, Meat Science, 42(2), 215–24. EVES A (1990) Physiological methods of food texture measurement (Thesis. University of Reading). FILLION L and KILCAST D (2001) Towards a measurement of oral tactile sensitivity and masticatory performance: development of texture tests. Leatherhead Food Research Report 781. FRIEDMAN H H, WHITNEY H and SZCZESNIAK A S (1963) The Texturometer – a new instrument for objective texture measurement, Journal of Food Science, 28, 390–403. GAO X, TAN J, SHATADAL P and HEYMANN H (1999) Evaluating food properties by image analysis, Journal of Texture Studies, 30(3), 291–304. GARRIDO VARO A, SANCHEZ PINEDA DE LAS INFANTAS M T and PEREZ MARTIN M D (2000) A new analytical method applied to the quality control of asparagus: near infrared reflectance spectroscopy, Alimentaria, June, 63–67. HEATH M R and PRINZ J F (1999) Oral processing of foods and the sensory evaluation of texture. In Food Texture: Measurement and Perception. Ed. A J Rosenthal, Gaithersburg, Aspen, MD. 18–29. HOUGH G, CALIFANO A N, BERTOLA N C, BEVILLACQUA A E, MARTINEZ E, VEGA M J and ZARITZKY N E (1996) Partial least squares correlations between sensory and instrumental measurements of flavor and texture for Reggiano grating cheese, Food Quality and Preference, 7(1), 47–53.
30 Texture in food and LILLFORD P (1988) The perception of food texture: The philosophy of the breakdown path, Journal of Texture Studies, 19(2), 103–15. International Standard ISO 5492 (1992); BSI 5098:1992. Glossary of terms relating to sensory analysis. ISO, Geneva. International Standard ISO 8586-1; British Standard BS 7667 Part 1 (1993) Assessors for sensory analysis. Part 1. Guide to the selection, training and monitoring of selected assessors. JACK F R and GIBBON F (1995) Electropalatography in the study of tongue movement during eating and swallowing (a novel procedure for measuring texture-related behaviour), International Journal of Food Science and Technology, 30(4), 415–23. JACK F R, PIGGOTT J R and PATERSON A (1993) Relationships between electromyography, sensory and instrumental measures of Cheddar cheese texture, Journal of Food Science, 58(6), 1313–17. JACK F R, PIGGOTT J R and PATERSON A (1994) Analysis of textural changes in hard cheese during mastication by progressive profiling, Journal of Food Science, 59(3), 539–43. JACK F R, PATERSON A and PIGGOTT J R (1995) Perceived texture: direct and indirect methods for use in product development, International Journal of Food Science and Technology, 30(1), 1–12. JUODEIKIENE G, PETRAUSKAS A, RIEDL O and MOHR E (1990) Applications of ultrasonics for the determination of wafer sheet texture, Ernahrung, 14(9), 507–11. JUODEIKIENE G, SCHLEINING G, KUNIGELIS V and ADOMAITIS , V (1994) Theoretically and experimentally investigated correlation between acoustic and structural properties of crackers, Ernahrung, 18(5), 235–7. KILCAST D (1999) Sensory techniques to study food texture. In Food Texture: Measurement and Perception. Ed. A J Rosenthal, Gaithersburg, MD., Aspen, 30–64. KILCAST D (2001) Modern methods of texture measurement. In Instrumentation and Sensors for the Food Industry, Second Edition. Eds E Kress-Rogers and C J B Brimelow, Cambridge, Woodhead, 518–49. KILCAST D and EVES A (1991) Integrating texture and physiology – techniques. In Feeding and the Texture of Food. Eds J F V Vincent and P J Lillford, Society for Experimental Biology Seminar Series 44, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 167–83. KILCAST D and FILLION L (2001) Understanding consumer requirements for fruit and vegetable texture, Nutrition & Food Science, 5, 221–5. KILCAST D and ROBERTS C (1998) Perception and measurement of stickiness in sugar-rich foods, Journal of Texture Studies, 29(1), 81–100. KILCAST D, BOYAR M M and FRY J C (1984) Gelation photoelasticity: a new technique for measuring stress distributions in gels during penetration testing, Journal of Food Science, 49(2), 654–5+7. KIM S-M, MCCARTHY M J, BIBBS D and CHEN P (1998) Water in tissue structures by NMR and MRI. In The Properties of Water in Foods: ISOPOW 6, Santa Rosa, 1996. Ed. D S Reid, London, Blackie, 30–39. KOHYAMA K, MIOCHE L and MARTIN J-F (2002) Chewing patterns of various texture foods studied by electromyography in young and elderly populations, Journal of Texture Studies, 33(4), 269–83. LILLFORD P J (2001) Mechanisms of fracture in foods, Journal of Texture Studies, 32(5/6), 397–417. LUCAS P W, PRINZ J F, AGRAWAL K R and BRUCE I C (2002) Food physics and oral physiology, Food Quality and Preference, 13(4), 203–13. MATHEVON E, MIOCHE L, BROWN W E and CULIOLI J (1995) Texture analysis of beef cooked at various temperatures by mechanical measurements, sensory assessments and electromyography, Journal of Texture Studies, 26(2), 175–92. MEILGAARD M, CIVILLE G V and CARR B T (1999) Sensory Evaluation Techniques (Third Edition). Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press. MIOCHE L and MARTIN J-F (1998) Training and sensory judgement effects on mastication as studied by electromyography, Journal of Food Science, 63(1), 1–5. HUTCHINGS J B
Measuring consumer perceptions of texture: an overview
31
and KRIEGER B (1995) The contributions of sensory liking to overall liking: An analysis of 6 food categories, Food Quality and Preference, 6(2), 83–90. MURAMATSU N, SAKURAI N, YAMAMOTO D, NEVINS D J, TAKAHARA T and OGATA T (1997) Comparison of a non-destructive acoustic method with an intrusive method for firmness measurement of kiwi fruit, Postharvest Biology and Technology, 12(3), 221–8. MURAMATSU N, SAKURAI N, WADA N, YAMAMOTO D, TAKAHARA T and OGATA T (1999) Evaluation of fruit tissue texture and internal disorders by laser Doppler detection, Postharvest Biology and Technology, 15(1), 83–8. NIELSON M and MARTENS H J (1997) Low-frequency ultrasonics for texture measurement in cooked carrots (Daucus carota L), Journal of Food Science, 62(6), 1167–70+1175. O’MAHONY M (1979) Short-cut signal detection measures for sensory analysis, Journal of Food Science, 44(1), 302–3. O’MAHONY M (1986) Sensory Evaluation of Food. Statistical Methods and Procedures, New York, Marcel Dekker Inc. O’MAHONY M (1995) Who told you the triangle test was simple? Food Quality and Preference, 6(4), 227–38. OVERBOSCH P, AFTEROF W G M and HARING P G M (1991) Flavour release in the mouth, Food Reviews International, 7(2), 137–84. PARK B, WHITTAKER A D, MILLER R K and HALE D S (1994) Ultrasonic spectral analysis for beef sensory attributes, Journal of Food Science, 59(4), 697–701+724. PELEG M (1998) Extracting useful information from irregular and irreproducible mechanical and other signatures. In New Techniques in the Analysis of Foods. Ed. M H Tunick, New York, Kluwer, 37–52. PELEG M and NORMAND M D (1992) Symmetrized dot-patterns (SDP) of irregular compressive stress-strain relationships, Journal of Texture Studies, 23(4), 427–38. PEYRON M-A, MIOCHE L, RENON P and ABOUELKARAM S (1996) Masticatory jaw movement recordings: a new method to investigate food texture, Food Quality and Preference, 7(3-4), 229–37. PITTS M J, ABBOTT J A, ARMSTRONG P R, BROWN G K, BRUSEWITZ G H, DAVIS D C, DELWICHE M J, GALILI N, GAN-MOR S, HAUGH C G, MASSIE D R, MIZRACH A, NAHIR D, PELEG K, ROHRBACH R P, SARIG Y, SCHAARE P N, SCHNILOVITCH Z, SHMULEVICH I, STONE M L, STROSHINE R L and YOUNCE F L (1994) Sensing fruit and vegetable firmness. In Nondestructive Technologies for Quality Evaluation of Fruits and Vegetables: Proceedings of the International Workshop, Spokane, Washington, June 1993. Michigan, ASAE, 31–43. ROHDE F, nORMAND M D and PELEG M (1993) Characterization of the power spectrum of force-deformation relationships of crunchy foods, Journal of Texture Studies, 24(1), 45–62. ROUDAUT G, DACREMONT C and LE MESTE M (1998) Influence of water on the crispness of cereal-based foods: acoustic, mechanical and sensory studies, Journal of Texture Studies, 29(2), 199–213. SCHMIDT S J (1999). Probing the physical and sensory properties of food systems using NMR spectroscopy. In Advances in Magnetic Resonance in Food Science: Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Applications of Magnetic Resonance in Food Science, Norwich, September 1998. Ed. P S Belton, Cambridge, RSC, 79–94. SHAMIL S H, WYETH L J and KILCAST D (1992) Flavour release and perception in reduced-fat foods, Food Quality and Preference, 3(1), 51–60. SHEPHERD R and SPARKS P (1994) Modelling food choice. In Measurement of Food Preferences. Eds H J H MacFie and D M H Thomson, London, Blackie 202–26. SIM B J, LUCAS P W, PEREIRA B P and OATES C G (1993) Mechanical and sensory assessment of the texture of refrigerator-stored spring roll pastry, Journal of Texture Studies, 24(1), 27–44. SMALLS I (1992) Electromyography versus Instron texture measurement of confectionery products, Proceedings of the 46th Annual Production Conference, Hershey, April 1992. Medford, Pennsylvania Manufacturing Confectioners Association, 56–61. MOSKOWITZ H R
32 Texture in food and KAHN E L (1971) Consumer attitudes to and awareness of food texture 1: adults, Journal of Texture Studies, 2, 280–95. TOURSEL P (1996) Equipment for texture analysis, Process, 1122, 48–50. TU K and DE BAERDEMAEKER J (1996) Investigation of apple quality using instrumental methods, Agri-food Quality: an Interdisciplinary Approach; Proceedings of a Conference, Norwich, June 1995, Cambridge, RSC, 204–7. VICKERS Z M (1985) The relationships of pitch, loudness and eating technique to judgements of the crispness and crunchiness of food sounds, Journal of Texture Studies, 16(1), 85– 95. VICKERS Z M (1988) Evaluation of crispness In Food Structure – its Creation and Evaluation. Eds J M V Blanshard and J R Mitchell, Oxford, Butterworths, 433–48. VICKERS Z M (1991) Sound perceptions and food quality, Journal of Food Quality, 14(1), 87–96. VICKERS Z M and BOURNE M C (1976) A psychoacoustical theory of crispness, Journal of Food Science, 41(5), 1158–64. VINCENT J F V, JERONIMIDIS G, KHAN A A and LUYTEN H (1991) The wedge fracture test. A new method for the measurement of food texture, Journal of Texture Studies, 22(1), 45–57. SZCZESNIAK A S
2 Consumers and texture: understanding their perceptions and preferences J-F. Meullenet, University of Arkansas, USA
2.1 Introduction: problems with consumer descriptions of texture The British Standards Institution defined texture as an attribute of a substance resulting from a combination of physical properties and perceived by the senses of touch, sight and hearing (Brennan, 1980). From a consumer point of view, this definition probably makes little sense. In fact, the obscureness of the various definitions proposed and their disconnection with what consumers define as texture is a major challenge for product developers in the food industry today. This will be the focus of this chapter. We shall start with a simple example. In the recent past, our lab was involved in a project dealing with a processor of poultry meat. The project had to do with meat tenderness and how long you have to leave the breast meat on the carcass to achieve maximum tenderness. Various treatments were evaluated using a trained descriptive panel and the resulting profiles presented to the client. On the profiles were obscure attributes such as cohesiveness of mass, toothpack and toothpull in addition to more commonly known attributes such as hardness. The client pondered for a few minutes and finally asked: “So, where are the results for tenderness?” I had to explain that tenderness is an integrated term and that a trained panel uses several attributes that, all put together, contribute to a consumer’s perception of tenderness. This illustrates the fact that descriptive analysis is sometimes not a very actionable tool for food processors, if the relationship between the sensory attributes defined by a descriptive panel and the consumer’s perception of the texture in the product is not well understood. This is a common problem in sensory evaluation, and stems from the fact that consumers use
34 Texture in food
loosely defined integrated terms that sometimes do not have the same meaning to the whole population. This seems, at first, like an insurmountable problem. However, several techniques are available to elucidate the complex nature of the acceptance of food from a hedonic standpoint by consumers. This chapter will discuss the issue of bridging the gap between science (rheology or sensory) and the perception and acceptance of texture by consumers.
2.2 Investigating consumer descriptions of texture 2.2.1 Establishing the importance of texture to consumers The effects of appearance and flavor on consumer acceptance of foods have been extensively studied. However, there are fewer studies dealing with the effect of texture attributes on food acceptability. In 1971, Szczesniak assessed the apparent relative and a priori importance of texture and flavour on the acceptability of foods via a survey of 150 consumers. Surprisingly, the texture/ flavour index, a measure of the relative importance of texture in comparison to flavour was 0.89 for the group. This demonstrated that texture was an important attribute of food acceptance and that more attention should be given to it. Texture has also been reported to be especially important in foods that are bland in flavour, such as rice, or those that are crispy or crunchy, such as puffed cereals (Szczesniak,1990). One of the major issues with attempting to understand consumer responses is the fact that the language used by consumers is very different from words used by experts, such as sensory scientists, practising descriptive analysis to describe the texture of food products. This is well illustrated by the classification of texture characteristics proposed by Szczesniak (1963; see Table 2.1). As seen in Table 2.1, consumers (popular terms) use different words to refer to increasing intensities on a specific continuum. For example, hardness, which is the term used in descriptive analysis, is referred to by consumers as soft, firm or hard, depending on the intensity of the stimulus. The main problem is that those terms are mutually exclusive of each other and that consumers will associate specific foods with specific descriptors. For example, soft and crumbly is often more appropriate to consumers for describing the texture of foods (for example, some cheeses such as Feta) of very low hardness and cohesiveness (i.e. by the sensory and not engineering definition) while hard and brittle are more applicable to describing confectionary products such as candies. Although these examples are trivial, it implies that those involved with consumer testing have to carefully design questionnaires in order to fit the language of consumers. 2.2.2 One model fits all? There is today a body of knowledge developed on how specific texture attributes are governing the acceptability of particular food products. Textural
Consumers and texture
35
Table 2.1 Relations between textural parameters and popular nomenclature (Szczesniak, 1963) Mechanical characteristics Primary parameters Hardness Cohesiveness
Secondary parameters Brittleness Chewiness Gumminess
Viscosity Elasticity Adhesiveness
Popular terms Soft → Firm → Hard Crumbly → Crunchy → Brittle Tender → Chewy → Tough Short → Mealy → Pasty → Gummy Thin → Viscous Plastic → Elastic Sticky → Tacky → Gooey
Geometrical characteristics Class Particle size and shape Particle shape and orientation
Examples Gritty, Grainy, Coarse, etc. Fibrous, Cellular, Crystalline, etc.
Other characteristics Primary parameters Moisture content Fat content
Secondary parameters Oiliness Greasiness
Popular terms Dry → Moist → Wet → Watery Oily Greasy
attributes have been found to have both positive and negative impacts on consumer acceptance of foods (Szczesniak and Kahn, 1971). Universally liked texture attributes include crispness, crunchiness, juiciness and tenderness, while attributes such as toughness or sogginess are for the most part disliked. However, although these general rules provide useful information, they do not address specific products or various consumer groups. A simple example of this is cooked rice. Rice is a staple food in a large portion of the world and Asian cultures are very discriminating about the rice they eat. It is known that texture is a very important attribute of rice. Its two main characteristics are hardness/firmness and stickiness. Okabe (1979) studied the acceptability of rice by Japanese consumers. He reported that there were narrow regions of acceptability for cooked Japanese rice for both hardness and stickiness, and that consumers favoured sticky and tender rice. However, this observation needs to be confined to Japan as other Asian cultures have different expectations. For example, a study by Meullenet et al. (2000) reported on the acceptance of various rices by consumers primarily from South-east Asia and concluded that rice texture was not a very important driver of overall acceptance when compared to rice appearance and aroma. However, the same general rules (i.e. preference for tender and sticky rice) were confirmed. These results were further confirmed by work published by Suwansri et al. (2002) on the acceptability of Jasmine rice by US Asian consumers.
36 Texture in food
This shows that, unfortunately, the importance of texture attributes to the acceptance of food is both product and consumer group dependent. The conclusion is that texture should be considered in every product development process.
2.3 Tests and test procedures Before considering methods designed to develop an understanding of consumers’ perception and acceptance of texture, we should briefly consider the methodologies best suited for this type of endeavour. Consumer testing methods described in the literature vary greatly. However, one common denominator of all methods is the use of some type of rating scale, at least when the hedonic response to a product is assessed. The primary goal in designing scales for use with consumers has usually been to keep them easy to use and easily understandable by all. The type of information gathered from consumers is either related to the acceptance/preference for a food product or to the perception of sensory attribute intensity or appropriateness. The main three types of scales are category, line and magnitude estimation scales. Category scales are probably overall most broadly used followed by line and magnitude estimation scales, respectively. Category scales are those using a fixed number of possible responses. For use with consumers, verbal anchors are associated with some or all of the categories. The most common examples of these scales are the nine-point hedonic scale and the relative to ideal or just right scales. Line scales have been used as hedonic scales (Pangborn et al., 1989) or as just right scales (Shepherd et al., 1988), but they can also be used to assess the intensity perceived by consumers for a specific attribute. Line scales described in the literature have varied between 100 and 150 mm, and it is not clear whether the scale length has true impacts on the results.
2.3.1 Hedonic scales The most commonly used hedonic scale, at least in English speaking countries, is the nine-point hedonic scale (Jones et al. 1955). The main characteristics of the scale are that each category is associated with a verbal descriptor from “dislike extremely” to “like extremely” and that the scale has a neutral category “neither like nor dislike”. Although it has been widely used for almost 50 years, the scale has been equally criticised. The nine-point hedonic scale has been popular because of its simplicity, accuracy and precision while being criticised mostly for end effects (i.e. avoidance of extreme categories) and the lack of equal hedonic intervals between categories. The hedonic scale has been accepted by sensory professionals to infer consumer acceptance from “liking”, despite its flaws, because it provides internal validity (accurate and precise results of consumer liking) at the expense of external validity (relevance to the marketplace) as described by van Trijp and Schifferstein (1995). In
Consumers and texture
37
addition, it has been shown not to translate well into Spanish (Curia et al., 2001) and several Asian languages (Yeh et al., 1998). The most reported complaint is the different meaning of the word “extreme” in these languages. Some illustration of results obtained from hedonic ratings is given in Fig. 2.1, which is a frequency plot of responses given in each category for various products. These results point out several of the challenges associated not only with the nine-point hedonic scale but also with most other hedonic scales. First is the type of distribution yielded by hedonic scales. With scales featuring a neutral category, it is often seen that the “neither like nor dislike” category is grossly under-represented. An obvious observation is that the distributions do not closely follow a normal distribution, rendering the use of analysis of variance questionable. Figure 2.1 also points out that product C was not perceived uniformly by the consumer group studied. Under these conditions, the mean hedonic scores for products B and C would be very similar although the distributions of the scores are quite dissimilar, leading to potentially erroneous conclusions. These results point out the need, when dealing with consumer data, to assess the distribution of the responses and to ensure that the distributions are unimodal (i.e. that a relative consensus exists among the group about the hedonic status of the products).
2.3.2 Just-about-right scales Another type of scale used for the optimisation of attribute levels in food products is the just-about-right (JAR) scale. Individual samples can be rated 35
Number of responses
30
A B C
25 20 15 10 5 0 Dislike Dislike very Dislike Dislike extremely much moderately slightly
Neither Like Like Like very dislike nor slightly moderately much like
Like extremely
9-point hedonic scale
Fig. 2.1 Distribution of consumer acceptance scores for texture of three candy bars. The question to consumers was worded as follows: Considering only the texture of this product, which of these statements best describes your impression?
38 Texture in food
on a JAR scale as “too weak,” “too strong” or “just-about-right” along a particular continuum such as tenderness or crispness. Data that are normally distributed around the center of the scale (i.e. the “just-about-right” point) are indicative of an optimized level of the continuum or attribute. It is important in this technique to examine the distribution of the raw data. For example, a consumer panel might contain one segment that prefers products with one set of sensory characteristics and another segment that prefers the same product with a completely different set of sensory characteristics. This is illustrated in Fig. 2.2 which is a distribution of scores on a JAR scale for the crispness of cheese sticks. In this example, the appropriateness of the level of crispness in a fried cheese stick appetizer was assessed with a panel comprising 180 individuals. The data clearly shows that it is not distributed around the just right score, although the mean value of scores would be close to the JAR point. Instead, the distribution of the data is bimodal with roughly equal numbers of consumers who found the product to be too soggy or too crispy. The appropriateness of the cheese texture for the same product was evaluated by the same consumer panel and the distribution of scores is given in Fig. 2.3. For cheese texture, there was a much greater consensus among consumers as to the appropriateness of the level of cheese firmness. This is in sharp contrast to results from Fig. 2.2. These two examples illustrate the importance of data distribution assessment of consumer data before more advanced analyses are performed. This is especially true when means are to be used for further analyses such as special cases of preference mapping. These methods will be discussed later in this chapter.
60
Number of responses
50 40 30 20 10 0 Much too soggy
Too soggy
Just about right Too crisp Crispness JAR scale
Much too crisp
Fig. 2.2 Distribution of the JAR scores for crispness of a fried cheese stick product.
Consumers and texture
39
140
Number of responses
120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Much too soft
Too soft
Just about right
Too firm
Much too firm
Cheese texture JAR scale
Fig. 2.3 Distribution of JAR scores for the cheese texture of a fried cheese stick product.
2.4 Understanding consumer preferences Moskowitz and Jacobs (1987) described several methods for developing an understanding of the importance of texture in determining the relative importance of food texture to the product acceptance. The simplest method they described is the direct rating of importance. With this method, consumers are asked to rate the importance of various product attributes, including texture, on a scale from 0 to 100. By comparison of mean values for the various attributes, one can evaluate if texture plays an important role in determining overall acceptance. However, this method has limitations in that it does not involve product testing and relies on the a priori judgement of the subject. It is similar to that employed by Szczesniak and Kahn (1971). A more popular approach has been to correlate attribute ratings to acceptance of foods. Several approaches have been described. Researchers often look at correlations between acceptance scores and intensity ratings in an attempt to assess the relative importance of specific texture attributes in consumer acceptance. Although many have used correlations to understand consumer response, there are some limitations to this approach. This is due to the fact that correlations evaluate linear relationships, and it is well known that attribute intensity and acceptance are not necessarily linearly related. Although it is probably true that, in cultures such as that of the USA, the sweeter the cola beverage the more acceptable it is, this is not necessarily true for most food products.
40 Texture in food
2.4.1 Linear relationships Example: Poultry breast meat One example of linear relationship between perceived intensity and acceptance of specific attributes is given in Fig. 2.4. In this consumer study, 80 panellists were presented with ten treatments of poultry breast meat (i.e. deboned at various times post mortem) representing a vast array of tenderness intensities. Among other questions, consumers were asked to rate the acceptance of the product’s texture on a nine-point hedonic scale (1 = dislike extremely and 9 = like extremely) and their perceived intensity of the various treatments on a nine-point category scale anchored at the extreme categories with extremely tough and extremely tender. Results show that the relationship between perceived intensity and acceptability was linear and that the more tender the product, the more acceptable it was to this group of consumers. This is not to say that in a different context, the results could not have been different. In this study, no common additives designed to enhance the tenderness of poultry meat were added. One can imagine that a product so tender that it became “mushy” could be produced and that its acceptance would be lower than for products of optimal tenderness. However, in many practical cases related to texture attributes of food the relationship between acceptance and perceived intensity will be linear.
2.4.2 Non-linear relationships When the relationship is known to be non-linear, it is often parabolic where the liking for a product will first increase with increasing levels of the
8.0
R 2 = 0.88
Perceived tenderness intensity
7.5 7.0 6.5 6.0 5.5 5.0 4.5 4.0 4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
Acceptance of poultry breast meat tenderness
Fig. 2.4 Relation between the acceptance of poultry breast meat tenderness and its perceived tenderness intensity.
Consumers and texture
41
attribute, peak and then decrease as the intensity of the attribute continues to increase. The peak has been described as the bliss point, and the shape of the curve, known as the inverted U or L function, relating hedonic response to stimulus intensity was first proposed by Wundt (Moskowitz and Jacobs, 1987). It should be noted that the relationships between the sensory experience or the hedonic response and the physical stimulus are governed by very different laws as the relationship between perceived intensity and stimulus intensity can usually be modelled by a power law (Stevens, 1975).
2.4.3 Single attribute analysis A common model described by Moskowitz (1980) is of the quadratic form: liking = A + B(intensity) + C(intensity)2
[2.1]
The main advantage of the equation is that it allows liking to follow a parabolic response, but does not force it if the relationship is not of that form. The relative importance of the attribute can be calculated as the absolute value of the partial derivative of Eq. [2.1] and is defined as: importance = |B + C(intensity)|
[2.2]
This equation implies that the importance of a single attribute for liking is dependent on the level of that attribute, which is a far superior approach to that of the simple correlations. One limitation of this approach is that liking is related to a single sensory attribute, disregarding the fact that multiple sensory texture attributes may be present in the product and that they may all influence liking. Even if multiple attributes are used to model liking, the correlation among the predictors is not being considered.
2.4.4 Multivariate analysis techniques Other researchers have considered multivariate analysis techniques to assess the relationship between liking and texture attributes ratings. Although it is not the primary purpose of this chapter to discuss these techniques in detail, some of the basics should be covered as they often help to elucidate the likes or dislikes of consumers for specific food products. Preference mapping techniques have been described in detail in publications such as that of MacFie and Thomson (1999). Their development came from the inability of sensory scientists to fully understand consumer reactions (acceptability) to specific food products. This comes from the simple fact that consumers have a limited vocabulary when it comes to describing perceived sensory attributes of food. As a general rule, they confine themselves to commenting about very general terms or to making vague statements such as “I disliked the texture of this product”. It is obvious that this type of data is not very actionable. To remedy these problems, researchers will usually try to ask more pointed questions about specific product attributes. For example, for
42 Texture in food
dairy beverages or nutritional supplements, one may consider asking about two main texture attributes, thickness/consistency and chalky or smooth. If the attribute ratings are that of perceived intensities or appropriateness level and a sufficient number of products (six or more) are evaluated by consumers, it is then possible to predict the acceptance of a product (i.e. overall acceptance or acceptance of texture) from attribute ratings. Figure 2.5 is an illustration of such a concept. In this study, 10 chocolate nutritional beverages were evaluated by 150 consumers. The objective of the study was to identify the drivers of product acceptance, including important texture attributes. The nine-point hedonic scale was used to assess the overall degree of liking by consumers while the appropriateness of the level of color, chocolate flavour, sweetness, tartness, smoothness and thickness was assessed using JAR scales. Anchors used for the JAR scales are given in Table 2.2. PC2 (20 %, 17 %) 0.8 C Thickness
0.6 H 0.4 B 0.2
I
G 0 –1.2
–1
–0.8
–0.6
–0.4
–0.2 0 –0.2 –0.4
F J
0.2
0.4
Color
Acceptance A Smoothness
0.6 0.8 Sweetness
PC1 (57 %, 59 %)
1
Chocolate
–0.6 Tartness E
–0.8
D
–1 –1.2
Fig. 2.5 Partial least squares regression of acceptability versus diagnostic ratings for 10 chocolate nutritional beverages. Table 2.2 Diagnostic attribute scales used to assess the appropriateness of various attributes of nutritional beverages Color Chocolate Sweetness Tartness Thickness Smoothness
Much too light Much too weak Not nearly sweet enough Not nearly tart/ sour enough Much too thin
Too light
Not sweet enough Not tart/ sour enough Too thin
Much too coarse/chalky
Too coarse/ chalky
Too weak
Just about right Just about right Just about right Just about right Just about right Just about right
Too dark Too strong Too sweet Too tart/ sour Too thick Too smooth
Much too dark Much too strong Much too sweet Much too tart/sour Much too thick Much too smooth
Consumers and texture
43
Consumer data was then analyzed by partial least squares (PLS) regression to predict consumer acceptance scores from attribute ratings. Results of this analysis are given in Figs 2.5 and 2.6. Figure 2.5 shows the product map, which is a spatial representation of products, acceptance and diagnostic attribute ratings. This map allows the interpretation of several pieces of information. First it allows the examination of the relationship between the acceptance dimensions and the diagnostic ratings. Figure 2.5 is a twodimensional scatter plot of X (attribute ratings) loading weights and Y loadings (acceptance) for two specified components from PLS. It shows the importance of the different variables for the two components selected and can thus be used to detect important predictors and understand the relationships between X (i.e. attribute ratings) and the Y-variable (i.e. acceptance). To interpret the relationships between attribute ratings and the product acceptance, start by looking at your response (Y) variable. Predictors (attribute ratings), projected in roughly the same direction from the center as a response, are positively linked to that response. Predictors projected in the opposite direction have a negative link. Predictors projected close to the center are not well represented in that plot and cannot be interpreted. In our example, the projection of the diagnostic attributes onto the acceptance vector allows the determination of the most important drivers of liking. Attributes which load most highly on the acceptance vector, either positively or negatively, are the most important drivers of acceptance. In our example, the most important drivers seemed to be smoothness and sweetness as positive drivers (i.e. those for which high attribute ratings resulted in greater acceptance) and tartness and thickness as negative drivers (i.e. those for which high attribute ratings resulted in lower acceptance).
Weighted regression coefficients
1.50E-01
1.00E-01
5.00E-02
0.00E+00
–5.00E-02
–1.00E-01 Color
Chocolate
Sweetness
Tartness
Thickness
Smoothness
Fig. 2.6 Weighted regression coefficients for the PLS model predicting overall acceptance from diagnostic attribute ratings for 10 nutritional beverages.
44 Texture in food
This interpretation is confirmed by Fig. 2.6 which is a plot of the corresponding weighted regression coefficients for a PLS model with two factors. Weighted regression coefficients rather than raw are useful when the relative importance of a specific predictive variable needs to be determined. In Fig. 2.6, it is clear that smoothness and sweetness are the most important positive determinants of product acceptance while thickness and tartness are the only negative drivers of acceptance. In addition, predictive attribute variables close to each other in the loading plot (Fig. 2.5) will have a high positive correlation if the two components explain a large portion of the variance of X. The same is true for variables in the same quadrant lying close to a straight line through the origin. Variables in diagonally-opposed quadrants will have a tendency to be negatively correlated. In our example, sweetness and smoothness are highly correlated while chocolate and thickness were negatively correlated. One should be reminded that correlations do not imply causality and that they are often a function of the product set chosen for the experiment. The overlay of product loadings in the space also allows for the interpretation of the product’s sensory dimensions using a multivariate approach. The plot can be used to interpret the products’ sensory properties. Look for variables projected far away from the center. Samples lying in an extreme position in the same direction as a given variable have large values for that variable; samples lying in the opposite direction have low values. For example, product A has the highest smoothness while product C has the highest thickness.
2.5 Challenges to understanding consumer preferences Although this simple example seems to provide the necessary elements for a product developer to optimize this type of product, it is rarely the case in practice. This is due to the fact that, to gain valuable information and a complete picture of the drivers of liking, one has to get several things right in the design of the experiment. First, the right questions need to be asked of consumers, and that is where the greatest challenge lies. The major limitation is that consumers have a very limited vocabulary and that words within that vocabulary do not necessarily have the same meaning for all. The example previously described is a good illustration of this phenomenon. The attribute smoothness and the JAR scale developed to establish its level of appropriateness in the products tested was the result of long debates with the industrial client for which the test was performed. The debate centred around the fact that smoothness and chalkiness are not necessarily mutually exclusive of each other. This seems especially true since the temporal perception of both attributes is not the same. While smoothness is perceived while manipulating the product in the oral cavity, chalkiness is often perceived most intensely after swallowing. In addition, the meaning of chalkiness to consumers can vary greatly as part of the population, at least in the USA, associates chalkiness as a texture
Consumers and texture
45
attribute while others think most readily of chalkiness as a visual attribute such as that of chalky rice or halibut. It is obviously of utmost importance for consumers to understand the scales they are asked to use, and confusion in terminology is often a difficult problem to overcome. In the previous example, it was decided that the scale anchors should state coarse/chalky instead of simply chalky although one could argue the use of the word coarse rather than gritty. Because of the challenges associated with understanding consumer responses and communicating effectively with them, many have shied away from trying to gather detailed information about the quality of the products tested from consumers. Many studies with consumers are now strictly designed to assess the overall degree of liking of food products. This leaves sensory scientists with little information to understand the underlying reason for the liking or disliking of product sensory qualities by consumers. The researcher is then left with explaining consumer liking from other sources of data.
2.5.1 External preference mapping External preference mapping is a technique designed to explain consumer results from data not generated by consumers (i.e. external data). The most common source of external data is sensory profiling data generated by trained descriptive panels. However, for texture, rheological data can also be used. We will give here several examples of such methods. Example 1: Jasmine rice In Suwansri et al. (2002), external preference mapping principles were applied to understanding the acceptance of Jasmine rice by Asian consumers living in the USA. Since the Asian population in the USA is very discriminating about the quality of the rice they consume, there is a need to assess the likes and dislikes of this population segment and to evaluate the key sensory differences between domestic and imported aromatic rice. The objectives of this study were to assess the acceptability of both domestic and imported Jasmine rice by US Asian consumers and to correlate the US Asian consumers’ acceptance of Jasmine rice to descriptive sensory data so that acceptance drivers could be identified. Fifteen commercial “Jasmine” rices consisting of three domestic varieties and 12 imported products were evaluated by a trained sensory panel and by 105 Asian families. An in-home-use test was used to gather consumer data of the 15 products, including acceptance data of rice texture which is usually a major driver of acceptance. A nine member panel, well trained in descriptive analysis of rice, evaluated five visual, 16 flavour and 11 texture attributes for all 15 Jasmine rice samples. Visual, flavour and texture lexicons were developed by the trained panellists during three orientation sessions (Meullenet et al., 1998). Results showed that this consumer group preferred imported over domestic
46 Texture in food
Jasmine rice. However, the univariate analysis of the descriptive data did not clearly point out the weaknesses of the domestic Jasmine products. The use of external preference mapping clearly identified the differences between domestic and imported products. As can be seen on Fig. 2.7, a bar chart of weighted regression coefficients for the descriptive attributes used to predict texture acceptance scores, there are two main constructs, hardness and stickiness, describing the texture of cooked rice. Manual stickiness, initial cohesion, adhesion to lips, cohesiveness, cohesiveness of mass and toothpull were identified as positive drivers of acceptance. From the texture lexicon, it is clear that these attributes are all related to the stickiness of rice. Hardness and roughness of mass, attributes that are usually highly correlated to each other, were found to be negative drivers of texture acceptance by consumers. These two attributes are indicative of firmness in rice. From this data, it could be implied that Asian consumers of Jasmine rice like it to be sticky and less firm. Although this is true in this particular context, one would have to be cautious about generalizing this type of result. This is definitely true in this instance as Jasmine rice is classified as a long grain rice not particularly known for being sticky. A previous study which was performed with a similar consumer group on a much wider range of rice products indeed drew different conclusions (Meullenet et al., 2000) as both hardness and stickiness (or attributes related to these two constructs) were negative drivers of consumer acceptance. This shows that the results obtained from preference maps are highly dependent on the samples selected for testing. In the case of Suwansri et al. (2002), the samples were carefully selected to represent products from a niche market. This allowed the identification of the sensory weaknesses of Jasmine rice samples produced in the USA and provided insight for rice breeders for improving the existing cultivars.
Weighted regression coefficients
0.3
0.2
R 2 = 0.61 RMSEP = 0.39 Manual Initial Adhesion stickiness cohesion to lips
Cohesiveness Cohesiveness of mass Toothpull
0.1
0
–0.1 Hardness
Roughness of mass
–0.2 Texture attributes
Fig. 2.7 Weighted regression coefficients for the PLS predicting the acceptance of cooked white rice texture from texture attributes evaluated by a descriptive panel.
Consumers and texture
47
Example 2: White corn tortilla chips Another example of external mapping applied to understanding the drivers of acceptance for the texture of white corn tortilla chips is that published by Meullenet et al., 2002. In that study, 11 white corn tortilla chip products were evaluated by a group of heavy users of the product. In addition, a descriptive panel profiled the products for appearance, flavor and texture attributes. Figure 2.8 gives the weighted regression coefficients for the prediction of the acceptance of texture in the 11 products by consumers from the texture profiles generated by the panel. A total of 13 attributes were assessed by the descriptive panel. However, it is unlikely that all of these attributes are contributors to liking by consumers. Therefore, for multivariate regression, statistical techniques need to be employed to reduce the number of predictors to those that are significant contributors. The approximate uncertainty variance of the regression coefficients can be estimated and a t-test performed for each element relative to its estimated uncertainty variance, giving the significance level for each parameter. All parameters with p < 0.05 were retained in the model. This allows for removal of independent variables either not influencing the prediction or creating noise in the model, a procedure which reduces “the uncertainty in the prediction models” and, in most cases, improves the validation statistics. In this study, only important variables selected by the Jack-knife optimisation method (i.e. hardness, crispness, loose particles and oily/greasy film) were included in the predictive models to predict consumer acceptance. R2 and RMSEP (root mean square of prediction) were 0.96 and 0.34, respectively, for the optimal PLS model predicting consumer texture acceptance from descriptive texture attributes. The weighted regression coefficients (Fig. 2.8)
Weighted regression coefficients
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 –0.2 –0.4 –0.6
Hardness
Crispness
Loose particles
Oily/greasy film
Attributes
Fig. 2.8 Weighted regression coefficients for the PLS predicting the acceptance of white corn tortilla chips texture from texture attributes evaluated by a descriptive panel.
48 Texture in food
show that the first bite attributes of hardness and crispness, surface characteristic of loose particles and residual characteristic of oily/greasy film were important contributors to the consumer acceptance of tortilla chip texture. Crispness and loose particles contributed to increased consumer acceptance of texture while hardness and oily/greasy film decreased consumer acceptance. Crispness is one of the most important texture attributes for potato chips (Smith, 1975; Segnini and Dejmek, 1999). Since tortilla chips and potato chips are similar salty snacks, it was expected that crispness of tortilla chips would positively contribute to overall acceptance.
2.6 Future trends Although it is difficult to foresee the future of this type of research, one certain fact is that consumers will remain difficult to understand. This implies that progress toward understanding consumer perception and acceptance of food texture will rely on the development of novel methods of data analysis and of improved methods for probing consumers. Many have documented the limitations of the internationally popular ninepoint hedonic scale developed by Peryam and Girardot (1952). These include the inequality of intervals between the semantic labels (Jones et al., 1955; Moskowitz and Sidel, 1971; Moskowitz, 1980), the presence of the neutral category (neither like nor dislike) and shortcomings of bipolar attitude scales (Olsen, 1999), and the central tendency (i.e. avoidance of end categories) issues (Stevens and Galanter, 1957). In the recent past, several researchers (Schutz and Cardello, 2001; Henderson and Shewfelt, 2002; Villanueva et al., 2002) have proposed alternatives to the scale widely used now for over 50 years. The most significant contribution is probably that of Schutz and Cardello (2001) who used modulus free magnitude estimation to develop a labelled affective magnitude (LAM) scale using the original labels from the nine-point hedonic scale. The results showed that the problems associated with the nine-point hedonic scale were minimised and that the data was shown to closely follow a normal distribution. This recent development provides an effective alternative to the problematic nine-point hedonic scale and the difficult to implement magnitude estimation scales. Another recent development is the application of alternative statistical methodologies for performing preference mapping. Because preference mapping is critical to understanding consumer acceptance of food texture, these methods have the potential to make a significant contribution. The methods described to date mostly rely upon deterministic modelling where the data dealt with is assumed to be normal. Several examples given in this chapter have demonstrated that this assumption is often violated. Consumer acceptance responses are usually ordinal categories. Ordinary least square (OLS) regression can be used for preference modeling when the ordinal response (Y) is treated as a continuous variable. As a result, with OLS
Consumers and texture
49
regression models, the mean scores of the ordinal response and the information on the structure (frequencies) of the ordinal response are lost. From a research point of view, the information from the structure of the ordinal response is often more meaningful and useful than that from the mean scores of the response. OLS regression requires that the distribution of error be normal. However, for the limited number of response categories used in consumer testing, or if the nine response categories (i.e. nine-point hedonic scale) are collapsed to five categories (i.e. end of scale avoidance), the normal distribution assumption will not be satisfied. In addition, OLS regression may produce extreme predictions that may be out of the categorical range. These drawbacks have limited the use of OLS regression in preference modeling. Proportional odds models (POM) do not have these limitations and could be an alternative for preference modeling. They are widely used in categorical data analysis in health science (Agresti, 2002) and have recently been applied to sensory data from a study on consumer acceptance of canola oil (VaiseyGenser et al., 1994), qualitative studies of food choice (Tepper et al., 1997) and consumer acceptance of oca cultivars (Sangketkit et al., 2000). The major advantages of the proportional odds model analysis are that it can apply to ordinal categorical responses, model the structure (frequencies) of the categorical responses and estimate the mean scores of the responses. Its invariance to choice of response categories is also an advantage (Agresti 2002). However, there exists little information on the application of proportional odds models for internal and external preference modeling besides that published by Meullenet et al. (2003), Malundo et al. (2001) and Jones and Wang (2000). Although PLS regression and POM are two commonly used methods in preference mapping, if the predictor variables are “JAR” scores, these linear models seem not to be appropriate, at least in most cases, because the relationship between the response and the JAR predictors is no longer linear. Multivariate adaptive regression splines (MARS), developed in 1991 by world-renowned Stanford physicist and statistician Jerome Friedman (Friedman, 1991), can automate variable selection as well as model selection. It has been proven effective in a variety of learning problems and is competitive with neural networks and non-parametric regressions (Dwinnell, 2000). MARS can be used to uncover underlying non-linear relationships between response and predictors in a piecewise linear regression function, which could be useful for modeling the JAR data. It is only in very recent years that MARS has become widely known in the data mining and business intelligence communities due to the availability of the commercial MARS software program (MARS, 2001). Recently, MARS was applied to the prediction of consumer acceptance of fried cheese stick texture from JAR data. One of the main advantages of MARS is its ability to determine the effect that JAR scores on both sides of the just right level have on the response variable (i.e. acceptance of texture). Figure 2.9 shows that for crispness, the drop rate was faster over the region
50 Texture in food 3
Texture acceptance
Texture acceptance
4 3 2 1
2
1
0
0 0
1
2 3 Crispness score (a)
4
5
0
1 2 3 4 Cheese texture score (b)
5
Fig. 2.9 Contributions to texture acceptance from crispness (a) and cheese texture (b) JAR scores.
of 3 to 5 than over the region of 3 to 1, suggesting that “too crispy” was more harmful to the acceptance of texture than “not crispy enough”. For cheese texture (i.e. 1 = much too soft/melted, 5 = much too firm/not melted), the drop rate was slower over the region of 3 to 5 than over the region of 3 to 1, implying that “too soft/melted” had more detrimental effects on texture acceptance than “too firm/not melted”. MARS, similarly to PLS regression, has the ability to determine the relative importance of variables toward the prediction of the response variable (100 and 96.73 % for crispness and cheese texture, respectively). Crispness had slightly more contribution to determining texture acceptance than did cheese texture. The R2 between the observed and predicted mean scores of texture acceptance was 0.95, indicating that the fitted MARS model could accurately predict the mean score for texture acceptance.
2.7 Conclusions Although a considerable amount of research has been done on food texture, most of this work has focused on the development of sensory and rheological methods designed to assess the effects of parameters such as processing conditions or formulation on food texture. The number of studies dealing with consumers and their expectation of texture in various food products has been limited. In a sense, texture remains the overlooked attribute (Szczesniak, 1990). However, the techniques used for understanding consumers have vastly improved and, with methods such as preference mapping and the like, there is an opportunity to expand studies focusing on consumers’ perception, expectation and acceptance of and preference in food texture.
Consumers and texture
51
2.8 References AGRESTI A
(2002) Categorical data analysis (Second Edition). New York, Wiley.
BRENNAN J G (1980) Food texture measurement. In Developments in Food Analysis Techniques-
2. Ed. R D King, London, Applied Science Publishers, 1–78. and MARGALEF M I (2001) How Argentine consumers understand the Spanish translation of the 9-point hedonic scale, Food Qual. Pref. 12, 217–21. DWINNELL W (2000) Exploring MARS: an alternative to neural networks, PC AI, 14(1), 21. FRIEDMAN J (1991) Multivariate adaptive regression splines, The Annals of Statistics, 19, 1–141. HENDERSON J D and SHEWFELT R L (2002) Evaluation of scales to measure consumer acceptability, 2002 IFT Annual Meeting Book of Abstract, Anaheim, CA. JONES B and WANG J (2000) The analysis of repeated measurements in sensory and consumer studies, Food Qual Pref, 11, 35–41. JONES L V, PERYAM D R and THURSTONE L L (1955) Development of a scale for measuring soldiers’ food preferences, Food Res, 20, 512–20. MACFIE H J H and THOMSON D M H (1999) Measurement of Food Preferences, Gaithersburg, MD Aspen. MALUNDO T M M, SHEWFELT R L, WARE G O and BALDWIN E A (2001) An alternative method for relating consumer and descriptive data used to identify critical flavor properties of mango (mangifera indica L.), J Sens Stud, 16, 199–214. MARS (2001) MARS User’s Guide, Salford Systems. MEULLENET J F, GROSS J, MARKS B P and DANIELS M (1998) Sensory profiling of cooked rice and its correlation to instrumental parameters using an extrusion cell, Cereal Chem, 75, 714–20. MEULLENET J-F, GRIFFIN V K, CARSON K, DAVIS G, DAVIS S, GROSS J, HANKINS J A, SAILER E, SITAKALIN C, SUWANSRI S and VASQUEZ CAICEDO A L (2000) External rice preference mapping for Asian consumers living in the United States, J Sens Stud, 16, 73–93. MEULLENET J-F, XIONG R, MONSOOR M, BELLMAN-HORNER T, ZIVANOVIC S, DIAS P, FROMM H and LIU Z (2002) Preference mapping of commercial toasted white corn tortilla chips, J Food Sci, 67, 1950–57. MEULLENET J-F, XIONG R, HANKINS J A, DIAS P, ZIVANOVIC S, MONSOOR M A, BELLMAN-HORNER T, LIU Z and FROMM H (2003) Modeling preference of commercial toasted white corn tortilla chips using proportional odds models, Food Qual Pref, 14, 603–14. MOSKOWITZ H R (1980) Psychometric evaluation of food preferences, J Foodservice Systems, 1, 149–67. MOSKOWITZ H R and JACOBS B E (1987) Consumer evaluation and optimizaton of food texture. In Food Texture: Instrumental and Sensory Measurement. Ed. H R Moskowitz, New York, Marcel Dekker Inc, 293–328. MOSKOWITZ H R and SIDEL J L (1971) Magnitude and hedonic scales of food acceptability, J Food Sci, 36, 677–80. OKABE M (1979) Texture measurement of cooked rice and its relationship to eating quality, J Text Stud, 10, 131. OLSEN S O (1999) Strength and conflicting valance in the measurement of food attitudes and preferences, Food Qual Pref, 10, 483–94. PANGBORN R M, GUINARD J X and MEISELMAN H L (1989) Evaluation of bitterness of caffeine in hot chocolate drink by category, graphic and ratio scaling, J Sens Stud, 4, 31–53. PERYAM D R and GIRARDOT N F (1952) Advanced taste-test method. Food Eng., 24, 58–61. SANGKETKIT C, SAVAGE G P, MARTIN R J, SEARLE B P and MASON S L (2000) Sensory evaluation of new lines of oca (Oxalis tuberosa) grown in New Zealand, Food Qual Pref, 11, 189–99. SCHUTZ H G and CARDELLO A V (2001) A labeled affective magnitude (LAM) scale for assessing food liking/disliking, J. Sens. Stud, 16, 117–59. CURIA A V, HOUGH G, MARTINEZ M C
52 Texture in food and DEJMEK P (1999) Relationship between instrumental and sensory analysis of texture and color of potato chips, J Text Stud, 30, 677–90. SHEPHERD R, GRIFFITHS N M and SMITH K (1988) The relationship between consumer preferences and trained panel responses, J Sens Stud, 3, 19–35. SMITH O (1975) Potato chips. In Potato Processing. Eds W F Talbut and O Smith, Westport, CT, Avi Publishing Co, 305–402. STEVENS S S (1975) Psychophysics: an Introduction to its Perceptual, Neural, and Social Aspects, New York, John Wiley. STEVENS S S and GALANTER E H (1957) Ratio scales and category scales for a dozen perceptual continua, J Exp Psych 54, 377–411. SUWANSRI S, MEULLENET J-F, HANKINS J A and GRIFFIN K (2002) Preference mapping of domestic/ imported jasmine rice for US Asian consumers, J Food Sci, 67, 2420–31. SZCZESNIAK A S (1963) Classification of textural characteristics, J Food Sci 28, 385. SZCZESNIAK A S (1971) Consumer awareness of texture and of other food attributes, J Text Stud, 2, 196. SZCZESNIAK A S (1990) Texture: is it still an overlooked attribute? Food Tech, 9, 86–95. SZCZESNIAK AS AND KAHN E L (1971) Consumer awareness of and attitudes to food texture, J Text Stud, 2, 280–950. TEPPER B J, YOUNG S C and NAYGA R M (1997) Understanding food choice in adult men: influence of nutrition knowledge, food beliefs and dietary restraint, Food Qual Pref, 8(4), 307–17. VAISEY-GENSER M, MALCOLMSON L J, RYLAND D, PRZYBYLSKI R, ESKIN NAM and ARMSTRONG L (1994) Consumer acceptance of canola oils during temperature-accelerated storage, Food Qual Pref, 5(4), 237–43. VILLANUEVA N D M, DA SILVA M A A P and PETENATE A J (2002) Performance of the selfadjusting and hybrid hedonic scales in the generation of internal preference maps, 2002 IFT Annual Meeting Book of Abstract, Anaheim, CA. VAN TRIJP H C M and SCHIFFERSTEIN H N J (1995) Sensory analysis in marketing practice: comparison and integration, J Sen Stud, 10, 127–47. YEH L L, KIM K O, CHOMPREEDA P, RIMKEEREE H, YAU N J N and LUNDAHL D S (1998) Comparison in use of the 9-point hedonic scale between Americans, Chinese, Koreans and Thai, Food Qual and Pref, 9, 413–19. SEGNINI S
3 Texture and mastication A. C. Smith, Institute of Food Research, UK
3.1 Introduction Texture perception is an important factor in consumer sensory appreciation (Wilkinson et al., 2000). Bourne (2002) defined the textural properties of a food as the group of physical characteristics that: 1 arise from the structural elements of the food; 2 are sensed by the feeling of touch; 3 are related to the deformation, disintegration and flow of food under force; 4 are measured objectively by functions of mass, time and distance. Brennan (1989) defines perceived texture as the attribute of a substance resulting from a combination of physical properties and perceived by the senses of touch, sight and hearing. Figure 3.1 shows the involvement of the various senses in eating. This chapter considers the sensory and instrumental definitions of texture before describing the different facets of mastication. Aspects of the mastication process are described and various in vivo techniques are described which join, albeit tenuously, sensory and instrumental texture. Muscle activity, acoustic emission, force and displacement have been measured. Subjective tasks such as event recording and time-intensity may be added as part of multi-tasking combined with objective monitoring of the subject while eating. Having discussed the wherewithal of the data acquisition, the next section stands back and considers the principal aspects of chewing, swallowing, salivation and bolus formation. The wider context of texture and mastication is considered, drawing on some current emphases such as flavour and nutrient release, the
54 Texture in food
Observation
Vision
Handling
Consumption – biting – chewing – manipulation – swallowing
Vision, hearing, somesthesis, kinesthesis
Hearing, somesthesis, kinesthesis
Fig. 3.1 The involvement of the senses in texture perception during the process of food consumption. (Reprinted from ‘From food structure to texture’, Wilkinson C, Dijksterhuis G B and Minekus M (2000), Trends in Food Science and Technology, 11, 442–50, with permission from Elsevier).
possibilities for modelling and the advances now possible with modern data analysis. A brief summary of research by commodity and related reviews conclude the chapter. Texture is a key factor in influencing consumer acceptability. Texture comprises visual, followed by tactile and in the mouth senses (Peleg, 1980). Szczesniak and Kahn (1971) described perception in the mouth as a mixture of conscious and unconscious processes, the awareness being accentuated when visual expectations are violated.
3.1.1 Sensory and instrumental texture Instrumental measurements are only as relevant as their predictive power with regard to sensory attributes. Szczesniak (1963) linked texture to sensory, structural and physical parameters.The subtlety is that instrumental measurements are not always focussed on texture but on maturity, in the case of fresh fruits and vegetables, or susceptibility to damage in transport or processing. Sherman (1979) expressed texture as the composite of those properties arising from the structural elements and the manner in which they register with the physiological senses. Jowitt (1974) stated that the appreciation of texture involves the interaction between both motor and sensory components of the masticatory and central nervous systems. Kilcast and Eves (1993) summarise this as ‘the complex reactions occurring during the chewing of food are all integrated by the brain into the sensation perceived as texture’. Peleg (1983) points out that sensory terms can be used interchangeably and cites crunchy, crisp and brittle as overlapping as do firm, tough and hard. Instrumental tests can be fundamental, empirical and imitative (Bourne, 2002). In the context of this chapter on texture and mastication imitative tests are most worthy of emphasis. In selecting fruit ripeness the tactile assessment by squeezing is often used in sorting and grading. The use of dentures or opposing single teeth with a universal test machine are probably the most memorable imitative tests. However, there is often failure of a
Texture and mastication
55
single instrumental measurement as a reliable texture descriptor. Mohsenin and Mittal (1977) commented that sensory tests generally correlated better with large strain failure instrumental tests than with small strain tests.
3.2 The mastication process Mastication needs to be seen as part of the wider oral processing of food, which can be divided into motility and secretory contributions. Oral processes affect breakdown of food in the mouth, and thence sensory perception, and depend on the properties of the food and their time dependence. The motility effect operates through lower jaw, tongue, cheeks and lips. Motility is needed to transport food to the pharynx for swallowing and to reduce particle size and to form a bolus for swallowing. If it is just placed in the mouth, this involves the tongue itself and pushing it against the palate. The tongue, cheeks and lips are able to push the food between particular teeth. Three stages have been identified (Hiiemae et al., 1996; Lund, 1991): Stage I involves transport from the front of the mouth to the premolars and is characterised by low amplitude jaw movements; Stage II reduces particle size; Stage III is pre-swallowing and the food moves to the back of the tongue by tongue–palate interaction. Food clearance uses tongue and jaw movements to remove food at the end of mastication and involves swallowing (Wilkinson et al., 2000). Swallowing occurs intermittently in a chewing sequence. Oral secretion of saliva is by the salivary glands located under the tongue, between the jaw bones, at the lower jaw and beneath the ear. Saliva is mixed with food during mastication to form a bolus for swallowing. Mastication is a process combining simultaneous food comminution and lubrication, although the formation of a cohesive bolus is seen as important (Prinz and Lucas, 1997). When food is introduced into the mouth, it is moved by the tongue and then pressed against the palate which serves to indicate surface morphology. Moistening with saliva and minor deformation give way to incision and chewing and the food is deformed and may be fractured (Lillford, 2001). The subject of oral motility in relation to food structure makes use of methods from oral health and speech therapy. Hence some studies have compared speech and mastication.
3.2.1 Physiology Oral processing of foods involves initial ingestion, incision and repetitive chewing and swallowing. The incision and chewing constitutes mastication. Mastication involves teeth, gums, palate, cheeks, tongue and lips and the movements of lower (mandible) and upper (maxilla) jaws together with the secretion from the salivary glands. The tongue has an important role in deciding whether particle comminution is sufficient and moist enough to swallow (Wilkinson et al., 2000).
56 Texture in food
Oral sensitivity varies with position in the body and after the finger tips, the tongue, peridontal membrane, lips and palate are particularly acute. Perception of texture and mouthfeel involves three distinct groups (Guinard and Mazzucchelli, 1996) of mechanoreceptors: 1 in the palate, tongue and gums; 2 in the peridonytal membrane surrounding the roots of the teeth; 3 of the muscles and tendons involved in mastication. All mechanoreceptors have characteristic nerve endings. The importance of physiology is at the scale of the receptor behaviour and also at the larger scale of oral processes and motility.
3.2.2 Jaw and teeth movement The teeth play an important part at different stages of oral processing. The first bite with the incisors is the part of the eating process which has been best emulated by texture measuring devices since it is closest in action to that of a unidirectional single deformation test in a universal test machine. The main chewing stage or mastication involves jaw movement and action of the teeth to break down foods. In some stages of jaw movement, such as moving the food into the mouth and manipulation to the molars, the teeth may not reach occlusion. Speeds are variable over a large range, but the teeth may move vertically and horizontally or with a myriad of combinations leading to compressive, tensile and shear forces. Food is bitten often at the extremes rapidly with low forces or slowly with high force. The lower jaw is attached to the head by the temporomandibular joint which enables a wide range of movements. Depression (mouth opening), elevation (mouth closing), protrusion (jaw moving forward) and retrusion (jaw moving backward) and lateral movements are possible (Boyar and Kilcast, 1986).
3.2.3 Muscle activity The muscle actions corresponding to the jaw movements described above are described in detail by Boyar and Kilcast (1986) and involve the masseter, temporal, pterygoid, mylohyoid, digastric and geniohyoid muscles (Fig. 3.2). Muscle fatigue is a phenomenon that is well charted, although it is rarely described in the context of the masticatory muscles.
3.3 Measuring mastication The complexity of eating or even the chewing phase makes high demands on a texture measuring instrument. Here there is a gulf with universal test machines which operate at one rate and in one direction or even instrumental tests such as texture profile analysis (TPA). One would ideally want to make measurements
Texture and mastication
57
Temporalis
Masseter
Temporalis
Lateral pterygoid
Mylohyoid
Medialpterygoid
Temporalis
Geniogossus Geniohyoid Digastric
Fig. 3.2 Lateral view of the skull showing the muscle attachments. Inset: muscle attachments to the medial surface of the mandible. (Adapted from Romanes G J (1967), Cunningham’s Manual of Practical Anatomy, vol. 3: head and neck and brain, with permission from Oxford University Press).
of structure, displacement and force on the subject. A logical argument is to make objective measurements on people while they are chewing or eating. However, the act of measurement may affect the observations and hence should be as unintrusive as possible. Various textural techniques used to monitor mastication have been reviewed by Boyar and Kilcast (1986). Among these techniques, electromyography (EMG), the measurement of the electrical activity of muscles, has found wide application. EMG is a potential link between purely instrumental measures of food mechanical properties and sensory evaluations of consumers. It is complementary to recording sounds emitted during consumption (Section
58 Texture in food
3.3.6) and tracking displacement using kinesiology (Section 3.3.5). Although forces between teeth and dentures have been measured, the local displacement information necessary to produce the same type of force-displacement data as generated by a universal test machine are not usually available simultaneously.
3.3.1 Electromyography (EMG) Electromyography is a technique to characterise the chewing patterns of foods which differ in texture (Agrawal et al., 1997; Brown et al., 1994; Kilcast and Eves, 1991). It forms something of a bridge between instrumental tests and sensory assessments since it is an objective measurement carried out on human subjects. Brown (1994) has shown the use of EMG to characterise consistent differences in chewing patterns between individuals, and reviewed its use in the literature. EMG characteristics depend strongly on muscle fibre length, position of the electrodes relative to the muscle fibres, electrode area and inter-electrode distance and fat thickness between skin and muscles (Lateva et al., 1993; Dimitrova et al., 2001). When the muscle lies close to the surface of the skin the EMG activity can be related to specific muscles using surface electrodes. Other electrodes need to be implanted for deeperlying muscles. In many studies the temporal and masseter muscles are used (Brown, 1994; Kilcast and Eves, 1993), although Plesh et al. (1987) and Hiiemae et al. (1996) describe the monitoring of the digastric muscle. In the study of surface muscles it is non-invasive, but Hiiemae et al. (1996) used unipolar needle electrodes to record from geniohyoid/genioglossus muscles. The EMG signal is amplified and recorded and then analysed as shown in Fig. 3.3. Filtering of the signal in various ways can take place to avoid mains Time intensity (T-I) slider
Data collection computer
Event marker button
ADC interface
Polygraph (4-channel amplifier)
EMG electrodes (left & right temporal and masseter)
Fig. 3.3 EMG, time intensity and swallow button block circuit diagram. (ADC: analogue to digital converter.)
Texture and mastication
59
electricity spikes and other undulations. A large amount of data is possible with monitoring of four muscles and other time-dependent signals. Kilcast and Eves (1993) describe the integration of the signal of each muscle and the extraction of various gradients, heights and areas. Brown (1994) used software to pool and rectify the signals from four muscles. This aided identification of chews and swallow events. Subsequent data analysis extracted parameters: chew time, number of chews, chew rate and chew work. In combination with kinesiology (Section 3.3.5), the chew work was divided into that occurring during jaw closing in the vertical direction and subsequent horizontal movement at the end of the chew stroke. Swallows were also identified from EMG traces by the shape of the EMG chew bursts. Jack et al. (1993) defined the following from their integrated EMG response: number of chews, duration of muscle activity up to first swallow, duration of muscle activity after first swallow, height of first peak and also mean peak amplitude, total of peak amplitudes and also maximum peak amplitude, and chew frequency. Plesh et al. (1987) defined cycle duration, burst duration and interburst duration. Edlund and Lamm (1980) evaluated ‘masticatory efficiency’ as integrated maximum values of EMG activity in volts for the temporal and masseter muscles of five subjects. The mean values ranged from 384 µV for apple to 690 µV for white bread, with 612 µV obtained for silicone-based dental test material Optosil. Horio and Kawamura (1989) found that the mean EMG amplitude from the masseter muscles of 29 subjects decreased from about 818 µV to 187 µV as the TPA (see Bourne 2002) shear force fell from 6.3 kg to 0.1 kg. The TPA ‘gumminess’, defined as the chewing energy to bite through a cross-section of the sample, fell non-uniformly from 0.74 to 0.22 (no units). Plesh et al. (1993) defined a ‘kinematic index of stiffness’ for jaw movements as the three-dimensional speed divided by the three-dimensional path length, and found it decreased with increasing chew rate.
3.3.2 Other-myographys This section completes the picture for the related muscle measurement methods, although these are used in the context of muscles more commonly studied by occupational therapists. EMG signals are affected by muscle fatigue. The frequency spectrum becomes narrower with fatigue, losing parts of the highfrequency content (Herzog et al., 1994). Other ‘-myographys’ behave differently. Acoustic myography (AMG) in which muscle sounds are recorded from the vibrations of contracting muscle applied to quadricep muscles. Vibromyography (VMG) (Matheson et al., 1997) uses an accelerometer to measure lateral oscillations during contraction. The mean power frequency does not change, with fatigue, leading to the claim that it is a measure of intrinsic mechanical activity (Zwarts and Keidel, 1991). Interestingly VMG was found to discriminate better the absolute forces between subjects than EMG. In comparison with EMG, where the median frequency decreased continuously,
60 Texture in food
an abrupt drop in the median frequency of the VMG signal occurred after fatigue. This change in signal was readily observed in the time domain for the raw data leading to identification of the onset of fatigue (Herzog et al. 1994).
3.3.3 Time-intensity and multi-tasking Time-intensity (T-I) techniques involve the recording of specific sensory attributes as a function of time (Lee and Pangborn 1986). Cliff and Heymann (1993) have reviewed the use of T-I techniques and their use for sensory flavour and texture. Wilson and Brown (1997) used combined EMG and TI in a study of mastication and flavour release from gels of differing mechanical properties, where they observed that the act of swallowing was often associated with a marked increase in flavour perception. Studies by Sprunt et al. (2002) and Wright et al. (2003) considered mastication and flavour release from gels incorporating different concentrations of flavour. The dual-attribute time-intensity (DATI) method has been developed recently (Duizer et al. 1996a; Duizer et al., 1997) for the collection of the perception of two attributes simultaneously. These authors suggested that the use of DATI should improve evaluation of interactions, allowing foods to be assessed in a more realistic manner. Duizer et al. (1996b) have studied the relationship between T-I, EMG and instrumental texture measurements of beef tenderness. More recently, Brown and Braxton (2000) have used combined EMG and T-I together with recording of jaw movement patterns in a study on biscuits, relating dynamics of food breakdown to perceptions of texture and preference. In this case T-I was used to monitor the wetness of the biscuit sample. Brown et al. (1996) studied the tenderness of meat and trained panellists recorded it as a function of time using a sliding potentiometer in conjunction with EMG. Significant correlations were obtained between perceived tenderness and the masticatory muscle chewing work rather than chewing time or number. Brown et al. (1996) comment that flavour perception starts at zero for a given stimulus, follows a smooth increase as the concentration of the stimulus is released and falls smoothly back to zero with increasing time. In contrast, texture perception may increase sharply on ingestion and may be little changed up to swallowing. Some researchers have investigated the concept of multi-tasking (asking panellists to perform at least two sensory assessment procedures at once). Larson-Powers and Pangborn (1978) asked panellists to use a foot-pedal to initiate chart recording when carrying out time-intensity measurements on beverages and gelatins. In evaluating tactile properties of skincare products, trained panellists can be asked to evaluate absorbency while rubbing at a rate marked to a metronome (Civille and Dus, 1991). A swallow button was used by Hiiemae et al. (1996) who also used videotape recording. Jack et al. (1994) used the event marker of their time-intensity
Texture and mastication
61
computer module to mark chewing strokes in combination with EMG. Brown et al. (1996) used a microphone strapped over the larynx at the same time as EMG and T-I studies. EMG and T-I can be combined with a swallow indicator button for panellists consuming confectionery gels of differing flavour levels. There are opportunities for the subject to make subjective measurements as well, such as T-I curves and swallowing events (Fig. 3.4) (Sprunt et al., 2002). This non-invasive combination allows synchronous collection of chewing activity, swallowing events and T-I data. The extracted parameters from each recording session (with units) are as follows: T-I area, T-I duration, T-I maximum intensity, number of chews, time of last chew, chewing rate, number of swallows, time of first swallow, time of last swallow and swallow rate (Sprunt et al., 2002). 3.3.4 Force measurement Force transducers have been used in dental prostheses to measure bite forces directly. Yeh et al. (2000) used a cross-arch transducer and found that it was directly correlated with salivary flow. Van Eijden (1991) and Waltimo and Kononen (1994, 1995) have made bite force measurements, including the contribution from single and multiple teeth. Mioche et al. (1993) and Peyron et al. (1994) used an intra-oral load cell. Kilcast and Eves (1993) compared EMG integrated peak height with force for a subject biting on a force transducer using the molar teeth, which yielded a good linear relationship (Fig. 3.5). Tornberg et al. (1985) used 10 strain gauges in a dental prosthesis which enabled measurement of deformation rates in the order of 2000–4000 mm min–1 and the maximum strain for different samples.
4
3
2
1
Volt
5
TempR MassR MassL TempL Volt Volt Volt Volt
6
TI Volt
3.3.5 Displacement and kinesiology Several studies have investigated oral motility from studies of tongue and jaw movements. Movement of the lower jaw can be studied by tracking
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
120 s
Fig. 3.4 Recording of EMG signals from left (L) and right (R) masseter (Mass) and temporalis (Temp) muscles, Time-Intensity (T-I) curve for flavour, and swallows indicated by a swallow button shown as voltage spikes (channel ‘5’).
62 Texture in food 16 14 12
Force (kg)
10 8 6 4 2 0 –2 30
35
40
45 50 Peak height
55
60
65
Fig. 3.5 EMG integrated peak height as a function of measured bite force. (Reprinted from Kilcast D and Eves A (1988), ‘Integrating texture and physiology – techniques’, in Lillford P J and Vincent J F V, Feeding and the Texture of Food, 167–83, with permission from Cambridge University Press).
a magnet attached to the lower incisors, termed kinesiography. Bellisle et al. (2000) described ‘edograms’ which use a strain gauge resting on the subject’s cheek via a light headset to detect jaw movements, corresponding to chewing. Simultaneously they measured swallowing (deglutition), using a water-filled ballon mounted against the patient’s throat with a collar, the volume of which reduced and the resulting increased pressure was detected with a pressure transducer. The authors also describe the use of videoing subjects eating to deduce eating parameters for foods of different physical form, described in their case as traditional, sandwich and semi-liquid. Horio and Kawamura (1989) used a Kinesiograph (KI) to measure vertical movements of the lower jaw at the same time as making EMG measurements for the first five chewing strokes. They defined a tooth contact period and degree of jaw opening. Plesh et al. (1986, 1987, 1993) used EMG and a KI to study the jaw movements of subjects chewing gum, at individuals’ preferred rates, and also at rates prescribed using a metronome. The Myotronics Kinesiograph measured three-dimensional movement of a magnet on the lower central incisors using three magnetometers mounted on a light frame. They allowed subjects to chew at their preferred rate and also in time with a metronome at faster rates. Various parameters were identified from the KI traces, such as cycle duration, duration of opening, duration of closing and duration of occlusal. Brown et al. (1998) and Brown and Braxton (2000) also used EMG and KI and synchronised the two techniques for various foods. They were then able to apportion which phase of jaw movement corresponded to which part of the muscle work (Fig. 3.6) (see Section 3.3.1).
Texture and mastication
63
Open
16
Right
12
Vertical (mm)
Left
8 Next opening
Single chew Jaw opening No muscle effort Vertical closing Horizontal closing Next opening
4
Closed
0 –2
0
2
Lateral (mm)
Fig. 3.6 Typical jaw movement profile for a single chew. During the closing movement EMG activity may occur at the same time as the initiation of closing or may be slightly delayed. The portion of jaw closing associated with EMG activity was divided into vertical and closing. Horizontal closing was determined as any movement which occurred when the teeth were less than 1 mm away from the minimum vertical separation, and may be associated with lateral movement. (Reprinted from ‘Dynamics of food breakdown during eating in relation to perceptions of texture and preference: a study on biscuits’, Brown WE and Braxton D (2000), Food Quality and Preference, 11, 259–67, with permission from Elsevier).
Hiiemae et al. (1996) used a Sirognathograph with a magnet glued to the lower central incisors and detected movement in three directions, with one set of subjects depressing a swallow button and another set being recorded on videotape. Togashi et al. (2000) used a magnet ‘pasted’ to the gum of a lower molar. Three mutually perpendicular Hall probes resulted in the threedimensional tracking of tooth movement. They divided mastication movements into two parts, a rhythmical chewing period followed by an irregular period in preparation for swallowing. Subsequently Agrawal et al. (2000) made measurements of height and width of the chewing loop and closing angle of the jaw from Sirognathograph traces. Peyron et al. (1997) used an infrared tracking system using three cameras with four infrared emitting diodes mounted on a framework attached to the subject’s forehead and a fifth on the chin. From data analysis the movement of the chin relative to the skull was obtained. Ostry and Flanagan (1989) used a linear voltage displacement transducer (LVDT) with the transformer fixed relative to the skull with a modified hockey helmet and the core linked to the subject’s chin. The LVDT was
64 Texture in food
oriented to capture the principal direction of motion of the jaw. These authors compared jaw movement in speech with mastication (of rubber tubes). They found amplitudes, velocities and times to be greater for mastication. They measured speaking and mastication rates at the subject’s preferred rate and at an imposed faster rate.
3.3.6 Acoustic emission and monitoring Mechanoreceptors are complemented with auditory cues. Vickers (1985, 1988) has reviewed the evaluation of crispness and the hypothesis that auditory sensations are involved in the perception of crispness (Vickers and Bourne, 1976). They concluded that the number of emitted sounds per unit biting distance and the loudness of the sounds changed with perceived crispness.One means of assessing sensory attributes such as crispness is to measure the sounds produced during compression of foods. This may occur with instrumentally or manually deformed samples or by holding a microphone against the outer ear (Vickers, 1985). The signal may be played back through a frequency analyser and the data can be presented as amplitude–time curves at different frequencies. Studies have indicated that vibratory stimuli can lead to the distinguishing of crisp and crunchy foods (Vickers, 1985). Although crispness and crunchiness were closely related sensations, crisper sounds were higher in pitch and louder than the crunchier sounds (Vickers, 1984). Crisp products are characterised by sudden, clean and total fractures. Loudness, crunchiness and crispness were judged to be very closely related. A complementary area of science is gnathosonics, the study of sounds from teeth occlusion. Occlusal disorders have been monitored using equipment from stethoscope to microphone, the permanent record being termed an occlusogram. Watt (1976) classified sounds into categories depending on the duration of the occlusal sound. Malocclusion was diagnosed from longer periods of sound emission during voluntary tooth contact. As described above (Section 3.3.2) AMG ‘listens’ to contracting muscles (Herzog et al., 1994).
3.3.7 Comparisons with physical properties The first bite is often used as the focus for relating food physical properties and sensory attributes. Peyron et al. (1997) emphasise that biting may be an isolated voluntary act or the first step of the masticatory process. A number of studies have compared in vivo mastication with aspects determined using laboratory equipment. Olthoff et al. (1986) used a pneumatic bite simulator with a crosshead speed of 30 mm s–1 and measured force for different angled cusp-shaped probes together with the particle size distribution of various foods and the model material Optosil. In the case of Optosil in vivo tests were carried out and the particle size distribution measured after different numbers of chewing strokes. Fragmentation into smaller particles was found with in vivo biting.
Texture and mastication
65
Ostry and Flanagan (1989) compared thin and thick walled rubber tubes. The duration of the jaw movement and its amplitude were less and the maximum velocity higher for the thinner-walled tube which had a lower stiffness (greater compliance). Kemsley et al. (2003) have recorded the EMG response for opening and closing elastic elements held between the incisors. The root-mean-square (RMS) voltage across the concatenated signals from the masseter-right and masseter-left channels (Fig. 3.4) was calculated for all measurements. It was plotted (in beats per minute) versus chew rate in Fig. 3.7(a) and (b). Elements with stiffer springs (Peg L) resulted in signals with generally greater amplitude, although they can lead to muscle tiredness, and the authors elected not to use these in the subsequent multi-volunteer study. The RMS voltage for less stiff elements (Peg W) averaged across all volunteers and sessions is shown in Fig. 3.7(c). The trend of increasing EMG response with chew rate is clear. The average energy needed to compress the elements had been calculated from force–displacement data obtained with a universal test machine. Turning to the relationship between mastication and instrumental texture of foods, Agrawal et al. (1997, 1998, 2000) point to the importance of the
RMS voltage Calculated from electrodes 2 and 3
0.07
Peg W Volunteer 0
Peg L Volunteer 0
Peg W Multi-volunteer study
0.06
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0
30
60 (a)
90
120
0
30
60 90 (b)
120
30
60
90
120
(c)
Chew rate (bpm)
Fig. 3.7 Root Mean Squared voltage versus chew rate for volunteer 0: session 1 metronome 䊐, freestyle 䊏, session metronome ● ; (a) Peg W, (b) Peg L, (c) RMS voltage averaged across all sessions and individuals in the multi-volunteer study, Peg W. Error bars show +/– one standard deviation. (Reprinted from ‘Electromyographic responses to prescribed mastication’, Kemsley E K, Sprunt J C, Defernez M and Smith A C (2003), Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology, 13, 197–207, with permission from Elsevier).
66 Texture in food
engineering properties of toughness and modulus of elasticity in determining the rate of breakdown of foods (Section 3.4.4), pattern of mandibular movements and muscular activity measured by EMG in mastication. Engineering properties fall within the class of fundamental texture measurement (Section 3.1.1), and these studies are noteworthy in defining a fragmentation index, (toughness/modulus)0.5 from a fracture mechanics point of view.
3.3.8 Monitoring subjects Kilcast and Eves (1993) have described aspects of reproducibility in EMG experiments in a study of 30 subjects chewing fruit pastilles. They compared the integrated peak height as a function of time and divided the responses into three groups. Grouping of volunteers on the basis of chewing efficiency as judged by almond attrition and chewing gum weight loss was reported by Brown and Braxton (2000) (Section 3.4.1). Kilcast and Eves (1993) also compared the response of five subjects on three separate occasions, this time with toffee. Initial differences in integrated peak height gave way to similar results in terms of the rate of decrease of height and similar total chewing times.
3.4 Chewing, swallowing, salivation and bolus formation One aspect of chewing function is to quantify it, and a number of authors have reported on the definition of ‘masticatory efficiency’. One approach is to identify a test substance. Dahlberg (1942) listed a number of requirements of a test material: 1 it should resemble an ordinary food in that it is crushed by the alveolar cusps of the teeth or, at the other extreme, not be difficult for those with a poor dentition; 2 it should not swell or dissolve in water or saliva and should be such that its pulverisation can be established; 3 it should not break along cleavage surfaces or be tough or sticky; 4 it should be capable of standardisation, non-perishable and of good or indifferent taste. Dahlberg (1942) concluded that a hardened gelatine was suitable. Peanuts were favoured from the 35 foods tested by Yurkstas and Manly (1950). Heath (1982) observed that chewing gum bolus has different shapes that relate to the chewer’s dentition. Liedberg and Owall (1995) described a masticatory test using two-coloured chewing gum. Colour mixing and shape indices were found to depend on dental status. Interestingly they compared comminution of foods with kneading and shaping in determining a swallowing threshold. Horio and Kawamura (1989) concluded that number of chewing strokes could stimulate the swallowing process, regardless of comminution.
Texture and mastication
67
3.4.1 Chewing Chewing activity appears as a burst in the EMG output from each of the monitored muscles. Horio and Kawamura (1989) found that the chewing force and movements were strongly influenced by the texture of food, highlighting its ‘hardness’. They measured the number of chewing strokes and chewing time until the final swallow and classified their subjects into two groups from these data. As a precursor to EMG studies, chewing efficiency was measured and used to divide subjects into groups by Braxton et al. (1996) and Brown and Braxton (2000). They used two techniques: 1 chewing gum, in which the weight loss from a stick of gum was measured after 100 chews as used earlier by Heath (1982) 2 chewing almonds, in which the median size for a whole, blanched nut after 10 chews was measured using the diameters from a scanned image. The EMG work for gum was also used to normalise EMG work obtained for other foods (Brown et al. 1994). Edlund and Lamm (1980) evaluated ‘masticatory efficiency’ as integrated maximum values of EMG activity in volts for the temporal and masseter muscles of five subjects. After the main chewing activity has finished some lower-level EMG activity may continue, due to muscle movements associated with mouth clearance. Swallowing (see Section 3.4.2) may be seen as longer EMG bursts due to teeth clenches during the chewing sequence as reported by Brown et al. (1994). As described in Section 3.3.1 above, a number of time and number parameters are used to define chewing. Hiiemae et al. (1996) compared the number of chewing cycles to the first swallow and the masticatory sequence duration for banana, peeled and unpeeled apple and ginger nut biscuits and concluded that they were determined by initial food consistency.
3.4.2 Swallowing In an exploration of EMG in assessing chewing behaviour for different foodstuffs, Brown et al. (1994) described the measurement of the timing and number of swallows, identifying a swallowing event as a short pause in the chewing sequence associated with a burst of activity from the masticatory muscles as the teeth are clenched. However, they were unable to measure these events for individuals who swallow with little involvement of the masticatory muscles (termed ‘visceral’ swallowing). Hiiemae et al. (1996) compared video evidence, a swallow button and inspection of the EMG output. In a later combined EMG and T-I study, Brown et al. (1996) used a miniature microphone placed over the larynx to measure swallowing, but only reported the final swallow at the end of mastication. A number of other techniques for measuring human swallowing events have appeared in the literature. Piezoelectric sensors have been used to measure laryngeal movements during swallowing of liquids (Pehlivan et al., 1996), and have also been used in combination with EMG activity of submental and cricopharyngeal muscles
68 Texture in food
(Ertekin et al., 1996). Commercial devices exist for measuring the ear’s tympanic membrane displacement during swallowing (Marchbanks, 1984). Sonotubometry is another method, whereby changes in sound pressure level due to eustachian tube opening are measured in the external auditory meatus, while a constant sound source is applied via the nostril (Munro et al., 1999). However, none of these methods has been shown to be effective for swallowing measurement during mastication of solid foods, where both a large amount of laryngeal and tympanic membrane displacement and inner-ear noise can be associated with mandibular movements and chewing activity. As a combined technique to couple with T-I, it is also desirable that any swallow measurement device should be as non-invasive as possible, to avoid distraction of the panellist. Some of the techniques are described in Section 3.3.3 above. At the end of the chewing sequence mouth clearance occurs, typified by irregular patterns of jaw movement (Hiiemae et al., 1996). They comment that there is little masseter muscle activity compared to that of the geniohyoid and genioglossus.
3.4.3 Salivation Saliva has a lubrication effect and also has a role in taste perception as well as containing enzymes which digest lipids and starches, counter microorganisms and buffer acids in the mouth. Saliva mixed with food initiates digestion and facilitates swallowing through formation of a bolus. If a food is dry it is difficult to swallow, e.g. the party game of how many cream crackers can be eaten. A key factor in determining salivary rate is the gustatory stimulus. Salivary flow rate has been found to vary considerably depending on the type of foodstuff being consumed (Guinard et al., 1998), being strongly influenced by food texture and water content as well as flavour type and level (Prinz and Lucas, 1997; Watanabe and Dawes, 1988a,b). Total salivary flow rates as a result of eating have been published by a number of workers. Hoebler et al. (1998) found that a basal flow rate of 0.8–0.9 g/min rose to 1.1 g/min for cooked spaghetti and 1.3 g/min for white bread. In a study of oil/water emulsions containing vanillin and limonene, Mialon and Ebeler (1997) found flow rates ranging from 1.4 g/min to 5.61 g/min for their 14 volunteers. For wines of varying composition, Fischer et al. (1994) found flow rates equivalent to 1.8–5.98 g/min after 30 seconds in the mouth. Watanabe and Dawes (1988a) studied a variety of foods, and found mean salivary flow rates of 0.72 ml/min with no oral stimulation and 3.15 ml/min for boiled rice, rising to 4.94 ml/min for rhubarb pie and 7.07 ml/min for oral infusion with 260 mmmol/l citric acid.
3.4.4 Structural change during mastication Methods for expressing food breakdown in terms of comminution typically focus on measurement of particle size after a given number of chewing
Texture and mastication
69
strokes. Multiple sieving techniques used to measure particle size distributions have been described by Lucas and Luke (1983) for chewed carrot samples, Edlund and Lamm (1980) for Optosil, and Olthoff et al. (1984) for both Optosil and peanuts. Mowlana et al. (1995) described a rapid optical scanning method to measure two-dimensional surface area of chewed almonds, Vanderbilt et al. (1993) used a similar device to compare different types of particle size distributions in foods and Agrawal et al. (1997) used image analysis to study fragmentation due to chewing for a variety of foodstuffs. The latter also related breakage of food particles to material properties and discussed a fragmentation index based on toughness and stiffness of the food (Section 3.3.7). More recently, Hoebler et al. (1998, 2000) have measured particle sizes of chewed and minced bread and pasta using laser light diffraction and image analysis. These authors also measured saliva content of the chewed foods, drawing attention to its importance in bolus formation. The resulting salivary impregnation for white bread to give an adequate water content for swallowing was found to be up to five times as great as that for pasta (Section 3.3.7). Some methods for measuring surface areas of foodstuffs have been reviewed by Mohsenin (1970). These include an airflow planimeter to measure flat surface area of leaves, peeling strips from the outer surfaces of fruits and vegetables for direct measurement of total outer layer, and calculations based on measured outer linear dimensions assuming idealised shapes (e.g. apples and eggs). Methods suitable for irregularly shaped soft samples such as chewed gels were not described. Adamson (1982) has reviewed surface area determination by adsorption of substances on solid surfaces, where the adsorbate forms a surface coating that may be one or more molecular layers thick. Among these are the well-known gas adsorption isotherm (BET) method, and adsorption of dyes on impermeable solids. The surface area is then determined by a consideration of quantity of adsorbed substance. However, gels may have surfaces permeable to water, so an adsorbate such as a dye used for coating may penetrate the outer surface layer. Sprunt and Smith (2002) presented a method to give total surface area of chewed gelatin gels by absorption of aqueous amaranth dye into the gel surface. This method was used to measure profiles of surface area, gel weight and saliva weight as a function of time for panellists chewing gels throughout the mastication sequence. These gels tended to congeal on mastication, so the fragments would not be easily separable for individual coating or particle size analysis. The method described should be suitable for any similar gels that can be coated by dye absorption, but since specific dye permeation quantity will be affected by the factors discussed above, a calibration graph of absorbed dye versus surface area would need to be constructed for each separate type and composition of gel. Figure 3.8 shows results for surface area with gel weight and saliva weight as a function of number of chews. Swallow positions were seen as sharp vertical drops in all three curves. Swallowing brings about an abrupt decrease in gel surface area and gel
Surface area/cm2
70 Texture in food 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
20
40
60 No. of chews (a) Surface area
0
20
40
0
20
40
80
100
120
80
100
120
60 80 No. of chews
100
120
Mean weight/g
5.0 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0 60 No. of chews (b) Gel weight
1.4
Mean weight/g
1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
(c) Saliva weight
Fig. 3.8 Gel surface area, gel weight and saliva weight as a function of chew number for one volunteer (Sprunt J C and Smith A C, unpublished).
weight from removal of gel mass. Saliva weight also drops significantly on each swallow as would be expected. The original (no. of chews = 0) gel mean surface area and weight are shown on the upper two curves. A sample is shown taken approximately half way to the first swallow, in this case at 17 chews. This gives an indication of the build-up of surface area and any change in solid weight as the gel is initially chewed. Although this study obtained total salivary flow rates indirectly from weights by subtraction, other studies have measured saliva flow rate directly from particular ducts. For example Guinard et al. (1998) used a suction cap over the orifice of Stenson’s duct.
Texture and mastication
71
3.4.5 Bolus formation The particle size of a friable food must be reduced to a size that can be accepted by the pharyngeal and esophageal passageways for comfortable swallowing. The end product of mastication is the bolus (Hutchings and Lillford, 1988), although authors comment that some foods form a bolus and some do not (Lucas and Luke 1983). Hutchings and Lillford (1988) report a classification into at least three types of bolus: 1 a subdivision model where the teeth subdivide the sample into smaller pieces for swallowing singly or gathered together in foods such as cheese and carrot which are the cited examples; 2 rolled bolus applicable to anisotropic foods such as meats; 3 shattered foods comprising many small pieces as in biscuits and snacks. Prinz and Lucas (1997) comment that formation of a bolus is instrumental in the initiation of swallowing.
3.5 Future trends 3.5.1 Texture related to flavour and nutrient release The organoleptic quality of fruits and vegetables is influenced not only by texture, but also by the taste and aroma (Boyar and Kilcast, 1986; Piggott, 2000). The taste of an ingested plant tissue will be dependent on the extent to which flavours and volatiles within the food are released into the mouth, enabling them to come into contact with saliva and then sensory cells. The most relevant cell-wall influence relates to the fracture or separation of plant cells, and therefore to texture. Cell rupture releases cell contents into the saliva as is the case in crisp, juicy apples. In some foods, cell rupture will also be instrumental in flavour creation. Where tissue fracture involves cell separation, as in thermallysoftened vegetables or over-ripe, mealy fruits, a degree of encapsulation will occur. This is why mealy apples are generally perceived to have a dry mouthfeel. In such circumstances, the opportunity for the juice (cell contents) to reach the sensory receptors responsible for taste will depend on the rate of diffusion across the intact cell wall into the surrounding saliva in addition to the ability of the saliva to transport them to the receptors. Flavour is the combination of taste and odour influenced by sensations of pain, heat and cold and by tactile sensation. Aroma, taste, texture and mouthfeel account for the major stimuli that make up flavour (Taylor, 1996). Chemicals from the food come into contact with sensors in the nose and mouth and interact with mucous membranes. Plant cell walls in tissues and organs affect the chewing process and interact with the mouth lining. Studies of chewing using EMG can be combined with volunteer’s direct recording of time-intensity signals with swallowing recorded indirectly with a throat microphone or directly with a swallow button on the volunteer’s console. The T-I device can be used to record sensory or quality attributes, including flavour intensity.
72 Texture in food
Again, indirect measurement of volatile flavour can be carried out. Most analyses of volatile flavours have been carried out on whole foods by extracting all aroma compounds by distillation or extraction. However, physical changes occur in the mouth with regard to both texture and flavour. Surface area of food may increase initially and then decrease during bolus formation. Exhaledbreath sampling during eating using mass spectrometry techniques is an objective approach to quantify aroma release, often in combination with generation of T-I profiles by the subject (Taylor, 1996). Modelling of flavour release is outside the scope of this chapter, but the interdisciplinarity of the approach requires information from different areas of science, notably T-I studies of flavour intensity together with chewing data: number of chews and chew times, swallow times and surface area change with chewing (Harrison et al., 1998; Wright et al., 2003). The arguments about flavour release also carry over to release of nutrients and impinge on digestion. The structure and physical properties of the food following comminution and bolus formation, and then swallowing are expected to be important. In fact Prinz and Lucas (1997) argue that models of the digestive system are incomplete without specification of the food being swallowed. 3.5.2 Modelling Ledley (1971) reviewed the analysis of forces on teeth and design of denture occlusal surfaces. Starting with flat-surfaced teeth he progressed to real anatomical-shaped teeth with cusps. Numerical force analysis was carried out for different chew angles and occlusal shapes and then extended to stability of complete dentures. A very interesting current area of research is that being carried out by Professors MR Heath, M Hector and PS Wright (Queen Mary University of London, School of Medicine and Dentistry) and RH Crompton (University of Liverpool) who are collaborating on the use of finite element stress analysis to create a 3D model of food reduction, capable of predicting differences in food failure from tooth morphology. In combination with instrumented dental prostheses to measure in vivo bite forces in humans, they propose to develop and verify a general model of food comminution applicable to prediction of food texture perception and design of dental prostheses. Another modelling area is that of neural networks that produce motor patterns and receive sensory patterns. Otten (1988) describes the modelling of neurons with responses that depend on firing rates. A pattern generator was simulated in a neural network consisting of a matrix of 15 by 15 neurons. 3.5.3 Bringing together sensory and fundamental tests Attempts to correlate physical measures of food properties with sensory quality do not account for the mastication process. Instrumental measures do not imitate oral motion, rates of force application and the effects of temperature and saliva (Pierson and Le Magnen, 1970). The distinction between structure
Texture and mastication
73
and texture is often ignored (Cardello, 1994) and the terms are used interchangeably. In other disciplines, texture is purely a structural, or topological term. The blurring of perceptional and instrumental terms has been highlighted and “may impede progress in either field”. This has been a recurring theme. Szczesniak (1963) separates textural attributes into three broad categories: mechanical, geometrical and compositional. The Scott-Blair approach divides instrumental methods of texture measurement into three types: empirical, imitative and fundamental (Brennan and Jowitt, 1977; Szczesniak, 1963). Empirical tests have been developed from practical experience and are often marked out as arbitrary, poorly defined, lacking an absolute standard and effective only for a limited number of foods (Bourne, 1994). Imitative tests are often seen as a subset of empirical tests that subject the food to a process that partially mimics the consumer. Empirical tests cannot easily be expressed in fundamental terms and are dependent on test geometry, friction and sample size (Peleg, 1983). Fundamental tests are more rigorously defined, usually in engineering units, whereas empirical tests are often more successful than their fundamental counterparts. Many fundamental tests use low stresses which do not cause the material to break or fail; they also use rectilinear motion, whereas the movement of the teeth is along an arc and much faster than speeds in the universal test machine. Physical tests often produce single values while the consumers may change rates and manipulate the food during mastication. How a food deforms during mastication depends on mechanical property contributions at the different levels of structure and their interaction. In line with this philosophy, the human mouth can be instrumented to make objective measurements during eating (Kilcast and Eves, 1991). Recent work studied EMG responses simplified by dispensing with the food stimulus and the associated phenomena of particle breakdown and saliva stimulation. Instead, volunteers simulated an aspect of chewing by making jaw movements to elastically deform calibrated springs held between their incisors. Moreover, the volunteers were asked to coordinate their movements with the sound produced by a metronome, operated at a number of predetermined rates (Kemsley et al., 2003). Advances in the understanding of texture depend on a multidisciplinary approach as claimed by several reviewers (Heath and Lucas, 1987; Wilkinson et al., 2000). Three main areas are sensory, physiology and, more broadly, physicochemical properties comprising rheology (including mechanical properties) and structure.
3.5.4 More data analysis The development of EMG took place in the early days of computing power. Much of the data was discarded or averaged or simplified in order to be analysed with what are now viewed as low-level PCs. The current surge in computing power and the advent of parallel computing has opened up new opportunities, demonstrated by the following example (Kemsley et al., 2002).
74 Texture in food
Multivariate modelling (Kemsley et al., 2002) was used to analyse individual EMG recordings, which were Fourier-transformed to give a power spectrum in the frequency domain. Examination of the raw data, and of subsets of power spectra, was carried out using Matlab 6.1 (The Mathworks, Inc.) running on a desktop computer. Algorithms were written in-house to identify bursts of activity corresponding to chews, and to carry out distributional analysis of the intervals between chews. A real Fourier transform algorithm was used, provided in the IMSL Fortran 90 MP Library (Visual Numerics Inc.) supplied with Visual Fortran 6.1 (Compaq Computer Corp). Before performing principal component analysis (PCA), data points corresponding to the d.c. component were discarded, the required number of data points from each channel was concatenated, and the data area-normalised. The sum of the vector elements was set equal to unity, a transformation which has been demonstrated to emphasise band shape differences between spectra. Correlation matrix PCA was used throughout. Matrices of power spectra too large to be processed on a desktop computer were analysed on the SGI Origin2000 (Silicon Graphics Inc., Mountain View, CA, USA), at Computer Services for Academic Research (CSAR, Manchester, UK). Algorithms to perform PCA were written in Fortran 90, incorporating LINPACK library functions. The low-frequency (<10 Hz) region contained spectral differences that varied between volunteers and were consistent between sessions. Principal component analysis showed some clustering of scores from different volunteers. However, PCA of the whole frequency range showed more pronounced clustering and therefore the higher frequencies also contribute to the distinction between volunteers. The higher frequency components of the signal are neglected in conventional analysis of EMG data, which processes raw signals to obtain parameters such as chew intervals and chew rate. Volunteers can, for example, be distinguished by their high-frequency EMG spectra. The later study on the deformation of elastic elements (Kemsley et al., 2003) has examined masticatory muscle activity during constrained mouth movements, in which four different chew rates were prescribed.Within-volunteer variance, arising from the different chew rates, as well as between-session variance is concluded to be a lesser phenomenon than between-volunteer variance. The low-frequency (<10 Hz) region was found to contain spectral features related to the prescribed chew rate. Multivariate analysis of the power spectra revealed that readings from each volunteer clustered together, and the clusters could be largely separated. Such grouping was found irrespective of whether data from each chew rate were analysed separately or simultaneously. This suggests that high-frequency components of the EMG signal are largely independent of gross chewing behaviour, and arise from factors beyond the control of individuals: even when asked to make jaw movements in the same prescribed manner, volunteers can nevertheless be uniquely distinguished by their EMG frequency spectrum. These findings open up a number of possibilities for the future. Signals
Texture and mastication
75
could be ratioed to a fundamental or background response collected from each individual, perhaps whilst chewing a model material, as in the studies of Brown et al. (1994, 1996, 1998). Alternatively, it may be possible to view the inherent subjectivity of EMG as an advantage: groups of individuals could be defined on the basis of their fundamental EMG responses, and correlations sought with groupings defined on a different basis, according, say, to food preferences. In combination with other information from a suite of tests, such as salivation and structure breakdown, more information on the origin of the differences might be sought to differentiate volunteers.
3.6 Mastication and particular foods Kilcast and Eves (1993) studied three commercial fruit pastilles and attempted to correlate EMG parameters (Section 3.3.1) with sensory panel terms. Given ambiguous relationships, they used canonical variate analysis (CVA) to describe EMG parameters. They were able to plot three non-overlapping groups. The method was applied to a further four confectionery materials of different structure and texture. One sample was separated, which was consistent with observations, although CVA of sensory profile data separated two of the four samples, which was attributed to some profile terms not being differentiated by the EMG response. Nonetheless the conclusion was that EMG combined with multivariate data analysis is a powerful approach to defining textures. Jack et al. (1993) describe a study on cheese in which EMG, sensory quantitative descriptive analysis (QDA) and instrumental tests were used. EMG muscle activity was subject-dependent. Amplitude of the integrated EMG peak increased with sample hardness. Brown et al. (1994) gave results of a study on various foods including cubes of raw carrot and showed the largest variations between subjects for carrot. Brown et al. (1998), using KI to complement EMG, assessed raw and cooked carrot. Brown et al. (1996) in a study of tenderness of roast meats found that the maximum tenderness intensity obtained using T-I correlated significantly with masticatory muscle activity for 18 out of 20 consumers. Tornberg et al. (1985) evaluated cooked meats and meat products using an instrumented prosthetic appliance and found that sensory evaluations correlated best with the product of loading rate and number of chewing cycles. Brown et al. (1998) compared meats, biscuit, apple and carrot using EMG and KI. Mastication of apple and carrot relied on vertical compression for each chew, whereas in biscuit early compression was replaced by shear with the progress of chewing. A consideration of the mechanical, structural and mechanical property changes accompanying apple mastication is given in Brown et al. (1999). A more detailed description of biscuits is given in Brown and Braxton (2000) where chewing work initially increased over the first 5 to 10 chews and then decreased. The chewing work and the assessment
76 Texture in food
of sensory attributes of hardness, crunchiness and crumbliness varied between the four groups which were classified by chewing efficiency with chewing gum and almond attrition. Hiiemae et al. (1996) examined biscuit, apple and banana using EMG, sirognathography, swallowing by button and video. Peyron et al. (1997) considered cheese and carrot and found that sensory hardness, crispness and firmness were related to the first bite. Interestingly they found that thicker samples were perceived as harder. Simple flavoured confectionery gums were considered as part of a study for understanding and modelling of flavour release as part of a multi-site BBSRC LINK project where the mastication data were provided as described in Section 3.6.1 (Kemsley et al., 2002; Sprunt et al., 2002; Wright et al., 2003 and included references).
3.7 Reviews A number of other reviews deal with aspects of this chapter in much more detail, including: • Sensory, T-I: Dijksterhuis and Piggott, 2001; Guinard and Mazzucchelli, 1996; Kilcast, 1999; Piggott, 2000 • EMG, dental, physiological: Ahlgren, 1966; Boyar and Kilcast, 1986; Heath, 1988; Heath and Prinz, 1999 • In vivo texture: Bourne, 2002; Wilkinson et al., 2000 • Neural: Lund, 1991 Mastication papers are published in a diverse number of journals from food science and technology, biomechanics, theoretical biology, dental and medical journals. In addition, the International Society of Electrophysiology and Kinesiology (ISEK) is a multidisciplinary organisation composed of members from health related fields such as biomedical sciences as well as engineering, physical education, physical therapy and many other disciplines. Every two years, these scientists gather at a Congress of ISEK to share advances and knowledge in the broad field of Electrophysiological Kinesiology. The participants with affiliated institutes and universities bring experience in the fields of EMG, Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES), Motor Unit Control, Neuromuscular Diseases, Rehabilitation, Muscle Fatigue, Kinesiology, Motion Analysis, Ergonomics and many other areas of study.
3.8 Acknowledgement The author was funded from the BBSRC competitive strategic grant. I would like to thank my collaborators and IFR colleagues Drs Kate Kemsley, Marianne Defernez and John Sprunt.
Texture and mastication
77
3.9 References ADAMSON A W
(1982) Physical Chemistry of Surfaces, New York, Wiley Interscience, 369–
401. AGRAWAL K R, LUCAS P W, PRINZ J F
and BRUCE I C (1997) Mechanical properties of foods responsible for resisting food breakdown in the human mouth, Arch Oral Biol, 42(1), 1–9. AGRAWAL K R, LUCAS P W, BRUCE I C and PRINZ J F (1998) Food properties that influence neuro muscular activity during human mastication, J Dent Res, 77(11), 1931–8. AGRAWAL K R, LUCAS P W and BRUCE I C (2000) The effects of food fragmentation index on mandibular closing angle in human mastication, Arch Oral Biol, 45(7), 577–84. AHLGREN J (1966) A quantitative ciematographic and electromyographic study of mastication movements in children, with special reference to occlusion of teeth, Acta Odont Scand, 24 (44), 1–108. BELLISLE F, GUY-GRAND B and LE MAGNEN J (2000) Chewing and swallowing as indices of the stimulation to eat during meals in humans: effects revealed by the edogram method and video recordings, Neursci Biobehav Rev, 24(2), 223–8. BOURNE M C (1994) Converting from empirical to rheological tests on foods–it’s a matter of time, Cereal Foods World, 39(1), 37–9. BOURNE M C (2002) Food Texture and Viscosity: Concept and Measurement, London, Academic. BOYAR M M and KILCAST D (1986) Review: food texture and dental science, J Text Stud, 17(3), 221–52. BRAXTON D, DAUCHEL C and BROWN W E (1996) Association between chewing efficiency and mastication patterns for meat, and influence on tenderness perception, Food Qual Pref, 7(3/4), 217–23. BRENNAN J G (1989) Texture perception and measurment. In Sensory Analysis of Foods. Ed. J R Piggott, London, Elsevier, 69–101. BRENNAN J G and JOWITT R (1977) Some factors affecting the objective study of food texture. In Sensory Properties of Foods. Eds G G Birch, J G Brennan and K J Parker, London, Applied Science, 227–45. BROWN W E (1994) Method to investigate differences in chewing behaviour in humans: I. Use of electromyography in measuring chewing, J Text Stud, 25(1), 1–16. BROWN W E and BRAXTON D (2000) Dynamics of food breakdown during eating in relation to perceptions of texture and preference: a study on biscuits, Food Qual Pref, 11(4), 259–67. BROWN W E, SHEARN M and MACFIE H J H (1994) Method to investigate differences in chewing behaviour in humans: II. Use of electromyography during chewing to assess chewing behaviour, J Text Stud, 25(1), 17–31. BROWN W E, LANGLEY K R, MIOCHE L, MARIE S, GERAULT S and BRAXTON D (1996) Individuality of understanding and assessment of sensory attributes of foods, in particular, tenderness of meat, Food Qual Pref, 7(3/4), 205–16. BROWN W E, EVES D, ELLISON M and BRAXTON D (1998) Use of combined electromyography and kinesthesiology during mastication to chart the oral breakdown of foodstuffs: relevance to measurement of food texture, J Text Stud, 29(7), 145–67. BROWN W E, SMITH A C, WALDRON K W, EVES D, INGHAM L M and ELLISON M (1999) Oral mechanics of mastication of fruit and vegetables in relation to sensory perception of texture. In Agri-Food Quality II: Quality management of fruits and vegetables. Eds M Hagg, R Ahvenainen, A M Evers and K Tiilikkala, London, RSC, 285–7. CARDELLO A (1994) Sensory-instrumental research, Cereal Food World, 39(8), 567–9. CIVILLE G V and DUS C A (1991) Evaluating tactile properties of skincare products: a descriptive analysis technique, Cosmet Toiletries, 106(May), 83–8. CLIFF M and HEYMANN H (1993) Development and use of time-intensity methodology for sensory evaluation: a review, Food Res Intnl, 26(5), 375–85.
78 Texture in food (1942) The masticatory effect, Acta Medica Scandinavica, 112(139), 1–479. and PIGGOTT J R (2001) Dynamic methods of sensory analysis, Trends Food Sci Tech, 11(8), 284–90. DIMITROVA N A, DIMITROV G V and NIKITIN O A (2001) Longitudinal variations of characteristic frequencies of skeletal muscle fibre potentials detected by a bipolar electrode or multi-electrode, J Med Eng Techn, 25(1), 34–40. DUIZER L M, BLOOM K and FINDLAY C J (1996a) Dual-attribute time-intensity measurement of sweetness and peppermint perception of chewing gum, J Food Sci, 61(3), 636–8. DUIZER L M, GULLETT E A and FINDLAY C J (1996b) The relationship between sensory timeintensity, physiological electromyography and instrumental texture profile analysis measurements of beef tenderness, Meat Sci, 42(12), 215–24. DUIZER L M, BLOOM K and FINDLAY C J (1997) Dual-attribute time-intensity sensory valuation: a new method for temporal measurement of sensory perceptions, Food Qual Pref, 8(4), 261–9. EDLUND J and LAMM C J (1980) Masticatory efficiency, J Oral Rehab, 7(12), 123–30. ERTEKIN C, AYDOGDU I and YUCEYAR N (1996) Piecemeal deglutition and dysphagia limit in normal subjects and in patients with swallowing disorders, J Neurol, Neurosurg Psych, 61(15), 491–6. FINCH C A, and JOBLING A (1977) The Physical Properties of Gelatin. In The Science and Technology of Gelatin. Eds AG Ward and A Courts, London, Academic Press, 250–94. FISCHER U, BOULTON R B and NOBLE A C (1994) Physiological factors contributing to the variability of sensory assessments: relationship between salivary flow rate and temporal perception of gustatory stimuli, Food Qual Pref, 5(1–2), 55–64. GUINARD J-X and MAZZUCCHELLI R (1996), The sensory perception of texture and mouthfeel, Trends Food Sci Tech, 7(7), 213–9. GUINARD J-X, ZOUMAS-MORSE C and WALCHAK C (1998) Relation between parotid saliva flow and composition and the perception of gustatory and trigeminal stimuli in foods, Physiol Behav, 63(1), 109–18. HARRISON M, CAMPBELL S and HILLS B P (1998) Computer simulation of flavor release from solid foods in the mouth, J Agric Food Chem, 46(7), 2736–43. HEATH M R (1982) The effect of maximum biting force and bone loss upon masticatory function and dietary selection of the elderly, Int Dental J, 32(4), 345–56. HEATH M R (1988) The basic mechanics of mastication: man’s adaptive success. In Feeding and the Texture of Food. Eds P J Lillford and J F V Vincent, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 143–66. HEATH M R and LUCAS P W (1987) Mastication: the need for collaborative research, J Text Stud, 18(2), 111–23. HEATH M F and PRINZ J F (1999) Oral processing of foods and the sensory evaluation of texture. In Food Texture: Measurement and Perception. Ed. A J Rosenthal, New York, Aspen, 18–29. HERZOG W, ZHANG Y-T, VAZ M A, GUIMARAES A C S and JANSSEN C (1994) Assessment of muscular fatigue using vibromyography, Muscle Nerve, 17(10), 1156–61. HIIEMAE K, HEATH M R, HEATH G, KAZAZOGLU E, MURRAY J , SAPPER D and HAMBLETT K (1996) Natural bites, food consistency and feeding behaviour in man, Arch Oral Biol, 41(2), 175–89. HOEBLER C, DEVAUX M-F, KARINTHI A, BELLEVILLE C and BARRY J-L (2000) Particle size of solid food after human mastication and in vitro simulation of oral breakdown, Int J Food Sci Nutr, 51(3), 353–66. HOEBLER C, KARINTHI A, DEVAUX M-F, GUILLON F, GALLANT D J G, BOUCHET B, MELEGARI C and BARRY J -L (1998) Physical and chemical transformations of cereal food during oral digestion in human subjects, Br J Nutr, 80(5), 429–36. HORIO T and KAWAMURA Y (1989) Effects of texture of food on chewing patterns in the human subject, J Oral Rehab, 16(2), 177–83. HUTCHINGS J B and LILLFORD P J (1988) The perception of food texture – the philosophy of the breakdown path, J Text Stud, 19(2), 103–15. DAHLBERG B
DIJKSTERHUIS G B
Texture and mastication JACK F R, PIGGOTT J R
79
and PATERSON A (1993) Relationships between electromyography, sensory and instrumental measures of cheddar cheese texture, J Food Sci, 58(6), 1313–17. JACK F R, PIGGOTT J R and PATERSON A (1994) Analysis of textural changes in hard cheese during mastication by progressive profiling, J Food Sci, 59(3), 539–43. JOWITT R (1974) Terminology of food texture, J Text Stud, 5(3), 351–8. KEMSLEY E K, SPRUNT J C, DEFERNEZ M and SMITH A C (2002) Multivariate analysis of electromyographic (EMG) frequency spectra to characterise mastication, J Text Stud, 33(1), 15–34. KEMSLEY E K, SPRUNT J C, DEFERNEZ M and SMITH A C (2003) Electromyographic responses to prescribed mastication, J Electromyog Kines, 13(2), 197–207. KILCAST D (1999) Sensory techniques to study food texture. In Food Texture: Measurement and Perception. Ed. A J Rosenthal, New York, Aspen, 30–64. KILCAST D and EVES A (1991) Integrating texture and physiology – techniques. In Feeding and the Texture of Food, Eds P J Lillford and J F V Vincent, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 167–83. KILCAST D and EVES A (1993) Modern methods of texture measurement. In Instrumentation and Sensors for the Food Industry, Ed. E Kress-Rogers, Oxford, Butterworth Heinemann, 349–74. LARSON- POWERS N and PANGBORN R M (1978) Paired comparison and time-intensity measurements of the sensory properties of beverages and gelatins containing sucrose or synthetic sweeteners, J Food Sci, 43(1), 41–51. LATEVA Z C, DIMITROVA N A and DIMITROV G V (1993) Effect of recording electrode position along a muscle fibre on surface potential power spectrum, J Electromyog Kines, 3(4), 195–204. LEDLEY R S (1971) Dental forces and mastication, J Text Stud, 2(1), 3–17. LEE W K III and PANGBORN R M (1986) Time-intensity: the temporal aspects of sensory perception, Food Tech, 40(11), 71–8, 82. LIEDBERG B and OWALL B (1995) Oral bolus kneading and shaping measured with chewing gum, Dysphagia, 10(12), 101–6. LILLFORD P J (2001) Mechanisms of fracture in foods, J Text Stud, 32(15–16), 397–417. LUCAS P W and LUKE D A (1983) Methods for analysing the breakdown of foods in human mastication, Arch Oral Biol, 28(9), 813–19. LUND J P (1991) Mastication and its control by the brain stem, Crit Rev Oral Biol Med, 2(1), 33–64. MARCHBANKS R J (1984) Measurement of tympanic membrane displacement arising from aural cardiovascular activity, swallowing, and intra-aural muscle reflex, ActaOtolaryngologica (Stockholm), 98(1–2), 119–29. MATHESON G O, MAFFEY- WARD L, MOONEY M, LADLY K, FUNG T and ZHANG Y -T (1997) Vibromyography as a quantitative measure of muscle force production, Scand J Rehab Med, 29(1), 29–35. MIALON V S and EBELER S E (1997) Time-intensity measurement of matrix effects on retronasal aroma perception, J Sensory Studies, 12(4), 303–16. MIOCHE L, PEYRON M A and AUROY P (1993) The use of intra-oral load cells in the study of texture-perception, J Text Stud, 24(4), 361–73. MOHSENIN N N (1970) Physical Properties of Plant and Animal Materials. New York, Gordon and Breach. MOHSENIN N N and MITTAL J P (1977) Use of rheological terms and correlation of compatible measurements in food texture research, J Text Stud, 8(4), 395–408. MOWLANA F, HEATH MR and AUGER D (1995) Automated optical-scanning for rapid sizing of chewed food particles in masticatory tests, J Oral Rehabil, 22(2), 153–8. MUNRO K J, BENTON C L and MARCHBANKS R J (1999) Sonotubometry findings in children at high risk from middle ear effusion, Clinical Otolaryngology, 24(3), 223–7. OLTHOFF L W, VAN DER BILT A, BOSMAN F and KLEIZEN H H (1984) Distribution of particle sizes in food comminuted by human mastication, Arch Oral Biol, 29(11), 899–903.
80 Texture in food OLTHOFF L W, VANDERBILT A, DE BOER A and BOSMAN F (1986) Comparison of force–deformation
characteristics of artificial and several natural foods for chewing experiments, J Text Stud, 17(3), 275–89. OSTRY D J and FLANAGAN J R (1989) Human jaw movement in mastication and speech, Arch Oral Biol, 34(9), 685–93. OTTEN E (1988) The control of movements and forces during chewing. In Feeding and the Texture of Food. Eds P J Lillford and J F V Vincent, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 123–41. PEHLIVAN M, YUCEYAR N, ERTEKIN C, GURBUZ C, ERTAS M, KALAYCI T and AYDOGDU I (1996) An electronic device measuring the frequency of spontaneous swallowing: digital phagometer, Dysphagia, 11(4), 259–64. PELEG M (1980) A note on the sensitivity of fingers, tongue and jaws as mechanical testing instruments, J Text Stud, 10(3), 245–51. PELEG M (1983) The semantics of rheology and texture, Food Tech, Nov, 54–61. PEYRON M A, MIOCHE L and CULIOLI J (1994) Bite force and sample deformation during hardness assessment of viscoelastic models of foods, J Text Stud, 24(1), 59–76. PEYRON M A, MASKAWI K, WODA A, TANGUAY R and LUND J P (1997) Effects of food texture and sample thickness on mandibular movement and hardness assessment during biting in man, J Dent Res, 76(3), 789–95. PIERSON A and LE MAGNEN (1970) Study of food textures by recording of chewing and swallowing movements J Text Stud, 1(3), 327–37. PIGGOTT J R (2000) Dynamism in flavour science and sensory methodology, Food Res Intl, 33(3–4), 191–7. PIGGOTT J R, SIMPSON S J and WILLIAMS S A R (1998) Sensory analysis, Int J Food Sci Tech, 33(1), 7–18. PLESH O, BISHOP B and MCCALL JR W D (1986) Effect of gum hardness on chewing pattern, Exp Neurol, 92(3), 502–12. PLESH O, BISHOP B and MCCALL JR W D (1987) Mandibular movements and jaw muscles activity while voluntarily chewing at different rates, Exp Neurol, 98(2), 285–300. PLESH O, BISHOP B and MCCALL JR W D (1993) Kinematics of jaw movements during chewing at different frequencies, J Biomech, 26(3), 243–50. PRINZ J F and LUCAS P W (1997) An optimization model for mastication and swallowing in mammals, Proc Roy Soc Lond B, 264(1389), 1715–21. ROMANES G J (1967) Cunningham’s Manual of Practical Anatomy, vol. 3: Head and Neck and Brain. London, Oxford University Press. SHERMAN P (1979), Food Texture and Rheology. London, Academic. SPRUNT J C, RAITHATHA C E and SMITH A C (2002) Use of a swallow indicator button as an enhancement to combined time intensity measurement of flavour release and electromyography for monitoring mastication, Food Qual Pref, 13(1), 47–55. SPRUNT J C and SMITH A C (2002) Measurement of surface area, gel weight and saliva weight in gelatin-based gels over the course of mastication, Int J Food Sci Nutr, 53(3), 261– 71. SZCZESNIAK A S (1963) Objective measurment of food texture, J Food Sci, 28(1), 410–20. SZCZESNIAK A S and KAHN E L (1971) Consumer awareness of and attitudes to food texture. I. Adults, J Text Stud, 2(3), 280–95. TAYLOR A J (1996) Volatile flavor release from foods during eating, Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr, 36(8), 765–84. TOGASHI M, MORITA A and NAKAZAWA F (2000) Rythmic and irregular movement of the first molar while eating foods with different textures, J Text Stud, 31(3), 257–71. TORNBERG E, FJELKNER-MODIG S, RUDERUS H, GLANTZ P, RANDOW K and STAFFORD D (1985) Clinically recorded masticatory patterns as related to the sensory evaluation of meat and meat products, J Food Sci, 50(4), 1059–66. VANDERBILT A, ABBINK J H, MOWLANA F and HEATH M R (1993) A comparison between dataanalysis methods concerning particle-size distributions obtained by mastication in man, Arch Oral Biol, 38(2), 163–7.
Texture and mastication
81
(1991) Three-dimensional analyses of human bite-force magnitude and moment, Arch Oral Biol, 36(7), 535–9. VICKERS Z M (1984) Crispness and crunchiness: a difference of pitch?, J Text Stud, 15(2), 157–63. VICKERS Z M (1985) The relationships of pitch, loudness and eating technique to judgments of the crispness and crunchiness of food sounds, J Text Stud, 16(1), 85–95. VICKERS Z M (1988) Evaluation of crispness. In Food Structure: its Creation and Evaluation. Eds J M V Blanshard and J R Mitchell, London, Butterworths, 433–48. VICKERS Z M and BOURNE M C (1976) A psychoacoustical theory of crispness, J Food Sci, 41(5), 1158–64. WALTIMO A and KONONEN M (1994) Bite force on single as opposed to all maxillary front teeth, Scand J Dent Res, 102(6), 372–5. WALTIMO A and KONONEN M (1995) Maximal bite force and its assocation with signs and symptoms of craniomandibular disorders in young Finnish non-patients, Acta Odontol Scand, 53(4), 254–8. WATANABE S and DAWES C (1988a) The effects of different foods and concentrations of citric acid on the flow rate of whole saliva in man, Arch Oral Biol, 33(1), 1–5. WATANABE S and DAWES C (1988b) A comparison of the effects of tasting and chewing foods on the flow rate of whole saliva in man, Arch Oral Biol, 33(10), 761–4. WATT D M (1976) Monitoring mastication, J Dent, 4(6), 271–8. WILKINSON C, DIJKSTERHUIS G B and MINEKUS M (2000) From food structure to texture, Trends Food Sci Tech, 11(12), 442–50. WILSON C E and BROWN W E (1997) Influence of food matrix structure and oral breakdown during mastication on temporal perception of flavor, J Sensory Stud, 21(1), 69–86. WRIGHT K M, SMITH A C, SPRUNT J C and HILLS B P (2003) Modelling flavour release from a chewed bolus in the mouth, Part 1: mastication, Int J Food Sci Tech, 38(3), 351–60. YEH C-K, JOHNSON D A, DODDS M W J, SAKAI S, RUGH J D and HATCH J P (2000) Association of salivary flow rates with maximal bite force, J Dent Res, 79(8), 1560–65. YURKSTAS A A and MANLY R S (1950) Value of different test foods in estimating masticatory ability, J Appl Physiol, 3(7), 45–53. ZWARTS M J and KEIDEL M (1991) Relationship between electrical and vibratory output of muscle during voluntary contraction and fatigue, Muscle Nerve, 14(8), 756–61. VAN EIJDEN T M G J
4 Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness P. Mallikarjunan, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, USA
4.1 Introduction The consumer market for fresh and frozen-coated foods has been rapidly expanding in recent years. An increase of 16 % in breading and batter usage occurred from 1978 to 1988 (Kulp and Loewe, 1992), and the number of crispy food products on the market has increased tremendously in the decades since 1980 (Bouvier et al., 1997), especially snack food products. In addition to snack foods, consumers like fried foods such as breaded fried shrimp and breaded chicken nuggets because of the unique and desirable combination of crispness from the dried outer crust layer with the soft and pliable inner crust layer. The traditional fried products, such as French fries and hushpuppies (bite-sized, US southern style fried cornmeal nuggets) still prevail in the food service business. However, new breaded products have been developed by food researchers and have become available as choices for consumers; for instance, in late 1997, Cargill Company introduced “breaded beef steak” with an attractive golden brown coloring and seasoned flavor and a solid texture bite into the market (Weller, 1997). According to Restaurants and Institutions’ 1995 Menu Census, half of the top 20 appetizers considered to be “good sellers” are frozen convenience items, e.g. onion rings, chicken wings, mozzarella sticks, breaded calamari and breaded vegetables (Anon., 1998). From the above list, for both food service products and frozen food products, crispness appears to be the most versatile single textural characteristic determining the success of the product in the market place.
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
83
4.1.1 Crispness vs crunchiness The definition of crispness is not yet completely understood with only the generalized concept having been established. In general, crispness is a highly valued and universally linked textural characteristic that has many positive connotations (Szczesniak and Kahn, 1971). Crispness in one commodity may not mean the same in terms of textural quality as crispness in another, e.g. crispness in nuts as compared with crispness in potato chips. Historically, crispness was defined as the quality of fracturing into many small pieces under compressive pressure and associated with brittleness. Amerine et al. (1965) defined crispness as a textural property characterized by a brittle, friable nature. Bourne (1975) indicated that a crisp or crunchy food is characterized by: • • • • • • • •
having a rigid, non-deformable, stiff structure that suddenly collapses with a brittle fracture and a rapid decay of the forces after fracture; having very low shear strength; breaking up under simple compression between the teeth with little or no grinding or tearing; rapidly breaking down into small pieces; requiring small number of chews per piece (not chewy); requiring low work for mastication; having sound effects associated with brittle fracture which is often a desirable feature; having a structure usually comprising cellular aggregates.
Eventually Vickers and Bourne (1976a, b) concluded that crispness has not been adequately defined. This conclusion corresponded to the work by Szczesniak (1988) who compiled the consumer descriptions of crispness and found it to be associated with brittleness, crackling, snapping, crunchiness and sound emission during eating. According to the American Heritage college dictionary (1997), crisp means (1) firm but easily broken or crumbled; brittle (2) pleasingly firm and fresh; crunch means to chew with a noisy crackling sound. The term crispness is more associated with mechanical failure, and crunchiness is more associated with sound burst during chewing. More often the use of crispness and crunchiness is interchangeable and users are unaware of their connotations. Primarily, it would be more likely that the distinction between crispness and crunchiness was conceived to be due to the physiological manipulation of specimens in the mouth. Vickers (1979) proposed that pronouncing the word “crunchy” makes use of the molars (back teeth) rather than the other parts of teeth; on the other hand, pronouncing “crispy” employs the incisors (front teeth) more intensely than the other parts. Perhaps it may be a consequence of this that crispness and crunchiness were evaluated by using the incisors and molars, respectively. The sound emission from a chew by the molars does not project much compared to that from a bite by the incisors. Therefore, Vickers (1984)
84 Texture in food
speculated that the sensations of crispness and crunchiness may differ in pitch. She found that the more crisp foods (than crunchy) nearly always produced the higher pitch sounds than the more crunchy foods (than crisp). In addition, when the eating technique was altered from a bite to a chew, judgments of crispness were depressed. Bite sounds were assumed to be relatively higher in pitch due to a combination of airborne and bone-conducted sounds, in contrast to chewing sounds which were assumed to be relatively lower in pitch due to the dampening effect of the higher frequency sounds by the soft tissue in the mouth (Vickers, 1987). This research implied that the association of sound may clarify a distinction between crispness and crunchiness. Seymour and Hamann (1988) used trained panelists to evaluate crispness and crunchiness in crunch twist, saltine cracker and three different potato chip brands. The definitions of crispness and crunchiness were based upon physiological manipulation and sound; that is, crispness was evaluated by the placing of a sample between the incisors and sensorial detection of a level of high-pitched sound; meanwhile, crunchiness was evaluated by the placing of a sample between molars and sensorial detection of a degree of low-pitched sound. They found that the crunchiness in a product advertised as crunchy (crunch twist) tended to be at a lower frequency than that in a product advertised as crisp (potato chips).
4.1.2 Batter/breading and its significance to crispness The terms batter, breading and coating, are often misused. Suderman (1983) described the distinctions among them. Batter was defined as a liquid mixture comprising water, flour, starch, and seasonings into which food products are dipped prior to cooking. Breading was defined as a dry mixture of flour, starch, and seasonings, applied to moistened or battered food products prior to cooking. Coating was referred to as the batter and/or breading adhering to a food product after cooking. Batters and breadings serve many functions as food coatings, i.e. enhancing a food product’s appearance (Elston, 1975) and contributing to a crispy texture (Elston, 1975; Zwiercan, 1974). Coating material is a key to producing a desirable crispness in breaded fried shrimp. The coating should exhibit a structure that sufficiently resists the initial bite, then it should disappear with a quick meltaway in the mouth (Loewe, 1993). With regard to the relation of cooking and crispness, crispness can be adjusted by time and temperature of cooking (Donahoo, 1970); however, it was formerly reported that mixtures of thickening agents offer the greatest promise for achieving desirable crispness (Hanson and Fletcher, 1963). The coating system for fried shrimp can be classified into two types: a tempura coating, where the batter forms the coating, and interface/adhesion coatings, where batter serves to hold a coating onto the product (LaBell, 1994). Loewe (1993) commented, “Consumers will praise or condemn a
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
85
battered or breaded food based on several general quality factors”. Furthermore, he also summarized the critical coating characteristics for breaded products to be appearance, color, crispness, adhesion and flavor. According to the author’s observations, the store brand breaded fried shrimp was less desirable in appearance and crispness quality than that obtained from a brand name company specializing in shrimp processing. The coating of the store brand product was mushy and easily absorbed moisture after the products were cooked and held for a short time. Low-quality batters can diminish the coating properties, e.g. minimizing moisture loss of the product (Suderman, 1983), thereby resulting in a decrease in shelf life and crispness. Another problem common to all breaded products is adhesion. It is especially important for both breading and batter to maintain uniform adhesion to the food substrate under the stresses involved (Loewe, 1993). The loss of breading may occur during processing, transportation, or handling to the consumers, as a result creating aesthetic and economic problems (Suderman, 1983). Loewe (1993) suggested that during reconstitution of a breaded product in the oven, the coating should not develop voids or pockets along the interface. These voids can create a “shelling” or coating separation indicating a lessthan-desirable product. However, adding appropriate starches can help control batter viscosity and yields a firmer coating that holds a shrimp better. Smooth, bubbly, puffy or crispy surfaces can be achieved, depending on the choice of starch (LaBell, 1994).
4.2 Characterization and determination of crispness Although many experiments have been dedicated to determining crispness, the best measurements are still inconclusive. However, the properties related to crispness were able to disclose the complexity of crispness and its association with other similar sensory attributes, e.g., brittleness, hardness, crackliness or crunchiness.
4.2.1 Structural and geometrical properties Many researchers agree that crispness should result from the structural properties of a food (Barrett and Peleg, 1992; Barrett et al., 1994; Bouvier et al., 1997; Gao and Tan, 1996a; Mohamed et al., 1982; Stanley and Tung, 1976; Vickers and Bourne, 1976 a,b). Matz (1962) and Coppock and Carnford (1960) proposed that crisp, dry foods, such as biscuit, break into many pieces when masticated and their eating quality is affected by the size of air cells and thickness of the cell walls. Crispness is conceived as being related to the cellular structure of foods. Perhaps the most direct method for its objective measurement is likely to be the investigation of the product’s structure and geometrical properties. A scanning electron microscope (SEM) is commonly employed to reveal the
86 Texture in food
internal structure of a product. Cell size and number of cells can then be measured and quantified from the projected image (Gao and Tan, 1996a). Barrett et al. (1994) investigated the structural properties determined from cell size distribution and bulk density of corn meal extrudates. They found that the mechanical strength, determined from a compressive stress, and fracturability, determined from fractal and Fourier analysis of the stress– strain function, increased with decreasing mean cell size or increasing bulk density. Furthermore, the sensory results indicated that cellularity strongly influences the pattern of mechanical failure. Gao and Tan (1996b) employed an image processing technique and hinted that some important sensory attributes could be predicted by processing the surface and cross-section images of the product. This may be another potential means of gaining further understanding of the relationship between crispness and structural properties.
4.2.2 Mechanical properties Perhaps the most prevalent objective measurement for crispness is determination via mechanical properties. Mechanical properties are believed to reveal the structural properties of materials by means of resistance to compression by a blade/probe and to a tensile fixture that pulls the structure of food material apart by using a universal testing machine or a texture analyzer. The measurement of mechanical properties is easier to conduct than that of structural properties, determined via the SEM. The mechanical variables are extracted from a force–deformation or stress–strain curve and shown in the chart recorder; force is used to determine brittleness and hardness (Szczesniak, 1963), and the area under the peak force is used to determine the energy required to bite or chew the products or toughness (Seymour and Hamann, 1988). Due to the various sensory attributes of foods, the mechanical properties measurement was developed in order to construct the texture profile analysis to obtain the correlation with sensory attributes (Bourne and Comstock, 1981). In order to authenticate the sensory assumptions, various modifications of jigs and tools were created for objective investigations, such as shear compression blade, puncture probe, Kramer shear test cell, and snap test cell. Nevertheless, there are no definite criteria for selection of an apparatus to measure the mechanical properties of foods. Also, the tests are dependent upon the nature of products; therefore, a variety of mechanical tests have been reported for different types of snacks even though the products are put into the same category as low-moisture foods, as shown in the following examples. • A puncture test has been used to measure crispness in extrudates (Bouvier, 1996) and cookies (Gaines et al., 1992). • A snap test or 3-point bending test, first proposed by Bourne (1975), was used to evaluate hardness and brittleness of cookies. It consists of two beams with a known distance apart supporting the product. Another beam
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
87
is brought down to touch the product at a point equidistant from both support beams (Gaines et al., 1992). • A shear compression test using the Kramer cell was used to determine crispness in peanuts and found to be the best correlated among the shear and compression tests with sensory crispness (Hung and Chinnan, 1989). Ward et al. (1998) also applied this cell to snack chips containing masa cornmeal, wheat flour, cowpea meal, and cornstarch. • A shear compression test by a modified Warner-Bratzler blade was used to determined crispness in bacon (Voisey and Stanley, 1979). • A needle test was used to determine crispness in Chee-tos and ginger snap by pushing a needle against the food. The average slope of each peak was found to correlate well with sensory crispness (Vickers, 1979). Voisey (1976) suggested that the criteria for selection of apparatus for mechanical properties tests should be considered as follows: its readings must relate to sensory analysis, the test conditions should be simple to replicate and the sample size and shape must also be predictable. Peleg (1978) also commented that the geometry of the material to be tested can pose a crucial problem with regard to the interpretation of the results of mechanical properties. The mechanical tests were performed for measuring crispness in different foods, such as bacon (Voisey and Stanley, 1979), potato chips (Katz and Labuza, 1981), biscuits (Mohamed et al., 1982), breakfast cereals (Sauvageot and Blond, 1991), and breaded shrimps (Tahnpoonsuk, 1999). Mohamed et al. (1982) used a constant force rate texture testing instrument to study the crispness of the biscuits. Good correlations were found between sensory crispness and the ratio of work to fracture to total work. Seymour (1985) used a Kramer shear cell in an Instron to crush samples of several dry crisp foods altered in crispness by humidification. He found large negative correlations between crispness and the following mechanical parameters: maximum force at failure and work done to failure. Although mechanical tests are relatively quick and easy to perform, they have not produced a high enough degree of correlation with sensory crispness. Also, many crisp foods cannot be tested by them because they are too small, have irregular sizes and shapes or are part of a food that also consists of noncrisp parts. 4.2.3 Acoustical properties Perhaps the first impression of a crisp food is the sound burst during biting. Due to the fact that the crushing of crisp or crunchy foods results in fracture and fragmentation, it appears that fracture and sound emission are associated. Attenburrow et al. (1992) reported that the sounds emitted during the crushing of a dry product are due to a sudden release of stored elastic energy. The association between mechanical fracture and sound emission has been further elaborated by Chakra et al. (1996) via the first and second law of thermodynamic principles. In brief, the rupture of a brittle product, obtained
88 Texture in food
as the applied stress reaches a critical value, induces an instantaneous liberation of the elastic energy from a binding of the inter-atomic bonds in the form of acoustical energy. Pioneering work on acoustical properties in foods was conducted by Drake (1963, 1965) who found that sounds from crisp foods differ from non-crisp foods, in the loudness. Later in the 1970s and 80s, acoustic measurement in food research gained more attention in the characterization of sound-related textural attributes, e.g. crispness, crunchiness. Mechanical properties were primarily used to determine and interpret crispness until Vickers (1987), Seymour and Hamann (1988), Mohamed et al. (1982) and Vickers and Bourne (1976a) found that the combination of sound and mechanical properties predicted sensory crispness better than mechanical properties alone. For example, crispness was found to be poorly correlated with an instrumental fracture force (r = 0.018) in a low-moisture food (Mohamed et al., 1982). This indicated that mechanical properties alone may not entirely explain crispness. Sensory crispness has been predicted using both mechanical and acoustical variables by the multiple linear regression technique summarized in Table 4.1. Studies have shown that auditory sensations are an important for evaluating crispness (Christensen and Vickers, 1981; Edmister and Vickers, 1985; Lee et al., 1988; Mohamed et al., 1982; Vickers and Bourne, 1976b). Vickers and Table 4.1 The regression equation for crispness prediction in different foods. (Adapted from Vickers, 1988) R2
Products
Prediction equation
Seymour and Hamann (1988) Potato chips (Pringles) Potato chips (O’Gradys) Potato chips (Rippled Pringles) Crunch twist Saltine crackers
Crispness Crispness Crispness Crispness Crispness
Vickers (1987) Potato chips
Crispness = –15.6 + 5.35 NP + 133 MHP
0.98
Vickers (1988) Breafast cereals
Crispness = 538 + 539 (log MHP) – 222 PF
0.74
F = peak force at failure (N) by Kramer shear cell Wy = work done to failure (mJ) SPL1= Sound pressure level (dBA) in 0.5–1.2 kHz ILT = Acoustic intensity (watts/m2) in 0.5–3.3 kHz NP = number of sound occurrences during bite MHP = mean heights taken from oscilloscope display of bite sounds
= 13.6 – 0.19Wx + 0.03 MP = 6.1 – 0.08F + 0.21 SPL3 = 8.1 – 0.004Wy + 0.003 ILT = 16.5 – 0.06F – 0.11 SPL1 = 9.5 – 0.12F + 0.017 MPL
0.96 0.88 0.89 0.95 0.91
Wx = work done to 1 cm deformation (mJ) MP = mean sound pressure (N/m2) in 2.6–3.3 kHz SPL3 = sound pressure level (dBA) in 1.9–2.6 kHz MPL = acoustic intensity (watts/m2) in 0.5–1.9 kHz PF = maximum force from a force– deformation curve
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
89
Bourne (1976a) studied the acoustical properties of tape-recorded biting sounds of wet and dry crisp foods. They found that crisp foods consist of an uneven and irregular series of noises, and suggested that the repeated breaking or fracturing of food samples during biting and chewing produced these acoustical characteristics. Observing differences in amplitude–time plots between the samples, Vickers and Bourne (1976a) concluded that less crisp samples produced less noise. Christensen and Vickers (1981) evaluated separately the loudness and crispness of 16 different products during chewing and biting. They found high positive correlations between crispness and loudness, indicating that biting and chewing sounds were important for evaluating crispness. Mohamed et al. (1982) studied the sound produced by five varieties of dry crisp foods stored at different relative humidities. The sounds were recorded as the foods were fractured by compressing in a constant loading rate, texture testing instrument. The sound energy correlated significantly with sensory crispness. Edmister and Vickers (1985) investigated the relationships between several instrumental acoustical parameters and sensory crispness. They found that the best acoustical predictor of auditory crispness was the logarithm of the number of sound bursts and the mean amplitude of the bursts. Vickers (1988) noted that an inverse relationship between crispness and the force–deformation variables (a negative sign preceding the force and work term) is more unusual and could mean that sensations of hardness and/or toughness are detracting from the sensation of crispness. Another problem in acoustic analysis relates to the source of the sound generation. Dacremont (1995) asserted that sounds generated from a food fracturing through a mechanical apparatus are different from eating sounds and do not contain the relevant information for texture judgment. Nevertheless, eating sounds still comprise various frequency components which can be either airborne or conducted via the bone. Regarding this matter, previously Lee et al. (1988) investigated acoustic behavior during 10 consecutive chews of potato chips and tortilla chips. They found that as chews increased, sound intensity tended to decrease. Also, the higher frequency of chewing sound which is audible decreased as chews increased. The latter finding was somewhat supportive of the psycho-acoustical theory proposed by Vickers (1979) that crispness should be characterized by high-pitched sound. Therefore, she hypothesized that the assessment of crispness may be more dependent on the information obtained from initial mastication as opposed to later chews. Caution has been raised by Peleg (1997) concerning the measured acoustic variables used in the past. They specifically questioned the use of peak count as it does not account for the peak magnitude and shape. In addition, the count can also be affected by the selected resolution and sampling rate adopted by the researchers. Peleg (1997) recommended using the Fourier transform method to obtain more reliable information for determining crispness (or crunchiness) in foods.
90 Texture in food
The development of acoustic measurement occurred in the late 1990s. Chakra et al. (1996) suggested that structural properties of pasta could be characterized based on the sound emission during its rupture. The mechanical and acoustical parameters changed in the same pattern over the water activity ranges, and good correlation was obtained. This ascertained their proposed assumption that both properties would have an existing link with each other. Nevertheless, characterization appeared to be more complicated since Tesch et al. (1996) found no relationships between mechanical and acoustical parameters. They were concerned that this complication may have been due to the effect of unequal frequency for the mechanical and acoustical measurements or because some parts of the crisp or crunchy information manifested in acoustical properties may not have been fully revealed in the mechanical properties, or vice versa. In response to the work of Chakra et al. (1996), Tesch et al. (1996) commented that changes in mechanical properties need not follow the same trend as those in acoustical properties, particularly if the changes occurred around the glass transition region. At the time of writing, acoustical measurements for crispness are undergoing study and are being used in investigations into the effect of glass transition on the tested materials. Hopefully, some textural changes in that range, particularly with regard to crispness, can be revealed and will elucidate the links between the material itself and the mechanical as well as the acoustical properties. Tahnpoonsuk (1999) conducted sensory and instrumental and acoustic measurements to evaluate crispness in breaded shrimps baked in an oven and held under a heat lamp. The 12 trained panelists rated the intensity of crispness on a 150 mm line scale with anchors at the ends. Crispness was defined as the ease of fracture in the mouth combined with the loudness of the sound produced. Panelists perceived significant differences in crispness among the tested samples. The change in sensory crispness was significantly dependent on holding time under a heat lamp and baking location in the oven. Although the objective analysis was significant, it did not produce satisfactory correlations with sensory crispness. A detailed description of various methods to collect texture-related acoustic properties using both destructive and non-destructive acoustic techniques can be found in Chapter 6. That chapter also provides a brief discussion of the types of most often used equipment for specific applications. In addition to using sound in the hearing range of humans, Povey and Harden (1981) measured crispness of biscuits using the ultrasonic pulse echo technique. They found good correlation between the crispness from sensory measurement and the velocity of longitudinal sound. The ultrasonic velocity correlated with crispness better than either the ultrasonically derived Young’s modulus, or the Instron universal testing machine derived modulus. Povey and Harden concluded that the ultrasonic technique offers promise as a method for the electromechanical measurement of crispness. Antonova et al. (2003) attempted to characterize crispness in breaded chicken nuggets using an ultrasonic technique and found that the ultrasonic
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
91
velocity had a higher correlation with sensory crispness. Higher ultrasonic velocities correlated with higher crispness in the samples suggesting that ultrasound traveled faster in dry and crisp samples compared to moist and soggy samples. They also found very high correlation between moisture content of the samples with sensory crispness and ultrasonic velocity. The details of the study can be found under the case study part of this chapter.
4.3 Methods of data correlation, evaluation and analysis Crispness has been associated with crunchiness, crackling, freshness, brittleness, snapping and sound emission during eating (Szczesniak, 1988). Many investigators have tried to measure crispness in foods, using different instrumental methods. Studies related to crispness in high-moisture products are very limited. Any reliable objective method that can accurately measure and quantify crispness should correlate well to sensory crispness. Such a method will allow control of crispness for process evaluation and the production of foods with desirable attributes. In order to assess the validity of any objective instrumental method, trained sensory panel tests have to be performed. A well trained sensory panel will produce results as valid and reliable as those from an analytical instrument.
4.3.1 Product description Different products should be used to familiarize the panelists with definitions of crispness. Eight samples of low-moisture foods, viz. Granola bar, club cracker, Graham cracker, oat cereal, bran flakes, cheese crackers, corn flakes, and Melba toast, can be used as standard dry crisp samples with different levels of crispness during panel training. The purpose is to increase familiarity with the crispness attribute and practise describing it. In the case of breaded fried foods, four samples, including French fries, onion rings, chicken nuggets and chicken strips, should be used to assist panelists in relating crispness intensity in a product with a dry outer crust layer and a moist core. In addition, panelists could be presented with products stored under different conditions for crispness evaluation. A suitable storage condition to simulate a fast food restaurant setting is to store the samples uncovered under a heat lamp at 60 °C to maintain crispness. Samples should also be held under ambient conditions (45–55% RH) and high humid conditions (75% RH) to accelerate loss in crispness. Samples should be removed at 10-min intervals and tested for sensory crispness in order to validate a trained panel. 4.3.2 Panelist training Eight to twelve panelists can participate in 12 1-h training sessions over a period of six weeks during which training in identifying and rating the intensity
92 Texture in food
of crispness should be completed. Sensory definitions and techniques for different texture attributes, including crispness, hardness, cohesiveness, and fracturability have to be relayed to the panelists during the training period (Table 4.2). In order to become familiar with crispness, the panel can spend three or four sessions evaluating samples of dry crisp foods with different intensities of crispness as reference standards. Standard crispness scale values of dry crisp foods can be used (Table 4.3). During the first session, the researcher should involve the panel in a group discussion of texture characteristics of presented samples, concentrating on crispness. For the following two sessions, panelists should rate crispness of dry crisp products on a nine-point intensity scale (1 = not crisp/soggy, 9 = very crisp) by checking the appropriate space on the scale. Crispness scale values obtained by panelists should then be compared to standard crispness scale values. Having established that the panelists can rate crispness intensity in dry crisp products, the training should then continue with discussion of crispness in breaded fried foods with a moist core. For the following four sessions, panelists should be presented with four samples of breaded fried foods such as onion rings, chicken nuggets, chicken strips, and breaded chicken breasts obtained from local fast food restaurants for crispness evaluation. Panelists will practise describing the texture characteristics of the presented products, focusing on crispness. A nine-point category scale can be used to indicate the intensity of crispness of tested breaded fried foods.
Table 4.2 Sensory definition and technique for crispness. (Source Meilgaard et al., 1999) Term
Definition
Technique
Crispness
The force and noise with which a product breaks or fractures (rather than deforms) when chewed with the molar teeth (first and second chew)
Place sample between molars and bite down evenly until the food breaks, crumbles, cracks or shatters
Hardness
The force to attain a given deformation, such as the force to compress between molars, the force to compress between tongue and palate, and the force to bite through with incisors
Place food between the molars and bite down evenly, evaluating the force required to compress the food
Cohesiveness
The degree to which sample deforms rather than crumbles, cracks, or breaks
Place sample between molars and compress fully (can be done with incisors)
Fracturability
The force with which the sample breaks
Place food between molars and bite down evenly until the food crumbles, cracks, or shatters
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
93
Table 4.3 Standard intensity crispness values (0–9) for low-moisture foods. (Source Meilgaard et al., 1999) Scale value
Product
Brand/type/manufacturer
Sample size
1.0 3.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0
Granola Bar Club Cracker Graham Cracker Oat Cereal Bran Flakes Cheese Crackers Goldfish Corn Flakes Melba Toast
Quaker Low Fat Chewy Chunk Keeblers Partner Club Cracker Honey Maid Cheerios Kellogg’s Bran Flakes Cereal Cheddar Cheese Crackers
1
/3 bar 2 cracker 1 in2 1 oz 1 oz 1 oz
Kellogg’s Corn Flakes Cereal Devonsheer Melba Toast
1
7.0 9.0
1/
1 oz /2 cracker
For the final training sessions, panelists should evaluate samples of commercially available fried products, stored under different conditions, for crispness intensity by using the same nine-point scale. 4.3.3 Evaluation of breaded fried products under experimental conditions For actual experiments, a trained panel should evaluate crispness intensity in breaded fried samples under different processing and storage conditions to get a range of crispness values. Samples could be finish cooked using the following procedures: (1) finish-fried in a deep-fat fryer; (2) baked in a convection oven; (3) heated in a microwave oven. The samples cooked in a microwave oven will have the least crispness, followed by the baked samples and the fried samples will have the highest crispness. The samples can also be placed uncovered under a heat lamp at 60 °C for up to 40 min to maintain crispness. Samples can also be held under ambient conditions (45–55% RH) to accelerate loss of crispness. Panelists can evaluate three samples at a time at 10-min intervals, using a nine-point category scale (1 = not crisp/soggy, 9 = very crisp). In addition to the category scale, panels could also use an unstructured 150 mm scale marked with specific crispness scores developed during training. Evaluations should be completed in individual testing booths with red lighting to mask appearance differences of the samples. 4.3.4 Statistical analysis A generalized randomized complete block design can be used to analyze the data from each training test and to determine if panelists could perceive significant differences in crispness among the products. A randomized block design is effective when the panelists are consistent in rating the samples but
94 Texture in food
might use different parts of the scale to express their perceptions. Data in the form of ratings from a randomized block design can be analyzed by analysis of variance (ANOVA). Tukey’s Test can be used to determine which of the samples differ significantly.
4.4 Case-study: breaded chicken nuggets This study was undertaken with following objectives: to determine ultrasonic parameters and mechanical properties and to investigate the relationships between the instrumental parameters and sensory crispness obtained using a trained panel for chicken nuggets (Antanova et al., 2003). Breaded par-fried chicken nuggets were used in this study. Frozen breaded chicken nuggets were finish cooked using the following procedures: (1) finish-fried in a deep-fat fryer at 375 °F for 4–5 min; (2) baked in a convection oven at 400 °F for 10 min; (3) heated in a microwave oven at full power for 3 min. The finish-frying times were obtained by measuring the temperature in the product and frying the sample until the geometric center of the product reached 70 °C. Samples were then placed uncovered under a heat lamp (model SW-2430, Merco Inc., Lakewood, NJ, USA) at 60 °C for up to 40 min to maintain crispness. Samples also were held under ambient conditions (45–55% RH) to accelerate loss of crispness (by getting soggier). Samples were removed at 10-min intervals and tested for sensory and objective crispness. Five replications were conducted in the study. A sensory panel consisting of eight trained members was used to evaluate sensory crispness in breaded fried chicken nuggets. The panelists had previously participated in 11 1-h training sessions over a period of six weeks during which training in identifying and rating the intensity of crispness was completed. Crispness was defined as the force and noise with which a product breaks or fractures (rather than deforms) when chewed with the molar teeth (first and second chew) (Meilgaard et al., 1999). Panelists were instructed to evaluate each tested sample for crispness by placing it between molar teeth and biting down evenly until the food breaks, crumbles, cracks or shatters and rate the intensity of crispness on a nine-point category scale (1 = not crisp/soggy, 9 = very crisp) by checking the appropriate space on the scale. Panelists evaluated three samples at a time at 10-min intervals. The instructions to panelists were given in the appropriate scorecard. Evaluations were completed in individual testing booths with red lighting to mask appearance differences of the samples. Samples were served in plastic soufflé cups coded with three-digit random numbers. Samples were presented such that each panelist received all samples, three at a time, in a random order.
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
95
4.4.1 Ultrasonic property measurements The ultrasonic non-destructive evaluation system developed at Virginia Tech (Antonova, 2001) was used to conduct ultrasonic measurements. The basic set-up of the ultrasonic non-destructive evaluation system included a highpower burst pulser (Model BP 9400A, Ultran Labs, Boalsburg, PA) a broadband receiver (Model BR 640A, Ultran Labs, Boalsburg, PA), a digital storage oscilloscope (Model 2232, Tektronix, Inc., Beaverton, OR), 250-kHz drycoupling ultrasonic transducers (Ultran Labs, Boalsburg, PA), and a microcomputer system for data acquisition and analysis. The driving voltage from the burst pulser for the transducers was 400 V with nominal output impedance of 4 ohms (Ω). The pulse width and separation time between pulses were adjusted for 250-kHz transducers. The broadband receiver, functioning as a signal amplifier and signal filter, had a maximum gain of 64 dB. The transmitted signal was measured and shown on the oscilloscope screen. A general purpose interface board (GPIB) installed in a microcomputer allowed the transfer of the digital data from the signal from the oscilloscope to the microcomputer for further analysis. The system set-up was in the through-transmission mode because breaded fried chicken nugget is highly attenuative material. Two transducers were placed on the opposite sides of a chicken nugget surface, one acting as a transmitter and the other as a receiver. For ultrasonic transducers at a frequency of 250 kHz, the transmitting transducer was connected directly to the burst pulser. The receiving transducer was wired directly to the receiver. A breaded fried chicken nugget to be tested was placed directly between the two transducers along the center-line of the sample and transducers to ensure the optimal propagation of the sound wave. A transducer holding device was used to apply a uniform pressure and a precise alignment of the transducers during each ultrasonic measurement, permitting the most efficient ultrasonic energy transmission through the sample. The burst pulser sent electrical energy bursts into the transmitting transducer to convert the electrical energy to ultrasonic energy in the form of ultrasonic pulses. The transducer then launched an ultrasonic pulse into the sample material. The ultrasound traveled through the sample material until it reached a boundary or discontinuity in the material. In such a case, some ultrasonic energy will be reflected. The transmitted ultrasound was received and converted to an electrical signal by the receiving transducer, amplified and displayed on the oscilloscope screen as real-time radio-frequency traces, from which the properties of the ultrasonic wave could be determined. The data were then transferred to the microcomputer for further analysis. From the transmitted ultrasonic signal, such ultrasonic properties as ultrasonic velocity (v) and transmission loss (Tloss) were determined in this study. Frequency analysis was performed to obtain the energy content distributed over the frequency bandwidth determined as a power spectrum of the signal. A fast Fourier transformation (FFT) algorithm was used to convert data at the time domain into the frequency domain, using MATLAB®. Peak
96 Texture in food
signal amplitudes and corresponding frequency ranges were identified and analyzed. Ultrasonic velocity Ultrasonic velocity represents the average speed of ultrasound through the sample from one side to the other. The time-of-flight (TOF), known as the traveling time of the ultrasonic pulse from one side of the sample to the other, was derived from the plot of the time domain waveform. The predetermined sample thickness and the determined time-of-flight through the sample and time-of-flight of the transducer were used to calculate the propagation velocity of the ultrasonic wave through the sample. The ultrasonic velocity for each breaded fried chicken nugget was determined according to the following equation: vsample =
l TOF – TOF0
[4.1]
where vsample = l= TOF = TOF0 =
ultrasonic velocity for breaded fried chicken nugget (m/sec) path length of transmission (mm) time-of-flight with the sample (ms) calibrated time-of-flight without the sample (ms)
4.4.2 Mechanical property measurements An Instron universal testing machine (Model 1011, Instron Inc., Canton, MA) interfaced with a microcomputer for data acquisition was used for mechanical property measurements. The test sample was placed in the Kramer shear-compression cell and the crosshead speed was set at 100 mm/min. The mass and thickness of the samples were measured before analysis as described before. The maximum peak force and total energy were obtained from the measurements using the software program (Instron Inc., Canton, MA).
4.4.3 Sensory crispness evaluation of breaded fried chicken nuggets The cooking method of breaded chicken nuggets, storage conditions under either a heat lamp or ambient conditions, and holding time had a significant effect on sensory crispness. Breaded chicken nuggets fried in a deep-fat fryer were crispier (6–8) than nuggets baked in an oven (3–5) and nuggets cooked in a microwave oven (1–2). The panelists found that cooked samples held under a heat lamp were significantly crispier than samples stored under ambient conditions. Changes in crispness with holding time, under either a heat lamp or ambient conditions, were perceived by judges. The panel determined the increasing intensity of crispness among samples kept under a heat lamp. The effect of holding time under a heat lamp and under ambient
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
97
conditions on the crispness intensity ratings of breaded fried chicken nuggets for each cooking method is shown in Fig. 4.1. The panel indicated the decreasing intensity of crispness with holding time under ambient conditions. Figure 4.2 shows the normalized sensory scores (each score divided by the mean score for a particular cooking method) against crust moisture content to see the effect of crust moisture content on sensory crispness. Sensory crispness was inversely related to moisture content, indicating that crispness intensity was increasing, while moisture content was decreasing when the samples were held under a heat lamp (Fig. 4.2). 10 9
Sensory crispness
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0
5
10
15 Fryer
20
25
30
Microwave
35
40
45
35
40
45
Oven
Holding time (min) (a)
9 8
Sensory crispness
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0
5
10
15 Fryer
20
25
Microwave
30 Oven
Holding time (min) (b)
Fig. 4.1 Effect of holding time on the mean sensory crispness intensity ratings of breaded fried chicken nuggets for each cooking method: (a) under a heat lamp and (b) under ambient conditions (Adopted from Antonova et al., 2003).
98 Texture in food 1.3
Normalized sensory scores
1.2
1.1
1
0.9
0.8 15
20
25
30 Fryer
35
40
Microwave
45
50
55
Oven
Moisture content, % w.b.
Fig. 4.2
Effect of moisture content on sensory crispness (Adopted from Antonova et al., 2003).
4.4.4 Ultrasonic velocity The significant differences in the ultrasonic velocity for the breaded chicken nuggets cooked by three different methods and stored under either a heat lamp or ambient conditions were observed. The samples cooked in a deepfat fryer had higher ultrasonic velocities (431.56–715.38 m/sec) than the samples cooked in an oven (221.41–533.83 m/sec), while the samples cooked in a microwave oven had much lower velocities (90.22–306.92 m/sec). This can be attributed to the changes in crust moisture content among the samples. The samples cooked in a deep-fat fryer had the lowest crust moisture content, while the samples cooked in a microwave oven had the highest. The ultrasonic velocity increased with increasing holding time under a heat lamp as the moisture content decreased. This implied that samples became crispier during holding under a heat lamp. On the other hand, ultrasonic velocity decreased with holding samples under ambient conditions as samples became soggier and softer. The changes in the mean ultrasonic velocities of the breaded fried chicken nuggets are plotted in Fig. 4.3. The relationships between ultrasonic velocity and moisture content are shown in Fig. 4.4. The decrease in the velocity with respect to an increase in moisture content can be attributed to the transmission loss in liquid rather than the transmission loss in a solid. Ultrasound can propagate better in solids than liquids.
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness
99
800 700
Velocity (m/sec)
600 500 400 300 200 100 0 0
10
20 Fryer
30
40
Microwave
50
Oven
Holding time (min) (a) 800 700
Velocity (m/sec)
600 500 400 300 200 100 0 0
5
10
15 Fryer
20
25 Microwave
30
35
40
45
Oven
Holding time (min) (b)
Fig. 4.3 Effect of holding time on ultrasonic velocity for each cooking method: (a) under a heat lamp and (b) under ambient conditions (Adopted from Antonova et al., 2003).
4.4.5 Mechanical property measurements Normalization of the peak force and total energy was done by dividing the values by the mass of the sample. The normalized peak force and normalized total energy significantly varied among the samples cooked by different
100
Texture in food 800
Ultrasonic velocity (m/sec)
700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 0
20
25
30 Fryer
35
40
Microwave
45
50
55
Oven
Moisture content (%) (a)
Fig. 4.4 Effect of moisture content on ultrasonic velocity (Adopted from Antonova et al., 2003).
methods and stored under different conditions. Samples cooked in a deep-fat fryer had higher values for the peak force and total energy than samples cooked in an oven and microwave oven. However, holding time under either a heat lamp or ambient conditions did not have a significant effect on either peak force or total energy. The effect of holding time under a heat lamp and under ambient conditions for each cooking method on the peak force is shown in Fig. 4.5. The peak force slightly increased with holding time under either a heat lamp or ambient conditions.
4.4.6 Relating instrumental parameters to sensory crispness To investigate the relationship between sensory crispness and objective quality parameters, the linear regression procedure was performed. Except for the relationship between ultrasonic velocity and sensory crispness, none of the objective parameters had an improvement in the correlation coefficient when analyzed separately against each cooking method. The relationship between sensory crispness and peak force is shown in Fig. 4.6 and described by Eq. [4.2]. The positive sign preceding the slope implied that sensory crispness increased when a high peak force was required. Sensory Crispness = 3.35 (Peak Force) – 5.20
(R2 = 0.64) [4.2]
The positive relationship between sensory crispness and ultrasonic velocity is described by Eq. [4.3], showing that sensory crispness and ultrasonic
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness 101 50 45
Peak force (N/g)
40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
5
10
15 Fryer
20
25
30
Microwave
35
40
45
Oven
Holding time (min) (a) 40 35
Peak force (N/g)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
5
10
15 Fryer
20
25
Microwave
30
35
40
45
Oven
Holding time (min) (b)
Fig. 4.5 Effect of holding time on peak force for each cooking method: (a) under a heat lamp, and (b) under ambient conditions (Adopted from Antonova et al., 2003).
velocity are closely related. Increasing sensory crispness of the breaded fried chicken nuggets is illustrated by increasing mean ultrasonic velocities, as presented in Fig. 4.7. When analyzed separately for each cooking method the R2 values for the predictive model were 0.87, 0.94 and 0.85 for fryer, oven and microwave oven, respectively. Sensory Crispness = 0.013 (Velocity) – 0.67
(R2 = 0.83)
[4.3]
The models were significant at the 0.05 confidence level. This indicates that
102
Texture in food 9 8
Sensory crispness
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 15
20
25 Fryer
30 Microwave
35 Oven
40
45
Peak force (N/g)
Fig. 4.6 Correlation between peak force and sensory crispness (Adopted from Antonova et al., 2003). 9 8
Sensory crispness
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0
100
200
300 Fryer
400
500
Microwave
600
700
800
Oven
Ultrasonic velocity (m/sec)
Fig. 4.7 Correlation between ultrasonic velocity and sensory crispness (Adopted from Antonova et al., 2003).
sensory crispness could be explained based on the ultrasonic and mechanical parameters. The ultrasonic velocity had high correlation to the sensory crispness (R2 = 0.83). This implies that sensory crispness could be reasonably well predicted by the ultrasonic velocity.
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness 103
4.5 Future trends As with any development of methods to characterize a complex textural attribute, like crispness, further research work is needed to validate these methods by collaborative research on various types of instruments and products. Many researchers are working on describing crispness in relation to other measurable attributes like moisture content and mechanical and acoustic properties. Further work is underway in relating various texture-attributes to glass transition temperature. Novel numerical methods, such as fractal analysis and Fourier transformation, have been employed to describe the objective measurements, especially for acoustic properties. Research related to using ultrasonic techniques with air-coupled transducers will lead to a true nondestructive, non-contact rapid crispness evaluation method. However, use of air-coupled transducers has been very much limited to low-power diagnostic measurement methods while crispness measurement requires a high-power diagnostic system and this might result in the use of the through-transmission system described in the case study of this chapter. Future research could also focus on the use of artificial neural network (ANN) techniques to process multiple attributes (such as moisture content, ultrasonic velocity, color, mechanical properties, and acoustic properties) from the sample to arrive at a comprehensive crispness evaluation that is well correlated with the sensory crispness.
4.6 References AMERINE M A, PANGBORN R M
and ROESSLER E B (1965) Principles of Sensory Evaluation. New York, Academic Press. ANON (1998) Frozen in food service (http://www.affi.com/facts/foodserv.htm). Amercican Frozen Food Institute. ANTONOVA I (2001) Determination of crispness in breaded fried chicken nuggets using ultrasonic technique (MS Thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University). ANTONOVA I, MALLIKARJUNAN P and DUNCAN S E (2003) Correlating objective measurements of crispness in breaded fried chicken nuggets with sensory crispness, J Food Sci, 68(4), 1308–15. ATTENBURROW G E, DAVIES A P, GOODBAND R M and INGMAN S J (1992) The fracture behaviour of starch and gluten in the glassy state, J Cereal Sci, 16(1), 1–12. BARRETT A H, and PELEG M (1992) Extrudate cell structure-texture relationships, J Food Sci, 57(5), 1253–7. BARRETT A H, CARDELLO A V, LESHER L L, and TAUB I A (1994) Cellularity, mechanical failure, and textural perception of corn meal extrudates, J Texture Stud, 25, 77–95. BOURNE, M C (1975) Texture properties and evaluations of fabricated foods. In Fabricated Foods. Ed. G E Inglett, Westport, C T, AVI Publishing Co. BOURNE M C and COMSTOCK S H (1981) Effects of compression on texture profile parameters, J Texture Stud 12(2), 201–16. BOUVIER J M (1996) Engineering analysis of preconditioning in the extrusion-cooking process, Cereal Foods World, 41(9), 737–40. BOUVIER J M, BONNEVILLE R and GOULLIEUX A (1997) Instrumental methods for the measurement of extrudate crispness, Agro-Food-Industry Hi-Tech, 8(1), 16–19.
104
Texture in food
CHAKRA W A, ALLAF K
and JEMAI A B (1996) Characterization of brittle food products: application of the acoustical emission method, J Texture Stud, 27(3), 327–48. CHRISTENSEN C M and VICKERS Z M (1981) Relationships of chewing sounds to judgments of food crispness, J Food Sci, 45, 574–8. COPPOCK J B M and CARNFORD S J (1960) Texture in Foods, SCI Monograph, No. 7, p. 64. DACREMONT C (1995) Spectral composition of eating sounds generated by crispy, crunchy and crackly foods, J Texture Stud, 26(1), 27–43. DONAHOO P (1970) The evolution in ingredients. Canner-Packer, May, 139(5): 20–22. DRAKE B K (1963) Food crushing sounds – an introductory study, J Food Sci, 28, 233–41. DRAKE B K (1965) Food crushing sounds: comparisons of objective and subjective data, J Food Sci, 30, 556–9. EDMISTER J A and VICKERS Z M (1985) Instrumental acoustical measures of crispness in foods, J Texture Stud, 16, 153–67. ELSTON E (1975) Why fish fingers top the market, Fishing News International, 14, 30. GAINES C S, KASSUBA A, FINNEY P L and DONELSON J R (1992) Instrumental measurement of cookie hardness. II. Application to product quality variables, Cereal Chem, 69(2),120– 25. GAO X and TAN J (1996a) Analysis of expanded-food texture by image processing. Part I: geometrical properties, J, Food Process Eng, 19, 425–44. GAO X and TAN J (1996b) Analysis of expanded-food texture by image processing. Part II: mechanical properties, J Food Process Eng, 19, 445–56. HANSON H L and FLETCHER L R (1963) Adhesion of coatings on frozen fried chicken, Food Technol, 17, 793. HUNG Y-C and CHINNAN M S (1989) Mechanical texture measurement of whole and chopped peanuts, Peanut Sci, 16, 32–7. KATZ E E and LABUZA T P (1981) Effect of water activity on the sensory crispness and mechanical deformation of snack food products, J Food Sci, 46, 403–9. KULP K and LOEWE R (1992) Batters and Breadings in Food Processing. St Paul, MN American Association of Cereal Chemists. LABELL F (1994) Coating systems for shrimp, Prepared Foods, 163(2), 79–80. LEE III W E, DEIBEL A E, GLEMBIN C T and MUNDAY E G (1988) Analysis of food crushing sounds during mastication frequency – time studies, J Texture Stud, 19, 27–38. LOEWE R (1993) Role of ingredients in batter systems, Cereal Food World, 38(9), 673–7. MATZ S A (1962) Food Texture. Westport, CT, AVI Publishing Co. Inc. MEILGAARD M, CIVILLE G V and CARR B T (1999) Sensory Evaluation Techniques. Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press LLC. MOHAMED A A A, JOWITT R and BRENNAN J G (1982) Instrumental and sensory evaluations of crispness: 1 – in friable foods, J Food Eng, 1, 55–75. PELEG M (1978) Some mathematical aspects of mastication and its simulation by machines, J Food Sci, 43, 1093–5. PELEG M (1997) Effect of absorbed moisture on the mechanical properties of cereal foods, instant coffee, legumes and nuts. Fifth Confererence of Food Engineering (1997) Annual Meeting of the American Institute of Chemical Engineers (AIChE). Paper no. 68d. POVEY M J W and HARDEN C A (1981) An application of the ultrasonic pulse echo technique to the measurement of crispness of biscuits, J Food Technol, 16, 167–75. SAUVAGEOT F and BLOND G (1991) Effect of water activity on crispness of breakfast cereals, J Texture Stud, 22(4), 423–42. SEYMOUR S K (1985) Studies on the relationships between the mechanical, acoustical and sensory properties in low moisture food products (Ph. D. Thesis, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC). SEYMOUR S K and HAMANN D D (1988) Crispness and crunchiness of selected low moisture foods, J Texture Stud, 19, 79–95.
Understanding and measuring consumer perceptions of crispness 105 and TUNG M A (1976) Microstructure of food and its relationship to texture. In Rheology and Texture in Food Quality. Eds J M de Man, P W Voisey, V F Rasper and D W Stanley, Westport, CT, AVI Publishing Co., Inc. SUDERMAN D R (1983) Use of batters and breadings on food products : a review. In Batter and Breading. Eds D R Suderman and F E Cunningham, Westport, CT, AVI Publishing Co. Inc. SZCZESNIAK A S (1963) Classification of textural characteristics. J Food Sci, 38, 385–9. SZCZESNIAK A S (1988) The meaning of textural characteristics – crispness, J Texture Stud, 19, 51–9. SZCZESNIAK A S and KAHN E L (1971) Consumer awareness and attitudes to food texture, J Texture Stud, 1, 280–95. TAHNPOONSUK P (1999) Determination of crispness in breaded shrimp (M. S. Thesis, The University of Georgia, Athens, GA). TESCH R, NORMAND M D and PELEG M (1996) Comparison of the acoustic and mechanical signatures of two cellular crunchy cereal foods at various water activity levels, J Sci Food Agric, 67, 453–9. The American Heritage College Dictionary (Third Edition) (1997) Boston, New York, Houghton Mifflin Co. VICKERS Z M (1979) Crispness and crunchiness of foods. In Food Texture and Rheology. Ed. P Sherman, London, Academic Press. VICKERS Z M (1984) Crispness and crunchiness – a difference in pitch? J Texture Stud, 15, 157–63. VICKERS Z M (1987) Crispness and crunchiness. In Food Texture: Instrumental and Sensory Measurement. Ed. H R Moskowitz, New York, Marcel Dekker, Inc. VICKERS Z M (1988) Instrumental measures of crispness and their correlation with sensory assessment, J Texture Stud, 19, 1–14. VICKERS Z M and BOURNE M C (1976a) A psychoacoustical theory of crispness, J Food Sci, 41, 1158–64. VICKERS Z M and BOURNE M C (1976b) Crispness in foods – a review, J Food Sci, 41, 1153– 7. VOISEY P W (1976) Engineering assessment and critique of instruments used for meat tenderness evaluation, J Texture Stud, 7, 11–48. VOISEY P W and STANLEY D W (1979) Interpretation of instrumental results in measuring bacon crispness and brittleness, J Can Inst Food Sci Technol, 12(1), 7–15. WARD C D W, RESURRECCION A V A and MCWATTERS K H (1998) Comparison of acceptance of snack chips containing cornmeal, wheat flour and cowpea meal by US and West African consumers, Food Qual Prefer, 9(5), 327–32. WELLER P (1997) Cargill foods introduces breaded beef steak (http://www.cargill .com/ today/pressrel/0517c97.htm). ZWIERCAN G A (1974) Case of the weeping pies (and others), Food Eng, 46, 79, 81. STANLEY D W
This page intentionally left blank
Part II Instrumental techniques for analysing texture
This page intentionally left blank
5 Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture Renfu Lu and Judith A. Abbott1, USDA Agricultural Research Service, USA
5.1 Introduction Force/deformation methods are widely used for objective measurement of the textural properties of solid foods. They directly measure either single or multiple (composite) mechanical properties of food that are important to the sensory perception of texture by humans in the hand or mouth and to the resistance to mechanical damage during handling. Compared to indirect methods such as optical and electrical, force/deformation methods offer the advantages of lower costs in instrumentation, ease of carrying out experiments, and simpler interpretation of measurement results. Since there is a vast range of foods with vastly different textural and mechanical properties, it is not surprising that a large variety of force/deformation methods and techniques are available for different types of foods. These force/deformation methods, based on their measurement principles, may be classified into fundamental, empirical, and/or imitative. Fundamental force/deformation methods are developed based on the engineering theory of materials and measure welldefined mechanical properties of food. On the other hand, empirical methods measure those mechanical properties that are not well defined and/or are poorly understood, but have been found to correlate with the sensory evaluation of the food. There are two approaches to force/deformation measurement of food texture: destructive versus non-destructive. Destructive force/deformation methods 1 Mention of the names of commercial products is solely for providing factual information for the reader and does not imply the endorsement of the United States Department of Agriculture.
110
Texture in food
are considered by many to be a preferred means of measuring the texture of food because they are usually better related to the sensory evaluation than are non-destructive methods (Bourne, 2002). Destructive measurements are often used as the standard against which a new non-destructive technique is compared. Destructive techniques are useful for providing information about the average quality for a batch of food items. However, they suffer a major shortcoming in that the food samples are destroyed in the process of measurement. Many foods, particularly fresh, raw or unprocessed food products, are inherently variable in texture among individual items. Measurements of ‘average’ texture are not sufficient to guarantee the quality and consistency of individual items of the food. Non-destructive sensing would provide us with a means to better manage the harvest time for optimal food quality and to monitor, grade, and sort food products to ensure their consistency and superior quality. Consequently, considerable recent research activity has been focused on non-destructive techniques for quality evaluation of fresh, raw food products.
5.2
Mechanical characterization of solid foods
5.2.1 Basic concepts Texture is a quality attribute that is closely related to the structural and mechanical properties of a food. It is, therefore, essential to understand the mechanical properties of foods, in studying their textural properties and measurement techniques. The study of mechanical behavior, i.e. deformation and flow, of foods under applied forces falls within the scope of food rheology, which is a broad, currently active research area covering both solid and liquid foods. A number of textbooks and monographs have been written about the rheology of agricultural and food products and engineering materials with various degrees of mathematical requirements (Ferry, 1980; Mohsenin, 1989; Rao and Steffe, 1992; Sherman, 1970). Those who are interested in the topic are recommended to read one or more of these textbooks to gain a better, more comprehensive understanding of this important subject area. The force/deformation relationship for most food materials is dependent on time or loading rate. Force (F ), deformation (D), and time (t) are three basic variables used in studying the mechanical properties of foods. Force, often expressed in N (newton), is considered an external variable because it is acting and/or measured at the surface (or at the surface point) of an object. (Gravitational and magnetic or electric forces are exceptions, which act on the entire body of the object.) In engineering applications, the force and deformation on a plane in the interior of an object are of considerable interest in quantifying the mechanical response of the object subjected to external loading. Corresponding to the force is stress, expressed in force per unit of area (N/m2 or Pa (pascal)), which has the same unit as pressure. Stress is
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
111
caused by, and accompanied by, external forces and/or other factors such as temperature (thermal stress) and humidity (hygroscopic stress). Strain is the measure of deformation at a point on a plane in an object; it measures the unit change, due to force, in the size or shape of an object with respect to its original size or shape and is a dimensionless quantity. There are two basic types of stresses; one is the normal stress, designated as σ, that acts in a direction normal (perpendicular) to the plane of an object and the other is the shear stress, τ, tangential to the plane on which the forces act (Fig. 5.1). For example, twisting of a rod by applying torsional force at the two opposite ends induces pure shear stresses on the transverse crosssection of the rod, whereas uniaxial compression or tension causes the normal stress either toward or away from the plane perpendicular to the direction of the applied force. As a sharp knife cuts through a food sample, shear stress is created along the two shearing surfaces of the food sample, whereas forces used to bend a beam create both normal compressive and tensile stresses as well as shear stress on the cross-section of the beam. Most destructive force/ deformation measurements involve a complex form of loads, which often induce both normal and shear stresses in a food sample. Corresponding to the two types of stresses are normal strain (ε) and shear strain (γ). Normal stresses are primarily responsible for the expansion or contraction, i.e. the size change, of an object (Fig. 5.1a) and shear stresses cause distortions or the angle change between two planes in the object (Fig. 5.1b). Foods come from biological origins, and they, whether raw or processed, constantly change with time due to chemical reactions (such as oxidation), microbial actions, and physical interactions with the environment (such as heat and moisture). Consequently, the mechanical properties of foods also change with time and are influenced by external or ambient conditions such
F (or σ) D
A0
L0
L
L0
F (or τ)
A0
θ
F (or τ) F (or σ) (L 0 – L ) F (a) σ = A = E ε = E L0 0
F D (b) τ = A = G γ = G tan θ = G L 0 0
Fig. 5.1 Uniaxial compression of a specimen with an original length L0 and area A0 and the Young’s modulus E (a) and shear stress τ acting on opposite planes causing the distortion of the specimen with shear modulus G and area A0 (b)
112
Texture in food
as temperature, humidity, air composition and pressure, and the supply and consumption of energy. Accurate and complete description of the mechanical behavior of agricultural and food materials is an extremely difficult task and fortunately, for many applications, it is not required. The engineering characterization of solid materials is based on some basic assumptions and simplifications – such as linearity in the stress/strain relationship, and homogeneity and/or isotropy in the material properties – which may or may not be valid for biological materials and food products. The theory of rheology describes the basic mechanical behavior of many food products with reasonable accuracy, especially when deformation is small. For many engineering materials, small deformation would mean having the strain level less than 0.2%. For solid foods, deformation as high as 5% may still be considered to be small. During the masticating process (chewing), food items undergo extremely large deformation, well beyond the limit of elasticity or the normal ‘small deformation’ level. No adequate theory is currently available for describing the mechanical response of food under large deformation that takes place during mastication. Despite this, the theory of rheology can help us better understand the underlying principles and processes of measuring the textural properties of food. And it offers a useful guide for designing a better and more efficient texture measurement method or system, which is especially true for non-destructive sensing of food texture. Solid foods, depending on their mechanical responses, may be classified into time-independent elastic materials and time-dependent inelastic materials (Fig. 5.2). For time-independent elastic materials, their mechanical response is independent of time or the rate of loading. Upon removal of applied loads (that did not exceed the elastic limit), the deformed body will recover to its original size and shape. Time-independent elastic materials may be further divided into linear elastic materials whose stress/strain relationship is linear Solid foods
Time-independent elastic foods
σ
ε
σ ε
Linear elastic
Fig. 5.2
Time-dependent inelastic foods
ε Non-linear elastic
ε
t
t
Viscoelastic
Viscoplastic
Classification of solid foods based on their mechanical properties.
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
113
and the non-linear elastic with the non-linear stress/strain relationship. Timedependent materials can be classified into viscoelastic and viscoplastic. Viscoelastic materials exhibit both solid-like (elastic) and liquid-like (viscous) behavior in which the stress/strain relationship is time-dependent. Upon removal of the applied loads, the deformed body of a viscoelastic material will recover partially, whereas a viscoplastic material retains its deformation without recovery. Most biological and food materials behave viscoelastically at small and/or intermediate levels of deformation. The viscoplastic theory may be needed for describing the mechanical behavior of food at large deformation. When the time-dependent response is not critical and can be ignored, the elastic theory offers considerable simplification in analyzing the mechanical responses of food when they are subjected to different forms of loading.
5.2.2 Elastic materials Different foods can exhibit very different mechanical behaviors under uniaxial compressive or tensile loading (Fig. 5.3). The force/deformation response for a cylindrical apple tissue specimen under compressive loading (Fig. 5.3a) may be divided into three phases. During the first phase of deformation, the relationship between force (or stress) and deformation (or strain) is linear and elastic. (Non-linearity at the beginning of the force/deformation curve is mainly caused by the imperfect contact between the loading device and the specimen and, therefore, is ignored in the discussion.) Since most food materials are not truly elastic, they often cannot recover completely to their original size and shape upon removal of the load even under small deformation. Despite this, the theory of linear elasticity applies to this phase of deformation. There are three material constants or parameters for characterizing a linear elastic material: the modulus of elasticity (also called Young’s modulus), designated as E; the shear modulus, G; and the Poisson’s ratio, µ. Since the three parameters are interrelated, once any two of the three parameters are determined, the third one can be calculated using an appropriate equation. The elastic modulus is the ratio of the normal stress to normal strain, which can be determined from the slope of the linear portion of the force/deformation curve in Fig. 5.3a using the following equation:
F / A0 E= σ = ∆ L/ L ε
[5.1]
where E has the unit of N/m2 or Pa; F is the applied force in N; A0 is the original, undeformed cross-sectional area of the specimen in m2; ∆L is the net deformation of the specimen in m; and L is the original length in m. The Poisson’s ratio is the absolute value of the ratio of transverse strain to the corresponding axial strain under uniaxial loading. It ranges from 0.0 for completely compressible materials (i.e. no lateral expansion under uniaxial compression of a constant cross-sectional specimen) to 0.5 for completely
114
Texture in food 750
600 II
Stress (kPa)
I
III
450
300
150
0 0
20 (a)
40 Strain (%)
60
80
250
Stress (kPa)
200
150 III
100 II
I 50
0 0
30 (b)
60 90 Strain (%)
120
150
Fig. 5.3 Stress–strain (or F/D) curves of a cylindrical apple tissue specimen under uniaxial compression (a) and a raw beef specimen of rectangular cross-section under uniaxial tensile loading (b) (Lu et al., 1998). The stress–strain curves may be approximately divided into three phases of deformation: elastic I, yielding II, and post-yielding (or stiffening for beef III).
incompressible materials. The Poisson’s ratio for most food materials is between 0.2 and 0.5 (Mohsenin, 1989). For example, apple flesh has a Poisson’s ratio of 0.25–0.35 whereas the Poisson’s ratio of potato tissue is as high as 0.49, close to that for incompressible materials. The Poisson’s ratio can be directly determined by simultaneously measuring both axial and lateral deformations from a constant cross-sectional specimen under uniaxial loading. The measurement error associated with this method can be great, due to the difficulty in accurate measurement of the small lateral deformation during uniaxial compression. A better approach is to prepare two same-size specimens; one is used for uniaxial loading with no lateral constraints and the other
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
115
measured under uniaxial loading with lateral constraints (i.e. no lateral deformation). From the force/deformation responses of the two specimens, the Poisson’s ratio can be determined using the following equation (Gyasi et al., 1981; Hughes and Segerlind, 1972): µ = 1 (R + 4
R 2 – 8R )
[5.2]
in which R=
Eu –1 Ec
[5.3]
where Eu and Ec are the Young’s moduli determined using Eq. [5.1] from the unconstrained and constrained uniaxial loading test, respectively. Beyond the first phase of deformation, the theory of elasticity is no longer valid. During the second phase of deformation, the force/deformation relationship starts to deviate from linearity and becomes increasingly nonlinear as the load increases. When the load is removed during this phase of loading, the specimen will recover only partially. As deformation continues to increase, a noticeable drop or sometimes no increase in the force occurs to many biological and/or food materials. The point at the force/deformation curve where a drop or no increase in force takes place with an increase in deformation is called the bioyield point. The bioyield point indicates the initial cell rupture in the cellular structure of the specimen. For some food materials, the bioyield point does not show clearly on the force/deformation curve. For example, the bioyield point may appear merely as a change in slope. Beyond the bioyield point, the third phase of deformation starts; the force/deformation relationship becomes irregular and jagged, with numerous peaks and valleys until complete breakdown of the specimen. Fresh fruits and vegetables often undergo all three phases of deformation under compressive loading. Other food products such as grains at the normal storage moisture content or even lower often only go through the first and second phase of deformation, followed by a sudden, complete failure of the specimen during the second phase of deformation (Wouters and de Baerdemaeker, 1988). Many muscle foods, when subjected to tensile loads, exhibit a mechanical behavior (Fig. 5.3b) that is significantly different from the one shown in Fig. 5.3a. Muscle foods can withstand large deformation and exhibit a prominent non-linear behavior under uniaxial tensile loading. The force/deformation behavior of raw beef under tensile loads may also be divided into three phases of deformation: linear elastic at small deformation, stress yielding at intermediate deformation, and work hardening (or stiffening) at large deformation (Lu et al., 1998). Depending upon muscle type and post-rigor treatment, raw muscle meats may exhibit all or some of the three phases of deformation.
116
Texture in food
5.2.3 Viscoelastic materials Although many foods can be approximated as elastic materials, most are in fact viscoelastic. The mechanical response of viscoelastic materials is timedependent; it depends not only on the current loading level but also on the rate and/or history of loading. Two types of tests are often used to characterize the viscoelastic properties of food materials (Fig. 5.4). One is the creep test, which measures the deformation of a specimen with time when a constant load is instantaneously applied to the specimen (Fig. 5.4a). The second type of test is the stress relaxation, which measures the change in stress over time when the specimen is subjected to a constant deformation (Fig. 5.4b). Mechanical models are often used to help us understand or visualize the mechanical behavior of linear viscoelastic materials. A large number of mechanical models can be constructed to describe the viscoelastic material; a vast majority of them consist of two basic elements: the spring (E) representing the elastic component of the material and the dashpot (η) for the viscous component to account for the time effect in the material. The viscosity η is related to the shear stress τ and shear strain rate γ˙ for the Newtonian liquid by the following equation: η= τ γ˙
[5.4]
E0 η
E1
Stress, σ
Strain, ε
Figure 5.4 shows two simple mechanical models that may be used to describe the creep and stress relaxation behavior of food materials. To better describe a viscoelastic material, a more complex model with additional spring and dashpot elements is often required. As more mechanical elements are added to the model, the mathematical equation becomes increasingly complicated. For more detailed discussion about characterizing the viscoelastic properties of foods and other solid materials, readers are recommended to consult the textbooks of Mohsenin (1989) and Ferry (1980).
E1
E0
η Time (a) Creep under constant load
Time (b) Stress relaxation under constant deformation
Fig. 5.4 Creep (a) and stress relaxation (b) response curves and two simple mechanical models for describing the viscoelastic behavior of solid foods.
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
117
5.2.4 Quasi-static versus dynamic measurement Since viscoelastic material is time or loading-rate dependent, its mechanical behavior will be different for different loading rates. For example, the elastic modulus of apple tissue generally increases with loading rate (Petrell et al., 1980). To completely describe this rate-dependent behavior, the test specimen may have to undergo an extended time period (e.g. from many minutes to days) under the creep and/or stress relaxation tests. This is not only timeconsuming but also impractical, as food specimens can experience a significant change in their mechanical properties over time due to chemical and/or physiological activities, and loss or gain of moisture. In addition, it is often difficult to apply a truly instantaneous load or deformation to the specimen. Dynamic tests allow the elastic modulus (to be exact, the complex modulus consisting of the storage modulus and loss modulus) to be determined for a range of frequencies over a short time period. With the commonly used dynamic test, a food specimen is subjected to a sinusoidal varying stress (or force) given by the following equation: σ = σ0 sin(ω t)
[5.5]
The resulting strain will be a sinusoidal response of the same frequency as the stress, but out of phase by a lag phase ϕ: ε = ε0 sin(ωt + ϕ)
[5.6]
The complex modulus E*(iω), also called dynamic modulus, is determined from the following equation: E *(iω ) =
σ0 (cos ϕ + i sin ϕ ) = E ′( ω ) + i E ′′( ω ) ε0
[5.7]
where E′ is called the storage modulus representing the elastic component of the material, E′′ is the loss or imaginary modulus representing the viscous component or loss of mechanical energy as in a dashpot, and i is the imaginary unit equal to – 1. In dynamic tests, the applied loads or deformations are generally very small and confined to the elastic limit. The loading rate can vary greatly over several scales of magnitude, depending on the vibration amplitude and frequency used. The test often requires a number of specimens to cover a desired range of frequencies, which is prone to experimental errors due to the variability among the test specimens. Lu and Abbott (1995) proposed a new method for fast measurement of the dynamic properties of solid foods. They showed that under certain constraints (i.e. specimen size and frequency range), the dynamic viscoelastic properties of solid foods can be measured over a range of frequencies from one single specimen using an impulse load (or transient load). This transient test makes it faster and easier to obtain the dynamic properties of solid foods.
118
Texture in food
In measuring basic mechanical properties of solid foods, several important issues need to be considered. First, many food products exhibit significantly different force/deformation behaviors under compressive and tensile loads. For example, apple flesh exhibits the force/deformation relationship shown in Fig. 5.3a under compressive loading. When subjected to tensile or bending loads, the apple flesh behaves more like a brittle material (Vincent et al., 1991). Secondly, many foods exhibit different mechanical properties when measured in different directions. Abbott and Lu (1996) studied the anisotropic property of apple fruit and found that the mechanical properties of apple tissues, as measured by the elastic modulus and failure strength, are significantly different in three perpendicular directions. Third, the mechanical properties of raw food products such as fresh fruits and vegetables and muscle meats are variable from location to location on the same food sample. Care must be taken in experimental design and reporting results to clearly indicate the location and direction from which specimens are taken.
5.3 Destructive measurements There are a wide variety of methods and/or techniques for destructive measurements of solid foods. Destructive methods can be empirical or fundamental. Empirical destructive methods are often somewhat imitative of methods used in sensory analyses or in the preparation of the food, such as spreading butter on bread, slicing meat, or cutting asparagus. They involve a complex form of loading with the stress and strain levels well beyond the initial failure, and the quantity measured often cannot be adequately interpreted in terms of basic engineering parameters or properties. Fundamental destructive methods, on the other hand, measure basic mechanical properties including the Young’s modulus, Poisson’s ratio, and shear modulus as well as yield strength, failure strength and others; but these often cannot be adequately interpreted in terms of human perception of ‘texture’. When the time- and/ or loading rate-dependent effect is important, the creep test, the relaxation test, and/or the dynamic test is required to measure the viscoelastic properties. Fundamental tests may be performed directly on original food samples that have well-defined dimensions but often require using specimens of specific dimensions excised from food samples. Therefore, the tests are more timeconsuming compared to many empirical tests. In addition it can sometimes be difficult to prepare specimens and mount them onto the testing device in such tests as tension and torsion. Fundamental tests are usually conducted using a universal testing machine. Overall, empirical methods tend to correlate better with sensory textural properties of foods and fundamental methods can help us better understand the mechanical behavior of a food, its structural features, and their changes. Based on the pattern of loading, destructive methods may include puncture, compression, shear, twisting/torsion, tension, bending, and so on.
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
119
5.3.1 Puncture The puncture test measures the force required for a probe to penetrate into a food sample for a pre-specified depth. The test involves both compression and shearing of a food sample; it is an empirical technique that is somewhat imitative of the biting of a food item in the mouth. Puncture measurements depend on a number of factors such as probe size and shape, type of food, speed of loading, and number of probes on the tester. Bourne (1966) proposed the following empirical equation relating the puncture yield force to the area and perimeter of the probe: Fs = KcA + Ks P + C
[5.8]
where Fs is the force in N acting on the probe; A and P are the cross-sectional area (mm2) and the perimeter (mm) of the probe, respectively; Kc is the compression coefficient in N/mm2; Ks is the shear coefficient in N/mm; and C is a constant in N. The first term in Eq. [5.8] represents the contribution of compression to the puncture force and the second term represents the shear contribution. Equation [5.8] suggests that as the ratio of area to perimeter increases, the proportion of compression contributing to the overall puncture force will increase. Conversely, as the ratio of area to perimeter decreases, the relative contribution of shear to the overall puncture force increases. Therefore, by using different probe geometries, such as circular, square, star, and polygonal, we can manipulate the relative contributions of compression and shear to the overall puncture force measurement. However, the edge effect (or stress concentration) with different probe geometries on texture measurements should also be considered. Most commonly used puncture probes are of circular shape, which gives the maximum area to perimeter ratio among all geometries, and thus measures the puncture force with the maximum compression to shear ratio. At the other extreme is the thin blade probe, which gives the minimum ratio of area to perimeter, and the test in fact becomes a shear test. Different foods have different compression and shear properties. The ratio Kc/Ks may be useful for comparing the relative contributions of compression and shear to the puncture force among different foods. For example, the ratio Kc/Ks is approximately five for apples, two for potatoes, and one for bananas (Bourne, 1966). The different ratios of Kc/Ks for different foods may explain why the puncture test works well for some foods but not for others. Equation [5.8] also suggests that, in order to optimize the texture measurement, different probe geometries should be considered for different types of foods. The geometry of the probe tip is also important in the puncture test. Commonly used probe tip geometries include flat end, hemispherical (both full and partial), and conical (Fig. 5.5). In measuring the firmness of many intact fresh fruits and vegetables, a partial hemispherical probe is widely used (Fig. 5.5b), as exemplified by the two standard Magness-Taylor probes. On the other hand, the flat-end probe has been suggested for testing fresh-cut commodities (cut slices or chunks), which would ensure constant contact
120
Texture in food
(a) Flat
(b) Partial hemispherical
(c) Full hemispherical
(d) Conical
Fig. 5.5 Different probe tips used in puncture tests. The Magness-Taylor probe, represented by (b) is popular for fruits and vegetables.
area between the probe and flat cut surface of the piece during the test (Wu and Abbott, 2002). Multiple conical probes have been used for measuring the tenderness of meat, such as the Armour Tenderometer that uses ten 3.2mm (1/8-inch) diameter probes with sharp points (conical probes) (Hansen, 1972). The Magness-Taylor (MT) firmness tester, which uses a partial hemispherical tip probe (Fig. 5.5b), is the best-known puncture method for measuring the texture of foods. The MT tester is widely used for estimating the harvest maturity or post-harvest firmness of many fruits and vegetables. There are several variations of the MT tester for measuring different fresh fruits and vegetables. A number of recent reviews have given detailed discussion of various forms of the MT tester (Abbott, 1999; Bourne, 2002). There are basically three types of MT tester available: the handheld MT tester with a mechanical force gauge, the portable MT tester equipped with an electronic force gauge, and the MT tester that uses a universal testing machine with a MT probe attached to it (Fig. 5.6). Two probe diameters, 11.1 and 7.9 mm, are used for different commodities. There are two types of MT testers with mechanical force gauges – the original Magness-Taylor with a helical spring and the Effe-gi with a spiral spring (Effe-gi testers may be marketed under the names McCormick, Wagner, R. Bryce, and others) – but the testers are fundamentally the same. Mechanical MT testers are popularly used for measuring the firmness of fruit in the orchard and at the packinghouse or the shipping point as well as in some laboratories. They are low in cost but prone to operational error because MT measurements are affected by the rate of loading and operator (Harker et al., 1996; Lehman-Salada, 1996). MT testing with a universal testing machine, such as Instron or Texture Analyzer, can accurately control the loading rate and record the force/deformation curve for each food sample. Thus, the measurements are more reliable and reproducible. But these machines are expensive and only suitable for laboratory uses. Many portable MT testers with an electronic force gauge are low in cost and can accurately record the force during the puncture test, and therefore they provide a good alternative to either the mechanical MT tester or the universal testing machine-based MT tester. One problem with these testers is that the loading rate is usually not controllable, although some reject excessively fast or slow measurements.
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
121
Fig. 5.6 Three Magness-Taylor (MT) firmness testers: (a) a handheld mechanical MT tester based on a calibrated spring that may be helical or spiral; (b) a portable MT tester with an electronic gauge; and (c) a MT probe mounted on a standard laboratory testing machine.
122
Texture in food
5.3.2 Compression Compression is widely used for measuring the basic mechanical properties of a large variety of solid foods including fruits (Abbott and Lu, 1996; Khan and Vincent, 1993), vegetables (Alvarez and Canet, 2000), grains (Wouters and de Baerdemaeker, 1988), and processed foods (Moiny et al., 2002). These tests are often conducted on cylindrical specimens excised from food samples under uniaxial loading with a universal testing machine. Compression tests may also be used to measure the basic mechanical properties of intact food samples with well-defined geometry. The American Society of Agricultural Engineers (ASAE) has provided a standard for conducting compression tests with intact food samples and the method for calculating the elastic modulus from the compressive force/deformation curve (ASAE, 2000). In texture measurement of intact foods, two types of compression are often used: the uniaxial compression test of food samples between two plates and the confined compression test, such as extrusion (Fig. 5.7). During uniaxial compression, force is applied to the sample in one direction and the sample is allowed to expand freely in the other two directions. The sample is compressed until it breaks or is completely crushed. The initial portion of the force/deformation curve can be used to estimate the modulus of elasticity of the food sample (Mohsenin, 1989). Uniaxial compression is easy to perform and is useful for such foods as grains. The single kernel wheat characterization system developed by the US Department of Agriculture (Martin et al., 1993) measures the hardness of individual wheat kernels by crushing them between two surfaces that move closer together through a rotor and a crescent. The crushing force profile is recorded and analyzed for predicting wheat kernel hardness. Gaines et al. (1996) reported a high correlation between predicted softness equivalent (SE) values from the single kernel wheat characterization system and actual SE milling values. In the simple compression–extrusion test shown in Fig. 5.7, force is applied through a plunger to compress the food sample in the test cell until it is
F
F
Plunger
Extrusion cell
F (a)
(b)
Fig. 5.7 Two types of compression tests: (a) uniaxial compression test between two plates and (b) simple compression–back extrusion test.
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
123
crushed and flows through the gap (or annulus) between the plunger and the test cell. The force required to compress the food sample not only depends on the properties of the food but also the size of the annulus. This type of test is often used for measuring viscous liquids, gels, fats, and some fresh and processed fruits and vegetables. A variation to the simple compression– extrusion tester is to have slits or a grid of holes in the bottom of the extrusion cell so that some of the food will be extruded forward through the slits or holes during compression by the plunger. The Kramer Shear Press (Kramer, 1951) and the Ottawa Texture Measuring System (Voisey, 1971) are two popularly used compression–extrusion testers for measuring the texture of many solid foods (Chen and Marks, 1998; Mafuleka et al., 1991; Rodrigo et al., 1997; Strange and Whiting, 1998). The measurement process involves a complex form of mechanical loading, including shear, compression and extrusion. For this reason, these testers are more often considered to be a shear device rather than a compression device. The Kramer Shear Press is generally more popular for processed products (S. Lakeway, Jr., Pres., Food Technology Corp.) than for fresh fruits and vegetables for several reasons: 1. it is intuitively appealing since each test can measure many pieces of cutup food; 2. the user does not need to be concerned about the choice of free or constrained compression, tension etc.; probe geometry; sample size; and measurement parameters to report; and 3. many practitioners come from a food science rather than horticultural background.
5.3.3 Shear Shear often refers to the action of applying force to cut an object into two separate pieces. This loose definition is different from the strict engineering definition of pure shear, which is difficult to conduct experimentally, except under torsion and some special loading conditions. Shear tests are especially useful for measuring the textural properties of muscle foods. The WarnerBratzler (WB) shear tester is the standard device recommended by the American Meat Science Association for measuring the tenderness of meat. The device (Fig. 5.8) consists of a thin blade with a triangular opening and slotted base (of specified geometry and dimensions) (Bratzler, 1949; Voisey, 1976). Cylindrical specimens of 13 mm diameter are excised from cooked meat. As the blade moves through the slot, the meat specimen is compressed and changes the cross-sectional shape to conform to the restriction imposed by the triangular opening of the blade until it is eventually sheared into two pieces. The maximum force recorded during shearing is considered to be a measure of meat tenderness. The measurement process involves shear, tension and compression. The conventional interpretation, as implied in the name, is that shear forces are primarily responsible for cutting the meat specimen during WB measurement. Other researchers (Voisey, 1976; Zhang and Mittal,
124
Texture in food
Blade
Specimen
Slot bars
Fig. 5.8 Schematic of the Warner-Bratzler shear tester for measuring the tenderness of meat.
1993) argue that tensile strength is the primary contributor in the WB shearing process. A number of different shear devices have been developed for measuring meat tenderness; they include the Volodkevich tenderometer (Volodkevich, 1938), the MIRINZ tenderometer (McFarlane and Marer, 1966), and the NIP tenderometer (Smith and Carpenter, 1973). Eckhoff et al. (1988) developed a rapid single-kernel wheat hardness tester. The tester consists of a rotary knife sitting in a groove. As the plate that contains kernels rotates, the knife slices through the kernels. The force required to cut the kernels over time is recorded and analyzed for differentiating hard wheat from soft wheat. Brusewitz et al. (1997) investigated a shearing technique to quantify the texture of several fruits: apples, peaches and bananas. A cylindrical specimen was cut through with a wire probe. A frequency analysis method, i.e. fast Fourier transform or FFT, was used to analyze the force–displacement curves generated as the wire cut through the specimen. They reported that FFT peak energies at frequencies below 4 Hz could be used to detect the change in the texture of fruits.
5.3.4 Torsion/twisting Torsion/twisting is another form of measuring texture that is based on the shear properties of foods. In a torsion test, force is applied to an object to cause the rotation or twisting of one part relative to another part of the object. Torsion tests are not commonly used for solid foods because of special requirements in preparing and mounting specimens and the difficulty of applying torsional force to food samples. Diehl et al. (1980) developed a torsion test to study the structural failure of selected raw fruits and vegetables.
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
125
The test required preparation of specimens of special dimensions. Phillips (1992) developed a rotating pin shear device to measure the tenderness of meat. The device consisted of two sets of concentric pins that can be rotated relative to each other. The force required to rotate the inner set was measured against the angle of rotation and used as a measure of meat tenderness. Studman and Yuwana (1992) developed a twist device for measuring fruit firmness. The device consists of a blade on a spindle, which is pushed into the fruit and rotated about the axis of the spindle. Fruit firmness is estimated by measuring the maximum moment (or rotational angle) required to crush the flesh. The twist test is quite different from a torsion test as the properties tested with the former are likely to be a combination of shear and compression. Hopkirk et al. (1996) suggested that puncture and twist tests may produce quite different firmness judgments. Harker et al. (1996) found the twist test to be more precise than several testers using the MT puncture probe. The twist test has the advantage of being able to measure strength of tissue zones at specific depths from the surface without requiring the excision of tissue samples.
5.3.5 Tension/bending Tensile tests measure the force required to stretch a food specimen or an intact food sample apart. Tensile tests are useful for studying the tensile mechanical properties and, particularly, the structural failure characteristics of foods. Many foods have tensile properties that are quite distinct from those in compression. For example, the tensile properties of muscle foods are very different from those in compression (Lepetit and Culioli, 1994), and tensile tests are considered to be especially valuable for understanding the structural changes of muscle food during such processing treatments as aging and cooking (Dransfield et al., 1986; Lu et al., 1998; Mutungi et al., 1995; Penfield et al., 1976; Purslow, 1991). Researchers also used tensile tests to examine the structural and/or textural changes and the mode of fracture in fruits (Hallett and Harker, 1998; Harker and Hallett, 1992, 1994; Schoorl and Holt, 1983; Stow, 1989). Tensile tests are not widely used for measuring the texture of foods because: 1. the process of mastication primarily involves compression and shearing, not tension, of the food; and 2. tensile tests are more difficult to perform than other techniques discussed above; they present a special challenge in gripping or holding a food specimen without causing tissue damage or slippage during the test. Bending tests provide an alternative for overcoming the specimen-gripping problem to study the tensile properties of foods. There are two types of bending tests available for measuring foods: the cantilever beam bending and the three-point bending. The latter seems to be preferred over the former due to the consideration of specimen mounting. Lu and Siebenmorgen (1995)
126
Texture in food
used a three-point bending test to measure the bending strength of rough and milled rice and related bending strength to rice milling quality. Rice kernels were placed on a sample holding device with the distance between the two supporting points at 4.5 mm. Loads were applied to the middle section of the kernel through a loading head mounted on an Instron universal testing machine. Abbott and Buta (2002) used three-point bending to measure the firmness of fresh cut pear slices and found that the bending test was less suitable and convenient compared to the puncture test. Alvarez et al. (2000) determined the fracture toughness and fracture energy of fresh fruits and vegetables from rectangular cross-section beam specimens by using a standard engineering method known as the single-edge notched bend test (a form of three-point bending). Suhendro et al. (1998) developed a bending technique to measure corn tortilla texture. Tortilla strips were bent to a 40° angle and the force required to bend them was used to detect tortilla texture (i.e. rollability and flexibility). In conducting bending tests, the specimen length to thickness (or diameter for a circular beam) ratio is an important consideration. To minimize the shear and compressive stress, the specimen length should be sufficiently large in comparison with its thickness. Standard bending tests for many engineering materials often require the length to thickness ratio to be at least 16 (Van Hecke et al., 1995). For many food products, this requirement can be difficult, if not impossible, to achieve and one has to balance various factors (such as sample geometry, the easiness of preparing test specimens, etc.) in selecting an appropriate length to thickness ratio.
5.3.6 Methods in data analysis In most destructive methods discussed above, the data extracted from the force/deformation curves is maximum force or, sometimes, the slope or the area up to the maximum force. This approach may not be good enough for certain applications since information embedded in the force/deformation curve, especially after initial failure, has not been effectively utilized or has even been totally discarded. A notable deviation from the conventional single parameter approach is the texture profile analysis (TPA) technique developed by Szczesniak and co-workers in the 1960s (Friedman et al., 1963; Szczesniak et al., 1963). The TPA test involves two complete cycles of compression and decompression of a food sample. The degree of compression of a food sample can be as high as 90%. The force/time or force/deformation relationship is recorded during the cycles of compression and decompression. From this force/time curve, a number of texture parameters such as fracturability, hardness, stringiness, and springiness are extracted. Szczesniak et al. (1963) reported that these parameters were closely related to sensory evaluation results. Bourne (1968; 1974) used an Instron universal machine to perform a modified TPA for pears and peaches. TPA tests have been used to quantify the textural properties of many other solid foods, including beef and beef loaves (Brady
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
127
et al., 1985), restructured beef steaks (Chen and Trout, 1991), Cheddar cheese (Bryant et al., 1995; Lakhani et al., 1991), pecans (Ocon et al., 1995), potatoes (Alvarez and Canet, 2000), and cooked rice (Champagne et al., 1999; Lyon et al., 2000). Abbott et al. (1982) examined puncture and compression force/deformation curves of apple tissue and extracted numerous data including forces, areas, slopes and locations of specific events, and estimated jaggedness after fracture. These data were compared to sensory evaluations of oral texture (crispness, hardness, toughness, mealiness, etc.) using stepwise regression (Abbott et al., 1984). Maximum force was never the first-selected variable. Variables often selected were peak force of the first peak (not necessarily bioyield force), mean force near mid-compression, force about the maximum compression (75% strain), and total work in compression. Slopes were seldom selected, indicating less relationship of oral texture to modulus of elasticity than to strength variables in apples. They concluded that inclusion of two or more force/deformation variables in regression equations generally improved prediction of sensory textural attributes over maximum force alone. Recently, several new methods have been reported for analyzing the force/ deformation (or stress/strain) curve to predict the textural properties of foods. These methods include the use of FFT, fractal analysis, and stress/strain spectral analysis. One significant feature of these new data analysis methods is that they utilize the entire force/deformation curve or the portion of the curve after initial failure that shows considerable jaggedness and irregularity. Barrett et al. (1992) used FFT and fractal methods to analyze the jagged stress/strain curves to measure the crispness of food. The FFT method gave qualitative representation of the jaggedness of the force/deformation curve, but it lacked quantitative interpretation of food texture such as crispness. Peleg (1997) recommended that the jaggedness of force/deformation curves be determined by at least two methods simultaneously for mutual verification. Meullenet et al. (1999) treated the force/deformation curves obtained from extrusion tests of cooked rice samples as if they were spectral data. Subsequently, a spectral analysis technique was used to develop a partial least square (PLS) model to predict eight sensory texture characteristics of cooked rice, including adhesion, hardness, cohesiveness, roughness, etc. Their results showed that the method has the potential to predict multiple sensory texture characteristics. These new data analysis methods are useful for improving the prediction of specific textural properties of foods since the entire force/deformation curve is used in analysis. One major drawback with these methods is that they are more involved mathematically and often cannot provide meaningful interpretation on how textural attributes are predicted. However, once the methods and appropriate algorithms are developed, it should not present a great challenge to food technologists who may not have a good mathematical background.
128
Texture in food
5.4 Non-destructive measurements Mastication is a process of destroying food, from which humans enjoy and sense the texture and flavor of the food. Hence it seems logical to food technologists that food texture should be measured through destructive means (Bourne, 2002). Any new techniques, especially those which are nondestructive, should be compared against the standard destructive techniques. This is understandable but should be put in perspective. Most destructive methods measure some combination of mechanical properties that are usually poorly understood, and they often measure some specific attributes of interest to the developer of the measurement but which cannot always be clearly articulated or properly considered by users adopting the method. Destructive methods often lack the sensitivity required to detect subtle changes in the texture of food, whereas non-destructive methods tend to better measure the mechanical properties of food, especially in ascertaining their changes at the structural level. For many fresh, unprocessed food products, grading or sorting them into consistent quality or texture categories or groups is even more important than measuring the actual texture. Non-destructive force/deformation sensing requires that food samples not be destroyed or degraded during the process of measurement. As a result of this basic requirement, the levels of force and/or deformation must be such that they will not exceed the limit that would cause permanent damage to the food product. The engineering theory of elasticity and viscoelasticity works well for describing the mechanical response of foods under non-destructive loading conditions. In fact, most non-destructive methods measure specific engineering properties, such as the modulus of elasticity and impact energy, either directly or indirectly. Voluminous literature is available on non-destructive force/deformation sensing techniques for measuring different types of foods, and it would need more space than is permitted here to give a comprehensive review of this important topic. Consequently, our following discussion is primarily focused on non-destructive firmness sensing of fresh fruits and vegetables, which is the primary focus of our research. Firmness of many fruits and vegetables changes during ripening and, hence, it is used for determining the optimal harvest time. Firmness is an important sensory attribute that directly influences eating and cooking quality and consumer acceptance. Firmness is also important in determining the resistance of a food product to mechanical damage in handling and shipping; for example, soft fruit are susceptible to mechanical damage in long-distance shipping and may have a shorter shelf life than firmer ones of the same type. Firmness is closely related to the mechanical properties of the product, and it, like many textural properties, does not have a universally accepted definition. For example, sensory scientists define firmness as the force required to break or bite into the food in the mouth, whereas horticulturists consider the force required to penetrate a mechanical probe – such as the standard MagnessTaylor firmness tester (see Section 5.3.1) – into a fresh product for a prespecified distance as a measure of firmness. To engineers, firmness may
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
129
mean the capacity of a food to resist elastic deformation; the modulus of elasticity is often used as a measure of firmness. In this section, we use the term firmness according to its common usage by engineers. We discuss nondestructive firmness measurement methods and techniques based on the rate of loading, which include quasi-static, dynamic, vibration and impact. Acoustic sensing also falls within the force/deformation category and is related to dynamic, but it is covered in Chapter 6.
5.4.1 Quasi-static loading Quasi-static methods measure the force at a specific level of deformation, or the deformation at a specific level of force, or both. Force measurement methods require controlling the displacement of the probe during testing so that reliable force measurements can be obtained. Verner (1931) developed a firmness tester for stone fruits, which squeezed the fruit between two flat plates for a specified distance. Ross (1949) reported on a fruit firmness tester that used a pneumatic system to press a rounded-end piston (4.0 mm diameter) onto the sample for a depth of 0.79 mm so that no apparent bruises or injuries would occur to the fruit. Schomer and Olsen (1962) developed a mechanical thumb that was attached to the MT tester so that the indentation of the probe would be limited to 1.4 mm. Firmness readings were comparable to those obtained with the MT tester but were less reliable. Fekete (1993) reported on a fruit firmness tester based on measuring applied force for a pre-set penetration depth (0.3 mm). The ratio of stress (force per unit area) to deformation was calculated as a measure of fruit firmness. Mohsenin (1989) reasoned that the bioyield point, which occurs to many fresh fruits and vegetables during compression, could be a better indicator of fruit firmness than MT puncture, because it goes beyond the elastic deformation but has not resulted in a complete rupture of fruit tissue (see discussion in Section 5.2.2). Mohsenin et al. (1965) used a 6.4-mm flat-tip steel probe to measure the bioyield point of apple fruit to monitor the maturity of fruit on the tree. When a rigid probe is compressed against a fruit, the stress distribution is not uniform within the contact area and stress concentration occurs, based on the Hertz and Boussinesq contact theory (Mohsenin, 1989). As a result, the tissue failure will occur gradually within and below the contact surface and go beyond the immediate contact region. Further, the bioyield point often cannot be detected from the force/deformation curve due to the gradual failure of fruit tissue with a rigid probe (Fig. 5.9a). Ababneh (2002) applied the finite element method – a powerful engineering simulation technique – to analyze the stress/strain distribution in the apple fruit when different probe designs (probe size, the elasticity and thickness of the tip material, and tip geometry) were used in the indentation (or penetration) test. His simulations showed that a 3.2-mm thick flat tip with an elastic modulus about one-half that of an apple fruit would lead to a uniform stress distribution within the contact region of intact apple fruit. This uniform stress distribution is desirable
130
Texture in food
because the tissue in the contact region tends to fail simultaneously, resulting in a conspicuous drop in force at the bioyield point and less damage to the tissue (Fig. 5.9b). Ababneh (2002) tested six probes with different tip materials with an Instron machine and confirmed that the probe with a diameter of 6.4 mm and a soft tip about 3 mm thick would be optimal for bioyield measurement. Lu and coworkers (unpublished data) further evaluated a new bioyield tester by coupling the 6.4-mm diameter probe with a 3.2-mm thick rubber tip (with an elastic modulus of about 150 kPa, about 40 % or less of that of apples) to a digital force gauge, which was in turn mounted onto a tabletop motor-driven stand. Bioyield force correlated reasonably well with 80
Force (N)
60
40
20
0 0
2
4
6
8
10
Displacement (mm) (a) 40
Force (N)
30
20
10
0 0
2
0
2
0
2
0
2
Displacement (mm) (b)
Fig. 5.9 Force–deformation curves obtained from two apples using an 11-mm diameter Magness-Taylor firmness probe mounted on a laboratory material testing machine (a) and from four locations on the same apple using a bioyield tester with a 6.4-mm diameter and a 3.2-mm thick soft rubber tip probe (b) (Lu unpublished data).
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
131
MT firmness. The bioyield tester was able to monitor the texture change in apples stored in refrigerated storage as well as the MT tester. However, the bioyield tester was found to be less sensitive than the MT tester in monitoring apples stored at room temperature. The force-type firmness devices are mainly used for firm fruits and vegetables such as apples, kiwifruits (at the stage of commercial interest – well before eating ripeness – they are very firm), pears, peaches and cucumbers. Their applications to softer commodities are less successful because the testers are often not sensitive enough to measure the firmness of soft products, and the rate of loading can significantly affect the firmness reading. Devices that measure deformation at a pre-set force are popular for soft fruits. Hamson (1952) developed a device for measuring tomato firmness by applying a constant weight through an 11.1-mm diameter flat-head plunger for five seconds to record the deformation of the tomato fruit. The five-second interval under the constant load was important because tomatoes are viscoelastic and their deformation increases as the time of loading increases. Kattan (1957) designed a tomato firmness tester by encircling the fruit with a chain through which a constant load was applied to the circumference of the fruit for a fixed time. The amount of compression was measured as a measure of tomato firmness. The Asco Firmness Meter, based on the same principle, was introduced commercially in 1959 (Garrett et al., 1960). Others (Diener et al., 1971; Shafshak and Winsor, 1964) also reported on firmness testers that were based on a similar principle. However, these methods have not been widely adopted, largely because of the waiting time required for each measurement. Wu and Abbott (2002) developed a method and procedure for measuring the firmness of fresh-cut tomato slices. Compressive loads were first applied through a cylindrical probe to the tomato slice at a loading rate of 1.0 mm/s. After the pre-specified deformation level was reached, the tomato slice was held for ten seconds to record the stress relaxation (Fig. 5.10). Wu and Abbott reported that a 4-mm cylindrical probe with an indentation of 3.0 mm provided more consistent firmness measurements than a spherical probe or a 1-mm indentation. The maximum force was significantly different for ripeness stages from mature green to red tomatoes. The responses of the relaxation parameters over storage time were dependent on the initial maturity of the tomatoes; values differed significantly between tomatoes stored intact or sliced. Considerable research has been reported on firmness measurement of small fruits such as cherries and berries based on the deformation measurement corresponding to a specific load (Bernstein and Lustig, 1981; Diener et al., 1969; Lusting and Bernstein, 1987; Parker et al., 1966; Rohrbach, 1981; Rohrbach and Mainland, 1993; Timm et al., 1996; Wolfe et al., 1980). An instrument developed by BioWorks, Inc. (Stillwater, Oklahoma, USA) based on the original design of Timm et al. (1996) was recently available for measuring the firmness of small fruits. Fruit are placed on 25 shallow pockets
132
Texture in food 4
Fmax
F0
Force (N)
3
2
Y = 1 – A ln(1 + t ) – B t /(C + t )
1
0 0 1 2 3 Loading distance 0 (mm)
2
4
6
8
10
Relaxation time (s) (a)
Force relative to initial force at 3-mm deformation
1.0 Ripeness stage Green
Tomato Tissue Relaxation under 3-mm deformation
0.9
Breaker
0.8
Turning Pink
0.7
Light-red 0.6
Red
0.5 0.4 0.3 0
2
4
6
8
10
Time (s) (b)
Fig. 5.10 Typical force/deformation curve during the loading and holding (stress relaxation) period (a) and the relaxation curves (b) of tomatoes harvested and measured at various stages of ripeness. Tissue at the junction of the outer pericarp and radial pericarp rays of 7-mm thick slices of tomato loaded with a 4-mm diameter cylindrical punch at 1–3 mm/s; each curve in (b) is a mean of three sites per slice × 10 tomatoes. Force shown is actual force divided by force at completion of loading (Wu and Abbott, 2002).
on an aluminum turntable that automatically rotates and aligns each fruit under the probe. Each fruit is compressed with a sensing probe from the preselected minimum force to the pre-selected maximum force. The force/ deformation curve is recorded and the slope between the minimum and maximum force is calculated as a measure of firmness. Several studies
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
133
(Donahue and Work, 1998; Mitcham et al., 1998; Tetteh et al., 2001) showed that the instrument was able to measure the firmness of small fruits, but measurements were affected by factors such as fruit orientation, size, and pre-set minimum and maximum force (Tetteh et al., 2001). Quasi-static techniques discussed above require physical contact between the loading probe and the food sample, which can be slow and inconvenient. A novel non-contact laser air-puff firmness tester was developed and patented by Prussia et al. (1994) for measuring the firmness of foods and other products. The laser air-puff firmness tester uses a brief puff of compressed air to deform the product surface, which is measured remotely with a laser displacement sensor. The modulus of elasticity is calculated from applied air pressure and the deformation and is used as a measure of firmness. For a constant-pressure air, soft foods would deflect more than firmer foods. Therefore, by adjusting the air pressure, the tester can be suited for different types of food products. The laser displacement sensor is not suitable for highly translucent tissues, such as tomato slices, due to excessive light scatter (S. Prussia, personal communication).
5.4.2 Dynamic loading Most quasi-static methods measure either force or deformation or both from a small local area of food samples. Many foods, especially meats and raw fruits and vegetables, exhibit considerable variability in the mechanical properties within the same food sample. The dynamic force/deformation methods discussed herein are less influenced by the local properties and are more representative of the overall mechanical properties of a food sample. Dynamic force/deformation methods are achieved by applying sinusoidal force to the food over a range of frequencies and recording the corresponding displacement, acceleration or velocity (Fig. 5.11). Firmness is determined by analyzing the frequency spectrum of the ratio of force to deformation (or velocity or acceleration). Rohrbach and Glass (1980) determined the firmness of blueberries by measuring the mechanical impedance using a dynamic device. The mechanical impedance, the ratio of force to velocity in the frequency domain, was measured with a swept sinusoidal vibration over a range of frequencies. An impedance model was developed to fit the experimental data. Rohrbach and Glass found that the spring constant in the model correlated reasonably well with the firmness measurement from quasistatic compression tests. Abbott and Massie (1993) studied a dynamic testing technique for measuring the firmness of apples by applying a swept sinusoidal vibration (40–440 Hz) to the apple fruit through a flat plate (Fig. 5.11). The frequency response, the ratio of output (force) to input (acceleration), was recorded and calculated using a dynamic signal analyzer. Abbott and Massie reported that the dynamic measurement had a higher correlation with the slope of the MT force/ deformation curve (r = 0.61) than with the maximum force (r = 0.41). Later,
134
Texture in food
Vibrator
Accelerometer Force transducer
Fruit
Lab jack
Fig. 5.11 Schematic of a dynamic test device for measuring the firmness of food products (adapted from Abbott and Massie, 1993).
Abbott and Massie (1995) used the device to test kiwifruits and reported a better correlation (r = 0.91) between dynamic measurements and MT firmness. Dynamic tests require a vibration device and a signal analyzer or a similar device to record both the input and output signals, which can be costly in instrumentation. Dynamic measurements are susceptible to the influence of fruit mass, size and shape. In addition, dynamic tests are slow in measurements and special care needs to be taken in loading the sample.
5.4.3 Vibration In both quasi-static and dynamic force/deformation tests, the force and/or deformation acting on the food sample is controlled, that is, the food samples have to conform to the constraint imposed upon them. As a result, the tests are not suitable for high-speed sorting or grading applications (with the exception of the laser air-puff tester). Vibration tests, on the other hand, are conducted by applying cyclic motions at certain frequencies to generate free vibrations in individual food items. When a periodic force is applied to a food item, it will vibrate at the same frequency as the applied force. At a particular frequency, the food item will vibrate vigorously and the maximal vibration amplitude is observed; such a condition is called resonance. The vibration behavior of the food is directly related to vibration frequency and the physical and mechanical properties of the food including the modulus of elasticity, mass, size and shape. Hamann and Carroll (1971) developed a sorting device for muscadine grapes using low-frequency vibration energy. The grapes were vibrated in an inclined separation trough at various frequencies between 100 Hz and 200 Hz. Ripe, soft fruit bounced from the trough at a lower frequency while
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
135
firmer fruit bounced out at higher frequencies. The same device was used to sort blueberries based on firmness and shelf life (Hamann et al., 1973). They reported that bruised berries bounced from the vibrating trough at lower frequencies. Bower and Rohrbach (1976) also developed and tested a similar vibration device to sort blueberries. They reported that vibration sorting was effective in separating most good fruit from damaged fruit, but it was not effective in separating blueberries based on firmness and shelf life. Wolfe et al. (1980) reported that vibration sorting of fruit into different quality grades was not accurate enough to meet the marketing requirements. This is not surprising since the vibration behavior is also affected by the mass, size and shape of the fruit. Vibration tests are suitable when products are relatively uniform in size and shape, and when there exists a large variation in the textural attributes. A commercial pilot tomato sorting system was developed, which was capable of sorting 9.0–13.6 tonnes of tomatoes per hour with 90–95% accuracy (Anon., 1976). Vibration tests were found to be effective in separating tomatoes into different firmness groups (Holmes, 1979; McClure et al., 1979).
5.4.4 Impact Impact occurs when two objects collide with each other in a very short time interval, resulting in rapid changes in the momentum and velocity of the impacting objects accompanied by relatively large forces exerted between them. During impact, the object may undergo three phases of deformation: initial elastic deformation, partial plastic or permanent deformation, and the final elastic recovery. The impact response of the object depends on its mechanical properties, mass, size and shape, and thus can be used to measure the texture of food products. Typical impact force responses (IFR) for different firmness levels of tomatoes with approximately the same mass are shown in Fig. 5.12 when they were dropped onto a rigid plate from the same height (therefore the same initial impact acceleration or velocity). The green tomato had the highest impact force and the shortest contact time and the red tomato had the lowest impact force and the longest contact duration. The firm fruit exhibited a relatively symmetric IFR curve, whereas soft fruit had a more skewed IFR curve. The degree of skewness is related to the type of food, firmness and degree of impact (i.e. drop height or initial impact velocity). Numerous studies have been conducted on the impact responses of fruits and vegetables and their relationship with firmness and bruise susceptibility (Bajema and Hyde, 1998; Baritelle and Hyde, 2001; Bartsch and Askariaman, 1982; Delwiche, 1987; Finney and Massie, 1975; Lichtensteiger et al., 1988; Mohsenin et al., 1978; Rohrbach et al., 1982; Zhang and Brusewitz, 1991; Zhang et al., 1994). Impact parameters that can be extracted from the IFR curve include peak force; the ratio of peak force to the time from initial contact to peak force (C1); the ratio of peak force to the square of the time from initial contact to
136
Texture in food
Green tomato mass = 103 g
80 70
Force (N)
60 Pink tomato mass = 103 g
50 40
Red tomato mass = 101 g
30 20 10
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Time (mSec)
Fig. 5.12 Impact force response curves for three tomatoes of the same mass dropping 10 cm onto a rigid plate (Lichtensteiger et al., 1988).
peak force (C2); the ratio of peak force to the contact time (C3); coefficient of restitution, which is the ratio of the velocities of the product before and after impact and reflects the energy absorbed during impact; contact time; and IFR frequency spectrum. Table 5.1 summarizes various impact parameters used by researchers to measure the firmness of fruits and vegetables. Impact firmness measurement can be implemented with different approaches, which will lead to different instrument designs. There are two basic types of impact test used for measuring the firmness of fruits and vegetables: the drop test and the probe impact test. In the drop impact test, the sample is dropped onto an impact-sensing unit that records the impact force with time. The mass and stiffness of the impact-sensing unit must be significantly greater than those of the impacting fruit so that the influence of the sensing element on the IFR is minimal. This type of impact test is relatively easy to implement, but measurements are affected by the mass and shape (especially the contact geometry) of the sample. The second type of impact test uses an impact probe with a sensing element to impact a sample. This approach reduces the effect of fruit mass and radius of curvature on the IFR curve; however, probe design is critical for measuring the impact response of the fruit reliably and consistently. The drop test has been used to measure the firmness of a number of fruits and vegetables. Rohrbach (1981) developed a computer-controlled impact device that recorded the IFR of blueberries dropping 40 mm onto a rigid plate sensor. Seventy five percent of berries with firmness defects (soft berries) were correctly sorted into appropriate firmness grades by using C2 as a sorting criterion. Delwiche et al. (1987) studied the IFR of peaches
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
137
Table 5.1 Impact parameters used to measure the firmness of fresh fruits and vegetables. (Adopted and expanded from Abbott et al., 1997) Impact parameter
Product
Reference
Peak force
apples, pears, peaches
C1a
peaches, kiwifruits
C2b
apples, blueberries, peaches, pears
Delwiche et al. (1991), Delwiche and Sarig (1991), Sugiyama et al. (1994) Brusewitz et al. (1991), Chen and Tjan (1996), Delwiche (1987), Delwiche et al. (1987), Zhang et al. (1994) Delwiche (1987), Delwiche et al. (1987), Delwiche and Sarig (1991), Delwiche et al. (1989), Rohrbach et al. (1982) Ozer et al. (1998) Brusewitz et al. (1991), McGlone and Schaare (1993), Patel et al. (1993), Zhang et al. (1994) Brusewitz et al. (1991), Zhang et al. (1994) Brusewitz et al. (1991), Zhang et al. (1994) Meredith et al. (1990), Sugiyama et al. (1994)
c
C3 Contact time Absorbed energy d IFR skewness Coefficient of restitutione IFR frequency spectrum Stiffness parameter Initial acceleration a b c d e
cantaloupe apricots, blueberries, kiwifruits, peaches, raspberries peaches peaches apples, peaches apples, peaches, pears tomatoes cherries
De Baerdemaeker et al. (1982), Delwiche (1987), Delwiche et al. (1987) Nahir et al. (1986) Younce and Davis (1995)
C1 is the ratio of the peak force to the time to the peak force C2 is the ratio of the peak force to the square of the time to the peak force. C3 is the ratio of the peak force to the contact time. IFR = impact force response. Coefficient of restitution is the ratio of the velocities of the specimen just before and after impact and reflects the energy absorbed in the product during impact.
impacting on a rigid surface. After comparing the results using different impact parameters, they concluded that C2 and force at 295 Hz were most highly correlated with elastic modulus and MT firmness. Based on this study, Delwiche et al. (1989) developed a prototype sorting line that could sort peaches and pears at a rate of five fruit/s. Approximately 74% of the peaches were sorted into the correct firmness grades. Meredith et al. (1990) used the coefficient of restitution determined from two consecutive bounces of peaches to determine fruit firmness, and they reported that the parameter correlated well with MT firmness. Brusewitz et al. (1991) investigated the relationship between peach ripeness and various impact parameters obtained from the drop test. They reported that peach ripeness correlated with C1, percent energy absorbed, and skewness of the IFR curve. McGlone and colleagues (McGlone and Schaare, 1993; Patel et al., 1993) developed three impact firmness devices for various applications to different fruits: ‘SoftSense’ for research uses and off-line quality control in industry; ‘BerryBounce’ designed for measuring the average firmness of batches of small-sized fruit; and ‘SoftSort’ for grading medium-size fruit such as kiwifruit. Impact firmness measurements for the three devices are based on the dwell time or contact time, defined as the peak width at half height of the first IFR curve. Ozer et
138
Texture in food
al. (1998) reported that the drop impact test based on C3, the ratio of peak force to the contact time from three consecutive impacts, had a good correlation with flesh firmness and elasticity of cantaloupe fruit. The impact probe method has been studied by a number of researchers for various fruits and vegetables. Delwiche and Sarig (1991) developed a probe impact sensor, which was controlled by an air cylinder. Good correlation was obtained between peak acceleration (or force) and penetrometer firmness for pears and peaches, but not for apples. Chen and Tjan (1996) and Jaren et al. (1992) proposed an improved approach to impact firmness measurement. The fruit was impacted with a small spherical impactor of known mass and radius of curvature, and the acceleration of the impactor was measured. Chen and Tjan (1996) reported that the IFR was independent of the fruit mass and was less sensitive to the variation of the radius of curvature of the fruit. A prototype sorter was developed, which can sort fruit at a rate of five fruit/s, and good firmness predictions were reported for peaches and kiwifruit (Chen and Tjan, 1996). Ortiz-Cañavate et al. (2001) tested this impact sorter in an experimental packing line. A commercial firmness sorting system was recently developed by Sinclare International Ltd, Norfolk, UK (Briggs, 1998). The sorting device uses expandable resilient bellows, which are expanded to bring the sensor in contact with the food sample to detect its firmness. In most impact devices, using either the drop test or impact probe test mode, the fruit is impacting against a rigid sensing device, which could cause bruising to the fruit. Thai (1994) tested a soft foam sensor, whose electrical resistance properties change when being deformed, for selected fruits and vegetables. Younce and Davis (1995) developed a firmness sensor for cherries, which measured the voltage signal generated from dropping a cherry fruit onto a modified intercom speaker. Compared to other force/deformation methods, the impact method is fast and generates no or minimal damage to the fruit if the system is properly designed. The impact technique has great potential for sorting fruits and vegetables for firmness. One inherent problem with the impact method is that it measures the firmness of fruit at a particular location, which may not be representative of the overall firmness of the fruit. Multiple measurements from the same fruit are needed to overcome the property variability problem.
5.5 Conclusions The ability to measure texture accurately and quickly enables the food industry to set standards for quality and to monitor deterioration that occurs during storage and distribution. The study of chemical and physiological changes that determine texture has been underpinned by the development of methods for quantifying texture. Since texture can be defined as the
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
139
human perception of the mechanical properties of the food, most commercial and research methods to measure texture have focused on the mechanical properties of the foodstuff. The diversity of foods, the variety of attributes required to fully describe textural properties, and the changes in these attributes as the product senesces (raw fruits and vegetables) or ages (processed foods) or undergoes microbial breakdown contribute to the complexity of texture measurement. The complexity of texture can still only be fully detected and described by sensory evaluation, which involves using a panel of people who have been trained to quantify defined attributes. However, instrumental measurements are preferred over sensory evaluations for both commercial and research applications because instruments are more convenient to use, widely available, tend to provide consistent values when used by different (often untrained) people, and are less expensive than sensory panels. We reviewed the principles of instrumental texture measurements and provided some practical applications that have been reported to give guidance in selecting among the many methods that have been developed. These instrumental measurements are widely understood and can provide a common language among researchers, producers and customers (retailers or consumers). There are numerous empirical and fundamental measurements that relate to textural attributes. Mechanical methods measure functions of force, deformation and time. Destructive mechanical methods generally relate more closely to sensory evaluations than do non-destructive measurements; but, by their destructive nature, they cannot be used for sorting products. Therefore, the commodity, the purpose of the measurement, sometimes tradition, and sometimes regulations guide the choice of the textural measurement method.
5.6 References (2002) Development of a Mechanical Probe for Nondestructive Apple Firmness Evaluation (unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, USA). ABBOTT J A (1999) Quality measurement of fruits and vegetables, Postharvest Bio Tech, 15(3), 207–25. ABBOTT J A and BUTA J G (2002) Effect of antibrowning treatment on color and firmness of fresh-cut pears, J Food Qual, 25(4), 333–41. ABBOTT J A and LU R (1996) Anisotropic mechanical properties of apples, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 39(4), 1451–9. ABBOTT J A and MASSIE D R (1993) Nondestructive firmness measurement of apples, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 93-6025, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. ABBOTT J A and MASSIE D R (1995) Nondestructive dynamic force/deformation measurement of kiwifruit firmness (Actinidia deliciosa), Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 38(6), 1809–12. ABBOTT J A, MASSIE D R and WATADA A E (1982) The use of a computer with an Instron for textural measurements, J Texture Stud, 13(4), 413–22. ABBOTT J A, WATADA A E and MASSIE D R (1984) Sensory and instrument measurement of apple texture, J Am Soc Hort Sci, 109(2), 221–8. ABABNEH H A A
140
Texture in food
ABBOTT J A, LU R, UPCHURCH B L
and STROSHINE R L (1997) Technologies for nondestructive quality evaluation of fruits and vegetables. In Horticultural Reviews, Volume 20. Ed. J Janick, New York, John Wiley and Sons Inc, 1–121. ALVAREZ M D and CANET W (2000) Storage time effect on the rheology of refrigerated potato tissue (cv. Monalisa), Eur Food Res Technol, 212(1), 48–56. ALVAREZ M D, SAUNDERS D E J, VINCENT J F V and JERONIMIDIS G (2000) An engineering method to evaluate the crisp texture of fruit and vegetables, J Texture Stud, 31(4), 457–73. ANON (1976) Pilot model is 95% accurate, Am Veg Grower, 24(6), 38. ASAE (2000) Compression test of food materials of convex shape, ASAE Standard: ASAE S368.4, Am Soc Agri Eng, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. BAJEMA R W and HYDE G M (1998) Instrumented pendulum for impact characterization of whole fruit and vegetable specimens, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng 41(5), 1399–1405. BARRETT A H, NORMAND M D, PELEG M and ROSS E (1992) Characterization of the jagged stress-strain relationships of puffed extrudates using the fast Fourier transform and fractal analysis, J Food Sci, 57(1), 227–32. BARITELLE A L and HYDE G M (2001) Commodity conditioning to reduce impact bruise, Postharvest Bio Tech, 21(3), 331–9. BARTSCH J A and ASKARIAMAN E (1982) Impact characteristics of storage cabbage, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 823080, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. BERNSTEIN Z and LUSTIG I (1981) A new method of firmness measurement of grape berries and other juicy fruits, Vitis, 20(1), 15–21. BOURNE M C (1966) Measurement of shear and compression components of puncture tests, J Food Sci, 31, 282–91. BOURNE M C (1968) Texture profile of ripening pears, J Food Sci, 33(2), 223–6. BOURNE M C (1974) Textural changes in ripening peaches, J Can Inst Food Sci Tech, 7(1), 11–15. BOURNE M C (2002) Food Texture and Viscosity (Second Edition). San Diego, Academic Press. BOWER D R and ROHRBACH R P (1976) Application of vibrational sorting to blueberry firmness separation, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 19(1), 185–91. BRADY P L, MCKEITH F K and HUNECKE M E (1985) Comparison of sensory and instrumental texture profile techniques for the evaluation of beef and beef-soy loaves, J Food Sci, 50(6) 1537–9. BRATZLER L J (1949) Determining the tenderness of meat by use of the Warner-Bratzler method, Proc Recip Meat Conf, 2, 117–21. BRIGGS P D S (1998) Assessment of the condition of fruit and vegetables, US Patent No 6,435,002 B1. BRUSEWITZ G H, MCCOLLUM T G and ZHANG X (1991) Impact bruise resistance of peaches, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 34(3), 962–5. BRUSEWITZ G H, RIGNEY M P and ANZALDUA-MORALES A (1997) Fast Fourier transformation analysis of the force-displacement curve as a texture method related to fruit morphology, J Texture Stud, 28(5), 503–16. BRYANT A, USTUNOL Z and STEFFE J F (1995) Texture of Cheddar cheese as influenced by fat reduction, J Food Sci, 60(6), 1217–19, 1236. CHAMPAGNE E T, BETT K L, VINYARD B T, MCCLUNG A M, BARTON II F E, MOLDENHAUER K, LINSCOMBE S and MCKENZIE K (1999) Correlation between cooked rice texture and rapid visco analyser measurements, Cereal Chem, 76(5), 764–71. CHEN H and MARKS B P (1998) Visible/near-infrared spectroscopy for physical characteristics of cooked chicken patties, J Food Sci, 63(2), 279–82. CHEN P and TJAN Y (1996) A low-mass impact sensor for high-speed firmness sensing of fruits, AgEng 96 Paper 96F-003, Madrid, Spain, September 23–26. CHEN C M and TROUT G R (1991) Sensory, instrumental texture profile and cooking properties of restructured beef steaks made with various binders, J Food Sci, 56(6), 1457–60.
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
141
DE BAERDEMAEKER J, LEMAITRE L and MEIRE R (1982) Quality detection by frequency spectrum
analysis of the fruit impact force, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 25(1), 175–8. (1987) Theory of fruit firmness sorting by impact forces, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 30(4), 1160–66, 1171. DELWICHE M J and SARIG Y (1991) A probe impact sensor for fruit firmness measurement, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 34(1), 187–92. DELWICHE M J, MCDONALD T and BOWERS S V (1987) Determination of peach firmness by analysis of impact forces, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 30(1), 249–54. DELWICHE M J, TANG S and MEHLSCHAU J J (1989) An impact force response fruit firmness sorter, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 32(1), 321–6. DELWICHE M J, SINGH N, AREVALO H and MEHSCHAU J J (1991) A second generation fruit firmness sorter, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 916042, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. DIEHL K C, HAMANN D D and WHITFIELD J K (1980) Structural failure in selected raw fruits and vegetables, J Texture Stud, 10(4), 371–400. DIENER R G, LEVIN J H and WOLTHUIS R J (1969) An instrument for automatically measuring the firmness of red tart cherries, Food Tech, 23(2), 125–7. DIENER R G, SOBOTKA F E and WATADA A E (1971) An accurate, low cost firmness measuring instrument, J Texture Stud, 2(3), 373–84. DONAHUE D W and WORK M T (1998) Sensory and textural evaluation of Maine wild blueberries for the fresh pack market, J Texture Stud, 29(3) 305–12. DRANSFIELD E, LOCKYER D K and PRABHAKARAN P (1986) Changes in extensibility of raw beef muscle during storage, Meat Science, 16(2), 127–42. ECKHOFF S R, SUPAK W A and DAVIS A B (1988) A rapid single-kernel wheat hardness tester, Cereal Chem, 65(6), 503–8. th FEKETE A (1993) Non-destructive method of fruit elasticity determination. In Proc 5 International Symposium on Fruit, Nut, and Vegetable Production Engineering, ValenciaZaragoza, Spain, March 22–26. FERRY J D (1980) Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers (Third Edition). New York, John Wiley and Sons Inc. FINNEY E E and MASSIE D R (1975) Instrumentation for testing the response of fruits to mechanical impact, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 18(6), 1184–7, 1192. FRIEDMAN H H, WHITNEY J E and SZCZESNIAK A S (1963) The Texturometer – a new instrument for objective texture measurement, J Food Sci, 28, 390–96. GAINES C S, FINNEY P F, FLEEGE L M and ANDREWS L C (1996) Predicting a hardness measurement using the single-kernel characterization system, Cereal Chem, 73(2), 278–9. GARRETT A W, DESROSIER N W, KUHN G D and FIELDS M L (1960) Evaluation of instruments to measure firmness of tomatoes, Food Tech, 14(11), 562–4. GYASI S G, FRIDLEY R B and CHEN P (1981) Elastic and viscoelastic Poisson’s ratio determination for selected citrus fruits, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 24(3), 747–50. HALLETT I C and HARKER F R (1998) Microscopic investigations of fruit texture, Acta Horticulturae, 464, 411–16. HAMANN D D and CARROLL D E (1971) Ripeness sorting of muscadine grapes by use of lowfrequency vibrational energy, J Food Sci, 36(7), 1049–51. HAMANN D D, KUSHMAN L J and BALLINGER W E (1973) Sorting blueberries for quality by vibration, J Am Soc Hort Sci, 98(6), 572–6. HAMSON A R (1952) Measuring firmness of tomatoes in a breeding program, J Am Soc Hort Sci, 60, 425–33. HANSEN L R (1972) Development of the Armour tenderometer for tenderness evaluation of beef carcasses, J Texture Stud, 3(3), 146–64. HARKER F R and HALLETT I C (1992) Physiological changes associated with development of mealiness of apple fruit during cooling storage, HortScience, 27(12), 1291–4. HARKER F R and HALLETT I C (1994) Physiological and mechanical properties of kiwifruit tissue associated with texture change during cold storage, J Am Soc Hort Sci, 119(5), 987–93. DELWICHE M J
142
Texture in food
HARKER F R, MAINDONALD J H
and JACKSON P J (1996) Penetrometer measurement of apple and kiwifruit firmness: operator and instrument differences, J Am Soc Hort Sci, 121(5), 927–36. HOLMES R G (1979) Vibratory sorting of process tomatoes, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 796543, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. HOPKIRK G, MAINDONALD J H and WHITE A (1996) Comparison of four new devices for measuring kiwifruit firmness, N Z J Crop Hort Sci, 24(3), 273–86. HUGHES H and SEGERLIND L J (1972) A rapid mechanical method for determining Poisson’s ratio in biological materials, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 72-310, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. JAREN C, RUIT-ALTISENT M and PEREZ DE RUEDA R (1992) Sensing physical stage of fruits by their response to nondestructive impacts, AgEng 92 Paper 9211-113, Uppsala, Sweden, June 1–40. KATTAN A A (1957) Changes in color and firmness during ripening of detached tomatoes, and the use of a new instrument for measuring firmness, Proc Am Soc Hort Sci, 70, 379–83. KHAN A A and VINCENT J F V (1993) Compressive stiffness and fracture properties of apple and potato paranchyma, J Texture Stud, 24(4), 423–35. KRAMER A (1951) Objective testing of vegetable quality, Food Technol, 5(7), 265–9. LAKHANI S, GULLETT E A, FERRIER L K and HILL A R (1991) Texture analysis of Cheddar cheese made from ultrafiltered milk, J Food Qual, 14(3), 257–71. LEHMAN-SALADA L (1996) Instrument and operator effects on apple firmness readings, HortScience, 31(6), 994–7. LEPETIT J and CULIOLI J (1994) Mechanical properties of meat, Meat Science, 36(1/2), 203– 37. LICHTENSTEIGER M J, HOLMES R G, HAMDY M Y and BLAISDELL J L (1988) Impact parameters of spherical viscoelastic objects and tomatoes, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 31(2), 595–602. LU R and ABBOTT J A (1995) A transient method for determining dynamic viscoelastic properties of solid foods, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 39(4), 1461–7. LU R and SIEBENMORGEN T J (1995) Correlation of head rice yield to selected physical and mechanical properties of rice kernels, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 38(3), 889–94. LU R, CHEN Y R, SOLOMON M B and BERRY B W (1998) Tensile properties and Warner-Bratzler tenderness measurement of raw and cooked beef, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 41(5), 1431–9. LUSTIG I and BERNSTEIN Z (1987) An improved firmness tester for juicy fruit, HortScience, 22(4), 653–5. LYON B G, CHAMPAGNE E T, VINYARD B T and WINDHAM W R (2000) Sensory and instrumental relationships of texture of cooked rice from selected cultivars and postharvest handling practices, Cereal Chem, 77(1), 64–9. MAFULEKA M M, OTT D B, HOSFIELD G L and UEBERSAX M A (1991) Dry bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) hardening and the consequences of pectin methylensterase activity in storage, J Food Proc Preservation, 15(1), 1–18. MARTIN C R, ROUSSER R and BRABEC D L (1993) Development of a single-kernel wheat characterization system, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 36(5), 1399–404. MCGLONE V A and SCHAARE P N (1993) The application of impact response analysis in the New Zealand fruit industry, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 936537, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. MCCLURE J R, HOLMES R G and HAMDY M Y (1979) Inclined vibrating plate tomato sorter, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 796008, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. MCFARLANE P G and MARER J M (1966) An apparatus for determining the tenderness of meat, Food Technol, 20(6), 838–9. MEREDITH F I, LEFFLER R G and LYON C E (1990) Detection of firmness in peaches by impact force response, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 33(1), 186–8. MEULLENET J C, SITAKALIN C and MARKS B P (1999) Prediction of rice texture by spectral
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
143
stress strain analysis: a novel technique for treating instrumental extrusion data used for predicting sensory texture profiles, J Texture Stud, 30(4), 435–50. MITCHAM E J , CLAYTON M and BIASI W V (1998) Comparison of devices for measuring cherry fruit firmness, HortScience, 33(4), 723–7. MOHSENIN N N (1989) Physical Properties of Plant and Animal Materials, (Second Edition). New York, Gordon and Breach Science Publisher. MOHSENIN N N, COOPER H E, HAMMERLE J R, FLETCHER S W and TUKEY L D (1965) “Readiness for harvest” of apples as affected by physical and mechanical properties of the fruit, Penn State Univ Agri Exp Sta Bul, 721. MOHSENIN N N, JINDAL V K and MANOR A N (1978) Mechanics of impact of a falling fruit on a cushioned surface, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 21(3), 594–600. MOINY V, MEULLENET J F and XIONG R (2002) Uniaxial compression of Cheddar cheese at various loading rates and its correlation to sensory texture profiles, J Texture Stud, 33(3), 237–54. MUTUNGI G, PURSLOW P and WARKUP C (1995) Structural and mechanical changes in raw and cooked single porcine muscle fibers extended to fracture, Meat Science, 40(2), 217– 34. NAHIR D, SCHMILOVITCH Z and RONEN B (1986) Tomato grading by impact force response, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 863028, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. OCON A, ANZALDUA-MORALES A, QUINTERO A and GASTELUM G (1995) Texture of pecans measured by sensory and instrumental means, J Food Sci, 60(6),1333–6. ORTIZ-CAÑAVATE J, HOMER I, GARCIA-RAMOS F J and RUIZ-ALTISENT M (2001) Determination of firmness in a fruit packing line using a non-destructive impact sensor. In Proc 6th International Symposium on Fruit, Nut, and Vegetable Production Engineering, Potsdam, Germany, September 11–14. OZER N, ENGEL B A and SIMON J E (1998) A multiple impact approach for non-destructive measurement of fruit firmness and maturity, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 41(3), 871–6. PARKER R E, LEVIN J H and WHITTENBERGER R T (1966) An instrument for measuring firmness of red tart cherries, Mich Agri Exp Sta Quart Bul, 48(3), 471–82. PATEL N, MCGLONE V A, SCHAARE P N and HALL H (1993) “BerryBounce”: a technique for the rapid and non-destructive measurement of firmness in small fruit, Int Soc Hort Sci, 352, 189–98. PELEG M (1997) Measures of line jaggedness and their use in foods textural evaluation, Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr, 37(6), 491–518. PENFIELD M P, BARKER C L and MEYER B H (1976) Tensile properties of beef semitendinosus muscle as affected by heating rate and end point temperature, J Texture Stud, 7(1), 77– 85. PETRELL R J, MOHSENIN N N and WALLNER S (1980) Dynamic mechanical properties of the apple cortex in relation to sample location and ripening, J Texture Stud, 10(3), 217–29. PHILLIPS D M (1992) A new technique for measuring meat texture and tenderness. In Proceedings of the 38th ICoMST, Clermont-Ferrand, France, 959–62. PRUSSIA S E, ASTLEFORD J J, HEWLETT B and HUNG Y C (1994) Non-destructive firmness measuring device, US Patent No 5,372,030. PURSLOW P P (1991) Measuring meat texture and understanding its structural basis. In Feeding and the Texture of Food, Eds J F V Vincent and P J Lillford Cambridge, Cambridge Unveristy Press, 35–56. RAO M A and STEFFE J F (1992) Viscoelastic Properties of Foods. New York, Elsevier Applied Science. RODRIGO C, RODRIGO M, FISZMAN S and SANCHEZ T (1997) Thermal degradation of green asparagus texture, J Food Protection, 60(3), 315–20. ROHRBACH R P (1981) Sorting blueberries to improve fresh market shelf life, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 811501, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. ROHRBACH R P and GLASS III S W (1980) Driving point mechanical impedance of blueberries, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 23(2), 298–302.
144
Texture in food
and MAINLAND C M (1993) Accurate low cost measurement of blueberry firmness for research workers, Acta Hort, 346, 338–53. ROHRBACH R P, FRANKE J E and WILLITS D H (1982) A firmness sorting criterion for blueberries, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 25(2), 261–5. ROSS E (1949) A quantitative hardness tester for food products, Science, 109(2826), 204. SCHOMER H A and OLSEN K L (1962) A mechanical thumb for determining firmness of apples, J Am Soc Hort Sci, 81, 61–6. SCHOORL D and HOLT J E (1983) A practical method for tensile testing of apple tissue, J Texture Stud 14(2), 155–64. SHAFSHAK S A and WINSOR G W (1964) A new instrument for measuring the compressibility of tomatoes, and its application to the study of factors affecting fruit firmness, J Hort Sci, 39(4), 284–97. SHERMAN P (1970) Industrial Rheology with Particular Reference to Foods, Pharmaceuticals, and Cosmetics. New York, Academic Press. SMITH G C and CARPENTER Z L (1973) Mechanical measurements of meat tenderness using the NIP tenderometer, J Texture Stud, 4(2), 196–203. STOW J (1989) The involvement of calcium ions in maintenance of apple fruit tissue structure, J Exp Bot, 40(218), 1053–7. STRANGE E D and WHITING R C (1998) Effect of temperature on collagen extractability and Kramer shear force of restructured beef, J Food Sci, 53(4), 1224–5, 1233. STUDMAN C J and YUWANA (1992) Twist test for measuring fruit firmness, J Texture Stud, 23(2), 215–27. SUGIYAMA J, OTOBE K and KIKUCHI Y (1994) A novel firmness meter for fruits and vegetables, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 946030, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. SUHENDRO E L, ALMEIDA-DOMINGUEZ H D, ROONEY L W, WANISKA R D and MOREIRA R G (1998) Tortilla bending technique: an objective method for corn tortilla texture measurement, Cereal Chem, 75(6), 854–8. SZCZESNIAK A S, BRANDT M A and FRIEDMAN H H (1963) Development of standard rating scales for mechanical parameters of texture and correlation between the objective and sensory methods of texture evaluation, J Food Sci, 28, 397–403. TETTEH M K, PRUSSIA S E, VERMA B P and NESMITH D S (2001) Blueberry firmness measurements by FirmTech II and Hertz contact theory, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 016089, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. THAI C N (1994) Soft transducer for firmness measurement, Am Soc Agri Eng Paper 946541, St Joseph, Michigan, ASAE. TIMM E J, BROWN G K, ARMSTRONG P R, BEAUDRY R M and SHIRAZI A (1996) Portable instrument for measuring firmness of cherries and berries, Appl Eng Agri, 12(1), 71–7. VAN HECKE E, ALLA K and BOUVIER J M (1995) Texture and structure of crisp-puffed food products. I. Mechanical properties in bending, J Texture Stud, 26(1), 1–25. VERNER L (1931) Experiments with a new type of pressure tester on certain stone fruits, Am Soc Hort Sci Proc, 27, 57–62. VINCENT J F V, JERONIMIDIS G, KHAN A A and LUYTEN H (1991) The wedge fracture test: a new method for measurement of food texture, J Texture Stud, 22, 45–57. VOISEY P W (1971) The Ottawa texture measuring system, Can Inst Food Technol J, 4(3), 91–103. VOISEY P W (1976) Engineering assessment and critique of instruments used for meat tenderness evaluations, J Texture Stud, 7(1), 11–48. VOLODKEVICH N N (1938) Apparatus for measurement of chewing resistance or tenderness of foodstuff, Food Res, 3, 221–5. WOLFE R R, SINGH A K and PUTHUR P A (1980) Roll-bounce firmness separation of blueberries, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 23(5), 1330–33, 1336. WOUTERS A and DE BAERDEMAEKER J G (1988) Effect of moisture content on mechanical properties of rice kernels under quasi-static compressive loading, J Food Eng, 7(2) 83–111. ROHRBACH R P
Force/deformation techniques for measuring texture
145
and ABBOTT J A (2002) Firmness and force relaxation characteristics of tomatoes stored intact or as slices, Postharvest Bio Tech, 24(1), 59–68. YOUNCE F L and DAVIS D C (1995) A dynamic sensor for cherry firmness, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 38(5), 1467–76. ZHANG M and MITTAL G S (1993) Measuring tenderness of meat products by WarnerBratzler shear press, J Food Processing and Preservation, 17(5), 351–67. ZHANG X and BRUSEWITZ G H (1991) Impact force model related to peach firmness, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 34(5), 2094–8. ZHANG X, STONE M L, CHEN D, MANESS N O and BRUSEWITZ G H (1994) Peach firmness determination by puncture resistance, drop impact, and sonic impulse, Trans Am Soc Agri Eng, 37(2), 495–500. WU T
6 Sound input techniques for measuring texture L. M. Duizer, Massey University, New Zealand
6.1
Introduction
Acoustic emissions are an important aspect of food texture perception. Quality and acceptability of food products are often assessed based on the sounds produced during crushing or biting of the food. For crisp food products in particular, when the sound is not appropriate, the food may be considered unacceptable and of poor quality (Szczesniak, 1990). Two acoustic emission techniques exist in the literature for measuring the sounds produced by manipulation of a food product. The first is destructive testing, which, as the name implies, refers to the permanent deformation of the food such that it can no longer be used for further texture research. The second, in which sound is transmitted through a food product to obtain the natural resonant frequencies of the product, is predominantly used for the assessment of fruit ripeness and quality. Consumers subjectively evaluate fruit ripeness and quality by tapping products and listening to the sounds they make in order to assess their texture. This approach has led to the development of objective instrumental techniques for collecting the same information. This chapter will focus on the destructive and non-destructive acoustic measures of food products. The equipment required for each test will be discussed and important factors to consider will be addressed. Various applications of these tests will be presented. The chapter will conclude with a brief discussion on the types of equipment most often used as well as books referenced to aid in the understanding of the contribution of sound to textural properties of foods. Key to understanding acoustic measurements is the physics of sound and the sensation of hearing. These topics will be discussed prior to explanation of the acoustic techniques.
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
6.2
147
Sound and its detection: what is sound?
Sound originates due to the vibration of a sound source moving through its surrounding medium. During eating or compressing food, the sound source is the product being crushed. During non-destructive testing, the sound source is a signal generator attached to the food being tested. The medium through which the sound wave travels is typically air; however, in the case of nondestructive testing, the sound medium is the flesh and skin of the fruit which the sound is being transmitted through. The vibrations from the sound source cause a disturbance in the surrounding medium, setting particles in motion, and thereby transporting energy through the medium. This motion is produced due to the vibration around the equilibrium of one molecule displacing others around it. This then causes a pressure wave to be produced. The pressure wave is composed of periods of rarefaction (regions of low air pressure due to decreased particle density) and compression (regions of high air pressure due to increased particle density) (Speaks, 1999). It is this pressure wave that is detected by the ear for the perception of sound and is also detected by microphones during recording of bite sounds. All elastic objects vibrate best at natural frequencies. A natural frequency is defined as the characteristic frequency at which an elastic structure is free to vibrate (Speaks, 1999). An object can have more than one natural frequency, and this natural frequency has significant implications during both destructive and non-destructive testing. Resonance occurs when a forced frequency, such as that occurring during non-destructive testing, coincides with a natural frequency, resulting in amplification of sounds at that frequency. The resonant properties of an object are dependent on the density of the object, as well as its shape and size (Abbott et al., 1997). 6.2.1 The detection of sound Within humans, sound detection occurs via two mechanisms; bone-conduction or air-conduction. Air-conducted sound is detected via the movement of sound waves throughout the auditory system. There are three sections to the auditory system; the outer ear, the middle ear and the inner ear. The auditory canal in the outer ear functions as a funnel for incoming sound waves (Stevens and Davis, 1938). At the end of the outer ear is the tympanic membrane, or eardrum. Internal to the tympanic membrane is the middle ear. This portion of the auditory system contains the ossicles which are three small bones called the malleus, incus and stapes (commonly referred to as the hammer, the anvil and the stirrups) (Kiang and Peake, 1988). The major function of the middle ear is to ensure the efficient transfer of sound from the air to the fluid in the cochlea within the inner ear (Moore, 1982). The last section of the auditory system, the inner ear, lies within the temporal bone of the skull. Located within the inner ear is the cochlea, which contains the oval and round windows, the helicotrema, the basilar membrane and the organ of corti. The cochlea is the most important part of the auditory system. It is here
148
Texture in food
that the sound pressure variations are transformed into neural impulses (Rossing, 1990). During air-conduction, sound waves enter the auditory canal and cause the tympanic membrane (eardrum) to vibrate. The ossicles transmit the vibrations through the middle ear. The movement of the foot-plate of the stapes vibrates the membranous covering of the oval window, causing pressure changes in the cochlear fluids. The inward movement of the oval window causes a flow of fluid around the helicotrema and an outward movement of the round window. This flow of fluid causes the basilar membrane to move in waves from the base of the cochlea toward the apex or end of the cochlea. The waves build slowly, increasing in amplitude as they move down the cochlea. Upon reaching maximum amplitude, the magnitude of the waves decreases abruptly. Sounds of different frequencies produce maximum amplitude at different places along the basilar membrane. High frequency sounds produce maximum intensity displacement near the oval window with little activity further along the membrane. Low frequency sounds produce vibrations along the entire membrane, with maximum amplitude near the apex of the cochlea (Moore, 1982). Resting on the basilar membrane is the organ of corti. The organ of corti is responsible for converting mechanical activity into neural activity. Hair cells within the organ of corti translate the wave motions of the basilar membrane into nerve impulses. Sound waves are also transmitted to the inner ear via bone conduction. For bone-conduction, the vibrations of the sound source do not enter the auditory system via the auditory canal. Instead they are picked up by the bones of the skull around the middle ear. These vibrations trigger the movement of the endolymphatic fluid and the basilar membrane within the inner ear similar to the movement triggered by air-conducted sounds (Stevens and Davis, 1938)
6.3
Destructive testing
Sound is produced due to the application of a force on the food product. The cell walls of the product snap and energy is released. It is this energy moving through the air (or other sound medium) which is detected and recorded. Destructive testing has been conducted in two ways; via recording the sounds produced by the application of a force on the product either by the teeth (during biting and chewing) or by instrumental shear or compression probes (the instrumental element). To record the sound emission produced via destructive means an experimental set-up such as that shown in Figs 6.1 and 6.2 is required. Requirements for this set-up include; a means of crushing the food product (either by eating as shown in Fig. 6.1 or by crushing as shown in Fig. 6.2), a microphone interfaced with an amplifier and sometimes a filter. Attached
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
149
Amplifier
Filter Data acquisition unit
Fig. 6.1
Example of acoustic apparatus used for destructive testing when biting with teeth.
Instron testing machine
Data acquisition unit Compression probe Amplifier
Filter Sound-proof chamber
Fig. 6.2
Example of acoustic apparatus used for destructive testing by instrumental compression.
to the amplifier and filter is a computer or other data acquisition system (such as a strip chart recorder). Data analysis software or equipment is then required to analyse the collected data. Each of these pieces of equipment will be discussed in turn. The microphone selected for use should be able to detect frequencies within the audible frequency range (20–20 000 Hz). The microphone acts to convert the acoustic energy of the sound wave produced during crushing of the food into electrical voltage. The voltage signal is then amplified and filtered. Amplification increases the signal in order to process the information while filtering reduces noise and gives a smoother signal for processing. In some systems, preamplifiers and amplifiers are interfaced with the microphone for this purpose and the data is processed prior to storage. However, it is also possible to use a data acquisition unit where the amplification and filtering may be done automatically. One such system that can be used is the Powerlab system developed by ADInstruments Pty Ltd (Castle Hill, Australia). Others have developed their own proprietary data acquisition systems (Seymour and Hamann, 1984). Once the signal has been amplified (and possibly filtered) the data is stored on either audio tape (Drake, 1963; Drake, 1965; Kapur, 1971; Vickers, 1987; Dacremont et al., 1991; Dacremont, 1995) or as a data file on a computer (Lee et al., 1990; Duizer et al., 1998). If saved onto tape, Fourier transformation of the data takes place using fast Fourier transformation (FFT)
150
Texture in food
signal analysers (Lee et al., 1988; Dacremont et al., 1991; Dacremont, 1995, or audio spectrometers (Drake, 1963; Kapur, 1971). FFT determines the important frequencies (in hertz (Hz)) of the sound wave. If stored on a computer, the saved data can be analysed using computer programs for determining the FFT of the sound wave (Seymour and Hamann, 1984; Bouvier et al., 1997; Liu and Tan, 1999; De Belie et al., 2000). This experimental setup can be used for recording data during testing with individuals biting and chewing samples as well as during instrumental compression and puncture. However, there are factors specific for each type of testing situation which must be considered.
6.3.1 Recording of sounds produced during physical biting of samples In order to fully record all vibrations produced during biting of foods, both air-conducted and bone-conducted sounds must be recorded. The location of the microphone for the recording of air-conducted sounds has included placement directly in front of the mouth (Drake, 1963; Lee et al., 1988; Lee et al., 1990) or beside the ear canal (Dacremont et al., 1991; Dacremont, 1995; De Belie et al., 2000). The majority of research into bone-conducted sounds has used a contact microphone as the sound detector. However, Kapur (1971) first devised a system for measuring bone-conducted vibrations where a very fine stainless steel needle was inserted on the bone under the skin in three areas of the face; the forehead, the mastoid process and the lower border of the mandible (Kapur, 1971). This needle was attached to a phonograph cartridge for picking up the signals from the bony surfaces. Although this is an invasive approach to collecting the information, it was felt that a needle placed on the bone was the only means of measuring bone-conducted vibrations. The vibrations were recorded onto magnetic tape and the amplitude of the vibrations plotted against frequency. Now, bone-conducted sounds are recorded via a contact microphone attached to the skin above the facial bones of subjects. This is a much less invasive technique than the needle used by Kapur (1971). A contact microphone detects vibrations at the location to which it is attached and no airborne sounds are detected. The frequency range of a contact microphone for recording bone-conducted sounds does not have to be as broad as that for air-conducted sounds, as bone-conducted sounds are lower in frequency than air-conducted sounds (Dacremont, 1995). Sounds have been recorded from contact microphones placed on the cheek of the subject near the maxillar angle of the jaw directly in front of the ear (Dacremont et al., 1991) or attached to the mastoid bone directly behind the ear of the subject (Dacremont, 1995). The eating technique employed during testing has an effect on recorded acoustic signals. High-frequency air conducted sounds are most prominent during biting of samples with the front teeth. The physiological tissue of the
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
151
cheeks will dampen air-conducted sounds produced during chewing food with the back molars (Dacremont et al., 1991). Also, open mouth chewing results in louder sound recordings than close mouthed chewing during recording of both air-conducted sounds and bone-conducted sounds as vibration transmission through the bone increases when biting with an open jaw (Lee et al., 1990; Hashimoto and Clark, 2001). When recording bone-conducted sounds, care must be taken to ensure that only the bite sounds are being recorded. When the teeth come into contact with each other during biting, an increase in the recorded sound amplitude has been noted (Hashimoto and Clark, 2001). It is important when evaluating physiological acoustic responses that the placement of the microphone and the eating technique (bite vs chew, open mouth vs closed mouth) be carefully considered for correlating acoustic results with sensory measures. When analysing bone-conducted sounds, it is important to note that the acoustic properties of this sound may be altered due to the resonant frequency of the mandible. Kapur (1971) showed that the jaw resonates at 160 Hz meaning that recordings at this frequency may be louder than what is actually heard during chewing. This has been further supported by Dacremont et al. (1991) who noted that when bone- and air-conducted sound recordings are combined to match what is heard by an individual during chewing, the boneconducted sounds are attenuated at 160 Hz.
6.3.2 Recording of acoustics produced during mechanical testing One of the stated advantages of recording an acoustic signature by mechanical testing is the reproducibility and consistency of mechanical tests (Mohamed et al., 1982; van Hecke et al., 1998). However, it is important that the instrumental test selected simulates the conditions to which a food is subjected during chewing (Mohamed et al., 1982). Factors such as the type of probe used and the speed of the crosshead during testing must be carefully considered to ensure that the instrument adequately mimics the sensations occurring in the mouth during chewing. Various instruments and probes have been used for the production of acoustic signatures via mechanical crushing. These have included the Instron Universal Testing Machine with a compression probe (Roudaut et al., 1998) or a Kramer shear cell (Seymour and Hamann, 1988), the Steven’s testing machine with a compression probe (Tesch et al., 1995) as well as other proprietary instruments (Mohamed et al., 1982; Al Chakra et al., 1996; Liu and Tan, 1999). Researchers have argued that mechanical tests such as puncture and compression are similar to tooth impact and molar action during mastication (Van Hecke et al., 1998; Liu and Tan, 1999). However, more recent debates point out that there is a difference between strain that occurs during chewing compared to that possible in instrumental tests (van Vliet, 2002). In order to remove extraneous noise from the collected signature during testing, the samples and the probe should be placed in an insulated chamber,
152
Texture in food
as shown in Fig. 6.2 (Mohamed et al., 1982; Seymour and Hamann, 1988; Tesch et al., 1995). This prevents the noise of the machine from interfering with the acoustic signal of the sample. This noise appears to originate from the electronic drive control as well as the toothed belts and drive mechanism required to move the probe into the sample. Additionally, background noise present in the room can be eliminated by using the insulated chamber. In order to ensure that instrumental acoustic recordings are similar to the acoustics produced during biting, a similar rate of fracture should occur. Sharp cracking sounds occur due to the high energy sound waves produced when a material fractures rapidly and is broken (Bruns and Bourne, 1975). On average, a human compression rate is 20 mm.s–1 (Bourne, 1982) whereas, instrumental compression varies between 0.3 mm.s–1 (Roudaut et al., 1998) and 3.33 mm.s–1 (Seymour and Hamann, 1988) depending on the instrument used. When allowing the sample to break at its own rate, Mohamed et al. (1982) observed that a Malteser fractured at a rate of 83.4 mm.s–1. The fracture rates may have an impact on the resulting acoustic properties of the sample, and care should be taken to ensure that consistency in the rate of compression or shear occurs.
6.3.3 Analysis of sound waves produced during destructive testing The sound wave recorded during destructive testing is presented as a plot of amplitude vs time. An example of an amplitude–time plot of sounds produced during biting of an extruded snack product stored at water activities of 0.11 and 0.44 is shown in Fig. 6.3. The sound wave from the 0.11 water activity sample represents the sounds made when biting a crisp product and the sound wave from the 0.44 water activity sample represents the sound made when biting a less crisp product. There are visual differences apparent between the two curves. The crisp product in Fig. 6.3(a) has more peaks as well as having peaks of a higher amplitude than the less crisp product in Fig. 6.3(b). Many different properties of sound waves have been measured and correlated with sensory properties, and a list of these acoustic parameters published in food literature is shown in Table 6.1. The amplitude of the sound wave refers to the amount of energy the sound source produces. A high amount of energy is reflected in a high-amplitude wave and a low amount of energy is reflected in a low-amplitude wave. The amount of energy transported across a given area per unit of time is known as the sound intensity (measured in decibels or dB) (Speaks, 1999). This measure, and its related measure, sound pressure level (also measured in dB), are related to the perceived loudness of the sound, a more subjective measure than the measured sound intensity and sound pressure (Rossing, 1990). There is a great deal of variability between individuals in terms of how loud a sound is perceived to be. In general, for one individual, the more intense the sound, the louder it is perceived as being. This will vary between individuals due to differences in ability to detect sounds because of age as well as other physiological variables inherent
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
153
15
10
Amplitude (mvolts)
5
0
–5
–10
–15 0
1000
2000 3000 Time (µs) (a)
4000
5000
15
Amplitude (mvolts)
10
5
0
–5
–10
–15 0
1000
2000
3000 4000 Time (µs)
5000
6000
7000
(b)
Fig. 6.3
Sound waves produced while biting extruded corn-based samples stored at water activities of (a) 0.11 and (b) 0.44.
154
Texture in food
Table 6.1
Acoustic parameters used to define crisp products
Author
Parameter
Drake (1965)
Mean frequency Bite time Sound level at 1.2 kHz Equivalent continuous sound level (Leq) Mean height of the peaks (mhp) Duration of sound Number of peaks (NP) Mean sound pressure (N/m2) Mean sound pressure level (dB) Acoustic intensity (watts/m2) Sound level (dB) for each chew Total sound level (dB) Frequencies Fractal analysis
Mohamed et al. (1982) Edmister and Vickers (1985); Vickers (1987) Seymour and Hamann (1988)
Lee et al. (1998) Lee et al. (1990) Dacremont (1995) Duizer et al. (1998)
Averaged over frequency ranges of: 0.5–3.3 kHz Averaged over frequency ranges of: 0.5–3.3 kHz Sum over frequency ranges of: 0.5–3.3 kHz
to a person. Additionally, different frequencies of sounds are perceived to be louder or softer than other frequencies (Rossing, 1990). The amplitude–time plot of sounds collected during destructive testing has been described as a jagged curve (Vickers and Bourne, 1976). And in fact, some of the measures of the amplitude–time curve can be used to characterise the jaggedness of the curve (such as number of peaks and mean height of the peaks). A technique which can characterise the jaggedness of peaks, and has recently been applied to food research, is fractal analysis (Barrett et al., 1992; Barrett et al., 1994; Duizer et al., 1998). Fractal analysis has been defined as a quantitative technique for assessing the overall ruggedness or jaggedness of irregular objects (Barrett et al., 1992). Briefly, fractal analysis involves the use of mathematical algorithms to determine the degree of jaggedness of a line in order to give a fractal dimension of the line. An area around the line is measured and, through various iterations of the algorithm, the space occupied by the line within that area is determined. This space is plotted against the measured area and the slope of the linear relationship is determined. The resulting number is the fractal dimension. The fractal dimension of a jagged line can range from one, which is a smooth line, to two, which occurs when the line is so jagged that it occupies the entire area being measured by the algorithm. Although there are many different algorithms which can be used for fractal analysis, the algorithm most often used for acoustic research is the Kolmogorov algorithm. This algorithm is a box counting technique that involves dividing the signature into a grid and counting the number of squares which contain
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
155
a part of the object. The size of the boxes of the grid is halved and again the occupied squares are counted. This process continues for numerous iterations. The size of the boxes cannot be smaller than the resolution of the object (Russ, 1994). The slope of a log:log plot of the number of filled boxes vs the size of the box gives the Kolmogorov fractal dimension. For an object to be truly fractal, it must be self-similar. This means that any part of the object cannot be distinguished from the whole object or another part of the object (i.e. it has the same scaling factor in all directions). In the case of an acoustic signature, it is not possible to achieve self-similarity due to restrictions in sampling rate. Despite this, Barrett et al. (1992) and Tesch et al. (1995) concluded that it was possible to use fractal analysis as an objective measure of the degree of jaggedness of acoustic signatures. In this instance, the fractal dimension must be termed ‘apparent’ rather than ‘true’. Frequency is an integral part of an acoustic signature. The frequency of the vibratory motion of the sound wave is the rate at which the particles in the medium vibrate as the wave moves through the surrounding medium. It is measured in hertz (Hz) where one hertz equals one vibration per second (Speaks, 1999). The particles within the sound medium vibrate at the same frequency at which the sound source vibrates. The objective frequency measurement of a sound corresponds with the subjective measure of pitch (Rossing, 1990). A high-frequency sound source is perceived to have higher pitch than a low-frequency sound source. The frequency of the sound is determined using FFT. During Fourier analysis, the original data points are transformed into underlying frequencies. These frequencies are then plotted as amplitude vs frequency. From the plot, it is possible to identify special or important frequencies as these are characterised by higher amplitude on the plot. FFT plots of the sound waves shown in Fig. 6.3 are shown in Fig. 6.4. The sample stored at a water activity of 0.11 which is a more crisp sample shows more high frequency peaks (Fig. 6.4(a)) than the sample stored at a water activity of 0.44, a less crisp sample (Fig. 6.4(b)). The frequencies of sound have been used to compare various textural properties in order to obtain a better understanding of how the characteristics are perceived (Mohamed et al., 1982; Dacremont, 1995).
6.4
Non-destructive testing
Non-destructive sonic transmission tests measure the dynamic resonant behaviour in the audio-frequency range of the products. This is based on the principle of resonance, where the object vibrates vigorously at a particular frequency. For each resonant frequency there is one (and sometimes more than one) vibration mode. This mode and the frequency can provide information regarding the mechanical properties of the food.
156
Texture in food 0.000 20
Amplitude (volts)
0.000 15
0.000 10
0.000 05
0.000 00 0
5000
10 000
15 000
20 000
25 000
Frequency (Hz) (a) 0.000 20
Amplitude (volts)
0.000 15
0.000 10
0.000 05
0.000 00 0
5000
10 000
15 000
20 000
25 000
Frequency (Hz) (b)
Fig. 6.4 Power spectrum analysis of sound waves produced while biting extruded corn-based samples stored at water activities of (a) 0.11 and (b) 0.44.
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
157
In the sonic transmission test developed by Abbott et al. (1968) the signal generator produces a pulse signal of uniform amplitude over a variety of consecutive frequency ranges. This is interfaced with an acoustic driver which imparts vibrational energy through the fruit, supported on a pedestal. An accelerometer attached on the opposite side of the fruit detects the vibrations which are converted to a signal and analysed via FFT. Due to the timeconsuming nature of the test, the acoustic impulse technique has been developed (Yamamoto et al., 1980). In the experimental set-up for the acoustic impulse technique, a microphone replaces the accelerometer. The microphone does not require attachment to the fruit, thereby eliminating the effect of detector placement on resonant frequencies. Additionally, in place of a signal generator, a ball pendulum is swung into the fruit at an equatorial location, thereby producing the sounds which are picked up by the microphone and analysed for resonant frequencies. A number of commercial bench top machines for non-destructive testing of fruit (such as the Acoustic Firmness Sensor™ by Aweta BV, The Netherlands) have been produced and high-speed machines for grading of fruit on packing lines are imminent. The test location around the fruit and the holding position of the fruit does not have an effect on the resonance frequencies but does affect their amplitude (Chen et al., 1992). Additionally, the hitting strength and location of the microphone do not have an effect on the peak frequency recorded during testing (Yamamoto et al., 1980). Fruit shape will have an effect on resonance and it has been recommended that three measurements be recorded and averaged in order to reduce the error due to variance in fruit shape (Chen and De Baerdemaeker, 1993).
6.4.1 Analysis of data collected during non-destructive testing The resonant frequencies resulting from the sound input signal have been used to calculate a stiffness factor of the fruit (Eq. 6.1). Abbott et al. (1968) found the second resonant frequency to be related to changes in the apple texture. This frequency was found to be the most reproducible, being less affected by the position of the driver and pickup than the other natural frequencies. The inclusion of mass in this stiffness coefficient equation compensates for the effect of the size of the apple on the resonant frequencies recorded. S = f 2m
[6.1]
where f 2 is the second frequency squared and m is the mass of the sample in grams. Others (Cooke and Rand, 1973) have modified this equation to that shown in Eq. 6.2. However, Abbott et al. (1997) indicate that this stiffness coefficient equation is designed for fruit with a large variation in sizes and may not provide any more useful results for fruit with small variations in size than the original equation.
158
Texture in food
S = f 2m2/3
6.5
[6.2]
Application of sound measurement techniques
Both destructive and non-destructive acoustic results have been applied to various food products in order to gain an understanding of the texture and quality of these products. In particular, destructive testing has provided key information regarding the perception of various textures of food while nondestructive testing has allowed for the determination of stiffness, leading to the evaluation of fruit quality. 6.5.1 The use of acoustics for understanding crispness The fact that crushing sounds might have an effect on the perception of texture was first suggested by Drake (1963). He proposed that when correlated to sensory data, vibrations produced during compression of foods could be helpful in the area of texture research. In 1976, Vickers and Bourne first published a psychoacoustical theory of crispness that led to numerous research publications exploring the use of acoustics and their relationship to the perception of crispness, crunchiness and crackliness of food products. All of the tests conducted have resulted in non-recoverable damage to the tested food samples. Structurally, crisp foods have a tendency to be cellular (Brennan et al., 1974). When a force is applied to such a cellular product, each cell ruptures, creating a sound and the overall rupture pattern produces an irregular frequency and amplitude signature (Vickers and Bourne, 1976; Vickers and Christensen, 1980; Vickers, 1981, 1987). Crisp food products can be classified into two general categories based on their structure; wet crisp (those which have water in their cells such as carrots, apples, water chestnuts and cabbage) and dry crisp (those which contain air within their cells such as toast, biscuits, extruded products and potato chips). The sound pattern generated by foods in these product categories is similar, and can be best characterised by the loudness of the sound and the number of sound occurrences. This is shown by the significant correlations between crispness and the log (number of peaks × mean height of the peaks) for wet and dry crisp products (r = 0.89 for wet and dry together, r = 0.95 for wet alone and r = 0.88 for dry alone (Edmister and Vickers, 1985)). Acoustics have been applied much more for understanding the textural properties of dry crisp products than wet crisp products, and the majority of published literature has been in the area of crispness perception of dry snack foods such as potato chips or extrusions (Mohamed et al., 1982; Vickers, 1987; Seymour and Hamann, 1988; Duizer et al., 1998). One reason for this is that dry crisp products have a texture which is easy to manipulate, usually through modifying the water activity, while keeping the structural properties of the samples constant.
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
159
Mohamed et al. (1982) suggested that crispness of potato chips could be understood through combining acoustical results with force–deformation results. Various instrumental parameters have been applied to regression equations in order to test this theory. These instrumental parameters include the ratio of work done during fracture to total work (Mohamed et al., 1982), the total work to fracture (Seymour and Hamann, 1988) and peak force (Vickers, 1987). The regression equations developed by these authors and the products studied are shown in Table 6.2. Each of the three regression equations shown in Table 6.2 has strong predictive ability, with R2 values greater that 0.85, indicating that a measure of force as well as the acoustic element is important for prediction of crispness. The negative relationship between crispness and peak force indicates that the hardness or toughness of the potato chip samples studied must counteract the auditory sensation of crispness, leading to the belief that crispness must have a vibratory component and a non-vibratory component and the non-vibratory component is counteracting crispness (Vickers, 1987).
6.5.2 The use of acoustics to differentiate between crispness, crunchiness and crackliness In addition to developing an understanding of the sensation of crispness, acoustic techniques have been used to differentiate between the sensation of crispness and those of crunchiness and crackliness. Crunchiness has been shown to be strongly related to crispness (Vickers and Wasserman, 1979; Vickers, 1981), and various definitions indicate their close association. Recently, Fillion and Kilcast (2002) proposed that the crispness of fruit and vegetables can be defined as ‘a light and thin texture producing a sharp clean break with Table 6.2
Regression equations used for predicting crispness of dry crisp products
Author
Foods tested
Regression equation
R2 value
Mohamed et al. (1982)
Sponge fingers, wafer biscuits, crisbakes, ice cream wafers, Maltesers varying in water activity
Log crispness = 0.59 + 0.49 log (Leq) + 0.50 (WF/WT)
R2 = 0.85
Vickers (1987)
Potato chips
Oral crispness = –15.6 + 5.35 (np) + 133 (mhp) – 6.21 (peak force)
R2 = 0.98
Seymour and Hamann (1988)
Pringles potato chips
Crispness = 9.904 – 0.134 (work) + 0.025 (mean sound pressure 2.6–3.3 kHz)
R2 = 0.95
Crunch twists
Crispness = 16.47 – 0.064 (force) – 0.110 (sound pressure level 0.5–1.2 kHz)
R2 = 0.95
Note: Leq is continuous sound level; WF /WT is the ratio of work done during fracture to total work; np is number of peaks and mhp is mean height of peaks
160
Texture in food
a high-pitch sound when a force is applied’. Crunchiness was associated with products with hard, dense textures producing a repeated loud, lowpitched sound (Fillion and Kilcast, 2002). During sensory evaluation of apples, crispness has been defined as ‘the amount and pitch of sound generated when the sample is first bitten with the front teeth’ and crunchiness as ‘the amount of sound generated when chewing with the back teeth’ (Harker et al., 1997). Vincent et al. (2002) differentiated between crispness and crunchiness based on the amount of force applied to the samples, with crisp products fracturing after the application of a lower force than that required for crunchy products. Certainly, there appears to be an association between the two textures. To differentiate between crispness and crunchiness, Vickers (1984a) asked judges to bite various crisp and crunchy foods and to indicate whether they were crisp or crunchy and then, in a separate experiment, to indicate which sample in a pair of crisp-crunchy samples was higher in pitch during biting. Foods which were classified as more crisp than crunchy nearly always produced a higher pitched sound than those which were classified as more crunchy than crisp. This was later confirmed by Dacremont (1995) who, through FFT of acoustic data produced during biting of food products, determined the actual frequencies of the sounds produced. Amongst the food products tested were extruded flat breads (crisp), carrot (crunchy) and dry biscuits (crackly). Crisp foods generated high-pitched frequencies (from 5–12.8 kHz) and these sounds were predominantly air-conducted. In contrast, crunchy foods produce low-frequency sounds when bitten, with frequencies within the frequency range of 1.25–2 kHz (Dacremont, 1995). Crackliness is not a texture term found frequently in sensory evaluation literature. Vickers (1984b) stated that a crackly product could be characterised by the number of sharp repeated noises produced when a food is bitten and chewed. This could be judged using either oral tactile or auditory cues. Dacremont (1995) showed that crackly food products produce a great deal of low-frequency sounds, similar to crunchiness, and can be differentiated from crunchiness because of the high level of bone-conducted sounds generated during biting.
6.5.3 The use of acoustics for the determination of fruit quality Both destructive testing and non-destructive acoustic testing have been used to determine the textural properties of fruit, predominantly firmness and crispness. Both of these properties have been related to the quality and ripeness of the fruit. For apples, texture is an important characteristic that directly influences consumer preferences for crisp, juicy fruit (Liu and King, 1978). However, for many other fruits changes in hardness are used to follow the ripening process. As the fruit ripens, it becomes softer, starch converts to sugars, acidity is lost and flavour develops. In these cases, consumers tend to have distinct preferences for softer and riper fruit (Jaeger et al., 2003). The different consumer needs from apples (crisp and hard texture) and other fruit
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
161
(ripe and flavourful) explain the different research approaches. In apples, both destructive and non-destructive approaches have been used to investigate the properties of fruit. However, for most other fruit, the focus has been on the use of non-destructive measurements to monitor the softening/ripening process. There has been a concentration of this type of research in fruit but not in manufactured foods, due to the fact that fruits are subject to high levels of biological variability (Dever et al., 1995). Therefore, there is commercial interest in methods that can sort for products that are more homogenous in quality. Manufactured foods do not face this high level of product variability. Using destructive acoustic techniques, a method for classifying apples based on crispness has been suggested (De Belie et al., 2000). Cox’s Orange Pippin apples were stored under various conditions to modify the texture. The apples were grouped into mealy and crisp categories and the sounds produced during biting were recorded. Crisp apples produced sounds which were higher in frequency than mealy apples. Through the use of principle components analysis of the analysed frequencies, the two groups of fruit could be separated based on frequencies, indicating that acoustics can be useful for the determination of fruit texture and therefore quality. The authors stated that with more extensive experiments, including sensory panels, the acoustic technique could be used to develop a method for objective crispness evaluation of apples, removing the necessity for trained sensory panels. Others, however, have concluded that chewing sounds were no better than other instrumental tests (in particular, puncture testing) for measuring apple texture (Harker et al., 2002). The stiffness coefficient calculated from results of the non-destructive acoustic tests has been related to firmness and ripeness measurements of fruit. The relationship between the stiffness coefficient and sensory firmness/ ripeness has been determined for Starking Delicious apples (r = 0.66) (Yamamoto et al., 1980), Golden Delicious apples (r = 0.6) (Abbott et al., 1992), Red Delicious apples immediately after picking (r = 0.84) (Finney, 1971a). Although different sensory scales have been used for the sensory portion of the research, each of these tests showed a strong relationship between the stiffness coefficient and sensory scores. Acceptability has also been related to the stiffness coefficient. Van Woensel et al. (1987) showed that the acceptability of Golden Delicious apples could be related to the stiffness coefficient, stating that it was important to find a relationship between the stiffness coefficient and the acceptability of the fruit for the consumer. While apples are a relevant subject to review in terms of methodologies for measuring crispness, other fruit are perhaps not so relevant. Research on measuring firmness as a method to follow ripening has involved kiwifruit (McGlone and Shaane, 1993), avocado (Peleg et al., 1990) and stonefruit (Finney, 1971b; Landahl et al., 2000). Furthermore, a number of studies have compared the ability of non-destructive acoustic testing to grade for quality with that of trained inspectors used to assess fruit against official
162
Texture in food
standards for tomatoes (Schotte et al., 1999) and apples (Abbott et al., 1992). Schotte et al. (1999) found that graders from different fruit auction houses showed a large amount of variability in the use of the scale. All results had to be rescaled prior to comparison with the stiffness data. The stiffness score was related to tomato firmness (R2 = 0.79), and the authors felt that it was a more objective technique than grading and could be used without requiring a rescaling of data.
6.6
Future trends
The area of acoustic research shows a promising future. Crispness perception has been studied from a mechanical and acoustical perspective and the contribution of the acoustic properties to the perceived crispness has largely been addressed. The focus can now shift to the relationship between these crispness components and structure. Acoustics will play a large role in furthering the understanding of crispness and how, by manipulating various structural properties of the food product, its acoustic properties and therefore its perceived crispness can be altered. Additionally, the use of acoustics during processing is an emerging trend. One area where this is receiving attention is in the acoustic emissions produced during extrusion of food products (Francis et al., 1998). The motor output of an extruder produces certain sounds when extruding samples. The output changes as the texture of the product changes. This is due to the amount of work that the extruder must do in order to produce the samples. An experienced extruder operator can tell by listening to the machine if it is making the correct noises during production and then modify the settings on the extruder (screw speed, feed rate) in order to ensure that the machine is making the correct noise. Extruder sounds have been recorded and related to the physical properties of the final extruded product (Francis et al., 1998). Quantifying these noises and analysing their frequencies can be a useful tool for predicting the quality attributes of the processed food product.
6.7
Sources of further information and advice
The following is a list of equipment commonly used for recording chewing sounds. It is compiled from published research papers and is not exhaustive. Inclusion in this list is by no means indicative of the quality of the equipment. It is merely an indication that it has been used for acoustic recordings. 6.7.1 Microphones Condenser microphones used to record air-conducted sounds include the AKG C414EB or Bruel and Kjaer 4133. These microphones have a suitable
Sound input techniques for measuring texture
163
frequency range for recording air-conducted sounds (within the audible frequency range). Contact microphones for recording bone-conducted sounds include the AKGC401B and the Shadow 4001. These microphones do not have as broad a frequency range as the condenser microphones; however, such a broad range is not required for bone-conducted sounds 6.7.2 Data acquisition equipment for recording and analysis of sound waves Various amplifiers have been interfaced with the microphones. Most often this amplifier is a Bruel and Kjaer. These amplifiers must be interfaced either with signal conditioners or to a computer with appropriate software. For recording and analysis of acoustic sound waves, one software package which has been mentioned is Soundedit (Macromedia, San Francisco, California). This software can be used to set up the testing situation as well as for analysis of the data by FFT. Another means for recording the data is to use a Powerlab (ADInstruments, Castle Hill, Australia) with associated software (Chart4) for analysis of data. This data acquisition unit has built in amplifiers and filters therefore the microphone can merely be plugged into the system for data collection. 6.7.3 Data analysis FFT can be analysed using any number of data programs. SigmaPlot (SPSS Inc, Chicago, Illinois) and MATLAB (The MathWorks Inc, Natick, Massachusetts) can be used to convert incoming signals into frequencies. 6.7.4 Useful references For further understanding of fractal dimensions, the book Fractal Surfaces by Russ (1994) provides an overview of fractal analysis. This book also contains a computer program which can be used for calculating fractal dimensions. Additionally, the fractal dimension of a sound wave can be calculated by using MATLAB (The MathWorks Inc, Natick, Massachusetts). There are also many books which can be of use for gaining an understanding of hearing, and the physics of sound. Two books which this author has found quite useful are: The Science of Sound by Rossing (1990) and An Introduction to Sound by Speaks (1999).
6.8
References
ABBOTT J A, BACHMAN G S, CHILDERS R F, FITZGERALD J V
and MATUSIK F J (1968) Sonic techniques for measuring texture of fruits and vegetables, Food Technol, 22(5), 635– 45.
164
Texture in food
ABBOTT J A, AFFELDT H A and LILJEDAHL L A (1992) Firmness measurement of stored ‘Delicious’
apples by sensory methods, Magness-Taylor, and sonic transmission, J Amer Soc Hort Sci, 117(4), 590–595. ABBOTT J A, LU R, UPCHURCH B L and STROSHINE R L (1997) Technologies for non-destructive quality evaluation of fruits and vegetables, Hort Reviews, 20, 1–120. AL CHAKRA W, ALLAF K and JEMAI A B (1996) Characterization of brittle food products: Application of the acoustical emission method, J Text Studies, 27(3), 327–48. BARRETT A H, CARDELLO A V, LESHER L L and TAUB I A (1994) Cellularity, mechanical failure, and textural perception of corn meal extrudates, J Text Studies, 25(1), 77–95. BARRETT A M, NORMAND M D, PELEG M and ROSS E (1992) Characterization of the jagged stress-strain relationships of puffed extrudates using the fast Fourier transform and fractal analysis, J Food Sci, 57(1), 231–2, 235. BOUVIER J M, BONNEVILLE R and GOULLIEUX A (1997) Instrumental methods for the measurement of extrudate crispness Agro Food Industry Hi Tech, Jan/Feb, 16–19. BOURNE M C (1982) Food Texture and Viscosity. New York, Academic Press. BRENNAN J G, JOWITT R and WILLIAMS A (1974) Sensory and instrumental measurement of brittleness and crispness, Proceedings of the IV International Congress of Food Science and Technology, 2, 130–43. BRUNS A J and BOURNE M C (1975) Effects of sample dimensions on the snapping force of crisp foods, J Text Studies, 6(4), 445–58. CHEN H and DE BAERDEMAEKER J (1993) Effect of apple shape on acoustic measurements of firmness, J Agric Eng Res, 56(3), 253–66. CHEN P, SUN Z and HUARNG L (1992) Factors affecting acoustic responses of apples, Trans of the ASAE, 35(6), 1915–20. COOKE J R and RAND R H (1973) A mathematical study of resonance in intact fruits and vegetables using a 3-media elastic sphere model, J Agric Eng Res, 18(2), 141–57. DACREMONT C (1995) Spectral composition of eating sounds generated by crispy, crunchy and crackly foods, J Text Studies, 26(1), 27–43. DACREMONT C, COLAS B and SAUVAGEOT F (1991) Contribution of air- and bone-conduction to the creation of sounds perceived during sensory evaluation of foods, J Text Studies, 22(4), 443–56. DE BELIE N, DE SMEDT V and DE BAERDEMAEKER J (2000) Principal component analysis of chewing sounds to detect differences in apple crispness, Postharvest Biology and Technology, 18(2), 109–19. DEVER M C, CLIFF M A and HALL J W (1995) Analysis of variation and multivariate relationships among analytical and sensory characteristics in whole apple evaluation, J Sci Food and Agric, 69(3), 329–38. DRAKE B K (1963) Food crushing sounds. An introductory study, J Food Sci, 28, 233–41. DRAKE B K (1965) Food crushing sounds: comparisons of objective and subjective data, J Food Sci, 30(3), 556–9. DUIZER L M, CAMPANELLA O and BARNES G R G (1998) Sensory, textural and acoustic characteristics of extruded snack food products, J Text Studies, 29(4), 397–411. EDMISTER J A and VICKERS Z M (1985) Instrumental acoustical measures of crispness in foods, J Text Studies, 16(2), 153–67. FILLION L and KILCAST D (2002) Consumer perception of crispness and crunchiness in fruits and vegetables, Food Qual Pref, 13(1), 23–9. FINNNEY E E (1971a) Dynamic elastic properties and sensory quality of apple fruit, J Text Studies, 2(1), 62–74. FINNEY E E (1971b) Random vibration techniques for non-destructive evaluation of peach firmness, J Agric Eng Res, 16(1), 81–7. FRANCIS G, SELLAHEWA J and CHESSARI C (1998) Use of acoustic emissions as a novel on-line sensor to evaluate the quality of extruded products, Presented at the 3rd Annual Smart Extrusion Seminar, Sydney, Australia. HARKER F R, REDGEWELL R J, HALLETT I C, MURRAY S H and CARTER G (1997) Texture of fresh fruit, Hort Reviews, 20, 121–224.
Sound input techniques for measuring texture HARKER F R, MAINDONALD J, MURRAY S H, GUNSON F A, HALLETT I C
165
and WALKER S B (2002) Sensory interpretation of instrumental measurements 1.Texture of apple fruit, Postharvest Biology and Technology, 24(3), 225–39. HASHIMOTO K and CLARK G T (2001) The effect of altering jaw position on the transmission of vibration between the skull and teeth in humans, Arch Oral Biol, 46(11), 1031–8. JAEGER S R, ROSSITER K L, WISMER W V and HARKER F R (2003) Consumer-driven product development in the kiwifruit industry, Food Qual Pref, 14(3), 187–98. KAPUR K K (1971) Frequency spectrographic analysis of bone conducted chewing sounds in persons with natural and artificial dentitions, J Text Studies, 2(1), 50–61. KIANG N Y S and PEAKE W T (1988) Physics and physiology of hearing. In Stevens’ Handbook of Experimental Psychology Second edition. Eds R C Atkinson, R J Herrnstein, G Lindzey and R D Luce, New York, John Wiley and Sons, 297–302. LANDAHL S, DE BELIE N, DE BAERDEMAEKER J, PEIRS A and NICOLAÏ B M (2000) Non-destructive and destructive firmness measurements on apples and peaches, Agricontrol 2000: IFAC International Conference on Modelling and Control in Agriculture, Horticulture and Post-Harvest Processing, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 297–302. LEE W E, DEIBEL A E, GLEMBIN, C T and MUNDAY E G (1988) Analysis of food crushing sounds during mastication: frequency-time studies, J Text Studies, 19(1), 27–38. LEE W E, SCHWEITZER M A, MORGAN G M and SHEPHERD D C (1990) Analysis of food crushing sounds during mastication: total sound level studies, J Text Studies, 21(2), 165–78. LIU F W and KING M M (1978) Consumer evaluations of McIntosh apple firmness, Hortsci, 13(2), 162–3. LIU X and TAN J (1999) Acoustic wave analysis for food crispness evaluation, J Text Studies, 30(4), 397–408. MCGLONE V A and SHAANE P N (1993) The application of impact response analysis in the NZ fruit industry, Am Soc Agr Eng, Paper#93-6537. MOHAMED A A A, JOWITT R and BRENNAN J G (1982) Instrumental and sensory evaluation of crispness: I – In friable foods, J Food Eng, 1(1), 55–75. MOORE B J (1982) An Introduction to the Psychology of Hearing, (Second Edition). London, Academic Press. PELEG K, BEN-HANAN U and HINGA S (1990) Classification of avocado by firmness and maturity, J Text Studies, 21(2), 123–39. ROSSING T D (1990) The Science of Sound (Second Edition). Boston, M A Addison-Wesley Publishing Company. ROUDAUT G, DACREMONT C and LE MESTE M (1998) Influence of water on the crispness of cereal-based foods: acoustic, mechanical, and sensory studies, J Text Studies, 29(2), 199–213. RUSS J C (1994) Fractal Surfaces, New York, Plenum Press. SCHOTTE S, DE BELIE N and DE BAERDEMAEKER J (1999) Acoustic impulse-response technique for evaluation of modelling of firmness of tomato fruit, Postharvest Biol and Tech, 17(2), 105–15. SEYMOUR S K and HAMANN D D (1984) Design of a microcomputer based instrument for crispness evaluation of food products, Trans of the ASAE, 27(4), 1245–50. SEYMOUR S K and HAMANN D D (1988) Crispness and crunchiness of selected low moisture foods, J Text Studies, 19(1), 79–95. SPEAKS C E (1999) Introduction to Sound: Acoustics for the Hearing and Speech Sciences (Third Edition). San Diego, Singular Publishing Group. STEVENS S S and DAVIS H (1938) Hearing: Its Psychology and Physiology, New York, John Wiley and Sons. SZCZESNIAK A S (1990) Texture: is it still an overlooked food attribute? Food Technol, 44(9), 86–95. TESCH R, NORMAND M D and PELEG M (1995) On the apparent fractal dimension of sound bursts in acoustic signatures of two crunchy foods, J Text Studies, 26(6), 685–94. VAN HECKE E, ALLAF K and BOUVIER J M (1998) Texture and structure of crispy-puffed food products: Part II Mechanical properties in puncture, J Text Studies, 29(6), 617–32.
166
Texture in food
VAN VLIET T (2002) On the relation between texture perception and fundamental mechanical
parameters for liquids and time dependent solids, Food Qual Pref, 13(4), 227–36. and DE BAERDEMAEKER J (1987) Relation between mechanical properties of apple fruit and sensory quality, J Food Process Eng, 9(3), 173–89. VICKERS Z M (1981) Relationships of chewing sounds to judgements of crispness, crunchiness and hardness, J Food Sci, 47(1), 121–4. VICKERS Z M (1984a) Crispness and crunchiness – a difference in pitch?, J Text Studies, 15(2), 157–63. VICKERS Z M (1984b) Crackliness: relationships of auditory judgments to tactile judgments and instrumental acoustical measurements, J Text Studies, 15(1), 49–58. VICKERS Z M (1987) Sensory, acoustical, and force-deformation measurements of potato chip crispness, J Food Sci, 52(1), 138–40. VICKERS Z M and BOURNE M C (1976) A psychoacoustical theory of crispness, J Food Sci, 41(5), 1158–64. VICKERS Z M and CHRISTENSEN C M (1980) Relationships between sensory crispness and other sensory and instrumental parameters, J Text Studies, 11(3), 291–307. VICKERS Z M and WASSERMAN S S (1979) Sensory qualities of food sounds based on individual perceptions, J Text Studies, 10(4), 319–32. VINCENT J F V, SAUNDERS D E J and BEYTS P (2002) The use of critical stress intensity factor to quantify ‘hardness’ and ‘crunchiness’ objectively, J Text Studies, 33(2), 149–59. YAMAMOTO H, IWAMOTO M and HAGINUMA S (1980) Acoustic impulse response method for measuring natural frequency of intact fruits and preliminary applications to internal quality evaluation of apples and watermelons, J Text Studies, 11(2), 117–36. VAN WOENSEL G, WOUTERS A
7 Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement S. Millar, Campden and Chorleywood Food Research Association, UK
7.1
Introduction
Along with appearance, the texture of foodstuffs is a key defining quality parameter. It is important not only in terms of consumer acceptance (whether an apple has a crisp and refreshing or dry and woolly mouthfeel, for example) but also for quality assurance during processing. Where internal damage to fruit and vegetables may be determined during processing, for example, appropriate decisions on the best use of the material may be taken. Although the rapid quantification of food texture attributes would be desirable, therefore, the technological means of effecting such determinations are not universally available. One of the suite of spectroscopy techniques which has become widely used over the last 30 or so years is near infrared spectroscopy (NIR). This technique continues to have many advantages as a practical tool under commercial situations. The reasons for this are rapid assessment times, the ability to obtain a number of separate pieces of information from one analysis (protein content, moisture content and texture of wheat for example), the relatively low cost of the analysers and the generally rugged nature of the equipment when compared with many of the high end, laboratory-based spectroscopic systems. This chapter reviews the use of NIR and related spectroscopic techniques for the assessment of food texture. A general introduction detailing the underlying principles of spectroscopy leads into a section describing the use of the near infrared region. There then follows specific reviews of the technique’s application in three main areas: cereals, fruits and vegetables, and muscle foods. Finally the current state of knowledge is summarised and some likely future trends highlighted.
168
Texture in food
7.1.1 Background to spectroscopy The term spectroscopy encompasses a wide range of techniques which have as their common denominator the function of determining the interaction of electromagnetic radiation with matter. Two main aspects of this interaction are recognised: • the absorption of energy by particular atoms, molecules or bonds; • the reflection and refraction of the incident energy as a result of its interaction with the physical structure of the material to be assessed. Although the importance of both aspects is generally recognised by those using one of the spectroscopic techniques, it is usually the former which achieves greater prominence. Readers will undoubtedly be familiar with examples such as ultraviolet (UV) and fluorescence spectroscopy [an example being the detectors commonly used in high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) systems for the quantification of proteins], visible spectroscopy, where electronic transitions which result in colour as perceived by human beings may be quantified, and infrared spectroscopy, where energy is absorbed in accordance with the modes of vibration of particular bonds. When used as a means of determining texture, however, it is generally the second of these aspects which is the more important, i.e. the interaction of the incident energy with the physical structure of the material to be assessed. As the way in which this interaction takes place is dependent on the wavelength of the energy source as well as the physical structure of the material, different spectroscopic techniques have differing levels of sensitivity to the physical aspects of the material. The subject of this chapter is the use of NIR spectroscopy for the assessment of food texture. This technique is interesting in this context as it provides a good balance of physical and chemical interactions with the incident energy. In fact, in many cases it is the strength of the interaction with the physical aspects of the samples assessed which becomes problematic in the use of the technique. An example of this is in the assessment of properties of materials derived from cereal sources such as wheat flour. Here, the accuracy of the determination of protein content is dependent on the effectiveness of the techniques used to reduce the sizeable effects of light scattering on the spectrum. Conversely, however, this feature makes the technique a strong one for application to the problem of assessing food texture.
7.1.2 Near infrared spectroscopy The region of the electromagnetic spectrum associated with NIR is broadly that covering 800–2500 nm (Fig. 7.1). The region from 800–1100 nm is often referred to as the near visible and represents energy having wavelengths just slightly longer than those generally seen as red by the human eye. The use of this region is primarily in those instruments used to determine the proportion of light transmitted through food materials. There is some debate
Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement 169 0.6 0.5
Log 1/R
0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 800
970
1140
1310
1480
1650
1820
1990
2160
2330 2500
Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 7.1
Example NIR spectrum of ground wheat.
as to how much of the passage of energy is due to true transmission as opposed to a combination of transmission and reflectance. Nevertheless, the penetrating power of the energy in this region is greater than that at longer wavelengths (Osborne et al., 1993). The region beyond 1100 nm is recognised as the true near infrared and is primarily used for sample assessment by diffuse reflectance. NIR instruments contain a source of radiation in the NIR region of the spectrum, a means of splitting this energy into wavelengths or wavelength regions and a system of detection to allow the energy which has been reflected from or has passed through the sample to be quantified. More expensive instruments generally have systems that allow continuous spectra to be recorded which have regular spacing between wavelengths. Such instruments tend to be more commonly used in research laboratories or technical centres where their flexibility justifies their higher cost. For more general usage, however, simpler instruments tend to be used, particularly in situations where a high degree of robustness for everyday use is required. Although there are a number of operating principles which may be used, these instruments tend to be based around the use of interference filters which capture discontinuous ‘slices’ of information from the spectrum. The wavelengths represented by the filters are generally pre-selected during manufacture in accordance with known regions of absorbance for the most important constituents such as protein, moisture and lipid. These and other absorbers may be quantified as a function of the modes of vibration generated in particular bonds as a result of the absorption of radiation at specific wavelengths. The most important absorbers are N–H (protein), O–H (moisture) and C–H (lipids). The NIR region does not contain any of the fundamental modes of vibration for such molecules, this information being found in the mid infrared region [covering the region 4000–400 cm–1
170
Texture in food
or 2500–25 000 nm (by convention the NIR region is referred to in terms of wavelength while the mid infrared is measured as a function of frequency)]. However, second and third overtones as well as combination bands due to interference between different modes of vibration may be found, and it is these that form the basis of the technique. Generally speaking, the physical characteristics of a given sample tend to cause variation in the overall spectral response such that during calibration for physical characteristics wavelengths are chosen which contain little chemical information but which will still vary systematically with the structural components of a food system. Irrespective of whether the information of interest is related to the chemical or physical characteristics of the sample, however, a means of relating it to meaningful units is required. NIR information is by nature empirical and generally needs to be calibrated against an accepted reference method to allow it to be used in a meaningful way. As a result, this process becomes defining in the subsequent performance. The precision of the reference method chosen (as well as the precision of the NIR technique), the meaningfulness (or otherwise) of the method for description of the parameter of interest, as well as the underlying relationship between the spectral data and the parameter of interest all impact on the accuracy and precision of the final calibration developed. Consequently, great care must be taken at this stage and, even where this is the case, an inappropriate choice of reference method may result in disappointing results which, although apparently due to the NIR method, actually have as root cause the inadequacy of the method to which the spectral output has been calibrated.
7.2
Application of NIR to cereals and their products
In many cases, cereals undergo a milling or comminution step to reduce their particle size for further processing. The way in which cereals are transformed during this stage is a function of a wide range of physical characteristics including size and shape. However, for a number of cereal species, the texture of the grain determines how the grain will function at subsequent stages of the production chain (Evers and Millar, 2003). Depending on the manifestation of the textural attributes in question, a number of different descriptors have been used. Examples include horny/flinty as opposed to mealy for maize and vitreous versus mealy for barley. Both these ‘scales’ have a component related to grain appearance, with vitreous grains tending to appear so due to the relative lack of ‘void’ regions in the endosperm, the central plant storage reserves, resulting in greater density. In contrast, mealy grains are those where air spaces in the endosperm cause light scattering which gives rise to a more diffuse appearance. Perhaps the most interesting cereal in this context, however, is wheat which not only exhibits variation in endosperm density as described above (Fig. 7.2) but also a separate phenomenon commonly termed as ‘hardness’.
Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement 171
(a)
(b)
Fig. 7.2 Examples of (a) vitreous and (b) mealy wheat grains.
The existence of these two descriptor scales for wheat texture and the assertion that they did not result from the same underlying cause (Simmonds, 1974) has been recognised for some time. However, the functional importance of these characters has arguably been recognised for as long as wheat has been milled. Hard milling grains require longer conditioning times (the process by which a controlled amount of water is allowed to penetrate the grain to ease the subsequent milling process) prior to milling and ultimately results in flour and intermediate products having larger, more angular particles which flow more easily than those from soft milling wheats. When examined microscopically, flour particles milled from hard wheats exhibit particles where the endosperm cells may be fractured randomly across the plane of the cell. This contrasts with those from soft wheats where a greater proportion of free, undamaged starch granules result (Greer and Hinton, 1950). Within the endosperm cells, starch granules are contained within a protein matrix which is more or less continuous depending on how vitreous the grains are. The way in which forces are transmitted to starch granules during milling is clearly a function of grain hardness as hard milling wheats result in more damaged starch granules. This term relates to apparently irreversible changes in starch granule physical structure which allow the granules to absorb more water and to be more susceptible to enzymatic attack. Up to a point this is desirable in wheats for breadmaking as they allow more water to be included (increasing yield) and result in sugars being available for yeast to feed on. Harder wheats are thus favoured for breadmaking. It could be argued on this evidence that the strength of the protein matrix or starch granules must vary between hard and soft milling wheats. In fact, Simmonds (1974) demonstrated that this was not the case, the relative strengths being similar. It was some time later that workers at the former Flour Milling and Baking Research Association (FMBRA), now part of Campden and Chorleywood Food Research Association (CCFRA), demonstrated that a suite of proteins having molecular weights of approximately 15 kDa could be extracted from water washed wheat starch (Greenwell and Schofield, 1986,
172
Texture in food
1989). When separated using electrophoresis, the band associated with these proteins was more intense for starches from soft milling wheats than those classified as hard milling. When durum wheats were assessed (the very hard wheats used for pasta production), the band was completely absent. Initially the ‘protein’ was termed friabilin due to the apparent relationship with grain texture, but further work has classified these proteins as part of the puroindoline family (Rahman et al., 1994). It was postulated that these proteins constituted a ‘non-stick’ coating which aided the release of starch from protein in the grain during milling. Subsequent work has demonstrated the genetic basis for this phenomenon (Giroux and Morris, 1997), and it remains an active area of research for cereal science. The use of NIR as a means of assessing the texture of cereals was recognised at an early stage of the adoption of the technique. Although the earliest work applying NIR to food and agriculture-based applications used instruments which collected spectra for whole cereal grains, it was not until diffuse reflectance instruments became available that the technique gained mass appeal (Osborne et al., 1993). This change not only provided the technique for use in applications such as the determination of the composition of the ground material, it also opened the way for rapid assessment of the particle size of the meal and thus the physical characteristics of the whole grains with respect to grinding. It is the light scattering properties of particulate material which result in the spectral variation which may be related to particle size. As the particle size of a given material decreases, the effective pathlength of the incident radiation through particles decreases causing a decrease in absorption by the chemical components within each particle. As light scatter is inversely proportional to mean pathlength, smaller particles lead to more scattered radiation. The scatter results from the many reflections and refractions at all the optical interfaces within the sample (Birth and Hecht, 1987). The net effect of this is that more, smaller particles show greater reflectance (less absorbance and more scatter) than few, large particles. As NIR data are commonly expressed as the log reciprocal of reflectance (to give an approximation of absorbance), this means that few, large particles give higher log 1/R values than many, small particles. This is consistent across all wavelengths in terms of order even if the absolute magnitude of the differences may vary, and so in theory any wavelength may be used to effect a measurement of particle size. In practice, however, those wavelengths which contain limited information about chemical absorbers give the best results as the information about physical characteristics and chemical composition is not combined. Early work showed that NIR could be used to discriminate between samples of hard and soft milling wheat (Hart, 1976; Williams, 1979). Later workers developed calibrations for both wheat and wheat flour using a number of reference measurements including sieving values (Osborne et al., 1981, 1982), pearling resistance (Svensson, 1981) and grinding resistance (Starr et al., 1981). Given the compositional information that may be collected at some wavelengths, the use of the difference in response between composition-
Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement 173
dependent and composition-independent wavelengths may be used to develop calibrations (Wetzel, 1984). In 1986, a method based on a new approach for the determination of wheat hardness was developed and approved by the American Association of Cereal Chemists (AACC). This approach was novel in that the NIR data were not related to another definable reference method (such as the proportion of material passing through a sieve of defined aperture). To ensure agreement between instruments, a set of five hard and five soft milling wheat standards were developed to allow ‘calibration’ by users (AACC, 1994). Subsequently workers (Windham et al., 1993; Le Bars et al., 1994) developed moisture correction factors to take into account the effect of differing moisture contents on the way in which grain is reduced in size during grinding. Although this part of the chapter has been concentrated on the assessment of wheat endosperm texture due to its widespread importance, the technique has been applied to the assessment of texture of other cereals, such as maize (Eckhoff and Paulsen, 1996). However, the widespread reporting of these applications has been lesser, even though the principles of the use of the technique are essentially the same.
7.3
Application of NIR to fruit and vegetables
While the texture of cereals tends to be an indicator of processing requirements, the texture of fruit and vegetables may often be used as an indicator of ripeness or the presence of damage. In some cases, it also may be used for the prediction of end-use properties such as when differentiating between waxy and floury potatoes. Fundamental to producer and processor, however, is an understanding of the integrity of the material produced or delivered. This has historically been a difficult area for the entire supply chain, particularly as in some cases bruising or damage may go undetected until the consumer purchases the item in question resulting in, at the very least, disappointment in the product. Interestingly one of the very first applications for NIR was to the assessment of egg contents and quality (Osborne et al., 1993). While this is clearly not in the fruit or vegetable area, it serves as an illustration of the way in which the technique may be applied in such situations. Although the penetrating power of the true NIR region is limited, that of the near visible is better. This has recently been used by a team which has developed a new method to allow the interior of fruit and vegetables to be assessed more accurately. The method is called the V-method and uses a system of transmitted and reflected light to ‘virtually peel’ fruit or vegetables where skin or peel serves to render the contents ‘invisible’ (Krivoshiev et al., 2000)). The method may be understood with reference to Fig. 7.3. Here the composite nature of the transmitted light passing through a schematic diagram of a fruit or vegetable may be seen. The incident energy interacts with the peel or skin on both sides of the object as well as the fleshy interior. By using
174
Texture in food Peel Flesh
T ≈ TA TO TB IA
TA 45°
RA
TO
TB 45°
IB
RB
Fig. 7.3 Diagrammatic representation of the V-method. Where: IA and IB represent the incident radiation from either side of the tuber; RA and RB represent the reflected radiation from either side of the tuber; TA, TO and TB represent the transmittance of light through peel from either side of the tuber (TA and TB) and the flesh (TO). The contribution of the peel (RA and RB) is removed from the optical density of the entire tuber (OD) to allow an estimation of the optical density of the flesh (ODO) using an equation of the general form: ODO ≈ a0 + a1 OD + a2 ln(1/RA) + a3 ln(1/RB)
reflected energy directed at both sides of the object, however, a description of the spectral properties of the external surface may be derived and thus removed from the transmitted energy. Thus the spectra of the flesh may be separated from that of the peel or skin. To date, this method has been applied to both potatoes and apples for the assessment of internal bruising of the materials. For potatoes, a set of 194 samples has been assessed within which the tubers were classified into one of three groups. The first of these (C1) comprises tubers which have low levels of internal damage and which may be used for structured products such as chips or potato crisps where appearance is of paramount importance. The second class (C2) contains those tubers which do show some evidence of internal damage but which may be used for comminuted or homogenised food products such as pureed potatoes. Finally, those tubers which were so severely damaged as to make them unsuitable for food use were classified in a third group (C3). Spectra covering the range 600–1100 nm were collected from the tubers both before and after peeling. The tubers were then dissected and classified according to the system described. Discriminant analysis was then used to classify the tubers on the basis of their spectral properties. The overall classification accuracy of these models was 83% which indicated the strong potential of the V-method for the routine assessment of potato quality (Krivoshiev et al., 2002). This work is still developing but the potential for instrumentation to rapidly grade fruit or vegetables with peel or skin is clear. Additionally, the technique will undoubtedly be extended to the assessment of other compositional characteristics, such as moisture or sugar contents, because the tissue or tissues of most direct interest, the flesh, may be isolated spectroscopically.
Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement 175
Another group of workers has reported the development of NIR calibrations for a range of properties of potatoes as assessed sensorily (Van de Laer et al., 2000). In addition to flouriness, the disintegration of the cooked flesh and its granulation could be modelled by NIR. As for many of the other applications reported, the accuracy of this calibration was limited in comparison with compositional analysis of lower moisture foods. Nevertheless, the level of performance was consistent with the repeatability errors of the sensory analysis and so would be unlikely to be improved upon unless significant improvements in the precision of reference determinations was demonstrated. More traditional approaches have previously been applied to the measurement of a number of parameters for fruit and vegetables. In many cases, the calibrations developed have been targeted at the measurement of overall acceptability whether using instrumental or sensory means of quality assessment. An example of how a range of attributes may be used for the assessment of global parameters is the use of NIR for the assessment of the maturity of vining peas (Scotter, 1996). The traditional method for assessing pea maturity is the Martin Tenderometer, an instrument which is essentially a shear force gauge. This instrument has been widely-used in Europe since the 1950s for assessment of the readiness for harvest of pea crops (Arthey and Dennis, 1991). A programme of work was undertaken at CCFRA under which calibrations were developed for the UK pea producers for pea firmness (calibrated against Tenderometer data), alcohol insoluble solids (AIS), which was closely correlated with Tenderometer data, and a number of sensory parameters. The work on peas was subsequently extended to include sweetcorn. Spectra were collected from both intact as well as macerated samples. Calibrations developed using this latter material were shown to be slightly better (Scotter, 1998), although the performance of calibrations representing both approaches was sufficient to allow them to be used commercially. In addition, calibrations were developed for a number of sensory attributes of peas including skin and flesh firmness and mealiness (increasing levels of starch result in more mealy textures). The textural characteristics for a number of other types of produce have also been studied by workers at CCFRA. For avocados, penetrometer values were supplied by commercial graders and processors along with samples for NIR scanning. Calibrations were developed which had acceptable levels of performance. However, it was found that the performance of these calibrations was highly dependent on information collected from the visible region of the spectrum (Scotter, 2000). Studies assessing the penetration depth of NIR radiation on intact avocados demonstrated that the skin contained inorganic material which largely blocked that from the true NIR region. It would seem, therefore, that the performance of these calibrations was not dependent on a straightforward relationship between NIR data and, for example, the texture of the flesh. Rather there appears to be a secondary correlation between colour of the skin or flesh and the texture of the flesh. Calibrations for the measurement of the texture of apples have also been
176
Texture in food
reported, again using penetrometer readings as the reference method (Cho et al., 1996). In this work, calibrations were developed using both full range scanning instrumentation as well as a less expensive filter instrument. Scanning instrumentation has also been used to determine nectarine and strawberry texture (Scotter, 2000). This latter work also included an interesting study on the use of NIR as a technique for grading potatoes on the basis of whether their eating quality was described as waxy or floury. A number of other groups have published on the use of NIR for the rapid assessment of apple texture, including one where the emphasis was on the use of the technique for rapid grading (Moons and Dardenne, 2000). One of the most interesting studies has used the technique for the assessment of changes in texture over time rather than simply at a fixed point (Sohn and Cho, 2000). The texture of both intact (including peel) and peeled fruits was determined using a texture analyser as well as a fruit hardness tester. The measurement of firmness of nectarine flesh by NIR has also been reported (Costa et al., 2000). Although the reference method was not described in detail and so the units of measurement and their errors may not be readily understood, an R2 of 0.75 was reported which indicates some potential for rapid grading or screening applications. Nevertheless, such squared correlation coefficients should be recognised as being at the lower end of acceptability for NIR calibration performance. It was interesting to note, however, that the performance for measurement of flesh firmness was superior to that for Brix (the % sucrose by weight of a solution at a given temperature) which, being dependent on the composition of the fruits, may have been expected to exhibit better performance than measures of texture. Increased reliance on spectroscopic techniques for grading of produce is likely to be a trend for the future. A survey presented at the 9th International NIR Conference in Verona, indicated that the grading of high-moisture plant products such as intact fruit and vegetables had the potential to be a multimillion $US industry (Kays et al., 2000). Although the instruments commercialised to date represent only a fraction of this potential, as technological challenges with instrumentation design and manufacture are addressed, it is clear that this will be a very significant development over the next years and decades. In 1999, the estimated grading cost was < $0.02 per product unit and it may be envisaged that this cost can only fall as the takeup of the technology increases.
7.4
Application of NIR to meat
The texture of meat is important ultimately as an indicator of acceptability to the consumer when eaten (Morgan et al., 1991). However, the appearance and texture of meat post mortem is influenced by the slaughter process as well as by the inherent characteristics of the meat. This becomes a stage,
Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement 177
therefore, at which measurement and ultimately control are desirable. Two conditions may arise as a result of increased pre-slaughter stress endured by the animal. Low pH caused by a rapid development of stress in pigs prior to slaughter results in PSE (pale, soft, exudative) meat which has an open texture. Where the stress is of a longer duration, DFD (dark, firm, dry) meat results in both pork and beef. In this case the meat has a higher than average pH and the muscle fibres are more closely packed. The texture of meat following slaughter has been investigated using spectroscopic means, and a number of instruments have been commercialised on this basis. Generally, such systems rely on changes in texture causing differences in the light scattering nature of the muscle fibres. Typically this has been achieved for the interior of joints using visible spectroscopy with wavelengths in the range 600–690 nm (Fortin, 1989) and at 700 nm (Murray et al., 1989) having been suggested. In addition, devices based on colorimetric assessment rather than information about a specific wavelength have also been developed (Irie and Swatland, 1992). More recently, however, NIR has also been applied to the assessment of meat texture. Given the published use of visible spectroscopy, it is not surprising that a number of studies have also been directed at the development of NIR calibrations for the assessment of meat tenderness (Lanza, 1983; Hildrum et al., 1994; Byrne et al., 1998). For the most part, these studies have resulted in calibrations relating meat texture to NIR properties for samples assessed at the same point in time. The last of these, however (Byrne et al., 1998), investigated the use of NIR spectra collected at earlier times post mortem to predict the tenderness of beef aged for 14 days. This approach was extended by Rødbotten et al. (2000) who developed NIR calibrations based on an assessment of meat tenderness using a Warner Bratzler shear-press device for beef M. longissimus dorsi stored for two and seven days. In this case, however, NIR spectra were collected both pre and post mortem. Although further work was felt to be required, the results indicated that the method may have potential. In addition to the use of instrumented methods of assessing tenderness, Hildrum and Nilsen (2000), developed calibrations against sensory measures. Both reference method approaches gave results having squared correlation coefficients in the range ~0.5–0.7. While again this would be seen as being at the lower limit of acceptability for use of such calibrations, the potential of the technique for such assessment was further demonstrated. In addition to work using the higher wavelengths, the near visible region (750–1100 nm) has also been applied to the analysis of meat tenderness (Venel et al., 2001). When a range of M. longissimus dorsi samples was assessed, calibrations for tenderness (Warner-Bratzler shear force) gave the best performance, although this indicated limited potential for a global calibration solution (R = 0.51). However, when specific calibrations were developed for segregated sample sets (e.g. separated by animal grade or pHu), slightly better performance was observed.
178
Texture in food
The storage history of meat is also an important consideration for processors in terms of both microbiological safety and the texture of the meat. The use of ‘fresh’ or ‘frozen’ labels has, historically, been challenging due to difficulty in defining general temperature limits on which to base a definition (Windham et al., 1996). Nevertheless, these workers investigated NIR as a means of assessing the storage conditions under which chicken breast meat had been kept. The meat was classified as falling into one of five classes representing samples stored at 4, 0, –3, –12 and –18 °C. Discriminant analysis based on principal components analysis (PCA) functions was shown to allow correct classification of 85 and 75 % of the unfrozen and frozen chicken breasts respectively.
7.5
Application of NIR to other foods
7.5.1 Pulses In addition to cereals, the textural attributes of pulses have also been characterised. An example of this is the prediction of the cooked texture of chickpeas (Flinn et al., 1998). Cooked samples were compressed in bulk using an Instron instrument and the results expressed as newtons per seed. NIR calibrations were developed for both whole and ground, uncooked material. Interestingly, the spectra collected from whole chickpeas gave slightly better performance than those for ground material. 7.5.2 Milk-based products Although compositional analysis of milk by NIR is commonly practised, there have been few reports on the use of spectroscopic methods for the assessment of the texture of milk based products such as yoghurts or cheese. However, there is evidence that such applications may be of interest as both NIR and UV (ultraviolet)/VIS (visible) spectroscopy have been applied to the analysis of the onset of clotting in milk (Giangiacomo et al., 1998). It was felt that, although the texture of the material changed as coagulation occurred, the ability of NIR to follow such variation was dependent on the changes in the amount of free water generated due to the differences in structure. 7.5.3 Chocolate Fourier transform NIR spectroscopy (FT-NIR) has also been applied to the assessment of a range of chocolate quality parameters including viscosity ∨ ∨ ( Tarkosová and Copíková, 2000). The calibration performance was encouraging although the cross-validation results were poorer than expected. This may have been due to the relatively low (n = 84) number of samples used for calibration development. Nevertheless as a rapid indication of the
Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement 179
flow properties of chocolate during processing, this may have significant value.
7.6
Conclusions and future trends
The use of spectroscopic approaches for texture measurement may at first seem counter-intuitive to many readers as many of these techniques have traditionally been seen as tools to probe the chemistry of materials rather than their physical structures. Nevertheless, certain regions of the electromagnetic spectrum allow the interaction of light with the physical structure of the material to be quantified relatively easily. Both the visible and near infrared regions contain relevant information for this purpose as has been demonstrated by many of the papers cited in this chapter. The application of NIR to the assessment of cereal grain texture is not that surprising given the fact that the technique was developed extensively as a result of its adoption as the method of choice for rapid analysis of grain protein and moisture contents. Applying the technique to particle size and ultimately textural attributes was a natural consequence of this. There are two key areas of interest in this scientific field for the future. The first is the extension of the technique when applied to powders to include assessment of particle size distributions as has been previously demonstrated by Hareland (1994). The second is the estimation of grain texture from the whole grain without recourse to grinding. This is already a commercial reality and, although detailed results have yet to be published, it appears that the accuracy is less than that achieved using ground material. Nevertheless, improvements in these calibrations are likely to be the next step. The assessment of fresh produce quality using spectroscopic approaches is well-established scientifically and appears to be gaining momentum commercially. There have been considerable gains in this area, most notably in the Far East where in-store grading of produce has been reported. One of the areas in which future development may be envisaged is through the use of techniques such as virtual peeling to obtain a more precise estimate of the spectral contribution of the flesh alone rather than the combined peel and flesh. Although less widely used, the application of spectroscopic techniques to meat quality assessment has been reported. The use of visible spectroscopy or colorimetry has been acknowledged while NIR approaches have also been reported. The advantage of the NIR technique in having the ability to estimate meat composition may actually have resulted in the technique having a lower level of application to the assessment of textural properties. It would seem logical to suggest, therefore, that the combination of these approaches will continue to grow in significance. Finally, it is surprising to see few reported attempts to apply spectroscopic approaches to the assessment of dairy product texture. It should be recognised,
180
Texture in food
however, that its use for the compositional analysis of products such as cheese is more common. It may only be a matter of time, therefore, before its application to texture analysis becomes more widespread.
7.7
Sources of further information
7.7.1 Other books There have been many books covering the application of NIR to analysis of foods with those cited below being good general introductions to the area. Practical NIR Spectroscopy with Applications in Food and Beverage Analysis. Longman Scientific & Technical, Longman House, Harlow, Essex, England. Near Infrared Technology in the Agricultural and Food Industries. American Association of Cereal Chemists, Inc., 3340 Pilot Knob Road, St Paul, MN, USA.
7.7.2 Journals Journal of Near Infrared Spectroscopy. NIR Publications, 6 Charlton Mill, Charlton, Chichester, West Sussex, England. Applied Spectroscopy. Society for Applied Spectroscopy, 201B Broadway Street, Frederick, MD 21701-6501, USA.
7.8
References
American Association of Cereal Chemists (AACC) (1994) Wheat Hardness as Determined by Near-Infrared Reflectance. AACC Method 39-70A. ARTHEY D and DENNIS C (1991) Vegetables Processing. Glasgow and London, Blackie; 18– 20. BIRTH G S and HECHT H G (1987) The physics of near infrared reflectance. In Near Infrared Technology in the Agricultural and Food Industries. Eds P Williams and K Norris, St Paul, MN, American Association of Cereal Chemists, Inc., 1–15. BYRNE C E, DOWNEY G, TROY D J and BUCKLEY D (1998) Non-destructive prediction of selected quality parameters of beef by near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy between 750 and 1098 nm, Meat Science, 49, 399–409. CHO R K, KWON Y K, LEE K H and IWAMOTO M (1996) Application of near infrared spectroscopy for quality evaluation of an intact apple. In AMC Davis and P Williams Eds Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Montréal, Canada, 6–11 August 1995 Chichester, NIR Publications, 629–31. COSTA G, NOFERINI M, ANDREOTTI C and MAZZOTTI F (2000) Non-destructive determination of soluble solids and flesh firmness in nectarines by near infrared spectroscopy. In AMC Davis and R Giangiacomo Eds, Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Verona, Italy, 13–18 June, 1999, Chichester, NIR Publications, 863–866. ECKHOFF S R and PAULSEN M R (1996) Maize. In Cereal Grain Quality. Eds R J Henry and P S Kettlewell, London, Chapman & Hall, 77–112.
Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement 181 EVERS A D and MILLAR S J
(2003) Cereal grain structure and development: some implications for quality, Journal of Cereal Science, 36, 261–84. FLINN P C, BLACK R G, IYER L, BROUWER J B and MEARES C (1998) Estimating the food processing characteristics of pulses by near infrared spectroscopy, using ground or whole samples, Journal of Near Infrared Spectroscopy, 6, 213–20. FORTIN A (1989) Detection of PSE pork under field conditions using the Colormet registered meat probe, Proceedings of the International Congress of Meat Science and Technology, 35, 195–200. GIANGIACOMO R, LIZZANO R, BARZAGHI S, CATTANEO T M P and BARROS A S (1998) NIR and other luminometric methods to monitor the primary clotting phase of milk, Journal of Near Infrared Spectroscopy, 6, 205–12. GIROUX M J and MORRIS C F (1997) A glycine to serine change in puroindoline b is associated with wheat grain hardness and low levels of starch-surface friabilin, Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 95, 857–64. GREENWELL P and SCHOFIELD J D (1986) A starch-granule protein associated with endosperm softness in wheat, Cereal Chemistry, 63, 379–80. GREENWELL P and SCHOFIELD J D (1989) The chemical basis of grain hardness and softness. In H Salovaara Ed., Wheat End-use Properties, Proceedings of the 1989 International Association of Cereal Science Technology Symposium, Helsinki, Helsinki Press, 59– 72. GREER E N and HINTON J J C (1950) The two types of wheat endosperm, Nature, 165, 746– 48. HARELAND G A (1994) Evaluation of flour particle size distribution by laser diffraction, sieve analysis and near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy, Journal of Cereal Science, 21, 183–90. HART H V (1976) Protein determination in (home-grown) wheat by the Infra Alyzer, FMBRA Bulletin, 6, 192–204. HILDRUM K I and NILSEN B N (2000) Near infrared reflectance spectroscopy for the assessment of meat tenderness. In AMC Davis and R Giangiacomo Eds, Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Verona, Italy, 13–18 June, 1999, Chichester, NIR Publications, 855–7. HILDRUM K I, NILSEN B N, MIELNIK M and NAES T (1994) Prediction of sensory characteristics of beef by near-infrared spectroscopy, Meat Science, 38, 67–80. IRIE M and SWATLAND H J (1992) Relationships between Japanese pork colour standards and optical properties of pork before and after frozen storage, Food Research International, 25, 21–30. KAYS S J, DULL G G and LEFFLER R G (2000) Challenges and opportunities in the use of near infrared for the analysis of intact, high moisture products. In AMC Davis and R Giangiacomo Eds, Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Verona, Italy, 13–18 June, 1999, Chichester, NIR Publications, 841–47. KRIVOSHIEV G P, CHALUCOVA R P and MUKAREV M IV (2000) Seeing through layers, NIR News, 11, 7–11. KRIVOSHIEV G, CHALUCOVA R, DAHM D, MILLAR S, EVANS D, GEGOV Y, BOJILOV P and LUNGOV A (2002) Application of the method “seeing through layers” to improve the accuracy of potato sorting, The 11th International Diffuse Reflectance Conference, August 10–16, Chambersburg, PA. LANZA E (1983) Determination of moisture, protein, fat, and calories in raw pork and beef by near infrared spectroscopy, Journal of Food Science, 48, 471–4. LE BARS C B, BROWN G and CURTIS P (1994) The influence of moisture content on wheat hardness testing, Chorleywood Digest, 141, 98–101. MOONS E and DARDENNE P (2000) Determination of internal apple quality by non-destructive visible and near infrared spectroscopy. In AMC Davis and R Giangiacomo Eds, Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 9th International
182
Texture in food
Conference, on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Verona, Italy, 13–18 June, 1999. Chichester, NIR Publications, 785–9. MORGAN J B, SAVELL J W, HALE D S, MILLER R K, GRIFFIN D B, CROSS H R and SHACKLEFORD S D (1991) National beef tenderness survey, Journal of Animal Science, 69, 3274–83. MURRAY A C, JONES S D M and TONG A K W (1989) Evaluation of the Colormet reflectance meter for the measurement of pork muscle quality. Proceedings of the International Congress on Meat Science and Technology, 35, 188–94. OSBORNE B G, DOUGLAS S and FEARN T (1981) Assessment of wheat grain texture by near infrared reflectance measurements on Bühler-milled flour, Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 32, 200–202. OSBORNE B G, DOUGLAS S and FEARN T (1982) The application of near infrared reflectance analysis to rapid flour testing, Journal of Food Technology, 17, 355–63. OSBORNE B G, FEARN T and HINDLE P H (1993) Near Infrared Spectroscopy in Food Analysis. Harlow, Essex, Longman Scientific & Technical. RAHMAN S, JOLLY C J, SKERRITT J H and WALLOSHECK A (1994) Cloning of a wheat 15-kDa grain softness protein (GSP). GSP is a mixture of puroindoline-like polypeptides, European Journal of Biochemistry, 223, 917–25. RøDBOTTEN R, NILSEN B N and HILDRUM K I (2000) Prediction of beef quality attributes from early post mortem near infrared reflectance spectra. In AMC Davis and R Giangiacomo Eds., Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference, on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Verona, Italy, 13–18 June, 1999, Chichester, NIR Publications, 809–12. SCOTTER C N G (1996) Approaches to the measurement of fruit and vegetable quality parameters using near infrared spectroscopy. In AMC Davis and P Williams Eds, Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Montréal, Canada, 6–11 August 1995, NIR Publications, Chichester, 625–8. SCOTTER C N G (1998) Fruit and vegetable quality measurement, New Food, 1(1), 57–60. SCOTTER C N G (2000) Rapid non-destructive assessment of fruit and vegetable quality by near infrared (NIR) spectroscopy, CCFRA R&D Report,104. SIMMONDS D H (1974) Chemical basis of hardness and vitreosity in the wheat kernel, Bakers Digest, 48, 16–18, 20, 22, 26–29, 63. SOHN M R and CHO R K (2000) Development of calibration equation for firmness and determination of cell wall components in apple fruits using near infrared spectroscopy. In AMC Davis and R Giangiacomo Eds, Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Verona, Italy, 13–18 June, 1999, Chichester, NIR Publications, 791–5. STARR C, MORGAN A G and SMITH D B (1981) An evaluation of near infrared reflectance analysis in some plant breeding programmes, Journal of Agricultural Science (Cambridge), 97, 107–18. SVENSSON G (1981) Varietal and environmental effects on wheat milling quality, Agri hortique genetica, 39, 1–103. ∨ ∨ TARKOSOVÁ and COPÍKOVÁ J (2000) Fourier transform near infrared spectroscopy applied to analysis of chocolate, Journal of Near Infrared Spectroscopy, 8, 251–7. VAN DE LAER G, DARDENNE P, AGNEESSENS R and ROLOT J -L (2000) Prediction of potato sensory properties by near infrared spectroscopy. In AMC Davis and R Giangiacomo Eds, Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Verona, Italy, 13–18 June, 1999, Chichester, NIR Publications, 879–82. VENEL C, MULLEN A M, DOWNEY G and TROY D J (2001) Prediction of tenderness and other quality attributes of beef by near infrared reflectance spectroscopy between 750 and 1100 nm; further studies, Journal of Near Infrared Spectroscopy, 9, 185–98. WETZEL D L (1984) Physical sample characterization by granulation sorting from diffuse reflectance measurements in the near-infrared. In Proceedings of Third Annual Users Conference for NIR Researchers, February, Pacific Scientific Inc., Silver Spring, MD.
Near infrared (NIR) diffuse reflectance in texture measurement 183 (1979) Screening wheat for protein and hardness by near infrared reflectance spectroscopy, Cereal Chemistry, 56, 169–72. WINDHAM W R, GAINES C S and LEFFLER R G (1993) Effect of wheat moisture content on hardness scores determined by near-infrared reflectance and on hardness score standardization, Cereal Chemistry, 70, 662–6. WINDHAM W R, BARTON F E II, LYON B G and LYON C E (1996) Classification of prior temperature history of chilled chicken breasts by near infrared spectroscopy. In AMC Davis and P Williams Eds, Near Infrared Spectroscopy: The Future Waves, Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Montréal, Canada, 6–11 August 1995, Chichester, NIR Publications, 596–600. WILLIAMS P C
8 Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in texture measurement A. K. Thybo, A. H. Karlsson, H. C. Bertram and H. J. Andersen, Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences, P. M. Szczypinski, Technical University of Lodz, Poland and S Donstrup, Aarhus University Hospital, Denmark
8.1
Introduction
8.1.1 Texture of foods and demands for non-destructive measurements Texture is a very important factor in food quality and indeed is perceived as the ultimate quality attribute in several foods. Moreover it is considered to be one of the most essential technological quality parameters of semi-processed/ composite foods during processing. The development of rapid and robust online and at-line methods for grading both raw material and semi-processed/ composite foods with differences in their technological and sensory texture qualities is ‘therefore’ a challenge to the industry, because such grading will allow optimal use. Over the years an extensive number of at-/on-line methods have been developed and successfully implemented in the food industry. However, only a few are able to predict and/or characterize quality attributes which are significant for the technological and sensory specifications of foods. Water characteristics, e.g. water distribution and mobility, and the anatomical structures of raw materials in processed foods have been identified as the physical/chemical properties of most importance for the technological and sensory properties of the final foods (Levine and Slade, 1991). Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is one of the few instrumental techniques to have proven high potential in the characterisation of both water distribution and the anatomical interior of foods, both known to be critical for texture (Chen et al., 1989; Berendsen, 1992; Cornillon, 1998; Hills, 1998; Ruan and
NMR and MRI in texture measurement
185
Chen, 1998). Consequently, this unique technique has attracted increasing attention within food research over recent years, and interest in it is further reinforced by its non-destructive sampling nature. The NMR technique includes NMR spectroscopy, MR-imaging and NMR relaxometry. Low-field NMR relaxation and MR-imaging are especially relevant in the context of food science due to the relatively low cost of the instruments used. The present paper gives a state of the art overview of the potential of these techniques in texture analysis of foods. 8.1.2 Principles in 1H low-field NMR relaxation In 1H low-field nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation (proton NMR) the specimen is investigated in a low magnetic field (Ruan and Chen, 1998). In a magnetic field, the magnetic moments of the nuclei will align with the magnetic field (like small compass needles). Following the application of a radio frequency, the protons (hydrogen molecules) in the material are excitated and consequently perturbed from their equilibrium state, to which they will subsequently return by a process described as relaxation. Two types of processes are involved in the return to equilibrium state, longitudinal relaxation (T1) and transverse relaxation (T2). These can consequently be used to characterize the material. In common low-field NMR studies, only the contribution from protons of mobile compounds, i.e. water and fat (non-crystallized) is ‘visualized’. Chemically, water is simple with its two protons but, more interestingly, water behaves differently in different environments. The individual water protons are differently associated to macromolecules providing distinct ‘availabilities’ and thus distinct mobilities for water, and this may be responsible for the various physical properties and functionalities of different food items. As an example, the water protons are less mobile in a solution with e.g. sugar compared with pure water, as the protons will form interactions with the sugar molecules. Thus, the water protons in the sugar solution will be restricted in motion, and an NMR relaxation measurement will display a faster relaxation of the water protons compared with pure water. Water is the most abundant compound in food materials (Isengard, 2001), and therefore water protons are found in high amounts in foods. During recent years, NMR relaxation has been used as an experimental technique for the study of the nature of water in food as well as non-food products (Fullerton and Cameron, 1988; Berendsen, 1992; Rutledge, 1992; McCarthy, 1994; Clark et al., 1997; Cornillon, 1998, Vackier et al., 1999; Ibanez and Cifuentes, 2001; Bertram et al., 2001a). Different water populations/compartments can be extracted from the NMR relaxation curves by e.g. exponential fitting of the relaxation decay. In the case of only one water compartment, a mono-exponential fitting is performed, which can be described as: S = Ae – t /T n
[8.1]
186
Texture in food
where S is the total relaxation signal, A is the amplitude representing the proportional water amount (equals protons in the water) and Tn is the relaxation time of the water protons. If several types of protons decaying at different rates exist in a material, each decay (or each type of proton) will have its own Tn describing the intrinsic relaxation rate. If two water compartments (two types of protons) are found in a system, e.g. bulk water and water in association with macromolecules (restricted water), a bi-exponential fitting may be performed, expressed as: [8.2]
SΤ = A1 e – t /T n 1 + A2 e – t /T n 2
where ST is the total relaxation signal, A1 and A2 are the amplitudes representing the proportional amounts of bulk and restricted water, and Tn1 and Tn2 are the relaxation times of bulk and restricted water compartments. As an alternative to the discrete exponential fitting described above, a ontinuously distributed exponential fitting has sometimes been applied (Kroeker and Henkelman, 1986). With this method, the number of exponential components is not pre-defined, and the result is expressed as a continuous distribution of relaxation times. Figure 8.1 shows an example of a continuous spectrum with three water components with transverse relaxation times T21, 6 1 % drip 5 % drip
5
Normalised amplitude
10 % drip 4
3
2
1
0 1
10
100
1000
(mm)
Fig. 8.1 Illustration of a continuous spectrum from low-field 1H NMR relaxation of three water compartments in pork with relaxation times T21, T22 and T23 (x-axis) and the relative amount of the water compartments presented by the amplitudes (A21, A22 and A23) on the y-axis. The three relaxation time constants reflect three types of water “associations” in pork, which are represented in different amounts (A21–23) and influenced by the water-holding capacity (Source: Bertram et al., 2002a with permission from Elsevier).
NMR and MRI in texture measurement
187
T22 and T23 (x-axis) and amplitudes (A21, A22 and A23) on the y-axis for three types of meat with different water-holding capacities (1, 5, 10 % drip losses) (Bertram et al., 2002a). A minor water component was detected with relaxation time between 1 and 10 ms (T21), a major water component between 40 and 60 ms (T22), and finally a water component with relaxation time between 150 and 400 ms (T23). 8.1.3 Principles in MRI An MR scanner used for magnetic resonance imaging (MR-imaging, NMRI or MRI) is in principle an NMR spectrometer equipped with gradient coils, which allows shaping of the magnetic field in a controlled manner. In this way it is possible to obtain images of the specimen placed in the scanner, where the intensity of the image reflects the value of various MR parameters for the corresponding position in the sample. Just as the intensity of the MR signal can be made dependent on a series of parameters, so can the intensity of the image. The most common of these parameters are proton-density, relaxation times and diffusion properties; these then make it possible to construct images showing the spatial distribution of molecules within a specimen. Consequently, all three contribute to the intensity of the image to a varying, but selectable, degree in a normal image. However, it is possible to combine a series of MR images and to obtain images that reflect separate physical properties. The proton-density reflects the concentration of water and fat in the specimen being imaged. These two contributions can be separated and the protons from non-mobile compounds, e.g. proteins and starch, will not contribute to the MR image. The relaxation times, T1 and T2, primarily reflect how water interacts with macromolecules, and a diffusion-weighted image can show to which extent barriers against free diffusion exist.
8.2
Methods and analysis
8.2.1 Low-field NMR methods Low-field NMR systems are typically benchtop systems, equipped with a permanent magnet, with field strength in the range 50–500 mT. The systems require sample sizes in the order of mL, and the domain for these instruments is relaxation and diffusion measurements. Due to the low magnetic field strength, these systems are in general not suited to carrying out chemical analysis, i.e. exploiting spectral differences between chemical groups. This is the domain of high-resolution–high-field NMR spectroscopy, a subject not covered in this chapter. However, low-field NMR is able to accomplish spectral differentiation between two of the most abundant compounds in foods, water and fat.
188
Texture in food
8.2.2 MRI methods MRI instruments can be roughly grouped by two factors; sample size and magnetic field strength. Small-bore MR scanners able to image samples in the mL range are available as special probes to low-field NMR spectrometers. Such systems should have a spatial resolution in the order of tenths of µL. Low-cost, low-field imagers are now available on the market and are increasingly being used for more applied purposes in the food industry. Alternatively, small-bore MR scanners with a field strength above 15 T can obtain a maximum resolution around 30 × 30 × 30 µm. These are of vast interest in basic research, but are much too expensive to be used in food industry applications. Wide-bore MR scanners are systems normally used for medical imaging, with a maximum sample diameter around 0.5 m. These systems are available with a magnetic field strength in the range from 0.2 to 3 T. In general, the high cost of wide-bore imagers is a hindrance but, realizing that it is not always necessary to use state-of-the-art wide-bore imagers in food science, an ever-accelerating pace of research activity in the exploitation of MRI in that industry has taken place during the 1990s.
8.2.3 Data analysis Most NMR relaxation data and MR-images are characterized by a complex multivariate structure with both compositional and spatial information. Optimal extraction of information from such data structures requires the use of advanced multivariate statistical data analysis techniques. Novel chemometric techniques extract the relevant information in the NMR data and develop a predictive model between the NMR data and the quality attributes (Bro et al., 2002). As an alternative to the previously mentioned exponential fitting and discrete exponential fitting of low-field NMR relaxation curves those with thousands of data points can also be correlated to e.g. sensory or other quality attributes using multivariate data analysis as Partial Least Squares Regression, and subsequently a predictive model can be built (Martens and Martens, 1986; Bechmann et al., 1998). In some cases all the information in the full relaxation curves has been used to predict quality related parameters, and in other cases the extracted water compartments (T2) and the relative amount of these (A2) have been useful for predictive purposes (Jepsen et al., 1999; Thybo, et al., 2000; Engelsen et al., 2001, Thygesen et al., 2001). In other experiments, more advanced data analysis, such as the so-called slicing-technique (a threeway modelling, Winding and Antalek, 1997; Pedersen et al., 2002), has been used to explore the information in NMR curves (Andersen and Rinnan, 2002; Jensen et al., 2002; Povlsen et al., 2003). Qualitative visual investigation of the MR-images is the most common way of interpreting them (Ishida et al., 1989; Clark et al., 1997; Bonny et al. 2000). Very few quantitative descriptions of these images have been provided (Barreiro et al., 2000; Thybo et al., 2003, 2004). A quantification of the
NMR and MRI in texture measurement
189
information in an MR-image can be determined by computer-assisted image texture (structure) analysis; afterwards multivariate statistical methods can be used to find correlations with food quality attributes. Many sophisticated image analysis features have been developed, but application is mainly in the medical field with determination of anatomical structures and boundaries and size of tissues. The most common method for computing image characteristics is the analysis of image histogram (image brightness distribution). This kind of analysis usually reveals statistics on image brightness, contrast and the ratio of light to dark areas within an image. Unfortunately the histogram itself does not carry any information on spatial relations between image elements (pixels). To overcome the problem of lack of spatial information in an image histogram, two-dimensional histogram (co-occurrence matrix) analysis may be applied. Co-occurrence matrix estimates the joint probability of two pixels having particular intensities and being related to each other with specified distance and direction. Therefore, co-occurrence-matrix-derived features provide quantitative information on the structure of an image texture pattern, including texture directivity. Another method used for texture evaluation is based on the run-length matrix. The matrix is defined as the number of times that a chain consisting of a specified number of pixels (in a given direction) has a certain grey level. Run-length-matrix-derived statistics provide some knowledge about texture directivity and homogeneity. Textural features of an image, such as histogram, gradient, co-occurrence matrix, run-length matrix, autoregressive and wavelet-based features, can be determined by e.g. MaZda software (ver. 3.20 by Politechnika Lodzka, Lodz, Poland). The program was created within the EU COST B11 project “Quantitative Analysis of Magnetic Resonance Image Texture” devised for the years 1998–2002. It is under continuous development, and new texture computation techniques are being implemented in this software. Further, development of appropriate mathematical tools for quantitative data analysis is a future challenge, if MRI is to become a successful non-invasive rapid online/at-line method for food quality attribute measurements.
8.3 Application of NMR: texture determination of solid foods 8.3.1 Determination of texture by low-field NMR relaxation As mentioned above, NMR relaxation can be used to display different water compartmentalizations in food materials by measuring the relaxation rates of the water protons. Several researchers have stated that NMR relaxation is a rapid, non-invasive and non-destructive method of determining the distribution of water pools with different relaxation rates in foods (Cornillon, 1998; Ruan and Chen, 1998). Water distribution in foods is an important characteristic in relation to food texture quality. The number of relaxation studies focusing
190
Texture in food
on water compartments has increased enormously during recent years. However, only in a minority of these studies have the results been correlated to actual texture attributes; most are focussed on the potential of determining water distributions within a food product, its water-holding characteristics and the effects of processing conditions, e.g. heating, cooking and freezing, on water exudation and migration. Nevertheless, it has been shown that low-field NMR relaxation measurements demonstrate a high correlation with texture properties in rice, bread, meat, fish and potatoes.
8.3.2 Fish Several researchers have applied NMR relaxation to fish in order to study water contents (Steen and Lambelet, 1997; Bechmann et al., 1998; Jepsen et al., 1999; Andersen and Rinnan, 2002; Jensen et al., 2002). However, only Steen and Lambelet (1997) correlated the transverse NMR relaxation data obtained with the sensory texture attributes of toughness, fibrousness and dryness. In cod mince exposed to different freezing conditions, the correlations using either sensory texture attributes or texture determined by compression test were r = 0.76–0.95 and r = 0.93–0.96, respectively. The conclusion was that transverse NMR relaxation is a relevant method both in determination of texture changes in cod mince upon freezing and in prediction of the final texture quality of cod patties.
8.3.3 Meat Fjelkner-Modig and Tornberg (1986) were the first to address the potential of transverse NMR relaxation in the context of raw meat to predict the sensory texture properties in cooked meat. With respect to the water distribution in pork, they revealed three compartments of water, which they designated as free, extra-cellular and intra-cellular water. In raw meat from the Hampshire breed, the sensory toughness was related to the relaxation time of intracellular water, while in raw meat from the Yorkshire breed, toughness was correlated with the amount of intra-cellular and extra-cellular water. Moreover, juiciness in meat from Yorkshire pigs tended to be related to the relaxation time of the intra-cellular water. Accordingly, the study demonstrated how NMR relaxation could be used as a tool to unravel the basis for differences in sensory textural properties among different meat qualities. Recently, it has also been demonstrated that NMR relaxation measurements reflect the changes in water characteristics in meat during cooking (Micklander et al., 2002; Bertram et al., 2004a) which are known to occur as a result of textural changes due to myosin denaturation and shrinkage of connective tissue. Finally, textural alterations of meat as a result of freezing/thawing have also been shown to be detectable by NMR relaxation (Yano et al., 2002).
NMR and MRI in texture measurement
191
8.3.4 Bread and starch-based products Hardness and water mobility in cooked rice were investigated by transverse NMR relaxation and correlated to texture measurement determined by TPA (Ruan et al., 1997). Furthermore, the change in firmness of the rice samples upon storage, which was due to retrogradation, was described by transverse NMR relaxation data. Seow and Teo (1996) showed that pulsed NMR could be used to monitor staling in different starch-based products e.g. cornstarch gel, bread and rice cup cake. With significant correlations (r = 0.96–0.98) between NMR measurements and firmness determined by a compression test, it was concluded that NMR (solid phase signal) can be used to predict staling in starch gels and starch-based products. Moreover, staling and changes in firmness of sweet rolls were correlated with water characteristics determined by transverse NMR relaxation (r = 0.87–0.98) (Ruan et al., 1996). The authors found that the change in the mobility of the water in the different water compartments was the basic reason for the staling process. Recent papers have confirmed the high correlation between transverse NMR relaxation measurements and changes in elasticity and firmness in bread during eight days of storage (Chen et al., 1997; Engelsen et al., 2001) (Fig. 8.2). Moreover, the study by Engelsen et al. (2001) showed that NMR relaxation data could be used to predict the texture in the bread at day 8 from changes in relaxation data between days 0 and 3, which is highly interesting due to the potential for the 2000 1800
r r2 RMSECV BIAS
= 0.95 = 0.90 = 147 = –9.6
Firmness (pred.)
1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 400
600
800
1000 1200 1400 Firmness (meas.)
1600
1800
2000
Fig. 8.2 Prediction of firmness of bread samples by Partial Least Squares Regression on low-field 1H NMR relaxation curves. Reference values versus predicted values. The middle diagonal line is the target line and the two other lines indicate the (+/–) RMSECV errors (Source: Engelsen et al., 2001 with permission from Elsevier).
192
Texture in food
prediction of shelf life. Finally, Engelsen et al. (2001) carried out on-line NMR relaxation measurement on dough during the full baking process and showed that changes in water characteristics could be used to follow the onset and off-set of the gelatinisation process and to understand the water associations with the proteins, starch and pentosans which reflect textural changes and which may be relevant to understanding the quality of the final baked product.
8.3.5 Potatoes Several recent studies have shown that NMR relaxation data obtained from raw potatoes can predict sensory-determined texture attributes in cooked potato samples. Transverse NMR relaxation measurements on raw potatoes have shown very high correlations with the sensory attributes of firmness, springiness, adhesiveness, mealiness (see Fig. 8.3), graininess and moistness in cooked potatoes (Bro et al., 2002; Thybo et al., 2000; Povlsen et al., 2003). Previous studies showed that NMR relaxation measurements correlated to some of the texture attributes, as the NMR relaxation data gave information about water content in the raw potatoes, which is inversely correlated with starch and dry matter content which are known to determine the specific texture attributes in the cooked product (Thygesen et al., 2001; Thybo et al., 2003, 2004). However, adhesiveness and springiness correlated better with NMR data than with the content of the chemical constituents. This indicated that NMR apparently gives information about certain mouthfeel variables which are difficult to measure by any other instrumental technique.
8.3.6 Cheese NMR relaxation has also been shown to reflect rheological properties of cheese analogs (Budiman et al., 2000). Transverse NMR relaxation measurements showed good correlation (R2 = 0.81–0.84 corresponding to r = 0.90–0.92) with texture determined as initial stress in a compression test of cheese analogous samples containing either milk fat or vegetable oil (Fig. 8.4). Moreover, the elastic constant g1 of the cheese analogs was also highly correlated to NMR measurements (r = 0.91–0.96). These results clearly indicate that transverse NMR relaxation might also have a high potential in determining cheese texture, but this needs further investigation.
8.3.7 Determination of water and water-holding capacity in solid food by low-field NMR relaxation As pointed out previously, many of the investigations using NMR to predict the contents of water and fat have been carried out without any attempt to predict texture. However, these studies are also relevant in the present context, as water and fat are of importance for texture, and they should be able to give
NMR and MRI in texture measurement
193
5000
Signal amplitude
4000
3000 2000 1000 0 0
9
1000
2000 Echoes
3000
4000
Mealiness r = 0.90 Moistness r = 0.84
8 7
Predicted
6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0
1
2
3
4 5 Measured
6
7
8
9
Fig. 8.3 Low-field 1H NMR relaxation curves of four different potato varieties (up); prediction of mealiness and moistness in cooked potatoes from NMR relaxation curves determined on raw potatoes – reference values versus predicted values (down). (Source: Bro et al., 2002 with permission from Elsevier).
appropriate information for future applications. Prediction of fat and water content (Bechmann et al., 1998; Jepsen et al., 1999; Andersen and Rinnan, 2002) in raw fish using NMR relaxation in combination with multivariate data analysis has shown intriguing results with an r-value up to 0.998 despite large sample variation with respect to muscle structure (Andersen and Rinnan, 2002). Other studies have shown that transverse NMR relaxation can be used to determine changes in water compartmentalization in fish during freezer storage (Lambelet et al., 1995; Jensen et al., 2002). NMR longitudinal relaxation data have been shown to reflect the water content of marinated chicken breast, and a good correlation between expressible moisture (water-holding capacity) and NMR transverse relaxation data has
194
Texture in food 45 Milkfat Vegetable oil
40 35
R 2 = 0.848 R 2 = 0.816
σ0 (kPa)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 14
16
18
20
22
24
26
T2a (ms)
Fig. 8.4 Texture of cheese analog samples containing either milk fat or vegetable oil determined as stress in uniaxial compression versus relaxation time T21 from low-field 1H NMR (Source: Budiman et al., 2000 with permission from Food and Nutrition Press).
been established (Rongrong et al., 2000). As in fish (Jepsen et al., 1999), several studies have displayed correlations (r = 0.60–0.85) between NMR transverse relaxation data and the water-holding capacity of pork (Renou et al., 1985; Tornberg et al., 1993; Brøndum et al., 2000; Brown et al., 2000; Bertram et al., 2001b). In some of these studies, correlations were established using multivariate statistical regression analysis on the relaxation decay (Brøndum et al., 2000; Brown et al., 2000), and accordingly no information was obtained about the specific transverse relaxation parameters to which the correlation could be ascribed. However, when discrete bi-exponential fitting was carried out on the relaxation decay, the highest correlation was obtained on the transverse relaxation parameter representing the most loosely ‘entrapped’ water (Tornberg et al., 1993; Bertram et al., 2001b), or the relative fraction of this component (A2 in Eq. 8.2) (Renou et al., 1985), which is in agreement with the hypothesis that it is the least restricted water which is related to potential drip loss (Bertram et al., 2002a). Besides waterholding capacity, high correlations between NMR relaxation data and protein content in fresh meat (Tipping, 1982; Bertram et al., 2002b), fat content in minced meat and meat products (Renou et al., 1985; Pedersen et al., 2001), and moisture content in sausages (Gerbanowski et al., 1997) have been reported. Finally, an indirect relationship between transverse NMR relaxation data and meat texture has been displayed in a recent study, where a strong relationship between meat structure, a decisive factor for meat texture, and NMR transverse relaxation was established (Bertram et al., 2002a; Fig. 8.5). Similar studies solely focussed on the changes in the distribution of water as a reflection of structural/anatomical changes will be very important tools for further
NMR and MRI in texture measurement
195
Sarcomere length (µm)
3
x = 0.84
2
1 40
42
44
46
48
50
T21 (ms)
Fig. 8.5 Relationship between the relaxation time T21 from low-field 1H NMR relaxation and meat texture displaying a strong relationship between T21 and meat structure (sacromere length), a decisive factor for meat texture (Source: Bertram et al., 2002c with permission from American Chemical Society).
understanding of the texture changes during processing in the future application of NMR in food science.
8.4 Application of MRI: texture determination of solid foods 8.4.1 Determination of texture by low-field MR-imaging The combination of non-invasiveness and visualization of water and lipid distribution makes MRI unique as a diagnostic tool. In the past, MR-imaging has mostly been applied successfully within the medical field, and it has achieved general acceptance as a powerful tool in the diagnosis and assessment of tumours in the human brain and body by visual interpretation of images (Lerski et al., 1999). As the technology has matured, new applications have been developed directed at non-medical areas, such as plant physiology and anatomy (MacFall and Johnson, 1994; MacFall and Van As, 1996). More recently, the potential of MR-imaging in studying anatomical details and changes in water and transport of solutes in foods during processing has begun to emerge.
8.4.2 Qualitative evaluation of structural/textural changes in food The first attempts to reveal the potential of MRI in food science were observations of the static food structures in a way which was analogous to
196
Texture in food
imaging of human anatomy. The observations were made in relation to the quality of fresh fruits and vegetables in terms of internal breakdown, bruises, voids and post-harvest studies (Chen et al., 1989; McCarthy, 1994; McCarthy et al., 1995; Clark et al., 1997). For apples this non-destructive method was used to investigate internal changes in water cores and the development of browning during storage (Clark and Burmeister, 1999; Clark and Richardson, 1999). The maturity of tomatoes has been followed by MR-imaging (Ishida et al., 1989; Saltveit, 1991), and MR-imaging has been used as a method of observing changes in internal structure during compression of tomatoes (Gonzalez et al., 1998). In the latter study, the macro-structural changes were quantified and this revealed registered changes in MRI signal intensity from specific tomato tissues. Changes in water mobility during storage in starch-based systems in the form of sweet rolls have been followed by MR-imaging. This showed that water migrated from the crumb to the crust, which was associated with the firming of the crumb (Ruan et al., 1996). Moreover, a spatial redistribution of water mobility within the sweet rolls during storage was also observed. A recent study revealed how MR-imaging can visualize and so be a valuable tool in the study of the adiposity distribution in fish (Collewet et al., 2001). The effects of high-pressurization, known to severely alter the texture of meat (Ratcliff et al., 1977), have also been studied and compared with nonpressured meat using MR-imaging (Bertram et al., 2004b). Finally, in a study of changes in the texture and structure of lasagne after cooking, as investigated by an instrumental compression devise, MR-imaging clearly demonstrated the differences in internal structure of the pasta in relation to cooking time and thereby facilitated the interpretation of the texture measurement (Gonzales et al., 2000). The above listed subjects show that MR-imaging is a useful technique to interpret defects and structural changes during maturity, processing and staling, all of which are very important factors for texture. However, further use of MRI in food science requires full exploitation of the quantitative aspects of MRI, as qualitative observations of changes are not always sufficient in foods, where transport of mass, heat and momentum and their effect on functionality are also of major importance. The use of MR-imaging in the quantitative determination of food quality is a new area with huge potential and one which deserves attention. The very few papers published within this area are presented below.
8.4.3 Quantitative evaluation of structural/textural changes in food Quantitative interpretation of MR-images is necessary in order to obtain correlations between MR-images and texture. When correlations are established, predictive models for texture using MR-imaging can be developed and subsequent MR-imaging can be used for on-line or at-line quality monitoring. In the following the few papers currently published which deal with a direct
NMR and MRI in texture measurement
197
correlation between texture of food and MR-images through quantitative interpretation of the MR-images are described. Mealiness in apples and peaches has been related to MR-imaging data from the fruits and to subsequent mechanical texture analysis of the fruit (Barreiro et al., 2000) (Fig. 8.6). Histogram features from MR-images of the mealy apples were more skewed than the histogram of fresh and crispy apples, and subsequent multivariate discriminant analysis of the MR-image T2 histograms
T2 images
d13 (mealy + internal breakdown)
3b 17 (mealy)
3b 12 (intermediate)
d16 (fresh & crispy)
Fig. 8.6 Examples of T2 MR-images and T2 histograms from two mealy apples (first, second), an intermediate (third) and a fresh (fourth) apple showing large visual differences in appearance of the images and more skewed histograms of the mealy apples compared with the fresh and crispy apples. (Source: Barreiro et al., 2000 with permission from Elsevier).
198
Texture in food
features clearly discriminated between the mealy and the fresh apples determined by instrumental compression test. In the previously mentioned MRI study on fish by Collewet et al. (2001), they also managed to quantify the adiposity distribution, which is highly interesting as the relative deposition of fat in the different edible flesh parts greatly influences the smoothness of the texture and the flavour of fish muscle. Another recent study describes the use of MRI coupled with image analysis in the prediction of soft cheese texture characteristics obtained by a sensory panel (Mariette and Collewet, 2001). This study revealed that several sensory attributes were correlated (r = 0.74–0.95) with variables from the MR images. It clearly demonstrated that the MRI technique associated with image analysis methods is a powerful tool to establish relationships with sensory texture. The prediction of cooked potato texture and dry matter content from MRimages of raw potatoes was also recently revealed (Thybo et al., 2003, 2004). The large visual variation in a T1-weighted MR-image of raw potatoes obtained in one of these studies is given in Fig. 8.7. Low signal intensity (dark areas) indicates relatively free water, while high signal intensity (bright areas) reflects a tighter ‘association’ between water and macromolecules. This large variation in MRI signal intensity within a potato has previously been reported where the
Folva
Sava
Primula
Ukama
Fig. 8.7 MR-images (T1-Weighted) of two mature raw potato varieties (Folva and Sava) and two immature raw potato varieties (Primula and Ukama). Low signal intensity (dark areas) indicates relatively free water, while high signal intensity (bright areas) reflects tighter “association” between water and macromolecules (Source: Thybo et al., 2003 with permission from Elsevier).
NMR and MRI in texture measurement
199
bright areas were stated to be the vascular tissue (MacFall and Van As, 1996). In the study no correlation was established between dry matter content and simple image analysis features (grey scale intensities) in the MR-images (Thybo et al., 2003, 2004). However, when approximately 260 image analysis features (Materka et al., 1999a, b, 2000) were subjected to multivariate data analysis a prediction of cooked potato texture attributes was possible, which resulted in a correlation coefficient of r = 0.70–0.85 for hardness, adhesiveness and moistness (Thybo et al., 2004). In contrast, the geometrical attributes, i.e. mealiness and graininess, were not well predicted from the MR-images. Present studies deal with a quantitative description of MR-images, showing that structural information of relevance for the sensory texture attributes can be extracted from MR-images of raw potatoes. Despite their preliminary nature, these studies display the potential of MR-imaging as a future method for quantitative quality evaluation. Finally, MRI has also been used to follow dynamic changes in the structure of foods during processing, e.g. cooking, drying, rehydration, freezing and freeze-thawing. MR-images have been shown to provide relevant information on structural changes (Hall et al., 1998; Nott et al., 1999a,b; Evans et al., 2002).
8.5
Future trends
The 1990s has seen NMR move into the area of modern food science due to its huge potential to reveal structural and dynamic changes of importance to many quality attributes. There is a growing awareness that low-field NMR relaxation and imaging of water provide useful insight into many structural aspects of raw and processed foods. Most of the results presented above are based on the fact that low-field NMR parameters, especially water, in foods are dependent on the cellular architecture of the food product and hence indirectly measure textural properties. The food industry demands rapid on-line methods to predict the sensory or technological quality of the raw material in order to obtain a final food product with the most optimal and uniform quality. In a recent paper the applicability of NMR relaxation, NIR and spectrofluorometry and multivariate handling of large data sets was presented in relation to characterization and prediction of quality parameters (Bro et al., 2002). The present review has addressed examples of applications of low-field NMR relaxation and MRI to the determination of texture and structure in food. However, can NMR techniques be developed which can offer at-line and on-line sensors of relevance for the industry? Until recently, the high cost of most NMR equipment has turned out to be the major hindrance, but the supply in recent years of lowcost, benchtop NMR models suitable for both relaxation measurements and imaging has indeed made NMR relevant to the food industry. At present NMR relaxometry has already shown potential as a natural at-line method in
200
Texture in food
fat determination of meat (Pedersen et al., 2001), and several other applications are apparent on the basis of our present knowledge. In particular, the preliminary results from the use of an NMR mobile surface device (the so-called NMRmouse) in food analysis indicate that, with further development of the hardware part, the introduction of on-line NMR relaxometry may be a reality in the near future (Martin et al., 2002). Moreover, the possibilities for exploiting MRI as an on-line sensor for process control and quality assurance throughout the food manufacturing chain are intriguing, and the next few years will probably see rapid development in this area. As mentioned previously, quantitative MRI has great potential in the food industry and use of the technique is set to increase. It is a very demanding technique and development of appropriate mathematical models for quantitative data analysis is going to be a crucial element within this area. Furthermore, the development within rheo-NMR (Hills, 1998; Callaghan and Gil, 2001) and solid imaging (Hills, 1998), even though both techniques are in a rudimentary stage, will undoubtedly contribute to a much better insight regarding the role of the intermolecular interactions known to be of great significance for the texture of foods and to be factors of importance in low-water-content foods, e.g. cookies, crackers, pasties, etc. In conclusion, NMR technology has proven to be dynamic and flexible. Its applications have been proven useful in the area of food science and texture analysis. Future development in hardware, exploitation in image analysis methods and development in multivariate data analysis tools will certainly make NMR the tool of the future within food science and food analyses.
8.6
References
and RINNAN Å (2002) Distribution of water in fresh cod, Lebensm -Wiss u – Technol, 35, 687–96. BARREIRO P, ORTIZ C, RUIZ-ALTISENT M, RUIZ-CABELLO J, FERNANDEZ-VALLE M E, RECASENS I and ASENSIO M (2000) Mealiness assessment in apples and peaches using MRI techniques, Magn Reson Imag, 18, 1175–81. BECHMANN I E, PEDERSEN H T, NØRGAARD L and ENGELSEN S B (1998) Comparative chemometric analysis of transverse low-field 1H NMR relaxation data In Advances in Magnetic Resonance in Food Science. Eds P S Belton, B P Hills and G A Webb, Cambridge, The Royal Society of Chemistry, 217–25. BERENDSEN H J C (1992) Rationale for using NMR to study water relations in foods and biological tissues, Trends Food Sci Technol, 3, 202–5. BERTRAM H C, KARLSSON A H, RASMUSSEN M, DØNSTRUP S, PETERSEN O D and ANDERSEN H J (2001a) The origin of multi-exponential T2 relaxation in muscle myowater, J Agric Food Chem, 49, 3092–3100. BERTRAM H C, KARLSSON A H and ANDERSEN H J (2001b) Comparative study of low-field NMR relaxation measurements and two traditional methods in the determination of water holding capacity of pork, Meat Sci, 57, 125–32. BERTRAM H C, DØNSTRUP S, KARLSSON A H and ANDERSEN H J (2002a) Continuous distribution analysis of T 2 relaxation in meat – an approach in the determination of water holding capacity, Meat Sci, 60, 279–85. ANDERSEN C M
NMR and MRI in texture measurement BERTRAM H C, RASMUSSEN M, BUSK H, OKSBJERG N, KARLSSON A H
201
and ANDERSEN H J (2002b) Changes in porcine muscle water characteristics during growth. An in vitro low-field NMR relaxation study, J Magn Reson, 157, 267–76. BERTRAM H C, PURSLOW P P and ANDERSEN H J (2002c) Relationship between meat structure, water mobility and distribution – a low field NMR study, J Agric Food Chem, 50, 824–29. BERTRAM H C, ENGELSEN S B, BUSK H, KARLSSON A H and ANDERSEN H J (2004a) Water distribution during cooking of pork as studied by low-field NMR relaxation – effects of curing and the RN-gene, Meat Sci, 66, 437–66. BERTRAM H C, WHITTAKER A K, SHORTHOSE A W, KARLSSON A H and ANDERSEN H J (2004b) Changes in water characteristics during tenderization and high-pressure of beef as studied by NMR microimaging, Meat Sci, 66, 301–6. BONNY J M, LAURENT W, LABAS R, TAYLOR R, BERGE P and RENOU J P (2000) Magnetic resonance imaging of connective tissue: a non-destructive method for characterising muscle structure, J Sci Food Agric, 81, 337–41. BRO R, VAN DEN BERG F, THYBO A, ANDERSEN C M, JØRGENSEN B M and ANDERSEN H (2002) Multivariate data analysis as a tool in advanced quality monitoring in the food production chain, Trends Food Sci Technol, 13, 235–44. BRØNDUM J, MUNCK L, HENCKEL P, KARLSSON A, TORNBERG E and ENGELSEN S B (2000) Prediction of water-holding capacity and composition of porcine meat by comparative spectroscopy, Meat Sci, 55, 177–85. BROWN R J S, CAPOZZI F, CAVANI C, CREMONINI M A, PETRACCI M and PLACUCCI G (2000) Relationships between 1H NMR relaxation data and some technological parameters of meat: A chemometric approach, J Magn Reson, 147, 89–94. BUDIMAN M, STROSHINE R L and CAMPANELLA O H (2000) Stress relaxation and low field proton magnetic resonance studies of cheese analog, J Texture Stud, 31, 477–98. CALLAGHAN P T and GIL A M (2001) Rheo-NMR of carrageenan gels and sols. In Magnetic Resonance in Food Science – A View to the Future. Eds G A Webb, P S Belton, A M Gil and I Delgadillo, Cambridge, The Royal Society of Chemistry, 27–42. CHEN P, MCCARTHY M J and KAUTEN R (1989) NMR for internal quality evaluation of fruits and vegetables, Trans ASAE, 32, 1747–53. CHEN P L, LONG Z, RUAN R and LABUZA T P (1997) Nuclear magnetic resonance studies of water mobility in bread during storage, Lebensm -Wiss u-Technol, 30, 178–83. CLARK C J and BURMEISTER D M (1999) Magnetic resonance imaging of browning development in ‘Braeburn’ apple during controlled-atmosphere storage under high CO2, Hortscience, 34, 915–19. CLARK C J and RICHARDSON C A (1999) Observation of watercore dissipation in ‘Braeburn’ apple by magnetic resonance imaging, New Zealand J Crop Hort Sci, 27, 47–52. CLARK C J, HOCKINGS P D, JOYCE D C and MAZUCCO R A (1997) Application of magnetic resonance imaging to pre- and post-harvest studies of fruits and vegetables’, Postharvest Biol Technol, 11, 1–21. COLLEWET G, TOUSSAINT C, DAVENEL A, AKOKA S, MÉDALE F, FAUCONNEAU B and HAFFRAY P (2001) Magnetic resonance imaging as a tool to quantify the adiposity distribution in fish. In Magnetic Resonance in Food Science – A View to the Future. Eds G A Webb, P S Belton A M Gil and I Delgadillo, Cambridge, The Royal Society of Chemistry, 252– 8. CORNILLON P (1998) Applications of NMR relaxometry to food products. A review, Sem Food Anal, 3, 235–49. ENGELSEN S B, JENSEN M K, PEDERSEN H T, NØRGAARD L and MUNCK L (2001) NMR-baking and multivariate prediction of instrumental texture parameters in bread, J Cereal Sci, 33, 59–69. EVANS S D, BRAMBILLA A, LANE D M, TORREGGIANI D and HALL L D (2002) Magnetic resonance imaging of strawberry (Fragaria vesca) slices during osmotic dehydration and air drying, Lebensm -Wiss u –Technol, 35(2), 177–84.
202
Texture in food
FJELKNER-MODIG S
and TORNBERG E (1986) Water distribution in porcine M. longissimus dorsi in relation to sensory properties, Meat Sci, 17, 213–31. FULLERTON G D and CAMERON I L (1988) Relaxation of biological tissues. In Biomedical Magnetic Resonance Imaging – Principles, Methodology, and Applications. Eds F W Wehrli, D Shaw and J B Kneeland, New York, VCH Publisher Inc, 1–115. GERBANOWSKI A, RUTLEDGE D N, FEINBERG M H and DUCAUZE C J (1997) Multivariate regression applied to time domain-nuclear magnetic resonance signals: determination of moisture in meat products, Sci des Aliment, 17, 309–23. GONZALEZ J J, MCCARTHY M J and MCCARTHY K L (1998) MRI method to evaluate internal structural changes of tomato during compression, J Texture Stud, 29, 537–51. GONZALEZ J J, MCCARTHY K L and MCCARTHY M J (2000) Textural and structural changes in lasagna after cooking, J Texture Stud, 31, 93–108. HALL L D, EVANS S D and NOTT K P (1998) Measurement of textural changes of food by MRI relaxometry, Magn Reson Imag, 16, 485–92. HILLS B (1998) Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Food Science, New York, John Wiley & Sons Inc, 35–151. IBANEZ E and CIFUENTES A (2001) New analytical techniques in food science, Crit Review Food Sci Nutr, 41, 413–50. ISENGARD H-D (2001) Water content, one of the most important properties of food, Food Control, 12, 395–400. ISHIDA N, KOBAYASHI T, KOIZUMI M and KANO H (1989) 1H-NMR imaging of tomato fruits, Agric Biol Chem, 53, 2363–7. JENSEN K N, GULDAGER H S and J øRGENSEN B M (2002) Three-way modelling of NMR relaxation profiles from thawed cod muscle, J Aquat Food Prod Technol, 11(3/4), 201– 14. JEPSEN S M, PEDERSEN H T and ENGELSEN S B (1999) Application of chemometrics to low-field H-1 NMR relaxation data of intact fish flesh, J Sci Food Agric, 79, 1793–802. KROEKER R M and HENKELMAN R M (1986) Analysis of biological NMR relaxation data with continuous distributions of relaxation times, J Magn Reson, 69, 218–35. LAMBELET P, RENEVEY F, KAABI C and RAEMY A (1995) Low-field nuclear-magnetic resonance relaxation study of stored or processed cod, J Agric Food Chem, 43, 1462–6. LERSKI R A, SCHAD L R, LUYPAERT R, AMORISON A, MULLER R N, MASCARO L, RING P, SPISNI A, ZHU X and BRUNO A (1999) Multicentre magnetic resonance texture analysis trial using reticulated foam test objects, Magn Reson Imag, 17(7), 1025–31. LEVINE H and SLADE L (1991) Water Relationship in Foods – Advances in the 1980’s and Trends in the 1990s, New York, Plenum Press. MACFALL J S and JOHNSON G A (1994) The architecture of plant vasculature and transport as seen with magnetic-resonance microscopy, Can J Bot, 72, 1561–73. MACFALL J S and VAN AS H (1996) Magnetic resonance imaging of plants. In Shachar-Hill Y and Pfeffer P E, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance in Plant Biology, Rockville, Maryland, American Society of Plant Physiologists, 33–76. MARIETTE F and COLLEWET G (2001) Relationships between sensory texture of soft cheese and MRI measurements. In Magnetic Resonance in Food Science – A View to the Future. Eds G A Webb, P S Betton A M Gil and I Delgadillo, Cambridge, The Royal Society of Chemistry, 67–74. MARTENS M and MARTENS H (1986) Partial Least Squares Regression. In Statistical Procedures in Food Research. Ed. J R Piggott, London, Elsevier Appl Sci Publ, 1–92. MARTIN D R, ABLETT S, PEDERSEN H T and MALLETT M J D (2002) The NMR-mouse: its application to food science. In Proceeding 6th Int. Conf. NMR in Foods, Paris, France, 4–6 Sept., 47. MATERKA A, STRZELECKI M, LERSKI R and SCHAD L (1999a) Feature evaluation of texture test objects for Magnetic Resonance Imaging. In Proceeding Infotech Oulu Workshop on Texture Analysis in Machine Vision, Oulu, Finland 14–15 June, 13–19.
NMR and MRI in texture measurement MATERKA A, STRZELECKI M, LERSKI R
203
and SCHAD L (1999b) Toward texture feature selection of Magnetic Resonance Phantom Images. In Proceedings Computers in Medicine, Lodz, Poland, 23–25 Sept., 23–5. MATERKA A, STRZELECKI M, LERSKI R and SCHAD L (2000) Toward automatic feature selection of texture test objects for Magnetic Resonance Imaging. In Proceeding 11th Portuguese Conference on Pattern Recognition, Porto, Portugal, 11–12 May, 11–16. MCCARTHY M J (1994) Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Foods, New York, Chapman and Hall. MCCARTHY M J, ZION B, CHEN P, ABLETT S, DARKE A H and LILLFORD P J (1995) Diamagnetic susceptibility changes in apple tissue after bruising. J Sci Food Agric, 67, 13–20. MICKLANDER E, PESHLOV B PURSLOW P P and ENGELSEN S B (2002) NMR-cooking monitoring the changes in meat during cooking by low-field 1H-NMR, Trends Food Sci Technol, 13, 341–6. NOTT K P, EVANS S D and HALL L D (1999a) The effect of freeze-thawing on the magnetic resonance imaging parameters of cod and mackerel, Lebensm -Wiss u –Technol, 32, 261–8. NOTT K P, EVANS S D and HALL L D (1999b) Quantitative magnetic resonance imaging of fresh and frozen-thawed trout, Magn Reson Imag, 17, 445–55. PEDERSEN H T, BERG H, LUNDBY F and ENGELSEN S B (2001) The multivariate advantage in fat determination in meat by bench-top NMR, Inn Food Sci Emerging Technol, 2, 87–94. PEDERSEN H T, BRO R and ENGELSEN S B (2002) Towards rapid and unique curve resolution of low-field NMR relaxation data: trilinear SLICING versus two-dimensional curve fitting, J Magn Reson, 157(1), 141–55. POVLSEN V T, RINNAN Å, VAN DEN BERG F, ANDERSEN H J and THYBO A K (2003) Direct decomposition of NMR relaxation profiles and prediction of sensory attributes of potato samples, Lebensm -Wiss u –Technol, 36, 423–32. RATCLIFF D, BOUTON P E, FORD A L, HARRIS P V, MACFARLANE J J and O’SHEA J M (1977) Pressureheat treatment of post-rigor muscle: objective-subjective measurements, J Food Sci, 42, 857–9. RENOU J P, MONIN G and SELLIER P (1985) Nuclear magnetic resonance measurements on pork of various qualities, Meat Sci, 15, 225–33. RONGRONG L, KERR W L, TOLEDO R T and CARPENTER J A (2000) 1H NMR studies of water in chicken breast marinated with different phosphates, J Food Sci, 65, 575–80. RUAN R R and CHEN P L (1998) Water in Foods and Biological Materials, Loncaster, PA, Technomic Publishing Company Inc. RUAN R, ALMAER S, HUANG V T, PERKINS P, CHEN P and FULCHER R G (1996) Relationship between firming and water mobility in starch-based food systems during storage, Cereal Chem, 73, 328–32. RUAN R R, ZOU C, WADHAWAN C, MARTINEZ B, CHEN P L and ADDIS P (1997) Studies of hardness and water mobility of cooked wild rice using nuclear magnetic resonance, J Food Process Preserv, 21, 91–104. RUTLEDGE D N (1992) Low resolution pulse nuclear magnetic resonance (LRP-NMR), Analusis Magazine, 20, 58–62. SALTVEIT M E JR (1991) Determining tomato fruit maturity with nondestructive in vivo nuclear magnetic resonance imaging, Postharvest Biol Technol, 1, 153–9. SEOW C C and TEO C H (1996) Staling of starch-based products: A comparative study by firmness and pulsed NMR measurements, Starch/Stärke, 48, 90–93. STEEN C and LAMBELET P (1997) Texture changes in frozen cod mince measured by lowfield nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, J Sci Food Agric, 75, 268–72. THYBO A K, BECHMANN I E, MARTENS M and ENGELSEN S B (2000) Prediction of sensory texture of cooked potatoes using uniaxial compression, near infrared spectroscopy and low field 1H NMR spectroscopy, Lebensm-Wiss u –Technol, 33, 103–111. THYBO A K, ANDERSEN H J, KARLSSON A H, DØNSTRUP S and STØDKILDE-JØRGENSEN H (2003) Low-field NMR relaxation and NMR-imaging as tools in differentiation between
204
Texture in food
potato sample and determination of dry matter content in potatoes, Lebensm-Wiss u – Technol, 36, 315–22. THYBO A K, SZCZYPINSKI P M, KARLSSON A H, DØNSTRUP S, STØDKILDE-JØRGENSEN H S and ANDERSEN H J (2004) Prediction of sensory texture quality attributes of cooked potatoes by NMR-imaging (MRI) of raw potatoes in combination with different image analysis methods, J Food Eng, 61, 91–100. THYGESEN L G, THYBO A K and ENGELSEN S B (2001) Prediction of sensory texture quality of boiled potatoes from low-field 1H NMR of raw potatoes. The role of chemical constituents, Lebensm-Wiss u –Technol, 34, 469–77. TIPPING L R H (1982) The analysis of protein in fresh meats using pulsed NMR, Meat Sci, 7, 279–83. TORNBERG E, ANDERSSON A, GÖRANSSON Å and VON SETH G (1993) Water and Fat Distribution in Pork in Relation to Sensory Properties. In Pork Quality: Genetic and Metabolic Factors. Eds E Puolanne and D I Demeyer with M Ruusunen and S Ellis, Oxon, CAB International, 239–58. VACKIER M-C, HILLS B P and RUTLEDGE D N (1999) An NMR relaxation study of the state of water in gelatin gels, J Magn Reson, 138, 36–42. WINDING W and ANTALEK B (1997) Direct exponential curve resolution algorithm (DECRA): A novel application of the generalized rank annihilation method for a single spectral mixture data set with exponentially decaying contribution profiles, Chem Intell Lab Syst, 37, 241–54. YANO S, TANAKA M, SUZUKI N and KANZAKI Y (2002) Texture changes of beef and salmon meats caused by refrigeration and use of pulse NMR as an index of taste, Food Sci Technol Res, 8, 137–43.
9 Modelling food texture L. M. M. Tijskens and H. Luyten, Wageningen University and Research Centre, The Netherlands
9.1
Introduction
9.1.1 What is texture Texture is one of the major characteristics in determining and defining the quality of horticultural crops and is also a major attribute for man-made products (Hutchings and Lillford, 1988). Researchers in the area of mechanical properties like to see texture as a property of food products that can be measured adequately by simple and objective techniques. The relations, however, between objective measures of mechanical properties, including all effects of physical conditions, and their sensorial counterparts are notoriously difficult to establish. For researchers in the area of sensory sciences, texture is just one of the many attributes that have to be estimated by panels tasting and chewing the product in more or less controlled conditions. Textural issues are sensory categories, defined as reactions to stress (force) or tactile feeling (Meilgaard et al., 1991). In other words, the notion of texture, in all its aspects, is as ill-defined and elusive as that of quality itself. Different people often use different definitions. Still, one has to work with texture in research and in practice. The textural properties of our food need to be communicated in such a way that scientists and growers and manufacturers, and all the actors in the food supply chain can at least understand one another. Since the analogy with quality in general seems to be so apt an approach similar to that used by Sloof et al. (1996), Tijskens et al. (1994) and Wilkinson and Tijskens (2001) can be followed. This approach is based on a decomposition of the problem of quality into product properties and associated quality attributes. Unlike other, better-defined attributes of food products, e.g. colour, infections and defects, the relationship between product properties and textural attributes
206
Texture in food
is rather ill-defined. Product properties can affect more than one attribute, while at the same time attributes can rely on more than one property. A rather incomplete picture for semi-solid foods is shown in Fig. 9.1 (Luyten, 2003 based on data from de Wijk et al., 2003). In addition to this labyrinth of relations among purely textural issues, texture of food products affects other senses as well. Texture can modulate flavour perception, e.g. sweetness as a function of sugar content and juiciness (Brückner and Auerswald, 2000; Brückner, 2003). Texture of food determines how fast or slow we chew and how much force we apply. And that in turn determines how the product reacts and how we perceive the texture. So, research on texture should be connected to knowledge of oral physiology (Hutchings and Lillford, 1988; Lucas et al., 2002). But Szczesniak (2002) provided the most important aspect of sensory perception of texture in terms of quality and acceptance, stating that an acceptable texture is hardly noticed, but negative texture experiences are strongly linked with a negative hedonic loading. In practice, this means that when the perceived texture is considered sufficient, it hardly adds anything to the preference and acceptance of consumers. However, when texture is lacking consumers will reject the product regardless of the intensity of its other quality attributes. It is a so-called critical attribute (Molnár, 1995 cited in Wilkinson and Tijskens, 2001). So, in dealing with texture, a systematic distinction has to be made between texturerelated chemical and physical properties which are intrinsic to the food, the perception of trained sensory panels, who judge attribute intensities regardless of their own likes and dislikes, and acceptance by consumers, who cannot detach their own preferences from their perception, and who always respond in complex combinations. 9.1.2 Assigned Quality versus Acceptance, Properties versus Attributes In an attempt to develop a framework for modelling quality in general, a philosophical view on quality was developed (Tijskens et al., 1994; Sloof et Property
Attribute
Viscosity
Thickness
Density
Melting
Particle size
Compact
Flavour concentration
Creamy
Adhesion
Sticky
Fig. 9.1 An illustration of the complexity in the attribute–property relation for mayonnaise and custards. Based on the results of de Wijk et al. (2003). (Picture is not complete.)
Modelling food texture 207
al., 1996; Wilkinson and Tijskens, 2001) that proved to be highly efficient, profitable and far more generally applicable than anticipated. The innate notion of product quality has three separate aspects. Product, user and market all influence the ‘product quality’. In this philosophical view a product does not have quality of its own; quality is assigned to a product by the user. The assignment of quality to a product can be decomposed into separate processes of perception, evaluation and appreciation (see Fig. 9.2). During these processes, the intrinsic properties of a product are converted into quality attributes that are evaluated and appreciated in the context of socio-psychological factors and the market situation. After a quality is assigned to the product the user decides whether or not to accept it. So, the complete quality scheme (see Fig. 9.3) consists of intrinsic product properties, quality attributes, quality assignment and product acceptance. Each of these steps is influenced to a greater or lesser degree by external factors. With this decomposition of the concepts of quality and of quality assignment a generic architecture for modelling quality change of agricultural products can be defined. From this view on quality it becomes evident that the buyer/consumer plays the active role in the process of quality evaluation. The consumer assigns quality to a product. So, quality does not exist other than in the mind of the observer (buyer/consumer) as a virtual property of the product. In other words, quality is the result of the act of assigning a uni-dimensional quality measure to a product by a given person. The assignment, however, is, Product Product properties
Attributes
Perception
Perception
Evaluation
Evaluation
Appreciation
Appreciation
Properties
Assigned quality
Human Quality assignment process
Fig. 9.2
Steps in assigning quality to a product by a human (from Wilkinson et al. 2001).
208
Texture in food Physical Gas conditions Relative humidity Temperature
Cultivar Intrinsic product properties
Quality
Cost
Growth conditions
Assignment
Product acceptance
Status symbol Fashion
on
Customs
om
Prior experience
Preference
ic
User
ps S yc oc ho io lo gi ca l
Ec
Availability
Climate
Fig. 9.3 Quality assignment of natural food products as affected by product properties, economic and socio-psychological circumstances (from Wilkinson et al., 2001).
as far as the product is concerned, completely based on intrinsic product properties. In other words, the assigned quality reflects (almost) solely the interaction between the product on the one side and the perceiving buyer/ user on the other. Based on the quality assigned to the product, the customer will decide whether or not to accept it. This decision is influenced by external factors, which are largely determined by the market situation (economic factors) and the psychological and social circumstances of the consumer. So, all these economic and socio-psychological effects are coming into play when the consumer has to decide whether or not to buy a particular product, in a particular market situation, in the particular circumstances that he/she happens to be in at a particular moment. Among these factors are the relative abundance of available produce and, equally important, the presence of a possibility of choice: if there are only bad-quality peaches (too hard, no taste) from southern Europe available in central Europe they will be sold due to lack of alternatives (Bohling and Adam, 1994). On the other hand, as long as poor-quality products can be sold, transport and sale of poor-quality produce will continue. A number of major issues that affect the modelling of quality (and texture) can be taken from this viewpoint on the issue. • Assigned quality is entirely based on intrinsic properties. Conversion of properties to attributes is done by the consumer/user/buyer/observer. • Conversion of intrinsic properties to attributes is complex and up to now unclear (see Fig. 9.1). • Quality (not acceptability) can and may be modelled based on the behaviour of relevant intrinsic properties only.
Modelling food texture 209
• What is normally called product quality is, in the majority of cases, the acceptability, where all the effects of economic and psychological influences combine with the assigned quality.
9.1.3 Role of modelling in texture analysis The ultimate goal of modelling is to provide reliable predictions of occurrences that have not yet taken place, for any product, from any source and in any situation. This goal, although agreed upon by every modeller and every user of models, is, however, currently a long way off and is far from being fulfilled by the present technology in modelling. Modellers have achieved major progress in mathematics, modelling techniques and modelling tricks during the past few decades, from the early 1970s (Thornley, 1976; Edelstein-Keshet 1988; Thornley and Johnson, 1990; Keen and Spain, 1992; Brown and Rothery, 1993) up to the 21st century. What technology can deliver at the moment is a fairly accurate mathematical description of the behaviour of a product or commodity in conditions not too far away from those in which the tests have been conducted and in which the results have been gathered, based upon which the model is so-called validated or calibrated. For modelling the quality (and texture) behaviour of our food from the growing site through the different handling sequences, the distribution chain, storage, and processing, up to consumption and the final judgement of consumers, the situation is no different. A vast number of models, submodels and applications have been built, and many of them have been reported in detail. Most of these models are very valuable for exactly this but only this application: predicting the future behaviour of a product in circumstances similar to the test circumstances. These are the so-called dedicated models. Once the application is to be extended to fairly new circumstances, the sometimes huge task of developing, creating and calibrating new models has to be repeated. In terms of efficiency of resource utilisation, this approach seems efficient in the short term; in the long run, however, it is neither very efficient nor very satisfying. Moreover, in terms of comprehension of the problem at hand and generation of knowledge, this approach leads only to indirect and incomplete understanding. To achieve the ultimate goal of modelling quality – predicting future behaviour of any product and its quality from any source in any circumstance while generating more knowledge about the process under study – we must include all the available knowledge, fundamental as well as practical, that is at our disposal. The results of this kind of approach are the so-called fundamental (or rather fundamental-oriented) models. These do indeed generate more knowledge and understanding, and can direct scientific research to those areas where information and understanding seem to be lacking. The benefit to be gained from the practical application of modelling lies exactly in the potential it offers for optimising processes, procedures and supply chains. The main advantage of modelling product behaviour is, in our
210
Texture in food
opinion, to be found in the steering and directing of research towards those areas where essential knowledge is lacking and where possible bottlenecks can be resolved in a more efficient and economic way (Tijskens et al., 1998a). Also process-oriented modelling greatly increases the efficacy of data analysis and interpretation.
9.1.4 Fundamental models and disciplines Fundamental-oriented models can be built in many ways and within many scientific disciplines. Disciplines, however, are a result of the deep-rooted urge of man and scientists to bring some order to our view and perception of the world. Nature, on the other hand, does not have or need disciplines at all. Processes occurring in nature “naturally” comply with the laws of nature. The ultimate drive of science is to detect and understand these laws, and to convert that understanding into some practical application in order to increase the quality of our lives. So, within the realm of each discipline, the same laws of nature will be present and known in one form or another. The direct consequence is that, in modelling and understanding processes of nature, it does not really matter which particular discipline is used as a framework, as long as its rules are used consistently and thoroughly. For chemists, the choice of kinetic modelling is self-evident. The general rules of kinetic modelling are summarised and described in van Boekel and Tijskens (2001). The rules of the discipline and the laws of nature in the area of chemistry were all discovered and formulated in the early days of chemical discoveries, and theories were formulated. They are now a standard part of textbooks on chemistry, physical chemistry, kinetics and enzyme kinetics (Chang, 1981; Fersht, 1984; Whittaker, 1994; etc.) Although this knowledge has been available for so many years, when building empirical models old-fashioned style, it is the first information that consistently is not used at all. Every time new data need to be analysed, mathematical and statistical relations are invented and tested all over again, and the model with the statistical best fit to the data at hand is chosen to represent the behaviour of that system, without recourse to any expert knowledge whatsoever. Modern science is based on the most important rule of all: the repeatability of a process. That is, in the same conditions the same process will occur at the same rate. In making models, we should use this, the very basis of science, and search for process rate constants that are true constants for any condition encountered. In other words, rate constants of processes will be the same for the same processes, no matter what the conditions are. Some general rules can be drawn up when modelling the complexity of interacting processes that occur in nature. When trying to model interactive processes, it is of the utmost importance to apply the old Roman rule “divide et impera” (divide and rule). In modern terminology, that is problem decomposition. Having used this technique almost unconsciously for several years in developing process-oriented models, a young information technologist
Modelling food texture 211
devoted a major part of his PhD thesis to developing a more consistent, understandable and applicable system in that respect (Sloof, 1999; Sloof, 2001). Still, the process of detecting possible and plausible mechanisms in rather unstructured data is apparently quite a difficult task for most people. In our opinion, that, rather than the necessary requirements of mathematical skills or product expertise, is what makes a good modeller. Another general rule for developing process-oriented models is the consistent application at all costs of the laws of a particular discipline. Adapting mathematical equations, whether at the level of differential equations or at the level of functions or analytical solutions of these differential equations, invariably changes the fundamental nature of a model into an empirical one. Changes are only permitted at the level of developing appropriate mechanisms. Changes at a mathematical level inevitably prevent any further development along fundamental lines. Process-oriented modelling does offer not only the advantage of an increased understanding of processes and interactions, it also ensures a reusability of models and, above all, the transferability of parameter values to all kinds of different situations and conditions in which the product is used. And that is the ultimate goal of modelling: providing a prediction of future behaviour of products from any provenance, from any growing conditions and in any circumstances during the food supply chain. Based on these ideas, using the vast knowledge product experts already have on the processes which take place and the applicability of the laws of the various disciplines, modelling product behaviour and food quality is not at all difficult – it merely takes a lot of time and effort. The reason why this technique has not been used consistently in every case is the idea that our food is too complex to be described by these simple principles.
9.2
Factors affecting texture
9.2.1 Texture of fresh produce As already pointed out in the introduction, texture can originate from different sources, physical and chemical as well as structural. Van Dijk and Tijskens (2000) provided an overview of the possible sources of texture for cellular food materials, that is food products from living tissues, at three levels of abstraction: molecular, cellular and organ. Processes that cause changes in texture occur mainly at the molecular level. Available information, however, is predominantly gathered at organ level and at best at cellular level. Due to this discrepancy it remains very difficult to understand what is going on with the texture in our food. It makes it almost impossible to interpret the information that is contained in phenomenological observations. Unravelling the sources of texture into processes at different levels may be helpful. Some examples are given below.
212
Texture in food
The possible sources of texture of cellular plant materials (fruits, vegetables), as measured at an organ level, have their roots in the cellular and molecular level (Vincent, 1991; Tijskens et al., 1999c; Van Dijk and Tijskens, 2000). This is shown in Table 9.1. At the lowest level the molecular composition of the cell wall determines the properties of the material. The composition and behaviour of polysaccharides like pectin are especially important at this level. Food properties can be understood from cell wall behaviour as well as tissue tension (or turgor pressure), the overall structure and shape of the cell and the presence of special compounds, like starch. The way cells are organised and arranged in tissues and organs (the histology and morphology) ultimately affects the textural properties of organs. The texture of cellular plant materials like fruits and vegetables is thus built upon molecular behaviour. But the actual stiffness and the strength of organ tissue, as perceived by humans as well as measuring devices, is largely determined by the physical structure of the tissue (Vincent, 1991). Inhomogeneities in the structure, like air channels in apples and vascular bundles in asparagus, play a particularly important role in the ultimate texture (Vincent et al., 1991). In a very similar way the texture of meat can be understood from the chemical composition and physical structure (Purslow, 1991). Here proteins are the most important structural molecules. In living material, processes that change all these items and properties occur simultaneously. Depending on the type of product some items are more important for the texture than others. In some products items may not be present at all; sometimes the processes are not active. Depending on the Table 9.1
The source of texture of cellular plant materials on different structural levels
Level Organ
Different tissues Adhesion Morphology
Tissue
Different cells Air spaces Adhesion and cohesion between cells Orientation/morphology
Cells
Cell wall Size and shape Turgor Special compounds (i.e. starch)
Cell wall
Constituents Thickness Orientation
Molecules
Polysaccharide types Modification (including enzyme action) Molecular size and conformation
Modelling food texture 213
relative occurrence and importance of one of the mentioned items, a very diverse range of textural behaviour can be depicted, e.g.: • When tissue tension (or cell turgor) is of major importance, cells are ruptured easily during the eating process. Juice will be expelled (which is an important (secondary) item in the texture of the products). An example is fresh strawberries. The cell walls in such products are soft and damage due to the fracturing process occurs in a large volume of the material. Often these fruits bruise easily. • When, in addition to tissue tension, the stiffness and brittleness of cell walls are of major importance (often due to the presence of pectin in the cell walls), the product is essentially crispy and juicy. Rupture occurs through the cell walls and the cell contents are expelled. Damage is often limited to a small volume around the bite. An example is fresh apples or celery. • When cell walls are relatively strong and the adhesion between cells is weak, the fracture path goes around the cells and not all the cell walls break (fracture always occurs at the weakest points). No juice (or only a small amount) is expelled and products are essentially mealy and dry as is sometimes the case in overripe apples. • When the morphological or histological structures are relatively important, the sensory texture, perceived during eating, may be affected by the orientation of product tissue. When biting parallel to the radial air spaces, apples were found to fracture at smaller deformations and were more brittle than when the bite was perpendicular to these air spaces (Vincent et al., 2002). This clearly shows the importance for the fruit texture of structural features at a higher level of aggregation. The presence of air channels was also used to explain differences in texture between different types of apples. • Dolores Alvarez and co-workers (2000) studied the differences in texture between different types of fruits and vegetables like carrot, apple, celery and cucumber. They concluded that both cell size and inter-cellular spaces affect texture. The effects of the position of the test-piece in the fruit or vegetable and of orientation could also be explained based on the same type of information. 9.2.2 Effects of processing Many fruits and vegetables are stored or processed before eating, these processes have major effects on the final texture of the food material, and they are studied and modelled by many scientists and technologists. The most important reason is the urge to optimise the texture, and with it the quality, of the food. It was shown above that the origin of texture is very complex. To understand it, both chemical and physical properties on different structural levels, as well as the structure itself, have to be taken into account. This implies that it will be very difficult or even impossible to model textural changes due to
214
Texture in food
storage or processing. Fortunately most changes due to processing are limited to a specific entity or compound, which facilitates our understanding and offers the potential to adjust texture. • The heating process applied to vegetables like carrots and beans changes particularly the molecular properties of the pectin in the cell walls. Enzyme activity plays an essential part in this process. Some examples are worked out in this chapter. • Leafy vegetables wither during storage. The main reason is the change in tissue tension upon loss of water and turgor pressure. • The effect of processing on the texture of products like tomato ketchup and apple sauce can be understood better when the structural changes are taken into account. Depending on the applied heating, the concentration, the homogenisation and the applied shear processes there is either a suspension of cells or a dispersion of cell contents and cell wall fragments (den Ouden, 1995; Schijvens et al., 1998), both with their own rheological properties. • The eating process is very difficult to describe. Often the breakdown occurs on different successive levels of aggregation. Textural attributes concerning the first bite are often governed by structures at a high level of aggregation and the existence of inhomogeneities in these structures. The fracture as a result of the deformation during the first bite is very important in perceiving texture. Large flaws and holes, where stresses are concentrated and fracture consequently starts (van Vliet and Luyten, 1995), govern the process of fracturing. A clear example is the difference in texture between apples from different cultivars and the effect of orientation (see above). • For nutritional reasons, the breakdown of cells and the accompanied release of the cell content (juice) is a very important aspect of the eating process. The point at which this happens, whether in the first bite, during further mastication or later during digestion, affects the perceived texture. The attributes as juiciness and mealiness are especially prone to this phenomenon.
9.2.3 Man-made products Although products with a natural origin, like meat, fruits and vegetables, are eaten fresh, the actual structure of many food products is obtained by processing. Examples of such man-made products are bread, cheese, mayonnaise, etc. The texture of this type of product depends on both composition and structure. Shear, pressure and temperature are the processing parameters that have most effect on the structure. Spontaneous compartmentalisation has to be taken into account (for instance phase separation). Models developed to understand and regulate the mechanical properties of non-food materials can often be used successfully for man-made food products. Some examples are given below.
Modelling food texture 215
Different food materials are so-called cellular solids1 (Jeronimidis, 1991). In this type of food commodity, cellular refers to the pocket foam-like structure. The structure of these products consists of a solid phase surrounding air pockets. Examples are bread, dairy dessert foams and different types of snacks. The air pockets can be closed or interconnecting. The presence or absence of interconnections between the air pockets and the density of the material are the most important parameters affecting the mechanical properties of such products (Gibson and Ashby, 1988). The theory developed for cellular solids was successfully applied to unravel the effects of ingredients and processing conditions on the texture of bread crumb (Scanlon and Zghal, 2001). Understanding was gained by separating the effects on the air cells (size, shape, porosity) and the physical properties of the solid phase (stiffness, brittleness, starch retrogradation, gluten behaviour). The textural quality of bread depends on the texture of both the crumb and the crust. Attributes like crispiness and crunchiness are clearly related to crust properties; the softness of bread is more affected by crumb properties. An overview of the different structural levels affecting bread texture is shown in Table 9.2 (Luyten et al., 2003). Changes in crispiness accompanying the ageing of bread are related to water transport from the crumb towards the crust. The transport may be affected by structure on an aggregated structural level, but the ultimate change due to the presence of water is on a molecular scale, increasing the mobility of the bread macro-molecules. Many solid or solid-like food materials can be considered as composite materials, that is, as a continuous phase interspersed with filler particles (Luyten and Van Vliet, 1990). Roughly the properties of such a material can be understood by the behaviour of the matrix material, the amount and properties of the filler particles and the interaction between filler and matrix. In this way it is possible to model the changes in cheese texture with temperature Table 9.2 The source of texture of cellular man-made food products on different structural levels. An example for bread Level Food product Macro level Meso-level Molecules
1
Visible structure (crumb/crust, other ingredients) Type of porous structure Size and shape of air cells/pores Cell wall shape and thickness Composition Localisation of ingredients Small air cells Ingredients, including water Functionality of ingredients, including mobility
Cellular in this case has to be understood differently from the meaning of cellular in fresh and natural materials.
216
Texture in food
(melting of the fat-filler), fat content (= filler content) and compositional factors like the water content, pH or amount of salt present (behaviour of the protein matrix) (Luyten, 1988; Luyten et al., 1991). This modelling allows us to separate effects on a molecular level (for instance the effect of pH on protein functionality) and on food structure (for instance amount and size of fat particles). Models were found to be applicable to a large range of food products. Ponne et al. (1996) provided a nice example on the effect of fibre enrichment on the texture of different gel-like foods. In that paper, the effects of type of fibre (via the swelling behaviour and the volume of filler), rigidity of the fibre, rheological behaviour of the gel matrix and molecular interactions between the matrix material and the fibre particles could very neatly be separated. The latter effect is shown in Fig. 9.4. Depending on the existence of interactions with the matrix material, pea fibres could either increase or decrease the modulus of the food model.
Slope of compression curve (N/mm)
9.2.4 Biopolymers The majority of firmness in living material is built up on biopolymers. The degree of polymerisation (DP), i.e. the number of units building up the polymer backbone, is generally considered to be the actual source of firmness and strength. In fruits and vegetables the most frequently occurring biopolymers are cellulose, pectins and starch. In meat this is mainly collagen. Firmness decay is then the results of a decrease in the degree of polymerisation by mechanical, chemical or enzymatic action. Every time the length of the polymers is diminished by ‘cutting’, the strength of that chain is diminished. However, a major difference exists between linear two-dimensional and three-dimensional polymers. For predominantly linear polymers, each cut in the backbone will roughly halve the remaining chain length. This behaviour is pictured in Fig. 9.5. However, when the same chain is cross-linked with covalent or ionic bonds, depending 0.3
Pectin Carrageenan
0.2
Gelatin Marmalade Gelatin-2
0.1
0.0 0
Fig. 9.4
1
2 Fibre (w/w %)
3
The effect of added pea fibre on the slope of the compression curve of different food gels (from Ponne et al., 1996).
Modelling food texture 217 0 cut 100 % 1 cut 50% 2 cuts 33% 3 cuts 25%
Fig. 9.5
Effect of increasing number of cuts in a linear polymer.
on where the cuts happen to be made, it takes some cuts before the chain length (or degree of polymerisation) starts to decrease. This is visualised in Fig. 9.6. The consequence for the changes in associated strength is shown in Fig. 9.7. Based on the theory of Markov processes, the cutting of a linear polymer was modelled by Saedt et al. (1991). The model was validated on data obtained from pectin degradation by a bacterial endo-transeliminase. Not only could an equation for the average DP be developed (see Eq. 9.1), but also the distributions of the various fractions of remaining chain lengths could be visualised.
DP =
1 1 – 1 – 1 ⋅ e – α⋅t DP0
[9.1]
Although Eq. 9.1 mathematically equals exactly the well-known logistic function, often used to describe sigmoidal behaviour, its behaviour in time
0 cut
100 %
3 cuts 100 %
2 cuts 50 %
Fig. 9.6
Retardation in decreasing chain length for cross-linked polymer chains.
218
Texture in food 100
Strength (%)
75
50
25
0 0
Fig. 9.7
10 Number of cuts
20
Decrease in chain length and strength per cut for linear and cross-linked polymer chains.
(t) does reflect the more normally encountered exponential decay. The reason is that the initial condition (DP0) is much larger than the asymptotic value obtained at infinite time. Of course when cutting down polymer chains, the final length will inevitably be unity. For a better understanding of firmness originating from biopolymers, it would certainly be worthwhile taking the distribution of chain length of the cut remains into account.
9.3
Effects of enzymes on texture
Enzymes play a prominent role in our food. They are essential in the development and decay of fresh fruits and vegetables and hence crucial in all quality attributes, including texture. However, in man-made products too the action of enzymes, or its prevention, is of prime importance. Conservation of fresh food to prolong product lifespan, by sterilisation, pasteurisation and freezing, relies to a large extent on the complete inactivation of those enzymes which enhance quality deterioration (polygalacturonases (PG), lipases, lipoxygenases, polyphenoloxidases, etc.). The most often used indicator for enzyme inactivation is peroxidase, since it is one of the most heat-resistant enzymes. At the same time, efforts are made to stimulate the action of quality-improving enzymes such as e.g. pectin methyl esterase. In the storage of fresh produce at low temperatures and low respiration conditions e.g. in controlled atmosphere and modified atmosphere (CA, MA) enzyme-catalysed quality deterioration is the main source of quality decay, apart from that induced by microorganisms. To model the very complex pathways involved in texture changes during growth, ripening, storage and processing, an understanding of the actions and peculiarities of the enzymes involved in these conversions is an absolute necessity. As far as the denaturation of enzymes during heat treatments like
Modelling food texture 219
blanching, cooking, pasteurisation and sterilisation is concerned, the simplest mechanism which is still plausible is: ks S + E→ P+E kd E → E na
[9.2]
The first reaction represents the conversion of a substrate (S) into a product (P) by the action of some enzyme (E). The second reaction represents the heat-induced inactivation of the active enzyme (E) into an inactive form. Based on the laws of chemical kinetics, this set of reactions can be converted into a set of differential equations: dt dS ( t ) = – ks ⋅ S ( t ) ⋅ E ( t ) dt dP ( t ) = ks ⋅ S ( t ) ⋅ E ( t ) dt
dE ( t )
= – kd ⋅ E ( t )
[9.3]
Upon integration at constant external conditions (mainly temperature), the solution for substrate and enzyme is: S( t ) = S 0 ⋅ e
e – k d ⋅t – 1 ks ⋅ E 0 ⋅ kd
E( t ) = E 0 ⋅ e
– k d ⋅t
[9.4]
As in all chemical and biochemical reactions, the rate constants (kd and ks) depend on temperature according to Arrhenius: E ⋅ 1 – 1 T ref T
k i = k i, ref ⋅ e R
[9.5]
This principle has been applied frequently in modelling enzyme behaviour during all kinds of technological treatments (Tijskens and Rodis, 1997; Tijskens et al., 1997a,b, 1998a,b, 1999a,b). Based on this mechanism, the activity of enzymes, as determined in practice, is represented by ks · E(t). In Fig. 9.8 a three-dimensional example is shown for the activity of an enzyme during inactivation at various different but constant temperatures. At relatively low temperatures the activity increases with temperature as expected. At a certain temperature the enzyme starts to denature, thereby effectively decreasing the molar amount of active enzyme present (E(t)). Even at these denaturing temperatures, the reaction rate constant of the remaining active enzyme (ks) continues to increase with temperature. It can be clearly seen that the temperature at which the maximum activity is exerted by the enzyme depends on the time of denaturation. This type of behaviour of enzymes acting during
220
Texture in food
Activity
0.04
0.02
0
20 40 Time
60 80 0 10 40
Fig. 9.8
50
60
70 Temperature
80
90
Example of enzyme activity during inactivation at different but constant temperatures. Based on Eq. 9.4.
a denaturing process is quite generic in nature. It has been observed, and the model has been applied in data analysis with remarkable success for a large range of food-related enzymes and fruit and vegetable types. It is expected to work equally well for enzymes in other types of foods like meat and manmade products. Polakovic∨ and Bryjak (2002) describe in detail a more elaborate model for enzyme denaturation (the Lumry–Eyring model), comprising an inactive but reversible intermediate. With this approach, the sometimesobserved regeneration of enzymes could be explained by the reversible conversion from intermediate inactive enzyme (Einter) back into the active enzyme (E). k
kd E← f→ E inter → E na
[9.6]
kb
The simple model on enzyme denaturation (Eq. 9.2) can be extended with a concurrent formation of enzyme. This is frequently observed as the so-called enzyme turnover (Eq. 9.7). Depending on the initial amount of enzyme present, the pattern of firmness decrease can now turn from a simple exponential type of decay (as for the simple model) to a sigmoidal type of decay (Tijskens, 2003)(see Figs 9.9 and 9.10). k
p S + E→ P+E kf →E kd E→ decay
[9.7]
Modelling food texture 221 10
8
Increasing rate of enzyme formation
S
6
4
2
0 20
Fig. 9.9
40
60 Time
80
100
Behaviour of substrate under the action of an enzyme exhibiting ‘simple’ turnover. Initial amount of enzyme = 0.
10
8
S
6 Increasing rate of enzyme formation
4
2
0 20
Fig. 9.10
40
60 Time
80
100
Same simulation as Figure 9.9, but now with a moderate initial level of enzyme.
The analytical solution at constant external conditions (mainly temperature) of the system of concurrent formation and decay of an active enzyme is: (e – k d ⋅t – 1) ⋅ E 0 – kf ⋅ t k ⋅ (e – k d ⋅ t – 1) S = S 0 ⋅ exp – f ⋅kp kd kd2
[9.8]
222
Texture in food
9.4
Applying models to predict texture
Based on the premises depicted in previous sections on biopolymers and enzymatic effects, a couple of models and applications were built. Two of these models will be highlighted in the next sections. The first one is on firmness of apples during all kinds of storage conditions (CA, MA) and the effect of enzymes accumulating during that storage (Tijskens et al., 1999c). The second one is the result of a EU project (AIR1-CT92-0278) on the effects that different combinations of time and temperature of blanching have on the firmness of fruits and vegetables after cooking (Van Dijk and Tijskens, 2000).
9.4.1 QUAST: Quality of apples during storage and transport During the storage and transport of apples, all kinds of processes remain active in the fruit tissue to a varying degree of intensity. The different treatments and conditions apples are given to prolong their natural life (maturity at harvest, low temperature, CA conditions, climacteric stage, ethylene scrubbing) do slow down the majority of these processes, but not all to the same degree. Processes occurring in the fruit, which are important in quality and firmness decay, comprise: • • • •
pectin degradation with effect of oxygen pectin degradation without effect of oxygen water loss cellulose degradation
Since, with modern technology, water loss is not the major source of firmness decay, and can be kept to a very low level, it will not be considered in this example. Cellulose decay can be completely neglected due to its very slow rate. So, in this example the main emphasis is on firmness loss caused by the decay of pectin. The conditions in which the apples are stored and those at harvest may affect the quality decay and firmness deterioration. Lowering the temperature slows down ripening and softening. Controlled atmosphere storage in low oxygen and elevated carbon dioxide conditions will also slow down these processes. One of the consequences of CA will, however, (probably) be an accumulation of firmness decaying enzymes (e.g. PG). Ethylene (during storage) and climacteric stage (at harvest) will enhance these processes. So in short the model can be represented (not necessarily the absolute truth) by the following basic processes: k
p Pect → decay
k
pO Pect + O 2 → decay
[9.9]
Modelling food texture 223
The first one always occurs, regardless of the gas conditions applied. The second process needs oxygen to proceed, and will consequently be slowed down by CA conditions. The effect of oxygen and carbon dioxide on respiration and decay in CA conditions can be described by the respiration models of Peppelenbos (Peppelenbos et al., 1993, 1996) and Hertog (Hertog et al., 1997). Based on these models a relative respiration was proposed (Tijskens, 1995) that is virtually independent of temperature. The relative respiration is the ratio between the respiration at actual temperatures, and the respiration at the same temperature in normal gas conditions:
RelResp =
1 + K mo ⋅ 21 O2 ⋅ 21 1 + K mo ⋅ O 2 + K moc ⋅ O 2 ⋅ CO 2
[9.10]
As for all chemical and biochemical reactions, all reaction rates (kp and kpO) depend on temperature according to Arrhenius’ law (see Eq. 9.5). The equilibrium constants (Kmo and Kmoc) in Eq. 9.10 were found to be virtually independent of temperature. In Fig. 9.11 an example is shown for the relative respiration of Elstar apples as a function of oxygen and carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere. The model on relative respiration (Eq. 9.10) is used to modulate all rate constants of oxygen-consuming reactions. Although not very well documented in the literature, experts in CA storage know that apples which have been stored in CA conditions generally soften
1
Relative respiration
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
20
1
15
2 CO2(%)
10 O2(%)
3
5
4 5
Fig. 9.11
0
Relative respiration in Elstar apples as simulated by the model (Eq. 9.10).
224
Texture in food
faster during subsequent shelf life. The longer the apples have been stored, and the more respiration-suppressing the conditions are, the faster the poststorage softening. This is modelled as the accumulation of an enzyme (maybe PG, more probably related to ACC production and accumulation) that enhances pectin decay in the ex-store life.
∂ PG = kPG ⋅ PG ∂t The oxygen-induced decay of apple pectin then becomes: ∂Pect pO ∂t
[9.11]
= – k pO ⋅ Pect pO ⋅ PG ⋅ RelResp
+ k pO ⋅ Pect pO ⋅ (1 – RelResp)
[9.12]
This formulation, however, is too empirical and is probably an incorrect representation of the processes involved. Studies to correct this situation are being conducted. It is more probable that the amount of active PG (or any other pectin-decaying enzyme system) is the result of an interactive production and degradation system where the degradation is affected by oxygen, while the production is not or much less (see Eq. 9.13). k
f → PG k dO O2 PG + O 2 →
[9.13]
kd
PG → decay Against a constant production (reaction 1 in Eq. 9.13) a decay increasing with increasing oxygen levels (reaction 2) effectively lowers the amount of active enzyme in high oxygen systems, while increasing its activity at low oxygen levels. The effect of stage of maturity is included in the model by means of a logistic approximation of ethylene production.
∂ Eth = kEth ⋅ Eth ⋅ ∂t
Eth 1 – Eth max
[9.14]
In this over-simplified equation for ethylene production, the time has to be seen as relative to a fixed state of the product at harvest, let’s say the climacteric stage (inflection point of the logistic function). The exerted effect of ethylene is expressed by the integral of this equation over the variable temperature, CA and ethylene conditions. The climacteric stage of the product, both pre- and post-harvest, depends on the history of ethylene production and action. In its turn, the climacteric stage, expressed as a fraction of the maximal climacteric stage, affects a number of processes like pectin decay.
Modelling food texture 225
Again assuming that the firmness of apples can be approximated by the decay of pectins under variable storage conditions, the firmness of Elstar apples can now be simulated. The model describes the behaviour of firmness based on the processes possibly occurring in any part of the lifespan of an apple, from growing through harvest to storage and transport. The model can now be applied to predict the firmness in any known or unknown scenario of temperature and applied gas conditions, from any starting point with regard to maturity at harvest or growing condition. Example 1: variable temperatures In Figs 9.12 to 9.15 a scenario (shown in Fig. 9.15) was applied to apples with a harvest maturity of 18 days before climacterium, with in total 1.5 days at 20 °C in air to simulate harvest, transport and auction before commercial 8
Firmness (kg)
7.5 Temp (°C) –1
7 6.5
–2 –3
6
–4 –5
5.5
–6 5
0
50
100
150
Time (days)
Fig. 9.12
Firmness during storage and ex-store life at different storage temperatures. 2.8
Firmness (kg)
2.6 Temp (°C) –1 2.4
–2 –3 –4
2.2
–5 –6 2 0
50
100
150
Time (days)
Fig. 9.13
Firmness generated by oxygen-sensitive pectin decay.
226
Texture in food 3
Firmness (kg)
2.5 2
Temp (°C) –1
1.5
–2 –3
1 –4 –5
0.5
–6 0 0
50
Fig. 9.14
100 Time (days)
150
Firmness as generated by oxygen-insensitive pectin decay.
Temperature (°C)
20
15
10
5
0 0
50
100
150
Time (days)
Fig. 9.15 Temperature scenario during storage and ex-store life.
storage, followed by commercial storage at 1–6 °C in an atmosphere of 1% O2 and 3% CO2 at a relative humidity of 90%. The effect on firmness decay of different storage conditions can clearly be seen (see Figs 9.12 and 9.14). The figures also show that firmness decreases only by the action of oxygen insensitive pectin decay. Moreover the (small) difference in the rate of firmness decrease during the ex-store period of 15 days at 20 °C (which is a simulation of the shelf-life at the consumers) should also be noted. Example 2: Variable harvest maturity In the same chain set-up as in Example 1, apples with a harvest maturity from 25 to 0 days before reaching the climacteric stages were stored at 1 °C in 1% O2 and 3% CO2. The simulations are illustrated in Figs 9.16 and 9.17.
Modelling food texture 227 8
Firmness (kg)
7
Harvest maturity (days) – 25
6
– 20 – 15
5
– 10 4
–5 –0
3
0
50
Fig. 9.16
100 Time (days)
150
Firmness as affected by maturity at harvest.
3
Firmness (kg)
2.5 Harvest maturity (days) – 25
2 1.5
– 20 – 15
1
– 10
0.5 0
–5 –0 0
Fig. 9.17
50
100 Time (days)
150
Firmness generated by oxygen-sensitive pectin decay.
The effects of harvest maturity are dramatically visible in Fig. 9.18 showing the development of the climacteric stage at the scenario shown in Fig. 9.19. The riper the apples are at harvest, the sooner climacterium is reached, even in CA conditions. The effects on firmness during storage are not that dramatic, but the riper the apples were harvested the faster the decrease in firmness during the shelf life of the product. 9.4.2 BRAM: Blanching Response Amplification Model The complexity of firmness changes as a consequence of technological actions is clear from the increase in firmness that is often encountered when cooking or sterilising fruits and vegetables that are rich in pectins (Stolle-Smits, 1996). This increase is observed both in objective measurements (StolleSmits, 1996 p. 96) and in sensorial evaluation (Stolle-Smits, 1996 p. 113). Whether or not the increase in firmness is an agreeable one remains to be seen. The phenomenon cannot only be observed in firmness, but is also reflected in the amount of pectin building blocks (galacturonic acid) that are
228
Texture in food 1
Harvest maturity (days)
Climacteric stage (–)
– 25 0.8
– 20 – 15
0.6
– 10 0.4
–5 –0
0.2 0
0
50
100
150
Time (days)
Fig. 9.18
Development of climacteric stage for different stages of maturity at harvest.
Temperature (°C)
20
15
10
5
0 0
Fig. 9.19
50
100 Time (days)
150
Temperature scenario for apples with different stages of maturity at harvest.
found in the treatment water (Stolle-Smits, 1996 p. 99). This already provides the modeller with a clue to what could be happening. The whole process is clearly related to the degradation of pectin chains, most probably under the influence of an enzyme. The effect of the cooking or sterilisation process, however, has to be a chemical non-enzymatic reaction, since at these high temperatures enzyme activity very rapidly ceases to be important. The most prominent of the enzymes that change the structure of the pectin biopolymer without actually decreasing its DP is pectin methyl esterase (PE). PE decreases the degree of methylation of the C6 carboxyl group of the pectin backbone. As a consequence of this action, Ca++ bridges could be formed between adjacent chains (the so-called egg-box model) effectively resulting in a higher degree of polymerisation. At the same time the enzyme PE will denature during prolonged exposure at high temperatures (see previous section). During the cooking process, β-degradation takes place, preferably
Modelling food texture 229
at places containing adjacent methylated carboxylic groups. So, in short, the action of PE enhanced during blanching effectively prevents depolymerisation at cooking time. This whole complex (but still massively simplified) process can schematically be represented as: ks DE + PE → PE kd PE → PE na
[9.15]
kβ
DP + DE → WSP + DE The first reaction in Eq. 9.15 represent the demethylation of pectins, the second the denaturation of the enzyme PE, and the third the β-degradation of the pectin chain. This last reaction contains the degree of esterification as a catalyst for the β-degradation, thereby effectively blocking the process when all ester groups have been removed. Based on this assumed simplified mechanism, and using the fundamental rules of chemical kinetics, the set of differential equations can be deduced: ∂ PE = – kd ⋅ PE ∂t p ∂ DE = – ks ⋅ DE ⋅ PE ∂t p ∂ DP = – k β ⋅ DP ⋅ DE ∂ tc
[9.16]
At constant conditions of treatment time and temperature, the set of differential equations can be solved analytically. The resulting equation, however, is very cumbersome to use in normal statistical analysis. It contains several occurrences of the mathematical exponential integral that can be handled by mathematical packages like MapleV (www.maplesoft.com) and Mathematica (www. wolfram.com), but not by standard statistical packages. It was therefore assumed that at blanching conditions the β-degradation can still be neglected, and that at cooking conditions the enzyme activity has been stopped by complete denaturation. This assumption has the additional benefit that we can split up the processes into separate activities, each with its own time and temperature. The input situation for the cooking/sterilisation process then becomes the output of the blanching treatment. This assumption results at constant external conditions in the following analytical solution for the degree of esterification: k ⋅ PE 0 ⋅ (e – k d ⋅t b – 1) DE ( t b ) = DE 0 ⋅ exp s [9.17] kd The solution for the remaining enzyme activity is shown in Eq. 9.4. Of
230
Texture in food
course all reaction rate constants depend on blanching temperature according to Arrhenius’ law (Eq. 9.5). The third differential equation in Eq. 9.16 can also be solved analytically for constant external conditions, now during the cooking process: DP ( t c ) = DP0 ⋅ exp [– k β ⋅ DE ( t b )]
[9.18]
During this cooking/sterilisation process, the initial situation with respect to DE (DE0) is provided by the previous equation (Eq. 9.17). Combining Eq. 9.17 and Eq. 9.18 integrates the effect of both the pre-heating and cooking time and results in: k ⋅ PE 0 ⋅ (e – k d ⋅ t b – 1) DP ( t c ) = DP0 ⋅ exp – k β ⋅ t c ⋅ DE 0 ⋅ exp s kd [9.19]
Assuming that the decrease in DP only affects the variable part of firmness (in this case firmness originating from pectins), and that the remaining firmness is unchanged by the process under study, DP0 is converted into Firmvar, and a term Firmfix has to be added (see Eq. 9.20) for the analysis of experimental results. Firm (tc)
k ⋅ PE 0 ⋅ (e – k d ⋅ t b – 1) = Firm fix + Firm var ⋅ exp – k β ⋅ t c ⋅ DE 0 ⋅ exp s kd [9.20] In Fig. 9.20 the three-dimensional behaviour of firmness is shown. In Table 9.3 the results from the statistical analysis of experimental data on carrots during different blanching time–temperature combinations, followed by a 30 min cooking at 100 °C using multiple non-linear regression analysis based on Eq. 9.20 (for time dependence) and Eq. 9.5 (for temperature dependence) is shown. Not all the parameters could be estimated on the experimental data. Therefore, a number of (less important) parameters were fixed at some plausible value, some obtained from visual inspection of the data (Firmfix), some from literature (kβ), and some from similar products 2 ) is (PE0, DE0). The exceptionally high explained part of the model ( Radj both amazing and encouraging. Taking into account the high measuring error when measuring objective firmness, a percentage variance accounted for of well over 95% is indeed high. All standard errors (s.e.) are relatively very low (well below 6%). All this statistical information leads to the conclusion that the model and the assumptions upon which it is based are valid. Since the development of the model is entirely based on processes occurring in the product, this model could well be extended to other (similar) products, provided reliable values for the parameters are available. Meanwhile the model has been applied to products like green beans and potatoes. Although the number
Modelling food texture 231
6
Firmness (kg)
5
4
3
2 120 30
40
50 Tempera 60 ture
60 70 (°C)
40 80
90 0
20
80
100
Time (min)
Fig. 9.20 Three-dimensional representation of the measure (symbols) and simulated (solid lines) firmness of carrots as function of pre-heating time and temperature followed by a cooking process.
of data points available and the number of blanching time–temperature combinations was considerably smaller, similar results were obtained. Again this indicates the generic applicability of the model and of the line of reasoning in developing it. More research in this respect is needed. 9.4.3 Optimisation and reversed engineering Modern society requires a different approach to consumers’ wishes. Nowadays, it is no longer technology push, i.e. putting new products on the market based entirely upon technological possibilities, that determines what consumers buy and eat; the technology has to adapt far more to the demands of the market in order to produce new and acceptable products (market pull). So, for food engineers, this changes the entire framework of their actions. The question is no longer: What can we produce? It is turned around as in: How can we produce a product with certain properties? On a fundamental level, the question is no longer: What happens when process circumstances are changed? It is now: How do we have to change the circumstances to obtain a certain property? And that question relies much more on fundamental knowledge of all the processes involved than was the case before. This process of reversion is called reversed engineering. Based on the model BRAM, it was shown that reversed engineering is relatively easy to achieve, if (and only if) we can rely on basic and fundamentally sound models.
232
Texture in food
Table 9.3 Results of the statistical analysis firmness modulation during pre-heating and cooking (BRAM model) Parameter
kd,ref Ead ks Eas Firmvar (≡ DP0)
Estimated Estimate 0.0487 162.12 0.242 113.90 4.73
s.e. 0.00268 3.86 0.00571 1.81 0.159
kβ PEsol DE0 Firmfix
Fixed 0.023 1 60 1.5
n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a
R 2adj Tref tc Nobs
Administrative information 95.4 60 30 294
n.a. = not applicable s.e. = Standard error of estimate
By combining the obtained firmness (left-hand side of Eq. 9.20) with the desired firmness values (Firmlim), and solving for the blanching time, all the solutions in the form of processing conditions that can deliver the desired product firmness are obtained (Eq. 9.21)
tb = –
k PE + ln s 0 ln
Firm lim – Firm fix ln Firm var – k β DE 0 t c ks PE 0 kd
kd
[9.21]
In Fig. 9.21 the results are shown for the processing circumstances required to achieve two levels of targeted firmness after a blanching/cooking sequence, based on the parameter values provided in Table 9.3. It can be clearly seen that achieving a higher targeted firmness requires longer blanching at lower temperatures. The higher temperatures rapidly become unable to provide the desired firmness. So, fundamental modelling not only provides easy and clear descriptions of intricate problems. It also provides the means to accommodate reversed engineering, in developing products with the properties asked for by the consumer.
Modelling food texture 233
Target 4.5 kg 140
Blanching time (min)
120 100 Target 4 kg 80 60 40 20 20
0
50
Fig. 9.21
9.5
55 60 65 Blanching temperature (°C)
70
0
10 Cooking time (min)
Behaviour of the blanching time (tb) to achieve a desired firmness at two different levels.
Future trends
9.5.1 Modelling as a directive of research As already stated in the introduction, the ultimate goal of modelling is to provide reliable predictions of occurrences that have not yet taken place, for any product, from any source and in any situation. If anything is made clear in the previous sections, it is that modelling texture and texture behaviour is not yet capable of fulfilling this target, especially not the last part. Progress has been made, but it is far from being sufficient to predict reliably future behaviour. When only one issue predominantly determines texture, some success has been achieved, as can be seen from the examples provided. When more then one interacting issue determines texture and texture behaviour, that behaviour becomes quite rapidly incomprehensible, and beyond the reach of understanding and modelling. However, based on current viewpoints and ideas, it is possible to model parts of that behaviour, in such a way that modelling can provide information on what could possibly be going on, and where the lack in knowledge actually is. The examples on enzyme activity, important in all changes in our food, whether fresh or processed, make this point evident. Far too little reliable information and knowledge is available on the behaviour of texture-affecting enzymes. But the examples also indicate strongly that not only the type of action that enzymes exert on the texture-generating biopolymers, but also
234
Texture in food
their own rate and mechanism of formation and decay is of major importance. Strong indications are emerging that this is at least one of the reasons for the difference in behaviour of similar food products which have come from completely different growing and/or production sites and systems. The intricate problem of texture origins and textural changes has to be decomposed into generic processes, that can be studied in their own right, and modelled in a fundamentally correct fashion in order to guarantee transferability of model parameter values from one situation and study to another one (Tijskens et al., 1998a). In our opinion that is the only way in which texture in all its forms and shapes can be understood and modelled consistently.
9.5.2 Consistent theory Consistency is the crucial issue in developing theoretical views and fundamental models, especially when interactions play their confusing role as they do in texture behaviour. The more interactions there are, and the more compounds or processes which could be the major source of change, the more a consistent theory is needed to understand all these interactions. But at the same time, the more difficult it is to develop a consistent viewpoint. But that is exactly what is needed to bring the understanding, the modelling and the prediction of texture behaviour for all kinds of food products from all kinds of growing and processing conditions to an acceptable and generic level. Advances in isolated targets have been achieved, and quite some progress has been made over the last decades, but still a consistent theory on texture, its sources, its conversion from chemical compounds to physical measurements, the interactions within the different sources of texture, the role and effect of enzymes in changes in texture is not available. And there lies in our opinion the major challenge for texture research for the coming decades.
9.6
Notation
Variable DE decay DP E Ea Eth k K O2 P PG
degree of esterification any decay products degree of polymerisation molar concentration enzyme activation energy ethylene rate constant (pseudo) equilibrium constant oxygen concentration product molar concentration polygalacturonase (Cont’d.)
Modelling food texture 235 R RelResp S t T WSP α
universal gas constant (8.314 J/mol/K) relative respiration substrate time temperature water soluble pectin degradation products rate constant of depolymerisation
Subscript 0 b c d dO Eth f Firm fix i inter max mo moc na p PG pO ref s var β
initial backward/of blanching of cooking denaturation oxygen induced denaturation of ethylene forward/formation firmness invariable part any intermediary maximal obtainable Michaelis Menten for oxygen inhibition by carbon dioxide not active product or pectin (eg 9) of polygalacturonase of pectin, consuming oxygen at reference temperature substrate variable part For β-elimination
9.7
References
and ADAM S (1994) Studies to determine ripening criteria for peaches, COST 94 Workshop on Quality Criteria, April 19–21, Ljubljana, Slovenia, 105 (abstract). BROWN D and ROTHERY P (1993) Models in Biology: Mathematics, Statistics and Computing, Chichester, Wiley Ltd. BRÜCKNER B (2003) Quality perception: multiple attributes – single acceptance, Proceedings 3rd International Conference An integrated View on Fruit and Vegetable Quality. Quality in Chains, 6–9 July, Wageningen, NL Acta Horticulturae, 604, 161–70. BRÜCKNER B and AUERSWALD H (2000) Instrumental data – consumer acceptance. In Fruit and Vegetable Quality: An Integrated View. Eds R L Shewfelt and B Brückner, Lancaster, PA, Technomic Publishing. CHANG R (1981) Physical Chemistry with Applications to Biological Systems. New York, Macmillan Publ. Co. DEN OUDEN F W C (1995) Physico-chemical stability of tomato products. (PhD thesis, Wageningen Agricultural University, Wageningen, NL). DOLORES ALVAREZ M, SAUNDERS D E J, VINCENT J F V and JERONIMIDIS G (2000) An engineering method to evaluate the crisp texture of fruit and vegetables, J Text Stud, 31, 457–73. EDELSTEIN-KESHET L (1988) Mathematical Models in Biology. New York, Random House. FERSHT A W H (1984) Enzyme Structure and Mechanism, New York, Freeman & Co. BOHLING H
236
Texture in food
(1988) Cellular Solids, Oxford, Pergamon Press. and EVELO R G (1997) Modified atmosphere packaging: optimisation through simulation. In Gorny, J R (Ed.), Proc 7th Intl Controlled Atmosphere Research Conference, July 13–18, UC Davis, CA, 5, 83– 8. HUTCHINGS J B and LILLFORD P J (1988) The perception of food texture – the philosophy of the breakdown path, J Text Stud, 19, 103–15. JERONIMIDIS G (1991) Mechanical and fracture properties of cellular and fibrous materials. In Feeding and the Texture of Food. Eds J F V Vincent and P J Lillford, Cambridge, University Press, 1–17. KEEN R E and SPAIN J D (1992) Computer Simulation in Biology, New York, Wiley-LISS. LUCAS P W, PRINZ J F, AGRAWAL K R and BRUCE I C (2002) Food Physics and Oral Physiology, Food Quality & Preferences, 13, 203–13. LUYTEN H (1988) The Rheological and Fracture Properties of Gouda Cheese (Ph D thesis, Wageningen Agricultural University, NL). LUYTEN H (2003) Quality in the market – technology push versus market pull, Proceedings 3rd International Conference An integrated View on Fruit and Vegetable Quality. Quality in Chains, 6–9 July, Wageningen, NL Acta Horticulturae, 604, 85–93. LUYTEN H and VAN VLIET T (1990) Influence of a filler on the rheological and fracture properties of food materials. In Rheology of Food, Pharmaceutical and Biological Materials with General Rheology. Ed. R E Carter, Amsterdam, Elsevier Applied Science, 43–56. LUYTEN H, VLIET T VAN and WALSTRA P (1991) Characterization of the consistency of Gouda cheese: 1. rheological properties, Neth Milk Dairy J, 45, 33–53. LUYTEN H, PLIJTER J J and VAN VLIET T (2003) Understanding the sensory attributes crispy and crunchy: an integrated approach, Proc 3th Int Symp Food Rheology and Structure, Zürich, 379–84. MEILGAARD M, CIVILLE G V and CARR T (1991) Sensory Evaluation Techniques, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press LLC. MOLNÁR P J (1995) A model for overall description of food quality, Food Quality and Preference, 6, 185–90. PEPPELENBOS H W, VAN ’T LEVEN J, VAN ZWOL B H and TIJSKENS L M M (1993) The influence of O2 and CO2 on the quality of fresh mushrooms, Proceedings Sixth International Controlled Atmosphere Research Conference, June 15–17, Ithaca, USA, 746–58. PEPPELENBOS H W, TIJSKENS L M M, VAN ’T LEVEN J and WILKINSON E C (1996) Modelling oxidative and fermentative carbon dioxide production of fruits and vegetables, Postharvest Biol Technol, 9, 283–95. ∨ POLAKOVIC M and BRYJAK J (2002) Modelling of the kinetics of thermal inactivation of glucoamylase from Aspergillus niger, Journal of Molecular Catalysis B: Enzymatic, 19–20, 443–50. PONNE C T, ARMSTRONG D and LUYTEN H (1996) Influence of dietry fibres on textural properties of food, Proceedings Profibre Symp, July 15–16, Nantes, 61–5. PURSLOW P P (1991) Measuring meat texture and understanding its structural basis. In J F V Vincent & P J Lillford (Eds), Feeding and the Texture of Food. Soc Exp Biol, 44, 34– 56. SAEDT A P H, HOMAN W J and REINDERS M P (1991) A finite state Markov model with continuous time parameter for physical and chemical cutting processes, European Journal of Operational Research, 55, 279–90. SCANLON M G and ZGHAL M C (2001) Bread properties and crumb structure, Food Research International, 34, 841–64. SCHIJVENS E P H M, VAN VLIET T and VAN DIJK C (1998) Effect of processing conditions on the composition and rheological properties of applesauce, J Text Stud, 29(2), 123–43. SLOOF M (1999) Physiology of Quality Change Modelling (Dissertation Free University of Amsterdam, No 99-1. 21-9, NL). GIBSON L J
and
ASHBY M F
HERTOG M L A T M, PEPPELENBOS H W, TIJSKENS L M M
Modelling food texture 237 (2001) Problem decomposition. In Food Process Modelling. Eds L M M Tijskens, M L A T M Hertog and B M Nicolaï, Cambridge, Woodhead Publishing, 19–34. SLOOF M, TIJSKENS L M M and WILKINSON E C (1996) Concepts for modelling quality of perishable products, Trends in Food Science & Technology, 7, 165–71. STOLLE-SMITS T (1996) Effects of thermal processing on cell walls of green beans: a chemical and structural study (PhD thesis, Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, NL). SZCZESNIAK A S (2002) Texture is a sensory property, Food Quality and Preference 13, 215– 25. THORNLEY J H M (1976) Mathematical Models in Plant Physiology: a Quantitative Approach to Problems in Plant and Crop Physiology, London, Academic Press. THORNLEY J H M and JOHNSON I R (1990) Plant and Crop Modelling: a Mathematical Approach to Plant and Crop Physiology, Oxford, Clarendon. TIJSKENS L M M (1995) A model on the respiration of vegetable produce during postharvest treatments, Proceedings International Conference on AGRI-FOOD Quality, June 25– 28, Norwich, 322–7. rd TIJSKENS L M M (2003) Modelling quality, Proceedings 3 International Conference an Integrated View on Fruit and Vegetable Quality: Quality in Chains, 6–9 July 2003, Wageningen, NL, Acta Horticulturae, 604, 123–36. TIJSKENS L M M and RODIS P S (1997) Kinetics of enzyme activity in peaches during storage and processing, Food Technol & Biotechnol, 35, 45–50. TIJSKENS L M M, SLOOF M and WILKINSON E C (1994) Quality of perishable produce. A philosophical approach, Proceedings of the Sixth International Symposium of the European Concerted Action Program COST94 The Post-Harvest Treatment of Fruit and Vegetables – Current Status and Future Prospects, 19–22 October, Oosterbeek, NL, 493–502. TIJSKENS L M M, RODIS P S, HERTOG M L A T M, WALDRON K W, INGHAM L, PROXENIA N and VAN DIJK C (1997a) Activity of peroxidase during blanching of peaches, carrots and potatoes, J Food Eng, 34, 355–70. TIJSKENS L M M, WALDRON K W, NG A, INGHAM L and VAN DIJK C (1997b) The kinetics of pectin methyl esterase in potatoes and carrots during blanching, J Food Eng, 34, 371–85. TIJSKENS L M M, HERTOG M L A T M, DIJK C VAN (1998a) Generic modelling and practical applications. In EUR 18183 – COST Action 915, Consumer Oriented Quality Improvement of Fruit and Vegetable Products, Food Quality Modelling. Eds B M Nicolai and D de Baerdemaeker, Luxembourg, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, 145–51. TIJSKENS L M M, RODIS P S, HERTOG M L A T M, KALANTZI U and VAN DIJK C (1998b) Kinetics of polygalacturonase activity and firmness of peaches during storage, J Food Eng, 35, 111–26. TIJSKENS L M M, HERTOG M L A T M and VAN DIJK C (1999a) GESSI: a Generic Enzyme System for Stimulation and Inactivation during storage and processing. Hägg M, Ahvenainen R, Evers A M and Tiilikkata K (Eds), Proceedings Second International Conference AGRI-FOOD QUALITY II, 22–25 April 1998, Turku, Finland, 81–86. TIJSKENS L M M, RODIS P S, HERTOG M L A T M, PROXENIA N and VAN DIJK C (1999b) Activity of pectin methyl esterase during blanching of peaches, J Food Eng, 39, 167–77. TIJSKENS L M M, HERTOG M L A T M, VAN SCHAIK A C R and DE JAGER A (1999c) Modelling the firmness of Elstar apples during storage and transport, International Symposium on Effect of Preharvest and Postharvest factors on Storage of Fruits and Vegetables, August 1997, Warsaw, Poland, Acta Horticulturae, 485, 363–72. VAN BOEKEL M A J S and TIJSKENS L M M (2001) Kinetic modelling. In Food Process Modelling. Eds L M M Tijskens, M L A T M Hertog and B M Nicolaï, Cambridge, Woodhead Publishing, 35–59. VAN DIJK C and TIJSKENS L M M (2000) Mathematical modeling of enzymatic reactions as related to the texture of fruits and vegetables after storage and mild preheat treatments. In Design of Minimal Processing Technologies for Fruit and Vegetables. Eds S M SLOOF M
238
Texture in food
Alzamora, S M Tapia and A López-Malo, Gaithersburg, M D, Aspen Publishers Inc., 127–52. VAN VLIET T, LUYTEN H (1995) Fracture mechanics of solid foods. In New Physico-chemical Techniques for the Characterization of Complex Food Systems. Ed. E Dickinson, Cambridge, Chapman & Hall, 157–76. VINCENT J F V (1991) Texture of plants and fruits. In: JFV Vincent & PJ Lillford (Eds.): Feeding and the texture of food, Soc Exp Biol, 44, 19–33. VINCENT J F V, JERONIMIDIS G, KHAN A A and LUYTEN H (1991) The wedge fracture test a new method for measuring food texture, J Text Stud, 22, 45–57. VINCENT J F V, SAUNDERS D E J and BEYTS P (2002) The use of critical stress intensity factor to quantify “hardness” and “crunchiness” objectively, J Text Stud, 33, 149–59. WHITTAKER J R (1994) Principles of Enzymology for Food Sciences (Second Edition), New York, M. Dekker. WIJK R DE, RASING F and WILKINSON C (2003) Texture of semi-solids 2: Sensory flavortexture interactions for custard desserts, J Text Stud (in press). WILKINSON E C and TIJSKENS L M M (2001) Modelling food quality. In Food Process Modelling. Eds L M M Tijskens, M L A T M Hertog and B M Nicolaï, Cambridge, Woodhead Publishing, 367–82.
Part III Understanding and improving the texture of particular foods
This page intentionally left blank
10 Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture K. W. Waldron, Institute of Food Research, UK
10.1
Introduction
Texture is probably one of the most important quality characteristics of edible fruits and vegetables. It is known that plant structure plays a key role in determining texture, and numerous researchers have sought to elucidate the relationship(s) between these aspects in the hope of identifying means of control. However, such relationships have been difficult to expose. As a result, methods and processes to control texture have often been developed empirically. This chapter starts by considering the meaning of texture, with special reference to sensory texture and analytical texture. This is followed by a brief description of plant structure and how it contributes to texture in relation to different length scales. In particular, the importance of cell adhesion is emphasised in relation to crispness and juiciness. The influence of postharvest treatments and processing are considered together with how our increased understanding of cell-wall microstructure and polymer chemistry is enabling us to identify new potential routes to control texture. Finally, the chapter ends by assessing where there may be key deficiencies in our understanding of texture and plant structure, and offers suggested areas of research. 10.1.1 Texture For decades, researchers have sought to define food texture, usually in relation to the food properties and the sensations created during eating. Texture is an important quality attribute of fruits and vegetables and is based on sensory perceptions. The term was originally used to describe the visual and tactile
242
Texture in food
characteristics of fabrics and applied later to other materials such as foods (Guinard and Mazzucchelli, 1996). Texture perception includes the appraisal of food in the mouth and involves the skin, muscles and connective tissues in and around the face. Bourne (1982) defined the textural properties of a food as the group of physical characteristics that: • arise from the structural elements of the food; • are sensed by the feeling of touch; • are related to the deformation, disintegration and flow of food under force; • are measured objectively by functions of mass, time and distance. More recently, Szczesniak (1990) has defined food texture as “the sensory manifestation of the structure of food and the manner in which this structure reacts to the applied forces, the specific senses involved being vision, kinaesthesia and hearing” (kinaesthesia comprises the sensation of presence, movement and position as resulting from nerve ending stimulation). The importance of the sensory basis of texture has stimulated research into the consumer perception of texture in foods. Indeed, Guinard and Mazzucchelli (1996) state that “analytical sensory evaluation and consumer testing provided the most meaningful and reliable information about the textural qualities and acceptability of a food or beverage”. Interestingly, visual and tactile information from handling and cutting are also important, enabling the appraisal of food texture to begin prior to ingestion (Bech et al., 2001).
10.2
Measurement of texture
10.2.1 Measurement of sensory texture Sensory assessment involves the codification of sensory experiences, and is commonly carried out by trained panels. These can provide an objective assessment of sensory attributes or characteristics (Civille and Szczesniak, 1973). Szczesniak (1963) developed a well-organised approach for the classification of textural characteristics according to three groups: 1. mechanical (hardness, cohesiveness, viscosity, elasticity and adhesiveness; brittleness, chewiness and gumminess); 2. geometrical (those related to size and shape, and those related to shape and orientation); 3. compositional characteristics (moisture and fat contents). For vegetables, Szczesniak also emphasised that the mechanical characteristics within the different components of a multi-phase food should be considered.
Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture 243
10.2.2 Measurement of mechanical texture The development of instrumental methods has arisen mainly from the desire to monitor and evaluate the texture of foods during food production and processing. It has also been driven by the need to relate texture to underlying food composition. Thus, a considerable amount of research has sought to elucidate the mechanical properties of plant-based foods in relation to composition and structure. The Scott-Blair approach identifies three types of texture measurement: empirical, imitative and fundamental (Szczesniak, 1963; Brennan and Jowitt, 1977). Empirical tests have been developed from practical experience and are often considered to be arbitrary and poorly defined (Bourne, 1994). Imitative tests have been considered to be a sub-set of empirical tests that seek to mimic the consumer (Peleg, 1983). In contrast, fundamental tests are usually defined in engineering units and include measurement of precise mechanical properties with universal testing apparatus (Smith et al., 2002).
10.2.3 Acoustic emission and crispness Crispness is a particularly important quality characteristic in many fruits and vegetables. There is a considerable body of research on crispness of foods, but most of it involves dry materials such as breakfast cereals and snack foods (Fillion and Kilcast, 2002) where it is significantly affected by the degree of hydration. This research suggests that crispness is poorly defined (Roudaut et al., 2002). The role of auditory sensations in crispness has been reviewed by Vickers (1985, 1988). Vickers and Bourne (1976) suggested that the number of emitted sounds per unit biting distance and the loudness of the sounds changed with perceived crispness. Crisp products are characterised by sudden, clean and total fractures; the rapid fracture propagation of dry crisp foods underlying the generation of sound is commensurate with Vincent’s (1998) definition of crispness as a sudden drop in load experienced in muscles and teeth sensors when a crisp item breaks in the mouth. As a result, one means of assessing sensory attributes such as crispness is to measure the sounds produced during compression of foods. Regarding fruits and vegetables, Fillion and Kilcast (2002) have studied the consumer perception of crispness and crunchiness, and have confirmed the complexity of these concepts and the important contributions made from a wide range of peceptions including fracture characteristics, sound, density and geometry.
10.2.4 Comparing instrumental and sensory measurement of texture Instrumental methods for measuring texture are valid only if they can predict sensory textural attributes. This aspect has been studied in depth (e.g. Szczesniak, 1987; Peleg, 1983; Brennan and Jowitt, 1977). However, a number of recent studies have indicated that in fruits and vegetables sensory measurement cannot yet be replaced by instrumental approaches (e.g. Harker et al. (2002). Nevertheless, recent advances in data handling and interpretation may provide
244
Texture in food
further opportunities to explore the relationships and associations between physical measurements and sensory perceptions (e.g. DeBelie et al., 2002). Hence, texture is a very difficult concept to describe or measure. This presents significant difficulties when attempting to develop food-chain strategies to modify the texture of fruits and vegetables. However, it is generally accepted that sensory texture of edible plant organs is dependent on the structure of those organs and, by understanding plant structure, it may be possible to develop methods to improve sensory texture.
10.3 Plant structure The fracture mechanics, and therefore textural characteristics, of edible plant organs relate to the way they deform and disrupt during mastication (e.g. Jackman and Stanley, 1995). Edible plant organs are highly complex. They comprise a range of contributory structures at different length scales: organs are made up of tissues, which exist in a range of shapes and sizes. These, in turn, consist of plant cells and intercellular air-spaces that also differ in shape, size and packing. Each cell is surrounded by its own cell wall, the dimensions of which, and the mode and extent of adhesion to one another, can also vary. Within the cell wall, there is a further level of complexity comprising substructures such as plasmodesmata which are involved in intercellular communication, in addition to the layered character of the middle lamella (between cells), primary and secondary walls (Fig. 10.1 a&b). Finally, the (bio)chemical composition of cell walls differs, not only from cell to cell, but between the substructures within any one wall. This hierarchy of structures is summarised in Fig. 10.2. This heterogeneity reflects the varying functionality of the tissues, cells and cell walls in the plant (Gibeaut and Carpita, 1993; Brett and Waldron, 1996). Edible fruits and vegetables are generally rich in weak, non-structural parenchyma cells. The strength and texture of such tissues is determined by the mechanical properties of the cell walls in conjunction with the internal turgor pressure of the cells and intercellular adhesion (Van Buren, 1979; Brett and Waldron, 1996). The functions of some tissues can change during the life of a cell or organ, and textural characteristics will result from the natural structural characteristics of the plant organ as modified by growth, development and post-harvest treatments.
10.4 Cellular basis of crispness, juiciness and mealiness in fruit tissue 10.4.1 Crispness and turgor pressure Whilst crispness is not fully understood as a perception, and cannot yet be measured directly by instrumental means, there is little doubt that the crispness
Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture 245
Fig. 10.1 (a) Electron micrograph of a cell wall of Chinese waterchestnut. Abbreviations: m: middle lamella; p: primary wall. The cell wall is approximately 0.5 µm across.
Fig. 10.1 (b) Electron micrograph of a cell wall of asparagus collenchyma cell. Abbreviations: m: middle lamella; p: primary wall; s: secondary wall. The cell wall is approximately 2 µm across.
246
Texture in food Root, Stem, Fruit, Leaf
Organ
Texture
Parenchyma, Epidermis, Vascular Tissue Adhesion, Shape, Transport Cell Strength, Elasticity, Porosity
Cell wall
Wall domains
Polymers
Adhesion, Communication Chemistry, Rheology
Physiological / processing events
Fig. 10.2 The hierarchy of structures within plants.
in fruits and vegetables relies on the sudden fracturing of the intact plant structure during masticatory activities. This is consistent with Szczesniak’s (1988) description of fresh celery which asserts that celery is crisp because it snaps cleanly, and it is crunchy because its cellular structure facilitates a series of successive fractures when eaten. The fracture characteristics of crisp plant tissues therefore depend on the crack propagation properties of the tissues. In the case of edible plant tissues, this will depend on the characteristics of the cellular structure in conjunction with turgor pressure. Turgor pressure results from the osmotically-driven influx of water into a cell as a result of the higher concentration of solutes within the protoplast which is bounded by a semi-permeable (plasma) membrane. In the native plant tissue, turgor pressure is the key driver of cell expansion, which then occurs as a result of controlled slippage between cell-wall polymers. For a cell to exhibit turgor, the cell wall must exhibit elasticity over a range of tensions which counters the osmotic influx of water. Without elasticity, there can be no turgidity, only a rigid state or a flaccid state (Brett and Waldron, 1996). The internal pressure of cells affects the mechanical properties of tissues, and Lin and Pitt (1986) argued that turgid cells cause the cell wall to be stressed. Crack propagation in crisp tissues involves cell wall breakage. Pressure on the tissue from the teeth increases the hydrostatic pressure in the nearest cells, the walls of which are stretched to the extremes of their elasticity and then fracture catastrophically. Because numerous cells around the point of force from the tooth are pressurised in this way, a crack will propagate
Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture 247
through them, rupturing the cell walls as it travels and releasing juice. If the tissue is being crushed between molars, then the pressure will be increased in many cells between the teeth, providing a potential path of fully stretched cells along which a crack can travel. If a tissue has lost moisture through evaporation (e.g. wilted celery), or if the extent of elastic extension of the cell walls has increased for whatever reason (e.g. asparagus stored under anaerobic conditions as described by Waldron and Selvendran, 1990), then turgidity will be low. In such a situation, a much greater degree of tissue deformation will have to be induced before the walls can be stretched to breaking point. Such tissues will have a rubbery texture. Hence, tissues containing turgid cells are crisper and are characterised by greater stiffness and lower toughness or work of fracture than flaccid tissues containing low turgor pressure cells (Hiller and Jeronimidis, 1996).
10.4.2 Juiciness and mealiness Juiciness and mealiness are terms commonly used to describe edible fruit and vegetable texture. Juiciness is used mainly in describing fruits. It results from the release of juice from the fruit tissues during mastication and is generally considered to be a highly positive attribute. The release of juice and associated flavour compounds will generally depend on cell rupture, although wall porosity will obviously play a role. If forces adhering cells to one another are stronger than the cell walls, then failure will occur in the walls. Alternatively, if the cell walls are stronger than the forces holding cells together, cell separation, tissue softening and mealiness will result (Fig. 10.3). Mealiness, thus involves encapsulation of juice, flavours and other cell contents within the cells and is usually considered to be a negative quality attribute, associated with fluffy appearance and a floury and granular texture (Jaeger et al., 1998; Barreiro et al., 1998). Like many sensory characteristics, there are other closely related expressions. For example the term ‘succulent’ is often used in reference to young vegetables (Szczesniak and Ilker, 1988). Mealiness is a term also applied to some vegetables after cooking (see below). Juiciness and mealiness are considered to be inversely related to each other (e.g. Kuhn and Thybo, 2001). The more mealy a ripe fruit tissue is, the less juicy it is often perceived to be. However, ripeninginduced softness is not always associated with mealiness as in the case of Spanish pears (Martin-Cabrejas et al., 1994). This has been studied sensorialy by Barreiro et al. (1998). In studies on apples, the sensory procedure profiled mealiness as a loss of crispness and juiciness, and an increase in the floury sensation in the mouth.
10.4.3 Ripening-related changes in cell adhesion Ripening-related softening of fruits is associated with a high degree of wall disruption (e.g. Ben-Arie et al., 1979; Brett and Waldron, 1996; Harker
248
Texture in food
Fig. 10.3 Phase contrast light micrograph of separated cells from mealy apple. The cells are approximately 100 µm across.
et al., 1997; Tucker, 2003). This involves loss of electron-density of the middle lamella and the solubilisation of pectic polysaccharides. It is usually accompanied by an overall decrease in non-cellulosic neutral sugars, for example galactose and arabinose (Redgwell et al., 1997). A resultant decrease in the strength of cell adhesion results in an increase in cell separation and tissue softening. Extreme cell separation results in a mealy character (see above) as in the case of certain apple varieties. Here, the juice remains inside the cells. There has been a considerable amount of research to try to correlate such changes in cell-wall chemistry with changes in texture in order to elucidate the biochemical mechanism and identify possible points of control. So far, evidence suggests that ripening-related softening involves the actions of a number of cell wall-degrading enzymes. These include endopolygalacturonase (endo-PG), pectin methyl-esterase (PME), and β-galactosidase in the main, but others, including cellulase, xyloglucan endotransglycosylase (XET) and expansins have also been identified. Brummel and Harpster (2001) have succinctly summarised a number of conclusions that can be drawn from molecular-genetic studies on such enzymes, mainly in tomato. In particular, PG, in conjunction with PME, is the main enzyme involved in the depolymerisation and associated solubilisation of pectic polysaccharides. Interestingly, its suppression appears to reduce fruit softening only slightly, but has a considerable impact on shelf life. In addition, early suppression of β-galactosidase activity reduces softening, presumably as a result of steric hindrance of the side chains in relation to endo-PG activity. Also, ripening-
Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture 249
related expansin levels correlate with softening, and may help to stimulate pectin depolymerisation. However, changes in the integrity of cell membranes and resultant leakage of water and electrolytes may also be important.
10.5 Cellular stability during processing High temperature heating of fruit and vegetable tissues causes an initial loss of instrumental firmness due to the disruption of the plasmalemma and an associated loss of turgor (Greve et al., 1994). This may result in the development of a rubbery character. However, the most notable change involves tissue softening which results from an increase in the ease of cell separation in many non-lignified tissues (Van Buren, 1979). Thermally induced cell separation is believed to be due to the β-eliminative degradation of pectic polysaccharides involved in cell adhesion (BeMiller and Kumar, 1972; Keijbets and Pilnik, 1974). Such depolymerisation is strongly influenced by pH, and is enhanced considerably under increasingly alkaline conditions (Neukom and Deuel, 1958). It is also strongly influenced by other ions and is enhanced by e.g. Ca, Mg, K ions, citrate, malate and phytate organic acids (Keijbets and Pilnik, 1974). The softening of acidic fruit tissues during heating has been attributed to acid hydrolysis of cell-wall polysaccharides, although this has been refuted by Krall and McFeeters (1998). Thermal treatment of plant tissues is often accompanied by wall swelling (Warren and Woodman, 1974; LeCain et al., 1997). This may be due to the thermal degradation of polymers that laterally stabilise the wall, facilitating disruption, and may also be affected by changes in the ionic composition of the cell wall. The ability of calcium to cross-link pectic polysaccharides and thereby reduce their solubilisation provides a dual role for this ion as a promoter of pectin degradation through eliminative degradation, whilst enhancing texture through cross-linking. 10.5.1 Pre-cooking If some edible plant tissues are thermally treated at 50–60 °C for approximately 30 minutes or more, they fail to soften to the same degree as non pre-treated tissues during subsequent high-temperature processing. This is thought to be due to the thermal-stimulation of wall-bound PME which de-esterifies pectic polysaccharides involved in cell adhesion (Van Buren, 1979). The result is a greater stability against β-eliminative degradation at high temperatures, which is augmented by a greater ability of the pectic polymers to be ionically crosslinked by divalent cations. Similar effects can be induced by chemical deesterication in cold, dilute alkali (Van Buren and Pitifer, 1992). The precooking effect can be sizeable in vegetables such as carrots (Ng and Waldron, 1997a). In some others, e.g. potatoes, it is often less and it is often variety dependent. However, the changes in cell-wall chemistry are similar (Ng and Waldron, 1997b). It is likely that the pre-cooking effect on thermal stability
250
Texture in food
of cell adhesion relies not only on the PME-induced de-esterification of pectic polysaccharides, but also on the availability of divalent cations to produce extra ionic cross-links (Ng and Waldron, 1997b), and the impact of their chelation by intracellular organic acids. This is in keeping with the observation that the pre-cooking effect in carrots can be reversed by soaking in CDTA (chelator of calcium) (Ng and Waldron, 1997b). There have been relatively few studies on the molecular mechanism of pre-cooking, although Sajjaanantakul et al. (1989) investigated the effect on solubilised polymers. More recently, Tijskens et al. (1997 a, b) studied the kinetics of PME activity to the firming process. Nevertheless, industrial exploitation of pre-cooking has been approached in an empirical manner, and is often carried out in conjunction with the addition of calcium salts to control texture. There is little understanding of the precise (bio)chemical basis for pre-cooking, and this area lends itself to further investigation in the light of the increase in demand for pre-prepared vegetables.
10.5.2 Resistance to thermal softening Some edible, non-lignified parenchyma tissues fail to soften during thermal processing. Chinese water chestnut (CWC), Chufa and mature sugarbeet and beetroot contain examples of these tissues (Parker and Waldron, 1995; Parr et al., 1997; Waldron et al., 1997a; Ng et al., 1998; Parker et al., 2000). In CWC, the edible tissues consist of thin-walled, starch-rich storage parenchyma with a few thin vascular bundles. After thermal treatments such as cooking or canning, CWC retains its firm and crisp texture in terms of both sensory perception and mechanically-measured tensile strength and toughness (Waldron et al., 1997a). This is because its cells fail to separate and tissue fracture occurs only by cell-wall fracture. A number of studies have been carried out to investigate this characteristic and to elucidate the nature of the polymers involved. It appears that in CWC, arabinoxylans, which are cross-linked by ferulic acid (FA) (Parr et al., 1997), are responsible for thermal stability of texture. Chufa, which is closely related to CWC (Parker et al., 2000), demonstrates similar properties. Sugarbeet and beetroot, both dicotyledonous plants, can exhibit similar characteristics as a result of the ferulate-crosslinking of pectic polysaccharides (Waldron et al., 1997a, b). The role of this cross-linking has been highlighted by the observation that increasing the cross-linking by peroxidation also increases the thermal stability of texture (cooking time) (Ng et al., 1998). In all these examples, the ferulic acid interpolymeric cross-links include a family of six dehydrodimers which make up to 4% of the FA. Interestingly, the level of FA in the cell walls is relatively low (about 2% dwt) as compared with the polysaccharide components. Perhaps this low level explains why it was overlooked in earlier studies (e.g. Loh and Breene, 1981). At the time of writing there are studies underway to investigate the molecular-genetic control of such cross-linking.
Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture 251
Tissues in immature edible organs such as those in immature stems and leaves often undergo post-harvest toughening (Burton, 1981). In many cases, this has usually been attributed to continued maturation. For example, the continued development of vascular and support tissues in edible stems such as asparagus and cauliflower involves secondary wall development with associated lignification. This may be augmented by the permeation of lignin precursor phenolics into the middle lamella between walls of adjacent nonlignified (e.g. parenchyma) cells. The resulting intercellular cross-links are resistant to thermal treatments, and reduce the extent of tissue softening during thermal processing (Femenia et al., 1999a, b). In addition, cinnamic acids may play a role in post-harvest toughening. In asparagus, this characteristic is accompanied by, and generally considered to be due to, an increase in lignification and the formation of interpolymeric cross-linking (Waldron and Selvendran, 1992). However, recent research has demonstrated that there is an additional increase in feruloylated polysaccharides which become crosslinked with diferulic acid (Rodriguez-Arcos et al., 2002). This is likely to be a wound response, stimulated by the harvesting process; the levels of FA are much lower in all parts of the stem during normal growth. This suggests that wound responses may also contribute to post-harvest toughening of vegetable tissues and could provide additional metabolic routes for control. An additional example of resistance to thermal softening concerns the development of the Hard-To-Cook (HTC) defect in grain legumes (Mattson et al., 1950). Storage of legume seeds under conditions of high humidity and high temperature as found in tropical countries results in an increase in cooking time of the seeds. This has a consequential impact on water and fuel use. Whilst much research has been carried out on this problem (Aguilera and Stanley, 1985; Reyes-Moreno and Liu, 1995), the mechanism is still poorly understood. Nevertheless, a possible multi-mechanism hypothesis has been suggested by Liu (1995). The way in which plant organs fracture is complicated further by the heterogeneity of component cell types. These can have very different mechanical and fracture properties which reflect their physiological function. In an onion leaf base, for example, the tissues are relatively homogeneous, comprising storage parenchyma cells. However, the tissues inside an asparagus spear reflect the immature stage of a rapidly-growing stem with vascular and strengthening cells. The walls of such cells are stronger and tougher than the thin, non-lignified walls of parenchyma cells and will strongly influence the mechanical and fracture properties of the stem.
10.6 Improving cell adhesion The above sections have described some of the many factors that contribute towards the textural characteristics of fruits and vegetables. The texture of a fruit or vegetable will depend predominantly on tissue fracture characteristics.
252
Texture in food
These will be influenced by a number of criteria including cell type, cell and tissue heterogeneity, cell adhesion, cell contents and turgor, and all as modified by food-chain and post-harvest events. Furthermore, the sensory texture is itself poorly defined. However, it is clear that a key determinant of texture is the degree to which cells separate or rupture during mastication. Hence, it is generally accepted that controlling cell adhesion is an important route to controlling texture. Many attempts to control cell adhesion in ripening fruits and processed vegetables have involved empirical approaches, for example modifying agronomic and processing events, or breeding, or genetic modification, followed by assessment of the end product quality. It is often assumed that by gathering large bodies of information, and applying statistical analysis, the mechanisms of cell separation during ripening or processing might be further understood, and control routes revealed. Unfortunately, this approach has highlighted the complexity of the softening process, and presented more questions than answers. We are still a long way from being able to precisely control texture in a predictive manner. One of the key reasons for this is that the architecture of cell adhesion at the molecular level is still poorly understood. For decades, cell adhesion has been considered to be the domain of the entire middle lamella generally. Like cement between bricks in a wall, the middle lamella has been thought of as the glue joining the faces of adjacent cells (e.g. Van Buren, 1979; Harker et al., 1997). This has stimulated much research into the physicochemical properties of pectic polysaccharides, particularly in relation to molecular weight, degree of methyl esterification, and propensity for βeliminative degradation. There have been numerous attempts to correlate changes in such properties with changes in tissue texture (e.g. Ng et al., 1997 a, b). However, there is an increasing body of evidence which indicates that cell adhesion is controlled by precise aspects of wall architecture. In the remaining sections, some of the findings supporting this are presented, and considered in relation to the possible future approaches to controlling texture.
10.6.1 The relationship between wall architecture and cell adhesion Several lines of research suggest that cell adhesion is not dependent on the entire middle lamella layer, but on components that are located predominantly at the edges of cell faces, and which therefore involve only a small fraction of middle lamella polymers. Kolloffel and Linssen (1984) investigated cell wall formation by TEM (transmission electron microscopy) during cell division. Cell adhesion between daughter cells begins at the later stages of cell division. A specific region of the parent cell wall is degraded, thereby enabling connection of the newlyformed cell plate (which separates the daughter cells), to the middle lamella surrounding the parent cell (Kolloffel and Linssen, 1984; Knox, 1992). The cell plate is fated to become the new middle lamella between the daughter cells. Afterwards, an inter-cellular space develops in the tricellular junction
Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture 253
region between the two daughter cells and the adjacent cell. The new intercellular space then spreads along the middle lamella. The extent of the space is regulated by electron-dense intra-wall structures at which space formation terminates (Kolloffel and Linssen, 1984). These regions are thus located at the corners of pre-determined intracellular spaces. If separation failed to cease at these points, it would continue until the cells separated completely. These regions represent sections of continuous arcs along the edges of intercellular spaces. However, the observations did not preclude the rest of the middle lamella from being involved in cell adhesion, and did not provide any information on the chemical or biochemical composition or nature of the arcs. There is now significant evidence to support the leading role of these arcs in cell adhesion. The importance of calcium in the cross-linking of low-ester pectic polysaccharides involved in cell adhesion is well established, and chelation of calcium from tissues such as potato parenchyma results in cell separation (Waldron et al., 1997a). Investigations into the localisation of calcium-binding, low-ester pectic polysaccharides were pioneered by the development of monoclonal antibody (Mab) technology. Cell walls of carrot tissues (Knox et al., 1990), suspension-cultured carrot cells (Liners and Van-Cutsem, 1992) and ripe cherry tomato (Roy et al., 1992) were immunolabelled with the anti-pectin Mabs JIM5 and JIM7. JIM5 Mabs bound preferentially to the electron-dense regions of the cell wall were highlighted by Kolloffel and Linssen (1984) indicating that they contained low-esterified homogalacturonan sequences. In contrast, the highly-esterified pectins to which JIM7 bound did not exhibit such localisation. This characteristic has been explored on the surface of separated cells by SEM (scanning electron microscopy) (Parker et al., 2001) and by using fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)-tagged JIM5 antibodies (Waldron et al., unpublished). The JIM5 Mabs bind preferentially to the edges of the cell faces. A number of more highly-characterised Mabs have also been raised to calcium-binding homogalacturonan. Of particular note is LM7 which is specific to a non-blockwise pattern of methyl esterification. This Mab binds specifically at the corners of all parenchyma inter-cellular spaces examined to date (Willats et al., 2001). In keeping with the distribution of unesterified pectic polysaccharides which can be crosslinked by divalent cations, calcium has been found to be located in the middle lamella, particularly at the corners of inter-cellular spaces (Roy et al., 1992). Additional evidence for the role of the edge of the cell face has come from studies on phenolic esters. If CWC tissues are extracted with hot, dilute alkali, cell separation can be induced. Under these conditions, only a proportion of the phenolics are released from the cell wall. Analysis of the separated cells by fluorescence microscopy has revealed that the remaining phenolic moieties are concentrated at the edges of the cell faces (Waldron et al., 1997a; Fig. 10.4). This strongly supports the hypothesis that the edge of the cell face is particularly important in cell adhesion. Interestingly, analysis of
254
Texture in food
Fig. 10.4 Fluorescence micrograph of a single cell of Chinese waterchestnut. The cell was released from parenchyma tissue after extraction in mild alkali. Abbreviations: f: cell faces; e: edges of cell faces. The cell is approximately 100 µm across.
the phenolic moieties remaining in the cell wall indicated that they were enriched in 8,8’-DiFA in the aryltetralyn form (Waldron et al., 1997a) suggesting that there may be some specificity in the role of this dehydrodimer as later highlighted by Parker et al. (2003). The role of the bulk of the middle lamella in cell adhesion has also been studied. Parker et al. (2000) have investigated the structures remaining on the surface of separated potato cells and have observed that the middle lamella is a separate entity which is attached to the cell walls only at the edges of the cell faces. This result strongly supports the dominant role of the edge of the cell face in adhesion, and indicates that the bulk of the middle lamella is probably not involved in adhesion. The importance of the edges of the face is also supported by mathematical considerations by Jarvis (1998).
10.7 Future trends Texture is a sensorial issue and relates to the interaction of food in the mouth during ingestion. As yet, it is not possible to use instrumental methods to replace a trained sensory panel. Furthermore, the relationships between the
Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture 255
different levels of plant structure and texture are a long way from being understood. However, the increase in understanding of wall architecture in relation to cell adhesion provides a useful focus for research since this area is likely to provide some control over texture. There is a paucity of information concerning the chemistry of cell-wall components at the edges of the cell faces. Apart from indirect evidence from epitope localisation studies and fluorescence microscopy, the composition of edge-of-face polymers is largely unknown. Moreover, the biochemical activities in this domain remain to be elucidated. This has significance not only from the textural perspective, but also as the basis of multi-cellularity in higher plants. The edge of the cell face results from metabolic events that occur during cell division. It provides the means by which the two daughter cells can adhere to each other and it is consequently fundamental to nearly every aspect of multi-cellular plant growth and development. Therefore this concept lends itself to basic research activities which would not only provide a greater understanding of plant morphology, but would also provide a potential leverage on the textural quality of plant-based foods.
10.8 Acknowledgements The author wishes to thank Dr M L Parker for the electron, light and fluorescent micrographs. This writing of this article was supported by the UK Biotechnology and Biological Science Research Council.
10.9 References and STANLEY D W (1985) A review of textural defects on cooking reconstituted legumes – the influence of storage and processing, J Food Proc Preserv, 47, 144–69. BARREIRO P, ORTIZ C, RUIZ-ALTISENT M, DE SMEDT V, SCHOTTE S, ANDANI Z, WAKELING I and BEYTS P K (1998) Comparison between sensory and instrumental measurements for mealiness assessment in apples. A collaborative test, J Text Stud, 29, 509–25. BECH A C, GRUNERT K G, BREDAHL L, JUHL H J and POULSEN C S (2001) Consumers’ quality perception. In Food, People and Society – A European Perspective of Consumer’s Food Choices. Eds L J Frewer, E Risvik and H Schifferstein Berlin, Heidelberg, Springer, 97–113. BEMILLER J N and KUMAR G V (1972) β-elimination of uronic acids: evidence for an ElcB mechanisms, Carb Res, 25, 419–28. BEN-ARIE R, KISLEV N and FRENKEL C (1979) Ultrastructural changes in the cell wall of ripening apple and pear fruit, Plant Physiol, 64, 197–202. BOURNE M C (1982) Food Texture and Viscosity: Concept and Measurement. London, Academic Press. BOURNE M C (1994) Converting from empirical to rheological tests on foods: it’s a matter of time, Cereal Foods World, 39, 37–9. BRENNAN J G and JOWITT R (1977) Some factors affecting the objective study of food texture. In Sensory Properties of Foods. Eds G G Birch , J G Brennan and K J Parker, London, Applied Science, 277–45. AGUILERA J M
256
Texture in food
and WALDRON K W (1996) Physiology and Biochemistry of Plant Cell Walls. Topics in Plant Functional Biology: 1. Series Eds M Black and B Charlwood, London, Chapman and Hall. BRUMMEL D A and HARPSTER M H (2001) Cell wall metabolism in fruit softening and quality and its manipulation in transgenic plants, Plant Mol Biol, 47, 311–40. BURTON, W G (1981) Post-harvest Physiology of Food Crops. London, Longman. CIVILLE G V and SZCZESNIAK A S (1973) Guidelines to training a texture profile panel, J Text Stud, 4, 204–23. DE BELIE N, LAUSTEN A M, MARTENS M, BRO R and DE BAERDEMAEKER J (2002) Use of physicochemical methods for assessment of sensory changes in carrot texture and sweetness during cooking, J Text Stud, 33, 367–88. FEMENIA A, WALDRON K W, ROBERTSON J A and SELVENDRAN R R (1999a) Compositional and structural modification of the cell wall of cauliflower (Brassica oleracea L. var botrytis) during tissue development and plant maturation, Carb Polym, 39, 101–8. FEMENIA A, RIGBY N M, SELVENDRAN R R and WALDRON K W (1999b) Investigation of the occurrence of pectic-xylan-xyloglucan complexes in the cell walls of cauliflower stem tissues, Carb Polym, 39, 151–64. FILLION L and KILCAST D (2002) Consumer perception of crispness and crunchiness in fruits and vegetables, Food Qual Pref, 13, 23–9. GIBEAUT D M and CARPITA N C (1993) Structural models of primary cell walls: consistency of molecular structure with the physical properties of the walls during growth, Plant J, 3, 1–30. GREVE L C, SHACKEL K A, AHMADI H, MCARDLE R N, GOHLKE J R and LABAVITCH J M (1994) Impact of heating on carrot firmness: contribution of cellular turgor, J Agric Food Chem, 42, 2896–9. GUINARD J X and MAZZUCCHELLI R (1996) The sensory perception of texture and mouthfeel, Trends, Food Sci Technol, 7, 213–19. HARKER F R, REDGWELL R J, HALLETT I C and MURRAY S H (1997) Texture of fresh fruit, Horticultural Reviews, 20, 121–224. HARKER F R, MACDONALD J, MURRAY S H, GUNSON F A, HALLETT I C and WALKER S B (2002) Sensory interpretation of instrumental measurements 1: texture of apple fruit, Postharv Biol Technol, 24, 225–39. HILLER S and JERONIMIDIS G (1996) Fracture in potato tuber parenchyma, J Mater Sci, 31, 2779–96. JACKMAN R L and STANLEY D (1995) Perspectives in the textural evaluation of plant foods, Trends Food Sci Technol, 6,187–94. JAEGER S R, ANDANI Z, WAKELING I N and MACFIE H J H (1998) Consumer preferences for fresh and aged apples: a cross-cultural comparison, Food Qual Pref, 9, 355–66. JARVIS M C (1998) Intercellular separation forces generated by intracellular pressure, Pl Cell Env, 21, 1307–10. KEIJBETS M J H and PILNIK W (1974) β-elimination of pectin in the presence of anions and cations, Carb Res, 33, 359–62. KNOX J P (1992) Cell adhesion, cell separation and plant morphogenesis, Plant J, 2, 137– 41. KNOX J P, LINSTEAD P J, KING J, COOPER C and ROBERTS K (1990) Pectin esterification is spatially regulated both within cell-walls and between developing tissues of root apices, Planta, 181, 512–21. KOLLOFFEL C and LINSSEN P W T (1984) The formation of intercellular spaces in the cotyledons of developing and germinating pea-seeds, Protoplasma, 120, 12–19. KRALL S M and MCFEETERS R F (1998) Pectin hydrolysis: Effect of temperature, degree of methylation, pH, and calcium on hydrolysis rates, J Ag Food Chem, 46, 1311–15. KUHN B F and THYBO A K (2001) The influence of sensory and physiochemical quality on Danish children’s preference for apples, Food Qual Pref, 12, 543–50. BRETT C T
Plant structure and fruit and vegetable texture 257 LECAIN S, NG A, PARKER M L, SMITH A C
and WALDRON K W (1997) Modification of cell-wall polymers of onion waste – Part I. Effect of pressure-cooking, Carbohydr Pol, 38, 59– 67. LIN T- T and PITT R E (1986) Rheology of apple and potato tissue as affected by cell turgor pressure, J Text Stud, 17, 291–313. LINERS F and VAN CUTSEM P (1992) Distribution of pectic polysaccharides throughout walls of suspension-cultured carrot cells – an immunocytochemical study, Protoplasma 170, 10–21. LIU K (1995) Cellular, biological and physicochemical basis for the hard-to-cook defect in legume seeds, Crit Rev Food Sci Nut, 35, 263–98. LOH J and BREENE W M (1981) Thermal fracturability loss of edible plant tissue: pattern and within-species variation, J Text Stud, 12, 457–71. MARTIN-CABREJAS M A, WALDRON K W, SELVENDRAN R R, PARKER M L and MOATES G K (1994) Ripening-related changes in the cell walls of Spanish pear (Pyrus communis), Physiol Plant, 91, 671–9. MATTSON S, AKERBERG I, ERIKSSON E, KOUTLER-ANDERSSON E and VAHTRAS K (1950) Factors determining the composition and cookability of peas, Acta Agric Scand, 1, 41–49. NEUKOM H and DEUEL H (1958) Alkaline degradation of pectin, Chem and Ind, 683. NG A and WALDRON K W (1997a) Effect of cooking and pre-cooking on cell-wall chemistry in relation to firmness of carrot tissues, J Sci Food Agric, 73, 503–12. NG A and WALDRON K W (1997b) Effect of steaming on cell wall chemistry of potatoes (Solanum tuberosum cv. Bintje) in relation to firmness, J Agric Food Chem, 45, 3411– 18. NG A, HARVEY A J, PARKER M L, SMITH A C and WALDRON K W (1998) Effect of oxidative coupling on the thermal stability of texture and cell wall chemistry of beet root (Beta vulgaris), J Agric Food Chem, 46, 3365–70. PARKER M L and WALDRON K W (1995) Texture of Chinese water chestnut – involvement of cell-wall phenolics, J Sci Food Agric, 68, 337–46. PARKER M L, NG A, SMITH A C and WALDRON K W (2000) Esterified phenolics of the cell walls of chufa (Cyperus esculentus), J Agric Food Chem, 48, 6284–91. PARKER C C, PARKER M L, SMITH A C and WALDRON K W (2001) Pectin distribution at the surface of potato parenchyma cells in relation to cell-cell adhesion, J Ag Food Chem, 49, 4364–71. PARKER C C, PARKER M L, SMITH A C and WALDRON K W (2003) The role of wall-bound phenolic components on the texture of chinese water chestnut, J Ag Food Chem, 51, 2034–9. PARR A J, NG A and WALDRON K W (1997) Ester-linked phenolic components of carrot cell walls, J Agric Food Chem, 45, 2468–71. PELEG M (1983) The semantics of rheology and texture, Food Technol, 37, 54–61. REDGWELL R J, FISCHER A, KENDALL E and MACRAE A (1997) Galactose loss and fruit ripening: high molecular weight arabinogalactans in the pectic polysaccharides of fruit cell walls, Planta, 203, 174–81. RODRIGUEZ-ARCOS R C, SMITH A C and WALDRON K W (2002) Effect of storage on wall-bound phenolics in green asparagus, J Ag Food Chem, 50, 3197–203. ROUDAUT G, DACREMONT C, PAMIES B V, COLAS B and LE MESTE M (2002) Crispness: a critical review on sensory and material science aproaches, Trends Food Sci Technol, 13, 217–27. ROY S, VIAN B and ROLAND J C (1992) Immunocytochemical study of the deesterification patterns during cell-wall autolysis in the ripening of cherry tomato, Plant Physiol Biochem, 30, 139–46. SAJJAANANTAKUL T, VAN BUREN J P and DOWNING D L (1989) Effect of methyl ester content on heat degradation of chelator-soluble carrot pectin, J Food Sci, 54(5), 1272–7. SMITH A C, WALDRON K W, MANESS N and PERKINS-VEAZIE P (2002) Vegetable texture: measurement and structural implications. In Postharvest Physiology and Pathology of Vegetables. Eds J A Bartz and J K Brecht, New York, Marcel Dekker Inc., 297–329.
258
Texture in food
(1963) Classification of textural characteristics, J Food Sci, 28, 385–9. (1987) Correlating sensory with instrumental texture measurements – an overview of recent developments, J Text Stud, 18, 1–5. SZCZESNIAK A S (1988) The meaning of textural characteristics – crispness, J Text Stud, 19, 51–9. SZCZESNIAK A S and ILKER R (1988) The meaning of textural characteristics – juiciness in plant foodstuffs, J Text Stud, 19, 61–78. SZCZESNIAK A S (1990) Psychorheology and texture as factors controlling the consumer acceptance of food, Cereal Foods World, 351, 1201–5. TIJSKENS L M M, WALDRON K W, NG A, INGHAM L and VANDIJK C (1997a) The kinetics of pectin methyl esterase in potatoes and carrots during blanching, J Food Eng, 34, 371–85. TIJSKENS L M M, RODIS P S, HERTOG M L A T, WALDRON K W, INGHAM L, PROXENIA N and VANDIJK C (1997b) Activity of peroxidase during blanching of peaches, carrots and potatoes, J Food Eng, 34, 355–70. TUCKER G (2003) Ripe for a change, Biologist, 50, 34–8. VAN BUREN J P (1979) The chemistry of texture in fruits and vegetables, J Text Stud, 10, 1– 23. VAN BUREN J P and PITIFER L A (1992) Retarding vegetable softening by cold alkaline pectin deesterification before cooking, J Food Sci, 57, 1022–3. VICKERS Z M (1985) The relationships of pitch, loudness and eating technique to judgments of the crispness and crunchiness of food sounds, J Text Stud, 16, 85–95. VICKERS Z M (1988) Evaluation of crispness. In Food Structure: its Creation and Evaluation. Eds J M V Blanshard and J R Mitchell, London, Butterworths, 433–48. VICKERS Z M and BOURNE M C (1976) A psychoacoustical theory of crispness, J Food Sci, 41, 1158–64. VINCENT J E V (1998) The quantification of crispness, J Sci Food Agric, 78, 162–8. WALDRON K W and SELVENDRAN R R (1990) Effect of maturation and storage on asparagus (Aspargus officinalis) cell-wall composition, Physiol Plant, 80, 576–83 WALDRON K W and SELVENDRAN R R (1992) Cell wall changes in immature asparagus stem tissue after excision, Phytochem, 31, 1931–40. WALDRON K W, SMITH A C, PARR A J, NG A and PARKER M L (1997a) New approaches to understanding and controlling cell separation in relation to fruit and vegetable texture, Trends Food Sci Technol, 8, 213–21. WALDRON K W, NG A, PARKER M L and PARR A J (1997b) Ferulic acid dehydrodimers in the cell walls of Beta vulgaris and their possible role in texture, J Sci Food Agric, 74, 221–8. WARREN D S and WOODMAN J S (1974) The texture of cooked potatoes: a review, J Sci Food Agric, 25, 129–38. WILLATS W G T, ORFILA C, LIMBERG BUCHJOLT H C, VAN ALEBEEK, G-J W M, VARAGEN A G J, MARCUS S E, CHRISTENSEN, T M I E, MIKKELSEN, J D, MURRAY B S and KNOX J P (2001) Modulation of the degree and pattern of methyl-esterification of pectic homogalacturonan in plant cell walls, J Biol Chem, 276, 19404–13. SZCZESNIAK A S SZCZESNIAK A S
11 Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear T. Kojima, S. Fujita and M. Tanaka, Saga University, Japan and P. Sirisomboon,* King Mongkut’s Institute of Technology Ladkrabang, Thailand
11.1 Introduction: variations in pear texture Pears have particularly interesting texture properties which are intermediate between those of apples and potatoes (Baritelle et al., 2000). Pear varieties which are well known for their different texture are European pears and Asian pears (sometimes known as apple pears, Japanese pears, Chinese pears, or Oriental pears). European pears such as Bartlett and Comice become soft when ripe while Asian pears such as Chojuro (Choujuurou), Twentieth Century (Nijisseiki), Ya Li, and Tsu Li are firm, sweet, and juicy, and more easily bruised than European pears (Chen et al., 1987). European pears mostly have a bell shape. They improve in both texture and flavor after being picked. The fruit of the Japanese pear has a sandy texture and a round shape. The Chinese pears Ya Li and Tsu Li have an obovate shape. Japanese pears can be eaten just after harvest because they ripen on the tree and not during postharvest storage (Yamaki et al., 1979a cited in Tanaka and Kojima, 1996). 11.1.1 European pear texture Ben-Arie et al. (1979a) reported the change in firmness in pear (Pyrus Communis L. cv. Spadona) during ripening on and off the tree. The softening of the harvested fruit was slightly delayed compared to that of fruit which was allowed to ripen on the tree. In both cases, however, the change in firmness was roughly steady state. Fruit kept for about a week at 20 °C showed a marked acceleration in softening. The firmness of Spadona pears declined gradually in cold storage at a fairly constant rate throughout a 25 week period. The subsequent decline in fruit firmness during one week ripening at 20 °C following cold storage was very rapid compared to that of
260
Texture in food
fruit ripened at 20 °C directly after harvest, even though little change in firmness had occurred during cold storage. Ma and Chen (2003) found that, for long-term storage, pear Pyrus communis L. (Doyenne du Comice) stored in air developed both flesh breakdown and senescent scald disorders after four months storage, and those disorders were increased after five and six months storage. Controlled atmosphere (CA) stored fruit were free from scald regardless of CA regime and storage time but developed internal browning after four months of storage which increased after five and six months of CA storage. Fruit stored in different CA conditions showed different disorders. Change in ethylene production and flesh firmness during post-storage ripening at 20 °C was found to be the best objective measurement of storage life of Doyenne du Comice fruit. Fruit stored in refrigerated air for 1–3 months exhibited typical climacteric-like patterns of ethylene production during 15 days at 20 °C and softened to proper ripeness with desirable eating quality on day 5 at 20 °C. When the fruit was initially transferred to a temperature of 20 °C, the magnitude of ethylene production increased with storage time. Fruit stored in air for four months or longer did not exhibit climacteric-like patterns of ethylene production during ripening and nor did it soften improperly with a coarse and dry texture. Fruit stored in short-term CA storage followed by holding in air at –1 °C for one, two, and three months were capable of ripening normally with desirable dessert quality without developing any physical disorders. The differences in mechanical property measurements between quasistatic (slow) and dynamic (fast) loading rates in pear tissue were studied by Fridley and Adrian (1966) (Baritelle et al., 2000). They stated that pears could withstand more compressive force before tissue damage occurs than other commodities such as apples, peaches or apricots. Baritelle and Hyde (2000) investigated the effect of strain rate and size on mechanical tissue failure properties of D’ Anjou and Bosc pear under dynamic axial compression testing. Their results indicated that the more rapidly the Bosc (not D’ Anjou) tissue sample was deformed (higher strain rate) the tougher the tissue. This tends to agree with Dal Fabbro et al. (1980). The shock wave propagation speed was not affected by fruit size and did not vary with strain rate, as long as strain rate was sufficient to cause impulse loading. This finding is important in developing non-destructive testing procedures. The larger size fruit had higher failure stress and higher failure strain resulting in a greater tissue toughness and secant elastic modulus. Shock wave speed was determined from differences in the force profiles at each end of the sample during compression. The secant elastic modulus is failure stress divided by failure strain. Tissue toughness is the area under the stress–strain profile. The important finding of this experiment concerns the locus of failure points as strain rate increases. Generally as the strain rate increases the failure stress also increases while the failure strain remains nearly the same. Thus the toughness and stiffness (secant elastic modulus) both increase with increasing strain rate. At increasing strain rates, the failure stress increases
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 261
and there is a small decrease in the failure strain. These in turn influence the calculated parameters of stiffness and tissue toughness. Baritelle et al. (2000) investigated the tissue failure properties of Bartlett and D’Anjou pears. The D’Anjou cultivar had higher failure stresses and failure strains and thus greater tissue toughness, while the Bartlett cultivar consistently had higher secant moduli. To counter the effect of hydration and ripeness when testing the dynamic (impact) mechanical properties of climacteric fruit, Baritelle et al. (2001) reported the result of using 1-MCP (1-methylcyclopropene) to inhibit the ripening process and reduce the influence of ripening in such testing. In the experiment the samples used were apples and Bartlett and D’Anjou pears. The results showed that treating climateric fruits with 1-MCP slowed the maturation process but did not completely inhibit changes in tissue failure properties. The effects of dehydration could have compounded this. The importance of accounting for ripening can easily be seen in the pears compared to apples from the large and significant differences found in all failure parameters. From Oron et al. (2002), Spadona pear firmness seemed not to change due to water salinity and irrigation technology (irrigation with tap water, irrigation with saline water with surface drip irrigation and subsurface drip irrigation). 11.1.2 Japanese pear texture The effect of harvesting dates, storage time and handling on susceptibility to mechanical injury or pear texture has been studied on several cultivars of Japanese pears. Tsukamoto (1981) reported that the Kikusui was more sensitive to bruising than the Choujuurou and that the flesh tissues under the skin of the Japanese pear were very sensitive to bruising by both impact and compression. Chen et al. (1987) studied impact and compression damage to Asian pears. The flesh firmness, measured with a U.C. fruit firmness tester, of Choujuurou was the highest, followed by those of Ya Li, Tsu Li, and Twentieth Century. Results of impact tests using the impact tester developed by Chen et al. (1985) and compression tests using an Instron universal testing machine also indicated that Choujuurou pears are the firmest and most resistant to mechanical damage. Twentieth Century pears are most sensitive to impact and compression bruising. At the time of harvest, Tsu Li and Ya Li pears could resist mechanical damage nearly as well as Choujuurou pears, but they become more susceptible to bruising in cold storage. Increased time in the ripening room (20 °C) produced more softening and increased bruise resistance in Choujuurou and Twentieth Century pears than in Tsu Li and Ya Li. The firmness of those fruits tended to decrease as the time in cold storage increased. In Choujuurou, Tsu Li and Ya Li firmness tended to decrease at about the same rate, whereas that of Tsu Li decreased faster. Kawano et al. (1984) kept single Nijisseiki pears in polyethylene bags (3µ-thickness), packed in polystyrene pack (PSP), and then in a three-layer corrugated cardboard box. The box was delivered by mail truck from an orchard in Tottori prefecture to the research station and kept in a refrigerator
262
Texture in food
at 0 °C. Within 10 days after harvest, the pears were subject to experiment as non-stored fruits. Another set of fruit was kept until 3–4 months before experiment as stored fruits. The conclusions were that the delayed harvest pears were softer and more prone to permanent deformation than the early harvest ones. This was confirmed by the G factor obtained from the impact compression test. The G factor is the limit or critical acceleration at which fruit drop does not result in bruising. When the G factor was small the fruit was easily damaged. The delayed harvest pears, both stored and non-stored, had a smaller G factor than the early harvest ones. The bioyield point of the delayed harvest pears when 112–152 N was applied was less than that of the early harvest. However, Kawano et al. (1984) pointed out that the results could not be used to reach any firm conclusions for stored fruit. The Takayuki Kojima research group at Saga University, Japan, carried out intensive analysis of the texture of Japanese pear (Sirisomboon et al., 2000a). The conclusions from their study (Pyrus serotina Rehder var culta Housui) were as follows. Using the plate compression test the only interpretable indices for the Japanese pear were the deformation ratio, modulus of elasticity and relaxation. However, using the puncture test the interpretable textural indices were the rupture force, deformation at the rupture point, toughness, average firmness, initial firmness, apparent modulus of elasticity, bioyield force, penetrating force and penetrating energy into the flesh. They indicated that the skin of the Japanese pear contributed 70–80% of the firmness of the fruit and, as the fruits enlarged, the strain decreased and the elasticity increased, the fruit skin was more prone to mechanical damage, the fruit flesh became softer, and the firmness and rigidity of the whole fruit was reduced. The effect of vibration and storage temperatures on quality, including hardness via puncture testing of Japanese pears, was also studied (Liu et al., 1998). The vibration test in the laboratory was carried out under conditions identical to those in highway trucks equipped with refrigeration units which commute between Saga and Osaka, and the fruits storage test was at 0 °C, 10 °C and 90% relative humidity. The hardness along with acid and Brix decreased with increased storage temperature (0, 5, 10 and 15 °C) and storage period (one day and three days). Under this condition weight loss was found to increase and peel color became darker. All of these properties were changed both during storage and by vibration. Near infrared spectroscopy provides a non-destructive method of distinguishing difference in storage period for Japanese pears and whether the fruits were subjected to vibration.
11.2 Measuring and modelling fruit firmness 11.2.1 The development of firmness testers for pear The technique of using a small spherical impactor for testing the response of fruits to impact was described for the first time by Chen et al. 1985 (cited in Chen et al., 1996). Chen et al. (1996) determined the effect of impacting
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 263
mass on firmness sensing of fruits both theoretically and experimentally. They pointed out that the desirable features associated with low impacting mass were: increases strength of the measured acceleration signal, thereby facilitating easier detection and maximizing signal-to-noise ratio; increases both the magnitude of the calculated firmness index, A/t, and the rate of change of A/t with respect to the fruit firmness, E; minimizes the error due to movement of the fruit during the impact; and minimizes fruit damage caused by the impact (A is the peak acceleration of the impactor, t is the time required to reach peak force, E is firmness). The development of firmness testers for pears was continued at the University of California at Davis supported by the California Pear Advisory Board and California Canners during 1989–1992 by Delwiche and Sarig in 1989 and by Delwiche et al. in 1990–1992 and during 1998–2000 by Chen et al. The Delwiche model is a probe-type sensor developed to measure the impact response of fruit conveyed on a packing line and to predict firmness. The prototype was tested on Bartlett pears (Delwiche et al., 1996). The Chen models (Chen and Thompson, 1999 and 2000) were the handheld tester (Fig. 11.1a) and the same tester installed as a real-time on-line sorter (Fig 11.1b). The hand-held tester could be used for both on-tree fruit and picked fruit. It was influenced by turgidity of the fruit which is in turn affected by tree moisture status. High turgor results in a high modulus of elasticity of the fruit (the fruit tissue deforms less to a given pressure), and the hand-held unit is very sensitive to change of elastic modulus. The handheld firmness reading should be done during consistent field conditions, i.e. under fairly consistent tree water status conditions for example, in the morning at about the same temperature from day-to-day and readings should not be taken during irrigation periods or when the trees are under moisture stress. The on-line sorter was effective in segregating pears into three distinct firmness categories. The unit operated at speeds of six fruits per second and was nondestructive. The prototype impact system for firmness sorting was modified and installed in an experimental fruit packing line in Spain (García-Ramos et al., 2003). The online sensor is being incorporated into a commercial sorting line in Japan. Based on the same acoustic impulse response method the De Baerdemaeker research group at Katholieke Universiteit te Leuven, Belgium evaluated the method in order to measure the firmness changes of Pyrus communis var. Conference and Doyenné du Comice pears on-tree during two successive years 1995–1996 (De Belie et al., 2000). They indicated that the method appeared to be a valuable means to monitor the firmness evolution of pears on-tree in a non-destructive manner and to determine the optimum harvest date. In both years, the firmness showed a sudden reduction between three weeks and one week before harvest to about 23 kHz2 g2/3 for Conference and on average 31.5 kHz 2 g 2/3 for Doyenné. The optimum harvest date, corresponding to firmness of about 20–21 kHz2 g2/3 for Conference and 26–27 kHz2 g2/3 for Doyenné, occurred within about two weeks from the
264
Texture in food
(a)
(b) Fig. 11.1 (a) Experimental hand-held pear firmness tester (from Chen and Thompson 2000); (b) on-line sorting system with dual impact sensors (from Chen and Thompson 1999).
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 265
measured sudden drop in firmness which indicated that the fruit was softening ready to eat. Continuation of the firmness measurements after this point and the construction of the first-order degradation model, S = S 0 e – α t s , allowed the optimum harvest date to be more accurately predicted. S is the stiffness factor at time ts in kHz2 g2/3, S0 is the stiffness factor at the initial time 0 in kHz2 g2/3, α is the temperature-dependent deterioration constant in day–1 and ts is the storage time in days. The correlation between the destructive firmness (maximum force at compression to 8 mm deformation at 50 mm/min of 8mm diameter metal cylinder) and the non-destructive firmness (stiffness factor) was high for Doyenné (correlation coefficient = 0.82) and fair for Conference (correlation coeff icient = 0.59). None of the measured meteorological parameters (temperature and rainfall) consistently provided a significant improvement in the predictive firmness model. Based on the impact technique used for the development of a portable instrument to monitor the firmness of melons, the pear firmness tester (Fig. 11.2) was modified by Sugiyama (2001). The experiment was done on La France and Le Lectier pears. Using the firmness tester the ripeness of the pears was evaluated using transmission velocity rather than resonance frequency, in order to compensate for variations in the size of samples. The maximum peak in the impact waveform required to calculate the transmission velocity was also easily detected. The ability to measure firmness was implied by the correlation between the transmission velocity and the apparent elasticity measured by the compression test using the universal testing machine. The firmness tester showed its ability to measure the La France pear firmness better than the Le Lectier pear. Sugiyama (2001) indicated that the result might be due to unequal distribution firmness of Le Lectier; several of the panelists also said that the firmness of Le Lectier was different even within one sample and further investigation was necessary. Sugiyama (2001) concluded, based on the daily change of transmission velocity at different pear storage temperatures and the different score in sensory evaluation, that the firmness tester was able to monitor physiological changes in ripening pears.
Fig. 11.2 Portable firmness tester for pears.
266
Texture in food
Bertelsen (2001) reported the development of an acoustic firmness sensor by the grading company Aweta. The firmness value is weight-specific and the fruit is weighed simultaneously with the sound recording. The University of Ghent has developed the mathematics behind the sound-to-firmness conversion. The Research Center Aarslev in Denmark have tested the sensor for a number of apple varieties and for Clar Frijs pear. They found no correlation between the sensor firmness value and fruit firmness measured on the peeled fruit using a penetrometer. Despite the lack of correlation, the newest version of the sensor program included a conversion feature between the sensor and the penetrometer values. Fruit size appeared to affect the firmness value with small fruits exhibiting lower values than the large fruits.
11.2.2 The sensitivity of texture measurement methods and instruments Garcia et al. (1995) reported that Blanquilla pears with higher turgidity had low values of deformation at skin puncture (DSP) compared with those of lower turgidity. The more turgid fruits showed high values of bruise volume because the stresses in the tissue might be higher. Turgid fruits exhibited different impact response compared to less turgid fruits when measured by the impact tester developed by Garcia et al., 1988 (cited from Garcia et al., 1995). For a given impact energy, impact forces were higher and deformations lower in turgid fruits. Stresses in tissue would therefore be higher, while Magness-Taylor firmness, related to tissue strength, did not change greatly between the two groups of fruit. This indicated that the Magness-Taylor sensitivity is not enough for measuring the effect due to the turgidity. Chen and Thompson (2000) reported that penetrometer readings did not differ significantly with the time of day of measuring (morning and afternoon). Time of the day influenced the turgor of fruit. They found that the penetrometer was sensitive to the ultimate strength of pear tissue but that the results were not much influenced by its elastic modulus. High turgor results in a high modulus of elasticity of the fruit and the hand-held tester they developed is very sensitive to change in elastic modulus. However, there appears to be a correlation between elastic modulus and ultimate strength of the pear tissue. Figure 11.3 shows the result of sorting by an on-line sorting system, compared with fruit firmness measured by hand held-firmness tester and by penetrometer. It is interesting to note that there are similarities between Magness-Taylor firmness and failure stress measurements using dynamic axial compression (between pear cultivars D’Anjou and Bosc), with the higher firmness values having the higher failure stress (Baritelle and Hyde, 2000). Dynamic axial compression testing showed highly significant differences between varieties for failure stress, failure strain, secant elastic modulus, and tissue toughness. Pears with higher Magness-Taylor firmness generally had higher failure stress. The Takayuki Kojima research group at Saga University, Japan reported that the puncture test was superior to the plate compression test in analyzing
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 267 On-line sorting, 40 fruits 170
Hand-held impact reading
160 150 140 130 120 110 100 90 0
1
2 Sorted group
3
(a) On-line sorting, 40 fruits
20
Ave. penetrometer reading, Ibs
18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0
1
2 Sorted group
3
(b)
Fig. 11.3 The result of sorting made with on-line sorting system, compared with fruit firmness measured (a) by handheld firmness tester and (b) by penetrometer (from Chen and Thompson, 2000).
the textural properties of the Japanese pear fruits with regard to changes in the pectin constituents. Their study (Sirisomboon et al., 2000b) showed that most of the correlation coefficient values between the textural properties from the puncture test and pectin constituents, alcohol insoluble solids and soluble solids were significant and were higher values than those obtained from the plate compression test. Hence, the puncture test would provide a better relationship between texture and pectin constituents of the Japanese pear fruit than the plate compression test.
268
Texture in food
11.2.3 The texture model of pear Kawano et al. (1984) proposed using Hertz’s theory of elasticity to analyze impact acceleration using the dynamic modulus of elasticity obtained from impact compression testing more accurately than it is possible to obtain the static modulus of elasticity from quasi-static compression testing. The linear regression model of bruise volume (BV, mm3) with the same impact energy related to Magness-Taylor firmness (F, N) and turgidity in terms of deformation at skin puncture (DSP, mm) for Blanquilla pears (García et al., 1995) was BV = 107.6–0.51 F-32.6 DSP
r2 = 0.39 (n = 720)
To develop the above model, BV was calculated from depth (h) and width of bruise (D) using the equation of Chen and Sun (García et al., 1995 cited from Chen and Sun, 1981) BV =
π hD 2 6
These two models have been analyzed and show that the parameter DSP explains 31% of the total variation in Blanquilla pears. Adding the MagnessTaylor firmness, the models can explain 39 % of the total variation. The results showed that Magness-Taylor firmness was related to bruise susceptibility, although not to the same extent as turgidity. When testing fruit with similar turgidity (for instance, at harvest), firmer fruit were shown to be less susceptible to bruising. The relationship between firmness and bruise susceptibility was closer in pears than in apples, since the ripening rate was faster in pears and the ranges of firmness values wider. The parameter firmness and turgidity exhibited no relationship between each other and influenced bruising independently. According to the models, bruise susceptibility was affected by fruit turgidity and firmness changes during ripening: bruise damage would increase with decreasing firmness, depending on which is the main factor in the ripening process. At Katholieke Universiteit te Lueven, Belgium the Josse De Baerdemaeker research group have carried out intensive work on numerical simulations to facilitate accurate firmness measurement of fruit and vegetables by the nondestructive acoustic impulse response method. They stated that the finite element method coupled with computer vision is well suited for analysis to gain insight into the mechanical vibration of fruit of different shapes (Jancsók et al., 2001). Dewulf et al. (1998) mentioned that the technique could be used to monitor the change of Conference pear fruit quality with time and to evaluate different storage methods. The dynamic characteristics of a Conference pear due to changes in material characteristics was investigated by Dewulf et al. (1999) using finite element simulations to determine the firmness of Conference pears by using the mechanical response technique. Using an image processing technique they obtained the geometrical model of a Conference pear. The dynamic behavior
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 269
of the pear and the correlation of its behavior with material characteristics were investigated by using a numerical modal analysis. They found that the oblate-prolate mode is the most sensitive with respect to the material characteristics of the calyx end of the pear and also that the influence of the material characteristics of the stem end of the pear on the eigen-frequency of this mode is small. The first two bending modes are the most sensitive eigenmodes with respect to the material characteristics of the stem end of the pear. Therefore they concluded that the texture quality of the calyx end and the stem end of a Conference pear could be determined separately. The Young’s modulus of the spherical calyx end of the pear could be determined from the oblate-prolate modes and that of the stem end from the first bending modes. A finite element analysis using a conical model for the stem end of the pear indicated that a similar formula for the firmness of the stem end of pear can be derived. The influence of the shape of Conference pears on acoustic response was investigated using finite element modeling by Jancsók et al. (2001). The effect of the easy to measure but imprecise length/diameter (L/D) ratio on the resonant frequencies was related linearly with the normalized frequencies in the first bending, compression and first torsion modes but not in the oblate-prolate mode. This was due to the oblate-prolate mode shape where the bottom part is deformed and nearly spherical and does not vary to a large extent. The first six more accurate Fourier descriptors, where the different pear shapes have their effect, were calculated and correlated with the raw frequencies. It is obvious that the third normalized descriptor correlates well with the modes with lower frequencies (bending, torsion, compression) but that the correlation is low for high-frequency modes (oblate-prolate). To estimate the Young’s modulus, the more accurate Fourier descriptors resulted in a more accurate estimation. When the stiffness factor ( f 2m 2/3 ) for oblateprolate mode is used to estimate the material properties then the error is small. They concluded that the simulated measurement carried out indicated that the Young’s modulus values or the stiffness factor could possibly be estimated based on the resonant frequency measurement, but that great care must be taken to identify the mode shape associated with the resonance frequency. The anisotropic relaxation properties of Dangshan pears were determined based on the relaxation model by Wang (2003). The three-element relaxation model was expressed as σ(t) = ε0E0 + ε0E1e–t/T where σ is the stress of the pear specimen under load in MPa; t is time of conducted experiment under load in s; ε0 is the constant strain, dimensionless; E0 is the equilibrium modulus in MPa; E1 is the decay modulus in MPa; T is the time of relaxation and T = η/E1 in s; η is the specific viscosity in MPa s. The three elements included E0, E1, and η. The results indicated that the decay modulus, the equilibrium modulus, time of relaxation, and specific
270
Texture in food
viscosity were significantly influenced by specimen orientation, latitude, and depth. The longitude of the specimen and initial deformation were not significant.
11.3 Chemical compounds affecting firmness: the example of Japanese pear The edible tissue of fleshy fruit is usually composed of parenchymatous cells which contain water and accumulate organic substances such as sugar and organic acids, have large air spaces between them, and are frequently of very large size (Rhodes, 1980). Fruits contain a very high percentage of their fresh weight as water (Tucker, 1993). In addition to the large parenchymatous cells, the flesh of many fruits contains stone cells, which may play a role in the texture of the ripe fruit and which contribute to the flesh of some fruits. This is because they frequently contain tannin-like compounds, leucoanthocyanins, which are responsible for the astringency of these fruits. Japanese pears have a water content of around 90%. The fruit of Japanese pear contains four constituent sugars; namely sucrose, glucose, fructose, and sorbitol (Tanaka and Kojima, 1996 cited from Yamaki et al., 1979a). Yamaki et al. (1979a) stated that, as the fruit ripens, the total sugar concentration increases gradually, but changes in the concentration of each sugar do not occur at the same time. In the Japanese pear, photosynthesis products translocate to fruits as sorbitol, and young fruits store sorbitol during the cellular division stage. At this stage sorbitol concentration was the highest and the sucrose concentration was the lowest. After a cell thickening stage, sorbitol is metabolized vigorously to fructose and glucose, which are stored as starch. In the ripening stage, a climacteric rise occurs, starch decreases, and sucrose increases. Fructose attained the highest concentration, followed by sorbitol, sucrose and glucose. Thus the changes in concentration of each sugar for the Japanese pear during growing season can indicate the growth phase and the degree of ripeness (Tanaka and Kojima, 1996). Generally, Japanese pear inner quality is determined by sweetness (not organic acid), and the quality of the texture. Destructively, sugar content of fruit can be measured directly via HPLC (high performance liquid chromatography) analysis for sucrose, fructose and glucose (Bartolomé et al., 1996). However, since sugars are usually the major component of soluble solids, it is much easier to simply measure soluble solids in extracted juice with a refractometer (Peiris et al., 1998 cited from Wills et al., 1989). Near infrared spectroscopy can be used effectively to measure soluble solids for fruit and vegetables (Kawano et al., 1992, 1993; Kojima et al., 1994; Slaughter et al., 1996; Peiris et al., 1998; Schmilovitch et al., 1999; Slaughter et al., 1999; Lu et al., 2000; Lu, 2001; Sirinnapa et al., 2001; Park et al., 2002). Kojima et al. (1994) reported that the Brix values of the Japanese pear Kosui and Housui could be measured at six wavelengths of 1508, 1668, 1932, 2132, 2212 and 2400 nm. The log
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 271
(1/R∞) values or the absorption coefficients at wavelengths of 620 nm may be used to predict the sugar content of the skin-flesh specimens of Japanese pear Nijisseiki (Budiastra et al., 1998).
11.3.1 Cell wall At cell wall, carbohydrate polymers of fruit make up 90–95% of the structural components of the wall, the remaining 5–10% being glycoprotein (Tucker and Grierson, 1987). The carbohydrate polymers or polysaccharides can be grouped together as cellulose, hemicelluloses and pectins. Fruit cell walls contain relatively more pectin material and less hemicellulose than other plant cell walls glycoprotein (Tucker and Grierson, 1987). Pectic substances are the major component of the middle lamella and of the primary cell walls of fruit tissues (Knee and Bartley, 1981; Batisse et al., 1994 cited from Voragen et al., 1983). Pectin is a linear polymer with many α-1,4-linked Dgalacturonic acid moieties, but it also contains neutral sugars such as Larabinose, D-galactose and L-rhamnose (Klavons et al., 1994). The carboxyl groups of the galacturonic acid are partly esterified with methanol and free groups are more or less neutralized. The monomer is thought to have C1 conformation. Yamaki et al. (1979b) investigated changes in polysaccharides and monosaccharide components in cell wall during cell division, cell enlargement and softening in Japanese pear (Pyrus serotina Rehder var. culta Rehder cv. Hosui) fruit. They reported as follows. The polysaccharides of Japanese pear were composed of glucose, uronic acid, xylose, arabinose, galactose, rhamnose, mannose and fucose. The total polysaccharide content of cell wall per cell (DNA content basis) remained constant during cell division but, during the pre-enlargement period, it began to increase rapidly in spite of the slightness of cell enlargement. Thereafter, during the enlargement period, the polysaccharides remained almost constant although the fruits enlarged dramatically, and the polysaccharides increased somewhat with ripening. The quality of the polysaccharides seemed to change actively at each stage, indicating that the extensive fruit enlargement did not require an increase in polysaccharide content, and was rather accompanied by the partial breakdown or partial interconversion of polysaccharide components already present. The loss of arabinose and galactose in acid-soluble hemicellulose was prominent in fruit softening occurring in the ripening stage. The cellulose component decreased with over-ripening. On the other hand, xylose and non-cellulosic glucose residues did not alter with ripening or over-ripening. Non-cellulosic glucose continued to accumulate during cell enlargement.
11.3.2 Pectins The chemical composition of pectins (i.e. degree of esterification, distribution of rhamnopyranoses and amount of specific neutral sugar) and the interrelation
272
Texture in food
with other cell wall polysaccharides, determine the firmness of the fresh and processed plant tissue (Boeriu et al., 1998). Change of pectin in degradation of cell wall was characterized by a decrease in the level of insoluble pectin with a concomitant increase in soluble pectin (Ben-Arie et al., 1979a). The degradation of pectin is catalyzed by two groups of enzymes, polygalacturonase (PG) and pectin methyl esterase (PE). The increase in PG activity was accompany by an increase in water-soluble pectin and fruit softening (Eskin, 1990 cited from Pressey et al.,1971). Two types of PG have been identified, endo and exo. The former randomly hydrolyzes the glycosidic bonds in the pectin molecule while the latter acts from the terminal end of the pectin molecule. In the presence of endo-PG the pectin molecules are rapidly degraded into smaller units accompanied by a marked decrease in viscosity. PE is involved in de-esterification of the cell wall galacturonans followed by PG action. The result of these enzyme activities is the release of soluble polyuronide with a corresponding decrease in the molecular weight of the polyuronide polymer (Gross and Wallner, 1979; Huber, 1983; Eskin, 1990 cited from Seymour et al., 1987).
11.3.3 Changes in cell wall structure Rhodes (1980), cited in much research, explained the cell wall structure change during fruit ripening as follows. Changes in cell wall structure in many fruits during ripening have been observed under electron microscope, including avocado (Pesis et al., 1978), pear (Ben-Arie et al., 1979b) and tomato (Crookes and Grierson, 1983). These changes usually consist of an apparent dissolution of the pectin-rich middle lamella region of the cell wall. At the biochemical level, major changes can be observed in the pectin polymers of the wall. There is a loss of neutral sugars during ripening; in most fruit, this is predominantly galactose, but some loss of arabinose also occurs (Tucker and Grierson, 1987). These two sugars are the major components of the wall’s neutral pectin. There are also major changes observed in the acidic pectin or rhamnogalacturonan fraction of the wall. During ripening, there is an increase in the solubility of these polyuronides and, in several cases, they have been shown to become progressively depolymerized. The degree of esterification of the polyuronide fraction can also change during ripening. It was indicated that an increased solubility of the cell wall polyuronides is the characteristic cell wall change occurring during softening in the whole range of ripening fruits (Shewfelt, 1965; Dolendo et al., 1966). It appears that levels of sugars commonly associated with either hemicellulose or cellulosic fractions remain constant throughout ripening. Fruit chemical compositions in cell wall structure change during ripening are reviewed in Table 11.1. Removal of calcium from junction zones between pectin molecules in the middle lamella is a possible mechanism of cell separation and fruit softening, but there is no direct evidence that it occurs (Knee, 1993).
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 273 Table 11.1 Change of fruit chemical composition in cell wall structure during ripening (Modified from Rhodes, 1980) Compositions Neutral pectin Acidic pectin (Rhamnogalacturonan)
Change Galactose Arabinose Polyuronides
Predominantly loss Some loss Increase in solubility, progressively depolymerized, change in esterification
Changes in the activities of some cell wall-degrading enzymes during development and ripening of Japanese pear fruit (Pyrus serotina Rehder var. culta Rehder cv. Hosui and 93-3) have been studied intensively by the Yamaki group (Yamaki and Matsuda, 1977; Yamaki et al., 1977; Yamaki and Kakiuchi, 1979). The following is the changing pattern of cell wall-degrading enzyme activities and pectin compound of Japanese pear during fruit development and ripening concluded from the studies of the Yamaki group. The activities per fresh weight of cell wall-degrading enzymes, i.e. endocellulase, PG, PE, and β-galactosidase during the cell division and preenlargement stages, were fairly high, decreased in the enlargement stage, and increased remarkably with ripening or over-ripening, except for PE. The endocellulase was present as an acid type and a neutral type. The former was more active than the latter in the cell division and pre-enlargement stages, but with ripening the reverse was found. On the other hand, the activities, on a DNA content basis (content in cell wall per cell), in all enzymes were roughly constant, not decreasing during the cell division, pre-enlargement and enlargement stages, but increasing extensively with ripening. That is, the lowering of these enzyme activities per gram fresh weight in the enlargement stage seemed not to be due to inactivation or stimulation of enzyme degeneration. The extensive enhancements of cell wall-degrading enzyme activities with ripening or over-ripening seem to be closely related to the softening or pithiness of the fruit. The Yamaki group concluded that in Japanese pear, PG and cellulase activities were mainly related to softening and βgalactosidase, and partial degrading of the hemicellulose component was related to flesh breakdown at over-ripening. In greater depth, Tateishi et al. (1996) investigated the cell wall-bound glycosidase (α-L-Arafase, α and β-galactosidase, β-glucosidase, α- and βmannosidase and α- and β-xylosidase) activities in pre-ripe and ripe fruit of Japanese pears (Pyrus serotina Rehder–var. culta. cv. Hosui). They indicated that α-L-Arafase played a role in fruit softening due to α-L-Arabinofuranosidase (EC.3.2.1.55) activity which increased dramatically (15-fold) with fruit ripening after the fruit enlargement stage, an effect which might be related to the loss of arabinose from cell wall fraction. In addition, they indicated that because the CDTA (tran-1, 2-cyclohexanediamine-N,N,N′,N′-tetra acetic acid) was the most effective in solubilization of α-L-Arafase, the enzyme might be solubilized in association with the pectic polysaccharides released by the
274
Texture in food
chelating reagent. In contrast, although galactose was also released from the cell wall, only a little change in the activity of β-galactosidase was observed between the pre-ripe and ripe stages. Kitagawa et al. (1995) (from Tateishi et al., 1996) reported that one of the isoforms of β-galactosidase played a role in the release of galactose from pectic polymers of Japanese pears. Total pectin (TP) content comprised 0.4–0.5% of the fresh weight (FW). Total pectin in FW did not change significantly during the cell division and pre-enlargement stages but decreased rapidly in the enlargement stage and then remained constant in the ripening stage. When expressed on DNA content basis, its value clearly increased in the pre-enlargement stage and ripening stage, with little change in the cell division stage and enlargement stage. Water-soluble pectin (WSP) increased parallel to the increase in total pectin with ripening. Hence the ratio of WSP to TP content was constant, which contrasted with the increased ratio in European pear (Barlette pear) with ripening (Yamaki and Matsuda, 1977 cited from Miura et al., 1963).
11.3.4 Alcohol insoluble solids and solubilization of pectin Pectin constituents in fruits and vegetables are extracted from alcohol insoluble solids (AIS). The AIS form the principal constituents of cell walls and may be partially associated with each other and with some phenolic compounds. They are composites of salts, proteins, starch and different non-starch polysaccharides such as pectin, hemicelluloses and cellulose (Reinders and Their, 1998). The changes in AIS and pectin constituents of the mature Japanese pear (Hosui) at different picking dates were intensively investigated by the Kojima research group at Saga University, Japan (Sirisomboon et al., 2000b). While fruit weight and average diameter increased over the harvest period, the alcohol insoluble solids on fresh weight basis (AIS in FW) decreased. Change in AIS in fruit appears to be related to the change in the rate of decline on a FW basis and the increasing weight of the fruit. The soluble solids (SS) in juice increased consistently during the fruit enlargement. While AIS in FW significantly decreased during fruit enlargement, WSP, OSP (oxalate soluble pectin), NSP (non-soluble pectin), and TP in AIS increased. The increasing rate of WSP was relatively high. There was no significant change in WSP in FW with picking dates, but the OSP, NSP, and TP in FW significantly decreased. There was an increase in the soluble pectin ratios (OSP/TP and WSP/TP) and a decrease in the non-soluble pectin ratio (NSP/ TP). These show the occurrence of the solubilization of pectin in the fruit. Ben-Arie et al (1979a) reported that fruit softening was accompanied by the solubilization of the insoluble pectic substances to a soluble pectic fraction. Though the solubilization occurred, the NSP in AIS gradually increased because of the increase of TP in AIS. Similar patterns of soluble pectin ratios (WSP/TP and OSP/TP) and non-soluble pectin ratio (NSP/TP) changes have been reported by Yamaki and Matsuda (1977). The correlations between AIS in FW and TP in FW were very high. Therefore, the decline in TP in FW
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 275
corresponded to the decline in AIS in FW. The decrease in AIS reflected in part the loss in the pectic substance (Ben-Arie et al., 1979a). Furthermore, the correlation between AIS in FW with WSP/TP was very high compared to that with OSP/TP, which indicated that the loss in pectic substances was predominantly due to the solubilization of NSP to WSP and partially due to that of NSP to OSP. This indicated that the binding force of OSP with fruit tissue may be stronger than WSP.
11.3.5 Oxalate soluble pectin In addition, the Takayuki Kojima research group also proposed a simplified method for determining the total OSP content of Japanese pear (Sirisomboon et al., 2001). The OSP is related to fruit firmness with respect to the chelation of calcium ions with carboxyl groups of adjacent polyuronide chains. However, an accurate total OSP content is not easy to attain. They proposed a simple method to define extraction time of total OSP in fruit without repetition based on half-extraction time which is the time when 50% of OSP was extracted. There were two stages of extraction – primary and secondary – and half-extraction was in the former. In the primary stage, different picking dates affected neither the extraction dates nor the ratio of unaccomplished extracted OSP content to total OSP content. However, in the secondary stage, different picking dates affected both (P < 0.01). The extraction time of total OSP could also be estimated. The method recommended that the extraction should be done until half-extraction time was reached and then the total OSP could be estimated by multiplying the pectin content at that time by two. Half-extraction time of Japanese pear was 1.5 hr. The Kojima research group also postulated that the method might prove useful for other fruit and vegetables as well.
11.4 The effect of constituents on fruit texture The development of fruit can be divided into cell division, pre-enlargement, enlargement and ripening stages. Yamaki et al. (1979b) described the importance of cell wall constituents during fruit growth as follows. Cell division in fruit generally continues only for a short period after fruit setting, and the fruit enlarges dramatically by expansion and elongation of cells until ripening. Ripening is the series of changes occurring during the early stages of the senescence of fruits in which the structure and composition of the unripe fruit is altered so that it becomes acceptable to eat (Rhodes, 1980). Ripening involves complex changes in the metabolism of the fruit in which both anabolic and catabolic processes take place. Some of the degradative processes involved in changes in adhesion between the cells lead to tissue softening. Tucker (1993) found that fruit softening arises from three mechanisms: loss of turgor, degradation of starch, or breakdown of the fruit cell walls.
276
Texture in food
Loss of turgor is largely a non-physiological process associated with the post-harvest dehydration of the fruit. Loss of water has only a minor effect on the fruit’s biochemistry, equivalent to about 5–10% of the fruit’s fresh weight. Degradation of starch probably results in a pronounced textural change, especially in fruit like banana, where starch accounts for a high percentage of fresh weight. In general, however, texture change during the ripening of most fruit is thought to be largely the result of cell wall degradation. The degradation of cell walls is exceedingly complex and is connected with some cell wall-degrading enzymes and, among these enzymes, pectin was one of the most strongly implicated in fruit softening (Yamaki and Kakiuchi, 1979). Pectin constituents, a complex of non-starch polysaccharides, in fruit and vegetables play an important role in harvest maturity and ripening and storage of fruit and vegetables which is related to the texture change in them (Shewfelt et al., 1971; Batisse et al., 1996; Taylor et al., 1995; Yu et al., 1996; Ketsa and Daengkanit, 1999).
11.4.1 Pear turgidity García et al. (1995) investigated the susceptibility to bruising of Blanquilla and Conference pears. They concluded that fruits at harvest were more susceptible to bruising than fruits after storage, due to a decrease in fruit turgidity; fruits picked early were less susceptible to bruising than those picked later, due to a decrease in fruit firmness; and fruit turgidity and firmness influenced bruise susceptibility independently although their effects combine during fruit ripening (see the texture model of pear in Section 11.2.3). The turgidity was explained in terms of the deformation at skin puncture (DSP). It was the parameter most related to weight loss, mainly due to water, and turgidity decrease was associated with water loss (García et al., 1995 citing from Strasburger et al., 1985). DSP appeared to be related to fruit turgidity. Turgid fruits exhibited different impact response compared to less turgid ones. Blanquilla pears with low values of DSP (turgid fruits) showed high values of bruise volume because the stresses in the tissue might be higher. Baritelle et al. (2000) reported that temperature and turgor effects were highly significant for failure stress, failure strain, secant elastic modulus, tissue toughness and shock wave speed; however, the cultivars responded in different and opposite ways. For Barlette pears, as temperature and turgor increased, the failure stress and strain decreased, while the opposite was true for the D’Anjou cultivar. The important finding of this work was that the small strain property, shock wave speed, decreased significantly with decreasing turgor.
11.4.2 Pectin constituents and related compounds The relationship between texture and pectin constituents and some related compounds of the Japanese pear (Pyrus serotina Rehder var. culta Housui)
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 277
during fruit enlargement and ripening was intensively analyzed by the Kojima research group at Saga university, Japan (Sirisomboon et al., 2000b). Among the studied constituents, the alcohol insoluble solids in fresh weight (AIS in FW) appeared to have a significant effect on the textural properties of the fruit. The textural properties, which correlated differently with the pectin content in AIS and with that in FW, indicated the different effects of the fruit cell wall and fruit flesh (including skin) on the texture of the fruit during fruit enlargement. This study showed for the first time evidence for the close relationship of the pectin constituents in determining the fruit texture of the Japanese pear. Three textural properties from the plate compression test – namely, the deformation ratio, modulus of elasticity, and relaxation – and nine from the puncture test – rupture force, deformation at the rupture point, toughness, average firmness, initial firmness, apparent modulus of elasticity, bioyield force, penetrating force in the flesh, and penetrating energy in the flesh of the Japanese pear – changed simultaneously with the average diameter and weight of the fruit and were affected by the pectin constituents, AIS and SS. Hardness and deformation of the fruit obtained from the plate compression test seemed to depend on the combination of the AIS in FW and the weight of the fruit. They found that the oxalate soluble pectin (OSP) seemed to play a more significant role in fruit texture than the water soluble pectin (WSP). The OSP both in AIS and in FW affected the fruit texture more than the WSP. Yu et al. (1996) reported that OSP affected strawberry firmness more than WSP, which might be because OSP exists as pectic acid which could bind calcium and form a cross-linked structure. Neal (1965) indicated that the chelation of calcium ions with carboxyl groups of adjacent polyuronide chains is a key factor for fruit firmness and Knee (1993) described how a major site of calcium deposition is in the junction zones in the middle lamella. However, the solubilization of the WSP appeared to influence the textural properties more than that of the OSP. To verify the effects of the pectin solubilization, the pectin ratio was determined. Due to the highest correlation coefficient (r) value among the pectin ratios, the WSP/TP ratio correlated best with deformation ratio, modulus of elasticity, relaxation value, and energy absorption and all the textural properties obtained from the puncture test (Sirisomboon et al., 2000b). These results confirmed the effect of the solubilization of NSP to WSP during cell wall degradation (Ben-Arie et al., 1979a) on the texture of fruit, whereas the solubilization of NSP to OSP had less effect on fruit texture than that of WSP. In the case of European pears, the relationship between flesh firmness and cell wall polysacharides of Marguerite Marillat and La France pears (Pyrus communis L.) after different storage periods was investigated by Murayama et al. (2002). In both cultivars fruit softened and reached a buttery and juicy texture after short-term storage (one month at 1 °C), while fruit softened but never reached that texture after long-term storage (4–5 months at 1°C). There was a cultivar difference in the relationship between flesh firmness and water-soluble polyuronide content. For La France, the lower the flesh
278
Texture in food
firmness, the higher the water-soluble content after short-term storage, while lower flesh firmness was correlated with lower water-soluble polyuronide content in fruit after long-term storage. The amount of water-soluble polyuronides in Marguerite Marillat varied conversely with decreasing flesh firmness for both types of storage, although water-soluble polyuronide levels of fruit after long-term storage tended to be lower than those of fruits after short-term storage when compared to fruit of similar flesh firmness. Murayama et al. (2002) indicated that the lower amount of water-soluble polyuronides seems to be related to the inferior texture of pear fruit after prolonged storage. The chelator-soluble polyuronide content was lower than water-soluble polyuronide and alkali-soluble polyuronide contents, independent of cultivar and storage period, and the amount was similar for both storage periods for both cultivars. Murayama et al. (2002) indicated that the chelatorsoluble polyuronide content seems not to be crucial in inducing dry texture. They found that the alkali-soluble polyuronide contents showed the highest correlation to flesh in both cultivars among cell wall polysaccharides. The lower the flesh firmness, the lower the alkali-soluble polyuronide contents independent of cultivar and storage period. With this result and the report of Murayama et al., 1998 (from Murayama et al., 2002) that the alkali-soluble polyuronide content decreased during softening of pears. Murayama et al., 2002 indicated that the amount of alkali-soluble polyuronides seems to be associated with the softening of pears. Fruit after short-term storage contained more alkali-soluble polyuronides than fruit after long-term storage in both cultivars, when compared with fruit having similar flesh firmness. Murayama et al. (2002) indicated that the extensive decomposition of alkali-soluble polyuronide occurred during storage at 1 °C in both cultivars and suggested that the alkali-soluble polyuronides were thought to metabolize and become water-soluble polyuronides during normal ripening of pears. However, water-soluble polyuronide levels after long-term storage also tend to be lower than those of fruit after short-term storage when compared with fruit having similar flesh firmness as mentioned above. Murayama et al. (2002) described that water-soluble polyuronides were further metabolized so that they were alcohol-soluble and lost from the alcohol-insoluble residue. Again the lower content of pectic polysaccharides after prolonged storage seems to be related to the inferior texture of fruit. In addition, Murayama et al. (2002) indicated that the differences in the amount of hemicellulosic polysaccharides between hard and soft fruit were slight and there was no negative correlation between flesh firmness and cellulose content, independent of cultivar and storage period. This leads to their conclusion that cellulose is not degraded during ripening of pears and that the amounts of hemicellulosic polysaccharides and cellulose seem not to be crucial in inducing inferior texture in pears.
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 279
11.5 Use of near infrared spectroscopy (NIR) to evaluate textural properties Near infrared (NIR) spectroscopy which can avoid the complexity of sensor contact and associated handling problems (Delwiche et al., 1996) has recently been studied as a means of evaluating the texture of intact apples by Cho et al., 1996, Onda et al., 1996, Sohn and Cho, 2000, Lu et al., 2000 and Park et al., 2002; plums by Onda et al., 1996; pear by Sirisomboon, 2001; sweet cherries by Lu, 2001. As described by Robert and Cadet (1998), the spectral information obtained in the NIR spectral region corresponds to the harmonics and combinations of the fundamental vibrations observed in the mid-infrared. These absorptions are of lower intensity and are less well-resolved, and they contain only part of the information content available in the mid-infrared region. The NIR spectra of carbohydrates can be split into two distinct and characteristic parts: the first part corresponds to the 1100–1800 nm wavelength region, and this is characteristic of the first and second harmonics of the OH and C-H stretching frequencies. The secondary part corresponds to the 1800–2500 nm wavelength regions and is characteristic of the combination bands of the O-H and C-H stretch. The possibility of determining the degree of esterification of pectic polymers of fresh, pre-heated and sterilized green beans using NIR spectroscopy was reported by Boeriu et al., 1998. They reported that the absorption of the methoxyl group at 2248 nm was clearly seen in the spectra of pectins. This result corresponds with the study of Sohn and Cho (2000), which indicated that the characteristic bands of the methoxyl group were at around 2250 nm. Sohn and Cho (2000) also reported that low accuracy was obtained for the estimation of the water-soluble pectin content of apple compared with that measured by a reference method. In addition, they found that the ability of NIR to predict methoxyl content in AIS was better than in apple fruit. The Takayuki Kojima research group at Saga University, Japan conducted an intensive analysis of texture and pectin constituents of Japanese pears (Pyrus serotina Rehder var. culta Housui) during fruit enlargement and ripening to clarify the relationship between the textural properties and pectin constituents and to develop the non-destructive method of evaluating pectin constituents and textural properties of the fruit using NIR spectroscopy (Sirisomboon, 2001). The NIR spectroscopy (1100–2500 nm at 2 nm intervals at 25 °C room temperature) was applied to estimate pectin constituents and textural properties for both intact Japanese pears and their juice. The NIR reflectance spectra of intact Japanese pears were measured by fiber optics in interactance mode. Before being measured, fruits were placed in a water bath to keep fruit temperature at 28 °C. Fruit was placed in a black box and the equatorial area was scanned. The NIR spectra of the juice were measured by diffuse transflectance. The juice sample was dropped on an aluminum cell for liquid sample (British cup) and pressed with a glass plate. The liquid layer for this
280
Texture in food
cell for data acquisition had a 30 mm diameter and 0.1 mm thickness. The NIR spectra of AIS were also measured using diffuse transflectance. The AIS was put and leveled with an angle spatula on a British cup and pressed with a glass plate as was done for the juice. The 210 spectra of intact Japanese pear and juice (two spectra per fruit) and 105 spectra of AIS (one spectra per fruit) were analyzed. Scanning was performed once per spectrum. Pure pectin from citrus fruits which contained galacturonic acid 76% and methoxy content 8.6% without sucrose or other sugars (Sigma Chemical Co., USA) and D-α-galacturonic acid (Katayama Chemical Co., Ltd, Japan) was dissolved in distilled water at concentrations of 100 µg/ml for the triplicate samples and for 60 µg/ml for the duplicate samples. The NIR spectra of those solution samples and the triplicate samples of pure pectin powder were measured following the methods used for juice and AIS, respectively. The results were as follows. The characteristic pectin absorption bands of the NIR spectra of intact fruit, juice and AIS of Japanese pear were proposed. The absorption at 2110 nm in juice spectra was partly due to the absorption of pectin. However, the 2242 nm might be more suitable for determining the pectin content in juice. For intact fruit spectra, the pectin absorption bands were observed at 1590, 1730 and 2362 nm. The 1590 nm was proposed for determining pectin content in AIS and the 1730 and 2362 nm for pectin content in fresh weight. For AIS spectra, the 1726 nm could be the suitable wavelength for determining the pectin content in AIS. The 1670–1674 nm were proposed for measuring the textural properties by intact fruit spectra. Intact spectra provided fairly accurate predictions for AIS in FW and OSP in AIS. In addition to those constituents, juice spectra could also provide predictions for WSP and TP in AIS. The textural properties capable of prediction included deformation at rupture point, rupture force, toughness, average firmness, penetrating force in the flesh and modulus of elasticity of both intact fruit and juice of Japanese pear and penetration energy in the flesh of juice-only spectra. It seemed that the intact spectra provided an accurate prediction of those textural properties compatible with the juice spectra.
11.5.1 Correlation spectrum Simple correlation coefficients between constituents (textural properties and pectin constituents) and absorbance at each measured wavelength for original intact spectra were improved by second derivative transformation. However, the correlation spectrum of juice spectra did not show any improvement in correlation values. The common three broad bands of the high correlation coefficients between both textural properties and pectin constituents with absorbance at each measured wavelength were observed in juice spectra including 1100–1300 nm, 1550–1850 nm, and 2100–2300 nm (Figs 11.4, and 11.5). Therefore, the pectin constituents in juice and textural properties
–0.60
–0.70
–0.70
–0.80 –0.90
–0.80 2166–2278 1100–1306 1600–1716
–0.90
Rupture force
–1.00
–1.00
0.00 –0.10 –0.20 –0.30 –0.40 –0.50 –0.60 –0.70 –0.80 –0.90 –1.00
–0.40
Toughness
–0.60 –0.70 2188–2274 1686–1752 1100–1300
Average firmness
–0.80 –0.90
–0.50
–0.50
1100–1300
1816 2084 1796
–0.70
1600– 1800
2150– 2250
2228 2252
–0.60
Penetrating energy into the flesh –1.00
1100 1300 1500 1700 1900 2100 2300 2500
Wavelength (nm)
1100–1316 1550–1800
2162–2272
Penetrating force in the flesh
–1.00
–0.40
–0.90
2162–2278 1100–1304 1610–1730
–0.50
–0.40
–0.80
1868
–0.50
–0.60
1776
–0.40
–0.50
1644
–0.30
–0.40
1132 1228 1236 1360 1364
–0.30
1364
Correlation coefficient
Correlation coefficient
Correlation coefficient
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 281
–0.60 –0.70 –0.80 –0.90
1100–1362
1596–1822
2162–2272
Modulus of elasticity
–1.00 1100 1300 1500 1700 1900 2100 2300 2500
Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 11.4 Correlation spectrum between textural properties with absorbance at each wavelength measured on juice (original spectra). Indicated wavelengths typed vertically were independent variables in each calibration equation and those typed horizontally were the highest correlation wavelengths.
related to the same vibration bonds. Intact original spectra also showed the same results with narrower broad bands at around 1404–1474 nm and 1900– 1966 nm. This indicated that the textural properties were correlated well with the pectin constituents.
11.5.2 Calibration equations for prediction Using multiple linear regression (MLR) calibration equations developed from intact fruit spectra and juice spectra, AIS in FW and OSP content in AIS
0.70
–0.50
0.60
0.40 0.30
0.80 2210– 2282
0.70 1100– 1300
0.60
0.60
0.50
0.50
1650– 1758
1860
1622– 1828
2332 2348
0.90
1852 2080
0.90
0.70
OSP in AIS
AIS in FW
0.20
1334
2144– 2276
0.50
–0.90
0.80 1100–
1632– 1810
2220
2166– 2280
2388
1632– 1810
1884
–0.70 1100– –0.80 1300
1388
–0.60
1100– 1328
2268 2316
0.80
–0.40
1852
–0.30
1344
0.90
2416
–0.20
1196
Texture in food
1544
Correlation coefficient
Correlation coefficient
282
2156– 2282
0.40
0.40 TP in AIS
WSP in AIS
0.30
0.30 1100 1300 1500 1700 1900 2100 2300 2500
Wavelength (nm)
1100 1300 1500 1700 1900 2100 2300 2500
Wavelength (nm)
Fig. 11.5 Correlation spectrum between pectin constituents and alcohol insoluble solids with absorbance at each wavelength measured on juice (original spectra). Indicated wavelengths typed vertically were independent variables in each calibration equation and those typed horizontally were the highest correlation coefficient wavelengths.
could be fairly accurately predicted. In addition, the equations from juice spectra, the WSP, OSP and TP in AIS were fairly accurately predictable. The textural properties, including rupture force, toughness, average firmness, penetration force in the flesh and modulus of elasticity of both intact and juice spectra, and penetration energy in the flesh of juice spectra, could be sufficiently accurately predicted. The best equation for each constituent was selected based on the lowest standard error of prediction (SEP); multiple correlation coefficient (R), which was equal to or higher than 0.90; the ratio of the standard deviation of reference data for prediction set to SEP (SD/ SEP), which was equal to or higher than 3; and the ratio of the range in reference data for prediction set to the SEP (RER), which was more than 10. However, when SD/SEP was less than 3 and RER was less than 10, the best equation based on an RER of more than 10 for at least one tenth of the range was selected (Williams and Sobering, 1996). The calibration equations obtained could predict only for the year, but could not be used to predict the data in another year. Data collection over many years is highly recommended in order to improve the calibration equations. This study (Sirisomboon, 2001) showed for the first time the
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 283
potential of NIR spectroscopy to measure the textural properties and pectin constituents of Japanese pear. The MLR equations (Table 11.2) developed from intact fruit spectra could predict mostly the same constituents of pectin and textural properties as those from juice spectra. The NIR absorbance of the spectra for intact fruit seemed to correlate better with the constituents than that of the spectra for juice. This leads to the effective non-destructive measurement of the texture and pectin constituents of fruit. NIR spectroscopy allows the evaluation of those inner properties of intact fruit. It also enables assessment of the freshness of fruit to be used for the commercial production of juices and beverages.
11.6 Future trends 11.6.1 Role of functional protein on texture of fruit The role of structural protein cross-links is evaluated within the context of cell-wall-mediated changes in texture during fruit ripening (Brownleader et al., 1999). Only a little of the investigation has been done and the conclusions show that intensive research is needed. The investigations of El-Buluk et al. (1995) showed that protein content measured by the AOAC (Association of Analytical Communities) method decreased markedly with fruit growth and development and that the texture measured by plunger-type pressure tester declined gradually during fruit development for all guava cultivars studied. That the softness of the fruit was associated with lower protein might be due to the fruit utilizing protein for growth and development which correspond with a rapid increase in the ratio between protein catabolism and anabolism which the study also found. Bartolome et al. (1995) measured the texture and soluble protein in Red Spanish and Smooth Cayenne pineapple fruit. They found that the values for texture, measured using a Kramer shear test, were lower for Red Spanish than for Smooth Cayenne (although the difference was not statitistically significant) and that the soluble protein, measured using a Bio-red kit, was higher for Red Spanish. It was thought that the soluble protein might be related to the lower total dietary fiber. Cano et al. (1997) measured along with several biochemical and physical constituents the soluble protein (also by Bio-red kit) and texture (by Kramer shear test) of bananas. The texture differences among cultivars did not correspond with their soluble protein. The use of suitable measuring methods and measured constituents may lead to greater understanding of the role of protein in fruit texture. 11.6.2 Application of a simplified method for the determination of total oxalate soluble pectin content in fruit and vegetables The chelation of calcium ions with carboxyl groups of adjacent polyuronide chains is a key factor in fruit firmness (Neal, 1965), with calcium deposition occurring in the junction zones in the middle lamella (Knee, 1993). Any
MLR of reflectance measurement for textural properties and pectin constituents of intact Japanese pear and juiceη MLR method
Wavelength selected λ1
λ2
λ3
λ4
λ5
λ6
λ7
λ8
λ9
R
SEC
SEP
Bias
SD SEP
INTACT SPECTRA Puncture test Rupture force Toughness Average firmness Penetrating force in the flesh Flat plate compression test Modulus of elasticity Pectin constituents AIS in FW OSP in AIS
Step Best Step Step
up original spectra pair 2nd derivative up original spectra up original spectra
2280 1310 1636 1456
1128 1666* 1664* 1640
Best pair original spectra
1636
1672* 1280
1752
Best pair 2nd derivative Step up/Best pair 2nd derivative
1350 2302
1630* 1542 1622* 1318
1886
1116 2126 2408 1104
1308* 1636 1726 1100 1588 1680* 1804
1736 1604
2460 1724
0.96 0.90 1.28 0.17 2.5** 0.92 13.38 12.96 –0.51 2.3** 0.91 0.69 0.73 –0.008 1.9** 1584 1784 1112 0.96 0.39 0.52 –0.07 2.4**
2006
1238
2042 1562
0.92
0.003 0.003 0.001 2.3**
0.93 0.95
0.57 5.65
0.62 –0.12 8.48 –0.47
2.1** 1.7**
0.89 1.09 0.11 9.83 10.61 –0.53 0.69 0.64 0.16 0.56 0.50 –0.06
2.6** 2.9** 2.2** 2.5** 2.2**
JUICE SPECTRA Puncture test Rupture force Toughness Average firmness Penetrating force in the flesh Penetrating energy in the flesh Flat plate compression test Modulus of elasticity Pectin constituents AIS in FW WSP in AIS OSP in AIS TP in AIS
Step up 2nd derivative Step up original spectra Best pair 2nd derivative Step up/Best pair 2nd derivative Best pair original spectra
1658 1132 2266* 1318
2362 1776 1886 2086
2084
2252* 1816
Best pair 2nd derivative
2378
Step Best Best Best
1388 1860 2268 1776
up original pair original spectra pair original spectra pair original spectra
2258 1360 1806 1658
1814 1376
1322 1228
2210
2274
1554 1574 0.96 1236 1364 1644 0.96 0.91 2038 1614 0.92
2228
1364
1796
0.91
2.91
2194
2266* 2418
2306
2094
0.95
0.025 0.029 0.005 2.8**
1884* 2220 2316* 1368
2416 1544* 1344 2064
2332 1852 1852 1200* 1452
0.93 0.91 0.91 0.94
0.53 0.63 0.13 1.51 1.41 0.16 7.34 7.93 –0.95 9.53 11.52 2.57
2214* 1868* 2210 1758*
2388 2080 1196 1712
1878 2042 2348
2.74
0.20
2.3** 2.1** 1.9** 2.0**
ηWavelengths in bold letters indicate the proposed wavelength ranges of pectin (1522–1638 nm, 1694–1762 nm, 2074–2202 nm and 2334–2410 nm) or methoxyl group (2202–2282 nm). *Most significant wavelength in each calibration equation determined by t-test. **The data predicted at RER > 10 with an accuracy of at least one tenth of the range. AIS: alcohol insoluble solids. OSP: oxalate soluble pectin. WSP: water soluble pectin. TP: total pectin. FW: fresh weight.
Texture in food
Constituents
284
Table 11.2
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 285
increase in free pectin carboxyl groups might be expected to increase the importance of calcium as a firmness increasing agent (Van Buren, 1979). Calcium binding agents, such as solutions of oxalate, ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) or polyphosphate, have been used to extract pectic acid from fruits (Pilnik and Voragen, 1971). For example, solutions of oxalic acid and ammonium oxalate are used to extract the pectic acid in the form of OSP. Oxalate soluble pectin exists as pectic acid which could bind calcium and form a cross-link structure (Yu et al., 1996). Researchers using various methods to extract OSP have reported differing quantites of OSP which might not represent the total. This gave rise to differences in or misinterpretations of the data, such as different correlations between pectin content and fruit firmness, contrasting comparisons of the solubilization of different kinds of pectin and so on. Moreover the time required to completely extract the pectin was possibly too long to be practicable. The method proposed by Sirisomboon et al. (2001) and described in Section 11.3.5 offers the potential of reducing the extraction time. The method recommended that the extraction should be done until half extraction time was reached and the total oxalate soluble pectin could be estimated by multiplying the pectin content at half extraction time by two. The method may be applicable to the extraction of other kinds of pectin or constituents contained in fruit. Therefore, this simplified method for the determination of total OSP content in fruit and vegetables could benefit researchers in different sectors, especially agricultural science, medical science, food science, pharmaceuticals and cosmetics, by enabling accurate and easy extraction of total pectin constituents.
11.6.3 Methodology for measuring actual and estimating bruise volume and bruise threshold The results of Kawano et al. (1984) for Japanese pear Nijisseiki indicated that the quasi-static compression test showed a difference in the absorbed energy per unit bruised volume for different harvesting dates whereas the impact test showed no difference. This might be due to the difference in the shape of the bruise. Although both impact and compression cause bruising to spread inwards from immediately under the skin, the impact bruise spreads radially and the compression bruise conically (Tsukamoto, 1981), a fact which might make the bruise volume estimation incorrect. The compression bruise pattern is similar to that found in European pears (Chen et al., 1987). The difference in patterns of impact and compression bruises indicates that the loading rate greatly affects the pattern of failure in Asian pears, and the irregular pattern of the impact bruise made it difficult to quantify the degree of bruising due to that cause (Chen et al., 1987). Bruise volume was generally described as a parabolic shape which could be used to estimate bruise area or volume. However, it is not capable of estimating the area of the irregularlyshaped impact bruise (Chen et al., 1987). Bollen et al. (1999) compared several methods for estimating the size of apple bruises caused by impact
286
Texture in food
test against the actual volume measured using a sectioning and image analysis technique. They concluded that all the volume estimation methods induced errors in prediction and there was not one single method which could be used for the estimation of bruise volume over the whole range of commercially significant impacts. The bruise threshold, which is the drop height at which bruising begins to occur for a given specimen mass, curvature, and impact surface (Varith et al., 2001 citing from Bajema and Hyde (1998), of apples was studied by Varith et al. (2001) to gain information to develop management tools to reduce bruising for fruits and vegetables. They used the dynamic axial compression (DAC) prediction equation for bruise threshold which Baritelle and Hyde (2001) developed based on Horsfield et al. (1972) in which the Hertz contact theory was applied. The model equates tissue failure stress to impact-induced stress at bruise threshold, and it was compared with the paired increasing-height multiple-impacting bruise threshold (PIHMI). The PIHMI detects bruise threshold in individual apples by comparing force profile pairs from successively higher drops of the specimen at the same location onto a rigid surface (Bajema and Hyde, 1998 citing from Varith et al., 2001). Varith et al. (2001) showed that when the drop height reaches the bruise threshold, the pair of profiles for the same drop height will differ because one will have more tissue failure than the other. They indicated that the method works for commodities only such as apples whose tissues fail in compression near the surface but it fails with potato and pear tissues which have higher Poisson’s ratios and fail in shear rather than compression. The results reconfirmed PIHMI as a promising technique for determining bruise threshold in apples, and showed that DAC could also predict bruise threshold. DAC showed the best results when grouped by turgor, reconfirming the strong dependency of bruise threshold on apple turgor. Practically speaking PIHMI bruise threshold is an easier process to use than DAC, although DAC is more sensitive to the post-harvest behavior of fruits and vegetables, e.g. turgor effect. There is a need for more research to find an accurate, sensitive and easy method to detect bruise threshold for pears and other fruit and vegetables. The machine vision procedure using visible and NIR ranges to detect bruising in sweet cherries was studied by the Daniel Guyer research group at Michigan State University, USA (Guyer et al., 1996) and in strawberries by the Masateru Nagata research group at Miyazaki University, Japan (Shrestha, 2002). This image processing technique can be used to detect, measure actual and estimate bruise volume and bruise threshold. For cherries, the bandpass filters that enhance the intensity contrast between bruised and unbruised fruits were determined. An optimum combination of two wavelengths is identified at 750 nm (NIR range) and 500 nm (green range). An optimum single wavelength is identified at 750 nm. Bruise detection via infrared edge detection had the least error potential which suggested the idea of implementing edge detection to detect the transitive area between good and bruised tissues.
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 287
For strawberries it was concluded that the a* level of the L*a*b* model was especially able to represent the bruises on the strawberry surfaces and the discoloration on bruises caused by a comprehensive force of less than 2 N was not detected. The images of non-bruised and bruised strawberry were taken at 860 nm and 960 nm filters, respectively. The former image was subtracted from the latter one. The method of image subtraction using the same strawberry has given 100% accuracy. However, for on-line sorting, the subtraction of the standard image from the on-line image resulted in an error of 5–10%. The study has confirmed the possibility of using the standard strawberry image to sort and judge bruises on strawberry.
11.6.4 Cell wall change and sensory evaluation The textural properties measured by mechanical methods may or may not yield a good correlation to human response (Jeon et al., 1973; Diehl and Hamann, 1979; Robertston et al., 1984; Bartolomé et al., 1996). Delwiche et al. (1996) suggested that future research should address the question of which physical properties are most closely related to human perceptions of fruit texture. Any properties or combinations of properties which are related to cell wall change or failure during mastication might be indicators of sensory perception. Cell wall and the middle lamella, their quantity and mechanical properties, are very important in determining how the plant food stuff will behave under the disintegrating action of the forces applied to it during mastication (Ilker and Szczesniak, 1990). Ilker and Szczesniak described as follows. If the cell wall is stronger than the middle lamella, the tissue will yield between the cell and the cell contents will not be released during mastication. The sensory perception will be that of a dry, chalky granular texture, e.g. raw potatoes. If the cell wall is weaker than the middle lamella, the yielding will occur through the cells and, as a result, the liquid contents will be released. The sensory perception will be that of a juicy product, e.g. good quality pears. The cell wall physical change may give a better correlation with the sensory evaluation than the texture properties obtained from whole fruit measurement, and the puncture test may provide better correlation than the plate compression test. Further investigation of how cell wall physical change is correlated with sensory evaluation may help to answer the question of why the textural properties measured by mechanical methods may or may not yield a good correlation to human response. Multivariate calibrations could help with mathematical manipulation of texture property variables to find combinations which offer a positive sensory experience to human consumers. 11.6.5 Development of texture model for non-destructive determination Destructive methods of measuring fruit texture cannot be used for on-line control of fruit quality (Dewulf et al., 1999). At the time of writing the well-
288
Texture in food
known, non-destructive methods of detecting fruit texture which have been investigated are the acoustic resonant measurement technique and the NIR spectroscopy technology. With regard to the former De Belie et al. (2000) expressed the following view: the acoustic impulse response technique is a fast, non-destructive firmness measurement normally applied to spherical fruit such as apples, peaches and tomatoes. Even the stiffness factor, which is calculated from the first resonance frequency and the mass of the fruit, is found to be significantly correlated with fruit f irmness and sensory measurement. However, it is not immediately clear whether the acoustic impulse response technique, which was initially developed for spherical fruit, is equally applicable to non-spherical fruits such as pears. This opinion showed that research is needed to clarify whether the technique is applicable to non-spherical fruits as well. The latter, NIR spectroscopy technology, as described in Section 11.5, is effectively able to evaluate the soluble solids of fruit non-destructively via the multivariate model. The soluble solids content of pears was reasonably well (negatively) correlated with the texture measures (De Belie et al., 2000; Sirisomboon et al., 2000b). Progress towards applying NIR spectroscopy technology to estimate textural properties and the flavor of fruit and vegetables in situ will be interesting to watch.
11.7 Sources of further information and advice • Journal of Texture Studies Food and Nutrition Press, 6527 Main Street, PO Box 374, Trumbull, Connecticut, 06611, USA. Publishes original research, reviews, and discussion papers on rheology, psychorheology, physical testing and sensory testing of foods. • Journal of Food Composition and Analysis (http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/08891575) By Academic Press: an international journal, it is the official publication of INFOODS, and is co-sponsored by The United Nations University and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. This journal is devoted to all scientific aspects of the chemical composition of human foods, and emphasizes new methods of analysis; data on composition of foods; studies on the manipulation, storage, distribution, and use of food composition data; and studies on the statistics and distribution of such data and data systems. The journal is looking to build on its strong base in nutrient composition and to place increasing emphasis on other food components such as anti-carcinogens, natural toxicants, flavors, colors, functional additives, pesticides, agricultural chemicals, heavy metals, general environmental contaminants, and chemical and biochemical toxicants of microbiological origin. • Postharvest Biology and Technology (http://www.elsevier.nl/locate/inca/503313) It is an international scholarly
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 289
journal covering biological and technological research in the area of post-harvest systems for agronomic and horticultural crops. It is published in three volumes of three issues per year by Elsevier Science. • Journal of Biosystems Engineering (http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/15375110) By Academic Press. • Academic Press The remit of Biosystems Engineering is research in the physical sciences and engineering to understand, model, process or enhance biological systems for sustainable developments in agriculture, food, land use and the environment. Topics are broadly classified under nine interest fields and each paper is allocated to the most appropriate category: Automation and Emerging Technologies (AE), Information Technology and the Human Interface (IT), Precision Agriculture (PA), Power and Machinery (PM), Postharvest Technology (PH), Structures and Environment (SE), Animal Production Technology (AP), Soil and Water (SW), Rural Development (RD). • Transactions of the ASAE (http://asae.frymulti.com/) Published six times a year (February, April, June, August, October, December) by the American Society of Agricultural Engineers, 2950 Niles Rd, St Joseph, MI 49085–9659, USA. Founded in 1907, ASAE is a professional and technical organization of members dedicated to the advancement of engineering applicable to agricultural, food, and other biological systems including the environment and natural resources, and to associated industries. Topics are broadly classified under five interest fields and each paper is allocated to the most appropriate category: Power and Machinery, Soil and Water, Food and Process Engineering Institute, Structure and Environment and Information and Electrical Technologies.
11.8 Acknowledgement The authors wish to express their appreciation to Woodhead Publishing Ltd for the honor of being asked to write this Chapter 11; to Prof. Paul Chen and Dr Junichi Sugiyama for their contributions of information and the photos of the pear firmness tester; and to the internet database for research journals, abstract databases and reference works: ScienceDirect (http://www.sciencedirect.com), SpringerLink (http://link.springer.de/home.hml), ASAE technical library (http:/ /asae.frymulti.com/), International Conference on Noise & Vibration Engineering (ISMA) at Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (http://www.isma-isaac.be/), BlackwellSynergy list of journals (http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/), Nordic Association of Agricultural Scientists www.njf.dk/njf/NJ-Abstracts/ oversight.htm
290
Texture in food
11.9 References and HYDE G M (1998) Instrumented pendulum for impact characterization of whole fruit and vegetable specimens, Trans ASAE, 41(5), 1399–405. BARITELLE A and HYDE G M (2000) Strain rate and size effects on pear tissue failure, Trans ASAE, 43(1), 95–8. BARITELLE A L and HYDE G M (2001) Commodity conditioning to reduce impact bruising, Postharvest Bio and Technol, 21(3), 331–9. BARITELLE A L, HYDE G M and VARITH J (2000) Turgor and temperature effects on pear tissue failure, www.bsyse.wsu.edu/gmhyde/impact-pdfs/pdf.mss-impact-properties/996003pear-dac.pdf/pear-turgor-temp.pdf BARITELLE A L, HYDE G M, FELLMAN J K and VARITH J (2001) Using 1-MCP to inhibit the influence of ripening on impact properties of pear and apple tissue, Postharvest Bio and Technol, 23(2), 153–60. BARTOLOMÉ A P, RUPERÉZ P and FÚSTER C (1995) Pineapple fruit: morphological characteristics, chemical composition and sensory analysis of Red Spanish and Smooth Cayenne cultivars, Food Chemistry, 53(1), 75–9. BARTOLOMÉ A P, RUPERÉZ P and FÚSTER C (1996) Non-volatile organic acids, pH, and titratable acidity changes in pineapple fruit slices during frozen storage, J Sci Food Agric, 70, 475–80. BATISSE C, FILS-LYCAON B and BURET M (1994) Pectin change in ripening cherry fruit, J Food Sci, 59(2), 389–93. BATISSE C, BURET M and COULOMB P J (1996) Biochemical differences in cell wall of cherry fruit between soft and crisp fruit, J Agric Food Chem, 44, 453–7. BEN-ARIE R, SONEGO L and FRANKEL C (1979a) Changes in pectic substances in ripening pears, J Amer Soc Hort Sci, 104(4), 500–5. BEN-ARIE R, KISLEV N and FRENKEL C (1979b) Ultrastructure changes in the cell walls of ripening apple and pear fruit, J Plant Physiol, 64, 197–202. BERTELSEN M (2001) Preliminary results with Aweta acoustic fruit firmness sensor. Measurement methods of soil, water, plant and fruit, in berry and fruit growing, Nordic Association of Agricultural Scientists, NJF seminar no 333, 29–30 November Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Alnarp, Sweden. www.njf.dk/njf/NJAbstracts/oversight.htm BOERIU C G, STOLLE-SMITS T and VAN DIJK C (1998) Characterisation of cell wall pectins by near infrared spectroscopy, J Near Infrared Spectroscopy, 6, A299–A301. BOLLEN A F, NGUYEN H X and DELA RUE B T (1999) Comparison of methods for estimating the bruise volume of apples, J Agric Engng Res, 74, 325–30. BROWNLEADER M D, JACKSON P D, MOBASHERI A D, PANTELIDES A T, SUMAR S T, TREVAN M T and DEY P M (1999) Molecular aspects of cell wall modifications during fruit ripening, Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 39(2), 149–64. BUDIASTRA W, IKEDA Y and NUSHIZU T (1998) Optical methods for quality evaluation of fruits (part 1) optical properties of selected fruits using the Kubelka-Munk theory and their relationships with fruit maturity and sugar content, J Jpn Soc Agric Mach, 60(2), 117– 28. CANO M P, BEGOÑA DE ANCOS, MATALLANA M C, CÁMARA M, REGLERO G and TABERA J (1997) Differences among Spanish and Latin-America banana cultivars: morphological, chemical and sensory characteristics, Food Chemistry, 59(3), 411–19. CHEN P and SUN Z (1981) Impact parameters related to bruise injury in apples, ASAE Paper No. 81-3041, St Joseph, MI, ASAE. CHEN P and THOMPSON J (project leaders) (1999) Development of a firmness tester for pears, www.calpear.com/ind.html CHEN P and THOMPSON J (project leaders) (2000) Development of a firmness tester for pears, www.calpear.com/ind.html CHEN P, TANG S and CHEN S (1985) Instrument for testing the response of fruits to impact, ASAE Paper No. 85-3537, St Joseph, MI, ASAE. BAJEMA R W
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 291 CHEN P, RUIZ M, LU F
and KADER A A (1987) Study of impact and compression damage on Asian pears, Trans ASAE, 30(4), 1193–7. CHEN P, RUIZ-ALTISENT M and BARREIRO P (1996) Effect of impacting mass on firmness sensing of fruits, Trans ASAE, 39(3), 1019–23. CHO R K, KWON Y K, LEE K H and IWAMOTO M (1996) Application of near infrared spectroscopy for quality evaluation of an intact apple. In Near Infrared Spectroscopy: Future Waves, Proc. Int. Conf. Near Infrared spectroscopy., 7th Meeting Date 1995. (M.C. Anthony Davies and P.C. Williams Eds.) NIR Publications: Chichester, UK. p. 629–31. CROOKES P R and GRIERSON D (1983) Ultrastructure of tomato fruit ripening and the role of polygalacturonase isoenzymes in cell wall degradation, J Plant Physiol, 72, 1088–93. DAL FABBRO I M, MURASE H and SEGERLIND L J (1980) Strain failure of apple, pear and potato tissues, ASAE paper No. 80-3048, St Joseph, MI, ASAE. DE BELIE N, SCHOTTE S, LAMMERTYN J , NICOLAI B and DE BAERDEMAEKER J (2000) Firmness changes of pear fruit before and after harvest with the acoustic impulse response technique, J Agric Engng Res, 77(2), 183–91. DELWICHE M J, ARÉVALO H and MEHLSCHAU J (1996) Second generation impact force response fruit firmness sorter, Trans ASAE, 39(3), 1025–33. DEWULF W, JANCSÓK P, PAPADIAMANTOPOULOU E, NICOLAI B and DE ROECK G (1998) Monitoring of the firmness of a Conference pear using experimental modal analysis, Proceedings of ISMA 23, the International Conference on Noise and Vibration Engineering, 16–18 September, Leuven, Belgium, 1489–96. DEWULF W, JANCSÓK P, NICOLAI B, DE ROECK G and BRIASSOULIS D (1999) Determining the firmness of a pear using finite element modal analysis, J Agric Engng Res 74, 217– 24. DIEHL K C and HAMANN D D (1979) Relationship between sensory profile parameters and fundamental mechanical parameters for raw potatoes, melons and apples, J Texture Studies, 10, 401–20. DOLENDO A L, LUH B S and PRATT H K (1966) Relation of pectic and fatty acid changes to respiration rate during of avocado fruits, J Food Sci, 31, 332. EL-BULUK R E, BABIKER E E and EL TINAY A H (1995) Biochemical and physical changes in fruit of four guava cultivars during growth and development, Food Chemistry, 54(3), 279–82. ESKIN N A M (1990) Biochemistry of Foods, (Second Edition). San Diego, Academic Press, Inc. p. 138. GARCÍA C, RUIZ-ALTISENT M and CHEN P (1988) Impact parameters related to bruising in selected fruits, ASAE Paper No. 88-6027, St Joseph, MI, ASAE. GARCÍA J L, RUIZ-ALTISENT M and BARREIRO P (1995) Factors influencing mechanical properties and bruise susceptibility of apples and pears, J Agric Engng Res, 61, 11–18. GARCÍA-RAMOS F J, ORTIZ-CAÑAVATE J O, RUIZ-ALTISENT M, DÍEZ J, FLORES L, HOMER I and CHÁVEZ J M (2003) Development and implementation of an on-line impact sensor for firmness sensing of fruits, J Food Engng, 58(1), 53–7. GROSS K C and WALLNER S J (1979) Degradation of cell wall polysaccharides during tomato fruit ripening, Plant Physiol, 63, 117–20. GUYER D, UTHAISOMBUT P and STOCKMAN G (1996) Tissue reflectance and machine vision for automated sweet cherry sorting, SPIE Proceedings, Vol. 2907, Optics in Agriculture, Forestry, and Biological Processing II, 19–20 Nov, Boston, MA, 152–65. HORSFIELD B C, FRIDLEY R B and CLAYPOOL L L (1972) Application of theory of elasticity to the design of fruit harvesting and handling equipment for minimum bruising, Trans ASAE, 15, 746–50. HUBER D J (1983) Polyuronide degradation and hemicellulose modifications in ripening tomato fruit, J Amer Soc Hort Sci, 108, 405–9. ILKER R and SZCZESNIAK A S (1990) Structural and chemical bases for texture of plant foodstuffs, Review paper, J Texture Studies, 21, 1–36. JANCSÓK P T, CLIJMANS L, NICOLAI B M and DE BAERDEMAEKER J (2001) Investigation of the
292
Texture in food
effect of shape on the acoustic response of ‘Conference’ pears by finite element modelling, Postharvest Bio and Technol, 23, 1–12. JEON I J, WILLIAM M B and SHIRLEY T M (1973) Texture of cucumbers: correlation of instrumental and sensory measurements, J Food Sci, 38, 334–7. KAWANO S, IWAMOTO M, HAYAKAWA A, YAMANE A and ANDOU K (1984) Mechanical properties of Japanese pear “Nijisseiki” as related to susceptibility of the fruit to mechanical injury, J Jpn Soc Agric Mach, 46(1), 627–32. KAWANO S, FUJIWARA T and IWAMOTO M (1993) Nondestructive determination of sugar content in Satsuma mandarin using near infrared (NIR) transmittance, J Jpn Soc Hort Sci, 62(2), 465–70. KAWANO S, WATANABE H and IWAMOTO M (1992) Determination of sugar content in intact peaches by near infrared spectroscopy with fiber optics in interactance mode, J Jpn Soc Hort Sci, 61(2), 445–51. KETSA S and DAENGKANIT T (1999) Firmness and activities of polygalacturonase, pectinesterase, β-galactosidase and cellulase in ripening durian harvested at different stages of maturity, Scientia Horticulturae, 80, 181–8. KITAGAWA Y, KANAYAMA Y and YAMAKI S (1995) Isolation of galactosidase fractions from Japanese pear: activity against native cell wall polysaccharides, Physiol Plant, 93(3), 545–50. KLAVONS J A, RAYMOND D B and VANNIER S H (1994) Physical/chemical nature of pectin associated with commercial orange juice cloud, J Food Sci, 59(2), 399–401. KNEE M (1993) Pome fruits. In Biochemistry of Fruit Ripening Eds G B Seymour, J E Taylor and G A Tucker, London, Chapman & Hall, 325–46. KNEE M and BARTLEY I M (1981) Composition and metabolism of cell wall polysaccharides in ripening fruits. In Recent Advances in the Biochemistry of Fruits and Vegetables. Eds J Friend and M J C Rhodes New York, Academic Press, 133–48. KOJIMA T, INOUE Y and TANAKA M (1994) Measurement of Brix value in various developing stages of Japanese pear by NIR spectroscopy, Bulletin of Faculty of Agriculture, Saga University, 77, 1–10. LIU J Y, KOJIMA T, TANAKA M and TATARA I (1998) Effects of vibration and storage temperatures on quality of Japanese pears, J Society of Agricultural Structures, Japan, 28(1), 217– 24. LU R (2001) Predicting firmness and sugar content of sweet cherries using near-infrared diffuse reflectance spectroscopy, Trans ASAE, 44(5), 1265–71. LU R, GUYER D E and BEAUDRY R M (2000) Determination of firmness and sugar content of apples using near-infrared diffuse reflectance, J Texture Studies, 3, 615–30. MA S S, CHEN P M (2003) Storage disorder and ripening behavior of Doyenne du Comice pears in relation to storage conditions, Postharvest Bio Technol, http:// www.sciencedirect.com/ MIURA H, HAGINUMA S and MIZUTA M (1963) Quality of pectin in pear with spectial reference to the changes during maturation and subsequent after-ripening in Barlett pears, J Jpn Soc Hort Sci, 21, 27–36. MURAYAMA H, TAKAHASHI T, HONDA R and FUKUSHIMA T (1998) Cell wall changes in pear fruit softening on and off the tree, Postharvest Bio Technol, 14, 143–9. MURAYAMA H, KATSUMATA T, HORIUCHI O and FUKUSHIMA T (2002) Relationship between fruit softening and cell wall polysaccharides in pears after different storage periods, Postharvest Biol and Technol, 26(1), 15–21. NEAL G E (1965) Changes occurring in the cell walls of strawberry during ripening, J Sci Food Agric, 16, 604–11. ONDA T, KOMIYAMA Y and OTOGURO C (1996) Time series analysis of postharvest ripening of plum fruit by near infrared spectroscopy, Nippon Shokuhin Kagaku Kogaku Kaishi, 43(4), 382–7. ORON G, DEMALACH Y, GILLERMAN L, DAVID I and LURIE S (2002) Effect of water salinity and irrigation technology on yield and quality of pears, J Biosystems Engng, 81(2), 237– 47.
Plant compounds and fruit texture: the case of pear 293 PARK B, ABBOTT J A, LEE K
and CHOI K (2002) Near-infrared spectroscopy to predict soluble solids and firmness in apples, ASAE/CIGR Annual International Meeting, Chicago, Illinois, USA, July 28–31, http://asae.frymulti.com/ PEIRIS K H S, DULL G G, LEFFLER R G and KAYS S J (1998) Near-infrared spectrometric method for nondestructive determination of soluble solids content of peaches, J Amer Soc Hort Sci, 123(5), 898–905. PESIS E, FUCHS Y and ZAUBERMANN G (1978) Cellulase activity and fruit softening in avocado, J Plant Physiol, 61, 416–17. PILNIK W and VORAGEN A G J (1971) Pectic substances and other uronides. In The Biochemistry of Fruits and their Products, Volume 2. Ed. A C Hulme, London and New York, Academic Press, 71. PRESSEY R, HINTON D M and AVANTJ K (1971) Development of polygalacturonase activity and solubilization of pectin in peaches during ripening, J Food Sci, 36, 1070. REINDERS G and THEIR H P (1998) Non-starch polysaccharides of tomatoes I characterizing pectins and hemicelluloses, Eur Food Res Technol, 209, 43–6. RHODES M J C (1980) The maturation and ripening of fruits. In Senescene in Plants Ed. K V Thimann, Boca Roton, FL, CRC Press, Inc. 157–205. ROBERT C and CADET F (1998) Analysis of near-infrared spectra of some carbohydrates, Applied Spectrosc Reviews, 33(3), 253–66. ROBERTSTON G L, KOOPMANSCHAP E A and SCRIVENS C A (1984) Research note. Comparison of instrumental and sensory panel methods for measuring kiwifruit firmness, J Texture Studies 15, 175–283. SCHMILOVITCH Z, HOFFMAN A, EGOZI H, BEN-ZVI R, BERNSTEIN Z and ALCHANATIS V (1999) Maturity determination of fresh dates by near infrared spectrometry, J Sci Food Agric, 79, 86–90. SEYMOUR G B, LASSLETT Y and TUCKER G A (1987) Differential effects of pectolytic enzymes on tomato polyuronides in vivo and in vitro, Phytochem, 26, 3137–9. SHEWFELT A L (1965) Changes and variations in the pectic constitution of ripening peaches as related to product firmness, J Food Sci, 30, 573. SHEWFELT A L , PAYNTER V A and JEN J J (1971) Texture changes and molecular characteristics of pectic constituents in ripening peaches, J Food Sci, 36, 573–5. SHRESTHA B P (2002) Basic studies on quality estimation and sorting system for fruit vegetables (Dissertation, The United Graduate School of Agriculture, Kagoshima University (Miyazaki University), Japan). SIRINNAPA S, SORNSRIVICHAI J and KAWANO S (2001) Improvement of PLS calibration for Brix value and dry matter of mango using information from MLR calibration, J Near Infrared Spectroscopy, 9, 287–95. SIRISOMBOON P (2001) Studies on the relationship between texture and pectin constituents of Japanese pear (Dissertation, The United Graduate School of Agriculture, Kagoshima University (Saga University), Japan). SIRISOMBOON P, TANAKA M, AKINAGA T and KOJIMA T (2000a) Evaluation of the texture properties of Japanese pear, J Texture Studies, 31, 665–77. SIRISOMBOON P, TANAKA M, FUJITA S and KOJIMA T (2000b) Relationship between the texture and pectin constituents of Japanese pear, J Texture Studies, 31, 679–90. SIRISOMBOON P, TANAKA M, FUJITA S, AKINAGA T and KOJIMA T (2001) A simplified method for the determination of total oxalate soluble pectin content in Japanese pear, J Food Composition and Analysis, 14, 83–91. SLAUGHTER D C, BARRETT D and BOERSIG M (1996) Nondestructive determination of soluble solids in tomatoes using near infrared spectroscopy, J Food Sci, 61(4), 695–7. SLAUGHTER D C, CAVALETTO C G, GAUTZ L D and PAULL R E (1999) Non-destructive determination of soluble solids in papayas using near infrared spectroscopy, J Near Infrared Spectroscopy, 7, 223–8. SOHN M R and CHO R K (2000) Possibility of nondestructive evaluation of pectin in apple fruit using near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy, J Kor Soc Hort Sci, 41(1), 65–70.
294
Texture in food
STRASBURGER E, NOLL F, SCHENCH H, SCHIMPER A F W, VON DENFFER D, BRESINSKY A, EHRENDORFER
(1985) Botánica (Botany), Barcelona, Marín. (2001) Application of non-destructive portable firmness tester to pears, Food Sci Technol Res, 7(2), 161–3. TANAKA M and KOJIMA T (1996) Near-infrared monitoring of the growth period of Japanese pear fruit based on constituent sugar concentrations, J Agric Food Chem, 44(8), 2272–7. TATEISHI A, KANAYAMA Y and YAMAKI S (1996) α-L-Arabinofuranosidase from cell walls of Japanese pear fruits, Phytochemistry, 42(2), 295–9. TAYLOR M A, RABE E, JACOBS G and DODD M C (1995) Effect of harvest maturity on pectic substances, internal conductivity, soluble solids and gel breakdown in cold stored ‘Songold’ plums, Postharvest Bio and Technol, 5, 285–94. TSUKAMOTO M (1981) Studies on the mechanical injury of fruit III The resistivities of fruits of Japanese pear and oriental persimmon to impact and compression, J Jpn Soc Hort Sci, 49(4), 576–82. TUCKER G A (1993) Tomato. In Biochemistry of Fruit Ripening. (Eds G B Seymour and J E Taylor, G A Tucker, London, Chapman & Hall, 105–42. TUCKER G A and GRIERSON D (1987) Fruit ripening. In The Biochemistry of Plants – A Comprehensive Treatise, Volume 2. Ed. D D Davies San Diego, Academic Press, 265– 318. VAN BUREN J P (1979) The chemistry of texture in fruits and vegetables, J Texture Studies, 10, 1–23. VARITH J, HYDE G M, BARITELLE A L and SATTABONGKOT T (2001) Fruit and vegetable bruise threshold prediction using theory of elasticity and tissue failure properties, ASAE Paper No. 01-6139, St Joseph, MI, ASAE. VORAGEN A G J, TIMMERS J P J, LINSSEN J P H, SCHOLS H A and PILNIK W (1983) Methods of analysis for cell wall polysaccharides of fruit and vegetables, Z. Lebensm Unters Forsch, 177, 251–6. WANG J (2003) Anisotropic relaxation properties of pear, Biosystem Engineering, 85(1), 59–65. WILLIAMS P and SOBERING D (1996) How do we do it: a brief summary of the methods we use in developing near infrared calibrations. In New Infrared Spectroscopy: the future waves. Proceedings of 7th International Conference on Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Montreal, Canada (A.M.C. Davies and Phil Williams Eds.) NIR Publications, UK p. 185–8. WILLS R H, MCGLASSON W B, GRAHAM D, LEE T H, HALL E G (1989) Postharvest: An Introduction to the Physiology and Handling of Fruit and Vegetables, Oxford, BSP Professional Books. YAMAKI S, and MATSUDA K (1977) Changes in the activities of some cell wall-degrading enzymes during development and ripening of Japanese pear fruit (Pyrus serotina Rehder var. culta Rehder), Plant & Cell Physiol, 18, 81–93. YAMAKI S and KAKIUCHI N (1979) Changes in hemicellulose-degrading enzymes during development and ripening of Japanese pear fruit, Plant & Cell Physiol, 20(2), 301–9. YAMAKI S, KAJIURA I, OMURA M and MATSUDA K (1977) Watercore in Japanese pear. III. Changes in the activities of some enzymes relating to the degradation of cell walls and the accumulation of sugar, Scientia Horticulturae, 6, 45–53. YAMAKI S, KAJIURA I and KAKIUCHI N (1979a) Changes in sugars and their related enzymes during development and ripening of Japanese pear fruit, Bull Fruit Tree Res Stn, A6, 15–26. YAMAKI S, MACHIDA Y and KAKIUCHI N (1979b) Changes in cell wall polysaccharides and their monosaccharides during development and ripening of Japanese pear fruit, Plant & Cell Physiol, 20, 311–21. YU L, REITMEIER C A and LOVE M H (1996) Strawberry texture and pectin content as affected by electron beam irradiation, J Food Sci, 61(4), 844–6. F
and
ZIEGLER H
SUGIYAMA J
12 Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables: the role of oxidising enzymes H. J. Wichers and C. Boeriu, Agrotechnology and Food Innovations, The Netherlands
12.1 Introduction: distribution of polyphenoloxidases (PPOs) and peroxidases (PODs) in plants and plant cells Polyphenol oxidases (PPOs) comprise an enzyme family that is composed of the copper-containing tyrosinases (EC 1.14.18.1) and laccases (EC 1.10.3.2). The denomination polyphenol oxidase resp. tyrosinase is sometimes used to indicate the same type of enzymes; polyphenol oxidase is seldom used to indicate a laccase. In the context of this chapter, when we discuss PPOs, we are referring to the tyrosinases, a group of enzymes that bears structural similarities to the oxygen-transporting hemocyanins from molluscs and arthropods (Decker and Tuczek, 2000; Fujimoto et al., 1995). PPOs are copper-containing enzymes that are ubiquitous in nature. PPOs, meaning tyrosinases, have been found to occur in mammals, many plant species, fungi, insects, molluscs, and arthropods as well as in bacteria (Andersen et al., 1992; Van Gelder et al., 1997). Also, for many PPOs, nucleotide sequences have been described, and analyses on their genetic relationships have been initiated (Wichers et al., 2003). In many organisms, PPOs occur in either latent or active forms that are sometimes mutually convertible (Van Leeuwen and Wichers, 1999). Peroxidases (donor: hydrogen peroxide oxidoreductase, EC 1.11.1.X, where X indicates the specific peroxidase) are enzymes that use hydrogen peroxide to catalyse the oxidation of a wide range of organic and inorganic compounds. Peroxidases (PODs) are widely distributed in nature and are expressed by both prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells. Peroxidases from higher plants, mammals, fungi and bacteria have been isolated and characterised. Most peroxidases contain the iron porphyrin (haem) as prosthetic group, but
296
Texture in food
peroxidases with other prosthetic groups such as metal ions (e.g. vanadate, selenium) or flavin have been characterised. Bacterial, non-metal peroxidases which require acetate or propionate buffer for activity have also been reported (Wolfframm et al., 1993; Hofmann et al., 1998). Plant peroxidases (PODs, EC1.1.1.7) belong to the class III peroxidases of the superfamily of plant, fungal and bacterial peroxidases, according to the classification of Welinder (Welinder, 1992). In plants, peroxidases exist in groups of discrete molecular isoforms, the isoperoxidases, that show different electrophoretic patterns and stability (McLellan and Robinson, 1984, 1987 a, b; Moulding et al., 1987; 1989; Ros Barcelo et al., 1987; Boucoiran et al., 2000; Forsyth et al., 1999). For example, horseradish peroxidase (HRP) shows 14 isoenzymes (three acidic, five neutral and six basic), of which the isoenzyme C (HRP-C) is the most abundant (Dunford, 1991a,b). Based on their isoelectric points, isoperoxidases have been classified into acidic, neutral and basic peroxidases. The acidic (anionic) isoperoxidases have isoelectric points in the pH range between 3.5 and 6, while basic (cationic peroxidases) have isoelectric points in the pH range 8.0–10.0. It has been suggested that small differences in the isoelectric point for a group of isoperoxidases can reflect organ specificity, genetic variation and minor post-synthesis modification (Robinson, 1991). Within one plant family peroxidase isoenzymes may show differences in physicochemical and catalytic activity (Lee et al., 2001; Yoshimura et al., 1998). The isoenzyme pattern depends on the developmental stage of the plant and may be affected by environmental stress (Bricage, 1987; Chang et al., 1983; Penel and Greppin, 1979). Season-related changes of the isoperoxidase pattern have also been reported (Baier et al., 1993). The location, transport and biosynthesis of peroxidases have been examined. The enzymes seem to be located in all parts and organelles of the cell, varying in amount and activity with physiological state. Taking into account the biosynthesis and transport mechanisms, and based on cytochemical studies, it has been claimed that peroxidases are located in the cell walls, intracellular free spaces and vacuoles (Gaspar et al., 1986). Location of individual isoperoxidases in plant cells is, however, not fully elucidated. Peroxidase activity has been found in the cell wall of young tissues and of lignifying parts. Cell wall peroxidases are either free or ionically or covalently bound to the cell wall polymers and wall, respectively. Ionic binding of isoperoxidases to cell wall pectin depends on the presence of calcium and on the degree of esterification of pectin (Penel and Greppin, 1994).
12.2 Biochemical and physiological role of PPOs and PODs It is generally assumed, for plants and fungi, that PPOs play a role in pigmentation and in defence against pathogens. Whereas the participation of PPOs in pigmentation seems obvious, considering their role in melanin formation, it is more difficult to provide direct evidence for their involvement
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables
297
in defence systems. The induction of a specific PPO in the button mushroom in response to microbial challenge, and the simultaneous activation of latent enzyme, is strongly indicative of a defence-related role (Soler-Rivas et al., 1997, 2001). In mammals, PPOs (tyrosinases) are particularly involved in skin and hair pigmentation (Oetting and King, 1992; Tobin and Paus, 2001). In insects, a role is suggested for PPO in cuticle sclerotisation (Andersen et al., 1992). Due to the crosslinking properties of PPOs, it is also possible to envisage a role in the formation of rigid exoskeletons and similar structures. Below, a more extensive survey of the role of PPOs in network formation will be given. In addition to colour formation and crosslinking, PPOs may be involved in taste perception of food products, also because of crosslinking properties: linking of smaller molecules for instance to peptides with a sensory impact may change the taste of a product. The mechanistic aspects of this phenomenon will be discussed in more detail below. Also the nutritional value of food products, in particular their content of nutraceuticals, may be affected by PPO-action, as many compounds with putative antioxidant properties, such as flavonoids, may be utilised by PPOs as substrates (Martinez and Whitaker, 1995; Van Rensburg et al., 2000). Additionally, the action of PPOs may lead to depletion of natural antioxidants such as vitamin C in food products. Vitamin C serves as a shuttle between catechols and quinones that are formed as a result of PPO-action, and is thus consumed in this process (Fig. 12.1; Espin et al., 2000d). Plant PODs exhibit a range of specificities and functionalities and are involved in various physiological processes associated with plant growth, ripening of fruits, defence against pathogens and senescence. For the various physiological processes in which they are implicated, PODs require H2O2. Temporal and spatial co-localisation of hydrogen peroxide and peroxidase in vivo has been demonstrated (Liu et al., 1999). It has been suggested that cell-wall-located PODs play a role both in cell wall formation and in cell wall reinforcement during regular plant growth (Fry, 1986; Fry et al., 2000; Wallace and Fry, 1995; Schopfer, 1996; Obel et al., 2002) and in response to wounding and infection (Graham and Graham, R
R
R PPO
PPO
POD (+H2O2) OH
Pigments
POD OH (+H2O2) OH
O O
Vitamin C, Other antioxidants
Fig. 12.1
Oxidation reactions catalysed by PPO and POD.
298
Texture in food
1991; Ketsa and Atantee, 1998; Ikegawa et al., 1996; Chen et al., 2001). Peroxidases are responsible for several biochemical processes related to cell wall formation and strengthening: (1) the H2O2-mediated crosslinking of phenolic moieties of cell wall polysaccharides and glycoproteins; (2) lignin biosynthesis; (3) generation of free hydroxyl radical. The significance of these biochemical processes catalysed by PODs is detailed below. Peroxidases have been shown to catalyse the formation of diferulic acid crosslinks between cell wall polysacharides (e.g. hemicellulose and pectins) in the non-lignified actively growing primary wall. Crosslinking of wall polysaccharides decreases the wall extensibility and enzymatic degradability (Fry, 1986; Fry et al., 2000; Wallace and Fry, 1995; Schopfer, 1996; Ng et al., 1998; Waldron et al., 1997a; Wende et al., 2000). Recent work on grass cell wall has shown that, during lignification, PODs can mediate the oxidative coupling between lignin units and ferulate esters thus anchoring lignins to polysaccharides and further strengthening the cell wall (Jacquet et al., 1995; Lapierre et al., 2001; Grabber et al., 2000). Recently, it has been shown that PODs are also able to degrade cell wall ˙ polysaccharides via generation of highly reactive hydroxyl radicals (HO), and thus they can play an important role in the cell growth caused by wall loosening (Schweikert et al., 2000, 2002). It has been reported that PODs are responsible for the rapid crosslinking of cell wall glycoproteins, such as extensin, through oxidative coupling of tyrosine residues and formation of iso-dityrosine (IDT) bridges, as response to elicitor infection (Waffenschmidt et al., 1993; Fry, 1982). Besides IDT, the trimeric and tetrameric tyrosine derivatives, di-IDT and pulcherosine may form intra-polipeptide loops and inter-peptide bridges (Brady et al., 1998). Structural proteins like collagen and many non-structural proteins have been crosslinked by the action of POD and H2O2 in vitro. Extensin crosslinking might enhance cell adhesion and confer rigidity to cell walls thus preventing wall penetration by pathogens. It has been proposed that PODs are involved in the dehydrogenative polymerisation of monolignols into lignins (Lagrimini et al., 1987; Nose et al., 1995). Lignin is an abundant heterogeneous phenolic polymer which forms a three-dimensional network in plant cell walls, and thus contributes to the mechanical strength of the cells. Among the many PODs expressed in plants, no studies have shown a particular isozyme to be specifically involved in lignin formation. Although it has been shown that lignification is always accompanied by an increased activity of most anionic isoperoxidases, the significance of the many PODs isozymes remains unclear. Based on in vitro studies, it was hypothesised that lignin formation occurs via the randomcoupling of monolignol radicals. Recently, it has been shown that a dirigent protein assists POD in the lignification process and is responsible for controlling
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables
299
the regio- and stereo-selectivity of the phenoxy free radical coupling (Davin and Lewis, 1997; Gang et al., 1999). It is also suggested that a family of dirigent proteins exits and that each member stipulates a distinct coupling mode of monolignol radicals. In potato tubers, an anionic POD has been associated with the oxidative coupling of hydroxycinnamates into the lignin-like polyphenolic domain of suberin (Bernards et al., 1999; Bernards and Razem, 2001). Suberin provides a physical barrier to moisture loss and forms a defensive shield against pathogens. The role of PODs in the defence against stress and pathogens has been clearly substantiated. It has been shown that a subfamily of apoplastic PODs are able to produce hydrogen peroxide through compound III during oxidative burst (Blee et al., 2001; Bolwell, 1999), while other PODs are involved in the removal of H2O2 and cell wall reinforcement through oxidative crosslinking (Bradley et al., 1992) and insolubilisation of hydroxyproline-rich proteins (Otte and Barz, 1996). Besides their role in cell wall formation, PODs are also involved in regulation of the in vivo concentration of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), a plant phytohormone that retards fruit ripening (Reinecke and Bandurski, 1988). It has been shown that plant PODs are highly specific IAA oxygenases, which oxidise IAA both in the absence and presence of H2O2 (see Section 12.4.2). In post-harvest fruits and vegetables, PODs may be responsible for deterioration of flavour, colour and nutritional value. Loss of vitamin C is related to ascorbic acid peroxidase, but it can also be linked to the cooxidation of ascorbic acid with phenoxyl radicals generated by peroxidase (Galati et al., 2002). Also, the concentration of dietary flavonoids and polyphenols can be lowered as a result of POD activity, since most of these compounds are substrates for PODs. Relationships between POD activity and off-flavour development due to oxidation of lipids and phenolic constituents have been established (Wagenknecht and Lee, 1958; Sessa and Anderson, 1981). Peroxidase activity also results in deterioration of colour due to pigment decay and associated browning reaction. Complementary localisation pattern and synergistic role of PODs and polyphenol oxidases in browning reactions has been suggested (Lopez-Serrano and Barcelo, 2001). Recently, it has been shown that in the vacuoles of Vicia faba, POD can catalyse the formation of melanin-like compounds by oxidation of dihydroxyphenylalanine (DOPA) and that this process is enhanced by cinnamic acid derivatives (Takahama, 1997). Involvement of PODs in chlorophyll degradation during leaf senescence and yellowing of fruit and vegetables has been also suggested (Funamoto et al., 2002). Peroxidase-mediated chlorophyll degradation requires both hydrogen peroxide and a monophenol. It has been suggested that peroxidative-chlorophyll degradation may be a naturally occurring breakdown process as both POD and phenols required for the process are formed within the chloroplasts.
300
Texture in food
12.3 PPOs and PODs: structure and mechanisms of action 12.3.1 Molecular structure of PPOs and PODs Homology between various PPOs was shown in a phylogenetic tree that was constructed for 35 PPO sequences from the EMBL and NCBI databases (Wichers et al., 2003). This phylogenetic tree was based on partial sequences, which included the central catalytic domains, flanked by the copper binding domains as defined by Van Gelder et al., (1997). Phylogenetic analysis showed that PPOs clustered in groups for higher plants, vertebrate animals, fungi and bacteria. Homologies within such clusters were considerably higher than between them. The most strongly conserved regions are the copper binding domains (Van Gelder et al., 1997; Wichers et al., 2003). On the basis of sequence analysis and structure similarity, it has been shown that PODs from plants, fungi and bacteria are structurally related and belong to the plant POD superfamily (Welinder et al., 1992). Haem-peroxidases of animal origin such as eosinophil, tyrosyl, lacto- and myelo-peroxidases constitute a separate superfamily (animal POD superfamily) unrelated in structure to the plant superfamily. Haloperoxidases, which catalyse the oxidation of halides by H2O2 resulting in the halogenation of organic compounds, form an apart group of PODs. They may contain haem, vanadium or no heterogroup at the redox active centre, and they show little sequence homology among them or with other known peroxidases (Butler, 1998; Conesa et al., 2002). The superfamily of plant, fungal and bacterial PODs contains three evolutionary lineages. Class I comprises intra-cellular PODs, including cytochrome C peroxidase (CcP), the cytosolic ascorbate peroxidase (APX) and the bacterial and fungal catalase-peroxidase. Class II contains the secretory fungal enzymes, like manganese peroxidase and lignin peroxidase (LiP). Class III consists of the secretory higher plant PODs, of which the horseradish peroxidase (HRP) is the most studied. Structural patterns conserved in the evolution of the plant POD superfamily have been identified, based on available sequences and crystallographic models (Welinder et al., 1992). Iron coordination and most of the residues in the active site are conserved in the PODs sequenced up to now. In the past decade, comprehensive and detailed analysis of the plant, fungal and bacterial genomes for peroxide-degrading enzymes have been reported (Zamocky et al., 2000; Regelsberger et al., 2002; Tognolli et al., 2002). The crystal structures of 12 haemperoxidases have been reported, including PODs from soybean (Henriksen et al., 2001), barley grain (Henriksen et al., 1998), horseradish (Gajhede et al., 1997), peanut (Schuller et al., 1996), arabidopsis (Ostergaard et al., 2000; Mirza et al., 2000) and ascorbate peroxidase from pea (Pisum sativum), (Patterson and Poulos, 1995). All plant PODs contain iron protoporphyrin IX as prosthetic group, generally coordinated by a histidine as proximal ligand, and have conserved arginine and histidine residues on the distal haem-binding site. They have two conserved calcium ions, an N-terminal signal peptide and four-conserved disulphide
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables
301
bridges. Plant PODs are glycosylated, but the amount of glycosyl residues varies for each particular enzyme family: eight asparagine glycosylation sites have been reported for horseradish peroxidase (Welinder, 1985), while the turnip TP7 possesses only one site and tobacco anionic isoperoxidases has four potential asparagine-linked glycosylation sites (Lagrimini et al., 1987). The carbohydrate residues are glycans with mannose and glucosamines as the predominant sugars. It has been shown that glycosylation increases the kinetic stability of peroxidases (Tams and Welinder, 1998).
12.3.2 Mechanism of reactions catalysed by PPOs and peroxidases PPOs (tyrosinases) are able to catalyse the ortho-hydroxylation of phenolic moieties into the corresponding catechols, and the subsequent oxidation of these catechols into the corresponding quinones (Fig. 12.1). After the formation of quinones, subsequent reaction is possible if a nucleophilic moiety, potentially intramolecularly, is present (Fig. 12.2). This nucleophilic moiety does not necessarily have to be present intramolecularly, which offers the mechanistic basis for the involvement of PPOs and PODs in a variety of cross-linking reactions, as will be discussed in more detail below (Section 12.4.1). Considerable research efforts have been invested in the Cu-chemistry of PPOs (tyrosinases and catecholoxidases) (Decker et al., 2000; Eicken et al., 1999; García-Borrón and Solano, 2002; Lind et al., 1999) and the co-ordination of copper in PPOs (Klabunde et al., 1998; Lind et al., 1999). The reader is referred to these references for further reading, as well as for further information, i.e. the relationship between PPOs and hemocyanins (Van Gelder et al., 1997; Decker and Tuczek, 2000). For the mono-phenolase activity, there appears to exist a positive relationship between electron density of hydroxyl-carrying carbon atoms in phenolic side chains and Vmax values for such substrates (Espin et al., 2000a,b). Plant PODs catalyse various reactions such as oxidative dehydrogenation, halogenation, oxygen transfer and hydrogen peroxide cleavage. Oxidative CH2
COOH
HO
NH2
HO
O O
Fig. 12.2
CH
CH2
CH2
NH2
HO
CH :NH2
COOH
COOH
CH
HO HO
COOH N H
H
Spontaneous cyclisation reaction following oxidation of phenolic substrates by PPO. Example for tyrosine-oxidation sequence.
302
Texture in food
dehydrogenation is the main reaction of PODs and it consists of the conversion of hydrogen peroxide to water in the presence of a wide range of compounds like phenols, arylamines, halides and thiols as hydrogen donor (Krylov and Dunford, 1996). Besides hydrogen peroxide, other organic hydroperoxides, peracids or inorganic oxides such as periodate can serve as electron donor. The reaction (Fig. 12.3a, pathways 1–3) is a three-step cyclic reaction in which the inactive ferric resting enzyme is first oxidised by H2O2 to an oxyferryl-porphyrin cation radical (compound I) and then reduced in two one-electron transfer steps by the reducing substrates, with formation of an intermediate oxyferryl porphyrin (compound II). The radicals generated in the reaction, i.e. the phenolic radicals, can polymerise, with the final product depending on the chemical character of the radical and the environment. In the absence of reducing substrates or when exposed to high concentration of hydrogen peroxide, POD is inactivated (Fig. 12.3b). Hydrogen peroxide is a suicide substrate that converts compound II to a highly reactive peroxyiron(III) porphyrin free radical (compound III) which is further oxidised by hydrogen peroxide or other oxidative species resulting in haem destruction and irreversible enzyme inactivation (Valderrama et al., 2002 and references therein). It has been shown that HRP isoenzymes behave differently during peroxide inactivation, basic isoenzymes being more susceptible to peroxide inactivation than acidic ones (Hiner et al., 1996). The key step in the enzymatic cycle of haem PODs is the formation of the catalytically active compound I by reaction of peroxide with the resting ferric form of the enzyme. Following elucidation of X-ray structures of CcP and HRP-C, a detailed mechanism has been proposed for the formation of compound I in these enzymes, which confirms the original acid-base mechanism proposed by Poulos and Kraut in 1980. This mechanism involves binding of peroxide to the haem iron of the ferric resting enzyme species with concomitant donation of a proton to the distal histidine from the αoxygen atom (Hiner et al., 2002). The positively charged guanidinium side chain of distal arginine stabilises the negative charge on the β-oxygen atom. Heterolytic cleavage of the O–O bond and the formation of H2O and compound I results from a general acid-base catalysis mediated by distal histidine (Hiner et al., 2002). Site-directed mutagenesis studies have been used to establish the mechanism of compound I formation and to elucidate the role of other residues in the distal haem pocket in compound I formation at molecular level (Gajhede, 2001; Smith and Veitch, 1998; Filizola and Loew, 2000; Tanaka et al., 1997). The reader is referred to these references and to recent monographs (Dunford, 1999) and reviews (Hiner et al., 2002; Valderrama et al., 2002) for further reading. Besides the oxidative dehydrogenation reaction discussed above, plant PODs can catalyse a variety of related reactions such as oxygen transfer (pathways 4 and 5, Fig. 12.3a) (Dordick et al., 1986; van Rantwijk and Sheldon, 2000). It has been reported that HRP can catalyse the hydroxylation of a range of aromatic compounds including tyrosine, phenylalanine and p-coumaric acid
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables
303
X– (6)
P-Fe(III)OX Compound X (7)
R•
+ RH + H+ P-Fe(IV)= O Compound II
(8)
RH (2)
RX+H2O (9)
(1)
(3)
RX + H2O
H2O
(4)
(10)
RH
+ RH+H
RH
H2O2 –
P-Fe(IV) = O• Compound I
OX
H2O2
R• + H2O
H2O + O2 (5)
P-Fe(III) Native POX
R• P-Fe(IV)OH
ROH (a) Haem destruction/release H2O2
(2)
H2O
+
RH
•
P-Fe(IV)=O Compound II
P-Fe(III)- OOH Compound III
R• + H2O2 P–Fe(III) Protein oxidation
(3)
(1) (4) Protein oxidation
•
•
OH
OOH
P-Fe(III)
(b)
Fig. 12.3 (a) Reactions catalysed by peroxidases (adapted from Valderrama et al., 2002); (b) inactivation of peroxidase by hydrogen peroxide (adapted from Valderrama et al., 2002).
in the presence of reducing equivalents of dihydroxyfumaric acid (DHF) and oxygen. NADH, pyridoxal compounds, thiols and indoleacetic acid can act as reducing agents. Dordick et al. (1986) showed that compound III is the key intermediate in this process. In the absence of reducing agents, PODs can show a “catalase” like activity, and decompose H2O2 to oxygen (pathway 10, Fig. 12.3a) (Hiner et al., 2001). Peroxidase-induced generation of hydroxyl radicals from oxygen, in the presence of suitable reductants, such as NADH or dihydroxyfumarate has also been reported (Chen and Schopfer, 1999). Peroxidative halogenation of aromatic compounds (pathways 6–8, Fig. 12.3a) is catalysed by haloperoxidases, but recently it has been shown that plant PODs (e.g. soybean peroxidase) are also able to catalyse bromination and iodination (not chlorination) of phenolic compounds (Munir and Dordick, 2000). A specific reaction catalysed by plant PODs is the oxidation of IAA. The oxidation of IAA proceeds via two different pathways, a conventional H2O2-
304
Texture in food
dependent pathway and one that requires oxygen but not peroxide. It has been shown that only those plant PODs that posses the domains with structural similarities with auxin-binding proteins, such as anionic tobacco peroxidase, HRP-C, cationic peanut peroxidase, soybean peroxidase, are able to oxidise IAA via the H2O2-independent pathway. A model for IAA oxidation catalysed by various states of HRP has been proposed (Kawano et al., 2002).
12.4 PPOs, PODs and texture development 12.4.1 Crosslinking of proteins catalysed by PPO Oxidation of tyrosine residues in proteins or in peptides by PPO leads to the formation of, initially, an L-DOPA-structure in the peptide chain. Subsequent oxidation to the corresponding DOPA-quinone results in the formation of a reactive moiety in the peptide chain that can react with nucleophilic amino acid side chains in adjacent proteins or peptides. Similarly, phenolic or catecholic moieties linked to carbohydrate backbones can be oxidised into quinones. Nucleophilic amino acid side chains may be found in lysine, asparagine, arginine, histidine, methionine, or cystein. An example of the role of PPO as crosslinker of gluten was given by Takasaki and Kawakishi (1997). Based on the reaction mechanism that was proposed by the authors, and taking into account the cyclisation mechanism as depicted in Fig. 12.2, a generic reaction scheme can be postulated for crosslinking of proteins by PPOs or PODs (Fig. 12.4). Also the ortho-positions at the phenolic residues possess a partly positive charge due to resonance structures. The postulated scheme is most likely because it is least subject to steric hindrance. Another example of the protein crosslinking properties of PPOs is the crosslinking of thaumatin molecules (Ramsohoye and Kozlov, 1991). The crosslinking of thaumatin by PPO, and the resulting decrease in sweetness, indicate an important potential role of PPOs in the sensory properties, not only in colour but also in taste, of food products. PPOs may play a role in the perceived taste of various protein and peptide containing food products, such as yeast extracts and bouillons, and PPO may be used as a tool to influence the taste of these products. Mechanistically interesting is the role of PPO in the formation of blue mussel adhesive (Burzio et al., 2000; Fant et al., 2002, Haemers et al., 2002), and in insect cuticle sclerotisation (Andersen et al., 1992).
12.4.2 POD and crosslinking of proteins and polysaccharides (in vitro experiments) In vitro oxidative dehydrogenation reactions catalysed by POD have been used in plant phenolic research as a means to study lignification, crosslinking of cell wall polymers and of proteins and for synthesis of new derivatives with potential industrial applications. Gelling of arabinoxylans, linear polymers
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables H N
C
305
CO
R NH H
C
X
Tyrosine residue CH2
OH
NH H
CH2
C
CO
O
CO
O
PPO, POD
DOPA residue
NH H
C
CH2
CO
H N
OH
C
CO
R
OH
X: PPO, POD
NH H
C CO
Fig. 12.4
+
DOPA quinone residue CH2
O O
NH H
C
CH2
O
CO O
Mechanism for cross-linking of (poly)peptide chains as a consequence of PPO or POD action.
of xylose substituted with arabinose, which carry ferulic acid molecules, and of feruloylated cell wall pectin polymers by peroxidase-mediated oxidative coupling with hydrogen peroxide has been reported. Crosslinking of these carbohydrate polymers occurs via the formation of diferulic acid bridges (Schooneveld-Bergmans et al., 1999; Oosterveld et al., 1997). Several studies have demonstrated that oxidation of tyrosine residues in proteins and peptides induces intra- and inter-molecular protein crosslinking via dityrosine bonds (Gross and Sizer, 1959; Aeshbach et al., 1976). Dityrosines and higher oligomers resulting from peroxidase-mediated conjugation of tyrosine radicals have been characterised for tyrosine-containing peptides (Michon et al., 1997). Involvement of cysteines and lysines in protein crosslinking has also been suggested, based on reduction of the amount of free –SH and –NH2 groups after reaction (Matheis and Whitaker, 1984, 1987). However, since cysteine is oxidised by hydrogen peroxide in model systems (Vinkx et al., 1991) the published data are not convincing. Nevertheless, since during peroxidase-mediated oxidative dehydrogenation of tyrosyl moieties quinone-like structures could be generated, it can be speculated that cysteine
306
Texture in food
and lysine residues may be involved in protein crosslinking via a similar mechanism as described in Fig. 12.4. More research is needed to identify the amino acid residues involved in protein crosslinking and to elucidate the reaction mechanism. In vitro peroxidase-mediated crosslinking of various proteins in the presence of hydrogen peroxide and low molecular weight phenols as hydrogen donors has also been reported (Stahmann et al., 1977; Matheis and Whitaker, 1984; Hurrell et al., 1982; Huizing et al., 1999; Faergemand et al., 1998). In these studies, formation of various oligomers and polymers of proteins has been detected using SDS gel electrophoresis and gel exclusion chromatography. It has been shown that product pattern and protein conversion are determined by the structure of both the protein and phenol substrate and by phenol reactivity (Boeriu et al., unpublished results).
12.4.3 PPO, POD and crosslinking of proteins with polysaccharides; role of endogenous and exogenous phenolics on peroxidase-mediated crosslinking (in vitro experiments) Chen et al. (2002) described the conjugation of gelatine to chitosan catalysed by PPO. Since chitosan (poly N-acetyl glucoseamine) is a polysaccharide that contains nucleophilic amino groups, a similar reaction mechanism as proposed for the crosslinking of proteins may be suggested (Fig. 12.4). The authors described the formation of gel-like structures that differed mechanically from the gels that were obtained by cooling gelatine solutions, and that could be broken down by chitosinase. These mechanistic observations are supported by the work of Lenhart et al. (1998) that describes the PPO-catalysed modification of chitosan by a variety of phenolic compounds such as phenol, catechol, caffeic acid and L-DOPA. The oxidative crosslinking of proteins with carbohydrate polymers containing phenolic residues (e.g. arabinoxylans and pectins) by POD has been suggested (Neukom and Markwalder, 1978; Oosterveld et al., 1997), but only recently confirmed (Oudgenoeg et al., 2000, 2001, 2002). Model studies with a tyrosine containing tripeptide (Gly-Tyr-Gly) and ferulic acid (FA), have shown that kinetically controlled reactions result in the formation of a complex range of isomeric hetero-oligomers of FA linked via oxidative dehydrogenation to the peptidyl tyrosine (Oudgenoeg et al., 2001, 2002). Based on the product pattern obtained, the authors suggest that oligomerisation is governed by radical chemistry. Two mechanisms for the formation of the ferulic acidtyrosine oligomers have been proposed that explain the concentration-dependent behaviour of FA, and their possible role in the regulation of plant cell wall tissue growth has been postulated (Oudgenoeg et al., 2002). Furthermore, βcasein and α-lactalbumin have been crosslinked with arabinoxylans containing ferulic acid residues in the presence of HRP and hydrogen peroxide (Oudgenoeg et al., 2000). Protein-arabinoxylan heteroconjugates containing up to 10% protein and 90% carbohydrate have been isolated and characterised.
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables
307
12.5 Controlling PPO and POD activity A number of technological approaches can be considered to control the activity of PPOs and PODs during the food manufacturing process.
12.5.1 Genetic modification of raw material First of all, manipulating the raw materials may control enzyme activity. Examples for this can be found in for instance the development of a potato variety in which PPO was knocked out via antisense technology (Zabeau et al., 1994), and in button mushroom that was transformed with antisense PPO-constructs (Stoop and Mooibroek, 1999).
12.5.2 Modification of PPO-activity via processing Additionally, many options are available via processing to manipulate PPOactivity, and thus its impact on sensory properties. Both physicochemical as well as biochemical approaches are feasible in this respect. It should be thoroughly understood that PPOs usually occur initially in latent forms that may be activated via a variety of mechanisms (Espín et al., 2000c). Some of the physicochemical parameters that affect PPO-activity are outlined below. Ionic strength in the microenvironment of PPO A latent mushroom preparation can be activated when the ionic strength of the buffer is decreased, for instance through dialysis (Fig. 12.5). Decrease of ionic strength stabilises intra-molecular ionic interactions, which may, therefore, be postulated to play a role in this activation process. Other factors that 70
Percent active PPO
60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0.01
Fig. 12.5
0.1
1 10 Phosphate (mM)
100
Activation of PPO through decrease of ionic strength.
308
Texture in food
possibly interfere with intra-molecular ionic interactions in relation to PPOactivity are for instance polyamines that bear multiple positive charges (JimenezAtienzar et al., 1991) or poly-negatively charged polyglucans (Jimenez and Garcia-Carmona, 1993), that are able to activate latent grape PPO. In addition, the pH in the micro-environment of PPO determines the activity of PPO. A decrease of the pH from 6.5 to 4.5, via dialysis, considerably activates latent mushroom PPO, measured against a non-dialysed control (Fig. 12.6). Kenten (1957) and Ichishima et al. (1984) described a similar activation for resp. broad bean and Aspergillus-tyrosinase. The latter also postulated the attachment of a protease to the latent PPO at low pH (see below for proteolytic activation of PPO). Pressure Pear-PPO can be activated at pressures of 400 MPa, highest activity being reached at 600 MPa (Asaka and Hayashi, 1991; Asaka et al., 1994). Temperature Mushroom PPO becomes activated before being thermally inactivated during heating of mushrooms (Wichers, unpublished). Viscosity and water activity A decreased PPO-activity with increased viscosity is claimed by some (Gama Terrazas et al., 1990), but questioned by others (Manzocco et al., 1998). Water activity is also claimed to decrease PPO-activity (Gama Terrazas et al., 1990), which may be consistent with the author’s observations (Fig. 12.5). 100
Degree of activation (%)
80
60
40
20
0 0
Fig. 12.6
5 Time (min)
10
Activation of PPO via pH-decrease. 䊊: control; ⵧ: phosphate pH 6.5; ∆: citrate, pH 4.5.
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables
309
Hydrophobic compounds The activation of latent PPO by hydrophobic or surface active compounds, such as various detergents, has been well documented for various PPOs (Asada et al., 1993; Escribano et al., 1997; Espín et al., 1999; Espín and Wichers, 1999a,b; Moore and Flurkey, 1990, Yamaguchi et al., 1970). Not only physiologically non-occurring and food-technologically unacceptable compounds such as detergents like SDS, but also endogenously occurring and sensorily valuable hydrophobic flavour compounds such benzyl alcohol (Espín and Wichers, 1999a) or 1-octen-3-ol (Espín and Wichers, unpublished observations) are able to activate latent mushroom PPO. All these physicochemical treatments have in common that they can be considered as leading to partial destabilisation or denaturation of proteins, in this case latent PPO, which may result in activation because the active site becomes more exposed or more readily accessible for substrates. Such hypothesis is in line with the proposed activation mechanism for mushroom PPO as formulated by Espín et al. (1999). Proteolytic activation of PPO The activation of latent PPOs from various organisms by proteases is well documented. Apple (Espín et al., 1995 a,b), pear (Espín et al., 1996), Drosophila (Chosa et al., 1997), broad bean (King and Flurkey, 1987; Robinson and Dry, 1992), frog epidermis (Galindo et al., 1983), mushroom PPO (Espín et al., 1999; Yamaguchi et al., 1970, Fig. 12.7), amongst many others, are proven susceptible to proteolytic activation. Also, a solid mathematical and theoretical description for such process has been published (Vazquez et al., 1993). Figure 12.7 shows that the degree of proteolytic activation depends on the specificity of the combination of protease and PPO, an observation that may
Degree of activation (%)
20
15
10
5
0 0
30
60
90 120 Time (min)
150
180
Fig. 12.7 Activation of latent mushroom PPO by various proteases. 䊊: subtilisin; ⵧ: clostripain; ∆: trypsin.
310
Texture in food
be useful for control of the activation process that may partly be tuned by a proper choice of enzymes. It may be anticipated that proteolysis leads to the removal of a part of the peptide chain, resulting either in conformational change or, directly, in improved accessibility of the active site (Espín et al., 1999). Proteolytic activation is obviously an irreversible process, but may be used, provided the treatment can be controlled sufficiently, to confer desired sensory properties to food products.
12.5.3 Modification of PODs activity via processing Thermal inactivation of PODs during heat treatment of fruit and vegetables has been thoroughly investigated, since the action of these enzymes may cause adverse changes of colour and flavours during food preservation. Moreover, PODs are generally used as indicator enzyme to assess the effectiveness of heat treatment. Thermal inactivation and regeneration of POD activity depends on several factors, such as temperature and time of treatment, pH value and ionic strength (Kermasha et al., 1988; Stolle-Smits et al., 2000; Lemos et al., 2000). It has been shown that most plant PODs have a maximum thermal stability at neutral pH values and are more susceptible to heat inactivation at extreme pH values (Lemos et al., 2000). The authors have suggested that the effect of pH on thermal stability of PODs is due to the equilibrium between several pH-dependent processes involved, such as (1) dissociation of haem from the holoenzyme, (2) conformation changes in the apoprotein and (3) modification or degradation of prosthetic group. Irreversible changes in the apoprotein at acidic pH and denaturation of haem at alkaline pH values (pH = 11 or higher) are responsible for irreversible inactivation of peroxidases. Thermal inactivation of PODs during the short time heating specific for blanching process shows non-linear kinetics (Adams, 1978; Ling and Lund, 1978; McLellan and Robinson, 1984; Moulding et al., 1987; Robinson et al., 1989; Khan and Robinson, 1993). Deviation from linear first-order kinetics has been related to (1) the presence of heat-resistant and heat-labile isoenzymes for crude enzyme preparates (Ling and Lund, 1978), (2) formation of thermostable enzyme aggregates (Lopez et al., 1994), and (3) conformation and chemical changes of protein accompanied by haem dissociation (Adams, 1997). Recent work has shown that purified anionic and cationic isoperoxidases differ significantly in thermal stability and in the ability to regenerate activity after heat inactivation (Forsyth et al., 1999; Boucoiran et al., 2000). A particular property of PODs is regeneration of activity after thermal denaturation, which is pH dependent (see discussion above). Recovery of POD activity has been observed over a period of a few hours after heat treatment of both test enzyme solutions and whole vegetables. Difference in the ability to regenerate activity after thermal inactivation has been observed between isoenzymes and between various PODs. Regeneration of POD activity after thermal inactivation has been associated with recombination of haem with
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables
311
apoprotein and with regain of protein conformation (Adams et al., 1996; Forsyth et al., 1999). Peroxidase activity is not significantly affected by high pressure (Krebbers et al., 2002). However, a combined effect of heat, ultrasonic waves and pressure on POD activity has been reported. A synergistic effect, which can substantially reduce enzyme resistance to heat treatment, has been observed (Lopez et al., 1994).
12.6 PPOs and PODs: implications for food texture The exact role of PPOs and PODs in determining texture of fruits and vegetables via their possible involvement in the formation of cell walls in food crops is sometimes hard to assess. An exact evaluation requires the study of the function of single parameters (the enzymes under study) in complex systems with interdependent parameters that affect the eventual outcome, i.e. texture. Yet, the work of Brett et al. (1999) suggests a direct relation between cell growth, cell wall expansion, and oxidative coupling of hydroxycinnamate derivatives in the cell walls to polymers, inducing network and texture formation. It has also been reported that ferulic-acid crosslinks between cell wall polysaccharides increase the thermal stability of cell–cell adhesion and consequently the textural strength of processed vegetables (Parker and Waldron, 1995; Waldron et al., 1997a, b; Ng et al., 1998). High levels of peroxidase activity have been associated with increased firmness of thermally processed green beans, but no information is available about the underlying mechanisms (Stolle-Smits et al., 2000). In processing, however, a variety of options to affect texture is offered by better control of the activity of oxidative enzyme systems such as PPO and POD during processing. A mechanistic basis is provided, that does not differ essentially from the mechanism by which PPOs and PODs may be involved in colour, in particular melanin, formation (Fig. 12.4). A variety of options exists to control PPO-activity during processing. This area has received little attention thus far, which is perhaps not surprising because of the much more prominent role of oxidative enzyme systems in colour of food products. However, research into improved process control of enzymatically catalysed oxidative reactions will offer a plethora of possibilities to fine-tune eventual texture of processed foods, and to develop novel texturedetermining food ingredients based on carbohydrate and peptides or proteins as starting materials.
12.7 Future trends Further research into the option of using natural products or properties such as (endogenous) enzymes would fit extremely well into a trend to decrease
312
Texture in food
the use of additives to optimise sensory food quality. A better understanding of the role of oxidative enzyme systems in product texture, but also in other sensory properties such as flavour and colour, would offer various openings to further decrease the use of ingredients. For instance, crops with desirable intrinsic properties could be developed, in particular against the rapidly expanding knowledge in the X-omics area. Enhancement of textural quality of fruits and vegetables by modulating the nature, the location and the degree of phenolic crosslinking in the cell walls is an area of potential interest. Waldron (Waldron et al., 1997b) has suggested the potential for exploiting metabolic pathways that are associated with the response to infection to improve textural characteristics, pest resistance, nutritional quality and sensory (e.g. colour and flavour) properties of crops. The growing market for replacement of animal proteins offers a further market perspective for enzymatic texturisation, including the potential use of oxidative enzyme systems. The need to develop products with a suitable texture is holding up consumer acceptance and market introduction. It seems worth investigating the feasibility of oxidative enzyme systems for such applications, as they may result in textures that could differ subtly from those that can be obtained via other enzymatic crosslinkers such as transglutaminase or via physical processes such as extrusion.
12.8 Sources of further information For further reading on the physical and chemical aspects of texture, the reader is referred to the references in the bibliography that are marked with an asterisk.
12.9
References
(1978) The inactivation and regeneration of peroxidase in relation to the high temperature-short time processing of vegetables, J Food technol, 13, 281–97. ADAMS J B (1997) Electrospray mass spectrometric study of haem changes during peroxidase denaturation, Food Chemistry, 58, 173–5. ADAMS J B, HARVEY A and DEMPSEY C E (1996) Regenerated and denaturated peroxidase as potential lipid oxidation catalysts, Food Chemistry, 57, 505–14. *AESCHBACH R, AMADO R and NEUKOM H (1976) Formation of dityrosine crosslinks in proteins by oxidation of tyrosine residues, Biochim Biophys Acta, 439, 292–301. *ANDERSEN S O, PETER M G and ROEPSTORFF P (1992) Cuticle-catalyzed coupling between Nacetylhistidine and N-acetyldopamine, Insect Biochem Mol Biol, 22, 459–69. ASADA N, FUKUMITSU T, FUJIMOTO K and MASUDA K-I (1993) Activation of prophenoloxidase with 2-propanol and other organic compounds in Drosophila melanogaster, Insect Biochem Mol Biol, 23, 515–20. ASAKA M and HAYASHI R (1991) Activation of polyphenoloxidase in pear fruits by high pressure treatment, Agric Biol Chem, 55, 2439–40. ADAMS J B
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables ASAKA M, AOYAMA Y, NAKANISHI R
313
and HAYASHI R (1994) Purification of a latent form of polyphenoloxidase from La France pear fruit and its pressure activation, Biosci Biotech Biochem, 58, 1486–9. BAIER M, GOLDBERG R, CATESSON A M, FRANCESCH C and ROLAND C (1993) Seasonal changes of isoperoxidases from poplar bark tissue, Phytochemistry, 32(4), 789–93. BERNARDS M A and RAZEM F A (2001) The polyphenolic domain of potato suberin: a nonlignin cell wall bio-polymer, Phytochemistry, 57, 1115–22. BERNARDS M A, FLEMING W D, LLWELLYN D B, PRIEFER R, YANG X L, SABATINO A and PLOURDE G L (1999) Biochemical characterization of the suberization-associated anionic peroxidase of potato, Plant Physiol, 121, 135–46. BLEE K A, JUPE S C, RICHARD A, DAVIES D R and BOLWELL G P (2001) Molecular identification and expression of the peroxidase responsible for the oxidative burst in French bean (Phaseouls vulgaris L.) and related members of the gene family, Plant Mol Biol, 47, 607–20. BOERIU C G (1998) Peroxidase-mediated cross-linking of proteins to induce new functional properties, 1st International Symposium on Enzymatic Protein Processing, 2–4 Dec, Noordwijkerhout, The Netherlands. BOLWELL G P (1999) Role of active oxygen species and NO in plant defence responses, Curr Opin Plant Biol, 2, 287–94. BOUCOIRAN C F S, KIJNE J W and RECOURT J (2000) Isolation and partial characterization of thermostable isoperoxidases from potato (Solanum Tuberosum L.) tuber sprouts, J Agric Food Chem, 48(3), 701–7. BRADLEY D, KJELBOM P and LAMB C (1992) Elicitor- and wound-induced oxidative crosslinking of a proline-rich plant cell wall structural protein: a novel, rapid plant defence response, Cell, 70, 21–30. BRADY J D, SADLER J H and FRY S C (1998) Pulcherosine, an oxidative coupled trimer of tyrosine in plant cell walls: its role in cross-link formation, Phytochemistry, 47, 349– 53. BRETT C T, WENDE G, SMITH A C and WALDRON K W (1999) Biosynthesis of cell-wall ferulate and diferulates, J Sci Food Agric, 79, 421–4. BRICAGE P (1987) The isoperoxidase pattern changes and the pigment changes of pedilanthus tithymaloides L. Variegatus calli as a result of sucrose concentration and phytoregulator content of the culture medium and daily temperature differences, Plant Science, 55(2), 169–73. *BURZIO L A, BURZIO V A, PARDO J and BURZIO L O (2000) In vitro polymerization of mussel polyphenolic proteins catalyzed by mushroom tyrosinase, Comp Biochem Physiol, 126, 383–9. BUTLER A (1998) Vanadium peroxidases, Curr Opin Chem Biol, 2, 279–85. CHANG H, SIEGEL B Z and SIEGEL S M (1983) Salinity-induced changes in isoperoxidases in taro Colocasia esculenta, Phytochemistry, 23(2), 233–5. *CHEN S X and SCHOPFER P (1999) Hydroxyl-radical production in physiological reactions. A novel function of peroxidases, European J Biochem, 260, 726–35. *CHEN T, EMBREE H D, WU L, PAYNE G F (2002) In vitro protein-polysaccharide conjugation: tyrosinase-catalyzed conjugation of gelatin and chitosan, Biopolymers, 64, 292–302. CHEN C, BELANGER R B, BENHAMOU N and PAULITZ T C (2001) Defense enzymes induced in cucumber roots by treatment with plant promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR) and Phythium aphanidermatum, Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology, 56, 13–23. CHOSA N, FUKUMITSU T, FUJIMOTO K and OHNISHI E (1997) Activation of prophenoloxidase A1 by an activating enzyme in Drosophila melanogaster, Insect Biochem Mol Biol, 27, 61–8. CONESA A, PUNT P J and VAN DEN HONDEL C A M J J (2002) Fungal peroxidases: molecular aspects and applications, J Biotechnol, 93, 143–58. *DAVIN L B and LEWIS N G (1997) Stereoselective bimolecular phenoxy radical coupling by an auxiliary (dirigent) protein without an active center, Science, 275, 362–6.
314
Texture in food
DECKER H and TUCZEK F (2000) Tyrosinase/catecholoxidase activity of hemocyanins: structural
basis and molecular mechanism, Trends Biol Sci, 25, 392–7. *DECKER H, DILLINGER R and TUCZEK F (2000) How does tyrosinase work? Recent insights from model chemistry and structural biology, Angew Chem, 39, 1591–5. DORDICK J S, KLIBANOV A M and MARLETTA M A (1986) Horseradish peroxidase catalyzed hydroxylations: mechanistic studies, Biochemistry, 25, 2946–51. DUNFORD H B (1991a) Heme peroxidase nomenclature, Plant Peroxidase Newsletter, 13, 65–71. DUNFORD H B (1991b) Horseradish peroxidase: structure and kinetic properties. In Peroxidases in Chemistry and Biology, vol. 2. Eds J E Everse, K E Everse and M B Grisham, Boca Raton, Fl, CRC Press, 1–24. *DUNFORD H B (1999) Heme Peroxidases, New York, John Wiley and Sons. *EICKEN C, KREBS B and SACCHETTTINI J C (1999) Catechol oxidase-structure and activity, Curr Opin Struc Biol, 9, 677–83. ESCRIBANO J, CABANES J and GARCÍA-CARMONA F (1997) Characterisation of latent polyphenol oxidase in table beet: effect of sodium dodecyl sulfate, J Sci Food Agric, 73, 34–8. ESPÍN J C, MORALES M, VARÓN R, TUDELA J and GARCÍA-CÁNOVAS F (1995a) A continuous spectrophotometric method for determining the monophenolase and diphenolase activities of apple polyphenol oxidase, Anal Biochem, 231, 237–46. ESPÍN J C, MORALES M, VARÓN R, TUDELA J and GARCÍA-CÁNOVAS F (1995b) Monophenolase activity of polyphenol oxidase from Verdedoncella apple, J Agric Food Chem, 43, 2807–12. ESPÍN J C, MORALES M, VARÓN R , TUDELA J and GARCÍA- CÁNOVAS F (1996) Continuous spectrophotometric method for determining the monophenolase and diphenolase activities of pear polyphenol oxidase, J Food Sci, 61, 1177–81. ESPÍN J C, VAN LEEUWEN J and WICHERS H J (1999) Kinetic study of the activation process of a latent mushroom (Agaricus bisporus) tyrosinase by serine proteases, J Agric Food Chem, 47, 3509–17. ESPÍN J C and WICHERS H J (1999a) Kinetics of activation of latent mushroom (Agaricus bisporus) tyrosinase by benzyl alcohol, J Agric Food Chem, 47, 3503–8. ESPÍN J C and WICHERS H J (1999b) Activation of a latent mushroom (Agaricus bisporus) tyrosinase isoform by sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). Kinetic properties of the SDSactivated isoform, J Agric Food Chem, 47, 3518–25. ESPÍN J C, VARÓN R, FENOLL L G, ANGELES GILABERT M, GARCÍA-RUIZ P A, TUDELA J and GARCÍACÁNOVAS F (2000a) Kinetic characterization of the substrate specificity and mechanism of mushroom tyrosinase, Eur J Biochem, 267, 1270–79. ESPÍN J C, SOLER-RIVAS C and WICHERS H J (2000b) The oxidation of 4-hydroxystilbene catalysed by mushroom, pear and grape polyphenol oxidases, Rec Adv Phytochem, 1, 7–18. ESPÍN J C, SOLER-RIVAS C and WICHERS H J (2000c) Maturation and activation of latent tyrosinase from Agaricus bisporus. Mushroom Science, 15, 79–86. In. Science and Cultivation of Edible Fungi: Proceedings of the 15th International Conference, Maastricht, Netherlands, 15–19 May. Ed. Van Griensven, Rotterdam, Balkema. ESPÍN J C, VELTMAN R H and WICHERS H J (2000d) The oxidation of L-ascorbic acid by pear tyrosinase, Physiol Plantarum, 109, 1–6. FAERGEMAND M, OTTE J and QUIST K B (1998) Cross-linking of whey proteins by enzymatic oxidation, J Agric Food Chem, 46, 1326–33. FANT C, ELWING H and HÖÖK F (2002) The influence of cross-linking on protein-protein interactions in a marine adhesive: the case of two byssus plaque proteins from the blue mussel, Biomacromolecules, 3, 732–41. FILIZOLA M and LOEW H G (2000) Role of protein environment in horseradish peroxidase compound I formation: Molecular dynamics simulations of horseradish peroxidaseHOOH complex, J Am Chem Soc, 122, 18–25.
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables FORSYTH J L, OWUSU APENTEN R K
315
and ROBINSON D S (1999) The thermostability of purified isoperoxidases from Brassica oleracea Var. Gemmifera, Food Chemistry, 65(1), 99– 109. FUJIMOTO K, OKINO M, KAWABATA S I, IWANAGA S and OHNISHI E (1995) Nucleotide sequence of the cDNA encoding the proenzyme of phenol oxidase A1 of Drosophila melanogaster, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 92, 7769–73. FUNAMOTO Y, YAMAUCHI N, SHIGENAGA T and SHIGYO M (2002) Effects of heat treatment on chlorophyll degrading enzymes in stored broccoli (Brasica oleracea L.), Postharvest Biol Technol, 24, 163–70. FRY S C (1982) Iso-dityrosine, a new crosslinking amino acid from plant cell-wall glycoprotein, Biochem J, 204, 449–55. FRY S C (1986) Crosslinking of matrix polymers in the growing cell walls of angiosperms, Annual Rev Plant Physiol, 37, 165–86. *FRY S C, WILLIS S C and PATTERSON A J (2000) Intraprotoplasmatic and wall-localised formation of arabinoxylan-bound diferulates and larger ferulate coupling-products in maize cell suspension cultures, Planta, 211, 679–92. *GAJHEDE M (2001) Plant peroxidases: substrate complexes with mechanistic implications, Biochemical Soc Trans, 29, 91–9. *GAJHEDE M, SCHULLER D J, HENRIKSEN A, SMITH A T and POULOS T (1997) Crystal structure of horseradish peroxidase C at 2.15 Å resolution, Nat Struct Biol, 4, 1032–8. GALATI G, SABZEVARI O, WILSON J X and O’BRIEN P J (2002) Prooxidant activity and cellular effects of the phenoxyl radicals of dietary flavonoids and other polyphenolics, Toxicology 177, 91–104. GALINDO J D, PENAFIEL R, VARÓN R, PEDRENO E, GARCÍA-CARMONA F and GARCÍA-CÁNOVAS F (1983) Kinetic study of the activation process of frog epidermis pro-tyrosinase by trypsin, Int J Biochem, 15, 633–7. GAMA TERRAZAS Y, KOZLOV I A and PYLE L D (1990) The effect of increased viscosity and decreased water activity on phenol oxidase. Proceedings 5th European Congress on Biotechnology, July 8–13, Copenhagen, 241. GANG D R, COSTA M A, FUJITO M, DINKOVA-KOSTOVA A T, WANG H B, BURLAT V, MARTIN W, SARKANEN S, DAVIN L B and LEWIS N G (1999) Regiochemical control of monolignol radical coupling: a new paradigm for lignin and lignan biosynthesis, Chem Biol, 6, 143–151. GARCÍA-BORRÓN J C and SOLANO F (2002) Molecular anatomy of tyrosinase and its related proteins: beyond the histidine-bound catalytic center, Pigm Cell Res, 15, 162–73. GASPAR T, PENEL C and GREPPIN H (1986) Peroxidases: structures and catalytic reactions, biosynthesis, transport and locations, physiological roles, Bulletin Liaison – Group Polyphenols, 13, 159–76. *GRABBER J H, RALPH J and HAYFIELD R D (2000) Cross-linking of maize walls by ferulate dimerization and incorporation into lignin, J Agric Food Chem, 48, 6106–13. GRAHAM M Y and GRAHAM T L (1991) Rapid accumulation of anionic peroxidases and phenolic polymers in soybean cotyledon tissues following treatment with Phytophtera megasperma f. sp. glycinea wall glucan, Plant Physiology, 97, 1445–55. GROSS, A J and SIZER I W (1959) The oxidation of tyramine, tyrosine and related compounds by peroxidase, J Biol Chem, 234, 1611–14. HAEMERS S, VAN DER LEEDEN M C, KOPER G J M and FRENS G (2002) Cross-linking and multilayer adsorption of mussel adhesive proteins, Langmuir, 18, 4903–7. *HENRIKSEN A G, WELINDER K and GAJHEDE M (1998) Structure of barley grain peroxidase refined at 1.9 Å resolution. A plant peroxidase irreversibly inactivated at neutral pH, J Biol Chem, 273, 2241–8. *HENRIKSEN A, MIRZA O, INDIANA C, TEILUM K, SMULECVICH G, WELINDER K and GAJHEDE M (2001) Structure of soybean seedcoat peroxidase: a plant peroxidase with unusual stability and haem-apoprotein interactions, Protein Sci, 10, 108–15.
316
Texture in food
HINER A N P, HERNANDEZ-RUIZ J, GARCIA-CANOVAS F
and ACOSTA M (1996) A comparative study of the purity, enzyme activity and inactivation by hydrogen peroxide of commercially available HRP izoenzymes A and C, Biotechnol Bioeng, 50, 655–62. HINER A N P, HERNANDEZ-RUIZ J, WILLIAMS G A, ARNAO M B, GARCIA-CANOVAS F and ACOSTA M (2001) Catalase-like oxygen production by horseradish peroxidase must predominantly be an enzyme-catalyzed reaction, Arch Biochem Biophys, 392, 295–302. *HINER A N P, RAVEN E L, THORNELEY R N F, GARCIA-CANOVAS F and RODRIGEUZ-LOPEZ J N (2002) Mechanism of compound I formation in heme peroxidases, J Inorg Biochem, 91, 27– 34. HOFMANN B, TÖLZER S, PELLETIER I, ALTENBUCHNER J, VAN PÉE K H and HECHT H J (1998) Structural investigation of the cofactor-free chloroperoxidase, J Mol Biol, 279, 889– 900. HUIZING H, DIJK VAN C and BOERIU C (1999) Enzymatic modification of proteins for industrial application, Patent nr. NL 1007158/30.03.1999 HURREL R F, FINOT P A and CUQ J L (1982) Protein-polyphenol reactions. 1. Nutritional and metabolic consequences of the reaction between oxidised caffeic acid and the lysine residues of casein, Br J Nutr, 47, 191–211. ICHISHIMA E, MAEBA H, AMIKURA T and SAKATA H (1984) Multiple forms of protyrosinase from Aspergillus oryzae and their mode of activation at pH 3.0, Biochim Biophys Acta, 786, 25–31. IKEGAWA T, MAYA S, NAKAYASHIKI H and KATO H (1996) Accumulation of diferulic acid during the hypersensitivity response of oat leaves to Puccinia coronata f. sp. avenae and its role in the resistance of oat tissues to cell wall degrading enzymes, Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology, 48, 245–55. JACQUET G, POLLET B, LAPIERRE C, MHMADI F and ROLANDO C (1995) New ether-linked ferulic acid-coniferyl alcohol dimers identified in grass straws, J Agric Food Chem, 43, 2746–51. JIMÉNEZ M and GARCIA-CARMONA F (1993) In vitro activation of grape polyphenol oxidase by polyglucan type elicitors, Plant Physiol Biochem, 31, 541–46. JIMÉNEZ-ATIENZAR M, ANGELES-PEDRENO M and GARCIA-CARMONA F (1991), Activation of polyphenol oxidase by polyamines, Biochem Int, 25, 861–8. KAWANO T, KAWANO N and LAPEYRIE F (2002) A fungal auxin antagonist hypaphorine prevents the indole-3-acetic acid dependent irreversible inactivation of HRP:inhibition of compound III-mediated formation of P-670, Biochem Biophys Res Commun, 294, 553–9. KENTEN R H (1957) Latent phenolase in extracts of broad-bean (Vicia faba L.) leaves 1. Activation by acid and alkali, Biochem J, 67, 300–307. KERMASHA S, ALLI I and METCHE M (1988) Changes in peroxidase activity during the development and processing of Phaseolus vulgaris cv., haricot seed, J Food Sci, 53, 1753–5. KETSA S and ATANTEE S (1998) Phenolics, lignin, peroxidase activity and increased firmness of damaged pericarp of mangosteen fruit after impact, Postharvest Biol and Technol, 14, 117–24. KHAN A A and ROBINSON D S (1993) The thermostability of purified mango isoperoxidases, Food Chemistry, 47, 53–9. KING R S and FLURKEY W H (1987) Effects of limited proteolysis on broad bean polyphenoloxidase, J Sci Food Agric, 41, 231–40. *KLABUNDE T, EICKEN C, SACCHETTINI J C and KREBS B (1998) Crystal structure of a plant catechol oxidase containing a dicopper center, Nature Structural Biology, 5, 1084–90. KREBBERS B, MATSER A M, KOETS M and VAN DEN BERG R W (2002) Quality and storage-stability of high-pressure preserved green beans, J Food Eng, (54-2002). KRYLOV S N and DUNFORD H N (1996) Evidence for a free radical chain mechanism in the reaction between peroxidase and indole-3-acetic acid at neutral pH, Biophysical Chemistry, 58, 325–34.
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables LAGRIMINI L M, BURKHART W, MOYER M
317
and ROTHSTEIN S (1987) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 84, 7542–6. LAPIERRE C, POLLET B, RALET M C and SAULNIER L (2001) The phenolic fraction of maize bran: evidence for lignin-heteroxylan association, Phytochemistry, 57, 765–72. LEE S H, KIM E S and LEE M S (2001) Purification of a cationic isoperoxidase from scented geranium, Phytochemistry, 58, 859–64. LEMOS M A, OLIVEIRA J C and SARAIVA J A (2000) Influence of pH on the thermal inactivation kinetics of horseradish peroxidase in aqueous solution, Lebensm Wiss U Technol, 33, 362–8. LENHART J L, CHAUBAL M V, PAYNE G F and BARBARI T A (1998) Enzymatic modification of chitosan by tyrosinase, ACS Symposium Series 684, Washington DC, American Chemical Society, 188–98. *LIND T, SIEGBAHN P E M and CRABTREE R H (1999) A quantum chemical study of the mechanism of tyrosinase, J Phys Chem, B103, 1193–202. LING A C and LUND D B (1978) Determining kinetic parameters for thermal inactivation of heat-resistant and heat-labile isozymes from thermal destruction curves, J Food Sci, 43, 1307–10. LIU L, ERIKSSON K E L and DEAN J F D (1999) Localization of hydrogen production in Zinnia elegans L. stems, Phytochemistry, 52, 545–54. LOPEZ P, SALA F J, FUENTE J L DE LA CONDON S, RASO J and BURGOS J (1994) Inactivation of peroxidase, lipoxygenase and polyphenol oxidase by manothermosonication, J Agric Food Chem, 42, 252–6. LOPEZ-SERRANO M and BARCELO A R (2001) Histochemical localization and developmental expression of peroxidase and polyphenol oxidase in strawberry, J A Soc Horticultural Sci, 126, 27–32 MATHEIS G and WHITAKER J R (1984) Modification of proteins by polyphenol oxidase and peroxidase and their products, J Food Biochem, 8, 137–62. MATHEIS G and WHITAKER J R (1987) A review: enzymatic crosslinking of proteins applicable to foods, J Food Biochem, 11, 309–27. MCLELLAN K M and ROBINSON D S (1984) Heat stability of peroxidase from orange, Food Chemistry, 13, 139–47. MCLELLAN K M and ROBINSON D S (1987a) Purification and stability of Brussels sprout peroxidase isoenzymes, Food Chemistry, 23, 305–19. MCLELLAN K M and ROBINSON D S (1987b) The heat stability of purified spring cabbage peroxidase isoenzymes, Food Chemistry, 26, 97–107. MANZOCCO L, NICOLI M C, ANESE M, PITOTTI A and MALTINI E (1998) Polyphenoloxidase and peroxidase activity in partly frozen systems with different physical properties, Food Res Int, 31, 363–70. MARTINEZ M V and WHITAKER J R (1995) The biochemistry and control of enzymatic browning, Tr Food Sci Technol, 6, 195–200. MICHON T, CHENU M, KELLERSHON N, DESMADRIL M and GUEGUEN J (1997) Horseradish peroxidase oxidation of tyrosine-containing peptides and their subsequent polymerization: a kinetic study, J Biochem, 36, 8504–13. MOORE B M and FLURKEY W H (1990) Sodium dodecyl sulfate activation of a plant polyphenol oxidase, J Biol Chem, 265, 4982–8. MOULDING P H, GRANT H F, MCLELLAN K M and ROBINSON D S (1987) Heat stability of soluble and ionically bound peroxidases extracted from apples, Int J Food Sci Technol, 22, 391–7. MOULDING P H, GOODFELLOW J, MCLELLAN K M and ROBINSON D S (1989) The occurrence of peroxidases in conference pears, Int J Food Sci Technol, 24, 269–75. MUNIR I Z and DORDICK J S (2000) Soybean peroxidase as an effective bromination catalyst, Enzyme and Microbial Technology, 26, 337–41. NEUKOM H and MARKWALDER H U (1978) Oxidative gelation of wheat flour pentosans: a new way of crosslinking polymers, Cereal Foods World, 23, 374–6.
318
Texture in food
NOSE M, BERNARDS M A, FURLAN M, ZAJICEK J , EBERHARDT T L
and LEWIS N G (1995) Towards the specification of consecutive steps in macromolecular lignin assembly, Phytochemistry, 39, 71–9. NG A, HARVEY A J, PARKER M L, SMITH A C and WALDRON K W (1998) Effect of oxidative coupling on the thermal stability of texture and cell wall chemistry of Beet root (Beta vulgaris), J Agric Food Chem, 46, 3365–70. OBEL N, PORCHIA A C and SCHELLER H V (2002) Dynamic changes in cell wall polysaccharides during wheat seedling development, Phytochemistry, 60, 603–10. OETTING W S and KING R A (1992) Molecular analysis of type 1-A (tyrosinase negative) oculocutaneous albinism, Human Genetics, 90, 258–62. *OSTERGAARD L, TEILUM K, MIRZA O, MATTSSON O, PETERSEN M, WELINDER K G, MUNDY J, GAJHEDE M and HENDRIKSEN A (2000) Arabidopsis ATP A2 peroxidase. Expression and high resolution structure of a plant peroxidase with implications for lignification, Plant Mol Biol, 44, 231–43. OOSTERVELD O, GRABBER J H, BELDMAN G, RALPH J and VORAGEN A G J (1997) Formation of ferulic acid dehydromers through oxidative cross-linking of sugar-beet pectin, Carbohydr Res, 300, 179–81. OTTE O and BARZ W (1996) The elicitor-induced oxidative burst in cultured chickpea cells drives the rapid insolubilization of two cell wall structural proteins, Planta, 200, 238– 46. OUDGENOEG G, PIERSMA S, BOERIU C, GRUPPEN H and HILHORST R (2000) Peroxidase mediated cross-linking of proteins and carbohydrates, Industrial Proteins, 8(2), 14–16. OUDGENOEG G, HILHORST R, PIERSMA S R, BOERIU C G, GRUPPEN H, HESSING M, VORAGEN A G J and LAANE C (2001) Peroxidase mediated cross-linking of a tyrosine containing peptide with ferulic acid, J Agric Food Chem, 49, 2503–10. *OUDGENOEG G, DIRKSEN E, INGEMANN S, HILHORST R, GRUPPEN H, BOERIU C G, PIERSMA R S, VAN BERKEL W J H, LAANE C and VORAGEN A G J (2002) Horseradish peroxidase-catalyzed oligomerization of ferulic acid on a template of a tyrosine-containing tripeptide, J Biol Chem, 277, 21332–40. PARKER M L and WALDRON K W (1995) Texture of chinese water chestnut: involvement of cell wall phenolics, J Sci Food Agric, 68, 337–46. *PATTERSON W R and POULOS T L (1995) Crystal structure of recombinant cytosolic ascorbate peroxidase, Biochemistry, 34, 4331–41. PENEL C and GREPPIN H (1979) Effect of calcium on subcellular distribution of peroxidases, Phytochemistry, 18(1), 29–33. PENEL C and GREPPIN H (1994) Binding of plant peroxidases to pectin in the presence of calcium, FEBS Letters, 343, 51–5. POULOS T L and KRAUT J (1980) The stereochemistry of peroxidase catalysis, J Biol Chem, 255, 8199–205. RAMSOHOYE P and KOZLOV I A (1991) Isoprotein composition and cross-linking of thaumatins using mushroom tyrosinase and dimethyl suberimidate, Int J Food Sci Technol, 26, 271–82. RANTWIJK VAN F and SHELDON R A (2000) Selective oxygen transfer catalysed by heme peroxidases: synthetic and mechanistic aspects, Curr Opin Biotechnol, 11, 554–64. REINECKE D M and BANDURSKI R S (1988) Oxidation of indole-3-acetic acid to oxindole-3acetic acid by an enzyme preparation from Zea mays, Plant Physiol, 86, 868–72. REGELSBERGER G, JAKOPITSCH C, PLASSER L, SCHWARGER H, FURTMULLER G, PESCHEK G A, ZAMOCKY M and OBINGER C (2002) Occurrence and biochemistry of peroxidases in oxygenic photothropic prokaryotes (cyanobacteria), Plant Physiol Biochem, 40, 479–90. ROBINSON S P (1991) Peroxidases and catalases in foods. In Oxidative Enzymes in Food. Eds D S Robinson and N A M Eskin, London, Elsevier, 1–47. ROBINSON S P and DRY I B (1992) Broad bean leaf polyphenol oxidase is a 60-Kilodalton protein susceptible to proteolytic cleavage, Plant Physiol, 99, 317–23. ROBINSON D S, BRETHERICK M R, DONELLY J K (1989) The heat stability and isoenzyme composition of peroxidases in Ohane grapes, Int J Food Sci Technol, 24, 613–18.
Controlling the texture of fruit and vegetables ROS-BARCELO A, MUNOZ R
319
and SABATER F (1987) Lupin peroxidases. I. Isolation and characterisation of cell-bound isoperoxidase activity, Physiol Planta, 71, 448–54. SCHOONEVELD-BERGMANS M E F, DIGNUM M J W, GRABBER J H, BELDMAN G and VORAGEN A G J (1999) Studies on the oxidative cross-linking of feruloylated arabinoxylans from wheat flour and wheat bran, Carbohydrate Polymers, 38, 309–17. SCHOPFER P (1996) Hydrogen peroxide mediated cell wall stiffening in vitro of maize coleoptiles, Planta, 199, 43–9. SCHWEIKERT C, LISZKAY A and SCHOPFER P (2000) Scission of polysaccharides by peroxidasegenerated hydroxyl radicals, Phytochemistry, 53, 565–70. SCHWEIKERT C, LISZKAY A and SCHOPFER P (2002) Polysaccharide degradation by Fenton reaction or peroxidase-generated hydroxyl radicals in isolated plant cell walls, Phytochemistry, 61, 31–5. *SCHULLER D J and BAR N, HUYSTEE R B, MCPHERSON A and POULOS T L (1996) The crystal structure of peanut peroxidase, Structure, 4, 311–21. SESSA D J and ANDERSON R L (1981) Soybean peroxidases: purification and some properties, J Agric Food Chem, 29, 960–65. SMITH A T and VEITCH N C (1998) Substrate binding and catalysis in heme peroxidases, Current Opinion in Chemical Biology, 2, 269–78. SOLER-RIVAS C, ARPIN N, OLIVIER J M and WICHERS H J (1997) Activation of tyrosinase in Agaricus bisporus strains following infection by Pseudomonas tolaassi or treatment with tolaasin-containing preparation, Myc Res, 101, 375–82. SOLER-RIVAS C, MÖLLER A C, ARPIN N, OLIVIER J-M and WICHERS H J (2001) Induction of a tyrosinase mRNA in Agaricus bisporus upon treatment with a tolaasin preparation from Pseudomonas tolaassi Physiol Mol Plant Pathol, 58, 95–9. STAHMANN M A, SPENCER K A and HONOLD G R (1977) Cross-linking of proteins in vitro by peroxidases, Biopolymers, 16, 1307–18. STOOP J M H and MOOIBROEK H (1999) Advances in genetic analysis and biotechnology of the cultivated button mushroom, Agaricus bisporus, Appl Microbiol. Biotechnol, 52, 474– 83. STOLLE-SMITS T, BEEKHUIZEN J G, RECOURT K, VORAGEN A J and DIJK VAN C (2000) Preheating effects on the textural strength of canned green beans. 1. Cell wall chemistry, J Agric Food Chem, 48, 5269–77. TAKAHAMA U (1997) Enhancement of the peroxidase-dependent oxidation of DOPA by components of Vicia leaves, Phytochemistry, 46, 427–32. *TAKASAKI S and KAWAKISHI S (1997) Formation of protein-bound 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine and 5-S-cysteinyl-3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine as new cross-linkers in gluten, J Agric Food Chem, 45, 3472–5. TAMS J W and WELINDER K G (1998) Glycosylation and thermodynamic versus kinetic stability of horseradish peroxidase, FEBS Letters, 421, 234–6. *TANAKA M, MORIMOTO A, ISHIMORI K and MORISHIMA I (1997) Mechanism of peroxidase activity as studied with some recombinant horseradish peroxidases, J Inorg Biochem, 67, 80. TOBIN D J and PAUS R (2001) Graying: gerontobiology of the hair follicle pigmentary unit, Exp Gerontol, 36, 229–54. *TOGNOLLI M, PENEL C, GREPPIN H and SIMON P (2002) Analysis and expression of the class III peroxidase large gene family in Arabidopsis thaliana, Gene, 288, 129–38. VALDERRAMA B, AYALA M and VASQUEZ-DUHALT R (2002) Suicide inactivation of peroxidases and the challenge of engineering more robust enzymes, Chemistry & Biology, 9, 555– 65. *VAN GELDER C W G, FLURKEY W H and WICHERS H J (1997) Sequence and structural features of plant and fungal tyrosinases, Phytochemistry, 45, 1309–23. VAN LEEUWEN J and WICHERS H J (1999) Tyrosinase activity and isoform composition in separate tissues during development of Agaricus bisporus fruitbodies, Mycol Res, 103, 413–18.
320
Texture in food
VAN RENSBURG W J, FERREIRA D, MALAN E
and STEENKAMP J A (2000) Tyrosinase catalysed biphenyl construction from flavan-3-ol substrates, Phytochemistry, 53, 285–92. VÁZQUEZ A, VARÓN R, TUDELA J and GARCÍA-CÁNOVAS F (1993) Kinetic characterization of a model for zymogen activation: an experimental design and kinetic data analysis, J Mol Catal, 79, 347–63. VINKX C J A, VAN NIEUWENHOVE C G and DELCOUR J A (1991) Physicochemical and functional properties of rye nonstarch polysaccharides. III. Oxidative gelation of a fraction containing water-soluble pentosans and proteins, Cereal Chem, 68, 617–22. WAGENKNECHT A C and LEE F A (1958) Enzyme action and off-flavour of frozen peas, Food Res, 23, 25–31. WAFFENSCHMIDT S, WOESSNER J P, BEER K and GOODENOUGH U W (1993) Isodityrosine crosslinking mediates insolubilisation of cell walls in Chlamidomonas, Plant Cell, 5, 809–20. WALDRON K W, NG A, PARKER M L and PARR A J (1997a) Ferulic acid dehydromers in the cell walls of Beta vulgaris and their possible role in texture, J Sci Food Agric, 74, 221–8. *WALDRON K W, SMITH A C, PARR A J, NG A and PARKER M L (1997b) New approaches to understanding and controlling cell separation in relation to fruit and vegetable texture, Trends Food Sci Technol, 8, 213–20. WALLACE G and FRY S C (1995) In vitro peroxidase-catalysed oxidation of ferulic acid esters, Phytochemistry, 39, 1293–9. WENDE G, WALDRON K W, SMITH A C and BRETT C T (2000) Tissue-specific developmental changes in cell-wall ferulate and dehydroferulates in sugar beet, Phytochemistry, 55, 103–10. WELINDER K (1985) Plant peroxidases. Their primary, secondary and tertiary structures and relation to Cytochrome C peroxidase, Eur J Biochem, 151, 497. *WELINDER K G (1992) Superfamily of plant, fungal and bacterial peroxisases, Curr Opin Struct Biol, 2, 338–93. *WELINDER K G, MAURO J M and NORSKOV-LAURITSEN L (1992) Structure of plant and fungal peroxidases, Biochem Soc Trans, 20, 337–40. *WICHERS H J, RECOURT K, HENDRIKS M, EBBELAAR C E M, BIANCONE G, HOEBERICHTS F A, MOOIBROEK H and SOLER-RIVAS C (2003) Cloning, expression and characterisation of two tyrosinase cDNAs from Agaricus bisporus, Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 61, 336–41. WOLFRAMM C, LINGENS F M R and VAN PÉE K H (1993) Chloroperoxidase-encoding gene from Pseudomonas pyrrocinia – sequence, expression in heterologous hosts, and purification of the enzyme, Gene, 130, 131–35. YAMAGUCHI M, HWANG P M and CAMPBELL J D (1970) Latent o-diphenol oxidase in mushrooms (Agaricus bisporus), Can J Biochem, 48, 198–202. YOSHIMURA K, ISHIKAWA T, NAKAMURA Y, TAMOI M, TAKEDA T, TADA T, NISHIMURA K, and SHIGEOKA S (1998) Comparative study on recombinant chloroplastic and cytosilic ascorbate peroxidase isoenzymes in spinach, Arch Biochem Biophys, 353, 55–63. *ZABEAU M, STEFFENS J C, HUNT M D, VERHEGGEN F T M, VAN DER LINDE P C G, SPECKMANN G J and BACHEM C W B (1994) Antisense expression of polyphenol oxidase genes inhibits enzymatic browning in potato tubers, Biotechnology, 12, 1101–5. ZAMOCKY M, JANECEK S and KOLLER F (2000) Common phylogeny of catalase-peroxidases and ascorbate peroxidases, Gene, 256, 169–82.
13 Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation G. Tucker, University of Nottingham, UK
13.1
Introduction
Texture of plant material, as described extensively within this book, is often dictated by the structure of the cell wall. Thus any modification to the wall, through either altered synthesis or degradation, may result in modification to texture. Change in texture, i.e. softening, is a major factor in determining the shelf life of fruit. Thus techniques to slow down softening have been extensively sought. Softening may be brought about by a combination of factors, but the most important is likely to be the degradation of the cell wall which accompanies the ripening of most fruit. The structure of a typical plant cell wall has been documented elsewhere in this book and has also been extensively reviewed (McCann and Roberts, 1991; Carpita and Gibeaut, 1993; Carpita et al., 2001). Similarly the changes in the wall accompanying ripening have had extensive coverage (Huber, 1983; Fischer and Bennett, 1991; Tucker, 1993; Brummell and Harpster, 2001; Giovannoni, 2001). The major observable changes in most fruit are those occurring within the pectin. These include a progressive solubilisation and depolymerisation of the galacturonic acid containing polymers; a reduction in the degree of esterification of the galacturonic acid residues and loss of neutral sugars, such as galactose and arabinose, from the side chains of the “hairy region” of the pectin polymer. There are also likely to be modifications of the other cell wall domains, in particular the cellulose/hemicellulose framework. There are many enzymes found in nature capable of degrading cell wall components (Table 13.1). The list in Table 13.1 is not exhaustive but includes enzymes – such as polygalacturonase – which are thought to be primarily targeted at the homogalacturonan or “smooth” region of the pectin and those like – galactosidase – targeted at the “hairy” regions. Some of these enzyme
322
Texture in food Table 13.1 Enzymes involved in cell wall degradation Pectin “smooth” region Polygalacturonase Pectate lyase Pectin lyase Pectin esterase Pectin acetylesterase Pectin “hairy” region Rhamnogalacturonase Rhamnogalacturonan lyase Rhamnogalacturonan acetylesterase Galactosidase Arabinosidase Other cell wall domains Glucanases Xyloglucan endotransferase Expansin Mannanase
activities are associated primarily with microbial sources; however, a good many are also found in plant tissues. These enzymes are encoded for by a very large array of genes. Following the entire sequence analysis of the Arabidopsis genome it has been shown that a staggering 1–2% of the genes, an estimated total of 730 open reading frames (ORF), are dedicated to the production of cell wall hydrolases or glycosyltransferases. A large number of the latter are presumably involved with the biosynthesis of the wall. The genes associated with hydrolytic enzymes have been grouped into classes (Table 13.2). Again this list is not exhaustive. For more detail see the review by Henrissat et al. (2001). Within this huge array of genes there seems to be a preponderance of genes, at least 170 ORFs, dedicated to pectin degradation. With the increase in knowledge of the enzymes and genes involved in wall degradation has come the ability to genetically manipulate these activities with a view to modifying the softening process and hence the texture of the fruit. Table 13.2 Putative Arabidopsis genes involved in wall degradation Enzyme
Class
Number of ORF
Hydrolases Pectin esterases Pectin acetylesterases Rhamnogalacturonan lyases β-galactosidase Cellulase
GH28 CE8 CE13 PL1 GH35 GH9
66 58 13 28 20 27
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation
323
13.2 Tools of genetic modification Genetic engineering has been used to alter a range of functions in plants. However, the majority of these genetic manipulations are directed at: • insertion of a “foreign” gene into a host cell such that a protein product not normally associated with that cell is produced; • enhancing the activity of an endogenous gene; • switching off a deleterious gene so that it can no longer produce the undesirable protein. Although these three objectives are widely different, the basic genetic engineering techniques used to achieve them are remarkably similar. Indeed much of genetic engineering relies on only a few basic techniques which, whilst often difficult to execute, are nonetheless relatively simple to understand. There are many excellent texts and reviews on the methodology of genetic engineering, but a good starting point is the text by Brown (1995). All genetic modifications require the transfer of new “DNA” into the plant in such a way that it is expressed and performs its desired function. Once a suitable piece of DNA has been obtained, the major problem is how to engineer this into the plant. There are several methods available for the transfer of the “foreign” DNA into a plant cell. In some cases the DNA can be inserted directly into the host cell. This inserted DNA may then be physically incorporated into the host’s DNA. There are several methods of direct implantation of the DNA, and these include electroporation, microinjection and the “DNA gun”. However, there are limitations to this methodology. The use of such direct methods often fails to result in the stable integration of the DNA into the host genome. Thus the new gene is not passed onto offspring as the cell divides or indeed may even be destroyed within the original cell. More efficient mechanisms employ the use of a vector or carrier to get the DNA stably inserted into a host cell. 13.2.1 Ti plasmid There are many vectors available for genetic engineering. Several viruses naturally incorporate their DNA into that of plant cells, and this property can be used to transfer new genes. A second, more commonly used vector is the Ti plasmid from Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Many plants are susceptible to infection by this bacterium which is responsible for the formation of crown galls on infected plants. The natural mechanism of infection of this particular bacterium involves gene transfer. The bacteria contain a plasmid – the Ti plasmid – which upon infection of a plant is passed from the bacteria into the plant cells where it inserts part of itself into the host’s genome and becomes functional. The genes on the plasmid direct the production of proteins which produce food for the bacteria and cause the plant tissue to differentiate into the gall associated with this disease. The properties of this natural genetic engineer have been harnessed to manipulate the plant genome. The virulence
324
Texture in food
genes can be deleted from the plasmid without impairing its ability to integrate into the host DNA. These are replaced with antibiotic resistance genes and any “foreign” DNA as required. When this recombinant Ti plasmid is used to transform plant cells the “foreign” DNA is stably inserted into the plant DNA, but no gall or other symptoms of disease develop. There is an extra problem encountered with the transformation of plants, and this is that they are multi-cellular organisms. The Ti plasmid is used to transform a single plant cell. However, this cell contains all the DNA needed to produce an entire plant. The original cell can be treated in such a way that it continually divides and eventually forms an entire plant. Since at each division the stably inserted “foreign” DNA is passed onto each of the progeny, all the cells in the resultant plant have a copy of the newly inserted gene. Transformed plant cells are selected during this process by exposure to antibiotic, and only those with the Ti plasmid insert would be able to survive and divide to produce plants. The use of antibiotic resistance genes in this technology has given rise to some concern about the possible spread of resistance to non-host organisms. The “foreign” DNA could in theory encode for any protein. This could be a novel enzyme not normally associated with the host. Alternatively it may represent a second copy of a gene already present in the host but under the control of a more efficient promoter in order to enhance the levels of the specific enzyme. Such genetic modification techniques have been, or could be, used to study the role of wall hydrolases during ripening. However, the majority of reports have involved the “switching off ” of endogenous host genes and examination of the subsequent effect on wall degradation and fruit texture. Conceptually this is the most difficult technique to comprehend (for a general coverage see Lycett et al., 1996). However, it is basically the same as that used for the insertion of a novel gene, or a second copy of an endogenous gene, into a host, except that in this case this new gene is what is known as an antisense gene. The first stage is to isolate the coding DNA sequence from the target gene, i.e. the gene that needs to be switched off. Under normal conditions it is the antisense strand of this gene which is copied to give sense mRNA (Fig. 13.1). However, for this technique a new type of gene is constructed in which the sense strand will be copied to give antisense mRNA (Fig. 13.1). This new gene is then introduced back into the cell. Now the cell has two genes, the normal gene making sense mRNA and the newly introduced gene which makes antisense mRNA. Exactly how these two interact is not known, but the end result is that the presence of both sense and antisense mRNAs in some way prevents any of the sense mRNA from being used to make protein, effectively switching the target gene off. There are other methods which can be employed for gene silencing. These include cosupression and transposon inactivation. However, the mechanisms of these are beyond the scope of this review. Given the complex structure of the plant cell wall it is unlikely that simply silencing the gene for a single hydrolytic enzyme would have any major
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation
325
Antisense
DNA
RNA Antisense RNA
Protein
Fig. 13.1 In the normal gene on the left the top strand of DNA ( ) is copied to produce mRNA ( ). A copy of this gene is transformed into the plant to produce an antisense gene. This antisense gene is constructed such that in this case the other ). Since the antisense RNA is strand ( ) is copied to give an antisense RNA( complementary to the normal mRNA these may hybridise and thus protein synthesis is blocked.
effect on texture. Indeed, this is the conclusion from many of the gene silencing experiments that will be discussed later in this chapter. Plants in which two or more genes are silenced can be produced by means of conventional breeding between the individually genetically modified lines. However, this is both labour-intensive and time-consuming. An alternative approach has been demonstrated through the application of “chimeric gene constructs”. This was f irst exemplif ied by the simultaneous silencing of genes for polygalacturonase and pectinesterase in tomato plants (Seymour et al., 1993). The technique involved is illustrated in Fig. 13.2. Parts of the coding sequence Polygalacturonase
Pectinesterase
Chimeric construct
Fig. 13.2 cDNA clones for the two endogenous genes – polygalacturonase and pectinesterase – are isolated. These are cut with restriction endonucleases and the products are ligated together to form a single chimeric construct. Such that the 5’ end represents part of the coding sequence for one gene and the 3’ end that from the other. This chimeric construct can then be used as an antisense gene in a single transformation event to simultaneously silence both polygalacturonase and pectinesterase genes.
326
Texture in food
from each of the target genes are taken and ligated together to form a chimeric antisense construct. When this is used to transform plants, the resultant transformants exhibit simultaneous silencing of the two endogenous genes. The orientation of these two fragments with respect to each other does not seem to be important. Indeed it has been shown that a chimeric construct containing both sense and antisense oriented fragments will still result in the silencing of both target genes (Jones et al., 1998).
13.2.2 GM approaches–QTL There is a potential problem in the commercial application of genetic modification due to the strong consumer resistance to this technology. An alternative “genetic”-based approach might be through the identification of quantitative trait loci (QTL) responsible for texture determination. This technology involves making a large number of crosses between two parental lines of a species with a relatively intensive genetic map. In the fruit area tomato is one such candidate. QTL are then identified by co-segregation, within the progeny, of the “trait” (in this case texture) with specific genetic markers which in turn indicate that gene(s) within the loci associated with those markers are having a determinant effect on the trait being measured. This concept is illustrated, in a very simplistic manner, in Fig. 13.3. Once a A
F
S
F
F
S
S
F
B S
F
F
Fig. 13.3 On the left the two boxes represent the genetic map of two parental lines A and B which show firm (F) or soft (S) fruit, respectively. For simplicity, this map shows just three loci when in reality there are many thousands. These two parents are crossed to generate a large number of progeny as depicted on the right hand side. Each progeny is tested for either the “trait” soft (S) or the “trait” firm (F) fruit. In addition each progeny is genotyped to determine the parental contribution at each of the loci. Correlations are then sought to determine co-segregation of specific loci with the trait. In this simple example the firm trait can clearly be seen to be associated with the inheritance of the middle loci ( ) of parent A. This would thus represent a QTL for texture.
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation
327
QTL, or more specifically its associated genetic marker, has been identified then this can be used in marker-assisted breeding programmes to rapidly generate lines with improved texture. One classic example of how this technology has been applied to the improvement of plants can be seen in the breeding of high glucosinolate lines of broccoli (Faulkner et al., 1998).
13.3 Approaches to the manipulation of texture: the tomato 13.3.1 Introduction Tomato has been used by many groups as a model to study fruit ripening. This is because the tomato plant is readily and easily transformed, has a short lifespan and has a good genetic map. The fruit are also easy to work with at a biochemical level as they contain little protease activity. As stated above, the vast majority of the approaches to manipulating fruit texture specifically using genetic modification have targeted cell wall degrading enzymes, and this has been recently reviewed (Brummell and Harpster, 2001). It can be seen from Table 13.1 that there are a significant number of these. Unfortunately little information is available regarding the relative load-bearing qualities of the various polymers or bonds within the wall. Since these are likely to be the most significant in terms of texture they would represent good targets for manipulation. In the absence of such information early targets for genetic modification were those enzymes whose activity increased dramatically during tomato fruit ripening, the classic example being polygalacturonase (PG).
13.3.2 Polygalacturonase Green tomato fruit exhibit very low levels of PG activity (Hobson, 1964), and that activity which is present is thought to reside in an exo-acting PG isoform that is expressed constitutively throughout development and ripening. Polygalacturonase activity increases exponentially during fruit ripening as a result of the de novo synthesis of endo-acting PG isoforms (Tucker and Grierson, 1982). Polygalacturonase is a hydrolytic enzyme that cleaves the α (1–4) bonds between adjacent galacturonic acids within the homogalacturonic acid backbone of pectin. This endo-acting PG was thus thought to be responsible for the progressive depolymerisation and perhaps solubilisation of pectin that accompanies tomato fruit ripening, and perhaps represented a key enzyme in the softening process. It was thus the first enzyme to be targeted for silencing. Two groups have independently down-regulated PG activity in tomato fruit (Sheehy et al., 1988; Smith et al., 1988). This resulted in a reduction in PG activity to below 1% of that normally detected in ripe tomato fruit. The effect on the degradation of the pectin during ripening was clearly seen. The depolymerisation of the pectin occurring during normal ripening was markedly
328
Texture in food
inhibited (Smith et al., 1990). Thus in normal ripening the chelator soluble pectin undergoes depolymerisation from an average molecular weight of around 300 000 in green fruit down to about 100 000 in red ripe fruit. In transgenic tomato fruit with reduced PG activity, the size of the chelatorsoluble pectin from green fruit was unaltered, but the reduction in molecular weight was largely eliminated, the chelator-soluble pectin from red ripe fruit in this case being in the order of 250 000. This modification to the depolymerisation of the pectin was as expected given the mode of action of PG. It was anticipated that the reduction in PG activity might also result in a reduction in the increased solubility of the pectin associated with ripening. This was not the case if pectins were solubilised with chelators such as 1, 2cyclohexanediamine tetraacetic acid (CDTA). Indeed in some reports this was actually found to increase in the transgenic fruit (Carrington et al., 1993; Brummell and Labovitch, 1997). However, solubility in water was found to be reduced in these transgenic fruit (Carrington et al., 1993). The degree of methyl esterification of the pectin throughout ripening was largely unaffected (Smith et al., 1990) showing that reduction in PG activity does not influence the action of the other major cell wall degrading enzyme in tomato fruit namely pectinesterase. These modifications to the pectin have also been shown to have an effect on the polymer in situ. During ripening a proportion of the polyuronide in the wall appears to increase in mobility as measured by NMR. This mobility is slightly reduced in the transgenic fruit with reduced PG activity (Fenwick et al., 1996). Transgenic fruit were only slightly firmer (Kramer et al., 1992; Langley et al., 1994; Errington et al., 1998; Tucker et al., 1999) and handled better with less cracking (Schuch et al., 1991). A major commercial advantage, however, was that this genetic modification resulted in an improved quality of the puree made from the transformed fruit (Schuch et al., 1991; Kramer et al., 1992; Brummell and Labovitch, 1997). The lack of any significant effect on texture in these transgenic fruit could have been explained by the fact that whilst PG activity had been reduced to around 1% of normal this still represents a significant level of activity given the unusually high level of this enzyme found in tomato fruit. More recently Cooley and Yoder (1998) have produced a line in which the PG gene has been disrupted by a transposon insertion. This resulted in the almost complete elimination of PG activity, but does not appear to have resulted in any further reduction in firmness. In addition Giovannoni et al. (1989) transformed a tomato ripening mutant – rin – with a copy of the PG gene under the control of another promoter. The rin is a natural pleiotrophic ripening mutant which does not soften and does not normally synthesise any endo-PG activity. Expression of the new PG gene in the transgenic rin fruit resulted in the synthesis of endo-PG activity in the ripe fruit and demonstratable depolymerisation of the pectin, but did not restore any softening phenotype. These results would seem to demonstrate that PG, whilst responsible for pectin depolymerisation and to some extent solubility, is not causal, on its own, for softening.
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation
329
Endo-polygalacturonase activity in tomato fruit results from the action of a single gene (Bird et al., 1988). However, the enzyme as extracted occurs in several isoforms – PG1, PG2A and PG2B (Ali and Brady, 1982; Tucker et al., 1980). It is thought that PG2 represents the primary gene product and is the catalytic subunit of the enzyme. This polypeptide is differentially glycosylated which accounts for isoforms PG2A and PG2B (Ali and Brady, 1982). The PG2 polypeptide is also thought to react post-transcriptionally with a second polypeptide – the β-subunit – and this results in the formation of PG1 (Tucker et al., 1981; Pressey, 1986). The β-subunit – unlike the catalytic subunit – is synthesised throughout fruit development and ripening and has been localised to the middle lamella of the tomato cell walls (Pogson et al., 1991). It is thought that this β-subunit is somehow involved in sequestering the catalytic subunit within the wall and thus limiting and controlling its activity. Expression of the β-subunit has been silenced in tomato fruit by the introduction of an antisense gene (Watson et al., 1994). This has resulted in transformed fruit in which expression of the β-subunit has been reduced to almost undetectable levels. In normal wild type fruit the early expression of endo-PG activity in ripening fruit is associated almost entirely with the presence of the PG1 isoform (Tucker et al., 1980). In contrast in these antisense β-subunit fruit almost all PG activity was associated with the PG2 isoform. The amount of chelator-soluble polyuronide was found to be about 50% greater from the ripe antisense fruit compared to normal fruit (Watson et al., 1994). More interestingly, there was also a 90% increase in chelatorsoluble polyuronide in mature green fruit (Chun and Huber, 1997) indicating a possible effect of reduced β-subunit which is independent of endo-PG activity. Analysis of the molecular weight distributions of the chelator-soluble polyuronides from normal and antisense β-subunit fruit showed little or no difference (Watson et al., 1994; Chun and Huber, 1997). There was no real difference in the firmness of normal or transgenic fruit at the mature green stage. However, ripe fruit from the β-subunit antisense plants showed a 22% reduction in firmness compared to controls (Chun and Huber, 2000). Pericarp discs cut from mature green β-subunit antisense fruit also exhibited a greater reduction in firmness, compared to controls, following treatment with exogenous PG2 enzyme (Chun and Huber, 2000). This apparent increase in the susceptibility of cell walls to digestion by PG2 in the absence of the βsubunit supports a role for the latter in controlling the activity of the former. 13.3.3 Pectinesterase A second major pecteolytic activity associated with fruit is that of pectinesterase (PE). This enzyme catalyses the removal of the methyl group from the C6 of methyl galacturonic acid to form the free acid. The enzyme is found in most, if not all, plant tissues. Its function, if any, in the determination of texture is not at all clear. In order for PG to degrade pectin it requires the presence of blocks of demethylated galacturonic acid residues. These can be produced by
330
Texture in food
the action of PE, and in this respect the enzyme may act in a synergistic fashion with PG to bring about a weakening of the wall structure. Alternatively, long regions of deesterified galacturonic acid residues on adjacent pectin polymers can interact via calcium chelation to generate the so called “egg box” junction zones (Grant et al., 1973) and thus strengthen the wall. In tomato fruit PE activity can be separated into at least three isoforms and, unlike endo-PG, these seem to be derived from the action of three separate genes or gene families. Some of these isoforms are fruit specific whilst others appear to occur in all tissues including fruit (Gaffe et al., 1994). Also unlike endo-PG, PE activity is present throughout the development and ripening of the fruit, although the ratio of the isoforms changes (Tucker et al., 1982). The major tomato fruit isoform – PE2 – accounts for about 80% of the activity in a ripe fruit and was also an early target for gene silencing technology. Genes encoding the PE2 isoform have been identified (Ray et al., 1988; Harriman et al., 1991; Hall et al., 1994), and two groups have independently down-regulated the expression of PE activity (Tieman et al., 1992; Hall et al., 1993). In both cases, expression of PE activity was reduced to around 10% of that in normal fruit. The expression of PE2 in these transgenics was found to be almost completely blocked, the residual 10% enzyme activity being associated with the continued expression of the other two isoforms – PE1 and PE3 – of this enzyme (Tucker and Zhang, 1996). This demonstrates the extreme selectivity of these gene silencing techniques. Presumably in this instance the genes encoding the PE1 and PE3 isoforms have insufficient sequence homology to those encoding PE2 for the antisense message to hybridise and thus inhibit expression. Little is known about the genes encoding these other PE isoforms although a tomato leaf PE gene (PMEU1) has been described which is also expressed in green fruit (Gaffe et al., 1997). During the ripening of normal tomato fruit the degree of esterification of the pectin drops, from around 90% in green to 35% in ripe fruit (Koch and Nevins, 1989). This degree of esterification was higher throughout ripening by between 15 and 40% in the transgenic fruit (Tieman et al., 1992; Hall et al., 1993), and the increase in the retention of methyl groups was accompanied by a reduced depolymerisation of the polyuronides in ripe fruit and a decrease in the amount of chelator-soluble pectin of around 20–30% (Tieman et al., 1992). These changes in pectin structure had little or no effect on fruit firmness during normal ripening (Tieman and Handa, 1994). However, they were associated with a complete loss of tissue integrity in over-ripe fruit (Tieman and Handa, 1994) and with an increase in quality of processed juice made from the transgenic fruit, these having higher soluble solids and viscosity (Thakur et al., 1996). 13.3.4 β-galactosidase The third pectin modifying enzyme to be targeted by genetic modification was β-galactosidase (β-gal). This enzyme is normally assayed using an artificial
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation
331
substrate–p–nitrophenyl galactoside. When this is used β-gal has been shown to occur in tomato fruit in at least three isoforms but only one of these – βgal II – has been shown, using lupin galactan as a substrate, to act as an exogalactanase (Pressey, 1983; Carey et al., 1995). This enzyme is thus presumably capable of cleaving off the terminal non-reducing galactose residues from the pectin sidechains. Whilst total β-gal activity does not change significantly during tomato fruit ripening, the activity specifically associated with the βgal II isoform has been shown to increase by about seven fold during this period (Carey et al., 1995). Thus isoform β-gal II has been the target for gene silencing. At least seven putative β-galactosidase genes (TBG1–7) have been identified in tomato fruit (Smith et al., 1998; Smith and Gross, 2000). TBG1, 3, 4 and 5 have all been shown to have ripening-related expression (Smith et al., 1998; Smith and Gross, 2000). The tomato ripening mutant rin has been shown to be deficient in β-gal II activity (Carey et al., 1995) and in the specific expression of TBG4 (Smith et al., 1998; Smith and Gross, 2000). The coding sequence of TBG4 also corresponds to the N-terminal amino acid sequence of the purified β-gal II enzyme from tomato fruit (Smith et al., 1998). This evidence suggests that TBG4 may be the most significant gene for the expression of exo-galactanase activity associated with tomato fruit ripening. The TBG4 gene has been shown to encode for an exo-galactanase by expression in yeast (Smith and Gross, (2000), and antisense suppression of this gene has resulted in a 90% reduction in exo-galactanase activity in transgenic fruit (Smith and Gross, 2000). It has also been shown that if this suppression of activity can be brought about very early in ripening then there is a 40% increase in the firmness of the ripe fruit (Smith et al., 2002). The antisense gene used in these experiments contained a very large proportion of the coding sequence of the TBG4 gene. This has high homology with other gene family members, in particular TBG1 and 3, and it is possible that these too had been silenced. The TBG1 gene has also been shown to encode for an exo-galactanase by expression in yeast (Carey et al., 2001), and sense suppression of this gene, whilst reducing TBG1 mRNA levels to less than 10% of normal, had little effect on either total exo-galactanase activity or fruit firmness (Carey et al., 2001). Suppression of TBG3 by antisense technology has resulted in a 75% reduction in total exo-galactanase activity (de Silva and Verhoeyen, 1998). In this case TBG1 and 4 may also have been affected, and whilst there was a demonstratable reduction of galactose loss from the wall there was no effect on texture.
13.3.5 Endo-glucanase Enzymes thought to be involved in the degradation of the other major cell wall domain – the cellulose/hemicellulose framework – have also been targeted by gene silencing techniques. The matrix glycans in particular have been shown to undergo depolymerisation in a range of fruit, including tomato,
332
Texture in food
during ripening (Huber, 1983; Brummell et al., 1999a). An early target in this area was endo-glucanase (EGase). This enzyme cleaves the β-(1-4) bond between adjacent glucose residues. It is thought that these bonds probably exist within the hemicellulases such as xyloglucan since these enzymes would be expected to have little if any activity against native crystalline cellulose (Brummell et al., 1994). The EGase activity in tomato plants is thought to arise from at least eight separate genes LeCel1–8. Of these LeCel1 and 2 show ripening related accumulation of mRNA transcripts (Lashbrook et al., 1994; Gonzalez-Bosch et al., 1996) and LeCel5 is also expressed in ripe fruit (Kalaitzis et al., 1999). The expression of LeCel1 is maximal early in ripening and then declines whilst that of LeCel2 continues to increase, and it is this gene transcript that predominates in ripe fruit. These two genes have both been a target for silencing – LeCel1 (Lashbrook et al., 1998) and LeCel2 (Brummell et al., 1999a). In each case silencing was highly specific in that whilst expression of the target gene was reduced by as much as 90% that of the other gene was unaffected. In both cases there was no detectable effect of the transformation on fruit texture. This suggests either that there is a degree of redundancy in the action of these EGases, i.e. that the LeCel1 (or LeCel5) product can compensate for loss of LeCel2 and vice versa, or that this enzyme alone does not play a significant role in texture development. Tomato fruit express low levels of EGase activity, the enzyme often being more predominant in other fruit. Two genes – FaCel1 and FaCel2 – have been identified in ripening strawberry fruit, and these have again been the target for silencing. In this case down, regulation of the FaCel1 gene had no effect on expression of the FaCel2 gene. This transformation had no effect on either total extractable EGase activity or fruit texture (Woolley et al., 2001). Sweet pepper has also provided a means to investigate the potential role of EGase in the development of texture. The depolymerisatin of the matrix glucans is a predominant feature in this fruit. The silencing of EGase, by sense suppression, to non-detectable levels, however, had no effect on this depolymerisation (Harpster et al., 2002a). Similarly expression of the pepper EGase gene in transgenic tomato fruit did not result in any increase in xyloglycan depolymerisation nor fruit softening (Harpster et al., 2002b).
13.3.6 Xyloglucan endotransglycosylase The EGase described above may be capable of the irreversible cleavage of matrix glycans such as xyloglucan. There is another enzyme found in plant tissues, however, that is thought to be more specifically involved in modification of the hemicellulosic polymer xyloglucan. This enzyme is called xyloglucan endotransglycosylase (XET). This enzyme catalyses the breakage of an internal bond, within a xyloglucan backbone, to form a free reducing group. This reducing group then reacts with the C4 group of a terminal non-reducing glucose associated with another xyloglucan polymer or oligosaccharide. As with many of the other wall hydrolases, XET activity in plant tissues is
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation
333
encoded for by a large multi-gene family and exists as several isoforms. In tomato fruit there are at least two genes involved in the production of XET activity – LeEXGT is expressed in expanding green fruit (Catala et al., 2000) and LeXETB1 shows maximal expression in pink ripening fruit (Arrowsmith and deSilva, 1995). Expression of both of these two genes has been the target for genetic modification. Asada et al. (1999) silenced the LeEXGT1 and deSilva et al. (1994) the LeXETB1 gene. In both cases antisense technology was employed. In neither case was an effect on the texture of the ripe fruit reported. Although it was shown that reduction or over-expression of LeEXGT1 resulted in smaller or larger fruit, respectively.
13.3.7 Expansin The last wall modifying protein to be discussed with respect to tomato fruit is expansin. This is an unusual protein in that it does not have any detectable hydrolase activity, yet it has clearly been shown to influence the structure of cellulose/hemicellulose frameworks (McQueen-Mason and Cosgrove, 1995). The protein has been shown to bind strongly to cellulose which is coated with matrix glycans, and it is thought to act by the disruption of the hydrogen bonds, thus allowing loosening of the wall and turgor-driven slippage (McQueen-Mason and Cosgrove, 1995; Whitney et al., 2000). This protein is again synthesised by several genes and occurs as several isoforms. In tomato fruit at least six genes have been identified and these are expressed differentially during ripening (Brummell et al., 1999c; Catala et al., 2000). The most abundant mRNA found in the ripe fruit is derived from the LeExp1 gene and this has been the target for genetic modification. Both down-regulation and over-expression of this gene resulted in modification of the softening process (Brummell et al., 1999b). Suppression of activity resulted in fruit with a 15–20% increase in firmness and with increased shelf life and processing quality (Brummell et al., 2002). Conversely, a three fold increase in expression resulted in fruit which softened more extensively. These changes in texture were accompanied by changes in the depolymerisation of cell wall polymers. Suppression of expansin gene expression prevented the depolymerisation of polyuronides normally associated with late ripening, whilst having no effect on the depolymerisation of the matrix glycans. Overexpression of this protein had no effect on polyuronide depolymerisation which proceeded as normal, but it was shown to enhance the depolymerisation of the matrix glucans, this presumably as a result of increased accessibility of the latter to wall hydrolases.
13.4 Other approaches to the manipulation of texture Whilst most of the work has been carried out in tomato, this fruit is by no means characteristic of all types of fruit ripening. In fact in some ways it is
334
Texture in food
actually atypical. This is particularly the case for PG activity, which is relatively high in tomato fruit but is low or even non-detectable in many other fruit such as strawberry, banana and melon. These fruit, in many cases, nonetheless still undergo extensive depolymerisation of their pectin backbones during ripening. There is another pectin degrading enzyme, pectate lyase (PEL). This enzyme can bring about the depolymerisation of polyuronides, not via a hydrolytic reaction as with PG, but through a β-elimination reaction targeted at the same chemical linkage, i.e. the α(1–4) link between galacturonic acid residues in the backbone of the pectin polymer. This enzyme has in the past been commonly associated with microorganisms, but it is becoming clear that it is also expressed in plant tissues. Pectate lyase in strawberry fruit has been inferred by the identification of at least two ripening related genes (Medina-Escobar et al., 1997; Benitez-Burraco et al., 2003). Two putative cDNA clones for PEL have also been identified in banana (DominguezPuigjaner, 1997; Pua et al., 2001; Marin-Rodriguez et al., 2003) one of which when expressed in yeast has been shown to encode a PEL enzyme (Marin-Rodriguez et al., 2003). This group, and others, have also demonstrated PEL activity in the fruit directly (Payasi and Sanwal, 2003). Antisense technology has been used to reduce the expression of a PEL gene in ripe strawberry, and this was accompanied by an increased firmness of the fruit (Jimenez-Bermudez et al., 2002) It is perhaps significant that in none of the cases described above has a major alteration to the texture of the intact fruit been achieved. This is perhaps not surprising given the complex nature of the cell wall and the fact that several hydrolytic activities are likely to be required to be modified in order to get a major effect. It is possible that the best approach would be to simultaneously target enzymes involved in the degradation of the two major cell wall domains, namely the pectin matrix and the hemicellulose /cellulose framework. This could be achieved by crossing plants in which individual enzymes have been down-regulated. An alternative approach would be to employ chimeric constructs aimed at two or more target endogenous genes. This was first achieved by Seymour et al., (1993) using PG and PE2 as the two target genes and has been described previously in this chapter. A single construct was made by ligating the 5’ region of the PG cDNA to the 3 region of the PE2 cDNA. When this single construct was used to transform fruit the resultant fruit were down-regulated for both enzyme activities. There was still no significant effect on fruit softening though. Recently, suppression of both PG and expansin together has resulted in significantly firmer tomato fruit (Powell et al., 2003). More recently a different approach seems to have been successful. All these degradative enzymes require to be targeted to the cell wall during ripening. It is thus possible that any disruption of this trafficking mechanism would mean that the cell wall hydrolases will not reach the wall and thus the fruit will remain firm. The process of trafficking within a plant cell is very complex and is outwith the scope of this review. However, this involves the
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation
335
complex interaction of many protein families including the so called rab GTPases (Rutherford and Moore, 2002). Early studies in this area identified a rab protein – rab11 – that appeared to be expressed in a ripening specific manner in mango fruit (Zainal et al., 1996). A close homologue to this mango protein was found in tomato fruit – although in this case expression was not entirely ripening specific (Lu et al., 2001). Silencing of this tomato rab11 protein resulted in fruit which whilst normal in all other respects, i.e. colour, shape, etc., retained their firmness for nearly twice as long as controls (Lu et al., 2001).
13.5 Future trends Although many degradative enzymes have been investigated for their effect on fruit texture using gene knock out techniques, they have by no means all been studied by this approach. Thus there is still scope in this area for examining the roles of arabinosidases and mannosidases for instance. Similarly, the role of isoforms has not really been addressed. Of particular interest may be the individual isoforms of pectinesterase. This enzyme is ubiquitous in that it is expressed in almost all plants and tissues. Its function is presently ambiguous in that it may be implicated in both the strengthening or weakening of the wall. To date only the fruit specific isoform of pectinesterase seems to have been targeted for silencing. It would be interesting to examine the relative roles of the fruit specific and constitutive isoforms. Finally there are several structural proteins associated with the plant cell wall (Cassab, 1998). The role of these, if any, in the determination of texture is not at all clear, and these might also be a target for gene silencing technology. It is unlikely that the reduction of any one enzyme activity would result in a significant change in texture. More progress may be made by using a combination of knockouts, and indeed, if these are targeted to different domains within the wall, a significant change in texture may well result. The approach of modifying the targeting of enzymes to the wall is also worthy of further investigation. Homologues of the rab11 from tomato fruit may exist in other fruit, and the effect of silencing these would be interesting. Protein engineering techniques may be employed in the near future to make subtle changes to the mode of action of these cell wall hydrolases. Information is accumulating on the domain structure and function of these hydrolases, in particular the microbial pectinases (Benen et al., 2002) and this could be used to modify the substrate specificity and functionality of these enzymes in genetically modified plants. One key example may again be pectinesterase – in this instance its functionality with respect to the size of the deesterified blocks formed may be a target for modification. Study of these enzymes is also important since, as well as determining texture, these cell wall components have many other useful functions (Thakur et al., 1997),
336
Texture in food
and it is likely that modification of these polymers, whilst perhaps not significant for texture within the whole plant, may have definite benefits in other areas. To date manipulation of cell wall polymers has focussed on modification of cell wall hydrolases. However, recent advances in genomics are highlighting many genes potentially encoding for enzymes involved in the biosynthesis of carbohydrate polymers including those of the cell wall (Henrissat et al., 2001). Whilst starch synthesis has been most intensively studied to date, significant progress is being made in the elucidation of the biochemical mechanisms involved in wall synthesis (Bolwell, 2000; Reiter, 2002). Most progress at present seems to be in the elucidation of genes involved with cellulose biosynthesis (Doblin et al., 2002), but those involved with the synthesis of other matrix polymers can also be sought using genetic-based techniques (Perrin et al., 2001; Ridley et al., 2001). This is providing a new set of gene targets for manipulation. Modification of these by gene silencing, or indeed by expression of new or over-expression of existing enzymes, may lead to some interesting polymers and may influence texture. Studies in this area have already started with, for example, the identification of transposon “knock out” mutants of several putative “cellulase synthase” genes in Arabidopsis (Bonetta et al., 2002). The QTL approach to defining the genetic basis of texture is likely to continue, but a complex trait like firmness may be difficult to study. Tomato QTL linked to texture attributes have been reported (Causse et al., 2001, 2002; Doganlar et al., 2002). This has already led to the production of a near isogenic line of tomato with good firmness (Frary et al., 2003). The technology is also being applied to other fruit such as apple (King et al., 2001), and QTL associated with texture attributes have been identified. Finally there is a need to integrate these genetic-based studies with those on a macro scale. Texture is likely to be determined not only at the molecular but at the supra molecular scale as well. Thus how modification to individual polymers translates into large scale modification of the tissue needs to be examined.
13.6 References and BRADY C J (1982) Purification and characterisation of the polygalacturonase of tomato fruit, Aust J of Plant Physiol, 9(1), 155–9. ARROWSMITH D A and DESILVA J (1995) Characterisation of two tomato fruit-expressed cDNAs encoding xyloglucan endo-transglycosylase, Plant Mol Biol, 28(3), 391–403. ASADA K, OHBA T, TAKAHASHI S and KATO I (1999) Alteration of fruit characteristics in transgenic tomatoes with modified gene expression of endo-xyloglucan transferase, HortScience, 34(3), 533. BENITEZ-BURRACO A, BLANCO-PORTALES R, REDONDO-NEVADO J, BELLIDO M L, MOYANO E, CABALLERO J L and MUNOZ-BLANCO J (2003) Cloning and characterisation of two ripening-related strawberry (fragaria x ananassa cv. Chandler) pectate lyase genes, J Ex Bot, 54(383), 633–45. ALI Z M
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation BENEN J A E, VICKEN J-P, VAN ALEBEEK G-J M
337
(2002) Microbial Pectinases. In Pectins and their Manipulation. Eds G B Seymour and J P Knox, Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press, 250–75. BIRD C R, SMITH C J S, RAY J A, MOREAU P, BEVAN M W, BIRD A S, HUGHES S, MORRIS P C, GRIERSON D and SCHUCH W (1988) The tomato polygalacturonase gene and ripening specific expression in transgenic plants, Plant Mol Biol, 11(5), 651–62. BOLWELL G P (2000) Biosynthesis of plant cell wall polysaccharides, Trends in Glycoscience and Glycotechnology, 12(65), 143–60. BONETTA D T, FACETTE M, RAAB T K and SOMERVILLE C R (2002) Genetic dissection of plant cell-wall biosynthesis, Biochem Soc Trans, 30(2), 298–301. BROWN T A (1995) Gene Cloning an Introduction (Third Edition). London, Chapman and Hall. BRUMMELL D A and HARPSTER M H (2001) Cell wall metabolism in fruit softening and quality and its manipulation in transgenic plants, Plant Mol Biol, 47(1–2), 311–40. BRUMMELL D A and LABOVITCH J M (1997) Effect of antisense suppression of endopolygalacturonase activity on polyuronide molecular weight in ripening tomato fruit and in fruit homogenates, Plant Physiol, 115(2), 717–25. BRUMMELL D A, LASKBROOK C C and BENNETT A B (1994) Plant endo-1,4-β-D-glucanase: structure, properties and physiological function. In Enzymatic Conversion of Biomass for Fuels Production. Eds M E Himmel, J O Baker and R P Overend, American Chemical Society symposium series 566, Washington, ACS, 100–129. BRUMMELL D A, HALL B D and BENNETT A B (1999a) Antisense suppression of tomato endo1,4-β glucanase Cel 2 mRNA accumulation increases the force required to break fruit abscission zones but does not effect fruit softening, Plant Mol Biol, 40(4), 615–22. BRUMMELL D A, HARPSTER M H, CIVELLO P M, PALYS J M, BENNETT A B and DUNSMUIR P (1999b) Modification of expansin protein abundance in tomato fruit alters softening and cell wall polymer metabolism, The Plant Cell, 11(11), 2203–16. BRUMMELL D A, HARPSTER M H and DUNSMUIR P (1999c) Differential expression of expansin gene family members during growth and ripening of tomato fruit, Plant Mol Biol, 39(1), 161–9. BRUMMELL D A, HOWIE W J, MA C and DUNSMUIR P (2002) Postharvest fruit quality of transgenic tomatoes suppressed in expression of a ripening-related expansin, Post Harvest Biol and Technology, 25(2), 209–20. CAREY A, HOLT K, PICARD S, WILDE R, TUCKER G A, BIRD C R, SCHUCH W and SEYMOUR G B (1995) Tomato exo-(1-4)-β-D-galactanase: isolation and changes during ripening in normal and mutant tomato fruit and characterisation of a related cDNA clone, Plant Physiol, 108(3), 1099–1107. CAREY A T, SMITH D L, HARRISON E, BIRD C R, GROSS K C, SEYMOUR G B and TUCKER G A (2001) Down-regulation of a ripening-related beta-galactosidase gene (TBG1) in transgenic tomato fruits, J Ex Bot, 52(357), 663–8. CARPITA N C and GIBEAUT D M (1973) Structural models of primary cell walls in flowering plants: consistency of molecular structure with the physical properties of the walls during cell growth, Plant J, 3(1), 1–30. CARPITA N C, CAMPBELL M and TIERNEY M (Eds) (2001) Plant cell walls. Plant Mol Biol, 47(1), 1–340. CARRINGTON C M S, GREVE L C and LABOVITCH J M (1993) Cell wall metabolism in ripening fruit. VI. Effect of the antisense polygalacturonase gene on cell wall changes accompanying ripening in transgenic tomatoes, Plant Physiol, 103(2), 429–34. CASSAB G I (1998) Plant cell wall proteins, Ann Rev Plant Physiol Mol Biol, 49, 281–309. CATALA C, ROSE J K C and BENNETT A B (2000) Auxin-regulated genes encoding cell wall modifying proteins are expressed during early tomato fruit growth, Plant Physiol, 122(2), 527–34. CAUSSE M, SALIBA-COLOMBANI V, LESSCHAEVE I and BURET M (2001) Genetic analysis of organoleptic quality in fresh market tomato.2. Mapping QTLs for sensory attributes, Theor Appl Genet, 102(2–3), 273–83.
338
Texture in food
CAUSSE M, SALIBA-COLOMBANI V, LECOMTE L, DUFFE P, ROUSSELLE P
and BURET M (2002) QTL analysis of fruit quality in fresh market tomato: a few chromosome regions control the variation of sensory and instrumental traits, J Ex Bot, 53(377), 2089–98. CHUN J P and HUBER D J (1997) Polygalacturonase isozyme 2 binding and catalysis in cell walls from tomato fruit: pH and β-subunit effects, Physiol Plant, 101(2), 283–90. CHUN J P and HUBER D J (2000) Reduced levels of beta-subunit protein influence tomato fruit firmness, cell-wall ultrastructure, and PG2-mediated pectin hydrolysis in excised pericarp tissue, J of Plant Physiol, 157(2), 153–60. COOLEY M B and YODER J I (1998) Insertional inactivation of the tomato polygalacturonase gene, Plant Mol Biol, 38(4), 521–30. DE SILVA J and VERHOEYEN M E (1998) Purification and characterisation of antisenseexogalactanase tomatoes. In Report of the demonstration programme on food safety evaluation of genetically modified foods as a basis for market introduction, The Hague, Netherlands Ministry of Economic Affairs, 99–106. DESILVA J, ARROWSMITH D, HEELYER A, WHITEMAN S and ROBINSON S (1994) Xyloglucan endotransglycosylase and plant growth, J Exp Bot, 45(280), 1693–701. DOBLIN M S, KUREK I, JACOB-WILK D and DELMER D P (2002) Cellulose biosynthesis in plants: from genes to rosettes, Plant and Cell Physiol, 43(12), 1407–20. DOGANLAR S, FRARY A, KU H M and TANKSLEY S D (2002) Mapping quantitative trait loci in inbred backcross lines of Lycopersicon pimpinellifolium, Genome, 45(6), 1189–202. DOMINGUEZ-PUIGJANER E, LLOP I, VENDRELL M and PRAT S (1997) A cDNA clone highly expressed in ripe banana fruit shows homology to pectate lyases, Plant Physiol, 114(3), 1071–6. ERRINGTON N, TUCKER G A and MITCHELL J R (1998) Effect of genetic down-regulation of polygalacturonase and pectin esterase activity on rheology and composition of tomato juice, J Sci Food Agric, 76(4), 515–19. FAULKNER K, MITHEN R and WILLIAMSON G (1988) Selective increase of the potential anticarcinogen 4-methylsulphinylbutyl glucosinolate in broccoli, Carcinogenesis, 19(4), 605–9. FENWICK K M, JARVIS M C, APPERLEY D C, SEYMOUR G B and BIRD C R (1996) Polymer mobility in cell walls of transgenic tomatoes with reduced polygalacturonase activity, Phytochem, 42(2), 301–7. FISCHER R L and BENNETT A B (1991) Role of cell wall hydrolases in fruit ripening, Ann Rev of Plant Physiol and Plant Mol Biol, 42, 675–703. FRARY A, DOGANLAR S, FRAMPTON A, FULTON T, UHLIG J, YATES H and TANKSLEY S (2003) Fine mapping of quantitative trait loci for improved fruit characteristics from Lycopersicon chielewskii chromosome 1, Genome, 46(2), 235–43. GAFFE J, TIEMAN D M and HANDA A V (1994) Pectinmethylesterase isoforms in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) tissues: effects of expression of a pectinmethylesterase antisense gene, Plant Physiol, 105(1), 199–203. GAFFE J, TIZNADO M E and HANDA A K (1997) Characterization and functional expression of a ubiquitously expressed tomato pectin methylesterase, Plant Physiol, 114(4), 1547– 56. GIOVANNONI J (2001) Molecular biology of fruit maturation and ripening, Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol, 52, 725–49. GIOVANNONI J J , DELLAPENNA D, BENNETT A B and FISCHER R L (1989) Expression of a chimeric polygalacturonase gene in transgenic rin (ripening inhibitor) tomato fruit results in polyuronide degradation, but not fruit softening, The Plant Cell, 1(1), 53–63. GONZALEZ-BOSCH C, BRUMMELL D A and BENNETT A B (1996) Differential expression of two endo-1,4-β-glucanase genes in pericarpand locules of wild-type and mutant tomato fruit, Plant Physiol, 111(4) 1313–19. GRANT G T, MORRIS E R, REES D A, SMITH P J C and THORN D (1973) Biological interactions between polysaccharides and divalent cations: the egg-box model, FEBS lett, 32, 195– 8.
Improving fruit and vegetable texture by genetic transformation
339
HALL L H, TUCKER G A, SMITH C J, WATSON C F, SEYMOUR G B, BUNDICK Y, BONIWELL J M, FLETCHER J D, RAY J A, SCHUCH W, BIRD C R
and GRIERSON D (1993) Antisense inhibition of pectin esterase gene expression in transgenic tomatoes, The Plant J, 3(1), 121–9. HALL L N, BIRD C R, PICTON S P, TUCKER G A, SEYMOUR G B and GRIERSON D (1994) Molecular characterisation of cDNA clones representing pectin esterase isozymes from tomato, Plant Mol Biol, 25(2), 313–18. HARPSTER M H, BRUMMELL D A and DUNSMUIR P (2002a) Suppression of a ripening-related endo-1,-beta-glucanase in transgenic pepper fruit does not prevent depolymerisation of cell wall polysaccharides during ripening, Plant Mol Biol, 50(3), 345–55. HARPSTER M H, DAWSON D M, NEVINS D J, DUNSMUIR P and BRUMMELL D A (2002b) Constitutive expression of a ripening-related pepper endo-1,-beta-glucanase in transgenic tomato fruit does not increase xyloglucan depolymerisation or fruit softening, Plant Mol Biol, 50(3), 357–69. HARRIMAN R W , TIEMAN D M and HANDA A K (1991) Molecular cloning of tomato pectinmethylesterase gene and its expression in Rutgers, ripening inhibitor, nonripening and never ripe tomato fruits, Plant Physiol, 97(1), 80–87. HENRISSAT B, COUTINHO P M and DAVIES G J (2001) A census of carbohydrate-active enzymes in the genome of Arabidopsis thaliana, Plant Mol Biol, 47(1), 55–72. HOBSON G E (1964) Polygalacturonase in normal and abnormal tomato fruit, Biochem J, 92, 324–32. HUBER D J (1983) Polyuronise degradation and hemicellulose modifications in ripening tomato fruit, J Am Soc Hort Sci, 108(3), 405–9. JIMENEZ-BERMUDEZ S, MUNOZ-BLANCO J, CABALLERO J L, LOPEZ-ARANDA J M, VALPUESTA V, PLIEGOALFARO F, QUESADA M A and MERCADO J A (2002) Manipulation of strawberry fruit softening by antisense expression of a pectate lyase gene, Plant Physiol, 128(2), 751– 9. JONES C G, SCOTHERN G P, LYCETT G W and TUCKER G A (1998) The effect of chimeric architecture on co-ordinated gene silencing, Planta, 204(4), 499–505. KALAITZIS P, HONG S-B, SOLOMOS T and TUCKER M L (1999) Molecular characterization of a tomato endo-β-1,4-glucanase gene expressed in mature pistils, abscission zones and fruit, Plant Cell Physiol, 40(8), 905–8. KING G J, LYNN J R, DOVER C J, EVANS K M and SEYMOUR G B (2001) Resolution of quantitative trait loci for mechanical measures accounting for genetic variation in fruit texture of apple (Malu pumila Mill.), Theor Appl Genet, 102(8), 1227–35. KOCH J L and NEVINS D J (1989) Tomato fruit cell wall. I. Use of purified tomato polygalacturonase and pectinmethylesterase to identify developmental changes in pectins, Plant Physiol, 91(3), 816–22. KRAMER M, SANDERS R, BOLKAN H, WATERS C, SHEEHY R E and HIATT W R (1992) Postharvest evaluation of transgenic tomatoes with reduced levels of polygalacturonase: processing, firmness and disease resistance, Postharvest Bio Technol, 1(3), 241–55. LANGLEY K R, MARTIN A, STENNING R, MURRAY A J, HOBSON G E, SCHUCH W and BIRD C R (1994) Mechanical and optical assessment of the ripening of tomato fruit with reduced polygalacturonase activity, J Sci Food Agric, 66(4), 547–54. LASHBROOK C C, GONZALEZ-BOSCH C and BENNETT A B (1994) Two divergent tomato endo-1,4β glucanase genes exhibit overlapping expression in ripening fruit and abscising flowers, Plant Cell, 6(10), 1485–3. LASHBROOK C C, GIOVANNONI J J, HALL B D, FISCHER R L and BENNETT A B (1998) Transgenic analysis of tomato endo-1,4-β glucanase gene function. Role of Cel1 in floral abscission, Plant J, 13(3), 303–10. LU C, ZAINAL Z, TUCKER G and LYCETT G (2001) Developmental abnormalities and reduced fruit softening in tomato plants expressing an antisense Rab11 GTPase gene, The Plant Cell, 13(1), 1–15. LYCETT G W, GRIERSON D and TUCKER G A (1996) Mechanisms and Applications of Gene Silencing. Nottingham, Nottingham University Press.
340
Texture in food
MARIN-RODRIGUEZ M C, SMITH D L, MANNING K, ORCHARD J
and SEYMOUR G B (2003) Pectate lyase gene expression and enzyme activity in ripening banana fruit, Plant Mol Biol, 51(6) 851–7. MCCANN M C and ROBERTS K (1991) Architecture of the primary cell wall. In The Cytoskeletal Basis of Plant Growth and Form. Ed. C W Lloyd, London, Academic Press, 109–29. MCQUEEN-MASON S J and COSGROVE D J (1995) Expansin mode of action on cell walls. Analysis of wall hydrolysis, stress relaxation and binding, Plant Physiol, 107(1), 87– 100. MEDINA-ESCOBAR N, CARDENAS J, MOYANO E, CABALLERO J L and MUNOZ-BLANCO J (1997) Cloning, molecular characterisation and expression pattern of a strawberry ripening-specific cDNA with sequence homology to pectate lyase from higher plants, Plant Mol Biol, 34(6), 867–77. PAYASI A and SANWAL G G (2003) Pectate lyase activity during ripening of banana fruit, Phytochem, 63(3), 243–8. PERRIN R, WILKERSON C and KEEGSTRA K (2001) Golgi enzymes that synthesize plant cell wall polysaccharides: finding and evaluating candidates in the genomic era, Plant Mol Biol, 47(1–2), 115–30. POGSON B J,