THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL Papers on child development and psychoanalytic training by
MARTHA HARRIS and...
77 downloads
1397 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL Papers on child development and psychoanalytic training by
MARTHA HARRIS and
ESTHER BICK
edited by Meg Harris Williams
published for
The Harris Meltzer Trust by
KARNAC
This revised edition published in 2011 for The Harris Meltzer Trust by Karnac Books Ltd, 118 Finchley Road, London NW3 5HT First published in 1987 by Clunie Press for The Roland Harris Educational Trust as Collected Papers of Martha Harris and Esther Bick, edited by Meg Harris Williams Copyright © 1987 The Roland Harris Educational Trust, 2011 The Harris Meltzer Trust Copyright © 2011 Meg Harris Williams for foreword and editorial matter Copyright © 2007, 2011 Ann Cebon for Appendix II Copyright © 2008, 2011 Margaret Rustin for Appendix III The rights of Martha Harris and Esther Bick to be identified as authors of this work have been asserted in accordance with §§ 77 and 78 of the Copyright Design and Patent Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A C.I.P. for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 978 1 78049 009 0 Cover illustration: Garden pond (watercolour) by Meg Harris Williams Edited, designed and produced by The Bourne Studios www.bournestudios.co.uk Printed in Great Britain www.harris-meltzer-trust.org.uk www.karnacbooks.com
CONTENTS
About the authors
ix
Acknowledgements
xiii
Foreword by Meg Harris Williams
xv
1 The Tavistock training and philosophy (1977)
1
2 The individual in the group: on learning to work with the psychoanalytical method (1978)
25
3 Bion’s conception of a psychoanalytical attitude (1980)
4 The place of once-weekly treatment in the equipment of a psychoanalytically trained child psychotherapist (1971)
45
51
5 Growing points in psycho-analysis inspired by the work of Melanie Klein (1982) 65 v
vi
CONTENTS
6
Esther Bick (1901-1983) (1983)
7
93
Notes on infant observation in psychoanalytic training by Esther Bick (1964)
8
97
The contribution of observation of mother-infant interaction and development to the equipment of a psycho-analyst or psychoanalytic psychotherapist (1976)
117
9
The experience of the skin in early object relations by Esther Bick
(1968)
133
10 Some notes on maternal containment in “good enough” mothering (1975)
139
11 A baby observation: the absent object (1980)
163
12 Towards learning from experience in infancy and childhood (1978)
171
13 The early basis of adult female sexuality and motherliness (1975)
14 Child analysis today by Esther Bick (1962) 15 The therapeutic process in the psychoanalytic treatment of the child (c.1968)
189
207
219
CONTENTS
16 The complexity of mental pain in a six-year-old child following sudden bereavement (1973)
235
17 The child psychotherapist and the patient’s family (1968)
251
18 The family circle (1967)
273
19 Therapeutic consultations (1966)
289
20 Teacher, counsellor, therapist: towards a definition of the roles (1972)
21 Consultation project in a comprehensive school (1968)
305
Appendix I: Martha Harris and the Tavistock course by Donald Meltzer
345
Appendix II: Supervision with Esther Bick by Ann Cebon
347
Appendix III: Esther Bick’s legacy of infant observation at the Tavistock by Margaret Rustin
375
References
391
Index
397
vii
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Martha Harris (1919-1987) was born Martha Gemmell Dunlop in Beith, Ayrshire. She read English at University College London, and then Psychology at Oxford. She worked for some years as a schoolteacher, specialising in history, and taught in a Froebel Teacher Training College. She trained as a psychologist at Guy’s Hospital, then as a psychoanalyst at the British Institute of Psychoanalysis, where she was a training analyst; her own supervisors were Melanie Klein and Wilfred Bion and her analyst Herbert Rosenfeld. She worked very closely with Esther Bick and in 1960 became responsible for the Child Psychotherapy training which Bick had established at the Tavistock. She developed this in many innovative ways, making use of both her Kleinian and her teacher-training experience. This course came to attract a very international range of candidates and to become a model for psychoanalytically-oriented clinic work with children and families in many countries (the “Tavi Model”). Together with her husband, Roland Harris (poet and teacher), Martha Harris started a pioneering schools’ counselling service. With Donald Meltzer (psychoanalyst), whom she married after ix
x
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Harris’s death in 1969, she taught widely throughout Europe, and in North and South America and India. They established the Roland Harris Educational Trust, which published for thirty years as the Clunie Press. Martha Harris wrote newspaper articles on child development and the family, and organized a series of books for parents, written by Tavistock therapists. Her most popular book, Thinking about Infants and Young Children (1975) has been published in many languages (new edition 2011). Her books on older children include Your Eleven Year Old, Your Twelve to Fourteen Year Old and Your Teenager, which have since been reprinted in one volume as Your Teenager (Harris Meltzer Trust, 2007). In 1976, at the request of the UN Organization for Economic and Cultural Development, she collaborated with Donald Meltzer on A Psychoanalytical Model of the Child-in-the-Family-in-the-Community, written for multidisciplinary use in schools and therapeutic units. Her many papers on psychoanalytic training, clinical work, and child development, were first collected (though not completely) in Collected Papers of Martha Harris and Esther Bick (Clunie Press, 1987). Most are republished in the present volume, but those specifically on adolescence are published instead in a joint collection by Harris and Meltzer entitled Adolescence (Harris Meltzer Trust, 2011). A tribute to Martha Harris by some of her ex-students is in preparation, to be entitled Enabling and Inspiring (Harris Meltzer Trust). Esther Bick (1901-1983) was a physician and psychoanalyst. She was born in Poland to orthodox Jewish parents and studied under Charlotte Bühler in Vienna, where she began to develop a method for the observation of infants and young children which took into account the need for both scientific objectivity and for making use of the emotional experience of the observer. She married, but separated from her husband before herself emigrating to England in 1938 to escape the Nazi occupation. Here she initially worked in a children’s nursery, whilst having analysis with Michael Balint. She then qualified as a psychoanalyst in London and had further analysis with Melanie Klein. In 1949 John Bowlby asked her to establish
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
xi
an analytic training course at the Tavistock. Here she developed further her Infant Observation method and made it foundational to her view of a psychoanalytic training. In 1960 Bowlby asked her to step down as course leader and Martha Harris succeeded her in this role. Bick continued to teach infant observation and Kleinian child psychiatry at the Clinic until 1967. She also taught privately trainees from both the Tavistock and the Psychoanalytic Institute. She ceased clinical practice in 1980. Although she wrote very little, and reluctantly, her papers proved highly influential, and she was invited to conduct seminars in France, Italy and South America, and her teaching and methodology have since had a profound and growing influence in the UK and abroad.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
A
cknowledgements are due to the following journals in which some of these papers first appeared: “Child analysis today”, International Journal of Psychoanalysis (1962), vol. 43, pp. 328-32; “Notes on infant observation in psychoanalytic training”, International Journal of Psychoanalysis (1964), vol. 45, pp. 558-566; “Therapeutic consultations”, Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1966), vol. 1(4), pp. 13-19; “The family circle: brothers and sisters”, in New Society (15, 22, 29 June and 6 July 1967); “The child psychotherapist and the patient’s family”, in Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1968), vol. 2 (2), pp. 50-63; “The experience of the skin in early object relations”, International Journal of Psychoanalysis (1968), vol. 49, pp. 484-86; “The place of once-weekly treatment in the work of an analytically trained child psychotherapist”, in Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1971), vol. 3 (1), pp. 31-39; “The complexity of mental pain seen in a six-year-old child following sudden bereavement”, in Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1973), vol. 3 (3), pp. 35-45; “Some notes on maternal containment in ‘good enough’ mothering”, in Journal of Child Psychotherapy xiii
xiv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
(1975) vol. 4 (1), pp. 35-51; “Growing points in psychoanalysis inspired by the work of Melanie Klein”, in Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1982), 8:2, 165-184; “Esther Bick”, in Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1983), vol. 9 (2), pp. 101-102. Acknowledgements are also due to Wildwood House which first published “The Tavistock training and philosophy” in The Child Psychotherapist, edited by Dilys Daws and Mary Boston (London, 1977); and to Caesura Press, which first published “The individual in the group: on learning to work with the psychoanalytical method”, in Do I Dare Disturb the Universe? A Memorial to W. R. Bion, edited by James Grotstein (Beverly Hills, 1981). Other papers were first published in Collected Papers of Martha Harris and Esther Bick (Clunie Press, 1987).
FOREWORD
T
he Collected Papers of Martha Harris and Esther Bick were published in 1987, the year of Martha Harris’ untimely death.1 More than twenty years later, it seems appropriate to reintroduce them to a new generation of readers and workers. Since that time, Bick’s work has become widely influential—to a significant extent through its promulgation by Harris, who from the beginning saw her as a “growing point” in psychoanalytic thinking that she determined to help bring into flower.2 Martha Harris was a training analyst for the British Society, working with both adults and children, and in 1960 had taken over from Esther Bick as head of the Child Psychotherapy training at the Tavistock Clinic, then in its cramped Beaumont Street premises. She devoted herself to developing and expanding the course, and to establishing child psychotherapy as a viable profession for the future. As Donald Meltzer has written: “If ever anyone had ‘greatness thrust upon them’, it was the reluctant Mattie at 1
That volume included nineteen papers by Harris (eight previously published) and three papers by Bick (1962, 1964, 1968). Martha Harris was disabled after a car accident in 1984. 2 As in her paper “Growing points”; see this volume, Chapter 5. xv
xvi
FOREWORD
the time when Mrs Bick left the Clinic and it was up to Mattie to either take over or to let the infant Child Psychotherapy course fade away.”1 As Bick wrote in 1962, child analysis was in danger of becoming non-existent; and Harris, like Bick, believed that work with children was crucial for both the community and the vitality of psychoanalysis itself. She ensured that Bick—together with Meltzer, who also specialized in child analysis—continued to provide the backbone of external teaching for the child psychotherapy trainees. When Bick ceased her sessions at the Clinic itself, in 1966, she continued supervising outside it.2 Harris also made full use of the potential offered by the Tavistock’s move to the new building in Hampstead in 1967, in terms of the course’s structure and outreach. Harris’s colleague Shirley Hoxter, who took over leadership of the course from 1981 to 1986, reflected on its history as follows: Martha Harris, herself trained by Esther Bick, succeeded her at the Tavistock and later on developed a longer and more substantial course taking a far larger number of child psychotherapy students. She also widened the scope of the pre-clinical studies to deepen the insights applicable by those of other professions in their work relating to a wide range of child and family care issues… Their teaching events spread far beyond the original base of the child psychotherapy training at the Tavistock and were attended by analysts and psychotherapists from every part of the world.3
Hoxter emphasized that both Bick and Harris excelled in “the live to and fro of spontaneous response in the setting of the seminar or supervision” (1988, p. 102). Of Bick she wrote: Although a poor writer, she was a brilliant educator in her face-to-face contacts with her students, revealing to us an 1
See Meltzer, Appendix I to this volume, p. 345 below. Further page numbers also refer to the present volume unless stated otherwise. 2 See below, Chapter 6, and Appendix II. For an account of the collaboration between Bick and Meltzer at the Tavistock see S. Hoxter, “Experiences of learning with Donald Meltzer” (Hoxter 2000, ,pp. 12-26). 3 S. Hoxter, review of the original edition of Collected Papers of Martha Harris and Esther Bick (Hoxter 1988, p. 102).
FOREWORD
xvii
awareness of the child’s inner world and the recognition of unconscious phantasies and their power to influence personality development. Her methods of infant observation were first developed for our training and influenced all our later work. (Hoxter 2000, p. 15)
Certainly the personalities and presence of both Bick and Harris were a significant factor in their teaching. Owing to her personal charisma and her belief in the efficacy of establishing a work-group atmosphere in which an ethos of fairness and hard work prevailed, and infant rivalries were contained and even used constructively in a scientific spirit, it has not always been recognized objectively to what extent Harris’ structural innovations and modifications were both pioneering and revolutionary. Her introduction of the “work discussion” group, her deepening of the psychoanalytic rationale behind infant observation and seminars, her expansion of psychoanalytic knowledge and techniques into the wider community, were highly personal moves that derived from her own experience in life and in teaching. Close collaboration with her husband Roland Harris (deputy head of an inner London comprehensive school) was also an important factor. “In retrospect”, writes Margaret Rustin, “this shift of gear still takes one’s breath away”1—the change from reliance on authority and bureaucracy, to inspiration by admired figures capable of instilling passionate devotion to the work. In terms of core values, as Meltzer puts it: The central conviction, later hallowed in Bion’s concept of “learning from experience”, was that the kind of learning which transformed a person into a professional worker had to be rooted in the intimate relations with inspired teachers, living and dead, present and in books. (below, pp. 345-46)
In line with this, Harris tried to establish a process of “self-selection” through the stages of the course—which, though it may sound utopian, was actually highly practical in conception: aimed at both fostering hidden talents and at facilitating realistic career choices 1
Margaret Rustin, introduction to the original edition of Harris & Bick’s Collected Papers (Rustin 1987, p. xii).
xviii
FOREWORD
through greater self-knowledge. The application of psychoanalytic knowledge in other fields she believed to be essential both to society and to the survival of psychoanalysis itself, and she sought various means of disseminating it, but always in accordance with “the possible” rather than the ideal—she was above all, a realist. Klein and Bion, her supervisors, were—Meltzer has said— a “great inspiration” to her, equivalent to Bick; yet he adds, she read them only “half-heartedly”; their inspiration for her was derived from clinical work and personal discussion, and can be seen applied in her own writings from the very beginning. She recognized the truth of their ideas partly as a result of her extensive reading in history and literature, and partly through her own reading of human nature, both inside and outside the consulting room, and—in earlier days—in the school classroom. She also saw how to make use of these ideas in a variety of situations. She had a “particular gift” (said Hoxter) for interrelating and integrating “in an apparently effortless way, bringing together areas and levels of experience which most of us find disparate and can only deal with one at a time” (p. 103). It was her “inclusiveness of attention”, Hoxter continues, that enabled her to be such an outstanding therapist, permeated her teaching and [that] comes across clearly in her writings. The comprehensive nature of her awareness heightened both her ability to integrate and also her ability to make fine distinctions. (Hoxter 1988, p. 104).
This comprehensive perspective contributed to her deliberately restrained use of theoretical formulations, and she frequently warns of the limitations of theory, whilst never being an antitheorist (a state of dogmatism in itself ). “Theory is convenient but not sacred”, as she put it: what is needed is a “three-dimensional growing through introjective identification” (p. 21). The value of theories is organizational, not diagnostic: “they enable us to mobilize our attention and our ability to see more” (p. 62). Like Bion and all the great psychoanalysts she put her faith in observation and sought constantly for means of enhancing it.
FOREWORD
xix
Harris applied the same principles to her students as to her analysands—and indeed to herself: the goal being to learn in a three-dimensional rather than a two-dimensional way, whether alone or in a group. The search for knowledge (Bion’s K-link) was always at the core of any activity that she undertook, for herself or with students. Like Keats who said that “real difficulties nerve the spirit of a man—the imaginary nail him down for a sufferer”,1 her philosophy when faced with conditions that were not ideal was to try to use the deficiency constructively. Thus she describes how having insufficient time can throw into relief the ever-present oedipal and sibling emotions that underlie rationalizations of “it’s not possible”; becoming aware of these “unrealistic idealizations” of oneself and one’s practice can then clear the path for an imaginative solution, and be rewarded by “the exhilaration that thrives upon difficulties” (p. 54). Where Bick wrote reluctantly and to a degree awkwardly, Harris with her literary background had the true writer’s ability to refine understanding through the process of writing; hence, perhaps, her recommendation to all her students to reflect and organize their thinking through written work. Hoxter points out that while none of Bick’s papers “convey the unforgettable brilliance and intensity of her living presence in the seminar or supervision”, Harris writes beautifully and almost each one of her nineteen papers is a delight to read. She makes frequent references to Bick’s paper on “second skin”, contributes two papers specifically relating to infant observations and, additionally, makes frequent further referenes to infant observation. Indeed the whole body of her work evidences the enhancement of sensitivity and the deepening of insight gained from such studies. Harris’s writings therefore provide valuable examples and amplifications of Bick’s papers, bringing these to life and rendering them more accessible to most readers. (Hoxter 1988, pp. 102-103).
Readers will notice that all her papers apart from the very shortest have a similar structure: a survey of the relevant ideas, and a longer section of clinical or observational examples which are 1
Keats, letter to C. Brown, 23 September 1819 (Letters, ed. Gittings (1970), p. 303).
xx
FOREWORD
brought in to frame one or two highly specific points of detail. Having listed the possible permutations and combinations, she then likes to undermine them, in order to demonstrate that learning from experience (as distinct from learning about) takes place only in a context of emotional involvement in a human reality. Her love of precision took the form of an intense focus on the particular—the particular situation, and the individual or individuals within it. “Never sacrifice a child to an ideology”, she once said; and every human situation has within it a child and an ideology. The child is the infant idea that is struggling to take root (in its “creative-destructive” potential in Bion’s terms, p. 27); and the ideology is the exoskeleton of memory and desire. The challenge for both the individual and the group is to “keep the mystical idea of psychoanalysis alive within a formal structure” (p. 27). Frequently Harris documents her own surprise at unexpected developments that fall outside the box and that can only be understood with hindsight, when some almost-overlooked detail emerges from the background and, as in the philosophers’ “selected fact”, organizes the pattern. The fine distinctions that make up the uniqueness of any human situation emerge in the process of trying to accurately describe its minutest features; and as many others have also said (including Bick and Meltzer), seeing and describing happen simultaneously and reinforce one another. When relating a baby observation, for example, she finds that in the process of precise description, a new concept emerges that transcends the expected scenario of baby, thumb and transitional object: Then there is the quality of filling the emptiness, the reminder of the nipple in the thumb which interestingly is perceived as “coming” to her aid at a moment of acute distress, as if it were the agent of an internalized object in advance of the baby’s own conscious control (p. 156).
The meaning of the thumb’s movement is not that of a transitional object controlled by the baby; it is an agent of inspiration—not substituting for but linking with the internal object, after the manner of the “herald” in Emily Bronte’s poem “He
FOREWORD
xxi
comes with western winds”. Hence the need for detailed examples and finding the right words to convey their impact; and hence her encouragement to students to write their observations down—not necessarily for publication (indeed she generally threw her own notes away), but for the purposes of enhanced attention and more penetrating observation. In her later papers she makes more use of Bion’s formulations than in her earlier ones, not because his theories have suddenly percolated into her consciousness, but because she sensed that they were becoming more known and it was therefore possible—without discouraging her audience—to speak in terms of K, O, the “commensal”, and “becoming”, whilst “transpos[ing these ideas] into a lower key” as she put it (p. 28). She was very alert to the dangers of the type of verbalizing that “blurs” observation, and of students being led to misread Bion. Meltzer has described how a certain apparent stutter in her speech was in fact “a complicated process of accommodation between the complexity of her thought and the minute responses of her audience”;1 and the elegance of her writing disguises a similar strenuous accommodation, in which simple expression frequently houses complicated nuance. Read slowly and carefully, these papers constitute a painless way of absorbing difficult ideas—which was indeed the way she taught in person, according to the testimony of her students. It is not only the theorist whom she consistently warns against (the person—or aspect of the self—too much in love with their own verbalization-faeces) but the comforter or reassurer, too much in love with their own mummyishness. Together these seductive faces constitute the false combined object. She often reminds her listeners that the useful qualities of an inspiring object are “strength and sensitivity”, not authority and reassurance. These are the qualities needed in a therapist (p. 221), in order to offer a model to the child (or child-within-the-adult) of learning to cope with unexpected situations, with the reality which is never fully known. For “the attempt to persevere in understanding the dynamics of the situation is in itself therapeutic, even when the understanding 1
Meltzer, foreword to Harris & Bick’s Collected Papers (Meltzer 1987, p. vii).
xxii
FOREWORD
is imperfect—as it must always be” (p. 222). Even when fate seems inexplicably cruel, as in the case of the six-year-old whose father had suddenly died, the answer is not to offer comfort but to make known—in the child’s own language—the complexity of the pain and thus clarify the “muddle” (Chapter 16). The same applies, on a less intense level, to teachers in schools; more than once she gives an example of two types of teacher—the overpraiser, and the accurate assessor who helps the pupil “know where they are” (p. 224). It is reality, not daydream, that enables life to continue and to develop. The essential vitality of a learning attitude is the reason why the presence of a non-judgemental observer in a situation such as infant observation can have a therapeutic effect. It models a position of humility, of educability, which can help the mother to make contact with her internal resources (Chapters 8, 10). This she terms the “respectful” experience (p. 91). It is the reason why infant observation was made central to the work-group containment of the students, as well as to the therapeutic work with children and families. Martha Harris stresses the need for “fellow-feeling” and a “non-directive” approach with children who have or cause difficulties (pp. 17, 307), not because it is nicer, but because it is more effective. This fellow-feeling can be acquired by the observer who is using their privileged position not only to gain knowledge about mother-baby interaction but also to gain self-knowledge. Not only are the nuances of non-verbal communication best learnt through mother-infant observation, but also, the process of knowing one’s own objects—the meaning of introjection.1 For the analytic stance which is genuinely useful in situations in the wider community is primarily self-analytic, rather than the application of psychoanalytic theories. It enables people to “distinguish appropriate goals from the impossible ones of deluded omnipotence” (p. 339)—to assess a situation realistically. The key premise of Martha Harris’s vision for a better society is that any 1
As one of Martha Harris’ students, Margot Waddell, has recounted: on beginning the training she asked what exactly was introjection? to which the “gnomic” answer was “wait and you will find out” ( personal communication). In other words, there is no point defining what can only be learned from experience, on the pulses.
FOREWORD
xxiii
worker’s usefulness increases exponentially with their self-knowledge, because this enables them to deal with situations which have not been stamped with a name; and any condition which has been named is liable also to have been partially obscured. Before autism was commonly diagnosed, for example, she had in her clinical vocabulary two different types of developmental interference: the “omnipotent distortions” that are traditionally the subject of the psychoanalytic treatment of neurotic patients, and another type that she calls “turning away” (p. 224). Later, in the context of subsequent work on autism, which she includes loosely alongside second-skin and two-dimensional personality structure, she advocates a closer inspection of the “lacunae” in ourselves (p. 175). Her view is that these autistic or “turning away” features exist in everyone, just as do narcissistic and paranoid-schizoid tendencies, and it is only the ability to recognize them in oneself that equips the analyst to cope with such cases. Consequently the psychoanalytic method is no different in new autistic cases from that in old narcissistic cases: the requirement is as always to engage with the infantile transference, and it is the analyst’s responsibility to find a way of establishing this contact—which can be done only through introspection. The same applies to other situations which may not fulfil standard criteria for analytic work: such as non-intensive or short-term therapy. “I have used the word ‘analytic’ advisedly”, she writes in the context of a seven-session analysis, “because the technique used in these sessions was that of following the child’s communications, trying to clarify them in the transference” (p. 236). On other occasions the most practicable or even preferable type of intervention may be a non-analytic one: it may simply be interest, or the sharing of anxieties, which constitutes the “therapeutic or mutative factor” and restores to life a stalled developmental process (p. 313). Here again, it is the therapist’s “personal analysis” that allows for flexibility in determining how to “use the observations he has been trained to make, without consistently employing the psychoanalytic technique of interpreting in the transference” (p. 60). It is what validates the otherwise non-economic exclusivity of psychoanalysis in a needy world where, she says, a balance must be
xxiv
FOREWORD
maintained between intensive practice and social obligation, and indeed is ultimately more developmental for the therapist. To quote once more from Shirley Hoxter: Psychoanalytic practitioners will find particularly valuable her discriminations between infantile elements and adult strivings, between external and internal influences, between transference and countertransference, between pseudo-cooperation or superficiality of development, and a genuine striving towards truth and a greater capacity for bearing mental pain. Harris is aware of the simultaneous existence of such matters and of the strugglings of the student (or experienced therapist or her readers) to encompass such a range and to maintain a state of learning which includes the pains of not knowing and of not idealizing or overestimating (or underrating) the developments to be achieved by psychoanalytic therapy. (Hoxter 1988, p. 104)
Self-scrutiny, therefore, provides the basis for coping with any situation in life, inside or outside the consulting-room. This is her credo, rather than adherence to any authority old or new. Indeed, she warns specifically against treating Melanie Klein as a “latter day saint”, or (anticipating a Bion bandwagon) regarding oneself as “spokesman for some advanced psychoanalytic group”. Instead, she says, One can hope to promote a relationship between fellow workers, students and teachers which might be described by Bion as symbiotic for some, and for the rest at least commensal: coexistent if not mutually profitable. Thus the therapist’s relationships with his patients, objects of study, may take place within a framework of teachers or colleagues who are all dedicated to the task of enlarging their field of observation and of self-scrutiny. In such an atmosphere, hopefully, senior colleagues instead of being content to rest upon positions earned by past achievements, or longevity, may be able to continue or to allow others to continue that process of mental and emotional growth whose infinite possibilities are released, according to Bion, by putting aside memory and desire in order to have a better apprehension of the present moment (p. 32).
FOREWORD
xxv
This volume contains eighteen papers by Martha Harris, of which three were not included in the 1987 Collected Papers; and some from that volume are omitted here as they are being republished in a companion collection on adolescents. The three papers by Esther Bick are reprinted, though they are easily found elsewhere, since they illuminate the historical picture. The order of the papers has been altered from that in the original edition, in order to lead the reader from the Tavistock analytic training and its philosophy, through the role of infant observation, to child analysis and the wider applications in family and society, ending with a paper from the 1960s describing the pilot project in a comprehensive school that she initiated with her husband Roland Harris and that later became the Tavistock Schools’ Counsellors course. Examples of clinical work appear throughout. In three appendices will be found a brief statement about Martha Harris and the Tavistock course by Donald Meltzer; an account of supervision that she had arranged with Esther Bick for one of her students, Ann Cebon; and a review of the legacy of Bick’s method of Infant Observation by Margaret Rustin, a student of Harris and Bick who was head of the Tavistock Child Psychotherapy training from 1986 to 2008. Martha Harris wrote that “Hopefulness informed by experience is the most precious ingredient this work requires; but also, I would think, the realization that it is not possible to hand over one’s experience en bloc in the form of theories or advice” (p. 315). It is however, as Donald Meltzer said, possible for new readers to have “intimate relations with inspired teachers, if not present in life, then in books” (p. 346). Meg Harris Williams Note
The three papers newly included in this volume are: “The place of once-weekly treatment in the work of an analytically trained child psychotherapist”, “Growing points in psychoanalysis inspired by the work of Melanie Klein”, and “Esther Bick”; also additional sections of “The family circle”. Omitted papers by Harris are:
xxvi
FOREWORD
“Depressive, paranoid and narcissistic features in the analysis of a woman following the birth of her first child and the death of her own mother” (1960), whose material is also used in Chapter 10; while “Depression and the depressive position in an adolescent boy” (1965), “Infantile elements and adult strivings in adolescent sexuality” (1976), and “Discussion of an adolescent girl” (1975), are all included in the new collection Adolescence: Talks and Papers by Donald Meltzer and Martha Harris (2011). A further unique tract in collaboration with Donald Meltzer, A Psychoanalytical Model of the Child-in-the-Family-in-the-Community (1976), is also being published separately and was included in Sincerity: Collected Papers of Donald Meltzer, edited by Alberto Hahn (Karnac, 1994).
CHAPTER ONE
The Tavistock Training and Philosophy1 (1977)
This paper covers the main features of Martha Harris’s development and consolidation of the psychoanalytic training founded on infant observation that she inherited from Esther Bick in 1960. In particular she instituted the work discussion group, personality development seminars, and the two-part training that also facilitated the dissemination of psychoanalytic knowledge into the wider community, through workers who would not necessarily train to become psychoanalysts themselves. Her distinctive principle was to encourage “self-selection”. She drew on various sources of personal experience—inspiring teachers (Klein, Bick, Bion), work in schools set up together with her husband Roland Harris,2 teaching and organizational skills, and above all, personal selfanalytic awareness—being firmly convinced that a psychoanalytic attitude is useful in all emotional situations where infant conflicts are inevitably involved and, unless acknowledged and understood, are liable to undermine the work-group ethos. 1 First published in D. Daws and M. Boston (Eds.), The Child Psychotherapist and Problems of Young People (London: Wildwood House, 1977). The editors explain that the Tavistock training in child psychotherapy was one of three existing at that time: the others being at the Hampstead Clinic and the Society of Analytical Psychology. 2 Documented in “Consultation project in a comprehensive school”, Chapter 21. 1
2
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
T
his chapter begins with a brief note on the history of the Tavistock course and its present position in a rapidly changing social framework. I shall try also to describe some of the thinking which has shaped and continues to shape this training, although the responsibility for the views expressed must remain my own. There is some description and discussion of aspects of the content of the course and of our teaching methods. However, no attempt is made to give a detailed account of the syllabus. The history of the course The Tavistock training in child psychotherapy began life in 1948 in the Department for Children and Parents, under the direction of John Bowlby. He saw the need for an analytical training for non-medical personnel practising psychotherapy in clinics. The organizing tutor during the first eleven years was Esther Bick, who set a high standard of learning from precise and detailed observation. This has continued to influence both students and tutors long after Mrs Bick’s retirement. For a number of years applications for this training were relatively few. This was no doubt due to the infancy of the profession, the degree of commitment required and the expense entailed. The current position is very different: despite the expense and commitment, which have not decreased, applications are many and our resources for training are strained. Although the Tavistock Clinic and Institute have expanded greatly and the teaching staff increased, we are able to meet only in a small way the demand for trained therapists. The place of the course The Tavistock is an amalgam of organizations and disciplines accountable to different governing bodies. The Clinic itself is within the National Health Service, which supports the bulk of the training of child psychotherapists, as well as the post-graduate
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
3
training of psychiatrists, psychologists and the advanced training of social workers. Nevertheless it is at present necessary to ask students to pay fees in addition to their personal analysis, as part of the training is supported by the Tavistock School of Family Psychiatry and Community Mental Health. Although the Tavistock is multi-disciplinary, various in its aims and speaks with many voices, there is nonetheless a certain consensus of ultimate goals and beliefs. These give it coherence as an institution. People who study and work there have over a period of time the opportunity to gather a rather wide experience of the way in which different disciplines and departments set about trying to implement their aims. I think all would agree that we are concerned with the promotion of healthy growth in the individual, the family and society. In this aim we pay attention not only to illness but also to the conditions which seem to permit developmental change. We are averse to fostering privilege, although oriented to allowing individual growth and eccentricity. We are aware of the responsibility we have to share with the community at large the knowledge and insights which we as privileged individuals acquire in pursuing our work. We believe that change is initiated by the enthusiasm of individuals and small groups, enabled by the very process of close observation of inter and intra personal relationships. We recognize that the possible quality and range of that observation has been radically affected by psychoanalysis, which obliges the observer to scrutinize himself, his feelings and motivation, the countertransference which may be used to enrich or to distort what he sees. Organization The training is organized in two parts. Minimally it comprises a four-year full-time period. Circumstances may arise, however, which make it desirable or necessary to take some aspects on a part-time basis, and in this case the total course exceeds four years. Students have to complete both parts of the training in order to be recommended for membership of the Association of Child Psychotherapists. The teaching is geared throughout to on-going
4
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
professional work; in the first two years that work takes place in an institution outside the Tavistock. Students are employed in a variety of roles with children, families or young people. Teaching during the first two years takes place in the evenings, so that it is possible for students to work full-time if necessary, but this would ordinarily be undesirable—preparation and writing of observations together with the necessary reading and attendance at seminars themselves should occupy around twenty hours a week during this section of the course. Students are responsible for finding their own jobs during this two-year period. They are accountable to their employers for the work they do. Nevertheless, we are often approached with a request for someone in training to undertake certain work, and are therefore often able to make suggestions to students about suitable employment. The kind of tasks which students are able to undertake during the first part of the course tends increasingly to be determined by their previous training or qualifications. It is likely that in the future the Tavistock will be required to evolve a more official relationship with the employing bodies, but it is unlikely that any tutorial or supervisory role which it has with students could extend to taking responsibility for the work they do with these employers. Of several essential seminars which run throughout the first section of the course, two are now described. The work-study seminar3 Seminar members, who are working in varied settings with children, adolescents and families, take turns to present detailed accounts of some aspects of their work. This presentation almost always includes aspects of the interaction between themselves and their “clients”. The presentation is discussed by the rest of the group, led by a psychotherapist experienced in analytic work with children and adolescents, although not necessarily in the particular work-roles of the group members. 3
Currently known as the “work discussion group”: see M. Rustin and J. Bradley (Eds.), Work Discussion. London: Tavistock, 2008.
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
5
No particular technique is taught in these seminars. The members are encouraged to consider and discuss appropriate ways of dealing with the situations and material described after the possible “meanings” have been explored. The aim of the seminar is to sharpen perceptions and to enlarge imagination, to understand more fully the underlying dynamics of the personality interactions described. Our belief is that education in sensitivity and awareness is a gradual process which takes place through working and discussing work with a more experienced colleague, through a close study of individuals and groups, and of one’s own role and responsibility. As a leader of one such seminar my task would be to elicit as fully as possible the details of the case, the problem, the situation concerned. It takes a little time to do this. Time is also required to allow the other seminar members to feel their way into the situation and to ask questions. The questions can sometimes cause the presenter to remember details he had not registered as important. It then takes further time to consider and to try to link together apparently disparate elements in the presentation, in ways that can make it more immediate and meaningful to the participants. I consider it important to pay attention to the emotions evoked by the case presented, both in the actual work and in the seminar group. Further, to consider these as relevant to the understanding of the material—and whether, in fact, the emotion evoked in us is the one we are meant to feel. In this way one tries to encourage the worker to make use of his own feelings, recognizing that these are a valuable part of imaginative perception without which any relationship and any attitude to work is two-dimensional. It is vital, conversely, to recognize when some of the feeling evoked is not a true response to something actually communicated by the child, but an arousal of inappropriate emotions connected with unresolved infantile conflicts in the worker himself. These may be projected in ways that distort the perception of the child’s real message and individuality. When projection is taking place it seems to me inappropriate to comment upon it in any personal way. It is appropriate, however, to try to make the members of the seminar aware as we go along that such distortions of perception
6
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
happen at times with us all. It is a possibility that has to be kept constantly under review. Projections may be examined and understood by renewed scrutiny of the situation in question, by discussion with colleagues, or by self-questioning. The personal analysis is of course the place in which the student has the possibility of fuller examination of personal motivation, and of disturbances and blocks in the capacity to see and feel for the object. The exchange of experiences in different work settings helps students to feel for the problems which other students encounter and to respect the work which they do. I shall single out for mention here the task which a number of students have undertaken in the past five or six years: that of working with small groups of children in primary schools. This work arose initially out of the request of various head teachers for someone willing to take charge of small groups of children unable to benefit from ordinary class teaching. These were children with behaviour and learning difficulties. Licence was given to the group worker to engage the children in any kind of activity which seemed profitable. This would at least give the class teacher some respite from coping with one or more children whom she found a source of trouble or despair. With these fairly free terms of reference, and despite great difficulties with chaotic and unmanageable children, as with others who began as inert “lumps” and only then went through periods of volcanic and destructive behaviour, many students found this an invaluable learning experience. It was for them, and I think for many of the teachers, both surprising and illuminating to watch the emotional and intellectual development of such a group of children, usually from chaotic and deprived homes. These were often thirsty for the interest and attention shown, relieved at the acceptance of their more unacceptable behaviour and at the opportunity to translate this into more constructive means of communication. In some of these small groups the children achieved a stage of deep intimacy and trust. This made it possible for a rich spectrum of the most intense emotions of infantile dependence, sadness and loss, jealousy and rage, to be talked about and lived through with the worker. Children who were formerly drawn together only in
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
7
collusive, thug-like alliances learned to show interest, friendliness and attentiveness to each other. Such behaviour would have seemed unthinkable in the chaotic early days of a group. Beneficial developments within the group invariably carried over to some extent, sometimes dramatically, into the child’s relationships in the wider areas of school life. There is much to learn from these small groups concerning interpersonal relationships. The parts and roles played by members of the group can be seen to be operating within the individual personality. The experience of taking a group has often helped the therapist of the individual child to describe and talk to these different parts of the child’s personality. Since the work study seminar runs parallel to the infant observation seminar, which I shall describe next, there is some crossfertilization between the two. It may in the future be possible for seminar leaders to initiate more formal and organized ways of making links between relationships and patterns discerned in the work experience and those seen in the baby-mother-family observations. At present we do this where we can and hope that students will be encouraged to integrate the variety of their own experience in a manner which may lead on to further fields of enquiry. The mother-infant observation seminar This seminar was initiated by Esther Bick at the outset of the course in 1948. All the current seminar leaders at the Tavistock have at some time or another taken part in one of her seminars and have made observations themselves. I mention this not only to acknowledge the debt of those of us who have found this a unique method of learning about the fundamentals of personality development, but also to emphasize that this kind of observation does require the help of trained and experienced people if it is to become meaningful. For most people other than the mother concerned the movements of a small baby are chaotic and fairly meaningless except in generalised behaviour terms. One has to allow oneself to come close to the baby in order to see and retain details, and to cope
8
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
with the emotional impact and struggle with a great deal of uncertainty in oneself before understandable patterns begin to emerge. At a distance one baby (or one person) is much like another. This particular seminar more than any other is valuable in helping students to discover the value of being, and themselves becoming, a receptive observer. In this exercise there is no obligation to do anything beyond observing—indeed, one has to learn to refrain from action. The mothers are asked if they are willing to have an observer who, although he may be a professional worker with children and may even be a parent himself, would like the opportunity to learn by observing for one hour each week how an infant grows and develops within a family. The mother is also told that it will be helpful and interesting for the student to be informed of any changes and developments which she has noticed in the baby during the intervening week. Her thoughts and feelings about the baby are welcomed, and one often finds that the interest of the observer seems to encourage the mother to take more notice of the baby as a developing individual. Most people who undertake this exercise find that the closeness to the infant and mother arouses in them extremely intense feelings deriving from their own infancy. These are not always readily recognizable as such, but even when recognized, not to be explained away. Clearly, it is important for the seminar leader to recognize when such feelings are aroused, in herself as well as in other seminar members. She must encourage them to feel both for the mother and for the baby not to over-identify with one or the other. By allowing himself to feel his own countertransference, by trying to contain it and refrain from action or interference, the observer may learn to comprehend the impact on the mother of the responsibility of the baby. He may feel the change and vulnerability evoked in her by her own aroused infantile feelings. He may learn how her sensitivity to the baby and his needs does indeed spring from her capacity to be open to reverberations of his gropings and disturbances, to learn to differentiate among messages by feeling and responding appropriately to them. This, rather than to do what she has learned or been told she ought to do by precept, hearsay or academic psychology.
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
9
Not every mother is able to respond in this way. In some the necessary learning comes only slowly. There is every possible variation in degree and in areas of responsiveness and blindness between mothers, and at different times within each mother, as within all of us. The seminar affords an opportunity to study these personality aspects over a period of two years, together with an opportunity to see the thrust for development in each infant, varying in strength in each case but present in all who live. One can observe the way in which trust and love and a capacity to form object relationships grows in the child through recurrent experiences of being understood. In these ways the student has the opportunity to introject selectively an experience which he can continue to draw on as a model and source for his own development as a therapist with patients. The observation experience helps the student to endure “living in the question” (as Keats put it)4 with his patients, to struggle till he can discern the implications of his first-hand, detailed impressions rather than to flee to premature application of theory. It helps him to see the infant in both the child and the adult, and in his analytic work to stay with that infant and aid him in his arrested or distorted development. It helps him to distinguish movements that are leading towards healthy rather than spurious or superficial growth. It helps to alert him to the significance of minute behavioural indicators and signs of emotion which, when taken into account, add dimension to the quality of his later work. I think observation also helps some of us in our analytic work to avoid premature, anxiety-ridden interpretation and intervention. It helps relax undue therapeutic zeal, allows us to learn to feel and to respect the drive towards development that exists in every patient, as in every baby. It cannot be hurried. It can be facilitated, encouraged and protected, but it cannot be created or forced. One acquires something of this feeling from observing the wise mother who has learned not to push the baby on prematurely. She knows it is illusory to believe that, if she is good enough, she can help him 4
A reference to Keats’s concept “Negative Capability”.
10
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
to grow up without any frustration. She therefore allows him to struggle with what is within his compass. It is possible to note and discuss in this seminar the general tendency at times to find fault with the mother. (Or, in another context, the other therapist or caretaking person.) To believe, surreptitiously, that one could to so much better oneself. One may see how this tendency lies behind he recurrent urge to find psychopathology in everything, the voyeuristic eye that looks to criticize rather than to empathize. One also sees the defences against this same tendency—the projective identification with and idealization of the mother-baby, and blindness to the difficulties with which they are struggling or failing to struggle. These impediments to accurate observation manifest themselves in every group at times. They are important to note and to be taken into account as material for the seminar. As in other working groups, their full significance for the individual student and his contribution towards them are matters for further comprehension within the privacy of the personal analysis. One further point about this seminar. As it is a discussion of observations, not of work undertaken by the participants, a standard not only of detailed but also of freer and more honest reporting is facilitated. In seminars and meetings where individuals present clinical work and results, there is tremendous pressure to trim up, to leave out longeurs, confusions, mistakes, and to organize presentation in a way that pre-empts criticism. The opportunities for mutual learning can be restriected by this desire to present oneself as above reproach. One cannot do away with competitiveness and the need to appear well in the eyes of authority, whoever that authority may be. We are all so tempted. But this seminar focuses attention on the material itself, rather than upon that comparison and measurement of individual performance, which so inhibits honesty and spontaneity in describing one’s work. Training in psychoanalytic psychotherapy The heart of the course, though not its ultimate goal, is the training in the techniques of psychoanalytic psychotherapy. Three cases—a
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
11
very young child, a child in the latency period and an adolescent— are seen on an intensive basis, optimally five times a week. During this part of the training the majority of the students have a sessional appointment at the Tavistock within the National Health Service. Very few spend all their time at the Tavistock, however, as most are working also at some other clinic, where they usually have been given a full-time post and seconded by the Authority concerned for training at the Tavistock. In this way we are able to train more people than the limitations of space and paid establishment at the Clinic itself would permit. For their three intensive cases students have three different supervisors. This arrangement helps to give them some experience of the ways in which different therapists think and work. They also see a number of children and young people whom they treat by the same general techniques on a less intensive basis. They have the opportunity to learn casework with parents and in some instances to conduct analytic psychotherapy with them, when this seems appropriate. This brings us to the often asked question: what is analysis and what is psychotherapy? Is analysis treatment of a patient on a four or five times weekly basis? And is what one does less intensively while using the same basic approach termed psychotherapy? One could use an arbitrary definition, and say that analysis is the method of treatment practised by members of psychoanalytic societies when they say they are practising analysis—however varied their ideas of this may be, and indeed are. I myself shall call psychoanalytic psychotherapy the analytic technique which our students are helped to grasp and to apply five times weekly or less. This is the analysis of the processes set in motion by interpretation of the transference relationship, enriched by private attention to the therapist’s counter-transference (Meltzer, 1967). Its essence consists in the provision of a setting in which the patient is encouraged, through attention to and interpretive descriptions of his total behaviour, to bring to the therapist increasingly unknown and hitherto unacceptable parts of himself. These are experienced in the relationship with the therapist. They are scrutinized together, and hopefully understood and integrated. This brief statement, as
12
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
will be appreciated, is necessarily an oversimplification of a complex process. On the whole, the therapists at the Tavistock employ this analytic technique whether the patient is seen five, four or even one session a week. The criteria for frequency of sessions remain a matter of constant debate and exploration. One of the simplest criteria is that of sheer expediency. If a therapist has a vacancy for an intensive case at a particular time, and if parents are willing and able to bring the child so frequently, or if it is a question of a child or adolescent of an age and sufficiently motivated to bring himself, the intensive help may be offered. I think this proves a better criterion than it may seem, especially if it turns out—as it sometimes does—that the patient’s willingness to attend indicates a willingness also to invest in analytic work. Nonetheless, there are some children who receive five times a week therapy who could have benefited significantly from less. On the other hand, there are some who for a variety of reasons cannot be seen more than once a week—but for whom one may feel this is totally inadequate. There are many fewer of these children, I suspect however, than is generally believed by those who have not had experience in working under clinic conditions. There is general agreement that, whether therapists after their training wish to work intensively or not, the training work on a five times weekly basis is a necessary and valuable core experience. In it students discern and gain conviction of the intensity of infantile transference to the therapist in analytic therapy. As a rule the transference manifests itself most clearly in the rhythm of the five days sessions and the two days week-end. A recurrent experience is afforded of time with the therapist, then time away. When the infant in the patient comes to trust the experience of being closely held by the therapist’s attention, he then has to cope with the break, the absence. We then see what he is able to retain of that previous experience of togetherness. The situation gives the student the most leisurely possibility of being able to study in the analytic therapy what has been glimpsed earlier in infant observation: how the infant may learn to trust, to love and to let
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
13
go, optimally and desirably through gradually introjecting and assimilating the experience of togetherness which he is given. It might in some ways be more accurate to state that analytic therapy is very largely concerned with studying in the transference the factors which militate against the possibility of internalizing—“learning from experience” (Bion, 1962). This study always includes oneself as well as one’s patients, for no development in therapeutic skill can take place without continual re-examination on the part of the therapist. In a field where resources are infinitesimal and need is great, the criteria of selection for frequency of sessions, or indeed for analytic treatment at all, concern all psychotherapists. We have come to realize increasingly that participation in diagnosis and assessment is a necessary part of the therapist’s training. It is likely to play an increasing part in the work he does and in which he can usefully co-operate with psychiatric and other colleagues, utilizing the experience that is accumulated over the years from investigating in depth the developmental potential of the individual. In the later stages of their training, or after qualification, psychotherapists are given the opportunity to be supervised on shortterm consultative work with self-referred adolescents in the Young People’s Consultation Centre and thereby begin to gain some experience of the possibilities and the limitations of this kind of work. Supervisions of clinical work During the first part of the course there is, as a rule, no individual supervision of students’ work unless it is specifically requested. Students, however, may go to their personal tutor to discuss general work problems and programme. If it seems vital that they should receive more support than can be given in the work discussion seminar groups, attempts are made to supply it. During the second part of the course, however, in addition now to individual supervision, students have three weekly clinical seminar groups. Here they have the opportunity to present, and to listen to others
14
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
presenting, material from the treatment of children, young people and parents. Throughout the second stage students are recognized as being responsible for the cases with which they are working, in conjunction of course with the relevant senior colleagues in their place of work. The role of the supervisor in this training is similar to that of the seminar leader, but more personally oriented. The personal supervisor helps the student to think about and better understand the material he is presenting. Equally, to understand the processes of communication, or failure to achieve communication, between him and the patients with whom he is working. The supervisor aims to help the student to sketch tentative maps of the patient’s personality and development. He encourages him in alternative ways of thinking about problems, and sometimes raises questions when all seems too clear or pat. As teachers we ask ourselves questions. How much should we feel we have to tell the student what to say? How far should we go in teaching him to make actual interpretations, and how far should we encourage him to formulate these for himself? It can be appropriate to do both at different times. Even if one is quite convinced that a student recurrently fails to comment upon or even see material that is asking for attention, one can be useful only by trying to approach the material again and again—by describing it ever anew from different angles as it recurs in different contexts. Just as working with a patient one has to do precisely that when trying to illuminate some blind spot. Undoubtedly the attitude of the supervisor can affect the attitude of the student-therapist to the particular case. A mother who is having trouble with her baby is often confirmed in her own inadequacy by some “well meant” advice de haut en bas. In the same way the student struggling with his own inadequacy in practising therapy can be crushed by overknowledgeable interpretations of the supervisor, which take no account of his feelings and his struggles. A supervisor can do much to strengthen or melt away the illusion that there is a “way” which those who have inside information know about. One may arouse feelings of envy and inadequacy, not by genuine and useful attempts to link material together
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
15
meaningfully, but by hinting rather nebulously about areas where the student is not in touch and “hasn’t got it quite right”—yet without offering a helpful alternative. In short, in implying a criticism without being able to document it clearly or to teach otherwise. I suspect that when we so act we are failing to shoulder our own uncertainties. We are failing to recognize or admit how we all have to struggle in the dark towards some glimmer of light. On the other side is the problem of the student who cannot bear to be wrong. He is touchy about being taught and having his work illuminated by someone else. That is his personal problem, with which he has to wrestle in his analysis. The supervisor may discern it and may have to take it into account. I do not think it is necessarily his job to draw attention to the student’s attitude, unless it is intractable. We have a constant task in trying to improve our methods of supervising, just as the student has his in learning how to remember, to record, to present material and ask the questions which can help supervisors to be useful. Written work We try to present students with the opportunity of describing and evaluating what they are learning and the teaching they receive. They are required to write descriptive papers on their observation and work experiences in each of the first two years of the course. If they go on to take the second part of the training they are asked to prepare further presentations and to write papers on some of their cases. The place of theory During their training and general reading the students encounter a variety of theoretical approaches and orientations. They are encouraged to make for themselves meaningful links between the work they are doing and the theories they study. The basis of formal teaching in the course is that of psycho-analytical theory, as developed by Freud in his clinical work and writings and his own self-analysis, which helped him to evaluate this
16
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
more accurately and to deepen the field of his enquiry—in short, to explore the unconscious in himself and in others. In addition, students study in particular Karl Abraham and the theories developed by Melanie Klein and her followers. If Freud discovered the child within the adult, then Melanie Klein revealed the possibility of seeing the infant within the child and the adult. Her work has contributed to our depth of knowledge of ways in which development, through truthfully based object relationships, may proceed in a healthy form. And, of course, of ways in which perversity and psychopathology originate and distort or impede growth (Klein; Meltzer, 1973). The Tavistock course is one which is inevitably known as the Kleinian course in child psychotherapy. Yet it seems a disservice to both the pioneer spirit of Freud and to Melanie Klein herself to label it such. As the years have gone by, many of us who have been intimately involved in the work have come to feel increasingly that the future of psychoanalysis depends not on the learning and propagation of even the most valuable or ‘”respectably” documented theories, but on attention to the conditions in which observations may be made. These allow each student of human nature to realize, and to note in others and in himself, the phenomena on which theories have been based. The furtherance of the work of Freud, of Melanie Klein and of other inspired contributors to the science or art of psychoanalysis, depends on each student living through in his own way that path of discovery—of the interaction between the internal and the external world, the influence of the unconscious upon conscious activities. The journey is made a little easier by using the maps of those who have crossed the wilderness before. But maps read in the cosy safety of home are no substitute for the journey itself. Such cosiness prevents not only further inroads into unknown territory, but the maintenance of ways that have already been cleared. The personal analysis Personal analysis is a requirement for every student who decides he wishes to proceed with the second part of the course. He is
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
17
asked to have about a year’s experience of analysis himself before undertaking analytic cases of his own. Some candidates may have had a personal analysis before they apply, but we do not require students to be in analysis during their first year with us. This is a time of mutual exploration and selection between tutors and students. Our experience over the last few years has shown that many people are able to develop in themselves to varying degrees an enquiring approach of considerable imagination and depth towards the work they are doing, without the experience of being analysed themselves. Many people, when given encouragement to utilize and examine their own emotional responses rather than discard them as unscientific, probably improve greatly the quality and range of their work in the field of personal relationships. Some people who have never had a personal analysis may indeed already be richer and more subtle human beings than others who have. The analyst cannot create the individual, any more than the parents create the baby in that sense. Nevertheless, even the most gifted individuals, capable of extensive learning from experience, do have unknown areas in themselves which can prevent them from learning from experience in particular areas. These unknown or hived-off areas may be discovered and integrated by analysis. The analysis is not part of the course in the way the seminars and discussions are. It remains a private affair. Its purpose is to put the student more fully in possession of himself. Hopefully it will give him the courage to submit himself more completely to observations and experiences from which he may learn, while tolerating degrees of anxiety and pain which he could not tolerate before. Analysis should increase the student’s fellow-feeling for the children with whom he works. Many of these will be quite crushed and stunted in their growth: in order to proceed in their development they need compassion and understanding from an adult, who knows what it is to be in pain or fear—but importantly, also knows how to struggle through it. During the personal analysis it is hoped the student will experience more fully the infant and the child in himself; learn step by step how to contain and educate them; and resolve residual
18
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
grievances and distortions of perception. He should eventually be more free to fully address himself to his patient’s similar problems but unique personality. Qualities desirable in the therapist The qualities of the good therapist are notably hard to define. In the past we have tried a variety of methods of selection for the course. These included group procedures, individual interview and reference to people who know the applicants well. We have never been entirely happy about the effectiveness or fairness of any method. Because of the inherent difficulties of selection we have tried, by dividing the course into two parts, to give individuals the opportunity for self-selection. In this way the candidate can obtain gradual, realistic experience of the kind of work he will be expected to do, the kind of training offered and his own responses to it. However, there has unfortunately still to be some selection even at the preliminary stage, as the demand for training in child psychotherapy continues to grow. Up to a point we work on the basis of first come, first served. Nonetheless, there is no objection to anyone not finding a place making a further application in a succeeding year. Many applicants come in their early twenties before they already have an established profession. Others come at a later point in their careers, when they envisage this training as furthering the development of interests arising from their previous work. Any group of students profits from the inclusion of both younger and more mature individuals from a variety of backgrounds. It is especially enriched in the present case by the inclusion of some from fields outside that of mental health—the humanities, for instance. An education which has afforded the opportunity to specialise in imaginative literature encourages a dimension of perception which may be dismissed as unscientific in many courses of academic psychology. That training takes cognizance of the reality of the inner world of feeling, imagination and values, with which psychoanalysis must be concerned. Such contributions help psychoanalysis not to surface into shallower fields of behaviourist description, nor
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
19
the aridities of Talmudic precept and argument over theory. The future of psychoanalytic work depends on the unswerving realization that the inner world of feeling and imagination is also a matter for scientific study and description. It is important for the profession that it should contain a living core of workers who are devoted to the study itself, but who bring into their consulting room a depth and wisdom from the accumulating experience of their own lives. From the private existence—both external and internal—comes the individual richness of experience. This enables one to be aware with greater sensitivity and precision of the more subtle shades of the patient’s communications and behaviour, more likely to bring about a meeting of minds than an explanation derived from a library of previously learned interpretations. It is equally important for the quality of the therapist’s work, however, that he should live in it and be fed by it, as well as by his private and personal life. It is doubtful whether, in the long run, any fundamental benefit can be derived from a contact between two people which does not benefit both parties. The child psychotherapist, nevertheless, has to acquire the capacity to delay, or rather to refrain from asking for, immediate satisfaction from the patient himself. He has to learn to contain and to struggle with just such qualities which militate against contact and comprehension, both in himself and in the child. In order to be able to learn from experience, and to be able to utilize that wisdom to help others to bear themselves better, a reasonable degree of intelligence is necessary. As a rule, the acquisition of an honours degree guarantees the presence of this. But the possession of intelligence by itself is not enough. Method and motivation for using it are vital. We all use our intelligence, to some extent, to find ways of managing ourselves and the world, ways which help us to avoid feeling small and inadequate. It is a more serious and questionable matter, however, when we use it to make ourselves big at the expense of others. The child psychotherapist has to be able to tolerate feeling small and in the dark, because this is the way a child often feels. This is what the child in us must often feel if he is to remain alive to the wonder and adventure, as well as the hazards, of the world.
20
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
Although the therapist’s private and professional life need to feed each other, at times they seem to interfere with each other For instance, although there is now an increase in the number of male applicants, and increasing recognition of satisfying career prospects for men in child psychotherapy, work with children and young people is likely to continue to have particular appeal for women—especially, perhaps, for young women already married, or likely to marry and have children themselves. It is not, however, enough to love one’s own children. One needs to have enough feeling and generosity to extend this to other people’s children (who represent in the depths of the unconscious one’s mother’s babies). For a time, when one’s own children are young, it may be difficult to find the emotional resource to make the necessary extension. It is, however, an extension which needs finally to be made in the field of work itself. It is not enough, and not in the interests of our own patients ultimately, if our preoccupation with them is so exclusive and intense that we ignore the existence of many others—those others, that is, who do not have the benefit of our special attention, however imperfect that may be. If the benefits of psychotherapy as an art-science are to be shared, it must concern itself with society as well as the individual. As analytical psychotherapists we must realize that it is a privilege, as well as a task, to be able to offer or receive an educational resource so rare and so costly in time and money. It is therefore an obligation, if we have so benefited, to continue to consider how the attitudes which we have found to be essentially life-promoting may be encouraged in others, especially those who have a hand in the rearing of children. For this reason students are encouraged during their training, or shortly afterwards, to take part in a teaching or consultative project, provided by the Tavistock for workers in the social and educational fields. Many participate in small group discussions in the course for teachers and others engaged in aspects of education. The philosophy of the training My own preference is to regard this course not as a training where students are encouraged to model themselves like apprentices on
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
21
their teachers, even on the best of them, but to see it as an opportunity for education in the field of inter- and intra-personal development. In this the students are encouraged to work from their own observations of themselves and of the young people with whom they work. They can be helped to organize their observations by psychoanalytical theory; but they must find and draw upon their own style of working within the psychoanalytical technique. We try to follow an approach which enables the study of links between intrapsychic development and interpersonal family and group relationships. We try to consider the extent to which the individual child seems able to develop by introjecting, assimilating and growing from within—as distinct from the spurious progress made by projecting oneself into unassimilated persons and knowledge. The difference, that is, between the three-dimensional creative growing which proceeds from introjective identification: as opposed to either the two-dimensional socializing, or the “being grown-up” which stops at projective identification. The latter is the “living in someone else’s shoes”; the former the still more impoverished mimicry that clings to surfaces and the appearance of things (Klein, 1946; Bick, 1968). Our method of teaching, as I have already indicated, is essentially through small seminar groups and individual supervisions. These aim to direct the attention of the student towards increasingly close observation of the details of interaction between himself and the individuals he is studying. The course intends to increase the student’s capacity to tolerate uncertainty; to contain, to think about and to use his countertransference, thereby becoming more sensitive to emotional as well as cognitive communication. It aims to help him respond in practice with less certainty of ever having the final answers, but with greater hope of learning, with the help of the patient or client, the direction in which to proceed. This attitude with patients will tend to take the form of interpretations that describe and bring together data in a way that leads on to further enquiry—and not to the kind of explanations that are conversation stoppers. Theoretical teaching and seminar discussion would aim to present theories not as sacred or final, but as convenient. They should
22
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
illuminate methods of organizing observations, of naming and generalising, and bring order out of chaotic experience—yet leave the space and freedom to admit new data. At the end of training one hopes that the student does not emerge feeling “qualified” with a certificate giving him the right to practise psychotherapy, or armed with a method and technique that gives him the edge over the other trainings and techniques. One hopes, certainly, he has learned something tangible. But more importantly, that he has learned how to bear uncertainties and difficult questions. One hopes he retains a deep sense of wonder at the infinite diversities of human nature, together with a great fellow-feeling for his patients. I would hope he has gathered some experience of the ways in which he may continue to explore the split-off or repressed aspects of mental functioning; how to bear the pain of struggling, sweetened by hope derived from hard-won experience. Some of the former students of the course have extended the age range of their clients to work also with adults, an extension which is increasingly taking place within the course. We are also concerned with the wider issues of personality development in families, schools and societies. We hope as therapists to do something towards breaking down the barriers of resentment about the privilege enjoyed by those who receive and practise psychoanalytic treatment. These barriers are erected, understandably, by some of those workers who have responsibility for the many needy not in a position to be helped in this way. We see the training in analytic psychotherapy as a foundation rather than an end, a foundation from which further researches into the infinite variety and complications of the individual and his relationships may proceed. We believe that it is necessary for a stream of analytic work to continue more deeply and more widely, not only because of its therapeutic value but because of its necessary fertilizing effect on all studies of human relationships. Post-graduate developments Ours is a course which owes its existence to the discovery of psychoanalysis. This, however fallible its practitioners, is essentially
THE TAVISTOCK TRAINING AND PHILOSOPHY
23
concerned with the self-realization and striving after truth in every human being. This quality of the teaching and of the work done by anyone who undertakes training in the psychoanalytic method ultimately rests on the way in which he continues to maintain that striving in his own heart; and further, tries to foster it in the patients whom he treats and the colleagues with whom he works. It can be kept alive only by the individual working as best he can, not by his following precepts set by supposedly superior authorities, not by remaining a child who wishes to please the parents, but by working through the crises which any truly developing adolescent has in finding his own mind, identity and style of life. To do this he has to question himself as well as what his parents have taught him, in order to find his best way of realizing in practice the values and experience that stand the test of scrutiny—of promoting and protecting what he loves. In saying this I am aware that it is the exceptional individual who is able to stand alone, who is confident enough about what he thinks and feels in the light of his own experience. The quality of his judgement reflects the capacity to internalize selectively, based upon some fairly clear discrimination between true and false. For most of us it takes a long time to reach a position of relative independence fortified by inner strength; we are often tempted lazily to give up the struggle and settle for our equivalent of the ten commandments, which give at least a sense of knowing how to avoid giving offence to whatever our particular representatives of God or Authority are—feared or idealized, or both. Most of us need help, support and stimulation long after we are trained and “qualified” to practise psychoanalytic therapy. This is not necessarily the help of further analysis—which has its parasitic temptations. We do need the protection of some group within which work may be discussed with colleagues of varying degrees of seniority and experience. It seems to me that such groups should see themselves as gatherings to promote mutual exchange and development, rather than to monitor or judge. Otherwise they may become, as the families of adolescents sometimes do, a restriction, rather than a nurturing resource that allows for and tolerates mistakes made in the struggle for identity and self-responsibility.
24
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
Analytical work inevitably brings the therapist into continual close contact with the relationships and constitutional factors which impede growth. To wrestle with these he has to tolerate the projection of a great deal of frustration, pain and sometimes hatred and reproach from his patients. Like parents who care for their wayward and troublesome children, therapists are also very vulnerable to criticism from the “neighbours”—that is, their own colleagues. It seems to me that as a professional group our health and strength depend upon the capacity of each one of us for self-scrutiny as well as devotion to the work. When we are genuinely able to shoulder the burden of trying to keep our own house in order (a never-ending task), we are more likely to be able to feel for, and to be good neighbours to, our colleagues. There is no group solution for work which is essentially individual. It is also a problem in this field, as in others, for a professional group to maintain an esprit de corps without becoming elitist or heresy-hunting. The problems with which psychotherapists struggle are likely to be slightly different at different times in their careers. As practitioners and teachers we are, in growing older, bound to face encounters with our younger colleagues and students. These are the kind of anxieties that middle-aged parents face when threatened by the growing-up of their children, and by their challenge. Such threats may encourage a dangerous tendency to shore up uncertainties by the collecting of followers or admirers, by using them to further one’s ideas through variations of the patronage system. Anxieties about the future of one’s work and profession can increase fear of change, and promote that kind of conservatism which looks always to be reminded rather than informed. The psychic demands of this work can make it difficult to steer between the narrows of complacency and self-righteous criticism and the whirlpool of disorganization. If we are able to face the demands however, it seems to me that the work may continue to be rewarding in a personal sense into old age, and always conducive to strength and wisdom. As long as we do not surface into clichés, we are continually wrestling with “the enemies of promise”, with the foe within. Where else, as Shakespeare so well knew, can death be defeated but in the inner world? (Sonnet 164).
CHAPTER TWO
The individual in the group: on learning to work with the psychoanalytical method1 (1978)
This paper explores the “Tavistock philosophy” in more specifically Bionian terms of the tension between the individual and the group as container or constricter, with special reference to Attention and Interpretation (Bion, 1970).The author suggests “transposing into a lower key” the turbulence and uncertainty associated with the “new state of mind”. The baby-observation seminar is a prelude to perceiving the emotions that characterize the psychoanalytic couple; and group learning can aim to be “symbiotic” rather than reinforcing basic assumptions. She discusses her method of “continued self-selection” by students; the usefulness of written work; the place of theories or “models” as “organizational tools”; problems of working in institutions; and the dangers of considering oneself a “spokesman” for some “advanced” psychoanalytic group, as distinct from struggling to learn through introjection—“becoming O”.
T
his paper attempts to convey some of the ways in which I see Dr Bion’s work as raising questions and throwing light upon problems of organizing training in psychoanalytical method and attitudes. His thoughts on this topic are most cogently but, as always, often obliquely stated in Attention 1 Written 1978; first published in J. Grotstein (Ed.), Do I Dare Disturb the Universe? A Memorial to W. R. Bion (Beverly Hills: Caesura, 1981), pp. 647-60. 25
26
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
and Interpretation. There he pursues further his ideas about the relationship between the container and the contained; the nature of the transformations effected by the quality of their interaction; the subtle proliferation of mythology and lies which in differing degrees obstruct the search for truth. There he continues the preoccupation which runs throughout his writings, with the relationship between the individual and the group, and, as befits a historian, the relationships between different groups. It is hardly possible to be complacent about the history of psychoanalytic groups or of psychoanalysis in groups. The tension between the pressures of the group and the thrust of the individual for development, is a theme which runs throughout Bion’s work: between man as a social animal dependent upon, and with obligations to society; and man as a developing individual with a mind that grows through introjecting experiences of himself in the world, impelled to think in order to retain internally relationships with needed and valued objects in their absence. Those of us who are concerned with training and the establishment of psychoanalytic work cannot afford to neglect his ideas. The vertex from which I shall be speaking is that of one who has been concerned for over twenty-five years with the practice and training in psychoanalysis in public institutions as well as privately, and in particular with the expansion of the Tavistock training in psychoanalytical psychotherapy with children, parents and young people. This is a four-year training based upon on-going work and is divided into two parts. Part One is concerned with the development of psychoanalytical observation and attitudes in various settings while Part Two is specifically concerned with learning to apply the method of psychoanalysis to treatment, ranging from once weekly to five times weekly. This training qualifies people to become members of the Association of Child Psychotherapists and to join what was initially a somewhat nebulous and almost unrecognized profession, which has now expanded to achieve a salary and career structure within the British National Health Service. This professional respectability carries with it the necessity of conforming to certain minimal criteria changeable only by the agreement of the appropriate committees. These are by definition
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
27
bound to be fairly conservative in their operation and undoubtedly inimical to “catastrophic change”. And yet change and expansion need to be facilitated so that psychoanalytic ideas and attitudes can travel and take root among workers who are ready to receive them, so that their usefulness may find homes in which to flourish. So how does one keep the mystical idea of psychoanalysis alive within such a formal structure? How can a structure remain adaptable and be used to protect, perhaps even to promote the development of the individual worker within it? How can one create a group of professionals, of psychoanalytic workers who are able to function with and among other groups of professionals in a way that reduces interference (is “commensal” in Bion’s terms), and may even be beneficial? To quote from Attention and Interpretation: In the symbiotic relationship there is a confrontation and the result is growth-producing though that growth may not be discerned without some difficulty. In the parasitic relationship the product of the relationship is something that destroys both parties to the association. The realization that approximates most closely to my formulation is the group-individual setting dominated by envy. The envy cannot be satisfactorily ascribed to one or other party; in fact it is a function of the relationship.… In a symbiotic relationship the group is capable of hostility and benevolence and the mystic contribution is subject to close scrutiny. From the scrutiny the group grows in stature and the mystic likewise. In the parasitic association even friendliness is deadly. An easily seen example of this is in the group’s promotion of the individual to a place in the Establishment where his energies are deflected from his creative-destructive role and absorbed in administrative functions… the dangers of the invitation to group or individual to become respectable, to be medically qualified, to be a university department, to be a therapeutic group, to be anything in short, but not explosive.… The institutionalizing of words, religions and psychoanalysis—all are special instances of institutionalizing memory so that it may “contain” the mystic revelation and its creative and destructive force… The function of the Establishment is to take and absorb the consequences so that the group is not destroyed. (Bion 1970, pp. 78-82)
28
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
Perhaps one could transpose this into a lower key and say that the function of the psychoanalytical training group or establishment is to provide a sufficiently protected and organized place in the world within which students are given the opportunity, facilitated by their own personal analysis, to study and to experience development and change, in themselves and in their patients; to study and to work with the elements and configurations which impede that process. If psychoanalytic work, transcending the urge to cure, has an appeal for them, this will be prompted by the emotional impact of the close scrutiny of the children and adults with whom they are concerned. As described by Bion in Elements of Psycho-analysis, the evolution of the transference in the psychoanalytic relationship, involving passion rather than violence (as for example in the form of action by either analyst or patient) is essentially creative-destructive for them both: destructive of existing states of mind and constantly creating others. It may not always be apparent whether the new state of mind is—so to speak—a step in the right direction. It is hard for the teachers and establishment of any group that begins to meet with some success in the world, to bear in mind that they may not know the right direction, that there may not be a right direction, without being formless and disintegrated. It is difficult to allow the individual workers to find their own style and voice in a language and in a setting which enables them to carry on some meaningful discourse. Some of the applicants for the Tavistock course have already sought analysis for their own personal problems. They may be motivated to become psychotherapists themselves partly through projective identification with their analysts, fundamentally still children who believe that to have children/patients will make them grown-up like mummy and daddy. This is a ubiquitous phenomenon and we all probably retain vestiges of it within our personality. Others, however, may wish to learn to work with patients, following some more genuine introjection and appreciation of the attention and understanding from which they have benefited and which they would like to share with others.
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
29
Observation as a prelude to analysis As Part One of the course is concerned not with the application of the psychoanalytic method to the patients, but with the development of psychoanalytic modes of observation and thinking in varied settings, students are not required to have had some experience of analysis themselves before they begin. We attempt to give them a disciplined experience of close observation of the week-by-week development of an infant in a family, of a young child or children. Such detailed observation has inevitably an emotional impact upon the observer which is likely to disturb complacency and to lead to the kind of self-questioning that evokes an interest in personal analysis in those whose desire to get at the truth of themselves is likely to be stronger than their wish to preserve the status quo. The same kind of closer observation of the details of interaction and the responsibilities involved in the work with children, families or young people which students are also doing in this first part of the course, also alerts them to the mental pain as well as to the developmental thrusts in their charges. It enables them to be more receptive of the projections of this which come their way and to see that personal analysis leading to self-analysis is a method for being able to bear this better. These infant observation seminars were initiated by Esther Bick in 1949. They now form part of the curriculum of the British Psychoanalytical Society and have proved to be one of the best preparations for developing those qualities of perception which Bion describes as essential in the psychoanalytic consulting room. The mother-baby couple, initially the baby-breast, can be perceived as a model for the psychoanalytic couple, exemplifying the relationships, for instance, which he categorizes as parasitic, symbiotic or commensal. The discussion of these observations within a small group in which theoretical preconceptions ar relegated as far as possible to the background, can be a model for the work group where the task is to study the aspects of material described and to look at them from different angles until some pattern emerges which speaks for itself. The discussion relates to a situation in which the observer has no responsibility other than
30
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
to notice what there is to be seen while remaining unobtrusively friendly and receptive. As the impulse to action has to be noticed and restrained, the task of the group is to follow, imagine and think about the observations, including the role and effect of the observer, and notice the difficulty sometimes in refraining from taking action to “improve” the situation. Thus one has the leisure to note how relationships develop and change without interpretation or formal intervention. This helps towards the orientation described by Bion in which the analyst realizes that he is observing phenomena from which it is possible to construe mental processes. If one is truly observing configurations which are there and is describing them well enough, unimpeded by theoretical preconceptions, other people with a different theoretical background may, if they can also free themselves from their preconceptions, make similar findings. As it is difficult to free oneself from one’s background and the expectations and modes of thinking established by that, it is a help in seminars which focus on detailed observation to have members who come from different backgrounds. There is no university course which prepares one for psychoanalytical thinking and observation. People may be facilitated, but are also limited, by the vertex from which they begin to describe human behaviour and interaction. To have in a seminar people who approach it from different vertices is an enrichment, even if at times one has to reckon with those whose previous training may have positively blocked their spontaneous vision. Let us assume that detailed observation, and that the increase in awareness of the children’s emotional life in their work settings which ensues, brings the student into greater contact with mental pain and the devices used to avoid experiencing this. He may feel the urge to understand the turmoil and disturbances evoked him himself, a state of mind which is likely to prompt him to seek analysis for himself. This may be necessary for his training and is essential for those who wish to proceed to Part Two. The link between analysis and training is, however, an unfortunate one. Experience indicates that the more the former can be seen as an entirely private matter, a process which will hopefully give the analysand a new experience of hitherto unapprehended parts
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
31
of himself, the freer he is likely to be to have such an experience, which will incidentally add to the equipment he can bring to his work. If the analyst is required to make judgements about his progress, this undoubtedly encourages the analysand to keep an eye on the expectations of analyst and teachers, to make transformations in K (learning about) rather than in O (becoming). It is difficult enough to become the person one is without positive encouragement from the establishment towards conformity and deception. Relationship between student and teaching group To recount a personal recollection of Dr Bion when confronted with the anxieties of a candidate with a first training case: “What do I do if the patient asks me if I am a student?” “What are you when you cease to be a student of psychoanalysis?” Every teacher must be continually learning or he has no immediate experience to share. Every therapist must be learning something in the heat of every session or he has nothing of interest to say. One of the ways in which senior practitioners can continue to learn, apart from their own direct experience, is by trying to share the experience of younger people and by trying to look at material from their vertices. In a psychoanalytically oriented framework, the work must be done by the individual on his own, whether he be concerned with the meaning of the behaviour of another individual in an intimate individual, family, or small group setting. In order to work well, to think about relationships involved, most people for a while do need the support of some group of colleagues as well as of teachers and supervisors, who are learning from them. According to Bion’s premises, all groups are subject to basic assumption activity which interferes with the capacity of the members to work severally and together. We must assume that no training group or society of psychoanalytical workers is going to be free from these phenomena, or that one can ever afford to relax one’s vigilance in trying to spot their recurrences. Perhaps the pairing groups produce the messianic hopes whether substantial or false, which tend then to become invested in a dependent group or
32
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
groups relying on these new or apparently original messages. Then in turn these are inclined to become the fight-flight groups ready to flee from or to attack enemy ideologies. The dependent group structure so often manifests itself in the reliance upon a crystallized selection of the theories of Freud (the original Messiah), sometimes pitted against a similar extrapolation from Melanie Klein (a latter day saint). Bion is unlikely to escape the same fate. Their theories in such a climate of polarization are suitably selected and presented to eliminate the essential questioning, contradictions and progressions inherent in the formulation of pioneers who are constantly struggling to conceptualise the clinical observations they are making. Bion’s postulation about the impossibility of knowing or describing truth, about the existence of thoughts which do not require a thinker (and of psychoanalysis as one of these thoughts) may help us to try to relinquish the idea of owning our own particular brand of psychoanalysis. One can hope to promote a relationship between fellow workers, students and teachers which might be described by Bion as symbiotic for some, and for the rest at least commensal: co-existent if not mutually profitable. Thus the therapist’s relationships with his patients, objects of study, may take place within a framework of teachers or colleagues who are all dedicated to the task of enlarging their field of observation and of self-scrutiny. In such an atmosphere, hopefully, senior colleagues instead of being content to rest upon positions earned by past achievements, or longevity, may be able to continue or to allow others to continue that process of mental and emotional growth whose infinite possibilities are released, according to Bion, by putting aside memory and desire in order to have a better apprehension of the present moment. Recruitment for training A group or training is either kept alive or ossifies, by virtue of the quality of the new members it recruits. These may be attracted by the power or status which membership is supposed to confer upon them; they may be attracted by the possibility of participating in some interesting learning experience connected with the
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
33
work which they are already doing or which they would like to do. The senior members forming the establishment which selects the new trainees tend to become increasingly exclusive as a training acquires a reputation and attracts more applicants. Sheer numbers may make exclusion necessary. The tendency in a genuinely wellmeaning establishment concerned with preserving standards of work is to use experience of past mistakes to play safe. The establishment of a group in which envy predominates, as described by Bion, may attend, under the guise of protecting standards, to proliferate regulations which do the choosing and end up by including a preponderance of people who have come to join an elite profession which they have a vested interest in restricting. If one has to limit recruitment, how can this be effected without producing an elitist atmosphere? The best way of selecting would seem to be to give candidates an experience analogous to the work which they wish to do, which will also allow them an opportunity for self-selection, and place the decision as far as possible in their hands. The most obvious course is to encourage prospective students to have a personal analysis. If they find they can stay with that and with the revelations of themselves which unfold in its progress, then hopefully they should have a better basis for supposing they may be able to help others to undergo a similar experience. This is the usual procedure in most psychoanalytical societies and in principle can hardly be bettered as an initial method of selection. One must allow, however, for the likelihood that some analysands will return having fairly successfully resisted a real experience and grasp of their more unpleasant parts (the unwanted O), perhaps having learned about them and become cleverer consciously or unconsciously in disguising them. These may return filled with enthusiasm about analytic work and training, having achieved some sort of collusion of mutual idealization with their analyst— enthusiasm about analysis for others, not for themselves. If one can sometimes deceive one’s analyst and go on deceiving oneself, one can surely also deceive one’s tutors and teachers. It seems necessary throughout training to allow work and study experiences which as far as possible encourage students to test the
34
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
results and capacities which they have. It seems important not to collude in the idealization of being a psychoanalyst or a psychotherapist. For that reason we hope that students in Part One will already be working professionally with children, families and young people in a job that may be seen as valuable in itself and potentially more interesting and rewarding as the worker’s perceptions increase. The aim is to make it easy for students to leave after the first part of the training, or to develop more satisfactory roles and methods of working in the fields where they are already employed. The basic aim of the course is not to create a certain number of trained professionals, labelled “child psychotherapist”, but to offer an education in psychoanalytical attitudes and ideas which will lead to some people learning to practise the psychoanalytical method, and to others learning to practise these attitudes and modes of thought in related fields: as in social case work, pastoral care in schools and colleges. The present Part Two of the course is likely in the future to be one alternative, alongside others which may be devised to try to meet the need for further development in related fields. Teaching methods and continued self-selection Students who do proceed to the second part of the course—the application of the psychoanalytic method, in the playroom and consulting room—need support to bear the exigencies of the work, but also sometimes towards selecting themselves out of it if the burden seems likely to be greater than the pleasure and profit derived from it. The attitude of the teaching group can surely do much to promote or discourage honesty in the individual. If seminars are used too much for monitoring and judging the progress of cases or of the students presenting the cases, their potential usefulness can be obscured by the evocation of feelings of inferiority, defensiveness and the urge to produce less than honest work: to bring to a seminar, for instance, only those sessions in which the therapist thinks he appears to advantage. The primary function of a seminar leader, as of a supervisor, is surely to help the therapist after the event to think about the experience of clinical
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
35
interaction which he is describing, and to recapture imaginatively the events described. Thus he may be able to think about them better and become more able to shoulder the burden of clinical responsibility and more open to receiving the patient’s projections. This, I imagine, is an aspect of what Bion is describing when he talks of experiencing O, involving always a further penetration in the direction of the unknown. I would be inclined to think that thte most fruitful seminar or supervision is one in which participants are left, not just satisfied with a piece of good work done, dazzled by the brilliance of pupil, teacher or patient, but with the impetus for further exploration in their own work, and encouraged to persevere in the face of difficulties. In supervision (surely one should try to discard the name and concept of “control”), the tendency of the non-omnipotent student who is anxious to learn and who respects his supervisor, is to look for explanations, clarifications and good interpretations which he is sure the greater expert can offer. Bion has repeatedly emphasized that however inexperienced and uncertain the candidate, no knowledge and experience on the part of the supervisor can equal the actual experience of being with the patient in the session. The supervisor is always working with the student’s reports. This perhaps brings us to the usefulness of Bion’s advocacy of the abdication of memory and desire. It is a difficult concept for the inexperienced student to grasp. When one is conscious of having so little information about psychoanalytic theory and personality development to remember, it is particularly difficult to put that aside rather than to cling tenaciously to the scraps that one has. But it seems to me essential to proceed and to encourage students to proceed on two fronts: they need to acquire and evaluate information which I suspect must mean in earlier learning days the writing of some very detailed notes on cases and observations as an exercise in remembering and in producing something which can be studied sufficiently closely in seminars or supervisors to throw into relief what is not there. But yet the encouragement towards the putting aside of memory and desire, that “willing suspension of disbelief ” as described by Coleridge, would seem to me
36
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
a state of mind essential to try to cultivate in the psychoanalytic sessions. When achieved it can, for instance, relieve the boredom and frustration of apparently interminable unchanging sessions with a latency child who sits everlastingly drawing similar geometric patterns. The recollection that so it was yesterday and the desire—somewhat hopeless—that it should not be thus tomorrow, can so cloud one’s perceptions that they are unable perhaps to receive some intimation of anxiety or emotionality peeping out from the confines of the pattern today. It is perhaps especially difficult for people working analytically in clinics to achieve the necessary state of sequestration to direct the “beam of darkness” [Bion] on the here and now: to put aside expectations arising from yesterday’s session together with whatever information may have percolated from some other worker about the family or crises at school. It is helpful as an exercise in studying what may be drawn out of the immediate session to concentrate occasionally in clinical seminars upon the presentation of a session in detail without any history, to work in the dark to find out how much food for thought there is when not flooded with information. If one has to guard against institutionalizing psychoanalysis, one must beware of using past experience in training to limit future as yet unthought-of developments. Bion’s comments on the limitations of relying upon memory and desire have some applicability to the field of training as well as to the consulting room; to one’s wish for instance to keep up standards which may alas tend towards reproducing paler copies of oneself. The more one has to delegate to committee judgement the more one is likely to flatten out into a group of social and well-adjusted banality consisting of those who have learned to adapt successfully to the system. However, as a tutor or supervisor one cannot abdicate entirely the responsibility which greater experience confers, both to the patient and to the student, for trying to see that some reasonable match of capabilities takes place between a particular case and a particular student with regard to his stage of development. Experience is likely to bear out the fallibility of these assessments
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
37
and certainly one cannot judge from the apparent progress of the treatment alone the capabilities of the worker who is undertaking it. Some patients have such an urge to grow and to understand, that they do well with attention but limited comprehension on the therapist’s part. Others need infinite patience and test to the limit the therapist’s capacity to bear negativism and the projection of frustration and pain. It seems to me that during training one must allow situations which give students the opportunity to test and live through some of the stresses to which they must inevitably be subjected sooner or later in psychoanalytic work, to find if they can struggle with them and even enjoy that struggle. As Dr Bion once remarked: one may not necessarily have to be outstandingly intelligent to be a psychoanalyst, but such intelligence as one has must be available for use “under fire”; and this is especially true in work with certain children. Baptism under fire at some point is an essential part of the development of a child psychotherapist, and it can be a help towards recognizing the same configurations occurring in a subtler form in the adult. If we cannot and should not protect our students from difficult and frustrating experiences and we should probably be loath to rescue them too soon even when the going becomes very rough, yet support may be necessary and required: support of the kind that shares the burden of thinking and worrying. This may alleviate but can never remove the loneliness in difficult clinical situations, for no supervisor can relieve one of the burden of deciding how to respond in the immediacy of the session. As obviously, in this field, teachers must continue to be practitioners, continued experience with patients—especially when these are not at all aspiring analysts or psychotherapists—keeps one closely in touch with the pains and unpredictabilities in becoming an individual, and more able to empathize with the problems of fellow practitioners who are less experienced in years. The humility which this should engender is the only way of hoping to create a profession that will not be idealized as an elite, and of hoping that it will not attract recruits for this reason.
38
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
Written work In the Tavistock training we have found that it helps students to think about what they are doing and learning, by writing accounts of their work at different stages. We seem likely to extend this as an additional method of self-selection: to ask for descriptions and distillations of sequences of observations, work experiences, case presentations and comprehension of theory. Encouragement to present honest accounts of experience, rather than scholastic essays including references to all the right authorities, may contribute to producing a group of workers who do not proliferate the kind of theories described by Bion as characteristic of the lying group dominated by envy. Probably one of the ways of mitigating the envy of the achievements of others, the passively dependent attitude which sees the strength and expertise in others, and which is moreover unable to differentiate between true and false achievement, is the attempt at least to do and to take stock of what one is managing to do oneself—to use language as a prelude to further achievement. Theory There is a question as to how to teach theory in a course which aims to encourage students to learn from a genuine experience of themselves in close contact with others. The collection, the manipulations, the evaluation of theories are traditionally used in the field of mental health as bulwarks against disturbing uncertainties endemic in the work. But yet one needs theories and “models”— to use Bion’s term—as a notation or mythology to bind constant conjunctions. They are necessary as tools to help one to organize thinking about experiences in order to proceed further. In Bion’s definition: “Theory not as a solution but as a model which may prove convenient and useful.” Over the years with the help of Donald Meltzer, a selection of reading has been evolving which aims to orient students to the study of psychoanalysis as a developing art-science of a descriptive kind, essentially useful as it illuminates the experiences and
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
39
furthers the method of working with the transference within the consulting room. It is studied from a historical point of view as a series of pioneering adventures in the mind. We begin with Freud’s attempts to free himself from a nineteenth-century physiological view of the mind, to evolve theoretical models which could account for the phenomena he encountered in his patients. We follow the development of his theories of psychopathology as he attempts to reconstruct from his patients their childhood neurosis and to account for what went wrong. The work of Melanie Klein centering round the Narrative of a Child Analysis, is studied from the point of view of her attempt to observe how the child builds up from infancy his inner world, and the way in which this influences the kind of adult that he will become. Finally Bion’s work is studied as an attempt to evolve a model of the mind providing a method of studying linkages between emotionality, truth and lies—an attempt which is in the vanguard of psychoanalysis. Working in institutions The emphasiz in all of this has been on how the establishment may foster the development of individuality and individual responsibility. Yet we are training people to work in institutions that are likely to contain rival groups and forces that are inimical to psychoanalysis. We must hope to create a friendlier climate in some of these institutions. The practice of the psychoanalytic method requires a degree of sequestration so that the patient may be protected from the impingement of unnecessary external intrusions which could interfere with the evolution of the transference. The therapist himself needs to find a place in his institution so that he too can deploy his attention during the treatment in a relatively uncluttered way. This sequestration and preoccupation lends itself to being perceived by other less psychoanalytically involved colleagues as a mystique and as a claim to special consideration and position. Therapists in a clinic can attract to themselves only too readily an ambivalent transference, as to parents who evoke curiosity by obtruding evidence that they are engaged upon some mysterious
40
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
intercourse, but who tantalise by performing it behind doors. They may take refuge from the attacks of the critical by forming a close-knit little group, a mutual protection society which, however much in possession of the truth it may feel, is bound to be essentially persecuted at core; or they may try to deal with these transference phenomena by denial and placation of differences. The tendency to revert to basic assumption behaviour enters into and between every group formation, in an institution or clinic which can readily split itself, and give up the task in hand in favour of defending respective positions or ideologies. The most pervasive basic assumption perhaps in work with children is the dependency one. Close work with children in pain, and accountability to rivalry with their parents, tends to bring out feelings of inadequacy and unresolved infantile dependence in ourselves. If we cannot manage to deal with those by introspection, and introjective identification with valued internal parental figures, how can we deal with them in the children we treat? Surely there must be someone who can provide a better answer than we can?—Our supervisors, our analyst, or—supporting these—some excellent theoretical formulation into which all clinical data must ultimately fit? There are tendencies even (perhaps particularly) in the most progressive groups to rely upon the latest findings and formulations to provide the answer for every problem. Hence the polarization in so many psychoanalytical groups between adherents to different psychoanalytical theories, rival loyalties to the different flags where unresolved hostility and envy underlying the dependence is split off on to the rival group. There is something to be said for working in an institution which contains a section of workers who are simply ignorant of or hostile to psychoanalysis. This gives one the impetus to have another look at essentials. Dr Bion’s studies of group behaviour have continued to be the germinal impulse for the recurrent group relations conferences held by the Tavistock, an impetus to institutional groups to study themselves and their behaviour to one another. There is one psychoanalytical tradition that regards the study of group behaviour as almost disloyal to psychoanalysis which is concerned with the internal world, the internal grouping. Yet the study of
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
41
the transferring of this internal grouping to the therapist in the psychoanalytic couple is surely complemented by the study of the behaviour of the individual in a group, of the impingement of group pressures upon him. The departure from analytic attitudes occurs when the study of group behaviour becomes the kind of group therapy in which a cure is effected through an abdication of responsibility, by fragmenting and losing parts of oneself in the group, by regressing to proto-mental activity, carried along by the stream of unconsciousness or the mythology jointly engendered. Work groups and establishments To return to that early distinction made by Bion between the basic assumption and the work group. Without continual and rigorous examination of group activities in the realm of training and of practice with colleagues, the activities of the establishment group are only too easy to talk about when one is an outsider but to overlook when one becomes a member. Knowing about groups and being aware of the nature of one’s emotional participation in a group activity are two different things; again instances of the distinction between transformations in K and becoming O, where experience is transformed into growth and learning through experience takes place. In order to prevent oneself from becoming the spokesman of some “advanced” psychoanalytic group, perhaps one should consider the following quotation from Attention and Interpretation: The individual himself must be able to distinguish between himself as an ordinary person and his view that he is omniscient and omnipotent. It is a step towards recognition of a distinction between the group as it really is and its idealization as an embodiment of the omnipotence of the individuals who compose it. Sometimes the separation fails and the group is not only seen to be ideally omnipotent and omniscient but believed to be so in actuality. The individual’s realization of a gulf between his view of himself as omnipotent and his view of himself as an ordinary human being must be achieved as a result of a task of the group itself as well as in individual analy-
42
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
sis. Otherwise there is a danger that a state of mind is transferred (by projective identification) to the group and acted out there—not altered. (Bion 1970, p. 76).
Despite all the emphasiz upon training people to be as far as possible individuals within their group it seems likely that for most of us the continuance of a group or an establishment within which we can work is a necessity. “The function of a group is to produce a genius; the function of the Establishment is to take up and absorb the consequence so that the group is not destroyed” (Bion 1970, p. 82). The International Psychoanalytical Association is the Establishment within which the work of psychoanalytic geniuses—rare as always, but including surely Bion—must be preserved and utilized. But when an establishment becomes too vast and monolithic the tendency is to increase committees and legislation in ways that do not allow for individual developments and eccentricities: Dislike of the onus of decision, or awareness of responsibility for the decision, contributes to the formulation of selection procedures by which selection, like dogma and laws of science, is made to act as a substitute for judgement or a scapegoat for the guilt attendant on overtly acknowledged exercise of responsibility. (Bion 1970, p. 123)
There is room and, it seems to me, a necessity to allow for a number of establishments within which the psychoanalytic ideas of genius are contained and within which students may become acquainted with them and learn to apply them from different vertices. The vertex from which one looks when nourished by close observation of child and of infant development would seem to be a fruitful one for discerning later on the presence of the child within the adult, an essential nucleus of analytic work with adults. How does a parent who wishes to have his child psychoanalysed or a person who wishes to have a psychoanalytic experience himself, know how to set about it? Bion in Experiences in Groups indicates that in this field, the label on the bottle can be no guarantee of the contents. “Psychoanalyst” like “psychotherapist” is a
THE INDIVIDUAL IN THE GROUP
43
trade name; the former more exclusive than the latter and carrying with it probably the guarantee of a more formal training. But neither name is any guarantee as to whether the individual in the role designated has some competence and capacity to go on struggling to improve that competence by practising the psychoanalytic method. Prospective clients or patients will have to continue to use their other known professional advisers, their friends, the grapevine, and sometimes—if available—their own intuition in the last resort when they wish to find their way to having psychoanalytical treatment. But a variety of training establishments which are attempting to cultivate a psychoanalytic attitude and to follow the psychoanalytic method must, hopefully, make this more available to patients—who exist everywhere, and not only in our capital cities. To quote Bion’s comments about the growth of the personality, applicable also to institutions which are concerned with this: “What is required is not the decrease of inhibition but a decrease of the impulse to inhibit; the impulse to inhibit is fundamentally envy of the growth-stimulating objects” (Bion 1970, pp. 128-29).
CHAPTER THREE
Bion’s conception of a psychoanalytical attitude1 (1980)
An obituary appreciation of the work of Bion, focussing on the implications of “introducing the patient to himself ” and the cultural infancy of thinking processes.
I
n considering Bion’s contribution to clinical work, much could be said of how he used and extended, in his own inimitable way, some of the theories of Freud and of Melanie Klein in so far as he found that they illuminated the observations which he was able to make in the consulting room: thus carrying on the great tradition in psychoanalysis. A number of people have been studying his work at the Tavistock Clinic in the past few years with Donald Meltzer, and this has been expounded in the third volume of The Kleinian Development (1978). I would like to select what is, for me, the most inspiring and liberating aspect of his conception of psychoanalysis. Although he believed that there is no substitute for undergoing an analytic experience in the sequestered but turbulent milieu of the consulting room, if one is bent upon exploring the mysteries of one’s 1
Published in Collected Papers of Martha Harris and Esther Bick (1987), pp. 340-44. 45
46
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
personality, Bion sees the discipline of psychoanalysis for analyst and patient alike, as aspiring to continue that great tradition of thinking in art, science and philosophy, which investigates not only the nature of the world in which we live, of human beings in that world, but also the mind of the observer, the thinker himself. The following quotation is from the last of the lecture/discussions he gave in New York in 1977. It follows upon some query about the way to approach a dying patient. Bion is aware that in a sense we are all terminally ill, and the problem is how to learn to best use the unpredictable time that we have available: “What is your assessment of the job of a psychoanalyst?” “I have already suggested that it would not be much use being invited to tell various forms of agreeable lies, nor would I want to terrify anybody by telling him frightening stories about his possibly having a fatal disease. Although it may seem theoretical, or even philosophical, I find it easier to fall back on the feeling that I am called upon to make the person familiar with a particular aspect of truth I know that is an unsatisfactory statement; Bacon summed it up in a famous essay: ‘What is truth? said jesting Pilate, and would not wait for an answer.’ But I think that most people know what I mean when I say it is safest to feel that one is falling back on as near as one can agent to the truth. At least one becomes part of a distinguished company of scientists, painters, musicians and other artists— they are all attempting to display some aspect of the truth—I say all, by which I mean all those who belong to the distinguished company. There is something unsatisfactory about the imitation, and if it is unsatisfactory to oneself it does not require a great deal of imagination to suppose it would be unsatisfactory to a patient who is in a desperate situation. “The truth—what does it look like?—Who wants to be confronted with a trompe l’oeil representation of Paradise? Such confections are pardonable to an agent selling us an earthly home, but not for our eternal home—our Self.” (Bion 1980, pp. 126-27)
Years earlier in Learning from Experience (1962), Bion has referred to truth as the food of the mind, and considered that the personality may suffer from starvation of truth much as the body
BION’S CONCEPTION OF A PSYCHOANALYTICAL ATTITUDE
47
suffers from malnutrition if it lacks nourishing food. Lies would be linked with imitations and perversions of that truth, leading to mental malnourishment and poisoning of the mind. Like Keats and many another poet he seems to regard truth as inevitably linked with beauty, and became in later years increasingly concerned with the problem of giving some fitting expression to the poetry of intimate personal relationships: A scientific paper should remind you of real people; it should not be so boring, so unaesthetic that it becomes a pain in your mind to read it. We have a difficult job—even the impromptus in the analysis, the interpretations that we give, would be all the better if they stood up to aesthetic criticism. I hope that this is not too much like Satan rebuking sin—I am well aware that my own interpretations, spoken or written, cannot pass these tests—but there is no reason why yours should not. You do not need to be confined by the limitations of your lecturers, teachers, analysts, parents. If you are there is no room for growth. (Bion 1980, p. 127)
Leaving room for growth, promoting development, becoming a mental midwife: these are functions which Bion attributes to the analyst, the parent, the educator, who is concerned with enabling the patient, the child, the pupil, to develop through having a genuine experience of himself: an experience of feeling, of thinking based upon that feeling, and of attempting to formulate or take action upon these thoughts. How does one help a patient, or child, to have a true experience of himself? Bion, as you remember, has used Keats’s term “Negative Capability”: the ability to “refrain from irritably reaching after fact and reason”, to restrain the impatience that reaches for the answer which stifles further questioning. “La reponse est le malheur de la question”, as he quoted. Negative Capability implies readiness to accept, to allow the impact of meeting another person. In his last paper to the British Psychoanalytical Society, “Making the best of a bad job”, he describes this meeting of two personalities at close quarters, between analyst and analysand, as giving rise to a disturbance which he called an “emotional storm” (Bion 1979, p. 247).
48
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
Throughout this, “storm-tossed but not shaken, the analyst must go on thinking clearly, from which the more disciplined reaction will build up and the troops will not run away but will begin to stand fast” (Bion 1980, p. 77). At first, the analyst is ignorant of what is happening: but “if we stay, do not run away … go on observing the patient, after a time a pattern will emerge” (p. 79). Discernment of that pattern, the wresting of some order from chaos, may result in mutually beneficial growth for both analyst and patient. Those of us with some experience of child analysis, and even of child rearing, may be aware how too intense an encounter with their hidden selves may be avoided by paramnesias, as he describes in his paper on “Evidence” (Bion, 1976). There are patients who may be successful in avoiding that unpleasant experience of “break-up, break-down, break-through” of catastrophic change (Bion 1991, p. 539); and with whom one may be seduced into carrying on that unsatisfactory imitation of an analytic encounter in which the truth of an immediate experience is bypassed. In order to achieve that state of negative capability or readiness to receive and think about the patient’s projections, a state of intuitive awareness, Bion has advocated the abandonment of memory and desire. This, of course, does not mean the abandonment of such mental equipment as our experience has enabled us to cultivate. But it would involve a wariness of being clogged by paramnesias, of space-filling facts, of loyalty to theories that have served us well in the past and which we may become committed to defend at the expense of noticing inconvenient new facts. It would mean forging goals both for ourselves and our patients. “What we ought to be is of no importance in the practice of psychoanalysis or in the practice of any part of real life. It does matter what we are … The analytic procedure is an attempt to introduce the patient to who he is, because, whether he likes it or not, that is a marriage that is going to last as long as he lives” (Bion 1980, p. 40). Bion, indeed, has been at times irritating to some of his admirers who have struggled strenuously to understand his concepts: as for instance, on those occasions when—questioned as to his
BION’S CONCEPTION OF A PSYCHOANALYTICAL ATTITUDE
49
meaning—he would often indicate that he had moved on from there. An example of this occurs in the New York lectures where,2 when questioned about the Grid—his famous attempt to categorise the movements in thought—he says: “As soon as I had got the Grid out of my system I could see how inadequate it was… He put in his thumb, and pulled out a plum, and said ‘what a good boy am I!’—but the satisfaction does not last long” (Bion 1980, p. 56). His attitude would be that truth can never be attained, or possessed; it is never static. Glimpses of aspects of truth occur fleetingly, on the way to becoming more experienced. This entails the ability to live in the present, bringing one’s experiences from the past constantly into the present to link up with the perceptions of the present. The Self grows in experience and in the ability to express itself. By “Yourself ” he means the total person, body and mind, with its whole history, pre- and post-natal. His perception of the modes of expression of the Self became increasingly sharpened by observations which led him to his imaginative conjectures about the relationship between these two selves pre- and post-natal, within the same body. Bion’s thinking about this remained still in the realms of imaginative conjecture, despite some later evidence of states that could be linked to it. Thinking he regarded as a human activity still in its absolute infancy. The development of a capacity to think creatively, which might harness human passions in the service of development and wisdom, appeared to him as something of a race against time. His own intuitive thinking was so far in advance of anyone else’s in our field that its seminal effect can only begin to be felt. Such is the impact of A Memoir of the Future, which traces the complex mind in action, talking from many vertices, from the whole gamut of his years—the foetus in the womb to the 77-year-old (as he was when he completed the third volume, The Dawn of Oblivion); it presents the living drama of his internal history: amusing, argumentative, 2 Martha Harris and Donald Meltzer, through Clunie Press, published both Bion in New York and Sao Paulo (1980), and The Dawn of Oblivion (Book 3 of A Memoir of the Future, 1979), followed by its Key (1980).
50
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
profound, puzzling, always unexpected, sometimes blindingly, obviously true. Those of us who had the privilege of listening to his mind in action in seminars, groups and in conversation in these last years, feel very cheated that his pen could not continue to glean from his still teeming brain;3 but we are very grateful for what remains, both published and as yet unpublished, to stimulate our attempts to think about ourselves and our work. As Bion says at the end of The Dawn of Oblivion, we must become more expert in discrimination: “There are no labels attached to most options—there is no substitute for the growth of wisdom. Wisdom or oblivion—take your choice. From that warfare there is no release” (Bion 1991, p. 576). This is the Bion who sees analysis in the consulting room not as a refuge, but as a preparation for the real thing: for a richer and wiser mode of living in the world.
3
A reference to Keats’s sonnet “When I have fears that I may cease to be/ Before my pen has gleaned my teeming brain”.
CHAPTER FOUR
The place of once-weekly treatment in the work of an analytically trained child psychotherapist1 (1971)
From the context of the pressures of working in a clinic (and other realities of life), the author evaluates both disadvantages and potential advantages of less intensive therapy with children— many aspects of which apply also to work with adults. This leads to more general considerations: the rhythm of work; the potential for learning for the therapist; the anxieties aroused and defences employed; the place of teamwork; the selection of cases; the goals which are realistically possible by comparison with more intensive therapy; technical matters such as alternative modes of communication to transference interpretation; the roles of observation, family history and theory; and the balancing of personal learning with social obligations.
T
his brief paper reintroduces a topic which was the focus of the Association’s very first study weekend eleven years ago: one with which those of us who work in clinics are continually occupied, and about which after those years of experience we may be in a better position to ask the relevant questions, and to make a few tentative generalizations. 1
Paper read to the Association of Child Psychotherapists; first published in the Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1971), vol. 3 (1), pp. 31-39. 51
52
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
I would like first of all to consider some of the anxieties that it tends to arouse in the therapist whose own personal analysis was a more intensive experience and who received a training largely based on cases receiving the same kind of intensive treatment. I would like then to consider some of the real differences and difficulties attendant upon the less intensive arrangement of sessions: possible goals; methods of selecting cases; the value and the dangers of teamwork. I would then like to mention situations where modification of the analytic technique of interpretation within the transference may seem to be more appropriate. Finally, I would like to take a glance at the relevance of our training for this onceweekly work, and at the place which it may usefully occupy within the timetable of the individual therapist. Anxieties aroused in the therapist by once-weekly treatment There is often the guilty feeling that we should be giving this child more for his need is great. Perhaps we are still in full analysis ourselves; at any rate we have had in the past a more leisurely opportunity to come to grips with our own problems in living. We may be treating other children on a more intensive basis and feel: why should those have an opportunity that is denied to this one? And here we need to take cognizance of our own still operative oedipal and sibling rivalries. An obsessive need for equality and fairness which does not take practicality into account is often a sign that these are interfering with our judgement. To make up for “selling him short” we may try too hard to get results, to become over-active, to reassure ourselves that we are doing something for him. This may take the form of cramming in too many theoretical interpretations, of becoming impatient with what we are able to do in the session and trying to operate through the social worker and the parents. It may take the form of bringing into the child’s session information gained through the social worker and the parents, information which the child has not given us but which we feel he ought to be dealing with. On the other hand, when we have over many once-weekly cases we may at times despair of getting anywhere with the less
THE PLACE OF ONCE-WEEKLY TREATMENT
53
forthcoming ones, and sink back in apathy hoping that circumstances—or the social worker and the parents—may bring about some mild amelioration of the situation so that we can stop without feeling too inadequate. For carrying too large a load of once-weekly cases can make therapists feel like the teachers of large and difficult classes whose attention and concentration is pulled in too many directions at the same time. We may find it difficult to find enough leisure to give mental space to each one, to review the progress of his treatment, to note perhaps when he is making headway in his development although he may be taxing and tiring during the sessions, or to gather ourselves together for the concentration upon small details which can let a chink of light into some period of non-communicativeness, stubborn resistance or inability to talk. The more infrequently spaced the sessions, probably the less inescapable the evidence of the effect of interpretative work: perceived not so much in the sessions during which the verbalization is made, as in the ongoing process of the child’s development in the treatment. Without faith in the beneficial effect of a relationship with a person who tries to comprehend, to stand firm and function while remaining receptive to the most violent and discouraging projections—a faith which probably needs to derive or be confirmed by our own experience of analysis and of working analytically with more intensive cases—once-weekly work during the lean periods with patients can be extremely discouraging. We may then tend to attribute (as the school and the parents probably do) any improvement in the patient to their good offices alone, or to his “growing out of it”. And indeed this is likely to be so in part. Always in analytic work one needs to have a proper humility and to be prepared to share with the child’s environment the credit for helping along the natural thrust of his development, and this is especially so when our contacts with him are less frequent. If we can make it a little easier for him to utilize whatever benefits his environment offers, and make it a little easier for his family to offer him a better environment, we have a valuable contribution to make. We can never function instead of his family and friends, and perhaps there is
54
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
less danger in once-weekly work of the therapist attempting to do this in an omnipotent way. There is on the other hand the danger that unless we are engaged also in some more intensive, and also long-term work, we fail to recognize and to struggle with the basic elements in the patient’s nature when we encounter them: perhaps idealize over-much what we might be able to do had we the opportunity of giving more time, and therefore fail to work towards what we do have the chance to achieve in the time available. Interest and pleasure in the work itself, the exhilaration that thrives upon difficulties, is important to offset that need for reassurance which probably continues to exist in even the most secure among us. Too great a reliance on reassurance leads to discouragement, to scotomization and unrealistic idealization of our work and our patients. The ability to enjoy the work, to feel that we are learning, and trying to help the child to learn a little more about himself, usually ensures that the satisfactions outweigh the pains engendered. Unless we are able to feel some enjoyment it is difficult for us to believe that the process for the child is other than painful. This tends to make us over-timorous in making interpretations which might hurt him. We may wonder, “Can he manage till next week if too much anxiety is stirred up by today? This interpretation may upset him and make him worse. There will be no chance to retrieve the mistake—if it was a mistake—tomorrow. If it isn’t a mistake but a probe into a very sore spot there will not be enough time to help him work through the pain which remains with him until next week.” We are indeed right to be careful, but we need to distinguish sensitivity on our part from timorousness, which the patient senses, identifies with, and which tends to increase his own vulnerability or his contempt. Differences in the nature of the treatment process, determined by the frequency of sessions I think it might be true to say that on the whole the patient’s dependence upon and emotional investment in treatment is
THE PLACE OF ONCE-WEEKLY TREATMENT
55
proportionate to his expectations and the conditions promised or given. So it is important not to promise more than we can give, to avoid implicit collusion with the unrealistic hopes which nearly every patient brings with him. This is not always so easy to put across in the work together, but it is at least possible to be clear and explicit about the framework within which the work takes place; the frequency and regularity of the sessions. We would then on the whole attempt to adhere to that framework, although circumstances in the course of treatment may lead us to change it, e.g., decisions to increase the frequency of sessions, or to work towards termination at a definite date. Less frequent sessions give the child or young person less opportunity to transfer fully and to work through with the therapist the full weight of his infantile neurosis or psychosis. The total containment of the illness in the analytic situation is a dream which is probably seldom realized, but I doubt whether one could possibly hope for it on a once-weekly basis. This does not for instance afford the same opportunity to transfer and to work systematically on the problem of separating from the object, that is afforded by even a twice-weekly basis where there is already felt to be a pattern of sessions: time with the therapist, and a weekend—time away. We probably also need to have a slightly different conception of acting out in once-weekly treatment, to expect that the transference of infantile affects and attitudes will be more mobile and made more generally to people in the environment of the child. Hence it may be more difficult to follow unfinished business from one session to another, due to pressure of events in the child’s life in between. Reliance on notes may be more necessary to keep the thread as there is not the same chance of relying upon an analytic process which by its very repetitiousness reminds us and carries us along. Material tends to be more episodic and a pattern does not tend to emerge so clearly in the transference. But the danger of relying too much on notes is, as always, that of lagging behind the child’s material today by returning too much to hindsight about last week.
56
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
The place of teamwork in once-weekly treatment
Co-operation with other workers is valuable, often indispensable, but it also has its perils for the therapist who is trying to use the psychoanalytic method of concentrating upon interpreting the transference. We are probably especially dependent on the continuing goodwill of the parents. Less opportunity to work through with the child or young person his attitudes to separation, as there is no weekend break, often means that holiday times—however well prepared in anticipation—come with more of a shock, mobilize hostility and a turning away from the therapeutic relationship; without support from the parents the patient may fail to return from holiday. This danger tends to become greater when the patient is beginning to make progress, is more deeply involved and threatened by pain of loss. This kind of negative reaction to holiday breaks can of course be intensified and made use of by parents who are themselves in treatment and reacting without insight to their holiday from their own worker, or maybe sometimes to a change of worker. These last points are exemplified in Mrs Rustin’s case in this issue of the Journal.2 It is often said that information about the family and about events in the patient’s life is especially useful and even essential in once-weekly treatment. While agreeing with this in the main, I am inclined to feel that the opposite danger—of too much information—is underestimated. This brings the temptation to bring into the sessions with the child material that does not belong there, to see him too much through the eyes of his parents, to be pressured by their anxieties, and sometimes those of their worker. When we are using the psychoanalytic technique, information is useful only if we can use it to sharpen our perceptions in the sessions themselves. Unless we are aware of this danger we can sometimes find ourselves sliding into the position of being consultant to the family instead of therapist to the child. 2
Margaret Rustin, “Once-weekly work with a rebellious adolescent girl”, Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1971), vol. 3(1), pp. 40-48.
THE PLACE OF ONCE-WEEKLY TREATMENT
57
If we are aware of this danger, mutual consultation between therapists treating the parents and the child can afford mutual support and illumination. The child’s therapist, for instance, can sometimes help the parents’ worker to understand the weight of the child’s provocation and projection which may be leading to apparent rejection on their part. It is usually much easier to see the deficiencies in the parents and to side implicitly with the child until we have a first-hand experience of trying to understand what the parents have to bear: to realize that parental attitudes can be affected by the nature of the child as well as vice-versa. If the parents’ worker has some opportunity to share with us the problem of coping with the child’s more unbearable projections, she is less likely to approach them in a guilty-making way, and liable then to elicit better co-operation on their own and on the child’s behalf. Possible goals in once-weekly treatment I suspect it’s a mistake to start any treatment with too definite an end in view. The young person’s view of what is wrong with his life may turn out to be quite different from that consciously expressed either by himself or by his parents, or that formulated by the diagnostic team. It is likely to alter if he develops in his sessions. The optimal duration of less intensive treatment is not necessarily any shorter than that of more intensive work. It is probable that in many cases the limits of what can be done to help the child’s development may seem to be reached sooner. Other cases may be able to continue over longer periods than they could manage were the treatment to be more frequent. We need a great deal more discussion about criteria for termination; but although one may perhaps usefully make a number of generalizations, each case will always have to be discussed and considered in relation to what is possible for the child, the family and the therapists involved. We would probably all agree that once-weekly treatment can be effective in diminishing paranoid anxieties, in making it possible for children to experience and contain better their hostile impulses, thereby allowing them to see more clearly and make better use of
58
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
their relationships and their opportunities in the world outside. It also affords the opportunity to sort out some of the confusions between different parts of the personality; between infantile and more mature areas; between bodily zones, as for example in the adolescent whose developing sexuality is confused with ongoing oedipal impulses and fantasies attached to the excretory organs. It can bring about economic improvement, a better grasp and disposition of emotions and anxieties, a better containment and management of the personality. Whether it is possible to bring about structural improvements on such a basis is another matter. Character improvement is notoriously difficult to effect even through prolonged intensive analysis. By this I am talking of the fundamental change in relationship to the primary object which carries the patient further into the depressive position, which enlarges his capacity to bear pain, develops his capacity to love as distinct from the hunger to be loved, and greater skill in bringing that about. Such a change does occasionally take place in the course of prolonged and intensive analytical work. I do not think we can expect it in any once-weekly work, although in the course of this a diminution of projective mechanisms and paranoid anxieties will lead to less interference with the exercise of the capacity for appreciation and concern which he does already possess. The selection of cases for once-weekly treatment As it is especially important when sessions are less frequent that attendance should be regular, if engagement in any long-term treatment process is to be evoked, in selecting a case one has to make a careful assessment of the family’s capacity to support the child’s coming. A school for maladjusted children can sometimes fulfil the function which a chaotic parental relationship cannot provide, and thereby allow children the opportunity of therapy who would not otherwise have it. With adolescents the drive to develop, the ego-strength of the young person himself, together with his capacity to receive help is more important than the actual family situation, although not
THE PLACE OF ONCE-WEEKLY TREATMENT
59
usually unrelated to it. Here too, a tactfully positive attitude on the part of parents may be necessary to help through difficult periods, and to contain their jealousies and hostilities which could be used to swell his negative transference (as in Mrs Rustin’s case). These criteria also apply of course to the selection of cases for intensive analytic therapy. The question is, when to offer onceweekly and when to offer more? This is first of all determined by what is possible, what time is available. There are also cases where it is clear that the family would not support a more frequent attendance. There are adolescents who would be terrified at the thought of a greater commitment, who advance exams and work as an excuse, and indeed these may be a real reason for those who have to travel some distance. Is there something to be said for starting cases on a once-weekly basis as a general rule, and increasing the sessions in the light of experience of work together, if this seems to be indicated and if this is possible? For adolescents in particular, this can be a means of enlisting a more responsible and decisive commitment to a process of work which they cannot after all know anything about until they have tried it. Indications for increasing sessions can be signs of excessive strain and anxiety during the interval between; or the other extreme—difficulty in reaching anxiety because it is too strongly split off and encapsulated, as for example in a psychosomatic symptom. This idea would run contrary to a fairly current practice of making a treatment contract after the initial diagnostic interviews, and this practice is probably influenced in training centres also by the training requirements for students. But in fact one cannot keep a family or a patient to a contract. It is unfortunate if the pressure to do so comes from the therapist’s side and too little from the patient’s perception of what is in his best interests. Optimally treatment is maintained by the therapist’s co-operation with this perception which encourages the patient to extend it into the darker and more painful areas. Starting on a once-weekly basis gives the child or young person the actual experience of analytic treatment; it gives the therapist the opportunity to see how the patient uses what she is able to
60
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
offer; to gauge how he tolerates the gap between sessions; to judge which patients in her caseload are likely to derive some benefit on this basis, and which it would be most profitable to increase, were it possible to do so. Alternative techniques in once-weekly treatment Here I am thinking of ways in which the analytically trained therapist may be able to use the observations he has been trained to make, without consistently employing the psychoanalytic technique of interpreting in the transference. Observation of transference phenomena which necessitate a sensitivity to one’s own countertransference is a most valuable focus for assessing the quality and mode of a patient’s relationships, and never to be neglected if we are trying to make an enabling contact with an individual, rather than a case to which we are trying to apply our theories about psychopathology and personality development. I have already suggested that it is possible that seeing too many children on a once-weekly basis and having considerable historical and current information from the family does tend to blur observation of transference phenomena, to stimulate tendencies to theorize about family interaction and make interpretations according to those theories, which are unlikely to make the child feel really understood and to stimulate him to think about himself. There are times however, when it might seem more useful and appropriate to use a form of treatment that relies upon our observation and grasp of the patient’s communications to us as transferring modes and attitudes from his primary objects, but without verbalizing this. We may use our observations to help him to link his words and actions together in a more meaningful way, but without making interpretations which are likely to encourage the further transference of infantile affects to the therapist. This method may be especially suitable for some adolescents and in cases where the therapy is envisaged as short term. These would be instances where it does not seem advisable to encourage too much dependence on the therapist, or where the patient’s
THE PLACE OF ONCE-WEEKLY TREATMENT
61
fear of dependence is so great that a close ongoing contact would not be tolerated. Linking and reconstructive comments about his behaviour and communications can give him a way of thinking about himself that may help him to organize his anxieties, to contain and diminish their disintegrative effects. This is a method employed for instance by some of the workers in the Young People’s Consultation Centre at the Tavistock Clinic, by those in counselling situations, and also in work with families. It is probably most suitable for situations where the patient or patients come in a potentially disintegrating acute state, where feelings are available to be understood and contained. It can be used in the case of some younger children to relieve an upwelling of sudden paranoid anxieties which are disturbing an otherwise ordinarily good relationship with their parents. It is not a method that is conducive to evoking and elucidating emotions which are split off or strongly repressed. It is not then likely to be helpful with a child or young person who is too defended and cut off from contact, where in order to make any therapeutic contact at all, it may be necessary to interpret the negative transference in a consistent and ongoing framework. Training for work on a once-weekly basis As the central core of training for sensitive and creative work on the basis described there is no substitute for the analytic experience; the therapist’s own personal analysis and her training and experience of more intensive work with some children and young people. This affords the opportunity to follow in detail the intra-psychic relationships of the patient, the ways in which these interact with his external relationships. It gives the confidence to approach the child or young person with some conviction that he is not merely the victim of circumstances but potentially a developing human being with the possibility of having some say, however slight, in his own destiny. But training in analytic technique is not the only necessity for this work, and not the only necessity for the creative non-rigid
62
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
practice of intensive analytic therapy. We have at the Tavistock Clinic come to value the exchange of experiences between students, of work with children, adolescents and families in various different settings, in order to give those students a wider and richer experiences. Detailed reports of particular children or groups and situations are presented for discussion. The technique of handling the situations described is also a matter for discussion. We work on the assumption that there is no substitute for close observation: that the efficacy of any therapeutic work—of any work with people’s inner life—totally depends on this. Theories are useful, and can in fact only be felt to be true in so far as they help us to organize and make sense of the observations we have been able to make, and in so far as they enable us to mobilize our attention and ability to see more. Discussion of observations of babies growing up in families with their mothers, and of young children, was designed by Mrs Bick as part of the original Tavistock course in child psychotherapy. Similar events take place in the other child psychotherapy trainings. Experience of work with normal children has always been a prerequisite for training as a child psychotherapist. The systematic discussion of non-analytical work with children and adolescents in different settings has been introduced only recently into the Tavistock training.3 The student’s role in this is twofold. She is learning to observe and to record what she sees, but in work situations in which she carries some responsibility for managing the group of young people. She then has the opportunity to study the effects of this responsibility on her and on them. The more varied the experience of children in different settings, and of different methods of working with them, the richer the background which feeds our work. This allows us to be more relaxed and imaginative in the treatment situation. The child in his weekly sessions benefits from our extra-analytical experience as well as from our intensive analytical work with its greater leisure to tackle obdurate resistances and explorer the perimeters of the personality. 3
This was introduced by the author.
THE PLACE OF ONCE-WEEKLY TREATMENT
63
The place of once-weekly treatment in the total timetable of the analytically trained child psychotherapist It is worth asking ourselves whether we do gain anything from this work to enrich our psychotherapeutic skills: whether given an absolutely free hand it could ever be a matter of choice rather than of expediency. I would think that we do gain a great deal. It gives us the opportunity to see many more children than would otherwise be possible and to widen our analytic experience. It helps us therefore to form gradually more accurate assessments of children’s personalities; to differentiate better between normal developmental difficulties and pathological states that are likely to continue to immobilize development—to differentiate between the healthy and the unhealthy parts of the child’s personality. Comparison of the effects and of the process of working within frameworks of differing frequency does help us to gain a better sense of proportion as to the value of our contribution to the child’s development—a more real sense, as distinct from either an omnipotently idealized or an over-deprecating one. The problem in most clinics, however, is to make the opportunity to do some more intensive work, which is of course one reason why so many child psychotherapists like to have some private practice. In the clinics, pressure of numbers, scarcity of therapists and sometimes geographical distances, make for difficulties in seeing many children more frequently. And how many children is the individual therapist able to carry for individual analytic therapy? The answer must vary from person to person. It is important to find one’s own level, to recognize one’s limits, and to work out the optimum balance between more and less intensive cases both for oneself and the clinic (and by more intensive I am referring to anything from twice weekly upwards). Pressure to see more cases is of course the great difficulty. It may be worth giving thought to the possibility of making space for some more intensive work, necessary for one’s own development, and yet trying to perform one’s social obligation by developing techniques of working with small groups of children or young
64
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
people, or with the family as a group. Activity and discussion groups in schools have been found valuable, both therapeutically and educationally, for children who have difficulty in benefiting from their ordinary classes for a variety of reasons. This is a field which some of our analytically trained members might explore further with benefit to themselves, the children, and the schools.
CHAPTER FIVE
Growing points in psychoanalysis inspired by the work of Melanie Klein1 (1982)
This paper, the last to be published by Martha Harris, takes a historical overview of certain key moments in the evolution of Kleinian thinking. These are: Klein’s extension of Freud’s “projection” into “projective identification” as a result of her observation of children’s phantasy worlds; work by her colleagues and students with psychotic adults and by Meltzer on sexual theory, enabling a clear differentiation between narcissistic and object-related modes of mental operation in forming personality structure; Bion’s extension of “projective identification” and of Klein’s “epistemophilic instinct” in his theory of thinking; and Bick’s perception of skin functioning in infants which, together with her colleagues’ and students’ work on autism, enabled a differentiation between twoand three-dimensional states of mind. These apparently different or differently-derived theories integrate into a single model of personality growth. The examples that follow on however emphasize the fact that individuality is varied and surprising and does not necessarily conform to the expectations aroused by any existing model.
1
Published in Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1982), vol. 8(2), pp. 165-184. 65
66
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
M
rs Klein’s great discoveries were made possible by her capacity to observe and take an interest in what little children were showing her in their play and conversation. She states categorically that children’s play is always meaningful and she certainly approached it with that supposition. Her insights and theoretical formulations were initially inspired and then perhaps somewhat constricted by her devotion to the theories of Freud, for whom she had profound admiration and whose work she saw herself as applying and extending into the field of child analysis. His failure to appreciate her work was indeed a source of continued grief to her. But looking back upon the development of her observations and theories one can see how revolutionary they were, and still are. History tells us how rare it is for one revolutionary to appreciate another who does not stick closely to the party line. To borrow the quotation from Thomas Browne with which Bion prefaces Learning from Experience: But the mortallest enemy unto knowledge, and that which hath done the greatest execution upon truth, hath been a peremptory adhesion unto Authority, and more especially the establishing of our belief upon the dictates of Antiquity. (Thomas Browne, “Enquiries into Vulgar and Common Errors: of Adherence unto Antiquity”; Bion 1977, p. v).2
The writings of Mrs Klein, like those of Freud, do indeed court that danger of becoming embalmed in Antiquity: a Talmud or Koran of Authority, if they are used to provide ready answers rather than to stimulate further questions in a field of study—that of the human personality—to whose depth and complexity she has contributed such illumination. It is possible that the extension of the field of child analysis and the continued interest in motherinfant observation which she helped to stimulate in Mrs Bick, who in turn introduced it into the training of child psychotherapists and analysts, may throw up so many surprises and questions that a tendency to rest complacently in possession of the best of all theories of development will continually be shaken. 2
Not in the 1962 edition.
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
67
Reviews of Mrs Klein’s achievement have been done many times and extensively from different points of view, most notably, perhaps, in Hanna Segal’s Introduction to the Work of Melanie Klein (1964) and Donald Meltzer’s The Kleinian Development (1978). These show how Melanie Klein’s work brought psychoanalysis out of a preoccupation with pathology and pathological clinical entities into what one might think of a new and more profoundly based study of developmental psychology and of human relationships. Her analytic work and observation of little children led her o perceive that object relationships start at birth with the baby’s relationship to the mother’s breast. She gradually constructed a theory of personality development based on object relationships which are always threatened by, and need to be distinguished from, narcissistic relationships which fundamentally impede emotional growth. This theory has opened up a view of the infinite complexity of the human personality and of the concept of identity: a recognition that we live not only in the outside world but in an internal world which is as real, and which has its own relationships and transactions which colour our view of the external world and of the meaning it has for us. Her work has shown us that children develop as individuals through introjecting and identifying with attentive caring people in intimate relationships, that unconscious phantasies are the transactions taking place in that internal world expressed by little children’s play and adults’ dreams. Play is children’s attempt to make some sense of the world, and tends to be rapidly evoked and transferred towards the attentive analyst or therapist. In the early days of her work with children Mrs Klein was very optimistic about the role of early analysis as a prophylactic measure in the education of children. There is no doubt she was immensely encouraged by the results of her analyses: notably perhaps by the freeing and enabling effect which was brought about by discerning and interpreting the part which projective mechanisms played in the creation of the cripplingly harsh superego figures which she initially discovered in little children. As time went on, and particularly perhaps as she came to discover the insidiously poisoning effect which uncontained and undetected envy had upon the
68
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
development and maintenance of good relationships, she became less optimistic, although no less unwavering in her belief in an uncompromisingly truthful analytic approach as the only “cure” for the human condition. The goal might be ultimately unreachable but the direction was clear, although requiring constant struggle and vigilance to find it. After the controversies in the British Society in the forties, when a number of analysts (notably those more traditional adherents to Freud who came with him and Anna Freud from Vienna in the late thirties) were disquieted by the phantasies which Mrs Klein attributed to young children, some very productive work was done by Mrs Klein’s students and colleagues, particularly in the treatment of adult psychoses. This was stimulated in particular by her 1946 paper “Notes on some schizoid mechanisms”, in which she first used the term “projective identification”, and which illuminated further the role of projection in narcissistic relationships. Currently perhaps some of the insights developed in work with psychotic adults, notably by Segal, Rosenfeld and Bion, are being more generally applied in adult work with borderline patients. Meltzer’s Sexual States of Mind (1973), which is based on work with a variety of patients, adults and children, is a comprehensive attempt to investigate the differentiation between narcissistic and object-related structures of the personality, as related to Melanie Klein’s concepts of the paranoid-schizoid and depressive positions. He exemplifies through case material how sexual (developmental) states of mind are based upon identification with parents who are introjected with love, and who are allowed the freedom to unite and interact in a loving procreation. Mrs Klein in her note on projective identification in Narrative of a Child Analysis (1961), says: In my view the processes of internalization and projective identification are complementary and operate from the beginning of post-natal life; they vitally determine object relations. The mother can be felt to be taken in with all her internalized objects; the subject which has entered another person may be felt to take with him his objects (and his relations with them). The further exploration of the vicissitudes of internalized object-relationships, which are at every step bound up with
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
69
projective processes, should in my view throw much light on the development of the personality and of object relations. (p. 114)
In the 1960s Bion’s work, notably Learning from Experience (1962), Elements of Psychoanalysis (1964), Transformations (1965) and Attention and Interpretation (1970), explored the origins and evolution of thinking from a study of the infantile transference with adults, and of the analyst’s part in receiving and thinking about that transference. His hypothesis is that the infant learns to think through its early intimate contacts with a thinking mother apprehended first as a part object, a “breast”. He extended Melanie Klein’s concept of projective identification (as she extended Freud’s concept of projection), and of the necessary role of the mother in receiving and dealing with the infant’s projections. He talks of how the infant, impelled by a primary anxiety—the fear of dying—is impelled to project that fear, together with the part of the personality which experiences it. If the mother has space in her mind, as well as in her arms, to receive the frightened infant, she will think about it, try to intuit the nature of its pain and act accordingly. She then gives back that frightened part of its personality in an improved form as put together and detoxified by a thinking mother, who is not only a provider of comfort. One could say then that the thinking, working mind of the mother, which leads her to respond specifically and appropriately, is the basis for introjecting a benign combined object—a developing and not a static one. Bion talks of the mother who is unable to accept projections, who remains impervious to the infant’s distress as tending to evoke intensified projections—a battering at the closed door, as it were, which leads to fragmentation of the personality. This may also be one of the sources of that omniscient empty moral superego which is so hostile to experience and to development, and which has ready-made answers but which cannot tolerate questions. When referring to the epistemophilic instinct, Mrs Klein laid emphasis on the innate urge of the child to learn about the world. Bion gave another slant to this: he regarded it as the basic need to know the truth about oneself, which is fostered by a mother who
70
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
is able to discard preconceived theories about children, who is able to be continent and cognisant of her own infantile emotions and to respond to the projections and communications of her own particular infant in its particular context. Bion has made explicit in his work what is implicit in Mrs Klein, for indeed her whole theory and practice of child analysis derives from the assumption that it is beneficial for children to tell them the truth in so far as one is able to discern it, unpleasant hearing though that may be at times: that an unpleasant experience may indeed be relieving and developmental if it is shared; that one cannot grow without meeting and bearing pain. Bion’s thesis is that pain can be better borne if it can be thought about. The mother first performs the thinking for the child. He introjects that function and is first impelled to use it by her absence; the first thought is the absent breast. While Bion was developing his profoundly novel work on the origins of thinking, on the evolution of the personality through learning from experience and its pathological distortion through lying or destruction of experience—work stemming from Mrs Klein’s discovery of the phenomenon of projective identification, of splitting and projection and the shift in values that takes place between the paranoid-schizoid and depressive organization of the personality—two other converging lines of enquiry into early development were proceeding in the fields of infant observation and in the analysis of psychotic children. These described a state of mind—or more accurately put, of mindlessness—more primitive than the object-related state which employs the mechanisms of projection and introjection, a two-dimensional state in which the infantile personality is not held and is without identity. Frances Tustin has vividly described her work with autistic children in a series of papers and books (1966; 1969; 1972; 1980; 1981). Anne Alvarez (1977) has published in this Journal an account of the treatment of an autistic boy. Donald Meltzer together with John Bremner, Shirley Hoxter, Isca Wittenberg and Doreen Weddell published in Explorations in Autism (1975) detailed expositions of the long-term treatment of a few children whose illness and failure to develop followed an inability or breakdown in the employment
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
71
of projective and introjective mechanisms. This autistic state was compared with areas of shallowness in other patients, of obsessional learning through the collection of information rather than through undergoing an emotional experience. All these people had worked at some time with Mrs Bick. Her researches resulted in an extraordinarily pithy paper “The experience of the skin in early object relations” (1968),3 a distillation of the experiences of listening to years of infant-mother observations and of work with a psychotic child. She describes a primitive state of mind in which there is no sense of an internal space and where the parts of the personality fasten upon and adhere to some external stimulus: a light, a sound, a pattern, in a limpet-like fashion, clinging rather than interacting. The baby in this state is in constant danger of spilling out, of falling apart if torn away from the surface to which he adheres. This state of two-dimensionality would ordinarily be most prevalent in the early days after birth, before the infant has had the repeated experience of his amorphous distress being gathered together and relieved by the mother and given some focus, optimally in her arms with the nipple in his mouth—a containment and focus for his person. Under ordinarily favourable conditions this would give the baby a sense of a containing object into which he could evacuate his distress and of a comforting pain-relieving one which he could take into himself. In Mrs Klein’s terms this would enable him to split his object into a good and bad breast: to project the bad breast and then through repeatedly introjecting the good one, to internalize that as the core of his personality, thereby acquiring the strength to face his separateness from his good object and to take back his projections. Mrs Bick talks of this primitive state of mind (the loss of an identity that is based on identification with a good internal object—a state in which the personality is liable to fall apart) as recurring in times of shock and stress, as for instance after childbirth. She talks of a second skin defence against this experience of falling apart or of being torn away from adhesion to an object that offers a focus for the personality. This is provided by a mobilization 3
Chapter 9, this volume.
72
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
of the muscularity of the personality most noticeable in physical activity but more subtly in mental agility, as in certain kinds of talking where the aim seems to be not the conveying of meaning but the assertion of mental gymnastics. There is probably a variety of second skin defences—institutional and group defences against anxiety, for instance. I shall now add a series of excerpts from infant observations and clinical material which illustrate or raise questions about differentiation between two-dimensional and three-dimensional states of mind: the differentiation between states of mind in which development is taking place through projection and introjection, and those in which this internal world of meaning is not operative or is in abeyance.4 Observations of Baby T The observer was given the name of Mrs T, who was about to have her first baby. She was an intelligent girl, modern in outlook, full of life and interests but leading a rather confused life. At their first meeting the observer was struck by the theatrical appearance of her clothing, which consisted of a strange juxtaposition of bits and pieces to be found in the latest fashion magazines. As she moved she looked worldly and theatrical as if she were going to perform in a wide auditorium. She bombarded the observer with questions but did not seem to listen to the answers. Then the focus of conversation shifted to herself, and she poured out to the observer a string of details about herself and her second marriage, her terror of labour with its unbearable pangs and risks and her resolve to have a caesarean “where you do not feel anything”. This first interview was a blueprint for the many that were to follow after the baby was born: observations in which the mother would give the observer outpourings of inconsequential information, questions that were not requiring an answer. She breastfed her baby for the first three months but her attention was seldom 4
My thanks are given to Sandra Piontelli, Sarosh Forbes, and Andrea Watson, for permission to use some of their work for this paper.
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
73
on him or more than momentarily on the observer. While feeding she could pick up the telephone and put a call through for no apparent reason; she might stop suddenly to go into the other room and return to pick up the baby, kissing or tickling him for a few seconds before passing on to something else. Or she could suddenly become immobile, looking fixedly at her hands or vacantly into the distance. The observer’s first opportunity to see the baby was when he was fifteen days old. She noticed difficulty in waking up and grasping the nipple and felt that the mother was emotionally not there to hold him and help him to do so. From the first feeds, he would wrap his tongue around the nipple, it seemed partly to grasp it but partly also to keep it at a distance. At the end of a feed he would relapse into stillness, and sleep looking strained and tired, never blissful and fulfilled as if he had taken a good experience into himself. When frightened— and he often looked frightened—he retreated into sleep and fairly continually sucked his tongue. His mother complained that he sweated a lot, and this the observer was able to see for herself, and then to notice that although he was kept meticulously clean and powdered, he frequently stank. Mrs T’s handling of baby T was erratic, oblivious of his needs, but affectionate. There were, however, two malign influences in his life: the first was his three year old little half-sister Gloria, who was the beautiful little star her name might suggest, extremely intelligent but spiteful to the baby and secretly dismissive of her mother who hardly seemed to notice. The second was a maid whom Mrs T engaged when they moved into a larger home when the baby was three months old. At that period, Mrs T was on the point of collapse, talked of fainting, feeling that “her substance was flowing out” and she had come to rely on the maid more and more. The maid was an attractive-looking, assured, secretive and covertly contemptuous young woman who handled the baby very expertly but had a thinly veiled sadistic attitude to him and enjoyed teasing his helplessness. His bottle, and then food, became all important to him. She would arouse his expectations, and would then enjoy withholding and laughed at his look of dismay and disappointment.
74
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
Baby T never shouted his demands, never went into a tantrum if they were not met. His prevalent expressions were bewilderment and dismay. Later smiles of a mechanical, learned variety appeared. He was frequently left to the tender mercies of the maid as the mother flitted about in her inconsequential way. She seemed to be subtly intimidated by the maid and would join in her laughter at the baby’s funny expressions when he was discomfited, as if she had no realization that he was a human being who suffered. The maid realized very well that he suffered, as also did Gloria who took a sadistic pleasure in his weakness. Apart from the observer, the only person who seemed to have pity for the baby’s fairly habitual air of distress and withdrawal was the father, who occasionally would put in an appearance and commiserate with “my poor little boy”. It was to the observer or to the father that the baby would look sometimes as if for help when he was upset. His first word was “Daddy”, and the first time he looked forlorn when left by somebody was when his father had left him. From the time that he was about five months old, the observer noticed how he seemed to be oblivious of physical pain. On two occasions about this time she caught Gloria going up to him when she thought that she could not be noticed, scratch him and then try to twist his wrist off. The baby showed no reaction. But even more notable than his insensitivity to pain was his total lack of joy and spontaneity—most obviously lacking in his smiles. To offset this emotional flatness, he began to show precocious muscular development from about six months. He then learned to raise himself up; soon after that he could stand up and then he would seldom lie down. If he was made to sit down, as for instance to eat his food, he would resist stiff-legged and scream. At eight months he took his first steps and at nine months he was habitually walking alone easily and with confidence, but he developed a tendency to hurt himself, by design rather than through lack of skill, because he would scratch himself as well as knock into objects. Here is a description of baby T at eleven months: After the summer, apart from his desperate non-stop walking he looked even more blank and terribly fat. He stank horribly,
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
was covered with scratches, and constantly and noisily sucked his tongue. He had learned a small repertoire of actions he would perform when asked by his mother and which seemed to reassure her greatly. He could clap hands, twirl round, dance in a circle when she sang “Ring o’ Roses”. Sometimes he would make a mistake so that his performance was the wrong one, not the one which he had been asked for. Everyone laughed but T on these occasions looked confused and bewildered, being suddenly paralyzed with terror and utterly unable to move in the middle of his pathetic performance. Food was still an obsession and he was constantly in quest of it. Now that he was on solids and was beginning to eat by himself, I noticed how he would literally throw food, water and beverages into his mouth and then gobble or gulp them down in a moment. This was particularly evident in the case of water and other liquids (with solids he alternated between this kind of behaviour and his usual wrapping, rubbing and so on with his tongue); he would throw them in with incredible swiftness, literally in a second, and then he would often, if given the chance, throw away the plastic glass or container from which he had been drinking, projecting it through the air with great force. One had the impression that eating and taking something in could not be a gradual process for him; it had to happen in a second without his perceiving the process; he just suddenly did not feel thirsty any more—but without recognition of the object that he had just imbibed—and the container was thrown out of sight. Apart from his father, he seemed unaware of and untouched by all the comings and goings of the people in the house, including his mother. His muscular ability had become more and more marked and this somehow projected him into the future; he was on this count remarkably forward—even unnaturally, monstrously advanced for his age, as well as being bizarre. He would, for instance, never use the support of his hands to stand up, never stretching out or bringing his hands forwards when he fell; instead he would quite literally fall flat on his face. He almost never bent his knees, even when he had to stoop to pick something up. This gave his gait a mechanical robot-like quality, as if he were made of metal, with rigid rusty joints, incapable of bending harmoniously. He did not seem to possess, or to have assimilated within himself, or within his body, any idea of support and protection: as if no-one had ever
75
76
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
been there to pick him up and prevent a painful fall. Also he seemed to have no idea of two separate parts or two separate entities working together harmoniously or of two people who could join together in unity. His hypertrophied muscular ability and extraordinary speed in walking served more and more the purpose of enabling him to get away from people and unwanted situations. He now could simply quit and when he did this he did it very rapidly. When he was eleven months old his mother became pregnant, and this was certainly something he could not get away from. The main impact it seemed to have on him was that he started to exhibit an interest in the inside of things. Until then I had almost only seen him explore the surface of objects. One of his favourite games was to try to juxtapose or make two surfaces adhere one to the other, or else he would bang violently the surfaces of objects against one another. But now he had become interested in the insides of things as if realizing that the inside of his mother’s body was occupied by another baby. He would bang his head against her pubis or her stomach. He would hide himself inside an old cupboard and literally spend hours there in complete darkness, immobile like a corpse inside a sealed coffin.
I have quoted at length from this vivid account of baby T who was followed regularly every week for over two years and then at infrequent intervals over the next six or seven years. During the first year he presents a painful picture of a child who exists in a two-dimensional state, terrified of experiencing emotion and developing a precocious second-skin muscular ability to keep him together. Mrs T herself is unintegrated, unheld together, “absentminded” in the literal sense. After this first year the observer feared that baby T would not learn to talk or indeed would be ineducable. In his second year however, he began to form words, unintelligible at first, but then he gradually acquired a large vocabulary and verbal facility based on mimicry. He went to school and became a “good scholar” in the same markedly mechanical parrot-like way. I shall follow these observations with excerpts from the account of the therapy of a little boy in Infant School, whose mother also seemed unable to be receptive to his needs, and who was held up
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
77
in an atypical development of a slightly different kind, but like baby T was unable to hold and think about his experiences. Peter5 Peter, aged five and a half years, was referred to a child guidance clinic by the school medical officer because he was distant and difficult to teach, unusually aggressive towards other children, and given to sudden twitches and a flinging of his arms. In the two sessions he had at the clinic he spent one sitting under his mother’s chair, playing from time to time a very frightened peek-a-boo, and in the next one he literally tried to climb the wall. He scrabbled frantically at it with hands and feet, making animal-like sounds of distress or machine gun noises. His mother maintained throughout these sessions that she did not think there was much wrong with Peter, and she felt this kind of behaviour—which was apparently very common—was normal and to be expected of boys. The only area of concern to her was his day and night time wetting, which she was quite hopeless and helpless about. She admitted that she had given up trying to train him, but just changed him without comment. She was unwilling or unable to try any new approaches. She did not relate to Peter nor he to her during the sessions. What struck me most forcibly about the mother was a deadening flatness in her demeanour. It was impossible to imagine her becoming enthusiastic or responding warmly to anything Peter said or did, but one could imagine her treating both his bizarre and his normal behaviour in exactly the same noncommittal, blanked-off way. By the end of the second session her original defensiveness turned to overt aggressiveness. She became angry and refused to accept another appointment. Contact with her since then has been extremely limited both in terms of frequency and attempted depth of intervention. One result of this is that we know practically nothing about Peter’s early history. All that is known is that he was a somewhat restless sleeper in his first year and that from 5
Although not explicitly stated it would appear that Martha Harris was herself the therapist in the cases of Peter and of Dr G.
78
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
what his mother states he reached all his milestones at the normal times (whatever that may mean for her). The school inevitably became increasingly worried about Peter, and particularly about his aggressive attacks on other children. Their picture was of a boy who flapped and twitched and panted, grunted and moaned: a boy in deep distress, who provoked a response of sympathy and desire to help in all who came across him—except apparently his mother. It was with this background that I became involved again and suggested that I might see him in school on a weekly basis, without trying to involve his mother at all. She agreed to this. The setting as a whole was about as far from ideal as could have been imagined without becoming totally untenable. There was no support either for or from the parents, and no background history worth note that could have formed an initial framework for understanding Peter’s behaviour. Our time together was restricted to school terms, missing half-terms, day trips, teachers’ strikes, Christmas parties, sports days and so on, all of which seemed to be arranged to clash with the session. We have contended over a two-year period with three changes of room plus the unscheduled arrival and departure of different pieces of furniture and equipment in these rooms; we have been interrupted physically by teachers and by other children, window cleaners and plumbers and aurally by telephone, television and general school noise. The only islands of constancy have been myself and his box of toys, which arrives and departs with me. I have quoted rather extensively from the beginning of this account of two years’ work with Peter in order to convey the graphic description of a child who is unable to think or play, who might be thought of in Bion’s terms as projecting a “beta screen”—a barrage of undigested unthought impressions. He could also be perceived in Mrs Bick’s terms as holding himself together muscularly with activity, noises and twitches, to compensate for his unheld state in both the external and internal world, symptomatically expressed in the continual leaking out of his urine. The therapeutic framework in terms of place, times and privacy was far from containing, and might seem less than adequate, but within this the therapist
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
79
demonstrated over the next two years how the presence even at unpredictable intervals of a constantly attentive and interested person may be used by a child in a state of pathologically arrested development to help him to think and make some sense of his own feelings at the impact the world has upon him. To continue with the account of Peter’s therapy: I felt that from the start Peter latched on to the sessions with the tenacity of a drowning man, and almost immediately invested them with a wealth of meaning and emotional warmth. It seems to be this that buoys him through the breaks and keeps his contact with me in spite of everything. In the sessions of the first three months it was extremely difficult to make any sense of much of the initially bizarre behaviour. The therapist, however, felt that he was acutely aware of her, playing or acting for her although he could not address himself to her. It was only after the almost intolerable pressure of the first summer break, a change of school, and a change of rooms, that he amazingly began to talk to her and show her what he called later his “mind picture”. One of the first centred on his box, which had been interpreted by her as representing the mummy’s mind and body: He took two little men and hung them on the side of the box: they were screaming and sobbing in distress and trying to get into the box which resisted their entry. They were being attacked from below by the bull, the hippo, the lion, the polar bear and the elephant. I suggest that this is a picture of the baby at the breast, feeling unheld and outside mummy’s mind, while at the same time feeling attacked from below in the bottom, being punished for his felt intrusiveness into the breast by having his projections pushed back into him in a hostile way…
It would seem to me likely that one could speculate on an almost total lack of response from his mother to Peter’s early overtures of exploration, leading to a dramatic increase in his need to project. Peter began with one safe place near to the therapist in the room, and over the weeks and months that safe area increased despite the various interruptions and intrusions that took place
80
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
and for a time would paralyze him utterly. Eventually he was able to talk about them: “We do not mind the telephone do we? It is nothing to do with us.” But before he was able to take this genuinely reasonable attitude to intrusions and to recognize that the therapist was also being interrupted by events outside her control, he went through recurrent periods of rage when he abused her, as in the following sequence: A designated mummy space ship became broken up in his box between sessions, without my knowledge, to be immediately discovered by Peter at the beginning of the next session He was understandably absolutely furious. “You’re hopeless, smelly and stupid—you can’t look after anything, you didn’t look after it—you break things up on purpose—you do it with your words—your words break things up—shut up, shut up”.
Perhaps here can be seen the anxiety that had to be overcome before he could even use words at all with me: they are dangerous in and of themselves, they can be used like sledge hammers to destroy. Their power for good or evil seems tremendous and my capacity to withstand his hard words seems immensely important at this stage—to go on using words to understand and make sense of, and not be deflected from that, in spite of his screaming at me. It seems to take away from their omnipotence so that two weeks later at the end of a session he can say, when putting away his spaceships: “I must put them away myself, carefully, because it’s my hard luck if I don’t and they get lost.” This seems to be taking responsibility for his actions, and an idea that saying the words can help him to be that careful thoughtful person. Peter began to be verbally appreciative of the therapist’s help in understanding what he called “my mysteries”, sufficient to tell her: “I’ve got a lot of work to do”. Unlike baby T, we have here in Peter a child who has a great impetus to make sense of his world and to learn the truth about himself and who has therefore developed remarkably in a relatively short time in a far from ideal situation for analytic therapy. But he was able to use the containment he had hitherto lacked in the
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
81
thinking mind of his therapist who makes him aware of “his mysteries” and inspires him to work to understand them. Now follow some excerpts from an infant observation here the relationship with the mother seemed to begin unpromisingly, a mother who was clearly traumatised, de-skilled and deprived of her sense of identity by the birth of the baby, much wanted though it had been. Rosalie Rosalie is a first baby born to a couple in their early thirties after some years during which a cyst had probably prevented the mother from conceiving earlier. Both parents are well established in their respective careers: the father in business and the mother in a teaching position in the welfare field. This she was determined to return to after her maternity leave was up, leaving the baby throughout the day with a nanny. The observer and the discussion group were very disquieted when they heard of this resolve. They were also disquieted by the mother’s businesslike and somewhat flippant way of talking about the baby in the early weeks and months from the birth onwards when “they both got stuck” because her pelvis was too small and a caesarean had to be performed. There was a wide discrepancy between the mother’s competence to manage her life and professional commitments, and her capacity to hold the baby physically and mentally. The baby was treated as if she were hardly human— more a parcel to be tended, fed, bathed and changed. In the early months she was never talked to by the mother, although she was talked about with care and concern for her welfare. Care was taken in the choice of a nanny who was to wear a white uniform so that she would not be mistaken for the mother (as if the mother needed some external distinction to give her an identity and role). The observer noted that the baby seldom looked at the mother; her eyes would move away to fix on a light, the surface of a wall or blankly into space. It was indeed as if the mother was hardly able to see her. She was friendly and welcoming to the observer
82
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
but seemed to need to talk to him and to grudge the attention he paid to the baby. She poured out, from her field of work, stories of illness and death of old people, of black babies like elephants. Beneath her flippant manner and physical competence it was evident that there was still a great deal of anxiety about the kind of baby she had produced, about the traumatic birth that made it difficult for her to become acquainted at close quarters with the baby she now had. The concern about the old and dying seemed to link with the death of her father from cancer some years previously, and worry about her lonely, ageing mother. This last was evidently an internal picture because when the grandmother turned up in the observations she was remarkably young and spry. There seemed to be a connection between black elephant babies and her own cyst that had had to be removed and the projection of some primitive forceful greedy quality of her own into Rosalie. Breastfeeding never seemed to become established enjoyably and was given up after five or six weeks. The mother was not helped in this by the mother-in-law who came to stay and categorically spoke against breastfeeding, and would take charge of the baby and give her a bottle when she was hungry. Mrs R at one point said wistfully, “They say breastfeeding helps you to come closer to the baby”, but her own mother had said that she had not felt close to any of her children until they were three months old. This throws a little light on Mrs R’s inability to feel close to Rosalie in the first months. There was a discrepancy between her statement to the observer that mothers are not important before the baby is aged eighteen months to two years (“what matters most before then is physical care”) and some recurrently stated anxieties that she must not become indispensable to the child or it would be difficult for her to return to work. For that reason she encouraged her husband to learn to give the baby the bottle and handed it over to others to look after. It seemed she feared being stuck with her own infantile helplessness, evoked by the baby’s needs. Her conversation to the observer was often as much about her work as about the baby. There she felt confident and was evidently
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
83
greatly appreciated. With the baby, despite all her reading and material preparation, she was emotionally at sea and clearly—as once or twice she was able to admit despite her flippancy and sophistication—quite terrified. Baby Rosalie was fortunately a strong sucker and could make herself felt when she was upset. On one occasion Mrs R admitted that she had tried to quiet or drown her crying by leaving the hoover on. When she eventually returned from the next room to switch it off the baby was still crying. Rosalie’s unresponsive and blank look worried the observer in the early weeks, and there were gloomy prognostications about a further withdrawal when the mother returned to work. The nanny who was employed was a young girl who had just recently left school but who had already had some experience of looking after a small child. The mother put off her return to work for a fortnight to help settle her in. The first time the observer saw Rosalie with the nanny she was struck by the close and relaxed way she held the baby to her body to give her the bottle, as if she felt quite at home with her physically. That heralded a gradual change in the whole family atmosphere and in the baby herself. It seemed that the arrival of the nanny was a tremendous relief to Mrs R. She seemed to feel quite at home instructing and enabling a young and relatively inexperienced girl; she was accustomed to doing that in her work. She knew a good deal about bringing up babies from her reading; the nanny (perhaps partly because of not having to carry total responsibility for the baby) was more in touch with the baby’s feelings, could come close to Rosalie and comment to the mother on the meaning of what she was doing. In this way she did indeed help to bring the mother closer to the baby emotionally. It was noticeable how quickly Rosalie became more alert, lively and responsive and able to focus her attention not only upon the nanny but on the observer. She also began to show increasing interest in, and preference for, her mother. She would try to attract her attention even when the mother was oblivious of her. The nanny would point out sometimes to the mother when this was happening.
84
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
The father had all along been very fascinated by the baby but was very uncertain of how to handle her physically. He was able to be more emotionally involved but less practically competent than his wife. In the nanny he found someone to share his more naïve wonder and fascination. The baby was developing in a lively, charmingly social way which prompted the observer (despite his experience of little children and infants) to voice his amazement at the extraordinarily complicated mental life which her actions, expressions and sounds conveyed. Then unexpectedly when the baby was nearly seven months old the nanny announced that she had to leave to go back to her family, and within the short space of three weeks another nanny had to be found. The first nanny tended to withdraw herself from the baby in the last week or so, clearly finding the parting too difficult to work more fully with her emotions. The father tended to deny that it mattered at all and became rather hostile to the nanny behind her back, but the mother unexpectedly seemed to be much more in touch with what it would mean to the baby. While herself remaining sorry to see the nanny go, she was able this time to make herself much more emotionally available to the baby, to talk to her and to play with her much more patiently. So to the observer’s surprise there was no sign of emotional withdrawal at the change of nannies. The new one was accepted by the baby after close scrutiny but it was quite clear that she did not forget the first one. For instance when Mrs R mentioned the nanny’s name fairly casually when talking to the observer Rosalie, who was feeding, suddenly broke down and cried. By the time the baby was nearing her first birthday the observer and the group discussing her development were astounded and delighted at the happy and playful relationship between her and her mother which had grown from such an unpromising start. This seemed to be a situation where the mother needed to return to her work to recover some sense of her adult competence and identity and where she needed the help of a nanny, like a younger sister, to share the responsibility for the child so that she felt held and supported sufficiently to be more emotionally receptive to the child’s projections.
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
85
This was also one of those situations in which the observer became crucially important as a receptacle for the projection of the mother’s anxieties and also to the baby as a reliable watching attentive person. Both the nanny and the observer helped the mother to recover her ruptured sense of identity but with additional space in her mind to accommodate the child. The following clinical material is from the analysis of a young man, a twin, of rich emotional potential but with an inhibited capacity to internalize a maternal object which could hold and enable him to express his emotions in a close relationship. Analysis of G Dr G is a well-built, energetic and intelligent young paediatrician whose career has been consistently successful since schooldays. He is one of twins, first children of a business couple who have lived a high principled hardworking life with, eventually, some material success. His twin brother is married and successful in the same line as his parents; his younger brother seems to feel very inadequate and defeated by life both in work and in intimate social relationships. In his early years he and his twin were inseparable, acting more or less as one person: for instance in the three-legged race at school they were traditionally unbeatable for that very reason. G around the age of eleven decided that he wanted a room of his own in which he would then seclude himself for long periods every day to study, which he did with such success that he habitually came top of the form in almost all subjects, far outstripping his brother, who seems to have had no less ability but less determination in the academic field. G is now the academic and professional success of the family. He came to analysis because he feared that there was something wrong with him as he was not married. He gets on well with women, particularly older women, but is chary of being committed permanently to anyone. When he was beginning analysis he was about to move into a smaller house on his own after sharing a flat for years with other people with whom he was quite friendly, but it irked him to share
86
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
his dwelling and his life with others at such close quarters. He was determined to feel free of intrusions after work. He hated analysis for the first months. He had a great impulse towards introspection, was in fact very co-operative, and brought occasional dreams. But he hated having to tell them to me; he was suspicious of being brain-washed and very sceptical. He was embarrassed to note how constantly he experienced me as a nagging mother. After six months or so this oppressive transference lifted greatly and he suddenly realized that in fact he was enjoying his life infinitely more, saw much more in his work with which he was involved increasingly for its intrinsic value and less as a vehicle for his ambition. Moreover he found that sometimes he was beginning to look forward to his sessions. It became evident as time went on that his presentation of himself as somewhat brash, competitive and struggling for precedence, is a shield against overwhelming emotions, including tenderness and grief for ills which he tends to makes his responsibility and which he cannot cure. Being a meticulously punctilious doctor who does more than his share of overtime and shoulders greater responsibility than necessary at his hospital gives him a role and involves him in so much activity that this protects him from being haunted by parents whom he sees as damaged and largely unfulfilled. Currently his mother is ill with a progressively crippling disease, although she is a relatively young woman, and his younger brother has had some sort of collapse. He is deeply distressed about his mother and his brother, and also about his mother’s distress about his brother, expressed as “What is the use of being a physician if you can’t help our own family?” And yet he is very chary of his time and privacy being invaded too much. He is still in many ways the boy he remembers becoming in prepubertal days, who withdrew from his brother’s room and from his former passion for the rugger field to walk alone, trying to think about and “feel the shape” of his own existence. Dr G had a series of dreams around the long summer break: He is on a ledge trying to get into a large building like a church or a clinic through the upstairs window. Just inside where he needs to put his foot to climb in, is one of the doctors at the hospital who keeps
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
87
getting in his way and irritating him. From inside the building water is streaming out. The doctor in the dream is a meticulous know-it-all who works very precisely and cannot be faulted. The water was associated with the unexpected flood of tears which had overwhelmed him during the previous session when he was recounting the illness of a woman friend of his family: she is the wife in a couple of whom he was extremely fond and whom he admired greatly. His grief was for the husband as well as for the wife, lest she should die after the operation she was shortly due to have. Then, following a session in which he had been utterly devastated because the consultant had made some glancing remark implying some slight carelessness on his part he had this dream: His father is up on a ladder mending the roof, hammering nails into it and using material that has been used before. The patient himself is elsewhere and seems to be running some sort of business. To this he associated the memory of his mother crying in childhood because a tree had fallen down and crashed onto the roof, and also the fact of her ringing up the previous night and crying about his younger brother whom she was unable to help in his apathy and depression. The next dream was simply: It seems that he is going to share a house with his mother, the two of them together. The dream of trying to get into a church or clinic has obvious reference to being shut out of the analysis during the summer holiday, and the irritating know-it-all doctor who will not let him get his foot in represents my husband, the father. But this father carries the projection of the precise competent know-it-all aspect of himself that he has constructed as a barrier against his emotionality. I think it is significant that this figure is near the entrance, the surface, and that he can see the water—the emotionality—leaking out. The indications are that his know-it-allishness is more of a brittle constructed second skin, as Mrs Bick has termed it, or an exo-skeleton (to use a term of Bion’s), than a deeply narcissistic state resulting from projective identification with a superior object. The nature of the building itself—a clinic, representing his work; a church—representing the framework of security in organized
88
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
religion within which he had been brought up and which he has accepted relatively unquestioningly for so many years—this can be seen as an institutional bulwark against unmanageable emotion—another form of second skin. If we link the first two dreams, the indications are that unmanageable emotion is connected with damage to the breast (the window, the roof ) and to the younger brother. It is not the sexual intercourse that damages mother, as maybe his childhood theory was when the tree crashed onto the roof, but his own infantile incontinence. This might amount to his unwarranted distress at the consultant’s glancing accusation of neglect of detail. In the dream he is engaged on his own business while father is mending the roof. These dreams help to fill out a picture that is gradually evolving for me in the transference of an infant with a depressed mother, unavailable for intimate emotional contact and no doubt overoccupied practically in trying to cope with twins as her first-born, as well as with the demands on her time as a helpmeet to her husband: an infant whose identity was twinned or stuck to that of his brother, giving him a kind of surface independence from mother lest she be shattered by his demands. The struggle to seek an identity of his own towards puberty leads him to find in his own room a physical framework to hold and protect him from intrusions, just as the walking alone gives him a muscular independence. There are now, however, hints that there is a reparative father with whom he might identify were he not so much engaged upon his own business. With the help of this reparative penis, represented by the analytic piecing-together interpretative work, he may be able to find space in his house—his internal world—for a depressed mother; the “shape of his existence” may expand to include this. I shall end with some brief excerpts from the observation of a baby who seemed to be born with a good internal object and who raises interesting questions about the influence of the prenatal relationship to the mother, questions with which Bion was occupied in the last years of his life, and which he explores in A Memoir of the Future (1975; 1977; 1979 [1991]). His “imaginative
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
89
conjecture” in that book was that projective identification may already begin in the womb. Emily Emily is a first baby born to a young couple who are both working and studying and not yet settled in their mode of living. As soon as she sensed that she was pregnant—unplanned though this was—the mother was thrilled and said that she often found herself talking to the baby. She had a good pregnancy and an easy delivery. The observer visited the baby twelve hours after her birth. In the room in the hospital there were three members of the family talking in one corner, the mother resting half asleep in another and the baby in a cot in a third corner. The observer noted her alert “listening” expression, her eyes moving around the ceiling. The mother then awoke and spoke, the baby’s eyes moved in that direction and stopped attentively with what the observer could only describe as a look of recognition on her face. There were initial difficulties in adjustment in the first week or two. The mother was anxious and worried about having enough milk, but the baby was a strong sucker and quite a protester if her needs were not met. Soon, however, an intensely enjoyable relationship developed between the mother and this baby who seemed from early days to have an inner smile which soon became a markedly sociable one. After a few weeks she would stop during her feed and “talk” in long cadences, a talking which she would carry on with other people when on her mother’s knee. She enjoyed company if it was not too intrusive. On one occasion, when she was about eight weeks old, the great grandparents and paternal grandfather were visiting the young couple just after she had been fed; they were talking volubly to and around the baby who looked intently and a little puzzled from face to face. The mother then took her to the sofa in the corner of the room and put her down to change her nappy as she was accustomed to do. The baby, at first, had a pleased expression and was carrying on some of her talking, singing sounds, while the great grandmother hovered in the background. The mother was
90
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
chatting to the baby in her usual way and removed the wet nappy. The baby’s face puckered suddenly and she dissolved into a hurt complaint. The mother caught her up rapidly and took her next door saying, “She feels humiliated in front of so many people”, apologised to her and changed the nappy in the bedroom. She was brought back again to the company all smiles. A little later the great grandmother—scented, bejewelled and voluble—wanted to hold her so Emily was handed over, smiling expectantly. The great grandmother sat her on her knee, bouncing her up and down and emitting a whole stream of conversation or rather monologue about how to be a good girl. A look of anxiety crossed the baby’s face although she still looked friendly. She tried to “talk” back, then her talk increasingly had a note of protest in it as if she were trying to tell this lady that she was not used to being treated like this. Her talk increased in vehemence as if she were trying to should down this over-voluble person. She kept up the attempt quite gallantly for several minutes. Finally it was too much and again she dissolved into hurt sobs and looked to her mother to be rescued. Emily was finally weaned at nearly nine months and took her first steps on her own a month later. By the time she was a year old she was walking very competently. At this time she had developed a way of walking with the bottle in her mouth held in one hand with the other outstretched to pat the knees of parents and friends as they sat talking to one another. These favours she dispensed fairly impartially to all the adults in her life, but it was clear that her attachment to her mother was of a more intense and passionate order. When she was a year old her mother contracted a viral infection which persisted for several weeks, leaving her increasingly tired and despondent. Emily seemed to note this, glancing at times at her mother with an anxious, searching look, sometimes bursting into sobs for no apparent reason. One day she was taken on a customary walk to the shops in the village. Instead of letting herself be pushed back home as usual she got out of her pushchair and insisted on walking all the way back, uphill much of the way, in an unwontedly persistent and determined manner, refusing help. A day or two later the mother had to go to hospital for treatment
GROWING POINTS IN PSYCHOANALYISIS
91
and was kept there for over a week. She was frantic initially about being separated from Emily, wondering how the baby would cope—until she had this dream: She was on the ground watching an aeroplane that seemed to be without a roof and which was heading into a snowstorm. There were several people in it and among them was Emily, but somehow it seemed as if the baby was also on her own and had to pilot herself through. The mother was filled with anguish at being so unable to help. The next thing she knew was Emily, standing on the ground beside her all neatly tucked up in her flying suit beaming at her. The mother was looking at her with awe that she had come through. And indeed that dream turned out to be a true intuition of how Emily did manage to cope with the separation from her mother. She was looked after by her father, a babysitter and friends, and taken to see her mother every evening. Her father said that the first evening Mrs E was in hospital and he had had to put Emily to bed, she caught hold of the bars of the cot and it looked as if she was about to make a violent protest; but then she looked him full in the face, thought better of it, and lay down with her cuddly toy as if she realized that he needed her help. The awe with which Mrs E regards her gallant little baby in the dream is, I think, a variant of the respect and wonder with which Melanie Klein and some of her colleagues—notably Mrs Bick in her Infant Observation seminars—have approached the study of children’s developing individuality. The theories, so necessary as an aid in trying to bring together and put some order into the wealth of detail we obtain in child analysis and observation, must indeed be seen as an aid but never as a substitute for the respectful experience.
CHAPTER SIX
Esther Bick (1901-1983)1 (1983)
Martha Harris took over Esther Bick’s course at the Tavistock in 1960 and continued to remain good friends and to work closely with her until her death. In a discussion with Meltzer about the difference between genius and talent, she said that she was one of the few who had “a touch of genius”. The following eulogy is the published version of what was felt by those present to be a “wonderful speech” (Elizabeth Spillius, personal communication). The speech transcript has been lost and there appear to have been differences from the published version. Joan Symington, who was present at the memorial occasion, writes: “What I noticed in Mattie’s very moving eulogy (which had many of the audience in tears) was that she said Mrs Bick had been ‘vouchsafed’ exceptionally fine internal objects. The word ‘vouchsafed’ struck me as some quite different way of looking at internal objects. It may link up with Bion’s ‘third eye’” (personal communication). Students have testified to the difficulty both Bick and later Harris both had in retaining infant observation as an integral part of the training at the British Psychoanalytic Institute. An obituary, first published in the Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1983), vol. 9(2), pp. 101-102. 1
93
94
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
M
rs Bick died in hospital on July 20th at the age of eighty-two after a period of failing health and memory after her retirement from practice with patients in 1980. She had no relatives in this country, which became her home after she arrived as a refugee from Austria just before the war. She was born in a small Polish city of Orthodox Jewish parents and by courage, perseverance and intelligence, she pursued her education without assistance, finally receiving her PhD in Vienna for a study of infant development undertaken with Charlotte Bühler. Her marriage broke up before she left Austria, her husband leaving for Switzerland. Her only brother and most of her family perished in concentration camps. It was not until many years later, in the 50’s, that she learned her niece had escaped and was living in Israel. Nusia, as she was called by her friends, was happy in her first contacts in this country. She first stayed with Violet Oates, the sister of the Antarctic hero, who became a friend, and who seemed in these last years to be assimilated in her internal world to her beloved grandmother and to Melanie Klein, as admired sources of strength and integrity. She then worked in a wartime nursery in Manchester where she also began analysis with Michael Balint. She completed her analytic training in London while working in a Middlesex child guidance clinic with Dr Portia Holman. She then joined the Tavistock staff and with John Bowlby began the Tavistock training in Child Psychotherapy in 1949. At the same time she began another analysis with Melanie Klein whose seminars at the British Institute of Psychoanalysis had impressed her greatly. It seems astonishing to reflect now that Mrs Bick was never at the Tavistock for more than four sessions a week, and in the latter part of her time there for two sessions only, because through her personality and her teaching she had a profound effect upon the Clinic. The course which was initiated by her and by Dr Bowlby wa then, and for some time, the most thorough and structured training in psychoanalytic work within the Tavistock and within
ESTHER BICK
95
the Health Service. Her students, who felt privileged to have such an inspiring teacher, tended to become a focus for envy and criticism but also of admiration and respect. But great talent is not always accompanied by diplomacy. Nusia Bick was never at any period of her life a compromiser and the course came under fire for its narrow Kleinian orientation. When in 1960 she was told by Dr Bowlby that he would not be asking her to undertake responsibility for another intake of students, she decided to leave the Clinic and to concentrate upon her analytic work and on her teaching at the Institute of Psychoanalysis. Nevertheless she continued to give extra-mural and private seminars to child psychotherapists for the next twenty years. During that time she also did a great deal of teaching abroad in Spain, in Italy, also in South America, Israel and Switzerland. Analysts and candidates came to her for supervision from these countries and also from France, the Commonwealth and the United States. Her introduction of Infant Observation within the family as a central part of the training of child psychotherapists was a stroke of genius which has helped to establish a tradition in child analysis founded upon attention to close observation and description rather than on ideology and theory. This exercise has now for some time been part of the training of all candidates at the British Institute of Psychoanalysis. It is used as a method of learning from experience by many other courses at the Tavistock which are concerned with the professional development of workers in various fields of child care and education. In the past ten to twenty years it has been introduced in comparable fields in a number of other countries—from Norway to India—and is helping to increase internationally a body of professional people who are able to think of child development and of mother-infant interaction from a sustained experience of observation at close quarters which entails appreciation of the emotional issues involved in the growth of the personality. The two passions of Mrs Bick’s life were psychoanalysis and Israel. She had high hopes of both, and to both she applied equally high standards which were impossible to realise, and so inevitably she was disappointed by the imperfections in them. Those exacting
96
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
standards she applied also to herself and her writing, which was seldom allowed to reach the printed page. Her papers on child analysis and on infant observation were seminal and remain so. But it is as a teacher rather than as a writer that she will be remembered by many of us who worked with her. Her appreciation of material presented to her, her capacity to seize upon salient points and use them to bring alive the personality of the child or person described, had a poetic quality displayed only by those who love life intensely. She had a vision of how lives might be improved by psychoanalysis, a burning desire to communicate this in her teaching, and little tolerance for attitudes which stood in the way of this. Her uncompromising and sometimes narrow vision gained her enemies and critics, but its integrity and illuminating force won from many others, especially from young people who were eager to learn, a devotion and admiration which few people are able to inspire. Lest this brief note about her life and complicated personality make her sound too austere, it should be said that she had a great sense of fun and gaiety, and a store of Jewish jokes. She loved to cook, to give parties, and she enjoyed party games. Her gaiety was not so evident in the last years of her life but it did return in the last months of failing health when she became a favourite of the young staff in the home for the elderly in which she was living. They found her both brave and entertaining and were fascinated by her as someone who seemed to have had an interesting life. And so indeed she had. Through that life she has left her profession and the world a richer place.
CHAPTER SEVEN
Notes on Infant Observation in Psychoanalytic Training1 Esther Bick (1964)
In this foundational paper, Esther Bick describes the nature and purpose of infant observation seminars, and the technical and emotional difficulties faced by the observer in relation to the family and the seminar group. Several examples are given, including long extracts from an observation of one particular baby, in order to demonstrate how only close attention to detail can make these primal emotional strains observable and illuminate the experience of the observer, and of the mother and baby couple. She also stresses the importance of consecutive observation for gathering scientific data as free as possible from linguistic preconceptions. She concludes that the psychoanalytic validity of the experience lies partly in learning how to observe, and partly in the prototypal relationship to the breast as part-object as being the “basic unit of relationship from which more complex relationships are built”.
I
nfant observation was introduced into the curriculum of the Institute of Psycho-Analysis in London in 1960 as part of the course for first year students. The detailed observational material that I am quoting in this paper is mainly drawn from the work of these students. Infant observation had, in fact, 1
Read to the British Psychoanalytical Society in 1963; first published in International Journal of Psychoanalysis (1964), vol. 45, pp. 558-66. 97
98
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
been part of the training course for child psychotherapists at the Tavistock Clinic since 1948 when the course began. We then decided to include in the first non-clinical year some practical experience of infants. I thought this important for many reasons but perhaps mostly because it would help the students to conceive vividly the infantile experience of their child patients, so that when, for example, they started the treatment of a two-and-a-half years’ old child they would get the feel of the baby that he was and from which he is not so far removed. It should also increase the student’s understanding of the child’s non-verbal behaviour and his play, as well as the behaviour of the child who neither speaks nor plays. Further, it should help the student when he interviews the mother and enable him to understand better her account of the child’s history. It would also give each student a unique opportunity to observe the development of an infant more or less from birth, in his home setting and in his relation to his immediate family, and thus to find out for himself how these relations emerge and develop. In addition he would be able to compare and contrast his observations with those of his fellow students in the weekly seminars. I want to turn now to the method of observation which has evolved over the years and has been constantly discussed in seminars. The child psychotherapy students visit the family once a week up to about the end of the second year of the child’s life, each observation normally lasting about an hour. The observations of the candidates at the Institute usually stop at about the end of the first year. Contrary to our expectations, there was no difficulty in finding mothers willing to have an observer—either through acquaintances or through other channels. Mothers have frequently indicated explicitly or implicitly how much they welcomed the fact of having someone come regularly into their home with whom they could talk about their baby and its development and their feelings about it. We found that it was best to give a simple explanation to the parents—namely, that the observer wished to have some direct experience of babies as part of his professional development. Note-taking during the observation was soon recognized as unsuitable and disturbing as it interfered with free-floating
NOTES ON INFANT OBSERVATION IN PSYCHOANALYTIC TRAINING
99
attention and prevented the student from responding easily to the emotional demands of the mother. Much thought had to be given to the central problem of the role of the observer in the whole situation. This problem seemed to be twofold, as it involved the conceptualization of the observer’s role, and also the conscious and unconscious attitudes of the observer. First the question of role: as infant observation was planned as an adjunct to the teaching of psychoanalysis and child therapy, rather than as a research instrument, it was felt to be important that the observer should feel himself sufficiently inside the family to experience the emotional impact, but not committed to act out any roles thrust upon him, such as giving advice or registering approval or disapproval. This would not seem to exclude him being helpful as a particular situation arose—by holding the baby, or bringing it an occasional gift. In other words, he would be a privileged and therefore grateful participant observer. The second problem, that of attitudes, is, however, more difficult. Here, in the house of parents with a newborn baby, the observer, however experienced with babies or in psychoanalysis or in scientific modes of observation, is confronted with a situation of intense emotional impact. In order to be able to observe at all he must attain detachment from what is going on. Yet he must, as in the basic method of psychoanalysis, find a position from which to make his observations, a position that will introduce as little distortion as possible into what is going on in the family. He has to allow some things to happen and to resist others. Rather than actively establishing his own personality as a new addition to the family organization he has to allow the parents, particularly the mother, to fit him into her household in her own way. But he must resist being drawn into roles involving intense infantile transference and therefore countertransference. To give an example, an older child in the family may try to monopolise him as an ally against the mother-baby couple. The mother may attempt to build up a strong dependence relation. He may find himself being influenced by the baby to become a substitute mother. In other words, if he becomes involved in the family organization as do other members of the family—grandparents,
100
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
father, relatives, friends, who all “observe” after all—his observations would then be as little objective as those of a father or mother student wanting to bring observations of their own children. Further, the tensions of the situation would invade him: particularly, the inadequacies in the care of the infant would upset him and the whole mystery of the situation intrigue him too much. He must not allow his behaviour to be dominated by these feelings which, on close scrutiny, will often be found to have been intensified by projections from members of the family. Whilst much of this must be dealt with in the student’s analysis, the seminar can at least uncover some of the projections into him that are operating and which intensify his own internal conflicts. To illustrate this function of the seminar I have chosen for discussion a problem which has appeared the most ubiquitous and difficult: namely, the operation of the mother’s post-partum depressive trends. While we have known for some time that these trends are almost universal, I was not prepared for the intensity with which they impinged on the observer. What one was struck by was the exclusive preoccupation of the students in the seminar with the mother’s handling of the baby. Their attitude was highly critical and emotional. At first I tried to mitigate the problem by encouraging them to give more attention to the baby and less to the mother. This did not help. I realized it was necessary to give more consideration to this factor—the depression in the mother and its impact on the observer as well as on the baby and other members of the family. It is, of course, not the purpose of this paper to attempt to give a systematic account of depression in the mothers of newborn babies, but before giving the observational reports I want to clarify how I am using the word “depressive” here. I am not using it primarily descriptively, but rather metapsychologically, to describe those aspects of the mother’s relation to the baby in which a clear-cut regression to part-object relationship is evident. The mother can be clearly seen to be experiencing emotional detachment from the baby, helplessness in understanding and meeting its needs, relying on the baby to make use of her breasts, hands, voice, as part-objects.
NOTES ON INFANT OBSERVATION IN PSYCHOANALYTIC TRAINING
101
Naturally depressive trends tend strongly to disturb the observer’s detachment, both because of the mother’s needs which pull the observer, and countertransference anxieties which push him. He is pulled towards augmenting the mother’s vitality and pushed to identify with the disturbed and resentful aspects of the baby. To illustrate this problem of the way in which the mother’s post-partum depressive trends tend to draw the observer into roles unsuitable to his function and to place him under greater emotional stress, I will bring two different types of material: one, a summary of two months’ observational work, and the second, more detailed observational notes. I think in both examples one can feel the observer’s struggle to tolerate the situation. In the first example it will be seen how the crumbling of the manic trends in the mother tends to draw the observer into the role of a dependent figure.2 K, a male baby, was the first child of young parents (about twenty-five years old) who worked together as office caretakers. The baby was unplanned and came after two years of marriage. Some months later, when the mother was much more secure about herself as a mother, she confessed to the observer that when other girls at school had talked of getting married and having children she thought privately to herself: “Married maybe, but I’ll never have a baby; I am sure I should let it die.” This mother was specially selected by a health visitor as one who was normal, capable, and unlikely to be disturbed by being observed. The mother continued work up to term despite diarrhoea and backache, as part of her dependent and grateful relationship to her devoted husband. She described the rather precipitous delivery which had caused her some lacerations as a delivery in which, once his head was through, “he shot out”. Thus she expressed an attitude emphasizing the baby’s strength and independence which she maintained later. At the first observation, when the baby was two days old, mother and baby were enthroned amid flowers, presents, and new furnishings; the mother, radiant, talked incessantly in an excited way about her pride in the baby, her delight that he was a boy and 2
The observer in this case was Martha Harris; see the end of Chapter 17 below.
102
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
so strong, the presents she had received, and her gratitude to her husband who helped her so much in the last weeks. At the same time she was planning to fit the baby into a routine which would enable her to go on with her work and to help her husband. She reiterated her intention to breastfeed, driven by the conviction that it produced less flabby babies, but she was plainly very uncertain about her ability to do so. Five days later all was changed. The mother was up, tired and harassed-looking, feeling burdened by the observer’s visit but impelled to incessant talk. She said she had never thought that feeding a baby and keeping him clean would take up so much time, or that it would take so much to satisfy him. She had a blister on her nipple and pains under her arm, and talked in terms of trying to continue breastfeeding for six weeks. When the baby, who had been asleep in the pram, began to cry, the mother seemed at a loss to comfort him, talking rapidly to the observer of his strength, the beauty of the pram, and of her over-worked state. Finally, she turned the baby over, saying, “Mustn’t spoil you, young man”, and told the observer that though they had not specially wanted a baby she and her husband were quite delighted, but since she had never much liked other people’s babies she did not know what to do with him, and ended, “I’ve really let myself in for something now…”. Further observations in the early weeks were similar, as the mother struggled to satisfy this “wild, hungry baby”, as she called him, who strained so hard both to get at and get away from the breast, who wanted but seemed unable to get all “the dark part of the nipple into his mouth”, who wriggled and struggled when being changed, quite unlike the doll they practiced on in the antenatal clinic. She continued to try to comfort him in the pram, to dress and undress him on the table. When the baby was screaming with hunger and impatience after the bath she would go on talking while dressing him in an apparently unconcerned way. At other times, when the baby was distressed, she pressed him on the observer while she got on with other tasks or even while she chatted. The breastfeeding ended at six weeks.
NOTES ON INFANT OBSERVATION IN PSYCHOANALYTIC TRAINING
103
The father seemed to give the mother a great deal of support; he sometimes impersonated the baby to express gentle criticism of the mother or to indicate the baby’s feelings to her. He did not compete with her in her role as mother, he regarded her unquestioningly, despite all her uncertainties, as the expert as far as the baby was concerned, and was at hand whenever possible. This supportive behaviour of the father seemed to be an important factor in the gradual improvement in the mother’s closeness and tolerance towards the baby. In this material the manic defences of an immature and dependent mother can be seen to collapse, revealing her great anxiety about being able to take care of the baby and her distrust in her ability to do so. The observer’s anxiety about the inadequacy of this baby’s mothering comes through in her difficulty in tolerating such points as the mother’s incessant talking when the baby was in distress and the mother’s lack of warmth and concern for her baby, as well as in her own relief at the father’s support and its effect on the family. The seminar also felt that as the relationship between mother and observer went on there were indications of a helpful improvement, evidenced, for example, in the mother’s being able to tell the observer of her adolescent anxieties about ever being able to be a mother at all. In the second example I will give an account of a first observation, both to show the observer at work, indicating, as I said earlier on, the impact of the mother’s depression on him, and also to show the richness of observational data—a point to which I shall come back later. Charles Charles, a baby of ten days at the first observation, was the second child of a professional couple. I shall quote now from the report: I rang the mother and explained who I was in terms of the line of contact and we arranged that I should come the next day so that we could meet and see how we liked each other and whether we could make an arrangement for observations. In
104
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
fixing the time of this meeting, mother asked whether I would like to see the baby awake or didn’t it matter. When I said I would prefer to see the baby awake, she suggested a feed, which I took up very readily. She showed some eagerness to accommodate me, being prepared to move the time of the feed up to half an hour. I said I could come when he was usually fed. Mother is aged about twenty-five, has glasses, short thick light-brown hair, a square masculine sort of head and face, rather quiet and serious in looks and voice, but smiles readily with a warm smile. She was wearing a Swedish-Liberty striped blouse and a large black skirt; rather shabby-looking was the general impression, but somehow not in an unattractive way. She had quite a dignified manner, although visibly anxious about how to deal with me. I was first taken out to the garden behind the house where the mother’s mother sat holding Charles wrapped up in a blanket. The mother muttered something about it being feeding-time and would I care to see the feed I followed her and Charles back into the living-room. The mother sat first on a divan and invited me to pull up an armchair opposite, then changed places because there was a draught onto the divan from the door to the garden (and grandma). By changing places the door could be left open without any draught on her. It also meant that the mother could be seen by her mother from the garden. While the divan where I sat could not. When I first saw Charles he was wrapped very voluminously in the blanket on his grandmother’s lap. When the blanket was drawn back he was lying with his left hand on his ear, his right hand over the whole front of his face, kneading his cheeks and mouth and nose. His right thumb was in his mouth. He had several scratches on his cheeks and upper cheekbone and his right eye looked faintly discoloured, as though he had poked it too hard. When the mother and Charles settled in the armchair for the feed I could see very little of him indeed. I asked his name and how old he was. The mother asked me about my work. I explained that I hoped to work with children ultimately. We discussed possible times for me to come, and the mother seemed to prefer me to come to see the bath rather than a feed. This, however, was a misunderstanding. We found a suitable time and agreed that arrangements would be flexible because
NOTES ON INFANT OBSERVATION IN PSYCHOANALYTIC TRAINING
Charles’s timetable would change and we could see how things went. Mother apologized for the unfinished state of the house, pointing out the packing-case legs of the dining-table. I said that the food probably tasted just as good, to which—“It’s OK now that Mother’s here!” There was a long pause in the conversation and she remarked that she ought to have my telephone number. Mother was timing the feed with her watch off her wrist. When she took the nipple out of Charles’s mouth and put him over her left shoulder the watch dropped off her lap and I picked it up for her. She patted his back firmly but not too hard, and he brought up wind almost at once. He straightway began to shout and roar in ever-increasing tones of anger, was not quietened by his mother’s talking to him and when she gave him the right breast he made several attempts to take the nipple, making a kissing sound as he did so. The mother finally put the nipple right into his mouth and he began to suck. This time I could see a bit better and he seemed to be sucking very gently and slowly. There was the same motionless quality to his whole body as he sucked. As he began to suck he gave the breast a pat with his right hand just above the nipple. His hand seemed to interfere with his mouth (as it were, falling on to the nipple), so that the mother twice moved his hand away. He finally arranged it in a trumpet shape around his mouth. His feet were motionless, except that I noticed he once made a small stroking action against the chair with one foot. Mother said: “Come on, work”, very gently, and in a somewhat resigned sort of way. After a certain time mother took Charles off the breast, very sleepy, and first held him sitting up facing her, saying that Spock advised winding this way before trying the shoulder method, but that she had never had any luck with this nor heard of anyone who had. I agreed, and mentioned my own son and our experiences in winding him. She asked how old he was and remarked that Jack, Charles’s brother, was nineteen months old. The mother then put Charles over her shoulder, very sleepy and lolling and with a replete air. I don’t recall that he brought up wind. She then put him back to the right breast, where he sucked even more slowly for a while. She then carried Charles against
105
106
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
her shoulder upstairs to change him. I walked behind, and at this point Charles’s face was quite calm but rather bloated and expressionless really. He was more in a stupor than asleep, it seemed, and made no sound. We went into the little room where the mother slept with Charles. The bed was unmade, and there was an empty chocolate wrapper beside it. The mother arranged the blanket on the bed and laid Charles on his back, at which he woke up quickly and began to scream. She left the room to fetch clean napkins. He continued to scream, both hands constantly round his face with pushing and scraping-off movements, his feet doing the same; pushing the left against and down the right. The screaming stopped when the mother called from another room, and was replaced for a moment by a happy low cooing sound. Then screams till the mother came back and talked sympathetically while she changed him. During the changing he cried miserably, but without drowning the sound of his mother’s voice. His hands were constantly around his face, his left hand moving in front of him with a stroking action which reminded me of a blind man. The mother powdered his genitals and stomach generously, drew attention to his rash, and remarked that lots of babies around had such a rash. When he was changed, she laid him on his left side in the cot, leaving his hands free of the blanket which wrapped him. She then left to get Jack up from his sleep, as they were going for a walk. Charles lay with his left thumb in his mouth, the fingers of his left hand over his face, especially over the right eye (the left eye was turned somewhat into the sheet); his right hand was curling over his temple. He breathed fast and noisily, and irregularly from time to time. Then his left hand assumed the trumpet shape that his right hand had done during the feed. His face showed scarcely any movement. All at once there was a sudden, heavy, heaving sigh and he seemed to relax altogether. His breathing became inaudible, his hands moved slightly away from his face. Over the next few minutes he gave several jerks forward, his arms outstretched as though he were falling and clutching at someone. This seemed to happen sometimes to external stimuli (the mother’s voice talking to Jack in the next room, a door banging), and sometimes without any external stimulus that I noted.
NOTES ON INFANT OBSERVATION IN PSYCHOANALYTIC TRAINING
107
Finally he lay quietly asleep. Two or three times he half woke at some loud noises from Jack’s room, began to pucker and cry, but then fell asleep again. He began to cry when his mother came and put a cardigan and bonnet on him, treating him sympathetically and talking to him. He fell asleep again and was carried downstairs on the cot mattress which was going in the pram. As he lay on the mattress while the mother and grandmother gathered together things for the walk, I was struck by his expression, which had quite altered in the meantime and was now fixed in a look of great pain of an intense kind, and not a muscle moved for the two or three minutes between when I first saw it and when I said goodbye to them outside the house.
I have given this material in considerable detail to show the observer at work and the impact that this experience makes on him. Further, I want this baby to become familiar because I shall discuss other material from him later in this paper. If we consider this material from the point of view of how it affected the observer, we naturally take into account that this was his first meeting with the family. The observer noted the mother’s anxiety about how to deal with him. Between the lines the observer’s tension can be discerned. He notes that the mother changes places with him so that grandmother in the garden can see the feed while he cannot. His sensitivity is registered in the record by calling the mother’s invitation “muttered”, and perhaps by misunderstanding her remark about times in the sense that she did not want him to see the feed. When, to the mother’s apologies for the state of the house, particularly the dining table, he remarks that the food probably tastes just as good, the mother says it’s OK now that her own mother is here. Here we can see the first glimpse of the mother’s depression and dependence on her own mother and the observer’s attempt at comforting her. “There was a long pause in the conversation and the mother remarked could she have my telephone number.” That two relationships are going on—babybreast, mother-observer—in relative isolation, is evident. The observer’s sympathy for the mother’s depression comes through again when, after prolonged attempts at the second breast, the
108
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
mother said to Charles, “Come on, work”, and the observer notes she said it “gently, in a somewhat resigned sort of way”. Identification with the baby’s misery (the scratched face) and later feeling of desertion in favour of the older brother whom the mother now went to awaken, is written in each subsequent line. The mystery of the face scratches begins to be solved as both hands constantly move around his face with pushing and scraping-off movements, his feet doing the same, while the mother is out of the room. After being changed the baby is seen to fall asleep, an event described by the observer vividly with great attention to detail, but on parting he was struck by Charles’s expression, which had quite altered into a look of great pain of an intense kind although the baby was asleep. That the observer could have noted and reported in great detail with these tensions going on and in his first baby observation is striking. The problem in such as paper as this is to convey the use that the seminar makes of such observations, and this I can do only to a very limited extent. To convey it correctly one would need to report the discussion in the seminar in as much detail as the observational material itself. And even this could give a fallacious impression, since the deductions drawn necessarily depend upon previous observations and discussions, from which, slowly, series of observations can be linked and patterns of behaviour seen to emerge. The point that I am stressing here is the importance of consecutive observation of the individual couple. The experience of the seminar is that one may see an apparent pattern emerging in one observation, but one can only accept it as significant if it is repeated in the same, or a similar, situation in many subsequent observations. Paying attention to such observable details over a long period gives the student the opportunity to see not only patterns but also changes in the patterns. He can see changes in the couple’s mutual adaptation and the impressive capacity for growth and development in their relationship, i.e. the flexibility and capacity for using each other and developing which goes on in a satisfactory mother-baby relationship. The excitement in the
NOTES ON INFANT OBSERVATION IN PSYCHOANALYTIC TRAINING
109
seminar has been just as much in searching backward as in looking forward. I will give two examples of such patterns of behaviour from the same baby, Charles. In the first observation the observer described the baby’s difficulties when feeding at the second breast; how the feeding was slow, long drawn out and how the mother remarked that he did not work hard—but went on with the feed. In later observations we began to see that this was part of a pattern in which he related himself differently to the two breasts. At the first breast he gulped vigorously, sometimes gulping whilst at the second breast he sucked very gently, his mouth barely moving. The mother remarked on one occasion that he usually takes his meal at the first breast and “fiddles around”, as she puts it, on the second. However she persevered, taking him off and putting him back, saying that he would not sleep the right length of time if he did not get enough. At the second breast Charles also made many movements with his hands, patting, making the trumpet shape, holding to his mother’s jersey, stroking. Thus after some weeks we had noted the pattern in the way Charles related himself to the two breasts, but it was only later with additional material about the hand movements that certain links suggested themselves—and these I am going to discuss later. Another pattern emerged from the second observation when the bathing was watched. Charles began to cry as soon as his napkins were taken off, but his crying became much more intense when his nightdress came off. It became fainter when his mother handled him, washed, soaped him and spoke to him softly. When put down on a sheet his crying became louder. Once back in his nightdress the crying stopped immediately; he relaxed and began to look around. This pattern of crying intensely when his body was exposed during the bath or when put down was repeated in every observation until the end of the second month. He was soothed by his mother’s voice and her handling, but quietened immediately when wrapped up, i.e. in his nightdress, or covered with a blanket in the cot.
110
THE TAVISTOCK MODEL
While the foregoing patterns seem to suggest the working of intrapsychic defensive operations, patterns of communication between mother and child can also be observed, in which the mother’s fundamental role of “holding” in Winnicott’s sense or containing projections in Bion’s sense can be observed. It becomes apparent that between a particular mother and child certain preferred modes of communication become central in their relation to one another. It is difficult to tell whether this choice originates in the mother’s or the baby’s preference. I would like to give two examples. One of the mothers, whom I will call Mrs A, was uneasy in the feeding situation. She held the baby very awkwardly, and seemed tense and anxious at having the baby so close to her body. This is similar to the mother on whom I reported at the beginning of this paper, who also could not stand the close physical contact with the infant