THE IRISH IN POST-WAR BRITAIN
This page intentionally left blank
The Irish in Post-War Britain ENDA DEL ANEY
1
1...
297 downloads
1708 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE IRISH IN POST-WAR BRITAIN
This page intentionally left blank
The Irish in Post-War Britain ENDA DEL ANEY
1
1
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford ox2 6dp Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With offices in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York © Enda Delaney 2007
The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First published 2007 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose the same condition on any acquirer British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Delaney, Enda, 1971The Irish in post-war Britain / Enda Delaney. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-19-927667-7 (acid-free paper) 1. Irish—Great Britain— History—20th century. 2. Ireland—Emigration and immigration— History—20th century. 3. Great Britain—Emigration and immigration— History—20th century. 4. Great Britain—Ethnic relations—History— 20th century. I. title. DA125 . I7D45 2007 941 . 00491’62—dc22 2007028207 Typeset by Laserwords Private Limited, Chennai, India Printed in Great Britain on acid-free paper by Biddles Ltd., King’s Lynn, Norfolk ISBN 978–0–19–927667–7 1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2
For J. T. N. D.
This page intentionally left blank
Contents Acknowledgements Abbreviations
viii x
Introduction
1
1. Leaving Home
10
2. In a Strange Land
45
3. People and Places
86
4. Cultures of Adjustment
127
5. A Sense of Self
176
Select Bibliography Index
210 223
Acknowledgements Many friends and colleagues have contributed in different ways to this book. After completing my postgraduate work at Queen’s University Belfast, under the expert tutelage of Liam Kennedy, I was fortunate to secure a research fellowship at the Institute of Irish Studies, and then subsequently a lectureship in the School of History in 1999. At this time Queen’s Belfast was an exciting place to be for an Irish historian. Discussions and debates with such talented scholars as Tim Bowman, Sean Connolly, Peter Hart, Alvin Jackson, Liam Kennedy, Patrick Maume, and Fearghal McGarry have profoundly influenced my approach to writing the history of the Irish abroad. Other people who offered encouragement and guidance included Bruce Campbell, Ian Green, and the late Martin Lynn. From 2000 until 2005 I was involved with the first phase of the Centre for Irish and Scottish Studies at the University of Aberdeen funded by the UK Arts and Humanities Research Council. During this period the Diaspora project, under the leadership of Tom Devine, established Aberdeen as the UK’s leading centre for diaspora and migration history, and brought me into direct contact with a number of the leading international figures in this field. In 2004 I moved to Aberdeen for a post in the Research Institute of Irish and Scottish Studies and the School of Divinity, History and Philosophy, and I would like to thank the following individuals for sharing ideas and offering support during my time there: Nathan Abrams, Andrew Blaikie, Nick Evans, the late Janet Hendry, Allan Macinnes, Andrew Mackillop, Angela McCarthy, Esther Mijers, Micheál Ó Siochrú and David Worthington. Since joining the School of History and Classics in Edinburgh University in late 2006, I have been reunited with a senior figure in the profession who has helped shape my career over the last decade. Since I first met Tom Devine in 1998, I have never ceased to be impressed by his energy, vigour, and intellectual leadership. From my undergraduate days at National University of Ireland Maynooth, Vincent Comerford has been a source of inspiration and a much-valued mentor and friend, who always makes time to offer wise advice. Don MacRaild, perhaps more so than anyone else, has helped shape my thinking about the Irish in modern Britain and equally urged me to
Acknowledgements
ix
think critically about the scope, purpose, and objectives of this project, as well as being a good friend and pioneering co-worker in this field. Kevin Kenny, who, through his own pioneering work on transatlantic approaches to studying the American Irish, has established new ways of looking at the history of the Irish overseas offered sharp insights and constructive criticism on my earlier work. Marianne Elliott kindly took time away from her own writing to read and comment on a draft chapter and offered much encouragement and a number of incisive suggestions. Other friends, colleagues, and professional archivists have offered advice, provided references, or identified relevant source materials. My thanks go to John Belchem, Mary E. Daly, Revd Ian Dickie (Westminster Diocesan Archives), Canon Anthony Dolan (Nottingham Catholic Archives), Diarmaid Ferriter, Liam Harte, Micheal Kennedy, Siobhan Kirrane (Luton Museum Service), Tina Morton (Brent Archive), Noirin Moynihan (National University of Ireland), Sean O’Connell, Louise Ryan, Revd Dr John Sharp (Birmingham Archdiocesan Archives), David C. Sheehy (Dublin Diocesan Archives), and A. E. C. W. Spencer. The research on which this book is based was supported by the Research and Conferences Fund, Queen’s University Belfast, the AHRC Centre for Irish and Scottish Studies at the University of Aberdeen, and a Small Research Grant from the British Academy. This financial support for my work enabled me to consult materials held in archives throughout Britain and Ireland, for which I am very grateful. Anne Gelling at Oxford University Press originally accepted my proposal to write on this subject. Her successor as commissioning editor, Rupert Cousens, has dealt with this project in a similarly professional and efficient manner. Zoe Washford and Rachel Woodforde guided me through the production process and Dorothy McCarthy did a superb job of copy-editing the original text. The dedication reflects a debt of gratitude to my father, who insisted that conventional wisdom should always be questioned and challenged. He, together with my dearly missed mother, created the environment where discussions about politics and history were part and parcel of everyday conversations. Thanks to my wife, Kathryn, for her constant support which sustained me during the inevitable dark days that accompany any writing project. E. D. Edinburgh November 2006
Abbreviations Archives AAW ADA BDA BL DDA LM LRO NAI NSA PRO TCD
Westminster Archdiocesan Archives Armagh Diocesan Archives Birmingham Archdiocesan Archives British Library Dublin Diocesan Archives Luton Museum Liverpool Record Office National Archives of Ireland National Sound Archive National Archives, Kew Manuscripts Department, Trinity College Dublin
Records CAB DFA DO DT HO LAB
Cabinet Papers Department of Foreign Affairs Dominions Office Department of the Taoiseach Home Office Ministry of Labour
Introduction As a first-year history undergraduate frantically preparing an essay on what was then the standard question on the causes of the Industrial Revolution in Britain, I came across on the library shelves Eric Hobsbawn’s pioneering survey of British economic and social history, Industry and Empire, published in 1968. I was quite taken by the engaging style of writing, and set about incorporating his compelling interpretation of the origins of the Industrial Revolution into an essay, which prior to this discovery was based on a number of dull and, it must be said, rather uninspiring standard textbooks on economic history. After extracting the relevant arguments and completing the essay, I flicked through the index to check if anything about Ireland or the Irish was listed there. Much to my surprise the Irish did feature, and not just in the seemingly obligatory references to the Great Famine of the 1840s, political violence in the early part of the twentieth century, or the ‘Irish Question’, as is still the norm for most general works on modern Britain. They were part of what he perceptively identified as ‘the other Britain’.¹ Unusually for an ambitious work of such breadth, Hobsbawn detailed the significant role of the Irish in nineteenth- and twentieth-century Britain. In Hobsbawn’s view the contribution of the Irish was ‘capital’.² He also warned against making unproven assumptions about the extent of assimilation by the mid-twentieth century, after the second great wave of Irish arrivals in the 1940s and 1950s: To say that this immigration has been assimilated would be misleading. However, it has increasingly become accepted, because invisible—at any rate compared to the much more obviously recognizable new migrants of the 1950s. The political separation of Ireland from Britain in 1921 had also eliminated one major reason why Englishmen and Scotsmen should be aware of Ireland and the Irish. Little by little the tensions between the communities have become less.³ ¹ E. J. Hobsbawn, Industry and Empire (Penguin edn., London, 1969), 312. ² Ibid. 311. ³ Ibid. 294–312.
2
Introduction
Hobsbawn’s assessment lodged in the deeper recesses of my memory, as such an acknowledgement of the Irish role was—and still is—a relatively rare occurrence in general accounts of modern British history, and prompted me some ten years later to begin research on this topic. Since the 1960s British historians have increasingly turned their attention to the neglected histories of this ‘other Britain’, in all its various guises. What emerges from a huge range of historical writing is that modern Britain was a complex mosaic of competing national and ethnic identities, a diverse society that included migrants and other minorities and outsiders of various forms, and incorporated overlapping class, gender, and regional cultures within fluid and ever-shifting structures of power and authority.⁴ Occupying a central position in this ‘other Britain’ were the Irish. Throughout the twentieth century the Irish were the single largest foreign-born population in Britain.⁵ During the second half of the century more than one million Irish people travelled ‘across the water’ in search of a better life. By the mid-1960s, when public concern about the levels of Caribbean and South Asian immigration reached its height, Britain’s Irish population at just under one million was by a long stretch still the largest migrant group. Yet the Irish attracted relatively little attention, in part because they were far less visible than other newcomers, and they were perceived to be ‘largely accepted’.⁶ However, this degree of ‘acceptance’ was fragile and subject to rapid renegotiation, as became painfully obvious in the early 1970s when IRA bombings in Birmingham and elsewhere reinvigorated long-standing enmities and prejudices, which had only surfaced sporadically in the post-war years.⁷ The significance of the Irish in post-war Britain, however, is not solely a consequence of sheer numbers. They had some unique characteristics ⁴ See, for example, Richard Weight, Patriots: National Identity in Britain, 1940–2000 (London, 2002), which surveys much of the literature for the post-war period. See also the seminal account of England in the first half of the twentieth century: Ross McKibbin, Classes and Cultures: England, 1918–1951 (Oxford, 1998). ⁵ Officially the census did not regard the Irish as a ‘foreign’ population, for reasons that will become apparent. ⁶ E. J. B. Rose et al., Colour and Citizenship: A Report on British Race Relations (London, 1969), 19. This figure includes those born in Northern Ireland, approximately one quarter of the total in both 1961 and 1971. ⁷ An assessment of the effects of the IRA bombings on the Irish in England prior to the Birmingham pub bombings in November 1974 can be found in Paul Harrison, ‘Culture and Migration: The Irish English’, New Society, 25, no. 272 (1973), 699–702. For the situation afterwards, see Mary Hickman and Bronwen Walter, Discrimination and the Irish Community in Britain (London, 1997), 210–19.
Introduction
3
compared with other migrants from the Caribbean, continental Europe, Africa, and South Asia. They were white and spoke English; most were Roman Catholics; the majority only viewed living in Britain as a temporary sojourn until the Irish economy improved; unlike other immigrants in the 1960s, Irish citizens were not subjected to any form of restriction on entry; they arrived in roughly equal numbers of men and women; they were the latest wave of a historical tradition of Irish movement to Britain which existed since the late eighteenth century; and they came from a recently established new state that had been part of the United Kingdom until 1921–2. Often perceived to be similar to other inhabitants, many retained strongly cherished notions of a distinctive Irish identity, sustained in part by constant interaction with the society that they had left. A sense of home was never far from the minds of the Irish in post-war Britain. This book concentrates on this generation who left independent Ireland from the late 1940s until the late 1960s. Much of the coverage is centred on the late 1940s and 1950s when huge numbers of Irish came to Britain, and greater emphasis is placed on these initial years of settlement. This account is confined to those born in independent Ireland (or the twenty-six counties before 1921), rather than the children or grandchildren of those people who had already settled in Britain before the Second World War. The second generation feature when appropriate, such as in accounts of growing up with Irish parents or perceptions of life in Britain. A multigenerational study of those of Irish ethnic descent—the Irish-British, the Irish-English, or the Irish in Scotland—is regrettably beyond the scope of this book.⁸ Other historical writings have explored the reasons for the mass migrations from twentieth-century Ireland and identified the consequences for Irish society from the perspective of the sending country.⁹ This book ⁸ For a preliminary indication of the profile of the second-generation Irish, see Mary J. Hickman, Sarah Morgan, and Bronwen Walter, Second-Generation Irish People in Britain: A Demographic, Socio-Economic and Health Profile (London, 2001). An anthropological multigenerational study of the Irish in the United States is Reginald Byron, Irish America (Oxford, 1999). ⁹ Mary E. Daly, The Slow Failure: Population Decline and Independent Ireland, 1920–1973 (Madison, 2006); Enda Delaney, Demography, State and Society: Irish Migration to Britain, 1921–1971 (Kingston/Montreal and Liverpool, 2000); id., Irish Emigration Since 1921 (Dublin, 2002); P. J. Drudy, ‘Migration between Britain and Ireland Since Independence’, in P. J. Drudy (ed.), Ireland and Britain Since 1922 (Cambridge, 1986) (Irish Studies 5), 107–23; Donal Garvey, ‘The History of Migration
4
Introduction
covers the second part of the story of this migrant generation, a neglected element of both British history and the history of the Irish overseas. It is the first major historical study of the post-war Irish in Britain to be published in over forty years, since John Archer Jackson’s seminal but now dated account which covered nearly two hundred years.¹⁰ In many respects, Jackson’s work was a product of its time. For instance, Irish women, who slightly outnumbered males, are almost completely absent from his narrative, and he was particularly concerned with the public reaction to large-scale Irish settlement. The intellectual framework in which he presented his findings was based around the now largely discredited process of one-sided immigrant assimilation, a key concern for historians and sociologists writing in the 1950s and 1960s.¹¹ Yet, with extraordinary regularity when writing this book and making a point that appeared to be original, I found, on consulting Jackson’s work, he had already covered similar territory. Frustrating as this was, it is a testament to his perceptive analysis, which was based almost exclusively on printed materials. Even with the increasing availability of unpublished records since the 1970s, many of the major findings of his study still stand the test of time. Since then, apart from one journalist, few historians have ventured into the more recent history of the Irish in Britain.¹² For the second half of the twentieth century, the best available historical account still remains Colin Holmes’s excellent overview of immigration and British society since the end of the nineteenth century.¹³ Inevitably his coverage of the Irish was circumscribed by the ambitious scope of the Flows in the Republic of Ireland’, Population Trends, 39 (1985), 22–30; J. J. Sexton, ‘Emigration and Immigration in the Twentieth Century: An Overview’, in J. R. Hill (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 7: Ireland, 1921–1984 (Oxford, 2003), 796–825; Pauric Travers, ‘ ‘‘The Dream Gone Bust’’: Irish Responses to Emigration, 1922–60’, in Oliver MacDonagh and W. F. Mandle (eds.), Irish-Australian Studies (Canberra, 1989), 318–42. ¹⁰ John Archer Jackson, The Irish in Britain (London, 1963). ¹¹ See Russell A. Kazal, ‘Revisiting Assimilation: The Rise, Fall, and Reappraisal of a Concept in American Ethnic History’, American Historical Review, 100, no. 2 (1995), 437–71. ¹² Kevin O’Connor, The Irish in Britain (London, 1972). See, for example, the listings in Maureen Hartigan and Mary Hickman, The History of the Irish in Britain: A Bibliography (London, 1986). One sociologist, Liam Ryan, has written a wide-ranging article based on his unpublished Ph.D. thesis: see ‘Irish Emigration to Britain Since World War II’, in Richard Kearney (ed.), Migrations: The Irish at Home and Abroad (Dublin, 1990), 45–67. ¹³ Colin Holmes, John Bull’s Island: Immigration and British Society, 1871–1971 (Basingstoke, 1988).
Introduction
5
book. Given the range and high quality of published accounts of the Irish in Britain for the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, this seems a curious anomaly. It may well be that historians view the more recent past as essentially the territory of the social scientist. Indeed, the more challenging findings on the Irish in post-war Britain have come from other disciplines such as sociology and geography.¹⁴ Much of this work is, however, infused with a strong theoretical component, which alienates those less versed in the abstruse vocabulary of postcolonial studies. What this book offers which is distinctive is a historical interpretation that seeks to locate those who arrived in the post-war years within the wider context of Irish settlement since the early nineteenth century. This long-range historical perspective is often lacking in social scientific accounts, leading to an inability or unwillingness to identify continuities and variations over the past two hundred years. By drawing on this rich historiography, it is possible to see how much had changed and equally what had stayed constant over time.¹⁵ This book does not aim to be comprehensive, covering every aspect of a bewildering array of individual experiences, but rather to identify and explore a number of key analytical questions. One of the overarching arguments is that there was no universal historical experience of being Irish in post-war Britain. Even if in the eyes of sometimes unsympathetic observers, the Irish were all the ¹⁴ e.g. Mary Hickman, Religion, Class, and Identity: The State, the Catholic Church, and the Education of the Irish in Britain (Aldershot, 1995); id., The Irish Community in Britain: Myth or Reality? (London, 1986); Hickman and Walter, Discrimination and the Irish Community in Britain. Bronwen Walter has also published extensively on this topic since the 1980s: for her recent contribution, see Outsiders Inside: Whiteness, Place and Irish Women (London, 2000). ¹⁵ Especially important works include Steven Fielding, Class and Ethnicity: Irish Catholics in England, 1880–1939 (Buckingham, 1993); David Fitzpatrick, ‘ ‘‘A Peculiar Tramping People’’: The Irish in Britain, 1801–70’, in W. E. Vaughan (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 5: Ireland Under the Union, I (1801–70) (Oxford, 1989), 623–60; David Fitzpatrick, ‘The Irish in Britain, 1871–1921’, in W. E. Vaughan (ed.), A New History of Ireland. Vol. 6: Ireland Under the Union, II (1870–1921) (Oxford, 1996), 653–702; Lynn Hollen Lees, Exiles of Erin: Irish Migrants in Victorian London (Manchester, 1979); M. A. G. Ó Tuathaigh, ‘The Irish in Nineteenth-Century Britain: Problems of Integration’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 5th ser., 31 (1981), 149–73; Roger Swift and Sheridan Gilley (eds.), The Irish in the Victorian City (London, 1985); Roger Swift and Sheridan Gilley (eds.), The Irish in Britain, 1815–1939 (London, 1989); Roger Swift and Sheridan Gilley (eds.), The Irish in Victorian Britain: The Local Dimension (Dublin, 1999). The best recent summary of this vast literature, which also incorporates a significant interpretative element and a valuable bibliographical essay, is Donald M. MacRaild, Irish Migrants in Modern Britain, 1750–1922 (Basingstoke, 1999).
6
Introduction
same, diversity rather than uniformity was the hallmark of the Irish migrant experience in Britain after 1945. Too often it was instinctively assumed by contemporaries that Irish nationality ensured a common mindset, pattern of behaviour, or ideological commitment. Geographical location, occupations, levels of education, length of time in Britain, gender, and most importantly social class shaped the divergent and often radically different experiences of the generation who left post-war Ireland. This heterogeneous character of the history of Britain’s Irish population after the Second World War is rarely acknowledged. The American historian John Bodnar’s comments on the historiography of immigrants in the nineteenth-century United States apply with equal force to the Irish in post-war Britain: Most previous descriptions of immigrants assume that the immigrant experience was a common experience shared equally by all; the transition to capitalism is either entirely difficult, conducted entirely within the confines of a traditional but apparently adaptive culture, or entirely rewarding over a given period of time. But even the most cursory glance at an immigrant community or stream will suggest that not all newcomers behaved in a similar fashion, that varying degrees of commitment to an assortment of cultures and ideologies were evident, and that not everyone faced identical experiences.¹⁶
In addition to presenting a more textured account, a second distinctive feature is the focus on the transnational history of the Irish in post-war Britain.¹⁷ Older histories often began the story of a migrant group on landing in the receiving country, with only a hazy knowledge or grasp of the social organization of the society which they had left. As migrants crossed the boundaries of nation-states the world over, few shed their cultural baggage and wholeheartedly embraced the values and norms of the host society where they settled. The complex process of negotiation and renegotiation that was involved in adapting and adjusting to life in an unfamiliar society lies at the heart of this book. A convincing interpretation of how migrants made sense of the new social worlds that they encountered in post-war Britain must take account of both elements of the society that they left and the landscape that they ¹⁶ John Bodnar, The Transplanted: A History of Immigrants in Urban America (Bloomington, 1985), p. xvi. ¹⁷ For an assessment of the value and weaknesses of such a transnational approach with particular relevance to this study, see Kevin Kenny, ‘Diaspora and Comparison: The Global Irish as a Case Study’, Journal of American History, 90, no. 1 (2003), 134–62, and more generally, Wendy Webster, ‘Transnational Journeys and Domestic Histories’, Journal of Social History, 39, no. 3 (2006), 651–66.
Introduction
7
now inhabited. This book demonstrates that any understanding of how the Irish interacted with each other and the wider society was as much shaped by experiences prior to leaving Ireland as by subsequent events in Britain. Even the migrants themselves recognized this. As the sociologist Liam Ryan, who had just embarked on a large-scale ethnographic study in the early 1970s, was pointedly told by one migrant, ‘if you want to understand the Irish in England, you are wasting your time and your money coming to London; go back to Ireland and take a good look at the Irish at home’.¹⁸ This study is based on a wide range of unpublished materials, from official government records to the available archives held by Catholic dioceses in both Ireland and Britain. Throughout the 1940s the Irish state kept a close eye on its displaced citizenry and so did the British authorities at particular points in time. The extensive papers of John Charles McQuaid, Catholic archbishop of Dublin from 1940 until 1972, proved particularly useful as McQuaid retained a keen—perhaps even obsessive—interest in the ‘moral and spiritual welfare’ of the exiled Irish in Britain. Inevitably the documentation is heavily weighted towards what contemporaries identified as ‘problems’. These included the young single pregnant females who left for England to have a child, or the perceived widespread falling off in religious practice. Other historians have used this body of material, although few have consulted corresponding documentation held in Catholic archives in Britain.¹⁹ In a sense this was the documentary trace of the Irish in post-war Britain.²⁰ But this study seeks to move beyond the archive into the more fragmented sphere of the migrant mentalité, the ways in which people conceptualized their world and their understanding of their place within it. Very rarely do the voices of the migrants themselves feature in the masses of official or church documentation, and this book could simply have descended into a catalogue of one ‘problem’ after another, with the migrants emerging as passive subjects with little agency or indeed power to influence their own lives. The challenge for historians is to ¹⁸ Quoted by Liam Ryan, ‘Religious Practice Among Irish Emigrants’, Social Studies, 3, no. 2 (1974), 222. ¹⁹ Daly, The Slow Failure; Lindsey Earner-Byrne, ‘The Boat to England: An Analysis of the Official Reactions to the Emigration of Single Expectant Irishwomen to Britain, 1922–1972’, Irish Economic and Social History, 30 (2003), 52–70; Kieran O’Shea, The Irish Emigrant Chaplaincy Scheme in Britain, 1957–82 (Naas, 1985). ²⁰ For the concept of the documentary trace and the archive, see Paul Ricoeur, Time and Narrative, Vol. 3 (Chicago, 1988), 116–17; id., Memory, History and Forgetting (Chicago, 2004), 166–81.
8
Introduction
explore the interactions between social realities and individual needs and to recover ‘the complexities of the lived experience’.²¹ Forms of personal testimony such as oral histories, memoirs, and autobiographies are extensively used to reconstruct the lived experience of migration and settlement, and to re-create what Bodnar terms the ‘culture of everyday life’.²² This inner history of immigration can only be probed by looking beyond the traditional documentary sources of historical enquiry.²³ Unlike official or ecclesiastical documentation, personal testimonies show that few people thought of their own lives in dichotomous terms, whether it be segregation in Irish ‘ghettos’ or wholesale assimilation, ‘good’ or ‘bad’ Catholics, or even success or failure. Such inner histories were often characterized by ambivalences, as Robert Orsi observed for Italian immigrants in Harlem in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.²⁴ The same can be said for the Irish in post-war Britain. Most retained a deep loyalty to home in the abstract sense of place rather than the Irish nation-state, yet recognized the material benefits of living in this ‘strange’ land. Others readily acknowledged the damaging consequences of Catholic hegemony of social and cultural life in independent Ireland, but still viewed Catholicism as an important component of individual identities. Some went as far as expressing anger at Britain’s historical role in Irish history yet just as instinctively identified ‘tolerance’ and ‘fair play’ as core English values. Migration by its very nature involved emotions. Leaving family and friends in Ireland was for many a deeply traumatic moment. Apprehension and a sense of venturing into the unknown naturally heightened anxieties, although these were often lessened by the knowledge that friendly faces were awaiting their arrival. Loneliness, alienation, dislocation, displacement with a disconnected sense of place and a perception of not belonging, are widely viewed as emotional responses to life in a new society.²⁵ Such emotions often went hand in hand with perceived needs. As Orsi argues, ‘the inner history of immigration is also a story of ²¹ Megan Vaughan, ‘Liminal’, London Review of Books, 28, no. 6 (2006), 15. ²² Bodnar, The Transplanted, 206–16. ²³ This term is taken from the impressive study of Robert Orsi, The Madonna of 115th Street: Faith and Community in Italian Harlem, 1880–1950, 2nd edn. (New Haven, 2002), 150. ²⁴ Ibid. 162. ²⁵ An imaginative account of this sense of dislocation can be found in Timothy O’Grady and Steve Pyke, I Could Read the Sky (London, 1997); see also the fascinating autobiographical account of Eva Hoffman, Lost in Translation: A Life in a New Language (New York, 1989).
Introduction
9
complex needs: for success, stability, participation, autonomy, faithfulness to tradition and an openness to the new ways, the need to recreate the familiar while in the midst of change’.²⁶ Lastly, this book eschews the traditional chronological structure much favoured by historians and instead is organized on a thematic basis, with each theme forming the analytical core of a chapter. The first chapter establishes the context of departure from Ireland and illustrates how migration to Britain became the established route for those who had lost any hope in the ability of the independent Irish state to provide jobs, economic security, or the range of opportunities so often associated with living in a ‘modern’ society. This disenchantment was one of the driving forces behind the massive exodus of the post-war years. Chapter 2 charts initial responses to the new environment as well as the ambiguous position of the Irish within the broader social landscape of post-war Britain. Where the Irish settled and how they coped with everyday life in Britain forms the core of the third chapter. By drawing on familiar elements such as the Catholic church, patterns of social interaction as well as leisure pursuits, it was possible to re-create a sense of home away from home, and these complex processes of adjustment and adaptation are examined in Chapter 4. The final chapter brings together much of the earlier arguments and maps out how individual and collective identities interacted, the ways in which the Irish imagined themselves and equally how they were perceived by others. ²⁶ Orsi, The Madonna of 115th Street, 162.
1 Leaving Home Young people left independent Ireland in droves throughout the 1940s and 1950s. Loved ones lamented their departure yet at the same time recognized the basic necessity of earning a livelihood and resigned themselves to looking forward to some day in the future when conditions would improve so that their family and friends could at last return home permanently. Post-war Britain offered hope to this disenchanted generation who had little to gain from staying in their country of birth, and was still close enough that relationships could be maintained across the Irish Sea. These reluctant exiles then set about making sense of the new social worlds that they were now a part of, a complex process of adaptation that was often guided by kin and friends already settled there, while at the same time rarely forgetting about the world that they had left. Unlike earlier generations who left Ireland for North America and Australasia, however, this decision did not involve a complete rupture with the homeland. Family gatherings, weddings, funerals, and holidays all made for continuing interactions with the homeland. Before turning to the dynamics that underpinned mass migration from post-famine Ireland, first a brief word about sources. Our knowledge of the reasons why such large numbers of people left independent Ireland is largely mediated through the prism of the views of ‘experts’, ranging from the members of the Commission on Emigration and Other Population Problems who conducted extensive inquiries across the country in the late 1940s, to anthropologists and sociologists who embarked on ethnographic studies of rural communities or completed large-scale surveys on intending or returning migrants in the 1950s and 1960s.¹ The Commission on Emigration was appointed by the new government in 1948, ostensibly to examine population trends in general,
¹ The best of which is Damian F. Hannan, Rural Exodus (London, 1970).
Leaving Home
11
but its work was in practice devoted to emigration.² Interestingly, when the commissioners travelled the length and breadth of the country they sought the opinions of priests, teachers, and local government officials. They also tried where possible to conduct interviews with intending migrants, with varying degrees of success, and if none could be found, these reports were simply based on information derived from ‘notables’, with all the inherent epistemological problems involved.³ The list of organizations and individuals who presented oral and written evidence to the commission was dominated by government departments, public bodies, and interest groups.⁴ Implicitly there was a hierarchy of knowledge, with the subjects themselves coming low down on the list of those who possessed any ‘expert’ knowledge. This was far from unusual in the study of ‘social problems’ in this era, but politicians and civil servants also claimed to know why young people emigrated, drawing to a greater or lesser extent on direct first-hand experience. These explanations centred on the familiar trinity of the economy, poverty, and lack of employment. In effect, the voices of the migrants themselves were marginalized in the extensive discourse on emigration that emanated from Irish society at this time. As has been argued in the context of British race relations in the 1950s and 1960s, ‘the subaltern could not speak, except within the epistemological framework imposed by academic experts’.⁵
1. GOING EAST At least eight million people left the island of Ireland between the Act of Union (1800) and the foundation of the independent Irish state in 1921–2, an enormous outflow by any international standard.⁶ No other European country experienced emigration on such a scale, relative to the size of the total population. This sustained exodus had profound implications on the evolution of Irish society, and the ² Pauric Travers, ‘ ‘‘The Dream Gone Bust’’: Irish Responses to Emigration, 1922–60’, in Oliver MacDonagh and W. F. Mandle (eds.), Irish-Australian Studies (Canberra, 1989), 329–31; Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 189–91. ³ See Arnold Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306. ⁴ Commission on Emigration, Reports, Apps. 1–3, 258–62; and for the transcripts of evidence, Marsh Papers, TCD MSS 8307–8. ⁵ Chris Waters, ‘ ‘‘Dark Strangers’’ in Our Midst: Discourses of Race and Nation in Britain, 1947–1963’, Journal of British Studies, 36, no. 2 (1997), 217. Emphasis as in the original. ⁶ David Fitzpatrick, Irish Emigration 1801–1921 (Dublin, 1984), 1.
12
Leaving Home
principal receiving countries of the United States, Canada, Britain, and Australasia.⁷ Traditionally in the Western world, coming of age involves leaving the family home. In modern Ireland those born since the mid-nineteenth century were faced with the more drastic prospect of leaving the country. As David Fitzpatrick has memorably observed, ‘growing up in Ireland meant preparing oneself to leave it’.⁸ Between the Great Famine of the 1840s and the First World War, emigration was an established stage in the life-cycle as generations of ‘young Irish people knew they were likely, like many before them, to experience adult life not in Ireland but in Britain, North America, or Australia’.⁹ In post-famine Ireland, few had the luxury of remaining within their local communities ‘as only a small minority were both able and willing to spend their lives in the house or farm of their upbringing’, and most knew that the ‘likelihood was their working lives would be conducted in another country’.¹⁰ By 1921 approximately one in four people who were born in Ireland lived abroad.¹¹ Little had changed after forty years of self-government. For the generation who came of age in the mid-twentieth century the decision to migrate was equally a rite of passage and an act that signified the difference between being dependent on one’s family and seeking to make one’s own way in the world. A quarter of the Irish population still resided overseas by the early 1960s. Roughly one in three of those aged under thirty years at the end of the Second World War no longer formed part of the social landscape by the early 1970s.¹² One sociologist, Damian Hannan, estimated that even though net emigration between 1946 and 1971 was recorded in official statistics as 670,000 people, more than twice that number had left the country at some stage during that twenty-five-year period.¹³ In other words, roughly three out of every five children growing up in the 1950s ⁷ See D. H. Akenson, The Irish Diaspora ( Toronto and Belfast, 1993), for a perceptive overview. ⁸ Fitzpatrick, Irish Emigration, 30. ⁹ Timothy W. Guinnane, The Vanishing Irish: Households, Migration, and the Rural Economy in Ireland, 1850–1914 (Princeton, 1997), 166. ¹⁰ David Fitzpatrick, ‘Emigration, 1801–70’, in W. E. Vaughan (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 5: Ireland Under the Union, I (1801–70) (Oxford, 1989), 562. ¹¹ Commission on Emigration and Other Population Problems, Reports (Dublin [1955]), Pr. 2541, table 95, 126. ¹² Donal Garvey, ‘The History of Migration Flows in the Republic of Ireland’, Population Trends, 39 (1985), 25. ¹³ Damian F. Hannan, ‘Irish Emigration Since the War’, unpublished typescript of RTE Thomas Davis Lecture [1973], 2. Annual net emigration is the difference between the number of people leaving and the number of people arriving in a country.
Leaving Home
13
were destined to leave at some stage.¹⁴ This was the generation of the ‘vanishing Irish’, as hundreds of thousands of young people who entered adulthood were to spend time living abroad, ranging from a couple of months to the rest of their lives.¹⁵ The destination for the vast majority of twentieth-century emigrants was Britain, Ireland’s nearest neighbour and the ‘old enemy’, which by 1971 had the largest number of people born in Ireland who lived overseas, at just under one million people.¹⁶ In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries the Irish had departed for North America and Australasia as well as Britain, yet after the 1920s short-distance migrations became the norm. How can we account for such a complete break with the past? There is no simple explanation for this dramatic change in direction.¹⁷ Accounting for the preferences of literally hundreds of thousands of individuals is almost impossible. One obvious factor is the existence or otherwise of restrictions on entry to a particular nation-state. The traditional interpretation is that crossing the Atlantic became a much less attractive option with the introduction of American legislation to curb immigration in 1921, subsequently superseded by the Johnson-Reed Act of 1924 and a range of ancillary measures, all of which made it more difficult for immigrants to enter the United States.¹⁸ According to John Jackson, ‘the gradual closing of the ever-open-door to the United States led to a greater number of emigrants turning eastwards toward Britain throughout the decade of the 1920s’.¹⁹ This gamut of restrictions was enshrined in legislation in the 1920s in ¹⁴ John A. Jackson, ‘The Irish’, in Ruth Glass (ed.), London: Aspects of Change (London, 1964), 305. Jackson based his comment on a newspaper report of a statement by the then Director of the Central Statistics Office, R. C. Geary. ¹⁵ Mary E. Daly, The Slow Failure: Population Decline and Independent Ireland, 1920–1973 (Madison, 2006), chs. 4 and 5; Enda Delaney, Demography, State and Society: Irish Migration to Britain, 1921–1971 (Kingston/Montreal and Liverpool, 2000), chs. 3–5. A brief account can be found in Enda Delaney, Irish Emigration Since 1921 (Dublin, 2002), 3–10. This was the title of a collection of essays edited by the Revd John A. O’Brien: The Vanishing Irish: The Enigma of the Modern World (New York, 1953). ¹⁶ Delaney, Irish Emigration Since 1921, table 4, 39. ¹⁷ P. J. Drudy, ‘Migration between Britain and Ireland Since Independence’, in P. J. Drudy (ed.), Ireland and Britain Since 1922 (Cambridge, 1986) (Irish Studies 5), 114–15. ¹⁸ David Caradog Jones (ed.), The Social Survey of Merseyside (Liverpool, 1934), i. 69; Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 42–6; John Archer Jackson, The Irish in Britain (London, 1963) 13, 97; R. S. Walshaw, Migration to and from the British Isles: Problems and Policies (London, 1941), 69–74. On the Act itself and its implications, see Mae M. Ngai, Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America (Princeton, 2004), 21–55. ¹⁹ Jackson, The Irish in Britain, 13.
14
Leaving Home
response to widely shared fears about the rising levels of immigration from eastern Europe and concerns about the capacity of the American economy to absorb additional immigrants. Even though a relatively generous quota was introduced for people from the newly established Irish Free State in 1924 and again in 1929, this was never filled before the eventual abandonment of the quota system in 1965 when the Immigration and Nationality Act fundamentally reformed American immigration policy.²⁰ But, as has recently been argued by Matthew J. O’Brien, it was not so much the introduction of the politically driven quota system as the implementation of administrative changes in the issuing of visas by consular officials in Dublin that discouraged Irish migration to the United Stares in the interwar years. In the late 1920s officials were instructed to apply a ‘likely to become a public charge’ test to all prospective immigrants.²¹ By 1929 an additional stipulation was added that they must be able to demonstrate either substantial financial capital or skills that would enable them to support themselves.²² After the Wall Street Crash in 1929, these criteria were imposed by local consular staff in Dublin with increasing rigidity.²³ Travelling across the Atlantic required a sustained engagement with officialdom, as well as the prospect of ‘proving’ that a potential migrant could support themselves either through capital or skills. The downturn in the American economy, news of which filtered back through networks of family and friends, presented a less than favourable impression of the once ‘promised land’. The Great Depression resulted in widespread unemployment and social deprivation, unlikely to prove attractive to any prospective newcomer. Its effects were particularly felt in the public sector, manufacturing, and industrial workforce, areas in which the Irish were heavily represented in urban America.²⁴ In the early 1930s thousands of Irish travelled back from the United States, stark evidence of the illusory nature of the American dream. ²⁰ P. J. Drudy, ‘Irish Population Change and Emigration Since Independence’, in P. J. Drudy (ed.), The Irish in America: Emigration, Assimilation, Impact (Cambridge, 1985), 72–6. ²¹ Matthew O’Brien, ‘Transatlantic Connections and the Sharp Edge of the Great Depression’, in Kevin Kenny (ed.), New Directions in Irish-American History (Madison, 2003), 80. ²² Ibid. 81; Commission on Emigration, Reports, app. V, 266. ²³ Sean Glynn, ‘Irish Immigration to Britain, 1911–1951: Patterns and Policy’, Irish Economic and Social History, 8 (1981), 51; O’Brien, ‘Transatlantic Connections’, 81. ²⁴ O’Brien, ‘Transatlantic Connections’, 85–7.
Leaving Home
15
To see this change in direction as solely an outcome of the legislative situation in the United States, however, captures only part of the story. One historian, Seán Glynn, argued in the early 1980s that since the American quotas on Irish entrants were never filled, the restrictions on immigration were not a ‘major direct influence’.²⁵ For Glynn, the altered political relationship between Britain and Ireland as well as the limited costs involved is more relevant, and, perhaps even more so, the widespread perception that the move to Britain ‘was easier to contemplate and less drastic and final than transatlantic movement’.²⁶ The domestic political environment also subtly shaped individual choices. The foundation of the Irish state in 1921–2 created what seem like—with the always helpful benefit of hindsight—unrealistic expectations about the capacity of an independent state to generate sufficient employment, reflecting earlier nationalist propaganda which posited that the solution to Ireland’s longstanding economic woes was the end of British rule and self-government. By the end of the Second World War the Irish economy was still unable to generate enough jobs to absorb the large numbers looking for work. After an initial boom in public expenditure in the late 1940s, including an aborted campaign to persuade skilled construction workers to come home in 1949–50, the economy declined even further in the 1950s, raising concerns about the capacity of the Irish state to function as a viable unit.²⁷ This was the ‘lost decade’, when unemployment and mass emigration dominated the political agenda.²⁸ Notwithstanding the actual course of events, contemporaries were unable to predict the future, and much of the rhetoric emanating from the main political parties centred on improving the economy. By choosing Britain over the United States or Australia allowed greater flexibility for a potential return home if conditions ever improved. As the sociologist Liam Ryan observed in the early 1970s, leaving for Britain was seen as a temporary expedient and was rarely the outcome of a decision to make a new life elsewhere: ‘A week’s wages will pay the fare over, and if things do not work out another week’s wages will pay the fare home again.’²⁹ And, as we shall see in a ²⁵ Glynn, ‘Irish Immigration to Britain, 1911–1951’, 51. Emphasis as in original. ²⁶ Ibid. ²⁷ For this campaign, see Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 192–3. ²⁸ See Dermot Keogh (ed.), A Lost Decade? Emigration, Culture and Society in Ireland in the 1950s (Cork, 2004). ²⁹ William Ryan, ‘Assimilation of Irish Immigrants in Britain’ (unpub. Ph.D. thesis, St Louis University, 1973), 116.
16
Leaving Home
later chapter, this possibility of return to Ireland loomed large in the migrant mentalité, even after decades living in Britain. Unlike the North American experience that was characterized by finality, emigration to Britain was driven by expediency and an easily reversible action. Although the American dream was increasingly looking like a figment of the immigrant imagination, enhanced opportunities were available in Britain from the mid–1930s, as, unlike its American counterpart, the British economy recovered quickly from the global depression, as new industries concentrated in the Midlands and south-east expanded to meet the demands of the consumer revolution. Car manufacturing and light engineering together with the construction industry expanded throughout the 1930s.³⁰ More traditional sources of employment for arrivals from Ireland such as domestic service and unskilled labouring continued to offer an abundance of opportunities. With the outbreak of war, the unprecedented demands of wartime production offered numerous new openings for the Irish, who could fill the gaps left by workers who were serving in the armed forces. The Second World War confirmed what was already the established pattern, as Britain became the main destination for Irish migrants. An official inquiry into emigration undertaken in the early 1950s reckoned that since the mid–1930s virtually all Irish migrants had departed for Britain.³¹ Later investigations have confirmed the continuance of this pattern until the early 1970s, with estimates that four out of five migrants from independent Ireland went ‘across the water’.³² Unlike the later nineteenth century, this was not a residual movement of those unable or unwilling to travel longer distances across the oceans.³³ While prior to the 1930s crossing the Atlantic had been the preferred pathway out of Ireland, John Bull’s island was now the destination of choice. Of equal significance was the issue of access. Britain could be entered freely and was just a short boat journey away. Until the outbreak of ³⁰ This account is based on Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 43–7. ³¹ Commission on Emigration, Reports, 117. ³² B. M. Walsh, ‘Expectations, Information, and Human Migration: Specifying an Econometric Model of Irish Migration to Britain’, Journal of Regional Science, 14, no. 1 (1974), 108; Hannan, ‘Irish Emigration Since the War’, 1; Ryan, ‘Assimilation of Irish Immigrants’, 7; National Economic and Social Council, The Economic and Social Implications of Emigration (Dublin, 1991) (Report No. 90), Pl. 7840, 60–1. ³³ David Fitzpatrick, ‘The Irish in Britain, 1871–1921’, in W. E. Vaughan (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 6: Ireland Under the Union, II (1870–1921) (Oxford, 1996), 653.
Leaving Home
17
the Second World War in September 1939, citizens of independent Ireland could enter the United Kingdom without having to satisfy any requirements for a visa or even produce any documents to confirm identity.³⁴ However, during the war a range of requirements were introduced by the British and Irish authorities to control and monitor movement between the two countries, many of which remained in place until the early 1950s.³⁵ After the eventual abandonment of controls in April 1952, Irish and British citizens could once again cross freely land and sea borders in what was formally constituted as the ‘common travel area’.³⁶ Official estimates indicate that as many as 150,000 had arrived during the Second World War, adding to the already substantial numbers of Irish living in Britain prior to 1939. The 1951 census recorded 466, 981 persons in England from independent Ireland, with an additional 131,955 who were residents of Northern Ireland.³⁷ This was a staggering increase of 65 per cent in just twenty years. In Scotland there were just under 90,000 Irish-born in the mid-twentieth century, divided roughly equally between those born in independent Ireland and Northern Ireland, reflecting the traditional links between Ulster and Scotland.³⁸ The number of Irish in Scotland had nearly halved since the early 1920s as Scotland declined dramatically as a destination for immigrants, from north and south, in the first quarter of the twentieth century. By 1951 the Irish in Britain numbered nearly 700,000 people, reversing the steady decline that had occurred from the late nineteenth century.³⁹ The actual proportions of Irish in the total population of England and Wales had risen dramatically throughout the 1930s and 1940s; by way of contrast, in Scotland the decline evident since the 1870s continued, as the flow was directed southwards to the expanding regions of the south-east. ³⁴ Elizabeth Meehan, Free Movement between Ireland and the UK: From the ‘Common Travel Area’ to The Common Travel Area (Dublin, 2000), 1, 22–6; for more details on the complicated issue of Irish citizenship, see Mary E. Daly, ‘Irish Nationality and Citizenship Since 1922’, Irish Historical Studies, 32, no. 129 (2001), 377–407. ³⁵ Commission on Emigration, Reports, app. VI, 267. ³⁶ Meehan, Free Movement Between Ireland and the UK, 26–30; Commission on Emigration, Reports, app. V, 266. ³⁷ Census 1951, England and Wales: General Report (London, 1958), table 49, 104. ³⁸ Census, 1951: Scotland: Vol. 3, General Volume (Edinburgh, 1954), table 32, 49. ³⁹ Fitzpatrick, ‘The Irish in Britain, 1871–1921’, 654.
18
Leaving Home
2 . ‘A N U PH E AVA L O F H O PE A N D H E A RT B R E A K ’ Why did so many people leave independent Ireland between the end of the Second World War and the 1960s? The dominant historical narrative centres on the dismal state of the Irish economy in the 1940s and 1950s, often described in terms such as ‘stagnation’ or ‘crisis’, and the consequent failure to create sufficient employment opportunities to absorb the large numbers of young people coming of age.⁴⁰ This is a convincing explanation for mass migration from Ireland, and not just in the post-war years but also throughout the modern period since 1750: a poor, underdeveloped, agricultural country, with an expanding population and an inadequate supply of jobs, generates mass movement, either internally to the centres of urban employment or externally to the rapidly expanding industrial economies. The European experience from the mid-eighteenth century would certainly show that such migrations are an inevitable outcome of the development of industrial capitalism. Independent Ireland was, however, different in one respect from its western European neighbours, and more akin to other peripheral regions of southern and northern Europe. Agriculture still accounted for approximately two-fifths of the working population in the late 1950s. Moreover, the small farm rural economy, especially in the west of Ireland, was in an irreversible decline.⁴¹ The interpretation that is offered here, while broadly accepting this backdrop, argues that additional factors unique to the 1940s and 1950s come into operation that explain the emergence of this second great wave of migration from modern Ireland. Since at least the mid-nineteenth century, mass migration was a response to the economic situation. The American historian Arnold Schrier identified what he termed as the American fever: ‘an alluring impression of America which came to predominate throughout the ⁴⁰ See Terence Brown, Ireland: A Social and Cultural History, 1922–1985, 2nd edn. (London, 1985), 211–38; Diarmaid Ferriter, The Transformation of Ireland, 1900–2000 (London, 2004), 470–7; J. J. Lee, Ireland, 1912–85: Politics and Society (Cambridge, 1989), 359–60, 373–8; Kieran A. Kennedy, Thomas Giblin, and Deirdre McHugh, The Economic Development of Ireland in the Twentieth Century (London, 1988), 141; Cormac Ó Gráda, A Rocky Road: The Irish Economy since the 1920s (Manchester, 1997), 216–17. ⁴¹ Finola Kennedy, Family, Economy and Government in Ireland (Dublin, 1989), 10; Damian F. Hannan, ‘Peasant Models and the Understanding of Social and Cultural Change in Rural Ireland’, in P. J. Drudy (ed.), Ireland: Land, Politics and People (Cambridge, 1985), 153–61; Daly, The Slow Failure, 50–74.
Leaving Home
19
Irish countryside’.⁴² Drawing on a range of contemporary sources, he illustrates how this ‘lure’ propelled and sustained the exodus to the United States during the post-famine period. While ‘British fever’ raises all sorts of negative connotations in the context of the fraught nature of British–Irish political relationships in the mid-twentieth century, Schrier’s emphasis on the cultural context of emigration offers a muchneeded counterbalance to models inspired by neoclassical economics centred on rational actors weighing up the relative costs and benefits of leaving or staying. Individual decisions were taken within a broader economic, social, and cultural environment, as migrants were not insulated from the wider society: in simple terms, they were influenced by what other people were doing, saying, planning, and discussing. Leaving home was a shared response to the situation in which young people found themselves, and was far from being deviant or abnormal behaviour, as so often was assumed by politicians and civil servants. In the mid-twentieth century thinking about emigrating was deeply embedded in the psychology of young Irish people. Many left, others stayed behind, but most at least thought about leaving at some point in the future. As with the first mass movement from Ireland during the second half of the nineteenth century, emigration emerged as the favoured option for those who often ironically retained a deep attachment to a nostalgic vision of ‘home’, even though it had very little to offer them. With the growing disenchantment with the bleak situation, going to Britain at least offered some hope and the opportunity to prosper when both were in short supply in independent Ireland. Leaving always involved mixed feelings, appropriately characterized by Jackson as ‘an upheaval of hope and heartbreak’.⁴³ This was, of course, not by any means unique to postwar Ireland, and its existence has been noted by social scientists in other migration-prone societies such as the Caribbean and Mexico.⁴⁴ Within poorer communities, emigration becomes ‘deeply ingrained into the repertoire of people’s behaviours, and values associated with migration become part of the community’s values’.⁴⁵ In the Caribbean, for instance, ⁴² Arnold Schrier, Ireland and the American Emigration, 1850–1900 (Minneapolis, 1958), 18–19. ⁴³ Jackson, The Irish in Britain, 160. ⁴⁴ Jeffrey H. Cohen, The Culture of Migration in Southern Mexico (Austin, 2004). ⁴⁵ Douglas S. Massey, Joaquín Arango, Graeme Hugo, Ali Kouaouci, Adela Pellegrino, and J. Edward Taylor, ‘Theories of International Migration: A Review and Appraisal’, Population and Development Review, 19, no. 1 (1993), 452–3.
20
Leaving Home
leaving for work abroad was embedded in the cultural framework of individuals, households, and the wider social structure.⁴⁶ As the historian Mary Chamberlain remarks about the historical tradition of movement from Barbados, ‘family ties cross continents, oceans and borders and have done so for generations’.⁴⁷ In effect, the organization of such societies was based around the displacement of large numbers, who in turn supported those who stayed at home through remittances.⁴⁸ ‘Going to England’ or ‘across the water’, as contemporaries described emigration to Britain, were the catchphrases of the post-war years, an implicit acknowledgement that the established route to secure and steady employment—and the lifestyle that went along with a regular weekly income—inevitably involved crossing the Irish Sea. As the commission noted in 1955, emigration was ‘a part of the generally accepted pattern of life’.⁴⁹ What was viewed as exceptional in some other societies was an altogether more routine matter for young people growing up in post-war Ireland. After quizzing prospective male migrants in New Ross, County Wexford, one member of the commission believed it was ‘a sign of inferiority to remain at home . . . In others words, it is ‘‘the thing’’ to go to work in England.’⁵⁰ For the young women living in these County Wexford coastal towns, he noted that departing for England after the completion of elementary education was ‘in the blood’.⁵¹ Ireland’s geographical location next to one of the world’s most advanced economies underscored the contrasting lifestyles available in the two countries. As the sociologist Damian Hannan argued in the early 1970s, ‘this widespread existence of British points of reference for judging the adequacy of conditions at home is probably one of the most influential local consequences of our recent emigration history’.⁵² Newspapers and radio offered glimpses of a different way of life based on material wellbeing, a consumer-based social scene organized around ⁴⁶ Elizabeth M. Thomas-Hope, Explanation in Caribbean Migration, 1st edn. (London, 1992), 159–60. ⁴⁷ Mary Chamberlain, ‘Gender and the Narratives of Migration’, History Workshop Journal, no. 43 (1997), 88; for more details, see id., Narratives of Exile and Return (London, 1987). ⁴⁸ Cohen, The Culture of Migration. 29; see also Douglas S. Massey, Rafael Alarcón, Jorge Durand, and Humberto González, Return to Aztlan: The Social Process of International Migration from Western Mexico (Berkeley, 1987). ⁴⁹ Commission on Emigration, Reports, 137. ⁵⁰ S.8, Rural Survey of Waterford, Dungarvan, New Ross, Carrick-on-Suir, Enniscorthy, Carlow and Bagenalstown, prepared by Stanley Lyon [1948], Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306. ⁵¹ Ibid. ⁵² Hannan, ‘Irish Emigration Since the War’, 8.
Leaving Home
21
popular activities such as dancing and going to the cinema, and, most importantly, a vision of a future that centred on the fulfilment of individual aspirations. In other words, what have come to be seen as central features of the ‘modern’ world were obtainable just across the water. British newspapers were read widely in Ireland, especially the more popular variants. A conservative Catholic cleric, the Revd Robert Devane SJ, estimated that nearly four hundred thousand British Sunday newspapers were imported every week, and even proposed in 1950 that the government should impose a special tariff on cheap imported newspapers and magazines to protect ‘innocent’ Irish minds.⁵³ Together with the alleged pernicious influence of newspapers, those living on the eastern coast of Ireland and close to the border with Northern Ireland could listen to the even more insidious British wireless service. Detailed research on listening habits undertaken by Radio Éireann in the early 1950s indicated that BBC Radio Light and Radio Luxembourg, both designed to appeal to a younger audience, were very popular across all social groups.⁵⁴ One of the most ubiquitous expressions of modernity was the cinema. Irish audiences invariably watched American or, to a lesser extent, British films as an indigenous industry had not developed to any degree.⁵⁵ By the mid–1930s it was reckoned that four-fifths of the films shown in Irish cinemas came from Hollywood.⁵⁶ For some conservative critics, the cinema was the ‘celluloid menace’, a powerful source that ‘confirmed the unthinking in their lack of thinking, and has filled their lives with a colourful and varied vacuity’.⁵⁷ A night out at the ‘pictures’ was by a long stretch the most popular form of leisure activity in Ireland by the mid-twentieth century. An estimate produced in 1954 suggested that roughly one in three people frequented the ‘palace of dreams’ at least once a week.⁵⁸ The wider world was viewed ⁵³ R. S. Devane, SJ, The Import Pressed: A National Menace—Some Remedies (Dublin, 1950), 8, 23; for more information about Devane and his idiosyncratic views, see Michael Adams, Censorship: The Irish Experience (Dublin, 1968), 162–4; Louise Fuller, Irish Catholicism since 1950: The Undoing of a Culture, 38. ⁵⁴ K. G. Forecast, ‘Radio Éireann Listener Research Inquiries, 1953–1955’, Journal of the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland, 19 (1955–6), 10–12. ⁵⁵ Kevin Rockett, ‘Protecting the Family and the Nation: The Official Censorship of American Cinema in Ireland, 1923–1954’, Historical Journal of Film, Radio and Television, 20, no. 3 (2000), 283. ⁵⁶ Gabriel Fallon, ‘Celluloid Menace’, in The Capuchin Annual, 1938 (Dublin, 1937), 249. ⁵⁷ Ibid. ⁵⁸ Ibid.; B. G. MacCarthy, ‘The Cinema as a Social Factor’, Studies, 33 (1944), 49; Fuller, Irish Catholicism since 1950, 40.
22
Leaving Home
through this technicolour lens, leading to unfavourable comparisons between the simple unencumbered life in rural Ireland and the cinematic representations of modernity contained in Hollywood’s portrayal of material success, fast city life, and private conceptions of morality. As Kevin Rockett has argued, Irish cinemagoers were confronted with ‘a radically contrasting world and lifestyle which necessarily challenged traditional Irish notions of morality and order and highlighted their own material lack, both personally and as a nation’.⁵⁹ Even if the notoriously strict censorship policy operated by the state removed licentious or sexually suggestive scenes from Hollywood films, the more compelling message that people elsewhere had better lives undermined traditional Irish nationalist values.⁶⁰ This sense of a disjuncture between life in Ireland and Hollywood representations was captured vividly by an educationalist writing in 1944: It is interesting to consider the average farm labourer, walking five or six miles . . . to go to the pictures, and then that way home again in our Irish rain. What has he seen that has the slightest relation to life as he knows it? He has seen night-club queens covered by a few spangles, Chicago gangsters talking a peculiar argot, society playboys babbling airily of Reno divorce. He has seen crooning cowboys, coal-black mammies, typists clad in Schiaparelli models living in luxurious flats, and millionaires living in Babylonian palaces. He is going home to fall into his bed in the loft, to rise the next morning and feed the pigs. What does he make of it all?⁶¹
Young Irish people were avid cinemagoers. While one can easily overstate the effect of the powerful images of late modernity contained in American and British films on the mentalities of a complete generation, films offered an alluring taste of the lifestyles available in the prosperous industrial economies. A member of the Commission on Emigration reflected on the far-reaching effects of these perceptions in 1948: It may be that, in years gone by, such persons have been content to live virtually on a subsistence basis, but the cinema, radio, newspapers and friends are now luring them into the attitude that they should not be satisfied with [this] but ⁵⁹ Kevin Rockett, Irish Film Censorship: A Cultural Journey from Silent Cinema to Internet Pornography (Dublin, 2004), 26. ⁶⁰ On censorship of film, see Rockett, Irish Film Censorship, chs. 3–7, and Donal Ó Drisceoil, Censorship in Ireland, 1939–1945 (Cork, 1996), 30–58. The best available treatment of the censorship of publications still remains Michael Adams, Censorship: The Irish Experience (Dublin, 1968). ⁶¹ MacCarthy, ‘The Cinema as a Social Factor’, 46; also partly quoted in Rockett, Irish Film Censorship, 26, and Ferriter, The Transformation of Ireland, 429.
Leaving Home
23
should leave home and get wages to enable them to raise their standards, get married and have homes of their own. Who can blame them?⁶²
Contemporaries often alleged that females were especially influenced by such glamorous portrayals of American life, although this tells us more about the gendered nature of discourse and the lack of understanding of the rising aspirations of young women than about any innate differences.⁶³ This is neatly illustrated in a public controversy about the plight of Irish emigrants that occurred in August 1951 when the merits of the wholesome life at home were compared with the perils of urban Britain by a leading Irish politician. The Irish government was passed a copy of an unpublished report written by a social worker on the deplorable conditions of Irish workers in Birmingham and other Midland cities, and the then Taoiseach, Eamon de Valera, made a public speech in which he implicitly suggested that base materialism was one of the driving forces behind Irish emigration to Britain: ‘The saddest part of all this is that work is available at home, and in conditions infinitely better from the point of view of health and morals.’⁶⁴ We shall return to the furore caused by this speech in a later chapter, but de Valera was not alone in this view, and politicians and other public figures failed to grasp that even if similar jobs could be secured at home—and this was a debatable suggestion in itself—such work was often insecure in nature, of low status, and poorly paid. The suggestion that in seeking to obtain secure and well-paid employment migrants were somehow embracing crass materialism was derisory. Migrants were responding to a changing set of values. Moreover, it was not simply the lifestyle available in Britain that tended to make it an attractive destination but the effects of the developing consumerism that starkly contrasted with the simple and ‘pure’ life available in rural and small-town Ireland.⁶⁵ Material success, as measured by regular and secure income and the lifestyle that accompanied it, was incongruous with the traditional values ⁶² S.5, Rural Survey of Clonmel, Arklow and Wexford, prepared by W. A. Honohan, Sept. 1948, Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306. ⁶³ See Ross McKibbin, Classes and Cultures: England, 1918–1951 (Oxford, 1998), 431–2, 434, on this point. ⁶⁴ Quoted in Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 194. See below, 98–100. ⁶⁵ This view was not confined to Irish Catholic thinking: see Joan Keating, ‘Faith and Community Threatened? Roman Catholic Responses to the Welfare State, Materialism and Social Mobility, 1945–62’, Twentieth Century British History, 9, no. 1 (1998), 86–108.
24
Leaving Home
of rural Ireland. Those values of pure living and simplicity were often expected of the lower social groupings, yet the political classes, civil servants, and to an extent the comfortable larger farmers failed to grasp this fundamental point. Migrants were only seeking for themselves the same choices that their social superiors exercised. The sanctity of poverty appealed to only the purest of the pure in post-war Ireland.
3 . OT H E R T I M E S A N D OT H E R P L AC E S Only the reckless or the foolhardy embarked on the inherently risky venture of moving to a new country without basic information about job opportunities, the cost and availability of accommodation, and at least some knowledge about the social scene.⁶⁶ Potential migrants could often quote chapter and verse about conditions in Britain, something that astonished contemporaries, especially since much of the information was derived from the much more reliable source of personal contact rather than newspapers, cinema, or the radio.⁶⁷ Migrants home on holidays, friends and relatives living in Britain, and returnees acted as conduits of trustworthy information percolating back and forth across the Irish Sea. Far from being displaced from a rural idyll and transferred to the faceless environment of urban Britain, migrants from post-war Ireland actually possessed a remarkable degree of knowledge about what the move entailed and the consequences for individuals. When the writer Heinrich Böll toured around Ireland in the mid–1950s he overheard conversations on trains and in post offices where the talk was of London, Birmingham, and other distant places.⁶⁸ The social landscape of this generation was truly transnational in that it crossed the borders of the nation-state and included family members and friends living in Britain and further afield. This preoccupation with faraway places could lead to what one anthropologist referred to as ‘imaginative displacement’. In his classic study of poorer regions of the west of Ireland in the late 1960s, Hugh Brody charted the effects of this dispersal on the family of one of his subjects, Kath Nee, in a postscript written nearly twenty years later: ⁶⁶ This section draws heavily on Enda Delaney, ‘Transnationalism, Networks and Emigration from Post-War Ireland’, Immigrants and Minorities, 23, nos. 2–3 (2005), 425–46. ⁶⁷ For examples, see Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 168–83. ⁶⁸ Heinrich Böll, Irish Journal: A Traveller’s Portrait of Ireland (London, 1983), 3, 65–6, 72–3.
Leaving Home
25
‘meanwhile, the imagination of her sons, like all the emigrants both at home and abroad, and like Kath Nee herself, continue to be haunted by images of other times and other places’.⁶⁹ Understandably, the collective memory of post-war Irish emigration centres on poignant stories of young rural migrants displaced from their local worlds in search of work in the anonymous industrial centres of Britain. The historical narrative mirrors collective memory in this instance, though historians stop short of the powerful image of exile, so pervasive for the American-Irish in the second half of the nineteenth century.⁷⁰ Migration to be sure resulted in displacement and loneliness and evoked self-perceptions of being exiled.⁷¹ But networks lessened the obvious dislocation of emigration. These informal networks were built on obligations towards kinsfolk and friends, in essence the product of personal relationships, and enabled those with relatively little resources or indeed initiative to depart for Britain. Individual agency or the power to determine one’s own destiny was far more important in the process of leaving home for life in Britain than was acknowledged by either the migrants themselves or subsequent commentators. For many who left, a sense of home, in the concrete form of kin and friends, was a defining feature of their adaptation to life in Britain. This massive human movement was sustained and perpetuated by networks that connected emigrants, returned migrants, and non-migrants in both Ireland and Britain. These networks were founded on personal exchanges of knowledge, letters, visits home by migrants, casual conversations, and scraps of information, sometimes derived from second- and third-hand sources. Networks were essentially the outcome of other relationships, be they through the visceral bonds of kin, or the more elastic ties of friendship and shared local origin. Norms of reciprocity and obligations towards family and friends as well as the basic needs of companionship were the foundations of these migrant networks. Social relationships were ‘maintained rather than lost by moving geographically’ and for young people emigration was in some instances ⁶⁹ Hugh Brody, Inishkillane: Change and Decline in the West of Ireland, 2nd edn. (London, 1986), 17. ⁷⁰ For notions of exile among Irish emigrants in the United States in the late nineteenth century, see Kerby A. Miller, Emigrants and Exiles: Ireland and the Irish Exodus to North America (New York, 1985), 102–30; Matthew Frye Jacobson, Special Sorrows: The Diasporic Imagination of the Irish, Polish, and Jewish Immigrants in the United States, 2nd edn. (Berkeley, 2002), 11–32. ⁷¹ An evocative representation of this sense of dislocation can be found in Timothy O’Grady and Steve Pyke, I Could Read the Sky (London, 1997).
26
Leaving Home
the only way to remain in close contact with their friends and peers.⁷² As Liam Ryan noted, ‘the lack of work and lack of vitality (‘‘crack’’) in the rural community are two elements in emigration’.⁷³ He saw the rekindling of friendships and relationships as one of the driving forces of post-war emigration as large numbers of young people from each generation deserted rural Ireland: A letter from a friend, contact with relatives, travellers’ tales of returned emigrants might trigger the individual act of migration but the stage has been set long before. Renewal of friendships during the annual summer influx of holidaying emigrants was important because it enabled both emigrants and locals to recapture briefly the companionship and gaiety of a youthful Ireland in which people worked and laughed and worshipped God and got along together. More important, it emphasized for the local resident that the comradeship and the laughter which he no longer finds in his own community may indeed have migrated to Britain along with his friends and companions, and so the crowd which came back on holiday went back augmented.⁷⁴
The writer Richard Power, who spent a year on the Aran Islands in the mid–1950s, records how when all his friends on the island went to England he felt he had ‘an irrational compulsion to discover the rapture of youth once more. I wanted to leave at once.’⁷⁵ He gathered his belongings together and simply left Inis Mór, made his way via Dublin to London, and then eventually located his friends living in Birmingham. Power’s haunting description of the barren social landscape after the departure of his friends encapsulates this sense that the energy of the community had silently moved elsewhere: I had to leave. Everytime I went past Cóilín’s house, the old door locked up, the stain of dust on the windows, my optimism faltered. Dara Pheig was gone. The girls who once danced by my side, they were gone. The young strangers who used to amble along the roads at night, swimming in the sun and enjoying themselves on the beach, they were gone. In the place where they played handball, pools of water gathered and green moss grew . . . It occurred to me that the heart of the human race was beating strongly on some distant place and that there was only a faint tremulous pulse to be sensed in this extremity. I didn’t rightly know yet where such a distant place was, but I was certain it was there.⁷⁶ ⁷² Ryan, ‘Assimilation of Irish Immigrants’, 116. ⁷³ Ibid. 118. ⁷⁴ Ibid. 116. ⁷⁵ Richard Power, Apple on the Treetop, trans. from the Irish by Victor Power (Dublin, 1980), 151. This book was originally published in Irish as Risteard de Paor, Úll i mBárr an Ghéagáin (Dublin, 1958). ⁷⁶ Ibid.
Leaving Home
27
Undoubtedly such sentiments were experienced across rural and smalltown Ireland as this generation witnessed the departure of so many friends and contemporaries. John Healy’s famous lyrical account of the decline of his hometown, Charlestown, County Mayo, is another later example of the widespread perception that rural Ireland was gradually ‘dying’ as young people left in large numbers.⁷⁷ Members of the Commission on Emigration travelled throughout the country in 1948–9 to establish for themselves the principal causes of emigration. They also interviewed prospective male emigrants at employment exchanges who opted to travel under schemes funded by British companies, desperately in need of scarce unskilled male labour for heavy work. It is not clear if each commissioner was specifically requested to ask the prospective emigrants if they had family members living abroad, and the precision of the responses therefore varies. At least a third of these men explicitly stated that members of their immediate family were already settled in Britain.⁷⁸ The report of the commission underscored the importance of emigrants already living abroad who acted as ‘magnets’ for family members and friends seeking better lives elsewhere.⁷⁹ Tradition and example have also been very powerful influences. Emigration of some members of the family has almost become part of the established custom of the people in certain areas—a part of the generally accepted pattern of life. For very many emigrants there was a traditional path ‘from the known to the known’, that is to say, from areas where they lived to places where their friends and relations awaited them . . . Such a custom is kept alive by the connection which former emigrants retain with the home country and there is little doubt that these family connections will continue to exercise an influence, even if substantial improvements are effected in economic conditions and social amenities at home.⁸⁰
Similarly, migrants at home on holidays were identified as a valuable source of information.⁸¹ One report specifically highlighted what the author referred to as the ‘lure of England’, and observed that people who came back for holidays ‘did not fail to exaggerate the multitude ⁷⁷ John Healy, The Death of an Irish Town (Cork, 1968). ⁷⁸ Calculated from Rural Surveys S.1–S.23, Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306. ⁷⁹ Commission on Emigration, Reports, 137. ⁸⁰ Ibid. ⁸¹ S.4, Rural Survey of Leitrim and Donegal, 23–25 Sept. 1948; S.10, Rural Survey of County Cork Employment Exchanges, n.d. [Oct. 1948]; S.11, Rural Survey of Galway City and Tuam, n.d. [Oct. 1948]; S.18, Rural Survey of Newbridge, n.d. [Oct. 1948], Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306.
28
Leaving Home
of attractions of ‘‘life’’ in England with its high wages and little work’.⁸² In Middleton, in County Cork, a recent upsurge in emigration was explained by the conspicuous presence in the town of a number of emigrants home on holidays who were ‘flashing rolls of notes’.⁸³ The ‘returned Yank’ was a familiar figure in rural Ireland during the later nineteenth century.⁸⁴ In the mid-twentieth century the successful migrant at home on holidays from ‘England’ was still the source of mild curiosity, as evidenced by the caricature in John B. Keane’s play, Many Young Men of Twenty: Then they come back with new suits an’ fancy shirts, with tall tales about loose women in Piccadilly, boastin’ an’ braggin’ about all the money they’re earnin’. Fine mannerly accents like a country curate at his first sermon. Men o’ the world, with stories about the wonderful sights o’ Camden Town. They’ll buy porter for me when they come back on holidays. They’ll buy porter for any one. They’ll buy porter for every smart man that’ll believe their stories.⁸⁵
Networks expanded as emigration gained greater pace in the late 1940s, and an even greater number of people left independent Ireland throughout the following decade. Given the scale of the exodus, most young people would have known or at the very least have been aware of one relative or friend settled in Britain. These networks were not systematic or formalized in any sense, but centred on reciprocity and a sense of duty to assist friends and family. Obligations towards kin were a distinctive element of the small farm economy in Ireland during the first half of the twentieth century.⁸⁶ As two American anthropologists observed in County Clare in the 1930s, this sense of duty was not abandoned with emigration: The bonds of affection and family obligations still hold. If they have emigrated, the family members send back remittances and passage money for nephews and nieces and brothers and sisters left at home. A great many farms, especially in West and North Clare, are partially supported by Christmas gifts sent from children living abroad.⁸⁷ ⁸² S.8, Rural Survey of Waterford, Dungarvan, New Ross, Carrick-on-Suir, Enniscorthy, Carlow and Bagenalstown, n.d. [Nov. 1948], Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306. ⁸³ S.10, Rural Survey of County Cork Employment Exchanges, n.d. [Oct. 1948], Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306. ⁸⁴ Schrier, Ireland and the American Emigration, 129–42. ⁸⁵ John B. Keane, Many Young Men of Twenty: A Play with Music (Cork, 1961), 42. ⁸⁶ Conrad M. Arensberg and Solon T. Kimball, Family and Community in Ireland, 2nd edn. (Cambridge, Mass., 1968), 59–75. ⁸⁷ Ibid. 143.
Leaving Home
29
The functions of these networks were constantly changing over time. In the first instance, they served to shape the behaviour of individuals by placing the option of emigration on the mental map of individuals assessing prospective life courses. Second, during periods of change such as the journey or arrival, practical assistance and social and emotional support were vital in the traumatic process of adjusting to life in Britain. This was especially important as most migrants were from insulated environments, unfamiliar with the practical challenges of urban industrial life. In its most mundane form, this could mean learning about transportation, work practices, outlets to socialize, and the peculiarities of living with and working alongside the ‘English’. Not all those who left post-war Ireland did so with the direct assistance of friends and family. For instance, reports of young Irish migrants arriving in London’s train stations with little information or even a place to stay were common in the late 1950s.⁸⁸ As David Fitzpatrick has noted, a network is ‘open and optional rather than exclusive and fully reciprocal’.⁸⁹ In some instances, such as young females who were embarking on nursing training in Britain, institutional support structures were already in place to provide accommodation and support. Young pregnant women often took ‘the boat to England’ to avoid the stigma associated with being unmarried mothers. Numerous organizations catered for these women, with varying degrees of compassion and humanity.⁹⁰ Others simply wanted to make their own way in the world, stubbornly resisting any help or advice.
4 . R I S I N G A S PI R AT I O N S Unlike advanced industrial societies such as Britain where class distinctions were articulated openly and widely understood, in a predominantly agricultural and rural society the social hierarchy was less obvious to an ⁸⁸ Reports from Catholic welfare workers in London frequently cited such cases: see, for example, dictabelt from Fr Casey, London, November 1958, AB8/B/XXIX, McQuaid Papers, DDA. ⁸⁹ David Fitzpatrick, ‘The Irish in Britain: Settlers or Transients’, in Patrick Buckland and John Belchem (eds.), The Irish in British Labour History (Liverpool, 1993), 7. ⁹⁰ See Lindsey Earner-Byrne, ‘The Boat to England: An Analysis of the Official Reactions to the Emigration of Single Expectant Irishwomen to Britain, 1922–1972’, Irish Economic and Social History, 30 (2003), 52–70; Paul Michael Garrett, ‘The Abnormal Flight: The Migration and Repatriation of Irish Unmarried Mothers’, Social History, 25, no. 3 (2000), 330–43.
30
Leaving Home
outside observer.⁹¹ Even within broad groupings such as farmers, huge regional variations existed in terms of the size of holdings, the productive capacity of the land, the levels of income generated by agricultural production, and the numbers employed to assist in the day-to-day running of the farm. For instance, in parts of the west and north-west of Ireland, where small-scale subsistence farming was the norm, outside labour was rarely employed, and most holdings could barely support a family.⁹² Much of the literature on rural Ireland in the twentieth century comes from the west of Ireland, where class differentiation was less developed, and the focus on this region helps explain the historiographical silences surrounding social class in mid-twentieth-century Ireland.⁹³ Class was intrinsically tied up with occupational status in these rural communities. The most basic distinction was between those who owned the land, and the workers who were employed at particular times in the year by farmers, especially relevant in the commercialized regions of Leinster and east Munster.⁹⁴ At the bottom end of this social ladder were agricultural labourers and farm servants. An ethnographic study of farming communities in east Limerick completed in the late 1950s pinpointed the class tensions that were bubbling away under the surface. A number of farmers expressed attitudes that were more akin to the vilified former landlord class than the new nationalist élite of independent Ireland, and seemed unwilling to accept the legitimate aspirations of their social inferiors. A common thread in the responses derived from interviews with the farmers was that the education system was creating unrealistic ambitions on the part of the rural working classes. As one farmer put it eloquently: ‘education is ruining them; it gives them airs above their station’.⁹⁵ Education was perceived by farm labourers and their families as the pathway to securing employment outside agriculture and this, by necessity, involved emigration since industrial or manufacturing employment was not available locally.⁹⁶ Prior to the ⁹¹ See McKibbin, Classes and Cultures, on England. ⁹² Damian F. Hannan, Displacement and Development: Class, Kinship and Social Change in Irish Rural Communities (Dublin, 1979), 27–40. For a detailed account, see John J. Scully, Agriculture in the West of Ireland: A Study of the Low Farm Income Problem (Dublin, 1971). ⁹³ On the relative absence of class differentiation, see Hannan, Displacement and Development, 197. ⁹⁴ Ibid. 36. ⁹⁵ Patrick McNabb, ‘Social Structure’, in Jeremiah Newman (ed.), The Limerick Rural Survey, 1958–1964 ( Tipperary, 1964), 197. ⁹⁶ Ibid. 205.
Leaving Home
31
introduction of universal free secondary education in September 1967, few of these poorer families in Limerick were financially able to realize the objective of securing secondary education for their children. Many left school before completing the requisite examinations, most of them eventually migrating to England without any qualifications.⁹⁷ The rural working classes were caught in an unenviable dilemma. Unable to obtain educational qualifications that would allow them to compete for much-sought-after central and local government posts, the immediate prospects were grim. With a few notable exceptions, unskilled factory employment was scarce and concentrated in particular regions such as along the east coast. For young women, domestic service was a traditional form of unskilled work in Ireland, but, as most contemporaries acknowledged, it was an arduous and poorly paid job, which involved a considerable degree of drudgery, particularly as the ‘servant girl’ on a farm.⁹⁸ Nursing training was restricted to the daughters of the wealthy farming class since a payment of fees was required. One female migrant who trained in Britain recalled that ‘all the nurses in Dublin at the time were all farmers’ daughters’.⁹⁹ Males faced a similar range of unattractive options: intermittent employment by farmers or casual labouring with the local authority, where such opportunities existed, punctuated by long spells of underemployment. Monotonous and extremely heavy work in Britain in building, coal-mining, and factories offered young Irish males a chance to escape from the endless insecurity of scratching out a living in rural and small-town Ireland. The relationship between social class and migration was intimately associated with the educational system. Young women from more prosperous backgrounds tended to stay in education longer as farming families were keen to provide their daughters with skills and qualifications. But, as one sociological study of Cavan in the mid–1960s noted, this led to a higher rate of female migration since it increased ‘the level of occupational and other status aspirations of the girls vis-à-vis the boys’, few of which could be satisfied by staying within the local area.¹⁰⁰ Even if work were available in local factories, this was deemed to be ⁹⁷ Ibid. 203. ⁹⁸ Transcripts of evidence, Irish Housewives’ Association, n.d., Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8307/3; McNabb, ‘Social Structure’, 173. ⁹⁹ Quoted in Kaja Irene Ziesler, ‘The Irish in Birmingham, 1830–1970’ (unpub. Ph.D. thesis, University of Birmingham, 1989), 172. ¹⁰⁰ D. F. Hannan, ‘Migration Motives and Migration Differentials among Irish Rural Youth’, Sociologia Ruralis, 9, no. 3 (1969), 210; Hannan, Rural Exodus, 225.
32
Leaving Home
unacceptable for educated young women since the term ‘factory girls’ carried with it all sorts of negative connotations in rural Ireland.¹⁰¹ Only a minority of the Irish in Britain had continued education beyond the completion of primary schooling. By the mid–1950s roughly two-thirds of young adults leaving school in independent Ireland did so at the age of 14, having completed primary education.¹⁰² It was estimated in the 1960s that just one in five of the Irish in Britain had attended any form of secondary schooling prior to departure.¹⁰³ Another survey of the migrant Irish completed in the early 1970s indicated that three-quarters had left school after primary education.¹⁰⁴ Without educational qualifications, these migrants were restricted in the jobs that they could obtain on arrival in Britain, confining them to the bottom rungs of the occupational hierarchy. The inflexible nature of the class structure was itself a cause of emigration as seemingly restricted opportunities for upward mobility strengthened the imperative to leave. Numerous studies of social mobility in post-war Ireland arrive at much the same conclusion: prior to industrial development and the educational reforms of the 1960s which led to rapid expansion in the availability of free secondary education, opportunities for upward mobility were exceedingly restricted. The general consensus is that mass emigration was a key factor in maintaining stability across the rigid class structure since it impacted disproportionately on the working and lower middle classes.¹⁰⁵ And while it is difficult to chart, there is fragmentary evidence that emigration was a reflection of changes in attitudes towards the rigid system of social stratification. According to one well-informed observer, emigration was an indication ¹⁰¹ Hannan, Rural Exodus, 253. ¹⁰² Commission on Emigration, Reports, 177. ¹⁰³ Quoted in Hannan, ‘Irish Emigration Since the War’, 6; see also B. J. Whelan and J. G. Hughes, ‘A Survey of Returned and Intending Emigrants in Ireland’ (Unpublished Report Prepared for the EEC Study of Housing Conditions of Migrant Workers, 1976), 52. Copy available at the Economic and Social Research Institute Library, Dublin. ¹⁰⁴ Ryan, ‘Assimilation of Irish Immigrants’, 137. ¹⁰⁵ Richard Breen, Damian F. Hannan, David B. Rottman, and Christopher T. Whelan, Understanding Contemporary Ireland: State, Class and Development in the Republic of Ireland (London, 1990), 54; Christopher T. Whelan, Richard Breen, and Brendan J. Whelan, ‘Industrialisation, Class Formation and Social Mobility in Ireland’, in J. H. Goldthorpe and C. T. Whelan (eds.), The Development of Industrial Society in Ireland (Oxford, 1992), 107; Richard Breen and Christopher Whelan, ‘Social Mobility in Ireland: A Comparative Analysis’, in Anthony F. Heath, Richard Breen, and Christopher T. Whelan (eds.), Ireland North and South: Perspectives from the Social Sciences (Oxford, 1999), 337; Michael Hout, Following in Father’s Footsteps: Social Mobility in Ireland (Cambridge, Mass., 1989), 109–10.
Leaving Home
33
that the rural working classes were no longer prepared to accept their unhappy lot.¹⁰⁶ This silent revolution was a significant cause of the mass exodus from post-war Ireland. At the upper echelons of the educational scale, for the minuscule élite who entered Irish universities in the 1940s and 1950s—less than one in every hundred of the population in 1950—leaving the country was widely regarded as the eventual outcome of the completion of a professional degree course.¹⁰⁷ While uncertainty exists about the precise level of graduate emigration at this time, Irish universities were producing large numbers of graduates for export.¹⁰⁸ The rapidly expanding National Health Service in Britain generated an abundance of openings for newly qualified young Irish doctors in particular. Somewhere between one-half and one-quarter of Irish medical graduates in the 1940s and 1950s were employed abroad, the majority going ‘across the water’. By the mid–1960s over 3,500 Irish-born doctors were working in Britain, of whom three-quarters were born in independent Ireland.¹⁰⁹ After reviewing the evidence, an official commission of inquiry into the Irish higher education system recommended in 1967 that an ‘allowance’ should be made in future calculations for emigration in the provision of medical education.¹¹⁰ Other higher professionals were also compelled to leave on graduating from Irish universities, a phenomenon that was identified internationally in the late 1960s as the ‘brain drain’.¹¹¹ Based on surveys with current students at Trinity College Dublin and University College Dublin, one report suggested that three-quarters intended to leave Ireland, and about a quarter planned to return at an unspecified later date.¹¹² For those who aspired to enter the professions as doctors, engineers, architects, and managers, moving to Britain and elsewhere was an inevitable stage in the ¹⁰⁶ McNabb, ‘Social Structure’, 193–209. ¹⁰⁷ In 1950 0.23 per cent of the population attended university (Commission on Emigration, Reports, 178, n. 1). ¹⁰⁸ Commission on Emigration, Reports, 178; Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 259–61. ¹⁰⁹ Oscar Gish, ‘Emigration and the Supply and Demand for Medical Manpower: The Irish Case’, Minerva, 7 (1969), 669. ¹¹⁰ Commission on Higher Education, 1960–67, Report (Dublin, 1967), Pr 9389, i. 246. A consideration here was that the universities were no doubt keen to ensure that the numbers who were allowed to train as doctors were not reduced as a consequence of any recommendations made by the Commission. ¹¹¹ See D. W. Forrest, Managerial Emigration (Dublin, 1967); Richard Lynn, The Irish Brain Drain (Dublin, 1968). ¹¹² Lynn, The Irish Brain Drain, 2.
34
Leaving Home
process of acquiring relevant experience. Graduate emigration attracted relatively little public interest until the late 1960s. For a small country with an underdeveloped economy it was widely acknowledged that there was a finite number of openings for skilled professionals, and the implicit assumption was that experience garnered abroad might at some future date benefit the country. Those who embarked on such degree courses were well aware of the marginal chances in the short to medium term of ever securing permanent employment in independent Ireland. Given the long tradition of movement and the impact of emigration across all social classes, it might be taken as a given that leaving Ireland carried with it no negative connotations. Migration was the ostensible means to secure a livelihood for the working and lower middle classes as well as professionals. However, among the strong farming classes in the south and east with large holdings, emigration was also perceived to be a marker of social class. An unpublished study undertaken in the early 1970s captures in vivid detail this subtle distinction: To the unskilled and unemployed England seemed a land of opportunity, but to the fifty-acre farmers and the petty bourgeoisie of the towns and villages it seemed a kind of ghetto for Irish people, a kind of huge Irish slum, a place where none of the better class of people ever went, not even on holidays. And the threat of a son or daughter to take the boat train was a threat that the family name might be tainted with the mark of the emigrant and coupled with the labourers and others who somehow weren’t talented enough to get employment at home.¹¹³
Even for those who acquired substantial savings through working abroad and subsequently purchased a farm or pub back in Ireland, this money ‘was somehow tainted by the sins of England’ and they often found themselves isolated by the local farmers.¹¹⁴ Apparently such views were confined to the bourgeoisie of rural Ireland, as farmers with medium-sized holdings in rural Limerick adopted a more pragmatic approach. Emigration was perceived as the means by which their offspring could maintain and improve their social status.¹¹⁵ Both the parents and children shared the belief that status and security were the key considerations for getting an ‘acceptable’ job after emigration; if a son had accepted manual work while living abroad ‘the family would try to hide this fact from the neighbours’.¹¹⁶ Even in the poorer regions of the west of Ireland, the ¹¹³ Ryan, ‘Assimilation of Irish Immigrants’, 114. ¹¹⁵ McNabb, ‘Social Structure’, 215. ¹¹⁶ Ibid.
¹¹⁴ Ibid.
Leaving Home
35
strong farmers or ‘respectable’ classes viewed England as the destination of only the ‘very poor’, since those with access to any resources went to North America.¹¹⁷ Such finely grained distinctions show that social class was a significant influence on attitudes towards emigration. For the working and lower middle classes, leaving Ireland was a necessity to secure steady employment; for their social superiors, given the narrow range of suitable opportunities for white collar and professional workers, in order to maintain social status and achieve career and income aspirations, emigration was just as inevitable. Where the distinctions are most evident are in the perceptions of the ultimate purpose of emigration, and the extent to which it was perceived to be volitional or not. Often the movement from post-war Ireland was implicitly characterized as the displacement of the lumpenproletariat from the poverty-ridden regions of rural Ireland to the large industrial slums of post-war Britain. Irish politicians, on the one hand, decried the depopulation of rural communities—the simple life in the rural idyll was a central component of earlier nationalist ideology—yet privately understood the potential implications of large numbers staying at home.¹¹⁸ The language of class was most trenchantly expressed by Alexis Fitzgerald in his now infamous reservation to the report of the Commission on Emigration in 1955. Fitzgerald, a lawyer and lecturer in economics at University College Dublin, epitomized the élite mindset when it came to understanding the impact of emigration on individuals and families: I cannot accept either the view that a high rate of emigration is necessarily a sign of national decline or that policy should be over-anxiously framed to reduce it . . . Where there is a danger of complacency I believe that there should be a more realistic appreciation of the advantages of emigration. High emigration, granted a population excess, releases the social tensions which would otherwise explode and makes possible a stability of manners and customs which would otherwise be the subject of radical change. It is a national advantage that it is easy for emigrants to establish their lives in other parts of the world not merely from the point of view of the Irish society they leave behind but from the point of view of the individuals whose horizon of opportunity is widened.¹¹⁹
Two lines of thought may be identified relating to attitudes towards emigration.¹²⁰ First, there were those such as Eamon de Valera who ¹¹⁷ ¹¹⁸ ¹¹⁹ ¹²⁰
Hannan, Displacement and Development, 162. Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 206. Commission on Emigration, Reports, 222. This section draws heavily on Lee, Ireland, 1912–85, 371 ff.
36
Leaving Home
believed that emigration was fuelled by unrealistic (and irrational) expectations on the part of the poorer sectors of Irish society. For a politician whose ideal society was rural-based, simple, and devoid of materialism, leaving Ireland simply to carve out a decent livelihood was unthinkable. The other view, exemplified by his successor as leader of Fianna Fáil from 1959, Seán Lemass, centred on conventional logic: in order to reduce emigration Irish living standards needed to be increased over time, rather than hoping that the populace would in time lower their expectations. In his famous Clery’s speech in January 1957 Lemass had declared that ‘our standards must approximate to British standards, or our people will go’.¹²¹ And he was quite right: those who were not prepared to subsist in poverty or near-poverty chose the exit option and left. Another element of the discourse relating to emigration highlighted by J. J. Lee is the issue of class differences. Discussions about emigration, both those in the public sphere and those which took place behind closed doors, often presented the emigrant as somewhat feckless, easily led (especially in the case of women), and driven by a base and contemptible desire for higher income. But these were the desires, needs, and aspirations of those who had relatively little in Ireland being viewed through the eyes and mindset of those who had a great deal more. A revealing example of the disparity between élite views and the harsh reality experienced by many people can be found in the discussions of whether emigration was the result of economic expectations or ‘want’ and whether the movement of people was a ‘voluntary’ or ‘involuntary’ process.¹²² These distinctions were artificial constructions and, as Lee observes, it suited contemporary purposes: if emigrants left in order to improve their standard of living ‘the blame accordingly lay with the emigrants themselves, not with the society they left’.¹²³ Of course, one obvious implication of the exodus during the 1950s was that people emigrated because they had lost confidence in the ability of their politicians, civil servants, and other members of the ruling classes to create a society that might in the future allow them to enjoy a decent standard of living. It was often suggested that emigration acted as a safety-valve in the 1940s and 1950s.¹²⁴ For instance, if the British government had decided ¹²¹ Quoted ibid. 386. ¹²² Ibid. 374. ¹²³ Ibid. For an innovative analysis of this issue, see J. J. Lee, ‘Continuity and Change in Ireland, 1945–70’, in id. (ed.), Ireland, 1945–70 (Dublin, 1979), 166–77. ¹²⁴ Delaney, Irish Emigration Since 1921, 43.
Leaving Home
37
to restrict Irish immigration, as was mooted in the early 1960s, and Irish citizens were no longer allowed to take up employment in Britain, the impact on Irish society would have been far-reaching. With no possible outlet for the unemployed and underemployed, a reduction in the income of many households as a result of a lower level of migrant remittances, and thousands of people back in Ireland without work seeking welfare payments from an already depleted exchequer, the potential for social unrest would have greatly increased. This social unrest could have resulted in the development of the politics of class, an otherwise absent theme in post-war Irish politics. A recurring undercurrent in much of the public discussions was the seemingly inability of the working classes to maintain and uphold the morals of a ‘respectable’ Catholic country whilst living aboard. Much ink was spilt on the problem of ‘leakage’, that is, Catholics who failed to maintain strict ‘Irish’ norms of religious observance in England. The perceived failure to observe traditional Irish Catholic standards of sexual morality emerged as a key issue for the Catholic church and the body politic. Given the inextricable relationship between these powerful institutions in independent Ireland, this issue was increasingly placed under the spotlight, as we shall see in a later chapter.
5 . FA M I L I E S A N D H O U S E H O L D S The family was encoded in the Irish constitution of 1937 as ‘the natural primary and fundamental unit group of society’, which was afforded protection under the constitution ‘as the necessary basis of social order and as indispensable to the welfare of the nation and the state’, reflecting interwar Catholic social teaching.¹²⁵ In theory, the departure of such large numbers of young people should have led to a fracturing of close-knit relationships and severely disrupted the effective functioning of the family. Many families in post-war Ireland were dispersed with siblings living overseas for years on end, carving out livelihoods and raising children without direct access to the support structures that most people took for granted, as they set up home after marriage. How, then, did families view mass migration and what were the consequences for migrant households? ¹²⁵ Bunreacht na hÉireann (Dublin, 2003), art 41.1, 1◦ –2◦ .
38
Leaving Home
Traditionally, as we have seen, emigration was conceived as a collective response to the economic situation in Ireland after the Great Famine. Prior to independence, ’ew emigrants were accused of placing their own wellbeing over the collective ‘national’ interest or of being selfish, with the exception of the Anglo-Irish war when the provisional Dáil Éireann prohibited emigration in 1920 to stop potential IRA activists leaving the country.¹²⁶ In the mid-twentieth century, as levels of emigration continued to rise, an emerging theme in public discourse was the conflation of leaving Ireland with a vague and unspecified form of individualistic behaviour that resulted in material values being perceived to be more important than maintaining the family unit, and in effect undermined the viability of the wider community in rural Ireland. The behaviour of individuals, however, was conditioned by the broader environment, and decisions about emigration were often taken within the context of household needs. For the family unit to survive, it could not support children who had come of age, yet were unable to contribute to the overall income. The famous ethnographic study of north Clare in the 1930s by two American social anthropologists, Arensberg and Kimball, demonstrated that emigration was a vital element in the survival of the small farm economy in the poorer regions of the west of Ireland. While their portrayal of a timeless rural society was influenced by the functionalist tradition in which the work was originally conceived, inheritance patterns and ultimately the economic survival of the family were predicated on the ‘dispersal’ of children. Viewed in the light of this family structure, the decline of population becomes interpretable not as a flight from intolerable conditions, though economic distress had a powerful effect, not as a political gesture, though political disturbance took its toll, but rather as a movement arising from the effect of all these causes upon a family system whose very nature predisposed it to disperse population and which could, therefore, accommodate itself to that dispersal when it occurred.¹²⁷
Far from being a disruptive influence, emigration was essential for the maintenance of a harmonious social system. The household adapted with apparently effortless ease to this dispersal of ‘surplus’ children. This was a natural part, in their view, of the social reproduction of ¹²⁶ David Fitzpatrick, ‘Emigration, 1871–1921’, in W. E. Vaughan (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 6: Ireland Under the Union, II (1870–1921) (Oxford, 1996), 632–3. ¹²⁷ Arensberg and Kimball, Family and Community in Ireland, 150.
Leaving Home
39
small farm communities in the subsistence farming regions of the west of Ireland. While a number of central components of Arensberg and Kimball’s analysis were challenged by later scholars, this observation that emigration served to maintain rather than undermine the traditional structures of the family has stood the test of time.¹²⁸ What changed, however, from the Second World War onwards was the rural economy of the west and north-western counties. Subsistence farming which had characterized these regions became an increasingly impecunious livelihood in the context of commercialized large-scale agricultural production.¹²⁹ By the early 1970s such areas were identified in a plethora of surveys and reports as a ‘problem’, echoing earlier reports from the Congested Districts Board in the 1890s. One of the major ingredients of the ‘problem’ now was rural depopulation and the reluctance of children to remain and take over the family holding.¹³⁰ The simple life of subsistence farming had little to offer this generation. As one sociologist noted, ‘whereas in the 1920s brothers had competed for the inheritance, in the 1960s they vied to escape it’.¹³¹ The emigration of family members was a necessity for poorer households, but did it lead to the fracturing of social relations between the migrants and those left behind in Ireland? One commentator has argued that both emigration and the urbanization of the 1950s ‘greatly weakened the traditional family’.¹³² The evidence is not, however, as unequivocal as this statement indicates. As was discussed earlier, one of the characteristic features of the mass migrations of the post-war era was the interaction between migrants in Britain and friends and relatives at home. Autobiographies and oral histories show that migrants living in Britain retained close links with family and friends back in Ireland. Proximity and constant movement back and forth across the Irish Sea for holidays and other visits ensured that siblings maintained contact with each other. While such bonds may have lessened over time, it ¹²⁸ Peter Gibbon, ‘Arensberg and Kimball Revisited’, Economy and Society, 2, no. 4 (1973), 479–98; Peter Gibbon and Christopher Curtin, ‘The Stem Family in Ireland’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 20 (1978), 429–53, and a critique by David Fitzpatrick, ‘Irish Farming Families before the First World War’, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 25 (1983), 339–74. ¹²⁹ For more details, see Hannan, Displacement and Development; Damian F. Hannan, ‘Kinship, Neighbourhood and Social Change in Irish Rural Communities’, Economic and Social Review, 3, no. 2 (1972), 163–88. ¹³⁰ Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 234–5. ¹³¹ Hannan, Displacement and Development, 159. ¹³² Kennedy, Family, Economy and Government, 12.
40
Leaving Home
appears that family relations were still maintained, notwithstanding the obvious problems posed by distance and location.¹³³ Does this imply that a gust of rampant individualism suddenly swept through post-war Ireland which undermined traditional social mores? According to one interpretative account of the changes in the family since the 1960s, ‘as Ireland developed from an agricultural and rural economy towards a more industrialized and urban economy, individualistic values tended to replace that set of values which granted pre-eminence to the family’.¹³⁴ Brody’s study described what he termed as a ‘personalized sense of self’ among young males, which shaped the decisions and judgements and confounded traditional expectations about the duty to the family and the land.¹³⁵ The cult of the ‘individual’ is a universally acknowledged feature of advanced capitalist societies.¹³⁶ But emigration could simultaneously reconcile the wants, needs, and aspirations of the individual with the collective interest in maintaining traditional ways of life.¹³⁷ In the 1940s and 1950s these attitudes towards family responsibilities were also gradually moving towards the western European norm. The values of the urban middle class, with an emphasis on individual fulfilment and personal achievement, and reflected in the patterns of consumption, clashed with rural norms of kin obligations and the ‘pre-eminence’ of the family as a group ‘over the individual’.¹³⁸ In a study conducted between 1949 and 1951 by an American Jesuit sociologist, based on fieldwork on the ‘new’ Dubliners, migrants who settled in the capital from rural Ireland, the author concluded that urbanization did result in the decline in traditional values centred on the family and kin.¹³⁹ Urban living did not, though, produce a more secular outlook: ‘In short, in spite of his [sic] many points of contact with modern secularism and his [sic] involvement with a modern ¹³³ See Sharon Lambert, Irish Women in Lancashire, 1922–1960: Their Story (Lancaster, 2001), 35–44; Louise Ryan, ‘Family Matters: (E)migration, Familial Networks and Irish Women in Britain’, Sociological Review, 52, no. 3 (2004), 351–70. ¹³⁴ Kennedy, Family, Economy and Government, 18. ¹³⁵ Brody, Inishkillane, 164–6. ¹³⁶ See Jose Harris, ‘Tradition and Transformation: Society and Civil Society in Britain, 1945–2001’, in Kathleen Burk (ed.), The British Isles Since 1945 (Oxford, 2003), 110. ¹³⁷ On this point, see Kennedy, Family, Economy and Government, 18. ¹³⁸ Alexander J. Humphreys, New Dubliners: Urbanization and the Irish Family (London, 1966), 22; also quoted by Kennedy, Family, Economy and Government, 18. ¹³⁹ Humphreys, New Dubliners, 32–9.
Leaving Home
41
industrial economy, the New Dubliner has not become secularized.’¹⁴⁰ This observation contrasts sharply with the frequently voiced concerns that life in urban—and, even more insidious, secular—Britain was a serious threat to the morals of Irish Catholics. One potential barometer of the degree to which the concerns of the family coexisted with the needs and aspirations of the individual was the amount of money sent home by migrants as remittances. According to a recent popular history of the Irish navvy in Britain, the ‘expectation of remittance money characterized almost every relationship between the Irish emigrant and his or her family back in Ireland’.¹⁴¹ Traditionally, sending money back home was an integral element of the process of migration. The flow of remittances back across the Atlantic in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries was enormous by international standards. One historian estimated that roughly $260 million (£52 million) was sent back to the United Kingdom between 1848 and 1900, the vast majority from the Irish in the United States.¹⁴² Such statistics, it must be said, should be treated with caution as they are of ‘doubtful quality’, although there is little doubt that the ‘golden stream of dollars’ was a significant source of income for migrant households across Ireland. The ‘American money’ was used to pay rents and other bills, and in the case of more comfortable families to purchase additional land or livestock.¹⁴³ By the mid-twentieth century ‘American money’ was still a crucial element in some of the poorer communities in the west of Ireland. One member of the Commission on Emigration was astonished to learn that the apparent prosperity of the parish of Lahardane in County Mayo was based solely on migrant remittances from the United States: Because of emigrants’ remittances and of gifts of clothing from relatives abroad, particularly those in U.S.A. [sic], the people of the parish are well dressed and are not short of money . . . This dependence on outside resources colours the outlook of many to such an extent that they are not prepared to do anything for themselves or even to avail of facilities designed to help them improve their lot. The senior curate, who takes a keen interest in the public affairs of the country ¹⁴⁰ Ibid. 38. ¹⁴¹ Ultan Cowley, The Men Who Built Britain: A History of the Irish Navvy (Dublin, 2001), 86. ¹⁴² Schrier, Ireland and the American Emigration, 105. This figure has been accepted by later historians, but Schrier’s original estimate refers to the United Kingdom as a whole and not just Ireland; see Kevin A. Kenny, The American Irish (Harlow, 2000), 139; Miller, Emigrants and Exiles, 397. ¹⁴³ Fitzpatrick, ‘Emigration, 1801–70’, 601; Schrier, Ireland and the American Emigration, 104–22.
42
Leaving Home
and is most enterprising, has found it impossible to arouse local interest in proposals for the improvement of conditions.¹⁴⁴
Clearly the Catholic curate was venting his frustration at the culture of ‘dependency’ in this particular parish, a dependency fed by the sense of duty and obligation of friends and relatives living overseas. Data on migrant remittances from the United States and Britain were collected by the Irish state by monitoring the amount of money and telegraphic or ‘wire’ orders. One estimate suggests that almost £3 billion was sent from Britain to Ireland between 1939 and 1969 through official means such as telegrams and money orders.¹⁴⁵ Any official statistics would underestimate the total figure since a couple of pounds could simply be slipped into an envelope or handed over faceto-face when home on holidays.¹⁴⁶ British currency was exchangeable in many shops in Ireland and there was therefore no need for this type of transaction to attract the attention of the prying eyes of the world of officialdom. As the historian Mary E. Daly has noted, by the mid to late 1950s the annual inflow of emigrants’ remittances amounted to roughly the sum spent by the Irish state on old age pensions.¹⁴⁷ In 1952 migrant remittances constituted roughly 2.5 per cent of national income, rose slightly in the early 1960s to 3.2 per cent, and thereafter remained at its previous level throughout the 1960s, until a steep decline in the following decade.¹⁴⁸ In the late 1960s roughly £20 million per annum was remitted back to Ireland.¹⁴⁹ While the total amounts involved are undoubtedly significant, there is fragmentary evidence that sending money home declined over the course of the post-war years. The widely shared assumption that migrant children living abroad would contribute to the household income was undermined by the ¹⁴⁴ S.1, Rural Survey of Mayo and Sligo, prepared by J. P. Beddy, n.d. (1948), Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306. ¹⁴⁵ Cowley, The Men Who Built Britain, 29. A slightly higher figure of £3.5 billion was cited by the leader of the Irish Labour Party, Pat Rabbitte, in a parliamentary debate in 2004: Dáil Éireaan Debates, 578 (27 Jan. 2004), col. 279. ¹⁴⁶ I am very grateful to Professor Mary E. Daly for advice on this point. ¹⁴⁷ Mary E. Daly, ‘The Irish Family Since the Famine: Continuity and Change’, Irish Journal of Feminist Studies, 3, no. 2 (1999), 6. ¹⁴⁸ Commission on Emigration, Reports, table 39, 55; Miceal Ross, Further Data on County Income in the Sixties (Dublin, 1972), tables 1–3; J. J. Sexton, B. M. Walsh, D. F. Hannan, and Dorren McMahon, The Economic and Social Implications of Emigration (Dublin, 1991), 242; Cormac Ó Gráda and Brendan M. Walsh, ‘The Economic Effects of Emigration: Ireland’, in Beth J. Asch (ed.), Emigration and Its Effects on the Sending Country (Santa Monica, Calif., 1994), 137. ¹⁴⁹ Hannan, ‘Irish Emigration Since the War’, 8.
Leaving Home
43
actual experience. Prospective migrants often cited the pressing need to support the family as one of the principal reasons for emigration.¹⁵⁰ Nevertheless, complaints about children (and indeed spouses) who failed to live up to this expectation were routinely received by welfare organizations and, as Daly notes, married men were the group most likely to send money home. She argues further that ‘the growing demand for economic independence on the part of daughters and sons also encouraged emigration, while making it less likely that emigrants would send money home’.¹⁵¹ In the initial stages this obligation was at the forefront of mindsets, but it is reasonable to assume that, as time moved on, financial commitments towards those remaining at home receded in consciousness, especially as disposable income was used for other purposes, including housing, personal consumption, and leisure activities. Admittedly the evidence is ambiguous on the extent to which maintaining a direct financial connection with family in Ireland was in itself a reflection of the durability of ties across the Irish Sea. The association between leaving home and sending money back is a component of the traditional migrant story, and not just in Ireland. The hard-pressed emigrant working abroad, living in American or British cities, scraped and saved every penny to support his or her poor relatives back in Ireland. By the 1950s this nostalgic vision was looking increasingly out of touch with the realities of the relationships between those who left and those who stayed behind. Whether individuals felt obliged to support family members who were still living in Ireland was influenced by the context of the original departure, the length of time in Britain, and, not least, the level of disposable income that could be allocated for this particular purpose. As with so much else in human actions, there is no one pattern of behaviour that can neatly be applied to the hundreds of thousands who left independent Ireland after the end of the Second World War. Mass migration from post-war Ireland was a continuation of a tradition of large-scale movement since at least the mid-eighteenth century. But significant differences existed in the post-war years. Gone were the days when the reluctant exile left the homeland on the assumption that they would never set foot in the old country again. Moving to Britain allowed for repeated visits home, and thousands ¹⁵⁰ Daly, ‘The Irish Family Since the Famine’, 6; for more details, see Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306. ¹⁵¹ Daly, ‘The Irish Family Since the Famine’, 8.
44
Leaving Home
regularly travelled back and forth across the Irish Sea, in a pattern more akin to seasonal migration than the finality of a permanent departure. This massive exodus had its roots in the dismal economic environment that existed up to the early 1960s, and leaving was rationalized as a temporary expedient until things improved at home. Individuals were also responding to changing values and attitudes that emphasized individual wellbeing and personal aspirations. As one contemporary observed, young people growing up in post-war Ireland were ‘gradually becoming less willing to accept the frugal standards of previous generations’.¹⁵² One the final decision was made, all that now remained was the initial journey across the Irish Sea. ¹⁵² McNabb, ‘Social Structure’, 260; also quoted in Brody, Inishkillane, 99.
2 In a Strange Land
1
What I couldn’t do. Eat a meal lacking potatoes. Trust banks. Wear a watch. Ask a woman to go for a walk. Work with drains or objects smaller than a nail. Drive a motor car. Eat tomatoes. Remember the routes of buses. Wear a collar in comfort. Win at cards. Acknowledge the Queen. Abide loud voices. Perform the manners of greeting and leaving. Save money. Take pleasure in work carried out in a factory. Drink coffee. Look into a wound. Follow cricket. Understand the speech of a man from west Kerry. Wear shoes or boots made from rubber. Best P.J. in an argument. Speak with men wearing collars. Stay afloat in water. Understand their jokes. Face the dentist. Kill a Sunday. Stop remembering.²
What was different about this ‘strange land’ that the Irish travelled to in such large numbers? According to one imaginative novel, it was the mundane things that were part and parcel of the minutiae of everyday existence that made the dislocation even more painful. In his twilight years, the elderly male narrator reflected on a lifetime spent working in England and recited this list of things that he felt he could never do. Remembering was a tortuous experience, as his life was marked by displacement, loss, and the ultimate loneliness of existing in a onebedroom flat in Kentish Town in London. But at the same time his memories were also interspersed with fleeting moments of happiness from his childhood and life back at home. This is a work of fiction, but, as the historian Patrick Joyce remarks, such an exploration illustrates the challenge to the historical imagination to re-create a social world ‘out ¹ The title of this chapter is taken from the autobiographical account of John O’Donoghue, In a Strange Land (London, 1958). ² Timothy O’Grady and Steve Pyke, I Could Read the Sky (London, 1997), 71; first cited by Patrick Joyce, ‘More Secondary Modern than Postmodern’, Rethinking History, 5, no. 3 (2001), 380.
46
In a Strange Land
of a sense of the intimate details of the everyday, the competencies and inner knowledge available only to those who experience them directly’.³ Traditional documentary sources shed little light on the inner feelings, fears, or emotions of migrants, as the complexities of the lived experience involved in such a move were intensely personal. Even contemporary surveys are more likely to tell us what the respondent felt should be the ‘right’ answer, as the dynamics of power shaped these encounters. By far the most valuable fragments are to be found in the actual words of the migrants themselves: in autobiographies, collections of interviews, memoirs, oral histories, and more ephemeral collections of memories and reminiscences. These disjointed, unsystematic, and diverse contrasting voices form the basis for much of what follows in this chapter, as we seek to explore what Robert Orsi describes as ‘the inner history of immigration’.⁴ As well as charting the actual experiences of the thousands who left post-war Ireland for Britain, the challenge for historians is to ‘reconstruct the world-view through which they experienced it’.⁵
1 . AC RO S S T H E WAT E R Taking leave of Ireland for the first time was a poignant event. The typical scene of the departing migrant at the quayside saying tearful goodbyes to huddled crowds of anxious relatives was, in fact, quite an untypical experience for the majority of those who left post-war Ireland. Few families could afford to accompany a loved one to the ports of Dublin, Dun Laoghaire, Cork, or Rosslare. The first stage of the emotional departure therefore occurred at the nearest railway station. Painful scenes of separation and loss were enacted on desolate railway platforms across post-war Ireland. Unlike their British counterpart, the railways in Ireland were constructed on a model that centred on the two main cities, Dublin and Cork, with the port of Dun Laoghaire only a short hop away by train from Westland Row in the capital city. The decaying railway network, which had suffered from decades of lack of investment, together with the even more unreliable rural motor-bus ³ Joyce, ‘More Secondary Modern than Postmodern’, 380. ⁴ Robert Orsi, The Madonna of 115th Street: Faith and Community in Italian Harlem, 1880–1950, 2nd edn. (New Haven, 2002), 150. ⁵ Matthew Frye Jacobson, Special Sorrows: The Diasporic Imagination of Irish, Polish, and Jewish Immigrants in the United States, 2nd edn. (Berkeley, 2002), 6.
In a Strange Land
47
services, transported hundreds of thousands of young Irish people to the sites of departure in what was truly a remarkable feat given its state of decrepitude. In an evocative documentary film, The Irishmen, produced for the BBC in the mid–1960s by Philip Donnellan, but for various reasons never broadcast, the central character is followed on the long journey from the Connemara Irish-speaking Gaeltacht to metropolitan London.⁶ Several of the scenes are concerned with the train journey to Dublin, and while this aspect is ‘perhaps the least well-handed feature’ of the film, they do capture with insight the initial stages of the experience of leaving home.⁷ For the journalist Donal Foley, who left his native Waterford in September 1944 for wartime London, it was a heartbreaking scene as ‘the platform was crowded with young people, the mothers clinging on to them loath to let go and anxious to get the last seconds of their companionship’.⁸ Paddy Fahey, the photographer who did so much to document the lives of the London Irish, remembered that the departure of the train from Waterford city was an event in itself. At a quarter to nine each evening the train for Rosslare in the early 1940s was watched by crowds to see who was leaving and ‘there was a procession of people catching the boat’.⁹ When the writer John B. Keane left County Kerry in 1952, he recounted that when he ‘boarded the train at Listowel that morning it seemed as if everyone was leaving. It was the same at every train station along the way.’¹⁰ In his musical play, Many Young Men of Twenty, first performed in 1961, Keane drew on these experiences, as one of the characters described what he witnessed on the train to Dublin: It was the same at every station along the way, Danger. ’Twould make anybody cry. Young boys and girls leaving home for the first time. Fathers and mothers heartbroken, turnin’ their heads away to hide the tears. ’Twould turn you against railway stations.¹¹ ⁶ The Irishmen: An Impression of Exile (BBC, not transmitted, 1965). For the background to this documentary and the reasons why ultimately it was not broadcast, see Lance Pettitt, ‘Philip Donnellan, Ireland and Dissident Documentary’, Historical Journal of Film, Radio and Television, 20, no. 3 (2000), 356–8. Donnellan’s BBC Controller described it, rather harshly, as ‘shapeless, pretentious and, to be frank, boring’ (ibid. 358). ⁷ Ibid. 356. ⁸ Donal Foley, Three Villages: An Autobiography (Dublin, 1977), 52. ⁹ Paddy Fahey, The Irish in London: Photographs and Memories (London, 1991), 24. ¹⁰ John B. Keane, Self-Portrait (Cork, 1964), 32. ¹¹ John B. Keane, Many Young Men of Twenty (Cork, 1961), 155.
48
In a Strange Land
It is a historical irony that the coming of the railway, which was such a portentous precursor of modernization in nineteenth-century Ireland, also signalled the arrival of a brutally efficient system of transporting large numbers of would-be migrants on the initial stages of the journey from geographically isolated locations to American and British cities. On arrival in Dublin or Cork many migrants stayed overnight with friends or relatives or in hostels or lodging-houses before setting sail the following day. From the Second World War until the early 1950s it was possible under certain conditions to have the complete passage paid for by the British authorities, who were anxious to secure workers for ‘essential industries and services’ that were experiencing labour shortages.¹² For instance, in 1946 thousands of Irish men were recruited for coal-mining. The following year nearly 3,000 women travelled to Britain to embark on nursing training.¹³ This scheme was a legacy of the elaborate machinery that was established by the British and Irish governments in 1940 to make arrangements for the placement of Irish workers in particular forms of employment. Even after the end of the war in 1945, these mechanisms continued to operate until the mid–1950s, offering the prospect of a guaranteed job and a pre-paid fare, albeit in the least desirable types of employment. But those who availed themselves of this scheme had to undergo a thorough medical examination in Dublin to ensure that they were fit, healthy, and suitable for the particular job, prior to leaving Ireland. By all accounts, this was a demeaning procedure conducted with ruthless efficiency by the Irish doctors who were assigned to the task. For one young woman who left Ireland in 1946 to be a domestic servant in Manchester the event was irrevocably etched in her memory: When we got to Dublin, we were met there and taken to this hotel. I’ll never forget that experience, it was terrible. The way they looked at you, we had to strip, take all our clothes off and they looked at every bit of us, at our hair and everything, before they gave us a cup of tea even. Then we had to go and get a bed; it was hard to get a bed because there was such a crowd of us. It was something terrible, I’ll never forget that night.¹⁴
A British official who was based in Dublin during the war praised the efforts of Irish public health doctors who were ‘100 per cent efficient’, but
¹² Julius Isaac, British Post-War Migration (Cambridge, 1954), 194. ¹³ Ibid. ¹⁴ Anne Lynch (ed.), The Irish in Exile: Stories of Emigration (London, 1988), 15.
In a Strange Land
49
this efficacy came at a deeply humiliating price.¹⁵ The Irish chief medical advisor, James Deeny, was shocked at the treatment that he witnessed on a visit to inspect the Health Embarkation Scheme at the Globe Hotel on Talbot Street in Dublin, during the war.¹⁶ For younger people who travelled with official assistance, for many of whom it was their first time away from home, to be subjected to an invasive medical examination in this clinical environment must have been a terrifying ordeal. The historical resonance with the experiences of famine refugees who arrived in North America and Britain in the late 1840s was obvious: thousands of reluctant and powerless migrants had to endure similar medical checks to ensure that they were in a fit state to enter the host country. And the irony was that it was now Irish medical officers in Dublin who had the power to say who was fit to travel and who had to remain behind. An additional aspect that necessitated an engagement with official bureaucracy was the requirement up to 1952 to obtain a travel permit from the Irish authorities. This document was issued by the Irish Department of External Affairs and obtained from the local police station, to be presented on arrival in Britain as proof of identity. Until December 1947 visas or permits to enter Britain were also required and applications were made to the United Kingdom Permit Office in Dublin. Visas were issued for visits or for those going to work on a temporary basis, although this flexible distinction was open to manipulation.¹⁷ Armed with various documents, including a travel permit and official guidance leaflets, and a case of personal belongings, the reluctant migrant was now ready to set sail. The port of Dun Laoghaire was the main hub of activity for the post-war exodus from Ireland. This locus of departure was, according to Keane’s retrospective account, a pathetic sight. Dun Laoghaire, for the first time, was a heartbreaking experience—the goodbyes to husbands going back after Christmas, chubby-faced boys and girls leaving home for the first time, bewilderment written all over them, hard-faced oldstagers who never let on but who felt it worst of all because they knew only too well what lay before them.¹⁸ ¹⁵ A. V. Judges, ‘Irish Labour in Great Britain, 1939–1945’, 44, Jan. 1949, LAB 8/1528, PRO. ¹⁶ Enda Delaney, Demography, State and Society: Irish Migration to Britain, 1921–1971 (Kingston/Montreal and Liverpool, 2000), 143. ¹⁷ More details can be found in Commission on Emigration, Reports, app. VI–VII, and Isaac, British Post-War Migration, 192–6. ¹⁸ Keane, Self-Portrait, 32.
50
In a Strange Land
Many departed from Carlisle Pier in Dun Laoghaire for Holyhead on one of the ships that daily criss-crossed the short distance across the Irish Sea. The irony of leaving on a ship named Hibernia to do work of British ‘national importance’ during the war was not lost on Donal Foley.¹⁹ While a number of newer, larger, and better-equipped ships operated this route, a smaller vessel which did not have stabilizers, the Princess Maud, was brought into service during busy periods, and its notorious roll and the ensuing sickness has ensured its place in the folklore of those who left.²⁰ Used as a troop-carrier during the Normandy D-Day invasion in 1944, comfort was not its selling point. One passenger described his crossing as a ‘nightmare journey’, with people vomiting as the wind buffeted the small ship.²¹ Others left from the North Wall to set sail for Liverpool, and for those who lived in the south of the country, Cork and Rosslare were the points of departure. The Innisfallen, which operated between Cork and Fishguard, was a similar icon for generations of Munster migrants.²² Conditions on board were grim. Despite glossy promotional materials designed to attract the lucrative first-class tourist passengers, the voyage was less appealing for those in the crowded second-class compartments. People slept where they could find any space, on benches, along the corridors, and even on the floors. The Cork–Fishguard trip was the longest one, with the boat setting sail around six o’clock in the evening and arriving in south Wales in the early hours of the morning. From the North Wall in Dublin to Liverpool the journey was roughly seven hours. The Dun Laoghaire route was much shorter, approximately four to five hours, depending on weather conditions. One migrant, who left as a child from Cork in the late 1950s, remembered that the boats ‘were appalling, just like converted cattle ships’.²³ Only in the mid–1960s with the introduction of the modern car ferry services did conditions improve for those who made that seemingly endless pilgrimage across the Irish Sea.²⁴ For Foley, who left from Dun Laoghaire, the ship was ‘like a travelling Irish town, moving slowly and darkly across the ¹⁹ Foley, Three Villages, 53. ²⁰ Interview with Michael Frank Horan, 9 April 2002, MH 2002/261, LM; Dónall Mac Amhlaigh, An Irish Navvy: The Diary of an Exile, trans. from the Irish by Valentin Iremonger (London, 1964), 5; John Healy, No One Shouted Stop! (Achill, 1988), 89. This is a revised and expanded edition of Healy’s famous study first published as The Death of an Irish Town (Cork, 1968). ²¹ Pam Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 2nd edn. (London, 1991), 135. ²² Lynch (ed.), The Irish in Exile, 2. ²³ Ibid. ²⁴ Ibid. 18.
In a Strange Land
51
water’.²⁵ Heavy drinking was one familiar leisure activity to pass the time, as the new exiles sought consolation from that most traditional source of Hibernian inner resolve.²⁶ Often the ships were overcrowded, with inadequate sleeping provision for the travellers in second class. Traditional prejudices could also surface, as, according to Keane, the British crew could not on occasions conceal their contempt for their Irish cargo: ‘The tourist is fawned over and spoiled, but they can’t wait to deposit the departing Paddy on the other side.’²⁷ Bleary-eyed and disorientated, the first-time Irish traveller arrived in Britain, often in the small hours of the morning and after a long and tiring journey. Holyhead was, according to one account, ‘surely the unfriendliest spot during those years in whole world’.²⁸ Foley described the scene in 1944 with ambivalence as the passengers disembarked from the ship: We shuffled off the boat, a long dark crocodile of people. Walking as it were into the unknown except for those among us who had known the horrors of Camden Town, Kilburn, Birmingham, Glasgow, Coventry, Leeds, Reading and Slough before now. Horrors, yes, but warm with consolations too. The welcoming pubs, the weekly wage packet and the comradeship of adversity.²⁹
The first hurdle was passing through customs and immigration controls, and the stringent set of checks that were imposed during the war (although relaxed thereafter). This process could often take hours, and meanwhile the travellers were left exposed to the elements.³⁰ This initial encounter with British officialdom was often remembered vividly by some of the new arrivals.³¹ For John O’Donoghue, who came to Britain during the later years of the war, the passengers were scrutinized by the ‘keen-eyed’ officials who met those coming off the boat on the quayside in Holyhead: When we landed we were filtered through one barrier after another where we had to show our tickets and travel permits, be examined from head to toe until the officials were satisfied that we were the real people whose pictures appeared on the permits, and that all particulars connected with us were in order, so that no undesirable person might enter the country at such a dangerous time in its history.³² ²⁵ Foley, Three Villages, 53. ²⁶ Foley, Three Villages, 53–4; O’Donoghue, In a Strange Land, 12–13. ²⁷ Keane, Self-Portrait, 35. ²⁸ Foley, Three Villages, 54. ²⁹ Ibid. ³⁰ Keane, Self-Portrait, 38; Judges, ‘Irish Labour in Great Britain’, 39. ³¹ See, for example, Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 149; Nottingham Irish Studies Group, Making it Home: Experiences of Being Irish (Nottingham, 2001), 27.
52
In a Strange Land
Dónall Mac Amhlaigh, who first arrived in 1951, recounted a touching scene he witnessed in the customs hall in Holyhead. One Irish man who carried an old battered suitcase tied together with rope was asked to open it for inspection by the customs officer. At first he protested, then eventually he acceded to the request. He cut the twine and out came an old pair of Wellington boots, but ‘devil the thing else was in the case—not even a change of socks’.³³ The absence of any material possessions was exposed for all to see in the clinical conditions of this customs hall. Given the sheer scale of this movement of people, it was inevitable that at least a minority of those who landed would quickly run into difficulties. The Ministry of Labour made extensive efforts to position welfare officers at the main ports for workers who travelled under official schemes, and after a number of initial teething troubles this seemed to work reasonably well in the late 1940s and early 1950s. For others, who made their own way on the basis of a job offer or simply speculatively, serious problems could develop. For instance, volunteers from the Liverpool Vigilance Association (LVA) kept a daily logbook of individuals who needed assistance, and the arriving Irish were one of the main groups offered advice and guidance. In one instance cited by the volunteers an unnamed young Irish woman who was travelling to Cheshire in 1945 for a job was waiting at the port to be met. A misunderstanding had developed with her potential employers and she was left stranded, even though it was her first time in England and she had no idea how to get to her new place of employment. Spotting her obvious distress, the LVA worker approached her and managed to identify the relevant firm and make contact to ensure someone was able to meet her at the train station.³⁴ By the early 1950s reports were passed to the Irish government of young females disembarking in Liverpool without a job offer, resources, contacts, or even luggage, and this fed into the moral panic created by the large-scale female emigration among politicians and religious leaders.³⁵ For others, the landing was followed by the much more mundane event of catching the Irish Mail service to all points eastwards. Changes at busy stations such as Crewe for those going to the West Midlands, ³² O’Donoghue, In a Strange Land, 14. ³³ Mac Amhlaigh, An Irish Navvy, 6. ³⁴ Cited in Liverpool Vigilance Association, Unpublished Annual Report, 1 Apr. 1945–31 March 1946, 326 VIG/3, LRO. ³⁵ Memorandum on the Problem of Irish Girls Emigrating to England, prepared by Elizabeth Fitzgerald, 25 Aug. 1953, DT S 11582E, NAI.
In a Strange Land
53
or Rugby, for places north of London such as Northampton, were an inevitable part of the arduous trek. Unfortunate incidents occurred, in part due to the complexity of the British railway network and the lack of familiarity of many of the Irish migrants with the changes required at appropriate points along the way. During the war one group of workers destined for Northampton had apparently boarded a train marked for Southampton and arrived there in the small hours of the morning ‘cursing the British government’.³⁶ Euston along with Paddington were the stations for arrivals travelling to London. By all accounts, Euston was a veritable outpost of Erin with thousands of Irish passing through the station each day, often in the very early morning when the train arrived from Holyhead. This was a grim vista of modernity for the new arrivals, according to Richard Power, who made the journey in the mid-1950s: Euston Station, a foggy winter morning. Derelicts still sleeping under the pillars in the main hall, like the cold clay statues of the poor who built this Victorian temple. In a barber’s shop, beneath the platform, a gang of Teddy boys waited for the barber, looking as if they hadn’t had a wink of sleep the night before. Graffiti on the walls of the toilet; swearwords, illicit appointments, obscene verses, cris de coeur ranting against some injustice or other or against life, boasts of demeaning sins, every sort of public expression that an overwrought person would make who desperately needed to broadcast a confession.³⁷
A frequent sight on the platform in Euston, with their distinctive armbands, were the volunteers from the Legion of Mary and the Catholic Women’s League who offered assistance to travellers. This was perhaps an unwelcome vision for the minority who had emigrated to escape the social control of the authoritarian streak of Irish Catholicism that the Legion of Mary represented in its starkest form. Nevertheless, for those who required information or guidance in the early hours of the morning, the volunteers were a useful source of immediate assistance. One Columban priest, who assisted the lay volunteers at Euston and Paddington in the late 1950s, reflected on its value: The meeting of the trains I think is useful work. Every day you meet somebody or other whom you can help; sometimes by simply giving them directions; sometimes telling them where to get digs; and in general making things easy for them. Some of them are very shy, but we find no resentment anywhere and ³⁶ Quoted in Judges, ‘Irish Labour in Great Britain’, 40. ³⁷ Richard Power, Apple on the Treetop, trans. from the Irish by Victor Power (Dublin, 1980), 160.
54
In a Strange Land
once they get to know who we are, they are glad to have us because a lot of them when they arrive on the journey for the first time, are inclined to be a bit frightened.³⁸
The Westminster Branch of the Catholic Women’s League was also involved in ‘escorting’ young Irish student nurses whose details had been passed on by Catholic organizations in Dublin from Euston and Paddington to London hospitals. But many more came independently and simply made their own way. According to railway workers at Euston in 1953, ‘they arrive in hordes’ to start out on this new life in Britain.³⁹
2 . T H E P RO M I S E D L A N D Expectations of the place of destination were part of the mental map that migrants brought with them on the journey to a destination society. For Italian immigrants making the long sea journey to New York at the turn of the twentieth century, ‘excitement and fear, apprehension and expectation characterized the crossing’.⁴⁰ For arrivals from the Caribbean in the 1950s, who had been socialized with positive images of the ‘Mother Country’ as an imagined space, a ‘mythological territory’, England as the centre of imperial power was the ‘land of milk and honey’.⁴¹ As a result of years of English-centred education and political rhetoric that emphasized equal citizenship within the Commonwealth, Britain was seen as a land of opportunity, a place for self-improvement.⁴² As Mary Chamberlain comments, any illusions about the welcome extended by the worthy inhabitants of the ‘Mother Country’ were ‘punctured at the point of arrival’, and it was not just the physical environment that did not match up, but also the prejudice and racism that Caribbean migrants encountered on an everyday basis.⁴³ For migrants from Pakistan in the early 1960s, Britain was also the ‘land of promise, a place to improve one’s standard of living and gain greater ³⁸ Dictabelt from Fr [John] Casey, London, Nov. 1958, AB8/B/XXIX, McQuaid Papers, DDA. ³⁹ Memorandum on the Problem of Irish Girls Emigrating to England, prepared by Elizabeth Fitzgerald, 25 Aug. 1953, DT S 11582E, NAI. ⁴⁰ Orsi, The Madonna of 115th Street, 162. ⁴¹ Mary Chamberlain, Narratives of Exile and Return, new edn. (New Brunswick, 2005) 75, 72. ⁴² Sheila Patterson, Dark Strangers (London, 1963), 225. ⁴³ Chamberlain, Narratives of Exile and Return, 70–9.
In a Strange Land
55
independence’, even if the morality of that society, as reflected in the standards of sexual behaviour, was something to be shunned at all costs.⁴⁴ Few Irish migrants possessed any such illusions of Britain as an El Dorado. Preconceptions were formed well in advance of leaving home. It was most certainly not the promised land of biblical imagery, and expectations of life in this ‘strange land’ were invariably formed by the wider cultural milieu of independent Ireland. British newspapers and the cinema played a significant role in shaping these images, as we have seen in the previous chapter. A further source of information were the stories—some accurate, some half-true, and others simply fiction, so called ‘tall tales’—that were recounted by earlier waves of migrants who had direct first-hand knowledge of John Bull’s island.⁴⁵ But the formation of consciousness about the amorphous ‘English’—few contemporaries distinguished between English and British—had begun much earlier and was subliminally transmitted in the development of young children at school. Moreover, what marks this generation out as relatively unique in the long history of emigration from Ireland is that those who left in the 1940s and 1950s were the first generation of expatriates who had attended primary school, with a national curriculum that was designed by the educational authorities of the independent state. Determined efforts were made in the 1920s and 1930s to revise the teaching of subjects most likely to instil a patriotic spirit: the Irish language and Irish history were the most obvious mechanisms for achieving such an objective. The guidelines for history teaching produced for the fledgling state in April 1922 stated that ‘one of the chief aims of the teaching of history should be to develop the best traits of the national character and to inculcate national pride and self-respect’, a sentiment that was echoed in the preface to one of the more popular textbooks.⁴⁶ Subsequent revisions to the history curriculum in 1926 recommended that the periods of Irish history that ‘were more inspiring and better calculated to lead to pride of country should be dwelt ⁴⁴ Verity Saifullah Khan, ‘The Pakistanis: Mirpuri Villagers at Home and in Bradford’, in James L. Watson (ed.), Between Two Cultures: Migrants and Minorities in Britain (Oxford, 1977), 69. ⁴⁵ For such ‘tall tales’, see Keane, Many Young Men of Twenty, 138. ⁴⁶ Quoted in David Fitzpatrick, ‘The Futility of History: A Failed Experiment in Irish Education’, in Ciaran Brady (ed.), Ideology and the Historians (Dublin, 1991), 176; James Carty, A Class-Book of Irish History: Book III (From the Flight of the Earls to the Act of Union) (Dublin, 1930), 2.
56
In a Strange Land
upon’.⁴⁷ At primary schools, only Irish history was taught, and the classbooks used were ‘impregnated with a spirit of exaggerated nationalism’ which reified rather than dissipated traditional prejudices.⁴⁸ What the historian David Fitzpatrick describes as the ‘subordination of history to patriotism’ continued without question until the early 1960s.⁴⁹ Invariably patriotism centred on the tortured course of British–Irish relations from the arrival of the Normans in the twelfth century, but more especially the ‘struggle’ for national independence since the late eighteenth century. A committee which included professional historians and educationalists put it more pithily in 1967: the long-standing ‘Ireland versus England’ theme had dominated much of the teaching of history since the 1920s.⁵⁰ It had done so for a long time before in particular schools, especially those run by the Christian Brothers, who, according to one scholar, since the second half of the nineteenth century had engaged in the ‘most systematic exploitation of history in the service of Catholic nationalism’.⁵¹ Even if textbooks that copiously documented the historic wrongs inflicted on the Irish ‘nation’ failed to capture the patriotic imagination of young children at school, popular nationalist ballads were even more effective mnemonic devices. One woman who left in the early 1950s could vividly remember the patriotic ballads from her schooldays some forty years later, and another had kept for posterity a collection of racy nationalist songs that was widely used by schoolchildren when she was growing up in Ireland.⁵² The irony that such a large proportion of this generation ended up in Britain after years of socialization that demonized the country’s historical role in Irish history was not lost on another interviewee: ‘In a sense we were taught to hate. We were taught this history, you were sorta [sic] taught to hate England and then sent there.’⁵³ Throughout the 1930s and 1940s patriotism was intimately associated with the narrative of self-sufficiency in the political, economic, and ⁴⁷ Francis T. Holohan, ‘History Teaching in the Irish Free State, 1922–35’, History Ireland, 2, no. 4 (1994), 54. ⁴⁸ Jack Magee, ‘The Teaching of Irish History in Irish Schools’, Northern Teacher, 10, no. 1 (1970), unpaginated. ⁴⁹ Fitzpatrick, ‘The Futility of History’, 177. ⁵⁰ ‘The Teaching of History in Irish Schools’, Administration, 15, no. 4 (1967), 285. ⁵¹ Fitzpatrick, ‘The Futility of History’, 169; Barry N. Coldrey, Faith and Fatherland (Dublin, 1988), ch. 6. ⁵² Sharon Lambert, Irish Women in Lancashire, 1922–1960: Their Story (Lancaster, 2001), 84. ⁵³ Quoted ibid. 88.
In a Strange Land
57
cultural spheres, as de Valera’s successive governments sought to reduce the reliance on Britain by asserting the obdurate sovereignty of the independent state—most obviously during the Second World War—and by nurturing a Gaelic and Catholic cultural ethos and encouraging the development of indigenous manufacturing industries.⁵⁴ But from the late 1930s onwards this drive for self-sufficiency and the cherishing of all things Irish sat awkwardly with the realities of large-scale poverty and the increasing numbers who were leaving the country. This simple rural life was an integral element of the nationalist ideology articulated by de Valera and other leading politicians. The long-standing anti-English overtones of Irish separatism were reinforced by more immediate events such as the fragile state of British–Irish relations in the 1930s and early 1940s. Constitutional issues about political sovereignty dominated public discourse as Eamon de Valera from March 1932 set about energetically removing the last vestiges of Ireland’s links with the Commonwealth, a process that ironically was finally completed by his political opponent, John A. Costello, in 1948 with the secession from the Commonwealth and the declaration of a republic. British and, to a lesser degree, American opposition to Irish neutrality during the Second World War consolidated domestic support around the leadership of de Valera, most obviously in the case of his dignified response to Winston Churchill’s intemperate remarks in a victory broadcast at the end of the war in Europe in May 1945, which were widely reported at the time and for many Irish illustrated the David and Goliath nature of the struggle.⁵⁵ Virtually all of the Irish political leaders up to the late 1950s had been actively involved in some shape or form with the revolutionary politics of the early twentieth century, and anti-English rhetoric came almost instinctively, and equally was always a guaranteed vote-winner in parliamentary elections. The wider political climate was suffused with negative images of Britain as the former governing power that combined with proximate concerns about political relationships as the goal of complete sovereignty inevitably nudged the independent state further away from the Commonwealth in the 1940s. Traditional enmities were never far beneath the surface when it came to relations between Britain and Ireland. ⁵⁴ See Terence Brown, Ireland: A Social and Cultural History, 1922–1985, 2nd edn. (London, 1985), chs. 5–6. ⁵⁵ Robert Fisk, In Time of War: Ireland, Ulster and the Price of Neutrality, 1939–45 (London, 1983), 537–41.
58
In a Strange Land
In addition to the political climate, in a society where Catholicism infused virtually all aspects of social and cultural life, the perception was that England was a ‘pagan’ place, where paganism was predictably equated with Protestantism.⁵⁶ Few troubled themselves with the finer distinctions of these varieties of deism. Britain was a ‘godless’ country in which Catholicism—in particular its Irish variant—was perceived with suspicion and mistrust. A ubiquitous theme in the clerical discourse on the evils of Irish emigration in the 1940s and 1950s was the potential danger to the faith and morals of the Irish in Britain posed by life in a secular society. This was one of the principal arguments advanced by leading Irish ecclesiastical figures for the regulation of emigration from the country, especially the movement of young females, who, it was believed, were more vulnerable to the pitfalls of secularism.⁵⁷ Secularism went hand in hand with that other great evil, materialism; for early twentieth-century Irish nationalists ‘the British characteristic most forcefully projected was an obsession with the material aspect of life, a convenient mirror-image to Ireland’s other worldliness’.⁵⁸ Nevertheless, these alarmist statements tended to instil apprehension about ‘pagan’ England and the degenerative effects of living in such a society infused with materialistic values and inhabited by what were semi-seriously described as ‘heathens’.⁵⁹ To say, as the Caribbean writer George Lamming memorably described the colonial encounter between Caribbean migrants and British society in the 1950s, that ‘we have met before’ is an understatement in the Irish case.⁶⁰ The complex and often fraught nature of British–Irish relations over centuries ensured that ‘England’ had many symbolic associations, most of which were negative, as it was cast as the ‘intimate enemy’.⁶¹ What then did the new arrivals make of the society which ⁵⁶ See, for instance, the comments of William McKeown on the Christian Brothers and ‘pagan’ England: Nottingham Irish Studies Group, Making it Home, 37. ⁵⁷ Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 187–92. ⁵⁸ Gabriel Doherty, ‘National Identity and the Study of Irish History’, English Historical Review, 111, no. 441 (1996), 347. ⁵⁹ Lambert, Irish Women in Lancashire, 88; Anne O’Grady, Irish Migration to London in the 1940s and 1950s (London, 1988) 10; the ‘heathen’ quotation is taken from Joyce, ‘More Secondary Modern than Postmodern’, 369; see also Fahey, The Irish in London, 33, for a comparable reference to the perception that England was a ‘heathen land’. ⁶⁰ George Lamming, The Pleasures of Exile (London, 1960), quoted in Bill Schwarz, ‘Crossing the Seas’, in id. (ed), West Indian Intellectuals in Britain (Manchester, 2003), 2. ⁶¹ This term is borrowed from Ashis Nandy, The Intimate Enemy: Loss and Recovery of the Self Under Colonialism (Oxford, 1983).
In a Strange Land
59
had for so long played a malevolent role in the history of Ireland and was widely blamed for much of the nation’s woes over the past eight hundred years, and which contained a population of ‘heathens’, or, even worse, Protestants? Apart from gloomy sights of Holyhead, Fishguard, or Liverpool, the train journey provided the first glimpses of the place that was ultimately to become the home of so many of these migrants, although the fact that the service was speeding through the night hindered any systematic inspection of the Welsh and English countryside. Wartime travellers could see even less, as the blackout created a vista of seemingly unending darkness. Simple differences were perhaps the most startling. For instance, the pace of life and the conception of time were different to the sleepy villages and towns of rural Ireland. Mac Amhlaigh, who was destined for Northampton, had a two-hour stopover in Rugby at four o’clock in the morning. As it drew nearer to the morning rush hour, the station became a hub of activity with commuters catching the train to work. My heart sank altogether as I stood and looked around at the dirty ugly station. Everything looked so foreign to me there. Round about six o’clock hundreds started pouring into the station, pallid pasty faces with identical lunch boxes slung from their shoulders. They were all getting the train to work and their likes were getting off the train at the same time coming to work in Rugby, I suppose. God save us, I murmured to myself as I thought that nobody in Ireland would be even thinking of getting out of their beds for another couple of hours yet.⁶²
Even the colour of the post-boxes, red instead of green, struck one new arrival as different and foreign.⁶³ This was ironic as one of the first things that the new Irish government did after 1922 was to paint all the pillar-boxes green to indicate a break with the old British regime. London was the epicentre of all things that were modern about living in post-war Britain.⁶⁴ A huge sprawling city, with an elaborate transportation system, it accommodated nearly seven million people by the end of the Second World War in 1945, and was over ten times the size of Ireland’s capital, Dublin, the closest experience that most migrants had to urban life. A common response was amazement at the sheer scale and ‘vastness’ of the city, and more pragmatic consideration of ⁶² Mac Amhlaigh, An Irish Navvy, 6. ⁶³ Lynch (ed.), The Irish in Exile, 22. ⁶⁴ For an assessment of London’s modernity in the period 1840–1950, see Richard Dennis, ‘Modern London’, in Martin Daunton (ed.), The Cambridge Urban History of Britain, III (1840–1950) (Cambridge, 2000), 99–117.
60
In a Strange Land
the time involved in simply getting around on the complex underground and bus network.⁶⁵ The chaos of large numbers of people rushing about was bewildering for the new arrival: I didn’t know what to think of London. There were crowds everywhere and I didn’t know where all the people were coming from or going to. I’d come now from a rural area where you saw lads once a week, unless they were going to the well or something. And now I’d come over here and everybody was knocking you down. I was bewildered. I remember well the underground, going on the tube and then the moving stairs. I was awful afraid until I got used to it.⁶⁶
The devastation of the central parts of London presented those who arrived in the immediate post-war years with a less than glamorous introduction to urban life in the metropolis. For one young woman, who travelled alone in 1946 on her way to a hospital job in Surrey, the grim reality that she was confronted with while making the trek from Euston to Waterloo contrasted with her image. As she walked through the bomb-damaged streets, she wondered, ‘where was the wonderful London of the picture palace? It was dust and bombs and broken down houses and crowds everywhere. There was nothing nice at all.’⁶⁷ The promised land did not live up to the heightened expectations of this recent arrival. A child vividly remembered the size of the clock at Paddington station and thinking that she had never seen one of that size.⁶⁸ Everything somehow seemed bigger and on a much larger scale than at ‘home’. Modernity could take other forms. In an industrial society time was a valuable commodity to be used as efficiently as possible, with sharp distinctions between work and leisure time; in a predominantly agricultural society these boundaries were always more fluid and flexible. Whether the Irish arrivals ‘clung to their traditional notions of time’, as famously asserted by the American historian Herbert G. Gutman in the context of immigrant responses to industrial America at the turn of the twentieth century, is less apparent.⁶⁹ Initial impressions did, however, ⁶⁵ O’Grady, Irish Migration to London, 10. ⁶⁶ Mary Lennon, Marie McAdam, and Joanne O’Brien, Across the Water: Irish Women’s Lives in Britain (London, 1988), 43. ⁶⁷ Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 150. ⁶⁸ Catherine Dunne, An Unconsidered People: The Irish in London (Dublin, 2003), 25. ⁶⁹ Michael Kammen, Mystic Chords of Memory: The Transformation of Tradition in American Culture (New York, 1991), 8; Herbert G. Gutman, Work, Culture, and Society in Industrializing America (New York, 1976); see for different perspectives, Daniel T. Rodgers, ‘Tradition, Modernity, and the American Industrial Worker: Reflections and
In a Strange Land
61
underline the quick pace of life and the predominance of clock time. On arrival at Euston, Foley remarked that there was ‘a special confusing urgency about early morning London. The people seem to be filled with a dogged determination to get somewhere fast.’⁷⁰ The organization of working time in round-the-clock manufacturing factories did differ significantly from Ireland, where few such operations existed; shift work was well paid but could adversely affect the social life of the young migrant, especially if it involved working for long periods of time or on a Sunday.⁷¹ The technology of modernity could also make a lasting impression. One child recalled her excitement when she spotted an airplane passing through the sky above London, a rare vista for an 8-year-old from Cork. Another migrant recounted his fascination when he watched television for the first time to see the Coronation in June 1953: this was an iconic moment when television ‘came of age’, with almost half of the population tuning in for the event.⁷² Technology could also mean liberation from the drudgery of rural life for women; a family who came from County Tipperary in the early 1960s witnessed the liberation of their mother, who ‘loved the technological advantages of living in a city with shops, transport and modern amenities’.⁷³ The heavily urbanized society often compared unfavourably with nostalgic memories of rolling green fields and beautiful unspoilt countryside back at home. A central theme in the subsequent recollections of first impressions is the ‘grim’, ‘drab’, or ‘dreary’ physical environment, and this has been incorporated into the collective narrative of the Irish in post-war Britain. For example, the introduction to an edited collection of ‘memories’ underscores this sharp distinction between ‘home’ and life in Britain: ‘Their stories begin more than fifty years ago, when London was a grey and hostile place, a bleak, alien landscape for those accustomed to the friendliness and pastoral beauty of their home land.’⁷⁴ The Irish were not alone in this reaction; migrants from the Caribbean Critique’, Journal of Interdisciplinary History, 7 (1977), 655–81; Tamara K. Hareven, Family Time and Industrial Time (Cambridge, 1982). ⁷⁰ Foley, Three Villages, 55. ⁷¹ Keane, Self-Portrait, 54; Ethnic Communities Oral History Project, Caoin na Gael: The Hammersmith Irish Reminiscence Group (London, 2000), 11. ⁷² Interview with Larry McGrattan (b. 1932), MH 2002/263, LM; on the televising of the Coronation, see Becky Conekin, Frank Mort, and Chris Waters, ‘Introduction’, in id. (ed.), Moments of Modernity: Reconstructing Britain, 1945–1964 (London, 1999), 2. ⁷³ Nottingham Irish Studies Group, Making it Home, 25. ⁷⁴ Lynda O’Hare (ed.), Thousands are Sailing: A Collection of Memories ([London], 2000), 1.
62
In a Strange Land
in the 1950s were confounded by the ‘dull’, ‘dead’, and ‘gloomy’ appearance and dissonance between the realities and long-cherished images of the ‘Mother Country’.⁷⁵ An unnamed interviewee in Donnellan’s documentary who came to London from the west coast of Ireland wondered: ‘Where were all the cows? Where were all the tracks leading to?’⁷⁶ For another, England was the ‘saddest and loneliest country’.⁷⁷ These nostalgic visions even extended to the conflation of the weather conditions with the mental state of the newly arrived migrant. For one female office worker, ‘the day we arrived was miserable, it was dreary and raining and foggy, and I suppose we did feel kind of awesome, because we’d left living in the country’. Even the notoriously poor Irish weather somehow now seemed better when feeling homesick and confronted with the monotonous physical environment of industrial Britain. Excitement and the sense of embarking on an adventure also featured prominently in these subsequent reminiscences. Most were young, few had any knowledge of urban life, and some had relatively sheltered upbringings. One young woman from rural Galway who left Ireland at the tender age of 15 to work in London, staying with a relative, recalled her excitement when first taken shopping on the Edgware Road. Having been brought up in an isolated farming community, the metropole was a ‘complete change’.⁷⁸ Keane surveyed the faces on board the ship and distinguished between those who knew what awaited them and the newcomers: ‘There was eagerness written on the younger faces. This would be their first time. Always the first time, despite the loneliness, there is an air of adventure. Not so the second and third times and the times after that.’⁷⁹ In many respects, these initial impressions of Britain were to be expected. It was then the most heavily urbanized country in the Western world and the majority of Irish migrants had negligible experience of city living, with all the opportunities and pitfalls that this new way of life presented.⁸⁰ Social interaction was different: for someone accustomed to the buzz of an inner-city neighbourhood in Dublin or the familiarity of knowing everybody within a small rural community, the unfriendliness of London, for instance, gave the impression of a ‘cold place’.⁸¹ But ⁷⁵ Chamberlain, Narratives of Exile and Return, 76. ⁷⁶ O’Grady, The Irish in Exile, 9. ⁷⁷ Ibid. ⁷⁸ Dunne, An Unconsidered People, 81. ⁷⁹ Keane, Self-Portrait, 36 ⁸⁰ Daunton, ‘Introduction’, in id. (ed.), The Cambridge Urban History of Britain, p. xx. ⁸¹ Lennon, McAdam, and O’Brien, Across the Water, 142.
In a Strange Land
63
the anonymity of the large city had obvious benefits compared with the suffocating environment of insular Ireland; as one migrant aptly put it: ‘if you sneeze in Cork everyone knows about it and that’s Ireland’s second largest city. In Britain you can get on with your life without everyone knowing everything.’⁸² This was by no means a cultural encounter that was unique to the generation who left Ireland in the 1940s and 1950s: a similar readjustment to urban living had been an inevitable part of the process of migration since the 1840s and 1850s. The culture shock that one priest described captures the initial experiences of Irish arrivals who found that ‘everything was so completely different from what they were used to at home’.⁸³ Urbanization, Irish style, took place across national boundaries. Historical longevity, however, did not make this process any easier for successive waves of new arrivals. Initial impressions were diverse, depending on the context of the migration, the outlook of the individual, place of arrival, subsequent journey, and even the weather. Few doubted the differences between Ireland and Britain, and often commented on the ‘strange’ or ‘foreign’ physical environment and the intimidating urban spaces of the large cities. Even relatively simple differences such as the complexity of the transport network, or the hectic pace of life as first witnessed in the rush hour as the migrants made their way after arriving in London in the early morning, were sometimes unsettling introductions to the norms and values of British society. But for the constant stream of arrivals this understandable apprehension about the alien land that they now inhabited could be fused with excitement about the potential opportunities that life in Britain offered, free from the relentless social control that had such a suffocating influence on communities across rural and small-town Ireland.⁸⁴ Urban England offered so much more than the pure life devoid of materialism barely existing in rural Ireland. 3. VISIONS OF RETURN The sense of foreboding that was a completely rational emotion for a new arrival was balanced by a strong conviction that settling in this ⁸² Henrietta O’Connor, ‘Women Abroad: The Life Experiences of Irish Women in Leicester’ (unpub. M. Litt. thesis, Trinity College Dublin, 1993), 105. ⁸³ Dunne, An Unconsidered People, 137. ⁸⁴ See, for example, interview with Tommy Healy, Reg Hall Archive, C903/377/C1, NSABL.
64
In a Strange Land
strange land was a temporary expedient, something to be endured—or perhaps even enjoyed—until conditions improved at home, as it was universally expected they must do in due course. Undoubtedly this lessened the inherent anxiety involved in the unsettling move in the first instance. Prior to departure, when asked if the decision to leave was a permanent one, the response was unequivocal across generations and over time.⁸⁵ For many the actual return proved to be little more than an illusion. Nevertheless, this possibility also shaped the mental images of home that were created over time. For one migrant, when she left she had ‘no intention of staying in England really’, and even after more than forty years ‘a terrible longing to go back to Ireland’ still existed.⁸⁶ A well-known study of the British worker in the mid-twentieth century by the sociologist Ferdynand Zweig recounted the comments of one personnel manager: ‘whenever you talk to an Irishman, the first thing he tells you is that he is going home when he makes enough money’.⁸⁷ This medium- to long-term aspiration had crucial implications for the sense of Irish identity that evolved over time, with few ostensibly expressing a desire to ‘become British’ and most retaining strong if diverse Irish identities, as we shall see in a later chapter. This vision of return also conditioned outlooks towards living in Britain. The sociologist Liam Ryan, who conducted an ethnographic study of over 1,400 Irish migrants in London in the late 1960s, noted that ‘the unwillingness to define emigration as permanent leads to a lack of commitment to British society which is a major factor preventing successful integration and assimilation of Irish immigrants at all social levels’.⁸⁸ This possibility of return was not new, and was a central component of Irish diasporic identity in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. And this should not be tritely dismissed as misty-eyed nostalgia, itself succinctly described by the writer Eva Hoffman as an ‘excess of memory’.⁸⁹ The redemptive homecoming loomed large in the social imaginaries of the expatriate Irish, when this term is used to describe, following the philosopher Charles Taylor, ‘the ways in which people ⁸⁵ John A. Jackson, Report on the Skibbereen Social Survey (Dublin, 1967), 39; Lynch (ed.), The Irish in Exile, 18, 24; Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 152; Lennon, McAdam, and O’Brien, Across the Water, 97. ⁸⁶ Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 149. ⁸⁷ Ferdynand Zweig, The British Worker (Pelican edn., Harmondsworth, 1952), 50. ⁸⁸ William Ryan, ‘The Assimilation of Irish Immigrants in Britain’ (unpub. Ph.D. thesis, St Louis University, 1973), 89. ⁸⁹ Eva Hoffman, ‘The New Nomads’, in André Aciman (ed.), Letters of Transit: Reflections on Exile, Identity, Language and Loss (New York, 1999), 52.
In a Strange Land
65
imagine their social existence, how they fit together with others, how things go between them and their fellows, the expectations that are normally met, and the deeper normative notions and images that underline these expectations’.⁹⁰ Individual world-views, social interactions with other Irish migrants and the wider society, and what Matthew Frye Jacobson refers to as the diasporic imagination were shaped by this vision of return. For Jacobson, this imagination is a fusion of ‘both the shared currency of cultural imagery, and the mindset of the individual as he or she navigates the inner geography of international migration’.⁹¹ While his particular focus is on the significance of homeland politics for Irish, Polish, and Jewish immigrants in the United States at the turn of the twentieth century, he has perceptively identified how home, be it an imaginary or real form, influenced the outlooks and mindsets of those who had moved to the New World. The most obvious historical parallel is with the Jewish diaspora in Europe and North America, where the return to Israel was preserved as the defining feature of Jewish identity over centuries of exile.⁹² Other migrant groups nurtured similar aspirations to return to the homeland, such as the Poles who had arrived in Britain after the end of the Second World War, many of whom had been forcibly removed from their homes by the Soviet Army and deported to Siberia.⁹³ The widely held perception was that a couple of years in England was a short-term strategy to get a job that offered stability, earn money, undergo training—particularly relevant for student nurses—and then return to Ireland.⁹⁴ Only a minority ever anticipated a much longer sojourn, and usually this was for a specific reason such as the breakdown of a marriage or a pregnancy outside marriage—both sources of shame in post-war Ireland—or strained relationships with family members. One historian, Patrick Joyce, himself the child of Irish parents living ⁹⁰ Charles Taylor, ‘Modern Social Imaginaries’, Public Culture, 14, no. 1 (2002), 106. ⁹¹ Jacobson, Special Sorrows, 7. ⁹² Arnold M. Eisen, Galut: Modern Jewish Reflection on Homelessness and Homecoming (Indiana, 1986). ⁹³ Kathy Burrell, ‘Homeland Memories and the Polish Community in Leicester’, in Peter D. Stachura (ed.), The Poles in Britain, 1940–2000: From Betrayal to Assimilation (London, 2004), 69–84; Sheila Patterson, ‘The Polish Exile Community in Britain’, Polish Review, 6, no. 3 (1961), 69–88. ⁹⁴ Such views were shared by Caribbean and Pakistani migrants who also arrived in the 1950s; see Chamberlain, Narratives of Exile and Return, 74; Muhammed Anwar, The Myth of Return (London, 1979).
66
In a Strange Land
in London in the 1940s and 1950s, perceptively delineates this longing for ‘the possibility of return, and often the possibility of restitution’.⁹⁵ Displaced from the social and mental worlds of rural Ireland, this redemptive vision loomed large in the minds of the Irish in post-war Britain. This was by no means unique to the generation who left post-war Ireland; indeed, the ‘myth’ of return is a common feature of all migrations, Irish or otherwise.⁹⁶ For instance, the Portuguese phrase emigrar para voltar (to emigrate to return) captures the extent to which the eventual return was seen as the ultimate outcome of departing in the first instance.⁹⁷ However, a distinction must be made between the intention of eventually returning and the actual physical act of coming back.⁹⁸ Migration and return were two contrapuntal forces, yet intimately related in the Weltanschauung of those who left. Personal testimonies are replete with references to Ireland as ‘home’, even in some cases after nearly half a century living in Britain; many expressed a desire to ultimately settle back in Ireland at some unspecified date in the future.⁹⁹ For elderly Irish migrants interviewed in the 1980s and 1990s after decades in Britain, this ‘dream’ usually involved moving back to Ireland after retirement.¹⁰⁰ Children of Irish migrants subsequently described this outlook with a degree of incredulity. For instance, Brian Keaney, who was raised in Walthamstow in East London, remarked that even though his parents had lived in England for thirty years, ‘as far as they were concerned they weren’t living in England at all, just visiting’.¹⁰¹ He then goes on to describe a scene that was a familiar one in thousands of Irish households across Britain, where Irish provincial newspapers were avidly read and his parents struggled to listen to the crackly reception of Radio Éireann on a Sunday morning on a special high-powered device which was on ‘really loud . . . because the ⁹⁵ Joyce, ‘More Secondary Modern than Postmodern’, 380. ⁹⁶ See, for an earlier historical period, Mark Wyman, Round-Trip to America: The Immigrants Return to Europe, 1880–1930 (Ithaca, 1993). ⁹⁷ Caroline B. Brettell, ‘Emigrar Para Voltar: A Portuguese Ideology of Return Migration’, Papers in Anthropology, 20, no. 1 (1979), 1–20. ⁹⁸ Ibid. 1. ⁹⁹ Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 141; Dunne, An Unconsidered People, 43–4, 68–9; 86–7, 147–8; Nottingham Irish Studies Group, Making it Home, 25, 33. ¹⁰⁰ See, for example, Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 133; Dunne, An Unconsidered People, 147–8. ¹⁰¹ Brian Keaney, Don’t Hang About (Oxford, 1985), 95.
In a Strange Land
67
interference was terrible’.¹⁰² Another woman, who had spent nearly four decades in London before eventually moving back to Ireland, remarked, somewhat unkindly, about the ‘fantasies’ of her compatriots: There are so many Irish people in England who didn’t want to be there. They had to go, for the work. Even though they’d physically gone over on the boat, they still lived in Ireland, in this dream-world of how wonderful it was. And it wasn’t wonderful . . . A lot of them have fantasies about going back home. But when are they going back? They don’t want to give up the money they’re earning, the life they have in London and all the good things that go with it.¹⁰³
The reality of home was never far away for those who sought to maintain personal relationships that transcended the borders of the two nation-states. Unlike famine migrants or the millions of others who left post-Famine Ireland for North America, regular visits back were possible, and indeed the ease of travel between the two countries was one of the principal reasons why Britain was in the first instance chosen over the United States as a destination from the 1930s onwards, as we saw in the previous chapter. Even by the mid–1950s the adventurous minority who opted for the United States, Canada, Australia or New Zealand were unconsciously making a statement about the degree of contact that they wished to maintain with Ireland. Migrants rarely thought of any move as irreversible, and given the short distances involved and relative ease of travel between the two countries, individuals could spend time in Britain, return home for a couple of weeks or months, and then go back across the water for another sojourn, and so on. Individual life stories underscore the extent of continuous movement back and forth across the Irish Sea.¹⁰⁴ While census enumerations invariably yield snapshots at decennial points in time, the migratory behaviour of human beings does not lend itself towards such rigid classification. We have to rely on other sources of information to capture the level of movement back and forth across the Irish Sea until the mid–1960s when the question was first posed in the British census about the ‘former usual residence’ in the previous five years.¹⁰⁵ Both governments collected statistics on net passenger movement and health insurance transfers that also provide a useful guide to the extent of movement. After ¹⁰² Ibid. ¹⁰³ Dunne, An Unconsidered People, 109–10. ¹⁰⁴ See, for instance, Mac Amhlaigh, An Irish Navvy, which details his constant trips home during the initial years of settlement. ¹⁰⁵ B. M. Walsh, Migration to the United Kingdom from Ireland, 1961–66 (Dublin, 1970), 1.
68
In a Strange Land
reviewing the various sources of data, the Commission on Emigration concluded in the mid–1950s that ‘in many cases, the outgoing traveller was not, in any sense, a permanent emigrant and frequently came and went like a seasonal migrant’.¹⁰⁶ From south-east England the reverse journey took less than a day, and was a habitual feature of the annual calendar at least during the early years of settlement in Britain. During the Second World War a visit home every six months was allowed under the official recruitment schemes.¹⁰⁷ Family relationships could often be maintained across the Irish Sea, through letters and visits. Holidays were also taken in Ireland, and one of the complaints of some British employers concerned workers overstaying their periods of leave, especially at Christmas.¹⁰⁸ One migrant recounted how her employer in Manchester coined the term the ‘Irish month’, ‘because we’d go for a month and stop six weeks!’¹⁰⁹ Children born and raised in Britain were often sent to Ireland for the summer holidays from school or even to stay for longer periods, leading to some piquant cultural encounters between those of Irish descent and the worthy inhabitants of the motherland.¹¹⁰ The equivalence of future intentions and actual realities varied considerably. Significant numbers did return in the 1960s and 1970s as the economy expanded and, in a remarkable discontinuity with the past century and a half, for a couple of years in the early 1970s more people came to live in Ireland than followed the traditional migrant pathways.¹¹¹ The sociologist John Jackson estimated in the mid–1960s that roughly one in four of the Irish population had at some stage lived abroad.¹¹² But sometimes the biblical return did not simply live up to ¹⁰⁶ Commission on Emigration, Reports, 128. For the technical issues, see [R. C.] Geary, ‘Statistics of Emigration and Passenger Movement’, Irish Trade Journal and Statistical Bulletin, n. v., June 1951, 83–4; J. G. Hughes, Estimates of Annual Net Migration and their Relationship with Series on Annual Net Passenger Movement: Ireland, 1926–76 (Dublin, 1977), 4–7. ¹⁰⁷ Judges, ‘Irish Labour in Great Britain’, 50. ¹⁰⁸ S.24, Employment and Living Conditions of Irish Workers in Great Britain, prepared by Stanley Lyon, n.d. [Nov. 1948], Marsh Papers, TCD MS 8306; John. A. Jackson, ‘The Irish’, in Ruth Glass (ed.), London: Aspects of Change (London, 1964), 301. ¹⁰⁹ Quoted in Lambert, Irish Women in Lancashire, 42. ¹¹⁰ Ibid. 42–3; see also John Healy, The Grass Arena: An Autobiography (1988), 6–10; Lennon, McAdam, and O’Brien, Across the Water, 221–2. I owe the reference to John Healy’s work to Liam Harte. ¹¹¹ Enda Delaney, Irish Emigration Since 1921 (Dublin, 2002), 6; J. J. Sexton, ‘Emigration and Immigration in the Twentieth Century: An Overview’, in J. R. Hill (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 7: Ireland, 1921–1984 (Oxford, 2003), 796–7. ¹¹² John A. Jackson, ‘Ireland’, in OECD, Emigrant Workers Returning to the Home Country: Supplement to the Final Report (Paris, 1967), 4.
In a Strange Land
69
expectations nourished over years spent in Britain; for example, one migrant who left in 1949 decided to move back to County Mayo in the 1960s, but was frustrated with the ‘quietness of country life’ and came back to England again after a couple of years.¹¹³ Ethnographic accounts point to the painful realities of initial readjustment to rural and small-town Ireland in the 1970s and 1980s. The slow pace of life, the ‘narrow-minded’ and provincial outlooks of local people, and difficulties in re-establishing former relationships with relatives and friends were cited by returnees as significant problems.¹¹⁴ Others eschewed the prospect of settling back into small communities and opted for Dublin and Cork, where more jobs were available, and urban living was closer to that of the large British cities from which they had returned. Nevertheless, a much larger group, for a variety of reasons, were unable—or unwilling—to return. As the number of years spent abroad increased, marriage, the availability of housing, the purchase of a property, as well as lifestyle and income aspirations, all worked against the realization of the eventual homecoming. The arrival of children signified a watershed in the life course of individuals living in Britain. Once children started school, it was even more difficult to contemplate the prospect of the upheaval involved in returning to Ireland. Raising a family was widely perceived to be a significant determinant in expediting the inevitable process of ‘settling down’, and, as one migrant aptly described, ‘imperceptibly, you put down roots’.¹¹⁵ Putting down roots invariably led to the postponement of the return. The passage of time and the death of relatives as well as the benefits of an extended family living in England militated against taking the plunge and resettling in Ireland. The sense that there was ‘nothing to go back to’ also featured occasionally in reminiscences.¹¹⁶ By the late 1990s, with the profound changes in Irish society brought about by sustained economic growth, some of the elderly migrants interviewed explicitly stated that as the country no longer resembled the imaginary homeland which was cherished over many decades living abroad, they no longer had any wish to live there.¹¹⁷ ¹¹³ Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 138. ¹¹⁴ These studies are examined in more detail in Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 271–7. ¹¹⁵ Lynch (ed.), The Irish in Exile, 24. ¹¹⁶ Schweitzer (ed.), Across the Irish Sea, 133; see also Dunne, An Unconsidered People, 61, 147–8. ¹¹⁷ This theme emerges clearly in the most recent study based on interviews: see Dunne, An Unconsidered People.
70
In a Strange Land
Whereas significant numbers of nineteenth and early twentiethcentury migrants from Ireland harboured deep resentment towards successive British administrations for their enforced exile in the New World, those who left post-war Ireland thought differently about the circumstances in which they found themselves heading across the Irish Sea. In the first instance, by the mid–1940s the independent Irish state had been in existence for nearly a quarter of a century, so any grievances about the political or economic conditions were more appropriately directed at the revolutionary generation who had secured self-government and dominated the political landscape for the next three decades. Some migrants, both at the time and subsequently in reminiscences, did vent anger at the ruling élite in independent Ireland who were ultimately responsible for the dismal state of the economy, but these feelings were vague and often directed more generally at the society as a whole than at any particular political party or interest group.¹¹⁸ That said, de Valera was predictably sometimes singled out for particular reproach, as the high priest of national self-sufficiency and the most vocal advocate of the virtues of the simple rural life.¹¹⁹ 4. CITIZENS AND ALIENS Restrictions on immigration were introduced across western Europe and North America during the twentieth century as nation states defined who belonged and equally who was to be excluded from the rights conferred by citizenship. In Britain the Aliens Act (1905) was passed, and other pieces of supplementary legislation introduced in the first quarter of the twentieth century sought to control the entry of Eastern European Jews. As we have seen, from the 1920s restrictions were introduced in the United States, primarily directed at arrivals from southern and eastern Europe, perceived to be less ‘desirable’ than their northern European counterparts. Under the Anglo-Irish treaty of 1921 Britain retained the historical tradition of free entry for those travelling from what was its nearest dominion after the foundation of the new Irish state in 1922.¹²⁰ The Irish ¹¹⁸ Foley, Three Villages, 53. ¹¹⁹ See, for example, Dunne, An Unconsidered People, 225–7. ¹²⁰ Eunan O’Halpin, ‘Politics and the State, 1922–1932’, in Hill (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 7, 105; Elizabeth Meehan, Free Movement between Ireland and the UK: From the ‘Common Travel Area’ to The Common Travel Area (Dublin, 2000), 22–4.
In a Strange Land
71
could enter Britain without the need for a visa or employment permit for most of the period after independence in 1922. The exception was the Second World War and shortly thereafter, when, on the basis of national security, the British authorities imposed strict border controls to restrict movement in and out of the country. Only those deemed to be on ‘business of national importance’ were allowed to enter the country. From June 1940 all arrivals from independent Ireland had to have in their possession a travel identity card, issued by the Irish government, and an employment visa, issued by the British Ministry of Labour through a permit office established in Dublin. The Irish government only issued identity cards to workers who were not regarded as essential to key industries such as turf-cutting or harvesting. Over time an elaborate set of mechanisms evolved, usually on the basis of detailed negotiations between the British and Irish officials, to regulate the movement of workers across the Irish Sea, and these migrants were allocated to particular forms of employment. The operation of this scheme has been extensively documented elsewhere, but its broader significance is that it was in effect an element of official control on the migrant flow from independent Ireland, which hitherto had been unregulated since time immemorial.¹²¹ Irish citizens living in Britain were also required to register with the local police and could be ‘repatriated’ back to Ireland under the Prevention of Violence Act (1939), an ‘emergency’ measure which was passed in response to the IRA bombing campaign in England.¹²² Even with the end of the war in 1945, these controls remained in place for a short period afterwards. From January 1947 employment visas were phased out and Irish citizens were no longer required to work in specific employments. The final stage in the dismantling of border controls was the removal of the need to have a travel identity document from April 1952 onwards. Free movement of individuals was then restored.¹²³ ¹²¹ See Delaney, Demography, State and Society, 116–28; Commission on Emigration, Reports, 268–70; Jackson, The Irish in Britain, 98–105. ¹²² Sean Glynn, ‘Irish Immigration to Britain, 1911–1951: Patterns and Policy’, Irish Economic and Social History, 8 (1981), 68; Paddy Hillyard (Suspect Community: People’s Experience of the Prevention of Terrorism Acts in Britain (London, 1993), 198) notes that during the fifteen years that this Act was in force ‘a total of 268 expulsion and prohibition orders were authorised by the then home secretaries’. For the operation of this Act in relation to one admittedly unique case, see Colin Holmes, ‘The British Government and Brendan Behan, 1941–54: The Persistence of the Prevention of Violence Act’, Saothar, 14 (1989), 125–8. ¹²³ Commission on Emigration, Reports, 268–9; Meehan, Free Movement between Ireland and the UK, 26–7.
72
In a Strange Land
The status, in legal terms, of the Irish in Britain was but one element of the vexed questions of citizenship and nationality that preoccupied Irish politicians in the interwar years and was intrinsically tied up with British–Irish relations until the late 1940s.¹²⁴ Under the terms of the Irish constitution introduced in 1922, a form of common citizenship existed and, in British eyes at least, Irish citizens were still viewed as subjects, much to the chagrin of nationalist politicians.¹²⁵ De Valera’s definition of nationality introduced in the Irish Nationality and Citizenship Act (1935) did not change the legal status of Irish citizens living in Britain since under British law such people were still regarded as ‘subjects’.¹²⁶ Even after independent Ireland formally withdrew from the Commonwealth in April 1949, Irish nationals retained a ‘special’ position in British nationality law and were not viewed as aliens.¹²⁷ Both the British Nationality Act (1948) and the Ireland Act (1949) enshrined a ‘unique set of nationality provisions’ for the Irish that, in short, conferred on them the same rights as British citizens.¹²⁸ One historian, Kathleen Paul, has underlined the racial undertones of these efforts by the Labour government to ‘construct a separate sphere of nationality for Irish people living in Britain because it believed that not to do so endangered the Commonwealth by undermining larger imperial ¹²⁴ Only a brief summary can be offered here; for more details, see Mary E. Daly, ‘Irish Nationality and Citizenship since 1922’, Irish Historical Studies, 32, no. 127 (2001), 377–407. This is an admirably clear account of what is a complicated set of legal issues. For the wider context, see Ronan Fanning, Independent Ireland (Dublin, 1983), 172–180; id. ‘The Response of the London and Belfast Governments to the Declaration of the Republic of Ireland, 1948–49’, International Affairs, 58, no. 1 (1981–2), 95–114; Ian McCabe, A Diplomatic History of Ireland, 1948–49: The Republic, Commonwealth and NATO (Dublin, 1991); J. H. Whyte, ‘Declaration of the Republic and the Ireland Act, 1945–9’, in Hill (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 7, 261–77. ¹²⁵ Daly, ‘Irish Nationality and Citizenship’, 379. ¹²⁶ Ibid. 387; Kathleen Paul, Whitewashing Britain: Race and Citizenship in the Postwar Era (Ithaca, 1997), 222, n. 9. As Daly points out (‘Irish Nationality and Citizenship’, 385) much of the groundwork for this legislation had been completed by the Cumann na nGaedheal administration before Fianna Fáil came to power in March 1932. ¹²⁷ Daly, ‘Irish Nationality and Citizenship’, 390; R. F. V. Heuston, ‘British Nationality and Irish Citizenship’, International Affairs, 26, no. 1 (1950), 77–90; John Megaw, ‘British Subjects and Eire Citizens’, Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly, 8, no. 3 (1949), 129–39. ¹²⁸ Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 105. See also Randall Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration in Post-War Britain (Oxford, 2000), 45–9; for the broader context of the introduction of this Act, see Randall Hansen, ‘The Politics of Citizenship in 1940s Britain: The British Nationality Act’, Twentieth Century British History, 10, no. 1 (1999), 67–95.
In a Strange Land
73
objectives’.¹²⁹ As she acknowledges, other considerations were equally as important as the imperial dimension, such as the perception that Ireland was a valuable source of much-needed labour, and the realization that it would be extremely difficult to impose border controls, which would among other things alienate the Irish government. A factor which Paul neglects, however, is the issue of Northern Ireland, where questions of nationality and citizenship were intimately related to the constitutional status of the province within the United Kingdom, which was reaffirmed in the Ireland Act of 1949.¹³⁰ It appears that in November 1948 Labour politicians did seriously contemplate amending the British Nationality Act after Costello announced his intention to repeal the External Relations Act (1936), and withdraw from the Commonwealth. These retaliatory measures included the imposition of border controls and treating Irish nationals already residing in Britain as aliens.¹³¹ Such a move would have had serious implications for the nearly threequarters of a million Irish citizens living in Britain at this time. Equally serious, from the point of view of British officials, were the potential outcomes of following through on these threats: the prospect of losing a valuable source of labour, strained relations with other Commonwealth countries with sizeable Irish populations; the practical difficulties in re-establishing border controls; and, most significantly, the potential repercussions for British–Irish relations.¹³² For these controls to work effectively would have required either a tightly monitored frontier at the land border between Northern Ireland and the southern state—which, given the length of the boundary, was almost impracticable—or a similar arrangement to what was in place during the war with Britain treated as an integral unit. Residents of Northern Ireland would be ¹²⁹ Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 90. ¹³⁰ Mary Hickman, ‘Reconstructing Deconstructing ‘‘Race’’: British Political Discourses about the Irish in Britain’, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 21, no. 2 (1998), 294–6; for more details on Northern Ireland, see Fanning, ‘The Response of the London and Belfast Governments’. ¹³¹ Daly, ‘Irish Nationality and Citizenship’, 390; D. W. Dean, ‘Final Exit? Britain, Eire, the Commonwealth and the Repeal of the External Relations Act, 1945–1949’, Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History, 20, no. 3 (1992), 404–7; Fanning, ‘The Response of the London and Belfast Governments’, 99–102; McCabe, A Diplomatic History of Ireland, 52–6; Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 101–2; Richard Weight, Patriots: National Identity in Britain, 1940–2000 (London, 2002), 142–5. McCabe notes that in the view of Lord Chancellor Jowett the repeal of the External Relations Act would not change the legal status of Irish citizens in Britain because of the provisions of the British Nationality Act, 1948 (p. 53). ¹³² Dean, ‘Final Exit?’, 405–10; Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 105–6.
74
In a Strange Land
subjected to the same controls if the latter option were introduced. Neither was a very attractive prospect, and certainly the establishment of Britain rather than the United Kingdom as the area for control would have incensed the Unionist government in Northern Ireland. Even during the war they deeply resented the restrictions on travel to Britain since it ‘was a little humiliating to have to submit to permit regulations which seemed to isolate the province from the rest of the United Kingdom’.¹³³ After frenzied negotiations a compromise was eventually reached in November 1948, whereby the status quo was maintained and independent Ireland was not viewed in practical terms as a ‘foreign’ state, and its nationals living in Britain were granted the same citizenship rights as their British counterparts.¹³⁴ Under this arrangement the Irish retained what one historian has recently concluded were ‘extraordinary rights of citizenship given to no other foreign country’.¹³⁵ Outside of the rarefied confines of high-level political intrigue, the decision to leave the Commonwealth created uncertainty among the Irish living in Britain. One letter sent to the Taoiseach, John A. Costello, written by a labourer working in England after the bill to declare the Republic of Ireland was introduced in the Dáil in December 1948, in Ronan Fanning’s telling words ‘exposes the gulf separating the world of Irish emigrants in Britain from the world of their erstwhile political leaders’.¹³⁶ I am an Irishman working in England. My foreman is an Englishman, my fellow workers are English. I live with an English family. Since your government announced its proposal to sever the last link with the crown and commonwealth, I have been asked questions by aforementioned persons viz. What are the advantages of such action by your gov’t. All the disadvantages are outlined for me and a very gloomy list it is for us, reporting to the Ploice [sic] station, having to return to Ireland, unemployment, a lower standard of living. Is the last doorway in Mr de Valera’s wall being bricked up. As Sean Ó Faoláin so ably put it in his talk over the radio tonight ‘The only world open to the Irish soon will be the next one.’ Don’t think that we are sending out angels and saints in our Irish boy and girl emigrants. Most of them are backward and unable to fit into the more civilized mode of living here after the more cramped and less free standards prevailing in Ireland.¹³⁷ ¹³³ J. W. Blake, Northern Ireland in the Second World War (Belfast, 1956), 84. ¹³⁴ Daly, ‘Irish Nationality and Citizenship’, 390; McCabe, A Diplomatic History of Ireland, 76–90. ¹³⁵ Weight, Patriots, 147. ¹³⁶ Fanning, Independent Ireland, 191. ¹³⁷ Ibid. Sean Ó Faoláin was a well-known Irish writer and broadcaster who along with other writers such as Liam O’Flaherty and Frank O’Connor ‘expressed a deep
In a Strange Land
75
Skin colour, prejudice, perceptions of racial inferiority, together with post-imperial considerations, shaped responses to the migrants from the ‘New’ Commonwealth in the mid-to-late 1950s, and reduced the political visibility at least of the Irish in post-war Britain.¹³⁸ In the mid–1950s, when the Conservative government led by Anthony Eden was preparing draft legislation to limit colonial immigration, which had become ‘an ominous problem’, it was concluded in November 1956 that the large number of Irish ‘does not give rise to the same kind of problems or forebodings as the presence here of similar numbers of coloured people might be thought to justify’.¹³⁹ An earlier interdepartmental committee had noted, in the previous year, the poor housing conditions of the Irish, but in a much-quoted passage emphasized the degree of homogeneity with the British population: When all this has been said, however, it cannot be held that the same difficulties arise in the case of the Irish as in the case of coloured people. For instance, an Irishman looking for lodgings is, generally speaking, not likely to have any more difficulty than an Englishman, whereas the coloured man is often turned away. In fact, the outstanding difference is that the Irish are not—whether they like it or not—a different race from the ordinary inhabitants of Great Britain, and indeed one of the difficulties in any attempt to estimate the economic and social consequences of the influx from the Republic would be to define who are Irish.¹⁴⁰ disillusionment about the kind of Ireland that independence had inaugurated’ (Brown, Ireland: A Social and Cultural History, 154). ¹³⁸ On the attitudes towards immigration in the 1950s, see D. W. Dean, ‘Conservative Governments and the Restriction of Commonwealth Immigration in the 1950s: The Problems of Constraint’, Historical Journal, 35, no. 1 (1992), 171–94; Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, chs. 3–4; Paul, Whitewashing Britain, ch. 6; Zig LaytonHenry, The Politics of Immigration: Immigration, ‘Race’ and ‘Race’ Relations in Post-War Britain (Oxford, 1992), ch. 2; Bob Carter, Clive Harris, and Shirley Joshi, ‘The 1951–55 Conservative Government and the Racialization of Black Immigration’, Immigrants and Minorities, 6, no. 3 (1987), 345. ¹³⁹ Colonial Immigrants: Supplementary Report of the Committee of Ministers, 14 Nov. 1956, CAB 129/84 CP (56) 263, PRO. For the wider context of this committee, see Dean, ‘Conservative Governments and the Restriction of Commonwealth Immigration’; Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 77; Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 146–7; Ian R. G. Spencer, British Immigration Policy Since 1939: The Making of Multiracial Britain (London, 1997), 85–6. ¹⁴⁰ Report of the Committee on the Social and Economic Problems arising from the Growing Influx into the United Kingdom of Coloured Workers from other Commonwealth Countries, 3 Aug. 1955, CAB 129/77 CP (55) 102, PRO. Also cited by Layton-Henry, The Politics of Immigration, 33; Hickman, ‘Reconstructing Deconstructing ‘‘Race’’ ’, 296–7; Carter, Harris, and Joshi, ‘The 1951–55 Conservative Government’, 345.
76
In a Strange Land
Once excluded from the imagined nation, by the 1950s the Irish were gradually being incorporated ‘whether they like it or not’ into the homogeneous British ‘race’.¹⁴¹ This process of deracialization had much to do with the changing climate relating to colonial immigration. Opinions differed, moreover, and this was not a universally shared view: for instance, the ‘social problems’ associated with the Irish were advanced by the Birmingham Young Conservatives in 1956 as good grounds for imposing controls to the flow from Ireland as well as ‘coloured men’, and this theme also featured in some later comments.¹⁴² The riots in Notting Hill and Nottingham in August 1958 focused the spotlight on the position of Commonwealth migrants, and ‘propelled the issue of black immigration onto the front pages of the newspapers and television, and made it a national rather a series of independent local issues’.¹⁴³ It is often assumed that since the Irish no longer openly featured in these debates about immigration restrictions they were ‘largely accepted’ after the Second World War.¹⁴⁴ However, this interpretation overstates the degree to which politicians and officials viewed the unregulated entry of Irish citizens into Britain as a fait accompli. The matter was more complex than is widely assumed, and even by the early 1960s the issue of whether controls should be applied to Irish citizens coming to Britain was still a matter of debate. In the late 1950s the traditional position that British subjects had the right to free entry to the ‘mother country’ was replaced by a widespread acceptance among the political élite that some form of control should be introduced.¹⁴⁵ Perceptions were all-important, and the Conservative government ‘spent much of its time searching for ways to limit possible damage to its reputation as it discarded unrestricted entry’.¹⁴⁶ In early 1961 officials were developing detailed proposals for the restriction of immigration, and inevitably the issue of the ¹⁴¹ Hickman, ‘Reconstructing Deconstructing ‘‘Race’’ ’, 296–9, describes this process as the ‘construction of a myth of homogeneity’. ¹⁴² Birmingham Young Conservatives, The Problem of Coloured Peoples in Britain, Oct. 1956, copy in DFA 402/218/3, NAI; see also Hickman, ‘Reconstructing Deconstructing ‘‘Race’’ ’, 302, for comments along similar lines during the debates on the Commonwealth Immigrants Bill in February–March 1962. ¹⁴³ Layton-Henry, The Politics of Immigration, 38. ¹⁴⁴ E. J. B. Rose et al., Colour and Citizenship: A Report on British Race Relations (London, 1969), 19. ¹⁴⁵ Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 99. ¹⁴⁶ Dennis Dean, ‘The Conservative Government and the 1961 Commonwealth Immigration Act: The Inside Story’, Race and Class, 35, no. 2 (1993), 67.
In a Strange Land
77
position of Irish citizens came up for discussion: the recommendation was that the restrictions should not apply to the Irish.¹⁴⁷ Rab Butler, the Conservative Home Secretary, recognized the potential difficulties in ‘privileging Irish aliens over British subjects’, and it was agreed by the cabinet that the Commonwealth Immigrants Bill would formally include the Irish, although in reality they would not be subject to any control.¹⁴⁸ On the day the bill was published, Harold Macmillan was asked by Hugh Gaitskell if the Irish were to be included and the reply was ‘Yes, certainly’.¹⁴⁹ This was a Jesuitical response, as it soon became apparent that this was merely window dressing and that, in practice, the Irish were to be exempt from any control.¹⁵⁰ Opinion across the political spectrum was vehemently opposed to this aspect of the bill. National newspapers, including The Times, strongly objected to the exemption of Irish citizens.¹⁵¹ A pressing concern for ministers was the possibility that a backbench revolt combined with Labour opposition would defeat the bill.¹⁵² For Labour this was conclusive proof that the aim was to impose a ‘colour bar’ on entry to Britain, a position that is echoed subsequently in the judgements of a number of historians.¹⁵³ One Labour MP noted that this underlined the racist intent of the bill. Mr Butler is saying that control is not to be applied to the Irish unless there is an absolute necessity, and that necessity will not arise as long as Irish immigrants continue to be white. But if enough people come in through Irish ports and Irish immigrants begin to be black, then the absolute necessity arises.¹⁵⁴
Conservative backbenchers, on the other hand, resented the privilege given to the ‘disloyal Irish’, who had remained neutral in the Second World War, whereas British subjects from ‘old’ Dominions were to ¹⁴⁷ Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 104; Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 108. ¹⁴⁸ Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 108–9. ¹⁴⁹ Quoted by Paul Foot, Immigration and Race in British Politics (Harmondsworth, 1965), 139. ¹⁵⁰ For a detailed discussion of the frenzied diplomatic discussions between Irish and British officials, see Meehan, Free Movement between Ireland and the UK, 84–93. ¹⁵¹ Sheila Patterson, Immigration and Race Relations in Britain, 1960–1967 (London, 1969), 19. ¹⁵² Dean, ‘The Conservative Government and the 1961 Immigration Act’, 69. ¹⁵³ Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 108–10; Bob Carter, Marci Green, and Rick Halpern, ‘Immigration Policy and the Racialization of Migrant Labour: The Construction of National Identities in the USA and Britain’, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 19, no. 1 (1996), 149–51; Spencer, British Immigration Policy, 153–4. ¹⁵⁴ The Times, 6 Dec. 1961, quoted in Carter, Green, and Halpern, ‘Immigration Policy and the Racialization of Migrant Labour’, 151.
78
In a Strange Land
be formally subject to restriction. As Randall Hansen has perceptively observed, ‘to the extent that the Conservatives longed for a racist exclusion, it was Canadians, Australians, and New Zealanders whom they wished to see exempted’.¹⁵⁵ John Biggs-Davison, a backbencher, organized opposition to the exclusion of the Irish from the legislation, and another prominent party official, Sir Douglas Glover, chairman of the Central Union of Conservative and Unionist Associations, declared in a speech in Bradford that ‘we have got to incorporate the Irish into this bill’.¹⁵⁶ Even Duncan Sandys, the Commonwealth Relations Secretary, acknowledged that he was ‘unhappy’ about the Irish being seen to have privileges that were denied to Commonwealth citizens.¹⁵⁷ It became readily apparent to ministers and officials that a significant number of backbenchers would vote against the bill on its third reading.¹⁵⁸ Eventually a compromise was agreed whereby Irish citizens who were convicted of an offence would be deported back to Ireland under the legislation, and the government undertook to examine the numbers of Irish people arriving in Britain.¹⁵⁹ By mollifying the backbench opposition led by Biggs-Davison, through minor amendments to the original bill, the government secured enough support for the legislation to be eventually passed in March 1962. According to Randall Hansen, ‘had it not been for this compromise, the government almost certainly would have been defeated’.¹⁶⁰ The ostensible justification for not applying controls in practice to Irish citizens was the impossibility of controlling the land border between independent Ireland and Northern Ireland, and the potential difficulties in regulating the numerous sea crossings to Britain, reflecting earlier views that were expressed in the late 1940s in the debates surrounding Ireland’s exit from the Commonwealth. An earlier agreement by the cabinet that it ‘might be justified by reference to the ‘‘special historical ¹⁵⁵ Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 118. This effectively occurred under the Immigration Act (1971), whose partiality provisions privileged Australians, Canadians, and New Zealanders (ibid. 195). ¹⁵⁶ Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 114; Foot, Immigration and Race, 140. Biggs-Davison was a rare bird: a devout Catholic who was a strong Ulster Unionist (Patrick Cosgrave, ‘Davison, Sir John Alec Biggs- (1918–1988)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (Oxford, 2004) [http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/70374, accessed 4 April 2006]). ¹⁵⁷ Dean, ‘The Conservative Government and the 1961 Immigration Act’, 69; Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 108. ¹⁵⁸ Dean, ‘The Conservative Government and the 1961 Immigration Act’, 69. ¹⁵⁹ Foot, Immigration and Race, 140; Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 117. ¹⁶⁰ Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 117.
In a Strange Land
79
and geographical relationship’’ between Ireland and Britain’ was not mentioned in parliament.¹⁶¹ What emerged in the debate was the view that if controls were to be effective, Northern Ireland and independent Ireland would have to be treated as a unit—as was the case during the war—and this would be vehemently opposed by the Unionist government in Northern Ireland, since it undermined the integration of the United Kingdom. In the House of Commons in November 1961, Butler referred to discussions with Lord Brookeborough, the prime minister of Northern Ireland, during which it became clear that ‘any proposal to restrict freedom of travel between Northern Ireland which is an integral part of the United Kingdom, and the rest of the country would be unacceptable to the Northern Ireland government’.¹⁶² As Mary Hickman points out, this complicating factor is rarely mentioned in analyses of the Commonwealth Immigrants Act that see the exclusion of the Irish as hard evidence of the racist intent of the legislation.¹⁶³ Undoubtedly an unstated preference for white migrants influenced the content of the controls introduced in 1962; nevertheless, the wider political context also determined which groups were to be restricted in practice. An additional element that is also neglected, although it featured in the discussions at the time, is that both countries were at this time applying for entry to the European Economic Community, which provided for the free movement of labour between member states.¹⁶⁴ From the early days the Irish government was assured that Britain would continue to be freely accessible to Irish citizens who wanted to leave the country. Both the government in Dublin and more particularly officials at the Irish Embassy in London were closely monitoring the developing situation. When it became clear from early 1961 that the intention was to introduce legislation, the question of whether this would apply to the Irish was raised in both the British and Irish press.¹⁶⁵ There was the admittedly unlikely prospect of nearly three-quarters of a million people having to seek retrospectively employment vouchers ¹⁶¹ Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 109–10; Hickman, ‘Reconstructing Deconstructing ‘‘Race’’ ’, 300. ¹⁶² Quoted in Hickman, ‘Reconstructing Deconstructing ‘‘Race’’ ’, 300–1; see also Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 117, on this point. ¹⁶³ Hickman, ‘Reconstructing Deconstructing ‘‘Race’’ ’, 301–2. ¹⁶⁴ Patterson, Immigration and Race Relations, 19; Dean, ‘The Conservative Government and the 1961 Immigration Act’, 73; Meehan, Free Movement between Ireland and the UK, 37. ¹⁶⁵ e.g. Sunday Times, 5 Feb. 1961.
80
In a Strange Land
to continue living in Britain. Few anticipated such a nightmarish scenario. More pressing, however, were the large numbers entering Britain every year at the time of the passing of the Act who might in the future be subject to control: British sources indicated that over 70,000 Irish people arrived in 1960 alone.¹⁶⁶ Informally Irish officials sought clarification from their British counterparts as to the eventual form that the legislation would take, and the government was naturally relieved to learn as early as February 1961 that a ‘certain amount of administrative ‘‘winking’’ would have to go on and that emigration from Ireland to Great Britain was unlikely to be radically altered’.¹⁶⁷ As we noted, such ‘winking’ fooled few people when the bill was first introduced in parliament. Prior to the publication of the original bill, an embassy official, Valentin Iremonger, enquired informally of his counterpart in the Commonwealth Relations Office what form the restriction might take, and was told that the proposals should cause the Irish authorities ‘neither alarm or despondency’ and that Ireland’s interests ‘would be very well catered for’.¹⁶⁸ By the second reading of the bill in November 1961, the Minister for External Affairs, Frank Aiken, could confidently state in response to questions in the Dáil that the ‘present freedom of movement between the two countries is to their mutual advantage and I hope that the consultations taking place will lead to its being maintained’.¹⁶⁹ By the end of November, Séan Lemass, the Taoiseach, issued a statement in response to newspaper requests for a comment on the proposed legislation. Apart from the usual banal claims about the aim of the government being the reduction of emigration, he also stressed the ‘mutual benefits’ of the existing arrangements, and noted that any moves to introduce controls would be a ‘retrograde step’.¹⁷⁰ He also pointed to the co-operation between the two countries on the control of aliens, an element that was an important consideration for British officials since, for the ‘common travel area’ to work effectively, the Irish authorities needed to be as rigorous as ¹⁶⁶ Seventh Report of the Overseas Migration Board, 1961–62, Cmd. 1586, XVIII, 767, 12. ¹⁶⁷ Cremin to Secretary, Department of the Taoiseach, 13 Feb. 1961, DT S 13476 D/61, NAI. ¹⁶⁸ Valentin Iremonger (London) to Secretary, Department of External Affairs, 30 Sept. 1961, DT S 97/6/310, NAI. ¹⁶⁹ Dáil Éireann deb, 192 (15 Nov. 1961), 173. ¹⁷⁰ Statement by the Taoiseach, Séan Lemass, on the proposed British legislation on Immigration, 21 Nov. 1961, DT S 97/6/310, NAI.
In a Strange Land
81
their British counterparts, an understanding that was privately agreed in discussions between officials.¹⁷¹ The Commonwealth Immigrants Act, 1962, was a landmark in the history of British immigration policy since for the first time it introduced ‘a formal difference between those subjects born in, or otherwise belonging to, the United Kingdom and those of the Commonwealth and colonies’.¹⁷² The employment voucher that was required for entry from July 1962 onwards was the first element of control; subsequent legislation introduced in 1968 and brought together under the Immigration Act (1971) sought to restrict even further who was free to enter the country.¹⁷³ Within a decade Britain had moved from the traditional position of free entry for Commonwealth subjects to an increasingly restrictive policy. From the late 1950s public opinion was strongly in favour of control and Macmillan’s Conservative government moved somewhat reluctantly to implement proposals in the context of increasing disquiet about the consequences of large-scale immigration, most of which had been discussed with a greater or lesser degree of urgency since the mid–1950s. The practical exclusion of Irish citizens was not universally accepted, and indeed it was one of the most contentious aspects of the legislation. Few policymakers doubted the need for some control of immigration, but the decisions about which groups were to be restricted provoked accusations that it was a racist piece of legislation.¹⁷⁴ Without doubt, the perceived cultural homogeneity influenced the decision not to apply controls to the significant numbers arriving from Ireland each year. Equally, there were the obvious difficulties with enforcing such restrictions, given the porous border with Northern Ireland. The government of Northern Ireland would have vigorously resisted any controls that were applied on entry to mainland Britain, since this raised fundamental questions about the integration of the province within the United Kingdom. The Irish were less visible than Commonwealth migrants, and this influenced public opinion that was at best ambiguous about the position of all white arrivals, from Ireland ¹⁷¹ Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 114, n. 56. Hansen bases this observation on an interview with an unnamed Home Office official. This was a long-standing concern for British officials, as it was perceived that Ireland could be a ‘back door’ for migrants to the United Kingdom. Elizabeth Meehan’s research on Irish official records confirms this: see Meehan, Free Movement between Ireland and the UK, 30–6. ¹⁷² Hansen, Citizenship and Immigration, 123. ¹⁷³ Ann Dummett and Andrew Nichol, Subjects, Citizens, Aliens and Others: Nationality and Immigration Law (London, 1990), 183–7, 202–3, 216–23. ¹⁷⁴ Patterson, Immigration and Race Relations, 19.
82
In a Strange Land
or from the ‘old’ dominions of Australia, New Zealand, and Canada.¹⁷⁵ Last but not least, such a restriction would have abolished the ‘common travel area’, and indubitably incurred the wrath of the Lemass government, which was less concerned with issues of national sovereignty and showing signs of a willingness to have a better working relationship with the old enemy. It would also have undermined the application of both countries to join the European Economic Community since the free movement of labour was a sine qua non of membership. The end result, in terms of how the legislation actually operated, certainly discriminated unduly against Caribbean and South Asian Commonwealth citizens. This admittedly long list of related considerations faced the Macmillan government in the early 1960s: to present the exclusion of the Irish as simply a matter of skin colour lacks subtlety. Needless to say, the inner workings of the politics of citizenship were of little interest to the majority of the Irish in post-war Britain. Citizenship, however, was more than just an abstruse legal concept, as, according to T. H. Marshall in his famous study published in 1950, it conferred rights in three key areas: civil rights, political rights, and social rights, including access to welfare and education.¹⁷⁶ Coming from a society where the concept of citizenship was weakly developed, being a citizen rather than classified as an ‘alien’ allowed the Irish to enter the country freely, come and go as they wished, vote in parliamentary elections, and have the same welfare and social security benefits as other citizens. As was noted in the late 1960s, few people objected to the extension of these rights to the Irish in post-war Britain.¹⁷⁷ The Irish were ‘neither subjects nor aliens’, but in that uncertain middle ground, where they most certainly were not ‘foreigners’, yet still could not be classified as British subjects.¹⁷⁸ This ambiguity in legal terms was also reflected in the migrant world-view. One newspaper in the early 1960s described Irish migrants in Britain as the ‘the Irish middle nation’, citizens of independent Ireland but living a life that traversed mentally and physically the Irish Sea.¹⁷⁹ In the aftermath of Enoch Powell’s notorious ‘Rivers of Blood’ speech in April 1968, the writer John Walsh recalls his father’s indignation at Powell’s apparent suggestion that the ¹⁷⁵ Spencer, British Immigration Policy, 153. ¹⁷⁶ T. H. Marshall, Citizenship and Social Class (Cambridge, 1950), quoted in Rose et al., Colour and Citizenship, 27. ¹⁷⁷ Rose et al., Colour and Citizenship, 19. ¹⁷⁸ This phrase is taken from Paul, Whitewashing Britain, 91. ¹⁷⁹ Irish Press, 18 June 1960, quoted in Jackson, The Irish in Britain, 159.
In a Strange Land
83
Irish be ‘repatriated’ along with other arrivals.¹⁸⁰ His father finds the description of the Irish as ‘immigrants’ insulting, yet his life in London was only ‘a temporary, contingent thing’.¹⁸¹ For one well-informed observer, Dónall Mac Amhlaigh, a curious feature of this outlook was that the Irish did not view themselves as ‘foreigners’ and deeply resented that label, which was often applied indiscriminately to all eastern Europeans, generically lumped together in the popular imagination as ‘Poles’.¹⁸² But, as Mac Amhlaigh perceptively observes, this sat rather uneasily with the more truculent expressions of Irish nationalism. All but the more politically aware of the Irish I knew resented being called foreigners and they did not thank you when you pointed out to them since they came from an independent republic . . . they must surely be foreign—they could hardly hope to have it both ways . . . We seemed to me to be wanting to have our cake and eat it, to be better accepted by the British than any other immigrant group while at the same time making it clear that we were different, and being very slow to forget the wrongs done to us in the past.¹⁸³
5 . ‘ I ’ M WA L K I N G B AC K WA R D S F O R C H R I S T M A S ( AC RO S S T H E I R I S H S E A ) ’ In a well-known speech, an energetic young Irish minister, Donogh O’Malley, speaking in London on a St Patrick’s Day visit in 1966, urged the Irish in Britain to be less concerned about matters in Ireland, and adumbrated the case for greater integration within British society: Any element of maudlin sentimentality about the ‘old country’ should be rejected; rather, the Irish in Britain should seek to play their full part in the political and social life of this island. I do not think that, at present, they exert an influence commensurate with their numbers. I suspect that this is partly due to a fear of betraying their Irish heritage. But today, we in these islands, are moving with the tide of history towards European citizenship . . . I look forward to the day when the Irish and their descendants will have forged a ¹⁸⁰ I have been unable to find evidence of Powell having made such a comment in his various speeches and this may well have been an urban myth. ¹⁸¹ This example is cited by Liam Harte, ‘ ‘‘Somewhere Beyond England and Ireland’: Narratives of ‘‘Home’’ in Second-Generation Irish Autobiography’, Irish Studies Review, 11, no. 3 (2003), 301. ¹⁸² Dónall Mac Amhlaigh, ‘Documenting the Fifties’, Irish Studies in Britain, 15 (1989), 12. ¹⁸³ Ibid.
84
In a Strange Land
satisfactory role for themselves in British society; when they are eager to go forth and serve the country of their adoption.¹⁸⁴
After decades of Irish politicians encouraging people not to emigrate in the first instance, and then reminding them at every opportunity that their true spiritual home was Ireland, this was a remarkable exhortation for the Irish in post-war Britain to ‘go forth and serve the country of their adoption’.¹⁸⁵ O’Malley was a different breed of Irish politician, representative of a new generation who were not veterans of the Irish revolution, less concerned with the past, and more preoccupied with shaping a prosperous ‘modern’ Ireland. He was mapping out a different future where sentimental attachments to the imaginary homeland could be maintained, but the primary focus should be on making inroads into the political and social fabric of British society. O’Malley also commented on the extent to which the Irish were part of two societies, yet never firmly located in either one as it was impossible to be ‘true citizens of Britain and Ireland simultaneously’.¹⁸⁶ For one journalist, Kevin O’Connor, his speech was finely timed since by the mid–1960s the Irish in Britain had ‘become assured and settled’.¹⁸⁷ Many had been living there for nearly two decades and ‘reluctantly they were beginning to realize that for most of them there would be ‘‘no going home next year’’; that they were here to stay’.¹⁸⁸ The view that the Irish were an element of British society, yet still somehow on the margins, was an all-pervasive one. This ‘strange land’ with its unfamiliar physical landscape would never be ‘home’, and even after decades living in Britain the vision of return and ultimate redemption was still a defining feature of the social imaginary. In 1956 Spike Milligan, with his usual wit, captured this ambiguity in his famous song from the Goon Show: ‘I’m walking backwards for Christmas (across the Irish Sea)’.¹⁸⁹ While proximity had the obvious advantage of being able to travel between the two countries at regular intervals and maintain family and personal relationships with those still in Ireland, it also served ¹⁸⁴ Copy of address by Donogh O’Malley, Minister for Health, to the National University of Ireland Club, Grosvenor House, London, on St Patrick’s Day, 1966, DT S 96/6/437, NAI. ¹⁸⁵ Ibid. ¹⁸⁶ Ibid. ¹⁸⁷ O’Connor, The Irish in Britain, 99. ¹⁸⁸ Ibid. 99–100. ¹⁸⁹ Ibid. 161. This song reached the top of the British charts in the summer of 1956. Milligan was well placed to observe the Irish migrant mindset as his father was Irish, he was raised in India, moved to London, and eventually took out Irish citizenship in the early 1960s.
In a Strange Land
85
to sustain the illusion of occupying a ‘half-way house’, between two cultures, with a ‘foot in both camps—with obligations to each’.¹⁹⁰ This proximity, however, strengthened rather than weakened Irish identities in Britain and added an element of continuous replenishment to cultural identities. As John Jackson noted in the early 1960s, ambivalence was a key feature of Irish migrant identity: For citizens of the British Isles and others whose migrations are local in character it is less easy to face the consequences of the personal upheaval. Proximity provides a convenient excuse and escape which allows the ambiguity to be sustained and fostered. The duality is expressed in the yearning to return home when away and the restlessness and readiness to be off again which may characterize the time that is spent at home.¹⁹¹
As the years passed the return home was a remote prospect for many migrants as they settled down to life in Britain, yet it still featured prominently in the diasporic imagination. ¹⁹⁰ Ryan, ‘Assimilation of Irish Immigrants’, 58; Jackson, ‘The Irish’, 306. ¹⁹¹ Jackson, The Irish in Britain, 161.
3 People and Places Where the Irish settled and who they shared these spaces with had been concerns of social investigators and other commentators since the early nineteenth century. Contemporaries outlined the potentially dire consequences for Victorian towns and cities of the growth of Irish ‘ghettos’, anticipating similar sentiments about virtually every other migrant group who arrived in significant numbers subsequently. Up to the last quarter of the nineteenth century the Irish were the largest and most visible presence. By the late 1950s, however, they were but one of many newcomers and less readily identifiable than other arrivals from the Commonwealth. Echoes of the past coexisted with new irrational fears as the ‘coloured’ quarter was now the source of foreboding and suspicion. From the mid-1830s contemporary accounts of the poor Irish who settled in the rapidly expanding industrial centres of Liverpool, Manchester, and Glasgow drew public attention to the horrendous conditions in which the Hibernian newcomers lived in urban slums. The talk was of ‘little Irelands’, synonymous with poverty, filth, and squalor, and this fuelled pre-existing stereotypes and prejudices about the innate racial inferiority of the ‘miserable’ Irish.¹ Middle-class nineteenth-century observers who documented the social problems of Victorian working-class life expressed similar sentiments as the ‘Condition of England’ was debated.² The Irish who arrived in the 1830s and 1840s were identified as one of the ‘main causes of the urban crisis in early Victorian Britain’.³ For ¹ Graham Davis, The Irish in Britain, 1815–1914 (Dublin, 1991), 51–82; David Fitzpatrick, ‘ ‘‘A Peculiar Tramping People’’: The Irish in Britain, 1801–70’, in W. E. Vaughan (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 5: Ireland Under the Union, I (1801–70) (Oxford, 1989), 633–6; Donald M. MacRaild, Irish Migrants in Modern Britain, 1750–1922 (Basingstoke, 1999), 51–7. ² Donald M. MacRaild, ‘Irish Immigration and the ‘‘Condition of England’’ Question: The Roots of an Historiographical Tradition’, Immigrants and Minorities, 14, no. 1 (1995), 67–85. ³ David Feldman, ‘Migrants, Immigrants and Welfare from the Old Poor Law to the Welfare State’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 6th ser., 13 (2003), 95.
People and Places
87
Friedrich Engels, who graphically described Manchester’s ‘Little Ireland’ in 1845, the wandering Celt was a degrading influence on native workers: The worst quarters of all the large towns are inhabited by Irishmen. Whenever a district is distinguished for especial filth and especial ruinousness, the explorer may safely count on meeting chiefly those Celtic faces which one recognizes at the first glance as different from the Saxon physiognomy of the native, and the singing, aspirate brogue which the true Irishman never loses . . . In short, the Irish have, as Dr Kay says, discovered the minimum of the necessities of life, and are now making the English workers acquainted with it.⁴
The principal fear was the possibility of moral contagion as the ‘wild Milesian Irish’, to quote Thomas Carlyle’s famous description from 1839, would be a pernicious influence and encourage indolence within the indigenous poor, a pressing concern after the introduction of the new English poor law system in 1834.⁵ The fact that these arrivals tended to settle, in the first instance at least, in close proximity to their fellow-compatriots conjured up threatening images of Irish ‘ghettos’ in the minds of hostile observers in the 1830s and 1840s. The Morning Chronicle remarked in 1849, when the famine refugees were arriving in huge numbers, that ‘the Irish invariably herd together’.⁶ The assertion that the Irish were hermetically sealed from the other residents of working-class districts of British cities and towns is now widely acknowledged by historians to be erroneous, a product of fertile Victorian imaginations and deeply engrained stereotypes. Undoubtedly within particular areas of cities and large towns clusters of Irish migrants developed, but this reflected the economic opportunities available to these unskilled and impoverished manual workers. As David Fitzpatrick has cogently argued, ‘though Irish ghettos developed virtually nowhere in Britain, the settlers were clustered in the most congested and decaying districts of most British towns, among which they moved ⁴ Friedrich Engels, The Condition of the Working Class in England, ed. David McLellan (Oxford, 1993), 102. Sir J. P. Kay-Shuttleworth was a social reformer who was secretary to the Manchester Board of Health, and had published an earlier pamphlet on The Moral and Physical Condition of the Working Classes Employed in Cotton Manufacture in Manchester (London, 1832); for further details, see Mary Hickman, ‘Alternative Historiographies of the Irish in Britain: A Critique of the Segregation/Assimilation Model’, in Roger Swift and Sheridan Gilley (eds.), The Irish in Victorian Britain: The Local Dimension (Dublin, 1999), 245–6. ⁵ MacRaild, ‘Irish Immigration and the ‘‘Condition of England’’ Question’, 72. ⁶ Quoted in Fitzpatrick, ‘ ‘‘A Peculiar Tramping People’’ ’, 634. For a selection of contemporary responses, see Roger Swift (ed.), Irish Migrants in Britain, 1815–1914 (Cork, 2002), 35–46.
88
People and Places
with startlingly rapidity from one insalubrious lodging to another’.⁷ By the turn of the twentieth century these so-called ‘Irish’ quarters were in terminal decline as the numbers arriving from Ireland decreased from the 1870s onwards. The more established settlers were dispersed within urban centres. When Engels republished his book in 1892, he concluded in the preface that the ‘Little Ireland’ in Manchester, which he had so graphically described in 1845, no longer existed.⁸ A century or more later such views were uncommon, since the gaze of policymakers and the wider public was now directed at the more visible alien presence, but this was a long-drawn-out process as ‘old prejudices die hard’.⁹ But even by the mid-1930s, liberal-minded writers such as J. B. Priestley could still describe the poor Irish in Liverpool in racial terms: The Irishman in Ireland may, as we are so often assured he is, be the best fellow in the world, only waiting to say good-bye to the hateful Empire so that, free and independent at last, he can astonish the world. But the Irishman in England too often cuts a very miserable figure . . . But the English of this class generally make some attempt to live as decently as they can under these conditions; their existence has been turned into an obstacle race, with the most monstrous and gigantic obstacles, but you may see them straining and panting, still in the race. From such glimpses that I have had, however, the Irish appear in general never even to have tried; they have settled in the nearest poor quarter and turned it into a slum or, finding a slum, have promptly settled to out-slum it.¹⁰
By the mid-twentieth century the numbers arriving reinvigorated existing centres of Irish settlement in many large British cities, the most obvious example being London. 1 . M E T RO P O L I S The Irish who arrived in London after the Second World War were by no means pioneers as the ‘London Irish’ had been a feature of ⁷ David Fitzpatrick, ‘The Irish in Britain, 1871–1921’, in W. E. Vaughan (ed.), A New History of Ireland, Vol. 6: Ireland Under the Union, II (1870–1921) (Oxford, 1996), 653. ⁸ Ibid. 656–7; Engels, The Condition of the Working Class in England, 315. ⁹ M. A. G. Ó Tuathaigh, ‘The Irish in Nineteenth-Century Britain: Problems of Integration’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 5th ser., 31 (1981), 173. ¹⁰ J. B. Priestley, An English Journey (Harmondsworth, 1977), 235–6, quoted in Steven Fielding, Class and Ethnicity: Irish Catholics in England, 1880–1939 (Buckingham, 1993), 131–2. On Priestley, see Chris Waters, ‘J. B. Priestley, 1894–1984: Englishness and the Politics of Nostalgia’, in Susan Pedersen and Peter Mandler (eds.), After the Victorians: Private Conscience and Public Duty in Modern Britain (London, 1996), 208–26.
People and Places
89
the metropolitan landscape for as long as records exist.¹¹ As the city expanded and changed throughout the nineteenth century so too did the social geography of the London Irish as older communities were displaced in the 1860s and 1870s by commercial development in the inner zones, and the Irish moved to Hammersmith, Islington, and other outlying districts.¹² Whereas much of the older historical writing tended to dwell on the enduring image of the nineteenth-century poor Irish in London, more recent work has underscored the multi-layered social profile of waves of migrants who arrived in the city. For middle-class professionals seeking to improve career prospects, London was the place to go. Opportunities for advancement and preferment far exceeded those available in Dublin or provincial Ireland. Journalists, politicians, lawyers, doctors, writers, and artists flocked to London in large numbers from at least the eighteenth century and entered into metropolitan life with some gusto. Roy Foster has described these late nineteenth-century ‘aspiring careerists’ as ‘Micks on the make’.¹³ The constant stream of arrivals from ‘across the water’ since the mid-1930s meant that London’s Irish population nearly doubled in twenty years. In 1951, with a total of 111,671 people in the administrative county of London, the Irish were the largest single group of people born in any foreign or Commonwealth country, in Scotland or Wales, or in any other county in England and Wales, with the obvious exception of London itself.¹⁴ If the outlying suburbs are included, this figure doubles. Roughly a third of the Irish-born population in England and Wales in the mid-twentieth century lived in Greater London, with areas such as Willesden in Middlesex and expanding industrial centres such as Luton, Dagenham, and Slough all containing significant numbers of Irish.¹⁵ Within the city boundaries the 1931 ¹¹ John A. Jackson, ‘The Irish’, in Ruth Glass (ed.), London: Aspects of Change (London, 1964), 293; Patrick Fitzgerald, ‘ ‘‘Like Crickets to the Crevice of a BrewHouse’’: Poor Irish Migrants in England, 1560–1640’, in Patrick O’Sullivan (ed.), Patterns of Migration (London, 1992), 13–35; Lynn Hollen Lees, Exiles of Erin: Irish Migrants in Victorian London (Manchester, 1979), 55–6. ¹² For a detailed discussion, see Lees, Exiles of Erin, 55–87. ¹³ Craig A. Bailey, ‘Metropole and Colony: Irish Networks and Patronage in the Eighteenth-Century Empire’, Immigrants and Minorities, 23 (2005), 161–81; Roy Foster, ‘Marginal Men and Micks on the Make: The Uses of Irish Exile, c.1840–1922’, in Paddy and Mr Punch (London, 1995), 281–305, quotation from 282. ¹⁴ Jackson, ‘The Irish’, 296. ¹⁵ Ibid. 302. On the development of suburban London in the first half of the twentieth century, see Jerry White, London in the Twentieth Century: A City and its People (London, 2001), 24–45.
90
People and Places
census recorded heavy concentrations of Irish in boroughs such as Westminster, Kensington, Chelsea, and Marylebone.¹⁶ By the 1950s the Irish accounted for just under 10 per cent of the population of the borough of Paddington, with smaller numbers in St Pancras, Westminster, Chelsea, Hammersmith, Hampstead, Holborn, Marylebone, and Kensington.¹⁷ Two decades later, by the early 1970s nearly half of the London Irish lived in seven boroughs: Camden, Kensington and Chelsea, Westminster, Islington, Hammersmith, Ealing, and Brent, which was a well-known stronghold.¹⁸ In ‘inner’ London, John Jackson observed the final stages of a shift in terms of historic settlement patterns from the nineteenth century centred on the East End to the West End. Hammersmith, Kensington, and Paddington became increasingly popular areas for Irish arrivals by the early 1950s. In large part, this reflected immediate needs and opportunities as ‘the new transitional areas of decayed Victorian terraced houses, unpainted, sub-divided and uncared for, provide cheap rooms and lodging for immigrant communities composed predominantly of single men and women’.¹⁹ One psychologist undertaking a study of personality types in a poor district close to Paddington railway station in the late 1940s—dubbed ‘one of the worst slums in London’—could not conceal her middle-class sensibilities when she described the living conditions of this area which was dominated by the displaced sons and daughters of Erin: The slum group selected is living in an area known to social workers and the police as one of the worst slums in London . . . All about the streets are children—whether it is a school day or a holiday there always seems to be children playing in the road or going to and fro with shopping baskets and ration books. Women and a few men stand in doorways or sit on the house steps; and everywhere there are dogs . . . The district is notorious in London for vice and delinquency; it is a major prostitution area and is considered by the Probation Service the blackest spot in the city for juvenile delinquency. A large proportion of the inhabitants are Irish; social workers say: ‘The Irish land here, and while the respectable soon move away, the ignorant and shiftless stay’ . . . The most noticeable characteristic of the house is the strong and unpleasant smell, indeed ¹⁶ Census of England and Wales, 1931: General Report (London, 1950), 171. ¹⁷ John Archer Jackson, The Irish in Britain (London, 1963), 18. ¹⁸ Colin Holmes, John Bull’s Island: Immigration and British Society, 1871–1971 (Basingstoke, 1988), 216. ¹⁹ Jackson, The Irish in Britain, 8. The data can be found in Census of England and Wales, 1951: General Report (London, 1958), 105.
People and Places
91
on a first visit the middle-class stomach may find it impossible to stay longer than five minutes.²⁰
From the 1950s the more established migrants tended to move away from central districts, and some of the new arrivals went to the expanding industrial areas of Dagenham, Staines, and West Drayton.²¹ This was in large part determined by the location of employment: for instance, in the 1940s the Ford motor plant in Dagenham recruited employees for heavy foundry work directly from Ireland.²² Many lived either in or near the West End, especially in hotels of various sizes and kinds. In the late 1950s one estimate produced by Catholic clergy suggested that over 15,000 Irish migrants, the majority female, worked in the hotels, clubs, and cafés of the West End. In one large hotel, the Cumberland, with 2,700 staff, over 90 per cent of the workers were Irish.²³ Over a quarter of all economically active Irish females by the mid-twentieth century were ‘persons engaged in personal service’, mostly domestic servants, cleaners, and waitresses.²⁴ One contemporary reported staying at a London hotel in 1950 where the staff included nearly two hundred young Irish women.²⁵ Hotel and catering work was a relatively easy entry to the labour market in London, since few skills were required and jobs could often be found simply by word of mouth through family and friends. Another source of employment were hospitals, and, as Jackson remarks, by the early 1960s the omnipresent Irish nurse had ‘become so much a characteristic feature of the London hospital service that they are taken for granted and not thought of as immigrant labour’.²⁶ By the early 1960s Irish women were viewed as so deeply embedded in the staffing needs of London hospitals that when a survey was completed on hospitals in Croydon, ²⁰ B. M. Spinley, The Deprived and the Privileged: Personality Development in English Society