i
The
casebook
Thermodynamics at work
ii
iii
The casebook Thermodynamics at work Second edition Edited by K. Hack
Woodhead Publishing and Maney Publishing on behalf of The Institute of Materials, Minerals & Mining
CRC Press Boca Raton Boston New York Washington, DC
WOODHEAD
PUBLISHING LIMITED
Cambridge, England
iv Woodhead Publishing Limited and Maney Publishing Limited on behalf of The Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Abington Cambridge CB21 6AH, England www.woodheadpublishing.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway, NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton FL 33487, USA First published 2008, Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC © 2008, Institute of Materials, Minerals and Mining The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-215-5 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-395-4 (e-book) CRC Press ISBN 978-1-4200-4458-4 CRC Press order number WP4458 The publishers’ policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publishers ensure that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by Replika Press Pvt Ltd, India Printed by TJ International Limited, Padstow, Cornwall, England
v
Contents
Contributing authors Software packages used for the case studies Member organisations of SGTE
xvii xx xxiii
Editor’s acknowledgements
xxv
Foreword
xxix
Introduction
xxxi
Part I:
Theoretical background
I.1
Basic thermochemical relationships
I.1.1 I.1.2 I.1.3 I.1.4 I.1.5 I.1.6
Introduction Thermochemistry of stoichiometric reactions Thermochemistry of complex systems Activities of stable and metastable phases Extensive property balances References
3 4 7 9 12 13
I.2
Models and data
14
I.2.1 I.2.2 I.2.3 I.2.4 I.2.4.1 I.2.4.2 I.2.4.3 I.2.4.4
Introduction Gibbs energy data for pure stoichiometric substances Conclusion Relative data Advantages of the use of relative Gibbs energies Solution phase systems Disadvantages Conclusion
14 16 20 20 22 22 24 25
3
vi
Contents
I.2.5 I.2.5.1 I.2.5.2 I.2.5.3 I.2.5.4 I.2.5.5 I.2.5.6 I.2.5.7 I.2.5.8 I.2.5.9 I.2.5.10 I.2.6
Solution phases Substitutional solutions Partial properties for the substitutional solution The sublattice model Partial properties for the sublattice model Interstitial solutions Lattice defects Ionic solid solutions The ideal gas Liquid solutions Magnetic effects in solution phases References
25 25 28 28 29 30 31 31 32 34 37 41
I.3
Phase diagrams
43
I.3.1 I.3.2 I.3.2.1 I.3.2.2 I.3.3 I.3.4 I.3.4.1 I.3.4.2 I.3.4.3
Introduction: types of phase diagrams Zero-phase-fraction lines Special cases of zero-phase-fraction intersections Conclusions on zero-phase-fraction lines Beyond classical phase diagrams The phase rule The ammonium chloride–gas equilibrium The water–phosphoric acid equilibrium The 2CaO·SiO2–3CaO·MgO·2SiO2–CaO·MgO·SiO2 equilibrium Conclusions References
43 50 53 55 55 66 69 70 70 71 72
Summarising mathematical relationships between the Gibbs energy and other thermodynamic information
73
I.4.1
Reference
74
Part II:
Applications in material science and processes
II.1
Hot salt corrosion of superalloys
77
II.1.1 II.1.2 II.1.3 II.1.4 II.1.5
Introduction Data used for the calculations The gas–salt equilibrium The interaction of gas and salt with Cr2O3 Limitations of the data and calculated results
77 77 79 82 88
I.3.5 I.3.6 I.4
Contents
vii
II.1.6 II.1.7 II.1.8 II.1.9
Extension to higher-order systems Future developments Acknowledgements References
88 89 89 90
II.2
Computer-assisted development of high-speed steels
91
II.2.1 II.2.2 II.2.3 II.2.4 II.2.5
Introduction Background Calculation Discussion Reference
91 91 91 92 97
II.3
Using calculated phase diagrams in the selection of the composition of cemented WC tools with a Co–Fe–Ni binder phase
98
II.3.1 II.3.2 II.3.3 II.3.4 II.3.5 II.3.6
Introduction: background to the problem The region of favourable carbon contents Effects of replacing Co by Fe and Ni Favourable carbon contents of a family of alloys Conclusions References
98 98 99 102 103 105
II.4
Prediction of loss of corrosion resistance in austenitic stainless steels
106
II.4.1 II.4.2 II.4.3 II.4.4 II.4.5 II.4.6 II.4.7
Introduction Theory Results Discussion Method of plotting diagrams Database References
106 106 107 111 112 113 113
II.5
Prediction of a quasiternary section of a quaternary phase diagram
114
Introduction Solid phases Modelling Results References
114 114 115 115 117
II.5.1 II.5.2 II.5.3 II.5.4 II.5.5
viii
Contents
II.6
Hot isostatic pressing of Al–Ni alloys
118
II.6.1 II.6.2 II.6.3 II.6.4 II.6.5 II.6.6
Introduction Generalised Clausius–Clapeyron equation Application to the Ni–Al equilibrium Conclusions Acknowledgement References
118 119 120 121 121 122
II.7
Thermodynamics in microelectronics
123
II.7.1 II.7.2
Introduction Thin-film deposition of SrTiO3 and interface stability with Si Reactive ion etching of HfO2 dielectric films Annealing of amorphous Ru–Si–O and Ir–Si–O thin films Conclusions References
123
128 130 131
Calculation of the phase diagrams of the MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 system at high pressures and temperatures: application to the mineral structure of the Earth’s mantle transition zone
132
II.7.3 II.7.4 II.7.5 II.7.6 II.8
II.8.1 II.8.2 II.8.3 II.8.4 II.8.5 II.8.6 II.8.7 II.9
II.9.1 II.9.2 II.9.3 II.9.4 II.9.5 II.9.6
Introduction Phases and models Phase equilibria in subsystems Phase diagrams for selected subsystems of the FeO–MgO–Al2O3–SiO2 system Phase diagram of the mantle composition at pressures up to 30 GPa Acknowledgements References
124 127
132 134 135 137 141 142 142
Calculation of the concentration of iron and copper ions in aqueous sulphuric acid solutions as functions of the electrode potential
144
Introduction Fe–H2SO4–H2O subsystem Cu–H2SO4–H2O subsystem The complete system Cu–Fe–H2SO4–H2O Conclusions and further developments References
144 145 146 148 152 154
Contents
II.10
ix
Thermochemical conditions for the production of low-carbon stainless steels
155
II.10.1 II.10.2 II.10.3 II.10.4 II.10.5 II.10.6
Introduction The mass action law approach The complex equilibrium approach Engineering conclusions Acknowledgements References
155 156 156 159 160 160
II.11
Interpretation of complex thermochemical phenomena in severe nuclear accidents using a thermodynamic approach
161
II.11.1 II.11.2 II.11.2.1 II.11.2.2 II.11.2.3 II.11.2.4 II.11.2.5 II.11.3 II.11.4 II.11.4.1 II.11.4.2 II.11.5 II.11.6 II.12
II.12.1 II.12.2 II.12.3 II.12.4 II.12.5 II.12.6 II.12.7
Introduction The nuclear thermodynamic database Pure elements and oxide components History Thermodynamic modelling of substance and solution phases Critical assessment of binary and ternary subsystems (calculation-of-phase-diagrams method) Content, assessed sub-systems, solution and substance phases Equilibrium calculation software Complex thermochemical phenomena in severe nuclear accidents In-vessel applications Ex-vessel applications Conclusions References
161 162 162 163 164 166 167 168 169 169 171 173 174
Nuclide distribution between steelmaking phases upon melting of sealed radioactive sources hidden in scrap
178
Introduction List of relevant nuclides Preparation of a suitable set of thermochemical data Calculated partition ratios Realistic distribution ratios Conclusions References
178 179 179 182 185 186 187
x
II.13
Contents
Pyrometallurgy of copper–nickel–iron sulphide ores: the calculation of the distribution of components between matte, slag, alloy and gas phases
188
II.13.1 II.13.2 II.13.3 II.13.4 II.13.5 II.13.6 II.13.7
Introduction Blowing the matte Phase separation in the matte Solidification and recrystallisation Thermodynamic models and data Acknowledgements References
188 188 191 191 193 195 198
II.14
High-temperature corrosion of SiC in hydrogen– oxygen environments
200
II.14.1 II.14.2 II.14.3 II.14.4 II.14.5 II.14.6 II.14.7
Introduction Models for the corrosion process Thermodynamic analysis Si–C–H system Si–C–O–H system Discussion References
200 201 204 204 206 206 211
II.15
The carbon potential during the heat treatment of steel
212
II.15.1 II.15.2 II.15.3 II.15.4 II.15.5 II.15.6
Introduction The carbon potential The carbon activity in industrial furnace atmospheres The carbon activity of multicomponent steels Summary References
212 212 213 219 220 223
II.16
Preventing clogging in a continuous casting process
224
II.16.1 II.16.2 II.16.3 II.16.4
Introduction Setting up the calculation Solution Final remarks
224 224 225 226
II.17
Evaluation of the EMF from a potential phase diagram for a quaternary system
228
Introduction Theory
228 229
II.17.1 II.17.2
Contents
xi
II.17.3
Results
230
II.18
Application of the phase rule to the equilibria in the system Ca–C–O
231
Thermodynamic prediction of the risk of hot corrosion in gas turbines
239
II.19 II.19.1 II.19.2 II.19.3 II.19.4 II.19.5 II.19.6 II.19.7 II.20
Introduction Hot corrosion Thermodynamic modelling Hot-corrosion risk in second generation circulating pressurised fluidised-bed combustion Hot-corrosion risk in pressurised pulverised coal combustion Conclusions References
239 240 240 241 244 246 246
The potential use of thermodynamic calculations for the prediction of metastable phase ranges resulting from mechanical alloying
248
II.20.1 II.20.2 II.20.3 II.20.4 II.20.5
Introduction Calculation principles and previous related work Results Summary and conclusions References
248 249 251 261 262
II.21
Adiabatic and quasi-adiabatic transformations
263
II.21.1 II.21.2 II.21.3 II.21.4 II.21.5
Introduction Theory Numerical calculations Discussion References
263 263 264 265 266
II.22
Inclusion cleanness in calcium-treated steel grades
267
II.22.1 II.22.2 II.22.2.1 II.22.2.2
Introduction Choice of the most adapted sample to qualify the calcium treatment Nature and composition of the inclusions obtained by scanning electron microscopy Thermodynamic modelling
267 268 268 270
xii
Contents
II.22.3 II.22.4
Conclusion References
272 272
II.23
Heat balances and CP calculations
273
II.23.1 II.23.2 II.23.3 II.23.4
Introduction Practical calculations Calculational example References
273 276 281 281
II.24
The industrial glass-melting process
282
II.24.1
Introduction to some fundamentals of industrial glass melting Description frame for the thermodynamic properties of industrial glass-forming systems Description frame for one-component glasses and glass melts Description frame for multicomponent glasses and glass melts Heat content of glass melts The batch-to-melt conversion Heat demand of the batch-to-melt conversion; simple raw materials Dolomite and limestone as examples of complex raw materials Modelling the batch-to-melt conversion Conclusions References
295 297 301 302
Relevance of thermodynamic key data for the development of high-temperature gas discharge light sources
304
II.25.1 II.25.2 II.25.3 II.25.4 II.25.5
Introduction Operation principle of high-intensity discharge lamps Thermochemical modelling Conclusions References
304 305 306 310 310
II.26
The prediction of mercury vapour pressures above amalgams for use in fluorescent lamps
312
Introduction Use of amalgams in compact fluorescent lamps
312 312
II.24.2 II.24.2.1 II.24.2.2 II.24.2.3 II.24.3 II.24.3.1 II.24.3.2 II.24.3.3 II.24.4 II.24.5 II.25
II.26.1 II.26.2
282 284 284 286 290 293 293
Contents
xiii
II.26.3 II.26.4 II.26.5
Calculation of phase equilibria for amalgam systems Conclusions References
314 321 321
II.27
Modelling cements in an aqueous environment at elevated temperatures
322
II.27.1 II.27.2 II.27.3 II.27.4 II.27.5 II.27.5.1 II.27.5.2 II.27.5.3 II.27.6 II.27.7
Introduction Previous modelling studies MTDATA Modelling approach Results and discussion C–S–H solubility at room temperature C–S–H solubility at higher temperatures Leaching simulation Conclusions References
322 323 323 325 328 328 331 333 334 335
Part III:
Process modelling – theoretical background
III.1
Introduction
341
III.2
The Gulliver–Scheil method for the calculation of solidification paths
343
III.2.1
Reference
346
III.3
Diffusion in multicomponent phases
347
III.3.1 III.3.2 III.3.3 III.3.4
Introduction Phenomenological treatment Analysis of experimental data: the general database References
347 347 349 350
III.4
Simulation of dynamic and steady-state processes
351
III.4.1 III.4.2 III.4.3 III.4.4 III.4.5 III.4.6
Introduction Concept of modelling processes using simple unit operations General description of the reactor model The control of material flows Conclusions References
351 351 353 355 357 357
xiv
Contents
III.5
Setting kinetic controls for complex equilibrium calculations
359
III.5.1 III.5.2 III.5.3 III.5.4
Introduction The basic concept Simple equilibrium calculations References
359 359 364 367
Part IV:
Process modelling – application cases
IV.1
Calculation of solidification paths for multicomponent systems
371
IV.1.1 IV.1.2 IV.1.3
Introduction: description of the phase diagram Solidification paths References
371 372 374
IV.2
Computational phase studies in commercial aluminium and magnesium alloys
375
IV.2.1 IV.2.2 IV.2.2.1 IV.2.2.2 IV.2.2.3 IV.2.2.4 IV.2.2.5 IV.2.3 IV.2.4 IV.2.5
Introduction Thermodynamic calculations for ternary subsystems Al–Mg–Zn system Cu–Mg–Zn system Al–Cu–Mg system Al–Cu–Zn system Quaternary Al–Cu–Mg–Zn system Conclusions Acknowledgement References
375 375 376 381 381 382 382 383 384 384
IV.3
Multicomponent diffusion in compound steel
386
IV.3.1 IV.3.2
386
IV.3.4 IV.3.5
Introduction Numerical calculation of diffusion between a stainless steel and a tempering steel Calculation of partial equilibrium between a carbon steel and an alloy steel Summary References
IV.4
Melting of a tool steel
392
IV.4.1 IV.4.2 IV.4.3
Introduction Calculation Discussion
392 393 393
IV.3.3
386 389 391 391
Contents
xv
IV.4.4 IV.4.5 IV.4.6
Conclusions Acknowledgement References
396 397 397
IV.5
Thermodynamic modelling of processes during hot corrosion of heat exchanger components
398
IV.5.1 IV.5.2 IV.5.3 IV.5.3.1 IV.5.3.2 IV.5.4 IV.5.5 IV.6
Introduction Database work Calculational results Two-dimensional mappings (phase diagrams) for alloys in corrosive atmospheres Model calculations for gas-phase corrosion Conclusions References
398 398 399 399 400 403 404
Microstructure of a five-component Ni-base superalloy: experiments and simulation
405
IV.6.1 IV.6.2 IV.6.3 IV.6.4 IV.6.5 IV.6.6 IV.6.7
Introduction Experimental work Microstructure simulation Discussion Conclusions Acknowledgement References
405 406 408 412 413 414 414
IV.7
Production of metallurgical-grade silicon in an electric arc furnace
415
IV.7.1 IV.7.2 IV.7.3 IV.7.4 IV.7.5
Introduction The stoichiometric reaction approach The complex equilibrium approach The countercurrent reactor approach Reference
415 416 416 418 424
IV.8
Non-equilibrium modelling for the LD converter
425
IV.8.1 IV.8.2 IV.8.3 IV.8.4 IV.8.5 IV.8.6 IV.8.7
Introduction Process model development Modelling tool Simulation results Conclusions List of symbols References
425 426 429 430 434 435 436
xvi
IV.9 IV.9.1 IV.9.2 IV.9.3 IV.9.4
Contents
Modelling TiO2 production by explicit use of reaction kinetics
437
Introduction Anatase–rutile transformation – a simple example of the constrained Gibbs energy method Model for the TiCl4 burner: comparison with the image component technique References
437
441 445
Index
447
437
xvii
Contributing authors
Editor and author: Klaus Hack, GTT-Technologies, Herzogenrath, Germany Authors • John Ågren, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden • Fritz Aldinger, Max-Planck-Institut für Metallforschung and Institut für nichtmetallische Anorganische materialien, Universität Stuttgart, Germany • Ibrahim Ansara, Institute National Polytechnique de Grenoble, Grenoble, France • Tom I. Barry, Amethyst Systems, Hampton, UK • Claude Bernard (emeritus), Institute National Polytechnique de Grenoble, Grenoble, France • Bernd Böttger, ACCESS e.V., Aachen, Germany • Pierre-Yves Chevalier, Thermodata, Grenoble, France • Bertrand Cheynet, Thermodata, Grenoble, France • Reinhard Conradt, RWTH Aachen (GHI), Aachen, Germany • R. Hugh Davies, National Physical Laboratory, Teddington, UK • Alan T. Dinsdale, National Physical Laboratory, Teddington, UK • Nathalie Dupin, Calcul Thermodynamique, 3 rue de l’avenir, 63670 Orcet, France • Gunnar Eriksson, GTT-Technologies, Germany • Olga Fabrichnaya, Max-Planck-Institut für Metallforschung (PML), Stuttgart, Germany • Françoise Faudot, Centre d’Etudes de Chimie Métallurgique, CNRS, Vitry-sur-Seine Cedex, France • Armando Fernandez Guillermet, Consejo Nacional de Investigationes Cientificas y Technicas, Centro Atomico Bariloche, Bariloche, Argentina • Evelyne Fischer, INPG – ENSEEG BP75, Saint Martin d’Hères, France • Graham M. Forsdyke, GE Lighting Europe, Leicester, UK • Suzana G. Fries, SGF Scientific, Consultancy, Aachen, Germany • John A. Gisby, National Physical Laboratory, Teddington, UK • Per Gustafson, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden • Anke Güthenke, Daimler–Chrysler, Stuttgart, Germany
xviii
• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
Contributing authors
Bengt Hallstedt, RWTH Aachen (MCh), Aachen, Germany Mireille G. Harmelin, Centre d’Etudes de Chimie Métallurgique, CNRS, Vitry-sur-Seine Cedex, France Ulrike Hecht, ACCESS e.V., Aachen, Germany Mats Hillert, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden Torsten Holm, AGA AB Innovations, Lidingö, Sweden Michael H.G. Jacobs, Technische Universität Clausthal, ClausthalZellerfeld, Germany Tamara Jantzen, GTT – Technologies, Herzogenrath, Germany Stefan Jonsson, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden Jürgen Korb, GTT-Technologies, Herzogenrath, Germany Pertti Koukkari, VTT, Espoo, Finland Ulrich Krupp, Fachhochschule Osnabrück, Osnabrück, Germany Ping Liang, Hans Leo Lukas and Fritz Aldinger, Max-Planck-Institut für Metallforschung and Institut für Nichtmetallische Anorganische Materialien, Universität Stuttgart, Germany Hans Leo Lukas (emeritus), Max-Planck-Institut für Metallforschung and Institut für Nichtmetallische Anorganische Materialien, Universität Stuttgart, Germany Jean Lehmann, ArcelorMittal, Maizières, France Dexin Ma, Foundry Institute of the RWTH Aachen, Aachen, Germany Torsten Markus, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Jülich, Germany Raymond Meilland, ArcelorMittal, Maizières, France Susan M. Martin, National Physical Laboratory, Teddington, UK Michael Modigell, RWTH Aachen (IVT), Aachen, Germany Peter Monheim, SMS-Demag, Düsseldorf, Germany Stuart A. Mucklejohn, GE Lighting Europe, Leicester, UK Erik M. Mueller, University of Florida, Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Gainesville FL, USA Michael Müller, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Jülich, Germany Dieter Neuschütz, RWTH Aachen (Men), Aachen, Germany Klaus G. Nickel, Universität Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany Ulrich Niemann, Philipps Forschungszentrum, Aachen, Germany Risto Pajarre, VTT, Espoo, Finland Karri Pentillä, VTT, Espoo, Finland Stefan Petersen, GTT-Technologies, Herzogenrath, Germany Günter Petzow (emeritus), Max Planck Institut für Metallforschung (PML), Stuttgart, Germany Alexander Pisch, Institute National Polytechnique de Grenoble, Grenoble, France Caian Qiu, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden Hans-Jürgen Seifert, Technische Universität Freiberg, Freiberg, Germany Malin Selleby, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden
Contributing authors
• • • • • • •
Philip J. Spencer, Spencer Group, Trumansburg, New York, USA Bo Sundman, University of Toulouse, Toulouse, France Jeff R. Taylor, Johnson Matthey Technology Centre, Reading, UK Vicente Braz de Trindade Filho, Technische Universität Siegen, Siegen, Germany Mark Tyrer, Imperial College, London, UK Colin Walker, Natural History Museum, London, UK Nils Warnken, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
xix
xx
Software packages used for the case studies
ChemSheet GTT-Technologies and VTT Gesellschaft für Technische Thermochemie und -physik mbH Kaiserstraße 100 D-52134 Herzogenrath, Germany www.chemsheet.com
DICTRA Thermo-Calc Software AB Stockholm Technology Park Björnnäsväge 21 S-11347 Stockholm, Sweden www.thermocalc.se
FactSage GTT-Technologies and Thermfact Gesellschaft für Technische Thermochemie und -physik mbH Kaiserstraße 100 D-52134 Herzogenrath, Germany Thermfact Ltd/LTEE 447 Berwick Montreal H3R 1Z8, Canada www.factsage.com
GEMINI Thermodata 6 rue du Tour de l’Eau F-38400 Saint-Martin d’Hères, France http://thermodata.online.fr/
Software packages used for the case studies
InCorr/ChemApp University of Siegen and GTT-Technologies Institut für Werkstofftechnik (IWT) FB 11 Lehrstuhl für Werkstoffkunde und Materialprüfung Universität Siegen 57068 Siegen, Germany http://www.mb.uni-siegen.de/ifw2/ Gesellschaft für Technische Thermochemie und -physik mbH Kaiserstraße 100 D-52134 Herzogenrath, Germany http://www.gtt-technologies.de/chemapp
Micress ACCESS e.V. Intzestraße 5 D-52072 Aachen, Germany http://www.micress.de/
MTDATA National Physical Laboratory Hampton Road, Teddington Middlesex TW11 0LW UK www.npl.co.uk/mtdata/
SimuSage GTT-Technologies Gesellschaft für Technische Thermochemie und -physik mbH Kaiserstraße 100 D-52134 Herzogenrath, Germany http://www.gtt-technologies.de/simusage
Thermo-Calc Thermo-Calc Software AB Stockholm Technology Park Björnnäsväge 21 S-11347 Stockholm, Sweden www.thermocalc.se
xxi
xxii
Software packages used for the case studies
CEQCSI Process Engineering Department, Arcelor Research J. Lehmann Voie Romaine, BP 30320 F-57283 Maizières-lès-Metz, France
[email protected]
xxiii
Member organisations of SGTE
www.sgte.org Arcelor Research Maizières-lès-Metz, France Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH Institute for Energy Research (IEF-2 : Materials Microstructure and Properties) Jülich, Germany GTT-Technologies Gesellschaft für Technische Thermochemie und -physik mbH Herzogenrath, Germany Institute National Polytechnique de Grenoble Laboratoire de Science et Génic des Matériaux et Procédés Saint-Martin-d’Hères, France Max-Planck-Institut für Metallforschung und Institut für Nichtmetallische Anorganische Materialien der Universität Stuttgart Stuttgart, Germany National Physical Laboratory Thermodynamics and Process Modelling Teddington, UK Royal Institute of Technology Department of Materials Science and Engineering Stockholm, Sweden
xxiv
Member organisations of SGTE
RWTH Aachen Materials Chemistry (MCh) Aachen, Germany Thermfact Ltd/LTEE Montreal, Canada Thermo-Calc Software AB Stockholm, Sweden Thermodata Saint-Martin-d’Hères, France The Spencer Group Trumansburg, New York, USA
xxv
Editor’s acknowledgements
I would like to express my thanks to all contributing authors without whom this book never could have been realised. Special thanks are due to those new members of SGTE who have been willing to contribute at rather short notice. I would like to thank Wajahat Murtuza Khan for his very patient and extensive help in the preparation of the manuscript. Klaus Hack
xxvi
xxvii
Dedication
This book is dedicated to Professor E. Bonnier and Dr Himo Ansara. Professor Bonnier, the first chairman of SGTE, provided tremendous enthusiasm, vision and patience during the creation, development and implementation of a European-based structure for the Scientific Group Thermodata Europe (SGTE). His wise leadership through the initial years of SGTE as a European group, first as a project supported by the French CNRS and afterwards by DG XIII of the European Community, was largely responsible for the establishment of the present wide-reaching joint activities of SGTE members. Himo Ansara was the first manager of the SGTE Pure Substance Database. He had an infectious love for the application of Gibbs energy thermodynamics to practical problems which led to the generation of valuable databases as well as to the development of fundamental Gibbs energy models for nonideal solutions. His many insights have made thermodynamics such a valuable thermodynamic tool to the materials industry for the development and optimisation of materials and processes. Their colleagues in SGTE, present and past, will always remember their contributions with affection
xxviii
xxix
Foreword
The major purpose of this book is to illustrate how thermodynamic calculations can be used as a basic tool in the development and optimisation of materials and processes of many different types. Since the first edition of this book was published in 1996, the field of ‘computational thermochemistry’ has exploded as the reliability and scope of commercial databases have grown, as software packages have been developed to cover kinetic considerations and as more scientists have become acquainted with the potential that the field offers for understanding and modelling industrial and environmental processes. The examples selected in this book are, to a large extent, real case studies dealt with by members of SGTE and their collaborators in the course of their work. SGTE is a consortium of European and North-American research organisations working together to develop high-quality thermodynamic databases for a wide variety of inorganic and metallurgical systems. SGTE has been at the forefront of the broader international effort to unify thermodynamic data and assessment methods by promoting use of standard reference data for the elements and binary systems, and generic models to represent the variation in thermodynamic properties with temperature and composition. SGTE data can be obtained via members and their agents for use on personal computers with commercially available software, to enable users to undertake calculations of complex chemical and phase equilibria efficiently and reliably. The case studies presented in the book have been treated using SGTE data in combination with such software. Members of SGTE have played a principal role in promoting the concept of ‘computational thermochemistry’ as a time- and cost-saving basis for the control and modelling of various types of materials processes. In addition, such calculations provide crucial process-related information regarding the nature, amounts and distribution of environmentally hazardous substances produced during the different processing stages. While further developments in data evaluation techniques, in the modelling of Gibbs energies of the different types of stable and metastable phases, in
xxx
Foreword
the coupling of thermodynamics and kinetics and in the scope of application software are still needed, the case studies presented in this volume demonstrate convincingly that thermochemical calculations have great potential for providing a sound and inexpensive basis for materials and process development in many areas of technology. Alan Dinsdale (Chairman)
xxxi
Introduction
‘The real raison d’être for the continuation of extensive experimental research in metallurgical thermochemistry is the potential application of its principles and data to practical, in particular industrial, problems. For this purpose the gathering of raw experimental data is obviously not enough. Missing numerical information must be supplemented by estimates … Raw data must be sifted and critically evaluated to provide for every chemical system a consistent set of thermochemical properties … In practice, it is true, the knowledge of reaction rates is as important as that of equilibrium, if not more so, but the kinetic problems can only be tackled when the thermodynamic ones have been settled. It is also true that, in practice, metallurgical reactions are quite involved … but with some effort it will be found that even complicated chemical processes may be broken up into simpler reactions which are accessible to normal thermodynamic evaluation.’ The above points are made in the 5th edition of Metallurgical Thermochemistry by Kubaschewski and Alcock in 1979 [79Kub]. Elsewhere in the same book the term databank is used, albeit in quotation marks. Most of the statements are still relevant; computer-supported calculations provide an enormous potential for the application of thermodynamic principles to the solution of practical problems. There is still the need for good estimates arising from the lack of data in certain fields of interest, and critical evaluation of raw experimental results to obtain consistent thermodynamic data sets for complete chemical systems is still of paramount importance. Nevertheless, the development of software for treating thermochemical problems has made considerable advances in the past two decades and the questions that remain open can be tackled in a much more comprehensive way. The enormous effort involved in data collection and evaluation as carried out for example by Kubaschewski for pure substance data and by Kaufman [78Kau] in the field of alloy phases is now a somewhat less arduous task because of the availability to thermochemists of the computer. This has made it possible to treat thermochemistry in a completely new way. The
xxxii
Introduction Experimental thermodynamic properties and phase equilibria
Assessment programs Gibbs energy database
←
augmented by estimation techniques based on (a) experimental trends (b) ab initio calculations
Application programs
Calculations of: Thermodynamic properties Phase equilibria Process simulation
I.1 Flow sheet of the work procedure, from data assessment to an application calculation.
computer, because of its data storage and management and its ‘numbercrunching’ capabilities, has enabled us to look at the thermochemistry of a system as a whole, i.e. in many cases the user needs nothing more than a list of elements in his system and the values of the global variables temperature, pressure and element concentrations to carry out a theoretical study. Calculations can then be made of the phases stable at equilibrium, their amounts and compositions, and even information about the degree of instability of the phases not present at equilibrium can be provided. The flow sheet shown in Fig. I.1 may be used to illustrate the work procedure entailed in the application of computational thermochemistry. The purpose of the present volume is to present some examples of such calculations and thus to demonstrate the enormous potential of this technique. The computerised databases are still limited but a considerable effort is ongoing to expand them. SGTE is making a major effort to provide comprehensive high-quality self-consistent computerised thermodynamic databases both for pure substances and for mixtures of all types and is playing a leading role in establishing methods for data evaluation and modelling of solution phases. Software for the storage and retrieval of assessed data has been developed and there are a number of application programs to treat different aspects of chemical equilibrium [70Kau, 80Bar, 83Tur, 84Sch, 85Sun, 85Tho, 85Tur, 87Bar, 88Che, 88Din, 88Roi, 88Sun, 88Tho, 002CAL].
Introduction
xxxiii
References 70Kau
L. KAUFMAN and H. BERNSTEIN: Computer Calculation of Phase Diagrams, Academic Press, New York, 1970. 78Kau L. Kaufman and H. Nesor: Calphad: Comput. Coupling Phase Diagrams Thermochem. 2, 1978, 55–80. 79Kub O. KUBASCHEWSKI and C.B. ALCOCK: Metalurgical Thermochemistry, 5th edition, Pergamon, Oxford, 1979. 80Bar I. Barin, B. Frassek, R. Gallagher and P.J. Spencer: Erzmetall 33, 1980, 226. 83Tur A.G. TURNBULL: Calphad 7, 1983, 137. 84Sch E. SCHNEDLER: Calphad 8,1984, 265–279. 85Sun B. SUNDMAN, B. JANSSON and J.-O. ANDERSSON: Calphad 9, 1985, 153. 85Tho W.T. THOMPSON, A.D. PELTON and C.W. BALE: F*A*C*T facility for the analysis of chemical thermodynamics, guide to operations, McGill University Computing Centre, Montreal, 1985. 85Tur A.G. TURNBULL and M.W. WADSLEY: The CSIRO–SGTE THERMODATA System, Institute of Energy and Earth Resources, CSIRO, Port Melbourne, 1985. 87Bar T.I. Barry, A.T. Dinsdale, R.H. Davies, J. Gisby, N.J. Pugh, S.M. Hodson and M. Lacy: MTDATA Handbook: Documentation for the NPL Metallurgical and Thermochemical Databank, National Physical Laboratory, Teddington, 1987. 88Che B. CHEYNET: Proc. Int. Symp. on Computer Software in Chemical and Extractive Metallurgy, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1988, in Proc. Metall. Soc. CIM 11, 1988, 87. 88Din A.T. DINSDALE, S.M. HODSON, T.I. BARRY and J.R. TAYLOR: Proc. Int. Symp. on Computer Software in Chemical and Extractive Metallurgy, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1988, in Proc. Metall. Soc. CIM 11, 1988, 59. 88Roi A. ROINE: Proc. Int. Symp. on Computer Software in Chemical and Extractive Metallurgy, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1988, in Proc. Metall. Soc. CIM 11, 1988, 15. 88Sun B. SUNDMAN: Proc. Int. Symp. on Computer Software in Chemical and Extractive Metallurgy, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1988, in Proc. Metall. Soc. CIM 11, 1988,75. 88Tho W.T. THOMPSON, G. ERIKSSON, A.D. PELTON and C.W. BALE: Proc. Int. Symp. on Computer Software in Chemical and Extractive Metallurgy, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, 1988, in Proc. Metall. Soc. CIM 11, 1988, 87. 002CAL Calphad 26(2), A special edition on integrated thermodynamic databank systems, 2002, Elsevier.
xxxiv
Part I Theoretical background
1
2
I.1 Basic thermochemical relationships KLAUS HACK
I.1.1
Introduction
Since the publication of Gibbs last paper [878Gib] in the series ‘On the equilibrium of heterogeneous substances’ in 1878, all terms necessary to describe (chemical) equilibrium are defined. The chemical potential had been introduced, and the relation governing the different types of phase diagram (the Gibbs–Duhem equation) had been derived. Furthermore the different work terms in what we now rightly call Gibbs fundamental equation had been discussed far beyond the contribution of chemical or electrical work and included already, e.g. the contribution of surface tension or the gravitational potential. Gibbs also stated clearly that it is only the relative magnitude of each of these terms that permits omission for practical purposes; in principle, all possible contributions are always present. Most problems dealt with in equilibrium thermochemistry are those with constant temperature and pressure and where the other work terms, except for the chemical contribution, are usually omitted. Electrochemistry, of course, can only be treated if the electrical work term is also explicitly included. It is important to keep this in mind since the entire database derived under these conditions is a Gibbs energy, rather than a Helmholtz, enthalpy or internal energy database. Problems with constant temperature and volume, for example, have thus to be treated in an indirect way, which is, of course, no problem for the computer. Using the Maxwell relations, one can easily derive a diagrammatic scheme (Fig. I.1.1) to relate the Gibbs energy in its natural variables (G(T, P)) with the other state functions and their natural variables, i.e. the Helmholtz energy F(T, V), the enthalpy H(S, P) and the internal energy U(S, V). The arrows in the scheme indicate the signs of the derivatives that one has to take of the respective state function with respect to the chosen natural variable, e.g. (∂G/∂P)T = V or (∂G/∂T)P = – S. It will suffice here to say that a complete change from one state function to another can be obtained by application of a mathematical procedure, called the Legendre transformation 3
4
The SGTE casebook S
U
H P
V F
G
T
I.1.1 Diagram representing the Maxwell relations.
[71Hit]. Such transformations have also been introduced by Gibbs himself. Equilibrium is established if the potential function of the system for the conditions chosen has reached an extremum; in the case of the Gibbs energy as a function of T, P, the mole numbers, etc., it is a minimum as expressed by the following equations: G = min or dG = 0 and d2G > 0 dG = – S dT + V dP + ∑µi dni + ∑zjFΦj dnj…
(I.1.1) (I.1.2)
with total entropy S, temperature T, total volume V, pressure P, chemical potential µ, molecular number n, charge number z, Faraday constant F and electric potential Φ. From Equations (I.1.1) and (I.1.2), two different routes for a quantitative approach to equilibrium are possible. These are described in the following two sections.
I.1.2
Thermochemistry of stoichiometric reactions
The historical route, established experimentally before Gibbs, is the method of stoichiometric reactions. For isothermal and isobaric conditions, disregarding electrical and other work terms in a system, one obtains dG = ∑µi dni
(I.1.3)
The mass balance of a stoichiometric reaction can generally be written as ∑ νiB i = 0
(I.1.4)
with ν being positive for products and negative for reactants. Thus the changes dni of the absolute mole numbers ni of the substances Bi are defined by the change dξ in the extent of reaction ξ and the stoichiometric coefficients νi of the mass balance equation, and Equation (I.1.4) becomes: dni = νi dξ
(I.1.5)
After splitting the chemical potential µ into the reference potential µ° and the activity contribution RT ln a (R = general gas constant)
µ = µ° + RT ln a
(I.1.6)
one obtains the well-known law of mass action expressed in the equation for equilibrium:
Basic thermochemical relationships
(
νi
∆G ° = Σν i µ i° = – RT ln Π a i
) = – RT ln K
5
(I.1.7)
This equation permits the derivation of most informative relations between the activities of the products and reactants: ai = func (aj, T) with j ≠ i
(I.1.8)
It should be noted that the temperature dependence of this relationship is contained solely in the Gibbs functions of the pure substances (µi° = Gi°(T)) that are involved in the reaction. However, in practice, one is usually interested in a relationship between concentrations rather than activities. The derivation of such a relation based on a stoichiometric reaction approach is perfectly feasible but is subject to two pitfalls, one mathematical, the other a chemical. Firstly, the use of numerical methods cannot be avoided except in the simple case of ideal homogeneous systems, e.g. gas equilibria. In general, one has to deal with transcendental equations and even in the simple case an auxiliary equation for the total pressure of the system has to be employed. It is, in other words, not a question of straight linear algebra. Secondly, and much more importantly, all the independent reactions in a system must be known before starting the calculation. In other words, one must either make assumptions on the complete set of independent reactions in the system or analyse these experimentally before a reasonable calculation can be carried out. Such assumptions can easily lead to simplifications with very striking differences in the results, e.g. in a phase diagram. Figure I.1.2 and Fig. I.1.3 show phase stability diagrams for Ni in sulphurand oxygen-containing atmospheres with additions of H2O(g). This is a 0 NiS
NiSO4
log pSO2 (bar)
–2
–4
NiO Ni3S2
–6
–8
Ni –20
–10 log pO2 (bar)
0
I.1.2 Phase stability diagram for Ni as a function of the partial pressure of O2 and SO2 at 873 K. Use of this diagram could give a misleading impression of the dependence of coexistence lines on log p O 2 at high and low oxygen potentials (cf. Fig. I.1.3).
6
The SGTE casebook 0 NiS NiSO4
log Σ pi mi (bar)
–2 Ni3S2 –4 NiO –6
Ni
–8 –24
–20
–16
–12 –8 log pO (bar)
–4
0
2
(a) 0 NiSO4
log Σ pi mi (bar)
–2 NiS –4 NiO –6 Ni3S2 –8
Ni –20
–10 log pO (bar)
0
2
(b)
I.1.3 Phase stability diagrams for Ni as a function of log p O 2 and log ∑ pimi, where pi is the partial pressure of each species containing S and mi is the stoichiometry number of S in species i at 873 K for two different pressures of H2O: (a) p H 2O = 10–5 bar; (b) p H 2O = 1 bar.
typical case for the application of stoichiometric reactions in the derivation of an equilibrium diagram. In Fig. I.1.2, only O2 and SO2 are considered to be important gas species, thus leading to the well-known straight line phase boundaries, whereas Fig. I.1.3(a) and Fig. I.1.3(b) show the influence of the entire equilibrated gas phase with a fixed potential of H2O. Comparison of Fig. I.1.2 and Fig. I.1.3(a) shows that, for some conditions, low p H 2 O and oxygen pressures between 10–20 and 10–4, the results are in good agreement, but outside the appropriate pressure range for oxygen the behaviour of the phases is quite different. However, if the partial pressure of
Basic thermochemical relationships
7
H2O is raised to a much higher level (Fig. I.1.3(b)), there is very little similarity left between Fig. I.1.2 and Fig. I.1.3(b) because of the severe changes in the gas phase. These cannot be taken into account if one bases all reactions on the assumption that SO2 and O2 are the only important gas species under all conditions.
I.1.3
Thermochemistry of complex systems
The above example leads directly to the second method. Equilibria in complex systems, i.e. systems with many components and many phases (some or all of which may be non ideal mixtures), can only be treated safely by minimisation of the total Gibbs energy of the system under some constraints. This requires the compulsory use of numerical methods. As indicated, computer programs for the solution of multivariable transcendental equation systems have to be developed. Now, the equilibrium condition is written as G = ∑niµi = minimum
(I.1.9)
Here the chemical potentials µi refer to the entire set of chemical species in the system, no matter whether they are, for example gas species or aqueous species and thus part of one particular phase, or condensed stoichiometric substances such as Al2O3 or CaCO3 and thus one phase each. A clearer way to write the same sum is given by putting a greater emphasis on the phases of the system. After all, it is the phases that can come into equilibrium and some species used for the description of condensed phases might well be artefacts of the model used for the Gibbs energy of the particular phase. Now
G = Σ ( ΣniΦ ) GmΦ = minimum Φ
i Here, GmΦ
(I.1.10)
is the molar integral Gibbs energy of phase Φ, and niΦ are is used. the mole numbers of the phase constituents i of this phase. Thus the inner sum refers to the respective phase amounts, and the outer sum runs over all phases. The mass balance equations ∑niai,j = bj with j = 1 to m
(I.1.11)
are subsidiary conditions and, with the introduction of Lagrangian multipliers Mj, one obtains at equilibrium the simple relationship: G = ∑bjMj
(I.1.12)
In this set of equations the ai,j are the stoichiometric coefficients of the n species i with respect to the m independent system components j (normally but not necessarily the elements), the bj are the mole numbers of the system components j, and the Mj the chemical potentials of the system components at equilibrium. Note that there are usually far more species i than system
8
The SGTE casebook
Table I.1.1 Example of a stoichiometric matrix for the gas–metal–slag system Fe– N–O–C–Ca–Si–Mg Phase
Components
System components Fe
N
O
C
Ca
Si
Mg
Gas
Fe N2 O2 C CO CO2 Ca CaO Si SiO Mg
1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 2 0 1 2 0 1 0 1 0
0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1
Slag
SiO2 Fe2O3 CaO FeO MgO
0 2 0 1 0
0 0 0 0 0
2 3 1 1 1
0 0 0 0 0
0 0 1 0 0
1 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 1
Liquid Fe
Fe N O C Ca Si Mg
1 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 1 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 1 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 1 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 1 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 1 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 1
components j (n » m) in a system. As an example the matrix ai,j for a gas– metal–slag system with the elementary components Fe–C–Ca–Mg–N–O–Si is given in Table I.1.1. It is also interesting to note that Equation (I.1.12) is a simple linear equation which defines the tangential hyperplane of dimension m – 1 to the transcendental Gibbs energy surface of the system of dimension m. At equilibrium the chemical potentials µi of the species can all be calculated from
µi = ∑ai,jMj
(I.1.13)
It is clear from the above that methods for calculation of complex chemical equilibrium require, on the one hand, models for the description of the molar integral Gibbs energy of ideal and non-ideal mixture phases and, on the other, robust and reliable numerical algorithms to solve the equation systems indicated. From Equation (I.1.10) it is obvious that for each phase an expression for GmΦ , the integral molar Gibbs energy of the phase Φ is required. Two cases can occur: either the phase is treated as a pure stoichiometric substance
Basic thermochemical relationships
9
(compound), e.g. alumina with the formula Al2O3, or the phase is a solution (mixture) with variable content of its phase components, e.g. a body-centred cubic (bcc) alloy of iron and chromium, {Fe, Cr}bcc. In the first case the Gibbs energy only needs to be known as a function of T and P, GmΦ (T, P), whereas the second case requires the Gibbs energy to be known as a function of T, P and the mole ni of the phase components, GmΦ (T, P, ni). It must be noted that for the modelling of the molar Gibbs energy it is preferable to use concentrations rather then absolute mole numbers. However, as will be demonstrated in Chapter I.2 the choice of the concentration variable, e.g. mole fraction, site fraction or equivalent fraction, is already intimately related to the Gibbs energy model used in a particular case. It may therefore suffice here to indicate that in general for solution phases the modelling requires the Gibbs energy to be described with at least the following three explicit terms: G(T, P, ni) = Gref(T, P, ni) + Gid(T, ni) + Gex(T, P, ni)
(I.1.14)
The first term contains the contribution of the pure phase components, the second term gives the contribution due to the ideal mixing of the chosen phase components, whereas the third term contains non-ideal (excess) contributions with respect to the chosen ideal mixing. For an overview of the most widely used Gibbs energy models and their mathematical representation see Chapter I.2.
I.1.4
Activities of stable and metastable phases
To obtain a better understanding of a calculation, which also includes solution phases, the following Gibbs energy diagrams for an example system A–B will be considered. The system consists of a solution phase (liquid), a stoichiometric compound AB and the pure end members A and B. The composition for which equilibria are considered has xB = 0.333. Figure I.1.4 shows the situation for an equilibrium between pure A and pure B. The linear combination of 0.6667µA + 0.3333µB = 0.6667µ A° + 0.3333µ B° represents the minimum Gibbs energy for the fixed system composition with xB = 0.333, as is given by Equation (I.1.12) G = ∑ biµi. This equation is obviously course the mathematical equivalent of the common tangent. Now it is possible to compare the Gibbs energies of the two other phases, AB and liquid, with the equilibrium Gibbs energy found. One finds that all other phases have Gibbs energies which are more positive than the common tangent line, i.e. they are not stable. One can even give a quantitative measure for the distance from equilibrium. For the compound phase AB this is a straightforward task as the Gibbs energy difference µA + µB – µAB = ∆ = RT ln a can be read directly from Fig. I.1.5. Note, however, that the diagram is for molar Gibbs energies. Thus one reads from the diagram half the value of ∆ as defined above.
10
The SGTE casebook
Gm
Liquid
° * µAB/2 µB = µ°B
µA° = µA
A
B
0.333
xB
I.1.4 The equilibrium situation between pure A and B in a binary system exhibiting the phases A, AB, B and liquid.
Gm
*
° mAB/2 mB
D (mA + mB)/2 mA
A
0.333
xB
B
I.1.5 The driving force or activity of pure AB.
For the solution phase it is slightly more complicated to find a value for ∆. As the composition in this phase is variable, there are infinitely many possibilities to calculate a difference between the common tangent and the Gibbs energy curve. However, there is only one point which is closest to the common tangent. This point is easily found by drawing a tangent to the curve which has the same slope as the common tangent (Fig. I.1.6). Now a value of ∆ (and with it the value x B′ ) can be calculated even for a solution phase. It must be noted that the interpretation of ∆ = RT ln a, i.e. as an activity, which is straightforward for a stoichiometric compound, may seem unusual in conjunction with a solution phase. The term ‘driving force’, applied to both cases, has also been suggested but so far the quantity has no unique name. Essentially, it is the amount of Gibbs energy that would have to be added to the phase to make it stable if all other conditions remain unchanged.
Basic thermochemical relationships
11
Liquid
Gm
mB
D = RT ln a
mA
xB′
A
B
xB
I.1.6 The driving force or activity of liquid.
So far the discussion has always been aimed at the stable equilibrium state, i.e. all activities are 1 or less than 1. In reality, and of course in the computations, it is quite possible to obtain states in which activities greater than one can occur. In terms of the diagrams above the consequences are obvious. The Gibbs energy value of the compound AB and at least a section of the Gibbs energy curve of the liquid phase must fall below the common tangent. Thus ∆ values greater than zero can be obtained. In reality this can occur, for example, during undercooling of liquids without human interference. A computer program, however, must be told deliberately by the user to search for such a state. All good complex equilibrium programs therefore have a facility by which the user can suppress or suspend a particular phase or even a species within a phase. Thus it is possible to calculate for example metastable extensions of phase boundaries or equilibria in systems with very strong kinetic inhibitions. Note that for the calculation of for example the non-equilibrium state of a gas mixture with H2, O2 and H2O this technique is not suitable. In this case the number of independent system components will have to be increased from 2 to 3, i.e. instead of a stoichiometric matrix of the system with three lines and two columns one now has to use three lines and three columns (Table I.1.2). In such a case, H2O is not formed by way of an equilibrium reaction from H2 and O2 but is fed into the system as an independent non-reacting further species. Table I.1.2 Change in stoichiometric matrix from free equilibrium to frozen equilibrium
H2 O2 H 2O
H
O
2 0 1
0 2 1
→
H
O
H 2O
2 0 0
0 2 0
0 0 1
12
The SGTE casebook
Such a change in stoichiometric matrix is usually not part of the equilibrium programs. However, a method for the explicit incorporation of reaction kinetic data into a general equilibrium environment based on the above reasoning has been recently designed [01Kou] as is discussed in more detail in Part III.
I.1.5
Extensive property balances
The extensive properties of a system such as enthalpy, entropy, Gibbs energy, internal energy, free energy and volume are all state functions and thus path independent. In Fig. I.1.7 the two-dimensional state space is depicted using the variables temperature and extent of reaction. It is assumed that all other variables such as pressure (or volume) of the system are kept constant. In such a representation the classical form of an extensive property balance based on a stoichiometric mass balance formula can easily be understood. The mass balance is given by ∑νrBr = ∑νpBp with Br and Bp the reactant and product substances respectively, and νr and νp their stoichiometric coefficients. In Fig. I.1.7, four different states are marked and interconnected by straight lines: I (= ∑ νr Br(Tr)) and I′ (= ∑ νr Br(Tp)) define the state of reactants at the initial temperature Tr and the final temperature Tp. II′ (= ∑ νp Bp(Tr)) and II (= ∑ νp Bp(Tp)) correspond to the products at the initial and final temperature. The straight lines indicate the two routes which are normally used to carry out an extensive property balance. Route 1 assumes that the reactants will be heated to the product temperature and then the isothermal formation reaction takes place to obtain the products. Route 2 is based on the idea that an isothermal reaction takes place at the reactants temperature and the products are then heated to their final temperature. In particular, the second route is often used to explain how an exothermal
I′
II
I
II′
Tp
Tr
0
ξ
I.1.7 Two-dimensional state space.
1
Basic thermochemical relationships
13
reaction takes place. (In the first step the reaction releases heat which is absorbed by the products in the second step; there is a clear-cut distinction between isothermal enthalpy of reaction (state I to state II′) and heat content (state II′ to state II).) However, the path independence permits any path between the initial state I and the final state II to be used, e.g. the complicated curved line, but also, and most important, the shortest possible line, i.e. the diagonal. This latter method results in a very simple mathematical expression for all extensive property balances ∆ Z (Z = H, S, G, U, F, ...). It resembles the stoichiometric mass balance
∆Z = ∑νpZp(Tp) – ∑νrZr(Tr)
(I.1.15)
From this equation it is for example possible to work out what influence a preheating, i.e. a rise in Tr, would have on ∆Z (= f(Tr)). On the other hand, an inverse question could be answered such as: what temperature will the products have if an adiabatic process takes place? For Z = H, one would have to find TP such that ∆H = 0. For a calculation of this type it is useful to employ numerical methods. There is, however, one large danger in the approach discussed above. In the mass balance, both sides need to be defined – not only the reactants but also the products! What if the reaction does not take place as assumed by the mass balance? The value of ξ could be less than 1, or worse the assumed products are not formed at all. A very good example for such a case is the simple reaction SiO2 + 2C → Si + 2CO(g). It is stoichiometrically sound but does not take place at all. Instead SiC and SiO(g) together with CO(g) will be formed in a wide temperature range. In order to avoid such a grave error it is necessary to base the calculations of the extensive property balances on the determination of the products with the execution of a complex equilibrium calculation. Only the initial state needs to be fully defined by the user in terms of the substances, their amounts and their temperature(s). The final state (TP and the products as well as their amounts) is a result of the equilibrium calculation thus avoiding assumptions. Of course it is also possible to calculate the inverse problems using such an approach. An adiabatic flame temperature can easily be carried out without prior knowledge of the resulting gas species.
I.1.6
References
878Gib J.W. GIBBS: ‘On the equilibria of heterogeneous substrances’, Trans. Conn. Acad. 3, 1878, 176. 71Hit O. HITTMAIR and G. ADAM: Wärmetheorie, Vieweg, Braunschweig, 1971. 01Kou P. KOUKKARI, R. PAJARRE and K. HACK: Z. Metallkde. 92(10), 2001, 1151.
I.2 Models and data KLAUS HACK
I.2.1
Introduction
The assessment of the thermodynamic properties of individual phases, i.e. their Gibbs energy as a function of temperature, composition and possibly pressure, is the basis for the successful establishment of a thermodynamic databank. Gibbs energy data have to be made available for phases with a wide variety of properties such as the following: –
– – – – – – –
–
Pure stoichiometric phases, e.g. metallic elements, stoichiometric oxides or gas species in their standard state. Pure stoichiometric condensed substances under a high pressure, e.g. real or synthetic geological phases or pure metals. Ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic or paramagnetic pure substances, e.g. magnetic elements or oxides. Species forming solutions, e.g. ideal or non-ideal gases or aqueous solutions. Condensed substitutional solutions, e.g. alloys with metallic components. Interstitial solutions, e.g. carbon and gases in alloys. Solutions exhibiting chemical defects, e.g. non-stoichiometric oxides or salts with differently charged ions. Solutions with several sublattices, e.g. alloys with metallic components occupying different sites of lattice or solid salts with equally charged ions. Solutions exhibiting ordering transformations, e.g. magnetically or chemically ordered alloys with metallic components.
The following chapter will give an overview of models used in the assessment of the Gibbs energies of such phases. Once the Gibbs energies are known, all other thermodynamic properties can be derived such as the following: 14
Models and data
15
molar volume V = ∂G ∂P T,n
(I.2.1)
molar entropy S = – ∂G ∂T P,n
(I.2.2)
molar enthalpy H = G – T ∂G ∂T P,n
(I.2.3)
internal energy U = G – T ∂G – P ∂UG ∂T P,n ∂P T,n
(I.2.4)
Helmholtz energy F = G – P ∂G ∂P T,n
(I.2.5)
heat capacity at constant volume 2 ∂ 2 Gm 2 ∂ Gm Cν = – T + ∂P∂T ∂T 2 P,n
∂ 2 Gm ∂P 2
T,n
(I.2.6)
heat capacity at constant pressure C P = – T ∂ G2 ∂T P,n 2
(I.2.7)
chemical potential (partial Gibbs energy)
µ = ∂G ∂n T,P
(I.2.8)
We know about the thermodynamic properties of phases through information gathered by experience or, more often, by intentional experiments. This information is formed into a physical picture or model, e.g. oscillating atoms on lattice sites with a restricted number of degrees of freedom to describe the maximum value of the heat capacity. To be able to quantify the measured properties the next step is to put the physical model into a mathematical form, which can subsequently be used for making interpolations or even predictions. Before accepting the prediction given by a model it is important to test the model by comparing a number of such predictions with experimental information already available or obtained by new experiments. Even after a
16
The SGTE casebook
successful passing of such a test it must be realised that the physical model behind the mathematical description may not give a correct picture of the real world, e.g. the description of carbon in iron or other metals as a substitutional solution. The mathematical description may thus result in incorrect predictions outside the range in which it has been tested.
I.2.2
Gibbs energy data for pure stoichiometric substances
Although the Gibbs energy is the central function, it is still customary to store and apply the data of a pure stoichiometric substance in the form of the enthalpy of formation and entropy at standard conditions (T = 298.15 K and Ptot =1 bar) as well as a temperature function of the heat capacity. The latter is integrated over temperature to derive the temperature dependence of H and S:
∫
H = H ref +
T
C P dT
(I.2.9)
CP dT T
(I.2.10)
Tref
and
S = S ref +
∫
T
Tref
The Gibbs energy is then calculated from the Gibbs–Helmholtz relation G = H – T S. Solid-state physics show that the temperature dependence of the heat capacity CV is best explained by a quantum-mechanical picture of lattice vibrations [07Ein, 12Deb]. Thus one obtains the Debye function
( )
CV = D Θ Τ
(I.2.11)
where Θ is the Debye temperature which is a material-dependent constant. Although this approach is theoretically sound and describes the heat capacity of a series of elements in their crystalline state very well, it is not suitable for assessing all experimentally known values for solid substances within their respective error limits. For a more detailed discussion see [98Hil]. Furthermore, for most applications it is not necessary to recur to 0 K as the reference temperature. Thus a system of thermochemical data has been established on the basis of the standard element reference (SER) state. As indicated above, room temperature (298.15 K) and a total pressure of 1 bar are introduced as standard conditions, and the enthalpy H298 of the state of the elements which is stable under these conditions is set to zero by convention. The entropy S298 is given by its absolute value and the heat capacity Cp, at constant pressure is described
Models and data
17
by a polynomial, commonly by the polynomial introduced by Meyer and Kelley [49Kel]: C P = c1 + c 2 T + c 3 T 2 +
c4 T2
(I.2.12)
This approach permits assessment of the thermal properties of most substances within their experimental error limits as there are sufficiently many adjustable parameters. In some exceptional cases it may be necessary to split the temperature ranges of the fit to stay within the experimental error limits. As an example, see Fig. I.2.1 for the heat capacity of O2(g). It should be noted that, instead of splitting the temperature range, some workers prefer to add further terms such as T1/2, T–3 or the inverse of these into the above equation. This has become customary particularly among geochemists [94Sax, 78Rob]. From the standard CP polynomial and the known values of ∆H298 and S298, one obtains the Gibbs energy equation as G = C1 + C2 T + C3 T ln T + C 4 T 2 + C5 T 3 +
C6 T
(I.2.13)
The coefficients Ci are now the data to be stored in a Gibbs energy databank. Note, that the first two coefficients contain contributions from both ∆H298 and CP as well as S298 and CP respectively, whereas the latter four can be directly related to the four coefficients of the standard CP equation. In this way, all properties, especially the enthalpy and entropy values at room temperature, are the result of a calculation and cannot be simply read from coefficient tables as in the standard compilations of, for example, JANAF [85Cha] or Barin et al. [77Bar]. For use in computer programs, however, there is the advantage that the above equation can be interpreted as a scalar product between a
Heat capacity (J mol–1 K–1)
44
I 24
0 RT 1000
II 3300 Temperature (K)
III 6000
I.2.1 Heat capacity of O2 (g): RT, room temperature.
18
The SGTE casebook
r r substance vector a = (C1, C2, C3, C4, C5, C6) and a temperature vector TG = (1, T, T ln T, T2, T3, 1/T). Taking the appropriate derivatives of the elements of this temperature vector with respect to T, all other properties H, S and CP can also be calculated as scalar products using the same substance vector: r r (I.2.14) Z = a • Tz with Z = CP, H, S, G Phase transitions of first order can easily be integrated into this data system, once the temperature and enthalpy of transition and the coefficients of the CP equation of the phase at higher temperature are known. The G function for the higher range is again derived from the integrals of enthalpy and entropy, but now based on the transition temperature instead of room temperature. Furthermore, the changes in enthalpy and entropy on phase transition need to be added. The standardised treatment described above has also been used for substances which exhibit magnetic (second-order) phase transitions. To be able to handle the anomaly in the heat capacity that arises in such a case (Fig. I.2.2), it was customary to split the temperature range around the Curie temperature into several small intervals such that the standard expression for CP could be used. This procedure creates an unnecessarily large number of coefficients (e.g. eight times four CP parameters for Ni) and it also causes numerical difficulties because of the unusually large values of the parameters. It is furthermore not suitable for solution phases where the Curie temperature as well as the magnetic moment depend on composition. SGTE has therefore adopted an approach suggested by Inden [76Ind1, 76Ind2] which simplifies the situation considerably.
Magnetic heat capacity (J mol–1 K–1)
30
0
0
1600 Temperature (K)
I.2.2 Magnetic contribution to the heat capacity of body centred cubic (bcc) Fe.
Models and data
19
Lattice heat capacity (J mol–1 K–1)
40
20 0
1600 Temperature (K)
I.2.3 Lattice contribution to the heat capacity of bcc Fe.
Total heat capacity (J mol–1 K–1)
60
20 0
1600 Temperature (K)
I.2.4 Total heat capacity of bcc Fe.
The magnetic contribution is treated separately, thus leaving a well-behaved curve for the non-magnetic contribution to the heat capacity which can usually be described by one set of standard parameters for the entire temperature range. For the magnetic part of CP the critical temperature (Tc, either the Curie or the Néel temperature), the crystalline structure of the phase and the magnetic moment ß per atom in this particular structure are the prerequisites. One obtains for 1 mol of magnetic element Gmagnetic = RT f T ln( β + 1) Tc
(I.2.15)
20
The SGTE casebook
f is a structure-dependent function of temperature. It is different for the ranges above and below the critical temperature (for the details of this as used by SGTE see [91Din]). Figure I.2.2, Fig. I.2.3 and Fig. I.2.4 show the two distinct contributions from magnetism and lattice to the heat capacity and the resulting total curve respectively. A further additive contribution to the Gibbs energy, which is usually ignored because of its negligibly small value, stems from the pressure dependence of the molar volume. However, recent technical developments such as hot isostatic pressing but also more detailed research in geochemical phenomena have created a need to be able to handle this extra contribution. SGTE has adopted the Murnaghan equation [44Mur] for its mathematical description. This equation uses explicit expressions for the molar V° volume at room temperature, its thermal expansion, α(T), the compressibility K(T), at 1 bar and the pressure derivative of the bulk modulus n (bulk modulus = 1/compressibility). G pressure = V ° exp
[1 + nK ( T ) P ](1–1/n )–1 α (T) dT (I.2.16) ( n – 1) K ( T ) 298 K
∫
T
with α(T) and K(T) polynomials of the temperature: α(T) = A0 + A1T + A2T 2 + A3T 2
(I.2.17)
K(T) = K0 + K1T + K2T 2
(I.2.18)
The necessary parameters have so far been assessed for a few substances, mainly metallic elements and some oxide phases of geological interest. Examples of the resulting P – T phase diagrams, are given in Fig. I.2.5 and Fig. I.2.6.
I.2.3
Conclusion
For pure stoichiometric substances the Gibbs energy is a function of only temperature and, if appropriate, total pressure: G(T, P). Different additive contributions can be treated separately. Thus one obtains Gm = latticeG + magneticG + pressureG
(I.2.19)
where latticeG depends upon ∆H298, S298 and a CP polynomial, magneticG depends upon lattice structure, critical temperature and magnetic moment, and pressureG depends upon standard molar volume, compressibility, thermal expansion and pressure derivative of the bulk modulus.
I.2.4
Relative data
If only an equilibrium state is to be discussed, it is sufficient and therefore often customary to work with relative Gibbs energies. This method is used
Models and data
21
Liquid
Temperature (K)
2500 1980 K 5.14 GPa 2000
Fcc A1 Bcc A2
1500 757 K 10.4 GPa
1000
Bcc A2
Hcp A3
500 0
10
20 30 Pressure (GPa)
40
50
I.2.5 Calculated P–T phase diagram for Fe. 2200 Liquid 2000 Cristobalite
Temperature (K)
1800
[67 Coh] [13 Fen] [78 Gra] [62 Ken] [66 Ost] [76 Jac] [76 Jac]
Tridymite 1600
1400
1200 β-quartz 1000 α-quartz 800
0
1
2
3
4 5 6 7 Pressure (108 Pa)
8
9
10
I.2.6 Calculated P–T phase diagram and experimental phase equilibria for SiO2 [94Sax].
for systems which can be treated by the stoichiometric reaction approach as well as solution phase systems. It has some advantages but great care must be taken not to confuse data from a relative scale with those based on the SER state.
22
I.2.4.1
The SGTE casebook
Advantages of the use of relative Gibbs energies
Pure substances and stoichiometric reactions As an example the simple gas system H2–O2–H2O will be discussed. This 1 system is governed by the stoichiometric reaction H2 + O2 with 2
PH 2 O ∆ G° = – RT ln K = – RT ln PH 2 PO 2
(I.2.20)
The standard method is to calculate ∆G° from the standard chemical potentials µ i° (= Gi° ) as
∆G° = µ H° 2 O – µ H° 2 – 1 µ O° 2 2
(I.2.21)
However, the same result can be obtained by postulating that the chemical potentials of the independent system components hydrogen (H2) and oxygen (O2), are identical with zero and the chemical potential of H2O is given relative to these two, i.e.
µ H° 2 ≡ µ O° 2 ≡ 0 and µ H° 2 O ≡ ∆G °
(I.2.22)
For the calculation of the equilibrium constant this postulation has no impact. Additionally, it can often be justified experimentally that ∆G° has a simple linear temperature dependence in a particular temperature range, resulting in constant values for the enthalpy change ∆H° and the entropy change ∆S° of the reaction, i.e. ∆G° = ∆H° – T ∆S°. This leads to a simple and easy-to-use thermochemical description of systems which are governed by only a few stoichiometric reactions. The experimental finding is the major reason for the relatively late appearance of generalised thermodynamic databases for pure substances. Furthermore, it is of course possible to use the simple numbers in complex equilibrium software which is based on Gibbs energy minimisation techniques. The equilibria calculated using relative Gibbs energies are the same as those calculated from SER data!
I.2.4.2
Solution phase systems
Although solution-phase systems cannot be based on a stoichiometric reaction approach, it is even for such systems customary to work with relative Gibbs energies. The thermodynamic reason is that in the equation for the molar Gibbs energy of a solution phase (Gm = refGm + idGm + exGm; see below) the first term, refGm, is linearly dependent upon the contributions of all phase constituents:
Models and data ref
G Φ = Σ X iref G Φi
23
(I.2.23)
Thus a choice of suitable reference states for each of the independent system components will only result in a linear transformation of the Gibbs energies of all phases in the system and does not affect any equilibria in the system. Graphically this can be seen from the two diagrams for the three solution phases present in the system Pb–Sn at the eutectic temperature and 1 bar pressure. Figure I.2.7 shows the Gibbs energy of the liquid, body-centred tetragonal (bct) (Sn) and face-centred cubic (fcc) (Pb) on the SER scale. Figure I.2.8 shows the Gibbs energies of the same phases relative to pure bct Sn and fcc Pb. There is of course no difference in the composition of the points of common tangency. The advantage of the relative scale representation is again found in the mathematical simplicity of the so-called lattice stabilities. For the liquid phase of the Pb–Sn system, one finds for example ref
liq liq bct fcc G liq = x Pb ( o GPb – o GPb ) + x Sn ( o GSn – o GSn )
(I.2.24)
Both terms in parentheses can again be represented by simple linear expressions in T, since only the enthalpy and the entropy of melting for the two elements are needed in the first approximation: ref
melt melt melt melt (I.2.25) G liq = x Pb ( ∆Η Pb – T ∆S Pb ) + x Sn ( ∆Η Sn – T ∆SSn )
–22000
Total Gibbs energy (J)
Liquid phase Bct A5 phase Fcc A1 phase
–32000
0
0.26
0.74
0.98
Mole fraction of Sn
I.2.7 Gibbs energy on the SER scale for 1 mol of phase (T = 454.56 K; SER).
24
The SGTE casebook 5000
Total Gibbs energy [J]
Liquid phase Bct A5 phase Fcc A1 phase
0
–5000
0
0.26
0.74
0.98
Mole fraction of Sn
I.2.8 Gibbs energy relative to bct Sn and fcc Pb for 1 mol of phase (T = 454.56 K; relative data).
I.2.4.3
Disadvantages
There are some severe disadvantages of the method of relative Gibbs energies which need careful consideration. 1
2
3
Once a data set for a system or even a complete database has been established, it is not possible to add any species or phases to this package unless the same reference state is chosen. Thus any data on the SER scale must be completed or augmented by other data on this scale. The same holds of course for data on a relative scale. Since it is possible to choose a different reference state for each class of substances (e.g. metals, salts, oxides and gases), data from two (or more) different sources need very careful checking with respect to the chosen reference state of each source before they can be combined. Combination is only possible after transformation to a common reference state! Extensive property calculations as well as property balances, especially heat balances, are normally not possible for systems which are described by relative Gibbs energies since in almost all cases the simple linear temperature dependence is chosen. However, proper extensive property balances can only be carried out if the contribution of the heat capacity is fully integrated in the Gibbs energy.
Models and data
I.2.4.4
25
Conclusion
The best possible representation of Gibbs energies is given using the SER state. Data on this scale permit any possible type of calculation. For restricted use relative Gibbs energies as discussed above may be useful. Great care must be taken when integrating relative Gibbs energies into data sets or databases which use the SER state. In particular, the application of the Neumann–Kopps rule for the derivation of missing heat capacities of compounds or phase constituents needs careful consideration.
I.2.5
Solution phases
I.2.5.1
Substitutional solutions
The properties of solutions are usually described relative to the properties of the pure substances in the same structure (ϕ) and at the same temperature: G ref = Σ x i o Giϕ
(I.2.26)
where xi is the mole fraction of constituent i. In addition at least one further term needs to be added which contains the contribution from ideal mixing: Gid = RT ∑ xi ln xi
(I.2.27)
The deviation of the real solution from this ideal solution must be described by a further additive term. It is important that the mathematics used for this term are such that they permit estimation the properties of higher-order systems from assessed data for the lower-order systems. Redlich and Kister [48Red] proposed that one should estimate the properties of a ternary solution from the three component binaries by applying the following type of expression to each binary and should evaluate the parameters by fitting to binary experimental information: ex GAB = x A x B Σ LνAB ( x A – x B ) ν
(I.2.28)
The first term in the Redlich–Kister series is xA xB L°AB and it is identical with the energy parameter in the so-called regular solution model. That model can be justified by the Bragg–Williams approach based on random mixing and a consideration of the energies of different bonds between like (AA and BB) and unlike (AB) next-nearest neighbours. The higher LνAB parameters may be regarded as describing the composition dependence of the energy parameter. If there is experimental information on the ternary solution range, this can be used to evaluate deviations from the predictions obtained by the Redlich– Kister sum for the binaries. One would first try to describe these deviations with a further regular term xA xB xC LABC or, if necessary, one may use a power
26
The SGTE casebook
series for LABC based on similar principles as the Redlich–Kister series. Experimental information from all four ternaries making up a quaternary system and from the quaternary itself is often not available. However, if that is the case, one may even introduce a quaternary regular term xA xB xC xD LABCD. The whole expression for the Gibbs energy of a solution phase can thus be given as GmΦ = Σ x i °GiΦ + RT Σ x i ln x i + Gmex,Φ
= Gmref + Gmid + Gmex,Φ
(I.2.29)
with mij
Gmex,Φ = ΣΣ x i x j Σ Lνij ( x i – x j ) ν + ΣΣΣ x i x j x k Lijk ν =0
i< j
i< j
+ ΣΣΣΣ x i x j x k x l Lijkl + . . .
(I.2.30)
i < j < k
Figure I.2.9, Fig. I.2.10 and Fig. I.2.11 show the different contributions given in equations (I.2.26)–(I.2.29). It should be noted, however, that the excess function has been chosen to be negative for clarity. This is not generally the case. In particular, systems exhibiting miscibility gaps must show positive excess Gibbs energies. Otherwise it is not possible that a Gibbs energy curve has two minima. At this point it is worth mentioning that there are several so-called geometrical models by which one can predict the excess Gibbs energy of a ternary solution as a kind of weighted average of the values for the binary solutions. Such methods have the advantage that they can even be applied to
Total Gibbs energy [J]
–70000
G ref G ref + G id G ref + G id + G ex
G ref
G id
G ex
–90000 0
1 Mole fraction of A (liquid)
I.2.9 All contributions to the Gibbs energy of a binary mixture phase for 1 mol of the liquid phase.
Models and data
27
0
Total Gibbs energy [J]
G id
G ex
G id G id + G ex –20 000 0
1 Mole fraction of A (liquid)
I.2.10 Contribution of ideal and excess term of a binary mixture phase for 1 mol of the liquid phase.
0
Total Gibbs energy [J]
G ex
G ex –20000
0
1 Mole fraction of A (liquid)
I.2.11 Contribution of excess Gibbs energy of mixing of a binary mixture phase for 1 mol of the liquid phase.
hand-drawn curves and without assessing the complete binaries. For computer calculations it is of course necessary that at least all binary subsystems be described by mathematical expressions covering the complete composition range. The most well-known methods are those by Kohler and Toop [60Koh]. A method suggested by Muggianu turns out to give the same mathematical
28
The SGTE casebook
expression as the Redlich–Kister equation used for a ternary. Pelton [001Pel] has recently given a comprehensive summary of these methods. In the above model the L parameters may be given a temperature dependence and thus they can be used to represent deviations from ideal entropy, although in a rough way only. There are more advanced theories considering deviations from random mixing of the atoms which are termed short-range order. In general, they do not yield explicit expressions for the Gibbs energy and are thus difficult to use except by numerical methods. Among the various models treating short-range order, one should mention the simplest, namely the classical quasichemical model [52Gug], later expanded by Pelton and Blander [86Pel], and a very advanced model, namely the cluster variation model (CVM), developed by Kikuchi [74Kik, 85Kik].
I.2.5.2
Partial properties for the substitutional solution
From the expression for the molar Gibbs energy of a substitutional solution, one can calculate the chemical potential for any component element i by the equation (I.2.31) µ i = Gi = ∂ G with G = Σ ni Gm ∂ni One obtains for substitutional solutions, i.e. in cases when the mole fractions are used as composition variables,
Gi = G m +
∂Gm ∂Gm – Σ xj ∂x i ∂x j
(I.2.32)
where all xj are treated as independent variables in the derivatives. It should be noted that the partial properties thus obtained do naturally obey the Gibbs– Duhem equation. Also note that the appropriate derivatives of this equation with respect to temperature yield the partial values for enthalpy, entropy and heat capacity.
I.2.5.3
The sublattice model
Now consider a solid solution where there is more than one kind of lattice site. A simple case with two sublattices and two elements on each site would be represented by the formula (A, B)a(C, D)c where a and c give the numbers of different sites per formula unit. The simplest model for such a solution would be obtained by assuming random mixing of the atoms within each sublattice. It is then convenient to define mole fractions for each sublattice. They are called site fractions and are denoted ys where the superscript s identifies the sublattice. The site fractions are used to define the frame of reference for the Gibbs energy of the solution phase. The Gibbs energy equation for a phase with two sublattices would thus be
Models and data
GmΦ = ΣΣ y i1 y 2j ° GijΦ + aRT Σ y i1 ln y i1 + cRT Σ y 2j ln y 2j
29
(I.2.33)
This is the so-called ‘compound-energy’ model [81Sun] and °GIJϕ represents the molar Gibbs energy for the compound iajc in the structure ϕ. Deviations from the ideal solution are primarily described with terms representing interactions between atoms within a sublattice. Recognising that such an interaction may be influenced by what atoms occupy the other sublattice, the excess Gibbs energy is represented by an expression GmE ,Φ = Σ y i1 ΣΣ y 2j y k2 Σ Lνi : j, k ( y 2j – y k2 ) ν j
+ Σ y i2 ΣΣ y 1j y 1k Σ Lνi , j : k ( y 1j – y 1k ) ν j
(I.2.34)
In addition, one may add so-called ‘reciprocal’ terms of the type y i1 y 1j y k2 y l2 Li,j :k,l . It was suggested that this term can give an approximate account of the effect of short-range order. It would then be negative and proportional to T (see below). It should be noted that the subscripts of the interaction parameters are constructed by separating elements on the same sublattice by a comma and elements on different sublattice by a colon. Thus i,j:k,l represents the index for interaction of components i and j on sublattice 1 with simultaneous interaction of components k and l on sublattice 2.
I.2.5.4
Partial properties for the sublattice model
The molar Gibbs energy for the (two) sublattice models discussed above is given per mole of formula units of the phase (A, B)a(C, D)c. The chemical potential of any compound that can be derived by filling the sublattices with one sublattice component each can be calculated from an equation similar to that for the simple substitutional solution. This time, however, the site fractions must be used in the partial derivatives. One obtains for example for the compound AaCc GA a C c = Gm +
∂Gm ∂Gm ∂Gm ∂Gm + – Σ y i1 – c Σ y 2j ∂y 1A ∂y C2 ∂y i1 ∂y 2j
(I.2.35)
There is no way of calculating the chemical potential of the elements from the model in this form. This is consistent with the fact that chemical potentials of elements are not defined for such a phase. They will not be defined until there is equilibrium with other phases. However, as for the substitutional solution, the temperature derivatives of the above equation yield the appropriate values for the enthalpy, the entropy and the heat capacity of the compounds. Because the compounds AaCc are major building blocks of the phase, the above method is often called the
30
The SGTE casebook
compound-energy formalism. Further applications of this formalism are briefly described below.
I.2.5.5
Interstitial solutions
In an interstitial solution an alloying element does not substitute for a host element but dissolves in interstitial sites. That kind of solution is described by considering two sublattices, the main (substitutional) sublattice and the interstitial sublattice (Fig. I.2.12). It should then be realised that the interstitial sublattice is mainly occupied by vacancies, which must be introduced as a special element. As an example, the solution of Mn and C in fcc Fe is represented by the formula (Fe, Mn)1(Va, C)1. The compound energies °GFe,Va and °GMn,Va represent the Gibbs energy of pure fcc Fe and fcc Mn, but °GFe,C and °GMn,C represent the Gibbs energy of hypothetical carbides, the values of which must be evaluated to fit the experimental information on the solution which may or may not extend to very high C contents. For cases such as TiC or NbC the situtation may actually be inverse; at equilibrium the second sublattice is mainly occupied by carbon. A small number of vacancies on the carbon site can then be used to treat the nonstoichiometry of MC1–x. From the compound-energy model, one can primarily calculate the chemical potential for compounds as shown before. For the above example, one would thus obtain
° C G Me
° C G Me
2
1
° G Me
C
° G Me
1
2
Gm
Me1
Me2
I.2.12 Schematic drawing of the Gibbs energy surface of (Me1, Me2) (Va, C).
Models and data
GFe = GFe,Va = Gm + 2 – y Va
31
∂Gm ∂Gm ∂G ∂G – – y 1Mn 1m – y 1Fe 1m 1 2 ∂y Fe ∂y Va ∂y Mn ∂y Fe
∂Gm ∂Gm – y C2 2 ∂y Va ∂y C2
(I.2.36)
but the chemical potential of the interstitial element would be obtained from the difference
GC = GFe,C – GFe,Va = GMn,C – GMn,Va =
I.2.5.6
∂G ∂Gm – 2m ∂y C2 ∂y Va
(I.2.37)
Lattice defects
The multisublattice approach can also be used for the case of phases with lattice defects, e.g. antisite atoms and vacancies. Thus the homogeneity range of a compound ‘A2B’ could be treated as (A, B)2(B, Va). The formula indicates that one has assumed antisite atoms on the A site and vacancies on the B site. The compound energies for the end members A2B (ideal compound), as well as A2Va, B2B and B2Va, would be needed. The Gibbs energies of the latter three end members can be used as adjustable parameters of the model. It should, however, be borne in mind that these energies are indirectly related to the formation energies of the defects. On the basis of the concept outlined in the previous paragraph it is obvious how interstitial defects could be integrated into this concept.
I.2.5.7
Ionic solid solutions
Ionic phases usually have different sublattices for cations and anions. There can be several cation or anion sites. If an ion of a different valency is dissolved in an ionic compound, it is necessary to maintain electroneutrality by introducing either vacancies or interstitials. The former case may be illustrated by the solution of SrCl2 in KCl which is represented by the formula (K+, Sr2+, Va0)1 (Cl–)1, where the vacant sites are assumed to be without a charge. In order to handle ionic solutions the compound-energy model needs to be combined with the condition of electroneutrality. It gives restrictions on what values are permitted for the site fractions yi. In the present case, one obtains 1(yK + 2ySr) – 1yCl = 0
(I.2.38)
A further application of the crystalline electric field (CEF) for ionic solid solutions is given by its use for the spinel phase. This is a solid oxide solution the main feature of which is the simultaneous occurrence of divalent and trivalent cations together with divalent oxygen anions. A simple formula for
32
The SGTE casebook
this phase would be Me′OMe″2O3 or (Me′)1(Me″)2O4. In this simple form a group of several divalent cations, e.g. Ni and Mg, can be accommodated on the first sublattice while trivalent cations, e.g. Cr and Al, occupy at the same time the sites of the second sublattice and oxygen occupies the third sublattice. This simple approach can even handle a case in which one element can occur in two different oxidation states, e.g. Fe2+ and Fe3+. FeO.Fe2O3, i.e. Fe3O4, would result as a pure stoichiometric compound. However, it is well known that Fe3O4 has a small but not negligible homogeneity range with respect to oxygen. This can only be incorporated into the model if defects are introduced. Even that is not a problem in the framework of the CEF. In fact, a full spinel model incorporating a good many of the elements at present known to dissolve in this phase is (Co2+, Cr2+, Fe2+, Mg2+, Ni2+, Zn2+, Al3+, Co3+, Cr3+, Fe3+)1 [Al3+, Co3+, Cr3+, Fe3+, Co2+, Fe2+, Mg2+, Ni2+, Zn2+, Va0]2 (O2–)4. One can recognise quite clearly the antisite atoms (ions), e.g. Al3+ on the first or Mg2+ on the second sublattice, and there are also vacant sites (Va) on the second sublattice which compensate for the excess charge caused by the anti-site atoms. A total of 10 × 10 × 1 = 100 compounds results from this phase formula, the majority of which are not real substances because they are composed of antisite combinations of the ions. An example is (Al3+)1(Mg2+)2(O2–)4 which carries in total one negative charge. As indicated above, the Gibbs energies of such compounds are the major adjustable parameters of the model while those of the ‘real’ compounds, e.g. (Mg2+)1(Al3+)2(O2–)4, are often already contained in the databases for pure substances.
I.2.5.8
The ideal gas
The gas phase is very often treated by an ideal model, which, however, takes into account the amounts of all species that actually exist in the gas. That is to say, there can be phase internal equilibria between some of the species. Usually, a minimisation of the Gibbs energy must be performed in order to find the equilibrium fractions of all species. The Gibbs energy is given for 1 mol of the final mixture of species and it should be noticed that the number of moles is not known until after the calculation has been performed. The expression for the Gibbs energy is Gm = Σ y i °Gi + RT Σ y i ln y i + RT ln P
(I.2.39)
and yi is used here to express the mole fractions among the species, and not among the elements. As an example, Fig. I.2.13 shows the Gibbs energy versus the composition for the H–O system at 1 bar. The variable on the composition axis was here taken as x O 2 = n O 2 /( n H 2 + n O 2 ) and for consistency the Gibbs energy was not given per mole of actual species but per 2 mol of total H and O, i.e. 2nH + 2nO. It is interesting to note that the curve has a V shape with a very sharp minimum at the position of H2O. Because of the high stability of H2O molecules
Models and data
33
Relative Gibbs energy (J mol–1)
0
∆GH° 2O
–140 000
0
1
xO2
I.2.13 Gibbs energy of the gas phase relative to pure H2 and O2 (T = 1000 K). 1
Equilibrium activities of species
H2 H2O O2
0
0
1
xO2
I.2.14 Activities (partial pressures at 1 bar total pressure) of the species in the system H2–O2 (T = 1000 K).
at T = 1000 K, there are very few other molecules at that composition. To the left of that composition there is hardly any O2 and to the right hardly any H2. This fact is further illustrated by Fig. I.2.14 showing the activities of H2, H2O and O2, where the activities are defined from the chemical potential by
µi = °Gi + RT ln ai and °Gi is the molar Gibbs energy for pure species i at 1 bar.
(I.2.40)
34
I.2.5.9
The SGTE casebook
Liquid solutions
Many models are used to represent the Gibbs energy of liquid solutions. Assuming that all the atoms mix at random with each other, one can directly apply the substitutional model. Assuming that an element with small atoms dissolves between the other atoms, one can apply the interstitial model. There are many cases where a liquid solution shows a strong deviation from random mixing. Such cases can sometimes be described by assuming that molecularlike associates form. By treating an associate as a new compound, one can again apply the mathematics of the substitutional solution model. For instance, suppose the compound A2B shows a high stability in the solid state of the A–B system. Then one may assume that A2B molecules exist in the liquid and one may apply the following expression: Gm = y A0 GA + y B0 GB + y A0 2 B GA 2 B + RT Σ y i ln y i + Gmex
(I.2.41)
where yi is used to define the mole fractions among A, B and A2B similar to those of a set of gas species. The important parameter in this ‘associated solution model’ is
∆ 0 GA 2 B = 0 GA 2 B – 2 0 GA – 0 GB
(I.2.42)
The Gm expression for this model is very similar to Gm for ideal gas. When ∆ 0 GA 2 B has a large negative value, then Gm versus composition would be very similar to the H–O case illustrated in Fig. I.2.13 and Fig. I.2.14. The associate solution approach treats short-range order in this way. Ionic liquids are composed of cations and anions. These cannot mix randomly because of local electroneutrality. Thus it is reasonable to assume that anions are surrounded by cations and vice versa. According to Temkin [45Tem], this situation can be described by introduction of two sublattices, one for the cations and another for the anions. The relative number of sites on the two sublattice now depends upon the valencies which can be illustrated by considering the liquid solution of SrCl2 in KCl. It would be represented by the formula (K+, Sr2+)P(Cl–)Q, (Fig. I.2.15). It is evident that Q/P varies from 1 for pure KCl to 2 for pure SrCl2. In the solid state there would be two quite different phases, the KCl rich solution (K+, Sr2+,Va0)1(Cl–)1 and the SrCl2 rich solution (Sr2+, K+)1(Cl–,Va0)2, while in the liquid there must be continuous transition from KCl to the SrCl2. Vacancies will in general not be required in the liquid state. (For an exception see below.) It has been proposed [85Hil] that a convenient way of defining the values of P and Q is to identify them with the average value of the ions on the other sublattice. For the liquid solution (A+, B2+)P (C–,D2–)Q, one thus obtains
– P = – 1 y C2 – 2 y D2 Q = + 1 y 1A – 2 y 1B
(I.2.43)
Models and data Va0Cl–
Cl
or
K
35
Sr
SrCl2
K+Cl–
Sr2+Cl–
I.2.15 Composition space of an electroneutral crystal.
A liquid solution between a metal and a non-metal is sometimes represented by the above ionic two-sublattice model. For the liquid Fe–O solution, one has thus used a model defined by the formula (Fe2+, Fe3+)P(Vaq–, O2–, O0)Q
(I.2.44)
The neutral O0 atoms have here been introduced in order to allow the solution to extend beyond the O content of Fe2O3. The vacancies have been introduced in order to allow the model to extend all the way to pure Fe. This is accomplished by assuming that these vacancies are not neutral but have an induced charge equal to minus the average of the charges of the cations, here
– q Va = – 2 y 1Fe 2+ + 3 y 1Fe 3+ = Q
(I.2.45)
The ionic two-sublattice model can also be applied to solutions between metals showing a strong deviation from random mixing. For instance, the liquid phase in the Mg–Sb system, which has a very stable solid phase Mg3Sb2, can be described by assuming that Mg is divalent and Sb is trivalent, (Mg2+)P(Sb3–, Vaq–, Sb0)Q. Surprisingly, the result of this model is identical with the result of the associated solution model if the associates are assumed to contain one atom of the more electronegative element, in this case Mg1.5Sb1. Molten oxides, in particular silicates, have been described with the associate solution model using neutral associates such as CaO, Ca2SiO4 and SiO2. This is equivalent to using an ionic two-sublattice model with (Ca2+)P(SiO44–,O2–, SiO20)Q. So far no particular comments have been made to the contributions of the excess function in the liquid. In general, this can be handled in the form of Equation (I.2.34) above. The reciprocal terms for systems of the type (A, B)a(C, D)b have already mentioned above. This case becomes particularly interesting for ionic liquid systems, e.g. the simple case (Na+, K+)P(Cl–, F–)Q. One can see immediately that P and Q will both be equal to one, and that the compounds are the simple salts NaCl, KCl, NaF and KF. This is, however, not a four-
36
The SGTE casebook
component system but has only three independent components. The reason for this is the exchange reaction NaCl + KF = NaF + KCl
(I.2.46)
This, however, provides not only a mass-balance constraint and thus reduces the number of free components to three but also has an effect because of its Gibbs energy change. In the present case, ∆G for the reaction is negative. The salts NaF and KCl are said to form the stable pair. In fact, if ∆G is sufficiently large, it can lead to a miscibility gap that is centred close to the stable diagonal in the reciprocal phase diagram. Blander [64Bla] proposed to derive from ∆G a value for the reciprocal term in the excess function which would be in the present case G ex =
– y Na y K y Cl y F ( ∆G ) 2 ZRT
(I.2.47)
In this equation, Z is the first-nearest neighbour co-ordination number. It is obvious that such a parameter can be derived from the pure substance data of the phase constituents involved. Even if no experimental data for the reciprocal system are available, this term can be given a value and therefore needs to be introduced. Two more liquid models should be mentioned which have also been used to describe silicate melts. One was given by Kapoor and Frohberg [71Kap] and was modified by Gaye and Welfringer [84Gay]. It treats shortrange order with a so-called cell model. The energy of formation of the cells and the energy of interaction between the cells are the adjustable parameters in this model. The other model is the quasichemical model that was first introduced by Guggenheim [35Gug]. The basic concept of this model is to use the bond energies between nearest neighbours for the derivation of a compositiondependent total Gibbs energy. In a binary system A–B there can be A–A and B–B bonds and one could envisage a formation reaction of two A–B bonds from one ‘pure’ pair each: (A–A) + (B–B) = 2(A–B)
(I.2.48)
If one now assumes two different coordination numbers ZA and ZB, one can write mass balance equations ZAXA = 2nAA + nAB
(I.2.49)
ZBXB = 2nBB + nAB where XA and XB are the overall mole fractions of A and B and nIJ is the number of bonds in one mole of solution. Introducing the mole fractions XAA, XBB and XAB for the bond pairs, one can
Models and data
37
write down a equilibrium constant for the above reaction between the bond pairs. One obtains 2 X12 – (ω – ηT ) = 4 exp X11 X12 RT
(I.2.50)
This is the reason why this model is called the quasichemical model. The basis is a chemical reaction but not for a stoichiometric substance, instead the bond pairs are the reactants and products. The XIJ can be retraced to the overall mole fractions XI by way of coordination equivalent fractions
YA = 1 – YB =
Z A XA ZA XA + ZB XB
(I.2.51)
It should be noted that the energy expression ω – ηT can be composition dependent using the overall mole fractions XI of the components. Pelton and Blander [86Pel] originally used a general coordination number Z which could not be adjusted in multicomponent systems. They emphasised that this model gives reasonable values for small deviations from random mixing only, whereas there are very large deviations in silicate melts. Nevertheless, they found that the fixed value of Z = 2 removes this shortcoming of the model and have used that value with considerable success. However, more recent developments by Pelton et al. [000Pel] have overcome the difficulty of having to fix Z. They introduced not only next-nearest-neighbour but also secondnearest-neighbour interactions and arrived at a so-called quadruplet model which is equally applicable to molten salts and oxides. In fact, it was successfully applied to modelling the molten salt phase in the cryolite–alumina system (NaF– AlF3–Al2O3) [002Cha] which implies a continuous transition from salt to oxide. This new model is much more flexible than the old model since it permits the coordination numbers to be composition dependent and the energy parameters ω – ηT to be polynomials in the bond fractions rather than the overall mole fractions.
I.2.5.10
Magnetic effects in solution phases
The general equation used for the calculation of the explicit magnetic Gibbs energy contribution has already been given for pure magnetic substances. It contains the critical temperature Tc and the magnetic moment β. For solution phases both are of course functions of the composition of the phase. This is the only difference between pure magnetic substances and solution phases. The critical temperature separates the range of either ferromagnetism or antiferromagnetism from the range of paramagnetism. That is why it is termed critical temperature rather than the Curie or Néel temperature. However, as ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism are mutually exclusive, it is possible
38
The SGTE casebook
to treat them in the same formalism. This is illustrated qualitatively in Fig. I.2.16 for the case for the bcc A2 phase in the Fe–Cr system. The continuous part shows the ‘real’ critical temperature as a function of xCr. Note that Tc must always be greater than or equal to zero! The zero point separates the ferromagnetic from the antiferromagnetic range. However, formally it is possible to calculate one continuous and steady curve by introducing ‘negative’ critical temperatures for the antiferromagnetic range. These have to be taken as their absolute values to obtain the real Néel temperature. This procedure also holds for the magnetic contributions to the Gibbs energy of the hcp phase. However, for the fcc A1 phase the situation is slightly more complex. The change from ferromagnetism to antiferromagnetism depends upon the number of nearest neighbours. For the bcc A2 phase this has no effect since the coordination number does not change upon change in the spin direction (ferromagnetic > antiferromagnetic), because bcc A2 is a symmetrical structure. For fcc A1 the situation is different since only one third of the changed spins will contribute in the antiferromagnetic range; the remaining two thirds cancel each other. Therefore a correction by a factor of one third before mirror imaging into the positive range is required. The structuredependent factor is thus defined to be 1 for bcc and hcp structures and one third for fcc structures. For a solution between a ferromagnetic and an antiferromagnetic element, Tc and β must go through zero at the same composition in order for the model to yield reasonable results. In general, the composition dependence of Tc and β may be described with the Redlich–Kister type of polynomial series. It should be noted that the magnetic phase transitions are of second order. Thus the two phase fields are normally separated by a
Curie on neel temperature (K)
1200
TC
TN 0
–400
0
1 Mole fraction of Cr
I.2.16 Curie on Néel temperature for 1 mol of the bcc A2 phase versus mole fraction of Cr in the system Fe–Cr (SGTE data used).
Models and data
39
single line, the line of the critical temperature. However, under certain conditions the magnetic contributions to the Gibbs energy lead to a normal two-phase field, i.e. first-order phase equilibria, which has the shape of a horn. This horn is named after Nishizawa who discovered this effect first (see the paper by Nishizawa et al. [79Nis]). A phase diagram exhibiting a Nishizawa horn with a continuous transition into a second-order phase boundary is the Fe–Ni diagram which is shown in Fig. I.2.17 as calculated from the SGTE solution database. A further effect that leads to second-order phase transitions results from chemical long-range ordering. An order parameter may be defined which decreases to zero at the transformation temperature and composition. Unlike first-order phase transitions which involve a change of state (solid, liquid or gas) or crystal structure (fcc, bcc, etc.) and also involve diffusion over distances large compared with atomistic dimensions, order–disorder transformations occur by atomic rearrangement over distances of the order of atomic dimensions. In order to handle such a situation in the framework of the Gibbs energy relationships already discussed above Ansara, et al. [97Ans] suggested a method similar to the method outlined above for magnetism. An explicit Gibbs energy term which describes the transition from disordered to ordered is added to the Gibbs energy of the disordered reference state.
Gm = Gmdis ( x i ) + ∆Gmord ( y is )
1800
(I.2.52)
Liquid Bcc A2
T (K)
1500
Fcc A1
1200
Tc
900 Bcc A2
Fcc L12
600
300
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Mole fraction of Ni
0.8
I.2.17 The Fe–Ni phase diagram with magnetic phase boundaries. Note the Nishizawa horn near the centre of the diagram (chemical ordering).
1
40
The SGTE casebook 2000
1800
Liquid
T (K)
1600
1400
Fcc A1
Fe2Si
Bcc A2
Fe5Si3
1200 Bcc B2 1000
FeSi 800 0
0.1
0.2 0.3 Mole fraction of Si
0.4
0.5
I.2.18 The Fe-rich end of the Fe–Si system showing the second-order phase boundary between the bcc A2 and the bcc B2 phases.
The disordered part Gmdis is in general a substitutional solution description on the basis of the mole fractions xi of the system components using a Redlich– Kister polynomial. The transformation energy from disordered to ordered ∆Gmord may be treated with the same mathematics as outlined above for the general multisublattice formalism. However, special conditions hold between the energy parameters for the second part such that the value of ∆Gmord equals zero for the state in which the site fractions y is equal the mole fractions xi, i.e. for the disordered state. A detailed analysis of these relationships has been given by Ansara et al. [97Ans]. Successful applications of this technique have been incorporated in the SGTE solution database, e.g. the transition from bcc A2 to bcc B2 in the Fe–Al and Fe–Si systems (Fig. I.2.18) as well as the transition from fcc A1 to fcc L12 in the Fe–Ni or Al–Ni system. The Fe–Ni phase diagram has already been shown above in the section on magnetic ordering. A further phase diagram exhibiting a case of fcc ordering (Au–Cu) is shown in Chapter I.3 in the section on the phase rule. For more details on Gibbs energy modelling the reader is referred to scientific journals such as Metallurgical Transactions, Chemica Scripta, Calphad, Journal of Physics and Chemistry of Solids, Journal of Alloys and Compounds, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta and Physics and Chemistry of Minerals as well as to the textbooks CALPHAD Calculation of Phase Diagrams – A Comprehensive Guide by Saunders and Miodownik [98Sau] and Computational Thermodynamics: the CALPHAD Method by Lukas et al. [007Luk].
Models and data
I.2.6 07Ein 12Deb 13Fen 35Gug 44Mur 45Tem 48Red 49Kel 52Gug 60Koh 62Ken 64Bla 66Ost 67Coh 69Ger 71Kap 73Bar 74Kik 76Ind1 76Ind2 76Jac 77Bar 78Gra 78Rob
79Nis 81Sun 84Gay
85Cha
85Hil 85Kik 86Pel 91Din 94Sax 97Ans
41
References A. EINSTEIN: Ann. Physik 22, 1907, 180. P. DEBYE: Ann. Physik 39, 1912, 787. C.L. FENNER: Am. J. Sci. 36, 1913, 331–384. E.A. GUGGENHEIM: Proc. R. Soc. A 148, 1935, 304. F.D. MURNAGHAN: Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 30, 1944, 244. M. TEMKIN: Acta Phys. Chim. USSR 20, 1945, 411. O. REDLICH and A.T. KISTER: Ind. Eng. Chem. 40, 1948, 345–348. K.K. KELLEY: US Bur. Mines, Bull. No. 476, 1949. E.A. GUGGENHEIM: Mixtures, Clarendon, Oxford, 1952. F. KOHLER: Monatsh. Chem. 91, 1973, 738. G.C. KENNEDY, G.J. WASSERBURG, H.C. HERD and R.C. NEWTON: Am. J. Sci. 260, 1962, 501–521. M. BLANDER: Molten Salt Chemistry, Interscience, New York: 1964, Chapter 3. I.A. OSTROVSKY: Geol. J. 5, 1966, 127–134. L.H. COHEN and W.KLEMENT JR: J. Geophys. Res. 72, 1967, 4245–4251. C. GERTHESEN and H.O. KNESER: Physik, Springer, Berlin, 1969. M.L. KAPOOR and G.M. FROHBERG: Proc. Symp. Chemical Metallurgy of Iron and Steel, Sheffield, UK, 1971, pp. 17–22. I. BARIN and O. KNACHE: Thermochemical Properties of Inorganic Substances, Springer, Berlin, 1973. R. KIKUCHI and C.M. VAN BAAL: Scripta Metall. 8, 1974, 425. G. INDEN: Proc. Calphad V, Düsseldorf, 1976, III.4 , pp. 1–13. G. INDEN: Proc. Calphad V, Düsseldorf, 1976, IV-1, pp. 1–33. L. JACKSON: Phys. Earth Planet. Inter. , J3, 1976, 218–231. I. BARIN, O. KNACKE and O. KUBASCHEWSKI: Thermochemical Properties of Inorganic Substances, Supplement, Springer, Berlin, 1977. P.E. GRATTAN-BELLEW: Exp. Miner. 11, 1978, 128–139. R.A. ROBIE, B.S. HEMINGWAY and J.R. FISHER: ‘Thermodynamic properties of minerals and related substances at 298.15 K and 1 bar (105 Pascals) pressure and at high temperatures’, Geol. Surv. Bull., US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, 1978. T. NISHIZAWA, M. HASEBE and M. KO: Acta Metall. 27(5), 1979, 817–828. B. SUNDMAN and J. ÅGREN: J. Phys. Chem. Solids 42, 1981, 297–301. H. GAYE and J. WELFRINGER: Proc. 2nd Int. Symp. Metallurgical. Slags and Fluxes (Eds H.A. Fine and D.R. Gaskell), Metallurgical Society of AIME, New York, 1984, pp. 357–375. M.W. CHASE JR, C.A. DAVIES, J.R. DOWNEY JR, D.J. FRURIP, R.A. MCDONALD and A.N. SYVERUD: JANAF Thermochemical Tables, 3rd edition, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 14, Suppl. 1, 1985. M. HILLERT, B. JANNSON, B. SUNDMAN and J. ÅGREN: Metall. Trans. A 16, 1985, 261–266. R. KIKUCHI and J.L. MURRAY: Calphad 9, 1985, 311. A.D. PELTON and M. BLANDER: Metall. Trans. B 17, 1986, 805–815. A.T. DINSDALE: Calphad 15, 1991, 317–425. S. SAXENA: J. Geophys. Res. 99, 1994, 11 787–11 794. I. ANSARA, N. DUPIN, H.L. LUKAS and B. SUNDMAN: J. Alloys Compounds, 247, 1997, 20–30.
42 98Hil
The SGTE casebook
M. HILLERT: Phase Equilibria, Phase Diagrams and Phase Transformations – Their Thermodynamic Basis, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1998. 98Sau N. SAUNDERS and A.P. MIODOWNIK: CALPHAD (Calculation of Phase Diagrams): A Comprehensive Guide (Ed. R.W. Cahn), Materials Series, Vol. 1, Pergamon, Oxford, 1998. 000Pel A.D. PELTON, S.A. DEGTEROV, G. ERIKSSON, G. ROBELIN and C. DESSUREAULT: Metall Mater. Trans. B 31, 2000, 651–659. 001Pel A.D. PELTON: in Phase Transformations in Materials (Ed. G. Kostorz), Wiley– VCH, Weinheim, 2001, Chapter 1. 002Cha P. CHARTRAND and A.D. PELTON: Light Metals 2002, Minerals, Metals & Materials Society, Warrendale, Pennsylvania, 2002, pp. 245–252. 007Luk H. LUKAS, S.G. FRIES and B. SUNDMAN: Computational thermodynamics: the CALPHAD Method, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2007.
I.3 Phase diagrams KLAUS HACK
I.3.1
Introduction: types of phase diagrams
Hillert [85Hil] has pointed out that what is usually called a phase diagram is derivable from a projection of a so-called property diagram. The Gibbs energy as the property is plotted along, for example, the z-axis as a function of two other variables. From the minimum condition for the equilibrium, one can derive the phase diagram of the system as a projection on to the x–y plane. This method is illustrated by Fig. I.3.1, Fig. I.3.2 and Fig. I.3.3: for a one-component system as a P–T diagram (Fig. I.3.1), for a two-component system as a T–x diagram (Fig. I.3.2), and for a three-component system as a x1–x2 diagram (Fig. I.3.3). Note that Fig. I.3.3 uses equilateral triangular coordinates for convenience only. One may draw any part of the triangular figure with rectangular coordinates.
γ α β mA
β+γ
γ
β
β
α+β
γ α+
T
γ
α α
T P
P
I.3.1 Unary system, projection from the µ–T–P diagram.
43
44
The SGTE casebook 1.0 0.5 0.0 G –0.5 –1.0 300 400 500 T 600 1.0 Ni
0.8
0.6
0.4 xNi
0.2
700 0.0 Cu
I.3.2 Binary system, projection from the G–T–x diagram.
α
°GMe
α
°GC
α
GMe α °GFe
GMeaCb °GFeaCb
α
GFe
GFeaCb α
GC Fe
b
a
I.3.3 Ternary system, projection from the G–x1–x2 diagram.
C
Phase diagrams
45
Pelton and Schmalzried [73Pel] have shown how the Gibbs–Duhem relation governs the topology of phase diagrams. The Gibbs–Duhem equation including considering all work terms is: S dT – V dP + ∑ ni dµi + ∑njzj F dΦj + … = 0
(I.3.1)
The generalisation of the different terms in the above equation leads to
Σ QiΦ dΦi = 0
(I.3.2)
One uses generalised potentials Φi which are the temperature T, total pressure p, chemical potential µi, electrical potential Φj, surface tension ∑k, etc., and their generalised conjugate extensive properties QiΦ which are the entropy S, volume V, mole number ni, generalised charge zjFnj (z is the charge number, and F is the Faraday constant), surface area Ak, etc. For each phase Φ present at equilibrium, one specific Gibbs–Duhem equation holds, since the values of the respective potentials hold for the system as a whole but their conjugate extensive properties have phase-related values. For the classification of twodimensional phase diagrams there are now only three different combinations of variable pairs available. – – –
Type 1 or potential diagrams: two potentials, Φi versus Φj. Type 2 or mixed diagrams: one potential and one ratio of conjugate extensive properties, Φi versus Q Φj / QkΦ . Type 3 or extensive property diagrams: two ratios of conjugate extensive properties, QiΦ / QkΦ versus Q Φj / QkΦ .
It is obvious that any higher-order dimensionality is governed by the same reasoning. However, representations with two dimensions are the only ones that will give quantitative results directly readable from the figure. The easiest to read are those two-dimensional diagrams which are sections of multidimensional diagrams, i.e. those for which sufficiently many parameters have been set constant. If two-dimensional projections are used, the readability usually suffers. It is worth noting that the three different types of diagram applied to a given system result in a family of figures which are interrelated by axis transformations. Each of these shows aspects that the others cannot show. Thus it may be necessary in certain cases to draw several diagrams to cover all aspects. The following examples will demonstrate this. It should, however, be emphasised that, for the generation of such a family of diagrams, only one series of calculations is required. The diagrams are generated by selecting the required axis variables from the result tables of the equilibrium calculations. For the unary system pure iron the family of diagrams is shown in Fig. I.3.4, Fig. I.3.5 and Fig. I.3.6. The potentials and their conjugate extensive properties are:
46
The SGTE casebook 2700 Liquid
2400
Temperature (K)
2100
Fcc
1800
Bcc
1500 1200 900
Hcp
600
Bcc
300 0
5
10
15
20 25 30 35 Pressure (GPa)
40
45
50
I.3.4 Type 1 diagram for the unary system Fe. 2700 2400
Liquid
Temperature (K)
2100 1800
Fcc Bcc
1500 1200 900
Negative pressures
600 300 –8.0
Hcp Bcc
–7.5
–7.0 –6.5 Molar volume (cm3)
–6.0
I.3.5 Type 2 diagram for the unary system Fe.
Φ1 and Q1,
Φ2 and Q2,
Φ3 and Q3,
T and S,
–P and V,
µ and n
The first diagram, Fig. I.3.4, is a potential or type 1 diagram using T and –P with the value of µ unspecified. It should be noted that Gibbs used this type of graphical representation in the derivation of the phase rule. The geometrical dimensionality of the phase fields (2), the phase boundary lines (1) and the points (0) is equal to the number of degrees of freedom of the respective equilibrium states. The second diagram, Fig. I.3.5, a mixed or type 2 diagram, is derived from the first by transformation of one axis. The transformation of the x-axis variable P is carried out by using the ratio of VΦ,
Phase diagrams
47
110 Liquid
Entropy (J K–1 mol–1)
100 90
Bcc
80
Fcc
70 60
Negative pressures
50
Bcc Hcp
40 30 –8.0
–7.5
–7.0 –6.5 Molar volume (cm3)
–6.0
I.3.6 Type 3 diagram for the unary system Fe.
the conjugate extensive variable for the total pressure, and n, the conjugate extensive variable of the (so far unspecified) chemical potential. One obtains VΦ/n = vΦ, the molar volume of the respective phase. In Fig. I.3.5 the resulting temperature versus molar volume diagram is shown. It has the topology of the common T–x diagram for a binary system! The triple points of Fig. I.3.4 split into eutectic- and peritectic-like horizontals and the phase boundary lines split into areas filled with tie lines parallel to the x-axis. Now the second axis, T, can also be transformed. One needs to divide the conjugate extensive property SΦ by nΦ to obtain the molar entropy S for the respective phase. This is shown in Fig. I.3.6. The three-phase equilibria split into tie triangles and the tie lines within the two phase fields can have any angle as required by the equilibrium values. From Fig. I.3.4, Fig. I.3.5 and Fig. I.3.6 it is obvious that categorising phase diagrams as unary, binary, ternary, etc., is not really of prime importance. The categories discussed here are not controlled by the number system components but are instead given by the choice of the axis variables. Two more examples will illustrate this fact in more detail. Furthermore, these examples show that it may sometimes be convenient to transform the Gibbs–Duhem relationship to obtain a set of possible axis variables which are related to experimentally more accessible quantities. The first example shows the family of phase diagrams for the binary system Fe–C after transformation of the Gibbs–Duhem equation to contain molar enthalpy and mole fractions instead of entropy and absolute mole numbers [93Hil]. One obtains
( )
µ VΦ H mΦ d 1 + m dP – Σ x iΦ d i = 0 T Τ T
(I.3.3)
48
The SGTE casebook
The resulting phase diagrams are given in Fig. I.3.7. In this series the interrelated quantities are enthalpies (of transformation), temperatures and concentrations (the total pressure is kept constant). The well-known T–x binary phase diagram is of course one diagram of the series. The second example shows the family of diagrams for a ternary system (Fig. I.3.8). The salt–water system KBr–RbBr–H2O rather than a metallic ternary has been chosen to demonstrate the generality of the method. The transformed Gibbs–Duhem equation for constant temperature (298.15 K) and total pressure (1 bar) now is [91Koe] (1 – x aq ) d(ln a kbr ) + x aq d(ln a RbBr ) +
1
M H 2 O Σm
d(ln a H 2 O ) = 0
(I.3.4) The possible relationships for the two-phase solid salt solution–water equilibria involve the chemical potentials, i.e. the activities, of the two salts
7
Liquid
Hm – HFe298.15 J mol–1
Hm – Href298.15 (J mol–1)
8
6 5 4
γ
3 2
1 E4 0 0
0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 Mole fraction of C
10 9 8 7 6
5 δ Cementite 4 3 2 1 0 –10 –8 –6 –4 –2 0 µC–°HC (298.15) (J mol–1)
(a)
1500 1400 1300 1200 1100 1000
(b)
δ Liquid γ
900 α 800 700 600 0 1
Cem
2
3 4 5 C (wt%) (c)
6
7
8
Temperature (°C)
Temperature (°C)
1600
Liquid
1600 δ 1500 1400 1300 1200 1100 γ 1000 900 800 α 700 600 0 0.5
Liquid
Cementite
1.0 1.5 Activity of C (d)
I.3.7 Phase diagram family for the binary system Fe–C.
1
Phase diagrams –0.21
49
–0.21
–0.22
–0.22
ln a(H2O)
ln a(H2O)
aq –0.23 –0.24
–0.23 –0.24
S –0.25
–0.25
–0.26 –2
–1.5
–1 –0.5 ln a(RbBr)
0
–0.26 0
0.2
0.8
1
0.8
1
II
10
10
8
8
1/(M(H2O) Σ m)
1/(M(H2O) Σ m)
I
0.4 0.6 x(RbBr)
6 4 2
6 4 2
0 –2
–1.5
–1 –0.5 ln a(RbBr) II
0
0
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 x(RbBr) III
I.3.8 Phase diagram family for the ternary system KBr–RbBr–H2O.
and water as well as the concentrations. For the latter the most convenient units have been chosen, i.e. the mole fractions in the binary solid salt solution and the molality for the aqueous phase. Königsberger and Gamsjäger [91Koe] have pointed out that the type 3 diagram of this series, 1/ M H 2 O Σm versus xRbBr, i.e. the typical ternary diagram with tie lines at variable angles with respect to the diagram’s axes, is equivalent to what has been called a Jänecke [06Jän] diagram among aqueous chemists for decades. The above three series of phase diagram families show that the thermodynamic equilibrium rules permit many possible representations. It is thus up to the user to decide from which type of plot most information can be gained. A unary extensive property (type 3) diagram is certainly more useful when the general principle has to be explained and is hardly related to any experiment or process, whereas the same type of figure for a fivecomponent alloy can give very useful answers to real-world engineering problems. For systems with more than three components it is, however, necessary to generalise the topological rules even further.
50
The SGTE casebook
In most cases, multicomponent phase relationships can best be represented by type 2 or type 3 diagrams. However, the restriction to two dimensions requires sections through (or projections of) a multidimensional space to be drawn. Figure I.3.14 (see below) shows such a section for the system Fe–Cr– C–W for T = 1123 K, P = 1 bar and 0.2 wt% C with the weight percentage of Cr and W as axis variables. It is obvious that such a section cannot be read with the rules applicable to the extensive property (type 3) diagrams discussed so far. It is highly unlikely that any tie line or tie triangle between the possible phase lies within the chosen two-dimensional space. Some new aspects have to be introduced to make proper use of diagrams such as Fig. I.3.14 below. These will be discussed in the following section.
I.3.2
Zero-phase-fraction lines
Masing [44Mas] stated in 1944 that ‘a state space can ordinarily be bounded by another state space only if the number of phases in the second space is one less or one greater than that in the first space considered’. Palatnik and Landau [64Pal] have added in the 1950s a series of papers about the dimensionality of phase boundaries from which comes the law of adjoining phase regions: R1 = R – D – – D + ≥ 0
(I.3.5)
In this, R1 is the dimension of the phase boundary, R is the dimension of the phase diagram (this may also be a section, isothermal or isopleth) and D– and D+ represent the number of disappearing and appearing phases respectively when crossing the phase boundary. For two-dimensional diagrams, as discussed here, R = 2. For the boundaries, one will therefore obtain either a dimension of 1, i.e. a line, or a dimension of 0, i.e. a point, because R1 ≤ R – 1, as was shown by Prince [66Pri]. These are of course all topological elements possible in a two-dimensional figure. Recently Morral and co-workers [84Bra, 84Mor, 86Gup] have published a series of papers in which they introduced the concept of zero-phase-fraction (ZPF) lines and thus add to the lines and points discussed so far one very useful aspect. This will be illustrated by the following series of figures: Fig. I.3.9, Fig. I.3.10 and Fig. I.3.11. Consider an isothermal section of a ternary phase diagram for the system A–B–C with the three terminal solution phases α, β and γ (Fig. I.3.9). What one usually does is to draw the lines around the phase regions of the pure phases, and to add the tie lines between the phase boundaries as well as the tie triangle around the three-phase region. From the tie lines, one can obtain information which is usually considered of importance: the amount of the phase present in the two- or three-phase equilibrium. This is given by the lever rule and can be read directly from Fig.
Phase diagrams
51
C
γ
β
α A
B
I.3.9 Conventional representation of an isothermal section for a ternary system (extensive property (type 3) diagram). C
γ
β=0
. γ = α = 50 mol%
β° = γ = 50 mol%
γ=0 β
α A
B . β° = α = 50 mol%
α=0
I.3.10 The lines of 50 and 0 mol% of the respective phases.
I.3.3. Drawing the lines for 0 and 50 mol% the next figure, Fig. I.3.10, is obtained. The most interesting lines are those for the zero phase amount (or fraction). These lines show for each phase, one by one, the composition range in which they can exist, notwithstanding whether alone or together with others. The major point here is that they do not exclude the other phases such as the lines marked in Fig. I.3.9 but include them as they may occur. Seen from the other side, the lines indicate the range in the diagram in which a particular phase does not exist. For the α phase for example, one obtains the ZPF line shown in Fig. I.3.11.
52
The SGTE casebook C
No α
α + others A
B
I.3.11 The ZPF line for the α phase. Outside
fα = 0
Others Inside α + others
I.3.12 The inside–outside property of a ZPF line. fα = 0
β + others
α + β + others
Others
α + others
fβ = 0
I.3.13 The intersection of two ZPF lines.
This aspect was not explicitly included in the considerations of Masing or of Palatnik and Landau or in Prince’s interpretation thereof but helps considerably to understand a diagram such as Fig. I.3.14 given below, as the inside–outside property relates the lines and phases in a diagram in pairs (Fig. I.3.12) When two such lines meet, they simply intersect, i.e. to follow the line of a particular phase means to go straight through the crossing. At the crossing, the law of adjoining phase regions holds for the four lines and the point of intersection. This is shown in Fig. I.3.13.
Phase diagrams
53
18 16
α + M23C6 + λ
α + M6C + λ 14
W (wt%)
12
α + M6C
10 8
α = γ + M6C α + M6C + M23C6
6 4
γ + M6C
α + M23C6
2 0 0
γ + M23C6
γ 3
6
9 Cr (Wt%)
12
15
I.3.14 Marked ZPF lines in the Fe–W–Cr–C system with 0.2 wt% C and T = 1123 K.
One further property of ZPF lines can be understood from Fig. I.3.11: ZPF lines begin and end on the diagram axes or else form a closed loop within the diagram. Knowing these properties one can now draw Fig. I.3.14, considering all lines as ZPF lines.
I.3.2.1
Special cases of zero-phase-fraction intersections
The more complex a system is, i.e. the more components and phases it has, the more likely it is that the rules outlined above are sufficient to understand the calculated two-dimensional phase diagrams. However, there are some exceptions which occur and which have to be discussed to prevent misunderstandings. Luckily, the exceptions occur in well-understood systems. The general case is that four lines meet at a point and that the law of adjoining phase regions holds. Both the rules seem to be violated in a simple binary eutectic system, as shown in Fig. I.3.15. At the points A and C, only three lines meet and, at point B, going from the liquid one-phase region into the solid two-phase region, the number of phases changes from one to two instead of three. This result stems from the fact that the three-phase field A–(B)–C is what Prince calls a degenerate phase region. Instead of one line there are really three, A–B, B–C and A–C, separating the three phase region α–liquid–β from the respective two-phase
54
The SGTE casebook
Liquid
T
α
A
B
C
β
x
I.3.15 Simple binary eutectic system.
Liquid α + liquid
Liquid + β
α + liquid + β
T α
α+β
β
x
I.3.16 Exaggerated plot of the three-phase α–liquid–β region in a binary eutectic system.
regions. An exaggerated drawing with a finite angle between the lines shows this very clearly (Fig. I.3.16). Now there are only points at which four lines meet and, at point B, going down from the one-phase region, one obtains three phases in accordance with the law of adjoining phase regions. Palatnik and Landau [64Pal] have already pointed out that there are some other exceptions which they called nodal plexi. These may result in six or eight lines meeting at a point. The classification of these nodal plexi has been given by Palatnik and Landau. For further details the reader is referred to the monograph Alloy Phase Equilibria by Prince [66Pri].
Phase diagrams
I.3.2.2
55
Conclusions on zero-phase-fraction lines
From the above, one may conclude that the concept of ZPF lines provides a useful basis in several ways: 1 2
3
For the programmer, because she or he can use the features of ZPF lines to derive algorithms for what is called two-dimensional phase mapping. For the reader of computer-generated multicomponent two-dimensional diagrams, because they provide a ‘read thread’ for each phase contained in the figure. For the experimentalist, because he or she can use the properties of ZPF lines to derive a first diagram from his or her experimental phase equilibria before a computer calculation is possible [84Mor].
I.3.3
Beyond classical phase diagrams
In this section it will be shown how very familar diagrams show new and extended features when regenerated using the latest calculational techniques for phase diagrams. Some cases will be discussed now. Almost every ferrous metallurgist knows what is called the Baur–Glässner diagram [03 Bau]. In this diagram the stability ranges of the various phases in the Fe–O system are shown with the temperature on one axis and the molar ratio of CO and CO2 or the appropriate mole fraction on the other. The major condition in this approach is that the indeed very small oxygen potential can be expressed by the more ‘tangible’ values of CO and CO2 because of the homogeneous gas equilibrium CO + 12 O2 = CO2. In fact, the Boudouard reaction (C + CO2 = 2CO), which is important too, is also taken account of by plotting the appropriate equilibrium line as an overlay into the diagram. In Fig. I.3.17, Fig. I.3.18 and Fig. I.3.19, diagrams are shown which relate to the classical situation described above. They have, however, been generated using the technique of ZPF line calculations. In Fig. I.3.17, all Fe–O phase boundaries are shown disrespecting the Boudouard equilibrium and using pure substance data for solid and liquid Fe as well as for solid and liquid oxides. The well-known hay-fork topology between the metallic phases on the one side and the oxides Fe3O4 and FeO is clearly recognisable in the diagram. It must, however, be noted that this diagram can only be generated by suppressing the graphite phase from all equilibria. Also phase boundaries with the gas phase have been ignored. In other words, the phase diagram contains many metastable phase boundaries. Figure I.3.18 shows the phase diagram for the case when graphite and gas both are permitted to become stable phases in the system. Note, however, that all condensed phases are still treated as stoichiometric pure substances. In the range of lower temperatures’ one can now see how the formation of stable graphite overrides the Fe–Fe3O4 phase boundary shown in Fig. I.3.17.
56
The SGTE casebook 2000 Fe3O4(l) + gas
Fe(l) + gas FeO(l) + gas Gas + Fe(s)
1680
1360
Gas + FeO(s)
T (K)
Gas + Fe(s2)
Gas + Fe3O4(s2)
1040
Gas + Fe(s)
720
Gas + Fe3O4(s)
400 0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Mole fraction CO2 /(CO + CO)
0.8
1
I.3.17 Phase diagram for P = 20 atm and mole Fe/(CO+CO2) = 0.000 01. 2000 Fe3O4 (l) + gas Gas 1680
FeO(l) + gas
Gas + Fe(bcc)
Gas + Fe(bcc) 1360
T (K)
Gas + C + Fe(fcc)
Gas + FeO(s)
Gas + Fe(bcc) 1040
Gas + C + Fe(bcc) Gas + C + FeO Gas + C + Fe3O4(s2)
Gas + Fe3O4(s2)
Gas + Fe3O4(s1)
720 Gas + C + Fe(s1) 400
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Mole fraction CO2/(CO + CO)
0.8
1
I.3.18 Phase diagram for P = 3 atm and mole Fe/(CO+CO2) = 0.000 01.
It must be noted that in order to obtain Fig. I.3.18 it is necessary to fix the total pressure which was given an arbitrary value of 3 atm. Thus the position of the Boudouard curve has also been fixed arbitrarily. It would shift on
Phase diagrams
57
change in the total pressure. Likewise the phase boundaries between gas and Fe(bcc) as well as gas and FeO(l) will shift with total pressure. Note furthermore that the Boudouard line is not an overlay as in the classical Baur–Gläsner diagrams. It is indeed a true phase boundary in this figure. An additional interesting side effect resulting from the present setting for the pressure is that no range of stability of liquid Fe is found. For the lower temperature range, Fig. I.3.18 represents the real equilibria quite well since the solubility of carbon in Fe is almost negligible. Also Fe3O4 may be treated as stoichiometric for these temperatures. However, when the temperature exceeds that of the α–γ transition of Fe the situation changes considerably since the solubility of C in γ–Fe is not negligible. Also liquid Fe can dissolve large amounts of C, not to mention the lowering of the stability temperature of the melt by the dissolution of the carbon. Furthermore wustite is not a stoichiometric compound and liquid iron oxide (slag) has a wide composition range. Thus, for a proper Baur–Glässner diagram, solid and liquid solutions need to be considered in the calculation. The resulting phase diagram is shown in Fig. I.3.19. It can be seen immediately that there are considerable changes in the phase boundaries on the CO-rich side of the phase diagram. The solubility of C in the condensed Fe phases now leads to phase boundaries that are dependent upon both the temperature and the mole fraction of CO2. Furthermore, the size and shapes of the phase fields of both the wustite and the liquid oxide (slag) are different from the respective phase fields in Fig. I.3.18 because of the wide homogeneity ranges of these phases. Figure I.3.19 should also be used to give a better understanding of the calculations as such. For all phase fields above the Boudouard line the mole fraction of CO2 can be read from the x-axis. Because above this line C does not precipitate from the gas, only the reaction CO + 12 O2 = CO2 is relevant. Since the amount of Fe that was chosen as an input parameter for the calculation is 10–5 mol per mole of gas, there is no significant loss of oxygen from the gas phase on formation of the iron oxides, and thus the mole fraction of CO2 is a direct measure for the oxygen potential at a given point in the diagram. The small amount of Fe also leads to only a small loss of C from the gas phase in the stability ranges of the Fe-based condensed solution. Thus the CO2 mole fraction read from the x-axis is identical with that in the gas phase for these ranges too. As an illustration of this behaviour of the system, two equilibrium tables are given. Table I.3.1 shows the equilibrium at the position of the label in the phase field for wustite. The overall amounts of CO and CO2 respectively shown in the top part of the table are identical with those in the calculated equilibrium gas phase. In Table I.3.2 is shown an equivalent calculation for the position of the label in the spinel (magnetite) plus carbon (+ gas) phase field. Comparison of the data for CO and CO2 with the values for the gas phase shows clearly that these are different from each other.
58
The SGTE casebook 2000 Gas Liquid + Fe + gas Bcc + gas
1680
1360
Slag–liquid + gas
Monoxide + gas
T (K)
Gas + fcc Gas + C + fcc Monoxide + gas
1040
Spinel + gas
720 Spinel + gas + C 400
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Mole fraction CO2/(CO + CO2)
0.8
1
I.3.19 Phase diagram for P = 3 atm and mole Fe/(CO+CO2) = 0.000 01.
Because of the finite amount of carbon formed in this phase field the CO2 mole fraction in the equilibrium state is not equal to that read from the x-axis. Now let us consider the case of an aqueous system. Classically such systems are depicted in Pourbaix diagrams, i.e. predominance area diagrams with the potential Eh of the half-cell H+(aq) + e– = 12 H2 plotted as the y-axis while on the x-axis the pH value of the system is represented. This type of diagram has been used successfully in Pourbaix’s atlas [63Pou] for the comparison of very many metal–aqueous systems. Compared with one another these diagrams give very useful information on the relative stabilities of metals in aqueous environments. For practical purposes, however, they are not so easy to use since, on the one hand, fixing the Eh value of a system can only be achieved indirectly by controlling either the O2 or the H2 partial pressure in the gas phase of the system and, on the other hand, controlling the pH of the system can also not be performed directly, i.e. by adding H+ ions, but only by adding an acid or a base, i.e. real substances, to the system. Thus a metal–water system is in practice investigated by setting up a metal– water–acid–base–H2 (or O2) system. For the purpose of this discussion the system Cu–H2O–HCl–NaOH–H2 was chosen. The phase diagram shown in Fig. I.3.20 was calculated using the following conditions. 1
A total of 1 mol of acid–base mixture with a variable mole fraction is entered for definition of the x-axis.
Phase diagrams
59
Table I.3.1 Equilibrium table for composition and temperature given by the position of the label “monoxide + gas” in Fig. 3.19 T(K) = 587.7, mole CO2/(CO+CO2) = 0.4486 T = 587.69 K P = 3.00000E+00 atm V = 1.16460E+01 dm3 STREAM CONSTITUENTS Fe CO CO2
AMOUNT/mol 9.9999E-06 5.5138E-01 4.4861E-01
PHASE: gas_ideal CO2 CO C3O2 Fe(CO)5 Fe O2 TOTAL:
EQUIL AMOUNT mol 7.2410E-01 3.7629E-04 9.0366E-25 7.1654E-34 6.1201E-34 5.4116E-36 7.2448E-01
MOLE FRACTION 9.9948E-01 5.1940E-04 1.2473E-24 9.8904E-34 8.4475E-34 7.4696E-36 1.0000E+00
FUGACITY atm 2.9984E+00 1.5582E-03 3.7420E-24 2.9671E-33 2.5343E-33 2.2409E-35 1.0000E+00
PHASE: FCC_A1 Fe:C Fe:Va TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 1.1003E-03 9.9890E-01 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 4.0133E-11 4.3277E-05 4.3325E-05
PHASE: BCC_A2 Fe:C Fe:Va TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 2.8154E-08 1.0000E+00 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 2.0980E-37 7.8983E-05 7.8983E-05
PHASE: Fe-LIQUID Fe C O TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 6.7414E-01 3.2586E-01 2.4778E-06 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 7.0465E-06 7.1598E-10 2.8077E-08 9.1665E-05
PHASE: Slag-liq FeO Fe2O3 TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 3.5358E-01 6.4642E-01 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 6.3908E-04 2.4595E-06 2.7156E-03
PHASE: Spinel Fe3O4 Fe3O4[1-] Fe3O4[1+] Fe3O4[2-] Fe1O4[5-] Fe1O4[6-] TOTAL:
mol 5.3091E-08 1.5652E-06 1.6651E-06 4.9908E-08 4.6572E-22 1.4849E-23 3.3333E-06
MOLE FRACTION 1.5927E-02 4.6958E-01 4.9952E-01 1.4973E-02 1.3972E-16 4.4549E-18 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 3.7409E-02 2.3802E-02 2.5681E-01 4.2537E-05 2.8122E-24 5.1596E-27 1.0000E+00
60
The SGTE casebook
Table I.3.1 (Continued) PHASE: Monoxide FeO Fe2O3 TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
C_graphite
mol 2.7551E-01
Cp_EQUIL J.K-1 3.86600E+01
H_EQUIL J -2.75038E+05
MOLE FRACTION 6.8987E-01 3.1013E-01 1.0000E+00
S_EQUIL J.K-1 1.72852E+02
ACTIVITY 3.7926E-02 3.3535E-06 1.2759E-01 ACTIVITY 1.0000E+00
G_EQUIL J -3.76621E+05
V_EQUIL dm3 1.16460E+01
Mole fraction of sublattice constituents in FCC_A1: Fe 1.0000E+00 Stoichiometry = 1.0000E+00 C 1.1003E-03 Stoichiometry = 1.0000E+00 Va 9.9890E-01 Magnetic properties for FCC_A1: Neel temperature = 67.00 K Average magnetic moment/atom = 7.0000E-01 Mole fraction of sublattice constituents in BCC_A2: Fe 1.0000E+00 Stoichiometry = 1.0000E+00 C 2.8154E-08 Stoichiometry = 3.0000E+00 Va 1.0000E+00 Magnetic properties for BCC_A2: Curie temperature = 1043.00 K Average magnetic moment/atom = 2.2200E+00 Mole fraction of sublattice constituents in Spinel: 3.0900E-02 Stoichiometry = 1.0000E+00 Fe[2+] Fe[3+] 9.6910E-01 4.8455E-01 Stoichiometry = 2.0000E+00 Fe[2+] Fe[3+] 5.1545E-01 Va[0] 1.4417E-16 Magnetic properties for Spinel: Curie temperature = 848.00 K Average magnetic moment/atom = 4.4540E+01
2 3 4 5 6
The partial pressure H2 is used for the y axis. 55.508 mole of water, i.e. 1 kg, is set as a constant. A constant molar amount relative to the given water amount is entered as the molality of the metallic component. The temperature is set to 25 °C. The total pressure is set equal to 1 atm.
Phase diagrams
61
Table I.3.2 Equilibrium table for composition and temperature given by the position of the label “spinel + gas + C” in Fig. 3.19 T(K) = 1342, mole CO2/(CO+CO2) = 0.5569 T = 1341.54 K P = 3.00000E+00 atm V = 3.66942E+01 dm3 STREAM CONSTITUENTS Fe CO CO2
AMOUNT/mol 9.9999E-06 4.4305E-01 5.5694E-01
PHASE: gas_ideal CO2 CO Fe FeO O2 TOTAL:
EQUIL AMOUNT mol 5.5693E-01 4.4306E-01 3.3516E-10 1.2855E-12 5.8846E-14 9.9999E-01
MOLE FRACTION 5.5693E-01 4.4307E-01 3.3516E-10 1.2855E-12 5.8847E-14 1.0000E+00
FUGACITY atm 1.6708E+00 1.3292E+00 1.0055E-09 3.8566E-12 1.7654E-13 1.0000E+00
PHASE: FCC_A1 Fe:C Fe:Va TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 5.1884E-04 9.9948E-01 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 5.8284E-06 2.5050E-01 2.5063E-01
PHASE: BCC_A2 Fe:C Fe:Va TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 2.2610E-05 9.9998E-01 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 3.4281E-25 2.4889E-01 2.4891E-01
PHASE: Fe-LIQUID Fe C O TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 9.8101E-01 1.3363E-02 5.6292E-03 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 1.8266E-01 1.8206E-06 1.1212E-03 1.8635E-01
PHASE: Slag-liq FeO Fe2O3 TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 8.9264E-01 1.0736E-01 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 4.9991E-01 2.5805E-03 5.1776E-01
PHASE: Spinel Fe3O4 Fe3O4[1-] Fe3O4[1+] Fe3O4[2-] Fe1O4[5-] Fe1O4[6-] TOTAL:
mol 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00 0.0000E+00
MOLE FRACTION 1.7712E-01 2.6112E-01 4.6154E-01 1.0021E-01 5.1600E-08 1.9802E-08 1.0000E+00
ACTIVITY 5.3624E-02 3.7564E-02 8.5771E-02 5.6105E-03 2.0080E-15 3.0005E-16 3.2761E-01
62
The SGTE casebook
Table I.3.2 (Continued) PHASE: Monoxide FeO Fe2O3 TOTAL: C_graphite Cp_EQUIL J.K-1 4.73776E+01
mol 8.1193E-06 9.4015E-07 9.0594E-06 mol 0.0000E+00
H_EQUIL J -2.24128E+05
MOLE FRACTION 8.9622E-01 1.0378E-01 1.0000E+00
S_EQUIL J.K-1 2.63995E+02
G_EQUIL J -5.78287E+05
ACTIVITY 8.2982E-01 2.3861E-04 1.0000E+00 ACTIVITY 3.4955E-03 V_EQUIL dm3 3.66942E+01
Mole fraction of sublattice constituents in FCC_A1: Fe 1.0000E+00 Stoichiometry = 1.0000E+00 C 5.1884E-04 Stoichiometry = 1.0000E+00 Va 9.9948E-01 Magnetic properties for FCC_A1: Neel temperature = 67.00 K Average magnetic moment/atom = 7.0000E-01 Mole fraction of sublattice constituents in BCC_A2: Fe 1.0000E+00 Stoichiometry = 1.0000E+00 C 2.2610E-05 Stoichiometry = 3.0000E+00 Va 9.9998E-01 Magnetic properties for BCC_A2: Curie temperature = 1043.00 K Average magnetic moment/atom = 2.2200E+00 Mole fraction of sublattice constituents in Spinel: Fe[2+] 2.7734E-01 Stoichiometry = 1.0000E+00 Fe[3+] 7.2266E-01 3.6133E-01 Stoichiometry = 2.0000E+00 Fe[2+] Fe[3+] 6.3867E-01 Va[0] 7.1402E-08 Magnetic properties for Spinel: Curie temperature Average magnetic moment/atom
= =
848.00 K 4.4540E+01
It should be noted that an increasing partial pressure of H2 on the y-axis is inverse to the classical Eh value while an increase in the mole fraction of the basic component of the acid–base pair defines the same direction along the x axis as an increase in pH. It must also be noted that the resulting diagram is a true phase diagram, i.e. the stability fields relate to the stable phases at equilibrium and not to particular species, be they stable solids or species in
Phase diagrams
63
0
Cu(s) + aqueous –12
2
log10 [p(H ) (bar)]
–6
Aqueous
–18
–24
–30
Cu2O(s) + aqueous
Cu (OH)2 (s) + aqueous
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Mole fraction NaOH/(HCl + NaOH
0.8
1
I.3.20 Phase diagram for T = 25 °C, mole H2O/(HCl+NaOH) = 55.508 and mole Cu/(HCl+NaOH) = 0.001.
the aqueous phase. The diagram therefore shows on the lower left (high acidity and low H2 potential) the field of stability of the single-phase water equilibrium while at higher mole fractions of NaOH, i.e. high basicity and thus high pH, the precipitations of copper hydroxide, copper oxide and copper metal occur with increasing H2, i.e. decreasing Eh. This is all in accord with the classical Pourbaix diagram for copper. However, on increase in the molality of Cu as shown in Fig. I.3.21, additional reactions occur in this system. When increasing the molality from 0.001 to 0.1 the phase diagram shows that the use of a real acid, here HCl, instead of an assumed pH value, leads to additional phase fields because CuCl can coprecipitate with copper hydroxide, copper oxide or copper metal or can even precipitate as a single solid from the aqueous phase. Such effects can never be realised in Pourbaix diagrams since the anion of the acid and the cation of the base are not entered explicitly into the method of calculation. On the other hand, the method described above can immediately be used to generate a diagram with the same axes as a Pourbaix diagram. For any point in diagrams such as Fig. I.3.20 or Fig. I.3.21 the value of Eh and pH is known. Therefore a simple axis transformation, i.e. different choice of x- and y-axis variables for the plot, will lead to a diagram as shown in Fig. I.3.22. This diagram is the Pourbaix-axes equivalent to Fig. I.3.20. It is clear from Fig. I.3.20 that this new diagram will also only show true phase boundaries; there are no equilibrium lines with single species in the one, and so there cannot be such lines in the other.
64
The SGTE casebook 0
Cu(s) + aqueous
log10 [(pH2) (bar)]
–6
Cu(s) + CuCl(s) + aqueous
–12
CuCl(s) + aqueous Cu2O(s) + CuCl(s) + aqueous
–18
Cu2O(s) + aqueous
Cu(OH)2(s) + CuCl(s) + aqueous –24
–30
Aqueous
0
0.2
Cu (OH)2 (s) + aqueous
0.4 0.6 Mole fraction NaOH/(HCl + NaOH)
0.8
1
I.3.21 Phase diagram for T = 300 K, mole H2O/(HCl+NaOH) = 55.508 and mole Cu/(HCl+NaOH) = 0.1.
0.65 0.55 Cu2+ 0.45 aqueous 0.35 0.25
Eh
Cu(OH)2 + aqueous
Cu 2 O( s)
0.15 0.05
Cu
2O
–0.05
+a
que
ous
–0.15 –0.25 Cu + aqueous –0.35 –0.45 –0.55 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7 pH
8
9
10
11
12
13
I.3.22 Eh versus pH plot derived from the phase diagram; the figure from the Eh–pH module is overlayed.
14
Phase diagrams
65
For comparison the predominance fields of a classical Pourbaix diagram are overlayed in this figure (thin lines). It is obvious that the line of ‘equilibrium’ between the Cu2+ aqueous ion and the metallic copper is not a true phase boundary, and also parts of the Cu–Cu2O and Cu2O–Cu(OH)2 coexistence lines of the Pourbaix diagram are not true phase boundaries. All these lines extrapolate into the region of stability of the aqueous phase when the phase boundaries are calculated considering all aqueous species and the stoichiometric solids simultaneously. Finally two phase diagrams for combustion systems with variable C–H–O ratios will be considered. A Gibbs triangular plot for an isothermal representation of the equilibria is used. In Fig. I.3.23, only the elements relevant for combustion are considered. The only important phase field that can be depicted in this diagram is that for the precipitation of C from the gas, i.e. the soot formation range. Different types of fuel, depicted by their specific range of fuel-to-oxygen ratios can be marked in the diagram, thus showing their tendency to soot formation. However, if the system C–H– O is considered together with one or more metallic components, then it is possible to use this kind of diagram in order to predict ranges for the corrosion of the metal both with respect to O and C. Figure I.3.24 shows such a diagram for a Fe–20% Cr stainless steel. The ratio of molar amount of alloy to gas has been chosen as 0.0001 in order to make sure that the amounts of
0.8
+ 0.8 H +
cti fra
0.6
ole M 0.5 0.2
0.7
0.3
0.6
0.4
Gas + C
) +O +H (C 0.5 H/ on cti 0.4 fra 3 0. ole M 0.2
on 0.7 C(C
0.1
O 0.9 )
C
O
0.9
0.1
Gas
0.9
0.8
0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 Mole fraction O/(C + H + O)
0.2
0.1
H
I.3.23 Phase diagram for T = 1200 K, mole Fe/(C+H+O) = 0 and mole Cr/(C+H+O) = 0.
66
The SGTE casebook
O) 0.8
H
le Mo
0.5
0.4 0.3
)
0.8
+ 0.7 C3 M7 0.6 te + C nti e+ 0.5 eme entit C cem + O3 M2 + C c + fc
Sp ine l+ Sp fcc ine l+ mo no xid e
0.2
+O
0.4
Spinel + fcc + C
M 2O 3
cti o 0.6 n C/ (C +H 0.7 +
C+ C/( on cti 0.3 fra 0.2
fra
le Mo 0.1
0.9
C
M
Sp
ine
l
O
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 Mole fraction O/(C + H + O)
2O 3
0.2
0.9
0.1
C
M2O3
+ fc
c
0.1
H
I.3.24 Phase diagram for T = 1200 K, P = 1 atm, mole Fe/(C+H+O) = 0.000 08 and mole Cr/(C+H+O) = 0.000 02.
C and O transferred from the gas to the condensed state on formation of carbides or oxides is negligible. Thus the mole fractions of C, H and O in the diagram can be read as those pertaining to the gas phase, except for those phase fields in which pure C is precipiated. In these ranges the amount of carbon transferred from the gas to the condensed state can lead to significant changes in the mole fractions of C, H and O in the gas phase. This behaviour is similar to that of the phase ranges of the Baur–Glässner diagram below the Boudouard curves (Fig. I.3.19).
I.3.4
The phase rule
Perhaps one of the most puzzling questions for students in thermochemistry is the derivation of the number c of components, to be inserted in the equation of the phase rule f=c+2–Φ
(I.3.6)
It is easy to count the number Φ of phases involved in the equilibrium but, when we consider the definition of c, even Gibbs [887Gib] explanations are not very stringent. In fact, he uses ‘actual’ components, which have amounts
Phase diagrams
67
that can be increased or diminished (p. 117), ‘possible’ components, which may be combined with but cannot be subtracted from the homogeneous mass in question (p. 117) and also ‘ultimate’ components (p. 134), which are the independent substances in the system (?). However, at a later stage (p. 155) Gibbs explains that an equilibrium between two phases (labelled with a prime(′) and a double prime (″) in an ncomponent system has only one degree of freedom (p = p(T) or vice versa) if n – 1 ratios of m′1 to m″n, the mole numbers of the components in the phase labelled with a prime, are equal to n – 1 ratios of m″1 to m″n, the equivalent mole numbers in the phase labelled with a double prime. This latter explanation helps to develop a concept from which it is easier to derive the value of c, which according to Rao [87Rao] should be called the number of Gibbsian components. Let us first consider the case as stated by Gibbs for a real system, the azeotropic point between the solid gold solution and the liquid as well as the two points of congrunet solid–solid transition in the system Au–Cu as marked in Fig. I.3.25. All equilibria are two-phase equilibria (Φ = 2) between two solution phases of a system with two elemental, components (n = 2). Yet there is one additional constraint, namely
1500
1300 Liquid
T (K)
1100
Fcc Al
900
700
500
AuCu
AuCu
Au3Cu 300 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5 x (Cu)
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
I.3.25 System Au–Cu (SGTE Solution Database). 䉭, 䉮 points with equal composition in both phases.
1
68
The SGTE casebook liq fcc m Cu m Cu = liq fcc m Au m Au
(I.3.7)
Note that it is not important that the value of the ratio is known; only the equality is important. Thus f=c+2–Φ=1+2–2
(I.3.8)
It is obvious that c in this equation is not equal to the number of system components or elements but must be reduced by the number of compositional constraints given by the extra condition(s) imposed on the system. Thus c=ε–s
(I.3.9)
where ε is the number of elements in the system and s is the number of compositional constraints within the solution phases which are in equilibrium with each other. At first sight, it seems of course as though the problem has only been shifted from finding the value for c to finding that for s, but at least counting the elements should be easy. The following discussion of some standard textbook cases will demonstrate that it is also not too complicated to find s, the number of compositional constraints. Before going into details, it is, however, necessary to emphasise that phases can be distinguished into two classes. These are stoichiometric pure substances and solutions, i.e. phases with intrinsically fixed ratios and those with variable or partially variable composition. Note that the gas phase always belongs to the latter class. This distinction may seem too strict in some respect but, when it comes to equilibrium calculations using computer programs, one has to decide beforehand what homogeneity range a particular phase will be given. Thus the following two equations have to be considered together when applying the phase rule: f = c + 2 – Φ and c = ε – s
(I.3.10)
The reason for the compositional constraints is twofold. Firstly, one has to investigate what are the smallest stoichiometric units which determine the exchange of matter between the phases. These are not always the elements! Secondly, one has to take into consideration the initial compositional situation of the system. Often both of the above apply at the same time. The following cases will be used to discuss these aspects and how they help to find the values to be used in the above equations. – The ammonium chloride–gas equilibrium, system Cl–H–N. – The water–phosphoric acid equilibrium, system H–P–O. – The 2CaO · SiO2–3CaO · MgO · 2SiO2–CaO · MgO · SiO2 equilibrium.
Phase diagrams
I.3.4.1
69
The ammonium chloride–gas equilibrium
This equilibrium has been discussed in many books that treat the phase rule [62Pri, 82Atk, 89Bar]. Usually one finds the stoichiometric reaction NH4Cl = NH3(g) + HCl(g) as the centrepiece of discussion. This approach can be quite misleading as it does not make use of the fact that the gas phase is capable of attaining any composition based on the elements H, N and Cl. If this was done, one could treat this case along the lines of the previous example. For the gas alone, one obtains
ε=3
N, H, Cl
Φ=1
gas = {N2, H2, Cl2, HCl, NH3, ...}
s=0 c=ε–s=3
no compositional constraint and
f=c+2–Φ=4
T and P as well as two mole fractions of the three elemental components can be varied independently. With this gas we can now require the salt (NH4Cl) to coexist. One obtains
ε=3
N, H, Cl
Φ=2
gas = {... as above ...}, NH4Cl
s=0 c=ε–s=3
no compositional constraint and
f=c+2–Φ=3
T, P and one mole fraction of the elemental components in the gas can be varied. By beginning with a mixture of ammonia and hydrochloric acid (xNH3(g) + yHCl(g) with x + y = 1) all one does is to impose a compositional constraint on the gas phase, thus leaving one compositional degree of freedom: y. One obtains
ε=3 Φ=2 s=1 c = ε – s = 2 and
N, H, Cl gas = (... as above ...), NH4Cl nH : (3nN + nCl) = 1 f=c+2–Φ=2
Now for example the pressure is a function of T and y. What if one starts with solid ammonium chloride? NH4Cl will dissociate into the gas species NH3(g) and HCl(g) in equal proportions. Thus one obtains
70
The SGTE casebook
ε=3 Φ=2 s=2
N, H, Cl gas = (... as above ...), NH4Cl mN(g) : mH(g) = 1:4 and mN(g) : mCl(g) = 1:4
c = ε – s = 1 and
f=c+2–Φ=1
The total pressure P is a function of T or vice versa, the system behaves like a one-component system as discussed by Gibbs. This case shows very clearly how the initial choice of the substances from which the system is made up, together with the fact that the exchange of matter between the phases is restricted by the fixed molar ratios between N and H as well as between N and Cl, limits the degrees of freedom step by step.
I.3.4.2
The water–phosphoric acid equilibrium
When adding phosphoric acid (H3PO4) to water (H2O), one deals with a single solution phase (Φ = 1) with internal phase equilibria between the different aqueous species. The usual way to find c, the only missing parameter for the phase rule, is to list all aqueous species, to search for all independent stoichiometric reactions between them and to subtract these two numbers. A far more straightforward way is given by the method at present employed. One does not need to know about the internal phase equilibria. Instead, the number ε of elements and the number s, of compositional constraints, given by the initial substances is sufficient. A similar example was given by Planck for the system H2O–H2SO4 [30Pla]:
ε=3 Φ=1 s=1 c=ε–1=2
H, P, O water with all possible species nH : (nO – 5nP) = 1 and
f=c+2–Φ=3
One can vary T, p and the mole fraction of H3PO4. The latter fact is obvious as, from xH2O + yH3PO4 (with x + y = 1), one will always obtain the concentration of hydrogen, oxygen and phosphorus from the initial mole fraction of H3PO4. It is, however, not necessary to know which aqueous species will form.
I.3.4.3
The 2CaO · SiO2–3CaO · MgO · 2SiO2– CaO · MgO · SiO2 equilibrium
When considering equilibria in oxide (or salt) systems it is often the case that each of the metallic elements in the system is present in only one oxidation
Phase diagrams
71
state. Thus the possible composition space of the system based on the elements is reduced by one dimension as knowledge of the concentrations of the metallic components is sufficient to work out the value for the oxygen (or the salt-forming element). The four component system Ca–Mg–Si–O can therefore be considered as the CaO–MgO–SiO2 system if no pure metal phase or gas is involved, i.e. at sufficiently high oxygen potentials. Thus the possible composition space is not a three-dimensional tetrahedron but only a two-dimensional Gibbs triangle. However, the particular phases taking part in the equilibrium discussed here underlie yet another compositional constraint. This is best recognised when the phase formulae are rewritten using the mole fractions of the basic oxides. One obtains →
2CaO · SiO2
2 1 3 CaO ⋅ 3 SiO 2
3CaO · MgO · 2SiO2 →
1 1 1 2 CaO ⋅ 6 MgO ⋅ 3 SiO 2
→
1 1 1 3 CaO ⋅ 3 MgO ⋅ 3 SiO 2
CaO · MgO · SiO2
All phases have the same concentration of SiO2, thus reducing the number of components even further. They are all on the so-called orthosilicate section. Thus one could use 2CaO · SiO2 and 2MgO · SiO2 to rewrite all phase formulae! Thus:
ε=4 Φ=3 s=2
Ca, Mg, Si, O 2CaO · SiO2, 3CaO · MgO · 2SiO2, CaO · MgO · SiO2 mCa + mMg + 2mSi = mO and xSiO2 = constant
c = ε – s = 2 and
f=c+2–Φ=1
This is the same result as for a three-phase equilibrium of a real binary system, i.e. we have shown that the equilibrium lies in a quasibinary section.
I.3.5
Conclusions
From the set of examples given above which can all be interpreted fairly straightforwardly using c = ε – s and f = c + 2 – Φ, two consecutive steps can be derived which finally lead to the application of the phase rule on a particular phase equilibrium. 1
2
Define the system by searching the databank based on the list of elements in that system. Extract a list of the phases and their phase components which are to be used in the equilibrium calculations. Transfer the system data to the equilibrium program and define the system composition by a set of substances contained in the phase list.
72
The SGTE casebook
Define the temperature and pressure. Check the resulting equilibrium for compositional constraints. Usually these concern compositional degrees of freedom in the solution phases involved but, as shown by the example for the Ca–Mg–Si–O system, equilibria between purely stoichiometric phases can also be governed by such constraints. In these cases it is possible to redefine the set of independent components as shown above. It should be noted that the more qualitative approach used in the discussion of the above examples of course has its mathematical counterpart. As was shown by Rao [87Rao] and Hillert [93Hil], it is possible by means of linear algebra to determine the number of stoichiometric constraints. Essentially this is achieved by calculating the rank of a stoichiometry matrix, the columns of which are constituted by the elemental components and the lines by the species from which the phases are constituted.
I.3.6
References
887Gib J.W. GIBBS: ‘On the equilibrium of heterogeneous substances’, Trans. Conn. Acad. 3, 1887. 03Bau E. BAUR and A. GLÄSSNER: Equilibrium between iron oxides and carbon monoxide and dioxide, Z. Phys. Chem. 43, 1903, 354–368. 06Jän E. JÄNECKE: Z. Anorg. Chem. 51, 1906, 132. 30Pla M. PLANCK: Thermodynamik, 9. Auflage, Walter de Gruyter, Berlin, 1930. 44Mas G. MASING: Ternary Systems, Reinhold, New York, 1944. 62Pri I. PRIGOGINE and R. DEFAY: Chemische Thermodynamik, VEB Deutscher Verlag für Grundstoffindustrie, Leipzig, 1962. 63Pou M. POURBAIX: Atlas d’Équilibres Électrochimiques, Publication du Centre Blege d’Étude de la Corrosion ‘CEBELCOR’, Gauthier-Villars, Paris, 1963. 64Pal L.S. PALATNIK and A.I.LANDAU: Phase Equilibria in Multicomponent Systems, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York, 1964. 66Pri A. PRINCE: Alloy Phase Equilibria, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1966. 73Pel A.D. PELTON and H. SCHMALZRIED: Metall. Trans 4, 1973, 1395. 82Atk P.W. ATKINS: Physical Chemistry, 2nd edition, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1982. 84Bra T.R. BRAMBLETT and J.E. MORRAL: Bull. Alloy Phase Diagrams 5, 1984, 433– 436. 84Mor J.E. MORRAL: Scripta Metall. 18, 1984, 407–410. 85Hil M. HILLERT: Int. Metals Rev. 30(2), 1985, 45. 86Gup H. GUPTA, J.E. MORRAL and H. NOWOTNY: Scripta Metall. 20, 1986, 889–894. 87Rao Y.K. RAO: Metall. Trans. A 18, 1987, 327. 89Bar I. BARIN: Thermochemical Data of Pure Substances, VCH Verlagsgesellschaft, Weinheim, 1989. 91Koe E. KÖNIGSBERGER and H. GAMSJÄGER: Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 95(6), 1991, 734. 93Hil M. HILLERT: J. Phase Equilibria 14(4), 1993, 418–424.
I.4 Summarising mathematical relationships between the Gibbs energy and other thermodynamic information KLAUS HACK
The preceding chapters have demonstrated how the different mathematical relationships of thermodynamics can be applied to a great variety of different tasks, from the simple calculation of a thermodynamic property of a pure substance to the phase diagram of a complex multicomponent multiphase system. Below is given a schematic summary in the form of a tree (Fig. I.4.1) showing which mathematical tools relate the Gibbs energy of a system to the various other items. Using G as a function of T, P and ni, Legendre transformations yield all other thermodynamic potentials with their respective natural variables. This has already been pointed out by Gibbs but is now well known under the term Maxwell relations. Based on G a minimisation leads to equilibrium conditions. In order to obtain a complete description of the respective system (including equilibrium amounts and not only potentials) the method of ‘extent of reaction’ can be applied for equilibria that can be described with simple stoichiometric reactions; for multicomponent, multiphase systems, one usually applies the Phase diagram
µ
,
i
cp
Gibbs–Duhem
,
H
()
i
l el w ,… x a F M U, H,
i
(),
Ai
,
vi
x
Minimisation
T
P
e n dr tio en ma g Le sfor n r ta
(),
i
Equilibria
P ith ar t re ial sp de ec ri t t va o tiv , es or
S
w
Gibbs energy
I.4.1 Schematic summary tree.
73
74
The SGTE casebook S
U
H
V
F F
G
T
I.4.2 The full arrow shows the positive value of the partial derivative.
method of Lagrangian undetermined multipliers. It should be noted that both ways require numerical procedures, i.e. a computer program. From single-equilibrium calculations the method of phase mapping based on the Gibbs–Duhem equation leads to phase diagrams of three different but interrelated kinds [73Pel]. To obtain quantitative relationships in multicomponent systems, two-dimensional sections can be generated, again using appropriate computer programs. Using the appropriate partial derivatives of G with respect to T, P and ni, all integral and partial values of the Gibbs energy, entropy and heat content of a phase can be calculated (Fig. I.4.2). This can be done by programming the derivatives explicitly for all Gibbs energy models which are based on explicit mathematical expressions of T, P and the concentration variables. However, it should be noted that some models, such as the cell model or the quasichemical model for ionic liquids, require a phase internal minimisation with respect to composition and subsequent numerical differentiation (with all the inherent disadvantages).
I.4.1 73Pel
Reference A.D. PELTON and H. SCHMALZRIED: Metall. Trans. 4, 1973, 1395.
Part II Applications in material science and processes
75
76
II.1 Hot salt corrosion of superalloys T O M I. B A R R Y and A L A N T. D I N S D A L E
II.1.1
Introduction
Under normal circumstances a nickel-based superalloy is protected from corrosive attack by an oxide layer on the surface, which is typically Cr2O3. However, in marine environments, turbine blades made from superalloys are particularly susceptible to corrosive attack by hot or molten salts. Under these conditions, NaCl can be swept into the turbine in the air stream to react with any sulphur-containing combustion products in the fuel to form sodium sulphate which condenses on to the oxide layer. This salt droplet may dissolve the protective layer and expose the alloy to corrosive attack from the oxidising and sulphidising atmosphere. In this chapter the range of conditions which might lead to this so-called ‘hot salt corrosion’ are explored in an attempt to provide a basis for understanding the detailed mechanisms involved. The driving force for corrosion is thermodynamic and hence it is attractive to analyse corrosion by reference to thermodynamic criteria. On the other hand, corrosion involves a series of processes that are linked together in a complex way. For the case of hot salt corrosion the mechanism by which chromium is removed from the surface of the turbine blade is particularly complex and may involve some sort of fluxing whereby the Cr2O3 is reprecipitated from the salt phase at its boundary with the gas phase. Traditionally corrosion problems have been analysed thermodynamically in terms of so-called phase stability diagrams. Such diagrams are conceptually simple but are really limited to systems where the material is a pure element. In view of the progress made in calculating phase equilibria involving many components and a wide range of phases it is appealing to analyse the corrosion phenomenon as a multicomponent system.
II.1.2
Data used for the calculations
In order to obtain some thermodynamic insight into this process, data for the C–H–O–N–Cl–S–Cr–Na system from the SGTE pure substance database 77
78
The SGTE casebook
were augmented by data assessed for the liquid phase and various solid salt phases thought to be of importance. Of the phases involved in hot corrosion, only the gas phase approximates closely to thermodynamically ideal behaviour. The phases present in the alloy, corrosion products and adherent salts are all non-ideal solutions. The chemical properties of the deposited salt are usually analysed in terms of its oxide activity. However, since NaOH is much more stable than Na2O in the presence of the water in the gas stream, it was decided to analyse the data required for calculations in terms of the quaternary system NaCl–NaOH–Na2CrO4–Na2SO4 Five condensed solution phases have been considered in this treatment: the liquid, the orthorhombic and hexagonal structures of Na2SO4, the halite structure of NaCl and the monoclinic (high-temperature) structure of NaOH. Mixing of all components was considered for the liquid but only pairs of components in the crystalline phases, as shown in Table II.1.1. None of these salt phases requires a large number of terms to model the solution behaviour and some approach ideality. The assessments for the systems NaCl–Na2SO4, NaCl–Na2CrO4 and Na2SO4–Na2CrO4 are based on the work of Liang et al. [80Lia1, 80Lia2] with some modifications. Different data are used for the pure components, and solution data are added for the orthorhombic sodium sulphate phase. The NaOH–Na2SO4 system has been assessed by Bale and Pelton [82Bal] but, since in that particular case equivalent rather than mole fractions were used, a complete reassessment was necessary. New assessments have also been made for the NaCl–NaOH and the NaOH– Na2CrO4 systems [87Bar]. The most important salt binary system is the Na2CrO4–Na2SO4 system in which the components are completely soluble in each other in both the liquid phase and in the hexagonal and orthorhombic Na2SO4-based solid solution phases. Figure II.1.1 shows the calculated phase diagram for this system. Figures II.1.2(a), Fig. II.1.2(b) and Fig. II.1.2(c) show the diagrams for three of the four ternary systems at 1023.15 K calculated from the critically assessed binary data.
Table II.1.1 List of condensed salt phases considered and their constituents Liquid Halite Monoclinic NaOH Hexagonal Na2SO4 Orthorhombic Na2SO4
NaCl, NaOH, Na2CrO4, Na2SO4 NaCl, NaOH NaCl, NaOH Na2CrO4, Na2SO4 Na2CrO4, Na2SO4
Hot salt corrosion of superalloys
79
1200 Liquid
Temperature (K)
1000
Hexagonal
800
600
Orthorhombic 400 300 0.0 Na2CrO4
0.2
0.4
0.6
xNa SO 2
4
0.8
1.0 Na2SO4
II.1.1 Calculated phase diagram for the Na2CrO4–Na2SO4 binary system.
II.1.3
The gas–salt equilibrium
The following calculations relate to the corrosion in a gas turbine operating at a fuel-to-air ratio of 50 to 1 by weight, a pressure of 15 bar (1.5 MPa) and a temperature of 750 °C. The fuel composition was taken to have the approximate formula CH1.8. With these assumptions the main combustion products have the following partial pressures: CO2, 0.61 bar; H2O, 0.55 bar; N2, 11.6 bar; O2, 2.216 bar On this basis, 1% sulphur in the fuel would cause the sum of the pressures of SO2 plus SO3 to be 0.0026 bar. The presence of 1 ppm of sodium chloride by weight of gas would result in a pressure of HCl of 0.0046 bar. The sodium will accumulate mainly as the sulphate on any surfaces. Hence the amount of sodium that can be used in the calculation is arbitrary. On the other hand, for calculations relating to the gas–salt interface, the amount of chlorine should reflect the levels expected in the gas atmosphere. For a given temperature, pressure and relative amounts or activities of components it is possible to calculate the stable assemblage of phases and their compositions by minimising the Gibbs energy. If necessary, the amounts of minor species are then calculated by equalisation of chemical potentials
80
The SGTE casebook NaOH
0.8
0.2
0.4 xNa2SO4
0.6
xNaOH
Liquid
0.4
0.6
0.2
0.8
NaCl
0.8
0.6
0.4 xNaCl
0.2
Na2SO4
(a)
Na2CrO4
0.8
0.2
0.6
xNa CrO 2
0.4
xNa SO 2
4
4
0.4
0.6 Liquid
0.2
NaCl
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.4 xNaCl (b)
0.2
Na2SO4
II.1.2 Phase diagram for 1023.15 K for ternary systems (a) NaCl– NaOH–Na2SO4, (b) NaCl–Na2SO4–Na2CrO4 and (c) NaOH–Na2SO4– Na2CrO4.
Hot salt corrosion of superalloys
81
Na2CrO4
0.8
0.2
0.4 xNa2SO4
0.6
xNa CrO 2
4
0.4
0.6 Liquid
0.2
NaOH
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.4 xNaOH
0.2
Na2SO4
(c)
II.1.2 (Continued)
followed by re-evaluation of the mass balance. Table II.1.2 shows the results of a calculation for the multicomponent system discussed below. The substances are grouped by phase. A number of less important gas-phase species and condensed stoichiometric substances have been omitted from the table. The values of chemical potential printed towards the end of the table are expressed in accordance with SGTE practice [85Bar]. It is possible to use the chemical potential to test whether the calculated equilibrium mixture would react with materials not considered in the calculation, e.g. for possible corrosion of the container. In accordance with the requirements of equilibrium the chemical potential of a species such as NaCl that is present in more than one phase are the same in all phases. The calculation shows that Cr2O3 does indeed dissolve in the salt phase, potentially exposing the turbine blade to corrosive attack from the oxidising atmosphere. Even under modest pressures of SO3, most of the sodium chloride can be expected to be converted to sodium sulphate. At the temperature of 1023.15 K, sodium sulphate itself is solid, whereas experimental evidence suggests that the corrosive agent at this temperature is a sodium-sulphate-rich liquid phase. However, Fig. II.1.2(a) shows that a liquid can form containing about 28 mol% NaCl, a little NaOH and the remainder Na2SO4 but this would depend on there being a sufficiently high partial pressure of HCl. The pressure of HCl required to cause the liquid to form depends on the partial pressure
82
The SGTE casebook
of SO3 which in turn depends on the partial pressure of oxygen. Figure II.1.3 shows the coexistence line between the liquid and crystalline sodium sulphate and also the less important line for the coexistence of liquid and the NaCl– NaOH of the halite structure. The equilibrium between the liquid and crystalline sodium sulphate is governed by the chemical reaction Na2SO4 + 2HCl = 2NaCl + SO3 + H2O
(II.1.1)
The proportion of NaOH is greatest under conditions of low pressures of HCl and SO3, as can easily be anticipated. The straightness of the line in Fig. II.1.3 arises because the concentration of NaOH is small and the proportions of NaCl and Na2SO4 in the liquid are insensitive to the relative pressures of HCl and SO3, provided that the liquid and crystalline sulphate coexist. However, as indicated by Reaction (II.1.1), the position of the line and hence the conditions for liquid-phase formation are dependent on the partial pressure of water. Thus the rates of diffusion of water in the crystalline and liquid phases may be important parameters in hot corrosion since these rates will influence liquid formation in microenvironments.
II.1.4
The interaction of gas and salt with Cr2O3
For systems of more than three components it is not possible to represent the results of calculations on a conventional phase diagram. Table II.1.2 shows the results of an individual calculation in the eight-component system 0
log pHCl
–1
Halite solid solution (NaCl–NaOH)
–2 Liquid –3 Hexagonal –4
–5 –10
–8
–6 –4 log pSO
–2
0
3
II.1.3 Diagram showing the conditions for the coexistence of the three-component liquid phase NaCl–NaOH–Na2SO4 with the twocomponent halite phase and hexagonal Na2SO4 at 1023.15 K (p H 2O = 0.55 bar).
Hot salt corrosion of superalloys
83
Table II.1.2 Edited output data from a single calculation of equilibrium in the system C–Cl–Cr–H–N–Na–O–S Temperature = 1023.1500 K Fixed gas volume = 8.395 500 × 10–2 m3 Calculated gas pressure = 1.515 009 × 106 Pa Phase Species
Gas phases CClO(g) CCl2O(g) CHNO(g) CO(g) CO2(g) Cl(g) Cl2(g) Cl2CrO2(g) ClH(g) ClHO(g) ClNO(g) ClNO2(g) ClNa(g) Cl2Na2(g) ClO(g) ClO2(g) Cl2O(g) Cl2OS(g) Cl2O2S(g) CrO2(g) CrO3(g) H(g) H2(g) H2N(g) H3N(g) HNO(g) HNO2(g) HNO3(g) HNaO(g) H2Na2O2(g) HO(g) HO2(g) H2O(g) H2O2(g) H2O4S(g) N(g) N2(g) N3(g) NO(g) NO2(g) NO3(g)
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
18 19 37 51 52 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 79 80 81 82 84 86 88 89 90 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 102 103 104 105 106 107
Amount (mol)
6.463 5.120 1.836 5.406 6.137 3.072 3.209 4.670 6.422 1.645 2.024 4.534 3.134 3.689 2.671 4.223 1.636 3.322 5.796 5.076 3.446 3.292 6.348 5.320 8.794 1.275 3.443 1.057 4.931 1.246 7.833 6.286 5.500 2.981 1.127 3.661 1.159 2.147 5.570 8.112 3.127
891 377 733 494 000 932 431 889 286 855 754 128 771 358 773 573 331 069 471 084 742 599 202 189 008 204 450 176 999 164 063 854 873 711 982 168 968 879 745 675 762
Mole fraction Partial pressure Notional activity × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × ×
10–18 10–17 10–22 10–11 10–1 10–6 10–5 10–6 10–3 10–6 10–7 10–10 10–5 10–6 10–7 10–11 10–12 10–19 10–17 10–17 10–11 10–14 10–11 10–22 10–19 10–12 10–7 10–8 10–10 10–16 10–7 10–8 10–1 10–9 10–9 10–21 10 10–23 10–4 10–5 10–11
6.464 5.120 1.836 5.406 6.137 3.073 3.209 4.671 6.422 1.645 2.024 4.534 3.134 3.689 2.671 4.223 1.636 3.322 5.796 5.076 3.446 3.292 6.348 5.320 8.794 1.275 3.443 1.057 4.932 1.246 7.833 6.287 5.501 2.981 1.128 3.661 1.160 2.147 5.570 8.112 3.127
081 528 787 654 181 023 526 027 476 903 814 262 864 467 852 697 379 167 641 233 843 696 389 345 267 241 551 207 144 201 294 039 035 798 015 276 002 942 909 914 854
× × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × × ×
10–18 10–18 10–22 10–11 10–1 10–6 10–5 10–6 10–3 10–6 10–7 10–10 10–5 10–6 10–7 10–11 10–12 10–19 10–17 10–17 10–11 10–14 10–11 10–22 10–19 10–12 10–7 10–8 10–10 10–16 10–7 10–8 10–1 10–9 10–9 10–21 10 10–23 10–4 10–5 10–11
84
The SGTE casebook
Table II.1.2 (Continued) Phase Species
N2O(g) N2O3(g) N2O4(g) Na(g) NaO(g) Na2O4S(g) O(g) O2(g) O3(g) OS(g) O2S(g) O3S(g) Phase total
Amount (mol) 10–7 10–13 10–15 10–16 10–16 10–10 10–10
× × × × ×
10–11 10–19 10–7 10–7 10
1.450 2.759 6.611 7.544 7.365 6.088 4.591 2.180 4.169 8.564 2.919 6.014 1.495
437 441 200 342 154 846 051 992 788 745 770 804 198
× × × × × × ×
10–7 10–13 10–14 10–16 10–16 10–10 10–10
× × × × ×
10–11 10–19 10–7 10–7 10
1.721 0.000 0.000 0.000 1.189 4.369 1.261 1.000 8.957 4.230 8.602
567 000 000 000 317 075 701 000 969 024 759
× 10–21
2.479 8.663 1.452 6.654 1.000
055 033 467 496 000
× × × ×
108 109 110 112 114 115 116 117 118 119 121 122
1 3 4 5 7 8 9 11 12 25 27
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
28 28 28 28
1 2 3 4
Halite phases ClNa(halite) HNaO(halite)
29 29
1 2
2.872 939 × 10–1 5.161 327 × 10–7
Monoclinic phases ClNa(monoclinic) HNaO(monoclinic)
30 30
1 2
1.632 411 × 10–1 4.444 794 × 10–6
31 31
1 2
32
1
Liquid phases ClNa(l) CrNa2O4(l) HNaO(l) Na2O4S(l) Phase total
Hexagonal phases CrNa2O4(hexagonal) Na2O4S(hexagonal) Phase total Orthorhombic Na2SO4 phases CrNa2O4(ortho Na2SO4)
395 359 005 120 937 666 916 927 665 493 684 627 153
× × × × × × ×
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Stoichiometric phases C C2Cr3 C3Cr7 C6Cr23 CNa2O3 Cr CrN Cr2O3 Cr2O12S3 CrH2Na4O6 HNa3O5S
1.450 2.759 6.611 7.544 7.364 6.088 4.590 2.180 4.169 8.564 2.919 6.014 1.495
Mole fraction Partial pressure Notional activity
3.210 702 × 10–2
3.460 1.209 2.027 9.288 1.395
268 187 355 352 801
× × × × ×
10–3 10–3 10–7 10–3 10–2
3.457 211 × 10–2 4.531 808 × 10–1 4.877 529 × 10–1
× 10–6 × 10–23 × 10–20 × 10–19 × 10–11 × 10–6 10–1 10–2 10–5 10–1
7.088 038 × 10–2 9.291 196 × 10–1 1.000 000
6.232 106 × 10–2
Hot salt corrosion of superalloys
85
Table II.1.2 (Continued) Phase Species
Amount (mole)
Mole fraction Partial pressure Notional activity
Na2O4S(ortho Na2SO4)
32
2
2.551 695 × 10–1
Orthorhombic NaOH phase HNaO(ortho NaOH)
33
1
2.396 193 × 10–6
Na2SO4 phase Na2O4S(Na2SO4)
34
1
2.458 958 × 10–1
Component
Phase chemical potential
C Cl Cr H N Na O S Total
–4.199 –1.676 –4.761 –1.745 –9.551 –3.567 –1.098 –4.833
367 515 963 120 675 809 866 949
× × × × × × × ×
Activity
105 105 105 105 104 105 105 105
3.644 2.761 4.891 1.232 1.329 6.106 2.455 2.098
258 495 850 839 623 673 424 815
Amount (mol) × × × × × × × ×
10–22 10–9 10–25 10–9 10–5 10–19 10–6 10–25
0.613 0.010 0.100 1.106 23.200 1.000 8.229 0.462 34.722
70 00 00 60 00 00 40 47 17
Helmholtz energy = –4.327 944 809 8 × 106 J Amount of Phase component 3.1067 × 10 1.6054 × 10–1 8.0404 × 10–2 3.4143
Mole fraction of following components within the phase (mol) C
Cl
Cr
H
N
Na
O
S
Gas
0.019 75 0.000 21 0.000 00 0.035 62 0.746 77 0.000 00 0.197 64 0.000 00
Cr2O3
0.000 00 0.000 00 0.400 00 0.000 00 0.000 00 0.000 00 0.600 00 0.000 00
Liquid 0.000 00 0.043 04 0.015 04 0.000 00 0.000 00 0.304 16 0.522 24 0.115 52 Hexagonal 0.000 00 0.000 00 0.010 13 0.000 00 0.000 00 0.285 71 0.571 43 0.132 73
C–Cl–Cr–H–N–Na–O–S The pressures of N2, CO2, H2O and initially O2 were set to the values expected in the gas turbine environment. The amounts of sodium and chromium were fixed and the oxygen and sulphur proportions were adjusted to explore the range of conditions that might be found within the salt mixture at its contact with Cr2O3. The method allows the user of the system to calculate the partition of chromium between the four phases in which it is involved, namely Cr2O3, the crystalline solid solution of Na2CrO4 with Na2SO4, the liquid and the gas. The effect of the reducing conditions that might be expected within the molten salt deposit was explored by varying the oxygen potential.
86
The SGTE casebook
Because the binary system Na2CrO4–Na2SO4 behaves almost ideally, both for the solid phase as well as for the liquid solution, an appreciation of the equilibrium between Cr2O3 and these phases can be obtained by considering the chemical reaction Na2SO4 + 0.5Cr2O3 + 0.25O2 = Na2CrO4 + SO2
(II.1.2)
The reaction suggests that the equilibrium between Cr2O3 and Na2CrO4 at a particular mole fraction in the crystalline phase can be plotted on a conventional phase stability diagram, as shown in Fig. II.1.4. The slope of the lines in Fig. II.1.4 is 14 , in agreement with Reaction (II.1.2). Moreover the lines are nearly equally separated in accordance with the fact that the activity of Na2SO4 and the activity coefficient of Na2CrO4 in the solid solution are essentially constant. Because of this behaviour it is possible to combine the lines of Fig. II.1.4 into a single relationship by plotting the logarithms of the concentration of sodium chromate in the solid solution as a function of log pSO 2 – 0.25 log pO 2 . The result is shown in Fig. II.1.5. The same procedure can be followed for the solution of sodium chromate in the liquid phase. Despite the fact that the proportion of NaOH, although small, varies substantially and that of NaCl slightly with the imposed pressures of SO2, O2 and HCl, very little deviation from the two lines drawn in Fig. II.1.5 was calculated to occur. Liquid does not form under all conditions of
–2 –3
Corundum (Cr2O3)
xNa CrO 2
–4
4
0.0001 log pSO2
–5 0.001
–6
0.01
–7
0.1 –8 –9 –10 –12
–10
–8
–6 log pO
–4
–2
0
2
II.1.4 The solubility at 1023.15 K of Cr2O3 expressed as the mole fraction of Na2CrO4 dissolved in the hexagonal Na2SO4 phase as a function of log p O 2 and log p SO 2 .
Hot salt corrosion of superalloys
87
–1.0 –1.5
Liquid
–2.5
2
log xNa CrO
4
–2.0
Hexagonal
–3.0 –3.5 –4.0 –4.5 –5.0 –8
–7
–6 –5 –4 log pSO – 0.25 log pO 2
–3
–2
2
II.1.5 The solubility at 1023.15 K of Cr2O3 expressed as the mole fraction of Na2CrO4 in the liquid and hexagonal Na2SO4 phases. The conditions for existence of the liquid phase are indicated by Fig. II.1.3.
oxygen and sulphur dioxide pressure. However, the conditions for liquid formation are not very much altered by the proportion of Na2CrO4 in solution and hence can be predicted by reference to Fig. II.1.3. In the chosen model of the liquid phase the alkalinity, often expressed as oxide activity, is represented instead by the activity of NaOH. In principle the solution of Cr2O3 as Na2CrO4 might be represented by any of the following reactions: Na2SO4 + 0.5Cr2O3 + 0.25O2 = Na2CrO4 + SO2
(II.1.3)
2NaOH + 0.5Cr2O3 + 0.75O2 = Na2CrO4 + H2O
(II.1.4)
Na2O + 0.5Cr2O3 + 0.75O2 = Na2CrO4
(II.1.5)
In conditions of chemical equilibrium these reactions will all give consistent results. On the other hand, in the non-equilibrium conditions obtaining at the interface between the salt and the oxide, material needs to be transported to and from the salt–gas interface. Reaction (II.1.3) would provide a good summary of the process if sulphur dioxide were able to diffuse rapidly through the salt or Reaction (II.1.4) if diffusion of NaOH and H2O were more rapid. The rates of diffusion would depend not only on the diffusion coefficients but also on the activity gradients. The concentration of Na2O is unlikely to be sufficient to act as a vehicle for maintaining the alkalinity of the melt by diffusion from the salt–gas to the salt–oxide surface, as required by Reaction (II.1.5).
88
The SGTE casebook
In principle, it is not necessary to express the problem in terms of specific stoichiometric reactions; indeed this carries dangers of misrepresentation. The reactions have been used here merely to indicate the need to include data for all the constituents that are active in diffusion processes.
II.1.5
Limitations of the data and calculated results
The calculated phase equilibria are of course totally dependent on the data. The authors are reasonably satisfied with the data for the pure substances and solutions considered but it must be stressed that other substances or solution species need to be included. Thus, under conditions of low oxygen potential, sodium carbonate may become a significant component of the liquid. At high pressures of SO3, sodium pyrosulphate (Na2S2O7) may form and chromium may dissolve as the sulphate Cr2(SO4)3. Furthermore it cannot be excluded that sodium chromite (NaCrO2) may dissolve in the liquid phase. There is nothing in principle to stop the inclusion of these constituents except the limited amount of data available. The conditions for liquid-phase formation would in practice be greatly extended by the presence of nickel and cobalt in the alloy [80Gup, 80Lut] and potassium in the gaseous and liquid environments. The calculations discussed above, therefore, are intended mainly as an indication of the power of recent thermodynamic methods.
II.1.6
Extension to higher-order systems
The alloys commonly used in gas turbines contain the components nickel, cobalt and aluminium as well as chromium and operate in an environment containing many others including nitrogen, oxygen, carbon, hydrogen, sulphur, chlorine, sodium, potassium, calcium, magnesium, phosphorus and vanadium. The oxides, sulphides and salts formed should be considered as solution phases as should the metallic and carbide phases which develop in subsurface regions of the alloy. Coatings containing the additional elements silicon, zirconium, titanium and yttrium may also be applied and these will participate in all the phases already mentioned, including the alloy phases and the gas. It will be appreciated that the potential products of reactions are very numerous and a substantial volume of data is required. However, many of the same phases and systems that are important in gas turbine operation are also of interest in aqueous corrosion, pyrometallurgy, hydrometallurgy, electronic materials, ceramics, catalysis and other applications of alloys. There is therefore the prospect that data can be accumulated from many sources, provided that the assessments are based on consistent criteria. In recognition of this fact there is a drive towards standardisation of the models and of key data values. Thus in many respects the methods and
Hot salt corrosion of superalloys
89
organisation required to provide the thermodynamic data needed for analysis of hot corrosion are already in place.
II.1.7
Future developments
To extend the calculations to the kinetics of chemical processes it is usual to assume that there is local achievement of equilibrium. With this assumption, various workers have given analytical descriptions relevant to the oxidation of binary alloys with considerable success [83Laq, 83Nis]. However, for multicomponent alloys carrying multiphase corrosion products an analytical description is not feasible. Indeed, even individual calculations of chemical equilibrium use numerical and not analytical methods. The obvious method of modelling the kinetics of corrosion is therefore through the use of boundary element analysis. For this to be feasible, data will be required in the form of coefficients of equations for the diffusion of species under the gradients of chemical (and perhaps electrical) potential present in the corrosion layers and in the depleted alloy. These coefficients will be temperature and composition dependent and will be required for each phase and for grain boundary diffusion. If, for example, H2O(g) is the agent that transfers oxygen along a crack to cause further oxidation, the calculation requires knowledge of the interdiffusion coefficients of H2O with all the other gases present. Provided that all the data are available and provided that the models and software for determination of chemical equilibria allow the chemical potentials and concentrations of diffusing species to be calculated, the user of the kinetic model does not need to state explicitly the processes involved in terms of chemical reactions. Thus it should not be necessary to decide in advance whether the solution of, say, nickel oxide in sodium sulphate occurs by alkaline or acid dissolution. The correct result will be automatically generated provided that data for both models are incorporated into the database. Further work will be required before a full thermodynamic analysis of the problem can be attempted. This could include the addition of some or all of magnesium, nickel, chromium, aluminium, potassium, vanadium, carbonate, chromite, pyrosulphate and oxide ions to the salt phase. Such ions could have the effect of lowering the melting point of the solid phase or providing a mechanism for the migration of chromium away from the surface of the turbine blade.
II.1.8
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge discussions with Dr S. R. J. Saunders, concerning hot-corrosion phenomena, and with Mr R. H. Davies and Mrs S. M. Martin concerning various aspects of the data and calculation methods. The calculations for this case study have been performed using MTDATA.
90
II.1.9 80Gup 80Lia1 80Lia2 80Lut 82Bal 83Laq
83Nis 85Bar 87Bar
The SGTE casebook
References D.K. GUPTA and R.A. RAPP: J. Electrochem. Soc. 127, 1980, 2194–2202. W.W. LIANG, P.L. LIN and A.D. PELTON: High. Temp. Sci. 12, 1980, 41–50. W.W. LIANG, P.L. LIN and A.D. PELTON: High. Temp. Sci. 12, 1980, 71–88. K.L. LUTHRA and D.A. SHORES: J. Electrochem. Soc. 127, 1980, 2202–2210. C.W. BALE and A. PELTON: Calphad 6,1982, 255–278. W. LAQUA and H. SCHMALZRIED: in High Temperature Corrosion (NACE-6) (Ed. R.A. Rapp), National Association of Corrosion Engineers, Houston, Texas, USA, 1983, pp. 115–120. K. NISHIDA: in High Temperature Corrosion (NACE-6) (Ed. R.A. Rapp), National Association of Corrosion Engineers, Houston, Texas, USA, 1983, pp. 184–191. T.I. BARRY: in Chemical Thermodynamics in Industry: Models and Computation (Ed. T.I. Barry), Blackwell Scientific, Oxford, 1985, pp. 1–39. T.I. BARRY and A.T. DINSDALE: Mater. Sci. Technol. 3, 1987, 501–511.
II.2 Computer-assisted development of high-speed steels P E R G U S TA F S O N
II.2.1
Introduction
The optimisation of the composition of high-speed steel and the recommendation for heat treatment are usually based upon a large amount of experimental work, because an adequate set of phase diagrams is not normally available for such a high-order system. However, by assessing the lowerorder systems thermodynamically it is possible to obtain a data set from which the state of equilibrium can be calculated for any composition and temperature. Such a data set has now been produced for the Fe–Cr–Mo–W–C system and it has been tested by comparing predictions with the results of some experiments. As a result, we can now trust the data set and use it for compositions and temperatures different from the experimental values. The experimental part of the development work can thus be reduced considerably.
II.2.2
Background
The earliest known high-speed steels were tungsten based, 18 wt% W–4 wt% Cr–1 wt% V steel being the best known. Different applications have resulted in the development of several variations on this composition, with a W content ranging from 22 wt% for increased red hardness and a V content up to 5 wt% for greater resistance to abrasive wear. V dissolves in the MC1–x carbide and will stabilise this otherwise rather unstable carbide. All these steels contain about 4 wt% Cr which is important in reducing scaling and in the hardening reaction (it increases the hardenability). More recently, Mo has entered this field. It can, owing to the similarity between the two, replace W atom for atom and induce very similar properties.
II.2.3
Calculation
The following calculations will show a number of examples on how the description of the Fe–Cr–Mo–W–C system can be used to attain a better 91
92
The SGTE casebook
understanding of the properties of the high-speed steel type of alloys. At the present time, the databank contains a description of the Fe–Cr–Mo–W–C system. This description will in the future be extended to include other elements of importance for the properties of many real high-speed steels. The influence of Co and V was thus ignored in the calculations presented in this paper.
II.2.4
Discussion
Figure II.2.1 shows a calculated vertical section in the C–Cr–Fe–Mo–W system at 6 wt% W, 6 wt% Mo and 4 wt% Cr. In the past, various sections in the ternary C–Fe–W and quaternary C–Cr–Fe–W systems have been used as a basis for discussions on the properties of high-speed steels. As an example the vertical dashed line shows the composition of typical high-speed steel, containing 0.6 wt% C. On cooling, this alloy will initially solidify to the α phase, but that reaction will not go to completion because γ will start to form. The γ phase grows peritectically and all α will be consumed before the last liquid disappears and before the first M6C starts to form. At about 876 °C some M23C6 will form and finally at about 820 °C all γ will disappear owing to the formation of α. The calculated section alone does not give all information required. It may be more interesting to know how the amount of the various phases varies with temperature. This is better illustrated in Fig. II.2.2. This diagram 1600 1500 1400
Liquid Liquid + α Liquid + α + γ
Liquid + γ
Temperature (°C)
1300 1200 1100
α + γ +M2C
Liquid + M2C γ + M2C
γ + M2C + M7C2
1000 900
γ + M2C + M22C9
γ + M2C + M23C8 + MC 800 α + λ α + M2C + M22C6 +M2C α + M23C9 + MC 700 α + M6C + M20C9 + MC 600 0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 C (wt%)
II.2.1 Vertical section of the C–Cr–Fe–Mo–W system at 4 wt% Cr, 6 wt% Mo and 6 wt%.
Computer-assisted development of high-speed steels
93
1.0 0.9 α
0.8
Weight fraction
0.7
γ
α
Liquid
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 M23C6 0 600 800
M6C 1000 1200 Temperature (°C)
1400
1600
II.2.2 The weight fraction of the phases forming in a high-speed steel containing 0.6 wt% C, 4 wt% Cr, 6 wt% Mo and 6 wt% W as a function of temperature. The weight fraction of a phase is represented by the fraction of the vertical axis covered by the phase.
0.20 0.18 0.16
Activity of C
0.14 0.12 0.10 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0 600
800
1000 1200 Temperature (°C)
1400
II.2.3 The activity of C as a function of temperature for a steel of the composition given in Fig. II.2.2.
shows the variation with temperature in the amount of the various phases that exist in a steel containing 0.6 wt% C. At each temperature the weight fraction of a phase is represented by the fraction of the vertical axis covered by the phase. Figure II.2.3 shows how the activity of carbon changes with
94
The SGTE casebook
temperature in the same steel. It may also be of interest to know how a change in the composition influences the amount of the different phases at a given temperature. This is illustrated in Fig. II.2.4. This diagram shows how the amount of the various phases varies along the horizontal deshed line in Fig. II.2.1. The experimental data included in Fig. II.2.4 are taken from an unpublished work on high-speed steels by Wisell [81Wis]. He also determined the carbon activity and the composition of the γ phase in the same alloys. Figure II.2.5 shows the variation in the carbon activity along the same line in comparison with Wisell’s data. Figure II.2.6 shows the variation in composition of the γ phase along the line. The agreement between Wisell’s experimental data and the present calculation is very good. This is encouraging especially since this information was not included in the evaluation of the thermodynamic properties of the C–Cr–Fe–Mo–W system. The type of information given in the diagrams presented above can for example be of help to explain the effect of a given heat treatment or change in composition on the structure and mechanical properties of high-speed steel. The calculations presented here are merely a few examples on what can be done with the data available in the SGTE databank. The calculations for this case study have been performed using ThermoCalc. 1.0 0.9 0.8
Mole fraction
0.7 0.6
γ
0.5 0.4 α 0.3 0.2 Liquid 0.1 0
0
0.5
1.0 C (wt%)
1.5
2.0
II.2.4 The mole fraction of the phases forming in a high-speed steel containing 4 wt% Cr, 6 wt% Mo and 6 wt% W at 1200 °C as a function of the total carbon content: | , experimental data from unpublished work by Wisell [81Wis]. The weight fraction of a phase is represented by the mole of the vertical axis covered by the phase.
Computer-assisted development of high-speed steels
95
0.45 0.40
Activity of C
0.35 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.15 0.10 0.05 0
0
0.5
1.0 C (wt%)
1.5
2.0
II.2.5 The activity of C as a function of the total carbon content, for the steel given in Fig. II.2.4: | , experimental data from unpublished work by Wisell [81Wis]. 2.0 1.8 1.6
C in γ phase (wt%)
1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
0.5
1.0 C (wt%)
1.5
2.0
(a)
II.2.6 The composition of the γ phase as a function of the total carbon content for the steel given in Fig. II.2.4 showing (a) the carbon content in γ as a function of the total carbon content, (b) the tungsten content in γ as a function of the total carbon content, (c) the molybdenum content in γ as a function of the total carbon content and (d) the chromium content in γ as a function of the total carbon content: | , | , , , experimental data for W: Mo: Cr = 6:6:4 from unpublished work by Wisell [81Wis]. |
The SGTE casebook 5.0 4.5
W in γ phase (wt%)
4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0
0
0.5
1.0 C (wt%)
1.5
2.0
1.5
2.0
(b)
5.0 4.5 4.0
Mo in γ phase (wt%)
96
3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0
0
0.5
1.0 C (wt%) (c)
II.2.6 (Continued)
Computer-assisted development of high-speed steels
97
5.0 4.5
Cr in γ phase (wt%)
4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0
0
0.5
1.0 C (wt%)
1.5
2.0
(d)
II.2.6 (Continued)
II.2.5 81Wis
Reference H. WISELL: Laboratory Report ASP-B 3/81, Kloster Speed Steel AB, Sweden.
II.3 Using calculated phase diagrams in the selection of the composition of cemented WC tools with a Co–Fe–Ni binder phase ARMANDO FERNANDEZ GUILLERMET
II.3.1
Introduction: background to the problem
It has long been known [54Gur, 70Mos] that the transverse rupture strength of Co-bonded WC tools is critically dependent upon the carbon content, and that the most favourable results are obtained when only the face-centred cubic (fcc) phase and WC are formed on cooling from the sintering temperature. For Co-bonded WC tools this is achieved if the W-to-C ratio is close to the value corresponding to the stoichiometric composition WC. An excess of carbon leads to the formation of graphite and a deficiency of carbon to the formation of M6C. In this last case, the decrease in the rupture strength is particularly drastic. When replacing Co by an Fe–Ni alloy the compositions leading to fcc + WC do not only necessarily coincide with the stoichiometric ratio. As a consequence, early attempts to produce (Fe–Ni) bonded WC tools along the lines suggested by the experience with the Co-based systems gave unsatisfactory results [60Sch], probably because of M6C formation. More recent work [82Thu] on the effect of carbon upon the martensitic transformation in (Co– Fe–Ni) binder phases further highlights the need for information about the interesting range of carbon contents for WC tools. It is shown here that this type of information can be obtained from calculated phase diagrams based on consistent thermodynamic data sets for all phases involved. The underlying assessment work has been described elsewhere [89Fer1].
II.3.2
The region of favourable carbon contents
Figure II.3.1 shows a vertical section of the Co–W–C phase diagram calculated for a constant Co content of 10 wt%, a so-called isopleth diagram. It is evident from this graph that alloys with a carbon content falling between the compositions indicated by a and b will exhibit immediately after equilibrium solidification the two phases fcc and WC only. Of course, consideration of 98
Composition of cemented WC tools with a Co–Fe–Ni binder Liquid + M6C + WC
1450
99
Liquid + WC
1400 a
Temperature (°C)
1350 Fcc + M6C + WC
1300 1250
b Liquid + graphite + WC
M6C + WC
1200 Fcc + WC 1150 Fcc + M12C + WC 1100 Fcc + graphite + WC 1050 1000 4.0
4.5
5.0 C (wt%)
5.5
6.0
II.3.1 Calculated vertical section (isopleth) of the Co–W–C system, with constant Co content of 10 wt%. See the text for the explanation of the full circle and points a and b.
the precipitation of M12C or pure graphite, which takes place at lower temperatures [89Fer2], will narrow the favourable range even further. However, neglecting these effects in the present discussion the range of carbon contents indicated by a and b will be referred to as ‘the favourable region’. A full circle on the horizontal axis of Fig. II.3.1 and all the following figures indicate the composition of the respective system corresponding to contents of W and C in stoichiometric proportion to form WC. For the system shown in Fig. II.3.1 this composition falls within the favourable region.
II.3.3
Effects of replacing Co by Fe and Ni
Figure II.3.2 and Fig. II.3.3 show calculated vertical sections (isopleths) of the Ni–W–C and Fe–W–C phase diagrams respectively. Comparison with Fig. II.3.1 elucidates the various effects of a full substitution of Co by Ni and by Fe respectively. Ni moves the favourable region towards lower carbon contents compared with the stoichiometric composition without decreasing its width. Fe has the opposite effect, moving the favourable region towards higher carbon contents and decreasing its width. Figure II.3.2 shows also that the solid–liquid temperatures in the Ni–W–C system are higher than in the Co–W–C system. However, the calculations predict that appreciable amounts of Co may be replaced by Ni without a drastic increase in the solid– liquid temperatures. This is demonstrated by Fig. II.3.4 and Fig. II.3.5 which
100
The SGTE casebook 1500 Liquid + WC 1450
Liquid + M6C + WC
a
1400 Fcc + M6C + WC
b
Temperature (°C)
1350
Liquid + graphite + WC
1300 1250 1200
Fcc + graphite + WC 1150 Fcc + WC 1100 1050 1000 4.0
4.5
5.0 C (wt%)
5.5
6.0
II.3.2 Calculated isopleth of the Ni–W–C system, with constant Ni content of 10 wt%. 1500 1450
Liquid + WC
Liquid + M6C + WC
1400 Liquid + graphite + WC
Temperature (°C)
1350 1300
a Fcc + M6C + WC
1250 1200 1150
M6C + WC
Fcc + WC b
1100
Fcc + graphite + WC
1050 1000 4.0
4.5
5.0 C (wt%)
5.5
6.0
II.3.3 Calculated isopleth of the Fe–W–C system, with constant Fe content of 10 wt%.
show sections (isopleths) of the Co–Ni–W–C system calculated for 10 wt% (Co + Ni) and Co–to–Ni weight percentage) ratios of 4 to 1 (Fig. II.3.4) and 1 to 1 (Fig. II.3.5).
Composition of cemented WC tools with a Co–Fe–Ni binder
101
1500 Liquid WC 1450 1400 Liquid + graphite + WC Temperature (°C)
1350 Liquid + M6C + WC
a
1300 1250 1200
Fcc + M6C + WC b
M6C + WC
Fcc + WC
1150 1100 Fcc + graphite + WC
1050 1000 4.0
4.5
5.0 C (wt%)
5.5
6.0
II.3.4 Calculated isopleth of the Co–Ni–W–C system, with constant Co + Ni content of 10 wt% and Co-to-Ni weight percentage ratio of 4 to 1.
1500 Liquid + WC 1450 1400 Liquid + graphite + WC
Temperature (°C)
1350 1300
Liquid + M6C + WC
1250 M6C + WC 1200
Fcc + M6C + WC
1150
Fcc + WC
1100 Fcc + graphite + WC 1050 1000 4.0
4.5
5.0 C (wt%)
5.5
6.0
II.3.5 Calculated isopleth of the Co–Ni–W–C system, with constant Co + Ni content of 10 wt% and Co-to-Ni weight percentage ratio of 1 to 1.
102
The SGTE casebook
A question of practical interest is the replacement of part of the Co + Ni content of the system by Fe. Figure II.3.6 and Fig. II.3.7 illustrate the effect of replacing half the content of Co + Ni (in weight percentage as given in Fig. II.3.4 and Fig. II.3.5) by Fe. Compared with Fig. II.3.4 and Fig. II.3.5 the calculated sections of the quinary Co–Fe–Ni–W–C system suggest relatively small effects of the replacement of Co + Ni by Fe. The favourable region is as expected somewhat narrower than in the Fe-free alloys with the same Coto-Ni weight percentage ratio and this unfavourable effect is more pronounced for the alloys with the lowest Co-to-Ni weight percentage ratio. Also, the substitution by Fe has moved the favourable region towards lower carbon contents. In Fig. II.3.6 and Fig. II.3.7 this region is roughly centred around the stoichiometric composition.
II.3.4
Favourable carbon contents of a family of alloys
As an alternative to the use of single isopleths to determine the limits of the favourable region (i.e. the position of the points a and b in all previous graphs) of a set of specific alloys one can also study a family of alloys as was demonstrated for the Fe–Ni–W–C system by Fernandez Guillermet [87Ferl, 87Fer2]. He showed that the lines defined by the displacement of the points 1500 Liquid + WC 1450 1400 Liquid + graphite + WC
Temperature (°C)
1350 1300
Liquid + M6C + WC
1250 1200
a
Fcc + M6C + WC M6C + WC b Fcc + WC
1150 1100
Fcc + graphite + WC 1050 1000 4.0
4.5
5.0 C (wt%)
5.5
6.0
II.3.6 Calculated isopleth of the Co–Fe–Ni–W–C system, with constant Co + Fe + Ni content of 10 wt%, constant Fe content of 5 wt% and Co-to-Ni weight percentage ratio of 4 to 1.
Composition of cemented WC tools with a Co–Fe–Ni binder
Liquid + WC
1450 1400
Liquid + M6C + WC Liquid + graphite + WC
1350
Temperature (°C)
103
a
1300 Fcc + M6C + WC 1250
M6C + WC
1200
b Fcc + WC
1150 1100
Fcc + graphite + WC 1050 1000 4.0
4.5
5.0 C (wt%)
5.5
6.0
II.3.7 Calculated isopleth of the Co–Fe–Ni–W–C system, with constant (Co + Fe + Ni) content of 10 wt%, constant Fe content of 5 wt% and Co-to-Ni weight percentage ratio of 1 to 1.
a and b in the temperature composition space can be directly obtained by calculation. The results of such calculation for alloys of the Fe–Ni–W–C system with 20 wt% (Fe + Ni) is demonstrated in Fig. II.3.8 which shows the temperature projections of the lines as a function of the Ni/(Fe + Ni) weight percentage ratio. The region between the lines in Fig. II.3.8 defines the favourable region of this family of alloys. If the Fe + Ni content is decreased, the favourable region becomes narrower. This is illustrated by Fig. II.3.9 which shows the result of the calculation for 10 wt% (Fe + Ni).
II.3.5
Conclusions
The present case study demonstrates the possibilities of obtaining information of direct practical use in connection with (Co–Fe–Ni)-bonded cemented WC tools by use of complex equilibrium calculations in multicomponent multiphase systems. By carrying out calculations based on the same set of thermodynamic data for other compositions, ranges outside those covered by the present discussion can easily be covered. The calculations for this case study have been performed using ThermoCalc.
The SGTE casebook 1.0 0.9 1400 °C
0.8
1300 °C
Ni/(Fe + Ni) (wt%)
0.7 M6C formation
Graphite formation
0.6 1250 °C
0.5 1350 °C
0.4
1200 °C
0.3 0.2
1300 °C
1150 °C
0.1 0 4.0
4.5
5.0 C (wt%)
5.5
6.0
II.3.8. Temperature projection of a section of the Fe–Ni–W–C system with 20 wt% (Fe + Ni). The lines describe the composition of a mixture of WC and liquid in equilibrium with fcc and M6C (to the left), and WC and fcc in equilibrium with liquid and graphite (to the right). The asterisk on the horizontal axis represents the favourable region in the system. 1.0 0.9 0.8
1400 °C 1300 °C
0.7 Ni/(Ni + Fe) (wt%)
104
0.6
0.4 0.3 0.2
1350 °C
1200 °C
M6C formation 1300 °C
0.1 0 5.0
Graphite formation
1250 °C
0.5
5.5
1150 °C
6.0 C (wt%)
6.5
7.0
II.3.9 Temperature projection of a section of the Fe–Ni–W–C system with 10 wt% (Fe + Ni). For explanation of the lines see Fig. II.3.8.
Composition of cemented WC tools with a Co–Fe–Ni binder
II.3.6 54Gur 60Sch 70Mos 82Thu 87Ferl 87Fer2 89Ferl 89Fer2
105
References J. GURLAND: Trans. AIME 200, 1954, 285–290. P. SCHWARTZKOPF and R. KIEFFER: Cemented Carbides, Macmillan, London, 1960, pp. 188–190. D. MOSKOWITZ, M.J. FORD and M. HUMENIK JR: Int. J. Powder Metallurgy 6, 1970, 55–64 (and references therein). F. THUMMLER, H. HOLLECK and L. PRAKASH: High Temp–High Press. 14, 1982, 129–141. A. FERNANDEZ GUILLERMET: Z. Metallkunde 78, 1987, 165–171. A. FERNANDEZ GUILLERMET: Int. J. Refractory Hard Metals 6, 1987, 24–27. A. FERNANDEZ GUILLERMET: Z. Metallkunde 80,1989, 83–94. A. FERNANDEZ GUILLERMET: Metall. Trans. A 20, 1989, 935–956.
II.4 Prediction of loss of corrosion resistance in austenitic stainless steels M AT S H I L L E R T and C A I A N Q I U
II.4.1
Introduction
Austenitic stainless steels contain a combination of Cr and Ni which makes them fully austenitic under most practical conditions. The Cr content is usually about 18 wt% or higher which is well above the critical limit for corrosion resistance, about 12 wt% Cr. It is difficult to produce commercial steels without any C and some decades ago it was usual to have around 0.1 wt% C in the austenitic stainless steels. This caused troubles in welded constructions because a Cr-rich carbide may precipitate in the heat-affected zone. The carbide forms at the grain boundaries by C diffusing there from the bulk material. Owing to the slow diffusion of Cr, this element is only taken from a thin layer along the grain boundaries and that layer may thus be drastically depleted of Cr and may lose its corrosion resistance. Clearly, the risk of losing the corrosion resistance would be lower if the C content were lower, and today it is possible to produce austenitic stainless steels with a C content as low as 0.02 wt%. However, for any C content there is a critical temperature below which a heat treatment can produce a depleted zone with less than 12 wt% Cr. It would be of considerable practical value to be able to predict the critical temperature of any composition, i.e. for any combination of Cr, Ni and C contents. Such predictions will now be presented.
II.4.2
Theory
An accurate calculation of the formation of the depleted zone would require a detailed consideration of the diffusion-controlled growth of the C-rich carbide. However, a rough estimate can be made already from the thermodynamic information on the Fe–Cr–Ni–C system, using the following method. For chosen values of the temperature and Ni content, the C activity in the reaction zone along the grain boundaries can be calculated from the carbide– 106
Loss of corrosion resistance in austenitic stainless steels
107
austenite equilibrium assuming that the C content of the austenite will be at the critical value of 12 wt%. In view of the very large difference between the diffusivities of C and Cr, it may be assumed that the rate of precipitation is controlled by the rate of Cr diffusion and that C has sufficient time to diffuse over long distances and eliminate all differences in C activity. One may thus assume that the calculated C activity is also valid in the austenite far away from the grain boundaries and at an early stage of the reaction it will be equal to the initial C activity. One may then calculate the critical value of the initial C content of a steel, which will give a depletion of Cr down to 12 wt%. In the above calculation it is necessary to make some assumption regarding the Ni content in the depleted zone of austenite. The Cr-rich carbide will normally contain less Ni than the austenite and the Cr-depleted zone will thus be enriched in Ni. A quantitative calculation of this enrichment requires a consideration of the rate of diffusion of Ni relative to Cr and is outside the scope of the present work. Stawstrom and Hillert [69Sta] chose to neglect this effect and simply assumed that the initial Ni content is also valid in the Cr-depleted zone. This approximation will be accepted in the present work and the calculations of Stawstrom and Hillert will now be repeated but using an improved description of the thermodynamic properties of the Fe–Cr–Ni– C system.
II.4.3
Results
Figure II.4.1 shows the critical C content in a steel with 8 wt% Ni as a function of the Cr content at four temperatures. For instance, in a steel with 18 wt% Cr (and 8 wt% Ni) a C content of just over 0.05 wt% will give the critical condition at 800 °C. Below that temperature the Cr content in the depleted zone will be less than 12 wt%. These curves were calculated as described in the preceding section. The slopes of the curves in Fig. II.4.1 show that more C can be tolerated if the Cr content is higher. This conclusion holds in spite of the fact that C and Cr both increase the tendency of forming the Cr-rich carbide. This apparent contradiction is demonstrated for 900 °C in Fig. II.4.2. The explanation is that Cr has a strong decreasing effect on the activity coefficient of C in austenite. The relative positions in Fig. II.4.1 demonstrate a very strong effect of temperature. One must go to exceedingly low C contents in order to decrease the critical temperature below 600 °C. Figure II.4.3 shows the critical C content in a steel with 18 wt% Cr as a function of Ni content at four temperatures. The slopes of these curves show that less C can be tolerated if the Ni content is higher. An increase from 8 to 24 wt% Ni decreases the tolerable C content to half.
108
The SGTE casebook 600 °C
24
700 °C
23
Cr (wt%)
22 800 °C
21 20 19
900 °C
18 17 16
0
0.05
0.10 0.15 C (wt%)
0.20
0.25
II.4.I. Conditions for the formation of a depleted zone with a Cr content of 12 wt% in steels with 8 wt% Ni. 25 24
Equilibrium conditions at 900 °C
23
Cr (wt%)
22 21
Critical conditions at 900 °C
20 19 18 17 16 0
0.05
0.10 0.15 C (wt%)
0.20
0.25
II.4.2 Comparison between equilibrium conditions and conditions, where the Cr content in the depleted zone goes down to 12 wt%. The Ni content is 8 wt%.
Figure II.4.4, Fig. II.4.5 and Fig. II.4.6 show similar diagrams for higher Cr contents. The set of diagrams in Fig. II.4.3, Fig. II.4.4, II.4.5 and Fig. II.4.6 covers the most common range of compositions in austenitic stainless steels.
Loss of corrosion resistance in austenitic stainless steels
109
24 22
Ni (wt%)
20 18 900 °C
16 14 12
800 °C
10
700 °C
8 600 °C 0
0.05
0.10 0.15 C (wt%)
0.20
0.25
II.4.3. Conditions for the formation of a depleted zone with a Cr content of 12 wt% in steels with 18 wt% Cr.
24 22
Ni (wt%)
20 18 900 °C 16 14 800 °C
12 700 °C
10
600 °C
8 0
0.05
0.10 0.15 C (wt%)
0.20
0.25
II.4.4 Conditions for the formation of a depleted zone with a Cr content of 12 wt% in steels with 21 wt% Cr.
Figure II.4.7 shows the same kind of information plotted in a different way. Here the critical temperature is plotted as a function of the carbon content for a number of Cr contents and 8 wt% Ni. It is again demonstrated that very low C contents are required in order to decrease the critical temperature to low values. For comparison, the equilibrium temperature is plotted in Fig.
110
The SGTE casebook 24 22
Ni (wt%)
20 18
900 °C
16 14 800 °C 12 10
700 °C
8 600 °C 0
0.05
0.10 0.15 C (wt%)
0.20
0.25
II.4.5 Conditions for the formation of a depleted zone with a Cr content of 12 wt% in steels with 24 wt% Cr.
24 22
Ni (wt%)
20 18
900 °C
16 14 800 °C
12 10 8 0
700 °C 600 °C 0.05
0.10 0.15 C (wt%)
0.20
0.25
II.4.6 Conditions for the formation of a depleted zone with a Cr content of 12 wt% in steels with 27 wt% Cr.
II.4.4. For 0.10 wt% C and 18 wt% Cr the difference is 130 K. For 27 wt% Cr it is twice as high because the higher Cr content increases the equilibrium temperature but decreases the critical temperature. Of course, the curves in Fig. II.4.8 also show how high the temperature is that must be reached in order to dissolve carbide which may have precipitated during a previous heat treatment.
Loss of corrosion resistance in austenitic stainless steels
111
1000 950 900 18% Cr
Temperature (°C)
850 21% Cr 24% Cr
800 750
27% Cr
700 650 600 550 500 0
0.02
0.04 0.06 C (wt%)
0.08
0.1
II.4.7. The variation in the critical temperature, where the C content of the depleted zone goes down to 12 wt%, with the C content of steels with 8 wt% Ni and 18–27 wt% Cr. 1000 950
27% Cr 24% Cr
900 Temperature (°C)
18% Cr 21% Cr
850 800 750 700 650 600 550 500 0
0.02
0.04 0.06 C (wt%) in fcc
0.08
0.1
II.4.8 The variation in the temperature, below which carbide starts to precipitate, with the C content of the steels considered in Fig. II.4.7.
II.4.4
Discussion
In the present work it has been assumed that the critical limit for the Cr content is 12 wt%. It should be realised that this critical limit most probably depends upon the composition of the steel. For instance, it seems to be well
112
The SGTE casebook
established that Mo may also contribute to the corrosion resistance and it seems most likely that Ni will also have an effect, maybe a negative one. As a consequence, the predictions presented in the present work should only be used as a guideline. The predicted effects of changing the Cr, Ni and C contents are probably more reliable and can be used if one wants to predict how a change in composition will affect the tendency of a steel to lose its corrosion resistance. In an attempt to make the predictions more accurate, one may try to estimate how much higher the Ni content will be in the Cr-depleted zone than in the bulk. A very rough consideration of the rates of diffusion of Cr and Ni showed that the local Ni content in the depleted zone may be higher by a factor of 1.3. In order to demonstrate the effect of such an enrichment, a series of calculations were carried out for a bulk content of 8 wt% Ni. See Fig. II.4.9 which should be compared with Fig. II.4.1. It is evident that this effect is almost negligible.
II.4.5
Method of plotting diagrams
The present calculations were carried out using the Thermo-Calc databank [85Sun]. It has a special feature for automatic calculation of diagrams involving two different but related equilibria in each step [90Hal] which can be illustrated by reference to Fig. II.4.3. In this case, each calculation is carried out in two steps. In the first step, one defines the conditions of equilibrium between the carbide and austenite, 25 24
600 °C 700 °C
23 800 °C
Cr (wt%)
22 21
900 °C
20 19 18 17 16 0
0.05
0.10 0.15 C (wt%)
0.20
0.25
II.4.9 Conditions for the formation of a depleted zone with a C content of 12 wt% in steels with 10.4 wt% Ni.
Loss of corrosion resistance in austenitic stainless steels
113
by first giving the pressure (1 bar), temperature, Ni content (a value between 7 and 25 wt%) and Cr content (12 wt%) of the austenite and requiring that the carbide will be present but without giving its composition. The C content of the austenite required by the two-phase equilibrium is then calculated automatically and its C content is stored. In the second step a one-phase system of austenite is considered under the same pressure, temperature and Ni content, with the Cr content of the steel (18 wt%) and with the C activity obtained from the first step. Its C content is then calculated and is tabulated together with the Ni content used. The procedure is repeated with another Ni content until the range of Ni contents has been covered. Then the whole calculation is repeated for a new temperature. Finally, the content of the table is plotted. The other diagrams could be calculated similarly because it is possible to define the conditions for each equilibrium calculation in any way and to transfer any condition or result of the first calculation into the conditions for the second calculation.
II.4.6
Database
The present calculations were carried out with a database for the Fe–Cr–Ni– C system which has recently been completed [90Hil] and included in the Thermo-Calc databank. For the present calculations, information on austenite and M23C6 were used.
II.4.7 69Sta 85Sun 90Hal 90Hil
References C.O. STAWSTROM and M. HILLERT: J. Iron Steel Inst. 207, 1969, 77–85. B. SUNDMAN, B. JANSSON and J.-O. ANDERSSON: Calphad 9, 1985, 153–90. B. HALLSTEDT and L. HOGLUND: Unpublished work, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, 1990. M. HILLERT and C. QUI: ‘A thermodynamic assessment of the Fe–Cr–Ni–C system’, Technical Report TRITA-MAC 420, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, 1990.
II.5 Prediction of a quasiternary section of a quaternary phase diagram M AT S H I L L E R T and S T E F A N J O N S S O N
II.5.1
Introduction
In order to visualise the phase diagram of a quaternary system under constant temperature and pressure, one would need three dimensions. However, in some cases, much information can be presented in a quasiternary section. This is the case for the Si–Al–O–N system where all the condensed phases fall in or very close to the section defined by the corners Si3N4, SiO2, Al2O3 and AlN as if all the phases were ionic and composed of Si4+, Al3+, O2– and N3–, which is not quite true. It has been possible to model the properties of the condensed phases using models which restrict their existence to the section mentioned. The modelling will now be described briefly and it will be demonstrated that it was possible to extrapolate the properties of the ternary side systems and to use the meagre information available from the quaternary system in order to predict the phase relations [91Hil2].
II.5.2
Solid phases
There are two solid Si3N4 modifications, α and β, but their relative stabilities are not well known and it is difficult to separate information on their individual properties. In the present work the α phase was completely neglected. The βSi3N4 phase extends far into the quaternary Si–Al–O–N system and, from a practical point of view, it is the most important phase in this system. The Si2N2O phase also extends into the system but has found less practical use. Inside the quaternary system these phases are often denoted by β′ and O′ respectively. In addition, there is a quaternary phase denoted by X. Its composition is not well known but will be treated as a stoichiometric phase with the composition Si12Al18O39N8. Finally, there is a whole series of socalled polytype phases related to AlN and situated close to the AlN corner. Their stabilities and properties are not well known and in the present work they were simply represented by one of them, the so-called 27R phase, which was treated as a stoichiometric phase on the AlN–Al2O3 side. 114
Quasiternary section of a quaternary phase diagram
II.5.3
115
Modelling
It was assumed that the β′ phase can dissolve Al in the Si sublattice and O in the N sublattice. Accepting the normal valencies the formula was thus written as (Si4+, Al3+)3(N3–, O2–)4. A general type of model for phases with mixtures of elements on two different sublattices, called the compound energy model [70Hil, 86And], has been developed and programmed for computer calculations [85Sun]. In the present case a special procedure must be used in order to ascertain that the composition stays inside the quasiternary section. It is simply based upon the condition of electroneutrality. With this model the β′ phase extends along a straight line from the Si3N4 corner to the AlN · Al2O3 point on the AlN–Al2O3 side. The O′ phase was treated in the same way using the formula (Si4+, Al3+)2(N3–, O2–)2(O2–)1. With this model the phase extends along a straight line from the Si2N2O point to the Al2O3 corner. The modelling of the liquid phase is most difficult. In an attempt to describe the covalent character of the bonds and the tendency to form a network, the SiO2–Si3N4 liquid was described simply by using hypothetical species SiO2 and SiN4/3 [91Hil1]. However, when analysing the properties of Al2O3 in various systems it was found that they could be represented with an ionic model, mainly using Al3+ and O2– [90Hal]. The liquid phase in the quaternary system was finally described with the formula (Al3+)P(N3–, O2–, SiN4/30, SiO20, SiO44–)Q using the ionic two-sublattice model [85Hil]. P and Q are coefficients to be adjusted to satisfy the condition of electroneutrality.
II.5.4
Results
The melting behaviour is particularly interesting in connection with the production and use of materials in this system. Figure II.5.1 shows a projection of the calculated liquidus surfaces but it should not be trusted close to the AlN corner where a number of polytype phases may form. In the other regions of the system the diagram may be regarded as a reasonable prediction based upon extrapolation of the ternary properties from the four side systems and on the meagre information available inside the system. A vertical section through the straight line of existence for the β′ phase is also of considerable interest. Figure II.5.2 shows when β′ starts to melt (see dashed line) and also the phases that it may be in equilibrium with in the case of a small excess of SiO2 (in parentheses). Phase fields, where the β′ phase of a given composition decomposes into β′ of another composition and another phase upon heating, are given without parentheses. It is possible to combine the calculated properties of the solid phases inside the quaternary section with the known properties of the gas phase,
The SGTE casebook Al2O3
SiO2 1873 100
1973
2073
2173
2073
Equivalent O (%)
70 60
Spinel
Al
X
80
2273
2O 3
Mullite 90
2173 O′
2273
50
2373
2373
β′
40
27R
2473
30
73 24 73 25 73 26 773 3 2 287 AIN 73 29
20 2573
10 0 0 Si3N4
20
40
60
80
2973
100 AIN
Equivalent Al (%)
II.5.1 Predicted projection of the liquidus surfaces with isotherms. The values give the liquidus temperatures in kelvin. 2700 2600
+S
P+
2300
LS
SP
β′ + (LS) 2200
β′ + (M) β′ + (O′)
β′+(SP)
β′ +
2100
IN
0.6 xAl3NO3
)
0.4
3
0.2
l 2O
1800
+A
1900
(A β′+
β′ + (X)
SP
2000
1700 0 Si3N4
S
β′
+L
S
2400
SP + β′ + 27R
+L
SP + LS + 27R
LS
β′
2500
Temperature (K)
116
0.8
1.0 Al3NO3
II.5.2 Predicted section through the Si3N4–Al3NO3 line showing equilibria with β-(Si–Al–O–N) (β ′). Two-phase fields with the other phase in parentheses indicate that the amount of the other phase is zero in the section. All regions below the dashed line actually represent 100% β-(Si–Al–O–N). The mullite and spinel phases are denoted by M and SP respectively.
Quasiternary section of a quaternary phase diagram Al2O3 0.1
3
0.2
90
Mullite
X
80
Equivalent O (%)
Spinel
0.4 0.8 1 2
70 60
O′
4
0 20 00 4
50 40
Al 2O
SiO2 100
8
β′
10
800
30
20
1000
27R
40
20
20 40 AIN 80
80
10 0
117
100 0
20
40
60
Si3N4
80
100 AIN
Equivalent Al (%)
II.5.3 Predicted projection of the liquidus surfaces with curves giving the vapour pressures in bars.
which in general falls outside the section. In this way it was possible to produce a diagram (Fig. II.5.3) showing what pressure is required in order to prevent boiling before complete melting. Even if the pressure is high enough to prevent boiling, there is a considerable risk of losing material by evaporation and thus changing the composition. The composition may thus move away from the quasiternary section which is in principle possible by the formation of metallic droplets. The calculations for this case study have been performed using Thermo-Calc.
II.5.5 70Hil 85Hil 85Sun 86And 90Hal 91Hil1 91Hil2
References M. HILLERT and L.-I. STAFFANSSON: Acta Chem. Scand. 24, 1970, 3618–3626. M. HILLERT, B. JANSSON, B. SUNDMAN and J. ÅGREN: Metall. Trans. A 16, 1985,261– 266. B. Sundman, B. Jansson and J.-O. Andersson: Calphad 9, 1985, 153–190. J.-O. Andersson, A. FernAndez Guillermet, M. Hillert, B. Jansson and B. SUNDMAN: Acta Metall. 34, 1986, 437–445. B. HALLSTEDT: J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 73, 1990, 15–23. M. HILLERT and S.JONSSON: Technical Report TRITA-MAC 465, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, 1991. M. Hillert and S. Jonsson: Technical Report TRITA-MAC 470, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, 1991.
II.6 Hot isostatic pressing of Al–Ni alloys KLAUS HACK
II.6.1
Introduction
Although there are a number of processes with phase transitions taking place under elevated total pressure, such as in squeeze forging or hot isostatic pressing (HIP), metallurgists tend to neglect the influence of pressure on chemical equilibria since, in most cases, the pressure level is near or even below atmospheric pressure. While geologists have to treat the total pressure as one of their major variables and, therefore, have developed explicit expressions [44Mur] and consistent databases [94Sax], calculations for alloy systems still have to be treated on an approximative level. Often, it is even difficult to find the values of the molar volume of an alloy phase, let alone the thermal expansion, the compressibility or the pressure derivative of the bulk modulus. The following example demonstrates how such a ‘thin’ database can still be applied to provide a reasonable first estimate of the pressure dependence of alloy phase equilibria. However, it should be noted that the Clausius– Clapeyron equation presented in all standard textbooks for the case of a onecomponent system first has to be generalised. In the example, the pressure dependence of the peritectic temperature of the reaction γ + γ ′ = liquid in nickel-based superalloys is calculated. The complex superalloy is approximated by the Ni–Al system, the phase diagram of which is given in Fig. II.6.1. The diagram shows that the phase boundaries between the two solid phases run almost vertically. Since during HIP the γ ′ phase is supposed to dissolve completely in the γ phase, the highest possible temperature is chosen. Theoretically this temperature is the peritectic temperature. On the other hand, the formation of liquid is to be avoided, because, on solidification, microporosity may occur, which is harmful to the mechanical properties. Thus the task is to find a value for the shift of the peritectic temperature on application of a pressure of 2000 bar at which the HIP process is operated. 118
Hot isostatic pressing of Al–Ni alloys
119
1650
1648
Temperature (K)
Liquid 1646
1644 γ 1642 γ′ 1640 0.70
0.72
0.74 0.76 Mole fraction of Ni
0.78
0.80
II.6.1 Phase diagram of the Ni–Al system.
II.6.2
Generalised Clausius–Clapeyron equation
Pelton and Schmalzried [73Pel] have shown that the phase boundaries in a phase diagram are mathematically governed by a Gibbs–Duhem equation with generalised potentials and conjugate extensive properties:
ΣQiϕ dΦi = 0
(II.6.1)
where ϕ is the number of equilibrium phase. With Φi = T, –P or µi as the potential, S, V, and the mole numbers ni must be used as the conjugate extensive properties. If the pressure dependence of equilibrium has to be calculated, only the first two terms (Sϕ dT – Vϕ dP) apply, as all changes in chemical potentials are zero at equilibrium. For a two-phase equilibrium in a one-component case the Clausius–Clapeyron equation is derived easily from 1 2 S 1 dT – V 1 dP = S 2 dT – V 2 dP[= 0] → dT = V 1 – V2 (II.6.2) dP S –S Note that this equation applies not only to a phase transformation of an element but also to all two-phase equilibria with one Gibbsian component, i.e. those cases in which both phases have the same composition with respect to all elementary components as stated by Gibbs [878Gib]. Examples are Zn(s) = Zn(l), but also H2O(s) = H2O(l), CaO · A12O3 · 2SiO2 = liquid, or azeotropic points in organic systems. It is also worth mentioning that the absolute values of entropy and volume are used, i.e. the conjugate extensive
120
The SGTE casebook
properties to temperature and pressure respectively although, because of the ratio, the result is the same if molar quantities are inserted. For a three-phase equilibrium such as a eutectic or peritectic in a binary system (binary in the sense of the phase rule), three equations of the above type are obtained. In the general case, all three phases are solution phases and thus the composition in each phase may vary with pressure. Thus it becomes more obvious that the slope dT/dP is calculated for a certain fixed value P°. One obtains 3 2 1 1 3 2 2 1 3 dT = ( x – x )V + ( x – x )V + ( x – x )V 3 2 1 1 3 2 2 1 3 dP ( x – x )S + ( x – x )S + ( x – x )S
(II.6.3)
with xϕ the mole fraction of component two in phase ϕ, and Vϕ and Sϕ the integral molar volume and entropy respectively of phase ϕ. The numerator can easily be interpreted as the volume change ∆V(1 + 2 → 3) (eutectic) or ∆V(l→2 + 3) (peritectic) of the respective reaction with the appropriate interpretation of the entropy changes in the denominator. A more general treatment of pressure dependence of all types of phase boundary has been given by Hillert [82Hil].
II.6.3
Application to the Ni–Al equilibrium
The data required for the application of the above equation to the Ni-rich equilibria in the Ni–Al system are summarised in Table II.6.1. Thermochemical data have been given by Murray [89Mur] who found eutectic behaviour between the liquid, γ and γ ′, while Sundman and Ansara [90Sun] in a more recent assessment concluded a peritectic reaction. The majority of the volume data had to be based on assumptions (e.g. the additivity of molar volumes of the component elements for the solution phases), interpolations or comparisons with similar metals. Different databases had to be used for the solid and the liquid state [75Tou, 90Lan]. It became obvious during the search for these data that there is a striking lack of precise data with respect to the pressure dependence for alloy calculations. From the data in Table II.6.1 the shift of the melting point of nickel (Ni(s) = Ni(l)) is calculated to be dT/dP = ∆V/∆S = 3.223 × 10–8 K Pa–1. For the eutectic reaction according to Murray, one obtains dT/dP = 4.92 × 10–8 K Pa–1, while the peritectic reaction according to Sundman and Ansara leads to dT/dP = 5.07 × 10–8 K Pa–1. Thus, for an HIP pressure of 2000 bar = 0.2 GPa, the melting temperature of nickel is raised by 6.446 K, and the three-phase equilibrium by 9.84 K or 10.14 K respectively. Consequently, under HIP conditions, the maximum operating temperature may be chosen to be about 10 K higher than the annealing temperature at ambient pressure.
Hot isostatic pressing of Al–Ni alloys
121
Table II.6.1 Univariant phase equilibrium in the system Ni–Al (a) Pure nickel: Ni(s) = Ni(l), Tm = 1728.3 K
∆V* (m3 mol–1) ∆S† (J mol–1 K–1)
3.26 × 10–7 10.1139
(b) Eutectic reaction [89Mur]: γ ′ + γ = liquid, Teut = 1658 K
XNi V × 106* [ m3 mol–1] S‡ [J mol–1 K–1]
γ′
γ
Liquid
0.740 8.126 2.168
0.798 7.891 4.184
0.750 8.71 15.209
(c) Peritectic reaction [90Sun]: liquid + γ = γ ′, Tper = 1643.4 K
XNi V x 106* [ m3 mol–1] S§ [J mol–1 K–1]
Liquid
γ
γ′
0.756 8.658 6.3774
0.787 7.928 –3.2833
0.760 8.037 –5.2587
*Based on the work by Touloukian et al. [75Tou] and by Lang [90Lan]. †Based on the work by Dinsdale [91Din]. ‡Relative to solid Al and Ni. § Relative to liquid Al and face-centred cubic Al Ni.
II.6.4
Conclusions
The generalised Clausius–Clapeyron equation yields a precise mathematical expression for the pressure derivative of univariant temperatures in binary (or higher-order) systems. The type of the univariant equilibrium (peritectic or eutectic) and data for the entropy change of the reaction can be calculated for a good number of systems from different thermochemical assessments, while volume data are still very scarce. Nevertheless, for the Ni-rich part of the Ni–Al system the resulting pressure derivatives of the univariant temperatures can be used for reasonable estimates of temperature changes on application of technically feasible pressures.
II.6.5
Acknowledgement
The author wishes to thank Professor D. Neuschütz, LTH, RWTH Aachen, for drawing attention to this subject matter.
122
II.6.6
The SGTE casebook
References
878Gib J.W. GIBBS: ‘On the equilibria of heterogeneous substances’, Trans. Conn. Acad. 3, 1878. 44Mur F.D. MURNAGHAN: Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. 30, 1944, 244. 73Pel A. PELTON and H.S. CHMALZRIED: Metall. Trans. 4, 1973, 1395. 75Tou Y.S. TOULOUKIAN et al.: in Thermophysical Properties of Matter. Vol. II, (Ed. Y.S. Touloukian), OFI–Plenum, New York, 1975. 82Hil M. HILLERT: Bull. Alloy Phase Diagrams, 3(1), 1982, 4. 89Mur J. MURRAY: Private communication. 90Lan G. LANG: in Handbook of Chemistry and Physics (Ed. D.R. Lide), CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, 1990. 90Sun B. SUNDMAN and I. ANSARA: COST507 Database, 1990. 91Din A.T. DINSDALE: Calphad 15, 1991, 317–425. 94Sax S. SAXENA, N. CHATTERJI, Y. FEI and G. SHEN: Thermodynamic Data on Oxides and Silicates, Springer, Berlin, 1994.
II.7 Thermodynamics in microelectronics A L E X A N D E R P I S C H and C L A U D E B E R N A R D
II.7.1
Introduction
The ongoing size reduction of the individual transistor and the growing number of active and passive devices within an integrated circuit are the current challenges in the microelectronics industry. The higher integration of devices allows higher clock frequencies and improves speed and performance but, at the same time, serious technological problems have to be solved. Some classical materials, such as insulating SiO2 as the dielectric and conducting Al for interconnects, which were used in the last 50 years, have instrinsic properties that are no longer good enough on a reduced scale. They have to be replaced by materials with improved electrical, mechanical and chemical properties. As examples for these new materials, one can cite HfO2 and SrTiO3 as promising new dielectrics. Metallic Cu is the choice for interconnects, but its high chemical reactivity requires the use of diffusion barriers such as TaN or W. However, these barriers are often insulating and therefore other materials such as conducting amorphous Ru–Si–O or Ir–Si–O are also under investigation. Integrated circuits have a multilayered structure of thin films with various thicknesses which are deposited by different techniques and complex process steps. Chemical stability is therefore a critical issue and thermodynamic calculations can provide valuable information. Two main fields are concerned. 1
2
Phase stability. Is the material stable with its environment or is it likely that interface reactions occur during thermal treatment of the complete structure? Is it possible to etch the material in order to obtain the desired geometric structure? If the answer is yes, by which technique and with which reactants? Materials synthesis. By which technique can the new material be deposited (evaporation, sputtering or chemical vapour deposition) and which are the optimum experimental conditions (temperature, total pressure and precursors)? 123
124
The SGTE casebook
Performing a thermodynamic modelling can provide at least qualitative answers to these questions. The thermodynamic approach will be illustrated on four examples: SrTiO3 film deposition by using organometallic precursors and interface stability of the thin film with the Si substrate, reactive ion etching of HfO2 thin films and thermal stability of Ru–Si–O and Ir–Si–O amorphous thin films upon annealing.
II.7.2
Thin-film deposition of SrTiO3 and interface stability with Si
Chemical vapour deposition of complex oxides using organometallic precursors is a process that is now widely used in microelectronics industry. The advantages of this process are process compatibility, good control of the deposition parameters, coverage of non-planar surfaces and selectivity depending on the nature of the substrate. In the case of SrTiO3, organometallic precursors such as Sr(thd)2 (thd = C11H19O2) and Ti(i-Opr)2(thd)2 (i-Opr = C3H7O2) are dissolved with a given stoichiometry in a suitable liquid organic solvent. In this study, monoglyme (1,2 diethoxymethane) (C4H10O2) was used. The dissolution of the highly reactive organometallic precursors in the solvent has the advantage of stabilising them chemically. Small quantities of the liquid are injected into the reaction chamber in a repetitive manner for reaction with O2 to form the oxide layer. The use of calibrated injection pumps increases considerably the reproducibility of this process. This liquid injection CVD process has still a large number of experimental parameters which have to be controlled. – – – – –
Total pressure in the reactor. Deposition temperature. Precursor concentration in the liquid solution. Injection frequency. Ar + O2 carrier gas flow.
The main goal of a thermodynamic modelling of the deposition process is to establish the parameter intervals for which a pure SrTiO3 thin film can be obtained [003Ran]. A two-dimensional plot is generally chosen to present the results of these calculations. The two axes correspond to two independent experimental parameters, all other conditions remain constant. It is important to mention that kinetic effects are not taken into account. It is supposed that the reactions at the surface are fast enough to obtain a local equilibrium. This is in general the case for oxide deposition from organometallic precursors. The SGTE Substance Database [006SGT] is used for thermodynamic calculations. No thermodynamic data are available for the organometallic compounds; therefore their complete decomposition at the surface was
Thermodynamics in microelectronics
125
supposed. As an example for the results of this thermodynamic modelling, the precursor ratio of Sr(thd)2 to Ti(i-Opr)2(thd)2 as a function of Ar+O2 carrier gas flow is simulated at 700 °C and a total pressure of 6.6 mbar and the results are reproduced in Fig. II.7.1. The precursor concentration is fixed at 0.02 M and the injection speed is 2.5 × 10–5 cm3 s–1. Pure SrTiO3 can only be obtained for an equimolar ratio of the two precursors and log(Ar+O2) partial pressures greater than –3. For lower carrier gas flow rates, carbon co-deposition is expected, because the oxygen potential is too low to transform the carbon and hydrogen of the solution into CO(g) or CO2(g) and H2O(g). If the precursor ratio deviates from unity, secondary phases such as TiO2 or Sr4Ti3O10 may occur. Experiments confirm the validity of this simulation approach. Thin-film deposition in the vicinity of the full code in Fig. II.7.1 revealed that it is difficult to obtain single-phase SrTiO3 because of process fluctuations during deposition. Secondary TiO2 and Sr4Ti3O10 are identified by X-ray diffraction and transmission electron microscopy [004Lho], in excellent agreement with the modelling. It is important to mention that the experimental precursor ratio to obtain near single-phase SrTiO3 differs from unity. This disagreement arises because transport phenomena and gas-phase diffusion are neglected. The qualitative agreement is good and the real diagram is only shifted when taking into account the transport and the diffusion in the modelling. The thermodynamic calculations serve therefore as a starting point for further simulations. In order to simulate quantitatively the deposition behaviour in a specific type of chemical vapour deposition reactor, a coupling of homogeneous and heterogeneous thermodynamics, kinetics, diffusion and heat and mass transport phenomena is necessary [002Ber]. After having demonstrated that it is possible to deposit near single-phase SrTiO3, the interface compatibility with the Si substrate is the main issue. The interface quality is the key parameter for the electrical properties of the material. In order to investigate the stability of SrTiO3 on Si, the Sr–Ti–O–Si quaternary phase diagram was calculated at 700 °C. The isothermal tetrahedron is presented in a reduced form in Fig. II.7.2. Nine four-phase equilibria including SrTiO3 were identified and are plotted separately in Fig. II.7.2 for better readability. It can be easily seen from these results that an SrTiO3–Si interface is not in thermodynamic equilibrium. There are, however, three possible threephase equilibria with SiO2: SrTiO3–SiO2–TiO2–Ti4O7, SrTiO3–SiO2–Ti4O7– Ti3O5 and SrTiO3–SiO2–SiSrO3–Ti3O5. As a consequence, the occurrence of secondary phases at the interface during film formation or annealing of SrTiO3 on Si are expected. An experimental study has shown that this interface reaction layer actually forms during thin film deposition. This layer has two distinct components: SiO2 and an amorphous or nanocrystalline phase with
PT i
log10(PSr)/log10(PTi) 0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
126
PSr
1.4
–1
SrCO3
TiO2
SrTiO3 + Sr4Ti3O10
–2.5
–3
–3.5
–4
–4.5
SrO + C
log10 [flow rate(O2 + Ar)]
–2
SrTiO3 + TiO2
SrCO3 + Sr4Ti3O10
SrO + C + Sr4Ti3O10
SrTiO3 + TiO2 + C
TiO2 + C
SrTiO3 + Sr4Ti3O10 + C
–5
II.7.1 Deposited phases for a precursor ratio of Sr(thd)2 to Ti(i-Opr)2(thd)2 as a function of Ar + O2 carrier gas flow at 700 °C and 6.6 mbar. The precursor concentration is 0.02 M and the injection speed is 2.5 × 10–5 cm3 s–1.
The SGTE casebook
–1.5
Thermodynamics in microelectronics Si3Ti5
SrTiO3
TiO Si4Ti5
TiO
Si3Ti5
SiSrO3
SiSr2O4 SrTiO3
SrTiO3
TiO SiO2
SiO2
Si2Ti
SrTiO3
Ti3O5 Ti2O3
TiO
SiO2
SiTi
TiO2
SiSrO2
Ti4O7
SiS2O4
Ti3O5
SrTiO3 TiO2 SrO
Sr
SrTiO3
Ti2O3
SrTiO3
SiSrO3
SrTiO3
Si4Ti5
Si
TiO
Sr4Ti3O10
SiSr2O4
SiSrO3
127
Sr4Ti3O40
Si4Ti5
SiSrO3
Si3Ti5 SiTi3
SrTrO3 Ti3O5
TiO Ti
II.7.2 Isothermal tetrahedron of the Sr–Ti–O–Si system at 700 °C. The nine four-phase equilibria including SrTiO3 are plotted separately.
a silicate signature in X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy analysis [004Lho]. From the equilibrium diagram, one can conclude that this silicate may correspond to SrSiO3.
II.7.3
Reactive ion etching of HfO2 dielectric films
Insulating HfO2 is a promising material for use as dielectric in complementary metal–oxide-semiconductor devices. For process integration of this new highk material, a process-compatible etch step has to be developed. Different process integration issues must be addressed: etch rate, etch uniformity and etch selectivity with respect to the SiO2 interface layer without damaging the underlying Si substrate. Plasma etching is considered to be the most viable technique to etch thin films of HfO2.To determine the most promising chemistry among the usually adopted halogen-based reactive gases, thermodynamic equilibrium calculations are performed. The goal is to select the most suitable gas or gas mixture with optimised process conditions, which means a maximum amount of volatile etch by-products for a given temperature and overall pressure. Although the process takes place at a low temperature, the use of a plasma assures the activation of the etch gases and thermodynamic equilibrium can be expected at the sample surface. The SGTE Substance Database [006SGT] is used for the simulation of the etch process. The first results show that fluorine-based gases are not suitable for this etch process, because the vapour pressure of HfF4(s) is too low.
128
The SGTE casebook
Therefore, the main focus is on chlorine-based chemistry. HfCl4(s) has a low melting point and exhibits high vapour pressures even at low temperatures. Different mixtures are investigated and the results of this study are summarised in Table II.7.1. Pure chlorine gas alone or a Cl2 + O2 mixture does not etch the HfO2 thin films even at temperatures as high as 700 K. One has to add a carboncontaining gas species to reduce the oxide and to transport the oxygen via the gas phase. CCl4 works theoretically but was not investigated experimentally. A Cl2 + CO gas mixture results in an HfCl4(g) + CO2(g) gas phase with considerable etching at low temperatures. The etch rate can be calculated from the Hertz–Knudsen relation [001Dum] by using the results from the thermodynamic equilibrium calculations [006Hel].
II.7.4
Annealing of amorphous Ru–Si–O and Ir–Si–O thin films
RuO2 and IrO2 are promising materials because of their high electrical conductivity, which is a rather unusual property among oxides. By simultaneous deposition with Si, one can obtain ternary amorphous layers with a nominal composition of Ru0.2Si0.15O0.65 and Ir0.2Si0.15O0.65. The films are obtained by reactive sputtering in an Ar + O2 plasma [99Gas, 001Che]. These materials can be used as a gate in GaAs metal–semiconductor field effect transistors or as a diffusion barrier against Al, Au, Ag and Cu [000Nic]. The thickness ranges from 100 to 200 nm. In order to relax mechanical constraints in the films due to the low-temperature deposition technique, a high-temperature anneal must be performed. This process step also increases the electrical conductivity. The annealing behaviours of the two different materials are completely different and the results are summarised in Table II.7. 2. Thermodynamic equilibrium calculations were performed in the Ru–Si– O and Ir–Si–O ternary systems using the SGTE Substance Database [006SGT]. No Gibbs energy data are available for iridium silicides. Their thermodynamic functions are estimated using the experimental enthalpy of formation from Table II.7.1 Thermodynamic and plasma etching studies for HfO2 at 5 × 10–6 bar Thermodynamic calculations Gas mixture
Etching
Gas species
Plasma etching at 423 K
Cl2 Cl2+O2 CCl4 Cl2+CO HCl
No No Yes, from 400 K Yes, from 400 K No
Cl2, Cl Cl2, O2, Cl HfCl4, CO2, CO, Cl2 HfCl4, CO2, CO, Cl2 HCl
No No Not performed Yes No
Thermodynamics in microelectronics
129
Table II.7.2 Annealing behaviour of Ir–Si–O films Atmosphere
Ru–Si–O
Ir–Si–O
Vacuum (≈10–9 bar)
800 °C for 5 h : amorphous 1000 °C for 30 min, nanocrystalline
1000 °C, metallic Ir
1 bar O2
700 °C for 5 min, crystalline + Ru loss + reaction with Si substrate
700 °C for 1 h, amorphous
the work of Meschel and Kleppa [98Mes1, 98Mes2]. A complete modelling of the Ru–Si and Ir–Si binary systems was not necessary because the process temperature is low enough to avoid the formation of a liquid phase and the oxygen chemical potential is high enough to avoid the reduction of SiO2 to Si. The amorphous phase was not modelled because the relative stability of this phase upon anneal seems to indicate that its Gibbs energy is close to that corresponding to a mixture of crystalline phases. The first step in the thermodynamic analysis of the annealing behaviour is the calculation of the ternary phase diagrams at the corresponding annealing temperatures [001Pis]. The isothermal section of Ru–Si–O and Ir–Si–O at 700 °C are presented in Fig. II.7.3(a) and Fig. II.7.3(b). Both diagrams show similar topologies with tie lines from metallic Ru or Ir to SiO2 and a threephase equilibrium Ru–RuO2–SiO2 or Ir–IrO2–SiO2. The main difference is the oxygen chemical potential inside these three-phase equilibria. While in the case of Ru this value is 2 × 10–8 bar and therefore close to the secondary vacuum pressure, it is 2 × 10–4 bar in the case of Ir. The consequence is that the amorphous phase in the Ru–Si–O system has no driving force to decompose, because the imposed pressure is close to the equilibrium value. This is not the case for Ir, where the equilibrium pressure is four orders of magnitude higher. The amorphous phase is reduced and metallic Ir is formed, which is observed experimentally. The equilibrium pressures of the gas species are low in vacuum. In the case of Ru–Si–O, RuO3(g) has a partial pressure of 5 × 10–11 bar and RuO4(g) a partial pressure of 10–13 bar. For Ir–Si–O, the partial pressures are 5 × 10–9 bar for IrO3(g) and 8 × 10–14 bar for IrO2(g). It is important to mention that the species IrO4(g) does not exist. The partial pressures change dramatically if the anneal is performed in oxygen at 1 bar. In this case, the partial pressure of RuO4(g) reaches a value of 4 × 10–6 bar and that of RuO3(g) a value of 3 × 10–7 bar. The sum of both values is five orders of magnitude higher than in the case of the vacuum anneal. The observed loss of Ru in the layer can therefore easily be explained by the vaporisation of Ru as RuO4(g). At the same time, the vaporisation seems to favour recrystallisation in the film. In
130
The SGTE casebook O 1.0
0.8 SiO2 0.6
RuO2
0.4
Mo
le f
rac
tio
no
fO
2 × 10–8 bar
0.2
0 0 Si
0.4 RuSi 0.6
0.2
0.8
Ru4Si3
Ru2Si3
1.0 Ru
Mole fraction of Ru (a)
1.0
O
0.8
2 × 10–4 bar
IrO2
Mo le fra cti on of O
SiO2 0.6
0.4
0.2
0 0 Si
0.2
0.4 IrSi 0.6
IrSi3 IrSi2
0.8
Ir2Si Ir3Si
1.0 Ir
Mole fraction of Ir (b)
II.7.3 Calculated isothermal sections of (a) the Ru–Si–O ternary system and (b) the Ir–Si–O system, both at 700 °C.
the case of Ir–Si–O, the partial pressures remain small, even under oxygen at 1 bar and the amorphous layer is stable.
II.7.5
Conclusions
Thermodynamic equilibrium calculations using the calculation-of-phasediagrams approach and the SGTE databases can give valuable insight into all
Thermodynamics in microelectronics
131
fields in the microelectronics industry. The benefits range from the definition of the chemical stabilities of new materials with improved properties to the determination of optimised process conditions. Thermodynamic process simulations can therefore save time and money in the development of new integrated-circuit devices with improved performance.
II.7.6 98Mes1 98Mes2 99Gas 000Nic 001Che 001Dum 001Pis 002Ber
003Ran
004Lho 006Hel 006SGT
References S.V. MESCHEL and O.J. KLEPPA: J. Alloys Compounds 274, 1998, 193. S.V. MESCHEL and O.J. KLEPPA: J. Alloys Compounds 280, 1998, 231. S.M. GASSER, E. KOLAWA and M.-A. NICOLET: J. Appl. Phys. 86(4), 1974. M.-A. NICOLET: Vacuum 59, 2000, 716. H.B. CHERRY, P.H. GIAUQUE and M.-A. NICOLET: Microelectron. Eng. 55, 2001, 403. L. DUMAS, C. CHATILLON and E. QUESNEL: J. Cryst. Growth 222, 2001, 215. A. PISCH and C. BERNARD: Calphad 25(4), 2001, 639–644. C. BERNARD: in Fundamental Gas-phase and Surface Chemistry of Vapor Phase Deposition II/Process Control, Diagnostics and Modeling in Semiconductor Manufacturing IV, Electrochemical Society Proceedings, Vol. 2001-13, Electrochemical Society, Pennington, New Jersey, 2001, p. 245. E. RANGEL-SALINAS, A. PISCH, C. CHATILLON and C. BERNARD: in Chemical Vapour Deposition XVI and EUROCVD 14, Electrochemical Society Proceedings, Vol. 2003-08, Electrochemical Society, Pennington, New Jersey, 2003, pp. 243– 248. S. LHOSTIS: PhD Thesis, Institut National Polytechnique de Grenoble, France, 2004. M. HELOT, T. CHEVOLLEAU, L. VALLIER, O. JOUBERT, E. BLANQUET, A. PISCH, P. MANGIAGALLI and T. LILL: J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 24(1), 2006, 30–40. SGTE: SGTE Substance Database, V.11, 2006.
II.8 Calculation of the phase diagrams of the MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 system at high pressures and temperatures: application to the mineral structure of the Earth’s mantle transition zone O L G A F A B R I C H N A YA
II.8.1
Introduction
According to geophysical data the Earth consists of a core (solid inner core and liquid outer core), a solid mantle and a crust. The borders between these parts of the Earth are indicated by seismic wave discontinuities. Figure II.8.1 presents the distribution of seismic waves VP and VS and density ρ in the Earth’s interior derived from seismological data. The mantle consists of a homogeneous lower mantle, where there are no pronounced seismic discontinuities, transition zones with two main discontinuities at 400 and 650 km depth accompanied by increases in the seismic wave velocities
Velocity (km–1 s) or density (g cm–3)
VP 12
r
10
VP
8
VS Core 6
r
VS
4
2 Mantle 0
2000
4000 Depth (km)
II.8.1 Seismic profile of the Earth.
132
6000
Phase diagrams of the MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 system
133
and density, and an upper mantle where the partial melting zones are indicated by decreases in the seismic wave velocities. Chemical analyses of rocks originating from deepest parts of upper mantle are available (i.e. peridotites, eclogites and lherzolites) and the possible composition of the whole mantle could be assumed on the basis of these data. The mantle composition up to about 95% is described by the MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 system. Ringwood [75Rin] assumed that the transition zone and lower mantle are formed by ‘pyrolite’ rock consisting of olivine (Mg, Fe)2SiO4, pyroxene (Mg, Fe)SiO3 and garnet (Mg, Fe)3Al2Si3O4 minerals. Experiments at high pressures and temperatures demonstrated that silicate minerals transform to denser structures at pressures corresponding to the depth of seismic discontinuities [83Jea]. Therefore, if data for the Gibbs energy of mantle-forming minerals are available, it is possible to calculate mineral assemblages stable at pressures and temperatures of the mantle transition zone and to attribute seismic discontinuities to changes in mineral assemblage. To calculate the Gibbs energy of the stoichiometric compound or end member of solid solution at high pressures, equation-of-state (EOS) parameters are necessary additionally to thermochemical information (enthalpy, entropy and heat capacity). One of the simplest equations of state is the Murnaghan [44Mur] equation. To calculate the volume of a compound at a high pressure and temperature, information on the volume in the standard state, the isobaric bulk modulus, its pressure derivative and the thermal equation is necessary. This kind of information for pyrolite-forming minerals and their high-pressure modification are partially available from experimental measurements. These data were combined with the results of modelling based on the theory of lattice vibrations, Raman and infrared spectra of compounds by Saxena et al. [93Sax]. Thus a consistent set of EOS parameters was derived. The calculationof-phase-diagrams (CALPHAD) method was applied to derive the thermodynamic database for minerals in the system FeO–MgO–Al2O3–SiO2 using thermochemical data and EOS parameters together with experimental phase equilibria at high pressures [004Fab]. The Gibbs energy of solidsolution minerals were described by compound energy formalism except for pyroxene, which is described by substitutional model. To verify the reliability of the thermodynamic description, many types of phase diagram for subsystems were calculated and compared with experimental data. The pressure distribution in the Earth’s interior is quite well determined from geophysical data, while the temperature estimates are less precise (±200 K in the transition zone). The calculated P–T diagram for pyrolite composition allows us to relate the seismic discontinuities observed in the mantle transition zone to chemical transformations in minerals. Based on the obtained results a density profile could be calculated [92Ita]. These data combined with the shear modulus make it possible to calculate the sound velocity profile [89Duf]. A comparison of the calculated profiles with seismic data allows us to verify
134
The SGTE casebook
the chemical composition of the Earth’s mantle [92Ita]. The thermodynamic data for minerals are also important for modelling convection in the mantle [88Tru].
II.8.2
Phases and models
Most mantle minerals are solid solutions and their Gibbs energies depend on the composition. The mixing parameters L depend on the temperature and pressure. The P–T dependence of the Gibbs energy for end members of solid solutions is described below. The Gibbs energy G of a pure phase and the end members of solid solutions at a certain P and T is expressed as
∫
° + G ( P , T ) = ∆ f H 298
T
298
+
∫
° C P dT – T S298 +
∫
T
298
CP dT T
p
(II.8.1)
V dP
1
° is the entropy, ∆ f H 298 ° is the enthalpy of formation from the where S298 elements and CP is the heat capacity given by CP = a + bT + cT–2 + dT2 + eT–3 + f T – 0.5 + gT –1
(II.8.2)
The molar volume as a function of pressure and temperature is calculated using the Murnaghan equation
K′ P V ( P , T ) = V (1, T ) 1 + P KT
–1/ K P′
(II.8.3)
where KT is the isothermal bulk modulus expressed as KT =
1 β 0 + β 1 T + βT 2 + β 3 T 3
(II.8.4)
and K′P is the pressure derivative of bulk modulus which in some cases has a temperature dependence: K P′ = K PT ′ r + K PT ′ ( T – Tr ) ln T Tr
(II.8.5)
K PT ′ r is the pressure derivative of bulk modulus at Tr = 298.15 K, and K′PT is its temperature derivative. The molar volume at 1 bar is expressed as a function of temperature by
V(1, T ) = V1,0Tr exp
∫
T
Tr
α ( T ) dT
(II.8.6)
Phase diagrams of the MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 system
135
where V1,0Tr is the molar volume at 1 bar and Tr=298.15 K, and α(T) is the thermal expansion depending on temperature and given by
α(T) = α 0 + α 1T + α 2T
–1
+ α 3T
–2
(II.8.7)
The parameters are related to each other by C P = C V + α 2 V TK T T
γ=
α KT V CV
(II.8.8) (II.8.9)
where γ is the Grüneisen parameter; also
KS =
K T CP CV
(II.8.10)
where KS is the adiabatic bulk modulus. Compressibility could be derived from different experimental data (static compression, shock-wave data and Brillouin scattering). CP is measured by calorimetric techniques (differential scanning calorimetry at high temperatures and adiabatic calorimetry at low temperatures). The volume and thermal expansion are determined from X-ray diffraction data, dilatometry or picnometry. If information on Raman and infrared spectra is available, the heat capacity CV at constant volume could be estimated using the Kieffer [79Kie] model. A review of experimentally determined EOS parameters and thermochemical values for stoichiometric minerals and end members of solid solution has been given by Fabrichnaya et al. [004Fab]. A list of the phases and models of solid solutions are presented in Table II.8.1.
II.8.3
Phase equilibria in subsystems
The development of high-pressure apparatus (piston–cylinder, Bridgman anvils, diamond anvil cell and multianvil split-sphere apparatus) with simultaneous heating made it possible to reach the pressures and temperatures of the Earth’s mantle [87Aki]. It was discovered that quartz (SiO2) transforms to denser phases of coesite and stishovite (rutile structure) under pressure increase. Ringwood and Major [70Rin] were the first to discover that olivine transforms at 14 GPa to the structure of distorted spinel (β) and to normal spinel (γ) at 18 GPa. Later olivine–β–γ phase transformations in the Fe2SiO4–Mg2SiO4 system were studied in detail by Akimoto [72Aki]. Liu [75Liu] was the first to find the post-spinel transformation of γ -spinel to a mixture of perovskite and magnesiowustite and the formation of phases with ilmente structure and perovskite at pressures of 20–25 GPa in the MgSiO3 composition [76Liu]. The phase diagram of FeSiO3–MgSiO3 system was studied in detail by Ito
136
The SGTE casebook
Table II.8.1 Phases and models in the system MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 Phase (abbreviation)
Formula
Olivine (Ol) β-spinel γ-spinel Orthopyroxene (Opx) Protopyroxene (Ppx) HP-clinopyroxene (Hpcpx) Ilmenite (Ilm, Il1) Perovskite (Pv) Garnet (Gar) Magnesiowustite (Mw) Spinel (Sp) Magnesioferrite (Mf) α-quartz (α-Q) β-quartz (β-Q) Tridymite (Tr) Cristobalite (Cr) Coesite (Coes) Stishovite (St) Hamatite (Hem)
(Fe2+,Mg2+) 2SiO4 (Fe2+,Mg2+) 2SiO4 (Fe2+,Mg2+) 2SiO4 Al2O3–FeSiO3–MgSiO3 (Fe2+,Mg2+)SiO3 (Fe2+,Mg2+)SiO3 (Al3+,Fe2+,Mg2+)(Al3+,Si4+)(O2–)3 (Al3+,Fe2+,Mg2+)(Al3+,Si4+)(O2–)3 (Fe2+,Mg2+)3(Al3+,Fe2+,Mg2+)(Al3+,Si4+)(Si4+) 3O12 (Fe2+,Fe3+,Mg2+,Va)(O2–) (Fe2+,Mg2+)(Al3+)2(O2–)4 (Fe2+,Mg2+)(Fe3+)2(O2–)4 SiO2 SiO2 SiO2 SiO2 SiO2 SiO2 Fe2O3
and Yamada [82Ito] at 1373 K using the multianvil split-sphere apparatus. Phase relations in the Fe2SiO4–Mg2SiO4 system were studied by Yagi et al. [79Yag] in a laser-heated diamond anvil cell at 1273 K and pressures up to 30 GPa. Experimental investigations of the Mg4Si4O12–Mg3Al2Si3O12 system indicated that the Mg4Si4O12 solubility in the garnet phase increases with increasing pressure, attaining a maximum at about 15 GPa (see the papers by Akaogi and Akimoto [77Aka] and Kanzaki [87Kan]). At high temperatures and high pressures, garnet and ilmenite structures form solid solutions in the whole composition range of the Mg4Si4O12–Mg3Al2Si3O12 system. According to the experimental data of Irifune et al. [96Iri] the solubility of the Al2O3 in perovskite structure is limited. A review of the experimental data for different subsystems in the FeO–MgO–Al2O3–SiO2 system has been presented by Fabrichnaya et al. [004Fab]. A review of experimental thermodynamic data for mantle minerals has also been given by Fabrichnaya et al. [004Fab]. Navrotsky [94Nav] derived the enthalpy of formation for several high-pressure phases by high-temperature oxide melt solution calorimetry. The temperature dependence of CP was determined by Watanabe [82Wat] using the technique of differential scanning calorimetry for several mantle minerals. Missing values were derived using the CALPHAD technique by Fabrichnaya et al. [004Fab].
Phase diagrams of the MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 system
II.8.4
137
Phase diagrams for selected subsystems of the FeO–MgO–Al2O3–SiO2 system
The P–T phase diagrams for the systems of olivine (Mg2SiO4) and pyroxene (MgSiO3) compositions are presented in Fig. II.8.2(a) and Fig. II.8.2(b). The calculated phase diagrams were compared with experimental data by Fabrichnaya et al. [004Fab]. It was shown that calculations were in agreement with available experimental phase equilibria within uncertainty limits except 26 Pv + MgO 24 γ
P (GPa)
22 20 18
β
16 14
Ol 12 1000
1500
2000
2500
T (K) (a) 26 Pv 24
P (GPa)
22 Ilm 20 Gar
γ + St 18 β + St 16 14 1000
Hpcpx
1500
2000
2500
T (K) (b)
II.8.2 Phase diagrams of (a) the Mg2SiO4 system and (b) the MgSiO3 system. For the meanings of the abbreviated phases, see Table II.8.1.
138
The SGTE casebook
for the data obtained by Irifune et al. [98Iri], indicating that the pressure of γ-spinel decomposition is 2 GPa lower than other studies. The calculated phase diagram of the Mg2SiO4–Fe2SiO4 system at pressures up to 30 GPa is presented in Fig. II.8.3. The phase relations in the pyroxene compositions (MgSiO3–FeSiO3) at 1373 K and 2073 K are shown in Fig. II.8.4(a) and Fig. II.8.4(b) respectively. The calculated phase diagrams for both systems were compared with available experimental data obtained by Fabrichnaya et al. [004Fab]. It was indicated that they agree within experimental uncertainty. It should be mentioned that iron partition between perovskite and magnesiowustite was extensively studied experimentally because of its importance for understanding the mineral composition of the lower mantle. However, there is still uncertainty in the partition coefficient obtained by different experimental techniques. The calculated partition coefficient [004Fab] is in agreement with data obtained by Ito and Yamada [82Ito] and by Fei et al. [91Fei]. The calculated phase diagrams for the Mg4Si4O12–Mg3Al2Si3O12 system at 1273 K and 1773 K at pressures up to 30 GPa are presented in Fig. II.8.5(a) and Fig. II.8.5(b) respectively. These calculations clearly demonstrate that the solubility of the Mg4Si4O12 in garnet in equilibrium with pyroxene increases with increasing pressure. The solubility of the Mg4Si4O12 component in garnet reaches a maximum in invariant equilibrium with pyroxene, stishovite and β-spinel. At higher 30 Pv + Mw
Pv + Mw + St Mw + St
25
P (GPa)
20
γ + Mw + St
γ β
15
Ol + γ 10 Ol 5 0 Mg2SiO4
0.2
0.4
0.6 x(Fe SiO ) 2
4
0.8
1.0 Fe2SiO4
II.8.3 Phase diagram of the Mg2SiO4–Fe2SiO4 system at 1873 K. For the meanings of the abbreviated phases, see Table II.8.1.
Phase diagrams of the MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 system
139
26 24 22
Pv
Pv + Mw + St
llm
P (GPa)
20 18
γ + Mw + St
γ + St
Mw + St
Gar
16 14 Hpcpx
12 10 0 MgSiO3
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
x(FeSiO ) 3
1.0 FeSiO3
(a) 30 Pv
Pv + Mw + St Mw + St
25 llm
γ + St + Mw
P (GPa)
20 γ + St β + St 15 Hpcpx + γ + St 10 Hpcpx 5 0 MgSiO3
0.2
0.4
0.6
x(FeSiO ) 3
0.8
1.0 FeSiO3
(b)
II.8.4 Phase diagram of the MgSiO3–FeSiO3 system at (a) 1373 K and (b) 2073 K. For the meanings of the abbreviated phases, see Table II.8.1.
140
The SGTE casebook 30 28 26
Pv Pv + ll1 Pv + llm
llm
24
P (GPa)
22
llm + Gar
20 γ = St + Gar
18
β = St + Gar
16
Gar
14 Hpcpx + Gar
12 10
0 Mg4Si4O12
0.2
0.4 0.6 xMg3Al2Si3O12
0.8
1.0 Mg3Al2Si3O12
(a) 30 28
Pv + II1
Pv
26
P (GPa)
22
Gar + II1
Pv + Gar
24 llm llm + Gar 20 18 γ + St + Gar
Gar
16 14 Hpcpx + Gar 12 10 0 Mg4Si4O12
0.2
0.4 0.6 xMg3Al2Si3O12
0.8
1.0 Mg3Al2Si3O12
(b)
II.8.5 Phase diagrams of the Mg4Si4O12–Mg3Al2Si3O12 system at (a) 1273 K and (b) 1773 K. For the meanings of the abbreviated phases, see Table II.8.1.
pressures, garnet is in equilibrium with ilmenite or β/γ + stishovite and its stability field decreases. The solubility of the Mg4Si4O12 in garnet also increases with increasing temperature. The calculations indicated the formation of continuous solid solutions in the whole composition range of
Phase diagrams of the MgO–FeO–Al2O3–SiO2 system
141
Mg4Si4O12–Mg3Al2Si3O12 at temperatures above 2000 K. The sequence of phase transformations depends on temperature, at 1273 K, the garnet phase directly transforms to the ilmenite structure while, at 1773 K, garnet decomposes to a mixture of perovskite and an Al2O3-rich ilmenite structure. It should be mentioned that the ilmenite phase has a miscibility gap at 1273 K, decomposing to MgSiO3-rich and Al2O3-rich phases.
II.8.5
Phase diagram of the mantle composition at pressures up to 30 GPa
The phase equilibria in samples